id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08888v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08888v1
|
Towards Enhancing Health Coaching Dialogue in Low-Resource Settings
| 2024-04-13T03:23:15 | 2024-04-13T03:23:15 |
Yue Zhou, Barbara Di Eugenio, Brian Ziebart, Lisa Sharp, Bing Liu, Ben Gerber, Nikolaos Agadakos, Shweta Yadav
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Health coaching helps patients identify and accomplish lifestyle-related
goals, effectively improving the control of chronic diseases and mitigating
mental health conditions. However, health coaching is cost-prohibitive due to
its highly personalized and labor-intensive nature. In this paper, we propose
to build a dialogue system that converses with the patients, helps them create
and accomplish specific goals, and can address their emotions with empathy.
However, building such a system is challenging since real-world health coaching
datasets are limited and empathy is subtle. Thus, we propose a modularized
health coaching dialogue system with simplified NLU and NLG frameworks combined
with mechanism-conditioned empathetic response generation. Through automatic
and human evaluation, we show that our system generates more empathetic,
fluent, and coherent responses and outperforms the state-of-the-art in NLU
tasks while requiring less annotation. We view our approach as a key step
towards building automated and more accessible health coaching systems.
|
[
-0.2404587418,
-0.6791655421,
0.5245808363,
0.1579389274,
-0.1611412168,
-0.001199682,
-0.2353628576,
-0.4429296851,
0.7814967632,
0.0759085193,
-0.9712179303,
-0.4027722478,
-0.4971312284,
0.319927007,
0.6253682375,
0.7881180048,
0.2789875865,
0.412422359,
0.1024477854,
-0.4392054081,
-0.5278289318,
-0.1716169119,
-1.0245480537,
-0.4315330386,
0.5327882767,
0.5279842615,
0.6033417583,
0.2887541652,
0.4639692008,
0.2966884673,
-0.0292131361,
0.530762136,
-0.2961005867,
0.4769569635,
-0.0134489695,
-0.367349267,
-1.0937845707,
-0.2138584852,
-0.106297344,
0.6290128231,
-0.3493267,
0.2024418861,
0.1849580854,
0.6305988431,
-0.3939929008,
0.3018031716,
-0.3182419837,
0.5605802536,
0.3449435532,
-0.2726197541,
-0.0275694449,
-0.1348293275,
0.0634894967,
-0.7404636741,
-0.1386431903,
0.1381089687,
0.2511819601,
0.6933905482,
-0.2285400778,
-0.0355393589,
-0.5684739351,
0.6293994784,
-1.0712186098,
-0.1005006656,
0.7071517706,
0.2912484407,
-0.0944383144,
-0.1310632229,
-0.183240667,
0.2437121272,
-0.3938357234,
0.6592224836,
-0.1790427119,
0.4366790354,
0.354896307,
0.2056415379,
-0.4192538559,
0.1002475992,
0.0589312091,
0.2392833829,
0.6807106137,
0.6593297124,
0.2259775251,
-0.6158146262,
0.4075064361,
0.410258323,
-0.0594623722,
-0.092853114,
-0.0293888263,
0.3717653155,
-0.3264022171,
0.4032335281,
-0.491099894,
0.4927395284,
0.2731564045,
-0.6280041337,
-0.0419462137,
-0.1243636832,
-0.3160780668,
0.2281636298,
0.5750179887,
0.8212320209,
-0.2653871179,
-0.2971332967,
0.1670370549,
-0.0822856501,
0.6348280311,
-1.0640648603,
-0.1547784954,
0.5765681863,
-0.8080196381,
-0.2734502256,
-0.4206541479,
-0.7856425047,
-0.2856448293,
-0.2891412079,
0.0885664895,
-0.4336904883,
-0.1824330539,
0.0449501723,
0.0002321055,
0.134596169,
0.3811988533,
-0.8703587651,
0.316172868,
0.5051754713,
0.8835641742,
0.1812186092,
0.4411664009,
-0.5936650038,
0.3064220846,
0.0537770502,
0.6287893653,
-0.5244714022,
-0.713773191,
0.1279134601,
-0.0729905218,
0.2202685922,
-0.4283908308,
0.6464701891,
0.3010226786,
0.1613422632,
-0.379149884,
-0.4629475176,
0.5103801489,
0.6105315685,
-0.2892221212,
0.5616744757,
0.3508547246,
-0.7679824233,
0.2799065709,
-0.8921811581,
-0.6721380353,
0.4597303271,
-0.2630280554,
-0.2879155278,
0.3314909339,
0.3187330365,
0.3565301001,
-0.5812555552,
0.0038366313,
-0.4539054334,
-0.2299138755,
-0.1344193071,
-0.1219799668,
0.4018143117,
0.2230980396,
-0.4582755864,
0.0462827235,
-0.683178544,
0.3618492782,
-0.2746918499,
-0.3628754318,
-0.3204981983,
0.045779556,
-0.2281279564,
-0.0064397017,
-0.3129437268,
-0.5268594027,
0.2681837678,
-0.5562796593,
0.6048339009,
0.527282238,
0.0036641534,
0.6979860067,
-0.3310475945,
0.7003464699,
-0.2477543056,
0.5453286767,
-0.2562622428,
-0.6745900512,
-0.377676785,
-0.6155128479,
-0.3502367437,
0.5473815203,
-0.6872761846,
0.8678705692,
-0.1272687614,
-0.4347633123,
-1.0420639515,
-0.0367347449,
0.4341557324,
0.9009790421,
0.5506336689,
-0.4169570208,
-0.2280660123,
-0.726690948,
-0.2457523644,
-0.0953761786,
-0.1497189999,
0.9673471451,
0.2184651345,
-0.2583096325,
0.6686378717,
-0.5568689704,
-0.4966727495,
-0.3422868848,
-0.0032047448,
0.0311738905,
0.6237712502,
0.2796138823,
-0.5183948874,
-0.6332194209,
-0.0241059475,
-0.8310280442,
-0.1327831298,
0.1089907214,
-0.4261089861,
-0.1352597028,
0.1198314056,
-0.550458014,
0.7228794098,
0.439801842,
-0.3304294944,
0.1886261702,
-0.0379259698,
0.4161994159,
-1.3135433197,
0.2102188617,
-0.2080752254,
-0.1880948246,
-0.4661557078,
-0.5594906807,
-0.5393856168,
-0.2936748266,
-0.1914000213,
0.566654563,
-0.0252893511,
0.2669817507,
-0.1685934663,
-0.3024488986,
0.0639549941,
0.5881428123,
-0.0010116145,
0.0642597303,
0.4185347557,
-0.2305884808,
0.6396946907,
0.7304370999,
-0.1283208877,
1.433023572,
-0.7392919064,
0.0476774834,
0.0064258492,
0.8768863678,
-0.3889648318,
-0.6652380824,
0.551689744,
-0.2833636701,
0.1292490959,
-0.2447997928,
-0.0843717158,
-0.4154630899,
-0.042832084,
0.4950792789,
0.6451559067,
-0.1208896935,
0.6321784854,
0.331420213,
-0.3130908906,
-0.3607730865,
-0.7072064281,
-0.0000264673,
-0.2446530163,
-0.5592975616,
0.2280231565,
-0.1510953456,
-0.2497383952,
0.3107824922,
-0.2153631002,
-0.1904332489,
0.067906104,
0.5076051354,
-0.0579584315,
-0.0286873914,
0.3618502617,
0.5553942323,
-0.1748972684,
0.0700661093,
-0.4848463833,
0.2316289395,
-0.0514020845,
-0.4236598909,
-0.8370730877,
0.9591170549,
0.2775529027,
-0.1143672094,
0.8860682249,
0.7334246039,
-0.3637011945,
-0.2218195349,
-0.3339825571,
-0.6220217347,
-0.4053050876,
0.1500488967,
0.0073427996,
-0.8782607317,
0.2273765951,
-0.1808453351,
0.0056396001,
-0.1744472533,
0.7862193584,
-0.1983506531,
1.2255718708,
0.1708554476,
0.2249531299,
0.329267323,
-0.1451866627,
0.3354057372,
-0.9150532484,
-0.3113745153,
-0.1925526112,
-0.6799486876,
-0.5238764286,
-0.2265758216,
0.664788425,
-0.1837813109,
-0.343115449,
0.0179390982,
-0.8765795231,
-0.0204579961,
0.4160608351,
0.7484577894,
0.0219888277,
-0.6645946503,
-0.1383517236,
-0.305773139,
-0.8431000113,
-0.2523598075,
0.383702457,
0.0132230753,
0.8069362044,
0.1993933022,
0.8792858124,
0.108616598,
0.6950386763,
-1.3199602365,
0.1733771265,
-0.012794327,
-0.5755752921,
-0.2755694091,
-0.4785532951,
-0.6735190749,
0.1232967451,
-0.4436683357,
-0.5778205991,
0.121634692,
0.5064364672,
-1.0007445812,
0.2881368995,
-0.6036571264,
0.8501506448,
-0.0710204318,
-0.5022729635,
-0.2060281634,
-0.7957234979,
0.1602244675,
0.0525025688,
0.1746514589,
-0.5463444591,
0.3702407181,
0.4130689204,
-0.739105165,
0.9781097174,
-0.2957055271,
0.1954711974,
0.0704116151,
0.1226791441,
0.1443297416,
0.5420666337,
-0.1553307325,
-0.5541049838,
-0.1393562257,
-0.6550036669,
-0.931126833,
0.5258446932,
-0.3824392259,
-0.6671501994,
0.045400504,
-0.4282402098,
-0.6325457096,
-0.002239252,
0.0072986009,
0.5426958203,
-0.4615359604,
0.158110708,
0.3208976686,
-0.6449049115,
0.2418438196,
0.3210855126,
0.4041016698,
-0.3443885148,
0.3941698074,
-0.169422701,
0.1833595783,
0.1837336868,
0.4790513217,
0.2630048096,
0.2723821402,
-0.1109935567,
0.0897839889,
-0.2954447269,
-0.6926732063,
-0.5513561368,
0.118693769,
-0.6390053034,
-0.408885479,
-0.3272713721,
-0.2014809549,
-0.1082487851,
-0.2027288079,
0.4491301477,
0.5167075396,
-0.4035987258,
0.3885320425,
-1.1475878954,
-0.0108804367,
0.5434216857,
0.2263799161,
0.2964541912,
-0.1917232424,
-0.4848966599,
-0.0472428091,
-0.3192783296,
-0.8690263033,
0.6524407268,
0.1222644448,
0.1682621837,
0.6419429779,
0.3210219145,
0.8125596046,
-0.9097370505,
0.723631084,
0.5201345682,
-0.8434717059,
0.8463580608,
-0.2842991352,
0.2721693516,
0.6744630337,
0.2777839601,
-0.5795734525,
-0.2681932747,
-0.6092794538,
-0.7232147455,
0.7378102541,
-0.0055245929,
0.4655597806,
-0.2929705381,
0.515393734,
-0.1619606912,
0.187139377,
-0.0114858216,
-0.0685290992,
-0.4508525133,
-0.4716122746,
0.3408034444,
0.0947086886,
-0.660830617,
-0.3494305313,
0.4324977994,
-0.4857330918,
0.4901752472,
0.4523251057,
0.3892844021,
-0.2286362499,
0.480039835,
0.2023792714,
-0.1267619431,
-0.125837341,
-0.0175787602,
0.3769426346,
0.0290133245,
-0.0438718386,
-0.2660180628,
0.412191689,
0.0130849713,
0.4245733023,
0.8385099769,
0.6505460739,
-0.4979452193,
0.3883543313,
-0.1609183699,
-0.088953197,
0.1542577744,
0.2487241477,
0.3591963351,
0.3907660544,
-0.1381354928,
0.0204033293,
0.3354631662,
-0.4546544254,
0.1181287989,
0.3991443813,
-0.7601780891,
-0.4993371964,
0.6678221822,
0.8026821017,
-0.7862603068,
0.494702071,
-0.0025245466,
-0.480140537,
0.2188256681,
0.3383001685,
0.7548974156,
-0.1666066051,
0.5327195525,
0.3570612371,
-0.0958603323,
-0.0382192694,
0.1721504033,
-0.4397774935,
-0.5323691368,
-0.4330061674,
-0.5803572536,
-0.8294047117,
-0.3548541665,
-1.1775865555,
-0.2185531706,
-0.2912984788,
-0.5650241971,
-0.0057636066,
-0.130357042,
-0.8534790874,
0.3110026717,
0.1075399071,
0.5246281028,
-0.6754170656,
0.5589004755,
0.5439853668,
-0.4315329492,
-0.8723914027,
-0.0973950401,
0.1600866318,
-0.9074133635,
0.614961803,
0.0929499939,
-0.199312672,
-0.1358670145,
-0.5727357268,
-0.0929809883,
1.2456777096,
0.3667667508,
-0.12463402,
-0.4832600355,
-0.1221667752,
0.7058522105,
-0.4816281199,
0.290687561,
0.3930265009,
0.5242369175,
0.0649109632,
-1.025236249,
0.0981192961,
-0.1485683769,
-0.0853055194,
-0.3013885319,
-0.9137867093,
0.3027959168,
-0.385340333,
0.0017066355,
0.1443519294,
0.1982415766,
-0.0643536821,
-0.0067434567,
0.3256301582,
0.5925714374,
0.8179977536,
-0.0234095752,
1.1167969704,
-0.5034453273,
0.2472314388,
1.1625020504,
-0.4329148531,
0.4823649824,
0.4204974174,
0.089270331,
0.2334451079,
0.3829226792,
0.1230075434,
0.3255563676,
0.1386365741,
-0.7740847468,
-0.4681159854,
-0.7264844179,
0.0547438189,
0.2724650204,
0.2063513398,
-0.3683193326,
-0.0789757967,
0.0782569647,
0.2673705518,
-0.0506233163,
-0.2248851508,
1.0064548254,
0.6058073044,
-0.6107040644,
0.1379881203,
-0.2238509804,
0.5691926479,
-0.4553636611,
-0.0718382522,
-0.3846285939,
0.0549742728,
-0.5098393559,
-0.2715406418,
0.4126886427,
0.1539890021,
-0.0974751115,
-0.598315239,
0.4695806801,
-0.4980499446,
-0.2031566799,
0.4522239566,
0.8501227498,
0.0147211431,
0.2884268761,
-0.8729149103,
-0.2151659727,
-0.2948675156,
-0.262246877,
0.2750284374,
0.601287365,
0.5241856575,
0.3610852659,
0.3429801166,
0.2476698756,
-0.4007090628,
0.2446305007,
0.6751053929,
-0.4817052782,
-0.3772518039,
-0.6182299256,
0.5809509158,
-0.2953331769,
-0.1745062172,
0.4840400219,
0.0252423417,
0.1539980769,
0.037181735,
0.9176244736,
-0.2614566982,
0.4696133435,
-0.192129001,
0.7484711409,
-0.7047521472,
-0.2650392354,
-0.2059033513,
-0.3807210922,
-0.5562931299,
0.8791495562,
-0.0475859568,
-0.0788403898,
0.6119306087,
0.6141983271,
0.1815050989,
-0.0433369055,
0.5669727921,
0.1215760708,
0.5487453341,
0.6030153036,
0.5127481818,
-0.0254291203,
0.3128790259,
0.0133335665,
-0.3071702719,
-0.1257946044,
-0.6467770934,
-0.8110050559,
-0.1876490414,
-0.2255490273,
-0.6328309774,
0.0661330223,
1.3832976818,
0.8373808265,
-0.5832210183,
0.0956963077,
0.2333808541,
-0.1179670617,
-0.0993056297,
-0.1763084084,
0.2413036972,
-0.4468833804,
-0.8277785778,
0.2835012078,
0.5670152903,
-0.3097577393,
-0.016250439,
-0.2488596439,
0.4636734128,
0.3317842782,
0.5400074124,
0.2735314071,
-0.4194074571,
-0.2800889015,
0.0144967409,
-0.1441513002,
0.3336928189,
0.9954050183,
-0.4064468741,
0.4123412073,
-0.0359510072,
0.7497584224,
0.2179294229,
0.1108718738,
0.5350511074,
-0.4286920726,
0.1662236899,
0.5735712051,
0.3559611142,
0.2822033167,
-0.3544362485,
0.4976684451,
0.1511563212,
-0.5804354548,
-0.7239337564,
0.4297154248,
-0.9552059174,
-0.0045369454,
1.1501953602,
-0.537042737,
-0.2352783531,
-0.1557669491,
-0.5020939112,
0.4108932614,
-0.5175777078,
0.764880538,
0.3697817028,
-0.8643614054,
0.3705455065,
-0.1830857694,
0.771474123,
0.5011903644,
-1.1675188541,
-0.1078040078,
0.3486407995,
0.1103835776,
-0.162425831,
0.9198505282,
0.1797770113,
-0.0338913389,
0.0197119843,
-0.0953358486,
0.2137175053,
0.27386114,
0.0852532536,
-0.2226112038,
-0.4388243556,
0.1308765113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08886v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08886v1
|
EIVEN: Efficient Implicit Attribute Value Extraction using Multimodal LLM
| 2024-04-13T03:15:56 | 2024-04-13T03:15:56 |
Henry Peng Zou, Gavin Heqing Yu, Ziwei Fan, Dan Bu, Han Liu, Peng Dai, Dongmei Jia, Cornelia Caragea
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
In e-commerce, accurately extracting product attribute values from multimodal
data is crucial for improving user experience and operational efficiency of
retailers. However, previous approaches to multimodal attribute value
extraction often struggle with implicit attribute values embedded in images or
text, rely heavily on extensive labeled data, and can easily confuse similar
attribute values. To address these issues, we introduce EIVEN, a data- and
parameter-efficient generative framework that pioneers the use of multimodal
LLM for implicit attribute value extraction. EIVEN leverages the rich inherent
knowledge of a pre-trained LLM and vision encoder to reduce reliance on labeled
data. We also introduce a novel Learning-by-Comparison technique to reduce
model confusion by enforcing attribute value comparison and difference
identification. Additionally, we construct initial open-source datasets for
multimodal implicit attribute value extraction. Our extensive experiments
reveal that EIVEN significantly outperforms existing methods in extracting
implicit attribute values while requiring less labeled data.
|
[
-0.1942005754,
-0.598423779,
0.4152936637,
0.2635761201,
-0.2755700946,
-0.0900610313,
0.0233634319,
-0.804279089,
-0.0900461003,
-0.1649799794,
-0.8752687573,
-0.5395040512,
-0.6283592582,
0.0876227096,
-0.2829685509,
0.9015919566,
0.2242994905,
-0.0456178486,
-0.5185979605,
-0.3702502549,
0.2629042566,
-0.3191666901,
-0.768535614,
0.0232968591,
0.9532510638,
0.0256728567,
0.4632116854,
0.489782095,
0.4815451503,
0.3400996923,
0.0578153171,
0.5559737682,
-0.4458578527,
0.2800267041,
0.2336081266,
-0.1852400601,
-0.7798519135,
0.1499137729,
0.0898031741,
0.195249483,
-0.1506628096,
0.3024009764,
-0.1495752335,
0.62142694,
-1.0078474283,
0.5874727368,
-0.369638741,
0.2126265615,
-0.141744554,
0.0560446605,
-0.328007251,
-0.4633712471,
0.0385092422,
-1.0233370066,
0.3504070044,
0.1414991468,
1.1200321913,
0.3713581562,
-0.5511968732,
-0.1863703579,
-0.6927726865,
0.9062079191,
-0.2701663077,
0.8543235064,
0.1733484268,
-0.0013932049,
0.1753670722,
-0.9577909112,
-0.878092289,
-0.067058526,
-0.1579542309,
0.4920033514,
-0.2799696922,
0.0077541745,
0.287257731,
0.2580311298,
-0.4056487381,
0.0191281587,
-0.2190806717,
0.1122172996,
0.5769818425,
0.0556076132,
0.1380103827,
-0.2635216713,
-0.5699865818,
-0.4264713228,
-0.8003666997,
0.1163272262,
0.2789118588,
-0.1887724996,
0.0102756936,
0.4384410679,
-0.2390868962,
0.5661207438,
0.1341470182,
-0.656657517,
0.5525510311,
-0.2922514081,
-0.3490338027,
-0.0834179223,
0.5877789855,
0.3558452725,
-0.1114423722,
-0.1419350505,
-0.2333591431,
-0.1778597832,
0.0276591051,
-0.72054106,
-0.3052574992,
0.0740978494,
-0.6290512681,
-0.214818269,
0.1669734269,
-0.9187811613,
-0.2387183011,
-0.4226200879,
0.2854758203,
0.1000964865,
-0.2667844296,
-0.271671176,
-0.2235475928,
0.6498522758,
0.7142096162,
-0.825240016,
-0.0629258081,
0.7337188125,
0.8166126013,
-0.4183725119,
0.1090636179,
-0.2505034804,
0.4696284533,
-0.0589639582,
0.6368659735,
-0.5258826613,
-0.0751159266,
-0.2356939763,
0.1793744862,
0.2123368382,
-0.4610179067,
0.2420380861,
-0.7995287776,
-0.2055169791,
0.0521658249,
-0.2989958227,
-0.1826521009,
0.5107471347,
-1.2407413721,
1.0452134609,
-0.0381837264,
-0.2437640876,
0.8147988319,
-0.4995505214,
-0.4170138836,
0.1207629889,
-0.2558747828,
-0.7858473063,
0.3101226389,
0.3928210735,
0.6130345464,
-0.5135263801,
-0.1579012126,
-0.4536345899,
0.1419711113,
0.4110863507,
-0.8894723058,
0.4884588122,
0.4091134965,
-0.2801721096,
-0.1331702322,
-0.8493067026,
0.1350587308,
0.1646534503,
-0.3496809304,
-0.3319483399,
-0.0966364518,
0.2899884582,
0.3288414776,
0.2771107852,
-0.6726899147,
0.0164785832,
0.1271294951,
-0.0342623517,
1.1855554581,
-0.4422588944,
0.3972041905,
-0.1534095258,
0.5307856202,
-0.0365966149,
0.4091112912,
-0.0519933291,
-0.4265508652,
-0.9794431329,
-0.6999252439,
0.2096269578,
0.3049639761,
-0.7744202018,
0.0779957846,
-0.4284702837,
-0.2405643165,
-0.5396707654,
0.262932986,
0.2887316346,
0.4727438688,
0.2930580676,
-0.0011962015,
-0.1835917234,
-0.9926367402,
-0.0541333482,
-0.1249275282,
-0.1196221113,
0.6667636633,
0.4320868254,
-0.135472998,
0.7875303626,
-0.8244590759,
-0.3992532492,
-0.2026321888,
0.5348567367,
0.0428401232,
0.4507119656,
0.0077460716,
-1.214848876,
-0.4479551911,
0.1673339754,
-0.7983249426,
-0.125184074,
-0.3488381803,
-0.1489013135,
0.2463549674,
0.2213861495,
-0.611019969,
0.54336375,
0.4804643691,
-0.1320862472,
0.1939366162,
-0.3253437877,
0.3805069029,
-0.9076530933,
-0.1597055793,
0.3137745559,
-0.2636106014,
-0.3989030719,
-0.013364736,
0.3714851737,
0.1333413422,
-0.8678459525,
0.3664792776,
-0.5765544772,
-0.0524100587,
0.1949445754,
-0.0966896415,
0.4438165724,
0.5207997561,
0.1929362118,
0.6235075593,
0.0621623658,
-0.7167820334,
0.9003377557,
0.2370499223,
-0.3282940686,
0.9924830794,
-0.4921545088,
0.2952759266,
-0.4879273474,
-0.0255948789,
-0.7903721333,
-0.025597766,
0.2993149459,
0.0307119489,
0.4554908872,
-0.2633733153,
-0.4971774518,
0.0698638782,
-0.367652297,
0.7413065434,
0.3550290465,
-0.87572366,
1.0798729658,
0.163027972,
-0.2153694183,
-0.5548564196,
-0.5405195951,
-0.1853411943,
-0.2525562942,
-0.6561267376,
0.5870886445,
-0.2130770385,
0.0417437106,
0.0097434986,
-0.0807708427,
-0.1122734547,
0.0652132928,
0.228656128,
0.3719804883,
0.0952365026,
0.4323399365,
0.0446510017,
-0.4184164405,
-0.0598334745,
0.0115250703,
-0.0823407099,
-0.1610665917,
-0.6100594401,
-0.1807120293,
0.4312199354,
0.3421973586,
-0.1180414781,
0.7747941613,
0.7585431337,
-0.2916091084,
-0.189936772,
-0.664493978,
-0.0162002482,
-0.4835473597,
0.5881094337,
-0.4662314951,
-0.4701646864,
0.1460456103,
-0.3373980224,
-0.1152368486,
0.3773301244,
0.2172640413,
-0.4089237154,
1.4516816139,
0.6808056235,
0.6000052691,
0.3423782289,
-0.1461289674,
0.0974421576,
-0.784996748,
-1.0138425827,
-0.2351154685,
-0.526016593,
-0.3631180823,
-0.2848693728,
0.5800482035,
-0.113413766,
-0.2146632224,
-0.0648294464,
-0.282305032,
0.4371603131,
0.4365623295,
0.6804438829,
0.3405970335,
0.1758327335,
0.2792520523,
-0.197086066,
-0.341958791,
-0.0680767372,
1.1203486919,
0.2330691069,
1.2441222668,
0.5549730659,
0.1100558713,
0.2085381448,
0.5779573321,
-0.916844666,
0.3270530403,
-0.3395996094,
-0.482596755,
0.0140687414,
-0.4129810035,
-0.7181149125,
0.3030306995,
-0.400118202,
-0.3191848397,
0.4540866613,
0.1681524813,
-0.4120139182,
0.2030811459,
-0.7112603188,
0.7939376235,
-0.8769291639,
-0.747128427,
0.1402427107,
-0.4481085241,
-0.0347947143,
-0.0628789291,
-0.0509997159,
-0.2788819969,
-0.3792664707,
0.7689571381,
-0.2921455204,
0.5551338196,
0.1264247298,
-0.1617410034,
-0.1761211902,
-0.2068949789,
0.5499811769,
0.0653229654,
0.1870425493,
0.2153292894,
-0.2614400983,
-0.2581730187,
-0.8487693071,
0.632532239,
-0.7143011093,
-0.3914287388,
-0.5008057952,
-0.3668908477,
-0.0066543208,
-0.1410193294,
0.1116881296,
0.3619523346,
-0.1400614381,
0.3813601732,
0.9770820141,
-0.3246877789,
0.6476302743,
0.3346810639,
0.0984483808,
-0.5010968447,
1.0223287344,
-0.1573158503,
0.3654280603,
0.4770238996,
0.0012354198,
-0.6918515563,
0.113696672,
-0.6592406034,
-0.0871059969,
-1.1117349863,
-0.3952228427,
-0.6309071183,
-0.0417449288,
-0.1746030897,
-0.1027804837,
-0.4073936641,
-0.3252505958,
-0.3460133076,
-0.349178344,
0.6320698261,
0.8338058591,
-0.1396675408,
0.2033390105,
-0.6908240318,
0.4576464891,
0.9456726909,
0.1845767796,
0.0031721136,
0.1111834943,
-0.1114198864,
-0.0426323041,
-0.2264707685,
-0.8761802316,
0.5084205866,
0.5356413126,
0.7425653934,
0.8547174931,
-0.1416480243,
0.9276111722,
-0.1315241754,
0.6918829679,
0.469753325,
-0.7442355156,
0.3067505062,
0.2658202052,
0.2211274803,
0.2426977009,
0.6076474786,
-0.3305616975,
0.2942765057,
-0.3221348524,
-1.2195848227,
0.7067996264,
0.1668655127,
0.1388050765,
0.1002460271,
0.2191269994,
0.3705741465,
0.4119548798,
-1.1365764141,
-0.6515164971,
-0.3571402133,
-0.4670562744,
0.0028664814,
-0.3270054758,
-0.1573656648,
-0.5836563706,
0.3263145685,
-0.2023369968,
0.4386431575,
0.0846759304,
-0.6827115417,
0.4398743808,
0.2745558918,
0.4348649681,
0.4684577584,
-0.0746328607,
0.4037194848,
0.2247735709,
-0.4238952994,
0.3547624648,
0.1494665146,
-0.1453964263,
-0.3717221618,
0.0365612544,
0.7743424177,
0.0338927209,
-0.4982342422,
0.7177836299,
-0.1911058128,
-0.000319016,
-0.5535026789,
-0.3033105135,
-0.135493651,
0.2139843255,
0.3686190248,
0.0156378262,
0.2468536198,
-0.1786889881,
0.1614088267,
0.3055972457,
-0.4204210341,
-0.1939266026,
0.6976098418,
0.3551034331,
0.1940165013,
0.9575455785,
-0.2061838657,
-0.2189155668,
0.6866482496,
0.6243446469,
0.946647048,
0.0534424633,
0.3823631704,
0.1378564537,
0.2448852062,
0.183170408,
0.2167350203,
-0.2789643407,
-0.7536059618,
-0.3332417011,
-0.556889832,
-0.0268022195,
0.0189262591,
-0.5937252045,
0.0930759683,
-0.4086248875,
-0.1374030262,
-0.2356173694,
-0.6054925919,
-1.0746052265,
0.3968396485,
0.3448834121,
0.2363879234,
-0.6541628242,
0.3405592442,
0.3971292078,
-0.6717818975,
-0.5666386485,
-0.5852719545,
0.145285964,
-0.6079203486,
1.3797353506,
0.3785219193,
-0.3837338686,
-0.0903252661,
-0.6954749823,
-0.6227135062,
1.4504338503,
0.3185936213,
-0.4103741944,
0.1539889425,
0.2889093757,
0.0583688319,
-0.5595266819,
0.8932644129,
0.3886019588,
0.7296909094,
0.4476820827,
-0.2841093242,
0.0054392428,
-0.5214195848,
0.2392896861,
0.0626533702,
-0.4361747205,
1.0160790682,
-0.069125466,
-0.3374209404,
-0.1503134072,
0.6198782325,
-0.0799767673,
0.3454948068,
0.5330689549,
0.8178722262,
0.7741710544,
-0.3710013628,
0.8915842772,
0.1625077426,
0.2631967366,
0.7209180593,
-0.2443187833,
0.7818084955,
0.4318536222,
-0.072183989,
0.6172896624,
0.5758441091,
-0.1487618536,
0.7341140509,
-0.1931847632,
-0.7295879126,
-0.5426819921,
-0.0340929367,
-0.2773437798,
0.3775530159,
0.3644941151,
-0.3690008819,
-0.0071009747,
0.0779927894,
-0.1124087647,
-0.495141238,
-0.3887053132,
1.1230851412,
0.004147708,
-0.0115948813,
0.1736670136,
-0.013324487,
0.7292454243,
-0.5494683981,
-0.4580433369,
-0.142446965,
0.2488037944,
-0.3848323822,
-0.3918684721,
-0.1812164783,
-0.1062170193,
-0.2467760444,
-0.5838653445,
0.6353248358,
-0.4895563722,
-0.7599381208,
0.212320894,
0.5906543732,
-0.1124080345,
0.0046355398,
-0.7628044486,
-0.1511023343,
-0.3180843592,
-0.3365919888,
0.150841862,
0.2578711212,
0.283452183,
0.8148341179,
0.8901539445,
-0.0630236268,
0.2352224737,
-0.0157881957,
0.7280818224,
-0.7201945782,
-0.2627976835,
-0.9031234384,
0.7727817297,
-0.4824447334,
-0.2812957466,
0.6343637109,
0.4854301512,
0.9516252279,
-0.1695541888,
0.5612864494,
-0.0831704363,
-0.0908271745,
-0.7413721085,
0.8367838264,
-0.8565965891,
0.3604430854,
-0.2570972443,
-0.9316657782,
-0.321903795,
0.7942909002,
0.1119143143,
0.2924869359,
0.7118842006,
0.9930907488,
-0.2126523852,
-0.0662463903,
0.3644155562,
-0.0686587617,
0.3814873397,
0.587767601,
0.9481745958,
-0.5046399832,
0.68650949,
-0.4376888573,
-0.3253832161,
0.0940394849,
-1.3164876699,
-0.4252187014,
-0.5566030145,
-0.5128132105,
-0.1795509309,
0.0651643202,
1.0654685497,
0.9650865793,
-0.7424527407,
0.1023705676,
0.2467108071,
0.3311034739,
-0.4322571158,
-0.2127225995,
0.3757687807,
0.1799338311,
-0.9643300176,
0.1551792771,
0.4210595191,
0.2588563263,
-0.1678803116,
-0.3203215003,
-0.0692317635,
-0.0873881653,
0.8674698472,
0.0817139298,
-0.5961114764,
-0.1547577679,
0.0349260643,
-0.0526155792,
0.1595647782,
0.6394838691,
-0.7504335046,
0.5520527363,
0.4576779008,
0.5827606916,
0.6486173868,
-0.0452907495,
0.522556603,
-0.8323820829,
0.1568690091,
-0.0841987133,
0.179683879,
0.3222847283,
-0.3185347319,
0.276917547,
0.3291608691,
-0.1479068398,
-0.2862106562,
0.5179179311,
-1.0087473392,
-0.1074841991,
1.1518378258,
-0.4610678256,
-0.4087172449,
-0.1749179065,
-0.0201769806,
0.0481411777,
-0.4399618506,
0.6374419928,
0.2117430121,
-0.0779743493,
-0.6894806623,
-0.1453672498,
0.4802761078,
0.1787005514,
-1.0363718271,
-0.5029329062,
0.6111286283,
0.0331581309,
-0.1402388811,
0.2034170777,
-0.0856560692,
0.2463832349,
-0.118030414,
0.2845255733,
-0.4187399149,
-0.4571680129,
-0.2699173391,
0.3011237681,
-0.0477510467,
-0.1539976597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08885v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08885v1
|
Is Next Token Prediction Sufficient for GPT? Exploration on Code Logic Comprehension
| 2024-04-13T03:11:07 | 2024-04-13T03:11:07 |
Mengnan Qi, Yufan Huang, Yongqiang Yao, Maoquan Wang, Bin Gu, Neel Sundaresan
|
cs.PL
|
cs.PL, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) has experienced exponential growth, they
demonstrate remarkable performance across various tasks. Notwithstanding,
contemporary research primarily centers on enhancing the size and quality of
pretraining data, still utilizing the next token prediction task on
autoregressive transformer model structure. The efficacy of this task in truly
facilitating the model's comprehension of code logic remains questionable, we
speculate that it still interprets code as mere text, while human emphasizes
the underlying logical knowledge. In order to prove it, we introduce a new
task, "Logically Equivalent Code Selection," which necessitates the selection
of logically equivalent code from a candidate set, given a query code. Our
experimental findings indicate that current LLMs underperform in this task,
since they understand code by unordered bag of keywords. To ameliorate their
performance, we propose an advanced pretraining task, "Next Token Prediction+".
This task aims to modify the sentence embedding distribution of the LLM without
sacrificing its generative capabilities. Our experimental results reveal that
following this pretraining, both Code Llama and StarCoder, the prevalent code
domain pretraining models, display significant improvements on our logically
equivalent code selection task and the code completion task.
|
[
-0.1528123021,
-0.4863443673,
0.6773506999,
-0.1134484336,
-0.4570453763,
0.3328671455,
-0.2237515897,
-0.4341112375,
-0.0101461234,
0.3837286234,
-0.5178479552,
-0.3562340438,
-0.7552760243,
0.1709655672,
-0.429751426,
1.0630344152,
-0.0652943477,
0.0985749587,
-0.4400739074,
0.2048002779,
-0.772667408,
-0.8845155835,
-0.5543177724,
-0.5064215064,
0.2106408328,
-0.0032934092,
0.5950266123,
0.5398067236,
0.524510026,
0.2516745627,
0.0204093233,
-0.2461162806,
-0.2647719383,
-0.1669700891,
-0.0051124864,
-0.9230870605,
-0.3602427542,
0.0707672462,
0.2307944596,
0.4797753096,
0.0749260113,
0.1696520001,
-0.0681551322,
0.5131111145,
-0.3464998901,
0.4208764732,
-1.2465457916,
0.2560594678,
0.0365712643,
-0.3600935042,
-0.4492507577,
-0.227690056,
-0.0462593213,
-0.5591786504,
0.1828267276,
0.2168223858,
0.6519589424,
0.4827234745,
-0.3746707141,
-0.1795092225,
-0.4317093492,
0.4172091186,
-0.5368617773,
0.3307903409,
0.4365518093,
0.1920027882,
0.0920720249,
-1.0089131594,
-0.8924173117,
-0.4730725288,
-0.1509488076,
0.1125495136,
-0.1906956583,
0.1719292998,
0.3559044302,
0.1520429254,
-0.6251860857,
0.0212139655,
-0.3633784056,
-0.4566754103,
0.1069923341,
0.0982327387,
0.2503874302,
-0.0593192987,
-0.4273632467,
0.0237640794,
-0.9835714698,
-0.0004300001,
0.1297620386,
-0.0901791081,
0.2679264545,
0.6190564632,
0.0010520678,
0.6491200924,
-0.1112860143,
0.1506211609,
0.4615523517,
-0.3829486668,
-0.4625020623,
-0.0387635417,
0.4288092256,
0.2353372872,
0.6001548767,
-0.1996596009,
-0.3722496927,
0.4963099062,
0.4507846832,
-0.7782020569,
-0.5559056997,
-0.0395277627,
-0.4977763891,
-0.266027391,
0.1847731769,
-0.2700256407,
-0.1747513413,
-0.5987922549,
0.3336210251,
-0.3047070801,
-0.2106003016,
0.1842491329,
-0.1030681804,
0.2510075271,
0.0700094774,
-0.7654067278,
0.1608037651,
0.79263556,
0.7695649266,
-0.1022047028,
-0.4251925647,
-0.6309686303,
-0.025626827,
-0.3976698816,
0.7976008654,
-0.8416227698,
-0.4325018823,
-0.1388897449,
-0.0996911898,
-0.3189042509,
-0.4916948974,
0.5340073109,
-0.916115284,
-0.0454375893,
-0.354539603,
-0.6569254398,
0.0177633222,
0.1730925739,
-0.4311241806,
0.4856719971,
0.2764951289,
-0.818883419,
0.6491556764,
-0.5349030495,
-0.483886838,
-0.0086041838,
-0.4237559438,
-0.2546099722,
0.1925923973,
0.4043267667,
0.4980863929,
0.0128129199,
0.3855139613,
-0.1857548356,
-0.7390714884,
0.2810714841,
-0.3991008997,
0.3484578133,
0.2633009851,
-0.5423967242,
0.2877832353,
-0.3021514118,
0.1880996525,
0.0095444536,
-0.0939646959,
0.1644333452,
-0.016589541,
-0.2051669508,
0.4394088387,
0.1144970581,
-0.2598024607,
0.3310475051,
-0.409011662,
0.6132825613,
1.144004941,
-0.3028270304,
0.5078252554,
-0.1829807609,
0.9013208151,
-0.1515074521,
0.1125932783,
-0.2526687086,
-0.521887362,
-0.5345886946,
-0.029338453,
0.2863039374,
0.6266936064,
-0.9793756008,
0.4481225908,
-0.5430304408,
-0.1147929281,
-0.0594654344,
0.1733985245,
0.5006476641,
0.4222712815,
0.4830872118,
-0.25855726,
-0.784889698,
-0.5093636513,
-0.4835799634,
-0.4925102293,
-0.0346706323,
0.0256417748,
0.4965381324,
-0.479424566,
0.8861854076,
-0.6052076221,
-0.3370124698,
-0.5151321888,
-0.1798914075,
0.3968026042,
0.3748503625,
0.3825088143,
-0.7721712589,
-0.3283227086,
-0.0656364635,
-0.4387620091,
0.0953381434,
-0.0386301577,
0.031323269,
0.2312771976,
0.9653797746,
-0.5536077023,
0.3749572635,
0.6051458716,
-0.5237163901,
0.5974105597,
-0.2074825615,
-0.166576162,
-0.7905772924,
0.0213816427,
-0.38299793,
-0.2843934298,
-0.4434937537,
-0.0266612936,
0.181554094,
-0.0394867398,
-0.209032625,
0.5472818017,
-0.392809093,
-0.2600223124,
-0.4750786722,
-0.1433439106,
-0.1853209585,
0.5193721652,
0.1431750506,
1.1382762194,
0.6193574667,
-0.3664058447,
0.1267906278,
0.2846531272,
-0.5600961447,
-0.1195135191,
-0.8004201055,
0.3198028505,
-0.083681494,
0.5172284842,
-0.895432055,
0.0743053779,
0.1035356894,
-0.6199039817,
0.2661964297,
-0.118610248,
-0.5754411221,
-0.6044352055,
-0.0833320618,
0.4683594704,
0.9456870556,
-0.5759458542,
0.3495975435,
0.1921076626,
-0.1301808506,
-0.6360529661,
-0.7053087354,
0.0934419036,
-0.1606663316,
-0.2339956164,
0.1827640086,
-0.0278167594,
0.0768273547,
0.0117199486,
-0.3357145488,
0.1511873156,
-0.0210483316,
0.1487115473,
0.6038934588,
-0.1165785193,
0.2281869352,
-0.1670104116,
-0.4042892754,
0.334305495,
-0.9757837653,
0.6688504219,
-0.1210673526,
-0.5068007112,
-0.1707002372,
-0.2429764569,
0.1994167566,
-0.4543711841,
0.4829057753,
0.8181524277,
-0.128883332,
-0.0792602897,
-0.5202234983,
-0.1181922182,
-0.5037401319,
0.6066219211,
-0.5606935024,
-1.1555533409,
0.372433126,
-0.0324124806,
-0.2435697615,
0.3895379901,
0.3949899971,
0.2014652342,
1.0256251097,
0.8052881956,
-0.4429334104,
0.5314795375,
-0.2245085835,
0.3109385073,
-0.6327298284,
-0.2932649255,
-0.4209215939,
-0.0168886147,
-0.2963487804,
-0.5940748453,
0.2438409626,
0.1768877655,
-0.4127649665,
0.3579337597,
-0.5011953115,
0.7343856692,
0.3439643085,
-0.0322727524,
0.2764194608,
0.1040720791,
-0.087484993,
0.1200799197,
-0.5939375162,
-0.2998707592,
1.5351109505,
0.153770715,
0.4841991365,
-0.3704351485,
0.6245532632,
0.1494563222,
0.5745996833,
-0.4955730736,
0.3838228285,
-0.1134196594,
-0.3636803627,
-0.0953941494,
-0.5242586732,
-0.7859792113,
0.2105584294,
0.026690254,
-0.8129737973,
-0.1374011636,
0.2233540863,
-0.2612836063,
0.338103652,
-0.7482761741,
0.9340684414,
-0.2124494314,
0.2240186185,
-0.1499453187,
-0.6138521433,
0.2975544333,
-0.3462708294,
0.2897080481,
0.0281508937,
-0.2430779934,
0.6282740235,
-0.4025803506,
0.6272579432,
-0.2730016112,
0.034209244,
0.2321585715,
0.0182828289,
0.8111749291,
0.1487720907,
-0.0220547859,
-0.1431913674,
-0.1399878412,
-0.4589347541,
-0.8367497325,
0.4429595172,
-0.692710042,
-0.8574947715,
-0.1694022268,
-0.2750148177,
-0.442506671,
0.1872514784,
0.4515051842,
0.4180700779,
0.1660594493,
-0.0944901109,
0.6306033134,
0.0058507356,
0.3694798946,
-0.0947880894,
-0.3205145001,
-0.3993973434,
0.8914809823,
-0.3346505463,
0.2282800227,
0.506203413,
0.0562336035,
-0.6116076708,
-0.943041563,
-0.2378191203,
-0.027707383,
-0.8355181813,
-0.4346944094,
-0.8455582261,
-0.096278362,
-0.2870495021,
-0.146510914,
0.0446464382,
-0.2039008588,
-0.2223248035,
-0.4440519512,
0.2424046397,
0.7984437346,
0.3220050037,
0.1719037294,
-0.8231672049,
0.2459571362,
0.1493050903,
0.3726326823,
-0.1089001074,
-0.7940114141,
-0.2728556395,
-0.1419583559,
-0.0501810312,
-0.430110693,
0.2729830444,
0.1000416726,
0.6708313823,
0.2433969229,
-0.1464920491,
0.7839943171,
-0.7258543372,
0.7094814181,
0.4341591001,
-1.1380485296,
0.4832994342,
-0.1259971112,
0.1593158096,
0.6670291424,
0.19231686,
-0.2724097967,
-0.3957118988,
-0.7015402913,
-0.5850001574,
0.3844509423,
0.2482181191,
0.4954297841,
-0.0625998825,
0.5333460569,
0.1747649908,
0.440335393,
-0.9184370041,
-0.0427367836,
-0.4144482017,
-0.0761790723,
-0.551158011,
-0.0870250687,
0.4198805988,
-0.5471680164,
0.3258839846,
-0.3137039244,
0.6078641415,
0.1032374129,
-0.1603714824,
0.0297287907,
0.0293239895,
0.2285341471,
0.9970389009,
0.1134508401,
-0.0041893586,
0.3420108855,
-0.6247819662,
0.1555539072,
0.0709249452,
0.2261604071,
-0.1762292534,
0.7003497481,
0.8228312135,
-0.0064404029,
-0.84209764,
0.8057197332,
-0.0697716102,
-0.3735657334,
-0.4714262187,
0.1856318116,
-0.0598961823,
0.2754725218,
0.4560805261,
0.4267411828,
0.0303001199,
-0.6778005362,
0.3626362383,
0.4391849935,
-0.3330764174,
-0.2587596476,
0.9454519153,
-0.0309129413,
0.0319898725,
0.6724537611,
-0.3344071209,
-1.0013798475,
0.7286784053,
0.6265969872,
0.9001053572,
0.2206055671,
0.0336012132,
0.0919645429,
0.3029472232,
-0.1488715857,
0.2053288519,
-0.0403099768,
-0.7933901548,
-0.9090282917,
-0.6648774147,
0.0583890527,
-0.0898855254,
-0.3403531015,
0.1970659494,
-0.3885954916,
0.0029472429,
-0.5667651296,
0.0700530559,
-0.8591415882,
0.356975317,
0.1326171756,
1.0571864843,
-0.5817093849,
1.2482446432,
0.7413820624,
-0.2833227515,
-1.0872823,
0.3668609858,
-0.3703158796,
-1.0980423689,
0.88098979,
0.3200604618,
0.121164307,
0.067577906,
-0.3723914325,
-0.8057907224,
1.1762633324,
0.4884371459,
-0.5873679519,
-0.2882173061,
0.0226259939,
0.5181441307,
-0.3886960447,
0.3554695547,
0.6450684071,
0.4237758219,
0.1532955319,
-0.8015518188,
0.2302244455,
-0.3298265636,
0.1929708868,
0.0890905261,
-0.2498746365,
0.9188793302,
-0.501763761,
-0.057995934,
0.1466644406,
0.7027154565,
0.1731198877,
0.0994496122,
0.74964571,
0.3343659341,
0.7844190001,
-0.0024201528,
1.2552329302,
-0.3849434555,
0.2462588549,
0.9734042883,
-0.2331651598,
0.8407407403,
0.3745147586,
-0.492287457,
0.464640379,
0.7060275078,
0.0339052007,
0.5977502465,
0.505395472,
-0.0885891914,
-0.3505830765,
0.3610884845,
-0.6330858469,
0.3396856487,
0.1430422217,
-0.2951068282,
0.2068505734,
0.0642877072,
-0.2223598808,
0.0121609233,
-0.4111958444,
0.7514141798,
0.1542801261,
-0.6948450804,
0.6037399769,
-0.184885785,
0.8124632835,
-0.5326077938,
0.0818557888,
-0.2455498427,
0.1826301217,
-0.1471631229,
-0.5143402815,
0.366489917,
-0.0726299807,
0.1243916824,
-0.236331284,
0.8852593899,
-0.0735035464,
-0.439950794,
0.2876626551,
0.6099944711,
-0.0035967757,
-0.4433369339,
-0.6414099336,
0.0312729627,
0.185943827,
-0.1789980233,
0.3677310944,
0.4710849822,
0.0690662339,
0.71895504,
0.8996344805,
0.1424680203,
0.1308169365,
0.1851985306,
1.1866116524,
-0.6449993253,
-0.6865436435,
-0.9663360119,
0.2442285568,
0.1863572299,
-0.1711245179,
0.4920413792,
0.4159331024,
1.1463868618,
-0.1792006195,
0.9612281919,
0.1881187111,
0.0571751706,
-0.8821452856,
0.5205824375,
-0.3610016108,
0.4711617529,
-0.4204597771,
-1.1542308331,
-0.2896695137,
0.4290946126,
-0.4641275704,
0.133148849,
1.065782547,
0.6153089404,
0.0748415366,
0.1809495538,
0.3329873681,
-0.0878153443,
0.3561634123,
0.7338613868,
0.9783956409,
-0.202605024,
0.8837119937,
0.1759245247,
-0.0664384589,
0.0976764187,
-0.811983645,
-1.1576834917,
-0.554007113,
0.0591391623,
-0.2514133751,
0.2108080238,
0.9407060146,
0.5089945793,
-0.6148836613,
0.1226754189,
-0.7015848756,
0.0527684242,
-0.0512293838,
-0.0958387032,
0.4238875806,
-0.7449283004,
-0.419945389,
0.1225466803,
-0.0259428583,
-0.0114380158,
0.1130958498,
-0.2303883433,
0.421230495,
-0.3046883643,
0.6980309486,
-0.0935744047,
-0.7133730054,
-0.3896333575,
0.1175639033,
0.090782851,
0.0293139759,
1.2893264294,
-1.1752533913,
0.1151078716,
0.3276560307,
0.9688835144,
0.3866361082,
-0.0256125703,
0.6799416542,
-0.4144809544,
0.1708067507,
0.2637678385,
0.5570296645,
-0.0208808165,
-0.3800568581,
0.4752454758,
0.3130464554,
-0.4488340318,
-0.5893517137,
0.3152613342,
-0.560454309,
-0.4357348084,
1.2130265236,
-0.2328004092,
-0.0741426647,
-0.152098015,
-0.2274716049,
0.0994958282,
-0.2284503877,
0.476839453,
0.4493771493,
-0.0445564874,
-0.0913725048,
-0.5920680165,
0.658231914,
0.6206547618,
-0.7594286203,
0.0030966457,
0.2670116425,
0.1704993099,
-0.1343384683,
0.9678258896,
-0.1002302393,
0.2814471424,
-0.0163076222,
-0.2632211745,
-0.2799649537,
-0.388564527,
-0.2717789412,
-0.0738549605,
0.2806431055,
0.005170993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08877v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08877v1
|
Aligning LLMs for FL-free Program Repair
| 2024-04-13T02:36:40 | 2024-04-13T02:36:40 |
Junjielong Xu, Ying Fu, Shin Hwei Tan, Pinjia He
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved decent results on automated
program repair (APR). However, the next token prediction training objective of
decoder-only LLMs (e.g., GPT-4) is misaligned with the masked span prediction
objective of current infilling-style methods, which impedes LLMs from fully
leveraging pre-trained knowledge for program repair. In addition, while some
LLMs are capable of locating and repairing bugs end-to-end when using the
related artifacts (e.g., test cases) as input, existing methods regard them as
separate tasks and ask LLMs to generate patches at fixed locations. This
restriction hinders LLMs from exploring potential patches beyond the given
locations.
In this paper, we investigate a new approach to adapt LLMs to program repair.
Our core insight is that LLM's APR capability can be greatly improved by simply
aligning the output to their training objective and allowing them to refine the
whole program without first performing fault localization. Based on this
insight, we designed D4C, a straightforward prompting framework for APR. D4C
can repair 180 bugs correctly in Defects4J, with each patch being sampled only
10 times. This surpasses the SOTA APR methods with perfect fault localization
by 10% and reduces the patch sampling number by 90%. Our findings reveal that
(1) objective alignment is crucial for fully exploiting LLM's pre-trained
capability, and (2) replacing the traditional localize-then-repair workflow
with direct debugging is more effective for LLM-based APR methods. Thus, we
believe this paper introduces a new mindset for harnessing LLMs in APR.
|
[
-0.1789239496,
-0.3465377986,
0.7118119597,
0.2367167771,
-0.0306854621,
0.3771627843,
-0.1714636385,
-0.5066776276,
0.1496682316,
0.3731521666,
-0.842330873,
-0.4632348716,
-0.3056926131,
0.1813554764,
0.0434090383,
1.117489934,
-0.4977647066,
-0.1641015261,
-0.2596007288,
0.0184871275,
-0.7882474661,
-0.262519002,
-0.8414255977,
-0.1112516448,
0.3427643478,
0.7156795263,
0.396510005,
0.8197566271,
0.620433569,
0.3277656734,
0.4089955986,
0.1633964181,
-0.3323571682,
-0.0419375151,
0.2490087897,
-0.7685709,
-0.6330171824,
-0.1091345474,
0.3856430054,
0.2384034693,
0.0518537275,
-0.1504292637,
0.127036646,
0.793771565,
-0.4020748138,
0.0748301372,
-0.6630609632,
-0.0071260352,
-0.171422258,
-0.3236539364,
-0.1094725505,
-0.299695909,
-0.4245571792,
-0.7537754178,
0.2026717216,
0.1204069331,
0.7426853776,
0.6624601483,
-0.2205008864,
0.0156106213,
-0.45437029,
0.7933986783,
-0.9014332891,
0.0394922495,
0.113697052,
0.279381901,
-0.4163321853,
-0.0840804055,
-0.358295083,
0.1381240487,
0.180837363,
0.1070424169,
0.0053637936,
0.1680879742,
0.2438598722,
0.4798472226,
-0.381906569,
0.4254695475,
-0.1422792971,
-0.5799435973,
0.6094997525,
0.0967354774,
0.2192531973,
0.4434172809,
-0.7333284616,
0.2839791179,
-1.0067521334,
0.0345707722,
0.4437840581,
0.2000874877,
-0.0925296471,
0.2829101384,
0.0531459525,
0.8563343883,
0.2167645842,
-0.3446237147,
0.269838661,
-0.3934653699,
-0.0795117393,
0.3133580387,
0.5282871723,
0.3608331382,
0.1599265933,
-0.0416161381,
-0.5754793286,
-0.0509673096,
0.1993827671,
-0.388299793,
-0.078893505,
0.2734315097,
0.0247606486,
-0.3726540208,
0.1491904259,
-0.4415768087,
-0.4634246528,
-0.4179275334,
0.2800680399,
-0.3379580081,
-0.2390694767,
0.0212775618,
0.1960590482,
0.2118154764,
0.1938286424,
-0.9272485971,
-0.0616997257,
0.8782036901,
0.8047654033,
-0.1546908468,
-0.3028347492,
-0.8050842881,
0.2121109366,
-0.5272092819,
0.9455043077,
-0.3592519164,
-0.0667771101,
0.1015450731,
-0.0059142141,
-0.0231284443,
-0.4016332328,
0.2675974965,
-0.3866701126,
-0.0622362904,
-0.6139863729,
-0.4049816728,
0.2285200506,
0.4623610377,
-0.4796834588,
1.0117908716,
0.2602446675,
-0.7855104804,
0.216222629,
-0.5704847574,
-0.1327466965,
-0.4012919962,
-0.1502606869,
-0.5476955771,
-0.0578991584,
0.6159502864,
0.1681403518,
0.0953348875,
0.1009058654,
-0.2939771414,
-0.6846836805,
0.2111758292,
-0.262437731,
0.5041287541,
0.1318755895,
-0.6973847151,
0.3596203923,
-0.5446192026,
-0.1498576403,
-0.2216970921,
-0.3347431123,
-0.1639153212,
-0.1753015667,
-0.6678951383,
0.2289257646,
0.4310343564,
-0.8607273698,
0.4591422379,
-0.9412855506,
0.2042770386,
1.1630538702,
-0.0712623373,
0.6338490844,
-0.4612978101,
0.838958919,
0.1598877311,
0.0807608962,
-0.2764894366,
-0.19896245,
-0.7323451638,
-0.5159642696,
-0.0903395563,
0.4193475544,
-0.6020584702,
0.3483972847,
-0.1250072867,
-0.098807551,
-0.4312250912,
0.2632324994,
0.4167742729,
0.8261735439,
0.264944613,
-0.089983359,
-0.8013273478,
-0.5701092482,
-0.2259778231,
-0.1014712974,
0.0635801256,
-0.1473203152,
0.0259099007,
-0.161522001,
0.9217579961,
-0.434070915,
-0.7249312401,
-0.2549495101,
-0.325337559,
0.3792962432,
0.3259950578,
0.22702384,
-0.2139962167,
-0.6213449836,
-0.1270678788,
-0.3961614966,
-0.4515466988,
-0.1130836681,
-0.1061192304,
0.7391620278,
0.7094504237,
-0.4153793156,
0.3463415802,
0.6716761589,
-0.3306168318,
0.3475135267,
-0.165184781,
0.2218735367,
-0.9355030656,
-0.0519527458,
-0.2323126048,
-0.2818955183,
-0.387509644,
-0.1954893321,
0.2069564909,
-0.0479484051,
-0.2974881232,
0.5311146379,
-0.8262060285,
-0.2476054281,
-0.5101501942,
0.1499532163,
0.0171872657,
0.4171216786,
-0.2638497651,
0.859829545,
0.4675680697,
-0.2338549793,
0.1588817835,
0.0646069646,
-0.0262310784,
0.452068001,
-0.3509556353,
0.1942031682,
-0.0923354551,
0.3711348772,
-1.1795884371,
-0.0834654272,
0.3356713057,
-0.2754833996,
0.5111922026,
-0.0269013979,
-0.1148111522,
-0.324539721,
-0.6147227287,
0.4239230156,
0.2717642486,
-0.605245769,
0.3637244999,
0.1194769517,
-0.0770686343,
-0.8410432339,
-0.5264155865,
-0.1068711653,
-0.440921098,
-0.6352232099,
0.5133510232,
-0.1729926169,
-0.0707709417,
-0.1841965169,
-0.7235053182,
0.0263347756,
0.2157256007,
0.3902947903,
0.4557500184,
-0.3554970026,
-0.0029850255,
-0.1753953397,
-0.4431824088,
-0.1840149611,
-0.3419052362,
0.4309911132,
-0.1994177252,
-0.6748856306,
-0.0944844037,
0.0653412044,
0.4428494275,
-0.5539667606,
0.3801678419,
0.5618194938,
-0.115553692,
-0.0335811637,
-0.750173986,
-0.1999382377,
-0.4828639925,
0.218035534,
-0.2268047482,
-0.9008900523,
0.4781342447,
0.0831849054,
0.3436757028,
0.2107056677,
0.2805519402,
-0.0603654645,
0.9705471396,
0.906347692,
-0.4676676691,
0.4143839478,
0.077763088,
0.6388203502,
-0.8723124862,
-0.1094806939,
-0.4267675877,
-0.479450047,
0.1482919455,
-0.305575788,
0.2729288042,
0.290866673,
-0.3288776875,
0.1852143854,
-0.6439744234,
0.652982831,
0.2893288136,
-0.0040533245,
0.2967996001,
0.0200788993,
-0.165625155,
-0.0578664392,
-0.5111727118,
-0.3542298675,
0.976028204,
0.4964320064,
0.5240588188,
0.0155880954,
1.1977901459,
-0.1664723307,
0.4186334014,
-0.6478178501,
0.370026648,
0.0889414698,
-0.1961960196,
-0.3867486715,
-0.1336565316,
-0.9321911335,
-0.269300133,
0.1772206575,
-0.5142143965,
-0.0397339426,
0.5506154895,
-0.4776549935,
0.3766583502,
-0.3738161027,
0.8379471302,
-0.4354378283,
-0.0518169925,
-0.0310614705,
-0.5151542425,
0.4053693414,
-0.2546314299,
0.4098065495,
-0.3168205619,
-0.2555615604,
0.4329940677,
-0.7707538009,
0.8169409037,
-0.4981364906,
-0.4992695451,
0.0780777559,
-0.002001822,
0.7491165996,
-0.0249904953,
-0.0621919334,
0.0254059024,
-0.0390553139,
-0.2795826197,
-0.5106198788,
0.9509122372,
-0.6356365681,
-0.7525972724,
-0.6181976795,
-0.7849874496,
-0.4154869318,
0.1774561703,
0.0207139887,
0.2282348573,
0.2413130254,
-0.383867681,
0.6032737494,
-0.0248035993,
0.6632493734,
0.7539686561,
-0.1836965084,
-0.2192848623,
0.8725170493,
-0.2306497097,
0.0296405144,
0.4223264456,
0.0582081079,
-0.1881826371,
-0.6266528368,
-0.2390747219,
0.2939272523,
-0.6228068471,
-0.734138608,
-0.2390226573,
0.0006601677,
-0.275049448,
-0.3801007867,
-0.3117057681,
-0.2116573751,
-0.3734950423,
-0.2070216537,
0.4814769328,
0.3617756963,
-0.13990587,
0.2232681215,
-0.8444145322,
0.165143922,
-0.1811813265,
0.6053429842,
-0.2953854501,
-0.3175452352,
-0.2728029191,
0.237232089,
-0.3502502441,
-0.7503834367,
0.2322903275,
0.2355908602,
0.5365943909,
0.2430202365,
0.0833308324,
0.9481664896,
-0.5507908463,
0.7656724453,
0.1898124665,
-0.8492513299,
0.5404171348,
-0.2487463355,
0.1614127159,
0.594381392,
0.1270157993,
-0.3203108013,
-0.5806214809,
-0.3200417757,
-0.7522416711,
0.6258257627,
-0.2850884497,
-0.1469765902,
-0.2203795761,
0.5159132481,
0.0462007895,
-0.0642013475,
-0.4515554607,
0.0833129659,
-0.2997523248,
-0.6892846227,
-0.0747115538,
-0.0773959383,
-0.1568782032,
-0.0805122778,
0.8791479468,
-0.4704054594,
0.431237787,
0.2906807959,
-0.1319541037,
-0.4729544818,
0.0539535098,
0.7718999982,
0.6978569627,
0.0315562971,
0.0871916413,
0.1151193753,
-0.1014962569,
0.2920930088,
-0.0983075649,
0.1931529194,
-0.2182535827,
0.351506412,
0.629971981,
0.315556407,
-0.6926673055,
0.7312986255,
0.1430812478,
-0.1408433616,
-0.2918209732,
0.1898097694,
0.061702475,
0.3783369064,
0.3379961252,
0.2545708418,
-0.3414575458,
-0.3264372945,
0.3039210141,
0.7053542733,
-0.5245885253,
-0.3380086422,
0.7236250639,
0.1698476076,
-0.1455820352,
0.711122632,
0.1589236856,
-0.5259718895,
0.7097120881,
0.697883606,
0.7159169316,
-0.2811979353,
0.0984475985,
0.3453911245,
0.2368482053,
-0.1904069483,
0.3029133677,
0.1724622995,
-0.6671996117,
-0.6362685561,
-0.6176700592,
-0.0066894377,
0.0550349019,
-0.1333220899,
0.5106927156,
-0.4633440077,
0.1231809556,
-0.5386615992,
0.0193109103,
-0.3965276182,
0.0351942144,
0.0076664253,
0.9592252374,
-0.8572970033,
0.8031210899,
0.5063790083,
-0.4041198492,
-1.2464692593,
0.191998899,
0.2431274354,
-1.0454982519,
0.3629842401,
0.4365218282,
0.2573647499,
0.1427875757,
-0.2878431082,
-1.199495554,
1.1491552591,
0.5759425759,
-0.7612518668,
-0.0825636908,
0.1112607345,
0.3093138933,
-0.3864920139,
0.0002346757,
0.4763783813,
0.5555114746,
-0.0004617615,
-0.916539073,
0.3310492635,
-0.0547428392,
-0.1999327987,
0.5302946568,
-0.4609062672,
0.5448633432,
-0.3892706633,
-0.022361856,
0.0752027258,
0.5110250115,
0.4216750264,
0.1427549869,
0.5712550282,
0.6070010066,
0.6725648046,
-0.2523508668,
0.9311784506,
-0.4278837144,
-0.0011480467,
0.9610207081,
-0.2130072117,
0.4117934108,
0.7596883178,
-0.1549560428,
0.4812446833,
0.8315612078,
-0.0577445365,
0.5758179426,
0.2443410158,
-0.1554382592,
0.0296452586,
0.317281574,
-0.2642491162,
0.1927229315,
-0.0011565537,
-0.0302063748,
-0.1942497194,
0.0064097592,
0.0918937624,
-0.0088667599,
-0.3718094826,
0.7943892479,
0.0900058001,
-0.9238055348,
0.7252241373,
-0.0074040177,
0.6634126902,
-0.6087151766,
-0.0107082641,
-0.5361086726,
0.3448578715,
-0.6749081016,
-0.5156754255,
0.7507745624,
-0.0658088401,
-0.1680259109,
-0.1346709579,
0.6454237103,
-0.5038847327,
-0.2682800591,
-0.0518847108,
0.0152338538,
0.0350726806,
-0.260369271,
-0.4514211714,
0.3937678039,
0.3943682015,
-0.1185351014,
0.5713540316,
0.3587391376,
-0.3840769231,
0.4598097503,
0.6132703424,
0.2605978549,
0.1483457834,
-0.0434289388,
0.7552554011,
-0.3809551299,
-0.2941674888,
-0.9168956876,
0.7927936316,
0.1342365891,
0.0490140915,
0.7168304324,
0.4361143112,
0.5301182866,
0.0678032637,
0.7524983287,
0.1454161108,
0.342177242,
-0.575545013,
0.2388532907,
-0.4148814976,
0.7713406682,
-0.2485217154,
-1.1642535925,
-0.4549793601,
0.5712510347,
-0.2125364691,
-0.1564239413,
0.6178779602,
1.0766375065,
0.0448965356,
-0.3236707747,
0.0680110753,
0.1570509225,
0.5690379143,
0.642365098,
0.6320599914,
-0.1880379915,
0.6177476645,
-0.1661857516,
-0.5022608638,
-0.0213086121,
-1.143512845,
-0.5896267295,
-0.2593215704,
-0.4754354656,
-0.12328206,
-0.0590682514,
0.8065767288,
0.2557163239,
-0.693389535,
0.1444267482,
-0.5128329992,
0.0794626325,
-0.4272699654,
-0.1962587088,
0.2930073142,
-0.8380092382,
-0.4581246078,
0.7959983945,
0.3925391734,
-0.0408873223,
-0.1427481025,
-0.3696265519,
0.1453990042,
-0.2009686232,
0.2057060748,
0.4265848994,
-0.7563408017,
-0.6505386829,
0.2180430442,
0.085022971,
0.324629128,
0.8665203452,
-0.7489165664,
0.2395582646,
0.2709012628,
0.8240221739,
0.1848304719,
0.0681422874,
0.9121354818,
-1.0786752701,
0.052984111,
0.1233537272,
0.4554203153,
0.4113318026,
-0.6349318027,
0.3359173834,
-0.1121864766,
-0.7431529164,
-0.8085663319,
0.2992539704,
-0.6401451826,
-0.1524917781,
1.0516833067,
-0.2266329825,
-0.0393390879,
-0.1534847617,
-0.5109450817,
0.3861828446,
-0.1572263092,
0.7637414932,
0.4560489058,
-0.255807817,
-0.2095314562,
-0.1410167813,
0.5775811672,
0.3996224701,
-0.5848093629,
0.0405598246,
0.5252765417,
0.6572465301,
-0.0649778321,
0.9875751138,
-0.329454124,
0.0947438106,
-0.3875533938,
0.1513578445,
-0.4882561266,
-0.2775224745,
-0.5745624304,
-0.2146918327,
0.3647427261,
-0.1841197163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08865v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08865v1
|
LLM In-Context Recall is Prompt Dependent
| 2024-04-13T01:13:59 | 2024-04-13T01:13:59 |
Daniel Machlab, Rick Battle
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The proliferation of Large Language Models (LLMs) highlights the critical
importance of conducting thorough evaluations to discern their comparative
advantages, limitations, and optimal use cases. Particularly important is
assessing their capacity to accurately retrieve information included in a given
prompt. A model's ability to do this significantly influences how effectively
it can utilize contextual details, thus impacting its practical efficacy and
dependability in real-world applications.
Our research analyzes the in-context recall performance of various LLMs using
the needle-in-a-haystack method. In this approach, a factoid (the "needle") is
embedded within a block of filler text (the "haystack"), which the model is
asked to retrieve. We assess the recall performance of each model across
various haystack lengths and with varying needle placements to identify
performance patterns. This study demonstrates that an LLM's recall capability
is not only contingent upon the prompt's content but also may be compromised by
biases in its training data. Conversely, adjustments to model architecture,
training strategy, or fine-tuning can improve performance. Our analysis
provides insight into LLM behavior, offering direction for the development of
more effective applications of LLMs.
|
[
-0.076643914,
-0.8025575876,
0.7313440442,
0.0486673415,
-0.1319790483,
-0.2342917174,
-0.0754101127,
-0.5922678113,
0.0999097899,
0.3118239343,
-0.3022820652,
-0.3741262853,
-0.4905418456,
0.4332772791,
-0.5943928361,
0.5522850752,
-0.0090012588,
0.040438436,
-0.4623572826,
0.0518514663,
-1.0371932983,
-0.8348887563,
-0.4192972481,
-0.2071063519,
0.5189906359,
0.5768020153,
0.1636224836,
0.7064928412,
0.369294256,
0.2542251945,
-0.4257663488,
0.0225648191,
-0.6503804326,
0.2624749541,
-0.1769553721,
-0.537935555,
-0.2025592178,
0.031206483,
0.9784318209,
0.5867403746,
-0.2387892753,
-0.049106326,
0.16051884,
0.4485856891,
-0.6985068321,
-0.200602904,
-0.9203598499,
-0.2456852794,
-0.0265456606,
-0.3058544397,
-0.5610214472,
-0.3338027,
0.4252168536,
-0.4767004251,
0.0301249884,
0.0861489177,
0.7734769583,
0.074454017,
-0.4106824994,
-0.5572097301,
-0.5464583039,
0.5667243004,
-0.7315503359,
0.0667644292,
0.5154643059,
0.1398898512,
-0.2992171049,
-0.496819824,
-0.2165309191,
-0.2955662012,
-0.252633214,
-0.1189004853,
0.2332056463,
-0.1372269243,
0.5549296737,
0.2293594629,
-0.1974171549,
0.3156788051,
-0.2245544046,
-0.1319992691,
0.1807236075,
0.605630815,
0.2484440207,
-0.32540676,
-0.4980033338,
0.179977268,
-1.0554924011,
0.2910733819,
-0.1472018808,
0.4511294365,
-0.019536715,
0.4356444776,
-0.1490620375,
0.6901861429,
0.0338318795,
-0.2779922485,
0.0038230997,
-0.3959222734,
-0.111125797,
0.0507029183,
0.4128893316,
0.1573299468,
0.1306023747,
-0.1066424996,
-0.6004292369,
-0.4300194383,
0.4516287744,
-0.7739418745,
0.3220653236,
0.041159343,
-0.3316404521,
0.1239288002,
0.1789946109,
-0.2707680762,
-0.5565215945,
-0.2899032533,
0.6654769778,
-0.5794565082,
0.0534872189,
0.0378425494,
-0.1777760386,
0.1703367084,
0.3256791234,
-0.9030347466,
0.0711853877,
0.8957439065,
1.1139591932,
-0.366410017,
-0.339703083,
-0.7107334733,
0.2625887096,
-0.3324650228,
0.7538899183,
-0.6156606674,
-0.5998936892,
0.332003653,
0.1383164078,
-0.2468383461,
-0.8369396329,
0.3756897449,
-0.4971126914,
0.0080212681,
-0.7887017131,
-1.0379025936,
-0.2803752422,
0.2416734248,
-0.8163421154,
0.9513838291,
-0.0382891037,
-0.686653316,
0.5144806504,
-0.0260405876,
-0.3959704936,
0.0194517374,
-0.2314970493,
-0.2359931767,
0.3481529951,
-0.04321732,
0.6985886097,
-0.2923827469,
0.2727241516,
-0.0578547306,
-1.1385827065,
0.6033909917,
-0.3407032192,
0.5046896338,
-0.2700684369,
0.0307906121,
0.0517633371,
-0.7788863182,
-0.5251927376,
-0.0126566133,
-0.6401794553,
-0.6085269451,
-0.0797622427,
-0.2500855029,
0.1083833054,
0.1656431705,
-0.3750066757,
0.0867114514,
-0.3342466354,
0.2793733478,
0.8144234419,
0.1987979114,
0.3072615266,
-0.5547584891,
0.4997042716,
-0.143989861,
-0.1181774288,
-0.7737181187,
-0.0293393806,
-0.7277315259,
-0.4834487438,
0.1633007824,
0.5140054226,
-0.4918288887,
0.2558320165,
0.0110615678,
-0.2611326873,
-0.0284004789,
0.0168875363,
0.4185228646,
0.7541828156,
0.0024828846,
-0.2761752307,
-0.4571943879,
-0.7906973362,
-0.3659024835,
-0.0506331511,
-0.0300486125,
0.5572769642,
0.3856140971,
-0.1026012003,
0.9153678417,
-0.0681707859,
-0.1753917187,
-0.2499670535,
-0.1961860359,
0.6241261363,
0.1846928,
0.319057405,
-0.3139730096,
-0.273588568,
-0.3420554399,
-0.8608890176,
-0.1078955308,
-0.2902756333,
-0.0204048567,
0.4060786963,
0.6269373298,
-0.5473044515,
0.3363172114,
0.2254661918,
-0.4553938806,
0.7247985005,
-0.3626587689,
0.0261647869,
-0.6452142,
0.4495465755,
-0.2790324688,
-0.0762327909,
-0.6387882829,
-0.2762561142,
0.4642757773,
0.2923574448,
-0.6060586572,
0.7595691681,
-0.4634374082,
-0.1503479332,
-0.1722931117,
0.1433436573,
-0.0417706631,
0.1488839239,
0.0714705586,
1.259427309,
0.4136603475,
-1.0702254772,
-0.1149296463,
0.0642077699,
-0.7397342324,
0.5697099566,
-0.610116601,
0.1878374815,
-0.0017972451,
0.1334522665,
-1.0682297945,
-0.2727997303,
-0.0698016509,
-0.0591958985,
0.3994067311,
0.1454770565,
-0.5559359193,
-0.0545871519,
-0.1902610213,
0.2411192954,
0.3985266089,
-0.6092998981,
0.5820471048,
0.3323446512,
-0.0430278257,
-0.5318321586,
-0.241118595,
-0.0136358896,
-0.5856263638,
-0.1628130376,
0.0660070553,
0.0981666297,
-0.101401709,
-0.5230773687,
-0.1667277068,
0.1991108954,
0.433345437,
0.3112887442,
0.4574064314,
0.1019686162,
0.5419697762,
-0.3658091724,
-0.1495938599,
0.2587345839,
0.0746203065,
0.473778218,
0.0097253025,
-0.1458912939,
-0.4136406481,
0.1853602082,
0.3931828737,
0.1749262065,
0.7353582382,
0.0055660205,
-0.3557669818,
-0.1119017154,
-0.7005854845,
-0.3955047131,
-0.4424378276,
0.4958277643,
-0.4499873221,
-0.9080082178,
0.6218953729,
-0.0339961685,
-0.06080091,
0.0896393433,
0.554291904,
-0.3572376072,
0.5275113583,
0.61310184,
-0.091499649,
0.7513148189,
-0.0260672551,
-0.3000694215,
-1.0435563326,
-0.3412199616,
-0.3604876697,
-0.1373447776,
-0.0166357141,
-0.2056958675,
0.5192012787,
0.1376479864,
-0.2100503743,
0.1487877816,
-0.0704870075,
0.5521756411,
0.5736293793,
0.0027427701,
0.4909139276,
-0.0783475861,
-0.388699621,
0.0484421924,
-0.8620579243,
-0.8384665251,
1.0275019407,
0.384582907,
0.6332902908,
-0.0512570292,
0.47230196,
-0.1154346168,
0.1397090852,
-0.8072696328,
0.6011603475,
0.0304640718,
-0.5805001855,
-0.3168845177,
-0.1346237063,
-1.101947546,
0.2998162508,
-0.1846002936,
-0.7652797699,
-0.0489183962,
0.1955170929,
-0.492511034,
0.0523802303,
-0.6239107251,
0.5279445052,
-0.1746880114,
-0.3834749758,
-0.1672317684,
-0.4238793254,
0.3633087277,
-0.3128938973,
0.0302509572,
-0.1613307446,
-0.2117218971,
0.5754052401,
-0.1514754593,
1.020539999,
0.0708347037,
-0.1925352365,
0.2849601507,
0.248565495,
0.6030864716,
-0.0102323489,
-0.1893711984,
0.2394471169,
0.0806854963,
-0.0834546164,
-0.4959355295,
0.5300136209,
-0.4772516191,
-0.7809303999,
-0.3293909431,
-0.4581488371,
-0.3170394897,
-0.0050414773,
0.1169335172,
0.5758682489,
-0.5042930245,
0.2114970833,
0.8551191688,
-0.445877403,
0.6040101051,
0.7006340623,
-0.2325882018,
0.0086400909,
0.7408897877,
0.2889525294,
0.3661194444,
0.4622170329,
0.2066123337,
-0.164291352,
-0.3925850987,
-0.3291373551,
0.3946663439,
-0.8255913258,
-0.2217695266,
-0.5362051725,
-0.0554031171,
0.1189686134,
-0.0833713636,
-0.1277801245,
-0.2053127289,
-0.6142523289,
0.0101392576,
0.5871289968,
0.9449541569,
0.1759659648,
0.3312970102,
-0.6707441807,
-0.0214087255,
0.3036186099,
0.4998469353,
0.316955626,
-0.7214844823,
-0.4476942122,
-0.2834724188,
-0.0441486351,
-0.7794837356,
0.1107517928,
0.0828693062,
0.7011188269,
0.205180794,
-0.2679775655,
0.5241203904,
-0.5978218913,
0.659455061,
-0.0976347104,
-0.8779301047,
0.4715476036,
-0.3983807862,
0.6259236336,
0.4179409742,
0.2453421354,
-0.8367296457,
-0.2809921205,
-0.3420647681,
-0.9370366335,
0.8580105305,
-0.1103779376,
0.0703032687,
-0.2893351018,
0.6945762634,
0.2650673389,
0.062019825,
-0.2951548696,
0.1229171753,
0.2377791256,
0.039026089,
-0.0033484655,
-0.6391344666,
0.0105762156,
-0.1053583845,
0.4290369749,
0.0008351069,
0.1121100932,
0.1279437095,
-0.3171529472,
0.2949354947,
0.0395611078,
0.5866390467,
0.8965055943,
-0.3544518948,
0.067061305,
0.5021784902,
-0.444896996,
-0.0233172774,
-0.5452225804,
-0.3074334264,
-0.0513363853,
0.6077866554,
0.6572745442,
0.5084400773,
-1.0644518137,
0.5028681159,
-0.0609775335,
0.2965604961,
-0.3325717747,
0.3172638714,
0.1162340716,
0.2173124403,
0.355866313,
-0.430278033,
0.2461184859,
-0.6287862659,
0.1975040138,
0.6009297371,
-0.3191343546,
-0.1534592807,
0.2347321212,
0.096549578,
-0.42892766,
0.6156489253,
0.2337878346,
-0.37114501,
0.7913615108,
0.7139770389,
0.7161873579,
-0.1860866249,
-0.1343457848,
0.612298727,
0.0586833097,
-0.2727976143,
0.1804577708,
0.1667115241,
-0.4529725611,
-0.1835285723,
-0.2391821891,
-0.2285354733,
0.039205499,
-0.6664128304,
0.3063602746,
-0.5519393682,
-0.3037688136,
-0.6053190231,
-0.1535516828,
-0.6975346804,
0.1079440042,
-0.0017598324,
1.0404348373,
-0.5755724907,
0.7874150276,
0.3354610205,
-0.2078609169,
-0.7221811414,
-0.0530932359,
0.1492431462,
-0.9033527374,
0.5083227754,
0.51300776,
-0.236580804,
-0.3194097579,
-0.4358065724,
-1.2094813585,
1.3291319609,
0.1828221977,
-0.719281137,
0.1959508955,
-0.2350660563,
0.4770764112,
-0.5977309346,
0.5230494142,
0.8763250709,
0.0650476143,
0.2307575494,
-1.0645701885,
0.2475762069,
0.1309810877,
0.3993651271,
-0.0464428291,
-0.5884554982,
0.8288679719,
-0.3357408047,
-0.5084661841,
0.2683651149,
0.392714411,
0.7604299784,
0.0523581691,
0.2912756205,
-0.0143336337,
1.0782734156,
0.1755991727,
1.1394467354,
-0.0422835983,
0.0711885318,
1.1334291697,
-0.2788626552,
1.1860135794,
0.6525992155,
0.1604054719,
0.406236887,
0.576187253,
0.2282258272,
0.3962978721,
0.2176112235,
0.0169146862,
-0.216210112,
-0.2206007093,
-0.2104852051,
0.4144489765,
0.5482373238,
-0.5021930337,
0.1155038849,
-0.1043179259,
0.0325863585,
0.0941920131,
-0.2613646984,
0.9414631724,
0.1273031384,
-0.6505895853,
0.8047237396,
-0.2235658914,
0.6444507837,
-0.4711562991,
-0.1442732364,
-0.4098139703,
0.0734779239,
0.1721408367,
-0.5657660961,
0.076771386,
-0.102122806,
-0.3717483282,
-0.0459483825,
0.5495221615,
-0.257039696,
-0.2769524753,
0.3127077818,
0.3989837766,
0.1682538986,
0.0927345976,
-0.3046362102,
0.3732883632,
-0.2996887267,
-0.2508410513,
0.3738279045,
0.4777835906,
-0.1580988318,
0.8878828883,
0.2598400712,
0.1242132485,
-0.0353914201,
0.0098398551,
0.6771051288,
-0.9855030775,
-0.3746530414,
-1.0056481361,
0.346273452,
-0.0166104492,
-0.3948113024,
0.8403056264,
0.5612962246,
0.7296522856,
-0.0196477193,
0.5829443932,
0.3670405149,
0.9249603748,
-0.9286214709,
0.5339028239,
-0.4707579613,
0.6601201892,
-0.2006064057,
-0.7199326754,
-0.1163286716,
0.6792632937,
-0.2393188626,
0.1349542737,
0.8282095194,
0.76696527,
0.2567125857,
-0.0476369746,
0.4036852419,
0.3566743135,
0.1929632276,
0.8610366583,
1.2305880785,
-0.295755893,
0.1622842997,
0.1892646551,
-0.1709770262,
-0.555334866,
-1.0280145407,
-1.086304903,
-0.5328924656,
0.0704692081,
-0.2252223045,
-0.0356506072,
0.8622688651,
0.4651241899,
-0.5185275674,
-0.6608537436,
0.3450608253,
0.3010932803,
-0.0645510703,
-0.131834209,
0.3625901937,
-0.5759310126,
-0.5067639947,
0.3631453812,
0.4352087975,
0.1391882747,
-0.1268655062,
-0.0583027974,
-0.2295456231,
0.2034777254,
0.5988805294,
0.1695587188,
-0.9209937453,
-0.3095249832,
0.1413146555,
-0.3443615735,
0.0610109195,
0.9478347898,
-1.1081879139,
0.5208767056,
0.4019819796,
0.5588877201,
0.2355621755,
0.1346100718,
0.6682367921,
-0.6095674634,
0.0918810517,
0.0239742808,
0.3329042196,
0.3623598814,
-0.3681534231,
0.2484513819,
0.0930628181,
-0.5046642423,
-0.7210224271,
0.0286189299,
-0.5473745465,
-0.5591720939,
1.5619168282,
-0.0125539508,
-0.0969593525,
-0.2089701444,
-0.3559130728,
-0.0625922456,
-0.3769407868,
0.9294084907,
0.9642380476,
0.0023974113,
-0.0548283868,
-0.6545442939,
0.507856369,
0.4079414904,
-0.4711191356,
0.1488519907,
0.6378218532,
0.4372724593,
-0.2435251623,
0.8044047952,
0.140393123,
0.1579353362,
-0.2937631905,
-0.2587381303,
0.0717360973,
-0.5109796524,
-0.7263213992,
0.0938269123,
0.2181507498,
0.055189535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08856v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08856v1
|
On Speculative Decoding for Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-04-13T00:02:36 | 2024-04-13T00:02:36 |
Mukul Gagrani, Raghavv Goel, Wonseok Jeon, Junyoung Park, Mingu Lee, Christopher Lott
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Inference with Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) is slow due to their
large-language-model backbone which suffers from memory bandwidth bottleneck
and generates tokens auto-regressively. In this paper, we explore the
application of speculative decoding to enhance the inference efficiency of
MLLMs, specifically the LLaVA 7B model. We show that a language-only model can
serve as a good draft model for speculative decoding with LLaVA 7B, bypassing
the need for image tokens and their associated processing components from the
draft model. Our experiments across three different tasks show that speculative
decoding can achieve a memory-bound speedup of up to 2.37$\times$ using a 115M
parameter language model that we trained from scratch. Additionally, we
introduce a compact LLaVA draft model incorporating an image adapter, which
shows marginal performance gains in image captioning while maintaining
comparable results in other tasks.
|
[
-0.1725218296,
-0.6169975996,
0.6659001112,
0.3544896841,
-0.5313061476,
0.2056154013,
-0.1637837142,
-0.6855527759,
0.3963467479,
0.7091255784,
-0.3256375194,
-0.0964580774,
-0.474337399,
0.0202186573,
-0.3455364704,
0.3959702551,
0.0518760458,
-0.040664617,
-0.1513326615,
0.1922422498,
-0.198817715,
-0.5243518949,
-0.5400384068,
0.2709745765,
0.6513378024,
0.1317930818,
0.540186584,
0.6301445961,
0.3407150805,
0.3303823769,
-0.0663124174,
0.5166525245,
-0.6904129982,
0.3734368682,
0.0347024612,
-0.8419926167,
-0.3391485512,
-0.382956624,
0.8507744074,
0.2615974844,
0.0759455413,
0.0730755851,
-0.5226964951,
0.5554000139,
-0.9809634089,
0.3925478458,
-0.8396803141,
-0.2381081134,
-0.4424135685,
-0.4379295409,
-0.980465889,
0.0148053635,
-0.372271955,
-0.6940760612,
0.2516696155,
0.6789585352,
0.7073003054,
0.1278049946,
-0.2954500914,
-0.0200799685,
-0.6339431405,
0.7798268795,
-0.8466548324,
0.5738898516,
0.4380955398,
0.3813127279,
-0.277846843,
-0.7158041596,
-0.8751224279,
-0.2483645082,
0.0488467216,
0.0264067706,
-0.062845163,
0.2048134506,
0.38059479,
0.1331085712,
-0.3238390088,
0.0521691032,
-0.5134937763,
-0.548894763,
0.5073408484,
0.3242067695,
-0.0558183379,
-0.2094844878,
-0.2193762511,
-0.0885285884,
-0.5696671605,
0.0064946208,
0.4959818125,
0.0644757822,
-0.0559942946,
0.5785989761,
-0.216385901,
0.6974733472,
0.0015805913,
-0.5187945366,
0.2443620414,
-0.1634870917,
-0.1076729,
-0.2195732445,
0.4245858192,
0.6327083707,
-0.1092882156,
-0.3762358129,
-0.2457897961,
0.556507051,
0.0981710106,
-0.8328137994,
-0.2424398363,
0.2549116015,
-0.7573280931,
-0.0556849875,
-0.4205441177,
-0.6978903413,
-0.4904676378,
0.0183611959,
-0.0386259966,
-0.5237470269,
-0.3402220011,
0.3742471635,
-0.3795228899,
0.2661955357,
0.6070679426,
-0.9742072821,
-0.0643497854,
0.233611688,
0.6500127316,
-0.1742086262,
-0.3630174398,
-0.5246919394,
0.3434522152,
-0.5727958083,
1.3467466831,
-0.8111943007,
-0.287214309,
-0.2233326435,
-0.0992948189,
-0.1969438791,
-0.0795434713,
0.6576559544,
-0.9849292636,
-0.41715312,
-0.2520670295,
-0.6252679825,
-0.1518887728,
0.2192620784,
-0.9015365243,
0.506590426,
-0.2964577079,
-0.8683921695,
0.5143765807,
-0.2915333807,
-0.1999627352,
-0.09421058,
-0.0218979008,
0.0491965897,
0.3094245195,
0.5769524574,
0.5505509377,
-0.3483954072,
0.2039033473,
-0.60044837,
-0.7730615735,
0.3270200789,
-0.8869869709,
0.2253405303,
0.5884846449,
0.1983523518,
0.0113062738,
-0.5928888321,
-0.0854637399,
0.0127404369,
-0.4679175019,
-0.2443936169,
-0.0452015884,
0.2345105112,
-0.1351768821,
0.0106724286,
-0.4896357656,
0.421182394,
-0.2882902622,
0.1513879448,
0.6436257362,
-0.142125845,
0.400821954,
-0.2733106911,
0.5253783464,
0.2085704803,
0.0813487396,
-0.633800745,
-0.4057224393,
-0.9105828404,
-0.585259378,
0.3626250029,
0.2429812998,
-1.4337587357,
-0.3756052256,
-0.2615870237,
-0.3665933013,
-0.8093669415,
0.0206707362,
0.289082408,
0.1802669615,
0.1255108416,
0.0195390843,
-0.6288266182,
-1.0246111155,
-0.3029498756,
-0.1672077924,
0.3577256203,
0.245817706,
0.0844555199,
-0.1740349382,
0.3246316612,
-0.3330039084,
0.3066074252,
-0.5358638763,
-0.0693208277,
0.2884310484,
0.3423479199,
0.76926893,
-0.6886406541,
-0.2487534732,
-0.2297770381,
-0.7095449567,
0.2471208423,
-0.2536760867,
-0.3207378387,
0.4869198501,
0.6731843948,
-0.9600322843,
0.3320937157,
0.6600030065,
-0.3775990903,
0.6479516029,
-0.2889475524,
0.4567601085,
-0.932534039,
-0.0302189663,
-0.3349324763,
-0.139041692,
-0.581880033,
0.3439202309,
0.3270095289,
0.2070555836,
-0.6204730868,
0.6601402164,
-0.7671967149,
0.0902827829,
-0.4324592948,
-0.1780163199,
0.1959366649,
0.3172976077,
0.2218366712,
0.883913815,
0.7628697157,
-0.3824210763,
0.1327636838,
-0.2225307524,
-0.4176962376,
-0.0901620686,
-0.230610162,
0.1617078185,
-0.5124365091,
0.5247476101,
-0.9202222824,
-0.4008429646,
0.1114045903,
-0.0769762248,
0.4290274084,
-0.2528552711,
-0.6952067614,
-0.4913513958,
-0.3143907487,
0.7158960104,
0.4653149545,
-0.4428442419,
0.9107604027,
0.201694712,
0.2721838355,
-0.8821677566,
-0.7251890302,
0.2665073872,
-0.0464367531,
-0.5716579556,
0.0724403113,
-0.0626213998,
-0.0803169012,
-0.0533783585,
0.1631760001,
-0.0025540881,
-0.1418160945,
0.2331796139,
0.4060764611,
-0.347809881,
0.1011692435,
0.2924799025,
-0.0476813093,
-0.084274292,
-0.3215483129,
0.4950399101,
-0.2453365326,
-0.3298259676,
-0.3232871294,
0.4480931163,
0.7860171795,
0.0735728294,
0.7356745601,
0.5945833921,
-0.055133231,
-0.1266875565,
-1.1474192142,
-0.0761713013,
-0.4954074025,
0.301176995,
-0.6430844069,
-0.818698287,
0.6671863794,
-0.1171195209,
-0.0537948646,
0.4092310667,
0.6260301471,
0.0264667645,
0.5671214461,
0.6310638785,
0.0421623103,
0.2799613476,
-0.2510500848,
0.0294407029,
-0.6471309066,
-0.2713015378,
-0.123770237,
-0.1705647707,
-0.3032799661,
-1.0560992956,
-0.0572173558,
0.0951676816,
0.2889883816,
-0.0552192517,
-0.0003354257,
0.7136785388,
0.4566465616,
0.2580532134,
0.3852478564,
0.2186257988,
-0.247877866,
-0.0287067052,
-0.9743972421,
-0.2854409218,
1.1547677517,
0.2674458921,
1.234172225,
0.0833266377,
0.3738388121,
0.270855993,
0.4328329563,
-0.5476731658,
0.4876112938,
-0.2349255532,
-0.7281616926,
0.046262484,
-0.1705467254,
-0.7192720771,
0.5314544439,
-0.3942323625,
-0.6629744768,
0.4512594342,
0.5903601646,
-0.2483093739,
0.6599710584,
-1.0093755722,
0.4161664844,
0.0268308558,
-0.5784267187,
-0.3813301623,
-0.3759063184,
0.8571861982,
-0.03339779,
0.1982166618,
-0.1276900768,
0.0334431343,
0.5308326483,
0.0589601658,
0.996522069,
-0.2168715745,
0.025107678,
0.4474492669,
0.2330971658,
0.6377037168,
0.1223998889,
-0.3955155313,
0.0895602927,
0.1353926212,
-0.6621569395,
-0.6770771742,
0.6249830127,
-0.6376799941,
-0.7333075404,
-0.1422950476,
-1.0010368824,
-0.3208352625,
0.0485278703,
0.1642991006,
0.4071024358,
0.2305564433,
0.0004541336,
0.5387641191,
-0.1883280873,
0.6139340997,
0.3662284315,
-0.3022079766,
-0.1427190006,
0.9678380489,
-0.1921494752,
0.3710891008,
0.5041528344,
-0.1029363051,
-0.5103079081,
-0.8041170239,
-0.6499618888,
0.2903203666,
-0.962331593,
-0.2359075695,
-0.8650570512,
0.0548040867,
-0.3176255226,
-0.1582115889,
-0.4210550785,
-0.5322034359,
-0.1387804598,
-0.0097115673,
0.541665256,
0.5491578579,
0.144580543,
0.3247302473,
-0.8591857553,
0.3970022798,
-0.1946236491,
0.2107564211,
0.435264498,
-0.6618126035,
-0.274094224,
-0.1724175513,
0.1557005495,
-0.5649724603,
0.5081995726,
0.0295353029,
0.6688606143,
0.5532391667,
0.0884034038,
0.9452379942,
-0.4721981883,
0.621956408,
0.2028115094,
-0.6639169455,
0.0371947326,
-0.3342188597,
0.3682782054,
0.3048277497,
0.1282609105,
-0.1241210327,
-0.5341546535,
-0.2265421748,
-0.7780745029,
0.4495511651,
0.0563659482,
0.3722270429,
-0.1613702327,
0.3850078583,
0.3402474225,
0.1692063212,
-0.6213703752,
-0.1490783691,
-0.2222552896,
0.1830945164,
-0.1169038117,
-0.7889770865,
0.1320783347,
-0.2255544811,
0.2446038127,
-0.2831397951,
0.4499190152,
0.1001884043,
-0.1977450848,
0.0140486863,
0.3528401852,
0.7374617457,
0.3986415565,
-0.2090650648,
0.3364762068,
0.1508597285,
-0.4771821201,
0.1387347579,
-0.037405137,
-0.0414724238,
-0.0279903598,
0.6819337606,
1.1463499069,
0.1719359607,
-0.8559458256,
0.170274958,
-0.3370435238,
-0.2147278935,
0.0825063139,
0.0018281147,
0.3079492152,
0.5181664824,
0.3898431659,
0.418104142,
0.3011524975,
-0.4003722966,
0.0418187492,
0.3048130572,
0.3125805557,
-0.2148410231,
0.6943634748,
0.0869327784,
0.3182947636,
0.4784478545,
-0.2267507315,
-0.111791864,
0.4937214553,
0.9102609754,
0.5011433363,
0.200992167,
-0.0269605033,
0.1407051533,
0.3692270815,
-0.1212770268,
0.5529175401,
0.0311588068,
-0.7224733233,
-0.9125518799,
-0.9085945487,
-0.200247854,
-0.1575414091,
-0.3421902359,
-0.1131969541,
-0.433322072,
-0.2273520231,
-0.1623792648,
-0.4956714511,
-0.7387140393,
-0.0674599633,
0.3332336545,
1.0957559347,
-0.4855804741,
1.0869133472,
0.4429737926,
0.0145727536,
-0.9342816472,
-0.0688708499,
-0.2919232845,
-0.7970534563,
0.8579770923,
0.1159953102,
-0.3486673832,
-0.2198724896,
-0.343354404,
-1.1746537685,
0.918489635,
0.7321568131,
-0.8265939355,
-0.1411508024,
-0.2990023792,
0.4500105977,
-0.4572090507,
0.4262346625,
0.2979548872,
0.4229998887,
0.3984950483,
-0.6927983165,
0.2263931185,
-0.4614595771,
0.1750133783,
-0.1587561369,
-0.7239085436,
0.9828773141,
-0.6505428553,
-0.1539916098,
0.2519962192,
0.8935358524,
0.3644171655,
0.1993581504,
0.4413054883,
0.3214602768,
0.6774194837,
0.3188141584,
1.4484928846,
-0.4285516143,
0.024184335,
0.7322548628,
-0.2033479959,
1.0466582775,
0.6893658638,
0.0183525607,
0.393089205,
0.5321205854,
0.1675664485,
0.5773025751,
-0.0242359545,
-0.2652576268,
-0.6599028111,
-0.0964808539,
-0.3210009336,
0.3720343709,
0.6501774788,
-0.4202948213,
-0.1540471315,
0.1510150433,
-0.2214746922,
-0.1387528628,
-0.4042557776,
0.264768213,
0.1029445454,
-0.5269075036,
0.8883071542,
0.089365229,
0.7926322818,
-0.5214536786,
0.0013976109,
-0.1293621808,
0.1443751454,
0.1347059757,
-0.5419498086,
0.1750428677,
-0.2666952908,
-0.3325603604,
-0.0079265796,
0.8508693576,
-0.3221696317,
-0.8460508585,
0.2289136648,
0.4755338728,
0.2230612189,
0.0433615334,
-0.4000468552,
0.6440051198,
-0.0858417377,
-0.2645801902,
0.1959354877,
0.4492419362,
-0.189814657,
0.9775801301,
1.011915803,
0.0665182993,
0.2262343913,
0.130854398,
1.2639322281,
-0.6864122748,
-0.5365012884,
-0.8212544918,
0.3841800392,
0.1265228838,
0.0409894474,
0.7389163375,
0.375028342,
0.4180725813,
-0.5578445196,
0.736137569,
0.1004372388,
0.0254757348,
-1.1110391617,
0.6607112288,
-0.4348908365,
0.3786108792,
-0.1011146829,
-0.5449592471,
-0.2016198784,
0.1361011267,
-0.252502352,
-0.2071885467,
0.7374922633,
0.9755970836,
-0.0583938994,
-0.1423399448,
0.7280853987,
0.4317748547,
0.1933936626,
0.4308028221,
0.9971524477,
-0.2645498812,
0.4539686441,
-0.1886691898,
0.063095428,
-0.2675995827,
-0.917748332,
-1.2715587616,
-0.3204404414,
0.2614219189,
-0.3960527778,
0.3318292499,
0.6083464622,
0.7488040328,
-0.512996912,
-0.1265941262,
0.3581525087,
-0.0439753346,
-0.041662734,
-0.198714301,
0.3729613423,
-0.3462966979,
-0.594478786,
0.5141214132,
0.2715193331,
0.0961999819,
-0.2917284369,
0.0564227849,
-0.1828782111,
0.294727236,
0.8637084961,
0.0691654757,
-1.1721919775,
0.0301131774,
0.1449006349,
0.149287641,
-0.2212562114,
1.0018024445,
-0.8812416196,
0.5026792288,
0.3387161791,
0.6741840839,
0.8158220053,
-0.0417893343,
0.5896685123,
-0.2643177509,
0.8703248501,
0.0778359696,
0.605553925,
0.1621648371,
-0.5556886792,
-0.1549270302,
0.3347944319,
-0.1686926484,
-0.7721950412,
0.0717645735,
-1.1084573269,
-0.4849574566,
1.1639196873,
-0.1246078685,
-0.6548554897,
-0.0908523053,
-0.4134407341,
-0.2767954767,
-0.7113768458,
0.696378231,
0.484057337,
-0.0934443399,
-0.6194502115,
-0.5167655349,
0.3483462632,
0.2155596912,
-0.5440458655,
0.1737051904,
0.5791273713,
0.0016800978,
0.0541836098,
0.831749022,
0.1312064081,
0.4057326615,
0.7560552955,
-0.0569485836,
-0.223860532,
-0.3576048911,
0.2274641097,
0.2436702996,
0.3243954182,
0.2044004053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08846v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08846v2
|
Experimental Design for Active Transductive Inference in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-12T23:27:46 | 2024-05-31T02:37:10 |
Subhojyoti Mukherjee, Anusha Lalitha, Aniket Deshmukh, Ge Liu, Yifei Ma, Branislav Kveton
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
One emergent ability of large language models (LLMs) is that query-specific
examples can be included in the prompt at inference time. In this work, we use
active learning for adaptive prompt design and call it Active In-context Prompt
Design (AIPD). We design the LLM prompt by adaptively choosing few-shot
examples from a training set to optimize performance on a test set. The
training examples are initially unlabeled and we obtain the label of the most
informative ones, which maximally reduces uncertainty in the LLM prediction. We
propose two algorithms, GO and SAL, which differ in how the few-shot examples
are chosen. We analyze these algorithms in linear models: first GO and then use
its equivalence with SAL. We experiment with many different tasks in small,
medium-sized, and large language models; and show that GO and SAL outperform
other methods for choosing few-shot examples in the LLM prompt at inference
time.
|
[
0.0349419639,
-1.1247160435,
0.716978848,
0.3518352807,
-0.2932211757,
-0.1924068034,
-0.3354270458,
-0.3329977691,
-0.1490055621,
0.0928846151,
-0.5882645249,
-0.2350265235,
-0.1762008965,
0.1135038435,
-0.1556693465,
0.5479230285,
-0.1823385954,
0.0403160974,
0.2589336932,
-0.2273202688,
-0.431504488,
0.0462749898,
-1.1061016321,
0.0791943297,
0.4950416982,
0.356800884,
0.6062496901,
0.5128272772,
0.103320241,
0.2484470457,
-0.3053766191,
0.2667143345,
-0.067810595,
0.4189734459,
-0.2251806706,
-0.6195055246,
-0.1616254002,
0.0223600511,
0.8261017203,
0.8492587805,
0.1147228628,
-0.066336371,
-0.0905395001,
0.0251036286,
-0.6904431581,
-0.0167314727,
-0.5850530267,
0.091997534,
0.2050356567,
-0.0238001216,
-0.7159372568,
-0.3668714166,
0.1021004245,
-0.5289726853,
0.097127974,
0.3327325881,
0.4137664735,
0.238553673,
-0.3115122914,
-0.2985855043,
-0.8558638096,
0.8497871161,
-0.8759101033,
0.3327693939,
0.2887397408,
0.2726570666,
-0.3442238867,
-0.7872538567,
-0.4892605543,
-0.2967313528,
-0.0448390506,
0.0934554711,
-0.3459630907,
0.0417843163,
0.3642298877,
-0.1168038175,
-0.60778898,
0.4175544381,
-0.1755238622,
-0.0763716847,
0.4551497102,
0.012595553,
0.1644072384,
0.0131375436,
-0.2470924109,
0.0163401943,
-0.8085561395,
0.2664097548,
0.0307320002,
0.5586506724,
-0.0894031227,
0.5113751888,
-0.0036749421,
1.0863375664,
0.2014458776,
0.045182582,
0.0905470476,
-0.3189877272,
-0.2859844863,
-0.0528229438,
0.8777101636,
-0.177250579,
0.1665458083,
-0.105462715,
-0.3807716072,
-0.3281902373,
0.0861147866,
-0.4658082426,
-0.051940728,
0.2275742739,
-0.3403620422,
-0.0165760536,
-0.2631895542,
-0.55788064,
-0.293982923,
-0.151553899,
0.6447714567,
-0.3926315308,
-0.0326817967,
-0.1540693194,
-0.0481301881,
0.2273727953,
0.4903508127,
-0.7720480561,
0.1834174842,
0.3462219834,
0.8926786184,
-0.525246799,
-0.3522382975,
-1.0703245401,
0.1863460988,
-0.5185030699,
0.9101670384,
-0.9096787572,
-0.3923934698,
0.0083160447,
0.1415242851,
-0.1011116281,
-0.3566676974,
0.64306885,
-0.6680545211,
0.4284386635,
-0.0855006874,
-0.4673700929,
-0.1895510107,
0.0322305709,
-0.609413743,
1.0320103168,
0.1473414898,
-0.5561518669,
0.4432983398,
-0.8665810823,
-0.3645267189,
0.0743222833,
-0.1586539447,
-0.3939158022,
0.4078655541,
0.2358547747,
0.3692194223,
-0.0649208352,
0.0224237759,
-0.3641827404,
-0.4595252275,
0.4343479276,
-0.4657019377,
0.9629075527,
0.2221248299,
-0.4328267574,
0.4228393137,
-0.664023459,
0.1689458489,
0.0937154591,
-0.4203572571,
-0.5647582412,
0.0483054928,
-0.3523875475,
-0.0423312336,
-0.233031556,
-0.2935488224,
0.4027714431,
-0.4056966007,
0.2347579151,
0.9630317688,
0.319462955,
0.6809142828,
-0.0832519084,
0.719174087,
-0.0640490651,
0.0847181007,
-0.1454860419,
-0.4796254635,
-0.8169665337,
-0.4641119838,
0.5504626632,
0.5009264946,
-0.791330874,
0.2303224206,
0.1487236023,
-0.2392398119,
-0.4311327338,
0.0321519263,
0.1845862567,
0.4172032475,
0.2053937018,
0.1187874824,
-0.3088378608,
-0.785071075,
-0.3949759305,
-0.5411768556,
-0.2196957171,
0.3869836032,
0.2934313715,
0.1551706046,
0.9051049948,
-0.444452107,
0.4765351415,
-0.3779230416,
0.2471465468,
0.4065158367,
0.2176447511,
0.6903486848,
-0.609265089,
-0.5397539735,
-0.4697245657,
-0.4397832155,
-0.4690041244,
-0.2739674449,
-0.3083601892,
-0.0054239957,
0.4123800695,
-0.4803348184,
0.3260782957,
0.1770959496,
-0.6077369452,
0.3297978044,
-0.0821123496,
-0.0669908151,
-0.8792852759,
-0.2133814394,
-0.0618486106,
-0.2805948257,
-0.7475041151,
0.0980500057,
0.2766817212,
-0.2343415916,
-0.645940125,
1.1936962605,
-0.729498744,
-0.1540512592,
-0.4332498014,
-0.1116559356,
-0.0763286725,
0.5475363135,
0.2663466036,
0.9528141618,
0.7212589979,
-1.0922626257,
0.3939017653,
0.1067373231,
-0.57495749,
0.1384246796,
-0.7954612374,
0.2293581367,
-0.2703867853,
0.2870856524,
-1.4575793743,
-0.1082797498,
0.3438442945,
-0.2130096406,
0.3563450873,
0.016129382,
-0.2685075998,
-0.3036924303,
-0.2283533514,
0.4234710932,
0.5720261931,
-0.7548286915,
0.6744534969,
0.0266930666,
-0.435169667,
-0.4003432691,
-0.6513447762,
-0.1447807401,
-0.3275294006,
-0.3000835478,
0.0916354656,
-0.316806823,
-0.4520552456,
-0.1222445965,
0.0726918653,
-0.0486850105,
0.3642877042,
0.0679737553,
0.1980788559,
-0.1682732403,
0.3663499355,
0.1596263796,
0.0925196707,
-0.0941545442,
-0.1581871063,
0.3848082125,
0.1924405992,
-0.5302157998,
-0.3501525223,
0.4307117164,
0.3450355232,
-0.1363495886,
0.537165761,
0.2742423415,
-0.3733282983,
-0.8199588656,
-0.2889495194,
-0.2359138578,
-0.4435899556,
0.1548948437,
-0.4316078722,
-0.5312043428,
0.4219908416,
-0.0631463453,
0.6598202586,
0.0417580344,
0.7314344645,
0.0719751045,
0.9095097184,
0.4994469285,
0.2102078646,
0.9166260958,
-0.0990668908,
0.0718977079,
-0.6646049023,
0.1103172675,
-0.5785832405,
-0.4120905399,
-0.0887102187,
-0.6075754762,
0.5198607445,
0.030945573,
-0.2534021437,
0.0776284412,
-0.1857663244,
0.2993017137,
0.7083359957,
0.1701779813,
0.2635499835,
0.0758742914,
-0.3790780604,
0.1743461341,
-0.862701416,
-0.2946510613,
0.8666579723,
0.2838894129,
1.1012957096,
0.4300861955,
0.2470775098,
0.2606877089,
0.2753208578,
-0.9957016706,
0.6137827039,
0.1779451966,
-0.7175387144,
-0.3801162243,
-0.1617918313,
-0.9648874402,
0.1664346457,
0.0080888998,
-0.5213027596,
0.3930398524,
0.1847873777,
-0.6100106835,
-0.0051884763,
-0.8450933695,
0.4855142832,
-0.3196382821,
-0.6822593212,
0.1274401844,
-0.4604442716,
0.3161590695,
-0.1223987564,
-0.0030277262,
0.13460581,
-0.3927237689,
0.6772015691,
-0.1174761355,
0.9466762543,
-0.3517701328,
-0.0928622261,
0.5744497776,
0.2098033577,
0.824246645,
0.1357119977,
-0.5985198617,
-0.5615984201,
-0.6590710878,
-0.4049332142,
-0.6499499083,
0.4253056645,
-0.6059730649,
-0.6734591722,
-0.2497581542,
-0.5427546501,
-0.4635782242,
0.0474040583,
0.1160144731,
0.4798626602,
-0.1195043847,
-0.0102220364,
0.7165645957,
-0.3000889719,
1.0053220987,
0.9380817413,
-0.0059436238,
-0.0363457948,
0.3484160006,
-0.0391897336,
0.4842405319,
0.3469846547,
0.3561026156,
-0.4852761328,
-0.7709697485,
-0.6179582477,
0.2415736616,
-0.7799276114,
-0.129021436,
-0.6360836625,
-0.0613317564,
-0.4471413791,
-0.1344057918,
-0.1252534986,
-0.4080654979,
-0.3867028058,
-0.1152243987,
0.4130121768,
0.2624107897,
0.0195789356,
0.3767417371,
-0.5039822459,
0.4077560604,
0.6010531187,
0.1569568515,
0.0219314229,
-0.9763903022,
0.1242652535,
-0.0854681358,
-0.0436234102,
-0.8685210943,
0.2019473612,
0.3783519566,
0.9248918295,
0.5993751884,
0.264226824,
0.3905400038,
-0.5723523498,
0.8601194024,
-0.0987940133,
-0.6079896092,
0.7244381309,
-0.1493590921,
0.5248407125,
0.5837827325,
0.5383673906,
-0.3549837172,
-0.3034572601,
-0.4301576316,
-0.4345908463,
0.7012653351,
0.0043303431,
0.0884041116,
-0.0918209627,
0.3529553115,
0.4033754766,
-0.110930495,
-0.8562958837,
-0.0911982954,
0.2229381949,
-0.1904454529,
0.1626392752,
-0.3483991623,
-0.2387054265,
-0.0863309801,
0.8131853938,
-0.4139229357,
0.4876304269,
0.0505965948,
-0.1315594912,
-0.2093982399,
0.3212291002,
0.4946319461,
0.9194165468,
-0.0675726458,
0.346955359,
0.3553667068,
-0.213347137,
0.4574008584,
-0.0215416662,
-0.5217411518,
0.2519263327,
0.5987747312,
1.2821390629,
0.0449263938,
-0.6649233699,
0.427701205,
-0.2700505853,
-0.0164237525,
-0.166900903,
0.4749473035,
-0.0370009392,
0.4575094283,
0.4920558333,
-0.420912236,
-0.0022901299,
-0.808390975,
-0.0143681187,
0.6101928353,
-0.293607682,
-0.3233752251,
0.7450645566,
0.2014804482,
-0.6444227099,
0.4345463514,
-0.331994921,
-0.321769774,
0.4303050339,
0.7823818326,
0.8624216914,
-0.4843755662,
0.1983030438,
0.2449082136,
0.0051022209,
-0.1577737927,
0.4420711994,
-0.0209022015,
-0.6595010757,
-0.538151145,
-0.5466963649,
-0.5210553408,
0.2863974571,
-0.2144905329,
0.5154588819,
-0.3983027339,
0.0680030361,
-0.0008817386,
-0.0289906953,
-0.3288089037,
0.1771483868,
0.0859190151,
1.0695568323,
-0.9933521152,
0.6585968733,
0.9554921985,
0.0328805186,
-0.6788123846,
0.1008888707,
-0.1364667416,
-0.9523745179,
0.5404312611,
-0.2758535445,
0.2502446473,
0.0121859647,
-0.7308043242,
-0.7804836035,
0.8695979714,
0.2030588984,
-0.4492307603,
-0.2033199668,
-0.3729322553,
0.1829325408,
-0.3619002998,
0.4935001433,
0.377500385,
0.4786081314,
0.3562562168,
-0.6376730204,
0.1072553098,
-0.0840074793,
-0.0967793763,
0.1760509014,
-0.7009549737,
0.8210823536,
-0.35712412,
-0.2281880528,
0.0844125897,
0.8411498666,
0.7051872015,
0.2367890477,
1.0039203167,
0.1185873523,
0.7273234725,
0.1080482751,
0.9048140049,
-0.0029838406,
-0.0582255125,
1.1782953739,
-0.2007207423,
0.5490496755,
0.5073621273,
-0.2721503079,
0.1782480329,
1.0184502602,
0.0835764483,
0.7691969872,
0.1659710109,
-0.6079075336,
-0.2237581015,
-0.0849851295,
-0.119095467,
0.3800976872,
0.3031698465,
-0.4641501009,
-0.2765719295,
0.183848232,
0.0219819732,
-0.3686386049,
-0.3803810775,
0.7718900442,
-0.0594463907,
-1.0202343464,
0.5972490311,
0.109240517,
0.4264730215,
-0.7108963728,
-0.0395257771,
-0.4748206735,
0.0189179592,
0.174836129,
-0.6200425029,
-0.1313792914,
0.011307775,
-0.0058512236,
-0.2402333617,
0.7609520555,
-0.3934959173,
-0.6874135137,
0.0082356781,
0.6588130593,
0.2611455023,
0.2100992799,
-0.7449324131,
-0.0365965627,
0.0611760169,
-0.7308155894,
0.0864804536,
0.6763911843,
-0.3416371942,
0.631855309,
0.42200315,
0.3464260697,
0.3102477789,
0.0767645463,
0.9274657965,
-0.6738190055,
-0.557112515,
-0.8394799829,
0.4259227514,
0.062597096,
-0.2516590357,
0.5593014359,
0.4299094379,
0.2710656524,
-0.0326789878,
0.8723654151,
-0.0363411494,
0.6427509785,
-0.7980601192,
0.0869328454,
-0.5686171055,
0.3572006822,
-0.0630106702,
-1.0856711864,
-0.14567554,
0.6939105988,
-0.1414675862,
0.0522055887,
0.8277395368,
0.7756015062,
-0.3204125762,
-0.1324469298,
0.0946584195,
0.316542238,
0.4880268276,
0.6579502225,
0.8429898024,
-0.1047865376,
0.4063840806,
-0.1293144971,
-0.3485254347,
-0.2264391929,
-1.0315662622,
-0.9895190001,
-0.3983810544,
-0.2112205178,
-0.2313385904,
0.0004029455,
0.9151747823,
0.5914870501,
-0.7001433969,
-0.0199806206,
-0.0746896639,
0.3358930647,
-0.2670818865,
-0.1861235052,
0.4833317697,
-0.4389610589,
-1.0768208504,
0.8310114145,
0.0496750586,
0.2636527419,
-0.2058153898,
0.1186523959,
-0.5553161502,
0.1166669577,
0.4367719889,
0.3332989514,
-0.4808286726,
-0.4655879736,
0.0835642517,
0.028867485,
-0.1458587497,
0.9154381156,
-0.930927515,
0.3340437412,
0.7100480199,
0.7397358418,
0.352058351,
0.2015764862,
0.7322502136,
-0.6864314079,
0.4703040123,
0.3622508943,
0.3580873907,
0.0012652088,
-0.1495284289,
0.7419563532,
0.1509295404,
-0.3133617342,
-1.0317659378,
0.2800693214,
-0.9164125919,
-0.6931070685,
1.6027296782,
-0.307517767,
-0.4182231724,
-0.1337105185,
-0.1077796966,
0.2494270056,
-0.3689114451,
0.5367142558,
0.6536881328,
-0.4288247228,
-0.3092190623,
-0.6374144554,
0.3592647314,
0.4710028172,
-0.7874474525,
0.2243891507,
0.490860045,
0.1610043198,
-0.0670442507,
0.5805539489,
0.3459035158,
0.3255919814,
-0.2314537168,
-0.3174346685,
-0.0827835053,
-0.4165783226,
-0.4725388587,
0.2486162484,
0.2835109532,
-0.2362535596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08836v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08836v1
|
BERT-LSH: Reducing Absolute Compute For Attention
| 2024-04-12T22:35:00 | 2024-04-12T22:35:00 |
Zezheng Li, Kingston Yip
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This study introduces a novel BERT-LSH model that incorporates Locality
Sensitive Hashing (LSH) to approximate the attention mechanism in the BERT
architecture. We examine the computational efficiency and performance of this
model compared to a standard baseline BERT model. Our findings reveal that
BERT-LSH significantly reduces computational demand for the self-attention
layer while unexpectedly outperforming the baseline model in pretraining and
fine-tuning tasks. These results suggest that the LSH-based attention mechanism
not only offers computational advantages but also may enhance the model's
ability to generalize from its training data. For more information, visit our
GitHub repository: https://github.com/leo4life2/algoml-final
|
[
-0.4193285108,
-1.0023735762,
0.7689352036,
-0.2574599981,
-0.1026248261,
-0.3692900836,
-0.1614133567,
-0.8127223849,
0.1451477706,
0.411793083,
-0.8820393085,
-0.3476355672,
-0.1492343247,
-0.3164116144,
-0.5868466496,
0.9699983001,
0.111600697,
-0.144719094,
-0.1689397544,
0.2174405009,
0.0524168126,
-0.4942086339,
-0.644982636,
-0.2525230646,
0.8788970113,
0.2886661291,
0.614349246,
0.8135496378,
1.1091195345,
0.1927371323,
0.0754878521,
-0.3066049218,
-0.7836294174,
0.1162126362,
-0.0011922533,
-0.3477468491,
-0.6331429482,
-0.3253701329,
0.8559542894,
0.6241859198,
-0.0824260861,
0.5451248288,
-0.1632873565,
0.9996797442,
-1.0578255653,
-0.0270825494,
-0.8027075529,
0.1125170887,
-0.3130535483,
0.1236168519,
-0.3821455836,
-0.1478322297,
0.2569556832,
-0.665497601,
0.6515920758,
-0.0592728667,
0.8764752746,
0.6865450144,
0.0989060923,
0.1052888855,
-0.3897259533,
0.8552007675,
-0.7569066286,
0.368090421,
0.6341140866,
0.0149354478,
0.2428327501,
-0.9049386978,
-0.2989188433,
-0.057565365,
0.0410975665,
0.1687808782,
-0.0370979793,
0.4989542961,
0.299808681,
0.5529285073,
-0.2567496002,
0.0204707086,
-0.2807077467,
-0.1847400218,
0.21448192,
0.1312106401,
-0.0316350274,
-0.2149563581,
-0.3559230864,
0.1226500794,
-0.8979789615,
0.1538038552,
0.1192178875,
0.5232698917,
-0.0004410243,
0.1968062818,
-0.158965081,
0.8227459788,
0.3329596519,
0.3404219151,
0.0019500373,
-0.0609418601,
-0.4848654568,
0.1395554841,
0.4087366164,
0.2306965739,
-0.1008852944,
-0.0503666848,
-0.0993716642,
-0.1529280096,
0.7832126617,
-0.9136663079,
-0.3792485297,
0.5312911868,
-0.7953894138,
-0.5195984244,
-0.2224999815,
-0.2437987626,
-0.0216748249,
-0.1367116421,
0.6598976254,
-0.5130941868,
0.1970329583,
-0.3348869085,
0.2355999202,
0.4036516845,
0.2706865966,
-1.1480264664,
0.39031142,
0.6944856644,
0.8736203313,
-0.2278009057,
-0.1962949485,
-0.4395755827,
0.3605092764,
-0.3643101752,
0.5455792546,
-0.1181312948,
-0.182664454,
-0.1037139222,
-0.2775167525,
0.2229867578,
-0.542331636,
0.6390657425,
-0.6576460004,
-0.1006945372,
-0.8359851837,
-0.646751523,
-0.1553986222,
0.1808064133,
-0.9797992706,
1.0094614029,
0.2347318381,
-0.834262073,
0.0867475346,
-1.1129939556,
-0.4736370444,
0.2033886909,
0.0803425163,
-0.5375833511,
0.285823971,
0.1505482048,
0.449578166,
-0.0825374126,
-0.1044527888,
-0.4926595688,
-0.8474799395,
-0.0926115215,
-0.0513187461,
0.6813317537,
0.4739921987,
-0.4505860209,
0.4318007529,
-0.4400275946,
0.4809860289,
0.1260592341,
-0.1688390821,
-0.2701719403,
0.0718330815,
0.1725177914,
-0.1378538609,
0.6540407538,
-0.4052644074,
0.0747493431,
-0.531468153,
0.4304371178,
1.1455295086,
-0.2462559938,
0.4514043927,
-0.3243212104,
0.0447421931,
-0.5099244118,
0.5180238485,
-0.1069639847,
-0.2080070376,
-0.8345976472,
-0.5314043164,
0.7507559061,
0.3362611234,
-0.2341746539,
0.565694809,
-0.0805465877,
-0.1687013656,
-1.2014635801,
0.0258347634,
0.5325295329,
0.5061129332,
0.2566202283,
-0.5684236288,
-0.4057607651,
-1.3537149429,
0.104754515,
-0.1733835936,
0.0816218778,
0.3855755329,
0.1604361534,
-0.1815624386,
0.8370494843,
-0.2997640371,
-0.2265900522,
-0.0271019842,
0.0807640404,
0.2299104929,
0.33885023,
0.6902070045,
-0.5649448037,
-0.8536983728,
-0.0244584903,
-0.6676572561,
-0.0042768866,
-0.004129542,
-0.3029171228,
0.2781953514,
0.3738763034,
-0.7547297478,
0.6817246675,
0.3426176012,
0.0298578851,
0.5976601243,
-0.1946915686,
0.3110068142,
-0.6259863377,
0.5396140218,
-0.5601925254,
-0.3315101862,
-0.7912450433,
0.8364473581,
0.4256243706,
-0.0636805445,
-0.4669301212,
0.4813640118,
-0.4923022687,
-0.3643880188,
-0.261226356,
-0.2586776614,
-0.2921657562,
0.7385598421,
-0.0541818477,
0.9742825627,
0.5959649086,
-0.5340294838,
0.3150622547,
0.1105356589,
-0.5560858846,
0.2764135897,
-0.8422960639,
0.3934262097,
0.0919430628,
-0.0762308165,
-0.8608164787,
-0.3383026719,
0.0505596735,
-0.5928536057,
0.3904211223,
0.2813003659,
-0.5809771419,
-0.4653390944,
-0.8642709851,
0.4732945859,
0.7186892033,
-0.5783330798,
0.4520623088,
0.038897004,
-0.1704162359,
-0.6532605886,
-0.8442314863,
-0.1273944974,
0.0139313461,
-0.3747185171,
0.7935263515,
-0.3769616187,
-0.3594901562,
0.2775740325,
-0.1498388648,
-0.3152239919,
0.158432126,
0.0971563384,
0.1293817014,
-0.0664017275,
0.3534634411,
-0.059765134,
0.1058759913,
0.156796366,
0.045802664,
0.5365579128,
-0.0447781868,
-0.5053379536,
-0.7214295864,
0.6519722939,
0.5935628414,
0.0030396271,
0.7180473208,
0.6541760564,
-0.3601920903,
-0.077542752,
-0.6415123343,
-0.4782537818,
-0.5349814296,
0.6141778231,
-0.2940401733,
-0.7069761157,
0.8583498597,
0.4357393086,
0.1748433709,
0.4515389204,
0.872667551,
-0.6209211946,
0.7895802259,
0.688809216,
-0.4505519271,
0.9208292365,
-0.0443871357,
0.1597388238,
-0.9364175797,
0.3510777652,
-0.2083999515,
-0.5613113046,
-0.2834683359,
-0.333701551,
0.4537044466,
-0.2225075662,
-0.5943741202,
-0.1759445816,
-0.8280784488,
0.6476264596,
0.9669605494,
0.5133312941,
-0.1962712854,
0.0894624591,
0.2159429789,
-0.1711402684,
-0.7501941919,
0.1209822968,
1.3199328184,
0.2222218215,
0.5647183061,
0.098584339,
0.9164636731,
0.7988144755,
0.1636061668,
-0.8439290524,
0.5784198046,
-0.0911889151,
-0.9979660511,
-0.5554243922,
-0.5340678096,
-0.9396367669,
-0.0649779737,
0.1319337785,
-0.5288822055,
-0.2113014907,
0.2406633198,
-0.6595195532,
0.4207684696,
-0.9344199896,
0.7407881618,
-0.2055313885,
-0.7193661928,
-0.5656057596,
-0.9097299576,
0.1330109835,
-0.309599191,
0.2152353674,
-0.0310001839,
0.0238488521,
0.5857508183,
-0.5976321697,
0.9295313358,
-0.2813884616,
-0.1544757783,
0.3344629407,
-0.0132744638,
0.776283741,
-0.4440588653,
-0.0126590319,
0.0299083982,
-0.4084181488,
-0.8708763719,
-0.3023126721,
0.9658688903,
-0.9551766515,
-0.394502461,
-0.0812639445,
-0.7598639131,
-0.1227891445,
0.3583918512,
0.3135541379,
0.114555791,
-0.1533308327,
0.1282081902,
0.9919216037,
0.1034653187,
0.4254682064,
0.3756457567,
-0.0368544646,
-0.2656794488,
0.5888327956,
0.1498069465,
0.5761665106,
0.4918048978,
-0.1417532414,
-0.1169860139,
-0.5548297167,
-0.1044943631,
0.2134162337,
-0.794350028,
-0.1920945644,
-0.2440544665,
-0.4059592783,
-0.4574061334,
-0.3873689771,
-0.5271597505,
-0.3388601243,
-0.2210866362,
0.0054532271,
0.3143455386,
0.5519176722,
-0.2077286094,
0.4045331478,
-0.4788880646,
0.5715174079,
0.7763135433,
0.7168490887,
0.3083091974,
-0.6311635375,
-0.6375973821,
-0.1297604442,
-0.1356097758,
-0.6462780237,
0.0220257621,
0.2616725266,
0.7106399536,
0.3209229112,
0.0960058123,
0.8682326078,
-0.5306127071,
0.6317980289,
0.2560208738,
-1.2666891813,
0.6262144446,
-0.6832564473,
0.7528322935,
0.7927151918,
0.0367303528,
-0.1360932291,
-0.165281415,
-0.6602184176,
-1.0445231199,
0.8364807963,
0.4803232253,
-0.0672428235,
0.1162922829,
0.6573870778,
0.0108752847,
0.1869070679,
-0.922893405,
-0.4736848176,
0.2125027031,
-0.3883371651,
0.3191607296,
-0.6089631319,
-0.1247056574,
-0.505623877,
0.7366273403,
0.156005159,
0.9651661515,
0.3349996507,
-0.0767010972,
-0.4535306692,
-0.0649225712,
0.3773205578,
0.3520168662,
-0.782569766,
-0.0213543829,
0.3583143353,
-0.6279082298,
-0.281067431,
-0.0249739699,
-0.3915711641,
-0.0705790967,
0.5842645168,
0.6369787455,
0.3112666607,
-0.4570485353,
0.2215162218,
0.1740972251,
-0.3377557397,
-0.0229501389,
-0.0436019972,
0.0157388337,
-0.0455025434,
0.3373574018,
-0.0715773925,
0.5740875006,
-0.5716823339,
0.1880542785,
0.4368140996,
-0.5162758827,
-0.0755170286,
0.5796840787,
0.349332422,
-0.2076938301,
0.5808129907,
0.0304101016,
-0.4289887846,
0.8499984741,
0.3847151697,
0.9214925766,
-0.4778270423,
-0.3251666427,
0.3276368082,
0.3987390101,
0.2031500041,
0.3659252226,
-0.7057417035,
-0.3691424727,
-0.578093946,
-0.246435523,
-0.6216680408,
0.1550857276,
-1.0018596649,
0.0769090876,
-0.6623015404,
-0.3962247372,
0.0183760356,
0.0907677561,
-0.6175062656,
0.1484894156,
0.357237488,
0.4777074754,
-0.2243832201,
1.1120675802,
0.6929774284,
0.1046587601,
-0.354336828,
0.1999478936,
-0.2649004459,
-0.9614749551,
0.2640826404,
0.2525758147,
-0.2673402131,
0.0719313174,
-0.8384108543,
-1.1488829851,
1.0032817125,
0.4011462033,
-0.9045153856,
-0.0557549745,
-0.2812436521,
0.4584558606,
0.2278897613,
0.0345243067,
0.3417069912,
0.4168192446,
-0.2078980803,
-1.0620256662,
-0.1569119841,
-0.4128469825,
-0.2177257985,
0.6219952703,
-0.8434861898,
1.097730279,
-0.456071347,
-0.1469779015,
0.1618535966,
0.4321193993,
0.2302118987,
0.0927666351,
0.3144275248,
0.7635689378,
0.8125709295,
0.026407633,
1.0658195019,
-0.5484452248,
0.71850878,
1.198543787,
-0.385156095,
0.9096564651,
0.6076388955,
-0.5016573071,
0.4049416184,
0.7002238035,
0.2395352423,
1.0958404541,
0.16545856,
-0.2088114023,
-0.3482950032,
-0.0113292495,
-0.7719299793,
0.0127789974,
0.162698701,
-0.4332088828,
0.0505285151,
-0.4258694649,
-0.3569704592,
-0.2451826036,
-0.7518820763,
0.7394083142,
-0.1810336709,
-0.3059859574,
0.7193622589,
-0.1373759061,
0.7654758096,
-1.0606387854,
0.102569513,
0.006645943,
0.2727441788,
-0.0242435969,
-0.5014041662,
0.2819277048,
-0.069462955,
-0.7487933636,
-0.1187537983,
0.8954690099,
-0.1108152121,
-0.417401433,
0.3661310673,
0.2419365048,
0.1113744453,
-0.2357308716,
-0.866288662,
0.1514748186,
0.2619313002,
-0.388800025,
0.5520969629,
0.3130452633,
0.1545535326,
0.6553153396,
0.754304111,
0.0014714823,
-0.0684997514,
0.0966694579,
0.7476962209,
-0.933375895,
-0.786662519,
-0.8517518044,
0.1518281251,
-0.1118310988,
0.1105729342,
0.5037030578,
0.4257349074,
0.6109261513,
-0.2926313579,
0.916122973,
-0.1713056415,
0.7040867209,
-0.3734011948,
0.976025641,
-0.6927886605,
0.0190578103,
-0.1897450536,
-0.7920827866,
-0.1639352888,
0.7955393791,
-0.056326773,
0.3103123307,
0.6940352321,
0.3069969416,
-0.0289486777,
-0.2492313385,
0.4633824825,
0.3348594606,
-0.0097802719,
0.8657577038,
0.4431578517,
-0.3485169113,
0.1770333648,
-0.5173335671,
-0.0968338549,
-0.4296728969,
-0.6926947832,
-0.9105567336,
-0.4487833977,
-0.016972566,
0.100702472,
0.4026226401,
0.7825935483,
1.0077453852,
-0.9621020555,
-0.0772518367,
-0.0861583054,
-0.1552951187,
-0.3310698867,
-0.2062484771,
0.6857318878,
-0.574488163,
-0.4496757686,
0.0763466656,
0.1757294089,
-0.043247208,
-0.3259524405,
0.0583404675,
-0.1634903848,
0.1951524913,
0.5731777549,
0.0876494497,
-0.9412615895,
-0.2592935562,
0.0117602972,
-0.3922460973,
0.0567893386,
0.6758851409,
-0.7946738601,
0.5056182742,
0.2227919996,
0.5289384127,
0.7666937113,
0.1308781803,
0.2678154409,
-0.854613483,
0.233926937,
0.2780399621,
0.1338858306,
0.2090412378,
-0.7761182189,
0.5797088146,
-0.0295472499,
-0.834666431,
-0.9319891334,
0.2340657264,
-1.1296530962,
-0.5016249418,
0.8579645157,
0.0236913003,
-0.6166742444,
0.0700635388,
-0.2226283997,
0.0310029835,
-0.6100307703,
1.2035987377,
0.8964204192,
-0.1662825346,
-0.1997200996,
-0.6310427189,
0.5643258095,
0.9696252942,
-0.7557193041,
0.3633674383,
0.38049981,
0.1086039841,
0.0904059261,
0.8849703074,
0.1979441941,
0.8450857997,
-0.0385798477,
0.6724863648,
0.034629073,
-0.3125412464,
-0.1686282158,
0.1934148818,
0.1243000031,
-0.2890909016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08821v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08821v1
|
Constrained C-Test Generation via Mixed-Integer Programming
| 2024-04-12T21:35:21 | 2024-04-12T21:35:21 |
Ji-Ung Lee, Marc E. Pfetsch, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This work proposes a novel method to generate C-Tests; a deviated form of
cloze tests (a gap filling exercise) where only the last part of a word is
turned into a gap. In contrast to previous works that only consider varying the
gap size or gap placement to achieve locally optimal solutions, we propose a
mixed-integer programming (MIP) approach. This allows us to consider gap size
and placement simultaneously, achieving globally optimal solutions, and to
directly integrate state-of-the-art models for gap difficulty prediction into
the optimization problem. A user study with 40 participants across four C-Test
generation strategies (including GPT-4) shows that our approach (MIP)
significantly outperforms two of the baseline strategies (based on gap
placement and GPT-4); and performs on-par with the third (based on gap size).
Our analysis shows that GPT-4 still struggles to fulfill explicit constraints
during generation and that MIP produces C-Tests that correlate best with the
perceived difficulty. We publish our code, model, and collected data consisting
of 32 English C-Tests with 20 gaps each (totaling 3,200 individual gap
responses) under an open source license.
|
[
-0.8030427694,
-0.5648726225,
0.5737165213,
0.3750843108,
-0.1352627724,
0.1150996238,
-0.2133387029,
-0.4969885349,
-0.1715619564,
0.1135610268,
-0.7832986712,
-0.3182872832,
-0.0776536092,
0.3095088005,
0.2073268294,
0.8006578088,
-0.4655008912,
0.128247112,
-0.2545670271,
0.1812203825,
-0.6192263961,
-0.2702844143,
0.019311469,
-0.0357807577,
0.2803494036,
0.803534925,
0.5799093843,
0.3376669288,
0.4822517931,
0.1392715871,
0.0478659011,
0.1162276864,
-0.3189512789,
-0.0716415569,
0.1050610617,
-0.143490538,
0.1731421202,
-0.0333560966,
0.4825634956,
0.8159387112,
-0.3800629377,
-0.0348789468,
-0.0170216467,
0.2079410404,
-0.8686221838,
-0.2263271213,
-0.8535875678,
0.1502728015,
-0.3483729362,
0.0671937689,
-0.2267077267,
-0.5582743287,
-0.1188689098,
-0.5230972171,
0.5129693747,
0.1806787997,
0.7590693831,
0.4528476,
-0.3107124865,
-0.6188590527,
-0.4337208867,
0.6695592999,
-0.7411965728,
0.4185674787,
0.0337724425,
-0.0270373821,
-0.4667398036,
-0.4882488251,
-0.7071861029,
-0.6426666379,
0.2657474577,
0.2693189979,
0.4139857292,
0.2750390768,
0.4847446978,
0.6824275851,
-0.9408938289,
-0.0118762562,
-0.8074685931,
-0.322984159,
0.7386508584,
0.1491747499,
0.5727683902,
0.2358252257,
-0.3726503253,
0.1076985151,
-0.832223475,
0.2564060688,
0.5543903708,
-0.0109414058,
0.105521746,
0.8276972771,
-0.1617590189,
0.7019143701,
0.122655265,
-0.037270125,
0.1937136054,
-0.21645841,
0.0202276167,
-0.1441090703,
0.5222766399,
0.2183296233,
0.1697573215,
0.1239768788,
-0.2143922299,
0.3526284993,
0.0169875212,
-0.8693432212,
-0.2151008993,
0.0528101586,
0.0920209289,
-0.0212266762,
-0.0329811946,
-0.7344741821,
0.0117475148,
-0.1270135641,
0.042702198,
-0.4244452417,
0.0250371099,
0.3313490748,
-0.1426294595,
0.082495831,
-0.2144123763,
-0.9081227779,
0.3841473162,
0.247788012,
0.8760287762,
-0.4458521605,
-0.3525613248,
-0.3858533502,
-0.0168343149,
-0.3208965063,
0.5817416906,
-0.4121789336,
-0.773144722,
-0.1443376243,
-0.6217204332,
-0.3940852582,
-0.5310189128,
0.3835901022,
-0.1995722055,
0.4460798502,
-0.0171328112,
-0.5619891882,
0.3577155769,
0.2190030366,
-0.3606591225,
1.2474271059,
0.5242862701,
-0.7935449481,
0.290754348,
-0.7034949064,
-0.1362568587,
0.312671572,
-0.5736597776,
-0.3793432713,
0.1456698924,
0.1333171129,
-0.0126093701,
-0.1068153754,
0.0431369059,
-0.5043251514,
-0.5800927281,
0.2447484434,
0.004021971,
0.5780621767,
0.2423995882,
-0.5289768577,
-0.2101164013,
-0.4635773003,
0.4397458732,
-0.0375122055,
-0.5743722916,
0.0625212193,
-0.0876398459,
-0.4217135012,
0.2330497801,
0.2356023043,
-0.8917039633,
0.4522681534,
-0.5439857841,
0.1865613759,
0.7677608728,
0.4463763833,
0.2739885151,
-0.1946502328,
0.9931175113,
-0.2261799127,
0.4140334427,
0.2985590994,
-0.7083390355,
-0.511946857,
-0.1539844573,
0.1914863288,
0.7834357023,
-0.7038547397,
0.0664731339,
0.2058658153,
-0.4205681086,
-0.2500194311,
0.2546261251,
0.2036756426,
0.2088523358,
0.1663705111,
-0.3213025331,
-0.0762779489,
-0.8816030025,
-0.0981095806,
-0.0430244952,
-0.0403331593,
0.4367819428,
0.5582555532,
-0.0671331584,
0.6328259706,
-1.1201963425,
0.1716524661,
-0.1742161065,
-0.0046137292,
0.22319749,
0.4723803997,
0.3080270588,
-0.8321163654,
-0.6838458776,
-0.1259905845,
-0.0998599604,
-0.4388379753,
-0.3095963597,
0.1070802659,
-0.041741658,
0.3173695207,
-0.5474312305,
0.651863277,
0.6626130342,
-0.2167011797,
1.0490329266,
-0.1034212783,
-0.017382998,
-0.5535238385,
-0.2368872464,
-0.1803307682,
0.1079990119,
-0.2373020351,
0.3090772927,
-0.0137538724,
-0.6914564371,
-0.4218009114,
0.3190754652,
-0.8084258437,
0.2256018221,
0.0157950092,
-0.1559991837,
-0.3583430648,
0.6945464015,
-0.0996097103,
1.001067996,
0.3859004974,
-0.6068171859,
-0.2051001936,
0.0289138295,
-0.3416630328,
0.1539359093,
-0.6764342785,
0.4595957398,
0.1869222522,
0.0260505788,
-0.8397256732,
-0.4708052278,
0.2042550445,
-0.4933305681,
0.1853480935,
0.1526084244,
0.0176190939,
-0.6890081763,
-0.4423699379,
0.8129738569,
0.4437869787,
-0.242459923,
0.0192457456,
0.125856027,
-0.4019711912,
-0.4368018508,
-0.549135685,
-0.2854089439,
-0.1755039394,
-1.0281900167,
0.6069566607,
-0.8494310975,
0.1314235479,
-0.4463379979,
-0.1762268096,
-0.3710238636,
-0.0013949786,
0.2440816462,
0.0743405074,
-0.107069999,
-0.3596189022,
-0.0131464833,
0.1368652284,
-0.2129404396,
-0.1075088903,
0.4661355019,
-0.3005068898,
-0.5487946272,
-0.0921624675,
0.8493441939,
0.3070409,
-0.3593598902,
-0.0240623467,
0.283886075,
-0.4249820411,
-0.5659176111,
-0.2566578984,
0.0679715723,
-0.5170645714,
0.0852858201,
-0.5065855384,
-1.044696331,
0.2920371592,
-0.1675947607,
0.1159915552,
-0.0184209943,
0.7490950227,
0.2158181071,
1.2162884474,
0.4990371168,
0.3592579961,
0.3848851323,
-0.1885931939,
0.562182188,
-0.6597818732,
0.0237504821,
-0.4392305017,
-0.1766140759,
-0.7111679912,
-0.4134811759,
0.7859677076,
0.3077838123,
-0.3217298687,
0.0761068761,
-0.8574286103,
0.6997670531,
0.6392031908,
0.0352246128,
-0.1658465117,
-0.3816521168,
-0.6829636693,
-0.2789839506,
-0.6388356686,
-0.0404354446,
0.8140179515,
-0.0822058395,
0.4125981629,
0.1930772662,
1.0738482475,
0.0633847266,
0.4271009266,
-0.6062034965,
0.4058030546,
0.3853332698,
-0.7432934642,
-0.2150825262,
-0.4567802548,
-0.8642277718,
0.1246688142,
-0.0812455118,
-1.0710275173,
0.1580096483,
0.3498798609,
-0.4525376856,
-0.0032850213,
-0.819765985,
0.6747307181,
-0.3358231485,
-0.3678690195,
0.129968524,
-0.5483645201,
0.8150516748,
0.0520574115,
0.2577642202,
-0.0250969492,
0.1246120781,
0.2663366199,
-0.6046110988,
0.4279259741,
-0.3637281656,
0.3138563037,
0.5963822603,
0.2416487485,
0.3735655546,
0.1999561042,
0.1336385012,
-0.272421509,
0.0053311386,
-0.5700218678,
-0.3820050359,
0.7085667849,
-0.4754751623,
-0.5544560552,
-0.7160422802,
-0.7517796755,
-0.3045325577,
0.3817232847,
0.6036615968,
0.1713097095,
-0.2336593121,
-0.1586776525,
0.5333836675,
-0.3461593986,
0.4562908709,
0.2468308061,
0.1224250942,
-0.6351305246,
0.7687736154,
0.0270281266,
0.4557150602,
0.0385010689,
0.4076471627,
-0.3565658331,
-1.0962823629,
-0.5064516664,
0.1266613007,
-0.1612520218,
-0.1531817019,
0.0231947619,
-0.1331358403,
-0.4509809315,
-0.6200514436,
-0.2455668002,
-0.3755130172,
0.0657591969,
0.0125577739,
-0.4413558543,
0.5361453295,
-0.4543041587,
0.4624284506,
-0.4720736444,
0.3367664218,
0.1571427882,
0.255048722,
-0.3694835901,
0.2015761137,
-0.1389009058,
-0.0875410438,
-0.9366226196,
-1.2488912344,
0.2510021627,
-0.0518341884,
0.3556747139,
0.1967803985,
0.101701878,
0.6365735531,
-0.4429861009,
1.1188000441,
0.4936798513,
-0.9695205688,
0.2461098582,
-0.5573348403,
0.212267831,
0.7760229111,
0.1826879382,
-0.4414888024,
-0.4971230924,
-0.7768135667,
-1.0225037336,
0.1193254665,
0.5804281831,
-0.2719526887,
-0.1769183278,
0.417437166,
-0.0740105957,
0.0805189908,
-0.9800478816,
0.1366485655,
-0.0306582972,
-0.2995996475,
0.3184415698,
0.0450354479,
0.165055722,
-0.0330032222,
0.6428077817,
-0.1124022678,
0.1603456438,
0.6302212477,
-0.1492884755,
0.1056097001,
0.318603158,
0.8346008658,
0.9066593647,
-0.3716988564,
-0.1782007664,
0.254622072,
-0.6263210773,
0.1199714467,
0.1863987297,
-0.5887756944,
-0.076662384,
0.0100354906,
0.2948152423,
-0.1074283421,
-0.6381870508,
0.5317579508,
0.0457678176,
-0.3983420134,
-0.561860323,
0.3252535462,
0.1032651961,
-0.1102333292,
0.1415427029,
-0.2144714445,
0.2845623493,
-0.2119099945,
0.5216088891,
0.2962417901,
-0.1740003973,
-0.0771928579,
0.7618995905,
0.2042571604,
-0.4639258087,
0.5748316646,
-0.638868928,
-0.6383641362,
0.6900456548,
0.7658666372,
0.4031976759,
-0.4089547098,
0.2243559211,
0.5649920106,
0.4497393072,
0.01967673,
0.7266095281,
-0.0677173734,
-0.6461462975,
-0.4041466713,
-0.2573002279,
-0.5741202235,
0.1385131329,
-0.6146381497,
0.2477401346,
-0.5795635581,
0.0195858162,
-0.1917466223,
0.3170731068,
-0.8955169916,
0.3644421697,
0.4126390815,
0.8660147786,
-0.550021708,
0.2092662454,
0.383259207,
-0.430826962,
-0.9192014933,
-0.0576646775,
-0.0621530972,
-0.8912594318,
-0.2114719152,
0.3918645382,
0.0371224061,
0.0733163878,
-0.7064532638,
-0.6775939465,
1.0311046839,
0.2105618119,
-0.5719382763,
-0.0239087921,
0.3213642836,
0.0489076748,
-0.3873039186,
0.2345113009,
0.4494946897,
0.5380810499,
-0.0175105296,
-0.621437192,
0.0109107392,
-0.2445160896,
0.0253569409,
0.6867257953,
-0.7472409606,
0.7105478644,
-0.520542562,
-0.3671197593,
0.2672882676,
0.6083911657,
0.8134170175,
0.7008823156,
0.8003775477,
0.7059061527,
1.0655457973,
0.1617842317,
0.9808497429,
-0.2458518744,
0.3286392093,
1.0021914244,
-0.3882518709,
0.5668258071,
0.5693520904,
-0.115255557,
0.5209155083,
1.1946150064,
0.0694106519,
0.5374119282,
1.1094747782,
-0.4493426383,
-0.0603623129,
-0.0896724612,
-0.3466018736,
0.1459764689,
0.3408804536,
0.1372021139,
-0.181418553,
-0.4107803404,
0.0384433046,
-0.0022472134,
-0.1182897463,
0.1892363429,
0.0717259571,
-0.9706377387,
0.5857053995,
0.0697075874,
0.4364010692,
-0.5810257196,
-0.0294263288,
-0.3730379343,
0.0497596413,
-0.1808502972,
-0.5107187033,
0.2505193353,
0.062320549,
-0.0272324122,
-0.1016733199,
0.5726037025,
-0.5231114626,
-0.6026753783,
-0.0050163325,
0.4556985199,
0.3470751941,
-0.1147294343,
-0.6872375011,
-0.203622818,
0.5935996175,
-0.2533347905,
0.1066842601,
0.2822407484,
-0.0765982941,
0.3051596582,
0.8436847329,
0.1900409609,
0.4717526138,
-0.032132525,
0.742597878,
-0.7291745543,
-0.7105898857,
-0.6812539697,
0.7198603153,
-0.0315416194,
-0.7488241196,
0.1180693805,
0.9041686654,
0.8889994621,
0.0800041705,
1.1197638512,
-0.1808060557,
0.2539182603,
-0.6042283773,
-0.0986011624,
-0.4231645167,
0.0045691766,
-0.0506851599,
-0.803634882,
-0.217948094,
0.1829968244,
-0.086546883,
-0.2136443853,
1.1287962198,
1.036948204,
-0.2267919183,
-0.2275575846,
0.1161643639,
-0.293489635,
0.4603862464,
1.3819997311,
1.0522520542,
0.0588755123,
0.6322265267,
-0.4672110975,
-0.6013301611,
0.1694413871,
-0.6673898697,
-0.7308399081,
-0.3817596734,
-0.2060651332,
-0.2382727414,
-0.3006732166,
0.5302000046,
0.4790555239,
-0.4473232925,
-0.1956260949,
-0.3569262624,
0.2721437216,
-0.0927792713,
-0.3063617349,
0.1626535952,
-0.2378689349,
-0.599445343,
0.4791841209,
0.001606548,
0.2667876184,
-0.1729801148,
-0.149368912,
-0.0316425338,
0.1207172871,
-0.0773769096,
0.474809587,
-0.3267941177,
-0.3856014311,
0.387353152,
0.2710438073,
0.0651465282,
1.2733603716,
-0.1714032888,
0.2492476404,
0.5442503691,
0.5257180929,
0.7977064848,
0.3217398822,
0.8565680981,
-0.7622715831,
0.181624949,
0.6995537281,
0.3301611543,
0.2921232581,
-0.6391625404,
0.6587807536,
0.341750145,
-0.8574939966,
-0.8654473424,
0.6413384676,
-0.9627870917,
-0.3488227427,
1.1916356087,
0.0141174989,
-0.0395060591,
-0.0285314471,
-0.0663126186,
0.1503006369,
-0.3246861994,
0.7576064467,
0.9517349601,
-0.8387091756,
0.1719781011,
-0.6909059286,
0.4266231358,
0.4241791964,
-0.689817369,
-0.4031814039,
0.7635981441,
0.3431989551,
0.1925943643,
0.9620227814,
0.2212143689,
0.384103179,
0.1247151792,
0.4382532239,
0.0246673897,
-0.1533387452,
0.1178324893,
0.1366909146,
0.120329693,
-0.3983587325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08819v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08819v2
|
The Illusion of State in State-Space Models
| 2024-04-12T21:30:06 | 2024-06-04T22:05:45 |
William Merrill, Jackson Petty, Ashish Sabharwal
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CC, cs.CL, cs.FL
|
State-space models (SSMs) have emerged as a potential alternative
architecture for building large language models (LLMs) compared to the
previously ubiquitous transformer architecture. One theoretical weakness of
transformers is that they cannot express certain kinds of sequential
computation and state tracking (Merrill & Sabharwal, 2023), which SSMs are
explicitly designed to address via their close architectural similarity to
recurrent neural networks (RNNs). But do SSMs truly have an advantage (over
transformers) in expressive power for state tracking? Surprisingly, the answer
is no. Our analysis reveals that the expressive power of SSMs is limited very
similarly to transformers: SSMs cannot express computation outside the
complexity class $\mathsf{TC}^0$. In particular, this means they cannot solve
simple state-tracking problems like permutation composition. It follows that
SSMs are provably unable to accurately track chess moves with certain notation,
evaluate code, or track entities in a long narrative. To supplement our formal
analysis, we report experiments showing that Mamba-style SSMs indeed struggle
with state tracking. Thus, despite its recurrent formulation, the "state" in an
SSM is an illusion: SSMs have similar expressiveness limitations to
non-recurrent models like transformers, which may fundamentally limit their
ability to solve real-world state-tracking problems.
|
[
-0.0771032944,
-0.5136439204,
0.9202710986,
-0.0729382038,
-0.3485182524,
0.5918830633,
-0.0803086311,
-0.1965177357,
0.59896034,
0.3442543149,
-0.8030495644,
-0.119000338,
-0.5572667718,
0.0146516105,
-0.7384966016,
0.6825138927,
-0.1600956172,
-0.0308866594,
-0.1723134667,
-0.0031971389,
-0.2989418805,
-0.6408249736,
-0.0504589751,
-0.3921916485,
0.1175781414,
-0.1791436225,
0.8256968856,
0.3452837169,
0.4393436015,
0.3747230172,
-0.0776299611,
0.1869287938,
-0.6832503676,
0.1764078885,
-0.1233303472,
-1.0276777744,
-0.2216567099,
0.0315702409,
0.9233544469,
0.5815392137,
-0.2780068815,
0.114569813,
-0.1012440398,
0.8768208623,
-0.6847608089,
0.1543191224,
-0.5931150913,
0.3145394027,
-0.3042922616,
-0.0369304307,
-0.3500517905,
-0.1909480989,
-0.0014756918,
-0.6550240517,
-0.022314867,
0.1791285574,
1.1701476574,
0.4670088887,
-0.1920894682,
-0.0079442542,
-1.2765362263,
0.73124367,
-0.4799877703,
0.3667913973,
-0.1082703993,
0.4306220412,
-0.3297083378,
-0.4614734948,
-0.9066143036,
-0.3056415915,
-0.0363579281,
0.3480971456,
-0.5952623487,
-0.0758764446,
0.5059172511,
0.5135729909,
-0.1777081043,
0.0314318612,
-0.3796943426,
-0.2822224498,
0.2512620389,
0.5794593096,
0.2581347525,
-0.5188170671,
-0.7441379428,
0.0197436344,
-0.6059536934,
0.2182739675,
0.2426108718,
0.1518540829,
-0.0374873392,
0.673907876,
0.1037957743,
0.70798558,
0.2234355509,
0.1331819445,
-0.1949126571,
-0.0571550168,
-0.1848491281,
-0.1483912468,
0.8264473081,
-0.0048522763,
-0.0372951813,
-0.3623711169,
-0.1926593035,
0.5491530895,
0.7778083086,
-0.36738047,
0.0672702119,
0.0447189622,
-0.3888496757,
-0.0859622955,
0.3375751376,
-0.5023081899,
-0.5381033421,
-0.2307630777,
0.758761704,
-0.4076809585,
-0.4927313328,
0.112132363,
-0.1100864932,
0.3977274895,
0.1360466331,
-0.6447662711,
0.5292198062,
0.9169334173,
1.013449192,
-0.2793326676,
-0.0153979752,
0.2106739432,
-0.1106954217,
-0.799212575,
0.5740492344,
-0.7490826845,
-0.4943689704,
-0.2881742716,
0.0350743942,
-0.203453809,
-0.4268075526,
-0.0868647248,
-0.453602165,
-0.0859696344,
-0.1799189448,
-0.7278285623,
0.0419225134,
-0.0897978097,
-0.8177608848,
0.8967956901,
0.1294023395,
-0.1564563364,
0.2980168164,
-0.4197067618,
-0.4685528278,
-0.0279163029,
-0.4786576331,
-0.3301829398,
0.7386090159,
-0.3405241072,
0.4122940004,
-0.0413857289,
0.1958141327,
-0.3125983179,
-0.7598491311,
0.54512012,
-0.2649780512,
0.3604469895,
0.4096138477,
-0.3154001832,
-0.0476034358,
-0.684010148,
-0.2061754912,
0.1980845779,
-0.3087771833,
-0.3728678524,
0.4648411572,
-0.6574226022,
0.3863525391,
0.2676706016,
-0.7324619293,
0.1999884397,
-0.5482627749,
0.578722775,
0.8879441023,
-0.2626122534,
0.7782851458,
-0.2563729584,
0.9660771489,
0.0984462649,
-0.0678860545,
-0.1437295526,
-0.1864427924,
-0.7528321743,
-0.3494356573,
0.1080930531,
0.4951770902,
-0.78416574,
0.3646990955,
-0.5269914269,
-0.6333902478,
-0.7177786231,
-0.2784400284,
0.2966715395,
0.2182400078,
0.2014344037,
-0.0972418264,
-0.4353211224,
-1.0843806267,
-0.5562270284,
0.1640013903,
0.0622855052,
0.1693743467,
0.5305062532,
0.6234624982,
0.9089746475,
-0.3357783258,
-0.2445870042,
-0.2370218635,
-0.3500190377,
0.2473887056,
0.4572282135,
0.1877288222,
-0.6333642006,
-0.002019716,
-0.3006133139,
-0.7138605118,
0.3361883163,
-0.200192377,
0.0119196055,
0.2015096396,
0.347448796,
-0.9517418146,
0.6710245013,
0.4779655039,
-0.2114543319,
0.3219046891,
-0.0063164015,
0.1130591258,
-0.9566115141,
-0.0012639649,
-0.0122778285,
-0.0038616543,
-0.7379158735,
0.1300667822,
0.0766309649,
-0.3978556693,
-0.4207601547,
0.3191458285,
-0.477250427,
-0.3470071554,
-0.3593420684,
0.3191165924,
-0.2331569791,
0.6564801335,
0.1209834218,
0.4434295297,
0.5054353476,
-0.7485767603,
0.1728831828,
-0.1319746971,
-0.7988909483,
0.7149100304,
-0.2611220181,
-0.0964981839,
-0.2785790265,
0.6449236274,
-1.1110467911,
0.0721950755,
0.1301990151,
-0.3159320056,
0.5555433035,
0.0328851268,
-0.3793687522,
-0.4342980683,
-0.0968881845,
0.0212556515,
0.6977595091,
-0.4127578139,
1.0419650078,
0.2701250017,
0.4597769678,
-0.5723395348,
-0.9361417294,
0.0337398238,
-0.1081513539,
-0.2772839963,
0.1260686517,
0.3656407297,
-0.1940026283,
0.1805744171,
-0.6702399254,
0.2035916895,
0.4602689147,
0.4750581086,
0.5030933619,
-0.183142513,
0.0976873264,
0.05455897,
-0.0835830942,
0.1094544008,
-0.2585387826,
0.4787390232,
-0.2519067526,
-0.5701488256,
-0.7768942118,
0.1475267559,
0.6299122572,
-0.1114839464,
0.805995822,
0.0671852157,
-0.4957529604,
-0.3290123641,
-0.2319848984,
-0.111581333,
-0.5006856918,
0.4383227825,
-0.6084264517,
-1.0135523081,
0.3590793908,
-0.1615389287,
0.1178019494,
0.6453367472,
0.3133182526,
-0.5270719528,
1.1647293568,
0.3965578675,
-0.0618000552,
0.4212119281,
-0.2908733487,
0.1481003463,
-1.0853638649,
-0.3523161113,
-0.5172122121,
-1.0128563643,
-0.84561795,
-0.3151422739,
0.2398883998,
-0.0083265686,
-0.254937917,
0.5128192306,
-0.4681642652,
0.3828552365,
0.2393289506,
0.1514900923,
0.1035616696,
0.0514461882,
-0.031718038,
-0.3575302958,
-0.9916267991,
-0.4500736594,
0.930885613,
0.2532734871,
1.2290402651,
0.2379212677,
0.5031670928,
0.0633480102,
0.1008178517,
-0.896219492,
0.8199422956,
-0.4073859155,
-0.8068854809,
-0.2646954954,
-0.4553926587,
-0.8181899786,
0.4188977778,
-0.392868042,
-0.9115574956,
0.3240312636,
0.2607059181,
-0.3835837245,
0.654964149,
-0.3650734723,
0.5818274021,
-0.0914300233,
-0.2115366459,
-0.4488847852,
-0.5266073942,
0.4816560447,
0.0295047686,
0.0956222937,
-0.2254468948,
-0.2088608593,
0.5217069387,
-0.6112289429,
0.9149746895,
-0.3461672962,
-0.0630082637,
0.2763771415,
0.624774456,
0.4885749221,
-0.5753407478,
0.1611439735,
0.1558539867,
-0.1351023316,
-0.3271210492,
-0.8046184182,
0.7882810235,
-0.5065348744,
-0.8228427768,
-0.5243231654,
-0.3825706542,
-0.2470408231,
-0.1065304428,
0.2239092141,
0.4384455085,
-0.1834613383,
0.1240897402,
0.5648338795,
-0.0828612149,
0.3481125236,
0.6179596782,
-0.4349420965,
0.1500130743,
1.033724308,
0.3460874557,
0.4584682584,
0.5646637678,
0.0440397337,
-0.4156057239,
-0.0295546651,
-0.4623456001,
0.1941555291,
-0.5148220062,
0.2152069807,
-0.1264494061,
-0.1865939349,
0.2226081342,
-0.006275313,
-0.5819868445,
-0.9418365955,
-0.2215180546,
-0.1167633459,
-0.0164491199,
0.9039259553,
0.1825366467,
0.2193639725,
-0.3200606704,
0.4251128435,
0.078477256,
0.6272126436,
0.1307742894,
-0.8066602945,
-0.2067305595,
-0.1872339398,
-0.1891361624,
-0.7543388605,
-0.1215274706,
-0.0290443487,
0.4049752057,
0.317140162,
-0.1938147545,
0.9633982778,
-0.811080277,
1.14234519,
0.2698470354,
-1.0225436687,
0.3120328486,
0.0795389265,
0.5422505736,
0.0149092404,
0.3555629253,
-0.389909029,
-0.8801993728,
-0.6912673116,
-0.4528515339,
0.9136181474,
0.0420338474,
0.3295297623,
0.0553988889,
0.5141325593,
-0.1204725727,
0.343531549,
-0.5022829175,
-0.6120117903,
-0.5290590525,
-0.0080713723,
-0.1278997958,
-0.0152453873,
0.0893030763,
0.0216154624,
0.643307507,
0.3166564703,
0.470967561,
0.2868602574,
-0.1800032407,
-0.277540952,
0.3532536328,
0.855614841,
0.6018286943,
0.2219821513,
0.2130260468,
0.1477902979,
-0.1142735034,
0.3861835897,
-0.1131291166,
-0.3342112899,
0.0921081305,
0.135426268,
1.1360350847,
0.4911418557,
-0.2148555219,
0.3871721029,
0.281558007,
-0.2476184964,
-0.3649237156,
0.3951090872,
0.2321700305,
0.316152662,
0.3752767146,
0.390142411,
-0.1794686317,
-0.5218803883,
-0.2368762046,
0.8005261421,
-0.7779919505,
-0.5314377546,
0.9747370481,
-0.2229048461,
-0.6812221408,
0.4016970396,
0.1670830101,
-0.4836626649,
0.6127153039,
0.5443194509,
0.8323238492,
-0.3196953833,
-0.029079685,
0.2645839751,
0.5476512909,
-0.1713655442,
0.2775385976,
-0.132666111,
-0.7545784712,
-0.5638150573,
-0.6167037487,
-0.3173214793,
0.1644987166,
-0.8860124946,
-0.0452144668,
-0.6529572606,
-0.4446702302,
-0.0368519612,
-0.2944653928,
-0.4610060155,
-0.1250475794,
0.2579039037,
0.9433683753,
-0.6612954736,
0.6359907389,
0.5403791666,
-0.0878645033,
-0.8178218007,
-0.2593310773,
0.1537727863,
-0.6841346025,
0.3553380966,
0.0384643525,
-0.5030639768,
-0.1638999432,
-0.8003723621,
-0.8762331009,
0.9868286848,
0.3604056239,
-0.754448235,
-0.0111525152,
0.1359462738,
0.7827913761,
-0.0384759568,
-0.3132039607,
0.5636523366,
0.4435418248,
-0.2525704503,
-0.8666219711,
0.1022157818,
0.0934885815,
0.1779749393,
0.724352181,
-1.0633780956,
0.6606507897,
-0.1341209263,
-0.6438092589,
0.334626019,
0.8875423074,
0.0537121631,
-0.1909697503,
0.5235027671,
0.7157164216,
0.4565428495,
-0.3639391363,
1.199198246,
-0.2298093438,
0.2510766685,
1.0104851723,
-0.5346997976,
0.7649959326,
0.426192075,
-0.4506371021,
0.8139653206,
0.0432738587,
-0.2555232644,
0.2720110416,
0.5284466743,
-0.070853509,
-0.5161299109,
0.3228182793,
0.0014164393,
0.5016260743,
0.5244438648,
-0.2270794213,
-0.0435071252,
-0.0185147617,
0.100489229,
0.4382154644,
-0.426655829,
0.5091782212,
0.244549498,
-0.6411288381,
0.2146466821,
-0.2961731851,
0.4383372366,
-0.975101769,
-0.0289273001,
-0.0907965377,
0.0464311838,
-0.1383575201,
-0.6435442567,
0.1847350001,
0.0478273891,
-0.0831079856,
-0.0657549202,
0.5339187384,
-0.1755447388,
-0.3551122546,
-0.0385146551,
0.3478071094,
0.3484281003,
0.2155534923,
-0.5856953859,
-0.0606146678,
-0.3161537051,
-0.4772547185,
0.2689869702,
0.1189819947,
-0.0423553735,
1.0150827169,
0.3477275968,
0.3065918982,
0.2155280411,
-0.2795768678,
0.4174776971,
-0.7913031578,
-0.4902549088,
-0.9572176933,
0.1932240129,
0.2058449984,
-0.0479680859,
0.7468340397,
0.6683864594,
0.7091810703,
-0.0951100811,
0.6384779215,
-0.0733473673,
0.6230642796,
-0.6553812027,
0.8632711768,
-0.7003597021,
0.3369609714,
-0.1331610233,
-0.7602683306,
0.0799071118,
0.5153842568,
-0.2590406835,
0.003152211,
0.8059622645,
0.6122482419,
0.023975689,
0.0913102031,
0.5019712448,
0.5908330679,
-0.0363907255,
0.5935575962,
1.4214352369,
-0.183846131,
0.5715239048,
-0.2316997349,
0.0709937438,
0.1429063827,
-0.5813024044,
-0.5406641364,
-0.7320889235,
-0.0874980241,
-0.3813071847,
-0.2790922225,
0.5473022461,
0.7012609839,
-0.6468865871,
-0.2849741876,
0.1523851156,
0.1452647746,
-0.3863791823,
-0.2789598703,
0.3301745355,
-0.0785909295,
-0.7930152416,
0.7749174833,
0.3933804631,
0.082882978,
-0.7297953367,
0.1457755268,
-0.0587595813,
0.282563597,
0.5146673322,
0.4100949168,
-1.0275614262,
-0.3030277491,
0.0680024475,
-0.2098507583,
0.0937596336,
0.8680374026,
-1.0497610569,
0.6260869503,
0.1086809486,
0.436480552,
0.628395915,
0.0365322046,
0.4048415422,
-0.5099380612,
-0.0610301197,
0.1642998457,
0.4130090177,
-0.0089147696,
-0.1715201735,
0.1427203417,
0.2919527888,
-0.2164120525,
-0.5921120644,
0.455021292,
-0.8595448732,
-0.4911957979,
0.7557000518,
0.0811264291,
-0.4529047012,
0.2435892671,
0.1889294386,
0.1106484458,
-0.2228379995,
0.7613666058,
0.9435328245,
-0.2845141888,
0.295304805,
-0.5990812182,
0.4980955422,
0.5066924691,
-0.3334195912,
-0.1131639853,
0.4994686246,
0.29073295,
0.4208481014,
0.3995142877,
-0.1857286394,
0.2415884882,
0.0217677336,
-0.1562296599,
-0.152283594,
-0.3502982557,
-0.7803892493,
0.2035401613,
-0.3037192523,
-0.3262739182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08817v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08817v2
|
Revisiting Code Similarity Evaluation with Abstract Syntax Tree Edit Distance
| 2024-04-12T21:28:18 | 2024-06-03T11:56:38 |
Yewei Song, Cedric Lothritz, Daniel Tang, Tegawendé F. Bissyandé, Jacques Klein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.PL, cs.SE
|
This paper revisits recent code similarity evaluation metrics, particularly
focusing on the application of Abstract Syntax Tree (AST) editing distance in
diverse programming languages. In particular, we explore the usefulness of
these metrics and compare them to traditional sequence similarity metrics. Our
experiments showcase the effectiveness of AST editing distance in capturing
intricate code structures, revealing a high correlation with established
metrics. Furthermore, we explore the strengths and weaknesses of AST editing
distance and prompt-based GPT similarity scores in comparison to BLEU score,
execution match, and Jaccard Similarity. We propose, optimize, and publish an
adaptable metric that demonstrates effectiveness across all tested languages,
representing an enhanced version of Tree Similarity of Edit Distance (TSED).
|
[
-0.0584056042,
-0.5566496253,
0.4287136495,
0.2669785917,
-0.180993408,
0.5291270614,
-0.4026810825,
-0.7127931714,
0.1533667743,
-0.125197053,
0.0365843922,
-0.8021025658,
-0.6071417928,
0.2642466724,
-0.6817363501,
0.6684892178,
-0.3097454309,
-0.4031525254,
-0.1876842827,
-0.3037704825,
-0.2253046781,
-0.2329296619,
-0.3983189762,
0.3012191355,
0.3229287565,
0.1640311927,
0.884482801,
0.9015830159,
0.5669199824,
0.3138745129,
-0.0942331925,
-0.1874545068,
0.0393253341,
-0.1295653284,
-0.1281251907,
-0.3466999531,
-0.5620764494,
-0.3307055533,
0.9350271821,
0.7301464081,
0.2691516578,
0.3068278134,
0.0523595139,
1.0212450027,
-0.4273045063,
0.0968236476,
-0.6079396605,
0.1128322929,
-0.349237442,
-0.3177505136,
-0.0023300762,
-0.8814054132,
-0.0091191754,
-0.3831674457,
0.2746152878,
-0.1818502843,
0.7918602824,
0.2768601477,
-0.1431431621,
-0.5655861497,
-0.4755239487,
0.3077485561,
-0.7228556275,
0.4538494349,
-0.1468297243,
0.2566230893,
0.1564913988,
-0.6815477014,
-0.3894150555,
-0.3132335544,
0.0104662254,
-0.0091429809,
-0.4873665273,
0.3319080174,
0.5623780489,
0.6444858313,
-0.5613363385,
-0.0449693315,
-0.5624165535,
-0.0966843441,
0.5118130445,
0.017594859,
0.4559377134,
-0.0068708714,
0.0433915928,
0.1003115773,
-0.7292865515,
0.2919295132,
0.5516270995,
0.024057718,
0.0613355748,
0.4503785968,
-0.3643477857,
0.7516224384,
-0.2952138484,
0.3391978443,
0.4703177512,
-0.3954024017,
-0.2034194618,
-0.19586429,
0.745372355,
0.7173800468,
0.2869999707,
-0.2180889398,
-0.2404869646,
0.1944420189,
0.2821293473,
-0.632843256,
-0.7057349086,
-0.1699159294,
-0.7337540388,
-0.1407726109,
0.317143023,
-0.5603684187,
-0.0794166848,
-0.2123127431,
0.0755753592,
-0.475638479,
-0.101060912,
0.0587097071,
-0.3273229897,
0.2704767585,
0.534514904,
-0.4465881586,
0.2850617766,
0.9630697966,
1.2001650333,
-0.2607389688,
-0.4768488705,
-0.2379122525,
-0.362087369,
-0.2768114507,
0.5807745457,
-0.976937592,
-0.5609194636,
-0.3043252528,
-0.3729957044,
-0.004538958,
-0.5507931709,
0.1682419479,
-0.4477476478,
-0.2819692194,
-0.0407737643,
-0.5055103302,
-0.3552696109,
0.2839372456,
-0.4109361768,
1.0761178732,
0.503722012,
-0.7791846395,
0.2827822864,
-0.8619216084,
-0.4409787655,
-0.248049736,
-0.1463879347,
-0.4621900022,
0.3301080465,
-0.1111698821,
-0.1304209381,
0.142872408,
-0.20175457,
-0.2401753813,
-0.5755962133,
0.1153224409,
-0.3427881598,
0.813685298,
0.2342632115,
-0.2312322855,
0.5417201519,
-0.6943078041,
0.3987220526,
-0.3960381448,
-0.5142607689,
-0.4702736139,
-0.1656063348,
-0.1742264032,
0.0778887421,
0.2585932314,
-0.5512499213,
0.5804323554,
-0.2975844741,
0.4826513827,
0.6853733063,
-0.0186435748,
0.0561429672,
-0.2535817325,
0.9052781463,
-0.3656225801,
-0.0596942604,
-0.0726944059,
-0.4637394845,
-0.3030160069,
-0.1306221783,
0.6908066869,
0.6328883171,
-0.4671241343,
0.3478461802,
-0.3809565604,
-0.6841725111,
-0.5173693895,
-0.0498136207,
0.7389580607,
0.0849911496,
0.2025492489,
-0.9271007776,
-0.5607951283,
-0.5929669738,
-0.9418742657,
-0.2632737756,
-0.0108599933,
0.2555283606,
0.3637290299,
-0.3821874261,
0.79710567,
-0.6619503498,
0.4355638623,
0.1832950413,
-0.186425209,
0.1288047135,
0.6202489138,
0.7330334187,
-0.2084793299,
-0.9490047693,
0.3093245327,
-0.3536980152,
-0.3574619889,
0.0836532637,
0.2565896213,
0.1105680689,
0.7167235613,
-0.4235526919,
0.6375336647,
0.4728093445,
-0.6327966452,
0.9704911113,
-0.1638481766,
0.8088487983,
-0.7442250848,
0.3010995686,
-0.3094343543,
-0.3740716577,
-0.0752398372,
0.5513121486,
0.2568994164,
-0.0133025106,
-0.2965635359,
0.1242832467,
-0.3923521638,
-0.7705723047,
0.1184700131,
-0.0592752621,
-0.2139048129,
0.2648336887,
-0.2763217092,
0.9009177089,
0.5667891502,
-0.1520207971,
0.3927624226,
0.0224117003,
-0.5401315093,
0.3354729116,
-0.6323130727,
0.5603812933,
0.3364159763,
0.1289603412,
-1.0528000593,
0.4245440066,
-0.0667250827,
-0.7358082533,
0.184153378,
-0.2291022688,
-0.4565195739,
-0.1908840835,
-0.791364789,
0.7566302419,
0.5373145342,
-0.3699551225,
-0.0574080199,
-0.2142640948,
-0.234490186,
-0.5883656144,
-0.4291262031,
0.2067401111,
-0.2739094198,
-0.4583551884,
0.2872635424,
-0.0394135639,
-0.4224323928,
0.1951472014,
-0.5268418193,
0.0956006274,
0.2373143584,
0.2667001188,
-0.208692506,
-0.6115355492,
-0.1454439461,
0.2228819579,
-0.1663219333,
0.0476491041,
-0.297939539,
0.1877090484,
-0.5019654632,
-0.6548733711,
-0.2296491861,
0.2365267128,
0.4075763226,
-0.3493620455,
0.1500103623,
0.1481992453,
-0.3300832808,
0.196024254,
-0.2015371025,
0.2430682629,
-0.4330863953,
0.4797513485,
-0.6432593465,
-1.1607550383,
0.4992845654,
-0.1318761855,
0.2552011907,
0.2811860442,
0.0810777023,
0.1553826779,
0.4743116498,
0.4700953662,
-0.1958761215,
0.6140711904,
-0.145600155,
0.1128708944,
-0.7957683802,
0.1171199009,
-0.9562579393,
-0.5220618248,
-0.6245951653,
-0.6696734428,
0.0665047765,
0.4277954102,
-0.1586719155,
0.5942761898,
-0.4803724885,
0.9514181018,
0.3999224305,
-0.2077062279,
0.6602305174,
-0.2752125859,
0.1206123009,
-0.0413120314,
-0.3265127838,
-0.415979296,
0.9561134577,
0.3121465147,
0.416556865,
0.2128396779,
0.8127054572,
0.4053335786,
0.107044898,
-0.4685588479,
0.3913105428,
-0.2732449472,
-0.0195133593,
-0.3715772629,
-0.3696831167,
-0.7352985144,
0.0682469606,
0.4469156861,
-0.8551493287,
-0.0370642953,
0.3249929249,
-0.4129304886,
0.3579992652,
-0.9529692531,
1.1465002298,
0.0491742007,
0.1740076244,
-0.4444172382,
-0.6603829265,
0.0186098963,
0.1363188028,
-0.0378255844,
0.2720809579,
-0.2336360365,
0.6102261543,
-0.6433590055,
0.4656252265,
-0.0644878,
0.1184395626,
0.2693026066,
0.5156025887,
0.0885552764,
0.1616776586,
-0.173982054,
0.3757989705,
0.2696110904,
-0.3718628287,
-0.7587665915,
0.893889308,
-0.434224844,
-0.409578681,
-0.2804020345,
-0.4294121563,
-0.0055298042,
0.2801725566,
0.0692251548,
0.5689325929,
-0.2012738287,
0.0124179348,
0.0596416444,
-0.3892374933,
0.6168162227,
0.3435395956,
-0.251971513,
-0.2260348052,
0.6803580523,
-0.0706204921,
0.4579145312,
0.5485418439,
0.0558977015,
-0.2935549319,
-0.8406590223,
-0.6482630372,
-0.288974911,
-0.6330640912,
-0.416066587,
-0.5189629793,
-0.1521215588,
-0.0964517444,
-0.7681458592,
-0.357555002,
-0.8126578331,
0.3908383548,
-0.2148805112,
0.8871213198,
0.9054538012,
-0.0592288524,
-0.0486312248,
-0.7476118803,
0.0154124219,
-0.060311839,
0.7876322865,
0.1955382079,
-0.1710973531,
-0.1147599891,
-0.1687122285,
-0.4421820939,
-0.8455919623,
-0.0346790478,
0.3223001659,
0.0728081316,
-0.1851596385,
-0.1680439413,
0.9940351844,
-0.4814645648,
0.8170405626,
-0.054882925,
-1.288928628,
0.6445268989,
-0.294556886,
0.5573435426,
0.8642342091,
-0.0680718198,
-0.6676953435,
-0.7015116811,
-0.7328825593,
-0.6679140925,
0.4911455512,
0.356978178,
-0.211238727,
0.0478627458,
0.2882519662,
0.1136582047,
0.1656601131,
-0.5107111335,
-0.3155383766,
-0.1073797792,
-0.1312048584,
0.1400213093,
0.1788680255,
0.523638308,
-0.5626045465,
0.1812400073,
0.0854902416,
0.3795392215,
0.0752395019,
-0.1345244348,
-0.1541765928,
0.4268561304,
0.4347267151,
0.87759161,
-0.0923071802,
0.2280522287,
0.4084343612,
-0.6144018769,
-0.1655324101,
-0.0122443493,
0.0406588726,
0.1784236729,
0.6806252003,
0.3118431866,
0.1783864349,
-0.7277797461,
0.4531765878,
0.0817257687,
0.1147331744,
0.0457379892,
0.0474464186,
0.0482163951,
0.1027388945,
-0.3652919531,
0.5012543797,
0.540116787,
-0.6782078743,
0.5492828488,
0.2582614422,
-0.6169760823,
-0.4272198379,
0.2928669453,
0.2723972201,
-0.9206463099,
0.6471562386,
-0.5062857866,
-0.8479884863,
0.9439279437,
0.4597738385,
0.9635074139,
-0.2751067281,
-0.2223941684,
0.4715058804,
0.2141539305,
0.2453036606,
0.1512484252,
-0.4001939893,
-0.1450294703,
-0.5794810057,
-0.4576002657,
-0.101130642,
-0.3627424538,
-0.4583502412,
0.3655852079,
-0.7964488268,
0.5282580853,
-0.0986795425,
0.1108314842,
-0.4133405089,
-0.1631169617,
-0.4265293777,
1.0802843571,
-0.7043988109,
0.9822805524,
0.8649888039,
-0.1489900649,
-0.8610959053,
0.1680118293,
0.1600307226,
-0.5086271763,
0.0916448906,
0.2845604718,
-0.0812156796,
-0.0734501258,
0.121316947,
-0.5283443928,
0.8705350161,
0.2008447647,
-0.5821897984,
-0.0048756422,
-0.0943025798,
0.8077756763,
-0.1189871952,
0.6229002476,
1.1510130167,
0.1278789788,
-0.2833316326,
-1.3675711155,
0.1351242959,
-0.6093566418,
0.1225509867,
0.7239038944,
-0.4219012558,
0.5471174121,
-0.3433620334,
-0.2496098578,
0.2418110222,
0.2841972709,
0.1746115386,
0.3909780383,
0.4993923604,
0.6025981903,
0.4645467401,
0.1056734696,
0.9332424402,
-0.2249269038,
0.5009993315,
1.1897490025,
0.0969500542,
0.6906906366,
0.1069639102,
-0.7109995484,
0.586643517,
0.491733104,
0.1196309701,
0.2474161834,
0.4030276239,
0.0380884372,
0.3444577754,
0.3681398928,
-0.6407284737,
0.0777293593,
0.2627535462,
-0.3845218122,
-0.2931647897,
-0.5335606933,
0.1078250259,
0.6017825007,
-0.1668563634,
0.6826787591,
0.2177075893,
-0.3140285015,
0.457331717,
0.1717857271,
0.6051421165,
-0.2669507861,
-0.1635129154,
-0.1496712714,
-0.0374218524,
-0.46762079,
-1.1370222569,
1.0143754482,
0.385833323,
-0.0266412888,
-0.1429460347,
0.2894012034,
-0.2675589919,
-0.1731740236,
0.1449439377,
0.249307707,
0.1500962377,
-0.195093751,
-0.9705661535,
0.1062845364,
0.3952434063,
0.1751184762,
0.1003569737,
0.7191907167,
-0.1137364507,
0.3189521134,
0.3461710215,
0.1544097513,
0.050199531,
0.0541776493,
0.6170813441,
-0.9391528368,
-0.7717828155,
-1.1321780682,
0.2529366314,
-0.0435907915,
-0.6410437226,
0.9598673582,
1.1104151011,
1.162964344,
-0.3659366965,
0.5998360515,
-0.4508613348,
0.4041584432,
-0.4702974856,
0.4487511814,
-0.267516017,
0.5445267558,
-1.0616958141,
-1.4359910488,
-0.4136830866,
0.5598348975,
-0.2671992779,
-0.0808615685,
1.0325324535,
0.9013628364,
-0.1113807335,
0.0551096089,
0.1368121356,
0.1302823275,
0.3650154769,
1.0151612759,
0.9335810542,
-0.4268798828,
0.2848104835,
-0.0335742384,
-0.2147889137,
-0.0282202754,
-0.8324602246,
-0.6796183586,
-0.6401877403,
-0.7112952471,
-0.2356435955,
0.3703045249,
1.1348969936,
0.2366488278,
-0.7598428726,
-0.1790915728,
-0.1845897883,
0.3287271857,
-0.624653697,
-0.2096190155,
0.6603674889,
0.0367027968,
-0.3486670554,
0.0398431942,
0.4625807405,
-0.1032692567,
0.3287422657,
-0.0591840409,
0.188475281,
-0.3171928227,
0.6705842614,
0.5422583818,
-0.7453936338,
-0.7678638697,
-0.1950258017,
-0.0037681418,
0.2745031416,
1.0486121178,
-0.7049404383,
0.5266568065,
0.7688925862,
0.7829486132,
-0.0531990863,
0.2250955403,
0.5498356819,
-0.8830065131,
-0.0674871281,
0.1563347727,
0.247358501,
0.271553129,
-0.1292718202,
0.801697135,
0.1369002759,
-0.4093410969,
-0.7955461144,
0.3116353452,
-1.0546069145,
0.0235022157,
1.1737569571,
-0.3607880771,
0.1733773053,
-0.2482106537,
-0.5457567573,
0.0149505083,
-0.4759169221,
0.8045822382,
0.5163464546,
-0.2391870618,
-0.0060638511,
-0.3516105413,
0.7783480883,
0.0936284736,
-0.8368096948,
0.1409499794,
0.4764275253,
0.4663142264,
0.1211438328,
0.6265195012,
-0.5037142634,
0.6008896828,
0.1173753962,
-0.0050346358,
-0.0708602816,
-0.1011321172,
-0.6294720769,
-0.1337825507,
0.711499095,
-0.1421875507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08816v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08816v1
|
Evaluating the Quality of Answers in Political Q&A Sessions with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-12T21:16:53 | 2024-04-12T21:16:53 |
R. Michael Alvarez, Jacob Morrier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, econ.EM
|
This paper presents a new approach to evaluating the quality of answers in
political question-and-answer sessions. We propose to measure an answer's
quality based on the degree to which it allows us to infer the initial question
accurately. This conception of answer quality inherently reflects their
relevance to initial questions. Drawing parallels with semantic search, we
argue that this measurement approach can be operationalized by fine-tuning a
large language model on the observed corpus of questions and answers without
additional labeled data. We showcase our measurement approach within the
context of the Question Period in the Canadian House of Commons. Our approach
yields valuable insights into the correlates of the quality of answers in the
Question Period. We find that answer quality varies significantly based on the
party affiliation of the members of Parliament asking the questions and uncover
a meaningful correlation between answer quality and the topics of the
questions.
|
[
-0.5828014016,
-0.9511565566,
0.9540962577,
-0.2495505065,
-0.3703328669,
0.0574531555,
-0.1149588004,
-0.1083804518,
0.3920613527,
0.5781291723,
-0.4666306376,
-0.315744549,
-0.7041831613,
-0.1546946764,
-0.5921196938,
0.4391382635,
0.3604840338,
0.117547296,
-0.2588787675,
-0.3066663742,
-0.3536410034,
-0.6020256877,
-0.5876987576,
-0.2079053223,
0.6418586373,
0.3520473838,
1.0956312418,
0.7486066222,
0.5855402946,
0.2834066749,
-0.2530011833,
0.2432087064,
-0.6439200044,
-0.0133377789,
-0.3763064742,
-0.5484907627,
-0.1530021727,
0.2241418362,
0.6010748744,
0.812048912,
-0.1816446483,
0.2471267283,
-0.0149249667,
0.4907782674,
-0.5282065868,
0.0831866115,
-0.9616569877,
-0.2881467044,
0.0158617962,
-0.538631618,
-0.290695101,
-0.4719469249,
0.0715345591,
-0.4290973246,
0.0602476969,
0.0246920921,
1.053532958,
-0.1116617918,
-0.5025686026,
-0.5247433186,
-0.5038379431,
0.5798688531,
-0.7613392472,
0.2364973873,
0.3787711859,
0.2882112861,
-0.1229353622,
-0.6184701324,
-0.7670859694,
-0.2028970867,
-0.4444496036,
0.0787314847,
-0.0090802675,
-0.0855159461,
-0.0624689572,
0.4690342546,
-0.6998832226,
-0.1790811867,
-0.2289482206,
-0.1826505363,
0.754509151,
0.5235304832,
0.4141557515,
-0.2647616565,
0.0461322255,
-0.3276728094,
-0.2174889296,
0.3151904643,
0.5953837633,
0.455080092,
0.221269846,
0.7651053667,
-0.2211573422,
0.697308898,
0.0241741501,
0.3481784463,
-0.532928884,
-0.9024441242,
0.2297451645,
-0.32269454,
0.6420126557,
0.2641990483,
0.0765203312,
0.0020008238,
-0.2352490574,
0.0369142517,
0.087971352,
-0.8855389953,
-0.2172494382,
0.4747044742,
-0.5483373404,
0.2077415884,
0.3967894614,
-0.6123961806,
-0.2328500748,
-0.6162797213,
0.4468371272,
-0.2359982878,
-0.5564156175,
0.1884785146,
-0.1174794585,
0.4694575965,
0.3464286923,
-0.6867559552,
0.3261386454,
1.1227405071,
0.590210259,
-0.0946386904,
0.0634618923,
-0.9658868313,
-0.4934004545,
-0.6870017648,
0.8792400956,
-0.6208045483,
-0.214250803,
0.1652013212,
-0.0092255259,
0.1045392677,
-0.5879520178,
0.1154780537,
-1.1003371477,
0.4955556691,
-0.6599540114,
-0.8114310503,
0.0508293658,
0.3892199695,
-0.5085023046,
0.7872722745,
0.1794548631,
-0.7236681581,
0.5282628536,
-0.6497065425,
0.0862260237,
-0.0240266994,
0.0805121735,
0.0715484247,
0.1658790559,
0.3197256625,
0.2596936226,
-0.179948166,
0.3203287423,
-0.416872263,
-0.233782053,
0.8727282882,
-0.1584706455,
0.8534616828,
0.0306243598,
0.2127142847,
0.4176430702,
-0.7358653545,
0.430665344,
-0.2793672681,
-0.1252585649,
-0.4091876745,
-0.0119969919,
-0.1472153068,
0.2708267868,
0.2684175968,
-0.8040283322,
-0.1706143171,
-0.7416139841,
0.4867907465,
0.5972969532,
0.3621592522,
0.4700887799,
-0.3327529728,
0.244171083,
-0.2890131772,
0.2388299406,
0.1149501801,
-0.3020035625,
-0.5773636699,
0.0242133271,
0.6467616558,
0.3679175377,
-0.5151876807,
0.3152398765,
-0.314386636,
-0.4976660907,
-0.6139924526,
-0.0246310141,
-0.0181992315,
0.0981193706,
0.2177389264,
-0.4966641366,
-0.142241925,
-0.7252885699,
-0.3742033243,
-0.7475053072,
-0.1891222745,
0.584890604,
0.6662142277,
0.3552091122,
1.0551891327,
-0.46990031,
0.4479783475,
0.0415853485,
0.3404449821,
0.3805895746,
0.1304332018,
0.3310903907,
-0.769392848,
-0.2948735654,
-0.0533601604,
-0.3351433575,
-0.0235876311,
0.1906373799,
-0.6076834798,
-0.0944777429,
0.3592872918,
-0.3102152646,
0.0878800303,
0.513122499,
-0.7057635784,
0.2478546649,
-0.1068087593,
0.569298327,
-1.0307543278,
0.2887129486,
-0.5560994744,
-0.0888707414,
-0.4924209118,
0.2609916925,
0.0797378793,
-0.1752961576,
-0.5957496166,
0.7313953638,
-0.0864618495,
-0.1182267517,
-0.3266208172,
0.4345366359,
0.1281128228,
0.1199498475,
-0.2075781226,
0.8876381516,
0.0780992061,
-0.541138351,
0.4052552581,
0.4365539253,
-0.537026763,
0.6984444857,
-0.8474710584,
0.494019717,
-0.4260846376,
-0.2288401425,
-1.6370607615,
-0.4910112917,
-0.1105815545,
-0.8099954724,
0.0152206803,
-0.0768480077,
-0.6923300028,
-0.1026142463,
-0.0362799205,
0.2945850492,
0.2158711106,
-0.3653581142,
0.1909993142,
0.5357206464,
-0.2027400136,
-0.3862081766,
-0.1596893072,
-0.0254582707,
-0.0446270332,
-0.864354372,
0.0021050349,
-0.1384116262,
-0.5592107177,
0.2359360009,
-0.1924000829,
-0.501775682,
-0.0066621336,
-0.2658273578,
0.0968550816,
-0.5246477723,
0.276322633,
-0.2549630404,
0.0026760807,
0.1872176528,
0.0104854107,
0.8679634929,
0.0678544641,
-0.2984657884,
-0.5036690235,
0.6402180195,
0.8358482122,
-0.7590867877,
0.9011868238,
0.1883438379,
-0.1844099909,
0.3794749379,
-0.6178668141,
-0.5084374547,
-0.4554057419,
0.3725028932,
0.0313031599,
-1.1000249386,
0.9748725891,
0.3290394545,
0.1917266846,
0.6509657502,
0.4589983523,
-0.2583468258,
1.1239073277,
0.5392130017,
0.1896505952,
0.3185388744,
0.0389857292,
0.3925585747,
-0.3573260307,
-0.2763264775,
-1.000156641,
-0.2826813459,
-0.5894845128,
-0.2707141638,
0.3233731389,
-0.0151584176,
-0.6473361254,
0.1856004447,
-0.5129960775,
0.2629642487,
0.4855106771,
0.1940476,
0.0024405743,
-0.4401404262,
0.45455423,
-0.1177976727,
-0.4895240068,
-0.576910615,
0.7437908053,
0.2381049097,
0.5639907718,
0.1558074355,
0.4980799854,
-0.0560946651,
0.3826038837,
-0.6921499968,
0.5546697378,
0.0719433352,
-0.776864171,
-0.9576493502,
-0.700900197,
-0.9403445125,
0.3628080785,
-0.1804099679,
-0.5683459044,
0.1913909912,
-0.0960752219,
-0.5390902758,
0.1869944036,
-0.0572117642,
0.9854037166,
-0.2874938846,
-0.1751236916,
-0.1478369087,
-0.4816197753,
0.2162932903,
0.2271493524,
0.029896535,
-0.4415332377,
-0.1935085356,
0.9923398495,
-0.21960482,
0.3197622299,
-0.0741904378,
-0.0882503986,
0.6263949871,
-0.0328526609,
0.1318849772,
0.4746232629,
-0.2960607409,
-0.229038462,
0.6824730635,
-0.5253830552,
-0.9063008428,
0.6616715789,
-0.7851473689,
-0.68407619,
-0.1835271865,
-0.5215531588,
-0.0471113101,
0.0891686529,
0.1228154674,
0.5471966267,
-0.2779897451,
0.5574074388,
0.5658746362,
-0.2861795127,
0.2874869406,
0.6049278975,
-0.1288972646,
-0.4225062728,
0.2730918229,
0.3654747307,
0.3342584372,
0.613137424,
0.3714767396,
-0.7746119499,
-0.2305108458,
-0.2596756518,
0.3220848739,
-0.6635392904,
-0.2671984136,
-0.6303124428,
-0.1299785823,
-0.1566220671,
0.1950806379,
-0.4590073526,
-0.2738179266,
-0.2619436681,
0.1276591867,
0.2556145787,
0.3742341399,
0.1554997414,
0.2536376417,
-0.638605535,
0.208477512,
0.6602669954,
0.5261984468,
-0.3666666746,
-0.740854919,
0.0609482713,
0.2554831207,
-0.2384231836,
-1.2380832434,
0.1704643667,
0.2423530072,
0.3509026468,
0.0404804349,
0.414513886,
0.5589256287,
-0.254175663,
1.2899068594,
-0.0633663908,
-0.7421408296,
0.7985021472,
-0.2660221756,
0.3261031806,
0.8628608584,
0.1704942882,
-0.5335798264,
-0.7247915268,
-0.4777249396,
-0.8125804663,
0.2524998486,
0.0454864167,
0.7525869012,
-0.2392617464,
0.5635327697,
-0.1183004305,
0.2390801162,
-0.3120777607,
-0.0510669574,
0.0223014411,
0.3311879933,
-0.1454376876,
-0.4734205306,
-0.1932906359,
-0.2372464836,
0.4149599969,
-0.091019541,
0.1979503483,
0.1625947952,
0.2826288939,
-0.2736855745,
0.5432682037,
0.3302361071,
1.3444287777,
-0.2329733074,
-0.0030027123,
0.1160019934,
0.1199434474,
0.1958912611,
-0.3976293206,
0.1383127123,
0.4636359513,
0.1777173877,
0.2960357368,
-0.1208069026,
-0.4079247415,
0.6451715827,
-0.2204878479,
-0.242069751,
-0.2038646042,
0.0843546465,
0.0940520167,
-0.1020540297,
0.1656766385,
-0.4228252769,
0.0679916069,
-1.1305993795,
0.5247328281,
0.8227086663,
-0.5834849477,
-0.1444398016,
0.6007841229,
-0.033036571,
-0.6200433969,
0.7361639142,
0.0298392437,
-0.396251291,
0.651743114,
0.1383884549,
0.4248149097,
-0.3583498299,
0.2493688762,
0.6547952294,
0.3654751182,
0.2139708102,
0.5412265062,
0.3012354076,
-0.6069530249,
-0.7725991607,
-0.6369513869,
-0.689289391,
0.3788742721,
-0.8830841184,
-0.0500462987,
-0.2922835946,
-0.3691673577,
0.0561818965,
0.3810311854,
-0.7296786308,
0.2473183274,
-0.258248359,
0.9541267753,
-0.8990206718,
0.3029569387,
0.4529806972,
-0.202885285,
-0.7614526749,
0.0223504677,
-0.4284626842,
-0.4975006282,
0.4297936261,
-0.1245218888,
0.0151887927,
-0.2531521618,
-0.7520697117,
-0.8356437683,
0.7108543515,
0.6037940979,
-0.2148895264,
0.2341144234,
0.2872450352,
0.6963757873,
-0.0297290664,
0.4405977726,
0.7819958329,
0.4644882083,
-0.1384321302,
-0.911872685,
-0.2505148351,
-0.1398103088,
-0.103311263,
0.4414059222,
-0.4702849984,
0.7313264608,
0.2783692479,
-0.3700104654,
0.159113571,
0.9335893989,
-0.1496842802,
0.3724777699,
0.5441818833,
-0.0069937771,
0.8308207393,
-0.4276122153,
1.0855175257,
-0.6949647665,
0.4146968424,
0.6704011559,
-0.0572302267,
1.1014065742,
0.698251605,
-0.0731020048,
0.0202613398,
0.6028153896,
0.5390259027,
0.5258154869,
0.7375568151,
-0.1946419179,
-0.629275322,
-0.1911502481,
-0.1115322113,
0.6580572724,
0.3415527344,
0.0411051661,
-0.2620892525,
-0.1058662683,
-0.1446786672,
0.7311925888,
-0.2346155494,
1.0287078619,
-0.1181088835,
-1.0106118917,
0.4912798405,
-0.0335398652,
0.2163574398,
-0.3743433356,
-0.0696334764,
-0.5465730429,
-0.2637378573,
0.0923677757,
-1.3725099564,
0.5955916643,
-0.0660615861,
-0.166885674,
-0.015956521,
0.0761632696,
-0.4467170238,
-0.4032476544,
0.2094698548,
0.8105329871,
0.1533723623,
-0.0234293565,
-0.4300411642,
0.0171719585,
-0.5257086158,
-0.2524433732,
0.3107948899,
0.6143660545,
0.4388149977,
0.3524016142,
0.4965205193,
0.0232917927,
-0.0636672229,
-0.3237178028,
0.8945581913,
-0.0938867256,
-0.5155274868,
-0.7681575418,
0.576936245,
-0.3215274215,
-0.5531643033,
0.4015605748,
0.5376549959,
0.8729662299,
0.3761664927,
0.32754758,
-0.0093730204,
0.7825536728,
-0.4720442891,
0.8161384463,
-0.6825406551,
0.1225415096,
-0.0013251406,
-0.966193974,
-0.2314859629,
0.6309203506,
-0.4611421525,
-0.3246421516,
0.5406776667,
1.1960804462,
-0.3267259896,
-0.0872747526,
0.5425444841,
-0.0734363198,
0.4206291139,
0.1747615784,
1.1121407747,
-0.2787711024,
0.6177216172,
-0.122247465,
-0.1125534698,
0.0394027941,
-0.5621720552,
-0.6019435525,
-0.8630138636,
-0.3782743514,
-0.5741479397,
0.291790545,
0.7004557848,
0.6125898361,
-0.7923622727,
-0.4102991223,
0.4073258936,
-0.1500445306,
-0.0540697426,
-0.2219497412,
0.6767960191,
-0.5644356608,
-0.4659502506,
0.0603832379,
0.0669125468,
-0.5716302991,
-0.19105272,
0.2719134092,
-0.1027712375,
0.5953164697,
0.5832585096,
0.0376571007,
-0.8248189092,
-0.9900191426,
0.4987352192,
-0.2898443639,
0.1539195329,
0.8676126599,
-0.148187831,
0.5915850997,
0.7472515702,
0.773165822,
0.176112175,
0.310955137,
0.3760217726,
-0.6953787208,
-0.2078357935,
0.5898633003,
0.0350869857,
0.3137626648,
-0.1726303101,
0.27483657,
-0.3466280699,
-0.7610234022,
-0.7352780104,
0.2391750216,
-0.8981392384,
-0.1019533128,
1.1115065813,
-0.1518549174,
-0.0860699266,
-0.1115720645,
-0.3636983931,
0.1531795859,
-0.1933044344,
0.7958409786,
1.0148912668,
-0.0150594423,
-0.395437181,
-0.8717651963,
0.2217254043,
0.2152641714,
-0.6802580357,
0.1589767635,
0.2852218449,
0.2415195704,
0.1268483847,
0.8483783603,
-0.3863899112,
0.4611695409,
-0.2666273117,
-0.4494611621,
0.4399927855,
-0.1882727444,
-0.0851079375,
0.5332654715,
0.2752881944,
-0.3222889304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08806v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08806v1
|
CreativEval: Evaluating Creativity of LLM-Based Hardware Code Generation
| 2024-04-12T20:41:47 | 2024-04-12T20:41:47 |
Matthew DeLorenzo, Vasudev Gohil, Jeyavijayan Rajendran
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have proved effective and efficient in
generating code, leading to their utilization within the hardware design
process. Prior works evaluating LLMs' abilities for register transfer level
code generation solely focus on functional correctness. However, the creativity
associated with these LLMs, or the ability to generate novel and unique
solutions, is a metric not as well understood, in part due to the challenge of
quantifying this quality.
To address this research gap, we present CreativeEval, a framework for
evaluating the creativity of LLMs within the context of generating hardware
designs. We quantify four creative sub-components, fluency, flexibility,
originality, and elaboration, through various prompting and post-processing
techniques. We then evaluate multiple popular LLMs (including GPT models,
CodeLlama, and VeriGen) upon this creativity metric, with results indicating
GPT-3.5 as the most creative model in generating hardware designs.
|
[
-0.4553246498,
-0.7643780708,
0.692515254,
0.4167010188,
-0.5210250616,
0.426276803,
-0.1600887179,
-0.304749012,
-0.0359890945,
0.1379550397,
-0.6384881735,
-0.4222534299,
-0.2631946802,
0.0296634231,
-0.1633665413,
0.769269228,
-0.2682902813,
-0.3385764062,
-0.3087689579,
0.1354978085,
-0.6514078975,
-0.3166552186,
-0.0206792131,
-0.1385589689,
0.386110872,
0.2842569649,
0.3472212553,
0.2289608121,
0.7499825954,
0.3983990252,
-0.1519555151,
0.2273824215,
-0.4449129999,
0.3306959271,
-0.1933771521,
-0.4552966356,
-0.5630571842,
-0.0924674943,
0.3305442035,
0.2338886559,
-0.1188097596,
0.5058526397,
-0.0558888577,
0.5258496404,
-0.2310153395,
-0.0866672471,
-0.8524653912,
0.2458717376,
-0.4656066895,
-0.5328038931,
-0.2986354828,
-0.9472202659,
-0.4226489663,
-0.5954436064,
0.2388765216,
-0.2342977524,
0.3295092285,
0.3869321644,
0.0520347692,
-0.6623930931,
-0.9117666483,
0.6332624555,
-0.7289595008,
0.2286921889,
-0.2357444763,
0.4221896529,
-0.1792421639,
-0.9060059786,
-0.6942994595,
-0.0377717838,
0.7238230109,
0.0495870411,
-0.1745851487,
-0.1967336535,
0.3447732627,
0.7905681729,
-0.6512146592,
0.1227374077,
-0.2180868089,
0.1456259787,
0.6562803984,
0.2175278068,
0.3435981274,
0.0930463523,
-0.4257929325,
0.194016993,
-0.9299783707,
0.1159313396,
0.4822095037,
-0.0798959434,
0.1909133345,
0.6005962491,
-0.0648575276,
0.6191439033,
0.0105811395,
-0.4009134471,
0.3596278429,
-0.5053467155,
-0.2443044931,
-0.2561876178,
0.4800212681,
0.1736923605,
-0.022313619,
-0.20468162,
-0.7093763351,
0.0179082714,
0.4309982955,
-0.829018414,
-0.1675013006,
0.2411373705,
-0.5011057854,
-0.6234853864,
0.0168775078,
-0.2912233174,
-0.3588099778,
-0.3336352408,
0.4165973067,
-0.0798012763,
-0.3051509261,
0.134729892,
-0.3982195556,
0.0046615936,
0.1423559934,
-0.5798550844,
-0.2754037976,
0.7891908288,
0.494164139,
-0.3416962624,
0.0560627952,
-0.411224246,
-0.1948276907,
-0.5963160396,
0.7784461975,
-0.2487380654,
-0.42019099,
-0.2350542694,
-0.302223742,
0.415823251,
-0.6743887067,
0.3739047647,
-1.0027221441,
-0.1335391104,
-0.5382583141,
-0.5207808018,
0.0770566165,
0.0767663345,
-0.5334621668,
0.7204282284,
0.2254755795,
-0.4762013257,
0.6511846185,
-0.4379112124,
-0.4180210233,
0.7755494714,
-0.3921000957,
-0.2916047275,
0.7263559699,
-0.1341125071,
0.0999267623,
-0.4352436066,
0.391274035,
-0.3663049042,
-0.4166811407,
0.8201702833,
-0.5563951731,
0.6694719791,
0.5192794204,
-0.4307022393,
0.2128251195,
-0.8847103119,
0.289152801,
0.0817599222,
-0.4598097503,
0.0706385598,
-0.2249716222,
-0.0629988164,
0.382950753,
0.440077275,
-0.7688229084,
0.2742869258,
-0.2897850573,
0.4746796787,
0.7337424755,
0.1737405807,
0.0119310906,
-0.4954791367,
0.9286731482,
-0.4811572433,
0.03393659,
-0.0441042334,
-0.6632336974,
-0.4311359823,
-0.312220335,
0.0712154359,
0.5029245019,
-0.8907122016,
0.2145833671,
0.1492969543,
-0.7404071689,
-0.4414531291,
0.4770580232,
0.2183442861,
0.4095691442,
-0.0106094191,
-0.2714739144,
-0.4034269154,
-0.7190647125,
-0.2576010823,
-0.1173873618,
-0.1674682349,
0.2281263918,
0.1997537613,
-0.2555027008,
0.6822234988,
-0.1665791124,
0.1870332211,
-0.2608059347,
0.4771307111,
0.5190196037,
0.3467440009,
0.5595348477,
-0.3887237608,
-0.3133570552,
0.0617844574,
-0.7995054126,
-0.4989079833,
-0.2276872694,
0.0197341889,
0.2575467527,
0.1698659509,
-0.6801624894,
0.4727234244,
0.2379730046,
-0.0047776164,
0.7693339586,
-0.1063226759,
0.4181911945,
-0.8373958468,
0.1832147837,
-0.5007502437,
0.0555338152,
-0.2558895051,
0.3353935182,
-0.1543799341,
-0.0180562511,
-0.6126310229,
0.3940107822,
-0.4031612277,
-0.276769489,
-0.4573251009,
0.0956304967,
-0.048368793,
0.1346675605,
-0.1730989218,
1.0231668949,
0.3499375582,
-0.3590072989,
0.8276381493,
-0.1488152891,
-0.6079084873,
0.4963913262,
-0.96483922,
0.418335557,
0.1104005352,
-0.3105815649,
-1.2193604708,
-0.1293694675,
-0.4850204289,
-0.3937783241,
0.1832814217,
0.1310776025,
-0.711622715,
-0.7665494084,
-0.0937007442,
0.6919999719,
0.7794390321,
-0.4707591832,
0.1964241266,
0.4206590056,
-0.4593143463,
-0.1216076091,
-0.971157968,
0.0542120598,
-0.3324145377,
-0.9372867942,
0.6911169887,
-0.5837954879,
-0.2945543528,
-0.0164287146,
0.0176390484,
0.1373333335,
0.1652453095,
0.0743404478,
0.2908163071,
-0.5017515421,
-0.0323164873,
-0.1081078798,
0.0094666574,
0.1147919968,
-0.3493250012,
0.4090717137,
-0.6043783426,
-0.526045084,
-0.2656743824,
0.1473410577,
0.526244998,
-0.2121276855,
0.2138091773,
0.5999706984,
-0.1668022573,
-0.7297705412,
-0.5422794223,
0.2489228547,
-0.6183558106,
0.2426719069,
-0.4996751845,
-0.9385511279,
0.7612918019,
0.1358200163,
0.2373209,
0.2803689241,
1.0699173212,
0.1235797256,
0.8496698141,
0.5384591818,
0.4760861993,
0.255725503,
-0.0743096992,
0.4396046102,
-0.5817955732,
-0.3638675511,
-0.1327993274,
-0.4602812231,
-0.5748007894,
-0.5040768981,
0.1891687512,
0.0778921545,
-0.2005859613,
0.1506338269,
-0.7175738215,
0.6477259398,
0.4317390323,
-0.3056470156,
0.2130506039,
0.1731860638,
-0.4032084942,
-0.1507583857,
-0.7792106271,
-0.5095815063,
0.8161716461,
0.4537130892,
0.9098951817,
0.2914378941,
0.7805302143,
0.238436684,
0.505971849,
-0.7768009901,
0.5302345753,
-0.1544500887,
-0.2874388993,
0.0070710466,
-0.5824425817,
-0.5734614134,
-0.3570980728,
0.2418813705,
-0.4345427454,
0.0966427848,
-0.0053838077,
-0.6896449327,
0.4072544873,
-0.3348450065,
0.5711405873,
-0.6066756248,
-0.6270199418,
-0.1564141214,
-0.0008859753,
0.6341745257,
-0.3885243833,
0.1601289511,
0.1044611707,
-0.0450150333,
0.5264964104,
-0.4123658538,
0.4120666385,
0.0204650704,
-0.3385060132,
0.7379209995,
0.403655231,
0.0628811121,
0.1373885274,
-0.2652860582,
-0.2705214024,
-0.2420196831,
-0.0236821864,
-0.5642493963,
0.9245508909,
-0.5654430985,
-0.5211476684,
-0.0220928788,
-0.6803474426,
-0.2571971714,
0.3074306548,
0.4698174,
0.5332057476,
-0.2578276992,
0.3701322675,
0.6111491919,
-0.5740823746,
0.58238554,
0.256816268,
-0.2258723527,
-0.6514568925,
1.1026984453,
0.1175848469,
0.1057075858,
-0.0702326819,
0.0859062374,
-0.4715884626,
-0.591322422,
-0.557700336,
-0.0097190831,
-0.7339476347,
-0.3313418627,
0.0208501723,
-0.5131647587,
-0.1966214925,
-0.4528050721,
-0.4193855226,
-0.655039072,
-0.4392612576,
-0.0034562885,
0.2319640815,
1.092530489,
-0.0372312777,
-0.004617746,
-0.6869551539,
0.3056593835,
0.600564003,
0.5599192381,
0.1041876152,
-0.6912028193,
0.0655245408,
-0.1995108575,
-0.6463627219,
-0.8270888329,
0.4701760113,
-0.0277294908,
0.8463588357,
0.1832634062,
-0.1887149662,
0.5506920815,
-0.2009793818,
0.9778818488,
0.3445608318,
-0.8566027284,
0.695507586,
-0.2649743557,
0.4237164259,
0.3309094012,
0.0467297435,
-0.0446147025,
-0.1008626521,
-0.748462081,
-0.6183297634,
0.0563527942,
0.1438839436,
0.0044057015,
-0.1255353987,
0.1956672519,
0.1940408349,
0.4821510017,
-0.5963807106,
0.3246401846,
-0.1666735709,
-0.2944606245,
0.5395466685,
-0.0833298862,
-0.0242331661,
-0.0773085803,
0.4458399415,
0.1009147242,
0.3473041356,
0.0512495637,
0.0531677455,
-0.1339456737,
0.3462761641,
0.8208632469,
0.7979364991,
0.1005109027,
0.2365451604,
-0.0106472261,
-0.1292740107,
0.232736215,
-0.133190006,
-0.0401471891,
-0.121817641,
0.2078557312,
0.6592284441,
-0.2218929082,
-0.6588489413,
0.5244860649,
-0.2248594612,
-0.2206138372,
-0.1209585965,
0.3420562744,
0.1724051535,
0.3515217006,
0.2352569848,
0.2388085425,
0.1150691956,
-0.3952647448,
0.3696555197,
0.5540277958,
-0.0441047028,
-0.5164115429,
0.7361998558,
0.1026259959,
-0.6492423415,
0.5997475982,
-0.7183846831,
-0.3965013623,
0.7917440534,
0.8296259046,
1.1697188616,
0.003701987,
0.0986368209,
0.2193822861,
0.3241100311,
0.303213805,
0.8256186247,
-0.0928212851,
-0.4286157787,
-0.5998310447,
-0.8516134024,
-0.0986708701,
0.2027976066,
-0.3215910196,
0.2539311051,
-0.5753923655,
-0.5496430397,
-0.1654595733,
-0.1194692925,
-0.9025079012,
-0.0721603483,
0.2963736355,
0.800607264,
-0.4846934974,
0.5934227109,
0.6456129551,
-0.3736260831,
-0.7616037726,
-0.5828782916,
0.054375235,
-0.7901420593,
0.7054761648,
-0.1398241818,
-0.1197661459,
-0.1375302225,
-0.4894467592,
-0.6722461581,
0.946197629,
0.223055467,
-0.5330293775,
0.227404952,
0.3316859305,
0.6013386846,
-0.5828694701,
-0.0100955004,
0.3598293662,
0.1344288439,
0.5244796276,
-0.6916496754,
-0.0837097019,
-0.6650847793,
0.2437891215,
-0.1203917712,
-0.3804729283,
0.6705029607,
-0.5092702508,
-0.1266360581,
0.3950446546,
0.5135568976,
0.969424367,
0.2603870928,
0.0480789095,
0.5752317309,
1.0034977198,
-0.0220937096,
0.8295946717,
-0.4859446585,
-0.0463524684,
0.8112140298,
-0.2157880068,
0.8004751801,
0.2794278562,
0.0811086223,
0.4503054023,
0.5268032551,
-0.1932381839,
0.489493072,
0.4909290075,
-0.3168680966,
-0.1851792783,
0.0971467495,
-0.4348859787,
0.1228689104,
0.3868402243,
-0.3629937172,
0.103435725,
0.1288477629,
-0.3680515587,
-0.2215622514,
-0.1918341219,
0.6647318602,
0.192426011,
-0.7162731886,
0.7365798354,
-0.0939056799,
0.4580356181,
-0.1427231878,
-0.0025574993,
-0.3328793943,
0.266359657,
-0.2100607008,
-1.2203727961,
0.5177230835,
0.3023355007,
-0.116326198,
-0.3851534724,
0.6845294237,
-0.2033665925,
-0.6571573615,
-0.3603809178,
0.3192393184,
0.2041847408,
0.2156290263,
-0.5538697839,
0.445821017,
0.0456673279,
-0.0465900823,
-0.0122431526,
0.9614272118,
0.1995528042,
0.5176802874,
0.7084975243,
0.400762856,
0.1964406967,
0.1914649904,
0.8055167198,
-0.5706085563,
-0.5274963975,
-0.6030435562,
0.6934967637,
0.153895691,
-0.78114748,
0.914192915,
0.5249869227,
0.568721354,
-0.2508825362,
0.8499757051,
0.0988399163,
-0.0133074736,
-0.3600029945,
0.5042288899,
-0.5484811068,
0.7998057008,
-0.4168959558,
-0.9737091064,
-0.2426943183,
0.6572304964,
-0.269487232,
0.0781090036,
0.3004542589,
0.8662207127,
-0.0957268551,
0.2747125924,
0.2040289938,
0.0851466358,
0.4623511136,
0.6805577874,
1.3792772293,
-0.1223008931,
0.115125522,
-0.0180964228,
-0.5732328892,
-0.0453537554,
-1.1921648979,
-0.5405935049,
-0.3292057216,
-0.4349519312,
-0.1778299809,
-0.371776998,
0.5483297706,
0.6053340435,
-0.5254666805,
-0.221349448,
-0.5769779086,
0.0084368242,
-0.0378583074,
-0.2062902302,
0.0042390698,
-0.5451865196,
-0.0553835146,
0.5687069893,
0.4051099718,
0.107419759,
-0.4986453652,
-0.0127494223,
0.7357215881,
0.4011253715,
1.0086427927,
0.2116566747,
-0.7834735513,
0.2233864665,
0.5020887256,
-0.098585099,
-0.2134794593,
0.8309346437,
-0.668748498,
0.4977637529,
1.1550312042,
0.8132891059,
0.3048238158,
0.0284815878,
0.4271682799,
-0.497304976,
-0.1387702972,
0.4964887202,
0.061182484,
0.385235399,
-0.1925124079,
0.0877461582,
0.3928343058,
-1.0630546808,
-0.7554824352,
0.1642989814,
-0.8493387103,
-0.350585252,
1.1486486197,
0.0339203849,
-0.2911213934,
0.1656567007,
-0.0783182159,
-0.0820492655,
0.0914800018,
0.7244071364,
0.508156538,
-0.4250492752,
-0.0236884616,
-0.5247308612,
0.4921976924,
0.1538631916,
-0.6213797331,
-0.0003061618,
0.3573586047,
0.3443135023,
0.2467626184,
0.6145350933,
-0.2638056278,
0.5348786116,
0.1756563336,
0.1254309267,
-0.214630425,
-0.4092442393,
-0.1296297312,
0.5232328773,
0.5158340335,
0.1456499994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08801v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08801v2
|
Megalodon: Efficient LLM Pretraining and Inference with Unlimited Context Length
| 2024-04-12T20:28:14 | 2024-04-16T07:27:58 |
Xuezhe Ma, Xiaomeng Yang, Wenhan Xiong, Beidi Chen, Lili Yu, Hao Zhang, Jonathan May, Luke Zettlemoyer, Omer Levy, Chunting Zhou
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
The quadratic complexity and weak length extrapolation of Transformers limits
their ability to scale to long sequences, and while sub-quadratic solutions
like linear attention and state space models exist, they empirically
underperform Transformers in pretraining efficiency and downstream task
accuracy. We introduce Megalodon, a neural architecture for efficient sequence
modeling with unlimited context length. Megalodon inherits the architecture of
Mega (exponential moving average with gated attention), and further introduces
multiple technical components to improve its capability and stability,
including complex exponential moving average (CEMA), timestep normalization
layer, normalized attention mechanism and pre-norm with two-hop residual
configuration. In a controlled head-to-head comparison with Llama2, Megalodon
achieves better efficiency than Transformer in the scale of 7 billion
parameters and 2 trillion training tokens. Megalodon reaches a training loss of
1.70, landing mid-way between Llama2-7B (1.75) and 13B (1.67). Code:
https://github.com/XuezheMax/megalodon
|
[
-0.4464759529,
-0.2885893881,
0.6005917788,
0.4198326468,
-0.3419944346,
-0.165308252,
-0.1383532882,
-0.4064755738,
0.315541178,
0.3676376343,
-0.5501361489,
-0.1177593991,
-0.6989864707,
0.0271156263,
-0.4082031846,
0.9528155327,
0.465613842,
0.0731782392,
-0.1087522954,
-0.2398150116,
-0.1667631865,
-0.4691911042,
-0.5446440578,
-0.4449115098,
1.0343718529,
0.2493721396,
0.7055814266,
0.9367983341,
0.3421061337,
0.3566044569,
-0.1994959712,
0.2129265964,
-0.4895707965,
-0.2061986327,
-0.1857230812,
-0.4532243311,
-0.8713795543,
-0.2006760836,
0.5272041559,
0.7906216383,
0.057014212,
0.3364016116,
-0.0749704093,
0.5680595636,
-0.7276419401,
-0.0070348196,
-0.4977874458,
0.2300946414,
0.0714199841,
-0.1899435818,
-0.4299711287,
-0.303509146,
0.4539280534,
-0.6084159613,
-0.0735667869,
0.0134361191,
0.4535237551,
0.6961761713,
-0.5502766371,
-0.3270520866,
-0.6489996314,
0.7248712182,
-0.5346902013,
0.5427658558,
-0.0376911685,
0.1225111634,
0.1774953902,
-1.0408449173,
-0.5736524463,
-0.1802880913,
0.0405172221,
0.2369036824,
-0.1164359674,
0.2931598127,
0.5754310489,
0.099708721,
-0.4646975696,
0.3252548873,
-0.3009439111,
-0.0956668556,
0.4233552814,
0.1874649376,
-0.2855627537,
-0.1711799651,
-0.5646808147,
-0.0763490275,
-0.7388353944,
-0.1360670775,
0.5167179108,
-0.2686304748,
0.1415911019,
0.238079533,
-0.0246847831,
0.5745152831,
-0.0170150585,
-0.2274421602,
0.1971095204,
0.0663549379,
-0.3226352632,
0.0708902925,
0.6780108809,
0.1893105209,
0.1944805235,
-0.1783606857,
-0.0690040439,
-0.2581519186,
0.4545779526,
-0.818038702,
-0.1197119281,
0.2611057758,
-0.1923697591,
0.1118289232,
-0.1685845554,
-0.9818087816,
-0.2235873044,
-0.4566401839,
0.6743083,
-0.3387051523,
0.1373183876,
0.0706637874,
0.2434565574,
0.333088249,
0.1148790866,
-1.1274311543,
0.09193746,
0.6444178224,
0.8571848869,
-0.1299340278,
-0.4777888656,
-0.3607197404,
0.0588179976,
-0.3748589456,
0.6819143295,
-0.0361831672,
-0.3423547447,
-0.273625493,
-0.1796817034,
-0.1610885262,
-0.6691111922,
0.3308205009,
-0.7995828986,
-0.2734636664,
0.283945173,
-0.2956265211,
-0.3946664333,
0.058223173,
-0.7064861059,
0.6293048859,
0.1467626095,
-0.3374685049,
0.1928825378,
-0.7342464328,
-0.4568420947,
-0.0770739168,
0.085489586,
-0.2307111174,
0.1901163012,
0.1489223689,
0.3882324994,
-0.4114939868,
0.1697927415,
-0.2110696733,
-0.4650259018,
0.0242259186,
-0.4137918055,
0.5731277466,
0.1264370382,
-0.5058220029,
0.3484649062,
-0.6400909424,
0.1586239189,
-0.088910915,
-0.3438116908,
-0.0265969969,
-0.0442736745,
-0.207265377,
0.2009217292,
0.2263604701,
-0.1880145967,
0.2870170176,
-0.47500664,
0.6404903531,
0.8562108278,
-0.3655338883,
0.4961938858,
-0.1533261091,
0.4425879419,
0.0105520608,
0.4109592736,
-0.3189654052,
-0.1346887797,
-0.9327734113,
-0.4160798192,
0.6695355177,
0.599075377,
-0.6265664101,
0.6632258296,
-0.7581069469,
-0.3780100644,
-0.1402220726,
0.2033097595,
0.375200063,
0.3128447533,
0.4168297946,
-0.2285218835,
-0.754491806,
-0.9776690006,
0.3064901829,
0.3282985985,
-0.2684170604,
0.3337495327,
0.6047203541,
-0.5832967758,
0.7043002248,
-0.3562078178,
-0.0590306669,
-0.3795687258,
-0.05606452,
0.5546956062,
0.3415605426,
0.3887218535,
-0.7379241586,
-0.1879746616,
-0.12484321,
-0.6148029566,
0.004160725,
-0.226796627,
-0.1026226729,
-0.1080003977,
0.2836155891,
-0.9734633565,
0.237100929,
0.7155460119,
0.1203689799,
0.4397737384,
-0.1612218022,
-0.3152681291,
-1.1188004017,
0.1773937047,
-0.2868264019,
-0.0352861322,
-0.6574682593,
-0.0435687117,
0.3595190346,
-0.0290289205,
-0.5410358906,
0.3401542008,
-0.1837888062,
-0.4919491112,
-0.3280914426,
0.1350812763,
-0.1570099145,
0.7730987668,
-0.2190608829,
0.8225291967,
0.3379044831,
-0.7546024919,
0.5036274195,
0.1384685636,
-0.4109174311,
0.1485716403,
-0.8417716026,
0.3658305109,
-0.0329092443,
0.5481238961,
-0.6858005524,
-0.2914711535,
-0.0972573236,
-0.394241631,
0.3264665604,
0.0145415077,
-0.4534335434,
-0.6272097826,
-0.3506639898,
0.6655138731,
0.6114302874,
-0.845676899,
0.8675866723,
0.1082747579,
0.0844145939,
-0.9397534728,
-0.4842143655,
0.0278629456,
-0.2368502468,
-0.4390678704,
0.2944088876,
-0.1434929967,
0.1339845955,
-0.2585942447,
-0.3396139145,
-0.0356124938,
-0.0090103988,
0.4789983034,
0.3059423864,
-0.1973819733,
0.1298892945,
-0.0291515738,
-0.3414759338,
0.2249704599,
-0.6512504816,
0.9085450768,
0.0466038212,
-0.1709222049,
-0.4556401968,
0.2250795811,
0.9401637912,
0.021093823,
0.4010839462,
0.4479596913,
-0.1289883852,
-0.4803012609,
-0.3901124001,
-0.1105127111,
-0.4994846582,
0.6215925813,
-0.2140126377,
-0.7306398153,
0.3438353837,
-0.3564731479,
-0.0975037068,
0.4308826327,
0.6147304177,
0.0940274298,
1.0940239429,
0.5994197726,
-0.266492188,
0.3322615623,
-0.7108129859,
0.3402019143,
-1.202193141,
-0.3003003597,
-0.0686515346,
-0.70672369,
-0.3257508278,
-0.4002554417,
0.3688012958,
0.1849634051,
-0.376691699,
0.5294442177,
-0.2261587977,
0.5900893807,
0.6893952489,
0.2655985653,
-0.0689127669,
-0.2775379717,
-0.1048915684,
0.1718784422,
-0.9467270374,
-0.3824681342,
1.253860116,
0.2728136778,
0.6955311298,
0.0419986658,
0.3408300281,
0.2112180442,
0.5093801022,
-1.1345553398,
0.729165554,
0.0271665566,
-0.576551497,
-0.275831908,
-0.463357389,
-0.8074140549,
0.2162462771,
-0.0134018539,
-0.6894800067,
0.0585409328,
0.3753563762,
-0.8518317342,
0.4279404879,
-0.6162237525,
0.6397336721,
-0.4537111223,
-0.4036382437,
-0.3438718319,
-0.7316389084,
0.3706121743,
-0.4717326164,
-0.2074899226,
0.033097107,
-0.4129083157,
0.5769194961,
-0.3134342134,
0.5730742812,
0.0736610964,
0.1287488788,
0.1870904714,
-0.2483283579,
0.3486459553,
0.2480014563,
-0.0429242663,
0.3641320169,
-0.4605051577,
-0.4689257741,
-0.7790820599,
0.6573744416,
-0.842197001,
-0.6271587014,
-0.1651183069,
-0.9650779963,
-0.2994478047,
0.1875587702,
0.4360353053,
0.4925311506,
0.2821979225,
0.5559344292,
0.922459662,
-0.2231738418,
0.745241046,
0.0609682426,
0.0606206097,
-0.6825373769,
0.4844674766,
0.192249164,
0.1837093532,
0.3850221932,
0.0447493456,
-0.484834224,
-0.641248703,
-0.5501980186,
0.0964653865,
-0.7706696987,
-0.3478592038,
-0.7784509063,
-0.3463662863,
-0.2925049365,
-0.0833604857,
-0.3606669009,
-0.2150028497,
-0.0661144108,
-0.1747670025,
-0.0827325955,
0.6500372887,
-0.2041949481,
0.5645715594,
-0.7666963935,
0.3161390424,
0.8502089977,
0.1503489017,
0.3542292118,
-0.7838767171,
-0.3745502532,
-0.2203066051,
-0.3156481087,
-0.4761819839,
0.3620463014,
0.1591449082,
0.4625233114,
0.5730837584,
-0.3127835095,
0.833183825,
-0.7675454021,
0.6038284898,
0.3579407036,
-0.9274167418,
0.2346661687,
-0.1076973081,
0.417355746,
0.1395044923,
0.7817915678,
-0.0764201134,
0.3832963705,
-0.5543570518,
-1.1190723181,
0.5289070606,
-0.0681156591,
0.3602447212,
-0.0533199385,
0.4162597954,
-0.0937781706,
0.1865370572,
-0.6974685192,
-0.0328665078,
-0.2232290804,
-0.1894636303,
-0.317638129,
-0.4889223576,
-0.2066486478,
-0.5003975034,
0.4349645376,
-0.2315024585,
0.4756632745,
0.2836701572,
-0.3569661379,
0.3330379426,
-0.0158080012,
0.9825939536,
0.875457406,
0.0647452101,
0.3307777047,
0.8791182041,
-0.5610666275,
0.3264473379,
0.0575742945,
0.1633045673,
-0.193317607,
0.5875221491,
0.7275748849,
0.4854897559,
-0.7705392241,
0.3767579198,
0.2377205491,
-0.3153915107,
-0.3786574304,
0.2373835146,
0.2386521548,
0.5667004585,
0.5079658031,
0.0318417922,
-0.0098546958,
-0.3842281401,
0.1662336588,
-0.0329826809,
-0.2494985014,
-0.3388410807,
0.8298167586,
0.1341797262,
-0.3241652548,
0.5465480685,
0.0062509631,
-0.5172946453,
0.966216445,
0.5003350377,
0.7427960038,
-0.2323921919,
-0.3313253224,
0.3447185755,
0.1932767779,
-0.0609557517,
-0.1371970773,
-0.2608930171,
-0.4573289752,
-0.7835142612,
-0.7369374633,
-0.3608195782,
0.2735924125,
-0.449069947,
-0.1600740105,
-0.851696372,
-0.2722901106,
0.128871426,
-0.1704994291,
-0.4938744605,
0.2721837759,
0.3664109111,
0.970946312,
-0.306984514,
1.0701131821,
0.4895362258,
0.1268356293,
-0.8406199217,
-0.0395242199,
-0.0041626729,
-0.7339445949,
0.976883769,
0.5894757509,
-0.2915588319,
0.370105356,
-0.4364944696,
-0.9296997786,
1.4573552608,
0.3314070106,
-0.7760378122,
-0.1080996618,
0.1678687185,
0.4232866168,
-0.354169786,
0.3371707797,
0.6978465319,
0.23539038,
0.0858582184,
-0.6104912162,
-0.2771548629,
-0.0272185393,
0.2534930706,
0.3648732901,
-0.8385335207,
0.8128020167,
-0.4480552077,
0.1144158021,
0.3937706947,
0.6393054724,
0.0955858007,
0.1629859656,
0.7446801662,
0.9644345045,
0.4239959717,
-0.1622096747,
1.074840188,
-0.4674093723,
0.3793119192,
1.0830562115,
-0.277390331,
0.4986738861,
0.2108276784,
-0.0460604466,
0.3848789632,
0.6269905567,
0.0382518247,
0.4640036225,
0.2372139096,
-0.4183761477,
-0.1729435176,
0.0535873473,
-0.1930973083,
0.4687021375,
0.3644725382,
-0.5422046185,
0.0305332076,
0.084298268,
-0.0679368675,
-0.473795414,
-0.5191855431,
0.5700064301,
0.0872092322,
-0.6597899795,
0.5024495125,
-0.4461994767,
0.6130717993,
-0.8152526021,
0.1316629052,
-0.4315588474,
0.398832649,
-0.2056611925,
-0.3658839762,
0.0699976012,
-0.2489098758,
-0.2475641221,
-0.0962844044,
0.3404408991,
0.0373489,
0.0226008799,
0.5648959875,
0.1308564395,
-0.0369180366,
-0.0511245877,
-0.4469988942,
-0.0628583133,
-0.2140817493,
-0.5600416064,
0.2656641006,
0.2832151651,
0.2179899663,
0.8043782711,
0.6837483048,
-0.0816418529,
0.3465416729,
0.0108745638,
0.8006650209,
-0.7239301801,
-0.2967039049,
-0.8419674039,
0.3006935716,
-0.1457786411,
-0.5223538876,
0.6016539335,
0.4207268655,
0.8708389401,
-0.1714959592,
0.2677897513,
-0.1074160784,
0.0276353322,
-0.5243163109,
0.4304071665,
-0.3732086718,
0.0888360888,
0.287861079,
-1.2984509468,
-0.3895402551,
0.4195548594,
-0.3918361068,
0.1208161116,
0.7737147212,
0.6740202904,
-0.2125556618,
-0.1835881919,
0.6510458589,
0.3248117566,
0.0110073416,
1.0281671286,
0.8478598595,
-0.2590220273,
0.8334637284,
-0.2612562776,
-0.156417191,
-0.3305684924,
-0.700450778,
-0.7855983973,
-0.1311792284,
0.2190427482,
-0.0028769011,
0.0090099256,
0.9307319522,
1.2351596355,
-0.5802385211,
-0.1214996576,
0.0910443738,
-0.0192134622,
-0.0610407032,
-0.1235514283,
0.2546678782,
-0.3967423737,
-0.8632912636,
0.4216566682,
0.4976602495,
-0.0856419653,
-0.3546297848,
-0.0944310874,
-0.1433886439,
0.1136085242,
1.0159716606,
0.269377321,
-0.5279586911,
-0.495701164,
-0.1116656885,
-0.1673042923,
0.1320866048,
0.842086494,
-0.6644240022,
0.1673922688,
0.3288309872,
0.8701446652,
0.5219367743,
0.005350342,
0.3265925646,
-0.4646296501,
0.4856885076,
0.4086015522,
0.441596061,
0.0071466044,
-0.1368707716,
0.7604672909,
0.2552199364,
-0.88063097,
-0.3953823149,
0.2847112417,
-0.9846665263,
-0.2412366271,
0.9241000414,
-0.2404721975,
-0.46533373,
0.2033555955,
-0.0370784439,
0.2563381493,
0.0846531987,
0.73132056,
0.3091231287,
-0.1937544048,
-0.1637405008,
-0.9094871879,
0.1891032308,
0.6263567209,
-0.7690526247,
-0.3355623186,
0.2684826553,
0.1956218779,
0.4988757968,
0.1252215207,
0.0971128866,
0.5313948989,
0.0414520465,
0.0189917907,
-0.1077693924,
-0.8492766619,
-0.4380915463,
0.2127571702,
-0.3446739614,
-0.1618530899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08793v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08793v1
|
JailbreakLens: Visual Analysis of Jailbreak Attacks Against Large Language Models
| 2024-04-12T19:54:42 | 2024-04-12T19:54:42 |
Yingchaojie Feng, Zhizhang Chen, Zhining Kang, Sijia Wang, Minfeng Zhu, Wei Zhang, Wei Chen
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
The proliferation of large language models (LLMs) has underscored concerns
regarding their security vulnerabilities, notably against jailbreak attacks,
where adversaries design jailbreak prompts to circumvent safety mechanisms for
potential misuse. Addressing these concerns necessitates a comprehensive
analysis of jailbreak prompts to evaluate LLMs' defensive capabilities and
identify potential weaknesses. However, the complexity of evaluating jailbreak
performance and understanding prompt characteristics makes this analysis
laborious. We collaborate with domain experts to characterize problems and
propose an LLM-assisted framework to streamline the analysis process. It
provides automatic jailbreak assessment to facilitate performance evaluation
and support analysis of components and keywords in prompts. Based on the
framework, we design JailbreakLens, a visual analysis system that enables users
to explore the jailbreak performance against the target model, conduct
multi-level analysis of prompt characteristics, and refine prompt instances to
verify findings. Through a case study, technical evaluations, and expert
interviews, we demonstrate our system's effectiveness in helping users evaluate
model security and identify model weaknesses.
|
[
-0.3455619514,
-1.0842456818,
0.6386088729,
0.522988081,
-0.1972060055,
0.3036203682,
-0.154680416,
-0.4591557086,
0.2326800972,
0.726578474,
-0.6461775899,
-0.5930283666,
-0.6397340894,
0.1805625558,
-0.4775559902,
0.5798465014,
-0.0696137547,
-0.0033021886,
-0.2514861822,
0.0453689545,
-0.9688996673,
-0.3467561901,
-0.4962455928,
0.4048066139,
0.3867643476,
0.4776149988,
0.4892491996,
0.3405423164,
0.6718539596,
0.429417938,
-0.1715055853,
-0.2408321798,
-0.3759997785,
0.5625382662,
-0.0512941368,
-0.2646835148,
-0.413934797,
-0.1459050626,
0.2057443112,
0.3194047511,
0.1075451598,
0.3123417199,
-0.2029372007,
0.680367291,
-0.6335786581,
-0.0564726591,
-0.620806694,
0.0624929555,
-0.4911938608,
0.1743309796,
-0.4379841983,
-0.3216329813,
0.0344056264,
-0.1905240566,
0.0157964025,
0.2903555334,
0.4432235956,
0.2240857631,
-0.1066830903,
-0.1442930698,
-0.1845975369,
0.4937978983,
-0.7940776348,
0.1941250265,
0.1355294138,
0.5953306556,
-0.2830978334,
-0.3995546997,
-0.1874603778,
-0.7805115581,
0.0907571539,
-0.3821136057,
-0.5484604836,
0.1024522856,
0.5067576766,
0.1012634858,
-0.8356853127,
0.3800302148,
-0.4523100257,
-0.2899403274,
0.6529755592,
0.4333419502,
0.7697668076,
-0.2790216506,
-0.473448813,
0.1242863759,
-0.7607503533,
0.0063611432,
0.3848031759,
0.3677605987,
-0.3010155857,
0.6427104473,
-0.0633589849,
1.0129301548,
-0.2615681291,
-0.1825869679,
0.1125737429,
-0.1259307116,
-0.2338044196,
-0.0607825629,
0.9531321526,
0.5225394964,
0.3620249927,
-0.1965522617,
-0.2997036278,
-0.2206981182,
0.2121732831,
-1.0452276468,
-0.235956654,
0.3417537212,
-0.5578505993,
-0.5401570201,
-0.0042602029,
-1.193415761,
-1.1664862633,
0.0181352552,
0.0487537272,
-0.4164314866,
-0.1026850343,
-0.202582866,
-0.2799686193,
-0.0969634652,
0.3030715287,
-0.6875420213,
0.2986216247,
0.4456880093,
1.0231109858,
-0.2442491353,
-0.2541193664,
-0.6624059677,
-0.0373707376,
-0.0674021989,
0.8627502322,
-0.5027807951,
-0.5598872304,
-0.1351360232,
-0.1377781183,
-0.1249754205,
-0.6434921026,
0.22605066,
-0.5395753384,
-0.5294832587,
-0.2059215307,
-0.6572403312,
0.0597024933,
0.3918572962,
-1.0580378771,
0.4514080584,
-0.1025456712,
-0.8912522197,
0.077775605,
-0.5133565664,
-0.2648813128,
0.2597491443,
-0.2699266672,
-0.3295932412,
0.3127800822,
0.371922642,
0.4870156646,
-0.1992934942,
0.2232728004,
-0.5545161366,
-0.2886560559,
0.3138400316,
-0.2414279133,
0.920401752,
0.3726003468,
-0.3064646721,
0.5563642979,
-0.846970439,
-0.2195524275,
0.4427290857,
0.0156201534,
-0.3962127864,
0.0903309435,
0.0834256634,
-0.1618325114,
0.4355332255,
-0.4245277345,
0.4644920528,
-0.2368305176,
0.5019929409,
0.7781306505,
0.0258673672,
0.1850134581,
0.3211769462,
0.9451620579,
-0.1631344259,
0.4222293794,
-0.4275543392,
-0.3609820902,
-0.3374711275,
-0.410243392,
0.1778067201,
0.8193760514,
-0.4766694605,
0.1582888216,
0.0910385996,
-0.6357405782,
-0.166871205,
0.4912369549,
0.4258788824,
0.441811651,
0.2204362601,
-0.16694884,
-0.6931267977,
-0.9704003334,
-0.5650510788,
-0.2463013083,
0.177584216,
0.1418105513,
0.5010784864,
-0.2616820335,
0.8878805041,
-0.4408791065,
0.0071634981,
-0.5694235563,
-0.078943707,
0.0015365453,
0.3622738123,
0.9103562236,
-0.4519566298,
-0.2377963513,
-0.2979083061,
-0.8584054708,
-0.5974605083,
-0.0237365738,
0.1660156846,
-0.069294773,
0.9291892648,
-0.4845194817,
0.5243570209,
0.5040762424,
-0.8575087786,
1.0276994705,
0.0994179919,
-0.0177452825,
-0.6254057288,
-0.005228017,
0.1687451005,
-0.1614925563,
-0.5715455413,
0.2340150326,
0.1374645531,
-0.3873796463,
-0.4785874188,
0.7378076315,
-0.4620099068,
-0.1975126565,
-0.0830515325,
0.2023932189,
-0.0611529648,
-0.0503806286,
-0.3958928287,
0.8912561536,
0.4990332127,
0.0176728368,
0.8121805787,
0.0194044467,
-0.5219077468,
0.3108796179,
-0.8074985743,
-0.0030875765,
0.1155847982,
-0.2510704398,
-1.1092377901,
-0.3491795063,
0.2610086799,
-0.2591493726,
0.2748803198,
-0.3250475824,
-0.536247611,
-0.4225890338,
-0.4385208786,
0.1805045903,
0.1558407247,
-0.4888702333,
0.4623319209,
0.2832668424,
-0.4349312782,
-0.4612297714,
-0.3820039034,
0.5261135101,
-0.489649564,
-1.0305559635,
-0.0202251561,
0.0143161723,
-0.8700511456,
-0.1297195554,
0.1649964154,
-0.0305194743,
0.5592139363,
0.5031274557,
0.5930461884,
0.0492847078,
-0.2834338546,
-0.0693218037,
0.0397342704,
0.3216986954,
0.0470477603,
0.4460619092,
-0.2765753269,
-0.220114544,
-0.4575813711,
0.2840947807,
0.9021581411,
-0.3856074512,
0.6770467758,
0.1218717098,
-0.0198281147,
-0.2392700315,
-0.6564487219,
0.1712723821,
-0.4883872271,
0.3874485493,
-0.4276309013,
-0.9948211908,
0.7470918894,
-0.1108242497,
-0.2177240252,
0.0581820495,
0.425299108,
0.0364119895,
0.9086009264,
0.9083406925,
-0.3119253516,
0.7362033129,
0.0267370213,
-0.027259659,
-0.4990074039,
-0.40897578,
-0.4372708201,
-0.1290469766,
-0.1752358228,
-0.0231951661,
0.1830494404,
0.3767323792,
-0.245687142,
0.3766196966,
-0.2163211703,
0.5670048594,
0.1782170981,
-0.1290984303,
0.1705911607,
-0.0903289914,
-0.263920933,
-0.0380598754,
-0.3486580849,
-0.6240157485,
0.8619599938,
0.558054924,
1.0257747173,
0.1753773838,
0.6047664881,
0.5346369147,
0.1732856333,
-0.8035548329,
0.801114738,
0.0858298093,
-0.3764099479,
-0.0861239284,
-0.4933696985,
-0.6276758909,
0.1070480347,
0.0009249134,
-1.1254826784,
0.0095017245,
0.2261462063,
-0.5388156772,
0.2600605488,
-0.9795825481,
1.270491004,
-0.5666514039,
-0.2693554163,
-0.0327083282,
-0.6186259389,
0.818695724,
-0.0385046452,
0.4206222892,
-0.1979669333,
0.1254394501,
0.762878418,
-0.9269872904,
1.1071404219,
-0.4763401747,
-0.1203002408,
0.3749324977,
0.5345071554,
0.449308008,
0.0855050683,
0.1696735471,
0.0514397696,
-0.1759540737,
-0.1345798373,
-0.7113494277,
0.7598705888,
-0.4332748353,
-0.83139503,
-0.0751214921,
-0.4430772066,
-0.1569405049,
0.1280536056,
0.0923415497,
0.2702096701,
-0.2497499585,
-0.3577073216,
0.5279548168,
-0.4362820685,
0.5133460164,
0.1877540499,
-0.6727121472,
-0.4610589743,
0.6473954916,
-0.021343451,
-0.0162036475,
-0.1131189093,
0.1073795781,
-0.0769600496,
-0.9777039886,
-0.6955607533,
0.0692825392,
-0.6081402898,
-0.354503423,
-0.0988791585,
-0.0202680361,
-0.3693469167,
-0.1574191898,
-0.1281228662,
-0.3544828296,
-0.1518396586,
-0.179066211,
0.7309426069,
0.7493386269,
0.1501192749,
0.5090523958,
-1.0391556025,
0.3377185762,
0.31642887,
0.2982381284,
0.0639260858,
-0.3619075119,
-0.1131141484,
-0.6289299726,
-0.2217275649,
-1.4471802711,
0.4684701264,
-0.2230491191,
0.5404418707,
0.5887641311,
-0.1106537208,
0.5949115157,
-0.8027472496,
0.8053155541,
0.3646118641,
-1.1605129242,
1.0054260492,
-0.3081892729,
-0.1607253551,
0.7421295047,
-0.0746990666,
-0.266769886,
-0.4294210672,
-0.3278452158,
-0.9059929252,
0.4145579338,
0.0664749369,
-0.0590293743,
0.0190810971,
0.3291344643,
-0.070691593,
0.1552601308,
-0.5124809742,
-0.0995989367,
-0.1662426591,
-0.0866211429,
0.2440777123,
-0.4203663468,
-0.0400289074,
-0.1447504908,
0.1618499756,
0.2730927169,
-0.2027396709,
-0.0802275762,
-0.4561499357,
0.1399518251,
0.3880404532,
0.5839607716,
0.7395950556,
-0.1587591171,
0.0723205954,
0.1044976786,
-0.5834722519,
0.1621322632,
0.1289617121,
-0.130457744,
-0.0377796218,
0.6681237221,
0.9376448989,
-0.0812698752,
-1.211643815,
0.7992787957,
-0.1697829217,
0.2182227373,
-0.3175292611,
0.1882954687,
-0.0642780587,
0.5770805478,
0.1302945465,
-0.0155920386,
0.2131765485,
-0.3652330339,
0.1076381505,
0.5199609399,
-0.3361562192,
-0.2910626829,
0.6019389033,
0.3245033026,
-0.4745942354,
0.648927331,
-0.0064478,
-0.6543395519,
0.8600105643,
0.4882683158,
1.0513361692,
-0.4303973317,
0.0188799705,
0.079614982,
0.6458407044,
0.092520088,
0.2554413974,
0.0387330167,
-0.434091866,
-0.5468619466,
-0.5064357519,
-0.3392845988,
0.1370754987,
-0.5526522994,
0.3572758436,
-0.8658102751,
-0.2313366681,
-0.2286168039,
-0.3586063683,
-0.3017154336,
-0.0228870623,
0.4245533645,
1.3470523357,
-0.8191081882,
0.5262064934,
0.4722182751,
-0.3049771488,
-0.536670506,
-0.3408876956,
0.4128290713,
-0.5853384733,
0.9941626787,
0.4290160537,
-0.0541577563,
-0.429941386,
-0.8785796165,
-0.5460207462,
0.7973517776,
0.5875858068,
-1.01692307,
0.0615905263,
-0.1313441992,
0.1734896451,
-0.3012523353,
0.1191539243,
0.9084727764,
0.6023423076,
-0.2383270562,
-0.8634921312,
0.2362804264,
-0.4314037561,
0.0505418517,
0.196049571,
-0.3612127602,
0.7141507864,
-0.5605084896,
-0.0323414952,
0.3553508222,
0.4682105482,
0.6532253027,
0.2356099635,
0.5186647773,
0.6674870849,
0.6053202748,
0.0934012979,
1.0101356506,
-0.2362537831,
0.0842921212,
1.1734366417,
-0.2101406455,
0.7954597473,
0.6324723959,
-0.0705889165,
0.5073561668,
0.4512265921,
-0.4102756977,
0.4922190607,
0.6254850626,
-0.1406392306,
-0.1989589632,
0.2516076565,
-0.2124245912,
0.2674433291,
0.471349448,
-0.3950771093,
-0.3004912138,
0.409616679,
0.2423104346,
0.0118896272,
-0.5136793256,
0.627466917,
0.0858560875,
-0.0510377325,
0.3539620936,
0.126646772,
0.5076562166,
-0.5629782677,
0.1029561087,
-0.2132699341,
-0.0740167126,
-0.2156995684,
-0.646486938,
0.1766640097,
0.6919563413,
-0.002538512,
0.0930329114,
0.8436561227,
0.1532898247,
-0.4468147457,
0.5319920182,
0.549597621,
0.0731107593,
-0.1967694014,
-0.8457624912,
0.7041320801,
-0.0343133472,
-0.4835553467,
0.2822577059,
0.2198878378,
-0.1657586843,
0.8522231579,
0.3737593591,
0.2296575159,
0.2249779999,
0.2970015705,
1.013092041,
-0.8440310955,
-0.2626294196,
-1.4895031452,
0.5881062746,
-0.3628616631,
-0.1751857996,
1.0185821056,
0.4168839753,
0.4231010079,
-0.0976845324,
0.8399211168,
-0.0378743149,
0.223799035,
-0.6909805536,
0.8960479498,
-0.2943594754,
0.7960315943,
-0.5076112747,
-0.7303315997,
-0.4310698807,
0.4119829237,
-0.5440478325,
-0.2397696227,
0.3706210554,
0.6876943707,
0.1594717801,
-0.0977685899,
0.1846221238,
0.4131939113,
0.4393287003,
0.3635957241,
1.3109810352,
-0.022669958,
0.4527991712,
-0.0610062033,
-0.3579461575,
-0.234955132,
-0.8882272243,
-1.3486725092,
-0.0776110664,
-0.2796545029,
-0.251537174,
0.1170130447,
0.7774804831,
0.452942282,
-0.754812479,
-0.3720872402,
-0.0512862168,
0.1715610474,
0.2482242286,
-0.2287983149,
0.2340775579,
-0.5058791041,
-0.2334825546,
0.8792017102,
0.3855744898,
0.0546829253,
-0.4121055901,
0.2539158762,
0.4318560958,
-0.0326699242,
0.6340922117,
0.368865788,
-0.6832235456,
-0.0953627601,
-0.1084975004,
-0.0436830781,
-0.1955073476,
0.9201593995,
-0.7814754844,
0.4861282408,
0.549244523,
0.6088953018,
0.0598263256,
-0.0025019655,
0.4164074957,
-0.668746233,
0.320214957,
-0.0153314229,
0.636549592,
0.3063560724,
-0.2880927622,
0.112968713,
0.2657670081,
-0.2684806287,
-1.0003225803,
0.3331088126,
-0.8753635287,
-0.7020112872,
1.0397219658,
-0.2689230144,
-0.4438230097,
-0.1059830785,
-0.3639501333,
-0.3071261048,
-0.444837302,
0.5780569315,
0.6587836742,
-0.049469769,
-0.2382873297,
-0.7744386792,
0.4468365908,
-0.0575690307,
-0.8632433414,
0.3710409999,
0.713077426,
0.3840599358,
0.1244996339,
0.2359205931,
-0.2341090143,
0.1414072365,
-0.080133684,
0.0008207041,
-0.4546979666,
-0.5401400924,
-0.6951729655,
0.387716502,
0.1991270036,
0.0547277778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08763v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08763v2
|
CATS: Contextually-Aware Thresholding for Sparsity in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-12T18:42:18 | 2024-04-27T00:01:02 |
Je-Yong Lee, Donghyun Lee, Genghan Zhang, Mo Tiwari, Azalia Mirhoseini
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have dramatically advanced AI applications, yet
their deployment remains challenging due to their immense inference costs.
Recent studies ameliorate the computational costs of LLMs by increasing their
activation sparsity but suffer from significant performance degradation on
downstream tasks. In this work, we introduce a new framework for sparsifying
the activations of base LLMs and reducing inference costs, dubbed Contextually
Aware Thresholding for Sparsity (CATS). CATS is relatively simple, easy to
implement, and highly effective. At the heart of our framework is a new
non-linear activation function. We demonstrate that CATS can be applied to
various base models, including Mistral-7B and Llama2-7B, and outperforms
existing sparsification techniques in downstream task performance. More
precisely, CATS-based models often achieve downstream task performance within
1-2% of their base models without any fine-tuning and even at activation
sparsity levels of 50%. Furthermore, CATS-based models converge faster and
display better task performance than competing techniques when fine-tuning is
applied. Finally, we develop a custom GPU kernel for efficient implementation
of CATS that translates the activation of sparsity of CATS to real wall-clock
time speedups. Our custom kernel implementation of CATS results in a ~15%
improvement in wall-clock inference latency of token generation on both
Llama-7B and Mistral-7B.
|
[
-0.4800741374,
-1.0271539688,
0.4153442383,
0.6287286282,
-0.451665163,
-0.2095701396,
-0.2095919847,
-0.5747445226,
0.28979972,
0.5562996268,
-0.3783633113,
-0.1980999261,
-0.5829607248,
0.0799715891,
-0.1833695769,
0.618530035,
0.2079200447,
-0.1302001178,
-0.0795338228,
-0.0357031301,
-0.5879496932,
-0.4245915413,
-0.6223347783,
-0.3673465252,
0.2632721663,
0.0899160579,
0.4054943323,
0.840075314,
0.4903862178,
0.2045530528,
-0.4464168251,
0.071094051,
-0.4687796235,
0.2532795072,
0.0817463323,
-0.136868462,
-0.4766513407,
-0.5724120736,
0.8063387871,
0.5676589608,
-0.1294062883,
0.03294513,
0.2487868071,
0.5760443807,
-0.9317330718,
-0.0645413473,
-0.8549224734,
0.1207137406,
-0.0769094154,
-0.4433867633,
-0.7146806717,
0.1695161611,
-0.2178069055,
-0.8067216873,
0.0822588652,
-0.3255916834,
0.8185655475,
0.7419139147,
-0.4645678997,
0.0769292936,
-0.345962733,
0.8253993988,
-0.5461416841,
0.8030604124,
0.3105760217,
-0.0913778022,
-0.4773957133,
-0.6343069077,
-0.369033277,
-0.4160777032,
-0.0372519717,
-0.1482630968,
-0.3835543692,
0.1117478311,
0.4470466971,
0.314053297,
-0.5313560963,
-0.0342438519,
0.1720463485,
-0.1222473085,
0.1569601595,
0.173184216,
0.1657014191,
0.1015225351,
-0.6507677436,
0.030542165,
-0.65354985,
0.388541013,
-0.201871559,
0.4323243201,
-0.1357976198,
0.2057124823,
-0.382101506,
0.7022374868,
0.4350299537,
0.0859023333,
0.2400030941,
-0.0974692628,
-0.326020807,
-0.1543983072,
0.3412912786,
0.1329447031,
-0.0711186305,
-0.1906632036,
-0.3509035707,
0.2104421109,
0.0652196631,
-0.954198122,
0.0417047366,
0.0469162315,
-0.1908952296,
-0.2678572536,
-0.5104845166,
-0.4893170893,
-0.3683025241,
-0.2425812185,
0.2797504067,
-0.15646635,
-0.5162134767,
0.3092733324,
0.038120538,
0.3083022237,
0.2284904271,
-0.8727573752,
0.49707219,
0.6806601882,
0.8400904536,
-0.2143104821,
-0.1189850345,
-1.1412495375,
0.1452415586,
-0.5506995916,
0.7492216229,
-0.7298604846,
-0.4315057397,
-0.3989413381,
-0.0087389043,
-0.0015120913,
-0.4915471077,
0.3059388995,
-0.6920349002,
-0.530031383,
-0.2492909282,
-0.1776903272,
-0.1229119971,
0.4119275808,
-0.7694509625,
1.5453950167,
-0.3751962185,
-0.601721704,
0.5448046327,
-0.7157860398,
-0.6191174984,
0.251770407,
0.3537480533,
-0.3804781437,
0.2352923453,
0.3391668499,
0.6554219723,
-0.0229797885,
0.712198019,
-0.3962340057,
-0.4624724686,
0.1648473591,
-0.3338235319,
0.5923029184,
0.0964341387,
-0.505939126,
0.2042442709,
-0.6644194722,
-0.0367656089,
-0.2498435676,
-0.3159862757,
-0.6121870279,
0.0031470915,
0.2172726393,
0.1094380468,
0.2999690473,
-0.2085088044,
-0.0228590947,
-0.3639622629,
0.4651060998,
0.6740608811,
0.0864973068,
0.3330001235,
-0.0844140872,
0.3351923525,
0.0610632189,
0.0862241313,
0.0031501779,
-0.5514175296,
-0.7165533304,
-0.6432031989,
-0.1007449776,
0.3611661196,
-0.6149104834,
0.5014278293,
-0.2972314954,
-0.4307590425,
0.2602590024,
0.256965369,
0.5676159263,
0.529128015,
0.4404067397,
-0.4869318902,
-0.5516842008,
-0.7902065516,
-0.1539234966,
-0.051609762,
0.1924340576,
0.2754246891,
0.4516589344,
-0.2214934975,
0.8785076737,
-0.2328983098,
-0.1905424595,
-0.2422108501,
0.1068738326,
0.0939535648,
0.6682322621,
0.2585513294,
-0.649507165,
-0.344791472,
0.0939107537,
-0.2828243375,
-0.3108711243,
-0.117078796,
-0.3212817907,
0.0876001716,
0.551636219,
-0.5606532693,
0.3743852675,
0.549130857,
-0.2870222032,
0.238367036,
0.0285112001,
-0.0839839205,
-1.0350955725,
0.4726181626,
0.2560185492,
-0.3745262027,
-0.9255490899,
-0.105651319,
0.038452398,
0.0527115054,
-0.4105609655,
0.844522059,
-0.5051739812,
-0.1638165861,
-0.2256560922,
-0.2310403883,
-0.0249158833,
0.8728408217,
0.4458347261,
0.7974963188,
0.5332593322,
-0.848190248,
-0.4397414327,
0.0449619293,
-0.1122075543,
0.2543622851,
-0.5411344171,
-0.0672540665,
0.1334680915,
0.5202502608,
-0.8190037608,
-0.1500268131,
0.1537271291,
-0.4197903275,
0.1117515042,
-0.1738866866,
-0.1583934873,
0.1738771945,
-0.2204974741,
0.7080820203,
0.3554730117,
-0.6258840561,
0.7648183703,
0.6820818782,
0.1675679535,
-1.0890688896,
-0.5612775087,
0.2986424267,
-0.2304748893,
-0.2937222719,
0.2855070829,
0.0777375251,
0.0031447152,
-0.0134366807,
-0.0721535906,
-0.3222847879,
0.4729198217,
0.4501633346,
0.0660546869,
-0.3426077962,
0.091489628,
0.1554273814,
-0.2564266026,
-0.213836059,
-0.2237392813,
0.5322993994,
-0.2081019878,
-0.1038051844,
-0.5172392726,
0.0656587705,
0.5610584021,
-0.3876984119,
0.3807481825,
0.6818671227,
-0.7201203704,
-0.4718468487,
-0.7603031397,
-0.3362094164,
-0.4819023311,
0.5636872649,
-0.5799309611,
-1.2072168589,
0.4556488395,
0.0644671693,
0.0700453147,
0.2547632754,
0.8473972678,
0.561512351,
1.08837533,
0.8265302181,
-0.1026092321,
0.791128397,
-0.0127046257,
0.2126626074,
-0.9682475924,
0.0115767065,
-0.254221946,
-0.0849721357,
-0.1499369889,
-0.6783436537,
0.4480878413,
0.0662280545,
-0.1772337109,
0.2652011812,
-0.5706014633,
0.6182633638,
0.1562713236,
0.1716997176,
0.3367656171,
0.3145333827,
0.0254541859,
0.0260613374,
-0.7123461366,
-0.3871923983,
0.7414647937,
0.4960539043,
0.6109306812,
-0.1167976558,
0.1107797772,
0.5524676442,
0.7356113791,
-0.7492988706,
0.691382885,
-0.1807525456,
-0.7407155633,
-0.4737755358,
-0.3389872909,
-0.9306291342,
0.4486988187,
-0.2339194715,
-0.8655711412,
0.3916396499,
0.440238446,
-0.3433936536,
0.3978540301,
-0.5505630374,
0.7302066684,
0.0792963207,
-0.8520680666,
-0.2773010731,
-0.2616459429,
0.5441718698,
0.1388990283,
-0.0143233202,
-0.365049392,
-0.2405529916,
0.5835262537,
-0.2189939916,
1.2078311443,
-0.3363367319,
-0.0200432222,
0.2344933897,
0.2553502917,
0.5475139022,
0.1320773065,
-0.0667388067,
0.226879403,
-0.1497641802,
-0.2429516166,
-0.3542611897,
0.7342758775,
-0.3742660284,
-0.6213194132,
-0.2076563686,
-0.5823732018,
-0.3954848349,
0.1909328401,
-0.0565876476,
0.5554126501,
-0.1863942146,
0.3323065639,
0.6113008261,
0.0760521963,
0.3430841863,
0.4022345841,
0.0589440875,
-0.4989183545,
0.9435352087,
-0.3335238695,
0.0929012448,
0.5634638071,
0.0523266755,
-0.5106737018,
-0.3793377876,
-0.7381411195,
0.1340740919,
-0.61242944,
-0.2408515513,
-0.7015565634,
-0.1035926566,
-0.1860288978,
-0.4143020213,
-0.3990296125,
-0.1929932833,
-0.2968055308,
0.047391735,
0.3735280335,
0.4395482242,
-0.2507974207,
0.436693579,
-0.4816032052,
0.2410230935,
0.1854175329,
0.6126698256,
0.2704648077,
-0.4908056855,
-0.3057984114,
-0.1730049551,
-0.155771479,
-0.5940246582,
0.4220072627,
0.2060260773,
0.4420724809,
0.4759465456,
-0.0738807842,
1.0018390417,
-0.2984535694,
0.6654509902,
0.2994301617,
-1.4001041651,
0.0534033142,
-0.1450766921,
0.0435580835,
0.3757798076,
-0.0888750106,
-0.5541105866,
-0.2725546658,
-0.023491418,
-0.8926719427,
0.5915288329,
0.1015123054,
0.254003495,
-0.0682396665,
0.2438888103,
0.072616905,
-0.1636194736,
-1.0670150518,
0.2535386086,
0.0127359703,
0.0965993032,
-0.1180629209,
-0.4099462926,
0.1323670745,
-0.0887266845,
0.7855058908,
-0.2175150216,
-0.0513856784,
0.4032714963,
-0.4433084428,
-0.3236014843,
0.2097519338,
0.7397174835,
0.3717814386,
-0.0321516283,
0.1778285056,
0.6331459284,
-0.6016175747,
0.2610531151,
-0.2581601739,
-0.0694456249,
-0.0440218449,
0.3075762093,
0.9566120505,
0.3495515883,
-0.7805535793,
0.4337033927,
-0.0609228723,
-0.1488700509,
-0.1020991802,
0.0459674746,
-0.1526310593,
0.1484164447,
0.2396039516,
-0.1267779171,
0.2929598689,
0.1194906309,
0.2945046425,
0.7652623057,
-0.5928664804,
-0.280666858,
0.716470778,
0.3105816543,
0.0694045499,
0.0530550778,
-0.1067063585,
-0.5727678537,
0.7593916655,
0.6607672572,
1.0912963152,
-0.2019311041,
-0.1248581111,
0.559794426,
0.3437441289,
-0.1193654686,
0.0418100618,
-0.6528823972,
-0.6920295954,
-0.6878496408,
-0.7960431576,
-0.3592932224,
0.3102668822,
-0.5060398579,
0.282981813,
-0.4587150216,
-0.5214162469,
-0.1753245592,
-0.2829361558,
-0.1559234113,
0.2980239093,
0.185495168,
0.8503746986,
-0.8516219854,
0.6361944675,
0.702521503,
0.207014963,
-0.4997066557,
-0.1072605923,
-0.3668062687,
-0.7078163624,
0.8529934883,
0.3724166751,
-0.6922228932,
0.0842547789,
-0.3942559659,
-0.8345713615,
0.7122136354,
0.1542046368,
-0.4926419854,
0.2617377937,
0.1443011165,
0.4436742663,
-0.3003886044,
0.078945376,
0.4338111877,
0.436360687,
0.072477214,
-0.7992213368,
0.343878448,
-0.6531193256,
0.3006244898,
0.378346324,
-0.4173436165,
0.7066221833,
-0.0448799878,
-0.347653091,
0.0885198563,
0.483309865,
0.3368679285,
0.4251939654,
0.9022353888,
0.6942915916,
0.4126246274,
-0.0163204651,
0.6370700598,
-0.7703434825,
0.1321920902,
0.6241156459,
-0.2855421603,
1.0309965611,
0.6773042679,
0.2634428442,
0.1217397004,
0.6507591009,
0.1763569564,
0.3629134893,
0.2319466174,
-0.3683124781,
-0.7988599539,
-0.3963987529,
-0.4471965432,
0.1179752424,
0.6206008792,
-0.0776697248,
-0.1420384198,
-0.0006307267,
-0.0684398264,
-0.2301809639,
-0.2883379161,
0.7603620291,
-0.0235390551,
-0.7923957109,
1.047403574,
0.0839302614,
0.6808690429,
-0.5195840597,
-0.085095264,
-0.2438704371,
0.2796070278,
-0.1503030658,
-0.5099672675,
0.2214625627,
0.2984743714,
-0.171857968,
-0.1783698648,
0.7415989041,
-0.2833716571,
-0.3482759893,
0.3303964436,
0.3423722982,
0.0027590778,
-0.1248584986,
-0.4736506343,
0.310644865,
-0.1956797838,
-0.4012943208,
0.0866863057,
0.2442718744,
-0.5036718845,
0.8393348455,
1.0301659107,
-0.0289939102,
0.1791318059,
-0.1325635016,
1.0055003166,
-0.5409080982,
-0.7916227579,
-0.7519055605,
0.6034687161,
0.1659081429,
-0.5026828051,
0.3680497408,
0.6952311993,
0.4769168496,
-0.0186655317,
0.4866639078,
0.1988700926,
0.1553992927,
-0.6266699433,
0.5902685523,
-0.9162982106,
0.305156976,
-0.1786011457,
-0.6612452865,
-0.7189635038,
0.4912415445,
-0.487039268,
-0.1290980726,
0.3805062175,
1.2765427828,
-0.1863762736,
-0.2449129075,
0.5221467614,
0.1086025313,
0.2533985674,
0.7422605157,
0.9665018916,
-0.0313866958,
0.4434214532,
-0.2573030293,
-0.2874351144,
-0.425845325,
-0.8571502566,
-1.0067352057,
-0.6931500435,
-0.2047865689,
-0.3264456689,
0.2677790523,
0.7649302483,
1.0190864801,
-0.7169798017,
-0.4067398608,
-0.2505552471,
0.0591860898,
-0.1595855057,
-0.2417717129,
0.2502464056,
-0.6067869067,
-0.5211376548,
0.3040677905,
0.5115163326,
-0.1904406399,
-0.114701964,
-0.2102801949,
0.0283532925,
0.1918812543,
0.6871278882,
0.4827670753,
-0.8544523716,
-0.0639063269,
0.1155856922,
-0.2595813274,
0.3198112249,
0.9076897502,
-0.720623076,
0.2710015774,
0.4091715813,
0.8600266576,
0.4952399433,
0.0552362651,
0.2022121102,
-0.5066738129,
0.4552993476,
0.123960413,
0.2770814896,
0.2881674469,
-0.4337396622,
0.2624301612,
0.2820251882,
-0.2332105786,
-1.1862270832,
0.1371237189,
-1.1419537067,
-0.1382247955,
1.039167881,
0.1386402845,
-0.4711703956,
-0.1840806752,
-0.0766626,
0.1483197659,
-0.581948638,
0.6989417076,
0.4736816287,
0.006387841,
-0.0296640396,
-0.3865745366,
0.655346334,
0.8048917651,
-0.70832479,
0.3131405115,
0.4796048999,
0.2843115628,
-0.1436142027,
0.6415897608,
0.0722439885,
0.4173240066,
0.0942588896,
0.3685668111,
-0.1200498343,
-0.2634680271,
-0.4195945263,
0.1025574282,
-0.0381779261,
-0.1148850769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08760v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08760v2
|
The Generation Gap:Exploring Age Bias in the Underlying Value Systems of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-12T18:36:20 | 2024-05-13T22:11:02 |
Siyang Liu, Trish Maturi, Bowen Yi, Siqi Shen, Rada Mihalcea
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this paper, we explore the alignment of values in Large Language Models
(LLMs) with specific age groups, leveraging data from the World Value Survey
across thirteen categories. Through a diverse set of prompts tailored to ensure
response robustness, we find a general inclination of LLM values towards
younger demographics. Additionally, we explore the impact of incorporating age
identity information in prompts and observe challenges in mitigating value
discrepancies with different age cohorts. Our findings highlight the age bias
in LLMs and provide insights for future work.
|
[
-0.385648936,
-0.5054036975,
0.4390116036,
0.0654564053,
0.2608479857,
0.3129514754,
0.1990713179,
-0.6690711379,
-0.2119026482,
0.1432100981,
-0.8429892659,
-0.0852145255,
-0.6007748246,
-0.1095660403,
0.1760527939,
0.5746744275,
0.3060109615,
0.0743446425,
-0.4404497445,
-0.0601780042,
-0.3646545708,
-0.4609681368,
-0.5924340487,
-0.5476448536,
0.4788070619,
0.584423244,
0.6847364902,
0.5047392845,
0.2243706733,
0.1678648293,
-0.5118430257,
0.0631811842,
-0.4851206541,
0.5833931565,
-0.316061765,
-0.2824404836,
-0.5519385934,
-0.0268911626,
0.3933057785,
1.0440317392,
0.3376123011,
0.2352232486,
-0.0816167668,
0.9091336727,
-0.5891678333,
0.0769018307,
-0.6634131074,
-0.00044943,
-0.5142541528,
-0.1460291892,
-0.3476822376,
-0.5751568079,
0.1800474972,
-0.2372926921,
0.1925471723,
0.1616540104,
1.0448511839,
-0.004856139,
-0.6776347756,
-0.1591887772,
-0.5033779144,
1.0860790014,
-0.7636643648,
0.2789052427,
0.2840456665,
0.1669169813,
-0.2095948011,
-0.0651115403,
-0.4431731701,
0.1660480499,
0.4005418718,
-0.1414466202,
-0.150091663,
-0.2688649595,
0.0649531111,
0.635964036,
-0.4725052714,
0.8389502764,
-0.5146201253,
-0.0355149992,
0.5818165541,
0.4798136353,
0.4421252906,
-0.0814220905,
-0.3031798601,
-0.1597701907,
-1.3723945618,
0.4651774466,
0.9127243757,
0.5998641253,
-0.2141232938,
0.8836364746,
-0.2905584574,
0.7562183142,
0.3057799637,
-0.249241963,
0.3258377314,
-0.2332529575,
0.0725695789,
0.1434117407,
0.6954413652,
0.7286415696,
0.7646503448,
0.1433156729,
-0.1349638253,
-0.0409136489,
-0.1997369975,
-0.6513626575,
0.3618074059,
0.0862778276,
-0.5859779716,
-0.2867150605,
-0.1359934211,
-1.2096908092,
-0.7106527686,
-0.1975810677,
-0.0888615549,
-0.015856551,
-0.2443235517,
0.1174044088,
-0.2200118303,
0.3249047101,
0.312799871,
-1.432394743,
0.061274875,
0.3509514332,
0.5647678375,
-0.1451302469,
0.0978741124,
-0.4413715005,
0.1560472399,
-0.3630403876,
0.7450953722,
-0.8576683402,
-0.540789783,
0.1342687756,
0.0613083988,
0.1972783357,
-0.7359178066,
0.2411141843,
-0.7788804173,
0.5069366693,
-0.2475328892,
-0.4023407698,
0.334074676,
0.0269146673,
-0.6701835394,
1.207498908,
0.2258781791,
-0.7252298594,
0.770524025,
-0.3275542855,
-0.0844215527,
0.270404011,
-0.2416657358,
-0.2665481567,
0.0770752132,
0.3788516223,
0.3262599111,
-0.4808984399,
0.4058863223,
-0.6268727779,
-0.1997201443,
0.3654167652,
-0.8280118704,
0.8526086211,
0.5570142269,
-0.2693960369,
0.1130827144,
-0.693305254,
0.0460398383,
0.2912793159,
-0.2563660443,
-0.5480322838,
-0.0958304927,
-0.1855790317,
0.3356306851,
0.5059555769,
-0.440697372,
0.6300059557,
-0.0820654482,
0.537568748,
0.8289364576,
-0.1618320793,
0.4938850999,
-0.4250999689,
0.8008373976,
0.1031150371,
0.0015677356,
-0.1843867302,
-0.4572949111,
-0.4320374727,
0.2377991378,
0.1811053902,
0.529504776,
-0.3291912377,
0.5361306071,
-0.470411092,
-0.1905849576,
-0.4733804464,
0.2694431245,
-0.215683341,
0.1205430999,
0.0373087637,
-0.0581718311,
-0.6227369905,
-0.9835634232,
-0.1054174006,
-0.6578685045,
-0.3045639098,
0.1859998554,
0.0663024858,
-0.1694269925,
0.8865081668,
-0.4488271773,
0.2151955813,
-0.1896423399,
0.0403729677,
0.0849878937,
0.4765071273,
-0.0041053551,
-0.6722587347,
-0.1067827642,
-0.1138745844,
-0.4133559167,
-0.7566321492,
0.0303127058,
0.1930205971,
0.1201710626,
0.7101425529,
-0.3657109737,
0.1912597418,
0.8609061241,
-0.6180740595,
0.3144418001,
0.1602362394,
0.1603672951,
-1.0090311766,
0.0263823494,
0.4587726891,
0.1113894433,
-0.4107556939,
-0.4409839213,
0.0286652856,
0.0783120692,
-0.3140416741,
0.6493802667,
-0.7030034661,
0.1186705232,
-0.0654480159,
0.1451244652,
0.1546346098,
-0.3082149625,
-0.1675658822,
1.0027648211,
-0.0411592759,
-0.4302519858,
0.2520540655,
0.1913826764,
-0.3652121127,
0.9471176863,
-0.4764989614,
0.1102216989,
-0.3993166089,
0.403039217,
-1.0442684889,
-0.0955684111,
0.0363675356,
-0.5982747674,
0.2536716163,
-0.291497916,
-0.1117191911,
-0.3157916069,
-0.3469734788,
0.7569660544,
0.5751442313,
-0.2177323848,
0.2672350109,
0.5153561831,
-0.8088207245,
-0.7670618892,
-0.5847697258,
0.1903066188,
-0.6585561633,
-0.8692073226,
0.3767596781,
-0.1602175683,
-0.6608693004,
-0.0265440531,
-0.0660794899,
0.079130441,
-0.1680169106,
0.2749118209,
0.500138402,
-0.3408100307,
0.2391853034,
-0.0093344394,
-0.0269770287,
-0.1266324073,
-0.2385112196,
0.8719667196,
-0.0905631855,
-0.109242022,
0.2703794539,
0.1588626206,
0.8310834169,
-0.1145344377,
0.8833805323,
0.1231973469,
-0.2505016029,
-0.1649661511,
-0.7493671179,
0.2220200747,
-0.5105016828,
-0.1417999417,
-0.2712328434,
-1.3941267729,
0.7200190425,
0.1755748093,
-0.2873233259,
0.6760888696,
0.8334773183,
0.281586647,
1.0761328936,
0.6039962769,
-0.0166616999,
0.4972625673,
0.1167764962,
0.3387501538,
-1.0206800699,
-0.5826405287,
-0.696841538,
-0.2127392441,
-0.6324078441,
-0.21425955,
0.0750471354,
0.2242280245,
-0.5816475749,
-0.2540840805,
-0.3859519362,
0.4818705022,
0.4344991744,
-0.2315067351,
0.2976720631,
-0.4302969575,
-0.0413101986,
-0.2752601504,
-0.7546545267,
-0.749540627,
0.9111276269,
0.6539894342,
1.2852655649,
0.0794561878,
0.3050895631,
0.322632581,
0.267785579,
-0.694299221,
0.392727077,
-0.0092178397,
-0.8905332088,
-0.5892356038,
-0.5598760843,
-1.371168375,
0.0899175331,
0.0774670392,
-0.959338069,
0.4622684717,
-0.2143610716,
-0.4833028316,
0.3191953599,
-0.5393289328,
0.76994133,
-0.1841113716,
-0.5785691142,
0.3259787858,
-0.8083708882,
0.6232350469,
0.1047147289,
0.4048580527,
-0.7524930239,
-0.0675776079,
0.5274071693,
-0.2681466937,
0.8869059682,
-0.051381886,
-0.5918293595,
0.2331152409,
-0.0381516851,
0.0867567062,
-0.1371731907,
-0.0227407161,
-0.1943955421,
0.0877053514,
-0.5813957453,
0.0054912153,
1.0919029713,
-0.6798325777,
-0.7692738771,
-0.6456716657,
-0.8672274351,
-0.3630752563,
0.0939049348,
0.1495536864,
0.2457848489,
-0.2558877468,
0.2427038103,
0.9816512465,
-0.7337762713,
0.4379939139,
0.3382567763,
-0.2756899595,
-0.2069997936,
0.3397302628,
0.2952384651,
0.8325513601,
0.3386750519,
0.2022037506,
-0.6261075735,
-0.1377685964,
-0.6679625511,
0.0549106747,
-0.8049057126,
-0.1243150234,
-0.4547261596,
-0.1343512088,
-0.758199513,
-0.2406903505,
0.1267039627,
-0.1926820725,
0.0326975137,
-0.2021138668,
0.3587965071,
0.7409614325,
-0.0407014154,
-0.0145000527,
-0.9188778996,
0.1212318465,
0.5204668641,
0.4069859385,
0.1542675048,
-0.3607538939,
0.0197428204,
0.0141318599,
-0.2893026471,
-0.8738849163,
0.2598488629,
-0.0936300829,
0.7222043276,
0.363309294,
-0.0190948676,
0.3290610611,
-0.3195784688,
1.3189375401,
0.0709858835,
-1.0652937889,
0.3249311149,
-0.6588654518,
0.7265175581,
0.5179328918,
0.206130892,
-1.0443843603,
-0.039333988,
-0.6358138919,
-1.0473719835,
0.3114998937,
-0.3390061557,
0.2055175602,
0.0711619779,
-0.0646617264,
0.1816590577,
0.094230555,
-0.8543316722,
-0.0988630354,
0.1574618369,
-0.6826232076,
0.139890179,
-0.2717806399,
-0.1322367936,
0.0356168747,
0.4043108523,
-0.2298405319,
0.0565060601,
-0.1885400116,
0.0639767721,
-0.7950546145,
0.7723520398,
0.6842803359,
1.0004581213,
-0.077729404,
0.5247735977,
0.362413764,
-0.0951214433,
0.8319108486,
-0.0048397579,
0.0167493131,
-0.4115692079,
0.3094068468,
0.6114655137,
-0.0907919109,
-0.8562043309,
0.4290695786,
0.1260068119,
0.1192379445,
-0.1043383479,
-0.1629169732,
0.3368589878,
0.1093739718,
0.6164951921,
-0.4619134068,
-0.3523499966,
-0.715718329,
-0.1208105758,
0.5012885928,
-0.2995261848,
-0.0867287293,
0.8942244053,
0.0815270245,
-0.2835879326,
0.4925127327,
0.0748935565,
-0.3724687994,
0.6123477817,
0.4690166712,
0.6716986299,
-0.4262150228,
0.1053405702,
-0.14235726,
0.4268894792,
-0.1021116823,
0.135268271,
0.394136101,
-0.9207181334,
-0.8426963687,
-0.3376009166,
-0.2750245631,
0.2899554968,
-0.6106212735,
0.2487876862,
-0.0327595472,
-0.2193220854,
-0.0958803147,
-0.2038122416,
-0.8162181973,
0.410808146,
0.4618150592,
0.7541103363,
-1.1726806164,
0.6036108136,
0.3438150287,
-0.3520101011,
-0.5480194092,
-0.0396096557,
0.3874616623,
-1.0042908192,
1.047119379,
0.2243008763,
-0.0693562031,
-0.3159631491,
-0.6028997302,
-0.9495761991,
0.8465502262,
0.024671156,
-0.6339120865,
-0.248855561,
0.2399337739,
0.3988017738,
-0.4463767409,
0.0730408207,
0.6126568317,
0.5029135346,
0.085827589,
-0.8441182971,
-0.0908996165,
-0.4139754176,
0.2306171656,
0.5642427206,
-0.7784202099,
0.7401130199,
0.003995934,
-0.0885006711,
0.0230800081,
0.4918499887,
0.5214706659,
0.6329491138,
0.6231113076,
0.6391667128,
0.5116396546,
-0.2153208405,
0.6656145453,
-0.2766414881,
0.026828099,
0.5523142815,
-0.2859941423,
0.3045847714,
0.5914880037,
-0.4782272875,
0.4166406691,
0.9918454885,
0.0552537031,
0.1525756568,
0.5177143216,
-0.329646796,
-0.033900626,
-0.358998239,
-0.6676323414,
-0.0636803582,
0.5683529973,
-0.362587899,
0.1316905022,
-0.284391433,
0.3937096894,
-0.0271215942,
-0.3282020986,
0.5765908957,
0.3355549574,
-0.604767859,
0.4199842811,
-0.2027620077,
0.9104098082,
-0.7693037391,
0.200074181,
-0.2630137205,
0.0043691169,
-0.1821432412,
-0.9040205479,
-0.1676131934,
0.0595200062,
-0.3604561985,
-0.3291001022,
0.6458319426,
-0.6800810695,
-0.4298551679,
0.0107103474,
0.7675154805,
-0.2346927971,
0.4605358541,
-0.39417696,
0.4068976641,
-0.1024060994,
-0.1199535728,
0.3958930373,
0.8127536178,
-0.3114619255,
0.7894676328,
0.3579160273,
0.2509929836,
0.3095901012,
0.1387396008,
0.4796612561,
-0.7868183851,
-0.342854768,
-1.0368145704,
0.7181867957,
-0.1579376161,
-0.8669373989,
0.9425318837,
0.4981278181,
0.8169696331,
0.2575245798,
0.9542090893,
-0.0028435972,
0.3966826797,
-0.6683914065,
0.2078076154,
-0.3168540895,
0.4405687153,
-0.4586600363,
-1.084174037,
-0.1409011483,
0.3320843875,
-0.5199990273,
0.3312014043,
0.3467983603,
0.6781336069,
0.4020778239,
-0.1355987787,
0.1975576431,
-0.4169174135,
0.6655269861,
0.6835867167,
1.4019914865,
-0.0216461346,
0.1302451789,
0.2940685451,
-0.138761431,
-0.3335843682,
-1.0691735744,
-0.4452198446,
-0.2689840496,
-0.0668234304,
-0.6299937963,
0.0372320674,
1.063508749,
0.4135596454,
-0.8169545531,
-0.3723649383,
0.3322200477,
-0.1184086353,
-0.0410916321,
-0.2959529459,
0.0459490493,
-0.2089151889,
-0.9242789745,
0.3526209295,
0.1547501236,
0.5188500285,
-0.6728981733,
0.0479071103,
0.0343009233,
0.2426400185,
0.2694313228,
0.2073444724,
-0.687235415,
-0.5523567796,
0.2504837215,
-0.2687214017,
0.21392937,
1.0050177574,
-0.427190423,
0.3819129467,
0.567537725,
0.6780521274,
0.3618730903,
0.1744706035,
0.8687998652,
-0.4422370493,
0.0676899254,
0.3092209399,
0.2781095207,
0.8300839663,
-0.4144566953,
0.394425422,
0.2612914741,
-0.9303560257,
-0.8171522617,
0.3917916417,
-0.8603880405,
-0.3711129427,
1.2085344791,
0.3266671002,
0.3277250528,
-0.264064908,
-0.0842432007,
0.1060470417,
-0.3692279458,
0.8876571655,
1.2099055052,
0.0544910356,
-0.4205446541,
-0.6122503281,
0.2575336099,
0.5451439619,
-0.8566694856,
0.0770282373,
0.7713317871,
0.2001677006,
-0.145901829,
0.3504325151,
-0.3308073878,
-0.3365511298,
-0.0315717459,
0.0635509491,
0.3054437041,
-0.0316062197,
-0.6631926894,
0.2306665033,
0.5257613659,
0.1923271865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08634v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08634v1
|
Pre-training Small Base LMs with Fewer Tokens
| 2024-04-12T17:53:34 | 2024-04-12T17:53:34 |
Sunny Sanyal, Sujay Sanghavi, Alexandros G. Dimakis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We study the effectiveness of a simple approach to develop a small base
language model (LM) starting from an existing large base LM: first inherit a
few transformer blocks from the larger LM, and then train this smaller model on
a very small subset (0.1\%) of the raw pretraining data of the larger model. We
call our simple recipe Inheritune and first demonstrate it for building a small
base LM with 1.5B parameters using 1B tokens (and a starting few layers of
larger LM of 3B parameters); we do this using a single A6000 GPU for less than
half a day. Across 9 diverse evaluation datasets as well as the MMLU benchmark,
the resulting model compares favorably to publicly available base models of
1B-2B size, some of which have been trained using 50-1000 times more tokens.
We investigate Inheritune in a slightly different setting where we train
small LMs utilizing larger LMs and their full pre-training dataset. Here we
show that smaller LMs trained utilizing some of the layers of GPT2-medium
(355M) and GPT-2-large (770M) can effectively match the val loss of their
bigger counterparts when trained from scratch for the same number of training
steps on OpenWebText dataset with 9B tokens. We analyze our recipe with
extensive experiments and demonstrate it efficacy on diverse settings. Our code
is available at https://github.com/sanyalsunny111/LLM-Inheritune.
|
[
-0.5052306056,
-0.4923972189,
0.2766534984,
-0.0021291021,
-0.4667310119,
-0.0872401521,
-0.2744581699,
-0.3188661933,
0.2116272599,
0.3331916332,
-0.5124338865,
-0.0911056772,
-0.6137142181,
-0.2012968659,
-0.0682220608,
0.8844232559,
0.024238199,
0.2753276229,
0.1007452458,
-0.1636630446,
-0.4318740964,
-0.2790474594,
-0.940208137,
-0.511910975,
0.5497757196,
0.6250611544,
0.3906925917,
0.8069059253,
0.2466006577,
0.1084112972,
-0.2590789199,
0.1206904873,
-0.7255949378,
-0.5732266307,
0.1923935562,
-0.6684196591,
-0.3085246682,
-0.1982728392,
0.7309868932,
0.8384791017,
0.0910854042,
0.3650746346,
0.2517387271,
0.84570539,
-0.6241977811,
-0.0423850603,
-0.7081497312,
0.1505462676,
-0.2530534565,
0.088427864,
-0.6753440499,
-0.1755236685,
-0.0758655891,
-0.3459184766,
0.1600274593,
0.2626428604,
0.6025787592,
0.0500653051,
-0.3856340945,
0.045838587,
-0.7213472724,
0.6725691557,
-0.6157749295,
0.4974869788,
0.1825623512,
0.216150403,
-0.0078022033,
-0.8000875711,
-0.4171874225,
-0.2489335984,
-0.1852575839,
-0.0325165205,
-0.3224195838,
-0.1168174595,
0.4857713878,
0.3807460368,
-0.6652573347,
0.3746815622,
-0.4103720486,
-0.1230275184,
-0.0519441068,
0.1836562902,
0.0691386238,
-0.0281773359,
-0.4072550237,
-0.0474451706,
-1.3678591251,
-0.1009695232,
0.29953897,
0.5477229953,
-0.3062635958,
0.3603127897,
-0.0923238471,
0.4658517838,
0.3229115903,
-0.121762231,
0.2104878426,
-0.5280213356,
-0.422090888,
0.1456305236,
0.5895419717,
0.0260862522,
0.2246970087,
-0.100464195,
-0.0904132128,
-0.0589455329,
0.0709836334,
-1.1980423927,
-0.5039235353,
-0.2200853974,
-0.6269750595,
-0.1883606315,
-0.140221417,
-0.2661143243,
-0.3781377077,
-0.4604215622,
0.52458781,
-0.46698457,
-0.1729154289,
-0.196675539,
0.0450696535,
0.548645854,
0.3191728592,
-1.2440195084,
0.6233368516,
0.6789567471,
0.8956599236,
-0.2510968447,
-0.1751866341,
-0.8549028635,
-0.0823830143,
-0.3563570976,
0.4353606403,
-0.1561847478,
-0.5813062191,
-0.3572463393,
-0.0562917851,
-0.1350078583,
-0.7078362107,
0.3634251058,
-0.3637121916,
0.0907483697,
-0.3375589848,
-0.4539699852,
0.224247992,
0.0221667495,
-0.8929718733,
0.9814970493,
0.16828233,
-0.630903244,
0.5466384888,
-0.5256741047,
-0.5712652802,
-0.0502451211,
-0.1739716977,
-0.4281697273,
0.456464529,
0.2443815321,
0.098374851,
-0.2950849831,
-0.6668658257,
-0.1892640591,
-0.5840066671,
-0.4069079459,
-0.4235627055,
0.6391583681,
0.2168921232,
-0.462094605,
0.0697710812,
-0.6838271618,
0.1441311687,
0.1243547127,
-0.2951891124,
-0.3857237995,
-0.3959984183,
0.08747188,
0.0701803789,
-0.0328604952,
-0.3218103349,
0.3069407344,
-0.6497661471,
0.2252682745,
0.7608565688,
-0.1516325921,
0.9635549188,
-0.3376280367,
0.3992620111,
0.1312600076,
0.1484325975,
-0.1283942014,
-0.4347352386,
-1.062197566,
-0.3759946823,
0.5600684881,
0.2138573974,
-0.4948731363,
0.4733411968,
-0.4955911636,
-0.4395081401,
-0.6407338381,
0.3735301793,
0.3826504052,
0.3267106116,
0.3082668483,
-0.3918403685,
-0.8405162096,
-1.0887881517,
-0.0790879056,
0.111958988,
-0.0104881786,
0.2152455598,
0.5860427618,
-0.3447226286,
1.0218012333,
-0.2315180302,
-0.1219320968,
-0.6337291002,
0.065636009,
0.1739325225,
0.7151605487,
0.7423077822,
-0.5589295626,
-0.6974235773,
0.1177611873,
-0.2746168673,
0.1551086903,
0.1597581953,
-0.1658545882,
0.1771883965,
0.2415807247,
-0.5956760645,
0.3117616177,
0.4829941094,
-0.071045056,
0.5078180432,
-0.0064311149,
-0.2191518694,
-1.3309112787,
0.0438592434,
-0.2899741232,
-0.4691895545,
-0.661781311,
-0.1436914951,
0.1282284707,
-0.0252935532,
-0.6255479455,
0.7162348032,
-0.5630594492,
-0.1157371178,
-0.4449174702,
-0.4131762981,
-0.2273459882,
0.5163185,
-0.0109003,
0.7043763995,
0.3283706903,
-0.4561827183,
0.013665542,
-0.0469026864,
-0.3050154746,
0.2336017042,
-0.6744602323,
0.3511277437,
-0.0334318727,
0.2332103699,
-0.7837727666,
0.1040037796,
0.4023014009,
-0.0831708089,
0.4142343402,
-0.5132377744,
-0.4836831093,
-0.2899450958,
-0.3956405818,
0.2706744373,
0.9042541385,
-0.9195403457,
0.5978714228,
-0.0056679449,
-0.1585499644,
-0.4699352682,
-0.7700543404,
-0.0597058386,
-0.3105880916,
-0.3675278723,
0.1542775333,
-0.330661267,
-0.0143855056,
0.0804680362,
-0.2171357274,
0.1415310502,
0.1675433367,
0.4039311707,
0.0616883822,
-0.6401154995,
-0.0221704487,
0.0467358939,
-0.2112706453,
-0.1440680027,
-0.6260391474,
0.8161551952,
-0.6307190657,
-0.4618083537,
-0.203014642,
-0.0437893495,
0.3210683465,
0.0790078193,
0.9176059365,
0.5381796956,
-0.4790019095,
-0.4223168194,
-0.3301724195,
-0.2436516136,
-0.4581910074,
0.2836581469,
-0.5172848105,
-0.7409000993,
0.5013719797,
-0.1117342338,
-0.0781828016,
0.5366030335,
0.7058838606,
0.050765764,
0.6897212267,
0.6613122821,
-0.4772180021,
0.5930460691,
-0.4654604793,
-0.2126939893,
-0.6494232416,
0.102395311,
-0.2396700233,
-0.3698734939,
-0.4593646526,
-0.6237603426,
0.0755345747,
0.2842523158,
-0.296179235,
0.3794871867,
-0.2077995241,
0.762801528,
0.6980621815,
0.2961415946,
0.3394163251,
0.1957322806,
-0.1271670163,
0.0016094749,
-0.996874094,
-0.4975186884,
1.2971395254,
0.5327835083,
0.9561393857,
-0.0316326655,
0.9701206684,
0.2206656784,
0.74537009,
-0.7890976667,
0.288095355,
-0.2260388732,
-0.4718759954,
-0.3235060871,
-0.6818208694,
-0.7430075407,
0.4411222041,
-0.2035725117,
-0.3214319646,
-0.0925390646,
0.459663868,
-0.2566711903,
0.4899876714,
-0.9917906523,
1.0336546898,
-0.4934879541,
-0.2942934632,
0.0274129063,
-0.7037140727,
0.2941983044,
-0.2426597476,
0.1539840996,
0.1645860821,
0.2169535905,
0.7124093175,
-0.6969809532,
0.8987016082,
-0.3409937918,
0.1021716446,
0.1767825186,
-0.1863743812,
0.6456320286,
-0.0582732819,
0.1456184238,
-0.0640572682,
-0.2576557696,
-0.5188760161,
-0.5381426215,
0.615534544,
-0.8097087741,
-0.2602818906,
-0.0444977731,
0.0649800673,
-0.1158667058,
0.5049964786,
0.6151738167,
0.3135255277,
-0.4067389965,
0.5863619447,
0.6260131598,
0.2207303643,
0.356998831,
0.2966175377,
-0.0804413185,
-0.3082368374,
0.6837213039,
-0.1186763495,
0.3842916787,
0.4457753599,
0.5559710264,
0.0019291603,
-0.6444368362,
-0.6943187118,
0.093798086,
-0.6654213667,
-0.1753241122,
-0.235950157,
-0.1520638913,
-0.1569659561,
0.1746282727,
-0.7426157594,
-0.3701917827,
-0.18132779,
-0.1629888415,
0.134855777,
0.6800097823,
0.0450999886,
0.7640015483,
-0.6793686748,
0.1317611635,
0.2282857448,
0.4574092925,
0.1838154942,
-0.7680572867,
-0.4603677392,
0.2844396234,
0.0251416937,
-0.3467566967,
0.0916325226,
0.2762599587,
0.7437071204,
0.4936314821,
-0.248885721,
0.6121509075,
-0.8332431316,
0.5337554216,
0.463575542,
-0.8730362058,
0.5290712714,
-0.0418438017,
0.307934612,
0.8031166196,
0.411085546,
-0.2852062285,
0.013281526,
-0.6190107465,
-0.6009711623,
0.6289954782,
0.2559292912,
0.1326175779,
0.3114464283,
0.3596900403,
0.4781539738,
-0.0210001878,
-1.0358679295,
-0.5399651527,
-0.0686333477,
-0.2458302528,
-0.194591105,
-0.272714138,
-0.2297826558,
-0.3039458692,
0.546151042,
-0.0906871483,
0.3111161292,
-0.3493536413,
-0.481641531,
-0.1178077683,
0.1610371768,
0.5985135436,
0.5161197782,
-0.2392017841,
0.3258790672,
0.5597240329,
-0.5141093135,
0.1506992877,
-0.0738829449,
-0.1010178849,
-0.042411942,
0.4434605241,
1.2589341402,
0.307911247,
-0.2185331136,
0.4331028163,
-0.1019252017,
-0.231229499,
-0.1249137968,
-0.0141068259,
0.3534243405,
0.0816023201,
0.3125255406,
0.0470823534,
-0.1957392842,
-0.5799443722,
0.3299499452,
0.3557736278,
-0.2032336742,
-0.3212760985,
0.520257771,
0.1791737527,
-0.1092322171,
0.5332472324,
-0.1619899422,
-0.3134560585,
0.5768065453,
0.7275324464,
0.7762211561,
0.1182331741,
-0.1753844321,
-0.0257666204,
0.6863412261,
-0.2766326964,
-0.1051527783,
-0.0347837061,
-0.7487058043,
-0.2193514705,
-0.6253532767,
-0.5064612627,
0.2996949255,
-0.4525081813,
0.285846442,
-0.6496847868,
0.0435166284,
-0.0509055294,
0.0127590112,
-0.9112969637,
0.2207955867,
0.4780880213,
0.9209213853,
-0.9806668758,
1.0061882734,
0.6470716596,
-0.422303617,
-0.8908486366,
-0.1016547456,
-0.2716454268,
-0.9177119732,
1.0272454023,
0.1412281543,
-0.1643657833,
-0.0269505456,
-0.397094667,
-0.6628202796,
1.0268437862,
0.39668715,
-0.614230752,
-0.0678318515,
0.2438899875,
0.4692068398,
-0.4872198403,
0.1098484471,
0.5735166073,
0.2571766973,
0.1881716549,
-0.8962515593,
0.0799694881,
-0.1397706419,
-0.1290712059,
0.269374162,
-0.458691597,
0.8112534285,
-0.2380225807,
-0.1807343662,
0.2753540874,
0.5636788607,
0.1793707162,
0.2738340795,
0.6761555672,
0.6772096753,
0.5586006045,
-0.033360213,
0.9154292941,
-0.2830934227,
0.3866647184,
1.2754893303,
-0.1341827363,
0.8424589634,
0.4300538003,
-0.2629891634,
0.3266859651,
0.5840493441,
0.0756716505,
0.6039388776,
0.4465592206,
-0.1582591683,
-0.0354305096,
0.4559637606,
-0.6133673191,
0.1900861114,
0.1501331329,
-0.4403814077,
-0.1562208384,
0.1734385788,
-0.0199414976,
-0.4770280123,
-0.5591550469,
0.7367293239,
0.3219898045,
-0.2390184104,
0.5769970417,
-0.000381247,
0.6528530121,
-0.8226815462,
0.3132375777,
-0.5872081518,
0.298065275,
-0.1314992905,
-0.1516381502,
0.0609580763,
-0.0758541003,
-0.2332609743,
-0.2630539238,
0.8636805415,
-0.2282450199,
-0.538703382,
0.0314650312,
0.6400232315,
-0.0160971116,
-0.0941793099,
-0.3459400237,
-0.0794191808,
-0.1648170799,
-0.4206912816,
0.5708448887,
0.2593347728,
-0.11632853,
0.398886621,
0.5990782976,
0.311758101,
0.2709057331,
0.2622181475,
1.038651824,
-0.5086460114,
-0.4938996136,
-0.956194818,
0.1511150002,
0.0260405876,
-0.243646279,
0.8417598605,
0.9932150841,
0.8103731275,
-0.4360387921,
0.7847537994,
0.1733347327,
0.3522855937,
-0.6394745708,
0.5617244244,
-0.4990139604,
0.3384263515,
-0.1490822136,
-1.2207973003,
-0.1264564693,
0.582783103,
-0.2211968452,
0.2755416334,
0.5943291783,
0.5274232626,
-0.3699855506,
-0.1387918442,
0.2204658687,
-0.0617789924,
0.1829827279,
0.6343492866,
1.016554594,
-0.3489865959,
0.5868896246,
-0.2866286337,
-0.310272485,
-0.4813639522,
-0.8434298635,
-0.919985652,
0.1180103496,
0.0847293288,
-0.126773566,
0.1680092812,
1.1186977625,
0.9527798295,
-0.7927134037,
-0.2011898905,
-0.1543654203,
-0.0232091527,
-0.1739830077,
-0.114229843,
0.3357234299,
-0.0690048859,
-0.5504879355,
0.3856252134,
0.0296459682,
0.2106428891,
0.0424918979,
-0.39930439,
0.1680627465,
-0.2320200205,
0.8095030189,
0.3728962541,
-0.4105203152,
-0.4623301029,
-0.0368356518,
-0.315184921,
0.0931864157,
0.9817644954,
-0.6263255477,
0.1583425999,
0.4300602376,
0.8097218871,
0.876159966,
0.0577505194,
0.4914032519,
-1.1606439352,
0.1756790429,
0.081091769,
0.4528805017,
0.1384695321,
-0.0534403957,
0.5407540798,
0.4649460614,
-0.1352175623,
-0.7207077146,
0.2904590368,
-1.0856249332,
-0.2411538661,
1.0528668165,
0.2380100787,
0.1071980968,
0.4420914948,
-0.2679876983,
0.0672414526,
-0.1006316468,
0.318828702,
0.4497424364,
-0.1113494411,
-0.2537811399,
-0.3913214505,
0.6196299195,
0.5522118211,
-0.831769824,
0.0872075409,
0.1799121052,
0.5424946547,
-0.0041549136,
0.8577668667,
0.0520663932,
0.3293774128,
0.3497635126,
0.0190978013,
-0.2501969039,
-0.3222980201,
-0.3880619705,
0.0147907427,
0.4314682782,
-0.3194621801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08627v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08627v1
|
Is ChatGPT Transforming Academics' Writing Style?
| 2024-04-12T17:41:05 | 2024-04-12T17:41:05 |
Mingmeng Geng, Roberto Trotta
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DL, cs.LG
|
Based on one million arXiv papers submitted from May 2018 to January 2024, we
assess the textual density of ChatGPT's writing style in their abstracts by
means of a statistical analysis of word frequency changes. Our model is
calibrated and validated on a mixture of real abstracts and ChatGPT-modified
abstracts (simulated data) after a careful noise analysis. We find that ChatGPT
is having an increasing impact on arXiv abstracts, especially in the field of
computer science, where the fraction of ChatGPT-revised abstracts is estimated
to be approximately 35%, if we take the output of one of the simplest prompts,
"revise the following sentences", as a baseline. We conclude with an analysis
of both positive and negative aspects of the penetration of ChatGPT into
academics' writing style.
|
[
-0.3628818095,
-0.8296474814,
0.338244766,
0.2346249968,
-0.2492904067,
0.1823077351,
-0.1727502197,
-0.4682394564,
0.3716772795,
0.3481678665,
-0.3588870168,
-0.3546093702,
-0.8801496029,
0.3857527375,
-0.7896701694,
1.6127841473,
0.0406754129,
0.0307188984,
-0.1042294502,
0.0412374735,
0.0018550395,
-0.4089691937,
-0.8647251725,
-0.2530519962,
0.7232003212,
0.2643114328,
0.5199005604,
0.4364401996,
0.7424297929,
0.20032309,
-0.0732436925,
-0.318557173,
-0.5510308743,
0.115708448,
0.1435628682,
-0.4243236482,
-0.5836309791,
0.0358372182,
0.8783277869,
0.6789362431,
-0.2456929684,
0.0812428966,
0.3382770717,
0.9236063361,
-0.2477442026,
0.1933444738,
-0.6185799837,
-0.0980647802,
-0.3433667421,
-0.520855546,
-0.5983216763,
-0.3694759905,
0.357727766,
-0.3914470375,
0.3739014566,
0.3674739599,
0.5781899691,
-0.0865352973,
-0.252853483,
-0.1352563649,
-0.6298882961,
0.4372538328,
-0.4850258231,
0.2256848663,
-0.200448215,
0.0442168936,
-0.4216527641,
-0.9150599837,
-0.6091348529,
-0.0607516877,
0.039962206,
0.2234923244,
-0.448658824,
-0.0373349041,
0.0719273537,
0.2595918477,
-0.5680509806,
-0.4814985394,
-0.8165150285,
0.1466035247,
0.5823873281,
-0.0185004249,
0.6132381558,
0.3561371863,
-0.0764072761,
-0.3180367053,
-0.6848176718,
-0.1478909701,
0.4518254399,
0.1970462203,
0.1461772323,
0.4785865247,
-0.0519123301,
0.4364399016,
-0.2173296213,
0.0167714432,
0.0212197993,
-0.3282626569,
0.0600095615,
0.4077318013,
0.8905128837,
0.5836035013,
0.3849706948,
-0.0030890829,
-0.0372270197,
-0.1918018162,
0.4864002764,
-0.8536014557,
-0.7301647663,
-0.0853486061,
-0.5277359486,
-0.499705106,
-0.001733996,
-0.8621876836,
-0.6630353332,
-0.0879728869,
0.2275046706,
-0.7182311416,
-0.249526605,
0.1061110124,
-0.2274278104,
0.3031845987,
0.4948741496,
-0.8439847231,
0.3725099564,
0.7987787127,
1.1353617907,
-0.3982105851,
-0.2804073989,
-0.1525229365,
-0.3650377691,
-0.2770861089,
1.452753067,
-0.5858172774,
-0.8664367199,
-0.0717638358,
-0.2711913884,
-0.3049576879,
0.0652257577,
0.6058058143,
-0.3343521953,
0.3872216642,
-0.1787551492,
-0.1549902856,
-0.0755017549,
0.1427465677,
-0.3033225834,
0.8558046222,
0.0941161066,
-0.6937459707,
0.4824689925,
-0.9253367186,
-0.3991351426,
0.0146180624,
0.2984992266,
-0.6891725659,
-0.3133987784,
-0.0001576434,
0.1540864557,
0.2503274083,
-0.094013676,
-0.0237419177,
-0.4724796712,
0.5822476745,
-0.4016361237,
0.4067716599,
0.3141305745,
0.0826896727,
-0.1210544109,
-0.8814455867,
-0.0491214581,
-0.353277266,
-0.2881394327,
-0.1899471581,
0.2160862684,
0.2468261868,
-0.0657368302,
0.0071405745,
-0.6669238806,
0.5911175609,
-0.3460263014,
0.7025357485,
0.6309844255,
0.4842152596,
0.3037179708,
-0.6515666246,
0.6179289222,
-0.5263893604,
0.0194013733,
-0.0897139162,
-0.7986688018,
-0.5396152139,
-0.1847563684,
0.3499099016,
0.4447067976,
0.0040377304,
-0.1174807698,
-0.2224074155,
-0.850207448,
-0.3034570515,
-0.5184592009,
0.0268459637,
0.5536991954,
0.5257176161,
-0.4088980258,
-0.485368669,
-0.5972415805,
-0.72126019,
-0.3137092292,
0.1780428737,
-0.0890417397,
0.67420578,
-0.1781502217,
0.5748907924,
-0.3151009381,
-0.0585524999,
-0.1316554695,
0.7828726768,
-0.0215539001,
0.5135183334,
0.270821929,
-0.6186698675,
-0.8819049001,
-0.0063964953,
-0.0903211981,
-0.4428691566,
-0.4209071696,
-0.0467193089,
0.1476880461,
0.7624964714,
-0.2077893466,
0.5004629493,
0.4381343722,
-0.4985898733,
1.0098050833,
0.0186589863,
0.6326568127,
-0.6818552017,
0.0051283883,
0.1573605984,
0.1889036447,
-0.5825682878,
-0.1747954935,
-0.1102927178,
-0.3218021393,
-0.1097752824,
0.3929532766,
-0.3812889457,
0.283580631,
-0.2796095014,
0.1805714369,
0.0168379527,
0.135685727,
-0.132891655,
1.3509525061,
0.3461170495,
-0.3984293342,
-0.0919726044,
0.4028474092,
-0.470695287,
0.5590763092,
-0.8220265508,
0.0860099345,
-0.109866403,
0.4314968586,
-1.4349651337,
-0.0933271572,
0.2124810666,
-0.6313961148,
0.2352660596,
-0.4182769656,
-0.3929899335,
0.1844952255,
-0.3492474556,
0.0802574232,
0.6456364393,
0.0153404297,
0.6077545881,
0.0119634448,
-0.7802955508,
-0.4684563279,
-0.5808092952,
0.6228114367,
-0.0427086093,
-0.7481845617,
0.4940548837,
-0.0885094032,
-0.6893567443,
-0.0489652902,
0.0463656373,
-0.0168041606,
-0.1195787638,
0.0187106784,
0.2990626991,
-0.1052106544,
0.1336348206,
0.1554981619,
0.2097505182,
0.2372513264,
-0.1474633366,
0.7988244295,
-0.3616779447,
-0.1402469575,
-0.4167363346,
0.2740829289,
0.4536766708,
-0.3691646159,
0.7868736386,
0.5562842488,
0.4164846838,
0.0509552285,
-0.3901970387,
-0.1861073226,
-0.4629479647,
0.5014787316,
-0.0437151045,
-0.500595212,
0.4825805426,
0.003649798,
0.2794855535,
0.603969872,
0.352837503,
-0.1748349369,
0.8389189243,
0.7393383384,
0.4200256467,
0.7964025736,
-0.0188462436,
0.30304721,
-0.8268195987,
-0.2555308342,
-0.6990600228,
-0.3233763576,
-0.7352513075,
0.126821965,
0.5608401299,
-0.4046166837,
0.0026183303,
0.1549142897,
-0.9911980629,
0.5366758704,
0.369405508,
-0.0531261563,
0.2714629769,
0.1427303404,
0.4401332736,
-0.1585710049,
-0.4637604654,
-0.6803890467,
1.2146292925,
0.1476592422,
0.6106929779,
0.1146607995,
0.6686640978,
0.5449441671,
0.3721595407,
-0.7974291444,
0.589561522,
-0.052299168,
-0.098787874,
-0.2704950273,
-0.0088794576,
-1.0976365805,
0.1776778102,
-0.3961330056,
-0.6304509044,
0.2607392371,
-0.0055553718,
-0.1419431418,
0.4057016969,
-0.7255901694,
0.4364954531,
0.4167994857,
-0.2626049519,
-0.1463392973,
-0.4601100683,
0.0999312326,
-0.00207121,
0.056113828,
-0.1846957505,
-0.035979908,
1.1673933268,
-0.3660045564,
0.7768386006,
0.2290208787,
-0.0496364869,
0.3691806793,
0.3900868893,
0.5791642666,
0.1185081676,
-0.2053873092,
0.0441675335,
0.4563328922,
-0.3783402741,
-0.5127108693,
0.5541267395,
-0.7122892141,
-0.4458609819,
-0.9210701585,
-0.452691108,
-0.1384313852,
0.2153827399,
0.4465520978,
0.7348687649,
-0.4623494446,
0.1901012063,
0.7069752216,
0.0695692524,
0.2867269218,
0.28155002,
-0.0993383005,
-0.1454571486,
0.7349022031,
0.3831327558,
0.3158417046,
0.2081719041,
0.200897634,
0.0107551739,
-0.8112871647,
-0.2940983772,
0.0933104977,
-0.4948932827,
0.3195854723,
-1.1020284891,
-0.1288044453,
-0.8727099895,
-0.5169050694,
0.0038952802,
-0.7898014188,
-0.1882903576,
0.3635406494,
0.7115667462,
0.6555809975,
0.1092336476,
0.7349879742,
-0.4508516788,
-0.3757594526,
0.1580623388,
0.3368307352,
-0.3480243683,
-0.8231471181,
0.0761742666,
-0.1195293367,
-0.4014037251,
-0.7124443054,
0.6134521961,
0.3830980361,
0.035093382,
0.0685705841,
-0.3037433624,
0.2400705367,
-0.728497088,
1.0128344297,
-0.0555026978,
-0.4892670512,
0.298137635,
-0.7002331614,
0.334744215,
0.6387355328,
0.3040862679,
-1.2753176689,
-0.4478074014,
-0.8795391917,
-0.7263679504,
0.3560396433,
0.0888673961,
0.3473987579,
0.027799964,
0.3969229162,
0.1156627387,
0.1843877584,
-0.5317384601,
-0.3119918406,
-0.4007593989,
-0.0265355241,
0.2341968268,
-0.5593415499,
-0.1674315482,
-0.224406749,
0.7501015663,
0.218434602,
0.7673603892,
0.2273492068,
0.4060995281,
0.2474804074,
0.737329483,
0.9225639105,
0.9129659534,
-0.3898254335,
0.0502521247,
-0.0342390053,
-1.0045015812,
-0.2604964972,
0.0691028684,
-0.1802695692,
0.0963325724,
0.3997569084,
0.3273578584,
0.0073668458,
-0.282017827,
0.3999952078,
-0.0885750875,
-0.5589717031,
-0.5244160295,
0.3814693987,
-0.4188907146,
-0.1764655709,
0.5475127697,
0.6669176817,
0.5149987936,
-0.6145575047,
0.2224985808,
0.2834254205,
-0.5927526951,
-0.4326873422,
0.6279934049,
0.1321778446,
-0.385266453,
0.2995752096,
-0.2298856676,
-0.3811691999,
0.4751222432,
0.6683502793,
0.8767596483,
-0.0469439067,
0.279148072,
0.4078018367,
0.2566470504,
-0.2184077948,
0.08001104,
0.2852161825,
-0.5058482289,
-0.4214653373,
-0.410053432,
-0.705706656,
-0.0883980319,
-0.3284338713,
0.6523270607,
-0.5022933483,
0.0163744055,
0.3034983575,
-0.2254092395,
0.0412953123,
0.0302056968,
-0.3485431969,
0.6882474422,
-0.555516839,
0.4252412021,
0.828777194,
-0.2331250012,
-0.2845465839,
0.1152314246,
0.3178187609,
-0.7247062325,
0.3805244267,
-0.151300177,
-0.3721513152,
0.3220123351,
-1.0312423706,
-0.7435529232,
0.7324114442,
-0.3908969462,
-0.2337406576,
0.2121561766,
-0.0632855296,
0.8536271453,
-0.164810136,
0.2401235551,
0.4167313874,
0.4171063304,
-0.15334405,
-0.7430287004,
-0.4311540425,
-0.5546586514,
-0.3849299848,
0.6029642224,
-0.6572367549,
0.9995522499,
-0.0247872733,
-0.4590842724,
-0.2822061479,
0.5699868202,
-0.0297064018,
0.1155121922,
0.0370802656,
0.0410798118,
0.6539795399,
-0.1694747061,
1.0114929676,
-0.4711244702,
-0.0102863004,
0.6993685365,
-0.0139436908,
0.8376874328,
0.555919826,
-0.4113803208,
1.088706851,
0.2113649547,
-0.3197567463,
0.2647360861,
0.0677505061,
-0.6155033112,
0.1365086734,
-0.0615455657,
-0.6034330726,
0.316459775,
0.4872240126,
-0.3032774031,
-0.176996544,
0.137381047,
0.8190204501,
0.2653957307,
-0.2789499164,
0.762720108,
0.0128259873,
-0.6692939997,
0.4809544086,
0.1063684896,
0.6817904115,
-0.5292399526,
-0.1677437574,
-0.0508419387,
-0.0698191673,
-0.2863288522,
-1.146846652,
0.326292634,
-0.0862033069,
-0.1007362157,
-0.5276763439,
0.8694622517,
-0.3651453853,
-0.3966969848,
-0.6455589533,
0.2334083915,
0.2528338432,
-0.1738785207,
-0.4922770262,
-0.1632644236,
0.0508737601,
-0.1978750527,
0.5409317613,
0.5586990714,
0.0513727702,
0.7465233803,
0.6081579924,
0.1848767549,
-0.1043753102,
-0.2358243316,
0.6177542806,
-0.2384181768,
-0.4606323242,
-0.9212210774,
0.1582149416,
-0.1821058989,
-0.6370726824,
0.724983871,
0.42937693,
0.3874961138,
-0.0254041106,
0.9977176785,
-0.183281064,
0.4910026193,
-0.4152027667,
1.1528697014,
-0.1240530908,
0.1274184585,
-0.4370961785,
-0.7686264515,
-0.366928339,
0.4325058162,
-0.7666017413,
-0.1112484559,
0.7941461205,
0.6813147664,
0.1256031841,
0.3560377061,
-0.0468727835,
0.0385295749,
0.3571950197,
-0.0978846028,
0.4627770185,
-0.4823070467,
0.9010945559,
-0.3480281532,
-0.3028901517,
-0.3103950918,
-1.0306971073,
-0.6434798241,
-0.7899352312,
-0.7779065371,
-0.5503020883,
0.2503367066,
0.7104831338,
-0.0065738866,
-0.6563791037,
-0.0528126061,
-0.0620602779,
-0.3178884685,
-0.3705372214,
-0.2960933447,
0.5278801918,
-0.4626325667,
-0.5974795222,
0.1035867557,
0.3312776685,
0.2122820914,
0.1165939867,
0.5173051953,
-0.1877298951,
0.3058283627,
0.802077651,
0.4339132607,
-0.0862227082,
-0.4593114555,
0.2225262821,
-0.2183273882,
0.3969745934,
0.8175193667,
-0.4332284629,
0.3450624645,
0.6484138966,
0.2210701853,
0.2857029736,
0.1682635248,
0.4710851312,
-0.6147867441,
-0.2076559961,
0.1812936962,
0.3503090739,
0.0623389333,
-0.3564465642,
0.5635384321,
0.4001270235,
-1.1808056831,
-0.9202656746,
-0.2581303716,
-1.048470974,
-0.2060334384,
1.3387178183,
0.3623085618,
-0.2291245013,
-0.3266091943,
-0.6896025538,
-0.0827367231,
-0.7106781602,
1.13022089,
1.0221129656,
-0.5376335979,
-0.3568556011,
-0.8372916579,
0.8303234577,
0.2148724943,
-0.5606462359,
0.2099932879,
0.2657210529,
0.274684608,
0.1767129898,
0.7898799181,
-0.4500912428,
0.2622190118,
0.239866063,
0.3715678751,
-0.0051175486,
0.0436059944,
0.0779431388,
-0.0456342287,
0.1949066073,
0.4853444695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08617v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08617v1
|
Synthetic Dataset Creation and Fine-Tuning of Transformer Models for Question Answering in Serbian
| 2024-04-12T17:27:54 | 2024-04-12T17:27:54 |
Aleksa Cvetanović, Predrag Tadić
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we focus on generating a synthetic question answering (QA)
dataset using an adapted Translate-Align-Retrieve method. Using this method, we
created the largest Serbian QA dataset of more than 87K samples, which we name
SQuAD-sr. To acknowledge the script duality in Serbian, we generated both
Cyrillic and Latin versions of the dataset. We investigate the dataset quality
and use it to fine-tune several pre-trained QA models. Best results were
obtained by fine-tuning the BERTi\'c model on our Latin SQuAD-sr dataset,
achieving 73.91% Exact Match and 82.97% F1 score on the benchmark XQuAD
dataset, which we translated into Serbian for the purpose of evaluation. The
results show that our model exceeds zero-shot baselines, but fails to go beyond
human performance. We note the advantage of using a monolingual pre-trained
model over multilingual, as well as the performance increase gained by using
Latin over Cyrillic. By performing additional analysis, we show that questions
about numeric values or dates are more likely to be answered correctly than
other types of questions. Finally, we conclude that SQuAD-sr is of sufficient
quality for fine-tuning a Serbian QA model, in the absence of a manually
crafted and annotated dataset.
|
[
-0.4634726346,
-0.6431990266,
0.2971990407,
0.1104277149,
-0.2002553046,
0.5910291672,
0.0117020626,
-0.390670687,
0.332475841,
0.37386024,
-1.1861437559,
-0.4356081784,
-0.1568651795,
0.3411015272,
-0.1930300295,
1.2168363333,
-0.2526167035,
0.4733363986,
-0.1037850529,
-0.1838434935,
-0.4860693514,
-0.3941280246,
-0.3506984115,
-0.1398422122,
0.4016094506,
0.6106203794,
0.6541824341,
0.180672884,
0.5887656808,
0.2776937783,
0.2353251576,
0.1397300065,
-0.5899074674,
0.3270634413,
-0.1988649517,
-0.6466512084,
-0.1130451709,
-0.072388649,
0.6414383054,
0.2203344703,
-0.0108450977,
0.7852317691,
-0.5779107809,
0.4853987396,
-0.178710252,
0.252905041,
-0.7316266298,
-0.1048100516,
0.1556334049,
0.0137593541,
-0.3350818753,
-0.5218757391,
0.1945054829,
-0.7120611072,
0.5051300526,
0.0638180524,
1.0949006081,
0.299854517,
-0.3544705808,
-0.1414757073,
-0.9477872252,
0.7114363909,
-0.5029059052,
0.1681429297,
0.0668693483,
0.7213125229,
-0.1263099313,
-0.58805269,
-0.6041007638,
0.1749157757,
-0.0865394846,
0.4048798084,
-0.284940362,
-0.1420277357,
0.2318517268,
0.1517352015,
-0.9018929601,
-0.2441071421,
-0.7411273122,
-0.1302362978,
0.7126095891,
0.2139641494,
0.5469616055,
-0.2429361939,
-0.0587307736,
-0.1717246324,
-0.7483744025,
0.3609636426,
0.758047998,
0.3904971182,
0.2121733278,
0.8892785907,
-0.5343199372,
0.5374096632,
0.1266541481,
0.254327029,
0.0493936166,
-0.6292904615,
-0.1354330927,
-0.0108050508,
0.5971992016,
0.1564760804,
0.5597599745,
-0.3885074854,
0.0899352878,
0.413128525,
0.6257540584,
-0.8227114081,
-0.3600145578,
0.2113966495,
0.002568681,
-0.1747916043,
0.3048606217,
-0.5020136237,
0.3979832828,
-0.44709149,
0.401463896,
-0.3756359816,
-0.0633697361,
0.174594447,
0.003926734,
0.5648617148,
-0.0587376133,
-0.56220752,
0.2927226722,
0.4436158538,
0.3725642562,
-0.1438779384,
0.0770607591,
-0.3897399008,
-0.3139785826,
-0.3739394248,
1.0257220268,
-0.4241296947,
-0.0752981827,
-0.0202596057,
0.3030637205,
-0.2064483017,
-0.4395754933,
0.5580718517,
-0.9303461909,
0.4150952399,
-0.2214928865,
-0.3209459782,
-0.0661663562,
0.3692992926,
-0.576946795,
1.1114119291,
0.5124748349,
-0.5179767609,
0.296626389,
-0.4218491316,
-0.4081834853,
0.1274333894,
0.1248075962,
-0.3516068757,
-0.0129218688,
0.340117842,
0.0371857099,
-0.2423008531,
0.4145677686,
-0.0145055382,
-0.2452813834,
0.4392372072,
-0.0387024879,
0.6343919635,
0.1248850375,
0.0593582764,
0.1915497184,
-0.7550712228,
0.6488655806,
-0.0846491382,
-0.1233869269,
0.016106043,
-0.1903180927,
0.0349738225,
0.6631794572,
0.0496120192,
-0.9422745109,
0.1517919153,
-0.6068059802,
0.3576271236,
0.3101834953,
0.0368891396,
0.3730455935,
-0.5191376209,
1.2795331478,
-0.0529173538,
0.1567060053,
0.009150777,
-0.5311991572,
-0.482308805,
-0.1768584847,
0.5780915618,
0.8111843467,
-1.1962884665,
0.2662981749,
-0.2533892691,
-0.6557235718,
-1.098652482,
-0.0963825285,
0.4809302688,
0.5975229144,
0.3973574936,
0.1738706678,
-0.9710456729,
-1.1233570576,
-0.0924569145,
-0.3360956609,
-0.0883248076,
0.2852264047,
0.5626581311,
0.0946235731,
1.1629757881,
-0.6257128716,
-0.096165508,
-0.6645277143,
0.0240172315,
0.3027138114,
0.5051318407,
0.4892120957,
-0.9372902513,
-0.6082695723,
-0.2698816359,
-0.4777294993,
-0.11755272,
-0.0663650706,
-0.4416870475,
0.2080366611,
0.1070075408,
-0.6270543337,
0.2020761073,
0.6557388902,
-0.3849848211,
0.7696793675,
-0.1044953689,
0.4433151186,
-1.4438979626,
0.0963681787,
0.0252081193,
-0.2162430584,
-0.8951417804,
0.2875337005,
0.2142176479,
-0.2283228785,
-0.6940511465,
0.4624323547,
-0.1597903222,
0.0201398395,
0.0090409322,
-0.0001861317,
0.1897444427,
0.426792413,
-0.0648455992,
1.1919343472,
0.2635806799,
-0.2089082748,
0.4418470263,
0.8341285586,
-0.6033369899,
0.4259931743,
-1.0769946575,
0.0362262465,
-0.3537720442,
0.2374209017,
-1.3054002523,
-0.2776539326,
0.2821997404,
-0.5697757602,
0.2959050536,
-0.5259671211,
-0.6243252754,
-0.5734371543,
0.0611019731,
0.6268268824,
0.5682904124,
-0.2829246521,
0.4121832252,
0.3326996565,
-0.3981987238,
-0.3446961045,
-0.3828998208,
-0.1723359376,
-0.0808964595,
-0.9899331331,
0.3339381218,
-0.3371798098,
-0.049661845,
-0.3003966212,
-0.2357593775,
-0.3456811607,
-0.1322982907,
0.1666508764,
0.7267939448,
-0.371834904,
0.1215542704,
0.2337237746,
-0.0518436879,
0.0675633177,
-0.1119761169,
0.6530115008,
-0.1789619625,
0.0385392755,
-0.4559651017,
0.4836498201,
0.4717453122,
-0.3655431569,
0.7952299714,
0.4309456944,
-0.0296122245,
0.0663052946,
-0.4886139333,
-0.1779743284,
-0.4147023857,
0.1859903485,
-0.6305166483,
-0.7148548961,
0.9072424173,
0.2759716213,
-0.1912409067,
0.4385640621,
0.3860054314,
-0.3606941104,
1.3377642632,
0.3695904315,
0.0433901101,
0.252478689,
-0.4737797678,
0.2710018754,
-0.7502353787,
-0.4346222281,
-0.7812008262,
-0.4366317689,
-0.8372270465,
-0.1502074897,
0.4663386047,
-0.2511801422,
-0.1065232605,
0.5495898128,
-0.3661431372,
0.58317101,
0.5570144057,
0.1949501634,
0.1388319433,
-0.2985860705,
0.2389991432,
-0.1707466543,
-0.8632412553,
-0.5308690071,
1.0302757025,
-0.1344209462,
0.7075746655,
0.0303645339,
0.4606369138,
-0.1025520787,
0.0296948347,
-0.6844140887,
0.3263379633,
0.0351237208,
-0.872027576,
-0.3103039861,
-0.4528515339,
-0.7143552303,
0.0308183506,
-0.3366718888,
-0.312001735,
0.0540779941,
-0.0407975018,
-0.5105133653,
-0.1505084187,
-0.8972056508,
1.0045173168,
0.0856684968,
0.0618685707,
0.1560638547,
-0.8718969226,
0.4187033176,
0.0086108278,
-0.229288727,
-0.1906607598,
0.3355968893,
0.6418723464,
-0.0814712197,
0.3470429778,
-0.0344729908,
-0.0860316679,
0.2610865831,
0.0452254899,
0.397810787,
0.4472169876,
-0.1827133298,
-0.1559043676,
0.6588308811,
-0.6533489823,
-0.8447219133,
0.4692310989,
-0.9291439056,
-0.5253953934,
-0.3065115511,
-0.9380334616,
-0.3103967905,
0.1152725965,
0.4737093151,
0.6058230996,
-0.3977282047,
0.1015809029,
0.731444478,
-0.2650653124,
-0.0471272543,
0.7942820191,
0.0334505066,
-0.2907484174,
0.6256235838,
0.2069996744,
0.4568018913,
0.2780981362,
-0.1949531287,
-0.4821914732,
-0.3959681094,
-0.8128963113,
0.3301880658,
-0.2377711684,
-0.5580801368,
-0.5723417401,
-0.4291161001,
-0.6483725905,
0.1117911115,
-0.245907262,
-0.6802565455,
-0.2698812187,
-0.1268992573,
0.2785660625,
0.3765100539,
0.5139883161,
0.3097620606,
-0.7362086177,
0.7990601063,
-0.0231104698,
0.2686898112,
-0.7016475797,
-0.650853157,
-0.1369041204,
0.5118629336,
-0.164785713,
-0.8079941869,
0.6283426881,
0.1763209552,
0.3875905275,
-0.1672359854,
0.5020142794,
0.6616230607,
-0.5178057551,
0.6993663907,
-0.2980823815,
-0.6795950532,
0.7130389214,
-0.4401722252,
0.6138681173,
0.9110748768,
0.5577096939,
-0.3254369795,
-0.6879609823,
-0.7086167932,
-0.5220094919,
0.9694274068,
0.4227606058,
0.3298665285,
-0.1050257087,
0.4973082542,
0.1869531572,
0.1587748677,
-0.3487364352,
-0.1983677447,
-0.1946172118,
-0.4144613743,
-0.0243969094,
-0.0539378524,
-0.0478815772,
-0.5056269765,
0.9683468938,
-0.3572317362,
0.2018926591,
0.1170332953,
-0.2822729349,
-0.2294211239,
0.4053918719,
0.721193254,
0.7775972486,
-0.2952418029,
-0.3609652221,
0.1546304971,
-0.3424715102,
0.4161985219,
0.0043834974,
-0.4922042191,
0.0973339304,
-0.1746616811,
0.5863265991,
0.0415076502,
-0.9014880061,
0.2149408162,
-0.387180537,
-0.2452991456,
-0.4715338647,
0.1445225477,
-0.2978603244,
0.2565201521,
0.3896906674,
0.0738534406,
0.0188899562,
-0.7116423249,
0.2714016736,
0.5553681254,
-0.3140515089,
-0.5985403061,
0.3848353326,
-0.2024873346,
-0.3138911128,
0.792879045,
-0.028618725,
-0.7435581684,
0.7894281745,
0.6262599826,
0.4134869277,
-0.2393143475,
0.8391190767,
0.4578415751,
0.2119045854,
-0.0827288851,
0.7552666664,
0.1244127154,
-0.7981411219,
-0.5213760734,
-0.5439549088,
-0.3815846741,
-0.1992670298,
-1.134770155,
0.1107937843,
-0.0816675425,
-0.0797632635,
-0.0577912964,
0.4195222855,
-0.7201594114,
0.4016283751,
-0.4896183908,
0.9481261373,
-0.9160788655,
0.8488388658,
0.7480930686,
-0.4964533448,
-0.8274314404,
-0.3160735369,
-0.5819159746,
-0.7431342602,
0.7663081288,
-0.044503998,
0.1021082178,
0.3205725551,
-0.5062422752,
-0.988947928,
0.9427562952,
0.474632293,
-0.2096831501,
-0.2947076261,
0.4195177555,
0.9517019987,
-0.4632145464,
0.2525810301,
0.8695734143,
0.3821786046,
0.3176451921,
-0.5688593388,
-0.1289251447,
-0.5051180124,
-0.0775890648,
0.2393041849,
-0.494651407,
0.3525497615,
-0.1905983388,
-0.3283579946,
0.5948384404,
0.5455030799,
0.1653773487,
0.0098216543,
-0.0545708649,
0.3351418674,
0.4043786824,
-0.441077441,
0.9906918406,
-0.3284530044,
0.1307332963,
1.0846068859,
-0.3259964883,
0.7044271231,
0.5201884508,
-0.0950208753,
0.5701473355,
0.4152237177,
-0.1735182106,
0.4793212712,
0.3062308133,
-0.0285252817,
-0.4229296148,
0.0188066922,
-0.0849732161,
0.5210704803,
-0.0496832803,
-0.1004045308,
-0.238213256,
0.2065292895,
-0.4161601067,
0.1028728187,
0.0067027891,
1.0357028246,
-0.37275666,
-1.0872933865,
0.4758097231,
-0.15598014,
0.206098333,
-0.5814660192,
0.1803259701,
-0.3651588559,
0.0192829762,
0.0117857978,
-0.8747295141,
0.5377550125,
0.095304966,
-0.6860778332,
-0.3122596741,
0.4090841711,
-0.751008451,
-1.0274840593,
-0.2906836569,
0.5237381458,
0.0009024875,
-0.097393848,
-0.5863769054,
-0.2156481147,
-0.1218940169,
0.2680540681,
0.3055526018,
0.2781855464,
0.015832385,
0.7784941196,
0.6142980456,
0.2681285739,
0.247110799,
0.0749775469,
0.8088648319,
-0.3737092912,
-0.3676248491,
-0.4152748287,
0.5802432299,
0.1336193979,
-0.3400243521,
0.6522672772,
0.6750725508,
0.8496174216,
-0.4002298713,
0.5999714136,
0.1259604245,
0.8127104044,
-0.414930135,
0.6403920054,
-0.0624838434,
-0.0894315466,
-0.2233711779,
-0.8381972313,
-0.2493886054,
0.4411009252,
-0.1905022115,
-0.2795711756,
0.3884702921,
1.0462136269,
-0.108877413,
0.1869321764,
0.3023414612,
0.0061013633,
0.3828895092,
0.5016763806,
0.9265358448,
-1.1041477919,
0.816861093,
-0.1764392704,
0.1663869172,
0.1144678667,
-0.3507699668,
-0.7928847671,
-0.7015417218,
-0.3587233126,
-0.3319469988,
0.0994341895,
0.8274828792,
0.6413552165,
-1.1679060459,
0.0083417427,
0.0814832076,
0.033903338,
-0.1204738393,
-0.2694170475,
0.0786172152,
-0.5206679106,
-0.7204780579,
0.3872355521,
-0.1731535941,
0.162849009,
-0.0873984918,
0.1542318016,
-0.3356928527,
0.1986896396,
0.4723763466,
0.3508194089,
-0.5841061473,
-0.3561473191,
0.7444442511,
0.1111499295,
0.2354034781,
0.9462367892,
-1.0865387917,
0.4453607202,
0.6499763131,
0.5257946849,
0.4325979054,
0.4443677962,
1.0247768164,
-0.8288068175,
-0.14031142,
0.3665889204,
0.1921949238,
0.2068208009,
-0.2250606269,
0.3354194164,
-0.2231920213,
-0.5306005478,
-0.753723681,
0.2292218506,
-1.0619536638,
-0.0182810575,
1.0659729242,
-0.1922421455,
-0.1978651285,
-0.3960321844,
-0.5919021964,
0.4471101761,
-0.3040079474,
1.0503205061,
0.7333987355,
0.04503645,
-0.0249245334,
-0.3552084565,
0.5656713247,
0.3413584828,
-1.0281152725,
-0.0615404546,
0.4692385495,
0.3945625424,
-0.0293513872,
0.0745213106,
-0.0757525712,
0.5685316324,
-0.5482732654,
-0.209555313,
-0.0406130664,
-0.5537650585,
-0.1806842238,
0.0667243749,
-0.4333574772,
-0.1174493358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08727v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08727v1
|
Can LLMs substitute SQL? Comparing Resource Utilization of Querying LLMs versus Traditional Relational Databases
| 2024-04-12T16:44:28 | 2024-04-12T16:44:28 |
Xiang Zhang, Khatoon Khedri, Reza Rawassizadeh
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL, 68-04, H.2.m
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) can automate or substitute different types of
tasks in the software engineering process. This study evaluates the resource
utilization and accuracy of LLM in interpreting and executing natural language
queries against traditional SQL within relational database management systems.
We empirically examine the resource utilization and accuracy of nine LLMs
varying from 7 to 34 Billion parameters, including Llama2 7B, Llama2 13B,
Mistral, Mixtral, Optimus-7B, SUS-chat-34B, platypus-yi-34b,
NeuralHermes-2.5-Mistral-7B and Starling-LM-7B-alpha, using a small transaction
dataset. Our findings indicate that using LLMs for database queries incurs
significant energy overhead (even small and quantized models), making it an
environmentally unfriendly approach. Therefore, we advise against replacing
relational databases with LLMs due to their substantial resource utilization.
|
[
-0.0857658535,
-0.8138335347,
0.790625453,
0.2393405139,
-0.2072283775,
0.0469182134,
-0.2271333337,
-0.6311814189,
0.0606264845,
0.9659875631,
-0.383172214,
-0.3840712607,
0.2353215814,
0.3674277067,
-0.4093765318,
0.3298959136,
-0.1747432798,
0.1783663929,
-0.4285645783,
-0.1077300012,
-0.5748336911,
-0.7074822187,
-0.3705049455,
-0.3405612111,
0.3457310796,
0.1042950153,
0.9229738116,
0.5609542131,
0.6788199544,
0.3411272764,
-0.1101244017,
0.1508036107,
-0.3507976532,
0.2298934311,
-0.2946249247,
-0.4778677225,
-0.45041278,
-0.0270521306,
0.5816820264,
0.8398476243,
-0.4717530012,
0.3557176292,
0.1048208401,
1.1097457409,
-0.6379620433,
0.4155254662,
-0.9839843512,
0.1936440468,
-0.3648509085,
-0.1193351075,
-0.5914834142,
-0.3843954802,
-0.1353857666,
-0.5441603065,
-0.0907289088,
0.4368413985,
0.5801483989,
0.4431654215,
-0.3478860855,
-0.3001639843,
-1.012675643,
1.0136735439,
-0.8454089165,
0.3301831484,
0.2685718238,
0.2752601206,
-0.3495335579,
-0.3700665236,
-0.6042886376,
-0.4320753217,
-0.4069001973,
-0.1077677533,
-0.0716448203,
0.4074244499,
0.5260697007,
0.3350138366,
-0.6257371902,
0.4506434798,
-0.1780381054,
-0.0106628444,
0.7047585249,
0.6384913325,
0.1603659093,
-0.4348627925,
-0.2700305581,
0.1928972602,
-0.9319253564,
-0.2692978084,
0.0482131727,
0.4759828448,
0.2539704442,
0.7875474095,
-0.0717437118,
1.1404935122,
-0.3981436491,
-0.1586327255,
-0.1130437404,
-0.4814158976,
-0.6963207126,
-0.0379410982,
0.911973238,
0.4292893112,
0.2320562452,
-0.2708391249,
-0.2854177356,
-0.0508650318,
0.1297742128,
-0.4698710144,
-0.0839207843,
0.2285051793,
-0.3862330914,
0.0057062618,
-0.2047520429,
-0.5031529665,
-0.6194271445,
-0.4198421836,
0.2433651537,
-0.3639058173,
-0.1928774118,
-0.0444532037,
0.2561038733,
0.3350209594,
0.2876396477,
-0.6276007891,
0.5439076424,
0.4651817083,
0.8583233356,
-0.225592196,
0.0646334141,
-0.0487635806,
0.2930549979,
-0.4890030324,
0.6364663243,
-0.4798957407,
-0.7642108798,
-0.3228403628,
-0.1774570048,
-0.0868951976,
-1.0514916182,
0.2495423704,
-0.7175438404,
0.0387509502,
-0.4918206036,
-0.7272258997,
-0.0456310511,
-0.2162588835,
-1.0431649685,
1.1177477837,
0.1513718367,
-0.268755734,
0.2447193265,
-0.5838290453,
-0.3001514375,
0.0286417473,
-0.1411576122,
-0.3042984605,
0.0285025965,
-0.0151929567,
0.35014081,
-0.8393745422,
0.0262642335,
-0.3140133619,
-0.6909819841,
0.560002923,
-0.2305425256,
0.6762645841,
0.4077984691,
-0.0470749177,
-0.4323722124,
-0.6787102222,
0.214984253,
0.130779162,
-0.443920821,
-0.3772762418,
0.3351318538,
-0.0211421028,
0.0450681895,
0.1482523978,
-0.389516294,
0.188558042,
-0.44090873,
0.3244301081,
0.5660315752,
0.0194026548,
0.6283772588,
-0.2435430437,
0.4730921984,
-0.2329928726,
0.0804520547,
0.1765343994,
-0.0949444696,
-0.4802481234,
-0.0574756712,
0.1452269405,
0.6771059632,
-0.6136778593,
0.2336802781,
-0.1616306603,
-0.5427937508,
-0.2124477774,
0.4377623796,
0.12145219,
0.2676332295,
0.3671744466,
0.1860360354,
-0.7817893624,
-0.7667272091,
-0.7444697022,
-0.3509352207,
-0.0950382799,
0.7642700672,
0.242093578,
0.1081845388,
1.0027632713,
-0.2000309676,
-0.3052481115,
0.054431051,
-0.362261951,
0.5692355633,
0.3152829707,
0.5444725752,
-0.5283990502,
-0.6295344234,
0.0141472388,
-1.1298466921,
-0.2159108818,
-0.3661926687,
-0.0211790055,
0.7113315463,
0.4534963071,
-0.8705347776,
-0.0134387044,
0.4325286746,
-0.0958043709,
0.5046315193,
-0.0216522478,
0.1535043269,
-0.6325958371,
0.069335945,
0.0409633107,
0.0217748452,
-0.466160506,
0.072553128,
0.1011557057,
-0.2062528729,
-0.505898416,
0.3535045683,
-1.0490701199,
-0.4882626534,
0.0341654569,
0.1063938886,
0.0463078134,
0.0212432984,
-0.1402714103,
1.0510547161,
0.3831705749,
-0.7437172532,
0.584394753,
-0.0507837795,
-0.5185310841,
0.5201630592,
-0.5690888166,
0.2784507275,
-0.0459023975,
0.097879611,
-0.6681790352,
-0.0640096441,
-0.0019278103,
-0.0058948798,
0.2104200274,
-0.2082723975,
-0.8564302325,
-0.2546656728,
-0.2829370201,
-0.1471074969,
0.5979651809,
-0.4456453919,
0.6692618132,
0.2635275424,
-0.0491960309,
-0.3706222773,
-0.9720217586,
0.4240902066,
-0.2620508075,
-0.5902722478,
0.3327546418,
0.3696861565,
-0.5424695015,
0.139860779,
-0.2175422758,
-0.0053587314,
0.1932400614,
0.1347548515,
0.499935776,
-0.4003666639,
0.2432675958,
-0.3080257773,
0.1830283403,
0.2837534249,
-0.0350827463,
0.3694083691,
0.1405247748,
-0.5891976953,
-0.4645449221,
0.1550575644,
0.6170065403,
0.0903542638,
1.169377923,
0.0336354077,
-0.3937114477,
0.053906098,
-0.7212972045,
-0.1534306109,
-0.4916577339,
0.2288364023,
-0.1502643675,
-0.5869981647,
0.4552946091,
-0.0036257899,
0.1385075003,
0.4116345346,
0.2554565668,
-0.4131688476,
0.7167797089,
0.2375103086,
-0.0613514595,
0.5190903544,
-0.1605142951,
0.1210192069,
-0.696325779,
-0.1462029368,
-0.5668865442,
-0.1961818486,
-0.6591039896,
-0.5882140994,
0.4865507185,
0.1198594943,
-0.2868757248,
0.3088431954,
-0.3790631294,
0.6702232957,
0.1566238254,
0.0189665277,
0.5250530839,
0.2987817228,
0.352448374,
-0.2697393,
-0.5916975737,
-0.7106518745,
1.0414705276,
-0.0408664383,
1.1996650696,
0.3446300328,
0.5500039458,
0.1269402206,
0.3795756996,
-0.5275326967,
0.8423348665,
-0.1283162534,
-0.5607095361,
-0.5221950412,
-0.7325250506,
-0.9255123734,
0.4327291548,
-0.209673062,
-0.5772290826,
-0.0302269626,
0.1502299756,
-0.1934565306,
0.602386117,
-0.834292531,
0.6824668646,
-0.4367201924,
-0.3609901667,
-0.4328227937,
-0.1190729588,
0.3246833384,
-0.2216967344,
0.2111391127,
-0.199834004,
-0.2922586203,
0.6154034734,
-0.5075146556,
0.7242853642,
-0.2840976119,
0.0026172092,
0.4887964725,
0.2931878269,
0.7545837164,
-0.2584069967,
-0.701077342,
0.142226398,
0.0339354835,
-0.2906502485,
-0.6890000701,
0.8131873608,
-0.449570328,
-0.7518084049,
-0.6304659843,
-0.3724295497,
-0.3407167196,
0.028628625,
-0.1519982517,
-0.0338836648,
-0.2734594643,
0.1905456483,
0.4089227021,
-0.3466629684,
0.4257548153,
0.752225697,
-0.2888844609,
0.2278568447,
0.7999204993,
0.4962427616,
0.3324619234,
0.3493959904,
0.0198780969,
-0.5236932039,
-0.6144666076,
-0.3010383844,
0.4483658671,
-0.3476122022,
-0.4482801557,
-0.5800994039,
-0.0292146411,
-0.1264247298,
0.0032045792,
-0.3993180096,
-0.2481855899,
-0.4869478047,
0.0351971835,
0.613085568,
0.7259289622,
0.379472971,
0.1627053171,
-0.9399282932,
-0.033825051,
0.0911568776,
0.5292526484,
-0.0201074649,
-0.2704255879,
-0.1452981383,
0.0559001118,
-0.0980679244,
-1.0265043974,
0.2591081262,
0.2505248189,
0.8452784419,
-0.2610153258,
0.1578689516,
0.5937542915,
-0.3678991497,
0.777561605,
-0.0047172047,
-0.8316345811,
0.486867696,
-0.2324985415,
0.1069736257,
0.2896510959,
0.3963947594,
-0.4312418103,
-0.1809872985,
-0.3069035411,
-0.7126587033,
0.7036969662,
0.2390624583,
-0.001341481,
0.1943507195,
0.5697036386,
-0.2723109722,
0.3158511221,
-0.6839914322,
-0.279201746,
0.3188443482,
0.1575319767,
0.1204493567,
-0.3274525106,
0.1889485121,
-0.0200141333,
0.5364895463,
-0.0000663882,
0.1520656049,
-0.1652151793,
-0.2613976598,
-0.1266618073,
0.3449681401,
0.0694866925,
0.7483659983,
-0.3283944726,
-0.1250932217,
0.575450182,
-0.133820042,
0.03192316,
-0.0930932313,
0.0313004181,
0.1869419217,
0.0482734293,
0.4760434926,
0.0525556244,
-0.7491013408,
-0.1984812021,
0.1822150052,
0.1888527721,
-0.3413428664,
0.1587443501,
0.4300406873,
0.1443604529,
0.1852344126,
-0.2111805677,
0.15002428,
-0.6281324029,
-0.3913064003,
0.7376612425,
0.060531199,
0.1065358892,
0.5692724586,
0.1487050503,
-0.1628908366,
0.7330950499,
-0.0037667532,
0.1028922424,
0.4402888417,
0.3109571338,
0.3396661878,
-0.3120644391,
-0.0657766834,
0.2236855328,
0.4457618296,
-0.1097459868,
0.4804961979,
0.2387006283,
-0.6226165891,
-0.7848552465,
-0.6822924614,
-0.6972421408,
0.0129035609,
-0.5670239329,
0.0771310925,
-0.6304246187,
-0.264631331,
0.072164312,
0.0015695062,
-0.5418590903,
-0.1032879204,
-0.0347282588,
0.8552122712,
-0.6409891844,
0.7795313597,
0.9435590506,
-0.3743568063,
-0.7184330821,
-0.4689779282,
0.2482385188,
-0.6463745832,
0.5966444612,
-0.4025855362,
-0.1607982963,
-0.3085569441,
-0.3493520916,
-0.9568788409,
1.2852218151,
0.6565990448,
-0.7434281111,
-0.0472228564,
0.4450573325,
0.6572238207,
0.006509169,
0.0831726044,
0.6831082106,
0.3776017129,
-0.1149590239,
-1.0618792772,
0.1811900288,
0.2643887997,
0.469165653,
0.3673432767,
-0.5301741362,
0.8941743374,
-0.2415231615,
-0.5564098954,
0.0094788605,
0.5101780891,
0.3833959699,
0.019524537,
0.5318764448,
0.1233894825,
0.8428502083,
0.0372878127,
1.1423023939,
-0.4863502979,
0.4207539856,
0.7416269183,
-0.9382793307,
0.7931284904,
0.7405427694,
-0.9219636321,
0.2877037823,
0.5347624421,
0.1069941074,
0.0080528548,
0.2631720304,
-0.3286747932,
-0.1451718807,
-0.0161804166,
-0.3119437099,
0.2191975862,
0.551422298,
-0.1934912205,
-0.1587463766,
-0.4057510793,
-0.0034622659,
0.2239304334,
-0.1155617908,
0.6635846496,
0.3555167317,
-0.3543218076,
0.7985360622,
0.0653304011,
0.4879074395,
-0.3500099778,
0.014608711,
-0.2756565213,
0.0254829321,
-0.400893867,
-0.8987945914,
0.4703097939,
0.0310307499,
0.0151520586,
-0.3071546853,
0.7272200584,
-0.0330844894,
-0.4153606594,
0.2149459571,
0.6890333891,
0.1733811498,
-0.3739046752,
-0.866340518,
0.0625939816,
-0.1452116519,
-0.3200070262,
0.5166116953,
0.3583499789,
0.1010171548,
0.7947416902,
0.6285390854,
0.3272252977,
-0.1544400454,
-0.0216552857,
0.7347016931,
-0.8794907331,
-0.2227776647,
-0.9867336154,
-0.0429448187,
-0.129520461,
0.3098589182,
0.9069898725,
0.6020824909,
0.5115178227,
-0.0137834074,
0.6007667184,
0.1320551485,
0.6376368403,
-1.0592166185,
0.4600910246,
-0.3799746037,
0.9251775146,
-0.3634211719,
-1.354593873,
-0.0846927539,
0.5672022104,
-0.3134916127,
0.1386142224,
0.6204057932,
1.0912652016,
0.1849951148,
0.1151907742,
0.3066314459,
0.4408617616,
0.1969233751,
0.3309549093,
0.8678366542,
-0.1317657083,
0.4523071945,
-0.0569662638,
0.1164140105,
-0.3591560721,
-0.7681373954,
-0.4268025458,
-0.0680021495,
-0.227627337,
-0.5244658589,
0.134624362,
0.8997731209,
0.2784588039,
-0.8119951487,
-0.7909746766,
0.1296125352,
0.2372309864,
-0.1775345057,
-0.2660703659,
0.1882630289,
-0.287185967,
-0.4810461104,
0.4330649376,
0.2870640159,
0.093933247,
-0.5204569697,
0.0783497766,
-0.1553042978,
-0.0991113931,
0.7066146135,
0.2271246314,
-0.6502155066,
-0.1724385619,
0.4219974875,
-0.4698907137,
0.0833904892,
0.8163447976,
-0.7931773067,
-0.0256990734,
0.3290844262,
0.4486504495,
0.4774059653,
-0.1317562759,
0.4351499379,
-0.5823766589,
0.0015404613,
0.3086386323,
0.4906714857,
0.397903055,
-0.4817237556,
0.623298347,
0.3488506079,
-0.6358503103,
-0.9057697058,
0.1018559635,
-0.9727370143,
-0.3148448169,
1.233946681,
0.2354082614,
-0.3116040826,
-0.2021193355,
-0.1349455714,
-0.238188073,
-0.236188367,
0.411218524,
0.5321484208,
-0.6732766032,
-0.151696533,
-0.8030794859,
0.4655317366,
0.5318547487,
-0.7419918776,
0.2208350003,
0.7476908565,
0.3060328066,
-0.0089216651,
0.7954059839,
-0.1780753285,
0.0601417981,
-0.023270525,
0.0796928927,
0.1404281408,
0.3363664746,
-0.1633427441,
-0.1013820544,
0.2581795752,
0.1308855563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08579v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08579v1
|
Small Models Are (Still) Effective Cross-Domain Argument Extractors
| 2024-04-12T16:23:41 | 2024-04-12T16:23:41 |
William Gantt, Aaron Steven White
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Effective ontology transfer has been a major goal of recent work on event
argument extraction (EAE). Two methods in particular -- question answering (QA)
and template infilling (TI) -- have emerged as promising approaches to this
problem. However, detailed explorations of these techniques' ability to
actually enable this transfer are lacking. In this work, we provide such a
study, exploring zero-shot transfer using both techniques on six major EAE
datasets at both the sentence and document levels. Further, we challenge the
growing reliance on LLMs for zero-shot extraction, showing that vastly smaller
models trained on an appropriate source ontology can yield zero-shot
performance superior to that of GPT-3.5 or GPT-4.
|
[
-0.3776775002,
-0.7000951171,
1.0104877949,
-0.5391254425,
-0.2535180449,
-0.2287788838,
0.056561213,
-0.5866033435,
-0.1941508949,
0.3690330386,
-0.5227375031,
-0.2145224214,
-0.6775854826,
0.1341937035,
-0.5573502779,
1.0369235277,
-0.0106880441,
-0.2082129121,
-0.1591094136,
-0.1251724511,
-0.4043897688,
-0.4138838947,
-0.9448742867,
-0.2529402673,
0.6514453888,
0.656416595,
0.2834240794,
0.6914284229,
0.3271921873,
0.0123232054,
0.2288554907,
-0.1047083884,
-0.3356334567,
-0.0896513462,
-0.6178088188,
-0.561054647,
-0.3904811144,
0.1218672842,
0.4014530778,
0.3808993995,
0.086146906,
0.3409517705,
-0.2104276121,
0.0689268708,
-0.8608430624,
-0.1505748034,
-0.8331964612,
0.1438550353,
-0.3572612405,
-0.143347308,
-0.5408369899,
0.0136227272,
0.4291875362,
-0.613391757,
0.1283153296,
-0.0757064447,
1.1108459234,
-0.0177888554,
-0.4189151525,
-0.2697908878,
-0.7503112555,
0.8519877791,
-0.9702954292,
-0.0923070237,
0.0894776955,
0.1537565142,
0.1239784434,
-1.0042970181,
-0.7780262828,
0.2619462311,
0.1135562882,
0.1705643535,
-0.7357380986,
-0.0449351817,
0.3558428288,
-0.0631258935,
-0.6044203639,
0.2252514064,
-0.3011362851,
-0.0028189574,
0.6184357405,
0.1745280027,
0.3830420077,
-0.4914848804,
-0.3459836543,
-0.0351487547,
-0.8138546944,
-0.1645497084,
-0.0552752726,
0.3006320894,
0.0317124575,
0.5842934251,
0.0523235314,
0.7142577767,
0.2116463184,
-0.0425972156,
-0.6373050213,
-0.571972847,
-0.4849335253,
-0.1274447441,
0.6333515644,
0.2226257771,
0.2758304477,
-0.4947740436,
0.2631319761,
-0.1658954918,
0.2371903807,
-0.9932634234,
-0.0604169518,
0.2754670382,
-0.4681702554,
-0.2139519006,
0.061242383,
-0.9435606003,
-0.2304824144,
0.0590032674,
0.6916840672,
-0.319716543,
0.1335045099,
0.1223236099,
-0.5009563565,
0.6432583928,
0.4756594598,
-0.5831931829,
0.2254348546,
0.7057042122,
0.7780664563,
-0.2630479634,
0.1681892574,
-0.8130661845,
0.4619404078,
-0.4602690637,
1.3745210171,
-0.5953053236,
-0.28377074,
0.0196144618,
-0.2150248736,
-0.1786648631,
-0.402751416,
0.7706261873,
-0.3406791687,
0.5464786887,
-0.3542821109,
-0.9677348137,
-0.2416381389,
0.2330605239,
-0.3144483268,
0.721247673,
0.0614683665,
-0.2581633627,
0.4989497364,
-0.8049364686,
-0.1958368123,
0.1071915329,
-0.3908670247,
-0.149379611,
0.3613429666,
0.2332470566,
0.5747698545,
-0.5950959325,
-0.5451807976,
-0.4648844004,
-0.1759998053,
-0.0281029455,
-0.3063874841,
0.6342138648,
0.1665425897,
-0.3986648619,
-0.2944434285,
-0.8751312494,
0.054092098,
0.2908077538,
0.1087840572,
-0.3311942518,
-0.2752568722,
-0.3826093674,
0.5671529174,
-0.2543278635,
-0.9696147442,
0.5228572488,
-0.4353093207,
0.4152402878,
0.3410334289,
0.2507369518,
0.7514737248,
-0.4205808342,
0.763843298,
0.0575146452,
-0.167473048,
-0.1814740002,
-0.5850734115,
-0.7283979654,
-0.2576633692,
0.4794493318,
0.5455484986,
-1.0054805279,
-0.0815788507,
-0.2755780518,
-0.5186665058,
-0.5496852994,
-0.1079559326,
0.1488390267,
0.6086817384,
0.3361378312,
-0.0022190076,
-0.2575611472,
-0.6489115953,
-0.3831850886,
-0.3565011322,
-0.1593849212,
0.3294931948,
0.3422938585,
0.407282263,
1.1342978477,
-0.4619237483,
-0.4381401837,
-0.4942535758,
0.402276516,
0.0104809785,
0.1317116618,
1.062641263,
-0.2782199681,
-0.7649251819,
0.1166018993,
-0.8632631302,
-0.271849215,
-0.5027229786,
-0.1864174604,
0.1762984693,
0.3975343704,
-0.8789672852,
0.6806126833,
0.1619231403,
-0.4165565968,
0.2612120211,
0.2488662302,
0.0585734658,
-1.2168569565,
-0.192043215,
0.0591107607,
-0.491181463,
-0.7874997258,
-0.0570259094,
-0.0247853026,
-0.0214419086,
-0.8075191975,
0.9527171254,
-0.4981468618,
0.2016756386,
-0.5281387568,
0.6407680511,
0.3507238925,
0.1759221703,
-0.0020394186,
0.5193226337,
0.484570235,
-0.1975750178,
0.1387773454,
0.4603127837,
0.0654034019,
0.8659146428,
-0.4524260461,
0.5127481818,
-0.0105076302,
0.0994144008,
-0.9258566499,
0.1611033231,
0.3968984187,
-0.1527110785,
0.4335838854,
-0.7020815611,
-0.161131382,
-0.0322300419,
-0.5155044794,
0.1515153944,
0.5982379913,
-0.5003415942,
0.7026236057,
0.0728617087,
-0.3537587523,
-0.3016162515,
-0.6236718893,
0.2568703294,
-0.4503946602,
-0.5829837322,
0.3913760781,
0.1537765712,
-0.2466448843,
0.2812462449,
-0.0628699437,
-0.0297104362,
-0.2522165179,
-0.0751011819,
0.3491810858,
-0.5952283144,
0.1147871912,
-0.0993547887,
-0.0066287201,
-0.1008689627,
-0.3629011512,
0.0526301786,
0.1959109753,
-0.3905229568,
-0.4575106502,
0.7570872307,
0.290217936,
0.232247591,
0.8372308016,
0.3089395165,
-0.3998185098,
-0.5052369237,
-0.4847485125,
-0.3527047634,
-0.3235484958,
0.207090646,
-0.5436472297,
-0.7892667055,
0.4191502631,
0.005304384,
0.3202877343,
0.8046323061,
0.3876037002,
-0.1894827932,
0.7106818557,
0.6220980287,
0.1913107038,
0.5257124901,
-0.302874893,
0.3189540505,
-0.7314969301,
0.2040345967,
-0.7734473944,
-0.0516696051,
-0.1989599168,
-0.5367091298,
0.0647360459,
0.2546083331,
0.0284565557,
0.385030061,
-0.1372830719,
0.4223522842,
0.0036000763,
-0.5141585469,
0.3216457665,
0.1470091045,
0.161003232,
-0.0907161832,
-1.196557641,
-0.7235512137,
1.0750280619,
0.2647570372,
0.5569447875,
0.1373892426,
0.5880540013,
0.2110521495,
0.4781577587,
-0.948214829,
0.4046463072,
-0.5393958688,
-0.6451131701,
-0.4206227958,
-0.2729078531,
-0.8321294188,
0.5555315018,
-0.3451697528,
-1.1677418947,
0.6267022491,
-0.162349999,
-0.8097319007,
0.6724395156,
-0.6279588342,
0.8517409563,
0.2452077121,
-0.2943067253,
0.1272611022,
-0.3163129389,
0.1180646792,
-0.2753139734,
0.0028331589,
-0.277477175,
0.0844410732,
0.838409245,
-0.340361774,
0.592689395,
0.0906736255,
-0.2322448492,
0.6353974938,
0.2083741874,
0.5503211021,
-0.0695169792,
-0.2905034721,
0.2650561929,
0.4855731726,
-0.4848405719,
-0.8924535513,
0.4197581708,
-0.5191244483,
-0.7571895719,
-0.3465021551,
-0.3200802505,
-0.2671340108,
0.1100250483,
0.436568141,
0.5709336996,
-0.2167595625,
0.3094631135,
0.4111821353,
0.0843700394,
0.7621612549,
0.7676515579,
0.1131516397,
-0.0449761599,
0.7525376081,
0.5076314807,
0.3568787873,
0.1927873939,
0.2327290773,
-0.232570678,
-0.5540849566,
-0.8002628088,
0.2199681848,
-0.8178156018,
-0.5163588524,
-0.8565058708,
-0.3404359818,
-0.4633419812,
-0.3838202953,
-0.5056298375,
-0.866060853,
-0.4190529287,
-0.1106186137,
0.2104123533,
0.6648290157,
-0.120097667,
0.3204607368,
-1.2429354191,
0.2570406795,
0.2182743251,
-0.1648195833,
-0.007134777,
-0.8378999829,
-0.0842074752,
-0.1465813965,
-0.3769466579,
-0.9670699239,
0.2710479796,
0.4719962478,
0.5266510248,
0.3164657652,
0.3104195595,
0.8391929865,
-0.4262752831,
1.0894087553,
0.1282960773,
-0.8827946186,
0.4120841622,
-0.0410207175,
0.0967378989,
0.4191813767,
0.4031785727,
-0.3311213851,
-0.279753089,
-0.8417112231,
-0.5736026764,
0.7570393085,
0.2071323097,
-0.0000745142,
-0.0818265378,
0.7824646831,
0.3010621369,
-0.1545931697,
-0.5219559073,
0.1197635233,
0.2519008517,
-0.118735984,
0.3039734662,
-0.1587869674,
-0.2652102411,
0.1311077178,
0.3992122114,
-0.4479388893,
0.2665721774,
0.4431732595,
-0.0876168907,
-0.3155488074,
0.4498129785,
0.3559571207,
0.4658424854,
-0.0270977076,
0.1216545105,
0.3976739347,
-0.1046214402,
0.2487552017,
-0.0834161267,
-0.3771176636,
-0.0367460363,
0.7115587592,
0.6647277474,
-0.0874734893,
-0.3073116839,
0.7195504308,
-0.2345398664,
-0.3405025005,
0.0579590052,
0.00927471,
-0.1969053447,
0.4461241364,
0.1741382629,
-0.2779824138,
0.124175109,
-0.7559705973,
0.2039405107,
0.5366277099,
-0.5836174488,
-0.4645460248,
0.5872581005,
0.0570363998,
-0.053929776,
0.3777016997,
0.0713473856,
-0.0058307024,
0.4544025064,
0.6173265576,
0.9392746687,
0.4339783192,
0.3707627952,
0.0857333019,
0.1540255845,
0.2275552452,
0.1585582346,
0.0181521587,
-0.8715043068,
-0.5828434229,
-0.4825135767,
-0.4746957123,
0.0912144631,
-0.691924572,
0.1149041578,
-0.1853898615,
-0.1531645805,
0.4141614139,
0.1484858096,
-0.7296295762,
-0.0332157761,
0.2707946897,
1.0690290928,
-0.858964622,
0.9794859886,
0.6876155138,
-0.7405275702,
-0.8162708879,
0.1497379541,
0.0355183557,
-0.2849876583,
0.4965790808,
-0.3975192904,
-0.1529479772,
0.028408695,
-0.5103129745,
-0.6727933288,
0.962143302,
0.5593072772,
-0.3164365888,
-0.1036215201,
0.1589773148,
0.4957873225,
-0.6837527752,
0.2044031918,
0.6770846844,
0.3966660798,
0.2689912021,
-0.7586439848,
0.1589075625,
0.1927123815,
-0.1450618804,
-0.1211012676,
-0.5968723297,
0.6998851895,
-0.1281613261,
-0.3833179176,
0.2452510446,
0.7010873556,
0.0037752707,
0.3917933702,
0.1867197603,
0.4631509781,
0.4451118112,
0.0220891442,
1.3649412394,
0.1601202637,
0.2635059655,
1.056935668,
-0.8025943637,
1.1289275885,
0.5804151893,
0.0395545289,
0.4501243532,
0.4056280255,
0.152260974,
0.4744236767,
-0.245304063,
-0.0238694306,
-0.5190537572,
-0.1506555378,
-0.0695291609,
0.6449497938,
0.1868255436,
-0.0016183032,
-0.5705054998,
-0.0209130999,
0.1609936357,
-0.219549939,
-0.1227084324,
1.1137535572,
0.3744935095,
-0.4865883291,
0.206364125,
-0.0401257351,
0.4020112455,
-0.4991078973,
-0.2361370027,
-0.3275836408,
0.1026325822,
-0.0949360579,
-0.8270666003,
0.532271564,
0.229696095,
-0.1308948696,
-0.1194904968,
1.2038025856,
-0.2456357628,
-0.2305864692,
0.4539654553,
0.9459512234,
0.2190552205,
-0.0377826095,
-0.4754672647,
-0.4111922681,
-0.0937346369,
-0.3237798214,
0.6375144124,
0.7942609191,
-0.2184336036,
0.2746680379,
0.5543704033,
0.4266535938,
0.2283638418,
-0.266495645,
0.7063981295,
-0.6417885423,
-0.1067230701,
-1.0054899454,
0.4255054593,
-0.2139796913,
-0.2956819832,
0.8916873932,
0.1770592481,
0.6615483165,
-0.0566992946,
0.833545804,
-0.0125542488,
0.4367911816,
-0.4504226744,
0.5196668506,
-0.7022466063,
0.068886295,
-0.1215140149,
-0.8285170794,
-0.4185674787,
0.4891210794,
-0.2897305787,
-0.2363636196,
0.7203370333,
0.486700803,
-0.0513078086,
0.0492974408,
0.8316178322,
0.0425184816,
0.6586104631,
0.5718753934,
0.8243350983,
-0.7296204567,
0.7560817003,
-0.0306749847,
-0.1805358976,
-0.2581721246,
-1.2911707163,
-0.8352054358,
-0.1057231426,
-0.665725708,
-0.2491489649,
0.0637608618,
0.7591428757,
0.9281433225,
-0.950815022,
0.0309062116,
0.3325412571,
-0.0946154445,
-0.0855359286,
-0.1576805264,
0.366622746,
-0.2050495446,
-0.6253163218,
0.4982169569,
0.6090807915,
-0.0815877244,
0.1490340978,
0.3851768076,
-0.3632982075,
0.9145266414,
0.8872437477,
0.6023210287,
-0.6290842891,
-0.8845019937,
-0.150861606,
-0.0828433037,
0.1280128062,
0.9222900271,
-0.6089963913,
0.2748118341,
0.6490910053,
0.6891074777,
0.593695879,
0.0805658475,
0.6651474833,
-0.7455178499,
0.1125498712,
0.0930651352,
0.375295788,
0.0740106404,
-0.2974050045,
0.6735371947,
0.2772650719,
-0.422858566,
-0.7376824617,
0.0866854042,
-1.0261797905,
-0.4638707638,
1.2367925644,
-0.4493554533,
-0.2906155288,
-0.254704237,
-0.1933432221,
0.1921349913,
-0.0382813998,
0.58477211,
0.9453408718,
-0.5832136273,
-0.4110047221,
-0.6154161692,
0.4715197384,
0.4481421113,
-1.0886297226,
-0.0399786122,
0.2941102087,
0.425796181,
0.2877664864,
0.6661912203,
-0.2446154356,
0.2447343767,
0.2332444191,
-0.0179662332,
0.0855509564,
-0.3138258159,
-0.5356151462,
0.6445350051,
0.0737991706,
-0.1081920639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08559v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08559v1
|
MoPE: Mixture of Prefix Experts for Zero-Shot Dialogue State Tracking
| 2024-04-12T15:57:41 | 2024-04-12T15:57:41 |
Tianwen Tang, Tong Zhu, Haodong Liu, Yin Bai, Jia Cheng, Wenliang Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Zero-shot dialogue state tracking (DST) transfers knowledge to unseen
domains, reducing the cost of annotating new datasets. Previous zero-shot DST
models mainly suffer from domain transferring and partial prediction problems.
To address these challenges, we propose Mixture of Prefix Experts (MoPE) to
establish connections between similar slots in different domains, which
strengthens the model transfer performance in unseen domains. Empirical results
demonstrate that MoPE-DST achieves the joint goal accuracy of 57.13% on
MultiWOZ2.1 and 55.40% on SGD.
|
[
-0.5036216974,
-0.6484971046,
0.8239114285,
-0.1684383005,
-0.281301707,
0.5110257864,
0.1915826946,
-0.4183417261,
0.4407812059,
0.4962846041,
-0.852062881,
-0.224589318,
-0.7283527851,
-0.4313042462,
-0.156350866,
0.8137988448,
0.1957730502,
-0.1079504266,
-0.0705174804,
-0.0278583858,
-0.700074017,
-0.6014249325,
-0.3895705938,
-0.2863160372,
0.0322147347,
0.2265489995,
0.404091537,
0.1588076055,
0.1841392815,
0.1590535194,
0.0515565053,
0.3201654255,
-0.3882163465,
0.1978868544,
-0.4218150973,
-0.4143248498,
-0.8915036321,
-0.0626696944,
0.150064081,
0.5112333298,
-0.268858552,
-0.089970164,
-0.2660989463,
0.3145018518,
-0.7391673923,
-0.0497965962,
-0.7191839218,
0.0036267326,
-0.1267374456,
-0.5483695269,
-0.1462692618,
0.0506126396,
0.2637831271,
-0.5725300908,
0.3811802268,
-0.1925872713,
0.5448773503,
0.3638609946,
-0.90268296,
0.2114479542,
-0.7821173668,
0.8121525049,
-0.8193417192,
0.1657223552,
0.3335139453,
0.2298686355,
-0.3090953529,
-0.3469528556,
-0.7575581074,
0.1111417264,
0.3673652411,
0.3559408188,
-0.0446924008,
0.1733312309,
0.2782610953,
0.4108854234,
-0.1344814599,
-0.1333034784,
-0.4211367071,
-0.296248883,
0.7668921351,
0.2819474638,
0.2729026377,
0.0751493201,
-0.7550438643,
0.2180296034,
-0.4659152925,
-0.1105921268,
0.1389163882,
0.3142648339,
0.0422209054,
0.4545997381,
-0.4475754201,
0.9033797383,
0.2545092106,
-0.4642830491,
0.0878245682,
-0.4993014634,
-0.2498995066,
-0.099876985,
0.6219261289,
0.520796597,
-0.0339445844,
-0.1118261442,
-0.2438476384,
0.0057678097,
0.0983640775,
-0.6717162132,
-0.2555882931,
0.0883527994,
0.1318516731,
-0.0844711587,
-0.0191457029,
-0.7047104239,
-0.3482157588,
-0.4570764303,
0.7210250497,
-0.7837606668,
-0.613940239,
0.3239907026,
-0.4034963846,
0.0756440908,
0.8076206446,
-0.9149804115,
0.4567238986,
0.6509974599,
1.0145708323,
-0.4329710305,
-0.0377419293,
-0.43024382,
0.3463117778,
-0.1650999337,
1.1229627132,
-0.4248075485,
-0.6973531842,
-0.3498722613,
-0.2636214197,
-0.6206763983,
-0.0297923032,
0.3488070667,
-0.2263345867,
0.2927599549,
-0.0508140735,
-0.9674162269,
-0.3109028935,
0.3994054198,
-0.1204851344,
1.09202075,
0.2151207179,
-0.1530314237,
0.298854202,
-0.7261045575,
-0.3117373288,
0.3322032392,
-0.2136375159,
0.2884408832,
0.2560567856,
0.183220312,
0.3912048638,
-0.0894717053,
0.1410465986,
-0.1996086836,
-0.2440048903,
0.071999453,
-0.5117155313,
0.6581454873,
-0.0467212349,
-0.2350719422,
-0.1937380284,
-0.9418757558,
0.2269395292,
-0.2537078559,
0.1086215302,
-0.5905354619,
-0.3050727546,
-0.2517275214,
0.4451904297,
-0.0270425901,
-0.6060174108,
0.5175103545,
0.0091869729,
0.2345767021,
0.7557592988,
0.4764253199,
0.3568322957,
-0.3144497573,
0.8797408938,
0.1633345783,
-0.0942260623,
-0.3233170807,
-0.8760026097,
-0.7456896305,
-0.3815340698,
0.3038325012,
0.56197083,
-1.024541378,
0.4814318717,
-0.1030180827,
-0.6757293344,
-0.3900276721,
-0.1682845652,
0.3478249013,
0.6832711101,
0.4029757977,
-0.5817204714,
0.032383278,
-0.7666199207,
0.01868462,
-0.072844401,
-0.083571054,
0.2169707566,
0.4558880329,
0.2279290408,
0.9975836277,
-0.8166239858,
-0.4258070886,
-0.0322269537,
0.3342073858,
-0.0481523946,
0.5028881431,
0.7822452784,
-0.6672250628,
-0.8431301117,
-0.094033815,
-0.2895492613,
-0.0408973396,
-0.0979845971,
-0.0794584006,
0.0187649075,
0.0632135347,
-0.7736396194,
0.5686687827,
0.6587439179,
-0.4351069927,
0.5367068648,
0.1722027361,
0.542514503,
-1.3793722391,
-0.1455433071,
0.0348653942,
-0.4765329063,
-0.961574018,
-0.2186885029,
-0.0896310955,
-0.2447864413,
-0.7014926672,
0.6185203791,
-0.4577938616,
0.0174404252,
-0.2767793536,
0.2282418013,
-0.0423798636,
0.9118087292,
0.0664772168,
1.2195738554,
0.7949165106,
-0.692438066,
0.4461148977,
0.4115529954,
-0.3414519131,
1.0468991995,
-0.3762615621,
0.4607385993,
0.5102984309,
0.1768607795,
-0.9642254114,
-0.0252122283,
0.1217996255,
-0.6206757426,
0.1906262338,
-0.6176911592,
-0.0568384565,
0.0251492634,
-0.0889817923,
0.3463453352,
0.5935513973,
0.1155896112,
0.5473065972,
0.5016463399,
-0.1856158972,
-0.4772037566,
-0.4307773113,
0.1438695341,
0.1299054325,
-0.609913528,
0.514714241,
-0.0342277065,
0.0720151365,
0.0612899847,
-0.658405602,
-0.4432953894,
-0.0038827583,
0.2113883048,
0.3761356473,
-0.3274869323,
-0.1008716822,
-0.1430284828,
-0.3505459726,
-0.261564225,
-0.2891893089,
0.6864833832,
0.2050049901,
-0.7094605565,
-0.6803100109,
0.5247836709,
0.7985802889,
-0.0053817448,
0.7080458403,
0.23720406,
-0.163808763,
-0.304276526,
-0.6132793427,
-0.0879735202,
-0.4303884506,
0.0762899593,
-0.7460256815,
-0.6787020564,
0.3602939546,
-0.2002274394,
0.0254419763,
0.5416851044,
0.2364873737,
-0.0820443705,
0.9376031756,
1.0428427458,
0.0498761982,
0.5062596202,
-0.1471018791,
0.2351574153,
-0.995608449,
-0.206000343,
-0.2371571064,
-0.2382298559,
0.0580746979,
-0.6722639799,
0.4275971055,
0.257683754,
0.1149861664,
0.6847333908,
-0.2848901451,
0.540099442,
0.8792081475,
0.0782661662,
0.5167084932,
-0.0271481685,
0.1015957817,
-0.1089667454,
-0.5931825042,
-0.0474522635,
0.843878746,
-0.1462374777,
0.6706987023,
0.134777531,
0.4732986689,
0.6172673702,
-0.3889347613,
-1.0313751698,
0.8136822581,
0.0020890334,
-0.6580935121,
-0.2046934366,
-0.1748488098,
-0.3049263954,
0.2790771723,
-0.2351337224,
-1.008072257,
0.369651109,
-0.0088234264,
-0.6546878815,
0.5303974152,
-0.5520891547,
0.4296291471,
0.0109527372,
-0.0245485902,
-0.4124590456,
-0.5132790208,
0.4448141456,
-0.2535050511,
-0.445299983,
-0.6695399284,
-0.0441593751,
0.6370081902,
-0.4893528521,
0.7841626406,
-0.2336871624,
-0.1314006895,
0.2792375386,
0.3438836336,
0.3834157288,
-0.3039321601,
-0.0580295995,
0.3722265959,
0.1475572139,
-0.6032684445,
-0.8091154099,
0.3371636569,
-0.5565716624,
-0.8368574977,
-0.5300331116,
-0.5957639217,
-0.7197042704,
0.1808880717,
0.2193704247,
0.5958198905,
-0.0964215547,
0.133677125,
0.6536937356,
0.1781347394,
0.1999027282,
1.0205593109,
0.1820402592,
-0.3042502999,
0.7246634364,
0.1477311552,
0.8245978355,
0.2753756344,
-0.2687572539,
-0.1071892083,
-0.4514038563,
-0.5875949264,
-0.0445809439,
-0.442710042,
-0.5087280869,
-0.645167768,
-0.6499432325,
-0.5459174514,
-0.2380180061,
-0.5982025862,
-0.877214551,
0.0501477346,
-0.1176600978,
0.4859613478,
0.384582907,
-0.0195259862,
0.5115826726,
-0.9286450744,
0.4950994253,
0.4557041526,
0.1882236004,
-0.4095957577,
-0.7441478372,
0.0010726684,
0.3944383264,
-0.391489625,
-0.8993317485,
0.2380832136,
0.2701839507,
0.5877495408,
0.3391253352,
0.1850030422,
1.199794054,
-0.2799526155,
1.1459696293,
0.6322937608,
-1.2360357046,
0.712528348,
-0.6218730211,
0.1817357093,
0.435900718,
0.2916144729,
-0.7081544995,
-0.378726691,
-0.7876605988,
-0.419923991,
1.0902885199,
0.2223632485,
0.0555894971,
0.2714007199,
0.0222161673,
0.2957173884,
0.3476127386,
-0.1012075618,
-0.2755980194,
0.1773984134,
0.1980983466,
0.2398692966,
-0.2209816873,
-0.3982987702,
-0.1470959187,
0.8717114925,
-0.2644500732,
0.3975510597,
0.1999470592,
-0.0092391865,
-0.166894719,
0.2940964103,
0.8960626125,
0.8358520865,
-0.3129953742,
-0.1479220837,
0.1587386578,
-0.4920104742,
0.4276614785,
-0.2384142131,
-0.345659852,
0.0376392901,
0.2439139634,
1.0396273136,
0.087983042,
-0.395195961,
0.7616642118,
0.2116835266,
-0.5307604671,
-0.0876730159,
0.5206656456,
-0.3069716394,
0.1838070005,
0.5045357347,
0.7696493268,
0.104382433,
-0.5777148008,
0.3197966814,
0.3272463381,
-0.5465749502,
-0.659137249,
0.5264573693,
0.6364170909,
-0.4231086075,
0.4627584219,
-0.1046360359,
-0.6421861053,
0.670969367,
0.5778104663,
0.9020590782,
-0.3897797167,
0.4565913677,
0.0624219626,
-0.0867012665,
-0.2333965003,
0.1586472392,
-0.1832695603,
-0.9879111648,
-0.6174501777,
-0.260607034,
-0.8493569493,
0.1558542997,
-0.7923621535,
0.4809603989,
-0.201797694,
-0.2686630487,
-0.017783992,
0.0514214598,
-0.4898602962,
0.0769377425,
0.2592844665,
0.9705069065,
-0.9197745323,
1.1301956177,
0.6226186156,
-0.3254523873,
-0.6217707992,
0.0590192676,
0.3264278471,
-1.0677319765,
0.3554593623,
-0.1635163724,
-0.4289592206,
0.1601013988,
-0.3072322309,
-0.8237625957,
1.0574775934,
0.3345413804,
-0.5155684352,
0.1097354516,
-0.1586460322,
0.4055809081,
-0.2054885775,
0.271643728,
0.5411789417,
0.1533932686,
0.5388523936,
-1.2579621077,
-0.1785483509,
-0.1873542219,
-0.4327732027,
0.5506165624,
-0.9252793193,
0.8212824464,
-0.0438508615,
-0.3676792085,
-0.0145352436,
0.396551609,
0.033307381,
0.4182367921,
0.6343836784,
0.5384990573,
0.7172092199,
-0.0072323424,
0.5898318887,
-0.3874313533,
0.2487931848,
1.2668204308,
-0.5256418586,
0.6447133422,
0.3727254868,
-0.3242044747,
0.4404085875,
0.3904014528,
-0.1115787774,
0.7542892098,
-0.4836868644,
-0.6750642061,
-0.3872647583,
-0.2460103333,
-0.4878405035,
0.3549311161,
0.4719651341,
0.2375004292,
-0.1853867322,
-0.1086447015,
-0.1146521941,
-0.2336512655,
-0.1367717087,
0.90368402,
0.0701892525,
-0.7710029483,
0.2360287756,
-0.2485029548,
0.6760994792,
-0.8739638925,
-0.1183058098,
-0.4138815403,
0.0627649426,
-0.0849482566,
-0.7621765733,
0.1275186092,
-0.1749043018,
-0.102088213,
-0.2668714523,
0.8742297292,
-0.6064150333,
-0.2621183395,
0.0854707211,
0.9176567197,
0.2249534428,
-0.2487758249,
-0.657233417,
-0.6529399753,
0.2936321795,
-0.143912062,
0.4452162683,
0.5024591088,
0.0012191659,
0.742133975,
0.6807788014,
0.3526854217,
0.1894797385,
-0.1664892435,
0.8553675413,
-0.8431292176,
-0.5411508679,
-0.685248673,
0.5302510262,
-0.2832001746,
-0.5169948936,
0.7902660966,
0.3324395716,
0.5771192312,
-0.0611104816,
0.8645004034,
-0.4088803828,
0.5791009665,
-0.5317150354,
0.3606112301,
-0.5033505559,
0.0390795879,
-0.0702755973,
-1.1034930944,
0.1350849271,
0.146744892,
-0.0279415809,
-0.2936964035,
0.7138023973,
0.7293463349,
-0.4262364805,
0.0974414274,
0.7887026668,
-0.0863758102,
0.344878763,
0.6845796704,
0.8830692768,
-0.5540286303,
0.3068037033,
-0.4560132325,
-0.1509970576,
-0.147789821,
-0.7530745864,
-0.8761945367,
-0.627471149,
-0.687174201,
0.1318038255,
-0.0711579621,
0.866055429,
1.1731544733,
-0.8002053499,
0.0370073617,
0.1140447855,
-0.2064153999,
-0.351665467,
-0.308786124,
0.193491146,
-0.2277938724,
-0.9134563804,
0.843876183,
0.5653409958,
0.1757662445,
-0.1625145823,
0.1877700984,
-0.2181456387,
0.2766600549,
0.4847141802,
0.3042839468,
-0.6446059942,
-0.2099498361,
-0.1269153655,
-0.0429135896,
0.0104517033,
1.0511699915,
-0.7598247528,
0.4100438356,
0.5797148943,
0.5203647017,
0.5770552754,
0.4009770751,
1.0731465816,
-0.8999313712,
0.4107889235,
0.2626327276,
0.3383975327,
0.0322746299,
-0.3739369214,
0.9466257691,
0.7215865254,
-0.4122825563,
-0.7396977544,
0.2141838074,
-1.2688038349,
-0.1413352042,
1.1007615328,
-0.2909084857,
0.2015485913,
-0.3487367928,
-0.2418419868,
-0.0617923178,
-0.7292878032,
0.5284678936,
0.8035433292,
-0.4064975977,
-0.1967657506,
-0.814399302,
0.4577445686,
0.4428026974,
-0.6669822335,
-0.329025805,
0.4218844473,
0.3560673296,
0.2437366694,
1.0913099051,
0.2094587833,
0.0699939281,
0.2577956617,
0.0831937343,
-0.2421409339,
-0.2482727915,
-0.0294849239,
0.009042603,
-0.5123569965,
-0.5075384378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08555v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08555v2
|
RLHF Deciphered: A Critical Analysis of Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback for LLMs
| 2024-04-12T15:54:15 | 2024-04-16T00:22:16 |
Shreyas Chaudhari, Pranjal Aggarwal, Vishvak Murahari, Tanmay Rajpurohit, Ashwin Kalyan, Karthik Narasimhan, Ameet Deshpande, Bruno Castro da Silva
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
State-of-the-art large language models (LLMs) have become indispensable tools
for various tasks. However, training LLMs to serve as effective assistants for
humans requires careful consideration. A promising approach is reinforcement
learning from human feedback (RLHF), which leverages human feedback to update
the model in accordance with human preferences and mitigate issues like
toxicity and hallucinations. Yet, an understanding of RLHF for LLMs is largely
entangled with initial design choices that popularized the method and current
research focuses on augmenting those choices rather than fundamentally
improving the framework. In this paper, we analyze RLHF through the lens of
reinforcement learning principles to develop an understanding of its
fundamentals, dedicating substantial focus to the core component of RLHF -- the
reward model. Our study investigates modeling choices, caveats of function
approximation, and their implications on RLHF training algorithms, highlighting
the underlying assumptions made about the expressivity of reward. Our analysis
improves the understanding of the role of reward models and methods for their
training, concurrently revealing limitations of the current methodology. We
characterize these limitations, including incorrect generalization, model
misspecification, and the sparsity of feedback, along with their impact on the
performance of a language model. The discussion and analysis are substantiated
by a categorical review of current literature, serving as a reference for
researchers and practitioners to understand the challenges of RLHF and build
upon existing efforts.
|
[
-0.2711676657,
-0.714546144,
0.5241858959,
0.0888578296,
-0.1247302666,
0.2068469375,
-0.2842206955,
-0.7277628183,
-0.0653814152,
0.7730336785,
-0.8369380832,
-0.2374446541,
-0.6589260101,
0.1438443214,
-0.0149132423,
0.8978864551,
-0.0779525191,
0.1325480491,
-0.2035324126,
-0.1339218765,
-0.4039792717,
-0.776596725,
-0.5904186964,
-0.7752543688,
0.7730981112,
0.4985894263,
0.5317887068,
0.6480602026,
0.4080673158,
0.2174078077,
-0.2020353824,
0.0698678419,
-0.7567175031,
0.1920048594,
0.1561904401,
-0.474263519,
-0.0562621653,
-0.0026829366,
0.564229846,
0.7594797015,
-0.4669176638,
-0.0021065422,
0.084580794,
0.9033260345,
-0.6100438833,
0.3776811361,
-0.2223765701,
0.4299987853,
0.1290654391,
-0.2406068444,
-0.7102565765,
-0.2417185754,
0.267668277,
-0.6011273861,
0.0086756591,
-0.0078073544,
0.5293322802,
0.3786747456,
-0.258712858,
-0.3229884803,
-0.8130833507,
0.7763685584,
-0.5996271372,
0.389511168,
0.4861846864,
0.3751267791,
-0.3825863004,
-0.3685521483,
-0.1958561987,
-0.8507652283,
-0.1613670439,
-0.0715460554,
0.3634694815,
0.3978118896,
0.3222591877,
0.3026141524,
-0.2575282753,
0.2342390865,
-0.3143425286,
-0.144287914,
0.5234795213,
0.1834302247,
0.19317846,
-0.071174033,
-0.476754576,
-0.3813013136,
-0.8169437051,
0.482065469,
0.4228850007,
0.2189546973,
-0.0434592143,
0.3230210245,
-0.1102134734,
0.5418961048,
-0.1436049789,
-0.2393196374,
0.0199000649,
0.1183175668,
-0.0183434431,
-0.1199876294,
0.5463247895,
0.2190174013,
0.2944267392,
-0.3804329038,
-0.475331068,
-0.1105383784,
0.4572950006,
-0.7651362419,
-0.0761616901,
0.0851257071,
-0.6859399676,
-0.5408371687,
0.1022633091,
-0.4463520348,
-0.6784902215,
-0.260907203,
0.1242545396,
-0.1592072248,
-0.4715867341,
0.0877598301,
-0.0880930349,
0.1915944368,
0.296867013,
-1.0701365471,
0.486142844,
0.873808682,
0.4027661085,
-0.3376019001,
-0.5752597451,
-0.5809213519,
-0.2152857631,
-0.2663474977,
0.7413547635,
-0.5599281788,
-0.6326410174,
0.1773539782,
-0.0075577246,
-0.0760767907,
-0.7167879939,
0.5391284227,
-0.688008368,
-0.0684700385,
-0.3524533212,
-0.4771819115,
-0.3040103912,
0.2977388203,
-0.7884072065,
0.7309166789,
0.1036479473,
-0.6784512997,
0.1851729006,
-0.4957863688,
-0.309158951,
-0.0457166545,
-0.2430824786,
-0.2966962457,
0.2062210292,
-0.0352394506,
0.203892976,
-0.2029017061,
0.2523521781,
-0.3769244254,
-0.5447422862,
0.7154998779,
-0.4062470496,
0.4062506557,
0.0947647467,
-0.2774120867,
0.4873260558,
-0.5312352777,
-0.0974014774,
0.1912870854,
-0.6497152448,
-0.0029365597,
0.1547346711,
0.1323728412,
0.0537208542,
0.0121156378,
-0.3484508097,
-0.0285465475,
-0.5659447908,
0.5466006398,
0.8578844666,
0.1182435006,
0.4419832528,
-0.348528415,
0.8577904701,
-0.330045253,
0.3511402309,
-0.1007514969,
0.0503320396,
-0.4814143181,
-0.1181700528,
0.4097150266,
0.4098156691,
-0.4462991357,
0.1210038289,
0.0553758778,
-0.117621921,
-0.510193646,
0.1541943103,
0.5790905356,
0.2431288809,
0.2215991467,
-0.3217287362,
-0.5228298903,
-0.8964582682,
-0.2568082511,
-0.3406967521,
0.233499378,
0.2318946123,
0.4769606292,
-0.2012687474,
0.7005311251,
-0.2833099961,
-0.1383385807,
-0.5243495703,
0.1462941319,
-0.0454252101,
0.2668879628,
0.0141703896,
-0.4736928642,
-0.0571279712,
-0.1293736845,
-0.5404770374,
0.1339461952,
-0.1262088269,
0.0812350512,
0.1267017126,
0.5417304635,
-0.3730344176,
0.3764808476,
0.3350262642,
-0.228819117,
0.7640359402,
-0.3265165091,
-0.1374504715,
-0.2659642398,
-0.0133903651,
-0.248648718,
-0.3120151758,
-0.425653547,
0.2982479334,
-0.0785591155,
0.0775611624,
-0.3106104434,
0.5518274307,
-0.3527953625,
-0.0946388617,
-0.7299809456,
-0.0133281508,
-0.3813411593,
0.8455829024,
0.3411113024,
0.5256579518,
0.0050211973,
-0.5579344034,
0.3291554749,
0.0419441126,
-0.2432073653,
0.2403301597,
-0.722738564,
0.0784637183,
-0.0037195592,
0.3098578751,
-0.6696618795,
-0.1223523915,
0.4673214853,
-0.5055934787,
0.2138020992,
-0.0288220495,
-0.3840578198,
-0.1249685138,
-0.3491638303,
0.3433032036,
0.3983668387,
-0.5598827004,
0.4568427205,
0.669451654,
0.1185146347,
-0.7587109208,
-0.2924893796,
-0.0935624242,
-0.160782069,
-0.2315073609,
0.2614944577,
-0.0390388183,
-0.2382431477,
-0.158096239,
-0.1812572777,
0.1113728285,
0.5005835295,
0.4079499245,
0.2621950507,
0.2834571898,
0.0904087424,
-0.4128122628,
-0.3572562039,
0.5542007089,
0.0827870741,
0.3474840522,
-0.2081230879,
-0.3946092427,
-0.1967060864,
0.0697533488,
0.4689491987,
-0.1431405097,
0.4144476354,
0.5169814229,
-0.157900244,
-0.454525888,
-0.2463512123,
-0.6221464276,
-0.4139672518,
0.5530973673,
-0.1451285183,
-0.9392707348,
0.3644544184,
-0.1464367509,
0.1230896711,
0.0203862302,
0.4716781676,
-0.0492700525,
0.9407036901,
0.7649167776,
-0.1010932475,
0.5470796227,
-0.1140986234,
-0.06888327,
-0.8097586036,
-0.4531559944,
-0.2728388309,
-0.2189804018,
-0.5485659242,
-0.2450131774,
0.109848462,
-0.0668310896,
-0.1907632053,
-0.101275228,
-0.2654066086,
0.4761347473,
0.5586724877,
0.2819088101,
0.3210989833,
-0.0647003353,
-0.1508465409,
-0.0988047943,
-0.7333790064,
-0.2938852906,
0.9368492365,
0.8655113578,
1.0181405544,
-0.0105660995,
0.737025857,
0.4432943761,
0.2883668244,
-1.0582079887,
0.3864400089,
0.3446291089,
-0.246831879,
-0.4801367521,
-0.3672054112,
-1.0097817183,
0.536482811,
-0.2075790912,
-0.4242582023,
-0.0706432089,
0.1605820656,
-0.2939106226,
0.0805772245,
-0.4824342728,
0.8787904978,
-0.3962233961,
-0.3571437895,
-0.5691393018,
-0.7840569019,
0.534963131,
0.427538693,
0.3576071858,
0.0274470728,
0.2229888886,
1.0146577358,
-0.4021819234,
1.0751473904,
-0.2764428258,
-0.3402690887,
0.1226586178,
0.132701382,
0.5340029001,
0.068827875,
0.3896916807,
-0.2816683352,
0.2151681185,
-0.3229091465,
-0.6349931359,
0.3964997828,
-0.8770416975,
-0.5809522271,
-0.4873363078,
-0.4438303113,
-0.4973464012,
-0.164493382,
-0.1029701605,
0.336252749,
-0.3669849336,
0.0403652787,
0.9554949999,
-0.1924432665,
0.1744835973,
0.4196450114,
-0.5361315012,
-0.4991470277,
0.8930422664,
-0.3752737045,
0.304315865,
0.4505667984,
0.1446561813,
-0.520891428,
-0.4755939841,
-0.2677328289,
0.5631079674,
-1.0021928549,
0.2988078296,
-0.1807789356,
-0.0983879119,
0.0729550794,
0.1953285486,
-0.3237537146,
-0.1572052687,
-0.3438927233,
-0.204145357,
0.0532235019,
1.1487524509,
-0.0178565998,
0.0420180596,
-0.7314051986,
0.2230486274,
0.4450575411,
0.4052156806,
0.4083974063,
-0.5755959153,
-0.4248771071,
-0.076767303,
-0.0712334961,
-0.9383663535,
0.1235343665,
-0.2622351944,
0.7736179233,
0.2450782061,
0.121083118,
0.3958550692,
-0.2391913235,
0.5629470944,
0.216083616,
-0.7007656097,
0.1948571652,
-0.0553819835,
0.1171369031,
0.5515193343,
-0.0251622144,
-0.8588959575,
-0.1875931174,
-0.6474083066,
-0.6443416476,
0.7330778837,
-0.2775216401,
-0.1336279958,
0.2163237333,
0.3631877005,
0.250761807,
0.14512375,
-0.9534755945,
-0.1544824094,
-0.0106082596,
-0.0034127063,
0.1192178056,
-0.4561874866,
-0.3392979503,
-0.1164116338,
0.5082909465,
-0.1297925264,
0.2816838026,
0.0727288797,
-0.4250983894,
-0.2588225305,
0.3688673675,
0.8064528108,
0.6543908715,
-0.316953361,
0.1975168139,
0.0808007121,
-0.3715453744,
0.1884921938,
-0.1469666213,
0.0707730055,
-0.2933523953,
0.6835602522,
1.0605179071,
0.4543176889,
-1.1642023325,
0.3733761609,
-0.2141262591,
-0.3360477388,
-0.3142662048,
0.1989126951,
0.0361020826,
0.2954870164,
0.3141290247,
-0.1050188318,
-0.0303253178,
-0.5062335134,
0.1466782838,
0.501294136,
-0.8036237359,
-0.3343214989,
0.2701784968,
0.3127010465,
-0.3688727021,
0.5061939359,
-0.0553823076,
-0.7665552497,
0.5516968966,
0.2995386124,
0.9485651255,
0.0737229288,
0.5143216252,
0.1639664322,
0.3239358068,
-0.2386996001,
-0.0239893459,
-0.3884198368,
-0.6248313189,
-0.5746532083,
-0.5056259632,
-0.7876331806,
0.1702505946,
-0.8019432425,
-0.1847384274,
-0.5585301518,
0.0160905812,
-0.4763504565,
0.0181404743,
-0.2775055468,
-0.0411252305,
0.2491512895,
0.6988167763,
-0.6059200168,
0.6666126847,
0.5200557113,
-0.4711159468,
-0.8377874494,
-0.0026094401,
-0.1901979893,
-0.9949411154,
0.8976703286,
0.0044445647,
-0.357657969,
-0.2102725357,
-0.4224219024,
-0.5338846445,
0.8959211707,
0.1798705757,
-0.4298493266,
-0.1704975367,
0.0885768458,
0.4909410477,
-0.4072232246,
0.3467846811,
0.8777894974,
0.4495360255,
0.1034485698,
-0.8848923445,
0.2089966983,
-0.0476294309,
0.1366966516,
-0.0372322276,
-0.3528460264,
0.4638165534,
-0.4885986745,
-0.2463755757,
-0.0683655813,
0.5942155123,
0.5393508673,
-0.0805334821,
0.6215264797,
0.3149378598,
0.6949301958,
0.2064939588,
0.9903738499,
-0.0420218967,
0.4892196655,
0.9361412525,
-0.1046700254,
0.9490681887,
0.6498400569,
-0.414131999,
0.4832595289,
0.8819397688,
0.3029919267,
0.7120977044,
0.6710843444,
-0.0592316613,
-0.264451772,
-0.0369008482,
-0.3833985329,
0.0414202698,
0.315181613,
-0.2647821903,
-0.2589646578,
0.0852990299,
-0.1454089135,
0.1178586781,
-0.2534070909,
0.8710575104,
0.1509134918,
-0.863247931,
0.8526269197,
0.0266502202,
0.6066611409,
-0.4106600285,
-0.2758271098,
-0.1323650926,
0.2228373736,
-0.0688061863,
-0.5934396982,
0.0289681293,
-0.3066730797,
-0.0877126083,
-0.3429596126,
0.6399108171,
-0.3591326177,
0.051139798,
0.4784504175,
0.3824310303,
-0.0500675887,
-0.0246712621,
-0.8447074294,
0.3586034477,
0.1635801941,
-0.2256546915,
0.4873804748,
-0.016480051,
0.2307567745,
0.8475430608,
0.4778096378,
0.2248131484,
-0.2034376264,
0.0501525402,
0.6070683599,
-0.8954613805,
-0.5806329846,
-0.8149266243,
0.2187430114,
0.250875473,
-0.1825767756,
0.2411158234,
0.0704873726,
0.7850450873,
-0.2753371596,
0.8162166476,
0.4738486409,
0.5091258287,
-0.7651191354,
0.508592248,
-0.2984122634,
0.4862971306,
0.1617771089,
-0.5355958939,
-0.1373775154,
0.7016515732,
-0.3843308687,
0.0368968844,
0.8770759106,
0.7342302799,
0.3605264723,
0.1602288038,
0.3024532199,
0.0429975875,
0.3359014094,
0.5869506598,
1.3496258259,
-0.0166750699,
0.6133434176,
-0.2336700857,
-0.143448934,
-0.483340919,
-0.5817392468,
-0.9503401518,
-0.4917155802,
-0.1028578356,
-0.4208008647,
0.0781213418,
1.1298692226,
0.6518159509,
-0.6318472624,
-0.6644302607,
-0.298697561,
0.6114934087,
-0.359010607,
-0.2111215293,
0.2517522573,
-0.461199671,
-0.3840406835,
0.390755862,
0.1214504838,
-0.0764978081,
-0.7364974022,
-0.7126723528,
0.1357240826,
-0.1482095867,
0.4838241935,
0.6956778169,
-1.0882300138,
-0.1998031139,
0.0377513655,
-0.1095411032,
-0.0125525314,
1.0702747107,
-0.8197917342,
0.2148106396,
0.386875689,
0.8908161521,
0.3910069466,
-0.0454258546,
0.5561880469,
-0.4733935297,
0.0071530659,
0.2542763948,
0.1342205554,
0.2854727209,
-0.2696420848,
0.3698469996,
0.3628626764,
-0.573556304,
-1.056340456,
0.5683650374,
-0.7836704254,
-0.5668969154,
1.0762403011,
0.0629385859,
-0.3971886337,
-0.1280257851,
-0.3904930353,
-0.063638337,
-0.4746167362,
0.9880696535,
0.7341837883,
-0.2570596039,
-0.5238122344,
-0.5185223222,
0.8450988531,
0.5108720064,
-0.6668990254,
0.4483994544,
0.4597369432,
0.2390766293,
-0.1821704358,
0.7982373834,
0.0278752763,
0.5252135992,
-0.2503885329,
0.1233438775,
-0.1955944598,
-0.2796937525,
-0.5436835289,
0.2941742539,
0.8024147749,
-0.0859884769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08538v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08538v1
|
VertAttack: Taking advantage of Text Classifiers' horizontal vision
| 2024-04-12T15:32:17 | 2024-04-12T15:32:17 |
Jonathan Rusert
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Text classification systems have continuously improved in performance over
the years. However, nearly all current SOTA classifiers have a similar
shortcoming, they process text in a horizontal manner. Vertically written words
will not be recognized by a classifier. In contrast, humans are easily able to
recognize and read words written both horizontally and vertically. Hence, a
human adversary could write problematic words vertically and the meaning would
still be preserved to other humans. We simulate such an attack, VertAttack.
VertAttack identifies which words a classifier is reliant on and then rewrites
those words vertically. We find that VertAttack is able to greatly drop the
accuracy of 4 different transformer models on 5 datasets. For example, on the
SST2 dataset, VertAttack is able to drop RoBERTa's accuracy from 94 to 13%.
Furthermore, since VertAttack does not replace the word, meaning is easily
preserved. We verify this via a human study and find that crowdworkers are able
to correctly label 77% perturbed texts perturbed, compared to 81% of the
original texts. We believe VertAttack offers a look into how humans might
circumvent classifiers in the future and thus inspire a look into more robust
algorithms.
|
[
-0.1123006195,
-0.7806107402,
0.4390352964,
-0.0134149743,
-0.2159913033,
0.181460008,
-0.1285626739,
-0.781247139,
0.1843540519,
0.8543043733,
-0.6052592397,
-0.4809873402,
-0.7154625058,
0.1818449497,
-0.6135632992,
1.2243065834,
-0.0539007448,
-0.0717457384,
-0.1072614491,
0.0016147682,
-0.6122360826,
-0.7124553919,
-0.4261163473,
-0.4140084982,
0.7009496689,
0.6229904294,
0.6160927415,
0.5556653738,
0.6706574559,
0.4110169113,
-0.1161125451,
-0.1962862015,
-0.7926751375,
0.3044012785,
0.1100603938,
-0.7309237719,
-0.0153279183,
0.1128556058,
0.7455220819,
0.2593967021,
-0.1608457863,
0.2195030153,
0.2642022073,
0.8839632273,
-0.5525882244,
-0.1317314208,
-0.7158326507,
0.2911543548,
-0.654173851,
-0.1934018284,
-0.4544487596,
-0.4478898644,
0.2054803371,
-0.481436491,
0.1454130262,
-0.0053388593,
1.2301521301,
0.5132787228,
-0.0979987532,
-0.1272889525,
-0.6389431357,
0.7311118245,
0.0845191255,
0.1995038986,
0.5103429556,
0.804731071,
0.0294965599,
-1.0685843229,
-0.5678341985,
-0.1207875386,
0.0281308424,
0.4524469674,
-0.3601468205,
-0.276661098,
0.1964779347,
0.2143885791,
-0.3687115312,
0.1275065839,
-0.6925019622,
-0.1882529259,
0.4016895294,
0.3328078687,
0.2419904172,
-0.4049382806,
-0.9634029865,
-0.2816888988,
-0.5292384624,
0.2098067105,
0.5242810249,
-0.0615015589,
0.3694365323,
0.6476981044,
0.1202953905,
0.570941925,
-0.1028616056,
0.0088377856,
0.1033839807,
-0.1337225288,
-0.5576670766,
0.1706853062,
0.4711710215,
0.3091824055,
0.0939957723,
0.0314044729,
0.0661522895,
0.1687083095,
0.8270904422,
-0.4941150248,
-0.2477030009,
-0.1345794797,
-0.4871142805,
-0.6026493311,
-0.0060012718,
-0.8723956347,
-0.9363466501,
-0.3038530648,
0.6406408548,
-0.3706371188,
0.1809239239,
0.215641126,
-0.4090963006,
0.2147922516,
0.4654799402,
-0.572874248,
0.1153254807,
0.7987185717,
0.7175550461,
0.0915653259,
-0.5307365656,
-0.3156448901,
-0.0617379546,
0.0464687422,
0.9496098161,
-0.4042170942,
-0.4730326533,
-0.0840482712,
-0.0823079944,
0.1518499255,
-0.2697171569,
0.6630288959,
-0.2307804674,
0.4113080502,
-0.3805724084,
-0.3663398325,
-0.1663392037,
0.3512220085,
-0.5431225896,
0.9171789885,
-0.0759458169,
-1.2783002853,
0.5265750289,
-0.2005717903,
-0.3860256374,
0.2013424337,
-0.1998740286,
-0.7228529453,
0.1799355894,
-0.2781665325,
0.2549461126,
-0.1916629225,
-0.2317833006,
-0.1003542244,
-0.1815168113,
0.1721269041,
-0.4233244658,
1.1078971624,
0.0717062056,
-0.3902173042,
0.0246977303,
-0.4176895618,
-0.0384804308,
-0.013110593,
-0.4762819707,
-0.6686733961,
0.0447971486,
0.2812696397,
-0.1889471859,
0.1739633381,
-0.59409374,
0.1582216769,
-0.1488818824,
0.1679210961,
0.9066005945,
-0.4597128332,
0.2825517356,
-0.3834147453,
0.5434904099,
-0.5020747185,
0.2378953099,
0.2612643242,
-0.6488021016,
-0.6196994185,
-0.6228730083,
0.2400114089,
0.7572456598,
-0.7655480504,
0.12275628,
-0.3073813319,
-0.8236416578,
-0.3385549188,
0.2066333741,
0.5338666439,
0.7067064643,
0.1665990651,
-0.2691285312,
-0.9311943054,
-0.867480278,
-0.6737371087,
-0.284368664,
-0.1995724291,
-0.0256511867,
0.3819557726,
-0.4181547761,
0.8167268038,
-0.4968851507,
-0.6928922534,
-0.2653407156,
0.2188146859,
-0.0316160396,
0.2158017009,
0.3388391733,
-0.8243535757,
-0.3398948312,
0.1062753275,
-0.7939673662,
-0.0406525172,
-0.0228336267,
-0.237465173,
0.3950266242,
0.5524286032,
-0.1613674015,
0.8719888926,
0.5903202891,
-0.4916569889,
0.5256409645,
-0.523637414,
-0.0719774663,
-0.8694680333,
-0.1174236536,
0.1459659338,
-0.1762462407,
-0.8336219788,
-0.1619099826,
0.1990978271,
0.118021816,
-0.2817200422,
0.1852205992,
-0.2940427959,
0.1166389585,
-0.295702666,
0.092512846,
-0.0431749448,
0.0151218874,
0.0823360384,
0.4483868778,
0.1497142911,
-0.2520537972,
0.1299972534,
0.2039152682,
-0.5180383325,
0.8791714907,
-0.5343930125,
0.0290112197,
-0.3483659327,
0.401569128,
-1.0134449005,
-0.2546949089,
0.0308849607,
-0.5621527433,
0.3410422206,
0.1414188892,
-0.4945652485,
-0.4882144332,
-0.5494038463,
-0.0053922227,
0.5135295391,
-0.7416226268,
0.790453136,
0.8865224123,
0.0770288631,
-0.7144252062,
-1.0428398848,
0.4772303402,
-0.5116283894,
-0.6129826307,
0.1163774505,
0.409919858,
-0.1115150154,
-0.3543079793,
-0.0134299956,
-0.1943389624,
0.2823539078,
0.6462239027,
0.2794322371,
0.2080097347,
0.2631271482,
-0.1465808153,
-0.3399082422,
0.0967260599,
-0.2190242708,
0.3372357488,
-0.4587286413,
-0.0598415583,
-0.6598489881,
0.07707946,
0.3413356245,
-0.0214442797,
0.5903619528,
0.5528510809,
-0.456853658,
-0.0008529778,
-0.5506070852,
-0.1770547032,
-0.4927757382,
0.4043816626,
-0.419632107,
-0.7948380113,
0.3809038997,
0.276668489,
0.0239206888,
0.3029593229,
0.5873805285,
-0.5177152157,
0.678702414,
0.8250953555,
-0.203480944,
0.580131948,
-0.1646968573,
0.1383602619,
-0.4235148728,
-0.4450015724,
-1.0552176237,
-0.4008097351,
-0.7068881392,
-0.1951398253,
0.2381206453,
-0.2296309322,
-0.0005376262,
0.576533556,
-0.7767583132,
0.4835455716,
0.7511669993,
0.2913346291,
0.1628273278,
0.3234212697,
0.2192414701,
-0.3503056765,
-0.4616872966,
-0.6343548298,
0.8737127185,
0.5915956497,
0.7493789792,
-0.0517759658,
0.8194672465,
0.3008930087,
0.5281819105,
-0.5147880912,
0.400475353,
-0.307451278,
-0.8439593911,
-0.4855072498,
-0.2592727542,
-1.061796546,
0.088982299,
-0.2542770505,
-0.920704186,
0.1000871435,
0.2645234764,
0.0266382955,
0.4509555697,
-0.8300718069,
0.8644033074,
-0.1524597108,
-0.4343755841,
-0.2246053219,
-0.6546343565,
0.3733251393,
-0.1261862963,
0.2222382277,
0.3448746204,
0.0854812041,
0.6117041707,
-0.5781635642,
1.1614502668,
-0.2733523846,
-0.2178232968,
0.3998178244,
-0.058870092,
0.3671671748,
-0.0564601272,
0.137444213,
0.4863654971,
0.0131263798,
-0.4303682148,
-0.3900373876,
0.4103628993,
-0.7353525162,
-0.6260079145,
-0.4647147655,
-0.0955196247,
0.27409482,
0.2325588167,
0.5436248779,
0.3444776833,
-0.1969666332,
0.4564977288,
0.4445888102,
-0.0745910928,
0.0086825099,
-0.0362693295,
-0.346773237,
-0.4288857579,
0.8488886356,
0.3106970787,
0.0330020078,
0.4040608704,
0.5057039857,
-0.4099392891,
-0.2989957929,
-0.2702921331,
-0.1540061384,
-0.6644871831,
-0.2793903351,
-0.5844090581,
0.0004056377,
0.0930867344,
-0.3589376211,
-0.1134955809,
-0.3369742334,
0.0257799849,
-0.1933472157,
0.4159151018,
0.6403749585,
-0.1402221471,
0.3739669621,
-0.5226843953,
0.0749264136,
0.6052730083,
0.0717514753,
-0.4512288868,
-0.4993165731,
-0.1386909783,
-0.1583198756,
-0.1812393665,
-0.8169577718,
0.2753351033,
-0.2578914762,
0.3788136542,
0.2494579107,
-0.0577771813,
0.6699476242,
-0.5182971954,
0.4428742528,
0.3274462819,
-1.0931559801,
0.4788312614,
-0.1682123393,
0.2555250525,
0.8654717803,
0.0714511871,
-0.5175657272,
-0.7531680465,
-0.5589573979,
-0.6605899334,
0.4772459865,
0.4158144295,
0.0444814824,
0.4106809795,
0.3061871231,
0.3030716479,
0.0339624509,
-0.4977759123,
0.0053557209,
-0.6923767328,
-0.3267144561,
-0.1614745259,
-0.3302774727,
0.0142023768,
-0.2156998515,
0.2712704241,
0.1319013834,
0.1459473222,
0.3437444568,
-0.0931182429,
0.0920677036,
0.056819167,
0.6768471599,
0.3338955343,
-0.0761591122,
0.5149770379,
0.4860221744,
-1.0261816978,
-0.0183353703,
-0.0619759001,
-0.2816129327,
-0.0037037644,
0.3705944121,
0.5418218374,
0.0904604197,
-0.563352406,
0.3331307769,
-0.5288076401,
-0.4472840428,
-0.6123641729,
-0.0287305806,
-0.1242874712,
0.3093192577,
0.4185700119,
0.2771534324,
0.1526058614,
-0.440847218,
0.0762344077,
0.3375015855,
-0.6437528133,
-0.2214279771,
0.609882772,
-0.0640178546,
-0.7141779661,
0.1569576561,
0.2733124197,
-0.8208696842,
0.6414048076,
0.2349720001,
0.8904140592,
-0.1365201473,
0.1706383526,
0.1104474589,
0.6018922329,
-0.22517699,
0.1694608331,
-0.2071359456,
-0.4822360873,
-0.2164780945,
-0.2971697152,
-0.5173940659,
-0.1913040429,
-0.6464502811,
0.3635667562,
-0.6484457254,
-0.4137243927,
0.2014175057,
0.261452198,
-0.648041904,
0.1426070631,
0.0806185007,
0.7942973375,
-0.7197340727,
0.9313470125,
0.9855416417,
-0.1825455427,
-0.645268023,
0.0070468956,
0.2585085332,
-0.6658915877,
0.875898242,
0.5127004385,
-0.5087768435,
-0.0717088282,
-0.6941934824,
-0.4790989459,
0.9996335506,
0.0734480992,
-0.3980697095,
0.2174527794,
-0.0317525864,
0.8684718013,
0.1371516883,
0.1239035204,
0.4876514971,
0.8250786662,
-0.2626306117,
-0.7651842237,
-0.1039536595,
-0.1146525517,
0.0870472193,
0.0936180279,
-0.5214003325,
0.7344734073,
0.0946351141,
-0.5560313463,
0.0522154793,
0.637473762,
0.1581811607,
0.4885757565,
0.6479438543,
0.5309258699,
1.0174834728,
-0.1261236072,
1.2187113762,
0.2802354991,
0.3609775603,
0.8895546198,
-0.2883082926,
0.9299088717,
0.5710752606,
-0.0672678351,
0.6696078181,
0.1084503382,
-0.0097666066,
0.4904251695,
0.3927209079,
-0.0934963971,
-0.3045030236,
0.2365467548,
-0.195990175,
0.8681999445,
0.1384715736,
0.0729221329,
-0.2095600814,
0.2714937925,
0.2588542998,
0.5604948401,
-0.0738164932,
0.5127032399,
-0.0611178279,
-0.4416494966,
0.5785264969,
-0.1188487485,
0.568097651,
-0.224766627,
0.3000907004,
-0.1466877908,
0.7226889729,
-0.1660164297,
-0.7958294153,
0.3563709855,
0.2360717803,
-0.1665357947,
-0.5508355498,
1.0085766315,
0.0010590677,
-0.5642703176,
0.2053389847,
0.0853086784,
0.1192567572,
0.1445932686,
-0.4526190758,
0.0695402995,
0.0969012529,
-0.1746791452,
0.2242212594,
0.663220346,
-0.0387672521,
0.708296895,
0.4012885094,
-0.0913684815,
0.1788923293,
-0.1435303539,
0.7237672806,
-0.7075263858,
-0.5097258687,
-0.8152735233,
0.4435253143,
-0.4537802041,
-0.437805891,
1.1015663147,
0.44255054,
0.7559156418,
-0.036169447,
0.6904404163,
0.1538007259,
0.7725280523,
-0.454472363,
0.9487084746,
-0.6306447983,
0.1301107705,
-0.3293410838,
-0.5198212266,
-0.5848315358,
0.7220110893,
-0.4692973495,
-0.3667842448,
0.6868770719,
0.5169432759,
0.2252791822,
0.3316547275,
0.2404664159,
0.169813931,
0.3034830391,
0.3994946182,
1.1291846037,
-0.3423959315,
0.8341304064,
-0.0801689327,
-0.4368650615,
-0.5823510289,
-0.657799542,
-1.2991427183,
-0.5586046576,
-0.1375141889,
-0.4465722144,
0.3060009778,
0.1386023611,
0.3875885606,
-0.4284816086,
-0.1699024439,
-0.1877217144,
0.2720763981,
-0.1189294532,
-0.1515524387,
0.2428739518,
-0.3287344277,
-0.4510262609,
0.0865957066,
0.2779141963,
-0.0289476253,
-0.420206815,
0.0500109717,
0.1428375989,
-0.1798351556,
0.441614747,
0.3268125653,
-0.4383297563,
-0.6070988774,
-0.0128969839,
-0.4058018923,
0.0419854671,
0.7652218342,
-0.9095981121,
0.5158346891,
0.8225666881,
0.7612451911,
0.5967170596,
0.0890837088,
0.3496508598,
-0.3713119626,
0.1051109657,
0.1544599831,
0.0904743075,
0.1428168416,
-0.2754580379,
0.3504630029,
0.2187316567,
-0.559533,
-1.0144113302,
0.1845543683,
-0.5845277309,
-0.3540783525,
0.8037161827,
-0.0241281092,
-0.6717605591,
-0.1986408532,
-0.574146688,
0.0697906911,
-0.1385526061,
1.1108158827,
0.497166276,
0.3434431553,
-0.0010659507,
-0.6449696422,
0.4056709707,
0.5621818304,
-0.9073230028,
-0.0247323308,
0.4579588771,
0.1321001053,
0.4383770823,
0.4197703302,
0.0391381681,
0.3171143532,
0.1843025237,
0.0895225629,
0.0587141328,
-0.4862455726,
-0.4617322683,
0.3599370718,
-0.2404528409,
-0.3734695911
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08517v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08517v1
|
Online Safety Analysis for LLMs: a Benchmark, an Assessment, and a Path Forward
| 2024-04-12T14:55:16 | 2024-04-12T14:55:16 |
Xuan Xie, Jiayang Song, Zhehua Zhou, Yuheng Huang, Da Song, Lei Ma
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
While Large Language Models (LLMs) have seen widespread applications across
numerous fields, their limited interpretability poses concerns regarding their
safe operations from multiple aspects, e.g., truthfulness, robustness, and
fairness. Recent research has started developing quality assurance methods for
LLMs, introducing techniques such as offline detector-based or uncertainty
estimation methods. However, these approaches predominantly concentrate on
post-generation analysis, leaving the online safety analysis for LLMs during
the generation phase an unexplored area. To bridge this gap, we conduct in this
work a comprehensive evaluation of the effectiveness of existing online safety
analysis methods on LLMs. We begin with a pilot study that validates the
feasibility of detecting unsafe outputs in the early generation process.
Following this, we establish the first publicly available benchmark of online
safety analysis for LLMs, including a broad spectrum of methods, models, tasks,
datasets, and evaluation metrics. Utilizing this benchmark, we extensively
analyze the performance of state-of-the-art online safety analysis methods on
both open-source and closed-source LLMs. This analysis reveals the strengths
and weaknesses of individual methods and offers valuable insights into
selecting the most appropriate method based on specific application scenarios
and task requirements. Furthermore, we also explore the potential of using
hybridization methods, i.e., combining multiple methods to derive a collective
safety conclusion, to enhance the efficacy of online safety analysis for LLMs.
Our findings indicate a promising direction for the development of innovative
and trustworthy quality assurance methodologies for LLMs, facilitating their
reliable deployments across diverse domains.
|
[
-0.2784176767,
-0.8079466224,
0.6269223094,
0.1360678077,
-0.2388041019,
0.316739589,
-0.1058079004,
-0.699578464,
-0.1581349522,
0.1601748168,
-0.3115396202,
-0.5875480771,
-0.6320125461,
0.1153000295,
-0.4672545195,
0.6742205024,
-0.2320330441,
0.1196839735,
-0.3585242033,
0.0610930696,
-0.2419346571,
-0.6590831876,
-0.687508285,
0.1257646382,
0.3224656582,
-0.0737554729,
0.4022451341,
0.5282642841,
0.7042303085,
0.3388413489,
-0.3374285698,
0.2121510208,
-0.6628909111,
0.1139101759,
0.0322270133,
-0.2681634724,
-0.7943429351,
-0.061233487,
0.5934303999,
0.5843035579,
-0.3707311451,
0.1485195756,
0.1882079691,
0.3987374008,
-0.8774371147,
-0.0636638403,
-0.6988081932,
0.181414783,
-0.181941092,
-0.1945920736,
-0.3491798639,
-1.0542666912,
-0.0367860943,
-0.3543433547,
-0.130925715,
0.0869474337,
0.6923294663,
0.0519840159,
-0.3953983188,
-0.3811442852,
-0.7348966599,
0.8966428638,
-0.8821343184,
0.4075300992,
0.3151468337,
0.5617225766,
-0.3438172638,
-0.6811382174,
-0.4921385944,
-0.1838175952,
0.2336864173,
0.0709366351,
-0.1523593813,
0.0304866973,
0.0931293964,
0.338257134,
-0.6386320591,
0.4301306307,
-0.1130128354,
-0.4615502656,
0.6842355728,
0.1564116627,
0.3874361217,
0.0943077952,
-0.4951908886,
0.0876286253,
-0.9753303528,
-0.1590370089,
0.4933224916,
0.064965412,
-0.329980135,
0.3781355917,
-0.2159212828,
0.4747797251,
-0.2791680992,
-0.4451862872,
0.2634612024,
-0.6223811507,
0.0350175947,
-0.0941446796,
0.9850977659,
0.7067964077,
0.2589773834,
-0.2482292056,
-0.2832573354,
0.0707108825,
0.1954244673,
-0.6110962629,
0.2983640134,
0.4651425779,
-0.6616879702,
-0.5097030997,
0.0889058337,
-1.0062471628,
-0.5898736119,
0.0132015729,
0.3252566755,
-0.0942770839,
-0.4837601781,
-0.0272937007,
0.2863104641,
0.2864658237,
0.0375959091,
-0.4491565526,
0.2939446568,
0.8007667661,
0.9228916168,
-0.553999424,
-0.0790349469,
-0.6553854942,
0.2002430707,
-0.2464489639,
0.7868536115,
-0.047064431,
-0.4241438806,
0.4181348085,
-0.2381747067,
0.0526143499,
-0.4504667521,
0.6388837099,
-0.6372608542,
-0.0392392464,
-0.0345411338,
-0.7390396595,
0.0722703263,
0.4718621671,
-0.5526269674,
0.9192821383,
-0.2011370957,
-0.8878864646,
0.475150764,
-0.3786524832,
-0.3222927153,
-0.1320951432,
-0.1946903467,
-0.6399327517,
0.1111746207,
0.0414435789,
0.5338047147,
-0.2427715957,
0.3550742567,
-0.6268409491,
-0.3030011058,
0.5939967036,
-0.4352473319,
0.7422657609,
0.1957338154,
-0.4121643305,
0.2661284208,
-0.9117688537,
0.3417598009,
0.2094261646,
-0.4434946179,
0.0205637217,
0.1971769929,
0.0730480328,
0.2787636817,
0.3460496962,
-0.8140181899,
-0.3630768955,
-0.3224632442,
0.2586108148,
0.6325752139,
0.2417760044,
-0.0371880345,
-0.2532032728,
0.5614416599,
-0.2589897215,
0.5421808362,
0.1085247993,
-0.4646551907,
-0.5616730452,
-0.0248414986,
0.2857013345,
0.5930136442,
-0.5284777284,
0.7432920933,
-0.2453643829,
-0.4703527391,
-0.3069748878,
0.2377209365,
0.6473770738,
-0.0111650592,
0.0768914819,
-0.4678766429,
-0.5557248592,
-0.6495665908,
-0.2760375738,
-0.2193544358,
-0.0011628985,
-0.1697616428,
0.1309077144,
-0.3474396765,
0.9718508124,
-0.220645532,
0.0188438408,
-0.4209447801,
0.187606439,
-0.1515700072,
0.3189445734,
0.378914535,
-0.4839510024,
-0.3253515065,
-0.0936820358,
-0.9819819331,
-0.1577186137,
0.0652652979,
-0.0356901325,
0.1851806045,
0.5008220077,
-0.356394887,
0.2135256082,
0.7890526652,
-0.0934947804,
0.3881373405,
-0.2542703748,
0.0575454161,
-0.9116740823,
-0.0035930341,
0.066717349,
-0.3424549699,
-0.7837197185,
0.3539778292,
0.0230713189,
0.1018775031,
-0.8419594765,
0.137350291,
-0.4632499218,
-0.3537208438,
-0.3018543124,
0.2456580698,
-0.2217171937,
-0.0274047572,
-0.2375299931,
0.6283623576,
0.4599023163,
-0.3538345098,
0.2465454638,
-0.0621659234,
-0.6005234122,
0.3384314179,
-0.5618641376,
0.3111712933,
0.0617068931,
0.0732434392,
-0.7850704789,
-0.2049582601,
0.2158509195,
-0.2806939185,
0.159998849,
0.055349499,
-0.7725162506,
-0.0206105728,
-0.4974955916,
0.1487044543,
0.5210874081,
-0.3114164472,
0.5556703806,
0.7146884203,
-0.3070480227,
-0.2262177765,
-0.3978373706,
0.0126844067,
-0.3386470973,
-0.6800351143,
-0.0220756494,
-0.1033159196,
-0.7622721791,
-0.2171950787,
-0.1022756174,
-0.3398507237,
0.5678104162,
0.3346260488,
0.4711670578,
-0.1458750665,
-0.3660838008,
0.1410894394,
-0.3283177316,
0.1837322861,
0.2460174412,
0.3092689216,
-0.1646004617,
-0.5467672944,
-0.4950591028,
0.1956428885,
0.4480855465,
-0.1290390491,
0.7524031997,
0.5025330782,
-0.5443341136,
-0.2003529817,
-0.6762124896,
0.067531772,
-0.5439888835,
0.0731312409,
-0.0196244679,
-0.8394360542,
0.2920512557,
-0.2131136805,
0.2623876035,
0.2580621243,
0.4640161097,
-0.2484582365,
0.7391974926,
0.5980743766,
0.1091097593,
0.1301616132,
0.2557345033,
0.2698952556,
-0.2845082581,
-0.3887542486,
-0.469604671,
0.1765818298,
-0.4609872103,
-0.5186174512,
0.5282714963,
0.2440520674,
0.0996678919,
0.1193079501,
-0.042265743,
0.5477109551,
0.1186643466,
-0.1507054865,
0.6328441501,
0.0069240644,
-0.1071224213,
-0.0460557453,
-0.3202652037,
-0.8559830785,
1.2046524286,
0.672264576,
0.5621828437,
0.3004311323,
0.648211658,
0.1994978637,
0.5084314942,
-0.4700510502,
0.7177557945,
0.1223221496,
-0.620767653,
-0.1877270937,
-0.7181572318,
-0.7842608094,
0.3037678003,
-0.4756959975,
-0.8422875404,
-0.3192521632,
0.0954293385,
-0.5339761376,
0.349258244,
-0.6051156521,
0.662732482,
-0.7796100974,
-0.3606244028,
-0.2914927602,
-0.5887565613,
0.6360105872,
-0.5441538692,
0.5363891125,
-0.3183800876,
-0.1272745281,
0.5318338275,
-0.2438583821,
0.8614475131,
-0.0114446748,
-0.3202827871,
0.3359322846,
0.1922855675,
0.5269828439,
-0.3458429575,
-0.1955127418,
0.5076127648,
0.046831321,
-0.0565170161,
-0.3118620813,
0.9112363458,
-0.6346564293,
-0.2729434669,
-0.4789136946,
-0.2517677844,
-0.6625596881,
0.1907660067,
0.0442131832,
0.2801249027,
-0.2330239117,
0.1554629505,
0.6549277306,
-0.5348936915,
0.673717916,
0.5133290291,
-0.2887401879,
-0.4423403442,
1.047571063,
0.0188932028,
0.5422798991,
0.2742937803,
0.2773205042,
-0.4561904669,
-1.1941531897,
-0.2784490883,
0.0456470586,
-0.8960185647,
0.0698402375,
-0.527562201,
-0.1911684871,
-0.2266200483,
0.0334243588,
-0.3825442195,
-0.2223258168,
-0.0686031058,
-0.1775907278,
-0.0712074339,
0.9487625957,
0.1415165216,
0.1975537091,
-1.0904785395,
0.1668113768,
0.2036330849,
0.6331617236,
0.0143491989,
-0.0276976414,
-0.015245555,
-0.3434512019,
-0.4444588125,
-0.7932039499,
-0.0073145023,
-0.0736000463,
0.8657745123,
0.6183724403,
0.0360964835,
0.2293200344,
-0.3923130929,
0.7047693729,
0.3375297487,
-0.8705132008,
0.2799137831,
-0.4496602714,
-0.2819332182,
0.6000066996,
0.4278521538,
-0.224742949,
-0.3585242331,
-0.3548596799,
-0.8881645203,
0.244340241,
0.5802379251,
-0.2298624963,
0.2617882192,
0.039042335,
0.2912294269,
0.1605833024,
-0.796751678,
-0.1574892849,
0.0897587612,
-0.1573749334,
0.1084426269,
-0.2364190817,
-0.2180297077,
0.2015031576,
0.5360881686,
0.0013950053,
0.0606597327,
-0.3597936034,
-0.1164767817,
-0.2317770422,
0.4486439228,
0.4838450849,
1.065267086,
-0.2614137828,
0.2318840474,
0.3977070451,
-0.2675325572,
0.2219961137,
0.0549874716,
-0.1360789239,
-0.0844544992,
0.526766479,
0.384409219,
0.2347529382,
-0.9655727744,
0.7233843207,
-0.1754953265,
0.1528803706,
-0.3583166599,
0.0599427596,
0.1197434664,
0.00279177,
0.2626542747,
-0.3466000259,
0.0409061685,
-0.441516459,
0.1562730819,
0.4301670492,
-0.2414719909,
-0.1979050189,
0.4917514622,
0.5089321733,
-0.1012612507,
-0.028471712,
-0.2478445023,
-0.2706964016,
0.568140924,
0.3159670532,
1.0732676983,
-0.0175867863,
0.1479258388,
0.1764875203,
0.5774774551,
-0.1017384976,
0.3106794655,
0.4239650667,
-0.6266773939,
-0.4133836031,
-0.7964391112,
-0.6751127839,
0.2284483165,
-0.5029786825,
-0.0392800421,
-0.7047400475,
-0.2783029675,
-0.4121749103,
-0.246092394,
-0.2205361426,
0.1865679771,
0.3307041824,
0.6947953701,
-0.7856966257,
0.523737371,
0.4602677226,
-0.128034696,
-0.5510125756,
0.3348192573,
0.3458116651,
-0.6628658772,
0.3169426322,
0.2405070215,
-0.4035480917,
-0.2486843765,
-0.2040184885,
-0.9541500807,
1.1060571671,
0.3197071552,
-0.8733902574,
0.2200755924,
0.4210928679,
0.5071639419,
-0.0404691063,
0.2949468493,
0.5627539754,
0.3320844471,
-0.1331243962,
-1.0556385517,
0.3232340813,
0.0261551253,
0.0389730483,
0.1609920114,
-0.3602056801,
0.5302045345,
0.07418897,
-0.5005162954,
0.2445522994,
0.4795511663,
0.4491263032,
0.4311676919,
0.6198548079,
0.3273645937,
0.627142787,
-0.077928409,
1.2254332304,
-0.4164375663,
0.3654922247,
1.020270586,
-0.4832733274,
1.0840770006,
0.538957417,
-0.4667139649,
0.2336051017,
0.5632234216,
0.2085677534,
0.3916581869,
0.3649421334,
-0.37384516,
-0.3663474619,
-0.1553952843,
-0.4370680153,
0.0062822071,
0.1369530857,
-0.2777810693,
-0.2657070458,
-0.1985698789,
-0.0708455667,
0.0053792312,
-0.2552217543,
0.780954659,
0.1656755656,
-0.3386490047,
0.2659867406,
0.1414842308,
0.6266556382,
-0.547614038,
0.1514462531,
-0.0868465379,
0.3552374244,
-0.2219671011,
-0.7488072515,
0.2515035272,
0.3173215091,
0.494467169,
-0.2390236855,
0.8438436985,
-0.0054808599,
-0.4213464856,
0.5422273278,
0.7151184678,
0.1378568858,
0.1511048824,
-0.3992138207,
0.5919264555,
-0.3016068935,
-0.0679189414,
0.5577120185,
-0.0012399565,
-0.0351949371,
0.6872774363,
0.6792199016,
0.2601190507,
0.4876929522,
-0.0123185487,
0.7471126914,
-0.4182184339,
-0.4180333614,
-0.7884082198,
0.7294273973,
-0.203216061,
-0.3218745291,
0.8886542916,
0.460260272,
0.8321725726,
0.120090194,
1.0033717155,
0.0586836301,
0.5275737643,
-0.7375104427,
0.9585077763,
-0.320974797,
0.3717098832,
-0.3796621263,
-0.9857364893,
-0.3230842948,
0.295266211,
-0.2024905384,
-0.1267657578,
0.7935653329,
0.7253303528,
0.0187752601,
0.2695269287,
0.3809750676,
0.0341988653,
0.3603583276,
0.288125515,
1.3450487852,
-0.2049033791,
0.7529900074,
-0.2947674692,
-0.3204829395,
-0.1067576036,
-1.2233660221,
-1.0982121229,
-0.0373413004,
-0.3592050672,
-0.3586911559,
0.1626550704,
1.007856369,
0.5043569803,
-0.9640612602,
-0.3805672824,
0.0137472721,
-0.1375295371,
-0.0594110526,
-0.1266250014,
0.0595037267,
-0.01869132,
-0.4351344109,
0.7645796537,
0.2164769322,
0.139339447,
-0.5194757581,
-0.2165842801,
0.0301410276,
0.0374913476,
0.5663729906,
0.1742476821,
-0.8126665354,
-0.3296357095,
-0.376134783,
-0.2711235583,
-0.0994629115,
0.8322188258,
0.0157591272,
0.4621113539,
0.6456311941,
0.9219319224,
0.1818979532,
-0.0065299906,
0.6046069264,
-0.5045313239,
-0.2446962744,
0.1616753191,
0.5179485083,
0.4955249727,
-0.1734118611,
0.3515858352,
0.1597084701,
-0.3857322335,
-0.9813241363,
0.1235978007,
-0.8514608741,
-0.0732291564,
1.3986251354,
-0.5420738459,
0.2102080435,
-0.4272728562,
0.1166741028,
0.3811236024,
-0.1674604863,
0.8700092435,
0.590231657,
-0.0634054095,
0.0726602376,
-0.684347868,
0.2894199193,
0.1878133565,
-1.5316287279,
-0.1547868699,
0.4961209595,
0.4528773427,
0.1147318855,
0.3390009105,
-0.2312937975,
0.0776122138,
-0.2074947655,
0.0583580881,
-0.0298703816,
-0.2762076855,
-0.5465545058,
0.5370802283,
0.2228708565,
-0.2030352801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08511v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08511v1
|
Leveraging Multi-AI Agents for Cross-Domain Knowledge Discovery
| 2024-04-12T14:50:41 | 2024-04-12T14:50:41 |
Shiva Aryal, Tuyen Do, Bisesh Heyojoo, Sandeep Chataut, Bichar Dip Shrestha Gurung, Venkataramana Gadhamshetty, Etienne Gnimpieba
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In the rapidly evolving field of artificial intelligence, the ability to
harness and integrate knowledge across various domains stands as a paramount
challenge and opportunity. This study introduces a novel approach to
cross-domain knowledge discovery through the deployment of multi-AI agents,
each specialized in distinct knowledge domains. These AI agents, designed to
function as domain-specific experts, collaborate in a unified framework to
synthesize and provide comprehensive insights that transcend the limitations of
single-domain expertise. By facilitating seamless interaction among these
agents, our platform aims to leverage the unique strengths and perspectives of
each, thereby enhancing the process of knowledge discovery and decision-making.
We present a comparative analysis of the different multi-agent workflow
scenarios evaluating their performance in terms of efficiency, accuracy, and
the breadth of knowledge integration. Through a series of experiments involving
complex, interdisciplinary queries, our findings demonstrate the superior
capability of domain specific multi-AI agent system in identifying and bridging
knowledge gaps. This research not only underscores the significance of
collaborative AI in driving innovation but also sets the stage for future
advancements in AI-driven, cross-disciplinary research and application. Our
methods were evaluated on a small pilot data and it showed a trend we expected,
if we increase the amount of data we custom train the agents, the trend is
expected to be more smooth.
|
[
-0.7291160226,
-0.5251035094,
0.7142137289,
-0.2335656285,
0.3123354614,
0.7475667,
-0.054341957,
-0.6434755325,
0.0673064366,
0.1104719415,
-0.5129292011,
-0.478289336,
-0.6548770666,
-0.059825398,
-0.0265658088,
0.55385077,
-0.0170631893,
-0.1104558408,
-0.7287197113,
-0.4408276081,
-0.5777415633,
-0.4535506368,
-0.4404153526,
-0.7427694201,
0.4860488176,
0.3058763444,
0.7570564747,
0.3350923061,
0.4384828508,
0.3820065558,
0.3770891428,
0.7208915949,
-0.0506863147,
0.0556863472,
-0.3503706753,
-0.3245338202,
-0.4362714589,
0.0092107654,
0.0192982163,
0.6288068891,
0.056440834,
-0.0860887095,
-0.1296801269,
0.4515322149,
-0.5745893717,
0.3476745784,
-0.4412104189,
0.2631725073,
-0.2647562623,
-0.2646563351,
-0.1249793321,
0.1081169322,
0.6516010165,
-0.8126196861,
0.3692358732,
0.0783948824,
0.5121911764,
0.5471968055,
-0.3566661775,
0.0364919715,
-0.8788419962,
0.6199833155,
-0.4827630222,
0.2204217017,
-0.1515853256,
0.7579603195,
0.0207238477,
-0.6593402028,
-0.5897623897,
0.0316400193,
-0.0291232727,
-0.0368172936,
-0.0967039019,
-0.3028644919,
-0.2380901873,
0.0719118416,
-0.7557575703,
0.1011207029,
-0.0127624907,
-0.4119106233,
0.8504791856,
0.2452217042,
0.3257519305,
0.6885970831,
-0.3795413673,
-0.1268791407,
-0.3529596031,
0.0493601002,
-0.0229907986,
0.6193859577,
0.0444649719,
0.4259973764,
-0.4160256982,
0.235627681,
-0.142642647,
-0.1420371383,
0.5460345745,
-0.6496455669,
-0.0422672033,
-0.2758618593,
0.6380389333,
-0.0380827673,
-0.0402777381,
-0.5330360532,
-0.02456793,
-0.0598604679,
0.3802711964,
-0.2937310934,
-0.0305142328,
0.037455257,
-0.2409649044,
0.1279553026,
0.0170221776,
-0.5242469907,
-0.6377827525,
-0.4040783644,
0.5567941666,
-0.4195249379,
-0.412450254,
-0.1878524721,
-0.7600767612,
0.0364460908,
0.645616293,
-0.27938658,
0.066081278,
0.7404872775,
0.5604079962,
-0.2494990081,
-0.9528239369,
-0.029092975,
0.3157222569,
-0.138910234,
1.0071358681,
-0.6805886626,
-0.0881120637,
0.0230888985,
-0.1913704276,
-0.4203483164,
-0.5610699058,
0.1664788872,
-0.6966008544,
-0.1466060728,
-0.2787245214,
-0.4659953117,
-0.4248292148,
0.4602918625,
-0.698025763,
0.612762332,
0.1328774244,
-0.4073114097,
0.6641952991,
-0.9925355315,
-0.4127129912,
0.3694919944,
-0.4437245131,
-0.387721628,
-0.3988267481,
0.1423116475,
0.4242391884,
-0.5590965152,
0.1394417882,
-0.2715711594,
-0.1062676981,
0.0582327396,
-0.1243374571,
0.4700474441,
-0.0079691578,
-0.6711965203,
0.172027424,
-0.3669698238,
-0.0129855759,
0.058963757,
0.06415914,
-0.5079550147,
-0.2321601957,
-0.2926973403,
0.2500242591,
0.2547404468,
-0.297616899,
0.2362831086,
0.1088584512,
0.1230100021,
0.5661692619,
0.0455098674,
0.7162882686,
-0.8704153299,
0.522597611,
0.2904098034,
0.3492774367,
0.0768864527,
-0.7436209321,
-0.2553580105,
-0.2426231652,
0.0661999285,
0.3592994809,
-0.8591182828,
0.355216831,
-0.1069808453,
-0.7267782092,
-0.7140436769,
0.0772621781,
0.158372432,
0.4169091284,
0.4615804255,
-0.2838219404,
-0.1472526193,
-0.624427259,
-0.2255028337,
0.0282387231,
0.2696727812,
0.7612563372,
0.6402168274,
-0.7813183665,
0.9686191678,
-0.1757889539,
-0.4897884727,
-0.265455246,
0.2049881071,
-0.2716934681,
0.3835045993,
0.5240662694,
-1.1447954178,
-0.6090396047,
0.3832688332,
-0.9960383177,
0.3568847477,
-0.0046009137,
-0.4083276987,
0.0621619783,
0.0267291889,
-0.8153248429,
0.6386601329,
-0.0011041582,
-0.2913565934,
0.2986131907,
-0.0557238609,
0.3653835654,
-0.7541597486,
0.1055811718,
-0.1144879907,
0.1730236113,
-0.7697249651,
0.0250694677,
-0.3575781882,
0.0934214592,
-0.2112393975,
0.503750205,
-0.4099374413,
-0.0862201899,
-0.1501993984,
0.1410079598,
0.1997281611,
0.599342525,
0.0974881351,
0.7904052734,
0.761236012,
-0.6165745258,
0.2656221092,
0.5088570714,
0.2702288926,
0.3778737783,
-0.3369400203,
0.2705387771,
-0.0136174895,
0.1873048246,
-0.4300837219,
0.0754434317,
0.3590678275,
-0.5603214502,
-0.3061522245,
0.0014110814,
-0.3463698626,
-0.2276940048,
-0.2713732421,
0.7175174952,
0.1095398739,
-0.5208126903,
1.0312815905,
0.7729034424,
-0.0689920336,
-0.8301517963,
-0.2791350484,
0.1303896606,
-0.0296901949,
-0.8938549757,
0.4444202483,
-0.11474742,
-0.3558724523,
0.2071005702,
-0.0550573915,
-0.2537691891,
0.0099284453,
0.394284606,
-0.0535641052,
-0.2885417342,
0.0648743585,
0.1206948981,
0.0268452559,
-0.0161640681,
-0.6894075871,
0.3435697556,
-0.1103660166,
-0.5671724677,
-0.330937475,
0.5105992556,
0.8222141266,
-0.7904235721,
0.7742344141,
0.7194135189,
-0.5677616,
-0.6206854582,
-0.3635044098,
-0.1250988096,
-0.4154381752,
-0.1263913959,
-0.3977980316,
-0.6581671834,
0.5291396379,
-0.5510097146,
0.057988964,
0.6221744418,
0.5947767496,
0.2379726917,
0.9082656503,
0.942630291,
-0.2016408145,
-0.0326205567,
-0.6864905357,
0.3451690376,
-0.5704682469,
-0.7977072597,
-0.6532217264,
-0.058140222,
-0.2419686615,
-0.6216711402,
0.606012404,
-0.6638492942,
-0.156009838,
-0.0893813446,
-0.3600455225,
0.0991437063,
0.948985517,
-0.0348384008,
0.4547957778,
-0.3777211905,
-0.1185379028,
0.429520309,
-0.8601192236,
-0.4403178394,
1.1198569536,
0.0145713082,
0.447052896,
-0.0391848609,
0.6694251299,
0.8847410679,
-0.0436317697,
-0.5296109915,
0.2532112002,
0.309954226,
-0.4780985415,
-0.7081057429,
-0.3599971831,
-0.9503080845,
0.2795267701,
-0.2501119375,
-0.156550467,
0.3364214003,
-0.2370344102,
-0.3679240048,
0.4352239072,
-0.4663232565,
0.9594336748,
-0.31221506,
-0.2262602299,
-0.4119788706,
-0.6795683503,
-0.053274326,
-0.1244232655,
0.1605353653,
-0.1245607957,
0.0918364599,
0.504945457,
-0.4189606309,
0.5267035365,
-0.2770088017,
0.0097774258,
0.5500438809,
-0.3469253182,
0.2244578153,
0.162768051,
-0.0586918853,
0.415736258,
-0.4346619844,
-0.3654955626,
-0.5526897311,
0.4711538553,
-1.2266482115,
-0.4684775174,
-0.4344753027,
-0.7755681276,
-0.4089277089,
0.3156792521,
-0.1489975154,
0.3297325671,
-0.3683406413,
-0.3140942454,
0.4033358395,
0.1070764661,
0.3901576102,
0.6064356565,
0.6018835902,
0.0065378686,
0.9382093549,
0.1032323018,
-0.1733432859,
0.5601055622,
-0.041904632,
-0.2565397918,
-0.6989846826,
-0.3852497041,
0.0106172794,
-0.3866015971,
-0.3318387866,
-0.6504591703,
-0.1370818168,
-0.663173914,
-0.0691747442,
-0.3349531889,
-0.0991967767,
-0.043609146,
0.1603678912,
0.1497644484,
0.8925766945,
-0.2457602173,
-0.0791890174,
-0.9118459821,
0.2197368443,
0.3706946075,
0.1747218966,
0.3136489689,
0.1428082585,
-0.6995409131,
0.1253261715,
-0.331046164,
-0.4175749421,
0.3404506445,
0.1709295213,
1.0714833736,
0.2977581024,
0.2834876776,
0.4113526046,
-0.2197782695,
0.5242459774,
-0.4091592431,
-0.684894681,
0.3620993495,
-0.0840048939,
0.0517267361,
0.5316517353,
0.5494299531,
-0.285330981,
-0.4346859753,
-0.7117550373,
-0.7982237339,
0.6170880795,
0.20306997,
-0.4545290172,
0.6775932312,
0.1398994774,
0.7308256626,
0.3844017982,
0.2289342135,
-0.4088054299,
-0.0884305835,
-0.0430243239,
-0.1411495358,
0.758690238,
-0.5016339421,
-0.1101331487,
0.7090579867,
-0.4028520882,
0.3874421418,
0.1493124664,
-0.3441833258,
-0.0031845632,
0.0245654956,
0.1952806115,
1.0148050785,
0.1806092262,
-0.0324495211,
-0.1103431657,
-0.2538015246,
0.0392215922,
0.4719063044,
-0.1314562261,
-0.0530689768,
0.5349273682,
0.5525383949,
-0.6302306056,
-0.8761177063,
0.3708659708,
-0.3233394921,
-0.2718552351,
-0.312780112,
0.2547728121,
-0.2582733929,
1.0612519979,
0.6898726821,
0.6520636678,
0.384891957,
-0.7464850545,
0.4059620798,
0.568112731,
0.1933106929,
-0.2207235247,
0.6491839886,
0.3670966029,
-0.4188532233,
0.4559474885,
-0.1884752363,
-0.6260758042,
0.953055501,
-0.0989829823,
0.7981480956,
0.1234928817,
0.5138768554,
-0.4325031042,
0.0451805182,
0.2363203913,
0.0816273764,
-0.4155045152,
-1.1138733625,
-0.0081038084,
0.0352973007,
-0.8497985601,
-0.2645389736,
-0.3221175373,
-0.3017952144,
-0.057207007,
-0.175144583,
0.3357265294,
0.3428780735,
-1.0266878605,
0.1780927181,
0.1360338032,
0.6678433418,
-0.7418453097,
0.6395169497,
0.9050391316,
-0.5438033938,
-0.6155764461,
0.0930487961,
0.1594225764,
-0.913937211,
0.168796882,
-0.0088084815,
-0.278341651,
-0.2818104923,
-0.3078060746,
-0.5271700621,
1.4188381433,
-0.0199618749,
-0.0608354546,
0.1416022778,
0.4165232182,
0.7684672475,
-0.8223717809,
0.4389051497,
0.651492238,
0.5418807268,
0.0887367278,
-0.8829624057,
0.0490543656,
-0.4350048006,
-0.3460977376,
0.0058429064,
-0.8002891541,
0.9126454592,
-0.4650425017,
0.1463208944,
-0.272472769,
0.6709736586,
0.1858418584,
1.2138026953,
0.403993547,
0.462692529,
1.0813221931,
0.294126451,
0.3784967661,
-0.335508585,
0.1462090164,
0.55137676,
-0.5739501715,
0.3555523157,
0.1291885674,
0.0267810188,
0.5879058838,
0.3486791849,
-0.0320184976,
0.5802218318,
-0.2064890265,
-0.3944038153,
-0.2632044852,
-0.4647361338,
-0.3511658609,
0.3223136663,
0.2285025865,
0.1696712673,
0.0805322453,
0.2982040048,
-0.2284844518,
-0.0232645236,
-0.2607451379,
0.9159325361,
-0.2253867686,
-0.7018915415,
0.1390094906,
-0.2079104483,
0.4104236066,
-0.2324489057,
-0.3757557869,
-0.3199490607,
0.3353218734,
-0.0581055358,
-0.5612955689,
0.0316992477,
-0.3734235168,
-0.2757935226,
-0.136373207,
0.6717541814,
-0.3170098364,
0.191010341,
0.5986966491,
1.3211963177,
-0.1172937304,
-0.2329217643,
-0.5944168568,
-0.1684069335,
-0.3500773013,
0.2950717807,
0.1948373914,
0.7976760864,
-0.0587630309,
0.8908492327,
0.4681935012,
-0.2100898474,
0.0950854942,
0.2986141741,
0.9392296672,
-0.5895244479,
-0.274150908,
-0.3626785278,
0.4373590648,
-0.1332053244,
-0.2651830018,
0.5469734669,
0.5233553648,
0.9285687208,
-0.0399114005,
1.4816035032,
-0.2305054963,
0.4073548615,
0.0821551979,
0.8700941205,
-0.711304009,
0.2217666507,
-0.0447102003,
-0.3130524158,
-0.0824680477,
0.0163187999,
0.1605972946,
0.1949964464,
0.5384584069,
0.6421528459,
0.1307481527,
0.2087325901,
0.089504391,
-0.0064469697,
0.432972163,
0.6143904924,
1.0048931837,
-0.2530991435,
0.3900599778,
-0.2877537012,
-0.3091705143,
-0.1233185306,
-0.0813901052,
-1.1253106594,
-0.864633739,
-0.2387935519,
0.2353400886,
0.2741696537,
0.8283296824,
0.8337679505,
-0.5676640868,
-0.0601010434,
0.1010720283,
0.5180428028,
-0.6203276515,
-0.1665686965,
0.1985229403,
-0.2375952005,
-0.701788187,
0.7434772253,
0.2282883078,
-0.0574866422,
-0.3805215657,
-0.4332547784,
-0.2851989567,
0.1687958241,
0.3782135844,
0.4171446562,
-0.1966317296,
0.0124340178,
0.1177106798,
-0.0167322494,
-0.0482087359,
0.9303481579,
-0.954859972,
0.0633665621,
0.4759873748,
1.1917893887,
0.3529858291,
-0.044463113,
0.6439237595,
-0.5284215212,
-0.1060709581,
0.3647480011,
0.1393645108,
0.1454472542,
-0.553494215,
0.5069253445,
0.526297152,
-0.678313911,
-0.4798502326,
-0.161926195,
-0.8307335973,
-0.2961781025,
0.4678125978,
-0.1765370816,
0.1038916707,
-0.4512342215,
0.0123850619,
0.2294920832,
-0.671339035,
0.9205108285,
0.2289813161,
-0.792757988,
0.1170609891,
-0.099904947,
0.4755473137,
0.2300302982,
-1.0218816996,
-0.3232076764,
0.2937240899,
-0.1037918255,
0.4293958843,
0.4719138741,
0.4078193903,
0.3044828475,
0.2521052957,
-0.0326593742,
-0.2404161841,
-1.036618948,
0.0609767847,
0.4479200244,
-0.0016894577,
-0.2323726416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08509v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08509v1
|
Efficient Interactive LLM Serving with Proxy Model-based Sequence Length Prediction
| 2024-04-12T14:46:15 | 2024-04-12T14:46:15 |
Haoran Qiu, Weichao Mao, Archit Patke, Shengkun Cui, Saurabh Jha, Chen Wang, Hubertus Franke, Zbigniew T. Kalbarczyk, Tamer Başar, Ravishankar K. Iyer
|
cs.DC
|
cs.DC, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have been driving a new wave of interactive AI
applications across numerous domains. However, efficiently serving LLM
inference requests is challenging due to their unpredictable execution times
originating from the autoregressive nature of generative models. Existing LLM
serving systems exploit first-come-first-serve (FCFS) scheduling, suffering
from head-of-line blocking issues. To address the non-deterministic nature of
LLMs and enable efficient interactive LLM serving, we present a speculative
shortest-job-first (SSJF) scheduler that uses a light proxy model to predict
LLM output sequence lengths. Our open-source SSJF implementation does not
require changes to memory management or batching strategies. Evaluations on
real-world datasets and production workload traces show that SSJF reduces
average job completion times by 30.5-39.6% and increases throughput by 2.2-3.6x
compared to FCFS schedulers, across no batching, dynamic batching, and
continuous batching settings.
|
[
-0.2931549251,
-0.702262342,
0.9052217007,
0.3459780216,
-0.3715743423,
0.173039943,
-0.0022414199,
-0.5595759749,
0.4326035082,
0.6829115152,
-0.9712306857,
-0.2192521691,
-0.5178724527,
0.0799262673,
-0.4591270089,
0.5931353569,
0.2768413723,
-0.0192716829,
-0.2931432426,
0.3348428309,
-0.0570532009,
0.1207865477,
-0.8893559575,
-0.1424672008,
0.7072770596,
0.533770442,
1.2354255915,
1.2443939447,
0.3361084461,
0.2736471891,
0.1377688199,
0.4494863451,
-0.6410391927,
0.307744354,
0.0761131421,
-0.5986841917,
-0.24640055,
-0.1418503374,
0.6749215126,
1.050209403,
-0.1575927585,
0.2941126823,
-0.1943132728,
0.7239893675,
-0.4313731194,
0.1115707979,
-0.7192443013,
0.2701993883,
-0.5787962675,
-0.2516302466,
-0.5206862092,
-0.1211397052,
0.0696404949,
-0.7631883025,
0.1600057483,
0.4411679506,
0.625177145,
0.4810670316,
-0.3841381669,
0.356924206,
-0.8244460225,
0.5299652219,
-0.811024189,
0.4864891171,
0.1451752931,
0.4787689745,
-0.5307913423,
-0.7851287723,
-0.587231636,
-0.2791334093,
-0.1324436516,
0.2171260118,
0.1616137773,
0.2561864257,
0.3721239865,
0.2236802727,
-0.7610364556,
0.4159011245,
-0.144896701,
0.2207904458,
0.4171318114,
0.6190658212,
-0.0882518664,
0.1084583849,
-0.5427515507,
0.1093980521,
-0.6815392971,
0.0323696211,
0.5645134449,
0.1162360758,
-0.1091395393,
0.5583058596,
-0.5426997542,
0.7300496101,
0.0119941905,
-0.0360074304,
-0.4484722316,
0.2197823822,
-0.2032806575,
-0.1608361751,
0.8300684094,
0.4099212289,
0.006476331,
-0.3633598983,
-0.1095390618,
-0.0855026469,
0.2307212651,
-0.9376369119,
-0.0518299267,
0.0779414028,
-0.2085714787,
-0.1957449466,
0.1717097014,
-0.6910842061,
-0.490766257,
-0.0065108663,
-0.0630852133,
-0.2668610811,
0.1392377764,
-0.3793397546,
0.1653216779,
0.1258938015,
0.3680819571,
-0.7370399237,
0.4170875847,
0.736374557,
1.0471564531,
-0.4348088801,
-0.1690073311,
-1.1611740589,
0.4068995118,
-0.3351847529,
0.5563435555,
-0.4498073161,
-0.5088514686,
-0.120304279,
0.1463559866,
0.0462167114,
-0.148365289,
0.329854995,
-0.858463943,
-0.3216249049,
0.0571146086,
-0.901275754,
0.2551638484,
-0.2328614742,
-0.8818199039,
0.9007889032,
0.0524744876,
-0.5518021584,
0.2875371575,
-0.4616834819,
-0.6697971225,
0.5107148886,
-0.2004503161,
-0.1861781925,
0.0406218916,
0.1354314536,
0.6233190298,
-0.4455600381,
0.355689913,
-0.5239996314,
-0.7688066363,
0.1194308177,
-0.5955270529,
0.3362610638,
0.4345737398,
-0.2624904811,
0.2388248444,
-0.5508722663,
0.0020566517,
0.2778634429,
-0.1467490792,
0.0926256254,
0.3261287212,
0.0963483304,
-0.0541986004,
0.1431391537,
-0.4996962845,
0.3723478615,
-0.5234764218,
0.089026019,
0.9237020016,
-0.2807226479,
0.3403513432,
-0.4486705661,
0.899628818,
-0.246464327,
0.5150920749,
-0.3536840677,
-0.41162467,
-0.7046405673,
-0.389497906,
0.0983605534,
0.5805875063,
-1.3295779228,
-0.0661380142,
-0.4999776483,
-0.6891340017,
-0.4546208382,
0.2405135781,
0.4885276854,
0.4040052593,
0.1109008119,
-0.1138115749,
-0.39631477,
-1.0130523443,
-0.3128439784,
-0.2019622624,
0.0593599565,
0.2940267622,
0.0065161223,
-0.1151886657,
0.8540950418,
-0.6043995619,
0.0776167512,
-0.2208835781,
-0.0216306001,
0.846817255,
0.1711271852,
0.4365932047,
-0.6214868426,
-0.7930181026,
-0.3256013095,
-0.3647401631,
-0.2894102931,
-0.3958268464,
-0.2024856657,
0.3380229473,
0.3082337379,
-0.6611594558,
0.4083494246,
0.6709648371,
-0.386438489,
0.3920578957,
-0.0473135449,
0.079504475,
-0.6803286076,
-0.2419815063,
-0.099582985,
-0.5698351264,
-0.6423310041,
-0.1231492981,
-0.1039040908,
-0.0141531443,
-0.718216598,
0.7816133499,
-0.4453618824,
-0.3118008375,
-0.5028119683,
-0.0402308851,
0.0161001328,
0.3140539527,
0.0444156602,
1.0072954893,
0.353993386,
-0.6778520346,
0.0490849391,
-0.0051495042,
-0.2830592394,
-0.0026514689,
-0.5801413059,
0.1929494441,
0.1731297523,
0.3013644218,
-0.8785491586,
-0.223240748,
0.2614159286,
0.0396849476,
0.1314458996,
-0.5488917828,
-0.665147543,
-0.4672021568,
-0.0167875215,
0.3520983756,
0.4782425463,
-0.8462311625,
0.4431107342,
0.0538869761,
-0.1581573784,
-0.5347076058,
-0.6745298505,
-0.0026919863,
0.0316197053,
-0.7946979403,
0.8757998347,
-0.0960573405,
0.0600187667,
-0.2301295698,
-0.1950230896,
0.0287394803,
0.3209046125,
0.5511953235,
0.6580135226,
-0.0182478242,
-0.5165355802,
0.2205000073,
0.0477347523,
-0.0355092958,
-0.1252776235,
0.5494084954,
0.0469218343,
-0.6877682209,
-0.4165944755,
0.3427585363,
0.7366393209,
0.3223765492,
0.8585451841,
0.7150580287,
-0.0895144716,
-0.1997042,
-0.6861495972,
-0.1793460101,
-0.5180880427,
0.1413076967,
-0.1969489008,
-0.8582077026,
0.4341838658,
-0.0655188337,
0.0902320519,
0.1704445928,
0.1119468883,
-0.1003607139,
1.0216879845,
0.3352034688,
0.019322997,
0.5885801911,
0.0074207573,
0.0676509365,
-0.4760186374,
-0.0298916362,
0.1616838574,
-0.171784386,
-0.6515744925,
-0.5938498974,
0.5966365337,
0.1414810866,
-0.0489638075,
0.0939464048,
-0.1313899904,
0.584546864,
0.5747187734,
0.0734120756,
0.2491430342,
-0.2803552151,
-0.1682743281,
0.1101428717,
-0.6745772362,
-0.4620611072,
0.7311191559,
0.1510167867,
0.7135090828,
0.0967479572,
0.599807322,
0.4228050113,
0.3360991776,
-0.5024909377,
0.7667649984,
-0.2698290646,
-0.1637782454,
-0.4919315577,
-0.4004737139,
-0.6960514188,
0.266769141,
-0.1713359207,
-0.4540357888,
-0.2726772428,
0.2790881991,
-0.4324008524,
0.5520538688,
-0.4272245765,
0.3515469432,
-0.4217743576,
-0.8963544369,
0.0197934918,
-0.6816403866,
0.5416162014,
0.1329734623,
0.0872563198,
-0.3121002316,
-0.1082691103,
0.5264486074,
-0.6764896512,
0.7490720749,
-0.419467628,
0.2111436278,
0.0148389544,
0.205308184,
0.9467343092,
0.3921211362,
-0.297091037,
0.1781005263,
0.165348351,
-0.3546461463,
-0.557721138,
0.6518194675,
-0.4621199965,
-0.9130731821,
-0.621157527,
-0.3417833745,
-0.2945491672,
0.245062381,
0.1215559915,
-0.1165294573,
-0.298853159,
-0.1411223263,
0.4340684712,
-0.1676777303,
0.6853669286,
0.6530225873,
-0.6973257661,
-0.0894062966,
0.4811422229,
0.0524353832,
0.2730947435,
0.3552252352,
-0.0916859582,
-0.2827913463,
-0.4991413057,
-0.7836662531,
-0.0835608393,
-0.4098463655,
-0.2046036124,
-0.6517291069,
-0.2106433511,
-0.2990121543,
-0.1444779485,
-0.5288312435,
-0.3822718561,
-0.3365955949,
0.15361844,
0.697706461,
0.4676190913,
0.249226287,
0.5952870846,
-0.7419291735,
0.3422483206,
-0.0134084104,
0.5843185186,
0.0293439291,
-0.4218954742,
-0.2493715882,
-0.2085720748,
-0.0289747212,
-0.6468733549,
0.5705407262,
0.1105325297,
0.541274488,
0.6525189281,
0.1139110848,
0.7945075035,
-0.9265655875,
0.8116745353,
0.2579253912,
-0.6054192185,
0.2321486622,
-0.3975204527,
0.3675897121,
0.4135907888,
0.5398712754,
-0.4927206337,
-0.2939321995,
-0.3011019826,
-1.0696264505,
0.7531931996,
0.1188764647,
-0.0880367383,
-0.3687546551,
0.4503791034,
0.4857805669,
0.1384879202,
-0.2989845276,
-0.5188775659,
-0.0213095583,
0.10429167,
-0.0081438115,
-0.1558066607,
0.2712215483,
-0.2092682868,
0.7461326122,
-0.4104455411,
0.5724782944,
-0.0572637096,
-0.1230799183,
-0.1231749281,
0.0572495125,
0.4581292868,
0.6296592355,
-0.2219216824,
0.1394405216,
0.2805927694,
-0.1980628669,
0.0010207362,
0.304251045,
-0.1267196238,
-0.0034628995,
0.1305390447,
0.869626224,
0.1595263779,
-0.8045971394,
0.4301586449,
-0.047671847,
0.1239148155,
-0.8797277212,
0.4883767068,
0.2240946591,
0.4977857471,
0.4266249239,
-0.1860149205,
0.2967692912,
-0.2403756231,
0.0490508489,
0.4207761586,
-0.1846461892,
0.2064217925,
0.9677416086,
-0.1135154441,
-0.2344979942,
0.7448499203,
-0.2380862236,
-0.1818877906,
0.6815478802,
0.4388790429,
0.7312161922,
-0.0682465211,
0.1301837116,
-0.1435927898,
-0.1014070436,
-0.1406621635,
0.3178687394,
0.1591062248,
-0.2921455204,
-0.5771746635,
-0.8937033415,
-0.7603708506,
0.0474480428,
-0.5423731804,
0.2123433352,
-0.5801210403,
-0.158934921,
-0.1697937697,
-0.1592727602,
-0.9103899002,
-0.0258272681,
0.3544654548,
0.8726047873,
-0.5280159116,
1.0319191217,
0.3826466501,
-0.1318609416,
-0.3723371923,
-0.1269391179,
0.0129364049,
-0.6609005928,
0.5362262726,
0.2467977554,
-0.3737854958,
0.0140682366,
-0.5015413761,
-1.1200329065,
1.4788212776,
0.5875921249,
-1.0054206848,
-0.1036869884,
0.4706056416,
0.3048067093,
-0.4979885817,
0.6972124577,
0.2705100179,
0.5276882648,
0.1548847258,
-0.4355439842,
0.2665270865,
-0.3150790334,
0.5196585655,
-0.050988052,
-0.9346232414,
0.5178127289,
-0.187355727,
-0.1720333844,
0.4396556616,
1.19549191,
0.4213325977,
0.3579028547,
0.817974627,
0.2145462334,
0.7185925245,
-0.125921011,
1.2507945299,
-0.4689498842,
-0.2328360826,
1.2585219145,
-0.7510300279,
0.6036413312,
0.7196139097,
-0.2339533269,
0.4003029764,
0.8533317447,
-0.2330850065,
0.5848220587,
0.3672135472,
-0.1610826403,
-0.2967665493,
-0.253041774,
0.0268646423,
0.0827946588,
0.0885144398,
-0.2357620448,
0.1494688392,
0.0188886952,
-0.0908655822,
-0.033914607,
-0.1594620347,
0.3606217206,
0.0312475916,
-0.9631300569,
0.3148936927,
0.1274344623,
0.7516877055,
-0.3142062128,
-0.2497351021,
-0.3230236769,
-0.1461693943,
-0.034403149,
-0.5583918691,
0.1858785301,
-0.0700018331,
-0.5124124289,
-0.2873865068,
0.5138678551,
-0.3257151544,
-0.2957921028,
0.5469739437,
0.4527604878,
0.0141663365,
0.0983435959,
-0.4989818931,
0.1304418892,
-0.3120371699,
-0.5097842216,
0.4972642362,
-0.0668665916,
-0.0608692355,
0.8258087039,
0.8212888241,
-0.0456263907,
0.5291838646,
0.1281371266,
0.7564865351,
-0.5692566633,
-0.5838329792,
-0.8690017462,
0.2391180843,
0.0263779424,
0.0430174805,
0.2000758499,
0.5064886212,
0.8035339117,
-0.2573395669,
0.525657773,
0.1193553954,
0.3877189159,
-0.8078756928,
0.5804884434,
-0.5710303783,
0.5432338715,
-0.1223309934,
-0.8829783797,
0.1398700178,
0.1323183924,
-0.1610331088,
0.0513025597,
0.4519825578,
0.7455491424,
-0.1917632371,
0.2920968533,
0.4690068364,
0.1147916168,
0.1702611595,
0.3904485404,
0.8631545901,
0.0352679789,
0.3720872402,
-0.6811814308,
-0.0242701937,
-0.4221021831,
-0.9609004855,
-0.7266285419,
-0.2929687202,
-0.1822077781,
-0.0620632246,
0.2921986282,
1.1523557901,
0.6577092409,
-0.4855853915,
-0.2748539448,
-0.1935515106,
-0.1720969677,
-0.5095267892,
-0.3579679132,
0.2286147028,
-0.2498885691,
-0.7393475175,
0.9999992251,
0.188458994,
-0.0645196959,
-0.1468076408,
-0.1897596121,
-0.3664959669,
0.2360585034,
0.4033318162,
0.186490342,
-0.9250241518,
-0.1440342963,
0.0253018104,
-0.1308246255,
-0.1996501386,
0.3897109926,
-0.5823286176,
0.0878127664,
0.323823452,
0.9591214061,
0.9035722017,
-0.1782573164,
0.5675798655,
-0.6293408275,
-0.0617604442,
0.1724068373,
0.5826297402,
-0.0436657295,
-0.9383749962,
0.7367553711,
0.1153528616,
-0.3059201241,
-0.6971746087,
0.3138612211,
-0.9970241189,
-0.1951334476,
0.8888248801,
-0.2790402174,
-0.3759967685,
0.2321484238,
0.3329933286,
0.5582299232,
-0.4332032204,
0.5186907053,
0.302498132,
-0.5385579467,
-0.2687665224,
-0.7678657174,
0.2298870683,
0.6260997057,
-0.5523243546,
-0.0459268615,
0.4042331576,
0.0583549254,
-0.2832909226,
0.5025437474,
0.2038585246,
0.1597911865,
-0.3305501044,
-0.1107145548,
-0.492970854,
-0.4758762419,
0.1473497599,
0.0579915829,
0.031604927,
0.1441029012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08495v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08495v3
|
Dataset Reset Policy Optimization for RLHF
| 2024-04-12T14:25:49 | 2024-04-16T17:36:39 |
Jonathan D. Chang, Wenhao Zhan, Owen Oertell, Kianté Brantley, Dipendra Misra, Jason D. Lee, Wen Sun
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Reinforcement Learning (RL) from Human Preference-based feedback is a popular
paradigm for fine-tuning generative models, which has produced impressive
models such as GPT-4 and Claude3 Opus. This framework often consists of two
steps: learning a reward model from an offline preference dataset followed by
running online RL to optimize the learned reward model. In this work,
leveraging the idea of reset, we propose a new RLHF algorithm with provable
guarantees. Motivated by the fact that offline preference dataset provides
informative states (i.e., data that is preferred by the labelers), our new
algorithm, Dataset Reset Policy Optimization (DR-PO), integrates the existing
offline preference dataset into the online policy training procedure via
dataset reset: it directly resets the policy optimizer to the states in the
offline dataset, instead of always starting from the initial state
distribution. In theory, we show that DR-PO learns to perform at least as good
as any policy that is covered by the offline dataset under general function
approximation with finite sample complexity. In experiments, we demonstrate
that on both the TL;DR summarization and the Anthropic Helpful Harmful (HH)
dataset, the generation from DR-PO is better than that from Proximal Policy
Optimization (PPO) and Direction Preference Optimization (DPO), under the
metric of GPT4 win-rate. Code for this work can be found at
https://github.com/Cornell-RL/drpo.
|
[
-0.3906689882,
-0.3882642984,
0.2281635106,
-0.4480006397,
-0.1382340193,
-0.1152099818,
-0.3839248717,
-0.1598052233,
0.2065424919,
0.5523059368,
-1.0377620459,
0.0154571319,
-0.1016899124,
0.1939922124,
0.3202145398,
1.4790426493,
-0.1088723019,
-0.2695418,
-0.1970904171,
-0.1020199731,
-0.417642206,
-0.3111608028,
-0.6694734693,
-0.7946129441,
0.503539145,
0.4639137387,
0.7750086784,
0.6338890791,
0.2357037216,
0.2122973651,
0.2140804678,
0.5419322252,
-1.1216495037,
-0.0218669251,
-0.1917886585,
-0.4128144681,
-0.2096097767,
0.0296910238,
0.5101964474,
0.2876164913,
-0.581738174,
-0.1408933401,
0.0111407982,
1.025878191,
-0.7487332821,
0.2132629901,
-0.4986759722,
0.4038429856,
0.2695023715,
-0.6160767674,
-0.4426654577,
-0.8004866838,
0.0941142663,
-0.994519949,
0.1404819936,
0.1205219477,
0.9376872182,
0.4388978779,
-0.1616235524,
0.065762572,
-0.7897532582,
0.9658027887,
-0.4601266384,
0.1249442622,
0.5627949238,
0.4088383317,
-0.4605160952,
-0.5016759634,
-0.617185235,
-0.2680817246,
0.0461382307,
0.3950079083,
0.0975204259,
0.134891063,
0.2096449882,
0.4716905355,
-0.4109565318,
0.0058548814,
-0.1206403375,
-0.2612291873,
0.6465167999,
0.183314532,
-0.2377462089,
-0.0369075313,
-0.4284759462,
-0.5255371332,
-0.857375741,
0.3662292063,
0.4735763073,
0.3262657523,
-0.0496240668,
0.2306173891,
-0.2942779958,
0.7744358778,
0.1439680606,
-0.3025653064,
0.4958296716,
-0.1725173444,
0.0337727442,
-0.0206973627,
0.347751826,
0.6139211059,
0.4891449809,
-0.0079767043,
-0.5214361548,
-0.2671598196,
0.4074445069,
-0.5424233675,
-0.3251996636,
0.2568682134,
-0.4618606567,
-0.5174270272,
0.1774828881,
-0.6453319788,
-0.5118184686,
-0.4385384917,
0.3545636833,
-0.0991718993,
-0.4895859659,
0.2025656998,
0.0322056264,
0.1064823344,
0.2754737437,
-0.9509729743,
0.2223473042,
0.5925014615,
0.4094959795,
-0.2087433487,
-0.3504572511,
-0.7621999383,
-0.0986857712,
-0.3678494692,
0.4203277528,
-0.4028806388,
-0.5577014685,
0.2037162483,
0.0291220266,
-0.108649388,
-0.7073035836,
0.5406730175,
-0.6664314866,
0.3057293296,
-0.5332682729,
-0.5825133324,
-0.1645439565,
0.5408298373,
-0.8351979852,
0.8662247658,
0.1715045273,
-0.803556025,
0.5882937312,
-0.765309751,
-0.2789657116,
-0.222120896,
-0.0979541317,
-1.0821120739,
-0.3245892525,
0.0277391635,
0.1220704615,
0.0287808776,
0.4769302309,
-0.477063477,
-0.4037995338,
0.0724518448,
-0.1926217228,
0.5333406329,
0.0137440581,
-0.3647196591,
0.4859746099,
-0.6001093388,
0.1639375389,
0.246414274,
-0.6918125153,
0.0374017879,
0.1478486061,
-0.109816812,
0.193315208,
0.0310099442,
-0.7184872031,
0.3916573524,
-0.3938936889,
0.6283005476,
1.0054033995,
0.3609770238,
0.2761228979,
-0.6051946282,
0.5338451862,
-0.3295360208,
0.3152964413,
0.0220674872,
-0.3100504875,
-0.4043443501,
-0.1972916126,
0.1560261399,
0.5208459496,
-0.9169418216,
0.5196589231,
-0.2097415179,
0.0190960988,
-0.2432456911,
-0.2542487979,
0.6015175581,
0.7906182408,
0.4103879035,
0.1048117056,
-0.4561707377,
-0.8779115677,
-0.0509906709,
-0.0858757049,
0.0979358032,
0.6404049397,
0.5023198128,
0.0538203418,
1.2082208395,
-0.672064364,
-0.4225737751,
-0.2649158835,
0.0848097429,
0.2010884881,
0.2112701386,
0.3284749985,
-0.7915520072,
-0.2415779084,
-0.3115943968,
-0.5273157954,
0.2104885578,
-0.0257480461,
0.0633130148,
0.2621690631,
-0.0058243801,
-0.161052838,
0.3648253381,
0.2358768731,
-0.1856444776,
0.5938678384,
-0.8195346594,
0.2608618438,
-0.6384016871,
0.1386975348,
-0.3477231562,
-0.4345762432,
-0.5098463297,
-0.1360437274,
-0.0517710745,
-0.2373197675,
-0.5103497505,
0.5417217016,
-0.1139083877,
-0.1377478391,
-0.3870320916,
-0.1560227275,
-0.099789001,
0.7616743445,
0.2487014085,
0.6609066725,
0.1688973159,
-0.7599576116,
0.3564810157,
0.3130196929,
-0.0800302699,
0.4362545311,
-0.4537929893,
0.027015904,
-0.3809994459,
0.6216611862,
-0.4647266567,
-0.2297036797,
0.4566317499,
0.0174251441,
0.286215961,
0.1522943228,
-0.2008795589,
-0.3132790029,
-0.5413680077,
0.3184233606,
0.4009021223,
-0.7527987957,
0.2673563361,
0.3971802592,
0.4321640134,
-0.7576441169,
-0.1367029399,
-0.4243139029,
-0.3504803479,
-0.082513772,
0.3918559253,
-0.0053057005,
0.0700396821,
-0.0268225297,
0.0198561382,
0.30054003,
0.0048872153,
0.1433207095,
0.369610846,
0.4638898373,
0.1179557443,
-0.3463519514,
-0.397256732,
-0.1544875801,
-0.3635231853,
0.4213977456,
-0.1737398058,
-0.2060807347,
-0.4035998285,
-0.0721497461,
-0.0020626965,
-0.1394744664,
0.3390780389,
0.3984638751,
-0.2700306177,
-0.3157404661,
0.0032415288,
-0.6653025746,
-0.4061356187,
0.3521324992,
-0.3824629784,
-0.5868795514,
0.1860060096,
0.1707573682,
0.3085002303,
0.2145431936,
0.2935056984,
-0.0754442662,
0.6475741863,
0.4633830786,
-0.2400121838,
0.4525080025,
-0.4340849817,
0.116868265,
-0.4345145822,
-0.344438076,
-0.0739592016,
-0.378239274,
-0.6948497295,
-0.0332182348,
0.5595197678,
0.05278017,
-0.3986077309,
0.106928952,
-0.534181118,
0.4292502105,
0.7248696089,
0.568500042,
0.2334694415,
0.203239888,
0.0424978994,
0.0073037413,
-0.7160690427,
0.0097024813,
1.2095282078,
0.2529353797,
0.7362989783,
-0.2298541367,
0.8166127205,
0.5638654828,
0.1813983023,
-0.6234698296,
0.3164359629,
-0.1305115223,
-0.3377243578,
-0.5844352245,
-0.6508321166,
-0.9861218333,
0.0284698214,
-0.3721389174,
-0.4436580539,
0.363090843,
0.8991619945,
-0.3811440468,
0.4114959836,
-0.2391082793,
0.5845713615,
-0.1903579086,
-0.4617544413,
-0.4880334437,
-0.7415665388,
0.3408456147,
0.0406258143,
0.0475361384,
-0.2245091349,
0.215536952,
0.8338806033,
-0.5351930261,
0.5793423653,
-0.7736648321,
-0.0603195243,
0.1619548947,
-0.2288179994,
0.8351483345,
0.0647112429,
-0.08996737,
-0.1167483926,
-0.0088226805,
-0.2729522586,
-0.56350106,
0.4410307109,
-0.9208961725,
-0.2349801958,
-0.4607683122,
-0.436136663,
-0.3634827137,
0.1511593312,
0.3240502477,
0.5059658289,
-0.1464709789,
-0.0237558037,
0.9180400372,
-0.3631327152,
0.3459113538,
0.5180683732,
-0.2800991237,
-0.6287657022,
1.2454532385,
-0.2808836102,
0.3312691748,
0.6163098216,
0.4571388662,
-0.4917339087,
-0.0447605513,
-0.5129315257,
0.0560915843,
-0.6109679341,
-0.2453337908,
-0.1819984317,
0.0248076078,
0.189745307,
-0.0233896542,
-0.4321744442,
-0.4312914312,
-0.122330755,
-0.0658952296,
0.4567397237,
0.4324284196,
-0.4250979125,
0.010789617,
-0.3600671589,
0.6153715849,
0.2515676022,
0.4680741131,
-0.2086409181,
-0.4050869346,
-0.0693075284,
0.3643571436,
-0.2101382464,
-0.5218450427,
0.1142201349,
0.5452673435,
0.4995246828,
0.6325123906,
0.478893131,
0.335029155,
-0.4075083137,
0.1928306073,
0.231863454,
-0.268507421,
0.4093203247,
-0.3641448021,
0.1917223781,
0.7982022166,
0.3121102154,
-0.4691172838,
0.2110743821,
-0.5757830739,
-0.6968838573,
0.8336754441,
0.0362864397,
-0.2092136145,
0.2465052456,
0.5338776112,
0.2483630031,
0.4028272629,
-0.4685300887,
-0.4437309802,
-0.5071213245,
0.0692472234,
-0.1187442765,
-0.0949556902,
-0.3804801404,
-0.0099372379,
0.9728441834,
-0.1393865049,
0.2397352755,
-0.0362555385,
0.1792840511,
-0.2405765355,
0.2562904358,
0.5789783001,
0.6581626534,
-0.6151205897,
-0.1845198274,
-0.1660109162,
-0.3914491534,
0.3825244606,
0.1113820449,
-0.7095527649,
-0.4720884562,
0.1254478246,
1.0598731041,
0.2656615078,
-0.7061775923,
0.3813130856,
-0.0523205809,
-0.4567336142,
-0.3395892978,
0.2444399148,
-0.3898312747,
-0.1818413436,
0.1926667988,
0.015637435,
-0.0284956284,
-0.4150690436,
0.556866169,
0.385016799,
-0.3415724933,
-0.15378654,
0.5602157116,
0.2188330293,
-0.1534356773,
0.8081911206,
-0.3635183573,
-0.6533662081,
0.5483597517,
0.5118695498,
0.5973411202,
0.0043125642,
0.5570263267,
0.6375909448,
-0.0825034678,
-0.2832912803,
0.585596621,
-0.0348242261,
-1.0087044239,
-0.0200533904,
-0.5784384012,
-0.5367509127,
0.2130686641,
-0.8096879721,
0.0692176223,
-0.4109056294,
-0.1593800634,
-0.3108257651,
0.1890664101,
-0.5433138013,
0.437413156,
-0.3065841198,
0.5309536457,
-0.8268640041,
0.7761507034,
0.4821264744,
-0.3434926569,
-0.7160346508,
-0.0288793538,
0.0638073385,
-0.9908096194,
0.3640834689,
-0.0019762411,
-0.1817360222,
0.2663518786,
-0.145553425,
-0.7608389258,
1.0037090778,
0.2492215335,
-0.5832260251,
0.1829978526,
0.1131950617,
0.1970180273,
-0.2163075656,
0.1411924511,
0.7160360813,
0.7108396888,
-0.1100097522,
-0.7762584686,
0.0349303484,
0.065749459,
-0.1209663302,
0.3942602277,
-0.498696357,
0.4289270639,
-0.5976743102,
0.0204218403,
-0.2723104954,
0.3768219352,
0.6549419165,
0.0281647574,
0.9975830317,
0.7131527066,
0.7898288369,
-0.1253092438,
1.0700588226,
-0.1576351821,
0.5888598561,
1.2352004051,
-0.2932232618,
0.8108863235,
0.3385686874,
-0.3849706352,
0.2206709087,
0.9796671867,
-0.1727230549,
1.0652457476,
0.4182294905,
-0.2605684102,
-0.1677633375,
-0.23749879,
-0.3755041659,
0.1614820361,
-0.2753069103,
-0.0328510404,
-0.3672040105,
0.316233784,
-0.0831926689,
0.1316584647,
-0.346388191,
0.894156754,
-0.2829053402,
-1.0146664381,
0.8114411235,
0.0882467404,
0.3796363771,
-0.519724071,
-0.2175059766,
-0.2676646709,
0.4734506011,
-0.3444141448,
-0.6422634721,
0.165042907,
-0.5089521408,
-0.3751935959,
-0.3081735969,
0.5741134882,
-0.4442970753,
0.010594354,
0.1266508698,
-0.036213778,
0.0169672351,
0.2397677451,
-0.7011486888,
-0.2386363745,
0.275202632,
-0.4248396158,
0.4101004303,
-0.2957275808,
-0.0960677341,
0.8682362437,
0.4852997661,
0.1754888892,
-0.3019945621,
0.1310305148,
0.7149757147,
-0.3306835294,
-0.8157934546,
-0.4480918348,
0.2704287469,
0.0197523683,
-0.2350550443,
0.1733471602,
0.5276012421,
0.8883298039,
-0.2031554282,
0.9314722419,
-0.0927774459,
0.7008901238,
-0.6120476127,
0.5701470971,
-0.547937274,
0.0196803492,
0.2158609331,
-0.7352865934,
0.1905840188,
0.5222129822,
-0.3885724247,
0.2052381337,
0.5067132711,
0.8575450182,
-0.0306390654,
0.0774767399,
0.1949063092,
-0.2698960602,
0.1755212396,
0.6896349788,
0.4974476099,
-0.101131402,
0.4556862414,
-0.5304422975,
-0.4759894907,
-0.2393829823,
-1.1042771339,
-0.5155408382,
-0.4099673033,
-0.1830045432,
-0.4660532475,
0.4218152165,
0.9692447186,
0.6315222979,
-0.8902660608,
0.0165316314,
-0.2524036467,
0.0568525866,
-0.5880789161,
-0.2465609759,
0.555599153,
-0.2261784673,
-0.3547722995,
0.3738936782,
0.1090232283,
-0.3539717197,
-0.287057966,
-0.6748808026,
-0.0360649489,
-0.2620006204,
0.1976829022,
0.7891804576,
-0.5350573063,
-0.2740453482,
-0.3811272085,
0.2837582827,
0.2277168781,
1.0286009312,
-0.8474456668,
0.6595074534,
0.4269029498,
0.7584697008,
0.6177531481,
0.287995249,
0.7268069983,
-0.6186537147,
0.0106109232,
0.106704466,
0.2369155437,
0.3487794399,
-0.4540329576,
0.4219943881,
0.2591147423,
-0.6658746004,
-0.6436055899,
0.5219272971,
-0.462084651,
-0.1697246134,
1.0068106651,
-0.337148726,
0.0833753049,
-0.0411793329,
-0.049652651,
0.2523084581,
-0.573829174,
1.0338813066,
0.1912607253,
-0.4407573342,
-0.1527144909,
-0.3719906211,
1.1105061769,
0.3888686299,
-0.9330557585,
0.2263394296,
0.4944297671,
0.3501368165,
-0.3423627019,
0.8789605498,
0.2530791759,
0.2273339033,
-0.4085279703,
-0.0044857212,
-0.4818539023,
-0.4532419443,
-0.3299817741,
0.0662850738,
0.0180274472,
-0.3533288538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08491v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08491v1
|
Mitigating Language-Level Performance Disparity in mPLMs via Teacher Language Selection and Cross-lingual Self-Distillation
| 2024-04-12T14:19:16 | 2024-04-12T14:19:16 |
Haozhe Zhao, Zefan Cai, Shuzheng Si, Liang Chen, Yufeng He, Kaikai An, Baobao Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large-scale multilingual Pretrained Language Models (mPLMs) yield impressive
performance on cross-language tasks, yet significant performance disparities
exist across different languages within the same mPLM. Previous studies
endeavored to narrow these disparities by supervise fine-tuning the mPLMs with
multilingual data. However, obtaining labeled multilingual data is
time-consuming, and fine-tuning mPLM with limited labeled multilingual data
merely encapsulates the knowledge specific to the labeled data. Therefore, we
introduce ALSACE to leverage the learned knowledge from the well-performing
languages to guide under-performing ones within the same mPLM, eliminating the
need for additional labeled multilingual data. Experiments show that ALSACE
effectively mitigates language-level performance disparity across various mPLMs
while showing the competitive performance on different multilingual NLU tasks,
ranging from full resource to limited resource settings. The code for our
approach is available at https://github.com/pkunlp-icler/ALSACE.
|
[
-0.6701015234,
-0.4155759513,
0.3274360895,
0.3747351468,
-0.162135303,
0.3382614553,
-0.3197417259,
-0.2784875929,
-0.1080974638,
0.447599858,
-0.3753527105,
-0.3070304394,
-0.9704424143,
0.1099117547,
-0.0686704442,
1.0952416658,
0.0967958942,
0.18474935,
-0.2639043927,
-0.3047748804,
-0.2142621279,
-0.8300840855,
-0.7053349018,
-0.7265184522,
0.6787140369,
0.5391994715,
0.3060908914,
0.3873803616,
0.2455841601,
0.2631488442,
0.0229401663,
0.1120859906,
-0.6724800467,
-0.1297445148,
-0.2284982949,
-0.2230742127,
-0.4137344062,
-0.1360147893,
0.8261653185,
0.5162854195,
-0.3656975329,
0.1718965173,
0.5201081038,
0.9114385843,
-0.8245945573,
0.1516287327,
-0.5389936566,
0.1423470825,
-0.4849775434,
-0.0857601762,
-0.3666809201,
-0.0706198737,
-0.0492359176,
-0.3734977841,
0.1795444638,
-0.2603811324,
0.6362059712,
0.4376681447,
-0.5020474195,
0.1618185341,
-0.7227405906,
0.8583645225,
-0.6337602735,
0.647030592,
0.7111161351,
0.3719614148,
0.1732023656,
-0.487688601,
-0.1978491843,
-0.0701801702,
-0.4054235518,
0.0324912369,
-0.2401803136,
-0.2207630277,
0.3336080015,
0.0900179744,
-0.7526004314,
0.4481146336,
-0.2517327666,
-0.1861795634,
0.6273049712,
-0.0784546435,
0.1650296599,
0.3538184762,
-0.2175693065,
-0.0888760611,
-0.6985062361,
0.1395654231,
0.5414949656,
0.3943605721,
-0.0267810859,
0.2786331475,
-0.2905137539,
0.6101272106,
-0.1985203922,
-0.2183910161,
0.399761796,
-0.1315026879,
0.0028997136,
0.1295088679,
0.6275982261,
0.0476090871,
0.5241184831,
-0.0696353763,
-0.5323404074,
-0.0704630762,
-0.1363243014,
-0.9137698412,
-0.732357502,
-0.2237101793,
-0.1847021431,
0.219044745,
-0.2834049761,
-0.8936417103,
-0.1203551814,
-0.3338738382,
0.3634606004,
-0.1356092691,
-0.3927046657,
-0.1191538349,
-0.1290459335,
-0.3203222454,
0.0576960482,
-1.2133899927,
0.3331041634,
0.3916496933,
0.5775089264,
-0.2040911913,
-0.8683977723,
-0.7015776634,
0.2823891342,
-0.0905198231,
0.5284073353,
-0.6762341261,
-0.4490664601,
-0.1526175141,
-0.1526720673,
-0.1694548726,
-0.6450644732,
0.146730721,
-0.3263475597,
0.1991029084,
-0.249756217,
-0.4354527295,
0.0960010439,
0.182730481,
-0.7558790445,
1.3344968557,
0.1046286002,
-0.7024719119,
0.6009165645,
-0.3183248043,
-0.7038174868,
-0.1095205396,
-0.1394322366,
-0.511007607,
0.0425337069,
0.6414347291,
0.3611713946,
-0.1548465043,
0.2008829862,
0.2171839029,
-0.240940541,
-0.3769450486,
-0.59732306,
0.5181812048,
0.118500486,
-0.361571312,
0.0295345522,
-0.824647665,
-0.0216403548,
0.1052941754,
-0.4522432685,
-0.321449101,
0.0617805347,
-0.1189564615,
0.3957691491,
0.2714369595,
-0.2793818116,
0.2005243003,
-0.0766208246,
0.1348212659,
0.7133548856,
-0.4054661393,
0.5141020417,
-0.1236475557,
0.5817195177,
0.1601892859,
0.3170296252,
0.1278117001,
-0.2882189751,
-0.7032435536,
-0.4654941857,
0.5045528412,
0.4843666255,
-0.9265245795,
0.1844448745,
-0.0945121497,
-0.6243821383,
-0.6986726522,
0.5543608665,
0.4435568452,
0.5054735541,
0.7081923485,
-0.3104617298,
-0.0842680037,
-1.1208585501,
-0.2329832613,
0.1270765066,
0.210744977,
0.1751865596,
0.2093323767,
-0.1861998886,
0.5801493526,
-0.5897158384,
-0.5204947591,
-0.4121468663,
0.1854591668,
0.1216541156,
0.6285511851,
0.8029252887,
-0.8677367568,
-0.8039925694,
-0.0077375635,
-0.2279963493,
-0.3179447353,
0.2016376108,
-0.2081908286,
0.4100694656,
0.5998517871,
-0.1266292036,
0.1469696909,
0.9135729671,
-0.2169088721,
0.4212559462,
-0.4898063838,
0.144348368,
-0.6814575195,
0.0789905787,
-0.0054717665,
-0.3499625027,
-0.5099144578,
-0.2775300145,
0.0712096021,
-0.0170402639,
-0.3738913238,
0.3931525052,
-0.502997458,
0.1264394969,
-0.1729758829,
0.0841059834,
0.0708475038,
0.529196322,
0.2783034444,
0.6269161105,
0.7129973769,
-0.5632995367,
-0.0005020162,
0.0096309008,
-0.4362010062,
0.260381937,
-0.3484536409,
-0.0993709043,
-0.1378814131,
0.0919184089,
-0.5561657548,
0.1157984287,
-0.0026892868,
-0.0696489513,
0.529109776,
-0.4518297911,
-0.4267293513,
-0.1734209508,
0.257990092,
0.7241050005,
0.606959343,
-0.6566716433,
0.4271110594,
0.4653818309,
-0.283063978,
-0.8373810649,
-0.8068891168,
-0.0753525943,
-0.2427212,
-0.1268527657,
0.0421862826,
-0.0007164924,
-0.0169193428,
-0.1034078076,
-0.0564093441,
-0.2938564122,
0.26155141,
-0.1934805065,
-0.0037541757,
-0.1155200377,
0.3557439148,
0.1326987445,
-0.3328555226,
-0.1630911678,
-0.3518372178,
0.735152185,
0.1477466375,
-0.5658254027,
-0.1057522818,
0.3766935468,
0.4182363451,
-0.8125457764,
1.0470255613,
0.7405318022,
-0.1124479249,
-0.5626820326,
-0.5071471334,
-0.325927943,
-0.4429452717,
0.3313976526,
-0.5659580827,
-0.9259850979,
0.2769906521,
-0.1309794337,
-0.1348296553,
0.3029253185,
0.4778431952,
0.1627364159,
1.0334994793,
0.7734423876,
-0.4528940022,
0.5289103389,
-0.146626249,
0.294072032,
-0.3731107116,
-0.1238789707,
-0.5745555162,
-0.3441339433,
-0.6772298217,
-0.4354304969,
0.4076150954,
0.2923223078,
-0.0349669419,
0.2259085923,
-0.4165592492,
0.7025379539,
0.8332952857,
-0.1758366078,
0.2742660046,
-0.0783109739,
-0.2471488416,
-0.1533949971,
-1.0694741011,
-0.4045247734,
0.8308033347,
0.1788990349,
0.6969942451,
0.1832704693,
0.9430612326,
0.0875501856,
0.0427795127,
-0.1766116172,
0.3092872202,
-0.4579316676,
-0.4422832727,
-0.5854525566,
-0.7067494988,
-0.8042859435,
0.5127502084,
-0.1494971514,
-0.6282518506,
0.0184979942,
0.4448426962,
-0.0336202607,
0.3263465464,
-0.762975812,
1.2799762487,
-0.5443526506,
-0.2903643847,
-0.3921890855,
-0.473649323,
-0.0830564126,
-0.5277360678,
0.3712010682,
-0.462792784,
0.3404493332,
0.3473240435,
-0.2105022222,
0.7755577564,
-0.4030844271,
-0.3657101989,
0.0624160618,
0.1218767613,
0.5561813116,
-0.0452458225,
-0.1376121044,
0.4309490025,
-0.0228640232,
-0.6176367998,
-0.5465492606,
0.837995708,
-0.7063674331,
-0.6465727687,
-0.2015931904,
-0.4698849618,
-0.3822777271,
0.2432206869,
0.4337788522,
0.5078988671,
-0.147861138,
-0.1025347114,
0.4725389183,
-0.1971216053,
0.4559182823,
0.6310196519,
-0.344376713,
-0.0977617353,
1.3458672762,
0.3428038061,
0.4468316734,
0.536552608,
0.3093366027,
-0.4227727056,
-0.5351256728,
-0.4992018342,
0.0098770652,
-0.5999225974,
0.0129745994,
-0.4672842324,
-0.0578745864,
-0.5174372792,
0.0733881667,
-0.5182855129,
-0.4180926979,
-0.1228080392,
0.0418447405,
-0.0373315103,
0.7042815089,
-0.3609191775,
0.0897534192,
-0.9232548475,
0.1989034861,
0.3273318112,
0.4888449609,
0.1113178506,
-0.3704668581,
-0.4941397905,
0.1615975499,
-0.209144339,
-0.3511824608,
0.3057464957,
0.4540397525,
0.8193282485,
0.0319087282,
0.2329418659,
0.5943624377,
-0.8751171231,
0.6018072367,
0.1338768899,
-0.9967642426,
0.6390166283,
-0.0616600551,
0.5984094143,
0.526574254,
0.5858437419,
-0.5098202825,
-0.5188661218,
-0.2599304914,
-1.0351427794,
0.7819082141,
0.1864476055,
0.0261945035,
0.1247760355,
-0.1846578419,
0.1743403822,
0.2058912665,
-0.9786763191,
-0.3107079566,
-0.2588231564,
-0.0562157482,
-0.7823466659,
-0.2392884493,
-0.2861639559,
-0.4395250976,
0.861468792,
-0.2158132046,
-0.3577472866,
0.12352328,
-0.2848322093,
-0.0625209436,
0.2902477682,
0.511732161,
0.942538619,
0.2572926879,
0.2828900516,
0.3857840002,
-0.1557259858,
0.3301862776,
0.2644197941,
0.2409519702,
-0.2110548615,
0.5350145698,
0.8739659786,
0.0295448955,
-0.581430912,
0.2675901353,
-0.0660326257,
0.0184828937,
0.0832059681,
0.1523690522,
0.0956381634,
0.3539108634,
0.2204445601,
-0.1943211108,
-0.098115474,
-0.2816720903,
0.3109649122,
0.1481814831,
-0.2096341848,
-0.0282922331,
0.5277042985,
0.4058100879,
-0.23150374,
0.5424221754,
-0.0392752551,
-0.6212695837,
0.4565445185,
0.43274647,
0.5726809502,
-0.5178456903,
0.2561562359,
0.2381466329,
0.4377836585,
-0.1000038832,
0.0185224172,
-0.2561379075,
-0.6134381294,
-0.4188686609,
-0.7088656425,
-0.0170232747,
-0.0456600413,
-0.7277536988,
0.219358027,
-0.1180845946,
-0.0583295114,
-0.0992238298,
-0.301176995,
-0.657104075,
0.3065009415,
0.2560613155,
0.8607547879,
-0.8968339562,
1.2279244661,
0.4829527736,
-0.0808391571,
-0.7549829483,
0.2253823131,
-0.1907321513,
-0.5735036135,
0.7674678564,
-0.0498332046,
-0.293430239,
0.1670975387,
0.1594600528,
-0.649331212,
0.6275317073,
0.688488543,
-1.1626447439,
0.3429608047,
0.5843340755,
0.6312769651,
-0.0915678889,
0.0298136156,
0.6634511948,
0.4917542338,
-0.0833100975,
-1.2949948311,
-0.4866328835,
0.0214716829,
-0.3238794208,
0.6420922279,
-0.6543284059,
0.7306615114,
0.0142217148,
0.058057297,
-0.482499361,
0.3056236804,
-0.0494243465,
0.3011336923,
0.5087723136,
0.763389647,
0.7330100536,
-0.1737891734,
0.8589608669,
-0.505617857,
0.4284623265,
1.335490346,
-0.3822361827,
0.7731230855,
0.4433723092,
-0.0127898268,
0.2706189752,
0.4976336658,
0.0884912834,
0.7423382401,
0.1992508173,
-0.4400007129,
-0.6108702421,
-0.0978840888,
-0.4532056451,
0.6488992572,
0.0872961059,
-0.072614491,
-0.4314454794,
0.2171482891,
-0.1933800578,
0.2807050347,
-0.3373914361,
0.82325387,
0.0450726263,
-0.7217294574,
0.7118667364,
-0.2284797877,
0.4588989615,
-0.7020461559,
-0.1720027924,
-0.2125436515,
0.2799269855,
-0.0834374502,
-0.8232265711,
0.2248773277,
0.001654778,
-0.1903847456,
-0.5498921275,
0.591093123,
-1.0364784002,
-0.547226429,
0.8683283925,
0.7463986874,
0.00560776,
-0.0454636775,
-0.6160415411,
0.0294037368,
0.0102469437,
-0.131538853,
0.537627995,
0.6166558266,
0.1155942306,
0.7522284985,
0.3547460735,
0.2247337103,
0.0290713031,
0.4136977494,
0.879189074,
-0.1257572919,
-0.5152940154,
-1.1346657276,
0.4706278145,
-0.0446056165,
-0.4725114107,
0.8343859315,
0.7366575599,
1.3376909494,
-0.054463882,
0.6271958947,
0.2275030315,
0.4595686793,
-0.5549208522,
1.0452848673,
-0.878171742,
0.1059514135,
-0.2052133381,
-1.0293759108,
-0.0946347788,
0.3795736134,
-0.2706151009,
0.0467602834,
0.3272438943,
0.6621090174,
-0.2254737616,
-0.3968706131,
0.6635278463,
0.0304208882,
0.3526961207,
0.5232715607,
0.7419216037,
0.1044340581,
0.4124207199,
-0.4934208691,
-0.1735744029,
0.135192588,
-0.8762239218,
-1.0432533026,
-0.6299403906,
-0.2886586189,
0.1459442824,
0.1859852225,
0.6410260797,
0.8365390301,
-0.832557261,
-0.3713312447,
0.1329420954,
0.262583673,
-0.0642022043,
-0.1206341311,
0.1660875529,
-0.3942053616,
-0.9382258058,
0.4569352865,
0.0908221453,
0.2416038662,
-0.2122066319,
-0.2579920292,
-0.3353486061,
-0.2339254618,
0.536575973,
0.1830805391,
-0.4223123789,
0.0619809367,
-0.5871393085,
-0.118477948,
0.0424080268,
0.9866124392,
-0.6212713122,
0.4502004683,
0.2574276328,
0.5004385114,
0.5100939274,
-0.1603342742,
0.6619513631,
-1.22488904,
0.4393260181,
0.3941567838,
0.3625105321,
0.3163907528,
-0.3067640662,
0.4675352275,
0.0878542364,
-0.6460074186,
-0.7841600776,
0.1388389766,
-0.2280973047,
-0.5327255726,
0.991057992,
-0.2594192028,
0.2615606487,
0.1123745218,
-0.2317827493,
0.1584244668,
-0.166458264,
0.717546761,
0.9734162092,
-0.1212095544,
-0.317062676,
-0.3653039038,
0.8278791308,
0.5980753303,
-0.734657824,
0.1651017517,
0.3138267696,
0.1638579965,
-0.0979531482,
0.6414490938,
0.3015139103,
0.0836482272,
-0.1612068713,
0.0430810265,
0.0695048794,
-0.799387157,
-0.318230778,
-0.0583112091,
0.275975436,
-0.0862347037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08488v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08488v1
|
Thematic Analysis with Large Language Models: does it work with languages other than English? A targeted test in Italian
| 2024-04-12T14:10:09 | 2024-04-12T14:10:09 |
Stefano De Paoli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper proposes a test to perform Thematic Analysis (TA) with Large
Language Model (LLM) on data which is in a different language than English.
While there has been initial promising work on using pre-trained LLMs for TA on
data in English, we lack any tests on whether these models can reasonably
perform the same analysis with good quality in other language. In this paper a
test will be proposed using an open access dataset of semi-structured
interviews in Italian. The test shows that a pre-trained model can perform such
a TA on the data, also using prompts in Italian. A comparative test shows the
model capacity to produce themes which have a good resemblance with those
produced independently by human researchers. The main implication of this study
is that pre-trained LLMs may thus be suitable to support analysis in
multilingual situations, so long as the language is supported by the model
used.
|
[
-0.2789089978,
-0.7446406484,
0.6379208565,
0.2535771728,
-0.4496649802,
0.0691119507,
-0.4794453681,
-0.7283792496,
0.6906163692,
0.3223913908,
-0.5572049022,
-0.6704446673,
-0.4632240236,
0.5552206635,
-0.5945855975,
0.8437846899,
-0.2039934844,
0.7258855104,
-0.1993852407,
-0.4661003053,
-0.5202645063,
-0.483181417,
-1.0402094126,
-0.2342101187,
0.6930329204,
0.3811815679,
0.1364392191,
0.0382864513,
0.5369154811,
0.3091098964,
-0.0952649936,
0.0615714565,
-0.4014793634,
-0.0302198194,
-0.4945159256,
-0.722538054,
-0.218448326,
0.0935409293,
0.7034491301,
0.6905457973,
0.0967527628,
0.272175312,
0.0513205007,
0.4067642689,
-0.2711997032,
0.2595371008,
-0.7026669383,
0.1109643504,
-0.2165371031,
-0.0759648755,
-0.3506036997,
-0.3881894052,
-0.1442420334,
-0.0885172412,
-0.0174029712,
0.2531713247,
0.9379069805,
0.0072342642,
-0.5517206788,
-0.2947225571,
-0.9703948498,
0.7155621648,
-0.6029108763,
0.1733376831,
0.4081636667,
0.2991456687,
-0.0434593894,
-0.659683466,
-0.4124076962,
-0.5819484591,
0.0590335019,
0.1571860015,
-0.2218143344,
-0.2976796925,
0.1421626061,
0.4678343236,
-0.5435090065,
0.4512723684,
-0.2159205377,
0.0123096732,
0.6475651264,
0.2875252962,
0.3834192157,
0.0782860667,
-0.2950468957,
0.2411327809,
-1.1101225615,
-0.0219162218,
0.4486913979,
0.5161269903,
-0.1936358809,
0.871948123,
0.0445238575,
0.384221673,
-0.334228456,
-0.1297542155,
0.0739014298,
-0.5206145048,
0.161016643,
0.0408986546,
0.8892390728,
0.2491470277,
0.770047307,
0.045158118,
-0.2627205849,
-0.2085014582,
-0.0625331402,
-0.5522556901,
0.1109911501,
0.0275077634,
-0.3048125505,
0.1774473637,
0.1186840162,
-0.8189604878,
-0.1475093812,
-0.2598876357,
0.0540685244,
-0.3490123749,
-0.2510044873,
0.2479596585,
0.2931786776,
0.2173441499,
0.2106433809,
-0.4690829515,
0.0543659776,
0.5276625752,
0.9310068488,
-0.3175338507,
-0.3944606185,
-0.3068834543,
0.0613232069,
-0.3922303319,
0.8799039721,
-0.6983755827,
-0.4631582499,
0.2027863711,
0.2404354215,
-0.1057743058,
-0.2945503891,
0.2964333594,
-0.3685832024,
0.5940931439,
-0.2202603668,
-0.4707652628,
0.0400104783,
0.4988685846,
-0.7188101411,
1.1847550869,
-0.0336817428,
-0.8554556966,
0.2190455347,
-0.6192780733,
-0.4765297472,
-0.1187669858,
-0.4306680858,
-0.3780468404,
0.2197839469,
0.009620822,
0.2652074695,
-0.7092260718,
0.683144033,
-0.3820397258,
-0.2989037037,
0.4341034591,
-0.2847556472,
0.7370629907,
0.2731521726,
-0.4981030822,
-0.0395326018,
-0.8065932989,
-0.1287120134,
0.3171673417,
-0.0825751722,
-0.5281172991,
0.1978112757,
0.2162538469,
0.1051718444,
0.1555079222,
-0.8264325261,
0.2766365707,
-0.3736833632,
0.2916446328,
0.4935338497,
-0.1078917682,
0.0146305198,
-0.1277759224,
0.9542862177,
0.0485684946,
-0.4056016207,
-0.1341466606,
-0.4338552654,
-0.8224049807,
-0.5359840989,
0.5787709951,
0.6368611455,
-0.9487258792,
0.5219119787,
-0.3725216687,
-0.4132754207,
-0.3233599365,
-0.2698809505,
0.2615735233,
0.1473042369,
-0.0262903608,
-0.5751827955,
-0.6737368703,
-0.9629876018,
-0.3114734888,
-0.3734293878,
0.0033848153,
0.2600133121,
0.9065204859,
0.1361228824,
1.0180573463,
-0.3290519118,
-0.2905206978,
-0.5732290745,
0.212507084,
0.379830718,
0.3491441309,
0.7999093533,
-0.5717164278,
-0.3983524144,
0.147032544,
-0.6559374332,
-0.1795095354,
0.1429840773,
0.2381015569,
-0.0186559651,
0.4541923106,
-0.5861829519,
0.3854125142,
0.4867822826,
-0.3685899079,
0.3612204492,
-0.2578834593,
0.3107974231,
-1.494030118,
0.2127020508,
0.2838797867,
-0.0831263289,
-0.4769113064,
0.0286181308,
-0.267649889,
-0.5535168648,
-0.6407444477,
0.9454889894,
-0.4048778713,
-0.1907723844,
-0.1517104954,
-0.2232800871,
-0.1309635341,
0.158240214,
0.403878808,
0.9979500175,
0.4568148255,
-0.1847707778,
0.1102946699,
0.0517165288,
-0.7732358575,
0.5962080359,
-0.7205092311,
0.1077285036,
-0.206908375,
0.0548855588,
-1.2363941669,
-0.0892620459,
0.1437926441,
-0.2984101176,
0.1124122068,
0.0497293696,
-0.5648846626,
-0.2935898304,
-0.1053705141,
0.4557828605,
0.2255921215,
-0.3288921118,
0.401161164,
0.2345689535,
-0.4648301303,
-0.2897396982,
-0.7799780369,
0.0893255621,
-0.8077622056,
-0.4211834073,
-0.0492591411,
-0.0542355403,
-0.5783904195,
-0.2552873194,
0.2553460896,
-0.6822231412,
0.2623846233,
-0.2200270146,
0.0897387639,
-0.573300004,
0.102356866,
-0.1506825536,
-0.0348628201,
0.0867155716,
-0.4695251584,
0.6035448313,
0.0913054869,
-0.6111141443,
-0.5405551195,
0.4642244577,
0.5341089964,
-0.6203853488,
0.7834248543,
0.5022398233,
-0.2705812156,
0.0472360924,
-0.4693353176,
-0.0372373648,
-0.3990264237,
0.4880453348,
-0.5180723667,
-0.9882593751,
0.7344718575,
-0.0363989659,
-0.1948673874,
0.411082238,
0.7746922374,
-0.331841141,
0.841594696,
0.7578995824,
-0.4570698738,
0.6184931993,
-0.1255968213,
0.3202166557,
-0.2040221095,
-0.171098277,
-1.2177326679,
-0.3919740915,
-0.798469007,
-0.1798770875,
0.4252453446,
-0.3068161607,
0.0056220321,
0.0026940666,
0.074200578,
0.7060781121,
0.2762001455,
-0.0534083955,
0.4522859752,
0.1982882172,
-0.0069138934,
-0.2939138114,
-0.4804365635,
-0.6052105427,
0.8340275288,
0.1832221001,
0.66143471,
-0.0494519472,
0.5273502469,
-0.0451740623,
0.1173551977,
-0.8157708049,
0.4887427986,
-0.1542691439,
-0.74472785,
-0.2283811569,
-0.3548883498,
-1.2710710764,
0.1688300371,
0.0391210727,
-0.7543377876,
0.1911717057,
-0.3467641771,
0.0430172719,
0.4102076888,
-0.5077353716,
0.5837328434,
-0.2935031652,
-0.1380758286,
-0.1166462749,
-0.2977616191,
0.2693777382,
-0.217481941,
0.3741755188,
-0.2847364545,
0.0125830788,
0.7936521769,
0.0659368932,
0.9816922545,
-0.0455255918,
-0.2438367903,
0.311378181,
0.0280117821,
0.2581169009,
0.2199887931,
-0.254888773,
0.3401737511,
0.0591264591,
-0.5206076503,
-0.5452690125,
0.3651800454,
-0.6349851489,
-0.7588207126,
-0.5005735159,
-0.7262619138,
-0.3998698592,
0.215140745,
0.0549671538,
0.314253062,
-0.4173723161,
0.3676208258,
0.4965365231,
-0.1634296179,
0.3497935832,
0.9828464389,
-0.1761078984,
-0.1093714461,
0.6199077964,
0.0609953031,
-0.0179702565,
0.3599281013,
0.2967224717,
-0.0508726351,
-0.9365873933,
-0.2903354466,
0.3425585032,
-0.2027635872,
0.042562373,
-0.1307049841,
-0.0025429272,
-0.0981346518,
0.2495806664,
-0.4140520096,
-0.2173312306,
-0.1356510371,
-0.2393220812,
0.3746806085,
0.803919971,
0.1526935846,
0.0733624101,
-0.8001986146,
-0.1055920124,
-0.1417174637,
0.0371120982,
-0.3308889866,
-0.3909491599,
-0.4336969256,
0.1675633937,
-0.0625094101,
-0.9446729422,
0.3843692541,
0.204095751,
0.4463200271,
0.3711721003,
-0.1649321914,
0.6837975979,
-0.7663196921,
0.9177814126,
0.1735419184,
-0.7707983851,
0.5997961164,
-0.6849786639,
0.1752753705,
1.0197826624,
0.9228103161,
-0.3744005561,
-0.8056569099,
-0.4242299199,
-0.4838881791,
0.7524086833,
0.2210896313,
0.387258172,
-0.1818266362,
0.527077198,
0.2283329666,
0.30447945,
-0.9368225932,
-0.1044439748,
0.4533909559,
-0.4825263917,
-0.5609906912,
-0.2548337579,
-0.2290595472,
-0.3520895541,
0.2185657024,
-0.0528781377,
0.3220286369,
0.0513629988,
0.1124908254,
0.0611969195,
0.335493207,
0.3033021092,
0.9436869621,
0.1042123213,
-0.0040783971,
0.2955355644,
-0.3109553158,
0.4515792429,
-0.1311299056,
-0.1406879276,
0.1243162304,
0.7946372628,
0.7395884991,
0.2655341029,
-0.7450249195,
0.3767920434,
-0.1706976295,
-0.0637001693,
-0.4142836332,
-0.1718528122,
0.0855849683,
0.320189029,
0.1491977274,
-0.5054109097,
-0.1181886271,
-0.9986088276,
0.108445704,
0.5074692965,
-0.3213615716,
-0.5174181461,
0.3574541807,
0.2822508812,
-0.518073082,
0.6214766502,
-0.0737635344,
-0.358789593,
0.888494432,
0.6957314014,
0.8014395833,
-0.4556617439,
0.2045882791,
0.1585041732,
0.4797844887,
0.1021054313,
0.590167284,
0.1909060627,
-0.848402679,
-0.5341315866,
-0.4571497142,
-0.4647041857,
0.1003431529,
-0.9829953909,
0.4550786316,
-0.1103616133,
0.1654370576,
-0.3293988109,
0.151239872,
-0.4883026183,
0.3710560799,
-0.0907201692,
1.036824584,
-1.2538605928,
1.2358349562,
1.0297863483,
-0.3803715408,
-0.7054371834,
0.0502548479,
-0.1645368636,
-1.0000860691,
0.7943986058,
0.1029950753,
-0.0447270684,
-0.0058929049,
-0.3740025163,
-0.8175123334,
0.9908460379,
0.7016646266,
-0.4949496388,
-0.1072171852,
0.4787463546,
0.9058883786,
-0.6996312737,
0.6702404618,
0.574729085,
0.5424143076,
0.1754671037,
-0.9946809411,
-0.4526215196,
-0.2019300312,
-0.0346762463,
0.2836672068,
-0.7356439829,
0.7754007578,
0.2915677726,
-0.1727204323,
0.4148158431,
0.8274483085,
0.1870690882,
0.5447791219,
0.50739187,
0.4708655477,
0.7245109677,
-0.2796197832,
1.2240463495,
-0.4333670139,
0.5660665035,
0.9789690971,
-0.7018837333,
0.8680312037,
0.5602985024,
-0.3450097442,
0.6202367544,
0.9608228803,
0.1983876228,
0.4540601075,
0.1932352185,
-0.1266107708,
-0.0747990534,
-0.5221982002,
-0.4760283828,
0.8358379006,
0.0518413819,
-0.1712478697,
-0.3486407101,
0.3016315997,
0.1940141022,
0.1796209961,
-0.3703297079,
0.6714636087,
0.0990467891,
-0.5774284005,
0.1901615858,
0.1794981807,
0.306279242,
-0.9052230716,
0.2413743883,
-0.7331759334,
-0.1006395072,
0.0431343503,
-0.6485832334,
0.5922092795,
0.4300966561,
0.0475124121,
-0.1286097318,
0.4256059229,
-0.6334432364,
-0.9550803304,
0.4167546332,
0.9002688527,
0.4338229895,
0.1493596584,
-0.6571449041,
0.0149091789,
0.0548627526,
-0.2174703777,
0.4662249982,
0.5787683725,
-0.2279020548,
0.5197778344,
0.3681468666,
0.3538146317,
-0.2333236486,
0.1471533477,
0.7397249341,
-0.8147149086,
-0.5129069686,
-0.9507763386,
0.4906887412,
0.0664352402,
-0.335878253,
0.8909575939,
0.6093221307,
0.8581926823,
0.052671548,
0.3535734117,
0.0221700985,
0.3878789842,
-1.0123157501,
0.388768971,
-0.8474630117,
0.1089426726,
-0.1657494754,
-1.2449749708,
-0.1446468234,
0.474141866,
-0.4457394481,
0.1696788371,
1.2596236467,
0.731910944,
-0.0838148519,
0.1590742022,
0.3688279688,
0.2704318762,
0.1070311591,
0.5851553679,
1.2839856148,
0.1056784466,
-0.0239210688,
0.0409887731,
-0.0582336672,
0.4102532268,
-0.8012611866,
-1.3187355995,
-0.4932527244,
-0.0919516385,
-0.137102589,
0.0673687011,
0.7838852406,
0.3290461898,
-0.9960145354,
-0.6370397806,
0.3500218391,
0.0345181264,
0.2200322002,
-0.1515477747,
0.2845580578,
-0.091031462,
-1.1912180185,
0.5940136313,
0.1644162387,
-0.1943144202,
-0.4501245916,
0.2875789106,
-0.4156179428,
0.0259088725,
0.3612054586,
0.0434028432,
-0.5332274437,
-0.4955217242,
-0.0696273595,
0.1256488562,
0.222591266,
1.3292120695,
-0.3924949765,
0.2986437082,
0.369554162,
0.7317075133,
0.4853722155,
-0.1587194502,
0.6834958792,
-0.7894316912,
0.6486068964,
0.2777711749,
0.7455426455,
0.0877131522,
-0.2901009321,
0.6474406123,
0.1712020934,
-0.1532342434,
-0.7753209472,
0.3176775277,
-0.6310293674,
-0.2106662691,
1.2550312281,
-0.665034771,
-0.1104383394,
-0.0601873957,
-0.1610423923,
0.0324886739,
-0.0057791807,
0.7798332572,
1.1524927616,
0.059828233,
0.0439892188,
-0.3287896812,
-0.1849375963,
0.6119237542,
-1.1877148151,
-0.5059787631,
0.2200680077,
0.2768952847,
-0.0199803077,
0.6554747224,
-0.142028302,
0.0946224183,
-0.5086990595,
0.0193080734,
0.0690598562,
-0.4842101932,
-0.7078205347,
0.1020938754,
0.3286990225,
0.0652233958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08480v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08480v1
|
Decoding AI: The inside story of data analysis in ChatGPT
| 2024-04-12T13:57:30 | 2024-04-12T13:57:30 |
Ozan Evkaya, Miguel de Carvalho
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.CO
|
As a result of recent advancements in generative AI, the field of Data
Science is prone to various changes. This review critically examines the Data
Analysis (DA) capabilities of ChatGPT assessing its performance across a wide
range of tasks. While DA provides researchers and practitioners with
unprecedented analytical capabilities, it is far from being perfect, and it is
important to recognize and address its limitations.
|
[
-0.3029977679,
-1.0880637169,
0.3610663712,
0.1475406736,
0.0149969421,
0.5313408971,
0.1530847549,
-0.6078084111,
-0.2369395494,
0.1724940091,
-0.4697937667,
-0.2189383805,
-0.8665322065,
0.093430303,
-0.7568045855,
1.262575388,
0.0499718152,
0.1184697673,
-0.3848073483,
0.025041068,
-0.7686100602,
-0.8386674523,
-1.1834614277,
0.0255348831,
-0.1144624501,
0.6726768613,
0.8773249984,
0.4040739238,
1.027007699,
0.2341129035,
0.075234957,
0.1107021272,
-0.6573283672,
0.3443262577,
0.435677886,
-0.7093257308,
-0.5048994422,
-0.065718621,
0.8034793139,
0.8661797643,
-0.0685494095,
-0.079823263,
0.1098571569,
1.0387142897,
-0.2685491145,
0.9551705122,
-0.4797599912,
0.164911896,
-0.5253655314,
-0.2092822045,
-0.2629337311,
-0.4226866364,
0.4495724738,
-0.4728145301,
0.5472223163,
-0.0178920813,
0.5239825845,
0.6361442804,
-0.4607573152,
-0.6271968484,
-1.0609002113,
0.5685122013,
-0.4450004995,
0.2709751129,
0.4560401142,
0.6100190878,
-0.2324509472,
-0.8609690666,
-0.6305636764,
-0.2070642859,
0.1526951343,
0.2248969823,
-0.5552058816,
0.1829278469,
0.2399781644,
0.9382058978,
-0.5846251845,
-0.1033384725,
-0.5936124325,
0.1010900885,
0.8924888968,
0.6499570608,
0.578395009,
0.0771328062,
-0.0384128466,
-0.2057336718,
-0.459408015,
-0.1388976872,
0.2147476524,
0.0037205869,
-0.1911576837,
0.5758214593,
-0.2080095559,
0.5466273427,
-0.3656732142,
0.4059037566,
0.0762024969,
-0.3621255457,
-0.3204312921,
0.0160688534,
0.6552394032,
0.4083992839,
0.1217652783,
-0.3996300697,
0.1264113188,
0.116148524,
0.3713830113,
-0.6694689989,
-0.7687602639,
0.2924701869,
-0.5463628769,
-0.2016143203,
0.0674787685,
-1.1110675335,
-0.7039917707,
-0.1806605309,
-0.0073138387,
-0.6155754328,
-0.3479017317,
0.132239446,
-0.366127491,
0.6371501088,
0.222370699,
-0.8062009811,
0.4281225801,
0.7665396929,
1.0135115385,
-0.2686848342,
-0.1839371324,
-0.2066743523,
-0.3532731831,
-0.5152863264,
1.0154144764,
-0.5900269151,
-0.642003417,
-0.2444800735,
-0.3031537235,
-0.46843642,
-0.356785953,
0.64133811,
-0.7216370702,
-0.0103315711,
-0.2559995055,
-0.8277792335,
-0.3893841803,
0.200819701,
-0.8568702936,
0.8081373572,
0.1803289205,
-0.8641633391,
0.698626101,
-1.170771718,
-0.1541928798,
0.0912540108,
-0.2526501715,
-0.5889678597,
0.1021315679,
0.2670866251,
0.2927751839,
-0.2594701052,
-0.1155324727,
-0.0452587716,
-0.5128346086,
0.6210237741,
-0.8660671115,
0.9281183481,
0.5441009998,
-0.179749772,
0.0551498197,
-0.8404996991,
-0.036059618,
0.1781776696,
-0.1881176978,
0.2072880566,
0.4209587276,
-0.1612953842,
-0.365152061,
-0.3682552576,
-0.3542784154,
0.3748452663,
-0.4112403095,
0.6347042322,
0.3971281648,
0.0972834453,
0.3424316049,
-0.2397837192,
0.9510495067,
-0.2295236439,
-0.1029377356,
-0.2485574633,
-0.7911394835,
-0.6695002913,
-0.1232055724,
0.5279906392,
0.6942840219,
-0.9078752398,
0.1069400758,
-0.2857938409,
-0.3593951762,
-0.9091022611,
-0.2904688716,
-0.0185320172,
0.1278668046,
0.224378258,
-0.277970016,
-0.510776937,
-0.6025128365,
-0.0085420031,
-0.1932414621,
0.0089936228,
0.0773392916,
0.3200520873,
-0.2535172403,
0.9347431064,
-0.5903072953,
-0.2714374959,
-0.4614720345,
0.2010342181,
0.0969303027,
0.234477818,
0.4985097945,
-0.8827040792,
-0.6531897187,
0.1999244839,
-0.877619803,
0.1071211919,
-0.2145317197,
0.1774621755,
-0.0929327831,
0.64668715,
-0.6570747495,
0.8759739399,
0.426692605,
-0.4244046807,
0.536937952,
-0.2678990364,
0.3970811665,
-0.689427495,
0.0799060762,
-0.3732985556,
0.1771928668,
-0.8454071879,
-0.1442813426,
-0.1667839587,
-0.4868673086,
0.2886502147,
0.1038170755,
-0.4015266001,
-0.2052280754,
-0.6875253916,
-0.3523194194,
-0.2939482629,
0.0464079529,
-0.2239973247,
0.9265992045,
0.9076450467,
-0.5073606372,
0.7780265212,
0.5278980732,
-0.5892949104,
0.4447899163,
-0.5781463981,
0.4575357735,
-0.3861887455,
0.3056900203,
-1.376686573,
-0.501830101,
0.5116130114,
-0.7207168937,
0.1317608356,
-0.3723737895,
-0.6145522594,
-0.2009491622,
-0.0130169392,
0.6403978467,
0.5829344988,
-0.5124747753,
0.2257414907,
0.4521315694,
-0.2168516666,
-0.3287602365,
-0.5616976023,
0.4019194245,
-0.5711545944,
-0.7275422812,
0.1741385013,
-0.1794863492,
-0.6447402239,
0.0515061729,
0.1103420556,
-0.4186772406,
0.1939472854,
0.1283258647,
0.1045987979,
-0.0065672463,
0.1005769297,
-0.1887633502,
-0.4830649495,
0.3506610096,
0.1558161676,
0.5112327933,
-0.0808618814,
-0.3471625745,
-0.6895290017,
0.3212778866,
0.5872901082,
-0.2452386767,
0.6050996184,
0.5542854071,
-0.0414155722,
-0.168375507,
0.0212290138,
0.1620399654,
-0.4299752116,
0.3709692061,
-0.4368881583,
-0.2247533649,
0.6041066647,
0.2819343209,
-0.0386630893,
0.5057495832,
0.3405932188,
-0.2057848424,
1.097315073,
0.6629246473,
-0.2736022174,
0.5522616506,
-0.4084665775,
0.4884205163,
-0.4591318369,
-0.176840961,
-0.6046169996,
-0.1069397032,
-0.7148296833,
-0.00655453,
0.5683057308,
-0.1448108554,
0.0773332566,
-0.251698643,
-0.6391893029,
0.5054033399,
0.5606386662,
-0.0652652234,
0.4199046791,
-0.0248280838,
1.0472216606,
-0.0345399864,
-0.7334964871,
-0.2612416446,
1.3457767963,
0.5070470572,
0.7493101954,
0.0630695969,
0.2175812274,
0.661967814,
-0.0286575295,
-1.0353080034,
0.2895447314,
-0.0783123523,
-0.386460036,
-0.2032174915,
-0.5172672868,
-1.2398797274,
0.1252253205,
0.0465716049,
-0.5069797635,
0.1549484432,
-0.0813757181,
-0.2373054773,
0.3551979363,
-1.0530651808,
0.6569223404,
0.1497084498,
0.4361893535,
-0.177191332,
-0.464805454,
0.187011838,
0.0892231688,
-0.021924559,
-0.0072582858,
0.3397740424,
0.9107427597,
-0.2823653817,
0.7325957417,
-0.218835324,
-0.0274593495,
0.5512505174,
0.1427577287,
0.2517296672,
0.0324710682,
-0.1957057863,
0.2257657349,
0.4080915749,
-0.6405052543,
-0.7466708422,
0.2165959179,
-0.5202435255,
-0.5057157874,
-0.6084611416,
-0.7498227358,
-0.3558034599,
-0.2133705467,
0.2989966273,
0.2985759377,
-0.3577517271,
0.2186319232,
0.5405474901,
-0.1128845215,
0.4255355597,
-0.0785757005,
0.2127128392,
0.0183988828,
1.0508028269,
0.1311096102,
-0.0103834877,
0.0574901924,
-0.0803103819,
-0.1190596819,
-1.0018354654,
-0.6203162074,
-0.3979599178,
-0.6091788411,
-0.0169660803,
-0.4192119241,
-0.4261542261,
-0.2023599893,
0.1831962466,
-0.3231585026,
-0.3112250865,
-0.1117029786,
-0.1684981883,
0.5515844226,
1.0958477259,
-0.0751711875,
0.4682794213,
-0.645806849,
0.308650285,
0.1290767938,
0.3560860455,
0.0136200478,
-0.0537150986,
-0.2135952115,
0.1733071804,
-0.3370393515,
-0.9011741877,
0.3217935264,
0.0347016975,
0.5418489575,
0.3339688778,
-0.1275927275,
0.5582913756,
-0.0434460528,
0.8777035475,
-0.3622234166,
-0.7840742469,
0.4514888227,
-0.2243864238,
0.0344800428,
0.300644964,
0.2202404141,
-0.5985642076,
-0.0240530316,
-0.6561686993,
-0.6059427857,
0.8951355815,
0.6459816694,
0.2538069189,
0.2276724726,
0.4100482166,
0.4403512776,
-0.0253757667,
-0.3259422183,
-0.2945923209,
-0.2485291958,
-0.2102892101,
-0.0603973605,
-0.2236445993,
0.0552910045,
-0.3620791733,
0.1767942607,
-0.0246460028,
0.7815240622,
-0.0033100958,
0.017108744,
0.3670980632,
0.1534381807,
-0.0914908275,
0.7782974839,
-0.0558072776,
-0.1888758093,
0.0634358898,
-0.7221133709,
-0.2761887014,
0.3225399256,
0.0878016055,
-0.1817151904,
0.7472689748,
0.7187966108,
-0.3827253282,
-0.7059400678,
0.3370640278,
-0.2641798854,
-0.0961835533,
-0.2699577808,
0.4070057869,
-0.5532693863,
0.2705535889,
0.4571987391,
-0.1173337996,
0.5197685957,
-0.7396402359,
0.0980163962,
0.3355664909,
-0.3159539104,
-0.4040979147,
0.5150520802,
0.0269906931,
-0.0721284449,
1.4357506037,
-0.2024926692,
-0.4464299679,
1.1077024937,
0.3929857016,
0.9898408651,
-0.2034229934,
0.177599296,
-0.0213405509,
0.1848973036,
0.3396703005,
0.3794253767,
-0.2838845849,
-0.8211168051,
-0.2742586434,
-0.1127701178,
-0.6465176344,
0.0159395449,
-0.6750315428,
-0.2141051143,
-0.0833729655,
0.0793490633,
0.2308625132,
0.2265477628,
-0.7021466494,
0.3566461802,
-0.1725406647,
0.5607799888,
-0.4269717932,
0.6722017527,
0.3203049302,
-0.4216476679,
-0.0402933545,
0.2292747498,
0.1378069967,
-0.8012206554,
0.5343942642,
-0.086624451,
0.1137641519,
0.0247975048,
-0.6825382113,
-0.7490386963,
1.0421421528,
0.2025776356,
0.0932648554,
-0.0455152132,
0.3567997515,
0.7081944942,
-0.069748722,
0.3472344875,
1.189375639,
0.4501760006,
-0.1392129362,
-0.9742165208,
-0.5060352087,
-0.3120992184,
-0.3235554397,
0.0571737327,
-0.4621686041,
0.9143344164,
-0.0819072872,
-0.8051758409,
0.0315786637,
0.5561602116,
-0.3093359172,
0.5895704627,
0.2084458917,
0.2744615972,
0.9540311098,
-0.2748101056,
1.3343573809,
0.0548364297,
0.2871735096,
0.7602074146,
0.0824183375,
0.3318419456,
-0.0300632138,
-0.6284700632,
0.2020889372,
0.749699533,
-0.3097414672,
0.484059304,
0.0547889359,
-0.2225399762,
0.2657584548,
0.2390535772,
-0.4335574806,
0.8289380074,
0.7599220872,
-0.0910511017,
-0.222411871,
0.1600731313,
-0.2132335156,
-0.3261736929,
-0.1967968196,
1.0731878281,
-0.1066355333,
-0.1617233455,
0.196334064,
-0.2378789037,
0.2036969811,
-0.3546219766,
-0.4137990475,
-0.3042545021,
0.0596028492,
-0.2693350017,
-1.180036068,
0.9061633945,
0.0621802434,
0.0427711867,
-0.0060193082,
0.6038609743,
-0.0114535093,
-0.1169908717,
0.0352320485,
0.5876737237,
0.4353823662,
-0.3401402533,
-0.5601530075,
0.3952159584,
0.1347729713,
-0.0641949028,
-0.0653199404,
0.4838388264,
-0.0197258815,
0.9795582294,
0.5067996383,
-0.186352998,
0.1377297193,
-0.1635852456,
0.6933168173,
-0.9905099869,
-0.5210795403,
-0.9323043227,
0.3296353221,
-0.0989097655,
-0.3353114426,
0.9334241152,
0.6594166756,
0.7338693738,
0.09533941,
1.0927270651,
-0.4569716752,
0.2731374502,
-0.6579403281,
0.7774445415,
-0.0248561557,
0.2639509141,
-0.087405093,
-0.875952363,
-0.302554518,
0.2803694606,
-0.4884791374,
0.04678322,
0.4901217222,
0.3967072368,
-0.0767196715,
0.6192362309,
0.2600907087,
0.2086066008,
0.6991987228,
0.414729178,
1.2296469212,
-0.4903828204,
0.6768401265,
-0.0945467055,
-0.3558219671,
0.0240555424,
-0.2743582129,
-0.8564273119,
-0.8959317207,
-0.2772795558,
-0.1983500272,
0.0163679738,
0.1469385624,
0.7175838351,
-0.7523143291,
-0.1235797778,
-0.4130441248,
0.1223048046,
-0.4254359007,
-0.3166997731,
0.9343028069,
-0.6435373425,
-1.1128495932,
0.6274889112,
-0.0664761513,
0.0451220088,
-0.0535802878,
0.1763129532,
0.4457305074,
-0.1041408405,
0.6542681456,
0.4139827192,
-0.0791986212,
-0.0821212232,
-0.3303226233,
0.2055415362,
0.3475142121,
0.9761962891,
-0.661141634,
0.7889983654,
0.6364845037,
1.0752372742,
0.6762753129,
0.0735582411,
0.7768744826,
-0.4297405481,
-0.1335958242,
0.2606176138,
0.1073330194,
0.278766036,
-0.5995777249,
0.7199141979,
0.0410411954,
-0.8756101131,
-0.775824666,
-0.0016505832,
-0.9796732068,
-0.2843514383,
0.8277540803,
0.0423989408,
0.1271210164,
-0.5807289481,
-0.6390302181,
0.0736595243,
-0.1548005641,
1.1360350847,
0.987264514,
-0.9023276567,
-0.1388536692,
-1.0188853741,
0.973652482,
0.2469197065,
-1.0772628784,
0.2845436931,
0.3685397804,
0.0728304386,
-0.259411335,
0.7687317729,
-0.1935357898,
0.2548799515,
0.6212204099,
-0.4711642861,
0.1030294821,
-0.2750686407,
-0.4075590372,
0.1959588528,
0.1115860045,
-0.6409842372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08417v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08417v1
|
AdapterSwap: Continuous Training of LLMs with Data Removal and Access-Control Guarantees
| 2024-04-12T12:06:02 | 2024-04-12T12:06:02 |
William Fleshman, Aleem Khan, Marc Marone, Benjamin Van Durme
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly capable of completing knowledge
intensive tasks by recalling information from a static pretraining corpus. Here
we are concerned with LLMs in the context of evolving data requirements. For
instance: batches of new data that are introduced periodically; subsets of data
with user-based access controls; or requirements on dynamic removal of
documents with guarantees that associated knowledge cannot be recalled. We wish
to satisfy these requirements while at the same time ensuring a model does not
forget old information when new data becomes available. To address these
issues, we introduce AdapterSwap, a training and inference scheme that
organizes knowledge from a data collection into a set of low-rank adapters,
which are dynamically composed during inference. Our experiments demonstrate
AdapterSwap's ability to support efficient continual learning, while also
enabling organizations to have fine-grained control over data access and
deletion.
|
[
-0.3866021633,
-0.5635024905,
0.4568828642,
0.0762340948,
0.0221754462,
0.0173699986,
-0.2359477431,
-0.5354736447,
-0.158566758,
0.670078218,
-0.7533603907,
-0.317830056,
-0.7542823553,
-0.0684650466,
-0.7379077077,
0.8833169341,
-0.3753567636,
-0.3698136508,
-0.5274160504,
-0.2282746583,
-0.5561168194,
-0.29561463,
-0.7814449072,
-0.4654089212,
0.6285344958,
0.6553236842,
0.5422107577,
0.7689881921,
0.4044218659,
0.2505849302,
-0.1440694779,
0.1571601033,
-0.5817693472,
0.3696898222,
-0.2458529025,
-0.7744861841,
-0.2767622173,
-0.1171401814,
0.7858003974,
0.9252767563,
-0.5556743145,
0.1124751717,
0.2175954729,
0.8021228909,
-0.7062331438,
0.0881107152,
-0.9445760846,
0.0917163938,
0.1283898801,
-0.1565272957,
-0.4309542477,
-0.4359854758,
0.1970760822,
-0.5743377805,
0.0868494436,
-0.0667429268,
0.8378683329,
0.2430950254,
-0.2204446346,
-0.5732189417,
-0.9194599986,
0.7328602672,
-0.3235494494,
0.4046488702,
0.4357191324,
0.308524698,
-0.4843631089,
-1.0068793297,
-0.637644887,
0.0594327487,
0.0994874164,
0.1911593825,
-0.0751430392,
-0.0494390018,
0.300862968,
0.3133374453,
-0.15963386,
0.3293444812,
-0.46000278,
0.1653790623,
0.3058934212,
0.1665811539,
0.2850192785,
0.2181909978,
-0.250769347,
0.1481385082,
-1.0205258131,
-0.2417760044,
-0.0146665806,
-0.0547232144,
-0.1886970252,
0.5536708236,
-0.415135771,
0.6964515448,
-0.1834143996,
-0.0682474002,
0.0616213009,
0.2240950465,
-0.3047230244,
-0.0918913633,
0.2321398109,
0.0330475606,
0.43023628,
-0.4988846779,
-0.4008734226,
-0.0814608112,
0.2832136154,
-0.4742753208,
-0.2200060487,
0.2158903778,
-0.5248633027,
-0.2749481499,
-0.2153711766,
-0.6437729597,
-0.4881967604,
-0.5823124647,
0.3967163563,
-0.4148778021,
-0.1468048543,
0.0334066078,
-0.1772384495,
0.3783167601,
0.5265678763,
-1.1206279993,
0.4904324412,
0.5037377477,
0.7365197539,
-0.5625936389,
-0.3125588,
-0.4855262041,
0.6382325888,
-0.1776487082,
0.673568964,
-0.7373555303,
-0.4325344563,
0.1367844343,
0.1900464296,
-0.305157423,
-0.7703114152,
0.2388064861,
-0.8860560656,
0.1195132509,
-0.0864347294,
-0.8783174157,
0.0130497338,
0.191648066,
-0.3538793623,
0.7205273509,
0.270262301,
-0.4802148044,
0.4750090241,
-0.6367462873,
-0.2484360337,
0.0593487509,
-0.149718374,
-0.4196449816,
0.2181984186,
-0.0068695871,
0.3189596236,
-0.1855169237,
0.0968498364,
-0.5382346511,
-0.0874720365,
0.1292079836,
-0.3987008035,
0.3542842567,
0.359239608,
-0.1062937975,
0.0072742742,
-0.9794766307,
-0.1672253758,
0.2442586869,
-0.7620300651,
-0.3673477173,
0.4119074941,
-0.2751390934,
0.1491304189,
0.1869800836,
-0.2618685365,
0.3441981971,
-0.1237881631,
0.475789994,
1.0193315744,
0.1084205806,
0.531548202,
-0.532949388,
0.4447193146,
-0.0376712382,
0.3531219661,
-0.198633492,
-0.2187363058,
-1.047591567,
-0.2891811728,
-0.097707957,
0.5261697769,
-0.7526550293,
0.4348572493,
-0.3582462966,
-0.3271057308,
-0.0862803385,
0.3219634295,
0.0528788567,
0.4963580072,
0.4842284322,
-0.0116749592,
-0.523444593,
-0.6369796991,
-0.1551495939,
0.0848331675,
-0.4263323247,
0.1621662974,
0.2362260669,
-0.4644844234,
0.9578781128,
-0.4939379096,
-0.1048465967,
-0.2759671211,
-0.1355837584,
0.1159072891,
0.5846056938,
0.340028733,
-0.8131605983,
-0.1880473495,
-0.1869734228,
-0.8899639845,
-0.1993533373,
-0.1965960562,
-0.1142228916,
0.0480466448,
0.8216189742,
-0.4256288111,
0.2965011299,
0.6259690523,
-0.0489367023,
0.4014565647,
-0.2851279676,
-0.2181307077,
-0.9868410826,
0.0940890014,
-0.3078379631,
-0.5314525366,
-0.4587210715,
-0.0013278249,
0.0591770336,
-0.0582102798,
-0.2596917152,
0.6396517158,
-0.426643759,
-0.0681238398,
-0.4467576444,
0.191566959,
-0.1651969999,
0.2442560792,
0.3459902704,
0.5461637974,
0.4495997727,
-1.1292033195,
0.2865842879,
0.3774065971,
-0.4249838293,
0.4206393361,
-0.4196849763,
0.040774554,
-0.2326351553,
0.1800645888,
-0.8264606595,
-0.2349251956,
0.0579204075,
-0.0388789549,
0.2761687934,
-0.268841207,
-0.3604887128,
-0.3570852876,
0.0702024996,
-0.071567513,
0.6398931146,
-0.8672325015,
0.5961661339,
0.4721080065,
-0.4056344926,
-0.4291012287,
-0.5776471496,
-0.093921043,
-0.3579052985,
-0.0330598131,
0.0794628486,
-0.1219194755,
-0.080728665,
-0.0566504113,
-0.3094760478,
-0.240400508,
0.3289156854,
0.4662282467,
0.2788864076,
0.1184900329,
0.2991825044,
0.2574994266,
-0.0514382459,
0.1231481433,
-0.3191363811,
0.7177064419,
0.2760852873,
-0.567741394,
-0.308816582,
-0.0793425739,
0.6179018021,
0.1991920322,
0.9235072136,
0.3209043741,
-0.3583519757,
-0.2088599056,
-0.6867983937,
-0.1096954644,
-0.5704452395,
0.2874352932,
-0.3430551291,
-0.7621504664,
0.4755889177,
-0.4367564619,
0.6006110907,
0.3716037869,
0.4331916273,
-0.3442721665,
0.6734416485,
0.6659161448,
-0.2344702482,
0.9341959953,
0.0260476898,
-0.3121314645,
-0.8344277143,
-0.3254628778,
-0.4343333542,
-0.3837127984,
-0.3315517902,
-0.1411637515,
0.0912740752,
0.3184443414,
-0.2273302078,
0.1656729132,
-0.2589486539,
0.5460050702,
0.3440487683,
0.2914069593,
0.2957208455,
0.1190600842,
0.1961164474,
0.2855707407,
-0.7040379047,
-0.3181290329,
1.2846703529,
0.4651804268,
0.9506745934,
0.0611257255,
0.6989790797,
0.3676584661,
0.5396264195,
-0.5635382533,
0.3973311186,
-0.0238094423,
-0.3687264621,
-0.2735500932,
-0.544651866,
-1.0408406258,
-0.0675973147,
-0.2642191648,
-0.820156157,
0.3053425848,
0.5697331429,
0.0427490063,
0.3942850828,
-0.6111570597,
0.3712443113,
0.0148792826,
-0.346981436,
-0.6216032505,
-0.3875387311,
0.3354204297,
-0.300643295,
0.2065385729,
-0.2436607778,
-0.1133101061,
0.8695876002,
-0.4049898386,
0.8710685968,
-0.4347300529,
0.0916717499,
0.2085260302,
0.0744135827,
0.8408360481,
0.0874671265,
-0.1939097047,
-0.1575404853,
0.2455173135,
-0.6133880615,
-0.2774698734,
0.5779656172,
-0.6667631269,
-0.4341121316,
-0.1633259803,
-0.6965423226,
-0.3982709944,
0.2705945075,
-0.0152870044,
0.2171700597,
-0.0610228814,
0.4029239118,
0.8391456008,
-0.3673952818,
0.4294148386,
0.7447142005,
-0.2830843329,
-0.0149501432,
0.8047844172,
0.0741706118,
0.7044674158,
0.3422752023,
0.2171755582,
-0.1471440643,
-0.9212409258,
0.0079725487,
0.0486396067,
-0.9302840829,
0.0627562925,
-0.5541149378,
-0.3247572184,
-0.1077808142,
-0.1576796472,
-0.1715066582,
-0.3662656844,
-0.2109647989,
0.058778692,
0.5872119665,
0.6234012246,
-0.022778172,
0.6721282601,
-0.8037640452,
0.5535069108,
0.3526990414,
0.5733015537,
-0.0727581158,
-0.8383238316,
-0.3307407498,
-0.2465276867,
-0.1840518266,
-0.2602102458,
0.2471199483,
0.2967274487,
0.7054945827,
0.4391124547,
0.0378664881,
0.5104601383,
-0.4917067587,
0.469937861,
0.0608280227,
-0.6097676158,
0.4993672967,
-0.4012323916,
0.3366481662,
0.7100304961,
0.3498717248,
-0.7470092773,
-0.4028957486,
-0.5081376433,
-0.9391799569,
0.5866921544,
-0.2666811347,
0.2770791054,
-0.031980373,
1.039283514,
0.1443167478,
0.4305469394,
-0.5503762364,
-0.0021484587,
0.3335221112,
-0.3270586729,
0.2000710368,
-0.3398650587,
-0.0918866768,
-0.0250056349,
0.6462771893,
0.0342911184,
0.1591947824,
-0.1487118751,
-0.3206183612,
0.1169881001,
0.1910864562,
0.3407505155,
0.9953531027,
-0.2265818864,
0.0033680329,
0.5267427564,
-0.8046851754,
0.0613269322,
-0.3412847817,
-0.287918359,
-0.2901953161,
0.3049742281,
0.6047700644,
0.2457506657,
-0.7057664394,
0.109070003,
-0.0841109976,
-0.1295135617,
-0.5473145843,
0.5246661305,
0.0868157744,
-0.0012982896,
0.3070709705,
0.1008034945,
-0.1839886159,
-0.4923258126,
0.4097017348,
0.2279079258,
-0.4839150608,
-0.1162457913,
0.4866984785,
0.1207600012,
-0.0362622626,
0.7841218114,
0.2720789909,
0.0485434346,
0.4685302079,
0.5411807895,
0.5208061934,
-0.405780822,
-0.1731737852,
0.0485514477,
0.2389802784,
-0.347669214,
0.1743874252,
-0.0731420591,
-0.8343594074,
-0.1495008022,
-0.734284699,
-0.7228546143,
0.4113857746,
-0.8236848712,
0.3463934362,
-0.6793678999,
0.2826437652,
-0.1831600368,
-0.4404637516,
-0.8501929641,
0.2901976705,
0.0737814978,
1.1756159067,
-0.8800476193,
1.2889192104,
0.1104838401,
-0.2307416946,
-0.427449584,
-0.0112060644,
0.0145215625,
-1.1586509943,
0.4467478395,
-0.0239583105,
0.0685461387,
0.1520473212,
-0.381788969,
-0.9224677086,
0.9478342533,
0.3754838705,
-0.9386456013,
-0.1897925884,
-0.0436429493,
0.1569495797,
-0.2122570723,
-0.1251537204,
0.9611113071,
0.4546047151,
0.0252810419,
-0.4523184597,
-0.2752591372,
0.0859284997,
-0.321952045,
0.091300495,
-0.2986911237,
0.5456123948,
0.0900453329,
-0.086978741,
0.0859482959,
0.6655516624,
0.3430988193,
0.1984198391,
0.7891308665,
0.3064934909,
0.9434843063,
-0.0472075082,
1.0812320709,
-0.2422938645,
0.0958702043,
1.5142399073,
-0.2925560772,
1.0197016001,
0.5910603404,
-0.2634657621,
0.5099290013,
0.69579041,
0.0390957892,
0.4766444266,
0.2110624164,
-0.4863308072,
-0.0158461723,
0.1505128294,
-0.0808751136,
0.2144605368,
0.6528543234,
-0.367382139,
-0.0150769977,
0.1600567251,
-0.0392089002,
-0.0415413342,
-0.3710295856,
1.0546183586,
0.0539354868,
-0.6284950376,
0.5114028454,
-0.2429402322,
0.4871354997,
-0.9784149528,
0.2109585404,
-0.1714268178,
0.3109226227,
-0.3509946764,
-0.7773696184,
0.5580255389,
-0.1474351436,
-0.3755300641,
-0.0841002762,
0.5336956978,
-0.4183879793,
-0.1554388106,
0.4633514583,
0.2679014802,
0.2337265611,
0.1062732413,
-0.6141375303,
0.1331630051,
-0.1391645074,
-0.614646852,
0.6043696404,
0.2589763999,
-0.2061445266,
0.9409889579,
0.6404619217,
0.4346043169,
0.2859664261,
0.297945112,
1.0495449305,
-0.2317143828,
-0.3557486534,
-0.7012610435,
0.0962148458,
-0.2601486146,
0.088057436,
0.3757880032,
0.5194522142,
0.5410704017,
0.0574632846,
1.1388869286,
-0.0379832089,
0.6790785193,
-0.8260967731,
0.6925008297,
-0.4571248889,
0.4577583671,
0.0869927034,
-1.0254216194,
-0.1704180688,
0.4514148235,
-0.4458256066,
0.0144774187,
0.439676553,
0.5360860825,
-0.2942428887,
-0.2363953888,
0.1129764691,
0.1217067093,
0.5739099979,
0.467492789,
0.6202985048,
-0.0877214298,
0.5245052576,
0.0051074214,
-0.3466021121,
-0.1044503227,
-0.8968571424,
-0.658233583,
-0.5034675598,
-0.2306497544,
-0.3123935759,
0.1102521196,
0.9595720172,
0.6657506824,
-0.9132370353,
-0.2115113884,
-0.4291642904,
0.1895252615,
-0.2008224428,
-0.1735365987,
0.3387750983,
-0.6259865761,
-0.5793358088,
0.5602983236,
0.3357297778,
0.2044040859,
-0.0774464682,
-0.1540145427,
-0.0309820622,
0.2001876235,
0.5275306702,
0.7505587339,
-0.3690038323,
-0.4896667302,
-0.4742473662,
0.0319455825,
-0.0283648074,
0.7698550224,
-0.7793465257,
0.4717676044,
0.3903647661,
0.7529695034,
0.7451809049,
-0.163048327,
0.7416461706,
-0.7704280615,
0.4058821797,
-0.2098926306,
0.4615698159,
0.1059046164,
-0.2116393894,
0.4230672717,
0.2467491627,
-0.5943959355,
-0.872153759,
0.3449251652,
-0.7390001416,
-0.3863357604,
0.9621664286,
-0.2365088016,
-0.2289162129,
-0.3743123114,
0.0852185786,
0.2196799219,
-0.0669539943,
1.1042730808,
0.4536910355,
-0.0264312513,
-0.4702951014,
-0.8693606853,
0.6235477328,
0.1371434778,
-1.2524051666,
0.4988516271,
0.2772236168,
0.649821043,
-0.131450206,
0.655061543,
-0.1321736574,
0.1360952407,
-0.1923871934,
0.1997476667,
0.0481258035,
-0.3975892663,
-0.2776123881,
0.2295351475,
0.4216487706,
-0.3108080626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00743v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00743v1
|
AIMDiT: Modality Augmentation and Interaction via Multimodal Dimension Transformation for Emotion Recognition in Conversations
| 2024-04-12T11:31:18 | 2024-04-12T11:31:18 |
Sheng Wu, Jiaxing Liu, Longbiao Wang, Dongxiao He, Xiaobao Wang, Jianwu Dang
|
cs.MM
|
cs.MM, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Emotion Recognition in Conversations (ERC) is a popular task in natural
language processing, which aims to recognize the emotional state of the speaker
in conversations. While current research primarily emphasizes contextual
modeling, there exists a dearth of investigation into effective multimodal
fusion methods. We propose a novel framework called AIMDiT to solve the problem
of multimodal fusion of deep features. Specifically, we design a Modality
Augmentation Network which performs rich representation learning through
dimension transformation of different modalities and parameter-efficient
inception block. On the other hand, the Modality Interaction Network performs
interaction fusion of extracted inter-modal features and intra-modal features.
Experiments conducted using our AIMDiT framework on the public benchmark
dataset MELD reveal 2.34% and 2.87% improvements in terms of the Acc-7 and w-F1
metrics compared to the state-of-the-art (SOTA) models.
|
[
-0.6992362738,
-0.6367039084,
0.4316831529,
-0.0018708197,
-0.119773671,
-0.1160715148,
-0.5853133202,
-0.607714057,
0.4980358183,
0.0617848523,
-0.5757500529,
-0.3569675386,
-0.4664604962,
0.0132007841,
-0.249334529,
0.6272855401,
-0.2589990795,
0.0713879541,
-0.3828123808,
-0.4440705776,
-0.3394017518,
-0.2887453735,
-0.3557690978,
0.0674313009,
0.6542127728,
0.6391968131,
0.3108758926,
0.0567461215,
0.809007287,
0.4140963256,
0.146018967,
0.5601495504,
-0.4984671474,
0.4192314446,
0.137531206,
-0.1460365355,
-0.4891336858,
0.114851132,
0.4901198745,
0.392203182,
0.084573254,
-0.1090548187,
0.1423504353,
0.4435664117,
-0.8015844226,
0.2447057664,
-0.3713829219,
0.1045638397,
0.0098370491,
-0.2693010867,
-0.3095101416,
-0.1208287999,
0.054776527,
-0.2929078639,
-0.19133991,
0.3236014247,
0.559110105,
0.2100575417,
-0.6413684487,
-0.072246097,
-0.8161925077,
0.4489567578,
-0.6592303514,
0.4970367253,
0.2532153428,
0.3004184663,
0.285892874,
-0.4742324948,
-1.0112259388,
-0.2077647895,
-0.3466267586,
0.206897527,
-0.2597169876,
0.3182696104,
0.1775986701,
0.4809729457,
-0.4842877686,
-0.1246720403,
-0.1059817821,
-0.0967902094,
0.5605765581,
0.2638078928,
0.2953428328,
-0.467110157,
-0.4514980316,
-0.3540475667,
-0.2185019553,
0.1502296627,
0.2502753735,
0.1482327133,
-0.2786359489,
0.4861786067,
-0.2167850584,
0.4606513381,
0.029336106,
0.0860335678,
0.5400691628,
-0.5230886936,
-0.1875985861,
0.0977621675,
0.8981586099,
0.405339092,
-0.2582353055,
0.3317873478,
0.0138908131,
0.1189691424,
0.2935096622,
-0.6458162665,
0.0638514981,
0.232347101,
-0.6031332016,
-0.2706793547,
0.1510085166,
-0.9561047554,
-0.377065897,
-0.4293161035,
0.6260389686,
-0.5872235894,
-0.5231423378,
-0.095965825,
0.1900986135,
0.2283092439,
0.4173950553,
-0.6311129928,
0.016344022,
0.4180395305,
0.8193240166,
-0.0269508138,
-0.3050002754,
-0.1896104366,
-0.0864463076,
-0.0676203668,
0.6691477895,
-0.9650675654,
-0.3271808922,
-0.1282753944,
-0.006533307,
-0.2167416364,
-0.1916142106,
0.5103157759,
-0.0750048757,
0.425286293,
-0.1890311837,
-0.1945889443,
-0.3378019631,
0.6009300947,
-0.7200268507,
0.7916575074,
0.1093698591,
-0.7730746269,
0.1380954385,
-1.093167901,
-0.3704243004,
-0.1279973239,
0.0356028937,
-0.1489212364,
0.2321066409,
0.2238639891,
0.5417780876,
-0.2341764271,
0.0382852592,
-0.5305834413,
-0.1440968066,
0.5066587925,
-0.6748808622,
0.0117442152,
0.3961153924,
-0.3720979393,
0.4303918481,
-0.8974579573,
-0.1085795835,
-0.2974179983,
-0.0729073808,
-0.479814887,
-0.1835021228,
0.2890322208,
0.4670572877,
0.108047314,
-0.7899243236,
-0.0815950036,
-0.3218125105,
0.4610850811,
0.6299452782,
-0.1512467265,
0.5173401833,
-0.0323120877,
0.3780009747,
0.5153191686,
0.1380485892,
-0.4867376387,
-0.0853956938,
-0.960375905,
-0.3804983199,
0.1324848682,
0.2971493602,
-0.7460429072,
0.4027409554,
-0.2027776986,
-0.3508898318,
-0.6855880022,
-0.0898028836,
0.533503294,
0.5366674066,
0.3546257317,
-0.4295693338,
-0.5801852345,
-1.0927426815,
-0.0022809904,
-0.3053977191,
0.0562228449,
0.7801570892,
0.1462205201,
-0.4035390913,
0.8904828429,
-0.2189984024,
-0.470823139,
-0.2377268523,
0.5481870174,
-0.1585762799,
0.5302706361,
0.4042394459,
-1.0557326078,
-0.528265655,
0.2697891593,
-0.8018664122,
-0.0020517828,
-0.0630925894,
-0.1911145598,
0.1033256054,
0.39733392,
-0.4504239857,
0.4775113463,
0.7138501406,
-0.426967144,
-0.1568264365,
-0.0025158825,
0.9019779563,
-1.3562222719,
0.1150109544,
0.2305566072,
-0.2270163596,
-0.7599239945,
-0.4430352151,
0.2755355239,
-0.4079286754,
-0.5777947307,
0.4558312595,
-0.3803423345,
0.0425639898,
-0.0559216142,
0.2143196166,
0.2061877847,
0.7172391415,
-0.1748948991,
0.5470814705,
0.4271705151,
-0.2918782234,
0.6297043562,
0.4868419766,
-0.1930533797,
1.2821583748,
-0.2803456485,
0.0731936917,
-0.2610381842,
0.1575422585,
-1.2319433689,
-0.5315330029,
0.3010190427,
-0.4734895229,
0.4410052299,
0.3206678927,
-0.0137290414,
-0.0960069746,
-0.2671484351,
0.713496685,
0.2921064794,
-0.4958845675,
1.1787098646,
0.2566623986,
-0.2814150751,
-0.303113997,
-0.5097787976,
0.1920509934,
-0.1870032102,
-0.9501002431,
0.3732223213,
-0.1802313775,
-0.1489655823,
0.0109286355,
0.249033615,
0.1141396537,
-0.1667991132,
0.5533440709,
-0.0180000216,
-0.113660872,
0.3696114719,
0.1795132756,
-0.0696989521,
-0.1167038903,
0.4494459033,
0.5355213284,
-0.3167063892,
-0.7294819951,
-0.5761607885,
0.7649502754,
0.9027968049,
-0.4828992784,
0.5940969586,
1.0005520582,
-0.3782340884,
0.1155789942,
-0.7694950104,
-0.2709298432,
-0.4345271885,
0.5868731141,
-0.3399081528,
-1.0283488035,
0.5000451803,
-0.155048281,
-0.1207762733,
0.3503961265,
0.5068353415,
-0.2569366693,
1.2710601091,
0.5211853385,
0.0873302072,
0.7625114918,
-0.021949295,
0.5066327453,
-1.2416616678,
-0.4590851665,
-0.1257283986,
-0.9608956575,
-0.1278688312,
-0.44888255,
0.7418442965,
-0.3274758458,
0.0786022395,
0.2651740909,
-0.1320095658,
0.1323872209,
0.3856328428,
0.5233729482,
-0.0031203658,
-0.1644190997,
0.2065342218,
-0.3504195809,
-0.3833280802,
-0.0209720414,
0.7068554759,
0.4859393835,
0.8977923393,
0.1862324625,
0.5353929996,
0.2574255466,
0.3133202493,
-0.8140630722,
0.7094306946,
0.1052264869,
-0.3108883798,
-0.1425015479,
-0.5225235224,
-0.4903711379,
0.1539968252,
-0.6026024818,
-0.544238925,
0.7186151743,
0.0902835503,
-0.1339122802,
0.2423750609,
-0.8696208596,
0.8427346945,
-0.3534903228,
-0.3499043882,
-0.4510369897,
-0.6297341585,
0.3390174806,
0.0707208887,
0.1775895208,
-0.209137395,
0.2553681135,
0.4864054918,
-0.2229511142,
0.8534796834,
-0.1314323992,
0.0447268672,
-0.0041842484,
0.2441463321,
0.3388432562,
0.0685564876,
0.1032252908,
0.244077906,
-0.3966341913,
0.182006374,
-0.6854736805,
0.7391337156,
-0.5292849541,
-0.2159123272,
-0.1155044511,
-0.7802051902,
-0.4094518423,
-0.1745822281,
-0.1286454052,
0.759301424,
-0.3728196323,
0.6041352749,
0.5581268072,
-0.0112032266,
0.6643622518,
0.257193476,
0.2616975307,
-0.5178670883,
0.9465425611,
-0.3170681894,
0.2587798238,
0.3551721573,
0.0303140283,
-0.0734252632,
0.0236406177,
-0.1094363779,
0.0090699699,
-0.7092170715,
-0.432780236,
-0.9105397463,
-0.1787336171,
-0.5056604147,
-0.0479325503,
-0.4589004219,
-0.2093505114,
-0.4368320107,
-0.0962747559,
0.4347639382,
0.3664441109,
-0.3794693351,
0.1734759361,
-0.8699602485,
0.1993207783,
0.5523561835,
0.4105464518,
-0.2237010896,
-0.4421417415,
-0.2678817809,
0.2667492926,
-0.1798842996,
-0.8503088951,
0.6348384619,
0.6249616146,
0.3819815516,
0.7403888106,
0.0704754367,
0.7426339388,
-0.2366149127,
0.6257998943,
0.5370381474,
-1.181252718,
0.5734351873,
-0.0646784455,
0.1172527969,
0.5019248724,
0.4444547892,
-0.8089050651,
-0.0478411913,
-0.4220906198,
-0.7806275487,
0.7586764693,
0.2046445012,
0.2691387832,
-0.0002978615,
0.0494351014,
-0.110714227,
0.3755068779,
-0.5929768682,
0.0174795389,
-0.2080529779,
-0.7935840487,
0.1015297696,
-0.5635464191,
-0.3607589602,
-0.1610362232,
0.3023844957,
-0.4244911969,
0.4873066545,
0.3092394173,
-0.1862091273,
-0.2582426071,
0.3471468389,
0.6277657151,
0.3293807209,
-0.1478551775,
0.2303112894,
0.0823900029,
-0.1210036874,
-0.0980168581,
0.1768109649,
0.5357952118,
-0.1613765359,
0.3269992173,
1.310128808,
0.568798542,
-0.6280460358,
0.6833395362,
-0.3350863159,
-0.2426181436,
-0.0060297032,
-0.0454780012,
-0.2476071268,
0.7709906697,
0.1130979061,
0.2380275428,
0.3413934708,
-0.6827824116,
0.1591733098,
0.5014785528,
-0.8102374673,
-0.4151286781,
0.5036857724,
0.6080647707,
-0.2544292212,
0.4065275192,
0.1336094141,
-0.6827451587,
0.2905647159,
0.2458707094,
0.9692857862,
-0.4376625419,
0.2654075325,
0.3604706228,
-0.0690155476,
0.3293571174,
0.3423027098,
-0.3210250735,
-0.7763309479,
-0.1714336723,
-0.5585139394,
-0.5973713994,
-0.4080059826,
-0.5332339406,
0.161538884,
-0.1456391215,
-0.1430512071,
-0.2722937465,
-0.589603126,
-0.6493109465,
0.0635369048,
0.4052723646,
0.3743539751,
-0.9191995263,
0.4358074963,
0.654271543,
-0.4161499441,
-0.6067378521,
-0.3614037633,
0.0953686386,
-0.5720127821,
0.6551725864,
0.3582755923,
-0.0614762269,
-0.0668815821,
-0.5299009681,
-0.7771797776,
1.1556622982,
0.1508513838,
-0.5849838257,
0.121803537,
0.0198557898,
0.3544393778,
-0.8134288788,
0.6593060493,
0.2057270557,
0.522279501,
0.30689767,
-0.9882892966,
-0.1198115945,
-0.5694246888,
0.0329468921,
0.3110085726,
-0.6423111558,
0.7925784588,
0.0855287388,
-0.211089462,
-0.4003250003,
0.614046216,
-0.1500006765,
0.3088848889,
0.7989328504,
0.5833031535,
0.379918009,
-0.2914483845,
0.5902144313,
-0.5164314508,
0.3158415258,
0.632167697,
-0.4845257998,
0.8923151493,
0.5218299031,
0.1643543392,
0.593337357,
0.4669368565,
0.3407750726,
0.3396529555,
-0.3375529349,
-0.3894584477,
-0.4355887771,
-0.3111706376,
-0.3196823001,
0.7649155855,
0.5977279544,
-0.3234981596,
0.0316158421,
0.6996505857,
-0.1271615475,
-0.1749053895,
-0.2089740634,
1.0369200706,
-0.0318689533,
-0.2794760466,
0.2132742852,
-0.2560833395,
0.7997173667,
-0.6861313581,
-0.3021799624,
-0.3548195064,
0.1107978672,
-0.2826487124,
-0.6236224174,
0.2022013366,
-0.3061472476,
-0.11940106,
-0.2925693393,
0.7910279632,
-0.9825696349,
-0.3761838675,
0.22229819,
0.2388026416,
-0.2257323712,
-0.1613488495,
-0.4557540119,
0.3947902322,
-0.2445747703,
-0.3886512518,
0.3680955768,
0.5578293204,
0.3610143661,
0.5049080253,
0.5650951862,
-0.1631389111,
-0.2887015641,
-0.0193268284,
1.1800321341,
-0.6277798414,
-0.4663113654,
-0.6635330915,
0.8060986996,
-0.2977191806,
-0.2600964606,
0.5139167309,
0.0636416897,
0.6114524603,
0.1236317679,
0.4759590328,
-0.4178825021,
0.3735399842,
-0.5705880523,
0.5898127556,
-0.9652704,
-0.0228306185,
-0.3771876991,
-0.9939931035,
-0.1430660784,
0.6944711208,
-0.0433692113,
0.1321326196,
0.8758520484,
0.8290610313,
-0.2848417461,
0.0843431726,
0.5540038347,
0.3347358406,
0.4303196967,
0.7039334774,
0.8143362999,
-0.3084713817,
0.4397727847,
-0.3899531066,
-0.2454939783,
-0.4365356863,
-0.7697692513,
-0.6982027292,
-1.0081590414,
-0.2640171051,
-0.3236893415,
-0.2691598535,
1.133767724,
0.7307834029,
-0.637575984,
0.0699109435,
0.324547708,
-0.2267108262,
-0.0231703017,
-0.2616976798,
0.2003344297,
-0.2698044181,
-0.8687773347,
0.5911471844,
0.7552695274,
-0.1515730768,
-0.5626135468,
-0.1630717218,
-0.2284019887,
0.0118828779,
0.6729912758,
0.1305751652,
-0.4791916013,
-0.5811195374,
-0.0935899019,
-0.0315284245,
0.3247979283,
1.0371339321,
-0.6130284667,
0.8208590746,
0.6436555982,
0.6629528403,
0.2214914709,
-0.0149228135,
0.6208924651,
-0.7293316722,
0.2426550537,
0.2494290471,
0.6199194193,
0.3402151167,
-0.2676857114,
0.3095110655,
0.2632592022,
-0.4389324188,
-0.8339797854,
0.4354327321,
-1.3464608192,
0.1275124848,
1.1093244553,
-0.071908623,
-0.3268001974,
0.227949366,
-0.6203379631,
-0.0185656063,
-0.4420044124,
0.5615985394,
0.4869407713,
-0.1871139854,
-0.7154437304,
0.0186630301,
0.2103325725,
0.4437240064,
-1.0439836979,
0.0380246118,
0.7357987761,
-0.2544893026,
0.3628986478,
0.4070382714,
-0.0467402451,
0.0649143383,
-0.1269698739,
0.2916600406,
-0.282690227,
-0.5535839796,
-0.3581397533,
0.2322101891,
-0.3333086967,
-0.0364715755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08403v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08403v1
|
Learning representations of learning representations
| 2024-04-12T11:30:16 | 2024-04-12T11:30:16 |
Rita González-Márquez, Dmitry Kobak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DL, cs.LG
|
The ICLR conference is unique among the top machine learning conferences in
that all submitted papers are openly available. Here we present the ICLR
dataset consisting of abstracts of all 24 thousand ICLR submissions from
2017-2024 with meta-data, decision scores, and custom keyword-based labels. We
find that on this dataset, bag-of-words representation outperforms most
dedicated sentence transformer models in terms of $k$NN classification
accuracy, and the top performing language models barely outperform TF-IDF. We
see this as a challenge for the NLP community. Furthermore, we use the ICLR
dataset to study how the field of machine learning has changed over the last
seven years, finding some improvement in gender balance. Using a 2D embedding
of the abstracts' texts, we describe a shift in research topics from 2017 to
2024 and identify hedgehogs and foxes among the authors with the highest number
of ICLR submissions.
|
[
-0.2411542088,
0.3390775919,
0.1690400094,
-0.1772090644,
0.0362467058,
0.4669655859,
-0.0535464659,
-0.5102647543,
-0.1769036651,
0.1639961153,
-0.2392704338,
-0.525095582,
-1.095667243,
0.4266139865,
-0.71204108,
1.2107175589,
0.2529355288,
0.3611966968,
-0.5351447463,
-0.5916800499,
-0.2979761362,
-0.6506509185,
-0.168341428,
-0.5833985806,
0.6302366257,
0.2048331946,
0.432251215,
0.540050447,
0.6310091019,
0.1618320644,
-0.2617720366,
0.1833385378,
-0.3042990267,
-0.2422305048,
-0.3497355878,
-0.4657171667,
-0.1631866097,
0.0417521335,
0.8558686376,
1.0178003311,
-0.2176482975,
0.1503016353,
0.3831157386,
0.6117016077,
-0.7202305794,
0.3809593022,
-0.7878989577,
0.3314099908,
-0.2359863967,
0.1757227629,
-0.746851325,
0.0676028356,
0.0270794872,
-0.3417294025,
0.1419954449,
0.0790728852,
0.7650883198,
0.0628743395,
-0.3920616508,
-0.4787643552,
-0.6359006166,
0.9305933118,
-0.3964377642,
0.2818628252,
0.3049467802,
0.1360169798,
-0.1355659962,
-0.7448370457,
-0.1897382587,
-0.0843137652,
-0.1219786406,
-0.1672457159,
-0.5831882954,
-0.1393189877,
0.1998768449,
0.1017241701,
-0.4431387186,
0.1687809378,
-0.441472739,
-0.0891202837,
0.7335842252,
0.1430966556,
0.3164429665,
0.1533804387,
-0.0761185661,
-0.2482297868,
-0.5988799334,
-0.2047268152,
0.2485644072,
0.4773463905,
-0.0540502109,
0.6984206438,
0.1979063451,
0.5741127133,
0.1148122922,
0.144835338,
0.2429929972,
-0.1624536514,
0.0946652442,
0.2437510341,
0.9008167386,
0.4062871635,
-0.0346750095,
-0.1794783622,
-0.0835125893,
-0.3438154459,
0.11921864,
-0.6976213455,
-0.1595048904,
-0.2883222699,
-0.6734530926,
-0.3843446374,
0.3965866268,
-0.7336621284,
-0.4656617641,
-0.269831866,
-0.0700970888,
-0.0852852836,
-0.3323900998,
0.1575312465,
-0.0992030278,
0.4193630219,
0.1145455763,
-0.8969419003,
0.5314905047,
0.6538686752,
0.7936775088,
-0.3014501631,
0.0049858456,
-0.210023433,
0.0618437268,
-0.5081939101,
0.5399198532,
-0.9020578265,
-0.4488246441,
-0.0667141527,
-0.0147165572,
-0.1052269638,
-0.7218725085,
0.4507694542,
-0.2630847096,
0.3139458895,
-0.4119867086,
-0.5843856931,
-0.166012466,
0.1015337929,
-0.6066899896,
0.7701463103,
-0.1484838128,
-1.0644791126,
0.4739366472,
-0.7914894819,
-0.0296549611,
0.1841315776,
-0.5647288561,
-0.6177444458,
0.1766707897,
0.2171958089,
0.3350643218,
-0.021999523,
0.3918197453,
-0.2314021587,
-0.3358832002,
0.5355347395,
-0.067277357,
0.9013117552,
0.1863718927,
-0.0127725573,
0.0463510416,
-0.7105448246,
-0.2466166615,
0.1603918672,
-0.1152951494,
-0.0522312522,
0.3488276601,
0.1190735698,
0.2354743481,
0.0139912246,
-0.6296642423,
0.3599312603,
-0.333433032,
0.9025676847,
0.590857625,
-0.3753423989,
0.4366024137,
-0.3472132087,
0.4763007164,
0.4471788704,
-0.2282778174,
-0.265313834,
-0.5113537312,
-0.57615453,
-0.0146973012,
0.6556648016,
0.2260059416,
-0.2816476524,
0.4162119627,
-0.292291522,
-0.4107599556,
-0.6873876452,
-0.3118666708,
0.1334973276,
0.2739368081,
0.3242837787,
0.0560206883,
-0.7538043857,
-0.9202510118,
-0.4195120931,
-0.3064104021,
0.1300160438,
0.1415053606,
0.6899439692,
-0.2301760316,
0.8300250173,
-0.3520953655,
-0.2866294086,
-0.4081377089,
0.5453591347,
-0.0295316093,
0.6236716509,
0.5415531397,
-0.7876169086,
-0.3173582554,
0.1425147504,
-0.683069706,
0.1867016852,
0.0818278715,
0.2044132799,
0.2881584466,
0.6954773664,
-0.485168457,
0.4223808348,
0.5053073764,
-0.239046663,
0.2247011214,
0.0281853154,
-0.0816971809,
-0.884241879,
0.2634215355,
-0.0926621258,
-0.3385837674,
-0.2078842521,
-0.0500673205,
-0.0769675747,
-0.2852064371,
-0.2185458541,
0.398974061,
-0.2718153596,
-0.2873674333,
-0.1266438216,
-0.2163178623,
-0.1332316846,
0.1065464318,
-0.2602301836,
0.8693447709,
0.4729089141,
-0.3545245826,
-0.2855626643,
0.4783644676,
-0.4298881888,
-0.0472674742,
-0.5478912592,
0.4207261801,
-0.6734285355,
0.3973828256,
-1.0412023067,
-0.0783582106,
0.3427037597,
-0.510471344,
0.4948301613,
-0.0945353732,
-0.567065835,
-0.3258861601,
-0.1323664188,
0.3695483804,
0.3712930977,
-0.3201516569,
0.6417413354,
0.4556610882,
0.0339171626,
-0.8715685606,
-0.8495809436,
0.4877844155,
-0.0088437442,
0.0737393051,
0.6824150681,
-0.0366295874,
-0.2263545096,
0.3030464649,
0.1668733507,
0.1537359506,
-0.0286382139,
0.1910260469,
0.0704269186,
-0.1315991879,
0.2789235711,
-0.0722564831,
-0.2335392833,
0.081775628,
-0.5473281741,
0.5262187719,
-0.2550629377,
-0.3319226503,
-0.3669464588,
0.4762273431,
0.5175421238,
-0.2454315573,
0.7891783118,
0.469797045,
-0.4285335541,
0.0234622397,
-0.0491243303,
-0.0354257226,
-0.3710093796,
0.5245895982,
-0.1097282171,
-0.98193717,
0.3477481306,
-0.0037734245,
0.3301962018,
0.7815551758,
0.3270081878,
-0.3785657287,
1.6003546715,
0.9250617623,
-0.2521729171,
0.2923812568,
-0.1504754573,
0.2781760097,
-0.6847727299,
-0.5125271678,
-0.8712354302,
-0.5811187625,
-0.7815046906,
-0.1402868181,
0.0710404068,
0.0153473988,
-0.2153375149,
0.1241103336,
-0.7193817496,
0.3677839041,
0.2375451624,
-0.008702701,
0.2387074083,
0.0109909987,
-0.1805932522,
-0.4446255565,
-0.6471836567,
-0.6526520848,
1.0513753891,
0.2892300785,
0.4959574044,
-0.1958958507,
0.4249097705,
0.6415733099,
0.2135245353,
-0.5305221677,
0.6989015937,
-0.5916627049,
-0.3923717141,
0.2509470582,
-0.3138402998,
-0.9551267624,
0.2124104202,
-0.1000395417,
-0.4308539629,
0.2210979462,
-0.2095396072,
0.0331233479,
0.6740632653,
-0.141427353,
0.3150278628,
-0.0298441835,
0.2034888864,
-0.0794579387,
-0.6799538732,
0.1224308759,
0.1489936858,
0.1162616313,
-0.2610285282,
-0.2291600406,
1.0958609581,
-0.1846202463,
0.8250175714,
-0.0900821239,
0.1832224578,
0.1384853423,
-0.2477317154,
0.151454255,
-0.2441519797,
-0.2029144466,
0.4448983073,
-0.0679031685,
-0.2849935889,
-0.3470052779,
0.395876199,
-0.8296429515,
-0.27810812,
-0.7398936152,
-0.3914113641,
0.1740055531,
0.1271213889,
0.4315379262,
0.5364117026,
-0.159006238,
0.3774761856,
0.6132927537,
-0.3576571941,
0.6110393405,
0.0509575307,
-0.5654840469,
-0.4349260628,
0.78292799,
0.342382282,
-0.1871082038,
0.6070989966,
0.2615985274,
-0.1162748933,
-0.7671503425,
-0.4688074887,
0.0760068074,
-0.8471163511,
-0.4203830659,
-1.1298230886,
-0.5140538216,
-0.2493149638,
0.0426530354,
-0.1060504168,
-0.4244885147,
-0.7259572148,
-0.2190841734,
0.1374177337,
1.122656703,
-0.0884299949,
0.1186195016,
-0.495066613,
-0.1083842441,
0.0636061057,
0.1045277566,
0.0226205159,
-0.3464272022,
-0.1864139736,
0.0296273977,
-0.4337460101,
-0.4912818968,
0.4160225093,
0.5741932988,
0.4942063689,
0.2177188396,
0.027903555,
0.5352710485,
-0.3351216912,
0.9485021234,
0.3484235704,
-0.8022540808,
0.4803157151,
-0.3396912515,
0.4283750057,
0.5368065238,
0.6118105054,
-0.4915059507,
-0.3214375377,
-0.6063640118,
-0.5222067237,
0.6851866245,
0.0166463964,
0.4466293156,
0.0385499671,
0.5492756963,
0.2862490416,
0.306820184,
-0.7324803472,
-0.468310982,
-0.108125031,
-0.6353203058,
0.167077899,
-0.29167521,
0.1140878499,
-0.4398222268,
0.4829122126,
-0.4054839909,
0.5573179722,
-0.0608523861,
-0.065975666,
-0.0567918532,
0.1422498673,
0.6877935529,
0.8884549737,
-0.0236076787,
0.2396409959,
0.2250704616,
-0.4528927505,
0.0754455924,
-0.0347625054,
-0.2618791163,
0.2656825185,
0.729490757,
0.5510740876,
0.2453395277,
-0.7360432744,
0.6711006761,
-0.2898919582,
-0.5261689425,
-0.2117680609,
-0.0785082281,
-0.0346818008,
0.0432079546,
0.6530213356,
0.5367293954,
0.324852705,
-0.4556237459,
0.3318651915,
0.2757022679,
-0.9509876966,
-0.5009125471,
0.6319186687,
-0.1791172624,
-0.0595383272,
0.6603211164,
-0.2369248569,
-0.7245184779,
0.3976762891,
0.5110980272,
0.8308342099,
-0.0187920965,
0.2454465181,
0.5973736048,
0.2462780178,
0.012895749,
0.0201060716,
0.2282675803,
-0.5781288147,
-0.4720932543,
-0.3703621626,
-0.3864404261,
0.1728427857,
-0.8407862186,
0.5849621892,
-0.4618552625,
0.0309625138,
0.1481291205,
0.0869614035,
-0.4734686315,
-0.2789663374,
0.430799067,
0.9196830988,
-0.6294990778,
0.5878753066,
0.9194430113,
-0.2632004321,
-0.1687803864,
-0.0902862176,
-0.0794900432,
-0.5004378557,
0.9343645573,
0.3562770188,
-0.1014460176,
-0.0939357355,
-1.1481435299,
-0.8479196429,
0.8512607813,
0.5472856164,
-0.7584164143,
-0.2027675062,
0.4775840044,
0.3069548607,
-0.5710806847,
0.1241448969,
0.1700256616,
0.3160701692,
0.0562038049,
-0.531470716,
-0.3880564868,
-0.2505969107,
0.0405750275,
0.1792455912,
-0.4405925572,
0.8108825088,
-0.0604247749,
-0.4086077809,
-0.0242186636,
0.9270173907,
0.2641578615,
0.25476861,
0.3683791161,
0.4353072941,
0.9111874104,
-0.291805774,
0.7206495404,
0.1211969331,
0.2911141515,
1.015357852,
-0.2978469431,
0.8500416875,
0.2070399225,
-0.33174178,
0.6582202315,
0.4328970909,
-0.2089842856,
0.662961185,
0.3841113746,
-0.1920549423,
-0.2429160178,
-0.3590265512,
-0.3127893507,
0.7170531154,
0.5454853177,
-0.3570273817,
-0.5029166937,
0.7099250555,
-0.0020709641,
0.2608297765,
-0.3444394767,
1.1274923086,
0.1576803178,
-0.2578608692,
0.1916817278,
0.0156136351,
0.7843706012,
-0.3670857847,
-0.3347108066,
-0.0566920862,
0.2289957553,
-0.246481657,
-0.9092532992,
0.5389609933,
-0.1823132038,
-0.4187661409,
-0.4707461298,
0.9926592708,
-0.5302355289,
-0.8653864861,
0.2436993569,
0.0359442607,
0.164437294,
0.231303975,
-0.8988165855,
0.2498264313,
-0.0809653625,
0.3556617796,
0.5252278447,
0.3822129071,
-0.0924529359,
0.7293229699,
0.2333341986,
-0.1929228604,
0.0677865744,
-0.2113123834,
0.9034525752,
-0.6203071475,
-0.1920026094,
-0.8816065788,
0.3809987605,
-0.101616919,
-0.3910927176,
0.3524190784,
0.6750195622,
0.887039721,
0.1695912331,
0.8144504428,
-0.1892657131,
0.6282539368,
-0.2767679691,
0.7716439962,
-0.4035315514,
-0.003679567,
0.059242744,
-0.3464865685,
-0.6017948389,
0.4586381316,
0.1071026176,
0.1209288612,
0.2660335004,
0.4052774012,
-0.0020591319,
0.3275340497,
0.2158968449,
-0.0981061533,
0.4119631052,
0.3244963884,
1.1985191107,
-0.7855712175,
0.4482606649,
-0.1272454858,
0.2334885001,
-0.5104416609,
-1.2173615694,
-0.675685823,
-1.0722306967,
-0.8097074628,
-0.1477067024,
0.0504868925,
1.1210290194,
0.7905917168,
-1.0087845325,
-0.1745693684,
-0.1197716594,
0.1534096748,
-0.2983213365,
-0.1493456066,
0.2309742123,
-0.4950642288,
-0.4409357607,
0.12678653,
0.1625807285,
0.0497676209,
-0.2878808081,
0.0779748037,
-0.2484213561,
-0.3298828304,
0.7176448107,
-0.0733626708,
-0.7151976824,
-0.1650364399,
-0.0123892017,
-0.2249394953,
0.3307266533,
0.8224554658,
-0.7772275209,
0.2355719209,
0.3210752904,
0.7535447478,
0.4710650444,
-0.4771230221,
0.6308617592,
-0.6579850912,
-0.2140788138,
0.6018040776,
0.3614100218,
0.4737788141,
-0.1878075153,
0.4360102117,
0.0736104473,
-0.4308639169,
-1.001196146,
-0.1459922045,
-0.8685573339,
-0.4313106239,
0.6817447543,
-0.1297280043,
-0.0419998169,
-0.1991093159,
-0.078216359,
0.1219455749,
-0.2610006928,
0.5696350336,
0.9000966549,
-0.0554438755,
-0.6605495214,
-0.6064471006,
0.4299436212,
0.2405608743,
-0.6964763403,
0.0547542572,
0.0644767508,
0.0173529796,
0.2017987221,
0.1787410825,
-0.5387101173,
-0.1878469884,
-0.4238076806,
0.1652749181,
0.0802864954,
-0.4890000522,
-0.5442982316,
0.2002991438,
0.153071925,
-0.0972896069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08720v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08720v1
|
Exploring Contrastive Learning for Long-Tailed Multi-Label Text Classification
| 2024-04-12T11:12:16 | 2024-04-12T11:12:16 |
Alexandre Audibert, Aurélien Gauffre, Massih-Reza Amini
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Learning an effective representation in multi-label text classification
(MLTC) is a significant challenge in NLP. This challenge arises from the
inherent complexity of the task, which is shaped by two key factors: the
intricate connections between labels and the widespread long-tailed
distribution of the data. To overcome this issue, one potential approach
involves integrating supervised contrastive learning with classical supervised
loss functions. Although contrastive learning has shown remarkable performance
in multi-class classification, its impact in the multi-label framework has not
been thoroughly investigated. In this paper, we conduct an in-depth study of
supervised contrastive learning and its influence on representation in MLTC
context. We emphasize the importance of considering long-tailed data
distributions to build a robust representation space, which effectively
addresses two critical challenges associated with contrastive learning that we
identify: the "lack of positives" and the "attraction-repulsion imbalance".
Building on this insight, we introduce a novel contrastive loss function for
MLTC. It attains Micro-F1 scores that either match or surpass those obtained
with other frequently employed loss functions, and demonstrates a significant
improvement in Macro-F1 scores across three multi-label datasets.
|
[
-0.6493458152,
-0.3982500732,
0.3887264431,
0.2929989994,
-0.2344419062,
0.1295833737,
-0.1907135248,
-0.4398859739,
0.3573259115,
0.2604497969,
-0.55106318,
-0.6427170038,
-0.7159144878,
0.2145650089,
-0.3180736899,
1.2704068422,
-0.0575653501,
-0.2427141666,
-0.1173581779,
-0.6795759201,
-0.2538225949,
-0.8478007317,
-0.6159097552,
-0.5702013969,
1.0268435478,
0.0871501565,
0.4367194176,
0.2835434973,
0.4944134057,
0.1919559538,
-0.1612007022,
0.0631421953,
-0.5411263704,
0.0009071236,
-0.0605567843,
-0.3599029183,
0.1202548891,
-0.0346272439,
0.8401678205,
0.8029226065,
-0.0803908557,
-0.3095840812,
0.6201927066,
0.8754701614,
-0.7878719568,
0.2228150964,
-0.3725674152,
0.409374088,
-0.2020855993,
-0.3249319494,
-0.7355498672,
0.0504070967,
0.2379210889,
-0.6983477473,
0.0351585522,
0.0938727558,
0.8241682053,
0.2834563255,
-0.9624065161,
-0.3240654469,
-0.3331571817,
1.0982960463,
-0.1870996058,
0.5184540749,
0.1817782074,
0.1675336063,
0.0498536676,
-0.4462020397,
-0.2440092862,
-0.0689488351,
-0.3425952196,
0.4045105875,
-0.1676707417,
0.0018238835,
-0.1140485257,
0.3359568417,
-0.3897762895,
0.4154281616,
-0.0726084635,
-0.2040051818,
0.1306026727,
0.1614348292,
-0.3545987606,
0.0488379449,
-0.5708426237,
-0.3321757317,
-0.4774335623,
-0.0434491225,
0.2612222433,
0.5452637076,
-0.2072893679,
0.3066541553,
0.108484894,
0.5283790827,
-0.0009330646,
0.015677128,
0.3755290508,
-0.2618944347,
-0.1430549622,
0.0960673541,
0.8138673306,
0.4434415698,
0.0733827502,
0.1390517354,
-0.0566753671,
-0.3348204792,
-0.012019746,
-1.1755540371,
-0.3854902983,
0.0213815216,
-0.5914025903,
-0.5487576723,
0.1567516029,
-0.6765801907,
-0.7149192095,
-0.2401426733,
0.4685524702,
-0.3932950497,
-0.3126475513,
0.1216683909,
-0.0955977142,
0.1405017227,
0.3168209791,
-0.8536152244,
0.3590810299,
0.3416083455,
0.8971533179,
-0.4103518128,
-0.1779221594,
-0.5285382271,
0.1674111187,
-0.3690081239,
0.5734810829,
-0.4799777269,
-0.2150552571,
0.0776333809,
-0.12151815,
-0.0679721907,
-0.5897464752,
0.3970543742,
-0.4827283323,
0.1590044051,
0.1076183394,
-0.5282613039,
-0.3272480369,
0.4476468861,
-0.8364462852,
0.7277930975,
0.1602830291,
-1.2137787342,
0.4422511458,
-0.4940541983,
-0.4461841583,
-0.3582389951,
-0.0577692203,
-0.9138293862,
-0.018883517,
0.1836587042,
0.871773541,
0.0755630657,
0.0189869646,
-0.4730193317,
-0.4201217592,
0.4447173178,
-0.3890725672,
0.8577743769,
0.0094475765,
-0.1840135008,
0.0662541762,
-0.8090913892,
-0.2042105794,
-0.1009044796,
-0.2894977331,
-0.8094268441,
-0.1643290818,
0.2085877657,
0.1552668363,
-0.2225549221,
-0.3086692393,
0.0661644861,
-0.2165258825,
0.1099581718,
0.7193892002,
0.0648268685,
0.4297069907,
-0.1408546865,
0.1617312878,
0.5640470982,
-0.2209257036,
-0.3060495853,
-0.4283321798,
-0.6956981421,
-0.3059102297,
0.467011869,
0.4851049781,
-0.7753344774,
0.3236597776,
0.0916437358,
-0.3268363476,
-0.5141870975,
0.0530770496,
0.2051648498,
0.5407506227,
0.7863300443,
0.076726526,
-0.2876623869,
-1.1030784845,
0.0829123259,
0.2608684897,
-0.0594122447,
0.145503521,
0.6053736806,
-0.5846731663,
0.5284841061,
-0.6448423862,
-0.7651960254,
-0.0699897781,
0.4477764368,
0.3589981198,
0.6138654351,
0.6010699272,
-1.0254399776,
-0.5799392462,
0.2017103136,
-0.6639735699,
0.0785905123,
-0.4568830729,
0.0818462372,
0.2995667458,
0.5399748087,
-0.3364993334,
0.4088312984,
0.6291515827,
-0.1214476749,
0.6957628131,
-0.2522784472,
0.2104090601,
-0.8205650449,
-0.118692562,
0.414732635,
0.0039247377,
-0.436978966,
0.0113981524,
0.3001344204,
0.0353582725,
-0.3065100014,
0.4281511307,
-0.1837294698,
0.2997144461,
-0.1006072387,
-0.0644596741,
0.1573531479,
0.5447545052,
0.0984877497,
0.6662561893,
0.5458365679,
-0.8164541721,
-0.1045293733,
0.0335912332,
-0.0509214029,
0.8458390236,
-0.324436903,
-0.3176526427,
-0.2266695946,
0.3673380017,
-1.0634412766,
0.0050433665,
0.3040371537,
-0.2408056557,
0.620775044,
0.1097893342,
-0.5561933517,
-0.0564444661,
-0.6323319674,
0.426607132,
0.1211383194,
-0.752509892,
0.4960550964,
0.0335223228,
0.139920041,
-0.8426678181,
-0.9867817163,
-0.165618822,
-0.5121523142,
-0.1700549275,
0.6375463605,
-0.0262717474,
0.0200570244,
-0.1192305386,
-0.1818026304,
-0.107462965,
0.0603356548,
0.0445500016,
-0.1968199611,
-0.1111557633,
0.5299520493,
0.2385653257,
-0.3474436998,
0.1091665775,
-0.0720188916,
0.3798648417,
-0.3172446489,
-0.1799176633,
-0.4956692755,
0.5076867342,
0.099566564,
-0.0507939197,
0.9999116659,
1.0512127876,
-0.1932990253,
-0.2956593335,
-0.3075338602,
-0.1224223375,
-0.4740496874,
0.5614922643,
-0.4843358397,
-0.8530290723,
0.6147301197,
-0.0149567062,
-0.171771571,
0.7696229219,
0.2754786611,
-0.5135262012,
0.8723840714,
0.9297302365,
0.1084923744,
0.4494980276,
-0.2556274533,
-0.1333377808,
-0.7388617992,
-0.3355644345,
-0.437438637,
-0.2457481474,
-0.9098892212,
-0.2351721525,
0.2683365345,
0.0213726349,
-0.425653547,
0.0427664369,
-0.6145300865,
0.3687966168,
0.5519382954,
0.4329488873,
0.2321293652,
-0.0498897955,
-0.1029444858,
-0.3999503255,
-0.5008189678,
-0.0341758579,
1.0372689962,
0.3690420389,
0.7443196774,
0.0822587758,
1.2259333134,
0.313356936,
0.6342054009,
-0.7961062789,
0.2169355601,
-0.5417952538,
-0.1866159439,
-0.0898971483,
-0.7310709953,
-1.0717179775,
0.5523440838,
-0.585114181,
-0.3487380743,
0.2258612812,
0.2038082778,
-0.0475900322,
0.3130756319,
-0.7218284011,
1.009685874,
-0.1990167499,
-0.4896640778,
-0.1884346902,
-0.8584824204,
0.4830653667,
-0.3133903146,
0.1875630319,
0.2002256811,
-0.2281665951,
0.8930021524,
0.0390332639,
0.8253925443,
-0.1622534096,
-0.1142269522,
0.0261158105,
-0.0420223922,
0.2134232372,
-0.0464881323,
-0.1397081316,
-0.0346570574,
-0.1298897713,
-0.4938515723,
-0.5278865099,
0.6174009442,
-0.5044170618,
-0.1640436053,
-0.5907440782,
-0.3191556334,
-0.1682635248,
0.3377014995,
0.102732636,
0.2592117786,
-0.0928941518,
0.5441410542,
0.9480998516,
-0.5282552242,
0.167244643,
-0.0648994893,
-0.3118626177,
-0.5540015697,
1.1815276146,
0.0556368046,
0.1700185835,
0.8237583637,
0.5160866976,
-0.4883348346,
-0.5449765325,
-0.101213932,
0.249825567,
-1.0386366844,
-0.4088029861,
-0.5004220009,
-0.0575287342,
0.1438864321,
-0.3095979989,
-0.019908756,
-0.3027053177,
-0.6759097576,
-0.0468536764,
-0.0248875041,
0.5887835622,
-0.083095111,
0.4463199377,
-0.5601650476,
0.3416751921,
0.1847655624,
0.550573647,
0.0686544105,
-0.307577014,
-0.333070159,
-0.1857916415,
-0.4650921226,
-0.8691045046,
0.210093841,
0.368476063,
0.5343341231,
0.5707095861,
0.2993068397,
0.6394361258,
-0.2608782053,
0.2990228236,
0.5901684165,
-0.6366305947,
0.193652302,
-0.1386525035,
0.3668920994,
0.7274256945,
0.7314232588,
-0.2531233132,
-0.4591794312,
-0.4546028376,
-0.8881413937,
0.3337569535,
0.2039051652,
0.0401169062,
-0.0035783257,
0.1052853912,
0.2554936707,
0.1700803638,
-1.306784153,
-0.5307509899,
-0.5293143988,
-0.3723372519,
-0.107175298,
-0.1718058884,
0.1161336452,
-0.1679866314,
0.5450422168,
-0.1328597069,
0.1516667753,
0.0581950545,
-0.0382145159,
0.5592000484,
0.4241920412,
0.53422153,
0.0487842932,
-0.5376927257,
0.408482492,
-0.0030534184,
-0.233547017,
0.1500298381,
0.4066354036,
0.1052410901,
-0.0384865105,
0.4281725287,
0.3765765131,
0.3215411305,
-0.3802793026,
0.5392180681,
0.1091481224,
-0.4682391584,
0.0411284454,
-0.34949103,
0.1970835775,
0.0001888461,
0.550538063,
0.1864209771,
0.4855535626,
-0.3315287232,
0.4709789455,
0.354073137,
-0.6789643168,
0.2018311024,
0.4186277688,
0.1758774221,
0.2188703269,
0.7163006663,
-0.354175508,
-0.5340989828,
0.5847423077,
0.6499657631,
0.6069183946,
-0.1396542192,
0.1981512755,
0.5657148957,
0.2498034537,
0.0740613863,
-0.4599548876,
-0.1937411875,
-0.4775523841,
-0.4439182281,
-0.3972951472,
-0.6506868601,
-0.0020207167,
-0.8048849702,
0.1975058019,
-0.3327313066,
-0.0976626799,
0.2340967655,
0.0105391871,
-0.5203970671,
0.1932427883,
0.164399296,
0.6738167405,
-0.7149323225,
0.6659703851,
0.3395815492,
-0.3824960291,
-0.2717511654,
0.0429301634,
-0.0916943774,
-0.4149922132,
0.8819186687,
0.9123889208,
-0.3798114359,
-0.1485570222,
-0.3469184041,
-0.3874237537,
0.7416414022,
0.0255185459,
-0.4769667983,
0.2910563052,
0.1640574336,
0.6363680363,
-0.3917275071,
0.0666759014,
0.3749022484,
0.4842914343,
-0.1589356661,
-0.4169652462,
-0.0262817256,
0.0258853976,
-0.2641021013,
0.5185564756,
-0.4998284876,
0.7257556319,
-0.2861492038,
-0.1936915964,
-0.1333578229,
0.762229681,
0.3154081106,
0.5739927292,
0.3990698457,
0.3757677972,
0.6109890938,
-0.1906589866,
0.9016830921,
0.1248348951,
0.6149516106,
0.912812233,
0.0265490692,
0.9730328321,
0.7296071649,
-0.2309536636,
0.4954401851,
0.6871196628,
-0.0441851243,
0.6838236451,
0.595312953,
-0.2102573663,
-0.1512914449,
-0.021199299,
-0.2782786489,
0.1620586812,
0.5866422653,
-0.2908633649,
-0.3826264143,
0.3240965605,
-0.1778457612,
0.2319853008,
-0.4078729749,
0.6239404678,
0.2086160332,
-0.033668559,
0.7449218035,
-0.1292158067,
1.1978271008,
-0.5617146492,
-0.304813236,
-0.0919574425,
0.3889820576,
-0.3579829931,
-1.1630331278,
0.4040667415,
-0.6207722425,
-0.1969026327,
-0.2468604594,
0.506008029,
-0.694213748,
-0.408711195,
0.667488277,
0.113750726,
-0.0417406633,
-0.1994594038,
-0.892378211,
0.0467378497,
-0.0832737684,
-0.2458444536,
0.5590561628,
0.5229757428,
0.1917823851,
0.7617021799,
0.2905304432,
-0.3365198374,
-0.2672387362,
0.1077272296,
0.7181020379,
-0.777635932,
-0.5135176182,
-0.810775876,
0.4822409451,
-0.1652579159,
-0.2639966607,
0.4830882549,
0.6008324623,
0.6662707329,
-0.2239815146,
0.487444967,
0.2595452964,
0.4829409719,
-0.5808756948,
0.6915674806,
-0.8642798662,
0.0703140125,
-0.476444751,
-0.7987257242,
-1.0670739412,
0.6521814466,
0.0823348761,
-0.0428395867,
0.851462245,
0.4353503585,
-0.1050002947,
-0.2966583967,
0.3604605794,
-0.0206534453,
0.3576649427,
0.7254587412,
0.7718048692,
-0.5940926671,
1.0011495352,
-0.5711081028,
-0.1452736259,
-0.2984157205,
-1.0980573893,
-1.021443367,
-0.7506029606,
-0.3853875995,
-0.3562319279,
0.0404313058,
0.6666092277,
0.4913632572,
-0.8269858956,
-0.0510337949,
0.1925155818,
0.3147430718,
-0.4739091396,
-0.2922548056,
0.8726081848,
-0.3738592267,
-0.5418230891,
-0.0778709948,
0.2287352681,
0.4213830829,
-0.0661302805,
-0.1821482331,
-0.2016610205,
-0.4109733403,
0.9131290913,
0.1076716781,
-0.4660035968,
-0.1588069648,
-0.2836420536,
-0.1779524535,
0.3017621338,
0.6468244195,
-0.8160438538,
0.3151758909,
0.0319188274,
1.0007485151,
0.7284131646,
-0.0720493197,
0.1984983683,
-0.9925403595,
0.1113789529,
0.3063679338,
0.3221892416,
0.5044233799,
-0.0330352113,
0.4849095941,
0.0564115159,
-0.3852844238,
-0.7707582712,
0.2172279954,
-1.3475739956,
-0.3885352015,
0.832698524,
0.0445722789,
0.1487150341,
-0.1857271194,
-0.2940790653,
-0.010919462,
-0.4386422634,
0.6390157938,
0.7402847409,
-0.3414779007,
-0.5235908031,
-0.3133984804,
0.4743999243,
0.382973969,
-0.7084298134,
0.1725844741,
0.3179210424,
0.0498643219,
0.4480433464,
0.3762734532,
0.1575905085,
0.0607642308,
0.0977218747,
-0.1707513928,
-0.1063733101,
-0.3767228723,
-0.3702831268,
0.4619284272,
-0.1709024608,
-0.157507062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08382v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08382v1
|
Look at the Text: Instruction-Tuned Language Models are More Robust Multiple Choice Selectors than You Think
| 2024-04-12T10:36:15 | 2024-04-12T10:36:15 |
Xinpeng Wang, Chengzhi Hu, Bolei Ma, Paul Röttger, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Multiple choice questions (MCQs) are commonly used to evaluate the
capabilities of large language models (LLMs). One common way to evaluate the
model response is to rank the candidate answers based on the log probability of
the first token prediction. An alternative way is to examine the text output.
Prior work has shown that first token probabilities lack robustness to changes
in MCQ phrasing, and that first token probabilities do not match text answers
for instruction-tuned models. Therefore, in this paper, we investigate the
robustness of text answers. We show that the text answers are more robust to
question perturbations than the first token probabilities, when the first token
answers mismatch the text answers. The difference in robustness increases as
the mismatch rate becomes greater. As the mismatch reaches over 50\%, the text
answer is more robust to option order changes than the debiased first token
probabilities using state-of-the-art debiasing methods such as PriDe. Our
findings provide further evidence for the benefits of text answer evaluation
over first token probability evaluation.
|
[
-0.2378623635,
-0.8919523954,
0.5451802015,
-0.1154474393,
-0.3419831395,
0.046493385,
-0.0275461841,
-0.1913801134,
-0.0647404268,
0.367064029,
-0.4220443666,
-0.4352029562,
-0.6809449196,
0.1693933159,
-0.281465292,
1.0611687899,
0.2903156877,
0.0902016982,
-0.4067801833,
-0.198682487,
-0.3399631083,
-0.8486917615,
-0.7608004212,
-0.0511408001,
0.541103065,
0.3290375769,
1.0206540823,
0.6548579335,
0.6289061308,
0.3671288788,
-0.2683893442,
0.0915084705,
-0.2745323479,
0.2706671953,
-0.1353594065,
-0.5381428599,
-0.4771662056,
0.0754825473,
0.4366413057,
0.2433891594,
0.1293070912,
0.360699743,
0.157982111,
0.3103493154,
-0.6035622954,
-0.1952936351,
-1.1367195845,
-0.2711689472,
-0.1442016065,
-0.4767095149,
-0.6475787163,
-0.2315954119,
-0.1052217409,
-0.0928468257,
-0.0687501207,
0.0894081444,
0.683267355,
0.4992437661,
-0.45768857,
-0.3358373046,
-0.4411422312,
0.9525985122,
-0.7134701014,
0.183911711,
0.5400984287,
0.2275286317,
-0.0985936821,
-0.4542114139,
-0.489646107,
-0.3129227757,
0.0036159204,
0.1148773506,
0.0302986056,
0.0952760279,
0.0890980959,
0.4197575748,
-0.5265855193,
0.3705777824,
0.1878350228,
-0.4870833755,
0.5452115536,
0.2351898402,
0.2196962535,
-0.2723469734,
-0.4954473078,
-0.4574618936,
-0.1725371778,
0.4331153929,
0.6873794198,
0.3761084974,
0.2762257159,
0.8239489198,
0.1157964841,
0.8719573021,
0.1419667006,
-0.5120407343,
-0.1458623111,
-0.6380467415,
-0.2470329851,
0.0049912333,
0.699793756,
0.2856368423,
0.2961361706,
0.0171568915,
-0.0810553655,
-0.1742489785,
0.3394840062,
-0.7344894409,
-0.0253053438,
0.4178789556,
-0.5874608159,
-0.6069934368,
0.1485288739,
-0.610141933,
-0.1478077769,
0.0970652327,
0.3962697089,
-0.3714295626,
-0.0274443589,
0.052272208,
0.0134406732,
0.2470932305,
0.0990431905,
-1.0916121006,
0.1086469218,
0.9158124328,
0.5904209018,
-0.4505914152,
-0.2287288159,
-0.7712390423,
-0.3616784215,
-0.3221005499,
0.7180421352,
-0.6932024956,
-0.3214970231,
-0.2126000971,
-0.146847263,
-0.2779892087,
-0.4474493861,
0.921662569,
-0.6454545259,
0.1872482151,
-0.1794100255,
-0.5362871885,
0.2867906988,
0.3632414639,
-0.6301863194,
1.0800154209,
0.0826031342,
-1.2203879356,
0.5147357583,
-0.0901062042,
-0.3071883619,
-0.3542259037,
-0.1046133488,
-0.5427253842,
0.0856013373,
0.3697568774,
0.2590227425,
0.1692228615,
0.0901331976,
-0.6246274114,
-0.4280478954,
0.8539364338,
-1.0697385073,
0.8602135181,
0.1052887514,
-0.117542021,
-0.0043156487,
-0.6969833374,
0.5149531364,
-0.3750601411,
-0.9402872324,
-0.3362774849,
0.0209107343,
-0.1498238742,
0.2843821049,
0.0616474003,
-0.3118105531,
0.0430972055,
-0.5751375556,
0.1614653915,
1.1378164291,
-0.1114171967,
0.2867111862,
-0.5502372384,
0.6562057734,
0.2111199349,
0.1420844793,
-0.1480764896,
-0.6981201172,
-0.4037199914,
-0.2466924191,
0.5319935679,
0.7116599679,
-0.5879457593,
0.2688506544,
-0.2255108654,
-0.5245198011,
-0.5957686901,
0.0332025588,
0.4747703969,
0.4957258999,
0.2906703949,
-0.101238139,
-0.363121897,
-0.8696940541,
-0.7935008407,
-0.6501083374,
-0.0258395318,
0.2973160148,
0.2995561361,
0.1083982438,
0.7292292714,
-0.2922341526,
0.3884240985,
-0.0962867662,
-0.0521955751,
0.2820020318,
0.4127791524,
0.5767996907,
-0.8521504402,
-0.4299222529,
-0.1233611926,
-0.129671514,
0.0721382871,
-0.052852843,
-0.412612766,
0.3552958667,
0.196159631,
-0.599560678,
0.3600841165,
0.4702866375,
-0.5012695789,
0.6767034531,
0.1354114562,
0.3774585426,
-1.1184561253,
0.0148008,
-0.3354700208,
-0.2817159891,
-0.3913879991,
0.0768491924,
-0.1235179156,
0.2612141073,
-0.4392789304,
0.5290488601,
0.0562333204,
-0.0983780921,
-0.0462322868,
0.1613204926,
-0.0793471262,
0.1516216546,
-0.3784027398,
1.0801420212,
0.3567478955,
-0.7293760777,
-0.0241006818,
0.3798328936,
-0.3341248035,
0.3236072063,
-0.5117894411,
0.2784291208,
-0.1652259529,
-0.2308018357,
-1.3488687277,
-0.2192516923,
-0.0898429304,
-0.7961345911,
0.3601790667,
0.0326295719,
-0.3719680905,
-0.3526269794,
-0.49700436,
0.1684415787,
0.156613037,
-0.4037311971,
0.3044173717,
0.2485808432,
-0.227442205,
-1.0987378359,
-0.8625905514,
-0.1386507154,
-0.1242941618,
-0.363688767,
0.1744311154,
-0.5661228895,
-0.3530288637,
-0.2280578017,
-0.5674845576,
-0.213327229,
0.6037163138,
-0.0750318021,
0.3894841075,
-0.3409559429,
0.2134179324,
0.10552077,
-0.008085303,
-0.0921056867,
-0.2201954722,
0.5216588974,
-0.0099938409,
-0.5772325993,
-0.2008890063,
0.2991351485,
0.7708229423,
-0.1228610426,
0.8997021914,
0.4131866395,
-0.1400885433,
0.1057936177,
-0.3182213008,
-0.0884010196,
-0.4979606569,
0.4774580598,
-0.458820045,
-1.0404828787,
0.2969047725,
0.5085684061,
0.2477687895,
0.4738057256,
0.7734022737,
-0.0372532904,
1.3816241026,
0.4605565965,
0.0789547414,
0.3537087142,
0.5098003745,
0.2344106287,
-0.4673832357,
-0.0216618143,
-0.9681997299,
-0.4130881727,
-0.8480492234,
-0.2277161479,
0.2170279771,
0.2597828209,
-0.3242255449,
0.1689338386,
-0.6195534468,
0.4979654253,
0.6629505754,
0.0921872705,
0.3834716678,
0.1353435814,
-0.5290824175,
-0.1662375331,
-0.7057456374,
-0.9651281238,
1.2167844772,
0.2308915108,
0.7383025885,
0.1651396304,
0.5758787394,
0.0229931064,
0.3421477973,
-0.7264407277,
0.549392581,
-0.3708005846,
-0.8343017101,
-0.4597252011,
-0.3998797536,
-0.7549664378,
0.2364270985,
-0.4326105416,
-0.9227819443,
-0.053508874,
0.2053339183,
-0.3895013332,
0.2597578168,
-0.5051510334,
0.749027133,
-0.423635751,
-0.2890980244,
0.3949016929,
-0.4160124063,
0.2468458563,
-0.0806565285,
0.0631872565,
0.1929107606,
-0.1362406164,
0.6559804082,
-0.1427008361,
0.5366618037,
0.2765184939,
-0.1887095869,
0.3734391928,
0.1241116151,
0.2813566327,
0.3117969334,
-0.6716402173,
-0.3403238356,
0.2082575262,
-0.3763352334,
-0.5688319802,
0.7904633284,
-0.67342484,
-0.8369743824,
-0.142191723,
-0.316503495,
-0.2496436238,
0.2237318456,
0.5349240303,
0.5477128625,
0.0735025704,
0.2880534232,
0.6554239392,
-0.3697283864,
0.7023074627,
0.1381168067,
-0.2238722593,
-0.5209193826,
0.360632956,
0.1137693971,
0.425015837,
0.5970410705,
0.2977491915,
-0.4763596356,
-0.4517436028,
-0.4894745946,
-0.2282816172,
-0.9722031951,
-0.3279303908,
-0.741904974,
-0.129215911,
-0.357114166,
-0.0782593265,
-0.0942244008,
-0.5248598456,
-0.3500921428,
-0.4573994577,
0.0363307744,
0.3762319088,
0.3947423398,
0.0114074629,
-0.7133898735,
0.1378553361,
0.5828940272,
0.4615482092,
-0.1528369039,
-0.5417475104,
-0.0042914231,
0.0785259604,
-0.4293551147,
-1.1104457378,
-0.0693862513,
0.2690293491,
0.7191726565,
0.3360815644,
0.1307521462,
0.6388193965,
-0.2462540269,
0.9559932947,
-0.1670920104,
-0.7449479103,
0.518176198,
-0.0484827831,
0.4026367068,
0.9657000899,
0.2856151164,
0.1367236972,
-0.6652742624,
-0.5712963343,
-0.532410264,
0.6058526635,
0.2100926936,
0.4985510409,
-0.4299108684,
0.4262583256,
0.2720469832,
0.3004177213,
-0.8396750689,
-0.4032340944,
-0.1388365328,
-0.3795983493,
-0.0940468013,
-0.3988266885,
0.2273800671,
-0.1315860152,
0.66080302,
-0.1743478626,
0.2403843552,
0.2074763328,
0.1033977717,
-0.0332067907,
0.5877507329,
0.5974946022,
0.4472297132,
-0.0703469962,
0.4001162052,
0.1888189912,
-0.641081512,
0.1578766257,
-0.1672392786,
-0.3019563556,
0.1960976571,
0.5151299238,
0.7472800612,
0.2214562148,
-0.600392282,
0.5866894722,
-0.2568020225,
-0.0389408097,
0.2748641372,
0.3780720234,
-0.1297968179,
-0.0588651337,
0.3529404402,
0.3377797604,
0.0317484848,
-0.636003077,
0.380029887,
0.6694688797,
-0.4585589468,
-0.0303794406,
0.9274976254,
-0.1901952624,
-0.6383881569,
0.3707197905,
-0.0619653389,
-0.7878227234,
0.7685793638,
0.7228147984,
0.6577687263,
-0.1974402219,
0.3242521882,
0.4749051034,
0.5025903583,
0.0063687856,
0.4682878852,
0.0919084921,
-0.5424208045,
-0.4705237746,
-0.8781272173,
-0.2728289068,
0.153289184,
-0.5659359694,
0.3743341863,
-0.3180834055,
-0.6134859324,
-0.1666460633,
-0.0580141507,
-0.5511399508,
0.3539509773,
-0.0567105003,
0.972878933,
-0.6316853762,
0.4743553698,
0.9297095537,
-0.1069775522,
-0.899301827,
0.3089651763,
-0.3797152042,
-0.6201147437,
0.2969783247,
0.3036295474,
-0.1600704789,
0.0418512449,
-0.6841602921,
-0.8645459414,
0.8579028845,
0.6421247125,
-0.2451105863,
0.2511936128,
0.1704989225,
0.5427950621,
-0.1650724858,
0.5712850094,
0.4573718607,
0.3834711611,
-0.0650495514,
-0.873695612,
-0.128714785,
-0.0489309616,
-0.0648785383,
0.0848616809,
-0.5088925958,
0.931332469,
-0.3471702337,
-0.2781942189,
0.2033007592,
0.4645560384,
0.2988691926,
0.2876783907,
0.4262372553,
0.4310570359,
0.8733922839,
-0.1374895722,
1.1887533665,
-0.3458403945,
0.415943265,
1.0660099983,
-0.0226565991,
1.1387845278,
0.6060439944,
-0.2887011766,
0.5145048499,
0.7479408979,
0.3689244986,
0.4213404059,
0.1511199772,
-0.0148166586,
-0.6726930737,
0.2861050963,
-0.061741855,
0.7273003459,
-0.127899766,
-0.3801444471,
0.0071196989,
-0.17376481,
0.0838586241,
0.2943687439,
-0.3149593771,
0.7577987909,
-0.0484580696,
-1.0896242857,
0.5330415368,
0.0058256965,
0.6038626432,
-0.314468503,
0.1863623559,
-0.2650471628,
0.0661354885,
-0.1727188528,
-0.9870218039,
0.2391950786,
0.1539756805,
-0.2941530049,
0.0650178269,
0.8264045119,
-0.1734625846,
-0.6390033364,
-0.0696281269,
0.4965211153,
-0.0600106381,
0.2271535993,
-0.6285169721,
-0.1104957983,
-0.0599472858,
-0.3806936741,
0.4030354023,
0.2339118123,
0.1030060947,
0.7589331865,
0.5817633867,
-0.2154903859,
0.2672572136,
-0.3114809394,
0.621458292,
-0.2404117733,
-0.4207509756,
-1.2434573174,
0.6420212984,
-0.093672134,
-0.5648722649,
0.730820179,
0.3887455463,
0.6888860464,
-0.0449415296,
0.6298223734,
0.1262183487,
0.4346141517,
-0.6162643433,
0.520164609,
-0.4475601912,
0.4264369011,
-0.3747863173,
-0.8217920065,
-0.2519803345,
0.4168900549,
-0.082892172,
0.1558845937,
0.6518267393,
0.6826642752,
0.0469078645,
-0.1430291682,
0.3994392753,
0.0073343609,
-0.0524341762,
0.4167118967,
0.6753066778,
-0.5327480435,
0.8104344606,
0.0997935012,
-0.1087377593,
-0.1029343978,
-0.9869342446,
-1.0468691587,
-0.4152435362,
-0.1915438473,
-0.3902843595,
-0.1549590975,
0.749371171,
0.380078882,
-0.9532173872,
0.2543596625,
0.1309372336,
0.4806683064,
-0.2658082545,
-0.2267859727,
0.3299511373,
-0.3289074004,
-0.6487236619,
0.1958616972,
0.2230614275,
0.1289348006,
-0.0460032113,
0.1215660274,
-0.1726513505,
0.5150696039,
0.4497324526,
-0.1989838481,
-0.6083804965,
-0.6168458462,
0.4855618477,
-0.3960679471,
0.0989829153,
0.5164561868,
-0.6695239544,
0.4467990398,
0.3633304536,
0.8869627118,
-0.1556524783,
0.3729652762,
0.2968470156,
-0.8709955812,
-0.0853932127,
0.1858970374,
0.1669613123,
0.2515074313,
-0.4527752697,
0.170514971,
-0.2666003108,
-0.7480259538,
-0.9339435101,
0.353656739,
-0.8029144406,
-0.2264702022,
1.1588834524,
-0.0557236299,
-0.1259783357,
-0.0342662483,
-0.3002707362,
0.2532526553,
0.0163112581,
0.7953171134,
1.1652618647,
0.0808639824,
-0.0925223231,
-0.5013119578,
0.432475239,
0.5448429585,
-0.6617597342,
-0.1390745193,
0.091493614,
0.195890069,
0.0735682696,
0.678224206,
-0.1240410432,
0.2108004987,
-0.0577544197,
-0.7633405328,
0.0825649872,
-0.1727685779,
-0.3538055122,
0.3552581072,
0.5232661963,
-0.1826974601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08368v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08368v1
|
ASR advancements for indigenous languages: Quechua, Guarani, Bribri, Kotiria, and Wa'ikhana
| 2024-04-12T10:12:38 | 2024-04-12T10:12:38 |
Monica Romero, Sandra Gomez, Iván G. Torre
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Indigenous languages are a fundamental legacy in the development of human
communication, embodying the unique identity and culture of local communities
of America. The Second AmericasNLP Competition Track 1 of NeurIPS 2022 proposed
developing automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems for five indigenous
languages: Quechua, Guarani, Bribri, Kotiria, and Wa'ikhana. In this paper, we
propose a reliable ASR model for each target language by crawling speech
corpora spanning diverse sources and applying data augmentation methods that
resulted in the winning approach in this competition. To achieve this, we
systematically investigated the impact of different hyperparameters by a
Bayesian search on the performance of the language models, specifically
focusing on the variants of the Wav2vec2.0 XLS-R model: 300M and 1B parameters.
Moreover, we performed a global sensitivity analysis to assess the contribution
of various hyperparametric configurations to the performances of our best
models. Importantly, our results show that freeze fine-tuning updates and
dropout rate are more vital parameters than the total number of epochs of lr.
Additionally, we liberate our best models -- with no other ASR model reported
until now for two Wa'ikhana and Kotiria -- and the many experiments performed
to pave the way to other researchers to continue improving ASR in minority
languages. This insight opens up interesting avenues for future work, allowing
for the advancement of ASR techniques in the preservation of minority
indigenous and acknowledging the complexities involved in this important
endeavour.
|
[
-0.2331155092,
-0.3926075399,
0.1582751274,
0.2915724814,
-0.0653109029,
0.2916309834,
-0.4039464891,
-0.7273224592,
-0.1416210681,
0.4722118974,
-0.0984190032,
-0.3602177501,
-0.6180208325,
0.3410517275,
-0.5231271982,
0.526327908,
0.218813315,
-0.1274639219,
0.2047841549,
-0.3866927028,
-0.4597094357,
-0.4775373638,
-0.7243857384,
-0.4041684568,
0.4301307797,
0.3014857769,
0.8170339465,
0.7831299901,
0.5700987577,
0.2673071325,
-0.5064350963,
-0.0641298741,
0.1065766588,
0.1360691786,
-0.1260291487,
-0.4305116534,
-0.1272659898,
-0.2600659132,
0.7415762544,
0.6146655679,
-0.4426470399,
0.0904900432,
-0.1118823066,
0.314604789,
-0.6926189661,
0.1793440878,
-0.6520390511,
0.0240751896,
-0.4173015654,
-0.0336877517,
-0.0946920365,
-0.6042811871,
0.3948295116,
-0.3572342098,
0.2265751213,
-0.1896117181,
0.8227710724,
0.3611133099,
-0.1879931986,
-0.3270890117,
-0.8214051723,
0.6955401897,
-1.0733363628,
0.6603056192,
0.4721732438,
0.3127326667,
0.0234187935,
-0.6010318398,
-0.4917884171,
-0.1370960176,
0.1886534393,
0.0006147123,
-0.6006858945,
-0.0707794353,
0.1491266489,
0.2848121226,
-0.7356739044,
0.5441834927,
-0.6361971498,
-0.3507925868,
0.6431104541,
0.1104378775,
0.2706714869,
-0.0091597429,
-0.1145170778,
-0.0879571065,
-0.4689154923,
0.154915303,
0.3681479394,
0.5979240537,
-0.2063280791,
0.4796015322,
-0.5036045313,
0.8148109317,
-0.183468923,
-0.3409759402,
0.2851281464,
-0.1611907184,
0.1947147399,
0.0942450091,
0.830266118,
0.0387579761,
0.1256974936,
-0.3043032587,
-0.0003817362,
0.3796061873,
-0.1652089655,
-0.5128171444,
-0.2574287057,
0.1206607297,
-0.4056643844,
0.0938514099,
-0.3016584218,
-0.6815103889,
-0.1334931552,
-0.3940047026,
0.4365989566,
-0.415655911,
-0.4130968153,
0.172309503,
-0.2520676553,
0.3284725845,
0.1601640284,
-0.8370978832,
0.4604097009,
0.5974778533,
0.8376438618,
-0.2455950826,
-0.4936705828,
-0.5065663457,
0.0365453921,
-0.1857856214,
0.8127783537,
-0.9360013008,
-0.3863086402,
0.1262423694,
-0.2780240774,
-0.2160058469,
-0.7350386977,
0.7801008821,
-0.6694869995,
-0.1849059016,
-0.3857374489,
-0.1578709632,
-0.3239559829,
-0.0334172845,
-0.4971401095,
0.9281467795,
-0.0976058245,
-0.4669400752,
0.3100528419,
-0.6481661797,
-0.4894514382,
0.2127426863,
0.0660162568,
-0.3709415197,
0.097450234,
0.166540429,
0.0507895388,
-0.4828208387,
0.1531486362,
-0.0691445842,
-0.4289846718,
0.2706044912,
-0.4844874144,
0.7750359774,
0.3681736588,
-0.3444449306,
-0.0852238908,
-0.8865358233,
0.1944880933,
-0.1367234886,
-0.7671962976,
-0.1682565957,
0.0510689691,
0.1190002561,
0.079793185,
0.0650499091,
-0.696506083,
-0.1531381458,
-0.3118030131,
0.6791732311,
0.2596185207,
-0.0120775728,
0.2107440978,
0.049146533,
0.4245987833,
-0.0725158602,
0.1334884316,
-0.1726417542,
-0.667232275,
-0.6578819156,
-0.0732055977,
0.6315210462,
0.4951249063,
-0.2677800357,
0.2328969985,
-0.2687236965,
-0.5650818348,
-0.6639273763,
-0.1771726459,
0.4844990969,
0.5088564157,
0.4492898583,
-0.5290722251,
-0.6265508533,
-0.6700190306,
-0.1310175061,
-0.3995988369,
-0.086105749,
0.0800897628,
0.1799635887,
-0.4972567558,
0.9164968729,
-0.2449442297,
-0.1148819104,
-0.0420398824,
0.2816522121,
0.1489895284,
0.4837792516,
0.2100318223,
-0.7700733542,
-0.4775263369,
0.2242154777,
-0.4078890085,
-0.1580275893,
0.362036109,
0.2832931876,
0.2839019597,
0.2290430218,
-0.4788604081,
0.5393958092,
0.5430496335,
-0.01739797,
0.4950904548,
-0.2152513266,
0.1605130583,
-0.4894175828,
0.2040664852,
-0.0186613761,
0.2612659335,
-0.7282387018,
0.3375449181,
0.1967542619,
-0.3651696444,
-0.1073397696,
0.3828288019,
-0.3653434515,
-0.1232595742,
-0.4297374785,
-0.1682011187,
-0.4648654163,
0.2869931757,
0.5171328783,
0.583278358,
0.6395769715,
-0.752045393,
0.2386874557,
0.4203158319,
-0.1507568955,
0.2105845958,
-0.938472867,
0.3884648383,
-0.017474195,
0.0526402742,
-0.7113710642,
-0.1480176598,
0.16546233,
-0.7684903145,
0.2332806587,
-0.4866221547,
-0.5125545859,
-0.4479315877,
0.2590466738,
0.3123207986,
0.5316225886,
-0.4887101948,
0.5001406074,
0.472142458,
-0.5256317258,
-0.5646440387,
-0.6060914397,
0.3744777441,
-0.4162092209,
-0.4416306019,
0.1189432219,
-0.036294274,
-0.2071082741,
-0.3034661412,
-0.0400880277,
-0.1430755109,
-0.1627544463,
0.1568388641,
0.0644510016,
-0.349434942,
-0.2187547833,
0.1363493353,
-0.3280837834,
-0.032731317,
-0.3739388883,
0.7574405074,
-0.2161126137,
-0.2596427202,
-0.5207415223,
0.3181609809,
0.4148481488,
-0.8639056087,
0.3131799102,
0.6991871595,
-0.5387157798,
0.3659399748,
-0.9764143229,
0.0892428234,
-0.4324396849,
0.1612769216,
-0.4021041691,
-0.695330143,
0.7621175647,
0.1932621002,
-0.1058729514,
0.1764877737,
0.4243385792,
0.4831972122,
0.922726512,
0.5380999446,
-0.3657311499,
0.236132741,
-0.2389050126,
0.095036298,
-0.9914278984,
-0.3489550948,
-1.0104153156,
-0.001413792,
-0.7753766179,
-0.4472266138,
0.4274811447,
-0.2679793835,
-0.0426393524,
0.6503169537,
-0.3196868598,
0.3318920434,
0.9007478952,
-0.0595904216,
0.4049448371,
0.0544165596,
0.0565460585,
-0.1489356458,
-0.6310287118,
-0.3753498197,
0.9958644509,
0.3672380447,
0.7128545642,
0.152170375,
0.6083881259,
0.1732222885,
-0.1653756052,
-0.5871753097,
0.3125698566,
-0.1227822378,
-0.5847023129,
-0.4759489,
-0.3010934293,
-1.0124171972,
0.2055949271,
0.0970081314,
-0.8978031874,
0.6925387383,
-0.0094748288,
-0.6186134815,
-0.0066352794,
-0.321390003,
0.5274092555,
-0.0574676022,
-0.2318805158,
-0.2116191238,
-1.0226073265,
-0.1060800776,
0.0980883986,
0.0963258669,
-0.1328697801,
-0.0985016972,
0.5876713991,
-0.1141527221,
0.4827546775,
-0.2039244473,
0.0300241951,
0.4068180919,
-0.0049486537,
0.4151340723,
-0.0228473656,
-0.5153259039,
0.2935302258,
-0.067353107,
-0.3106445074,
-0.3174591362,
0.5064386129,
-0.6660596132,
-0.2184650451,
-0.3721713424,
-0.54493922,
-0.0881746784,
0.2027845085,
0.3117763996,
0.5357893109,
0.1237671524,
0.232952863,
0.5861895084,
-0.1585053504,
0.5481677055,
0.9446246028,
0.1906425208,
-0.5338948965,
1.0289419889,
0.3560604751,
0.1375318766,
0.304661274,
0.3501451313,
-0.5254708529,
-1.129093051,
-0.4176500738,
0.1302571148,
-0.4585169554,
-0.289735496,
-0.8882942796,
-0.1666851938,
-0.5888060331,
0.0855473503,
-0.2299015075,
-0.4568900168,
-0.1657520831,
0.0482988916,
0.1719363183,
0.4483034909,
-0.4265094101,
0.3405429721,
-0.7185465693,
0.1966452748,
0.3536831737,
0.1628508717,
0.1086217165,
-0.7923508286,
-0.134117648,
0.1232026219,
-0.1848412454,
-0.5952353477,
0.7787712216,
0.5053519011,
0.5791087151,
0.362518698,
0.0108551625,
0.8220509291,
-0.3922142088,
0.4807037711,
-0.045537468,
-0.8003494143,
0.73494941,
-0.5026600957,
0.3818689883,
0.5088695288,
0.3616344035,
-0.6392959356,
-0.4446729422,
-0.4388709962,
-0.9288046956,
0.5623995662,
0.1433143765,
0.1531162262,
0.0639805198,
0.346783638,
0.2752710879,
0.2060209662,
-0.436201781,
-0.0768495202,
-0.0537843928,
0.0683626607,
0.0828571767,
-0.0239523109,
0.2079467326,
-0.2452812195,
0.5436241031,
-0.1313888282,
0.0415545888,
0.1869791448,
-0.1041278392,
-0.2337001115,
0.1951311231,
0.231394738,
0.6128422022,
-0.1309786886,
-0.0641282722,
0.2744688094,
-0.5968433022,
0.0227707233,
0.5423571467,
-0.5162584782,
0.092406489,
0.1386014968,
0.8252196908,
0.1589119136,
-0.7518606782,
-0.0467247739,
-0.0154986652,
0.2066569328,
-0.4129822254,
0.0870905221,
-0.1068473235,
0.3238200843,
0.7466984987,
0.3374661803,
0.6528596282,
-0.7143969536,
-0.0025308952,
0.249616757,
-0.4259752333,
-0.4757715762,
0.8087781072,
0.0712700188,
-0.5631665587,
0.7453612685,
-0.1361918151,
-0.6579647064,
0.5241751671,
0.7886399627,
0.5689188838,
-0.5741144419,
0.123367101,
0.6101886034,
0.2506171465,
-0.253918469,
0.159484759,
-0.1736436337,
-0.5340352654,
-0.2301143706,
-0.7447357178,
-0.6950288415,
-0.0203159675,
-0.9141277671,
0.2871803343,
-0.1892117709,
-0.2174106836,
0.1082744375,
0.1572986543,
-0.5657992363,
0.427215457,
0.3713746369,
0.7639828324,
-0.85032022,
0.5998821259,
0.5491642356,
-0.3539053798,
-0.597011745,
0.0680019781,
-0.0251378026,
-0.6030141711,
0.2323386073,
-0.0595698953,
0.0186438262,
0.1192401126,
-0.2563031018,
-1.3967963457,
0.8896459937,
0.2654865682,
-0.462536782,
-0.1518405229,
0.2526080608,
0.7639707327,
-0.1481016576,
0.3176065683,
0.9391874075,
0.4004816115,
0.1455099881,
-1.2833129168,
-0.2081456035,
-0.3638735414,
0.2795969546,
0.0930778235,
-0.7980372906,
0.5637239218,
-0.5303911567,
-0.1899935603,
0.5473714471,
0.7914406061,
0.5436463952,
0.4787765145,
0.0964269936,
0.4940012693,
0.5947185755,
-0.1527844965,
0.7914627194,
-0.0875566602,
-0.0872273818,
1.1110383272,
-0.2204765677,
1.1199252605,
0.15159145,
-0.5548917651,
0.3548581302,
0.5764599442,
-0.0605503023,
0.3323056996,
0.0963121206,
-0.2498611361,
0.0553347804,
-0.3744509518,
-0.4983978271,
0.8029999137,
0.4494558871,
-0.0313135497,
0.1753899902,
0.0141594587,
0.00790253,
0.1428902298,
-0.184944585,
0.5411164761,
-0.1629329622,
-0.6038477421,
0.5890752077,
0.1236439198,
0.8524294496,
-0.64851439,
0.1751683056,
-0.2236407995,
-0.010639051,
-0.2890465558,
-0.3199978471,
0.2557775974,
0.18624641,
-0.0245629642,
0.471309185,
0.6145887375,
-0.5012569427,
-0.4944547117,
0.2941111326,
0.215457648,
0.2006756365,
-0.122640565,
-0.33049348,
0.5162465572,
-0.2413977087,
0.2371263802,
0.1409201771,
0.1460032463,
-0.0702485591,
0.8452076316,
0.7176356912,
0.3355938196,
0.4372093379,
0.1991254836,
0.7223282456,
-0.4789911509,
-0.3753607869,
-0.4960072339,
0.4776312709,
0.1205683947,
-0.3102864325,
0.8061481118,
0.881064117,
0.7871133089,
0.0364107527,
0.8207933903,
-0.1301657856,
0.8429958224,
-0.2853457034,
0.5596146584,
-0.0492076315,
0.0834457129,
-0.5218387246,
-0.8719736934,
-0.2965095639,
0.440962255,
-0.2895636857,
-0.1747910678,
0.173985675,
0.6962295771,
-0.0359394029,
-0.0127549171,
0.1353168041,
0.0917459279,
0.1910613924,
0.207840845,
0.8048739433,
-0.7137172222,
0.8106948733,
-0.3411003947,
-0.1394987553,
-0.032202784,
-0.4011112452,
-0.2690478265,
-0.6279925704,
-0.6610430479,
-0.0476998463,
0.3618717492,
0.7863302827,
0.6774843335,
-1.0279058218,
-0.4911156893,
0.0021990496,
-0.1466313004,
-0.3082212806,
-0.1845303923,
0.1571516395,
-0.1079383492,
-0.9131629467,
0.6240975261,
0.2890334427,
0.0827135965,
0.0577971451,
-0.2653952539,
-0.0827828422,
-0.080952473,
0.5299116969,
0.8911283612,
-0.8172218204,
-0.1488956511,
0.0980531648,
0.3104630709,
0.0999093577,
0.5836427808,
-0.8261753917,
0.5426515341,
0.3183038533,
0.3798844218,
0.509542644,
0.0189816318,
0.6703993678,
-0.2318056971,
0.1989991665,
0.4902909398,
0.169585973,
0.5191456079,
0.0300364383,
0.6668272614,
0.1072222143,
-0.5770971179,
-1.1475834846,
0.139398098,
-0.6384435296,
0.348377347,
1.0172089338,
-0.1294179708,
0.2232110649,
-0.4205403924,
-0.1319880635,
0.3203984797,
-0.5385270119,
0.8055074215,
0.2400436848,
-0.2056056112,
-0.272177726,
-0.4594046474,
0.2723232508,
0.3129291236,
-0.4527804554,
-0.0537820533,
0.4458427727,
0.2934860587,
0.3959679008,
0.4467557371,
-0.3178089857,
0.4665218592,
0.0868691951,
-0.1287195235,
0.2723117173,
-0.381155163,
-0.5747559667,
-0.0088351071,
0.3200954199,
-0.0768146366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08359v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08359v1
|
Improving Health Question Answering with Reliable and Time-Aware Evidence Retrieval
| 2024-04-12T09:56:12 | 2024-04-12T09:56:12 |
Juraj Vladika, Florian Matthes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
In today's digital world, seeking answers to health questions on the Internet
is a common practice. However, existing question answering (QA) systems often
rely on using pre-selected and annotated evidence documents, thus making them
inadequate for addressing novel questions. Our study focuses on the open-domain
QA setting, where the key challenge is to first uncover relevant evidence in
large knowledge bases. By utilizing the common retrieve-then-read QA pipeline
and PubMed as a trustworthy collection of medical research documents, we answer
health questions from three diverse datasets. We modify different retrieval
settings to observe their influence on the QA pipeline's performance, including
the number of retrieved documents, sentence selection process, the publication
year of articles, and their number of citations. Our results reveal that
cutting down on the amount of retrieved documents and favoring more recent and
highly cited documents can improve the final macro F1 score up to 10%. We
discuss the results, highlight interesting examples, and outline challenges for
future research, like managing evidence disagreement and crafting user-friendly
explanations.
|
[
-0.1988434643,
-0.6983158588,
1.0863801241,
-0.1587453336,
-0.3702879846,
-0.0686431378,
0.1768142283,
-0.7002393007,
0.4325547814,
0.2691841424,
-0.2545157075,
-0.3213781118,
-0.7005217075,
0.2449677736,
-0.0462616533,
0.8828068972,
-0.0529165454,
0.0834822208,
-0.4012218714,
-0.3059650362,
-0.0217824578,
-0.3630577922,
-0.5006009936,
-0.2251375765,
0.7452248931,
0.3530268073,
0.7617860436,
0.5212346911,
0.844976306,
0.0801881105,
-0.1191306487,
0.3113850653,
-0.5803450346,
0.3196115792,
-0.2050795853,
-0.3357416689,
-0.3818908036,
-0.0824066699,
0.3276310861,
0.6758982539,
0.1543166786,
0.393524617,
-0.2033632845,
0.7394483685,
-0.7591028214,
-0.0200645346,
-0.421335578,
-0.0598603785,
-0.3149927557,
-0.6029497385,
-0.2379440218,
-0.5985417962,
0.5109229088,
-0.9324705005,
0.1225563213,
-0.0915464982,
0.9349433184,
0.1178088039,
-0.6994158626,
-0.1514827609,
-0.6812781096,
0.3454660475,
-0.7883504033,
0.3754473925,
0.3746773303,
0.2997532785,
-0.0284521189,
-0.8975508809,
-0.2530352473,
0.4266540408,
-0.2516071796,
0.1763471067,
-0.1811028719,
-0.0549367741,
0.2798676491,
0.3482115865,
-0.6218962669,
-0.3037275672,
-0.437214613,
-0.316219151,
0.5127198696,
-0.0222779736,
0.2116028666,
-0.11404147,
-0.013442398,
-0.0390110575,
-0.8790566325,
0.2002713978,
-0.1995552033,
-0.0320739448,
0.4269775152,
0.57611233,
-0.44338727,
0.5865439177,
0.0607143603,
0.0300644599,
0.3901469409,
-0.5852131844,
-0.1008531973,
-0.1556660533,
0.2735857964,
0.5802339315,
-0.050575316,
-0.2033745795,
0.2064324915,
-0.3248273432,
0.4282245338,
-1.0602426529,
-0.1547095925,
0.7225294113,
-0.7103305459,
0.1091793552,
0.1773024201,
-0.9252055287,
-0.1954624951,
0.0092401356,
0.5355347991,
-0.4209887385,
-0.1960044503,
0.1179704145,
-0.3780408204,
0.2111504972,
0.4012660086,
-0.4257309437,
0.2448767871,
0.5388939381,
0.6859722137,
0.0572664998,
0.3167533576,
-0.9330421686,
0.0484485067,
-0.3774282634,
0.912997067,
-0.4555150867,
-0.4295409918,
0.1434910148,
0.303308636,
-0.1040693671,
-0.6857395172,
0.5634945035,
-0.808014214,
0.5684776902,
-0.5927592516,
-0.533364594,
-0.0004572623,
0.1699035764,
-0.7113311887,
0.4726552069,
-0.0099136876,
-0.8730970621,
0.486202836,
-0.674836278,
-0.596473515,
-0.060514167,
-0.0497453399,
-0.4175776243,
0.2033909857,
0.6012578607,
0.1730384231,
-0.1333735585,
0.0856277421,
-0.2450747937,
-0.2938342392,
0.0575508699,
-0.1209063604,
0.7355895042,
0.4513871372,
-0.3301700354,
-0.0890789777,
-0.5433350801,
0.3399494588,
0.0333837084,
-0.3172913194,
-0.6777530909,
0.0169902593,
-0.2599270046,
0.1911679357,
0.0458855964,
-0.8571835756,
-0.0588156581,
-0.3819144666,
0.485340476,
0.3861789405,
0.548579514,
0.1093713269,
-0.8211721182,
0.4455344081,
0.0922209322,
0.2845637798,
-0.2422638088,
-0.8021202087,
0.0302446168,
-0.1184018031,
0.3675842285,
0.2850963473,
-0.7914646268,
-0.0596593432,
-0.4328194857,
-0.2015011907,
-0.9306767583,
-0.0889567137,
0.2263743579,
0.7792743444,
0.6548102498,
-0.4147081375,
-0.238827154,
-0.7210856676,
-0.4580120146,
-0.3248002529,
-0.2441602349,
0.5605419874,
0.4283640683,
-0.0553098656,
0.9016541839,
-0.8546219468,
-0.0445591174,
0.2669141889,
0.1439753324,
0.0727432147,
0.225429222,
0.5115768909,
-1.0220739841,
-0.2180232406,
-0.2430163175,
-0.6300659776,
-0.1601426005,
0.1929182708,
-0.2534717321,
-0.2190773785,
0.2819841504,
-0.6367899179,
0.2830283046,
0.1828083843,
-0.4664993584,
0.1580791622,
-0.0238249861,
0.5812783837,
-0.9485939741,
0.4690641463,
-0.2001837194,
-0.3008306324,
-0.4685403705,
0.0872146562,
0.1670248061,
-0.1906873137,
-0.3961523771,
0.5990895033,
-0.4228028953,
0.2087040544,
0.0246167425,
0.1315876245,
0.4447462857,
-0.0156272575,
-0.0727384016,
0.7670565844,
-0.0533353314,
-0.2486284077,
-0.2867947221,
0.3522210419,
-0.2930032611,
0.4968361557,
-0.7243875265,
0.2599484324,
-0.4065378904,
0.2371367067,
-0.7882376313,
-0.4400536716,
0.1258196682,
-0.4125055373,
0.1928076744,
0.0723195374,
-0.2287974805,
-0.4144801795,
-0.395031482,
0.2445995659,
0.3368579447,
-0.2638849318,
0.3189351559,
0.5815636516,
-0.4359179735,
-0.6598649621,
-0.2577742934,
-0.2290761769,
0.0113385953,
-0.437692076,
0.3244180977,
-0.151104331,
-0.3898880482,
0.2883526981,
-0.5708178282,
-0.3983272314,
0.1287716776,
0.0861014649,
-0.0822477192,
-0.2745033801,
0.4417226911,
0.0803720802,
0.315520227,
0.2836483419,
-0.2342730612,
0.0347648561,
0.0597415976,
-0.326867938,
-0.1248071417,
0.7452403307,
0.6657141447,
-0.4406634867,
0.6264678836,
0.3939322233,
-0.5516597033,
0.2863294482,
-0.4821421206,
-0.4174441099,
-0.3112679124,
0.0733232051,
-0.0656703413,
-1.0644954443,
0.2913964689,
-0.111457102,
0.4784196615,
0.5708646774,
0.2687995434,
-0.3086239994,
0.7891434431,
0.2129060179,
0.1293445975,
0.1777713299,
-0.0204503834,
0.1980830878,
-0.6315943003,
-0.2992565036,
-0.5894121528,
-0.1418120563,
-0.263435632,
-0.6082744002,
0.874994576,
0.0101803653,
0.0295571331,
-0.0771686137,
-0.4376663268,
0.1303170919,
0.5494929552,
0.7894288301,
0.5865356922,
-0.444901973,
-0.1426930726,
0.1674091965,
-0.6563456059,
-0.3422379494,
1.3987175226,
0.2740927637,
0.4157236814,
0.1741121411,
0.6527006626,
0.1152747497,
0.2823751569,
-0.3338593841,
0.1280295998,
0.0422766171,
-1.1879065037,
-0.3454552293,
-0.4988171756,
-1.10658288,
0.1009504646,
-0.3606992364,
-0.3433444202,
0.2608284652,
0.1845133305,
-0.7414160371,
0.0717929155,
-0.682040751,
0.8281786442,
-0.2087086141,
-0.3743501604,
-0.0813269317,
-0.8737745881,
0.0691534206,
-0.0588096231,
0.1219276935,
-0.002886065,
0.087924242,
0.6211553216,
-0.4419462085,
0.2756307721,
-0.1563451886,
0.1381145418,
0.4680983126,
-0.2319576889,
0.3084880114,
0.4186914265,
-0.2262508273,
-0.0806235597,
0.6050262451,
-0.6976625919,
-0.738357842,
0.5168081522,
-0.6238141656,
-0.8923599124,
-0.4544816017,
-0.2565951049,
-0.356808126,
0.3954886198,
0.18447496,
0.5029292107,
-0.4206043184,
0.4033991694,
0.9675906301,
-0.1913853586,
0.0338061154,
0.5409085155,
-0.0377487056,
-0.3218066096,
0.4181413054,
0.2429036498,
0.1895330846,
0.7856669426,
0.2493934184,
-0.3176248968,
-0.5934846401,
-0.3930136561,
0.190571472,
-0.572999835,
-0.2796843052,
-0.8906158209,
-0.2027805746,
-0.8185853362,
0.1527288705,
-0.03399086,
-0.517205596,
-0.3947690427,
-0.1913142055,
0.3397179544,
0.3701055348,
-0.0101971393,
-0.2725650072,
-1.0216161013,
0.5610303283,
0.6142570972,
0.4782670736,
-0.2664021552,
-0.2165681124,
-0.2075263411,
-0.0466648787,
-0.1802066267,
-1.0098974705,
0.0651059225,
0.2323348671,
0.6790218949,
0.4422793984,
0.5340899229,
0.5227797627,
-0.4440398514,
0.7090310454,
-0.210895136,
-0.369876653,
0.7818974257,
-0.2711170912,
0.6280754209,
0.9314177036,
0.9068151712,
-0.2537700534,
-0.1755695939,
-0.5484345555,
-0.8324840069,
0.0345510468,
0.2232806534,
-0.2809925079,
-0.2593563795,
0.3992021382,
0.2025339603,
0.2740355134,
-0.2140930593,
-0.0468786024,
-0.3272646666,
-0.071081087,
0.0536100864,
-0.1933562905,
-0.5052189231,
-0.1864626259,
0.5119364262,
-0.3298262656,
0.3665308356,
0.8384600878,
-0.0925710797,
-0.3334739506,
0.6684728861,
0.3714779317,
0.9231324792,
-0.5975317955,
0.1996769756,
-0.2154134065,
-0.6779444814,
0.1327074766,
0.2980391681,
-0.3148139119,
0.2122239918,
0.3656684458,
0.2014530748,
0.0362847932,
-0.8530275822,
0.5179467797,
-0.0541900694,
-0.2002271116,
0.0962474123,
-0.100480929,
0.1263293475,
0.1946744323,
0.5508244634,
-0.1587392986,
0.3822439313,
-0.5567939878,
0.5213208795,
0.3636827469,
-0.5095015168,
-0.1744145006,
0.8398378491,
0.3176777363,
-0.0342265293,
0.4990583658,
0.3636355102,
0.0301038418,
0.4170838296,
0.3210377097,
0.3743160367,
-0.0173720103,
0.4294271767,
0.3560527861,
0.2032624632,
-0.1334474087,
0.5822971463,
0.1921726018,
-0.3045378625,
-0.3836592734,
-0.37742275,
-0.5877802372,
0.1649476886,
-0.7629263401,
-0.308955431,
-0.2206550539,
-0.4777285457,
0.137873739,
0.2495422065,
-0.6897423267,
0.3630796075,
-0.3160493076,
1.1533139944,
-0.6619250178,
0.5896404982,
0.8539170623,
-0.5380949974,
-0.6393238902,
0.2296968251,
-0.0749467537,
-0.3646535575,
0.0927576721,
-0.0138035556,
0.1480909735,
-0.1056045592,
-0.4772055447,
-0.8423427939,
1.1937282085,
0.3168843687,
-0.2697474658,
-0.334341079,
-0.2182293683,
0.7394539714,
-0.2077930719,
0.4235429764,
0.3657005429,
0.4233916402,
-0.0735734627,
-0.8602963686,
0.0746064261,
-0.4002249539,
-0.4448255599,
0.0393476114,
-0.6054104567,
0.5450606942,
-0.4770185649,
-0.236189574,
-0.0295831226,
0.5148769021,
0.2227131277,
0.9062036276,
0.3840783238,
0.6245453954,
0.9745795131,
-0.153020218,
0.9634262323,
-0.1362991631,
-0.0408297107,
1.0482960939,
-0.3285179734,
0.8619889021,
0.6486718655,
-0.0719007924,
0.5551917553,
0.7222941518,
0.56766361,
0.7544389367,
0.0686782897,
-0.2932287455,
-0.2237929255,
-0.2571309507,
-0.6041710377,
0.0809533447,
0.2047289759,
-0.6066297293,
-0.2258390188,
0.053537216,
0.17612423,
0.0028620814,
-0.1728703231,
0.7576726675,
0.1334979832,
-0.8797652125,
0.3884097338,
-0.5310080051,
0.0708224401,
-0.4974704683,
-0.2326114327,
-0.333427906,
-0.2000789344,
-0.1483358145,
-0.7983992696,
0.3141187429,
-0.0858564824,
-0.4666057825,
-0.1822183579,
0.7128667831,
-0.2577105463,
-0.0804943889,
0.1423083395,
0.8949980736,
0.1267234832,
-0.1394261718,
-0.3654332757,
-0.1652653962,
-0.3446144462,
-0.3627111614,
0.3900670409,
0.6158699989,
0.0927892029,
0.4733166993,
0.7198926806,
0.3393103778,
-0.0402177237,
-0.3092224598,
0.9994820952,
-0.3825938106,
-0.2745767832,
-0.1711023003,
0.2484330982,
-0.3070873022,
-0.3465642929,
0.542139709,
0.4293635488,
0.7692973614,
0.0511205196,
0.5598652363,
-0.0531903803,
1.1150671244,
-0.4943110943,
0.8723543882,
-0.7760457993,
-0.0013213818,
-0.1819501072,
-0.4690132737,
-0.3082030714,
0.2155769467,
-0.2297240347,
-0.2515931129,
0.8914845586,
0.4667101502,
0.2149285525,
0.1421962231,
0.0219270494,
0.2925119698,
0.4517845213,
0.6530558467,
0.2563994527,
-0.5293848515,
0.5262931585,
-0.1343289912,
-0.1636557132,
-0.264752388,
-0.8306159377,
-0.4690867364,
-0.4547850192,
-0.2809441686,
-0.5400303602,
0.6477189064,
0.7971143126,
0.6680690646,
-0.8866672516,
0.4413764179,
0.3950923085,
0.2572229505,
-0.5657451153,
-0.1811378747,
0.3938596547,
-0.1380693913,
-0.3205932379,
0.4979215264,
0.1999696046,
-0.2964934707,
0.3090371788,
0.1709211022,
-0.6484615207,
0.0675476566,
0.4649321735,
0.6559206843,
-0.2569212615,
-0.474124819,
0.4884453118,
-0.2717164159,
0.3677451909,
0.8799267411,
-0.8680654764,
0.7474964857,
0.6923886538,
1.0960292816,
0.5010071993,
0.4242284,
0.6829488873,
-0.2268860489,
-0.6322106123,
0.5079970956,
0.1562211514,
0.1181175932,
-0.5363277793,
0.5785381198,
0.3407324255,
-0.7298305035,
-0.6121297479,
-0.1601924151,
-0.9032166004,
-0.5509596467,
0.8910155892,
-0.3677143157,
-0.233775124,
-0.5442126989,
0.0383184291,
0.176174432,
-0.3404073715,
0.9642355442,
0.6173482537,
-0.2607747614,
-0.1259503961,
-0.5894398093,
0.571829319,
0.4765332937,
-1.1211915016,
-0.0749716014,
0.64706707,
0.4286259413,
0.1085347757,
1.2023290396,
-0.4487498999,
0.6506895423,
-0.3498112857,
-0.4508477151,
0.0420197956,
-0.4769417942,
-0.1635054201,
0.4702653289,
-0.0188269559,
-0.1239304245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08354v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08354v3
|
Gaining More Insight into Neural Semantic Parsing with Challenging Benchmarks
| 2024-04-12T09:48:58 | 2024-05-07T21:15:40 |
Xiao Zhang, Chunliu Wang, Rik van Noord, Johan Bos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Parallel Meaning Bank (PMB) serves as a corpus for semantic processing
with a focus on semantic parsing and text generation. Currently, we witness an
excellent performance of neural parsers and generators on the PMB. This might
suggest that such semantic processing tasks have by and large been solved. We
argue that this is not the case and that performance scores from the past on
the PMB are inflated by non-optimal data splits and test sets that are too
easy. In response, we introduce several changes. First, instead of the prior
random split, we propose a more systematic splitting approach to improve the
reliability of the standard test data. Second, except for the standard test
set, we also propose two challenge sets: one with longer texts including
discourse structure, and one that addresses compositional generalization. We
evaluate five neural models for semantic parsing and meaning-to-text
generation. Our results show that model performance declines (in some cases
dramatically) on the challenge sets, revealing the limitations of neural models
when confronting such challenges.
|
[
-0.3462707102,
-0.6110418439,
0.6481122971,
0.2371815294,
-0.2902418077,
-0.1432870477,
-0.2504867613,
-0.4764244258,
-0.0315979272,
0.5274939537,
-0.6415033937,
-0.3719991148,
-0.7704473138,
0.2634154558,
-0.3089242578,
0.953805685,
0.1126490533,
0.0961795673,
-0.5738717914,
-0.1934136748,
-0.740558207,
-0.4202208817,
-0.490416944,
-0.451536864,
0.5445548892,
0.1442878246,
0.6616426706,
0.8758437037,
0.6855769753,
0.3344418108,
-0.3504869938,
0.1256801635,
-0.0721197948,
0.1912169009,
-0.5271277428,
-0.5029637814,
-0.3172552586,
-0.0701670349,
0.6383923292,
1.1777982712,
-0.0290341657,
0.0920230597,
-0.1914167851,
0.5613845587,
-0.6238779426,
0.2350015342,
-0.7159382701,
-0.1961505711,
-0.3187536001,
0.0952599123,
-0.4550556839,
0.0563325621,
0.2032982111,
-0.1585395038,
0.3665004373,
0.2211401612,
1.0341647863,
0.2552089989,
-0.4367040098,
-0.1534280181,
-0.3978912532,
0.8496229053,
-0.6247959733,
0.2066426873,
0.3448725939,
0.3535948694,
-0.0370153449,
-0.7278627753,
-0.5291948318,
-0.3038542867,
0.0314062238,
-0.0454176962,
-0.0482084639,
0.0360675827,
0.3183290958,
0.3261985481,
-0.3305478692,
0.0093087787,
-0.295598805,
-0.1626161784,
0.4073588252,
0.5287855268,
0.1321787089,
-0.5831864476,
-0.4905381799,
-0.4078710377,
-0.4287542105,
0.0595163405,
0.5348459482,
0.3622475564,
0.4573464096,
0.6247007251,
-0.2247471511,
0.8928184509,
-0.3809407353,
0.078091599,
0.1032116786,
-0.4429811239,
-0.1944940686,
-0.0571785606,
0.4830552042,
0.3016482592,
0.1314494163,
-0.2104688734,
-0.4247144461,
0.2893317044,
0.2823811471,
-0.7147853971,
-0.3093131483,
0.1384769082,
-0.5758856535,
-0.0597481988,
-0.1933559924,
-0.5752400756,
-0.2487185299,
-0.6196861863,
0.1862713993,
-0.7295786738,
-0.2824341953,
0.3365299106,
-0.4779630005,
0.3349882364,
0.1783957779,
-1.0981605053,
0.6307196617,
0.9743195176,
0.5750880241,
0.0155851208,
-0.3599074781,
-0.1878935248,
-0.0027119205,
-0.1045998409,
1.0402369499,
-0.5536642075,
-0.0980216935,
-0.3178329766,
-0.438418597,
-0.5821355581,
-0.8543922305,
0.5398648977,
-0.4920716584,
0.0101183783,
-0.6390844584,
-0.8015338778,
0.1040633991,
0.498675853,
-0.6190361381,
0.6165583134,
0.122262314,
-0.7196451426,
0.1474976838,
-0.4189765155,
-0.3250539899,
-0.1190752313,
-0.1720450073,
-0.01993775,
0.4198927581,
0.12374264,
0.243518874,
-0.6522617936,
0.4208503366,
-0.2691738009,
-0.0443856791,
0.2483907044,
-0.2514511645,
0.6529167295,
0.1025188118,
-0.2515200377,
0.0101859709,
-1.049176693,
0.163661465,
0.0776058361,
-0.1078978255,
-0.2896848321,
0.3559544981,
0.191205591,
0.3147225976,
0.1273976266,
-0.7425674796,
-0.2558283806,
-0.4449373186,
0.5109504461,
1.0452882051,
-0.3555619121,
0.2109942734,
-0.2622186244,
0.0829192698,
0.3653382659,
0.0038546501,
-0.2180387825,
-0.4564255476,
-0.8782464862,
-0.0969654322,
0.6739186645,
0.4338503778,
-0.3438754678,
0.3150678575,
-0.3389045894,
-0.1907829642,
-0.5877773166,
0.1493042111,
0.4772435427,
0.885661006,
0.6213440299,
-0.3329139352,
-0.2899274528,
-1.2712908983,
-0.377828747,
-0.1046019047,
-0.0758663714,
0.2912368178,
0.4535286725,
0.1257333457,
0.969681263,
-0.5590717196,
-0.0086176582,
-0.2461276501,
0.1790966541,
0.2187308073,
0.4762786031,
0.1491071135,
-0.9130836725,
0.0337726027,
-0.2666340172,
-0.5886058211,
-0.0724292547,
-0.0107065216,
-0.1136005819,
0.0535441786,
0.4207527637,
-0.804402709,
0.1385406405,
0.3946845233,
-0.501036942,
0.4980318546,
-0.0753182694,
-0.3938602805,
-1.0891137123,
-0.0706277266,
-0.2729961276,
-0.0814986378,
-0.3606572151,
0.0842573717,
0.1788965762,
-0.0375897437,
-0.2128718793,
0.2401904166,
-0.2250531316,
-0.0339194238,
-0.4805042744,
0.0944640934,
0.1095734462,
0.3582548797,
-0.0963194445,
0.197018519,
0.2310093194,
-0.3011278808,
0.5007889271,
0.3125557601,
-0.4816268981,
0.5104643703,
-0.7168821096,
0.1228731796,
-0.322614789,
0.146654889,
-1.0404856205,
-0.1615237594,
-0.0803239048,
-0.2905444205,
0.1660213768,
0.366968751,
-0.7310948968,
-0.1323856264,
0.0461034738,
0.5371774435,
0.468765676,
-0.5900384784,
0.5345109105,
-0.0358122252,
0.1215918809,
-0.4957710505,
-0.7311552167,
0.1648995429,
-0.0398477875,
-1.1877931356,
0.5498262644,
0.2436409146,
-0.4283489287,
0.3366329074,
-0.3106685281,
-0.0736606643,
0.1433432251,
0.0866783708,
0.2221874148,
-0.4456662536,
0.2579400539,
-0.1116621569,
-0.3504031301,
0.4019012451,
-0.3371875286,
0.4838492274,
-0.1431414783,
-0.1565996855,
-0.2118130475,
0.5468382835,
0.1051924229,
-0.483266443,
1.0448924303,
0.1460527778,
-0.2705884278,
-0.3601002097,
-0.5343433022,
-0.0148595804,
-0.4686858654,
0.2178666741,
-0.5652992725,
-0.8486915231,
0.4753147662,
-0.1259423047,
-0.1890266687,
0.504604876,
0.4618797004,
0.0002505889,
0.8227142096,
0.4408450723,
0.3495709598,
0.1190496907,
0.057715375,
0.2951954007,
-0.6702797413,
-0.183673948,
-0.48085922,
-0.4953130782,
-0.517056942,
-0.1973803341,
-0.1224391684,
0.0213847831,
0.0808629096,
0.3563937247,
-0.2650749683,
0.6372177005,
0.6532075405,
0.1878185868,
0.1390045732,
-0.3924577534,
-0.3830444217,
0.0331857093,
-0.4395470023,
-0.294445008,
1.0142862797,
0.1015997231,
0.2309368849,
-0.0541707128,
0.6552250385,
-0.2501669228,
0.1054767594,
-0.4830177128,
0.6862694621,
-0.2713504136,
-0.6358463764,
-0.0005749854,
-0.5068168044,
-0.7672348619,
0.5369204283,
0.1170469224,
-0.6119977832,
0.0737759173,
-0.1333498359,
-0.4075394571,
0.141519174,
-0.9578999877,
1.2091511488,
0.1501866877,
-0.2719264328,
-0.1435296983,
-0.8378171325,
0.5243273973,
0.0250783376,
-0.0253363941,
-0.4974675775,
-0.0768894032,
0.5975095034,
-0.7336782813,
0.6311503649,
-0.1590366066,
0.3196599185,
0.264242202,
-0.2619189322,
0.2941784561,
-0.0484119505,
0.0071828547,
-0.1021548212,
-0.002625617,
-0.8332742453,
-0.6446375847,
0.5885720253,
-0.6485738158,
-0.6678469777,
-0.3345275223,
-0.8619309068,
-0.4389549494,
0.1041618288,
0.109185487,
0.3467355371,
0.056407962,
0.1635138988,
0.5240589976,
-0.0687723607,
0.532592833,
0.0706921443,
0.1118361726,
-0.5044124126,
0.7358265519,
0.1271503121,
0.2761960626,
0.3795602322,
0.3050732911,
-0.3658902347,
-0.8212771416,
-0.2333036661,
0.1723653674,
-0.6759568453,
-0.0833866149,
-0.5655426383,
-0.0108420905,
-0.5843804479,
0.210735023,
-0.4079256058,
-0.5811824799,
-0.0563573427,
-0.1916777939,
-0.0277564712,
0.3414033055,
0.0546822101,
0.2664833069,
-0.7713882923,
0.2870374322,
0.2676884234,
0.193219319,
-0.0976056606,
-0.0937193856,
-0.1451758444,
-0.3014679253,
-0.3163861334,
-0.8666756749,
0.1668553501,
-0.0898054987,
0.2520914078,
0.1274341345,
-0.0616171882,
0.7387099266,
-0.6616594791,
0.6397785544,
0.0795462132,
-0.9999322295,
0.4026720524,
-0.3706698716,
0.4512600601,
0.673828423,
0.2511999905,
-0.4544707239,
-0.2296563089,
-0.7275848985,
-0.9396281838,
0.7697585821,
0.2692255378,
0.3666476607,
-0.298499763,
0.3457090855,
0.0612952225,
0.1423321813,
-0.4967797697,
-0.0514874384,
-0.1438300163,
-0.3333798647,
-0.1541399062,
-0.3508166671,
-0.0417115577,
-0.2518236935,
0.2754128873,
-0.0521227047,
0.0162171423,
0.0901843011,
-0.1323800385,
0.2390737832,
0.2251833975,
0.3782095015,
0.6378748417,
-0.15610829,
0.2865946889,
-0.143484652,
-0.1174794808,
-0.0299100932,
0.3607751131,
-0.0505293123,
-0.0315371193,
0.405685842,
0.9123805165,
0.3363527656,
-0.897367239,
0.5393694639,
-0.03102188,
-0.3692921996,
-0.1640727669,
0.0095421625,
0.3896382153,
0.3598818183,
-0.0787096769,
0.2836594582,
0.0030217224,
-0.3124963045,
0.2352894098,
0.1145925671,
0.0140144471,
-0.2955809534,
0.4997165203,
-0.0543403365,
-0.2415037155,
1.079990387,
-0.1442649812,
-0.3339775205,
0.6974970102,
0.6649433374,
0.8928737044,
-0.01659148,
0.0604749396,
0.1018950492,
0.2023749202,
-0.2052385509,
0.1377459913,
-0.3829064369,
-0.8392543793,
-0.650898397,
-0.9768029451,
-0.4560770988,
-0.0554721244,
-0.7754219174,
0.1896386445,
-0.6079390049,
-0.1898806691,
0.3766511977,
-0.2644194663,
-0.519910872,
0.2865206599,
0.2254127562,
0.9133919477,
-0.57614398,
0.760442853,
0.6087726355,
-0.2465444952,
-0.781021893,
-0.2280917764,
-0.2983140349,
-0.5438227057,
0.7709803581,
0.5263117552,
0.5306896567,
-0.1737906635,
-0.1315744221,
-0.8117669225,
0.7185723186,
0.5375540257,
-0.287471056,
-0.4227418005,
0.5675726533,
0.6469473839,
-0.1017735973,
0.2960424423,
0.8617118597,
0.4075798988,
0.0576639697,
-0.7071530223,
0.1548028737,
-0.3142772615,
0.2191159725,
0.4479420781,
-0.7792802453,
1.2539277077,
0.2581969798,
-0.0242796112,
0.143752709,
0.7686875463,
0.1614025831,
0.2873690724,
0.4698467553,
1.1116919518,
0.6397105455,
-0.1477157027,
1.1955964565,
0.1003474444,
0.1829530448,
1.2666344643,
-0.3119049072,
1.0027884245,
0.6339030862,
-0.0474032573,
0.5580000877,
0.6264370084,
-0.162651062,
0.4420108795,
0.589787364,
-0.2821370363,
-0.5183908939,
-0.1407422274,
-0.1173418313,
0.7512634397,
0.1050544381,
-0.5767616034,
-0.7888391018,
-0.0063049528,
-0.199730292,
0.3242973089,
-0.0966130793,
0.5127344728,
0.17703861,
-0.8047519326,
0.3887072504,
0.3329727054,
0.3106558621,
-0.5083824992,
0.1646790802,
-0.1226147637,
0.5325103998,
0.0847827122,
-0.2628799975,
0.7855271101,
-0.0163457971,
-0.3357219994,
-0.5380041003,
0.7729541659,
0.0555095673,
-0.4015182257,
0.4651398659,
0.5441222787,
0.0143934367,
-0.2986295521,
-0.6083338261,
-0.019937383,
-0.2474992722,
-0.4164257646,
0.6877449751,
0.406390965,
0.098925896,
0.1045371592,
0.6405027509,
-0.2229237258,
0.5233134031,
-0.0108539565,
0.8021261692,
-1.0569058657,
-0.2879222035,
-1.08641994,
0.2310602814,
-0.1606709808,
-0.6378068328,
0.6611586809,
0.4887217581,
1.1239478588,
0.1877375692,
0.2579494119,
-0.0668924451,
0.2814126313,
-0.5664414763,
0.407048732,
-0.4179580212,
0.1164390743,
-0.0775044933,
-0.9165689349,
-0.3456029594,
0.1447946727,
-0.4179598689,
-0.2360403687,
1.1466082335,
0.5617826581,
0.1289230585,
0.5089018941,
0.3756965995,
0.0280868728,
0.2378031462,
1.0035700798,
1.0361680984,
-0.5181280375,
0.6640278101,
-0.5111916065,
0.0419230945,
0.4420523942,
-0.6945039034,
-0.8759951591,
-0.316372782,
-0.1105777398,
-0.3991205394,
0.0308215357,
0.7159926295,
0.4483901858,
-0.5738281012,
-0.2554129064,
-0.5389372706,
-0.0090312194,
-0.2098082006,
-0.1847057492,
0.313439548,
-0.9141512513,
-0.8240829706,
0.4270587564,
0.1234592721,
-0.342835933,
0.1282196939,
0.3716474175,
-0.1699671447,
0.220195204,
0.3680829704,
-0.1107825264,
-0.5165768862,
-0.2850591242,
0.0124250269,
-0.1732832193,
0.0523479916,
0.8074328303,
-0.7070990205,
0.1530432999,
0.697380662,
1.272048831,
0.5432374477,
-0.074987106,
0.4218074381,
-0.5259569883,
0.0409688763,
0.4009345472,
0.448338151,
0.2731929719,
0.0296494272,
0.2624530196,
0.6471082568,
-0.3806210458,
-0.8308947086,
0.2016445547,
-0.9815214276,
-0.5191903114,
0.9350908995,
-0.1499446929,
-0.9295642376,
0.0989490673,
0.1804761738,
0.0370848402,
0.0390320159,
0.5763170719,
1.1837918758,
-0.3577743471,
0.0436714515,
-0.3832426071,
0.1855083853,
1.2116773129,
-0.6335227489,
0.0633583665,
0.5649225116,
0.2538156807,
0.3398704827,
0.4963051379,
-0.2151370943,
0.2554464936,
0.5075705051,
-0.3009274006,
-0.1270381212,
-0.355648011,
-0.2362435311,
0.7107207179,
-0.1325922608,
-0.1830213219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08345v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08345v1
|
FastSpell: the LangId Magic Spell
| 2024-04-12T09:21:29 | 2024-04-12T09:21:29 |
Marta Bañón, Jaume Zaragoza-Bernabeu, Gema Ramírez-Sánchez, Sergio Ortiz-Rojas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language identification is a crucial component in the automated production of
language resources, particularly in multilingual and big data contexts.
However, commonly used language identifiers struggle to differentiate between
similar or closely-related languages. This paper introduces FastSpell, a
language identifier that combines fastText (a pre-trained language identifier
tool) and Hunspell (a spell checker) with the aim of having a refined
second-opinion before deciding which language should be assigned to a text. We
provide a description of the FastSpell algorithm along with an explanation on
how to use and configure it. To that end, we motivate the need of such a tool
and present a benchmark including some popular language identifiers evaluated
during the development of FastSpell. We show how FastSpell is useful not only
to improve identification of similar languages, but also to identify new ones
ignored by other tools.
|
[
-0.3936099708,
-0.595980823,
-0.0094735613,
0.2923972309,
-0.2307023704,
0.4765818417,
-0.360563606,
-0.5496073961,
0.3178473711,
0.3522880077,
-0.2985623181,
-0.6059973836,
-0.7460387349,
0.3033187091,
-0.5015258193,
1.1042431593,
-0.1814469248,
-0.4227578044,
0.047034204,
-0.4835813642,
-0.2307537496,
-0.3830067813,
-0.5142903924,
-0.1962002069,
0.9979479909,
0.3769161999,
1.2173771858,
0.9569978714,
0.3864843547,
0.416967988,
0.0421919115,
0.4007124901,
-0.1904217899,
0.0462462828,
-0.3326268792,
-0.3767211735,
-0.1379895955,
0.0546102002,
0.3058532476,
0.5804591179,
-0.0521672256,
0.6132585406,
0.0286448877,
0.5389966965,
-0.8519871235,
-0.02158265,
-0.5949616432,
0.1204209849,
-1.0927408934,
-0.1497821212,
-0.255130887,
-0.8129857183,
0.1970267147,
-0.6125397086,
0.2408296168,
0.4920439124,
0.9339078665,
0.0717887878,
-0.4442591965,
-0.6610291004,
-0.7138825059,
0.7104204893,
-0.4387602508,
0.4006908536,
0.2083433121,
0.5913328528,
-0.0602588505,
-0.6982043982,
-0.8119366169,
0.0220431071,
-0.3271589279,
-0.4320383668,
0.2337233722,
-0.1153915897,
0.2816343009,
0.1660137028,
-0.7945867181,
0.2415425926,
-0.2884021103,
-0.6735718846,
0.4419988394,
-0.0383261032,
0.4826290905,
0.1142895669,
-0.0752451271,
0.0447520316,
-0.5844165087,
-0.2727044225,
0.5152368546,
0.523753345,
0.1140369773,
0.401085943,
0.0280186702,
0.6952698827,
-0.025239028,
-0.3998368382,
0.4814629555,
0.1250701398,
-0.1536671072,
0.2209315598,
0.7100996375,
0.0996410847,
0.6525339484,
-0.1180052981,
-0.029837491,
0.0017877982,
-0.1789836735,
-0.8127989173,
0.0080700014,
-0.0022791212,
-0.475905478,
-0.0537839681,
0.0052451915,
-0.8611764312,
-0.6630678773,
-0.2161289454,
0.2981803119,
-0.1812616736,
-0.4249862731,
-0.2534787059,
-0.0905832276,
-0.1007177979,
0.1674347073,
-0.8665602207,
0.4028319418,
0.9153513312,
0.5700891614,
-0.4144068062,
-0.9436078072,
-0.3686803579,
-0.0993879139,
-0.5032032132,
0.7366836071,
-0.3774828017,
-0.1349026561,
0.2831863463,
0.2426891923,
-0.1414685547,
-0.7944393158,
0.4863978922,
-0.7352343202,
0.2522667944,
0.0200188048,
-0.4831779003,
-0.0504942872,
-0.1015055329,
-0.906332314,
1.1693706512,
0.0552970283,
-0.8521981835,
0.6011177301,
-0.2470779866,
-0.8577061296,
0.4459320605,
0.1762041748,
-0.4850741327,
0.240670085,
-0.1750044376,
0.2472548932,
-0.4408240616,
0.0440165922,
-0.3229159415,
-0.5888307691,
0.2751688063,
-0.3416835368,
0.6745391488,
0.4873881638,
-0.3085780144,
-0.1864005029,
-0.8916369677,
0.3102865815,
0.0578764603,
-0.0598314293,
-0.8966016173,
0.0771250203,
0.1422564983,
0.1129074469,
0.4638243914,
-0.3245417476,
-0.027088942,
-0.5218363404,
-0.1090071425,
0.6135879755,
-0.3342560232,
0.2715329826,
0.1000499427,
0.4312867522,
-0.2986133397,
0.2723272741,
-0.0137675479,
-0.1592285037,
-0.5858163834,
-0.4346010685,
0.5634056926,
0.6574707031,
-0.6983783245,
0.2514947057,
-0.1052838862,
-0.6780019403,
-0.7738955021,
0.4567372501,
0.6666491032,
-0.0484895706,
0.0949216187,
-0.0925843045,
-0.6355348825,
-0.8946566582,
-0.9951152802,
0.1542447507,
0.220740065,
0.1217280626,
0.3010039032,
-0.2824271321,
0.7183651924,
-0.3368238807,
-0.2540869415,
-0.1374146938,
0.235561505,
0.4936913252,
0.0146602476,
0.5936623216,
-0.7517635822,
-1.0762027502,
0.2906075418,
-0.5348741412,
-0.1889449358,
0.2691352367,
-0.0356152281,
0.0325119644,
0.2189023942,
-0.3660856485,
0.4207294881,
0.6568679214,
-0.4657839835,
0.8001716733,
-0.4981336296,
0.4242565334,
-0.6132388115,
0.2000908405,
-0.0435801484,
0.345166713,
-0.7718348503,
0.2087078989,
0.2625881732,
-0.281236589,
-0.7235190272,
1.1393532753,
-0.5476933718,
-0.0099499533,
-0.3056700826,
0.0216423087,
-0.2399967909,
0.2088263929,
-0.1891475022,
1.0448745489,
0.4756934941,
-0.4550921023,
0.373919487,
0.1202974021,
-0.7535351515,
0.6436032057,
-0.3495076895,
0.1791847497,
-0.0716327354,
-0.0957731381,
-0.6481675506,
-0.0493542328,
-0.1879797131,
0.0114367995,
-0.0299429279,
-0.0814897716,
-0.6640722156,
-0.969537735,
0.0463020019,
0.5126569271,
0.4398100972,
-0.8801178932,
0.6065446138,
0.3900684416,
-0.150160864,
-0.8275935054,
-0.3922471404,
-0.0508223251,
-0.2913458347,
-0.2108741999,
0.2155982256,
-0.0625045523,
-0.4293952286,
-0.2121746689,
-0.061327897,
-0.7211614847,
0.1390862763,
0.4584889412,
0.0203672703,
-0.0879049376,
0.0638690218,
0.1846052557,
-0.329716444,
-0.3822034299,
-0.1035504118,
0.1412532479,
0.1392281651,
-0.4097841978,
-0.5583127141,
0.4678063095,
1.0956017971,
-0.4926228225,
0.5502003431,
0.5872458816,
-0.1834916919,
-0.6614935994,
-0.6171415448,
0.0439389311,
-0.5201678276,
0.1931043714,
-0.6693725586,
-0.5826506615,
0.4366257787,
-0.2742225826,
0.0951158851,
0.2763393521,
0.6030799747,
0.0341268703,
0.950992167,
0.5524970889,
-0.1683548093,
0.3581665456,
0.3803703487,
0.5676839352,
-0.1234844476,
0.0644335523,
-0.8395283818,
-0.2441349179,
-0.4355767965,
-0.1458838135,
-0.1007169411,
0.1308626235,
0.0214650184,
0.6648236513,
-0.5469702482,
0.6838153601,
0.6547005773,
-0.3246188462,
-0.0981304646,
0.088534683,
-0.425798744,
-0.3461035788,
-0.3017973006,
-0.3710761964,
0.749350369,
0.0124491891,
0.4580745995,
-0.0232658498,
0.7564812303,
0.6583860517,
0.5860525966,
-0.478574425,
0.7145106196,
-0.5286858678,
-0.7369868159,
-0.1149510294,
0.0575031638,
-1.0030099154,
0.5416376591,
-0.2070972025,
-0.3918810487,
-0.0274619013,
0.372677654,
-0.4221357703,
-0.0336353146,
-0.9187812209,
1.0795257092,
-0.4313776791,
-0.2942712307,
-0.3972207904,
-0.2157401294,
0.1068710014,
-0.2271844149,
0.7039294839,
-0.3868457377,
0.3465177417,
0.842954874,
-0.8140749931,
0.5894018412,
-0.2827506065,
-0.0313656814,
0.4942761362,
0.3365214765,
0.6230078936,
-0.5463362336,
-0.3156252503,
0.3073551357,
0.3550222516,
-0.1678978354,
-0.7421867251,
0.7836095095,
-0.5208185315,
-0.3328036964,
-0.3390323818,
-0.2241017967,
0.03452117,
0.4768604934,
-0.0895326436,
0.654301703,
-0.0737152547,
-0.1987987012,
0.3618052304,
-0.2859728336,
0.4399781823,
0.8976753354,
-0.2966122329,
-0.414768815,
1.2198687792,
0.1886330098,
-0.1530779898,
0.2802120745,
0.4576768875,
-0.2042241096,
-0.3276699185,
-0.2198033482,
0.4158712029,
-0.5713279843,
0.0926084593,
-0.2464756519,
-0.0139850806,
-0.2437594533,
-0.2210233957,
-0.3142366409,
-0.073823683,
0.1555700004,
0.1080670282,
0.2006054819,
0.3949782252,
0.0596635565,
0.1729667634,
-0.6504315734,
0.3732915521,
0.5518315434,
0.3440444171,
-0.1320598722,
-0.0755364001,
-0.4375849068,
-0.3528366983,
0.4748801291,
-0.8415685892,
0.2930503786,
0.3550002575,
0.6101709604,
0.5379248261,
0.0696927086,
0.8244835138,
-0.9700533152,
0.4717327058,
0.0489313975,
-0.8585674763,
0.3385714591,
0.2583301961,
0.2218239307,
0.6653727889,
0.4612571001,
-0.9197657108,
-0.4264581203,
-0.3071221709,
-0.5877668262,
0.116093494,
-0.3827023208,
-0.1446451098,
-0.4484607875,
0.1328996122,
0.4719901085,
0.3684673607,
-0.2904846966,
-0.3301680982,
0.1879510731,
-0.5161885023,
-0.077897191,
-0.4727321565,
-0.1156560853,
-0.0658537447,
0.3331066966,
-0.2740968466,
-0.057210777,
-0.4991950691,
-0.5608499646,
0.1721340269,
0.3886470497,
0.4133486152,
0.5282353163,
0.1664753556,
0.4036065936,
0.189198032,
-0.663477242,
0.0293980446,
0.1200054884,
-0.0762202516,
0.2491852343,
0.5855097175,
0.7145603895,
0.3855527341,
-0.7271782756,
0.6738678813,
0.2147634178,
-0.1442315876,
-0.0437867492,
-0.0220994614,
-0.583229661,
0.0659634694,
0.376116842,
0.0512947924,
-0.1057273597,
-0.3167932928,
0.2609373927,
0.4310715199,
-0.3076334596,
-0.439286679,
0.349216938,
0.5000501871,
-0.8897464275,
0.2396019995,
-0.1935214549,
-0.7685329318,
0.4650497139,
0.3689829111,
1.0082697868,
-0.5384066701,
0.1969272196,
0.1455696076,
0.2705745697,
-0.0278352778,
0.1646079272,
-0.2110724896,
-0.651681304,
-0.4903893173,
-0.7618074417,
-0.2075662464,
-0.4041875601,
-0.4479072392,
0.2822448909,
-0.3444982469,
-0.0735458359,
0.1167072058,
0.3000964522,
-1.0034912825,
0.2265723944,
0.1224051714,
1.0702767372,
-1.2628488541,
1.3507096767,
0.2316360623,
0.2814097703,
-0.602730453,
-0.1629295349,
0.4325876534,
-0.7739504576,
1.0414835215,
0.0836868063,
-0.2588998675,
-0.0228360333,
0.0040552579,
-0.8461377621,
0.747146666,
-0.1664745957,
-0.7007756233,
0.2160004675,
0.080257073,
0.6325508356,
-0.1109562889,
0.5566066504,
0.7953035235,
0.870003581,
-0.1731345356,
-1.3026564121,
-0.077437982,
-0.1004621461,
-0.0103115542,
0.3857061565,
-0.1829487979,
0.6320791245,
-0.3526566029,
-0.6404469013,
0.2632237077,
0.6161757708,
0.0551756285,
0.4001910985,
0.8070607781,
0.2490506321,
1.0453213453,
-0.1140199974,
0.7731740475,
-0.5500398278,
0.2096407413,
1.078106761,
-0.7654348016,
0.841082871,
0.3968225718,
-0.3000365198,
0.6063948274,
0.3788197339,
0.1204677522,
0.7286069393,
0.3142057061,
-0.2596251369,
0.2465206236,
0.0351506285,
-0.298712343,
0.0886505023,
0.3971523345,
-0.1016014814,
-0.2783115804,
0.4331072867,
0.2707984447,
0.415663451,
-0.1219195873,
0.4844398797,
-0.3557843566,
-0.8438873291,
0.571228981,
-0.1820877939,
0.7956982851,
-0.7568926811,
0.199295029,
-0.2137687653,
0.6095809937,
-0.1841000915,
-0.6398581266,
0.3002010882,
-0.3193615079,
-0.1477088928,
-0.3184092343,
0.5855383277,
-0.7660076618,
-0.1149664968,
0.3053649068,
0.3557898402,
0.1892282218,
0.1972612441,
-0.834859252,
0.4421939552,
-0.3036030829,
-0.0406975858,
0.1114800796,
0.5263751745,
-0.2322157472,
0.6482765079,
0.5803416967,
0.3221339583,
0.2315339148,
0.2916990221,
0.1097668558,
-0.4550667703,
-0.5957769156,
-0.807790637,
0.117295593,
-0.1679778695,
-0.5173203945,
1.2234377861,
0.5080202222,
0.3510726094,
-0.2318091393,
0.6492422819,
-0.1773418039,
1.1974803209,
-0.0801741704,
0.7529423833,
-0.4189954698,
-0.2785658538,
-0.2794495821,
-0.9145244956,
-0.5347443223,
0.2490396649,
-0.1570043117,
-0.4697039127,
1.2531679869,
1.0109937191,
0.1572353989,
-0.074664019,
0.3693835437,
0.1615514159,
0.093149215,
0.1772920936,
0.5514300466,
-0.198741436,
0.484011054,
-0.1679497212,
-0.2782149613,
-0.3893871605,
-0.9412246346,
-1.0208580494,
-0.6801990271,
-0.4946262538,
-0.4680807292,
0.3866027296,
0.9042723775,
0.8109773397,
-1.001647234,
-0.4109939635,
0.4327810407,
0.5184610486,
-0.9238847494,
-0.1533864588,
0.5307360291,
-0.0912283808,
-0.805414319,
0.4883688688,
0.4016509354,
-0.0409516022,
-0.3217836022,
-0.0963141248,
0.0322658196,
0.1437942833,
0.5706490874,
0.9100648761,
-0.8197524548,
-0.3080587685,
-0.3319217265,
-0.3109004796,
-0.571197331,
1.0810194016,
-0.7041773796,
0.4784192443,
0.3651701808,
0.5305603147,
0.2418805659,
-0.4494111836,
0.3766876459,
-0.5174111724,
0.6160903573,
-0.1225537956,
0.1082386374,
0.011080225,
0.0774367377,
0.1649082601,
0.2943352163,
-0.4236778319,
-0.7882845998,
0.1081372797,
-0.249839291,
-0.1729012132,
0.946587503,
-0.0007109796,
-0.5571803451,
-0.290718168,
-0.2170938402,
-0.3934758902,
0.0831802562,
0.4470176399,
0.6303229928,
0.5892374516,
-0.0458935425,
-0.3492305577,
0.8282960057,
0.1720178425,
-0.6805475354,
0.0805726498,
0.2320242822,
0.3896819651,
0.2801809311,
0.6096214056,
0.2327548265,
0.1686978042,
-0.3081765473,
0.3071615696,
0.1197781488,
-0.6117599607,
0.1363679618,
0.6675370932,
0.0269552283,
-0.2093731314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08335v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08335v1
|
Toward a Theory of Tokenization in LLMs
| 2024-04-12T09:01:14 | 2024-04-12T09:01:14 |
Nived Rajaraman, Jiantao Jiao, Kannan Ramchandran
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
While there has been a large body of research attempting to circumvent
tokenization for language modeling (Clark et al., 2022; Xue et al., 2022), the
current consensus is that it is a necessary initial step for designing
state-of-the-art performant language models. In this paper, we investigate
tokenization from a theoretical point of view by studying the behavior of
transformers on simple data generating processes. When trained on data drawn
from certain simple $k^{\text{th}}$-order Markov processes for $k > 1$,
transformers exhibit a surprising phenomenon - in the absence of tokenization,
they empirically fail to learn the right distribution and predict characters
according to a unigram model (Makkuva et al., 2024). With the addition of
tokenization, however, we empirically observe that transformers break through
this barrier and are able to model the probabilities of sequences drawn from
the source near-optimally, achieving small cross-entropy loss. With this
observation as starting point, we study the end-to-end cross-entropy loss
achieved by transformers with and without tokenization. With the appropriate
tokenization, we show that even the simplest unigram models (over tokens)
learnt by transformers are able to model the probability of sequences drawn
from $k^{\text{th}}$-order Markov sources near optimally. Our analysis provides
a justification for the use of tokenization in practice through studying the
behavior of transformers on Markovian data.
|
[
-0.2218761146,
-0.5733504891,
0.5504036546,
-0.1958436966,
-0.4506059587,
-0.0437390693,
-0.2335314453,
-0.2136389464,
0.1628075391,
0.3381779492,
-0.4144990742,
-0.2732001841,
-0.6891614795,
-0.1243911535,
-0.7560238838,
1.0452717543,
0.0310868379,
0.1919979453,
0.0853688344,
0.1337815672,
-0.3314994872,
-0.8180701733,
-0.5471820235,
-0.4404378235,
0.5962990522,
0.1971524358,
0.6733836532,
0.7378298044,
0.3662434518,
0.260430485,
-0.0110668568,
-0.2935696542,
-0.4493661523,
0.1741774529,
0.0555161387,
-1.0992625952,
-0.0769444928,
0.1114182249,
0.6757746339,
0.9622926712,
-0.2247586399,
0.1675513536,
-0.0381866172,
0.3495172262,
-0.1943932474,
0.048549775,
-0.9681952,
0.2498841435,
-0.4867225885,
-0.4820863307,
-0.6781698465,
0.1404138505,
-0.2836219668,
-0.2680404186,
0.3334756196,
0.2758782506,
0.5824669003,
0.1411120445,
-0.4470512271,
-0.1786170006,
-1.0377596617,
0.8228154778,
-0.6167792082,
0.4623031616,
0.2353662699,
0.2972213626,
-0.2612511516,
-0.8420755863,
-0.6707653999,
-0.1327283829,
-0.0926094651,
-0.0319234692,
-0.4211505651,
0.1117070541,
0.284360677,
0.3284146786,
-0.114478901,
0.3324485421,
-0.4472649693,
-0.1746980101,
0.1518102288,
0.5373765826,
0.2384925634,
-0.3238232136,
-0.5530498028,
0.018782435,
-0.7018902302,
0.1489109546,
0.5025823712,
0.4571759701,
0.0188138653,
0.9497427344,
0.2990441024,
0.3037121892,
0.0590348803,
0.0866251141,
-0.1838657558,
-0.3776758313,
-0.2605285347,
-0.0618451796,
0.6096890569,
0.0786142498,
0.390933603,
-0.5327953696,
-0.3843944073,
0.1825931072,
0.3842234313,
-0.6309921741,
-0.1645249128,
0.1731521636,
-0.6563155055,
-0.4978679419,
0.1932546049,
-0.3042377234,
-0.1412788033,
-0.358451277,
0.3335523009,
-0.3340958357,
-0.1810942143,
-0.0521574244,
-0.128992185,
0.2395946085,
-0.0560001731,
-1.1035480499,
0.3735580444,
0.7450516224,
0.825538218,
-0.5201610327,
-0.416595459,
-0.3654423654,
0.2611862719,
-0.3703380823,
0.7722042799,
-0.5733485222,
-0.4700714052,
-0.0490958653,
-0.0658644736,
-0.0825763121,
-0.3393860757,
0.2670298815,
-0.637067616,
0.0160387382,
-0.0107934372,
-0.7048515081,
0.1178630963,
-0.1441836208,
-0.5206858516,
0.8731837273,
-0.0481121279,
-0.8783131242,
0.6935064793,
-0.5957092047,
-0.3710562289,
-0.2066467255,
-0.0339673348,
-0.230621919,
0.6728664041,
-0.1933780164,
0.5391837358,
-0.225394398,
0.3922365606,
-0.1565444767,
-0.4782144725,
0.6747579575,
-0.7877222896,
0.6454583406,
0.1989894509,
-0.3343689144,
0.0863866955,
-0.7674403191,
-0.1316397488,
0.0958904251,
-0.5434516668,
-0.2341179103,
0.1836667657,
0.205744192,
0.0854679719,
-0.2087763995,
-0.5194672942,
0.3017865717,
-0.4954539835,
0.3843306899,
1.1240483522,
-0.0675304085,
0.8458474874,
-0.3088746965,
0.5213964581,
0.4709522724,
0.2222266197,
-0.3610593379,
-0.4696912467,
-1.0100567341,
-0.3042812943,
0.4407748282,
0.3014501333,
-0.5390063524,
0.3243937492,
-0.1888566613,
-0.2927718163,
-0.347892344,
-0.1367873847,
-0.0129207326,
0.298256278,
0.2368061841,
-0.4384593666,
-0.7978307605,
-0.7556299567,
-0.3607281744,
-0.4281219542,
-0.2747828662,
-0.0843377113,
0.2623583674,
-0.3720984161,
1.1391384602,
-0.2121125162,
-0.0851470754,
-0.3240109086,
0.0778718591,
0.4866356552,
0.5929425955,
0.1457176805,
-0.4462885857,
-0.0759790018,
-0.1093217656,
-0.4840938747,
0.0389609672,
-0.1919878423,
0.0615908839,
0.4824346006,
0.5836020708,
-0.8108463287,
0.6859278083,
0.257245034,
-0.2786387503,
0.4071880877,
-0.1516419649,
-0.3627806902,
-1.2829781771,
0.0763611794,
-0.1980011165,
-0.255451411,
-0.9842313528,
-0.1491058618,
-0.3423740864,
0.0038994499,
-0.4887940884,
0.4951674044,
-0.3090863824,
-0.2598162591,
-0.3284190297,
-0.2374677658,
-0.3752990663,
0.6158694029,
-0.1177677065,
0.5213034153,
0.6159514189,
-0.6701791286,
0.0305729751,
-0.072351642,
-0.3243298531,
0.4264189303,
-0.655156374,
-0.0296052117,
-0.2918082178,
0.1719295681,
-1.1212935448,
0.0712567046,
0.4133404493,
-0.4940421879,
0.4664031863,
-0.3661154509,
-0.6969518661,
-0.0432966053,
-0.0588832982,
0.5768431425,
0.8364992142,
-0.5923959613,
0.5653145313,
0.4794919193,
0.3177811503,
-0.392095387,
-0.7945159674,
0.1626116037,
-0.4366842508,
-0.4209394157,
0.2279494107,
-0.0767034739,
-0.2206182331,
-0.1355169117,
-0.0078590931,
0.139646858,
0.220885396,
0.3576405048,
0.2503736615,
-0.0819566026,
0.208788693,
-0.2559292018,
-0.5319989324,
0.1827791184,
-0.5219450593,
0.7147846818,
0.0739892125,
-0.6510157585,
-0.456479013,
0.0688571259,
0.4142720103,
0.2873852849,
0.8691741228,
0.7755591869,
-0.3986610174,
-0.2468929887,
-0.3488763869,
-0.3137284815,
-0.5108002424,
0.2129213214,
-0.4774908721,
-0.7697866559,
0.7653723359,
-0.0440624394,
-0.0069463728,
0.5167763233,
0.8286816478,
-0.242032975,
0.9876343012,
0.7345929742,
-0.0051381337,
0.5034220219,
-0.3852567971,
0.4706456959,
-0.7069174051,
-0.2963285446,
-0.3930777013,
-0.3762355745,
-0.8856500983,
-0.6046514511,
0.3009018004,
0.1499640197,
-0.0584794246,
0.3037858009,
-0.2457373142,
0.5021303892,
0.6323530078,
-0.3086336851,
0.3255540133,
0.2469757497,
-0.438613236,
-0.0409700572,
-0.9482924938,
-0.5288661122,
1.1062577963,
0.4721286297,
1.034870863,
-0.0064368579,
0.8259162903,
0.3912035823,
0.3015603721,
-0.8098651171,
0.5007546544,
0.1755079776,
-0.572514534,
-0.4727734327,
-0.3400036991,
-1.3056231737,
0.2080911547,
-0.1007896885,
-0.8078950644,
0.2003438771,
0.0291986,
0.1103361323,
0.75614959,
-0.4839700758,
0.5968872309,
0.0161849838,
0.1226461157,
-0.1022360697,
-0.5795837641,
0.4536007941,
-0.2299338132,
0.2308107764,
-0.0193885043,
-0.2203579992,
0.6878452301,
-0.6297301054,
1.0587762594,
-0.1934656799,
-0.0543609969,
0.3734787107,
0.173523277,
0.6635776162,
-0.0292656235,
0.1627044231,
0.335370183,
0.0226509571,
-0.5324985385,
-0.5623142123,
0.3287861347,
-0.6813027263,
-0.4793421924,
-0.3973324895,
-0.377248913,
0.0150847584,
0.0662679002,
0.4581430256,
0.3437463939,
-0.1622572988,
-0.1996282935,
0.291977793,
-0.0116806515,
0.7130888104,
0.2835254073,
-0.3045853972,
-0.2667993009,
0.9532349706,
0.2064424455,
0.2660222948,
0.1850987524,
0.1539409459,
-0.2524269223,
-0.6420546174,
-0.3556351662,
0.1639684439,
-0.9412459135,
-0.181837827,
-0.4700562954,
-0.2461116463,
-0.0405380838,
0.0208693296,
-0.2712273002,
-0.7117141485,
-0.5138356686,
-0.2562369704,
0.1019039601,
0.8225538135,
-0.1875086278,
0.4029644132,
-0.8139258027,
0.1059857607,
0.1636278629,
0.3786112368,
0.3834220767,
-0.8151538968,
-0.449362725,
-0.1098796502,
-0.1386554539,
-0.6518647075,
0.2032074481,
-0.099921234,
0.6568507552,
0.493404448,
-0.141329363,
0.6842328906,
-0.8348833323,
0.8120492697,
0.355014354,
-1.1573258638,
-0.0005346927,
-0.2635145783,
-0.0389039367,
0.3149921,
0.1021560654,
-0.8679774404,
-0.4966452718,
-0.8132464886,
-0.8061175942,
0.6665967703,
0.3957439661,
0.556671679,
-0.2957211137,
0.2393532991,
0.3457504511,
0.2236977816,
-0.7192072272,
-0.4145777822,
-0.1138564572,
-0.1077996343,
-0.1441816539,
-0.2582511306,
0.2634700537,
-0.2172868699,
0.575755477,
-0.0523736253,
0.6362066865,
-0.1788204014,
-0.2668144405,
-0.2657503188,
0.2329630107,
0.6145555973,
0.510532558,
0.0428303853,
0.4933094382,
0.1175916046,
-0.1451868862,
0.3242456913,
-0.3456034064,
-0.2282740772,
0.1761022508,
0.2743372917,
0.8327621818,
0.2712196112,
-0.3899382651,
0.4916768372,
0.0189583581,
0.2086767554,
-0.314435482,
-0.04354522,
0.0245645549,
0.341486305,
0.5655327439,
0.2689831257,
-0.0950520113,
-0.6730036139,
0.4472304881,
0.6918331385,
-0.3784178793,
-0.7692618966,
0.8073151708,
-0.0947227851,
-0.5490150452,
0.6650799513,
0.0044079679,
-0.3952969611,
0.4969941974,
0.6417202353,
1.0027195215,
0.0497651659,
0.1097370014,
0.1040890813,
0.448160857,
-0.1042370647,
-0.0297409352,
-0.1210068017,
-0.7417120934,
-0.3848639429,
-0.7604042292,
-0.2049822658,
-0.2873361707,
-0.455809623,
0.3004301488,
-0.3524595797,
-0.4662303627,
-0.1913172007,
-0.4983764589,
-0.7256532907,
-0.1270766258,
0.2267921865,
0.7997320294,
-0.8782740831,
0.8170734644,
0.1934878081,
-0.3298921883,
-0.5237832069,
0.112269409,
-0.3561738133,
-1.1740809679,
0.7543360591,
0.0744762719,
0.2025275528,
0.0434662886,
-0.4173540175,
-1.0104862452,
0.9656767845,
0.2796889246,
-0.0981829986,
-0.1317047328,
0.5648311973,
0.6278887987,
-0.3590970933,
0.1681493968,
0.541377306,
0.3986111581,
0.0587826744,
-0.6099302173,
-0.0207513385,
-0.0755828246,
0.2787234783,
0.5080937743,
-0.4058211744,
0.8756147623,
-0.3949363828,
-0.6085309386,
0.16466555,
0.7087054849,
0.0213647727,
0.2279088795,
0.4414438903,
0.4773454964,
0.5096075535,
-0.0245564021,
1.0783121586,
-0.3157074451,
0.4445319474,
0.6782515049,
-0.0340000167,
0.7249037027,
1.0577242374,
-0.4923239946,
0.4009732902,
0.5284513235,
-0.082909517,
0.4846475422,
0.5840539932,
0.0078791212,
-0.1810177863,
-0.1311040223,
0.1626657844,
0.3431343436,
-0.0079258224,
-0.476116389,
-0.0790487379,
0.0593670011,
-0.1750719249,
-0.3307924569,
-0.2123276293,
0.7487184405,
0.2863590717,
-0.3145496845,
0.5359302163,
0.2879441082,
0.6414681077,
-0.4033594429,
0.2512435913,
-0.2407184243,
-0.157483086,
-0.0914776102,
-0.4554427564,
0.4140574038,
0.0789480656,
-0.2491014004,
-0.3272390068,
0.6459675431,
-0.2970736921,
-0.7391350269,
0.0478581749,
0.5954123735,
0.4116833806,
0.3739844561,
-0.2689833641,
-0.0884520859,
-0.2524254024,
-0.4818454683,
0.4869551361,
0.3554728627,
0.0488517992,
0.5992688537,
0.8330934644,
0.1716358364,
0.3863839805,
0.0700342506,
0.6183765531,
-0.7346595526,
-0.4367821515,
-1.1988984346,
0.7194748521,
0.3256037533,
0.0242917724,
0.5301273465,
0.5710221529,
0.9187301397,
-0.0979466662,
0.6525372863,
0.165600419,
0.1308852285,
-0.6521264911,
0.5052528381,
-0.3026976585,
0.4129886925,
-0.0433194228,
-1.0041501522,
-0.3558358848,
0.3046947718,
0.1759041101,
0.0936710387,
0.7062668204,
0.7736990452,
-0.1727564782,
-0.188490808,
0.6359124184,
0.0807306543,
0.2640071809,
0.3364842832,
1.0400521755,
-0.5131066442,
0.5177178383,
-0.077436313,
0.2328863889,
-0.0751098469,
-0.7108564973,
-1.0887262821,
-0.7956165671,
0.113135919,
-0.309358269,
-0.2669781744,
0.9391286969,
0.4214739203,
-0.6269699335,
-0.3796288073,
-0.2891553044,
0.1963971853,
0.0610908642,
-0.1960663795,
0.2481078804,
-0.5728827119,
-0.6611955166,
0.2616255283,
0.3414827883,
0.4444126487,
-0.5279626846,
-0.1756023467,
0.1996438503,
0.4980270267,
0.4258907437,
0.0526479445,
-0.8430772424,
-0.3395463824,
0.038619101,
-0.0769897103,
0.3718772531,
1.2607290745,
-0.8451474905,
0.1512164772,
0.3663168848,
0.6135920882,
0.5810655951,
-0.1431635469,
0.5597711205,
-0.8265432715,
0.0594864227,
-0.0179115534,
0.468847096,
0.1641989797,
-0.1915952712,
0.4365355968,
0.4922524691,
-0.3311747015,
-1.2349047661,
0.4254937768,
-0.7192023993,
-0.1467430294,
0.9744217396,
0.2304692119,
-0.1958385557,
0.0265336242,
0.0183028746,
0.5338513255,
-0.1654642522,
0.9148232341,
0.6782213449,
-0.1308748126,
-0.0070887897,
-0.1730006039,
0.4340410233,
0.5618540645,
-0.5350093246,
0.1906799972,
-0.0306744166,
0.2523460686,
0.0454118364,
0.5916604996,
0.0709217042,
0.0122507066,
-0.1283981502,
-0.1196020991,
0.0324206166,
-0.2264957279,
-0.609993577,
0.1029279307,
0.2885513902,
-0.0380345769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08313v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08313v1
|
The Integration of Semantic and Structural Knowledge in Knowledge Graph Entity Typing
| 2024-04-12T08:17:44 | 2024-04-12T08:17:44 |
Muzhi Li, Minda Hu, Irwin King, Ho-fung Leung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The Knowledge Graph Entity Typing (KGET) task aims to predict missing type
annotations for entities in knowledge graphs. Recent works only utilize the
\textit{\textbf{structural knowledge}} in the local neighborhood of entities,
disregarding \textit{\textbf{semantic knowledge}} in the textual
representations of entities, relations, and types that are also crucial for
type inference. Additionally, we observe that the interaction between semantic
and structural knowledge can be utilized to address the false-negative problem.
In this paper, we propose a novel \textbf{\underline{S}}emantic and
\textbf{\underline{S}}tructure-aware KG \textbf{\underline{E}}ntity
\textbf{\underline{T}}yping~{(SSET)} framework, which is composed of three
modules. First, the \textit{Semantic Knowledge Encoding} module encodes factual
knowledge in the KG with a Masked Entity Typing task. Then, the
\textit{Structural Knowledge Aggregation} module aggregates knowledge from the
multi-hop neighborhood of entities to infer missing types. Finally, the
\textit{Unsupervised Type Re-ranking} module utilizes the inference results
from the two models above to generate type predictions that are robust to
false-negative samples. Extensive experiments show that SSET significantly
outperforms existing state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
-0.3097121418,
-0.7101029158,
0.5773146152,
0.062148083,
-0.2168997973,
0.4115940034,
0.1411578208,
-0.4605948031,
0.9002087712,
0.3666586578,
-0.1695913076,
-0.9676811099,
-0.5634537935,
-0.0278358124,
-0.2579958439,
0.6758021116,
-0.2672243714,
-0.1420284808,
-0.292075634,
-0.1263580322,
-0.3838564157,
-0.2170368135,
-0.2544784546,
-0.225900501,
0.4921897352,
0.1968197823,
0.5268935561,
0.5246505141,
0.2159317881,
0.2008752674,
0.0028578208,
0.1393379271,
-0.3385493457,
0.0738476664,
-0.2568523884,
-0.5430612564,
-0.6423982978,
-0.056766443,
0.5604088902,
0.6849048734,
0.0371533409,
0.0647675246,
-0.0903831944,
0.6112092137,
-0.4658668637,
0.4076963365,
-0.9183200598,
0.3316110075,
-0.350468576,
-0.3377185464,
-0.5266093016,
-0.3068898916,
0.0161176194,
-0.7695996165,
0.1663071662,
0.1304308027,
0.8464682102,
0.4162452817,
-0.9016119242,
-0.1662276685,
-0.3298921585,
0.1696266532,
-0.3415095806,
0.7147234082,
0.5239536762,
0.2474021465,
-0.1680270135,
-0.4286877513,
-0.314897716,
-0.2673529685,
-0.2185145468,
0.3689085543,
0.1313307732,
0.3514989913,
-0.0547335483,
0.2720027268,
-0.4444126189,
0.1421757042,
-0.4209803939,
-0.581656754,
0.2240352184,
-0.2502400875,
0.4989625514,
-0.577868402,
-0.2443229407,
0.3261477053,
-0.9661195278,
-0.2247431278,
0.2834984362,
0.4544469118,
-0.0611581914,
1.0529356003,
-0.3566733003,
0.6348881125,
0.0758612528,
0.0488328747,
0.4400630891,
-0.1087873653,
-0.3466456831,
0.2425603718,
0.3502243459,
0.0520899147,
0.049379576,
-0.6736151576,
0.025824124,
0.5221713185,
0.2432165444,
-0.5610824823,
-0.2470906228,
0.3571102321,
-0.2988086641,
-0.4930439293,
-0.3692330122,
-0.5549404025,
-0.3796857595,
-0.1700237542,
0.7950295806,
-0.6950320005,
-0.5264440775,
-0.2499012947,
-0.6309043765,
-0.2064911574,
0.1657239199,
-0.4823298752,
-0.1548877954,
0.4465595186,
0.7184337378,
0.2522183359,
0.0052670129,
-0.5181819797,
0.6525346041,
-0.2448082864,
0.8139646649,
-0.7042216063,
-0.3355293572,
-0.140267238,
-0.3531824946,
-0.3132005036,
-0.1251247227,
0.4650821984,
-0.8550438285,
-0.0331600569,
-0.2575648427,
-0.934682548,
-0.3438866436,
0.513358295,
-0.6371403933,
1.0166867971,
0.511672616,
-1.0853625536,
0.6129792929,
-0.6752761602,
-0.6429111362,
0.242017895,
-0.3287228048,
-0.3878240585,
-0.0182589088,
-0.0619218312,
0.4788699448,
0.0520440601,
0.1050221622,
-0.9751236439,
-0.0571357459,
-0.186207369,
0.3229928315,
0.4867952466,
-0.1673579365,
-0.2449113578,
-0.3236972094,
-1.1633538008,
0.2191271484,
-0.0865366012,
-0.2599614263,
-0.7693386674,
-0.090532735,
-0.6797908545,
0.2078436315,
0.1121019796,
-0.9140725732,
0.1494226307,
-0.3774877489,
0.5516216159,
0.7212557197,
0.2346833646,
0.4262571335,
0.0821401849,
0.3567131162,
0.1102290601,
-0.2092296928,
0.5800822377,
-0.3222424686,
-0.5765790939,
-0.4516305923,
0.3253309429,
0.5930616856,
-1.382617116,
0.3074662387,
-0.4294964373,
-0.8689123988,
-0.1277267337,
-0.1341281384,
0.5999472141,
0.9006723166,
0.6641134024,
-0.0400076471,
-0.4830114543,
-0.7392637134,
-0.4898543656,
-0.2187773734,
0.13173756,
0.4342105687,
0.5030002594,
-0.1821319312,
1.0287531614,
-0.7507417798,
-0.3314415514,
-0.0863876343,
0.2429417968,
-0.1138616279,
0.5196083188,
0.4856158793,
-0.9588122964,
-0.5421201587,
-0.0368385278,
-0.8145512342,
0.2003445029,
0.3878912628,
-0.3807186186,
0.0495121069,
0.2153668404,
-0.7964578867,
0.4649428427,
0.4080968797,
-0.5540009737,
0.6700513363,
0.1653179824,
0.0509714037,
-1.2937790155,
-0.1882444024,
-0.010741991,
-0.0926680416,
-0.5836889744,
-0.1403227746,
0.2313270569,
-0.2197021842,
-0.1019497141,
0.4895726442,
-0.3205106258,
-0.3589724302,
0.2706466913,
0.3553979099,
0.1209948361,
0.6866307259,
0.190455243,
0.4778109193,
0.5480340719,
-0.7500686049,
0.0330813564,
0.5363509655,
-0.0020340215,
0.8761020303,
-0.4180691838,
0.0364344046,
-0.2838307619,
0.2355121672,
-1.0686210394,
-0.3013507128,
0.2065136582,
-0.7254688144,
0.5527178049,
-0.7296333909,
-0.2851783037,
-0.6194376349,
-0.2509644032,
0.2477098852,
-0.0242301971,
-0.2581171989,
1.1519277096,
0.3334421217,
0.1332841665,
-0.6523076296,
-0.8526688814,
-0.0831479281,
-0.1347731501,
-0.8462092876,
0.4409400821,
0.2613434196,
0.2241967171,
0.5778568387,
-0.4759903848,
-0.3951511681,
0.2295957655,
0.273855865,
0.389452219,
-0.456240207,
0.5172632933,
0.5136424899,
-0.2765236795,
-0.2997011244,
-0.6704086065,
0.3161919415,
0.0600274615,
-0.5621834397,
-0.1735500395,
-0.1746698916,
0.5087935328,
-0.3216332197,
0.6698215604,
0.4599126577,
-0.4510370493,
-0.0336003862,
-0.4887849689,
0.0721638352,
-0.4387390614,
0.6511777043,
-0.6474032998,
-0.9127762318,
0.449118495,
0.0465739816,
-0.2333354205,
0.5968838334,
0.0848163292,
-0.1352879256,
0.5738494992,
0.4168946445,
0.1739487797,
0.2988313735,
-0.232565701,
0.4423251152,
-0.8598423004,
-0.0319268554,
-0.4261620045,
-0.0937667042,
-0.7234218717,
-0.1831209958,
0.510224402,
0.0603428259,
-0.3194970489,
0.828325212,
-0.3194422126,
0.1943703145,
0.42448318,
0.3029173911,
0.1694950014,
0.017769305,
-0.678212285,
0.0944530964,
-0.6574849486,
-0.0052735624,
1.2166669369,
0.0288499035,
0.2294920236,
0.043481186,
1.0390392542,
0.6017733216,
0.494655937,
-0.7349523902,
0.5257171392,
-0.1957022548,
-0.7685305476,
-0.4542823434,
-0.7278547883,
-0.3730314076,
0.2625412345,
-0.0604064539,
-0.841155231,
0.2610371411,
0.5587002039,
-0.2392845899,
0.5044546127,
-1.0570375919,
0.8528904915,
0.2513127327,
0.072154507,
-0.2603067756,
-0.5782747865,
0.2316543907,
0.0471070111,
0.0368517041,
-0.0532984138,
0.3179649711,
0.6183491945,
-0.3380708098,
1.0188187361,
-0.6079282165,
-0.0187107325,
0.3911605477,
0.4760038555,
1.0527267456,
0.0117450701,
-0.0577782243,
0.0369409882,
-0.0582003295,
-0.4407154918,
-0.7638517022,
0.3406219482,
-0.717215538,
-0.3833403885,
0.1457178146,
-0.2619672716,
-0.7248462439,
0.4452984929,
0.2852582932,
0.8715884089,
0.0076009948,
0.0349782221,
0.6035875678,
0.0442160033,
-0.0406907946,
0.5644687414,
0.1707843393,
-0.7001675963,
1.4677624702,
0.6957479715,
0.3739718795,
1.0960379839,
0.0306028835,
-0.4202923477,
-0.3692273498,
-0.4704773426,
0.3465188146,
-0.9483938217,
-0.4590992033,
-0.9297550321,
-0.3246958256,
-0.427511096,
-0.3668015301,
-0.5097669959,
-0.8728628755,
-0.0244353767,
-0.6689744592,
0.3031044006,
0.422044009,
0.0686758831,
0.0427752994,
-0.8278487921,
0.2228739262,
0.2549208701,
0.4964942336,
0.1705045551,
-0.1568258554,
-0.1177307293,
-0.0769641697,
-0.0670854077,
-0.9112716913,
0.0156460255,
-0.0788787752,
0.581094861,
0.3379372656,
0.1528896093,
0.4758269787,
-0.1530300379,
0.4822576046,
0.0947825834,
-0.7764915824,
0.3605568707,
-0.4193292856,
-0.391413331,
0.5173985362,
0.5006129742,
-0.7176942229,
-0.7306603789,
-0.6676826477,
-0.5560092926,
0.4354248941,
0.4588557482,
-0.4120426476,
-0.0712429062,
0.258607924,
0.0164829697,
0.4727680981,
-0.8621405363,
-0.2776863873,
-0.6658633351,
-0.4441108108,
0.4686601758,
-0.3575249016,
-0.0404240228,
0.03932878,
0.9852725863,
-0.1088507175,
0.5704834461,
0.3162843287,
-0.5034114122,
0.1477147192,
0.2533579469,
0.3866793513,
0.4012441933,
-0.3136202097,
0.4159242511,
0.1128727049,
-0.474350363,
0.0105077084,
0.2060958296,
-0.4692748785,
-0.1846454442,
0.3620707095,
0.5465362668,
0.2740967572,
-0.0004328882,
0.1770159602,
0.3933136761,
-0.2543486059,
-0.3091770113,
-0.1407649219,
0.1719841361,
0.1419526488,
0.1875897348,
0.2873898745,
0.0233824737,
0.0204982832,
0.195481196,
0.2938429117,
-0.6527224183,
-0.5327734351,
0.3874394298,
0.4257227778,
-0.0591907129,
0.3585001528,
-0.6851403117,
-0.9344678521,
0.737891376,
0.5658150911,
0.7675966024,
-0.080555357,
0.5974546075,
0.2779732645,
0.2422249168,
0.4385814369,
0.227099672,
-0.2717650831,
-1.1231787205,
-0.3238708377,
-0.4985002875,
0.0660491809,
-0.2709386349,
-0.2918823659,
0.2401269823,
-0.2954876423,
0.0422192514,
-0.0397320278,
0.085411109,
-0.5330933332,
0.2437985092,
-0.0463352762,
1.102609992,
-0.9862174392,
0.7038772106,
0.7729195952,
-0.7396073341,
-0.9059388638,
-0.1214414164,
0.0245700814,
-1.2060757875,
0.7879570723,
0.0962329283,
-0.2142213732,
0.3860615194,
0.0004021035,
-1.2895333767,
1.2003314495,
0.1482782662,
-0.0763087943,
-0.4081717432,
0.1943711787,
0.2359916568,
-0.1904492676,
0.1530900449,
0.2187297642,
0.7054266334,
0.2046773881,
-0.5962385535,
0.3586091399,
-0.0291555077,
-0.1023728102,
0.5878726244,
-0.8864783645,
0.279337585,
0.0499039255,
-0.2782310843,
-0.2373591065,
0.7830404639,
0.0357650034,
0.2877982855,
0.6136411428,
0.9879345298,
0.8320611715,
0.1151692867,
0.7751314044,
-0.5041288733,
0.4420571625,
1.1019976139,
-0.1876932979,
0.4662740827,
0.1745325178,
-0.1705561727,
0.6224474907,
0.6334918737,
-0.0088883685,
0.6490109563,
-0.2126191556,
-0.0136795659,
-0.4649473727,
0.0224716291,
-0.5959031582,
0.4372091293,
0.4476947486,
-0.3001188636,
-0.3772533834,
-0.2513077557,
0.1635168493,
-0.3170163631,
-0.2244943082,
0.2974030077,
-0.0303270277,
-0.4037249982,
0.2279578149,
-0.0632759407,
0.2227611095,
-0.6062533855,
0.0444676913,
-0.1308939606,
-0.2205272317,
-0.3357613087,
-0.5384091139,
0.3714717329,
-0.6768071055,
-0.2345169634,
0.2202152759,
1.1070028543,
-0.4633069634,
-0.299138993,
0.3125356436,
0.3335700929,
-0.189237684,
-0.1918937415,
-0.257883817,
-0.5773393512,
-0.1073335558,
-0.1455155313,
0.0614494123,
0.7449614406,
-0.0979208201,
0.6832745075,
0.3448436558,
-0.0753765851,
0.0297241453,
0.0765322819,
0.981741786,
-0.4439929128,
-0.7921016812,
-0.5143965483,
0.4052785635,
-0.279776752,
-0.0934531167,
0.8218553066,
0.5689326525,
0.5229680538,
-0.0713329762,
0.8466360569,
-0.5279229283,
0.5752184987,
-0.5406574011,
0.6679448485,
-0.5065817833,
-0.2515740395,
-0.5713703036,
-0.6498621702,
-0.1574037224,
0.0567743443,
-0.6835727096,
-0.0941920653,
0.8915390968,
0.7979040742,
-0.0860483423,
0.0956808478,
0.2319672555,
0.6379439831,
0.2560926974,
0.444429338,
0.5471411347,
-0.2124388218,
0.6596170068,
-0.0602941625,
-0.0930292904,
-0.3590630591,
-0.8401719332,
-0.8823956847,
-0.6022363305,
-0.2917417586,
-0.5628780127,
-0.0795235187,
0.8358073235,
0.6002654433,
-0.5780109167,
0.5637491345,
-0.398828119,
0.5715472102,
-0.0383836962,
-0.2880854905,
0.6554360986,
-0.2015924305,
0.1281873733,
0.389818877,
0.457596004,
0.1934285164,
0.0024614448,
0.1287595481,
-0.076525338,
-0.0762373209,
0.6841150522,
0.2619735003,
-0.3589604199,
-0.7002125978,
-0.0443158709,
0.1347762793,
0.1166803613,
0.8085628748,
-0.5663327575,
0.2758691013,
0.4871095121,
0.8065516949,
0.5867140293,
-0.1753365695,
0.4948348403,
-1.0207288265,
0.0312075336,
0.237993598,
0.5437728167,
0.2066139728,
-0.735329926,
0.5758897662,
0.9742076993,
-0.0345718525,
-0.651350677,
0.5473678708,
-0.7615135312,
-0.0456438698,
1.0125031471,
-0.1969735324,
-0.3273511827,
-0.2968656719,
0.2492175102,
0.462803334,
-0.4152139723,
0.8871654868,
0.6669996977,
-0.0004481349,
0.4126576185,
-0.0317710638,
0.3358913958,
0.1885778755,
-0.642843008,
-0.1950622797,
0.3702262044,
0.5057994723,
0.3566053212,
0.6715014577,
0.0081482818,
0.1393959969,
0.2537028193,
0.1561497748,
-0.4055047929,
-0.3932724595,
0.6651525497,
0.4057877958,
-0.1539729387,
-0.1482553333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08309v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08309v1
|
Subtoxic Questions: Dive Into Attitude Change of LLM's Response in Jailbreak Attempts
| 2024-04-12T08:08:44 | 2024-04-12T08:08:44 |
Tianyu Zhang, Zixuan Zhao, Jiaqi Huang, Jingyu Hua, Sheng Zhong
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) of Prompt Jailbreaking are getting more and
more attention, it is of great significance to raise a generalized research
paradigm to evaluate attack strengths and a basic model to conduct subtler
experiments. In this paper, we propose a novel approach by focusing on a set of
target questions that are inherently more sensitive to jailbreak prompts,
aiming to circumvent the limitations posed by enhanced LLM security. Through
designing and analyzing these sensitive questions, this paper reveals a more
effective method of identifying vulnerabilities in LLMs, thereby contributing
to the advancement of LLM security. This research not only challenges existing
jailbreaking methodologies but also fortifies LLMs against potential exploits.
|
[
-0.5174215436,
-1.1090043783,
0.7689311504,
-0.0971757248,
-0.3658177257,
0.0446413495,
-0.0042440915,
-0.3654132187,
0.3482285142,
0.6124456525,
-0.6557696462,
-0.28531304,
-0.6793860793,
0.2801309824,
-0.3323890865,
1.061173439,
0.0200747177,
-0.1872703582,
-0.1640391648,
-0.2083570212,
-0.6240817308,
-0.6807758808,
-0.3493523002,
0.0005937736,
0.6537407041,
0.3407616615,
0.528799355,
-0.1870571226,
0.6809251308,
0.3012126386,
-0.4323242009,
-0.3614810705,
-0.2268794179,
0.3650832772,
-0.4857809246,
-0.8624042869,
-0.2316388786,
-0.1373624057,
0.0089593446,
0.2172835618,
0.0618103519,
0.1864534467,
-0.246295765,
0.783831358,
-0.5690734982,
-0.3936952055,
-0.8952658772,
0.0736630857,
-0.164497301,
-0.1582275629,
-0.5486517549,
-0.2945161462,
-0.1561773419,
-0.1209420189,
0.028557511,
-0.0599580966,
0.3553850353,
0.2786540389,
-0.4174804688,
-0.2781654298,
-0.4028502703,
0.748978138,
-0.8649993539,
0.2009056509,
0.2810732126,
0.0901899934,
-0.154026404,
-0.2835625708,
-0.133913666,
-0.5722875595,
0.193801105,
-0.1612530351,
-0.2726701796,
-0.1893905401,
0.2321612388,
0.3169946373,
-0.5008535981,
0.0901968405,
-0.2047934234,
-0.2185373306,
0.7020475864,
0.3158195317,
0.4887776673,
-0.0305460505,
-0.3374789059,
0.1948313415,
-1.0124361515,
0.1083657816,
0.6162153482,
0.3647761643,
-0.0945709273,
0.7903614044,
-0.0070582363,
0.4376181066,
0.2876553833,
-0.0437272228,
-0.1431570649,
-0.3584021926,
-0.0212663524,
-0.0948133841,
0.5717823505,
0.4636157751,
0.3460794389,
-0.0395826139,
-0.073797293,
-0.5065244436,
0.4362330735,
-0.73535496,
0.0976832286,
0.6857833266,
-0.2974181175,
-0.6592666507,
-0.0155076124,
-0.7656407356,
-0.9925704598,
0.1977140754,
0.2014214098,
-0.2888463736,
-0.4486156702,
-0.0940032899,
-0.0261985697,
0.563460052,
0.263863802,
-0.9466285706,
0.135875389,
0.6994267702,
0.9253922105,
-0.1941930354,
0.1489703059,
-0.2229949534,
0.0187444985,
-0.2396431267,
0.5831516981,
-0.4978892207,
-0.7027475238,
-0.0418112874,
-0.0638142899,
0.1375886053,
-0.6547918916,
0.2785038352,
-0.8681508899,
-0.1761695743,
-0.5206207037,
-0.366907537,
0.1109771878,
0.7406687737,
-0.5767546892,
0.7495514154,
0.0965703726,
-1.1545211077,
-0.0699073374,
-0.4584165514,
-0.3424802721,
-0.0849804133,
0.0394799113,
-0.3133649826,
0.2487715334,
0.407664597,
0.1582860351,
-0.2725816965,
0.3258964717,
-0.3190217614,
-0.0105134659,
0.7764134407,
-0.1985987574,
0.7902185321,
0.3006545007,
-0.3494113684,
0.2005873621,
-0.2787343562,
-0.1940614134,
0.3316152096,
-0.4300559461,
-0.6346593499,
-0.0350196362,
-0.3537544012,
0.0545560643,
0.5825737715,
-0.8153830171,
0.4620930552,
-0.4580031037,
0.5774234533,
0.9549171329,
0.2494871914,
0.4590215683,
0.0586215593,
0.8748250008,
0.0943708271,
0.5038889647,
0.0132208401,
-0.3414981067,
-0.5694279671,
0.1417194307,
0.0845598429,
0.8747386932,
-0.5790092945,
0.0666958243,
0.1987407058,
-0.6732919812,
-0.2745188177,
0.3315544426,
0.4146857858,
0.6035937667,
0.5990870595,
-0.0936211944,
-0.5821461678,
-0.8168040514,
-0.6921218634,
-0.5650176406,
0.1527919322,
0.4268218279,
0.6069549918,
-0.1443456709,
0.9150806069,
-0.5750344396,
0.2156840563,
-0.8423057795,
-0.1863010973,
0.2826891541,
0.4099541306,
0.6121769547,
-0.9059966207,
-0.4047729969,
-0.2250391394,
-0.7589245439,
-0.3568768501,
0.1043243855,
0.2716078758,
-0.0485615768,
1.0527435541,
-0.6058831215,
0.1726237386,
0.3153993189,
-0.4151849747,
0.7375733852,
0.1934993565,
0.0268298909,
-1.0760269165,
-0.4167717993,
0.0378785729,
0.1209606007,
-0.7132732868,
0.5427675247,
-0.0079950383,
-0.0675396845,
-0.8685629964,
0.6608823538,
-0.236244753,
0.0894976109,
-0.2491052598,
-0.1488470137,
-0.2898764312,
0.0600089692,
-0.145966962,
0.8101598024,
0.5420789719,
-0.4495818615,
0.5639466643,
0.0157571621,
-0.1416561306,
0.4460630119,
-0.999569118,
0.4625526369,
-0.023944784,
0.0524932668,
-1.2128289938,
-0.1493988782,
0.2329661399,
-0.3893639147,
0.2400577813,
-0.4196044207,
-0.2521642447,
-0.2267301679,
-0.5605874658,
0.5681573153,
0.4025544822,
-0.2752969563,
0.5122005939,
0.3709178269,
-0.5138798952,
-0.5859184861,
-0.5952423811,
0.1676241755,
-0.6656724811,
-0.6851255894,
-0.0224063266,
-0.1134940609,
-0.7591308951,
-0.3602967262,
-0.1642953157,
0.1955695003,
0.3324821591,
0.1080774739,
0.3836603165,
-0.1104718298,
-0.2884266675,
0.1609231383,
-0.0733195543,
0.3882904053,
-0.019495558,
0.6034449935,
-0.2544845641,
-0.254433006,
-0.0256079398,
0.4217062294,
0.5339245796,
-0.2706566155,
0.764138937,
-0.0118254786,
0.1265510619,
0.1205754504,
-0.4387805462,
-0.2204810977,
-0.5797336698,
0.4289319515,
-0.4459114373,
-1.1921746731,
0.7339007258,
-0.3202043772,
-0.0890994146,
0.013652565,
0.8277111053,
-0.0390977375,
0.8222735524,
0.8278326392,
-0.4109568,
0.5749621391,
0.1133349091,
0.2243329138,
-0.9362906218,
-0.2556462884,
-0.490472585,
-0.1295322031,
-0.5039742589,
-0.3136618733,
0.4735360444,
-0.0265463702,
-0.0327056088,
0.6565675735,
-0.1710558236,
0.4848284721,
0.0585136712,
0.1340507716,
0.2809201777,
-0.5387939811,
-0.3694910407,
0.1103697941,
-0.2157603949,
-0.4555999041,
1.0643206835,
0.6562899351,
1.1776754856,
0.4638773203,
0.6857225299,
0.189714238,
0.2872194648,
-0.8661575913,
0.8421058059,
0.3848409057,
-1.2247703075,
-0.4354347289,
-0.2277916521,
-0.7230545282,
0.2309514135,
0.1551434696,
-0.9974416494,
0.1520114541,
0.0902687237,
-0.3191870451,
0.4738212228,
-0.6565448642,
0.665086925,
-0.3018016219,
-0.3131095171,
0.2486648262,
-0.81021595,
0.5379472375,
-0.0510204323,
0.5021944046,
-0.1394575834,
-0.2681685686,
0.5936356187,
-0.5214224458,
1.0791498423,
-0.3792595863,
-0.5852566361,
0.5409936309,
0.4145422876,
0.6382474899,
0.423042655,
-0.1573776454,
-0.1017936692,
-0.2475551665,
-0.2781581879,
-0.5708573461,
0.4966830015,
-0.5493143797,
-1.0988892317,
-0.1738618016,
-0.7426634431,
-0.4465650022,
0.022128731,
0.3505808413,
-0.0096561927,
-0.2161426693,
-0.0727872923,
1.0152752399,
-0.5956277251,
0.4705529511,
0.5625982285,
-0.2633549273,
-0.1383230537,
0.4694908261,
-0.0711061433,
0.4546509683,
0.5095416903,
0.3258237839,
-0.3454226255,
-0.8834657073,
-0.2847859859,
0.0734443814,
-0.5888162255,
-0.2303147912,
-0.5159494877,
-0.1132971942,
-0.7283428311,
-0.2496763617,
-0.4555425644,
-0.201918304,
-0.0866730139,
-0.540574193,
0.6775545478,
0.4063847661,
0.0359692946,
0.1597453505,
-0.764460206,
0.3845020235,
0.4691642821,
-0.2039748728,
-0.3642021418,
-0.857119441,
-0.0022596898,
-0.3522344232,
-0.1760892421,
-1.4280757904,
0.3251612186,
-0.2931225896,
0.4005890489,
0.1876200885,
0.3471913934,
0.1711370796,
-0.3495666981,
0.7868446112,
0.145792976,
-0.9087301493,
1.1562975645,
-0.5239700675,
-0.0117121525,
0.809450686,
0.6006832123,
-0.3318605721,
-0.7629266977,
-0.4789297283,
-1.0776375532,
0.227475673,
-0.0659584254,
0.5864850879,
0.1074829996,
0.6377788186,
0.1442594081,
0.1824211031,
-0.9755312204,
-0.2644730508,
-0.0628289878,
0.0454405323,
0.0188780632,
-0.4063358307,
-0.1911932826,
-0.3821232617,
0.2845337093,
-0.0012967229,
-0.0463973023,
0.2679736316,
-0.266438514,
0.1605307758,
0.9691823721,
0.3666717112,
0.3969212174,
-0.3607730567,
0.3475117087,
0.4796641469,
-0.7592477202,
0.642080605,
-0.4161934853,
-0.5222020745,
-0.3511450887,
0.4538756907,
0.4155910313,
-0.2095802277,
-0.7598590255,
0.5042607784,
0.0354479589,
-0.0317707509,
-0.1472999454,
0.3818022311,
0.0815275833,
0.3427481353,
0.3005513251,
-0.3354226649,
-0.0413832217,
-1.0065602064,
0.109679535,
0.4209216833,
-0.7053455114,
-0.316798836,
0.457000643,
0.2500099242,
-0.2652209401,
0.4580037892,
-0.0095002791,
-0.7163541317,
0.6881946921,
0.7652412057,
0.8858147264,
-0.4795427024,
0.2296887934,
0.1666408032,
0.8423615694,
0.4036820531,
0.4435885847,
0.0951649323,
-0.8409276009,
-0.3631430864,
-0.3615684807,
-0.601788938,
0.1655931026,
-0.8316081166,
0.0155314514,
-0.8399037719,
-0.2785752714,
-0.3290792108,
-0.2842101455,
0.2539270222,
0.1901227683,
0.0104699302,
1.1356670856,
-0.9160229564,
0.7444367409,
0.8359282017,
-0.3216453791,
-0.4985169768,
0.1415998936,
0.2420842052,
-0.7388481498,
0.5495160222,
-0.0180660523,
0.069655247,
-0.1487628967,
-1.0656206608,
-0.6430586576,
0.7839112282,
0.4720537961,
-0.623593986,
0.1129449829,
0.2734309137,
0.3079118431,
-0.1820115,
0.0740859658,
0.9707807899,
0.5334544182,
-0.0571280159,
-0.6330627203,
0.4334268272,
-0.371534884,
-0.2512170374,
0.3803558946,
-0.6812639236,
0.9740722775,
-0.7299920321,
0.2992842793,
0.0250116456,
0.5253332257,
0.5341143012,
0.2543886006,
0.5164238811,
0.5392385125,
0.3997411132,
-0.0988278314,
1.1403995752,
0.1202043742,
0.2751658559,
0.9647933245,
-0.366717577,
0.6667145491,
1.0423523188,
-0.3913017809,
0.5839289427,
0.6181465387,
0.020227069,
0.6699718833,
0.514791429,
-0.3034992218,
-0.3183992803,
-0.0305992309,
-0.5130962133,
0.1496755928,
0.3151184618,
-0.0616149455,
-0.2053464055,
0.3697407842,
0.2282499373,
0.0464639999,
-0.5507233739,
0.841709137,
0.2494146824,
-0.3832341135,
0.0947931334,
0.3809116483,
0.8776714802,
-0.5567978621,
0.4181769788,
-0.5398542881,
-0.100639455,
-0.1940574348,
-0.9009942412,
0.3521912098,
0.5420266986,
0.0578946285,
0.0521230996,
1.061413765,
0.2615003288,
-0.3431052864,
0.3889855444,
0.4313211143,
0.1238558516,
-0.2968937457,
-0.8913354874,
0.1588805616,
-0.0259768777,
-0.459861666,
0.7258421183,
0.2124554366,
0.0490976535,
0.8154855371,
0.6026105285,
-0.1261443645,
0.2453092933,
0.0496300124,
1.2012642622,
-0.8818764091,
-0.2979875803,
-1.2549577951,
0.548822999,
0.1389009804,
-0.3385584354,
0.9433547854,
0.2083489597,
0.6502833366,
-0.045686435,
0.8281303644,
-0.394439429,
0.367788136,
-0.6896808147,
0.3323509395,
-0.2852573395,
0.6827790141,
-0.5674654245,
-0.5377117991,
0.0763061866,
0.358189404,
-0.6989963651,
0.0619380064,
0.5797761679,
0.7877440453,
0.3215161264,
-0.1512011886,
0.1769679189,
0.3043046594,
0.4172162414,
0.7349745035,
1.3788235188,
-0.3345371187,
0.4934104085,
-0.1933367401,
-0.0756755918,
-0.26255849,
-0.8102672696,
-1.0481258631,
-0.1624501795,
-0.3054489195,
-0.3972774148,
-0.0295753703,
0.6645491123,
0.2081252635,
-0.8509181738,
-0.0530510508,
-0.3134835064,
0.5066142678,
0.1345224828,
-0.2584064603,
-0.0226435568,
-0.154514879,
-0.4966390431,
0.5553388596,
0.2219540775,
0.1791055202,
-0.3453018665,
0.1294697225,
-0.2732865512,
0.4018209875,
0.613592267,
0.3260909617,
-0.3277205229,
-0.3768540621,
0.2655002773,
-0.0945810005,
-0.1113063768,
1.0390563011,
-0.4280746281,
-0.0817803741,
0.4500208795,
0.5383785367,
0.2148303688,
0.2035287023,
0.2986732423,
-0.8204330206,
0.3454506397,
0.3655064106,
0.2450359613,
0.0933143944,
-0.552998662,
0.3955481052,
0.0995428339,
-0.2757866085,
-0.9876164198,
0.7161509991,
-0.9412346482,
-0.6450553536,
1.4018832445,
-0.3073684275,
-0.2202931941,
-0.4864372611,
-0.3193598688,
-0.1878361106,
-0.1534704268,
0.7056537271,
0.7395194173,
-0.3737462759,
-0.2610360682,
-0.4679669738,
0.1491923481,
0.5253405571,
-1.0045911074,
0.143003583,
0.0819792673,
0.5284411907,
0.1942203045,
0.6530536413,
-0.5681331158,
0.055060342,
-0.101967372,
-0.3741162717,
-0.0461081304,
-0.4495871961,
-0.2722723186,
0.4119992256,
0.3300677538,
0.1972398162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08263v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08263v1
|
Relational Prompt-based Pre-trained Language Models for Social Event Detection
| 2024-04-12T06:23:07 | 2024-04-12T06:23:07 |
Pu Li, Xiaoyan Yu, Hao Peng, Yantuan Xian, Linqin Wang, Li Sun, Jingyun Zhang, Philip S. Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
Social Event Detection (SED) aims to identify significant events from social
streams, and has a wide application ranging from public opinion analysis to
risk management. In recent years, Graph Neural Network (GNN) based solutions
have achieved state-of-the-art performance. However, GNN-based methods often
struggle with noisy and missing edges between messages, affecting the quality
of learned message embedding. Moreover, these methods statically initialize
node embedding before training, which, in turn, limits the ability to learn
from message texts and relations simultaneously. In this paper, we approach
social event detection from a new perspective based on Pre-trained Language
Models (PLMs), and present RPLM_SED (Relational prompt-based Pre-trained
Language Models for Social Event Detection). We first propose a new pairwise
message modeling strategy to construct social messages into message pairs with
multi-relational sequences. Secondly, a new multi-relational prompt-based
pairwise message learning mechanism is proposed to learn more comprehensive
message representation from message pairs with multi-relational prompts using
PLMs. Thirdly, we design a new clustering constraint to optimize the encoding
process by enhancing intra-cluster compactness and inter-cluster dispersion,
making the message representation more distinguishable. We evaluate the
RPLM_SED on three real-world datasets, demonstrating that the RPLM_SED model
achieves state-of-the-art performance in offline, online, low-resource, and
long-tail distribution scenarios for social event detection tasks.
|
[
-0.1805684865,
-1.1361274719,
0.608075738,
0.202476576,
-0.6921491027,
0.1456069648,
-0.36301139,
-0.1408891231,
0.5781100392,
0.1755055338,
-0.6609098911,
-0.9152769446,
-0.3817175329,
0.0800285339,
-0.0879461467,
0.7681907415,
0.1376440525,
-0.1433331072,
-0.3957077265,
-0.1674333066,
-0.1301406175,
-0.8481976986,
-0.7686216831,
-0.1066633016,
0.4069433808,
0.2865273356,
0.5322318077,
0.2989401817,
0.2313682735,
0.2599028945,
-0.1034695059,
0.4216271341,
-0.5689858198,
0.1773882955,
-0.0083240289,
0.0531343594,
-0.1243380681,
-0.049138546,
0.8491736054,
0.646089077,
-0.1932840347,
0.0389481224,
0.1303327829,
0.375304848,
-0.5151058435,
0.4552975297,
-0.3898384273,
-0.0201553944,
-0.078724362,
-0.2750919163,
-0.5223240852,
-0.3822198212,
-0.1277490705,
-0.5890995264,
0.0231818389,
-0.0644667223,
0.6894040704,
-0.1250112355,
-0.3518198133,
-0.0974420384,
-0.4152026176,
0.5059195757,
-0.4496724308,
0.4148229957,
0.1744475961,
0.1533793956,
-0.2764644325,
-0.5862032771,
-0.4762152731,
0.0012947487,
-0.0749666765,
-0.0062366836,
0.1145835444,
-0.0112435156,
0.1178077981,
-0.2634979784,
-0.7433418036,
0.099818483,
0.1369503289,
-0.0469379872,
0.6468744874,
0.2201200128,
0.4169101417,
-0.421878159,
-0.3511003852,
-0.034694396,
-0.5568618178,
0.0133711929,
0.1995538026,
0.5728917718,
-0.5140157938,
0.0113047929,
-0.1955568194,
0.3910502493,
-0.067058742,
-0.0878309011,
0.2376132607,
-0.4982168078,
0.1594679952,
-0.136124149,
1.0822052956,
0.3012268245,
0.3858299851,
-0.0420562848,
0.0880525112,
0.2741309404,
-0.3252660036,
-0.7097997069,
-0.2087045312,
-0.1337351501,
-0.8762426376,
-0.4433003366,
-0.0007648369,
-0.6848713756,
-0.5835471153,
-0.2721046805,
0.1829739213,
-0.3579820096,
-0.5534635186,
0.0707023814,
0.1547880024,
0.0791190937,
0.444277674,
-0.3868470788,
0.1387031525,
0.6428853869,
0.8890030384,
-0.1463743448,
-0.3582632244,
-0.7761129737,
-0.0629567206,
-0.0079209376,
0.8722657561,
-0.5146645308,
-0.4029413462,
0.1607760936,
0.1404237598,
-0.2180647105,
-0.1132974401,
0.3212501109,
-0.6217186451,
-0.0291319489,
-0.3293115497,
-0.6104509234,
0.2199587971,
0.2761487663,
-0.373572886,
0.6737570167,
-0.160687983,
-0.8659568429,
0.2800685763,
-0.2499257475,
-0.6844816804,
0.3181091547,
-0.4428180754,
-0.6928780675,
-0.1284131408,
0.3869077563,
0.67527318,
-0.1090853438,
0.5352270007,
-0.8007827997,
-0.2883788049,
0.3209336698,
-0.2498734891,
0.7399281859,
0.068151474,
0.0893397033,
0.4935283363,
-0.8628953099,
-0.083788991,
0.3562267721,
-0.0268410314,
-0.3012637794,
0.2098302245,
0.0595019758,
0.3371074796,
0.1143297628,
-0.374145925,
-0.1097864881,
-0.1801604033,
0.5237970948,
0.8427938819,
0.3321522176,
0.3977568746,
-0.0410938449,
0.5493966341,
0.2895205021,
0.3146190345,
-0.5169576406,
-0.5496422052,
-0.2324925959,
0.0444591194,
-0.0377719291,
0.7268163562,
-0.9477807283,
0.5970323682,
-0.0306835398,
-0.0799692795,
0.0638299286,
-0.0071748663,
0.2191133648,
0.34455809,
0.1652305871,
-0.1342571676,
-0.5399065614,
-0.3651209176,
-0.4074304402,
-0.539609313,
0.386449337,
0.3317449093,
0.2988092899,
-0.0493624844,
0.7690545321,
-0.3991279006,
-0.2115096301,
-0.6529666185,
0.1087750047,
0.2607331574,
0.2995363772,
0.4263111949,
-0.736880362,
-0.6589034796,
-0.1161669716,
-0.8518155813,
-0.203333959,
-0.1859141737,
0.1662462205,
0.1251642555,
0.6961809397,
-0.5399734378,
0.5744629502,
0.1986824274,
-0.4961365759,
0.5218812823,
-0.1891480237,
0.0512936413,
-1.1477304697,
-0.4552888572,
0.0848929733,
-0.4816735983,
-0.8054427505,
-0.1723064184,
0.2171932012,
-0.411634326,
-0.6104568839,
0.5595065355,
-0.5893383622,
-0.2215417176,
-0.2038217187,
0.4268360436,
-0.0646514744,
0.4306651354,
0.2554173172,
0.3532004952,
0.5512701869,
-0.5564736128,
0.4819067121,
0.3021032512,
-0.3755219281,
0.5852184296,
-0.5052078962,
0.1705895662,
-0.5331605673,
0.3618359864,
-0.9964331388,
-0.0706654638,
0.5088632107,
-0.553044498,
0.182499513,
-0.3295736015,
-0.6260510087,
-0.3654384613,
-0.2279144228,
0.3128872514,
0.3483769596,
-0.6708943844,
0.7439683676,
0.4020235538,
-0.2209024131,
-0.2647361755,
-0.2351623923,
0.000067326,
-0.236001119,
-0.9838677049,
0.1469171792,
0.2654360533,
0.0706433505,
0.0982703716,
0.1288289428,
0.0375502445,
0.1666710228,
0.2920006216,
0.330126524,
-0.0313479751,
0.2368497699,
-0.1759517938,
-0.3369499147,
0.2152242213,
-0.1885539889,
0.6391969323,
-0.1302670836,
-0.4840681553,
-0.7360929251,
0.5772373676,
0.1449955851,
-0.2989339828,
1.0938624144,
0.81368047,
-0.3257446289,
-0.0677652359,
-0.4606412947,
-0.4485872984,
-0.4287882745,
0.3081128895,
-0.1160715744,
-1.0153625011,
0.7264192104,
-0.1887899935,
-0.5090337396,
-0.1732888222,
0.079272151,
-0.0683464333,
1.0649979115,
0.2673002481,
-0.0696980059,
0.8471449018,
0.0364334248,
0.2522081435,
-0.4720446765,
-0.0740624592,
-0.4987303913,
0.0390820615,
-0.3157678246,
-0.4322816432,
0.328366369,
0.2730670273,
-0.1415375024,
-0.0501300581,
-0.1798147559,
0.5740932226,
0.3827581704,
0.3581785262,
0.2082537711,
-0.0314959809,
0.0183317661,
0.0044603921,
-0.893140316,
-0.3393371701,
0.8410628438,
0.122618109,
0.7385815382,
-0.1818925142,
0.957398653,
0.1635916531,
0.1418036222,
-0.1989546418,
0.7770511508,
-0.0660806075,
-0.0403410047,
-0.312895,
-0.627140224,
-0.8084653616,
0.1710619777,
-0.3976415992,
-0.7155585885,
0.2608835399,
0.0414340831,
-0.4542651176,
0.304399997,
-0.603027463,
1.171916604,
-0.1008422226,
-0.2753913701,
-0.1506742537,
-0.8287909627,
0.0545871742,
0.2618131042,
0.6410182714,
-0.2545601726,
0.3249692917,
0.7025646567,
-0.3079273403,
1.0912111998,
-0.4753106833,
0.4430063963,
0.5011011958,
-0.1861195415,
1.2744572163,
0.4517678618,
0.2866449654,
-0.1637285203,
-0.1054228619,
-0.2259076834,
-0.4420226812,
0.6058177352,
-0.7541819811,
-0.4798366129,
-0.2226381004,
-0.1912306547,
0.0226235427,
0.0272494219,
0.1239769384,
0.6703271866,
-0.4435711503,
0.1633509248,
0.5828809142,
-0.67918998,
0.4812885523,
0.45686391,
-0.5006916523,
-0.4453586936,
0.8524291515,
-0.0896308869,
0.0906789079,
0.2842930555,
0.1520815939,
-0.4305208921,
-0.4615414739,
-0.2558267415,
0.4567827284,
-0.9166588783,
-0.1325054914,
-1.0713838339,
-0.0478637889,
-0.7369123697,
-0.0687094107,
-0.2094995975,
-0.0957755595,
-0.8262279034,
-0.1180683002,
0.3851171732,
0.3261367381,
-0.2999263406,
0.4624421,
-0.8805695176,
0.4861883819,
0.1161764041,
0.2634473741,
-0.0702216849,
-0.1073831618,
0.0054978449,
-0.0994530991,
0.1245964095,
-1.2150872946,
0.3829878569,
0.3058855534,
0.509790957,
0.5147676468,
0.4428629875,
0.2754299343,
-0.3123258054,
0.3891054988,
0.2510671616,
-0.6969317198,
0.7456356883,
-0.3805651665,
0.0335947759,
0.2724616826,
0.3166165054,
-0.7841938138,
-0.0093718898,
-0.6647703648,
-0.6333481669,
0.8492110968,
-0.0380401388,
0.0017116615,
-0.4552108347,
0.4167808294,
-0.267481178,
0.0661111251,
-0.8717327118,
-0.2923612297,
-0.2059655786,
-0.1323963255,
0.0183002353,
-0.426915437,
0.3644598126,
0.0144705605,
0.4907274246,
-0.1364115328,
0.0739567131,
0.0848956779,
-0.2433809638,
-0.0052104024,
0.326454252,
0.3000934422,
0.576010704,
-0.0966511816,
0.0997868404,
0.1325652152,
-0.064428553,
0.235688746,
0.2473473251,
-0.1354159415,
-0.0046809623,
0.3199081719,
0.9389090538,
0.1824494451,
-0.3978289664,
0.8750513196,
-0.3271674514,
0.1604174376,
-0.3150101602,
-0.233675763,
0.246381402,
0.2231920511,
0.1827609688,
-0.3230143487,
-0.0802399069,
-0.5928791761,
0.2967801988,
0.6012875438,
-0.354752481,
-0.4540559351,
0.5084228516,
0.3048909307,
-0.3347955644,
0.5243974924,
-0.7595407963,
-0.740427196,
0.7352932096,
0.5699986219,
0.5767951608,
-0.3671555221,
0.6958952546,
0.2305305749,
0.2576231062,
0.025181286,
0.637432456,
0.0063820053,
-1.0946886539,
-0.5991088748,
-0.5102328062,
-0.1793996394,
0.1419072896,
-0.5548444986,
0.3921955228,
-0.4534055591,
-0.198882103,
-0.183812499,
-0.1853894591,
-0.5906446576,
-0.1801931411,
0.0840357989,
0.4797262251,
-1.1573075056,
0.6549110413,
0.7432768941,
-0.0651531667,
-0.721848309,
-0.5507917404,
0.0975117013,
-0.4616053402,
0.4652594924,
0.3237761557,
0.3482282162,
0.1423139572,
-0.2084314972,
-0.6509430408,
0.7313331962,
0.1095513925,
-0.4322426021,
-0.0219716746,
0.1088872403,
0.2737222016,
-0.5788280964,
0.1293516308,
0.1782147288,
0.3424764574,
0.0365277752,
-0.4121709466,
0.1099668294,
-0.1019855216,
0.1080130413,
0.4159888625,
-0.3751619458,
0.9098416567,
-0.1055251211,
-0.6056161523,
-0.1541732997,
0.7455048561,
0.5441551208,
0.6042068601,
0.4833548665,
0.2916718125,
0.7282585502,
-0.1542244703,
0.985676825,
-0.2598042786,
0.3474009335,
1.0896724463,
-0.6184999347,
0.3768572807,
-0.0189074147,
-0.1486489773,
0.490149647,
0.6561102867,
0.490093559,
0.536362946,
0.0938791707,
-0.4375173748,
-0.739775598,
-0.3258161247,
-0.5205484033,
-0.0390545465,
0.5756201148,
-0.2224405706,
-0.3659249842,
0.2454219311,
-0.2655763924,
0.353428334,
-0.3374324143,
0.8038380742,
0.1924190074,
-0.2001934946,
0.0844272971,
-0.1589924842,
0.5546301603,
-0.3314603865,
0.1321182996,
-0.1569533497,
0.086312227,
0.0151528008,
-0.4645751715,
0.1781140715,
-0.4034338593,
0.0022952324,
-0.1640570164,
1.4986299276,
-0.4126037359,
-0.351665765,
0.5905396342,
0.7445058227,
0.0701343864,
-0.3339762688,
-0.7056191564,
0.3180825114,
-0.2804284692,
-0.1239809319,
0.3149751723,
0.7216567993,
-0.1511401683,
0.5635403395,
0.7893352509,
0.0147869242,
-0.0576613955,
0.5853743553,
0.8334928155,
-0.6761866212,
-1.1569523811,
-0.97309798,
0.0811321586,
-0.3304265738,
0.1924538314,
0.4840188026,
0.1354248822,
0.5691385865,
0.0561194047,
0.6515999436,
0.3286553323,
0.6670767665,
-0.5056582689,
0.4596028626,
-0.1101830006,
0.1927322745,
-0.5092727542,
-0.6273052096,
-0.3591711521,
0.7544255853,
-0.3032621443,
0.0960744619,
0.5460686684,
0.7146393061,
0.1911887079,
0.3181274533,
0.2000847906,
-0.0550701767,
0.391803056,
0.593526721,
1.3747791052,
-0.0580190904,
0.4737755358,
-0.1199887991,
-0.2890360653,
-0.422210753,
-1.0896891356,
-1.2414900064,
-0.599263072,
-0.5415050983,
-0.3003793657,
0.3582797647,
1.1990329027,
0.601049304,
-0.6473010182,
-0.0287579671,
-0.1234894693,
0.4827852845,
-0.0957989097,
-0.2433436811,
0.4790428877,
-0.4370520711,
0.0087202052,
0.4557594359,
0.3830232322,
0.1473948956,
0.1170607209,
-0.1192677021,
-0.4677648246,
-0.3373978436,
0.67314744,
0.2080542892,
-0.3956747651,
-0.4466146529,
-0.088011317,
0.0487789623,
-0.0781686604,
0.62866956,
-0.8287225962,
-0.0733734593,
0.6276974082,
0.5872839689,
0.4435052276,
0.0737797394,
0.3220057786,
-1.0217101574,
0.322142154,
-0.0531673208,
0.4819011688,
0.3941126168,
-0.5370149016,
0.3337811232,
0.5509750247,
-0.4867655933,
-0.798048079,
0.4241127074,
-0.8198519349,
-0.3373839259,
1.1956356764,
-0.1886900663,
-0.3332600892,
-0.4046944082,
0.0407795161,
0.452334404,
-0.582937181,
0.4404779673,
0.4581820369,
0.0485639386,
-0.5391840935,
0.0209771115,
0.3947328627,
0.1423723996,
-0.8468176126,
0.1613478661,
0.6191493273,
0.0451358072,
0.0172110163,
1.0389975309,
0.1682944447,
0.4364954531,
-0.3694876134,
-0.0597464778,
-0.2967167497,
-0.4340358377,
-0.3001003563,
0.2358065695,
-0.2447467148,
0.0876272395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08262v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08262v2
|
Pretraining and Updating Language- and Domain-specific Large Language Model: A Case Study in Japanese Business Domain
| 2024-04-12T06:21:48 | 2024-04-16T02:24:00 |
Kosuke Takahashi, Takahiro Omi, Kosuke Arima, Tatsuya Ishigaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50
|
Several previous studies have considered language- and domain-specific large
language models (LLMs) as separate topics. This study explores the combination
of a non-English language and a high-demand industry domain, focusing on a
Japanese business-specific LLM. This type of a model requires expertise in the
business domain, strong language skills, and regular updates of its knowledge.
We trained a 13-billion-parameter LLM from scratch using a new dataset of
business texts and patents, and continually pretrained it with the latest
business documents. Further we propose a new benchmark for Japanese business
domain question answering (QA) and evaluate our models on it. The results show
that our pretrained model improves QA accuracy without losing general
knowledge, and that continual pretraining enhances adaptation to new
information. Our pretrained model and business domain benchmark are publicly
available.
|
[
-0.2542914152,
-0.9724683762,
0.6033149362,
0.2070212662,
-0.4866055548,
0.2160701156,
-0.1965716183,
-0.6327933669,
-0.0052137314,
0.93596977,
-0.5979311466,
-0.5024650693,
-0.3517659605,
0.1549952328,
0.0530226454,
0.8560678959,
-0.1946460456,
0.1475111246,
-0.3044425845,
-0.2352719009,
-0.9120886326,
-0.9217098951,
-1.0426843166,
-0.3331165612,
0.2304195464,
0.1082269847,
0.6082835197,
0.2809709311,
0.4386992455,
0.2571776807,
0.2715077996,
-0.1482803226,
-0.4006974399,
0.0300584733,
-0.2631796002,
-0.755872786,
-0.5134987831,
-0.0273909513,
0.6786527634,
0.950494349,
-0.2548322082,
0.2145107538,
-0.3041599393,
0.5266088843,
-0.4216676354,
0.3280224502,
-0.7251757383,
-0.3161565065,
-0.0922655389,
-0.2255727351,
-0.424347192,
-0.2552212477,
0.2350414246,
-0.8025969863,
0.065447472,
0.1794864088,
1.1053080559,
0.1682373285,
-0.3133565784,
-0.0997688696,
-0.642241776,
0.564915061,
-0.6929201484,
0.4886895716,
0.4373269081,
0.2917965055,
-0.1466005594,
-0.8954290748,
-0.2762254179,
-0.2560155988,
0.215684399,
0.1286671907,
-0.063135609,
-0.0563265905,
0.418615967,
0.1797780395,
-0.5001934767,
0.4199711382,
-0.1612083018,
0.2108115554,
0.6906681657,
0.023355335,
0.5239654779,
0.3228006661,
-0.1528490037,
-0.0949732661,
-0.8750733733,
-0.0918587893,
0.1830507666,
0.1208116487,
0.155266583,
0.1601439714,
-0.3797387183,
0.6188722253,
-0.1438819617,
-0.0890590698,
0.1726121753,
-0.1809384525,
-0.3979317248,
-0.037786711,
0.5383796096,
0.0750704035,
0.627533555,
-0.2689131498,
-0.1380262375,
-0.2565919757,
0.3248924613,
-0.8012630939,
-0.1259936094,
0.1034106463,
-0.2824855447,
0.1927915812,
-0.1652338952,
-0.5218161345,
-0.262242645,
-0.3144161105,
0.6326448321,
-0.0435422324,
-0.3607104421,
0.4136136472,
-0.0126920892,
0.4984494448,
0.3030258119,
-0.7687367201,
0.1699612886,
0.4685766995,
0.3317468166,
0.023040995,
-0.4094547927,
-0.1424717754,
0.2924216688,
-0.6151833534,
0.6449303031,
-0.5430507064,
-0.358599782,
0.146863848,
0.1576580703,
-0.0971200615,
-0.857373476,
0.1724426448,
-1.1373542547,
0.2969042361,
-0.0916394889,
-0.6668404937,
-0.120316036,
0.3076235056,
-0.6137657166,
0.7366790771,
0.2656408548,
-0.4407608807,
0.4775164127,
-0.5121688843,
-0.5432174802,
0.4711727798,
-0.0723436028,
-0.4924355447,
-0.019965902,
0.1570161134,
0.384167552,
-0.3472338617,
0.4044198394,
-0.3150770962,
-0.0751712695,
0.4936986566,
-0.1838083416,
0.6670306921,
0.0424166471,
-0.0618951917,
-0.172967419,
-0.8465868831,
0.1894239485,
0.3391403854,
-0.3316521645,
-0.4544546008,
-0.2840575874,
-0.2767224312,
0.1564711928,
0.7194146514,
-0.2718844414,
0.1834909171,
-0.3011458516,
0.1793105006,
0.5764665604,
0.376570493,
0.0742710084,
-0.2627988458,
0.8694178462,
0.1185180992,
0.0987803787,
-0.2768176794,
-0.5010376573,
-0.7072470188,
-0.1062965468,
0.4518727362,
0.4230098724,
-0.7503681779,
0.2695282102,
-0.3630589545,
-0.4339633286,
-0.642169714,
0.1610347182,
0.2605058551,
0.2360425889,
0.3527197838,
-0.5708165765,
-0.4582623541,
-0.6804246306,
-0.3940636814,
0.0281659253,
-0.0495864972,
0.2927404344,
0.2610620856,
-0.4347509742,
0.7754814029,
-0.6726262569,
-0.1528715193,
-0.5119428635,
0.1874292046,
0.4244279265,
0.2217743248,
0.4469073713,
-0.7377815843,
-0.7053999305,
0.1010524556,
-0.4944734871,
-0.0532870293,
-0.1175903454,
-0.2827018201,
0.2079996169,
0.4903990924,
-0.6991148591,
0.2259088606,
0.3090994358,
-0.1332862824,
0.5815751553,
-0.4734922349,
0.2304845005,
-1.3871471882,
0.1542680562,
0.0171484593,
-0.4341546595,
-0.7772890925,
0.1869263351,
0.0131603265,
-0.5790212154,
-0.3875293732,
0.6822334528,
-0.6442219615,
-0.2832688391,
-0.5691509843,
0.1173765436,
0.1722978354,
0.6155340075,
0.4387205839,
0.8929264545,
0.6482274532,
-0.9238682389,
0.3021215498,
0.3599718809,
-0.6679275632,
0.3155281842,
-0.6885088682,
0.2461044788,
-0.111606054,
-0.0453828275,
-0.6573703289,
-0.1562967896,
-0.116440624,
-0.2200753093,
0.4888958037,
-0.1131578609,
-0.5432374477,
-0.3505774736,
0.2547720075,
0.1445736736,
0.7637707591,
-0.3974480629,
0.5687889457,
0.3813930452,
-0.6575203538,
-0.254336834,
-0.4758928418,
0.0341269076,
-0.1169438809,
-0.4049413204,
0.2132963687,
-0.1392311454,
-0.0078739673,
-0.0610802025,
-0.1325965673,
-0.6664613485,
0.4635693133,
-0.2072664499,
0.2930574715,
-0.4493505061,
-0.1898886412,
-0.22727938,
-0.1157491654,
0.258620739,
-0.2726613879,
0.6166216731,
0.1636204869,
-0.129825592,
-0.5992377996,
0.0575760715,
0.3860616386,
-0.3099809289,
0.7819346786,
0.0703516826,
-0.4026417732,
-0.2478443235,
-0.5824510455,
-0.0432010368,
-0.5169381499,
0.7697019577,
-0.5358060002,
-0.8177395463,
0.4217783511,
-0.3468650281,
-0.1321789026,
0.3795451224,
0.5712593198,
-0.0129819876,
0.8988724351,
1.0301382542,
-0.3651040494,
0.4393721819,
0.0073755975,
0.5379449725,
-0.435574472,
-0.1097651124,
-0.6053734422,
0.0820419118,
-0.4762049019,
-0.2681346834,
0.0523900017,
0.1980632097,
-0.184566617,
0.3720279038,
0.1909098178,
0.6065474749,
0.4404960573,
-0.1757362932,
0.2671553791,
-0.1433623731,
0.1541771293,
0.1017897353,
-0.6169297695,
-0.4607366621,
1.1553134918,
0.2977662683,
0.813932538,
0.0394304283,
0.3306822777,
0.0317929089,
0.4376365542,
-0.535338819,
0.4089624882,
-0.2870253325,
-0.8414230943,
-0.2269007117,
-0.5100666285,
-0.9571747184,
-0.0060379901,
0.0640215874,
-0.4572159946,
-0.101260893,
0.0552740954,
-0.163767308,
0.1569845229,
-0.7153294683,
1.1017251015,
-0.5010015965,
-0.1932780743,
-0.2378677428,
-0.3791828156,
-0.0232253745,
-0.6474429369,
0.1749854684,
-0.1116047874,
-0.0190223772,
0.7971616387,
-0.1124850512,
0.7636964917,
-0.2407969981,
-0.2100495398,
0.1583368629,
-0.286783129,
0.4447031617,
-0.0494289994,
-0.0347372591,
0.0718591362,
-0.0234883297,
-0.5142709613,
-0.7531306148,
0.3200840652,
-0.9455683827,
-0.9602032304,
-0.2964843214,
-0.4441042244,
-0.892388165,
0.5071209669,
0.1660355926,
0.2965256572,
-0.3643241525,
0.2469488829,
0.8756995201,
-0.3971930742,
0.0463071167,
1.0425502062,
-0.2824280262,
-0.2374243438,
0.6606414914,
0.0621536486,
0.3025039732,
0.5644536614,
-0.0005585154,
-0.4979070127,
-0.6157941818,
-0.2672027647,
0.5173865557,
-0.5599477887,
-0.0121614924,
-0.5617091656,
-0.3058380187,
-0.4823479056,
0.0668693408,
-0.3032593727,
0.0202176105,
-0.1800960451,
0.0489165187,
0.1183713302,
0.7274618745,
0.6507978439,
0.3491127789,
-0.8541893959,
0.4057877362,
0.315420419,
0.4874130785,
-0.207287699,
-0.7389782071,
-0.7007413507,
0.2196934074,
-0.1764064431,
-0.5781627297,
0.4230597317,
0.1548254341,
0.7903300524,
0.2174651176,
-0.1163487881,
0.6362776756,
-0.5345361829,
0.8287132978,
0.1854426414,
-0.8930866122,
0.5810483098,
-0.2665588558,
0.4142070711,
0.6002749801,
1.0711599588,
-0.5775928497,
-0.3099367917,
-0.6887748837,
-0.6144811511,
0.5810703039,
-0.4171189964,
0.5270655155,
0.1660249233,
0.704875648,
0.1742699891,
0.5692949295,
-0.7734891176,
-0.0765798539,
0.1000771075,
-0.2475546151,
-0.3543630242,
-0.3630691171,
0.2712778449,
-0.0160352364,
1.0656869411,
-0.0463939048,
0.0954841897,
-0.2050176859,
-0.3526847959,
0.1724123806,
0.3214673698,
0.1837702245,
1.1443662643,
-0.0025235228,
-0.3217487633,
0.235490799,
-0.5042675138,
0.2029556334,
0.0503797643,
-0.1393054873,
-0.0916662216,
0.1611753404,
1.0325706005,
0.1300997436,
-0.8504133224,
0.5249239802,
0.0025000952,
-0.3905908167,
-0.2052683681,
0.0215254761,
0.1123175919,
0.0432686508,
0.2558173835,
-0.5049676299,
-0.2229814976,
-0.8248720169,
0.016760746,
0.2676642239,
-0.121717602,
-0.3115904927,
0.6313077211,
0.1682551205,
-0.0943069011,
0.6180157661,
-0.0258920044,
-0.6409007907,
0.5115461946,
0.7500319481,
0.817933023,
-0.2757998407,
0.0951914117,
0.0669502541,
0.1949176043,
-0.1336900145,
0.4036415815,
0.2264366895,
-0.9940983057,
-0.5273501873,
-0.5121186972,
-0.89033252,
0.5736231804,
-0.6699370742,
0.2375079393,
-0.7471795082,
-0.2393269688,
-0.1950297654,
0.5316202641,
-0.7287268043,
0.7088451982,
-0.1234382018,
0.7692730427,
-0.7276496887,
1.0673300028,
0.9377703071,
-0.5255748034,
-0.8466516137,
0.0633376464,
-0.8296716213,
-0.8653013706,
0.7321823835,
0.063676171,
0.0709277764,
0.3057119846,
-0.3842787743,
-0.930193603,
0.9009868503,
0.3866905868,
-0.6682914495,
0.1439223737,
0.3955645561,
0.6704823375,
-0.3753468096,
-0.1326866448,
0.5204588175,
0.2033948004,
-0.2832826674,
-0.6820807457,
-0.2208531201,
-0.2877268791,
0.2092527449,
0.1639222503,
-0.7615150213,
0.4684818387,
0.0906651244,
-0.1518302411,
0.0277163461,
0.6572480798,
0.1654254347,
0.2187565416,
0.2547205985,
0.6190956235,
1.0685961246,
-0.0356046408,
0.922647357,
-0.6169359088,
-0.0339939371,
1.2808995247,
-0.8657081723,
1.0638746023,
0.0721664429,
-0.2330375612,
0.7198671699,
0.6108260155,
-0.1113957986,
0.4305111468,
0.1372403055,
-0.2240275145,
-0.2647387087,
-0.051220566,
-0.4793540835,
0.2464092821,
0.1183258072,
-0.0505470298,
0.2858979702,
0.12419568,
0.149906829,
-0.1560343802,
-0.3891252875,
0.8993368745,
0.1412537396,
-0.8054820299,
0.383486867,
0.2640480101,
0.3906463981,
-1.0137723684,
0.5472556353,
-0.3360599875,
0.1257546395,
0.1864417791,
-0.5184763074,
0.1787160188,
0.2394049615,
-0.1596754044,
-0.2871911228,
0.6380275488,
-0.5303262472,
-0.1790411025,
0.1804310977,
0.3434272707,
0.2157945782,
-0.1803848445,
-0.6548585892,
-0.0911465138,
-0.1577347368,
-0.2618401945,
0.4001675546,
0.5656984448,
-0.0534657687,
0.7262275815,
0.6419190168,
0.1954865158,
0.194471404,
0.6071767211,
0.6918408275,
-0.8372266293,
-0.7474851608,
-0.2821480334,
0.1350706071,
-0.0578528307,
-0.3500938416,
0.7869826555,
0.5593464375,
1.1272230148,
-0.3106081784,
0.8603698015,
0.5325389504,
0.4172339439,
-0.7298458815,
0.7184409499,
-0.7250883579,
0.103076458,
0.0570029356,
-1.021263361,
-0.0568054244,
0.4481995106,
-0.5108216405,
0.4467589855,
0.8908832073,
0.66184479,
0.1884969324,
0.0931046084,
0.5506125689,
0.4540412724,
0.244584322,
0.556143105,
0.7812110186,
-0.4113403857,
0.2573726773,
-0.0561988726,
-0.0515255406,
-0.0911575183,
-0.8433052301,
-0.7991254926,
-0.3738608658,
-0.8412249088,
-0.1139690578,
0.0476243161,
0.6362389922,
0.5541892052,
-0.6582630873,
-0.4403239489,
0.1202615872,
-0.2274283171,
-0.1110221818,
-0.2067531943,
0.0412768163,
-0.6437974572,
-0.5212031603,
0.3847979307,
0.2800542414,
0.2439533621,
-0.112774156,
0.0822401345,
-0.2350918949,
0.3472650647,
0.5606338382,
0.2303942889,
-0.1072408333,
0.0549781844,
0.0363591164,
-0.0239336584,
0.1053230315,
0.8071270585,
-0.4218931496,
0.1954908967,
0.2804936469,
1.1571803093,
0.6608229876,
-0.0567979664,
0.7982077599,
-0.6142539382,
0.0292384289,
0.0450078696,
0.3834043145,
0.4824074507,
-0.3365314007,
0.2252991498,
0.3800930381,
-0.4930799007,
-0.4677985013,
0.2718707025,
-0.668507278,
-0.5384866595,
0.9601494074,
-0.2571027577,
-0.4157138169,
-0.3546269834,
0.0087469602,
0.1633802354,
0.1543512195,
0.5494046807,
0.8624883294,
0.3672337532,
-0.0771607459,
-0.4050605297,
0.3643516004,
0.4047307074,
-1.1905215979,
0.0952486917,
0.2892476916,
0.5787032843,
-0.2473143339,
1.0712651014,
-0.0085126432,
0.4238905907,
-0.1839205772,
0.1338976473,
0.1071234196,
-0.3904154897,
-0.378703773,
0.1250016838,
0.6323599815,
0.0429374799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08259v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08259v1
|
Investigating Neural Machine Translation for Low-Resource Languages: Using Bavarian as a Case Study
| 2024-04-12T06:16:26 | 2024-04-12T06:16:26 |
Wan-Hua Her, Udo Kruschwitz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Machine Translation has made impressive progress in recent years offering
close to human-level performance on many languages, but studies have primarily
focused on high-resource languages with broad online presence and resources.
With the help of growing Large Language Models, more and more low-resource
languages achieve better results through the presence of other languages.
However, studies have shown that not all low-resource languages can benefit
from multilingual systems, especially those with insufficient training and
evaluation data. In this paper, we revisit state-of-the-art Neural Machine
Translation techniques to develop automatic translation systems between German
and Bavarian. We investigate conditions of low-resource languages such as data
scarcity and parameter sensitivity and focus on refined solutions that combat
low-resource difficulties and creative solutions such as harnessing language
similarity. Our experiment entails applying Back-translation and Transfer
Learning to automatically generate more training data and achieve higher
translation performance. We demonstrate noisiness in the data and present our
approach to carry out text preprocessing extensively. Evaluation was conducted
using combined metrics: BLEU, chrF and TER. Statistical significance results
with Bonferroni correction show surprisingly high baseline systems, and that
Back-translation leads to significant improvement. Furthermore, we present a
qualitative analysis of translation errors and system limitations.
|
[
-0.4397405684,
-0.553996861,
0.5844734311,
0.2295611203,
-0.290299654,
0.0698631033,
-0.6250048876,
-0.3642666638,
0.059290424,
0.1756676137,
-0.3925800025,
-0.3882125318,
-0.6778317094,
0.4021064341,
-0.3096000254,
0.8575626612,
-0.2038780004,
0.4943081439,
0.1028774828,
-0.5365693569,
-0.4968354404,
-0.8069904447,
-0.6746585369,
-0.5439711213,
0.7209977508,
0.2893002629,
0.6374419332,
0.6222205162,
0.5824445486,
0.3079938591,
-0.1067903936,
0.1014384553,
-0.2961649001,
0.0615476146,
-0.1513851434,
-0.3209606707,
-0.3514475226,
-0.4294314384,
0.8105108738,
0.9189472795,
0.2408341318,
0.2527408004,
0.2050669491,
0.5750569105,
-0.7043016553,
0.0950479209,
-0.4761542082,
0.234890148,
-0.2021474242,
-0.1151236147,
-0.3120596707,
-0.202337712,
0.0065860893,
-0.2942835689,
0.3933197856,
-0.0607769825,
0.6505603194,
0.3600936234,
-0.4491652846,
-0.0445113331,
-0.8955439925,
0.7988954782,
-0.7137425542,
0.5322211981,
0.2550861239,
0.1468142867,
-0.0395827107,
-0.4661231935,
-0.369507879,
-0.1933800578,
-0.2742600441,
0.0678825676,
-0.516143024,
-0.3709059656,
0.0636501089,
0.0708612874,
-0.6092784405,
0.3398933709,
-0.2101880163,
-0.2496273071,
0.3880842328,
0.1915623844,
-0.015631346,
-0.059835054,
-0.0641985908,
-0.3720968068,
-0.2900160253,
-0.0312935412,
0.3166430295,
0.5244635344,
-0.0706647485,
0.4183064699,
-0.2081375867,
0.6871965528,
-0.1436559111,
0.3743868172,
0.3785955608,
-0.5968272686,
-0.0496428087,
0.1103424802,
0.8165880442,
0.0307717193,
0.0911349878,
-0.4901342094,
-0.4842848778,
-0.1646366268,
0.2014729679,
-0.8252514601,
0.0512286648,
-0.1250709444,
-0.649235189,
-0.0966149569,
-0.3758610785,
-0.6076933146,
-0.1969112158,
-0.1550189406,
0.2766839564,
-0.6457047462,
-0.1510312557,
-0.0086580627,
0.0573116429,
-0.0278591011,
0.1217075884,
-0.9514921904,
0.2496457547,
0.2468896061,
0.9865692258,
-0.2939973474,
-0.4946233332,
-0.4574595988,
-0.0565455444,
-0.5574694872,
0.6424403191,
-0.134777233,
-0.3325600624,
0.0111960052,
0.0306180026,
-0.0844386518,
-0.6554541588,
0.507674396,
-0.6668637991,
-0.1214568019,
-0.0735195577,
-0.1621205807,
-0.0897141844,
0.1916629225,
-0.7131763101,
0.7728891373,
0.078359805,
-0.5352248549,
0.1206007525,
-0.5286444426,
-1.0563181639,
-0.0256540384,
0.0788142458,
-0.2331162244,
0.5279160142,
0.0748003498,
0.2703764141,
-0.3731423318,
0.0056168493,
-0.082975626,
-0.4017904699,
0.4300157726,
-0.8169463873,
0.6471783519,
0.2841824591,
-0.3455842137,
0.0502547584,
-0.6555075645,
0.3163400292,
0.179455027,
-0.5814039707,
-0.2871620059,
-0.4413726926,
0.3214742243,
0.2620086968,
0.3532575369,
-0.2553702295,
-0.1122216806,
-0.3759556115,
0.5554141402,
0.4026623368,
-0.2216208279,
0.7128572464,
-0.0645367652,
0.4929721355,
0.106693469,
-0.1795605719,
0.0294469502,
-0.2105408013,
-0.8738362193,
0.0599470139,
0.6452681422,
0.6779469252,
-1.0104519129,
0.3395176828,
-0.4038790762,
-0.3424793482,
-0.8504697084,
0.2016716748,
0.44233796,
0.5090329647,
0.5582157969,
-0.4375162423,
-0.2005327493,
-1.192995429,
-0.1156819239,
0.057232406,
-0.0936044529,
0.2308105528,
0.3246878088,
-0.1366584003,
0.3571836054,
-0.2327895015,
-0.2212460935,
-0.0951707736,
0.190820545,
0.1519223601,
0.5601923466,
0.5205824971,
-0.6849454641,
-0.2589799464,
0.4098204076,
-0.8109419942,
0.1671352834,
-0.0080959452,
-0.1795619279,
0.6470755339,
0.3447482586,
-0.5796992779,
0.1247439384,
0.6943282485,
0.0462802872,
0.2801000774,
-0.5471247435,
0.2881306112,
-0.9484189749,
0.4165067971,
-0.0593471937,
-0.1198775992,
-0.5784553289,
-0.0640267581,
0.0132235074,
-0.2536525726,
-0.6075308323,
0.5305680633,
-0.3072131276,
-0.2227512151,
-0.3580566645,
-0.0287928507,
-0.2198038995,
0.635679543,
-0.021752378,
0.6664019823,
0.1879395694,
-0.5591109395,
0.409267813,
0.1011611372,
-0.0397045612,
0.5841426253,
-0.2049036771,
0.2116719633,
0.060120482,
-0.0266756807,
-0.593886137,
-0.1135652438,
0.4334231019,
-0.5717482567,
0.3439128995,
-0.1201381013,
-0.8210799098,
-0.1813772321,
0.3714708984,
0.5481638312,
0.5468947291,
-0.1277551651,
0.3051606715,
0.0685969964,
-0.3016178012,
-0.3057225645,
-0.9857860208,
0.3054821193,
-0.16262272,
-0.4591936469,
0.3029460311,
0.1812940091,
-0.1964597404,
0.3213890493,
-0.1035790592,
-0.4185622633,
0.1893461347,
-0.2406646162,
0.1055083573,
-0.452406913,
0.4359205663,
0.0513854958,
-0.240804702,
-0.1398570687,
-0.7541022301,
0.5798729062,
-0.5285666585,
-0.3321540952,
-0.445422411,
0.4023967683,
0.302387774,
-0.3006654382,
0.707269311,
0.8731339574,
-0.5756815672,
0.0799164101,
-0.2976593971,
-0.4571979046,
-0.3849460185,
0.5816915631,
-0.5264143348,
-0.6792711616,
0.3745266795,
-0.1153731048,
-0.1276327074,
0.5677446723,
0.7073574662,
-0.1717630625,
1.0698831081,
0.7116978765,
0.0225721393,
0.4146809578,
-0.1257842034,
0.1814487725,
-0.2112725675,
0.0467605852,
-0.6414383054,
-0.6287533045,
-0.8160111904,
-0.217181474,
0.1565202624,
0.1744426936,
-0.0095671564,
0.7161542773,
-0.2606031895,
0.198391661,
0.7744193673,
-0.0668425709,
0.4734027982,
0.1534437537,
-0.1764168441,
-0.1876037717,
-1.1536928415,
-0.5341556072,
0.7030708194,
-0.0233771987,
0.2703323066,
-0.079165034,
0.7347384095,
0.2671970427,
0.3821181059,
-0.8774715066,
0.3096354008,
-0.4386054575,
-0.4974595308,
-0.5241566896,
-0.7361865044,
-0.9714718461,
0.3879604936,
-0.3832882047,
-0.2551528811,
0.0863584056,
0.1595138013,
-0.3156786263,
0.2790322304,
-0.8431142569,
0.9640977979,
-0.7078897953,
-0.3921696544,
-0.4021390676,
-0.6512485147,
-0.054954119,
-0.438609302,
0.1649587601,
0.1879074574,
0.0098762559,
0.3619365096,
-0.0507289134,
0.5740557313,
0.114236258,
-0.1303942651,
-0.0653093234,
0.150925383,
0.2593111992,
-0.2555055916,
-0.2319738418,
0.5291230083,
-0.0970758572,
-0.5889335871,
-0.6637482047,
0.7038677335,
-0.6014523506,
-0.4159601033,
-0.2555877566,
-0.7186142802,
-0.223622486,
0.6394833326,
0.4820818305,
-0.1629560739,
-0.2481791973,
0.1241323873,
0.3709739149,
-0.1949513108,
0.588316679,
0.5191756487,
0.1956593841,
-0.3669551313,
1.0888041258,
0.315523535,
-0.0342250057,
0.1286769658,
-0.0711411908,
-0.1173003986,
-0.5960022807,
-1.1189444065,
0.1142778844,
-0.4884512126,
-0.1439605951,
-0.4379077256,
-0.1606183797,
-0.2694595754,
-0.0878364518,
-0.4843057394,
-0.4518760145,
-0.2299467325,
0.2023869604,
-0.0460904241,
0.4927855432,
-0.097542733,
0.3726455569,
-1.1292382479,
-0.0145506244,
-0.192049861,
0.2193553448,
0.2042492181,
-0.3209467828,
-0.8348701596,
0.0228551365,
-0.4459775388,
-0.7809711099,
0.5246905088,
-0.1564616859,
0.4883251786,
-0.1240040064,
0.0679513142,
0.3778728843,
-0.6573300958,
0.1939966232,
0.2065057158,
-0.8536743522,
0.2394462377,
-0.1353315264,
0.3253332973,
0.5298221111,
0.2787885964,
-0.6797497869,
-0.1953321546,
-0.5465158224,
-0.7524041533,
0.7004537582,
0.5058629513,
0.3388833106,
0.332290709,
0.2587154806,
0.1226657629,
0.3876912296,
-0.4299171567,
-0.0902744234,
-0.1152286828,
-0.0805082768,
-0.3426485956,
0.4268788695,
-0.087163806,
0.1199012995,
0.6203549504,
-0.1279643178,
0.0350151248,
-0.0072464668,
-0.2728225291,
-0.2184937447,
0.5293163657,
0.479147017,
0.3296019733,
0.1402565688,
0.1190611124,
0.6967537999,
-0.0367814936,
0.4858007133,
0.4911163449,
-0.3002495468,
0.1334210485,
0.4048726261,
0.7999060154,
0.0808309689,
-0.4212819636,
0.2175802737,
-0.0270781144,
-0.0287708491,
-0.1073477492,
-0.2935701013,
0.2861592472,
0.4404267669,
0.3057011068,
0.4647966623,
0.043831978,
-0.3326533735,
0.0833392665,
0.2723041177,
-0.5537223816,
-0.3807197213,
0.3856686056,
0.2507812679,
-0.5292162299,
0.7665575147,
-0.30816257,
-0.3984395564,
0.5160340667,
0.5025767088,
0.7813785076,
0.0575700365,
0.1240559965,
0.112150006,
0.4151349962,
-0.0410008356,
0.0315213911,
-0.0716772228,
-0.5967053771,
-0.4830271006,
-0.5445314646,
-0.2219285667,
0.1843160689,
-0.6157298684,
0.2385539263,
-0.246822983,
-0.6234096289,
-0.2132325321,
-0.1230466813,
-0.880669415,
-0.0074264286,
0.1809195876,
0.6837161183,
-0.7884042859,
0.895144999,
0.8349813223,
-0.421634078,
-0.3503287733,
0.1901131421,
-0.3236129284,
-0.5979914665,
0.8182522655,
-0.0900584385,
-0.3929968774,
0.2243495733,
-0.0332841948,
-0.5853443742,
0.6899738908,
0.7837093472,
-0.48882851,
-0.2192816883,
0.1786757857,
1.001680851,
-0.0598746836,
-0.2826005518,
0.5821866989,
0.6256476641,
-0.2149222046,
-0.7848688364,
0.0428221188,
-0.244448036,
-0.0567727722,
0.2238753736,
-0.7243786454,
0.6252825856,
-0.1426882595,
-0.2513869405,
0.206283018,
0.6008068919,
-0.1031272039,
0.3893645704,
0.2334502637,
0.4694582224,
0.5201538205,
-0.0337733328,
0.9572486877,
-0.4857726097,
0.2091518939,
1.0121139288,
-0.2917301953,
0.7984588742,
0.6672180891,
0.1747572422,
0.0339418463,
0.5761583447,
-0.1293100566,
0.5295088887,
0.3297805786,
-0.2731550932,
-0.3437823057,
-0.4548119903,
-0.3405998647,
0.462015599,
0.0089263385,
-0.3500299156,
-0.2401942164,
0.0982541218,
-0.0452568121,
0.0989117622,
-0.032962434,
0.64130795,
0.2174113989,
-0.6892367601,
0.8163244128,
0.3546947539,
0.5014632344,
-0.3990330696,
0.0207862761,
-0.3636433184,
0.3597409725,
0.0082837027,
-0.5012918711,
0.4454915822,
0.1802217364,
-0.2152982354,
-0.4329471588,
0.5717048645,
-0.3202062547,
-0.5680975914,
0.638333261,
1.0057715178,
0.2003852576,
0.0328289792,
-0.4585994184,
-0.1387711912,
-0.2436492443,
-0.0361482799,
0.4248738885,
0.6198337078,
-0.1685239971,
0.3618671,
0.5875540376,
0.4109603465,
-0.0663606301,
-0.0499555878,
0.6353800893,
-0.6249466538,
-0.4143893421,
-0.9057172537,
0.029451428,
0.1838134527,
-0.3928025067,
0.6284486651,
0.5894358158,
1.2320798635,
-0.1297237873,
0.8612295985,
0.218734026,
0.0390660502,
-0.4937354624,
1.0813385248,
-0.6650818586,
-0.2264743745,
0.0056898915,
-1.0354079008,
-0.3639519215,
0.3472193182,
-0.233266443,
-0.0445988439,
0.7042400837,
0.4851489365,
-0.1315326691,
-0.2623355985,
0.5555492043,
0.0812253878,
-0.0785087571,
0.6743150949,
0.7622491717,
-0.3278806806,
1.0677753687,
-0.3180209696,
-0.0275920387,
-0.2611409426,
-0.6060978174,
-0.5009645224,
-0.4643178582,
0.0265075583,
-0.4368554354,
0.2872830927,
0.7119134665,
0.6542652845,
-0.9244922996,
-0.433557719,
0.0880243778,
0.0405588187,
-0.2958056331,
-0.0898885578,
0.3313271999,
-0.5361389518,
-0.8307339549,
0.533639729,
0.0877265856,
0.3516992331,
-0.183735922,
-0.2927850485,
0.0232363157,
-0.2624846995,
0.4238426089,
0.234732464,
-0.4276632667,
-0.0730402842,
0.359087646,
-0.47707057,
0.1493635178,
1.0007106066,
-0.5605344176,
0.1297438592,
0.5434451699,
1.1682249308,
0.6393321753,
-0.2801571488,
0.6855234504,
-0.7622801065,
0.2155365646,
0.3286039531,
0.3560171425,
0.6054782867,
-0.2256251574,
0.3714462519,
0.2762424052,
-0.1954132318,
-0.5853511691,
0.3140469491,
-0.2608193457,
-0.2957698405,
0.7169595361,
-0.213001281,
-0.1045113131,
0.1305610836,
-0.0091860648,
0.8001554608,
-0.363450706,
0.7923412919,
1.0636079311,
-0.1621718109,
0.0697982684,
-0.5621010661,
0.1935934871,
0.7831630707,
-0.6375700831,
-0.0300479885,
0.477170825,
-0.0138824973,
0.3706635535,
0.348572433,
0.0402891487,
0.2213601619,
0.0662381724,
0.0266919341,
0.0703135058,
-0.2450721264,
-0.846647501,
0.0218339711,
0.0071694329,
-0.261850208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08191v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08191v1
|
Measuring Cross-lingual Transfer in Bytes
| 2024-04-12T01:44:46 | 2024-04-12T01:44:46 |
Leandro Rodrigues de Souza, Thales Sales Almeida, Roberto Lotufo, Rodrigo Nogueira
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multilingual pretraining has been a successful solution to the challenges
posed by the lack of resources for languages. These models can transfer
knowledge to target languages with minimal or no examples. Recent research
suggests that monolingual models also have a similar capability, but the
mechanisms behind this transfer remain unclear. Some studies have explored
factors like language contamination and syntactic similarity. An emerging line
of research suggests that the representations learned by language models
contain two components: a language-specific and a language-agnostic component.
The latter is responsible for transferring a more universal knowledge. However,
there is a lack of comprehensive exploration of these properties across diverse
target languages. To investigate this hypothesis, we conducted an experiment
inspired by the work on the Scaling Laws for Transfer. We measured the amount
of data transferred from a source language to a target language and found that
models initialized from diverse languages perform similarly to a target
language in a cross-lingual setting. This was surprising because the amount of
data transferred to 10 diverse target languages, such as Spanish, Korean, and
Finnish, was quite similar. We also found evidence that this transfer is not
related to language contamination or language proximity, which strengthens the
hypothesis that the model also relies on language-agnostic knowledge. Our
experiments have opened up new possibilities for measuring how much data
represents the language-agnostic representations learned during pretraining.
|
[
-0.4670728147,
-0.3770285249,
0.4645553827,
0.2352141291,
-0.0465889275,
0.0128844986,
-0.1664988846,
-0.7334746718,
0.496268183,
0.2697278559,
-0.3968533278,
0.0498431399,
-0.6644887924,
0.0716892481,
-0.5066693425,
0.8241750002,
-0.3458721936,
0.2487346828,
-0.1372909844,
-0.3106150925,
-0.2779607475,
-0.5284873247,
-0.1353937536,
-0.4909856319,
0.3944895267,
0.2227512896,
0.5629956126,
0.5506402254,
0.365149349,
0.2351612747,
0.3717277348,
-0.5845743418,
-0.3884276152,
-0.3941041231,
-0.5566552281,
-0.7757974267,
-0.2288490534,
0.0750607997,
0.9319366813,
1.1530739069,
0.0977604166,
0.3763794005,
-0.0321529806,
0.4694057107,
-0.6264032722,
-0.0712652877,
-0.6202523708,
0.3333132565,
-0.3307724595,
-0.1370046288,
-0.5734497309,
-0.1396449804,
0.2461971343,
-0.8919871449,
0.2169596851,
-0.0275111143,
0.7570369244,
-0.158924073,
-0.6681472063,
-0.3718299568,
-0.783646524,
0.7785295248,
-0.2938455045,
0.6747634411,
0.3449833393,
0.1357972771,
0.3714187443,
-0.4966272712,
-0.5102667809,
-0.2533611953,
-0.1940099448,
-0.0269073751,
-0.4060155153,
-0.2012746334,
0.20475927,
0.194256708,
-0.4962156713,
-0.0138826938,
-0.5251477361,
-0.5260341763,
0.4159111381,
-0.1242917925,
0.6483748555,
0.1921866685,
-0.5823627114,
-0.2895491719,
-0.6462430954,
0.1007823199,
0.4004439116,
0.346026063,
-0.3008430898,
0.4150445461,
-0.0085536661,
0.5882575512,
0.016387675,
-0.0043185828,
0.3796510398,
-0.8002272844,
0.1842451841,
0.3301301897,
0.7432694435,
0.1067200527,
0.7157608271,
-0.4474437237,
0.0716108233,
0.0616693273,
0.2369076461,
-1.0875011683,
-0.1938581318,
-0.4053348005,
-0.4298840165,
0.0901526064,
-0.1072090939,
-0.5292879343,
-0.1444263756,
-0.1854951084,
0.6311271191,
-0.5695214272,
-0.7820101976,
0.2377769053,
-0.0474625416,
0.2045902908,
0.0452445224,
-1.3554564714,
0.3281976581,
0.2908731997,
0.6606550217,
-0.3725248873,
-0.7208281159,
-0.2556006312,
0.17149131,
-0.4125751257,
0.7611867785,
-0.6610117555,
-0.2463310063,
-0.0729158148,
0.0541372746,
-0.3239783347,
-0.3907489181,
-0.2674054503,
-0.4175758958,
-0.0479270406,
-0.6062855124,
-0.5068950057,
-0.2421935946,
0.2075624168,
-0.5921624899,
0.6049697399,
0.2210198939,
-0.6562604308,
0.6137682796,
-0.3131600618,
-0.6140048504,
-0.0369529054,
-0.254894942,
0.0963542759,
0.2613067031,
-0.1724360734,
0.2056150734,
-0.1954725534,
0.012356828,
-0.5227968693,
-0.2197899967,
0.2606805563,
-0.365545243,
0.8000044227,
0.1432228535,
-0.2944181263,
-0.0966701582,
-0.7171394825,
0.1999585927,
0.000076897,
-0.3095690012,
-0.5505832434,
-0.4709632695,
-0.1240626499,
0.192991212,
0.3624500036,
-0.7173116207,
0.2595151663,
-0.0189181734,
0.18314372,
0.48068887,
-0.3318663836,
0.8746660948,
-0.1085728332,
0.6448235512,
0.268522799,
-0.1816473305,
-0.3241938651,
-0.1214319319,
-0.551805675,
0.013083946,
0.3705997765,
0.3988149166,
-0.5170425177,
-0.0401369072,
-0.6103585958,
-0.4424870014,
-0.7530955672,
0.0989063755,
0.3587961197,
0.3338892162,
0.3564774394,
-0.5958102345,
-0.3108793795,
-1.0545794964,
-0.5035107732,
-0.3319260478,
0.0783041716,
0.0899371654,
0.4199842513,
-0.249792546,
0.7432686687,
-0.0720237419,
-0.0102263046,
-0.1996633261,
0.2988381386,
-0.0851049125,
0.6027128696,
0.9382682443,
-0.656953156,
-0.8333883286,
0.4146930277,
-0.5767406821,
-0.0752088428,
-0.0622809008,
-0.1439266205,
0.0647462979,
0.4472615421,
-0.4358265102,
0.2862430811,
0.7193032503,
-0.6203872561,
0.7738286853,
-0.2401242107,
0.4049604237,
-0.8252902627,
0.3539948165,
-0.3112772703,
-0.3271716833,
-0.8969879746,
-0.1119868606,
0.3833296895,
0.0509223081,
-0.5964633226,
0.756462574,
-0.6402956247,
-0.4229650795,
-0.1706023067,
-0.2103391141,
0.0215377323,
0.2963397801,
0.3000217676,
0.9119881392,
0.7551656961,
-0.6242527962,
0.1022792757,
0.0235863533,
-0.4136961997,
0.5913977027,
-0.5247706771,
0.0777669474,
0.074265562,
-0.173275426,
-1.0066462755,
0.0805683583,
0.0144090224,
-0.4339237809,
0.314180702,
-0.3044720292,
-0.215756759,
0.1350096017,
0.1502382755,
0.8184928298,
0.399066925,
-0.2772978246,
0.5452163219,
0.378970623,
-0.1972056776,
-0.5836946964,
-0.9968219995,
-0.2430411428,
-0.2371874601,
-0.5655453801,
0.2895630896,
-0.1147208959,
-0.0659621507,
0.2218184322,
-0.2388077527,
-0.2318744659,
0.1234440431,
-0.1398936659,
0.0955572724,
-0.408207655,
0.0143424673,
-0.1043646932,
0.0401473641,
0.4860687852,
-0.4926840663,
0.6053366065,
-0.2634220123,
-0.6043663025,
0.0580930412,
0.2613307536,
0.6310727,
-0.3621347249,
0.8133084774,
0.743555069,
-0.2363500893,
0.0257799923,
-0.3589499891,
-0.0736519247,
-0.4136307836,
0.5729481578,
-0.7647252679,
-0.6887496114,
0.9530624747,
0.0197653901,
-0.2249584198,
0.341942817,
0.3448253572,
0.33704862,
0.8079288006,
0.9266211987,
-0.1056660563,
0.5802681446,
0.0515284576,
0.0479032621,
-0.4742271006,
-0.0031300313,
-0.5667652488,
-0.238128081,
-0.4880666733,
-0.2930886447,
0.0096262991,
0.2061235309,
-0.1616786867,
0.531627357,
0.059522137,
0.6046229005,
0.3416679502,
-0.3285022676,
0.2103241682,
0.3226979375,
-0.4449883699,
-0.0325712897,
-0.732147336,
-0.062770009,
1.2250759602,
0.2576600909,
0.7444834709,
0.118534714,
0.5159066916,
0.0761591047,
0.4012932181,
-0.5124889016,
0.3205788732,
-0.2297302186,
-0.7947012782,
-0.2898347676,
-0.7164910436,
-1.0022007227,
0.4069860876,
-0.1299932301,
-0.7792956829,
0.2406632155,
-0.0413412265,
0.0187482741,
0.4490657449,
-0.7549039721,
1.1109758615,
-0.3671536446,
-0.4144567847,
-0.372399509,
-0.5269970894,
0.0965893716,
-0.3612161279,
0.2839850485,
0.0210070834,
0.1646752059,
0.8787254095,
-0.058830075,
0.5380831957,
-0.1557913125,
-0.2942026258,
0.213702634,
0.5152922869,
0.1988321096,
-0.3824530542,
-0.0094309114,
0.3584106565,
0.3268269002,
-0.6595568061,
-0.4508184195,
0.370310843,
-0.8901068568,
-0.2984320223,
-0.2280227244,
-0.6485242844,
-0.1838612258,
0.7661978006,
0.3567712903,
0.1607827693,
-0.2103049606,
0.1527111381,
0.6481348872,
-0.0893626809,
0.2316221744,
1.049597621,
-0.6035995483,
0.1487112343,
1.0181758404,
0.3296445012,
0.7278280854,
0.4860236943,
0.1484504193,
-0.3057180941,
-0.6033775806,
-0.6830649376,
0.219205752,
-0.734536469,
0.2967372537,
-0.5492693782,
-0.0315521993,
-0.5576322675,
-0.1454818547,
-0.7375871539,
-0.2821889818,
-0.0554286465,
-0.0863441899,
-0.0390135013,
0.6190463305,
-0.2453431934,
0.1098557189,
-1.0125608444,
0.217989713,
0.1926919371,
0.3814191818,
0.0069133448,
-0.6777454615,
-0.440636456,
0.2248615474,
0.2046990544,
-1.0562033653,
0.3452092707,
0.1910920143,
0.754085362,
0.3379392326,
-0.1357170343,
0.8054007888,
-0.4847695529,
0.4838801324,
0.4722477794,
-1.1798396111,
0.1615729779,
-0.2150850743,
0.384480685,
0.7538079023,
0.7670868039,
-0.6286558509,
-0.1450915933,
-0.4084782004,
-0.4742135108,
0.7554141283,
-0.2337182313,
0.1458494663,
0.1702144295,
0.0979522541,
0.4059722722,
0.229688853,
-0.8737767935,
-0.1644337922,
-0.1824011505,
0.0533304363,
-0.2300328165,
0.0507742278,
0.2413458526,
-0.2243694663,
0.2765903771,
-0.1918659508,
0.1118821502,
0.1367768794,
-0.5431140065,
-0.2837908268,
0.2808369994,
0.2765423059,
0.7257112265,
0.0526980273,
0.5486040711,
0.2429335266,
-0.8914169669,
0.5546293855,
-0.0087461919,
-0.2103088051,
-0.1400290877,
0.5091082454,
0.8448165059,
0.1764122099,
-0.5632995367,
0.4678365886,
-0.0631986707,
-0.094500564,
-0.105631128,
-0.0662512332,
0.1509845257,
-0.0278883372,
0.1807779521,
0.1325596571,
0.0774631724,
-0.8636425734,
0.3120420277,
0.4305970669,
-0.3796259165,
-0.8975459933,
0.4536404908,
0.0433184728,
0.1134524718,
0.6479984522,
-0.2624437809,
-0.5486658812,
0.5988473892,
0.7966212034,
0.4956635237,
-0.5341754556,
0.2204594463,
0.3806967437,
0.5147090554,
-0.0960806981,
0.0440884158,
-0.196751982,
-1.035420537,
-0.4822511077,
-0.6151255965,
-0.0832524002,
-0.0441007726,
-0.950660646,
0.087279439,
0.0175819993,
0.0319261961,
0.1735428572,
0.0783033073,
-0.988473475,
-0.0585630275,
0.35151124,
0.8712981343,
-1.2171541452,
1.0089108944,
0.8860125542,
-0.2939991653,
-0.8537916541,
-0.1976894438,
-0.3232759535,
-1.0150185823,
0.7687978745,
0.2499833107,
-0.1250710934,
-0.0600741766,
-0.041133251,
-1.1095331907,
0.7112022042,
0.7698674798,
-0.5744719505,
-0.0350379348,
0.7277703285,
0.5542451739,
-0.4435546696,
0.3991759717,
0.4771721661,
0.5092697144,
-0.0618573688,
-1.2551068068,
0.1711869687,
-0.3687725663,
-0.3484123945,
0.2512537241,
-0.4744330347,
1.2237222195,
-0.2039522976,
-0.4068168998,
-0.4892810881,
0.5578879118,
-0.0614097938,
0.2074565142,
0.5412703156,
0.515896678,
0.7244718075,
0.2751998007,
1.0163345337,
-0.4816854,
0.138586849,
0.7779583335,
-0.4476532042,
0.6078759432,
0.6169896126,
-0.3706980944,
0.4235338569,
0.2650960684,
0.1956164986,
0.4998681545,
0.2637544572,
-0.0859221816,
-0.3048523366,
-0.1489072591,
-0.4243521392,
0.3516851962,
0.2392365932,
-0.140480265,
-0.3090922534,
0.2684593499,
0.1408237666,
-0.1927839667,
-0.4145880044,
0.5801908374,
-0.0320584029,
-0.9451488256,
0.7324960828,
-0.2801546156,
0.6775404215,
-0.9516008496,
0.1648984998,
-0.2156840414,
0.2331087887,
-0.1102359965,
-0.8376265168,
0.52772367,
-0.0129046375,
-0.26610744,
-0.5385263562,
0.9436120391,
-0.7160838842,
-0.2605300546,
0.7358607054,
0.6970700622,
0.5291230679,
-0.0132607063,
-0.335768044,
0.024272237,
0.3778749406,
-0.1930382699,
0.8566262722,
0.6075792313,
-0.056410253,
0.5259800553,
0.4802526236,
0.4729126692,
0.5651452541,
-0.1791509688,
0.5457994342,
-0.5198942423,
-0.6487345099,
-0.7302790284,
0.1829766482,
0.3652633131,
-0.1795901507,
1.058874011,
0.5093359351,
1.1789799929,
-0.1553738564,
0.8988754749,
-0.1395890117,
0.1314316392,
-0.3776789606,
0.7916304469,
-0.6414422989,
-0.1117456034,
0.0339828469,
-0.9485933185,
0.3123478293,
0.5393579006,
-0.2939461768,
-0.0408947691,
0.6582992077,
0.3814470172,
-0.4970723391,
-0.0828021243,
0.2807332873,
0.0766290128,
0.1641318947,
0.6972970963,
0.6391220093,
-0.211294353,
0.6359663606,
-0.1663153321,
-0.1656323075,
0.0253801253,
-0.8092225194,
-0.7102001905,
-0.6211416125,
-0.3516167104,
-0.1324505955,
-0.1040032655,
0.3804522157,
0.8444677591,
-0.6979575157,
-0.467151016,
-0.1795688868,
-0.2078333497,
-0.2113601267,
-0.1379156113,
0.1448542327,
-0.3635273874,
-0.4216746688,
0.3333638012,
-0.1272354871,
0.2898362279,
-0.4004510343,
0.001644088,
-0.116489239,
0.0111395605,
0.4166719019,
0.4272703826,
-0.1027215049,
-0.2977193594,
0.2027144432,
-0.1689382941,
-0.0404745489,
0.8919466734,
-0.721965909,
0.4496432245,
0.7342066169,
0.6878598928,
0.7111231685,
-0.3739514649,
0.5952280164,
-0.86829108,
0.3353273869,
-0.0609659478,
0.2865525484,
0.1534760445,
-0.0843603015,
0.3001284301,
0.2738873065,
-0.2539806068,
-0.8664188385,
0.3487533629,
-0.6499592066,
-0.3981516957,
1.1265909672,
-0.4458324015,
-0.2250314653,
0.0827674344,
0.3775881827,
0.2269787639,
0.0149562182,
0.4483624995,
1.0491911173,
0.0251278561,
0.0395005122,
-0.575340271,
0.2692768574,
0.6863651872,
-0.6815299392,
0.1654711068,
0.1972774714,
0.6216881275,
0.6504454017,
0.8113541603,
-0.1698162556,
0.1251060963,
0.4122785032,
0.2402001917,
0.0885562003,
-0.5077133775,
-0.2720289826,
0.0781091154,
-0.0913003236,
-0.0394139104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08189v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08189v1
|
Reducing hallucination in structured outputs via Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-04-12T01:42:09 | 2024-04-12T01:42:09 |
Patrice Béchard, Orlando Marquez Ayala
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
A common and fundamental limitation of Generative AI (GenAI) is its
propensity to hallucinate. While large language models (LLM) have taken the
world by storm, without eliminating or at least reducing hallucinations,
real-world GenAI systems may face challenges in user adoption. In the process
of deploying an enterprise application that produces workflows based on natural
language requirements, we devised a system leveraging Retrieval Augmented
Generation (RAG) to greatly improve the quality of the structured output that
represents such workflows. Thanks to our implementation of RAG, our proposed
system significantly reduces hallucinations in the output and improves the
generalization of our LLM in out-of-domain settings. In addition, we show that
using a small, well-trained retriever encoder can reduce the size of the
accompanying LLM, thereby making deployments of LLM-based systems less
resource-intensive.
|
[
-0.4958263338,
-0.6109318733,
0.4883593619,
0.0910803527,
-0.1792256385,
0.1467960924,
-0.2599955201,
-0.6248944998,
0.5698543191,
0.6948142648,
-0.2720242441,
-0.2922245562,
-0.5049561858,
0.3443404138,
-0.5094768405,
1.0249606371,
0.1264091879,
-0.3005467057,
-0.1404800415,
0.0940305889,
-0.4940921962,
-0.5264963508,
-0.7715987563,
-0.6050103903,
0.396299243,
0.2402402908,
0.8171631694,
0.406868428,
0.7288633585,
0.2930024266,
-0.0347114503,
0.570526123,
-0.6665160656,
0.4691128731,
-0.0941537172,
-0.2570971847,
-0.4598306417,
-0.3526667953,
0.5977615714,
0.759340167,
-0.4607824981,
0.0726175234,
0.1711589098,
0.8938542604,
-0.7530230284,
0.0699422583,
-0.4658923149,
0.1930439472,
-0.1115331203,
-0.4064162374,
-0.63014853,
-0.1159608662,
-0.1516230851,
-0.790151298,
0.4191304445,
0.1755024046,
0.9686338902,
0.5363076925,
-0.0374058373,
-0.1992037594,
-1.2406215668,
0.5869429708,
-0.6064774394,
0.3665871918,
0.3990991712,
0.2796050012,
-0.471165359,
-0.7407612801,
-0.5671601892,
-0.1520235389,
-0.3330987692,
0.0181760099,
-0.0076885638,
0.2314439565,
0.4828872681,
0.4825914204,
-0.8653313518,
-0.0111771654,
-0.4864078164,
-0.0981745794,
0.583943665,
0.2864406705,
0.1791623533,
-0.2505482435,
0.135153681,
-0.054857377,
-0.6581630111,
-0.5628724098,
0.1419819146,
0.2552170753,
0.3539709747,
0.7247041464,
-0.2744099498,
0.6031056046,
0.130970642,
-0.1236524209,
0.414301604,
0.0220384877,
-0.527962923,
-0.1037324592,
0.6269278526,
0.0282647256,
0.1391190886,
-0.4783614576,
-0.4205082953,
0.1513033509,
0.6947914362,
-0.9116210938,
-0.1249949187,
0.0837581828,
-0.5038256049,
-0.0783526078,
0.0661207363,
-0.8040133119,
-0.6828681231,
-0.3910195231,
0.3229703605,
-0.5079808235,
-0.0295622423,
-0.2909681201,
-0.2692898214,
0.4048627317,
0.284699142,
-0.9467512369,
0.299598366,
0.8192492127,
0.8850170374,
-0.1002847999,
0.0172059834,
-0.9134622216,
0.3981601298,
-0.4866765738,
0.6533458233,
-0.7207999825,
-0.4779877961,
-0.0867326111,
-0.1936578453,
-0.0141297802,
-1.1067401171,
0.3189299107,
-0.601223588,
0.1198826581,
0.261346072,
-0.4150927067,
-0.0311399885,
0.157577768,
-0.6094684601,
0.8985144496,
0.118768692,
-0.3946645856,
0.3941215277,
-0.5913597941,
-0.6716684699,
0.3936502934,
-0.3926510215,
-0.3335783482,
0.4229951203,
0.1243252307,
0.3558166921,
-0.3169446588,
0.2878635228,
0.0746522471,
-0.698255837,
-0.2442224324,
-0.2093866616,
0.4028686583,
0.4969202876,
-0.435256362,
0.0203127246,
-0.9648205638,
-0.1982881278,
0.1052005887,
-0.3428596258,
-0.4497359991,
0.0170932095,
-0.18592906,
-0.1260192245,
0.0415108278,
-0.3155654669,
0.2269455492,
-0.7008287311,
0.0218110085,
0.5798944831,
0.0349984877,
0.7222108841,
-0.2557834685,
0.6063578129,
-0.1386607587,
0.0463127941,
0.1882134229,
-0.3921481669,
-0.8307138681,
-0.4971560538,
-0.1196291894,
0.4830849469,
-1.2079149485,
0.3659217358,
-0.3076263964,
-0.2367372811,
-0.6328014135,
0.3696075976,
0.3759542108,
0.5913003683,
0.1960448474,
-0.2388372123,
-0.7282668948,
-0.9095537663,
0.0907988623,
-0.2365799397,
-0.4552682936,
0.2948461473,
0.4281964302,
-0.6852225065,
0.6840711832,
-0.3671866059,
-0.602229178,
-0.3724384606,
0.461160481,
0.3375183642,
0.3484959006,
0.1781933159,
-0.8805719018,
-0.2991809547,
0.0604847558,
-0.9244622588,
-0.1717812568,
-0.2674634159,
-0.2741616368,
0.6219832301,
0.2965910435,
-0.7605172396,
0.7160133123,
0.5087001324,
-0.2630865574,
0.4278720021,
-0.4654991925,
0.1460441202,
-1.1979558468,
0.2465500087,
-0.1937929243,
-0.164109692,
-0.654430151,
0.2104430944,
-0.2653113306,
-0.2873303294,
0.0417051129,
0.323790282,
-0.5011854172,
-0.2634077668,
-0.2994827032,
0.132004112,
0.3433280289,
0.442619592,
0.1302586794,
1.1312074661,
0.2716838419,
-0.8992527127,
0.2175798118,
0.6480924487,
-0.059778478,
0.4760972559,
-0.4769735038,
0.2503735423,
-0.4717111886,
0.1546438485,
-0.4439879358,
-0.5223690271,
0.3133668005,
-0.4245058596,
0.4538793266,
0.0545584708,
-0.5101908445,
-0.2637754381,
-0.1793022901,
0.0005353802,
0.8926087022,
-0.8230006099,
0.9212577939,
0.2263715565,
0.1009430662,
-0.3434595168,
-0.7907239199,
0.3800088763,
-0.1017414853,
-0.5889706612,
0.5218054056,
0.0651523024,
-0.2829973698,
-0.1196534261,
0.0286939647,
-0.0310491435,
0.06824705,
0.3631872833,
0.2301903218,
-0.087790072,
0.1335831136,
-0.1120443419,
0.1024604812,
0.0980890766,
-0.1173000708,
0.5186315775,
0.0627608076,
-0.2605099976,
-0.3691542149,
0.4373468161,
0.546795249,
-0.1748947799,
1.0276814699,
0.6376584768,
-0.5637080669,
-0.5210514069,
-0.4960685074,
-0.257081151,
-0.506604135,
0.2922749221,
-0.3653610945,
-0.7930445671,
0.5154585242,
-0.0512957722,
-0.0962048545,
0.3526345789,
0.4380654693,
-0.103272073,
1.1462554932,
0.5890003443,
0.0494151823,
0.3642466068,
-0.4773786962,
0.4927342534,
-1.1753386259,
-0.3869753182,
-0.5542320013,
-0.1126558781,
-0.5736652017,
-0.3348073363,
0.4287845194,
-0.0034812323,
-0.2534840405,
0.120856978,
-0.862908721,
0.3011180758,
0.5987550616,
0.0360533334,
0.2623077631,
0.1752818972,
0.1928091943,
0.0182180032,
-0.6350201368,
-0.6984730959,
0.7311367989,
0.1196651235,
0.8631893992,
0.2565563321,
1.1015449762,
0.5229471922,
0.3852235675,
-0.6202180982,
0.6173149347,
-0.3358098269,
-0.3187693655,
-0.5229153633,
-0.7734578848,
-1.0353627205,
0.1102984697,
-0.0948340744,
-0.6321511865,
0.3018328249,
0.1995747834,
-0.416213274,
0.3413135707,
-0.6118695736,
0.5800476074,
0.0968576223,
-0.3039339185,
-0.1576427817,
-0.2522743642,
0.3200986385,
-0.1105896905,
0.0986729413,
0.2127769738,
0.257604003,
0.6007153988,
-0.7197713852,
0.6701259017,
-0.2408652157,
-0.107709296,
0.376986593,
0.2373104692,
0.7513151765,
-0.1341249794,
-0.1283382326,
-0.1518231928,
-0.4198068976,
-0.1455620378,
-0.8620480299,
0.5320090652,
-0.559145987,
-0.6896138787,
-0.3764634728,
-0.5463804603,
-0.1562055051,
-0.0803864822,
0.3817675114,
0.4069926143,
-0.2286134809,
0.1135248616,
0.7808653712,
-0.3649557531,
0.3200326264,
0.056229163,
-0.3545656204,
-0.373018235,
1.0398800373,
0.0639663413,
0.1369671226,
0.285903275,
-0.0540666021,
-0.1053476781,
-0.5856032968,
-0.4196233451,
0.1958001703,
-0.5797353983,
-0.3431374431,
-0.4999889731,
-0.3392012119,
-0.6661701798,
-0.1242386624,
-0.1625163704,
-0.2709780335,
-0.669331491,
0.1271615177,
0.351939559,
0.9437970519,
-0.0211789235,
0.2165894955,
-0.7679151893,
0.7442399859,
0.331215471,
0.5871440172,
0.022559505,
-0.9432002306,
-0.3312596381,
-0.0584896766,
-0.0958054587,
-0.6789783239,
0.8670570254,
0.4996030927,
0.3923606873,
0.3911690414,
0.1315428317,
0.8694779873,
-0.5419695377,
0.6052882671,
-0.106344372,
-0.6909586191,
0.5782572031,
-0.1613035351,
0.0630438179,
0.4790565073,
0.054957971,
-0.368455857,
-0.5570504665,
-0.2190152854,
-0.8383612037,
0.5458180904,
0.3390895724,
0.1582878977,
-0.2595039606,
0.4819180965,
0.0099169025,
0.1210657805,
-0.3561415374,
0.0012383903,
-0.1469056755,
-0.1713047624,
0.0574082136,
-0.3957020938,
0.0071196295,
-0.151665017,
0.9898196459,
-0.0963540822,
0.3961230814,
0.3321320117,
-0.2450704277,
-0.134290114,
0.2815715969,
0.4317238331,
0.563228488,
-0.2469881624,
0.0809115022,
-0.0198678244,
-0.5313482285,
-0.0050417148,
-0.0002817641,
-0.5982934833,
0.2243454605,
0.1709392667,
0.9293212891,
-0.2677940428,
-0.651137352,
0.1744433492,
0.0676376969,
-0.1543149054,
-0.5426677465,
0.1697635502,
-0.2575238347,
0.3364113271,
0.5191637874,
-0.0017168918,
0.5485351086,
-0.4870193899,
0.074840866,
0.3823737204,
-0.0795006603,
0.0063183978,
0.7654391527,
0.1656870693,
-0.663931489,
0.9542885423,
-0.6045740247,
-0.3177957535,
0.4362213314,
0.7031438351,
1.2133694887,
0.0073665022,
0.4152614474,
0.2671105266,
0.4623118341,
-0.1413949132,
0.2734871209,
0.126920253,
-0.5085725784,
-0.693967402,
-0.8655725121,
-0.4813629091,
0.1308316141,
-0.69163692,
-0.1218612716,
-0.4264041483,
-0.1773980558,
-0.3811301291,
-0.278116256,
-0.6041864753,
0.0016812959,
0.4151437581,
0.5421661735,
-0.5845234394,
0.6400539279,
0.6780019403,
-0.6713638306,
-0.647927165,
-0.0887475237,
-0.4121184349,
-0.3135739863,
0.7458056211,
0.1658488363,
-0.1491998583,
-0.1853494495,
-0.4837056398,
-0.6918919683,
1.0088613033,
0.27874735,
-0.5971640944,
-0.0566455126,
0.2237099707,
0.9167336822,
-0.3807007074,
-0.0717904493,
0.6768240333,
0.4369084537,
0.1841624826,
-0.8704094291,
0.0635726601,
-0.4359950721,
0.3355855048,
0.2691690326,
-0.2084631622,
0.5044112802,
-0.2023747116,
-0.4769282639,
0.079817079,
0.7798832059,
0.5193822384,
0.4639185965,
0.2539733052,
0.6487050056,
0.8746798635,
0.0131244874,
1.1472206116,
-0.0880752578,
-0.083948113,
1.2272071838,
-0.5549029112,
0.8478896618,
0.7127205729,
0.1282529533,
0.7213982344,
0.2329356521,
-0.0173993837,
0.3137308955,
0.2076065093,
-0.2866938114,
-0.087774314,
-0.338675499,
-0.1168615595,
0.2703669071,
0.3653451502,
-0.433121264,
0.1737902015,
0.3499158323,
-0.231372416,
0.3695383966,
-0.2669603229,
1.0854718685,
-0.0101752942,
-0.7269158959,
0.8515373468,
-0.2258685678,
0.6397781968,
-0.2954424322,
-0.5253822803,
-0.5373904705,
0.1203291565,
-0.3821842372,
-0.2743532956,
0.6899876595,
0.1851662546,
-0.2995402515,
-0.3945360482,
0.7351130247,
-0.3033762872,
-0.3883568048,
0.4494797289,
0.3386108577,
0.4543662965,
-0.2649777234,
-0.1589083374,
0.0455725975,
-0.2392102182,
-0.3892630339,
0.2417334318,
0.5685116649,
-0.0856100693,
0.6799551249,
0.5288593769,
0.2878617644,
0.1499944329,
0.4871222377,
0.8795895576,
-0.5419293642,
-0.2007892877,
-0.5493943095,
0.1702960581,
-0.162614271,
0.1433644742,
0.4631189108,
0.635204196,
0.6634764671,
-0.1935670376,
0.7352765799,
-0.2808358073,
0.5239505768,
-0.397084564,
0.7980363369,
-0.6418296695,
0.5349498987,
-0.1969398707,
-1.0772894621,
-0.454341352,
0.6571679711,
-0.0148964254,
0.0794499964,
0.596763432,
1.0698080063,
0.1385763884,
-0.3176159561,
0.5124566555,
0.1906056553,
0.2807846963,
0.3523857594,
0.7261176705,
-0.3409465253,
0.6573655605,
-0.3408046663,
-0.1781053096,
-0.2317881882,
-0.6811057329,
-0.8970953226,
-0.4820175171,
-0.2498446107,
-0.5509892106,
0.2952231467,
0.9048277736,
0.4679970443,
-0.9515537024,
-0.1714647114,
-0.2118068039,
0.0537852198,
-0.1003391892,
-0.2686932385,
0.2357419282,
-0.6851534843,
-0.5590183735,
0.4713321328,
0.408046186,
-0.0235710945,
-0.3847156167,
-0.4693521559,
-0.1125940159,
0.1137221903,
0.7098886967,
0.3372943997,
-0.6121650338,
-0.3008859754,
0.142261833,
-0.2485925257,
0.1287616342,
0.5547938943,
-0.9948933721,
0.4354828298,
0.6685039401,
0.8004012704,
0.4538389444,
0.0621000603,
0.5867581367,
-0.8532758951,
0.0788924322,
0.4181993008,
0.2628896832,
0.3797044754,
-0.6009940505,
0.8810285926,
0.1576321423,
-0.5634263754,
-0.829028368,
0.0824081525,
-0.4918340147,
-0.1524837166,
1.0935264826,
0.2940343022,
-0.3300020695,
-0.1337868571,
-0.1914665848,
0.3130729496,
-0.3170930445,
1.2110487223,
0.2914250493,
-0.1872056276,
-0.0615634322,
-0.4549239278,
0.6051030755,
0.5221296549,
-0.9596261382,
0.1274871677,
0.802724719,
-0.3619783223,
0.3832190633,
0.5856521726,
0.0830974355,
0.1387944371,
-0.1123216748,
0.5529879332,
-0.0226219054,
-0.6540483236,
-0.4057182074,
0.1317826211,
0.1066122875,
-0.1428563893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08164v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08164v2
|
Language Model Prompt Selection via Simulation Optimization
| 2024-04-12T00:03:56 | 2024-05-20T02:34:42 |
Haoting Zhang, Jinghai He, Rhonda Righter, Zeyu Zheng
|
stat.ML
|
stat.ML, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
With the advancement in generative language models, the selection of prompts
has gained significant attention in recent years. A prompt is an instruction or
description provided by the user, serving as a guide for the generative
language model in content generation. Despite existing methods for prompt
selection that are based on human labor, we consider facilitating this
selection through simulation optimization, aiming to maximize a pre-defined
score for the selected prompt. Specifically, we propose a two-stage framework.
In the first stage, we determine a feasible set of prompts in sufficient
numbers, where each prompt is represented by a moderate-dimensional vector. In
the subsequent stage for evaluation and selection, we construct a surrogate
model of the score regarding the moderate-dimensional vectors that represent
the prompts. We propose sequentially selecting the prompt for evaluation based
on this constructed surrogate model. We prove the consistency of the sequential
evaluation procedure in our framework. We also conduct numerical experiments to
demonstrate the efficacy of our proposed framework, providing practical
instructions for implementation.
|
[
-0.6275912523,
-0.9505966306,
0.8022886515,
0.7715519071,
-0.3475818932,
-0.1420627087,
-0.2417100668,
0.2252441645,
-0.1229434311,
0.3071154058,
-0.9832600355,
-0.2470359653,
0.0041074706,
0.4843609333,
-0.19804883,
0.7586547732,
0.1408808976,
0.0418902338,
-0.5981028676,
0.4825140536,
-0.8697255254,
-0.2542294264,
-1.0426280499,
-0.2022175342,
0.5156861544,
0.4067675173,
0.4794303477,
0.6739093661,
0.0907133594,
0.298874706,
-0.2602037787,
-0.1053664908,
-0.3622711003,
0.4574040174,
-0.020768512,
-0.2630123198,
0.2586234808,
0.0401440375,
0.7509772182,
0.7309771776,
-0.1108843163,
0.0995468646,
-0.0048980722,
0.3583492041,
-0.4625730813,
-0.1064065546,
-0.2821636498,
0.100623399,
0.0336227641,
-0.3070755005,
-0.6486632824,
-0.6902848482,
0.1208842024,
-0.4577480257,
0.2327046245,
0.2605137825,
0.544849813,
0.0413691513,
-0.1526164263,
-0.1849613786,
-0.6745052934,
0.838939786,
-0.3101842701,
0.2541376054,
0.2596797645,
0.5760480762,
-0.2546221912,
-0.6758593321,
-0.5108305216,
-0.8486326933,
0.2183816284,
0.1547539234,
-0.1714346409,
0.1591001153,
0.5098668933,
0.0622229129,
-0.9576464295,
0.2774868011,
-0.2842928171,
-0.295286864,
0.3843555152,
0.4958983362,
0.5044921041,
-0.3488885164,
-0.5269093513,
-0.2320673168,
-0.6846418381,
0.1641164124,
0.62333709,
0.4514054656,
-0.0824932531,
0.3679457009,
-0.210872978,
0.8797689676,
-0.0866207331,
-0.1253462881,
0.0107134292,
-0.2540742755,
0.0567724667,
-0.2154745609,
0.8936773539,
0.3695444167,
0.2504281402,
0.0310254451,
-0.4599686861,
0.3564197123,
0.3332151771,
-0.8471343517,
0.1119363159,
0.2432136834,
-0.5934565067,
-0.4569250643,
-0.2301402539,
-1.0096117258,
-0.339456737,
-0.3566134572,
0.1973405331,
-0.2410894632,
-0.1336392164,
0.0242764689,
-0.1692969054,
-0.1145851463,
0.398142606,
-0.9268106222,
0.2001589239,
0.4904649854,
0.7763258815,
-0.2798427641,
-0.1988448352,
-0.6957697868,
-0.3795441985,
-0.5609443784,
0.881026566,
-0.9143882394,
-1.0638189316,
0.0746269599,
-0.3500433266,
-0.0197172388,
-0.3363839686,
0.8881994486,
-0.6568822861,
0.4172077477,
-0.4582140148,
-0.4989865124,
0.0210993178,
0.0376805253,
-0.8339679837,
1.0703054667,
0.4158058763,
-0.5769791603,
0.2106759399,
-0.6251152754,
-0.3368758857,
0.3273350596,
-0.3150990605,
-0.1243031844,
0.0741485581,
0.1170447692,
0.1997719109,
-0.6899781823,
0.2997259796,
0.0150303366,
-0.4736013114,
0.0968058929,
-0.5486930013,
0.9426957369,
0.4572153687,
-0.0558173433,
0.241085574,
-0.4828361869,
-0.0662564337,
0.061997667,
-0.5783483386,
0.0154473186,
-0.0783238485,
0.0417874344,
0.1519344151,
0.0334592685,
-0.3963940442,
0.3745438159,
-0.2494145483,
0.0281838924,
0.7250588536,
0.3835372925,
0.5057653189,
-0.2749742866,
1.3816577196,
-0.2511931658,
0.3605165184,
-0.3791123033,
-0.5631090999,
-0.3784285188,
-0.0790359899,
0.4842422903,
0.7634009719,
-1.009388566,
0.3018626869,
0.0880813673,
-0.2937995493,
-0.3976074159,
-0.1634712219,
0.4911004603,
0.6685917974,
0.1765303761,
0.0651027486,
-0.5251533389,
-0.8034828901,
-0.0097007258,
-0.4168101549,
0.0080893999,
0.2594410777,
0.1454779059,
-0.0062882272,
1.1007660627,
-0.6130280495,
0.2376928926,
-0.6591474414,
0.3158625066,
0.3940915763,
0.5159487724,
0.822699368,
-0.7988016605,
-0.4307071865,
-0.2769230604,
-0.4338181317,
-0.5849047899,
-0.5415971279,
-0.2054919899,
-0.052631449,
0.546806097,
-0.6394271851,
0.3243336976,
0.3381288648,
-0.2168888301,
1.0515364408,
-0.1820711344,
0.1807984561,
-0.9378348589,
0.156630069,
0.0682250187,
-0.09945333,
-0.5652186275,
-0.0575703867,
-0.0666276813,
-0.3311460316,
-0.2944985628,
0.9146538377,
-0.3321641982,
0.1266158521,
-0.2276034057,
0.1511170715,
0.1099950746,
0.3804777861,
0.0593301579,
1.1533472538,
0.6114971042,
-0.7493012547,
0.4858804345,
0.2024744004,
-0.5128597617,
0.3857651353,
-0.918946445,
0.1055908352,
-0.3772151172,
0.0637706146,
-0.9909080863,
-0.0147633953,
0.2986190319,
-0.433703661,
0.1768074036,
-0.1205551028,
-0.5300834775,
-0.4909290075,
-0.1729058474,
0.4275156558,
0.7976486683,
-0.3718499839,
0.4331515729,
0.1099083722,
-0.564040184,
-0.2705145478,
-0.1079452261,
-0.0733944252,
-0.1599737555,
-0.3982743919,
0.202442959,
-0.4840894043,
-0.1753359139,
-0.1858238727,
0.2811983526,
0.3468409181,
0.1615003943,
0.0686527565,
0.4552832544,
-0.0261976756,
0.0794266835,
0.4567097723,
-0.3748485744,
0.2126756459,
-0.1414108723,
0.7495558858,
0.2658230364,
-0.3758858442,
-0.3345312476,
0.6659682393,
0.1036360189,
-0.2458202839,
0.4245935082,
0.3465411961,
-0.3491108119,
-0.4597311616,
-0.4322043955,
-0.3067890704,
-0.5265497565,
0.3139423728,
-0.5436872244,
-0.5961249471,
0.368530035,
-0.2308855057,
0.0103024766,
0.1148205847,
0.6198456883,
0.2623796761,
1.4853700399,
0.4192468226,
0.2034911066,
0.682287693,
-0.0154333152,
0.0119912755,
-0.7332566381,
-0.2868235707,
-0.8894718885,
0.0904829428,
-0.275421083,
-0.4398222864,
0.5831774473,
0.3659659922,
-0.081627287,
0.1416281164,
-0.313064605,
0.6215921044,
0.8046043515,
-0.0583775192,
-0.2055108994,
0.003550204,
-0.953640759,
-0.0979060158,
-0.6712796092,
-0.8033100367,
0.3796855211,
0.19414033,
0.5460091829,
-0.0719923526,
0.522916913,
0.2869587243,
0.1804460734,
-0.5418841839,
0.8013641238,
0.0407488197,
-0.5142248869,
-0.3808524013,
-0.5691392422,
-0.9969103932,
0.2509683967,
-0.1082913727,
-0.9370709062,
0.046876736,
0.0716698766,
-0.7119731307,
-0.3290942907,
-0.6746074557,
1.0668935776,
-0.012835701,
-0.0726340935,
-0.0798097998,
-0.5798289776,
0.1531645507,
-0.0830319226,
0.1255055219,
-0.0801319256,
0.0185490493,
0.4907541871,
-0.3902571201,
0.8040972948,
-0.3662652671,
0.0803516731,
0.4703837633,
0.2663551867,
0.4166477621,
0.2777578235,
-0.4367205203,
-0.4558909833,
-0.1292748451,
-0.0882914588,
-0.8635525703,
0.3583877981,
-0.622790575,
-0.7438411117,
-0.0971843526,
-0.1902038753,
-0.2564065456,
0.1868485212,
0.387104094,
0.7008799314,
-0.3662810326,
-0.1995824426,
0.4849134982,
-0.6891511679,
0.5489052534,
0.262729764,
-0.5676938891,
-0.3019764721,
0.9125442505,
-0.2730814815,
0.2577472925,
0.3413933218,
0.615624249,
-0.5775640011,
-0.4087266028,
-0.7565751076,
0.0158120561,
-0.8820963502,
-0.2329442054,
-0.5708637238,
-0.0929966494,
-0.2623755038,
-0.2299858332,
0.0984710455,
-0.1756531,
-0.5047718883,
-0.179329887,
0.164783746,
0.4895994663,
-0.0591075234,
0.3320949078,
-0.7862017155,
0.4221878648,
0.3757594228,
0.1150174513,
0.0711176246,
-0.4589830935,
0.144690752,
-0.0220729336,
-0.1712618768,
-1.0192351341,
0.2618530393,
-0.0461076796,
0.8826868534,
0.4666920006,
0.2157655805,
0.3673679829,
-0.7943948507,
0.897559166,
0.2552490234,
-0.9657600522,
0.9162163138,
-0.3549256921,
0.4337417185,
0.5470893383,
0.3458896279,
-0.7433025241,
-0.2993611991,
-0.3619143665,
-0.651440084,
0.7040570974,
0.1819850653,
0.5586315989,
-0.516115427,
0.3782660365,
0.3228088021,
0.1496044695,
-0.3722781539,
-0.252459079,
0.099869214,
-0.0709425583,
0.2833547294,
-0.4968593419,
0.1056293398,
-0.0096350005,
0.5683941245,
-0.0956755504,
0.3056015968,
-0.1044548303,
0.1434531361,
-0.1848552823,
0.0701595545,
0.7253200412,
0.6243937612,
0.2138325423,
-0.2595518827,
0.0348907523,
-0.5176852942,
0.1538562179,
0.0977447629,
-0.5948114991,
0.3003075123,
0.3354736567,
1.2570217848,
0.1570141613,
-0.7650865316,
0.6135804653,
-0.2627744079,
0.0052987337,
-0.2156048864,
0.2842380404,
-0.1360706836,
0.2980511189,
0.2743598819,
-0.057662487,
0.2703238428,
-0.1962503344,
0.1609896123,
0.2218239456,
-0.0474751666,
-0.1566639245,
0.8331679106,
0.2284606695,
-0.6989572048,
0.8367512822,
-0.6851955056,
-0.5922117233,
0.7235246897,
0.6818069816,
0.8963793516,
-0.48184973,
0.6341401339,
0.5768091679,
0.0207095016,
-0.2652888,
0.8127959371,
0.1376025081,
-0.6615784168,
-0.4607077539,
-0.9099392891,
-0.336959511,
-0.1884976327,
-0.6442225575,
0.5946358442,
-0.3228901625,
-0.3477877378,
-0.1941647381,
-0.0108702956,
-0.7410455346,
0.3287766576,
0.2383893877,
1.1240034103,
-0.8298169374,
0.5751979351,
0.6748406887,
-0.5524870157,
-0.9504519105,
-0.0409684703,
-0.0830846652,
-0.7090127468,
0.6416109204,
0.2104531527,
0.0449337512,
0.2447631359,
-0.427146852,
-0.573892355,
0.8028142452,
0.5766271353,
-0.5117361546,
-0.0497005917,
-0.1576494575,
0.4700096846,
-0.5181689262,
0.4151021242,
0.363730371,
0.3766022325,
0.5000899434,
-0.720533669,
0.1610808522,
-0.2248958796,
0.7579659224,
-0.0804438516,
-0.2309427857,
0.8861109614,
-0.3557080328,
-0.4697600603,
0.4225046337,
0.6972916722,
0.7181919217,
-0.121588327,
0.7501170039,
0.0829679742,
0.6733776927,
0.0583956465,
1.3367865086,
-0.2752265334,
0.2655907869,
0.6960549355,
-0.2322266847,
0.6256106496,
0.4066489637,
-0.3274991512,
0.5528666377,
1.017390728,
0.0084126629,
0.7255814672,
0.5565101504,
-0.5004359484,
-0.3040511012,
-0.4675029516,
-0.2927378118,
0.2497275025,
0.1840502471,
-0.2941921055,
-0.2249774784,
0.0848842859,
-0.1086284369,
0.0086236112,
-0.1554530859,
0.6605305076,
0.008956599,
-1.1195443869,
0.4366919398,
0.199742347,
0.079153657,
-0.4783483446,
-0.2457549572,
-0.3466138244,
-0.5250096321,
0.2131965607,
-0.5980316997,
-0.0611804053,
0.129013896,
-0.2377776057,
-0.480416894,
0.6353729963,
-0.4794145226,
-0.5807445049,
0.0076124431,
0.4860461652,
0.2208169252,
0.0176336188,
-0.6932886839,
0.4668664634,
-0.1484327167,
-0.4749901295,
-0.0314556435,
0.4854117334,
-0.2533829212,
0.6185926199,
0.7709778547,
0.128051728,
-0.1419564039,
0.725301981,
1.0047149658,
-0.385222733,
-1.0071972609,
-0.949202776,
0.740868032,
-0.1395814121,
-0.3793243468,
0.3169518113,
0.4226872027,
0.4662878215,
-0.2633988857,
1.0068073273,
-0.052716624,
0.4853007793,
-0.7165673971,
0.2960019708,
-0.3085545301,
0.3301998973,
-0.3619722724,
-1.180544138,
-0.128053844,
0.732052505,
-0.2726881206,
0.4217203557,
0.6739143729,
0.9850281477,
0.3289986849,
0.2138229609,
0.3987753987,
-0.3342300653,
0.0655336305,
0.33303532,
1.1550328732,
0.0825032443,
0.2906339467,
-0.1699850261,
-0.4055911303,
-0.3066973388,
-1.0076367855,
-1.1214632988,
-0.7579045296,
-0.2374473959,
-0.2183880657,
-0.046486903,
1.2565610409,
0.5651021004,
-0.5855110884,
-0.1915681064,
-0.1231121942,
0.1720711291,
-0.2669233382,
-0.2509422302,
0.1166775897,
-0.6744633317,
-0.744261086,
0.5284149647,
0.2306942493,
0.1888817102,
-0.5049782395,
-0.102043353,
0.0576228872,
0.0754546672,
0.441672653,
0.0997806489,
-0.6119938493,
-0.2432038039,
0.1645570099,
-0.2808356583,
-0.305603236,
1.0131200552,
-0.8261409402,
0.5478648543,
0.7346887589,
0.7204793096,
0.0818849951,
0.1986535788,
1.0247460604,
-1.0621587038,
0.1109693274,
0.3849578798,
0.2514611781,
0.2642461658,
-0.4776861072,
0.2605338693,
0.0287881009,
-0.3566505611,
-0.8194617629,
0.5374922156,
-0.7136439681,
-0.3724836409,
1.5085996389,
-0.072822012,
-0.0154135628,
-0.0159199983,
-0.5752652287,
0.1916353106,
-0.4393807054,
0.675133884,
0.5964204669,
-0.0834921226,
-0.4262268841,
-0.7231815457,
0.6524602771,
0.2935851216,
-0.7416819334,
-0.1675880253,
0.6153168678,
-0.0873255655,
-0.0178882312,
0.7222509384,
0.0991917923,
0.4331538379,
0.1615383625,
-0.1360563189,
0.1096882522,
-0.4432821572,
-0.4213919342,
0.1092690378,
0.1762264073,
-0.2121718824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08156v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08156v1
|
Multimodal Contextual Dialogue Breakdown Detection for Conversational AI Models
| 2024-04-11T23:09:18 | 2024-04-11T23:09:18 |
Md Messal Monem Miah, Ulie Schnaithmann, Arushi Raghuvanshi, Youngseo Son
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Detecting dialogue breakdown in real time is critical for conversational AI
systems, because it enables taking corrective action to successfully complete a
task. In spoken dialog systems, this breakdown can be caused by a variety of
unexpected situations including high levels of background noise, causing STT
mistranscriptions, or unexpected user flows. In particular, industry settings
like healthcare, require high precision and high flexibility to navigate
differently based on the conversation history and dialogue states. This makes
it both more challenging and more critical to accurately detect dialog
breakdown. To accurately detect breakdown, we found it requires processing
audio inputs along with downstream NLP model inferences on transcribed text in
real time. In this paper, we introduce a Multimodal Contextual Dialogue
Breakdown (MultConDB) model. This model significantly outperforms other known
best models by achieving an F1 of 69.27.
|
[
-0.6758363247,
-1.0893945694,
0.7478843331,
0.2246163636,
0.0105235502,
0.1256134808,
0.009804978,
-0.4283973277,
0.1497066319,
0.54417032,
-1.0918936729,
-0.3171248734,
-0.4112644792,
-0.223275438,
-0.2803666592,
0.7928221822,
0.3594559431,
0.2073754519,
-0.3198153675,
-0.4482008219,
-1.0390607119,
-0.6180984378,
-0.8552514911,
-0.2409954071,
0.3045785725,
0.3919444382,
0.7445417643,
0.0765852183,
0.2781667709,
0.3702963293,
0.0420086011,
0.2349956781,
-0.1260160059,
0.5027822256,
0.1937985867,
-0.2931750715,
-0.4617226422,
-0.1997985095,
0.4898756742,
0.5333686471,
-0.4456513524,
-0.2610853612,
-0.0934364945,
0.3074014485,
-0.4409135878,
0.2146154642,
-0.3027701974,
0.0812168643,
0.1310547888,
-0.255733043,
-0.4844594896,
-0.0528805293,
0.0626675561,
-0.275002569,
0.1364314705,
-0.2026408613,
0.5942829847,
0.4234849215,
-0.6297746301,
-0.2707064748,
-0.7216255069,
0.5501844883,
-0.6986770034,
0.747405529,
0.2302075028,
0.3885557353,
-0.0912112966,
-0.7529729605,
-0.6923090816,
-0.5182729363,
-0.196700573,
0.0168752223,
-0.1402344257,
0.3201884329,
0.2846421897,
0.1785219908,
-0.4036893249,
0.0500459261,
-0.1153364703,
-0.1331601441,
0.0525842682,
0.3429299295,
0.4311443269,
-0.4477702975,
-0.3377280533,
-0.1025302261,
-0.3124677837,
0.061994087,
-0.0470060147,
-0.1223493665,
-0.1469275653,
0.0508671962,
-0.1033507884,
0.6863795519,
-0.0356212631,
-0.5272421241,
0.2492365837,
-0.8092283607,
-0.353068471,
0.216916576,
0.9747174978,
0.4162602425,
-0.1732267737,
0.2076825052,
-0.0398657285,
-0.1612248421,
0.1086941063,
-0.7805079222,
-0.1922642589,
0.4461710155,
-0.4460283816,
-0.244138062,
-0.274304837,
-0.4536400139,
-0.3080520928,
-0.2682147026,
-0.085706383,
-0.6471502185,
-0.5091923475,
-0.3625421226,
-0.0116908504,
-0.0788508952,
0.4081264436,
-0.7500709891,
-0.1188603789,
0.3275096714,
1.0384759903,
0.0916127041,
-0.0974650458,
-0.8059495687,
-0.1750824302,
-0.0968683064,
0.8010852933,
-0.4460525811,
-0.5207707286,
-0.2585952282,
0.1065985262,
-0.3577478528,
-0.4850691557,
0.6706950068,
-0.0705087483,
0.2219058126,
0.2965016961,
-0.378346771,
-0.1504041702,
0.4631648064,
-0.9004696608,
0.722781539,
0.0418984406,
-0.6377381682,
0.3700074553,
-1.076343298,
-0.296310991,
-0.0387266502,
-0.2230997235,
-0.4164607823,
-0.0337242633,
0.4610136449,
0.5035825968,
-0.2941631973,
0.8165994883,
-0.5313534141,
-0.0541970395,
0.4450362325,
-1.0615481138,
0.9745263457,
0.3050780594,
-0.3701604009,
0.2343630344,
-0.9129605889,
0.0471142232,
-0.1852207035,
-0.2546088398,
-0.2243222743,
0.0395606682,
0.4149864316,
0.4708323479,
-0.3859822452,
-0.4108563364,
0.0566497445,
-0.3043768406,
0.5117207766,
0.4683376849,
0.1126228198,
0.1025618091,
-0.2517598271,
0.7318195701,
0.266908437,
0.0983524919,
-0.7072317004,
-0.5421501398,
-0.6764931083,
-0.6166055202,
0.2713489234,
0.6192253828,
-0.6332411766,
0.2774111032,
-0.008108397,
-0.5834873915,
-0.6353037953,
-0.173589468,
0.3704071939,
0.9266620874,
0.2741039395,
-0.1000942811,
-0.29608953,
-0.9169338942,
0.0507558584,
-0.0575608239,
-0.12544249,
0.5087854266,
0.2751486003,
-0.5417788029,
0.8399167657,
-0.3503109515,
-0.397159338,
-0.4364867806,
0.3742890656,
0.2015763968,
0.6174988151,
0.4940328896,
-0.9059630036,
-0.1561970711,
-0.1398269087,
-0.8142095208,
0.0552167706,
-0.4247456193,
0.0344208553,
0.2657839954,
0.7842960358,
-0.654740274,
0.5847794414,
0.774911046,
-0.3576557636,
0.8373070359,
-0.2189241499,
0.4454229176,
-1.162229538,
0.1578301638,
-0.0977986604,
-0.4745933414,
-0.7474510074,
-0.364816606,
0.0007654523,
-0.2445369065,
-0.6095961928,
0.2685803175,
-0.3328869045,
0.0639712662,
0.1423367709,
0.0351982154,
0.2687851787,
0.6935084462,
0.2005464584,
0.5599644184,
0.3209886849,
-0.4810878932,
0.626110673,
0.3360734284,
-0.6112794876,
0.7675930858,
-0.6776016355,
-0.103206493,
0.1655567437,
0.7264887094,
-1.1417089701,
-0.3936525881,
0.124030441,
-0.3344318867,
0.147929877,
-0.0972453356,
-0.2291756868,
0.152294144,
-0.092368789,
0.6040890217,
-0.2590605319,
-0.4277430475,
0.807574451,
0.4829428792,
-0.3775036335,
-0.4623638093,
-0.8220648766,
0.0135848271,
0.0193057116,
-1.1244927645,
0.1361529529,
-0.1883508712,
-0.2493355572,
-0.2978151739,
0.1370077431,
-0.2356484234,
0.2445311695,
0.6069269776,
0.3578957021,
-0.2964017093,
0.2803280652,
0.2353454232,
-0.0774878487,
0.139329493,
0.1259430498,
0.7607005239,
-0.0909291804,
-0.5906935334,
-1.0103330612,
0.650519371,
1.080922842,
-0.3649686277,
0.9339798689,
0.6123010516,
-0.3208276629,
0.1461604536,
-0.4896867871,
-0.3163220584,
-0.4126616716,
0.4179206491,
-0.3606409132,
-0.597874105,
0.4579996169,
0.0669582859,
-0.0439179763,
0.3109757006,
0.7839692235,
-0.2150853276,
1.3912911415,
0.4311101735,
0.1753665656,
0.5765480995,
-0.1671831906,
0.3574925363,
-0.6017565727,
-0.3940102756,
-0.4009205103,
-0.0403890796,
-0.5496452451,
-0.1903291047,
0.6835850477,
0.014881473,
0.2489210069,
-0.3038237393,
-0.3251957595,
0.2741944492,
0.7918645144,
0.1958119422,
0.4494077265,
-0.14010638,
-0.4109202325,
0.1047039628,
-0.6675985456,
-0.1552002132,
0.6460603476,
0.4621013701,
0.7085858583,
0.2041860819,
0.2699545026,
0.5860286951,
0.410861522,
-0.8017647862,
0.0965430513,
0.3308018446,
-0.8541819453,
-0.3291501999,
-0.204847455,
-0.6203215122,
0.3864531219,
-0.2303381413,
-0.6930985451,
0.2726635039,
0.2873980105,
-0.5500833988,
0.0362360068,
-0.8881527781,
1.3303930759,
-0.1593535095,
0.0376761518,
-0.2307493538,
-0.7834516764,
0.6775344014,
0.1783658862,
0.4959434867,
-0.143900305,
0.6013419032,
0.5988978148,
-0.6534506679,
0.7151665688,
-0.3295219541,
0.0307054762,
0.1643274426,
0.1734918654,
0.2223428488,
0.3283424675,
0.2646449506,
0.2331351787,
0.2828277051,
-0.2684343755,
-0.4838210642,
0.6581760049,
-0.439492166,
-0.2348941565,
-0.3851605952,
-0.5712942481,
-0.4603499472,
-0.0125953937,
0.4022890627,
0.9062188268,
-0.3885233104,
0.3077657223,
0.463971138,
-0.1676338911,
0.5159762502,
0.1962809563,
-0.2088048011,
-0.3707965314,
0.7207148671,
-0.0651293918,
0.4287894666,
0.0574042983,
-0.1292946935,
-0.5009655356,
-0.3173510432,
-0.6805210114,
0.1173264533,
-0.8710383177,
-0.1405154765,
-0.9562385678,
-0.1646434516,
-0.3792563975,
-0.0499346592,
-0.3009234667,
-0.3783694506,
-0.2557987869,
-0.258264631,
-0.1696060151,
0.521984756,
-0.0038707182,
0.3440189064,
-1.1693735123,
0.2833829224,
0.340891093,
0.0438601896,
-0.0691702813,
-0.1250009239,
-0.1074583083,
0.1373964548,
-0.4551982582,
-0.9346116781,
0.4373409152,
0.2988098264,
0.422688067,
0.5864082575,
-0.0714658722,
0.5958272815,
-0.3439899683,
0.8228234649,
0.5919591784,
-0.8716407418,
0.5572188497,
-0.3325930834,
0.5170037746,
0.5015740395,
0.1224725917,
-0.9096477032,
-0.4826805592,
-0.6059861779,
-0.7565037012,
0.8593353033,
-0.0305817127,
-0.2800610662,
-0.0308677368,
-0.3965720832,
-0.0289425142,
0.1593588591,
-0.4524859488,
-0.2705077827,
-0.2354823202,
-0.1625783592,
-0.0788531229,
-0.3453042209,
-0.2276281714,
-0.0010010487,
0.3660405874,
-0.2345820814,
0.2872826159,
0.252068758,
-0.4453893602,
0.2015609741,
0.4610251188,
1.0089784861,
0.8969295025,
-0.4159694612,
-0.1108312011,
0.0029663243,
-0.2950216532,
0.3006866574,
0.2050753534,
0.061544016,
0.3792029619,
0.468254745,
0.8232963085,
0.228599593,
-1.0499558449,
0.5948488712,
-0.5089678168,
-0.0146818627,
-0.4197882414,
0.0205923077,
0.1671562344,
0.2779879272,
0.22125341,
0.4496937692,
0.3989984691,
-0.6593387127,
0.5019176006,
0.2332473397,
-0.6596089005,
-0.0081042051,
0.6629493833,
0.4572792053,
-0.3467028141,
0.8250924945,
0.1315380335,
-0.4372980893,
0.7187163234,
0.2948082685,
0.8114717007,
-0.4322197735,
0.2440672964,
0.0789874941,
0.0004069027,
0.2949409187,
-0.1197892651,
-0.201946944,
-0.8053827286,
-0.5303131938,
-0.5751529336,
-0.5957680345,
0.2488061339,
-0.7209138274,
0.040710561,
-0.4400759935,
-0.2468562424,
0.2924768925,
-0.6116080284,
-0.6353358626,
0.3727204204,
0.2730620205,
0.5772618055,
-0.5375532508,
0.8823475242,
0.1852648258,
-0.3769493401,
-0.522816956,
-0.1544851661,
0.2989994287,
-0.4603453875,
0.7142342925,
0.5255240798,
-0.2789696157,
-0.3614958823,
-0.3350545466,
-0.2926304042,
0.7803613544,
0.495557934,
-0.7252100706,
-0.1918346733,
-0.1414398402,
0.2869485915,
-0.5184342861,
0.7021897435,
0.8516511321,
0.4285999537,
-0.0193014275,
-1.1356472969,
-0.0904725343,
-0.1197542325,
-0.3102969825,
0.2651292086,
-0.4681816101,
0.8589966893,
0.0468804799,
-0.0849197209,
-0.169672668,
0.2405558974,
0.2677333355,
0.6521220803,
0.787285924,
0.5001989007,
0.8084527254,
-0.1671728939,
1.1352261305,
-0.3271927238,
0.2849126756,
1.2347253561,
0.1398617327,
0.5521769524,
0.248870492,
0.1476255357,
0.4464734495,
0.5801608562,
0.3329633176,
0.4365286231,
-0.4102934897,
-0.4738706052,
-0.3925868869,
-0.3057943583,
-0.2941746712,
0.74814713,
0.749522984,
-0.4488446414,
-0.1364565343,
0.5242164731,
0.2905186713,
-0.4660808444,
-0.0057918038,
0.8852972984,
-0.1370829344,
-1.12867558,
0.8806060553,
-0.1664048284,
0.4058960676,
-0.5791000128,
-0.197397247,
-0.3005848527,
0.340931654,
-0.241198808,
-0.3639203906,
0.3244291544,
-0.2187590748,
-0.3124959171,
-0.2580476999,
0.580124855,
-0.5205513239,
-0.3880704343,
0.4132312834,
0.4589824378,
0.0397902131,
-0.419379741,
-0.9031633735,
0.110993959,
0.2895383537,
-0.2840785086,
0.1405863762,
0.2179381698,
0.1758390963,
0.7950633764,
0.8849205375,
-0.3785252273,
0.0979027823,
0.1071135104,
0.7759478092,
-0.7636612654,
-0.5202590823,
-0.8439764977,
0.8613344431,
-0.2359220833,
-0.3923714757,
0.3202302158,
0.3479910493,
0.4218701422,
0.2221100032,
0.8442100883,
-0.0837348625,
0.4661685228,
-0.6248321533,
0.7637807727,
-0.5956157446,
0.1967548579,
-0.0881385729,
-0.5649498701,
-0.227571547,
0.4344175756,
0.2370240092,
-0.3094874322,
0.7867622972,
0.8055137396,
-0.1303674579,
0.1606478989,
0.4943434894,
0.2081167549,
0.8519589305,
0.2184122205,
0.8536851406,
-0.0453247055,
0.7225481272,
-0.2589027882,
-0.4054994285,
-0.5128949881,
-0.6396435499,
-0.6733190417,
-0.5649344325,
-0.1512909383,
-0.6170781851,
-0.3015623093,
0.9465373755,
0.9615689516,
-0.9719198942,
-0.0540236011,
0.1246163622,
0.2754057944,
-0.3059498966,
-0.3034663498,
0.1299079061,
-0.4602918625,
-0.7717360854,
0.7821726203,
0.5894015431,
-0.1925715357,
-0.407047987,
-0.0796885416,
-0.4977229834,
-0.1295597702,
0.6605345011,
0.1236799359,
-0.7125327587,
-0.0805560052,
-0.3415745795,
-0.1601841897,
0.3443551362,
0.8938009143,
-0.6679286957,
0.7563174367,
0.4516409636,
0.4643687904,
0.5893186331,
-0.0587572232,
0.598628819,
-0.6946405768,
0.3590648472,
0.5520052314,
0.5208159685,
0.3005955815,
-0.2226352543,
0.3451918662,
0.4191493392,
-0.6290153265,
-0.8581625819,
0.2043777108,
-0.9069022536,
-0.362537384,
0.600804925,
-0.132224679,
-0.1836944222,
-0.374990195,
-0.526971221,
0.0175613668,
-0.6707350612,
0.2895411551,
0.8254532814,
-0.5659729838,
-0.3877494931,
-0.664883852,
0.5364418626,
0.4122999609,
-0.7242604494,
-0.0926880017,
0.8246557713,
0.0542931221,
0.5215572119,
0.8034210205,
0.2349873185,
0.3909080923,
0.0175404865,
-0.0723932832,
0.0762209669,
-0.3451229036,
-0.1531143039,
0.5444276333,
-0.252966553,
-0.3298674226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08155v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08155v1
|
Graph Integrated Language Transformers for Next Action Prediction in Complex Phone Calls
| 2024-04-11T22:47:50 | 2024-04-11T22:47:50 |
Amin Hosseiny Marani, Ulie Schnaithmann, Youngseo Son, Akil Iyer, Manas Paldhe, Arushi Raghuvanshi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current Conversational AI systems employ different machine learning
pipelines, as well as external knowledge sources and business logic to predict
the next action. Maintaining various components in dialogue managers' pipeline
adds complexity in expansion and updates, increases processing time, and causes
additive noise through the pipeline that can lead to incorrect next action
prediction. This paper investigates graph integration into language
transformers to improve understanding the relationships between humans'
utterances, previous, and next actions without the dependency on external
sources or components. Experimental analyses on real calls indicate that the
proposed Graph Integrated Language Transformer models can achieve higher
performance compared to other production level conversational AI systems in
driving interactive calls with human users in real-world settings.
|
[
-0.3855251968,
-0.795055747,
0.3722780645,
0.1254931688,
0.0895962343,
0.5690339208,
0.1600474864,
-0.9535643458,
-0.0033046883,
0.7056126595,
-0.7091159225,
-0.1728182733,
-0.4371719956,
-0.1531758457,
-0.3796789944,
0.5327080488,
0.1204641238,
0.2038961202,
-0.0868440047,
0.015050686,
-0.7749816775,
-0.4302913845,
-0.9164386392,
-0.7819418311,
0.2282000631,
0.3633497655,
1.2293378115,
0.1657278538,
0.3664100468,
0.4525979757,
0.0586233027,
0.214247793,
-0.2679959536,
0.0802656859,
0.1626597792,
-0.6408256888,
-0.4860949516,
-0.04786909,
0.3046314418,
0.6868023276,
0.0331572406,
-0.0115294037,
-0.0618262775,
0.3390787244,
-0.1309315711,
0.8621791005,
-0.3429110646,
0.208026737,
0.2442851216,
-0.157581076,
-0.5988092422,
-0.5631513,
0.4953038394,
-0.2616702914,
-0.1031770483,
-0.0402262025,
0.7099288106,
0.2789486051,
-0.2326228172,
-0.3573401272,
-1.2409676313,
0.2897595763,
-0.7118110657,
0.443520844,
0.1785497665,
0.5128954053,
-0.3009411693,
-0.9735661149,
-0.686426878,
-0.2521431148,
-0.5353531241,
0.2948638797,
-0.4545849562,
0.4446235299,
0.2343818396,
-0.1636637449,
-0.1746766269,
0.3180656433,
-0.4363813698,
-0.235460192,
0.4367215037,
0.4399398863,
0.4310187399,
0.0020377368,
0.1297504902,
-0.0583100282,
-0.6368631721,
0.2885110974,
0.5267156363,
0.4501152933,
-0.0128751295,
0.4684942365,
-0.0379005894,
0.869024694,
0.2488322407,
-0.0620467216,
0.1683841944,
-0.1132564694,
-0.1641293913,
0.3106347024,
0.8521488309,
0.2657450736,
0.6394538879,
-0.2084295601,
0.1967572868,
0.1104392633,
0.3734649718,
-0.9212622046,
-0.2728040814,
0.2860896587,
-0.1517012119,
-0.2670275271,
-0.0168769695,
-0.4902460873,
-0.2028169185,
-0.5358319283,
0.0901743621,
-0.5633886456,
-0.2772069871,
-0.1709245294,
0.084258981,
0.2623203993,
0.2990785837,
-0.7013620734,
0.5703950524,
0.6262145042,
0.791205883,
-0.0092304554,
-0.254507333,
-0.9142670035,
0.1511262208,
-0.3376579285,
0.962488234,
-0.8366287351,
-0.5316946507,
0.1085180417,
0.0342415646,
-0.2801758647,
-0.6669544578,
0.4130504429,
-0.5955045819,
0.3276038468,
0.294436723,
-0.3118215501,
-0.4018529356,
-0.0713407248,
-0.5656808019,
0.9292644858,
0.409496218,
-0.4174090624,
0.2336709946,
-0.9811640978,
-0.7510394454,
0.4476256669,
-0.1976871938,
-0.445584178,
-0.2499522567,
0.2101305276,
0.3787555695,
-0.005455764,
0.3690884411,
-0.166432932,
-0.6025503278,
0.311866045,
-0.2231914997,
0.6819053888,
-0.0793814659,
-0.4596754014,
0.4023413062,
-0.4881808162,
0.0174278338,
-0.2482558936,
-0.096386224,
0.2019971907,
0.1087440103,
-0.1198338419,
0.4920271933,
-0.1182823703,
-0.2909078598,
-0.0409088247,
-0.4933083653,
0.5273513198,
0.6905444264,
-0.2436065674,
0.5701689124,
-0.0257643666,
0.8126443624,
0.1366623938,
0.16287902,
-0.276691258,
-0.7089267969,
-0.8998774886,
0.0935061499,
0.2891454399,
0.9279215336,
-0.4792715311,
0.499992013,
-0.5387691259,
-0.5153417587,
-0.4576041102,
0.009721769,
0.2598638237,
0.7205467224,
0.1549499184,
-0.412620306,
-0.5529899001,
-0.6307823062,
-0.1480050981,
-0.5198207498,
-0.0770843551,
0.5596547127,
-0.126995191,
-0.5150517225,
1.3282163143,
-0.4777005315,
-0.126862824,
-0.3957185447,
0.2248190343,
0.2458569854,
0.0471921526,
0.4397224188,
-0.8366173506,
-0.6476982236,
0.1862980127,
-0.4786870182,
-0.1041276604,
-0.0781525373,
-0.0118626626,
0.0021338621,
0.7684645057,
-0.628739357,
0.4439712465,
0.7923436761,
-0.0980903208,
0.3145413995,
-0.0139211109,
-0.2645191848,
-0.926469624,
-0.2489039153,
0.0295995902,
-0.3748222888,
-0.8768794537,
-0.6783412695,
-0.2468193471,
-0.5591096282,
-0.341176331,
0.2909551561,
-0.2281277925,
-0.5042597055,
-0.0290026627,
0.1096597016,
-0.4496150613,
0.6303365231,
-0.1167159304,
0.933352232,
0.5709486008,
-0.7673045993,
0.4555377662,
0.5033318996,
-0.3275542557,
0.3504965901,
-0.6068838239,
0.1753493845,
0.0440320596,
0.5259529352,
-1.3023087978,
-0.1718408912,
0.2190548033,
-0.4882468879,
0.268242687,
-0.266564548,
-0.4708095789,
-0.6594623327,
0.222160548,
-0.0280354675,
0.5496805906,
-0.3541603982,
1.03956604,
0.4702020586,
-0.4835119545,
-0.3522336781,
-0.5682106018,
0.1905470788,
-0.0036225659,
-0.8362210393,
0.08638414,
0.0352650136,
-0.2344455123,
-0.0237658769,
0.1300638765,
-0.0172198489,
-0.0751931891,
0.6246358156,
0.3814327717,
-0.0725098774,
-0.0996241793,
0.0238335878,
-0.4771955907,
0.2296096832,
-0.3608459532,
0.9629298449,
0.016134385,
-0.4085754156,
-0.9869756699,
0.30386585,
0.9143673778,
-0.1020855159,
0.4529038966,
0.7102487087,
0.0519864559,
0.323330164,
-0.3268572688,
-0.1889424324,
-0.5432909727,
0.5737406015,
-0.4313297868,
-0.6900365353,
0.5410761833,
-0.6486929059,
0.0258240253,
0.1205755472,
0.4965543449,
-0.1987657547,
1.6730645895,
0.518966496,
-0.1914016306,
0.9133828282,
-0.3784654737,
0.8018831611,
-0.6045606732,
-0.2857234776,
-0.1506098658,
-0.3870845139,
-0.7337736487,
-0.1684013307,
0.3599118292,
-0.1018704921,
-0.3931683302,
0.5770304203,
-0.1848864555,
0.2216142565,
0.5308004618,
0.0159133766,
0.248534292,
-0.0005587853,
0.1903900504,
0.0785307065,
-0.8273351789,
-0.3794014454,
0.6255339384,
0.2983581722,
0.6433939338,
0.0176091474,
0.3020950258,
0.2145114392,
0.548630774,
-1.1170381308,
0.499936074,
0.133969143,
-0.0822013542,
-0.3486588299,
-0.1607266366,
-0.9789910913,
-0.0006924852,
-0.1898511797,
-0.9567988515,
-0.052597452,
0.1714383215,
-0.3666457236,
0.0810148716,
-1.0863864422,
0.4194743037,
-0.0474972017,
0.1346390843,
-0.2209626734,
-0.7061704397,
0.0546756126,
0.1483578235,
0.308398366,
0.0067894002,
0.528765738,
0.5039682984,
-0.5074335337,
1.1566672325,
-0.0909674838,
-0.1576368511,
0.561475575,
0.0995537862,
1.004927516,
-0.2324523926,
0.0012547377,
0.2030541897,
-0.5507745743,
-0.1769984514,
-0.5846108794,
0.4840163291,
-0.718390286,
-0.6373722553,
0.0798133984,
-0.6193409562,
-0.4743918478,
0.239988789,
0.2374738008,
0.6180182099,
-0.0501424856,
-0.1293893456,
0.2062248141,
0.1212378144,
0.6996685266,
0.3215934932,
-0.1120394021,
-0.2483519763,
0.7529836297,
0.2272606939,
0.3378896713,
0.186690703,
0.1110504195,
-0.3395061195,
-0.4510350525,
-0.6128893495,
0.0530887619,
-0.5320770144,
-0.2561565936,
-1.1081461906,
-0.2289612591,
-0.5780792236,
-0.1229431927,
-0.1883611977,
-0.2967932224,
-0.1011394486,
-0.3722603023,
0.3451475799,
0.8667278886,
0.3511922956,
0.7583217025,
-0.9435142875,
0.0732245371,
0.4663838744,
0.4701051116,
0.0133132804,
-0.2657132149,
-0.3088527918,
0.0374504998,
-0.464207828,
-0.7973690033,
0.4268678129,
0.0885883197,
0.4504517913,
0.3146665394,
-0.2136124372,
0.9415838718,
-0.7026951313,
0.6254157424,
0.3753065765,
-1.0257285833,
0.3710380495,
-0.2184953541,
0.3052948713,
0.0765087157,
0.130953908,
-0.6989515424,
-0.4713288248,
-0.6581528187,
-0.7339282632,
0.9738274217,
0.2035728544,
0.3893003762,
0.2820336819,
0.0583637692,
-0.1802334487,
-0.1211521327,
-0.3199324012,
-0.2777872384,
-0.0230170824,
-0.0814772472,
0.0184997395,
-0.0368596613,
0.0141020957,
-0.3020785153,
0.2519742846,
-0.4198556244,
0.333150655,
-0.1313679218,
-0.024817545,
-0.3569966257,
-0.0115577206,
0.3339920044,
0.7126227617,
0.0062854276,
-0.3292224407,
0.4176696241,
-0.4668166935,
-0.0972747877,
0.0390850082,
0.1791125238,
0.2030713707,
0.3399653435,
0.9822192788,
0.3612733483,
-0.672840476,
0.2639452517,
-0.0471448712,
0.0701389909,
-0.742506206,
0.2100075036,
0.2584958076,
0.3986317515,
0.2870651186,
0.4191193283,
0.1590303183,
-0.852940917,
0.2682541907,
0.2766419947,
-0.9476780295,
-0.3712525964,
0.3725454509,
0.4561834335,
-1.0003783703,
0.7081884146,
0.0976874977,
-0.8957576156,
0.5605137348,
0.6517881751,
0.8277519345,
-0.527145505,
0.3132526278,
0.2180030793,
-0.1016482338,
0.1598522663,
-0.0163768884,
0.1112437993,
-0.8585925698,
-0.7488052845,
-0.1366472393,
-0.7348767519,
-0.0936769247,
-0.273167789,
0.6127799153,
-0.2055961639,
-0.151630044,
0.0224214587,
-0.2394279838,
-0.6353484988,
0.176314652,
0.1005026102,
0.5756388307,
-0.7060117722,
0.7777268887,
0.3364140987,
-0.2413651943,
-0.785533905,
-0.0384429321,
-0.281568706,
-0.8044365048,
0.9551618695,
0.2065522224,
-0.6420017481,
0.1591739208,
-0.3411941528,
-0.6866292357,
1.0812063217,
0.447917819,
-0.3962397277,
-0.0572010428,
0.3993405998,
0.5687487125,
-0.5452638268,
0.6262537241,
0.672164619,
0.4990147352,
0.4029220939,
-0.9609217644,
-0.1288797706,
-0.133564651,
-0.0328022465,
0.5407329798,
-0.7368022799,
0.7043781281,
-0.2649749517,
-0.4165055156,
-0.2191310674,
0.7018350959,
-0.3383164108,
0.1497639269,
0.7188929915,
0.0896175951,
0.6798511147,
-0.1053955033,
1.0266816616,
-0.3752692938,
0.1339515746,
1.2268030643,
-0.1764870137,
0.6932379007,
0.1615804434,
-0.2573890388,
0.9467193484,
0.541916728,
0.1284358054,
0.2289496958,
0.0021590942,
-0.3075144887,
-0.1058013588,
-0.1483840644,
-0.0532771796,
0.788431108,
0.66131109,
-0.2458373308,
-0.0642394423,
-0.2719561458,
0.0137890503,
-0.1405853629,
0.0541964918,
1.1086065769,
-0.1804433167,
-0.8327405453,
0.3699465692,
-0.4397400022,
0.4099362493,
-0.3948547542,
-0.2590897381,
-0.0611526221,
0.2363850623,
-0.4029490352,
-0.8576613665,
0.4965125024,
-0.2286740988,
0.1670599729,
-0.1014639214,
0.6363298893,
-0.3805631995,
-0.2245052457,
0.6521294117,
0.3042627871,
-0.0559578203,
-0.0266835857,
-0.662963748,
-0.1499604732,
-0.0043415567,
0.0055399905,
0.0379017778,
0.253903687,
-0.1937499642,
1.0066976547,
0.7495964766,
-0.2497728169,
-0.0194209963,
0.2621345818,
0.8925124407,
-0.5275474191,
-0.5118626356,
-0.689822197,
0.5010188222,
-0.3757936656,
-0.0509063974,
0.3976278305,
0.6181178093,
0.6664779186,
0.1718868464,
0.9361262321,
0.1947678626,
0.1326253712,
-0.2531035841,
0.365236789,
0.2763676643,
0.0725080371,
-0.3739555776,
-0.8542384505,
-0.3451174796,
0.3495382369,
-0.4069479108,
-0.1948610842,
0.5347453952,
0.6869218946,
-0.2181841582,
0.314910531,
0.3470079899,
0.2518659532,
0.7616772056,
0.2238229662,
0.8192721009,
-0.4121164978,
0.9124751687,
-0.0266526081,
-0.0783039778,
-0.4611988664,
-0.4075210392,
-0.7905953526,
-0.5263676047,
-0.195555523,
-0.5268122554,
-0.2719452679,
0.6469174027,
0.8687279224,
-0.9094904065,
-0.4461343884,
-0.4098120928,
0.0036724727,
-0.3346509337,
-0.3301270604,
0.1274217367,
-0.5950446725,
-1.2983884811,
0.2490270734,
0.4881486595,
0.1126433089,
-0.1702646464,
-0.2711285353,
0.1910455674,
0.0117743928,
0.8726137877,
0.227039516,
-0.6733894348,
-0.4736818373,
-0.1091876477,
0.1382164657,
0.4193674326,
1.1465491056,
-0.9243969321,
0.5033732057,
0.4844409823,
0.5197490454,
0.6821337938,
-0.0609239936,
1.1760692596,
-0.3684532642,
0.404735148,
0.3055897951,
0.3465574682,
0.3619878888,
-0.5412317514,
0.5576920509,
0.0118238404,
-0.229094997,
-0.4414027631,
0.7102985382,
-0.8383398652,
0.0417762212,
0.7391931415,
-0.1793445945,
0.0020046898,
-0.5129445195,
-0.553884685,
0.4804640114,
-0.5627579689,
0.4658761024,
0.5497205853,
-0.7881247401,
-0.2809860706,
-0.384801209,
0.3505465686,
0.1487897336,
-0.7639135718,
0.1410392076,
0.3451633453,
-0.2043705136,
0.4992204309,
0.3724255264,
-0.1239844561,
-0.0437498838,
-0.1200226396,
-0.4311943948,
0.1962901652,
-0.0585048608,
-0.0219124183,
0.0347497277,
-0.2039968669,
-0.1976045966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08148v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08148v1
|
Distilling Algorithmic Reasoning from LLMs via Explaining Solution Programs
| 2024-04-11T22:19:50 | 2024-04-11T22:19:50 |
Jierui Li, Raymond Mooney
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Distilling explicit chain-of-thought reasoning paths has emerged as an
effective method for improving the reasoning abilities of large language models
(LLMs) across various tasks. However, when tackling complex tasks that pose
significant challenges for state-of-the-art models, this technique often
struggles to produce effective chains of thought that lead to correct answers.
In this work, we propose a novel approach to distill reasoning abilities from
LLMs by leveraging their capacity to explain solutions. We apply our method to
solving competitive-level programming challenges. More specifically, we employ
an LLM to generate explanations for a set of <problem, solution-program> pairs,
then use <problem, explanation> pairs to fine-tune a smaller language model,
which we refer to as the Reasoner, to learn algorithmic reasoning that can
generate "how-to-solve" hints for unseen problems. Our experiments demonstrate
that learning from explanations enables the Reasoner to more effectively guide
program implementation by a Coder, resulting in higher solve rates than strong
chain-of-thought baselines on competitive-level programming problems. It also
outperforms models that learn directly from <problem, solution-program> pairs.
We curated an additional test set in the CodeContests format, which includes
246 more recent problems posted after the models' knowledge cutoff.
|
[
-0.5124713778,
-0.5849853158,
0.9028184414,
-0.0303316545,
-0.1597928554,
0.363627702,
-0.4637761116,
-0.1047068238,
-0.0397184268,
0.3427712023,
-0.8443540335,
-0.2141840011,
-0.6085178256,
0.0951067135,
-0.1325520128,
1.0601644516,
-0.2829758823,
-0.2734492421,
-0.360335201,
0.1376166791,
-0.5643702149,
-0.0935919434,
-0.5510321856,
-0.6480728388,
0.5107017159,
0.597391367,
0.4407922626,
0.7634804845,
0.499712199,
0.3646244407,
-0.0488644429,
0.3523136973,
-0.601000011,
0.221372053,
-0.3884842694,
-0.8226026893,
-0.0691656619,
-0.1054736748,
0.1095914766,
0.9115107059,
-0.3287611902,
0.2844659388,
0.0567732938,
0.753723979,
-0.4935666323,
0.1698978394,
-1.0167638063,
-0.1385749876,
0.0532940067,
-0.5665742755,
-0.4564398229,
-0.139424473,
-0.0500196926,
-0.6298210621,
0.1625887007,
-0.0275024194,
0.568051517,
0.6194346547,
-0.0900109485,
-0.6007553935,
-0.8599590063,
0.6797923446,
-0.5626972318,
-0.12409015,
0.0111847566,
0.6059356332,
-0.3875381649,
-0.5785332918,
-0.4801802635,
0.0554376282,
0.1469723582,
0.0466755293,
-0.312579304,
-0.0881534368,
0.3881850839,
0.356723249,
-0.4055239558,
-0.047251869,
-0.5830238461,
0.0996134207,
0.7667070031,
0.0473983362,
0.0961191133,
0.3454211056,
-0.2240246534,
0.1837812215,
-0.6352583766,
0.1810217053,
0.0767615288,
-0.0010638669,
0.1229780093,
0.4210889637,
0.0077500027,
0.7199236751,
0.2469492853,
-0.1697308272,
-0.0541511439,
-0.0604838468,
-0.0964377001,
0.163775593,
0.3580033481,
0.1727523804,
0.3882434964,
-0.1970741153,
-0.3401090503,
0.0747861639,
0.2239269763,
-0.5193264484,
-0.5416648984,
0.2814423442,
-0.4112555385,
-0.2920305133,
-0.2266596109,
-0.6580969691,
-0.6211226583,
-0.4934491813,
0.305881381,
-0.1172041446,
-0.2366116047,
0.3571306765,
-0.4855217934,
0.2202119976,
0.119170785,
-0.756116271,
0.1530796289,
0.6977354884,
0.6641021967,
0.1312878132,
-0.0319413021,
-0.6258591413,
0.0559364483,
-0.4713948667,
0.7688038349,
-0.5888501406,
-0.0222272314,
-0.2857146859,
-0.440962702,
0.1146394014,
-0.8170621395,
0.2133456469,
-0.4254384935,
-0.0150883738,
-0.3232642412,
-0.5323714018,
0.1092771664,
0.3269424736,
-0.2792176604,
0.7992017865,
-0.3347070813,
-0.6271399856,
0.1019354463,
-0.6360698938,
-0.2403606474,
0.2323421538,
-0.4335146248,
-0.1449235976,
0.3769325614,
0.5515386462,
0.2982385159,
-0.217343539,
0.2923184633,
-0.25045982,
-0.4074810147,
0.2233179659,
-0.2744160295,
0.8201841712,
0.2733874619,
-0.4922113121,
0.0899986252,
-0.5518756509,
0.0443405807,
0.5322105885,
-0.2065105438,
-0.2682465911,
0.2079817355,
-0.9813166261,
0.403331846,
0.2321425378,
-0.1802073121,
0.2633892894,
-0.4955632687,
0.7335950732,
0.9985055923,
0.0938011333,
0.1633865535,
-0.3779968917,
0.7649546862,
-0.1678543985,
0.0504957438,
-0.2817558646,
-0.4482480884,
-0.9129117727,
-0.007424877,
-0.089412421,
0.3798691928,
-0.9343467951,
0.0999299511,
-0.1080462411,
-0.5592854023,
-0.7388588786,
0.3089854717,
0.4842593074,
0.5656837821,
0.4086978137,
0.3141739964,
-0.396856755,
-0.7531549931,
-0.4889723063,
-0.1336851418,
-0.0104249874,
0.3426511586,
0.5995413065,
0.0867306814,
0.7203601599,
-0.7483155727,
0.2673186362,
-0.6764858365,
0.0791526437,
0.4809937775,
0.2390395403,
0.182866931,
-0.6428810358,
-0.3920671344,
-0.1053632945,
-0.6357825994,
-0.3786346614,
-0.4051751792,
-0.1858457327,
-0.1939464957,
0.6891627312,
-0.2142340541,
0.079924345,
0.3861024082,
-0.2882206738,
0.7631960511,
-0.5675208569,
-0.2337010056,
-0.8483924866,
-0.0958463401,
0.0990116522,
-0.1791385859,
-0.3112128377,
0.3745471239,
-0.4457070529,
-0.0991616696,
-0.0547556765,
0.1578641683,
-0.663122952,
0.0638876706,
-0.3120940626,
0.5480234027,
0.1254494488,
0.5927227736,
-0.1286889017,
0.5171852708,
0.6299604177,
-0.4598896801,
0.6815653443,
-0.035599824,
-0.1797206998,
0.2846085727,
-0.8285607696,
0.356058538,
-0.4102346301,
0.0750457868,
-1.0687565804,
0.2015660405,
-0.0542522334,
-0.3731820285,
0.0392751321,
-0.375022471,
-0.3098511994,
-0.7029649615,
-0.0935297981,
0.3682333529,
0.654084146,
-0.831058085,
0.3704404831,
0.2667174935,
-0.0667809844,
-0.4313533306,
-0.5539429784,
-0.0227703173,
-0.4700244069,
-0.5190461874,
0.3979535699,
-0.3632442951,
-0.4971098602,
-0.1590578854,
-0.5439084768,
-0.1230890602,
0.4620163143,
0.0956906676,
0.2542731464,
-0.0983049646,
0.2025791407,
0.0112993428,
-0.3581455648,
0.5329917073,
-0.5388864279,
0.3661300838,
-0.1835754514,
-0.3717327714,
-0.2235586792,
0.2839994729,
0.4589674771,
-0.4659334421,
0.7874053121,
0.180637762,
-0.1702004075,
-0.7676460743,
-0.432798177,
-0.2956345081,
-0.4939164221,
0.1803810298,
-0.7452682257,
-0.7909772396,
0.5264545679,
-0.5335946679,
0.1354202181,
0.1725608855,
0.5310944915,
-0.122508429,
1.2741883993,
0.4133221507,
-0.0134146186,
0.1177269518,
-0.3871896863,
0.6167960763,
-0.4805680513,
-0.4249328673,
-0.424464196,
-0.4455434978,
-0.3133100867,
-0.4955238998,
0.4240756631,
0.5112947822,
-0.134777382,
0.1040686592,
-0.7580647469,
1.0935071707,
0.5008589625,
0.1233049333,
0.3063952029,
-0.1229173467,
-0.2757277191,
0.1530314535,
-0.9924052954,
-0.4252366126,
0.8067907691,
0.3601275086,
0.5677875876,
0.015755387,
1.0888576508,
-0.0146479774,
-0.0117851477,
-0.6034620404,
0.3791903257,
-0.0190600529,
-0.4391608238,
-0.1270229369,
-0.5977591872,
-0.5815941095,
0.2194111347,
-0.0998983458,
-0.616443038,
-0.102861017,
0.4561143517,
-0.4185293317,
0.229659453,
-0.5132853389,
0.9743994474,
-0.3358364403,
-0.3452416956,
-0.3707006574,
-0.4950200915,
0.3702832758,
0.231837675,
0.5268152356,
0.0974621698,
0.1912335306,
0.5378172398,
-0.6121117473,
0.544154346,
-0.1386280358,
-0.244464457,
0.3829378188,
0.2627978027,
0.6784214973,
-0.0488579497,
-0.0381328687,
-0.2349740267,
-0.2005778253,
-0.3806859553,
-0.9438797832,
0.616564095,
-0.3163782358,
-1.0397529602,
-0.0277211834,
-0.5858305097,
-0.0082818652,
0.0078987656,
0.0779754296,
0.5098541975,
0.3977783322,
-0.0986235365,
0.8189578056,
-0.143543154,
0.2567777932,
0.2167826444,
0.0073832003,
0.0825305134,
0.9579437971,
-0.242560938,
0.3596066833,
0.1659938097,
0.4260714948,
-0.1857061088,
-0.8598576188,
-0.208253786,
0.2156349421,
-0.8464213014,
-0.0692093819,
-0.1130189002,
-0.1496246308,
0.2399681211,
-0.4249674976,
-0.2182671279,
-0.3239807487,
0.0713117197,
-0.1775883734,
0.1073354781,
0.6339717507,
-0.0620669313,
-0.0153118242,
-0.4512600899,
0.4254762828,
0.3228453696,
0.2630462646,
0.2238093466,
-0.4850718975,
-0.2784689069,
0.2368798107,
-0.210161984,
-0.9701923132,
0.1939786822,
0.0212555602,
0.7687940598,
0.4577037096,
0.2057439834,
0.9573094249,
-0.3542708158,
0.6835451722,
0.0306686647,
-1.0024044514,
1.0043832064,
-0.1169733033,
0.2524635792,
0.509239614,
0.327260077,
-0.2481515557,
-0.5706779957,
-0.4602473378,
-0.7836633325,
0.5887573361,
0.3076371849,
-0.2360679805,
-0.2239875346,
0.7442016006,
0.051604446,
-0.0556729697,
-0.7748912573,
-0.3808574975,
0.1490359008,
-0.2900269926,
0.0693734586,
-0.0582048446,
-0.2538321018,
-0.2774757445,
0.8206633925,
-0.1755801588,
-0.0872855112,
0.0824747831,
-0.1850675344,
0.0516601019,
0.3849197924,
0.3746737838,
0.9787431955,
0.0253346451,
0.7078031301,
-0.0548978895,
0.1420908868,
0.0081107831,
0.0331484862,
0.1561708301,
-0.197992444,
0.586828649,
0.5556846261,
-0.2423937321,
-0.9685668945,
0.4245049357,
0.0907947645,
-0.2983509004,
0.0413368195,
0.2322843373,
0.4562999904,
0.5876296759,
0.2286687195,
-0.0095967241,
0.1627631485,
-0.4904085398,
-0.0298916791,
0.4898048043,
-0.2871370614,
-0.1218151376,
0.5656727552,
0.2909561396,
-0.2861216962,
0.5514618754,
-0.4614101648,
-0.8622692227,
0.8649814725,
0.7606126666,
0.4969236851,
0.1598902643,
0.2393610328,
0.2098220885,
0.2186590135,
-0.2055954933,
0.2397531867,
-0.4100229144,
-0.6164213419,
-0.665845871,
-0.3175306618,
-0.0833236724,
0.1141689718,
-0.579867959,
-0.0906703398,
-0.2923494875,
0.2614210546,
0.2325013131,
-0.0892879143,
-0.4185193479,
-0.2601745725,
0.4210920334,
0.8193221688,
-0.8577498198,
0.4025842845,
0.660584867,
-0.4666726887,
-1.0645809174,
-0.1267694384,
-0.048402708,
-0.8919534087,
0.6863789558,
0.1278743744,
-0.2990307808,
-0.0166139267,
-0.5715315342,
-0.5406000614,
1.102653265,
0.5574146509,
-0.9106761217,
0.0609528534,
0.0443208292,
0.3996516168,
-0.4648864865,
0.1908241063,
0.7002533078,
0.3028739095,
0.261471808,
-0.7721412778,
0.1915208548,
-0.3901010752,
-0.1616629064,
0.3182632923,
-0.2029831856,
0.5862064362,
-0.7161743045,
-0.1025338247,
-0.3054871261,
0.3051201403,
0.7272980213,
0.3185202181,
0.520925045,
0.5018857121,
0.9195873737,
0.1356024891,
0.7905802131,
-0.2424606234,
0.3006576896,
1.2698185444,
-0.0475775674,
0.5518270135,
0.7983505726,
-0.1235092878,
0.9407907128,
0.4921667576,
0.0749070719,
0.5045716763,
0.8614602685,
-0.0565725267,
-0.7527505159,
0.048401691,
-0.1052608564,
0.3727757931,
0.2161778957,
-0.346280396,
-0.3717861474,
-0.0915473029,
-0.0953379422,
0.6059799194,
-0.5510392189,
0.7428410053,
0.1332131177,
-0.9165176153,
0.7673200369,
-0.0263135973,
0.4751866162,
-0.2741746604,
-0.3567796946,
-0.1536914408,
0.4967684448,
-0.1190347821,
-0.7985906005,
0.3564995825,
0.2432260215,
-0.3130406439,
-0.3595083952,
0.5391747952,
-0.5170729756,
-0.4929384291,
0.2166487277,
0.6040709019,
0.3223215044,
-0.1308407933,
-0.8214433789,
-0.0515090637,
0.1455226392,
0.1879483312,
-0.0083631147,
0.6918991804,
0.1585878581,
1.0516829491,
0.4528605938,
0.1656923443,
0.0619617552,
0.1523889601,
1.0259404182,
-0.3727629781,
-0.4995805025,
-1.3152672052,
0.5343905687,
-0.1433044523,
0.0746008679,
0.5533837676,
0.4690020084,
0.7123816013,
0.0021989553,
0.7581598759,
0.1080706567,
0.2003411353,
-0.5504674315,
0.3453422785,
-0.5030611157,
0.8392393589,
0.0222149286,
-0.6051964164,
-0.0806493759,
0.6559115648,
-0.3885724247,
-0.0747439936,
0.6535693407,
0.6390105486,
-0.0492566191,
-0.1838937998,
-0.1452597231,
0.3211635947,
0.5170558691,
1.1595898867,
0.8918187022,
-0.0093621472,
0.8096838593,
-0.2717119157,
-0.5310795307,
0.0861370042,
-1.0460830927,
-1.1540060043,
-0.322295785,
-0.5264334083,
-0.2058167607,
0.2281490415,
0.8553435802,
0.5471338034,
-0.4818587303,
-0.1769186556,
-0.6721970439,
0.5759004951,
-0.6231091022,
-0.2030643374,
0.1456086934,
-0.537894845,
-0.1795651615,
0.4443531036,
0.1844995916,
-0.4143771231,
-0.2896391153,
-0.2085774541,
0.0660872981,
0.2385397404,
0.2860156894,
0.1359361559,
-0.7884938121,
-0.0803459361,
-0.0725794435,
0.4380105138,
-0.037907239,
0.8960936069,
-0.8529654741,
0.6087007523,
0.3496347964,
0.5077647567,
0.4825109243,
-0.0747407228,
0.6279509068,
-0.7381864786,
-0.1724920571,
0.1353893727,
0.3541510701,
0.0288414676,
-0.2946354151,
0.2763145566,
0.0497003496,
-0.4687586129,
-0.8025906086,
0.4199030399,
-0.7225598097,
-0.6651095748,
0.9346566796,
-0.3199653327,
-0.1151274741,
-0.0977842808,
-0.0833161622,
0.1711149812,
-0.1358163655,
1.0182654858,
0.5954174995,
-0.3537072837,
-0.3651710451,
-0.2815882862,
0.4974026978,
0.1142460778,
-0.7737125754,
0.4486775696,
0.3311433792,
0.2899007201,
0.1237286255,
0.5424472094,
0.0488947481,
0.1647130251,
-0.0001133435,
-0.2598291337,
-0.5196225643,
-0.4809119999,
-0.2767175138,
0.1456543654,
0.2677366734,
-0.1483681649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08134v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08134v1
|
Extending Translate-Train for ColBERT-X to African Language CLIR
| 2024-04-11T21:31:02 | 2024-04-11T21:31:02 |
Eugene Yang, Dawn J. Lawrie, Paul McNamee, James Mayfield
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
This paper describes the submission runs from the HLTCOE team at the CIRAL
CLIR tasks for African languages at FIRE 2023. Our submissions use machine
translation models to translate the documents and the training passages, and
ColBERT-X as the retrieval model. Additionally, we present a set of unofficial
runs that use an alternative training procedure with a similar training
setting.
|
[
-0.2902216017,
-0.1611400992,
0.2864091098,
0.1632141471,
-0.1310844272,
0.0438091047,
-0.3963636458,
-0.4848159552,
0.4013017714,
0.7193965912,
-0.3287853301,
-0.1543707699,
-0.7086400986,
0.2428910881,
-0.7791135907,
0.9803743958,
-0.4858363867,
-0.0719289035,
0.1989777684,
-0.2666722238,
-0.1246596649,
-0.9193376899,
-0.5329206586,
-0.3160587549,
0.7112511396,
0.6632862687,
0.7368583083,
0.6407549381,
0.6129156351,
0.1991348267,
0.0445832163,
-0.3253522813,
-0.7619141936,
-0.1099172309,
-0.2431864738,
-0.3805261552,
-0.2288450748,
-0.0336612388,
0.5735364556,
0.4155372381,
-0.1094141454,
-0.0079462146,
-0.1875594556,
0.5088192225,
-0.7383565903,
-0.1178138256,
-0.5853784084,
-0.0922160819,
-0.145408541,
-0.1588558853,
-0.4932004809,
-0.4306152463,
0.2112606913,
-0.592676878,
0.3735948503,
0.2139530629,
0.8891448975,
-0.2381969839,
-0.5478503704,
-0.7745890021,
-0.4978240728,
0.8724218607,
-0.4172810614,
0.5715404749,
0.3795929253,
0.4149979651,
0.1262627989,
-1.1626591682,
-0.7448234558,
-0.1710144877,
-0.0842922851,
0.0109756924,
0.0380355641,
0.0148167042,
0.0403086171,
0.6194841862,
-0.4723980129,
-0.2704211473,
-0.6395449042,
-0.2953301072,
1.1787518263,
0.1376749873,
0.0334916338,
0.0044003557,
-0.391358763,
-0.3588071167,
-0.485157758,
-0.0212608706,
0.6018921137,
0.1636796892,
-0.4631241858,
0.3366112411,
-0.353526026,
0.6814000607,
-0.32619524,
0.1082566008,
0.3906785846,
-0.096433118,
-0.0624506958,
0.3312436044,
0.7020870447,
0.1184004471,
0.2892086804,
-0.3020884693,
-0.3986950815,
-0.1694371551,
0.2950794399,
-0.9085415006,
-0.4939176738,
-0.0049443664,
-0.3273155987,
-0.4080925882,
-0.203662619,
-0.8037090302,
-0.128285557,
-0.2631310523,
0.4428595603,
-0.3557120264,
-0.2295042425,
0.1385030299,
-0.1964796633,
0.2989915013,
0.2782205641,
-0.7406978607,
0.3203340471,
0.3410719633,
0.6643826962,
0.0616049655,
-0.2764178514,
-0.8591880202,
-0.0650076792,
0.0496130101,
0.2890348732,
-0.6996715069,
-0.6999931931,
0.5101649761,
0.327847451,
-0.3531793356,
-0.1853909343,
1.2732633352,
-0.8081151843,
-0.1165843979,
-0.6494600773,
-0.298630774,
-0.4774136841,
0.1369167864,
-0.5702214241,
0.9487555027,
0.3900334537,
-0.672064662,
0.0251063891,
-0.6093466282,
-0.6958175302,
-0.029260017,
0.1985041052,
-0.4826777577,
-0.0716406405,
0.3396067321,
0.1354469657,
-0.1008208022,
-0.0992382839,
-0.2508192062,
-0.3056029975,
0.0205911119,
0.1534153372,
1.1065459251,
0.5523073673,
-0.4777981639,
-0.0916909277,
-0.9040178061,
0.2091761082,
0.0346925817,
-0.3831769824,
0.009684464,
-0.2611856163,
0.6219087243,
0.471016854,
0.050120756,
-1.0139838457,
0.3232826889,
0.1096013114,
0.4625258744,
0.0709059909,
-0.2473184019,
0.5956320167,
-0.3175634146,
0.8385717273,
-0.2549066544,
-0.0425483026,
-0.2122732103,
-0.460380435,
-0.8958218098,
-0.114968963,
0.3672439754,
0.8215973377,
-0.7478982806,
-0.0351880826,
-0.3186647296,
-0.5957810879,
-0.6704095006,
0.3389033973,
0.2192571014,
0.4571631253,
0.5162517428,
-0.329900533,
-0.9463940263,
-0.6787842512,
-0.0014040179,
0.034884762,
0.7047793865,
0.1611042619,
1.0405151844,
-0.4747867584,
0.4112247229,
-0.2101121098,
-0.4599890411,
-0.6495890021,
0.2057477385,
-0.0808487609,
0.6592188478,
0.6627126336,
-0.79861027,
-0.8510733247,
0.5220239162,
-0.6669648886,
0.0234396234,
0.0513636358,
-0.1186280474,
0.0243246779,
0.6178743839,
-0.1480510086,
0.8934314251,
0.5429227352,
-0.0351159796,
0.3883086145,
0.0029842341,
0.2234344333,
-0.9396802783,
0.221825853,
-0.4008056521,
-0.5986961126,
-0.607281208,
0.3860947788,
0.184211269,
-0.4249058664,
-0.5707832575,
0.8828062415,
-0.4878438115,
0.0972059444,
-0.4295004904,
0.0854797065,
0.0579345226,
0.2974961102,
0.5013716221,
0.7152912021,
0.5289419293,
-0.5625652671,
0.4357608557,
0.8887813091,
-0.5313413143,
0.4267196357,
-0.7127174735,
0.3851585686,
0.0314999521,
0.3212644756,
-0.7107827663,
-0.2674648762,
-0.0333406664,
-0.4513143301,
0.3875331581,
-0.1092527658,
-0.3480963707,
-0.5778598785,
0.1565383971,
0.3276243508,
0.5897363424,
-0.6144111753,
0.2751689851,
-0.0428583175,
-0.1219364926,
-0.8521624207,
-0.741756618,
0.4830031395,
-0.0656688213,
-0.6743699312,
0.3185868561,
0.0195693206,
-0.1804255098,
-0.1795835644,
0.4190052152,
-0.2136370242,
0.0648701862,
0.0397803038,
-0.4114804566,
-0.286929518,
-0.37909621,
-0.057488963,
0.3813028038,
0.0569333918,
-0.1646678597,
0.4893368781,
-0.1803845018,
0.1921395808,
-0.4940734804,
0.7465686202,
0.2516744435,
-0.5428386331,
0.9598432779,
0.8115274906,
0.0702615529,
0.15459764,
-0.6099228263,
-0.0528296232,
-0.4334390759,
0.1656950116,
-0.4611501694,
-0.8236723542,
0.6120558977,
0.1419990063,
0.0491625182,
0.2124330103,
0.6394514441,
-0.3638684452,
0.7099490762,
0.9042106867,
-0.0228274409,
0.4412864745,
-0.8220598102,
-0.0397749618,
-1.0395627022,
-0.0459794365,
-0.6587047577,
-0.4924803674,
-0.330485791,
0.1221942678,
0.1754877716,
0.0992618278,
-0.0103026815,
0.9842634797,
-0.1842788756,
0.1459005326,
0.401468873,
-0.0636083633,
0.0903389826,
0.0788097233,
-0.205632031,
0.2110677212,
-0.7159075141,
-0.4903902709,
1.2052836418,
0.1762667298,
0.5260493159,
0.1304793954,
1.0638619661,
0.4192819893,
0.7831475735,
-0.5535371304,
0.2570783198,
0.0839241296,
-1.0259094238,
-0.2319687009,
-0.0548273437,
-1.0366309881,
0.1666574627,
0.0701340362,
-0.6306818128,
0.7618934512,
0.1472887099,
0.018034162,
0.4205798209,
-0.4945600331,
0.9406293631,
-0.40965271,
-0.3842844665,
-0.3389077187,
-0.9097854495,
0.3211054504,
-0.224307552,
0.1812046021,
0.380880475,
0.3352095485,
0.6863545775,
-0.5759738684,
0.4594867826,
-0.171704188,
-0.2119876295,
0.6792454123,
0.215287149,
0.6521331668,
0.0524572358,
-0.7745761871,
0.1372629404,
-0.0389047526,
-0.6364721656,
-0.1939167082,
0.5299429297,
-0.9377118945,
-0.4132752419,
-0.6013051867,
-0.882932663,
0.1973877996,
0.2418195605,
0.6723101735,
0.5912911296,
-0.3746850789,
0.2557317317,
0.1685935259,
0.1056985557,
0.6509925127,
0.210946545,
-0.2480906397,
-0.7891682982,
0.7039183974,
-0.1175789163,
0.4723736942,
0.5885239244,
-0.2585951984,
-0.3538760543,
-0.6549617648,
-0.498209089,
0.2807630599,
-0.7774620056,
0.0286840908,
-0.8042672873,
-0.1670716852,
-0.5932078362,
-0.5819576383,
0.0250860136,
-0.5368090868,
-0.2575457394,
0.038461592,
0.1568912417,
0.6644559503,
-0.3787808716,
1.2361639738,
-0.7004984021,
-0.0739937127,
0.1716594547,
-0.2401741147,
-0.307916671,
-1.1614329815,
-0.7841082215,
0.1923887283,
-0.804616034,
-0.7077535987,
0.8702007532,
0.5314837694,
0.3684721291,
0.1762688905,
0.125276193,
0.5357198119,
-0.5703089237,
0.5837127566,
0.3498361111,
-0.9320792556,
0.5952364206,
-0.2392614484,
-0.1551219076,
0.9841884375,
0.7889038324,
-0.3294758797,
0.0302166343,
-0.5374538302,
-0.2167365402,
0.6033177972,
0.6042779088,
0.182555452,
-0.1394288391,
0.3366841078,
0.180569157,
0.3602033854,
-0.7076258659,
-0.0860919356,
-0.5059010386,
0.1724880189,
-0.2288402468,
-0.2617777586,
-0.0691663548,
-0.4419045746,
0.7858065963,
-0.0510544032,
0.3187898993,
0.5696522593,
-0.6601967812,
-0.1211689413,
0.4596105516,
0.9110648632,
0.8413009644,
-0.4147410095,
-0.3219762146,
0.0821516961,
-0.5761632323,
0.4157269597,
0.1172384545,
-0.0312103517,
0.2235596031,
0.393355459,
1.0379008055,
-0.0203480404,
-0.3360646665,
0.7047119737,
0.0728600845,
-0.5120241046,
-0.8270817399,
-0.0846374556,
-0.195555985,
-0.0434847102,
0.1382452101,
0.1768722832,
0.1940652281,
-0.7654693127,
0.2871189117,
0.1494728476,
-1.0645067692,
-0.6477639675,
0.9270656109,
0.7697575092,
-0.2881840467,
0.8504810333,
-0.5648715496,
-1.006331563,
0.4478716552,
0.5260536671,
0.8356285095,
-0.354914248,
0.0302650444,
0.658554852,
0.5394541025,
0.1255577654,
0.9101002216,
-0.1710642427,
-0.5155717731,
-0.3447263837,
-0.4562158585,
-0.2263495773,
0.1676624715,
-1.080601573,
0.6328813434,
-0.0399682745,
-0.119866617,
-0.4079480469,
-0.1017591953,
-0.9156173468,
0.4867452681,
0.3405550718,
1.3774534464,
-0.6447327137,
1.2959774733,
0.7491028309,
-0.2953644991,
-0.3122705221,
-0.2820660472,
-0.3137093484,
-0.8428209424,
1.0650428534,
-0.0283112898,
0.2389330864,
0.1684441715,
-0.5470821857,
-0.6743821502,
0.8772304058,
0.3226214051,
-0.8326345086,
-0.0111369798,
0.279337436,
0.1909703761,
-0.5743017197,
0.3370694816,
0.6275743246,
0.484678179,
0.0217238441,
-1.2094460726,
-0.4078125656,
-0.184258312,
-0.2042652667,
0.1719662398,
-0.7319684625,
0.6839537024,
-0.6095123887,
-0.1265532523,
0.7255715728,
1.0707587004,
-0.2641935945,
0.296058476,
0.4716882706,
0.8362348676,
0.5361558795,
0.0454970635,
1.4304286242,
-0.4762688577,
0.4469542801,
1.1919668913,
-0.5154852867,
0.9301282763,
0.3548617065,
0.0259610843,
0.8829076886,
0.4741432071,
0.3199343085,
0.6158864498,
0.323674649,
-0.3093235195,
-0.3063995242,
-0.203690052,
-0.59661448,
0.3947930038,
0.5001116395,
-0.4935000539,
-0.1118695065,
0.27729702,
0.2445011139,
0.1864168793,
-0.3612672985,
0.3062434494,
0.3588285148,
-0.6870184541,
0.9627961516,
-0.0599388741,
0.3154316545,
-0.5651002526,
0.0629123598,
-0.1286699176,
0.3934098184,
-0.2998814881,
-0.8052148223,
0.3140955269,
-0.326936841,
-0.0576020218,
-0.1620409638,
0.3428297639,
-0.6202568412,
-0.6777925491,
0.2886300385,
0.0732532218,
0.2624038756,
-0.1158549041,
-0.6790083051,
0.2256837785,
0.3116431236,
0.2133910507,
0.0495195389,
0.401240617,
-0.1799307764,
0.5672906041,
0.372674644,
0.1503778845,
0.4852725863,
-0.2497112304,
0.5944224,
-0.5483314991,
-0.6535003185,
-0.3955853581,
0.2402358502,
-0.1701458842,
-0.6128483415,
0.5994644165,
0.8366763592,
0.8288343549,
-0.367792815,
1.1452823877,
-0.339074105,
0.4599507153,
-0.2208117992,
0.6608583927,
-0.4232540131,
-0.3263425827,
-0.0554106273,
-1.0351383686,
0.1474094987,
0.3714800775,
-0.33376351,
-0.3120369911,
1.0405818224,
0.5799590945,
-0.3291413486,
0.1740641445,
0.374609381,
-0.0408747084,
0.3814817369,
0.6490927339,
0.8503878117,
-0.9976899624,
0.9594398737,
-0.6053041816,
0.1086119413,
-0.4322748184,
-0.8541097045,
-1.0327701569,
-0.7538942695,
-0.4529718459,
-0.4964313507,
0.0745696723,
0.7440240979,
0.8782842755,
-1.1573418379,
-0.5849257112,
0.3077166378,
-0.1628211588,
-0.3243767023,
-0.1562872082,
0.3201049864,
-0.4379065335,
-0.6042835116,
0.4867297411,
-0.1803825051,
-0.0123183755,
-0.0589383356,
-0.3942439258,
-0.5254397988,
-0.1745029688,
0.7203688025,
0.6876986027,
-0.5470168591,
-0.3145558834,
0.083895117,
-0.0165806878,
0.1474715322,
1.1037688255,
-0.7197802067,
0.3838233054,
0.518642664,
0.8576062918,
0.7672843933,
-0.2496880591,
0.8323414326,
-0.5729733706,
0.4031597376,
0.0858246088,
0.6045020223,
0.5912813544,
-0.3292374313,
0.7713780999,
0.3718696833,
-0.6364206076,
-0.7513227463,
0.1188502386,
-1.3128986359,
0.5048822761,
1.3544459343,
-0.3021319211,
-0.3522063196,
-0.4261838794,
-0.3674135208,
-0.0771860406,
-0.3000323176,
0.4446450174,
0.7243516445,
0.3571436703,
-0.2564922273,
-0.8125060797,
0.4137833714,
0.2975506485,
-0.540176928,
-0.3081323504,
-0.1601549983,
0.1574373692,
0.189184621,
0.3498932123,
-0.0363615528,
0.5977496505,
-0.315020591,
0.4297707379,
0.1825396568,
-0.2390114218,
-0.1579607576,
-0.0614823736,
-0.2516805828,
-0.1751874983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08118v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08118v1
|
HLTCOE at TREC 2023 NeuCLIR Track
| 2024-04-11T20:46:18 | 2024-04-11T20:46:18 |
Eugene Yang, Dawn Lawrie, James Mayfield
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
The HLTCOE team applied PLAID, an mT5 reranker, and document translation to
the TREC 2023 NeuCLIR track. For PLAID we included a variety of models and
training techniques -- the English model released with ColBERT v2,
translate-train~(TT), Translate Distill~(TD) and multilingual
translate-train~(MTT). TT trains a ColBERT model with English queries and
passages automatically translated into the document language from the MS-MARCO
v1 collection. This results in three cross-language models for the track, one
per language. MTT creates a single model for all three document languages by
combining the translations of MS-MARCO passages in all three languages into
mixed-language batches. Thus the model learns about matching queries to
passages simultaneously in all languages. Distillation uses scores from the mT5
model over non-English translated document pairs to learn how to score
query-document pairs. The team submitted runs to all NeuCLIR tasks: the CLIR
and MLIR news task as well as the technical documents task.
|
[
-0.4442420304,
-0.5270503163,
0.4790556729,
0.1576455981,
-0.3119465411,
0.3928782046,
-0.2158273011,
-0.628395617,
0.2968634963,
0.5356506109,
-0.4906789362,
-0.5084820986,
-0.6744984984,
0.4706001878,
-0.514331162,
1.2329577208,
-0.3023874164,
0.2471392602,
0.1753733158,
-0.2072149664,
-0.3050121963,
-0.3378490508,
-0.7050560713,
-0.5582415462,
0.8831532001,
0.5690347552,
0.3360058665,
0.3519236743,
0.6921883821,
0.2679772973,
-0.2541752756,
-0.2344522774,
-0.6169170737,
0.1986847818,
-0.3308016062,
-0.3915242553,
-0.5072804093,
0.3854953647,
0.5885359645,
0.2950454056,
-0.1990689635,
0.0692581981,
0.1930890977,
0.4081998169,
-0.5028484464,
-0.0878532603,
-0.5955725312,
0.1174923182,
-0.3088505566,
-0.3912781179,
-0.689637363,
-0.4342651963,
0.0639103949,
-0.814637959,
0.3423339725,
0.3967269957,
1.0719301701,
0.0059860498,
-0.8405778408,
-0.6917577386,
-0.4802900255,
1.0860536098,
-0.386410296,
0.7313435674,
0.3860109448,
0.3771153092,
0.116122134,
-1.05597651,
-0.463086009,
-0.1594091952,
0.0328331701,
0.3149892092,
0.0912861973,
-0.0471705906,
-0.0372672528,
0.2906119525,
-0.4398975074,
0.0746442825,
-0.7631364465,
-0.2019701004,
0.5767115355,
0.2184280306,
-0.1800867766,
-0.159583196,
-0.5784501433,
-0.3304078877,
-0.4339830279,
-0.3273792863,
0.3712622821,
0.0930536091,
-0.3680161536,
0.2964019477,
-0.0168872941,
0.5001918674,
0.2861829102,
0.0692375973,
0.2676531672,
-0.5242626071,
-0.3431449234,
0.2469961792,
0.9144851565,
-0.0328055397,
0.1306029409,
-0.2368344963,
-0.4959542155,
-0.7361503243,
0.3177456558,
-0.6922748685,
-0.2913166583,
0.0024887109,
-0.4137972295,
-0.3974445164,
-0.2154389024,
-0.8974945545,
-0.0489532426,
-0.42698434,
0.5347465277,
-0.4557286203,
-0.2828455567,
-0.1458876729,
-0.3212623,
0.3905703127,
0.4534867406,
-0.770830214,
0.2010158449,
0.51458323,
0.7197239995,
-0.2615063488,
-0.7119360566,
-0.9395157099,
0.140675962,
-0.2434784919,
0.6123008728,
-0.4888349473,
-0.4632223248,
0.0013253281,
0.3860270083,
-0.2945549786,
-0.2919669449,
0.9019658566,
-0.678707242,
0.5977525115,
-0.5468579531,
-0.2449931055,
-0.1347236037,
0.3394246399,
-0.8142769933,
1.1912105083,
0.2161946297,
-0.896225512,
0.3787399828,
-0.7199630737,
-0.5930072665,
-0.0857704878,
0.5026038885,
-0.4309641421,
0.112079747,
-0.002047179,
0.2458915412,
-0.3011249006,
0.2404994667,
-0.0101527432,
-0.3917571902,
-0.1201122478,
-0.1445736289,
0.9680113196,
0.5346127748,
-0.3373172879,
-0.0358305462,
-0.4635917544,
-0.1666778922,
-0.2199809104,
-0.8756445646,
-0.1057215109,
-0.5037076473,
0.6737684608,
0.4005172551,
0.1646213084,
-0.6897090673,
-0.0067907418,
0.0552345179,
0.6522250772,
0.4391146898,
-0.0387358405,
0.6010294557,
-0.2975750566,
0.6448897123,
0.0658622533,
0.2947385013,
0.1171477661,
-0.5669304132,
-0.8061479926,
-0.0092858961,
0.730312407,
0.5141732097,
-0.9788600802,
-0.2152729034,
-0.2359418273,
-0.4825860858,
-0.6339686513,
-0.0079193451,
0.4054308236,
0.6004843116,
0.6149662733,
-0.0174023695,
-0.6436361074,
-0.8256376982,
0.0172552075,
0.0207999386,
0.380305022,
-0.1920721233,
1.0110762119,
0.0436756238,
0.3005078435,
-0.0429969653,
-0.3208707869,
-0.5334791541,
0.5817331672,
0.2853588462,
0.6350191236,
0.4875822663,
-0.8345194459,
-0.8195489049,
0.2601478696,
-0.5345100164,
-0.0453786962,
0.1506522596,
-0.3902674019,
0.4161813855,
0.6662521958,
-0.2378001511,
0.3959369063,
0.641567111,
-0.0702665821,
0.4132100046,
-0.2917612493,
0.6380754113,
-1.4395684004,
0.012661932,
-0.116207391,
-0.392831862,
-0.469024092,
0.1038716957,
0.3022231758,
-0.0869385898,
-0.7769572139,
0.4403166771,
-0.6649500728,
0.0794083253,
0.0132662645,
0.1501452774,
0.3698191941,
0.3112930954,
0.1988830864,
0.626411438,
0.2531818748,
-0.5874893069,
0.407584548,
0.3334284425,
-0.1368382722,
0.7790248394,
-0.6241973042,
0.2327758968,
0.1493133903,
0.0196201149,
-0.9624853134,
-0.0915150121,
-0.1625836045,
-0.6120421886,
0.686414063,
-0.2559376955,
-0.2956612408,
-0.5466125607,
-0.1358097643,
0.2837233841,
0.4399833679,
-0.4583528638,
0.7218316197,
0.3200129867,
0.1340879053,
-0.5554575324,
-1.0781904459,
0.4081725478,
-0.4230652452,
-0.4981697798,
0.5516127944,
0.0454644412,
-0.1470508426,
0.0564855784,
0.1870087534,
-0.4166954756,
-0.0049932655,
-0.1442524493,
0.0876988098,
-0.301815033,
-0.0913455635,
-0.0512064695,
0.084463194,
-0.1235034168,
-0.4114982784,
0.6136534214,
-0.0032517931,
-0.0047370372,
-0.6240412593,
0.3643602431,
0.6832740307,
-0.3926689029,
0.6939283013,
0.8949306607,
-0.0634725019,
0.1116225421,
-0.7971417904,
-0.1980728954,
-0.4258723557,
0.2956844866,
-0.6535412073,
-0.7420765758,
0.5254661441,
0.3025574684,
0.2138097733,
0.5286543965,
0.6118701696,
-0.4924149513,
0.5776014924,
0.6470085382,
-0.0706765503,
0.5349857211,
-0.4118908048,
-0.0324968696,
-0.9721625447,
-0.4515454471,
-0.9143106341,
-0.5170413256,
-0.8490307927,
-0.2229070812,
0.3838933706,
-0.1260307282,
-0.1308339387,
0.9349495173,
-0.4202208221,
0.3791697919,
0.84294945,
-0.1049705967,
0.367900908,
-0.0574148111,
-0.3605590463,
-0.1677098572,
-0.7680030465,
-0.2589577436,
1.1899939775,
0.2841201723,
0.6789989471,
0.1219875365,
1.1739364862,
0.1284334213,
0.5079033971,
-0.7033486962,
0.2116210312,
-0.2002816796,
-0.7949095368,
-0.3236660659,
-0.2669625282,
-0.9163451791,
0.0182594322,
-0.1764659584,
-0.2399135381,
0.5104593635,
-0.0313167125,
0.1000374556,
0.3003683686,
-0.537863791,
0.7521088719,
-0.3659358919,
-0.8195812702,
-0.2092052847,
-0.4921387732,
0.3915962875,
-0.2547994852,
0.3400755525,
0.282669425,
0.1772518456,
0.9173232913,
-0.0660813227,
0.3782260716,
-0.1005879417,
-0.1961993575,
0.2379119247,
0.3903930783,
0.6182688475,
0.0347485095,
-0.6465249658,
0.0134803914,
0.0568575636,
-0.4257697463,
0.013328407,
0.6092916727,
-0.683994174,
-0.5871104002,
-0.490716666,
-0.5068966746,
0.086927101,
0.3584882319,
0.6378955841,
0.3919824064,
-0.4056696594,
0.485958606,
0.5515395403,
-0.0474595465,
0.7975251675,
0.5685073733,
-0.0207747538,
-0.7486078739,
0.5887234211,
-0.1655733883,
0.4594652951,
0.7695162296,
0.0334959961,
-0.6448999047,
-0.8024157286,
-0.3128916621,
0.2717115283,
-0.6314569116,
-0.025925478,
-0.7308475375,
-0.1166467369,
-0.5835095644,
-0.2408133894,
-0.3084395528,
-0.4067094028,
-0.1138549894,
-0.0104703251,
-0.0243418012,
1.0523833036,
-0.2099657953,
0.4442597628,
-0.6227794886,
0.0503359064,
0.2604313791,
-0.0587159321,
-0.5167176127,
-0.9952439666,
-0.5482878089,
0.0334342495,
-0.6754471064,
-0.8314210176,
0.5439212918,
0.1615509391,
0.6493886709,
-0.1568819731,
-0.0954830945,
0.6533861756,
-0.4110001326,
0.5846807361,
0.4071523547,
-1.0159202814,
0.6528373957,
-0.4259600043,
0.1227964908,
0.9882988334,
0.4801973403,
-0.5571236014,
-0.4317546785,
-0.4143400192,
-0.3605638444,
0.8599444032,
0.2630885243,
-0.0631731525,
-0.0878534988,
0.0137572912,
0.007136568,
0.2764298618,
-0.8896868229,
0.3422841132,
-0.4621495008,
-0.08989764,
-0.0510903783,
-0.2271943092,
-0.0523405485,
-0.2825540006,
0.747163713,
0.0086582508,
-0.0321843512,
0.3289606273,
-0.2477346808,
0.0071074096,
0.3963269293,
0.7372872233,
0.7138208747,
-0.4209785461,
0.104111664,
0.2559910119,
-0.6520935893,
0.1027492657,
-0.0900470093,
0.0242614821,
0.2482556999,
0.5497656465,
0.7534020543,
0.3140511513,
-0.0976557657,
0.401545614,
-0.0776854679,
-0.7928058505,
-0.245997414,
-0.2363346964,
0.2866131961,
0.0927676335,
0.250938952,
-0.1476751864,
0.1440348327,
-0.6937666535,
0.2797508836,
0.0476282313,
-0.9543374181,
-0.3537838757,
1.0084477663,
0.6620822549,
-0.2653006315,
0.8689210415,
-0.3133568466,
-0.6691224575,
0.6762068272,
0.4530808628,
1.0342515707,
-0.481657356,
0.2222980559,
0.7187026739,
0.5935300589,
-0.1451304406,
0.3451770246,
-0.101344347,
-0.4176644981,
-0.2361002266,
-0.7351139188,
-0.3918092549,
0.0273662284,
-0.9073141813,
0.6794842482,
0.0353142507,
-0.2248004079,
-0.1045558602,
0.1406370848,
-0.81053406,
0.1952493042,
-0.0773439407,
1.1414541006,
-0.7017874122,
1.2726743221,
0.7008740902,
-0.4635525346,
-0.7423831224,
-0.0043259701,
-0.1656221747,
-0.6870099902,
1.2625205517,
-0.2809773386,
0.0653311387,
0.2343239188,
-0.2672333419,
-0.6472919583,
1.2625184059,
0.1218626648,
-0.802275598,
-0.0785578936,
0.1854634285,
0.3799987137,
-0.4210321307,
0.3990601897,
0.5283563733,
0.7424213886,
0.4457524419,
-1.4274897575,
-0.3824391961,
-0.0743194818,
-0.3787856698,
0.2270337492,
-0.5675193667,
1.1614238024,
-0.3081804812,
-0.117339097,
-0.1051887944,
0.4090454876,
0.1270199567,
0.4762201011,
0.2832708955,
0.7347412109,
0.681392312,
-0.2529320419,
1.0741378069,
-0.3777175844,
0.5104060769,
1.3540832996,
-0.3638861477,
0.8309873939,
0.6933010221,
0.0043415586,
0.3877846301,
0.7448941469,
0.1685848236,
0.659211874,
0.0204332452,
-0.0674218014,
-0.296892494,
-0.262824595,
-0.2900692523,
0.6040124297,
0.1577849388,
-0.4814419746,
-0.2616594434,
0.0877556279,
0.0915058777,
0.0257715452,
-0.1418213248,
0.681193769,
0.1500140578,
-0.9621449709,
0.8367784619,
0.1330216974,
0.6444994807,
-0.402687192,
0.1550283432,
-0.4617727995,
0.1843357086,
-0.0835864469,
-1.0270578861,
0.4314494133,
-0.1616478711,
0.0452245995,
-0.5651932955,
0.1248578653,
-0.5825105309,
-0.6209241748,
0.4246726036,
0.4101211727,
0.1521105617,
0.0739543065,
-0.6717143655,
-0.0008929868,
0.1529688835,
-0.2339522988,
0.101738438,
0.8515684605,
-0.1462244689,
0.4752114713,
0.3969047666,
0.0274336841,
0.2198333442,
0.1994126588,
0.7178204656,
-0.7226493955,
-0.3819270134,
-0.6588700414,
0.2607349455,
-0.2564911246,
-0.5733925104,
0.5735241175,
1.0231589079,
0.710036993,
-0.1506781131,
0.6173561215,
-0.1677326411,
0.2416651696,
-0.6356714964,
0.6821337342,
-0.7315564752,
-0.0859994069,
-0.0737432986,
-0.9540672302,
0.2353533655,
0.2385600358,
-0.3383424878,
-0.130412519,
1.382978797,
0.5923002958,
-0.2732605636,
0.0233547091,
0.3383938968,
0.1722635925,
0.3506388664,
1.0592281818,
0.8702040315,
-0.7354182005,
0.907313168,
-0.3786597848,
0.1896836311,
-0.1184950843,
-0.9414700866,
-1.0860689878,
-0.9221109152,
-0.2067395598,
-0.4139628112,
0.1658999771,
0.493342787,
0.7916132808,
-0.8985272646,
-0.4867149889,
0.0140470006,
0.2829479277,
0.2196976691,
-0.2714553177,
0.0930450708,
-0.4335087538,
-1.1677165031,
0.3287840486,
0.3441366553,
0.1771818846,
-0.064850159,
-0.172536701,
-0.6083137393,
-0.3487749696,
0.4094111323,
-0.0642807335,
-0.4849419296,
-0.1530563533,
0.3472021222,
-0.3558909595,
0.2071267813,
0.8825187683,
-0.5492252707,
0.1654184759,
0.8106119633,
0.2537551522,
1.0522990227,
-0.2160973549,
0.7469838858,
-0.4243685305,
0.3220661581,
0.3546206057,
0.3732810616,
0.3492395282,
-0.1884649843,
0.7215370536,
0.3585039675,
-0.5416849852,
-0.7682237029,
-0.0723910034,
-0.9351826906,
-0.0422652252,
1.0294357538,
0.0810696781,
-0.4341820478,
-0.5193173289,
-0.0250318684,
0.201849848,
-0.323838383,
0.598739624,
0.9126371741,
0.268458724,
-0.3138215244,
-1.0051625967,
0.4057105482,
0.1427435577,
-0.6346939802,
-0.3508148193,
0.126606673,
0.5219987631,
0.0567725524,
0.7142205834,
-0.2987490892,
0.2782229483,
-0.1544620842,
0.2881053984,
-0.1030269414,
-0.3376366794,
0.0666920021,
0.1410553753,
-0.132660985,
-0.2615319788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08111v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08111v1
|
S3Editor: A Sparse Semantic-Disentangled Self-Training Framework for Face Video Editing
| 2024-04-11T20:25:26 | 2024-04-11T20:25:26 |
Guangzhi Wang, Tianyi Chen, Kamran Ghasedi, HsiangTao Wu, Tianyu Ding, Chris Nuesmeyer, Ilya Zharkov, Mohan Kankanhalli, Luming Liang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Face attribute editing plays a pivotal role in various applications. However,
existing methods encounter challenges in achieving high-quality results while
preserving identity, editing faithfulness, and temporal consistency. These
challenges are rooted in issues related to the training pipeline, including
limited supervision, architecture design, and optimization strategy. In this
work, we introduce S3Editor, a Sparse Semantic-disentangled Self-training
framework for face video editing. S3Editor is a generic solution that
comprehensively addresses these challenges with three key contributions.
Firstly, S3Editor adopts a self-training paradigm to enhance the training
process through semi-supervision. Secondly, we propose a semantic disentangled
architecture with a dynamic routing mechanism that accommodates diverse editing
requirements. Thirdly, we present a structured sparse optimization schema that
identifies and deactivates malicious neurons to further disentangle impacts
from untarget attributes. S3Editor is model-agnostic and compatible with
various editing approaches. Our extensive qualitative and quantitative results
affirm that our approach significantly enhances identity preservation, editing
fidelity, as well as temporal consistency.
|
[
0.1032446697,
-0.7006185651,
0.7087279558,
0.2795426548,
0.1283556223,
0.1542143375,
-0.1156893,
0.0274258833,
0.1221462339,
0.3526828587,
-0.9483245015,
-0.3478921056,
-0.7459390163,
0.2379091382,
-0.4771048725,
1.2135962248,
-0.3836665452,
-0.0683218762,
-0.3500480652,
-0.1563571393,
-0.4058967829,
0.0697697625,
-0.4632945657,
0.120739989,
0.4641664922,
0.102773726,
0.7660350204,
0.8469898701,
0.3115601838,
0.4193765521,
-0.2871733606,
0.1844631135,
-0.4192405343,
0.066166386,
-0.3743127882,
0.0167185199,
-0.7061196566,
0.1029513329,
0.6094809771,
0.5083437562,
-0.1955883652,
0.3729413748,
0.163411051,
0.8230307698,
-0.9055646062,
-0.1719094366,
-0.6198345423,
0.2726031244,
-0.191054076,
0.1688706279,
0.1661572307,
-0.0354049727,
-0.2647977173,
-0.8567588329,
0.5026687384,
-0.5172675848,
0.5815448165,
1.0036211014,
-0.0439447016,
0.2676106989,
-0.5721821189,
0.3888400197,
-0.0913317427,
0.4210025668,
0.2930668294,
0.4970378876,
-0.0480704568,
-0.7044318318,
-0.6859001517,
0.4822439849,
0.3051532209,
0.2491419464,
-0.2983261049,
0.2423012704,
0.2584125102,
0.3917910159,
-0.3450408578,
0.1744664013,
0.0776228607,
-0.1753121316,
0.6573601365,
0.1566646993,
0.2684671283,
-0.2355375886,
-0.2122357935,
0.1456710249,
-0.5487697721,
-0.1564101279,
0.6821908355,
-0.1929097325,
0.2003605515,
0.2789946496,
-0.5552095771,
0.5771695971,
0.4063522518,
-0.291680336,
0.1157300323,
0.0208140966,
-0.2528819144,
0.2227445394,
0.6893160343,
0.5247924328,
-0.3217985332,
-0.3021101654,
-0.2010218054,
0.0736931711,
0.4793047607,
-0.7673432231,
-0.3551979661,
0.4077095687,
-0.5308312774,
-0.7638600469,
-0.2524791062,
-0.7764621973,
-0.4718612134,
-0.1334500164,
0.7386207581,
-0.1520632654,
-0.283177346,
0.3437591791,
-0.2174715996,
-0.3669879735,
1.0275967121,
-1.2428667545,
0.2754472196,
0.4439282715,
0.7648454905,
-0.3039520085,
-0.6492802501,
-0.4593159556,
0.4091596007,
-0.0624466203,
0.4523437619,
-0.0801312849,
0.0086151045,
0.050860744,
-0.1290281862,
0.1681289673,
-0.3906621337,
-0.0864805281,
-0.6460386515,
-0.3583995998,
0.140446797,
-0.2361066937,
0.1857532114,
0.1776116341,
-0.7978439927,
1.2220124006,
0.244247511,
-0.5231217146,
0.3851976097,
-0.3497293591,
0.0543345399,
-0.0472915806,
-0.1818951517,
-0.6802942753,
0.1523123831,
0.304076463,
0.5726566911,
0.2312544286,
0.3931787908,
-0.2190077901,
-0.2023729086,
0.034259446,
-0.2058036625,
0.6403348446,
0.0217837784,
-0.265696913,
-0.0108326199,
-0.938552618,
-0.3642047346,
0.0073846905,
-0.0247267019,
0.0478938743,
-0.0947744176,
-0.2168141901,
0.1573366672,
0.301931411,
-1.0777671337,
0.3646346033,
0.1901176423,
0.5509985685,
1.0917505026,
0.1165237948,
0.3425518572,
0.0243633352,
0.1457016915,
0.0140592689,
0.4839513898,
0.2806513608,
0.0709443465,
-0.6200095415,
-0.5350338221,
0.0319797657,
0.2801876068,
-0.8124163151,
0.1440352499,
-0.359233737,
-0.343259871,
-0.6091011763,
0.7479377389,
0.229462415,
0.4798633456,
0.4958364666,
0.0556144975,
-0.1247552037,
-0.8934068084,
-0.6227226257,
0.2986211479,
-0.1070624441,
-0.0980277061,
0.563837707,
-0.3968304098,
0.9537864327,
-0.524335444,
-0.7277060747,
-0.2365021706,
-0.0247871056,
0.0341503732,
0.6911919713,
0.45933339,
-0.5252637267,
-0.4043276906,
-0.3418894708,
-0.9105352759,
-0.1232847422,
-0.5032762289,
-0.3622861207,
-0.2287184447,
0.6415727735,
-0.6499429345,
0.6943652034,
0.3661708236,
0.26755777,
0.2969005406,
0.0150038768,
0.1012971029,
-0.7051502466,
-0.2070748061,
-0.1429542303,
-0.3120366335,
-0.6245530248,
-0.3369663656,
0.2470245659,
-0.3692702651,
-0.5113605261,
0.3183358908,
-0.1856795847,
0.0474814139,
-0.0712761953,
0.1501397043,
0.1643960029,
0.8556599617,
0.1758610457,
0.6332303286,
0.4830814302,
-0.3536208868,
0.4765670002,
0.6603363752,
-0.2354708761,
1.0281534195,
-0.6704154611,
0.2022320777,
-0.3456556201,
0.0312729329,
-0.6116910577,
-0.4579910934,
0.0098651778,
-0.3195594549,
0.3329045177,
-0.3943511248,
-0.6542109847,
0.0289860126,
-0.5361165404,
0.447401762,
-0.0480000749,
-0.9527326822,
0.7698857188,
0.2881450355,
0.0676125363,
-0.5396670699,
-0.6211114526,
0.1596768051,
-0.1474451274,
-0.6928760409,
0.8263549209,
0.078366071,
0.2401054502,
0.1073342413,
-0.572915256,
-0.1684764922,
0.1495741308,
0.3397529721,
0.2943370938,
0.4380962253,
-0.1409050226,
0.3521232605,
-0.2133768499,
-0.0569760799,
0.1323264986,
-0.3971537948,
-0.0599652044,
-0.2107029706,
-0.9030290246,
0.4792452455,
0.2171065658,
-0.1371278316,
0.3840434849,
0.4281452,
-0.3110709786,
-0.2803806067,
-0.6521826982,
0.2733807862,
-0.5638954639,
0.5357214808,
-0.3772954941,
-1.0912451744,
0.5068600178,
-0.4638858438,
-0.1320772767,
0.3612127006,
0.3575921655,
-0.3624198735,
1.0871045589,
0.5180829167,
0.3260189891,
0.6598311067,
-0.4487656057,
-0.0832265913,
-1.1289590597,
-0.138367936,
0.084881857,
-0.2417677194,
-0.4397568107,
-0.0137078119,
0.7945924401,
0.0108065642,
-0.4190658927,
0.3762786984,
-0.502227664,
0.6640718579,
0.2350095361,
0.3230800033,
0.0394873843,
-0.3210094869,
0.4710420966,
-0.205220446,
-0.5835903883,
-0.1933492124,
0.7884036899,
0.479218632,
0.9824458957,
0.4586894512,
0.7793803811,
0.4367929101,
-0.0450808443,
-0.335247159,
0.4105043709,
-0.1039911807,
-0.5377118587,
-0.2930342257,
-0.2773282528,
-0.3855884969,
0.066425018,
-0.349047929,
-0.9120377302,
0.3086085021,
0.5527695417,
-0.48987782,
0.3963981271,
-0.2537487149,
1.4290351868,
-0.2572846115,
-1.071125865,
-0.1316276938,
-0.7322888374,
0.2623153031,
0.0051145097,
-0.2371163219,
-0.1354677081,
0.0594690181,
0.5231887102,
-0.7970606685,
0.919365406,
-0.3673034012,
0.2552773952,
0.0486291237,
0.4256941378,
0.4770391285,
0.4635899961,
0.4028282166,
0.3843321502,
0.1329070479,
-0.1213070527,
-1.051746726,
0.650632143,
-0.9139426947,
-0.611128211,
-0.5728695989,
-0.0834729224,
-0.3569687903,
0.2131034285,
0.0371778011,
0.3469890058,
-0.1963680685,
0.1282259971,
0.7825053334,
-0.1754068434,
0.3614525199,
0.2073526978,
0.2027745098,
-0.6575738192,
0.9537425041,
-0.2383142412,
0.3632394075,
0.0993375033,
-0.1077809185,
0.0752848536,
-0.4010205567,
-0.9089933634,
0.0156478286,
-0.6681155562,
-0.6360728145,
-0.6692946553,
-0.3474965692,
-0.3733561635,
-0.3862302303,
-0.8499733806,
-0.4498220384,
-0.3926355839,
-0.038398277,
0.5686967969,
0.5346700549,
-0.3084880412,
0.795335114,
-0.5644800663,
0.5537888408,
0.6938282847,
0.8271089196,
-0.2475723177,
-0.3054920137,
-0.3977838457,
-0.3252506852,
-0.3898162246,
-0.9201904535,
0.0247763433,
0.4612743258,
0.4056150913,
0.1399624199,
-0.2753945589,
0.8809699416,
-0.6860591769,
0.823628068,
0.0723705813,
-1.2338240147,
0.7357423902,
-0.321950376,
0.1733169556,
1.0319888592,
0.1088867337,
-0.5605124235,
-0.2535554171,
-0.5702484846,
-0.4668569565,
0.9505184293,
0.1749067456,
0.1778306812,
0.0796770751,
0.3809891343,
0.171784237,
0.4824705124,
-0.6388744116,
-0.0948090106,
-1.0241891146,
-0.1200329214,
0.4987952411,
-0.3579233289,
-0.2149497569,
-0.2002487183,
0.5587874651,
-0.1130956337,
0.1744333953,
0.3318410218,
-0.4371731579,
0.0056772302,
-0.1412548572,
0.2359608412,
0.2083406448,
-0.5402114391,
-0.0518800654,
0.2508850992,
-0.6683900952,
0.197358042,
-0.1470455378,
-0.1596581191,
-0.2102343291,
0.3508697152,
0.9756681323,
0.2368842661,
-0.2759474814,
1.1258406639,
-0.1606975943,
-0.4373354614,
-0.2400009036,
0.1104822084,
-0.4719017446,
0.1110809594,
0.0407186933,
0.3004225791,
0.5549997687,
-0.0943852141,
0.00195498,
0.1411486715,
-0.1518438458,
-0.2999384999,
1.1123197079,
0.2513216436,
-0.004069461,
0.433382839,
-0.0459591784,
-0.3909533024,
0.0787800029,
0.1712049097,
1.1394456625,
-0.1123282686,
0.3043285906,
0.3363837004,
0.1780344695,
0.0047490201,
-0.1310810298,
-0.4934012294,
-0.5355718136,
-0.2253021151,
-0.6404822469,
-0.1736416668,
0.1200732589,
-0.7597791553,
0.2553384006,
-0.7942091823,
0.0258267969,
0.2476549447,
-0.325771749,
-0.6503540874,
0.3115661442,
-0.2061179131,
0.818192184,
-0.8439891934,
0.4330970347,
0.3186610937,
-0.4156779051,
-0.4800337851,
-0.3229500353,
0.5011212826,
-0.5180202723,
0.6570484042,
0.0998454913,
-0.4354199469,
-0.038096793,
-0.3787253201,
-0.7779815197,
1.1307467222,
0.3077941537,
-0.2121752501,
0.1712717712,
0.0178822875,
0.4038400352,
-0.1389459819,
-0.1070801094,
0.5809832215,
-0.1087913439,
0.182623893,
-0.5866031051,
-0.2340990156,
-0.262093395,
0.4325657487,
0.0397882946,
-0.8556647897,
0.5780648589,
0.1991527975,
-0.127533555,
0.0436729826,
0.6833876967,
-0.3427208364,
0.0137757966,
0.5453256965,
0.7301153541,
0.1427720934,
0.0619675182,
0.5388981104,
-0.2252877206,
0.1269539446,
1.225127697,
-0.209037438,
0.3947862685,
0.5589771867,
-0.0216993485,
0.4598096013,
0.566149652,
-0.032151334,
0.8673242927,
-0.2278676331,
-0.5600753427,
-0.3960882127,
0.2232268453,
-0.0113482056,
0.9171251059,
0.0313811265,
-0.1839179993,
-0.3527820706,
0.1170625836,
0.2656456828,
0.2738295794,
-0.3451119065,
1.0884979963,
-0.5836675763,
-0.3197650909,
0.0862084106,
-0.0742624179,
0.1735178232,
-0.4872586727,
-0.3134147227,
-0.2471464723,
0.047863882,
-0.4259707034,
-0.8152033687,
0.4464696348,
0.3473345339,
-0.0214319583,
-0.7231017947,
0.5383558869,
-0.3982146978,
-0.2525050342,
-0.1752408892,
0.0947421342,
-0.0972011164,
-0.0291757155,
-0.6675307751,
0.4345684052,
-0.2396586984,
-0.2173410505,
0.4489110112,
0.5460363626,
0.1338983029,
0.278460592,
0.4422104657,
0.1207552552,
-0.368245244,
0.0082177306,
1.106910944,
-0.3714215159,
-0.4624569714,
-0.7949675322,
0.6621198058,
-0.4171661139,
-0.4180169702,
0.7122129798,
0.5270298719,
0.8264468908,
-0.1963350177,
0.5693415403,
-0.0035482107,
0.4442902207,
-0.6774495244,
0.6678020954,
-0.5824157596,
0.0934214517,
-0.6110618114,
-0.8931147456,
-0.3504801989,
0.6997737288,
0.0773117915,
-0.1354449242,
0.2773251832,
0.9204768538,
-0.1578266323,
-0.1386023313,
0.061521437,
-0.0634445921,
0.17657426,
0.2966438532,
0.743778646,
-0.5198234916,
0.134463191,
-0.4831010401,
-0.4767895341,
-0.1223842502,
-1.0437116623,
-0.943893075,
-0.4912987947,
-0.564261198,
-0.2779861689,
0.2059284747,
0.6337217689,
0.5418371558,
-0.1939579248,
0.0933214724,
-0.0430564359,
-0.0014460956,
-0.3416406512,
-0.0969349965,
0.3905471265,
-0.0625921115,
-0.5335870385,
0.2378514409,
0.6699670553,
-0.0900440738,
-0.2551842332,
0.1295014918,
0.0512665585,
-0.2340297848,
0.4475526512,
0.4304402769,
-0.4874947965,
-0.6479278207,
-0.2465049028,
-0.0321816467,
-0.1500822157,
0.4883007407,
-0.5096731782,
0.9546709657,
0.1093373001,
0.836366117,
0.7181327939,
-0.0028699243,
0.1873250157,
-1.0854204893,
0.2079989463,
-0.0774680898,
0.1186483353,
0.4873081744,
-0.6230995655,
0.4895046055,
0.3094856143,
-0.5947716236,
-0.915887773,
0.1504555047,
-1.0165153742,
0.1426405758,
0.7026084065,
-0.0796998888,
-0.4694158137,
0.3758885562,
-0.249394238,
0.3257926106,
-0.0585780554,
0.9503600001,
0.5516358614,
-0.57348454,
-0.2726431787,
-0.6768420935,
1.2392431498,
0.3071310222,
-0.5787316561,
0.3359556496,
0.7368105054,
0.2981496155,
-0.1381824464,
0.5381521583,
-0.1650879532,
0.8321768045,
0.1046875194,
0.2527261972,
-0.4819313288,
-0.626853168,
-0.5310195684,
-0.3726729155,
-0.1609281451,
-0.3141376078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16053v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16053v1
|
Human Latency Conversational Turns for Spoken Avatar Systems
| 2024-04-11T20:20:48 | 2024-04-11T20:20:48 |
Derek Jacoby, Tianyi Zhang, Aanchan Mohan, Yvonne Coady
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
A problem with many current Large Language Model (LLM) driven spoken
dialogues is the response time. Some efforts such as Groq address this issue by
lightning fast processing of the LLM, but we know from the cognitive psychology
literature that in human-to-human dialogue often responses occur prior to the
speaker completing their utterance. No amount of delay for LLM processing is
acceptable if we wish to maintain human dialogue latencies. In this paper, we
discuss methods for understanding an utterance in close to real time and
generating a response so that the system can comply with human-level
conversational turn delays. This means that the information content of the
final part of the speaker's utterance is lost to the LLM. Using the Google
NaturalQuestions (NQ) database, our results show GPT-4 can effectively fill in
missing context from a dropped word at the end of a question over 60% of the
time. We also provide some examples of utterances and the impacts of this
information loss on the quality of LLM response in the context of an avatar
that is currently under development. These results indicate that a simple
classifier could be used to determine whether a question is semantically
complete, or requires a filler phrase to allow a response to be generated
within human dialogue time constraints.
|
[
-0.6171808243,
-1.0270744562,
0.6854106784,
0.1876719147,
-0.1888459474,
0.2878508568,
0.0243398398,
-0.7070011497,
0.2493554205,
0.5056121349,
-0.7630169988,
0.0394064859,
-0.1200813651,
0.1746562272,
-0.269800812,
0.6711900234,
0.1670857966,
-0.0264691524,
-0.4367204607,
0.0503987968,
-0.5629150867,
-0.762417376,
-0.9349604249,
-0.5641149879,
0.396928966,
0.3282439709,
0.9746183157,
0.2780720294,
0.2893593311,
0.2244636416,
-0.2817663252,
-0.111421071,
-0.4519739449,
0.1612540036,
0.0986146405,
-0.5474812984,
-0.3089971244,
-0.0085148271,
0.6047525406,
0.7630031109,
-0.3509633839,
0.0391104892,
-0.1845830679,
0.4181288481,
-0.4052575529,
0.1290773302,
-0.2943712771,
0.4806876779,
-0.1931543499,
-0.2993397415,
-0.2106034309,
-0.251532346,
0.3481102586,
-0.6413661838,
0.3408492208,
0.0994381458,
0.611667037,
0.3047337234,
-0.1754067689,
-0.1201528758,
-1.175232172,
0.5145813227,
-0.8478240371,
0.3421472311,
0.4723432362,
0.4229899347,
-0.3917108476,
-0.4618701041,
-1.156820178,
-0.324234128,
0.0062401406,
0.2098434418,
0.0074022505,
0.3272867501,
0.4106189907,
0.4309558868,
-0.5756661296,
-0.1637513191,
-0.1445838064,
-0.3606836796,
0.4865012765,
0.463011086,
0.3642690778,
-0.2868893445,
0.0137056792,
-0.2100960016,
-0.5784879923,
0.0903418884,
0.5132302046,
-0.0713458061,
-0.0093657076,
0.6112338305,
-0.2718673944,
0.7600561976,
0.2332130373,
-0.1439736634,
0.0468551666,
-0.5916555524,
-0.0617063753,
-0.0584566966,
0.6927219629,
0.4435904622,
0.1542510688,
-0.1250917763,
-0.2107883096,
0.1730374396,
0.3256313503,
-0.7119258642,
0.0620496161,
0.32404688,
-0.1012205705,
0.0629864335,
-0.3771021664,
-0.330455929,
-0.0237616207,
-0.3377978206,
0.2391687483,
-0.2023821622,
-0.247850582,
0.0601264164,
0.0577626079,
0.7260092497,
0.4076294005,
-0.7657461762,
0.3757157326,
0.4948841631,
0.9221343994,
-0.0883031487,
0.1746929735,
-0.8536626697,
-0.0540263094,
-0.4384869039,
0.8078608513,
-0.5670680404,
-0.5283724666,
-0.1305999756,
-0.1157221794,
0.0157841817,
-0.4671489894,
0.2880726457,
-0.8079867363,
0.5723090768,
-0.1274893433,
-0.3901950419,
-0.1006276235,
0.3417437375,
-0.3786710501,
0.6967372894,
0.0022014393,
-0.6863201261,
-0.0421202406,
-0.7046900392,
-0.4705675542,
0.3498975337,
-0.3138196766,
-0.1698043942,
0.0027182745,
0.2808895707,
0.4019190371,
-0.0892911702,
0.0817415416,
-0.0301940683,
-0.6294701099,
0.489903599,
-0.2726757228,
0.3125327826,
0.2317975909,
-0.2627008557,
-0.1337851584,
-0.4826634824,
0.1655078828,
0.1819081306,
-0.4699376523,
0.0369099602,
0.2015592605,
0.0446030721,
0.062129464,
-0.0446840078,
-0.6589848995,
0.0396357477,
-0.5045149326,
0.5912135839,
0.6486282349,
0.1879613698,
0.2830545604,
-0.3215109706,
0.7497208714,
-0.1731836498,
0.2323312312,
-0.3317455947,
-0.6834865808,
-0.7873607874,
0.2803815305,
0.079924114,
0.7378783226,
-0.9773610234,
0.1057105958,
-0.1851747781,
-0.2067842931,
-0.394785732,
-0.2252151668,
0.582429111,
0.5205276012,
0.1022218317,
-0.7272571325,
-0.2326361686,
-0.7577856183,
-0.1587177962,
-0.62596488,
-0.4214725196,
0.7268858552,
0.0593957081,
-0.2536432147,
1.0614401102,
-0.596766293,
0.1043175459,
0.0453810543,
0.4055138528,
0.0453604273,
0.0550732203,
0.2475651801,
-0.8876282573,
-0.1043039188,
-0.1393214762,
-0.8688171506,
-0.1300816238,
-0.192814827,
0.1142225936,
0.1688506603,
0.4876576364,
-0.6271983981,
0.5301222205,
0.3758089244,
-0.283631891,
0.5406919718,
-0.0580343492,
0.219293505,
-0.7314627767,
-0.0632923916,
-0.3190391064,
-0.3927532136,
-0.7906961441,
-0.2302601635,
-0.3794992566,
-0.352118969,
-0.7187926769,
0.7310126424,
-0.3798495829,
-0.5400930643,
-0.2359588742,
0.2919510305,
-0.1430829912,
0.6378301978,
0.1320603192,
1.1084434986,
0.0231192484,
-0.9406784773,
0.4850070179,
0.5400169492,
-0.2080068141,
0.6835811734,
-0.8938080668,
0.7013534904,
-0.3353739083,
0.3591066301,
-1.0846674442,
-0.5405502319,
0.4710574448,
-0.7292121053,
0.0237674564,
-0.2294977158,
-0.2958765626,
-0.4389579892,
0.1025460139,
0.5877183676,
0.4130978584,
-0.1923933476,
0.6062366366,
0.344900161,
-0.6331377625,
-0.3589369655,
-0.5706361532,
0.4164140224,
0.0264688972,
-0.8734340668,
0.3032046854,
-0.4389873445,
-0.2182686776,
-0.2058983147,
0.2145110965,
0.0351419449,
0.037393894,
0.3213098645,
0.1114871427,
-0.0872435048,
0.053335242,
-0.2326468527,
-0.0361502692,
0.0238442142,
-0.042421598,
0.7026254535,
-0.1100446209,
-0.4582514465,
-0.6851425767,
0.4752488732,
0.6174548268,
0.1328114569,
0.3332514763,
0.530678153,
-0.3005916774,
0.836856246,
-0.728674233,
-0.2773469985,
-0.3813582063,
0.188856855,
-0.2849946916,
-0.7768180966,
0.8565791845,
0.5036872029,
-0.02171118,
0.1207544059,
0.5653944016,
-0.1015870497,
1.244166851,
0.581602335,
-0.0478797033,
0.93016541,
-0.0812439099,
0.1742527038,
-0.8953781128,
-0.3630591929,
-0.233440876,
-0.1448661983,
-0.406018585,
-0.4243214428,
0.5313898325,
-0.1882541627,
-0.2160677016,
0.0169682708,
-0.238830179,
0.3888351619,
0.5513102412,
-0.148563385,
0.346922785,
-0.0530076995,
-0.0103148604,
0.0062246677,
-0.5600228906,
-0.4350143075,
0.6284722686,
0.324421674,
0.8472723961,
0.1856945455,
0.2866263986,
0.4552575946,
0.0228985026,
-0.8362737894,
0.6225063801,
0.5277904272,
-0.5226911306,
-0.5876792669,
-0.3559779823,
-0.7885115147,
0.0623349883,
-0.1886728555,
-0.5479862094,
-0.0972864702,
0.1154893488,
-0.6543546915,
-0.0966350138,
-0.6970284581,
0.4044406116,
-0.2225640714,
-0.3220686316,
-0.1240973696,
-0.9217961431,
0.1391673833,
0.0727691129,
0.0633845255,
-0.1279827505,
0.2974899113,
0.9267233014,
-0.4375789464,
0.763028264,
-0.3628941476,
-0.1063153893,
0.4216150939,
0.0123952562,
0.3704819679,
0.2333426028,
0.3872104287,
0.0385101512,
-0.0884380043,
-0.4812878668,
-0.6686397195,
0.3288946748,
-0.8580128551,
-0.6393777728,
-0.4710068703,
-0.2389800847,
-0.2379293889,
-0.1098250374,
0.3528833687,
0.2845647931,
-0.2810621262,
-0.3777527511,
0.6675754786,
-0.3487741649,
0.5163587332,
0.5527676344,
-0.2908407152,
-0.2866214514,
0.5640584826,
0.1122272015,
0.3351677656,
0.1490936279,
-0.0367600247,
-0.3448182344,
-0.3050763607,
-0.7156276703,
0.3676797748,
-0.4022105038,
-0.0234137792,
-0.6206097007,
-0.3397260308,
-0.3748678267,
0.1004409119,
-0.3055415452,
-0.3319628537,
-0.2599830031,
0.0184249077,
0.2789727747,
0.9643720388,
0.1858146042,
0.6635139585,
-0.9057461023,
0.4585278332,
0.6314904094,
0.2323291898,
0.0507772155,
-0.6816752553,
-0.0932792276,
0.3555368781,
-0.3280094564,
-0.5496079326,
0.311236918,
0.3070536852,
0.446923852,
0.4302725494,
-0.1744748354,
0.740508914,
-0.5282825232,
1.1456961632,
0.2560194135,
-0.7664524317,
0.5612848401,
-0.3248418868,
0.7257336378,
0.0015588307,
0.1657368988,
-1.3561298847,
-0.2765413821,
-0.4938777983,
-0.8830230236,
0.6667916179,
0.429713279,
0.2963401675,
-0.1060694382,
0.655013144,
-0.0996276066,
0.1950776428,
-0.3713713884,
0.0095881792,
-0.1992195547,
0.4472841918,
-0.1857334822,
-0.3886655569,
0.0608947463,
0.1811679006,
0.3074170649,
-0.262929827,
0.672984004,
0.3066807091,
-0.0690804869,
-0.2976135612,
0.338054657,
0.7652762532,
0.5563943982,
-0.4097851813,
-0.1579629928,
0.0808169618,
-0.5213628411,
0.1629310846,
-0.2157000005,
-0.13921386,
-0.1007006019,
0.3558377028,
0.7968071103,
-0.0341262557,
-0.6217426062,
0.5443049073,
-0.555988431,
0.1000692695,
-0.6148228049,
-0.0006407154,
-0.0674023256,
0.162035808,
0.6996996999,
-0.118981488,
0.1090650707,
-0.6089676023,
0.0907209218,
0.3390473127,
-0.3789939582,
-0.5216866732,
0.6234943271,
0.2668834031,
-0.578271389,
0.9339818358,
-0.1464047581,
-0.6272636056,
0.3378556967,
0.4371765852,
0.7496580482,
-0.3268445432,
0.2406018525,
0.0879583806,
-0.2738319635,
0.0220993254,
0.2644796968,
-0.2694275975,
-0.6738567948,
-0.9045137167,
-0.5324470401,
-0.7613859177,
0.1153986454,
-0.5996610522,
-0.1894704103,
-0.4511675239,
-0.4646941423,
-0.1783812195,
-0.1665771455,
-0.7414337993,
0.2290402353,
0.4208891392,
0.4182542861,
-0.800922215,
0.0604146458,
0.6359208822,
-0.3828867078,
-0.5469662547,
0.0609856471,
-0.2324017584,
-0.7546467781,
0.6204589009,
0.0131247714,
-0.476593852,
-0.2290892452,
-0.8296059966,
-0.7511054277,
0.8372477889,
0.3361661732,
-0.5711004734,
-0.3224728107,
0.2116424441,
0.6679829955,
-0.1914824098,
0.6086794138,
0.6599627137,
0.2072686702,
0.5360682011,
-1.1501243114,
-0.1938578933,
-0.1977985203,
0.2526286542,
0.1125007048,
-0.6356868148,
0.7928717732,
-0.2417417318,
-0.3402408659,
0.1542870104,
0.7385904193,
-0.0793004408,
0.4724174738,
0.458445549,
0.468983978,
0.7936106324,
0.028533699,
1.0795366764,
0.0247271527,
0.1324365437,
0.7510739565,
-0.1163905337,
0.8875905871,
0.4637362063,
-0.3474908769,
0.2610961795,
0.91730088,
0.6240581274,
0.4173018038,
0.2592157125,
-0.4872383475,
-0.4117618799,
-0.26427719,
-0.5235924721,
0.5873569846,
0.4664695859,
0.3631272614,
0.1566775441,
0.3467922509,
-0.0644829273,
-0.2534121573,
-0.165851295,
0.9655985236,
0.0646965727,
-0.8646123409,
0.811999917,
-0.3009328842,
0.5662858486,
-0.1703510582,
-0.1801486015,
-0.6600895524,
-0.131612584,
-0.1964942068,
-0.8015890718,
0.2621343732,
-0.1338751763,
-0.3735870123,
0.1549039036,
0.386916548,
-0.2800565362,
-0.212761119,
0.1258834451,
0.5116165876,
0.546602428,
-0.2438011765,
-0.2950980067,
-0.060421586,
-0.0730058178,
-0.1916624457,
0.183485508,
0.1444273889,
-0.1982045025,
1.0771530867,
0.6078569889,
-0.0288079716,
0.1330281645,
0.0000328534,
0.895531714,
-0.8267902732,
-0.5375711918,
-0.5219250321,
0.0915767103,
0.1314442456,
0.001150056,
0.3215604722,
0.3285500705,
0.7624708414,
0.0057281861,
0.9873811007,
0.0622738115,
0.578990519,
-0.7121173739,
0.3763659596,
-0.3703275919,
0.2822112441,
-0.1767900139,
-1.0072380304,
-0.1916973293,
0.6734704375,
-0.3461668193,
0.0115139242,
0.351129055,
0.6359885335,
0.1117012948,
-0.059727408,
0.4683999419,
0.0694302097,
0.6442241073,
0.5659371018,
1.1329234838,
-0.3246720731,
0.6712572575,
0.2311246693,
-0.1214805096,
-0.5465789437,
-0.6778166294,
-0.6918259859,
-0.4905709624,
-0.287715584,
-0.3625802994,
0.1673297584,
0.6337119341,
0.6763045192,
-0.6171652079,
-0.165875867,
0.1516035944,
0.0009003264,
0.0694432333,
-0.2593666911,
0.0308371242,
-0.1772849262,
-0.718552947,
0.3212020397,
0.3501696885,
0.3965314329,
-0.3075272441,
-0.2928923965,
-0.0598766282,
0.1455334872,
0.5238967538,
0.6524755359,
-0.7880315185,
-0.6433286667,
0.2617287636,
0.134930253,
0.3232083619,
0.8219385743,
-1.0613012314,
0.6925634742,
0.3432744741,
0.487557888,
0.8049678206,
0.2440416068,
0.7965313196,
-0.7538332939,
0.0358765647,
0.4829537272,
-0.0754633322,
0.6538035274,
-0.4657517076,
0.3760023117,
0.3673376143,
-0.7280989885,
-0.531532824,
0.4333208203,
-0.8930917978,
0.2946469486,
0.9485649467,
0.0046972199,
-0.3280492723,
-0.333444953,
-0.3894090652,
0.2723791599,
-0.5662673116,
0.5890468359,
0.8367541432,
-0.6088931561,
-0.1874652803,
-0.5518632531,
0.4024133682,
0.3774524033,
-0.501355052,
-0.0387467593,
0.5948874354,
0.1715230495,
0.5394539833,
0.9969137311,
0.1123278141,
0.2712974548,
-0.0852650255,
0.0539374948,
0.2323650122,
-0.1149096265,
-0.1681219786,
-0.2020713538,
0.2829035819,
-0.3403436542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16859v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16859v1
|
Rumour Evaluation with Very Large Language Models
| 2024-04-11T19:38:22 | 2024-04-11T19:38:22 |
Dahlia Shehata, Robin Cohen, Charles Clarke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Conversational prompt-engineering-based large language models (LLMs) have
enabled targeted control over the output creation, enhancing versatility,
adaptability and adhoc retrieval. From another perspective, digital
misinformation has reached alarming levels. The anonymity, availability and
reach of social media offer fertile ground for rumours to propagate. This work
proposes to leverage the advancement of prompting-dependent LLMs to combat
misinformation by extending the research efforts of the RumourEval task on its
Twitter dataset. To the end, we employ two prompting-based LLM variants
(GPT-3.5-turbo and GPT-4) to extend the two RumourEval subtasks: (1) veracity
prediction, and (2) stance classification. For veracity prediction, three
classifications schemes are experimented per GPT variant. Each scheme is tested
in zero-, one- and few-shot settings. Our best results outperform the precedent
ones by a substantial margin. For stance classification,
prompting-based-approaches show comparable performance to prior results, with
no improvement over finetuning methods. Rumour stance subtask is also extended
beyond the original setting to allow multiclass classification. All of the
generated predictions for both subtasks are equipped with confidence scores
determining their trustworthiness degree according to the LLM, and post-hoc
justifications for explainability and interpretability purposes. Our primary
aim is AI for social good.
|
[
-0.2946631014,
-0.8677563071,
0.6857848167,
0.467219919,
-0.1831661165,
0.2580963671,
-0.4755574763,
-0.6072131395,
0.4639617801,
0.1900141239,
-0.695184648,
-0.4595638812,
-0.6722416878,
-0.0525460728,
-0.4695932567,
1.1090465784,
0.0848687366,
-0.0383308604,
0.118773669,
0.1520862281,
-0.5197224617,
-0.3878724575,
-0.7843881249,
-0.1357445717,
0.6840477586,
0.5002455115,
0.7974482775,
0.0726200491,
0.1146175712,
0.218474701,
-0.0009221671,
0.2123466581,
-0.4651963711,
0.3139414787,
-0.0538428128,
-0.4537808001,
-0.1671272367,
0.2675160468,
0.327565223,
0.3679705262,
-0.3795937896,
0.2527848184,
0.0671288818,
0.3631385267,
-0.4771052599,
0.2833423316,
-1.0939356089,
-0.1834334284,
-0.0951050594,
-0.2136056423,
-0.5086871386,
-0.6292474866,
0.2520693839,
-0.3391096592,
0.0503035635,
0.3806066215,
0.8290303349,
-0.0397336408,
0.2161286175,
-0.4535503983,
-0.7049412727,
0.8021062016,
-0.6526854634,
0.1316883564,
0.469686836,
0.5434852839,
-0.0499737859,
-0.3517206013,
-0.5289128423,
-0.4916930199,
0.0124634691,
0.2104228884,
-0.4106525481,
-0.1754971445,
0.2746506631,
-0.0074230977,
-0.4739863575,
0.091275312,
-0.2938200533,
-0.4498234391,
0.5284131169,
-0.1473669708,
0.0839681998,
-0.1959527582,
-0.2156942785,
0.21052742,
-0.6715722084,
-0.2810748518,
0.4110378921,
0.2655932605,
-0.1946181953,
0.519130826,
-0.3401014805,
0.1569002271,
0.390370369,
-0.3342206478,
0.1321792156,
-0.0731205419,
-0.0159728732,
0.392647475,
0.7292019725,
0.5077604651,
0.451656431,
-0.1109289303,
-0.2977100909,
0.2354324013,
0.0347829722,
-0.4094113708,
0.0279018749,
0.2715117037,
-0.4548295736,
-0.4948320091,
0.0428788811,
-0.7543801665,
-0.7636904716,
-0.2263829708,
0.4129958451,
-0.6584972739,
-0.2498618364,
-0.0115699274,
-0.1281407923,
0.2371556014,
0.8639442325,
-0.5494135618,
-0.0515248962,
0.7603570223,
0.7214831114,
-0.0167002641,
-0.2804764509,
-0.5419999957,
0.3018232882,
-0.4592574239,
0.9145182967,
-0.584895134,
-0.2012253106,
0.2422517389,
-0.2562460303,
0.0947593227,
-0.3672848344,
0.8445977569,
-0.6599000692,
0.4186648428,
-0.2508727014,
-0.332829833,
-0.3443556726,
0.5425715446,
-0.5243251324,
0.9041411281,
0.054735709,
-0.9993107915,
0.3405600786,
-0.5225497484,
-0.4882302284,
0.0343552567,
-0.0774113461,
-0.1571896374,
0.2273224592,
0.4991480112,
0.5918369889,
-0.558942914,
0.5071161985,
-0.2306116819,
-0.2963317633,
0.3350024223,
-0.9672863483,
0.5202289224,
0.2545346022,
-0.4754183888,
0.0498852357,
-0.3709534407,
-0.1557857394,
-0.1394294053,
-0.0027877714,
-0.1774939001,
-0.297546953,
-0.3115701973,
0.1872781664,
0.1899399906,
-0.3769495487,
0.0927635431,
-0.2471685708,
0.1970571131,
0.7205482125,
0.106076926,
0.0572074726,
-0.7602530718,
0.5560515523,
0.0392928645,
0.2279071361,
-0.1965937465,
-0.5888866782,
-0.6528977752,
-0.2308386713,
0.2824717164,
0.6488991976,
-0.9235346913,
0.1307283044,
-0.228537336,
-0.6255688071,
-0.6062086225,
-0.183561936,
0.1074959189,
0.4754257798,
0.2022970319,
0.2415399849,
-0.6785094142,
-0.9213212132,
-0.3936853409,
-0.7419835925,
0.0542500317,
0.033505857,
-0.0171220433,
-0.1332107931,
0.8056023717,
-0.1470288187,
0.0495574586,
-0.511282444,
0.4647530913,
0.3847280145,
0.0382282212,
0.4970046878,
-0.4497633576,
-0.6614196897,
-0.1475180089,
-0.455650121,
-0.1822891533,
-0.154507786,
0.1678148955,
0.5945394635,
0.0880191997,
-1.02739501,
0.4078934193,
0.4081853926,
-0.0079324795,
1.0333783627,
0.1880732626,
0.4185473621,
-0.9350543022,
-0.3263640702,
0.1250086427,
-0.2479735613,
-0.5182185173,
-0.455498904,
-0.1455122083,
0.17467843,
-0.4142799973,
0.4661996365,
-0.3559478223,
0.1432797909,
-0.3116346896,
0.0935063064,
-0.2809091508,
-0.0018966664,
0.0072175325,
0.5961574912,
0.8827644587,
-0.5313342214,
0.3996367753,
-0.1228029802,
-0.2394317687,
0.593041122,
-0.4776978195,
0.0071320641,
-0.3290671706,
0.448505789,
-1.0659863949,
-0.4829390943,
0.492320776,
-0.7551890612,
0.2289249152,
-0.2215281725,
-0.681325376,
-0.5720385313,
-0.6485581398,
-0.257627815,
0.692691505,
-0.6407747269,
0.5378622413,
0.1460747421,
-0.4406864345,
-0.5720446706,
-0.5506188273,
0.2896192968,
-0.5618177652,
-0.6189641953,
-0.0958418995,
0.0046458719,
-0.5351238847,
-0.195558697,
-0.1529566944,
0.1451806426,
-0.2730176747,
0.2662545145,
0.6013277769,
-0.1885810494,
0.0798007548,
-0.0999406502,
-0.1676660478,
0.2678358555,
-0.381470412,
0.5274018645,
-0.0977265909,
-0.2392022014,
-0.5189457536,
0.0482731126,
0.582973063,
0.1049541682,
0.8606554866,
0.7526919842,
-0.4293963015,
-0.2657700181,
-1.2507635355,
-0.2180302441,
-0.4703940451,
0.1533896923,
-0.2142255306,
-0.7497091293,
0.3655268252,
-0.1972154528,
0.0855358094,
0.4804101586,
0.5543287992,
-0.0662895069,
0.7884423137,
0.2775042653,
-0.4312158823,
0.0657097995,
0.0322892964,
0.1336970031,
-0.2130933106,
-0.0829089805,
-0.4175803363,
0.0197754763,
-0.4292773604,
-0.601593554,
0.1287626475,
-0.0217590276,
0.151586026,
0.2037419826,
-0.2161193192,
0.3691199422,
0.2096866518,
-0.0942203328,
0.4501817226,
0.3253640831,
-0.0318784341,
-0.0713916197,
-0.7063496113,
-0.69737041,
0.8321518302,
0.6733470559,
0.9133155942,
-0.039974425,
0.4903922081,
0.453879714,
0.827925086,
-0.8617840409,
0.6103637218,
0.1420093477,
-0.6911044717,
-0.32707268,
-0.3352668583,
-0.4159421623,
-0.0396691263,
-0.259995997,
-0.9274184108,
-0.2285812646,
0.1268550903,
-0.3601085544,
0.3316011131,
-0.5207012892,
0.0770142525,
-0.241441831,
-0.1012458205,
-0.5537939668,
-0.4649270773,
0.5603072047,
-0.2604129612,
0.5932879448,
-0.2936975956,
0.0809036791,
0.6237088442,
-0.1196507812,
1.0342025757,
-0.258913368,
-0.1678471267,
0.5694740415,
0.00533013,
0.9322615266,
0.2064405829,
-0.5528376698,
0.1860767007,
-0.1753707677,
-0.0377666689,
-0.4787062705,
0.7120509744,
-0.6329921484,
-0.7810434103,
-0.3793659806,
-0.5229930282,
-0.5775863528,
-0.046890907,
0.4100376964,
0.180063948,
-0.19815135,
0.1287008375,
0.6730773449,
-0.317289561,
0.3861119747,
0.5816271901,
-0.3928774893,
-0.2564438283,
0.8118706942,
0.0854832008,
0.1087119728,
0.2902772129,
0.5428699851,
-0.5074186325,
-0.5936192274,
-0.2285401225,
0.2312612832,
-0.6774695516,
-0.3188838065,
-0.5896990299,
-0.5669641495,
-0.4277185202,
-0.1241161674,
-0.2327811867,
-0.3989432454,
0.0620039776,
-0.3393314481,
0.6069737673,
0.933808744,
-0.1161978096,
0.4053658843,
-0.6465534568,
0.1788578629,
0.1766088903,
0.2926239967,
0.0812355429,
-0.7894929647,
-0.1183487102,
0.0687832907,
-0.0582793057,
-0.9277120829,
0.3034811318,
-0.1753665656,
0.6622938514,
0.5109906197,
0.2294559032,
0.6245020628,
-0.4215323627,
0.7128216624,
0.5128114223,
-0.6822457314,
0.5008907914,
-0.5787966847,
-0.1303944737,
0.6247209311,
0.6063691378,
-0.4997052848,
-0.5845873952,
-0.9271173477,
-0.602894187,
0.5709815621,
0.1727997959,
0.0831326097,
-0.1361821145,
0.2486321926,
0.4667102098,
0.2288152277,
-0.5033481121,
-0.2884660363,
-0.0576337054,
-0.0615422316,
0.2423650324,
-0.5093408823,
-0.0310424715,
-0.1732256711,
0.89174366,
-0.0517089441,
0.0669711828,
-0.0546264388,
0.0157607459,
-0.2290622741,
0.5496279597,
0.2735346556,
0.899443686,
-0.0754994601,
0.0709835738,
0.4434225559,
-0.4443583488,
0.1237124279,
0.1696204841,
-0.3524583578,
0.4195899069,
0.2991343439,
0.666844964,
-0.0557008758,
-0.384169668,
0.3743911684,
-0.1434938163,
-0.3312036693,
-0.5114281774,
-0.121255435,
0.2287099808,
0.2248485833,
0.5831635594,
0.0579255559,
0.1095124111,
-0.6536480784,
0.1276814342,
0.4926648736,
-0.3051256239,
-0.3824601769,
0.3909530044,
0.0571369343,
-0.0700756535,
0.2363886237,
-0.4528877437,
-0.4785987735,
0.2684812248,
0.5210962892,
0.8128548861,
-0.3568389118,
0.711533308,
0.3750111163,
0.4799277484,
-0.4144523442,
0.1699573249,
0.3745419979,
-0.6893578768,
-0.547467351,
-0.5232174993,
-0.5092382431,
0.5935906172,
-0.2192591578,
0.4727541506,
-0.5083387494,
-0.1245490685,
-0.0645381287,
0.0039438857,
-0.4673432112,
0.0949066654,
0.3390295208,
1.0819753408,
-0.6177285314,
0.7448962331,
0.7438158989,
-0.1090347841,
-1.1459107399,
0.6694662571,
0.248751685,
-0.8476228118,
0.37111184,
0.3598864675,
-0.0781245455,
-0.2769919634,
-0.8614257574,
-0.826474905,
0.9787634611,
0.5568246245,
-0.7938207388,
0.125145793,
0.1184809655,
0.2718387544,
-0.3854729533,
0.444486171,
0.559099853,
0.8266820908,
0.6302682757,
-1.1188545227,
0.1129917949,
0.2070178539,
-0.2481385767,
-0.311207056,
-0.6721529961,
0.4713941813,
-0.2401040196,
-0.1280292124,
0.0324212089,
0.773568213,
0.7105372548,
0.3416653275,
0.7638596296,
0.079629533,
1.0489400625,
-0.0154800229,
0.9031403661,
-0.4155779481,
-0.0016338546,
1.019697547,
-0.3290020227,
0.6297769547,
0.3403236568,
-0.1024032831,
0.4620656669,
0.627887547,
0.207233876,
0.2416562736,
0.285246104,
-0.2016067952,
-0.1714521348,
-0.3167288899,
-0.3731285334,
0.2678622305,
0.6866284609,
-0.0900344998,
-0.3095498085,
-0.1123018488,
0.2435794771,
-0.1287817806,
-0.4221471548,
0.4078809321,
0.1104167551,
-0.7703019977,
0.3289593458,
-0.0024232774,
1.0174922943,
-0.7027400136,
0.0378090218,
-0.0705047101,
-0.1980792731,
-0.1814227253,
-0.7748135924,
0.2808806002,
0.0591191389,
-0.1303321272,
-0.1316495389,
1.1732459068,
-0.404853195,
-0.5498653054,
0.1880226135,
0.6444875002,
0.1817705929,
-0.3394541144,
-0.7516394854,
0.2185867578,
0.0496183336,
-0.2686165273,
0.0559847914,
0.8509767056,
-0.2457654476,
0.7336292863,
0.4992439449,
0.3287109435,
-0.2419135273,
0.2647442818,
1.0892877579,
-0.6129214168,
-0.4984922707,
-0.8977305889,
0.2152047455,
-0.0802535415,
0.0997580737,
1.024078846,
0.3990179002,
0.281884253,
0.0261105578,
1.2418230772,
-0.0410066918,
0.879599154,
-0.504881084,
0.7275568843,
0.0582132712,
0.6372156143,
-0.4530688524,
-0.920799911,
-0.0527394228,
0.4283183217,
-0.5570002198,
0.0404894426,
0.7074280977,
0.7818626165,
0.2022026032,
0.3577274978,
0.26271981,
0.5189140439,
0.1085261106,
0.1115508676,
1.2927478552,
0.1026973575,
0.7001801729,
-0.0875187293,
-0.3317040801,
-0.3180983961,
-0.9952149987,
-1.0421333313,
-0.1762682796,
-0.3732740879,
-0.6005040407,
0.3299304843,
0.9599560499,
0.6904447079,
-0.8421934247,
0.0300430823,
0.2067242116,
0.1293911636,
0.0414384864,
-0.2664499581,
0.1437261254,
-0.305262357,
-0.2897892892,
0.3679579198,
0.2125470638,
0.0060571623,
-0.446806401,
-0.127881974,
-0.0112338047,
0.3518046737,
0.6937047839,
0.058867503,
-0.7571487427,
-0.3500836194,
-0.011460742,
0.0556989387,
-0.1672184318,
0.5735992789,
-0.7997524738,
-0.135996893,
0.2170825303,
0.5126128793,
0.2142546773,
0.2241578698,
0.6267614365,
-0.7216806412,
0.0398019888,
0.2316540629,
0.2432277203,
0.4472865164,
-0.6199118495,
0.3397443593,
0.0838006958,
-0.285476476,
-0.4523284137,
-0.018108286,
-0.7556406856,
-0.1926125288,
1.5410208702,
0.1269572824,
-0.2637043595,
-0.3161803186,
-0.3888536692,
0.0138714164,
-0.9399167299,
1.0279172659,
0.9850794673,
-0.0222951751,
-0.1770055443,
-0.7145130038,
0.4875771999,
0.2312718481,
-0.7658831477,
0.256264329,
0.5651692748,
0.3772595227,
0.2509518266,
0.7299161553,
-0.1151381508,
0.1727133095,
-0.1463488787,
-0.2249998897,
0.091075927,
-0.4496186972,
-0.1114186496,
0.181742534,
0.2563497126,
0.1447449774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08092v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08092v1
|
Data-Augmentation-Based Dialectal Adaptation for LLMs
| 2024-04-11T19:15:32 | 2024-04-11T19:15:32 |
Fahim Faisal, Antonios Anastasopoulos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This report presents GMUNLP's participation to the Dialect-Copa shared task
at VarDial 2024, which focuses on evaluating the commonsense reasoning
capabilities of large language models (LLMs) on South Slavic micro-dialects.
The task aims to assess how well LLMs can handle non-standard dialectal
varieties, as their performance on standard languages is already
well-established. We propose an approach that combines the strengths of
different types of language models and leverages data augmentation techniques
to improve task performance on three South Slavic dialects: Chakavian,
Cherkano, and Torlak. We conduct experiments using a language-family-focused
encoder-based model (BERTi\'c) and a domain-agnostic multilingual model
(AYA-101). Our results demonstrate that the proposed data augmentation
techniques lead to substantial performance gains across all three test datasets
in the open-source model category. This work highlights the practical utility
of data augmentation and the potential of LLMs in handling non-standard
dialectal varieties, contributing to the broader goal of advancing natural
language understanding in low-resource and dialectal settings.
Code:https://github.com/ffaisal93/dialect_copa
|
[
-0.3304915726,
-0.4908342063,
0.5019817948,
0.2438297421,
-0.456527859,
0.0883729011,
-0.4612597227,
-0.506967485,
0.0648284256,
0.8993762136,
-0.6142359972,
-0.4509423077,
-0.1943872422,
0.3409743309,
0.0505642295,
0.6993127465,
0.1754095852,
0.3948324919,
-0.4616681933,
0.0468026474,
-0.2917915881,
-0.7336499691,
-0.2630686164,
-0.2778547108,
0.1563921422,
0.7247260809,
0.5081421733,
0.3782490492,
0.3420175314,
0.2037410438,
0.0174380857,
0.4507741034,
-0.345598042,
0.2434843332,
-0.202404812,
-0.6142886281,
-0.6273978949,
-0.3178116381,
0.6012488008,
0.7457404733,
-0.0831287652,
-0.0554666929,
0.0702298805,
0.5733591914,
-0.2474757582,
0.2909374237,
-0.9415197968,
-0.2399863452,
-0.183954373,
0.0635641292,
-0.3104357719,
-0.2230932564,
0.0550740361,
-0.6034821868,
0.1784332097,
0.4037206173,
0.582683742,
-0.0069162599,
-0.1786173433,
-0.1536812633,
-0.5213436484,
0.8588526249,
-0.9813191891,
0.5313791037,
0.3317089975,
0.2919982374,
-0.3471360207,
-0.2063894719,
-0.4418340921,
-0.2548827529,
0.1382056773,
0.1348451674,
-0.3099550307,
0.2600242496,
-0.0304496828,
0.4089638889,
-0.3270344138,
0.2118201554,
-0.4921191931,
-0.1410877556,
0.63689816,
0.3845360279,
-0.1920198649,
-0.2387288362,
-0.1442809105,
0.4173676968,
-0.7107809782,
-0.2747417986,
0.5961721539,
0.8175453544,
-0.2772034407,
0.7167860866,
-0.2685149014,
1.1006211042,
0.2360501438,
0.2286029905,
0.317034483,
-0.7283540964,
-0.3426539898,
-0.2604124844,
0.3835295141,
0.3526618183,
0.2481925339,
-0.314370364,
-0.1916205138,
-0.300009042,
0.1708541662,
-0.3030001223,
-0.0362529866,
0.1088802069,
-0.1740372479,
-0.4762670398,
-0.2694627643,
-1.2266983986,
-0.6242269278,
-0.6214146614,
0.236969471,
-0.5972912312,
-0.1220408827,
0.2280876935,
0.1083197519,
0.2331611216,
0.4862457514,
-0.9257258177,
0.5927195549,
0.7986522913,
0.7881680131,
-0.3932075202,
-0.2242876291,
-0.5673826337,
0.0532901883,
-0.3881952465,
0.6300218701,
-0.8549956679,
-0.2506230474,
0.0180565342,
0.1619284302,
-0.2555608451,
-0.8805531859,
0.5380163789,
-0.3483114839,
0.0987352505,
-0.2730937302,
-0.4842989743,
-0.1474169046,
-0.024838306,
-0.5835359693,
1.1128405333,
0.4791564345,
-0.4782434404,
0.2965369225,
-0.5848876238,
-0.2022033483,
-0.0138581833,
0.0946954861,
-0.149691388,
0.4397115111,
0.189863801,
0.3422595561,
-0.4930999577,
0.2159387171,
-0.5584061742,
-0.2808348238,
0.2737303078,
-0.2878913283,
0.6923366785,
0.1486145109,
0.0132924486,
0.2510966063,
-0.7984099388,
-0.1867447048,
-0.1811215878,
-0.1363042444,
-0.2290394455,
-0.1895464063,
0.1600182652,
0.2057009339,
0.1955447048,
-0.5698487163,
0.2649947703,
-0.5445201397,
0.2851526439,
0.7830243707,
-0.0575338304,
0.5476368666,
-0.4594590664,
0.5335704684,
0.1176064014,
0.2242667824,
0.186875701,
-0.2393543422,
-1.1090756655,
-0.3563568294,
0.5554426312,
0.5640076399,
-1.0539103746,
0.5718325973,
-0.4592801929,
-0.4348593354,
-0.6326595545,
0.2154646069,
-0.0505856797,
0.4161277115,
0.3016487062,
-0.3663561344,
-0.9134166241,
-0.9430646896,
-0.0207137167,
-0.076786533,
-0.0731176287,
0.6587011218,
0.4414212406,
-0.0603828132,
0.7980314493,
-0.0521878749,
0.0377447419,
-0.5988504887,
-0.0386618972,
0.2563664615,
0.334253341,
0.5347799063,
-0.4753117263,
-0.2944518626,
0.1630752087,
-0.3259476423,
-0.5851362944,
0.0355904847,
0.0760788843,
0.5097293854,
0.1710199118,
-0.2161692232,
0.1296822429,
0.8773590922,
-0.2710641921,
0.9219704866,
-0.217362538,
0.2407319844,
-0.9574354887,
-0.2316484302,
-0.1425065845,
-0.3329445422,
-1.1058006287,
-0.0455222763,
-0.0367639437,
-0.1376973838,
-0.4445271194,
0.4330446422,
-0.3644480109,
-0.4920336902,
-0.2567195594,
-0.0262828376,
-0.1076201946,
0.3192912936,
0.158214435,
1.1128672361,
0.6974393129,
-0.4970403612,
0.450006932,
-0.1618777514,
-0.3035874069,
0.6190313101,
-0.4555827975,
0.2521515191,
0.0165609084,
-0.018386215,
-0.797770977,
-0.3698325455,
0.3321254253,
-0.3803023398,
0.0566188134,
-0.5400454998,
-0.4154899716,
0.0472721271,
-0.1507988423,
0.11325638,
0.2150420547,
-0.5697831511,
0.70924896,
0.3257458508,
-0.4499846101,
-0.1736019552,
-0.7563025951,
0.3722748756,
-0.4492775202,
-0.8124769926,
0.226682663,
0.0891232044,
-0.4733602703,
-0.1102075651,
-0.0238256529,
-0.2448250353,
-0.0667859316,
-0.039379973,
0.6678072214,
-0.1919902712,
0.1436958015,
-0.0827029049,
0.1258026809,
-0.2251235694,
-0.4540041685,
0.761952281,
-0.4987381697,
-0.2486910969,
0.0276896469,
0.3013797104,
0.6269438863,
0.0172908213,
0.6312475801,
0.4283687174,
-0.1756290793,
-0.0188638419,
-0.6175600886,
-0.0191535354,
-0.4539812207,
0.1769744456,
-0.3784999251,
-1.0683903694,
0.5598093271,
-0.2389358133,
-0.2130722702,
0.1623048931,
0.4502313137,
-0.1686294079,
0.4233742952,
0.5357391238,
-0.2506731153,
0.3774605393,
-0.0505193919,
-0.0322871916,
-1.1096469164,
-0.1129946932,
-0.4428950846,
0.1461346895,
-0.6366000772,
-1.1087201834,
0.3334708512,
-0.1669305414,
0.0394128226,
0.3218770027,
0.0591796637,
0.1398838311,
0.3320783079,
0.1980128735,
0.2869994342,
0.0675874054,
0.0545247942,
-0.2272945195,
-0.7530350089,
-0.3813197911,
1.1677899361,
-0.0182088651,
0.8278488517,
0.1197012886,
0.6570717096,
0.4467868209,
-0.2115179747,
-0.6888424158,
0.5627526045,
-0.402115196,
-0.3719307184,
-0.3320887983,
-0.4024371803,
-0.6810618043,
0.3477802873,
-0.3411173522,
-0.7401206493,
0.5232890248,
0.0416172221,
-0.0551580973,
0.1059585288,
-0.4533857703,
0.4977984726,
-0.3024485409,
-0.5224115252,
-0.2754934728,
-0.4664461613,
0.2732768655,
-0.2705036104,
0.4901373386,
-0.125897646,
-0.3087799251,
0.3400147259,
-0.0940845609,
0.9031257629,
-0.3151525557,
0.1216938421,
0.0787602141,
-0.0846288204,
0.6619418263,
-0.1279808283,
-0.4760330915,
0.3219943643,
-0.1973315626,
-0.4771644771,
-0.7368764281,
0.533241868,
-0.4724790752,
-0.6066772938,
-0.331507802,
-0.9042961001,
-0.4908623993,
-0.0064148055,
-0.1962456554,
0.2900143266,
-0.2670892775,
0.2712669671,
0.6375687718,
-0.1412118226,
-0.0090502519,
0.6337293983,
-0.3272716403,
-0.6762963533,
0.8193780184,
-0.1237031445,
0.7003946304,
0.08003252,
0.085986197,
-0.1985530853,
-0.9836077094,
-0.6363030076,
0.2158887088,
-0.3919107616,
0.0365551189,
-0.220462054,
-0.0725159273,
-0.6118175387,
-0.1125124618,
-0.2432823032,
-0.8414863348,
-0.3269498348,
0.0702218115,
0.3672246337,
0.4993422925,
-0.1608785987,
0.2910133898,
-0.4708505571,
0.0109122721,
0.0491862744,
0.1201293319,
-0.5334004164,
-0.8975747824,
-0.2225773782,
0.090097867,
0.2506439984,
-0.8425135612,
0.5402141213,
0.3190887272,
0.697755456,
-0.1086411774,
-0.0366022922,
0.7514470816,
-0.283036083,
0.9153705239,
-0.1075479314,
-1.0379202366,
0.4053514898,
-0.5314366221,
0.0740449652,
0.6395606995,
-0.0513435788,
-0.5951516628,
-0.3914659619,
-0.4196988642,
-0.7327593565,
0.7337984443,
0.1277226359,
0.0442550853,
0.4930498302,
0.3746880889,
0.3585783541,
0.248682037,
-0.4018780887,
0.0744141638,
-0.1706904918,
-0.2295879275,
-0.1063335687,
-0.1359363645,
-0.045786269,
-0.3967665732,
0.7393801808,
-0.3914967477,
0.2267230451,
-0.0148180956,
-0.2753291428,
0.1012608334,
0.6333550811,
0.6651211977,
0.4742492139,
-0.1702859402,
0.1163742989,
0.5819633007,
-0.2664368451,
0.0560101308,
0.1686517298,
-0.2336883992,
-0.0466665402,
0.2136870772,
0.994964242,
0.2966663241,
-0.5785534382,
0.2498588115,
0.1894435883,
-0.243641898,
-0.0981460065,
0.1486511976,
0.0395333506,
0.2195053697,
0.2068401128,
0.114706032,
0.2031363696,
-0.6431501508,
0.1864134669,
0.2257977277,
-0.4138968885,
-0.3772377968,
0.0683305189,
0.21480079,
-0.0843807831,
0.3333134353,
-0.0559973791,
-0.537342906,
0.5196338892,
0.7307146788,
0.712746501,
-0.2654857337,
0.181422919,
0.1572302282,
0.4196965694,
0.3271666169,
0.4881567061,
0.0468389355,
-0.7244982123,
-0.3285553753,
-0.5330129862,
-0.6521045566,
0.2802969813,
-0.6245868206,
0.3633213937,
-0.20548217,
0.1056553647,
-0.0832424685,
0.1334846765,
-0.5583533049,
0.0073083225,
0.0174605008,
1.0952720642,
-1.117244482,
0.9523759484,
0.5458413363,
0.0035517726,
-0.1499836892,
0.08952301,
0.1725142449,
-0.8788422942,
0.2628599703,
-0.3660831153,
-0.1731345654,
-0.2433422506,
-0.3699939549,
-0.902533412,
0.9135988355,
0.5232074261,
-0.5620048046,
0.1509491801,
0.4812710285,
0.6294349432,
-0.7741656899,
-0.0214763377,
0.9004837275,
0.6905918121,
0.165567413,
-0.9817236662,
-0.0733526349,
-0.0448066033,
0.1302602142,
-0.0699319616,
-0.5006024837,
0.5918364525,
-0.0453514308,
0.1821301281,
0.2386726439,
0.6631006002,
0.3387739658,
0.2926121056,
0.6163933873,
0.3367756307,
0.8368019462,
-0.1759254187,
0.6795741916,
-0.2554066777,
0.0226018094,
1.2890002728,
-0.2881751657,
0.6040732265,
0.6416989565,
-0.3712575138,
0.4083680212,
0.6419355273,
-0.1264716834,
0.6061849594,
0.1838529706,
-0.4760470986,
-0.3388698995,
-0.3055627942,
-0.133826226,
0.684319675,
0.6622058749,
-0.2739209235,
-0.0741861239,
0.0171548445,
-0.0553624183,
0.0173757747,
-0.2925563157,
0.7790125608,
-0.2234851867,
-0.5410188437,
0.5248036385,
-0.1550147384,
0.6141805053,
-0.4788708389,
0.1047183052,
-0.236518696,
0.0045852242,
-0.1252257824,
-0.7201049328,
0.5083819628,
0.1595318913,
-0.0933560058,
0.1199031174,
0.9972699881,
-0.7041634917,
-0.6979572177,
0.144258976,
0.4803647995,
0.3058941662,
0.1781124622,
-0.6418271661,
0.2974355817,
0.1008343026,
0.3133284152,
0.4279640913,
0.3663149476,
-0.031774357,
0.5448037982,
0.570294857,
0.5777401328,
0.1957135946,
0.2936719358,
0.9560571313,
-0.3874926567,
-0.1710564196,
-0.5142691731,
0.2249077111,
-0.2414056957,
0.0079482691,
0.9180889726,
0.8100662231,
0.6845897436,
-0.130033344,
1.0646277666,
-0.0600763261,
0.4343598783,
-0.6650009155,
0.1559872031,
-0.428622961,
0.3786859512,
-0.1433535069,
-0.6954662204,
-0.2260311544,
0.2680911422,
-0.478479296,
-0.1421694309,
0.2946177721,
1.007583499,
-0.0893921852,
0.2466175258,
0.4689284563,
0.1417632401,
0.1101410538,
0.5070675611,
0.7834746838,
-0.0879589543,
0.4214257896,
-0.373295933,
-0.3058050275,
-0.2029627711,
-0.8730877042,
-0.6898255944,
-0.5900261998,
0.0787010789,
-0.1561889052,
0.6546601653,
0.9733349085,
0.7009505033,
-0.9745889306,
-0.4651760459,
-0.2121144384,
0.0433216691,
-0.2300996333,
-0.2451893985,
-0.0064544966,
-0.5120685101,
-0.8369717598,
0.8347835541,
0.3944116831,
-0.0091200555,
-0.1771676838,
-0.1605048031,
-0.0791322887,
0.3351267576,
0.4655419588,
-0.0635892153,
-0.8256770968,
-0.5009192824,
0.167519182,
0.2563366592,
0.2023052424,
0.8894588351,
-0.5625578761,
0.7086094618,
0.5005211234,
0.3745011687,
0.5776206255,
0.0956163108,
0.8035423756,
-0.638494432,
0.1166989505,
0.319917351,
0.4077967405,
0.5625568628,
-0.3267886043,
0.7203651667,
0.3982877135,
-0.5013621449,
-0.8334586024,
0.227920264,
-1.0215859413,
-0.0815840662,
1.3270761967,
-0.1089207381,
-0.189520672,
-0.654251039,
-0.1377627999,
0.0387086347,
-0.4803071618,
0.6424818635,
0.9006050229,
-0.3986211717,
-0.3102159798,
-0.6608863473,
0.3758261204,
0.2449629158,
-0.9895175099,
0.6286963224,
0.6512588859,
0.3158015907,
-0.2126776874,
0.3989613354,
-0.1584592611,
0.337656945,
0.029174149,
-0.0899218321,
-0.249113977,
-0.3944024742,
-0.7879456878,
-0.3552258313,
-0.0402698368,
0.0084558772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08080v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08080v1
|
Variance-reduced Zeroth-Order Methods for Fine-Tuning Language Models
| 2024-04-11T18:35:49 | 2024-04-11T18:35:49 |
Tanmay Gautam, Youngsuk Park, Hao Zhou, Parameswaran Raman, Wooseok Ha
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, math.OC
|
Fine-tuning language models (LMs) has demonstrated success in a wide array of
downstream tasks. However, as LMs are scaled up, the memory requirements for
backpropagation become prohibitively high. Zeroth-order (ZO) optimization
methods can leverage memory-efficient forward passes to estimate gradients.
More recently, MeZO, an adaptation of ZO-SGD, has been shown to consistently
outperform zero-shot and in-context learning when combined with suitable task
prompts. In this work, we couple ZO methods with variance reduction techniques
to enhance stability and convergence for inference-based LM fine-tuning. We
introduce Memory-Efficient Zeroth-Order Stochastic Variance-Reduced Gradient
(MeZO-SVRG) and demonstrate its efficacy across multiple LM fine-tuning tasks,
eliminating the reliance on task-specific prompts. Evaluated across a range of
both masked and autoregressive LMs on benchmark GLUE tasks, MeZO-SVRG
outperforms MeZO with up to 20% increase in test accuracies in both full- and
partial-parameter fine-tuning settings. MeZO-SVRG benefits from reduced
computation time as it often surpasses MeZO's peak test accuracy with a
$2\times$ reduction in GPU-hours. MeZO-SVRG significantly reduces the required
memory footprint compared to first-order SGD, i.e. by $2\times$ for
autoregressive models. Our experiments highlight that MeZO-SVRG's memory
savings progressively improve compared to SGD with larger batch sizes.
|
[
-0.5236191154,
-0.7757996917,
0.0710587502,
0.1024671793,
-0.1440881789,
-0.1341582388,
-0.5387138724,
-0.0895014554,
-0.232496649,
0.4308211505,
-0.7848911881,
-0.5938298702,
-0.2052963674,
-0.3179357648,
0.147560671,
0.8284963965,
0.032110218,
0.1540376544,
-0.0179054886,
-0.0887564942,
-0.2749222815,
-0.1610697955,
-0.6692311168,
-0.2773254216,
0.7185698152,
0.7979034781,
0.4797817171,
0.7464338541,
0.1166346669,
0.1746708453,
0.0007017271,
0.1943658441,
-0.6991022229,
0.1520784199,
-0.2114400268,
-0.4816954732,
-0.5017283559,
-0.0202369392,
0.2684545219,
0.6906399131,
-0.5169360638,
0.2888265252,
-0.1334715337,
0.7216656804,
-1.1979618073,
-0.0279761404,
-0.4107845128,
0.1356770843,
-0.1777002513,
-0.2309132814,
-0.3667311072,
-0.2393735796,
-0.1550520509,
-0.3502122164,
0.5351647735,
-0.1245684922,
0.7866949439,
0.4745744467,
0.3215729892,
0.1181382537,
-0.880507946,
0.9214832783,
-1.1570346355,
0.543461442,
0.359010756,
0.2969126403,
-0.3180928826,
-0.3022789955,
-0.4725677371,
-0.0565823652,
0.5902251005,
0.1916717142,
-0.0776025653,
0.5041923523,
0.1933220625,
0.6078703403,
-0.527970612,
0.5181664228,
-0.3644163013,
-0.1211302727,
0.54220891,
0.2835737467,
-0.0322110131,
0.285658747,
-0.0721186474,
-0.3870840073,
-0.7067968249,
0.1956271678,
0.2511784136,
0.574696064,
0.2839117348,
0.2891320586,
-0.4891436696,
0.8265115023,
0.3644435704,
-0.1853444874,
0.1750469953,
-0.2678560913,
-0.5660937428,
-0.2868142128,
0.7359868288,
0.316537261,
0.2164471298,
-0.1381497979,
-0.1240060925,
-0.1521049291,
0.3220697343,
-1.0868035555,
-0.1357316077,
0.0458265208,
-0.3236243725,
-0.0482031517,
-0.3372527361,
-0.8274533749,
-0.0120385773,
-0.1655826569,
0.4419418573,
-0.3983871043,
0.086684145,
0.3645710945,
0.1811405867,
0.1545450985,
0.7041575313,
-1.1502462626,
0.4291042387,
0.5199928284,
0.7395594716,
0.0881915912,
-0.4085136652,
-0.7898792028,
-0.1374411732,
-0.8163872361,
0.32214728,
-0.4381000102,
-0.178737998,
-0.0649658591,
-0.2414697856,
-0.1423542202,
-0.6396135092,
0.4764699936,
-0.3401278257,
0.0651433691,
-0.2388038337,
-0.4892741144,
-0.2484769374,
0.0005282418,
-0.2362846583,
1.2727434635,
0.2248046398,
-0.0954706296,
0.1814426184,
-0.1393284798,
-0.3280740082,
-0.4821323156,
-0.0721155629,
-0.4506154656,
0.3982696533,
-0.0485447384,
0.7890510559,
-0.4528003931,
-0.1250402629,
-0.5922300816,
-0.4990258515,
-0.4624032378,
-0.386374265,
0.3752414584,
0.327783674,
-0.464207381,
0.0425238758,
-1.0015428066,
0.0568059869,
-0.2321315557,
-0.2019802183,
-0.4556148946,
0.0603979416,
-0.272022754,
0.392906785,
0.0160044227,
-0.5222462416,
0.1454413831,
-0.5672557354,
0.2479044199,
0.5935028791,
-0.0944112763,
0.6587045193,
-0.0902142823,
0.355212003,
-0.0609076209,
0.2282100469,
-0.1770499945,
-0.2988828421,
-0.990903914,
-0.2961667776,
0.2006296366,
0.5942318439,
-0.5541028976,
0.2793405354,
-0.179229036,
-0.6315943599,
-0.5222281218,
0.2980133295,
0.6432822943,
0.5312811732,
0.6257576346,
-0.1221258491,
0.1028259024,
-0.8774927855,
-0.0919394344,
0.0844484791,
-0.2775323689,
0.5721466541,
0.1491757035,
-0.0616617352,
0.575761795,
-0.5930299759,
-0.1055720225,
0.1390921772,
0.467877537,
0.2832782865,
0.6340802312,
0.7314078212,
-0.2286438048,
-0.5228098035,
0.2048751861,
0.0209688861,
-0.2306022048,
-0.1783432811,
0.0384069048,
0.335023284,
0.5479453206,
-0.5092869401,
0.4012196958,
0.3638381362,
-0.2051197439,
0.505231142,
-0.6454438567,
0.0954550952,
-0.850150764,
-0.2548078001,
-0.0814667642,
-0.1753322482,
-0.878412962,
-0.0754617676,
0.2181414962,
0.091699779,
-0.1419593692,
0.5783798695,
-0.5524650216,
-0.0455742814,
-0.187008813,
-0.1409144402,
-0.0617267974,
0.7535998225,
-0.4431960583,
0.8527449369,
0.4245183468,
-0.8402203321,
-0.0233987011,
-0.1831666827,
-0.2123480737,
0.2627358437,
-0.4257034957,
0.1037725955,
-0.0231832508,
-0.3978806138,
-1.0088133812,
0.2295632511,
0.3253182769,
-0.4205960333,
0.840017736,
-0.0098566543,
-0.4200442135,
-0.2641553879,
-0.4828111827,
0.1707016826,
0.4935775995,
-0.5080725551,
0.3831296265,
-0.0332981609,
-0.2861715853,
-0.7746254206,
-0.6417267323,
-0.1900097132,
-0.012499786,
-0.2709712982,
0.4053629637,
-0.2132509649,
-0.1397490054,
-0.3823091388,
-0.4119318128,
-0.18284069,
0.273938477,
-0.1261025965,
0.0615549237,
-0.4466273189,
0.1572446823,
0.4292613864,
-0.0994919986,
-0.4841880798,
-0.2083919793,
0.5279530287,
-0.1541534066,
-0.2177346945,
-0.1864908487,
0.2571065426,
0.7160395384,
-0.0347906053,
0.7984235883,
0.7819023728,
-0.1746878773,
-0.6561354995,
-0.6726327538,
-0.1378429383,
-0.4762704372,
0.357063055,
-0.330966562,
-1.2300262451,
0.7068391442,
-0.0621524826,
0.1529388875,
0.2691406608,
0.7868785262,
-0.0252125189,
0.6750233769,
0.4607109427,
-0.2934309244,
0.7829897404,
-0.1066831872,
0.3535211086,
-0.5647382736,
0.2279514074,
-0.5534891486,
-0.20933792,
-0.3967681229,
-0.9273602366,
-0.1451713443,
0.462453872,
-0.2585224807,
0.188371703,
-0.2095250487,
0.5056526065,
0.471516639,
0.0647554323,
0.003303536,
-0.0659406036,
-0.0423295572,
-0.1429957449,
-0.7435511351,
0.0072358581,
0.8039520979,
0.1549148411,
0.8414882421,
-0.2152026892,
0.5164423585,
0.2048383206,
0.0227445513,
-0.6331003308,
0.3376194537,
-0.4440661967,
-0.2124676853,
-0.656072557,
-0.4011884034,
-0.583935082,
0.5400702953,
-0.0723170266,
-0.7963765264,
0.455411613,
0.2266270965,
-0.7507533431,
0.2175286412,
-0.5367608666,
0.5299735665,
0.0673079342,
-0.7020618916,
-0.6285250783,
-0.4930885732,
0.105813086,
0.2161730826,
0.0503358357,
-0.4127059579,
-0.0353195108,
0.2813728154,
-0.803057313,
0.6840983629,
-0.3047029674,
-0.3619301319,
0.0059630955,
0.1272682548,
0.5113429427,
-0.2146053314,
-0.2408810705,
0.2058968395,
-0.2050545514,
-0.3809246421,
-0.8039367199,
0.8057729602,
-0.5574746132,
-0.5501969457,
0.1875673681,
-0.7208141088,
-0.2886137962,
0.2875632644,
0.138977617,
0.4524808824,
-0.1806062162,
0.086952202,
0.8657147288,
-0.2624740303,
0.6552042365,
0.5045382977,
0.1799875051,
-0.450581938,
0.9379258156,
0.4778031707,
0.4564258754,
0.4060545266,
0.0547363609,
0.1388484836,
-0.8988626599,
-0.6179664731,
0.0833593607,
-0.4107363522,
-0.3046479821,
-0.3352026939,
0.0892299265,
-0.2082866728,
-0.2996322513,
-0.9566944242,
-0.57290411,
-0.4121014476,
-0.0030923942,
0.345074296,
0.0887579769,
-0.0932867154,
0.3458367586,
-0.6754443049,
0.170081988,
0.1890002042,
0.5287650824,
0.0643829182,
-0.391291976,
-0.5153377652,
0.1584405303,
0.0873548165,
-0.5399672389,
0.369466126,
0.4336659908,
0.5973598361,
0.7162511349,
0.1997652948,
1.2074147463,
-0.7734367251,
0.5332717896,
0.0475254878,
-0.9909638166,
0.2804320157,
-0.7011779547,
-0.0268260278,
0.7235811949,
0.0145800766,
-0.2467531711,
-0.3056590557,
-0.4297251999,
-0.9154205918,
0.7408052087,
0.1547403187,
0.1424310058,
0.1252905279,
0.8336033821,
0.2368082702,
0.4004044235,
-0.090754956,
-0.5577285886,
0.0086131841,
-0.1323332936,
-0.4792338014,
-0.2787964642,
0.2283935398,
-0.4407305121,
0.5578986406,
-0.2835230231,
0.1367992163,
0.1033440158,
-0.0657705069,
-0.2052989155,
0.3254513144,
1.0377447605,
0.5049946904,
-0.3808242083,
-0.0569920056,
0.3905844688,
-0.3619046211,
-0.0049560927,
0.025944462,
-0.2900635004,
0.171473965,
-0.1455380917,
1.0243326426,
0.5805833936,
-0.5529257655,
0.3386364579,
0.0288419481,
-0.2718420625,
0.2667102218,
0.4785570502,
-0.080039829,
0.5229415298,
0.2242317498,
0.161173135,
0.2376439422,
-0.1947147697,
0.1196959689,
0.5187138319,
-0.3383235037,
-0.3308039904,
0.4468836784,
-0.1782229245,
-0.3227691948,
0.1503506154,
-0.0299523398,
-0.0909353346,
0.5046583414,
0.4936365187,
0.8614083529,
-0.6479672194,
0.1098399535,
0.4930665195,
0.1457166672,
-0.4673416913,
0.299896121,
-0.5224342942,
-0.7373076677,
-0.2658040226,
-0.560080409,
-0.5665258765,
0.1399100572,
-0.980997324,
-0.0010439656,
-0.8528786898,
0.0323663466,
-0.1070339978,
0.1008777469,
-0.2466762662,
0.3135532141,
0.1487766504,
0.8284048438,
-0.5914798379,
0.97016716,
0.2952743769,
-0.050549861,
-0.547509551,
0.0767050982,
-0.2956838608,
-0.6233413219,
0.0740557313,
-0.0320676342,
-0.4360312819,
0.2630198002,
-0.5316805243,
-0.9021010399,
1.0698992014,
0.5934201479,
-0.7610834241,
0.2036108822,
-0.2799794674,
0.7073749304,
-0.3365049362,
0.1520151645,
0.5001882911,
0.1142363548,
0.3089352846,
-0.7988307476,
-0.061984729,
-0.2242937833,
0.32938537,
0.3767240345,
-0.8345932961,
1.2880148888,
-0.3724211454,
-0.1310163587,
0.0529325753,
0.6758230925,
0.1444704384,
0.1445015967,
0.2010110617,
0.5683717728,
0.9955148697,
0.0311984364,
0.7090474367,
-0.2980774045,
0.5668521523,
1.1682275534,
-0.1455885768,
0.9966261983,
0.5631562471,
-0.1257479787,
0.4761559665,
0.8162270784,
-0.0316630751,
0.7239950895,
0.2990282774,
-0.0028728985,
-0.3150371313,
0.2176637501,
-0.316323936,
0.0808603391,
0.4199713767,
-0.0012895697,
-0.4210471511,
-0.0537950471,
0.2921682,
-0.1414873749,
-0.6538052559,
0.5337517262,
0.0124769351,
-0.428740412,
0.9800031781,
0.0581553914,
0.6308652759,
-0.309101522,
0.0380821191,
-0.4113470614,
0.6465005279,
0.0396869816,
-0.1309994906,
0.2035766095,
-0.2721765339,
-0.3815214038,
-0.1908671111,
0.60192734,
-0.689792335,
-0.3141678274,
0.5249193907,
0.4378124774,
-0.1519301981,
0.0965780988,
-0.5623538494,
-0.3725741506,
-0.1503458321,
-0.5252007246,
0.5338765383,
0.4104228616,
-0.0448252968,
0.7521795034,
0.6774919033,
0.1989063919,
0.2541581988,
0.1794588119,
0.777349174,
-0.6152247787,
-0.4711609781,
-0.9919092655,
0.1970217079,
0.2136923671,
-0.1008596271,
0.8636387587,
0.3226093948,
0.898360312,
-0.2230925113,
0.5226709247,
0.1897809505,
0.3980682194,
-0.5955536962,
0.7158098221,
-0.8461338878,
0.0533793457,
-0.3481113017,
-0.6111091971,
-0.4927322567,
0.8692187071,
-0.2005342841,
0.05296202,
0.252377063,
0.7954870462,
-0.0124802077,
-0.2812187672,
0.577183187,
0.3379603326,
0.0149842491,
0.4890957177,
0.4554601312,
-0.5524284244,
0.0594891496,
-0.3807374835,
-0.2294329405,
-0.3698230386,
-0.6151362062,
-1.0748933554,
-0.2736012638,
-0.129302457,
-0.214835465,
0.2246004641,
0.8911674619,
0.633257091,
-1.1072140932,
-0.3067993224,
-0.2568186522,
0.0839805901,
-0.2364272922,
-0.1351975799,
0.1639869958,
-0.6842722893,
-0.7706241608,
0.3960230947,
0.8147789836,
-0.1447739601,
-0.0790958256,
-0.2439332902,
-0.1041478068,
0.2751055658,
0.4212232828,
0.4521577656,
-0.6558868885,
-0.2216861099,
0.1867191643,
-0.1178743839,
0.327565074,
0.5726528764,
-0.408615768,
0.4535131156,
0.7005272508,
0.5150642395,
0.7020913363,
0.0839641169,
0.8136123419,
-0.5142677426,
0.2542383373,
0.1435807347,
0.1338608116,
-0.0654532984,
-0.3172065616,
0.4345062971,
0.0974943191,
-0.3266372979,
-0.7803806663,
-0.0113408342,
-0.7548863292,
-0.3353644907,
0.9484754205,
-0.2529562414,
-0.2887281775,
-0.0512560084,
0.0655521527,
0.2994530797,
-0.4179786146,
0.7948169708,
0.642460227,
-0.1673125327,
-0.4313566387,
-0.6184991002,
0.7374526858,
0.6730411053,
-0.5417927504,
0.4035490751,
0.5807837844,
0.3040541112,
0.1094566062,
0.6925960779,
0.1529087424,
0.3968876004,
-0.1479419023,
0.2378004193,
-0.1610872298,
-0.4606482089,
-0.4925732315,
0.0024921647,
-0.1422053874,
-0.2553198636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08078v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08078v1
|
SQBC: Active Learning using LLM-Generated Synthetic Data for Stance Detection in Online Political Discussions
| 2024-04-11T18:34:11 | 2024-04-11T18:34:11 |
Stefan Sylvius Wagner, Maike Behrendt, Marc Ziegele, Stefan Harmeling
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Stance detection is an important task for many applications that analyse or
support online political discussions. Common approaches include fine-tuning
transformer based models. However, these models require a large amount of
labelled data, which might not be available. In this work, we present two
different ways to leverage LLM-generated synthetic data to train and improve
stance detection agents for online political discussions: first, we show that
augmenting a small fine-tuning dataset with synthetic data can improve the
performance of the stance detection model. Second, we propose a new active
learning method called SQBC based on the "Query-by-Comittee" approach. The key
idea is to use LLM-generated synthetic data as an oracle to identify the most
informative unlabelled samples, that are selected for manual labelling.
Comprehensive experiments show that both ideas can improve the stance detection
performance. Curiously, we observed that fine-tuning on actively selected
samples can exceed the performance of using the full dataset.
|
[
-0.5668489933,
-1.0651884079,
0.4549131393,
-0.1399786025,
-0.5335478187,
0.1727184951,
-0.3747453988,
-0.3503672183,
0.6573562026,
0.4326387048,
-0.4489877522,
-0.6242787242,
-0.3900889456,
-0.0434668176,
-0.2409050465,
0.8435989022,
0.2025119662,
0.2402999401,
-0.0463004708,
-0.3581104577,
-0.126450628,
-0.3814638257,
-0.6362883449,
-0.1332656741,
0.5826810002,
0.4585064054,
0.7394968867,
0.7538211346,
0.093239449,
0.3311742842,
-0.1549783796,
0.5474798083,
-0.6098764539,
0.331229955,
-0.0756680369,
-0.7653861046,
-0.4076401293,
0.2039399743,
0.7266164422,
0.32284832,
-0.0509976856,
-0.1707380116,
-0.2687685788,
0.5535347462,
-0.6076408029,
0.1028258353,
-0.9222462773,
0.1656442583,
-0.1683785319,
-0.1257905662,
-0.4966709614,
-0.4353639185,
-0.4539316893,
-0.6404229999,
0.3864593804,
0.1155322492,
0.5995902419,
0.0578915104,
-0.5777310133,
-0.3149115741,
-0.6800131798,
0.5587289333,
-0.718321979,
0.3617385924,
0.2011428624,
0.2961764634,
-0.2172957808,
-0.8216525316,
-0.9339798689,
-0.0891313404,
-0.0231837761,
0.2649178803,
-0.3064005971,
0.1655460894,
0.1878708154,
0.2972171605,
-0.3395486176,
0.1108200997,
-0.2110736221,
-0.2886537015,
0.7756423354,
0.0274489336,
-0.1402082592,
-0.4698006809,
-0.4958928525,
-0.1638887525,
-0.7017428875,
-0.0009500819,
0.726195097,
0.5647772551,
0.264526546,
0.7069350481,
-0.3001134396,
0.5910905004,
0.6081555486,
0.3031025231,
-0.0790871829,
-0.1788663119,
-0.1476794779,
0.0377581194,
0.8604761958,
0.0226164721,
-0.1618655771,
0.188515678,
-0.3340187371,
0.0745606869,
0.3195476234,
-0.7069413662,
-0.381405741,
0.2254238278,
-0.4060646892,
-0.4313775897,
0.4567778409,
-0.5968597531,
-0.7892284393,
-0.7117071152,
0.2674699426,
-0.1618583947,
-0.2472224832,
-0.2233986855,
0.0564665124,
0.3801324964,
0.5317288637,
-0.4405920208,
0.0768977329,
0.8248612881,
0.6293416023,
-0.5586862564,
0.3165004253,
-0.7019959688,
-0.0128963469,
-0.4953980446,
1.0339423418,
-0.6590610743,
-0.2408481985,
0.0980806276,
0.1443182975,
0.2865323722,
-0.8736935854,
0.409676075,
-0.5997390151,
0.1515999585,
-0.2668316066,
-0.7418663502,
0.0618536919,
0.5658401251,
-0.9776711464,
1.1668021679,
-0.2680647671,
-0.5991309285,
0.5941596627,
-0.5194320083,
-0.3649917245,
-0.014570483,
-0.3061302006,
-0.7040772438,
-0.0470573381,
0.207845062,
0.5443825126,
0.2916213572,
0.3110234439,
-0.4369550049,
-0.1832274497,
0.5605369806,
-0.290543139,
0.7532047629,
0.1116941795,
-0.4280346632,
0.6393297911,
-0.7927223444,
-0.140404731,
-0.1578966975,
-0.4278335571,
-0.2566696107,
0.1721823812,
-0.2303874344,
0.1465926319,
0.0298910309,
-0.410077244,
0.3858093023,
-0.433044672,
0.0166320205,
0.8426023126,
0.2106628716,
0.5587517619,
-0.1519830078,
0.4641910195,
0.0074636484,
0.030445464,
0.1639133841,
-0.3529939353,
-1.019053936,
-0.3691821992,
0.352283448,
0.3819314539,
-0.6695969105,
0.3803444803,
0.0551182069,
-0.4249811471,
-0.5485829115,
0.1323851049,
0.0027955512,
-0.0703987107,
0.380346477,
-0.1173333526,
-0.6301371455,
-0.6939762831,
-0.5530924201,
-0.4100283384,
0.0390734375,
0.3889630735,
0.2388755679,
-0.0371460803,
0.9943757653,
-0.4090086818,
-0.0919394419,
-0.339722842,
0.4439471364,
-0.1554767489,
0.0440903008,
0.2249037474,
-0.9015131593,
-0.5370561481,
-0.1009938195,
-0.3596661687,
-0.0432436205,
-0.4780298769,
-0.2760214508,
0.2567658126,
0.5016698837,
-0.8503379226,
0.4160611928,
0.1584675014,
-0.2496867478,
0.2549919188,
0.205555737,
0.0894349962,
-1.1037881374,
-0.2305931598,
0.0919996053,
-0.6850195527,
-0.7037608027,
0.0002838341,
0.1350550205,
-0.1207185164,
-0.7535475492,
0.4878880978,
-0.416451335,
0.1234444007,
-0.5975152254,
0.2524214983,
-0.2390343994,
0.345854193,
0.2880292833,
0.4361463189,
0.3007899225,
-0.5247965455,
0.5462561846,
0.1671066284,
-0.1096471325,
0.3662655354,
-0.2837386131,
0.3907054961,
-0.0593617447,
0.5360470414,
-1.2888629436,
-0.3266986012,
0.4669322371,
-0.427674979,
0.4578722715,
-0.2494588345,
-0.3903130293,
-0.0542797036,
-0.4851903915,
0.090339385,
0.1378774792,
-0.6459205151,
0.5958769321,
0.6907345653,
0.1944692731,
-0.5142151713,
-0.2979119122,
-0.0820712,
-0.3143186271,
-0.3163233995,
0.364920944,
0.3597790003,
-0.391848594,
-0.2136180997,
-0.3058072925,
0.1338829845,
-0.3179725409,
0.3697332144,
0.0129143,
-0.1484149545,
0.218788743,
0.0357779972,
-0.0475888923,
0.1858585179,
-0.134790659,
0.3258837461,
-0.0009611308,
-0.460119307,
-0.5373569131,
0.1733749956,
0.4854021072,
-0.0381915197,
0.7004191875,
0.8027368784,
-0.2738843262,
-0.6498701572,
-0.4113977551,
-0.5196832418,
-0.5184383392,
0.1372430176,
0.2517243028,
-0.7533694506,
0.2927069366,
-0.4530621171,
0.1360033751,
0.2522257566,
0.8579758406,
-0.4005103707,
1.0013023615,
0.4557945728,
0.002138735,
0.6128417253,
-0.3347672522,
0.2192439139,
-0.1352880299,
-0.2668958008,
-0.3824950755,
-0.6323415637,
-0.6403005719,
-0.8109386563,
0.2574732304,
-0.2060768902,
-0.0374434032,
0.151398927,
-0.459218055,
0.3776195645,
0.2472388446,
0.296214819,
0.1599613279,
0.0065838583,
0.2488701344,
-0.1020026356,
-0.5732418895,
-0.4126625955,
0.8027122021,
0.1295623779,
0.7207596302,
0.0362090617,
0.4320251048,
0.5329079628,
0.3601585925,
-1.2633212805,
0.8967954516,
0.0897438973,
-0.6809348464,
-0.2379487902,
-0.4765431285,
-1.0608519316,
0.3648611307,
-0.5094102025,
0.0594999306,
0.1655819118,
0.2998883426,
-0.025396049,
0.4969771802,
-0.2026311457,
0.7549870014,
-0.366804719,
-0.5052545071,
-0.482337445,
-0.6415171623,
0.096053198,
0.1056903377,
0.005055015,
-0.019684786,
-0.105957672,
0.7667787671,
-0.2433468252,
1.2794376612,
-0.6162193418,
-0.0418352522,
0.5677886605,
-0.10970781,
0.8407282233,
0.3167913556,
-0.1421948671,
-0.1788392216,
-0.5449745655,
-0.2545322478,
-0.5592913032,
0.5208680034,
-0.7792784572,
-0.7604692578,
-0.4145898521,
-0.4127853811,
-0.2480081618,
0.0176442992,
-0.0238946546,
0.0820352435,
-0.5251229405,
0.5092976093,
0.7177946568,
-0.0196788311,
0.1672917455,
0.5184762478,
0.025718553,
-0.3109103143,
0.6732997298,
0.1437029839,
0.0419250689,
0.4143250883,
0.2494693995,
-0.5962408781,
-0.4481232762,
-0.1506822258,
0.1778251827,
-0.7438021898,
-0.5333268046,
-0.4803150892,
-0.0061705802,
-0.2398799509,
-0.0753580406,
-0.5504515767,
-0.8670899272,
-0.4136033952,
-0.3847013712,
0.3834166229,
0.607385993,
-0.0340825953,
0.4862787127,
-0.2760005593,
0.5395091772,
0.337472111,
0.0746719018,
-0.5395450592,
-0.4743859172,
-0.0089504765,
0.2502942085,
-0.7455633879,
-1.1743835211,
0.3388932943,
0.3054390252,
0.642657876,
0.719830513,
0.4926104844,
0.624678731,
-0.0246635582,
0.7223905325,
-0.0855981261,
-0.6447304487,
0.7335540652,
-0.3904530406,
-0.1306063533,
0.3850511312,
0.6474134326,
0.0040966123,
-0.6823141575,
-0.6201687455,
-0.9368169308,
0.7246830463,
0.2271323502,
0.3261604011,
-0.0738160163,
0.3942243159,
0.2360564172,
0.1474719048,
-0.8026788235,
-0.2362508029,
-0.3603989482,
0.0590270758,
0.4242078662,
0.1311800927,
-0.286893338,
-0.4430055916,
0.811781764,
-0.3894996345,
0.1845608205,
-0.1083219871,
-0.1452646852,
-0.2724364996,
0.1722608358,
0.227846846,
0.3949861825,
0.070637539,
0.1769355685,
0.4016720057,
-0.2472263426,
0.0716288164,
-0.1712415814,
-0.1325742602,
0.2797541916,
0.0153235169,
0.9766584039,
-0.0109216748,
-0.3130041957,
0.4782375991,
0.015924694,
-0.2131969631,
-0.4130383134,
0.2500397563,
0.2083539069,
0.3211070299,
0.3046259284,
0.0496919826,
-0.025974296,
-0.8667191267,
0.482881695,
0.7919772863,
-0.4553818107,
-0.3545594215,
0.5633372664,
0.1666993797,
-0.2229174823,
0.3894710839,
-0.1471279413,
-0.5249916315,
0.6184616089,
0.5174247622,
0.4061364532,
-0.2618377209,
0.4226496816,
0.4358761013,
-0.0220622327,
0.1036472693,
0.2277448773,
-0.1645516455,
-0.6784465313,
-0.2670786977,
-0.3346168697,
-0.6271349192,
0.2896560729,
-0.6930390596,
0.7189133763,
-0.5620866418,
-0.4482583106,
0.0429891124,
0.4847429395,
-0.2302586287,
0.1478537768,
0.2224475741,
0.6225330234,
-0.957226634,
0.8669323325,
0.9441603422,
0.128718257,
-0.5788807869,
0.2007561028,
0.2127758712,
-0.5253686905,
0.1322298199,
0.0657837912,
-0.1041503102,
-0.112119399,
-0.7652189136,
-0.276366055,
1.0039442778,
0.4620355368,
-0.408744663,
0.3303852379,
0.3353812099,
0.5340790153,
-0.2816430032,
0.159044072,
0.1953035146,
0.6868566275,
0.1773196757,
-0.170649603,
0.0937542766,
-0.1123811156,
-0.5316551924,
0.3674857318,
-0.913217485,
0.5907511115,
0.1071761847,
-0.3199501932,
-0.3678242564,
1.0671383142,
0.3781469464,
0.5183122158,
0.6829488873,
0.2726812065,
0.9280495644,
-0.08552064,
0.569126308,
-0.0932506174,
0.2716206312,
0.6408566236,
-0.3128241897,
0.9070543051,
0.4355466366,
-0.043427106,
0.3213657737,
0.737275362,
-0.1418286711,
0.2759551108,
0.1897228658,
-0.51111871,
-0.6609145403,
0.1104599386,
0.0629921034,
0.5305611491,
0.6542273164,
-0.1241734102,
-0.045482263,
-0.028057782,
-0.0403881371,
0.2315201014,
-0.3130241632,
1.0475971699,
0.0656940714,
-0.6643870473,
0.5464651585,
0.0267019495,
0.5207477808,
-0.490205884,
-0.1222720593,
-0.3755114079,
0.1187951267,
-0.3719319403,
-0.8146779537,
0.3816837668,
-0.0235293489,
0.0058187358,
-0.2881082892,
1.0411975384,
-0.529625535,
-0.3089852631,
0.0144782541,
0.5651241541,
0.0822684988,
0.0222815592,
-0.8479596972,
-0.024689747,
0.0626720041,
-0.5803570151,
0.447324872,
0.6230813265,
-0.3225833178,
0.4257976413,
0.9507914782,
0.1423868984,
-0.0139712859,
-0.1259074956,
1.2492333651,
-0.5187183022,
-0.4047974646,
-0.6372672319,
0.4327758253,
-0.3177537024,
0.0297244266,
0.7963799834,
0.750445962,
0.774153471,
0.0878466517,
0.8255283237,
-0.0767440796,
0.3865706325,
-0.4557104111,
0.7585398555,
-0.5073367357,
0.3525006175,
0.252802819,
-0.8825105429,
-0.477897644,
0.9201695919,
-0.140838176,
-0.1592431217,
0.4064427018,
1.1536335945,
-0.5892272592,
0.117276378,
0.1240083575,
0.2682496011,
0.304264456,
-0.0399616584,
1.0065498352,
-0.1057514474,
0.6462789178,
-0.2300632894,
0.0715183094,
-0.3073126972,
-0.7924725413,
-1.1048375368,
-0.4786470234,
-0.5318440795,
-0.4497417212,
0.0056963186,
1.035744071,
0.8002489209,
-1.0451023579,
-0.1185410619,
-0.0338291228,
0.0589871146,
-0.0990128666,
-0.2096703947,
0.4324863851,
-0.2070750445,
-0.7406539321,
0.6220271587,
-0.1662011743,
-0.1754425019,
-0.1586717367,
-0.1249849126,
-0.2617973089,
0.4156495035,
0.5052595735,
0.4102963507,
-0.7410097718,
-0.1925172955,
0.0772018284,
-0.0057551777,
0.3963367641,
1.1178774834,
-0.9519250393,
0.4726920724,
0.662879765,
0.5468843579,
0.7943229079,
0.5521456003,
0.392296195,
-1.1446354389,
0.2415428907,
0.4652310908,
0.1475809067,
0.3564324677,
-0.3671354949,
0.2898652852,
0.3281169534,
-0.4359768331,
-0.7737822533,
0.1884366274,
-1.2024023533,
-0.4443799257,
1.4555145502,
0.0165576525,
-0.1118659973,
-0.2932541966,
-0.4998548329,
0.7283934951,
-0.5326682925,
0.8123852015,
0.2600202858,
-0.3237775266,
-0.0542369187,
-0.3952191472,
0.5488994122,
0.3203955293,
-0.7847560644,
0.2201896906,
0.6926802993,
0.0707587451,
-0.1356954128,
0.4353713393,
0.0707241595,
0.0996087492,
-0.2228940725,
-0.2637877464,
-0.1437766999,
-0.3707194328,
-0.0719879568,
0.3270782232,
-0.1876698434,
-0.0638960153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08066v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08066v1
|
MSciNLI: A Diverse Benchmark for Scientific Natural Language Inference
| 2024-04-11T18:12:12 | 2024-04-11T18:12:12 |
Mobashir Sadat, Cornelia Caragea
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The task of scientific Natural Language Inference (NLI) involves predicting
the semantic relation between two sentences extracted from research articles.
This task was recently proposed along with a new dataset called SciNLI derived
from papers published in the computational linguistics domain. In this paper,
we aim to introduce diversity in the scientific NLI task and present MSciNLI, a
dataset containing 132,320 sentence pairs extracted from five new scientific
domains. The availability of multiple domains makes it possible to study domain
shift for scientific NLI. We establish strong baselines on MSciNLI by
fine-tuning Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) and prompting Large Language
Models (LLMs). The highest Macro F1 scores of PLM and LLM baselines are 77.21%
and 51.77%, respectively, illustrating that MSciNLI is challenging for both
types of models. Furthermore, we show that domain shift degrades the
performance of scientific NLI models which demonstrates the diverse
characteristics of different domains in our dataset. Finally, we use both
scientific NLI datasets in an intermediate task transfer learning setting and
show that they can improve the performance of downstream tasks in the
scientific domain. We make our dataset and code available on Github.
|
[
-0.187863633,
-0.372970134,
0.1578003317,
0.5145526528,
0.0613180511,
0.3038055003,
-0.383715868,
-0.7795166373,
-0.083070226,
0.3754165471,
-0.6340413094,
-0.4467895031,
-0.6354804635,
0.6955653429,
-0.0216232818,
1.0460150242,
0.2081129998,
0.1948840022,
-0.274695456,
-0.1511052996,
-0.0752022862,
0.0402172059,
-0.4037491083,
-0.116593115,
0.6087363958,
0.2560213804,
0.403960526,
0.4108195901,
0.6856129169,
0.1591086239,
-0.0812877938,
0.474447459,
-0.4773584008,
0.0145984869,
-0.24297598,
-0.5861179829,
-0.0671264008,
-0.0472863391,
0.7934364676,
1.1858887672,
0.3709056675,
0.1829303503,
0.0642558411,
0.5839545131,
-0.6529160142,
0.0901783183,
-0.731893003,
-0.0147490771,
-0.3360809982,
-0.04016966,
-0.747820437,
-0.3637740016,
0.3197008073,
-0.8242923617,
0.2478723079,
0.0815774277,
0.8071207404,
0.3338427544,
-0.5646802783,
0.010582014,
-0.4810776114,
1.2214910984,
-0.9301887155,
0.3766816556,
0.173101306,
0.272017628,
-0.2254929841,
-0.6320303679,
-0.4499933124,
-0.4212552011,
-0.0050305072,
0.0818497241,
-0.1478257775,
-0.2576879263,
0.1388527006,
-0.0624136925,
-0.7791742086,
0.1863502115,
-0.5478689075,
0.1900826544,
0.7337268591,
-0.0069142906,
0.1681396961,
0.0537487417,
0.0207478628,
-0.1087583825,
-0.8109559417,
-0.1459033936,
0.202631548,
0.5817371607,
0.0969161987,
0.5427829623,
-0.080961369,
0.8349815011,
-0.1981259137,
-0.0406255648,
0.4876914024,
-0.6789280772,
-0.2684980333,
0.206036821,
0.7636290789,
0.469504118,
0.3277001679,
-0.2827347815,
0.3644522429,
0.1984176338,
0.16393812,
-0.6882833242,
-0.1508307606,
-0.0804088339,
-0.3010333776,
-0.1436251402,
0.1708123982,
-0.5670551062,
-0.1570989192,
-0.3889257312,
-0.1285417378,
-0.5222019553,
-0.1275114864,
-0.0867782161,
-0.0397642255,
-0.0964133963,
0.0949270278,
-0.5583691597,
0.4450813234,
0.8166220784,
0.943682909,
-0.7255370021,
-0.3448938727,
-0.2592011094,
0.2948492169,
-0.1509772837,
0.5430770516,
-0.693162322,
-0.3736365736,
-0.2511206865,
0.0617394894,
-0.7039903402,
-0.5658953786,
0.6744362116,
-0.3873600662,
0.1838955581,
-0.2350444794,
-0.6954136491,
-0.0723810345,
-0.1319584697,
-0.7322196364,
1.0376977921,
-0.1051254347,
-1.1657705307,
0.3880259097,
-0.9497672915,
-0.4757568836,
0.0691913068,
0.203590855,
-0.0986594632,
0.108555004,
-0.1097307429,
0.1340024173,
-0.2527555525,
0.7386817932,
-0.6027139425,
-0.1971717179,
0.3335259855,
-0.345069468,
0.8875077963,
0.5429484248,
-0.2186061591,
-0.0757925734,
-1.0387314558,
0.0397282727,
-0.3918016851,
-0.0056580538,
-0.6131705046,
0.0301406235,
0.3979153931,
0.1987207532,
-0.0496401042,
-0.8597192764,
0.1199142337,
-0.5666013956,
0.4812257886,
0.3322534561,
0.0400835536,
0.2634709477,
-0.0923098847,
0.0793224126,
0.0075855246,
0.099320218,
0.390955925,
-0.7923990488,
-0.331181258,
-0.3632176816,
0.4129801691,
0.6363713741,
-0.6030796766,
0.396589458,
-0.4802695215,
-0.4128292799,
-0.9366681576,
-0.0434037037,
0.1523179412,
0.5426071882,
0.3880091608,
0.1774578243,
-0.6757435799,
-1.1127890348,
-0.5377230644,
-0.0112010697,
-0.1813315153,
0.2010915875,
0.7000581622,
-0.2375739366,
1.1722067595,
-0.2373658717,
0.2100888342,
-0.0205520429,
0.563729167,
0.5104577541,
0.5349618196,
0.5451012254,
-0.9944357276,
-0.5454117656,
0.25506863,
-0.7902941704,
-0.2702344954,
-0.155412972,
-0.2305436283,
0.0330868252,
0.2538003027,
-0.5693336725,
0.231416598,
0.5195521116,
-0.335098654,
0.5357240438,
0.1363032758,
0.3087749779,
-1.0659842491,
0.4081479013,
0.3729764521,
-0.011223454,
-1.0121423006,
0.0285561178,
-0.1421666294,
0.397305429,
-0.5681576729,
0.4206043482,
-0.1810062677,
0.0603260286,
-0.2826316357,
-0.0814093053,
-0.1284121126,
0.0943357348,
0.1396558881,
0.8893329501,
0.45145154,
-0.5928938985,
-0.4018437564,
0.197742641,
-0.311761409,
0.1897773594,
-0.6839305758,
-0.22720249,
0.0769286007,
0.1549106836,
-0.7047373652,
0.0058159884,
-0.0728570223,
-0.2170006186,
0.1722759306,
0.2747348845,
-0.3734966218,
-0.3383069634,
-0.1192251742,
0.4577848911,
0.067463778,
-0.4897915721,
0.2267488837,
0.1593342721,
-0.2338139266,
-0.6073897481,
-0.7392563224,
0.335364759,
-0.2250187546,
-0.5056337714,
0.548202455,
-0.3985367119,
-0.5589939952,
0.114720732,
-0.0780102909,
-0.2765887678,
0.150671646,
0.2845684886,
0.4248546064,
-0.4471646249,
-0.1405244619,
0.3126366436,
0.141471684,
0.1769526005,
-0.3990600109,
-0.2099448293,
-0.1843895465,
-0.0752107725,
-0.361458838,
0.4311867952,
0.5929268599,
0.0613456629,
0.6937006712,
0.4203869998,
-0.3413999081,
-0.0353162475,
-0.326431632,
0.0094507542,
-0.3761588037,
0.3337830901,
-0.4265143871,
-1.1862767935,
0.1391253471,
-0.2492362857,
0.3372119963,
0.635607183,
0.2254676372,
0.0741631836,
0.9618420601,
0.6344433427,
-0.2334973365,
-0.0669252649,
-0.1235677153,
0.2667826414,
-0.6964356899,
-0.0713139996,
-0.7771620154,
-0.1299067885,
-0.6421666741,
-0.4833272398,
0.146464631,
0.0431608744,
-0.1246492192,
0.3361183703,
-0.4048906565,
0.4738025367,
0.4676364362,
-0.1741681546,
0.4184840918,
0.0015840397,
-0.0588813722,
-0.4077312946,
-0.7093420625,
-0.6622906923,
0.8823282123,
0.1237578914,
0.3236157894,
-0.0319890268,
0.5044202209,
0.2990982234,
0.6549893022,
-0.2829577923,
0.4209372401,
-0.509147644,
-0.3434745073,
-0.2417804897,
-0.6759949923,
-0.7533146143,
0.3903672099,
-0.1500433087,
-0.6595208645,
0.4200661182,
-0.2916765511,
-0.0526781268,
0.2521205842,
-0.6534264684,
0.7637873292,
-0.0991187543,
-0.3392320871,
-0.1421317905,
-1.031370759,
0.6963058114,
-0.2129247934,
0.3508715928,
-0.3999049366,
0.1640591025,
0.6534978151,
-0.0996313021,
0.9752679467,
-0.00430523,
0.2039539516,
0.0294079725,
-0.0639344156,
0.1274546683,
0.2421046942,
-0.5238286257,
0.2749456465,
0.1053510979,
-0.4133855104,
-0.4691875279,
0.9395444989,
-0.7760198116,
-0.2210672945,
-0.4448964,
-0.7810799479,
-0.3110361397,
0.1416783482,
0.3009688258,
-0.1499340832,
-0.5250407457,
0.0382544138,
0.6624422669,
0.0444008037,
0.5648964643,
0.3967986405,
0.2697152793,
-0.2526461184,
0.8182995915,
-0.2469617277,
0.1791745424,
0.4712110758,
0.0120724319,
-0.2029911131,
-0.6227518916,
-0.1475795209,
0.3329143226,
-0.4025740623,
-0.1429853141,
-0.8959076405,
-0.2016238719,
-0.5026813149,
-0.1702296436,
-0.1961841136,
-0.5913926959,
-0.5731929541,
-0.1275764853,
0.414655596,
0.7318860888,
0.177821666,
-0.1159983501,
-0.7514360547,
0.0643238127,
-0.0912167504,
-0.0769492164,
-0.2857017815,
-0.5079370737,
-0.0719608441,
0.136953488,
0.1632844508,
-0.581605494,
0.6512461901,
0.921004355,
0.627278626,
0.4023409486,
0.103786245,
0.7123319507,
-0.7041178346,
0.7665223479,
0.2878581882,
-0.7143231034,
0.4589163959,
-0.1013383195,
0.4829175174,
1.062440753,
0.7815093398,
-0.3948494196,
-0.8481160998,
-0.3103326261,
-0.6700887084,
0.2859974205,
0.2009848803,
-0.2784516513,
-0.1785462946,
0.2421992719,
0.6157456636,
0.174639225,
-0.6191611886,
-0.1252863109,
-0.1703667194,
-0.4239101112,
-0.2945201695,
0.1951782107,
-0.1397564411,
-0.5416728854,
0.7088060975,
-0.5257634521,
0.0014104826,
0.2166510075,
-0.4080868959,
0.0756446049,
0.1785563529,
0.8331412077,
0.8570626974,
-0.2370150238,
0.2892587483,
0.262300998,
-0.5957872868,
-0.2175267339,
0.1914804727,
-0.1819170564,
0.3014836609,
0.6049038768,
0.9342061281,
0.4431222379,
-0.749828577,
0.0958628953,
0.0433419347,
-0.4232010841,
0.2411928773,
-0.0992023945,
-0.0059269047,
0.0024579491,
0.552044034,
0.4376361668,
0.4877721667,
-0.1964306235,
0.5094802976,
0.136832878,
-0.2484037727,
-0.5971759558,
0.7739127278,
-0.0823207125,
-0.0148791773,
0.442971468,
-0.1189951226,
-0.1427962929,
0.5217308998,
0.7386610508,
0.7084514499,
-0.2056546509,
0.5021626353,
0.4830829799,
0.1953680962,
0.0169350822,
0.089807637,
0.1134248599,
-0.5506640673,
-0.8128811717,
-0.6416702271,
-0.400945127,
-0.1708736569,
-0.7394662499,
-0.0773970708,
-0.0830815583,
-0.0199386403,
0.5486539602,
0.0362453461,
-0.4802801609,
-0.0208190903,
0.1166922301,
1.1048241854,
-1.1938780546,
1.1436675787,
0.5707451701,
0.1136369258,
-0.1489893943,
-0.2422050089,
0.0413123667,
-0.2644622028,
1.1464189291,
0.2285199612,
-0.2242105454,
-0.1516441405,
-0.7542722225,
-0.8880172968,
0.7651885152,
0.3099264801,
-0.7501246929,
0.1735507399,
0.3274267316,
0.8049640059,
-0.7922824621,
0.326924026,
0.7513942719,
0.6428876519,
0.1416504234,
-0.7480335832,
0.0426559784,
-0.562918067,
0.1179512516,
-0.1199918017,
-0.2267380059,
0.6181827784,
-0.1212771386,
-0.1124570593,
0.1276534796,
0.9354090095,
0.6775191426,
0.6537191868,
0.4695519507,
0.2881635427,
0.93273139,
0.0346498601,
0.8420589566,
-0.2633368075,
0.0953156278,
1.0698685646,
-0.83387357,
1.0146850348,
0.7821759582,
-0.0910925046,
0.5006956458,
0.7405958176,
-0.2995063663,
0.6063358188,
0.2264035046,
-0.5074378252,
-0.0700308904,
-0.4297610819,
-0.2857834101,
0.0903538913,
0.4145086706,
-0.1571200043,
-0.1852179468,
0.3787633777,
-0.090904668,
0.0949402824,
0.0954423472,
0.3634485304,
0.0533150323,
-0.6911253333,
0.4803337753,
-0.2424183786,
0.7466551661,
-0.5269588232,
-0.165283516,
-0.0641975626,
-0.0438393094,
-0.2568172812,
-0.5200551748,
0.4002156258,
0.0012790461,
-0.419285506,
-0.0786134973,
0.5150034428,
-0.5659627318,
-0.7653342485,
0.228766039,
0.2634908259,
0.2294198871,
0.2776796818,
-0.7684546709,
-0.1018358245,
0.1502517909,
-0.1485901475,
0.377142936,
0.2387349904,
-0.3795583248,
0.5510313511,
0.74164325,
0.0725694969,
0.2997833788,
0.335146457,
0.7558392286,
-0.4389335215,
-0.2459366173,
-0.4930236936,
0.2558714449,
-0.4109437168,
-0.5682501197,
0.9584288597,
0.7927666903,
0.5202733874,
-0.371647656,
0.8140112758,
0.0020628672,
0.4376112819,
-0.3940903842,
0.5197799802,
-0.214708969,
0.0292158239,
-0.1371278018,
-0.8003048897,
-0.810305357,
0.3053937554,
-0.0927998349,
-0.2948767841,
0.925396502,
0.6925700307,
-0.0214617718,
0.5224146247,
0.051571276,
0.2674735487,
0.1093668491,
0.5301645398,
0.6424638629,
-0.2551950812,
0.0925597847,
-0.094073005,
-0.1720140278,
0.0993214324,
-0.8815250993,
-0.7381035686,
-0.3135468066,
-0.825653851,
0.0608627796,
0.4431084394,
0.8152865767,
0.8632382751,
-1.4096425772,
-0.4375846982,
-0.3310669661,
-0.0144958179,
-0.6403076053,
-0.281870991,
0.2994960546,
-0.3847221434,
-0.7787476778,
1.1124615669,
0.2630080283,
-0.2968711853,
0.0922677964,
0.023967037,
-0.8302429318,
-0.0796102062,
0.5753543973,
0.4662103653,
-0.7415181994,
-0.066601187,
0.2688584328,
-0.0073048975,
0.0052135824,
0.7934161425,
-0.4378940761,
0.1185918078,
0.3834356964,
0.7995998263,
0.5143474936,
-0.2711703479,
0.6577585936,
-0.8285964131,
-0.0259267185,
0.2812023461,
0.0554035455,
0.2260170579,
-0.2686452568,
0.7700711489,
0.3554189801,
-0.4693684578,
-0.9904613495,
-0.1526391953,
-1.0550404787,
-0.5397344232,
0.822496295,
-0.1244955733,
-0.5595018864,
-0.3843399286,
0.2111352682,
0.0682124421,
-0.1648201197,
0.4694449306,
0.5811885595,
-0.1129899174,
-0.1091402769,
-0.8256306648,
0.5987485051,
0.5608054399,
-0.8515617251,
-0.1383886933,
0.2154125273,
0.1937743872,
0.3268800974,
-0.0221508685,
0.0648966953,
0.0705547929,
-0.1829985678,
0.1820300668,
0.1586644351,
-0.4247133732,
-0.2736921608,
0.2327984869,
-0.2366369814,
-0.0004538365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07989v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07989v2
|
Any2Point: Empowering Any-modality Large Models for Efficient 3D Understanding
| 2024-04-11T17:59:45 | 2024-05-31T01:36:53 |
Yiwen Tang, Ray Zhang, Jiaming Liu, Zoey Guo, Dong Wang, Zhigang Wang, Bin Zhao, Shanghang Zhang, Peng Gao, Hongsheng Li, Xuelong Li
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Large foundation models have recently emerged as a prominent focus of
interest, attaining superior performance in widespread scenarios. Due to the
scarcity of 3D data, many efforts have been made to adapt pre-trained
transformers from vision to 3D domains. However, such 2D-to-3D approaches are
still limited, due to the potential loss of spatial geometries and high
computation cost. More importantly, their frameworks are mainly designed for 2D
models, lacking a general any-to-3D paradigm. In this paper, we introduce
Any2Point, a parameter-efficient method to empower any-modality large models
(vision, language, audio) for 3D understanding. Given a frozen transformer from
any source modality, we propose a 3D-to-any (1D or 2D) virtual projection
strategy that correlates the input 3D points to the original 1D or 2D positions
within the source modality. This mechanism enables us to assign each 3D token
with a positional encoding paired with the pre-trained model, which avoids 3D
geometry loss caused by the true projection and better motivates the
transformer for 3D learning with 1D/2D positional priors. Then, within each
transformer block, we insert an any-to-3D guided adapter module for
parameter-efficient fine-tuning. The adapter incorporates prior spatial
knowledge from the source modality to guide the local feature aggregation of 3D
tokens, compelling the semantic adaption of any-modality transformers. We
conduct extensive experiments to showcase the effectiveness and efficiency of
our method. Code and models are released at
https://github.com/Ivan-Tang-3D/Any2Point.
|
[
-0.2545390427,
-0.5189247727,
0.8575849533,
0.0498043634,
-0.2916218638,
-0.789159894,
0.0507409461,
-0.4060533047,
-0.0504699461,
0.6049991846,
-0.1963684708,
-0.5428756475,
-0.3789396882,
-0.1318159103,
-0.3122444153,
0.3862935603,
-0.0532321781,
-0.081791319,
-0.0686648041,
-0.1611590236,
-0.2941778302,
-0.2205939144,
-0.7070037127,
-0.1417935193,
0.363303721,
0.6589455605,
0.7359646559,
1.0391572714,
0.1300709993,
0.3089188933,
0.0639111996,
-0.0848199725,
-0.7735759616,
0.0052334336,
-0.4661512077,
-0.6436623335,
-0.4024124742,
-0.1594979465,
0.6806713343,
0.8885139227,
-0.0338619985,
0.0699725002,
-0.1042199209,
0.5438243747,
-0.7200021744,
-0.0574108735,
-0.6088855267,
0.3355067074,
0.0540787727,
-0.1730117351,
-0.2274426371,
-0.1240134388,
0.3050718606,
-1.0586431026,
0.3882904947,
-0.0350030921,
0.5581238866,
0.3730420768,
-0.652336657,
0.2849578857,
-0.6618337035,
0.6253910661,
-0.1909147799,
1.0019484758,
0.2101397663,
0.6684235334,
0.0694414899,
-0.6965450048,
-0.4661512077,
0.1371849626,
-0.0804561004,
0.4389180839,
-0.0419130251,
-0.0322288275,
0.1805678904,
0.0390603915,
-0.6779330969,
0.1796206087,
-0.2318861485,
0.0414903834,
0.3346918225,
0.0038134276,
-0.2064064443,
-0.5685808063,
-0.6970730424,
-0.470549345,
-0.4940141141,
0.1378500611,
-0.116552569,
0.2615422606,
-0.4689469934,
0.686932385,
0.1217495278,
1.0003101826,
0.2894687057,
-0.1514734477,
-0.1399273872,
-0.2280312181,
-0.2466466725,
-0.063765958,
0.4285466671,
0.1640661061,
-0.0929716378,
-0.093006596,
-0.0730525181,
-0.4296155274,
0.4651151299,
-0.9186102152,
-0.3898300827,
0.0517586656,
-0.5514068007,
-0.0347505659,
0.080863446,
-0.7037313581,
-0.8387423754,
-0.3074040413,
0.5378085971,
-0.4215477407,
-0.56388551,
0.3036514819,
-0.2494834214,
0.4099302292,
0.5200889707,
-0.8844287992,
-0.1496463418,
0.4806749225,
0.8854108453,
-0.1021884009,
-0.1802278459,
-0.1577900946,
0.4758269191,
-0.5266245008,
0.8039906621,
-0.3274866939,
-0.6035758257,
-0.0860997587,
-0.3728247881,
-0.2286427319,
-0.3860752881,
0.4315243661,
-0.3314578831,
0.2344007045,
-0.1232282072,
-0.2245629579,
-0.5806564093,
0.2923953831,
-0.685793817,
0.477922976,
0.6278225183,
-0.3359553218,
0.3767211139,
-0.8662701845,
-0.2324587554,
-0.244052574,
-0.6361867189,
-0.2261816561,
0.3394702077,
0.1790477484,
0.5794866085,
-0.4950911105,
-0.1476017237,
-0.2453694493,
-0.0891197771,
-0.1969901919,
-0.4982272387,
0.6208859682,
-0.02553818,
-0.2658491433,
0.1244321018,
-0.8827975988,
-0.3530524671,
0.3294003606,
-0.1563467234,
-0.0174036734,
-0.1227372959,
0.3207193911,
0.3790440559,
0.0680447444,
-0.3372336924,
0.0883656591,
-0.3278588951,
0.3088886142,
0.4748632908,
-0.1740119308,
0.9254618883,
-0.1452467144,
0.4893577397,
-0.1604493111,
0.1706613302,
-0.3238019049,
-0.2784962058,
-0.4765164256,
-0.8072521091,
-0.0117063113,
0.2920490503,
-0.734906435,
0.4911625683,
-0.799916923,
-0.4416972399,
-0.2374488115,
0.0336781107,
0.0909213424,
0.7300068736,
0.3722376823,
0.1291974038,
-0.5041754246,
-0.7561481595,
0.1289509535,
-0.1571504921,
-0.8289753199,
0.3426300883,
0.1656231433,
0.2003064454,
1.1522666216,
-0.3920695484,
-0.7074322701,
-0.1701435745,
-0.3216799498,
0.2536514699,
0.5919815898,
0.7124709487,
-1.0616544485,
-0.2287193537,
0.1186828911,
-0.874748826,
0.2300181389,
-0.1775502861,
-0.2908757925,
-0.031273704,
0.5152271986,
-0.6593204141,
0.3535169363,
0.72002244,
-0.722471118,
-0.0074065998,
0.1384395063,
0.0682461485,
-1.178935647,
0.2958391905,
-0.1174310222,
-0.2536555231,
-0.7322645783,
-0.0360569656,
-0.0073225065,
-0.4655866027,
-0.5668563843,
0.6892870069,
-0.2299658954,
-0.0317440256,
-0.053614933,
0.6319631934,
0.49635607,
0.4782259166,
0.5393199921,
0.0820471272,
0.6208981872,
-0.3529833555,
0.2346623689,
0.5975959897,
-0.3464883268,
0.9101874232,
-0.5145602822,
0.0648929775,
0.0603458621,
0.4340285063,
-1.0157583952,
-0.1243638769,
0.1780842096,
-0.4231154919,
0.2565872669,
-0.3632218242,
-0.1900212765,
0.0985066369,
-0.2280175537,
0.7188248634,
0.0791994333,
-1.1447793245,
1.4300777912,
0.0102668041,
0.2725437284,
-0.0961873531,
-0.5860459208,
-0.0970575437,
-0.0615719818,
-0.8891088367,
0.4330216944,
0.2182421684,
0.1463638693,
0.0588735268,
-0.4658869803,
0.1069691852,
-0.1508946121,
0.4190684855,
0.2037488222,
-0.3504427671,
-0.1508131176,
-0.0449559949,
-0.5238305926,
-0.0529492162,
-0.3726677597,
0.3329340518,
0.2542400956,
-0.4157207608,
-0.2216338217,
0.4748917222,
0.8601570129,
-0.0770055205,
0.4084276855,
0.6176403761,
-0.4233336747,
-0.2056083828,
-0.5669334531,
-0.1589156538,
-0.4922624826,
0.8152559996,
-0.8780961037,
-0.841065228,
0.3076372445,
-0.2215413302,
0.1229426265,
0.230238378,
0.2396534532,
0.1406801641,
1.4326014519,
0.9092389941,
0.1387181431,
0.4579087794,
-0.6049592495,
0.4350149632,
-0.8444536328,
-0.5553842187,
-0.3669424951,
-0.4442468584,
-0.0363968052,
-0.7930764556,
0.699295938,
0.53606534,
-0.4169378281,
0.4249122143,
-0.4424830079,
0.3351449966,
0.2455522269,
0.0817453489,
0.192937538,
-0.0152991964,
-0.080171667,
0.2292494625,
-1.1671191454,
-0.0887399763,
0.773254931,
0.4352196753,
0.3719502985,
0.2765575945,
0.04474191,
-0.2527030408,
-0.0150581012,
-0.885438323,
0.3731001616,
-0.112005733,
-0.722638309,
-0.5773001909,
-0.3779467344,
-0.6610131264,
0.6104568839,
-0.4932923019,
-0.7449510694,
0.9311435223,
0.2816820741,
-0.4916435182,
0.7160807848,
-0.5625136495,
1.004478097,
-0.1970774829,
-0.2469488382,
-0.1085390598,
-0.4732248485,
0.3042796254,
-0.2458328754,
-0.09975335,
-0.0735613853,
-0.287166059,
0.4059736729,
-0.10750743,
0.6208561063,
-0.3549209237,
-0.4089600742,
-0.1211627796,
0.5058552027,
0.4149694741,
0.6066922545,
-0.3442083299,
0.5785734653,
0.1392247826,
-0.4713230431,
-0.9484480023,
0.6738032699,
-0.893899262,
-0.3946987092,
0.0982386023,
-0.7244695425,
-0.3614679873,
0.1399689764,
0.5485647321,
0.5526561141,
0.0316088423,
0.4203248322,
0.2329721749,
0.0364568867,
0.1649656892,
0.7598366737,
-0.1126186252,
-0.2441647798,
0.8448969126,
-0.3707653284,
0.0764465705,
0.7788210511,
0.1345583349,
-0.4836077988,
-0.2914569676,
-0.57470119,
0.0702883601,
-0.7648276091,
-0.4692622125,
-0.4470074773,
-0.0717370063,
-0.3733724058,
-0.9146748781,
-0.884737432,
-0.6123027802,
-0.2505995035,
-0.2032362968,
0.2929191291,
0.4530600607,
-0.4531320035,
0.2218679637,
-0.5073212385,
0.7353278995,
0.5612560511,
0.5121430755,
-0.0011755712,
-0.8043009639,
-0.0998509973,
0.0326516889,
-0.1242874414,
-0.4922946393,
0.0197788905,
0.2096958756,
0.2856736481,
1.2024798393,
-0.0419729762,
0.8122192025,
-0.4117071629,
0.7777119875,
0.502684772,
-1.0301640034,
0.4288133383,
-0.1950326115,
0.3669351637,
0.5082170963,
0.4975244999,
-0.2455849499,
0.2278689891,
-0.2524009347,
-0.7840410471,
0.8428490758,
0.0507098176,
-0.0256962236,
0.3039398491,
0.5720232129,
0.0889380202,
-0.2856985927,
-0.3256495595,
-0.273240149,
-0.8641253114,
0.0846471339,
-0.1925123185,
-0.0997036546,
-0.3453302979,
-0.4424141049,
0.218522653,
-0.1750533432,
0.3463658988,
0.1907917708,
-0.0259301644,
-0.2509761453,
-0.2208230197,
0.414383918,
0.9392749667,
-0.1377729326,
0.2656344771,
0.2893611491,
-0.3521053791,
-0.0364213958,
0.2198556215,
-0.0083299614,
0.0457464755,
0.390832305,
0.9333108068,
0.3586621583,
-0.4001387954,
0.669077754,
0.0737700909,
-0.5687910914,
-0.1496380121,
-0.145171687,
-0.2916660905,
0.590872407,
0.4403983653,
0.2581680119,
0.0881137177,
-0.21204862,
-0.0208862387,
0.22309196,
-0.7290964127,
-0.4183297753,
0.8673282862,
0.2703556418,
-0.1005330458,
0.6485096216,
0.2603449523,
-0.3047454059,
0.2176838517,
0.7297357321,
0.7857402563,
-0.3567075729,
0.1366336793,
0.4080478847,
-0.0518976748,
0.1294659078,
-0.123696208,
-0.4589556456,
-1.0018639565,
-0.4291574657,
-0.4828953743,
-0.2392189652,
0.0985876694,
-0.6237451434,
0.3981511295,
-0.4100437164,
0.137761265,
-0.1904908866,
-0.4111485779,
-0.739982307,
0.2755545378,
0.2967835665,
1.0003726482,
-0.6862398982,
0.6348424554,
0.6703386903,
-0.0386805236,
-0.7024724483,
-0.4218474329,
0.1230361387,
-0.8679561019,
0.2937306762,
-0.0665484518,
-0.3749314547,
0.326498121,
-0.2564814687,
-1.0132828951,
1.2603331804,
0.4284700453,
-0.4369271398,
-0.0648237094,
0.368175,
0.0665395111,
-0.2391543835,
0.312563926,
0.6939825416,
0.7626311779,
0.4979937375,
-0.5373881459,
0.2838279307,
-0.3247153163,
0.2924722731,
0.1994946301,
-0.1542315185,
0.3880622983,
-0.2951721549,
-0.2613607347,
0.2273920774,
0.6293718815,
0.2721161842,
-0.1207874939,
1.0246486664,
0.3655959368,
0.1267958581,
-0.0659642816,
0.9584984183,
-0.4087875783,
-0.0147112254,
0.7587695718,
-0.061535757,
0.7960829735,
0.5054109097,
0.2348093241,
0.0868589804,
0.3502485454,
-0.1287167966,
0.6347193122,
0.0490069687,
-0.0272879712,
-0.6536893249,
-0.0426892079,
-0.3886265755,
0.8827788234,
0.3944679797,
-0.0264199171,
-0.3534202874,
0.3055893183,
-0.1540488899,
0.1242995933,
-0.1729134768,
0.5574741364,
0.1873509139,
-0.2056609988,
0.8715811968,
0.0443815999,
0.3509567976,
-0.8194382787,
-0.2201480418,
-0.310208261,
0.016064046,
-0.365873009,
-0.3150237203,
0.133814618,
-0.2733975649,
-0.419139266,
-0.2719537616,
0.0767877698,
-0.3268388808,
-0.4415612817,
0.324059695,
0.2784034312,
-0.093271248,
-0.4477170706,
-0.4845322967,
0.004870702,
-0.2859167457,
-0.3390358984,
0.2721832097,
0.5491149426,
0.1248435229,
0.3243218064,
0.638276577,
-0.0125948852,
-0.2638878822,
0.1115170121,
0.7841690779,
-0.3959392011,
-0.3913999796,
-0.2353874594,
0.5229182243,
0.0567334816,
-0.4801175892,
0.6953417063,
0.5939671993,
0.92160815,
0.0550522804,
0.4577545822,
-0.1566248089,
0.373953253,
-0.572879374,
0.6930227876,
-0.8595141768,
0.2820050418,
0.0385058522,
-1.4350858927,
-0.7064699531,
1.0011632442,
-0.2679850757,
0.0920693725,
0.61423105,
0.8834100366,
-0.358684212,
-0.133313179,
0.82916224,
0.3833112121,
0.3353056312,
0.4944576025,
0.6645827293,
-0.2925016284,
0.9126651883,
-0.3920864761,
-0.312862128,
-0.0616107732,
-0.8174472451,
-0.8364318609,
-0.5139437318,
-0.0862377286,
-0.1312815845,
-0.1063955277,
0.7461583614,
1.0929011106,
-0.6932972074,
-0.1931156218,
0.0023574308,
-0.0673929453,
-0.2608956397,
-0.1443327218,
0.7310857773,
0.1829633713,
-0.7028957605,
0.7417712808,
0.4007810354,
-0.2938257754,
-0.155014053,
0.0488268547,
0.2033227235,
0.0222417675,
0.9120977521,
0.4432208538,
-0.5428084135,
-0.5387219787,
-0.0359762907,
0.1959063113,
0.0536410511,
0.9437128305,
-0.5761595368,
0.6390656233,
0.5320546031,
0.3346426487,
0.7069213986,
0.1324805319,
0.7861047983,
-0.4308263063,
0.3350587189,
0.1895061731,
0.2937701046,
0.4068253934,
-0.078900516,
0.4841042757,
-0.1457790732,
-0.2040277719,
-0.4565922618,
0.3992110491,
-1.1530920267,
-0.3708082438,
1.173196435,
-0.0953572839,
-0.0101105496,
-0.2170925587,
-0.2110523432,
0.1270171702,
-0.036538735,
0.9168072939,
-0.3615045547,
-0.0667969286,
-0.2093993574,
-0.4045525491,
0.5747861266,
0.3911350071,
-0.433591187,
-0.2335474491,
0.3196366131,
-0.0176335517,
0.2253000736,
0.1961409152,
-0.3184859157,
0.3206051886,
0.0542058013,
0.0900654495,
-0.324555248,
-0.5799818039,
-0.5921971202,
0.3454722762,
-0.2692815363,
-0.2183182836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07982v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07982v3
|
Language Imbalance Can Boost Cross-lingual Generalisation
| 2024-04-11T17:58:05 | 2024-05-13T13:30:35 |
Anton Schäfer, Shauli Ravfogel, Thomas Hofmann, Tiago Pimentel, Imanol Schlag
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7
|
Multilinguality is crucial for extending recent advancements in language
modelling to diverse linguistic communities. To maintain high performance while
representing multiple languages, multilingual models ideally align
representations, allowing what is learned in one language to generalise to
others. Prior research has emphasised the importance of parallel data and
shared vocabulary elements as key factors for such alignment. In this study, we
investigate an unintuitive novel driver of cross-lingual generalisation:
language imbalance. In controlled experiments on perfectly equivalent cloned
languages, we observe that the existence of a predominant language during
training boosts the performance of less frequent languages and leads to
stronger alignment of model representations across languages. Furthermore, we
find that this trend is amplified with scale: with large enough models or long
enough training, we observe that bilingual training data with a 90/10 language
split yields better performance on both languages than a balanced 50/50 split.
Building on these insights, we design training schemes that can improve
performance in all cloned languages, even without altering the training data.
As we extend our analysis to real languages, we find that infrequent languages
still benefit from frequent ones, yet whether language imbalance causes
cross-lingual generalisation there is not conclusive.
|
[
-0.4691127241,
-0.3771201074,
-0.0865515769,
0.6103087664,
-0.0866766721,
0.4286817014,
-0.1550199687,
-0.6227182746,
0.6800587177,
0.2519651651,
-0.2434764057,
0.1274887174,
-0.6946397424,
0.0689422414,
-0.2399821132,
0.8435375094,
-0.0216421634,
0.6420431137,
-0.1561489701,
-0.9938026071,
-0.5633193254,
-0.7506004572,
-0.3271176517,
-0.8599762917,
0.4901284277,
0.3050283194,
0.8920086026,
0.7496180534,
0.1116284281,
0.2522999048,
0.1428546309,
0.1399965882,
-0.6483812332,
-0.0294904411,
-0.2207089812,
-0.6977192163,
-0.4294283986,
-0.3076516092,
1.0099204779,
1.0813189745,
-0.1514784545,
-0.1296376437,
0.2367918193,
0.6135928035,
-0.5765371323,
-0.153112188,
-0.6712676883,
-0.0405793078,
-0.42883268,
-0.1403146833,
-0.016462544,
0.2744393349,
-0.0186142046,
-0.8103737831,
0.2448901832,
0.1015604958,
0.9065542221,
-0.1287193596,
-0.3635319173,
-0.1372805089,
-0.5504655242,
0.9571756124,
-0.4011578262,
0.4238092005,
-0.0916014612,
-0.0031505493,
0.4448142946,
0.0400526896,
-0.5517941117,
0.0938002244,
-0.1019741893,
-0.1016011164,
-0.1499951929,
-0.2495923787,
0.2575063407,
0.4903304279,
-0.6614249349,
0.4431233406,
-0.2978476882,
-0.2426095456,
0.2688845396,
0.0608678721,
0.869758606,
0.2516421676,
-0.3618158996,
-0.1843320429,
-0.8896806836,
-0.0018709406,
0.7051767111,
0.3214564621,
-0.2532331347,
0.5613183975,
0.0047819857,
0.7503612638,
0.1081977263,
-0.0608021989,
0.556722343,
-0.6018064022,
0.2201389223,
0.2142800391,
0.5801181197,
0.4397284389,
0.876124084,
-0.1940055192,
-0.0231805071,
0.0879113749,
0.1503428072,
-0.6344573498,
-0.050177414,
-0.1722131371,
-0.0644960403,
-0.1253232956,
0.1156306565,
-0.5052449703,
-0.0111860186,
-0.3198829591,
0.183982268,
-0.3338824213,
-0.7041031718,
0.1308532953,
-0.3912891746,
0.2206593305,
0.0016221137,
-1.3535279036,
0.2508564591,
0.8133078814,
0.7729136348,
-0.3773878813,
-0.8810327649,
-0.4005010128,
0.3048399389,
-0.4401392937,
0.5313661695,
-0.5320141912,
-0.0725696161,
-0.0322973244,
0.1340976059,
-0.328315258,
-0.9215363264,
-0.090488784,
-0.3540017605,
0.2940064073,
-0.4136035442,
-0.22295928,
0.0651693791,
0.1336181164,
-0.7954300642,
0.9016466141,
0.1725142002,
-0.9703463912,
0.8013215661,
-0.1025530994,
-0.7397672534,
-0.0067933579,
-0.2182405591,
-0.4108218551,
0.1453073919,
0.2431821227,
-0.0054626297,
-0.1733842343,
0.1702639163,
-0.5357010365,
-0.4214739501,
0.1384580731,
-0.2757020295,
0.8351231217,
0.0757186636,
-0.3680326045,
-0.2064923942,
-0.2129187435,
0.0026640706,
-0.0297050327,
-0.1491289735,
-0.8258687854,
-0.3672751188,
0.0927240327,
0.2487460077,
0.2028592676,
-0.5527777076,
0.1437760293,
-0.4196662605,
0.0811474472,
0.4812216163,
-0.3483920693,
0.8543756604,
-0.6808332801,
0.6826372147,
0.4311598539,
-0.2801655829,
-0.0070302994,
-0.5367677808,
-0.5472260714,
-0.3642574549,
0.3790794611,
0.7740114927,
-0.4961905181,
-0.0321274251,
-0.7034118176,
-0.0996676385,
-1.0748487711,
0.7794461846,
0.5552492142,
0.0514954515,
0.2166195661,
-0.5390226245,
-0.4250472784,
-1.2464878559,
-0.5720992684,
0.0885523483,
0.0992381349,
0.1430399716,
-0.0080486666,
-0.3496317863,
0.8025273681,
0.0182861034,
-0.1130777225,
-0.5040883422,
0.1854407042,
-0.1608572602,
0.7017685771,
0.9694967866,
-0.8381091952,
-0.7462697029,
0.5479562879,
-0.7261609435,
-0.4596484303,
-0.1448498368,
-0.0497913063,
0.328181535,
0.4177417755,
-0.2920260429,
-0.065605022,
0.7824739218,
-0.0274610817,
0.1536793262,
-0.2582935691,
0.0991116837,
-0.8666424751,
0.0497527197,
-0.1054036841,
-0.1458998919,
-0.579026103,
0.1209078431,
0.2070987523,
-0.0246393289,
-0.3601679206,
0.7193075418,
-0.5803009868,
-0.0133572705,
-0.3574090004,
0.088244848,
0.005068609,
0.2977314591,
-0.0900610983,
0.6773602962,
0.7107753158,
-0.3042025864,
0.1085023135,
-0.1320109814,
-0.1660789698,
0.6471720338,
-0.5577311516,
-0.4034463763,
-0.1354177892,
-0.1530581713,
-0.8098962903,
-0.2370204777,
-0.1789246202,
-0.2697055042,
0.7038709521,
-0.0988458991,
-0.4229727387,
-0.2519137263,
-0.1563146859,
0.9600942135,
0.2765141129,
-0.6741303802,
0.5944917798,
0.5133075714,
-0.0705305338,
-0.900847435,
-0.9943485856,
-0.1226913854,
-0.3564476073,
-0.7288938761,
0.2721128762,
0.0810425058,
-0.5375580788,
-0.0123309968,
-0.2383785099,
0.0193345733,
0.1542834938,
0.0096484786,
-0.1252601743,
-0.3750676811,
-0.0258708708,
0.0930027962,
0.0345557369,
-0.1694268584,
-0.5087421536,
0.7550150752,
-0.0234871209,
-0.4554671645,
-0.0648894086,
0.6267673373,
0.9351797104,
-0.0998146906,
0.7385316491,
0.42132622,
-0.1013611332,
-0.2927462757,
-0.525822103,
0.0940380245,
-0.4082247913,
0.4146167338,
-0.4750818908,
-0.8485158682,
0.7845382094,
0.2575269639,
-0.0393256731,
0.3569052219,
0.5874909163,
0.1507558376,
1.0799325705,
0.7449157238,
-0.6043689847,
0.6148411036,
0.1065542549,
0.0704998672,
-0.4407230318,
0.0041011428,
-0.2039852738,
-0.3370863497,
-0.7871825099,
-0.5098145604,
0.0774497613,
0.1375601739,
0.1347814947,
0.1988641918,
-0.037868686,
0.6413528919,
0.5891854763,
-0.1502465457,
0.3243499994,
0.3524849713,
-0.5531538725,
-0.0815376639,
-1.0714088678,
-0.1088048518,
1.1868219376,
0.1421470493,
0.8719379902,
0.0325819701,
0.6705370545,
-0.0077102166,
0.3020071089,
-0.455901593,
0.1027695239,
-0.3664124906,
-0.6520518661,
-0.2378500998,
-0.5058780909,
-0.943092227,
0.6464554667,
-0.1013655663,
-0.2197912931,
0.224764511,
0.3294725418,
0.0479704589,
0.3707476556,
-0.8089319468,
1.0050514936,
-0.4908585846,
-0.6265447736,
-0.462362498,
-0.4247508049,
0.4032463431,
-0.4219231009,
0.4238260388,
0.1107040197,
0.0950824469,
0.4033824801,
-0.4302230179,
0.7249602675,
0.018878879,
-0.2771631181,
0.010413399,
-0.0881558582,
0.1421880573,
-0.0688657612,
0.1612960696,
0.3208660483,
-0.106821619,
-1.1286488771,
-0.5169119239,
1.0610785484,
-0.8910833597,
-0.568936646,
-0.3394864798,
-0.7634170055,
-0.2651225626,
0.1445201784,
0.4393730164,
0.2398179173,
-0.2973076403,
0.149326697,
0.5579375029,
-0.0360820033,
0.1638520211,
0.4566180408,
-0.4675383866,
-0.4527974129,
1.1147779226,
0.2172964811,
0.8829677701,
0.5099923015,
0.000889448,
0.0759330988,
-0.1278021485,
-0.6703443527,
0.31333974,
-0.3779582381,
0.2223333567,
-0.7870542407,
0.2037493736,
-0.5039601326,
-0.289945215,
-0.2885529399,
-0.7335059643,
0.169377476,
-0.0911719799,
-0.1370503157,
0.5598368645,
-0.4230352938,
0.4605884552,
-0.4486557543,
0.4048776329,
0.4849858284,
0.1846770942,
0.1206277311,
-0.300529778,
-0.4670424759,
0.3108822703,
-0.2330336124,
-0.5322941542,
0.3323374093,
0.3485125601,
0.883143723,
0.4947661161,
-0.5302129984,
0.8079622984,
-0.3405747414,
0.4276621938,
0.2234433591,
-0.7911798358,
-0.1826441586,
-0.4531227052,
0.6450977921,
0.4190101326,
0.3549505174,
-0.8428352475,
-0.7601923347,
-0.5057732463,
-0.778711915,
0.6577746272,
-0.0268943384,
0.1707487404,
0.0743590891,
-0.2307387143,
0.223579362,
0.1499260962,
-0.9665485024,
-0.2689545453,
-0.3299012184,
-0.1110104322,
-0.3305808902,
-0.2057615221,
-0.2313607186,
-0.2632770836,
0.4319844246,
-0.1823015958,
-0.0992396325,
-0.2924502194,
-0.4743263721,
-0.4759731293,
0.1314201504,
0.5281472802,
0.6740176082,
0.0930419415,
0.1370538622,
0.2203382552,
-0.4192277193,
0.1757578999,
-0.0539003871,
-0.1346418262,
0.1022956967,
0.521830976,
0.6212911606,
0.4582818747,
-0.6030748487,
0.5099737048,
0.2203285098,
-0.0647675842,
0.2224029303,
-0.0425017215,
0.2019053698,
-0.0034931428,
0.3205618858,
0.2258538753,
-0.4340600669,
-0.7139796615,
0.3192961514,
0.7963843942,
-0.0564898998,
-0.3716619611,
0.552425921,
0.1414833963,
0.0520345792,
0.4861190021,
-0.0094736852,
-0.8344346285,
0.756868124,
0.7186784744,
0.6928178072,
-0.3382393718,
0.0517532341,
0.1922243387,
0.5460492373,
-0.2248304486,
0.269993633,
-0.1303905547,
-0.9249334335,
-0.3117018938,
-0.7150998116,
-0.2787780166,
-0.2556169033,
-0.6828701496,
0.302058816,
-0.0339052528,
0.1488679796,
-0.1658346653,
-0.404340595,
-0.5493990779,
-0.0951030329,
0.348924309,
0.5829303265,
-1.2154836655,
1.0772982836,
0.7498303056,
-0.0539227836,
-0.601369679,
0.06315393,
-0.0743448138,
-1.0163775682,
0.7519847155,
0.2217234671,
0.0139356237,
-0.3298857808,
-0.0690689906,
-0.7946565747,
0.5478909612,
0.5161391497,
-0.6879302859,
-0.1413282901,
0.77372998,
0.7152360082,
-0.6348212361,
0.0112565169,
0.2446174026,
0.2427540123,
-0.1090720817,
-1.1879688501,
-0.1575615555,
-0.3320156634,
-0.1224507391,
0.5092908144,
-0.6253535151,
1.0143932104,
-0.0954206064,
0.001299905,
-0.1131722406,
0.4277408719,
0.2506456077,
0.2379560769,
0.3506598175,
0.8920987844,
0.6388410926,
0.0185930394,
0.9124340415,
-0.5963668823,
0.0517821349,
1.1169910431,
-0.2369536757,
0.4497999847,
0.6949948072,
0.1660476774,
0.431004107,
0.2302044034,
-0.0227889307,
0.4777725041,
0.0336582251,
-0.1504819393,
-0.3691617548,
0.0585354082,
-0.5804277062,
0.3481370807,
0.2749068439,
-0.377337873,
-0.4475951791,
0.3819927871,
0.0224343948,
0.0998017937,
-0.3648753762,
0.4902403355,
-0.0660971403,
-0.9149697423,
0.8400753736,
-0.3317196965,
0.9873877764,
-0.6213824153,
0.2834377587,
-0.4518812895,
0.4431488812,
-0.165250659,
-0.599647522,
0.3850469589,
-0.3364345133,
-0.3333588839,
-0.6562970281,
0.2371156961,
-0.9507140517,
-0.3390524387,
0.7608018517,
0.6261777878,
-0.1169358268,
-0.0012641703,
-0.5313044786,
-0.1373216063,
0.1483477056,
0.3594762087,
0.7491961718,
0.7351267934,
-0.4285936058,
0.5836443901,
0.4103654623,
0.3225349486,
0.5388746262,
0.0681358427,
0.7503959537,
-0.3818588853,
-0.3976539969,
-0.8692990541,
0.1878738105,
-0.0093668373,
-0.3857452571,
0.9396129847,
0.9110314846,
1.3290193081,
-0.0857830793,
0.6934556365,
0.1265248507,
0.4489764273,
-0.2351320386,
0.6615108252,
-0.9631006122,
0.191046834,
-0.2135557085,
-0.7928063273,
-0.2241039574,
0.1481567323,
-0.169160381,
-0.1849129945,
0.557218194,
0.8727385998,
-0.3937235773,
-0.3327708244,
0.300599277,
0.04845725,
0.0585409403,
0.4457974136,
0.7017316818,
-0.2067666352,
0.4811722338,
-0.3025106788,
-0.1965186596,
-0.0812230259,
-0.5294377208,
-0.9055569768,
-0.3235836029,
-0.1600067616,
-0.2042755485,
0.0983110592,
0.6067364812,
0.5274167657,
-0.9426230192,
-0.755848527,
-0.0926903561,
0.2448653877,
-0.397102356,
-0.2011769265,
-0.3150991499,
-0.5175098181,
-0.928557694,
0.1071173474,
0.2404063791,
0.2338056564,
-0.1365582198,
-0.0976567715,
-0.3417201936,
-0.1867056042,
0.3442560732,
0.6552324295,
-0.6764827967,
0.2204580307,
0.0457648709,
-0.3744621873,
0.2129927576,
1.0786082745,
-0.5881496668,
0.5845192671,
0.5503892899,
0.6493359208,
0.380789876,
0.053605549,
1.1428931952,
-0.8864257336,
0.564268589,
-0.0752064511,
0.5082028508,
0.5685743093,
-0.1160401627,
0.2685631514,
0.4985509217,
-0.2291004658,
-0.8102756739,
0.098753199,
-0.8112592697,
-0.2919321358,
1.1455640793,
0.1084128842,
-0.1146353483,
-0.0343578458,
-0.019711582,
0.0899274424,
-0.1386829168,
0.5923541784,
1.0706630945,
0.1397016346,
0.1268817186,
-0.2954609394,
0.333073467,
1.0183392763,
-0.3013782501,
0.1598006189,
0.2518357337,
0.5076277852,
0.3444249332,
0.2459866554,
-0.0988622606,
0.2270891815,
-0.076201342,
-0.1128879637,
0.4590287209,
-0.2336185873,
-0.4621076882,
0.2029790878,
0.0750954598,
0.0257563181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07981v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07981v1
|
Manipulating Large Language Models to Increase Product Visibility
| 2024-04-11T17:57:32 | 2024-04-11T17:57:32 |
Aounon Kumar, Himabindu Lakkaraju
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly being integrated into search
engines to provide natural language responses tailored to user queries.
Customers and end-users are also becoming more dependent on these models for
quick and easy purchase decisions. In this work, we investigate whether
recommendations from LLMs can be manipulated to enhance a product's visibility.
We demonstrate that adding a strategic text sequence (STS) -- a carefully
crafted message -- to a product's information page can significantly increase
its likelihood of being listed as the LLM's top recommendation. To understand
the impact of STS, we use a catalog of fictitious coffee machines and analyze
its effect on two target products: one that seldom appears in the LLM's
recommendations and another that usually ranks second. We observe that the
strategic text sequence significantly enhances the visibility of both products
by increasing their chances of appearing as the top recommendation. This
ability to manipulate LLM-generated search responses provides vendors with a
considerable competitive advantage and has the potential to disrupt fair market
competition. Just as search engine optimization (SEO) revolutionized how
webpages are customized to rank higher in search engine results, influencing
LLM recommendations could profoundly impact content optimization for AI-driven
search services. Code for our experiments is available at
https://github.com/aounon/llm-rank-optimizer.
|
[
-0.12699157,
-0.7013043165,
0.8517113924,
0.5692034364,
-0.4182513356,
0.3593006134,
-0.3326210678,
-0.7054623961,
0.2896111012,
0.7256013155,
-0.4404454231,
-0.7011860013,
-0.7373954654,
-0.1572075486,
-0.5852330923,
1.0560895205,
0.3561058044,
-0.1146848202,
-0.2096307725,
0.0215873439,
-0.5488596559,
-0.513363421,
-0.7338498235,
-0.1924452037,
0.9400894046,
0.3896501362,
1.0918587446,
0.7718474269,
0.6730453372,
0.4351756573,
-0.2758057714,
0.2985027432,
-0.6960168481,
0.6551870704,
-0.3331096768,
-0.6935346127,
-0.3484784067,
-0.3156282008,
0.7839644551,
0.687967062,
0.0188971199,
-0.0521194674,
0.5387969017,
0.6976937652,
-0.6081598401,
0.0206080247,
-0.773989141,
-0.1888190061,
-0.1691803336,
-0.3544039428,
-0.8441643715,
-0.2315997928,
0.2996133566,
-0.7601940632,
-0.1395926625,
0.3121986985,
0.9248859882,
0.2266526669,
-0.3102433383,
-0.2354287654,
-1.2970175743,
0.8370062709,
-0.5882109404,
0.3800491095,
0.126358673,
0.2362716198,
-0.411485672,
-0.7044907212,
-0.1786893904,
-0.184825018,
-0.2128764689,
0.0406502895,
-0.3767465055,
0.0319116451,
0.2327778637,
0.2015636414,
-0.5613661408,
0.1768407375,
-0.3159600198,
0.0928180367,
0.6777197719,
0.0189824942,
0.1994664073,
0.1998187453,
-0.2017024606,
-0.0032646055,
-0.6729499102,
-0.1557103395,
0.2123584002,
0.2722133398,
0.2128186673,
0.8059581518,
-0.3020918071,
0.6199020743,
0.2662519813,
-0.018023178,
0.1296850741,
-0.3210437894,
-0.240453124,
0.3024870753,
0.6497778893,
0.4541706145,
0.1049515754,
-0.055903282,
-0.3148614764,
-0.2453256845,
0.4645000398,
-0.8745450974,
0.0720882416,
-0.0965832546,
-0.5869809985,
-0.4097975791,
0.4474005401,
-0.4578542709,
-0.6530449986,
-0.2227478623,
0.6393231153,
-0.1674348414,
0.2172823548,
0.2604779303,
-0.3048990965,
0.0193895772,
0.0935994312,
-0.7610635161,
0.2976688743,
0.9167419672,
1.0149048567,
-0.2379415482,
0.1103674322,
-0.3800477684,
0.5976305604,
-0.4983066022,
0.8018184304,
-0.7830632329,
-0.6590197682,
0.2506771684,
0.0838390067,
0.2700264156,
-0.8606446385,
0.626554966,
-0.8774623871,
0.2949564457,
-0.3128968477,
-0.4928708375,
-0.0932175517,
0.094661653,
-0.5971139669,
0.8266630173,
-0.4169770479,
-0.4749651253,
0.3367895782,
-0.5543083549,
-0.9865555167,
0.1242978424,
0.0512480885,
-0.3121537864,
0.1902579218,
0.3017659187,
0.4251818359,
-0.0131562138,
0.0446311124,
-0.332998842,
-0.3733095825,
0.3604759872,
-0.3878787756,
0.2911957502,
0.1260403991,
-0.3123313487,
0.4164223969,
-0.6580148935,
-0.1554461718,
0.2411902696,
-0.6149331331,
-0.6676180363,
0.1235911399,
-0.1210279018,
-0.0660497919,
0.4997840226,
-0.0159966927,
0.2498400509,
-0.7238268256,
0.2797011137,
0.979293406,
0.3588925302,
0.5908200145,
-0.4115720689,
0.626748383,
-0.2077064365,
0.2965088487,
-0.3492791057,
-0.7064294815,
-0.9977582097,
-0.0729613379,
0.257350415,
0.3574906588,
-0.5223154426,
0.4528740346,
-0.2883886695,
-0.4397535622,
-0.4358028769,
0.1753048599,
0.2635372579,
0.1251524985,
0.1963737309,
-0.2147181332,
-0.5366978049,
-1.0086624622,
-0.7424702048,
-0.0485555157,
-0.1624662429,
0.5919413567,
-0.1757743657,
-0.3429683447,
0.690390408,
-1.005987525,
-0.3497867882,
-0.3351054192,
-0.0054251947,
0.7208759785,
0.0226320662,
0.2817575932,
-0.6418557167,
-0.6265158653,
-0.0776152387,
-0.2405889481,
-0.2732678056,
-0.1776020825,
-0.3851216435,
0.0680992231,
0.4360546172,
-0.5679456592,
0.2263441086,
0.4347046614,
-0.2215257138,
0.4939783216,
-0.4930588007,
0.1206586882,
-1.0436030626,
-0.3022980094,
0.3249380887,
-0.1433737874,
-0.3646266758,
-0.0462566726,
-0.2543843389,
-0.0475128479,
-0.2938380837,
0.5547720194,
-0.1715293974,
-0.2693417966,
-0.325502038,
0.2344402969,
0.4132370353,
0.1573615223,
-0.2420327514,
0.8017571568,
0.3061921,
-0.9008101821,
-0.0950206369,
0.2416875809,
-0.5946457386,
0.2687872946,
-0.8351715803,
-0.04321393,
-0.1068315133,
0.2843229473,
-1.1034083366,
-0.0052669588,
0.0669607148,
-0.2117292434,
0.1632105559,
0.061456982,
-0.7720057368,
-0.05838212,
-0.2111240476,
0.1831808239,
0.3694280386,
-0.62909621,
0.4115083516,
0.2898774445,
-0.341722399,
-0.2937628329,
-0.7250069976,
0.3319830596,
-0.2887426019,
-0.7629784346,
0.8910407424,
-0.4164388776,
-0.3072791994,
-0.194080025,
-0.0476814918,
0.407586813,
0.1408662349,
0.4632892609,
0.3505415618,
-0.0884833336,
0.3685240448,
-0.0371037163,
-0.1066416726,
0.0888317376,
-0.6972094178,
0.7450168133,
-0.0753506497,
-0.2839080095,
-0.4823956788,
0.1242197976,
0.455833286,
-0.2191566825,
0.7519785166,
0.4132884741,
-0.2120182812,
-0.2899259329,
-0.3855869472,
-0.2822047472,
-0.6707339883,
0.3574649394,
-0.0259373877,
-0.790329814,
0.10770192,
-0.1205584109,
-0.1235336885,
0.41811499,
0.6635088325,
-0.2599666715,
1.6971554756,
0.7371741533,
-0.1649761796,
0.8359728456,
-0.0865415186,
0.4938280284,
-0.5493490696,
-0.3002203107,
-0.569644928,
-0.7202113271,
-0.8800005913,
-0.3573097289,
0.4707347155,
-0.0711135194,
-0.2129067034,
0.2493268996,
-0.5397723913,
0.5957095027,
0.6808441877,
0.3622035086,
0.5726615191,
0.1902243346,
-0.2704768181,
-0.0708625019,
-0.5849367976,
-0.4476246238,
0.8359125257,
0.3787327409,
0.788198173,
0.1524119675,
0.4951289296,
0.5966764688,
-0.0200369433,
-0.8614463806,
0.7884305716,
-0.4952056408,
-0.3417737186,
0.0019801487,
-0.1586645395,
-1.0023692846,
-0.1141639426,
-0.2880924046,
-0.4634485841,
0.0577422939,
-0.1916706711,
-0.3642420769,
-0.1327188313,
-0.5093177557,
0.4319474101,
-0.7319673896,
-0.6136084795,
-0.7075208426,
-0.176572606,
-0.0350981914,
-0.05393181,
0.2349297553,
0.1334891617,
-0.1232521236,
0.7944576144,
-0.3079682291,
0.6888124943,
0.2563225329,
-0.2496804148,
-0.1179680154,
0.1693540514,
0.7625890374,
-0.0254281722,
-0.0594596602,
-0.0109275747,
-0.5179736018,
-0.1901692748,
-0.7803880572,
0.9802911878,
-0.5313692689,
-1.1947615147,
-0.2719172835,
-0.3356962502,
-0.2708619237,
0.5647934079,
0.1003720462,
0.1757404357,
-0.1898421794,
0.5402044654,
0.7186123729,
-0.5384236574,
0.4002490938,
0.4233975112,
-0.5151445866,
-0.4016946554,
0.8782368302,
0.0114118457,
0.2872733772,
0.6560034752,
0.5029290318,
-0.3696018159,
-0.6417661309,
0.0134913018,
0.2363559455,
-0.816329658,
0.0221328139,
-0.6646193862,
-0.2422916442,
-0.3550767899,
-0.1699867547,
-0.0320828781,
-0.5200380087,
-0.3904981315,
-0.2202316821,
0.2112214118,
0.9863567352,
0.2564341724,
0.6675022244,
-0.6198387742,
0.1181193292,
0.2413123101,
0.5356661081,
-0.144616127,
-0.604126215,
-0.4150764942,
-0.1130418852,
-0.3888485134,
-0.6558353901,
0.4162303805,
0.1345320642,
0.5240061283,
0.8959754705,
-0.0945612937,
0.6630012393,
-0.5683150887,
0.6688348651,
-0.0269396007,
-0.6796867251,
0.6446706057,
-0.574205935,
0.5128584504,
0.291218251,
0.4745059311,
-0.4913799465,
-0.4831282496,
-0.3563033342,
-0.947881639,
0.4940532744,
0.0336428881,
0.3757436872,
0.0366931185,
0.1775767058,
-0.0611700714,
0.3277705908,
-0.3987461925,
-0.2941786349,
0.314273268,
0.022232309,
-0.1366358101,
-0.4658011198,
0.122570008,
-0.0221372209,
1.0443781614,
0.2291840166,
-0.068385087,
-0.0317879766,
0.1548649371,
-0.0179736596,
0.2268010378,
0.5826656222,
0.5859744549,
-0.0441939831,
-0.0653681681,
-0.2611545622,
-0.1687790155,
-0.2627511621,
-0.0990256742,
-0.3209492564,
0.1274543107,
0.0833075047,
0.696346581,
0.497912854,
-0.5840899944,
0.2028675228,
-0.0784123689,
0.1020178124,
-0.043317154,
0.1736217141,
0.1594338119,
0.5191397667,
0.3935992718,
0.0626105219,
0.3598328233,
-0.6616349816,
0.2657927275,
0.6290171146,
-0.3652383685,
0.0546161048,
0.6074565649,
0.1372856349,
-0.769225657,
0.2871238589,
0.322316736,
-0.633138299,
0.3309598863,
0.6985359788,
0.8276605606,
-0.2412782609,
0.3107889593,
0.1763676405,
0.3186299503,
-0.1765143722,
-0.2549555302,
0.1935291141,
-0.5669355989,
-0.3123832643,
-0.6169335246,
-0.3831197321,
0.035930533,
-0.3704654276,
0.6124056578,
-0.7641004324,
-0.4134034514,
0.3553599119,
0.00569352,
-0.5061252713,
0.1205811948,
0.2261399478,
0.7097104192,
-0.2786445618,
0.5027087927,
0.4813296497,
-0.2303365469,
-0.3663183451,
0.3483627439,
-0.1118637025,
-0.812309742,
0.5328676701,
0.3197863996,
-0.2965056598,
-0.1909126043,
-0.608155787,
-0.9661602974,
0.9879250526,
0.2286720574,
-0.7698993087,
0.0892195702,
0.453235656,
0.6444787383,
-0.5564882755,
0.2071787417,
0.2633693814,
0.6446861029,
0.1904273182,
-0.6311095953,
0.1395510435,
-0.0481440201,
0.0949619934,
0.1244038418,
-0.6334664822,
0.1812245846,
-0.3170014918,
-0.2944873869,
0.144255951,
0.4161867201,
0.5126709938,
0.2405140996,
0.4901800156,
0.3321487904,
0.6332962513,
0.1886236817,
0.9923398495,
-0.2645094395,
-0.0713725239,
1.1919759512,
-0.4655238986,
1.1129155159,
0.3153191805,
0.0837978572,
0.8060703874,
0.562022984,
-0.3004055917,
0.7222581506,
0.1564169675,
-0.2379282117,
-0.2621613443,
-0.4448428154,
-0.2892356515,
0.391627878,
0.4504151344,
-0.9535501003,
0.037331406,
-0.1789017916,
-0.056268204,
0.1144540012,
-0.1978656948,
0.9240115285,
0.1362325251,
-0.748852849,
0.4672636986,
0.3814737797,
0.5684534311,
-0.5284693837,
-0.0385447964,
-0.0688149631,
0.4367612898,
-0.2546871603,
-0.7828012705,
0.0857245475,
-0.1539776921,
-0.3835178316,
-0.5404288173,
1.0583766699,
-0.3560620546,
-0.7830696106,
0.5088742375,
0.2840931416,
-0.2052827775,
-0.2850560248,
-0.7224254608,
0.2061060667,
-0.0092424117,
-0.2888256013,
0.3610703349,
0.0914789811,
0.0597559921,
0.721473515,
0.9958068132,
-0.0958776176,
-0.0868890285,
0.1929885298,
0.8501799107,
-0.5727218986,
-0.6456555724,
-0.9700811505,
0.2247240543,
-0.2806161344,
0.3130069375,
0.9038800597,
0.7176145911,
0.7725135684,
0.0849637613,
0.7795706391,
0.5277287364,
0.1468196362,
-0.3887783587,
0.9923545718,
-0.6382053494,
0.8900296092,
-0.1233471259,
-1.1903070211,
-0.3311288059,
0.1143623069,
-0.4229357541,
0.1429084986,
0.4380861819,
0.9059051275,
0.1178957969,
0.0073477263,
0.3949284554,
0.7663538456,
0.3756354153,
0.1928518414,
0.6996814013,
-0.1303815842,
0.9082949162,
-0.0447564572,
-0.119663462,
-0.3638725579,
-1.0308037996,
-0.6816576719,
-0.3737016022,
-0.3558134735,
-0.5288022757,
0.536074996,
0.6100766659,
0.6768476367,
-0.6680149436,
-0.1888820082,
0.1113157645,
0.3347890973,
-0.2359613478,
-0.2657386363,
0.1900910884,
-0.2221706659,
-0.668037951,
0.761241436,
0.5991299152,
-0.0761001855,
-0.3199366033,
-0.0127297994,
-0.1812944263,
0.2913465798,
0.7826291919,
-0.2852559388,
-0.6938388348,
-0.0378619432,
0.3273737431,
0.0748952329,
0.2339446545,
0.8549749255,
-0.8299561143,
0.3659084141,
0.5877370834,
0.5742000341,
0.5143148303,
0.099668853,
0.8179601431,
-0.8252496123,
-0.1938298047,
-0.0617161319,
0.2628171742,
0.2640906274,
-0.6549592018,
0.1739149094,
-0.0208657365,
-0.5127601027,
-0.5095888972,
0.3158272803,
-0.7712512612,
-0.4152252674,
1.603087306,
0.1800715774,
-0.0451140925,
0.1804807186,
-0.2977429926,
0.0961538628,
-0.6548633575,
1.011425972,
0.7501212358,
0.0386746228,
0.0974988192,
-0.5839663148,
0.2426580936,
0.5550543666,
-0.5764992237,
-0.1671736389,
0.2077759951,
0.1828030199,
0.2691106796,
0.1181037575,
0.0012427722,
-0.1464789063,
-0.6818597913,
-0.6109273434,
0.1065949127,
-0.573756814,
-0.3578495681,
0.0339886062,
0.2662255466,
-0.1231493652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07979v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07979v1
|
LLoCO: Learning Long Contexts Offline
| 2024-04-11T17:57:22 | 2024-04-11T17:57:22 |
Sijun Tan, Xiuyu Li, Shishir Patil, Ziyang Wu, Tianjun Zhang, Kurt Keutzer, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Raluca Ada Popa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Processing long contexts remains a challenge for large language models (LLMs)
due to the quadratic computational and memory overhead of the self-attention
mechanism and the substantial KV cache sizes during generation. We propose a
novel approach to address this problem by learning contexts offline through
context compression and in-domain parameter-efficient finetuning. Our method
enables an LLM to create a concise representation of the original context and
efficiently retrieve relevant information to answer questions accurately. We
introduce LLoCO, a technique that combines context compression, retrieval, and
parameter-efficient finetuning using LoRA. Our approach extends the effective
context window of a 4k token LLaMA2-7B model to handle up to 128k tokens. We
evaluate our approach on several long-context question-answering datasets,
demonstrating that LLoCO significantly outperforms in-context learning while
using $30\times$ fewer tokens during inference. LLoCO achieves up to
$7.62\times$ speed-up and substantially reduces the cost of long document
question answering, making it a promising solution for efficient long context
processing. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/jeffreysijuntan/lloco.
|
[
-0.305849582,
-0.9101534486,
0.7035239935,
0.1121221259,
-0.4638582766,
-0.1023327857,
-0.5226153135,
-0.7036632299,
0.1417995542,
0.4272123277,
-0.6252236366,
-0.3070100248,
-0.2611406744,
0.2470102757,
-0.3042658567,
0.8854638338,
-0.0224489011,
-0.2226733416,
-0.3023252189,
-0.0099306982,
-0.2819931507,
-0.364169538,
-0.8478465676,
-0.0384856425,
0.6238459945,
0.6182173491,
-0.1513194442,
0.6677363515,
0.0792339295,
0.3327333331,
-0.2243520319,
0.4652041197,
-1.0507105589,
0.4130503833,
0.0173289049,
-0.4985641539,
-0.3624148667,
-0.3488092422,
0.594332397,
0.5116274357,
-0.1443602294,
0.1722103357,
0.2161308527,
0.5803416371,
-0.7248867154,
0.138051793,
-0.9285036922,
-0.096593909,
-0.1311386526,
-0.4758677483,
-0.3937431276,
0.0125047797,
0.1140999645,
-0.8016249537,
-0.0685899556,
0.0505872406,
0.587949872,
0.5660796165,
-0.502959013,
-0.4663309157,
-0.4341312349,
0.8509581685,
-0.4929974973,
0.2615965009,
0.5321708918,
0.3774885833,
-0.1958849281,
-1.0183489323,
-0.4751562774,
0.1101530492,
0.2183765173,
0.0304664094,
0.1182238981,
0.0610222369,
0.151014775,
0.3993363976,
-0.0726795495,
0.2779720128,
-0.5348299742,
-0.1127961501,
0.3357533216,
-0.082112357,
-0.1772340089,
-0.1662700921,
-0.5094907284,
0.2071677297,
-0.9439518452,
0.1904232651,
0.139762044,
0.3189812303,
0.0120028071,
0.2025853992,
-0.337680757,
0.7408791184,
0.1166344061,
-0.3672081828,
-0.112834692,
-0.0863700956,
-0.4265139699,
0.0889207274,
0.4134466648,
0.242668286,
-0.0515889786,
-0.2860756814,
-0.1888705343,
-0.4850313365,
0.0434446968,
-0.9798955321,
0.3185628653,
0.3608354628,
-0.0210791491,
-0.1247523576,
-0.1746611446,
-0.9213936329,
-0.0690367594,
-0.4683689475,
0.1868707687,
-0.0340191685,
0.5129850507,
-0.1434876174,
0.2283416688,
0.2163130492,
0.6104184389,
-0.8781318069,
0.2911813557,
0.6492471099,
0.9707602859,
-0.2222449481,
-0.1136746407,
-1.1926760674,
0.1936145574,
-0.0233787615,
0.7396116257,
-0.2879087925,
-0.1857886016,
0.0605016239,
0.2340958118,
0.2482407689,
-0.4524284601,
0.4578123093,
-0.6637110114,
0.1661520749,
-0.2138884515,
-0.6356295347,
0.0103954487,
0.2207126617,
-0.585790813,
1.1557272673,
0.2390105128,
-0.5123974681,
0.1483627707,
-0.5511876345,
-0.4858929813,
0.1467922628,
-0.2690982819,
-0.1690903604,
-0.0166280605,
0.3049197793,
0.7259500027,
-0.3551561534,
0.2248317152,
-0.1344651431,
-0.6194550991,
-0.1066734567,
-0.1856371611,
0.6461228132,
0.2945334613,
-0.4431376159,
0.0769757032,
-0.7825837135,
-0.0527797192,
0.1371817589,
-0.7109665871,
-0.3217923939,
-0.0747783482,
-0.0208343752,
0.121056281,
0.421805352,
-0.5189163685,
0.2704353034,
-0.4543856382,
0.9815514088,
0.7808442712,
-0.2375775427,
0.4961579144,
-0.0398826078,
0.2664875686,
-0.145805344,
0.0008943274,
-0.356571883,
-0.2848420739,
-0.8911134601,
-0.4173013866,
0.047445178,
0.4324241579,
-0.6877880692,
0.406026125,
-0.3447142541,
-0.1201852337,
-0.3133156598,
0.6381053329,
0.3307432234,
0.8831543326,
0.5314348936,
0.0583904646,
-0.6614094973,
-0.5978873372,
0.1427728087,
0.1133583263,
-0.1244593114,
0.7257174253,
0.5200176239,
-0.4899038076,
1.0861541033,
-0.5893806815,
-0.5630851388,
-0.2467686087,
0.0370854251,
0.0784858689,
0.1553730518,
0.3197173178,
-0.7645384073,
-0.4372534752,
0.0493595526,
-0.5528318882,
-0.1009730324,
-0.0223013796,
0.0879564211,
0.5198780298,
0.8820923567,
-0.3838782609,
0.0815718919,
0.612557888,
0.1100956053,
0.0210367106,
-0.3767967224,
-0.1160228848,
-1.3985573053,
0.2189000845,
-0.2946541011,
-0.705175221,
-0.5011401772,
0.203449294,
0.2085137963,
-0.0787897408,
-0.9381029606,
0.8179547787,
-0.5727026463,
-0.0831622034,
-0.2717085481,
0.401771605,
0.1559604108,
0.7242082953,
-0.028464213,
0.9385581017,
0.3833504319,
-0.6219893694,
0.3152893484,
0.0153191416,
-0.6491433382,
0.1998290271,
-0.5513970256,
0.469915092,
-0.3595473468,
0.6874241233,
-0.9164475203,
-0.4912829101,
-0.0541155748,
0.0289134104,
0.2755107284,
-0.3313134909,
-0.3538985252,
-0.0165227577,
-0.2599622309,
0.6129903197,
0.4534216225,
-0.7943563461,
0.444126308,
0.4499866068,
-0.0492689423,
-0.7641963959,
-0.6733350754,
0.006859492,
-0.5759363174,
-0.238007471,
0.4701659381,
-0.1700750887,
-0.118321836,
-0.551258564,
0.0134309987,
-0.2667776644,
0.1739349812,
0.2209084332,
-0.1707171798,
0.0074555045,
0.2965818644,
0.1661535501,
0.1514447182,
-0.2037376165,
-0.2796276212,
0.6206036806,
-0.1833168268,
0.2615340054,
-0.3997153044,
0.3828713894,
0.5449795127,
0.1085731164,
0.6107726693,
0.1971074194,
-0.4066900015,
-0.4699930847,
-0.511377275,
-0.1228988394,
-0.5329676867,
0.2765746117,
-0.3040015996,
-1.364866972,
0.6800982952,
-0.2197608203,
-0.0343134701,
0.1780253947,
0.4313829541,
-0.2167433649,
0.4459696412,
0.6733503938,
-0.260281235,
0.6048204899,
-0.366637975,
0.0905083045,
-0.8862720728,
-0.0836044922,
-0.1274623275,
-0.0652784407,
-0.2915175259,
-0.6826459169,
0.3545334637,
0.4583826959,
-0.029825082,
0.3822960556,
-0.2099723965,
0.7901517153,
0.2223292142,
0.2400961071,
0.319898814,
0.0983126312,
0.1530192941,
0.3368331492,
-0.5945373774,
-0.2873831391,
0.9879419804,
0.4230901003,
0.5764454603,
0.0896240398,
0.7560381889,
0.1915292591,
0.2065852433,
-1.0641149282,
0.4913712144,
0.1250693947,
-0.4608296752,
-0.5769520998,
-0.4895274043,
-0.9333105087,
-0.0192565266,
0.1189778447,
-0.9088532925,
0.0463044159,
0.3358515501,
-0.6428231597,
0.1850795895,
-0.4755994976,
0.5884066224,
-0.1234657988,
-0.680647254,
-0.1022428572,
-0.7939241529,
0.1933438778,
-0.461312443,
0.2458363175,
0.0132480552,
-0.2017692029,
0.622644484,
-0.3635788858,
1.0618542433,
0.0342201181,
-0.5502257347,
0.5174220204,
-0.119056955,
0.6820347905,
0.4608463049,
-0.1242144853,
0.1448473781,
0.0332690589,
-0.344699949,
-0.6296662688,
0.981919229,
-0.5746183991,
-0.5368834138,
-0.1981474161,
-0.5178375244,
-0.0843677893,
0.323851198,
0.4750349224,
0.6114114523,
-0.0291394405,
0.3428242207,
0.5544461608,
-0.0189961549,
0.6342608333,
0.228130132,
0.0519760475,
-0.4268566072,
0.6448271275,
0.1450843364,
0.2495575249,
0.6272798777,
0.2225701958,
-0.3733299971,
-0.2681397498,
-0.4508523345,
0.1368636191,
-1.1158994436,
-0.3465111256,
-0.4839198887,
0.0622244738,
-0.3132645786,
-0.2986141741,
-0.3663361371,
-0.2598411143,
-0.5746083856,
0.1193937436,
0.3405188024,
0.4515532255,
0.2320891023,
0.4283358157,
-0.5111558437,
0.1268823147,
0.5666299462,
0.2022243142,
0.0475723222,
-0.5703251958,
-0.2310959548,
0.104573153,
-0.1749747396,
-0.5383265615,
0.2966913581,
0.6601639986,
0.0796699077,
0.7217453718,
0.3155199587,
1.0906863213,
-0.7554802895,
0.6027218103,
-0.1470500827,
-1.0573233366,
0.5253704786,
-0.336514473,
0.2589729428,
0.8709493876,
0.5489007235,
-0.3989334404,
-0.0225756224,
-0.220154658,
-1.0575091839,
0.5483133197,
0.050509613,
0.2954617739,
-0.2533235848,
0.8380066752,
0.2067645639,
0.0736468136,
-0.8581130505,
0.0277757049,
0.0420421436,
-0.0304877162,
-0.2983745337,
-0.3616806567,
-0.2663240731,
-0.3417772651,
0.3288061023,
-0.6942812204,
0.3481566906,
0.4653048217,
-0.4364557266,
-0.0805043876,
0.3194738626,
1.0077867508,
0.8769509196,
-0.3134392202,
0.208227098,
0.6728251576,
-0.1087501645,
-0.0802395195,
-0.1377107799,
0.1801737994,
-0.4483183324,
0.4121205211,
0.7262434363,
0.4732168019,
-1.0302546024,
0.5531121492,
-0.1823707372,
-0.0947367251,
-0.6531931758,
-0.0209078416,
-0.0357584991,
0.2230757177,
0.4340458512,
-0.5909506679,
0.1267228127,
-0.848885119,
0.1715911627,
0.236606583,
-0.4445918798,
-0.0629396439,
0.4915437996,
0.3863104284,
-0.0390285738,
0.6071847677,
-0.0322322957,
-0.3231502771,
0.5582066774,
0.7806988955,
0.4144205749,
0.0757362917,
-0.1987960339,
0.2586286366,
-0.377748251,
-0.0934278071,
0.1697800457,
-0.7754410505,
-0.3155986667,
-0.5984494686,
-0.6415688992,
-0.3274191022,
0.3565506935,
-0.55477494,
0.3007167876,
-0.5098488331,
0.1398792863,
-0.3588550687,
0.1037671119,
-0.3656629026,
0.2073259354,
0.1154613346,
0.8108064532,
-0.4386105835,
1.1309918165,
0.3720602691,
-0.0454930551,
-0.4392912388,
0.0021188995,
-0.1832281798,
-0.7395388484,
0.9011387825,
0.6450887918,
-0.4151494205,
0.2931413949,
-0.5642405152,
-0.9097445607,
1.31311059,
0.368100673,
-0.8885688782,
-0.1667919606,
0.0435374789,
0.4839451313,
-0.4642631114,
0.2054719031,
0.3751411438,
0.0942454934,
0.1597213745,
-0.7684118152,
0.0634382963,
0.0924583077,
-0.2797032595,
0.1653387547,
-0.8289362788,
0.6316432357,
-0.2380079627,
-0.3677853346,
0.1769157052,
0.780382812,
0.1810298264,
0.2874109745,
0.5560982227,
0.4033631086,
0.9083295465,
0.0955057889,
0.9692809582,
-0.4858634174,
0.556829989,
1.1774379015,
-0.234225899,
1.154871583,
0.8018995523,
0.2500556707,
0.4800119102,
0.8487679362,
0.4968415499,
0.6742844582,
0.3366683424,
-0.4116244018,
-0.3252408206,
-0.0572069138,
-0.1210465282,
0.4841380417,
0.2380707562,
-0.1635478139,
-0.1799215674,
-0.0186422672,
0.1660831124,
-0.1342729032,
-0.3555968106,
0.7199423313,
0.3656966686,
-0.8771012425,
0.8981333971,
-0.0172877125,
0.7045105696,
-0.5235624909,
-0.0132394796,
-0.4591157436,
0.2794154584,
-0.0908653736,
-0.4027849436,
0.1885218024,
0.035547588,
-0.052709341,
-0.3242713809,
0.2944597304,
-0.5009256601,
-0.2497001588,
0.4596475363,
0.1156812608,
0.2921593785,
-0.0339783728,
-0.3418183625,
-0.0042433455,
-0.2251906991,
-0.2806563079,
0.4322645366,
0.3449533284,
-0.233793661,
0.8327723742,
0.5984346867,
-0.1774820983,
-0.0393277518,
-0.1056893393,
1.05938375,
-0.4773944616,
-0.692404151,
-0.7812281251,
0.3018464148,
-0.0028152613,
-0.5147917271,
0.4474588633,
0.5535552502,
1.0232414007,
0.1146320328,
0.3194404542,
0.0528822057,
0.2306674421,
-0.7911980748,
0.5686466694,
-0.9196596146,
0.2872423232,
-0.0096820574,
-0.8579083085,
-0.2586916089,
0.5624711514,
-0.2987200916,
-0.1735649258,
0.7124404311,
0.5524018407,
-0.3524957895,
-0.3346063197,
0.2543394268,
0.0251012594,
0.3004069626,
0.8009422421,
0.6820602417,
-0.5342805982,
0.5089334846,
-0.2843855619,
-0.1337728351,
-0.3633529842,
-1.1825959682,
-1.1224607229,
-0.7180762887,
0.0339574702,
0.0285261441,
0.1551688313,
1.103724122,
0.9927114844,
-0.5741923451,
-0.3236600757,
-0.1862035245,
-0.0100700036,
0.1080828011,
-0.157565847,
0.4512090981,
-0.4803155065,
-0.9241338968,
0.8014551401,
0.1942787617,
-0.1201721132,
-0.1555505693,
-0.2007238567,
-0.0842593983,
-0.0106183551,
0.9218821526,
0.461138308,
-0.8553327918,
-0.2864513099,
-0.1288934797,
-0.0288638081,
0.3571630418,
0.8085374236,
-0.8384305835,
0.3112810552,
0.5604950786,
0.7952969074,
0.6505351067,
0.2596719265,
0.4291388392,
-0.9107804894,
0.3833156228,
0.0393651538,
0.4098141789,
0.2921251655,
-0.7073038816,
0.3549815714,
-0.0728735626,
-0.6371073723,
-0.8828875422,
0.2242510021,
-1.1172627211,
-0.5065549016,
1.256480813,
-0.2953233719,
-0.5225356221,
-0.0687997937,
-0.1921577156,
0.2602220476,
-0.4571075737,
0.8937206864,
0.338822484,
-0.1179416329,
-0.2872547209,
-0.7272328138,
0.6272871494,
0.2669123411,
-0.9794515371,
0.1188616231,
0.337648809,
0.3704055548,
-0.0247012191,
0.4862027466,
0.301366955,
0.0135828285,
-0.6650883555,
-0.2661963403,
-0.2387923151,
-0.6403061152,
-0.3742838502,
0.2445848137,
-0.2197640687,
0.1901063472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07972v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07972v2
|
OSWorld: Benchmarking Multimodal Agents for Open-Ended Tasks in Real Computer Environments
| 2024-04-11T17:56:05 | 2024-05-30T08:55:12 |
Tianbao Xie, Danyang Zhang, Jixuan Chen, Xiaochuan Li, Siheng Zhao, Ruisheng Cao, Toh Jing Hua, Zhoujun Cheng, Dongchan Shin, Fangyu Lei, Yitao Liu, Yiheng Xu, Shuyan Zhou, Silvio Savarese, Caiming Xiong, Victor Zhong, Tao Yu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Autonomous agents that accomplish complex computer tasks with minimal human
interventions have the potential to transform human-computer interaction,
significantly enhancing accessibility and productivity. However, existing
benchmarks either lack an interactive environment or are limited to
environments specific to certain applications or domains, failing to reflect
the diverse and complex nature of real-world computer use, thereby limiting the
scope of tasks and agent scalability. To address this issue, we introduce
OSWorld, the first-of-its-kind scalable, real computer environment for
multimodal agents, supporting task setup, execution-based evaluation, and
interactive learning across various operating systems such as Ubuntu, Windows,
and macOS. OSWorld can serve as a unified, integrated computer environment for
assessing open-ended computer tasks that involve arbitrary applications.
Building upon OSWorld, we create a benchmark of 369 computer tasks involving
real web and desktop apps in open domains, OS file I/O, and workflows spanning
multiple applications. Each task example is derived from real-world computer
use cases and includes a detailed initial state setup configuration and a
custom execution-based evaluation script for reliable, reproducible evaluation.
Extensive evaluation of state-of-the-art LLM/VLM-based agents on OSWorld
reveals significant deficiencies in their ability to serve as computer
assistants. While humans can accomplish over 72.36% of the tasks, the best
model achieves only 12.24% success, primarily struggling with GUI grounding and
operational knowledge. Comprehensive analysis using OSWorld provides valuable
insights for developing multimodal generalist agents that were not possible
with previous benchmarks. Our code, environment, baseline models, and data are
publicly available at https://os-world.github.io.
|
[
-0.5423713923,
-0.7780068517,
0.6463454366,
0.1908960491,
0.2402221262,
0.1584337354,
-0.05042338,
-0.7574473619,
-0.0018959326,
0.2773359716,
-0.7127553821,
-0.3118162751,
-0.2846421301,
0.0379457921,
0.0559335127,
0.7282149792,
-0.0821489245,
-0.4567578137,
-0.9092305899,
-0.5216497183,
-0.2492033839,
-0.3862043023,
-0.3509987295,
-0.195275858,
0.3960918784,
0.3814944923,
0.9528635144,
0.4241410196,
0.5619946718,
0.3678741455,
0.3535946012,
0.4217121899,
-0.3857614696,
0.5193302631,
-0.2503960431,
-0.0388443135,
-0.7006207108,
0.2230498344,
0.3976405859,
0.3995758295,
0.0182203967,
0.2608745694,
-0.2264518291,
0.2684749365,
-1.0195473433,
0.2409067899,
-0.1775132418,
0.2849590182,
0.039298676,
-0.0348000787,
-0.2816591561,
-0.0927382633,
-0.0274196677,
-1.1204303503,
-0.021292191,
0.1195324212,
0.4719951749,
0.1794549525,
-0.5101100802,
-0.0499479659,
-0.7059360147,
0.8951676488,
-0.2686311603,
0.4827474654,
-0.062834464,
0.5476096272,
-0.3226223886,
-0.7156646252,
-0.5203314424,
-0.6845777035,
0.2092629075,
0.2444872409,
-0.4328729212,
0.1808341593,
0.4924055934,
0.1963535398,
-0.5645937324,
-0.1764469892,
-0.1400049776,
-0.3911678493,
0.4295315742,
0.3280170262,
0.5560448766,
0.4619687796,
-0.4918472171,
-0.518437326,
-0.2020119578,
0.4053636789,
0.3295525014,
0.3210246265,
-0.1603264958,
0.5209273696,
-0.7047752142,
0.5513274074,
-0.443495363,
-0.5334260464,
0.4649390876,
-0.2590579093,
-0.1930268854,
-0.4696963727,
0.6107866168,
0.6225309372,
0.0829483271,
-0.3897578418,
-0.4338183403,
0.3875804543,
0.5781759024,
-0.6805017591,
0.1523577273,
0.2935782969,
-0.2599129081,
-0.1997230649,
-0.0133569101,
-0.4605943263,
-0.4465631247,
-0.3628506362,
0.6489611268,
-0.2353152782,
-0.3184432685,
-0.326611191,
-0.3765873909,
-0.0135566955,
0.6270881891,
-0.1449373066,
0.6941519976,
0.5693818331,
0.9466190934,
-0.4283990264,
-0.4435356259,
-0.8663980961,
-0.0338875875,
-0.1738658249,
0.7167633772,
-0.4967864454,
-0.2227318883,
-0.1280347705,
0.0447740555,
0.1644235402,
-0.5305747986,
0.2354450971,
-0.3262897134,
-0.2161897719,
0.0396687873,
-0.0121140433,
-0.0355710238,
0.7824258208,
-0.6294463277,
1.0742146969,
0.2297956347,
-0.3400667608,
0.2348755747,
-0.9739357233,
-0.3520716429,
0.0460915379,
-0.0965593904,
-0.128702119,
0.1354988515,
0.0148738762,
0.2748914957,
-0.3576132059,
-0.1591000408,
-0.5365114808,
-0.3714286387,
0.0426988192,
-0.2877975106,
0.5715042353,
0.3521352708,
-0.2694737911,
0.2833296955,
-0.7067271471,
0.4172476232,
0.048489552,
-0.1668778062,
-0.344856739,
-0.0943587497,
0.3371138573,
0.2956989706,
0.323025763,
-1.0115833282,
0.5104506612,
0.3252747655,
0.1521728635,
0.6719301343,
-0.3097934425,
0.0818878859,
-0.3933807909,
0.7655550241,
0.0230141245,
0.6256886125,
-0.1112534776,
-0.4380713999,
-0.1888517886,
-0.541029036,
-0.1834238321,
0.5493749976,
-0.8935587406,
-0.2328733951,
-0.3586046696,
-0.6250958443,
-0.1726889759,
0.1016304716,
0.63264817,
0.3214141428,
0.3169988394,
-0.5397006273,
-0.2503249049,
-1.0067529678,
-0.1536407322,
-0.1225272864,
-0.0332019925,
0.3919044733,
0.5768861771,
-0.6969712973,
1.2605721951,
-0.3394374549,
-0.2598317564,
-0.0357842408,
0.1234020665,
-0.1017024294,
0.288474828,
0.3908387721,
-0.7957723737,
-0.4695160091,
0.3147982061,
-0.9906257391,
-0.1426175833,
0.0605766363,
-0.0889057741,
-0.0103242779,
0.3575287759,
-0.3999277949,
0.2417660505,
0.6177811027,
-0.1610718817,
0.6364821792,
-0.5964404941,
0.2031908631,
-0.5879572034,
0.2879019976,
-0.0083118547,
-0.5738474131,
-0.4974318147,
0.5381850004,
0.2521503568,
-0.4107908607,
-0.4595291317,
0.7207944989,
-0.5134724379,
-0.4235425889,
-0.1790208668,
0.1335813552,
-0.1029640138,
0.5515491366,
-0.1567305326,
0.974778831,
0.48340711,
-0.5522265434,
0.5945979357,
-0.1915286928,
-0.1350929886,
0.8048937917,
-0.5780374408,
0.2694141567,
0.1187944189,
0.3065163791,
-0.830391109,
-0.2296546102,
0.1065509245,
-0.1821137667,
-0.3595245183,
0.2254814804,
-0.6073576212,
-0.3254351616,
-0.4851514995,
0.3439870775,
0.4836440384,
-0.466997683,
0.7261873484,
0.3523281217,
0.1317228824,
-0.7262205482,
-0.2785009444,
0.1580117196,
0.2314229161,
-0.6132586002,
0.2096443623,
-0.3797135055,
-0.5901899934,
0.0244874377,
-0.3165377676,
-0.0358488187,
0.3963870704,
0.7710396647,
0.0590478554,
-0.2147971243,
-0.1157963723,
0.0127756149,
-0.1467300206,
-0.1713370085,
-0.1701701283,
0.0126760136,
-0.3975649476,
-0.4702335,
-0.2626487911,
0.2503136992,
1.0364385843,
-0.10526485,
0.3651885688,
0.5104669333,
-0.4125508368,
-0.2728452384,
-0.5365809798,
0.2451320589,
-0.4439200461,
0.2304745913,
-0.5663041472,
-0.5398544073,
0.3196555674,
-0.3952533603,
0.4282971919,
0.2180347443,
0.2063560635,
0.0981857702,
1.0732798576,
0.8204442263,
0.0280050244,
0.4147347808,
-0.1158670485,
-0.2242847532,
-0.7819694877,
-0.0585552119,
-0.152869314,
-0.297940731,
-0.3772441745,
-0.5279780626,
0.8159685135,
-0.3524231613,
-0.073603116,
0.3466076851,
-0.4325387478,
0.4940040708,
0.6323002577,
0.1253333241,
0.2408207357,
-0.0114469426,
-0.3595484197,
0.3252720535,
-0.2452693284,
-0.5088098049,
0.9899717569,
0.2728796601,
0.7157151103,
0.1918841153,
0.3775477409,
1.0332090855,
0.579903245,
-0.5181716681,
0.6358669996,
0.2598218322,
-0.6149035692,
-0.5467524529,
-0.2449790835,
-0.8537169099,
0.7059018612,
-0.1875324249,
-0.7455087304,
-0.0667533875,
0.073876597,
-0.2990432382,
0.1734817624,
-0.60865587,
1.1480664015,
-0.2459379137,
-0.7414368987,
-0.2886683941,
-0.599804759,
0.064813368,
0.2805784643,
0.4230507016,
-0.2803869545,
-0.3890163302,
0.3675972223,
-0.4686245322,
0.6380593777,
-0.4289503396,
-0.0108181899,
0.0794542283,
0.1077897325,
0.3850508332,
-0.1944615841,
-0.1129397526,
0.0828223303,
0.1753903627,
-0.4804694355,
-0.3994983137,
0.8101443648,
-1.0374757051,
-0.1775095165,
-0.7042999268,
-0.6659652591,
-0.5167507529,
0.2238428295,
-0.1899912953,
0.7387478352,
-0.5813564658,
0.1902175844,
0.5165627003,
-0.1138527021,
0.2954126298,
0.8085042238,
-0.2525263131,
-0.2465135157,
1.0042247772,
-0.0419323146,
0.3560835719,
0.3917533457,
-0.0501836091,
-0.010639878,
-0.2897400856,
-0.7388983369,
-0.2181675136,
-0.6502168775,
-0.0649728104,
-0.699732542,
0.2490407676,
-0.3956129551,
-0.2248784304,
-0.4636294544,
-0.1189426333,
0.2700917125,
0.2615026236,
-0.071459271,
0.8654592037,
-0.1863621473,
0.2485091388,
-0.5125412345,
0.6405041814,
0.5349363089,
0.3785892129,
-0.1307985038,
0.1042079553,
-0.3080044091,
-0.0259279516,
-0.6994893551,
-0.4424089789,
0.2452469319,
0.1742312908,
0.9371340275,
0.4767656624,
0.2779504955,
0.6617233753,
-0.2461731434,
0.8359257579,
0.1271775216,
-0.9352759719,
0.424597472,
-0.1660624146,
0.3864803016,
0.6222846508,
0.3487435877,
-0.5813159347,
-0.4505749047,
-0.403111726,
-0.7022430897,
1.0023548603,
0.2220340818,
-0.1317531765,
0.1075582132,
-0.1049073413,
0.3506118357,
0.2624783516,
-0.8124717474,
-0.1460819095,
-0.0123306094,
0.0629329979,
-0.3018917441,
0.1215538457,
-0.2334618121,
0.1275212765,
0.6827713251,
-0.4226557016,
0.2610863745,
0.2695198357,
-0.6480824947,
-0.1706601381,
0.052611772,
0.746373415,
0.854863584,
-0.3690078557,
0.3201707304,
0.0822186545,
-0.5449718833,
0.1941218525,
0.0571495928,
0.0787778944,
-0.3416326344,
0.4941816032,
0.5649552345,
0.0411247201,
-1.2801436186,
0.5582101941,
-0.3473333716,
0.0609805025,
-0.3346791267,
0.3276949525,
-0.1778543741,
0.3369993269,
0.454277277,
0.1886667758,
0.29926759,
-1.0215529203,
-0.0508964621,
0.5170894861,
-0.592952311,
-0.2493616045,
0.6695404053,
0.3378344774,
-0.3611376286,
0.5881963968,
-0.3263554871,
-0.1477244347,
0.8520848751,
0.3745549023,
0.941591084,
-0.0270291753,
0.1155184507,
0.0852634385,
0.4894352257,
0.0016696745,
0.2438815087,
-0.6786376238,
-0.4157751501,
0.0277006049,
-0.5373304486,
-1.0112450123,
-0.2224729806,
-0.538857162,
-0.2842509449,
-0.4314336181,
-0.1835969985,
-0.0652590841,
0.0679928735,
-0.6426324844,
0.3479680717,
0.2808531523,
0.9069462419,
-0.792121172,
0.6410797834,
1.0860235691,
-0.2049847096,
0.0272958893,
0.0122076301,
0.098046869,
-0.6216008663,
0.4900398254,
0.4707000554,
-0.4609314203,
-0.4726095498,
-0.4905192554,
-0.6873585582,
1.2556587458,
0.2285722345,
-0.3491671085,
0.2270610482,
0.2046444267,
0.641911149,
-0.2915037274,
0.9253548384,
-0.1074455157,
0.586496532,
-0.359023571,
-1.1072432995,
0.104071781,
-0.680529058,
0.1682174206,
0.0443076715,
-0.6756163836,
1.0223281384,
-0.1119484156,
-0.0336228572,
0.13384597,
0.4665722549,
0.1383843571,
0.8382211328,
0.9624341726,
0.4285323918,
0.4909425378,
0.0175109394,
1.1641966105,
-0.2712608576,
0.1024181396,
0.5746012926,
-0.5445526838,
0.6718260646,
0.2598456442,
-0.2038323879,
0.4531904161,
0.3212609291,
0.540533483,
0.4318937063,
0.0519212,
-0.3486407697,
-0.4478022754,
-0.2183873653,
-0.1886349469,
0.1793215722,
0.1836233735,
0.233906731,
-0.234441936,
0.5349212885,
-0.2694143057,
-0.0128280865,
-0.2377694547,
0.7302815914,
-0.3218969703,
-0.8053584099,
0.2564654648,
0.0424464494,
0.7482584119,
-1.0144928694,
-0.1842787266,
-0.1717481017,
0.3958859146,
-0.0026154511,
-0.5242525935,
-0.1439702064,
-0.0225727763,
-0.1669754833,
-0.5932419896,
0.6256053448,
0.1316438466,
-0.1535774171,
0.4048029184,
0.4249111712,
0.2571396828,
-0.3461581767,
-0.456697762,
0.361289531,
-0.3222964406,
-0.3040097952,
0.6507829428,
0.3111458719,
-0.4148510993,
1.0051726103,
0.6722532511,
-0.3576153815,
-0.199669674,
-0.4151217341,
0.8053247333,
-0.5349598527,
-0.6109183431,
-0.4228527248,
0.3464933336,
-0.2160987258,
-0.4723991156,
0.7662189603,
0.8724470735,
0.7340630293,
-0.1604590565,
0.9252815843,
-0.3899499178,
0.2635504007,
0.0745345876,
0.4125898182,
-1.0079286098,
-0.3497538567,
-0.2896310389,
-0.7935992479,
0.143071577,
0.3655285537,
-0.0116720507,
0.0388493612,
0.3897414505,
0.6787557602,
-0.4693646431,
-0.0831388384,
0.7410477996,
0.0789464787,
0.3473921418,
0.396605134,
0.9574228525,
-0.1340575963,
0.5720888376,
-0.4855147004,
-0.5608004332,
-0.4008316994,
-0.8805074692,
-0.5781470537,
-0.4557929337,
-0.3290533423,
-0.0850670859,
0.4249782562,
1.0935052633,
0.9695495367,
-0.549298048,
-0.4001473486,
0.2042115182,
-0.0196900014,
-0.8465228081,
-0.1628911942,
-0.3492195308,
-0.2216124088,
-0.7388074994,
0.6484392881,
0.413053751,
-0.3509231806,
-0.3955515623,
-0.1781003475,
0.173061192,
0.0167427044,
0.8839138746,
0.6059419513,
-0.6654053926,
-0.2428554744,
-0.0294532906,
-0.3833058178,
-0.2458179146,
0.6691111326,
-1.0569245815,
0.707416594,
0.2576148808,
0.4007826149,
0.2310047001,
0.1001937166,
0.3750493526,
-0.7836783528,
0.0682510659,
0.1393321902,
0.1271178126,
0.0337818339,
-0.1016680747,
0.7465324998,
0.2563612461,
-0.4232045412,
-1.0117155313,
-0.0972890109,
-1.2557208538,
-0.3486476243,
0.7813376784,
-0.2094278485,
-0.1815037429,
-0.099229224,
-0.2996290922,
-0.1027548164,
-0.4821071625,
0.4741477072,
0.3770864904,
-0.3809223473,
0.2969013453,
-0.7656782269,
-0.0688396618,
0.0262187645,
-1.0381747484,
0.0672532097,
0.6906096935,
0.1763920933,
0.400274843,
0.7293556929,
0.3956525624,
0.4650060833,
0.3521810472,
0.5433380604,
-0.5586284399,
-0.5326506495,
0.1251011789,
0.4987304807,
-0.0842328295,
-0.4289649129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07965v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07965v2
|
Rho-1: Not All Tokens Are What You Need
| 2024-04-11T17:52:01 | 2024-05-23T06:57:07 |
Zhenghao Lin, Zhibin Gou, Yeyun Gong, Xiao Liu, Yelong Shen, Ruochen Xu, Chen Lin, Yujiu Yang, Jian Jiao, Nan Duan, Weizhu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Previous language model pre-training methods have uniformly applied a
next-token prediction loss to all training tokens. Challenging this norm, we
posit that ''Not all tokens in a corpus are equally important for language
model training''. Our initial analysis examines token-level training dynamics
of language model, revealing distinct loss patterns for different tokens.
Leveraging these insights, we introduce a new language model called Rho-1.
Unlike traditional LMs that learn to predict every next token in a corpus,
Rho-1 employs Selective Language Modeling (SLM), which selectively trains on
useful tokens that aligned with the desired distribution. This approach
involves scoring pretraining tokens using a reference model, and then training
the language model with a focused loss on tokens with higher scores. When
continual pretraining on 15B OpenWebMath corpus, Rho-1 yields an absolute
improvement in few-shot accuracy of up to 30% in 9 math tasks. After
fine-tuning, Rho-1-1B and 7B achieved state-of-the-art results of 40.6% and
51.8% on MATH dataset, respectively - matching DeepSeekMath with only 3% of the
pretraining tokens. Furthermore, when pretraining on 80B general tokens, Rho-1
achieves 6.8% average enhancement across 15 diverse tasks, increasing both
efficiency and performance of the language model pre-training.
|
[
-0.1703873575,
-0.7039110065,
0.1311506033,
0.0650448501,
-0.4939387143,
0.1819670498,
0.0409431756,
-0.306871742,
0.3170709014,
0.4785535038,
-0.665489614,
-0.669876039,
-0.8259602189,
-0.0954056308,
-0.4731629491,
1.0261977911,
0.0876453966,
0.328795284,
-0.1787454337,
-0.2984631658,
-0.4227512479,
-0.6777029634,
-0.6015765667,
-0.3972326815,
0.7131965756,
0.3365250826,
0.4209284186,
0.844019115,
0.6351577044,
0.1013942808,
0.0417406149,
-0.0977500454,
-0.658236742,
0.0228109322,
0.0660938993,
-0.7236269116,
-0.4378000796,
0.0828833506,
0.628064394,
0.815613389,
-0.3895635307,
0.3934381306,
-0.2602488697,
0.5898829103,
-0.7737800479,
-0.1638805568,
-0.9735229611,
0.2144770324,
-0.6044248343,
-0.1804837883,
-0.5448114276,
-0.1918826699,
0.0568417124,
-0.7119210362,
0.2438081801,
0.3855203986,
0.7094358206,
0.2987893522,
-0.0652437508,
-0.1237090304,
-0.206964165,
0.9339114428,
-0.6321942806,
0.5806942582,
0.4972990453,
0.0857375041,
0.0939746574,
-0.6795739532,
-0.2836702764,
-0.1321531981,
0.0467632785,
0.1336655915,
-0.1072484925,
0.1328128874,
0.0434828885,
0.0227607507,
-0.453032583,
0.2689500451,
-0.3579510748,
-0.4963961542,
0.0802552626,
0.3145215809,
0.1571810544,
0.1032180786,
-0.3866344988,
-0.1660716236,
-0.6199620962,
0.062167231,
0.396304369,
0.5296013951,
-0.0464648642,
0.3753288686,
0.2755726576,
0.6994489431,
-0.1853888333,
-0.3290162385,
-0.0824120417,
-0.1806087196,
-0.151082024,
0.0672055557,
0.6413857341,
-0.0037068427,
0.4178692997,
-0.2363622338,
-0.1850622147,
0.1871380955,
0.3232196271,
-0.8487736583,
-0.157742545,
0.02483977,
-0.5270264149,
-0.3403953314,
0.0846536681,
-0.4894346297,
-0.2688125372,
-0.2213404328,
0.1232648566,
-0.3920972645,
-0.5048550367,
0.086972706,
-0.019659983,
0.1270122677,
0.235247314,
-0.9832808375,
0.6413916945,
0.8551082611,
0.9110801816,
-0.6076558232,
-0.7279774547,
-0.7734140754,
-0.4372982383,
-0.8279533982,
0.8688469529,
-0.6780647635,
-0.3192206919,
0.123208195,
-0.2981494665,
-0.1575532407,
-0.5520219803,
0.2737810016,
-0.5672012568,
0.0028284958,
-0.0347907171,
-0.6132049561,
0.1333302855,
0.1585902572,
-0.588183105,
1.1236203909,
0.17861256,
-0.8106298447,
0.7470117211,
-0.3743464053,
-0.427280575,
-0.0552528612,
-0.0487052277,
-0.4935340583,
0.3654023409,
0.0309073497,
0.2152194083,
-0.20037283,
0.1477519274,
-0.4678728282,
-0.4335478842,
0.1754378527,
-0.1849604994,
0.4509871304,
0.1337553263,
0.0067253886,
0.3009547293,
-0.8783602118,
0.2402085066,
-0.0005961445,
-0.3700611889,
-0.1528769583,
-0.2948428392,
0.220850721,
0.1226561517,
0.0974424779,
-0.5197041631,
0.1389728636,
-0.6335554123,
0.1558376998,
0.8892706037,
-0.3419041634,
0.7197762132,
-0.1919471174,
1.0767726898,
0.2390240878,
0.1141507551,
-0.2611552775,
-0.3520502448,
-0.7372705936,
-0.3709359765,
0.5356476307,
0.5781193376,
-0.1908131689,
0.2717786133,
-0.2176046669,
-0.5427584052,
-0.8253147602,
0.1824462265,
0.6772637367,
0.5880562663,
0.2840759158,
-0.3548325598,
-0.9267870784,
-0.8060820699,
-0.4767521322,
-0.0674867034,
0.4363130033,
-0.1731717587,
0.4313902259,
-0.1632143408,
1.2454767227,
-0.1757219583,
-0.2874164581,
-0.489017874,
0.1113369688,
0.1042023078,
0.3953021467,
0.4918326139,
-0.3326403499,
-0.4437471926,
0.0618686751,
-0.4822507203,
-0.0223986767,
0.0758306086,
-0.0691443607,
0.2854653597,
0.4623709023,
-0.2026190609,
0.5328990221,
0.6558246017,
-0.0833457112,
0.3549546897,
-0.2033921331,
-0.3849745393,
-0.8541298509,
0.1851765811,
-0.3119334877,
-0.2768525183,
-0.5441426039,
-0.0294651184,
0.1374394447,
-0.2800726891,
-0.6572023034,
1.1707005501,
-0.2150339335,
-0.1879943013,
-0.3538402319,
0.1120225936,
-0.1187166944,
0.7659354806,
-0.0166261885,
0.8180218339,
0.9006568789,
-0.6704151034,
-0.1269657612,
0.1765265018,
-0.4159394801,
-0.0252723657,
-0.6330103874,
0.3267927766,
-0.3184078038,
0.0468580313,
-0.9066018462,
0.1114828289,
0.0851489902,
-0.5996121168,
0.4186200798,
0.0185381714,
-0.2689862251,
-0.1762945354,
-0.2260580659,
0.4331690669,
0.4876555502,
-0.2619993985,
0.62738657,
0.3822947145,
-0.0502264798,
-1.0163021088,
-0.8784249425,
-0.2005560994,
-0.101044476,
-0.1580849737,
0.1002833024,
0.0341278091,
-0.126555115,
-0.0158321615,
-0.3675545454,
-0.1185590252,
0.2839249969,
0.2527409494,
0.2045114189,
-0.030978376,
0.2417557538,
-0.1531687677,
-0.5029634833,
-0.1764010638,
-0.3902322054,
0.7758169174,
0.0039449255,
-0.4662216902,
-0.6114695668,
0.273863703,
0.4835257828,
-0.3224278986,
0.9063998461,
0.5646682978,
-0.2845745385,
-0.1078139991,
-0.5178077221,
-0.2110907882,
-0.3376158178,
0.7609440684,
-0.6248386502,
-0.8066795468,
0.8541343212,
0.0966863856,
0.1887284964,
0.3363316655,
0.3883647919,
0.2217971385,
1.0519658327,
0.8058732152,
-0.2243372351,
0.8246868849,
-0.2017227709,
0.2095278502,
-0.6428573132,
-0.1263510138,
-0.4956868887,
-0.1289770305,
-0.4224945605,
-0.0568659604,
0.0809744671,
0.3327254653,
-0.2494158745,
0.2288248688,
-0.3957193494,
0.4917687178,
0.6350685954,
0.0449117646,
-0.0040965066,
0.1881238222,
-0.2793171108,
-0.1786150038,
-1.1509364843,
-0.394852221,
1.3363486528,
0.4955204427,
0.9409829974,
-0.1737450659,
0.9333528876,
0.1330484599,
0.6983017921,
-0.9451306462,
0.4554605186,
-0.1107732356,
-0.7548083663,
-0.5018422008,
-0.3968296051,
-1.130086422,
0.2014617622,
-0.2677108943,
-0.3089311421,
-0.1877294481,
0.2057766914,
-0.3999553025,
0.2436110675,
-0.5545606017,
0.8729040027,
-0.1096425876,
-0.2379558235,
-0.2062990665,
-0.5653469563,
0.1419161111,
-0.2590969503,
0.4010866284,
-0.1759586781,
-0.1417212635,
0.9016897082,
-0.5776150227,
0.8005331755,
-0.1617638022,
-0.0096113337,
0.4830264151,
0.2228484899,
0.5234314799,
-0.1652372628,
-0.2026771754,
0.2038058639,
0.0682214424,
-0.722884953,
-0.5955959558,
0.2659786046,
-0.8196797967,
-0.3719364405,
-0.4953231514,
-0.1725015342,
0.0276408419,
0.2446301132,
0.4968295693,
0.7643452883,
-0.2557608783,
0.2074202299,
0.4646907747,
-0.0788946226,
0.2240381092,
0.258605659,
-0.4546326101,
-0.6269612908,
0.751232028,
-0.006697536,
0.4463804066,
0.6088995934,
0.3933726847,
-0.4863271415,
-0.6745572686,
-0.2986207604,
0.1936276704,
-1.0838209391,
-0.2575004101,
-0.6766939759,
0.0277479254,
-0.735304594,
-0.0459698811,
-0.5166698694,
-0.223506704,
-0.2326809764,
-0.2508427799,
0.3060715497,
0.5786904097,
-0.0375377461,
0.474347055,
-0.7828601599,
0.1066775471,
0.3877803981,
0.5137919188,
0.0833244175,
-0.8392386436,
-0.2794629633,
-0.0723811015,
0.1598145515,
-0.607927084,
0.3684219718,
0.2887989581,
0.7512055635,
0.2168828547,
-0.3046206832,
0.8725796938,
-0.5835042596,
0.5902665854,
0.5627906322,
-0.9173613191,
0.5056130886,
-0.184067741,
0.2701426744,
0.8495021462,
0.0341847576,
-0.4667401016,
-0.1480964571,
-0.6074281335,
-0.5053117275,
1.0174511671,
-0.0424055047,
0.2548140883,
-0.2831406295,
0.454623282,
0.2701698542,
0.2356302887,
-0.9087279439,
-0.441275984,
-0.4162712395,
-0.244566828,
0.0205784794,
-0.1589444876,
0.1311038584,
-0.251850754,
0.6041560769,
-0.1394922435,
0.0875400603,
0.0134384334,
-0.283913523,
-0.2589096427,
0.0488467589,
0.643496871,
0.93361485,
-0.1584014595,
0.0359001383,
0.3770353198,
-0.6483194232,
-0.0663176998,
-0.3128339052,
0.16603975,
0.1858822256,
0.7783033848,
1.1605706215,
0.5306153297,
-0.778768003,
0.46234411,
0.0844800025,
-0.226477921,
-0.1104963496,
-0.0052901227,
-0.1947051138,
-0.3133181036,
0.3816046417,
0.0722404271,
-0.4320557117,
-0.8899520636,
0.2316145599,
0.3765597939,
-0.4194940329,
-0.2399645299,
0.5763222575,
0.062948823,
-0.6181874871,
0.547539711,
-0.2656028271,
-0.6068975925,
0.6486216784,
0.6943287849,
0.835741818,
-0.2024451941,
0.0635087267,
0.5936477184,
0.1944463402,
-0.214505434,
0.1218566373,
0.0497267544,
-0.7236379981,
-0.4450751543,
-0.9950317144,
-0.5306460261,
-0.1483015269,
-0.7102559209,
0.4971308708,
-0.6060820222,
-0.1229802817,
-0.2593331933,
-0.0327659175,
-0.8577535748,
0.2463149726,
-0.146200344,
0.8951313496,
-0.6151576638,
1.0708191395,
0.6296620369,
-0.3360154629,
-0.7122183442,
-0.4582208395,
-0.4632350504,
-1.2278072834,
0.8669931293,
0.0420151837,
-0.0914102793,
0.3676959872,
-0.4091598392,
-1.0216310024,
0.87825948,
0.3834224045,
-0.7816922665,
-0.0709168315,
0.2057997137,
0.3794079125,
-0.5442304611,
0.3079153001,
0.3788674474,
0.2630790472,
0.0590523146,
-0.8564462662,
-0.3564816415,
-0.062132705,
0.0229201298,
0.473204881,
-0.3712295294,
1.0114269257,
-0.2504221499,
-0.3771730661,
0.0759223327,
0.5844739676,
0.5168263912,
0.3170104623,
0.5524197817,
0.6172840595,
0.7443552017,
0.1382787079,
1.1406302452,
-0.4238031209,
0.3682783842,
1.106931448,
-0.1316112578,
0.900650084,
0.3741624057,
-0.3894760609,
0.4052747488,
0.6315966845,
0.4063853025,
0.5382870436,
0.2819212973,
0.0690060779,
-0.6099542379,
0.1442715377,
-0.3480522037,
0.407189548,
0.1498533934,
-0.0179871395,
-0.2372971773,
0.2848660946,
-0.0534863658,
0.2431878,
-0.2767850757,
0.6635893583,
0.1375835538,
-0.794672668,
0.6078357697,
-0.1589461565,
0.8707121611,
-0.9953249097,
0.218727529,
-0.43219468,
0.1658844203,
-0.0232033283,
-0.3098293841,
0.3581448793,
-0.0393157154,
-0.0528757982,
-0.4113386869,
0.632019043,
-0.2286531031,
-0.5886534452,
0.312027365,
0.6959845424,
0.3102597594,
-0.1198714972,
-0.7208932638,
0.1752643585,
-0.2086883038,
-0.1959319115,
0.5079988241,
0.3568374217,
0.0705004036,
0.7023084164,
0.8110738993,
0.1829029471,
0.3440316021,
0.4757814407,
0.6380832195,
-0.7265409231,
-0.4336142838,
-0.8073112369,
0.3219940662,
0.1893496364,
-0.7905968428,
0.5265327692,
0.5288593769,
0.7558444738,
0.0061218706,
0.6114361882,
0.3242016137,
0.7377447486,
-0.4899202287,
0.3763973713,
-0.6027033329,
-0.0557037294,
-0.0645491555,
-0.9219651222,
-0.4526044428,
0.7851623297,
0.0625444055,
-0.0332699232,
0.911266923,
0.7767118812,
0.2082612365,
-0.2552069724,
0.581686914,
-0.157426253,
0.2073881626,
0.3002856076,
0.7577930093,
-0.6476085782,
0.6961404681,
-0.0589869432,
-0.1055069193,
-0.2148873508,
-0.7461662292,
-1.0656886101,
-0.4642407596,
-0.2223494053,
-0.1500530243,
-0.0276212152,
0.9995684624,
0.9296744466,
-0.7955979109,
-0.1364287287,
-0.4841679633,
-0.0192414578,
-0.2655336261,
-0.1459079981,
0.1970745325,
-0.8189353347,
-0.6324064732,
0.2615211308,
0.197750479,
0.0388763361,
-0.4403100908,
-0.0996403173,
-0.1432900578,
-0.021698989,
0.4826157689,
0.2251279354,
-0.9383410215,
-0.1165720895,
0.4798559844,
-0.186090216,
0.0676969364,
0.9856695533,
-0.9117337465,
0.4080150723,
0.4213913679,
0.6967141628,
0.5380558372,
-0.1236806139,
0.3221721351,
-0.7364202738,
0.4986851215,
0.3553613722,
0.3103280067,
0.1481654048,
0.0308595691,
0.4807884693,
0.2394569516,
-0.3579456508,
-1.0390474796,
0.2805310488,
-0.9114308357,
-0.341611445,
1.0025355816,
-0.0529516563,
-0.273471266,
-0.1154261529,
-0.1623093337,
0.3485518098,
-0.3320607245,
0.5883435607,
0.9469397068,
0.1190874651,
-0.216014266,
-0.3615172505,
0.4417966306,
0.7874774933,
-0.6135166883,
0.1821867526,
0.0509526581,
0.2540459335,
0.2255553007,
0.9283466935,
0.0845106244,
0.1397580951,
0.2848788798,
0.1107021645,
-0.1242725179,
-0.5340439677,
-0.3423880041,
0.1673448086,
0.2368394434,
-0.3102351725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08707v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08707v4
|
Large Language Model Can Continue Evolving From Mistakes
| 2024-04-11T17:44:56 | 2024-06-17T11:32:29 |
Haokun Zhao, Haixia Han, Jie Shi, Chengyu Du, Jiaqing Liang, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
As world knowledge evolves and new task paradigms emerge, Continual Learning
(CL) is crucial for keeping Large Language Models (LLMs) up-to-date and
addressing their shortcomings. In practical applications, LLMs often require
both continual instruction tuning (CIT) and continual pre-training (CPT) to
adapt to new task paradigms and acquire necessary knowledge for task-solving.
However, it remains challenging to collect CPT data that addresses the
knowledge deficiencies in models while maintaining adequate volume, and
improving the efficiency of utilizing this data also presents significant
difficulties. Inspired by the 'summarizing mistakes' learning skill, we propose
the Continue Evolving from Mistakes (CEM) method, aiming to provide a
data-efficient approach for collecting CPT data and continually improving LLMs'
performance through iterative evaluation and supplementation with
mistake-relevant knowledge. To efficiently utilize these CPT data and mitigate
forgetting, we design a novel CL training set construction paradigm that
integrates parallel CIT and CPT data. Extensive experiments demonstrate the
efficacy of the CEM method, achieving up to a 17% improvement in accuracy in
the best case. Furthermore, additional experiments confirm the potential of
combining CEM with catastrophic forgetting mitigation methods, enabling
iterative and continual model evolution.
|
[
-0.0162173994,
-0.7413511872,
0.4955199063,
0.2983920872,
-0.2376855314,
0.3587453365,
-0.6600763202,
-0.0085389968,
-0.2929733694,
0.4695749879,
-0.664604485,
-0.423458457,
-0.5702502728,
-0.1605423987,
-0.029166704,
0.9162835479,
-0.1042401493,
0.1657817662,
-0.3025101721,
-0.2371107042,
-1.0652729273,
-0.5019119978,
-1.120079875,
-0.1773960739,
0.4193170965,
0.7564789653,
0.3881402314,
0.7559633851,
0.2684789002,
0.2584632039,
-0.0565426573,
0.4710658491,
-0.7876669765,
0.0623171329,
-0.4839155972,
-0.4426169395,
-0.2478980124,
-0.307103157,
0.9460599422,
0.8457064033,
-0.3689934909,
0.0091852089,
0.3476783037,
0.7777662277,
-0.5608423352,
0.2889679968,
-0.9385274053,
-0.1282370985,
-0.1788113117,
-0.2891088128,
-0.5459192991,
-0.2672218978,
0.1469253153,
-0.4188205898,
0.2732027471,
-0.0996519476,
0.6200842857,
0.3951022029,
0.1958520412,
-0.3834378719,
-0.6926090717,
0.9853330255,
-0.7666687965,
0.4480781853,
0.1478712112,
0.1538141072,
-0.2063809931,
-0.522185266,
-0.4563787282,
-0.2952601016,
0.2973715961,
0.1678168476,
0.3232091963,
-0.3474928737,
0.0787581131,
0.1230331734,
-0.5996834636,
0.1832460463,
-0.3540014625,
-0.0272708312,
0.4737730026,
0.1229969338,
0.404180944,
0.584610641,
-0.3146902025,
-0.3544147611,
-1.1190826893,
-0.1413873732,
-0.0394470505,
0.3057534695,
-0.1240520626,
-0.0065292288,
0.202438578,
0.7398249507,
-0.0731097534,
-0.2854397893,
0.3048499823,
-0.2748252451,
-0.1369163692,
-0.0134341419,
0.5425401926,
0.0465560704,
0.4397277236,
-0.1547899544,
-0.1618747562,
-0.0796250403,
0.4600337148,
-0.2709112167,
-0.5249210596,
-0.1029090881,
-0.1092450693,
0.0245917384,
-0.188570708,
-0.5899896622,
-0.1121328399,
-0.6966798902,
0.3021807671,
-0.7056652904,
-0.2292809784,
0.2417124659,
0.084844999,
0.0703414455,
0.2504313588,
-0.6946088076,
0.0366828777,
0.5892285109,
0.8146755099,
-0.2004777789,
-0.5977749825,
-0.5646926165,
0.2033686042,
-0.6523481607,
0.703535378,
-0.3228730559,
-0.5180629492,
-0.0083562704,
0.0917412266,
-0.491997093,
-0.8214187026,
0.3596189022,
-0.4911845922,
-0.0148328142,
-0.531422019,
-0.643640995,
-0.0812642127,
0.444218725,
-0.3672825992,
0.7690290809,
0.1800842434,
-0.5861893296,
0.3774624169,
-0.4511114359,
-0.1767715663,
0.1549533159,
-0.0955641344,
-0.849899292,
0.1809277087,
0.2142461985,
0.3344775736,
-0.0433222689,
0.289372474,
-0.3525929153,
-0.2871362269,
-0.0442179628,
-0.3542379737,
0.612985909,
-0.223543033,
-0.3202341199,
-0.2076048255,
-0.5070335269,
-0.0644170791,
0.263355732,
-0.4558415413,
-0.2569394112,
0.3068473041,
-0.4478799403,
0.4201916754,
0.408819288,
-0.4350000918,
0.1552767754,
-0.2353422046,
0.1712446958,
0.8599416018,
0.2588487267,
0.1046852618,
-0.8400635719,
0.2731253803,
0.2961096168,
0.1207514703,
-0.4468041956,
-0.0482546426,
-1.1900111437,
0.1604036689,
0.0620621629,
0.7171400189,
-0.8121262789,
0.4020345509,
-0.6928008795,
-0.6678573489,
-0.0056127966,
0.4465534985,
0.6178575158,
0.4868232906,
0.6197798848,
-0.1794728041,
-0.6266489029,
-0.5222480893,
-0.1822789311,
-0.1245138347,
0.2494129837,
0.0541851185,
0.4218812585,
-0.2478609085,
0.79832232,
-0.2309329361,
-0.0476710796,
-0.2581255436,
0.0841787905,
0.0304132458,
0.8703606725,
0.3029369414,
-0.4553053379,
-0.5754480958,
0.0649960488,
-0.849948585,
0.1663237661,
-0.4980410039,
-0.1308775991,
0.1596793681,
0.6006708145,
-0.3478961289,
-0.0210016277,
0.3754312694,
-0.0976165533,
0.7482160926,
-0.3537363112,
-0.0125699919,
-0.8849598169,
-0.2022700906,
-0.3530447185,
-0.2480958104,
-0.3324581087,
-0.1516294926,
0.3685542345,
0.1747709811,
-0.3663413227,
0.4788413644,
-0.641623497,
0.231130749,
-0.3310931027,
0.0179550759,
-0.3860371113,
0.5534595847,
0.1213143915,
0.6724969149,
0.7667797804,
-0.8672690988,
-0.011782567,
0.2600673735,
-0.1476776898,
0.4585596025,
-0.2542147636,
0.3079606295,
-0.2291961461,
-0.0466959365,
-0.4845224023,
-0.0291255973,
-0.0399250425,
-0.3932481706,
0.682636261,
0.0538783409,
-0.5085759759,
-0.3577939868,
-0.1043903753,
0.1723450571,
0.6539365649,
-0.869807899,
0.3750325739,
0.1255768687,
-0.5583214164,
-0.6153857112,
-0.3598228097,
0.0671750978,
-0.1867130995,
-0.4803493321,
0.1684824377,
-0.3695489466,
-0.0086418083,
-0.2625493705,
-0.2884290516,
0.2190968245,
-0.0603393354,
-0.0841680169,
0.312852025,
-0.1146976203,
0.3975665867,
-0.012354115,
-0.0055712913,
-0.040363688,
-0.5732826591,
0.6913397908,
-0.088030383,
-0.2033597082,
-0.2636311948,
0.1432669163,
0.5006127954,
-0.0768645778,
0.7847946882,
0.1407615095,
-0.301045686,
-0.5872613192,
-0.7598397732,
-0.0292349569,
-0.4451679289,
0.4991767108,
-0.2617628872,
-0.8440904021,
0.3973419964,
-0.2521105111,
0.5506900549,
0.2983699143,
0.4578022063,
-0.3528294861,
0.5812715888,
0.8805627823,
-0.2289226055,
0.4866409898,
-0.1150304899,
0.0258624423,
-0.7173451185,
-0.0879633725,
-0.2659485042,
-0.0404430553,
-0.0846254081,
-0.3883918524,
0.3243062198,
0.4625852704,
-0.611675024,
0.3417725563,
-0.2857609987,
0.4547921717,
0.2445280552,
0.393684864,
0.2589607537,
0.0385154337,
0.0174260419,
0.0068500373,
-0.8875626326,
-0.2578499615,
1.2190511227,
0.2880335152,
0.5444949865,
-0.0779802427,
0.7006568313,
0.1436801255,
0.6028368473,
-0.245723024,
0.3218070567,
-0.1310037225,
-0.037426088,
-0.2615363896,
-0.5120613575,
-0.6855081916,
-0.0688540041,
0.2282124609,
-0.6350866556,
0.0813256651,
0.7561281323,
-0.1614194512,
0.4395217896,
-0.4347051084,
0.7754701972,
-0.3479319215,
-0.345176965,
-0.3292532563,
-0.4675631821,
0.3461757898,
-0.5623438954,
0.2829820514,
0.1583523899,
-0.0503719337,
0.7025315166,
-0.5477539897,
0.9464001656,
-0.122836329,
-0.0271248072,
0.4587163329,
0.0275627896,
0.7499634624,
0.0845445395,
0.1288862228,
0.1907069385,
-0.2275268286,
-0.6345083714,
-0.4621863365,
0.735988915,
-0.663898468,
-0.4270804822,
-0.2430139035,
-0.5713461041,
-0.5771335363,
0.001058046,
0.4783031344,
0.3391576111,
-0.0827315301,
0.2346509546,
0.9812641144,
-0.3073031902,
0.6446175575,
0.4639092982,
0.1979489326,
-0.4116320312,
1.0707029104,
0.1927429289,
0.4842091799,
0.156086579,
0.1801487058,
-0.1689945757,
-0.7892974019,
-0.2736010551,
0.3528333306,
-0.7132291198,
-0.3188960254,
-0.6538117528,
-0.2351098359,
-0.1657700241,
-0.4676989615,
-0.6251555085,
0.2692221105,
-0.0147628291,
0.0381936021,
0.2080774307,
0.3142841458,
-0.2332279682,
0.467697531,
-1.0926766396,
-0.2225423157,
0.243392244,
0.1962366402,
0.0515899993,
-0.6017560959,
-0.5889007449,
0.1509559005,
-0.3832538128,
-0.5932964683,
0.4522459507,
0.3333017528,
0.5173633099,
0.0526219197,
-0.2968715131,
0.7900345922,
-0.5851832628,
0.7592895627,
0.2787590921,
-0.6934243441,
0.4588919282,
-0.4461988807,
0.7065476179,
0.7152299285,
0.205698967,
-0.6087840796,
-0.3129479885,
-0.6980993748,
-0.7107053995,
0.5061071515,
-0.0840058103,
0.074617587,
-0.2256389409,
0.4613697231,
0.1397829354,
0.1269216239,
-0.685485065,
0.0658335909,
-0.0932163894,
-0.3210150898,
-0.2444141507,
-0.1620631516,
0.1040802822,
-0.2020216286,
1.0507297516,
-0.1616829783,
0.1625767499,
-0.1233007908,
-0.515088439,
0.1258527786,
0.163498044,
0.5436306,
0.9802426696,
0.1723522693,
-0.1518940628,
0.6604870558,
-0.5583464503,
-0.0012477543,
-0.2848125398,
-0.0707325637,
0.0169305205,
0.4309469461,
0.5927051902,
0.4522370398,
-0.9473239183,
0.3695040643,
0.236633271,
-0.1629770547,
-0.8991257548,
0.2202453315,
0.3486305773,
0.0475765169,
0.1038345322,
0.1289044619,
-0.5173213482,
-0.4304458201,
0.4696969688,
0.1215421855,
-0.4064682424,
-0.0457448103,
0.2465738654,
-0.1884635091,
-0.1689482778,
0.920160234,
-0.2072202414,
-0.5622939467,
0.6843115091,
0.6864328384,
0.6894196868,
-0.4970130026,
-0.0412761047,
0.6719183326,
0.2746728361,
-0.7501031756,
0.2907589376,
-0.1180950552,
-0.7889804244,
-0.4545323253,
-0.7365639806,
-0.325783819,
0.3005128205,
-0.4228254855,
0.3566757143,
-0.7024083734,
0.4070638716,
-0.5787117481,
-0.4148025215,
-0.7440336943,
0.377946645,
-0.0391082279,
0.7844238281,
-0.5622654557,
0.9711544514,
0.405362606,
-0.2210793644,
-0.9482426643,
0.0106838411,
0.1018644124,
-0.5978727341,
0.5409814715,
0.0548902303,
0.0579087809,
0.1242284253,
-0.5632370114,
-1.0208051205,
1.0845803022,
0.1631553918,
-1.3068010807,
-0.0894024074,
-0.0755189955,
0.2599945664,
-0.373612076,
-0.1710996628,
0.8307608366,
0.293056637,
0.1122786626,
-0.8143542409,
-0.2453392297,
-0.1025245935,
0.0359174795,
0.3333151937,
-0.6313269734,
0.8399839997,
-0.2589921057,
-0.2541128993,
0.0410538204,
0.4925355017,
0.6013250351,
0.068530418,
0.5996882319,
0.8733440042,
0.7807790637,
-0.1552644819,
0.6456062794,
-0.2422656864,
0.4937725067,
1.6889992952,
-0.0665729791,
0.8028230071,
0.1061825603,
0.0936184898,
0.4258586168,
0.7627025247,
-0.1970579177,
0.5208954811,
0.3300255537,
-0.5228792429,
-0.401824832,
0.5599917173,
-0.3155804276,
0.2605164945,
0.6200852394,
-0.2837014794,
-0.4268755317,
0.3304703534,
0.3661398888,
0.1546553224,
-0.4981935918,
0.7796109319,
0.1620293558,
-0.826947093,
0.7331749797,
-0.2285977155,
0.6767858267,
-0.6097685695,
-0.0275053903,
-0.1758346558,
0.3770308197,
0.1330711842,
-0.2842004299,
0.4934500158,
-0.104811959,
-0.2578373551,
-0.1953987926,
0.3606148064,
-0.5525816083,
-0.508433044,
0.18150343,
0.3779885173,
0.0526758954,
0.0516422763,
-0.7127480507,
0.2393016666,
0.0933442712,
-0.0148314247,
0.2651574314,
0.1946235448,
-0.2153760344,
0.6843631268,
0.6289461255,
0.135799244,
0.1812909693,
-0.0689158812,
0.793002069,
-0.7173293233,
-0.5542010069,
-0.9172808528,
0.6885575652,
-0.2464823425,
-0.5312556624,
0.340675205,
0.4322380424,
1.1455415487,
-0.2226377428,
0.9768092632,
0.198046878,
0.6721416712,
-0.7083963752,
0.7356974483,
-0.3188534081,
0.3681481183,
-0.0396358073,
-1.027848959,
-0.149015829,
0.399020046,
-0.2742619216,
0.0733085647,
0.9643886089,
0.6900380254,
0.031978,
-0.0643294603,
0.3989827931,
0.3768187463,
0.3380323946,
1.001984477,
0.5119128823,
-0.2671343088,
0.3560319543,
-0.0821851641,
-0.3861037195,
0.1838749051,
-0.7043076158,
-0.8472260833,
-0.5859656334,
-0.5265569687,
-0.1890442967,
0.3999764323,
0.7886815667,
0.6479921937,
-0.7279197574,
0.0216497742,
-0.5512024164,
-0.2036059946,
-0.4407047331,
-0.1274946779,
0.5116629004,
-1.080699563,
-0.6844733357,
0.6795166731,
0.306487143,
-0.0855193138,
-0.0688600913,
-0.2348641902,
-0.0828650072,
-0.0390587077,
0.4885209799,
0.7191332579,
-0.3447037637,
-0.5399059057,
-0.1079362184,
0.1834540218,
0.1032821685,
0.7326120138,
-0.7850934267,
0.5962821841,
0.1117440239,
1.0885730982,
0.459692508,
-0.2918364406,
0.729737103,
-0.7308466434,
-0.1352199465,
0.2321401834,
0.5217766166,
0.6027387977,
-0.3859607279,
0.3618556559,
0.3983798921,
-0.70032686,
-0.5710018873,
0.18827115,
-0.8607660532,
-0.3116339743,
0.7926107645,
-0.4053961337,
-0.0460286811,
-0.3418619931,
0.0470345803,
0.2998234034,
0.0320737362,
0.9393334389,
0.6878606677,
0.0629138872,
-0.4882132113,
-0.5707265735,
0.5068004727,
0.5475010872,
-0.9815036058,
0.1426699758,
0.3896959722,
0.7730413079,
0.079223685,
0.5626344085,
-0.385261029,
0.5031765699,
0.0511459075,
0.0455320552,
-0.0105687352,
-0.5964611173,
-0.1754175574,
0.1445325911,
0.1331668943,
-0.2207103372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07922v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07922v5
|
LaVy: Vietnamese Multimodal Large Language Model
| 2024-04-11T17:09:28 | 2024-05-26T10:27:51 |
Chi Tran, Huong Le Thanh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) and Multimodal Large language models (MLLMs)
have taken the world by storm with impressive abilities in complex reasoning
and linguistic comprehension. Meanwhile there are plethora of works related to
Vietnamese Large Language Models, the lack of high-quality resources in
multimodality limits the progress of Vietnamese MLLMs. In this paper, we
pioneer in address this by introducing LaVy, a state-of-the-art Vietnamese
MLLM, and we also introduce LaVy-Bench benchmark designated for evaluating
MLLMs's understanding on Vietnamese visual language tasks. Our project is
public at https://github.com/baochi0212/LaVy
|
[
-0.2770880759,
-1.0660768747,
0.7406666279,
0.2911621332,
-0.1721417457,
0.1185351536,
-0.3605679274,
-0.3670833409,
-0.1535812467,
0.719319582,
-0.2498703003,
-0.5173401237,
-0.5111566186,
-0.1178891957,
-0.4229352474,
0.5430611968,
-0.2242859453,
0.1974143088,
-0.2941347063,
-0.4169356823,
-0.136839956,
-0.5393693447,
-0.4812058508,
-0.2556905746,
0.73647964,
0.2045139372,
0.3989672959,
0.635148406,
0.5769007206,
0.3319604099,
-0.0303544998,
0.3820131421,
-0.7417439222,
0.267670691,
-0.0588195063,
-0.6545429826,
-0.466678381,
-0.3180595636,
0.7336966991,
0.3776839674,
0.0787387937,
0.3303456008,
-0.2906875014,
0.6659846902,
-0.7718935609,
0.4229251146,
-0.5557707548,
-0.2598620057,
-0.1949251145,
-0.1760651767,
-0.2952531278,
-0.03212744,
0.0367694199,
-0.5455862284,
-0.0967165232,
-0.087342307,
0.5865897536,
0.4158963561,
-0.7273898721,
0.1215429455,
-0.3158114851,
0.9644352198,
-0.5483046174,
0.6091362834,
0.2552032173,
0.4990933239,
-0.2029326409,
-0.8960028291,
-0.550194025,
-0.6419793367,
0.1441905648,
0.1758759022,
0.0026100948,
-0.0517084263,
0.1446320713,
0.1908975393,
-0.6389217377,
0.1435081959,
-0.4642829299,
-0.025922196,
0.7164551616,
0.3077346087,
0.1664505005,
-0.0787619352,
-0.5962482691,
0.2544378936,
-0.4821341336,
0.0431702733,
0.071991764,
0.3572060764,
-0.1402689219,
0.8636453152,
-0.3876409531,
1.0449054241,
-0.5046603084,
-0.6102743745,
0.3625486195,
-0.5141236782,
-0.4358318746,
-0.2949980497,
0.7061192989,
0.5888794661,
0.3594363928,
0.2469173819,
-0.3562074006,
0.2215306759,
-0.0182027128,
-0.3594063818,
0.1878480911,
0.4039544761,
-0.563931644,
-0.1403750926,
-0.046823401,
-0.6077514887,
-0.7046283484,
-0.3938786387,
0.4791463614,
-0.1488409936,
-0.6498519778,
0.1907248199,
-0.1270321161,
0.4045360982,
0.607863009,
-0.4853240848,
-0.1302697212,
0.7963936925,
0.8784564137,
-0.4773561358,
-0.5014494061,
-0.7557208538,
0.1965997517,
-0.18150042,
0.7274606228,
-0.4973013699,
-0.2273387611,
0.4153312147,
0.1168690696,
0.1356186867,
-0.6052668691,
0.407440722,
-0.303958565,
-0.1296153963,
0.0078540454,
-0.4069933891,
-0.2223190814,
0.4496409297,
-0.7837015986,
1.1163159609,
0.3377330601,
-0.5345678926,
0.0838045701,
-0.4654121995,
-0.0816136748,
0.1592656374,
-0.0491112471,
-0.0803380832,
0.2142968476,
0.09130916,
0.7515129447,
-0.4331942201,
0.3455104828,
-0.3868382275,
-0.3407793343,
0.4348386526,
-0.3409481347,
0.8121234775,
0.4810117781,
0.0128827943,
0.588983357,
-0.8968773484,
0.0341363512,
0.2321809679,
-0.4862667024,
-0.316452235,
-0.4856852889,
0.6515859962,
0.2498963922,
0.6070005894,
-0.0761472955,
0.2732508779,
0.1753010303,
0.5120625496,
0.590541482,
-0.312966913,
0.3694796562,
-0.1979717314,
0.4584441483,
-0.0013241738,
0.1633415669,
-0.4913324416,
-0.3678433597,
-1.0792491436,
-0.6877838969,
-0.091143623,
0.6761777997,
-0.9727574587,
-0.0130622601,
-0.0913297981,
-0.6190295815,
-0.63366431,
0.383839339,
0.3942565024,
0.0389599502,
0.2353896797,
-0.0765559003,
-0.5148183703,
-0.9168467522,
-0.3668275177,
-0.2385079563,
0.0370954759,
0.1177522466,
0.5062722564,
-0.5745816827,
0.5336267948,
-0.2413644642,
-0.2215463668,
-0.453519851,
-0.094743982,
0.2062229663,
0.1064269617,
0.6402552724,
-0.9113191962,
-0.5572133064,
0.0657574236,
-0.9160649776,
-0.2428441048,
0.0919460133,
-0.0368627794,
0.3291299641,
0.8915818334,
-0.752004683,
0.280411154,
0.7716279626,
-0.4738054872,
0.6916512847,
-0.3268767297,
0.1094008461,
-0.8724222183,
-0.1179368123,
0.147407487,
-0.4917280078,
-0.7691563368,
0.5151785612,
0.1026888639,
0.2574110329,
-0.8881451488,
0.9767790437,
-0.5511496067,
-0.0993034989,
-0.185677588,
0.3860242665,
-0.143207714,
0.2582440376,
-0.0048523024,
0.5267095566,
0.5445445776,
-0.4375664294,
1.0211845636,
-0.1995384991,
-0.4909478724,
0.8108691573,
-0.5594331026,
-0.1998214424,
-0.2075732946,
0.066226691,
-0.8144196272,
-0.3202413917,
0.0408103056,
-0.1067520604,
0.114820689,
-0.1234708875,
-0.3906566501,
-0.3411923349,
-0.236651361,
0.3195728362,
0.2865888476,
-0.4770109057,
0.5547234416,
0.4865927398,
0.0382677764,
-0.7527288198,
-0.5086680651,
0.140593648,
-0.423327446,
-0.3847420812,
-0.1683201641,
-0.1580749899,
-0.7457444668,
-0.1563512385,
0.2466367334,
-0.1937464923,
-0.2558068633,
0.1100209132,
0.2537635863,
-0.4330023229,
0.3139887452,
-0.6368767619,
-0.1527633667,
-0.1579907984,
-0.2831368148,
0.563893497,
-0.4973570406,
-0.3924046159,
-0.3140385747,
0.1555280536,
0.9995360374,
-0.4061779678,
0.6829618812,
1.0567278862,
-0.1656185538,
0.0372950621,
-0.8896739483,
0.5290510654,
-0.4134509861,
1.0204766989,
-0.4547198415,
-1.0655641556,
0.1906737387,
-0.067918241,
-0.0083256308,
0.2176280469,
1.0024086237,
-0.0024119043,
0.6017818451,
0.6922313571,
-0.0506424606,
0.6657614112,
-0.2049732953,
-0.1595731527,
-0.6081346869,
-0.2228716612,
-0.2786664963,
0.0361766145,
-0.7475998998,
-1.1344345808,
0.207740739,
0.1046273559,
-0.4493104517,
0.0539846048,
-0.1587095559,
0.1778254211,
0.67203933,
-0.0631349459,
0.5581195951,
-0.0680828094,
0.1092853323,
0.1189331114,
-0.4945761859,
-0.5440480709,
1.1642363071,
0.4394592941,
0.9935606122,
0.0796439499,
0.5061756968,
0.1285132915,
0.0989445597,
-0.8609393239,
0.6987205744,
-0.1588683128,
-0.4255212247,
-0.4624938071,
-0.4323525131,
-0.8147414923,
0.5276377201,
-0.3298329115,
-0.6646245718,
-0.3660337925,
0.058401227,
0.1289450526,
0.243382439,
-0.6558305025,
0.857299149,
-0.7743264437,
-0.5316645503,
-0.3245974183,
-0.2882831991,
0.5653985739,
-0.1487082094,
0.4417198896,
-0.4230087996,
-0.5159553289,
0.4277535379,
-0.1267754585,
0.548021853,
-0.1885289103,
-0.2147104293,
0.4207274914,
-0.1245689765,
0.412425369,
0.3233226836,
0.230487287,
0.1878717393,
0.0626513064,
-0.5308309793,
-0.4901505411,
1.0268679857,
-0.8213767409,
-0.5601370931,
-0.376408577,
-0.724268496,
-0.0964155942,
0.3971668184,
-0.1810716838,
0.0732276663,
-0.2540772259,
0.2516023517,
0.6697851419,
-0.4812193215,
0.3767769635,
0.5061789751,
-0.8182418346,
-0.4891741872,
0.9873434305,
0.0347337909,
0.3652128577,
0.4984938204,
0.0137404157,
-0.2561525106,
-0.4938972592,
-0.2499485761,
0.4220880866,
-0.8509963751,
0.0622487478,
-0.6382281184,
-0.2899350822,
-0.1261065453,
-0.065447472,
-0.5517956018,
-0.4660590887,
-0.1169878915,
0.2235319912,
0.391533196,
1.0241057873,
0.2405172884,
0.1355741769,
-0.7948638201,
0.7144126296,
0.5245177746,
0.3490335047,
-0.1653832346,
-0.4860221148,
-0.2735883594,
-0.1498006433,
0.1430455297,
-0.3456526697,
0.3155588508,
-0.0379395001,
0.9280470014,
0.3712105453,
-0.2293403298,
0.7213067412,
-0.3424133062,
0.7716631293,
0.3387027085,
-0.6932890415,
0.3092928529,
-0.498020798,
0.7397797704,
0.132834807,
0.1310557574,
-0.5379047394,
-0.3118390441,
-0.2682811916,
-0.7920081019,
0.1017811969,
-0.0359922647,
-0.118763186,
0.4321785569,
0.129721418,
0.1215584949,
0.307510674,
-0.962667644,
-0.2165439725,
-0.215997383,
-0.256608367,
-0.525447607,
-0.481164366,
0.0158698205,
-0.2217734158,
0.4833892286,
-0.2023551166,
0.0746223256,
-0.128098011,
-0.3609353602,
0.0407819115,
0.3039130569,
0.9086475372,
0.8371733427,
-0.1212065741,
0.300237596,
0.2548772991,
-0.450648427,
0.2277874053,
-0.0820423216,
0.0423367247,
-0.0085164644,
0.8119530082,
0.7413604259,
0.0166300461,
-1.1285965443,
0.430903703,
-0.1205759421,
-0.0254570767,
-0.4404814541,
0.0762304813,
0.4002851546,
0.6644791961,
0.2861948013,
-0.2119659185,
-0.3031810224,
-0.5517297387,
-0.0772539675,
0.5706069469,
-0.5676056743,
-0.0737565681,
0.5341554284,
0.2120495588,
-0.1950701922,
0.3558671176,
0.2063803375,
-0.4153165221,
0.3335328996,
0.4172588289,
0.5924502015,
-0.1878219992,
0.0055310517,
0.4639036059,
0.3959854245,
-0.2532280087,
0.4596198499,
0.2070667893,
-0.5004104376,
-0.4556494057,
-0.7659384012,
-0.1466871351,
0.4216140211,
-0.4605310261,
0.4660621881,
-0.1743405461,
-0.2215327919,
-0.3209707141,
-0.037227001,
-0.7730972171,
0.1194756925,
0.3285516798,
1.0576598644,
-0.5449244976,
1.0294612646,
0.8848830462,
-0.3023562431,
-0.1030541807,
-0.2631702721,
0.1470237225,
-1.0851655006,
0.777923286,
0.2892567515,
-0.1167344898,
-0.2645990849,
-0.5520800352,
-0.9392709732,
0.9674922228,
0.4528829753,
-0.6456725597,
0.1778946817,
0.2145579606,
0.5444108844,
-0.4622358382,
0.1530924588,
0.6536861658,
0.683699429,
-0.0952986926,
-1.2279529572,
-0.277241081,
-0.2690501213,
0.1259609312,
-0.0893650874,
-0.9663870335,
0.9853880405,
-0.4108746648,
0.2126926929,
0.1993408203,
0.6998791099,
0.4528676271,
0.282941252,
0.5612677336,
0.3080088794,
0.6735146046,
-0.0963460729,
0.750138998,
0.0466512702,
0.2881593704,
1.0660346746,
-0.1962248236,
1.1719107628,
0.6791183949,
-0.2564465702,
0.1247011349,
0.5190194845,
0.0871048123,
0.3309964836,
0.310623616,
-0.2608919144,
-0.4737844467,
-0.324637413,
-0.4240650237,
0.7343569398,
0.5325738788,
-0.169199571,
0.2678498328,
0.1015081033,
-0.0802021846,
0.0667468831,
-0.5783688426,
0.5280604959,
0.1802153587,
-0.5216866732,
0.8600990176,
-0.2553355396,
0.6759576797,
-0.6157000661,
-0.0894539654,
-0.0706314072,
0.4292658567,
-0.077447623,
-0.8251382113,
-0.1997162849,
-0.160766691,
-0.0446727835,
-0.090047963,
0.6317387819,
-0.744265914,
-0.6147034168,
0.610604465,
0.8376452327,
0.000187242,
0.0203878954,
-0.6299419403,
0.4994252026,
-0.1206362993,
-0.4039843678,
0.2591202557,
0.5763852596,
-0.2089770287,
1.0734270811,
0.4796691239,
0.1250414252,
0.1505325437,
0.2127284706,
0.7480958104,
-0.8422518373,
-0.3797787428,
-0.8266488314,
0.608510077,
-0.0970370248,
-0.1471322179,
0.8579387665,
0.4801819324,
0.9442366362,
-0.3000137508,
1.0171197653,
0.1221064329,
0.2796964645,
-0.5527507663,
0.7007929087,
-0.9052155018,
0.1038610265,
-0.276037395,
-0.9617029428,
-0.52050668,
0.548001349,
0.1566701978,
-0.0054025357,
0.6812570095,
0.7074052095,
0.0901420563,
-0.4598105848,
0.7744681239,
0.5621446967,
0.2980762422,
0.6118443012,
1.3012996912,
-0.1947864592,
0.6814647913,
0.0190683622,
-0.3708292842,
-0.503911972,
-0.9036265612,
-1.3284153938,
-0.7220857739,
-0.0204157904,
-0.2691766024,
0.0049840859,
0.8855156302,
0.5953669548,
-0.6506856084,
-0.7013263106,
0.3517793417,
0.1332855523,
-0.1394884437,
-0.1557176262,
0.1938336045,
-0.1625852883,
-0.776792109,
0.3957378864,
0.4689439237,
0.1400307417,
-0.7438486814,
-0.3650434911,
-0.4121363163,
-0.197989285,
0.96454072,
0.058076635,
-1.2142658234,
-0.1195531711,
-0.0082070297,
-0.3223991394,
-0.1188237369,
0.854118824,
-0.753549993,
0.7428713441,
0.4841500819,
0.3196167648,
0.5539622307,
-0.3788706958,
0.569034934,
-0.2673031688,
0.6552915573,
-0.2157453895,
0.6424232125,
0.4544376433,
0.0389109515,
0.7448684573,
0.1441507488,
-0.5230949521,
-0.9505041838,
0.2355762422,
-1.1832021475,
-0.2262214422,
1.3332307339,
-0.1151823923,
-0.3343992531,
-0.2300573438,
-0.5615394711,
0.2710415423,
-0.2120503783,
0.3990228474,
0.5751456022,
-0.0007836857,
-0.5238410234,
-1.0530107021,
0.2310533673,
-0.0948192403,
-0.8737257719,
0.2255185097,
0.4632806778,
-0.0418423302,
0.0590249561,
0.6595628262,
0.1864570975,
0.2764243186,
0.0613518469,
-0.1385174692,
-0.1892031133,
-0.3100888431,
-0.2107169777,
0.1164465174,
0.2659989893,
0.2384600639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07921v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07921v2
|
AmpleGCG: Learning a Universal and Transferable Generative Model of Adversarial Suffixes for Jailbreaking Both Open and Closed LLMs
| 2024-04-11T17:05:50 | 2024-05-02T01:08:37 |
Zeyi Liao, Huan Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As large language models (LLMs) become increasingly prevalent and integrated
into autonomous systems, ensuring their safety is imperative. Despite
significant strides toward safety alignment, recent work
GCG~\citep{zou2023universal} proposes a discrete token optimization algorithm
and selects the single suffix with the lowest loss to successfully jailbreak
aligned LLMs. In this work, we first discuss the drawbacks of solely picking
the suffix with the lowest loss during GCG optimization for jailbreaking and
uncover the missed successful suffixes during the intermediate steps. Moreover,
we utilize those successful suffixes as training data to learn a generative
model, named AmpleGCG, which captures the distribution of adversarial suffixes
given a harmful query and enables the rapid generation of hundreds of suffixes
for any harmful queries in seconds. AmpleGCG achieves near 100\% attack success
rate (ASR) on two aligned LLMs (Llama-2-7B-chat and Vicuna-7B), surpassing two
strongest attack baselines. More interestingly, AmpleGCG also transfers
seamlessly to attack different models, including closed-source LLMs, achieving
a 99\% ASR on the latest GPT-3.5. To summarize, our work amplifies the impact
of GCG by training a generative model of adversarial suffixes that is universal
to any harmful queries and transferable from attacking open-source LLMs to
closed-source LLMs. In addition, it can generate 200 adversarial suffixes for
one harmful query in only 4 seconds, rendering it more challenging to defend.
|
[
-0.2257749587,
-0.8783822656,
0.4983566105,
-0.0057993452,
-0.1891511679,
0.2510311604,
-0.2313551605,
-0.2537412047,
-0.0301796049,
0.4608452022,
-0.6116550565,
-0.7523061037,
-0.7660256028,
-0.1903292835,
-0.5023272634,
1.0630989075,
0.1781524867,
0.0440718606,
0.1553575099,
-0.0439107716,
-0.4619267881,
-0.6444613338,
-0.7317190766,
0.0681118146,
0.1080549583,
0.3488147259,
0.9759389758,
0.8909773231,
0.4587981999,
0.2670258284,
-0.1242208704,
0.2894074023,
-0.6429689527,
-0.1236590073,
-0.1039869338,
-0.3462809026,
-0.2430239171,
-0.0125401067,
0.2435826659,
0.4122338295,
-0.3548001647,
-0.1184012741,
-0.0462515131,
0.5860714912,
-0.6346980929,
-0.4034045339,
-1.0797643661,
0.0964616984,
-0.3196914792,
0.0218013618,
-0.3790364563,
-0.5204980373,
-0.2487720847,
-0.8190158606,
0.2912019491,
0.1479712129,
0.8150529861,
0.3520735204,
-0.2808149159,
-0.2599396706,
-0.5303397775,
0.4576176107,
-0.3238969445,
0.1264518648,
0.1186335459,
0.1278981119,
-0.6603499651,
-0.7815212607,
-0.3598726392,
-0.4748950303,
0.2757434845,
0.0582486279,
-0.3492822349,
0.4105541408,
0.2027263641,
0.5945945382,
-0.6243517399,
0.282897085,
-0.3497670889,
-0.2835113108,
0.5502007008,
0.1279204935,
0.6954675913,
0.0032172964,
-0.7653058767,
0.193549484,
-1.1468846798,
-0.275419414,
0.6357758641,
0.2103365958,
-0.0655616075,
0.3426840007,
0.1515886933,
0.6856051087,
0.0389593691,
0.1720927358,
-0.0967276543,
-0.2275970131,
-0.0671899244,
-0.0752407983,
1.0188627243,
0.1737043113,
0.3544407189,
-0.591743052,
0.1013041958,
0.1263805479,
0.5168433785,
-0.61868155,
-0.2914907038,
0.0610580035,
-0.033889927,
-0.4051198065,
0.2088159025,
-0.6327593923,
-0.6288952231,
-0.1547483206,
0.2294019014,
-0.7180433273,
0.0913384929,
0.0921367034,
-0.0525817461,
0.2435081452,
0.0118120322,
-1.1302531958,
0.238519147,
0.9487752914,
1.1446464062,
-0.1851455569,
-0.2708014846,
-0.8528764844,
0.2825204432,
-0.3698094487,
0.5533508062,
-0.2805356979,
-0.6325692534,
-0.1766219288,
-0.0530326329,
-0.2059391141,
-0.2826344967,
0.6974617839,
-0.6190938354,
-0.2119877934,
0.0070629898,
-0.7642400265,
-0.049910102,
0.1426843107,
-0.5747051835,
0.475710392,
-0.0586636998,
-0.689483285,
0.3566609919,
-0.4258544445,
-0.3969162405,
0.1745923012,
-0.0734188333,
-0.4744206071,
0.232374981,
0.3375715315,
0.2528984249,
-0.1822050512,
0.2531353831,
-0.5842158794,
-0.3965207636,
0.0296695158,
-0.3691142797,
0.9044155478,
0.3071487844,
-0.1564184725,
0.4418308437,
-0.4136264026,
-0.1157107502,
0.1887410879,
-0.1910897046,
-0.2981087267,
0.0176067147,
-0.2581671178,
-0.0663551092,
0.0218595807,
-0.5613641143,
0.6208212972,
-0.5494353771,
0.464056462,
1.0117824078,
-0.0771278068,
0.4547435343,
0.0072629587,
0.6198612452,
-0.4718303382,
0.4874279499,
0.2339318693,
-0.353735894,
-0.5847463012,
-0.5674669147,
0.5224211812,
0.6747572422,
-0.6461185813,
0.5608700514,
-0.2278880775,
-0.3326054513,
-0.5368067026,
0.3812901676,
0.3842588961,
0.170165658,
0.161344409,
-0.2783489823,
-0.5993536115,
-0.6366417408,
-0.3880497515,
-0.1337818205,
0.0482573584,
0.1198657602,
0.3470127285,
-0.172401607,
0.4873231351,
-0.668630302,
-0.3564377725,
-0.1772029698,
-0.0920582563,
-0.0506158955,
0.3824047744,
0.6222175956,
-0.7061270475,
-0.4735172391,
0.0902650431,
-0.7694326639,
0.0707009509,
-0.1038364917,
-0.3796605468,
0.0231332909,
0.7642071247,
-0.7728324533,
0.3461504281,
0.46448192,
-0.320869565,
0.8197054863,
-0.1597716957,
-0.0753354356,
-1.0473704338,
-0.1117568836,
-0.230503425,
-0.3074035347,
-0.7658125758,
0.6694995761,
0.0531184822,
-0.0282009244,
-0.552503407,
0.5628530979,
-0.5452842116,
0.2115646005,
-0.3851093352,
0.0423881188,
-0.4362396896,
0.3487731516,
-0.4747602344,
1.0506429672,
0.8407977223,
-0.4410901666,
0.5132082105,
0.2872013152,
-0.1405905187,
0.1885879636,
-0.5156548619,
0.2885720432,
0.1068666875,
-0.1176291332,
-0.7364307046,
-0.3266628087,
0.4220291078,
-0.5320035815,
0.4946701825,
-0.5126662254,
-0.5436677933,
-0.2332463861,
-0.3593532145,
0.1018978208,
0.5989050269,
-1.0256246328,
0.4142094553,
0.4467042685,
0.1726906747,
-0.656177938,
-0.2769145072,
0.236769706,
-0.5612741709,
-0.6866930723,
0.4956758618,
0.0677361116,
-0.0809457749,
-0.0166075788,
-0.1139168441,
0.313652575,
0.4262623489,
0.3335033059,
0.5292642713,
0.0955203101,
0.0121535733,
-0.2465594262,
-0.1032648236,
0.0338925719,
-0.6399132609,
0.465297699,
-0.3657310903,
-0.380794853,
0.2222546786,
0.2050522417,
0.3805890679,
-0.0105282236,
1.0778169632,
0.645563364,
-0.2019951046,
-0.2482190579,
-0.3259278834,
0.0920060501,
-0.5202388167,
0.3897707164,
-0.2878390253,
-1.1153845787,
0.5476109982,
-0.1332232207,
-0.0461130887,
0.3903099895,
0.3129238486,
0.4541333318,
1.1898937225,
0.8779379725,
-0.4931484759,
0.4486452937,
-0.1211175397,
0.238797769,
-0.8772037029,
-0.1523660868,
-0.0978794023,
0.1330851018,
-0.7093806863,
-0.2197897285,
0.3655685782,
0.6256075501,
-0.2335860878,
0.2690756321,
-0.5747793317,
0.6987240314,
0.3471140862,
0.0644029006,
0.0962122679,
0.0909286514,
-0.2130982131,
0.1835680455,
-0.5657106638,
-0.3292870224,
1.3537592888,
0.1688441634,
0.8253188133,
0.3931178451,
0.6028167605,
0.26670295,
0.5797443986,
-0.727257967,
0.5351464748,
-0.6143966913,
-0.40167436,
0.0753092393,
-0.5492423773,
-0.8746601939,
0.22506468,
0.022441119,
-1.0840111971,
-0.3725810051,
0.1802828014,
-0.3642488718,
0.651932478,
-0.6561176181,
0.8465343714,
-0.4023720026,
-0.2785962224,
-0.0782811046,
-0.6250694394,
0.9222701788,
0.0355209671,
0.0682903826,
-0.0362187251,
0.0616853647,
0.4475877881,
-0.6985155344,
0.5247167349,
-0.10105896,
0.1272139996,
0.3043157756,
0.0540423878,
0.6124643087,
-0.0184401255,
0.2087155282,
0.1586143225,
-0.5517597795,
-0.2861684561,
-0.5237995982,
0.940898478,
-0.8278009892,
-0.9909223318,
-0.4682273269,
-0.3993037045,
-0.1160246581,
0.0254042186,
0.4865999818,
0.0676492751,
-0.4384334385,
-0.0729920939,
0.7737669349,
-0.1378849894,
0.2255872339,
0.2275616378,
-0.2292852253,
-0.4626355767,
0.9915011525,
-0.1626451015,
0.4070131183,
-0.0447931997,
0.0816576779,
-0.3114751279,
-0.7769510746,
-0.6302232742,
0.0988163725,
-0.6735582352,
-0.4083844125,
-0.5693340898,
-0.5522837639,
-0.328160882,
-0.2468221188,
-0.115162462,
-0.3399551511,
-0.5129973292,
-0.2760238051,
0.656935215,
0.4639803767,
-0.3980911374,
0.5383775234,
-0.7053849697,
0.3933441341,
0.2560028732,
0.3871897459,
-0.1207055375,
-0.6071872115,
0.0868757218,
-0.2412685007,
-0.4898103476,
-1.0742635727,
0.3870629668,
0.3400729299,
0.4208023846,
0.536911726,
-0.1849209517,
0.6666722298,
-0.6281806827,
0.6510186195,
0.3837021291,
-0.980234623,
0.4743984342,
-0.54573071,
-0.053031534,
0.4958486855,
0.3556837738,
-0.4450212717,
-0.2529157102,
-0.5191398263,
-1.2023671865,
0.6571758986,
0.1558233947,
0.1477879435,
-0.144072175,
0.5654520392,
0.1153058484,
-0.026703041,
-0.6172757149,
-0.3413012326,
-0.0855604932,
-0.1142125502,
0.2163412273,
-0.1168124676,
-0.2124753892,
-0.07118617,
0.8800140023,
-0.2037157863,
0.1777412742,
-0.2126828283,
-0.0566252097,
0.3250524104,
0.3964354694,
0.3730677068,
0.0034431501,
-0.0867179036,
0.1121401712,
0.2004887015,
-0.7110369802,
0.3568191826,
0.4068958759,
-0.2484067976,
-0.5280934572,
-0.0005664463,
0.8692024946,
-0.2824763358,
-0.5870808363,
0.5662663579,
-0.1815594882,
-0.1818747222,
-0.362522155,
0.385918051,
-0.1401530504,
-0.0890868083,
0.2304246426,
0.1841541827,
0.1713967919,
-0.4754324257,
0.2484028041,
0.9069346189,
-0.3517642021,
-0.1291803867,
0.9214465022,
-0.0999412537,
-0.0499061868,
0.6328415871,
-0.5459054708,
-0.7812336087,
0.5446497202,
0.5526735187,
1.1985980272,
-0.1996881366,
0.1055497155,
0.217295453,
0.4299557209,
-0.313147068,
-0.0137643022,
0.1420245618,
-0.5694113374,
-0.3844166994,
-0.6807364225,
-0.2059941292,
0.3150801063,
-0.3614282012,
0.1552723795,
-0.7403391004,
-0.0966409594,
-0.0980631635,
-0.3087300062,
-0.4302112758,
-0.0101516386,
0.2563189566,
0.713978827,
-0.7256112695,
0.4641181827,
0.4681458175,
-0.2283609957,
-0.7814323902,
0.0490110405,
0.2922587097,
-0.9626031518,
0.2409251183,
0.2915381193,
-0.2296042889,
0.0810881108,
-0.8487544656,
-1.0250507593,
0.7856823802,
0.5138361454,
-0.4821009934,
0.029765062,
0.0146418083,
0.3232828081,
-0.1329130083,
0.0181945134,
0.7451320887,
0.1807506979,
0.2697869837,
-0.5269801021,
0.3103759587,
-0.3061977029,
-0.0277549569,
0.5756500363,
-0.6833297014,
0.5582761168,
-0.4441198409,
-0.5549870729,
0.5131316781,
0.639170289,
0.371722877,
-0.1750608683,
0.2732217312,
0.9064701796,
0.6256940365,
-0.4595615268,
1.2993427515,
-0.2347277701,
0.1612104923,
0.8738737702,
0.0091419853,
0.4476906657,
0.2680943012,
-0.0613078624,
0.1678001583,
0.5265265703,
-0.2858631909,
0.7636958361,
0.5757809281,
-0.5858493447,
-0.1247785836,
-0.0696327314,
-0.2090879977,
0.2378073186,
0.6037803292,
-0.1558751613,
-0.1579248011,
0.1583425403,
0.3194661438,
-0.0074292431,
-0.5489295125,
0.808416605,
0.1274864972,
-0.6850424409,
0.6826363206,
0.3418176472,
0.8084179163,
-0.7636194229,
0.2206733972,
-0.1264980882,
0.2455766499,
-0.3214952648,
-0.58934623,
0.3228748143,
0.2876501381,
0.0472483449,
0.2026299834,
0.8416288495,
-0.1969664246,
-0.3425664604,
0.3568389118,
0.0494488142,
0.1241026148,
-0.1316414624,
-0.5957804918,
-0.073354423,
0.1088445485,
-0.0098755518,
0.4469501674,
0.1234417185,
-0.0362057798,
0.7005681396,
0.9143064618,
0.3601121306,
0.2924827337,
0.0814846233,
1.0030218363,
-0.5522290468,
-0.5251306891,
-1.2163507938,
0.3205428421,
-0.0852718279,
-0.1303427666,
0.8927006721,
0.4350285828,
0.6143421531,
0.1771529317,
1.0322765112,
-0.1530985385,
-0.0692332909,
-0.8431301117,
0.6564000845,
-0.2831606269,
0.468582809,
-0.0274995174,
-0.6881365776,
-0.3343691528,
0.2410779297,
-0.4374829531,
-0.1269789934,
0.3724653125,
0.8171632886,
-0.0688500777,
0.0079368418,
0.2841423452,
-0.0080562541,
0.5104158521,
0.7885469198,
0.967004478,
-0.3536930978,
0.671310544,
0.1378139555,
-0.2786380351,
-0.0354592428,
-0.7363908291,
-0.9506801367,
-0.0882687271,
-0.2906787694,
-0.4311795533,
0.5177659988,
0.7461201549,
0.6021941304,
-0.5586695075,
0.2083063275,
-0.6451158524,
0.1361228228,
0.0690772086,
-0.2343577147,
0.4585348964,
-0.3567326963,
-0.3181856573,
0.5988870859,
0.2294763327,
0.1794081926,
-0.1068762988,
0.0017570538,
-0.0035297023,
-0.0123296911,
0.2464653403,
0.5944423079,
-0.7292646766,
-0.3560739756,
-0.0022521063,
-0.0777047724,
0.0061825984,
0.6378551126,
-0.4516109526,
0.3421468735,
0.102941446,
0.7519662976,
0.2734968662,
0.3305282891,
0.6183523536,
-1.0924665928,
0.0457255989,
-0.0712141767,
0.390006572,
0.4969474971,
-0.606775701,
0.534889102,
0.2404465973,
-0.6464186907,
-0.7008963227,
0.5042583942,
-0.5842847824,
-0.4864449799,
1.3500572443,
-0.2479768097,
-0.1506077349,
0.0196124855,
-0.1121470854,
0.34632954,
-0.1790393144,
0.8398239017,
0.4899790287,
0.0448420979,
0.084637709,
-0.4943985343,
0.8263162971,
0.2860525548,
-0.8598120213,
0.0473721102,
0.4337665141,
0.3954497874,
0.000789899,
0.4135732949,
-0.1997730881,
0.3583064377,
0.0628559142,
-0.0227319933,
-0.2250879407,
-0.3332877755,
-0.6058160067,
0.2541755736,
0.105065465,
-0.3849986792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07917v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07917v1
|
DesignQA: A Multimodal Benchmark for Evaluating Large Language Models' Understanding of Engineering Documentation
| 2024-04-11T16:59:54 | 2024-04-11T16:59:54 |
Anna C. Doris, Daniele Grandi, Ryan Tomich, Md Ferdous Alam, Hyunmin Cheong, Faez Ahmed
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This research introduces DesignQA, a novel benchmark aimed at evaluating the
proficiency of multimodal large language models (MLLMs) in comprehending and
applying engineering requirements in technical documentation. Developed with a
focus on real-world engineering challenges, DesignQA uniquely combines
multimodal data-including textual design requirements, CAD images, and
engineering drawings-derived from the Formula SAE student competition.
Different from many existing MLLM benchmarks, DesignQA contains
document-grounded visual questions where the input image and input document
come from different sources. The benchmark features automatic evaluation
metrics and is divided into segments-Rule Comprehension, Rule Compliance, and
Rule Extraction-based on tasks that engineers perform when designing according
to requirements. We evaluate state-of-the-art models like GPT4 and LLaVA
against the benchmark, and our study uncovers the existing gaps in MLLMs'
abilities to interpret complex engineering documentation. Key findings suggest
that while MLLMs demonstrate potential in navigating technical documents,
substantial limitations exist, particularly in accurately extracting and
applying detailed requirements to engineering designs. This benchmark sets a
foundation for future advancements in AI-supported engineering design
processes. DesignQA is publicly available at:
https://github.com/anniedoris/design_qa/.
|
[
-0.601031661,
-0.5829082727,
0.6613872647,
0.4408052564,
-0.1527790874,
0.3753240108,
0.2737115622,
-0.4493406117,
-0.2404161841,
0.3383825719,
-0.6400012374,
-0.5941537619,
-0.2351879627,
-0.0691289976,
-0.3365296125,
0.2692608237,
-0.695340991,
-0.1186520532,
-0.4691665173,
-0.1194007173,
-0.556212306,
-0.4265288711,
-0.3692188859,
-0.1450550109,
0.5567994118,
0.0358931795,
0.5231381655,
0.201790601,
0.5499628186,
0.2470371574,
-0.1034458578,
0.3340698779,
0.0581030436,
0.3642607927,
0.2335419655,
-0.18163158,
-0.5260903239,
0.1861913651,
0.6422194839,
0.4337495267,
0.0917110592,
0.395509243,
0.2026323825,
0.6375101805,
-0.6421329379,
0.6235848069,
-0.0057259621,
0.0534440242,
-0.0506945625,
-0.1413021088,
-0.525633812,
-0.2780270875,
-0.133919403,
-0.9553750157,
-0.0965158716,
0.2595492601,
1.1773741245,
0.3299992383,
-0.914727211,
-0.4237059355,
-0.2711825371,
0.6071221232,
-0.5148821473,
1.1129900217,
0.2635123134,
0.5309398174,
-0.2409703881,
-0.9021587372,
-0.5126183033,
-0.5005361438,
0.0627799481,
0.0819021463,
-0.060647998,
0.2071149945,
0.4727425873,
0.3388630152,
-0.851477325,
0.039172709,
-0.5648143291,
-0.4435834885,
0.4804893732,
0.0642878413,
0.4094775915,
-0.2874037027,
-0.3092259467,
-0.1574994326,
-0.4780828357,
0.2150393277,
0.1169584021,
-0.1586968005,
-0.2376523465,
0.4407016933,
-0.2872540355,
0.4530765116,
-0.3870021403,
-0.0229887534,
0.7221497297,
-0.4396236241,
-0.314147234,
-0.5256189704,
0.6500651836,
0.2240418196,
0.1515301764,
-0.122345984,
-0.456371516,
-0.192975983,
0.3126007617,
-0.6162057519,
-0.3320803046,
-0.0058497703,
-0.6214759946,
0.0192410275,
-0.342653811,
-0.6583499312,
-0.5436216593,
-0.6325634122,
0.650801301,
0.033602424,
-0.2998748124,
-0.0685253441,
-0.4363940954,
0.3199292719,
0.2973003983,
-0.4866429865,
-0.2005437613,
0.6316256523,
0.8424551487,
0.0558638088,
-0.2997326255,
-0.3731802702,
-0.0851940513,
-0.3431906402,
0.8782730103,
-0.3676145971,
-0.4438354671,
-0.130217582,
-0.0423372574,
0.0146799022,
-0.4845966101,
1.0875231028,
-0.6134742498,
-0.170699805,
-0.1188349947,
-0.1717541516,
-0.2941044271,
0.3315491378,
-1.0245295763,
1.0087002516,
0.3143504262,
-0.4930541813,
0.6087765098,
-0.846761167,
-0.1852672994,
0.1258758456,
-0.5215824246,
-0.3496408463,
0.1038183421,
0.0619055107,
-0.0225406699,
-0.4717178047,
0.2868136764,
-0.4804475904,
-0.1047852263,
0.0576082021,
-0.4234805405,
0.7486550212,
0.432897687,
-0.1930665225,
0.3332313895,
-0.8197064996,
0.4128320217,
-0.061946325,
-0.6008318663,
-0.2355707139,
-0.1066666096,
0.2549625039,
0.62740767,
0.0720641166,
-0.5444067717,
0.120317176,
-0.0665116087,
0.5170197487,
0.6942360997,
-0.1835948676,
0.3458192348,
-0.3951175213,
0.7087031007,
-0.2036407292,
0.3058918118,
-0.1897927523,
-0.4670560062,
-0.8084165454,
-0.3282088935,
0.4070468843,
0.2272553593,
-0.8236740232,
-0.1586732566,
0.0528878197,
-0.453360796,
-0.7535015345,
0.3051270247,
0.333601892,
0.3253412843,
0.3136991262,
-0.2551964521,
-0.6414324045,
-1.2305151224,
-0.1469546854,
-0.327460736,
-0.4105526209,
0.1939742863,
0.5835620165,
-0.155838415,
0.4508433044,
-0.1562948376,
-0.1825148463,
0.0108988462,
0.7473236918,
0.0754771233,
0.2908011377,
0.5990150571,
-1.0009278059,
-0.4622009993,
-0.0853204876,
-1.0388047695,
-0.2510866225,
-0.2173280269,
-0.2102743089,
-0.0215514619,
0.4806788564,
-0.8145385385,
0.5035235286,
0.4430257082,
-0.297273308,
0.6183996797,
-0.0787356272,
0.3094807863,
-0.7419759631,
0.1565952897,
-0.0321754217,
0.0708993077,
-0.4060688019,
0.4775164723,
0.6962583661,
-0.1587243527,
-0.4790632427,
0.7535828352,
-0.737146914,
-0.0078152297,
-0.0996479988,
0.1370428652,
0.5409053564,
0.4699363708,
-0.2650044858,
0.8596404195,
0.2309839129,
-0.3074241281,
0.2673361003,
0.3030737042,
-0.666434586,
0.6752803326,
-0.694881022,
0.1931578219,
-0.1814207435,
0.2866937816,
-0.9727445245,
0.0888038129,
-0.0955679938,
-0.260299325,
0.1901026666,
0.0957798585,
-0.7194404006,
-0.5993555784,
-0.3216601908,
0.5296331048,
0.2780015171,
-0.2823459506,
1.0400301218,
0.3635794222,
-0.2420324087,
-0.327342689,
-0.4360264242,
0.283254534,
0.0441405848,
-0.8436979651,
0.3472749889,
-0.4788502455,
-0.4262650013,
-0.1870451421,
-0.3316309452,
-0.475875169,
0.2858942151,
0.558403492,
0.1451591849,
-0.3695572317,
0.281221509,
0.0139832515,
-0.0299727935,
0.392445296,
-0.0708199516,
0.1875394732,
0.0189367253,
-0.5551066995,
-0.7510077357,
0.6972891092,
0.9970927238,
-0.3091929257,
0.2223941684,
0.4441274703,
-0.4338757396,
-0.1587462425,
-0.6421827078,
0.1346925944,
-0.4770960808,
0.3542831838,
-1.0142157078,
-0.4377290606,
0.2789615989,
0.0344838127,
0.5811914206,
0.6089122295,
0.316886276,
-0.4888973534,
1.1053500175,
0.721242249,
0.1022494212,
0.2770748436,
-0.0122101596,
0.0349875949,
-0.8048849702,
-0.3631818891,
-0.7765507102,
-0.2662765086,
-0.1792862862,
-0.3008392453,
0.3856803179,
-0.0735685006,
-0.4076158404,
0.15252994,
-0.1521372348,
0.2647157609,
0.6300414205,
0.0421176478,
0.4278039038,
-0.2436132133,
-0.6370785832,
-0.0702820122,
-0.3618266284,
-0.5587958694,
0.9421218634,
0.6843019128,
0.8629182577,
0.1721747816,
0.3202689588,
0.5851656795,
0.3724391162,
-0.8076868057,
0.2513786852,
0.1705633402,
-0.6060627699,
-0.1385586262,
-0.3256858587,
-0.5700252652,
0.3582814038,
-0.0567774363,
-0.2123144269,
0.1673638076,
0.0018923881,
-0.2540230155,
0.0161716491,
-0.796788156,
0.9457746148,
-0.5839634538,
-0.073245354,
-0.2119389325,
-0.1788735241,
0.3660722077,
-0.4098111987,
0.4903558195,
-0.1919729263,
-0.0812127218,
0.7072635889,
-0.108499147,
0.5317331553,
-0.1144679785,
-0.3949443996,
0.025898505,
0.0698174462,
0.3867911696,
-0.1502107382,
-0.4240564406,
-0.0707608834,
0.260363102,
-0.5440577269,
-0.6087582707,
0.4923566282,
-0.6281187534,
-0.6821150184,
-0.2005491257,
-0.5633539557,
-0.3779439032,
0.2600910068,
-0.0279477313,
0.4375789464,
-0.178147465,
0.4163996875,
0.4547724128,
-0.2212746888,
0.2980255783,
0.6138724685,
-0.0346395113,
-0.2028607875,
0.5692613125,
0.1016084105,
0.1363338679,
0.428465724,
-0.1909436285,
-0.7217254043,
-0.6764782071,
-0.9186275601,
0.1043218523,
-1.1082601547,
-0.020722596,
-0.5967662334,
-0.5525246859,
-0.130743131,
0.0985783488,
-0.0779856518,
-0.4006714821,
-0.1306481957,
0.0901528075,
-0.2746073902,
1.0879710913,
0.3741087019,
-0.2899361849,
-0.7581161857,
0.3541885614,
0.4553427398,
0.5033916235,
-0.0137229208,
-0.7205067277,
-0.0835948661,
-0.0761502236,
-0.7377278209,
-0.686316669,
-0.0548451729,
0.1002645567,
1.2269932032,
-0.0639825314,
0.1528109014,
0.3416693807,
-0.3929757476,
0.5317528248,
-0.000289567,
-0.7958388925,
0.3497363627,
-0.2352948338,
0.5838272572,
0.4816642106,
0.3485342562,
-0.4796641171,
-0.1884063631,
-0.1450061053,
-0.585490346,
0.0810972229,
0.21568878,
-0.1028495431,
0.4854954183,
0.1629722416,
-0.0495329872,
0.1720369756,
-0.6358602047,
0.1324181408,
-0.1967768073,
-0.3778301179,
0.2805171311,
-0.3905043602,
-0.0756177977,
0.1072818786,
0.4127309918,
-0.1204113066,
0.0248911846,
-0.1358118951,
-0.4406302273,
0.1765561104,
0.3425107002,
0.8539126515,
1.0366511345,
-0.0100574763,
0.1513157338,
0.146817416,
-0.3483872414,
0.1473401189,
0.1768942624,
-0.090278998,
0.2330640405,
0.3469091952,
0.4293422401,
0.3039468825,
-0.6710191369,
0.4274111092,
-0.3616975844,
-0.7481976748,
-0.2290296853,
-0.3119525015,
0.1497660726,
0.4074764848,
0.56254071,
-0.2516937256,
0.2738884985,
-0.2309294939,
0.3742655814,
0.3937336206,
-0.2946831882,
-0.3317344785,
0.9068133235,
0.5937079787,
-0.3218524754,
0.3350973129,
-0.1036290303,
-0.2184046805,
0.8204904199,
0.2060712725,
0.9859890342,
0.1428714544,
0.2623187304,
0.3352083564,
0.4196018577,
0.2633359134,
0.6130398512,
-0.2361451238,
-0.038623888,
-0.3378775418,
-0.7666608691,
-0.4974669814,
0.0973974317,
-0.2986460328,
0.3309524357,
-0.4070212543,
-0.0609554201,
0.309420526,
-0.0906137973,
-0.8466358781,
0.0650104582,
0.1252963394,
1.2562217712,
-0.5186586976,
0.6977930665,
0.59966892,
-0.5929138064,
-0.6308377981,
-0.1551994085,
0.4447980225,
-0.5707445145,
1.0642342567,
0.2182599604,
-0.1704080403,
-0.2608315945,
0.030770801,
-0.7005173564,
1.0435432196,
0.1990134269,
-0.632732749,
-0.4407717586,
0.1357388496,
0.392808497,
-0.1187633052,
0.4579801559,
0.1781883985,
0.5867031813,
-0.138872236,
-1.3978379965,
0.0094489269,
-0.7038452625,
-0.2369350195,
0.2861893177,
-0.6312055588,
0.8943864107,
0.167639479,
-0.4058720469,
0.2925131023,
0.4183405638,
0.2789047658,
0.495488286,
0.6179506779,
0.3427734971,
0.7270717621,
-0.0641110912,
0.5599730015,
-0.3117571175,
0.0805221349,
0.9572411776,
-0.0880236477,
0.963630259,
0.4099898338,
-0.1309243888,
0.5122947693,
0.7339817882,
0.1827929914,
0.1556570083,
0.3298665583,
-0.2925754786,
-0.3013585806,
-0.2572689056,
-0.6584886909,
0.409230262,
0.2559550107,
-0.5255696177,
-0.274962306,
0.0431562029,
-0.345100224,
-0.0353022702,
-0.197173804,
0.61064744,
0.1499622762,
-0.5101684332,
0.880364418,
-0.2407687455,
0.180926919,
-0.3804187775,
-0.2337447703,
-0.2600156963,
0.1276845783,
-0.0307476334,
-0.9920148253,
0.045883514,
-0.1282274127,
-0.2170435339,
-0.3928134739,
0.1750714183,
-0.0234679356,
-0.4921022356,
0.1849826276,
0.4276855886,
0.0675972626,
-0.1928007752,
-0.7614536285,
0.2172452211,
-0.1023656875,
-0.0848755091,
0.1957269162,
0.4240514338,
-0.3073408306,
0.8682758212,
0.3359568417,
-0.3974027634,
-0.0282400306,
0.4528565109,
1.0423225164,
-0.6377221942,
-0.3567635119,
-0.4858300686,
0.6443097591,
-0.117663078,
-0.322665751,
0.6558558345,
0.7290835977,
0.715149641,
-0.0160139222,
0.9935442805,
0.2616862953,
0.2391881049,
-0.6449543238,
0.7888271809,
-0.8914805651,
0.1313185543,
-0.1210676283,
-0.6376271248,
-0.200192064,
0.1680069268,
-0.0079472633,
-0.0000633529,
0.7827209234,
0.8217516541,
-0.1226358861,
0.0900013596,
0.3051364124,
-0.03192994,
0.6613463759,
0.7309235334,
1.1677113771,
-0.4025232494,
0.9716095924,
0.0369742326,
-0.3095231652,
-0.0928169489,
-0.7918326855,
-0.9324675798,
-0.8451305628,
-0.0191745162,
-0.0558232963,
-0.0855919719,
0.6570264697,
0.7863402963,
-0.6766268015,
-0.0187205467,
0.3472556174,
0.1218655407,
0.0283960346,
-0.0992123932,
0.2004609257,
-0.3209353387,
-0.5596321821,
0.5207260847,
0.3306756616,
0.218792215,
-0.6083627939,
-0.1332586408,
-0.079981789,
-0.0630715936,
0.7373434305,
0.3190721273,
-0.9509221911,
-0.1041551009,
0.2638289928,
-0.3232483268,
0.1466836929,
0.7836818099,
-0.4750101864,
0.6863065958,
0.8628592491,
0.7168118358,
0.4068448842,
-0.1002028883,
0.5683506131,
-0.4765365422,
-0.1623368859,
-0.0489927381,
0.4171382487,
0.1217008084,
-0.0538954735,
0.384870857,
0.0322393179,
-0.5941188931,
-0.7379912734,
0.2338921726,
-0.7147798538,
-0.1947484612,
0.8572416306,
-0.1579032987,
0.0312113483,
-0.6017080545,
-0.5205386281,
-0.1779378504,
-0.2365643978,
0.8613003492,
0.8664280176,
-0.0308938716,
-0.4852165282,
-1.2018067837,
0.3863170445,
0.3014534712,
-0.9196359515,
0.0557506792,
0.5490783453,
0.0515220016,
0.0484022982,
0.430811882,
0.1015279144,
0.7190539241,
0.0537745319,
0.0291786995,
-0.187609762,
-0.3306336105,
0.0596796758,
0.4511535466,
0.4673687816,
-0.1963067949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07904v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07904v1
|
HGRN2: Gated Linear RNNs with State Expansion
| 2024-04-11T16:43:03 | 2024-04-11T16:43:03 |
Zhen Qin, Songlin Yang, Weixuan Sun, Xuyang Shen, Dong Li, Weigao Sun, Yiran Zhong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Hierarchically gated linear RNN (HGRN,Qin et al. 2023) has demonstrated
competitive training speed and performance in language modeling, while offering
efficient inference. However, the recurrent state size of HGRN remains
relatively small, which limits its expressiveness.To address this issue,
inspired by linear attention, we introduce a simple outer-product-based state
expansion mechanism so that the recurrent state size can be significantly
enlarged without introducing any additional parameters. The linear attention
form also allows for hardware-efficient training.Our extensive experiments
verify the advantage of HGRN2 over HGRN1 in language modeling, image
classification, and Long Range Arena.Our largest 3B HGRN2 model slightly
outperforms Mamba and LLaMa Architecture Transformer for language modeling in a
controlled experiment setting; and performs competitively with many open-source
3B models in downstream evaluation while using much fewer total training
tokens.
|
[
-0.2280891985,
-0.6346741915,
0.2183241993,
0.2821302414,
-0.1367881149,
-0.1123497039,
-0.3505474627,
-0.6253589392,
-0.1512739956,
0.1355304867,
-0.3740208745,
-0.0380469561,
-0.6709121466,
-0.2324268371,
-0.1270902753,
0.9819527864,
-0.0042953375,
-0.0228973813,
0.1306924969,
0.0235380176,
0.0186939966,
-0.2177435756,
-0.8880435228,
-0.7975215316,
0.9939227104,
0.006771198,
0.752953887,
1.0182423592,
0.7084907293,
0.3062491119,
-0.1952015162,
-0.139261663,
-0.9004144669,
-0.0399319343,
-0.0022246721,
-0.2982619107,
-0.4919835925,
-0.2731525302,
0.6474122405,
0.421212554,
-0.2275373638,
0.3625049889,
0.1541735232,
0.7009055614,
-0.599527359,
0.499543041,
-0.5266245604,
0.1967973113,
-0.182598263,
0.2179232538,
-0.3013214171,
-0.3182608187,
0.3144420385,
-0.4793586433,
0.1542510688,
0.1396100223,
0.9562261701,
0.2744452357,
-0.1261475235,
0.1769628227,
-0.7680978179,
0.7727799416,
-0.6773554087,
0.6129295826,
-0.0706623346,
0.3256888688,
-0.1619814783,
-0.8320189118,
-0.4363003671,
0.0175279006,
-0.0703305304,
0.0852209702,
-0.5770584345,
0.5276690125,
0.4211608171,
0.3838402033,
-0.5871114731,
0.0194907561,
-0.6184229255,
-0.0495946109,
0.2541882396,
-0.1497372389,
0.049359791,
-0.1727037728,
-0.7756199241,
0.0866725072,
-0.6929228902,
-0.0732664913,
0.1360947937,
0.3078457415,
-0.037563242,
0.5205601454,
-0.2009391189,
0.6974619031,
-0.0366826653,
-0.149349764,
0.1692131162,
-0.112018913,
-0.3795609772,
-0.0345549472,
0.7385962605,
0.1554981619,
-0.0824682191,
-0.2814935148,
-0.3657440543,
0.0113242054,
0.1086986661,
-0.9297879934,
-0.1566537321,
0.0256537739,
-0.7965295315,
-0.1338064969,
-0.1159057468,
-0.9299687147,
-0.3637201488,
-0.2757678628,
0.5561059713,
0.2464963198,
-0.3110100627,
0.212516889,
-0.233252123,
0.2320985049,
0.0829153508,
-1.1198006868,
0.6203265786,
1.027305007,
0.9487659931,
-0.3337737918,
0.0739614516,
-0.4863587618,
-0.3321226537,
-0.4345372617,
0.4614481032,
-0.2529589832,
0.0930004045,
-0.0704231635,
-0.1103183106,
0.1795060337,
-0.5144513845,
0.0454838835,
-1.0249106884,
0.0836105868,
-0.1849374473,
-0.0466034822,
-0.1130937338,
0.0878657401,
-0.6736013889,
1.1374821663,
0.5431225896,
-0.572276473,
0.076579161,
-0.5600519776,
-0.1569741219,
0.0341615044,
-0.3183410168,
-0.4237621129,
0.0308923163,
-0.1571249962,
-0.0907662585,
-0.5046955347,
0.1448623836,
-0.3375667632,
-0.1539226323,
-0.0635967329,
-0.3139055967,
0.3937223554,
0.3491264284,
-0.4437133074,
0.1603837907,
-0.4212667644,
0.0880234912,
0.0403081179,
-0.5228840709,
-0.0607090741,
-0.2874398232,
-0.0474199653,
0.5251333117,
0.2565168142,
-0.7660204768,
0.103115879,
-0.7291149497,
0.2813673317,
0.7098269463,
0.0032594437,
0.6528160572,
-0.2034254074,
0.7692381144,
-0.1239312738,
0.1402679086,
-0.0101344762,
-0.6607083082,
-0.8579866886,
-0.1584254205,
0.6126073599,
0.4346949756,
-0.6927190423,
0.2906942368,
-0.4229923189,
0.0177187212,
-0.5337718129,
0.2314943969,
0.6760863066,
0.3462069631,
0.0760229528,
-0.3336100578,
-0.6875793338,
-1.1343233585,
-0.1761319786,
-0.2281474769,
0.0434563607,
0.2985103726,
0.371801585,
-0.2091599554,
0.8932520151,
-0.3702133298,
-0.3358294964,
-0.6071644425,
0.2536591589,
0.3028255701,
0.2767840326,
0.0375599712,
-0.2196684629,
-0.2716253698,
0.3520753384,
-0.4879908264,
-0.0487023219,
-0.1587931514,
-0.2258809954,
0.1851421595,
0.4244812131,
-0.5724402666,
0.512925446,
0.6803573966,
0.0802984089,
0.0485768095,
-0.1063273475,
-0.4130176902,
-1.0853593349,
-0.1701664478,
0.1896508932,
-0.3293801546,
-0.5954164267,
0.1857133806,
-0.0429718569,
-0.1712421328,
-0.3141172826,
0.754463613,
-0.6461189985,
-0.5382215381,
-0.651796639,
0.2583907843,
-0.1943549961,
0.8184595704,
-0.0384736918,
0.5591656566,
0.3024521172,
-0.3305497766,
0.5738084912,
0.0857716799,
-0.4581177831,
-0.3097188771,
-0.8678785563,
0.0028344295,
-0.3885128498,
0.358097136,
-0.8108756542,
-0.0909656957,
0.3284196854,
-0.3574416041,
0.2954342663,
-0.3074524999,
-0.3905538321,
-0.6379030347,
-0.0933647901,
0.563303411,
0.8870245218,
-0.8821171522,
0.4943038523,
0.1556901485,
-0.225179702,
-0.5080674887,
-0.8889325857,
0.0808701888,
0.1855318397,
-0.4514220357,
0.1703063846,
0.4773025215,
-0.2735459208,
0.1887277365,
-0.2522903383,
0.1848857254,
-0.2017479539,
0.1036006436,
0.0397552922,
-0.645973146,
0.2464947701,
-0.1636226773,
-0.3439041376,
0.148106426,
-0.7569339871,
0.4934239686,
-0.2394460589,
-0.1307557821,
-0.554659009,
0.2378169298,
0.267039299,
-0.3102842569,
0.4503127038,
0.403467983,
-0.6885159612,
-0.5066985488,
-0.2539465427,
-0.3239391148,
-0.5036152005,
0.7187786698,
-0.3098275363,
-0.8242905736,
0.1787765473,
0.0133245355,
-0.0018434414,
0.4183841348,
0.590899229,
0.1885523051,
0.8397526145,
0.434730202,
-0.1056381688,
0.5779182315,
-0.1541129798,
0.4575808644,
-1.0365698338,
-0.2173860073,
-0.2685252428,
-0.636207521,
-0.7295372486,
-0.7736622691,
0.3241616189,
-0.0271981079,
-0.2915461361,
0.3731547296,
-0.2354501933,
0.4804483652,
0.4964514077,
0.3148501217,
0.0676312298,
0.321796447,
0.0827358365,
-0.1423414797,
-0.9102010131,
0.0200719107,
0.8216241002,
1.0670551062,
1.400318861,
0.2902623415,
0.3830463588,
0.1099871546,
0.4336155951,
-1.1763317585,
0.2467278391,
-0.1715031713,
-0.7229821682,
-0.3948971629,
-0.4667425454,
-0.8469717503,
0.3877936304,
0.0504377708,
-0.6409617066,
0.4045166075,
0.3274633288,
-0.687545836,
0.3544184268,
-0.5772677064,
0.6232537031,
-0.3432131112,
-0.5650844574,
-0.0614675954,
-0.5347715616,
0.3698652685,
0.1814267039,
-0.0986115411,
0.2009256482,
-0.1256582737,
0.6525430679,
-0.4101804793,
0.7485830784,
-0.1745580286,
-0.284432888,
0.2732164264,
0.0280493759,
0.6974102259,
-0.0176226944,
0.106334202,
-0.0050435928,
-0.7233585119,
-0.4020512998,
-0.9928538203,
0.7153493762,
-0.6357566118,
-0.657366097,
-0.3927756846,
-0.4319678843,
-0.1338295788,
0.2152217627,
-0.0296790153,
0.7312963009,
0.1345231384,
0.566824913,
0.9004004598,
0.0246787462,
0.4858080745,
0.1598851234,
-0.6121636033,
-0.522642374,
0.7520760894,
-0.1484193057,
0.7158759832,
0.367528528,
0.4650105536,
-0.4978690445,
-0.1741593182,
-0.5296672583,
0.2541708648,
-0.6210927963,
-0.0931801274,
-0.80991745,
-0.5767374635,
-0.2087756991,
0.3102042377,
-0.4840797484,
-0.4984254539,
-0.044460021,
-0.1997557133,
0.3733537495,
1.0186921358,
-0.2417341322,
0.6027418375,
-0.2701494098,
0.689588666,
0.7061132193,
0.7040518522,
0.2605124712,
-0.7467883825,
-0.2761518061,
-0.0225731079,
-0.0866833925,
-0.5685446858,
0.1757646203,
0.2125718892,
0.4228651822,
0.6954959035,
-0.4598109424,
0.5617712736,
-0.6686709523,
0.5813227892,
0.4564915001,
-0.5692656636,
0.09537182,
-0.5052843094,
0.4983378947,
0.1413168162,
0.1019142121,
-0.5372856855,
0.10950353,
-0.3938879967,
-0.5824005604,
0.8747661114,
0.0909896865,
0.1093682796,
0.075558722,
0.353707552,
-0.0914979875,
0.0363285393,
-0.8370863199,
-0.2973461151,
-0.0577781089,
-0.1171928421,
0.0928498209,
-0.4071955979,
-0.165760994,
-0.2676337361,
0.7453991175,
-0.0646759048,
0.7350484729,
0.1797770113,
0.1322956383,
-0.1359898299,
0.1455230117,
0.5453867912,
0.2897634804,
-0.1040881798,
0.2852742374,
0.0816378072,
-0.2225896716,
0.1568915546,
0.0411721617,
-0.1253053397,
0.0925679728,
0.1468286663,
1.2506057024,
0.2783840597,
-0.0872220695,
0.5423064232,
0.0628019199,
-0.428735882,
0.0948229656,
-0.0497381687,
0.2126134932,
0.3384414017,
0.0032427602,
0.2609674633,
0.2055159062,
-0.4410316348,
0.3412043452,
0.2606039047,
-0.8722959757,
-0.1493480355,
0.6404989362,
0.3144648075,
-0.3618117273,
0.3470634222,
-0.5075718164,
-0.6420913935,
0.5741630793,
0.9634557366,
0.9978359342,
0.0547655933,
0.0963565186,
0.674172163,
0.6909776926,
-0.3902974129,
0.3766731024,
-0.0713860691,
-0.6756469607,
-0.3850801289,
-0.3974304795,
0.0264613926,
0.3580596447,
-0.5880127549,
-0.0815418139,
-0.5878300071,
-0.4252862334,
-0.2810434997,
-0.1835609227,
-0.3635116518,
0.1532998383,
0.398810178,
0.8773120642,
-0.3993943334,
0.8800132275,
0.2106719017,
-0.0473605953,
-0.4172488451,
-0.1244501248,
0.06018259,
-0.6364201903,
0.9077361226,
0.0715943202,
-0.4579292834,
0.0425206162,
-0.4132048786,
-1.1801056862,
0.8899583817,
-0.0726111904,
-0.7857007384,
-0.1674628407,
0.124767445,
0.7274199724,
-0.3303950131,
-0.0502976961,
0.5314770341,
0.3146294057,
-0.0150781041,
-0.6356348395,
-0.0654638559,
-0.3398126364,
0.5900542736,
0.2736546099,
-0.6514550447,
0.7522819638,
-0.4169292152,
-0.439506799,
0.3038522601,
0.9966506362,
0.0832372159,
-0.0989651084,
0.5753707886,
0.6437428594,
0.4467211366,
-0.3818646073,
1.0038986206,
-0.1315779686,
0.4548222125,
1.4708237648,
-0.2968190312,
0.8707678318,
0.3867699504,
-0.082591638,
0.4763237238,
0.4137630463,
-0.0063754623,
0.5849101543,
0.7497555614,
-0.3071917593,
-0.1171240732,
-0.2710136473,
-0.4524964988,
0.2108406574,
0.2516593337,
-0.4061055183,
-0.3775323033,
-0.1262785792,
-0.1032274589,
-0.1167410538,
-0.2036369145,
0.8086767197,
0.2412819862,
-0.560575068,
0.3883455992,
0.1674234867,
0.6542605758,
-0.5487459302,
-0.0020386796,
-0.1750018299,
0.4537136257,
-0.1272997856,
-0.4586352408,
-0.0225857589,
0.0139732827,
-0.14735277,
-0.3191055059,
0.6627374887,
-0.766428709,
-0.374763906,
0.4970692396,
0.1782133877,
-0.2331691831,
0.2709613442,
-0.6031416655,
-0.0404864252,
-0.2185108811,
-0.2661056221,
0.0620107614,
0.2163551301,
-0.0923824832,
0.6635053158,
0.4468359947,
0.1853133291,
0.384208113,
0.3280743361,
0.7257352471,
-0.4019208848,
-0.3758628368,
-0.5271782875,
0.2059014887,
-0.0939182192,
-0.2830066085,
0.4869302809,
0.7765054703,
0.5929933786,
-0.0898074433,
0.9560486078,
0.0710115135,
0.3248072565,
-0.4674925506,
0.7186213732,
-0.407699734,
-0.0659868866,
0.1972920746,
-0.6751763821,
-0.1512004733,
0.4016621709,
-0.27354756,
0.2767451704,
0.7333894372,
1.1112835407,
-0.055221431,
-0.099265486,
0.2864309251,
0.3662490249,
0.2297486663,
0.6192640066,
0.7915938497,
-0.7350834608,
0.3704045713,
-0.2331914008,
-0.3651542962,
-0.1345339566,
-0.7330203056,
-0.8785535693,
-0.2671545148,
-0.2310402095,
-0.5731063485,
0.21810624,
1.0397495031,
0.949900806,
-0.7618464828,
-0.231394574,
-0.1779542565,
0.0821955949,
-0.0644766241,
-0.2189587355,
0.0151428506,
-0.4198159873,
-0.3932926357,
0.3369830847,
0.4020369649,
-0.0397617891,
-0.4195907712,
-0.1506894678,
-0.0408533439,
0.062331222,
0.7639313936,
0.470715493,
-0.941364646,
-0.0079150759,
0.2087802291,
-0.4461396635,
0.056676615,
0.78160429,
-0.5692331791,
0.6647132039,
0.809258759,
1.0176582336,
0.5151841044,
0.3011134565,
0.7384014726,
-0.6850557923,
0.1463574618,
-0.1380726397,
0.1020843908,
0.0356363989,
-0.1925384104,
0.161618188,
0.0660538152,
-0.4846281409,
-0.2739475667,
0.3266298473,
-0.8308380246,
0.0691624582,
1.6809602976,
0.0474355929,
-0.5029942989,
0.0336012691,
-0.1933508217,
0.1788238585,
-0.4719101787,
0.6006971598,
0.3756772578,
0.0666826963,
-0.2967878878,
-0.6482892036,
0.7005025744,
0.1918033808,
-0.8939911127,
0.0944589376,
0.2175285518,
-0.088040933,
0.0857269019,
0.4191715419,
-0.311334312,
0.4862321913,
0.0244578011,
0.2659958303,
-0.0137417382,
-0.6709693074,
-0.7407957315,
0.0052867481,
0.0593323112,
-0.4165617526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07900v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07900v2
|
High-Dimension Human Value Representation in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-11T16:39:00 | 2024-06-25T12:23:00 |
Samuel Cahyawijaya, Delong Chen, Yejin Bang, Leila Khalatbari, Bryan Wilie, Ziwei Ji, Etsuko Ishii, Pascale Fung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The widespread application of Large Language Models (LLMs) across various
tasks and fields has necessitated the alignment of these models with human
values and preferences. Given various approaches of human value alignment,
ranging from Reinforcement Learning with Human Feedback (RLHF), to
constitutional learning, etc. there is an urgent need to understand the scope
and nature of human values injected into these models before their release.
There is also a need for model alignment without a costly large scale human
annotation effort. We propose UniVaR, a high-dimensional representation of
human value distributions in LLMs, orthogonal to model architecture and
training data. Trained from the value-relevant output of eight multilingual
LLMs and tested on the output from four multilingual LLMs, namely LlaMA2,
ChatGPT, JAIS and Yi, we show that UniVaR is a powerful tool to compare the
distribution of human values embedded in different LLMs with different langauge
sources. Through UniVaR, we explore how different LLMs prioritize various
values in different languages and cultures, shedding light on the complex
interplay between human values and language modeling.
|
[
-0.1691755354,
-0.1897168159,
0.3343650997,
0.2706061602,
-0.0483643711,
0.3661662936,
-0.4716905355,
-0.4781096876,
0.2228725851,
0.6051233411,
-0.2082307637,
-0.3920207322,
-0.3893529773,
-0.3017095327,
-0.0690618679,
0.7507817745,
0.0774952397,
0.146221891,
-0.4065295458,
-0.4602273405,
-0.2888040841,
-1.1166403294,
-0.0684836134,
-0.6618853211,
0.535710156,
0.4320304692,
0.8292006254,
0.4757395983,
0.2925672531,
0.2451613247,
-0.1983573586,
0.1031504646,
-0.3495342135,
-0.0159006938,
-0.1468510032,
-0.1689263582,
-0.5212350488,
0.2715834975,
0.6915701032,
1.0558274984,
-0.1212512404,
0.3194809556,
0.1068437099,
0.6072604656,
-0.4446305931,
0.2830093503,
-0.2337278277,
-0.0239648335,
-0.4589444101,
0.0324515924,
-0.393024534,
-0.2976305485,
-0.2028028518,
-0.461897254,
-0.2715555727,
0.084160164,
1.0845284462,
0.2289886773,
-0.7163262963,
0.468794167,
-0.6059502959,
1.1539171934,
-0.5859405994,
0.3838328719,
0.241099149,
0.4180108607,
-0.2754375935,
0.0006227139,
-0.3598882258,
0.1446231455,
-0.1949228197,
-0.0989506841,
0.0259722229,
-0.0443013869,
-0.1692917049,
0.3111941814,
-0.246646896,
0.6334300637,
-0.0701905265,
-0.1607721448,
0.784288168,
0.1623838395,
-0.000758377,
-0.3003178835,
-0.4377270639,
-0.4262243807,
-0.8029001951,
0.3166138828,
0.5113984942,
0.538166821,
-0.1063853651,
0.5793358684,
-0.1795364618,
0.6521787643,
-0.2064071149,
-0.2406202555,
0.5247097015,
0.0549272522,
-0.1797394454,
-0.1500386596,
0.9891651273,
0.26171875,
0.5298622847,
-0.0559327714,
-0.1964188814,
-0.2485002726,
0.1485239863,
-0.7057521939,
0.1568605453,
-0.0597276986,
-0.6275398731,
-0.578773737,
-0.1456083655,
-0.9414219856,
-0.4728586674,
-0.5212564468,
0.1101802811,
-0.0475793965,
-0.2734089494,
0.010235331,
0.2197213322,
0.2272743881,
0.3330681026,
-1.277769804,
0.0412027091,
0.4145433903,
0.3679443598,
-0.2935585082,
-0.5115583539,
-0.4048085809,
0.0698914975,
-0.3914780915,
0.9181604385,
-0.6962658167,
-0.133972764,
-0.0031214035,
-0.1648098081,
0.3858968914,
-0.595503211,
0.5008242726,
-0.6175707579,
0.0131876068,
-0.5435642004,
-0.4218259752,
-0.2897218466,
0.0481270105,
-0.5780995488,
1.2535551786,
0.4413652718,
-0.6630981565,
0.5021247268,
-0.6718015075,
-0.3525186777,
0.1608017683,
-0.6804347038,
-0.3538201451,
0.2234144658,
0.1314499378,
0.7700317502,
-0.7932447195,
0.3730733395,
-0.3188012838,
-0.129362002,
0.5048983693,
-0.7858221531,
0.8189611435,
0.1219656765,
-0.1448410004,
0.4133415818,
-0.7255190611,
0.2128293663,
0.1601594836,
-0.6009662747,
-0.318253696,
-0.0941876397,
0.4553413689,
0.1889408827,
0.2819359303,
-0.4017451704,
0.4230052829,
-0.0483192876,
0.3836333156,
0.789198041,
-0.2796326876,
0.5032489896,
0.0003802422,
0.519131422,
0.1559064835,
0.0982517526,
0.1659072042,
-0.3087261021,
-0.3301668465,
-0.4774024487,
0.5115855336,
0.3155488074,
0.0981937423,
0.4059141874,
-0.1889482886,
-0.1661810577,
-0.831710577,
0.1417042315,
0.26584813,
0.1276724935,
0.1957136095,
-0.0966652557,
-0.4315665364,
-1.1154475212,
-0.0921566486,
-0.2204550505,
-0.196751371,
0.0963618532,
0.2502086759,
-0.2958783209,
0.9845710993,
-0.5417820215,
-0.3574408591,
-0.263281554,
0.4682882428,
0.0661590844,
0.1369692534,
0.6032242179,
-0.7035223842,
-0.2888388336,
0.3083205521,
-0.688193202,
-0.248776257,
0.0790969357,
-0.2637678683,
0.3577567935,
0.1858456135,
-0.2951707542,
0.3817788064,
0.6660621762,
-0.4067046344,
0.4589861035,
-0.4340234101,
0.3468586504,
-1.1186630726,
0.1935251057,
-0.2042743713,
-0.285538286,
-0.3754878342,
-0.143790096,
0.2290990502,
0.1130309477,
-0.39689821,
0.6626108885,
-0.466837883,
-0.5889366865,
-0.129585892,
-0.1127414703,
0.0891412646,
0.534476459,
0.1464868933,
0.8691610098,
0.0983766913,
-0.2585919499,
0.5224812627,
0.3969636858,
-0.4729223251,
0.8232150674,
-0.4876265824,
-0.2450783849,
-0.2662006021,
-0.0249765441,
-0.6794925332,
-0.4375781417,
-0.2515946031,
-0.3709160089,
0.1071560904,
-0.1846615523,
-0.6455435157,
0.0658026785,
-0.1633912027,
0.6570909023,
0.700445056,
-0.6134916544,
0.4677699804,
0.8835234642,
0.0371372998,
-0.5397350192,
-0.5227842927,
0.0417823307,
-0.4800548851,
-0.4563817978,
0.1281265616,
0.1484402567,
-0.3135233223,
-0.1256169677,
0.5274718404,
-0.1382015795,
0.1621365845,
0.3141773939,
0.2076812983,
-0.0598113984,
0.2748985887,
-0.150984779,
-0.168636322,
-0.1492647082,
-0.3532952666,
0.4362158477,
-0.121191524,
-0.5482723713,
-0.1279551834,
0.5464374423,
0.8107358217,
-0.4878373146,
0.6938800812,
0.4593345523,
-0.4321557581,
0.0985684171,
-0.4276232719,
0.1525541693,
-0.3472160697,
0.3741417825,
-0.2000540197,
-0.760855794,
0.5429620743,
-0.0911081061,
0.1642309129,
0.5278725028,
0.713732481,
-0.1798255742,
1.1363531351,
0.6751592755,
-0.4259961843,
0.2208906412,
-0.1376265287,
0.0924748033,
-0.9642842412,
-0.4679315686,
-0.4718413055,
-0.3666022718,
-0.3590053916,
-0.6597256064,
0.31045416,
0.3012056649,
-0.6060493588,
0.098422341,
-0.331415087,
0.4659230113,
0.4961247146,
-0.4496316314,
0.3086791337,
0.1570535153,
-0.2490950376,
-0.3342060447,
-0.5213195086,
-0.7282655835,
1.0319722891,
0.5190953612,
1.0336254835,
0.223792091,
0.4283301532,
0.0712806582,
0.4681532681,
-0.7406868339,
0.2139156461,
-0.308898896,
-0.3862430453,
-0.7024743557,
-0.4471545219,
-1.0748480558,
0.5438730717,
-0.2271303833,
-0.8001878262,
0.3223542869,
0.1721988767,
-0.5804254413,
0.4318339825,
-0.4295327961,
1.1005241871,
-0.753608644,
-0.1136238873,
-0.0759975314,
-0.4933228195,
0.172421962,
-0.0608034059,
0.4706510305,
-0.4436078966,
0.230546996,
0.6638736129,
-0.1517667472,
0.9243371487,
0.072141543,
-0.2766424417,
-0.0787446573,
-0.0127433194,
0.208520472,
-0.0421997681,
-0.1032587811,
0.3809821606,
-0.000140466,
-0.6093867421,
-0.2955696881,
0.6168200374,
-1.2046240568,
-0.4198252261,
-0.6407182813,
-0.8342895508,
-0.1781380326,
0.1527473181,
0.135607481,
0.2157097757,
-0.4302946329,
0.0556947328,
0.6373414993,
-0.4388150275,
0.1372252703,
0.2248273492,
-0.5874693394,
-0.3611733317,
0.732662797,
-0.0084530106,
0.4775282145,
0.5886049867,
0.3077196181,
-0.4464969337,
-0.0814865306,
-0.7281668782,
0.1957414746,
-0.7298797369,
-0.2817995548,
-0.3697651625,
-0.1032978371,
-0.3347125351,
-0.1801433712,
-0.5400070548,
-0.2680231333,
-0.3784627318,
-0.0605187826,
0.7375506163,
1.0372036695,
-0.0511844717,
0.1021709591,
-0.7211298943,
0.0302698426,
0.3981922567,
0.4803696275,
0.0731447786,
-0.5433318019,
-0.2743204832,
0.3336440921,
-0.2754276693,
-0.6738672256,
0.534208715,
-0.0226277206,
0.5790656209,
0.5987224579,
0.0094584236,
0.7065711617,
-0.4226699471,
0.5794863105,
0.2170722485,
-0.8661152124,
-0.0440462194,
-0.2716480494,
0.2236329615,
0.4460529983,
0.15377675,
-1.0144753456,
0.1581922174,
-0.2832565308,
-0.7499708533,
0.6157548428,
-0.198495701,
0.1122062877,
0.1072186902,
0.1734844297,
0.0575007983,
0.2125844061,
-0.664124608,
-0.0208095349,
-0.2071665972,
-0.3978769481,
-0.233609587,
-0.3489474952,
-0.1026233807,
-0.3127500713,
0.2805611789,
-0.2418442965,
0.2342328131,
-0.3666486442,
-0.1054111347,
-0.4175046086,
0.4410734475,
0.5102371573,
0.5472925305,
-0.1652052701,
0.3439808488,
0.1351957917,
0.1409421265,
0.5663200021,
-0.1904509366,
0.0630599633,
-0.4019436836,
0.2904870808,
0.8673746586,
0.4788346589,
-0.7331516147,
0.6805174351,
0.1985320151,
-0.1036863402,
-0.3539196551,
-0.3324170709,
0.5212447047,
0.1829242408,
0.1107444316,
-0.1516828835,
-0.2233838737,
-0.8305072784,
-0.0478072464,
0.4731081426,
-0.3732596636,
-0.4211900532,
0.7574915886,
0.2396999002,
-0.1534276903,
0.8484824896,
-0.269600451,
-0.7483696938,
0.2659273148,
0.2103663087,
0.6292165518,
-0.3229854703,
0.3612345457,
0.0092727998,
-0.0012939863,
-0.1970095336,
0.28921175,
0.3271764815,
-0.7018387914,
-0.5753134489,
-0.8823177814,
-0.1766616255,
0.1226420626,
-0.6332163811,
0.1131838784,
-0.0166007541,
0.0778157562,
0.1312165856,
-0.118260704,
-0.6643612385,
-0.1828224361,
0.0993877873,
0.480265379,
-1.1569256783,
0.9859240651,
0.8119659424,
-0.5196649432,
-0.7210499644,
-0.0162019432,
0.0715066716,
-0.8116238117,
1.2762085199,
-0.0229289513,
0.0044873781,
-0.3305704594,
-0.0862704217,
-1.0126750469,
1.0154647827,
0.6882869005,
-0.3575619161,
0.1540593803,
0.6513072252,
0.5624987483,
-0.470268786,
0.2677320242,
0.5002564788,
0.6197214127,
0.1905311346,
-0.8383271694,
-0.1927936226,
0.1341391653,
0.3533020318,
0.5949031115,
-0.7674383521,
0.9184001088,
-0.2535755932,
-0.0987737849,
-0.2106059045,
0.7489972711,
0.1557835042,
-0.3120289743,
0.4240394831,
0.5211553574,
0.86137712,
0.1338611245,
0.8262211084,
-0.0248545222,
0.3353197277,
0.7947279215,
-0.4494685531,
0.9601582885,
0.5011738539,
-0.440613538,
0.1684625298,
0.8299493194,
0.2377378792,
0.2953785062,
0.4417396188,
0.0090142386,
-0.5777063966,
-0.2587471604,
-0.0027622289,
0.4830124676,
0.0317281783,
0.0187028032,
-0.2662007213,
-0.0430626497,
0.1285620928,
0.3610950708,
-0.05584912,
0.6158374548,
-0.0115568768,
-0.6091561913,
0.8006040454,
0.0270751566,
0.5174475312,
-0.2763910294,
-0.151201576,
-0.2855860591,
0.3076025546,
-0.1910447329,
-0.9793234468,
0.1387293339,
0.0731417611,
-0.3374666572,
-0.4273421466,
0.0146436989,
-0.7288858891,
-0.62736094,
0.5744008422,
0.1811994314,
0.2954503596,
-0.0879418626,
-0.4448474944,
0.0562564023,
-0.0795267448,
-0.2729524076,
0.731148541,
0.5597278476,
-0.6844547391,
0.5749896169,
0.4609993696,
0.1716109067,
-0.0792243481,
0.3269950151,
0.5757389069,
-0.6931843162,
-0.2800820172,
-0.6935817599,
0.4443007708,
-0.0607758127,
-0.4199144244,
0.4353247285,
0.4587870836,
0.8232371211,
0.1352388561,
0.7193797231,
0.2848109007,
0.4556495845,
-0.3129969239,
0.6953580379,
-0.5579761863,
0.2994502783,
-0.086809054,
-0.7614614964,
-0.3497386277,
0.6797315478,
-0.055777777,
-0.0515876673,
0.3434709609,
0.387911886,
-0.016352959,
-0.415792793,
0.6147029996,
0.0268523823,
0.381457746,
0.4422770441,
0.8552576303,
-0.0266666058,
0.1853736937,
-0.0283807348,
-0.4614397883,
-0.4179464877,
-0.9486302137,
-0.8508139253,
-0.6890607476,
-0.0443268456,
0.0428317487,
-0.2930476964,
1.3982150555,
0.7566856146,
-0.8114600778,
-0.732863009,
0.3786515296,
-0.042476356,
-0.3329644203,
-0.1253363937,
0.535918951,
-0.2322523892,
-0.5123927593,
0.0787860751,
0.4274794161,
0.1960285604,
-0.6583847404,
-0.261465162,
-0.1387142986,
0.1319188327,
0.6742459536,
0.21877563,
-0.7732850909,
-0.5430802107,
-0.1037620381,
-0.165579319,
0.2622873187,
0.750534296,
-0.6413609385,
0.1160568297,
0.4117698967,
0.7921674848,
0.1827175319,
-0.0569033735,
0.7253397703,
-0.7616369128,
0.1837195158,
0.0799609125,
0.5493665934,
0.4818688035,
-0.4644816816,
0.1321805865,
-0.0684789568,
-0.7175083756,
-0.7271947861,
0.5238968134,
-0.7520609498,
-0.2701096535,
1.2205281258,
-0.0854878724,
-0.1663003415,
0.0044401204,
-0.1549534351,
0.037730664,
-0.5034922957,
0.8314898014,
0.6465593576,
-0.0435012467,
-0.1352401376,
-0.6336004138,
0.4575280547,
0.4336729646,
-1.0301789045,
0.697514832,
0.4011234343,
0.1425992996,
-0.0117642563,
0.3986574411,
-0.3515877724,
-0.1746180058,
-0.6658746004,
0.7485439777,
0.2447333485,
-0.1711357981,
-0.4619901478,
-0.0211789627,
0.6474464536,
-0.1068010181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07879v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07879v1
|
Analyzing Toxicity in Deep Conversations: A Reddit Case Study
| 2024-04-11T16:10:44 | 2024-04-11T16:10:44 |
Vigneshwaran Shankaran, Rajesh Sharma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI
|
Online social media has become increasingly popular in recent years due to
its ease of access and ability to connect with others. One of social media's
main draws is its anonymity, allowing users to share their thoughts and
opinions without fear of judgment or retribution. This anonymity has also made
social media prone to harmful content, which requires moderation to ensure
responsible and productive use. Several methods using artificial intelligence
have been employed to detect harmful content. However, conversation and
contextual analysis of hate speech are still understudied. Most promising works
only analyze a single text at a time rather than the conversation supporting
it. In this work, we employ a tree-based approach to understand how users
behave concerning toxicity in public conversation settings. To this end, we
collect both the posts and the comment sections of the top 100 posts from 8
Reddit communities that allow profanity, totaling over 1 million responses. We
find that toxic comments increase the likelihood of subsequent toxic comments
being produced in online conversations. Our analysis also shows that immediate
context plays a vital role in shaping a response rather than the original post.
We also study the effect of consensual profanity and observe overlapping
similarities with non-consensual profanity in terms of user behavior and
patterns.
|
[
-0.2386611402,
-1.307481885,
0.5153976679,
0.2392528802,
-0.3553064466,
0.0561353937,
-0.1134183556,
-0.6647585034,
0.1047187373,
0.4755155444,
-0.5160012841,
-0.5251877904,
-0.8141798377,
-0.0552824102,
-0.7807056308,
1.1438481808,
0.3893322051,
-0.2124976814,
-0.0682646781,
-0.2474277467,
-0.5026086569,
-0.7008474469,
-0.9191490412,
0.1415768415,
0.8787817955,
0.3417725861,
0.6723259687,
0.397136569,
0.6340494156,
0.3987491131,
-0.3525545299,
-0.197619617,
-0.9730407,
0.4671219587,
-0.3847990632,
-0.1014645547,
-0.1434863061,
-0.1779695004,
0.2318031341,
0.3347782493,
0.0453056097,
0.176667586,
0.0258034319,
0.3438130617,
-0.5080510974,
-0.1341350079,
-0.7162888646,
0.2220398039,
-0.3022044897,
-0.2793259621,
-0.1938814074,
-0.4799604118,
0.1384837925,
-0.4024864137,
-0.0934489742,
-0.2956314981,
0.5593789816,
0.185261637,
-0.6293053031,
-0.6401244402,
-1.07627666,
0.8312746882,
-0.7518063784,
0.106861271,
0.3443617225,
0.1053370535,
0.0998416841,
-0.6469696164,
-0.6106775403,
-0.1812581122,
-0.6257530451,
-0.0036810632,
-0.3118144274,
0.1359509379,
0.1489876062,
0.226141274,
-0.2421706021,
-0.0235397927,
-0.4512812793,
-0.1483028382,
0.9325328469,
0.3192880154,
0.6249628663,
-0.1319964528,
-0.1793179065,
0.0900563374,
-0.2145219147,
-0.2188325077,
0.3978689611,
0.0957930014,
0.0466532893,
0.3607092798,
0.124679625,
0.3073491752,
-0.3188689351,
0.0503147319,
-0.1024010703,
-0.5222030878,
0.0502618887,
-0.0090136295,
0.9148180485,
0.9755861759,
0.6824559569,
0.2415002286,
0.3222611845,
0.4316677749,
0.5332095623,
-1.0008499622,
-0.3708588779,
0.1144725308,
-0.5163963437,
-0.5380772948,
-0.2537613213,
-1.1459743977,
-1.0830962658,
0.0111111607,
0.0827822834,
-0.0679211915,
-0.4479775131,
-0.2778960764,
-0.1279443204,
-0.2329392731,
0.150894329,
-0.5310232043,
0.3640313447,
0.4441770911,
0.8047710657,
-0.2065867931,
0.0416240133,
-0.1889157891,
0.1470521539,
-0.1671636254,
0.611025691,
-0.8545868993,
-0.371955514,
0.2976083755,
-0.0971924216,
0.3261045814,
-0.5137717724,
1.0410984755,
-0.4106775224,
0.2752044201,
-0.2102690637,
-0.2407972664,
-0.5174329281,
0.3855026066,
-0.2874858975,
0.5066617727,
-0.2028097063,
-1.0422033072,
0.1952600926,
-0.7814559937,
-0.7396782041,
0.1621053815,
-0.1132838801,
-0.4066864252,
-0.0797075778,
-0.1935662478,
0.3467719257,
0.2431481332,
0.0396079719,
-0.5229138732,
-0.3572202027,
0.3931876421,
-0.452455759,
0.6939728856,
0.4235274792,
-0.5676528811,
0.426034987,
-0.2430209965,
-0.1271804571,
0.047506053,
-0.1683880836,
-0.7691414356,
0.2976987958,
0.0650730059,
0.2518221438,
-0.1799502075,
-0.6652007699,
-0.6087210774,
-0.4840389788,
0.8995605111,
0.5314743519,
0.5501149297,
0.0535517,
-0.3327147365,
0.1446095705,
0.2038394362,
0.5187433362,
0.153715834,
-0.2991171777,
-0.5506557822,
0.2892426848,
-0.2957004309,
0.3861342371,
-0.1929692924,
0.0886562616,
-0.0146373138,
-0.468562454,
-0.2708521783,
-0.0302769467,
0.5313577652,
0.4190166891,
0.4180273116,
-0.6014957428,
-0.5637466311,
-0.9016510844,
-0.402467221,
-0.2991692126,
0.0471380726,
0.6986502409,
0.2122926116,
-0.3243524432,
0.6728859544,
-0.5226805806,
-0.5545346737,
0.2521033883,
0.1810522377,
-0.2295299619,
0.3558157682,
0.5093801618,
-0.7491349578,
-0.8155882955,
0.0566595308,
-0.6121062636,
-0.0536411963,
-0.0089143598,
-0.2626928687,
-0.2179761678,
0.5549656749,
-0.3030014932,
0.3733876944,
0.4446524978,
-0.3710228503,
0.1983408034,
0.1675387919,
0.4487519562,
-0.6399052739,
0.1257366687,
0.0786648989,
0.1581255049,
-1.0528026819,
-0.1091610491,
-0.5910651684,
-0.0202831682,
-0.6476233006,
0.2967056334,
-0.0461578593,
0.2840106785,
-0.1460670531,
0.271740973,
-0.1739345044,
0.3266972601,
0.0240796413,
0.6095634103,
0.1919648498,
-0.5128586292,
0.16414617,
0.25270769,
-0.1955051571,
0.5028432608,
-0.4697322547,
0.1529720873,
-0.3952269256,
0.2392660379,
-0.9678441286,
-0.3064109683,
0.4893584847,
-0.5625065565,
-0.3175399601,
0.0497796237,
-0.3236168325,
-0.3319005966,
-0.4446853995,
0.5229640603,
0.1200654879,
-0.005600011,
0.2520041466,
0.9209036231,
-0.4520660043,
-0.39695099,
-0.6123006344,
0.1496071368,
-0.5997849107,
-0.4689103663,
0.1678357273,
-0.4110732973,
-0.7387315035,
-0.1304498613,
0.0643661991,
-0.3259194493,
0.3229970336,
0.3214453161,
-0.4416969419,
0.1591669023,
0.1698754728,
0.1748132259,
0.3443714976,
0.6131557822,
0.6324936748,
0.616823256,
-0.1567700058,
0.1669534594,
-0.6120141745,
0.6196029782,
0.7524617314,
-0.0268362891,
0.6251016259,
0.3612546027,
-0.3636140227,
-0.1373572201,
-0.3227877021,
-0.4601100981,
-0.4949088693,
0.362555027,
0.2949826419,
-0.8930037618,
0.4539689124,
0.0612565354,
0.1922036111,
0.1382523924,
0.6359593868,
-0.3379175961,
1.1466010809,
0.2853395343,
0.0523202643,
0.6846066713,
0.1110192016,
0.4056617618,
-0.2136958539,
-0.1659763455,
-0.2789561749,
-0.406524837,
-0.4276930094,
-0.1034772694,
0.2448656708,
-0.2422618866,
-0.5008718371,
0.1558211446,
-0.7142803073,
0.7433153987,
0.2176814079,
0.1885424703,
0.448099792,
0.0701676682,
0.3141753078,
-0.2688552737,
-0.3127179146,
-0.5511153936,
0.5498094559,
0.5623127222,
0.4409368038,
0.3054087758,
0.2078707069,
0.695146203,
0.8247998953,
-0.7243098021,
0.5485922694,
-0.2053913474,
-1.1497377157,
-0.2950106263,
-0.3122769594,
-0.9326624274,
0.1670356393,
-0.4030728638,
-0.6701946259,
-0.1791408062,
0.1398515552,
-0.6433443427,
0.2504745126,
-0.8010548949,
0.7744912505,
-0.2537112534,
-0.5949960351,
-0.3960569501,
-0.873121202,
0.5811644793,
-0.0125112589,
0.6438471675,
-0.0754202232,
0.2476986796,
0.9278849363,
-0.0418137014,
1.1389644146,
-0.1518965364,
-0.1643107086,
0.6013929248,
0.1787388921,
0.0710676014,
0.0912838504,
0.0447028689,
0.2125046551,
0.0339450501,
-0.0361464098,
-0.2624920607,
0.8424866796,
-0.7483525872,
-0.483173877,
-0.1480165124,
-0.2031221241,
-0.1618323475,
0.2939985096,
0.055791568,
0.02882245,
-0.2855698764,
0.3099592626,
0.6754118204,
-0.4990423024,
0.3159188926,
0.2619761825,
-0.100477621,
-0.2467784286,
0.8403833508,
0.0011113103,
0.1228439659,
0.0243830178,
0.6398336887,
-0.1583214104,
-0.6258645654,
-0.0989686772,
0.3200153112,
-0.7001655698,
-0.1841527671,
-0.6779767275,
-0.2692327797,
-0.2997522652,
-0.1248483583,
-0.0816560686,
0.1155479997,
-0.2277650237,
-0.2196459472,
0.3055207729,
0.9975513816,
0.0975036621,
0.4720085263,
-0.8137627244,
-0.2104074955,
0.6039298177,
0.4612867534,
0.2613296211,
-0.3303364813,
0.1973864138,
0.1352520734,
-0.3935297132,
-1.279740572,
0.3743677437,
0.0536227264,
0.1423766166,
0.5930090547,
0.3611667752,
0.6631464362,
-0.2081193328,
0.7581298351,
-0.0177156478,
-0.5770453215,
0.6484776139,
-0.5850842595,
-0.167435661,
0.7955052853,
0.6692525148,
-1.103394866,
-0.793158114,
-0.5401201248,
-0.8068149686,
0.3748792708,
0.3895861208,
0.8510105014,
-0.3116799593,
0.130095914,
0.0366815999,
0.2454453111,
-0.8735265136,
-0.4124308825,
-0.215174064,
-0.0635584742,
0.1305634826,
-0.5475184321,
-0.6360898614,
-0.3409363627,
0.4374252856,
0.3520712852,
0.1047775224,
0.0067309453,
-0.1059927344,
-0.3538418114,
0.3414191902,
0.8883641958,
0.4809986949,
-0.2235899568,
0.3640946448,
0.2128892541,
-0.6227378249,
-0.1628758013,
-0.4426158965,
-0.1179918423,
-0.2096120715,
0.258864522,
0.394697696,
0.2319016159,
-0.760730803,
0.7281179428,
-0.1561424881,
-0.0971161649,
-0.2989350855,
0.0820953175,
0.2134548128,
0.2036397904,
-0.0142716058,
-0.1330630034,
0.230101943,
-0.8392007351,
0.5238533616,
0.3473663032,
-0.6750041842,
-0.2650875747,
0.6762260795,
0.6920876503,
-0.4190729558,
0.4125675261,
0.0727434307,
-0.5496279597,
0.2648590803,
0.2213375717,
0.5886287689,
-0.1600483358,
0.4099576473,
0.6443242431,
0.1191378832,
0.7455376387,
-0.064361304,
-0.001293266,
-0.6964603662,
-0.2199959606,
-0.6958193779,
-0.2020447105,
0.643971324,
-0.1517370939,
-0.1751936376,
-0.8224239349,
-0.2604467571,
0.1068435758,
0.0847987905,
-0.1549345404,
0.1845036596,
0.1991766542,
0.3257252574,
-1.2633953094,
0.366912663,
0.4022862911,
-0.4095939696,
-0.3065191507,
0.2248134762,
0.289026469,
-0.5881333947,
0.3885228634,
0.3034182191,
-0.2351244986,
0.0228227582,
-0.671611011,
-0.5536577702,
0.655192852,
-0.0087236706,
-0.3411796689,
0.2469814122,
0.225322023,
1.1495341063,
0.0064901211,
0.444250226,
0.642873466,
0.3964252472,
0.1965542287,
-0.5286790133,
0.2320341766,
-0.2623842359,
-0.0481186882,
0.2163069397,
-0.6732344627,
0.5148081183,
0.1068789363,
-0.9490712285,
-0.2582889199,
0.5539348125,
-0.0184055101,
0.3683508635,
0.5810560584,
0.1502503753,
0.4841425717,
0.3433920145,
0.5714128017,
-0.2437541932,
0.2816776931,
1.0367697477,
-0.0253702328,
0.8459580541,
0.377466917,
-0.0344741233,
0.6060256362,
0.472260952,
0.1938503832,
0.3329800665,
0.5362282991,
-0.6587320566,
-0.0624111071,
-0.5612401366,
-0.3428940773,
0.1958075613,
0.5077789426,
-0.5633741021,
-0.3586142063,
-0.043863602,
0.584857583,
0.5827736259,
-0.3426197767,
0.9492518306,
-0.0008863598,
-0.6451290846,
0.0667731762,
-0.057902012,
0.8530809283,
-0.2274870425,
-0.0404684395,
-0.3792999387,
0.1576232761,
-0.4698195755,
-1.0985697508,
0.7848953605,
0.0926358998,
0.3767675459,
-0.2560550869,
1.0051816702,
-0.5052503347,
-0.108437255,
0.4433154166,
0.307094276,
0.2761529088,
-0.1426517069,
-0.7585737705,
0.1669247597,
-0.2212938815,
-0.1011501774,
0.3062188029,
0.3251487911,
-0.1500240564,
0.5018084049,
0.6221534014,
-0.2165088058,
0.075639829,
0.0064740656,
0.9683302045,
-0.4741253257,
-0.1595433801,
-1.0332152843,
0.5028392673,
-0.4623829126,
-0.5504992008,
0.7436609864,
0.2864225507,
0.8890483379,
0.223093152,
0.508267343,
-0.1518181115,
0.627636373,
0.1159787625,
1.2883456945,
-0.2415016145,
0.0040051718,
-0.4423922598,
-0.7047078609,
-0.7334695458,
0.7182255983,
-0.3986181915,
-0.0801534876,
0.5745742917,
0.8729744554,
0.1896637976,
0.2018845081,
0.2507345974,
0.7046049237,
0.3250334263,
0.284247458,
1.0475800037,
-0.1313180923,
0.9215289354,
-0.3541334271,
-0.1768268645,
-0.1546446979,
-0.7093559504,
-0.8925666213,
-0.394567132,
-0.2824454904,
-0.3408112824,
0.0291140378,
0.3686744273,
0.3197148144,
-0.8264053464,
-0.1915090978,
-0.1653314978,
0.2568745911,
-0.0216341037,
-0.3515957594,
-0.0074158111,
0.0634246543,
-0.7092084885,
0.1200923026,
0.1472866833,
-0.2200772166,
-0.1865077764,
-0.0091676312,
-0.3515912294,
0.2504527867,
1.1101346016,
0.2201969624,
-0.5058845878,
-0.7216064334,
-0.238372609,
-0.10298343,
0.0565673634,
0.7814512849,
-0.3132399023,
0.433798641,
0.6261076331,
0.3588790894,
0.3865073025,
0.378867805,
0.2527074516,
-0.7745590806,
-0.4225753546,
0.5317510366,
-0.2899101675,
0.155658856,
-0.4209269583,
0.2188526839,
0.3540426493,
-0.5616621375,
-0.8871395588,
0.3328579366,
-0.8029749393,
-0.5913375616,
1.3121358156,
0.160055995,
-0.0372639745,
-0.3653080165,
-0.5526379943,
0.2980620265,
-0.6022104621,
1.0560946465,
0.8123007417,
-0.1633809805,
-0.0751954243,
-0.6823471785,
0.8173501492,
0.2032140046,
-1.029530406,
0.4888470173,
0.5880300403,
0.3144289553,
0.330928117,
0.791682899,
-0.0698967874,
-0.0432266109,
-0.1715481132,
-0.4136044681,
0.3420698941,
-0.3013647497,
-0.1532366276,
0.5868987441,
-0.2091876864,
0.0936637148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07851v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07851v1
|
Guiding Large Language Models to Post-Edit Machine Translation with Error Annotations
| 2024-04-11T15:47:10 | 2024-04-11T15:47:10 |
Dayeon Ki, Marine Carpuat
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Machine Translation (MT) remains one of the last NLP tasks where large
language models (LLMs) have not yet replaced dedicated supervised systems. This
work exploits the complementary strengths of LLMs and supervised MT by guiding
LLMs to automatically post-edit MT with external feedback on its quality,
derived from Multidimensional Quality Metric (MQM) annotations. Working with
LLaMA-2 models, we consider prompting strategies varying the nature of feedback
provided and then fine-tune the LLM to improve its ability to exploit the
provided guidance. Through experiments on Chinese-English, English-German, and
English-Russian MQM data, we demonstrate that prompting LLMs to post-edit MT
improves TER, BLEU and COMET scores, although the benefits of fine-grained
feedback are not clear. Fine-tuning helps integrate fine-grained feedback more
effectively and further improves translation quality based on both automatic
and human evaluation.
|
[
-0.2051974982,
-0.5627430677,
0.6644976735,
0.3153876066,
-0.4066048265,
0.0429016091,
-0.5738657117,
-0.2798760235,
0.1243530214,
0.7177750468,
-0.464931041,
-0.5836142898,
-0.8278856277,
0.5281444788,
-0.0986520201,
1.2187244892,
-0.3256630599,
0.2668854892,
0.1484003067,
-0.0448889062,
-0.6916954517,
-0.5674571395,
-0.7173014879,
-0.2790288329,
0.9182389379,
0.4368188679,
1.0484449863,
0.6842826605,
0.5610656142,
0.2174999565,
-0.1415252984,
0.9265368581,
-0.1802384108,
0.0149724549,
-0.1986661255,
-0.6606301665,
-0.8074139357,
-0.0601020977,
0.6765790582,
0.6600955129,
-0.0073361499,
0.2555340528,
0.5637003779,
0.5878198147,
-0.2404988557,
0.1372653693,
-0.5202035308,
0.0246965494,
-0.1417304873,
-0.4320386648,
-0.6202178597,
-0.3280871809,
-0.3214775324,
-0.5846154094,
-0.1822896898,
0.0813165829,
0.8053156137,
0.6916329265,
-0.3264361024,
-0.1145645455,
-0.6857457757,
0.7815306783,
-0.7927188873,
0.2574147582,
0.6163386703,
0.0440490097,
-0.4167754948,
-0.2583050728,
-0.3667413294,
-0.1249001771,
-0.2129071802,
0.0580337793,
0.0178731065,
0.0225427262,
0.1346600503,
0.1460885555,
-0.2163038254,
0.5038067102,
-0.2322056442,
-0.1378221661,
0.5481284261,
0.1590732187,
-0.0136139691,
-0.0905644521,
0.0494885221,
-0.1339388788,
-0.795971334,
0.1314448714,
0.2818884254,
0.4298154712,
-0.1021906957,
0.8194065094,
-0.3031076789,
0.6073619127,
0.0709505379,
-0.0047437665,
0.2739171088,
-0.3066521883,
-0.1981372535,
-0.2505460083,
0.9051174521,
0.8022895455,
0.1472399533,
-0.1205153316,
-0.6308764219,
-0.2219054103,
0.1806186587,
-0.5608403683,
-0.1916803718,
0.2814432979,
-0.5315770507,
-0.2137369066,
-0.0060232948,
-0.5510692,
-0.46414572,
-0.6204715371,
0.5493258834,
-0.2310719788,
0.0160092302,
0.1022316515,
0.1042057648,
-0.0656413585,
0.8114923239,
-0.9411993623,
-0.1270456463,
0.6632773876,
0.9224722981,
0.0096995775,
-0.4070959389,
-1.152074337,
0.1725232899,
-0.6885154247,
0.7577905059,
-0.4572912753,
-0.2750707269,
0.026016254,
0.2314728647,
0.1679717898,
-0.609841466,
0.6180045009,
-0.4697592854,
0.1699533165,
-0.4143973887,
-0.2242187858,
-0.3315437138,
0.3593462408,
-0.3066629767,
0.9988051057,
0.1330066025,
-0.5098692179,
0.4046074748,
-0.6325269938,
-0.37063393,
-0.1369615942,
0.27156353,
-0.3795375824,
0.5735929012,
0.6452764273,
0.5454224348,
-0.1681288332,
0.3724794388,
-0.1923283488,
-0.161842823,
0.2040845007,
-0.21775271,
0.3046223521,
0.0215968955,
-0.0853206813,
0.5452712178,
-0.6174658537,
-0.0418597199,
-0.1067486331,
-0.6998959184,
-0.1375229657,
0.0056273881,
-0.1255440116,
0.3832007945,
0.0893859118,
-0.1912209988,
0.5141295791,
-0.2700819671,
0.3987969756,
0.6794862747,
-0.0773338005,
0.2778477371,
-0.3890366852,
0.4341914058,
-0.0543497987,
0.1375800818,
-0.3584726751,
-0.4889562428,
-0.7811483145,
0.027911365,
0.5415238738,
0.6284386516,
-0.9517352581,
0.5015823841,
-0.202087149,
-0.3548264205,
-1.0569933653,
0.6030198336,
0.3007661998,
0.1210832521,
0.615989089,
-0.3520676196,
-0.4649150968,
-0.6391277909,
-0.058738295,
-0.0968472958,
-0.2691173851,
0.0224766266,
0.3831090927,
-0.591715157,
0.3616682887,
-0.028112866,
-0.4291637838,
-0.1396159828,
0.1677947193,
0.1746055931,
0.5710304976,
0.1129231378,
-0.2980094254,
-0.3616804481,
0.1646918952,
-0.5649999976,
-0.4323005974,
-0.2368695885,
-0.2582501173,
0.2329889387,
0.462002635,
-0.619972527,
0.0810556263,
0.7733052373,
-0.052539248,
0.6116064787,
-0.5555400848,
0.4958994687,
-0.9685596824,
-0.1709130406,
-0.1655341238,
-0.3081136942,
-0.3263781667,
0.024519762,
0.1078508422,
0.4032754898,
-0.3064928651,
0.234473139,
-0.1755361855,
-0.0406352729,
-0.4967350364,
0.3494835496,
0.112537384,
0.3322587311,
-0.0175355542,
0.5634857416,
0.2051276565,
-0.5616149306,
0.3390521705,
0.3360943794,
-0.1081286743,
0.624861598,
-0.6153103113,
0.1239714921,
-0.1078203246,
0.3764863014,
-0.9518622756,
-0.3897881806,
0.2886410356,
-0.4792411625,
0.3567405939,
-0.2446330935,
-0.9625188112,
-0.2282194793,
-0.2892196476,
-0.1274865121,
0.2016055435,
-0.5586504936,
0.3153067231,
0.0272642002,
-0.223633945,
-0.2727760077,
-0.8289418817,
0.4045157135,
-0.0718925297,
-0.4647365212,
0.1162310392,
-0.0071418905,
-0.2057119906,
-0.1822285354,
0.3661799729,
0.1632804126,
0.2778893709,
0.2819467187,
0.2541230023,
-0.2133021504,
0.2702891529,
0.3807319403,
-0.3938252032,
-0.0222570766,
-0.4406490028,
0.4252584577,
0.1150967628,
-0.2139669061,
-0.7356230021,
0.1236728504,
0.4075242281,
-0.4235996008,
0.7632928491,
0.7507835031,
-0.2703554332,
-0.0073624668,
-0.5114803314,
-0.4199376106,
-0.3552066386,
0.2299270332,
-0.3482818604,
-1.0135452747,
0.3013032675,
-0.0873472393,
0.3298375905,
0.6230614185,
0.6998309493,
-0.3583019674,
1.3869735003,
0.517659843,
0.0201977566,
0.2862919569,
-0.0744011477,
-0.0741488934,
-1.1617882252,
0.0137493527,
-0.5539799929,
-0.451796174,
-0.5979759693,
-0.5190346241,
0.2437855303,
0.463391453,
-0.029542597,
0.1987322271,
-0.3265115321,
0.2834922373,
0.6064327359,
0.1168620735,
0.3987639248,
-0.1406159997,
-0.1799906939,
-0.2315006107,
-0.6428126097,
-0.8197475076,
0.9479650259,
0.5231101513,
0.5382167101,
-0.0189171042,
0.5644985437,
0.0364086889,
0.5255406499,
-0.607809782,
0.1290961057,
-0.2495267987,
-0.2460336983,
-0.1575156003,
-0.4328438044,
-0.6738592386,
0.3652274013,
-0.4048133194,
-0.5319033265,
-0.2751327753,
0.5455325246,
-0.6301486492,
0.2346414626,
-0.642858088,
0.8478440642,
-0.3187490106,
-0.2093200386,
-0.2726897895,
-0.6160572767,
0.2601675689,
-0.3761672378,
0.5321495533,
-0.0558898859,
-0.1666547656,
0.5317764878,
-0.4431527853,
0.8403437734,
-0.1536053121,
-0.3559096456,
0.1215633526,
0.3255060613,
0.82632339,
0.0003724763,
-0.1573423296,
0.0306246374,
-0.0567692704,
-0.1603971571,
-0.531041503,
0.4817721248,
-0.7084115744,
-0.6974540949,
0.197162047,
-0.5332304835,
-0.151099354,
0.1553240567,
0.2707458138,
0.0839471817,
0.5222631097,
0.2913279235,
0.3429492712,
-0.4109647572,
0.2673140764,
0.4890912771,
-0.5340511799,
-0.5142036676,
0.6633552909,
0.246819824,
0.3441957831,
0.3493865728,
0.3864942789,
-0.2256690711,
-0.8447538614,
-0.9289208651,
0.2208079398,
-0.6205257773,
-0.4244551063,
-0.6336221099,
0.090448156,
-0.0667102635,
-0.1675775796,
-0.4123802781,
-0.2918596864,
-0.3500611186,
-0.2394974083,
0.4604101777,
0.8371935487,
-0.1965499967,
0.7867574096,
-1.2548162937,
0.0423822403,
-0.0833695456,
0.3352228403,
-0.1672338396,
-0.9762994051,
-0.5824816227,
0.2005395144,
-0.3244549334,
-0.627540946,
0.3183903992,
0.0464429855,
0.153452754,
0.0789104626,
-0.1919445246,
0.6739475727,
-0.5492326021,
0.9835700393,
-0.0495889112,
-0.9038943648,
0.7707045078,
-0.416156888,
0.5017948151,
0.3201442957,
0.1128655374,
-0.660738647,
-0.7677605152,
-0.1511124969,
-0.6317065358,
0.5912514329,
-0.1156970188,
0.1122346818,
0.0816998109,
0.49621889,
0.2057659775,
0.3119156659,
-0.7581005096,
0.0207407679,
-0.0040487298,
-0.1809536815,
-0.2067655474,
-0.265262723,
-0.0347878411,
-0.0498343073,
0.8177984953,
-0.2437456697,
-0.3625923395,
0.2153078616,
-0.2382636964,
-0.574573338,
0.2602113485,
0.6700852513,
0.5919641852,
-0.0182456262,
0.220087707,
0.5382743478,
0.0506952368,
0.0900965258,
-0.0693887174,
-0.3281781077,
0.0220620334,
0.4539607465,
0.7069456577,
0.0520073362,
-0.2767975032,
0.1221896112,
0.0413619019,
-0.1217509806,
0.1939727366,
-0.028656844,
-0.0379794501,
0.348400712,
0.2080422938,
0.1789343953,
-0.1211890057,
-0.1574791223,
0.1399223953,
0.2687698007,
-0.5269418359,
-0.4099994004,
0.8065365553,
0.1518039554,
-0.4188973606,
0.2418815941,
-0.2188016474,
-0.5861341953,
0.0132684652,
0.2096467018,
0.5047552586,
-0.3861859143,
0.0904080123,
0.3897279501,
0.7338032126,
-0.401963532,
0.0760719478,
0.2567265332,
-0.3766061962,
-1.1177197695,
-0.6245440841,
-0.4876312912,
0.0128881643,
-0.3678895235,
0.4800842702,
-0.4122957885,
-0.2873408496,
-0.1158733219,
-0.1568333954,
-0.6091688871,
0.3383023143,
0.1182864979,
0.6007448435,
-0.5651947856,
0.9281541109,
0.5972743034,
-0.4763881862,
-0.8471879363,
-0.1726468354,
0.140216887,
-0.6585745215,
0.7046213746,
0.2096193433,
-0.1127403304,
-0.0186374057,
-0.3868929744,
-0.7939665318,
0.6307370663,
0.3215905726,
-0.8174647093,
0.2046844959,
0.2019664347,
0.6583726406,
-0.1516157538,
0.2246562541,
0.5627806783,
0.7164897919,
-0.2070517242,
-1.1348706484,
-0.0673929676,
0.0537334122,
-0.0266041197,
0.2877957821,
-0.5705169439,
0.5000186563,
-0.2601076066,
0.1481752247,
0.0772396624,
0.6450666785,
-0.1097917035,
0.0043522413,
0.5367922187,
0.4970759749,
0.6966702342,
-0.2521823049,
1.078263998,
-0.0882968605,
0.0698209628,
1.2937449217,
0.0614991635,
1.2224771976,
0.5659025908,
-0.0946626365,
0.2563148141,
0.894071877,
-0.0438273735,
0.1847756654,
0.2320296168,
0.2907971144,
-0.1676877886,
-0.3006440997,
-0.2943871319,
0.3218657374,
0.4394402802,
-0.5477861166,
0.0620331615,
0.0084677823,
0.167639479,
0.0683295429,
-0.486145556,
0.8291009665,
0.1584799439,
-0.9216095805,
0.5386829972,
0.2374695241,
0.6837752461,
-0.2912046611,
-0.0265836492,
-0.2346087545,
0.0987099335,
-0.5083730817,
-0.884514451,
0.5628572106,
0.128034994,
-0.2720564306,
-0.2445046753,
0.0861730948,
-0.6448420286,
-0.5418695211,
0.454372704,
0.4055503309,
0.0624050274,
-0.2529640198,
-0.4720606208,
0.305868566,
0.0481152907,
-0.1886312068,
0.0583048053,
0.676325202,
-0.1038470566,
0.5023388267,
0.8042605519,
0.3645664454,
-0.0315240696,
0.1995677799,
0.525414288,
-0.5288833976,
-0.2076360136,
-1.0751982927,
0.7238399982,
0.2187262177,
-0.2989705205,
0.8392142057,
0.2516321838,
1.0381062031,
-0.0215653274,
0.6383505464,
0.4457779527,
0.5987374783,
-0.7063549757,
0.4255060554,
-0.6444414854,
0.2752113044,
-0.1878267974,
-1.1344704628,
-0.7740243077,
0.3993209004,
-0.3340348601,
-0.2210553735,
0.5165998936,
0.8025076985,
0.1864508837,
-0.3221219778,
0.2544432878,
0.3555681407,
0.4657758474,
0.3716782928,
0.8905372024,
-0.3746473491,
0.6364687681,
-0.0415090956,
-0.113174051,
-0.4560129344,
-0.7853475213,
-0.7275905013,
-0.272883445,
-0.5104634166,
-0.5252190232,
-0.0661911145,
1.2744704485,
0.6452404261,
-0.9061818719,
-0.0622884221,
0.2727139592,
0.1662558764,
-0.1737545431,
-0.1022884101,
0.3091885149,
-0.7064944506,
-0.6997868419,
0.2912808657,
0.4637559652,
0.1565185636,
-0.1407018304,
-0.2732488513,
0.1904481053,
-0.131366834,
0.7052466273,
-0.3278201818,
-1.0206019878,
-0.4621319771,
-0.2691889405,
-0.2698913813,
0.189812243,
0.5210745335,
-0.1818849295,
0.514134407,
0.2530816197,
0.7586849928,
0.0553176403,
-0.0715853646,
0.8369777203,
-0.6518464684,
0.0250230115,
-0.0796378404,
0.489902854,
0.7178442478,
-0.2697610259,
0.4835375547,
-0.0474937521,
-0.6897761822,
-0.6856880188,
-0.102396898,
-0.4811682105,
0.0187844709,
1.2702393532,
-0.2375732511,
-0.0890980512,
0.108962968,
-0.7330272198,
0.3442740738,
-0.2480985075,
0.84098351,
0.9834868908,
0.2294655144,
-0.3985921443,
-0.829929471,
0.6370580196,
0.5956340432,
-0.8415631652,
0.1205274165,
0.490231663,
-0.1865256429,
0.1109675616,
0.1729276776,
-0.0498959385,
0.3130345643,
-0.4095028043,
-0.0474432632,
-0.0135219898,
-0.3697820306,
-0.5550393462,
-0.2582514882,
0.5601884127,
-0.0548378006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07840v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07840v2
|
On Training Data Influence of GPT Models
| 2024-04-11T15:27:56 | 2024-04-16T10:05:27 |
Qingyi Liu, Yekun Chai, Shuohuan Wang, Yu Sun, Qiwei Peng, Keze Wang, Hua Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Amidst the rapid advancements in generative language models, the
investigation of how training data shapes the performance of GPT models is
still emerging. This paper presents GPTfluence, a novel approach that leverages
a featurized simulation to assess the impact of training examples on the
training dynamics of GPT models. Our approach not only traces the influence of
individual training instances on performance trajectories, such as loss and
other key metrics, on targeted test points but also enables a comprehensive
comparison with existing methods across various training scenarios in GPT
models, ranging from 14 million to 2.8 billion parameters, across a range of
downstream tasks. Contrary to earlier methods that struggle with generalization
to new data, GPTfluence introduces a parameterized simulation of training
dynamics, demonstrating robust generalization capabilities to unseen training
data. This adaptability is evident across both fine-tuning and
instruction-tuning scenarios, spanning tasks in natural language understanding
and generation. We will make our code and data publicly available.
|
[
-0.1998293251,
-1.0081771612,
0.4305306971,
0.0441260599,
0.075156495,
-0.0405551903,
-0.1692404598,
-0.2837601006,
-0.4164815545,
0.2192977965,
-0.3789033592,
-0.1879748255,
-0.5892718434,
-0.280081749,
-0.4801748693,
1.4080379009,
-0.1383876204,
0.033192154,
-0.255936861,
-0.1071077213,
-0.3672166467,
-0.7874534726,
-0.5094474554,
-0.4004275799,
0.1879501194,
-0.2148135155,
0.6561985016,
0.3946128488,
0.1696772277,
0.2794364095,
0.080970794,
-0.4398030043,
-0.8159519434,
-0.0544750765,
-0.0911061093,
-0.6838455796,
0.0274352357,
0.2839930058,
1.064602375,
0.5321820974,
-0.3322803676,
-0.079641819,
0.4172578752,
0.3075849116,
-0.3579009771,
0.4964370131,
-0.5779643655,
0.0131481821,
-0.0152474558,
-0.1127012968,
-0.1898642629,
-0.3220135272,
0.4314198792,
-0.5107632279,
0.9584419131,
-0.2376058847,
0.6795427799,
0.2149734199,
-0.1908936352,
-0.1698924452,
-0.9427663684,
0.5743433237,
-0.4781061113,
0.7522257566,
0.1642771065,
0.3020407557,
-0.3334406018,
-0.8903474212,
-0.3686664402,
-0.4934717715,
-0.0254581571,
0.0816536248,
0.0608314313,
0.3245442212,
0.4516506791,
0.522537291,
-0.5388393402,
-0.230717048,
-0.3419029713,
0.0327966996,
0.4163610041,
0.1559478641,
0.3604722321,
0.3456927836,
-0.0555359088,
-0.372264713,
-0.5046080351,
0.2019157112,
0.4592250586,
0.3953045905,
-0.2838184536,
0.2224077582,
-0.2341060787,
0.5494378209,
-0.10786549,
0.0480816588,
-0.062179666,
-0.3341811001,
-0.5032842755,
-0.1224156767,
0.7307624817,
-0.0168762244,
0.1630260199,
-0.7013685107,
0.0575616434,
-0.0823815539,
0.4806587398,
-1.0770363808,
-0.7356217504,
-0.3343160152,
-0.0557558872,
-0.3515401483,
0.0338455327,
-0.6973050833,
-0.3090907037,
-0.3468719721,
0.4103288054,
-0.6105970144,
-0.3214378059,
0.1085424051,
-0.0092560966,
0.2544878125,
0.322503984,
-1.2571913004,
0.2063600123,
0.9006632566,
0.9332447648,
0.0468047597,
-0.5329222083,
-0.5693506002,
0.1186207533,
-0.1016683877,
0.5235326886,
-0.7584002614,
-0.4697591662,
-0.1522739232,
0.041182816,
-0.5759485364,
-0.2476365119,
0.430771172,
-0.4502270818,
0.1865133494,
-0.2528949082,
-0.8109164238,
-0.3090424836,
0.0873624682,
-0.7610579133,
1.0407538414,
0.2541951835,
-0.6617797613,
0.8377844691,
-0.8001976013,
-0.3679794669,
0.1551655829,
-0.4802547693,
-0.535513103,
0.5156525373,
0.0782157183,
0.416334033,
-0.1194012687,
0.3608929217,
-0.3594079912,
-0.3299539983,
-0.1187219843,
-0.6065095067,
0.4785471559,
-0.1696987301,
-0.4371543229,
-0.03437756,
-0.7527603507,
0.0771781802,
0.0383310542,
-0.3973387182,
-0.2844614983,
0.1106862426,
0.0100986576,
0.0300791729,
-0.4134515822,
-0.3120004237,
0.4756076336,
-0.2852198482,
0.3640762866,
0.5400522947,
0.2930228412,
0.2441378236,
-0.0346075408,
0.8494258523,
-0.2961019576,
0.1347320676,
0.1641881466,
-0.7051689625,
-0.2252461165,
-0.0767288655,
0.4620766044,
0.1906069368,
-0.6453054547,
-0.3376307487,
-0.3364057541,
-0.2828974724,
-0.4569498301,
0.1924740374,
0.1603004336,
0.4947158992,
0.2676072717,
-0.1044191495,
-0.3382149935,
-0.62320292,
-0.3024125099,
-0.3286221623,
-0.1082123667,
-0.009570553,
0.5172076225,
0.0236600917,
0.8955084085,
-0.2348825932,
0.1591270417,
-0.2992204726,
0.5030866265,
-0.0781779289,
0.6740691066,
0.9307702184,
-0.5692640543,
-0.2004857957,
-0.0704850107,
-0.5974981785,
0.2130628526,
-0.3553202748,
-0.0825319514,
-0.0743351281,
0.1665056348,
-0.3286848068,
0.395650208,
0.7956385612,
-0.3715272248,
0.6780723929,
-0.2687541842,
0.3511942625,
-0.6828393936,
0.0782527849,
0.0127367834,
0.1113002822,
-0.8094614148,
0.1758900732,
-0.0498646833,
-0.0914978608,
-0.2144461423,
0.1612032801,
-0.2544089258,
0.005839278,
0.0627075732,
-0.5051876307,
-0.0660223141,
0.2914010584,
0.0157706589,
1.3626601696,
0.5789211988,
-0.4109034836,
0.1321709752,
0.2400442213,
-0.5302283764,
0.2308942974,
-0.6828999519,
0.2346401066,
-0.0017032595,
-0.0065867268,
-0.9056645036,
-0.2849117517,
-0.0036191489,
-0.2222803533,
0.3453043699,
-0.7308258414,
-0.6775800586,
-0.1247094944,
-0.0501695871,
0.3544600904,
0.4000464678,
-0.5448938012,
0.5583998561,
0.0413442664,
-0.0225593057,
-0.1733546257,
-0.5356505513,
0.065978758,
-0.4491348863,
-0.444227308,
0.037386667,
-0.0254138019,
0.1536131203,
-0.280683428,
0.0183564387,
-0.1088225618,
0.5187619925,
0.3012524247,
0.1292536557,
-0.2889818549,
0.2352036089,
0.0401684195,
0.2335803062,
0.3336912096,
-0.4441820085,
0.5339902043,
-0.4124003351,
-0.3819311857,
-0.3540819287,
-0.0005329198,
0.3878284395,
-0.0472827405,
1.0608978271,
0.7576672435,
-0.1424148381,
-0.3410059214,
-0.3372460306,
-0.1109586135,
-0.5045279264,
0.6565701962,
-0.2842743993,
-0.7761053443,
0.5105682015,
0.1040859297,
-0.0489932857,
0.1822204441,
0.5829131007,
0.1106003821,
1.1221323013,
0.762460649,
-0.358561933,
0.7217352986,
-0.4719241261,
-0.022587467,
-0.5309216976,
-0.1244349107,
-0.2254342884,
-0.1741795093,
-0.6194421053,
-0.4254825711,
0.2004363835,
0.4426698387,
-0.0451120809,
0.1137854084,
-0.3078187704,
0.4821104109,
0.322694689,
-0.0590043031,
0.233422488,
0.0818826854,
-0.1359137744,
-0.0966680646,
-0.7522292137,
-0.3483510613,
1.2564690113,
0.3064226508,
0.7241848707,
-0.0212235693,
0.4169218242,
0.0778289735,
0.7822475433,
-0.6663228273,
0.2693917751,
0.0513417423,
-0.4482306242,
-0.2530472577,
-0.6394415498,
-0.8053130507,
0.0939581692,
-0.0858494714,
-0.7987047434,
-0.2413508147,
0.2672418654,
-0.161047861,
0.4921339154,
-0.7878759503,
0.9689887762,
-0.328315258,
-0.4252144992,
-0.0505398773,
-0.1953613162,
0.3452889025,
-0.0527335741,
-0.2166695595,
-0.0386378542,
0.1928724349,
0.7706264853,
-0.356661886,
0.7984377742,
-0.4432819486,
-0.2441882938,
0.2052091956,
-0.0681061149,
0.6867709756,
0.2080715597,
-0.0813664272,
0.1104903594,
-0.0128279626,
-0.3321369886,
-0.9931384921,
0.5594171286,
-0.5748134255,
-0.4410458505,
0.0964137316,
-0.7751269341,
-0.7268339992,
0.0026179072,
0.2378506362,
0.5302020311,
-0.4553260505,
0.0904223025,
0.5087938905,
-0.0023600322,
0.2557109594,
0.2240020484,
-0.1322603673,
-0.2659684718,
1.0090417862,
0.1668860465,
0.4073959291,
0.0923470408,
0.32507357,
-0.4279865026,
-0.9718902707,
-0.6286356449,
0.1117501929,
-0.5187779069,
0.1721056104,
-0.5266351104,
0.0150724715,
-0.3291226923,
-0.0251153316,
-0.2204318345,
-0.2181728929,
-0.1133346558,
-0.397842437,
0.6318711638,
0.9124843478,
0.2478538603,
0.4654797316,
-0.5934406519,
-0.1010261402,
0.5316474438,
0.8570770025,
-0.0099588996,
-0.3798983991,
-0.4222599268,
0.1644451618,
-0.3022792637,
-0.5703341365,
0.1330189705,
0.5679395795,
0.8979747891,
0.3595516086,
-0.2918117046,
0.7251996398,
-0.3378959894,
0.7791355848,
0.033987388,
-0.7754024267,
0.6183928847,
-0.5876253843,
0.1439928412,
0.8529458642,
0.3296212256,
-0.2584433258,
-0.5794634223,
-0.7305114865,
-0.4465938807,
0.6085451245,
0.3815231919,
0.1877352148,
0.2108042985,
0.541703701,
0.1016325951,
0.1185939834,
-0.3397607207,
0.018806912,
-0.374458313,
-0.1766849309,
-0.1969652176,
0.0682629347,
0.0446668416,
-0.4966072738,
0.4353200495,
-0.199723199,
0.3831081986,
-0.1862739474,
-0.1689381152,
0.2015563995,
0.0587122217,
0.6611968875,
0.459107101,
-0.092775099,
-0.1579586565,
0.3922666609,
-0.9621195793,
0.2113005966,
0.254653573,
-0.1522323787,
-0.0199879371,
0.4559341669,
1.0716184378,
0.5111761689,
-0.3663642406,
0.2162871808,
-0.2273965925,
-0.5474460721,
0.2382818311,
0.526730597,
-0.0462299176,
0.3363879621,
0.2543121874,
-0.220916748,
0.1300463527,
-0.4916871786,
0.4819241166,
0.3160004914,
-0.6010578871,
-0.7597672343,
0.9787020683,
-0.1186824366,
0.0232571941,
0.7192049623,
-0.1336267292,
-0.5362542868,
0.5690466166,
0.4173319936,
0.9113680124,
-0.448818475,
0.2364943624,
0.2470196784,
0.1557793468,
-0.3283283412,
-0.0578740649,
-0.1422933191,
-0.4729570746,
-0.611225307,
-0.6631122828,
-0.2874733508,
0.4341825545,
-0.8046092391,
-0.0917190835,
-0.5068292022,
-0.1332173347,
-0.0984464809,
-0.055551637,
-0.8675486445,
0.1473523378,
0.0863463879,
0.6450917125,
-0.9536375999,
1.1634503603,
0.845808804,
-0.31229949,
-0.9081839323,
0.430776,
-0.094905436,
-0.8509525061,
0.5527485013,
0.1939167678,
-0.0961478204,
0.2065631747,
-0.4066109359,
-0.6525065899,
1.0540180206,
0.7380341291,
-0.1843883246,
-0.1835277677,
0.5363965631,
0.7962870598,
-0.0277884975,
0.1365264356,
0.9477118254,
0.2209227681,
0.0552285463,
-0.8609343171,
-0.1238483861,
-0.1005024835,
0.2017463595,
0.2883075178,
-0.3878933787,
0.5562084317,
-0.1542057693,
-0.5416033864,
-0.1462672502,
0.5432232022,
0.0876456872,
-0.0276195034,
0.2558455765,
0.5328251719,
0.675280869,
-0.1576682776,
1.3117979765,
-0.2648685277,
0.8116756678,
1.1832779646,
0.0815179572,
0.4809350371,
0.2780178189,
-0.6326993704,
0.1239743978,
0.3603639901,
-0.2589203715,
0.7175271511,
0.3536030054,
-0.3660653234,
-0.0713131949,
0.1627827436,
-0.5975666046,
0.4645839036,
0.1715347469,
-0.3437200487,
-0.4476791322,
0.2513813078,
-0.092960991,
-0.2853435278,
-0.1955229193,
0.5788077116,
-0.3491096795,
-0.2538250089,
0.7366352677,
-0.3220687807,
0.4553846717,
-0.6701864004,
-0.1345141679,
-0.1385739595,
0.1527752876,
0.0537246764,
-0.6004475951,
0.3116750419,
-0.0951781943,
0.0068304348,
-0.2101319283,
0.4137271047,
-0.4175071418,
-0.5721210837,
0.2275526524,
0.3202041686,
-0.1026665866,
-0.233739838,
-0.6945587993,
-0.0560654029,
-0.0764947087,
-0.4830610156,
0.7173472047,
0.4645558894,
0.1477065086,
0.5830882788,
0.4499327242,
-0.0071707098,
0.2571495771,
0.2025890499,
0.8445798159,
-0.4685301483,
-0.5332970023,
-0.7588447332,
0.2503575385,
0.0926866382,
-0.4681675732,
0.6702249646,
0.6510945559,
0.8622152805,
-0.1135467067,
0.9310793281,
0.058204934,
0.1145606935,
-0.6129388213,
0.985989511,
-0.2884260118,
0.1265288293,
-0.3449959457,
-0.621062994,
-0.0743712708,
0.4764384329,
-0.676633954,
0.1963111758,
0.3074063957,
0.6830348969,
-0.1804285347,
0.5666504502,
0.4223787487,
0.0555891171,
0.5113243461,
0.3957905769,
0.8950765729,
-0.4499069154,
0.5034297109,
-0.3036414385,
0.0043192115,
-0.0441249348,
-0.7904913425,
-0.8670472503,
-0.6654859781,
-0.344666332,
-0.0214125216,
0.2404911369,
0.4428207278,
0.6949052215,
-0.9631527066,
0.0448038988,
-0.6237385869,
-0.2561813593,
-0.3647371233,
-0.3031101823,
0.3270775378,
-0.5255880952,
-0.5893675685,
0.4300053418,
-0.1577301323,
0.486217469,
-0.1105064973,
-0.0836791024,
0.1037836447,
-0.3328497708,
0.4846099913,
0.2516752779,
-0.3927225471,
-0.5775689483,
-0.3945918977,
0.2173685431,
0.0509213991,
1.2346664667,
-0.8821020722,
0.4302138984,
0.2421855628,
0.8186517954,
0.6333389878,
0.1670718193,
0.8393422365,
-0.9043552279,
0.1466569155,
0.0457871705,
0.1088157743,
0.0550071225,
-0.4517308176,
0.7236653566,
0.476320684,
-0.5068153143,
-0.8336221576,
-0.0728606954,
-0.5545241237,
0.0919188187,
0.9146639109,
-0.2811902165,
0.2543794811,
-0.2656680346,
0.2088428885,
0.2058981359,
-0.2590540946,
0.988334775,
0.7917596102,
-0.3458580971,
-0.3279723525,
-1.278293848,
0.8257035613,
0.2571893036,
-0.8172757626,
0.4074093699,
0.443929404,
0.5834850073,
-0.3457866013,
0.2872750163,
0.1624902189,
0.0802775323,
0.2170814425,
-0.2565745413,
-0.3038178086,
-0.1285870075,
-0.5355882049,
0.2343263924,
-0.0805773735,
-0.0848303139
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07839v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07839v1
|
RecurrentGemma: Moving Past Transformers for Efficient Open Language Models
| 2024-04-11T15:27:22 | 2024-04-11T15:27:22 |
Aleksandar Botev, Soham De, Samuel L Smith, Anushan Fernando, George-Cristian Muraru, Ruba Haroun, Leonard Berrada, Razvan Pascanu, Pier Giuseppe Sessa, Robert Dadashi, Léonard Hussenot, Johan Ferret, Sertan Girgin, Olivier Bachem, Alek Andreev, Kathleen Kenealy, Thomas Mesnard, Cassidy Hardin, Surya Bhupatiraju, Shreya Pathak, Laurent Sifre, Morgane Rivière, Mihir Sanjay Kale, Juliette Love, Pouya Tafti, Armand Joulin, Noah Fiedel, Evan Senter, Yutian Chen, Srivatsan Srinivasan, Guillaume Desjardins, David Budden, Arnaud Doucet, Sharad Vikram, Adam Paszke, Trevor Gale, Sebastian Borgeaud, Charlie Chen, Andy Brock, Antonia Paterson, Jenny Brennan, Meg Risdal, Raj Gundluru, Nesh Devanathan, Paul Mooney, Nilay Chauhan, Phil Culliton, Luiz GUStavo Martins, Elisa Bandy, David Huntsperger, Glenn Cameron, Arthur Zucker, Tris Warkentin, Ludovic Peran, Minh Giang, Zoubin Ghahramani, Clément Farabet, Koray Kavukcuoglu, Demis Hassabis, Raia Hadsell, Yee Whye Teh, Nando de Frietas
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We introduce RecurrentGemma, an open language model which uses Google's novel
Griffin architecture. Griffin combines linear recurrences with local attention
to achieve excellent performance on language. It has a fixed-sized state, which
reduces memory use and enables efficient inference on long sequences. We
provide a pre-trained model with 2B non-embedding parameters, and an
instruction tuned variant. Both models achieve comparable performance to
Gemma-2B despite being trained on fewer tokens.
|
[
-0.3912487924,
-0.9694865942,
0.2585865259,
0.0168238748,
-0.0635022968,
-0.0247383304,
-0.2085240036,
-0.4157564938,
0.0375873037,
0.547504425,
-0.4357765317,
-0.3449825048,
-0.6582948565,
-0.1724629253,
-0.5454394221,
0.7032832503,
-0.0552719869,
-0.0040056766,
0.0712605044,
-0.347602576,
-0.1421987414,
-0.6330808401,
-0.7183285952,
-0.5292349458,
0.44020468,
0.3181650639,
0.8527146578,
0.6997997761,
0.2161879838,
0.2836965621,
-0.2457901537,
-0.0084222369,
-0.6734068394,
0.0264556371,
-0.2569395006,
-0.5696802735,
-0.193978563,
0.0996918529,
0.7977460623,
0.6355879307,
-0.2343755364,
0.2960330844,
0.0612583272,
0.6988523006,
-0.5647764802,
0.414403677,
-0.5886681676,
0.3433853686,
-0.0728671402,
-0.1212235838,
-0.5824885964,
-0.4699026942,
0.0616482757,
-0.5108463168,
0.3291329443,
0.0643132329,
0.7627347708,
0.3464582562,
-0.0294591747,
-0.2121431977,
-0.7184838653,
1.0481061935,
-0.3370065987,
0.6051440835,
0.1436777115,
0.2047742754,
-0.5205296874,
-1.4144561291,
-0.4166081548,
-0.222234562,
0.1660553068,
0.0209238157,
-0.7073805332,
-0.1030184627,
0.3062928617,
0.819016695,
-0.450687319,
-0.1930631399,
-0.329438448,
-0.0194770135,
0.0211294908,
0.112804465,
0.2757147849,
0.357717067,
-0.3646551371,
0.3136586845,
-0.7172183394,
0.3336527646,
0.1402492374,
0.4582329988,
0.1325331181,
0.6269261837,
-0.0129390033,
0.7290653586,
0.7356137037,
-0.0236711297,
0.1563090235,
0.1070265323,
-0.4323610961,
0.0198387876,
0.4013994932,
-0.2156640291,
0.3269658983,
-0.6129127145,
0.1597898006,
0.0273741689,
0.6341468692,
-0.9021302462,
-0.2993210256,
0.0859954134,
-0.7388176918,
0.0007086762,
0.0210931338,
-0.7460049987,
0.0234966818,
-0.2844717503,
0.3615402877,
-0.4201235175,
-0.2082524896,
0.4703657627,
0.1754119992,
0.3527104855,
0.0710633397,
-1.2700639963,
0.5125570297,
1.0037010908,
0.9478684068,
0.140828684,
-0.2927173674,
-1.1816823483,
-0.048652716,
-0.3451882005,
0.6111830473,
-0.9237844944,
-0.3097313046,
0.0900631472,
0.333666116,
-0.1870583296,
-0.585295856,
0.3571303487,
-0.4781733751,
0.3847221136,
0.0913151875,
-0.6763257384,
-0.6983417869,
-0.0901121497,
-0.7348707914,
1.4202179909,
0.4227294922,
-0.6712729335,
0.3547376692,
-0.7888987064,
-0.3803918958,
0.0016944576,
0.1497934908,
-0.3977912664,
0.2560388446,
0.2191920727,
0.2365905046,
-0.1877232194,
0.0974555761,
-0.2738081813,
-0.4407651722,
-0.2309527248,
-0.0287369248,
0.5495170355,
0.4214687049,
-0.4894278049,
0.3435951471,
-0.5916852355,
-0.0723970458,
0.0233002398,
-0.3374724388,
-0.0990198255,
0.1340670735,
-0.389906764,
0.018766921,
0.2892932594,
-0.6363912225,
0.4260635972,
-0.4678145945,
0.6726115942,
0.3151951134,
-0.3425979614,
0.7177621126,
-0.3750665784,
0.7443276048,
0.0531231463,
0.1434103698,
-0.338834703,
-0.8401913047,
-0.745452404,
-0.5616313815,
0.2586972713,
0.4950164557,
-0.5767270327,
0.2645423114,
0.0463170633,
-0.4388563037,
-0.81074965,
0.1414752603,
0.3376655579,
0.3485878408,
0.4771696329,
-0.4591845274,
-0.5196091533,
-0.757538259,
-0.2233109623,
-0.1832103282,
-0.1697181016,
0.2342346907,
0.1323613673,
-0.3732866645,
0.9498035312,
-0.4388449788,
-0.0374281444,
-0.6498224139,
0.4801448882,
0.3340798616,
0.2013641894,
0.6683795452,
-0.2696720064,
-0.2525536716,
0.1040355116,
-0.4862118363,
-0.1057808325,
-0.0556137599,
-0.0832006782,
0.5685032606,
0.5130352974,
-0.882573843,
0.435361743,
0.663669765,
-0.1981221288,
0.2546161115,
-0.095298782,
0.0238428898,
-1.0973116159,
0.0806298777,
-0.0058999793,
-0.4994492531,
-0.6290330291,
0.5342697501,
-0.0080892742,
-0.2063774168,
-0.6004911661,
0.7268868089,
-0.6524143815,
-0.3892126381,
-0.3923380971,
0.1614321321,
-0.2755366564,
0.6505095363,
0.1325695068,
1.0788093805,
0.7268691659,
-0.6827613711,
0.2361349016,
0.326197505,
-0.6701882482,
-0.221043393,
-0.4705444872,
0.2372529209,
-0.1634621471,
-0.0033720669,
-0.8375049829,
0.1890078783,
0.396253258,
-0.4928362668,
0.5102720261,
-0.3120574653,
-0.438367933,
-0.5436351299,
-0.1170535684,
0.2948902249,
0.6811845899,
-1.0194727182,
0.6555438042,
0.5029286742,
-0.3823154867,
-0.5556303859,
-0.4442351162,
-0.0043865233,
-0.1528176963,
-0.6439219713,
0.2519706488,
0.3352930248,
-0.2380073965,
0.0194891039,
0.0741626695,
-0.1094849408,
-0.0141579872,
0.0912550017,
-0.1115895584,
-0.5428122878,
0.1548907012,
-0.2498939782,
-0.1132695302,
-0.1679396182,
-0.4143222868,
0.8734551072,
-0.4275232255,
-0.0853273273,
-0.6420578361,
0.3955996931,
0.6500545144,
-0.3180527687,
0.7165263891,
0.6014146805,
-0.2124550939,
-0.2172966599,
-0.2315811068,
-0.0931747928,
-0.481857121,
0.3064078093,
-0.3541859388,
-1.2938272953,
0.5166395903,
-0.0165653788,
0.2939210534,
0.1930817664,
0.9388257265,
0.2623364925,
0.8555445671,
0.553121388,
-0.3877564669,
0.6506584287,
-0.0454340614,
0.5517960191,
-0.6524551511,
-0.1410718858,
-0.6378189921,
-0.1042106897,
-0.6582516432,
-0.6080434918,
-0.3661925197,
0.4113496244,
-0.629875958,
0.6143172979,
-0.4392223656,
0.1749936491,
0.9302598238,
-0.1875761449,
0.0583613031,
0.1042139456,
-0.2860019803,
0.0653981566,
-0.9641119838,
-0.6229794025,
0.9418242574,
0.6940799952,
1.1435731649,
0.2378461063,
0.472935766,
0.2291499376,
0.3945163488,
-1.0899249315,
0.5444720984,
-0.2850614488,
-0.3570058048,
-0.2683353126,
-0.2765271068,
-1.3287385702,
0.1635972857,
0.0005055143,
-0.9184195399,
-0.2809139788,
0.2421309501,
-0.282502234,
0.7087251544,
-0.5575315356,
0.5579767227,
0.2474153042,
-0.4120052755,
-0.1594275981,
-0.0906862915,
0.4432947338,
0.1832076311,
-0.3338025212,
0.1960308403,
0.2450008094,
0.2608391643,
-0.4148819149,
0.7360950112,
-0.0527669415,
-0.0607006513,
0.6242291927,
0.1136706322,
0.6579121351,
-0.1708974391,
0.1201711819,
0.4077201188,
-0.4162647724,
-0.4127182662,
-0.5446637273,
0.709636569,
-0.5649384856,
-0.8431527615,
-0.3521617353,
-0.3880495429,
-0.0962430835,
0.0302709062,
0.1478826553,
0.6420353651,
-0.0549757034,
0.4002280235,
0.5664471388,
-0.4390932918,
0.5756642818,
0.4153369963,
-0.5616956949,
-0.3094314337,
0.4310110807,
-0.0612329841,
0.1325980276,
0.490311116,
0.0960771143,
-0.5933647752,
-0.5300735831,
-0.4680343866,
0.16131033,
-0.3388768137,
0.1899498105,
-0.7762601376,
-0.3645114005,
-0.4019213915,
0.0310843717,
-0.5140011311,
-0.601379931,
-0.3883947432,
-0.1321470737,
0.3359149992,
0.719374299,
-0.0086300597,
0.1974824071,
-1.0852353573,
0.4978629053,
0.4446030855,
0.622859478,
0.1418414414,
-0.7607744336,
-0.2153233588,
-0.0907669961,
-0.6042492986,
-0.3804964721,
0.4786130786,
0.091296345,
0.9433214664,
0.5828664899,
-0.1549715102,
0.7052242756,
-0.8154933453,
0.9834975004,
0.2496819794,
-1.0050053596,
0.1589446366,
-0.2910093963,
0.5824722648,
0.1493336558,
0.2645365596,
-0.3705441952,
-0.5675157309,
-0.4251531065,
-0.4572768509,
0.64435637,
0.1511273235,
0.1043508649,
-0.6321845055,
0.3786673844,
0.2625778615,
0.0501939766,
-0.4816970825,
-0.2864159346,
-0.3969680369,
-0.0460998639,
-0.0081227981,
-0.4569026232,
0.1649911851,
-0.1974723488,
0.7252286077,
0.0403402112,
0.7606014609,
0.0158536043,
-0.1734003127,
-0.287954241,
0.1754884422,
1.0382637978,
0.5009338856,
-0.0945991874,
-0.2422448397,
-0.0934331641,
-0.5749557018,
-0.0500426702,
-0.0767414197,
-0.1906284839,
0.2029100358,
0.2562997341,
0.8536791205,
0.5297002196,
-0.3376333416,
0.2284703106,
-0.0055258176,
-0.3399464488,
-0.478308022,
0.0558297522,
0.1849360913,
0.5042710304,
0.2023322582,
-0.1770906895,
0.0173567124,
-0.7639907598,
0.5768226981,
0.3765232563,
-0.6174461246,
-0.2555825114,
0.8542524576,
0.1938871741,
-0.6060945988,
0.5653403997,
-0.0110320291,
-0.377486527,
0.4166735709,
0.6917976141,
1.2218488455,
-0.374649018,
0.1894544661,
0.6348930597,
0.171138674,
-0.3565369546,
0.4734033346,
-0.0331391916,
-0.6467912793,
-0.6203300953,
-0.6583488584,
-0.3402681947,
0.4842746854,
-1.0519263744,
0.1407676637,
-0.6516755819,
-0.3161257505,
-0.1830020845,
-0.0970348045,
-0.3063707054,
-0.2043003291,
0.0236878935,
1.3431981802,
-0.1408718228,
1.1263478994,
0.5209572315,
-0.0784971863,
-0.4602276087,
-0.0577076189,
-0.1465228945,
-0.8823768497,
0.7515019178,
0.4498758912,
-0.6339748502,
0.1507209688,
-0.4672596455,
-0.9147500992,
0.9235099554,
0.2698713839,
-0.7875826359,
0.2117200792,
-0.220915094,
0.4664810002,
-0.5720900893,
-0.2389661372,
0.6306382418,
0.2399730533,
0.1686225086,
-0.6916712523,
-0.354290545,
-0.151812464,
-0.1439273506,
0.7254812717,
-0.726926446,
1.0440683365,
-0.4390678108,
-0.6677306294,
0.7593569756,
0.7805605531,
0.0028183465,
0.1921158433,
0.1076876596,
0.9688252211,
0.7657673955,
-0.2575007081,
1.2114902735,
-0.6546266675,
0.6112943888,
1.4303972721,
-0.2976383269,
0.9292638302,
0.2826247215,
-0.1784943342,
0.5924464464,
0.5456030369,
0.0277010221,
0.6508278847,
0.3665952086,
-0.449554503,
-0.2965311408,
0.2758179009,
-0.3781497478,
0.5380588174,
0.1940570921,
-0.5676503778,
-0.3843436539,
-0.2383689731,
0.0188526157,
0.242062971,
-0.6887346506,
0.7845547199,
-0.0184942875,
-0.8587727547,
0.6628020406,
0.1286265105,
0.4087632596,
-0.4703975916,
-0.0915290862,
-0.3675529361,
0.3229183853,
0.072380051,
-0.6509997845,
0.4209100604,
0.0134807471,
-0.2993222177,
0.0505044684,
0.4599015117,
-0.5975773931,
-0.4617529213,
0.5338394642,
0.178746745,
0.1227196679,
0.0378108434,
-0.6313089728,
-0.3360534608,
-0.2047730386,
-0.2517451942,
0.2469756454,
0.3164023161,
0.0496833362,
1.0700879097,
0.6107069254,
-0.0969808847,
0.3695129156,
0.1648491025,
0.6657927632,
-0.933268249,
-0.5060300231,
-0.6351134181,
0.0879046768,
0.2357757241,
-0.059687227,
0.6173906922,
0.5701354742,
0.7723981738,
-0.2494716495,
0.742890954,
0.3107135594,
0.7312787175,
-0.6613618135,
0.4883268178,
-0.3571298122,
-0.1065047979,
0.0067251148,
-1.0588786602,
-0.3907712698,
0.7042323947,
-0.1942325085,
-0.0941105559,
0.6583763361,
0.8711727262,
0.0480171219,
0.1630856395,
0.5279388428,
0.1963941306,
0.0816676691,
0.6672899127,
0.8578339219,
-0.176513806,
0.4665835202,
0.2813699841,
-0.2040768564,
-0.2342210114,
-0.804263711,
-1.1715455055,
-0.322787106,
-0.1008547768,
-0.1549828798,
-0.0458177514,
0.9230059981,
0.5742869973,
-0.8807671666,
0.0070933416,
-0.1726094633,
-0.1406231225,
-0.2871118188,
-0.2587475479,
0.1862254441,
-0.7892599106,
-1.0213986635,
0.4181388915,
0.6418805122,
-0.051385276,
-0.2526379228,
-0.1435160041,
-0.1155557781,
0.3955092728,
0.9037039876,
0.8118057251,
-1.0094382763,
-0.5902062058,
-0.1430150121,
-0.0362215415,
0.3309159577,
1.0636813641,
-0.7904865742,
0.4743400812,
0.3975571096,
0.8782300949,
0.601863265,
0.3232124448,
0.7052617669,
-0.2110116184,
0.3931915462,
-0.0948581696,
0.6337154508,
0.1274641752,
-0.1208271086,
0.4336928725,
0.0091860546,
-0.4455294907,
-0.3432892561,
0.4795888364,
-0.8495463133,
-0.3700621128,
1.1865448952,
-0.4604997337,
-0.1751360297,
-0.469273895,
-0.0275695734,
0.1256413162,
-0.3579288423,
1.0593975782,
0.8730481267,
-0.0878455266,
-0.4575818777,
-0.4177060127,
0.4221515954,
0.1863534003,
-0.4674125612,
0.0322005861,
0.3050855994,
0.2700453997,
0.1229357794,
0.4253326952,
-0.4340526462,
0.4496680796,
0.1250284761,
0.0861533135,
-0.2962801158,
-0.7464753389,
-0.3859887719,
0.4436903894,
0.0604694821,
-0.6527448297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07836v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07836v1
|
Question Generation in Knowledge-Driven Dialog: Explainability and Evaluation
| 2024-04-11T15:24:50 | 2024-04-11T15:24:50 |
Juliette Faille, Quentin Brabant, Gwenole Lecorve, Lina M. Rojas-Barahona, Claire Gardent
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We explore question generation in the context of knowledge-grounded dialogs
focusing on explainability and evaluation. Inspired by previous work on
planning-based summarisation, we present a model which instead of directly
generating a question, sequentially predicts first a fact then a question. We
evaluate our approach on 37k test dialogs adapted from the KGConv dataset and
we show that, although more demanding in terms of inference, our approach
performs on par with a standard model which solely generates a question while
allowing for a detailed referenceless evaluation of the model behaviour in
terms of relevance, factuality and pronominalisation.
|
[
-0.5900392532,
-0.8625782132,
0.8084718585,
-0.0899883956,
-0.1197456643,
-0.3510434628,
0.2204324603,
-0.0664234161,
-0.1079979613,
0.5916843414,
-0.8509960175,
-0.153760612,
-0.1640427113,
0.0464481115,
-0.4884981513,
0.9634456635,
0.0910628736,
-0.0240142085,
-0.8794753551,
-0.1795056909,
-0.5172747374,
-0.385486722,
-0.5556711555,
-0.4223311245,
0.2912096977,
0.5375593901,
0.7323453426,
0.2324266434,
-0.1464587003,
0.2577011287,
-0.2151266187,
0.0965355784,
-0.4607940316,
0.3309885263,
0.0622477792,
-0.7372764945,
0.1593104005,
0.142214939,
0.3612288237,
1.1871939898,
-0.0634362847,
0.2262342721,
-0.2104030401,
0.4740394056,
-0.4977197647,
0.1024523005,
-0.492626667,
0.0607135966,
0.5742021203,
-0.3186247647,
-0.3259934187,
-0.7018615007,
0.5039479136,
-0.511084497,
0.3516295254,
0.1016009748,
0.5146254301,
-0.0463642292,
-0.7039920092,
-0.7667772174,
-0.7394083738,
0.3535449207,
-0.6474505663,
0.4499942958,
0.1714343131,
0.5810502172,
-0.0326516703,
-0.9562543035,
-0.6597074866,
-0.2743700445,
-0.1416949481,
0.3897562623,
0.0567157455,
-0.0619687848,
0.4933932722,
0.4152406454,
-0.6137725711,
-0.4192533791,
-0.3565412164,
-0.1292424798,
0.4960365295,
0.3854860663,
0.1115611494,
-0.4462196529,
-0.1104853973,
0.170657292,
-0.6246210933,
0.2421697527,
0.4429499209,
-0.1404578984,
0.2646227479,
0.5133374333,
-0.609112978,
0.6543533802,
0.3958447278,
-0.1616592705,
-0.3003654182,
-0.6463932395,
-0.1452063471,
0.0793130919,
0.4689995944,
0.6800647974,
0.3038358092,
-0.2341067791,
0.2583149672,
-0.156915307,
0.1899322122,
-0.9817290902,
-0.2103285342,
0.5018701553,
-0.2196388543,
-0.7186482549,
-0.016846437,
-0.5200495124,
-0.2985416353,
-0.253839761,
0.3300749063,
-0.2139661908,
-0.5421774387,
0.0784647986,
-0.2059358805,
0.4186564982,
0.3591697514,
-0.6931492686,
0.0525060557,
0.387578398,
0.0471841544,
0.2147484273,
-0.1169668585,
-0.1126749143,
0.1327796578,
-0.4670552015,
0.8016812205,
-0.298836112,
-0.7832839489,
-0.0315448716,
-0.0095478017,
-0.0974204168,
-0.6962673068,
0.0792498738,
-0.5191030502,
0.7808177471,
-0.6564247608,
-0.5902075171,
-0.51025635,
0.5377970934,
-0.2482860386,
0.9072764516,
0.1940161884,
-0.7344770432,
0.6207403541,
-0.5363734365,
-0.2981626093,
0.0962513238,
-0.2392721176,
0.0737905353,
-0.0184651874,
0.1588581651,
0.4310340285,
-0.5064659119,
0.7595635653,
-0.0078983549,
0.0929700807,
0.3951297998,
-0.2811959982,
0.5372864604,
0.3068658412,
-0.0368199721,
0.0138438633,
-0.7470340133,
0.4314434826,
0.096926704,
-0.0431780554,
-0.0046860557,
0.0654466972,
-0.620249033,
0.328974992,
0.018046191,
-0.3707586527,
0.0144070191,
-0.3568501174,
0.256763339,
0.3388439417,
0.6753237247,
0.3034671545,
-0.3521496356,
0.84427917,
0.0875099227,
0.2194910645,
-0.5738947392,
-0.5338736773,
-0.7487686872,
0.3186207116,
0.2405626774,
0.5112011433,
-0.8565668464,
-0.0423824526,
0.0697869584,
-0.7035638094,
-0.154103145,
-0.1713630408,
0.4004621208,
1.0650360584,
-0.1797161549,
-0.0503655076,
-0.3963906169,
-0.8208617568,
-0.0760654137,
-0.6793090105,
-0.0007282437,
0.6297976971,
0.5102724433,
0.2737674117,
1.1488702297,
-0.9273588657,
0.7846524715,
-0.7042450309,
0.593090117,
0.0806780085,
0.2846117616,
0.3418985605,
-1.1738810539,
-0.1839561015,
-0.2262035012,
-1.0051572323,
-0.3327340484,
-0.2514252067,
-0.0519891232,
-0.2109370828,
0.564950943,
-0.9326816201,
0.3181569576,
-0.0258913562,
-0.4136970639,
0.9250048399,
0.0866434723,
0.2985819578,
-1.3702975512,
0.1269036084,
-0.6158831716,
-0.2796248198,
-0.8882433772,
-0.0742028281,
-0.2782286406,
-0.4929025471,
-0.6446627975,
0.4710583687,
-0.0739154592,
-0.0322805792,
-0.2027882487,
0.1641977429,
0.2874383032,
0.4160510004,
-0.2848876715,
0.6905742288,
0.2784543037,
-1.0482604504,
0.3353526294,
0.5542795658,
-0.6361098886,
0.4385657609,
-0.9135864973,
0.1145941913,
-0.4596095681,
0.1062870324,
-1.208065629,
-0.3888014257,
0.1039200127,
-0.6937254667,
-0.0263533499,
-0.0729143471,
-0.4266303778,
-0.3490683734,
0.0765529871,
0.3875911534,
0.6610524654,
-0.380574286,
0.4573530555,
0.1015584767,
-0.5328692794,
-0.2168966979,
-0.1987559199,
-0.3511220515,
-0.2425969988,
-0.893885076,
-0.1572742164,
-0.362662077,
-0.5317171812,
-0.0761039034,
-0.2024278939,
-0.0182924531,
0.3024685085,
0.3200631142,
-0.0112629123,
-0.2190430462,
0.1472344398,
0.0887237936,
-0.0077203419,
0.4838502705,
-0.110123083,
0.461512357,
0.1580162048,
-0.3035638332,
-0.1695320308,
0.5254638195,
0.5913917422,
-0.0321381092,
0.4202314913,
0.0468961447,
-0.1122211069,
-0.0907310024,
-0.4845389128,
-0.1168686822,
-0.4440215528,
0.2494870871,
-0.4676840007,
-0.7659778595,
0.7205293179,
-0.3060462773,
-0.0161635354,
0.5891993642,
0.6034395099,
-0.2347065359,
1.3187571764,
0.4743269384,
0.4588343799,
-0.0149985682,
-0.1987935454,
0.227420494,
-0.3587253392,
-0.399192661,
-0.272369951,
0.2624299824,
-0.3359560966,
-0.2346121222,
0.4361857772,
0.3961914778,
0.1209608838,
0.0926887468,
0.1178853661,
0.4591446519,
0.3502453268,
-0.243425265,
0.2642341852,
-0.5874079466,
-0.4565917253,
0.1781445444,
-0.9897842407,
-0.4956336617,
1.0517919064,
-0.0377942175,
0.2223144919,
-0.1384923607,
0.4314152002,
0.1282524616,
0.3281615973,
-0.711817205,
0.6492879391,
0.6924874783,
-0.7669442892,
-0.3448143601,
-0.4722958803,
-0.6873990893,
0.3441656828,
0.0044673756,
-0.5175176263,
-0.0916168392,
0.1792090535,
-0.6899888515,
0.0224198196,
-0.9416235685,
0.8396004438,
0.0383689404,
-0.0646534339,
0.0986697376,
-0.6926860809,
0.6775200963,
0.0470835567,
0.0062495801,
-0.0371514037,
0.5829905868,
0.8821330667,
-0.5660660267,
0.3977684975,
-0.4395060837,
-0.0174667574,
0.8924106956,
0.1040799394,
0.1885029227,
0.2934059203,
0.1464722902,
-0.6077311635,
0.236031428,
-0.1053491011,
-1.1382781267,
0.1996385604,
-0.3486908674,
-0.9742041826,
0.0692923218,
-0.8789379597,
-0.4870743752,
0.2492263615,
0.2430854142,
0.7864263058,
-0.4379352629,
-0.0139817791,
0.8376556039,
-0.5449570417,
0.1546602845,
0.7294285893,
-0.668192625,
-0.3161926568,
0.6812257171,
0.234927237,
0.6131283641,
0.1360919625,
0.3575862646,
-0.327144146,
-0.3665950298,
-0.4016817808,
-0.0238990095,
-0.8476982117,
0.0775385648,
-0.8060836196,
-0.312877655,
-0.551928103,
-0.094437629,
-0.2335633188,
-0.7367248535,
0.0275243223,
-0.582047224,
0.1428272426,
0.9232969284,
0.239980042,
0.3202435672,
-0.4181353152,
0.4332793653,
0.92710042,
-0.1415515244,
-0.0834503695,
-0.3431939483,
0.0860862732,
0.143736124,
-0.5627064705,
-0.853959322,
0.1457019597,
-0.2023676932,
0.3948410153,
0.6370908022,
0.1866222024,
0.5516527891,
-0.2982264459,
1.1350406408,
0.117907472,
-0.6098763347,
0.7778859735,
-0.4120627344,
0.5751183629,
0.7844381332,
0.3783655167,
-0.4772939086,
-0.3679879606,
-1.0653529167,
-0.7002158761,
0.4613159895,
0.2937519848,
0.0357985683,
-0.0994625911,
0.4309617281,
0.5928838849,
0.493088603,
-0.1900547147,
-0.3561966717,
-0.137160033,
0.0982993394,
-0.0403844863,
-0.7104692459,
-0.1402540207,
-0.2634264529,
0.4284428954,
-0.1155363992,
0.3990799189,
0.3259533644,
-0.1309397966,
0.0848160535,
0.3934392333,
0.7290585637,
1.1237213612,
-0.3104249239,
-0.0840427727,
0.2673329115,
-0.042319756,
0.096421808,
0.0058602276,
-0.5156827569,
0.0559753589,
0.1840393394,
0.7443175316,
0.1349405646,
-0.6138854623,
0.4220398664,
-0.1290065646,
-0.7815321088,
-0.3318619728,
0.0420130901,
0.1330557466,
0.1797566414,
0.1419558376,
-0.1899860948,
0.1103970632,
-0.6864545941,
0.3026848435,
0.1927778274,
-0.2829109728,
-0.4530978799,
0.8448494673,
0.1555525959,
-0.0644761473,
0.516651094,
-0.3231562972,
-0.6686069965,
0.8214407563,
0.4185785353,
0.8270991445,
-0.0960787237,
0.5654737949,
0.386816591,
0.0489118509,
0.3521584272,
0.9035649896,
-0.5697424412,
-0.9257986546,
-0.3327592015,
-0.2549966872,
-0.7346417904,
0.2761245966,
-0.8429082036,
0.0294975508,
-0.2362474054,
0.1434705257,
0.0293743536,
-0.1804284602,
-0.5321285725,
0.5420995355,
-0.1434574425,
1.0264556408,
-0.8285596371,
0.3368084431,
0.4174707234,
-0.3904305398,
-0.808126688,
0.0993846953,
-0.3142304718,
-0.7081881166,
0.5244514942,
0.3192049563,
0.2307871431,
-0.0183070265,
-0.6645025015,
-0.7073990703,
1.4682956934,
0.1654384285,
0.1672675312,
-0.0507576801,
0.4004759192,
0.3319544792,
-0.3171764612,
0.372969538,
0.6283825636,
0.3994886577,
0.4095093608,
-0.5959279537,
-0.0586865619,
-0.2832853496,
-0.2229484469,
0.0994497389,
-0.4800109863,
0.5062067509,
-0.41834113,
-0.2940201461,
0.0642039552,
0.7289896011,
0.1215672791,
0.5519116521,
0.6239254475,
0.5079174042,
0.7533515692,
-0.0786438435,
1.2667415142,
-0.3891296983,
0.0080442093,
1.1066992283,
-0.1567943841,
0.2288545817,
0.3845089376,
-0.1103280485,
0.2808165252,
0.5147940516,
0.2915553153,
0.5341591835,
0.2871116996,
-0.1545198262,
-0.2460304052,
-0.3955569267,
-0.3560279012,
0.6279784441,
0.1821116209,
-0.2850085795,
-0.332911849,
-0.0653462708,
0.070190385,
-0.2219700515,
-0.2903893292,
0.9691186547,
-0.1510636955,
-1.2170674801,
0.3728235662,
-0.2803928554,
-0.3820897937,
-0.7853155136,
-0.0920538232,
-0.3641589582,
-0.34080562,
0.1411154866,
-0.7362568378,
0.2321268916,
-0.0576735921,
-0.436295867,
-0.4072675109,
0.7107946277,
-0.4180112779,
-0.4592198133,
-0.3343093097,
0.8140937686,
0.3562986255,
-0.0289615765,
-0.2330923676,
-0.6955476403,
0.2816854715,
-0.5007929802,
0.1304541677,
0.5496504307,
0.1524857432,
0.911337316,
0.4487190247,
-0.3898128271,
0.1755827814,
0.1007363945,
0.8774192333,
-0.6537955999,
-0.6248033047,
-0.4090162814,
0.8057519197,
0.1144059524,
-0.4706578851,
0.800624609,
0.5039775372,
0.4713764191,
-0.0550967492,
1.0705214739,
-0.2412299067,
0.5400154591,
-0.5708453655,
0.6018122435,
-0.2159575373,
-0.1187160537,
-0.1934999824,
-0.5594526529,
0.2444504648,
0.0617218688,
-0.3679668009,
-0.0271415748,
0.7585517764,
0.7764613628,
0.3399507105,
0.5650972724,
0.5651205778,
0.2170603424,
0.102069959,
0.3539433181,
1.2117795944,
-0.3643367589,
0.519517839,
-0.4100465775,
0.0190740544,
0.2294379324,
-0.719615221,
-0.8723617792,
-0.6169300079,
-0.3214626908,
-0.1432337314,
-0.3239605129,
0.4501048326,
0.4743924737,
-0.6814132333,
0.1022165343,
-0.2894105315,
0.2687385082,
0.0626619235,
-0.3027134538,
0.0456055515,
-0.2951928377,
-0.2685631216,
0.4249252379,
-0.0601894408,
0.1042159274,
-0.2979344428,
0.0526940823,
-0.087637119,
0.2343284786,
0.7126839757,
0.1704153717,
-0.3999246359,
-0.2864576578,
-0.0996760502,
0.5533163548,
-0.2358686626,
0.9858607054,
-0.8570845723,
0.6448699832,
0.3824498057,
0.5289607644,
0.4499517679,
0.2855012715,
0.9907962084,
-0.7319452763,
-0.0823488608,
0.2215455025,
0.0753713176,
0.1531274468,
-0.3528781533,
0.4062543809,
0.2652742267,
-0.4444579482,
-0.7034592032,
0.5393810272,
-0.7118373513,
-0.057505209,
1.0940568447,
-0.0489114821,
0.1475775093,
-0.1000790596,
-0.2778434753,
0.1876104921,
0.1635751128,
0.511649847,
0.9746494293,
-0.319044739,
-0.0687816292,
-0.8847458363,
0.5177823901,
0.6062896252,
-0.7644996643,
0.2010706216,
0.4282704592,
0.3598695993,
0.0058373115,
0.6255264878,
-0.0808461607,
0.3743321896,
0.0877133757,
-0.1894049346,
-0.2139817476,
-0.2799249589,
0.208475247,
0.5703965425,
0.0302983299,
-0.0011793093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07824v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07824v1
|
Heron-Bench: A Benchmark for Evaluating Vision Language Models in Japanese
| 2024-04-11T15:09:22 | 2024-04-11T15:09:22 |
Yuichi Inoue, Kento Sasaki, Yuma Ochi, Kazuki Fujii, Kotaro Tanahashi, Yu Yamaguchi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Vision Language Models (VLMs) have undergone a rapid evolution, giving rise
to significant advancements in the realm of multimodal understanding tasks.
However, the majority of these models are trained and evaluated on
English-centric datasets, leaving a gap in the development and evaluation of
VLMs for other languages, such as Japanese. This gap can be attributed to the
lack of methodologies for constructing VLMs and the absence of benchmarks to
accurately measure their performance. To address this issue, we introduce a
novel benchmark, Japanese Heron-Bench, for evaluating Japanese capabilities of
VLMs. The Japanese Heron-Bench consists of a variety of imagequestion answer
pairs tailored to the Japanese context. Additionally, we present a baseline
Japanese VLM that has been trained with Japanese visual instruction tuning
datasets. Our Heron-Bench reveals the strengths and limitations of the proposed
VLM across various ability dimensions. Furthermore, we clarify the capability
gap between strong closed models like GPT-4V and the baseline model, providing
valuable insights for future research in this domain. We release the benchmark
dataset and training code to facilitate further developments in Japanese VLM
research.
|
[
-0.3454665244,
-0.2666265666,
0.6203930378,
-0.0126570705,
-0.4323966205,
-0.222403422,
-0.0572314449,
-0.6539554596,
-0.2859682441,
0.5540506244,
-0.5518350005,
-0.5457950234,
-0.400818646,
-0.050651677,
0.0333631746,
0.3880400658,
-0.1818697453,
0.4004944265,
-0.2494357228,
-0.6314947605,
-0.6237702966,
-0.0874265507,
-0.3889220655,
-0.0663817152,
0.3810892999,
0.1943740845,
0.4847836494,
0.7518389225,
0.6130328178,
0.2725772262,
0.3784757555,
0.0314879976,
-0.2767741978,
0.2020028979,
-0.0809648558,
-0.5683782101,
-0.2081553787,
-0.1075936407,
1.0472444296,
0.8330718279,
0.1560859233,
0.3000901341,
-0.1731925607,
0.7425413728,
-1.1135377884,
0.5200924873,
-0.50782305,
0.3483160138,
-0.5324311852,
0.0662845522,
-0.2446728647,
-0.0550839752,
0.1389998794,
-0.8035268784,
0.1220088899,
-0.0486300439,
0.8486148715,
0.2930571735,
-0.2336443067,
0.4469143152,
-0.3551754057,
0.9405607581,
-0.6051102281,
0.6737291217,
0.387264967,
0.8350066543,
0.3871881664,
-0.7274960876,
-0.2605923712,
-0.2887113988,
0.1974105686,
0.4948071539,
-0.0467395559,
-0.0311258994,
0.4132672846,
0.2768680155,
-0.6709347963,
0.0036086119,
-0.3938363492,
-0.1131043211,
0.4442175031,
0.3187022507,
0.2264450043,
-0.3124471903,
-0.2666312456,
-0.3833532035,
-0.3530759811,
0.1487773657,
0.0399965197,
0.3034976125,
-0.0481807031,
0.6439741254,
-0.459287852,
1.1092147827,
-0.6295884252,
-0.1999861896,
0.2769742608,
-0.373829335,
-0.2194868922,
-0.200454995,
0.7175691724,
0.7162194848,
0.212041378,
0.0295153167,
-0.2622706294,
0.2938468754,
0.2580833137,
-0.5309683681,
0.1404159218,
-0.258852154,
-0.469935298,
-0.1158892661,
0.1481696665,
-0.6136630177,
-0.2276870459,
-0.1290447712,
0.4719768465,
-0.41384992,
-0.3317838311,
0.0913678631,
-0.4134504795,
0.7093761563,
0.1785737574,
-0.5168610215,
0.2495752871,
0.5972711444,
0.8324155211,
-0.0300448705,
-0.4762051702,
-0.5083267093,
0.1082771719,
-0.5873152018,
0.3781181574,
-0.6535941362,
-0.3964623213,
-0.06465251,
-0.0355127528,
-0.093452394,
-0.4173030555,
0.2993845046,
-0.1746127158,
0.1849651188,
-0.3261695802,
-0.360245049,
-0.141912967,
0.2362191379,
-0.5779155493,
0.7599516511,
0.4034776986,
-0.6504803896,
0.3647015095,
-0.4251427054,
-0.0584351569,
0.6656411886,
-0.6379243135,
-0.4177936018,
0.4304985404,
0.2162777483,
0.157934159,
-0.4434621036,
0.0170843918,
-0.6833227873,
-0.4010778964,
0.2698677182,
-0.5388979316,
0.7234801054,
0.158907637,
-0.347446382,
-0.1207620054,
-0.7509381771,
0.6147325635,
0.0077799982,
0.1187213436,
-0.7146475911,
-0.2026675045,
0.1516753435,
-0.0668625683,
0.2945965827,
-0.4904051423,
-0.0519721434,
-0.1612206548,
0.2044998109,
0.6443420649,
-0.2006338835,
-0.0567308925,
-0.2063178867,
0.7190886736,
-0.1216419712,
0.5943330526,
-0.4499978125,
-0.5701203942,
-0.7989092469,
-0.2346355766,
0.0027065184,
0.2367297262,
-0.9825707078,
-0.1526294798,
-0.2970772982,
-0.544937849,
-0.8843407631,
0.0018245024,
0.9594659805,
0.6496161819,
0.1963331848,
-0.7439182401,
-0.5320893526,
-1.106986165,
-0.3688463867,
-0.2086257935,
0.1663199961,
0.5369131565,
0.2166477591,
-0.0100615229,
0.7559857368,
-0.2220868915,
-0.0810594484,
-0.0023546547,
0.0183342677,
0.0655458719,
0.2633701861,
0.6238722801,
-0.9255450368,
-0.6029245257,
0.1803236157,
-1.0618081093,
-0.092393592,
0.2945931256,
-0.0359117426,
0.0797612816,
0.3307654858,
-0.240539968,
0.5410460234,
0.5573142171,
-0.2490537763,
0.5832131505,
-0.0640843436,
0.2883939743,
-0.866925776,
0.3007464409,
0.2158832699,
-0.2555888295,
-0.4356682599,
0.5309886336,
0.4278624952,
-0.2943133712,
-0.4760382175,
0.4594290853,
-0.5420509577,
-0.8348437548,
-0.090486519,
-0.0532392077,
0.0145695712,
0.2778966427,
0.2611402869,
0.8705332875,
0.6977511644,
-0.4023108184,
0.4096367955,
0.0880423784,
-0.6413552761,
0.863905251,
-0.783280313,
0.0018196892,
0.027067896,
-0.3261300623,
-0.9284282327,
-0.1606523991,
0.1343622953,
-0.2611769438,
0.1460880488,
-0.4109413326,
-0.0100202132,
-0.473388344,
-0.349127084,
0.440169394,
0.5279531479,
-0.2770022452,
0.3765355349,
0.2308694273,
0.0387292877,
-0.8430460095,
-0.7751072049,
0.0987637267,
-0.0691407472,
-0.4294562042,
0.3567995429,
-0.077096276,
-0.3758566678,
0.2119027227,
-0.1725019962,
-0.118893072,
-0.0071822372,
0.1662915051,
0.4708948433,
-0.8577859402,
-0.2203605026,
-0.4419281185,
-0.4213861227,
-0.1322705448,
-0.5040081739,
0.2404617518,
-0.5523124933,
-0.5927175283,
-0.3910441697,
-0.0014489623,
0.9460859299,
-0.5258458853,
0.4211830497,
0.5491620302,
-0.1762949973,
0.0344162509,
-0.5764713287,
0.1065007001,
-0.4220891595,
0.6177711487,
-0.6914665103,
-0.5020148754,
0.1961174607,
0.1271469444,
-0.01304531,
0.2535590529,
0.1008384079,
0.0235645063,
1.0455583334,
0.8809649348,
0.0393243358,
0.5607028008,
-0.2107653767,
-0.2310111821,
-1.1465611458,
-0.0706163347,
-0.2270847708,
-0.1337033361,
-0.5108843446,
-0.5060405731,
0.5159084201,
-0.1051833704,
0.0087070772,
0.208951503,
-0.222537145,
0.5982966423,
0.4767993391,
-0.0603550375,
0.2398100942,
-0.0677618831,
-0.2837447226,
-0.4390018284,
-0.6897870302,
-0.1383654028,
1.2370743752,
0.0545964949,
0.4589370489,
0.0555984452,
0.3765549958,
0.0710425004,
0.0102935238,
-0.6339824796,
0.5971837044,
-0.2866058648,
-0.3158610165,
-0.4451974332,
-0.4624041319,
-0.792993784,
0.6473702788,
0.0720536038,
-0.5726515651,
0.0059350277,
-0.1729906797,
-0.1084233001,
0.0761905015,
-0.6072854996,
1.233930707,
-0.5645015836,
-0.7710694075,
-0.136707291,
-0.458622545,
0.5110701919,
-0.0126889395,
0.1713505387,
-0.1976074278,
-0.31642887,
0.4421131313,
-0.5024850965,
0.6616113186,
-0.3673676252,
0.2199570686,
-0.1744243205,
-0.29927513,
-0.0227891691,
0.0283047874,
-0.0474062152,
-0.0076669981,
0.1201000363,
-0.609262228,
-0.528142333,
0.5630409718,
-0.987585783,
-0.3587560952,
-0.4146844745,
-0.3671422899,
-0.5490112305,
0.3607817888,
0.3083794117,
0.6769446135,
-0.0961005464,
0.3776659667,
0.500169456,
-0.2090910077,
0.3522049189,
1.0455011129,
-0.4031646252,
-0.3384181857,
0.8276821971,
0.2334574908,
0.2560482323,
0.2909047306,
0.1791476607,
-0.3740276396,
-0.7041413784,
-0.605332315,
0.1295905113,
-0.7272788882,
-0.0175986309,
-0.1126172543,
-0.324432075,
-0.2903775573,
0.0567041896,
-0.6384323835,
-0.1578659415,
0.4016705751,
0.1941358745,
0.1165140793,
0.6577458382,
0.2046165317,
-0.0780040845,
-0.6568476558,
0.4379551113,
0.4978500903,
0.7489526868,
-0.2179477513,
-0.4171124101,
-0.2510790527,
-0.0168602318,
0.04246144,
-0.6845383048,
0.2772915065,
0.1089246944,
0.9217426181,
0.2508215904,
-0.0369554199,
1.0948326588,
-0.221870929,
0.6978910565,
0.3874685466,
-0.7750830054,
0.7516046762,
-0.3867075443,
0.7466519475,
0.6423256993,
0.1633021384,
-0.6557692289,
-0.4464768469,
-0.5061405897,
-0.7305062413,
0.6642439961,
0.0220397022,
-0.1457197368,
0.4969224334,
0.2612042725,
0.1639498472,
0.2290949374,
-0.7145146132,
-0.0145374713,
-0.4486446083,
-0.182638973,
-0.3311210573,
-0.061464835,
0.1759546995,
-0.3086289465,
0.4317117631,
-0.2587449551,
-0.1940514594,
-0.0196529478,
-0.2855154276,
-0.1200186312,
-0.0024115192,
0.3133563697,
0.8612213731,
-0.0920097232,
0.0007415108,
0.0524786413,
-0.5689799786,
-0.1663940102,
0.0765169635,
-0.4467287362,
0.0429832526,
0.5261119008,
1.1806118488,
0.3949192464,
-0.7732762098,
0.5163966417,
-0.385920614,
-0.0406073742,
-0.3304632008,
0.2447974533,
-0.2400478125,
0.2012245953,
0.2980840206,
0.0615748838,
0.0816065297,
-0.5773707032,
0.1569415778,
0.4055260718,
-0.625849247,
-0.0824246258,
0.4504234195,
0.0511543341,
-0.1458616704,
0.615051806,
0.0982476026,
-0.3324064612,
0.6296317577,
0.3749142587,
0.8505817056,
-0.1848233193,
0.2506037652,
0.4657880068,
0.3900740743,
0.0384040624,
0.3677326441,
-0.2847559154,
-0.7476831079,
-0.2231191844,
-0.6182104945,
-0.5418335795,
0.4974027872,
-1.0430417061,
0.1542335004,
-0.5453488231,
-0.1815890074,
-0.0353854522,
0.1271554679,
-0.7467985153,
0.0798272938,
0.4141833782,
0.6929635406,
-0.735516727,
0.9313309193,
0.8739911318,
-0.4948478639,
-0.4960386157,
-0.1013029963,
0.0964014083,
-1.014477849,
0.4888342023,
0.4259211421,
-0.3286517262,
0.0007817315,
-0.29269889,
-0.7817815542,
1.1404557228,
0.3855939806,
-0.7355831265,
0.3489548564,
0.2122813761,
0.5442290902,
-0.3484178185,
0.3287968636,
0.3775355816,
0.5709531903,
-0.1144655645,
-0.8557452559,
-0.3621274531,
-0.6872550249,
0.6396088004,
-0.0894368067,
-0.7865229845,
0.7442405224,
0.0046133753,
-0.0806604624,
0.338293463,
0.4243683219,
0.3520858586,
0.2773058414,
0.4365972281,
0.4958156347,
0.6074483395,
-0.1342643052,
1.1046648026,
-0.2803673446,
-0.0446681418,
0.965808928,
-0.4397469461,
0.9985904098,
0.4776314497,
-0.1837330312,
0.2869370282,
0.2663777173,
-0.1430990994,
0.5888656378,
-0.0578915961,
-0.1153459027,
-0.3596507311,
-0.1512531042,
-0.556150198,
0.7051297426,
0.3158670366,
-0.045992922,
-0.0116381831,
0.3350214064,
-0.5026999116,
0.2379352897,
-0.4541340172,
0.596718967,
0.022403378,
-0.8685099483,
0.6036670804,
-0.0299361944,
0.4628429711,
-1.0595499277,
0.1295608878,
-0.3213780224,
0.4972516596,
0.1931542158,
-0.8401159048,
0.1073983535,
0.1912766546,
-0.0720777661,
-0.1806083322,
0.5835724473,
-0.1894377619,
-0.5388094187,
0.2873046398,
0.4100051522,
0.1093790084,
0.2266140282,
-0.8533617854,
0.4467003942,
-0.054221075,
-0.0780474171,
0.2928573787,
0.3661703467,
-0.0687608868,
0.6825814247,
0.4309481978,
0.1874854565,
0.0921681598,
0.3792188168,
0.4685932696,
-0.6649097204,
-0.4412676096,
-0.6559238434,
0.4461458623,
-0.3623614013,
-0.5823529363,
1.0010530949,
0.6560158134,
0.9630219936,
-0.1491581947,
1.0828059912,
0.2079553753,
0.2177999616,
-0.6592717171,
0.5699320436,
-0.8637320995,
0.131739974,
-0.2367068082,
-0.8476734161,
-0.1023597419,
0.8477916121,
-0.3661675453,
0.1707101911,
0.5565912127,
0.6293169856,
-0.2707929909,
-0.0485305898,
0.7987413406,
0.2313685715,
0.0367877036,
0.8587380648,
1.0052863359,
-0.4801546633,
0.3167375624,
-0.3511530459,
-0.3023039699,
-0.1611370593,
-0.7431052923,
-0.6724612117,
-0.667062223,
-0.3569544554,
0.1424482614,
0.3807472587,
0.2134828418,
0.8099500537,
-0.5149405599,
-0.5103099346,
-0.2006565183,
-0.2095549256,
-0.5030277967,
-0.1671585441,
0.0182575304,
-0.4429423511,
-0.5719108582,
0.3467847109,
0.5624191165,
0.1295700222,
-0.5992816091,
-0.3175348938,
0.3538679481,
-0.2856027782,
0.3737646043,
0.5219391584,
-0.878241539,
-0.1276336908,
0.0218956564,
-0.2023822814,
-0.1710537225,
0.5485562682,
-0.9009233117,
0.992315948,
0.2982882559,
0.5686500669,
0.8197334409,
-0.451252073,
0.9087772369,
-0.6595593095,
0.3493135273,
0.1437026709,
0.6102458239,
0.6044275761,
0.2413409054,
0.6441609859,
0.4078569114,
0.085563533,
-0.8419008255,
0.2966795564,
-0.865467608,
-0.3226213455,
0.7925642133,
-0.2378993332,
-0.5057174563,
-0.0090850499,
-0.0897822678,
0.0322865844,
0.3449578881,
0.4889819622,
0.6596568227,
0.3066357672,
-0.5274882317,
-0.817651391,
0.3156790435,
0.4831923544,
-0.623678863,
0.2269774079,
0.5034923553,
0.0900009722,
-0.065851137,
0.7532157898,
-0.3254274428,
0.81216681,
0.2756639719,
-0.1983861327,
-0.3182296455,
-0.3001607358,
-0.2632500231,
0.0686723888,
0.2531577945,
-0.3385951519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07814v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07814v1
|
MultiLS-SP/CA: Lexical Complexity Prediction and Lexical Simplification Resources for Catalan and Spanish
| 2024-04-11T14:57:19 | 2024-04-11T14:57:19 |
Stefan Bott, Horacio Saggion, Nelson Peréz Rojas, Martin Solis Salazar, Saul Calderon Ramirez
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic lexical simplification is a task to substitute lexical items that
may be unfamiliar and difficult to understand with easier and more common
words. This paper presents MultiLS-SP/CA, a novel dataset for lexical
simplification in Spanish and Catalan. This dataset represents the first of its
kind in Catalan and a substantial addition to the sparse data on automatic
lexical simplification which is available for Spanish. Specifically, MultiLS-SP
is the first dataset for Spanish which includes scalar ratings of the
understanding difficulty of lexical items. In addition, we describe experiments
with this dataset, which can serve as a baseline for future work on the same
data.
|
[
-0.4299943745,
-0.3914702833,
0.3908772171,
0.8129518628,
-0.2547253668,
0.1906186193,
-0.0237913653,
-0.3261216879,
0.4702152312,
0.1059452221,
-0.8914412856,
-0.4023417234,
-0.7080524564,
0.2156861126,
-0.2434736788,
1.0430018902,
0.1094212532,
0.3966158032,
0.1204880551,
-0.1286024898,
-0.2512465715,
-0.6485372782,
-0.5416662097,
-0.0985661373,
0.8359428644,
0.4573968947,
1.1947710514,
0.6241422296,
0.5704814792,
0.2924130559,
-0.2931803465,
0.5197046995,
-0.3912789226,
-0.2213800102,
-0.0967587903,
-0.2610960305,
-0.5218963027,
-0.6110848188,
0.6240698695,
0.9776989818,
-0.0822123066,
0.0924158469,
0.024210263,
0.9355223775,
-0.5483529568,
0.5756905079,
-0.5856571794,
0.2381798029,
-0.2243618816,
-0.5537609458,
-0.1821248382,
-0.3921278417,
0.0765471905,
-0.6642534733,
0.6244703531,
0.0592896678,
0.339497,
0.8578590155,
-0.5604405403,
-0.7410068512,
-0.7601260543,
0.6918004155,
-0.0205486193,
0.4714074135,
0.1440718621,
0.2367663234,
-0.4233582318,
-0.7598657012,
-0.3733474016,
-0.1875853091,
-0.0740126371,
-0.1584937274,
-0.0451421812,
0.1519894451,
0.2110996544,
0.4355561435,
-0.5368483067,
-0.2467162758,
-0.9860085249,
-0.4765785038,
0.4645521343,
0.2984135747,
0.2261814773,
0.1169190109,
-0.3161480129,
-0.0149127394,
-0.8363382816,
0.1862791032,
0.336189419,
0.5239627361,
0.1490993202,
0.7573221326,
-0.0909250975,
0.4924588799,
-0.4059537649,
-0.2351115942,
0.7550932765,
-0.5075358152,
-0.1435410082,
0.2679032981,
0.4456378818,
-0.123795934,
0.3165709674,
0.0941564068,
-0.0428722091,
0.2143948525,
-0.1244690791,
-0.363989085,
-0.2646854818,
0.0000440848,
-0.2063692957,
-0.0003050617,
0.2481185794,
-0.5449507833,
-0.4771293104,
-0.3538651764,
0.1390604824,
-0.1691885591,
-0.0716648549,
0.5619738698,
-0.0044097346,
-0.1788091511,
0.5482980013,
-0.4050725102,
0.7643979192,
0.4513049126,
0.7377612591,
-0.2687787414,
-0.7524440289,
-0.2758898437,
-0.2062431127,
-0.258125037,
0.6632840037,
-0.1850731671,
-0.0961668938,
-0.5025592446,
0.1944067329,
0.0213854909,
-0.1977048069,
0.9305892587,
-0.1284382492,
-0.3264034688,
-0.4454239011,
-0.2125983983,
-0.0296054035,
-0.2337350249,
-1.229321599,
1.4343436956,
-0.3713790774,
-1.037974,
0.282150954,
-0.373316139,
-0.4328307509,
-0.0636067837,
-0.0000312811,
-0.1185604185,
0.2662561238,
0.2474257052,
0.3282310069,
-0.2985369265,
0.2104344517,
-0.1463987976,
-0.2436756939,
0.1930843145,
-0.755621016,
0.512545228,
0.4569098353,
-0.0918321237,
-0.2883666158,
-0.9069446921,
-0.0924745873,
0.1345014125,
-0.1799332798,
-0.2847737372,
0.2631973028,
-0.0374328531,
0.5549252033,
0.7869685888,
-0.5109795928,
-0.1291540414,
-0.4495218694,
-0.0952903703,
0.3903872073,
-0.1662406027,
0.2195643336,
-0.3648207784,
0.5923614502,
0.0560956188,
0.3178034425,
-0.3029717207,
-0.816224277,
-0.6784691215,
-0.2371946722,
0.0991770774,
0.6238380671,
-0.6532432437,
0.2667526901,
-0.2354041785,
-0.7406342626,
-0.4935094118,
0.1828944534,
0.4325119555,
0.0919683501,
0.5718246102,
-0.0758950859,
-0.6483858228,
-0.6849595308,
0.0145804603,
-0.0297150053,
0.2710705698,
0.0833491907,
0.3719709814,
0.1853904277,
0.7603106499,
-0.4941700697,
-0.4120238125,
-0.2312103212,
0.1515838951,
0.171862781,
0.3851143718,
0.4366549551,
-0.8883512616,
-0.3850140572,
-0.0819923803,
-0.3909648955,
-0.0457995757,
0.107984148,
0.503049314,
-0.1466367394,
0.6696639657,
0.0732077807,
0.6432088614,
0.7959334254,
-0.400441736,
0.5010012984,
-0.9064173102,
-0.0582358837,
-0.6177258492,
-0.1943961084,
-0.061212711,
-0.0062035755,
-0.8356705308,
-0.2223752439,
0.0605637245,
0.0353621505,
-0.8890389204,
0.4967749119,
-0.6058426499,
-0.3443719149,
0.2229442,
-0.3957797885,
-0.1167304143,
0.6297718883,
0.2574094832,
0.8547638655,
0.6595730782,
-0.632805109,
0.3652477562,
-0.2642242312,
-0.2990410626,
-0.0943438932,
-0.8472136259,
-0.1885249019,
-0.5964989066,
0.2907007039,
-1.2925995588,
-0.058309637,
-0.1983529329,
-0.2200524956,
-0.3712016046,
0.1855517477,
-0.7352256775,
-0.5342092514,
-0.361089468,
0.9684686661,
-0.2433626205,
-0.5511757135,
0.3275268674,
0.3649106324,
-0.3787674606,
-0.8875151873,
-1.0174449682,
0.0240840539,
0.0276966672,
-0.4149986804,
0.3653378189,
-0.6417746544,
0.0178901367,
-0.174697578,
0.0937516913,
-0.4199657738,
-0.1910620779,
0.3651923537,
0.079450056,
-0.1373270005,
0.3959226608,
0.3302696645,
-0.0806142911,
-0.2879959941,
0.2530106604,
0.7100741863,
-0.6406676173,
-0.7373403311,
-0.5009247065,
0.1086490005,
0.8502592444,
-0.086893402,
0.5764945149,
0.3685605228,
-0.5911262631,
-0.0773004293,
-0.5697164536,
0.2633395195,
-0.4329887927,
0.3664726913,
-0.9097363353,
-0.4216454029,
0.783013463,
-0.0109326653,
-0.0476410165,
0.6220446825,
0.7400755286,
0.2748931348,
1.1527580023,
0.6156921387,
0.0403009281,
0.0552874953,
-0.0627028197,
0.0347288586,
-0.005606527,
-0.6807678938,
-0.7228403687,
-0.1808306426,
-0.4578514695,
-0.6129572392,
0.3278191388,
-0.2491094172,
-0.1328365207,
0.267881602,
-0.4647791684,
0.9853220582,
0.2103217244,
0.1461722255,
0.6431605816,
0.0616539344,
-0.3048990965,
-0.3310459554,
-0.8087214231,
-0.2485523373,
1.1234519482,
0.6192458272,
1.0479512215,
0.2183004916,
0.5433262587,
0.4623669088,
-0.3865348995,
-0.8672752976,
0.2652400136,
-0.6036892533,
-0.3209824264,
-0.3668189049,
-0.3850449324,
-0.9173306823,
0.2835909128,
-0.2917731702,
-0.3707751334,
0.4714911878,
-0.0553363487,
-0.3870528638,
0.1848734766,
-0.9933148026,
0.5233920217,
-0.2264777869,
0.1424899995,
-0.2030708492,
-0.604419589,
0.1658998281,
-0.1950026602,
0.6060679555,
-0.0542464405,
-0.3665372133,
0.5625116229,
-0.5400629044,
0.7218698859,
-0.0644955635,
-0.0047871694,
0.1922900528,
0.1216099858,
0.3041714728,
0.0052111009,
-0.3095508218,
-0.0752863586,
0.2539590895,
-0.3209096491,
-0.3928615749,
0.6915427446,
-0.7832770944,
0.2271264642,
-0.6242685318,
-0.6922883391,
0.0581282862,
-0.0178911835,
0.1602505594,
0.5992501974,
-0.511285305,
0.1268076301,
0.6816919446,
-0.2545210421,
0.2346491665,
0.3743671477,
0.1167823672,
-0.3535864651,
1.0516443253,
0.242075488,
0.0118251033,
0.1107751578,
0.2324175388,
-0.6177917123,
-0.3349516094,
-0.3470070064,
0.3102481961,
-0.8372858763,
-0.196661219,
-0.5815565586,
-0.3735541999,
-0.2800545096,
-0.1121130288,
-0.5745863914,
-0.896936357,
-0.4077737331,
-0.0770352855,
0.1423242092,
1.2207970619,
-0.0715840012,
0.3511051238,
-0.4327792227,
0.5022124052,
0.1053777859,
0.164205417,
-0.0703179166,
-0.3187241852,
0.002170186,
-0.1274549365,
0.1496534646,
-1.0166662931,
0.5823194385,
0.6243356466,
0.5289749503,
0.4057047069,
-0.1164854988,
0.8752277493,
-0.5015004873,
0.5464179516,
0.287150979,
-0.9837725163,
0.3117438555,
0.1310908943,
0.2256809026,
0.6320909858,
0.5106609464,
-0.3288207352,
-0.3940128386,
-0.8126263618,
-0.7594310641,
0.8754811883,
0.173447594,
-0.1687261164,
0.0725943074,
0.3079282045,
0.2841805518,
0.2677761912,
-0.9694184065,
-0.7237487435,
-0.084209308,
-0.4852975905,
-0.4623819888,
-0.3972405791,
0.2965078056,
-0.5044068694,
0.6001640558,
-0.076612629,
-0.054073751,
0.2079674155,
-0.1838022918,
0.0020621312,
0.1901829094,
0.650485754,
0.6531820297,
-0.0304364637,
0.4300994873,
0.6260787845,
-0.5670269728,
0.0921807662,
-0.0673630834,
0.3979925513,
0.1844966561,
0.2007893771,
0.6378074884,
0.2455391735,
-0.8228160739,
0.6661508679,
-0.1229448467,
-0.1475475729,
-0.4910621345,
-0.2380913347,
-0.0845149904,
-0.0419683233,
0.422088474,
0.0954488739,
0.404530853,
-0.5277646184,
0.1863407791,
-0.0588146634,
-0.1380449533,
-0.2754507959,
0.2249287814,
-0.3340591788,
0.0614082664,
-0.0964036509,
-0.5431877375,
-0.5265623927,
0.9153363705,
0.5296087265,
0.1631641686,
-0.3907303214,
0.2608676255,
0.5355188847,
0.5231227875,
-0.5437472463,
0.7069006562,
-0.0306920651,
-0.6164599657,
-0.2776144147,
-0.6748416424,
-0.5391916633,
-0.1249476448,
-0.5517037511,
0.7155991197,
-0.5794123411,
0.1616527885,
0.1434101462,
0.0766041651,
-0.894073844,
0.2267034054,
0.1019100845,
1.0300267935,
-1.3630379438,
1.0749387741,
0.6184833646,
-0.2550848424,
-0.6490955949,
-0.4908684194,
0.2479211986,
-0.946256578,
0.771721065,
-0.1425238103,
-0.7161561251,
-0.2090480328,
-0.1517918557,
-1.0775405169,
1.0218235254,
0.4023483694,
-0.2048386633,
-0.1482281834,
0.6776291728,
0.847890079,
-0.4604285359,
0.3959456384,
0.6636713743,
0.4921302497,
0.5586943626,
-1.1396448612,
-0.2033347338,
-0.3144777417,
-0.1053004786,
0.079555735,
-0.3343724906,
1.2879490852,
-0.3116747439,
-0.170562461,
0.1197154075,
0.694190979,
0.0013565037,
0.5274144411,
0.5933167338,
0.4916186333,
0.9871337414,
-0.0605699271,
0.3634984791,
-0.2924422622,
0.4844369292,
1.4009011984,
0.0875497609,
0.6604213715,
0.500223279,
-0.2521423697,
0.4250213504,
0.6509090662,
0.1209019721,
0.3944991529,
0.389395088,
-0.3474493623,
0.0984357595,
-0.167205736,
-0.4518589079,
0.4778152108,
1.0349886417,
-0.1805077046,
-0.4848763943,
0.0598141551,
-0.2080150843,
-0.0104918219,
-0.6132989526,
0.7765154839,
-0.3294970393,
-0.3815799654,
0.5663346648,
0.0957986638,
0.6335036159,
-0.6001598835,
0.0748734623,
-0.0137990778,
0.1182407811,
-0.444557786,
-1.0067592859,
0.6233336329,
-0.0551914163,
-0.0180258024,
-0.0659549832,
0.6285676956,
-0.5387499928,
-0.794282198,
0.4421987832,
0.8957111239,
0.6331273913,
-0.1498786956,
-0.8313057423,
-0.0970514417,
0.0727938414,
0.2130961567,
-0.0998623371,
0.8250522614,
-0.0469684191,
0.920314312,
0.4746088982,
0.4390371144,
0.7878148556,
0.2225012332,
0.8736357093,
-0.5830219388,
-0.7810596824,
-0.5326528549,
0.1501619369,
0.3457992077,
-0.3343523741,
0.3429109454,
0.6940146685,
0.5907275677,
0.0322489887,
0.4981755018,
-0.0254342649,
0.4961234629,
-0.2248409241,
0.2430230528,
-0.7811213136,
0.2500429153,
-0.3259116709,
-0.8350937963,
-0.6604625583,
0.3148838878,
0.1980885863,
-0.2033486664,
1.0401417017,
1.2784844637,
-0.3816016614,
0.1469224989,
0.2965166867,
-0.0735914111,
-0.0697918981,
0.6821510196,
0.5477858186,
-0.3888818026,
0.9154739976,
-0.5986323953,
-0.4216465056,
0.1469982713,
-0.7608519793,
-0.6878346205,
-0.9793128371,
0.1929405183,
-0.1609966606,
-0.0805474892,
1.2275114059,
0.2824737132,
-0.9650142193,
-0.3622329235,
-0.3915225565,
0.1511915475,
-0.2108854502,
-0.1311965287,
0.6568459272,
-0.6124082804,
-0.808363378,
0.5195189118,
0.0163435359,
0.2306367308,
-0.4388189018,
-0.2183686048,
0.0159556624,
0.0765608102,
0.4428639412,
0.4972903132,
-0.820050776,
0.1153291836,
-0.0576029941,
-0.1748155206,
0.1240578964,
0.9043563008,
-0.7925472856,
0.6079043746,
0.6078333259,
0.4660357237,
0.3619320989,
-0.3410366476,
0.0117110079,
-0.9866207838,
0.5465512276,
-0.017120827,
0.7245168686,
0.0708784685,
-0.3229301274,
0.3935670555,
0.1582957506,
-0.2132950723,
-0.4521287382,
0.1568072736,
-1.2123761177,
-0.2057365626,
1.0004355907,
0.0572049208,
0.0609647371,
-0.6758121252,
-0.4772465229,
0.0147717921,
-0.3970756829,
0.482270509,
0.6793537736,
0.0134391347,
0.0119673144,
-0.3026416004,
0.7282388806,
0.5626577735,
-0.6622196436,
0.100898318,
0.4759514332,
-0.0354397371,
0.3103723824,
0.6930390596,
-0.2745595276,
0.4240670204,
-0.1255381554,
0.067182295,
0.0302485246,
-1.1571029425,
-0.6038674116,
0.4704779088,
0.1683160365,
0.1758297682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07792v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07792v1
|
Nostra Domina at EvaLatin 2024: Improving Latin Polarity Detection through Data Augmentation
| 2024-04-11T14:35:23 | 2024-04-11T14:35:23 |
Stephen Bothwell, Abigail Swenor, David Chiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper describes submissions from the team Nostra Domina to the EvaLatin
2024 shared task of emotion polarity detection. Given the low-resource
environment of Latin and the complexity of sentiment in rhetorical genres like
poetry, we augmented the available data through automatic polarity annotation.
We present two methods for doing so on the basis of the $k$-means algorithm,
and we employ a variety of Latin large language models (LLMs) in a neural
architecture to better capture the underlying contextual sentiment
representations. Our best approach achieved the second highest macro-averaged
Macro-$F_1$ score on the shared task's test set.
|
[
-0.7179579139,
-0.2804841101,
0.6102548242,
0.3329425156,
-0.6293691397,
0.2518694103,
-0.2832440138,
-0.6691724658,
0.8335859179,
0.461199373,
-0.6822514534,
-0.9111058116,
-0.5918614268,
0.3946002424,
-0.2572585046,
1.2816632986,
-0.0540143289,
0.3255823553,
-0.2958473563,
-0.693831563,
-0.1424599737,
-0.5627153516,
-0.3454280198,
-0.4070895314,
0.8073074222,
0.5596672297,
0.3346870542,
-0.0791021511,
0.4505102038,
0.2561329603,
0.0314488076,
0.1311330795,
-0.2526295781,
0.4590523541,
-0.0426403098,
-0.6376040578,
-0.9371207952,
0.1867070347,
0.4305929244,
0.3189982176,
0.4786601961,
0.064676404,
-0.3933621645,
0.796559155,
-0.3698599637,
0.2630694509,
-0.4109100997,
0.0218653399,
-0.0951479226,
-0.3253701031,
-0.2927779853,
-0.2748832405,
-0.0939567462,
-0.2948877215,
0.1045914888,
0.0745857805,
0.5750089288,
0.4362982512,
-0.6311573386,
-0.0254850145,
-0.6075849533,
0.9552509189,
-0.5803646445,
0.2617732286,
0.1038932428,
-0.0425584652,
0.1621424556,
-0.1931079477,
-0.6066319942,
-0.0323254503,
0.1263555288,
0.2994441688,
-0.3997119367,
-0.0450581238,
0.0915683582,
0.1623755246,
-0.3184277415,
-0.160144195,
-0.2561247945,
0.1269990653,
0.823058486,
0.1105736569,
0.433118701,
-0.2513152361,
-0.3750167191,
-0.0252166707,
-0.7147663236,
-0.099327825,
0.8261417747,
0.1094114482,
-0.360627532,
0.4731044471,
-0.1962679774,
0.4117266536,
-0.0729554147,
0.5820055008,
0.5164309144,
-0.3474742472,
0.0510049202,
-0.0539102145,
0.6575513482,
0.61314255,
-0.0320356861,
0.1071189716,
-0.3485671282,
0.4328156114,
0.2695083916,
-0.5950633287,
-0.1890795976,
0.5094689727,
-0.1039181501,
-0.4384393394,
0.0157884005,
-1.2423112392,
-0.5948198438,
-0.8026976585,
-0.0466989502,
-0.381265521,
-0.2987271249,
0.0634237304,
-0.1762375534,
0.2326575071,
0.5319841504,
-0.5410343409,
0.3739640713,
0.9677786827,
0.646848619,
-0.2790280581,
0.0697698966,
-0.6298149824,
-0.6315433979,
-0.13159661,
1.1704210043,
-0.5964372754,
-0.0929273739,
-0.1475720704,
0.0603699461,
-0.1502231359,
-0.4145638645,
0.8711686134,
-0.4983246326,
0.2581655383,
-0.4222140014,
-0.4266488254,
-0.2601742148,
0.1622437388,
-0.707279563,
1.1321918964,
0.3761484325,
-0.9104460478,
0.0549113229,
-0.6738282442,
-0.2031249702,
0.2477955222,
-0.0831710324,
-0.5086377263,
0.4152747095,
0.055421792,
0.2822042108,
-0.1595599204,
0.2449569702,
-0.536169529,
-0.1370572895,
0.4220379889,
0.0392118394,
0.7087524533,
-0.0614081994,
-0.8145298362,
0.3541424572,
-0.62602669,
-0.2271777838,
-0.0856388733,
0.1129039377,
-0.2732429802,
-0.2215597034,
0.3070489764,
0.3432801962,
0.3432755172,
-0.8615003228,
0.1415319741,
-0.5626423955,
0.261190176,
0.7799125314,
-0.1250037849,
0.663932085,
-0.0793992579,
0.9016447663,
-0.0632976517,
0.1365903616,
0.176309675,
-0.6431818604,
-0.9626820683,
-0.2848975956,
0.2219093293,
0.6548258662,
-0.622971952,
0.5162061453,
-0.2240214795,
-0.5174808502,
-0.6441690326,
0.2530133724,
0.1669671088,
0.4519639611,
0.4931162,
-0.3160223961,
-0.930295527,
-0.9806967378,
-0.0205436461,
-0.1203274801,
0.2562079132,
0.3140039742,
0.6677741408,
-0.3352027535,
0.556062758,
-0.2670609653,
-0.1040278599,
-0.4579322934,
0.6698631048,
0.1952002943,
0.2026484311,
0.7579036355,
-0.772636354,
-0.797501862,
0.1968484074,
-0.5776423216,
-0.5280245543,
0.3399581313,
-0.1663437337,
0.4605509639,
0.1607141644,
-0.4236348569,
0.3557554781,
0.6718382239,
-0.5682538152,
0.3835693002,
0.13880831,
0.3968046606,
-0.763070941,
-0.0863720626,
0.1505265385,
-0.398789525,
-0.8969732523,
-0.2034387589,
0.180526197,
-0.0256011859,
-0.4718003869,
0.4627153873,
-0.2851088345,
0.0128802098,
-0.6321112514,
0.2077808082,
0.2682186663,
0.4871293604,
0.0919735432,
0.6650426388,
0.6428312659,
0.0843753219,
0.5995076299,
0.0694494769,
0.0799272656,
1.1309691668,
-0.5355221033,
0.1513229907,
-0.6113887429,
0.3138605058,
-1.0604143143,
-0.0797574222,
0.3224699199,
-0.6083973646,
0.1855655313,
-0.1842915416,
-0.2327774912,
-0.3129980266,
-0.5981114507,
0.5905910134,
0.359867692,
-0.3751198351,
0.8283264041,
0.3742749393,
-0.4632633924,
-0.3420594633,
-0.289465934,
0.3428654671,
-0.4018210173,
-0.7240775824,
0.2678514123,
-0.1549689919,
-0.4148703516,
-0.1474301964,
0.2433909774,
0.1910767108,
-0.0177848712,
0.472094357,
0.5687820315,
-0.0501889698,
0.154098168,
0.1164986417,
-0.1364440173,
0.2482845485,
-0.0341892317,
0.7553706169,
-0.4118048847,
-0.1430366784,
-0.6606711745,
0.5576441288,
0.8094510436,
-0.3238452971,
0.6456261873,
0.5933160782,
-0.2289304733,
-0.1844883561,
-0.6129618287,
-0.126965642,
-0.3809874356,
-0.0496897697,
0.1027544141,
-0.7187207341,
0.7417435646,
0.1399836987,
-0.3638147712,
0.4022605717,
0.4414743781,
-0.2690654993,
1.0830293894,
0.5154415369,
-0.498291105,
0.601231873,
-0.490601182,
0.5052117705,
-1.0582993031,
-0.1527710259,
-0.4958803356,
-0.4698860049,
-0.3959887326,
-0.6913561225,
0.4524677992,
-0.4957862496,
0.2312344164,
0.4008096159,
-0.4151840806,
0.2692909241,
0.4442659616,
0.0885758027,
-0.0526455678,
-0.1322945952,
0.2716944516,
-0.2454976439,
-0.27171579,
-0.2831285298,
1.2361352444,
0.3132802248,
0.0738176554,
-0.1417472064,
0.8623456955,
0.4130266905,
0.7569665313,
-0.8120434284,
0.55621171,
-0.1188791618,
-0.3266327977,
0.0930762067,
-0.1577021778,
-0.61436975,
0.0615796149,
-0.2570508718,
-0.4697758257,
0.4057601392,
-0.0186885651,
-0.2677311301,
0.0370803997,
-0.4826462865,
0.7408956289,
-0.1700419486,
-0.3888191283,
-0.1446170956,
-0.4483089447,
0.1994343102,
0.188578099,
0.3916194439,
-0.27784127,
-0.1943543851,
0.7676271796,
-0.1148756966,
0.8968068361,
-0.3809105456,
0.0368059799,
0.3743874431,
-0.1498524249,
0.7100759149,
0.1585445106,
-0.2488383353,
0.2266326696,
-0.4317465127,
-0.4242176116,
-0.7257886529,
0.8003800511,
-0.6378659606,
-0.3284759521,
-0.4875160754,
-0.4775729775,
-0.0213439874,
-0.2555520236,
0.1403746456,
0.4343101382,
-0.1218885407,
0.1599761993,
0.6552473903,
-0.0327318236,
0.2853777111,
0.3861624002,
0.0723963678,
-1.0330736637,
0.9805468917,
-0.0592566803,
0.0033127558,
0.1191565394,
0.0242214166,
-0.3990443945,
-0.4712383151,
-0.2961759567,
0.4462868273,
-0.5585966706,
-0.4768688083,
-0.9149551988,
0.2241929621,
-0.6653959155,
-0.3192062974,
-0.585739255,
-0.4578900039,
-0.4122604132,
-0.441893518,
0.6111646295,
0.6749905348,
-0.1370576918,
0.4421713352,
-0.4305523932,
0.173610568,
0.0708423927,
0.0805048868,
-0.4641905427,
-0.4510359466,
-0.1382660419,
-0.1184815541,
-0.2740242779,
-1.1395998001,
0.8616970778,
0.0507335328,
0.194093883,
0.4430701435,
0.1648761779,
0.1730442196,
-0.2038424313,
0.7862686515,
0.1385941058,
-1.0772609711,
0.7463303208,
-0.6290398836,
0.1038342342,
0.6904990077,
0.4177519679,
-0.4599490762,
-0.8627323508,
-0.8145874143,
-0.9537946582,
0.5411225557,
0.3784886599,
0.1174367443,
0.0055839103,
0.2864536345,
0.1432961375,
0.3506466448,
-0.9559697509,
-0.4029404521,
-0.2303605229,
-0.6059647202,
-0.2393221557,
-0.3740845621,
-0.3100731671,
-0.6289232373,
0.7238786817,
-0.2634089887,
0.5019129515,
0.2457584888,
0.1499428898,
-0.2819975317,
0.4049830735,
0.8335987329,
0.2274576128,
-0.3343557715,
0.3730282485,
0.1493475586,
-0.2163059264,
0.0618823096,
0.155056715,
-0.2112670243,
0.2024121135,
0.3694418073,
1.0656425953,
0.1382983178,
-0.6125946045,
0.7318040133,
-0.1317050904,
-0.23696962,
-0.6411552429,
-0.134431541,
0.0003683294,
0.3732972741,
0.1501260698,
0.1256105155,
0.3172802329,
-0.5217418075,
0.155036509,
0.6577988863,
-0.7641434669,
-0.9284026623,
0.4594211578,
0.1980579644,
-0.2800656855,
0.016954435,
-0.5525084138,
-1.2209966183,
0.7911052108,
0.1907448769,
0.9735231996,
-0.3158138394,
0.6634923816,
0.3789399266,
0.1392109096,
0.105167605,
0.8285701275,
-0.0943661854,
-0.6813149452,
-0.1775968522,
-0.5216255784,
-0.5075297356,
-0.0794868991,
-0.590747714,
0.497176677,
-0.3870978057,
-0.1954844594,
-0.088186115,
0.1318496317,
-0.600764811,
0.1528232843,
0.3326712847,
0.3249075711,
-1.3997391462,
0.5194911361,
0.8060162067,
-0.2459270656,
-0.1574654728,
-0.5622749329,
0.0386546403,
-0.4761146903,
0.751806736,
0.3004640341,
-0.1669944227,
-0.3461844623,
-0.7272284031,
-0.6809023023,
0.9079527855,
0.2078173161,
-0.2187406719,
0.5426039696,
0.2620114982,
1.053103447,
-0.8431161046,
0.3626459837,
0.5757569671,
0.7284381986,
-0.0775886774,
-0.2175151259,
-0.1091503799,
-0.5889692307,
-0.4163529277,
0.3486265242,
-0.6275044084,
0.9335100651,
0.3633197546,
-0.1380120069,
-0.2374861836,
0.7149588466,
-0.0351910852,
0.8104299903,
0.5837603807,
0.8596152663,
0.6100728512,
-0.0738151893,
0.8234205246,
-0.5947734118,
0.2234931439,
1.1180417538,
-0.4252820909,
0.7561144829,
0.668015182,
-0.0865701288,
0.8461222053,
0.362672776,
0.0918331221,
0.2453926057,
-0.0245062616,
-0.7713605762,
-0.3452727795,
-0.5445260406,
-0.0905443877,
0.3375302553,
0.332906872,
-0.3496097624,
-0.0906945989,
0.2839949727,
0.0539637357,
0.1531079561,
-0.2128930092,
0.6440148354,
0.0743166655,
-0.7406365275,
0.3765200377,
-0.1631649435,
0.6423806548,
0.1877963394,
0.0904218778,
-0.4196691811,
-0.1913917214,
-0.3170321584,
-0.542517364,
0.4316450953,
0.1911754757,
-0.1231498495,
-0.441865176,
0.8150442243,
-0.426758498,
-0.802411139,
0.8056821227,
0.3098649383,
-0.0176586732,
-0.3355605602,
-0.4331422448,
0.239569962,
-0.0948675126,
-0.121249184,
0.1481341124,
0.4682154655,
0.1380975842,
0.4047490656,
0.3636234403,
0.418754369,
0.0964764729,
0.33245942,
1.1734116077,
-0.5527998209,
-0.1998714954,
-0.6723884344,
0.6241376996,
-0.372385323,
-0.1351945549,
0.6339166164,
0.3789090216,
0.4513131976,
-0.0579812862,
0.5796841979,
0.145702526,
0.3405888677,
-0.0893703848,
0.2926774919,
-0.5748089552,
0.1037457362,
-0.3388820589,
-0.9124888182,
-0.379852742,
0.3253868222,
-0.733721137,
-0.5022522211,
0.7303823233,
0.8429971933,
0.0144000323,
0.3173403144,
0.0818191841,
0.0161989927,
0.1610014141,
0.5424211621,
0.777143836,
-0.602512598,
0.0205518417,
-0.6143729091,
-0.3234131336,
-0.3486471474,
-0.7529035211,
-0.821424067,
-0.5966832638,
-0.6785106063,
-0.3050503135,
-0.2569217384,
1.0833511353,
0.2973546684,
-1.1508535147,
-0.0475336686,
-0.3453944921,
0.4227505326,
0.1488639265,
-0.2660074234,
0.0204098094,
-0.2740910053,
-0.9892759919,
0.4329836965,
0.686050415,
-0.0087837595,
-0.2900498211,
0.0184385851,
-0.1697952449,
0.2450025976,
0.5283520222,
0.1137898043,
-0.3375645578,
-0.4269376993,
0.0841023475,
0.1292678416,
0.4141195416,
0.8840074539,
-0.4977926612,
0.3502110243,
0.7479875684,
0.4514726698,
0.1873705089,
0.1789315641,
0.4971308112,
-0.5025977492,
0.2860870361,
0.6383214593,
0.5058173537,
0.5411996841,
-0.5216939449,
0.4216794074,
0.4977039993,
-0.5765523911,
-0.8675735593,
0.2514180839,
-1.2968010902,
0.1752390563,
1.1254136562,
-0.1256563514,
-0.6800123453,
-0.2358247042,
-0.2112554312,
0.0709957033,
-0.6774039268,
0.7740321755,
0.6922234297,
-0.4223123491,
-0.2560465336,
-0.4345697165,
0.4621584117,
0.7968612313,
-0.9879798889,
-0.0510810204,
0.562722981,
0.039584484,
0.2699247897,
0.6394203901,
-0.1095122099,
0.2220751494,
-0.3788129091,
0.3303417563,
0.3313147724,
-0.6380773783,
-0.689971149,
0.1133254692,
-0.1756823063,
0.1634949893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07775v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07775v1
|
Discourse-Aware In-Context Learning for Temporal Expression Normalization
| 2024-04-11T14:13:44 | 2024-04-11T14:13:44 |
Akash Kumar Gautam, Lukas Lange, Jannik Strötgen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Temporal expression (TE) normalization is a well-studied problem. However,
the predominately used rule-based systems are highly restricted to specific
settings, and upcoming machine learning approaches suffer from a lack of
labeled data. In this work, we explore the feasibility of proprietary and
open-source large language models (LLMs) for TE normalization using in-context
learning to inject task, document, and example information into the model. We
explore various sample selection strategies to retrieve the most relevant set
of examples. By using a window-based prompt design approach, we can perform TE
normalization across sentences, while leveraging the LLM knowledge without
training the model. Our experiments show competitive results to models designed
for this task. In particular, our method achieves large performance
improvements for non-standard settings by dynamically including relevant
examples during inference.
|
[
0.2318292111,
-0.831325531,
0.7613083124,
0.2697263062,
-0.4895076752,
-0.1063091457,
-0.3664311767,
-0.3199029565,
-0.1284586042,
0.3248612583,
-0.3605318666,
-0.6999266744,
-0.4091948569,
0.2094261497,
-0.1731412411,
0.7283809185,
-0.0456885844,
0.0831685886,
-0.0429274291,
-0.2601504326,
-0.4639229178,
-0.2929780185,
-0.6669050455,
-0.24668549,
0.2474379539,
0.4436431229,
0.1423443854,
0.5856221318,
-0.1442015469,
0.2653225958,
-0.3216026723,
0.2225096524,
-0.4921669364,
0.3107705116,
-0.080592148,
-0.3285219371,
-0.2326299846,
0.0943243876,
0.9958862662,
0.9163247347,
-0.0187842883,
0.2550460398,
0.1103428751,
0.0534368306,
-0.5963535309,
0.5194569826,
-0.6917306185,
0.2976238132,
-0.0944457874,
-0.1784294248,
-0.6594956517,
-0.6955431104,
0.1460609287,
-0.7196272016,
-0.1329486966,
0.0957006365,
0.8955547214,
0.1209186912,
-0.7938973904,
-0.0045162891,
-0.7106562853,
0.8926566243,
-0.9537763,
0.2030844092,
0.0105587803,
0.4213579595,
-0.029767571,
-0.8493254185,
-0.367934078,
-0.2042549402,
-0.291359961,
0.0774492621,
-0.2644405663,
0.0619542338,
0.5743706226,
0.1661045104,
-0.3760361373,
0.3458274901,
-0.0852161571,
0.1705417782,
0.0240708441,
0.2354272902,
0.1456536055,
-0.1966521591,
-0.3823480308,
0.3213616908,
-0.6964319944,
0.2508201897,
-0.1963862032,
0.4853410423,
-0.0808564052,
0.5123569965,
-0.2147832811,
0.8516674638,
0.0923867747,
-0.2051272541,
0.1691789329,
0.0247446671,
-0.6787475348,
-0.216236189,
0.4779453278,
0.3092564344,
0.0921090096,
-0.4402923584,
-0.2991504073,
-0.1047700718,
-0.182495743,
-1.045861125,
0.4679002464,
-0.0838311166,
-0.3803623617,
-0.0523374565,
-0.0867014974,
-0.7046553493,
-0.2273510247,
-0.5872789621,
0.3683937192,
-0.3768914342,
0.0588477887,
0.0182821453,
-0.0886737108,
0.3069222271,
0.4965596795,
-0.391551137,
0.3196680546,
0.4126338065,
0.696891427,
-0.0793454573,
0.1057734489,
-1.0196875334,
0.5086931586,
-0.3952879012,
0.4281926155,
-0.7260175943,
-0.4368689954,
0.1119931489,
0.1373545229,
-0.1000332162,
-0.5624028444,
0.4485600889,
-0.7107917666,
0.6110352874,
-0.0023355128,
-0.8261057138,
-0.0966095924,
0.1134394258,
-0.3641616106,
0.9571126699,
0.2387446016,
-0.6314843893,
0.3639872074,
-0.8942758441,
-0.5111829042,
0.1830491275,
-0.2860427797,
-0.3627356887,
0.2591024935,
0.3178917766,
0.6052010059,
-0.2135675251,
0.6644317508,
-0.1266794801,
-0.5028652549,
0.0635121092,
-0.2928622961,
0.9052904248,
0.3617171943,
-0.4909716249,
0.2444402575,
-0.6626784205,
-0.0981182754,
-0.0012605662,
-0.3636060059,
-0.3510865271,
-0.2822421491,
0.0506232269,
0.3134618998,
0.0941868946,
-0.7052815557,
0.2258876115,
-0.4836168289,
0.5595766306,
0.8071286082,
0.1672266424,
0.5399945974,
-0.2443573475,
0.5619619489,
0.1071080118,
0.0818796307,
-0.3423719704,
-0.2911767066,
-0.5141397715,
-0.4594186246,
0.3055184782,
0.6187224984,
-0.7656373978,
0.4559907019,
-0.4327708483,
-0.2604009807,
-0.2364532351,
-0.2015043646,
0.3813396692,
1.2495033741,
0.4110305309,
0.11595276,
-0.3355654478,
-0.9657461643,
-0.3458094895,
0.2074599713,
-0.4746606052,
0.5296242237,
0.0640466884,
-0.1894093901,
1.1505404711,
-0.4250334501,
-0.0224868748,
-0.1149142459,
0.3769952357,
0.1940875202,
0.1262783557,
0.4923506975,
-0.5160904527,
-0.3933728337,
-0.1791762561,
-0.8276588917,
-0.5146971345,
-0.2046924531,
0.306363523,
0.300885886,
0.8663694263,
-0.1705897599,
0.4850102365,
0.2285582572,
-0.3442471027,
0.0439541861,
-0.1479353011,
0.0431921966,
-1.3813992739,
0.0766678751,
0.3181556165,
-0.5859966278,
-0.5784237385,
-0.1157876998,
0.2466033846,
-0.4403403401,
-0.7645591497,
0.7828316689,
-0.4518969655,
-0.0058603734,
-0.0489137918,
0.1767421812,
0.0524196513,
0.5580578446,
0.0449315943,
0.6789342165,
0.3479102254,
-0.6107468009,
-0.171152249,
-0.097343646,
-0.4498871267,
0.3918160796,
-0.6941477656,
0.1116039902,
-0.3414471745,
0.4436549544,
-0.7531390786,
-0.1803676933,
0.0840506032,
0.0133887697,
0.3665436208,
-0.2127643079,
-0.6880019903,
0.276055187,
-0.1040049046,
0.3776105642,
0.6491853595,
-0.6440506577,
0.8297969103,
0.3681096435,
-0.090347819,
-0.4616967142,
-0.5709201694,
0.1678902358,
-0.5452994108,
-0.4824478924,
0.688996613,
0.1516404897,
-0.3970299363,
-0.2156034112,
-0.014796285,
0.0411245935,
0.1995718479,
0.1782230586,
0.245069325,
-0.1106356382,
0.501552701,
0.4601145089,
0.1662127376,
-0.2783378661,
-0.294213742,
0.2589204311,
-0.1576935947,
-0.1000078395,
-0.6802799702,
0.6285035014,
0.4953869879,
-0.1657647043,
0.5685003996,
0.4054899216,
-0.7160314918,
-0.3480314016,
-0.426877141,
-0.2468109876,
-0.4680796266,
0.0282190517,
-0.1840283573,
-1.3808535337,
0.2133518606,
-0.4984792471,
0.1933206171,
0.1575553417,
0.3608994484,
-0.0478046536,
0.7811089754,
0.6635628343,
0.1087936759,
0.842703402,
-0.0093951235,
0.1785307974,
-0.6937090158,
-0.0203108937,
-0.3642361462,
-0.3899969757,
-0.4841056764,
-0.3525775671,
0.6758443713,
-0.1233781204,
-0.5470756292,
0.0604256652,
-0.2925761938,
0.5334444642,
0.3811634183,
0.2102905512,
0.3708924949,
-0.1815095842,
-0.2418692261,
-0.1775904298,
-0.5981599092,
-0.6379419565,
0.7814357281,
0.2448171973,
0.5622048378,
-0.0068827211,
0.4922697842,
0.1615611315,
0.4533018172,
-0.6425411701,
0.6740451455,
-0.2708483338,
-0.1878418922,
-0.3635852039,
-0.5371915698,
-1.0276844501,
-0.0926268846,
-0.1017205343,
-0.9121139646,
0.1950059831,
-0.1016988009,
-0.5137978792,
0.1995221674,
-0.8699758053,
0.7926552296,
0.1131771654,
-0.2401925176,
0.0381735824,
-0.8166114092,
0.1036068201,
0.0494386405,
0.266382277,
-0.1169997156,
-0.3616948128,
0.4854759276,
-0.1227984577,
1.2904677391,
-0.335863173,
0.1313528717,
0.1718967408,
0.031426765,
0.4996339381,
0.2286460549,
-0.0906863362,
-0.209281683,
-0.3256157041,
-0.3919414282,
-0.6824910641,
0.6402643919,
-0.5285375118,
-0.6158593297,
-0.2604797781,
-0.5560645461,
-0.3901681304,
0.1357670575,
0.2629273832,
0.4746346772,
-0.3608941734,
0.3376564085,
0.8828133345,
-0.2488696724,
0.7396773696,
0.6904593706,
-0.1659733057,
-0.0376298428,
0.482911706,
0.1765518785,
0.0348216109,
0.7315487862,
0.4292910695,
-0.1935536414,
-0.392744571,
-0.2860321701,
0.1556752473,
-0.6701554656,
-0.2340690047,
-0.6809338927,
0.0345465168,
-0.5635254979,
-0.1186408401,
0.0314092375,
-0.6327430606,
-0.6532859802,
-0.105659008,
0.2671618462,
0.4330727756,
0.4637487531,
0.2626649141,
-0.6811801791,
0.2475073338,
0.448979944,
0.2355917096,
-0.2500410974,
-0.6731084585,
-0.0897421911,
-0.2876698673,
-0.3158607483,
-0.936526835,
0.3323809505,
0.2825433314,
0.3822127283,
0.424779892,
0.0861433372,
0.3302853107,
-0.6161843538,
0.9298560619,
-0.2075637579,
-1.1260348558,
0.722571075,
-0.4861347377,
0.4779795408,
0.2105167061,
0.3757294714,
-0.7734374404,
-0.3373734653,
-0.590718329,
-0.7334118485,
0.4389741421,
-0.1798944771,
0.1151366606,
-0.1406187117,
0.5320174098,
0.1885886937,
0.19905141,
-0.7168800831,
0.1883258969,
0.0205175374,
-0.2044647485,
0.0824739039,
-0.0135635948,
-0.2005932182,
-0.271424979,
0.4066712856,
-0.3787533045,
0.1597048044,
0.0694522932,
-0.2704463601,
0.087249428,
0.6456225514,
0.4967452288,
0.6639220119,
-0.020392539,
-0.1144465357,
0.4292733967,
0.2134179771,
0.0306853559,
0.1991249323,
-0.4337144196,
0.1135118082,
0.0350623429,
0.7004467249,
0.4851203263,
-0.7017249465,
0.556663692,
-0.1828323454,
0.0988347083,
-0.3189052641,
-0.1660229713,
0.0998744443,
0.4164687395,
0.1983424872,
-0.2390065789,
0.1896939874,
-0.4957778752,
0.0177415609,
0.3470995426,
-0.3249107003,
-0.1721875221,
0.6262230277,
-0.0058548274,
-0.2709324956,
0.6034300327,
-0.27614218,
-0.062787123,
0.4576569498,
0.6242037416,
0.9489648342,
-0.1880692244,
0.1210191697,
0.1467498094,
0.000631196,
0.0613933392,
0.3279599547,
0.0287052188,
-0.4194846749,
-0.5463556051,
-0.3380175829,
-0.4871777296,
0.1672468781,
-0.4982536733,
0.561350286,
-0.5561031699,
-0.2599309087,
-0.2382158339,
-0.2807863057,
-0.6686661839,
0.1861893535,
0.0232603978,
0.9359411597,
-0.9357293844,
1.0349316597,
0.5936377048,
-0.1663000733,
-0.6735543013,
0.2167838663,
-0.0918667093,
-0.4024534225,
0.6086480618,
0.2268070281,
-0.0742119774,
-0.2241217643,
-0.5559846759,
-0.5113677979,
1.3280262947,
0.851142168,
-0.4299713075,
-0.381662339,
-0.2078264207,
0.6536944509,
-0.7857536077,
0.1486280113,
0.3741635382,
0.3690994978,
-0.1026439741,
-0.7135469913,
0.1835455447,
-0.1947204471,
0.3827151954,
0.1338668764,
-0.5866604447,
0.8391990662,
0.1170230433,
-0.5429531336,
-0.1264107823,
0.8184699416,
-0.0024966595,
0.4411779344,
0.5414417982,
0.4878781438,
0.8104515672,
-0.0098352106,
0.89211303,
-0.1818660945,
-0.0844373107,
1.4577111006,
-0.2990637124,
0.6438897252,
0.492038995,
0.3508979678,
0.4791849852,
0.6614227891,
0.2593216896,
0.2995359302,
0.2949572802,
-0.5782324672,
-0.1078376547,
-0.5073236227,
-0.0658921227,
0.3259861469,
0.4735859334,
-0.4963959754,
-0.4444162846,
0.1637396514,
0.3287979066,
0.3271537125,
-0.2704709172,
0.9000357389,
-0.0311147533,
-0.557690084,
0.4206922352,
0.1418995261,
0.6869101524,
-0.4730030298,
-0.096907936,
-0.1744784862,
-0.1583830714,
0.021867821,
-0.4248183966,
0.4129747152,
0.1501065195,
-0.0455112085,
-0.5010988712,
0.5505541563,
-0.390630424,
-0.3525381386,
0.1881850064,
0.6049938798,
-0.0917917117,
0.0884159282,
-0.2707405984,
-0.3119311035,
-0.2392418385,
-0.3085395992,
0.4515402615,
0.7888965011,
-0.465158999,
0.4496878088,
0.1043176055,
-0.1336719245,
-0.0577994473,
0.1330687106,
1.0216515064,
-0.4397416413,
-0.5428506732,
-0.6809931993,
0.5035883784,
-0.2915945053,
-0.3793054223,
0.5174115896,
0.5477129817,
0.7056599855,
-0.0221323986,
0.5904063582,
0.391831696,
0.7674765587,
-0.5907623172,
0.4284079373,
-0.5788616538,
0.3801210821,
-0.0945544541,
-0.7584337592,
-0.5333727598,
0.1622919887,
-0.4162300527,
-0.0705974698,
0.7245762348,
0.6983817816,
-0.1338062137,
0.1075771675,
0.3906764984,
0.1924434006,
0.426874578,
0.6391482949,
0.4962238073,
0.055881612,
0.4457642138,
-0.11575903,
-0.6959847212,
-0.1298002303,
-1.3456770182,
-0.9431357384,
-0.6618843079,
-0.2232955694,
-0.0709783211,
0.0875174701,
1.2674068213,
0.6130331755,
-0.5330209732,
-0.2556732297,
0.2737374008,
-0.0101109836,
-0.1616643816,
-0.2062366903,
0.2964542508,
-0.5339012742,
-0.8608059883,
0.6499425769,
0.2314278483,
0.1375622302,
0.2608115971,
0.3646903336,
-0.1316906363,
0.2037210315,
0.7637457848,
0.205365777,
-0.5784041882,
-0.4615912735,
0.1805054098,
-0.1146750599,
0.2144508362,
1.0716398954,
-0.9691919088,
0.3557153344,
0.4617831111,
0.7897319198,
0.6167417169,
-0.1744712144,
0.610915184,
-1.1157512665,
0.2520078719,
0.6906163692,
0.6840603948,
0.3189381659,
-0.4393430948,
0.3361934125,
0.162049517,
-0.5257299542,
-0.6014142632,
0.4721725285,
-0.9305247068,
-0.5224156976,
1.1386518478,
-0.3547450602,
-0.165436253,
0.0246282853,
-0.1033430323,
0.5135923624,
-0.6560292244,
0.9272036552,
0.4027765989,
-0.2073787302,
-0.1006646082,
-0.3570195138,
0.437135905,
0.2155803889,
-0.9314302802,
0.1666553319,
0.6184358597,
0.2639960349,
-0.1221102104,
0.4988953173,
-0.2751669586,
0.0462258086,
-0.623713553,
-0.2881152332,
-0.1333669424,
-0.2123903036,
-0.5737295747,
0.3090618253,
-0.1147839352,
0.0666395277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07768v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07768v3
|
Using Letter Positional Probabilities to Assess Word Complexity
| 2024-04-11T14:06:39 | 2024-04-30T07:03:19 |
Michael Dalvean
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7; J.4
|
Word complexity is defined in a number of different ways. Psycholinguistic,
morphological and lexical proxies are often used. Human ratings are also used.
The problem here is that these proxies do not measure complexity directly, and
human ratings are susceptible to subjective bias. In this study we contend that
some form of 'latent complexity' can be approximated by using samples of simple
and complex words. We use a sample of 'simple' words from primary school
picture books and a sample of 'complex' words from high school and academic
settings. In order to analyse the differences between these classes, we look at
the letter positional probabilities (LPPs). We find strong statistical
associations between several LPPs and complexity. For example, simple words are
significantly (p<.001) more likely to start with w, b, s, h, g, k, j, t, y or
f, while complex words are significantly (p<.001) more likely to start with i,
a, e, r, v, u or d. We find similar strong associations for subsequent letter
positions, with 84 letter-position variables in the first 6 positions being
significant at the p<.001 level. We then use LPPs as variables in creating a
classifier which can classify the two classes with an 83% accuracy. We test
these findings using a second data set, with 66 LPPs significant (p<.001) in
the first 6 positions common to both datasets. We use these 66 variables to
create a classifier that is able to classify a third dataset with an accuracy
of 70%. Finally, we create a fourth sample by combining the extreme high and
low scoring words generated by three classifiers built on the first three
separate datasets and use this sample to build a classifier which has an
accuracy of 97%. We use this to score the four levels of English word groups
from an ESL program.
|
[
-0.1750812232,
-0.690859437,
0.7650048137,
0.2925685346,
-0.1018165648,
0.2315727919,
-0.0843151584,
-0.5712261796,
-0.0823488384,
-0.1290267855,
-0.2534597814,
-0.5776241422,
-0.894100368,
-0.0673309937,
-0.0437037162,
0.5453998446,
0.0314403586,
0.0701629966,
-0.1586243659,
-0.1668245643,
-0.3984973431,
-0.4877696335,
-0.3945385218,
-0.4569919109,
0.6175057292,
0.4503007531,
0.9636849165,
0.4470162988,
0.6429004669,
0.4027929306,
-0.3017941117,
-0.0588402227,
-0.3248642385,
-0.0942380428,
-0.0609864816,
-0.7153460979,
-0.3458534777,
0.1925919354,
0.3153838515,
1.3343725204,
-0.2049330175,
-0.1698648334,
0.0782334432,
0.9394577742,
-0.6308728456,
0.2028450072,
-0.426951319,
0.3298671544,
-0.3739793897,
-0.2409578711,
-0.224626258,
-0.3401564062,
0.4603859484,
-0.4947555363,
0.2246910036,
0.2570486069,
0.5062265992,
-0.1746750176,
-0.2142499834,
-0.7808458805,
-0.8478988409,
0.8137603998,
-0.4521462619,
0.2727496326,
0.4743180275,
-0.0358421057,
-0.5235975981,
-0.34788692,
-0.699954927,
-0.4319325387,
0.020748321,
0.2157312483,
-0.2143794298,
0.2936857641,
0.4168950319,
0.5883662701,
-0.7687420845,
0.2127538472,
-0.3817252815,
-0.1805309206,
0.5302344561,
0.065166384,
0.41099599,
-0.1228189841,
-0.0723119676,
-0.2621519864,
-0.4926804006,
0.7033330202,
0.9296098948,
0.4182689488,
0.3016340733,
0.9638678432,
-0.0740937889,
0.6160017252,
-0.0245747436,
-0.4233708084,
0.3496809602,
-0.0292461775,
-0.0733838305,
0.1996347755,
0.6380844116,
0.2552170753,
0.2798094749,
-0.1123173758,
-0.2114126682,
0.2455579191,
-0.0044656205,
-0.316124469,
-0.3456254601,
0.2449091524,
-0.2508054972,
-0.2128993273,
0.3646623492,
-0.2271055877,
-0.3691028953,
-0.1384438276,
0.6389006376,
-0.5607914329,
0.158178255,
0.5333973765,
-0.0569074601,
0.146469593,
0.1392202526,
-0.6392426491,
0.2475452423,
0.6523264647,
0.8168234229,
-0.2906892002,
-0.5224861503,
-0.1610729694,
0.0156766009,
-0.3610582054,
0.8545660973,
-0.6387028098,
-0.421933949,
0.0270453561,
0.0823097527,
0.1587569416,
-0.5582308769,
0.8716552854,
-0.2743424773,
0.4822673202,
-0.112228319,
-0.8530887365,
-0.1055587381,
0.0758502707,
-0.6901810169,
0.9936484694,
0.0305740517,
-0.9289146066,
0.4060819447,
-0.0706209764,
-0.6893354058,
0.1128763855,
-0.1232808456,
-0.2963347137,
0.224973321,
-0.1151779518,
0.5196909308,
0.0138031235,
-0.138240844,
-0.2021275908,
-0.6179355383,
0.3585169911,
-0.3907812238,
0.3510855436,
-0.1380131096,
-0.3096692264,
-0.2789735496,
-0.8130834103,
0.1244907305,
-0.02503548,
-0.7340219617,
-0.625056982,
0.1398663968,
-0.1168332249,
0.0985894278,
0.2817252874,
-0.4842138588,
0.4061235487,
-0.6894439459,
0.200939849,
0.4424861073,
-0.0700214356,
0.6471951604,
-0.5148420334,
0.5834252238,
0.0947787091,
-0.1226347983,
0.377633363,
-0.8215296268,
-0.4111151695,
0.012725207,
0.3872298002,
0.868884325,
-0.5781425834,
0.6971969008,
-0.2208250463,
-0.804063499,
-0.2583059967,
0.0171711445,
0.4765807092,
0.1696891785,
0.2438363433,
-0.3794823885,
-0.2255026549,
-0.7574118376,
-0.3867354393,
-0.5170511603,
-0.4608122706,
0.1011027023,
0.240060553,
0.1264320165,
0.5853824615,
-0.7617797852,
-0.3317229748,
-0.0790309981,
0.5385180712,
0.5388104916,
0.2915664911,
0.2114705741,
-0.4556553662,
-0.1349896342,
-0.5400443673,
-0.419118464,
-0.1153215915,
0.1646034122,
0.0736271441,
-0.0583159439,
0.4092901051,
-0.3893217146,
0.435721457,
0.4022240639,
-0.446898669,
0.517113626,
-0.6328900456,
-0.0596652292,
-0.6512544751,
-0.2277214676,
0.0703124478,
0.1883454919,
-0.6547698379,
-0.2138668001,
-0.3725913465,
0.1631127447,
-0.3582534492,
0.1102713645,
-0.5596072674,
-0.0860851407,
-0.0084592765,
0.0745613351,
-0.2186980993,
0.4210558832,
-0.0467236452,
0.4855102301,
0.3047531545,
-0.4938601255,
0.1036145911,
-0.3809936941,
-0.8247766495,
0.4515049756,
-0.6719603539,
-0.1235993579,
-0.304741621,
-0.1205892488,
-1.5097807646,
-0.1129855216,
-0.0078610666,
-0.1570648253,
0.2034172714,
0.3915964663,
-0.3479733467,
-0.491168648,
-0.3191094398,
0.2663796544,
0.2865927219,
0.0901284441,
0.3474897444,
0.6326195598,
-0.2665385008,
-0.6387858987,
-0.6919807792,
-0.1004172415,
-0.0746801049,
-0.5041787624,
0.4513038695,
-0.3812633157,
-0.3491447866,
-0.0522834249,
-0.3448858261,
0.0149866045,
-0.091133371,
0.5688985586,
-0.1473186314,
-0.0817001835,
0.2443508059,
-0.077765435,
0.1403104514,
-0.1401384175,
0.0170521624,
0.5716701746,
-0.4741256833,
-0.3498075306,
-0.1843783408,
0.2573256493,
0.7318015695,
0.2676329613,
0.548848331,
0.385809958,
-0.5394644737,
-0.0167994238,
-0.2653572559,
0.1189642102,
-0.437189728,
0.408390373,
-0.6887251735,
-0.6540641189,
0.5727840066,
0.2941594124,
-0.1556842029,
0.3143924475,
0.4403123558,
-0.3871645033,
0.979896009,
0.4316944778,
0.1367572099,
0.4272353053,
-0.261269182,
0.3116742373,
-0.3861169815,
-0.3345884979,
-0.2570125759,
-0.6478577852,
-0.8632514477,
-0.4004687667,
0.2021360993,
0.3978903592,
0.0604150146,
0.2208389491,
-0.3920811117,
0.6290795803,
0.6040138602,
0.2955650091,
0.2497431934,
0.1822554171,
-0.1954535693,
-0.2309113145,
-0.6364349127,
-0.6334426999,
0.9021984339,
0.5204590559,
0.7271270752,
0.5511268973,
0.5527364612,
0.4289061129,
0.1412458718,
-1.3606874943,
0.6899787188,
-0.6557757854,
-0.1998445094,
-0.7254459262,
-0.1123111844,
-1.2977333069,
-0.0715473071,
-0.4858999848,
-0.4464358985,
0.3450750411,
-0.2137561738,
-0.4139662683,
0.1323183179,
-0.6063290238,
0.2343248129,
0.0161507893,
-0.4238775969,
0.0905339718,
-0.5920271873,
0.2402619421,
0.0629387796,
0.4766514599,
-0.1130265817,
-0.1277404279,
1.0674312115,
-0.678406775,
0.5534896851,
0.0245452914,
-0.30091995,
0.3369272053,
0.1974292994,
0.3377307653,
-0.3644215167,
-0.1775728762,
-0.0305874925,
0.0499209799,
-0.3863186836,
-0.586773634,
0.4595668018,
-0.9842363596,
-0.5400128365,
-0.768075943,
-0.5128275752,
-0.2008154094,
0.1368051618,
0.4833258986,
0.5218786001,
0.0103182178,
0.4282638729,
0.5174138546,
-0.116372183,
0.3597545326,
0.4882622063,
0.2619993985,
-0.2776817083,
0.9195362329,
0.8658879995,
0.0474906377,
0.5922961235,
0.7047566772,
-0.3970057666,
-0.7065787911,
0.2078867406,
0.0347090885,
-0.7005441785,
0.1669293344,
-0.4090930223,
-0.23558411,
-0.3082992733,
-0.3061545789,
-0.0079872534,
-0.4179247618,
-0.0210033022,
-0.0809339806,
-0.1303756535,
0.893789649,
-0.012710169,
0.4284618199,
-0.363003701,
0.2269323468,
0.6689586639,
0.1723751724,
-0.1263560951,
-0.6408127546,
0.1874019355,
-0.3302279413,
-0.1053694412,
-1.1456938982,
0.2548612058,
0.4836616814,
0.6881811619,
0.5698570609,
0.0774033815,
0.4834681451,
-0.5163089633,
0.894898653,
0.2475572675,
-0.9357461929,
0.3076179624,
-0.1856127083,
0.3813060224,
0.6375982165,
0.5642140508,
-0.254057765,
-0.6515069604,
-0.8421038985,
-0.9986718297,
0.3711958528,
0.267926544,
-0.2549049556,
0.0175459608,
0.5473935008,
-0.1853381842,
0.1509486437,
-0.5998775959,
-0.3141953647,
0.1780447215,
-0.4838752151,
-0.2327314913,
-0.438313812,
0.0482222624,
-0.1092242822,
0.3239658773,
0.1145519018,
0.1315519959,
0.265712589,
-0.078689985,
-0.0800106376,
0.4789399803,
0.7790462375,
0.664206624,
-0.512593329,
0.6499245763,
0.1546229273,
-1.0836793184,
0.5116837621,
-0.1974301189,
0.0517178513,
-0.0231054593,
1.0224875212,
0.439034462,
0.3684515059,
-0.5369668007,
0.7471324801,
-0.1208369881,
-0.2190502882,
-0.3203791678,
0.0766021609,
0.0749842227,
0.1475730985,
0.263843894,
0.0329608731,
0.3413508832,
-0.9366064072,
0.1771528423,
0.057883542,
-0.382383734,
-0.269138068,
0.1533281356,
0.0034412518,
-0.5740399957,
0.3048576415,
-0.5581426024,
-0.5904454589,
0.6052863598,
0.4901106656,
0.6105794907,
-0.3058376908,
0.1494164914,
0.4943384826,
0.446706444,
-0.5337765217,
0.6997313499,
0.2721157968,
-0.8149836063,
-0.129440546,
-0.8788095117,
-0.6089359522,
0.3271077573,
-0.5093093514,
0.1928049177,
-0.5610995889,
-0.2438160777,
0.0630692691,
0.3758758008,
-0.6756336093,
0.296238482,
0.2860481143,
0.6639595628,
-1.2026906013,
0.5520670414,
1.0242317915,
-0.1951411366,
-0.9794416428,
0.2166436911,
-0.170102641,
-0.5993211865,
0.8735317588,
0.3096287251,
-0.5204648376,
-0.1694235206,
-0.3553689122,
-0.5531449318,
0.9919627905,
-0.1031324863,
-0.9622200727,
-0.1253246218,
0.3172146082,
0.8275467157,
-0.1881698668,
0.2745909393,
0.398057729,
0.3580622375,
0.3500648439,
-0.5409656763,
-0.0929245651,
-0.1128053218,
0.1025559306,
-0.1667601764,
-0.1019520462,
0.9426726103,
-0.3602298498,
-0.3954046369,
-0.1316783875,
0.723013401,
0.4828519225,
0.3847284913,
0.9845247269,
0.5511830449,
1.1625250578,
-0.1450590193,
0.7243466973,
-0.4828693569,
0.2253710777,
1.0833451748,
0.0357774012,
1.1811634302,
0.3979432881,
-0.7316622734,
0.4966810048,
0.7072640657,
0.1596584022,
0.4286610782,
0.7783028483,
-0.3536619842,
-0.2791604996,
0.0028262651,
-0.1563033015,
0.6419428587,
0.6110264659,
-0.2040818781,
0.1547959,
-0.0507302992,
-0.1167312711,
0.1923214197,
-0.3926855326,
0.4698106945,
0.0864153355,
-0.5917382836,
0.3112637401,
0.114904739,
0.7413446903,
-0.4887901843,
0.2066914141,
-0.0167618021,
0.1120887846,
-0.2677814066,
-1.5483733416,
0.0952745527,
-0.3058006763,
-0.2917965353,
0.144286409,
0.7504025698,
-0.6346127391,
-0.7333154082,
0.0640547425,
0.6124651432,
0.4082670808,
0.1276644617,
-0.4425447285,
-0.2279150933,
-0.4761795402,
-0.4971162975,
-0.0906538144,
0.6977081895,
0.1276878864,
0.5398952365,
0.4684765935,
0.5223227739,
-0.0027242303,
0.1210164949,
0.3896602988,
-0.528606534,
-0.5893883705,
-0.7967050672,
0.015337605,
0.1686681956,
-0.4638930857,
0.5359535217,
0.3233833909,
0.6269018054,
-0.0788180456,
0.6174641848,
0.0192297529,
0.3075858653,
-0.5180581212,
0.3967633247,
-0.5314590931,
0.3730415404,
-0.5361636281,
-0.942052424,
-0.5604308248,
0.863250792,
-0.6288428307,
-0.1827052236,
0.672221005,
0.7000638843,
0.1320565343,
-0.1054400653,
0.5182723403,
0.2173614502,
0.1721137762,
0.7856844068,
0.7016462088,
-0.4548010528,
0.3223666549,
-0.3082973063,
-0.4766225219,
-0.2276844978,
-0.9010045528,
-0.8414826393,
-0.6831336021,
-0.2079695612,
-0.5445846319,
-0.1090911552,
0.9293689132,
0.2507115304,
-0.6933587193,
-0.1693066359,
-0.0745270327,
0.2341227531,
-0.2744274437,
-0.2191708088,
0.6449964046,
0.0922162309,
-0.7362472415,
0.1288509965,
0.1422679424,
0.3238474429,
-0.3640826643,
0.1710535437,
-0.1825295091,
0.1923137009,
0.9508882761,
0.1581940204,
-0.75151968,
-0.7413755059,
0.0366532914,
-0.3219226003,
-0.1027331278,
0.5666951537,
-0.4276355505,
0.3777157962,
1.0535625219,
0.1338758022,
-0.1644022614,
0.0199354347,
0.2698730826,
-0.8304530978,
0.0143007077,
0.1434525102,
0.369590193,
0.2975986302,
-0.2230715752,
0.4287338257,
0.5828217268,
-0.4988589287,
-0.6855526567,
0.3643345535,
-1.1245536804,
-0.4083424807,
1.1508154869,
-0.1229577139,
-0.2654111981,
-0.3230913281,
-0.1784857213,
0.153534025,
-0.2191119939,
0.7829889655,
1.0947284698,
-0.2818372846,
0.1470103264,
-0.3043264449,
0.5714075565,
0.2759104371,
-0.4191769361,
-0.2830800116,
0.0656934604,
0.2731280923,
0.652608633,
0.5147899985,
0.0338581391,
-0.2610238492,
-0.0426882207,
0.0314262249,
0.2430315465,
-0.3868522942,
-0.3618199527,
0.8202987313,
0.2171991616,
0.0334483944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07765v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07765v1
|
AnnoCTR: A Dataset for Detecting and Linking Entities, Tactics, and Techniques in Cyber Threat Reports
| 2024-04-11T14:04:36 | 2024-04-11T14:04:36 |
Lukas Lange, Marc Müller, Ghazaleh Haratinezhad Torbati, Dragan Milchevski, Patrick Grau, Subhash Pujari, Annemarie Friedrich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Monitoring the threat landscape to be aware of actual or potential attacks is
of utmost importance to cybersecurity professionals. Information about cyber
threats is typically distributed using natural language reports. Natural
language processing can help with managing this large amount of unstructured
information, yet to date, the topic has received little attention. With this
paper, we present AnnoCTR, a new CC-BY-SA-licensed dataset of cyber threat
reports. The reports have been annotated by a domain expert with named
entities, temporal expressions, and cybersecurity-specific concepts including
implicitly mentioned techniques and tactics. Entities and concepts are linked
to Wikipedia and the MITRE ATT&CK knowledge base, the most widely-used taxonomy
for classifying types of attacks. Prior datasets linking to MITRE ATT&CK either
provide a single label per document or annotate sentences out-of-context; our
dataset annotates entire documents in a much finer-grained way. In an
experimental study, we model the annotations of our dataset using
state-of-the-art neural models. In our few-shot scenario, we find that for
identifying the MITRE ATT&CK concepts that are mentioned explicitly or
implicitly in a text, concept descriptions from MITRE ATT&CK are an effective
source for training data augmentation.
|
[
-0.3899573684,
-1.0884693861,
0.1329753101,
-0.2183209062,
-0.261393249,
0.3657409549,
-0.2167192698,
-1.0297361612,
0.3926252723,
0.4368298352,
-0.4070370495,
-0.5530132651,
-0.4536722004,
0.2430789918,
-0.6537329555,
1.4234070778,
0.1604323685,
-0.4036870897,
-0.2107593864,
0.24112688,
-0.535382688,
-0.6539103985,
-0.744720757,
0.1146374419,
0.3778206706,
0.2284045517,
0.4286783934,
0.5303291678,
1.0724672079,
0.2953849733,
0.085331507,
0.0868087709,
-0.2141931802,
0.0101968981,
0.0703902543,
-0.2512471378,
-0.4160964191,
-0.070648849,
0.1570430249,
0.2698713541,
0.13909325,
0.2438153177,
-0.0493030883,
-0.0530801006,
-0.5899953246,
-0.0205408223,
-0.9283049107,
-0.0527933687,
-0.4058338702,
-0.4300665855,
-0.5377539992,
-0.3213616014,
0.5076296926,
-0.8706843257,
0.0904922187,
0.2926388383,
0.4217689633,
0.2822541893,
-0.2755203247,
-0.4347048998,
-0.5182008743,
0.3925589621,
-0.3670161664,
0.0725010261,
0.486820668,
0.4339503944,
0.1386220902,
-0.7388463616,
-0.3897671103,
-0.2219666094,
-0.3948854506,
-0.2544602156,
-0.555065155,
0.0157262981,
0.2000181377,
-0.0087960325,
-0.4849867821,
0.1063301116,
-0.6459656954,
-0.5363751054,
0.7058392167,
0.1692025363,
0.2861412466,
-0.1401195079,
-0.8645282984,
0.0896359682,
-0.4696766436,
-0.1493297815,
0.4290153384,
0.4765045047,
-0.4552934766,
0.4403736293,
-0.0897525772,
0.7911661267,
-0.0020998428,
-0.2098568827,
0.130273208,
-0.482092768,
-0.0817751065,
0.6741803288,
0.6826643348,
0.3532119393,
0.3113414347,
-0.2848290801,
-0.2789497375,
0.2442252338,
0.7785940766,
-0.561689496,
-0.522781074,
-0.1135027334,
-0.1473665386,
-0.6271235943,
0.2036973238,
-0.8279480934,
-0.5619576573,
-0.4995310903,
0.2453145385,
-0.5548937321,
-0.0295683835,
-0.2880883813,
-0.1272552907,
-0.1787228435,
0.2982264459,
-0.3926469088,
0.6467441916,
0.6060197949,
0.6782177091,
-0.2784928083,
0.0389401317,
-0.4221743345,
0.004734138,
-0.1931092888,
1.085275054,
-0.6996503472,
-0.0165263209,
0.1562658399,
-0.3469195366,
0.0644074157,
-0.2224504352,
0.4389618933,
-0.6575266719,
0.0292007793,
0.0603689589,
-0.3842688203,
-0.289531976,
0.6266050339,
-0.667276144,
0.844065547,
0.0303407144,
-1.0456410646,
0.51853019,
-0.9456638098,
-0.599478364,
0.3101876676,
-0.1154444218,
-0.1560466886,
-0.1820846796,
0.0658056065,
0.2263174504,
-0.486704886,
0.0185755137,
-0.0188511107,
0.0071371067,
0.4073688984,
-0.2527095377,
0.6052750945,
0.1102292165,
-0.2454464138,
0.1059735045,
-0.6809124351,
-0.0345875621,
-0.0177638531,
0.0359739959,
-0.5943201184,
-0.0579222888,
0.1261696517,
0.0980618596,
0.2424791604,
-0.6466875672,
0.0843157545,
-0.2330592424,
0.3161652386,
0.5443201065,
0.3058350384,
0.3083865047,
-0.2889096141,
0.3972205222,
0.1663870662,
0.4165333509,
-0.1993101388,
-0.2598510981,
-0.5893968344,
-0.3167467415,
0.0725350156,
0.7437687516,
-0.9137477875,
0.1714917123,
-0.2675490379,
-0.4552392364,
-0.4927832484,
-0.0066745351,
0.2506815195,
0.8078268766,
0.7793979645,
-0.0081782453,
-0.7070084214,
-0.9285587668,
-0.0972438678,
-0.2623873055,
0.1034438908,
-0.0087499563,
0.6162821651,
-0.0729941502,
1.0862234831,
-0.6264255047,
-0.4483183324,
-0.1827236265,
0.6210530996,
-0.1940903515,
0.2078876048,
0.6059736609,
-0.9689659476,
-0.4629427493,
0.109456934,
-0.6748820543,
-0.0844300464,
-0.3281528354,
0.1555905491,
0.1376483738,
0.5562782884,
-0.3259911537,
0.6432368159,
-0.0922389328,
-0.220171243,
0.3534513414,
0.1820778847,
0.2458366305,
-0.9963520765,
0.0939027965,
0.0734510049,
-0.131447807,
-0.9962005019,
-0.0287733171,
-0.2514820099,
0.0617320426,
-0.680734694,
0.4079955518,
-0.1031953841,
0.0986530632,
-0.2241845429,
0.3500904441,
-0.1916618794,
0.2539038658,
0.1299372315,
0.5240407586,
0.5045699477,
-0.7329673171,
0.5064231157,
0.4233168066,
-0.1457064301,
0.8522247672,
-0.6027597785,
0.3002175987,
0.0614772551,
0.1059084013,
-0.63107723,
-0.3182660341,
0.4787507355,
-0.6678129435,
0.3105817139,
-0.0138182659,
-0.5441184044,
-0.178657636,
-0.4333036244,
0.4164168537,
-0.1499808431,
-0.2996404767,
0.5116968155,
0.5219234824,
-0.1130573899,
-0.5546589494,
-0.8866487145,
0.2652348578,
-0.2973650992,
-0.3879592419,
0.4204783142,
-0.0430523865,
-0.4551587403,
0.0252085775,
0.1270999312,
-0.3558468819,
0.2444561869,
0.385103792,
0.5955951214,
-0.040403042,
0.0563577302,
-0.4712972641,
-0.1181304753,
0.283634603,
-0.2887110412,
0.3794178963,
0.1195780486,
-0.151708737,
-0.4905768633,
0.231163308,
0.1079679206,
-0.1853265911,
0.6716070771,
0.6869772077,
-0.5636048913,
0.0240611974,
-0.4436689019,
-0.4791590273,
-0.3882561624,
0.0521735363,
0.1263801903,
-0.8256446719,
0.3746719658,
0.2540115416,
0.2236589491,
0.5017701387,
0.0943480507,
-0.0238435008,
0.3531468809,
0.6924817562,
-0.3726476133,
0.4170770943,
-0.1235928982,
0.4084017873,
-0.6591883898,
-0.4091999531,
-0.4600171447,
-0.3024024367,
-0.6770942211,
0.0043138475,
0.3161039352,
-0.3703425825,
-0.3253076971,
0.7957063317,
-0.6763477921,
0.2303491086,
0.3143037856,
0.1385264844,
0.2918844223,
0.0079271644,
0.0446514748,
0.0970065594,
-0.4798686802,
-0.4662991762,
1.0311430693,
0.2333253324,
0.5988637805,
0.0057674544,
0.5708436966,
0.7308692932,
0.3632923067,
-0.653321445,
0.5441307425,
0.1107426137,
-0.8112312555,
-0.0654966757,
-0.3579312861,
-0.6847205758,
-0.4151604772,
-0.5573946238,
-1.0332251787,
-0.0659752116,
0.1528656632,
-0.5440862179,
0.3061217666,
-0.2216886133,
0.5098665357,
-0.2251045257,
-0.1592872143,
-0.0841929987,
-0.7562589645,
0.2250084281,
-0.4052509069,
0.2015750408,
0.12556988,
-0.0745488703,
0.685770154,
-0.2690575719,
1.0923266411,
0.2105274647,
0.2559292316,
0.75604707,
-0.0100672124,
0.5238590837,
0.1146675572,
0.1189845651,
0.1858856827,
-0.3709118664,
0.1349040717,
-0.224610284,
0.3759971559,
-0.4819582403,
-0.1757092327,
-0.613450408,
-0.4066180587,
0.2188984305,
0.1913895905,
0.5160107613,
0.6286937594,
-0.3302378953,
0.1302180439,
0.5645659566,
-0.0994312391,
0.4485598803,
0.3765470684,
0.2709743381,
-0.5435316563,
0.691311717,
0.1298725009,
0.3053931594,
0.8331428766,
-0.1743252277,
-0.136189431,
-0.5140629411,
0.0689411983,
-0.317982465,
-0.6745497584,
-0.8978242874,
-0.6605628133,
-0.3490873277,
-0.3379360437,
-0.450266391,
-0.0141674336,
-0.2958474457,
-0.1946669072,
-0.33882761,
0.995863378,
0.7548583746,
0.0673752353,
0.773626864,
-0.4618113637,
0.3163854182,
0.0555820353,
-0.1592084318,
-0.3021553755,
-0.3050855398,
-0.2015199959,
0.2315661609,
-0.2563765943,
-0.8052523136,
0.4083586633,
0.0527357385,
0.3797856271,
0.2562334836,
0.4167664349,
0.4551663399,
-0.2402248681,
0.7659758925,
0.2447923124,
-0.7162168622,
0.6787434816,
-0.2371921688,
0.0527038388,
0.8073506951,
0.6477633119,
-0.3259263635,
-0.1813220233,
-0.7574175,
-0.8314780593,
0.6599154472,
0.231134668,
-0.1159783527,
-0.3227206767,
0.1066198796,
-0.1417284012,
0.3866909146,
-0.6334118843,
-0.2588955164,
-0.0005668901,
-0.1484491527,
0.3572780192,
0.024261497,
-0.2380401045,
-0.0273339339,
0.5715528131,
-0.2278048694,
0.5927339792,
0.0999664217,
-0.4129363298,
0.0021734633,
0.1155361831,
0.514703691,
0.3941988647,
-0.0962896794,
0.3774701059,
0.5556120276,
-0.7098795176,
-0.1921295226,
0.1788072437,
-0.1703033894,
0.0981957018,
0.7611516118,
0.5859901309,
0.6052597761,
-0.5122024417,
0.6113097668,
0.1355458796,
0.065907307,
-0.7090126872,
-0.0632175058,
-0.4500763416,
0.1114976034,
0.5292075276,
0.1991880238,
0.301854223,
-0.4807301164,
0.5615664721,
0.3181906641,
-0.5685427785,
-0.4011010826,
0.5464751124,
0.0619097278,
-0.2476190776,
0.717343986,
-0.1336418539,
-0.8313798308,
0.5817600489,
0.4057195485,
0.7687159181,
-0.1424204707,
0.1659043729,
0.3420365453,
0.703989923,
0.3025460541,
0.0419037752,
-0.0150139304,
-0.3694937527,
-0.1730354875,
-0.4425116777,
-0.1198453084,
0.1860676259,
-0.5550290942,
0.6579646468,
-0.8653464913,
-0.3452391326,
0.531421423,
-0.0158059169,
-0.8040056229,
0.164317444,
0.3012872338,
0.9954742789,
-0.7390446067,
0.4386044741,
0.6338275075,
-0.5065877438,
-0.5002158284,
-0.1976339072,
0.5156589746,
-0.4598928988,
0.8087132573,
0.2442217916,
0.0668687448,
-0.3418869078,
-0.6038400531,
-0.701790452,
1.0203318596,
0.1642846316,
-0.3120066524,
0.0150442189,
0.5096254945,
0.5269411206,
-0.7715246677,
0.3806331456,
0.4689673781,
0.5974590778,
-0.1271199882,
-0.8788715601,
-0.0136305979,
-0.1490626037,
-0.5491140485,
0.610157907,
-0.2526452839,
0.7067682147,
-0.043598488,
-0.1330423206,
-0.3955676854,
0.5072988868,
-0.2827924788,
0.5541836023,
0.394344002,
0.3861345053,
0.4342933595,
-0.1248058528,
0.9592399597,
-0.1781472266,
-0.051177185,
1.346683383,
-0.0101220822,
0.8250493407,
0.1852575541,
0.2432617992,
0.4856949151,
0.503785491,
-0.2510842383,
0.5019898415,
0.0007289361,
-0.3148171008,
-0.1178574786,
-0.6256992221,
-0.0512510836,
0.4771358371,
0.4903808832,
-0.442379266,
-0.3431258202,
0.0713641644,
0.2448019683,
0.0467736572,
-0.2612756491,
1.1236341,
0.0173509195,
-0.2183917016,
0.1481997073,
-0.1980220377,
0.6705662012,
-0.6760357618,
-0.0247848071,
0.3489411771,
-0.1488649994,
-0.4607329965,
-0.6735289097,
0.4950467348,
0.2443857789,
-0.0216959585,
0.1372693032,
0.9146701097,
-0.3491347432,
-0.3763515651,
0.2304157317,
-0.0442112312,
-0.0009253334,
-0.002003399,
-0.5306514502,
0.0234412439,
-0.1023095027,
0.0970775336,
0.1746944338,
0.3261472285,
-0.2499263883,
0.5348202586,
0.7100002766,
-0.0112489257,
-0.1201464906,
-0.3837921917,
1.0717409849,
-0.2603481114,
-0.4812045693,
-0.8667237759,
0.6116368175,
-0.5853184462,
-0.6594051719,
0.4772824943,
0.6000220776,
0.847271502,
0.252158314,
0.7558863163,
-0.2780798376,
0.4046251774,
-0.301649332,
0.4497433305,
-0.0196108706,
0.4420309961,
-0.3442662656,
-0.7727313638,
-0.2274319679,
0.4110126495,
-0.4394220412,
-0.3148818016,
0.6512879729,
0.5867031217,
-0.0722787008,
0.2982088625,
-0.0644581169,
0.0616511479,
0.1290339231,
0.261685133,
0.632001102,
-0.4435393512,
0.5385813713,
-0.5040318966,
-0.0007866997,
-0.4113749266,
-1.0269200802,
-1.0564768314,
-0.5448306203,
-0.6607560515,
0.0764978155,
0.2847391367,
1.2039377689,
0.6352477074,
-0.8385630846,
0.312504977,
0.1393406689,
-0.1699055582,
-0.0471080355,
-0.2084274441,
0.1818136722,
-0.341809839,
-0.0315651558,
0.2370917201,
0.182342425,
0.0676167607,
-0.0035339147,
0.3843011558,
-0.547988236,
0.0501053333,
0.5313199759,
0.1128355861,
-0.3340125382,
-0.5837248564,
0.1180566177,
-0.0409219339,
-0.1162451655,
0.833753109,
-0.7206014395,
0.3370001614,
0.3429295123,
0.7934525013,
0.0404172018,
-0.0763937309,
0.4236827195,
-1.1034474373,
0.1143542826,
0.5069749355,
0.1290263236,
0.4958363175,
-0.801247716,
0.7312881351,
-0.0078787301,
-0.1328131258,
-0.7620543838,
-0.1507021487,
-0.9269465208,
-0.2268347442,
0.7871505618,
0.0164690465,
-0.1762383878,
-0.3435061276,
-0.1091278419,
0.2334816754,
-0.5486413836,
0.6585874557,
0.4704278708,
0.1153404787,
0.130341962,
-0.8791893125,
0.7682042122,
-0.3551698029,
-1.1898441315,
0.2377438396,
0.4473908246,
-0.0670184046,
0.6538940668,
0.1330265105,
0.091756247,
0.3098720312,
-0.0074921432,
-0.1962997168,
-0.2015784681,
-0.7714613676,
0.0898292288,
0.0727872923,
-0.3028073609,
-0.1127133816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07738v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07738v1
|
ResearchAgent: Iterative Research Idea Generation over Scientific Literature with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-11T13:36:29 | 2024-04-11T13:36:29 |
Jinheon Baek, Sujay Kumar Jauhar, Silviu Cucerzan, Sung Ju Hwang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Scientific Research, vital for improving human life, is hindered by its
inherent complexity, slow pace, and the need for specialized experts. To
enhance its productivity, we propose a ResearchAgent, a large language
model-powered research idea writing agent, which automatically generates
problems, methods, and experiment designs while iteratively refining them based
on scientific literature. Specifically, starting with a core paper as the
primary focus to generate ideas, our ResearchAgent is augmented not only with
relevant publications through connecting information over an academic graph but
also entities retrieved from an entity-centric knowledge store based on their
underlying concepts, mined and shared across numerous papers. In addition,
mirroring the human approach to iteratively improving ideas with peer
discussions, we leverage multiple ReviewingAgents that provide reviews and
feedback iteratively. Further, they are instantiated with human
preference-aligned large language models whose criteria for evaluation are
derived from actual human judgments. We experimentally validate our
ResearchAgent on scientific publications across multiple disciplines,
showcasing its effectiveness in generating novel, clear, and valid research
ideas based on human and model-based evaluation results.
|
[
-0.1829611361,
-0.5749592185,
0.7133776546,
0.2056442946,
-0.1669335514,
0.4341079593,
-0.2112291306,
-0.3303237557,
0.5611714125,
0.445464164,
-0.1274873763,
-0.3099203408,
-0.2359363884,
0.1483008713,
-0.3750249147,
1.1952233315,
-0.0980726257,
-0.0392545573,
-0.2693214715,
0.4230288565,
-0.1652329713,
-0.0489312261,
-0.7835169435,
-0.6159441471,
0.7784553766,
0.5929150581,
0.5440095067,
0.4150596261,
0.6287146807,
0.3967557847,
0.2924931645,
0.1454137117,
-0.455222249,
0.3069129288,
-0.412918061,
-0.3111248016,
-0.4616729617,
-0.1447713077,
0.460290283,
0.3853399456,
-0.1628754884,
0.1909463108,
-0.2571056485,
0.3672281206,
-0.3773162961,
0.1033341065,
-0.6238027215,
0.0353356898,
-0.0683890805,
-0.3901717067,
-0.4058448076,
-0.6212615371,
0.1892264485,
-0.7305150032,
0.4925656021,
0.1594103128,
0.8145055175,
-0.0199470948,
0.0884875581,
-0.3198512793,
-0.8085573912,
0.5554854274,
-0.8200281262,
-0.2701644003,
0.0600609221,
0.2581144869,
-0.266754061,
-0.8820651174,
-0.6620433927,
-0.642642796,
0.0671918914,
0.0395975262,
-0.2307816595,
-0.2163887471,
-0.0209444035,
-0.0460593887,
-0.7286875844,
-0.3089822829,
-0.4560099244,
-0.0030078976,
0.7291967273,
0.1294620335,
0.2140651792,
-0.0051393723,
0.0515824407,
-0.2068062276,
-0.2857623696,
-0.1525371075,
0.3234181404,
0.1038408428,
0.6636526585,
0.6990749836,
-0.0703409463,
0.224472627,
-0.051863838,
0.0648506805,
0.1607601941,
-0.3907900155,
0.1108464897,
0.1890868843,
0.8671369553,
0.1817738414,
-0.0323915519,
-0.4747051895,
-0.309490025,
0.2729695737,
0.6062915325,
-1.0459133387,
-0.3638065755,
0.2347059548,
-0.0657956824,
-0.6780766249,
0.1160262525,
-0.5843895674,
-0.6016147137,
-0.0502758846,
0.4420523047,
-0.4774402976,
-0.7406146526,
0.1481205225,
-0.5572407842,
-0.1236624867,
0.3828623891,
-0.2314003259,
0.3195617199,
0.5479617715,
0.7952592969,
-0.1509863138,
-0.6192852855,
-0.0354838148,
0.180480659,
-0.5508116484,
1.1402542591,
-0.6592018604,
-0.4962441623,
-0.2892785668,
-0.2229221016,
-0.0812037066,
-0.1329734623,
0.5476771593,
-0.6138525009,
0.0478420295,
-0.1240407452,
-0.4110461175,
0.2038889676,
0.2502394617,
-0.8102545142,
0.9290829897,
-0.0378169864,
-1.0765545368,
0.3448932767,
-1.1278370619,
-0.4883005619,
0.3385373652,
-0.148515448,
-0.5971133113,
0.0479078554,
-0.222513631,
0.0211238004,
-0.7193723321,
0.4708405137,
-0.0222681649,
-0.0506396629,
0.4820767045,
0.0477274917,
0.3494126201,
0.4080296159,
-0.4786754251,
0.496361196,
-0.8520976305,
0.1419938356,
0.4901946485,
-0.0475231744,
-0.4355431795,
-0.1360652745,
0.1300504804,
-0.1552788913,
0.0245876051,
-1.1005172729,
0.4481384754,
-0.1730433851,
0.7352412343,
0.4882361591,
0.2874229252,
0.4756796658,
-0.5579500198,
0.6742148995,
-0.3929286003,
-0.2546964288,
-0.0651181862,
-0.3478051126,
-0.6991308928,
-0.0250424054,
0.3387115002,
0.1907451153,
-0.7739349008,
0.157458961,
-0.2161438316,
-0.8599076271,
-0.6768991351,
-0.1231167912,
0.1528016478,
0.5750674009,
0.0377936885,
-0.212278828,
-0.389077574,
-0.6951586008,
-0.3483832777,
-0.1466101408,
0.0989154056,
-0.0523962565,
0.8642976284,
-0.1618728936,
1.1408813,
-0.6112589836,
-0.2431745529,
-0.3666982651,
0.7238827944,
-0.0934591517,
0.5008434057,
0.206110388,
-0.7717305422,
-0.3790060878,
0.2589528263,
-0.5698335767,
-0.1896783412,
0.097953558,
-0.4123931825,
-0.0442934446,
0.2173302472,
-0.9613230228,
0.2983900607,
-0.2856686413,
-0.5378673077,
0.7272693515,
-0.278557092,
0.4242250919,
-1.2464990616,
0.4868839085,
-0.155537039,
0.1888178885,
-0.6896303892,
-0.1716954112,
0.000277166,
-0.5308842659,
0.0319215208,
0.6234021187,
-0.36658144,
0.3628294766,
-0.7344138622,
0.0771447644,
0.3938703835,
-0.1333822161,
0.1360097528,
0.7527100444,
0.0973142087,
-0.2007495761,
0.1576835662,
0.0940034017,
-0.1183489338,
0.1771808565,
-0.8345861435,
0.4962340593,
-0.3651872277,
0.2782984376,
-0.7282221317,
-0.3145078719,
-0.0795985684,
-0.4276169837,
0.1629235297,
0.3278454244,
-0.5958382487,
-0.6548571587,
-0.3608568609,
0.2433633357,
0.1358947456,
-0.0459856465,
0.5890128016,
0.2378680706,
-0.6361422539,
-0.5442985296,
-0.4453372061,
0.4711202979,
-0.1058534235,
-0.7447828054,
0.4400791824,
-0.1573967785,
-0.6021131873,
0.7319751978,
0.3573728204,
-0.153606534,
-0.256111294,
0.0402222462,
0.1304942369,
-0.0100760674,
0.4015351534,
-0.0762749687,
-0.1208719313,
0.2068724483,
-0.4458708167,
0.2069970816,
-0.1424265653,
-0.207194984,
0.2178732604,
0.5756446123,
0.5395990014,
-0.3644938767,
0.1617921144,
0.6192566156,
-0.2112828493,
-0.6219800115,
-0.5339156389,
-0.4292710423,
-0.4214865565,
0.5496340394,
-0.5623780489,
-0.7619221807,
0.3125427365,
0.0059543736,
0.4393506646,
0.2879990935,
0.4585452378,
0.1246156618,
0.7953676581,
0.7991767526,
0.1891655028,
0.293533206,
-0.3923880458,
0.3271634877,
-0.4287316799,
0.0025062752,
-0.8213135004,
-0.1194851995,
-0.0941576138,
-0.5413916707,
0.2330380231,
-0.3291917741,
-0.135559991,
0.2121850401,
-0.8975737691,
0.5522134304,
0.6333512664,
-0.0253418218,
0.3991159797,
-0.0089093558,
-0.2323134392,
0.0104183527,
-0.82173419,
-0.7551010251,
0.9679827094,
0.0997867733,
1.0749417543,
-0.1313623786,
0.7254704237,
0.5769749284,
0.6076160669,
-0.7193073034,
0.3973203599,
0.4593643844,
-0.6736797094,
-0.2509635985,
-0.2445851862,
-0.9605892301,
0.256469965,
0.0928159282,
-0.5139558315,
0.1166337579,
0.1119994819,
-0.2211497426,
0.2312528044,
-0.5573680997,
0.7041569948,
-0.3356797993,
-0.7354956865,
-0.4080865383,
-0.2988416255,
0.3292169571,
-0.1655338854,
0.0279396325,
0.1100379452,
0.1691787988,
0.8781635761,
-0.5909904242,
0.6746972203,
-0.1939509362,
-0.0178387538,
0.7481437922,
0.3352709115,
0.6082599163,
-0.0077078259,
-0.2596996427,
-0.3785560429,
-0.1418821961,
-0.2837466598,
-0.3540967405,
0.7464305758,
-0.9280685186,
-0.7244539857,
-0.4609553814,
-0.9224478602,
0.0010053819,
0.2738778889,
0.3092443347,
0.1562647969,
-0.3901264966,
-0.0804640353,
0.3830958009,
0.0439059623,
0.2877705395,
0.6403526068,
-0.1876727045,
-0.4414976835,
1.102571249,
0.1386021823,
0.0828151479,
0.324227035,
0.3366958201,
-0.0753959045,
-0.5282443166,
-0.3740803003,
0.2428385466,
-0.7314359546,
-0.1480873525,
-0.7956516743,
-0.1601900756,
-0.4251259267,
-0.251870513,
-0.4382879436,
-0.507671535,
-0.1170915067,
-0.0623872727,
0.5266457796,
1.1114490032,
-0.060047064,
-0.0105051324,
-0.5360196233,
0.0970367789,
0.2956487834,
-0.0436200686,
0.1987446845,
-0.3737756908,
-0.3116315007,
-0.2231333554,
-0.4861190617,
-0.7075825334,
0.6590108275,
0.0991205052,
0.4193180501,
0.2438832223,
0.0294453949,
0.332806468,
-0.6727824211,
0.5348898768,
0.1355935484,
-0.4689025879,
0.5671483874,
-0.3826974034,
0.1447875202,
0.699056983,
0.2959398031,
-0.2445938587,
-0.4447810054,
-0.5689515471,
-0.7783250213,
0.3186421096,
0.2905719578,
-0.3015595078,
0.1911555082,
0.1250924468,
0.2931081355,
0.4683557451,
-0.5993769169,
0.3899806738,
-0.5339567065,
-0.1137945056,
0.2098324597,
0.0127564138,
-0.5454258323,
-0.0923606902,
0.9521521926,
-0.3441330791,
0.4430691302,
0.4944025874,
-0.1492480338,
-0.5478096604,
0.6016107202,
0.6311393976,
1.1201037169,
-0.1828570366,
0.3190510571,
-0.3454858959,
-0.5379545093,
0.3996727765,
0.5805248022,
-0.5590961576,
0.0357690789,
0.0888049379,
0.552490592,
-0.2048939019,
-0.6640358567,
0.1471511573,
-0.4273523986,
-0.4542284012,
-0.3299940526,
0.0774004385,
0.4122288227,
0.2685079873,
0.6664093137,
0.2533762455,
0.1772890091,
-0.3582161367,
0.091898486,
0.4235611856,
-0.2097848058,
-0.5697673559,
0.5864994526,
0.2198318392,
-0.5702455044,
0.0639960319,
-0.5178965926,
-0.4700887799,
0.9177557826,
0.843670547,
1.1458125114,
0.1373081952,
0.557048738,
0.1373961717,
0.4918744266,
0.0144140217,
0.4147482812,
0.1269744486,
-0.7042952776,
-0.4808756411,
-0.7272852063,
-0.4821558595,
0.2527775764,
-0.1207078397,
0.1153822839,
-0.2026065737,
-0.3498141468,
0.3592907488,
0.1298729926,
-0.5722224116,
-0.3536653519,
-0.3752619624,
0.816647172,
-0.7213662863,
0.8275197744,
1.2306351662,
-0.636172235,
-0.9059494138,
-0.2835548818,
-0.151611194,
-0.3072537184,
0.6525048018,
-0.0229216367,
-0.359661907,
0.2449249923,
-0.5390565395,
-0.8879819512,
1.2582962513,
0.1283112466,
-0.5457535386,
-0.0917420834,
0.0487614162,
0.7187424898,
-0.7561463714,
0.3444343209,
0.2615767121,
0.7129212618,
0.1962052882,
-0.7986693382,
0.0298270453,
-0.8719406724,
-0.2191335857,
0.080811657,
-0.538843751,
0.8267896771,
-0.5293101668,
0.0736135319,
0.2245913297,
0.4392946661,
0.4778713286,
0.371342212,
0.2695571184,
0.567240715,
0.781252861,
0.3490998447,
0.8689754605,
-0.2726283073,
0.1136026308,
1.1155067682,
-0.5780118704,
0.3583351374,
0.3631807268,
0.1835523993,
0.4068317115,
0.3217380047,
-0.148351863,
0.3801718652,
0.2454635054,
-0.3376214504,
0.0066094962,
-0.5395814776,
-0.2425888032,
0.1432618499,
0.2124182284,
-0.4067239463,
-0.2436438352,
0.3422342837,
0.2474747002,
0.2648996711,
-0.0853045061,
0.5996038914,
0.0303308833,
-0.8999475241,
0.2786414027,
-0.1378899068,
0.2809333503,
-0.7079731822,
-0.1677114069,
0.1464817077,
0.2908104658,
-0.1042415872,
-0.6437469125,
-0.2083936036,
0.1370839179,
-0.3046764135,
0.0220513865,
1.2714965343,
-0.3733851314,
-0.6498839259,
0.0242820736,
0.69815588,
0.085277006,
0.0910708532,
-0.6908636689,
0.0707828701,
-0.2740543783,
-0.616953671,
-0.0138641857,
0.6854614019,
-0.22525841,
0.6895704865,
0.5063564777,
0.5856097937,
-0.1412252933,
0.2803722322,
1.13859272,
-0.7772243619,
-0.5008246303,
-0.5271523595,
0.3763993382,
-0.4236353636,
-0.259521991,
0.7035055161,
0.3768088222,
0.3478297591,
-0.1479247212,
1.3754888773,
-0.2686029971,
0.499946475,
0.270488441,
0.9092763662,
-0.145813778,
-0.0367228761,
-0.3778378069,
-0.8506957889,
-0.0918269083,
0.6420408487,
-0.2937699854,
0.0001713196,
1.013900876,
0.7443550825,
0.0778608993,
0.0612667352,
0.0036415081,
0.3189088404,
0.8005413413,
0.0937687308,
0.9434566498,
0.0712223724,
0.550134778,
-0.2424757779,
-0.361099422,
-0.0345878415,
-0.8088070154,
-1.0293639898,
-0.4246858656,
-0.196749568,
-0.3066853285,
0.178486228,
0.9445642829,
0.5443308949,
-0.5259509087,
-0.4417414963,
-0.5727413893,
-0.1776134521,
-0.0864658579,
-0.3514755666,
0.4189899564,
-0.4854578078,
-0.4568252563,
0.3710567951,
0.19389835,
-0.4092739224,
-0.657063663,
-0.0711943209,
-0.3247454762,
0.3091646731,
0.4643617868,
0.3579798341,
-0.3515014052,
-0.1022839695,
0.1872724295,
-0.1902203262,
-0.1930813789,
1.214614749,
-0.6275674105,
0.7319573164,
0.495718956,
0.8296127915,
0.6994791031,
-0.0713895783,
0.7209894061,
-0.3614507318,
0.1298282444,
0.8103479743,
0.193893075,
0.4544517696,
-0.3018800616,
0.5745245218,
0.1618183255,
-1.0325707197,
-0.8595454097,
0.1274117678,
-0.6718036532,
-0.4515934885,
1.0724585056,
0.0269369353,
-0.6484036446,
-0.1080777198,
-0.5717899203,
0.1368686855,
-0.8490555286,
1.0898054838,
0.4701586664,
-0.2688871622,
0.0027330983,
-0.420119673,
0.5497107506,
0.3556344807,
-0.9990270734,
0.0667256713,
0.3534923196,
0.2256516814,
0.6902452111,
0.8048791289,
0.0667021126,
0.3523308039,
0.3380248547,
0.8344815969,
-0.1825409681,
-0.3040485084,
0.3930698931,
0.4985414445,
0.5313211083,
0.3371142447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07720v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07720v2
|
Automatic Generation and Evaluation of Reading Comprehension Test Items with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-11T13:11:21 | 2024-05-20T19:08:00 |
Andreas Säuberli, Simon Clematide
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Reading comprehension tests are used in a variety of applications, reaching
from education to assessing the comprehensibility of simplified texts. However,
creating such tests manually and ensuring their quality is difficult and
time-consuming. In this paper, we explore how large language models (LLMs) can
be used to generate and evaluate multiple-choice reading comprehension items.
To this end, we compiled a dataset of German reading comprehension items and
developed a new protocol for human and automatic evaluation, including a metric
we call text informativity, which is based on guessability and answerability.
We then used this protocol and the dataset to evaluate the quality of items
generated by Llama 2 and GPT-4. Our results suggest that both models are
capable of generating items of acceptable quality in a zero-shot setting, but
GPT-4 clearly outperforms Llama 2. We also show that LLMs can be used for
automatic evaluation by eliciting item reponses from them. In this scenario,
evaluation results with GPT-4 were the most similar to human annotators.
Overall, zero-shot generation with LLMs is a promising approach for generating
and evaluating reading comprehension test items, in particular for languages
without large amounts of available data.
|
[
-0.4130364358,
-0.7832401395,
0.7888774872,
-0.083087638,
-0.338857621,
-0.2521820962,
-0.0568889529,
-0.618662715,
-0.165250957,
0.3548397124,
-0.4610289931,
-0.2447972149,
-0.4976249933,
0.6119645834,
-0.5320120454,
0.9937896729,
-0.3938613534,
-0.130917415,
-0.2748830318,
-0.0726463944,
-0.3686026335,
-0.296538204,
-0.501211226,
-0.6090769768,
0.5913992524,
0.4446609616,
0.6368124485,
0.682952702,
0.5649405122,
0.2836344242,
0.1198622584,
0.0675740242,
-0.2813647687,
0.2649486959,
-0.0800271109,
-0.3890999258,
-0.3278500736,
0.1557918042,
0.6960374117,
0.3980165124,
0.0019324111,
0.4256079495,
0.0726634786,
0.492308557,
-0.3646008074,
0.0871117637,
-0.525375843,
0.1244132221,
0.053405907,
-0.2951886654,
-0.5034972429,
-0.3368533552,
0.3119645417,
-0.5432064533,
0.2148652077,
0.1655275077,
0.9084263444,
0.3101090789,
-0.5138265491,
-0.6393045187,
-0.4827333093,
0.6474326849,
-0.7596572042,
0.3289774358,
0.6266428828,
0.3495189548,
0.146370098,
-0.5622792244,
-0.8682019114,
-0.5460852981,
0.0772100389,
0.2415782809,
-0.0777285546,
-0.2263351232,
0.2694567144,
0.225438565,
-0.8457422256,
0.0798419565,
-0.2493569106,
0.010132934,
0.7260267138,
0.2485236526,
0.2618256211,
-0.3759274781,
-0.2544476986,
-0.2216087133,
-0.6835268736,
-0.106658265,
0.4850915968,
-0.0247877184,
0.1532991529,
0.94485569,
-0.3330851793,
0.9003475904,
-0.025088165,
-0.304204911,
0.31354478,
-0.6417541504,
-0.2660194039,
-0.2387970686,
0.7044579983,
0.3915456235,
0.4223662913,
-0.1222305,
-0.4437758327,
-0.0675881803,
0.118370153,
-0.864392817,
-0.0489725359,
0.3275262117,
-0.4404043555,
-0.4646847248,
-0.1263483316,
-0.4568147361,
-0.189929679,
-0.2965028286,
0.6438777447,
-0.4701622725,
0.0566401221,
0.2622043192,
-0.0915394723,
0.4777862728,
0.1693969816,
-0.8256873488,
-0.0458282866,
0.2567981184,
0.7890930772,
-0.2281111479,
-0.4974951744,
-0.6221713424,
0.15118137,
-0.4133621752,
1.1570409536,
-0.4471351206,
-0.2399920225,
-0.0626530424,
-0.1877244115,
-0.0269837081,
-0.3616660833,
0.4507674575,
-0.7030616999,
0.4281135201,
-0.2736823857,
-0.8018918633,
-0.1737032533,
0.5690993667,
-0.6393201351,
0.9691733718,
0.2806711197,
-0.7543811798,
0.5006730556,
-0.7487367392,
-0.4808465838,
0.2837213278,
0.0588752814,
-0.3778244257,
-0.0838969126,
0.349532038,
0.5463138223,
-0.4499177039,
0.1107624844,
-0.3959332705,
-0.5848664045,
0.4837303758,
-0.6708328128,
0.4751618803,
0.0068289912,
-0.3142483234,
-0.0790868625,
-0.5373567343,
0.1850851774,
0.2856748998,
-0.5643735528,
0.01028038,
-0.1042758599,
-0.132006824,
0.2546780109,
0.2178373486,
-0.5373973846,
0.0650799274,
-0.369078666,
0.3792586923,
0.6910483241,
0.315838486,
0.361956805,
-0.6218155622,
0.7354635596,
-0.2004818469,
0.1830859631,
-0.3978497684,
-0.4788585603,
-0.8553689122,
0.0154577065,
0.3424153924,
0.7530019879,
-0.9605346322,
0.5602096915,
-0.0706838667,
-0.6871634126,
-0.300096184,
0.1340999305,
0.2608108521,
0.5820112228,
-0.0070031364,
-0.070012413,
0.0796765983,
-0.6278702617,
-0.0637478083,
-0.3809633255,
-0.2259948552,
0.3772878647,
0.6719566584,
-0.2626133561,
0.6976466775,
-0.5271117091,
-0.0363096334,
-0.1122164801,
-0.0215190165,
0.1026783958,
0.0346660614,
0.5659484863,
-0.365332067,
-0.3217306137,
-0.0697937831,
-0.7490116954,
-0.3278921545,
-0.0337175094,
-0.1249651536,
0.2772942781,
0.1957554072,
-0.4540389478,
0.1135106981,
0.5313077569,
-0.4814653099,
0.8769578338,
-0.164259389,
0.1732160151,
-0.9999831319,
0.053489577,
0.0443669073,
-0.2905996442,
-0.4683459699,
0.2135054916,
0.1541609466,
-0.0558720715,
-0.4890092909,
0.8576359749,
-0.3567757308,
-0.1719910949,
-0.1830613762,
0.3359244168,
0.2204015702,
0.1447492391,
-0.0096975239,
0.7100415826,
0.4511378706,
-0.5536975861,
0.4308823943,
0.3217174411,
-0.533385098,
0.700551033,
-0.7531297803,
0.1181673855,
-0.2817800045,
0.2967228591,
-1.0111819506,
-0.4013174176,
0.2834748328,
-0.3760397434,
0.024381306,
0.2278830558,
-0.7586789727,
-0.4496478736,
-0.2725717127,
0.316742152,
0.4956952035,
-0.4498669207,
0.2210171521,
0.0824551806,
-0.4544002116,
-0.4581949711,
-0.7504596114,
-0.0940633416,
-0.2284095585,
-0.6346193552,
-0.2294389755,
-0.5462466478,
-0.1333803684,
-0.1193389073,
0.0517571568,
-0.0488387868,
0.0531315841,
0.0004077029,
0.4105775058,
-0.1395776123,
0.2689188421,
0.2705466449,
-0.2418293208,
-0.1470353305,
-0.1919120401,
0.4235661626,
-0.1751846224,
-0.7606359124,
-0.3715668917,
0.3312467337,
0.2973341942,
-0.3066879213,
0.2823911607,
0.5727683902,
-0.2282238901,
-0.2600781024,
-0.6254262924,
-0.3627399802,
-0.4900656641,
0.2364633232,
-0.4351506233,
-0.9024156928,
0.3184767365,
0.3332628906,
0.2479626685,
0.4179255664,
0.7335788608,
-0.2128831595,
1.0038958788,
0.2362262309,
0.1546617746,
0.2748437524,
-0.0515522398,
0.1411298662,
-0.6603043675,
0.0323512591,
-0.4707465768,
-0.0701315403,
-0.162238881,
-0.3859468102,
0.3862511218,
-0.0038961431,
-0.3148019612,
0.1217533648,
-0.5396306515,
0.6872202754,
0.5616717935,
0.0082660951,
0.6903503537,
0.1971214563,
-0.14344199,
0.2413937896,
-0.5016806722,
-0.9536405206,
1.3169080019,
0.3644230068,
0.4596512318,
-0.0160203576,
0.7397688627,
0.2742866278,
0.5343622565,
-1.0796422958,
0.4728137255,
0.1476507038,
-0.4751549959,
-0.603043735,
-0.3760506511,
-0.9461145997,
0.2685805261,
0.0335625596,
-0.5225259066,
-0.0722581968,
-0.0734611228,
-0.4386435449,
-0.0472378321,
-0.8031209707,
0.6298800111,
-0.213071987,
0.1588515341,
0.2255511433,
-0.3559480906,
0.4698644876,
-0.5726991296,
-0.0266758222,
-0.2793157697,
-0.2615590096,
0.6976319551,
-0.0683908314,
0.4743331373,
0.0843540654,
-0.3422363102,
0.4789976478,
0.337143451,
0.3844240606,
0.2273928225,
-0.546110332,
0.0649703294,
0.2968328297,
-0.4009914994,
-0.4457929432,
0.4284092486,
-0.7662674785,
-0.4072402716,
-0.5050674677,
-0.6724963784,
-0.2091932446,
0.4955390692,
0.2871190012,
0.4338011146,
-0.0980376825,
-0.096630916,
0.4494871497,
-0.1809718311,
0.6524759531,
0.8596266508,
0.017559424,
-0.2824772,
0.8737894297,
0.1629011333,
0.4212089777,
0.1196608618,
0.1398236603,
-0.5444609523,
-0.6682732701,
-0.7491781712,
0.3067546189,
-0.736661315,
-0.2414923161,
-0.3163517416,
-0.2164499611,
-0.1198161542,
-0.2308453918,
0.145636797,
-0.1617790908,
-0.3391631246,
-0.2504580915,
0.1463172734,
0.975178957,
-0.0229035635,
0.2841931581,
-0.8025218248,
0.3116608262,
0.3481810391,
0.312930882,
0.0360970236,
-0.5823762417,
-0.0958114862,
-0.1175391451,
-0.3702618182,
-0.9876096249,
0.2432373613,
0.013558751,
0.31733796,
0.4726187289,
0.0349496119,
0.2778697014,
-0.6408954859,
0.8946425915,
-0.0130451377,
-0.9040910006,
0.1730588078,
-0.4452755749,
0.4360414743,
0.4856606126,
0.1369710863,
-0.5289068818,
-0.46460253,
-0.4948605299,
-0.564874649,
0.6522820592,
0.2494116277,
0.1772243232,
-0.0724945664,
0.3627306521,
0.3325729072,
0.0848591253,
-0.7784909606,
0.0269661844,
-0.0520801842,
-0.2322338372,
-0.2402535677,
-0.3704728782,
-0.0710120499,
0.0601309314,
0.6498271823,
-0.2146260887,
0.2252286971,
0.2334980518,
-0.0844718739,
-0.1106368974,
0.2743361294,
0.415576309,
0.7944487929,
0.0655050352,
-0.0434478745,
0.2515195012,
-0.3439371586,
0.5029714704,
0.1597108394,
-0.5088295937,
-0.1031254157,
0.5275355577,
0.7390531301,
-0.2341642082,
-0.8496358395,
0.5603545308,
-0.1226762086,
-0.4047980309,
-0.370326072,
0.0743263885,
0.1035438627,
0.2978316247,
0.2483032048,
-0.3997825086,
0.0950855315,
-0.2156497985,
0.3462965786,
0.2771478891,
-0.0726577863,
-0.0378633179,
0.4242045581,
0.1397153437,
-0.1751121283,
0.5802263021,
-0.5459122062,
-0.1180797145,
0.5199858546,
0.6536699533,
0.5773432851,
-0.2438715398,
0.6484194994,
0.2091085762,
0.6172923446,
-0.0403633602,
0.44761765,
-0.0453033634,
-0.8181542754,
-0.6267977953,
-0.7867854238,
-0.5358718634,
0.24123092,
-0.4944169819,
0.0311032273,
-0.0829045922,
-0.0276206248,
-0.1227168441,
0.0909978822,
-0.8416627049,
0.2653222084,
0.0194650721,
0.8018438816,
-0.9421200156,
0.6487969756,
0.6037717462,
-0.4822766781,
-0.8963277936,
0.227296859,
-0.2441033274,
-0.8508254886,
0.3064385653,
0.1965190768,
0.2243739665,
0.0584117286,
-0.1762023419,
-0.9782284498,
1.0680239201,
0.4038690925,
-0.5375887752,
-0.1359445453,
0.3301424086,
0.4992416203,
-0.0908577442,
0.6231759191,
0.7838452458,
0.7803894877,
0.0284159835,
-0.7995852828,
0.085291788,
-0.1463621408,
-0.0828469098,
0.0487745255,
-0.4749643207,
0.6290076971,
-0.1143931448,
-0.1012077183,
0.1851948053,
0.3525423706,
0.5769449472,
0.2452085167,
0.4982343018,
0.5667357445,
0.8855700493,
0.0452726632,
1.3211779594,
-0.1252185553,
0.2929910719,
0.9855145216,
-0.5471401811,
0.9921961427,
0.2108855546,
-0.0466991812,
0.2951305509,
0.8844631314,
-0.1840843409,
0.1751340777,
0.240591526,
-0.2374858558,
-0.2411971092,
0.099591516,
-0.1675540209,
0.4832210839,
0.0440063067,
-0.3387328088,
-0.3853752911,
0.0896306559,
-0.0586462207,
-0.3395476937,
-0.0635737106,
0.8638081551,
0.0190500002,
-0.809135139,
0.6779366136,
0.0179909002,
0.3830757737,
-0.4644379616,
0.1773621589,
-0.1691599637,
-0.1152278855,
-0.0205437187,
-1.2095832825,
0.1652366668,
0.2436838299,
-0.1090269089,
-0.0389987417,
0.6793153882,
-0.3736362755,
-0.7263140082,
0.1122503951,
0.7762625217,
0.4601536691,
-0.0910771489,
-0.6824460626,
-0.1552980691,
-0.0159431007,
-0.784741044,
0.2427156419,
0.344845444,
0.1763976365,
0.7078153491,
0.7604183555,
0.0998648778,
0.0091120433,
0.162884295,
0.4146939516,
-0.4530386627,
-0.3302274048,
-0.8696778417,
0.4046554565,
0.0662584007,
-0.3170546889,
0.6991205812,
0.3536275625,
0.7471551299,
-0.0563166179,
1.1154776812,
0.1706987321,
0.3776050508,
-0.3823957741,
0.8223429322,
-0.4812405109,
-0.0346235111,
-0.2684334219,
-1.1835899353,
-0.2684726715,
0.4719150662,
-0.2627389729,
0.1068485975,
0.8821357489,
0.6047516465,
-0.0365280174,
-0.0002100072,
0.3827491999,
0.0354122408,
0.290407002,
0.6145697236,
0.762301743,
-0.3911549449,
0.7543761134,
0.0324781127,
-0.3915082514,
-0.036480546,
-0.9616695642,
-0.9992977381,
-0.7046704888,
-0.1111593768,
-0.2635855675,
-0.1388644874,
0.4772684872,
0.4981927574,
-0.463473171,
-0.1321432143,
0.0714367926,
0.0657041371,
0.0565767586,
-0.2215113044,
0.3906976283,
-0.3286789358,
-0.7966096997,
0.3645879328,
0.2676335573,
0.2951864004,
-0.4290399849,
-0.0453852415,
0.1672904193,
0.3797329366,
0.794382453,
0.0052037588,
-0.6193900108,
-0.4315662682,
0.0290122721,
0.0717132464,
-0.1754032075,
0.3746943772,
-0.5789472461,
0.4617056251,
0.6927081347,
0.6682927608,
0.4265535772,
0.0772340223,
0.4578957558,
-0.353622973,
-0.1636579782,
0.3426401317,
0.3482870758,
0.3624376953,
-0.2393267304,
0.4823032916,
-0.1759567857,
-0.9161002636,
-0.885907948,
0.3673819304,
-0.7345196009,
-0.0480750799,
1.4666368961,
-0.0960195214,
-0.182319507,
0.0023179748,
-0.323620975,
0.2007976919,
-0.3103231788,
0.7609737515,
0.9436217546,
-0.1582849771,
-0.1038942412,
-0.710352838,
0.2146530747,
0.3612073362,
-1.1965370178,
-0.0842703134,
0.55887115,
0.5212925673,
-0.0795422792,
0.6229464412,
-0.0232695509,
0.3541088998,
-0.1206976771,
-0.002519035,
-0.0794913992,
-0.224439621,
-0.2306300253,
0.1613176018,
0.0807549208,
-0.0454199575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07677v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07677v2
|
ODA: Observation-Driven Agent for integrating LLMs and Knowledge Graphs
| 2024-04-11T12:16:16 | 2024-06-04T07:16:14 |
Lei Sun, Zhengwei Tao, Youdi Li, Hiroshi Arakawa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) and knowledge graphs (KGs)
has achieved remarkable success in various natural language processing tasks.
However, existing methodologies that integrate LLMs and KGs often navigate the
task-solving process solely based on the LLM's analysis of the question,
overlooking the rich cognitive potential inherent in the vast knowledge
encapsulated in KGs. To address this, we introduce Observation-Driven Agent
(ODA), a novel AI agent framework tailored for tasks involving KGs. ODA
incorporates KG reasoning abilities via global observation, which enhances
reasoning capabilities through a cyclical paradigm of observation, action, and
reflection. Confronting the exponential explosion of knowledge during
observation, we innovatively design a recursive observation mechanism.
Subsequently, we integrate the observed knowledge into the action and
reflection modules. Through extensive experiments, ODA demonstrates
state-of-the-art performance on several datasets, notably achieving accuracy
improvements of 12.87% and 8.9%.
|
[
-0.2719565332,
-0.933831811,
1.1065292358,
-0.0151431151,
-0.0474586189,
0.2588977218,
-0.0095180869,
-0.4835346341,
0.3660584986,
0.61485219,
-0.6362899542,
-0.6633706093,
-0.5488812327,
0.0521564037,
-0.1930906475,
0.7085943818,
-0.2453707606,
-0.1578568518,
-0.4267801344,
-0.0706896409,
-0.1932590157,
0.0014615135,
-0.9786537886,
-0.644746244,
0.604426384,
0.2263320982,
0.6665478945,
0.707887888,
0.1348986179,
0.3774481416,
0.2654077113,
0.9422756433,
-0.4157731533,
0.2765741646,
-0.4218535423,
-0.6873645186,
-0.7849909067,
0.0750244409,
0.5329607725,
0.7910710573,
-0.2381447852,
-0.1360530406,
-0.1767112762,
0.5152756572,
-0.634961307,
0.9835935831,
-0.166049853,
0.0485056266,
0.1816882342,
-0.0307622403,
-0.3188352883,
-0.408151418,
0.0806187615,
-0.9833356142,
-0.2794531286,
-0.0445224606,
0.2703090608,
0.5762370229,
-0.4366264343,
-0.4267973602,
-0.7249144316,
0.5821899176,
-0.5679644346,
0.4205672443,
0.169312939,
0.451841563,
-0.4505634606,
-0.9032635689,
-0.8701362014,
-0.1066875309,
-0.0960416645,
0.1627276987,
-0.1854835749,
0.0501335934,
-0.0477077439,
0.0196477063,
-0.3371166587,
0.057535097,
0.0684959441,
0.0030960154,
0.6862874627,
0.5157283545,
0.1349138319,
0.0145538002,
-0.2227104157,
0.2064915001,
-0.3583760262,
-0.1361512095,
0.2721188068,
0.3439129889,
-0.067318514,
0.5229686499,
-0.694306314,
0.8900530934,
-0.1227554008,
-0.1952095032,
0.3243884742,
-0.2253676951,
-0.3361927867,
0.0290768985,
0.7112070322,
0.2321068496,
0.2414126247,
-0.3207397759,
-0.1676428914,
0.3114322722,
0.2897926569,
-0.6163614988,
-0.1345697194,
0.2363262177,
-0.1249632239,
-0.4527004659,
0.0760378167,
-0.6772828698,
-0.9466651082,
-0.3587494493,
0.2829497457,
-0.4163288474,
-0.4253277481,
0.1972477436,
-0.0094113937,
0.1286156625,
0.6067124605,
-0.4452811778,
0.2978926897,
0.8198069334,
0.5405774117,
-0.0790940449,
-0.5721750259,
-0.76505059,
0.2357498556,
-0.544142127,
0.8341271281,
-0.7317438126,
-0.2011825144,
0.049276486,
-0.1747598797,
-0.2389736474,
-0.4049315453,
0.2717783749,
-0.9482272267,
-0.0609385855,
-0.1243432537,
-0.4856459796,
-0.4030659199,
0.5198858976,
-0.4197356105,
1.0021377802,
0.3517743945,
-0.3362150788,
0.5039208531,
-1.141076088,
-0.3591455221,
0.1106163561,
-0.405138284,
0.0138267055,
-0.2141347826,
0.3827649951,
0.300483793,
-0.3144116104,
0.2561022639,
-0.1220817044,
-0.0905249864,
0.126636073,
-0.1685376912,
0.5724918246,
0.3216577768,
-0.2110878676,
0.2608680427,
-0.9137361646,
0.1959910989,
0.2666636109,
-0.4118448198,
-0.2420350164,
0.3367816508,
-0.6364987493,
-0.1811479777,
0.2937394679,
-0.5562700033,
0.6277992725,
-0.3900744319,
0.6303654909,
0.7120053172,
0.1285517961,
0.4307434559,
-0.1887267232,
0.5906813145,
-0.0070422417,
0.1821845621,
-0.1096523777,
-0.5061815381,
-0.7313996553,
-0.2992581725,
-0.1023615301,
0.2089119405,
-1.2315673828,
0.2985214293,
-0.4267439544,
-0.4083332419,
-0.6470285654,
0.1963387579,
0.3453394175,
0.6773976684,
0.1078170463,
-0.1987671256,
-0.373134613,
-0.5643364191,
-0.2324958146,
-0.4337429404,
0.1807376891,
0.4036917984,
0.5059679747,
-0.6000418663,
1.2965004444,
-0.8571642637,
-0.3618255854,
-0.3983704746,
0.2618386149,
0.3374631405,
0.1787311733,
0.4682876468,
-0.7447535992,
-0.5046064258,
0.2804694176,
-1.1925477982,
-0.2960478961,
0.1526105255,
-0.1900915205,
0.4458188713,
0.6845911145,
-0.64276582,
0.4404987991,
0.232515648,
-0.4580455124,
0.3180740476,
-0.2035708278,
-0.0022121994,
-0.8282018304,
-0.1216358691,
-0.3607582152,
-0.4364381135,
-0.7260603309,
0.2649004459,
-0.1760766059,
0.2455597073,
-0.2394486666,
0.6064938903,
-0.3772602975,
-0.371625185,
-0.433396697,
0.4722533226,
0.0579932556,
0.6233215332,
0.053635817,
0.5887051821,
0.5571048856,
-0.6786185503,
0.770678997,
0.2422459573,
-0.6195967197,
0.7092524171,
-0.2499510646,
0.4483822286,
-0.4129647613,
0.0300897043,
-0.6032032967,
-0.3241921961,
0.6186795831,
-0.5141863823,
0.0949528888,
0.0697876364,
-0.5712637901,
-0.1512796581,
-0.1599434316,
0.2232012302,
0.1627116799,
-0.70368433,
1.2936987877,
0.1154095903,
0.0737653375,
-0.5981844664,
-0.489612788,
-0.0747468397,
0.3016193807,
-0.5637859702,
-0.0719266534,
0.1531020105,
-0.6063916087,
0.497492522,
-0.0727935955,
0.2636830509,
-0.006300116,
0.1811689585,
0.0446548723,
-0.2729468346,
0.1204364374,
-0.1250203103,
-0.1670838147,
0.1827530414,
-0.7085869312,
0.6960701942,
-0.0092801834,
-0.6790469289,
-0.3256162703,
0.0981188864,
0.7513484359,
-0.2388246506,
0.8728861213,
0.1498793215,
-0.2791911364,
-0.6487217546,
-0.3411227763,
0.1677920967,
-0.4792656004,
0.4895391762,
-0.3343774974,
-0.3176388144,
0.4008194208,
0.0143009359,
0.0104786502,
0.2782258987,
0.2345068902,
-0.2188237309,
1.1247214079,
0.6374002099,
-0.3408251107,
0.5435379744,
-0.4888366461,
0.1636619866,
-0.895830214,
-0.4343771935,
-0.2416862696,
-0.20942761,
-0.2940783501,
-0.5241628885,
0.5361682773,
-0.057490591,
-0.5486313701,
-0.2089410722,
-0.2399027348,
0.3903243244,
0.5612607002,
0.2220738977,
0.6329290271,
-0.4458830953,
0.0790764838,
0.5032951236,
-0.8028407693,
-0.4033839703,
0.9707326889,
0.0211524013,
0.8357682824,
0.0846125111,
0.5169159174,
0.5521059036,
0.5423361063,
-0.758237958,
0.8365385532,
0.2443542182,
-0.2428314537,
-0.5875359178,
-0.4854079187,
-0.8527057767,
0.2655955255,
0.0974140391,
-0.7769499421,
0.1174897999,
0.0083203465,
-0.0782926828,
0.3149383664,
-0.651566565,
0.6683755517,
-0.1475057453,
-0.0571881048,
-0.2404656112,
-0.4026489854,
0.1412079483,
0.0757408366,
0.3167192042,
0.1406027377,
-0.0968693942,
0.4510969222,
-0.749029398,
1.1326402426,
-0.4470973313,
-0.206858024,
0.5570774674,
-0.0477163047,
1.0129086971,
-0.1056264713,
0.0822928697,
-0.1161868349,
-0.3491897881,
-0.2767598629,
-1.0339961052,
0.5900985599,
-0.8634145856,
-0.7086473107,
-0.517326951,
-0.8150455952,
-0.216122061,
0.3457722962,
-0.2477609813,
0.2554024756,
-0.1399196982,
-0.2677614093,
0.3349222243,
0.0295362175,
0.2429062873,
1.09284091,
-0.7061960101,
-0.3597258031,
0.9059028625,
0.0731131583,
0.4713501036,
0.3743848503,
0.0994270667,
-0.2253525108,
-0.5328606963,
-0.3520496786,
0.238732785,
-0.862531364,
-0.0211183969,
-0.6154851317,
-0.1467986405,
-0.479698211,
-0.1020976827,
-0.2245327979,
0.0110906046,
-0.0782660916,
-0.3199906647,
0.4143073261,
1.1107831001,
0.1261194646,
0.124525927,
-0.3488689065,
0.4692312777,
0.4713260233,
0.4107249975,
0.2498591095,
-0.0751135498,
-0.23679775,
-0.0057390109,
-0.1438419372,
-0.6460294127,
0.3243350685,
0.0263945572,
0.7247962356,
0.7490349412,
0.1407999843,
0.4696935117,
-0.2005742192,
0.525760293,
-0.24516581,
-0.8133569956,
0.5390866995,
-0.3435666263,
0.3170206845,
0.1197666898,
0.0735526606,
-0.4769724905,
-0.6696934104,
-0.3433413804,
-0.4484107494,
0.9925329685,
0.0952431336,
-0.4035345018,
0.0241623875,
0.4919474721,
0.0586448163,
0.4955252707,
-0.2153581232,
-0.2853118479,
-0.1057337672,
-0.1304163039,
-0.3250355422,
0.0671690702,
-0.1358167529,
-0.0325736254,
0.58878088,
-0.5060203075,
0.1158096865,
0.4004446566,
-0.1784894019,
-0.0898707286,
0.0093634306,
0.3514950573,
0.6493691206,
-0.0335652269,
0.1990640461,
0.0823156983,
-0.6599909067,
-0.1302420944,
0.1083933562,
-0.4899520874,
-0.410954088,
0.6519056559,
0.6630771756,
0.0392792858,
-0.8087512851,
-0.0288616233,
0.2327085286,
-0.0987024456,
-0.3783985376,
0.336139828,
0.2510602772,
0.9265803695,
0.3230897486,
0.0033170916,
-0.1363695711,
-1.0055636168,
-0.2222993821,
0.4139343202,
-0.2718386352,
-0.3298233151,
0.6823276281,
0.1492649019,
-0.4951239228,
0.7130390406,
-0.4515219629,
-0.6108496785,
0.9662594795,
0.2268725932,
0.7517131567,
-0.0857843757,
0.3046388328,
-0.1524277478,
0.3355995417,
0.1423778683,
0.7964740992,
-0.1532786936,
-1.2925087214,
-0.3341099024,
-0.4538071454,
-0.5953356624,
-0.1982413232,
-0.6455114484,
-0.0852882043,
-0.16320315,
0.1376514882,
0.1005792841,
0.1205807403,
-0.6132582426,
0.2031643391,
-0.1590885222,
0.9293522239,
-0.6090660095,
1.0071183443,
0.8726465106,
-0.4928857982,
-0.5773461461,
-0.1723152548,
-0.1001614034,
-1.1154623032,
0.6752547026,
-0.0476879291,
-0.4652662873,
0.0768987462,
-0.5523739457,
-0.7005919218,
1.4502447844,
0.4486557245,
-0.2070448846,
0.1871058941,
0.205280751,
0.6713262796,
-0.6914857626,
0.0528429821,
0.9213241339,
0.7745366693,
0.0444333926,
-0.5740994811,
-0.0983589962,
-0.0980189815,
-0.3823255002,
0.4372016788,
-0.8111615181,
0.7655645609,
-0.3996795416,
-0.1037757695,
0.0521384254,
0.7646320462,
0.0907728523,
0.7722740769,
0.6976861954,
0.6254980564,
0.9934029579,
0.0629132465,
1.1939018965,
-0.1216511354,
0.0788061991,
1.1699185371,
-0.6878618598,
0.4145442545,
0.3448244929,
-0.2567718029,
0.6468820572,
0.0253218357,
0.1876801997,
0.6318693161,
-0.0383240618,
-0.4213949442,
-0.2363412231,
-0.4070432782,
0.0553563461,
0.367892772,
0.3339477479,
-0.3173229694,
-0.1929714084,
-0.031362094,
0.0512435474,
0.3700911105,
-0.5816817284,
0.8915492892,
-0.1444051117,
-0.8774690032,
0.0784047768,
-0.1236447096,
0.1615223289,
-0.7139422894,
-0.2830587924,
-0.2584350705,
0.333789438,
-0.2250269949,
-0.7486431003,
0.2134345025,
-0.069148846,
-0.2752346992,
-0.2722569406,
0.5572968125,
-0.181168884,
-0.3169520199,
0.5207701325,
0.6601031423,
0.1043733582,
-0.0606615208,
0.0623084344,
-0.0318985879,
-0.1545006484,
-0.3208571672,
0.2589325607,
0.655731976,
-0.1242232099,
0.9980185628,
0.4136072397,
0.0784865916,
-0.1137559116,
0.090760991,
1.1613664627,
-0.5927712917,
-0.5131601095,
-0.688991487,
0.2252109498,
-0.1172771677,
-0.1456421316,
0.5561125875,
0.4987811744,
0.800550282,
0.1460896879,
1.0276949406,
-0.1588695943,
0.526725769,
-0.6441200972,
0.7264301181,
-0.397136271,
0.262403667,
0.0694274083,
-0.7045322657,
0.0999918655,
0.4116583169,
-0.4886730909,
0.0422241054,
0.5685183406,
0.6877582073,
0.246514082,
0.1699743569,
0.2673282027,
0.7169555426,
0.5799201131,
0.5193331242,
0.9225218296,
0.0302862022,
0.5035930276,
-0.0623654202,
-0.2465476245,
0.0188457724,
-0.8662036061,
-0.9533886909,
-0.4050193727,
-0.2995220125,
-0.0349153243,
0.1150152609,
0.8223326206,
0.4142885506,
-0.5617134571,
0.0205139443,
-0.3647434711,
0.4134616256,
-0.5479200482,
-0.269752413,
0.370900929,
-0.3721337318,
-0.9233670235,
0.7758434415,
0.2603858113,
-0.4408921599,
-0.5128096938,
-0.3190663457,
-0.0542439073,
0.2429197431,
0.5851171613,
0.3794408143,
-0.5924216509,
-0.4509927332,
-0.163070038,
0.0748433098,
-0.0095337126,
0.6365267634,
-1.1197544336,
0.7396368384,
0.3956587911,
0.5813730359,
0.6627444029,
-0.0747195706,
0.6979819536,
-0.518114686,
-0.0372503176,
0.209627986,
0.3734128475,
-0.0860674977,
-0.3490143418,
0.8519150615,
0.2472164184,
-0.343039006,
-0.9031737447,
0.3458372653,
-0.8367952704,
-0.1638647914,
0.9030045867,
-0.2204630524,
-0.1899272799,
-0.1984535456,
-0.2658398747,
0.1718951464,
-0.5152376294,
0.8104070425,
0.5293558836,
-0.4454613328,
-0.0709489882,
-0.565824151,
0.1404604763,
-0.0278283786,
-1.0769455433,
-0.0659011751,
0.4221141338,
0.0332416221,
0.3044024706,
0.7589102387,
0.1519753337,
0.1867763102,
0.1569498479,
0.0666331053,
-0.6266277432,
-0.3452156782,
-0.0950658619,
0.3089782,
0.0310656149,
-0.3813880682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07673v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07673v1
|
Curated Datasets and Neural Models for Machine Translation of Informal Registers between Mayan and Spanish Vernaculars
| 2024-04-11T12:09:47 | 2024-04-11T12:09:47 |
Andrés Lou, Juan Antonio Pérez-Ortiz, Felipe Sánchez-Martínez, Víctor M. Sánchez-Cartagena
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The Mayan languages comprise a language family with an ancient history,
millions of speakers, and immense cultural value, that, nevertheless, remains
severely underrepresented in terms of resources and global exposure. In this
paper we develop, curate, and publicly release a set of corpora in several
Mayan languages spoken in Guatemala and Southern Mexico, which we call MayanV.
The datasets are parallel with Spanish, the dominant language of the region,
and are taken from official native sources focused on representing informal,
day-to-day, and non-domain-specific language. As such, and according to our
dialectometric analysis, they differ in register from most other available
resources. Additionally, we present neural machine translation models, trained
on as many resources and Mayan languages as possible, and evaluated exclusively
on our datasets. We observe lexical divergences between the dialects of Spanish
in our resources and the more widespread written standard of Spanish, and that
resources other than the ones we present do not seem to improve translation
performance, indicating that many such resources may not accurately capture
common, real-life language usage. The MayanV dataset is available at
https://github.com/transducens/mayanv.
|
[
-0.1591891348,
-0.2192509621,
0.2748037875,
0.282194078,
-0.2525519729,
0.1725621223,
-0.5643500686,
-0.4725419283,
0.0701378435,
0.4928525388,
-0.4028722644,
-0.7229523659,
-0.6420091391,
0.3455685079,
-0.3225671649,
0.907957077,
-0.0487984344,
0.2411394864,
-0.1493869126,
-0.4250614345,
-0.1100662351,
-0.3778616786,
-0.2593250573,
-0.1503907144,
0.5438959002,
0.0355577618,
0.8408750296,
1.1452902555,
0.3820471168,
0.2953068614,
-0.1953141689,
0.3043660223,
-0.4243784845,
0.1364545375,
-0.16849868,
-0.3281820118,
-0.3637977839,
-0.1357649267,
0.4737091064,
0.9281599522,
0.0493890941,
0.4071799517,
-0.0371872149,
0.1783329993,
-0.6200667024,
0.4881931245,
-0.4260048866,
0.0875288919,
-0.5357412696,
-0.0936873928,
-0.0623627752,
-0.76540941,
0.2185339183,
-0.3134054244,
0.4524135292,
-0.0360449776,
0.5371760726,
0.3431963027,
-0.6025642753,
-0.3314441741,
-0.7349563837,
0.6927930117,
-0.625425756,
0.3075188994,
0.4425162673,
0.1761030108,
-0.2350433171,
-0.6951121688,
-0.3282518387,
-0.3251469135,
-0.0158572663,
0.091384761,
-0.3994372785,
0.0351867527,
-0.2021661103,
0.4706420898,
-0.5195180774,
0.1543531865,
-0.6030459404,
-0.21952492,
0.4906850755,
0.3973638415,
0.1744688898,
-0.1587140709,
-0.1269640177,
-0.1380368769,
-0.8171582222,
-0.1473510861,
0.6447172165,
0.6079319119,
-0.0804240853,
0.7387201786,
-0.1470558941,
0.9911753535,
-0.4302300811,
-0.1869832128,
0.2755385935,
-0.7318425775,
-0.1771748066,
-0.1356869489,
0.7777434587,
0.0718509331,
0.1178418621,
-0.4706231356,
-0.5046923161,
-0.0217828676,
0.1900338978,
-0.4287537932,
-0.1091664061,
-0.0869081989,
-0.4008375406,
-0.2732012272,
-0.0014443597,
-0.5846376419,
-0.4226457775,
-0.6337210536,
-0.0133907143,
-0.0301582459,
-0.3445468843,
0.0573396534,
0.0626374781,
-0.0006455395,
0.2584438622,
-0.605512619,
0.6255191565,
0.6560925245,
1.1452571154,
-0.2506830096,
-0.0585650019,
0.0869672447,
-0.3020466566,
-0.5086346865,
0.4271368086,
-0.3557210863,
-0.3242912889,
0.3211349249,
0.0762901083,
-0.0151240723,
-0.6838139296,
0.2695246935,
-0.6826563478,
-0.026892161,
-0.1733074188,
0.0195424519,
-0.0013066409,
0.0921384543,
-0.8422520757,
1.0446389914,
0.2844073772,
-0.347350657,
0.0755442753,
-0.1663683653,
-0.4263363183,
-0.1931308508,
0.0404024459,
0.038801454,
0.2227216661,
0.0624997728,
0.5601127744,
-0.5239101052,
0.3761620522,
-0.0967091098,
-0.1211403161,
0.3246158659,
-0.4849704802,
0.8164209127,
0.5914032459,
-0.2835980058,
-0.0724983364,
-0.6918409467,
-0.3368338346,
-0.0566050522,
-0.1755502671,
-0.6047475934,
-0.2362580299,
0.3591988385,
0.3764488399,
0.3600324094,
-0.4577531815,
0.3351732194,
-0.3950174749,
0.1464202851,
0.6896274686,
-0.3091808259,
0.6454409361,
-0.2939837575,
0.5300350189,
0.1365717649,
-0.1121954843,
-0.0579236411,
-0.4830701649,
-0.7232614756,
-0.1849990636,
0.3728747964,
0.3343784809,
-0.5215876698,
0.1366921365,
-0.786773324,
-0.3734739125,
-0.7699593902,
0.1604677439,
0.4372641444,
0.5493394732,
0.4246400595,
-0.2533668578,
-0.6398528814,
-0.8313549757,
0.4059851468,
-0.1453751922,
-0.2256305665,
0.4311076105,
0.2805961668,
-0.0309698209,
0.8623912334,
-0.3073581755,
-0.3316011727,
0.0275829677,
0.1409304589,
0.1461259127,
0.4281846881,
0.420147568,
-0.5103501678,
-0.0166508351,
0.4375886917,
-0.5459821224,
-0.3402627707,
-0.1017840877,
0.1751963347,
0.2990513146,
0.532841742,
-0.0662093908,
0.3406613469,
0.7747218609,
-0.0559045486,
0.2502302527,
-0.2031888366,
0.0099115223,
-1.3049141169,
0.3129695952,
-0.1142044812,
-0.2238765061,
-0.4544979036,
0.0103175342,
-0.0582193993,
0.1402234137,
-0.5998183489,
0.7316888571,
-0.6907584071,
-0.1941629499,
-0.1770263016,
-0.0166660938,
-0.1603363901,
0.3243589401,
0.3897524476,
0.8310710788,
0.167368561,
-0.576222837,
0.6531947851,
0.0877534226,
-0.3369172513,
0.0826392546,
-0.6825877428,
0.3453306556,
-0.1328844577,
0.1220193282,
-0.6560764909,
-0.2341103554,
0.4463327825,
-0.2110916227,
0.2763251066,
-0.5041126013,
-0.4497064054,
-0.053242974,
0.0115928799,
0.5150421858,
0.2455343157,
-0.3353073895,
0.2127756774,
0.4184194505,
-0.3305484951,
-0.7911541462,
-0.9681246281,
0.2116044909,
0.1121840253,
-0.735140264,
0.2501442432,
0.362421602,
-0.5157080889,
0.2692389488,
-0.110512875,
-0.2350558937,
-0.1585854292,
0.1994368583,
0.4351311624,
-0.7577975988,
0.1457596719,
0.0211179331,
0.2299733162,
-0.0143648591,
-0.8430719972,
0.4925597906,
-0.3843100965,
-0.177783981,
0.0410972498,
0.1324331909,
0.5336126685,
-0.2186396718,
1.018196702,
0.40840891,
-0.5245414972,
-0.0462297425,
-0.7103337049,
0.0978480577,
-0.3288392723,
0.2580361366,
-0.4524202645,
-0.5364286304,
0.8564833403,
-0.0915297195,
-0.1380368322,
0.3075312674,
0.7642781138,
0.2414846569,
0.4814423919,
0.4048832357,
-0.1386007816,
0.4218485057,
-0.5151708722,
-0.2192294002,
-0.8072014451,
-0.6106209159,
-0.8090426922,
-0.3093398213,
-0.6813154817,
-0.8055868745,
0.1512283832,
-0.4313199818,
0.1066595986,
0.7304646373,
-0.1267476827,
0.5000674725,
0.6448082328,
-0.1710141152,
0.4199132919,
-0.2115862221,
-0.2629683018,
-0.0979162976,
-0.6654467583,
-0.6704276204,
1.1182855368,
0.0083128335,
0.8176407814,
0.2763870358,
0.4544173479,
0.402105391,
0.2022396326,
-0.84734267,
0.1269434988,
-0.1635397673,
-0.3793677688,
-0.049354028,
-0.4786444306,
-1.2478274107,
0.1267434061,
0.0603787787,
-0.3762926161,
0.6993009448,
-0.2088935524,
-0.3343344927,
0.1815863997,
-0.5719996691,
0.9384846091,
-0.0019999424,
-0.3491519988,
0.0373109132,
-0.7287042737,
0.290245384,
0.0181074776,
-0.0474172272,
-0.0082148938,
-0.4761937559,
0.3032705188,
-0.3365823328,
0.9279892445,
0.3971807957,
-0.0161741115,
0.264780283,
0.3754235506,
0.3307286203,
0.0402123258,
-0.2031112313,
0.5293294787,
0.0683646798,
-0.504311204,
-0.4423526525,
0.6059542298,
-1.1369707584,
-0.1960770637,
-0.7188641429,
-0.4811568856,
0.1698280275,
0.0410720967,
0.2963889241,
0.5052037835,
-0.6919972301,
0.0408650562,
0.5156536102,
0.051202815,
0.3087471128,
0.3265147209,
0.1514980197,
-0.2294512242,
0.8239912987,
0.2729263902,
0.1600595564,
0.1517003328,
0.1009314209,
-0.4891607165,
-0.6746537685,
-0.6323607564,
0.0277239271,
-0.7406451702,
-0.3288003206,
-0.6302708983,
-0.0953743383,
-0.7441783547,
-0.1197507158,
-0.5304504633,
-0.6649166346,
-0.3972917497,
-0.049626898,
0.0941227227,
0.9536116123,
-0.0924249291,
0.0908895731,
-0.6343827248,
0.0425248966,
0.1017289087,
-0.022415759,
-0.0327350385,
-0.5771083832,
-0.2172234952,
0.101298824,
0.2402124852,
-0.7863325477,
0.666097343,
0.0834395885,
0.4369160831,
0.4051263928,
0.0722911358,
0.7136478424,
-0.403422147,
0.5060938597,
-0.2086714804,
-0.7126840949,
0.3368269801,
-0.5065445304,
0.3245843947,
0.5140143037,
0.3834729791,
-1.223954916,
-0.5040057898,
-0.4407333732,
-1.0113816261,
0.9266482592,
0.2913038135,
0.5256621838,
-0.2085836679,
0.0610155575,
0.2851174772,
0.2723700702,
-0.4706889689,
-0.2697222531,
-0.4152830243,
-0.2703525126,
0.1348925084,
0.3023000062,
-0.0874133706,
-0.1125394776,
0.4967676699,
-0.0679612979,
0.0341768228,
0.150374651,
-0.4445506632,
0.1760706007,
0.0139196264,
0.624071002,
0.5548185706,
-0.1317371875,
0.5122898817,
0.0658617467,
-0.8176466227,
0.0501405001,
0.1291077584,
-0.4669036865,
0.1410805583,
0.3180482388,
0.726187408,
0.1026575342,
-0.337610811,
0.3912189007,
0.010236782,
0.4658295512,
-0.489141643,
-0.1580263823,
0.1276768744,
0.1240140125,
0.179999426,
0.6429001093,
0.1326546967,
-0.507801652,
-0.2339016497,
-0.1027064696,
-0.2964921892,
-0.5366249681,
0.5602022409,
0.2930178344,
-0.1854677498,
0.7141996622,
-0.3354313672,
-0.2298431098,
0.6725144386,
0.4808509946,
0.8707555532,
0.0384753682,
0.2727904916,
0.5026831627,
0.4267349839,
-0.390699178,
-0.2569815516,
-0.1924307048,
-0.6493157148,
-0.216839835,
-0.6066468954,
-0.3464649022,
0.2385089993,
-0.5751374364,
0.2475811541,
-0.2967250049,
-0.149590984,
-0.2494303435,
-0.0523906238,
-0.8646227121,
-0.1280943602,
0.3156429827,
0.6567950249,
-0.8626651764,
0.8432663679,
0.4774404764,
-0.667073071,
-0.1908283681,
-0.1210215613,
0.2922328413,
-0.7130967975,
0.7978435755,
-0.3876253963,
-0.3279173076,
-0.1242398396,
-0.2756260335,
-1.026501894,
0.9137766957,
0.4827795625,
-0.2902640104,
0.0057692532,
0.3704141378,
0.9172499776,
-0.4204734266,
0.2936505973,
0.4791380167,
0.3315401673,
0.1072928905,
-0.8187214136,
0.0172484163,
-0.4407459199,
0.4415249228,
-0.0203834418,
-0.4209328592,
0.6347622871,
-0.0537051409,
-0.3044005632,
0.2484162599,
0.7449153662,
-0.2175872624,
0.1335467398,
-0.0929822773,
0.0422644913,
0.8837231398,
-0.3407841921,
1.0299171209,
-0.0375206992,
-0.1388354301,
1.326084137,
-0.0616922528,
0.6177791953,
0.4441745281,
0.0141533362,
0.2084565908,
0.7851894498,
-0.1545436978,
0.3441808224,
0.4753289819,
-0.74839288,
-0.0434280187,
-0.591031611,
-0.3848290741,
0.6048662663,
0.2940019071,
-0.5154546499,
-0.0633156821,
-0.173476547,
0.3220693469,
0.1588707864,
-0.2969833612,
0.5636880994,
0.0794838294,
-0.8081601858,
0.4298600256,
0.2853306532,
0.5393883586,
-0.5591455102,
0.2404962927,
-0.6845007539,
0.1481559724,
-0.1303813159,
-0.4640572071,
0.5790727735,
0.1851359159,
-0.0663074031,
-0.3203632534,
0.571495235,
-0.56550771,
-0.460836798,
0.1216970235,
0.9720585942,
0.2059418708,
0.1456060261,
-0.2872947454,
-0.2032175511,
-0.4422504306,
-0.2014969736,
0.1209832355,
0.5754821897,
-0.5521492362,
0.4271569848,
0.7897626758,
0.5832733512,
0.5749272108,
0.3302393258,
0.7939056754,
-0.4224314094,
-0.1789921522,
-0.7123988271,
0.0824643224,
0.0237744115,
-0.6454409361,
0.6283411384,
0.7463132143,
1.2149882317,
-0.2747880816,
0.4748772383,
-0.0364563093,
-0.2668023705,
-0.4308487773,
0.8702808619,
-0.2238020897,
0.2165825367,
-0.0996799916,
-0.9616851807,
-0.5155338049,
0.4824305475,
-0.1206806824,
-0.1769111753,
0.6273280978,
0.9286258221,
-0.3594261408,
-0.2151192725,
0.3293139637,
0.1763724685,
-0.048370067,
0.1891436577,
0.7071712613,
-0.3323742449,
0.9069871902,
-0.4284080863,
0.1290815324,
-0.106044814,
-0.8316937685,
-0.6561840177,
-0.8488587737,
-0.223380819,
-0.5011013746,
0.192006588,
1.3284307718,
0.6066328883,
-0.9177473187,
-0.4917840362,
0.0667115673,
0.2375005037,
-0.2251859158,
-0.1037987545,
0.3945622146,
-0.2943566442,
-1.1110956669,
0.4812799096,
0.2076003551,
0.2892176807,
-0.5002334118,
-0.0629882514,
-0.0494598374,
-0.0858307183,
0.2856506705,
0.432495743,
-0.6439062953,
0.0085828723,
0.6513504982,
-0.6477529407,
0.1609798968,
0.8762812018,
-0.8450117111,
0.6433039308,
0.8059468865,
0.5788211823,
0.5231586695,
-0.2902629972,
0.6872489452,
-1.1150645018,
0.4587994516,
0.5987782478,
0.397660315,
0.5810599327,
-0.0855852813,
0.7273783088,
0.4876465797,
-0.150227204,
-0.5215439796,
-0.0144645842,
-0.7470598221,
0.0459634066,
1.3121132851,
-0.2927086949,
-0.5329448581,
-0.7700334191,
-0.065055497,
0.6385547519,
-0.3278155625,
0.9024448395,
0.7100153565,
0.4481550455,
0.2555119693,
-0.4970164001,
0.52161479,
-0.0328977518,
-0.3778761029,
0.0212311372,
0.6604246497,
0.1542938948,
0.3049170375,
0.6531509161,
-0.358387202,
0.2370290905,
0.1338902861,
0.0978557765,
-0.3444673419,
-0.2130499035,
-0.5225208402,
-0.206264779,
-0.2536999285,
-0.1145390645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07654v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07654v1
|
rollama: An R package for using generative large language models through Ollama
| 2024-04-11T11:37:18 | 2024-04-11T11:37:18 |
Johannes B. Gruber, Maximilian Weber
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
rollama is an R package that wraps the Ollama API, which allows you to run
different Generative Large Language Models (GLLM) locally. The package and
learning material focus on making it easy to use Ollama for annotating textual
or imagine data with open-source models as well as use these models for
document embedding. But users can use or extend rollama to do essentially
anything else that is possible through OpenAI's API, yet more private,
reproducible and for free.
|
[
-0.3584130406,
-0.9933851957,
0.322721988,
-0.130324766,
-0.2598654032,
0.1678925902,
0.0106383255,
-0.3957378566,
0.5610744953,
1.0667027235,
-0.2377079278,
-0.723976016,
-0.4324044585,
-0.1815434396,
-0.2226856202,
1.1862475872,
-0.4108825624,
-0.1351871789,
0.0475202166,
-0.5853508115,
-0.422270447,
-0.2866337895,
-0.3856791258,
-0.3443782032,
0.8430615664,
0.5133022666,
1.0712066889,
0.4754900634,
0.9494906664,
0.2482446581,
0.0585159436,
0.2920219302,
-0.2920069098,
0.1579811126,
-0.1178895608,
-1.0274888277,
-0.6797764897,
-0.0322698727,
0.6529948115,
0.305865705,
-0.3316288292,
0.6129656434,
-0.6246370673,
0.7221102118,
-0.9725047946,
-0.0958778113,
-0.2889168561,
0.105098471,
-0.5390146375,
-0.2724401653,
-0.3084772527,
-0.7942215204,
-0.1879999936,
-0.6657853127,
-0.0979244411,
0.2993905842,
0.9263987541,
0.4752811193,
-0.1875267774,
-0.986042738,
-0.9516401887,
0.7882512212,
-0.6677696109,
-0.2132889181,
0.5330664515,
0.6995880008,
-0.3569273055,
-0.4410318434,
-0.6798859835,
-0.3415434361,
0.1259194911,
0.0874408409,
0.0876454189,
-0.0712720603,
0.2934383154,
0.9634607434,
-0.896966815,
0.3887298703,
-0.8109203577,
0.5403539538,
0.6002696157,
0.2260594517,
0.9982004166,
0.0331496969,
-0.8138775229,
-0.2994022071,
-0.8947008252,
-0.4238083363,
0.7671046257,
0.2708998322,
-0.5294568539,
1.0771632195,
0.3122984171,
0.7546485066,
-0.7479158044,
-0.3177727461,
0.5027669668,
0.1999937147,
-0.5629924536,
-0.0614885874,
0.7763857245,
-0.0349016301,
0.2084680647,
0.1009895355,
-0.268550545,
0.3383327425,
0.3198435307,
-0.6068582535,
-0.1404554099,
0.7009925246,
-0.699020505,
-0.0893074498,
0.3084523976,
-1.2349381447,
-0.3127333522,
-0.2852987349,
0.4466555119,
-0.3789605498,
-0.5818519592,
0.2387352586,
-0.0180814918,
0.2746518254,
0.0063911602,
-0.6528177261,
0.1852073371,
0.7727339268,
1.2886977196,
-0.2240772694,
-0.2603339553,
-0.8686219454,
0.3411506712,
-0.5285525918,
1.0068057775,
-0.7440671325,
-0.6438233852,
0.4274796844,
-0.2008519322,
-0.0616290905,
-0.7570020556,
0.538076818,
-0.6744953394,
0.4055211544,
0.2162059098,
-0.5181257129,
-0.6168680191,
-0.1046804935,
-0.9030508995,
1.079600215,
0.2998310328,
-0.487136662,
0.3303618729,
-1.2728968859,
-0.1640038043,
0.3137204647,
-0.0367307067,
-0.5324676037,
0.2054904103,
-0.080094628,
0.4369905293,
-0.2126316726,
0.2925560474,
-0.4953155816,
-0.4042564332,
0.4553746283,
0.1670728773,
0.957819581,
0.6969742775,
-0.0365328491,
0.5048367381,
-1.0064707994,
-0.1144155562,
0.1108399481,
-0.2458086461,
-0.8204062581,
-0.2547185123,
0.2267347276,
-0.0550669357,
-0.0639718249,
-0.2431540191,
0.8222657442,
-0.2066576183,
0.2397470921,
0.5265088677,
-0.3381726742,
0.5134900808,
-0.3236247003,
1.0373374224,
0.1864868999,
-0.0367716514,
-0.3995749056,
-0.8226878643,
-0.8506974578,
-0.6810448766,
0.0948790461,
0.6666461825,
-0.9711951613,
0.1941663325,
-0.1590561569,
-0.502946198,
-0.9660505056,
0.3800271749,
0.4379755259,
-0.1046818346,
0.5333728194,
-0.2172358334,
-0.5482718945,
-0.7708476186,
0.4615716636,
-0.0192479864,
-0.2850527763,
-0.3883303106,
0.9663212895,
-0.6871384382,
1.0936414003,
-0.9173250794,
-1.0624984503,
-0.2297978103,
0.6276690364,
0.1944336742,
0.2404599041,
0.6797292829,
-0.8035112619,
-0.3172045648,
0.2041198462,
-0.9260417223,
-0.0917691737,
0.0992389098,
-0.0154999159,
0.6699718833,
0.1394366175,
-0.6251596212,
0.4978385866,
1.1193087101,
-0.2707463801,
0.3708196878,
-0.5762938261,
-0.0736450329,
-1.416446805,
0.2487199157,
-0.2504208684,
-0.0055670114,
-0.5397635698,
0.6114891768,
-0.305563122,
-0.193209067,
-0.29780671,
0.8893620372,
-0.6204701066,
-0.2786002457,
-0.5384945273,
0.24881652,
-0.3293439448,
0.2507666945,
0.011577867,
1.0365281105,
0.4211224616,
-0.6607317924,
-0.0064041964,
0.4107817113,
-0.5754361749,
0.6616171002,
-0.5116539598,
0.4719041586,
-0.2908803821,
0.1933354586,
-0.7197878957,
-0.4804798365,
0.6016450524,
-0.2525322437,
0.0660648346,
0.0376453847,
-0.1431177855,
-0.3494670391,
-0.56528157,
0.3230586052,
0.6391099095,
-0.6955319047,
1.1349278688,
0.8130620122,
0.2135428041,
-0.5570896864,
-0.846717,
-0.0030679882,
-0.5737649798,
-0.2864604294,
0.0424925722,
-0.2129414827,
-0.7063595057,
0.1120701134,
0.7507206202,
-0.1566805094,
-0.2390125841,
0.8017234802,
0.4271687567,
-0.5006265044,
-0.0384540185,
-0.3504649997,
-0.3945347071,
-0.314563036,
0.2318784595,
0.7527124286,
-0.0998262987,
-0.2742339373,
-0.1599934399,
0.4351262152,
0.3534668088,
-0.3761879504,
1.0018970966,
0.8048840761,
-0.166780889,
-0.680758059,
-0.4488671124,
0.4652062356,
-0.4819386303,
-0.0605080985,
-0.3126941919,
-0.8501513004,
0.711301744,
0.3629683256,
0.1714280099,
0.2224681824,
0.7382226586,
0.0162287746,
0.4634260535,
0.5741178393,
-0.3203107417,
0.1877381206,
-0.4163456261,
0.1296507269,
-1.0825805664,
-0.064874135,
-0.9182218313,
-0.1887135059,
-0.4114532471,
-1.0744650364,
0.0586023703,
0.1183355004,
-0.2831761241,
0.2364059687,
-0.5898096561,
0.2908318639,
0.6937417984,
-0.3164151609,
0.5656530261,
-0.0193741471,
0.4614220858,
0.3671925366,
-0.4375505149,
-0.8571089506,
1.0946758986,
0.5646023154,
1.2501918077,
0.3188037574,
0.6575418711,
0.3147816658,
0.7488562465,
-0.8951864243,
0.6477528811,
-0.3411297202,
-0.4470852613,
0.0610814653,
-0.4016676545,
-1.164948225,
-0.018183995,
0.0832740366,
-0.7899551392,
-0.005238798,
0.0457982793,
-0.2578722537,
0.6889999509,
-0.6906657219,
0.4263164103,
0.0237338897,
0.4330791235,
-0.214552924,
-0.1643226147,
0.7720836997,
0.1684577316,
0.379046917,
-0.3321572542,
-0.2488185465,
0.7367444634,
-0.2456848025,
0.9043565989,
-0.1436549276,
-0.4622634053,
0.6890284419,
0.2021278143,
0.1696477383,
-0.0816249922,
0.1736836582,
0.4605124295,
-0.196133703,
-0.0950932428,
-0.5529391766,
0.7195796371,
-0.8389849067,
-0.2797904313,
-0.610175252,
-0.6372825503,
0.2398289591,
-0.100315772,
-0.1236684471,
0.4329837561,
0.0714023039,
0.2166229486,
0.6581822038,
-0.462013334,
0.3452925086,
0.5009655356,
-1.0886365175,
-0.5104771256,
0.9258663654,
0.2225807458,
0.289354682,
0.484937638,
0.1765816361,
-0.1913285702,
-0.5384991765,
-0.5408915877,
0.2420940548,
-0.7934775352,
-0.2616710961,
-0.6407296062,
-0.1045664027,
0.1327657849,
-0.3940709829,
-0.2397592068,
-0.1607886702,
-0.2015624344,
-0.0259707235,
0.5705487132,
1.1694988012,
0.0306086168,
0.4870944917,
-0.7576862574,
0.7966218591,
0.1766634881,
0.3380119205,
-0.1397739351,
-0.2354032397,
-0.0691579655,
-0.0190569069,
0.0001925992,
-0.6907128692,
0.4042084813,
0.1608726233,
0.3984474242,
0.4890622199,
-0.0685006529,
0.5978386402,
-0.2131969482,
0.8987507224,
0.0882404298,
-0.6484153271,
0.6733537912,
-0.526552856,
0.4916899502,
0.2375437021,
0.6794720888,
-0.2227650732,
-0.3725261688,
-0.1278092861,
-0.778539598,
0.442446053,
-0.096506387,
0.0952751711,
-0.048895631,
0.1362162828,
0.2920831442,
-0.0486206934,
-0.6362611055,
-0.1533326358,
0.0726073533,
-0.3712419271,
-0.1473243386,
-0.5987452865,
-0.4517793059,
0.4806503952,
0.7809132338,
-0.3636525869,
0.2217148989,
-0.0789721832,
-0.1630904675,
-0.2823414207,
0.1219405979,
0.8238790631,
0.7737525105,
-0.2586515844,
0.0771637633,
-0.0679428354,
-0.8460264802,
0.1404070705,
-0.275777638,
-0.5434233546,
-0.0043908055,
0.3198189437,
1.0203896761,
0.2382074147,
-0.8781548142,
-0.1387409568,
0.2546110451,
0.0557764657,
-0.6316287518,
0.3735404015,
-0.005814217,
0.0752360597,
0.4842269719,
-0.3621531427,
-0.0854826048,
-0.8102265,
-0.2024396956,
0.3557677567,
-0.1745064408,
-0.2754837871,
0.6902848482,
-0.1381321996,
-0.7473270297,
0.4069575965,
-0.0295051169,
-0.1511334628,
0.5902563334,
0.5719402432,
1.0797930956,
-0.6503727436,
0.8957275152,
0.4418182671,
0.1942203492,
-0.1008677557,
0.5074383616,
0.4482342601,
-0.680532515,
-0.3357447088,
-0.9697432518,
-0.7320370078,
0.1456948668,
-0.7304239273,
0.488761574,
-0.3423691988,
-0.0460071266,
-0.0341517217,
-0.3555845916,
-0.4004949331,
0.1553767025,
0.1260898709,
0.8472749591,
-0.4350399375,
1.0529508591,
0.8934083581,
-0.8703870773,
-0.7392638922,
-0.185939759,
0.0428751484,
-0.8643758893,
0.7895367742,
0.2954837084,
-0.4686009884,
-0.5375599861,
-0.2897757292,
-0.8083356023,
0.9237943888,
0.0879450068,
-0.2619251609,
0.1529870182,
0.5243901014,
0.6115142703,
-0.5500277281,
0.407979697,
0.1118956581,
0.4536840618,
0.1707499027,
-0.711032331,
-0.1657553017,
0.1258478314,
0.4197176993,
0.352263093,
-0.6181410551,
0.9821731448,
-0.2328339219,
-0.4036910534,
0.2761726975,
0.8826717734,
0.4538590908,
0.3548625708,
0.30523628,
0.7812963128,
0.804444015,
-0.0705894455,
1.1076335907,
0.0076284874,
0.4024344087,
1.3566485643,
-0.7026266456,
1.3590072393,
0.2552650571,
-0.3207065761,
0.8926689625,
0.125240609,
0.0539495721,
0.1154393777,
0.0593175888,
-0.1802074164,
0.3841917515,
0.1527319998,
-0.5786293745,
0.6792176366,
0.4854671657,
-0.0880487859,
-0.0983456448,
0.4566428363,
0.3274482787,
0.1790083498,
-0.6251410246,
0.5029848814,
0.3256763816,
-0.6701014638,
0.4705764651,
-0.2209694982,
0.9480725527,
-0.9734217525,
-0.150599882,
-0.1984193325,
0.4931670725,
-0.3224981129,
-1.0254667997,
0.8958188295,
-0.2156967521,
0.0581133328,
0.1235934496,
0.7751096487,
-0.4880190194,
-0.488203615,
0.526655376,
0.0550398603,
0.1673141122,
0.3177952766,
-0.55131495,
0.418056637,
-0.3978114128,
-0.5055345893,
0.405818522,
-0.1118154675,
-0.1691921204,
1.2533665895,
0.7669621706,
-0.0353836343,
0.0099601913,
0.0530877784,
0.7273850441,
-0.5886188149,
-0.4310897887,
-0.6202809811,
0.5263114572,
0.0416676924,
-0.6057514548,
0.9373857975,
0.5866243839,
0.6150093079,
-0.6792379618,
0.4545832574,
-0.3732184172,
0.5783064365,
-0.9461035728,
0.7766470313,
-0.5204266906,
-0.0711557716,
-0.0206446201,
-1.1967734098,
-0.3777538538,
0.6759274602,
-0.2650107741,
-0.2257534862,
0.583347559,
0.9701417089,
-0.035416685,
0.1954302639,
0.3217812777,
0.1259822696,
0.3143481612,
0.2964330316,
0.7429189682,
-0.150065735,
0.1632125974,
0.1074601561,
-0.3552102745,
-0.1774029136,
-0.824572742,
-1.3613091707,
-0.8429051042,
-0.3617938757,
-0.34398368,
0.0356902592,
0.9444985986,
0.5557287335,
-1.1028394699,
-0.5044053197,
0.3738824129,
0.0702605173,
-0.0240529962,
-0.2805906534,
0.4598881006,
-0.3895645142,
-1.033233881,
0.4959729612,
0.5880071521,
-0.0542874001,
-1.0469144583,
-0.1261703074,
-0.3757073581,
0.1046715677,
0.4663251936,
0.6059427261,
-0.5027285218,
-0.2168083936,
-0.4776429236,
0.0007065539,
0.1684414148,
0.8125864267,
-0.6630028486,
0.4295985401,
0.5076851845,
0.4317336082,
0.2704983652,
-0.1547585726,
0.6730994582,
-0.2435484976,
0.6906293035,
0.0734572783,
0.2372389585,
0.1991381347,
-0.1780674905,
1.0244458914,
-0.3937534392,
-0.7737488747,
-1.0573513508,
0.1457914263,
-1.3201197386,
-0.1167895868,
1.3358217478,
-0.4353240132,
-0.5822039247,
-0.1803471297,
-0.5339108109,
-0.2168445587,
-0.0374650769,
0.8978091478,
0.4600355923,
0.4493394792,
-0.2159939706,
-1.1075357199,
0.4866224825,
-0.0372017734,
-1.3230768442,
-0.3580557704,
0.2661198974,
0.0237501841,
0.6615840197,
0.8210942149,
-0.0905477554,
-0.0073787076,
-0.0297883675,
0.2448385805,
-0.1982408315,
-0.4257707,
-0.2266146988,
0.5523298979,
-0.2326349169,
-0.3845642805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07647v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07647v1
|
Why do small language models underperform? Studying Language Model Saturation via the Softmax Bottleneck
| 2024-04-11T11:10:36 | 2024-04-11T11:10:36 |
Nathan Godey, Éric de la Clergerie, Benoît Sagot
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advances in language modeling consist in pretraining highly
parameterized neural networks on extremely large web-mined text corpora.
Training and inference with such models can be costly in practice, which
incentivizes the use of smaller counterparts. However, it has been observed
that smaller models can suffer from saturation, characterized as a drop in
performance at some advanced point in training followed by a plateau. In this
paper, we find that such saturation can be explained by a mismatch between the
hidden dimension of smaller models and the high rank of the target contextual
probability distribution. This mismatch affects the performance of the linear
prediction head used in such models through the well-known softmax bottleneck
phenomenon. We measure the effect of the softmax bottleneck in various settings
and find that models based on less than 1000 hidden dimensions tend to adopt
degenerate latent representations in late pretraining, which leads to reduced
evaluation performance.
|
[
-0.595764637,
-0.4932099581,
0.6533599496,
0.0484213457,
-0.1174043491,
-0.046839986,
-0.3335402608,
-0.3480267823,
-0.3107666671,
0.4309704602,
-0.4823771119,
0.0307935774,
-0.6578469276,
-0.0824178532,
-0.12160106,
0.8231861591,
0.1395708919,
0.1230858639,
-0.5270221829,
-0.3233003616,
-0.6953061223,
-0.510563612,
-0.3696924448,
-0.7287270427,
0.3565328121,
0.573723495,
0.9115018845,
0.5791380405,
0.2844929099,
0.2624249756,
-0.1904943883,
-0.2009714991,
-0.7559891343,
-0.0171577297,
0.1998928785,
-0.6502447724,
-0.255235523,
0.2762925327,
0.7720307112,
1.3598208427,
0.0706121996,
0.1366180927,
0.3459884524,
0.6040047407,
-0.7753407359,
0.0135238748,
-0.7988097668,
-0.0276273396,
-0.2078576535,
0.1893378794,
-0.2017520666,
-0.1136722118,
0.3130097687,
-0.240587607,
0.3971511722,
-0.002779298,
0.5165287852,
0.2645837069,
-0.2201686949,
-0.1510765553,
-0.8957565427,
0.923873961,
-0.6925094724,
0.2273893803,
0.2334086448,
0.210776329,
0.2077994943,
-0.3687334657,
-0.5375723243,
-0.4127648473,
-0.0658662096,
-0.443443507,
-0.3574594259,
-0.1004272401,
0.4557539523,
0.3685891628,
-0.6483256817,
0.3611073792,
-0.4466485977,
0.0465524867,
0.417689085,
0.2241524756,
-0.0677416101,
0.0472082011,
-0.1420010477,
-0.099577181,
-0.9712733626,
-0.0132193565,
0.3274837136,
0.6999163628,
0.1224041358,
0.475304693,
-0.0130259646,
0.4170017838,
-0.0944016054,
-0.0257046018,
0.4769351184,
-0.110790126,
-0.396825701,
-0.1045048237,
0.5710120201,
0.0381930619,
0.6026834846,
0.0319473296,
-0.3414580524,
-0.0567479841,
0.117018722,
-0.9349428415,
-0.0244929269,
0.0699547529,
-0.5468825102,
-0.2529557943,
-0.304890126,
-0.536477983,
-0.4066559076,
-0.1350010931,
0.523735702,
-0.0267102588,
-0.4002483487,
0.0591062903,
-0.0810175985,
-0.1790863574,
0.0791102126,
-0.6459789872,
0.5092118979,
0.4795438051,
0.8380106091,
-0.1506952941,
-0.2630412579,
-0.1805103272,
-0.3518899977,
-0.5359251499,
0.5413961411,
-0.5846443176,
-0.4067108035,
0.0267392676,
-0.1585472375,
-0.3725881875,
-1.0367689133,
0.2726157904,
-0.2163886279,
0.0913513973,
-0.1886904389,
-0.3013502061,
0.2008530498,
-0.1732661277,
-0.7823287249,
0.8898531795,
0.103209205,
-0.6009944081,
0.3479521871,
-0.1895580739,
-0.2419879138,
0.0385804474,
-0.2489648759,
-0.3664646745,
0.6455368996,
-0.168408215,
0.4152118266,
-0.4729912877,
-0.2555611432,
-0.2841760814,
-0.8316279054,
0.4292781651,
-0.551148057,
0.6296550035,
0.1959103197,
-0.4063759446,
-0.1298479885,
-0.7393066883,
0.3066424131,
0.3320342004,
-0.2673137486,
-0.6441800594,
-0.1732995361,
-0.0142847067,
0.3412290812,
0.0175190959,
-0.0679092258,
0.2395184636,
-0.6748213768,
0.3752095103,
0.5351451635,
-0.2350143641,
0.6571875811,
-0.0951008499,
0.6665580869,
0.1465812624,
0.0231421292,
0.1701025516,
-0.3376470804,
-0.8568693995,
0.1925737411,
0.4515897334,
0.4464691579,
-0.2863988876,
-0.2330261767,
-0.431665659,
-0.5852770805,
-0.521283567,
0.5351125002,
0.5380500555,
0.1554946601,
0.1551795751,
-0.4022760987,
-0.2492698282,
-1.1678454876,
-0.2848255634,
0.0387932137,
-0.1655537486,
0.3629090786,
0.5595847368,
-0.4462874234,
0.7191525102,
-0.4689157009,
-0.4055699408,
-0.7241441607,
0.3045147061,
0.2646236122,
0.6813440323,
0.583771646,
-0.7059738636,
-0.3363156319,
-0.3469483256,
-0.2563837469,
-0.0931696072,
0.0830404684,
0.334418714,
0.1844322383,
0.4863151014,
-0.6739195585,
0.3959815502,
0.5893175602,
-0.1188970506,
0.5762109756,
-0.3064424694,
-0.4855696857,
-0.4603714645,
-0.0279702507,
-0.0245680045,
-0.1370142847,
-0.4596622884,
-0.2089413404,
-0.1566736698,
-0.3934997916,
-0.2777035534,
0.2528381944,
-0.5651609302,
-0.1676457971,
-0.4492067099,
0.3819817901,
0.1097030118,
0.4891879261,
-0.2613812983,
0.7526908517,
0.3673766553,
-0.5131850839,
-0.0156778917,
-0.0238424037,
-0.3931544721,
0.2053708732,
-0.7940484881,
0.0571261756,
-0.1022052392,
-0.0199880451,
-0.7382400632,
0.0875811055,
-0.3118371069,
-0.2343740016,
0.5372328162,
-0.2142575085,
-0.40321666,
-0.3741408587,
-0.19081828,
0.5857409835,
0.5767661333,
-0.0981882513,
0.0423812009,
0.3768912256,
-0.0633429512,
-0.6337840557,
-1.04357481,
-0.2798081934,
-0.0375537463,
-0.4920778573,
0.1648341417,
-0.1831611246,
-0.3792518973,
0.0207076557,
-0.2378362417,
-0.1668756455,
0.1378215551,
0.3780959845,
-0.202381283,
-0.7094796896,
0.1975656003,
-0.2472039014,
-0.2362292409,
-0.0485837236,
-0.2311155945,
0.6101124287,
-0.6379771233,
-0.0798472315,
-0.1679921448,
0.3500671387,
0.5839478374,
0.1450183541,
1.1280063391,
0.3232125044,
-0.4326789975,
-0.5009617805,
-0.4386446178,
-0.1132643521,
-0.4700550139,
0.3250640035,
-0.4458048046,
-0.7972946763,
0.4354086816,
-0.0075527797,
-0.4316202402,
0.6220773458,
0.5324609876,
0.1227738634,
1.2135019302,
1.0145493746,
0.2409439832,
0.2956809402,
-0.5688625574,
0.0829572156,
-0.7140551805,
0.0174351651,
-0.5348896384,
-0.040066883,
-0.956310153,
-0.3961941004,
0.1011569425,
0.3351118863,
-0.2120761573,
0.3649910986,
-0.2342187166,
0.7167190909,
0.5059356689,
-0.3781470656,
0.2077239454,
-0.0973276272,
-0.3274694085,
-0.2931601405,
-1.1315096617,
-0.674182713,
0.8795658946,
0.6050226092,
0.8039591908,
-0.1523674279,
0.2813091874,
0.291885525,
0.1820886284,
-0.624206543,
0.3841779828,
-0.2362158448,
-0.7333877087,
-0.3934629858,
-0.5866321921,
-1.0608592033,
0.4534166455,
-0.1537239254,
-0.6950762272,
0.5942025781,
0.4110344648,
-0.5198346376,
-0.0821635276,
-0.8907328844,
1.5519090891,
-0.1360010803,
-0.4247274697,
-0.303933233,
-0.3701269031,
0.2098966092,
-0.1110440791,
0.3414966166,
-0.1762464792,
0.189341411,
0.5679129958,
-0.5823293924,
0.6764625311,
-0.2474668473,
0.1232057661,
0.2405532151,
0.3048585057,
0.347061336,
0.0348210149,
0.0900401101,
0.1772468835,
0.0613554753,
-0.5273212194,
-0.4258520305,
0.8558029532,
-0.7818316817,
-0.573882401,
-0.4686772823,
-0.1746685356,
-0.4815070033,
0.0883946121,
0.6085340381,
0.5876255631,
-0.0722353756,
0.4429947436,
0.6119580269,
-0.3178052902,
0.3267066181,
0.230967924,
0.0162590966,
0.135180369,
0.947445631,
0.4909019768,
0.5023472309,
0.0058791256,
0.2321785539,
-0.0500736162,
-0.6389757395,
-0.1422104836,
0.1893442124,
-0.780518055,
-0.0616827682,
-0.3681618869,
-0.21407561,
-0.5620023608,
0.0838285461,
-0.8084563613,
-0.4622323513,
-0.2385850698,
0.0777043626,
-0.3611938059,
0.8893768787,
-0.2431871146,
0.5745217204,
-0.3505403697,
0.0302545205,
0.4025967717,
0.5770587921,
0.292200774,
-0.5173216462,
-0.5985901952,
-0.1659734249,
-0.2594769001,
-0.6848523021,
0.3734509945,
0.3272868395,
0.5725771785,
0.4358962774,
-0.2246211618,
0.4731547832,
-0.6126906872,
0.4704422951,
-0.0127031924,
-0.9345868826,
0.2532799542,
-0.0365499184,
0.5792803168,
0.6525541544,
0.3434876502,
-0.3464436531,
-0.2470812351,
-0.7000479698,
-0.9331336021,
0.6438663602,
0.2813113034,
0.315182507,
0.2274088562,
0.1698373407,
0.2860348821,
0.4383805096,
-1.056427598,
-0.335023433,
-0.1671697944,
0.1074132249,
-0.3886955976,
-0.7330431342,
0.2267891467,
-0.0724769831,
0.5225936174,
-0.1571340412,
0.3093482256,
-0.1892476678,
-0.3637873232,
-0.440998286,
0.220601365,
0.6362300515,
0.801014781,
-0.2962697744,
0.1657937467,
0.2545130253,
-0.2600519657,
-0.1226465479,
0.0686000884,
-0.0070201205,
0.1318198889,
0.5318947434,
1.0438028574,
0.4016709328,
-0.7835543156,
0.8320662975,
-0.156997785,
0.172876671,
-0.4759966731,
0.1686288863,
-0.0097409189,
0.2985291779,
0.6793936491,
0.2152130306,
0.0194891319,
-0.7628402114,
-0.0358419046,
0.5331162214,
-0.4436267912,
-0.119905062,
0.6318116784,
0.1113974527,
-0.1314103007,
0.5311150551,
-0.1352112591,
-0.639113903,
0.6070459485,
0.2331974357,
0.5928747654,
0.0638939068,
0.0482947566,
0.1425383985,
0.6390968561,
-0.1269292235,
-0.064635776,
0.0818544105,
-0.5281714201,
-0.4964199662,
-0.8332006335,
-0.0511396825,
0.692525506,
-0.4544519782,
-0.0312037654,
-0.3701835871,
-0.3174307644,
-0.066818431,
0.2647944093,
-1.0480561256,
0.4395554364,
0.3973900974,
0.7653006315,
-0.8895305395,
0.7180646658,
0.1201668158,
-0.4778524041,
-0.5982112885,
0.1598635763,
-0.2408049256,
-0.5027102828,
0.8736146688,
0.4407244623,
-0.0987236127,
-0.1848379374,
-0.3300852776,
-0.865355134,
0.4939610958,
0.412997961,
-0.6611994505,
-0.120056048,
0.4794762135,
0.869189918,
-0.7256406546,
0.1021865308,
0.5755624771,
0.1404378861,
-0.1958534122,
-1.0763539076,
0.0413980745,
-0.0380538069,
0.3629370332,
-0.1226204336,
-0.4726580977,
1.2366633415,
-0.2850418687,
-0.3273364902,
0.1050691009,
0.3672081232,
0.0716607347,
0.375372082,
0.5628521442,
0.3496148884,
0.3973196447,
-0.130086109,
1.1365886927,
-0.0746203139,
0.4904222786,
0.9459481239,
-0.2132627964,
0.9420443773,
0.2600277066,
-0.0194640458,
0.4958408773,
0.5522717834,
0.0520947315,
0.5283128619,
0.3590943813,
0.1229101941,
-0.4512787163,
0.2007738203,
-0.475353092,
0.5110888481,
0.4335716069,
-0.405698061,
0.0560772754,
0.2584106922,
-0.2325146794,
0.0617118701,
-0.432687819,
0.4173193574,
0.3199560046,
-0.447471112,
0.9998005033,
-0.0408021882,
0.5056374073,
-0.2989415228,
0.2891696692,
-0.302840054,
0.4791924059,
-0.0008129164,
-0.4057574868,
0.3288556635,
-0.179547593,
-0.2557287216,
-0.3466895819,
0.8617258072,
-0.2860747278,
-0.3606817126,
0.4482542872,
0.8944766521,
0.2262632549,
-0.3253867924,
-0.7221263647,
0.2580877542,
-0.4924801886,
-0.4360024035,
0.3599265516,
0.5645625591,
0.1016165763,
0.6082063317,
0.2808686495,
0.1934791654,
-0.0515217036,
0.1703558564,
0.7093789577,
-0.4962490499,
-0.2800626755,
-0.8187918067,
0.1933151931,
0.0321018882,
-0.4550240636,
0.7095699906,
0.6487352252,
1.031535387,
-0.2893715203,
0.5961347818,
0.2242341191,
0.5846144557,
-0.2473941147,
0.8262719512,
-0.9066597819,
0.3763602674,
-0.0976908356,
-1.1145223379,
-0.0278712306,
0.5468907952,
-0.5488182902,
0.3360458016,
0.5421136618,
0.6119983196,
-0.1307312995,
-0.4862314165,
0.609306097,
0.5562365651,
-0.140327096,
0.6986159682,
0.6700496674,
-0.3399092257,
0.7262860537,
-0.3209527135,
0.0161630623,
-0.686714828,
-0.780251801,
-1.0432981253,
-0.5493206382,
-0.2641403377,
-0.410120517,
0.0133644985,
0.5755557418,
0.9103038311,
-0.8213945031,
-0.2661573887,
-0.2008821666,
0.1692523509,
0.0311235785,
-0.2652953267,
0.0568115413,
-0.1514958888,
-0.7124341726,
0.3908002973,
0.0694785938,
0.1966108382,
-0.6646383405,
0.1509867609,
0.1031548753,
0.2526028752,
0.3538960218,
0.4664201438,
-0.421238333,
-0.0806751251,
-0.3330248296,
-0.5322403312,
-0.0041782027,
0.9922484756,
-1.0297343731,
0.0610234961,
0.3691810369,
0.3348974586,
0.5779806972,
-0.3960334957,
0.6515489817,
-1.1226816177,
0.5023190975,
0.3149109483,
0.2366233468,
0.5483339429,
-0.1424843222,
0.2136770785,
0.5419083834,
-0.4023392498,
-1.2230026722,
0.1973169595,
-0.5098581314,
-0.7547246814,
1.0067760944,
0.1846212298,
-0.2774097919,
0.1040396169,
0.1298822612,
-0.0245019123,
0.0691406056,
0.5871838331,
0.6981742978,
-0.062557444,
-0.0264539588,
-0.9125772119,
0.7909680009,
0.5830081701,
-0.2035584003,
0.1524708122,
0.2418489605,
0.3155534863,
0.3646015227,
0.3586381376,
0.3383128643,
0.1124278307,
0.383042872,
-0.5233160853,
0.162992239,
-0.3138965666,
-0.4019628465,
0.4880667329,
0.3171444535,
0.2332082689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07622v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07622v1
|
Multi-Image Visual Question Answering for Unsupervised Anomaly Detection
| 2024-04-11T10:16:44 | 2024-04-11T10:16:44 |
Jun Li, Cosmin I. Bercea, Philip Müller, Lina Felsner, Suhwan Kim, Daniel Rueckert, Benedikt Wiestler, Julia A. Schnabel
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Unsupervised anomaly detection enables the identification of potential
pathological areas by juxtaposing original images with their pseudo-healthy
reconstructions generated by models trained exclusively on normal images.
However, the clinical interpretation of resultant anomaly maps presents a
challenge due to a lack of detailed, understandable explanations. Recent
advancements in language models have shown the capability of mimicking
human-like understanding and providing detailed descriptions. This raises an
interesting question: \textit{How can language models be employed to make the
anomaly maps more explainable?} To the best of our knowledge, we are the first
to leverage a language model for unsupervised anomaly detection, for which we
construct a dataset with different questions and answers. Additionally, we
present a novel multi-image visual question answering framework tailored for
anomaly detection, incorporating diverse feature fusion strategies to enhance
visual knowledge extraction. Our experiments reveal that the framework,
augmented by our new Knowledge Q-Former module, adeptly answers questions on
the anomaly detection dataset. Besides, integrating anomaly maps as inputs
distinctly aids in improving the detection of unseen pathologies.
|
[
-0.4448645115,
-0.9985027313,
0.776991725,
-0.2445930392,
-0.47730878,
-0.1397839785,
0.2734079957,
-0.5027753711,
0.2184632272,
0.827717185,
-0.8426833749,
-0.4521678984,
-0.6116345525,
-0.0972269848,
-0.3733622432,
0.6618489027,
-0.0243154578,
0.3841696382,
-0.5352999568,
-0.3940803111,
-0.5171123743,
0.0130205657,
-0.377766192,
0.0244512968,
0.1812099963,
0.3536003232,
0.6675879359,
0.5689063668,
0.88509202,
0.3074215949,
0.2499355078,
0.1680428982,
-0.1031530499,
-0.0361167006,
0.0819966421,
-0.6046229601,
-0.3312205374,
-0.4300203025,
0.4973649681,
0.785908699,
0.058251515,
-0.0426684357,
-0.5035164952,
0.4731919765,
-0.384876579,
-0.0532058775,
-0.5643045306,
0.2290657908,
-0.1577464491,
-0.4536133409,
0.0657929704,
-0.048620794,
0.3539008498,
-0.8602525592,
0.4067836106,
-0.164088577,
0.7143309116,
0.3753374815,
-0.3397659957,
-0.1078138873,
-0.5072713494,
0.350694418,
-0.2582440972,
0.2336522788,
0.1393802315,
0.5506267548,
-0.1906394213,
-1.009631753,
-0.5825752616,
0.1545703858,
-0.0844003335,
0.3041309714,
-0.5341554284,
-0.2506395876,
0.0776125565,
0.341393888,
-0.974611938,
0.0693531036,
-0.5327462554,
-0.3218854964,
0.4368670583,
0.4437113702,
0.9206646681,
-0.095261775,
-0.528352499,
0.1138913855,
-0.6382824183,
0.3066438735,
0.0592897646,
-0.2962773442,
-0.1327063888,
0.4207540751,
-0.1566132456,
0.752869308,
-0.2580195367,
-0.0028141274,
0.1370811909,
-0.1873729527,
0.0939761549,
-0.2921173275,
0.5023518801,
0.778978169,
0.1648951322,
-0.0094429879,
0.0571149252,
0.1772226691,
0.1902911961,
-0.6205611825,
-0.7511149645,
0.1619594991,
-0.6634168029,
-0.2685252726,
0.1475586146,
-1.0267243385,
-0.7517672777,
0.0843668655,
0.5481100678,
-0.2939198315,
-0.6839746237,
0.263476491,
-0.5899240375,
0.1939203143,
0.6017161608,
-0.4590052664,
0.111614868,
0.014999616,
0.2714892924,
-0.0627127215,
-0.3634272218,
-0.5955369473,
0.0466666482,
-0.4416174591,
1.1495764256,
-0.5131406188,
-0.2169658542,
-0.0004124382,
0.4914645851,
-0.0000561102,
-0.5297822952,
0.0466109961,
-0.5220469832,
0.2613541782,
-0.5419204235,
-0.2976230085,
-0.5498365164,
0.2953539789,
-0.450655818,
0.5408462882,
0.2151252031,
-0.7153373957,
0.3277859092,
-0.8669022322,
-0.099577181,
0.328253448,
-0.2747934759,
-0.3252885938,
0.1779004782,
0.7142601013,
0.2937817574,
-0.3693478703,
-0.0039043033,
-0.469789654,
-0.2029146701,
0.5401060581,
-0.4001146257,
0.5088320374,
-0.0062325899,
-0.0905369371,
0.1185222268,
-0.4785528183,
0.1376750618,
0.6100126505,
0.2061784118,
-0.3543309867,
-0.3452197909,
-0.0956723765,
0.0106803589,
0.2356729507,
-0.5576925278,
0.0693490505,
-0.1376797855,
0.1591289043,
0.4053949118,
0.544308424,
0.1905064136,
-0.1059298664,
0.8222248554,
0.7596226931,
0.3240697682,
-0.5764223933,
-0.9681151509,
-0.5216349363,
-0.4688090682,
-0.0981158689,
0.5737563968,
-0.8517956734,
-0.04529728,
-0.1076455563,
-0.215890646,
-0.796497941,
0.0951546952,
0.3880990446,
0.8640663028,
0.5721283555,
-0.3098199964,
-0.297341913,
-0.9246944785,
-0.3322040737,
0.1313617378,
0.2439700365,
0.3014457524,
0.5693987012,
-0.2896027565,
0.6270193458,
-0.9140063524,
-0.2710642815,
-0.2381242365,
0.2845162749,
0.0463866852,
0.4038611948,
0.7969224453,
-1.1231861115,
-0.1728128046,
-0.0355704427,
-0.9978621006,
-0.0762705803,
-0.1231277213,
0.1884440184,
-0.1726385206,
0.5408534408,
-0.3258472383,
0.7972863913,
0.251865536,
-0.1987711042,
0.3673162758,
-0.4355597794,
0.4653289318,
-1.0849584341,
-0.1078621969,
0.0462257378,
-0.2609618008,
-0.7723067999,
0.2227941602,
0.2134172469,
-0.2252027094,
-0.4769852161,
0.3489059508,
-0.4641212225,
-0.1850662827,
-0.0953410193,
-0.1027354002,
0.2089307755,
0.4234744906,
0.0090445159,
0.5432878733,
1.3987878561,
-0.3208716512,
0.4870771468,
0.1858218163,
-0.1907247156,
0.6486907601,
-0.5509547591,
0.0604778081,
-0.7090448737,
-0.0703007951,
-1.3547327518,
-0.5633144975,
0.25819695,
-0.5542309284,
0.261067152,
-0.4226347804,
-0.1452688277,
-0.6508052349,
-0.129486829,
0.4680321217,
0.3736256957,
-0.6728721261,
0.3645746708,
0.4283737242,
0.2279595733,
-0.5117101073,
-0.9013345242,
0.0023862717,
-0.3556127548,
-0.5934140682,
-0.142641753,
-0.0278378837,
-0.15226762,
0.4115851223,
0.0851802304,
-0.7025622129,
0.1755382866,
0.1715717763,
0.3581162393,
-0.5738191605,
0.0960872248,
0.0614586659,
0.1597849727,
-0.042197533,
-0.0984979421,
0.3563909233,
-0.3319330812,
-0.8512125015,
-0.5728846788,
0.804528296,
0.7391151786,
-0.5145296454,
0.3369708061,
0.6477831006,
-0.6792675257,
0.2732602358,
-0.29250893,
-0.1653651744,
-0.4457861781,
0.6090377569,
-0.2973454595,
-0.5469663143,
0.7713622451,
-0.0636220127,
-0.3083400726,
0.27652812,
0.2888926566,
-0.4429214597,
1.2992305756,
0.5238078833,
0.3403905332,
0.0471796654,
-0.3155473769,
0.224308759,
-0.6877830625,
-0.3327989578,
0.0624054298,
-0.118525438,
-0.4684683681,
-0.3475665152,
0.8077042699,
0.1526994556,
0.3862678707,
0.0332031213,
-0.5034321547,
0.6686196923,
0.3430956006,
0.3659133911,
0.1173851714,
-0.1118840352,
0.2421342283,
-0.1420148313,
-0.8392537832,
-0.0110257557,
1.0925775766,
0.0067461054,
0.6616334915,
0.1702342927,
0.4187327027,
0.1824467778,
0.1321848333,
-0.454672277,
0.2583195269,
-0.0956823677,
-0.5696712732,
-0.3287367523,
-0.1488824338,
-1.0380961895,
0.2733021379,
-0.5233386159,
-0.9652662873,
0.4653911591,
0.4493611157,
-0.4179844856,
0.422167331,
-0.8940492868,
1.159545064,
-0.3078295588,
0.1159359366,
0.1563605219,
-0.8522256017,
0.7583523393,
0.154680565,
0.2788037956,
0.3212979436,
0.0949847773,
0.1849933416,
-0.1684026718,
0.648557961,
-0.2399821877,
0.3398125172,
0.3229045868,
-0.0174984522,
-0.0456982739,
0.2707237601,
0.6619378328,
0.1428597122,
0.1855586171,
-0.4795321524,
-0.9102407098,
0.4853440523,
-0.4812400639,
-0.5641334057,
-0.1337359399,
-0.7957710028,
-0.141361028,
0.1215456128,
0.4489119053,
0.7629600167,
-0.0507660173,
0.0118681062,
0.8035422564,
-0.5422409177,
0.4389216304,
0.3822548985,
-0.1816699952,
-0.0767242685,
0.9544243813,
-0.1823086292,
0.010433672,
0.4368542433,
0.2576660514,
-0.3862784803,
-0.5628141761,
-0.7693135142,
0.0770286545,
-0.8377605677,
-0.0996697173,
-0.7832063437,
-0.0496736802,
-0.5348008275,
0.1197413057,
-0.1266083866,
-0.4545193911,
-0.3411178887,
0.3417009711,
0.4568094313,
0.5689433813,
-0.1085517928,
0.2313288599,
-0.9970472455,
0.6810115576,
0.5879087448,
0.0787314102,
-0.2868953049,
-0.3843069375,
0.1490543336,
0.1327808201,
-0.172536388,
-1.3354879618,
0.3090316057,
0.2154897153,
0.6286721826,
0.7674637437,
-0.1286154538,
0.8588554263,
-0.1261256188,
0.6893744469,
0.4522345066,
-0.3558951318,
0.6995508671,
-0.3893158138,
0.3807442784,
0.213992089,
0.3570444584,
-0.3532487452,
-0.347245723,
-0.7346675396,
-0.5556778312,
0.4696426094,
-0.1140541881,
-0.0815776512,
0.1437067538,
0.4019191861,
-0.0314951017,
0.1919193715,
-0.5423526764,
-0.3926755488,
-0.4800159931,
0.045650579,
-0.1050511971,
0.0303120632,
-0.4766798317,
-0.3976766467,
0.0017710022,
-0.3006874621,
0.4169150591,
0.3673461676,
-0.4822496772,
-0.1836372167,
0.1685060114,
0.6843929887,
0.6895914078,
-0.022484608,
0.3887782693,
0.1475379914,
-0.5493473411,
-0.2027344108,
0.0940670967,
0.1247091889,
-0.0283975266,
0.4656476378,
0.6674070954,
-0.2357786447,
-0.7809923291,
0.8605301976,
-0.3242910504,
-0.2132700384,
-0.2707818747,
0.1222143769,
0.1808346808,
0.3556708992,
0.3437824845,
0.3735077977,
0.4167044461,
-0.5776134729,
0.3878863454,
0.7097447515,
-0.5974329114,
-0.400696516,
0.495862484,
-0.2062170058,
-0.07964205,
0.4991384149,
0.0341534913,
-0.6338490248,
0.988881886,
0.4675872624,
0.3400308788,
-0.1860201508,
0.3777213395,
-0.0626541898,
0.5621962547,
0.2736514211,
0.7306075692,
0.2536124885,
-0.8366829753,
0.0247455146,
0.0470886491,
-0.0556600355,
0.4922336042,
-0.7595513463,
0.0409251638,
-0.1692005843,
0.1294439584,
0.1482302099,
-0.7050033808,
-0.7126168609,
0.4955371618,
0.0180462748,
0.5837163329,
-1.1317584515,
0.5162473917,
1.1744126081,
-0.4252817929,
-0.5499700308,
0.0031928199,
-0.0179172438,
-1.1032104492,
0.1281050295,
0.0860304236,
0.2500434518,
0.0145490076,
-0.5506406426,
-0.614546895,
0.7577300072,
0.4170688093,
0.0105846897,
0.4467867911,
0.1711399108,
0.609208107,
-0.4373947084,
0.2866064608,
0.518533051,
0.4358575642,
0.096117273,
-0.3062443137,
-0.0865709782,
-0.313272208,
-0.2361683697,
0.3962186277,
-0.0813365132,
0.6428280473,
-0.7879588604,
0.0600414015,
0.0023196163,
0.2652509809,
0.0288787764,
0.6264214516,
0.5903831124,
0.6588441133,
0.8374823928,
-0.243405804,
1.1642649174,
-0.2957803011,
-0.0894996375,
0.7393125296,
0.2140648216,
0.1882802397,
0.5125399232,
0.1462414861,
0.3096645176,
0.7803450823,
0.0328421779,
0.6041879058,
-0.0846703798,
-0.0781485289,
-0.7223360538,
-0.1632758379,
-0.6641938686,
0.7054256797,
0.2390510142,
-0.1206286922,
-0.4133414626,
0.2404846251,
-0.5616112947,
-0.0757211819,
-0.3713408709,
0.7699192762,
-0.1689223349,
-0.4271547496,
0.4167748988,
-0.3776319325,
0.0786410645,
-0.3372977078,
-0.4288558662,
-0.3310199678,
-0.0779268816,
-0.0979312584,
-0.9764909744,
0.1989264637,
-0.1765884459,
-0.1664920598,
0.2789185047,
0.7477571368,
-0.5556719303,
-0.5563523173,
-0.1877454221,
0.8438737392,
0.4354515374,
0.051838614,
-0.6487026811,
-0.5019736886,
-0.1710340679,
0.1697372794,
0.3451697826,
0.7837649584,
-0.4629476964,
0.7138447165,
0.6744381785,
-0.0486804843,
0.1919110715,
0.0401927754,
0.8507089019,
-0.2064608037,
-0.6002851129,
-0.3367164135,
0.828250289,
-0.2256299704,
-0.468131274,
0.4491589665,
0.2084891945,
0.3739839196,
-0.471960187,
0.5330854058,
0.1767351925,
0.3035111725,
-0.390409112,
0.7534072399,
-1.3085894585,
0.1491071135,
-0.3044981956,
-0.4214840829,
-0.4352542162,
0.3361222744,
0.0646201521,
-0.321446836,
0.840491116,
1.1110258102,
-0.2695933878,
0.0106601873,
0.5382549763,
0.0159142185,
0.0001104217,
0.4707627594,
1.1485984325,
-0.4093285501,
0.4693846405,
-0.1974007487,
-0.3349116445,
-0.0413928963,
-0.6655480862,
-0.8715831637,
-0.6839740276,
-0.4243292809,
0.0437032543,
0.1059037149,
0.406804949,
0.7199838758,
-0.6875520349,
0.3196601272,
-0.2083796263,
0.3552750051,
-0.3456947803,
-0.1829111576,
0.5393610597,
0.0477389097,
-0.3911344707,
0.3337648809,
0.4727143943,
0.3509192169,
-0.1333847791,
0.2773301005,
-0.0549092218,
-0.3230446577,
0.0643040463,
0.4226709604,
-0.4811534882,
-0.0443857759,
0.1608172655,
0.2208831012,
0.3332761228,
1.0091696978,
-0.5767678022,
0.7679584026,
0.4376799464,
0.6850030422,
0.3655150235,
-0.0997690558,
0.3413920403,
-0.4756909907,
0.4076059163,
0.117338419,
0.5380626917,
0.3775858283,
-0.7158544064,
-0.0169345401,
0.4494520724,
-0.0877408013,
-0.9139789343,
0.5248345137,
-0.9511973858,
-0.4608393013,
0.7452555895,
-0.3982527852,
-0.2097734213,
-0.408437252,
-0.0222032052,
0.106754519,
-0.0226484258,
0.741151154,
0.192508772,
-0.540127337,
-0.6583226919,
-0.3610097468,
0.3151138425,
0.4846204817,
-1.1201922894,
-0.3621197939,
0.4360631108,
0.3769566417,
-0.0292637497,
0.6676853895,
-0.2600830495,
1.0523093939,
-0.2866966128,
-0.1337445527,
-0.2121105939,
-0.4940960109,
-0.4467050135,
0.0696299076,
-0.1669130474,
-0.7297766805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07616v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07616v1
|
Audio Dialogues: Dialogues dataset for audio and music understanding
| 2024-04-11T10:08:34 | 2024-04-11T10:08:34 |
Arushi Goel, Zhifeng Kong, Rafael Valle, Bryan Catanzaro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Existing datasets for audio understanding primarily focus on single-turn
interactions (i.e. audio captioning, audio question answering) for describing
audio in natural language, thus limiting understanding audio via interactive
dialogue. To address this gap, we introduce Audio Dialogues: a multi-turn
dialogue dataset containing 163.8k samples for general audio sounds and music.
In addition to dialogues, Audio Dialogues also has question-answer pairs to
understand and compare multiple input audios together. Audio Dialogues
leverages a prompting-based approach and caption annotations from existing
datasets to generate multi-turn dialogues using a Large Language Model (LLM).
We evaluate existing audio-augmented large language models on our proposed
dataset to demonstrate the complexity and applicability of Audio Dialogues. Our
code for generating the dataset will be made publicly available. Detailed
prompts and generated dialogues can be found on the demo website
https://audiodialogues.github.io/.
|
[
-0.5787309408,
-0.6794225574,
0.8336067796,
0.2645850778,
-0.1481852829,
0.1155828834,
-0.3673664629,
-0.4085250497,
0.2097709924,
0.8223454356,
-1.1402355433,
-0.705552578,
-0.1093384251,
0.1527028531,
-0.5232698917,
0.8861694932,
0.2416340262,
0.4179622531,
-0.3750773668,
-0.4060968459,
-0.6743657589,
-0.2220612317,
-0.7868252993,
-0.1210215166,
0.3983410597,
0.6987440586,
0.4942709804,
0.0378753804,
0.3237268329,
0.3383177519,
0.0715151429,
0.1659941226,
-0.2308142185,
0.3984434307,
0.331405133,
-0.3374019861,
-0.0523093939,
0.1363321394,
0.4733645022,
0.6815522313,
-0.1536384225,
0.3555576205,
-0.4103495479,
0.6871286631,
-0.1436197162,
0.4709044695,
-0.4264093637,
0.0930205286,
0.0410987735,
-0.2963045537,
-0.3570597172,
-0.2636649311,
0.2163847387,
-0.9398854375,
0.091590412,
0.1749791652,
0.2601038516,
0.273984164,
-0.0999974236,
-0.6529349685,
-1.008636713,
0.7614657879,
-0.5179188848,
0.2862911522,
0.6548662782,
0.703591764,
0.006950696,
-0.4578744471,
-0.822764039,
-0.0968965739,
0.2020663619,
0.2103457749,
-0.0147233009,
0.0587016568,
0.2683669329,
0.7413821816,
-0.4513698816,
-0.1824472696,
-0.2783662379,
-0.0093717463,
0.7566001415,
0.2936164737,
0.5700037479,
-0.2901198268,
0.0040739798,
-0.0753059089,
-0.5362451673,
0.1279064566,
0.6027778983,
0.4167199135,
-0.2487663627,
0.5549793839,
0.0565266646,
0.8682993054,
-0.0364173539,
-0.2555350065,
0.3515286744,
-0.8986837268,
-0.1453267038,
0.1856063008,
0.8663039804,
0.3671769202,
0.3502295017,
-0.1735432744,
-0.0547078848,
-0.2182800025,
-0.0096480828,
-0.4383545518,
-0.3109439015,
0.6930222511,
-0.2933758795,
-0.2435542345,
-0.0152275693,
-0.7842029333,
-0.6976184249,
-0.7015027404,
0.5597733259,
-0.383541882,
-0.2102827579,
0.2899469435,
-0.2377654761,
0.1545322835,
0.4686055779,
-0.8123802543,
0.4879898727,
0.4411670864,
0.761939764,
-0.0977862775,
-0.0735550523,
-0.7357189655,
0.032901749,
-0.0821934342,
0.7197283506,
-0.5971788168,
-0.5085366964,
0.0598455109,
-0.0553169549,
0.0715174526,
-0.6687108874,
0.4873827696,
-0.2462967783,
0.3083164096,
-0.0523322858,
-0.4319759011,
-0.2651796341,
-0.0356478989,
-0.9857863784,
0.6825304627,
-0.1420851499,
-0.5639921427,
0.1819409579,
-1.0520653725,
-0.3941298723,
-0.1284453124,
-0.2288209647,
-0.2780792415,
-0.0725386143,
0.6608344913,
0.1227835566,
-0.3120691478,
0.2316206843,
-0.1955961436,
-0.4900527596,
0.5909250379,
-0.425331831,
0.6497908235,
0.2963501811,
0.1047252044,
0.2676207721,
-0.7661896944,
-0.3664407432,
0.1887925714,
-0.1537285596,
0.0514374003,
0.0217567272,
0.2671833634,
-0.1175189391,
-0.1746228635,
-0.7037052512,
0.3049688637,
-0.1584151387,
0.8345098495,
0.3986655176,
0.2211221904,
0.392062664,
-0.353705585,
0.6103721261,
0.1023793966,
0.1411090642,
-0.8681459427,
-0.5406139493,
-0.4233525693,
-0.2093163729,
0.2984932065,
0.6806854606,
-0.5848496556,
0.2519460917,
-0.1720561832,
-0.1423732191,
-0.9899426103,
0.1983804852,
0.1696507931,
0.3295035064,
0.376221925,
-0.1652567834,
-0.6913311481,
-0.8050965071,
0.0201603267,
-0.2170021981,
-0.3358145654,
0.6898877621,
0.1774663776,
-0.056062907,
0.9168202877,
-0.2420064807,
-0.0993439481,
-0.4189814031,
0.3722855747,
0.4815936983,
0.3019571006,
0.3161009252,
-0.7433973551,
-0.1493947953,
-0.3788712323,
-0.4500575662,
-0.0277713053,
-0.3850910068,
0.0595446154,
-0.3329058588,
0.6128122211,
-0.6558744907,
0.0766413286,
0.6264522076,
0.0774202645,
0.4467202723,
0.470697552,
0.4831604958,
-1.0249937773,
-0.2484063059,
-0.1136499569,
-0.2675732076,
-0.6782140732,
-0.6628042459,
-0.5647425652,
-0.4227739275,
-0.3982564509,
0.2668237984,
-0.2665127516,
-0.4702175558,
-0.0547305085,
0.3408531249,
0.1336939037,
0.6103611588,
0.2027629316,
0.969598949,
0.7105208039,
-0.361541599,
0.6933660507,
0.7397328019,
-0.78498739,
0.5598080158,
-0.5379681587,
0.3846499622,
0.0134223374,
0.3346377909,
-1.3077501059,
-0.3449164629,
0.0909986794,
-0.5723231435,
0.2745756805,
-0.4159460962,
-0.547480762,
-0.2223442048,
-0.1679476053,
0.5854558349,
0.1323407143,
-0.6503042579,
0.6081034541,
0.5363987088,
-0.6747264862,
-0.2111105472,
-0.4925629795,
0.1950332969,
-0.2858112156,
-0.7906228304,
-0.133302778,
-0.4542502165,
-0.54605335,
-0.1852714568,
0.0571994968,
-0.1781338155,
-0.2592460513,
0.4426678717,
0.2376247495,
-0.200312078,
0.3768914342,
-0.0195023585,
-0.0720984712,
0.1356453151,
-0.3251110315,
0.4372291863,
-0.118407689,
-0.5073069334,
-0.5599372387,
0.6056422591,
0.7722716331,
-0.2080186754,
0.2212860137,
0.3730483651,
0.077343367,
0.2261644006,
-0.5022574663,
-0.1989454776,
-0.4199649096,
0.2167197913,
-0.3470640779,
-0.9136710763,
0.5289546847,
-0.0478745587,
0.3015621006,
0.0415056609,
0.5711759329,
-0.5128151774,
1.1897349358,
0.0870587751,
-0.193731159,
0.5648508072,
-0.2136053592,
0.090873234,
-0.7509889603,
-0.2441165745,
-0.4921077788,
-0.1862508506,
-0.4803729951,
-0.2737132609,
0.257966578,
-0.3579770029,
-0.1503079534,
0.2497130781,
-0.3143315911,
0.6215427518,
0.6844639778,
0.1121085882,
0.5071465373,
-0.0444217399,
0.0497620143,
0.1017905995,
-0.4833526611,
-0.1967196465,
1.1494810581,
0.4209867716,
0.7418674827,
0.1435462236,
0.4857574403,
0.2919124961,
-0.2684484422,
-1.1573630571,
0.240047276,
0.3310719728,
-0.7172474265,
-0.5680174828,
-0.4575157166,
-0.7445239425,
-0.185694918,
-0.2316447049,
-0.6991765499,
-0.0361337587,
-0.1030585766,
-0.4283011258,
0.1578761339,
-0.769045651,
0.6121803522,
-0.2262018472,
-0.0630728975,
-0.0373639651,
-0.6428399682,
0.2683091164,
0.1987859756,
0.6298245788,
-0.1666921526,
0.6256703138,
0.7599907517,
-0.1486494541,
0.5068200827,
-0.2291491181,
-0.025061436,
0.5610336661,
0.078157343,
0.0619730055,
0.4731592536,
0.1027464122,
0.1033049822,
0.0526457056,
-0.197573632,
-0.7268815041,
0.5503362417,
-0.6662550569,
-0.4252026975,
-0.0601793379,
-0.8977620006,
-0.5863123536,
-0.1094279438,
0.090406023,
0.7299178839,
0.0171171352,
0.2177956104,
0.7692755461,
-0.4762920439,
0.4307079613,
0.5824848413,
-0.4066307545,
-0.6941041946,
0.8070047498,
-0.3540982306,
0.2415066659,
0.1276708245,
0.0153692327,
-0.4520357847,
-0.5831502676,
-0.6994895339,
0.1728986204,
-0.5945903659,
0.0832763016,
-0.5461337566,
0.1067907065,
-0.2687908113,
0.2590768039,
-0.2824103534,
-0.6838948131,
0.0087503577,
-0.4125280678,
0.7971695065,
1.0230654478,
-0.172503233,
0.1961340457,
-0.8964250684,
0.6799268126,
0.6007634997,
0.4105849266,
-0.285521239,
-0.4819815755,
-0.335495472,
-0.0296843722,
-0.0233385805,
-1.0695943832,
0.0893209726,
0.1224780604,
0.3451514542,
0.3309625685,
-0.2005109191,
0.443500191,
-0.6119328141,
0.9336699247,
0.2984401584,
-0.9520252347,
0.7509467602,
-0.4637268186,
0.3994911313,
0.9114043117,
0.1645001769,
-0.7110548615,
-0.3809649646,
-0.4032604098,
-0.6551559567,
0.7944805026,
0.501999259,
0.101117447,
0.3150331378,
0.0556551255,
0.292167604,
0.3870676458,
-0.5218969584,
-0.4105321169,
-0.4499473274,
-0.3390617669,
-0.3049007654,
0.0006214213,
-0.4144321978,
-0.3924250603,
0.4622424245,
-0.0425799266,
0.3867076933,
0.1174586266,
-0.0343835577,
-0.0778069347,
0.4913639426,
0.5404137969,
0.3856345117,
-0.2805528939,
-0.1027655378,
-0.0168217719,
-0.5411758423,
0.1069352627,
0.0485698655,
0.222639963,
0.1082814112,
0.4274602234,
1.0466040373,
0.2775392234,
-0.7538794279,
0.2984491587,
-0.4238726795,
-0.2095007747,
-0.5886406302,
0.0557504632,
0.4372488856,
-0.0838241726,
0.2922558784,
-0.1387886554,
0.5453107357,
-0.7111759186,
0.2804072797,
0.0410423204,
-0.7171344161,
-0.100394614,
0.2984449565,
0.2870357633,
-0.3024710417,
0.9354165196,
0.1546921432,
-0.1788510829,
0.608006835,
0.1409292519,
0.9626689553,
0.0913156644,
0.253585577,
0.4873771369,
0.0442579947,
0.345969975,
0.4481641054,
-0.59813869,
-0.6049124002,
-0.6875839829,
-0.5388193727,
-1.0169422626,
0.5203233957,
-0.7439488173,
0.1218252182,
-0.2262001336,
0.0835766643,
0.2938093245,
-0.1921881437,
-0.4780168235,
-0.0207514502,
0.2280327678,
0.8340314627,
-1.021659255,
0.4911634028,
0.4355823696,
-0.710247457,
-0.6378903985,
-0.0826006755,
0.1091242582,
-0.4261333346,
0.2919105589,
0.2956300974,
-0.1897518486,
-0.2138363123,
-1.0862052441,
-0.4016979635,
0.7946389318,
0.1615422815,
-0.6406604648,
0.3646713197,
0.312161535,
0.3142985106,
-0.5318976045,
0.4230736494,
0.8013341427,
0.7402419448,
0.4450218081,
-0.8529613018,
-0.5812667608,
-0.5118629932,
-0.5105755329,
0.090494439,
-0.2470649183,
0.5218707323,
-0.2190928459,
-0.0354155079,
0.1924276501,
0.511995554,
0.3608465493,
0.656826973,
0.7518968582,
0.4176907539,
0.5436676741,
-0.3750329912,
1.0208138227,
-0.0485300571,
-0.0035926392,
1.4428099394,
-0.0905465111,
0.4848778248,
0.4965062439,
-0.2639153004,
0.4794952571,
0.8086239696,
0.102799207,
0.4270264804,
0.3733139038,
-0.4811603129,
-0.5880593061,
-0.1964962482,
-0.1708412915,
0.5162600279,
0.4343107045,
-0.0245114844,
0.2372106463,
0.2364983261,
-0.3946403563,
-0.0622447468,
-0.1518319696,
1.162869215,
0.0859428123,
-0.4531281292,
-0.0241233427,
-0.6441364288,
0.2042557895,
-0.4179987907,
-0.4965026975,
-0.0693788603,
-0.5210530162,
-0.180061698,
-1.1681377888,
0.0581026897,
0.0721221492,
-0.38851282,
-0.0845279843,
0.1862326711,
-0.7290381789,
-0.3695426285,
0.2334056199,
0.2504181564,
0.2691307962,
-0.1186318025,
-0.6090724468,
0.1328539401,
-0.0734617114,
-0.0322973691,
-0.06820786,
0.4297275841,
0.3326016665,
0.590188086,
0.6958294511,
-0.0268766358,
-0.016477963,
0.6606733799,
0.6307421327,
-0.4945434034,
-0.4617247581,
-0.2626226246,
0.4438612759,
-0.0093405889,
-0.0233631898,
0.5098572373,
0.6043605804,
0.642388165,
-0.1878186166,
1.0272051096,
0.2735713124,
0.8191631436,
-0.8638789058,
0.2327910066,
-0.516361773,
0.3314386606,
-0.3969846368,
-0.744636178,
-0.0279723108,
0.4810192287,
-0.2439315766,
0.0335426703,
0.3898065984,
0.6751328111,
-0.1833544523,
0.7562488317,
0.1810063124,
0.0906410366,
0.2081169635,
0.5415787697,
1.2339606285,
-0.3581120372,
0.7837461829,
-0.1780938804,
-0.0363385268,
0.0418554693,
-0.5639828444,
-0.8321870565,
-0.8037558794,
-0.2824493349,
-0.2797379494,
-0.142664969,
0.8313294053,
0.7344086766,
-1.2938379049,
-0.4182591736,
-0.1948270053,
0.1968465596,
-0.0681855083,
-0.2428150326,
0.1350642592,
-0.160218209,
-1.0958285332,
0.9808201194,
0.3634310067,
-0.0239182003,
-0.4408028126,
-0.2855246663,
-0.047965724,
0.2966549098,
0.3139426708,
0.4583028555,
-0.4709501266,
-0.1631025523,
0.0797820613,
0.3494927287,
0.3962594271,
1.1891169548,
-0.4715742171,
0.9390284419,
0.5097523928,
0.3680332005,
0.8508048654,
-0.1250049323,
0.746378541,
-0.6163438559,
0.0007236076,
0.2110151798,
0.296012938,
0.571810782,
-0.0717777982,
0.3628213406,
-0.0991740748,
-0.5000891089,
-0.632917583,
0.4706435204,
-1.3493349552,
-0.0551034547,
1.0417488813,
-0.0053759357,
-0.015214731,
-0.5191377997,
-0.5104553103,
0.2662913501,
-0.6528090835,
0.3782412112,
0.9601646066,
-0.3593512475,
-0.4076006413,
-0.7475219965,
0.575843513,
0.2248399705,
-0.7893844843,
0.2070928514,
0.7141780853,
-0.0520032458,
0.3225954771,
0.4897220731,
-0.3451050818,
0.4597334862,
-0.1278279424,
0.0529834889,
-0.2689006627,
-0.6200273037,
-0.503082931,
-0.0559506789,
-0.0791247562,
-0.4241994023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07613v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07613v1
|
Medical mT5: An Open-Source Multilingual Text-to-Text LLM for The Medical Domain
| 2024-04-11T10:01:32 | 2024-04-11T10:01:32 |
Iker García-Ferrero, Rodrigo Agerri, Aitziber Atutxa Salazar, Elena Cabrio, Iker de la Iglesia, Alberto Lavelli, Bernardo Magnini, Benjamin Molinet, Johana Ramirez-Romero, German Rigau, Jose Maria Villa-Gonzalez, Serena Villata, Andrea Zaninello
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Research on language technology for the development of medical applications
is currently a hot topic in Natural Language Understanding and Generation.
Thus, a number of large language models (LLMs) have recently been adapted to
the medical domain, so that they can be used as a tool for mediating in
human-AI interaction. While these LLMs display competitive performance on
automated medical texts benchmarks, they have been pre-trained and evaluated
with a focus on a single language (English mostly). This is particularly true
of text-to-text models, which typically require large amounts of
domain-specific pre-training data, often not easily accessible for many
languages. In this paper, we address these shortcomings by compiling, to the
best of our knowledge, the largest multilingual corpus for the medical domain
in four languages, namely English, French, Italian and Spanish. This new corpus
has been used to train Medical mT5, the first open-source text-to-text
multilingual model for the medical domain. Additionally, we present two new
evaluation benchmarks for all four languages with the aim of facilitating
multilingual research in this domain. A comprehensive evaluation shows that
Medical mT5 outperforms both encoders and similarly sized text-to-text models
for the Spanish, French, and Italian benchmarks, while being competitive with
current state-of-the-art LLMs in English.
|
[
-0.263966918,
-0.4039847553,
0.7748000622,
0.2371726483,
-0.3301556408,
0.0017145615,
-0.4110643566,
-0.6235843301,
0.1268652976,
0.5169324279,
-0.3102194071,
-0.9261436462,
-0.9272599816,
0.6769367456,
-0.1090647355,
0.8963468671,
-0.2794368863,
0.6220292449,
-0.4535241127,
-0.6682135463,
-0.2729007006,
-0.9411469698,
-0.4681212902,
-0.279289037,
0.8332448602,
0.2122325003,
0.3961496055,
0.7343315482,
0.8983556032,
0.249959439,
0.2922676802,
0.2908377945,
-0.234491691,
-0.0114978468,
-0.0870290399,
-0.3110391498,
-0.7043580413,
-0.2247290015,
0.6677951217,
0.7030693293,
-0.1561365426,
0.1279750466,
-0.2583827078,
0.5884443521,
-0.3767813742,
0.1358640641,
-0.4150772989,
0.0259711817,
-0.4114146531,
-0.4772010744,
-0.508649826,
-0.3106921315,
-0.0749473646,
-0.5238502622,
0.0095568029,
0.0082839774,
0.6337031722,
0.3636217713,
-0.5705379248,
-0.4684677124,
-0.4653632045,
0.6262210608,
-0.7043488026,
0.7338936925,
0.3943192661,
0.4281344414,
-0.0300745592,
-1.0458345413,
-0.4288145602,
-0.1978218406,
0.2146667242,
0.1628538072,
0.0064772139,
-0.0733360946,
-0.0980765149,
0.2368153632,
-0.6182525158,
0.2241705656,
-0.4940389097,
0.100575082,
0.2767530084,
0.1373334527,
0.4447594881,
0.2130177319,
-0.2257924974,
0.1246702299,
-0.9987915754,
-0.5643541217,
-0.0772858635,
0.1495069712,
-0.2435556799,
0.5886155963,
0.2489603013,
0.5063833594,
-0.3000672162,
-0.438680917,
0.6598918438,
-0.5210026503,
-0.2065973878,
-0.0814733282,
1.0543670654,
0.3657726645,
0.235850215,
-0.2100154907,
-0.014204694,
0.0350331664,
0.4464829862,
-0.9929908514,
-0.1464653462,
0.3795755506,
-0.6372933388,
-0.171343118,
-0.4129920304,
-0.4301994145,
-0.2313426435,
-0.0453375578,
0.1484496146,
-0.6292021871,
-0.0104597071,
0.2790186405,
0.2599450052,
-0.2123220116,
0.2262004316,
-0.7607837319,
0.2713070512,
0.3279450536,
0.715660274,
-0.4740182757,
-0.4724434316,
-0.391097337,
0.3147131801,
-0.353831619,
0.8607780337,
-0.4715457857,
-0.5134748816,
-0.0082071181,
0.1513666809,
0.0159143209,
-0.7967505455,
0.7696149349,
-0.2600427866,
0.5390530229,
0.0096189957,
-0.326613009,
-0.0913988128,
0.3902797699,
-0.7079012394,
0.7243984342,
-0.0012835814,
-0.693336904,
0.362403959,
-1.0444021225,
-0.5947329998,
0.0798324272,
-0.3066114187,
-0.7055188417,
0.0008052864,
0.4342833757,
0.4789973795,
-0.7434036136,
0.3579810858,
-0.2799289823,
-0.0634663552,
0.2800360322,
-0.3631034791,
0.4830613434,
0.2923855782,
0.075848572,
0.3597228229,
-0.8133029938,
-0.1394643039,
0.230430007,
-0.566482842,
-0.2721881866,
0.1117836088,
0.116600886,
0.2438660115,
0.2677538991,
-0.5006556511,
0.0533698201,
-0.525491178,
0.4150304794,
0.3247960806,
-0.1957253069,
0.0315409191,
-0.2815103829,
0.4691052437,
0.2248435616,
0.1878947169,
-0.4080191851,
-0.4643028975,
-0.3031114042,
-0.6614556313,
0.6412491202,
0.5231361985,
-0.8671805263,
0.0853881091,
-0.386457026,
-0.1875663698,
-1.0016109943,
0.0820965618,
0.3299281895,
0.4042896628,
0.5900235772,
-0.2654545605,
-0.5046391487,
-0.8422790766,
-0.1857999861,
0.1763372272,
0.0013701507,
0.1874869913,
0.4457632899,
-0.601847887,
0.393353194,
-0.221028477,
-0.4180721343,
-0.3562359214,
-0.1385895759,
0.1530151814,
0.3392585814,
0.7532212734,
-0.6088960171,
-0.4993339479,
0.3531614244,
-0.8948625326,
-0.055572167,
0.3104661703,
0.1188514531,
0.2050148398,
0.1918775737,
-0.3311672211,
0.0292643197,
0.8982492089,
-0.0396021232,
0.2480623871,
-0.7696685791,
0.299880147,
-1.5786808729,
0.4513789117,
-0.0014661029,
-0.391123265,
-0.5941810608,
0.1092709824,
0.2354634106,
0.0121771088,
-0.618413806,
0.6939823627,
-0.5826460719,
0.0556111112,
-0.203656584,
-0.0114418967,
-0.173776567,
0.1020490378,
0.0503514148,
0.7402409315,
0.4158479869,
-0.5295743346,
0.3234907091,
0.3864911795,
-0.2507503629,
0.6757507324,
-0.5406630635,
0.1291084737,
-0.1193321794,
0.096628651,
-0.4940011501,
-0.3056392968,
0.1586462259,
-0.6631392837,
0.2289570272,
-0.0389528237,
-0.7416984439,
-0.4291815758,
-0.170798704,
0.5075471401,
0.456458807,
-0.4654654562,
0.3366717398,
0.6659213901,
-0.2789649069,
-0.5216478109,
-0.7977564931,
0.2608991563,
-0.0770033449,
-0.4514032006,
0.2630099356,
-0.2855965495,
0.0962425098,
-0.1043306142,
0.2432334274,
-0.3557292223,
-0.1106270552,
0.0285696797,
0.3408212662,
-0.3794772029,
0.2353500128,
0.1166202798,
-0.2474295944,
-0.0069131698,
-0.3877345622,
0.4220090508,
0.20852907,
-0.5636617541,
-0.2492955476,
0.4280488193,
0.7548912764,
-0.4654788375,
0.8245106936,
0.416680187,
-0.4556598663,
0.1211351603,
-0.4556515217,
0.0992993563,
-0.3828364909,
0.5830913782,
-0.4851449132,
-0.819435358,
0.242697075,
-0.3561784029,
0.2563815713,
0.5146598816,
0.9861537218,
-0.0592176653,
1.1607165337,
0.6924241781,
0.1396636367,
0.0110763041,
0.2581197917,
-0.0957943052,
-0.6005892158,
-0.2830545306,
-0.6001964211,
-0.0733607337,
-0.4953354001,
-0.6016583443,
0.7118373513,
-0.4604478776,
0.0448348746,
0.0397796445,
-0.4155071974,
0.3439605236,
0.2615667582,
-0.0327810831,
0.5551867485,
0.1052102074,
-0.5790599585,
-0.0903804824,
-0.8148964047,
-0.5618604422,
1.4196732044,
0.4597734511,
0.561188519,
0.084739022,
0.5219704509,
-0.1372278482,
0.6849011183,
-0.5871345997,
0.2227672487,
-0.6993688345,
-0.5716734529,
0.1366890371,
-0.4967945218,
-1.2937464714,
0.2619017959,
-0.2746492028,
-0.1270835251,
-0.366351217,
0.0940397084,
-0.187011987,
0.3250238895,
-0.610132575,
1.0414890051,
-0.4631252885,
-0.1907478273,
-0.1667007804,
-0.7590200305,
0.2020189613,
-0.3861811459,
0.5237306952,
-0.0348568596,
-0.1966500133,
0.435315907,
-0.3385217488,
0.6187025905,
0.049352739,
-0.0923237279,
-0.1382194906,
-0.2890854776,
0.0379745327,
-0.0784165114,
-0.0184156671,
0.4559607506,
0.3428452909,
-0.4134106636,
-0.181593135,
0.601067245,
-0.7694245577,
-0.0943846628,
-0.4491781592,
-0.4161877632,
-0.3671196699,
0.4870917201,
0.2882097363,
0.4987142682,
-0.5236460567,
0.1715915352,
0.6169881821,
-0.7233710885,
0.107799381,
0.7268174887,
-0.5063723326,
-0.6748014688,
0.8684269786,
-0.037485633,
0.2084070146,
0.5380064845,
0.1164235845,
-0.3696711361,
-0.8875391483,
-0.8693531752,
0.5520454645,
-0.5406198502,
-0.0635349825,
-0.7022148371,
-0.063359201,
-0.3447710276,
0.0578302369,
-0.4069086611,
-0.1128613725,
-0.1152125001,
0.039390862,
0.2164434493,
0.893304646,
0.2398415804,
0.1275265366,
-1.1812198162,
0.5185234547,
-0.3416284621,
0.6211604476,
-0.4929671884,
-0.1741873026,
-0.5234167576,
-0.086896047,
-0.2226177007,
-0.7424567938,
0.5194113851,
-0.0320418179,
0.6088804603,
0.3053633273,
-0.2971610129,
0.3877669275,
-1.0321747065,
0.5334385037,
0.5038172603,
-0.5174018145,
0.3251909614,
-0.2549130023,
0.5073133111,
0.4829781353,
0.4955420494,
-0.6208171844,
-0.2810505629,
-0.4282187521,
-0.6057878137,
0.4843936563,
-0.0050079753,
-0.0008769092,
-0.1557332277,
0.0897351205,
0.3661824763,
0.432163924,
-0.6565567851,
-0.1871572286,
-0.006490645,
-0.8425219059,
-0.1546245664,
-0.0876863152,
-0.299521178,
-0.0866017044,
0.3796828389,
-0.3112247586,
0.5483828187,
0.0505273603,
-0.1466483325,
0.0740147009,
0.2641184032,
0.8824603558,
0.637411356,
0.0515746586,
0.1339847296,
0.3588499725,
-0.7459716797,
0.0357696265,
0.2266364247,
0.1929851919,
0.1948688924,
0.3358124495,
0.7122502327,
0.0732438043,
-0.9230992198,
0.5290195942,
-0.1185569763,
-0.341147989,
-0.1628457308,
-0.4182218611,
0.2926599383,
-0.030691877,
-0.0532481447,
0.0685512722,
-0.0226536803,
-0.5598832369,
0.1875880808,
0.294580549,
-0.3010011017,
-0.4795898795,
0.8751435876,
0.4283139706,
-0.0642980859,
0.2901566923,
0.1691411287,
-0.2991316915,
0.2654572427,
0.6163859367,
0.5794827342,
-0.5112704635,
-0.2346022427,
0.2561469078,
0.3155448735,
-0.1223478094,
0.5280718207,
0.4624490142,
-0.6220958233,
-0.6317346692,
-0.4118623734,
-0.4719002843,
0.042141933,
-0.1964695305,
0.4735024273,
-0.2866071463,
-0.3032771349,
0.0494031906,
-0.3197396696,
-0.6256046295,
0.3859598935,
0.0392039567,
0.7857141495,
-0.1918919384,
1.294731617,
0.9136214852,
-0.4273060262,
-0.3648423254,
-0.251593411,
-0.1410651058,
-1.0274730921,
0.5103472471,
0.0055228416,
-0.0727187619,
-0.0482542887,
-0.320661515,
-0.4579335153,
0.9055690169,
0.6211368442,
-0.4392005503,
-0.2458565682,
0.4546797872,
0.7042898536,
-0.5309396982,
0.2966160774,
0.2209891528,
0.3616538346,
-0.0006144795,
-1.2188622952,
-0.0778416619,
-0.3096966743,
-0.3455195725,
0.3320053518,
-0.5487041473,
0.6046843529,
-0.3078910112,
0.044008024,
0.083067365,
0.3290296495,
0.2054781467,
0.3690542877,
0.0139776394,
0.4600912929,
0.715913415,
-0.1104361862,
1.2614566088,
-0.739977479,
0.1040177122,
0.8563330173,
-0.5056726933,
0.9399905801,
0.3068171144,
-0.1241810098,
0.2114168257,
0.5163316727,
0.1450076848,
0.3439619839,
0.0175413862,
-0.437125206,
0.1085740626,
0.071976915,
-0.571141839,
0.2131304592,
0.5050694346,
-0.6341060996,
0.0622300543,
0.1986966282,
0.1915857345,
-0.0616242774,
-0.1534006,
0.8709971309,
0.2910214067,
-0.4785020053,
0.6344425082,
0.3294427395,
0.4914360344,
-0.8097102642,
0.0751159489,
-0.0009529497,
0.3178414702,
-0.1612268984,
-0.5676475167,
0.3646761775,
0.2593114972,
-0.1347879022,
-0.2855762541,
0.592941761,
-0.6228640079,
-0.5890259743,
0.2871749401,
0.688831985,
0.3411305547,
0.2190656513,
-0.5067604184,
0.1475490481,
-0.1594088525,
0.0720486119,
0.4152094722,
0.6122071147,
0.0203830861,
0.7014586926,
0.7825545669,
0.394772768,
-0.0481785536,
0.2157487571,
0.7018142343,
-0.6655842662,
-0.3659449518,
-0.9318796992,
0.3360258043,
0.0718583241,
-0.2731228471,
0.4417991936,
0.8019157052,
0.5871599913,
-0.142985478,
0.9982911944,
0.3736647666,
0.920201838,
-0.5671780705,
0.9467511177,
-0.7530242205,
0.1323764473,
0.0596311651,
-0.5467932224,
-0.7350678444,
0.4556960166,
0.0069240276,
0.0908061117,
1.164019227,
0.3646050692,
-0.005515446,
-0.1779528409,
0.5969874263,
0.29599154,
0.1496492475,
0.6898577213,
0.5495910645,
-0.2297748774,
0.4947400093,
0.2771783471,
-0.0976850986,
-0.1564605087,
-0.7265203595,
-0.9682263136,
-0.4041024446,
-0.087320812,
-0.2768731117,
0.2169209719,
1.1650161743,
0.6382799149,
-0.7391776443,
-0.2884839177,
0.3805521727,
-0.1733111739,
-0.0326350145,
0.0166348778,
0.1876998693,
-0.2031743973,
-0.8678901196,
0.5944868922,
0.6631891131,
0.0417273454,
-0.3050814867,
-0.2251243889,
-0.0628783256,
0.0378869548,
0.7314373851,
0.0775730833,
-0.5687890649,
-0.0480869673,
0.1747911274,
-0.4519925117,
0.6273251176,
0.832644999,
-0.6295542121,
0.5207642913,
0.1541173756,
0.8939589858,
0.4493407309,
-0.3071140349,
0.8236552477,
-0.4701946378,
-0.0568606816,
0.240059644,
0.4547466338,
0.4592434168,
0.0208800416,
0.6072036624,
0.3316390216,
-0.4661130309,
-0.7411026359,
-0.0118048377,
-0.7701172829,
-0.3566531539,
0.9551643133,
-0.1149586439,
-0.0880308896,
-0.1160804927,
-0.3656537235,
0.4065470099,
-0.0815092251,
0.5680624843,
0.6922801137,
-0.0158532094,
-0.1316755414,
-1.0847226381,
0.3786107004,
0.3166500032,
-1.3227219582,
-0.3548205793,
0.3611760139,
0.3991596699,
-0.0700803399,
0.973175168,
-0.4952379167,
0.2253448367,
-0.3125887513,
0.3628355861,
-0.0126312757,
-0.3480773568,
-0.256963104,
0.3233964145,
0.2555175126,
-0.224093318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07611v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07611v2
|
NoticIA: A Clickbait Article Summarization Dataset in Spanish
| 2024-04-11T09:59:01 | 2024-05-31T15:19:18 |
Iker García-Ferrero, Begoña Altuna
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present NoticIA, a dataset consisting of 850 Spanish news articles
featuring prominent clickbait headlines, each paired with high-quality,
single-sentence generative summarizations written by humans. This task demands
advanced text understanding and summarization abilities, challenging the
models' capacity to infer and connect diverse pieces of information to meet the
user's informational needs generated by the clickbait headline. We evaluate the
Spanish text comprehension capabilities of a wide range of state-of-the-art
large language models. Additionally, we use the dataset to train
ClickbaitFighter, a task-specific model that achieves near-human performance in
this task.
|
[
-0.0679972619,
-0.3863344193,
0.2858346403,
0.7897758484,
-0.2410185337,
0.2072457075,
0.0107801734,
-0.4079674482,
0.3847534657,
0.5997114778,
-0.5421091318,
-0.6645143628,
-0.5884797573,
0.4883061945,
-0.7629538178,
1.4469468594,
0.2124814987,
-0.017113639,
-0.3786299825,
0.0291980244,
-0.1205979362,
0.1560250372,
-0.5508754849,
-0.0770581067,
0.5919177532,
0.4237468243,
0.6617844105,
0.4416297674,
0.3342995048,
0.1765846312,
0.0327790827,
0.0427499972,
-0.8217448592,
-0.3561547995,
-0.5104279518,
-0.5297403932,
-0.4828894436,
-0.1231615394,
0.40698874,
1.0036457777,
0.0337044187,
0.2771495283,
-0.1398514658,
0.9103310704,
-0.338291347,
0.1174790412,
-0.519107461,
-0.2317543775,
-0.0908309221,
-0.2938378453,
-0.4274370372,
-0.6925637722,
0.2689472735,
-0.6382091641,
0.5297264457,
0.299546212,
0.8692669272,
0.8600580096,
-0.6981897354,
-0.3846130967,
-0.3053990901,
0.5534070134,
-0.363101989,
0.3858807683,
0.6123213768,
-0.0408497006,
-0.1234756485,
-0.3406835794,
-0.1349911094,
-0.3443240225,
-0.0457115434,
0.2650023401,
-0.4484380782,
-0.1167487353,
0.0572469085,
0.2764383256,
-0.8661536574,
-0.021621624,
-0.8233434558,
-0.0123187499,
0.7143217921,
0.1013602614,
0.3711578846,
-0.2741323709,
-0.2931065559,
0.1343366653,
-0.6793135405,
-0.1356750876,
0.8018245697,
0.0710458905,
-0.2382278442,
0.4625827074,
-0.48351717,
0.7786706686,
0.0815123767,
-0.3205801249,
0.3690565228,
-0.1481663287,
-0.4703191519,
0.1079885662,
0.7663822174,
0.5726972222,
0.319114089,
-0.6720517278,
0.1008646041,
-0.0921254084,
0.4629520178,
-0.5501938462,
-0.1911971271,
0.6803114414,
-0.4973427057,
-0.816383183,
0.2697132826,
-0.9616057277,
-0.3478192091,
0.0170540251,
0.4155621827,
-0.2319280505,
-0.2024370432,
0.5029408336,
-0.4712925553,
-0.1779824346,
0.0881889313,
-0.8186819553,
0.1689544767,
0.1185506508,
0.6332720518,
-0.3910717368,
-0.6210663915,
-0.2485460788,
0.1602683216,
-0.3810103536,
1.0026960373,
-0.2660228014,
-0.2483886927,
-0.2642698586,
0.1256041527,
-0.5583972335,
-0.4147006273,
0.6631668806,
-0.7737264037,
0.3061772287,
-0.3520809412,
-0.1790847033,
-0.6427170038,
0.104607217,
-1.1251734495,
0.8892498612,
0.1076241434,
-0.9724259973,
0.3151710629,
-0.8199189305,
-0.8860225677,
-0.2391889989,
0.2792404294,
-0.1181008592,
0.2721118927,
0.2859885395,
0.3609279096,
-0.2893046439,
0.4829897881,
0.2693945467,
-0.2220997214,
0.2878412604,
-0.3180379868,
0.7500597835,
-0.0149344141,
-0.3014127314,
0.035490714,
-0.757153213,
-0.5842769742,
0.0759834573,
-0.683668375,
-0.2311639637,
-0.1661347151,
0.2820365131,
0.2189620435,
0.5941524506,
-0.3656071723,
-0.0321160182,
-0.4728039205,
0.1779769063,
0.1368840188,
0.0754342824,
0.3886376023,
-0.5588614941,
0.6927890182,
-0.2107981592,
0.1317259669,
-0.4090532362,
-0.2199846506,
-0.5636436343,
0.1199127659,
0.4867808819,
0.755351603,
-1.0664845705,
0.0324194841,
-0.4855474234,
-0.4667359293,
-0.2758434713,
0.166045323,
0.5038251281,
0.6975695491,
0.3654800653,
0.2504946887,
-0.6269597411,
-0.7269412875,
-0.3667576611,
0.0384523757,
-0.0783358067,
0.0322714671,
0.9597896338,
0.3289532959,
0.8280957341,
-0.4048018157,
-0.6811203957,
-0.6658785939,
0.4644248784,
0.4437630475,
-0.0789254382,
0.7583462,
-1.1068668365,
-0.3477132022,
-0.2367202193,
-0.9961746931,
-0.2563434839,
-0.2640130818,
0.287360847,
0.0712506473,
0.6335666776,
-0.1623822302,
0.2908048928,
0.8238489032,
-0.5082552433,
0.5100415349,
-0.4594619274,
0.4926117063,
-1.0410654545,
0.4356767237,
0.242260173,
-0.236690104,
-0.6144556999,
-0.1961528957,
0.217561245,
0.127074942,
-0.7898490429,
0.3434724212,
-0.4030641913,
-0.181655407,
-0.4671550691,
-0.0369229764,
0.1535433829,
0.3834238946,
0.3821522892,
1.0253624916,
0.3559799194,
-0.6483256817,
0.3355942667,
0.4915548861,
-0.2919275463,
0.6355271935,
-1.0566936731,
-0.4522126317,
-0.6615985632,
0.3629446328,
-1.0502715111,
-0.7722872496,
-0.1983630955,
-0.6319483519,
-0.1358044147,
-0.1341572851,
-0.5972523689,
-0.416441977,
-0.6348888874,
0.2445510328,
0.081914492,
-0.4828639925,
0.3612143099,
0.4509800971,
-0.1420847178,
-0.591408968,
-0.7164714336,
0.3813494146,
-0.3366989493,
-0.4758966267,
0.3758134842,
0.1184040457,
-0.0452665947,
0.1355189532,
0.0432487465,
-0.1007438377,
0.0682852566,
0.1515260041,
0.0822827369,
-0.0160330702,
0.2015272826,
0.312219739,
-0.1554656774,
0.064412035,
-0.2127104998,
0.4981566966,
0.3537791669,
-0.0271091405,
-0.5581350923,
0.2494663298,
0.7408923507,
-0.3472351432,
0.9059084058,
0.1747777313,
-0.2173503041,
-0.0385972746,
-0.4559650421,
0.1030865461,
-0.3481199741,
0.3706024587,
-0.2152071744,
-0.4388087094,
0.4916778505,
0.0977438316,
0.1206766441,
0.5980252028,
0.4176474214,
-0.2059294134,
0.8464587927,
0.6881771088,
-0.3091213703,
0.1882452965,
-0.3694460988,
-0.1664792597,
-0.4772135019,
-0.5478876829,
-0.4173561931,
-0.4768228233,
-0.1010378152,
-0.2543037832,
0.4121439457,
-0.3590734005,
0.3178328872,
0.475646466,
-0.0212144088,
0.8893525004,
0.5391157866,
0.1236271784,
0.7588196993,
-0.1674201936,
0.4982881248,
0.1168706119,
-0.6214499474,
-0.4682886302,
1.1757676601,
0.1634084582,
0.9973644614,
0.2278203368,
0.3201467693,
0.6250193715,
-0.1184640229,
-0.6519846916,
0.1782887131,
-0.3361557424,
-0.6746433377,
-0.1667793989,
-0.2940172255,
-1.1720505953,
0.3238127232,
-0.131549716,
-0.6172312498,
0.1546610147,
0.020229185,
-0.4735963047,
0.2139496803,
-0.5947211385,
0.8658364415,
-0.1690877676,
0.0478794239,
-0.2047897428,
-0.5902411938,
0.3250493705,
-0.0227283314,
0.2827256322,
-0.0240859911,
-0.5922820568,
1.0501996279,
0.0104625262,
0.8305472136,
0.2576210797,
0.0296027213,
-0.0502149425,
0.0365814939,
0.2894806266,
-0.0203228574,
-0.0965568423,
-0.0222360119,
-0.1511410028,
-0.5851262808,
-0.1174529567,
0.4674675763,
-0.5485432744,
-0.0137447054,
-0.4000922143,
-0.6747655272,
-0.1241886541,
0.2367473543,
0.5840649605,
0.4410240352,
-0.5125905871,
0.1522426307,
0.8854364157,
-0.1046651304,
0.6513231993,
0.6559482813,
0.0265354719,
-0.3784709871,
1.0858368874,
0.0777637139,
-0.1232878417,
0.4751516581,
-0.2372767329,
-0.590010643,
-0.8798702359,
-0.6441121101,
0.6063244939,
-0.2978734076,
-0.1043097451,
-0.994599402,
0.11741025,
-0.2789550722,
-0.1543812454,
-0.1513472944,
-0.2906672955,
-0.5322173834,
-0.3794535995,
0.2674144506,
1.1219259501,
0.1232483685,
0.5383375883,
-0.7588235736,
0.6229894161,
-0.0329503417,
0.1994194835,
-0.0568822175,
-0.5572162271,
-0.3195519745,
-0.3325175643,
-0.1336461008,
-1.369784236,
0.4763513505,
0.0755164251,
0.4548433423,
0.6042702198,
0.1373877376,
0.1852450669,
-0.0692215189,
0.6601996422,
-0.1093618721,
-0.7383593917,
0.6377114058,
-0.9482157826,
0.3034263253,
0.9563884139,
0.7872216702,
-0.2765666246,
-0.4857223928,
-0.7021003962,
-0.7496200204,
0.8637809753,
0.3538864553,
0.1719446033,
-0.020239586,
-0.0605766103,
0.3538494408,
0.7007990479,
-0.6708316803,
-0.1794599295,
-0.0550508685,
-0.4299499989,
-0.0324492641,
-0.416769594,
0.2164718062,
0.0382731408,
0.7907469869,
-0.0187686402,
-0.3454211056,
-0.0161929093,
-0.760938406,
0.1046320796,
0.0225818716,
0.7805302143,
1.1228291988,
-0.236998722,
-0.1340726465,
0.1807925105,
-0.5871149898,
-0.1295648664,
0.0558798648,
-0.2742320895,
0.1931974739,
0.4887173176,
0.6852494478,
0.7611138821,
-0.8687804937,
0.644298315,
-0.0928777009,
-0.4408710599,
-0.1726144105,
-0.0617980473,
-0.0250012223,
0.1769382656,
0.815973103,
-0.1763619334,
0.4832573533,
-0.3528894186,
0.1369774789,
-0.081283778,
-0.2329842299,
-0.4634338319,
1.0909754038,
0.452152282,
0.22878699,
0.1439058632,
-0.1882250458,
-0.4244988263,
0.8694625497,
0.4072518349,
0.4574300349,
-0.037445154,
0.7797527313,
0.4377920926,
0.4137111604,
-0.4786410332,
0.3802185655,
0.0334108248,
-0.3781640232,
-0.6115605831,
-0.4225251377,
-0.4626618326,
0.1647638679,
-0.605222106,
0.1632920355,
-0.1396041363,
0.1819736063,
0.0703008696,
-0.0757156834,
-0.3414592445,
0.328551501,
-0.2831281424,
1.2024496794,
-1.3833050728,
0.4588102698,
0.8502981067,
-0.8353521824,
-0.1150984019,
0.1773793548,
-0.1179099753,
-0.6079775095,
0.2886401415,
0.0548209399,
-0.0331036896,
0.2545469105,
-0.4112967849,
-0.8121177554,
0.9808869362,
0.5615996122,
-0.0508020595,
-0.506223917,
0.0356903635,
0.4619575739,
-0.1040807515,
0.2243548036,
0.9392783642,
0.567506671,
0.2997536063,
-1.0766897202,
-0.302264154,
-0.099814333,
-0.3688339889,
0.218620494,
-0.8981317282,
0.7477900386,
-0.3382816613,
-0.000544928,
-0.0763578862,
0.7080498338,
-0.1596891284,
0.5073916316,
0.3698650301,
0.6009577513,
0.7184295654,
-0.0553023927,
1.0601276159,
-0.0506759323,
0.3227359653,
1.1531221867,
0.3775214553,
0.5915153027,
0.3428007662,
-0.1630222946,
0.3904167712,
0.6298672557,
-0.0587336496,
0.6440132856,
-0.3427616656,
-0.0371623263,
-0.190006569,
-0.3710385859,
-0.1178072914,
0.6795947552,
0.1562595516,
-0.5124283433,
-0.7321434021,
0.3491978049,
0.3903984427,
0.2299493849,
-0.5531086922,
0.9444454908,
-0.3435060084,
-0.6814631224,
0.1809026748,
0.0489105769,
0.686999917,
-0.2208506912,
0.3163970709,
-0.2211667448,
-0.3114962578,
-0.5618207455,
-0.6735622287,
0.4580952227,
0.3161750436,
-0.4890565872,
-0.0590391532,
0.3919778764,
-0.3637623489,
-0.5860009193,
0.0211984385,
0.5998669863,
0.5009624958,
-0.4844060242,
-0.5046671629,
0.0291632935,
0.111178875,
-0.1487778574,
0.0112595186,
0.0936026126,
-0.1286160797,
0.5549798012,
0.6319132447,
0.1389361471,
0.0213836487,
0.3557703197,
0.7496540546,
-0.7236993313,
-0.8356873393,
-0.835072577,
0.5630435348,
-0.2378931642,
-0.2880494893,
0.6777223945,
0.8994489908,
0.4835291803,
-0.2679450214,
0.885940671,
-0.1075391471,
0.4733379781,
-0.439445287,
0.8871275783,
-0.5837781429,
-0.2956853211,
0.0390898138,
-0.7242955565,
-0.3380348384,
0.3096141219,
-0.5150501728,
-0.0315168761,
0.7153525352,
0.4402578473,
-0.2504180372,
0.0663305745,
0.3746411204,
0.2513018847,
-0.1777882725,
0.6905422211,
0.5182979703,
-0.4833012819,
0.9054728746,
-0.0143779851,
-0.2883550227,
-0.5723592043,
-1.0106130838,
-1.4434323311,
-0.6864645481,
-0.3179334104,
0.0013930713,
0.0251463652,
0.6502590775,
0.511803925,
-0.7616475224,
-0.0591221154,
0.0154398577,
0.4263220131,
0.1040774062,
-0.2078822404,
0.4387144446,
-0.252383858,
-1.088830471,
0.5373568535,
0.235225454,
-0.0057614008,
-0.2839968204,
0.3516821563,
-0.0726870969,
0.1759018898,
0.4652175903,
0.4605304301,
-0.2882091999,
0.2386179715,
0.0511668921,
0.068781741,
-0.0495714583,
0.6725130081,
-0.9850962162,
0.1570062488,
0.6967823505,
0.4266882539,
0.4197436869,
0.3146072328,
0.3455488682,
-0.7704719901,
0.3412718475,
-0.0692402646,
0.1787489355,
0.3740313649,
-0.421154201,
0.4519574046,
-0.1062919274,
-0.1763512194,
-0.696171999,
-0.0509686433,
-0.9384093285,
-0.1624549329,
0.9974434972,
0.226886332,
-0.5309020281,
-0.5336698294,
-0.3588711917,
-0.0076495539,
-0.6757376194,
0.9004297853,
0.5047723651,
-0.0074619246,
-0.1447377801,
-0.7216832638,
0.5568588972,
0.038498912,
-1.0255304575,
-0.2041117847,
0.3845426142,
0.5190881491,
-0.0085589206,
0.6830648184,
-0.0526354685,
0.661816895,
-0.1350760758,
-0.2277035117,
-0.3557325304,
-0.6907073259,
-0.2294508219,
0.4630883038,
-0.3275904953,
-0.3276929855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07584v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07584v1
|
UltraEval: A Lightweight Platform for Flexible and Comprehensive Evaluation for LLMs
| 2024-04-11T09:17:12 | 2024-04-11T09:17:12 |
Chaoqun He, Renjie Luo, Shengding Hu, Yuanqian Zhao, Jie Zhou, Hanghao Wu, Jiajie Zhang, Xu Han, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Evaluation is pivotal for honing Large Language Models (LLMs), pinpointing
their capabilities and guiding enhancements. The rapid development of LLMs
calls for a lightweight and easy-to-use framework for swift evaluation
deployment. However, due to the various implementation details to consider,
developing a comprehensive evaluation platform is never easy. Existing
platforms are often complex and poorly modularized, hindering seamless
incorporation into researcher's workflows. This paper introduces UltraEval, a
user-friendly evaluation framework characterized by lightweight,
comprehensiveness, modularity, and efficiency. We identify and reimplement
three core components of model evaluation (models, data, and metrics). The
resulting composability allows for the free combination of different models,
tasks, prompts, and metrics within a unified evaluation workflow. Additionally,
UltraEval supports diverse models owing to a unified HTTP service and provides
sufficient inference acceleration. UltraEval is now available for researchers
publicly~\footnote{Website is at \url{https://github.com/OpenBMB/UltraEval}}.
|
[
-0.0029430105,
-0.5914044976,
0.4917344451,
0.4924405217,
-0.2342114002,
0.2582198679,
-0.4588665366,
-0.2154841274,
-0.0358823277,
0.3467389345,
-0.2366456091,
-0.54332757,
-0.1149522066,
-0.1541461498,
-0.6188880205,
0.8795168996,
-0.0078821601,
0.2339156568,
-0.2830414772,
-0.2862794697,
0.0344757438,
-0.4215973914,
0.0052513457,
-0.5689106584,
0.1831894219,
0.432218045,
0.6956812143,
0.4912549257,
0.8044814467,
0.3234917223,
-0.1451637149,
-0.1154193953,
-0.6052609682,
0.3932348788,
-0.3159038126,
-0.2107526958,
-0.5085699558,
-0.2947001159,
0.7211503386,
0.9459596872,
-0.4394682646,
0.6212007999,
0.2303976864,
0.6463322639,
-0.8324176669,
-0.2059232295,
-0.5857810378,
-0.0895129517,
-0.2199642658,
-0.0068853823,
-0.39852795,
-0.266694963,
0.1136095002,
-0.2823641896,
-0.1325612217,
0.0615812019,
0.2509271204,
-0.1020138785,
-0.251369983,
0.1244683936,
-0.7057661414,
0.8328106999,
-0.6315698624,
0.6135435104,
-0.2632894814,
0.5326895118,
-0.1131004244,
-1.0088694096,
-0.3239346147,
-0.5281350017,
0.3572342992,
-0.0653194413,
-0.2748179734,
0.1091231406,
-0.1588089466,
0.4249245822,
-0.4420191646,
0.2180413455,
0.0837681293,
-0.1560512036,
0.2379410863,
0.5121164322,
0.2892505825,
-0.4067613482,
-0.4272085428,
0.3740861416,
-0.7233712077,
-0.0373330228,
0.0368015803,
0.6482123137,
-0.1905901879,
0.6435810328,
-0.3317373693,
0.3655364513,
-0.3284671307,
0.0293768551,
0.3212186396,
-0.3093800247,
-0.4646466076,
-0.3501789272,
0.9474532008,
0.1716884226,
-0.2750276923,
-0.0835292935,
-0.6560189724,
-0.1303016692,
0.0927887857,
-0.8716555834,
-0.1708286107,
0.1309150904,
-0.9180409908,
-0.4328898489,
-0.0889066085,
-0.8300487399,
-0.563792944,
-0.1448949724,
0.3687770665,
-0.0347356126,
-0.2307154685,
0.094022736,
0.2759349644,
-0.0401418582,
0.3180215359,
-0.8035274148,
0.358861804,
0.6197255254,
0.7969408631,
-0.2725756168,
-0.2735908329,
-0.4821237624,
-0.0230649021,
-0.2194580734,
0.7919480205,
-0.7616074681,
-0.5991134048,
0.0692614242,
-0.1209142134,
0.0701812729,
-0.4243195355,
0.9158656597,
-0.4786196649,
-0.2917955518,
-0.0248158295,
-0.4262726307,
0.1111602709,
0.0403740518,
-0.4961007833,
1.3226280212,
0.3592498302,
-0.7057341933,
0.0994487256,
-0.8737869263,
-0.2203630954,
0.7059870362,
-0.0976409316,
0.0122999176,
0.3837191164,
0.0918533206,
0.5119994283,
-0.5861669779,
0.2818842828,
-0.5689896941,
-0.5557413697,
0.1207078844,
-0.4238135219,
0.7256425023,
0.3798250258,
-0.5407548547,
0.4747343659,
-0.824657321,
0.1165247038,
0.0242904481,
-0.5637255311,
-0.3127701283,
-0.0481488556,
0.6164656281,
-0.1998543441,
0.3823592961,
-0.5476102829,
0.1518966556,
-0.1458431482,
0.2084937394,
0.7708700299,
-0.2789949179,
0.235670343,
0.1490505785,
0.6575828195,
-0.5109390616,
0.4682565033,
0.0139081115,
0.0418392271,
-0.7689116001,
-0.5269715786,
0.5525185466,
0.5223553181,
-0.4770025909,
0.5234047771,
-0.4052684307,
-0.7513127923,
-0.7558594942,
0.502556324,
0.5569945574,
0.5074602365,
0.0897253081,
0.0065490608,
-0.7694280148,
-0.7902561426,
-0.0826850384,
-0.2935969234,
-0.2629792988,
0.1664257944,
0.6417478323,
-0.6107699871,
0.6550828218,
-0.0906697214,
0.065054737,
-0.6793551445,
0.1019546688,
0.147108689,
0.4451690316,
0.3321906626,
-0.4816507399,
-0.258924067,
0.0710425973,
-0.8175336123,
-0.2553567588,
0.2109549642,
-0.020487437,
-0.0859235153,
0.2273332924,
-0.3342109621,
0.0232510995,
0.435980022,
-0.1141318977,
0.7318227291,
-0.1448213458,
0.0844544172,
-0.8635446429,
0.316552788,
-0.2051491737,
-0.3541350365,
-0.3690744936,
0.4770497978,
0.1072833538,
-0.1153971329,
-0.6062909961,
0.5737355351,
-0.4458377063,
-0.2658093572,
-0.0315290168,
0.3534606695,
-0.050939288,
-0.2794266939,
-0.1990566999,
0.7934705615,
0.7312605977,
-0.2915207744,
0.5567513704,
0.1693459153,
-0.693307519,
0.5429077744,
-0.8181822896,
0.1323705167,
0.3137665987,
0.163239494,
-0.7945764065,
-0.1091706678,
-0.2904365361,
-0.2624565661,
-0.0688283667,
-0.1620472819,
-0.5125082731,
-0.3162923753,
-0.6777715683,
0.2269904017,
0.4874660969,
-0.810340941,
0.5325186849,
0.4583466053,
-0.1529776454,
-0.5962489843,
-0.648935616,
0.2816041708,
-0.0172459986,
-0.528698504,
-0.0668328628,
-0.1985572577,
-0.370552361,
-0.0263705384,
-0.0842982009,
0.1136140898,
0.2476289868,
0.2399365157,
0.6323370337,
-0.3774577677,
0.0084484071,
-0.2425463945,
-0.0796044841,
-0.2682261765,
-0.2358306199,
0.3011002243,
-0.6467180252,
-0.522270143,
-0.4783367515,
0.1350273788,
0.7460352182,
-0.1273843944,
0.2450628132,
0.3618741333,
-0.2929835916,
-0.3067615032,
-0.7100747228,
0.2204449624,
-0.483772397,
0.428314656,
-0.4285230935,
-0.985550344,
0.5667777658,
-0.3195694089,
0.1510979682,
0.3966184556,
0.8170217872,
-0.079749532,
1.0930775404,
0.8106561899,
-0.0103989094,
0.2542897463,
-0.291238308,
0.0618085824,
-1.2877001762,
-0.5863446593,
-0.8602982163,
-0.0584212132,
-0.2530559897,
-0.4617682397,
0.2354230732,
0.2334858477,
-0.0653423518,
0.1204522401,
-0.5311464071,
0.5224368572,
-0.0093289381,
-0.3698998392,
0.4444763362,
-0.1594406068,
-0.5894738436,
-0.1056542471,
-0.4907563925,
-1.0234516859,
1.3458646536,
0.4109159708,
1.2737826109,
-0.0021751537,
0.6052761078,
0.3795987368,
0.4919023514,
-0.740013063,
0.7147376537,
-0.1858796775,
-0.52115798,
-0.1618141532,
-0.5322930813,
-0.7066252828,
0.4631028771,
-0.3084769547,
-0.9663488269,
0.0521397069,
-0.1550582796,
-0.5507889986,
0.3410151303,
-0.529029429,
0.7182924151,
-0.5318362117,
-0.3360265493,
-0.1849202961,
-0.4876862168,
0.4100866616,
-0.0461564474,
0.3535606861,
-0.1449708641,
-0.2657596171,
0.8889071345,
-0.3292899728,
0.496483624,
-0.1948009729,
0.267781049,
0.0565310344,
0.3850225806,
0.1523150057,
0.3407019377,
-0.4148167074,
-0.1866809726,
0.1073386818,
-0.3125976324,
-0.669038415,
1.1046762466,
-0.5973808765,
-0.1429566443,
-0.1210144088,
-0.5942722559,
-0.3443697691,
0.3047530055,
-0.2431995273,
0.5929602385,
-0.597509563,
0.5249263048,
0.6767044067,
0.0342679545,
0.5581549406,
0.804328382,
-0.6699022651,
-0.3741625547,
0.7299443483,
-0.3877029121,
0.0376140848,
0.2314541489,
0.3548792005,
-0.5765527487,
-0.9503406882,
-0.5605858564,
-0.1688001752,
-0.796992898,
-0.1368105561,
-0.5319074988,
0.1857818663,
-0.2768253088,
-0.3093343377,
-0.6297261715,
-0.6619849205,
-0.1615752876,
-0.2510323822,
-0.0287568513,
0.9644827843,
-0.0687763095,
0.3512187302,
-0.8822072148,
0.2907847464,
0.2414058894,
0.571536243,
0.0755963549,
-0.5877589583,
-0.1701131016,
-0.2103119791,
-0.11913573,
-0.3830138445,
-0.0594115444,
0.2134466767,
0.8172587752,
0.5534397364,
-0.0560144186,
0.6854507923,
-0.2765930295,
0.8844292164,
0.2498993278,
-1.0785859823,
0.3744081259,
-0.2917791903,
0.0099465037,
1.1979702711,
0.2473696321,
-0.3208686709,
-0.0569876879,
-0.391597122,
-0.9243226051,
0.2018893659,
-0.0874729827,
0.3554205596,
0.2309734225,
0.2562649846,
0.1784520149,
0.2195944786,
-0.7359374166,
-0.0104081025,
-0.0266924128,
-0.038286645,
0.1576977521,
-0.5283024907,
-0.2942244411,
-0.4529932439,
0.5984690189,
-0.1232901737,
-0.0244089589,
0.0105931256,
-0.4277874529,
-0.0025404701,
0.510078609,
0.0480341017,
0.9621468782,
-0.4769727588,
0.134635523,
0.1513827145,
-0.2097972482,
0.1772228926,
0.1762351096,
-0.2021819055,
-0.032195352,
0.6690072417,
0.6363556385,
0.5577731729,
-0.9404655099,
0.656811893,
-0.0802677721,
0.0964640528,
0.2024769634,
-0.2943058312,
0.1785301864,
0.248695761,
0.4249852896,
-0.1758240312,
0.5273901224,
-0.6983721852,
0.1876677871,
0.4798057675,
-0.6275628805,
-0.3096881509,
0.5590882897,
0.6412982941,
-0.1665421724,
0.4916716516,
-0.127610907,
-0.4916575253,
0.0156722926,
0.6063122153,
1.1370856762,
-0.4066164494,
0.3406163156,
-0.2522488832,
0.3519342244,
0.0108837076,
0.5837255716,
-0.0375855118,
-0.1705306321,
-0.3288368285,
-1.1212972403,
-0.5468302965,
-0.1335020661,
-0.4882429242,
0.0970851779,
-0.3628685176,
0.0933052003,
-0.120305866,
-0.0414156355,
-0.2631813884,
0.0617851801,
0.0223034993,
1.2141257524,
-0.7292475104,
0.6641945243,
0.9329687953,
-0.308504492,
-0.680680573,
-0.2524797022,
0.1767310649,
-0.7244886756,
0.5130909085,
0.0459126346,
-0.4945282042,
-0.3629724979,
-0.3477739394,
-0.4025844038,
0.9358412623,
0.6124938726,
-0.5566408634,
0.1736668199,
0.0727090761,
0.6677815318,
-0.7166071534,
0.844502151,
0.6220800281,
0.5059399605,
0.171625644,
-1.0214432478,
0.1288114637,
-0.2833603024,
0.3075520098,
-0.0019960965,
-0.5700464845,
0.5088858604,
-0.2593905032,
0.0480955727,
0.2953175604,
0.4766223729,
0.2516850233,
0.0386020131,
0.3893300891,
0.4598504603,
0.8490320444,
0.1370601654,
1.0706005096,
-0.2582324445,
0.4995085299,
1.0003453493,
-0.605294466,
1.090367794,
0.3497016728,
-0.2513203919,
0.5839732885,
0.4588890374,
-0.0407947712,
0.2275999784,
0.2970920205,
-0.3301691413,
-0.3809635937,
-0.393835187,
-0.2343749702,
0.4608578682,
0.0794153064,
-0.0226350334,
-0.4509394467,
-0.1124813408,
-0.0831609294,
0.14959611,
-0.2916275263,
0.3715184033,
0.0803235322,
-0.0412206836,
0.6083612442,
0.1060678735,
0.7276446819,
-0.7800298929,
0.1481249183,
-0.2390460074,
0.2575686574,
-0.5700576305,
-0.6524535418,
0.1089238599,
0.2168651372,
0.1446407288,
-0.1205616295,
0.7206963301,
0.0985425785,
-0.6803790927,
0.6945962906,
0.5969774127,
0.2362362295,
0.1157357469,
-0.9039999843,
0.4379988611,
-0.0894407555,
-0.6386612654,
0.4115324318,
0.1490164548,
-0.170394063,
1.0302673578,
0.8185548782,
0.2321626246,
-0.0951073021,
0.525859952,
0.9858205914,
-0.5587297082,
-0.1116171703,
-0.8375817537,
0.5614420176,
0.1304062307,
-0.2431622297,
0.771872282,
1.0067374706,
0.1814890802,
0.2319402993,
0.8886722922,
-0.15141128,
0.5143680573,
-0.2364422977,
0.7861937881,
-0.601724267,
0.5867917538,
-0.5371809006,
-1.133005619,
-0.4371864796,
0.2371483743,
0.1514929086,
-0.022808956,
0.7500529289,
0.5991917849,
-0.269241035,
0.0208141711,
0.3504188955,
0.1630345285,
0.3167395294,
0.3144164085,
1.0392532349,
0.0276565365,
0.8017821312,
-0.1793354005,
-0.6630479693,
-0.2917630672,
-1.0132136345,
-0.809666276,
-0.2194419503,
-0.0444909856,
0.0063603511,
0.2440234721,
1.0243582726,
0.8410312533,
-0.7118076086,
-0.7383072972,
0.308948487,
0.1142818183,
0.0749570057,
-0.2099285424,
0.3160347044,
-0.2779652178,
-0.4733619392,
0.9226224422,
0.6191037297,
-0.2692829669,
-0.5587694049,
-0.0166525021,
-0.11861635,
0.1628746688,
0.5476933122,
0.0667898953,
-0.5559106469,
0.0140633397,
-0.1105043218,
-0.0560164526,
-0.1355682313,
0.8826235533,
-0.7152540088,
0.6244156361,
0.5350703597,
0.7992243767,
0.2667204738,
-0.0901511088,
0.456264168,
-0.2535923421,
0.0339502245,
0.3188748956,
0.5216186047,
0.6569281816,
-0.1253173202,
0.5618282557,
0.0788844526,
-0.6711230278,
-1.3291219473,
-0.0110235177,
-0.9279560447,
-0.04382037,
0.8977347016,
-0.3475318849,
-0.0478583463,
-0.0866323039,
0.0442671329,
-0.1482854187,
-0.433378756,
0.4666206539,
0.495496124,
-0.369656533,
0.0694186166,
-0.7328249812,
0.0824680775,
0.5609121323,
-0.8462542892,
0.3693957031,
0.4747832417,
0.4494773448,
0.042669218,
0.5769725442,
-0.3636640906,
0.2078509778,
-0.2338953763,
0.2606083453,
-0.0330278426,
-0.4012992978,
-0.7578561306,
0.2028297186,
0.4250389934,
0.1040422991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07549v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07549v1
|
Comments as Natural Logic Pivots: Improve Code Generation via Comment Perspective
| 2024-04-11T08:30:46 | 2024-04-11T08:30:46 |
Yijie Chen, Yijin Liu, Fandong Meng, Yufeng Chen, Jinan Xu, Jie Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Code generation aims to understand the problem description and generate
corresponding code snippets, where existing works generally decompose such
complex tasks into intermediate steps by prompting strategies, such as
Chain-of-Thought and its variants. While these studies have achieved some
success, their effectiveness is highly dependent on the capabilities of
advanced Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT-4, particularly in terms of
API calls, which significantly limits their practical applicability.
Consequently, how to enhance the code generation capabilities of small and
medium-scale code LLMs without significantly increasing training costs is an
appealing challenge. In this paper, we suggest that code comments are the
natural logic pivot between natural language and code language and propose
using comments to boost the code generation ability of code LLMs. Concretely,
we propose MANGO (comMents As Natural loGic pivOts), including a comment
contrastive training strategy and a corresponding logical comment decoding
strategy. Experiments are performed on HumanEval and MBPP, utilizing StarCoder
and WizardCoder as backbone models, and encompassing model parameter sizes
between 3B and 7B. The results indicate that MANGO significantly improves the
code pass rate based on the strong baselines. Meanwhile, the robustness of the
logical comment decoding strategy is notably higher than the Chain-of-thoughts
prompting. The code is publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/pppa2019/Mango}.
|
[
-0.6395007968,
-0.5922850966,
0.4476606846,
0.1915799975,
-0.6206642985,
0.0994865447,
-0.3902750611,
-0.2963207662,
0.1260724515,
0.7893169522,
-0.5992890596,
-0.1599970907,
-0.1871185601,
0.501464963,
-0.0985808,
1.3588088751,
0.2000127286,
-0.020638505,
-0.1322065145,
0.0942546204,
-0.365347296,
-0.6280000806,
-0.4442528486,
-0.1454489827,
0.2294233292,
0.382358849,
0.3795557916,
0.2714501023,
0.4559619427,
0.2655059695,
0.2781278193,
0.5308716893,
-0.2768008709,
0.081463173,
-0.1474689394,
-0.7087541819,
-0.2666999698,
-0.2310221046,
0.1928438246,
0.3177100122,
0.022456063,
0.2057581544,
0.1591612995,
1.1205871105,
-0.5120604634,
0.6625363231,
-0.7812764645,
0.2049674541,
-0.0801948383,
-0.3372136652,
-0.5874245167,
-0.7555568814,
-0.5355218649,
-0.2063374519,
-0.0343467444,
-0.1545487493,
0.5075683594,
0.4719936252,
-0.063809216,
-0.1810368299,
-0.5649546385,
0.7007921934,
-1.0781832933,
-0.0251792837,
0.1728169769,
0.3637393415,
-0.1691685617,
-0.644672811,
-0.6618238688,
-0.2989807129,
0.0376048125,
-0.1254326701,
-0.0203996878,
-0.1651209295,
0.5964661837,
0.3026077449,
-0.0050140014,
-0.531837225,
-0.1905344129,
-0.0208440758,
0.6296898723,
0.11403732,
0.2177617252,
-0.3822000325,
0.0889367536,
0.5877696276,
-0.8899148107,
0.0925586522,
0.2645738125,
0.4565514326,
-0.1718767136,
0.4834684432,
-0.4049058259,
0.9340571165,
0.1603107303,
-0.1693835855,
0.4243210256,
-0.5228725076,
-0.0330655202,
-0.3003054857,
0.7124183178,
0.7641369104,
0.6105288863,
-0.0146768326,
-0.0542717092,
0.2131601423,
0.4994094372,
-1.0528331995,
-0.5571583509,
-0.1634251773,
-0.3563660085,
-0.4482627511,
0.1427580267,
-0.8890194893,
-0.5331721306,
-0.5686231852,
-0.0952491388,
-0.4296667874,
-0.2192162126,
-0.2363651842,
0.1856611669,
0.4267641008,
0.4520951211,
-0.7938513756,
0.4211385846,
0.7182198167,
0.5995872021,
0.2394637614,
0.100652881,
-0.8829400539,
-0.0268382449,
-0.3183251023,
0.6335750222,
-0.6574042439,
-0.3152704835,
-0.1200070754,
-0.3613251448,
-0.1230337843,
-0.5723395944,
0.4076711535,
-0.4075490236,
0.0846200287,
-0.3327006698,
-0.21440804,
-0.0894453824,
0.3137467802,
-0.3830033243,
0.8696836233,
0.0545188971,
-1.2377740145,
0.2192691416,
-0.8219432235,
-0.7794901133,
0.1315232962,
-0.6562849283,
-0.4064667821,
0.2897874415,
0.4772230685,
0.4155164659,
-0.4607590735,
0.1017492637,
-0.0925182998,
-0.1452063471,
0.5758997202,
-0.063784197,
0.3964817226,
0.5267651677,
-0.643065989,
-0.0467490181,
-0.6248258948,
0.402189523,
0.068924062,
-0.5742468834,
0.1205733642,
0.1447222531,
-0.4173437655,
0.4104087949,
-0.0435015522,
-0.3960248828,
0.2729080915,
-0.6189693809,
0.5348735452,
0.4691390395,
0.459482193,
0.2960519195,
-0.0506802723,
0.3710694015,
0.0943811461,
0.151470378,
-0.4049001336,
-0.8280131817,
-0.7419484854,
-0.2163971514,
0.1939084232,
0.3944613039,
-1.2749974728,
0.210468486,
-0.2112960815,
-0.0116204396,
-0.4570378363,
0.6336459517,
0.5353725553,
0.756429255,
0.1765721589,
-0.6245427132,
-0.8925293684,
-0.8527337909,
-0.3607312739,
-0.104820177,
-0.1033885702,
0.2751264572,
0.3689466715,
-0.2541385889,
1.2723660469,
-0.7075812221,
0.1587733477,
-0.4338858426,
-0.0747417435,
0.442863822,
0.3703845143,
0.2849004865,
-0.7297175527,
-0.7622677684,
-0.0468131639,
-0.4881776869,
-0.2688411474,
0.1209213287,
-0.217494294,
0.42206043,
0.3747039437,
-0.6203601956,
0.4069186449,
0.0346485339,
0.2173360735,
0.3370166123,
0.0300777983,
0.1705003381,
-1.0484384298,
0.0320437774,
-0.0474200584,
-0.2821990848,
-0.5298733711,
0.2941212058,
0.1248567775,
-0.1468619257,
-0.443285346,
-0.0770482197,
-0.3262881637,
0.0830156282,
-0.397043556,
-0.1932149231,
-0.0340043046,
0.8348711729,
0.0374705754,
0.7766187787,
0.2274442166,
-0.6261594296,
0.1683624089,
-0.234045729,
-0.1471943259,
0.6110752225,
-0.3325434923,
0.4211569428,
0.212258026,
0.3521583378,
-0.7189177275,
-0.261097163,
0.4222548008,
-0.5187341571,
0.2794445753,
-0.3607320487,
-0.7167828679,
-0.5414879322,
-0.8347325325,
-0.0048479447,
0.8080493808,
-0.3289060891,
0.3406881988,
0.4044832885,
-0.2724950016,
-0.2006190866,
-0.8256482482,
0.2711841762,
0.0783906356,
-0.5193836689,
-0.3472543657,
-0.1959425062,
-0.2028895319,
-0.183592245,
-0.1833470017,
0.1082622409,
-0.0898272172,
0.3477537632,
0.275416851,
-0.2628412545,
-0.1524270624,
-0.3123137355,
-0.1967655867,
0.3474043906,
-0.5082203746,
0.5460526943,
-0.3984183371,
-0.1315250546,
0.0703360662,
0.163578704,
0.385343641,
-0.601573348,
0.5285041928,
0.0972293466,
-0.2064260244,
-0.4399856925,
-0.5982837677,
-0.0313083082,
-0.4551626444,
0.1358137876,
-0.3760919273,
-0.5750390291,
0.2324613929,
-0.1634562314,
0.0920669064,
0.2125443965,
0.8649914265,
0.1739179343,
1.1243885756,
0.6405155063,
-0.1401664913,
0.2532834709,
-0.330306828,
0.6346720457,
-0.927323103,
-0.2455450445,
-0.5348646045,
0.1631182283,
-0.5018405318,
-0.92882061,
0.0479719155,
-0.076759778,
-0.3516733646,
0.0613258965,
-0.7569415569,
0.7185481191,
0.45266065,
0.2087750137,
0.2832361162,
0.0871983171,
-0.4029625058,
-0.1762341857,
-0.7296335101,
-0.5143194199,
1.2033629417,
0.2522117496,
0.7059471607,
-0.0211522896,
0.8968670964,
0.1033535153,
0.6623128653,
-0.5965715051,
0.8152534962,
-0.0434602313,
-0.2669980824,
0.1858882755,
-0.7110471725,
-0.3828589022,
0.0807246417,
0.0887532458,
-0.5870385766,
-0.1221650019,
0.2065794915,
-0.2044844031,
0.3398250341,
-0.8867923617,
0.5962542295,
-0.1942864209,
-0.7447219491,
0.0625137687,
-0.7593057752,
0.5378153324,
-0.0662906989,
0.572719872,
0.0901468322,
-0.0409635343,
0.4640462697,
-1.0710510015,
1.0711733103,
-0.4333952963,
-0.1103394404,
0.6970527768,
0.1550617516,
0.4372447431,
0.0872923806,
-0.0643466115,
-0.3686904311,
-0.6958545446,
-0.2054228187,
-0.4849824607,
0.7080407143,
-0.5928716063,
-0.4909624159,
0.0119862985,
-0.3539557457,
-0.5111575723,
0.2251028717,
0.3320054412,
0.3802637756,
0.3639909923,
-0.0828672498,
0.585577786,
0.1276843101,
0.4878638983,
0.3574452698,
-0.457252115,
-0.6690056324,
1.0372350216,
-0.0566572808,
0.2060968876,
0.3025863469,
0.0476047471,
-0.2323741764,
-0.376267761,
-0.3230868578,
0.2531771362,
-0.8538173437,
-0.6687415242,
-0.5443130732,
-0.1677299887,
-0.17908369,
-0.0629241392,
-0.2511135936,
-0.6131485105,
0.1515557766,
-0.1842156202,
0.5624927878,
0.7376580834,
0.3183021843,
-0.1429916322,
-0.6594253778,
0.6109819412,
0.3663814664,
0.6257175803,
0.2008259892,
-0.2593983412,
-0.5099236965,
0.1480319053,
-0.286309123,
-0.9017353654,
0.2704106569,
0.0086514736,
0.2921829224,
0.161998868,
0.2561553419,
0.4463911951,
-0.6566565037,
0.7485375404,
0.4554644227,
-0.9558916688,
0.86026752,
-0.1968536824,
0.3379285634,
0.7586756945,
-0.1531518251,
-0.1090189293,
-0.7045347095,
-0.4316163659,
-0.7486505508,
0.6304812431,
0.3204114735,
0.1492992342,
-0.1516907662,
0.2480273545,
0.0946109369,
0.721586585,
-1.0672876835,
0.1056292355,
-0.5472687483,
-0.1520386934,
0.1259419024,
-0.0671041608,
-0.0457357578,
-0.3669419885,
0.4061366618,
-0.3998100162,
0.2027328759,
-0.0275404286,
-0.0679313317,
-0.1259029657,
0.5003113747,
0.4301624,
0.4866388738,
-0.0586192459,
0.4219287634,
0.1088762581,
-0.5186501145,
0.0468217731,
-0.1881951243,
-0.2497821748,
-0.1353695542,
0.1676907092,
0.574346602,
0.3805741966,
-0.3992838562,
0.3291394114,
0.0029666738,
-0.1269486994,
0.1140493676,
0.4673784673,
0.308124572,
-0.1065348238,
0.1729774028,
0.5044201016,
0.0572487861,
-0.742983222,
0.1905909628,
0.084385559,
-0.1645787358,
-0.235850051,
0.7018253207,
0.7275063992,
-0.3460040987,
0.5252257586,
-0.4086032808,
-0.8440872431,
0.5486332178,
0.5228476524,
1.0330067873,
0.1582743078,
0.0690709725,
0.1651209146,
0.4017094672,
0.0813077316,
0.410525322,
-0.4762018919,
-0.4096687138,
-0.7396611571,
-0.5410376787,
-0.5234927535,
-0.3738569915,
-0.3480041921,
0.2695758343,
-0.8509213328,
-0.1058657989,
-0.2810892463,
0.2361422628,
-0.5287775993,
0.1222114563,
0.4310485423,
0.920809865,
-0.6129930019,
1.139616251,
0.8583146334,
-0.7895507812,
-0.9179075956,
0.3016901314,
-0.1544298679,
-0.4866222739,
0.5937815905,
0.5558680296,
-0.3407539129,
-0.2554148138,
-0.6776902676,
-0.2165939063,
0.4973060787,
0.4964098632,
-0.3436916769,
0.291351974,
0.4966228306,
0.7329851985,
-0.6420055032,
0.1954093575,
0.6010047197,
0.32057482,
0.0418491624,
-0.6634957194,
0.2425755709,
-0.8363807201,
0.1822449416,
0.330249995,
-0.5230209827,
0.6695014238,
-0.4551725388,
0.1839833856,
-0.1495245844,
0.2685346305,
0.4837260544,
0.3329875469,
0.3661342859,
0.4306205511,
0.4183975756,
0.0270499606,
1.3295989037,
-0.4849458635,
0.1708062589,
1.0281903744,
-0.5754542947,
0.9780362248,
0.7874763012,
-0.4304746091,
0.7218697667,
0.222367987,
0.1647839695,
0.5281705856,
0.4446550906,
-0.0786015093,
-0.0165585782,
0.2152434736,
-0.5213394165,
-0.1842137128,
0.2930039167,
-0.086672239,
-0.0056721629,
-0.2278398126,
0.2273976058,
0.4578055143,
-0.4450937212,
0.8084129095,
0.2508148253,
-0.8439090848,
0.5956138372,
0.0096461494,
0.7134414911,
-0.5280084014,
-0.2407580912,
-0.5503094792,
0.2858510613,
-0.62495327,
-0.6116162539,
0.2760900259,
0.5892940164,
-0.2323133945,
-0.0977273285,
0.6821070313,
-0.1093431935,
-0.5889724493,
0.02822892,
0.0885274932,
-0.2175788879,
-0.1188537255,
-0.5734640956,
0.1257501245,
0.3869537711,
-0.2146318704,
0.1544776857,
0.5741805434,
0.0841621011,
0.4626606703,
0.6540291309,
-0.0586981624,
0.228675276,
0.0111753829,
1.1706397533,
-0.6799147725,
-0.805457592,
-0.9200707078,
0.6624025702,
-0.4318727553,
0.1067561135,
0.9701652527,
0.707709074,
0.572583735,
-0.4377846122,
0.9547380805,
-0.111241959,
0.707103014,
-0.6078633666,
0.3268160522,
-0.0460843779,
0.8961241841,
-0.5667183995,
-0.9840565324,
-0.3022758067,
0.6365813017,
-0.6015667319,
0.1834307462,
0.5994779468,
0.7162125111,
-0.0432340875,
0.1399638206,
-0.0817029998,
0.2408694178,
0.3757825196,
0.7824519873,
0.9459990263,
-0.1125778779,
0.5510151982,
-0.3641111255,
-0.2075374275,
-0.4203487635,
-0.9502770305,
-0.9219714999,
-0.0020411483,
-0.5233361721,
-0.3890253305,
-0.2285548002,
0.8167463541,
0.6108452678,
-0.7564621568,
-0.2631630301,
-0.5863070488,
0.2460794747,
0.1190560162,
-0.257204026,
0.0306903347,
-0.6160420775,
-0.2527750432,
-0.0870940611,
0.4843975902,
-0.4775223732,
-0.0346038751,
-0.3941521049,
0.074596256,
0.3606097698,
0.6803321838,
0.463727057,
-0.4764159024,
-0.059704911,
-0.1341950893,
-0.0818810388,
0.2723886669,
1.0733622313,
-1.0270162821,
0.4730591178,
0.4270380735,
0.6391046643,
0.5886083841,
0.000280058,
0.5976448059,
-0.8495445848,
0.344394803,
0.166726172,
0.3143294156,
0.4657293558,
-0.1529350579,
0.7118708491,
0.183978498,
-0.280444175,
-0.8539819717,
0.3985103369,
-0.6278476715,
-0.1488138735,
0.8213005662,
-0.0540490933,
-0.2239219397,
0.0290875565,
-0.6649660468,
-0.0324904658,
-0.3324760795,
0.4511535764,
0.2368597686,
-0.452991426,
-0.2186500281,
-0.6598039269,
0.5712069869,
0.4025647044,
-1.1349802017,
0.0664183721,
0.487595886,
0.2474749833,
0.1890334785,
0.9345722795,
-0.4267241359,
0.5611575246,
0.0893157721,
0.121656552,
-0.1229804158,
-0.0591793843,
-0.2170962691,
0.2466387302,
0.4807855487,
-0.1789752841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07546v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07546v1
|
Decomposing Label Space, Format and Discrimination: Rethinking How LLMs Respond and Solve Tasks via In-Context Learning
| 2024-04-11T08:20:10 | 2024-04-11T08:20:10 |
Quanyu Long, Yin Wu, Wenya Wang, Sinno Jialin Pan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In-context Learning (ICL) has emerged as a powerful capability alongside the
development of scaled-up large language models (LLMs). By instructing LLMs
using few-shot demonstrative examples, ICL enables them to perform a wide range
of tasks without updating millions of parameters. However, the precise
contributions of demonstrations towards improving end-task performance have not
been thoroughly investigated in recent analytical studies. In this paper, we
empirically decompose the overall performance of ICL into three dimensions,
label space, format, and discrimination, and we evaluate four general-purpose
LLMs across a diverse range of tasks. Counter-intuitively, we find that the
demonstrations have a marginal impact on provoking discriminative knowledge of
language models. However, ICL exhibits significant efficacy in regulating the
label space and format which helps LLMs to respond in desired label words. We
then demonstrate this ability functions similar to detailed instructions for
LLMs to follow. We additionally provide an in-depth analysis of the mechanism
of retrieval helping with ICL and find that retrieving the most semantically
similar examples notably boosts model's discriminative capability.
|
[
-0.3225449324,
-0.6778640151,
0.516315639,
0.0104313977,
-0.2956835032,
0.0247805174,
-0.3428657949,
-0.4668772519,
-0.4084429145,
0.2644359171,
-0.2263042778,
-0.5082042217,
-0.4785856307,
0.0698108003,
-0.4635054469,
1.1207153797,
-0.0813880861,
-0.1306847036,
-0.6228326559,
-0.1455200762,
-0.3484414816,
-0.6849840283,
-0.4147650301,
-0.5092716813,
0.2346966416,
0.6806817055,
0.1504637897,
0.6041968465,
0.223476842,
0.2490503788,
-0.2343154401,
0.1002766415,
-0.675516367,
0.0525678582,
0.0385176614,
-0.452552408,
0.0182545763,
0.2492648661,
0.8839085102,
0.965395987,
-0.0607794002,
0.244372502,
0.6512570977,
0.4087867141,
-0.6573408246,
0.2636674941,
-0.7038001418,
-0.0883137137,
-0.1282313168,
-0.0942052826,
-0.7902664542,
-0.0674008206,
0.1208876669,
-0.6058291793,
0.0954872817,
0.1152622402,
0.5969309807,
0.2361639738,
-0.5987561345,
-0.5376471281,
-0.7847416401,
0.8064028025,
-0.6721323133,
0.4835732579,
0.3648858368,
0.2833158076,
-0.1637142599,
-0.8947538733,
-0.3950576186,
-0.3970354795,
-0.3150512576,
-0.0164695419,
-0.1104138717,
-0.0422075875,
0.5105543137,
0.0960934013,
-0.2368679941,
0.4502718747,
-0.2381370366,
-0.0151196122,
0.3523320556,
0.1280766726,
0.2834290862,
0.2462819815,
-0.5195189714,
-0.0967764482,
-1.0205127001,
0.3161665797,
0.0015321956,
0.2995088696,
-0.1041129902,
0.2950371504,
-0.0943078771,
0.8775019646,
0.0894308239,
-0.3832193911,
0.0396205671,
-0.031014381,
-0.3377847075,
0.0472940877,
0.498573631,
0.1669806838,
-0.0362106785,
-0.2760048211,
-0.3063333333,
-0.1533974558,
0.1148294955,
-0.8034396172,
-0.0166408364,
-0.1092251316,
-0.4727516174,
0.1849743277,
-0.2869199216,
-0.281044662,
-0.2457495928,
-0.5225813985,
0.5627636909,
-0.4484726489,
0.036161676,
0.1367177069,
-0.0578694604,
0.2929573059,
0.2928244472,
-0.7569468617,
0.6018556952,
0.6606137753,
0.5376235843,
-0.3532134295,
-0.1550630033,
-0.488060087,
0.3445279896,
-0.2891283035,
0.6246798635,
-0.5763405561,
-0.3122311831,
0.070750773,
-0.1639358401,
-0.0407256745,
-1.1053212881,
0.1534993649,
-0.5403623581,
0.1049091741,
-0.3543891907,
-0.7202997208,
-0.1501813531,
0.3298967481,
-0.5644301772,
0.828880012,
-0.0197693035,
-0.4889546633,
0.6364811659,
-0.8008592129,
-0.2984034717,
0.2539367676,
-0.3211375177,
-0.2891302705,
0.186070621,
-0.0533055738,
0.7056601048,
-0.1281239539,
0.1860626042,
-0.223884806,
-0.670365572,
0.4675893486,
-0.3125171065,
0.5673668981,
0.1515022963,
-0.3919577897,
-0.0231508687,
-0.704900682,
-0.2021286339,
-0.0618124492,
-0.6202389002,
-0.4661897421,
0.1209162474,
-0.2608494163,
0.375697881,
-0.0536148213,
-0.6029058695,
0.0057622758,
-0.4090351462,
0.4164435565,
0.4699172378,
-0.2048828453,
0.518304348,
-0.0750730112,
0.4518134296,
0.0853507444,
-0.0103113782,
-0.0932507515,
-0.1223641708,
-0.4939438701,
-0.3554524481,
-0.0517568365,
0.0727821961,
-0.7350560427,
-0.2320299,
-0.1713798195,
-0.2073472887,
-0.3296273947,
0.1936424524,
0.6807425618,
0.705014348,
0.3459880352,
-0.1302216053,
-0.2299234718,
-1.033737421,
-0.2302891314,
-0.2063259482,
-0.1285880655,
0.3062060177,
0.532965064,
0.1083215475,
0.9592761397,
-0.2013324201,
-0.2397543341,
-0.3408468962,
-0.0669939741,
-0.0216231048,
0.2037074566,
0.5523246527,
-0.6984114647,
-0.5611258149,
0.0845075473,
-0.6304674149,
-0.1625540107,
0.0851913542,
0.1857102811,
0.1673578471,
0.8670199513,
-0.1143920645,
0.4899031222,
0.234024331,
-0.2192011178,
0.5690146685,
-0.202035144,
-0.2294310331,
-0.6487342715,
-0.1615905762,
0.1081064716,
-0.1226014644,
-0.7114661932,
0.2260051221,
0.3408069015,
0.0805607811,
-0.735703826,
0.6505689025,
-0.5011441112,
-0.2123301923,
-0.414291352,
0.3638868928,
-0.1320301741,
0.466139704,
0.01204638,
0.826925993,
0.2969594002,
-0.8375880122,
-0.2269497663,
-0.0051642247,
-0.5396055579,
0.3857209682,
-0.4148834348,
0.1135813221,
-0.3851970434,
0.3526310623,
-1.2837218046,
-0.1549452245,
0.0984764844,
0.0725819543,
0.4572383761,
-0.0080020037,
-0.6523134708,
-0.0268717594,
-0.1330838203,
0.6174529195,
0.4561954737,
-0.8482971191,
0.2935575843,
0.3516112864,
0.2307388037,
-0.4166742563,
-0.5773835182,
-0.1184810475,
-0.63346982,
-0.0339836441,
0.6026029587,
-0.2491523027,
-0.5847161412,
-0.3130761385,
-0.0599460788,
0.1183276325,
0.4153769612,
0.1617972404,
-0.0991539508,
0.0750611499,
0.3086048067,
-0.0424761511,
0.0923754945,
0.1276624054,
-0.2345850766,
0.3166111708,
-0.2524445951,
-0.505259037,
-0.30129987,
0.2920437455,
0.3985396922,
-0.0671338663,
0.6565338969,
0.308406353,
-0.410135299,
-0.4152142704,
-0.2382908612,
-0.1535437554,
-0.458424598,
0.3874218166,
-0.4627247155,
-1.0100238323,
0.4142549634,
-0.3329829872,
0.1644804776,
0.0348226167,
0.545265615,
-0.2199206799,
0.9257155657,
0.8630979061,
0.1995102763,
0.5133558512,
-0.3530748487,
0.2486773282,
-1.105255723,
-0.6757075191,
-0.4301043153,
-0.5238719583,
-0.2524339855,
-0.2045385689,
0.4216345549,
0.3242418468,
-0.353014797,
0.1650846601,
-0.3952618837,
0.5913063884,
0.4537837803,
0.1639088094,
0.1929978281,
-0.0307686068,
-0.3288897276,
-0.1407383829,
-0.6378059983,
-0.7081260085,
0.8006954789,
0.3156488836,
0.7681001425,
0.262702316,
0.6514378786,
-0.0692459419,
0.6961847544,
-0.8227057457,
0.6448213458,
-0.2615002394,
-0.3105230629,
-0.1003990173,
0.1397055537,
-0.8588301539,
0.4172471464,
0.1584425718,
-0.9492476583,
0.1291846484,
0.1950598955,
-0.135949403,
0.3064555228,
-0.7974604964,
0.6440366507,
-0.1528502703,
-0.3163458407,
-0.0130800297,
-0.5324063897,
0.3643442988,
-0.090003483,
0.2675298154,
0.103840664,
-0.163321048,
0.7498495579,
-0.1775849462,
1.2371199131,
-0.1990465224,
-0.4663146734,
0.1645597667,
0.2830360234,
0.2466155142,
-0.1174038053,
-0.0469103195,
-0.3230092227,
-0.1003939509,
-0.2590126693,
-0.875469625,
0.6518357396,
-0.648373723,
-0.6494267583,
0.1614569277,
-0.6709271669,
-0.2777351141,
-0.2428723574,
0.19795084,
0.7025697231,
-0.0587532185,
0.409096241,
0.80037117,
-0.169009164,
0.6875779629,
0.5805985332,
-0.1991759837,
0.1336781383,
0.708840847,
0.1598563194,
0.5350118279,
0.5737810135,
0.0801361054,
-0.468433708,
-0.6038383842,
-0.1063364893,
0.0970313549,
-1.0576967001,
-0.1353610009,
-0.5686776638,
0.0641365722,
-0.1094427109,
-0.2149714381,
-0.0485823713,
-0.2157852501,
-0.4411839247,
-0.2018530518,
-0.0516671427,
0.9532204866,
0.0560016148,
0.4593569636,
-0.1493535936,
0.0405277424,
0.3579487503,
0.2544655204,
0.2278313339,
-0.7430767417,
-0.3820349574,
-0.0885844305,
-0.4443740249,
-0.7961593866,
0.2511372566,
0.361762464,
0.814774096,
0.3961841464,
-0.0270632654,
0.8257313371,
-0.5173166394,
0.9377683997,
-0.1369445771,
-0.9401643276,
0.4328778088,
0.0917721316,
0.3420293927,
0.0849510282,
0.5489925742,
-0.4775937796,
-0.4340375364,
-0.407738626,
-0.8394873142,
0.7192159891,
-0.1477841288,
0.084361285,
-0.2094308287,
0.5905296206,
0.3099416196,
-0.0290193744,
-0.8374116421,
-0.2247285694,
-0.0409674384,
-0.1288224161,
-0.1859561056,
-0.4804831743,
-0.2526660562,
-0.3640779853,
0.43827492,
-0.4072127342,
0.3027046621,
-0.0242795683,
-0.4757567346,
0.3476921022,
0.3771710694,
0.7191066742,
0.6925598979,
0.1017176136,
0.3496077359,
0.275765568,
-0.0497532263,
0.2676456869,
-0.1417986751,
-0.0169171132,
-0.253362745,
0.5509181619,
0.8628324866,
0.5392696261,
-0.7106409669,
0.309558779,
0.006297444,
-0.2545223534,
-0.0348175354,
0.0325413086,
-0.0653438792,
0.2538967431,
0.4130426943,
-0.3927038312,
0.3211580217,
-0.6355727911,
0.2544274926,
0.5826709867,
-0.4635559916,
-0.3172022402,
0.7226323485,
-0.2720068097,
-0.4392525852,
0.5299746394,
-0.1377668083,
-0.3974885345,
0.5506639481,
1.2560915947,
0.6645192504,
0.1315934658,
0.2274037153,
0.1267837882,
0.0242606252,
0.1619058549,
-0.1265001148,
-0.4971865118,
-0.7527772784,
-0.4576969445,
-0.4017593861,
-0.2387773097,
0.2621535361,
-0.7352617383,
-0.0802268535,
-0.3614711463,
0.1632114053,
-0.1243726611,
-0.0674106777,
-0.7532914281,
0.1064196751,
0.3389608562,
0.9276531339,
-0.8889098167,
0.7520676851,
0.8794093728,
-0.1842636168,
-0.8452310562,
0.2078993469,
0.0206342414,
-0.5934253335,
1.2126010656,
0.28334409,
-0.2505804598,
0.0098243933,
-0.9204863906,
-0.812713623,
1.0846112967,
0.5468914509,
-0.2364955693,
0.2412692159,
0.1897298545,
0.6468824744,
-0.6897491813,
0.3642886281,
0.6135668755,
0.0235619061,
-0.0734186694,
-0.8853994608,
0.0324118026,
-0.0501042232,
0.2722020447,
-0.0812332183,
-0.50650841,
0.543156147,
-0.1442965865,
-0.3988657594,
-0.0492001437,
0.6158571839,
0.564501822,
0.2592965066,
0.4490303397,
0.2359566987,
0.6547637582,
-0.1404991895,
1.1092250347,
0.0140797701,
0.1597578675,
1.0141714811,
-0.3830603957,
0.9240477681,
0.720046699,
-0.0295667201,
0.6792265177,
0.5931052566,
0.5510573983,
0.6535197496,
0.3816705048,
-0.4042464495,
-0.2219318002,
-0.3494853079,
0.0375816785,
0.5617421269,
0.7413670421,
-0.1723817736,
-0.486230582,
0.5534697175,
-0.1152864248,
0.4018290341,
-0.2526041567,
0.9127798676,
0.0346984603,
-0.5468956828,
0.6038616896,
-0.1818025261,
0.6787808537,
-0.3561591506,
-0.3175098896,
-0.2691763341,
0.2002299726,
0.0460990407,
-0.8710139394,
0.1193298176,
-0.278416425,
-0.2113284618,
-0.5246656537,
0.6713092327,
-0.5566139817,
0.0525254868,
0.4445770979,
0.2264001667,
0.3571316004,
0.255916059,
-0.3907938302,
0.1921913624,
-0.1065270752,
0.0286840424,
0.6088305712,
0.538521409,
-0.334210217,
0.9970264435,
0.2921616733,
-0.3358862102,
0.0552263744,
0.0515862517,
0.7957593203,
-0.3738382161,
-0.2551271319,
-0.9649244547,
0.4938764572,
0.117381312,
-0.1831666827,
0.7259280682,
0.5991874337,
1.5208134651,
-0.1450324655,
0.5050674081,
0.1358779669,
0.338899374,
-0.5893821716,
0.4092386365,
-0.7354674339,
0.4838674366,
-0.1544270366,
-0.4814499319,
-0.5318437815,
0.350250572,
-0.3392433524,
0.0373888202,
0.5630354881,
0.6690177321,
-0.0758893415,
-0.2823902071,
0.5404077768,
0.1175242439,
0.642074883,
0.4952636659,
1.0808019638,
-0.1529287696,
0.5054758787,
-0.3699777424,
-0.1490212828,
-0.2121848911,
-0.7731041312,
-0.8166841269,
-0.8223868608,
-0.3474811912,
-0.0596455671,
-0.1802031547,
0.8525059819,
0.7245220542,
-0.4647311568,
-0.5088905692,
0.3216557205,
0.1095172837,
-0.3669822812,
-0.2356867045,
0.3549261093,
-0.5716401935,
-0.810053885,
0.5460545421,
0.3746627569,
0.0611089543,
-0.034545783,
-0.1842107326,
-0.0036605448,
-0.3714629412,
1.1056578159,
0.320199728,
-1.0384594202,
-0.2798761427,
-0.1665777862,
-0.07748124,
-0.0881627351,
0.921364367,
-1.1597858667,
0.3367584646,
0.1850240678,
0.6762579083,
0.38783288,
-0.1422555745,
0.3976749182,
-1.0510166883,
0.1240462363,
0.0355188996,
0.3796430826,
0.2678405643,
-0.2094482929,
0.3292559683,
-0.0580486841,
-0.5017929673,
-0.8720462322,
0.3708758652,
-0.5496022701,
-0.5433781743,
1.1803866625,
-0.129078418,
-0.1734199077,
-0.1284402609,
-0.1897698045,
0.1330150664,
-0.0495932996,
0.7038971782,
0.5683489442,
-0.3957521617,
-0.1803195477,
-0.5305208564,
0.6038448811,
0.295557946,
-0.5755312443,
0.0769312456,
0.4388443232,
0.4270681739,
-0.0162913278,
0.6136361957,
-0.1433042139,
0.0443012081,
-0.4877967834,
-0.1686846614,
-0.0234343503,
-0.454082191,
-0.5414661169,
0.3105803728,
0.2848263681,
-0.2063651681
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07544v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07544v2
|
From Words to Numbers: Your Large Language Model Is Secretly A Capable Regressor When Given In-Context Examples
| 2024-04-11T08:12:43 | 2024-04-30T07:40:57 |
Robert Vacareanu, Vlad-Andrei Negru, Vasile Suciu, Mihai Surdeanu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We analyze how well pre-trained large language models (e.g., Llama2, GPT-4,
Claude 3, etc) can do linear and non-linear regression when given in-context
examples, without any additional training or gradient updates. Our findings
reveal that several large language models (e.g., GPT-4, Claude 3) are able to
perform regression tasks with a performance rivaling (or even outperforming)
that of traditional supervised methods such as Random Forest, Bagging, or
Gradient Boosting. For example, on the challenging Friedman #2 regression
dataset, Claude 3 outperforms many supervised methods such as AdaBoost, SVM,
Random Forest, KNN, or Gradient Boosting. We then investigate how well the
performance of large language models scales with the number of in-context
exemplars. We borrow from the notion of regret from online learning and
empirically show that LLMs are capable of obtaining a sub-linear regret.
|
[
-0.2033372521,
-0.8951355815,
0.6408666372,
0.3585006595,
-0.1038950607,
-0.0056162858,
-0.3365479112,
-0.406755507,
0.1269141585,
0.3734655976,
-0.4535912871,
-0.1440890133,
-0.7033870816,
0.0250222608,
-0.6996189952,
1.1541247368,
0.067879729,
0.4048459828,
-0.37921682,
-0.040405225,
-0.4269166291,
-0.7567153573,
-0.6841372252,
-0.2909267247,
0.5998811126,
-0.0332637504,
0.6761910319,
0.4519492686,
0.356902957,
0.3397176266,
0.183584556,
-0.0212770626,
-0.8260785341,
0.0900000706,
0.1348851323,
-0.6114663482,
-0.1704491377,
0.2002824396,
0.5589560866,
0.7145226002,
-0.0666122362,
0.0464885831,
0.2859395742,
0.6355965137,
-0.3230903745,
0.3071486056,
-0.6334391832,
-0.2383893728,
-0.0772337094,
0.1178079993,
-0.6581352949,
-0.7074459791,
0.2149608284,
-0.5382641554,
0.0882733762,
-0.1910814792,
0.8020543456,
0.378536433,
-0.257384032,
-0.591046989,
-0.9214795232,
0.9892264009,
-0.8204060793,
0.3426548243,
0.6217771769,
0.2001388967,
-0.1821195483,
-0.9775545597,
-0.3132137358,
-0.3104576468,
-0.138677448,
-0.104282029,
-0.256526202,
-0.0588838831,
0.5684934258,
0.2293371409,
-0.3201018274,
0.0122953607,
-0.3095353544,
-0.0608160682,
0.4799550772,
-0.2506999075,
0.0332444534,
0.4336982965,
-0.2575647831,
-0.2906778753,
-0.7324371934,
-0.0088574011,
0.2956331074,
0.3224672675,
0.1337809563,
0.4243660569,
0.1318302602,
0.876653254,
-0.2521829307,
-0.2376211882,
0.1864448935,
-0.1647174954,
-0.325121671,
-0.3329146504,
0.61819309,
0.0054725083,
0.6682791114,
-0.3211347461,
-0.3905495107,
0.1214853004,
0.0871648341,
-0.7256137729,
-0.1892302334,
-0.0798587874,
-0.3680558503,
-0.3207384348,
0.0521228798,
-0.8034827113,
-0.4186939001,
-0.1451695561,
0.815382123,
-0.3164160848,
0.1405477673,
0.0773596019,
-0.021693049,
0.1647412181,
0.3492122591,
-0.7287032008,
0.5875768065,
0.7714178562,
0.9189339876,
0.3158331513,
-0.2222118974,
-0.7704765797,
-0.3480115235,
-0.6145007014,
0.4255080521,
-0.5582200885,
-0.2903016508,
0.2693081796,
-0.1815416366,
0.0874332413,
-0.4222607315,
0.2200216055,
-0.5162603259,
0.4162920713,
-0.3757384717,
-0.6544992924,
-0.2965720892,
-0.0176046472,
-0.6616690755,
1.0146805048,
0.0629477277,
-0.4391503036,
0.3611865938,
-0.3144472539,
-0.3402155638,
-0.0325206071,
-0.1074586064,
-0.4430892169,
0.5572136045,
0.0142575093,
0.5383355021,
-0.3487442136,
0.5801007748,
-0.5288336277,
-0.4698745608,
0.4483571351,
-0.4825274944,
0.6682562828,
-0.022376677,
-0.4187696576,
0.0039775358,
-0.6224014759,
0.0236604773,
0.0535025746,
-0.2914712429,
-0.5616109967,
0.385104835,
-0.0488162637,
0.457475245,
0.2044553161,
-0.4195374846,
0.3132829964,
-0.2148121297,
0.4537783563,
0.7576642036,
-0.3968805969,
0.2099823058,
-0.3350706697,
0.5086285472,
-0.4994554222,
-0.1329470426,
-0.1932680905,
-0.712356627,
-0.9075955153,
-0.3940876126,
0.3710342944,
0.3535876274,
-0.693614006,
0.2562868595,
-0.3288862705,
-0.5602920651,
-0.3775047064,
0.2555102408,
0.4298134744,
0.3577423096,
0.3639142513,
0.0556069091,
-0.4821418822,
-0.9309820533,
-0.4541484118,
-0.178886652,
-0.0955895931,
0.4408146441,
0.3459986448,
-0.0713648722,
0.953972578,
-0.4106980562,
-0.371830076,
-0.2049668878,
0.3608526289,
0.1975187957,
0.0744689554,
0.5434629321,
-0.6995880008,
-0.4010339379,
-0.1497136056,
-0.843237102,
-0.2929284573,
-0.1536239833,
0.4594300091,
0.2444878966,
0.8291591406,
-0.2559151351,
0.2898302972,
0.9058941007,
-0.3217618763,
-0.0866310745,
-0.3700354993,
-0.422735095,
-1.1247295141,
-0.1227794141,
0.256616354,
-0.3627135158,
-0.7207896709,
-0.059560556,
0.070071727,
0.0171333235,
-0.144011423,
0.3734134138,
-0.393414855,
-0.0981370509,
-0.2534036934,
-0.1622840166,
-0.2598087192,
0.200921908,
-0.0201942418,
0.6331256628,
0.6771922708,
-0.3079200387,
0.1802170575,
-0.0497706756,
-0.580786407,
-0.1717902124,
-0.7222821116,
0.0954948664,
-0.3682893515,
0.3450451195,
-1.2190375328,
-0.2284302711,
-0.2505100965,
-0.282784462,
0.3663935661,
-0.1511377394,
-0.5392799377,
-0.4815666974,
-0.3219671547,
0.1245919093,
0.7926626205,
-0.4694185257,
0.3699708283,
0.2639170885,
-0.2696341574,
-0.6818599701,
-0.8767254949,
0.1037025154,
-0.4839355648,
-0.1750261039,
-0.0672000498,
-0.0671254843,
-0.5494866967,
-0.1906726956,
0.2700509429,
-0.0740513429,
0.1749227941,
0.2795772851,
0.3590593934,
-0.1912054569,
0.383358866,
-0.5113606453,
-0.0155704627,
0.0403452143,
-0.4196762145,
0.6417997479,
-0.3113978505,
-0.0980923474,
0.0710033923,
0.2076361328,
0.5364313126,
-0.066912666,
0.7526479959,
0.5087268949,
-0.5491630435,
-0.197078526,
-0.6040236354,
-0.2666930556,
-0.4517093301,
0.5274885893,
-0.2263014317,
-1.0959795713,
0.3727138937,
-0.0278216545,
-0.002869173,
0.1842562109,
0.569968164,
0.1874126643,
1.0359205008,
0.8269357085,
-0.2474811524,
0.5307213068,
-0.172428444,
0.3053258955,
-0.399060756,
-0.0319567472,
-0.393425107,
-0.3728202581,
-0.960814774,
-0.5676080585,
0.0895173699,
0.3358236849,
-0.1156419665,
0.3398040235,
-0.0350379348,
0.4378407896,
0.4536336958,
-0.1794825047,
0.0690951124,
0.0899247155,
0.276869148,
-0.1952109486,
-0.5733388066,
-0.4754697382,
1.0910099745,
0.4043960273,
0.9840490818,
0.1367853582,
0.6059978008,
0.0365668014,
0.882897377,
-1.0808143616,
0.3583905399,
-0.3145051599,
-0.5338435173,
-0.4828401804,
-0.4967294931,
-0.8898249865,
0.1610791385,
-0.1968180835,
-0.9502609968,
0.3234185576,
0.143130213,
-0.2224921137,
0.311925739,
-0.6677314043,
0.4526965022,
-0.2444575876,
-0.4587258101,
0.0090792477,
-0.535353303,
0.3448462486,
-0.7347733378,
0.4198262691,
0.1308266371,
-0.2262538821,
0.7743755579,
-0.4114643633,
0.903704226,
-0.1083501875,
-0.2639960051,
0.2104205042,
0.1811830252,
0.7539942265,
-0.1735235006,
-0.1612926424,
0.2133260369,
-0.3670627177,
-0.3477235436,
-0.7015387416,
1.0107613802,
-0.7466510534,
-0.4933457971,
-0.4104444385,
-0.5341857076,
-0.4998168349,
0.1559562534,
0.3827894926,
0.5626464486,
-0.0181579906,
0.5038820505,
0.4035831094,
-0.3414863646,
0.833881557,
0.3222556412,
-0.4629939795,
-0.3857318461,
1.0778813362,
0.542042613,
0.3880176246,
0.5128884315,
0.5142550468,
-0.4138328731,
-0.3471770883,
-0.0367176607,
0.3635155857,
-0.4976865053,
-0.1734962612,
-0.5643978119,
0.0031111699,
-0.211353749,
-0.2106899321,
-0.3458635807,
-0.3076043129,
-0.0391125232,
-0.2486641258,
0.3390040398,
1.4702532291,
-0.1865516603,
0.2811619043,
-0.5100777149,
-0.002599712,
0.6699815989,
0.253816843,
0.0509127639,
-0.4719843864,
-0.249199912,
0.0892531127,
0.0432229899,
-0.6746947169,
0.7157978415,
0.2453081757,
0.211746186,
0.5080698133,
-0.2046502531,
0.8075963259,
-0.5396593213,
0.7283726335,
-0.0216826741,
-1.0062016249,
0.1594021171,
-0.4690419436,
-0.1592120379,
0.3119532168,
0.5788733959,
-0.3085623085,
-0.2003804892,
-0.6833361387,
-0.9256115556,
0.611566186,
0.0459055677,
0.3119397461,
-0.0782309696,
0.2437504232,
0.0530161783,
0.3457315862,
-1.0700355768,
-0.1791151315,
-0.1663139313,
-0.0264625866,
-0.6233322024,
-0.4101938307,
0.0675263479,
-0.0314683132,
0.492827028,
-0.2595950961,
0.2384298891,
0.002938295,
-0.0056836084,
-0.0490521416,
0.0891510472,
0.8908666372,
0.6899593472,
-0.2473310381,
0.1122327596,
0.2115992755,
-0.2029442638,
0.0970950574,
-0.0104255285,
-0.1581755579,
-0.0963875875,
0.686537981,
0.7388502955,
0.2337914854,
-0.5048996806,
0.6143468618,
-0.0894280374,
-0.2767263651,
-0.3739729226,
-0.3354385495,
0.0976954475,
0.0539547689,
0.4374866188,
0.0149390269,
-0.0121813975,
-0.5938210487,
0.2916453779,
0.4449454248,
-0.8388088346,
-0.4108997881,
0.5546836257,
-0.1243028119,
-0.4054612219,
0.5261596441,
0.0344949029,
-0.3655161858,
0.4290126562,
0.9807834625,
0.7463544607,
-0.1280268282,
0.2030608207,
0.2191141397,
0.3054011762,
-0.6360211968,
0.2021119595,
0.2662406862,
-0.7356735468,
-0.7857865095,
-0.5871841908,
-0.0551071241,
0.5772957802,
-0.7983012795,
0.1726341546,
-0.3044349551,
-0.1302235126,
-0.0655555576,
-0.1303514987,
-0.5121178627,
0.222561866,
0.2071669996,
0.8399285674,
-1.0046540499,
0.9830662012,
0.5787951946,
-0.2612550259,
-0.809615016,
0.1934241951,
-0.1029834077,
-0.9204806685,
0.8749600053,
0.234029308,
-0.085144043,
0.1470234692,
-0.6234742999,
-1.005834341,
0.7926546335,
0.5010347366,
-0.6669583321,
-0.1063963026,
0.0226503406,
0.7611348033,
-0.2257244289,
0.1454835236,
0.2052588612,
0.4437112212,
-0.0999453664,
-0.7509540319,
-0.1788272113,
-0.0322210044,
0.0102263642,
0.258520782,
-0.8178904057,
1.1784023046,
-0.2611398101,
0.037956439,
0.2905426025,
0.5000785589,
-0.0602393635,
-0.0258711651,
0.4358697534,
0.5626080632,
0.7943288684,
-0.2211095095,
1.4402492046,
-0.2016007751,
0.3963435292,
0.9811173081,
-0.2548681498,
1.0089646578,
0.5455931425,
-0.2137190998,
0.4137769938,
0.5145019889,
0.1098701507,
0.5009289384,
0.4683815241,
-0.1438413709,
-0.4151595533,
-0.0506631508,
-0.2094634324,
0.47113958,
0.5331450701,
-0.5013523102,
-0.0976303816,
0.0007688104,
0.2324777693,
0.0709468424,
-0.2308768332,
0.8044192195,
0.201762557,
-0.6006174088,
0.3882081211,
-0.2154591382,
0.6199831367,
-0.7564867735,
-0.1478673965,
-0.1368539631,
0.4134855866,
-0.0118480446,
-0.5455086231,
0.1485438049,
-0.1640367359,
0.0906642079,
-0.4458340406,
0.5618399978,
-0.4684434831,
-0.8365005255,
0.5422216654,
0.7405475974,
0.176241532,
0.0585494488,
-0.2692783773,
-0.1624582708,
0.0845525637,
-0.3254380226,
0.4659321308,
0.4044038951,
-0.2205344886,
0.8322224617,
0.6293390989,
0.3380318284,
-0.0033229277,
0.1251806617,
0.6871061921,
-0.5924226046,
-0.0923775584,
-1.1986789703,
0.0870204568,
0.0417552516,
-0.3009953201,
0.8822678328,
0.6263938546,
0.9338763952,
-0.2018097192,
0.9047780037,
0.1223302707,
0.4226061702,
-0.3100404143,
0.4789492786,
-0.4770509005,
0.1497855932,
-0.367667377,
-0.9067369699,
-0.4874711931,
0.9100897908,
-0.4519187212,
0.1525700688,
0.6066182852,
0.6982387304,
0.2653180361,
-0.1557830423,
0.7742313743,
0.4801184833,
0.369029969,
0.2970763743,
0.8352859616,
-0.4043623209,
0.4269842207,
-0.0430321805,
-0.3287082016,
-0.1309362501,
-0.9641314745,
-0.916628778,
-0.6021841764,
0.0331627131,
-0.5670439005,
-0.057923954,
0.8291724324,
0.6855970025,
-0.7911446095,
-0.4342891574,
-0.1849608719,
-0.0399236381,
-0.0498436093,
-0.2005352974,
0.1652925462,
-0.4381356239,
-0.8322229981,
0.4689022005,
0.1162892357,
0.2904798985,
-0.3856202066,
0.0765018538,
-0.013340096,
0.2314445525,
0.7935557961,
0.1167033613,
-0.6539278626,
-0.3629499972,
0.0898324922,
0.0302866139,
-0.1892337203,
1.0387958288,
-0.9911746979,
0.3335541785,
0.59898597,
0.6489567161,
0.4833520353,
0.071892418,
0.8834613562,
-0.6820338964,
0.1197186261,
0.1060055196,
0.5533371568,
0.3730483353,
-0.019335743,
0.6252088547,
0.1725427955,
-0.4953253567,
-0.8224490881,
0.2087860405,
-0.5685015917,
-0.1634437144,
1.3883374929,
-0.2448802143,
0.0369407944,
-0.1084450632,
0.0044603096,
0.0666239187,
-0.3173778057,
0.866361022,
0.8971623182,
-0.073827453,
0.0883384943,
-0.6926742792,
0.7802442312,
0.2827252448,
-0.6034092903,
0.2792870998,
0.2801508904,
0.0707340986,
0.2815732956,
0.3817727566,
-0.0558528081,
-0.3549954295,
0.0116310827,
-0.2266192138,
0.0653245598,
-0.2619562745,
-0.5082461238,
0.1385308504,
0.229747206,
0.1305568069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08705v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08705v1
|
Introducing L2M3, A Multilingual Medical Large Language Model to Advance Health Equity in Low-Resource Regions
| 2024-04-11T07:39:22 | 2024-04-11T07:39:22 |
Agasthya Gangavarapu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Addressing the imminent shortfall of 10 million health workers by 2030,
predominantly in Low- and Middle-Income Countries (LMICs), this paper
introduces an innovative approach that harnesses the power of Large Language
Models (LLMs) integrated with machine translation models. This solution is
engineered to meet the unique needs of Community Health Workers (CHWs),
overcoming language barriers, cultural sensitivities, and the limited
availability of medical dialog datasets. I have crafted a model that not only
boasts superior translation capabilities but also undergoes rigorous
fine-tuning on open-source datasets to ensure medical accuracy and is equipped
with comprehensive safety features to counteract the risks of misinformation.
Featuring a modular design, this approach is specifically structured for
swift adaptation across various linguistic and cultural contexts, utilizing
open-source components to significantly reduce healthcare operational costs.
This strategic innovation markedly improves the accessibility and quality of
healthcare services by providing CHWs with contextually appropriate medical
knowledge and diagnostic tools. This paper highlights the transformative impact
of this context-aware LLM, underscoring its crucial role in addressing the
global healthcare workforce deficit and propelling forward healthcare outcomes
in LMICs.
|
[
0.2667208612,
-0.2367055714,
0.7491154671,
0.0227149427,
-0.1817388237,
0.0528713986,
-0.1195324808,
-0.7314323187,
0.0225086622,
0.7095416188,
-0.38109833,
-0.2395614982,
-0.8305737972,
0.1147600785,
0.0485066175,
0.7377951741,
-0.156855762,
0.2772355974,
0.1224365532,
-0.3065682352,
-0.2563471794,
-0.2629123032,
-0.4038725197,
-0.5425195694,
0.7309954762,
0.8103790283,
0.9864991903,
0.893996954,
0.3779432774,
0.1243031323,
-0.05140616,
0.2469871193,
-0.6210600138,
-0.293378979,
-0.0512329377,
-0.6570622325,
-0.5884152055,
-0.2624425292,
0.4243994355,
0.8309779763,
-0.1704038531,
0.1202035993,
0.2960572541,
0.7447265983,
-0.357018888,
0.1288001239,
-0.6412751675,
0.1433410645,
-0.2436858565,
0.0944325104,
-0.0212272573,
-0.0657189637,
-0.1234564707,
-0.2832722664,
-0.2618514895,
-0.1267320663,
0.3879805207,
0.3505706787,
-0.6647685766,
-0.1726755351,
-0.4781897962,
0.8260836005,
-0.8593505025,
0.3062574267,
0.4124063849,
0.3580778539,
-0.3222446144,
-0.8814503551,
-0.3690636456,
0.4898536503,
-0.1371771544,
0.2414296716,
-0.1127549112,
-0.0555554368,
-0.2343564928,
0.185882777,
-0.4494391978,
0.5533412695,
-0.6727807522,
0.0452651829,
0.2962086201,
0.3211859167,
0.2956635654,
-0.345654577,
-0.3155718148,
0.4624246657,
-0.9538736343,
-0.0531781651,
-0.1972213835,
0.5144370198,
-0.6162917018,
0.4868420064,
-0.1790588796,
0.3348453045,
-0.4807533324,
-0.7731215954,
0.3311328888,
-0.2205281705,
-0.2655228376,
-0.0739939287,
0.5847420692,
0.3836360574,
-0.2445793599,
0.0251011793,
-0.0858807266,
-0.3960589767,
-0.0682955757,
-0.843547523,
0.058874432,
0.4128772914,
-0.8037996888,
-0.1961368471,
-0.3881955743,
-0.650288403,
-0.8146209121,
-0.2360138148,
-0.0369861014,
-0.0247096289,
-0.2803839743,
0.3383232653,
0.4366143942,
-0.1146862805,
0.3201642931,
-0.7640528679,
0.0319395252,
0.8432471752,
1.0903021097,
-0.0424702987,
0.0042042062,
-0.296245575,
0.3316087723,
-0.2623288333,
0.2503362596,
-0.1836223006,
-0.4174675941,
0.2126943767,
0.3365777731,
0.1384133101,
-0.6984578967,
0.3282173574,
-0.2324512303,
-0.0104939835,
-0.1772987992,
0.1048214063,
-0.0550086834,
0.2369609922,
-0.6316268444,
0.8539908528,
0.3942677379,
-0.6192318797,
0.0603550225,
-0.7068375945,
-0.4819916785,
0.3197828233,
-0.260323137,
-0.4713808894,
0.2042738795,
0.1640217006,
0.4074999988,
-0.7335953712,
0.3649051785,
-0.2952432334,
-0.231232971,
0.0526115857,
-0.3301386237,
0.9011240602,
0.2798044682,
-0.210895732,
0.1754864156,
-0.2823711336,
-0.1270214766,
0.2139898986,
-0.4217301905,
-0.2100102305,
0.2325210571,
0.1732433736,
0.4670500159,
0.3078198433,
-0.1361621916,
-0.0762913451,
-0.6029679179,
0.7791051865,
0.3750098944,
-0.047579594,
0.301320821,
-0.3387739658,
0.4768132567,
0.1081301719,
0.5811573267,
-0.0647850931,
-0.5905587673,
-0.3630775511,
-0.4553994536,
-0.1002074182,
0.7552578449,
-0.9050987363,
0.216509074,
-0.2817125022,
-0.4378784001,
-0.9346514344,
0.3540864587,
0.0397485569,
0.7744784355,
0.3983030617,
0.0928543881,
-0.4261081815,
-1.1017295122,
-0.0786372572,
-0.1880544871,
-0.0902689248,
0.2135577053,
0.4377968907,
-0.6730954051,
0.5747184753,
-0.3326797187,
-0.3295696676,
-0.6348046064,
-0.3262168467,
0.44613114,
0.488509506,
0.2751025558,
-0.8660626411,
-0.2817542851,
0.2742819786,
-0.8189842105,
-0.0776067674,
0.2340977192,
-0.2524133325,
-0.0044342093,
0.3352136016,
-0.0732031092,
0.1112296134,
0.9506517053,
0.0037065984,
0.1037097275,
-0.1967439801,
-0.1537428647,
-1.4354326725,
0.2135128826,
-0.1199067533,
-0.2383606583,
-0.729844451,
0.1094871312,
0.2324160188,
-0.428517133,
-0.6876772046,
0.7646952271,
-0.3886217475,
0.1709746569,
-0.4235099852,
-0.052558668,
-0.0898381695,
-0.033196032,
0.0083052572,
0.531339705,
0.2009074837,
-0.1873859465,
0.0754234716,
0.0894083977,
-0.4804245532,
0.5235697031,
-0.560851872,
-0.0144752562,
-0.0253874883,
0.4201708436,
-0.3176512718,
-0.4357990921,
0.1764363199,
-0.1300058216,
-0.1247837543,
-0.1366040856,
-0.7947596312,
-0.6729979515,
0.0451860987,
0.5057166219,
0.620488286,
-0.3343128562,
0.1979689896,
0.706692636,
-0.4897810817,
-0.5323724151,
-1.0859372616,
0.2119144946,
-0.2515617311,
-0.6726694703,
0.0584948733,
0.1542106271,
-0.3178789914,
-0.2778201401,
-0.0097006876,
-0.2333420366,
0.5251735449,
0.0410637073,
0.3722198904,
-0.2249859869,
0.1474626958,
0.0806719661,
-0.2539829612,
-0.086555928,
-0.5170598626,
0.2683260143,
-0.00767165,
-0.3554819822,
-0.2916624248,
0.6689353585,
0.7169108391,
-0.1696460992,
0.8085075617,
0.6647330523,
-0.9387804866,
0.3216720819,
-0.4467348754,
-0.0372872427,
-0.4294100106,
0.850602746,
0.1118913069,
-1.2362283468,
0.3748690188,
-0.2879070342,
0.0658764765,
0.1999563277,
0.8088015318,
-0.0284174625,
0.7832401395,
0.7777594924,
-0.1056006476,
0.0066180616,
0.0687701404,
0.4386588335,
-0.8151425719,
-0.4509296417,
-0.4200121462,
-0.2013830841,
-0.7120449543,
-1.0100473166,
1.1576142311,
0.2327192277,
-0.1878522038,
-0.0690905079,
-0.20502159,
0.1923477352,
0.2957486808,
0.3873048425,
0.3328881264,
-0.3510522842,
0.0595610291,
-0.237091586,
-0.8366892934,
-0.6024473906,
0.7286099792,
0.7784592509,
0.4928207099,
0.4074449539,
0.5473337173,
0.28187114,
0.6349822879,
-0.7733284831,
-0.0087297894,
-0.2737913728,
-0.5589795709,
-0.2478066832,
-0.2576295137,
-0.8107428551,
0.3519071937,
-0.3362535238,
-0.5865740776,
0.100247331,
0.0613535233,
-0.4951936603,
0.443484813,
-0.3277261257,
0.7645303011,
-0.4540133178,
-0.5233896971,
-0.2654292881,
-0.7238286734,
0.488386333,
-0.4595298767,
1.0785614252,
-0.5370886326,
-0.3195022047,
0.4052515626,
-0.6002507806,
1.0298117399,
-0.2154355198,
-0.3436797559,
0.1610726416,
-0.1211690009,
0.4642541111,
0.1419742256,
-0.3234241307,
0.3057355583,
-0.2537039518,
-0.7986275554,
0.030940501,
0.6371260881,
-0.7511876225,
-0.5025109053,
0.0130224386,
-0.6388404965,
-0.3945070207,
0.4181804657,
-0.1404394507,
0.2296755016,
-0.1430476159,
0.0818745717,
0.4151328206,
-0.6429033875,
0.280962497,
0.5963426232,
-0.0262858719,
-0.4858108461,
0.4695366621,
0.0456402898,
0.4083454311,
0.1927133948,
0.2567958236,
-0.0497676283,
-0.4257307649,
-0.4690203965,
0.3320592344,
-0.7690398097,
-0.5238683224,
-0.6353747845,
-0.0646362454,
-0.3985524774,
-0.5572645068,
-0.2636882365,
0.0356927067,
-0.2139165252,
-0.1200597063,
0.1020249128,
0.9643954039,
-0.3643046916,
0.4042311907,
-0.8279169202,
0.2560525239,
0.1168644875,
0.297676295,
0.0365965962,
-0.4112547636,
-0.8110429049,
-0.0302686282,
-0.0856593177,
-0.9450694323,
0.6217960119,
-0.4025118649,
0.293750912,
0.297570914,
-0.0766906366,
0.5610234141,
-0.8281849623,
0.7732887268,
0.7008183002,
-0.7890479565,
0.4237780869,
-0.5692027211,
0.5407782197,
0.5151993632,
0.1721113324,
-0.8616175652,
-0.1763636768,
-0.0720696375,
-1.2240425348,
0.4649936259,
-0.2128148228,
0.0278319158,
-0.2180193067,
0.0057525923,
0.2442739457,
-0.0283751246,
-0.8900557756,
0.0809508413,
0.0219484512,
-0.4452055693,
0.102059342,
-0.3451703191,
-0.4302215278,
-0.0278168898,
0.5305023789,
-0.4544928074,
0.0511818938,
0.20024544,
-0.0754284188,
-0.2705314159,
0.6097128987,
0.6180102229,
0.568705678,
0.0446721055,
0.2032826394,
0.4127755165,
-0.2521188557,
0.206473276,
-0.0189490952,
0.0886034891,
-0.1406616867,
0.4900249243,
0.6323537827,
0.4133128226,
-0.6366969943,
0.5058506131,
0.3304799199,
0.0635212064,
-0.1914340109,
-0.2742742598,
0.6213385463,
0.3894507587,
0.5459409356,
-0.0617956668,
0.0718264729,
-0.5123789907,
-0.0457658134,
-0.001163984,
-0.5747981668,
-0.1045487896,
0.7716950178,
0.5314948559,
-0.1409292519,
0.302685529,
0.2193309069,
-0.2715797424,
0.576053679,
0.598615706,
0.4276258349,
-0.2455737889,
-0.077398859,
0.3266366124,
0.6523393393,
-0.4990074337,
0.2846123278,
0.590111196,
-0.4472368956,
-0.5434491634,
-0.3062362969,
-0.3265393972,
0.2011233121,
-0.7471365929,
0.3252387047,
-0.137792021,
0.0010275836,
-0.4502836168,
-0.2799618542,
-0.9106177092,
0.1616840363,
0.4197262228,
0.8752959967,
-0.8865976334,
1.0175683498,
0.3849770725,
-0.1088642627,
-0.4992802143,
0.1864477396,
0.3401810825,
-1.3438078165,
0.3187275529,
0.2719346285,
-0.0067102723,
-0.2457229048,
-0.33415097,
-0.8372941613,
1.409740448,
0.465175122,
-0.8405751586,
-0.0640257448,
0.3972587883,
0.3414719999,
-0.5195131898,
0.0732307434,
0.4968600571,
0.5547679067,
-0.4026800096,
-1.3146013021,
0.1707265377,
0.0428235754,
0.1632617265,
-0.1282876879,
-0.8211312294,
0.6930093169,
-0.5777053237,
-0.1034188196,
0.1487650126,
0.5813546181,
0.2945477068,
0.2119523883,
0.2798525691,
0.1620356888,
0.9037321806,
-0.0682829469,
1.2146151066,
-0.4577231109,
0.1786953658,
0.9622471929,
-0.5851265192,
0.7840789557,
0.385573864,
-0.214293018,
0.2921427488,
0.4888705313,
0.4545464218,
0.5098429918,
0.3785062432,
-0.526370883,
-0.0843856409,
-0.5643962026,
-0.3576423824,
0.4218939841,
0.547759831,
-0.505848527,
-0.0156278666,
0.1322511733,
0.5574956536,
0.2837023139,
-0.6597307324,
0.6260178089,
0.4188614786,
-0.3370642066,
0.4459018409,
0.3280812204,
0.6515398622,
-0.4470750988,
0.022617083,
-0.2731728852,
0.1581412703,
-0.3609844744,
-0.6080100536,
0.409873873,
-0.0418266766,
-0.4171801209,
-0.3472472727,
0.4977487326,
-0.5753645897,
-0.693957448,
0.6644374132,
0.8651054502,
-0.0140742566,
0.3520014584,
-0.7026939988,
0.2857783437,
-0.0346590914,
0.4531867802,
0.3578291535,
0.6108057499,
-0.0428041704,
0.3916750848,
0.3824271858,
0.3121656477,
-0.4029574394,
0.0817817971,
0.5933368206,
-0.4996757805,
-0.5537782907,
-0.8489438891,
0.7245372534,
0.0317820348,
-0.0083663175,
0.1595055163,
0.5475509167,
0.4038417339,
0.0012799957,
1.2403948307,
0.1321322173,
0.7291332483,
-0.3265807927,
0.8252661228,
-0.7949828506,
0.0545647033,
0.0369506516,
-0.1344187111,
-0.4084119797,
0.1756861508,
-0.207491979,
-0.2968977392,
0.5303212404,
0.6728079319,
0.0213716943,
-0.4638917148,
0.5898905396,
0.370906949,
0.3029440045,
0.6596658826,
0.3638392091,
-0.2998171747,
0.3300321996,
0.2111445367,
-0.2504511476,
-0.2979179919,
-0.7782090902,
-0.4685279727,
-0.0967748538,
-0.0573875085,
-0.5614401102,
0.156707108,
1.0353919268,
0.6864875555,
-0.6801199913,
-0.3340344429,
0.4806458652,
0.1156023219,
-0.0196177885,
-0.1699116081,
0.1641094834,
0.2229900807,
-0.4926066101,
0.6339508295,
0.7009906173,
0.0215758849,
-0.4400862753,
-0.2229770124,
0.0425827168,
0.0330603272,
0.6377879381,
0.2436899394,
-0.9333596826,
-0.0046210052,
-0.1895508319,
-0.4689172804,
0.1840472519,
0.5910267234,
-0.3882902265,
0.2599374652,
-0.0170091987,
0.5802372694,
0.0831044987,
-0.4185728431,
0.579323411,
-0.32595855,
0.4624859989,
0.3375317156,
0.6694294214,
0.7371003032,
-0.3555253148,
0.6969820261,
0.2799189389,
-0.3340686858,
-0.8094957471,
0.3992305994,
-0.5104343295,
-0.3477598727,
1.2606178522,
-0.1819092482,
0.0355676338,
-0.2884857357,
0.0351371244,
0.4240225554,
-0.1308448762,
0.7658610344,
0.2993485034,
-0.0000268652,
-0.0213278104,
-1.0304636955,
0.1741242856,
0.337982893,
-1.1255098581,
0.0643131807,
0.3157333434,
0.3122966588,
-0.2492498308,
1.1219992638,
-0.4477317929,
0.1511818022,
-0.4343882203,
0.382768631,
0.3579924703,
-0.0815498009,
-0.3361083269,
0.0553358719,
0.2296778262,
0.2862379253
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.