id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18312v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18312v1 | AI-native Memory: A Pathway from LLMs Towards AGI | 2024-06-26T12:51:37 | 2024-06-26T12:51:37 | Jingbo Shang, Zai Zheng, Xiang Ying, Felix Tao, Mindverse Team | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated the world with the sparks of
artificial general intelligence (AGI). One opinion, especially from some
startups working on LLMs, argues that an LLM with nearly unlimited context
length can realize AGI. However, they might be too optimistic about the
long-context capability of (existing) LLMs -- (1) Recent literature has shown
that their effective context length is significantly smaller than their claimed
context length; and (2) Our reasoning-in-a-haystack experiments further
demonstrate that simultaneously finding the relevant information from a long
context and conducting (simple) reasoning is nearly impossible. In this paper,
we envision a pathway from LLMs to AGI through the integration of
\emph{memory}. We believe that AGI should be a system where LLMs serve as core
processors. In addition to raw data, the memory in this system would store a
large number of important conclusions derived from reasoning processes.
Compared with retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) that merely processing raw
data, this approach not only connects semantically related information closer,
but also simplifies complex inferences at the time of querying. As an
intermediate stage, the memory will likely be in the form of natural language
descriptions, which can be directly consumed by users too. Ultimately, every
agent/person should have its own large personal model, a deep neural network
model (thus \emph{AI-native}) that parameterizes and compresses all types of
memory, even the ones cannot be described by natural languages. Finally, we
discuss the significant potential of AI-native memory as the transformative
infrastructure for (proactive) engagement, personalization, distribution, and
social in the AGI era, as well as the incurred privacy and security challenges
with preliminary solutions. | [
-0.4153069854,
-0.921754539,
0.76444906,
-0.2312266529,
0.0538646393,
0.172906816,
-0.342271179,
-0.7735388279,
0.2811281979,
0.2598003745,
-0.227827996,
-0.1797446162,
-0.2731841505,
-0.1433427632,
-0.4981422126,
0.7220579982,
-0.0602270886,
-0.3958785534,
-0.3864194751,
-0.2762934566,
-0.460119009,
-0.7981082797,
-0.7613264322,
-0.3813501298,
0.4353371263,
0.2345940769,
0.5512761474,
0.8787565231,
0.1985056847,
0.2884985507,
-0.1792560071,
0.0661319122,
-0.4159721732,
0.0684189424,
-0.0482605919,
-0.5726947188,
-0.6094802022,
0.0222766437,
0.7102685571,
0.6492388844,
0.0019951207,
-0.07153216,
-0.1595392823,
0.6805859804,
-0.6894105673,
-0.2076081187,
-0.6278134584,
0.1118903831,
-0.217206791,
-0.0267300121,
-0.291797936,
0.0202598348,
0.0772446841,
-0.3745993674,
-0.1357520521,
-0.0156035312,
0.5563679338,
0.2663042843,
-0.4590340257,
-0.3385495842,
-1.2077593803,
0.8311622739,
-0.4765081108,
0.1360120773,
0.2998362482,
0.4510169029,
-0.1109726727,
-0.7074893117,
-0.5154037476,
-0.4252842963,
0.0634631962,
0.0851661339,
-0.2959576547,
0.0963917151,
0.0757391527,
0.6314735413,
-0.2943522334,
0.1060439423,
-0.4165779352,
-0.1073632091,
0.8362811804,
0.1957297027,
0.2462857813,
0.3179561794,
-0.2559862733,
0.483186096,
-0.6844998598,
-0.110102661,
0.1240915731,
0.1469958574,
-0.0096413819,
0.4697127342,
-0.3425746262,
0.6613970399,
-0.0557036288,
-0.0839286819,
-0.1285479516,
-0.4756354988,
-0.0035223379,
0.1728097647,
0.6233069301,
0.0144476378,
0.5680535436,
-0.5601308346,
-0.1878629029,
0.4456677139,
0.3332367241,
-0.6456000209,
0.0748628676,
0.177344203,
-0.390871048,
0.2413291782,
-0.037935961,
-0.3884072602,
-0.192776531,
-0.3939373791,
0.2202449292,
-0.513579309,
0.0337776393,
-0.0870195404,
0.1587696671,
0.3218425512,
0.1455426961,
-0.993645072,
0.6130096316,
0.8591791391,
0.8819265962,
-0.2917796969,
-0.2415561676,
-0.4519241452,
0.488029629,
-0.1609807462,
0.6054610014,
-0.7570846081,
-0.6119539142,
-0.0142311836,
-0.36848405,
-0.012424483,
-0.5616545081,
0.2593584955,
-0.5450617671,
0.0453469343,
-0.1200939119,
-0.6362906098,
-0.3346245587,
0.4473855495,
-0.3919253945,
0.7153559923,
-0.1146157533,
-0.2171764672,
-0.0272907633,
-0.8501824141,
-0.6630890965,
0.1187141389,
-0.2783965766,
0.2282041162,
0.3134954572,
0.0452934876,
0.3998249471,
-0.4028799534,
0.4412807226,
-0.2314245999,
-0.5719425678,
0.1892753243,
-0.4995512366,
0.3689082861,
0.3905959129,
-0.1145294309,
-0.031022938,
-0.6366071105,
-0.2100636661,
0.1141805127,
-0.4816820025,
-0.4002529383,
0.1043149084,
-0.4574746788,
-0.1185561717,
0.6900379658,
-0.4981875122,
0.2103590071,
-0.4079117775,
0.7545605302,
0.7778229713,
-0.2221431732,
1.0181297064,
-0.2357449383,
0.3063204587,
-0.0505927913,
0.3017711639,
-0.5563041568,
-0.4292412996,
-0.7649852633,
-0.0647222623,
0.0616489872,
0.6568904519,
-0.247910738,
0.3963809907,
-0.3129958808,
-0.3003484011,
-0.2715066373,
0.1778047681,
0.1100565046,
0.6694103479,
0.3031246364,
-0.2873564363,
-0.3133278489,
-0.9599228501,
-0.0805311278,
-0.3058059216,
-0.1168846935,
0.8003348112,
0.4282076061,
-0.6034607291,
1.0781885386,
-0.2395704836,
-0.3620206714,
-0.2146093249,
-0.1752193868,
0.2186374068,
0.3704398274,
0.3010781705,
-0.8003044724,
-0.2119466066,
0.1392249614,
-0.8242497444,
0.1330776215,
-0.2339828312,
-0.0932354629,
0.2318182737,
0.4325906932,
-0.9179597497,
0.47081092,
0.2248619795,
-0.2787621915,
0.3349655569,
-0.4433106184,
-0.1791687608,
-1.126115799,
0.2626255751,
-0.0868679062,
0.0942522287,
-0.7518672347,
0.1103705689,
-0.3289496005,
-0.1281792819,
-0.3141475916,
1.0188432932,
-0.5346257091,
-0.2558273971,
-0.5177097321,
0.0059660571,
-0.2011339217,
0.3108485937,
-0.1731607616,
1.0096000433,
0.6549876332,
-0.8493805528,
0.3694319427,
0.1900480986,
0.0928272009,
0.437640965,
-0.5596710443,
0.2616506219,
-0.1691152751,
0.4045245349,
-0.597758472,
-0.1895104498,
0.167615965,
-0.5157317519,
0.1652710885,
0.2385101467,
-0.3536605537,
-0.1304094046,
-0.0220410842,
0.6707205772,
0.6090753078,
-0.4754360616,
1.200774312,
0.4917747676,
-0.1537160277,
-0.3448474109,
-0.7215318084,
0.5473892689,
-0.3197707832,
-0.7328526378,
0.5800541639,
-0.0191821307,
-0.4402766228,
0.2338992655,
0.1080420092,
-0.0946573168,
0.2441001832,
0.203835234,
0.2743118405,
-0.3861063123,
0.2359215021,
-0.1245185733,
-0.3356187642,
0.0873558074,
-0.3279687166,
0.558835566,
-0.5504510403,
-0.2802930474,
-0.1652845591,
0.7659894824,
0.5589632392,
-0.4433698058,
0.7150067091,
0.3756988645,
-0.5541823506,
0.1376585066,
-0.6588290334,
-0.0982833132,
-0.4418123066,
0.216995284,
-0.2783544958,
-1.1069674492,
0.7930735946,
-0.3069968224,
-0.0360175967,
0.3378487229,
0.4475127459,
0.0052180542,
1.0329649448,
0.6934499145,
-0.5289682746,
0.3792600632,
-0.3244425058,
0.3843714595,
-1.0105845928,
-0.2390833199,
-0.1673949063,
-0.6992995739,
-0.2687320411,
-0.2960767746,
0.2194431722,
0.0455479622,
-0.6372858882,
-0.1895471662,
-0.3186820149,
0.6610763073,
0.8029487133,
-0.2126587778,
0.1771645397,
-0.1322289407,
0.1886450797,
0.2780411243,
-0.7076773047,
-0.6371170878,
0.9008344412,
0.4444900751,
0.7427487969,
-0.0438002907,
0.6779345274,
0.2829740942,
0.3198758662,
-0.7996499538,
0.863873899,
-0.3006900847,
-0.4534494579,
-0.070690386,
-0.1983884573,
-0.8821576238,
-0.2409944832,
-0.0584902801,
-0.9983125329,
0.1195540801,
0.0555265732,
-0.6058066487,
0.446467787,
-0.7359779477,
0.5871037841,
-0.5772209167,
-0.4128127992,
-0.36424914,
-0.7015903592,
0.4413918555,
0.1062839031,
0.0423199832,
-0.0484869778,
-0.2616615593,
0.5958863497,
-0.185009703,
0.8648643494,
-0.0367225781,
0.2380144745,
0.5936120749,
-0.0533242486,
0.3439618647,
-0.0750792548,
0.0370462127,
0.1880105883,
-0.4106418192,
-0.3557506502,
-0.4596096575,
0.8323672414,
-0.7666447759,
-0.7894605994,
-0.3160693944,
-0.6379773617,
-0.1093629599,
0.04585208,
-0.0411012806,
0.1626554132,
-0.3383627236,
0.1204178631,
0.7412906289,
-0.0748590231,
0.6169733405,
0.2278587818,
-0.0216335841,
-0.1413831115,
0.9740156531,
-0.0088723078,
-0.0376950763,
0.274210453,
0.3073855937,
-0.4039260447,
-0.5143887401,
-0.2163526714,
0.3664184511,
-0.7032511234,
-0.0663800985,
-0.5829424858,
-0.4501588941,
-0.1940071732,
-0.3903309703,
-0.3933873177,
-0.0933367014,
-0.5774905086,
-0.0507411994,
0.421622932,
0.65208143,
-0.0902497694,
0.3305767179,
-0.9017630219,
0.295909524,
0.4212469459,
0.3394122422,
0.4061774611,
-0.452852577,
-0.2964835167,
0.1281511188,
-0.1226032153,
-0.6765270829,
0.2535363436,
0.4653948843,
0.6757665873,
0.690895021,
-0.2042542249,
0.7414633632,
-0.6861135364,
0.7802272439,
0.0307282638,
-0.7276521921,
0.6004527807,
-0.1838408858,
0.2642770708,
0.6096401811,
0.2581224144,
-0.6777665615,
-0.1745412648,
-0.5027199984,
-1.0112677813,
0.2115688026,
-0.2852231562,
0.6221512556,
-0.3600739837,
0.7825433612,
0.0024832296,
-0.0587251335,
-0.542049408,
-0.1765708625,
0.2105692178,
-0.0375189856,
-0.1806684881,
-0.3160367012,
-0.1214513555,
-0.3259055018,
0.3089358211,
-0.2107046694,
0.5371004939,
0.1498409063,
0.1370477974,
0.1487661451,
0.2375449687,
0.4843848944,
0.6169695854,
0.0601091906,
0.1921735853,
0.2639466226,
-0.3379474878,
0.1709941775,
-0.028421551,
-0.3600119352,
-0.3191853464,
0.161582157,
0.7902562022,
-0.1606632322,
-0.7581496239,
0.2528135478,
0.0198322795,
0.0851774067,
-0.7543410659,
0.2396201938,
0.1263346076,
0.3972979784,
0.5890647769,
0.0370892659,
0.1124208048,
-0.991078496,
0.2596883178,
0.7198114395,
-0.3341115713,
-0.4370402396,
0.8469323516,
0.3071088791,
-0.606693089,
0.827789247,
-0.1408495754,
-0.3359858692,
0.4873678684,
0.6056161523,
1.0135542154,
-0.1842202991,
-0.138788268,
0.2088513225,
0.1160159409,
-0.0139918355,
0.0234024748,
-0.2074144334,
-0.846903801,
-0.6333490014,
-0.5146459937,
-0.2324831039,
0.1044573858,
-0.3247509897,
-0.2048012763,
-0.5818421841,
-0.0559643395,
-0.5417522192,
-0.0398964435,
-0.4044635594,
0.1992565542,
0.614122808,
1.1247851849,
-0.7164623737,
0.7195006609,
0.6656914949,
-0.0785710812,
-0.4640592933,
-0.0584124662,
-0.2751763165,
-0.8560999632,
0.4148058295,
0.4222520888,
0.0255403444,
-0.1684180647,
-0.4876719415,
-0.8653869629,
1.3208914995,
0.1041668206,
-0.3360489011,
-0.0949006453,
0.1508809775,
0.6455405354,
-0.8118000627,
0.0670392141,
0.8103368282,
0.4212875068,
0.2471029758,
-0.4610427916,
-0.0008376759,
-0.3433001339,
0.0341756642,
0.1392907351,
-0.6889333129,
0.8188111782,
-0.3813000023,
-0.3288619816,
0.1434736401,
0.9149721861,
0.1918255687,
0.5712416172,
0.1983968914,
0.7074073553,
0.7299672365,
0.0811086074,
1.3532949686,
-0.42142874,
-0.4271971583,
0.948425591,
-0.4151871502,
0.9622603655,
0.5349577665,
0.0620202348,
0.2467631102,
0.4706119001,
0.2468304932,
0.3026730716,
0.056006331,
-0.7108321786,
-0.2213516235,
-0.4662877917,
-0.2120839357,
0.5494891405,
0.4312441647,
-0.2027980089,
-0.0693101957,
-0.0710406378,
-0.2355643511,
0.2181142271,
-0.497993499,
0.8892465234,
0.2404814214,
-0.6973463297,
0.2611101866,
0.031960465,
0.8077344894,
-0.5115122795,
0.0642917901,
-0.4500915706,
0.1835696399,
0.0899918452,
-0.6628793478,
0.6572110057,
0.0980845094,
-0.227964282,
-0.1675474048,
1.0120594501,
-0.2011963427,
-0.2863267958,
0.3825085163,
0.7613603473,
0.1749671549,
-0.1183380038,
-0.5475733876,
-0.134617731,
-0.3214031756,
-0.2124761343,
0.507633388,
0.2871457934,
-0.2220631838,
0.9798032641,
0.6593317389,
0.137289241,
0.0295342635,
-0.2200042903,
0.8330180049,
-0.775559485,
-0.5881351829,
-1.1066004038,
0.2823430002,
0.0696849599,
-0.1256127059,
0.4667935371,
0.6416597366,
0.5813131928,
0.2299528569,
0.7401283979,
0.0352550782,
0.2852669358,
-0.2931459546,
0.6361651421,
-0.5785006285,
0.1763757616,
0.3914320171,
-0.9552108645,
-0.1869796067,
0.4346131682,
-0.3939739168,
0.0272607785,
0.2614108622,
0.4791947007,
-0.1408279985,
-0.1160619333,
0.2647150457,
0.2030134946,
0.2171971947,
0.8875986338,
0.9374756217,
-0.1219843253,
0.5123400688,
0.0935093835,
-0.1951796263,
-0.0512175299,
-0.6355344653,
-0.5930247307,
-0.3997907937,
-0.1185619831,
0.1624824256,
-0.0401939899,
0.4674094617,
0.5206446052,
-0.4829962254,
-0.3731183112,
-0.3027882278,
0.0019497828,
0.0852961913,
-0.1791946143,
0.0612636991,
-0.1512169242,
-0.6088192463,
0.5496234298,
0.656221509,
0.3138229251,
-0.441660285,
-0.3356100917,
-0.2632833719,
0.1928172559,
0.6151930094,
0.774415493,
-0.8357806802,
-0.3019533455,
0.2046783715,
0.0286885761,
0.2072831541,
0.5620859265,
-1.0751620531,
0.2315505892,
0.2015508115,
1.0492591858,
0.3599024713,
0.0085374489,
0.6451541185,
-0.5417622328,
0.2155943215,
0.5059041381,
0.3799497187,
0.1808203161,
-0.4637992978,
0.5311009884,
0.0466897115,
-0.6077313423,
-0.5684375167,
0.4706628025,
-0.8633543849,
-0.3326602578,
1.0899688005,
0.0157924034,
-0.6160596013,
0.0772492737,
-0.0910752192,
0.0974198058,
-0.3051550686,
0.9043847919,
0.5545478463,
-0.2768649161,
-0.142020002,
-0.5681855679,
0.1289757192,
0.3611745536,
-0.7863696814,
-0.0149524678,
0.4941058159,
-0.2323986143,
0.511151433,
0.9490593672,
0.0392681323,
0.2097730488,
-0.0037148653,
-0.1510647982,
-0.1251328737,
-0.5790243149,
-0.3452840745,
0.060670007,
-0.0496752337,
-0.2527848184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18305v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18305v1 | S3: A Simple Strong Sample-effective Multimodal Dialog System | 2024-06-26T12:45:43 | 2024-06-26T12:45:43 | Elisei Rykov, Egor Malkershin, Alexander Panchenko | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this work, we present a conceptually simple yet powerful baseline for the
multimodal dialog task, an S3 model, that achieves near state-of-the-art
results on two compelling leaderboards: MMMU and AI Journey Contest 2023. The
system is based on a pre-trained large language model, pre-trained modality
encoders for image and audio, and a trainable modality projector. The proposed
effective data mixture for training such an architecture demonstrates that a
multimodal model based on a strong language model and trained on a small amount
of multimodal data can perform efficiently in the task of multimodal dialog. | [
-0.1915166527,
-0.7803698182,
0.6872286201,
0.059546005,
-0.1924971193,
0.0838153809,
-0.0141515573,
-0.2416623831,
0.0498704761,
0.260643065,
-0.6463074088,
-0.2417817116,
-0.6278939247,
0.1425492615,
-0.1992437392,
1.0257160664,
0.1202580854,
0.3511995971,
-0.3158859611,
-0.241093874,
-0.5839497447,
-0.232339561,
-0.3753938377,
-0.1396241337,
0.5632430315,
0.4328953028,
0.7332236171,
0.4251807928,
0.4955120683,
0.3379263282,
0.1249333769,
0.1992015392,
-0.426672101,
0.1061069816,
0.2217949927,
-0.5547786355,
-0.6417027116,
-0.1047319695,
0.4859599471,
0.6247223616,
-0.186500743,
0.0752524808,
0.0368981101,
0.0976790935,
-0.3740365207,
0.2787314653,
-0.3840778768,
-0.0402851216,
-0.1747363657,
-0.3206886053,
-0.2892820537,
-0.0348733254,
0.1431631595,
-0.6341432333,
-0.0927095041,
0.1442715526,
0.650167644,
0.2284238189,
-0.8882317543,
-0.226769343,
-0.4820602834,
0.9133067131,
-0.3856219053,
0.6831091046,
0.4006613195,
0.5163377523,
0.294531852,
-0.6124154329,
-0.7631872296,
-0.2194044888,
0.400000453,
0.2573389411,
-0.084235169,
0.1175412983,
0.0078089731,
0.5227043629,
-0.6259400249,
-0.0844084546,
-0.4618055522,
-0.1727441847,
0.1639625579,
0.2827076912,
0.277901113,
-0.3045045435,
-0.5622425079,
0.0131043587,
-0.5460942984,
-0.2006337047,
0.0542152077,
0.2683507204,
-0.3421485722,
0.5379627943,
-0.254608959,
0.855239749,
-0.076507777,
-0.6442435384,
0.4697332978,
-0.7439457774,
-0.1903913766,
-0.4170000553,
0.8766745925,
0.6658685803,
-0.4397289753,
-0.1361261904,
-0.2584986389,
0.1672279239,
0.2981927991,
-0.675761342,
0.0231322814,
0.3144135475,
-0.4661969244,
-0.2510711551,
-0.2132221311,
-0.5356353521,
-0.2652489841,
-0.4523693919,
0.5516165495,
-0.5433216691,
-0.2703340352,
0.0776023492,
0.058667779,
-0.1350958645,
0.8310097456,
-0.7482891083,
-0.0480218045,
0.3528494239,
0.7707209587,
-0.214929983,
-0.254709214,
-0.5269339681,
0.1926424801,
-0.1563219726,
0.6373401284,
-0.4501532018,
-0.3941565752,
-0.1302319914,
-0.1416330636,
-0.0857831538,
-0.5403677225,
0.3371620774,
-0.3844945133,
0.4151635766,
0.0966037214,
-0.4441206157,
-0.0771870911,
0.5427758098,
-0.7214075327,
0.8320653439,
0.1714120805,
-0.4543896019,
0.4173888266,
-0.6845695972,
-0.1883229613,
0.1689538062,
-0.246050939,
0.0201060772,
-0.0458082967,
0.2968455255,
0.511685729,
-0.4467134774,
0.3051743507,
-0.2367200255,
-0.3190502822,
0.2306770682,
-0.444489181,
0.5491428971,
0.5895514488,
-0.1076796427,
0.2028378844,
-0.8391141295,
-0.1343249828,
0.0376222357,
-0.5196381211,
0.211433515,
-0.3618096113,
0.2481169552,
0.0894676521,
0.3416125774,
-0.6373301744,
0.3006177247,
0.2217602432,
0.4376715124,
0.786929965,
-0.263795346,
0.4745803475,
-0.3686073124,
0.4875132442,
0.0768454969,
0.119977951,
-0.570227623,
-0.430480063,
-0.7369762063,
-0.5798233747,
0.1548917443,
0.6311274767,
-1.1853607893,
0.6048359275,
-0.3973494172,
-0.3210703731,
-0.4766880274,
0.3160097301,
0.1687910855,
0.2963387072,
0.0945208296,
-0.3231542408,
-0.5017979145,
-1.0222045183,
0.3126052618,
-0.3020843863,
-0.0839042515,
0.241724804,
0.2879780233,
-0.324137181,
0.654312849,
-0.3722363114,
-0.2745419741,
-0.8992059827,
0.210897103,
0.0743211508,
0.4949471056,
0.4142043293,
-0.8149974942,
-0.193655014,
-0.2974066138,
-0.9745477438,
0.2313364744,
-0.1406051666,
-0.1128644049,
-0.3575108945,
0.5001978874,
-0.7287889719,
0.1174908951,
0.5771915317,
-0.2396137714,
0.1582213342,
0.1497748494,
0.415522784,
-1.3475718498,
-0.1640216261,
0.0493569598,
-0.2456745356,
-0.8499748111,
0.0022336144,
-0.1005540565,
-0.3797954321,
-0.6028367281,
0.4427819252,
-0.1154331714,
0.2430640161,
-0.2189670652,
-0.0137837706,
0.0239291005,
0.7252531052,
0.0300330333,
0.6651533842,
0.6849184632,
-0.4474470317,
0.4315853715,
0.4217505455,
-0.6936513782,
1.037019968,
-0.4283284247,
0.2532998025,
-0.2598343492,
0.4503747523,
-1.2872873545,
-0.4487829208,
-0.1276240349,
-0.3570978343,
0.0233612433,
0.0199360289,
-0.604945004,
-0.1765636355,
-0.009925765,
0.5418595076,
0.2769652903,
-0.4019960165,
0.8795025349,
0.3556007743,
-0.2438074648,
-0.0716414154,
-0.5027424693,
0.2460225075,
-0.1623076349,
-0.7001655698,
0.0098570678,
-0.4070033431,
0.1791474521,
-0.4661899805,
0.0656511635,
-0.156200707,
-0.0257798564,
0.2878631353,
0.3810111284,
-0.1895069033,
-0.0566267669,
-0.4535520971,
-0.1293102056,
-0.3239914477,
0.3340036571,
0.6303907037,
-0.3354552984,
-0.4855548739,
-0.9033764005,
0.3917228878,
0.86020118,
0.1071485057,
0.332197696,
0.6321895719,
-0.2507764995,
0.307115972,
-0.5146999359,
-0.1466932148,
-0.4563582838,
0.4142403007,
-0.6105401516,
-0.9330713749,
0.1198969483,
0.0085074576,
0.0864312947,
0.0899511278,
0.4321283102,
-0.249074012,
1.4895983934,
0.3734056652,
0.1590518951,
0.6925197244,
-0.1805285364,
0.1530526876,
-0.7830318213,
-0.2654612064,
-0.2259650975,
-0.1090205163,
-0.1396239996,
-0.6610603929,
0.5411562324,
-0.0240658484,
-0.1949858069,
0.2539415359,
0.1357811987,
0.1234960034,
0.7953926921,
0.3200539052,
0.2690740228,
-0.0693768486,
-0.0309292767,
-0.3573762476,
-0.7397856116,
-0.4992429018,
1.0968973637,
0.3733085394,
0.7471705079,
0.3204733431,
0.4804276228,
0.241755873,
0.2995206714,
-0.7912968397,
0.6868367195,
0.237754941,
-0.6860821247,
-0.1211546734,
-0.4092094004,
-0.6381888986,
0.3906921744,
-0.4498750865,
-0.8260963559,
-0.2083631754,
0.0330909304,
-0.5358205438,
0.2927495539,
-0.6497172713,
0.7809283733,
-0.2991124094,
-0.2859228551,
-0.0300199892,
-0.7036727071,
0.3691869378,
0.0925744772,
0.258487761,
-0.1156164855,
0.2971434593,
0.7435184121,
-0.2690662444,
0.7551108003,
-0.1896987706,
0.0684797242,
0.2483341694,
0.1559175998,
0.2482789308,
-0.058422301,
0.3027800918,
-0.0046319924,
-0.1891913116,
-0.523457408,
-0.8152172565,
0.224595502,
-0.8582751751,
-0.32269153,
-0.157870397,
-0.4536200166,
-0.592636168,
0.2024234831,
0.0504083969,
0.7963144779,
-0.3270099163,
0.6821747422,
0.41598472,
-0.0781718791,
0.2122984231,
0.2318042368,
-0.1330834329,
-0.7657068372,
1.0146105289,
-0.3433000445,
0.3777543902,
0.3015039563,
-0.0236744341,
-0.2784564197,
-0.4537037909,
-0.8295352459,
-0.0465664491,
-0.7285245061,
-0.2680568099,
-0.969930768,
-0.0566657931,
-0.2672283649,
-0.2126622945,
-0.6272715926,
-0.3223759532,
-0.0850681365,
-0.2731897533,
-0.2417806834,
0.8663280606,
0.0434557647,
0.7554504871,
-0.9009090066,
0.5434206128,
0.6945612431,
0.1537902951,
-0.212656945,
-0.3012129962,
-0.2339241505,
0.0730058625,
-0.4979484975,
-0.513035357,
0.0499111079,
0.0430609733,
0.6938747764,
0.6801056862,
-0.5949094296,
0.6439163685,
-0.3359264135,
1.2385392189,
0.8005232811,
-0.8628638387,
0.7262793183,
-0.6025509238,
0.6087197661,
0.9218087196,
0.1883002371,
-0.5368457437,
-0.3183653355,
-0.606669724,
-0.5879920721,
0.7107176185,
0.3094415963,
-0.033034645,
0.0388352722,
-0.317342639,
0.3430536091,
0.4794695079,
-0.8421307802,
-0.0084986053,
-0.4824050367,
-0.5701348186,
-0.1029221639,
-0.1512897909,
-0.3885228634,
-0.131328702,
0.3335571587,
-0.3134161234,
0.4938839972,
-0.3491465747,
-0.2395968288,
0.3168339431,
0.2960237265,
0.6019169688,
0.5472404361,
-0.4898295105,
0.3194325864,
0.0419273637,
-0.4043053091,
0.2552503943,
-0.1839692444,
0.0936025679,
-0.2932155132,
0.5107038617,
1.1363719702,
0.265476197,
-0.7659829259,
0.7588997483,
-0.2045417577,
-0.2238885164,
0.1603907347,
0.0232419688,
-0.1641530544,
0.2427655458,
0.4564628601,
0.2496000975,
0.3159384429,
-0.7731209397,
0.1598817706,
0.1326405704,
-0.483766675,
-0.3868820667,
0.6465663314,
0.5740091205,
-0.1352975518,
0.39741081,
-0.0038018723,
-0.3668054342,
0.3357285261,
0.5875101686,
0.4615941346,
-0.0894226953,
0.2245606333,
0.2388731986,
0.0936650112,
-0.1494614482,
0.4301903844,
-0.325379163,
-0.9580239654,
-0.1256160885,
-0.4183766842,
-0.5326853395,
0.3590799272,
-0.6119500995,
0.0680703893,
-0.3427893817,
-0.3300017715,
-0.1896061748,
-0.3232131302,
-0.8718339205,
0.5220391154,
0.3623788655,
0.5812938809,
-0.7739160061,
0.3681101501,
0.6629576087,
-0.3378553689,
-0.4863433838,
-0.3322496414,
0.3935836256,
-0.8450348973,
0.7589096427,
0.3712909818,
-0.2703569233,
-0.3554898202,
-0.685077548,
-0.9198391438,
1.0922518969,
0.0993991271,
-0.2289555222,
0.0461313576,
0.0124495663,
0.1882584095,
-0.6694034934,
0.5246341228,
0.3052483201,
0.2570705116,
0.4777359366,
-0.9930297136,
-0.1426532269,
-0.6272813678,
0.0838173702,
-0.3227603137,
-0.7874525785,
0.7104581594,
-0.0369635299,
-0.2719295025,
0.3054591417,
0.9602715373,
0.5406870842,
0.19946374,
0.9115499258,
0.4794383943,
0.598841846,
-0.3484300971,
0.9930063486,
-0.3682798445,
-0.1231803894,
1.1425482035,
-0.3762892187,
0.7014534473,
0.3766508102,
0.0213809405,
0.303907901,
0.5114485025,
0.3242810071,
0.8507386446,
-0.1514632106,
-0.3249657154,
-0.6186771989,
-0.2507465482,
-0.3260657191,
0.9826265574,
0.3876003027,
-0.0591937676,
-0.1781431735,
0.3667606711,
-0.0821983144,
-0.4590322375,
-0.0159999914,
0.9108281136,
-0.2211151421,
-0.6633651257,
0.3060366511,
-0.1499569565,
0.8469438553,
-0.6165033579,
-0.0324135162,
-0.1817566752,
0.0141436821,
0.060262084,
-0.6024206877,
-0.3166384995,
-0.1099579334,
0.2254236192,
-0.56647861,
0.3799799085,
-0.4812100828,
-0.4335077405,
-0.2041730285,
0.8460563421,
0.1047901809,
0.2174638957,
-0.5306777358,
0.3015181422,
0.0131382681,
-0.1706859618,
0.0680273846,
0.409665525,
0.2735083699,
0.6646896601,
0.6637021303,
-0.0487200916,
-0.1022291929,
0.5019387603,
0.8063102961,
-0.7299557924,
-0.792075634,
-0.3863950372,
0.6367145181,
-0.3030861616,
-0.440467298,
0.6945350766,
0.7426397204,
0.4588260055,
0.1156493351,
0.9854179621,
0.0510143563,
0.5628168583,
-0.6563181877,
0.2255236655,
-0.850948751,
-0.0302271694,
-0.1950136274,
-0.8451538086,
-0.2558913827,
0.87672472,
0.1832883954,
0.2354522794,
0.6832951307,
0.8547921181,
-0.1982056201,
0.4150354266,
0.3684992492,
-0.1100934744,
0.422578305,
0.5227413177,
1.3904087543,
-0.3841404915,
0.3996276259,
0.1088923886,
-0.4011766016,
-0.4193124175,
-0.4608037472,
-0.8800373673,
-0.7670113444,
-0.1015840396,
-0.4036352932,
-0.1760606021,
0.991109252,
1.074532032,
-0.3832538724,
-0.3578708172,
0.2840385735,
-0.2782595456,
0.1208193675,
-0.1988624483,
-0.1382718682,
-0.095524475,
-0.8287963271,
0.8588932753,
0.4496601224,
0.3589679301,
-0.3805654049,
-0.1125504598,
-0.12587668,
0.0571047068,
0.8398869634,
-0.2124636322,
-0.5887871385,
-0.4111188352,
0.141619578,
-0.4191675484,
0.3109654784,
0.8973748088,
-0.3698293567,
0.6720983386,
0.3354071081,
0.4422190189,
0.6120533943,
-0.077187784,
0.7728680372,
-0.5681516528,
0.2108692527,
0.0477556139,
0.5255253911,
0.6388888955,
0.0078338357,
0.6196690798,
0.2312690914,
-0.2424712479,
-0.7767159343,
0.290011555,
-1.4607137442,
-0.1563245952,
1.2729330063,
0.2230949849,
-0.1814433932,
-0.2804024518,
-0.4703455269,
0.0762922913,
-0.5442379117,
0.5153657794,
0.793917954,
-0.2550647855,
-0.2014654875,
-0.6228666306,
0.2808503509,
0.4088873863,
-0.9245970249,
-0.3874064684,
0.7787946463,
0.0350205153,
0.44045645,
1.1900677681,
0.016228307,
0.2255469412,
0.2977814972,
-0.1218535826,
-0.0500327833,
-0.6507620811,
0.0009673656,
0.397469759,
-0.1110160649,
-0.1576172411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18301v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18301v1 | MSR-86K: An Evolving, Multilingual Corpus with 86,300 Hours of Transcribed Audio for Speech Recognition Research | 2024-06-26T12:35:12 | 2024-06-26T12:35:12 | Song Li, Yongbin You, Xuezhi Wang, Zhengkun Tian, Ke Ding, Guanglu Wan | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Recently, multilingual artificial intelligence assistants, exemplified by
ChatGPT, have gained immense popularity. As a crucial gateway to human-computer
interaction, multilingual automatic speech recognition (ASR) has also garnered
significant attention, as evidenced by systems like Whisper. However, the
proprietary nature of the training data has impeded researchers' efforts to
study multilingual ASR. This paper introduces MSR-86K, an evolving, large-scale
multilingual corpus for speech recognition research. The corpus is derived from
publicly accessible videos on YouTube, comprising 15 languages and a total of
86,300 hours of transcribed ASR data. We also introduce how to use the MSR-86K
corpus and other open-source corpora to train a robust multilingual ASR model
that is competitive with Whisper. MSR-86K will be publicly released on
HuggingFace, and we believe that such a large corpus will pave new avenues for
research in multilingual ASR. | [
-0.3019251823,
-0.3619033098,
0.034651801,
0.2623992264,
-0.0289795157,
0.3752112985,
-0.6685176492,
-0.5397214293,
0.1935577393,
0.1664243788,
-0.4025903642,
-0.2035066336,
-0.6653879285,
0.2920997441,
-0.3076723814,
1.0471179485,
0.1370593756,
0.4753882587,
0.1120489985,
-0.3532967865,
0.1290760785,
-0.8266150355,
-0.5986838341,
0.0313287042,
0.6194545627,
0.2044449896,
0.419148922,
0.5579644442,
0.3010058105,
0.3840676248,
-0.2802834511,
0.0499982648,
-0.280521661,
0.1957299113,
0.2153144926,
0.0673056915,
-0.3613525033,
-0.3719569147,
0.984177649,
0.415612787,
-0.180738613,
0.3434625566,
0.2471838742,
0.4940320253,
-0.540237844,
0.28744331,
-0.4922938347,
0.030278353,
-0.5830816627,
0.0289987829,
-0.264462322,
-0.0600499697,
0.2669824362,
-0.4467216134,
0.102177307,
-0.2694756687,
0.3733546436,
0.1977749467,
-0.0576363243,
-0.5932329297,
-0.7626000643,
0.7806466222,
-0.4200231135,
0.998038888,
0.5153426528,
0.4014976025,
0.2512640953,
-0.3633622229,
-0.4479659498,
-0.3609415591,
0.4447005987,
0.0587865785,
-0.0718675181,
-0.1172014847,
0.1353603601,
0.0835830569,
-0.6670568585,
-0.0882699415,
-0.9448609352,
-0.423656553,
0.4829182327,
-0.2058578134,
0.3670327663,
-0.3054225445,
-0.1668310165,
-0.0347314663,
-0.5003563762,
0.1206163466,
0.6727175713,
0.62003088,
-0.2153819799,
0.5213950276,
-0.1049906164,
0.5389065742,
-0.2104980499,
-0.3167663515,
0.559351027,
-0.0854311436,
0.0872849301,
0.7258760333,
0.9811250567,
-0.1657487601,
0.1292289346,
-0.1359919608,
0.0955897421,
-0.0573938526,
0.2107747942,
-0.5864390731,
-0.2129808664,
0.1138965786,
-0.3751005828,
0.085459508,
-0.0744213238,
-0.7153772116,
-0.1011475921,
-0.4000620544,
0.1763145626,
-0.8357592225,
-0.5967114568,
-0.06134931,
-0.0943771303,
0.2139232159,
0.2280241549,
-0.6734147668,
0.1396805197,
0.8165025711,
1.0320196152,
-0.2207158357,
-0.809017241,
-0.7349604368,
0.0465584397,
-0.1961578876,
0.6956571341,
-0.7627722621,
-0.3752734065,
0.1391682923,
0.1187907085,
-0.12529625,
-0.2793561816,
0.4926839471,
-0.3434526324,
0.0898977593,
-0.0212554261,
-0.22156021,
-0.0437018014,
0.207495302,
-0.485648483,
1.1971726418,
-0.2099416852,
-0.5606001616,
0.1130844131,
-0.9313181043,
-0.2823554873,
0.2129131109,
-0.0639220402,
-0.2896808982,
-0.2031298131,
0.045453053,
0.1578139812,
0.1856902987,
0.1694427878,
-0.2265124619,
-0.0965333581,
0.3543418944,
-0.5654533505,
0.7957043648,
0.6359601617,
-0.1852021813,
0.0933028013,
-0.8482435942,
-0.013530408,
-0.2996433675,
-0.7086513638,
-0.1858607829,
-0.084183,
0.3782362044,
0.2003715485,
0.2700394392,
-0.9577788115,
-0.3466663361,
-0.2295769304,
0.6608017087,
0.4766036272,
-0.4760090113,
0.3209401071,
-0.0965364203,
0.6388261914,
-0.2541291714,
-0.0095320949,
-0.322306782,
-0.5004208684,
-0.5873177648,
-0.2530835271,
0.4536978006,
0.5013855696,
-0.4575799704,
0.1575186253,
-0.3791038096,
-0.4469327927,
-1.0583086014,
0.2357326001,
0.4467279911,
0.2891928852,
0.4624943733,
-0.055965215,
-0.6804081202,
-0.6755338311,
-0.1179425642,
-0.0032544725,
-0.187312603,
0.2954284251,
0.1749526411,
-0.2382297665,
0.5133376122,
-0.0379412211,
-0.3270396292,
-0.2980749905,
0.0642288923,
-0.2097523212,
0.4205261171,
0.4349509478,
-0.7478039861,
-0.7805944681,
0.2114772946,
-0.6954472065,
0.2827840447,
0.236290291,
-0.0643818453,
0.1523570269,
0.6702538133,
-0.3200049698,
-0.1122627631,
0.8524506092,
0.0548864454,
0.5611634254,
-0.2836201787,
0.2470456213,
-1.2115353346,
0.0795195401,
-0.1609895229,
-0.223027572,
-0.7211344242,
-0.0815834999,
0.1874302924,
-0.573227644,
-0.5766059756,
0.2908637226,
-0.577008009,
0.0230541658,
-0.2075016499,
-0.0331703946,
-0.5381766558,
0.2695400119,
0.3339413404,
0.8598026037,
0.7429551482,
-0.5165914893,
0.1874803752,
0.3711432815,
-0.2255990505,
0.540094614,
-0.40487656,
0.5101014376,
-0.2299076915,
0.0156377312,
-0.5750908256,
-0.205026865,
-0.0699204281,
-0.7440216541,
0.3968223333,
-0.538659513,
-0.1773452014,
-0.2663315535,
-0.3339178264,
0.3019104302,
0.3468256295,
-0.4470113814,
0.8487785459,
0.7257261276,
-0.7849005461,
-0.879188776,
-0.4680972397,
0.334751457,
-0.2589864433,
-0.5916684866,
-0.0336197652,
-0.3927681446,
-0.0372044817,
-0.1438470185,
0.0625640228,
-0.0690278038,
-0.3946577013,
0.3941844404,
0.0510705896,
-0.6051063538,
-0.0666352063,
-0.1300950795,
-0.1776546091,
-0.0772787333,
-0.057437662,
0.6378872991,
-0.3068863153,
-0.3324156106,
-0.3779482543,
0.7084301114,
0.5095405579,
-0.4181462526,
0.4153814316,
0.8238804936,
-0.1604339182,
0.0307726469,
-0.6674430966,
0.2166980654,
-0.4815224707,
0.529399693,
-0.5100970864,
-1.0010557175,
0.3576993346,
0.0972134396,
-0.0036187372,
0.3613135517,
0.6312981844,
0.001028616,
0.87615484,
0.4548198283,
-0.3933582604,
0.745490253,
0.05889038,
-0.178779766,
-0.8362222314,
-0.1994147003,
-0.7337360382,
-0.0650756583,
-0.4212780893,
-0.2821592093,
0.4697447419,
-0.3957477808,
-0.0961899608,
0.2852838337,
-0.4604316652,
0.4752684832,
0.6075740457,
-0.0322598964,
0.1811562628,
0.0302583948,
0.1615053564,
-0.0424807034,
-0.467739284,
-0.4066689909,
1.0668559074,
0.3641244471,
0.5183647871,
0.2880143523,
0.4441638589,
0.2310220301,
0.0428608656,
-0.7173008323,
0.2440370917,
-0.338106513,
-0.6287844777,
-0.2690137923,
-0.382170558,
-0.8022815585,
0.0819329768,
0.0503991991,
-0.5354304314,
-0.1268211901,
0.2607479095,
-0.3653575182,
0.0966209546,
-0.8073592186,
0.6909113526,
-0.3051451147,
-0.0308258161,
-0.0982539579,
-0.8289985657,
0.0112887286,
-0.0054463372,
0.4128041565,
-0.0970812812,
0.2247652262,
1.0610202551,
-0.1366319507,
0.574085772,
-0.3268493116,
0.1714337617,
0.2970679104,
0.0381738208,
0.2458813041,
-0.0877091363,
-0.0730596855,
0.4003097713,
0.1220492199,
-0.1879510581,
-0.0554770902,
0.594050765,
-0.8991138339,
-0.056299597,
-0.5172049999,
-0.4225544631,
-0.3466581106,
0.2195717245,
0.2903900445,
0.5789378285,
-0.4780083299,
0.46463269,
0.5779089332,
-0.3618692756,
0.2540357411,
0.734885335,
0.1544420421,
-0.5353615284,
1.223942399,
0.2463982701,
0.1313259751,
0.2656992674,
0.4543015957,
-0.4256678522,
-0.5743759274,
-0.8052943349,
0.0875703469,
-0.4720440209,
-0.1258411855,
-1.1569769382,
-0.4179165959,
-0.6242552996,
-0.0416658632,
-0.7230013609,
-0.2799507976,
-0.0220687967,
-0.1062266976,
0.6721259356,
0.7845107913,
-0.5030189753,
0.1943925023,
-0.8484244347,
0.3619134724,
0.1258381605,
0.3544376493,
-0.0863942131,
-0.6722422838,
-0.2545418739,
0.2167205364,
0.021171879,
-0.5812071562,
0.4206950068,
0.7856648564,
0.5043331981,
0.5063738227,
-0.1652033776,
0.7346949577,
-1.0082484484,
0.6486715674,
0.1648274213,
-0.7210205197,
0.2946757078,
-0.5012947917,
0.2500025034,
0.5532199144,
0.537973702,
-0.8499430418,
-0.4997003376,
-0.3685709536,
-0.7598207593,
0.7905615568,
-0.0826553404,
0.442460686,
0.3335959017,
-0.1639884412,
0.4536837339,
0.1476400793,
-0.3114508986,
-0.0823253319,
-0.765422225,
-0.4001969695,
-0.3086791039,
-0.2494500428,
-0.067743957,
-0.2131198794,
0.6129013896,
-0.2152729779,
0.3347652853,
-0.125627175,
-0.4426793754,
0.1224292219,
0.4474508762,
0.7604645491,
0.3691269159,
-0.2213544995,
0.3017848432,
0.1519323736,
-1.0126869678,
-0.0798010826,
0.5409191847,
0.0448501743,
0.0191996042,
0.1624997109,
0.6337375641,
0.2943812013,
-0.8971033096,
0.2783396244,
0.0149403,
-0.2069781125,
-0.7046619058,
-0.1283600479,
0.4502778947,
0.1789307743,
0.4153131247,
-0.0093113091,
0.3408205807,
-0.5132210255,
0.358343631,
0.3029739559,
-0.674228549,
-0.4570896626,
0.6311417222,
-0.0070734387,
-0.4835512936,
0.4081095755,
-0.2627782226,
-0.6852266192,
0.1655714512,
0.3496638834,
0.6963764429,
-0.6684443355,
0.165112704,
0.4717438817,
0.0653391182,
-0.2039982975,
0.2443800271,
-0.2124417275,
-0.5464804173,
-0.2226460725,
-0.8396654129,
-0.6619283557,
0.1282936782,
-0.6865469813,
0.2285510302,
-0.1221757159,
0.1425057948,
0.4409452677,
-0.27711308,
-0.5778258443,
-0.1618987322,
0.3992629647,
0.5856921673,
-0.5868703127,
0.9312221408,
0.5788148046,
-0.2331373841,
-0.5583165884,
-0.4465336204,
0.4726122022,
-1.0074089766,
0.4821198583,
-0.073192507,
-0.4277260602,
-0.116331026,
-0.4963331819,
-0.8939253092,
0.6238720417,
0.4372718036,
-0.4034675956,
0.0543139465,
0.1261304468,
0.5079197288,
-0.193866387,
0.1762505323,
0.286809355,
0.2349892855,
0.1411794275,
-1.2602769136,
-0.5740902424,
-0.4729485512,
-0.28182742,
0.0103057986,
-0.7396886945,
0.7393276691,
-0.1649328619,
0.0379047059,
0.0259646568,
0.6444081068,
0.2429424077,
0.2580132186,
0.3035570681,
0.1513678581,
0.6250484586,
0.1645086855,
0.5742812157,
-0.2644042671,
0.0671406165,
1.22660923,
-0.2214568853,
1.2797658443,
0.1253678352,
-0.2657223642,
0.3568484485,
0.4218872488,
0.0179135669,
0.3946062028,
-0.1680834293,
-0.5441567302,
0.0027508668,
-0.1869825125,
-0.4853271544,
0.79223001,
0.4737609923,
-0.1827527285,
-0.1765154749,
0.4515491128,
0.2605156898,
-0.1318529695,
-0.2730953395,
1.0494194031,
0.12795946,
-0.1629270613,
0.3117754161,
-0.2817834914,
1.0711547136,
-1.0495311022,
0.1897053719,
0.2034917772,
0.2804839909,
-0.0991576463,
-0.5501211286,
0.3131465614,
0.4710911214,
-0.0646373034,
-0.3048927188,
0.6992769837,
-0.7192352414,
-0.6780712605,
0.4083362222,
0.4850333333,
0.5068736672,
-0.3253878355,
-0.7440353036,
0.310996443,
-0.0820507035,
-0.0286535695,
0.6040208936,
0.5523149371,
0.4012289047,
0.6525767446,
0.8009579182,
0.3040224612,
0.3560214937,
-0.0338818878,
0.7669414282,
-0.6233593225,
-0.8236832619,
-0.6320816278,
0.3313007653,
0.0639800429,
-0.3508392274,
0.8969496489,
0.9251251817,
0.7799018621,
-0.0868262202,
1.093457222,
-0.0119141899,
0.9711478949,
-0.4354731441,
0.9447772503,
-0.3720937669,
-0.4199030101,
-0.3316758573,
-0.5711376667,
-0.0276280157,
0.635360539,
0.0270209927,
-0.0757367462,
0.3901930451,
0.6508152485,
-0.2874149978,
0.2507612109,
0.191577673,
0.1484218091,
0.1468715221,
0.2748845518,
0.8718838692,
-0.1411965191,
0.9640735984,
-0.1610113084,
-0.1882416457,
-0.0550788939,
-0.5219196081,
-0.6752039194,
-0.9347398281,
-0.1708477587,
-0.2754521966,
0.0611250326,
1.1812825203,
0.8019763827,
-1.004550457,
-0.5208292007,
0.5742926002,
-0.4161649048,
-0.1188276857,
-0.1520882845,
0.4081985056,
-0.2344809324,
-0.8344727159,
0.7977075577,
0.2372081876,
-0.0579542853,
-0.3674557507,
-0.3893888295,
-0.0805576816,
-0.3991335034,
0.7230352163,
0.6688534617,
-0.3686176836,
-0.2034462541,
0.3091644347,
0.2606836259,
0.3638397157,
0.9167773724,
-0.4321909547,
0.6530515552,
0.2088170946,
0.7549625635,
0.5800891519,
-0.0617301874,
0.6062169075,
-0.6823348403,
0.2274326831,
0.3028613627,
0.3089721203,
0.6590206623,
-0.2039913088,
0.2944183946,
-0.0699287131,
-0.6123626232,
-0.968832016,
-0.1261883974,
-1.0958502293,
0.0154973492,
1.3498005867,
0.0101983389,
-0.0952029005,
-0.5238599777,
-0.3108861446,
0.1726082563,
-1.042689085,
0.5833438039,
0.8006382585,
-0.2227614075,
-0.3915531039,
-0.9508655071,
0.890008986,
-0.1261717975,
-0.5619962811,
0.2703984678,
0.2820649743,
0.4673919082,
0.4707212746,
0.7922706604,
-0.1439245939,
0.2416795343,
0.2022001296,
0.107080251,
-0.128510654,
-0.4054748714,
-0.4374342561,
0.2408649623,
0.1190786138,
-0.2786519825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18297v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18297v1 | FactFinders at CheckThat! 2024: Refining Check-worthy Statement Detection with LLMs through Data Pruning | 2024-06-26T12:31:31 | 2024-06-26T12:31:31 | Yufeng Li, Rrubaa Panchendrarajan, Arkaitz Zubiaga | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid dissemination of information through social media and the Internet
has posed a significant challenge for fact-checking, among others in
identifying check-worthy claims that fact-checkers should pay attention to,
i.e. filtering claims needing fact-checking from a large pool of sentences.
This challenge has stressed the need to focus on determining the priority of
claims, specifically which claims are worth to be fact-checked. Despite
advancements in this area in recent years, the application of large language
models (LLMs), such as GPT, has only recently drawn attention in studies.
However, many open-source LLMs remain underexplored. Therefore, this study
investigates the application of eight prominent open-source LLMs with
fine-tuning and prompt engineering to identify check-worthy statements from
political transcriptions. Further, we propose a two-step data pruning approach
to automatically identify high-quality training data instances for effective
learning. The efficiency of our approach is demonstrated through evaluations on
the English language dataset as part of the check-worthiness estimation task of
CheckThat! 2024. Further, the experiments conducted with data pruning
demonstrate that competitive performance can be achieved with only about 44\%
of the training data. Our team ranked first in the check-worthiness estimation
task in the English language. | [
-0.4129944444,
-0.7281904221,
0.8179698586,
-0.0257408656,
-0.6290816069,
0.2288667113,
-0.3015495539,
-0.399505347,
0.1323303282,
0.6069464684,
-0.5070845485,
-0.5591468215,
-0.6888364553,
0.1842224598,
-0.4743421376,
1.0073055029,
-0.0333882608,
-0.1097141951,
-0.2840097547,
-0.0378959887,
-0.4333376586,
-0.4722510278,
-0.4518039823,
-0.4734039307,
0.3538712263,
0.5823161602,
0.5068671703,
0.916052103,
0.5165151358,
0.2853213549,
-0.1909332275,
0.5215995312,
-0.558254838,
0.035103295,
-0.3169264495,
-0.6174955964,
-0.1522165239,
0.3120323718,
0.4662440121,
0.2620354295,
0.0355439372,
0.2487334162,
-0.005434535,
0.5843888521,
-0.5645260811,
0.3254800439,
-0.8515726924,
-0.1395255178,
-0.3815323114,
-0.3085169494,
-0.2588408589,
-0.8806962967,
-0.0914489478,
-0.123675555,
0.4240573645,
0.0705872402,
1.1593462229,
0.23913306,
-0.4026895463,
-0.333378464,
-0.5236316323,
0.7827000618,
-0.6295277476,
0.4784574211,
0.4734137356,
0.0249091052,
-0.1440053135,
-0.6378073096,
-0.5901605487,
-0.1640922874,
-0.0621541515,
0.0971733704,
-0.1330309063,
-0.0258374624,
0.2822055221,
0.5071256757,
-0.5443094373,
0.1104880795,
-0.3589835465,
-0.4427626431,
0.6550288796,
-0.2399048656,
0.0087048393,
-0.1699399948,
-0.4284406006,
0.0122628743,
-0.9255712628,
-0.1289967149,
0.3467829227,
0.3192645311,
0.1049285457,
0.742188096,
-0.3214633763,
0.5262212753,
-0.0026087447,
-0.2181391865,
0.0553889871,
-0.7396048903,
-0.2505508065,
-0.066163823,
0.7262107134,
0.4241684377,
0.1239844561,
-0.1891384125,
-0.4015824795,
0.357919693,
0.0384914763,
-0.8593969345,
-0.3902122676,
0.2506913841,
-0.4075366259,
-0.3517477512,
0.1658466756,
-0.7730425,
-0.6445637345,
-0.5168386102,
0.1982285231,
-0.3387106955,
-0.138806656,
0.1134794876,
-0.0703471377,
0.2022845745,
0.3845654428,
-0.2292997539,
-0.220314905,
0.9292773604,
1.0025299788,
-0.2884121537,
0.1060738787,
-0.8089185953,
-0.1945413351,
-0.4384815693,
1.0333924294,
-0.526053071,
-0.154349342,
0.0491397493,
0.0981472135,
0.1730834395,
-0.7741228342,
1.0685100555,
-0.6330829263,
0.2385692596,
-0.5333865285,
-0.7143262029,
-0.068535015,
0.5192490816,
-0.8017389178,
0.9078971148,
-0.2191267461,
-0.6070069075,
0.6090646982,
-0.4849049449,
-0.4492926598,
0.0564357154,
-0.1492786705,
-0.8052795529,
0.1203630716,
0.2042671144,
0.4773069918,
-0.320709914,
0.5257392526,
-0.1050715074,
-0.1999440342,
0.2797599733,
-0.2843601108,
0.7913458943,
0.1722581983,
-0.4496920407,
0.2757157087,
-0.8080061674,
-0.0257693455,
-0.0598297939,
-0.6607587934,
-0.0162418392,
0.218987748,
-0.2343886644,
0.3058394492,
0.1837146878,
-0.6853672862,
0.1610942781,
-0.3041700125,
0.4139112234,
0.8193674088,
0.0624874532,
0.0420620814,
-0.6501547098,
0.4631193578,
-0.0316995978,
0.0348239541,
0.0145076597,
-0.3289201856,
-0.9690588713,
-0.3729025424,
0.4671942294,
0.6987525821,
-0.7769010663,
0.6541563869,
-0.0847062469,
-0.5869447589,
-0.4277703166,
0.05492891,
0.0182173103,
0.2647611797,
0.3830312788,
-0.0588971786,
-0.7734852433,
-0.8596076369,
-0.6580784917,
-0.3842277825,
-0.0293706823,
-0.1422667354,
0.5674939156,
0.0737326443,
1.0639998913,
-0.4225611389,
-0.1973829716,
-0.214498207,
0.1011259109,
0.1540246159,
0.1191979647,
0.1086274758,
-0.7660381794,
-0.131953463,
-0.2401668429,
-0.413528353,
-0.1223394051,
-0.2273753434,
0.1025106385,
-0.1004789919,
0.3543335199,
-0.6676589251,
0.1967636645,
0.4738321602,
-0.3993541598,
0.5330839157,
0.064505823,
0.2280960083,
-0.7664427757,
-0.1387658417,
0.189577058,
-0.6679362655,
-0.4756415188,
0.0037949528,
0.1599535048,
0.1113598049,
-0.3366340995,
0.1824433357,
-0.4869513512,
0.1645533592,
-0.4012900293,
0.0726228505,
-0.2398734242,
0.1417260915,
-0.10147468,
0.7979311943,
0.5317053795,
-0.7085935473,
0.335501641,
0.1271386594,
-0.7377246022,
0.5262937546,
-0.4268474281,
0.1641886681,
-0.0542375147,
0.2297607064,
-0.9604430199,
-0.1507457197,
0.0687542185,
-0.3772571683,
0.1432255805,
-0.2257845551,
-0.5162618756,
-0.333422482,
-0.4238206446,
-0.1607253551,
0.4326672554,
-0.747528255,
0.3126401007,
0.6310804486,
-0.2498137504,
-0.3372842968,
-0.5038333535,
0.3607626855,
-0.3253435194,
-0.3469547927,
0.2093643546,
0.081125997,
-0.2921282053,
-0.1121709645,
-0.4280584753,
-0.0907899961,
0.1735085547,
0.0213355105,
0.3199448884,
0.0293161683,
0.0908295885,
-0.3720657825,
-0.1433986127,
0.2819216847,
-0.3048093319,
0.2172465473,
-0.1104934514,
-0.3748797178,
-0.4263940156,
-0.0042439457,
0.5750931501,
-0.5526041389,
0.6470388174,
0.5898278952,
-0.2794633806,
-0.3161583543,
-0.8361478448,
-0.3513924181,
-0.4760332406,
0.2248856127,
0.090363428,
-1.294012785,
0.1780201495,
-0.4085282087,
0.3810731769,
0.4011691213,
0.5436967611,
0.0333874933,
0.8339836001,
0.5253178477,
-0.1131536365,
0.4840719998,
-0.0554067269,
0.5150840878,
-0.0719289556,
-0.0800165758,
-0.7625086308,
-0.1117458567,
-0.6895775199,
-0.5570062399,
0.2930136621,
-0.2189856917,
0.0469454415,
0.1070850492,
-0.5040060282,
0.6205903888,
0.4219495058,
0.1160953492,
0.4467639327,
0.1094903573,
0.4424945116,
-0.0421731025,
-0.4278259873,
-0.5569931269,
0.9323816299,
0.3539117575,
0.4867913425,
-0.0650051087,
0.6886867881,
0.3686175346,
0.4257968366,
-0.7557741404,
0.8238152266,
-0.087469019,
-0.4549570382,
-0.2730665803,
-0.7560986876,
-0.7115991116,
0.1975101531,
-0.2551232278,
-0.3223039806,
0.1755890995,
0.2554012537,
-0.1932393312,
0.5081037283,
-0.4064695835,
0.472220093,
-0.384322226,
-0.30387941,
-0.3910664916,
-0.2087188214,
0.4564418197,
-0.1157136336,
0.3593384027,
-0.2372192442,
-0.0990441144,
0.872923851,
-0.4474416077,
0.8501611948,
-0.2963841856,
-0.1798862964,
0.2979206741,
-0.1437970698,
0.8742308617,
-0.1211701483,
-0.0185311642,
0.1410958022,
-0.2184962779,
-0.1957889646,
-0.1857063025,
0.5453492999,
-0.3670933247,
-0.6562577486,
-0.4581552446,
-0.1832676232,
-0.2785657942,
0.2975362837,
0.1831030995,
0.2728000283,
-0.3643317223,
0.521245122,
0.8788571954,
0.0691622719,
0.1637277305,
0.6375673413,
0.0596661046,
-0.3327033222,
1.1291968822,
0.3656660616,
-0.0967855677,
0.3397016525,
0.374553591,
-0.3860668838,
-0.9191438556,
-0.0477803126,
0.4552524686,
-0.4326794744,
-0.4169946611,
-0.4977455139,
0.049774915,
-0.0861657858,
0.158754617,
-0.3966287673,
-0.4779598117,
0.0257537793,
-0.2685139179,
0.4206549823,
0.7433708906,
-0.1127573252,
0.1665697247,
-0.5626175404,
0.4212455153,
0.3133902252,
0.6084304452,
-0.6415692568,
-0.3117720187,
-0.3174035847,
-0.0002764949,
-0.3837754428,
-0.8139042258,
0.1165438369,
0.0747089013,
0.3640520275,
0.0992968157,
0.1650129557,
0.3372941017,
-0.2857199609,
0.8135445118,
-0.0335213766,
-0.6123389006,
0.5275160074,
-0.1570735574,
-0.0496331342,
0.6485708952,
0.3423344195,
-0.2536555231,
-0.5367518067,
-0.6029418111,
-0.8584291339,
0.5742576122,
0.1886935383,
-0.2484480441,
-0.0885131955,
0.2156984508,
0.0633389726,
0.3444161117,
-0.4562639892,
-0.1346681118,
-0.0858385861,
-0.1585160047,
-0.0052184477,
-0.3297409415,
-0.271016717,
-0.0605305061,
0.9425037503,
-0.1549928039,
-0.0011694439,
0.1590195149,
-0.0295576788,
-0.0655539483,
0.6669684649,
0.4337440729,
0.8005236387,
-0.1548531204,
0.0951051265,
0.0083084432,
-0.524769783,
0.2464821488,
0.2191683799,
-0.4864763916,
0.3617648482,
0.1657794267,
0.6475799084,
-0.0615077801,
-0.486806035,
0.5761129856,
-0.0022177703,
-0.2987672985,
-0.0707060099,
0.0151175661,
0.0816233754,
0.1242998093,
0.2044948936,
0.1090543717,
-0.0011308878,
-0.5960122943,
0.3211100698,
0.576500535,
-0.1562633812,
-0.2997380793,
0.4701173007,
0.3012484908,
-0.0764465556,
0.3916091323,
-0.2125227749,
-0.8258146048,
0.5550721884,
0.1854676604,
0.8615731597,
-0.2429393083,
0.2043762505,
0.4594911635,
0.7060850859,
-0.4645681679,
0.3657066226,
0.0262523331,
-0.5995818973,
-0.7535508871,
-0.3832989633,
-0.7140333652,
0.5832008123,
-0.351990819,
0.2972458005,
-0.4131138921,
-0.3742496073,
0.0063789333,
0.3320738673,
-0.8217862248,
0.3055096865,
-0.0716010779,
0.9319130182,
-0.8759573698,
0.645098865,
0.5812653303,
-0.0920145586,
-0.6599817872,
0.1458759606,
0.3382765651,
-0.6030920148,
0.3812586665,
0.2014327943,
-0.0372186415,
-0.0926842839,
-0.7866674662,
-0.5799700022,
0.872161746,
0.6545924544,
-0.7826491594,
-0.1121685058,
0.0982927382,
0.0421202928,
0.1108519062,
-0.0195226371,
0.7729566693,
0.8187009096,
-0.1077003255,
-0.7967453003,
-0.0643152073,
0.0474792756,
-0.5796037316,
0.3313094079,
-0.7740568519,
0.641715467,
0.0507058166,
-0.4662931263,
-0.2301672399,
0.7623667121,
0.2908944488,
0.2846283913,
0.8253868222,
0.4771753252,
1.1543223858,
-0.3994090557,
0.9050372243,
-0.3057497442,
0.2714696825,
0.8986723423,
-0.1722719669,
0.5919630527,
0.2829987407,
-0.2386123538,
0.2240612954,
0.5811498165,
-0.2634628117,
0.2458455861,
0.185909763,
-0.2421372682,
-0.4762101173,
-0.3609330654,
-0.1253743172,
0.4242782295,
0.4465710521,
-0.1323694438,
-0.3064457774,
-0.128600657,
0.2107971162,
0.0559927709,
-0.2253640145,
0.8004211187,
-0.0684828907,
-0.908241272,
0.4856050909,
-0.0707580969,
0.7594530582,
-0.6113148332,
-0.1464847028,
-0.1334222704,
0.0806099176,
-0.2941813469,
-0.9603130221,
0.1553143114,
0.3652915061,
-0.1414585263,
-0.4695910811,
0.8864725232,
-0.6344316602,
-0.2361139357,
0.0273492914,
0.5935500264,
0.1547381729,
-0.3321321607,
-0.5837553144,
0.2433730215,
0.28971228,
-0.2536617815,
0.1929898709,
0.4456929266,
-0.0125467554,
0.6248762012,
0.7717917562,
0.5182718039,
-0.3785528839,
0.0136358449,
1.0002712011,
-0.4279259741,
-0.4877894223,
-0.9134581089,
0.3339226544,
-0.2907990217,
-0.0410270356,
0.9738518,
0.8326271772,
0.9096045494,
0.1585255563,
1.0310153961,
0.0303418245,
0.8514893651,
-0.6315197945,
0.6600931287,
-0.2701408863,
0.1943167746,
0.0643799752,
-0.7670280933,
-0.1314460933,
0.4896437228,
-0.3687771857,
-0.0951565504,
0.5409162641,
1.0056324005,
-0.0952268317,
0.1626777947,
0.1431252062,
0.332701385,
0.5742931962,
0.2063959986,
0.801536262,
-0.0267301016,
0.7108141184,
-0.1820901781,
-0.2644067705,
-0.2413066626,
-1.1631453037,
-0.9267176986,
-0.4428234994,
-0.6374675035,
-0.4716781378,
0.0424819179,
0.7185643315,
0.6497250199,
-0.9491330981,
0.0907463059,
-0.0533780642,
0.2964013517,
-0.1011971757,
-0.1974570304,
0.4591746926,
-0.2025734782,
-0.3116001189,
0.6336528063,
0.1186219528,
-0.270188272,
-0.083841525,
0.1875784099,
-0.3246170878,
0.2666163146,
0.4626814425,
0.3146816492,
-0.5482075214,
-0.4052657485,
-0.1220672578,
0.1177283004,
0.0600658506,
1.2275044918,
-0.7331267595,
0.4053906798,
0.5187013745,
0.8875293136,
0.2933184505,
0.2906716466,
0.3489844203,
-0.7251954079,
-0.2295322418,
0.1971443146,
0.3866991401,
0.6451943517,
-0.2197926044,
0.6143162847,
0.3276315928,
-0.8292737603,
-0.9439131021,
0.1814523637,
-0.6337407231,
-0.1670841128,
1.0308492184,
0.0808895603,
-0.1167441159,
-0.3062942624,
-0.2624156475,
0.3346645236,
-0.3942229152,
0.7639863491,
0.9122053385,
0.1853027791,
-0.1234227642,
-0.711827457,
0.7615739703,
0.3437876701,
-0.9234448075,
0.3840933144,
0.5716234446,
0.2635039985,
0.0694835111,
0.4965637922,
0.0412047878,
0.3151430488,
-0.5613206029,
-0.2284662426,
-0.1000423357,
-0.1272726208,
-0.2465824485,
0.2924492359,
0.1090966687,
-0.3036062419
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18294v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18294v2 | Hierarchical Context Pruning: Optimizing Real-World Code Completion with Repository-Level Pretrained Code LLMs | 2024-06-26T12:26:16 | 2024-06-27T04:40:52 | Lei Zhang, Yunshui Li, Jiaming Li, Xiaobo Xia, Jiaxi Yang, Run Luo, Minzheng Wang, Longze Chen, Junhao Liu, Min Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Some recently developed code large language models (Code LLMs) have been
pre-trained on repository-level code data (Repo-Code LLMs), enabling these
models to recognize repository structures and utilize cross-file information
for code completion. However, in real-world development scenarios, simply
concatenating the entire code repository often exceeds the context window
limits of these Repo-Code LLMs, leading to significant performance degradation.
In this study, we conducted extensive preliminary experiments and analyses on
six Repo-Code LLMs. The results indicate that maintaining the topological
dependencies of files and increasing the code file content in the completion
prompts can improve completion accuracy; pruning the specific implementations
of functions in all dependent files does not significantly reduce the accuracy
of completions. Based on these findings, we proposed a strategy named
Hierarchical Context Pruning (HCP) to construct completion prompts with high
informational code content. The HCP models the code repository at the function
level, maintaining the topological dependencies between code files while
removing a large amount of irrelevant code content, significantly reduces the
input length for repository-level code completion. We applied the HCP strategy
in experiments with six Repo-Code LLMs, and the results demonstrate that our
proposed method can significantly enhance completion accuracy while
substantially reducing the length of input. Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/Hambaobao/HCP-Coder. | [
-0.5283941031,
-0.4857468605,
0.4219844937,
0.208676219,
-0.4322945774,
0.3154743016,
-0.3203172386,
-0.4826033711,
0.1572885364,
0.3344524503,
-0.5984308124,
-0.6185688972,
-0.3209634721,
0.1867142022,
-0.098418273,
0.7439925671,
-0.0440095551,
-0.1330938935,
-0.4992644191,
0.0164919142,
-0.6847270131,
-0.6603206396,
-0.061091844,
-0.1457153112,
0.5642300248,
0.6359761357,
0.476318419,
0.9548819661,
0.658860743,
0.255957067,
-0.1408029795,
0.1596119702,
-0.5607088208,
0.2094111741,
0.2943145931,
-0.4438716471,
-0.3541335464,
-0.2476922423,
0.5787187219,
0.4548536241,
-0.1416628361,
0.1642482281,
0.3101531565,
0.7703168392,
-0.9060671926,
0.1012866572,
-0.1939591765,
0.2163379043,
0.033519838,
-0.7270733714,
-0.2983314693,
-0.3779790103,
0.2399902344,
-0.6187411547,
-0.116266422,
-0.0610320382,
0.6373832226,
0.4667747617,
-0.259799391,
-0.1540471166,
-0.7366996408,
0.6315017939,
-0.7558504939,
0.2176964879,
0.3188222051,
0.0182433873,
0.0052124294,
-0.6328620911,
-0.1778729558,
-0.3281483352,
-0.383216083,
0.1189118177,
0.3013052344,
0.2846408188,
0.4882521629,
0.3087711036,
-0.520072639,
-0.1361968815,
-0.3039160073,
-0.1642097682,
0.0336901844,
-0.1336243898,
0.3264275491,
-0.2778483331,
-0.3390103877,
-0.0282027293,
-1.0420703888,
0.0678171664,
0.1605827212,
0.0757372379,
-0.0078152455,
0.4547398686,
-0.1096830368,
0.7944229841,
-0.0774650052,
-0.3991087079,
0.2454064935,
-0.45197317,
-0.1699299365,
-0.1399775594,
0.3544105887,
0.2676486671,
0.4042668641,
-0.1420643628,
-0.3016192019,
-0.1855365187,
0.554841876,
-0.8493543863,
-0.0148061439,
0.4125683606,
-0.4243369997,
-0.2791545689,
0.060885597,
-0.4430231154,
-0.3137474358,
-0.5747971535,
0.075541541,
-0.435092479,
-0.0392588414,
-0.2180759162,
0.0355683044,
0.2941648066,
0.3531988561,
-0.4109741747,
0.1951402128,
0.6754837036,
0.9892191887,
-0.1311535835,
-0.4389251173,
-0.8598546982,
0.4254590571,
-0.3128650188,
0.5099411011,
-0.4061937928,
-0.3399553299,
0.173196286,
-0.1380942613,
0.2824752927,
-0.8206247687,
0.1599382758,
-0.5117400885,
-0.105354093,
-0.2364603281,
-0.439314723,
0.2068473399,
0.5024021864,
-0.5690960288,
0.8087405562,
0.3652600348,
-0.866469264,
0.304005295,
-0.1938525289,
-0.5986616015,
0.192572087,
-0.4407108128,
-0.3525903821,
-0.0292230137,
0.0985774621,
0.3504907489,
-0.1539609879,
0.6254557371,
-0.0480243042,
-0.8412544727,
-0.2898361087,
0.269554764,
0.5139940381,
0.1276611835,
-0.4272830486,
0.3428385258,
-0.476762563,
-0.0825529024,
-0.0854046494,
-0.6587088704,
-0.2426878214,
-0.0678325295,
0.0244243406,
0.2535963356,
0.4018927813,
-0.2277133614,
0.3707270324,
-0.1958710998,
0.3762755394,
0.6766350269,
-0.0579187796,
0.7766148448,
-0.674908638,
0.7717599273,
0.022115605,
0.2465000749,
-0.3708831668,
-0.1665329635,
-0.5148730874,
-0.4118257463,
0.3489685655,
0.7267407775,
-0.7865605354,
0.6627109647,
-0.2055048347,
-0.1870504618,
0.1268783212,
0.1254702061,
0.5322911143,
0.5438578725,
0.3024286628,
-0.3610844612,
-0.8288359046,
-0.7948989868,
-0.1086982489,
-0.1664537191,
-0.2405838221,
0.393102318,
0.5756653547,
-0.3509952426,
1.0861608982,
-0.4741016924,
-0.4161262214,
-0.10409078,
-0.2252629697,
0.0862870887,
0.7108361125,
0.3815727234,
-0.8102964759,
-0.1702253073,
-0.1410498917,
-0.5400183797,
-0.1340065151,
-0.045369342,
0.0742123276,
0.0472183451,
0.6685518622,
-0.5186522007,
0.2908618152,
0.5350675583,
0.0637194663,
0.8122680187,
-0.3605980277,
0.1847773194,
-0.7890689969,
0.1681370288,
-0.1220021769,
-0.3253694475,
-0.4057967663,
0.36959216,
0.361074537,
-0.2321230769,
-0.5855978131,
0.3786075413,
-0.7668628693,
-0.2608481348,
0.0082457149,
0.015225756,
-0.1633906364,
0.783777535,
0.111082226,
0.8178486228,
0.427528888,
-0.5147441626,
0.1054168567,
-0.1053612381,
-0.4486527145,
0.0807931423,
-0.6135217547,
-0.0418221764,
0.0314993598,
0.4935576618,
-0.7882422805,
-0.3664266765,
0.0167209823,
-0.1829578876,
0.3969040513,
-0.5071480274,
-0.6070748568,
-0.1440695524,
-0.3421281576,
0.6440449953,
0.6705770493,
-0.4254805744,
0.3081835508,
0.4598833323,
-0.1747174263,
-0.6400178671,
-0.7132952809,
0.0831031352,
-0.2685071826,
-0.5379498601,
0.5317552686,
-0.0537945963,
0.0495834127,
-0.3518122733,
-0.3720915914,
-0.1048149616,
0.1721594781,
0.2874119878,
0.2489517778,
0.0034972802,
0.0413671322,
-0.1216320023,
-0.1447098702,
-0.0347600542,
-0.5401908159,
0.5268532634,
-0.1458963901,
-0.3278969228,
-0.3621956408,
0.3064750135,
0.555131495,
-0.0573194288,
0.5044639707,
0.0945127085,
-0.5468141437,
-0.1782220602,
-0.471419543,
-0.1574003696,
-0.466643244,
0.1543076932,
-0.2622363269,
-1.2473917007,
0.5239357948,
-0.4094557762,
0.1342767626,
-0.2149440199,
0.2263767719,
-0.1005323306,
0.6125070453,
0.7090791464,
-0.1302103102,
0.8847616315,
-0.4312379062,
0.2255617082,
-0.6700304151,
-0.0682883635,
-0.5785778761,
-0.2638046145,
-0.5545283556,
-0.6041398048,
0.3667018712,
0.3589123189,
-0.165148288,
0.4916916192,
-0.6364572644,
0.646535933,
0.5654543638,
0.1328521073,
0.4327199757,
-0.0517554618,
-0.0208733063,
0.0629727989,
-0.9147242308,
-0.2677443624,
0.6841654778,
0.4355738163,
0.6022862792,
-0.1064769626,
0.9400100112,
0.1380166709,
0.2350953072,
-0.8698840141,
0.3487691879,
0.2056487948,
-0.2517865896,
-0.2805941999,
-0.6737269163,
-0.6445072293,
0.0155499605,
0.1059438959,
-0.444409579,
0.4011641443,
0.3657554388,
-0.3611025214,
0.0163597036,
-0.6530904174,
0.8015066981,
-0.0011701613,
-0.200360164,
-0.1047378629,
-0.7527056932,
0.3023879826,
-0.0545738861,
0.3336408436,
0.3999453187,
-0.2859525084,
0.4957052469,
-0.7187978029,
0.6988057494,
-0.2405063659,
-0.2816044986,
0.219622016,
0.2215183526,
0.7301553488,
0.2546446621,
0.2679935098,
0.1224566102,
-0.017788291,
-0.552511096,
-0.5319299698,
0.6720873713,
-0.6112514734,
-0.6258938909,
-0.2003428191,
-0.6264773011,
-0.2925293148,
0.3022300005,
0.390298605,
0.7856256962,
0.1257069409,
0.4503203034,
0.7564224601,
-0.2365169972,
0.3084505498,
-0.0313580707,
-0.1481070668,
-0.4760004878,
0.6472949982,
0.1641271412,
0.2061487883,
0.527446568,
-0.0581993759,
-0.0022631593,
-0.7559223175,
-0.3292494714,
0.0889656991,
-0.5145434737,
-0.407597363,
-0.4965671599,
-0.2648754418,
-0.3803901672,
-0.53708601,
-0.1842207462,
-0.2837458253,
-0.000118325,
0.1501986086,
0.0876622126,
0.5477053523,
0.2236239016,
0.4595756829,
-1.1144301891,
0.3593800068,
0.0894734412,
0.4606806934,
0.025235828,
-0.2716812491,
-0.5594159365,
-0.0219471436,
-0.032366205,
-0.7428869605,
0.3485655189,
-0.1205513924,
0.3772149086,
0.0850454941,
0.1571058184,
0.7101691961,
-0.4456067085,
0.3654270768,
0.2382769585,
-0.8570581079,
0.7199401259,
-0.6967460513,
0.8062492609,
0.7333400249,
0.2386791557,
-0.3940365314,
-0.5946937203,
-0.3711598516,
-1.0067100525,
0.5759853721,
0.2363978475,
-0.2856354713,
0.1252990663,
0.5543905497,
-0.2422539741,
0.3016213477,
-0.6584945917,
-0.162501514,
0.1435573548,
0.0151212383,
0.1696120799,
-0.2445607632,
-0.2618983686,
-0.270513624,
0.2862971425,
-0.3499222994,
0.0882357806,
0.4027420878,
-0.4611737132,
-0.0845810324,
0.2436054796,
0.5025367141,
1.1708437204,
-0.3120439351,
0.0091781672,
0.0269688815,
-0.5784600377,
0.1181365103,
-0.2657319903,
-0.1583367288,
-0.1065781564,
0.5707556009,
0.2291009128,
0.2908442616,
-0.7552242875,
0.574370265,
-0.1370456666,
-0.1550612599,
-0.3582783341,
0.0891173854,
0.1828718632,
0.0115042301,
0.5164781213,
0.2304447442,
0.0870761499,
-0.6290543675,
0.3690212965,
0.1979233176,
-0.3505342305,
0.1403715312,
0.0969492421,
0.3789705336,
-0.3201369047,
0.5252816677,
0.1226281524,
-0.5885490179,
1.0006736517,
0.3701941073,
0.7082839608,
0.1459792256,
0.0001973131,
0.4405404329,
0.3243103027,
-0.170475632,
0.1015443578,
-0.5175860524,
-0.380407989,
-0.8586998582,
-0.6313742399,
-0.371816963,
-0.0149291987,
-0.5695238113,
0.227867052,
-0.7004532218,
-0.002641838,
-0.6360420585,
0.2180627882,
-0.2257532924,
0.1734475791,
-0.0552768223,
1.0982807875,
-0.4647991657,
1.0439945459,
0.7113463283,
-0.1516325474,
-0.7161777616,
0.2644149661,
-0.03860531,
-0.2898305058,
0.4123364985,
0.366961211,
-0.0721378699,
0.0933188945,
-0.515345037,
-0.8808073997,
1.1389480829,
0.3616537154,
-0.932338655,
-0.3032348454,
-0.132829532,
0.4457235038,
-0.5026254058,
0.0582427979,
0.501334846,
0.5243042707,
0.156461969,
-0.8475782275,
0.171697855,
-0.4579384029,
0.1682155132,
0.3991340697,
-0.2252907604,
0.4831300676,
-0.3989000022,
-0.220586434,
0.1749069095,
0.4874412715,
0.7890546322,
0.0006080102,
0.6870438457,
0.351980418,
0.5865665674,
-0.0758204982,
1.0126684904,
-0.5963751078,
0.3331540525,
1.09737432,
-0.1234421656,
0.5741743445,
0.6324742436,
0.1070044041,
0.4237273037,
0.9252470732,
0.2555376589,
0.4721872509,
0.48367697,
0.0174167715,
-0.1114415303,
-0.1390999109,
-0.5914416909,
-0.1606595069,
0.154392004,
0.1157057881,
0.1044632867,
-0.0966803133,
-0.1331439167,
-0.113046132,
-0.0397499502,
0.751273334,
0.1962249726,
-0.8629794717,
0.7815665603,
-0.3170087039,
0.9200450778,
-0.5437199473,
-0.0199641734,
-0.343120873,
0.1002016068,
-0.4331050813,
-0.4947779179,
0.3712679148,
-0.0562252179,
-0.2696692348,
-0.4868595004,
0.6341069341,
-0.3424316645,
0.1689480692,
0.613730371,
0.5154249668,
-0.1506572962,
-0.1466812342,
-0.4733716547,
-0.0296863578,
-0.0724934787,
-0.3415513039,
0.6490325928,
0.3806221783,
0.0496361144,
0.6631479263,
0.6877744794,
0.1401169747,
-0.2483563423,
0.1395370364,
1.0390787125,
-0.7651494741,
-0.5350210667,
-0.5324357152,
0.4672085643,
0.0456981286,
-0.2401214391,
0.4459699094,
0.5909315348,
1.0993686914,
-0.0646505356,
0.5306545496,
-0.1926548779,
0.129229337,
-0.4430985153,
0.5117914081,
-0.6310456991,
0.6173924208,
-0.4113087952,
-1.2155314684,
-0.4266799688,
0.5311079025,
-0.187575534,
0.1846595556,
0.8828321695,
0.8639104962,
0.0252748355,
-0.317186594,
0.3430278003,
0.029787736,
0.0704792812,
0.5499797463,
1.0695185661,
-0.1838594973,
0.5771150589,
-0.493858695,
-0.4632105529,
-0.1972791255,
-0.8925471306,
-0.5800619721,
-0.3785328865,
-0.232670173,
-0.317507118,
0.0129038664,
0.7283514142,
0.9516635537,
-0.5770748258,
-0.5318505168,
-0.3198649287,
0.3393209279,
-0.0969236121,
-0.2260198891,
0.0434236974,
-0.5231802464,
-0.4436940849,
0.2271441817,
0.5057274699,
-0.1651833057,
-0.1472687572,
-0.3327142,
-0.339391619,
-0.4392887354,
0.4953535199,
0.1397522986,
-0.4702080786,
-0.1537447274,
0.2228258848,
-0.4197929204,
0.2748739421,
1.3017567396,
-0.9505751133,
-0.0379503071,
0.9273425341,
0.5287753344,
0.2676769793,
0.2467420846,
0.7944164276,
-0.9616820812,
0.1800993979,
0.3667809367,
0.412994206,
0.0144095644,
-0.5734782815,
0.6191485524,
0.1925813258,
-0.6913477778,
-0.7881801128,
0.1413826793,
-0.8334138989,
-0.6182284951,
1.0164119005,
-0.2775056958,
-0.3198723197,
-0.2221733034,
-0.2949499786,
0.1932255179,
-0.3511129916,
0.5420132279,
0.4998945594,
0.0815967843,
-0.2506194115,
-0.43865031,
0.7065111995,
0.4031970501,
-0.8982776403,
0.1600657105,
0.8052981496,
-0.0042695981,
0.3944708109,
0.7534524798,
-0.1143767387,
0.54392308,
-0.3129258752,
0.0993127748,
-0.0167812966,
-0.7683347464,
-0.3625043631,
0.317219615,
-0.0074943183,
0.2797924876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18276v1 | Sanskrit Knowledge-based Systems: Annotation and Computational Tools | 2024-06-26T12:00:10 | 2024-06-26T12:00:10 | Hrishikesh Terdalkar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | We address the challenges and opportunities in the development of knowledge
systems for Sanskrit, with a focus on question answering. By proposing a
framework for the automated construction of knowledge graphs, introducing
annotation tools for ontology-driven and general-purpose tasks, and offering a
diverse collection of web-interfaces, tools, and software libraries, we have
made significant contributions to the field of computational Sanskrit. These
contributions not only enhance the accessibility and accuracy of Sanskrit text
analysis but also pave the way for further advancements in knowledge
representation and language processing. Ultimately, this research contributes
to the preservation, understanding, and utilization of the rich linguistic
information embodied in Sanskrit texts. | [
-0.191431433,
-0.6645015478,
0.4245986938,
0.2539944053,
-0.1545694172,
0.3553745151,
-0.1120455116,
-0.5458064675,
0.5237009525,
0.1871852577,
-0.4497461617,
-0.3044495881,
-0.3346480727,
0.3972747028,
-0.3216138482,
0.7001683712,
-0.1238883659,
0.2161898166,
-0.476536274,
-0.0628663003,
-0.6177753806,
-0.4066539705,
-0.4564335942,
-0.3032275736,
0.4366353154,
0.4316776097,
0.6595724225,
0.3754527569,
0.7220990658,
0.2495168149,
0.017615784,
0.1975312978,
-0.1279413551,
0.645997107,
-0.2150683254,
-0.5958740711,
-0.1352901012,
-0.2159046233,
0.7437240481,
0.7432986498,
0.0253126156,
0.4346262217,
-0.1176758707,
0.3362857401,
-0.7837578058,
0.2599605322,
-0.2362258285,
0.1658570021,
-0.4556548893,
-0.5643119216,
-0.3258384764,
-0.9603580832,
-0.1796769649,
-1.2229328156,
-0.3810244501,
0.1556402743,
0.6157462001,
0.5619208217,
0.0471799187,
-0.5417222381,
-0.7828983665,
0.7237197757,
-0.2202010006,
0.3294722438,
0.524319768,
0.648088634,
0.0221065283,
-0.6340413094,
-0.6443420053,
0.2845078707,
-0.2999389172,
0.1013286412,
0.0765318796,
-0.0407264382,
0.1199305579,
0.5807683468,
-0.6267583966,
-0.0404936336,
-0.643104434,
-0.4818246961,
0.5622557998,
0.225878939,
0.7051277757,
-0.4609084427,
-0.0624798089,
0.0793656409,
-0.6839386225,
-0.2748654783,
0.1420816183,
0.1695588678,
0.1835238785,
0.8223922849,
-0.2990304232,
1.0263793468,
-0.4579428434,
-0.1086849719,
0.0546848439,
-0.4691599905,
-0.3713528812,
0.153948918,
0.3374631703,
0.1448989511,
0.2486830354,
-0.2248205394,
0.2464721352,
0.4005002677,
-0.1349357665,
-0.4017371833,
-0.0282011759,
0.2562787831,
-0.3127641082,
-0.3066394627,
-0.1141837537,
-0.7475571036,
-0.8585987091,
-0.4298429191,
0.2708351016,
-0.4690311253,
-0.5183486342,
-0.2240758389,
-0.7154892087,
0.5600727797,
0.5549573302,
-0.7819370627,
0.379658848,
0.5862603784,
0.7778915167,
-0.0086437669,
-0.1524806917,
-0.0800625011,
0.4887334704,
-0.3108874559,
1.0050654411,
-0.8383867145,
-0.6970621943,
-0.0274969283,
-0.3472851813,
0.0239423271,
-0.3284035325,
0.6321256161,
-0.7733200192,
0.0670113191,
-0.7500744462,
-0.7419070005,
-0.3859215677,
0.3974500597,
-0.3240042925,
1.1036974192,
0.073619552,
-1.0320842266,
0.0591702014,
-1.1095567942,
-0.4868244529,
0.4331371486,
-0.3105656803,
0.4047816098,
-0.1440124065,
-0.1416093558,
0.3021314144,
-0.5827833414,
-0.1707774103,
-0.1223931536,
-0.2487143427,
0.1748315394,
0.2424343824,
1.0022374392,
0.6870809793,
-0.0632524043,
0.3674706221,
-0.8621536493,
0.3089249134,
0.1113593578,
-0.2112877518,
-0.7595456243,
-0.2381438166,
0.227176398,
0.0455286615,
0.4613363147,
-0.8686810732,
0.2434414625,
-0.2945649922,
0.4998445511,
0.7239778638,
-0.0264796596,
0.3984751701,
0.0114159882,
0.8952320814,
-0.192937091,
0.0445834771,
-0.2972398996,
-0.5830416679,
-0.6450074911,
-0.0369083509,
0.4908977151,
0.9141307473,
-0.8974097371,
0.1655337811,
-0.2567836344,
-0.7326357961,
-0.6006661654,
-0.0712899864,
0.4433912933,
0.6108067036,
0.2014754564,
-0.2574259341,
-0.7286164761,
-0.6325336695,
-0.1143086851,
-0.3206339777,
0.256606102,
0.1148177087,
0.3043364584,
0.0017388553,
1.2847137451,
-0.8990246654,
-0.1374982446,
0.0630272999,
0.0630933046,
-0.4485176802,
0.4282825589,
0.2444194108,
-1.1467103958,
-0.423535794,
0.2196106315,
-1.1751806736,
-0.3387643397,
0.2692461014,
-0.2482244968,
0.2326291203,
0.5796650648,
-0.5444377065,
0.7103410959,
0.1594192535,
-0.4271332026,
0.5256439447,
0.1135059148,
0.2071177661,
-1.15695858,
0.5296663046,
-0.5462322235,
-0.0723526701,
-0.6212781668,
0.1652865559,
-0.1146004051,
-0.219230935,
-0.2249627262,
0.7383254766,
-0.2843109667,
-0.3974329829,
-0.3204838336,
0.3619101048,
0.0084981881,
0.2124609649,
0.0059896694,
0.9189245105,
0.433714658,
-0.535390377,
0.6270602345,
0.6210508943,
0.0199139696,
0.9359126687,
-0.6555892825,
-0.0189667549,
-0.1159820929,
-0.0639264807,
-1.0297968388,
-0.5110790133,
0.5540463924,
-0.796364367,
0.0607361197,
0.133079797,
-0.6331330538,
-0.2808680236,
-0.1353924572,
0.4441300631,
0.4249285758,
-0.0319002829,
0.5506535769,
0.6100683212,
-0.4467486143,
-0.5077561736,
-0.9004909396,
0.0454423018,
-0.0799489319,
-0.4718893468,
0.0087252688,
0.0598517656,
-0.6526464224,
0.4506787956,
0.2531483769,
-0.2988922596,
0.0408482961,
0.4355061352,
0.1012248844,
-0.0432025827,
0.7494906783,
0.2280356288,
-0.3457306623,
-0.1803110391,
-0.6498789191,
0.447286576,
-0.119996801,
-0.6534839272,
-0.3704393208,
0.4311172366,
0.4382385314,
-0.406334877,
0.426966995,
0.491499275,
-0.6571927071,
0.3130615354,
-0.4158514738,
0.2367375791,
-0.4123385847,
0.0326346904,
-0.446385175,
-0.9648943543,
0.7978839874,
-0.0492173955,
-0.1159504801,
0.8514760733,
0.3569529057,
0.0709244609,
0.3778203428,
0.7080844641,
-0.011820551,
0.2098645568,
0.1143552735,
0.2585377097,
-0.8982989192,
-0.1867169887,
-0.7505263686,
-0.0936789736,
-0.5979562998,
-0.2850698829,
0.4242543876,
0.0102913408,
-0.2709321082,
0.1884426475,
-1.0127822161,
0.3558737636,
0.7190566063,
-0.408151865,
0.4238916039,
-0.3114491701,
-0.2286513299,
-0.0341345854,
-0.6638287306,
-0.4363132715,
1.0745806694,
0.0104214475,
0.6538098454,
0.0845819786,
0.4011034071,
0.3758988082,
0.0521532781,
-0.5047003627,
0.5676088333,
0.2840359807,
-0.9373549223,
-0.7085342407,
-0.0125488974,
-0.6493071318,
-0.0580489002,
0.0309940688,
-0.5890882015,
0.2939655781,
0.0076657403,
-0.4578102231,
0.1590808928,
-0.8679677248,
0.7077640891,
-0.0472692586,
-0.1138114929,
-0.2849653065,
-0.8108477592,
0.1051374301,
0.0017912274,
0.2497804761,
0.1725950241,
0.041022744,
1.0030148029,
-0.4729136527,
0.806386292,
-0.4288510084,
0.0760100931,
0.6470538378,
-0.0523707569,
-0.0068499958,
-0.0190032925,
-0.1541486084,
-0.2401100248,
0.4861013293,
-0.5670618415,
-0.6540040374,
0.6028833389,
-0.7469836473,
-0.3277072608,
-0.6669777632,
-0.576826036,
-0.0686947554,
0.6694312692,
-0.0439483039,
0.1811835915,
-0.0043963399,
-0.2621863782,
0.6741148233,
-0.248133719,
0.297375679,
0.1015441045,
-0.8366106153,
-0.4130779803,
1.005431056,
0.4047856927,
0.1287120283,
0.4173838496,
-0.0320016406,
-0.3471072614,
-0.3003545105,
-0.5022132397,
0.0061213612,
-1.1996287107,
-0.1785058379,
-0.3909859359,
-0.2405189872,
-0.5752150416,
-0.0997875109,
0.0640266091,
-1.0457140207,
-0.2620994747,
-0.1385137439,
0.8964104056,
1.1676769257,
-0.0337521844,
0.1871701628,
-0.6960977912,
0.0252308249,
0.4060851336,
0.5466997027,
-0.0228450708,
-0.0294874068,
-0.2107683271,
-0.1005506665,
-0.1764414459,
-0.8562319875,
-0.1788039804,
0.0716311783,
0.3088347614,
0.2563065886,
-0.0623082519,
0.7131150365,
-0.3091436625,
0.9602220058,
-0.0612387732,
-0.8636870384,
0.7980313897,
-0.5764756799,
0.1885081232,
0.6309347153,
0.3316753507,
-0.8370117545,
-0.094068341,
-0.3848102391,
-0.5799259543,
0.3158782721,
0.3122761846,
-0.2101539224,
0.1729490757,
0.759155035,
0.0551310778,
0.3237064183,
-0.2824204266,
-0.2644055784,
-0.4089838862,
-0.2287006676,
0.1464332491,
-0.0700404271,
-0.0699956864,
-0.448787123,
0.6455669999,
-0.1326812655,
0.2571891844,
0.4291533828,
-0.2037422359,
-0.1705630571,
0.2367456704,
0.8480811119,
0.8668023348,
0.2212338597,
0.1565962732,
0.1236889958,
-0.6239102483,
-0.0019758532,
0.2866353989,
-0.4531547427,
-0.1745023429,
0.0329474062,
0.6339483261,
0.0109520974,
-0.6401402354,
-0.0401736386,
0.0707041696,
0.3329845667,
-0.8269963861,
0.0144168613,
0.3864965439,
0.0081378268,
0.6272203326,
0.0517501831,
0.2086471319,
-0.2900906503,
-0.1136226952,
0.3209127188,
-0.4465039968,
-0.2864493132,
0.608895123,
0.1544073224,
-0.3407965302,
0.2979904711,
-0.3478007317,
-0.6479027271,
0.2410909384,
0.2671558559,
0.6183073521,
-0.2160559148,
0.0852172673,
0.0478058457,
0.1657674611,
0.3519603014,
0.6838695407,
-0.2615116537,
-0.340610534,
-0.4628406167,
-0.9217880368,
-0.617998004,
-0.6247695684,
-0.4850667119,
0.3099033237,
-0.4337920845,
-0.0947931111,
0.2178148031,
-0.0527723096,
-0.2940957844,
0.3537270427,
-0.0710741803,
1.0073248148,
-0.8777484894,
0.6804427505,
1.1948457956,
-0.9983115792,
-0.7283770442,
-0.4044110477,
-0.0274568517,
-0.7820767164,
0.9429157376,
-0.2418859303,
-0.1975168437,
0.188793838,
-0.4060894251,
-1.0807970762,
1.2002019882,
0.1096472293,
0.1323787719,
-0.0687210783,
0.4371205866,
0.711083293,
-0.0342481472,
0.2204514593,
0.4179906547,
0.8689053655,
0.1570867747,
-1.0208444595,
0.0646309257,
-0.8028392792,
0.0660438687,
0.2610684633,
-0.550837338,
0.703881681,
0.3824953139,
-0.1098271832,
0.1492023319,
0.6916543245,
-0.0077598542,
0.2209289819,
0.1260941476,
0.7969350815,
1.0073037148,
-0.1989832073,
1.0147895813,
-0.2281794846,
-0.0133657772,
0.7283458114,
-0.2177978009,
0.6728332639,
0.6547018886,
-0.3608985841,
0.7119896412,
0.8106496334,
0.2082748562,
0.0191964712,
0.3898966908,
-0.0924889669,
-0.1629128605,
-0.683673501,
-0.5099477768,
0.3399991393,
0.6213421822,
0.083566837,
-0.1115895137,
0.1725684851,
-0.0513470024,
0.1595645547,
-0.245724529,
0.6676056981,
-0.009093334,
-0.6554798484,
0.3341943324,
-0.2077676505,
0.416580081,
-0.5314419866,
-0.2909787595,
0.2254585624,
-0.203643173,
-0.5486038327,
-0.8641421199,
0.9573252201,
-0.0536506362,
-0.2234533578,
-0.1474063247,
1.2990994453,
-0.0712081417,
-0.5462017059,
-0.0694194436,
0.4853831828,
0.2411631197,
0.1086900681,
-0.1214006245,
0.1647308618,
-0.2882030904,
0.0220246222,
0.0653580055,
0.3626473546,
-0.3251966536,
0.6493698955,
0.5277977586,
0.1255689114,
0.4159205556,
-0.2902068496,
0.8510086536,
-0.8454090953,
-0.6215131283,
-0.5090077519,
0.4652615786,
-0.2522772551,
-0.2825848162,
0.9481067657,
0.477054745,
0.770298481,
0.0191368423,
1.4540530443,
-0.5433849096,
0.9301158786,
-0.0652659163,
1.0153334141,
-0.455172509,
0.0124395974,
-0.3406769335,
-0.7089617252,
-0.7641571164,
0.4297145009,
-0.5267130136,
-0.0965313092,
0.5600298643,
0.3106187284,
0.2490497231,
0.4914556146,
-0.097764492,
-0.0462361053,
0.0791805908,
0.2310119569,
0.8184677362,
-0.3560985327,
0.4260990024,
-0.003111091,
-0.2415644974,
-0.1389353573,
-0.5219449401,
-0.5093075633,
-0.910828352,
-0.0664028302,
-0.1155666709,
0.0939151794,
0.7276442051,
0.2807370126,
-0.8665553331,
-0.2353365868,
-0.1799388081,
0.2521615028,
0.0535648167,
-0.2167579532,
0.6685014367,
-0.4967042208,
-0.3450104892,
-0.1312240064,
0.5599799752,
-0.0671496168,
-0.6435261369,
-0.0725958124,
-0.4278621376,
-0.0571288541,
0.5561944842,
0.7384252548,
-0.6544058323,
-0.3685244322,
0.3455757797,
0.092868425,
0.0298367813,
0.6745855212,
-0.7230560184,
0.5976659656,
0.7724275589,
1.058128953,
0.1476511657,
-0.1456317306,
0.4701153338,
-0.4469278455,
0.1431508511,
0.2026044279,
0.0898987353,
0.6473370194,
-0.3221142888,
0.6341426373,
0.3389524519,
-0.5125536919,
-0.8667654395,
0.3201080263,
-0.7493640184,
-0.1792703718,
1.0408298969,
-0.1494348496,
-0.2921270132,
-0.4870603979,
-0.5048861504,
0.6366964579,
0.1655833572,
0.4853761792,
0.962932229,
-0.3273697495,
0.1589396596,
-0.2762965858,
0.6091723442,
0.4727448821,
-1.0451308489,
-0.0201921724,
0.5494287014,
-0.0061976262,
0.8876062632,
0.8697891235,
-0.2989651859,
0.4214765429,
-0.1981058121,
0.2543697655,
0.0269746035,
-0.1575195491,
-0.2769009173,
0.39928478,
0.4030657709,
-0.1397748142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18266v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18266v2 | "Vorbeşti Româneşte?" A Recipe to Train Powerful Romanian LLMs with English Instructions | 2024-06-26T11:39:51 | 2024-06-27T20:30:47 | Mihai Masala, Denis C. Ilie-Ablachim, Alexandru Dima, Dragos Corlatescu, Miruna Zavelca, Ovio Olaru, Simina Terian, Andrei Terian, Marius Leordeanu, Horia Velicu, Marius Popescu, Mihai Dascalu, Traian Rebedea | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved almost human-like
performance on various tasks. While some LLMs have been trained on multilingual
data, most of the training data is in English; hence, their performance in
English greatly exceeds other languages. To our knowledge, we are the first to
collect and translate a large collection of texts, instructions, and benchmarks
and train, evaluate, and release open-source LLMs tailored for Romanian. We
evaluate our methods on four different categories, including academic
benchmarks, MT-Bench (manually translated), and a professionally built
historical, cultural, and social benchmark adapted to Romanian. We argue for
the usefulness and high performance of RoLLMs by obtaining state-of-the-art
results across the board. We publicly release all resources (i.e., data,
training and evaluation code, models) to support and encourage research on
Romanian LLMs while concurrently creating a generalizable recipe, adequate for
other low or less-resourced languages. | [
-0.3754137754,
-0.4499717951,
0.2372400165,
0.3295287192,
-0.4683783948,
-0.1402473897,
-0.5809767246,
-0.2627045512,
0.2619037032,
0.4851848483,
-0.4665085375,
-0.7430329919,
-0.6585667133,
0.1429371089,
-0.5136588812,
0.9002615809,
-0.3512227237,
1.0208485126,
-0.1643880606,
-0.3751020432,
-0.3164693713,
-0.5241983533,
-0.3370859325,
-0.4038336277,
0.7344114184,
0.5081204772,
0.0802538246,
0.4796990752,
0.5575782657,
0.2296713889,
0.0044791987,
0.3632281423,
-0.4904203117,
0.0599922128,
-0.2912981212,
-0.8835436106,
-0.2751667202,
0.0503139906,
0.5722798705,
0.2503640652,
-0.2817551196,
0.3103100061,
0.1316981167,
0.6415778995,
-0.4776339233,
-0.0035057853,
-0.6822998524,
0.1147857979,
-0.2064598501,
-0.6312690973,
-0.5216870904,
-0.622929275,
-0.323291719,
-0.2433348298,
0.1917057782,
-0.0088276779,
0.7104836702,
-0.0046382188,
-0.2156492621,
-0.5603545308,
-0.9204509854,
0.6604071856,
-0.2917410433,
0.5126444101,
0.0839563683,
0.3601587415,
-0.47340101,
-0.6200221181,
-0.2017540485,
-0.2553100586,
0.3404497504,
0.1297334135,
-0.3457907736,
-0.2098501772,
-0.0563881695,
0.3090654612,
-0.6875812411,
0.3411361873,
-0.4734546542,
0.0165022686,
0.5004857779,
0.0836811736,
0.3493908942,
0.3236214817,
-0.5541376472,
-0.1345462054,
-1.0664234161,
-0.2483411729,
0.3095037937,
0.1015151218,
-0.1569447815,
0.9462737441,
0.2222775221,
0.4775825143,
-0.4366660416,
-0.2457901984,
-0.1525382102,
-0.0638101026,
0.0685833991,
-0.0339561552,
0.8065412045,
0.2860636115,
0.4551330507,
-0.5393761992,
-0.3351519704,
0.2278529257,
0.2013213634,
-1.0276759863,
0.1893067658,
0.1173936725,
-0.0960303769,
-0.0976921543,
0.0195232667,
-0.5121957064,
-0.0647665933,
-0.4250539243,
0.2149074674,
-0.6546763182,
-0.0288002919,
0.1154814214,
-0.1601738483,
0.6397415996,
0.2122045904,
-0.6622063518,
0.3654146492,
0.9756117463,
0.936483562,
-0.3637467325,
-0.2775342464,
-0.9404942989,
0.0637092516,
-0.6119123697,
0.9799426794,
-0.4937059581,
-0.5741952062,
0.3111293614,
0.1541172862,
0.1924508959,
-0.7190542221,
0.6514935493,
-0.362093389,
0.2767308354,
-0.0668495372,
-0.7037160397,
0.1361664087,
-0.0200773347,
-0.5053588152,
1.0803117752,
-0.3106881082,
-0.6544247866,
0.2518828809,
-0.3269456923,
-0.644890964,
0.2885518372,
-0.3620624542,
-0.0836349204,
0.4191481173,
-0.0144552384,
0.6930944324,
-0.4757209122,
0.079808794,
-0.2322888076,
-0.4229465425,
0.1552972496,
-0.3855719566,
0.7582084537,
0.2400667369,
-0.5167710185,
-0.1081513539,
-0.7557194233,
0.0135476971,
0.06084745,
-0.5935252905,
-0.2512931526,
0.048637215,
0.2634295225,
-0.1253564954,
0.2227632552,
-0.3493486345,
0.2858397961,
-0.1831149012,
0.5305237174,
0.7550225258,
-0.4031477869,
0.4581958055,
-0.2328195572,
0.7755632997,
-0.2686272264,
-0.0367022268,
0.062573567,
-0.2351056188,
-0.8517013192,
-0.4936206937,
0.5663427114,
0.8386821151,
-0.5331463218,
0.4147146046,
-0.4256696701,
-0.921816349,
-0.55809021,
0.3951151669,
0.2799268067,
-0.1013054922,
0.1238995492,
-0.164935261,
-0.5978083014,
-0.846353054,
-0.0881906748,
0.0623387508,
-0.0514737591,
0.0491799936,
0.7219771743,
-0.308383137,
0.4141205549,
-0.0793007687,
-0.4929575622,
-0.4261380434,
0.0368023589,
-0.0569278374,
0.3570175767,
0.3943863511,
-0.5607165098,
-0.2459931523,
0.2762824595,
-0.8114319444,
0.1672830582,
0.3390777111,
-0.4873318374,
0.3186976016,
0.6758392453,
-0.4365531206,
0.0775888041,
0.8301595449,
-0.0377698392,
0.4904935062,
-0.4931769967,
-0.085712783,
-1.4940532446,
0.0269541536,
0.1735923737,
-0.373233825,
-0.2397840023,
0.1918687671,
0.0939929187,
-0.1175109297,
-0.7026283741,
0.7919996977,
-0.7430332899,
-0.0429265089,
-0.0970019698,
0.2674601376,
-0.2315295041,
0.2540311217,
0.2862236202,
0.9438120127,
0.3955945969,
-0.5801537037,
0.458196193,
0.0690485388,
-0.6181181073,
0.7606345415,
-0.5799620748,
0.0900040641,
-0.1060464382,
-0.0014415943,
-0.6258015037,
-0.1937499642,
0.0039960067,
-0.5074067116,
0.3862728179,
-0.3301123977,
-0.3581460416,
-0.2235027552,
-0.0502482764,
-0.2274152637,
0.5347841382,
-0.57984972,
0.7662693262,
0.4303386509,
0.0760691613,
-0.4902594984,
-0.7055817246,
0.1315359026,
-0.432009846,
-0.4998085797,
0.2404325455,
-0.2258732468,
-0.4298211336,
-0.0952424929,
0.0132983411,
-0.2799537182,
0.0658824667,
0.0184116364,
0.1124029979,
-0.2366327196,
0.0881283805,
-0.2560690641,
0.0013991724,
-0.0129778115,
-0.3917282224,
0.5735162497,
-0.4084914625,
-0.1246753186,
-0.4494547546,
0.3433003724,
0.6308898926,
-0.4142221212,
0.7147384286,
0.7602226734,
-0.4725879133,
-0.445430547,
-0.6893042922,
-0.0986727774,
-0.3871646821,
0.4288532138,
-0.4924636781,
-0.6755179167,
0.1871066689,
-0.3343637884,
0.3258567154,
0.0079617938,
0.7430953383,
-0.307262063,
0.9363036156,
0.7268332243,
-0.1673702896,
0.5378473401,
-0.4491011798,
-0.1458422542,
-0.4775024652,
-0.3297273517,
-0.8464847207,
-0.1103296354,
-0.7373787761,
-0.6785788536,
0.5128036141,
0.1808839589,
0.2264640331,
0.4043864012,
-0.2855637372,
0.4368517101,
0.518655479,
0.1269160807,
0.1465983391,
0.4428489506,
-0.3395453691,
-0.0989977345,
-0.8285474181,
-1.019993782,
1.066971302,
0.1950673461,
0.9602102041,
0.011867078,
0.9070862532,
0.1272360831,
0.256492883,
-0.8853662014,
0.5038059354,
-0.2392115146,
-0.5842676163,
-0.1661837399,
-0.4138660431,
-1.1774109602,
0.3010509014,
-0.2152397186,
-0.2858197689,
-0.3040277064,
0.1459832937,
0.0787933543,
0.2445338815,
-0.8912360668,
0.7999396324,
-0.6902284622,
-0.561304152,
-0.4548784196,
-0.0224361829,
0.0985399783,
0.2320045978,
0.4482615292,
-0.1259117275,
-0.3497350812,
0.7279210687,
-0.366715461,
0.5588956475,
-0.031471543,
-0.0240923706,
0.1508706212,
0.147054702,
0.592432797,
0.198197335,
-0.023588907,
0.2604021132,
0.0825496539,
-0.733761847,
-0.5130552053,
0.6698188186,
-0.8427559733,
-0.5759086609,
-0.4176179171,
0.1297305673,
-0.1201590747,
0.1119403243,
0.4558039308,
0.6412514448,
-0.8074458241,
0.3527212143,
0.8798778057,
-0.0028084402,
0.3196041286,
0.6700206995,
0.0323807597,
-0.5110474229,
0.921197772,
0.1342650354,
-0.023391258,
0.5442122817,
0.0552298017,
-0.082952939,
-0.6111534238,
-0.7717117667,
0.3997012675,
-0.4933844507,
0.0116045885,
-0.2877371311,
-0.0592550449,
-0.0547960401,
-0.1993721426,
-0.7124662995,
-0.0206617843,
-0.318385452,
-0.1908144653,
0.2512363195,
0.8977326751,
-0.0701871961,
-0.0289986189,
-0.5812646747,
0.1192791462,
0.1626532376,
0.2777677476,
-0.3345550597,
-0.3527273536,
-0.4002393484,
0.1106735468,
-0.1368519515,
-0.7396095991,
0.4191328883,
-0.0310020279,
0.7000831962,
0.2432555556,
-0.2681829035,
0.5267521739,
-0.8382337093,
0.4543144703,
0.3631459773,
-0.599537313,
0.6108934879,
-0.124859795,
0.0578178242,
0.3967088163,
0.824375391,
-0.5695675015,
-0.3301879168,
-0.3430803716,
-0.7471162677,
0.5761299133,
0.1036255434,
0.4570348263,
-0.064624384,
0.2844976783,
0.2504477799,
0.0760052428,
-0.6207741499,
-0.1558448523,
0.1292831302,
-0.059376549,
-0.1646017879,
-0.3357333839,
-0.2462649792,
-0.265912801,
0.9600275159,
-0.0018115839,
0.2572759092,
0.1265699416,
-0.3587793708,
0.0707420558,
0.4408290684,
0.8191021085,
0.9021176696,
0.0455371961,
0.0860790238,
0.4252178073,
-0.4508373737,
0.3688421845,
-0.2072927952,
-0.0231367238,
0.2753771544,
0.5196598172,
0.911521256,
0.3025532961,
-0.7895087004,
0.5307232141,
-0.5069307685,
-0.1916723996,
-0.9847632647,
0.1682946831,
0.4584861994,
0.2293357402,
0.3155370355,
-0.1447504908,
-0.3216685653,
-0.6656906605,
0.0436626077,
0.4670421481,
-0.6584082842,
-0.3975994587,
0.4841401875,
0.4612860084,
-0.7085204124,
0.2165573686,
-0.115467079,
-0.3298697174,
0.1662062109,
0.2563905716,
0.7134869695,
-0.2936285436,
0.3653697371,
0.3984290361,
0.5095734,
-0.2259996086,
0.3390166759,
0.1272954941,
-0.5333538055,
-0.322506994,
-0.7666320801,
-0.4445697069,
0.4463663399,
-0.830719173,
0.7845982313,
-0.3424889445,
-0.0403087288,
-0.0640149415,
-0.051101733,
-0.8897346258,
0.1066241711,
0.1462087631,
1.1871058941,
-0.653501153,
0.8816505671,
0.878847301,
-0.2077459991,
-0.4388654828,
-0.3914550245,
-0.338383913,
-1.0439870358,
0.4703872204,
-0.0106468685,
-0.2174751908,
-0.0838886499,
-0.5418838263,
-0.383672744,
0.7624320388,
0.7182798386,
-0.83314538,
-0.207331866,
0.1361429095,
0.6038613319,
-0.5009552836,
0.4334247708,
0.4581488669,
0.3234404922,
-0.0654926524,
-0.5875467658,
-0.4563698471,
-0.3270642757,
0.1623417288,
-0.1142381951,
-0.7216038108,
0.0803843811,
-0.0924701169,
-0.2913541496,
0.0692309216,
0.7838703394,
0.0723665282,
-0.1500361711,
0.2213013172,
0.3318197429,
0.7954180241,
-0.1861515641,
1.0615077019,
-0.567902267,
-0.232921496,
0.952466011,
-0.1586271673,
1.2100992203,
0.4905869067,
-0.0351641625,
0.500446856,
0.6444993019,
0.0575125553,
0.3161883056,
0.3902689517,
-0.3531357348,
-0.4402428865,
-0.1530807912,
-0.3043808043,
0.6007244587,
0.2131967247,
-0.2804276645,
-0.1104517803,
0.2119376659,
0.3917755187,
0.2662302256,
-0.1759138852,
0.8852832317,
0.2139941156,
-0.8875408173,
1.0865616798,
0.1312322021,
0.6583086252,
-0.6357215047,
0.0080535877,
-0.5239012241,
0.3411122561,
0.0415181592,
-0.3403863311,
-0.0665575936,
0.4084150493,
-0.0580302812,
-0.2908099294,
0.1180153862,
-0.4894833267,
-0.7934165001,
0.6618096232,
0.4600768685,
0.5960730314,
0.1521569788,
-0.4801175892,
0.2418088019,
0.0284883939,
-0.2232021242,
0.2527786195,
0.5413112044,
-0.0862411931,
0.7202649117,
0.3327740431,
0.6014261246,
0.3242519498,
0.0885052681,
0.6467906833,
-0.5262166262,
-0.0862432718,
-0.8380156755,
0.3623585999,
0.0828552172,
-0.5148912072,
0.55292207,
0.8904772401,
1.1737514734,
-0.0917657912,
0.8522106409,
0.2781381607,
0.3654863238,
-0.693351984,
0.4707176685,
-0.795029819,
0.0128723783,
0.3759253621,
-1.1372302771,
0.1741827726,
0.4681539834,
-0.0394318663,
-0.2101804912,
0.7197972536,
0.9458661079,
0.0296667814,
-0.0890935957,
0.4153101444,
0.3100963235,
0.1817892194,
0.4098746479,
0.6901538372,
-0.2736816704,
0.9597511888,
-0.1571564078,
-0.3668589294,
-0.2586370111,
-0.6668723226,
-1.2044149637,
-0.6328246593,
-0.0975585282,
-0.3248157799,
0.4415229261,
1.0220901966,
0.7738479972,
-0.9412410855,
-0.69769454,
-0.0428844579,
0.0454685837,
-0.1368130893,
-0.0952348188,
0.0665332749,
-0.4119871855,
-1.0738731623,
0.5371515751,
0.1208070666,
0.1163710356,
-0.6482172012,
-0.3581519127,
0.0157102719,
0.0868045613,
0.5481778979,
0.079431653,
-0.7167339921,
0.0741162151,
0.2290154994,
-0.3539700806,
0.1401410401,
0.9401349425,
-0.1602232158,
0.3246634901,
0.3633185923,
0.4007458687,
0.7778650522,
-0.4477936029,
0.8863469958,
-0.5111894608,
0.4136719704,
0.2523105741,
0.620031178,
0.4609467685,
0.0259174295,
0.7182214856,
0.1212353781,
-0.2874747217,
-0.8267883062,
-0.1665319502,
-0.6432936192,
-0.2464203984,
1.5590766668,
-0.2245687842,
-0.6975727677,
0.2978321314,
-0.2635394335,
0.3021225333,
-0.2455450594,
0.6949686408,
0.8752012253,
0.3747772276,
0.0400294103,
-0.805790782,
0.403396666,
0.320566088,
-0.7719166875,
-0.0188408829,
0.3845764995,
0.5685462356,
-0.1720443368,
0.4695565701,
-0.2803790569,
0.3332086504,
-0.2352201492,
0.6460384727,
0.0929828733,
-0.5538794398,
-0.2472916245,
0.0929995254,
0.3324694633,
0.0043465598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18259v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18259v1 | Detecting Machine-Generated Texts: Not Just "AI vs Humans" and Explainability is Complicated | 2024-06-26T11:11:47 | 2024-06-26T11:11:47 | Jiazhou Ji, Ruizhe Li, Shujun Li, Jie Guo, Weidong Qiu, Zheng Huang, Chiyu Chen, Xiaoyu Jiang, Xinru Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As LLMs rapidly advance, increasing concerns arise regarding risks about
actual authorship of texts we see online and in real world. The task of
distinguishing LLM-authored texts is complicated by the nuanced and overlapping
behaviors of both machines and humans. In this paper, we challenge the current
practice of considering LLM-generated text detection a binary classification
task of differentiating human from AI. Instead, we introduce a novel ternary
text classification scheme, adding an "undecided" category for texts that could
be attributed to either source, and we show that this new category is crucial
to understand how to make the detection result more explainable to lay users.
This research shifts the paradigm from merely classifying to explaining
machine-generated texts, emphasizing need for detectors to provide clear and
understandable explanations to users. Our study involves creating four new
datasets comprised of texts from various LLMs and human authors. Based on new
datasets, we performed binary classification tests to ascertain the most
effective SOTA detection methods and identified SOTA LLMs capable of producing
harder-to-detect texts. We constructed a new dataset of texts generated by two
top-performing LLMs and human authors, and asked three human annotators to
produce ternary labels with explanation notes. This dataset was used to
investigate how three top-performing SOTA detectors behave in new ternary
classification context. Our results highlight why "undecided" category is much
needed from the viewpoint of explainability. Additionally, we conducted an
analysis of explainability of the three best-performing detectors and the
explanation notes of the human annotators, revealing insights about the
complexity of explainable detection of machine-generated texts. Finally, we
propose guidelines for developing future detection systems with improved
explanatory power. | [
-0.2990110815,
-0.6467400193,
0.7996317744,
-0.2032844573,
-0.2096364498,
0.21312356,
-0.1360660791,
-0.7282552719,
-0.1178467199,
0.5795385838,
-0.5566649437,
-0.5703270435,
-0.7013628483,
0.5622796416,
-0.5664839149,
1.2204856873,
-0.0685478225,
-0.3192422092,
-0.2370868027,
-0.0697004721,
-0.4137074053,
-0.538995266,
-0.4733869731,
-0.4659934342,
0.4002773762,
0.4988330901,
0.5591102839,
0.6657274365,
0.4100635648,
0.3660412133,
-0.0849014595,
0.3528442383,
-0.2221675664,
0.1178961471,
-0.0538386479,
-0.6754474044,
-0.3075116575,
-0.2224123925,
0.3155764639,
0.4501434863,
0.3614342213,
0.1233214661,
-0.0062648822,
0.4876684844,
-0.46879071,
-0.0815086588,
-0.5420081615,
0.1205948889,
-0.3806276023,
-0.693063736,
-0.6378914118,
-0.2611134648,
-0.088339746,
-0.4534462392,
0.4051956236,
0.1411044002,
0.6049873233,
0.2525158823,
-0.5227122903,
-0.6735644937,
-0.8030637503,
0.6350848675,
-0.4499002993,
-0.0569234341,
0.0936400369,
0.0914690346,
-0.1325049251,
-0.556188345,
-0.7415172458,
0.0161955561,
-0.0811651647,
-0.0315922648,
-0.4596601427,
-0.1731547266,
0.1429944336,
0.0054049944,
-0.6078660488,
0.4647310078,
-0.1741693616,
-0.3318603039,
0.6196280122,
0.1469947994,
0.6488044262,
-0.3235940635,
-0.4898846745,
0.4252929986,
-0.7567412257,
0.0507049672,
0.4589221478,
0.0866119415,
0.0442316905,
0.596632123,
0.0925582275,
0.2745359838,
0.0432641543,
-0.1226625368,
0.0113320593,
-0.1929187626,
-0.0495360978,
0.510997355,
1.0204554796,
0.2575365305,
0.3110492229,
-0.1651940495,
-0.2217563689,
0.1189076006,
0.057136707,
-0.5854158401,
-0.1121781096,
0.181385234,
-0.6032153964,
-0.6435665488,
0.0768931508,
-0.3160724938,
-0.755169034,
-0.1421824247,
0.5241649151,
-0.0794732124,
-0.2766057551,
0.0610672385,
-0.1427033544,
-0.1331353933,
0.3520042896,
-0.9871130586,
0.0776662529,
0.7407704592,
0.4591115415,
-0.2718093395,
-0.1690450311,
-0.3036067486,
0.122428827,
-0.4622943699,
1.1120840311,
-0.3916913867,
-0.083901234,
-0.2452913821,
-0.1496813148,
0.3464511633,
-0.3855930865,
0.5141857862,
-0.4988646805,
0.6680640578,
-0.157630071,
-0.4503770471,
-0.3263762295,
-0.0128194671,
-0.4820724428,
1.1095650196,
-0.2263284177,
-0.9042465091,
0.6601356268,
-0.6303307414,
-0.4450542331,
0.3923944533,
-0.3141882122,
-0.6273036599,
0.0738499165,
0.0466925614,
0.8013936877,
-0.3656672537,
0.7564213276,
-0.1579895318,
-0.6501899362,
0.7592023611,
-0.5498049855,
0.788074851,
0.2099342942,
-0.6928724051,
0.2060141712,
-0.7473883629,
-0.1270689815,
0.1241129935,
-0.2772336304,
-0.3209431469,
0.0308760721,
0.0834643692,
-0.129714787,
0.218388468,
-0.4003834724,
-0.1358240694,
-0.1886627227,
0.6526911855,
0.9252377152,
-0.1383813024,
0.4460324645,
-0.1606918126,
0.4250838757,
-0.1335451603,
-0.1253529042,
-0.1909422576,
-0.5106773376,
-0.7073124647,
-0.1842167079,
0.2001103014,
0.3369161487,
-0.8886125088,
0.603577435,
-0.1728681922,
-0.3227361143,
-0.2880330086,
0.0765952244,
0.5643168688,
0.4332284629,
0.1445521861,
-0.0310672894,
-0.6225078106,
-0.7197037339,
-0.5709854364,
-0.5348635912,
-0.1265692115,
0.1798399836,
0.7069292665,
-0.2468966395,
0.9554986358,
-0.3699986637,
0.042818442,
-0.4954523146,
0.4346755147,
0.0377030112,
0.2414471209,
0.2916893065,
-0.9886245131,
-0.2774647176,
-0.0629983172,
-1.1666787863,
-0.4769344628,
-0.3263276219,
0.0931217968,
0.4292319119,
0.587526083,
-0.3703175187,
0.5310075283,
-0.0430522636,
-0.4999465048,
0.4380791783,
-0.1567511111,
-0.0118921306,
-0.8568144441,
0.0636388585,
-0.0309328679,
-0.4040092826,
-0.7596932054,
0.0295741986,
-0.0733284801,
0.0618659817,
-0.3593800664,
0.3443267941,
-0.4013640583,
-0.1035144106,
-0.4212720394,
0.0450337492,
-0.0009464477,
0.454068929,
0.0185499731,
0.6085914373,
0.2319523394,
-0.5874384046,
0.0923837051,
0.0675865039,
-0.2050518245,
0.5737829804,
-0.5994505882,
0.1820842475,
-0.324432373,
0.3432571888,
-1.1730830669,
-0.1703424603,
0.5160679221,
-0.7926493883,
0.1343421638,
-0.0816125646,
-0.6974655986,
-0.1318449527,
-0.2862066925,
0.2000347674,
0.3129711449,
-0.5342636108,
0.6336959004,
0.4142483473,
-0.171569705,
-0.5072000623,
-0.6960846186,
0.4379526973,
-0.5612691641,
-0.4459792376,
0.2893313468,
-0.0343917236,
-0.265597105,
0.0847374275,
-0.2023629844,
-0.1541155577,
0.5431672335,
0.4830935895,
0.3303674459,
-0.2754391134,
0.3141196072,
-0.0685509667,
-0.664267838,
0.2602103949,
-0.2564023137,
0.2389916033,
-0.1127877086,
-0.2138356715,
-0.7366111279,
0.3588566482,
0.3020579219,
0.0981550738,
0.5231746435,
0.9172718525,
-0.3305674493,
-0.1234334558,
-0.3063309491,
-0.0329592563,
-0.4882537425,
0.1490905732,
-0.4343941212,
-0.991969049,
0.2556531131,
0.1720738858,
-0.0249401443,
0.6939799786,
0.7568921447,
-0.4379218519,
1.0385056734,
0.6665897369,
0.2433523834,
0.2092789561,
0.0369087048,
0.227506578,
-0.3468807042,
-0.453968823,
-0.6622823477,
-0.2983451486,
-1.048330307,
-0.0358351581,
0.310729593,
-0.3061045408,
-0.3173916936,
0.2188940495,
-0.7771711946,
0.7883508801,
0.6177138686,
0.215356946,
0.6262701154,
-0.0994919389,
0.417201221,
0.0747542605,
-0.3535483181,
-1.0549433231,
1.1814156771,
0.2887469232,
0.6925622225,
0.2404409349,
0.9182813168,
0.7056939602,
0.1854548156,
-0.6059530973,
0.6810811758,
-0.3045441508,
-0.8410096765,
-0.0982991084,
-0.342869401,
-1.119022131,
0.1022220403,
-0.4989932477,
-0.7343750596,
-0.1525357962,
0.0186743326,
-0.1957605034,
0.3246203065,
-0.7383956909,
0.6482420564,
-0.4149793983,
-0.1502216905,
0.1747203618,
-0.8217886686,
0.3422510922,
-0.1026545241,
0.1932544857,
-0.1403667629,
-0.2194036394,
1.0358732939,
-0.3007115722,
1.0080931187,
-0.0849091485,
-0.1910649538,
0.442828685,
0.1272357702,
0.2673097849,
-0.0679545552,
0.0998260528,
0.1215799004,
-0.2527646124,
-0.2786518335,
-0.3866490722,
0.3325255513,
-0.7267000079,
-0.4860747755,
-0.4039117992,
-0.2771314979,
0.212116003,
0.4104096591,
0.6937660575,
0.3690638542,
0.0551938564,
0.217371121,
0.8122972846,
-0.2042880058,
0.3551483452,
0.4893173277,
0.0493648015,
0.0179809239,
1.1096997261,
-0.1874098927,
-0.1104080826,
0.8301691413,
0.3429828584,
-0.395721674,
-0.8181813359,
-0.5483770967,
-0.203424409,
-0.838119328,
0.0054856557,
-0.9454346299,
0.0017158217,
-0.012492938,
-0.2835068405,
0.0943108723,
-0.4869417548,
-0.7937934995,
-0.0628277883,
0.231163159,
1.0317034721,
0.0326456279,
0.3346865177,
-0.5001019835,
0.5671858191,
0.1736024916,
-0.1141492948,
-0.1107023507,
-0.5321961641,
0.173417002,
-0.1961417496,
-0.2048350722,
-0.9356851578,
0.1413612664,
-0.0906536505,
0.3311026394,
0.3843622804,
0.1971211135,
0.2893778682,
-0.1234232038,
0.6080952287,
0.2811675966,
-1.0796517134,
0.4227650762,
-0.2255855352,
-0.2024029344,
0.4242479503,
0.2633502483,
-0.3197090924,
-0.3954490125,
-0.545788765,
-0.7477632761,
0.8297382593,
0.437261641,
0.1249235943,
0.329054594,
0.3329435587,
0.6624242663,
0.1014740765,
-1.0610547066,
-0.3092036247,
0.1727486402,
-0.5150591731,
-0.1115055084,
-0.345112741,
0.0209838543,
0.3541341424,
0.4671619534,
-0.117283687,
0.4028922915,
-0.0229789764,
-0.2744510472,
0.0461451523,
0.4220164716,
0.4269063771,
0.4203145802,
-0.0496066362,
0.7398872972,
-0.0372222438,
-0.2843041718,
0.3979313374,
-0.0769159645,
-0.4158527553,
-0.0341108963,
0.9187860489,
0.660684526,
0.0192438141,
-0.5726294518,
0.5315839648,
-0.1549325585,
-0.2362360954,
-0.1216061637,
0.3896916509,
-0.0383099616,
0.1787666082,
0.5026767254,
0.2550285459,
0.3499233127,
-0.6248803139,
-0.0505230464,
0.3011949062,
-0.3580686152,
-0.478624016,
0.6647834182,
0.4228106141,
-0.5293365717,
0.1121633202,
-0.3591330647,
-0.7633190155,
0.8259088397,
0.4915798008,
0.9520236254,
0.4124203026,
0.3963994086,
-0.2790118158,
0.398673445,
0.1975571513,
0.3201700747,
-0.3217645586,
-0.6992967129,
-0.1805835664,
-0.1202891767,
-0.5448979139,
0.0828222409,
-0.4736582041,
0.2808727324,
-0.3315832913,
-0.1029818282,
0.6162723899,
-0.0055103251,
-0.4624796808,
0.1225516573,
0.2015541047,
0.3258223832,
-1.0446970463,
0.085391596,
0.6884423494,
-0.1930004358,
-0.4355031848,
0.1801513731,
0.2416960448,
-1.1154372692,
0.6132674217,
0.4427178204,
-0.316886127,
-0.0216589198,
-0.7953130007,
-0.2439521849,
0.8531857133,
0.3136264086,
-0.0565389097,
0.14629215,
0.1446741819,
0.7029009461,
-0.2220071703,
0.5331324339,
0.340782553,
0.5267133713,
0.0136958836,
-0.4326221645,
0.2928289175,
-0.1282848716,
-0.1974879205,
0.3246157467,
-0.3444217741,
0.5397399664,
-0.5312839746,
-0.4240080118,
0.1047534943,
0.5431278944,
0.3030019701,
1.1046836376,
0.4144994617,
0.1820874065,
0.781662941,
-0.0721535236,
0.7353748679,
0.3723019361,
0.1506290883,
1.0254650116,
-0.0865741745,
0.5311790705,
0.2601070106,
-0.214298889,
0.6319323778,
0.838472724,
-0.0012675785,
0.0872854218,
0.088681221,
-0.1974253953,
-0.514650166,
-0.3676916957,
-0.2652393878,
0.723937571,
0.0428893194,
-0.4977680445,
-0.0244565997,
-0.0407136865,
0.1361791641,
0.1682751626,
-0.1735368371,
0.8920829892,
-0.112626195,
-0.5217996836,
0.3791431487,
0.1506041288,
0.7240950465,
-0.1620582342,
0.215544045,
0.0142090889,
0.1028599665,
-0.6171009541,
-1.2327023745,
-0.027411839,
0.6247364879,
-0.2331722528,
-0.4053001702,
0.9584626555,
-0.1512933373,
-0.4192499518,
-0.10638199,
0.5741664171,
0.5472817421,
0.0399760231,
-0.4673068523,
-0.0349524096,
0.24937433,
-0.0025043373,
0.0959604234,
0.9487301707,
-0.2983369231,
0.8131619096,
0.7727748752,
-0.3143868148,
-0.2697351277,
-0.08848349,
0.6284413934,
-0.8195958734,
-0.4800975323,
-1.2537647486,
0.3364805579,
0.20741871,
-0.2181949764,
0.5229153037,
0.4751361609,
0.4660666287,
0.0328029543,
0.9030867815,
-0.0951242149,
0.3044914007,
-0.6202048659,
0.5934041739,
-0.6268017292,
0.5268623233,
-0.1527310163,
-0.5990166664,
-0.3253631294,
0.221143499,
-0.034584783,
0.1966722012,
0.6314370632,
0.4504487813,
0.1078354865,
0.2915253937,
0.0131191127,
0.1493834406,
0.4319809675,
0.7557634711,
1.2294602394,
-0.3205893934,
0.8611011505,
0.1205337942,
-0.2532702386,
-0.4179367721,
-1.0540400743,
-1.1471629143,
-0.544031918,
-0.408306241,
-0.099709399,
-0.156639114,
0.5015266538,
0.5402621031,
-0.7193412185,
0.1873570681,
-0.2858954072,
0.6187416315,
0.1711612046,
-0.2318938822,
0.3028848469,
0.1030784324,
-0.5942350626,
0.0460085124,
0.4320437312,
0.1303365231,
-0.2533763945,
-0.0397545062,
0.2238654643,
-0.0917065293,
0.494328469,
0.1569314003,
-0.8259859681,
-0.1898888499,
-0.0323503576,
-0.1736077517,
-0.0175200179,
0.7757046223,
-0.6893029213,
0.5356191397,
0.5805129409,
0.4564006627,
0.241860956,
-0.0720459372,
0.1672331393,
-0.5498334765,
-0.3457702696,
0.2210258842,
0.0440093093,
0.3528628349,
-0.6986289024,
0.6003929377,
0.3148372769,
-0.445207566,
-0.9960089326,
0.2031425834,
-0.9043243527,
-0.4869506955,
1.038582921,
0.0565890446,
-0.0781011805,
-0.5152125955,
-0.304705441,
0.2996547222,
-0.4638562799,
0.7365269661,
0.435657382,
-0.3350981772,
0.003579895,
-0.2230354846,
0.165103808,
0.2212234885,
-1.048189044,
0.0168382302,
0.319116205,
0.2020283341,
0.1489653289,
0.7594454885,
0.0848882571,
0.3934497237,
-0.2003121078,
0.1130412072,
-0.2089236975,
-0.3935709894,
-0.1331113577,
0.1721386611,
0.0293357242,
-0.2132309824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18256v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18256v1 | LLaMIPa: An Incremental Discourse Parser | 2024-06-26T11:08:17 | 2024-06-26T11:08:17 | Kate Thompson, Akshay Chaturvedi, Julie Hunter, Nicholas Asher | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper provides the first discourse parsing experiments with a large
language model (LLM) finetuned on corpora annotated in the style of SDRT
(Asher, 1993; Asher and Lascarides, 2003). The result is a discourse parser,
LLaMIPa (LLaMA Incremental Parser), which is able to more fully exploit
discourse context, leading to substantial performance gains over approaches
that use encoder-only models to provide local, context-sensitive
representations of discourse units. Furthermore, it is able to process
discourse data incrementally, which is essential for the eventual use of
discourse information in downstream tasks. | [
-0.2116103172,
-0.8994624615,
0.7893518806,
0.4728699327,
-0.4488086402,
0.0750263855,
0.054258164,
-0.3289531767,
0.3680838943,
0.5430944562,
-0.279525131,
-0.4710647762,
-0.672944665,
0.2231802195,
-0.5640257597,
0.6811730862,
0.0578804649,
0.1397001892,
-0.1693992168,
0.0188853797,
-0.448838681,
-0.5335538983,
-0.9540332556,
-0.4512732923,
0.5256969929,
0.5191686749,
0.4603011012,
0.6118953824,
0.3239063025,
0.362018764,
-0.2273369282,
-0.0542096719,
-0.3942408562,
0.4157391787,
-0.2319444418,
-0.563775301,
-0.3951137364,
-0.3988181949,
1.0108906031,
0.6661257744,
0.0103013935,
0.2024757862,
0.025777135,
0.1649115682,
-0.414852649,
0.0554681309,
-0.6525484324,
0.0855923593,
-0.3934459984,
-0.6001190543,
-0.5861774683,
-0.6315224767,
-0.2800733447,
-0.3092958033,
-0.2380132675,
-0.2077500075,
0.7930781841,
0.3517449498,
-0.4648532867,
-0.3161653876,
-0.6382175088,
0.5002788901,
-0.719186306,
0.1993553489,
0.0663394704,
0.1125876531,
-0.1936649531,
-1.1203420162,
-0.656501174,
-0.3096686006,
-0.1124322042,
-0.2525268495,
-0.0809019208,
-0.0017127447,
0.2333611697,
0.5727875233,
-0.402692467,
0.4283407629,
-0.3401946425,
0.0755510628,
0.2218271047,
0.3577931225,
0.1259950101,
-0.2135788202,
-0.538000524,
0.2034195364,
-0.9138230085,
-0.0390759073,
0.1825028509,
0.1038810611,
-0.0157048143,
0.731421113,
-0.0534354635,
0.6208678484,
-0.1024935469,
-0.5514555573,
0.0103291152,
0.0446398407,
-0.527135551,
0.2158140838,
0.5845866203,
-0.2749227881,
-0.0020684097,
0.2357116938,
-0.030255273,
0.3153912425,
0.0747271404,
-0.8166915774,
0.0054733916,
0.2206499726,
-0.1906045675,
-0.347287029,
-0.4292363822,
-0.8281820416,
-0.3889463246,
-0.5791105628,
-0.1050611362,
-0.458876431,
-0.0863541141,
-0.113567926,
0.3829859495,
0.5104860067,
0.4694439173,
-0.707786262,
0.5641410351,
1.0347322226,
0.955940485,
-0.3645927012,
-0.3383655548,
-0.4904764295,
0.1688361019,
-0.3225573003,
1.2755074501,
-0.6625290513,
-0.4294585586,
0.0465838835,
0.0671510994,
0.1337659657,
-0.4706841707,
0.7525417805,
-0.5991402864,
-0.1891427785,
-0.1805317402,
-0.7765182257,
-0.1227273718,
0.4083565474,
-0.4938228428,
1.0018233061,
0.2206617296,
-0.7742727995,
0.1773109138,
-0.6416878104,
-0.3200495839,
0.2297480255,
-0.3728525639,
-0.0578510836,
0.0071218614,
0.0830398127,
0.324827373,
-0.4704445004,
0.6968743205,
-0.0949879289,
-0.4510301352,
0.4070917964,
-0.6176974773,
0.9846796393,
0.1838754714,
-0.1157485545,
0.1952135712,
-0.8976514339,
-0.2756486833,
0.2528083026,
-0.5541898012,
-0.3516255915,
-0.2608765066,
-0.0701676309,
0.1432261169,
0.5119934082,
-0.6646983027,
0.386452198,
-0.3111304045,
0.3236382306,
1.0372438431,
0.0580919236,
0.0504996665,
-0.0214203428,
0.6195799112,
0.0429469533,
-0.2104271799,
-0.5436037779,
-0.5546764731,
-1.0793093443,
-0.4690103233,
0.5820114613,
0.6335988045,
-0.5543761253,
0.1028929502,
-0.5231337547,
-0.3725227416,
-0.7145462036,
-0.0826820284,
0.1718236357,
0.6782433987,
0.1091962308,
-0.2546975911,
-0.8328229189,
-1.0830948353,
0.2504457533,
-0.0797843039,
-0.0260259043,
-0.0929937959,
0.5146579742,
-0.1936680824,
0.7311218381,
-0.6026936769,
-0.1344459057,
-0.3180366457,
0.1814273596,
0.1868926585,
0.3445467651,
0.2604035735,
-0.499522984,
-0.4110877812,
0.059404742,
-0.8786245584,
-0.2850047052,
-0.0780202374,
-0.0781269073,
-0.0305292886,
0.6511013508,
-0.6247313619,
0.3098409176,
0.7625792623,
-0.3431827128,
0.3372632563,
-0.0178149007,
0.0418658964,
-1.1256651878,
-0.0026215485,
-0.2530450225,
-0.5668599606,
-0.5930985212,
0.2329284996,
-0.0613449775,
-0.0270911399,
-0.6727789044,
0.536637187,
-0.1392306685,
-0.4559133649,
-0.4492657781,
0.2586660087,
0.1516313106,
0.599619329,
0.0738842115,
1.2459369898,
0.194320783,
-0.5978789926,
0.1811793894,
0.2795929611,
-0.4711259007,
0.8136292696,
-0.7418036461,
0.3230001032,
-0.0731655657,
0.1660382897,
-1.2088667154,
-0.1357788444,
0.1777614951,
-0.1177421734,
0.2658315003,
-0.026583001,
-0.6443274617,
-0.0036049364,
-0.3510830402,
0.4057949185,
0.1231173798,
-0.7187522054,
0.2818830907,
0.7441107035,
-0.5272474885,
-0.3377988636,
-0.757001698,
0.2491950691,
-0.3324353993,
-0.5001369715,
0.3360337913,
0.0614782907,
-0.5186033845,
-0.356603235,
0.6110745668,
-0.1741066724,
-0.0338949896,
0.2740063369,
0.2094105929,
-0.3847808838,
0.0230060797,
0.3882102668,
-0.103910476,
-0.0904322639,
0.2242112756,
1.0369571447,
-0.2364965975,
-0.2269313782,
-0.7489007711,
0.6206091046,
0.3172765076,
0.1551673412,
0.5812663436,
-0.0108245099,
-0.2065081447,
0.2423220277,
-0.4473583102,
0.2249095738,
-0.4983300567,
0.0788189694,
-0.6301745772,
-1.1389962435,
0.3073928058,
-0.5295609236,
0.0314262919,
0.2703810334,
0.6353859305,
0.1883858591,
0.6382348537,
0.7301862836,
-0.2361130714,
0.2830188274,
-0.007111371,
0.0501453131,
-1.244125843,
0.1371974349,
-0.4666085839,
-0.22339122,
-0.667612493,
-0.5343332291,
0.1929471791,
-0.3165083826,
-0.5692716241,
0.2879999876,
-0.4797661304,
0.3455472291,
0.393319875,
-0.2720392346,
0.8069526553,
-0.0320443213,
-0.0364220366,
-0.3083862364,
-0.3444921672,
-0.7776759267,
0.767123282,
0.5958436728,
0.5710510612,
0.0842133909,
0.5599144101,
0.2022013962,
0.6063479185,
-0.827870667,
0.8714882135,
-0.0233238041,
-0.0322440676,
-0.0344893187,
-0.0511753783,
-1.1448156834,
0.7406380773,
0.4065423012,
-0.8951599002,
0.38972193,
-0.1621679962,
-0.2045323253,
0.2637102306,
-0.2338783592,
0.5664834976,
-0.0065154461,
-0.204626143,
0.0602424704,
-0.2571515441,
0.7989374399,
0.0704533681,
0.1526841521,
-0.2772230506,
-0.3200809956,
0.4206233323,
-0.0703432858,
0.9101157784,
-0.0447551459,
-0.451166749,
0.3676821589,
0.3782501817,
0.4904386103,
0.1646040976,
-0.1391916275,
0.267804563,
-0.1938613802,
-0.070580177,
-0.2512364686,
0.9122042656,
-0.5961896181,
-0.6714276671,
-0.567889452,
-0.4405443966,
-0.0610698014,
0.0221941713,
0.0654110014,
0.0701039135,
-0.3995246887,
0.0196212139,
0.5984310508,
-0.1391644925,
0.3322391808,
0.4121575952,
-0.4999830723,
-0.4887712002,
0.5449028015,
0.0864767507,
0.0332093611,
0.4910002351,
0.048007451,
0.0474612452,
-0.4093787074,
-0.2406176627,
0.3284361064,
-0.8904871345,
-0.4308000803,
-0.8329292536,
-0.408154428,
-0.2621219754,
-0.1678921282,
-0.4549599886,
-0.6262347102,
-0.5141331553,
-0.3433122039,
0.205234915,
0.6719129086,
0.0986654684,
0.5320227742,
-0.2438546717,
0.2635449767,
0.3597580791,
-0.1442586482,
-0.1850212216,
-0.6780593395,
0.2110934854,
-0.2136256099,
-0.4621608555,
-0.8466022611,
0.6579185128,
0.0423374884,
0.0753380954,
0.327483356,
-0.3440646827,
0.8892346621,
-0.6495164037,
0.9457642436,
-0.1120852008,
-1.0052024126,
0.736751318,
-0.3533067107,
0.5936142206,
0.548576951,
0.3522843719,
-0.4478756189,
-0.5012361407,
-0.3403955102,
-0.9489098191,
0.3927639723,
-0.1411021948,
0.2895652056,
-0.2688233256,
0.2797871232,
0.4590440691,
0.2789391279,
-0.9360252023,
-0.1521732062,
0.1478781998,
0.0453544147,
0.1724302918,
-0.8571084738,
-0.1798382401,
-0.4657419324,
0.4956097901,
-0.2120977193,
0.5028942227,
0.1788005829,
-0.1300482452,
0.1101747379,
0.4703164697,
0.7804967165,
0.8338031173,
0.1494656056,
0.3559693396,
0.3386931717,
-0.411601752,
0.4217117727,
-0.1047523245,
-0.6282902956,
0.1905954033,
0.2481606156,
0.849363327,
0.5655699372,
-0.6267920136,
0.292466104,
-0.1579084247,
0.0470162556,
-0.8764857054,
-0.202585578,
0.1672220528,
0.2716063261,
0.1824840307,
-0.4261336625,
0.2986543477,
-0.4833810031,
0.1962964833,
0.0727507696,
-0.015873516,
-0.1884832829,
0.5753715634,
-0.2030774355,
-0.2557798028,
0.3617047071,
-0.1271287501,
-0.1147180647,
0.3763745427,
0.8774690032,
0.7249697447,
-0.5748050213,
0.3379482329,
0.3395652175,
0.106399551,
0.0492947027,
0.3537039161,
-0.0050037215,
-0.6066465974,
-0.6538004279,
-0.8267742395,
-0.6971175671,
0.2924351394,
-0.5168042779,
0.3048775494,
-0.5900121331,
-0.0382697769,
0.0481321216,
-0.2660210133,
-0.4815992415,
0.005424764,
0.0929718167,
0.8693095446,
-0.3994897306,
1.325745225,
0.3176165223,
-0.2003379464,
-0.3806191683,
-0.0574675575,
-0.073065348,
-0.846570611,
0.7596622109,
0.0754009783,
-0.1754931659,
-0.0981170014,
-0.530211091,
-1.1077854633,
1.1634454727,
0.8312146664,
-0.551117897,
0.1908632517,
0.4789866805,
0.5754660368,
-0.6720950603,
-0.0086160554,
0.9547755718,
0.309217155,
0.1628972292,
-0.6711327434,
0.1297048926,
-0.1059158668,
0.4610892534,
0.0002059109,
-0.6605266333,
1.2224012613,
0.3055335879,
-0.184947148,
0.1870153099,
1.1325166225,
0.394736737,
0.1474929154,
0.108833231,
0.6055124402,
0.8078734875,
0.0725525469,
1.0918358564,
-0.1517312378,
-0.0034834673,
1.672932148,
-0.4808168411,
1.2224986553,
0.5973597169,
-0.3236546814,
0.865414083,
0.6332105994,
0.2953774333,
0.4233902693,
0.1389705241,
-0.601033628,
0.2729144096,
-0.4700705707,
-0.2546847463,
0.6449241638,
0.6548403502,
-0.3791876733,
-0.2175571471,
0.0975674391,
0.5018538833,
0.1403515935,
-0.4003790617,
0.7866424322,
0.2536742687,
-0.7110565305,
0.5967724919,
0.169362098,
0.6691964865,
-0.4405962825,
-0.1773022264,
-0.3217289448,
0.1079146639,
-0.0258518998,
-0.8443222642,
0.5379472375,
0.1643690467,
0.3244363964,
-0.139499113,
0.8463379741,
-0.1961681694,
-0.5406202674,
0.3891300559,
0.2098074853,
0.2533647418,
0.2467913181,
-0.3629771769,
0.4768146276,
-0.1741562635,
-0.4478148818,
0.5958237648,
0.4298551381,
0.1615902781,
0.5987747908,
0.4313781559,
0.037559811,
0.1008344889,
-0.0287057403,
1.2270936966,
-0.6932375431,
-0.3217135072,
-0.9739236832,
0.4900797009,
-0.13677077,
-0.3174833953,
0.6811526418,
0.5355296135,
0.6071934104,
0.1113544106,
0.7011795044,
0.05835611,
0.6021862626,
-0.5074957013,
0.1090259925,
-0.1907248199,
0.3837774992,
-0.0379163399,
-0.8388467431,
-0.1953747869,
0.693670392,
-0.3161402643,
-0.4641140699,
0.6284992695,
0.5200907588,
0.0390037484,
0.0871751904,
0.4824326038,
0.3534820378,
0.2023311108,
0.4358943105,
0.7659971118,
-0.3121756613,
0.0951379016,
-0.3797929287,
-0.1043822318,
-0.0212204996,
-0.8154811859,
-0.6214442849,
-0.4102417827,
-0.1268129647,
-0.1561802477,
-0.015861541,
0.8752129078,
0.10557504,
-0.7256662846,
-0.524774313,
-0.1145819724,
0.1496302783,
0.1599657387,
-0.2656877339,
0.2431497872,
-0.3680596352,
-0.9144849777,
0.7123464346,
0.5389826894,
-0.1684585661,
-0.6881582737,
0.291456461,
-0.5923144817,
0.330168575,
0.8875533342,
0.3263519704,
-0.5482400656,
-0.3284772635,
-0.4650236368,
-0.1686038971,
0.7001036406,
0.8945028186,
-0.8123431802,
0.0802245662,
0.2986908555,
0.5117222667,
0.6853901744,
-0.0771869346,
0.4926367104,
-0.7671291828,
0.6950656772,
0.3427070379,
0.550359726,
0.5564938784,
-0.4998848736,
0.7239416242,
-0.1998899281,
-0.6890537739,
-0.9663648605,
0.2767443359,
-0.8272651434,
-0.1754528284,
1.1294306517,
-0.3372499049,
-0.3863586187,
-0.1638788879,
-0.5049023628,
0.0284037404,
-0.2895642519,
0.5729455352,
0.4303005934,
-0.308647871,
-0.4852977991,
-0.8155391216,
0.2962549329,
0.1130252257,
-1.1319385767,
-0.0635514632,
0.2017653286,
0.1133158132,
0.1603171229,
1.2637465,
-0.2013780028,
0.0140103418,
0.2297670841,
-0.2296560705,
0.3614846766,
-0.2763163745,
-0.4559692442,
0.6852123737,
0.3339291513,
0.0136625152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18245v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18245v2 | Weak Reward Model Transforms Generative Models into Robust Causal Event Extraction Systems | 2024-06-26T10:48:14 | 2024-06-27T10:19:55 | Italo Luis da Silva, Hanqi Yan, Lin Gui, Yulan He | cs.CL | cs.CL | The inherent ambiguity of cause and effect boundaries poses a challenge in
evaluating causal event extraction tasks. Traditional metrics like Exact Match
and BertScore poorly reflect model performance, so we trained evaluation models
to approximate human evaluation, achieving high agreement. We used them to
perform Reinforcement Learning with extraction models to align them with human
preference, prioritising semantic understanding. We successfully explored our
approach through multiple datasets, including transferring an evaluator trained
on one dataset to another as a way to decrease the reliance on human-annotated
data. In that vein, we also propose a weak-to-strong supervision method that
uses a fraction of the annotated data to train an evaluation model while still
achieving high performance in training an RL model. Our code is available at
https://github.com/oyarsa/event_extraction/tree/causal-event-extraction. | [
-0.0839418918,
-0.5042960644,
0.6457587481,
0.2569545805,
-0.3235798776,
-0.4199154079,
-0.2679551542,
-0.6411679983,
-0.1466614604,
0.2234135419,
-0.5083038807,
-0.2241336554,
-0.996178627,
-0.0380323604,
-0.0985477716,
1.2927545309,
-0.0989201888,
0.0551669672,
-0.0874746144,
-0.1209025979,
-0.5156857371,
-0.3887253702,
-0.8096857667,
-0.6940542459,
0.8699696064,
0.2141023129,
0.4695429802,
0.5331901908,
0.5326290727,
0.2119588405,
-0.1113902032,
0.173606813,
-0.6787263751,
-0.0848986208,
-0.6611750722,
-0.2495548427,
-0.2256594747,
0.1526147127,
0.3408609331,
0.5453473926,
-0.1239543334,
0.2240081131,
0.0151401749,
0.1377126276,
-1.0809532404,
0.2943473458,
-0.5007069111,
0.1444282383,
-0.0534703657,
-0.3663086593,
-0.5620080233,
-0.212370947,
0.168382898,
-0.548283875,
0.1078878716,
-0.1842224747,
1.2554348707,
0.2456542253,
-0.5173687339,
0.0692605525,
-0.7288523912,
0.99598068,
-0.4792517424,
0.1585076898,
0.4375542402,
0.2639422417,
-0.1362230629,
-0.8346168995,
-0.2165154368,
-0.0457139015,
-0.1095715314,
0.2228091061,
-0.2032276839,
0.0365727469,
0.2606523931,
0.172602281,
-0.2223098576,
0.4247728884,
-0.4603996277,
0.0616928935,
0.8626407385,
0.4767604768,
0.2264435887,
-0.4823845029,
-0.5223285556,
-0.2245966643,
-0.6484177113,
0.2603720129,
0.3152236342,
0.62961936,
-0.0589143708,
0.4976857603,
-0.1506814063,
0.6460716724,
0.0117627103,
0.0673818812,
0.0198039003,
-0.2378163189,
-0.3229427636,
-0.0372284576,
0.9799899459,
-0.0291149057,
-0.1205312908,
-0.6083942056,
-0.3635877073,
0.2085567117,
0.6041965485,
-0.7664365172,
-0.2815145552,
-0.0081652598,
-0.7646458149,
-0.677921474,
0.3384107649,
-0.896835804,
-0.4873750508,
-0.415812254,
0.6975721717,
-0.1219926924,
-0.1990667731,
0.2389609367,
-0.5227224827,
0.3956974447,
0.4580526948,
-0.9227697253,
0.2400921732,
0.5625324249,
0.627612114,
-0.4893782139,
-0.1711700112,
-1.0423690081,
-0.0389857627,
-0.0786469653,
0.564678371,
-0.2881859243,
-0.1760079414,
-0.1713590473,
0.0827403218,
-0.0735167861,
-0.5277818441,
1.0093346834,
-0.6572304368,
0.1748181581,
-0.0364229158,
-0.2839232087,
-0.0272434,
-0.0264354851,
-0.6297733188,
0.777338028,
0.1127432808,
-0.6725074053,
0.7607606649,
-0.525139153,
-0.6807705164,
0.0448177978,
-0.2355065793,
-0.8196700811,
0.2545538247,
0.3763197958,
0.605062902,
-0.4117347002,
0.7110783458,
-0.6047643423,
-0.4085016847,
-0.0190712847,
-0.453381598,
0.893586874,
0.2083656639,
-0.6443713903,
0.6026845574,
-0.8200775385,
-0.245175004,
0.4845072925,
-0.3827861845,
-0.4891765416,
0.4011386037,
0.2705519795,
0.5026040077,
0.1146204174,
-0.3234905005,
0.2485544384,
-0.3999809623,
0.1341900826,
0.9587442279,
0.2215847373,
0.326161772,
-0.0173011981,
0.3523881733,
-0.0065240059,
0.3279347718,
0.3877607286,
-0.3155070841,
-0.5664801002,
-0.2946944833,
0.1317117959,
0.4161389172,
-0.6744803786,
0.7150787115,
-0.2209265679,
-0.2588623762,
-0.3736106157,
0.3520552516,
0.4363833368,
0.4951872528,
0.3325037956,
-0.5032321811,
-0.635676682,
-0.7810213566,
-0.219519034,
-0.4238676727,
-0.1829895973,
0.1807449758,
0.5319515467,
0.0216505285,
0.9888208508,
-0.454762578,
-0.2347619236,
-0.4407795668,
0.6644514203,
0.2688238621,
0.4718391299,
0.1743361801,
-0.9198560119,
0.1954033077,
0.0160626676,
-1.0938520432,
-0.0158025753,
-0.3409841657,
-0.1357548386,
-0.4106509984,
0.2902446687,
-0.4389694333,
0.6525617838,
-0.0399062596,
-0.6034590006,
0.6851513982,
0.1652606577,
0.1087021455,
-0.6389507055,
0.3510534763,
0.0789817721,
-0.2483444959,
-0.2879377902,
-0.0162485056,
0.1470162719,
-0.0495858975,
-0.5746181011,
0.5036494136,
-0.1538456529,
-0.1952930093,
-0.1964401156,
0.0572153963,
0.121376656,
0.7508460879,
0.251439631,
0.2579760253,
0.304585129,
-0.5735036135,
0.3593775332,
0.2912241518,
-0.3741742671,
0.4506126046,
-0.7474852204,
-0.1746875048,
-0.0316621587,
-0.1111512333,
-0.5459000468,
-0.2900762558,
0.381011039,
-0.2302667648,
0.3965104222,
-0.3777103722,
-0.3434922099,
-0.215177983,
-0.1456319988,
0.2574942112,
0.4309358597,
-0.9338341951,
0.4238248467,
0.1724392325,
-0.0442786738,
-0.546651125,
-0.3815280199,
0.0113413855,
-0.652130127,
-0.2294139117,
0.0903065056,
0.5453521013,
-0.1177276671,
0.2252230793,
-0.0251109861,
0.0565514266,
0.5593536496,
0.4688216746,
0.477003783,
-0.1004352123,
0.2514973283,
-0.0857417732,
-0.1481229067,
0.2456369847,
-0.1912240833,
-0.0762847736,
-0.0011489482,
-0.4911476672,
-0.5899577141,
0.2747061253,
0.2882261276,
-0.2370483726,
0.7051330805,
0.8506134748,
-0.4420078993,
-0.109022826,
-0.1411195099,
-0.35563761,
-0.3603169322,
0.4372731149,
-0.3197154105,
-0.7093502879,
0.3688914776,
-0.2455274761,
-0.1302053928,
0.7443632483,
0.5221118331,
0.2133002281,
1.3336055279,
0.5060962439,
-0.2755782306,
0.8099654913,
-0.0285778977,
-0.0431792997,
-0.5543779135,
-0.2559137046,
-0.5653361082,
0.0530603118,
-0.1400379539,
0.0473596789,
0.1792320311,
0.6160160303,
-0.3244114816,
0.2635802031,
-0.3483062088,
0.1059689,
0.4248500764,
0.3947310746,
0.1311009228,
-0.2345986813,
0.3097956777,
-0.0625299364,
-0.9011172056,
-0.4562307298,
0.9719660878,
0.3511757255,
0.9636574388,
0.0825903937,
0.7794865966,
0.3957188427,
0.5045636892,
-0.6509109139,
0.0316698104,
0.1432631463,
-0.4121361077,
-0.4499982297,
-0.7322158217,
-1.2009459734,
0.3941621184,
-0.4027543366,
-1.0374586582,
0.6305867434,
-0.2218437195,
-0.3160245121,
0.345014751,
-0.7573481202,
1.3509762287,
-0.2557562292,
-0.7705685496,
-0.1678510755,
-0.7208294868,
0.636916697,
0.3080850542,
-0.0835740641,
0.0508326218,
0.4241999984,
0.9446740746,
-0.389334172,
0.9553430676,
-0.2365283072,
0.1858218759,
0.2572134435,
-0.0293643009,
0.9465587735,
0.170618102,
0.0919122919,
-0.0476583913,
-0.3331894279,
-0.5856685638,
-0.7913426757,
0.3329353034,
-0.9555660486,
-0.3151345253,
-0.3048638105,
-0.1399830878,
-0.097000517,
-0.0810318291,
0.0253097992,
0.3149808347,
-0.3454218507,
-0.0667875186,
0.4399324954,
-0.2224995941,
0.2138625681,
0.2639107406,
0.0731348544,
-0.2312203944,
1.0074080229,
-0.5576247573,
0.136896953,
0.1991651952,
0.2516892552,
-0.2548537552,
-0.2882332504,
-0.4825756848,
-0.1134322807,
-0.7353210449,
-0.3587983251,
-0.5837798715,
-0.0653128996,
-0.2820518911,
-0.2311756611,
-0.3603127599,
-0.1992897242,
-0.5903711319,
-0.3018428087,
0.0892699659,
0.7958987355,
-0.3036501706,
0.2449417263,
-0.4979636073,
0.4671806693,
0.5521306992,
0.1751236618,
0.1604635119,
-0.3594742119,
-0.3409252763,
-0.5272700191,
-0.4724056423,
-0.9829317331,
0.4303940237,
-0.0738470256,
0.6282715201,
0.7530881166,
0.0185660664,
0.7640225887,
-0.0751175806,
0.6449016929,
0.5740126967,
-0.8921607137,
0.8033454418,
-0.1928251982,
0.0337297916,
0.6022705436,
0.2945712209,
-0.1939342767,
-0.393445015,
-0.9346781969,
-1.0497566462,
1.0340733528,
0.2388778776,
-0.5189452171,
-0.0039309841,
0.2696346045,
0.0776290521,
-0.1089362055,
-0.9614862204,
0.0309779141,
-0.1164115965,
-0.2075956762,
-0.2420253605,
-0.2073664367,
-0.1762475222,
-0.0677361041,
0.6071856022,
0.1477495879,
0.2256608009,
0.1814186424,
-0.2758498788,
-0.4062943757,
0.4226368964,
0.2849992216,
0.644741416,
-0.5088022947,
0.4560322762,
0.1576751769,
0.0359243937,
0.1227151006,
0.36371544,
0.0441134013,
-0.3485244215,
0.7533480525,
0.9832181334,
0.4872301221,
-0.6950654387,
0.7717447281,
-0.2173357159,
0.0559791215,
0.178833425,
0.0509385727,
-0.2775649726,
0.3677779436,
0.2746189833,
-0.0327727385,
0.3593271375,
-0.2281274945,
0.4517825842,
0.2664681971,
-0.8572884798,
-0.348644793,
0.8741923571,
0.0532807633,
0.0669988319,
0.7642422318,
-0.4152196646,
-0.3868518472,
0.6838496327,
0.4657243788,
0.8726945519,
0.1416151077,
0.1568802893,
0.4303790629,
0.3357803524,
-0.0908075422,
0.0480895489,
-0.2169935703,
-0.4691327512,
-0.707970202,
-0.6623858809,
-0.202646926,
0.1666905433,
-1.0881541967,
0.3945631981,
-0.0821373612,
0.0123517709,
0.0972700566,
-0.0701175928,
-0.8617108464,
0.1264166087,
0.0550974943,
0.3922126889,
-1.4345841408,
0.5605193377,
0.4030106962,
-0.8776813745,
-0.8072109222,
-0.4801252782,
-0.1837679595,
-0.4003653824,
1.0145177841,
-0.1126749218,
0.2283544391,
-0.4732600152,
-0.6028930545,
-0.3799408376,
0.8626255989,
0.2099475712,
-0.2453364134,
0.1292390972,
-0.3453993499,
0.4279244542,
-0.1404928863,
0.248688817,
0.3536200523,
0.356094867,
-0.0731705427,
-0.5554738045,
0.308075726,
-0.1340852082,
-0.1448358744,
0.2249333113,
-0.1444358826,
0.5819790959,
-0.1129260436,
-0.3395658433,
-0.0324029885,
0.698025465,
0.3026141524,
0.4526155591,
0.512057662,
0.5396699309,
0.5118091702,
-0.0838635191,
1.3061311245,
0.5116068721,
0.6476913095,
1.1971926689,
-0.1512725353,
0.6220428944,
0.6789943576,
-0.207728073,
0.3276050091,
0.9592206478,
0.0813514367,
0.8057096601,
0.2383466512,
-0.0707849935,
-0.6878117919,
-0.1781189293,
-0.0281631891,
0.3561408222,
0.2229786515,
-0.3931163549,
-0.552926898,
-0.0767238289,
-0.3118836284,
-0.2034253627,
-0.3278135061,
0.9068565965,
0.0512491055,
-0.5865084529,
0.2900444567,
0.2672912478,
0.4275550544,
-0.6692082286,
-0.2950971127,
0.0918899104,
0.0828088894,
-0.2229520231,
-0.347632587,
0.1721448004,
-0.0392669551,
-0.1041590795,
-0.1827087849,
1.0255988836,
-0.1999400109,
-0.2367583066,
0.5114384294,
0.5547627807,
0.0771141276,
0.123818621,
-0.6369863749,
-0.079408884,
-0.2623590231,
-0.37916556,
0.5003309846,
0.3960916996,
-0.3833974302,
0.2304815054,
0.6194255352,
0.1887919456,
-0.0983915776,
0.2051187754,
0.8723030686,
-0.7719568014,
-0.5603706241,
-0.9368901253,
0.5694410205,
-0.2790906727,
-0.4379593432,
0.4151468873,
0.3636635542,
0.4960103929,
-0.0141170509,
0.6750364304,
-0.1870013475,
-0.0125319213,
-0.4955332875,
0.3736988902,
-0.6700338721,
-0.124059774,
-0.5275803208,
-0.4846401811,
-0.3136323988,
0.5559861064,
-0.5529724956,
-0.1512055099,
0.3748818934,
0.4234303832,
-0.3593963385,
0.0209016614,
0.3018854558,
-0.0357281901,
0.4204802513,
0.8601810932,
1.2439141273,
-0.3931909502,
0.253911823,
0.1029108763,
-0.3429338932,
-0.4453644454,
-0.8770904541,
-0.7123357654,
-0.5074983835,
-0.2743352056,
-0.412261039,
0.3206993937,
0.7078844309,
0.8634901047,
-0.8188357949,
-0.1146768481,
-0.1581666619,
0.6131603718,
-0.6183416843,
-0.3337615728,
0.7957031727,
-0.6708558798,
-0.4028446674,
0.4544828534,
0.2723210752,
-0.262347281,
-0.0051547047,
-0.2144288868,
-0.2809177637,
-0.2563839555,
0.5046883225,
0.5182085633,
-0.5145809054,
-0.4713641405,
-0.7214811444,
-0.2469079345,
-0.1335774362,
0.8621149659,
-0.6922575235,
0.3663213849,
0.3317902982,
0.8864582777,
0.985054791,
0.0643082112,
0.5589085817,
-0.734927237,
0.1698829234,
0.085683167,
0.2989605367,
0.074399434,
-0.5714190006,
0.6577313542,
0.342636019,
-0.4091661572,
-0.920188427,
0.1592027694,
-1.0945208073,
-0.3028809428,
1.0368072987,
-0.2919013202,
-0.2683403194,
-0.2596074939,
0.0884516612,
0.4661829472,
-0.1438210905,
0.9665915966,
0.415935874,
-0.3313007057,
0.048617214,
-0.3566215634,
0.4450727403,
0.5101263523,
-0.8806954026,
-0.0505661927,
0.4472775757,
0.097913444,
-0.1085640416,
0.444467485,
-0.301227212,
0.5388765931,
0.0208012648,
0.4777238667,
0.0073411306,
-0.3949100077,
-0.7460666299,
0.4857543707,
0.1796602756,
-0.2211700976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18239v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18239v1 | Zero-shot prompt-based classification: topic labeling in times of foundation models in German Tweets | 2024-06-26T10:44:02 | 2024-06-26T10:44:02 | Simon Münker, Kai Kugler, Achim Rettinger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Filtering and annotating textual data are routine tasks in many areas, like
social media or news analytics. Automating these tasks allows to scale the
analyses wrt. speed and breadth of content covered and decreases the manual
effort required. Due to technical advancements in Natural Language Processing,
specifically the success of large foundation models, a new tool for automating
such annotation processes by using a text-to-text interface given written
guidelines without providing training samples has become available.
In this work, we assess these advancements in-the-wild by empirically testing
them in an annotation task on German Twitter data about social and political
European crises. We compare the prompt-based results with our human annotation
and preceding classification approaches, including Naive Bayes and a BERT-based
fine-tuning/domain adaptation pipeline. Our results show that the prompt-based
approach - despite being limited by local computation resources during the
model selection - is comparable with the fine-tuned BERT but without any
annotated training data. Our findings emphasize the ongoing paradigm shift in
the NLP landscape, i.e., the unification of downstream tasks and elimination of
the need for pre-labeled training data. | [
-0.4976264238,
-0.9821822047,
0.4312110245,
0.3878702521,
-0.2873495519,
0.142341122,
-0.1604251564,
-0.425796926,
0.0843576789,
0.303098619,
-0.7731717229,
-0.8460143805,
-0.6938973069,
0.2695950866,
-0.5339397788,
1.1020796299,
0.0503737405,
-0.2516190708,
0.0688317493,
0.0259373188,
-0.4980810881,
-0.4101338089,
-0.6948295236,
-0.2864225805,
0.5610805154,
0.3721844554,
0.4610758126,
0.5958433747,
0.3494745195,
0.2229913622,
-0.0854805559,
-0.2998964489,
-0.251139015,
0.1618682593,
-0.1803666949,
-0.0390723236,
-0.1020093635,
0.2339843214,
0.2722455859,
0.9074164033,
0.3339710832,
0.2546072304,
-0.0122018149,
0.2925423682,
-0.7085987926,
0.1852792054,
-0.483376503,
0.1366378516,
0.0435346141,
-0.4800606966,
-0.3906235695,
-0.245473206,
0.4430349171,
-0.3956425786,
0.6269358397,
-0.2369702756,
0.9093247652,
0.3105552197,
-0.434653759,
-0.2182433158,
-0.6870974898,
0.6027525067,
-0.3161019981,
0.1380300224,
0.2180509865,
0.2879542708,
-0.0297412854,
-0.5686187148,
-0.3310422003,
-0.0471942239,
-0.029903112,
-0.1742350161,
-0.2978121638,
0.072765708,
0.4411026537,
0.009583462,
-0.4122633934,
0.2389517725,
-0.1912757456,
-0.3235165477,
0.5579111576,
-0.1778620183,
0.1524765342,
-0.4806268811,
-0.2632596493,
-0.0245780684,
-0.4418685138,
0.066853039,
-0.1406934112,
0.6357590556,
-0.1306235492,
0.4214990139,
-0.6366715431,
0.7269895077,
0.0919014066,
0.0508224666,
0.158386901,
-0.1273724288,
-0.3972894251,
0.1504397392,
0.736348629,
0.3904222548,
0.3454063833,
-0.3233531117,
-0.085316658,
0.2300190032,
0.0103959106,
-0.8522183299,
-0.1074305698,
0.1081286445,
-0.2668108344,
-0.4844837785,
-0.0126996348,
-0.5784246325,
-0.4593378007,
-0.3507577479,
0.4928331971,
-0.2358148545,
0.0593337342,
0.1451770812,
-0.2794894874,
0.1883261204,
0.7709997296,
-0.4873946309,
-0.1231629252,
0.597037971,
1.0225555897,
-0.0873746648,
0.0738082379,
-0.5915378332,
-0.2465735972,
-0.5065301657,
1.1340796947,
-0.4667316973,
-0.4557948709,
0.1854878515,
0.1033320278,
0.1400546581,
-0.0094764419,
0.5141688585,
-0.3560894728,
0.4299891591,
-0.4162226915,
-0.5820553899,
-0.0109358486,
0.1530842334,
-0.3933542073,
0.9748225212,
0.0530619435,
-0.8316653967,
0.6910545826,
-0.9494416118,
-0.5017098188,
0.0877445042,
-0.1183601394,
0.0571125112,
-0.0358978063,
0.3712539971,
0.9747563004,
-0.2904289961,
0.6215562224,
-0.4075753987,
-0.3508552015,
0.0169685427,
-0.3132296503,
0.9358246922,
0.0581386536,
-0.533557415,
0.1530733407,
-0.7594467402,
-0.3224618137,
-0.0452143028,
0.0527830459,
-0.2012231201,
-0.1093527898,
0.1001456305,
0.5064716935,
-0.0383749865,
-0.6289135814,
0.2209309042,
-0.1545478404,
0.4639046192,
0.5977463126,
0.4411388934,
0.6952244043,
-0.2205086201,
0.3229062855,
-0.2186709642,
-0.0345103443,
-0.5669776797,
-0.6647843719,
-0.6792928576,
-0.3095067143,
0.4490802288,
0.7676002383,
-0.805311799,
0.6384720802,
-0.2609765232,
-0.6335139275,
-0.3206532001,
-0.286771208,
-0.0945335105,
0.8541686535,
0.4092308283,
-0.0938394219,
-0.3334689438,
-0.7962153554,
-0.0338138603,
-0.2412530929,
-0.1987654716,
0.1850082725,
0.3980560899,
-0.1007131487,
1.2011836767,
-0.4429651797,
-0.0723126382,
-0.1147921905,
0.8544371128,
0.0304395091,
0.4445622265,
0.7074486017,
-0.6623720527,
-0.3887595534,
-0.2286477685,
-0.7442820668,
-0.6399914026,
-0.3140479326,
-0.0909167603,
0.4165212512,
0.5275374651,
-0.4335252643,
0.6852653623,
-0.0588733926,
-0.450892657,
0.235671252,
0.2912119627,
0.3052971661,
-0.8550739288,
0.2150544971,
0.338778466,
-0.3056399822,
-0.906649828,
-0.4554242194,
0.0751885623,
-0.2452188432,
-0.3749586046,
0.8999391198,
-0.1285272241,
0.1118884236,
-0.3315183222,
-0.0600700155,
-0.1336687952,
0.2971497774,
0.3837597966,
0.4609273076,
0.5939596891,
-0.5786141753,
0.1745409369,
0.2581908703,
-0.1076545343,
0.4569756687,
-0.4224027097,
0.054910019,
-0.3434644639,
0.3443806171,
-1.1948338747,
-0.2811359167,
0.4038918018,
-0.6051713228,
0.1858614087,
-0.189844951,
-0.5986916423,
-0.253220886,
-0.3584055603,
-0.2116777003,
0.55796206,
-0.2631949484,
0.2928664684,
-0.0141511401,
-0.3258065283,
-0.351687938,
-0.5653932095,
0.3111042976,
-0.1972279251,
-0.3103934824,
0.3016461134,
0.1479407847,
-0.1020331532,
0.1732973903,
-0.1816812903,
-0.2722677886,
0.4879800975,
0.2241353393,
0.2375071943,
-0.1112748459,
0.4076004326,
0.2004467845,
-0.2909575701,
-0.0352343097,
-0.2289074361,
0.3238711655,
0.1999321729,
-0.0156934261,
-0.7177104354,
0.4013750851,
0.2668002844,
-0.1141897514,
0.7434720993,
0.6413484216,
-0.4895429015,
-0.1965231746,
-0.5672630668,
-0.3612708151,
-0.3525245488,
0.0454075783,
-0.0928637981,
-1.123666048,
0.357322216,
-0.2100928128,
0.3273470998,
0.780377984,
0.2887836397,
-0.2228461504,
0.5854661465,
0.8696686029,
-0.0649423674,
0.6521372795,
-0.1510468572,
0.1611567438,
-0.0209640656,
0.0259427782,
-0.8189838529,
-0.1825290322,
-0.5281336308,
-0.2027802467,
0.063250795,
0.1389031261,
-0.3073913753,
0.293733865,
-0.6120103002,
0.2036479115,
0.4754717052,
-0.1470209509,
0.1325359344,
0.1097967178,
0.4310568273,
-0.1636113226,
-0.6641563177,
-0.6049047709,
0.9552041888,
0.2508453131,
0.2629453242,
-0.4553433359,
0.8193217516,
0.5935304165,
0.6686038375,
-0.7370046973,
0.5916567445,
-0.0455050766,
-0.6397730112,
-0.510315299,
-0.1755890846,
-0.7108153105,
0.0275397319,
-0.4682906866,
-0.8390054703,
0.3917081058,
-0.0145039754,
-0.5494802594,
0.1031129956,
-0.7293644547,
0.911629498,
0.0892294869,
-0.0443753414,
0.0934901163,
-0.6005362868,
0.0197882336,
-0.2993222475,
0.1127605215,
-0.4603334665,
-0.0936620384,
0.8584721684,
-0.0265088063,
1.1025521755,
-0.4698551595,
0.0641702488,
0.2292045206,
-0.1514456123,
0.215926975,
0.030048985,
0.0214092247,
0.2022186816,
-0.067924723,
-0.4865424335,
-0.5611577034,
0.3586684763,
-0.5389909744,
-0.63712883,
-0.5057438016,
-0.2999666333,
-0.2640043795,
0.14431642,
0.2199278027,
0.3925064504,
-0.2291742414,
0.2749055028,
0.4539560676,
-0.3204314113,
0.7709871531,
0.6154595017,
-0.022298079,
-0.0601919629,
0.5550180674,
0.424778074,
-0.1701733321,
0.5331969261,
0.0610926077,
-0.1665030271,
-0.4205361605,
-0.4092381895,
-0.0015892767,
-0.6854587793,
-0.3534346223,
-0.973682344,
-0.2206310928,
-0.5440639257,
-0.5270665288,
-0.0585443191,
-0.6485207081,
-0.5833554864,
-0.2322929949,
0.5810269713,
0.4723818302,
-0.1438799948,
0.5119945407,
-0.6563228369,
0.3311610818,
0.0852004811,
0.2067240328,
-0.2329077423,
-0.3775963783,
-0.0754228979,
-0.2045318335,
-0.1962346137,
-1.200979352,
0.0866218582,
0.2006657273,
0.1567524821,
0.4326041043,
0.4481654763,
0.4396281838,
-0.4970367551,
0.7572111487,
-0.0509111956,
-0.9943760037,
0.7877656817,
-0.5169906616,
0.3379457593,
0.5434983373,
0.5976435542,
-0.6441842914,
-0.249669835,
-0.6029492617,
-0.8788229823,
0.8251554966,
0.1174161509,
0.1949581802,
-0.1704312563,
0.49546808,
0.3007749617,
0.4256695509,
-0.3963335454,
-0.2994761467,
-0.2268416584,
0.0463981405,
-0.2400860935,
-0.2205934078,
0.1560164094,
-0.2583581209,
0.6138727069,
-0.1156703234,
0.2584138811,
0.3897038102,
-0.1130791381,
-0.0798887163,
0.3676171601,
0.2094746232,
0.5766752362,
-0.320199579,
-0.2020114511,
0.0268462375,
0.0450852178,
0.2545245588,
0.5705384016,
-0.5400179625,
0.4975515604,
0.6042061448,
0.9884181619,
0.3570621908,
-0.4079340398,
0.5244647264,
0.1402995288,
-0.3020553887,
-0.0287946165,
0.0337991379,
-0.2457562983,
0.1671143025,
0.7292072773,
-0.0693852007,
0.3413256407,
-0.387450248,
0.3908775151,
0.2146136314,
-0.2904641032,
-0.3571262062,
0.3680961728,
0.3642098606,
-0.2632401884,
0.156771794,
-0.4219714999,
-0.2774483263,
0.4362220764,
0.1418219358,
1.1803683043,
-0.1996911317,
0.8151512146,
0.3123193085,
0.2854785025,
-0.0858824849,
0.1527847797,
-0.364705503,
-0.6237732172,
-0.7329028845,
-0.5254200101,
-0.3856614828,
0.1898726672,
-0.6973113418,
0.3900408149,
-0.5681163669,
-0.3237089813,
0.5849885941,
0.0459618345,
-0.7352588177,
0.3406145871,
0.1666473746,
1.1821943521,
-1.2226426601,
0.6249957681,
0.854722321,
-0.0595019087,
-0.1748821735,
0.1179520115,
0.118814595,
-0.36292696,
0.6102099419,
0.5421885848,
0.4107142687,
0.1310391128,
-0.7314209938,
-0.6052525043,
0.8213331699,
0.3200599253,
-0.2984628975,
-0.1134760156,
0.0184716713,
0.6414051056,
-0.408100605,
0.0267548058,
0.5009525418,
0.353084743,
0.1580154449,
-0.854799211,
-0.0865986198,
-0.1414755732,
-0.0921087638,
0.2915908694,
-0.1059606746,
0.5430076718,
0.0565573946,
-0.5062501431,
-0.2217907906,
0.5611967444,
-0.1624239534,
0.5804727674,
0.5128024817,
0.2454873472,
0.5718904138,
-0.3882815838,
0.960072279,
-0.232311666,
0.3621659875,
0.8505945802,
-0.3098247051,
0.7107700706,
0.2427800596,
0.0432281196,
0.2383541614,
0.9229280353,
-0.1068922356,
0.5119969249,
-0.1258408278,
-0.1228989363,
-0.3330873549,
-0.5009871125,
-0.2009533644,
0.1878578514,
0.2988679707,
-0.130269438,
-0.7500598431,
0.2369077206,
0.0931323543,
-0.127796188,
-0.3012082875,
0.9680269957,
-0.0479044653,
-0.3973503113,
0.3160398602,
0.0854697227,
0.7470668554,
-0.3895176649,
0.1085798368,
-0.1509109885,
-0.4152992964,
-0.0028666533,
-0.7272875309,
0.4046999514,
0.3918376565,
-0.1481981426,
-0.4829703867,
0.9307753444,
-0.1001531929,
-0.4383153617,
0.2591990232,
0.752340734,
-0.001999785,
-0.4203742743,
-0.6268083453,
-0.1932326108,
-0.0402325317,
-0.458671242,
0.0851968899,
0.6900955439,
-0.3261357248,
0.5423516631,
0.6493400931,
-0.20109725,
-0.1881845146,
-0.1187858507,
0.8022878766,
-0.8668349981,
-0.5921006799,
-0.8574646115,
0.5107460022,
-0.1691376269,
-0.2128019929,
0.5542730689,
0.1753376573,
0.6881324649,
0.0483273491,
0.9958263636,
-0.2117971331,
0.684507966,
-0.1880173534,
0.5449098945,
-0.4098045528,
-0.0950203538,
-0.300355494,
-0.7924735546,
-0.5685277581,
0.4688165784,
-0.595041275,
-0.1611274481,
0.4551494122,
0.3355093896,
0.1201307923,
0.100199379,
0.1557926983,
0.1102748364,
0.1930580586,
0.0612124018,
0.549846828,
-0.0828454643,
0.166251719,
-0.5566466451,
-0.3240624666,
-0.2907360792,
-1.0498692989,
-1.2043708563,
-0.6872392297,
-0.6213514805,
-0.1851528734,
0.2141194046,
1.1270468235,
0.6069247127,
-0.9948062301,
0.1964201629,
-0.0451878496,
-0.0448424555,
0.1910032183,
-0.2518112361,
0.4700855315,
-0.6125988364,
-0.4906817675,
0.0315055214,
0.3965485394,
0.2819692791,
-0.0186356027,
0.3975391388,
-0.1330581307,
-0.0201082043,
0.6729490757,
0.3243064582,
-0.657248795,
-0.2183668911,
0.1232279912,
-0.0161640998,
-0.0220447537,
0.6193646789,
-0.9993887544,
0.3096081316,
0.4518838525,
0.9219340682,
0.1540277302,
0.0204326995,
0.4111120105,
-0.7385341525,
0.368467629,
0.1736389995,
0.1218601614,
0.4961183369,
-0.3001888394,
0.537412107,
0.3696376681,
-0.2264147401,
-0.9138991833,
-0.0795381963,
-0.7300685644,
-0.4399147928,
1.1015802622,
-0.0808196962,
-0.0598116815,
-0.2003748417,
-0.214397639,
0.4014910161,
-0.8197332621,
0.9230734706,
0.9053573608,
0.0671207011,
-0.2163205445,
-0.7797572017,
0.6074391603,
0.0985438973,
-0.8154674768,
-0.0892919749,
0.5497227907,
0.064148657,
0.1883684844,
0.7378845215,
0.3687725067,
0.2943525612,
-0.4623195529,
0.0596317835,
0.071928896,
-0.3849865496,
-0.6215054393,
0.3043915927,
-0.344275564,
-0.1666972041
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18227v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18227v1 | GUIDE: A Guideline-Guided Dataset for Instructional Video Comprehension | 2024-06-26T10:24:00 | 2024-06-26T10:24:00 | Jiafeng Liang, Shixin Jiang, Zekun Wang, Haojie Pan, Zerui Chen, Zheng Chu, Ming Liu, Ruiji Fu, Zhongyuan Wang, Bing Qin | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | There are substantial instructional videos on the Internet, which provide us
tutorials for completing various tasks. Existing instructional video datasets
only focus on specific steps at the video level, lacking experiential
guidelines at the task level, which can lead to beginners struggling to learn
new tasks due to the lack of relevant experience. Moreover, the specific steps
without guidelines are trivial and unsystematic, making it difficult to provide
a clear tutorial. To address these problems, we present the GUIDE
(Guideline-Guided) dataset, which contains 3.5K videos of 560 instructional
tasks in 8 domains related to our daily life. Specifically, we annotate each
instructional task with a guideline, representing a common pattern shared by
all task-related videos. On this basis, we annotate systematic specific steps,
including their associated guideline steps, specific step descriptions and
timestamps. Our proposed benchmark consists of three sub-tasks to evaluate
comprehension ability of models: (1) Step Captioning: models have to generate
captions for specific steps from videos. (2) Guideline Summarization: models
have to mine the common pattern in task-related videos and summarize a
guideline from them. (3) Guideline-Guided Captioning: models have to generate
captions for specific steps under the guide of guideline. We evaluate plenty of
foundation models with GUIDE and perform in-depth analysis. Given the diversity
and practicality of GUIDE, we believe that it can be used as a better benchmark
for instructional video comprehension. | [
-0.402012676,
-0.8163977265,
0.2603546381,
0.2523784935,
-0.5486958027,
-0.3311729431,
0.0648044124,
0.3620297611,
-0.2284479886,
0.7277926207,
-1.0293068886,
-0.6574375033,
-0.4008354545,
0.0562660582,
-0.5781189203,
1.1772946119,
-0.3136529326,
0.2360188067,
-0.3866938651,
0.040034622,
-0.7509825826,
0.1500268131,
-0.4762814641,
-0.2195215821,
0.2833554745,
0.7129547,
0.1269452274,
0.8773787022,
0.6125192642,
0.1619640589,
0.0833869427,
0.2541167438,
-0.3207834661,
0.0944369361,
0.1225078329,
-0.1453980505,
-0.3276598454,
-0.06522578,
0.4006629884,
0.9804627299,
-0.2155922949,
0.6007573009,
0.3168660998,
0.833242774,
-0.5599891543,
0.336274147,
-0.1565711647,
0.2104924768,
0.2127662152,
-0.3680221736,
-0.2255687118,
-0.285338223,
0.3847906888,
-1.0658769608,
0.6218020916,
-0.079855524,
0.4308900535,
0.8509303331,
-0.3799281418,
-0.0550290309,
-0.40841344,
0.4186514914,
-0.4320260286,
0.4730142951,
0.6733790636,
0.6233068705,
0.2575989366,
-0.6696364284,
-0.2509273887,
0.0461947881,
0.0985040739,
0.037668407,
-0.126277864,
0.2157916278,
0.6421697736,
0.125844717,
-0.7649781704,
-0.3837435246,
-0.5234755278,
-0.0220020656,
0.3862302899,
0.2497811019,
0.1587355882,
-0.4178794026,
-0.3008020222,
-0.2914535403,
-0.3650144935,
0.4422951639,
0.2461696267,
-0.0500223786,
0.0082135247,
0.4670597613,
-0.5787361264,
0.9891579151,
0.1465780139,
-0.4375580251,
0.1858381182,
-0.5589847565,
-0.5990413427,
-0.0099440133,
0.273866117,
0.8403328657,
0.6875603199,
-0.0747800991,
0.1189907417,
-0.2246899754,
0.3544858694,
-0.7744753957,
-0.572938025,
-0.0284462087,
-0.4256739318,
0.0927984715,
0.0531824008,
-0.6716778278,
-0.4939695597,
-0.7077860236,
0.5349768996,
-0.3261357546,
0.0910179764,
-0.0424115732,
-0.2587049007,
0.2165857255,
0.3518853784,
-0.7996639013,
0.6471408606,
0.6204063892,
0.8616839051,
-0.0185478535,
-0.3162253797,
-0.6278437972,
0.1481816322,
-0.1249840558,
0.8214096427,
-0.3688932061,
-0.0908893943,
0.0969073102,
0.2870253921,
-0.1147096679,
-0.261996299,
0.4705701172,
-0.3082234561,
-0.1803423166,
-0.472522825,
-0.707608223,
-0.7849596739,
0.4400674105,
-0.8154355288,
0.5346739292,
-0.0830629915,
-0.5325477719,
0.4812875986,
-0.6625943184,
-0.4032036364,
-0.211177215,
-0.1041008309,
0.0235384516,
-0.3940477669,
0.6911098957,
0.5964413881,
-0.3391439915,
0.2685345113,
0.0659610853,
-0.5088254213,
-0.3130374849,
-0.5287291408,
0.5770555139,
-0.0302934106,
-0.388152808,
0.0547606535,
-0.6449315548,
0.0503481738,
-0.4522139728,
0.0325522199,
-0.1711480469,
0.0105437329,
-0.1482176632,
-0.0170721412,
-0.0969950259,
-0.1099012941,
-0.0262634698,
0.1724639088,
0.3869068921,
0.7463679314,
0.5780505538,
0.2805939913,
-0.2959326804,
0.7921889424,
-0.0176370554,
0.4424865544,
-0.6513606906,
-0.2874557674,
-0.830183506,
0.0068847304,
-0.0331882797,
0.4106417,
-0.6486407518,
0.0025152629,
-0.2468786538,
-0.439840585,
-0.3802282214,
0.5738785267,
0.5178548098,
0.8487893343,
0.6210713983,
-0.1748509407,
-0.6050856709,
-0.8121209741,
0.0973848924,
0.1329575181,
-0.075919494,
0.3240317404,
0.4889467657,
0.1887619197,
0.6496983171,
-0.6278062463,
-0.5533679128,
0.0863759518,
0.070884563,
0.2852654755,
0.2675839067,
0.1069796681,
-0.9894874096,
-0.7005933523,
-0.2654860318,
-0.8460376263,
0.1712369323,
-0.0686518252,
-0.0643188432,
-0.3373250365,
0.6039531231,
-0.1642093211,
0.420861423,
0.3428160846,
-0.2100289166,
0.1768784225,
-0.1780450195,
0.4425866902,
-0.6714354753,
0.0000371496,
0.2722086906,
0.1403756589,
-0.5098316669,
-0.2668628991,
0.0086167352,
-0.0627393723,
-0.395806849,
0.2776764631,
-0.2268175036,
-0.0749615729,
0.0487438925,
0.0747957677,
0.0585174263,
0.865118742,
0.192307204,
0.7552720904,
0.6630316973,
-0.6954027414,
0.6372535229,
0.4732615054,
-0.4162126482,
0.8214527369,
-0.8030240536,
-0.1787971854,
-0.3604699671,
0.2469123155,
-0.9826042652,
-0.4317836761,
0.2683064342,
-0.2001034915,
0.0236824676,
-0.5407408476,
-0.1451187581,
0.0436989218,
-0.2656669617,
0.3982300162,
0.5095949173,
-0.3281237483,
0.4166831672,
0.0816238448,
-0.0876552016,
-0.8591675162,
-0.2731793821,
-0.3774038255,
-0.392391175,
-0.6181348562,
0.2307967395,
-0.4579562247,
-0.0864764974,
0.1831963062,
-0.5234293342,
-0.496781826,
-0.0819298029,
0.7257584333,
-0.0269247554,
-0.1387307495,
-0.1548485011,
-0.0711008459,
0.0687427968,
0.2086606026,
-0.2336979508,
0.0346006863,
0.2475224435,
-0.3982039094,
-0.2874065936,
0.4291391075,
0.361728102,
-0.170537129,
0.0180391539,
0.5284170508,
-0.3730320036,
-0.2482368499,
-0.6100876927,
-0.2121138424,
-0.3807674944,
0.3089484572,
-0.1447364241,
-0.3638792634,
0.2404621989,
0.4022898674,
0.2503727078,
0.0431888364,
-0.1294167936,
-0.3945539296,
1.0077588558,
0.5253156424,
0.2366092205,
0.5292399526,
-0.602647543,
-0.3134843111,
-0.8398497105,
-0.6079618931,
-0.2925119102,
-0.2009545118,
-0.1171123087,
-0.3682504892,
0.4090464413,
0.1631840914,
-0.4497140944,
0.4365365803,
-0.4032199681,
0.5828792453,
0.7786837816,
0.2993229032,
0.2505574226,
0.3602100015,
0.058288265,
-0.1426885128,
-0.6312485933,
-0.504755497,
1.2087118626,
0.072955966,
0.7882623672,
-0.0291443765,
0.3488111794,
0.7323690057,
-0.0610321313,
-0.6173037291,
0.6857169867,
-0.2446613014,
-0.4618486166,
-0.3944574893,
-0.1447272003,
-0.772025466,
-0.0871638656,
0.1608241796,
-0.4370218813,
-0.2537014484,
0.3196988702,
-0.4890093505,
-0.0919861346,
-0.6705574989,
1.2420394421,
-0.1175286025,
-0.3927845657,
-0.0422930233,
-0.5686820745,
0.316482693,
0.041437611,
0.2239164263,
0.0932438821,
0.1436063498,
1.0674608946,
-0.4838831127,
0.7514045238,
-0.4228668213,
0.3785760403,
0.5324953794,
-0.1702989638,
0.2116700113,
-0.0928362906,
0.38112849,
-0.4271721244,
0.1750377268,
-0.3616010845,
-0.7791104913,
0.4245400727,
-0.5630236864,
-0.5719037056,
-0.0788836926,
-0.235826984,
-0.2235149592,
0.0708680227,
0.1321530491,
0.5863006115,
0.0063354159,
0.3035463095,
1.1177749634,
0.2634133399,
0.4306616783,
0.7620583177,
0.4408895671,
-0.6320355535,
0.9813181758,
0.1219748408,
-0.0836914927,
0.3358369172,
-0.2236946523,
-0.3234708309,
-0.7007017732,
-0.5038355589,
-0.0105793402,
-1.0314348936,
-0.1318987757,
-0.304268539,
-0.052786611,
-0.2389035821,
0.1363021284,
0.2858986557,
-0.0662192032,
-0.3209380507,
-0.3223821819,
0.4230259061,
0.7338080406,
0.1743649095,
0.2927611172,
-0.6586902142,
0.5290904641,
0.8337550759,
0.3357131183,
-0.1050551236,
-0.7642428875,
-0.3332268298,
0.0520594604,
-0.3994067907,
-0.9697487354,
-0.0180390757,
0.3338075578,
0.8294725418,
0.6113877892,
0.1648373157,
1.0375962257,
-0.7254818082,
0.7692163587,
-0.0032385648,
-0.6555088758,
0.5654647946,
-0.3494442999,
0.0479210056,
0.5927209258,
0.6273640394,
-0.4740082026,
0.1308247447,
-0.5451908708,
-0.6199712753,
0.5501375794,
0.1302605867,
-0.0570212938,
0.3159525692,
0.3242561519,
0.2228647619,
0.3215259314,
-0.3750509322,
-0.3325523734,
-0.6045681834,
-0.2981178761,
-0.2318905443,
0.1684453189,
-0.2606032491,
-0.1708011329,
0.5590470433,
-0.3285064995,
-0.1550302356,
0.212160632,
-0.410747081,
-0.1689839661,
-0.0826727599,
0.5622788668,
0.7696968317,
-0.439888984,
-0.0044405172,
0.0177377295,
-0.6018010378,
0.1757449061,
0.2602540851,
-0.4034233987,
-0.0792762563,
0.5938780904,
0.7612241507,
0.4440336525,
-0.8252270222,
0.4656599462,
0.0647869855,
-0.3365662992,
-0.4125553071,
0.4662798047,
-0.2808228433,
0.3552719057,
0.467069,
-0.0102939829,
0.4116278887,
-0.2001297176,
0.3996732235,
0.1809971631,
-0.4834486246,
-0.2794423997,
0.5724030733,
0.4404873252,
-0.3376835883,
0.4594124556,
0.0750457495,
-0.198721692,
0.6865320802,
-0.1709691584,
0.6877951622,
0.2300757319,
0.5075377226,
0.7110028267,
0.2404362261,
-0.3991190493,
0.1282517612,
-0.6238542795,
-0.0515632741,
-0.4779729843,
-0.2191361934,
-0.3947756588,
0.2721012235,
-1.0222861767,
0.1917640567,
-0.3407022953,
0.1756937802,
0.1374312639,
0.1962283701,
-0.8524470329,
0.5565325022,
-0.0712078363,
1.1094231606,
-1.026247859,
0.5543783903,
0.8021245599,
-0.8802348971,
-0.8721187115,
-0.1410612464,
-0.0668573007,
-0.5197461843,
0.4892245531,
0.1752278507,
0.2560963035,
-0.0402200371,
-0.4733346999,
-0.6332885027,
1.3833806515,
0.1112912595,
-0.3790576458,
-0.4141196907,
-0.0237670839,
0.4036964178,
-0.3818039894,
0.2989768088,
0.5844755173,
0.4292473793,
0.1976123601,
-0.5632156134,
-0.0616615452,
-0.3289960921,
-0.4176122546,
-0.1120291725,
-0.2912349701,
0.658663094,
-0.2607111335,
0.1675933897,
-0.001784213,
0.2093962431,
0.0479474291,
0.6910868883,
0.6860862374,
0.2518925965,
0.3224621117,
0.0234997813,
0.6437329054,
-0.0749530196,
-0.0014189965,
1.2067222595,
0.3900242746,
0.7368771434,
0.5729343295,
-0.1757213771,
0.4766830206,
0.796846211,
-0.2441392094,
0.6733180285,
0.0725400746,
0.0947792456,
-0.5897364616,
-0.2223559767,
-0.2266316265,
0.1199402437,
0.0804066733,
-0.3797062337,
-0.2118230164,
0.0261037555,
-0.3389841318,
0.1348782629,
-0.5475981236,
0.8013722897,
-0.2195532918,
-1.2301962376,
0.458142072,
-0.545427382,
0.0494787134,
-0.7443822026,
-0.4345327318,
-0.4733761251,
0.0000455487,
-0.3435060382,
-0.7962469459,
-0.2563439906,
0.447545141,
-0.3760600388,
-0.1732478738,
0.0644449368,
-0.5055503249,
-0.2919194698,
-0.1038089544,
0.252654016,
0.3121299744,
-0.1213208437,
-0.5285196304,
-0.1995212287,
0.1848262101,
-0.2979024351,
0.0119153466,
0.3765695393,
-0.1247820035,
0.8224630356,
0.3609687388,
-0.301713258,
0.1082574576,
0.0969763175,
0.6912751794,
-0.535564661,
-0.2725866139,
-0.4863362908,
0.7425847054,
-0.1489425153,
-0.3304272294,
0.8617188334,
0.2938106358,
1.0217546225,
-0.1534727365,
0.6671205163,
0.0701252222,
0.2362491786,
-0.6986228228,
0.2517338097,
-0.6550838947,
0.2196369767,
-0.505004704,
-0.9483044147,
-0.0052929302,
0.5934522748,
0.0329992026,
0.0428944677,
0.767636776,
0.6092149019,
-0.1730402857,
0.2013558,
0.1174890324,
-0.2617181242,
0.0057468768,
0.5804615021,
0.6753575206,
-0.5510458946,
1.2297362089,
-0.6763962507,
-0.1286770254,
-0.2137069255,
-1.0307421684,
-1.1486042738,
-0.6903223991,
-0.615269959,
0.0371740349,
0.3503859937,
0.7731984258,
1.155248642,
-0.6207512617,
-0.2279923856,
-0.3286999166,
0.1142935306,
-0.7757282257,
-0.1321019977,
0.4297615588,
-0.018252261,
-0.5711215138,
0.2561707497,
-0.243748486,
0.0743892342,
-0.423183769,
-0.2816026211,
0.0506527871,
-0.2010698318,
0.1456281841,
0.3328995705,
-0.7241784334,
-0.1318107098,
0.4610468447,
0.3069006801,
-0.2463672161,
1.0588428974,
-0.6949208379,
0.7307056785,
0.5327982903,
0.3342892528,
0.6587581038,
0.236511156,
0.3447021246,
-0.7854605317,
-0.2884456515,
-0.0097337998,
0.3267992437,
0.4685356319,
0.0748092607,
0.8306843638,
0.0124383802,
-0.4011902213,
-0.8359572887,
0.0625256673,
-1.0769611597,
-0.0041496446,
1.1156032085,
-0.4842493236,
-0.0596208647,
-0.1436717361,
-0.3817258179,
0.2650591433,
-0.3826729357,
0.5538644195,
0.688372612,
-0.1576237679,
-0.3717146516,
-0.7978682518,
0.6657372713,
0.317345053,
-0.6068792343,
0.2115763724,
0.5326275826,
0.5161533952,
-0.0630632117,
0.2915889025,
0.5897405744,
0.686182797,
0.034083169,
-0.5493415594,
-0.5987910628,
-0.6188238859,
-0.2378083169,
0.2334525287,
-0.2003305107,
-0.4804222286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18221v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18221v1 | Enhancing Data Privacy in Large Language Models through Private Association Editing | 2024-06-26T10:08:47 | 2024-06-26T10:08:47 | Davide Venditti, Elena Sofia Ruzzetti, Giancarlo A. Xompero, Cristina Giannone, Andrea Favalli, Raniero Romagnoli, Fabio Massimo Zanzotto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are powerful tools with extensive applications,
but their tendency to memorize private information raises significant concerns
as private data leakage can easily happen. In this paper, we introduce Private
Association Editing (PAE), a novel defense approach for private data leakage.
PAE is designed to effectively remove Personally Identifiable Information (PII)
without retraining the model. Our approach consists of a four-step procedure:
detecting memorized PII, applying PAE cards to mitigate memorization of private
data, verifying resilience to targeted data extraction (TDE) attacks, and
ensuring consistency in the post-edit LLMs. The versatility and efficiency of
PAE, which allows for batch modifications, significantly enhance data privacy
in LLMs. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of PAE in
mitigating private data leakage. We believe PAE will serve as a critical tool
in the ongoing effort to protect data privacy in LLMs, encouraging the
development of safer models for real-world applications. | [
-0.083487846,
-0.7902555466,
0.5083408356,
0.0900852382,
-0.0959946811,
0.1590036303,
-0.2744074166,
-0.3165981174,
-0.0709593371,
0.7354214191,
-0.1513663679,
-0.9062369466,
-0.7321454883,
0.001603285,
-0.2904039621,
0.8179178238,
0.0636330545,
-0.2739657164,
0.1814601868,
-0.100516811,
-0.5203486681,
-0.8496004343,
-0.881059587,
0.2837554514,
0.4750837982,
0.2576693296,
0.5939728618,
0.9555536509,
0.5891212225,
0.4419732988,
-0.2943430245,
0.2719934583,
-0.5350513458,
0.1147582233,
-0.433308512,
-0.6221331358,
-1.1358191967,
-0.2175679654,
0.8113814592,
0.4284998477,
-0.0430783555,
0.0286696497,
-0.148942396,
0.7669177651,
-0.9365196824,
0.2242547125,
-0.7654170394,
-0.018323997,
-0.6149400473,
0.0509678014,
-0.6806156039,
-0.1374777257,
-0.0484082922,
-0.330227077,
0.018399179,
-0.0992417186,
0.4491027296,
0.0170594919,
-0.0896326378,
0.1624794304,
-0.8704605103,
0.4207603931,
-0.7854421139,
0.4141069055,
0.5940418243,
0.0174024478,
-0.3726916909,
-0.4744891822,
-0.5018466115,
-0.0260678492,
0.0612971857,
-0.1426439583,
-0.2790829837,
0.1303606778,
0.1456916779,
0.6283024549,
-0.236579448,
0.2974141538,
-0.3420689702,
-0.1461848766,
1.0094740391,
0.0841316432,
0.2549369335,
0.2924230993,
-0.0792649239,
0.0712752491,
-0.7565861344,
-0.1233737245,
0.6051014662,
0.0747620016,
0.0059058797,
0.6699507236,
-0.0812137276,
0.1658026725,
0.2340816706,
-0.1631441563,
0.0089608477,
0.1168705821,
-0.5619519353,
-0.09485434,
0.9276838303,
0.1959057003,
0.3550925255,
-0.5423500538,
-0.1254331917,
-0.2311229706,
0.0454186574,
-0.5548189282,
-0.4249438047,
0.4399499297,
-0.5493693948,
-0.5334811807,
0.0967979953,
-1.0902639627,
-0.8312932849,
0.0383972228,
0.2238297909,
-0.4245984852,
-0.13827613,
0.3071067035,
0.1565143317,
-0.3349115252,
0.1724327058,
-0.7892526388,
0.5990312099,
1.0112229586,
0.6669181585,
-0.2541429698,
-0.3253619969,
-0.8668667674,
0.7831904292,
-0.3307884932,
0.3714345396,
-0.7134093046,
-0.8305286169,
-0.1456329823,
0.1572412401,
0.13293989,
-0.58075881,
0.2388493717,
-0.6620211005,
0.1397679597,
0.003851332,
-0.8120914698,
0.0007384008,
-0.0014653641,
-0.6595383286,
0.4491723776,
-0.3733608425,
-0.5481436253,
-0.0204504244,
-0.8835653067,
-0.2612677515,
-0.0044269077,
-0.0029690599,
-0.8361749053,
0.2403093278,
0.2869673371,
0.520139277,
0.3234059513,
0.1634036154,
-0.379981935,
-0.0562772155,
0.3921619356,
-0.5056608915,
0.5704745054,
0.1300069243,
-0.2257920653,
0.2881188393,
-0.924896121,
-0.3911216557,
0.179352358,
-0.2552177608,
-0.4581714571,
-0.1561015844,
-0.522380054,
-0.2122046649,
0.534329474,
-0.5670333505,
0.4313154519,
-0.5092258453,
0.0115032857,
1.2308123112,
0.4264887869,
0.6971735954,
-0.2536010146,
0.3965171576,
-0.0052397395,
0.4394423962,
-0.1033202559,
-0.4632869363,
-0.3434606194,
-0.6430420876,
0.4424342811,
0.6346273422,
0.0801302269,
0.622272253,
-0.1977937073,
-0.501200974,
-0.362672478,
0.2784070373,
0.4732985497,
0.0067416891,
0.1786817461,
-0.4945442677,
-0.3078413606,
-0.8200992942,
-0.5971038938,
0.1444904506,
0.0759501755,
0.3534749448,
0.2102363855,
-0.1601234823,
0.5798921585,
-0.469108969,
-0.4637650251,
0.0148849329,
-0.0865742862,
-0.1361011267,
0.7187317014,
0.1719290614,
-0.5661814809,
-0.5946111083,
-0.0477619953,
-0.6282069683,
-0.0854847357,
-0.0533201285,
-0.2292995602,
0.1751392186,
0.3254872262,
-0.6362689734,
0.6555384994,
0.4538964927,
-0.5152969956,
0.2607561052,
-0.4465391934,
-0.0480604954,
-0.8197543621,
0.0050863242,
-0.1607311219,
-0.3418150246,
-0.7393314242,
0.2216929197,
0.1440254748,
-0.4799764156,
-0.452860415,
0.5882205367,
-0.5825856328,
0.0347659811,
-0.2557601333,
-0.202009052,
-0.1447789669,
0.3931483924,
-0.0427961797,
0.8340069056,
0.6227734685,
-0.6068587899,
0.0268292297,
0.4357925653,
-0.1721693873,
0.1469108462,
-0.3471074104,
0.7895802259,
-0.2357359529,
0.0808261856,
-0.5159478188,
-0.1262609959,
0.4353370965,
-0.0907564387,
0.5779069066,
-0.1975312978,
-0.6001775265,
0.3400474787,
-0.3701139092,
0.0661951751,
0.1927118003,
-0.6953590512,
0.7019234896,
0.7212292552,
-0.3174953163,
-0.5442047119,
-0.6561670899,
0.3955952525,
-0.3500067294,
-0.5257575512,
0.4437595308,
-0.2823886275,
-0.5220503807,
-0.120100528,
-0.1051590368,
-0.5202607512,
0.3353376389,
0.2720232308,
0.3251454234,
0.1379672736,
-0.0236340873,
-0.0073986384,
-0.2427304387,
-0.0462360047,
0.2286883295,
0.4949090779,
-0.005371104,
-0.1074187309,
-1.0202606916,
0.6239452362,
0.4523239136,
-0.8328663707,
1.0690461397,
0.1094230115,
-0.460406363,
-0.100273937,
-0.4685715139,
-0.0502457246,
-0.5303363204,
0.3341957033,
-0.5096877217,
-0.5941669345,
0.4049322307,
-0.3387096226,
0.3199219704,
-0.0642833561,
0.3911184669,
0.3771234453,
0.7688845992,
0.656122148,
-0.418720305,
0.4606684744,
-0.2105311602,
0.5013363957,
-0.7204217315,
-0.1453226656,
-0.2432519794,
-0.1757452339,
-0.6192362905,
-0.3418076634,
0.1230577454,
0.0475886762,
-0.0015950624,
0.0484259538,
-0.3717575669,
0.9297682643,
0.1153880954,
0.2766119242,
0.5754393935,
-0.3096305132,
0.6489167213,
-0.0652357638,
-0.0936115906,
-0.7691677809,
1.3468887806,
0.6761738658,
0.5925795436,
0.4238427281,
1.154902935,
0.2484066486,
0.2837372124,
-0.2714117467,
0.7592521906,
-0.4912008345,
-0.6377120018,
-0.3771571219,
-0.2180891782,
-0.6763831973,
0.1990326047,
-0.225482896,
-1.1623980999,
0.5508870482,
0.229749009,
-0.2364888042,
0.7272010446,
-0.8494273424,
0.7986438274,
0.008417394,
-0.7731115818,
-0.2377831936,
-0.1770060658,
0.5456888676,
-0.318121016,
0.3682735562,
0.1006672308,
-0.2304835916,
0.6503219008,
-0.6071926355,
0.8802211881,
-0.3379188776,
-0.2159608006,
-0.0790571198,
0.4980615377,
1.1087293625,
0.3878175914,
-0.2889110148,
0.2857103348,
-0.2408993393,
-0.2885538936,
-0.5180591941,
0.7556996942,
-0.5356563926,
-0.8298596144,
-0.4024184644,
-0.5905971527,
-0.3359290659,
0.2497192621,
-0.1455074698,
0.1499960124,
-0.1889451444,
0.2757402062,
0.7309429646,
-0.3826712966,
0.2761758566,
0.6723965406,
-0.1296596825,
-0.1449215412,
0.8077905178,
0.0012107845,
0.2302067429,
0.3534436226,
0.4291595519,
-0.1186476499,
-0.9243802428,
0.2682930529,
0.3989190757,
-0.4635505974,
0.0269553289,
-0.7369869947,
-0.0984519422,
-0.4256711006,
-0.0689606369,
-0.7073848248,
-0.2914597094,
0.0478745326,
-0.1545366645,
0.4022575021,
0.5395181179,
-0.3126797974,
0.4654064775,
-0.7516586781,
0.3837793469,
0.2790258825,
0.6086588502,
-0.1804333776,
-0.2896706164,
0.1316009015,
-0.2711251676,
-0.1316693425,
-0.8875743151,
0.4961222112,
0.1410368085,
0.179380089,
0.1029966027,
-0.0399273708,
0.5981951356,
-0.6401928663,
0.6608735323,
-0.2637383342,
-1.2135293484,
0.3861452341,
-0.2971238196,
-0.0576226264,
0.5789347291,
0.064781785,
-0.2716708779,
-0.5642846227,
-0.755884409,
-0.602881968,
0.5458680987,
0.0683141649,
0.126609236,
0.1293175817,
0.5270518661,
0.1329393983,
0.3560340703,
-0.673088789,
-0.4881334603,
0.3330481946,
-0.0129082613,
0.1793875098,
-0.4337623119,
-0.0229279846,
0.0211475268,
0.91109097,
0.4834343195,
-0.054956127,
0.0227924641,
0.3620870113,
-0.0509035997,
0.5186179876,
0.0470475927,
0.6236884594,
-0.3404866755,
-0.1419217288,
0.1863624007,
-0.3858331144,
0.0261834078,
-0.0833725631,
-0.2051819265,
-0.1004466638,
0.0981795713,
0.4517023563,
-0.1018291712,
-0.3839244545,
0.5565737486,
-0.3089952767,
0.026590582,
-0.3150582314,
0.3331140876,
-0.1004046127,
0.0166405831,
-0.2140547335,
0.0974149927,
0.0430071503,
-0.4912967384,
0.0861989707,
0.1582498401,
0.1692750305,
-0.1949893832,
0.6921584606,
-0.0452136472,
-0.6759521365,
0.2662325501,
0.0647141114,
-0.0109174177,
0.2085361183,
0.3246436715,
0.8626708984,
-0.7507004738,
-0.1293776929,
0.0176871568,
0.2484432757,
0.1002661362,
0.102570042,
0.1985198855,
-0.4709261954,
-0.2527254224,
-0.1000136659,
-0.2748073041,
0.88718611,
-0.53901577,
0.2000743449,
-1.0442521572,
0.1782221794,
0.0999023095,
-0.1323199272,
-0.4237072468,
0.1524153799,
0.0116063692,
0.7922586799,
-0.423717469,
1.0527076721,
0.1309652925,
-0.054784447,
-0.7818964124,
0.1073418558,
0.2812745869,
-0.3931163549,
0.4036844075,
-0.1840174198,
0.1059179157,
-0.2130816132,
-0.3276352882,
-0.5950964689,
0.7232603431,
0.4056619108,
-1.0321984291,
0.0852400959,
0.1718751192,
0.4371315837,
-0.0970705077,
-0.5169369578,
0.6301960945,
0.5840070844,
-0.6360595822,
-0.639049232,
-0.0354973115,
-0.1105956361,
-0.1014419794,
0.2325666994,
-0.7565211654,
0.7350742221,
0.1509106308,
-0.1883562505,
0.2029224783,
0.6735665798,
0.1825757772,
0.21244286,
0.4472305477,
0.4222726822,
1.0856140852,
0.324135989,
1.197683692,
-0.3262939155,
-0.0136819035,
1.4378234148,
-0.5944024324,
0.8698771596,
0.2334479839,
-0.0880588144,
0.0704241171,
-0.0135192424,
-0.0045512132,
0.5660275221,
0.1009924263,
-0.7464820147,
-0.0644227192,
0.2568982244,
-0.3205362558,
0.6982787251,
0.1967827082,
-0.5929898024,
0.1417489797,
-0.2066273391,
0.4791483879,
0.5891288519,
-0.2007897049,
0.8963258862,
-0.0543037914,
-0.2602106333,
0.1498701274,
0.4707889855,
0.4000145793,
-0.7184354663,
0.0919126794,
-0.2141401917,
0.5630167127,
-0.2522622645,
-0.6168128252,
0.6411822438,
0.4360358715,
-0.2372566015,
-0.1588454396,
0.5918418169,
-0.487356931,
-0.2938644886,
0.1947485507,
0.1999334544,
0.1331677288,
-0.1899041235,
-0.6443657279,
0.2448026985,
0.0106578926,
-0.2758682966,
0.5988757014,
0.4545454979,
0.0846544057,
0.4947187603,
0.8439821005,
0.5235672593,
0.150957644,
0.0087091671,
0.6320070624,
-0.4066337347,
-0.5670714974,
-1.0990611315,
0.3802267313,
-0.2743045986,
-0.1179443374,
0.8066871166,
0.7440716028,
0.6241409183,
-0.2018711865,
0.864900589,
0.353549093,
0.5837222338,
-0.523550272,
0.8742974997,
-0.0014440863,
0.631006062,
-0.22044532,
-0.6778768301,
-0.5670787096,
0.2868020833,
-0.6704981327,
-0.3677507639,
0.6040558815,
1.1899285316,
-0.0340887979,
0.0397155881,
0.2748199701,
0.5631614327,
0.8415942788,
0.527708292,
0.3736958504,
-0.5703485012,
0.3818033636,
-0.7320751548,
-0.3243002892,
0.49132967,
-0.878559649,
-1.1021457911,
-0.2378920019,
-0.583273232,
-0.1301719546,
0.476228863,
0.6483719349,
0.6669918299,
-0.8360049129,
-0.141123414,
-0.1440549791,
-0.0413718261,
-0.0864379033,
-0.1942752302,
0.7135289907,
0.0988568142,
-0.9685493112,
0.9328958988,
0.4699071646,
0.0269146953,
-0.0539455153,
0.0728645474,
-0.2495501041,
0.1090795845,
0.1985252351,
0.4725482464,
-0.5135161281,
-0.1856171489,
-0.6097832322,
0.1355297714,
0.080071874,
0.6930026412,
-0.2097067088,
0.5949028134,
0.2250942886,
0.8864665031,
0.249621287,
0.1211942807,
0.6754150391,
-0.9216504693,
0.3720659912,
0.0488914698,
0.4587635398,
0.2818525136,
-0.9117516279,
0.2696143389,
0.0660006329,
-0.6243383884,
-0.8733630776,
0.031818375,
-0.7982971072,
-0.2716169655,
0.8739941716,
-0.5110231042,
-0.6918207407,
-0.0635171831,
-0.3959663808,
0.0500475988,
-0.4878129661,
1.0609529018,
0.5919283032,
0.3370281458,
-0.1513008475,
-0.2450613379,
0.4706842601,
0.2746414542,
-1.0185104609,
0.6187999845,
0.3769289851,
0.2846538126,
-0.1445252299,
0.7266413569,
-0.5564968586,
0.1950211525,
-0.3098991811,
-0.2154951692,
-0.4757042229,
-0.3953567445,
-0.5316005349,
0.2609367967,
0.1215154752,
-0.4570029974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18219v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18219v1 | A Closer Look into Mixture-of-Experts in Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T10:07:57 | 2024-06-26T10:07:57 | Ka Man Lo, Zeyu Huang, Zihan Qiu, Zili Wang, Jie Fu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Mixture-of-experts (MoE) is gaining increasing attention due to its unique
properties and remarkable performance, especially for language tasks. By
sparsely activating a subset of parameters for each token, MoE architecture
could increase the model size without sacrificing computational efficiency,
achieving a better trade-off between performance and training costs. However,
the underlying mechanism of MoE still lacks further exploration, and its
modularization degree remains questionable. In this paper, we make an initial
attempt to understand the inner workings of MoE-based large language models.
Concretely, we comprehensively study the parametric and behavioral features of
three recent MoE-based models and reveal some intriguing observations,
including (1) Neurons act like fine-grained experts. (2) The router of MoE
usually selects experts with larger output norms. (3) The expert diversity
increases as the layer increases, while the last layer is an outlier. Based on
the observations, we also provide suggestions for a broad spectrum of MoE
practitioners, such as router design and expert allocation. We hope this work
could shed light on future research on the MoE framework and other modular
architectures. Code is available at
https://github.com/kamanphoebe/Look-into-MoEs. | [
-0.6949454546,
-0.8339178562,
0.5414509773,
-0.0195910688,
0.0279561952,
0.0079809809,
-0.3826926649,
-0.4681803286,
0.21816203,
0.3623582423,
-0.2891379893,
-0.036694359,
-0.8098974824,
-0.2434351593,
-0.390968591,
0.7163108587,
0.4405917823,
-0.1267855465,
-0.0865190476,
-0.0521325767,
-0.7395694852,
-0.3341596127,
-0.5598763227,
-0.4035741091,
0.4716622829,
0.4443247318,
0.7808759212,
0.4721589386,
0.2990833819,
0.355156064,
-0.1226884872,
0.1328360289,
-0.6200088263,
0.1741219759,
-0.1497811973,
-0.7191393375,
-0.5816141367,
-0.3249271214,
0.6413121223,
0.7811334133,
-0.2601534724,
-0.1708081067,
0.1291812509,
0.5024956465,
-0.5991345644,
0.1841006875,
-0.9765677452,
-0.1102880538,
-0.5264495611,
-0.0026520935,
-0.4562076628,
0.2754147053,
0.2156787813,
-0.1877714396,
0.0190933496,
0.1811653376,
0.5098297,
0.2237650454,
-0.575928092,
-0.0376489162,
-0.579374373,
0.9909433722,
-0.9157640934,
0.1504112631,
0.4459896088,
0.2706514895,
-0.3789798915,
-0.0664987117,
-0.4555103779,
-0.1255162805,
0.067355752,
-0.0840616897,
-0.1499622613,
0.0577403419,
-0.2098133564,
0.6863499284,
-0.2668831348,
0.4218660891,
-0.4179725051,
0.0590244457,
0.7458167076,
0.2009735107,
0.348336339,
0.0125539163,
-0.2728056312,
0.263573885,
-0.4388433397,
0.0474059097,
0.5939865112,
-0.11152374,
0.0070604198,
0.5594664216,
-0.3620629013,
0.7897544503,
0.1740664244,
0.0901115835,
0.0211640056,
0.0647244155,
0.1071772128,
-0.1513918638,
0.8966385126,
0.1834858507,
0.5089722872,
-0.3350248933,
-0.4667969346,
-0.6533437967,
0.2387993783,
-0.5418480635,
-0.7156888247,
0.1909315735,
-0.503441155,
-0.2368890047,
-0.0188377015,
-0.6056613922,
-0.1799946129,
-0.3537335694,
0.5716347098,
-0.5203313828,
-0.7668737173,
0.239217028,
-0.195989579,
-0.0721074268,
0.2584217787,
-1.0564296246,
0.2746306658,
1.035779357,
0.6285736561,
-0.2578653991,
-0.4353975952,
-0.3804224133,
0.1488530338,
-0.2341493368,
0.661795795,
-1.0536804199,
-0.3491087556,
-0.2165341824,
-0.6068499088,
-0.1844628155,
-0.5982124209,
-0.054789044,
-0.7160125971,
-0.0272695702,
-0.2920608819,
-0.6185026765,
-0.3813108504,
0.1541567445,
-0.408017993,
1.0853830576,
-0.088216655,
-0.64608109,
0.2765920758,
-0.5594757795,
-0.3211492598,
0.0090340599,
-0.2970283926,
0.2216885835,
0.5978012681,
0.1739002615,
0.773729682,
-0.1362167597,
0.4074065685,
-0.5095645785,
-0.2098806947,
0.6770325899,
-0.4597228467,
0.8120882511,
0.0583908148,
-0.1950064898,
0.0333049595,
-0.7510010004,
-0.2116975188,
-0.2078261971,
-0.2247467935,
-0.5965723991,
0.1850077361,
-0.236865133,
0.2172531188,
0.317306757,
-0.2961490154,
0.2353417426,
-0.0461138897,
0.531840384,
0.9970564842,
0.0108746365,
0.6667649746,
-0.3021431267,
0.2419824004,
0.1938661188,
0.1838815212,
-0.3054268956,
-0.959861517,
-0.8163660765,
-0.6012770534,
0.3881907761,
0.1561656743,
-0.5864758492,
0.6410413384,
-0.2985165417,
-0.5602531433,
-0.570127666,
0.3556209505,
0.3024730086,
0.3208159506,
0.1901266575,
-0.3484065533,
0.1213038266,
-1.1917042732,
-0.2463968545,
-0.0870764405,
-0.0019201838,
0.2416663468,
0.4367824793,
-0.179899022,
1.2683855295,
-0.4909833968,
0.0504778139,
-0.118948251,
0.1829271615,
0.1029668823,
0.6530100703,
0.5939927101,
-0.6546133161,
-0.4506828189,
0.2946060002,
-0.5552233458,
-0.016760122,
0.0901666284,
-0.3176069558,
-0.3271292448,
0.4164664447,
-0.6555153131,
0.0506435856,
0.5098220706,
0.1897441745,
0.384401232,
-0.1887672991,
-0.1747486144,
-1.0208830833,
-0.1195532456,
-0.0213057492,
0.0020028143,
-0.5732397437,
0.4985422194,
-0.1374270767,
0.1650532782,
0.004378451,
0.4686439037,
-0.5717827082,
-0.0744075775,
-0.3687455356,
-0.1051480398,
-0.3559924364,
0.733256042,
-0.2171565443,
0.6624279022,
0.9427127838,
-0.5260655284,
0.2694809139,
-0.1233417168,
-0.4984826446,
0.3418705761,
-0.5502737761,
0.2643504441,
-0.0649129748,
0.0744256824,
-1.0062220097,
-0.5381947756,
0.1431972831,
-0.3356037438,
0.4865586758,
-0.1947775185,
-0.6449536085,
-0.1477451771,
-0.1905609369,
0.6952145696,
0.7351723909,
-0.1179672703,
0.8033010364,
0.6624762416,
-0.5353451967,
-0.4185399711,
-0.6457161307,
0.1433205307,
-0.1069217846,
-0.736543119,
0.0733554959,
-0.0190623682,
-0.5269246101,
0.0380420536,
0.0545787364,
-0.4082584381,
0.1889322996,
0.0816112384,
-0.2101905495,
-0.4793307781,
0.0487571321,
0.4938162565,
-0.0448001325,
0.2285921723,
-0.3349375427,
0.6045374274,
-0.1453851163,
-0.7060137391,
-0.4167951047,
0.5240923166,
0.6662300229,
-0.473127991,
0.664427042,
0.5563451052,
-0.1762924492,
-0.1503547877,
-0.8962210417,
-0.2655827999,
-0.4747341871,
0.5525044799,
-0.3059738576,
-0.579249084,
0.8188076019,
0.1948663145,
0.0582128763,
0.5191400051,
0.696570456,
0.1206785366,
0.9858041406,
0.4664187729,
-0.2614176571,
0.5407021642,
-0.0657652393,
0.2136724591,
-0.8915513158,
-0.3817289472,
-0.2880938947,
-0.648578167,
-0.178003028,
-0.4459899962,
0.3040593565,
0.1714994162,
0.17757532,
0.0022835294,
-0.1260062158,
0.5122203231,
0.6667796969,
0.2313515246,
0.160635516,
-0.1697324812,
-0.0263787713,
0.2929085195,
-1.0339579582,
-0.1586327106,
1.0430827141,
0.415538013,
0.6782842278,
0.0536470711,
0.6558864713,
0.1423015147,
0.0102755763,
-0.7242098451,
0.7375345826,
0.0210479032,
-0.9280227423,
-0.2640017867,
-0.3723702729,
-0.59619838,
0.4414623678,
-0.2109418213,
-0.6720762849,
0.4873811603,
0.1701092422,
-0.3649820387,
0.5139927864,
-0.8077818155,
0.4311062992,
-0.2456108481,
-0.1885486245,
-0.550188005,
-0.6042742729,
0.5097052455,
-0.3772559464,
0.244622454,
-0.1088828743,
-0.0790661797,
0.4439001977,
-0.3460468948,
0.9066776633,
0.0094315484,
-0.3949207366,
0.1561387479,
0.1537100822,
0.3287535608,
-0.0133137945,
-0.2229062766,
0.4080112576,
-0.5617177486,
-0.7233490944,
-0.4575726986,
0.8106073737,
-0.7200168967,
-0.7071419358,
0.2004110664,
-0.770753026,
-0.2926648259,
0.2596130967,
0.2849902809,
0.7840796709,
0.1951485872,
0.5830895901,
0.8216693997,
0.0014124118,
0.3445432782,
0.1981624365,
-0.2808425128,
-0.0791462064,
1.0038033724,
0.2860181928,
0.2313429862,
0.5186161995,
0.2102272511,
0.0994319469,
-0.9220708013,
-0.4445768595,
-0.0950549766,
-0.5040299296,
0.0862951055,
-0.8194313049,
0.0931972712,
-0.0675698221,
-0.035694804,
-0.4582040012,
-0.2842290103,
-0.2666503787,
0.0752566308,
0.2490006685,
0.8987107277,
0.2059590369,
0.5098894835,
-0.8434760571,
0.0178710744,
0.541641891,
0.291588068,
0.6249349117,
-0.3867832422,
-0.4446431994,
0.2261060774,
-0.1056259573,
-0.6489719152,
-0.0561664738,
0.24480699,
0.7894420028,
1.0883905888,
-0.0198534932,
0.5423066616,
-0.6116409302,
0.8308973312,
-0.0031166356,
-0.7948564887,
0.0045838128,
-0.762387991,
0.0224290211,
0.3308884799,
0.0579062514,
0.0470415056,
-0.8192514181,
-0.4911561906,
-0.7775352597,
0.6728464961,
0.3506374955,
0.5650836825,
0.0167702734,
0.2426835299,
0.6341719031,
0.2930337787,
-0.3736982942,
-0.1948734522,
0.1614835262,
-0.0975443125,
0.0310652051,
-0.4805124998,
-0.0699441433,
-0.2281863838,
0.4139559269,
0.1892101616,
0.1319921315,
-0.3784734011,
-0.2654301822,
0.0113043748,
0.2123533487,
0.6636862755,
0.7486779094,
-0.1191892624,
0.073091805,
0.1410404742,
-0.1746097207,
-0.3336018622,
-0.1484435499,
0.1151708886,
-0.0265696291,
0.5681835413,
0.88359797,
0.6538522243,
-0.5004679561,
0.5842527747,
0.3120825589,
-0.0860453174,
0.0506761968,
0.4809851944,
-0.0142970625,
0.4219047427,
0.7330239415,
0.6190451384,
0.3010161817,
-0.6292841434,
-0.084347181,
0.446636796,
-0.0318228044,
-0.6873658895,
0.3921292126,
0.538510859,
-0.351370275,
0.3995466828,
-0.0815210119,
-0.6405504942,
0.4545540512,
0.1872651726,
0.7909834981,
-0.1295703202,
-0.156171456,
-0.4037443399,
0.2560956478,
-0.1752765626,
-0.1427373588,
-0.1990110129,
-0.5634217858,
-0.4962400496,
-0.18310076,
-0.2258045822,
-0.1621733308,
-0.9092531204,
0.1239457428,
-0.2172040194,
-0.1785876602,
-0.1175888181,
-0.5229195356,
-0.4733197391,
-0.0377697647,
0.1105579659,
0.6748169065,
-0.6113206148,
0.7915145755,
0.8323370814,
-0.0127784833,
-0.4855594635,
0.391220659,
-0.2934352458,
-0.911524713,
0.5392628312,
0.0520429797,
0.0758512691,
-0.0405023284,
-0.3762944341,
-0.5936440825,
0.6933513284,
0.3357739747,
-0.6151391268,
-0.2649033964,
-0.1113259792,
0.4980689883,
-0.1509223133,
0.3788208067,
0.2219876647,
0.3263653219,
-0.270388931,
-0.8777288795,
-0.2777763009,
-0.4641185403,
-0.0511944853,
0.3406558633,
-0.8640674353,
1.3308458328,
0.1115472764,
0.414447844,
-0.0001676205,
0.8221311569,
-0.0214974768,
0.2612922192,
0.4679729044,
0.4013716877,
0.6894379854,
0.2322844267,
1.1226872206,
-0.5047737956,
0.3158356249,
0.7282451391,
-0.1151025966,
0.9703665376,
0.4457224011,
-0.1425893158,
0.5471815467,
0.5430817604,
0.2160100341,
0.445610851,
-0.1702403128,
-0.2037196159,
-0.6220756173,
0.3977266252,
-0.5317593217,
0.3931996822,
0.3557694852,
-0.2245328575,
-0.111528337,
0.112118952,
-0.1172556207,
-0.2723679841,
-0.5166620612,
0.7389734387,
0.1177785546,
-0.592604816,
0.1543744057,
0.006952282,
0.8268770576,
-0.4341391325,
0.2193810791,
-0.109865129,
0.0405769758,
-0.0456770584,
-0.9203633666,
-0.0813755542,
-0.2135026902,
-0.3407936692,
0.0696594715,
0.6237922907,
-0.4557714164,
-0.3166675568,
0.1811130643,
0.4358259141,
0.1654263139,
-0.3979976177,
-0.4799933136,
-0.2320110053,
-0.0767519921,
-0.2416649163,
0.4954961836,
0.9247261882,
-0.0412153639,
0.7162824869,
0.4959467649,
-0.0520071089,
0.5465732813,
-0.3699198365,
0.8701308966,
-0.1733845025,
-0.5350036621,
-0.9522489905,
0.6981573105,
-0.0772248283,
-0.5146742463,
0.7560749054,
0.4181861877,
0.82684201,
-0.3099224865,
0.5913141966,
0.0997950435,
0.0473669767,
-0.7083956599,
0.8521126509,
-0.7776481509,
0.1673881263,
-0.2338994741,
-0.8685906529,
0.0051793209,
0.2996274829,
-0.5695762634,
0.3121342957,
0.3282807767,
0.6992428899,
-0.5394436121,
-0.0300344508,
0.3627535403,
0.3771807849,
0.1705417782,
0.1942131668,
1.0422050953,
0.1172790229,
0.3593194485,
-0.1749608964,
-0.1775489151,
-0.798330307,
-0.5840143561,
-1.1025674343,
-0.5076239109,
-0.2418510169,
0.3365133703,
-0.1928423643,
0.8300984502,
0.9773083925,
-0.7503297329,
-0.0415497534,
-0.0497791618,
0.0881198794,
-0.0263555199,
-0.1970397979,
-0.0310232602,
-0.3327362537,
-0.8553849459,
0.3606721461,
0.4118320942,
-0.374353677,
-0.3850495815,
-0.0571574979,
0.0249239411,
0.24948892,
0.5008456111,
-0.0914264247,
-0.8636782765,
-0.018005114,
-0.202150628,
0.0497603975,
-0.0390378237,
0.83562994,
-0.244186461,
0.515807569,
0.7293142676,
0.8121849895,
-0.0277679842,
-0.0899478048,
0.7914453149,
-0.7457556129,
0.169525966,
0.0868956223,
0.6024597287,
-0.0276705883,
-0.3140961826,
-0.0596609823,
0.0763011128,
-0.5386310816,
-0.9854168892,
0.2001457214,
-0.9992340207,
-0.3337962031,
1.1874923706,
-0.0665667579,
0.0411139503,
-0.1150606051,
-0.458476156,
-0.2175490409,
-0.7107035518,
0.7779422998,
1.0733106136,
-0.0234661903,
-0.1038491875,
-0.561997354,
-0.1090676114,
0.6191706657,
-0.3169812262,
-0.2165427655,
0.2761920691,
0.3295796514,
0.1397100836,
0.349416554,
0.1522139758,
0.0505584143,
-0.0408801883,
-0.1508033425,
-0.3084700406,
-0.434473604,
-0.305555284,
0.2306276411,
0.18626526,
-0.201785177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18200v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18200v1 | SEED: Accelerating Reasoning Tree Construction via Scheduled Speculative Decoding | 2024-06-26T09:33:41 | 2024-06-26T09:33:41 | Zhenglin Wang, Jialong Wu, Yilong Lai, Congzhi Zhang, Deyu Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate remarkable emergent abilities across
various tasks, yet fall short of complex reasoning and planning tasks. The
tree-search-based reasoning methods address this by surpassing the capabilities
of chain-of-thought prompting, encouraging exploration of intermediate steps.
However, such methods introduce significant inference latency due to the
systematic exploration and evaluation of multiple thought paths. This paper
introduces SeeD, a novel and efficient inference framework to optimize runtime
speed and GPU memory management concurrently. By employing a scheduled
speculative execution, SeeD efficiently handles multiple iterations for the
thought generation and the state evaluation, leveraging a rounds-scheduled
strategy to manage draft model dispatching. Extensive experimental evaluations
on three reasoning datasets demonstrate superior speedup performance of SeeD,
providing a viable path for batched inference in training-free speculative
decoding. | [
-0.0629541427,
-0.789940536,
0.7939617038,
0.5463762283,
-0.2537224889,
0.4502793252,
-0.0799843967,
-0.3327401578,
0.0288378131,
0.3641153276,
-0.836204052,
-0.2825222909,
-0.4805639088,
-0.1583884656,
-0.4679891467,
0.4270909727,
-0.1253097802,
-0.3893459439,
-0.2106918246,
0.2368446887,
-0.2438600361,
-0.2057793587,
-0.8324369192,
-0.0736434981,
0.296292752,
0.1627296507,
0.6294654608,
1.1758116484,
0.1776061654,
0.1861331612,
-0.0334419534,
0.2984715402,
-0.6356002092,
0.393489629,
-0.0257945322,
-0.5267783999,
-0.1498524845,
-0.0389367566,
0.6350304484,
0.5578770638,
-0.2044663578,
0.1484867632,
-0.4827613533,
0.32604146,
-1.0268362761,
0.1415252239,
-0.9369812012,
0.2610127628,
-0.317178756,
-0.8094317317,
-0.7786753178,
-0.3582820594,
-0.344132334,
-0.882838726,
0.4260017574,
0.3353677094,
0.5301254988,
0.4199393392,
-0.0871028155,
0.0349200889,
-0.8148831725,
0.7852210999,
-0.5738720894,
0.3724933267,
0.0723198578,
0.3616623282,
-0.4517048597,
-0.6722801924,
-0.3618626893,
0.0397921689,
0.1369785517,
0.1351221502,
-0.0404250249,
0.2403133661,
0.6153097153,
0.4375481904,
-0.4221101403,
-0.0963801518,
0.0178797655,
-0.093674615,
0.3804908693,
0.1486821324,
0.1535521746,
-0.004005834,
-0.1048227772,
-0.0742437243,
-0.8427185416,
-0.0189863369,
0.3954766691,
0.1494794935,
0.2257739305,
0.4874919057,
-0.3409907818,
0.8460358381,
-0.0612541325,
-0.1576305032,
-0.2414412349,
-0.3726458251,
-0.3526924849,
0.103878893,
0.7248858809,
0.151664272,
-0.0741926357,
-0.3316739202,
-0.0583009087,
0.5566378236,
0.1137036681,
-0.9960574508,
-0.2593843937,
0.4005796909,
-0.3678457141,
-0.3804462254,
-0.4035406113,
-0.5564332008,
-0.28407076,
0.2334897965,
-0.2970850468,
-0.7308464646,
-0.2018521726,
0.2510631084,
-0.3720507324,
0.2071019858,
0.383490473,
-0.9547611475,
0.1782540679,
0.9212630987,
0.6693047285,
-0.0563939512,
-0.0018920717,
-0.650344491,
0.3259405196,
-0.8585453629,
0.9294056892,
-0.8543427587,
-0.4981926084,
-0.3844744563,
-0.3023300469,
-0.2758499682,
-0.1110465527,
0.7192289829,
-0.6867981553,
-0.0039955527,
-0.1865275055,
-0.6730057597,
-0.0287376232,
0.1555638462,
-0.2925741673,
1.1731761694,
-0.0054850318,
-0.9655209184,
0.6811054945,
-0.4348410368,
-0.5763518214,
0.3798396587,
-0.4228757024,
0.1016839594,
0.2134912163,
0.6147719622,
0.495433569,
-0.4704360068,
0.3784822524,
-0.3315281272,
-0.5158560276,
-0.2884679437,
-0.4392108619,
0.6557376385,
0.4695835114,
-0.3173657656,
0.280179441,
-0.5441091061,
0.4078983665,
0.3410130739,
-0.0314001553,
-0.3312934041,
0.5900284648,
-0.3959081769,
0.0465982482,
-0.0730697066,
-0.5029082298,
0.6006273627,
-0.3178012967,
0.512568891,
0.7112132907,
0.1102761254,
0.2193498611,
-0.1950172782,
0.6430683136,
0.0769449398,
0.1408126205,
-0.6170042157,
-0.5255169272,
-0.8574142456,
-0.0311250221,
-0.1735185385,
0.481929034,
-0.8775184751,
0.1242188364,
-0.3754459918,
-0.5403776765,
-0.5233255625,
-0.1520449817,
0.3219701648,
0.2657474577,
0.1854493469,
0.2776859999,
-0.7525953054,
-0.6285339594,
-0.3665561974,
-0.1311548203,
0.3856300414,
0.4219915271,
0.1891690493,
-0.0884756595,
0.7531368136,
-0.5766921639,
0.5517985225,
-0.3386031091,
0.1038506553,
0.4187868237,
0.3782997429,
0.2599990368,
-0.376229912,
-0.1776066422,
-0.1892396212,
-0.7484744787,
0.0312539451,
-0.4997484088,
-0.259581387,
0.041337572,
0.5581935644,
-0.7383454442,
0.1653073281,
0.4701580107,
-0.4303989112,
0.6295560002,
-0.1032933965,
0.2744826078,
-0.9702686071,
-0.0882666707,
-0.3753204048,
-0.1538683474,
-0.0776854679,
0.3370703757,
0.0105331931,
0.0527423471,
-0.2034933269,
0.3917379677,
-0.6572290659,
-0.1696105301,
-0.3141224086,
-0.2497439981,
-0.1746215671,
0.0768574178,
0.1080481485,
1.273329854,
0.6837124825,
-0.5202584267,
0.1423355788,
-0.2223220319,
-0.4132114053,
-0.155834049,
-0.2642856538,
0.363824755,
-0.0069276504,
0.4836318493,
-0.4460630715,
-0.1161252633,
0.1031028926,
-0.1731317639,
-0.0457232296,
-0.314899981,
-0.6773335934,
-0.760789454,
-0.0023543369,
0.5482174754,
0.5042617917,
-0.573150456,
0.4544123709,
0.0655336156,
0.1653602719,
-0.5553551316,
-0.2775316536,
0.1032442003,
-0.0763294548,
-0.6618237495,
0.3373177648,
0.1308248937,
-0.2570593953,
0.135724768,
-0.1975008994,
0.2160198539,
0.1371652633,
0.3025935292,
0.0329991318,
-0.3606035411,
-0.0630622283,
0.3607177734,
-0.2239262313,
0.1984559298,
-0.8615663052,
0.3907453418,
0.1217893958,
-0.4465746284,
0.0018928829,
0.3274733424,
0.4792807996,
0.0008255399,
0.5171776414,
0.1386837065,
-0.3104954958,
-0.6994762421,
-0.692322731,
-0.253711313,
-0.4104596078,
0.1237941831,
-0.5532903075,
-0.8226863742,
0.1591718644,
-0.4198562801,
0.2704741955,
0.473326236,
0.4172064662,
0.0730651841,
0.9128496051,
0.4677603245,
0.1388892531,
0.1472180784,
-0.3801843524,
0.1841561347,
-0.6267393231,
-0.1538617462,
-0.2484582365,
-0.0274132341,
-0.3184286952,
-1.2284924984,
-0.1068134308,
0.25707075,
-0.1034583077,
0.0955152288,
-0.5874801874,
0.6908470392,
0.5661506057,
-0.1388711184,
0.4398069084,
-0.0496695526,
-0.4335622489,
0.0294832848,
-0.9886415005,
-0.3610122502,
1.0498310328,
0.0716354772,
0.5870077014,
-0.4239017963,
0.5105942488,
0.0791957751,
0.3040596545,
-0.5792654157,
0.7308002114,
0.0597873963,
-0.5179868937,
-0.03214157,
-0.4141028821,
-0.4945330322,
0.3401849568,
-0.1537487656,
-0.9193376303,
-0.1196733341,
0.2518299222,
-0.5368232131,
0.830839932,
-0.6529937983,
0.5411168337,
-0.2598099113,
-0.5288459659,
-0.5831944942,
-0.2402719408,
0.8719402552,
0.0997480899,
0.0014510207,
-0.2506435215,
0.1563179642,
0.858725369,
-0.5060848594,
0.3714061677,
-0.091187194,
0.3341351748,
0.4544388354,
0.2591733932,
0.8053426147,
0.1373885423,
-0.0994718373,
-0.1080910563,
-0.0278483648,
-0.4388791919,
-0.6417298317,
0.8762502074,
-0.5826862454,
-0.8470567465,
-0.7169995308,
-0.9548482299,
-0.4458118379,
0.2050356418,
0.2517012358,
0.0411602333,
-0.163260296,
0.0643530861,
0.5963043571,
-0.2642123103,
0.589389801,
0.1800735295,
-0.4023876488,
-0.1494160444,
0.6184853911,
-0.2674340308,
0.1058241576,
0.5852052569,
0.1979546398,
-0.1405896693,
-0.9082099795,
-0.480365932,
0.0260521043,
-0.369989574,
-0.0325981602,
-1.0241259336,
-0.3276711404,
-0.2585389018,
-0.1798321754,
-0.4636484087,
-0.4627687931,
0.09391734,
-0.4086989462,
0.6283568144,
0.5280815363,
0.0882664993,
0.4863002598,
-0.5347428322,
0.2520912588,
-0.068911083,
0.2551585138,
0.1252755821,
-0.1392166466,
-0.0022587257,
-0.1829233319,
-0.2889054418,
-0.7346454263,
0.3043636978,
-0.1865867972,
0.438295126,
0.6931411624,
-0.092567347,
0.9170386195,
-0.4865522087,
0.4139983952,
0.0882822871,
-0.5767445564,
0.7453427315,
-0.4777764976,
0.3341339529,
0.2164126337,
0.1871675253,
-0.3310063481,
-0.340786159,
-0.8420079947,
-0.7390323877,
0.6737561226,
0.3037822247,
-0.3656091392,
-0.1820725501,
0.2710318267,
0.0804766268,
0.0060270275,
-0.2046512514,
-0.2092489302,
-0.0087873889,
0.401022613,
-0.0295470376,
-0.5335786939,
-0.0487617105,
-0.488761127,
0.6860047579,
-0.2021672279,
0.2409849614,
-0.1208061725,
0.1950615644,
-0.1316416562,
0.3474922478,
0.3496787548,
0.5258051753,
-0.4168100059,
0.2152058333,
0.0339492932,
-0.4043394029,
0.229309842,
0.2001468241,
-0.5505481362,
-0.1313054413,
0.3803254962,
1.0300744772,
0.2427432239,
-0.5058779716,
0.0115472833,
-0.1622776985,
-0.1696538031,
-0.1013884321,
0.3470696509,
0.360632658,
0.1095725149,
0.4395321012,
0.2786319852,
0.0051440434,
-0.2441813797,
0.1310928017,
0.345972389,
-0.0415404737,
-0.1459483653,
0.801589787,
0.1142409071,
0.0126622329,
0.9317548871,
-0.4816328883,
-0.2538925409,
0.6097097397,
0.7742883563,
1.1267844439,
0.0999507383,
0.1381545514,
0.4583515525,
0.440305531,
-0.1072988808,
0.5776911378,
-0.1895849407,
-0.7999354005,
-1.0093911886,
-0.7988874912,
-0.2993136644,
0.0880679041,
-0.1432239264,
-0.140645355,
-0.6674254537,
-0.0469788164,
-0.2491045147,
-0.084107101,
-0.5785949826,
0.0717236549,
-0.0091753257,
1.4526770115,
-0.6708304882,
1.0480670929,
0.4391773939,
0.0702219605,
-1.0972776413,
-0.1432874203,
-0.0074084569,
-0.7239560485,
0.6246745586,
0.310811758,
-0.1447360367,
0.1926607192,
-0.2258846611,
-0.9111514091,
1.0006719828,
0.4843057096,
-0.8385570645,
-0.2741093636,
-0.285430491,
0.1010422483,
-0.414311111,
0.6253141165,
0.6655970216,
0.3826908469,
0.6408205628,
-0.2693557441,
0.2279179245,
-0.2593457997,
-0.0178255197,
0.3807456791,
-0.2572264373,
0.6323994994,
-0.6303972602,
-0.5187238455,
-0.0378046297,
0.8302787542,
0.7325763702,
0.1663410515,
0.4763300419,
0.9350394607,
0.9823945165,
-0.3892178237,
1.3957577944,
-0.7383503914,
-0.0713238791,
1.1510365009,
-0.1434241831,
0.7000053525,
0.5249313116,
-0.2330881357,
0.4611666799,
0.9370896816,
0.2759672999,
0.4063974321,
0.2908339798,
-0.513117075,
-0.7124361992,
-0.1602653265,
-0.4224185646,
0.1093292758,
0.6627493501,
-0.2211406082,
-0.3865455985,
-0.4722748697,
0.0416250117,
-0.170200631,
-0.2519571781,
0.2934325635,
0.1094456166,
-0.9998304844,
0.352019757,
-0.0013479047,
0.5024057627,
-0.6339963078,
-0.0655457452,
-0.0839617327,
0.3127305806,
-0.0615165532,
-0.4649259448,
0.4071258008,
-0.0513499714,
-0.24912332,
-0.5499598384,
0.5236278772,
0.1145671159,
-0.7579215765,
0.2516061068,
0.4888561368,
0.0275697783,
-0.2011699677,
-0.6962683201,
0.1719439924,
-0.2066069543,
-0.3164617717,
0.0283429362,
0.5600617528,
-0.4120932817,
0.8922080994,
1.1644160748,
0.3781686425,
0.3246757388,
0.0103272554,
0.9763323665,
-0.8517917395,
-0.6344056129,
-0.9262322187,
-0.0429149531,
-0.1139300391,
-0.0741830096,
0.8715826869,
0.8763868809,
0.490308255,
-0.0373779349,
0.8857353926,
-0.1377485245,
0.1862942278,
-0.6416738033,
0.383461982,
0.0507248938,
0.3012858629,
-0.1334336251,
-0.8345236778,
-0.0283898991,
0.3604031801,
-0.5169630647,
-0.0627069548,
1.0142647028,
0.6753312945,
-0.1109585166,
0.3423264623,
0.2383269072,
0.3286052346,
0.4535999,
0.9595048428,
0.8940765262,
-0.098624438,
0.2942400277,
-0.3046038747,
-0.322268784,
0.1251281798,
-1.3165266514,
-0.7076755762,
-0.139391467,
-0.1645495296,
-0.2512530386,
0.4856833518,
0.7998383641,
0.9454301,
-0.7386177778,
-0.2667922676,
-0.724540472,
0.1471498609,
-0.4881723225,
-0.2492582053,
0.3429215848,
-0.4239014387,
-0.389890343,
0.8823353052,
0.5721479654,
-0.318012923,
-0.2567453682,
-0.0091943387,
-0.2968839705,
0.1265558749,
0.471732378,
0.3726540804,
-0.8538985848,
0.0190046038,
0.1027948111,
0.1020765007,
-0.197112456,
1.2286674976,
-1.2459022999,
0.6224777102,
0.5732291937,
0.7885023355,
0.79224509,
0.1131866276,
0.8153792024,
-0.3493514657,
0.4850594997,
0.3608810604,
0.4528992772,
0.1576337814,
-0.4992157519,
0.4545637965,
0.6376913786,
-0.1488190293,
-0.6431047916,
0.1500400007,
-0.8734228611,
-0.3165804446,
1.1170493364,
-0.0044455798,
-0.297491163,
0.2249490023,
0.0910079554,
0.1250151396,
-0.4304669797,
0.5080730319,
0.5604228973,
-0.1917254478,
-0.347525686,
-0.6537054181,
0.6244343519,
0.2352268249,
-0.8263759017,
0.2567237616,
0.37743783,
-0.0679108873,
-0.0563113578,
0.9317184091,
0.1675212532,
0.0926218033,
0.5185513496,
-0.141518116,
-0.2823964655,
-0.4423572719,
0.3788127601,
0.3464131355,
0.0797645673,
-0.1427836567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18192v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18192v2 | Methodology of Adapting Large English Language Models for Specific Cultural Contexts | 2024-06-26T09:16:08 | 2024-06-27T02:17:19 | Wenjing Zhang, Siqi Xiao, Xuejiao Lei, Ning Wang, Huazheng Zhang, Meijuan An, Bikun Yang, Zhaoxiang Liu, Kai Wang, Shiguo Lian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The rapid growth of large language models(LLMs) has emerged as a prominent
trend in the field of artificial intelligence. However, current
state-of-the-art LLMs are predominantly based on English. They encounter
limitations when directly applied to tasks in specific cultural domains, due to
deficiencies in domain-specific knowledge and misunderstandings caused by
differences in cultural values. To address this challenge, our paper proposes a
rapid adaptation method for large models in specific cultural contexts, which
leverages instruction-tuning based on specific cultural knowledge and safety
values data. Taking Chinese as the specific cultural context and utilizing the
LLaMA3-8B as the experimental English LLM, the evaluation results demonstrate
that the adapted LLM significantly enhances its capabilities in domain-specific
knowledge and adaptability to safety values, while maintaining its original
expertise advantages. | [
0.0535555929,
-0.7291381955,
0.4028074443,
0.3827759326,
-0.1116352752,
0.0492639765,
-0.5911028981,
-0.3882403076,
-0.0347950235,
0.4363151491,
-0.425837189,
-0.4844188392,
-0.334830761,
0.2177741379,
-0.0617886111,
0.8505700827,
-0.2884915769,
0.156618312,
0.2009369731,
-0.1997571737,
-0.5868813396,
-0.4060459435,
-0.7122516036,
-0.0448869914,
0.3088251948,
0.5753544569,
0.6174928546,
0.8621539474,
0.4811317027,
0.305762589,
-0.0659980848,
0.2823322415,
-0.5155259967,
-0.1756598353,
-0.4857951701,
-0.4787921607,
-0.5617103577,
-0.1349489242,
0.6941424608,
0.5125997663,
-0.0786174536,
0.2048127502,
0.0792595297,
0.2463065237,
-0.5666896701,
0.1795776933,
-0.8761066794,
0.1466494203,
0.0931742564,
-0.5131971836,
-0.6700729728,
-0.2796718478,
0.1752180457,
-0.8508147597,
-0.2596003115,
0.0932534933,
0.5261583924,
0.260494113,
-0.5834051967,
-0.2842668891,
-0.8038557172,
1.0330553055,
-0.7484630942,
0.2243784368,
0.2941522002,
0.3086594641,
-0.3333591819,
-0.4454525411,
-0.4473985434,
-0.2735612094,
0.0751776323,
-0.0383860469,
0.400816977,
-0.2852169871,
0.0931844488,
-0.2660765052,
-0.3995267153,
0.6334249973,
-0.3007170856,
-0.1110349745,
1.0034022331,
0.4044530988,
0.5018997788,
0.1273977757,
-0.2612961531,
-0.1511054635,
-0.7225114703,
0.1471579373,
-0.1504779607,
0.4013870358,
-0.4769794047,
-0.1479753107,
-0.1899322569,
0.568567574,
-0.0074287746,
-0.8149265647,
0.332349658,
-0.1088604182,
-0.1284780055,
0.147752583,
0.4325945675,
0.481341511,
0.5713401437,
0.0279204585,
-0.1255499274,
-0.4020521939,
0.0173400473,
-0.8030971289,
0.0215660334,
0.015969919,
-0.408005178,
-0.0940903053,
-0.336836338,
-0.4795170128,
-0.4893286824,
-0.2617531121,
0.5420776606,
-0.3629607856,
-0.1633308232,
0.0929269791,
0.2217700481,
0.6559799314,
0.3670924604,
-0.8967785239,
-0.1507744193,
0.4092423618,
0.7445393801,
-0.3382422626,
-0.4954145551,
-0.3476328254,
0.4889235198,
-0.6355016232,
0.5498163104,
-0.5813241005,
-0.4070132077,
0.043823678,
0.4797360003,
0.0236947909,
-0.3674978614,
0.5182472467,
-0.6226688623,
0.0221057311,
-0.1925908178,
-0.1451274753,
-0.3656722903,
0.2517051101,
-0.4056063294,
0.6719338894,
-0.0582153387,
-0.4583911896,
0.3068394065,
-0.7766253948,
-0.9545924067,
0.1736402065,
0.015898006,
-0.121156916,
-0.160706684,
0.3157470226,
0.6352866888,
-0.338824749,
0.1465785205,
-0.2262567729,
-0.6224222183,
0.0736257434,
-0.410320878,
0.9966763258,
0.1835789979,
-0.3367435336,
0.2129948437,
-0.7848310471,
0.1182631627,
0.3622288704,
-0.4558830559,
-0.5276316404,
0.30153808,
-0.159648031,
0.1617602706,
0.3638927042,
-0.0375876836,
0.0265262295,
-0.2543465197,
0.5973077416,
1.00474298,
-0.0758218616,
0.4937986732,
-0.359559983,
0.5154978633,
0.0434381478,
0.1293968856,
-0.2598020732,
-0.0927202031,
-0.8677726984,
-0.1996875405,
0.0739767849,
1.0716013908,
-0.8544586301,
0.4600353539,
-0.2838760018,
-0.4221399128,
-0.4479220808,
0.2814814746,
0.1042815521,
0.4311211407,
0.1967698038,
-0.2841531634,
-0.4187938273,
-0.7067892551,
-0.1630949825,
-0.2038958818,
-0.1820851862,
0.3478429019,
0.3468618691,
-0.1909650415,
0.4865642488,
-0.2862772644,
-0.0090576401,
-0.1153592542,
-0.1949089468,
0.2618734241,
0.4207564592,
0.6387491822,
-0.6134184003,
-0.5762773752,
0.2834117115,
-0.8829623461,
-0.0658252537,
-0.2702784538,
-0.4221955538,
0.3673103452,
0.5048267841,
-0.0116246631,
0.100982219,
0.6617075205,
-0.2655105889,
0.4115060568,
-0.2607132792,
0.2703573704,
-1.3453731537,
-0.1928914636,
0.0534176193,
-0.060295932,
-0.7060954571,
0.2458651215,
0.3597797751,
0.0800520927,
-0.8041036129,
0.7420181036,
-0.4009422362,
0.1667087376,
-0.331528306,
0.0584597848,
-0.1770315766,
0.3400783539,
0.382548362,
0.8078427911,
0.6278948188,
-0.863825798,
0.2142635137,
0.175887078,
-0.432048887,
0.5344876647,
-0.3929621279,
0.2878285646,
-0.1914781332,
0.1707635373,
-0.4786567688,
-0.4360921979,
-0.0956333876,
0.1020292714,
0.147378996,
-0.0191581454,
-0.1517128199,
-0.1278730184,
-0.1711383015,
0.3150942922,
0.8128483891,
-0.6232216954,
0.8340255022,
0.221035555,
-0.5126288533,
-0.5078527927,
-0.5370646119,
0.0420970134,
-0.6051681638,
-0.7453060746,
0.318062216,
-0.3719831705,
-0.3463402092,
-0.3634832501,
0.0538588949,
-0.0832619146,
0.4858829081,
-0.051678244,
0.2454109192,
-0.5094757676,
-0.0327776484,
0.1760129929,
0.1962852478,
0.1210399941,
-0.0200804882,
0.2103298753,
0.0395435058,
0.0541288257,
-0.4710929096,
0.3133112192,
0.6829308271,
-0.3326033056,
0.9186738133,
0.4471342266,
-0.3526680171,
-0.7584552169,
-0.2869665325,
-0.3367466927,
-0.5909116268,
0.8556749225,
-0.4126504362,
-0.8408989906,
0.4534943402,
-0.2042590827,
0.2387376428,
0.1160052195,
0.7856977582,
-0.0586682335,
0.9440185428,
0.8888641596,
-0.3326209188,
0.5067449212,
0.2617633939,
0.2885612845,
-0.5517975688,
-0.1252195239,
-0.4732806683,
-0.3858606517,
-0.5976404548,
-0.4846668541,
0.6624937654,
-0.156720072,
-0.6881884933,
0.0414746478,
-0.1459572315,
0.5670740008,
0.1926667988,
0.0613287985,
0.2243323475,
0.038145747,
0.0973636657,
0.146353066,
-0.7647511959,
-0.6052493453,
0.9871032834,
0.4386651814,
0.7753075361,
0.2666133344,
0.1661231369,
0.2461284846,
0.5769609213,
-0.7202137709,
0.5893220305,
-0.3699599504,
-0.3964927793,
-0.245639801,
-0.2870241106,
-0.5991612673,
0.0768166333,
-0.2830410302,
-0.6148144007,
-0.3122069836,
-0.001140274,
-0.3991903663,
0.13571769,
-0.842805326,
0.6966581345,
-0.7390401363,
-0.142040357,
-0.1591880769,
-0.4270485044,
0.4502229393,
-0.6378425956,
0.6936574578,
-0.310513258,
-0.109658286,
0.8135643601,
0.1031671315,
0.9690704346,
-0.1545361429,
-0.3505553305,
0.1419248134,
0.1966306865,
0.7110863328,
-0.1142584458,
-0.4600332081,
0.1405626535,
-0.0363144837,
-0.5169380903,
-0.5218669176,
0.7896057367,
-1.1066138744,
-1.0275439024,
-0.02797601,
-1.1247751713,
-0.5059028268,
0.1640364975,
-0.2125508636,
-0.0435809679,
-0.0933883488,
0.1128734052,
0.5003687739,
-0.7131422162,
0.6439617872,
1.0642608404,
0.056184642,
-0.0375848822,
0.6848929524,
0.0975125954,
0.2885867357,
0.3062203825,
0.3122462332,
0.0955263674,
-0.6435436606,
-0.5370596051,
0.1538507491,
-0.889283061,
0.0008027958,
-0.1967685223,
-0.2806700766,
-0.3004132509,
-0.5928290486,
-0.1073971838,
-0.0486674309,
-0.2896607816,
-0.0442119129,
0.6445040107,
0.4209501147,
0.3782468438,
0.2616787255,
-0.7878099084,
0.0661629066,
0.187954545,
0.2577625215,
-0.040530894,
-1.1821783781,
-0.5255352259,
-0.1201644689,
-0.0374758653,
-0.63594383,
0.359000653,
0.3537056148,
0.6027392745,
0.3494420946,
0.2814126015,
0.6850244999,
-0.7503292561,
0.7878989577,
-0.230644092,
-0.9018452764,
0.4770013988,
-0.2563197613,
0.2913703024,
0.1371276379,
0.7513524294,
-0.4869267046,
-0.0337209553,
0.1021412835,
-0.8610883355,
0.6221984625,
-0.4407439232,
0.5454682112,
0.1512112767,
0.4971158206,
0.1224317551,
-0.3784375191,
-0.773293376,
0.163036257,
-0.0713461787,
-0.4373394847,
-0.0870403424,
-0.0033559203,
-0.1911163777,
-0.1805323958,
0.8976265788,
-0.5076004863,
-0.179590717,
-0.2310258895,
-0.4037750661,
-0.0176415276,
0.3942203224,
0.5854136348,
0.7943091393,
0.0879364312,
-0.0974183157,
0.9668207765,
-0.4375428557,
0.4384406209,
-0.1897646189,
-0.246043697,
-0.6202782393,
0.455757916,
0.7190514207,
0.0836022794,
-0.9254931808,
0.1023376808,
0.1678173989,
0.1102933809,
-0.4682802558,
0.4261286557,
0.0913367569,
0.3644387126,
0.4551946819,
-0.5333884358,
-0.2968676388,
-0.6928902268,
0.016850898,
0.2588415742,
-0.0724403262,
-0.2482286245,
0.584633708,
0.5945453048,
-0.4206523895,
0.4265165627,
-0.0145303383,
-0.3110639155,
0.80287534,
0.9272705317,
0.6586560011,
-0.5981226563,
-0.0588476285,
0.3191352785,
0.4680080712,
-0.0758170784,
0.3317374587,
0.5154741406,
-1.0689364672,
-0.8101232052,
-0.5286175013,
-0.2820130587,
0.2423576415,
-0.5029027462,
0.4298905134,
-0.837970674,
0.2251371145,
-0.2954686582,
-0.1696923822,
-0.7177975178,
0.4526111484,
0.2205978334,
1.1710983515,
-0.9784443974,
1.0893828869,
0.8516709805,
0.1753198951,
-1.0552821159,
0.1991785318,
0.154078722,
-1.0279411077,
0.61795187,
-0.1108902544,
-0.1480105519,
-0.0341481008,
-0.4696778059,
-1.0478913784,
1.352312088,
0.447507143,
-0.7666774988,
0.1208374053,
0.000523856,
0.5142856836,
-0.6999144554,
0.05209269,
0.9527064562,
0.383554846,
-0.2260518968,
-1.1450152397,
0.2355289012,
-0.1843653768,
0.1764908731,
-0.1449451894,
-0.950696826,
0.496286124,
-0.2882797122,
0.0880221128,
0.0068516028,
0.7373802066,
0.3654474914,
0.044127699,
0.6376500726,
0.0092852814,
0.8304142356,
0.1900465786,
0.8867704868,
-0.5761543512,
-0.1747166961,
0.8732199669,
-0.6913992763,
0.9843441248,
0.1721695811,
0.0565749258,
0.6167324781,
0.5262601972,
0.1313813925,
0.4395632148,
0.0548682734,
-0.2531809211,
-0.2507751882,
-0.3140117526,
-0.2690740824,
0.8057162762,
0.5258708,
-0.413834393,
0.2992963195,
0.0056198095,
0.4426974058,
0.0522197187,
-0.7346445918,
0.6173482537,
-0.0249844417,
-0.6075340509,
0.8610088825,
0.4629619718,
0.6721066236,
-0.6010958552,
0.1335168481,
-0.3759000003,
0.0889280736,
-0.1244703531,
-0.5378761888,
0.0190801024,
0.2615485191,
-0.242097348,
-0.0736424997,
0.4673885405,
-0.2679288983,
-0.6596993208,
0.3667458296,
0.1794957221,
0.0206289236,
0.5969768763,
-0.4387792945,
0.2578131855,
0.1251122952,
-0.2488784194,
0.4210729003,
0.5363723636,
-0.5661635995,
0.7014505863,
0.3788847327,
0.0138589423,
-0.1334630251,
-0.0775338411,
0.5673177242,
-0.9541884661,
-0.6021556258,
-0.6505774856,
0.527583003,
0.2547962964,
-0.0967015922,
0.6345504522,
-0.0078442041,
0.9693061113,
-0.1354185343,
1.1658535004,
0.1298879683,
0.2105783224,
-0.7975361943,
0.8259660602,
-0.5692952275,
0.4180413485,
-0.1008727401,
-0.8237019777,
-0.1639417559,
0.7059862614,
-0.435239166,
0.1772413254,
0.6589929461,
0.8579944968,
0.0161166135,
-0.1045980975,
0.4127140939,
0.6191355586,
0.1103090942,
0.8662627339,
0.675804317,
-0.0272816718,
0.4693341553,
-0.1419157386,
-0.5150486827,
-0.1775258332,
-1.3393720388,
-0.9173772931,
-0.3021562696,
-0.3809871972,
-0.0869780257,
0.1475020796,
1.1235512495,
0.8177728653,
-0.9011002183,
-0.2611006498,
0.8048067093,
-0.0919070318,
-0.2934968174,
-0.1910082102,
0.4504824281,
-0.1853405237,
-0.7702174783,
0.7386944294,
0.2664090395,
-0.0530018322,
-0.2187346965,
-0.336586535,
0.201298207,
0.5138625503,
0.7880443335,
0.2207958698,
-0.5519570708,
-0.8320138454,
-0.0351640768,
0.1088808924,
-0.1285514832,
0.6131690741,
-0.4175132811,
0.06509462,
0.1365893632,
0.8872644901,
-0.0275234096,
-0.2474177927,
0.638271451,
-0.5924946666,
0.6283474565,
0.009927501,
0.3588036001,
0.4695210457,
-0.4505571723,
0.3779999316,
-0.0019190795,
-0.5041487217,
-0.6434957981,
0.3090642691,
-0.7295164466,
-0.436355412,
1.3162127733,
-0.3367986977,
-0.2709496319,
-0.0154653098,
-0.0854103267,
0.1283759475,
-0.0537894815,
1.0531083345,
0.6297540069,
0.2248140126,
-0.2432424724,
-0.6308653951,
0.291454643,
0.5305228233,
-1.0264526606,
-0.0712554306,
0.1774747521,
0.6539341211,
-0.1838407516,
0.270195514,
0.1111390442,
0.4024347067,
-0.46200037,
0.0843199641,
0.1261903197,
-0.3756038547,
-0.3333874047,
0.0755220577,
0.4847995639,
0.2822419703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18187v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18187v1 | Selective Prompting Tuning for Personalized Conversations with LLMs | 2024-06-26T09:03:52 | 2024-06-26T09:03:52 | Qiushi Huang, Xubo Liu, Tom Ko, Bo Wu, Wenwu Wang, Yu Zhang, Lilian Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In conversational AI, personalizing dialogues with persona profiles and
contextual understanding is essential. Despite large language models' (LLMs)
improved response coherence, effective persona integration remains a challenge.
In this work, we first study two common approaches for personalizing LLMs:
textual prompting and direct fine-tuning. We observed that textual prompting
often struggles to yield responses that are similar to the ground truths in
datasets, while direct fine-tuning tends to produce repetitive or overly
generic replies. To alleviate those issues, we propose \textbf{S}elective
\textbf{P}rompt \textbf{T}uning (SPT), which softly prompts LLMs for
personalized conversations in a selective way. Concretely, SPT initializes a
set of soft prompts and uses a trainable dense retriever to adaptively select
suitable soft prompts for LLMs according to different input contexts, where the
prompt retriever is dynamically updated through feedback from the LLMs.
Additionally, we propose context-prompt contrastive learning and prompt fusion
learning to encourage the SPT to enhance the diversity of personalized
conversations. Experiments on the CONVAI2 dataset demonstrate that SPT
significantly enhances response diversity by up to 90\%, along with
improvements in other critical performance indicators. Those results highlight
the efficacy of SPT in fostering engaging and personalized dialogue generation.
The SPT model code (https://github.com/hqsiswiliam/SPT) is publicly available
for further exploration. | [
-0.5343392491,
-1.0442461967,
0.6038656831,
0.3038438559,
-0.2940691113,
0.2606584728,
-0.5109554529,
0.00185389,
0.0362613872,
0.4517835379,
-0.9675542712,
-0.4064814448,
-0.1419815421,
0.1708418727,
0.0901464298,
1.1190855503,
0.2892703116,
0.1307539493,
-0.1488934457,
-0.1492800564,
-1.1172374487,
-0.1437896192,
-0.8422459364,
-0.4076326191,
0.7647798657,
0.7737226486,
0.4505124986,
0.3544526398,
0.138250351,
0.3172938526,
-0.1347536147,
0.5539911389,
-0.6589038372,
0.6235079765,
-0.3750719726,
-0.3306929767,
-0.1643698961,
-0.2848915458,
0.4887705445,
0.714771986,
-0.0392493047,
-0.1846310794,
0.4462761581,
0.4949144125,
-0.4668554068,
0.0191037543,
-0.6826482415,
0.0568152778,
-0.0822192505,
-0.4506871104,
-0.5983998179,
-0.2847831845,
0.518396616,
-0.5355843306,
0.1160664186,
-0.0300658215,
0.5037637949,
0.3880932331,
-0.391821593,
-0.3265259564,
-0.8287548423,
0.7650054693,
-0.2665906549,
0.1204199046,
0.1595115066,
0.3638038933,
-0.1657471806,
-0.5305768251,
-0.1957027167,
-0.2997492552,
-0.0682358816,
0.3486673832,
-0.1024604291,
0.2175075859,
0.1008739546,
0.3463217318,
-0.4577157199,
0.3934597969,
-0.0458797924,
-0.0560246967,
0.4617740512,
0.4853638411,
0.0102187498,
0.0077189165,
-0.2577912211,
0.0074586333,
-0.5072793961,
0.2193820179,
0.3336908519,
0.4516053498,
-0.249527812,
0.4284166992,
-0.3609975874,
0.6707887053,
0.6311318278,
0.1231337786,
-0.0561540723,
-0.3506013751,
-0.2331083417,
-0.2183508873,
0.7808055282,
0.3914945126,
0.4603692591,
-0.1796260625,
0.0383147374,
-0.1861661524,
0.1290404648,
-0.7272012234,
-0.3209841549,
0.3737273514,
-0.2805013955,
-0.1655964106,
0.004219898,
-0.829107523,
-0.6281052232,
-0.4836997688,
0.0643194914,
-0.5351498127,
-0.0387006775,
0.0766723678,
-0.0131137352,
0.2150340974,
0.5149884224,
-1.0380386114,
0.0777036622,
0.6300976872,
0.5977531075,
-0.3349336088,
-0.1562782526,
-0.8118019104,
0.0447327867,
-0.0650535747,
1.0082185268,
-0.8484731913,
-0.6276280284,
0.125402391,
-0.181600228,
-0.1186574027,
-0.6861938834,
0.4808793068,
-0.2056048512,
0.5786893368,
-0.4745063782,
-0.5075426102,
0.0934100896,
0.1767469496,
-0.1507866532,
0.6874851584,
0.1363023967,
-0.5724669099,
0.364046365,
-0.6816663146,
-0.3410152197,
0.3929832876,
-0.3483146727,
-0.2954355776,
0.1889079958,
0.3381274045,
0.5180439949,
-0.2488426566,
0.5198969245,
-0.3019479811,
-0.4916557968,
0.3906372786,
-0.4077941179,
0.4388079345,
0.3656068742,
-0.2592939138,
0.6191979647,
-0.6588051915,
-0.0751728863,
0.0006905769,
-0.3007412851,
-0.0755708143,
-0.0583432317,
-0.1490664333,
-0.2148250192,
0.2942017317,
-0.3332164586,
0.1397249103,
-0.5444757342,
0.3710996509,
0.9677852988,
0.2615538538,
0.6165416837,
-0.5547136068,
0.3101392984,
0.2080474198,
-0.0695237517,
-0.6936790347,
-0.470308423,
-0.7366183996,
-0.400375545,
0.056261804,
0.7639094591,
-0.6975595951,
0.7329961658,
-0.1081819385,
-0.2796741724,
-0.4873121083,
0.1395577937,
0.3575046659,
0.6821747422,
0.2295277566,
-0.1412225664,
-0.4888138771,
-0.8896951675,
-0.4809106588,
0.0159364678,
-0.3820874095,
0.8775480986,
0.0006595223,
-0.1956744492,
1.2790629864,
-0.4746425748,
-0.0200955626,
-0.3716295063,
0.1199251786,
0.1223623529,
0.3936905265,
0.204809472,
-0.6750638485,
-0.7999874949,
-0.0875265002,
-0.5398774147,
-0.3950005174,
-0.4395934343,
-0.0752220824,
-0.1399195492,
0.1328673959,
-0.474150449,
0.1374610513,
0.1312192976,
-0.2716399729,
0.2032397687,
-0.1957684308,
0.1426268667,
-1.3175936937,
-0.0754638687,
0.1324964762,
-0.221843034,
-0.7839036584,
-0.2090302408,
-0.211888805,
-0.1508493423,
-0.4490912557,
0.7135466337,
-0.2604933977,
0.1621259302,
-0.1897770911,
0.1387440413,
-0.1261811256,
0.6495285034,
0.0321922526,
0.8849203587,
0.4861973226,
-0.8194366097,
0.2962919176,
0.6768275499,
-0.1966259629,
0.9366585016,
-0.9097421765,
0.5107843876,
-0.3015827835,
0.4609526098,
-1.1558455229,
-0.3689652383,
0.3827708662,
-0.1930597723,
0.1392736733,
0.0119151669,
-0.2494029999,
0.1033377349,
-0.3006504178,
0.1299902797,
0.4752604961,
-0.7801667452,
0.6054819226,
0.0864694491,
-0.4465877414,
-0.1083257124,
-0.338228941,
0.0291248076,
-0.3874200881,
-0.8438298702,
0.3232069314,
-0.6658099294,
-0.1865575761,
-0.6173092723,
0.139976427,
0.1719274968,
0.066789493,
0.2251267433,
0.0924886838,
-0.0665290877,
-0.0512174591,
0.3731154203,
-0.2337598652,
-0.3578754365,
-0.1193975806,
0.8667457104,
-0.125718832,
-0.1616860479,
-0.8188955188,
0.4726126492,
0.3643967211,
-0.2926130593,
0.5787392259,
0.68080163,
0.0520682856,
-0.0345509574,
-0.6278296113,
-0.5217455626,
-0.5321656466,
0.1914099455,
-0.6044408679,
-1.3127552271,
0.6217791438,
-0.2577831745,
0.214107573,
-0.0959096029,
0.8334128857,
-0.1835796088,
1.2540557384,
0.3077092171,
0.0694385916,
0.9006504416,
0.0848228633,
0.0214621983,
-0.8355281353,
-0.4170469642,
-0.4080891311,
-0.4559390247,
-0.5780117512,
-0.1547141224,
0.2772885561,
-0.334105283,
-0.4494744837,
-0.1061342582,
-0.6303374171,
0.5948867798,
0.5816276073,
0.3512634933,
0.1376964897,
0.1342067719,
0.1009231359,
-0.3916285038,
-0.5068556666,
-0.2796427011,
0.6642751098,
0.3902282715,
0.8161611557,
-0.0278311856,
0.7346436381,
-0.0048642429,
0.0079451026,
-0.7684842944,
0.5705151558,
-0.1927600354,
-0.2507893145,
-0.0544081926,
-0.4740864933,
-1.1723810434,
0.180889681,
-0.2405240089,
-0.9613485932,
0.1848506182,
0.2058871239,
-0.8013912439,
-0.2429019064,
-0.8271994591,
0.6486189365,
-0.0328673087,
-0.3771955073,
-0.1367866397,
-0.6911741495,
0.1317018867,
0.1469414681,
-0.3859751821,
-0.1174746081,
0.0313806571,
0.2797409892,
-0.0215026997,
1.1534321308,
-0.1869564652,
-0.034906745,
0.1030394509,
0.1867296845,
0.6996716857,
0.4247963428,
0.0159097333,
-0.3379163146,
-0.1684725732,
-0.3537832201,
-0.7115080953,
0.7921838164,
-0.7282437682,
-0.7243154049,
-0.1116485372,
-0.5926146507,
-0.4890066683,
0.0528424159,
0.4820708334,
0.3634752035,
-0.3802525401,
0.3992840946,
1.1131304502,
-0.48458305,
0.1866730601,
0.7325503826,
0.2292283326,
-0.5068203807,
0.8446501493,
-0.3351908326,
0.0944151506,
0.4846159816,
0.4831373096,
-0.3238065243,
-0.3714942932,
-0.3436385393,
0.0995835885,
-0.4222095311,
-0.2008556575,
-0.7266712785,
0.0295410939,
-0.3955646753,
-0.2950378358,
-0.0759458691,
0.0225354508,
-0.7378434539,
0.0579114817,
0.3781057894,
0.5187425613,
0.4528520107,
0.6473324895,
-0.738751471,
0.2199303508,
0.4029039741,
0.2437127084,
-0.3698044419,
-0.6436540484,
0.1468399167,
0.1362240165,
-0.3934192955,
-0.7542641759,
0.1551465541,
0.3500603139,
0.4472979605,
0.4093311727,
0.1265348941,
0.6701472998,
-0.4629402459,
0.8472064734,
0.0599460006,
-0.6889178157,
0.8932301998,
-0.7328287363,
0.7094500661,
0.9387024045,
0.0954896286,
-0.6213744283,
-0.432567507,
-0.4612390995,
-0.7055221796,
0.781160593,
-0.0855994523,
0.5369409919,
-0.0359982997,
0.4837090075,
0.3289488554,
0.2001795024,
-0.4129495919,
-0.1475597173,
0.0534014031,
-0.4761781991,
-0.0251289643,
-0.2650630772,
-0.2958751619,
-0.227205798,
0.248307392,
-0.3999375105,
0.1315882653,
0.0675844699,
0.1420707554,
-0.0794057995,
0.2999746203,
0.6460610032,
0.439104259,
-0.0557964519,
-0.203544274,
0.2241569906,
-0.0744096935,
-0.1508558542,
-0.0313819647,
-0.2463439703,
-0.128345266,
-0.1421429664,
1.1293042898,
0.4464254677,
-0.4949922562,
0.3016837537,
-0.3869594336,
-0.0101195704,
-0.1481840312,
0.4330916405,
-0.085484013,
0.3235248625,
0.1281913221,
0.1008874476,
0.0985487625,
-0.4084550142,
-0.0001508335,
0.4707018137,
-0.2458988577,
-0.2877613306,
0.5611212254,
0.6507762074,
-0.6386314034,
0.593708694,
0.087725006,
-0.1676662117,
0.1337643862,
0.4602808654,
0.9995860457,
-0.2942022681,
0.3862743676,
0.1802545786,
-0.2689462006,
0.0947795436,
0.1087603942,
-0.472401917,
-0.6290391684,
-0.1511972249,
-0.3084818721,
-0.5944410563,
0.2515066266,
-0.5067579746,
0.4240696132,
-0.6674937606,
0.0485927723,
-0.1493762583,
0.0992295519,
-0.5976133943,
0.0167838093,
0.0298374686,
0.7270659804,
-0.6434538364,
0.5526409149,
0.692481041,
-0.266449064,
-0.6076940894,
0.1858386397,
0.0503538698,
-0.7284253836,
0.1633016914,
0.1403830647,
-0.0385421216,
0.1795812696,
-0.5528734326,
-0.433003664,
1.0836914778,
0.6351276636,
-0.6131136417,
0.1082626283,
0.065647684,
0.4614318013,
-0.598254323,
0.3269244432,
0.6926639676,
0.3156653345,
0.4472221136,
-0.7628617287,
-0.0431828275,
-0.1094172895,
0.1787862629,
0.0173904262,
-1.0143803358,
0.4771903753,
0.0202190764,
-0.2078008056,
0.4023988545,
0.729026556,
0.5780158043,
0.4970377684,
0.5433276892,
0.0864675194,
0.9960620403,
-0.1314342767,
0.8377138376,
-0.3545704782,
-0.0456147455,
1.2008514404,
-0.3173007965,
0.492970705,
0.3517712653,
0.1627040952,
0.4126923978,
0.9319345951,
0.0779854655,
0.5047278404,
-0.0302837156,
-0.5869476199,
-0.266862154,
-0.3221479654,
-0.2304705828,
0.3687716722,
0.3350502551,
-0.3110301495,
0.0588133149,
0.1493644118,
-0.0547779053,
0.24269104,
-0.0618101843,
1.1555649042,
0.0262226984,
-1.1858648062,
0.4125998914,
-0.1863014698,
0.9437080622,
-0.6450659037,
0.1525998116,
-0.6710332632,
0.126279071,
-0.1593087167,
-0.751024127,
-0.0130841164,
0.0535839759,
-0.2771033347,
-0.5430417657,
0.6966207027,
-0.6757339239,
-0.103141509,
0.0235072933,
0.4520594478,
0.000664161,
0.0304030757,
-0.7875062227,
0.0708174258,
0.2730120718,
-0.2051990777,
0.4464681745,
0.4144509733,
0.1537094861,
0.7382737994,
0.617297411,
-0.1842457801,
-0.3603399992,
0.4849385917,
0.9380536675,
-0.4036378264,
-0.6829507351,
-0.8190014362,
0.7451699376,
-0.1007157266,
-0.5177224278,
0.5982182622,
0.3827537,
0.5413653851,
-0.0629500747,
0.6642463207,
0.2971701324,
0.5595955253,
-0.450992018,
0.3117378652,
-0.2405393869,
0.5165911913,
-0.1547220796,
-0.9844123721,
-0.0626783893,
0.5477916002,
-0.2798361182,
0.2374429405,
0.4292645752,
0.8203119636,
-0.0576152578,
0.2452237606,
0.3829468489,
0.0473548546,
0.5254455805,
0.5381949544,
1.0086755753,
0.1467525065,
0.3974723518,
0.0305869114,
-0.3917748034,
-0.3064193428,
-0.5765942335,
-0.9508047104,
-0.6634190083,
-0.3215884864,
-0.3574953377,
0.1312064528,
1.1436765194,
0.6468129158,
-0.7491980195,
-0.1639481336,
-0.2084034681,
-0.016528694,
0.2458847016,
-0.2487393171,
-0.1323107183,
-0.5811969042,
-0.9243949056,
0.5942614079,
0.4018442333,
0.1709143668,
-0.1684301496,
-0.2223294079,
0.2428004444,
0.1376037747,
0.4683179259,
0.2482969314,
-0.6010285616,
-0.2786035538,
0.1460179985,
-0.0057579894,
0.2061637789,
1.1002521515,
-0.7658256292,
0.4728832841,
0.507361114,
0.7047473192,
0.4428274632,
0.2506003082,
0.8896202445,
-1.1222503185,
0.2483302951,
0.4264943898,
0.1066107452,
0.5175020695,
-0.6976734996,
0.209214434,
0.0835408866,
-0.7780677676,
-0.7540740371,
0.5523008108,
-1.10519135,
-0.1671832353,
1.1742743254,
0.0001372037,
0.038331788,
-0.1201507449,
-0.7015003562,
0.06808687,
-0.7550312281,
0.6673425436,
0.5658112168,
-0.5436633825,
-0.4375745654,
-0.0469687656,
0.5736053586,
0.8404332995,
-0.7317974567,
0.0506178774,
0.5159316659,
0.2735571861,
-0.1300215274,
0.7822012305,
0.3571543097,
0.2628808618,
-0.4225589037,
-0.6009488702,
0.0245125946,
-0.3334160745,
-0.5708141327,
0.0621414185,
0.0621976815,
-0.0981807783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18173v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18173v1 | UIO-LLMs: Unbiased Incremental Optimization for Long-Context LLMs | 2024-06-26T08:44:36 | 2024-06-26T08:44:36 | Wenhao Li, Mingbao Lin, Yunshan Zhong, Shuicheng Yan, Rongrong Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Managing long texts is challenging for large language models (LLMs) due to
limited context window sizes. This study introduces UIO-LLMs, an unbiased
incremental optimization approach for memory-enhanced transformers under
long-context settings. We initially conceptualize the process as a streamlined
encoder-decoder framework where the weights-shared encoder and decoder
respectively encapsulate a context segment into memories and leverage these
memories to predict outputs of the subsequent segment. Subsequently, by
treating our memory-enhanced transformers as fully-connected recurrent neural
networks (RNNs), we refine the training process using the Truncated
Backpropagation Through Time (TBPTT) algorithm, which incorporates innovative
incremental optimization techniques. These techniques not only diminish time
complexity but also address the bias in gradient computation through an
unbiased optimization process. UIO-LLMs successfully handle long context, such
as extending the context window of Llama2-7b-chat from 4K to 100K tokens with
minimal 2% additional parameters, while keeping the inference cost nearly
linear as context length increases. | [
-0.3182049096,
-0.5907086134,
0.5086518526,
0.5534119606,
-0.4454017878,
0.1149738133,
-0.5999048948,
-0.2110363096,
-0.0521435328,
0.6095748544,
-0.556250751,
-0.1828059107,
-0.3557730317,
0.1712780297,
-0.1835462898,
0.8351500034,
-0.0385236181,
-0.076338172,
-0.2570381463,
-0.1306616813,
-0.4619327188,
-0.5131739974,
-0.6277980804,
-0.6184629202,
0.3225197196,
0.4983623326,
0.2563237846,
0.4569654167,
0.1829497814,
0.2783029675,
-0.2594917119,
0.1317722201,
-0.6477956772,
0.3218901455,
0.0180581976,
-0.2261053473,
-0.2890105247,
-0.3336333036,
0.8304918408,
0.6684961319,
-0.3130403161,
0.0669379458,
0.2284404337,
0.8871771097,
-0.6466619968,
0.0273415782,
-0.7885123491,
0.2695735991,
0.0557698943,
-0.4792364538,
-0.5535236597,
-0.0411153845,
0.1907041073,
-0.3406218886,
-0.3054617941,
0.0021652055,
0.5011773109,
0.4471807778,
-0.5506708026,
-0.0655893013,
-0.6502096057,
1.2717869282,
-0.5965067148,
0.2123851329,
-0.0690982044,
-0.0070894421,
-0.4027203619,
-0.6189537644,
-0.3603676558,
-0.2938342392,
0.0779352859,
0.2402199358,
-0.1285043359,
0.3548663855,
0.2279126644,
0.252626121,
-0.0796112493,
0.3660034537,
-0.2010834813,
-0.1244171783,
0.3652653694,
0.0032468184,
0.0293652341,
-0.1165638268,
-0.8689243793,
0.3148678541,
-0.4719467163,
0.0174266081,
0.1854245812,
0.0323627517,
-0.1469650269,
0.4999902546,
-0.1071749777,
0.4320406318,
0.0406676978,
-0.1801615059,
0.2774445117,
-0.1619652212,
-0.2584835291,
0.1701138467,
0.8939712048,
0.3021395206,
0.3139167726,
-0.3954949975,
-0.2909148037,
-0.2155598402,
0.3163857162,
-0.8415638208,
0.4952407181,
0.2219170779,
-0.2519659996,
-0.268275708,
-0.2840187848,
-0.7828114033,
0.0946618915,
-0.471950978,
0.4242855906,
-0.29595837,
-0.0264319256,
0.032193765,
-0.0137591837,
0.0338695534,
0.3219626546,
-0.769336462,
0.0945340395,
0.4471490383,
0.8253338337,
-0.5648944974,
-0.296313107,
-0.5063818693,
0.3190567195,
-0.2582285702,
0.5330551267,
-0.3491776288,
-0.5669685006,
-0.0808719173,
-0.1555282176,
0.0170504712,
-0.3570797741,
0.5444584489,
-0.5170696974,
0.1806426942,
0.2993090451,
-0.5378058553,
0.0878454745,
0.2357739061,
-0.4138212502,
1.4583741426,
0.3891324401,
-0.5100755095,
0.0672013089,
-0.7767275572,
-0.500647068,
-0.1570815146,
-0.100786373,
-0.4022908807,
0.390419513,
0.2859921753,
0.4953313172,
-0.5192338824,
0.3688448966,
-0.0314096957,
-0.524864018,
0.2237980217,
-0.6003415585,
0.5591660142,
0.2492499202,
-0.4752444923,
0.302775681,
-0.6536380053,
-0.0243048742,
-0.1888389587,
-0.5471646786,
-0.4746219516,
-0.0250747018,
-0.1549014598,
-0.0037706003,
0.3960402608,
-0.6336352825,
0.2849596441,
-0.3959765434,
0.6273030043,
0.9767110348,
-0.0896343365,
0.6792580485,
0.0332571566,
0.2398085892,
0.0944809243,
0.4165100157,
-0.4051361382,
-0.1433152258,
-0.8115609288,
-0.3480736315,
0.0187545847,
0.4421349764,
-0.707156837,
0.7629199624,
-0.5330484509,
-0.0115530584,
-0.28455773,
0.2529548705,
0.2698021829,
0.7679306269,
0.4198692143,
-0.4427932799,
-0.4769128561,
-1.030659914,
-0.0263045989,
0.1736136824,
-0.2320231944,
0.2671150565,
0.4386148751,
-0.7585064769,
0.9694381952,
-0.2461130023,
-0.4188559651,
-0.089912124,
-0.0417489894,
0.3489928544,
0.3198321462,
0.2891106009,
-0.5822215676,
-0.510404706,
0.2307443172,
-0.7178583741,
-0.1340876818,
-0.3037545085,
-0.0925747678,
0.5122457743,
0.6391098499,
-0.5640873909,
0.3408575952,
0.6254318953,
0.0847684965,
0.3481586874,
-0.3010942638,
-0.0449016765,
-1.2182172537,
-0.1529305726,
-0.1171261892,
-0.2957991362,
-0.3680928349,
-0.0850426927,
0.1843274236,
0.0364509597,
-0.3689470887,
0.6909663081,
-0.8694916964,
-0.0563679747,
-0.4395477176,
0.1085084528,
-0.0533816591,
0.7789130807,
0.0155533301,
0.8744090796,
0.5274336338,
-0.4757808149,
0.2419488728,
-0.2162369937,
-0.486466825,
0.4031508565,
-0.381583482,
0.3120496273,
-0.1406814605,
0.2179307789,
-0.8360441923,
0.1735440344,
-0.1572307795,
-0.2409384698,
0.5295796394,
-0.1694430858,
-0.3903648555,
-0.3710216582,
-0.5584474802,
0.4607006311,
0.5741377473,
-0.8489038944,
0.797804594,
0.3789142966,
-0.0098600555,
-0.9269628525,
-0.4698977768,
0.2370991856,
-0.2746027112,
-0.3930240571,
0.408801347,
-0.0662008077,
-0.0752919242,
-0.2634687126,
-0.2313394099,
0.1243430898,
-0.0216672774,
0.1856600642,
0.1309942156,
-0.0603624806,
0.1076395437,
0.3722840548,
-0.2031510025,
-0.0358746238,
-0.3962861001,
0.6513525248,
-0.0838607028,
-0.0781686082,
-0.5502994657,
0.4704683721,
0.5128177404,
0.3105967343,
0.6422259808,
0.4913008511,
-0.0909838825,
-0.2850285172,
-0.8355439901,
-0.0727969855,
-0.5416858196,
0.5849432945,
-0.3820880353,
-1.1422455311,
0.3686060607,
-0.3313674927,
0.0980792344,
0.157433629,
0.6425148249,
-0.1256492883,
0.7638549209,
0.4759435952,
-0.5968673229,
0.5522043109,
-0.2151086628,
-0.009575584,
-1.2681301832,
-0.2400467545,
-0.1593065709,
-0.2699756324,
-0.4431209862,
-0.6518333554,
0.3560541868,
0.179986909,
-0.495464325,
0.1337568611,
-0.6200168133,
0.4384699166,
0.531714499,
-0.0913136154,
0.3779169023,
0.3842354715,
-0.1170894504,
0.084753409,
-0.4478452206,
-0.244599998,
1.1054047346,
0.4596325159,
1.0107228756,
-0.0953968987,
0.5765146613,
0.3191175759,
0.5352966189,
-0.9736506343,
0.5812320113,
-0.0006484432,
-0.2006991804,
-0.4457935691,
-0.605178237,
-0.9781446457,
0.3351955712,
0.174686864,
-0.9382337928,
-0.0616003573,
0.0093468381,
-0.0300722886,
0.3801364303,
-0.576857686,
0.3436733484,
-0.3775613308,
-0.2807652652,
-0.2076930553,
-0.6611685753,
0.1149701849,
-0.0974104926,
0.0957247317,
-0.0986363739,
-0.4624290466,
0.509663403,
-0.2639416456,
0.6794810891,
0.0726079941,
-0.1968337595,
0.4671150148,
-0.2783283591,
0.5964838862,
0.1575618535,
-0.2361122966,
0.564380765,
-0.2368959635,
-0.2558566034,
-0.4093305767,
0.8915394545,
-0.8466620445,
-0.6157487035,
-0.4134164453,
-0.5511612892,
-0.2467592061,
0.1297589839,
0.4232272804,
0.2677575946,
-0.0617315359,
0.6055112481,
0.5720378757,
-0.1530007869,
0.7422946692,
0.4049369693,
-0.0739388838,
-0.5569983125,
0.4195000529,
-0.189085722,
0.4118716717,
0.7490266562,
0.2935441136,
-0.3581856489,
-0.6575263739,
-0.4103970826,
0.126137495,
-0.516492784,
-0.3433617651,
-0.5296470523,
-0.2840131819,
-0.2176666409,
-0.066189073,
-0.5574618578,
-0.2151105255,
-0.4563916624,
-0.0046885451,
0.3060125709,
0.1822205186,
0.0470506437,
0.6275634766,
-0.7468596101,
0.3501421511,
0.2313182652,
0.4209951162,
0.1411931515,
-0.7040937543,
-0.3280735612,
0.0984428823,
-0.2270638496,
-0.5102841854,
0.4229033291,
0.1070802286,
0.409324199,
0.414244622,
-0.0921047777,
0.8111524582,
-0.6716160178,
0.5713284016,
0.5035982728,
-0.8287995458,
0.4090829492,
-0.3457045853,
0.4309912622,
0.5431060791,
0.1700760722,
-0.4147113562,
-0.0543648563,
-0.0641699135,
-1.1184186935,
0.6276230216,
0.3127255738,
0.5638085604,
-0.076628156,
0.7616814971,
0.1079845503,
0.2600547969,
-0.8738750219,
-0.4111495018,
-0.0236499924,
-0.1775203794,
0.0808194354,
-0.6275672317,
-0.035426978,
-0.3190404177,
0.5232688189,
-0.2971242666,
0.3814768791,
0.0960459262,
-0.192677021,
-0.059904296,
0.4995185435,
0.552129209,
0.6552144885,
-0.2012007236,
-0.2808283567,
0.3969184756,
-0.6247882247,
0.104768239,
0.0440039784,
-0.2004022151,
-0.0651426166,
0.1171849892,
1.0404474735,
0.5555154085,
-0.7054473758,
0.3469120562,
-0.184184581,
0.0038293276,
-0.8084710836,
0.0251724347,
-0.0318800919,
0.2310372293,
0.8538870215,
-0.2306199074,
-0.055115182,
-0.5391242504,
0.0770819038,
0.550873816,
-0.5402085185,
-0.1960250437,
0.4189610481,
0.3783594668,
-0.2961858511,
0.6603485346,
0.2556838691,
-0.2794958055,
0.5228598714,
0.5266107321,
0.8811687231,
-0.2363832742,
-0.175968051,
0.3053078353,
0.164890781,
-0.2610471547,
0.0239000041,
-0.3282605708,
-0.7732553482,
-0.5076987743,
-0.7715533376,
-0.2458817512,
0.3758527339,
-0.8294588327,
0.1532344222,
-0.2146379054,
-0.3702941537,
-0.5255233645,
-0.0611769855,
-0.5484904647,
0.1553347707,
-0.1594030261,
0.847011447,
-0.0229014587,
1.1196835041,
0.2169980705,
0.0821415409,
-0.383009851,
-0.1180035397,
-0.2176054567,
-0.9795668125,
0.489536196,
0.3824787736,
-0.3302296698,
0.2369716018,
-0.3263078332,
-0.8006575108,
1.2269635201,
0.264484942,
-0.9862347245,
-0.2046612799,
0.0496707857,
0.4578542709,
-0.4926096499,
0.134383142,
0.6223269701,
0.2296100259,
0.0493145287,
-0.9316638112,
-0.1622773409,
0.0081835417,
0.3506578505,
0.4651788771,
-0.6965990067,
0.5570976734,
-0.4214577973,
-0.1920457035,
0.3728717566,
0.8709127307,
0.1463537514,
0.1784045994,
0.5928866863,
0.5442960262,
0.2866392136,
0.0175185353,
1.1293616295,
-0.2764879167,
0.3819918334,
1.2023998499,
-0.1616298258,
0.7805879712,
0.9335991144,
-0.0317422971,
0.5106025338,
0.4771716893,
0.2188072503,
0.5053874254,
0.1425042748,
-0.5229840875,
-0.0054296223,
-0.1022270992,
-0.3716677129,
0.3514205217,
0.3798124492,
-0.4565032423,
0.024425175,
0.1553214788,
0.0417912118,
-0.0632480532,
-0.4086863399,
0.8268164396,
0.4301217198,
-0.79817307,
0.4542256296,
-0.0349693596,
1.1290820837,
-0.7625283003,
0.3200891018,
-0.3953101337,
0.3877623081,
0.0904466882,
-0.7550717592,
-0.0551433153,
-0.0865545422,
-0.0866950676,
-0.3372330666,
0.5741630793,
-0.4829045236,
-0.4024252295,
0.7259302735,
0.2074375004,
-0.123565428,
-0.1985925883,
-0.5399545431,
0.1183018163,
-0.0117108831,
-0.6275388002,
0.5651439428,
0.4055663347,
-0.0815111622,
0.8906738758,
0.6112080216,
0.0595172755,
-0.1906852275,
0.3918170631,
0.7497450709,
-0.8363098502,
-0.3836689591,
-1.0883841515,
0.5354315042,
-0.2172008604,
-0.2201734781,
0.72115767,
0.6819630861,
0.7058547139,
-0.0381164253,
0.6535333395,
0.4363055527,
0.355460614,
-0.5912484527,
0.4973947108,
-0.6598426104,
0.4192939401,
-0.0476287864,
-1.0666191578,
0.0298916064,
0.4051578939,
-0.0341638774,
0.0253638122,
0.4855656028,
0.5323267579,
0.0988731757,
-0.2425432503,
0.311296314,
0.0803629905,
0.1998345703,
0.6862607002,
0.8298726082,
-0.3621639907,
0.6633626223,
-0.4126484692,
-0.3010253608,
-0.1867505461,
-1.1514489651,
-1.0411186218,
-0.4524969161,
-0.1675697863,
-0.0915793106,
-0.0669084713,
0.8232041597,
0.5710973144,
-0.4675129652,
-0.5159534216,
0.1043056399,
0.1537804157,
0.0710602552,
-0.2643647194,
0.3129831553,
-0.450954169,
-0.8955650926,
0.4514881074,
0.7886299491,
-0.0244889166,
-0.3073710799,
-0.1685515791,
-0.0083850604,
0.0601169877,
1.1405292749,
0.2634015381,
-0.6567911506,
-0.2659813464,
-0.0376287512,
-0.0708228573,
0.3854219019,
0.7689967752,
-0.7955267429,
0.5027423501,
0.2507951856,
0.5763344765,
0.7463787794,
0.1091287211,
0.6148107052,
-1.0021381378,
0.5240810513,
0.2912918627,
0.4511629045,
0.2873025835,
-0.412653625,
0.6202010512,
-0.069789812,
-0.5238372684,
-1.0096976757,
0.0516951568,
-1.1542272568,
-0.3642472923,
1.3499047756,
0.1688332111,
-0.2385339439,
-0.066594258,
-0.1014547125,
0.0724849179,
-0.6528744698,
0.9083128572,
0.3844762743,
-0.1933003813,
-0.3030569851,
-0.3890266716,
0.3261462748,
0.3065094054,
-0.8493884206,
-0.1353147626,
0.3111690581,
0.2885291576,
0.0500769354,
0.7586222887,
-0.1313995123,
0.0090666506,
-0.4844777286,
-0.035311088,
-0.0853996873,
-0.2001152933,
-0.1775905639,
-0.0511183739,
-0.2593410015,
-0.1680897027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18164v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18164v1 | NeBuLa: A discourse aware Minecraft Builder | 2024-06-26T08:24:44 | 2024-06-26T08:24:44 | Akshay Chaturvedi, Kate Thompson, Nicholas Asher | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | When engaging in collaborative tasks, humans efficiently exploit the semantic
structure of a conversation to optimize verbal and nonverbal interactions. But
in recent "language to code" or "language to action" models, this information
is lacking. We show how incorporating the prior discourse and nonlinguistic
context of a conversation situated in a nonlinguistic environment can improve
the "language to action" component of such interactions. We fine tune an LLM to
predict actions based on prior context; our model, NeBuLa, doubles the
net-action F1 score over the baseline on this task of Jayannavar et al.(2020).
We also investigate our model's ability to construct shapes and understand
location descriptions using a synthetic dataset. | [
-0.0169283971,
-1.1322283745,
0.6815222502,
0.1938631535,
0.2158152759,
0.1387641132,
0.1160836369,
-0.5343370438,
0.7282561064,
0.4954786897,
-0.4484384358,
-0.4642572999,
-0.4374148846,
-0.2222714275,
-0.5478459001,
0.5762990117,
0.1747338176,
-0.4458349943,
-0.3669449091,
0.0985385031,
-0.5044965148,
-0.4422414899,
-0.8778589368,
-0.1723202169,
0.4299664199,
0.2968354523,
0.8390026689,
0.6420242786,
0.3812021315,
0.5005874038,
-0.1648310274,
0.1148072481,
-0.7171397209,
0.054564435,
-0.5118365884,
-0.4384251237,
-0.4905830324,
-0.0789747983,
0.573125422,
0.7934032679,
0.0377330817,
0.2681650519,
0.0388239026,
0.1832877994,
-0.5067834854,
0.306432277,
-0.462505281,
0.3597484529,
-0.0091441954,
-0.3128401935,
-0.4846301377,
0.0657855719,
0.0659592003,
-0.7780613899,
-0.0190721322,
0.4026206732,
0.4745602012,
0.5003495812,
-0.4704498053,
-0.1078459322,
-0.6163398027,
0.6712278724,
-0.4804885089,
0.4073431194,
0.4606213868,
-0.0806229636,
-0.6208080649,
-0.9377506375,
-0.5364851952,
-0.0160585586,
-0.1228133142,
0.3387373984,
-0.2782076597,
0.4111682177,
0.3804560304,
0.2652898729,
-0.4639832675,
0.1377502382,
-0.4593623877,
-0.2103137076,
0.5094347596,
0.407944113,
0.2409787476,
-0.6248324513,
-0.2670152187,
0.2739206553,
-0.4509834945,
0.2831786573,
0.1836967915,
0.3156014085,
-0.2735259831,
0.7124482989,
-0.1387325227,
0.8924145699,
0.3720571995,
-0.2484093606,
-0.232533142,
-0.2706997097,
-0.6755859852,
0.035788361,
0.5738669634,
0.4173945189,
-0.1293849349,
-0.1922109425,
0.4613511264,
0.2064149976,
0.6780958772,
-0.7161633372,
-0.3159279227,
0.5862934589,
-0.5946853757,
-0.5352548957,
0.0682286024,
-0.355620563,
-0.5779609084,
-0.2468679696,
-0.0278147757,
-0.0189744178,
-0.5014888048,
-0.0455724262,
-0.0867153928,
0.0000568156,
0.1881841719,
-0.6344085336,
0.4900021255,
0.7434093356,
0.852584064,
-0.0023177038,
-0.3833822906,
-0.6312120557,
0.2886814177,
-0.6117136478,
0.8478167057,
-0.6757299304,
-0.8451370001,
-0.2462775707,
-0.0320261344,
-0.0165400598,
-0.3058567047,
0.3632576764,
-0.1122616678,
0.6565902829,
0.0293868929,
-0.5191904306,
-0.5323761702,
0.3583034277,
-0.5296954513,
0.9574589729,
0.224259764,
-0.6510320902,
0.237869218,
-0.9024659991,
-0.4283326268,
0.2506164908,
-0.1905068159,
-0.0287386701,
0.4975104034,
-0.1044994593,
0.4900951684,
-0.1101592705,
0.5563355088,
-0.2157401145,
-0.4906390607,
0.1595956981,
-0.0685382038,
0.4952411652,
0.0358217284,
-0.3752683103,
0.4884974658,
-0.3299658597,
0.3326285481,
-0.2057106942,
-0.1552165896,
0.0353557542,
0.3347300887,
-0.3499284089,
0.4955485463,
0.0410262793,
-0.2914235592,
0.0817719027,
-0.6725847125,
0.2133903056,
0.7991928458,
0.0577594228,
0.788608551,
-0.3870033324,
0.7708882093,
-0.040132232,
0.1031336039,
-0.0154002113,
-0.7592841387,
-0.7844817042,
-0.0261636581,
0.1001214832,
0.5720095038,
-0.8913971782,
0.2876723707,
-0.1220083684,
-0.5167375207,
-0.3811612427,
-0.134635523,
0.5976257324,
0.7691702247,
0.104300946,
-0.6865102053,
-0.8444591761,
-0.477216512,
-0.049506709,
-0.6024912,
0.1381200701,
0.8070580959,
0.1429424435,
-0.2235348821,
1.0085657835,
-0.581041038,
-0.1073421538,
-0.1577057689,
-0.00559424,
0.0941046923,
0.2471840531,
0.3588490486,
-0.6130111217,
-0.5016946197,
0.0412691571,
-0.8481439352,
-0.0042402213,
-0.2301106751,
-0.1797996461,
0.070433192,
0.7372661233,
-0.4525845945,
0.6426663399,
0.971427083,
-0.748246789,
0.3869443536,
0.114880085,
0.1632493287,
-1.4424740076,
0.2209578454,
-0.083963789,
-0.3608796895,
-0.7170704603,
0.0863268822,
-0.264501363,
-0.3672551215,
-0.8512040377,
0.8038671017,
-0.3183728158,
-0.2903930247,
-0.4327493012,
0.0678433701,
-0.2211866081,
0.6258958578,
0.3852483928,
0.7602915168,
0.7621482015,
-0.7312703729,
0.0994206294,
0.2787498236,
-0.3363659084,
0.8008984327,
-0.8323537111,
0.107598722,
-0.0969442129,
0.2516928017,
-0.7784122229,
-0.407587409,
0.1044495553,
-0.5302091241,
-0.0657560974,
-0.3646778762,
-0.4127412736,
-0.3478349149,
-0.0950018466,
0.1320160478,
0.3208131194,
-0.3622240722,
0.727037847,
0.6978089809,
-0.082756713,
-0.3004691303,
-0.5934744477,
0.2084222287,
-0.3127011061,
-0.6901224852,
0.4747650325,
-0.2801825106,
-0.4123233855,
-0.212702021,
-0.0599068739,
-0.2952708006,
0.2897873819,
0.88234514,
0.0451159216,
0.0118781226,
0.1120901257,
-0.1216985583,
-0.1838766336,
0.1824669242,
-0.3865245581,
0.5000941157,
0.1573028266,
-0.1436730176,
-0.4574195445,
0.3933928907,
0.4025750756,
-0.0202072766,
0.5503466129,
0.180106163,
-0.2042464912,
-0.0966452584,
-0.0993808433,
-0.202770263,
-0.6130661368,
0.2431452572,
-0.3129034638,
-1.0745127201,
0.3876197934,
-0.5556021929,
-0.0279460642,
0.1751220971,
0.3967472315,
-0.246656552,
0.8742332458,
0.9269621968,
0.1028944626,
0.7332656384,
-0.1418975592,
0.3239480853,
-0.983196497,
-0.2276894003,
-0.1651283503,
-0.6813609004,
-0.5591658354,
-0.802059412,
0.1970107704,
-0.0745773837,
-0.0246987604,
0.5498695374,
-0.5229582191,
0.7328943014,
0.3635531366,
-0.1570473164,
0.0058585992,
-0.1606788188,
-0.2497400939,
-0.1864560544,
-0.9162106514,
-0.3701896369,
0.8433674574,
0.1550376564,
0.3966214359,
0.3415322602,
0.7423590422,
-0.1492416114,
0.294610858,
-0.8292512894,
0.7283530831,
0.1550878733,
-0.5773953199,
0.026039945,
-0.3861492872,
-1.234115839,
0.134558931,
-0.2983782589,
-0.7499555945,
-0.1113636568,
0.1676268578,
-0.4548837543,
0.0550738759,
-0.9379187822,
0.8803530335,
-0.1570611447,
-0.6146211624,
-0.077811338,
-0.4154789746,
0.175103277,
0.2551735342,
0.4406788051,
-0.0039287019,
-0.0030874566,
0.2943187654,
-0.1986565143,
1.1952658892,
-0.0980372429,
0.0070523573,
0.4630978107,
0.5952758789,
0.4642228484,
0.1295826584,
0.0118008293,
-0.0718752965,
-0.6217519641,
-0.2842296362,
-0.6615880132,
0.9449967742,
-0.5337417126,
-0.7008840442,
-0.4014915526,
-0.4910818636,
-0.1369508654,
0.1144423336,
0.0532035604,
0.3145515025,
-0.6125781536,
-0.0072984635,
0.4271311164,
-0.1232489124,
0.6397502422,
0.5412764549,
-0.4041104019,
-0.2215775251,
0.6409130096,
-0.1147299483,
0.194102481,
0.2099078745,
0.0590105355,
-0.2082436979,
-0.445047766,
-0.0682458505,
-0.0211588964,
-0.377414465,
-0.1348060817,
-0.6329602599,
-0.2046631873,
-0.2049400955,
-0.6669671535,
-0.1562978923,
-0.7149834037,
-0.4778783917,
-0.4137400389,
0.1084161922,
0.9334166646,
0.1197659448,
0.3897599876,
-0.3564552367,
0.1486163139,
0.2536144257,
0.3890007138,
-0.0838887468,
-0.3804869354,
-0.0154401278,
0.0038598615,
-0.4989182651,
-0.569265008,
0.4734268785,
0.1772251427,
0.4027492106,
0.1181494296,
-0.3222962916,
1.1400316954,
-0.5523269176,
1.1956840754,
0.2205505818,
-0.9820065498,
0.8626589775,
-0.3142929673,
0.7458308339,
0.1832848042,
0.257250458,
-0.6156154275,
-0.4410878718,
-1.1806682348,
-0.6666226387,
0.4808225334,
0.2552135885,
0.1992892325,
-0.2792938948,
0.2395095378,
-0.2654648125,
0.1650862098,
-0.8841216564,
0.0254478883,
-0.1721307933,
-0.1020208374,
-0.2246451974,
-0.0514585041,
-0.0452064238,
-0.2297897339,
0.3717571199,
-0.3509010673,
0.3732858002,
0.1425890476,
-0.1094395295,
-0.1011666209,
-0.0268525239,
0.662537694,
0.3132425249,
0.3157239854,
0.2091754675,
0.2796483934,
-0.3852054477,
-0.139268294,
-0.2454329133,
0.0111728432,
-0.2520583868,
0.4466554523,
0.6405166984,
0.6833990812,
-0.5413066745,
0.2840988934,
-0.1195668653,
-0.3105332851,
-0.249320358,
0.3666028976,
0.356944412,
0.362596333,
-0.405454427,
0.3329779804,
0.3065160215,
-0.6975110769,
0.1322851926,
0.3133422434,
-0.7106131315,
-0.418754518,
0.6973919868,
0.5684886575,
-0.5777941346,
0.4680176377,
-0.3645457029,
-0.3705743253,
0.5770338774,
0.7996147871,
0.7917075753,
-0.2299564332,
0.517190516,
0.4941775799,
0.0730449036,
0.0470863804,
0.6538774967,
-0.0904868171,
-0.5653950572,
-0.6472473145,
-0.3496215045,
-0.4005463123,
-0.4193137884,
-0.0672102347,
0.2268663049,
-0.8926469088,
-0.2195113301,
-0.0437215045,
0.1627577245,
-0.5625845194,
0.287491709,
-0.180585146,
0.5333595276,
-0.4147080183,
0.7764977813,
0.6292871833,
-0.1365968585,
-0.8672392964,
-0.2344722897,
0.4582427442,
-0.457053721,
0.4598012865,
0.1766913831,
-0.237236172,
0.148970291,
-0.3990080059,
-1.1523692608,
1.2302155495,
0.3166161776,
-0.3356167078,
0.0901988521,
0.0197046082,
0.7115975618,
-0.4881264567,
0.2713672817,
-0.0117653301,
0.2015027404,
0.3602121174,
-1.1850291491,
-0.0465386063,
-0.4165998697,
0.0650410205,
0.5189355612,
-0.6877304912,
0.6206105351,
-0.1989432871,
-0.4454495907,
0.0369956605,
0.6537335515,
-0.0329584889,
0.2070405036,
0.1720587164,
0.6047356725,
1.0835204124,
0.0027227334,
1.3406213522,
-0.3331208229,
-0.0002475302,
1.2619735003,
-0.253493011,
0.9845762253,
0.3210060894,
0.1140416786,
0.8401470184,
0.3887963891,
0.3869156837,
0.4375951588,
0.1959187239,
-0.2322838753,
-0.0267611928,
-0.4158644676,
0.0513456576,
0.8379121423,
0.5101105571,
-0.4393256903,
0.1619472206,
-0.3337422609,
0.1607650816,
0.2333611995,
-0.45334813,
1.1553697586,
0.0093942666,
-0.8198156953,
0.2243888974,
0.0537459776,
0.5676414371,
-0.4257574379,
0.0307946298,
0.0212570559,
-0.1105859354,
-0.5268645883,
-0.7158289552,
0.8032885194,
-0.0914431736,
-0.2333222926,
-0.4089897573,
0.7892289758,
-0.4304351807,
-0.4220258594,
0.0707654506,
0.4253400862,
0.228151232,
0.0328968689,
-0.72748667,
0.1078967452,
-0.0615498386,
0.2113180757,
0.1396540701,
0.2106908709,
-0.1220017821,
0.5277501345,
0.9168410301,
-0.182094574,
-0.2013325542,
-0.2138468921,
0.6467832327,
-0.7824887633,
-0.7735104561,
-0.5288237333,
0.9181301594,
-0.4039385915,
-0.5291016698,
0.8129829764,
0.5986512303,
0.6300212741,
0.152884841,
0.5775832534,
-0.1790219396,
0.2698703408,
-0.4564709365,
0.4376803339,
-0.1689157784,
0.0156453457,
-0.3521567285,
-0.9428192973,
-0.3402187526,
0.9791563153,
-0.1159352735,
-0.0729003325,
0.872964561,
0.7449729443,
-0.1861328781,
0.181989938,
0.4986113012,
0.1605461389,
0.3036728501,
0.6766813993,
0.7242560983,
-0.3055702448,
0.0961996615,
-0.0304430649,
-0.2848249376,
0.1053537801,
-1.1176745892,
-1.1060310602,
-0.5494711399,
-0.4368848503,
-0.1786403954,
-0.2408466041,
0.6929080486,
1.1588124037,
-0.4467229247,
-0.4372278452,
-0.4060402215,
0.1618214697,
-0.2377489209,
-0.2296888232,
-0.1178030223,
-0.0622893162,
-0.6476022005,
0.8954709768,
0.5314372778,
0.2035263181,
-0.1777361035,
-0.2226040959,
-0.1186427251,
0.3299507797,
0.8994073272,
0.3155371249,
-0.7073304057,
-0.4616795182,
0.2481324971,
0.1714740694,
0.0042372299,
0.8773735762,
-1.1437237263,
0.5631107688,
0.2627291977,
0.308275193,
0.4523762763,
0.0213316996,
0.8839333057,
-1.0728929043,
0.4073405266,
0.2328964323,
0.1956053972,
0.2768919766,
-0.6568524837,
0.6453129053,
0.0175667591,
-0.4663618505,
-0.3581689894,
0.537779808,
-0.9439412951,
-0.3888806999,
0.9447655082,
0.0090113822,
-0.2714878321,
-0.1339443624,
-0.535920918,
-0.2607105672,
-0.1275094002,
0.9142635465,
0.7618486881,
-0.2150650471,
-0.2393889576,
-0.3557577431,
0.6829380393,
0.4042060077,
-1.1876175404,
-0.1781003177,
0.7714838982,
-0.0197390616,
0.3200631738,
0.8178388476,
0.1848331392,
0.4214648306,
0.1622311324,
-0.4100189209,
-0.1245509908,
-0.4982028306,
0.0588964559,
0.2444233745,
0.1153015792,
0.1742414087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18139v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18139v1 | LOOK-M: Look-Once Optimization in KV Cache for Efficient Multimodal Long-Context Inference | 2024-06-26T07:44:24 | 2024-06-26T07:44:24 | Zhongwei Wan, Ziang Wu, Che Liu, Jinfa Huang, Zhihong Zhu, Peng Jin, Longyue Wang, Li Yuan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Long-context Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) demand substantial
computational resources for inference as the growth of their multimodal
Key-Value (KV) cache, in response to increasing input lengths, challenges
memory and time efficiency. Unlike single-modality LLMs that manage only
textual contexts, the KV cache of long-context MLLMs includes representations
from multiple images with temporal and spatial relationships and related
textual contexts. The predominance of image tokens means traditional
optimizations for LLMs' KV caches are unsuitable for multimodal long-context
settings, and no prior works have addressed this challenge. In this work, we
introduce LOOK-M, a pioneering, fine-tuning-free approach that efficiently
reduces the multimodal KV cache size while maintaining performance comparable
to a full cache. We observe that during prompt prefill, the model prioritizes
more textual attention over image features, and based on the multimodal
interaction observation, a new proposed text-prior method is explored to
compress the KV cache. Furthermore, to mitigate the degradation of image
contextual information, we propose several compensatory strategies using KV
pairs merging. LOOK-M demonstrates that with a significant reduction in KV
Cache memory usage, such as reducing it by 80% in some cases, it not only
achieves up to 1.5x faster decoding but also maintains or even enhances
performance across a variety of long context multimodal tasks. | [
-0.4441003799,
-0.6485687494,
0.5436363816,
0.4367441535,
-0.5542999506,
-0.1930496842,
-0.3858714998,
-0.3590661883,
0.1983839869,
0.3964556158,
-1.0340566635,
-0.4422178268,
-0.3681136966,
-0.0394104309,
-0.1001812369,
0.3991479874,
-0.0951438844,
-0.0810692012,
-0.5285300612,
-0.2818128169,
-0.3379057944,
-0.3009866476,
-0.5574625731,
0.1681383401,
0.9182591438,
0.4312188029,
0.5355907679,
0.3924057782,
0.5004490018,
0.232000187,
0.0092328619,
0.6336475015,
-0.6102096438,
0.5983160138,
0.0470233187,
-0.3118647039,
-0.2501189709,
-0.0689389855,
0.6265772581,
0.1991171241,
0.214316532,
0.1262247413,
-0.0571635067,
0.7160078287,
-1.4488402605,
0.1800668538,
-0.5661241412,
0.0496802032,
-0.2701120377,
-0.5426338911,
-0.7839417458,
-0.0177812912,
0.2179811895,
-0.7744992971,
-0.01620939,
0.0357057154,
0.6144542694,
0.5908765793,
-0.4609444737,
0.0899743214,
-0.3765979111,
1.156293273,
-0.6005454063,
0.7038149834,
0.3523664474,
0.158377558,
-0.366756618,
-0.6540288925,
-0.7262452841,
-0.139639616,
-0.1176690236,
0.188377142,
-0.0645988137,
0.0211817306,
0.0209990554,
0.0542318001,
-0.5717461705,
-0.1043001637,
0.0171565246,
-0.2725198865,
0.0670957118,
0.0478881486,
0.0428372733,
-0.1444327086,
-0.5660946965,
-0.2881813943,
-0.6890531182,
0.019574929,
-0.1523679793,
0.3780595362,
-0.1288105845,
0.4036361575,
-0.3263580501,
0.4948527217,
-0.2664659321,
-0.2841514945,
0.2830057442,
-0.6751808524,
-0.1755675972,
-0.1732219607,
0.6471291184,
0.7010006905,
0.3073056936,
0.0750887766,
0.0393740349,
0.0928528309,
0.1444458067,
-1.106500864,
-0.1012474895,
0.1353147924,
-0.6794580817,
-0.2700936794,
-0.359256506,
-0.8751444817,
-0.0232979767,
-0.3498778343,
0.5142573118,
-0.2392871678,
0.0190776754,
0.0107103121,
-0.00045653,
0.348271668,
0.6050621271,
-0.6269252896,
-0.0698711649,
0.336560756,
0.9820805788,
-0.1932316273,
-0.3466968834,
-0.8135690689,
0.2054260522,
-0.2516247034,
0.524754107,
-0.667879343,
-0.3498288393,
0.0062720375,
0.1624241173,
0.047312934,
-0.3007048965,
0.3523401618,
-0.579411149,
0.0986155421,
-0.3095436096,
-0.1310224086,
0.2027465999,
0.4740955234,
-0.8325473666,
1.2187519073,
-0.0380848944,
-0.8127216101,
0.6311688423,
-0.5685544014,
-0.4680905342,
-0.2587729394,
0.0895974264,
-0.5184921622,
0.269424051,
0.6662949324,
0.4894638658,
-0.1270759404,
-0.0959021747,
-0.6003263593,
-0.352856487,
-0.1496268213,
-0.4365212321,
0.2249047756,
0.2421163619,
-0.3172542453,
0.3003575802,
-0.6573895216,
0.2449578941,
0.1890508831,
-0.3066414893,
-0.6040075421,
0.291657865,
0.2484240085,
0.3781889379,
0.4131527841,
-0.4692238867,
0.2947620451,
-0.0927847624,
0.3377322555,
0.8061256409,
-0.2418432981,
0.4285055101,
-0.0498578474,
0.3741144538,
0.4292880893,
0.3995092809,
-0.8927351236,
-0.2145642787,
-0.9489225149,
-0.6177287102,
0.0326408856,
0.2125512362,
-0.9770843387,
-0.1877530962,
-0.342282027,
-0.1080491766,
-0.6099621058,
-0.0360144079,
0.5897996426,
0.340983361,
0.6189445257,
-0.1419825852,
-0.4721913338,
-1.3003578186,
-0.1961002797,
0.1627186388,
0.1885912865,
0.6529323459,
0.3252156377,
-0.4231919348,
0.9043079615,
-0.6393695474,
-0.0187284835,
0.243165493,
0.042737335,
-0.1462713927,
0.5047841072,
0.4586603642,
-0.8031901121,
-0.4467802048,
-0.1140379161,
-0.4896098077,
-0.0116691338,
0.0296340529,
-0.3278064728,
0.4911662936,
0.6584402919,
-0.6986607313,
0.5232931376,
0.5916752815,
-0.2174516618,
0.5765587091,
-0.2946542799,
0.4281119704,
-1.0607757568,
0.1476852,
-0.2059862167,
-0.2732670605,
-0.3182507157,
0.1883091182,
0.4970871806,
-0.0396910906,
-0.4998872876,
1.0476042032,
-0.6621888876,
0.0611559078,
0.0635967106,
0.0432102829,
0.1511946768,
0.6273283958,
-0.1478051841,
0.9606922269,
0.4165493846,
-0.5519075394,
-0.1668484509,
0.105524525,
-0.3033014834,
0.5543791056,
-0.2288949043,
0.2288199365,
-0.2642696202,
0.2883452773,
-1.0329487324,
-0.1379617155,
-0.0441839583,
-0.2254445255,
0.5479868054,
-0.1554985493,
-0.6024289131,
-0.2142912149,
-0.5769624114,
0.9191695452,
0.002346497,
-0.8560253382,
0.6288090348,
-0.0443853922,
0.0551858023,
-0.929787457,
-0.4655066431,
0.1600138843,
0.0608792417,
-0.774076581,
0.4677650332,
-0.2336443961,
0.1261166483,
-0.1622897089,
-0.2548976839,
-0.0903979689,
-0.0827294216,
0.0782979578,
0.1133265644,
-0.3324825466,
0.4145835936,
0.3304204047,
-0.2238432914,
-0.2136774361,
-0.2187363803,
0.6089417338,
0.0894282758,
-0.3461464942,
-0.372758925,
0.5103975534,
1.0463498831,
-0.4316700101,
0.8309990168,
0.6341121197,
-0.1920062751,
-0.1362968683,
-0.6978826523,
-0.1666135788,
-0.4922559261,
0.3418937325,
-0.6020187736,
-1.1194627285,
0.4612058997,
-0.0886079222,
-0.0319243483,
0.1473986953,
0.55778265,
-0.098188743,
0.9811365008,
0.4005149007,
-0.2064768821,
0.631192863,
-0.0283427499,
0.1356536597,
-0.6677002907,
-0.40153566,
-0.3049813211,
-0.4193213582,
-0.5890170932,
-0.8639977574,
0.3860222101,
-0.0541740581,
-0.1114123315,
0.0307453573,
-0.2836614251,
0.5495530963,
0.5830380321,
0.4652614594,
0.1855833977,
-0.120263733,
-0.3536421657,
-0.2835381031,
-0.5586389303,
-0.0927475765,
1.0219413042,
0.0293564461,
0.9888525009,
-0.0630664453,
0.5335739851,
-0.0048008761,
0.206598565,
-0.7990230322,
0.5390256047,
-0.1053707153,
-0.488700062,
-0.061406292,
-0.4431154132,
-0.8490301371,
0.3410516679,
-0.2196350843,
-0.4431790709,
0.0008377433,
0.423926264,
0.0715602934,
0.0631721169,
-0.7315824628,
1.0095202923,
-0.0649637133,
-0.5866765976,
-0.4437355101,
-0.747195065,
0.2786821127,
-0.0911421925,
0.0581823587,
0.0450327955,
-0.1560806483,
0.3018027246,
-0.2729633451,
0.4451133609,
-0.2110440731,
-0.1444700807,
-0.0369128734,
0.1622098386,
0.6339942813,
-0.0152360182,
0.2636218965,
0.0475367494,
0.0610445514,
-0.5283716917,
-0.6945650578,
0.9281141162,
-0.4123492241,
-0.1785624176,
0.0888297409,
-0.5604391098,
-0.0710408539,
0.378611505,
0.2378084958,
0.7411942482,
-0.1717984676,
0.4393208623,
0.6710329652,
-0.3305639625,
0.586501956,
0.1440836191,
-0.3092775345,
-0.415412426,
0.703538835,
-0.3047123551,
0.4101293087,
0.717330575,
-0.0141068669,
-0.372400701,
-0.3029052913,
-0.2823317647,
0.1449938565,
-0.7261391878,
-0.1817285717,
-0.6868029833,
0.2787092924,
-0.0425492153,
-0.2545648515,
-0.6095867157,
-0.2218930274,
-0.2795063853,
0.5059629679,
0.1997862756,
0.0558432043,
0.256975174,
0.4636693001,
-0.6950073838,
0.3842701018,
0.2153082341,
0.5764645338,
0.0571692102,
-0.0017682969,
-0.3654201627,
-0.0745242089,
-0.1267112941,
-0.4173516333,
0.3286719918,
0.2482865751,
0.2402472496,
0.6296160817,
-0.135477826,
0.9940622449,
-0.5934907198,
0.5480793715,
0.200955078,
-0.8604362607,
0.4708610475,
-0.3597566485,
0.7008785009,
0.5503853559,
0.1447919309,
-0.4296912253,
-0.1268258244,
0.0236608032,
-0.9114715457,
0.5181428194,
0.4090957642,
0.0412124097,
-0.3100045621,
0.2532545626,
-0.1474084556,
0.236626178,
-0.6308345795,
-0.3266590238,
-0.1446787417,
-0.1456753165,
-0.1943050921,
-0.491417706,
0.157721445,
-0.2995065153,
0.3122782111,
-0.3963711262,
0.3520435095,
0.3251300454,
-0.4393171668,
-0.061979413,
0.2266545743,
1.1114033461,
0.5718585253,
-0.3884841204,
0.3525701463,
0.0693078637,
-0.4521339536,
-0.0750489905,
-0.1937042922,
0.2649405003,
0.138956517,
0.2187168151,
0.6947081685,
0.8155912161,
-0.715423584,
0.4309945703,
-0.3127955496,
-0.0465151295,
0.0197996292,
-0.2721129954,
-0.0076857819,
0.4106616974,
0.3277763128,
-0.0754176229,
-0.0500960238,
-0.423022449,
0.3046033382,
0.7821978331,
-0.1709567755,
-0.1196530312,
0.5418974757,
0.0850884691,
-0.0390034392,
0.5131809115,
0.007230164,
-0.6160575747,
0.3168966174,
0.515227139,
0.8841064572,
-0.1720633507,
-0.3043653071,
0.4658288956,
0.2453223765,
0.0775405243,
0.2185015231,
-0.3533336222,
-0.6082838774,
-0.6378337741,
-0.71876055,
-0.1909776032,
0.2387748212,
-0.5593647361,
0.32910797,
-0.2149730921,
-0.1405442059,
-0.0729701295,
-0.2056813687,
-0.7147492766,
0.1972638369,
-0.0630278811,
0.8772186041,
-0.193361789,
0.7287184,
0.1879773885,
0.0954824835,
-0.1721639186,
-0.1523382664,
0.0676495433,
-0.6902348399,
0.838526845,
0.6161029935,
-0.5311129093,
0.010716523,
-0.7925077081,
-0.9116556048,
0.9654951096,
0.2725142241,
-0.6367129683,
-0.1612718403,
-0.3185364306,
0.1178902388,
-0.4731718898,
0.142552644,
0.3357245326,
0.6386421323,
0.1980859786,
-0.9510658383,
0.0163558535,
-0.2966651917,
0.003605729,
0.8004966974,
-0.5067273378,
0.7383324504,
-0.2938861847,
-0.1838927269,
0.1949939281,
0.4508861601,
0.3216010928,
0.5001909137,
0.5142351389,
0.8405663371,
0.3411803246,
0.1285663098,
0.8394731283,
-0.3984214664,
0.4452368319,
1.1360909939,
-0.0131433709,
0.9265571833,
0.8435996771,
0.090439789,
0.2267991304,
0.581345737,
0.346224308,
0.8616756201,
-0.0829808861,
-0.3500749469,
-0.4897932112,
0.168737784,
-0.335624367,
0.590516746,
0.2093446702,
-0.4650881886,
-0.3531739712,
-0.1216608435,
-0.0036809086,
-0.4322426915,
-0.2418939173,
0.4954890311,
0.0532387793,
-0.6971812248,
0.5314694643,
-0.202368021,
0.8136962056,
-0.4537155032,
0.0036167032,
-0.1067724004,
0.3000968993,
0.1807360947,
-0.3053472638,
-0.0308912061,
-0.376729697,
-0.600441277,
-0.1661704034,
0.7437323332,
-0.5723474026,
-0.2202648818,
0.4558391571,
0.4025663435,
-0.0777238756,
-0.3759567142,
-0.3982425332,
0.1361401081,
-0.1416914761,
-0.4380037189,
0.4362308085,
0.2969156504,
-0.0708646476,
0.9113847613,
0.9206569791,
-0.3662914634,
0.1926212609,
0.0048127128,
1.1159510612,
-0.7160719037,
-0.4382780492,
-1.0987768173,
0.5367116928,
0.0277115107,
-0.3313509822,
0.4765852988,
0.6048697233,
0.6734303236,
-0.1091974378,
0.2869851589,
0.365555495,
-0.061829187,
-0.8396294713,
0.7467609644,
-1.0935876369,
-0.3453896046,
-0.4958519042,
-1.105012536,
-0.213790223,
0.5572473407,
0.1361423284,
0.1032839566,
0.7506452203,
0.931432724,
-0.2873923182,
-0.3900874257,
0.4233964384,
-0.0102879824,
0.2597374022,
0.5008199811,
0.7247995734,
-0.2868355215,
0.4584841728,
-0.0919433236,
-0.0001998585,
-0.4417417645,
-1.1362006664,
-0.7547051907,
-0.6901209354,
0.049069263,
-0.2285465747,
-0.114268899,
0.8492473364,
0.9892276525,
-0.4653983116,
0.2691926062,
0.2912835479,
-0.0381711498,
0.2220420837,
-0.2221587598,
0.2844337821,
-0.443605125,
-0.6255028248,
0.5753238797,
0.7983497381,
-0.1168599352,
-0.3067238629,
-0.1908969283,
-0.2424891889,
0.1792987585,
1.1260192394,
-0.0198439471,
-0.9733349085,
-0.3051982522,
0.1940889806,
-0.133132726,
0.2312550545,
0.8999869227,
-0.8265307546,
1.0666520596,
0.2914186418,
0.5987179875,
0.9665196538,
-0.2199883908,
0.4954083562,
-0.9131228328,
0.452249825,
0.0214199517,
0.4971098006,
0.0878438205,
-0.0445878804,
0.2860431373,
-0.0223028921,
-0.5051380992,
-0.8731009364,
0.2859551907,
-1.3183238506,
-0.2966913581,
0.8534926176,
-0.0346937329,
-0.2011196911,
0.1583481729,
-0.1846662313,
0.167529732,
-0.4987894595,
0.5324129462,
0.7379652262,
0.353479594,
-0.5896697044,
-0.5577629805,
0.6095922589,
0.5847620964,
-0.7766749859,
0.0543913133,
0.5942837,
0.0078209853,
0.0835458487,
0.4861533046,
0.0822053328,
0.3091574311,
-0.3058345914,
0.0315767266,
-0.0756997392,
-0.7192538977,
-0.066838488,
-0.0209233295,
-0.2565576732,
-0.2308392078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18135v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18135v1 | Automatic Speech Recognition for Hindi | 2024-06-26T07:39:20 | 2024-06-26T07:39:20 | Anish Saha, A. G. Ramakrishnan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Automatic speech recognition (ASR) is a key area in computational
linguistics, focusing on developing technologies that enable computers to
convert spoken language into text. This field combines linguistics and machine
learning. ASR models, which map speech audio to transcripts through supervised
learning, require handling real and unrestricted text. Text-to-speech systems
directly work with real text, while ASR systems rely on language models trained
on large text corpora. High-quality transcribed data is essential for training
predictive models. The research involved two main components: developing a web
application and designing a web interface for speech recognition. The web
application, created with JavaScript and Node.js, manages large volumes of
audio files and their transcriptions, facilitating collaborative human
correction of ASR transcripts. It operates in real-time using a client-server
architecture. The web interface for speech recognition records 16 kHz mono
audio from any device running the web app, performs voice activity detection
(VAD), and sends the audio to the recognition engine. VAD detects human speech
presence, aiding efficient speech processing and reducing unnecessary
processing during non-speech intervals, thus saving computation and network
bandwidth in VoIP applications. The final phase of the research tested a neural
network for accurately aligning the speech signal to hidden Markov model (HMM)
states. This included implementing a novel backpropagation method that utilizes
prior statistics of node co-activations. | [
-0.2518669665,
-0.602042377,
-0.1213059574,
0.3233290911,
-0.0962467864,
0.3826521933,
-0.1338773668,
-0.549341917,
0.0186200179,
0.2166683525,
-0.2613272071,
-0.24340415,
-0.4569196105,
0.132835865,
-0.8937684894,
0.4223288,
0.0838184357,
0.3986890018,
0.2317545563,
-0.0444501936,
-0.4271645248,
-0.4273663759,
-1.1036670208,
-0.4730040431,
0.1879294068,
0.3387310207,
0.3217972219,
0.6103072166,
0.652998507,
0.3968343139,
-0.0395688936,
-0.13216649,
0.0501561277,
0.1025933251,
-0.0411100164,
-0.1670004129,
-0.2290633917,
-0.3140632808,
0.791038692,
0.5485416055,
-0.501057446,
0.1582929343,
0.0161219649,
0.6739843488,
-0.4565536678,
0.1843741089,
-0.4109835923,
0.1271759272,
-0.4419259727,
-0.1478443891,
-0.1110969186,
-0.3536022902,
-0.0104696993,
-0.2519870102,
0.1661568433,
0.0348388776,
0.9012525678,
0.433524996,
-0.2286692709,
-0.6278474927,
-1.1617171764,
0.4398648143,
-0.4266812801,
0.8233376741,
0.5893121958,
0.6913591027,
0.1679555327,
-0.3186230958,
-0.7832477689,
-0.014627181,
0.2068911493,
0.1081497371,
-0.3483015299,
-0.1053641886,
0.0913820192,
0.5337183475,
-0.6790000796,
0.2503103614,
-0.6110885739,
-0.2957627475,
0.7156865597,
0.1187073588,
0.5787994266,
0.0233239438,
0.100906983,
-0.3087613285,
-0.5036537051,
0.2871402502,
0.293630898,
0.6388534307,
-0.3388105035,
0.5926806927,
-0.2927394509,
0.7645181417,
0.1918100417,
-0.2346819341,
0.2219360769,
-0.2959941924,
-0.2509672344,
0.6474645138,
0.855989933,
-0.2988394499,
0.2380805016,
0.1815373451,
-0.1006551757,
0.2471363842,
0.3187505901,
-0.2788466513,
-0.0722885653,
0.0829684362,
-0.2452639937,
0.0650656596,
-0.151006639,
-0.6149505377,
-0.1530728042,
-0.5398393273,
0.5401976109,
-0.4495047331,
-0.3777958751,
-0.0020842727,
-0.0982191637,
0.6626532078,
0.2891938984,
-0.8726524115,
0.7356601954,
0.345058471,
0.8624399304,
-0.2965120673,
-0.1351831108,
-0.4400552809,
0.3046135008,
-0.2020112723,
0.7130438685,
-0.4327353537,
-0.7977749705,
-0.0184927937,
-0.2565930188,
-0.1922685951,
-0.5513048768,
0.5103578568,
-0.4967828989,
-0.0802364498,
0.2023545802,
-0.3563854694,
-0.1816944778,
-0.0680276453,
-0.5120518208,
0.7286715508,
-0.3180190027,
-0.4481145144,
0.2527477145,
-0.9028057456,
-0.6070087552,
0.125311017,
-0.1468708813,
-0.5251036286,
-0.1324918866,
0.0505571999,
0.2308893502,
-0.2879249752,
-0.078244254,
0.388110131,
-0.3290573061,
0.2819888592,
-0.3241896927,
0.7819260955,
0.4853836,
-0.2396570295,
0.2813012898,
-1.0203868151,
0.1383618414,
-0.0833335519,
-0.5730606318,
0.040774975,
-0.0427001603,
0.378185153,
-0.00118474,
-0.0824580267,
-0.6374357939,
-0.3703280985,
-0.6041543484,
0.2821570933,
0.2867976129,
-0.3010576665,
0.3564837277,
0.0294153765,
0.429246515,
-0.0614526197,
0.0448862836,
0.1513982713,
-0.4303874969,
-0.6693643928,
-0.1279936582,
0.4997356236,
0.842361927,
-0.3950050473,
0.3696903586,
-0.2436962724,
-0.5698781013,
-0.6380378604,
0.1164705306,
0.824121654,
0.3502956033,
0.3689537942,
-0.4587600231,
-0.8189828396,
-0.6679115295,
-0.1345646083,
-0.2242567092,
0.1367428899,
0.0313323401,
0.0623831078,
-0.4684920013,
1.0020250082,
-0.37221241,
-0.6781900525,
-0.2531311512,
0.1539572626,
-0.0270847399,
0.7363777161,
-0.0569732748,
-1.1681421995,
-0.9359125495,
0.2107876241,
-0.38114959,
-0.2613371313,
0.4862936139,
0.4436199069,
0.2656162679,
0.4783993661,
-0.5148816705,
0.7484765053,
0.5739614367,
-0.025256766,
0.4637146592,
-0.0436389931,
0.2764799595,
-0.848634243,
0.2205019295,
-0.0536896624,
-0.2014240324,
-0.870888114,
-0.1984847337,
-0.179527998,
-0.7274612188,
-0.3197287023,
0.4513866305,
-0.5168859363,
-0.3299206495,
-0.5695201755,
-0.223828584,
-0.4472554922,
0.1083208397,
0.1334202737,
1.0867110491,
0.6671611667,
-0.7491220832,
0.4971052408,
0.423009187,
0.116257906,
0.3513923883,
-0.553380847,
0.0986849815,
0.236846298,
-0.1452925056,
-0.9510536194,
-0.3810125291,
0.163031131,
-1.0160901546,
0.6509528756,
0.0668715835,
-0.3097324073,
-0.5109046102,
0.1051344946,
0.2272166014,
0.5777511597,
-0.1902033538,
0.7755255699,
0.9548876286,
-0.2360111624,
-0.2248892784,
-0.6536186337,
0.1003355831,
-0.0402246416,
-0.2835469544,
0.1489605457,
0.1491363347,
-0.2338421941,
-0.156691879,
-0.1949599981,
-0.6011219025,
-0.2897548974,
0.5949373245,
-0.162724793,
-0.1363494247,
-0.1484041065,
-0.0710010752,
-0.277664274,
-0.2043379396,
0.0366761312,
0.7590378523,
-0.1227710992,
-0.5540117621,
-1.1997549534,
0.527790904,
0.4136736691,
-0.2245949507,
0.2116388381,
0.8142589927,
-0.6483694315,
0.2383067906,
-0.7300582528,
0.2920234799,
-0.5021839142,
0.0834993795,
-0.4315150678,
-0.5644620657,
0.4304822683,
0.0407711379,
-0.5543615818,
0.4035430849,
0.5638276339,
-0.0267464798,
1.0380147696,
0.6444209814,
-0.2490814179,
0.5288200974,
-0.0297665205,
0.3305602372,
-0.6901568174,
-0.234796688,
-0.87030828,
0.1849796176,
-0.4345082939,
-0.1274698824,
0.3556404412,
-0.1581016034,
-0.0369473025,
0.3746526241,
-0.788387835,
0.2034083009,
0.5599381328,
-0.1117178723,
0.171442464,
0.1769687086,
0.0179274529,
0.0366622061,
-0.2818594277,
-0.3380761743,
0.7393782139,
0.1996817589,
0.8334782124,
0.2499736547,
0.4367572963,
0.4064926207,
-0.2374255657,
-0.810890913,
0.592060864,
-0.3046081364,
-0.5402508378,
-0.5150766373,
-0.1727106273,
-0.9886331558,
-0.2320901752,
-0.0298915654,
-0.7104923725,
0.2485796809,
0.4719283879,
-0.5228044987,
-0.0043673143,
-0.9610290527,
0.345859617,
-0.1793569773,
-0.2751957774,
-0.3594319224,
-0.7637831569,
-0.0943801552,
-0.0295414757,
0.0807088837,
0.1668414772,
0.2353503108,
0.8539426923,
-0.1530794948,
0.7420656085,
-0.3548201621,
0.3315139711,
0.3297343552,
-0.2392980307,
0.0021032088,
-0.2944778204,
-0.0931758359,
0.2060916871,
0.0983988047,
-0.1453954726,
-0.193643406,
0.491966188,
-0.8737956882,
-0.5144143701,
-0.7132871747,
-0.2183470428,
-0.3531162143,
0.2476472408,
0.1619237065,
0.3799644411,
-0.2221389115,
0.134777993,
0.667455554,
-0.264139533,
0.5072789788,
0.5665041208,
-0.3270980418,
-0.4112993777,
1.0020160675,
0.1892196685,
0.0926298648,
0.5035752654,
0.2103981972,
-0.5968651175,
-0.8713192344,
-0.6175009608,
0.0209749602,
-0.5753127933,
-0.1868923008,
-0.7765496969,
-0.9075339437,
-0.7203702331,
-0.0037772038,
-0.4661602676,
-0.2202257663,
-0.325093478,
0.1939458251,
0.431729883,
0.6905519962,
-0.2258995771,
0.5424292088,
-0.7685259581,
0.4383798242,
0.4628636241,
0.2649797797,
0.0428310893,
-0.4698277116,
-0.2408872843,
0.0582777448,
-0.3382951915,
-0.7015708089,
0.7241148949,
0.6656561494,
0.3239648938,
0.3459145129,
-0.4796269834,
0.9425629973,
-0.6971959472,
0.6533412337,
0.4396736026,
-1.1308157444,
0.8400527835,
-0.3415344059,
0.3144969046,
0.442248553,
0.3991146088,
-0.4204955995,
0.0201385841,
-0.2248692214,
-0.6718682051,
0.576518178,
0.2019166201,
-0.1668182909,
0.3587435782,
0.3284240961,
0.0152866431,
0.2176427692,
-0.3709283173,
-0.0777941346,
-0.3749372959,
-0.4662314057,
-0.0969616547,
-0.0197660364,
0.2000999451,
-0.5578017235,
0.5694417357,
0.0915648937,
0.4065355957,
0.2281425148,
-0.0409386419,
-0.2477155477,
0.3149554133,
0.6035884023,
0.491050452,
-0.0017241111,
-0.0403658599,
0.2617481649,
-0.9227131009,
0.3768311143,
0.2437948585,
0.0054967138,
0.0632286668,
-0.076039657,
0.6430310011,
-0.2014045566,
-0.7493689656,
0.3631029129,
-0.2105422467,
0.157114327,
-0.9453772902,
0.3413185477,
-0.002124083,
0.1234246045,
0.6655837297,
0.105871506,
0.4714513123,
-0.7273725271,
0.208880201,
0.3431845009,
-0.6670385599,
-0.354986757,
0.5545524359,
0.0873703063,
-1.058427453,
0.3194865882,
-0.2087179273,
-0.6943054199,
0.4093647301,
0.7118873596,
0.8126004338,
-1.0210084915,
-0.207615152,
0.3854499757,
-0.2586651742,
-0.1495430171,
0.471891135,
-0.0270325951,
-0.4939357638,
-0.1172072738,
-0.967895329,
-0.5155155659,
-0.0857471302,
-0.6471639872,
0.4400296509,
-0.5146670938,
-0.232650727,
0.148894161,
-0.0406094752,
-0.4091017246,
0.6787839532,
0.0147096831,
0.511695087,
-0.7427589297,
1.0457223654,
0.6330314875,
-0.4214549661,
-0.9138309956,
-0.1011466086,
0.3296633959,
-0.761117816,
0.9167494774,
-0.045317255,
-0.6548451185,
0.4114146829,
-0.1919398159,
-1.0333125591,
0.8238199353,
-0.133861959,
-0.7391370535,
-0.0097511234,
0.160959363,
0.7535085082,
-0.0987086743,
-0.2199677974,
0.2994243205,
0.147376284,
0.2870979607,
-1.5248668194,
-0.3147135079,
-0.4677761793,
0.0746459812,
0.2172812372,
-0.5166957974,
0.5702545047,
0.1349661499,
-0.3979863226,
-0.0235104766,
0.4792173207,
0.1972363591,
0.5251362324,
0.4424650371,
0.4857171476,
0.3964073658,
-0.0486258678,
0.6990574002,
-0.0588476211,
-0.1883472055,
0.7752949595,
-0.4644621313,
1.2110414505,
0.3739396334,
-0.3609720469,
0.1060247645,
0.4716961384,
0.0630125031,
0.4474958479,
0.3294087946,
-0.3707853556,
0.3483844995,
-0.3152411878,
-0.4260302484,
0.9793692827,
0.645057857,
0.0498508662,
0.1798803955,
0.361492902,
-0.3259872198,
0.2586582601,
-0.4966626763,
1.0899375677,
0.1534068882,
-0.4023160934,
0.4646903276,
-0.0775250047,
0.6840680242,
-0.7486633658,
0.0423509404,
0.5078549385,
0.3211683035,
-0.3966640532,
-0.4564629495,
1.0183192492,
0.4026088715,
-0.2366524041,
-0.198497206,
0.9279133081,
-0.2395615876,
-0.4251866341,
0.3178607523,
0.3860257864,
0.3463116586,
0.0825190619,
-0.5508996844,
0.3940360248,
-0.2042274028,
0.277281791,
0.3676470816,
0.0925550759,
0.1013401523,
0.8827486634,
0.7794331908,
0.5084187984,
0.1581489593,
0.1725336313,
0.6483303308,
-0.7645996213,
-0.6840236187,
-0.6405854225,
0.1611729115,
-0.033804629,
0.0254277475,
0.7346503735,
0.7030923963,
0.6686966419,
0.1011802033,
0.5910739899,
-0.083238937,
1.030595541,
-0.4344986975,
0.9727122188,
-0.4397473037,
0.0289592035,
-0.2319924533,
-0.3607210815,
-0.5492157936,
0.7506186366,
-0.1471261829,
-0.073566556,
0.4733031988,
0.7120622993,
-0.0322494209,
0.1664068997,
0.2817316949,
-0.0994163156,
0.1867996603,
0.0637120381,
0.7576599121,
-0.473261416,
0.5497217178,
0.0086890152,
0.0061397799,
-0.2791855335,
-0.2929854393,
-0.4217081964,
-0.983312726,
-0.3815286756,
-0.2051561773,
0.3896820247,
0.9466325641,
0.8083277345,
-1.0843912363,
-0.7846441865,
-0.1505336612,
-0.2852193713,
-0.1279404312,
-0.2278645784,
0.4352819026,
0.1029858589,
-0.6675149798,
0.3890943229,
0.4812468886,
0.2408546358,
-0.1318362504,
-0.076509878,
-0.6489396095,
-0.1715067774,
0.3569803536,
0.7900503874,
-0.7036842108,
-0.1093139872,
-0.1762936413,
-0.0943748951,
0.3999644518,
0.5857734084,
-0.476092577,
0.504858017,
0.4665813744,
0.7736368775,
0.5018745661,
0.1733610183,
0.5048625469,
-0.5917311907,
0.1044760868,
0.4837565422,
0.07963375,
0.6950484514,
-0.349453032,
0.2826031148,
0.1129852831,
-0.5390353799,
-1.0253732204,
0.0886337757,
-1.0405399799,
0.1808253378,
0.883897841,
0.1557674259,
-0.2002604306,
-0.5905079246,
-0.4113819897,
0.7579351664,
-0.4676333666,
0.6379998922,
0.4334491789,
-0.5594469905,
-0.3748697042,
-0.5931266546,
0.6630915403,
0.0247329623,
-0.6042125225,
-0.2275002897,
0.2269122601,
0.1912320852,
0.540817678,
0.9257436991,
-0.1550251245,
0.2758447528,
0.1403010637,
0.242350474,
0.1478423178,
-0.2016361058,
-0.7368162274,
0.2494105101,
0.1805687398,
-0.5009093285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18134v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18134v1 | Assessing "Implicit" Retrieval Robustness of Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T07:38:24 | 2024-06-26T07:38:24 | Xiaoyu Shen, Rexhina Blloshmi, Dawei Zhu, Jiahuan Pei, Wei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-augmented generation has gained popularity as a framework to
enhance large language models with external knowledge. However, its
effectiveness hinges on the retrieval robustness of the model. If the model
lacks retrieval robustness, its performance is constrained by the accuracy of
the retriever, resulting in significant compromises when the retrieved context
is irrelevant. In this paper, we evaluate the "implicit" retrieval robustness
of various large language models, instructing them to directly output the final
answer without explicitly judging the relevance of the retrieved context. Our
findings reveal that fine-tuning on a mix of gold and distracting context
significantly enhances the model's robustness to retrieval inaccuracies, while
still maintaining its ability to extract correct answers when retrieval is
accurate. This suggests that large language models can implicitly handle
relevant or irrelevant retrieved context by learning solely from the
supervision of the final answer in an end-to-end manner. Introducing an
additional process for explicit relevance judgment can be unnecessary and
disrupts the end-to-end approach. | [
-0.2409073859,
-0.9026139379,
0.751933217,
0.0063286508,
-0.1083153859,
-0.2727335691,
-0.4270402193,
-0.6570045948,
-0.4678416848,
0.2646490932,
-0.2833358943,
-0.2361506075,
-0.6971430182,
0.1959038377,
-0.6058368087,
0.877358973,
0.2738934159,
-0.2437758446,
-0.2051056176,
-0.1261006147,
-0.4639465213,
-0.5458793044,
-0.6144999266,
-0.1666132361,
0.3888995945,
0.0953432992,
0.7522825003,
0.6126869917,
0.2661630511,
0.374705404,
-0.4269713759,
0.2479132414,
-0.6527456641,
0.4260878265,
-0.5389448404,
-0.3038749397,
-0.3687368333,
-0.2713449597,
0.6932834983,
0.8169572353,
0.1388493776,
0.319927901,
0.3292401433,
0.5132936835,
-1.1561954021,
0.1977791339,
-1.0081523657,
-0.3884443939,
0.0670099482,
-0.2339713275,
-0.747381568,
-0.1837918013,
0.4037685096,
-0.4588345289,
0.1822859049,
-0.0411566384,
0.755073905,
0.3383046389,
-0.5807662606,
-0.3050600886,
-1.0039781332,
0.7011304498,
-0.4854827225,
0.2541226745,
0.723847568,
0.3141345382,
0.0404235758,
-0.815331161,
-0.2242360711,
-0.5302734971,
-0.1494292915,
0.0549589619,
-0.0328574739,
0.052696798,
0.4909962714,
0.3038311899,
-0.1820865273,
-0.1235009208,
-0.1870458275,
-0.0718635619,
0.4670437872,
-0.2201265842,
0.2630265057,
-0.0469159931,
-0.0081580291,
0.0503070131,
-0.7257096171,
-0.0261248406,
0.4620941579,
0.6836988926,
0.3274888992,
0.6572551727,
-0.3914531767,
0.6323963404,
0.2395504117,
0.2156856209,
0.0224819332,
-0.3397940397,
-0.0580666363,
-0.0406463332,
0.4033804834,
-0.0155327301,
0.2852707207,
-0.3720525801,
-0.4444952905,
-0.1891119927,
0.3638765216,
-0.8196741343,
0.0686904192,
0.3779555261,
-0.0958962739,
-0.0543032438,
0.0971973166,
-0.4542562366,
-0.0429721586,
-0.1871661395,
0.6766943932,
-0.2500837743,
-0.2616256177,
-0.1713881642,
0.0443861373,
0.0916894674,
0.317858994,
-1.006246686,
0.1367829144,
0.8056244254,
0.6430459619,
0.1156594455,
0.0262274388,
-1.1035255194,
0.3189774156,
-0.4843171239,
0.5989770293,
-0.7056291103,
-0.3301636279,
0.3345231116,
0.0638670772,
0.0922357216,
-0.5000184774,
0.7889799476,
-0.8521215916,
0.1357198209,
-0.5201182365,
-0.3167490959,
-0.0506625958,
0.2968659699,
-0.6775271893,
0.968152225,
0.0568076223,
-0.6762866974,
0.5602174997,
-0.2213212997,
-0.418820709,
-0.0405227244,
0.0478413478,
-0.2655901909,
0.1954679936,
0.3552183807,
0.3152377605,
-0.0239418969,
0.3348335624,
-0.5462072492,
-0.6114534736,
0.0871480107,
-0.5953984261,
0.4702423811,
0.0734188482,
-0.360193193,
-0.0302409213,
-0.8028121591,
0.0466006584,
-0.1495553404,
-0.4512448311,
-0.6833170056,
-0.0426122695,
-0.0900069922,
0.2542876899,
0.3465284407,
-0.3827126622,
-0.0506111644,
-0.5391438603,
0.1678133756,
0.9186481237,
-0.0947722346,
0.6165486574,
-0.1981059462,
0.2062752694,
-0.2755803466,
0.0669831559,
-0.2300983965,
-0.1877347678,
-0.5851387382,
-0.1271700561,
0.4560289979,
0.388235122,
-0.6686064005,
0.3694595993,
-0.4495637417,
-0.147317946,
-0.3143804669,
0.3681718409,
0.6034449339,
0.6240229011,
0.349847734,
0.0347899273,
-0.3244808018,
-0.867967248,
-0.4648053348,
-0.2414719164,
0.027503062,
0.5481174588,
0.6056178212,
-0.2392563373,
0.7650596499,
-0.134324491,
0.0183512084,
0.0770819709,
0.1597668082,
0.0521882437,
0.60043329,
0.4113150537,
-0.9830113649,
-0.4122768044,
0.241496101,
-0.7424576879,
-0.1592833251,
0.1274395287,
-0.1713208407,
0.24647744,
0.5091418624,
-0.6350997686,
0.2407262623,
0.1893144846,
-0.2673514783,
0.4749765396,
-0.3712102771,
0.107330285,
-0.7645395994,
0.6808810234,
-0.279607892,
-0.2201671451,
-0.4483496845,
0.3587297797,
0.169897005,
0.226715222,
-0.354049921,
0.7088956237,
-0.5778301358,
-0.2512277663,
-0.2595428526,
0.2210126221,
-0.0440093912,
0.1721335202,
-0.0140378168,
0.9639455676,
0.2786467969,
-0.8089976311,
0.0007778461,
0.2283704728,
-0.2529044747,
0.4321732223,
-0.7468675375,
0.2135471851,
-0.4760817289,
-0.0263535772,
-0.923955977,
-0.4284613132,
-0.2320363075,
-0.4375775456,
0.5466536283,
-0.5261343718,
-0.5090525746,
-0.0888587609,
-0.2496610135,
0.4169189036,
0.5250219107,
-0.6050104499,
0.6163030267,
0.0505503863,
-0.3460818529,
-1.0283821821,
-0.5035566092,
-0.1081803143,
-0.1789479554,
-0.4626910686,
0.05318911,
-0.1126113236,
-0.3099527359,
0.0008699333,
-0.2732628584,
0.0044013583,
0.2579212487,
0.0527157113,
0.1998552978,
-0.1163878292,
0.0872347355,
0.1224751547,
-0.0835106,
0.1323277652,
-0.066192016,
0.3670291603,
-0.1859381646,
-0.5365146399,
0.1269135326,
0.3448491096,
0.6657544971,
-0.3453157842,
0.8850997686,
0.5381689072,
-0.5079938173,
-0.123079963,
-0.6311127543,
-0.1202335358,
-0.5159525275,
0.4393871427,
-0.3757247925,
-0.9104140997,
0.7175735235,
-0.0147645669,
0.1479607224,
0.4772514105,
0.4102393687,
0.2608127892,
1.6671617031,
0.596499145,
0.2435106784,
0.5507469177,
-0.0628665537,
0.0447327495,
-1.1020565033,
-0.3275029659,
-0.7987225652,
0.1658837944,
-0.5600795746,
0.1580474526,
0.2643793523,
0.3347398043,
-0.4853722453,
-0.0105627673,
-0.3648394048,
0.4282640815,
0.5137743354,
0.1050870195,
0.5201399922,
0.0721732825,
-0.1069573238,
0.0120607289,
-0.393581599,
-0.6278125048,
0.9846356511,
0.1118470058,
0.6604193449,
0.421480149,
0.1778900027,
0.1291084737,
0.4267014563,
-0.4681479037,
0.2995589077,
-0.089337863,
-0.6840880513,
-0.1918721348,
-0.6122822165,
-1.1048771143,
0.4508273005,
-0.19837524,
-0.9949225783,
0.2019418329,
0.2379813939,
-0.4421570003,
-0.0985300168,
-0.8596653342,
0.6405960321,
-0.1481065899,
-0.8969426751,
0.1319433749,
-0.6123054028,
0.51822263,
-0.2993527055,
0.1897138953,
0.1060700119,
-0.1021130607,
0.2591553926,
-0.2386618406,
0.5808929205,
0.0113879954,
-0.3842000067,
0.1035468429,
0.3484321237,
0.6373900175,
0.2392634749,
-0.3014906049,
-0.5142921805,
0.0724490434,
-0.4228337705,
-0.8013340831,
0.9211788774,
-0.5852649808,
-0.8500295281,
-0.2580780685,
-0.47305879,
-0.4821082056,
0.500374198,
0.2475746572,
0.5715239048,
-0.0009158232,
0.3685192764,
0.7399638295,
-0.2798434496,
0.3019271195,
0.5842556953,
-0.2230334431,
-0.184468627,
0.7753919363,
0.2309430391,
0.4929947257,
0.1879697293,
0.0659881085,
-0.6677761078,
-0.4798285067,
-0.4774924517,
0.1011150181,
-0.8390566111,
-0.0253900997,
-0.6542383432,
-0.1294258833,
-0.3849589527,
-0.0087838434,
-0.2919081151,
-0.1225696355,
-0.2702977657,
-0.1410517097,
0.074090451,
0.6437919736,
0.0630048513,
-0.0294251218,
-0.8094144464,
0.1116741076,
0.5701618195,
0.3802976608,
0.0143330339,
-0.7121891379,
-0.0362787955,
0.1937352568,
0.0817327201,
-0.5609987378,
0.1811260283,
0.3686326742,
0.5927839279,
0.3895711005,
0.2256689668,
0.738304615,
-0.4256392717,
0.8094217181,
-0.416934818,
-0.8902551532,
0.832190156,
-0.466117233,
0.4624271095,
0.7474879622,
0.224016428,
0.0923502743,
-0.377563864,
-0.5627857447,
-1.2284677029,
0.5706678033,
0.2105264217,
0.470289737,
-0.2139379233,
0.5866544247,
-0.0573903993,
0.3086688519,
-0.7369813919,
0.0032103804,
0.1623868644,
-0.0120544508,
0.0712959915,
-0.4870702624,
-0.0663117692,
-0.0672230646,
0.8465130925,
-0.3075051308,
0.0194155797,
0.1684611887,
-0.345457375,
-0.3239469528,
0.3317596614,
0.4353450239,
0.7933228612,
-0.4473528266,
0.2803233564,
0.2559991479,
-0.385735333,
-0.0379660204,
0.1346245557,
-0.5601201653,
-0.15140827,
0.4837821424,
0.5621939898,
0.2858700752,
-0.8532312512,
0.6573262215,
-0.1494913697,
0.1684588492,
-0.2386940718,
0.1048566252,
-0.3025422692,
0.1706366539,
0.6298406124,
0.0929270089,
0.3022825718,
-0.6618808508,
0.2216107398,
0.7807614207,
-0.3715591133,
-0.2383621335,
0.8878857493,
-0.0923259035,
0.0765936077,
0.6527093053,
0.0280936006,
-0.4348695874,
0.400282681,
0.7279803753,
0.6984216571,
-0.1758800894,
-0.1631733924,
0.480586201,
0.4302329719,
-0.3113532662,
0.1216129065,
-0.2269217074,
-0.4616749585,
-0.8656289577,
-0.5626679659,
-0.1566116661,
0.2378087193,
-0.9687612057,
0.0132683748,
-0.259269774,
-0.2618426383,
-0.3441572487,
-0.1048663631,
-0.4152320325,
0.2888586819,
-0.0288069267,
0.9065999985,
-0.6608585119,
0.4620171785,
0.6836330891,
-0.543469131,
-0.6068837643,
0.1485949457,
-0.421359092,
-0.5384389162,
0.6253730059,
0.2279754728,
-0.3463929892,
-0.0307459533,
-0.6833223104,
-1.1000090837,
0.8625048995,
0.8692380786,
-0.162053898,
0.0244247578,
-0.2705319524,
0.7450389266,
0.1793316454,
0.5205990076,
0.4713510573,
0.3208038509,
0.3103107512,
-0.9549123049,
0.1853137165,
-0.4897444546,
0.1900229454,
-0.0003394753,
-0.4814360142,
0.7085369825,
-0.1346291006,
-0.479734093,
0.3132166862,
0.727468729,
0.2483705133,
0.0011618608,
0.4046092033,
0.314936012,
0.7470126152,
-0.1368011087,
1.2830251455,
-0.2711358368,
0.4369143546,
1.1028944254,
-0.281339407,
1.1508795023,
0.3225909472,
0.1616977006,
0.218778789,
0.3132368326,
0.4199207425,
0.6914696097,
-0.2046565413,
-0.3930575252,
-0.4337755144,
-0.2530923784,
-0.5159166455,
0.2010865211,
0.4627186954,
-0.4165630639,
-0.2425932586,
-0.1954761893,
-0.0164387282,
0.1881848574,
-0.4309429526,
0.8163154721,
0.0080056088,
-1.0579544306,
0.6848493218,
-0.2123103887,
0.4695676863,
-0.5174946785,
-0.2023381293,
-0.1767285913,
0.3241868317,
-0.2935130894,
-0.7021576166,
0.2857631147,
0.1149500236,
-0.1786830127,
0.0840757787,
0.8043931127,
-0.4529933333,
-0.3627020717,
0.361007452,
0.5681084394,
-0.2306948304,
-0.1435105652,
-0.3975562751,
0.0287909023,
-0.3000650108,
-0.320694387,
0.464785099,
0.5406065583,
-0.0007277563,
0.9088090062,
0.8383894563,
0.0234451015,
0.0803755522,
0.0257983487,
0.700599432,
-0.1611854881,
-0.3398442864,
-0.948097229,
0.4795405865,
-0.1432625949,
-0.1327757537,
0.9451856613,
0.3718227148,
0.8050941825,
0.1541018635,
0.716125071,
0.0867693126,
0.4431952834,
-0.5377728939,
0.5860826969,
-0.6468911767,
0.5572891831,
-0.4598734379,
-1.0402556658,
-0.271168679,
0.6265780926,
-0.4664936364,
0.5966565013,
0.3257042766,
0.713929832,
-0.2936333418,
-0.17077595,
0.3772165775,
0.3700091839,
0.1024252325,
0.3008102179,
0.9123584032,
-0.3735215664,
0.6705308557,
-0.0944045261,
-0.1704704911,
-0.15115197,
-0.9287361503,
-0.8320348859,
-0.5700019002,
-0.0940370858,
-0.6417356133,
0.221839413,
0.7474609017,
0.670740962,
-0.8054792881,
0.3408908546,
-0.021242151,
-0.006940085,
-0.1538323611,
-0.2088197768,
0.4783430099,
-0.4878757,
-0.9312351942,
0.3300096691,
0.0438455492,
-0.0888147429,
-0.2361042649,
0.1088068485,
-0.2044052333,
-0.0582907349,
0.8222279549,
0.4111380577,
-0.6489870548,
-0.6295404434,
0.0130183678,
-0.189314276,
-0.293666482,
0.4117092192,
-0.7847471833,
0.4936549962,
0.3879398406,
0.8733730912,
0.4367728531,
0.4094780087,
0.7530319691,
-1.0635691881,
-0.0200585574,
0.0591456257,
0.4273444414,
0.4281198084,
-0.6322526932,
0.4687385261,
-0.114312388,
-0.6288123727,
-1.0123490095,
0.1255873442,
-0.653156817,
-0.2756517529,
1.4234770536,
-0.179255411,
-0.284527272,
-0.2673032284,
-0.2914862037,
0.2353894711,
-0.3228507638,
0.817073524,
0.6557615995,
0.2761723101,
-0.1386707872,
-0.8137366772,
0.424814254,
0.6329573393,
-0.5526248813,
0.1464496255,
0.5762739182,
0.316459626,
0.2527997494,
0.3843667209,
-0.1409926265,
0.3460309207,
-0.1775202304,
-0.5173927546,
-0.0278653968,
-0.3048366904,
-0.3696468174,
0.3217886686,
0.4217401445,
0.2403286994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18133v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18133v1 | ConvoCache: Smart Re-Use of Chatbot Responses | 2024-06-26T07:35:10 | 2024-06-26T07:35:10 | Conor Atkins, Ian Wood, Mohamed Ali Kaafar, Hassan Asghar, Nardine Basta, Michal Kepkowski | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present ConvoCache, a conversational caching system that solves the
problem of slow and expensive generative AI models in spoken chatbots.
ConvoCache finds a semantically similar prompt in the past and reuses the
response. In this paper we evaluate ConvoCache on the DailyDialog dataset. We
find that ConvoCache can apply a UniEval coherence threshold of 90% and respond
to 89% of prompts using the cache with an average latency of 214ms, replacing
LLM and voice synthesis that can take over 1s. To further reduce latency we
test prefetching and find limited usefulness. Prefetching with 80% of a request
leads to a 63% hit rate, and a drop in overall coherence. ConvoCache can be
used with any chatbot to reduce costs by reducing usage of generative AI by up
to 89%. | [
-0.4252126813,
-1.027172327,
0.2175134271,
0.0978328213,
-0.2595205307,
0.1689646989,
0.0045124697,
-0.7885257006,
0.631480217,
0.6295256019,
-0.8836207986,
-0.1416723132,
-0.1014513597,
-0.1217485517,
-0.8093307614,
0.7183899879,
0.5137841702,
-0.0922814533,
-0.4148796797,
0.2633630633,
-0.765450716,
-0.3739349544,
-1.2496381998,
-0.4895329177,
0.4985277951,
0.750900209,
0.9744545817,
-0.2728693783,
0.2893218398,
0.3685041666,
0.1525045931,
0.0605838671,
-0.7511322498,
0.6705954671,
0.1583278924,
-0.6066119075,
-0.3104719222,
0.0013353571,
0.03898146,
0.502592504,
-0.3627624512,
-0.1020551324,
0.0947095081,
0.4715939164,
-0.8380485773,
0.1102287397,
-0.9003090858,
0.1571801901,
0.0033035579,
-0.2920217514,
-0.5601998568,
-0.4395645857,
0.4734881818,
-0.8433391452,
0.6037740111,
-0.1541794091,
0.4799342453,
0.5706486106,
0.3081321418,
-0.379822284,
-0.6649581194,
0.7011123896,
-0.6515294313,
0.1614060998,
0.5762646198,
0.5723612905,
-0.4978547692,
-0.9252243638,
-0.8943110108,
-0.4341192544,
0.1051319167,
0.3984878361,
-0.3328841925,
-0.0414065011,
0.0958713368,
0.4273673892,
-0.4504861832,
0.1207795814,
0.1074676663,
-0.7426527739,
0.4257789552,
0.4906310439,
0.4120152891,
0.3151076436,
-0.1844741851,
-0.2942138016,
-0.5951191783,
0.3204474747,
0.3697648346,
0.2445145696,
0.0473975502,
0.3198793828,
-0.4308734834,
0.5573543906,
0.1336827874,
0.1148896813,
0.1466995627,
-0.4872926474,
-0.3586078286,
0.2727086246,
0.706872046,
0.3115472496,
0.3620176017,
-0.0974246711,
0.2327230871,
0.0906615108,
0.5366021395,
-1.1901608706,
-0.4560699761,
0.4348849356,
-0.2332789153,
-0.2205272019,
-0.4113512337,
-0.6935223341,
-0.4276168048,
0.1435207576,
0.1121947244,
-0.3558929265,
-0.0243566372,
0.2186231315,
-0.2181489021,
0.1681555063,
0.7540999055,
-0.7550125718,
0.3514121473,
0.4986690283,
0.8827448487,
0.002152507,
0.0383958295,
-0.6081668139,
-0.3158787489,
-0.2192053497,
1.1710498333,
-0.703022182,
-0.8369642496,
-0.007601033,
0.1944458932,
0.2227672935,
-0.6030256748,
0.3548813462,
-0.6046685576,
0.3538397849,
-0.2091651559,
-0.4982424378,
-0.1898681968,
0.1994438916,
-0.8669573069,
0.6299594045,
-0.1700131744,
-0.4442445636,
0.287668556,
-0.5336943269,
-0.5423457623,
0.3465417325,
0.18454732,
-0.4242684245,
-0.2766477466,
0.1829601079,
0.2566848397,
-0.3805937767,
0.105327189,
-0.4229604006,
-0.7057144046,
0.139621824,
-0.7266066074,
0.9229462147,
0.3804825544,
-0.3183849156,
-0.0436487384,
-0.6825309992,
0.198367089,
0.0518948101,
-0.1234060824,
-0.1220409721,
0.2513498664,
-0.0777504668,
-0.1492539644,
0.2837583721,
-0.6636794209,
-0.0055647325,
-0.6860286593,
0.4674749076,
0.5710808039,
0.0569391176,
0.2448765337,
-0.2830067575,
0.3944551647,
-0.0586607158,
0.1981918812,
-0.3964264393,
-0.5418145657,
-1.0133252144,
-0.3164135218,
-0.061943274,
0.5361186862,
-0.7709158659,
0.4766910076,
0.1069259271,
-0.8302671313,
-0.6184847355,
-0.1347908676,
0.336927861,
0.5842734575,
0.397721231,
-0.7083865404,
-0.1318410635,
-0.8621827364,
0.0846439376,
-0.1711245328,
-0.1061573029,
0.2552761137,
0.0405861959,
-0.2221104205,
0.8784570098,
-0.2588972747,
0.0777240545,
0.1062916294,
0.0884423926,
0.0709398463,
0.5269786716,
0.358478725,
-0.5596513748,
-0.4391104877,
-0.499899745,
-0.419365257,
-0.2083354741,
-0.2436514646,
-0.0693450496,
0.2654536963,
0.6218318939,
-0.783749342,
0.6366934776,
0.6468240619,
-0.0862239078,
0.409869194,
-0.1855115294,
0.207205236,
-1.012116909,
0.1101330593,
-0.7042919397,
-0.3723708093,
-0.3827557862,
-0.148485586,
-0.4089576304,
-0.5029379725,
-0.6971927285,
0.5962973237,
-0.2441122085,
0.0962223187,
-0.58716923,
0.180888325,
-0.1310719252,
0.512196064,
-0.378318578,
0.9230540395,
0.4674763978,
-0.8478326201,
0.7344375253,
0.195806697,
-0.1937201172,
0.4903018475,
-1.0502489805,
0.5414589643,
0.2165893018,
0.841604948,
-1.3547873497,
0.0029117486,
0.4900912941,
-0.4461292028,
-0.1103158966,
0.0457062945,
-0.5690307021,
-0.2162028104,
-0.2896257043,
0.351180464,
0.3088021278,
-0.48947528,
0.5122870207,
0.4631994963,
-0.0756595507,
-0.4231061041,
-0.4105816782,
0.2997304201,
0.2679081857,
-0.6432785392,
0.3758174777,
-0.3902674913,
0.0240584668,
-0.1105529964,
-0.0516465902,
0.2064077407,
0.3757017255,
0.4857679009,
-0.0766915157,
0.1956156343,
0.1533402503,
-0.1468773782,
-0.3958265781,
-0.1614749581,
-0.0915060714,
1.2849793434,
0.0933466926,
-0.3386478126,
-0.9609100819,
0.5484778285,
0.5796921253,
0.0564564876,
0.5906082988,
0.4100203812,
-0.3605965078,
0.1953066438,
-0.532976687,
-0.5401605368,
-0.5334021449,
0.071071282,
-0.3089657724,
-0.8567460775,
0.9066513181,
0.269310683,
0.3658508062,
0.4626296163,
0.8791431785,
-0.2972860932,
0.7945331335,
0.4440190494,
-0.2630099952,
0.8777981997,
-0.2722609043,
0.3666881621,
-0.0490576513,
-0.2712584138,
-0.7825214267,
-0.4195147455,
-0.8660036325,
-0.1290514767,
0.0233524702,
-0.4284662902,
-0.1992190033,
0.4095733166,
-0.3764472604,
0.2460856587,
0.668926537,
0.3443694115,
0.1524226964,
-0.1559820324,
0.3030006289,
0.2872128785,
-0.5403293371,
-0.2185469419,
0.646936655,
-0.1617671996,
0.9873641133,
-0.1314380467,
0.4369156361,
0.4811382294,
-0.1161797568,
-0.9461337924,
0.8458542228,
-0.0030064571,
-0.4688604474,
-0.4631584287,
-0.172929287,
-1.4941855669,
-0.0641580448,
-0.1444485933,
-0.5243666172,
-0.0221715476,
0.3733409941,
-0.5263758302,
-0.0328918546,
-0.8908191919,
0.5639921427,
0.2648070157,
-0.163442269,
-0.8949738741,
-0.589179635,
-0.1673481017,
0.1845148355,
-0.3770440221,
-0.2232062668,
0.3983094692,
0.5894578099,
-0.8478660583,
1.2353893518,
-0.309885025,
-0.1124576777,
0.693418622,
0.3074683845,
0.7163359523,
0.1348464638,
0.1484282464,
0.0971043557,
0.0351555347,
-0.6718677878,
-0.7624114156,
0.8075485826,
-0.6474758387,
-0.8876909018,
-0.1958247721,
-0.3608810902,
-0.1544429362,
0.1328092217,
0.174319759,
0.4612199068,
-0.4853273034,
0.3389377296,
0.444476217,
-0.3103366494,
0.5108371973,
0.5649779439,
0.2572050095,
0.0790378675,
0.586664319,
-0.0883788913,
0.3200731575,
0.2662757933,
0.1325887889,
0.0524698943,
-0.1240195408,
-0.0943255126,
-0.3457871079,
-0.3844679594,
-0.3796934485,
-1.0021806955,
-0.2752181292,
-0.3398019671,
-0.1851304322,
-0.6592828631,
-0.388310194,
-0.3627725542,
0.192852959,
0.4899997711,
-0.0916683376,
0.192208603,
0.5208317041,
-0.6202856302,
0.2002542168,
0.6375771761,
0.0611540154,
0.0401152223,
-0.2825467288,
-0.1271651089,
0.3990287185,
-0.4576874375,
-0.6008760929,
0.2150962502,
0.1979803592,
0.5757712126,
0.1792256087,
0.1484227628,
0.8631373644,
-0.326730907,
0.9952203631,
0.2038465887,
-0.7917408943,
0.5663929582,
0.1106164753,
0.6548061371,
0.6900731921,
-0.0033249292,
-0.7698835731,
-0.8858379126,
-0.7848672271,
-1.0525755882,
0.1155234203,
0.171977967,
0.7086107135,
-0.0770241395,
0.3013291359,
0.294857204,
-0.0054823891,
0.0695022568,
0.0391194262,
-0.2791955173,
-0.0292156283,
-0.1662603319,
-0.2089183629,
0.1113396809,
0.0747413486,
0.4595038593,
-0.1405741423,
0.525331974,
0.1708181202,
-0.1134010181,
-0.0006853694,
0.052857317,
0.3859715164,
0.2239224762,
-0.0920163319,
0.0678261071,
0.1677599549,
-0.6530890465,
-0.0885749459,
-0.0668641701,
-0.0303060878,
-0.0782551542,
0.2651831508,
0.320692122,
0.2431312352,
-0.6944807172,
0.2220982909,
-0.5232664347,
0.2684171796,
-0.4752195179,
0.6270259023,
0.0031360572,
0.2678624094,
0.1267517507,
0.1412335485,
0.3107760549,
-0.8997344375,
0.2287107855,
0.5547681451,
-0.3468366265,
-0.2407991141,
0.3416259289,
0.5311890244,
-0.5616318583,
0.95016855,
0.0844880417,
-0.3201555312,
0.5652070045,
0.431450665,
1.0783172846,
-0.166108042,
0.2001546919,
0.3386918306,
-0.2350971401,
0.232594803,
0.1569171846,
-0.3475018144,
-0.9441571236,
-0.3144831657,
-0.1119473577,
-0.8777599931,
0.0112103336,
-0.359465003,
0.0675440729,
-0.4314400852,
-0.2717572749,
0.2021587789,
0.277819097,
-0.9654445052,
0.0722709149,
-0.265830189,
0.8218194842,
-0.4728071392,
0.6641390324,
0.0679635182,
-0.3514153063,
-0.3500649929,
0.1057578921,
-0.0623443723,
-1.0973864794,
0.1670569777,
0.1468926817,
-0.7034217715,
-0.0666267723,
-1.1870802641,
-0.5850633383,
0.9594635963,
0.4736235738,
-0.5351686478,
0.2590270042,
-0.4023704827,
0.8390368819,
-0.2092903107,
0.4509556293,
0.5223257542,
0.1240637973,
0.3628044724,
-0.7929236293,
0.0691140518,
-0.4028418958,
-0.2143420726,
-0.1965174675,
-0.9481599331,
0.5530974865,
-0.1483848244,
-0.6052020788,
0.2262822837,
0.5610949993,
0.0923711732,
0.3473203778,
0.6451687813,
0.5628564358,
0.8433326483,
0.0935942978,
0.9243154526,
-0.155008018,
0.1271712929,
1.1215718985,
-0.1190496981,
0.7187607884,
0.4803617299,
0.0961239189,
0.6079630852,
0.7096582055,
0.2726517916,
0.7863862514,
0.3627412319,
-0.4181473553,
-0.3103427589,
-0.3628236055,
-0.3535017669,
0.4450977743,
0.2624004483,
0.2801327407,
-0.2861674726,
0.0106012281,
0.3949174285,
-0.2749602199,
0.0987224281,
0.9107048512,
-0.0126254102,
-0.9067972302,
0.6839683652,
-0.5644880533,
0.5046594739,
-0.3984421492,
-0.1179228425,
-0.5687820315,
0.3025302291,
0.0053264126,
-0.6973385811,
0.2372245938,
-0.0872958824,
-0.2231081128,
-0.2087442726,
0.8095738292,
-0.3307403326,
-0.1036795825,
0.2394245118,
0.3374710381,
0.3099427223,
-0.2109114081,
-0.7373204827,
-0.1315933913,
-0.0669880658,
-0.1286133975,
0.1046855673,
0.1970482469,
0.0461622775,
0.9502549767,
0.9878464341,
-0.2106703371,
-0.2760954499,
0.4311271012,
1.0508966446,
-0.5326749086,
-0.6221607327,
-0.7147977352,
0.2200675607,
-0.0988404825,
-0.1532327086,
0.5068253875,
0.329287529,
0.7875796556,
0.2526322007,
0.6247288585,
-0.0659433529,
0.3283843398,
-0.5753911734,
0.712413609,
-0.4453082383,
0.0287401415,
-0.18910335,
-0.590934813,
-0.1047392935,
0.5456029773,
0.0889618918,
-0.0712891743,
0.5083617568,
1.0439834595,
0.3059483171,
0.3573558927,
0.355288595,
0.0479980595,
0.9432559609,
0.6294763684,
0.8077153563,
-0.3293169439,
0.5891039371,
0.0751810297,
-0.166164577,
-0.6032652259,
-0.6346929669,
-0.7705644369,
-0.5302850008,
-0.1518796086,
-0.4040644467,
0.1788087934,
0.6884961128,
0.6175690293,
-0.9227367043,
0.0675790235,
-0.0777034611,
-0.021842381,
-0.2326153517,
-0.2514495552,
0.1103900447,
-0.7557684183,
-0.7573862672,
0.3410661519,
0.2430818379,
0.1714677662,
-0.42586568,
0.2524851561,
0.0968981907,
0.1840428114,
0.4869454205,
0.3260586262,
-0.4150444567,
-0.6737693548,
0.1234798282,
-0.3707340956,
-0.0360153951,
0.9209961891,
-0.866508007,
0.9113097787,
0.6931677461,
0.6576068401,
0.8457052708,
-0.2153306603,
0.5387142897,
-0.4978850782,
0.6747046113,
0.4072223604,
0.2482862025,
0.2300932109,
-0.3282370567,
0.211193189,
0.3322035074,
-0.55233711,
-0.3639510274,
0.1808272451,
-1.1359164715,
-0.1438634098,
0.7361662984,
-0.079043828,
-0.0318924487,
-0.3381598294,
-0.3997626305,
0.3880504072,
-0.7700522542,
1.0450108051,
0.6628928185,
-0.0969782099,
-0.0452646986,
-0.3351829648,
0.4165320694,
0.5563293099,
-0.9030186534,
-0.0421794131,
0.5701839924,
0.1331448704,
0.3425366282,
1.0987217426,
-0.0191760082,
0.4011310935,
0.2136515379,
0.041282285,
0.2682695389,
-0.4098958969,
0.230977416,
0.0019421171,
-0.4701344073,
-0.5806068778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18125v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18125v1 | ResumeAtlas: Revisiting Resume Classification with Large-Scale Datasets and Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T07:25:18 | 2024-06-26T07:25:18 | Ahmed Heakl, Youssef Mohamed, Noran Mohamed, Ali Sharkaway, Ahmed Zaky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | The increasing reliance on online recruitment platforms coupled with the
adoption of AI technologies has highlighted the critical need for efficient
resume classification methods. However, challenges such as small datasets, lack
of standardized resume templates, and privacy concerns hinder the accuracy and
effectiveness of existing classification models. In this work, we address these
challenges by presenting a comprehensive approach to resume classification. We
curated a large-scale dataset of 13,389 resumes from diverse sources and
employed Large Language Models (LLMs) such as BERT and Gemma1.1 2B for
classification. Our results demonstrate significant improvements over
traditional machine learning approaches, with our best model achieving a top-1
accuracy of 92\% and a top-5 accuracy of 97.5\%. These findings underscore the
importance of dataset quality and advanced model architectures in enhancing the
accuracy and robustness of resume classification systems, thus advancing the
field of online recruitment practices. | [
0.0998209566,
-0.2664144039,
0.3636624217,
0.2777649164,
0.439453125,
0.2462829053,
-0.3884691596,
-0.4866957963,
0.1152053773,
0.594058454,
-0.2516104579,
-0.7205486298,
-0.6494937539,
-0.0580395609,
-0.5286315084,
1.0359104872,
0.0979122221,
0.0450831056,
-0.3816362321,
-0.3290995955,
-0.6271968484,
-0.3328795731,
-0.6290612221,
-0.0941857323,
0.641548872,
0.465649873,
0.127575025,
0.5271376371,
0.3112797737,
0.2702127397,
-0.0070403647,
0.4054253697,
-0.5212013721,
0.340277493,
0.0396062285,
-0.629912734,
-0.3216434121,
0.1327475905,
0.5833047628,
0.7730010152,
-0.5721390247,
0.5246198177,
0.0255137868,
0.5201054215,
-0.4883816838,
0.3882248998,
-0.5382238626,
-0.0592840426,
-0.2617653608,
0.0666488782,
-0.7514926195,
-0.4923175275,
0.0139441555,
-0.3622379303,
0.336776793,
0.0409519598,
0.5198755264,
-0.1649125814,
-0.4405705631,
-0.3003245592,
-0.6314437389,
0.8957016468,
-0.3599996567,
0.5958625078,
0.3452472091,
0.9290038347,
-0.0321484283,
-0.7845907211,
-0.2525182962,
0.0355029553,
0.351434052,
0.0110232411,
0.0834568143,
0.0668135211,
0.1686899811,
0.5625831485,
-0.7458022237,
0.845490396,
-0.6029931903,
-0.1874200702,
0.5761855245,
0.1041402444,
0.0900437683,
0.3616342545,
-0.145467788,
-0.3769960105,
-0.6148186326,
0.0075959628,
0.4241575301,
0.5726450682,
0.0755972192,
0.4017198682,
-0.3037468791,
0.9230472445,
-0.102127783,
-0.3012305796,
0.3179035783,
0.0365493111,
-0.1701169312,
-0.0121496292,
0.4536112249,
0.5325512886,
-0.0643572435,
-0.1793145388,
-0.3467125893,
-0.0428275242,
0.6354238391,
-0.6974391937,
-0.1610307395,
0.3803141713,
-0.6721122861,
-0.3165470362,
0.3601276577,
-0.6775164008,
-0.672852695,
-0.235064432,
0.0757096261,
-0.0269929543,
0.2623040676,
0.0480912812,
0.0055414271,
0.2712595463,
0.9499647021,
-0.5415007472,
0.0485029258,
0.8514463305,
0.9039561749,
-0.3114186227,
0.0931035802,
-0.6568014026,
-0.087363258,
-0.2308110446,
0.5814718604,
-0.6464802027,
0.1050487012,
0.5841814876,
0.2168172449,
0.0007606605,
-0.5662429333,
0.6014325619,
-0.9300422668,
0.4594482183,
-0.0019306978,
-0.6433791518,
-0.6219409108,
0.6857659817,
-0.7422994375,
0.6759409308,
0.4801913798,
-0.3352269232,
0.567138195,
-0.4687409699,
-0.0302575976,
0.0440876149,
-0.2951569557,
-0.4156016111,
-0.0124374917,
-0.0740236938,
0.8916995525,
-0.3033184111,
0.1028830707,
-0.0444137566,
-0.4258609712,
0.1341170222,
0.0006173651,
0.7249017954,
0.3106114566,
0.155703932,
0.0948338732,
-0.5980294943,
-0.1044692248,
-0.1507689208,
-0.7860571742,
0.0315424092,
-0.3443094492,
0.4944103956,
0.2636042833,
0.3550797105,
-0.8289313912,
0.486196667,
-0.2367460579,
0.1347909719,
0.7553144097,
-0.4102506638,
0.3999781311,
-0.5549837351,
0.5979908109,
-0.1620369256,
-0.0886465609,
-0.3038469255,
-0.6321496367,
-0.2439759076,
-0.6369662881,
0.292272985,
0.8452948332,
-0.3033596277,
0.8618924618,
-0.520134747,
-0.9649947286,
-0.2676282525,
0.2280578464,
0.1850452125,
0.3055983186,
0.460740447,
-0.3884454668,
-0.5648151636,
-0.7767160535,
-0.2544325292,
-0.1966205388,
-0.4098255336,
0.3071885705,
0.0867014676,
-0.6671108007,
0.5685634613,
-0.3662885427,
-0.6431030035,
-0.3718185723,
-0.0443528146,
0.6021069884,
0.5405851007,
0.5915520787,
-0.7675557137,
-0.2652134597,
0.0429000184,
-0.6702010036,
0.2197433412,
-0.2981302738,
0.2801352441,
-0.0282856636,
0.310633868,
-0.6341866851,
0.2295163572,
0.1934448183,
-0.0476377904,
0.2840209603,
-0.0763673261,
0.2403651923,
-0.9275632501,
0.0442799255,
0.3127520978,
-0.3559327424,
-0.5002645254,
0.2078146935,
0.0892449319,
-0.0859293118,
-0.2798524201,
0.372774303,
-0.172511369,
-0.0583012626,
-0.3471007943,
-0.4266484082,
-0.2227033526,
0.0542652272,
-0.3339866102,
0.4573055506,
0.5900381207,
-0.619595468,
0.7250731587,
0.7309263945,
-0.5279640555,
0.5971056819,
-0.2898413539,
0.0459337942,
-0.5382450223,
1.0799640417,
-1.429041028,
-0.7168192267,
-0.2105224729,
-0.3107721508,
0.4629855156,
-0.060632389,
-0.8215401173,
-0.5116228461,
-0.504673481,
0.4990622699,
0.7791648507,
-0.7747020721,
0.6612436771,
0.3637664318,
-0.0985911041,
-0.5809836984,
-0.8522667289,
0.1046778411,
-0.3443564773,
-0.1975970268,
0.5131773949,
0.3680769205,
-0.1591073871,
-0.8644705415,
0.1120935604,
-0.519333303,
0.0337464437,
0.3947102427,
0.3566056788,
0.1686446816,
0.063398689,
-0.1084880829,
0.1765730381,
-0.2176650167,
-0.4421281517,
0.6543736458,
0.0160842184,
-0.2166271508,
-0.8458549976,
-0.051367674,
0.966152966,
0.0642586872,
1.0011351109,
0.8382105827,
-0.4314444363,
-0.0954297483,
-1.0645128489,
0.046424374,
-0.4368655682,
0.3624116778,
0.2332596779,
-0.9247566462,
0.54371351,
-0.1029471606,
0.5348971486,
0.3757238984,
0.490953207,
-0.1457914263,
0.5547781587,
0.7081254125,
-0.233960554,
0.4571858346,
-0.2132192105,
-0.1050459519,
-0.4460682571,
-0.5177192092,
-0.4777341783,
-0.547436595,
-0.6981257796,
-0.4286483228,
-0.0407561697,
-0.437887758,
-0.2855208516,
0.6486855745,
-0.5164374709,
0.3444148898,
0.3035229146,
0.3921058476,
-0.0232165772,
0.0825143531,
0.5275398493,
0.0612241104,
-0.3918430209,
-0.6324883103,
1.298845768,
0.5621755719,
0.73015064,
0.1248703599,
0.6537698507,
0.5446458459,
0.4290563166,
-0.4971134365,
0.3643437624,
-0.4616132677,
-0.4566862583,
-0.1705400348,
-0.4110450149,
-0.9162023664,
-0.1322683096,
-0.1305371821,
-0.8222360611,
0.2840897739,
-0.0389743373,
-0.4648083448,
0.4400233328,
-0.4221298397,
0.6978340149,
-0.172029227,
-0.142306149,
-0.2920622528,
-0.7490835786,
0.2647453547,
-0.355979532,
0.3849124014,
0.1239152551,
-0.088491708,
1.0034327507,
-0.0978577808,
0.9366014004,
-0.2138159126,
-0.1426160038,
0.0521714911,
0.0288080871,
0.5929911137,
-0.2202725112,
-0.4726952016,
0.2570489347,
-0.0275468528,
-0.5433109999,
-0.3535122871,
0.7589671612,
-0.5392904878,
0.0569631122,
-0.2097613662,
-0.6270227432,
-0.1875537634,
0.0083907675,
0.142940402,
0.2410994619,
-0.1070026904,
0.5841787457,
0.6128038764,
-0.7670283318,
-0.0455239825,
0.1190800145,
-0.3723528087,
-0.2416224927,
0.9394313097,
0.3803449273,
-0.1572444588,
0.379211396,
-0.3588531017,
-0.5077623129,
-0.4520631135,
-0.1935056299,
0.1996939778,
-0.6663560867,
-0.2340332121,
-0.6672451496,
-0.0433415286,
-0.6816594005,
-0.1940650344,
-0.2384923548,
-0.3914985359,
-0.280141741,
-0.0385108776,
0.1404864639,
0.8387969136,
0.2897221744,
0.4121731818,
-0.8680548668,
0.1245495602,
0.1960273832,
0.5171017051,
-0.0474290363,
-0.754838109,
-0.0920530036,
-0.0930451304,
-0.2259997278,
-0.5304542184,
0.2597806454,
0.629386723,
0.749126792,
0.4718124568,
-0.123101458,
0.3348592818,
-0.4650439322,
0.7055439949,
0.1627536416,
-0.1454531997,
0.516410768,
-0.5443810225,
0.0414270982,
1.0594965219,
0.7142164707,
-0.4947431684,
-0.0320276543,
-0.5418700576,
-0.8502768278,
0.5235224962,
0.0804029778,
0.2849610448,
-0.0412834585,
0.5466921926,
0.5666281581,
0.3718799055,
-0.2742334306,
0.197712034,
0.1998249739,
-0.5236694217,
-0.0949752852,
-0.1486510932,
0.0729380473,
-0.277621299,
0.3232008815,
0.0566336177,
0.4233720303,
-0.3755400479,
-0.2184720039,
0.2764927745,
0.0029407961,
0.4884443879,
0.9269466996,
-0.3057659566,
-0.2130888104,
0.4054799676,
-0.2650157213,
0.20334436,
-0.1849498302,
0.2749325335,
0.1056832969,
0.2348541021,
0.1543370783,
-0.0073924223,
-0.8956811428,
0.962010324,
-0.0206296314,
-0.0855785385,
-0.6251558661,
0.0739840493,
-0.2778050303,
0.2279007584,
0.5266004205,
0.1019200534,
0.0432010144,
-0.6316289902,
0.2984871566,
0.3665792346,
-0.2519281805,
-0.0569002442,
0.5585065484,
0.0861949995,
-0.2628016472,
1.0435050726,
-0.0000058757,
-0.3939468563,
0.5370573997,
0.2752424479,
0.7561312914,
-0.4614831209,
0.0821809843,
0.5142023563,
-0.2583577931,
-0.895129621,
-0.0613866225,
-0.0599876828,
-0.5895629525,
-0.4508697987,
-0.8199147582,
-0.5987381339,
-0.0068113781,
-0.8373736143,
0.3149746656,
-0.8875706196,
0.0583180599,
-0.2329102606,
-0.4988434315,
-0.7585392594,
0.2566182911,
0.3976509869,
1.0213758945,
-0.9712582231,
0.4731387496,
0.9178398848,
-0.3371721506,
-0.0579930656,
-0.1349365562,
-0.0452787764,
-0.7325695157,
0.9643747807,
0.9741886258,
0.3254158199,
-0.017496068,
-0.5691922307,
-0.3913916349,
1.052585721,
0.2776884735,
-0.512111187,
-0.3609667122,
-0.2034926564,
0.4672252834,
-0.4474446177,
0.3322114944,
0.2353851944,
0.2823901474,
0.0006502714,
-1.2905700207,
-0.1534244865,
-0.0953776389,
0.1156655326,
-0.253916502,
-0.6281514168,
0.6960616708,
0.1269138604,
-0.1690618992,
0.1061020344,
0.7896200418,
0.2804976404,
0.2227243036,
0.5946030021,
0.5456130505,
1.1174639463,
-0.1342962384,
0.8725254536,
-0.2559790015,
0.4237132072,
0.6540011168,
-0.4413172901,
0.8948400617,
-0.0924941152,
-0.4802693129,
0.9401885271,
0.7556341887,
-0.3942694962,
0.1236932129,
0.2846722603,
-0.0217335708,
-0.6144543886,
-0.1835884601,
-0.3508468866,
0.7213873863,
0.3136070967,
-0.4877512753,
-0.4267854691,
0.5848997831,
-0.4307101965,
0.2127085179,
-0.4350619912,
0.6441053152,
-0.2787491977,
-0.3085415363,
0.3843107522,
0.0902738348,
0.9109879732,
-0.1667773277,
-0.2964255214,
0.0765615627,
0.433298111,
-0.5166217685,
-0.8230879903,
0.1327663511,
-0.0486329421,
-0.2065048516,
-0.5420258641,
0.6264716387,
-0.2347146571,
-0.4349586666,
-0.1170997918,
0.168295294,
0.4780081511,
-0.2144047767,
-0.29938519,
-0.0240973607,
-0.2411746383,
0.141508162,
0.5201337337,
0.0240336191,
-0.0680355802,
0.77656883,
0.6474612355,
-0.1464939713,
-0.0647126883,
-0.1879635602,
0.7793479562,
-0.5687369108,
-0.9728546739,
-0.5740249157,
0.2760205865,
-0.3690357804,
-0.269890517,
0.6817277074,
0.8549278975,
0.8436166644,
-0.2347918004,
0.5877695084,
-0.0124593731,
0.9144473672,
-0.269998014,
0.8047029972,
-0.4433835745,
0.2784464359,
-0.0643256605,
-1.1306664944,
-0.5213450193,
0.7735004425,
-0.3537891209,
0.2155918628,
0.0903891921,
0.5671281815,
-0.0741495937,
-0.1737978756,
0.0883100331,
0.01579413,
0.2983303964,
0.4999576807,
0.6921688318,
-0.47126773,
0.2588897049,
0.1419010311,
-0.3442964256,
-0.82277143,
-0.3619893193,
-0.7584556937,
-0.538625896,
-0.4408110976,
-0.5814497471,
-0.0038281386,
1.2745556831,
0.7139966488,
-1.0694795847,
-0.2520111203,
-0.0013297,
-0.3742360473,
-0.2160680294,
-0.2238489687,
0.1142392829,
-0.3571354747,
-0.5331232548,
0.5559280515,
0.0258821975,
-0.1122090816,
-0.2155228406,
0.2130457014,
-0.2805661857,
-0.406194061,
0.6465483308,
0.5807401538,
-0.7893187404,
-0.0979313627,
-0.2647146881,
-0.4117912948,
-0.0316452011,
0.5264388323,
-0.8195000887,
0.2841998041,
0.5841318965,
1.3187298775,
0.2410372943,
0.3702391982,
0.4362108707,
-0.8184225559,
-0.0062769419,
0.3247193992,
0.3051135242,
0.4966460168,
-0.4480602443,
0.4791023731,
0.0307464208,
-0.6835520864,
-1.0828795433,
0.1031281501,
-1.2230148315,
-0.1468510777,
1.1868473291,
-0.2057042271,
-0.0536169969,
-0.3121233284,
-0.1841513813,
0.2575421631,
-0.2338057905,
1.0202031136,
0.4327616096,
-0.036010161,
0.0375766791,
-0.7417554855,
0.0370657407,
0.1087059975,
-0.6271165609,
0.129131943,
0.6768296957,
0.1444270015,
0.3857967854,
0.2405707538,
0.0375728346,
0.4902966321,
-0.4940110445,
0.0633769408,
-0.0172328614,
-0.5065000057,
-0.2441740334,
0.4971098006,
0.1384855211,
-0.2673461735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18122v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18122v1 | Poisoned LangChain: Jailbreak LLMs by LangChain | 2024-06-26T07:21:02 | 2024-06-26T07:21:02 | Ziqiu Wang, Jun Liu, Shengkai Zhang, Yang Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the development of natural language processing (NLP), large language
models (LLMs) are becoming increasingly popular. LLMs are integrating more into
everyday life, raising public concerns about their security vulnerabilities.
Consequently, the security of large language models is becoming critically
important. Currently, the techniques for attacking and defending against LLMs
are continuously evolving. One significant method type of attack is the
jailbreak attack, which designed to evade model safety mechanisms and induce
the generation of inappropriate content. Existing jailbreak attacks primarily
rely on crafting inducement prompts for direct jailbreaks, which are less
effective against large models with robust filtering and high comprehension
abilities. Given the increasing demand for real-time capabilities in large
language models, real-time updates and iterations of new knowledge have become
essential. Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG), an advanced technique to
compensate for the model's lack of new knowledge, is gradually becoming
mainstream. As RAG enables the model to utilize external knowledge bases, it
provides a new avenue for jailbreak attacks.
In this paper, we conduct the first work to propose the concept of indirect
jailbreak and achieve Retrieval-Augmented Generation via LangChain. Building on
this, we further design a novel method of indirect jailbreak attack, termed
Poisoned-LangChain (PLC), which leverages a poisoned external knowledge base to
interact with large language models, thereby causing the large models to
generate malicious non-compliant dialogues.We tested this method on six
different large language models across three major categories of jailbreak
issues. The experiments demonstrate that PLC successfully implemented indirect
jailbreak attacks under three different scenarios, achieving success rates of
88.56%, 79.04%, and 82.69% respectively. | [
-0.2151896656,
-1.0846508741,
0.3181618154,
0.1291833371,
-0.1782744676,
0.3042157888,
-0.1838992685,
-0.6483486891,
0.458227545,
0.9930235744,
-0.2567758262,
-0.4256691635,
-0.3951705396,
-0.0072310637,
-0.5895373821,
1.0390993357,
0.1884931177,
-0.1020611972,
0.3967568576,
0.0710073709,
-0.5843629241,
-0.7635214925,
-0.5698223114,
0.0223746356,
0.5440549254,
0.266010046,
0.5564303398,
0.3976471424,
0.4569790959,
0.3044627607,
-0.3192850351,
0.0402979478,
-0.4121376276,
0.4108138084,
-0.2163151801,
-0.3697898686,
-0.3430947959,
-0.2532935441,
0.1428239942,
0.1405888796,
-0.337806493,
-0.0432928354,
-0.2327397764,
1.0470373631,
-0.8533920646,
-0.2800123096,
-1.1907154322,
0.036337316,
-0.4580604732,
0.1346306801,
-0.7455661297,
-0.1454526782,
-0.1803369671,
-0.1996379644,
-0.016089296,
0.2295365781,
0.545386076,
-0.1665363908,
-0.2771462202,
-0.4599967301,
-0.373449564,
0.5170820355,
-0.8547581434,
-0.0628785044,
0.3147521019,
0.3130674362,
-0.4661241174,
-0.8377078772,
-0.3651918769,
-0.7067636251,
0.0624246225,
-0.1697171628,
-0.0815794691,
0.2605514228,
0.3447583318,
0.331758827,
-0.360684067,
0.1801279038,
-0.310885787,
-0.0435949825,
0.6746661663,
0.1744493991,
0.7067744732,
-0.7224879861,
-0.433950901,
0.2056666017,
-1.162774682,
-0.3984418511,
0.735337317,
0.4582022429,
-0.1112183705,
0.6443417072,
0.0261258762,
1.0053683519,
-0.0690852776,
-0.0918798372,
-0.229083553,
-0.2726196051,
-0.189683333,
0.5417776108,
0.872507453,
0.2176531553,
0.3388500512,
-0.1544063687,
-0.1450620443,
-0.3636679053,
0.2186009735,
-0.8285411,
-0.3148878813,
0.3436808884,
-0.0683149844,
-0.8020996451,
0.0250669681,
-0.9442800879,
-0.9886431098,
0.3831661046,
0.2631451786,
-0.3277678192,
-0.2968947589,
-0.0776340812,
-0.201108098,
0.2219150513,
0.0130227124,
-1.1102876663,
0.2852696776,
0.6617205143,
0.9511339664,
0.0649479777,
-0.1319479048,
-0.6783806086,
0.4765625894,
-0.2721920013,
0.5114053488,
-0.0294852462,
-0.4307800233,
0.0751205385,
-0.1396502852,
0.0316384733,
-0.7857575417,
0.1661906093,
-0.8428723812,
-0.1708533764,
0.0565896183,
-0.3342734873,
-0.0077124126,
0.4624789655,
-0.8854539394,
0.5540105104,
-0.2856019139,
-1.2492904663,
-0.1596564949,
-0.3721569479,
-0.6229295135,
-0.0929269493,
0.1588493139,
-0.3544051945,
-0.0611990504,
0.2850127518,
0.3316222727,
-0.3565063179,
0.5610535145,
-0.3980737329,
-0.13014929,
0.4266776741,
-0.3759076595,
0.8522971272,
0.3308682144,
-0.2991968691,
0.0137240812,
-0.6300207376,
-0.1115332767,
0.5169865489,
-0.1541472077,
-0.6180539131,
0.1781436354,
-0.0145424772,
0.0457614325,
0.4288075268,
-0.5329744816,
0.3451723158,
-0.9054676294,
0.5609318614,
0.7948895693,
0.5262383223,
0.1530869007,
-0.218891412,
0.2942589819,
-0.2221866697,
0.2137148678,
-0.2406161427,
-0.2972290814,
-0.4920128584,
0.0128045781,
0.2110388428,
0.9710671306,
-0.6996709108,
0.188921392,
0.0845493972,
-0.6172440052,
-0.2956447005,
0.4083288014,
0.512988627,
0.4566326439,
0.4116670787,
-0.1643134803,
-0.7369892597,
-0.6209208965,
-0.7853199244,
-0.2484235615,
0.2338897437,
0.3043638468,
0.3241459727,
-0.2400722504,
0.5239045024,
-0.4395792186,
-0.205647558,
-0.6729185581,
-0.234488681,
0.398571521,
0.4933744967,
0.3675408065,
-0.5541422963,
-0.4907315373,
-0.0033859215,
-0.7704766393,
-0.2026568204,
-0.0819069296,
0.0586412661,
0.2763441801,
0.6068946123,
-0.4673280418,
0.2998470366,
0.4362630844,
-0.3821311891,
0.921739161,
-0.1204274669,
-0.0859546512,
-1.2769479752,
-0.0505742468,
-0.174360618,
-0.1700146645,
-0.8819856644,
0.5846095681,
0.0082099279,
-0.2409282327,
-0.7718299627,
0.7870587111,
-0.3874896467,
0.1592373103,
-0.2264156938,
0.2946464121,
-0.2157907337,
0.0942378119,
-0.2897286117,
0.6195917726,
0.3237342536,
-0.182748735,
0.7356555462,
0.0513219833,
-0.3482504189,
0.0530341417,
-0.623007834,
0.2070676386,
0.0654928014,
-0.0601786636,
-0.6388154626,
-0.3457052112,
0.2563787103,
-0.1987561285,
0.4340735674,
-0.3648939729,
-0.6676615477,
-0.2896554172,
-0.4406237304,
0.0116460687,
0.4284562767,
-0.7287433147,
0.4509426057,
0.2905978858,
-0.1541839242,
-0.7842953801,
-0.5980663896,
0.6533355117,
-0.5608975887,
-0.7064467072,
0.1678813696,
0.0201729201,
-0.7342914939,
-0.2534333766,
-0.0130044064,
0.0314835757,
0.2678091526,
0.1336344332,
0.374630183,
0.0705206767,
-0.315795362,
-0.0131829809,
0.1061866283,
0.2262739092,
-0.0183517803,
0.6725127101,
0.0820833966,
-0.150296703,
-0.2337984741,
0.2418462783,
0.6289156675,
-0.1976282299,
0.9992001057,
0.1075525805,
-0.0801880211,
-0.3550516069,
-0.7213101387,
-0.1673855335,
-0.5473468304,
0.4363817871,
-0.3186704516,
-0.654376924,
0.5262653232,
-0.2572308481,
-0.2069894522,
0.0758500993,
0.4688253701,
0.2220477909,
0.8994279504,
0.5106384754,
-0.5792022347,
0.5288793445,
-0.160966754,
0.3282958269,
-0.8943582773,
-0.1598030478,
-0.2412767261,
0.1336846352,
-0.5854450464,
0.0152323544,
0.2517317533,
0.5187022686,
-0.530297935,
0.5227797031,
-0.3805736005,
0.4955562055,
0.2296331227,
0.0922724307,
0.387919426,
-0.0315433033,
-0.5398318768,
0.1318499446,
-0.5042930245,
-0.1967053413,
1.0788589716,
0.3035154939,
0.9572477937,
0.3626781404,
0.8720449209,
0.3578829169,
0.414470762,
-0.5635929108,
0.5775550604,
-0.1310132444,
-0.9132073522,
-0.014313437,
-0.3855267167,
-0.8168520927,
0.2669804096,
0.0967409089,
-1.1348814964,
-0.2744885385,
0.0323116668,
-0.1141378209,
0.6820822954,
-0.9121536613,
0.8592515588,
-0.4933691621,
-0.5229696631,
-0.0492409095,
-0.781799674,
0.9910476804,
-0.3500692844,
0.5262076259,
-0.0151114957,
0.2632160485,
0.6904882789,
-0.9882782102,
0.8706378341,
-0.3911578059,
-0.0899142474,
0.4358483255,
0.5256109834,
0.9379760623,
0.3831677735,
-0.1740774363,
-0.2224250585,
-0.1506389827,
-0.0887966231,
-0.50475353,
0.7934141159,
-0.4974712729,
-1.0908676386,
-0.4169215858,
-0.3669421077,
-0.0691752136,
0.0999191403,
0.201342985,
0.3268096745,
0.0949474722,
-0.2772028148,
0.5315328836,
-0.577496469,
0.5755662322,
0.5510658026,
-0.6277234554,
-0.7829400301,
0.8936581612,
-0.009645097,
0.5756309628,
0.2072176188,
0.2802641392,
0.0907433182,
-0.4468528926,
-0.4403396845,
0.4314947426,
-0.6381474733,
-0.4914982617,
-0.4186716676,
-0.6856940985,
-0.3542383313,
-0.2363100648,
-0.317563951,
-0.208660543,
0.0170168355,
-0.1717465967,
0.8084344268,
0.6749405265,
-0.1788426638,
0.328391999,
-0.8725186586,
0.5312092304,
0.3187959492,
0.0109772813,
0.2122728527,
-0.4747528732,
-0.1423759609,
-0.2406165749,
-0.1672417969,
-1.4284437895,
0.606957972,
-0.0553154945,
0.225197807,
0.3567786515,
0.196310088,
0.5743486881,
-0.7767600417,
0.7027459741,
0.3313687444,
-0.9089922905,
0.9397193789,
-0.4209296703,
-0.0536362156,
0.4409442842,
-0.0053034262,
-0.6151376963,
-0.7107176185,
-0.5016005039,
-1.2965084314,
0.4317325056,
-0.0346089676,
0.3665934205,
-0.1953768432,
0.3459005952,
-0.1928420067,
0.2389702052,
-1.0938975811,
-0.4683305919,
0.0217802506,
-0.0477756262,
0.2002032846,
-0.4087535739,
-0.101202406,
-0.2295842916,
0.6956338882,
0.3780623972,
-0.0509880185,
0.1460934728,
-0.2132254839,
0.2305919528,
0.397352159,
0.3161836863,
0.245504424,
-0.2124466747,
0.1876785159,
0.221009478,
-0.7485032678,
0.4666522443,
0.2100628018,
-0.2191855907,
-0.2703412771,
0.4067328274,
0.7132060528,
-0.0849345624,
-0.9989162683,
0.5544311404,
0.0946683958,
0.3168357611,
-0.6281151175,
0.2488619983,
0.0055311117,
0.0970170572,
0.3020533919,
-0.1503494531,
-0.0817021728,
-0.5989242792,
0.2287256867,
0.4640791416,
-0.4351511598,
-0.034634769,
0.6358547211,
-0.11806079,
-0.2577922642,
0.664090693,
-0.1919318438,
-0.6337508559,
0.6720913649,
0.9573282003,
0.8908076286,
-0.4333860874,
-0.0615671277,
0.3576577008,
0.5847836137,
0.0655571371,
0.1595690399,
-0.0648545772,
-0.7511150837,
-0.5204978585,
-0.5898188353,
-0.2216170579,
0.3934072554,
-0.324151814,
0.2462680787,
-0.6327386498,
-0.0571247861,
-0.5158143044,
-0.1299974024,
0.1073194891,
-0.0460156724,
0.0767155737,
1.1080164909,
-0.4851086736,
0.9828315377,
0.2483489662,
-0.2485773712,
-0.9494407773,
-0.0350839794,
0.1242593229,
-0.611097157,
0.8131173253,
0.3089445233,
0.1576590538,
0.039538186,
-0.4904364645,
-0.8639295101,
0.6850965023,
0.2933337986,
-0.6514707804,
-0.0420150757,
-0.1792294383,
0.1409759521,
-0.0210338049,
-0.1411195099,
0.7407147884,
0.4474714398,
-0.0515202619,
-0.7535657883,
0.1804636419,
-0.321560353,
-0.0402605608,
0.603346765,
-0.3157679439,
0.6476955414,
-0.5431113839,
0.0608405024,
0.4082321227,
0.358382076,
0.7426974177,
0.0377199613,
0.315026015,
0.7903078794,
0.4321080446,
0.1171523705,
1.0391900539,
-0.3739921749,
0.0707874224,
1.2691440582,
-0.5773006678,
0.9115158916,
0.6242038012,
0.0419257656,
0.7375317216,
0.2543254495,
-0.1391846836,
0.7884662151,
0.8186026216,
-0.6722236276,
0.2828750312,
0.0559078567,
-0.3513927758,
0.1877848506,
0.6337535977,
-0.3917226195,
-0.1332588792,
0.531435132,
0.5379914641,
0.0975851566,
-0.4410330057,
0.9771592021,
0.205674395,
-0.5419119596,
0.6002605557,
0.5174608231,
0.5682204366,
-0.6941648126,
0.2021010518,
-0.2177056521,
0.1135649011,
-0.2009254545,
-0.398917824,
0.1809624881,
0.4895063639,
0.1676580459,
0.1795874387,
1.0463721752,
-0.1489784271,
-0.2724438906,
0.718431592,
0.2867237628,
0.0119093433,
-0.0718982965,
-0.621055603,
0.1870227605,
0.0007533294,
-0.483027786,
0.4673905373,
-0.0212337337,
0.1072536856,
0.6768839955,
0.6517275572,
0.525003314,
0.3333868384,
0.0554233119,
0.9016122222,
-0.816871047,
-0.3122953176,
-1.2596188784,
0.3435058296,
-0.2230854183,
0.2767053545,
0.9718908072,
0.5086644888,
0.4881237447,
0.0651708245,
0.852204442,
-0.2581210434,
0.4056686461,
-0.8102902174,
0.9498550892,
-0.1955832988,
0.6052665114,
-0.5067287087,
-0.6589799523,
-0.4016325772,
0.2970298231,
-0.5112595558,
-0.0192386638,
0.660019815,
0.8290795088,
0.293608278,
-0.1845882535,
0.0767805502,
0.4505593479,
0.4735603631,
0.5687981248,
0.9867781997,
-0.4437511265,
0.4180983305,
-0.3340885937,
-0.0082148286,
-0.0742241815,
-0.8128724098,
-1.0332410336,
-0.1881116927,
-0.0075785303,
-0.6709806919,
0.3643651307,
0.7363755107,
0.3224600852,
-0.6436850429,
-0.4507389665,
-0.4406033158,
0.372160852,
0.142632544,
-0.3061498106,
0.2967215776,
-0.3889254034,
-0.2023918033,
0.6620611548,
0.3329789639,
0.0264882538,
-0.265583992,
0.0883330554,
-0.3595576584,
0.1205673441,
0.4339133799,
0.4578500688,
-0.757438004,
-0.0559097342,
-0.3486549258,
-0.1524823457,
-0.1997879297,
0.7466777563,
-0.9151850343,
0.5136777163,
0.256952107,
0.6398651004,
0.3993005157,
-0.0390248932,
0.4188559353,
-0.8851593137,
0.4816776812,
0.0622982122,
0.4853555858,
0.3896600902,
-0.5174506307,
0.2623111308,
0.2897496223,
-0.4996183515,
-1.0352779627,
0.4866002202,
-0.5257244706,
-0.710059762,
1.0766576529,
-0.0672299862,
-0.4645005465,
-0.1421192884,
-0.2555362582,
0.003959409,
-0.110193871,
0.7134886384,
0.4103993773,
0.0999929607,
0.0076525845,
-0.844293952,
0.5201181173,
0.1378371269,
-0.9405353069,
0.250274837,
0.2484313399,
0.239092797,
0.1237493008,
0.3836461604,
-0.371039331,
0.0713538602,
-0.2264342606,
0.0470793843,
-0.1014740914,
-0.4339061081,
-0.294775039,
0.4600611627,
0.3206466138,
0.3157446682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18120v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18120v1 | ArzEn-LLM: Code-Switched Egyptian Arabic-English Translation and Speech Recognition Using LLMs | 2024-06-26T07:19:51 | 2024-06-26T07:19:51 | Ahmed Heakl, Youssef Zaghloul, Mennatullah Ali, Rania Hossam, Walid Gomaa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Motivated by the widespread increase in the phenomenon of code-switching
between Egyptian Arabic and English in recent times, this paper explores the
intricacies of machine translation (MT) and automatic speech recognition (ASR)
systems, focusing on translating code-switched Egyptian Arabic-English to
either English or Egyptian Arabic. Our goal is to present the methodologies
employed in developing these systems, utilizing large language models such as
LLama and Gemma. In the field of ASR, we explore the utilization of the Whisper
model for code-switched Egyptian Arabic recognition, detailing our experimental
procedures including data preprocessing and training techniques. Through the
implementation of a consecutive speech-to-text translation system that
integrates ASR with MT, we aim to overcome challenges posed by limited
resources and the unique characteristics of the Egyptian Arabic dialect.
Evaluation against established metrics showcases promising results, with our
methodologies yielding a significant improvement of $56\%$ in English
translation over the state-of-the-art and $9.3\%$ in Arabic translation. Since
code-switching is deeply inherent in spoken languages, it is crucial that ASR
systems can effectively handle this phenomenon. This capability is crucial for
enabling seamless interaction in various domains, including business
negotiations, cultural exchanges, and academic discourse. Our models and code
are available as open-source resources. Code:
\url{http://github.com/ahmedheakl/arazn-llm}}, Models:
\url{http://huggingface.co/collections/ahmedheakl/arazn-llm-662ceaf12777656607b9524e}. | [
-0.2321192473,
-0.5393382907,
0.1989352852,
0.2512206137,
-0.3460586369,
0.190915212,
-0.1926769465,
-0.7645863891,
-0.0016262351,
0.708568573,
-0.1781311929,
-0.6067522168,
-0.8858135343,
0.3010076284,
-0.9239369631,
1.1245423555,
-0.7370746732,
0.2993384004,
0.4209168553,
-0.2606144845,
-0.0012794653,
-0.421836555,
-0.8124940991,
-0.5082204938,
0.3602652252,
0.2394187152,
0.5465918779,
0.8959789872,
0.5710488558,
0.2642699182,
-0.0053062164,
0.1349518597,
-0.0004684829,
0.2330894321,
0.3080625236,
-0.4053326547,
-0.5782594681,
-0.1048963368,
0.6508245468,
0.4443746805,
-0.3791763783,
0.3484971225,
0.0893446282,
0.5457607508,
-0.375336349,
0.1642730385,
-0.6398495436,
0.0886226743,
-0.2503224909,
-0.2419785261,
-0.1339771301,
-0.2928154171,
0.0945134312,
-0.2371650934,
-0.1168956831,
0.1952275336,
0.7165808082,
0.3234427571,
-0.565950036,
-0.8930218816,
-0.9331423044,
0.8452749848,
-0.7091959119,
0.4210071266,
0.3386482894,
0.2591102719,
0.0761831105,
-0.7714983821,
-0.5100781918,
-0.3767660856,
0.3139898181,
0.1374957412,
-0.5341553688,
-0.0178121142,
-0.0526100211,
0.4552350342,
-0.2252353728,
0.0483165942,
-0.3758226037,
-0.1050762385,
0.6038271189,
0.1413962096,
0.552020967,
0.0481106415,
-0.3763289154,
-0.023185648,
-0.8793264031,
0.0523153953,
0.5501585603,
0.3623284996,
-0.373867631,
0.6412632465,
-0.0061411755,
0.7351953387,
-0.1746363491,
-0.2875141799,
0.071891658,
-0.0794080421,
-0.2156439573,
0.3891123533,
0.609577179,
0.0558265969,
0.0573280044,
-0.0856826901,
-0.6593654752,
0.4429706633,
0.0410878733,
-0.6815840602,
-0.00887674,
0.1110973135,
-0.7947547436,
-0.3514331579,
-0.2728438973,
-0.3641061783,
-0.0438288301,
-0.1207386553,
0.4820467532,
-0.2490685582,
-0.2826869488,
0.4324211776,
0.219977051,
0.4005839229,
0.4308519363,
-0.5721436143,
0.6736571789,
0.2730965316,
0.901096046,
-0.3224820197,
-0.406109184,
-0.3410433531,
0.4203570485,
-0.3247816861,
0.569050312,
-0.4872825742,
-0.707927525,
0.2450889051,
-0.3432611525,
-0.0496016145,
-0.795363903,
0.685092628,
-0.7203598619,
-0.0880858228,
0.3814858496,
-0.289731741,
-0.3936625421,
0.0637657419,
-0.615619123,
0.7891309261,
-0.5536145568,
-0.3022429645,
-0.363414377,
-0.8121829629,
-0.6904075742,
-0.1934659034,
-0.2407378256,
-0.4455215037,
0.051979363,
0.1159626245,
0.2679697573,
-0.3994186819,
-0.0928390175,
0.4468052983,
-0.3491510451,
0.6488242149,
-0.6271085739,
0.6651482582,
0.4969403446,
-0.4379709661,
0.0433644094,
-0.7683609128,
-0.0483000763,
0.0786492825,
-0.8126266599,
-0.0070431046,
0.2422507405,
0.5257425904,
0.1886811852,
0.4500567913,
-0.3144101799,
0.0718932673,
-0.241675362,
0.5812218189,
0.4731011689,
-0.3908866644,
0.2992997766,
-0.4478786588,
0.7076923251,
0.1183664054,
-0.1914495826,
-0.0084319571,
-0.7274152637,
-1.1448198557,
-0.1403797865,
0.3116607368,
0.9146922827,
-0.7006927133,
0.1164713576,
-0.1616647094,
-0.1262450963,
-0.9813925028,
0.111861214,
0.7136437893,
0.2935302258,
0.4531330168,
-0.2626821101,
-0.6614503264,
-0.7730880976,
-0.3541748822,
-0.3533360958,
0.054809764,
0.3544773459,
0.4029029012,
-0.6299378276,
0.4668896496,
-0.122345157,
-0.2694240808,
-0.4180936217,
0.2185088992,
0.3925861716,
0.4746939242,
0.0344432816,
-0.7644799948,
-0.5355615616,
0.4270652533,
-0.3625607491,
-0.4426854849,
0.0239074063,
0.2118514627,
0.4708130956,
0.629098475,
-0.3605596721,
0.7185294628,
1.0016716719,
0.0180767532,
0.6615411639,
-0.1271423399,
0.3541489542,
-1.1923402548,
0.1430628449,
-0.2360141128,
-0.2515628934,
-0.7016218305,
0.0958627239,
-0.028382523,
-0.0792626664,
-0.4971091747,
0.6879181862,
-0.7430523038,
-0.2586905658,
-0.5569584966,
-0.1618919224,
-0.3378352225,
0.3782571554,
0.028085826,
1.2410340309,
0.2591272295,
-0.8155984879,
0.4578786194,
0.5225176811,
-0.5898743272,
0.2836952209,
-0.5487964749,
0.3268872797,
0.4942761064,
0.0577176772,
-0.8133304715,
0.1217008531,
0.6423330903,
-0.6453968287,
0.3104997277,
-0.4427529573,
-0.4564834237,
0.086664781,
0.1564731151,
0.5155597925,
0.6148065329,
-0.5138327479,
0.7730579376,
0.3601187766,
-0.5617883205,
-0.5499171615,
-0.7919769883,
0.5523045063,
-0.1608974189,
-0.4495988488,
0.5231097937,
0.0738959461,
-0.4669521749,
0.0101998756,
-0.3829237223,
-0.0860733688,
-0.1918552965,
0.2961206734,
0.4771719575,
-0.2823231518,
-0.3769577444,
0.266307652,
-0.4649991691,
0.0414939746,
-0.4257643521,
0.5655617118,
-0.3581990302,
-0.5100290775,
-0.4757594168,
0.6110199094,
0.4126793444,
-0.3311758637,
0.4742322266,
0.3047496378,
-0.3341526985,
-0.0248489995,
-0.6312773824,
0.1459784657,
-0.4665157497,
0.5034740567,
-0.5948348045,
-0.9279819727,
0.8328217268,
-0.2503550947,
0.1286812723,
0.2251057625,
0.8785129786,
-0.2024073154,
1.1074390411,
0.5913834572,
-0.3001860678,
0.5103797317,
-0.1187314987,
0.2617737055,
-0.8753762245,
0.0052000633,
-0.6808941364,
-0.4384424388,
-0.6031480432,
-0.5047439337,
0.5612961054,
-0.0287992209,
0.0010076584,
0.1940430552,
-0.2302542031,
0.1202284843,
0.4460721016,
-0.0249242019,
0.6929342747,
0.2222997248,
-0.0345896296,
0.1587848961,
-0.4588901997,
-0.8275882006,
1.0768125057,
0.2901670933,
1.2429901361,
0.3023608029,
0.6510974765,
0.4559330344,
0.1416246593,
-0.8558412194,
0.7090443373,
-0.2068149596,
-0.3611323535,
-0.1100738198,
-0.3577906787,
-1.040170908,
0.2197341323,
0.0961002409,
-0.3502284884,
-0.0620863773,
0.02740933,
-0.1876254231,
0.5392404795,
-0.4871778488,
0.2587935925,
-0.3646339774,
0.1246304139,
-0.5711972713,
-0.7120109797,
-0.0202147663,
0.1400287747,
0.1077263951,
-0.0354085527,
-0.4294528961,
0.9220796824,
-0.2596744001,
0.7846075892,
0.2537713945,
-0.4372000992,
0.1240518168,
0.1508476585,
0.6423822045,
-0.218093127,
-0.0184883922,
0.6307119131,
-0.0384481959,
-0.1937146038,
-0.2248693556,
0.5537829995,
-1.1674046516,
-0.5744074583,
-0.6005707979,
-0.724183917,
-0.0053620371,
0.1228268147,
0.2671943009,
0.4321225584,
-0.1570798308,
-0.1830518395,
0.6806444526,
-0.2429144084,
0.3097143173,
0.9564541578,
-0.5470422506,
-0.5036717057,
0.8106905222,
0.2252299488,
0.1806809008,
0.4466038942,
-0.2085299492,
-0.1185896024,
-0.9465810657,
-0.6616895199,
0.231842041,
-0.6016941071,
-0.3006127179,
-0.6042572856,
-0.5907832384,
-0.2276301384,
-0.2613171637,
-0.3130297661,
-0.3375011683,
-0.3823468387,
0.2180208862,
0.5191878676,
0.7492712736,
-0.0104347691,
0.267878443,
-0.8844106197,
0.3885553181,
0.3324777484,
0.1309848577,
-0.0767973587,
-1.0042654276,
-0.4661465585,
0.0098121762,
0.0002470685,
-0.9837138057,
0.6090143919,
0.0944550484,
0.352989465,
0.286267668,
-0.2054948062,
0.5804207325,
-0.9197123051,
0.2394976169,
0.1513632387,
-1.1026501656,
0.4412663579,
-0.4723220468,
0.1023168042,
0.3014704585,
0.0008788407,
-1.0925908089,
-0.2628548741,
-0.1767023951,
-0.8074107766,
0.6900920272,
0.271525532,
0.2122728676,
0.2287433594,
0.2493161559,
0.0264504831,
0.3842572868,
-0.5996539593,
-0.6242559552,
0.0404364951,
-0.2679575384,
0.1285620481,
-0.2926730216,
-0.2532203794,
-0.1179048046,
0.8685927987,
0.1660312265,
0.4579879045,
-0.004416192,
-0.4024950266,
-0.1395163685,
0.503785789,
0.6236137748,
0.3377739489,
-0.126446411,
0.1735157669,
0.2394832373,
-0.9108992219,
0.3416741788,
0.4626187682,
-0.226533711,
0.1792024821,
0.1032095626,
0.87938416,
0.3045784533,
-0.6228429675,
0.0985550582,
0.1643114239,
0.0522120222,
-0.5116159916,
-0.0222812351,
0.0882116035,
0.4072498381,
0.5759373307,
0.2862841785,
0.2054741085,
-0.3648222089,
-0.1156489104,
0.2605757713,
-0.2099204659,
-0.2815166414,
0.5952646136,
0.5342783928,
-0.7349819541,
0.5786888599,
0.1917954385,
-0.4599175751,
0.5922598243,
0.8204289675,
1.0436739922,
-0.5935901403,
-0.0341799632,
-0.2019465715,
0.3995369077,
-0.0858401805,
0.4168159068,
-0.1393328607,
-0.9844793081,
-0.2391794175,
-0.4893297851,
-0.7883225083,
0.0795047656,
-0.9288925529,
0.2359874994,
-0.1906856149,
-0.0952444971,
-0.4758428335,
0.0742607415,
-0.4726922512,
0.0178857967,
0.1934685707,
0.9630927444,
-0.579710722,
1.18874681,
1.104583025,
-0.1411070675,
-0.5269879699,
-0.0738917217,
0.0556041896,
-1.4086216688,
0.579458952,
-0.1359761059,
-0.7397834659,
0.5059409738,
-0.5085956454,
-0.8014190197,
1.0554219484,
0.1732318401,
-0.6323922276,
0.1280977875,
0.1639095992,
0.1964347661,
-0.3817921877,
-0.082122609,
0.5313363671,
0.1666796356,
0.0658407584,
-1.0716949701,
-0.4118173718,
-0.57018888,
0.2052003741,
0.3489358127,
-0.4887121916,
0.6815078259,
-0.1706666499,
-0.2704274356,
0.5435655117,
0.6768884659,
0.4564200044,
0.2338929027,
0.2939529717,
0.5026355386,
0.313968271,
0.1633383185,
0.7629312277,
-0.53476125,
-0.0167105272,
0.8272365928,
-0.5283176899,
1.2372357845,
0.7244531512,
-0.4462285936,
0.4477598369,
0.3596968055,
0.2587290108,
0.472263962,
0.1161190942,
-0.8195536733,
-0.0493422449,
-0.0939896479,
-0.6945448518,
0.4085976183,
0.5401563048,
-0.3235985339,
-0.0649061576,
-0.0101211825,
0.207704246,
-0.0937141776,
-0.4261636138,
0.6664016843,
0.4131162763,
-0.1098902822,
0.5043206811,
0.5590232015,
1.0822378397,
-0.9097696543,
-0.0718651935,
-0.1935213804,
0.062205106,
-0.0702845082,
-0.4328447878,
0.2097348869,
0.3899899721,
-0.3362378478,
-0.6033617854,
0.7944298983,
-0.5511801839,
-0.7452263236,
0.3038442433,
0.6863732934,
0.3832830191,
0.2691315114,
-0.7680937052,
0.5136229992,
0.1190695316,
-0.0137658427,
0.3520597816,
0.0845334083,
0.0407356918,
0.814419508,
0.7130459547,
0.4482033551,
0.1573014259,
-0.0337347947,
0.6322700381,
-0.6411339641,
-0.5530040264,
-0.8237972856,
0.0923615322,
0.5310568213,
-0.2699048519,
0.8256548047,
0.5820410252,
0.7796570659,
-0.079062514,
0.9219644666,
0.1829840094,
0.5819263458,
-0.7003288269,
1.0579850674,
-0.246651873,
0.3960266411,
-0.1419537514,
-0.7240126729,
-0.0869221613,
0.956512928,
-0.3769117594,
-0.0126115177,
0.4012748897,
0.8546494842,
0.102226153,
-0.1488639712,
0.3117697537,
0.3344978392,
0.1376181096,
0.512034595,
1.0930718184,
-0.7329667211,
0.8950870037,
0.3545464873,
-0.1084700227,
-0.367264837,
-0.5906816125,
-0.5422805548,
-0.6090817451,
-0.4568351209,
-0.4579672217,
0.3484493792,
0.9579663277,
0.4043533504,
-0.9853875041,
-1.0304647684,
0.1696431637,
0.1090805382,
-0.345495671,
-0.0582197197,
0.1799518317,
0.0269059744,
-0.7854332924,
0.457131356,
0.4963262081,
0.2982658446,
-0.1558448076,
-0.4985896945,
-0.1859801263,
0.1742783487,
0.3540235758,
0.5006617904,
-1.0042062998,
0.1588632911,
-0.0518977344,
-0.3106204271,
0.075933598,
0.8126824498,
-0.6545032859,
0.1726157516,
0.1149320453,
0.8317141533,
0.4769004583,
-0.3942911327,
0.5332247615,
-0.2210796624,
0.1848747879,
0.2362350672,
0.3002464771,
0.2900945842,
0.10016305,
0.3313095272,
0.0498376936,
-0.5247743726,
-0.8378213048,
0.3918712437,
-0.752916038,
0.1510497779,
1.2349867821,
0.0448891409,
-0.0271863993,
-0.3845717907,
-0.4321184158,
0.3771564662,
-0.4774161279,
0.9237954617,
0.6970857978,
-0.1487573087,
-0.2913977802,
-0.6858131289,
0.336708039,
0.503369987,
-0.6696658134,
-0.4761528671,
0.2568300962,
0.1334380805,
-0.0347230211,
0.8016840816,
-0.078594178,
0.2970220447,
-0.279753536,
0.4121746421,
-0.0319294333,
-0.0959255695,
-0.6702315211,
-0.3716457784,
0.1738307625,
-0.5812297463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18118v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18118v2 | SafeAligner: Safety Alignment against Jailbreak Attacks via Response Disparity Guidance | 2024-06-26T07:15:44 | 2024-06-28T06:06:59 | Caishuang Huang, Wanxu Zhao, Rui Zheng, Huijie Lv, Shihan Dou, Sixian Li, Xiao Wang, Enyu Zhou, Junjie Ye, Yuming Yang, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | As the development of large language models (LLMs) rapidly advances, securing
these models effectively without compromising their utility has become a
pivotal area of research. However, current defense strategies against jailbreak
attacks (i.e., efforts to bypass security protocols) often suffer from limited
adaptability, restricted general capability, and high cost. To address these
challenges, we introduce SafeAligner, a methodology implemented at the decoding
stage to fortify defenses against jailbreak attacks. We begin by developing two
specialized models: the Sentinel Model, which is trained to foster safety, and
the Intruder Model, designed to generate riskier responses. SafeAligner
leverages the disparity in security levels between the responses from these
models to differentiate between harmful and beneficial tokens, effectively
guiding the safety alignment by altering the output token distribution of the
target model. Extensive experiments show that SafeAligner can increase the
likelihood of beneficial tokens, while reducing the occurrence of harmful ones,
thereby ensuring secure alignment with minimal loss to generality. | [
-0.2911789119,
-0.6967763305,
0.2551935911,
-0.0844193697,
-0.1908825785,
0.407543242,
0.1111230701,
-0.3333372474,
0.0437876657,
0.3398412764,
-0.3437278867,
-0.5257114768,
-0.8494397402,
0.0382249951,
-0.4273871183,
1.2524064779,
0.1367605031,
-0.00071952,
0.1040242538,
0.0124903517,
-0.740606904,
-0.4796718359,
-0.5403882861,
-0.0338123292,
0.4858857989,
0.2013508677,
0.967215836,
0.6286070943,
1.0196473598,
0.2842051089,
-0.4769017994,
-0.0546776764,
-0.3729744256,
0.4207801223,
-0.4371677935,
-0.3658111989,
-0.6313057542,
-0.0456768014,
0.2059626281,
0.2624570131,
-0.2614354789,
-0.0595371127,
0.1014980525,
0.9051696658,
-0.8723974824,
-0.3246281147,
-0.7769569159,
0.0185301453,
-0.2652414739,
0.2784099281,
-0.6082704067,
-0.4988905489,
-0.1426490247,
-0.2135432512,
0.249053672,
0.3817041218,
0.5700820088,
0.2308360934,
-0.4173572659,
0.0268955734,
-0.6525619626,
0.5385432839,
-0.4790289402,
0.0617793277,
0.3634259999,
0.4294644892,
-0.5373826027,
-0.4800310135,
-0.3902575374,
0.027271159,
-0.1087269709,
-0.2013844252,
-0.4260560572,
0.3237754405,
0.2262134105,
0.2059682757,
-0.529497683,
0.1337081939,
-0.5061230063,
-0.3122820556,
0.6427366138,
0.4419294894,
0.4434259832,
-0.1358433664,
-0.4220121205,
-0.2936853468,
-0.9169311523,
-0.0031998199,
0.3194541037,
0.4122545719,
-0.2238769978,
0.5227586627,
0.0570753664,
0.7782523036,
0.4650144279,
-0.1348816603,
0.0073896162,
-0.2807933986,
-0.0695577562,
0.5438992381,
0.9091918468,
0.6621826291,
-0.064675875,
-0.3776385486,
-0.2397349477,
0.0924346447,
0.4915094972,
-0.8298053741,
-0.2119620293,
0.3001840115,
-0.4301601052,
-0.8549135327,
0.1908173561,
-1.0118809938,
-1.0058994293,
0.1093296632,
0.2767922878,
-0.4233866632,
-0.3007736504,
0.1113516539,
-0.1090172455,
0.1739241332,
-0.0872217417,
-1.1198732853,
0.4277401865,
0.7782095075,
0.9564191699,
0.064707309,
-0.0553253442,
-0.8995655775,
0.1839056164,
-0.2406950593,
0.5310522318,
-0.1494418681,
-0.4285840392,
-0.2224979848,
-0.0565124042,
-0.326755017,
-0.2991833091,
0.441072762,
-0.9713009,
-0.2352210581,
0.0199266598,
-0.3212121725,
-0.0426949933,
0.4380420446,
-0.9299592972,
0.4523251653,
0.0385696776,
-1.3081949949,
0.2420928329,
-0.479385376,
-0.5289705992,
-0.2655869126,
0.1401459426,
-0.6173779368,
0.1862603575,
0.3943674564,
0.1336161792,
-0.1820182502,
0.2180081308,
-0.5356087685,
-0.2845053077,
0.3875643611,
-0.2364234179,
0.8073318005,
0.6946217418,
-0.4173090458,
0.2463866472,
-0.8105982542,
-0.1197199225,
0.2248027325,
-0.1136810035,
-0.6044733524,
0.1112464592,
-0.1758896559,
0.052525647,
0.2391691208,
-0.6067783833,
-0.0845502466,
-0.335752368,
0.4541905522,
0.8232628107,
-0.1622575074,
0.6995330453,
-0.2046691477,
0.4723037481,
0.1329812109,
0.4783787131,
-0.1144123226,
-0.0658849478,
-0.389993161,
-0.6355466247,
0.4541582167,
0.9714836478,
-0.1525972039,
0.431303829,
0.0132760331,
-0.3276851773,
-0.6258890033,
0.2644666731,
0.5556454659,
0.5943446755,
0.4024008214,
-0.2661113143,
-0.6874885559,
-0.6550490856,
-0.4495737255,
-0.2563282847,
0.2163456678,
-0.610683918,
0.0419080704,
-0.1703299582,
0.8185654283,
-0.4310185909,
-0.2052686065,
-0.5002230406,
-0.2181688547,
0.2685066164,
0.6725717783,
0.6330565214,
-0.6023695469,
-0.2901413143,
-0.1960682273,
-0.8849894404,
0.0658157021,
0.0509518906,
-0.2361211181,
0.0143847633,
0.8109068274,
-0.6206472516,
0.4848981202,
0.5004774928,
-0.555750668,
-0.0109865172,
-0.0504612289,
-0.0290855356,
-1.4649243355,
-0.1613065004,
-0.1431326568,
-0.2646353245,
-0.9477082491,
0.3886310458,
0.198880136,
-0.0287039578,
-0.4925480783,
0.232513994,
-0.307907939,
0.3355788589,
-0.2130171955,
0.0889369771,
-0.0106947562,
-0.316323489,
-0.4044867754,
0.9343659878,
0.5220319033,
-0.2513996661,
0.2693773806,
0.4314347208,
-0.2329966873,
0.5643499494,
-0.9044579268,
0.3079375625,
-0.4196722209,
-0.0570545942,
-0.8494579792,
-0.3411765993,
0.3983668089,
-0.2301679999,
0.5940255523,
-0.5529764295,
-0.4218912125,
-0.3118249178,
-0.375880301,
0.5298126936,
0.563600421,
-0.5570094585,
0.6384446025,
0.5291938782,
-0.3067606688,
-0.7565108538,
-0.4855082631,
0.2102096528,
-0.6808497906,
-0.8458167911,
0.1217144355,
0.0028683662,
-0.6649407744,
-0.270732224,
-0.1174519584,
-0.046130199,
0.5129506588,
0.4356920123,
0.6498330832,
0.0485347994,
-0.2258200943,
0.196111694,
-0.3952631354,
0.1989178807,
-0.1845142394,
0.392172873,
-0.4336013198,
-0.4165887237,
-0.4276608825,
0.4422091246,
0.7915124297,
-0.4027118981,
1.1870821714,
0.204763338,
-0.1915786862,
0.3984067738,
-0.4152402282,
-0.2104018331,
-0.5674325824,
0.2348056734,
-0.2647489309,
-0.9897996187,
0.4763608873,
0.1035622433,
0.1107761189,
0.0358118601,
0.1669976711,
0.0419798307,
1.2247376442,
0.7691489458,
-0.5483199954,
0.4951616824,
0.2451821417,
0.6298528314,
-0.7102228403,
-0.3446156979,
-0.4752480984,
-0.3022456169,
-0.4448937178,
-0.0366118737,
0.3014760017,
0.5768228173,
-0.5065216422,
0.5657086372,
-0.5932059884,
0.8392826915,
0.3469056487,
0.1034184098,
0.2664407492,
0.049257841,
-0.3237886727,
-0.0097688083,
-0.6226705313,
-0.5407215357,
1.1256738901,
0.4745198488,
1.3132795095,
0.5453190804,
1.1054909229,
0.3194990456,
0.299855113,
-0.4310992658,
0.4972991347,
-0.0300966389,
-0.8910253644,
0.0687653273,
-0.1909873039,
-0.8442087173,
0.3251361549,
-0.2957174778,
-0.8838608265,
0.0286836419,
0.3130996227,
-0.5426194668,
0.3859710693,
-0.5780059099,
0.7781082988,
-0.3957194984,
-0.3744627833,
0.0037158413,
-1.0439395905,
0.603505075,
-0.1795046329,
0.3820464015,
-0.1879668981,
0.4611292183,
0.4148143232,
-0.5910301805,
0.8506707549,
-0.2358842045,
0.2358929366,
0.3355012238,
0.3661698997,
0.6956161261,
0.1694254875,
-0.0639189109,
-0.1063088849,
-0.110172905,
-0.3186377585,
-0.1711996645,
0.469456017,
-0.6122874022,
-0.9277140498,
-0.5664130449,
-0.8899861574,
0.1276611537,
0.4168071449,
0.1771877408,
0.1503337622,
-0.3452516496,
-0.1073960885,
1.1367695332,
-0.0719485357,
0.4617815018,
0.2856001556,
-0.1315617263,
-0.866535604,
0.3930618763,
-0.4971867502,
0.3471295834,
0.1301442683,
-0.1364575028,
-0.3905136287,
-0.6756363511,
-0.3782086372,
-0.0028208001,
-0.722453475,
-0.6144780517,
-0.4893730879,
-0.4236041903,
-0.4826664627,
-0.4085657597,
-0.3781785369,
-0.575637877,
-0.0389374606,
-0.58696872,
0.7574016452,
0.469188571,
-0.5098645687,
0.4148621857,
-1.082868576,
0.1498414129,
0.0808829889,
-0.0052810451,
-0.3014911413,
-0.4006094337,
-0.1043851227,
-0.100882411,
-0.4611419141,
-0.8717839122,
0.2312138379,
-0.0439383872,
0.4680154324,
0.5776426792,
0.6278316975,
0.6106336117,
-0.6772893667,
0.3899220824,
0.6192688942,
-0.9223823547,
0.7640769482,
-0.3191199899,
0.0330665596,
0.8814327717,
-0.037943773,
-0.2451506257,
-0.6973828673,
-0.1544445008,
-1.0560195446,
0.40012604,
0.1673807502,
0.278475374,
-0.3587201536,
0.1938746423,
-0.1480181366,
0.045932427,
-0.6885119677,
0.0643442571,
-0.4257261753,
-0.5766857266,
0.146753639,
-0.1701882184,
-0.786438942,
0.0212117042,
0.2403087318,
0.0881687254,
0.2369548976,
0.0613361672,
-0.3285972178,
0.1631705165,
0.656478703,
0.5701088905,
0.1681907475,
-0.3120189905,
0.5149894953,
0.1985006183,
-0.7157119513,
0.628936708,
0.4891082048,
-0.3415791392,
-0.2809679806,
0.1619954705,
0.4966706634,
-0.307908684,
-0.3694068789,
0.5494303107,
-0.403241992,
-0.0124621727,
-0.1057924256,
0.401093781,
-0.1627530456,
0.4231649637,
0.1163599268,
0.3228709996,
-0.1519992203,
-0.0136931837,
0.2296077311,
0.5562847257,
-0.6623870134,
-0.1630239934,
1.2423224449,
0.2176231742,
-0.2136199921,
0.8237687945,
-0.0178865399,
-0.5161286592,
0.6952982545,
0.8690430522,
1.0317124128,
-0.3705270886,
-0.1262029856,
0.2704025209,
0.8715744615,
-0.2177149951,
0.0590580106,
0.352634728,
-0.5663712025,
0.0025617238,
-0.4745961428,
0.0276034456,
-0.1334239542,
-1.0071305037,
0.0773003027,
-1.0124663115,
-0.525539577,
-0.4019705355,
-0.6444861889,
-0.2913526893,
-0.0461150259,
0.0615487024,
1.2270700932,
-0.7701573372,
0.5781689882,
0.5725943446,
-0.3608283699,
-0.6933085322,
0.0262486301,
0.5674569011,
-0.3897305131,
0.572284162,
0.2999860644,
-0.389890492,
-0.2293443084,
-0.2964867651,
-0.9239025116,
1.1395696402,
0.3125830889,
-0.8200006485,
0.0790363625,
0.1432313621,
0.2147008032,
-0.3120564818,
-0.2353544533,
0.5667764544,
0.1887722313,
-0.1791109592,
-0.595468998,
0.4192841649,
-0.2565788627,
0.2822327018,
0.6935328245,
-0.517824471,
0.5684630275,
-0.6444557905,
-0.0265060086,
0.5434792042,
0.5893968344,
0.6622197628,
0.504286468,
0.4606668055,
0.7391577959,
0.7235737443,
-0.2380274832,
0.7992770076,
-0.5988035202,
0.0903393105,
0.9926709533,
-0.3886493444,
0.6844131351,
0.6890665293,
0.1995808482,
0.4246516228,
0.5107378364,
0.0195433628,
1.2596610785,
0.1753356904,
-0.6849369407,
-0.1485355794,
0.2671888173,
-0.544056356,
0.1482482255,
0.2720986009,
-0.4535936117,
-0.1965235174,
0.0726388693,
0.5660274625,
0.0865947455,
-0.3814701438,
0.7306483984,
0.1326646656,
-0.5646302104,
0.5972818136,
0.2075875551,
0.4060322046,
-0.5509256124,
0.4173027277,
-0.4078119695,
0.607788384,
-0.2020656765,
-0.5127952099,
0.599671483,
0.4304035306,
-0.5062390566,
0.211585328,
0.8492435813,
-0.1022130325,
-0.4028762579,
0.3268503845,
-0.1056076288,
-0.3296456933,
0.4744694829,
-0.5610171556,
0.227064237,
-0.1918687224,
0.0486339964,
0.7139151096,
0.0545923859,
-0.0926925912,
0.5877837539,
0.4962964058,
-0.3476716578,
0.23054111,
-0.171325922,
1.1131732464,
-0.5229749084,
-0.4033305645,
-1.1097444296,
0.8236194253,
-0.3096393049,
0.1941143274,
0.765129745,
0.4271574914,
0.5793591738,
-0.0006372388,
0.8259205818,
-0.2053064704,
0.2769034803,
-0.6044925451,
1.0591791868,
0.0465709455,
0.6860682368,
-0.4494034052,
-0.7211925983,
-0.7088576555,
0.8591520786,
-0.3545301855,
-0.3659126759,
0.5721539259,
1.1689485312,
-0.0987695381,
-0.0789019391,
-0.0826878473,
0.026152147,
0.4655046463,
0.5258456469,
1.0740294456,
-0.5710379481,
0.713409543,
0.0375905894,
-0.3332705796,
-0.0069701537,
-1.0897121429,
-1.2009733915,
0.1432133317,
-0.1571216136,
-0.9372647405,
0.5618430376,
0.8886656761,
0.6334184408,
-0.9358823895,
-0.0379618295,
-0.2620211244,
0.2777612209,
-0.1131752357,
-0.1348911077,
0.0569889061,
-0.4341072738,
-0.2549263239,
0.5500814915,
0.2708711028,
0.2838187814,
0.2753204405,
-0.256667763,
0.2763046622,
0.2322107106,
0.3013958335,
0.4008300602,
-0.4878923297,
-0.2160293609,
0.086357519,
-0.3098839521,
-0.1208151579,
0.5766695738,
-0.4061511159,
0.371268779,
0.2888951898,
0.7246298194,
-0.0545323007,
-0.0165271461,
0.6954384446,
-0.5009719729,
0.4688243568,
-0.1042431742,
0.3920689523,
0.4429654479,
-0.4675701261,
0.3796476126,
-0.0602315441,
-0.5468304753,
-0.9802494049,
0.5677981377,
-0.7046665549,
-0.1491887271,
0.8297624588,
-0.2889502347,
-0.2924773097,
-0.2143361121,
-0.194119662,
0.0042096828,
-0.3027952015,
1.2565428019,
0.4275077879,
0.2500574589,
-0.2210902274,
-0.0126609532,
0.4630894065,
0.1973714083,
-0.6496711373,
0.0843120888,
0.4064784646,
0.6570394635,
0.1930311769,
0.2909000218,
-0.6052507758,
0.3688696921,
0.0444608331,
-0.260956943,
-0.2033608407,
-0.5131821036,
-0.463524729,
0.1123088375,
0.426119566,
-0.4923478961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18116v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18116v1 | BADGE: BADminton report Generation and Evaluation with LLM | 2024-06-26T07:07:52 | 2024-06-26T07:07:52 | Shang-Hsuan Chiang, Lin-Wei Chao, Kuang-Da Wang, Chih-Chuan Wang, Wen-Chih Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Badminton enjoys widespread popularity, and reports on matches generally
include details such as player names, game scores, and ball types, providing
audiences with a comprehensive view of the games. However, writing these
reports can be a time-consuming task. This challenge led us to explore whether
a Large Language Model (LLM) could automate the generation and evaluation of
badminton reports. We introduce a novel framework named BADGE, designed for
this purpose using LLM. Our method consists of two main phases: Report
Generation and Report Evaluation. Initially, badminton-related data is
processed by the LLM, which then generates a detailed report of the match. We
tested different Input Data Types, In-Context Learning (ICL), and LLM, finding
that GPT-4 performs best when using CSV data type and the Chain of Thought
prompting. Following report generation, the LLM evaluates and scores the
reports to assess their quality. Our comparisons between the scores evaluated
by GPT-4 and human judges show a tendency to prefer GPT-4 generated reports.
Since the application of LLM in badminton reporting remains largely unexplored,
our research serves as a foundational step for future advancements in this
area. Moreover, our method can be extended to other sports games, thereby
enhancing sports promotion. For more details, please refer to
https://github.com/AndyChiangSH/BADGE. | [
-0.1121767461,
-0.464558512,
0.5489287972,
0.4665973186,
-0.3498039246,
0.1733635217,
-0.0181129277,
-0.6614149809,
0.2264806777,
0.0180356856,
-0.3781588674,
-0.9032900929,
-0.4352284968,
0.1412736475,
-0.2856383324,
0.6740095615,
-0.2728166282,
0.2357133031,
-0.2514933646,
-0.1709570438,
-1.015971899,
-0.5523966551,
-0.7524385452,
-0.524510622,
0.2168547213,
0.2520926595,
-0.2038578391,
0.5586255789,
0.6669707298,
0.2571678162,
0.2014674693,
0.355684638,
-0.6179061532,
0.412656635,
-0.2336443067,
-0.468002528,
-0.6863366365,
0.258700341,
0.6577877402,
0.2382130474,
0.0721922219,
0.5457202792,
0.1806081086,
0.51186198,
-0.4884820879,
0.7758864164,
-0.4766481519,
0.0303956363,
-0.3862879574,
-0.5802564621,
-0.4888566732,
-0.3114645183,
-0.5332938433,
-0.4825811386,
-0.1105992869,
0.262717545,
0.7301998734,
-0.2215114236,
-0.286390841,
-0.2860428989,
-0.7249676585,
0.5934500694,
-0.4761954546,
0.012591836,
0.5410859585,
0.6465067267,
0.002001361,
-0.5366458893,
-0.3007459939,
-0.2093505114,
0.059230715,
0.6464506984,
0.1756918579,
-0.2132113427,
0.0246597864,
0.1709775627,
-0.7227791548,
0.1714082211,
0.0153650334,
0.2772906125,
0.9955884218,
0.603990078,
0.3004530072,
-0.2239626497,
-0.2500217259,
0.2483571172,
-0.7443490028,
0.2222151309,
0.1957896948,
0.5315289497,
0.0395807289,
0.4559082687,
-0.2151838243,
0.4953467846,
0.4868102372,
-0.2089617252,
0.0112508731,
-0.1690184921,
-0.0653484464,
0.2453964651,
0.6349745393,
0.9091387987,
-0.1917598993,
-0.2627504766,
-0.3254636526,
0.1807475984,
-0.1326195598,
-0.9342244267,
-0.1241883561,
0.2822577357,
-0.6202249527,
-0.4392086864,
0.2937366664,
-0.4193360507,
-0.6166326404,
-0.2684752643,
0.6100789309,
-0.465075314,
-0.2204124928,
-0.0238443594,
-0.0679601878,
0.7688313127,
0.3770573735,
-0.8849656582,
0.1235790849,
0.8536483049,
0.862647593,
-0.3851625025,
-0.2681748867,
-0.9762428403,
0.4500043988,
-0.3344117403,
0.9410369396,
-0.6421890855,
-0.6452240348,
0.3325739801,
-0.1190246716,
-0.0011852121,
-0.553221643,
0.0755043775,
-0.4779141247,
-0.143142879,
-0.4262401164,
-0.8982631564,
0.1797878593,
0.4827542305,
-0.4325227439,
1.1317156553,
0.2399599999,
-0.6000591516,
0.8953499794,
-0.7826307416,
-0.7353895307,
0.7326794863,
-0.3415286541,
-0.4279496968,
0.0582415126,
0.1973068565,
0.4048364162,
-0.4885334074,
0.1436529011,
-0.330735594,
-0.8722934723,
0.272808075,
0.1314151585,
0.3932069838,
-0.1358455122,
-0.3891384006,
0.3106039464,
-0.6101518869,
0.163922444,
-0.100381203,
-0.4936389923,
0.0799085349,
0.2629352808,
-0.0031220864,
0.0657189935,
0.1732351929,
-0.6112787127,
0.1886682361,
-0.2526116371,
0.1198161095,
1.0565350056,
0.0709725618,
0.1730437726,
-0.4071973264,
0.7413794398,
-0.3194920123,
0.5568915009,
-0.0824071094,
-0.4153983295,
-0.2912567258,
-0.3427315056,
0.3714500368,
0.3732296526,
-0.5976512432,
0.5764631033,
-0.3366144896,
-0.5431550145,
-0.4865555763,
0.0589164831,
0.2417911887,
0.4001830518,
0.1192525476,
-0.3749369681,
-0.5364629626,
-0.5602377653,
-0.4436815083,
-0.4802663922,
0.099577792,
0.5840142369,
0.3982946873,
0.0646806359,
0.8001403809,
-0.6727976203,
-0.5022200346,
-0.4951638877,
0.2707484961,
0.1104933619,
0.3435127735,
0.7737693787,
-0.5688586235,
-0.9936320186,
-0.0267171916,
-0.9823345542,
-0.2858255208,
0.0029899878,
-0.263381511,
0.1650590599,
0.3553918898,
-0.2667112052,
0.6294422746,
0.3143209219,
-0.3070401251,
0.8374173641,
0.0651824549,
0.5635414124,
-0.9283617735,
0.3528129458,
-0.1910090595,
-0.440774411,
-0.182360068,
0.0046478384,
-0.0379791856,
0.0149841774,
-0.3193633258,
0.6608334184,
-0.4888786972,
0.0437955074,
-0.5374457836,
-0.0458716042,
-0.0851036608,
0.1618380547,
-0.1503871679,
0.6502622962,
0.5309855342,
-0.5515636802,
0.4765661061,
0.1561158746,
-0.5583122373,
0.9219142795,
-0.348227948,
0.0431966186,
-0.0880917609,
0.214345932,
-1.1297608614,
-0.4471353292,
0.1775169224,
-0.4241081178,
0.6118142605,
-0.2760545015,
-0.6381341219,
-0.6584177017,
-0.6467990279,
0.2669956982,
0.5022448301,
-0.6853047013,
0.4200311303,
0.7714728713,
0.0270067882,
-0.0690254793,
-0.6296923161,
0.1847243607,
-0.3116104305,
-0.2114786804,
0.1943661124,
-0.4329355061,
-0.0393169448,
-0.1693146229,
-0.3645090461,
-0.0845370069,
0.1615487337,
0.4394741952,
0.2013410032,
-0.0573023595,
0.0927370265,
-0.2886402011,
-0.0560153499,
0.1270025522,
-0.2722732127,
0.5412620306,
-0.0479459316,
-0.2791706324,
-0.5633927584,
0.583681345,
0.1548085064,
-0.1216669083,
0.6131660938,
0.4706344903,
-0.0459600762,
-0.4154580534,
-0.2834266424,
-0.0108638154,
-0.5130943656,
0.2380873114,
-0.5818058252,
-0.7770225406,
0.412181288,
-0.2096538544,
-0.1872110665,
0.4683470428,
0.5081621408,
-0.2531437576,
1.3101673126,
0.6691970825,
-0.1691426486,
0.2481129915,
0.0744004548,
0.0861753076,
-0.7625710964,
-0.2690222263,
-0.2949022353,
-0.3768186867,
-0.4229829311,
-0.0548171923,
0.3303278089,
-0.023926327,
-0.2486890554,
0.0331944935,
-0.4687002599,
0.9013600945,
0.2442856133,
0.1281871647,
0.0700746775,
-0.3562884033,
0.0375079475,
-0.178754285,
-0.5636255741,
-0.3522209227,
1.1139650345,
-0.2050869018,
0.6894429326,
0.3549375236,
1.0230240822,
0.6367480159,
0.8436869979,
-0.6904390454,
0.7491983771,
-0.0607523285,
-0.398653239,
-0.0358196832,
-0.3004373312,
-0.8158189058,
-0.1520180553,
-0.0332968161,
-0.6034377217,
-0.420501411,
0.0510221608,
-0.2837518454,
0.2731248438,
-0.3500164747,
0.4163666368,
-0.3461508751,
-0.5022279024,
0.3328357041,
-0.4655022919,
0.7907720208,
-0.3748196661,
0.106998913,
-0.0711997822,
0.2730301321,
0.890578568,
-0.4820857048,
0.9297538996,
-0.4109823704,
0.0628752261,
0.316031009,
0.2555549443,
0.2981952727,
0.1055933088,
-0.1450256407,
-0.3505339324,
-0.132490322,
-0.2194921374,
-0.438470751,
0.8611671329,
-0.5304786563,
-0.6109248996,
-0.6838336587,
-0.3955213428,
-0.3283333778,
0.2791990638,
0.0709703341,
0.2715871036,
-0.4289105237,
-0.0414829031,
0.1643492877,
-0.2180332243,
0.3709055185,
0.8019043207,
-0.6553350091,
-0.1832697541,
0.8978375196,
0.3126781881,
-0.3419357836,
0.4152341485,
0.2107854038,
-0.4998982251,
-0.7063931823,
-0.0314021185,
0.2191222459,
-0.7202097178,
-0.4786926806,
0.0650241971,
-0.2176911086,
-0.5991129875,
0.0681081638,
-0.2249683887,
-0.198634088,
0.0441166274,
-0.2512801588,
0.2700585425,
1.2016700506,
-0.2398727834,
0.3308038116,
-0.5421109796,
0.10182897,
0.2128238678,
0.7853634357,
0.0015309893,
-0.5896431208,
-0.3017709851,
-0.3808027208,
-0.1870099157,
-0.6578092575,
0.297888428,
-0.0283702891,
0.5347536802,
0.2542491853,
0.0518150628,
0.8439098597,
-0.70183599,
1.0233802795,
0.332025528,
-0.8852888346,
0.6997602582,
-0.5208403468,
0.2129060626,
0.6449553967,
0.1240736544,
-0.3760106862,
-0.3506780565,
-0.3393891752,
-1.1122095585,
0.7398820519,
-0.0452456251,
-0.2039248794,
-0.3419408798,
0.4799740911,
0.215092063,
0.2438627332,
-0.5566254258,
-0.2289272547,
-0.1033372059,
-0.1351948231,
-0.1529009044,
-0.3248443007,
-0.1513893306,
-0.2962228656,
0.6383572221,
-0.0482994691,
0.2186821848,
-0.1315217465,
-0.3023492098,
0.0251048505,
-0.051493749,
0.5236833096,
0.8696151376,
-0.460578084,
0.0208077412,
0.0401151069,
-0.2128527611,
0.0954434723,
-0.1344037056,
-0.2571057975,
-0.1461355835,
0.4721623063,
0.3336060047,
0.2186725736,
-0.2682688832,
0.6217980981,
-0.1931042969,
-0.4541828334,
-0.0661610588,
-0.120240055,
0.1285468042,
0.1815751046,
0.2613402307,
-0.3764807284,
-0.028766742,
-0.50953722,
0.4071802497,
0.3902575672,
-0.3353960514,
-0.4996064603,
0.9621068239,
0.4571770132,
-0.1750204265,
0.1548107862,
-0.4981001019,
-0.4397682548,
0.2221877426,
0.7622585893,
0.8317258954,
-0.2817547321,
0.4109308124,
0.3881419003,
0.0956944078,
0.0823544189,
0.5662228465,
0.0143873906,
-0.1684531569,
-0.559738636,
-0.8377776146,
-0.2925761938,
0.2833919823,
-0.5136938691,
-0.1010570899,
-0.5482952595,
-0.3329982162,
-0.100830771,
0.2284063548,
-0.6289874315,
-0.0315616876,
0.3329881728,
0.8657559752,
-0.908428967,
0.6251849532,
0.4427835345,
-0.7754025459,
-0.8307056427,
-0.0320344679,
0.0651168451,
-0.8510884643,
1.1227172613,
0.363833487,
-0.1490148902,
-0.1181378961,
-0.5894318223,
-0.2351486534,
1.2134336233,
-0.0503723919,
-0.3927588165,
0.2998285294,
0.4474416971,
0.3011232316,
-0.4750877321,
0.1583892852,
0.5434908867,
0.7604840994,
-0.0477681868,
-0.6217127442,
0.1190338284,
-0.252291888,
-0.0162587985,
-0.001944489,
-0.9632303119,
0.7244900465,
0.3500332236,
-0.2145386338,
0.2806685567,
0.6090190411,
0.241227299,
0.1696747541,
0.1630962193,
0.2628907859,
1.0336328745,
-0.0227390397,
1.1481558084,
-0.2983303666,
0.2663433552,
1.2743979692,
-1.1416422129,
0.6887283921,
0.2315919399,
-0.0822040811,
0.1393896043,
0.5707800388,
-0.322023809,
0.3362876177,
0.5518242121,
-0.3601240814,
-0.3700762987,
-0.0863766894,
-0.2433574498,
0.7355079055,
-0.1318953633,
-0.11241097,
-0.350194335,
-0.0101884427,
-0.0737810507,
0.174719274,
-0.492677331,
0.7420769334,
-0.1150241047,
-0.5615829229,
0.2551200688,
0.1101421937,
0.5062090755,
-0.6611218452,
-0.1143348888,
-0.3846179843,
0.455134064,
-0.0576749071,
-0.8652231693,
-0.0328260548,
0.3808657825,
-0.2625533044,
-0.2720593214,
0.6861923933,
-0.324036926,
-0.5043318868,
0.302025795,
0.4216867089,
0.3383821845,
-0.0589115694,
-0.5677012205,
0.1550359428,
-0.2451873422,
-0.0773785636,
0.5602405667,
0.3637550473,
-0.0559406988,
0.490537405,
0.4385473728,
0.3260190487,
-0.0526151806,
0.3261892796,
0.6062242389,
-0.6874906421,
-0.5365139246,
-0.9476891756,
0.2039089203,
-0.3286927938,
-0.1088155881,
1.1400374174,
1.2821033001,
0.1498860568,
-0.0771223158,
0.9863017201,
0.0633779466,
0.4932561219,
-0.376460731,
1.1577967405,
-0.2979587913,
0.2346022576,
0.0167715456,
-0.5992346406,
-0.6473434567,
0.1805367172,
-0.1805402637,
-0.1396286339,
0.6219621301,
0.4710482061,
0.0438599363,
-0.0989895836,
0.2834807634,
0.2436444759,
0.8245502114,
0.6605494022,
0.8182540536,
-0.3057401478,
0.5064803958,
0.458439976,
-0.5596294999,
-0.4493435323,
-0.8393219113,
-1.1901849508,
-0.3636696041,
-0.2568859756,
-0.3905619085,
0.2173689008,
0.564283967,
0.5393921137,
-0.6653291583,
-0.4922553301,
0.3522445858,
-0.2117876559,
-0.1995139569,
-0.2768730521,
0.6920904517,
-0.5179013014,
-0.5244120359,
0.474183619,
0.4764688015,
-0.2968099117,
0.0982884765,
-0.2627004683,
-0.4950866699,
0.0775752962,
0.9331108332,
0.3905510008,
-0.2584746778,
-0.5576102138,
-0.1851608008,
-0.009049966,
0.1629841328,
0.5172137022,
-0.7075964808,
0.4791216552,
0.3676451147,
0.5445024967,
0.7376312017,
0.0094888788,
0.6050547361,
-0.7673820853,
-0.2738862634,
0.1312902123,
0.138371855,
0.2377937883,
-0.0455549471,
0.5800299048,
0.3846937418,
-0.4631999135,
-1.0206437111,
0.0856102854,
-0.8799814582,
-0.2335894555,
1.1128338575,
-0.046633739,
-0.5587239265,
0.0700477064,
-0.1904799342,
0.212013483,
-0.1657466888,
0.8453666568,
0.8724444509,
-0.4406508207,
0.4480489194,
-0.2487555146,
0.6666468382,
-0.0465567037,
-0.8079491854,
0.2969345748,
0.2811343968,
0.4453917146,
-0.4397766888,
0.9998914003,
-0.1640847921,
0.4290055633,
0.0153531358,
-0.1197944954,
-0.2811689973,
-0.1578286588,
0.0447016433,
0.3143461645,
0.1156725362,
-0.3156315088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18108v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18108v1 | Token-Weighted RNN-T for Learning from Flawed Data | 2024-06-26T06:48:11 | 2024-06-26T06:48:11 | Gil Keren, Wei Zhou, Ozlem Kalinli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | ASR models are commonly trained with the cross-entropy criterion to increase
the probability of a target token sequence. While optimizing the probability of
all tokens in the target sequence is sensible, one may want to de-emphasize
tokens that reflect transcription errors. In this work, we propose a novel
token-weighted RNN-T criterion that augments the RNN-T objective with
token-specific weights. The new objective is used for mitigating accuracy loss
from transcriptions errors in the training data, which naturally appear in two
settings: pseudo-labeling and human annotation errors. Experiments results show
that using our method for semi-supervised learning with pseudo-labels leads to
a consistent accuracy improvement, up to 38% relative. We also analyze the
accuracy degradation resulting from different levels of WER in the reference
transcription, and show that token-weighted RNN-T is suitable for overcoming
this degradation, recovering 64%-99% of the accuracy loss. | [
0.2845241427,
-0.3573793471,
0.1587186158,
0.0610214882,
-0.4266230762,
0.2438278943,
-0.1902041733,
-0.1103628948,
0.2563814223,
0.0842163935,
-0.2806362212,
-0.5409160256,
-0.8233336806,
0.3377302587,
-0.4696211219,
1.1949518919,
0.0382668972,
0.6737026572,
-0.0922718346,
-0.2830757499,
-0.3592120707,
-0.6967876554,
-0.8584202528,
-0.3660584092,
0.9248175621,
0.3415798843,
0.2146538794,
0.6025602221,
0.6313772798,
0.2077547163,
-0.1170512587,
0.0775516927,
-0.4835493565,
-0.223083511,
-0.0536537431,
-0.8632676601,
-0.4633331299,
-0.0003677019,
0.6771572232,
0.5398762822,
-0.1220935285,
0.463175118,
-0.079230614,
0.4347049594,
-0.6044884324,
-0.1165690422,
-0.4503316879,
0.4281917512,
-0.3817437291,
-0.528000176,
-0.4727290869,
-0.2760288715,
0.043822825,
-0.568911612,
0.3705523908,
0.1571979076,
0.7882142067,
0.5984418392,
-0.3056256175,
0.011158457,
-0.5121857524,
0.9482038617,
-0.7147952914,
0.4547250867,
0.5275503397,
0.02447992,
0.0899575874,
-0.7724192142,
-0.3624506891,
-0.195916906,
0.0460628532,
0.1835777611,
-0.1542524397,
0.0409929045,
0.4532392621,
0.1080979779,
-0.3750768006,
-0.0188530143,
-0.6544986367,
-0.7963576317,
0.2392664403,
-0.0980943963,
0.4332077205,
-0.0850489363,
-0.474070847,
-0.3365307748,
-0.5494552851,
-0.0451875217,
0.5170612931,
0.5871584415,
-0.0646499917,
0.786546886,
0.2158609331,
0.868357718,
0.1592337042,
-0.2437962145,
0.6012442112,
-0.2948024869,
-0.1426709592,
0.4996285141,
0.4963648915,
0.2908074558,
0.1415604204,
-0.479998827,
-0.5183348656,
0.0882222131,
0.3030492067,
-0.6201574206,
-0.2541260421,
-0.0447347574,
-0.5892398953,
-0.4887412786,
0.4733849764,
-0.2742860913,
-0.1544417739,
-0.4472182691,
0.914770484,
-0.3494698107,
-0.0137812253,
0.0713971108,
-0.7066537738,
-0.096480608,
0.0133189857,
-0.271147877,
0.1259206682,
0.4499754012,
1.0804531574,
-0.2783224583,
-0.0256215129,
-0.9409661293,
0.1091388613,
-0.2229083925,
0.451102674,
-0.4417172968,
-0.3816131651,
-0.4730435908,
-0.463606745,
0.0170732141,
-0.4574894011,
0.6854519844,
-0.3939127624,
0.2396677732,
-0.5090206265,
-0.5392938852,
0.0667473897,
0.2513132393,
-0.6121723652,
0.8856300712,
0.2932210565,
-0.9884855151,
0.6703146696,
-0.5309638381,
-0.8301771879,
-0.321785152,
0.0690095574,
-0.8809628487,
0.2696842253,
0.0968731195,
0.1062038988,
-0.1804338098,
0.3435767293,
-0.2266210467,
-0.6173863411,
0.3532716334,
-0.3085661232,
0.8038556576,
0.0654705614,
-0.5379717946,
0.1952065229,
-0.9267944098,
0.0891268253,
-0.201647073,
-0.4686207473,
-0.4053006172,
-0.4871831834,
0.1423432529,
0.2448029369,
0.0335368402,
-0.8427940011,
0.0143851954,
-0.1820584387,
0.4945334494,
0.8423839211,
-0.0165359825,
0.4454554617,
-0.6379919648,
0.4060069323,
0.3520338535,
0.2018758804,
0.4227168858,
-0.3499742448,
-0.6185403466,
-0.4988791347,
0.8573902249,
0.5733375549,
-0.9109543562,
0.6592152715,
-0.3241857588,
-0.3764236271,
-0.6515939832,
0.0665408298,
0.8095437288,
1.1067279577,
0.7992319465,
-0.5209816098,
-1.034058094,
-0.6143890023,
-0.6488566399,
-0.2804055512,
-0.3514668643,
0.1115396842,
0.1636710465,
-0.1978185177,
0.9222189188,
0.0075790565,
-0.6649037004,
-0.1795602888,
0.5364294648,
-0.0416731983,
0.6982212067,
0.1336999387,
-0.8734948039,
-0.3014712036,
-0.4319033623,
-0.2861658633,
-0.3314734697,
-0.1193005517,
0.2036283612,
0.1170358881,
0.4373339713,
-0.2959229648,
0.7348165512,
0.1577280462,
-0.2936700583,
0.2638919055,
-0.3462494016,
0.0407180972,
-0.9669409394,
0.1072192788,
0.2802610099,
-0.3155445158,
-0.582908392,
-0.4977151453,
0.2666570246,
0.2804219425,
-0.3266811371,
0.5307476521,
-0.2138945907,
-0.1039289162,
0.0720336884,
-0.2414668649,
0.0178104118,
0.2930454314,
0.0304453224,
0.6151770949,
0.3059860468,
-0.3766282201,
0.0979506895,
0.32513991,
-0.1736476719,
0.5638259053,
-0.8091763258,
0.1875873953,
-0.2546364665,
0.5087311268,
-0.6964278221,
0.0572439693,
0.3604763448,
-0.6733741164,
0.7053520679,
-0.1596702039,
-0.4028274715,
-0.4320949912,
-0.3204404712,
0.711338222,
0.4594813585,
-0.4094578922,
0.6578013301,
0.0644148886,
0.3033022285,
-0.8804732561,
-1.151407361,
0.1915730834,
-0.3155705333,
-0.1359021217,
0.3005075753,
0.2804074585,
0.0346430689,
0.0733195618,
-0.5981349349,
0.2632566392,
-0.1187030077,
0.1923851967,
0.2064806074,
-0.1794940233,
0.0862795487,
-0.3477862775,
-0.3284120262,
-0.215780884,
-0.9134107232,
0.2716888785,
0.2240227461,
-0.3584080637,
-0.7697349191,
-0.1495326757,
0.3024897873,
-0.194722414,
0.7313097119,
0.8984438777,
-0.3341452777,
-0.1094064489,
-0.6588442326,
-0.3570435941,
-0.3765195906,
0.438380748,
-0.1299887002,
-0.598094523,
0.5978036523,
0.2876763344,
-0.2551677227,
0.492141068,
0.3020627797,
-0.3879055083,
0.7277837992,
0.4650764763,
-0.2834772766,
0.7322568297,
-0.2312785536,
0.2638322711,
-0.8578249812,
-0.4859108627,
-0.6102855206,
-0.8955594301,
-0.2215471268,
-0.622800827,
0.5838330984,
-0.2980701923,
-0.4856489897,
0.2006640285,
-0.4758743942,
0.125396356,
1.02757442,
0.713696301,
0.1290618628,
0.087596029,
-0.1977086365,
0.1530895829,
-0.7558373809,
-0.0741872191,
1.4972294569,
0.1945675611,
0.8123810887,
-0.0516595133,
0.8370069265,
0.6697551012,
0.3513564467,
-0.520142436,
0.0977451429,
-0.2635211051,
-0.6543166041,
-0.5911052227,
-1.0712647438,
-0.5848439932,
-0.276863873,
-0.1631625146,
-0.5625235438,
0.216985777,
0.5047127008,
-0.3066447079,
0.6092964411,
-0.506162107,
0.8559343219,
-0.3779331446,
0.1139925197,
0.1465111822,
-1.1014721394,
0.0426579081,
-0.1348971874,
-0.1075016335,
0.2496639043,
-0.2937112749,
1.0765479803,
-0.8026405573,
0.9133992195,
-0.6429340839,
0.3111112714,
0.2410895973,
-0.2406392395,
0.7496700287,
-0.3372551799,
-0.2876886427,
0.3043984771,
-0.2369961888,
-0.5274694562,
-0.5536058545,
-0.0348996259,
-0.8053189516,
-0.1670000702,
-0.3652265668,
-0.4064206779,
-0.2134562135,
0.1579788029,
0.6496845484,
0.7718883157,
0.2872794867,
0.3671444356,
0.638881743,
-0.0835978761,
0.0760284588,
0.0932974145,
0.3624374568,
-0.6173032522,
1.160962224,
0.2752461135,
0.2711471915,
0.4955961406,
0.4526671767,
-0.4466305375,
-0.8787682652,
-0.331536144,
-0.1142683625,
-0.6972697973,
-0.7823995352,
-0.6499180794,
-0.0088308407,
-0.0711251572,
0.13094078,
-0.2489370853,
-0.6769019961,
-0.5294294357,
-0.3642729223,
0.4044485092,
0.2138438821,
-0.2664786279,
0.4261087775,
-0.7242581844,
0.4708514512,
-0.1411742866,
0.355932951,
-0.068972446,
-1.1856127977,
-0.0150086489,
0.2968903184,
0.1631109118,
-0.4399403334,
0.0633756965,
0.5306267738,
0.3470987976,
0.2990232408,
0.26059407,
0.9450086355,
-0.3873906434,
0.4931111038,
0.533990562,
-1.0167965889,
0.3363496959,
-0.0669163689,
0.1249184459,
0.7448943257,
-0.0021527228,
-0.5585331917,
-0.5603766441,
-0.7462725639,
-0.9164763689,
0.7347167134,
0.2789601386,
-0.0058109411,
0.1458953768,
0.6769789457,
0.0509218983,
0.1182286665,
-0.7089936137,
-0.3595880866,
-0.4130345285,
-0.6869797707,
-0.1319601834,
-0.1527664363,
-0.0524188951,
-0.3620366156,
0.8948350549,
-0.1124251932,
0.0459899083,
0.5561555028,
-0.4401248693,
-0.3878390193,
-0.2078073472,
0.5463315248,
0.5878303647,
-0.1788391173,
0.2160121799,
0.3713200986,
-0.6847375631,
0.273747772,
-0.036256846,
-0.4287433028,
-0.1457504779,
0.5771304965,
0.614982307,
0.355730325,
-0.4347122014,
0.7591562867,
-0.2134925574,
-0.1063801721,
-0.052559521,
-0.1299879253,
-0.1542314589,
0.0448998362,
0.7014865875,
0.6594886184,
-0.0271124914,
-0.356539607,
0.6908246279,
0.3127926588,
-0.6897881031,
-0.2530680597,
0.7874841094,
-0.0085439915,
-0.3535953164,
0.6508256197,
-0.0747660846,
-0.7715478539,
0.5813330412,
0.5387929678,
0.8296027184,
-0.1629201472,
0.153922677,
0.4082357287,
0.2621981502,
-0.5094789863,
0.3581862748,
-0.1453546584,
-0.6329697371,
-0.2825193405,
-0.7302884459,
-0.1704583615,
-0.3761027455,
-0.9029046893,
0.3972141147,
-0.5874247551,
-0.4996129572,
-0.1163640842,
-0.2552394867,
-0.6533843875,
0.4983518422,
-0.0431954451,
0.8021480441,
-0.9056149125,
0.7231108546,
0.6522362232,
-0.4638535082,
-0.9734158516,
0.137998566,
0.0341339409,
-0.7095811367,
0.865968585,
-0.0990596935,
-0.0339791439,
0.0559510961,
-0.2769329846,
-0.9564294219,
0.983864367,
0.3833978772,
-0.5961307883,
-0.1423604488,
0.2288048565,
0.580137074,
0.0325368196,
0.0981833115,
0.3029417098,
0.6091323495,
0.3313649297,
-0.9215485454,
0.1436538249,
-0.0117537193,
-0.1880620271,
0.2513519526,
-0.6486542225,
0.5317285657,
-0.1762814671,
0.0653665066,
0.0079319282,
0.6119174957,
0.06733156,
0.4975475669,
0.7303606868,
0.7537202239,
0.9487518668,
-0.2756494582,
0.9072042704,
0.1817818582,
0.2010741234,
1.1495908499,
0.106650874,
0.5020840168,
0.6742134094,
-0.2135124058,
0.2456735224,
0.7443345785,
-0.234181717,
0.5938170552,
0.6459793448,
-0.0031106912,
-0.1238813922,
-0.0670057982,
0.0005440327,
0.3828796148,
0.0788506046,
-0.2743014991,
0.0897704735,
0.1544535905,
-0.3036721349,
-0.0930592567,
-0.481987983,
0.7463849187,
0.2180099636,
-0.2847429812,
0.2429262847,
-0.0018554756,
0.8454132676,
-0.3024290204,
0.1823438555,
-0.0501701199,
0.1174182817,
-0.3954167366,
-0.0486663431,
0.3777791262,
0.0935769007,
-0.1262388974,
-0.237171337,
0.6798074841,
-0.5186302662,
-0.8672031164,
0.0225555599,
0.1547338814,
0.0067556649,
0.0654137656,
-0.6432260871,
0.0103464723,
0.0632813275,
-0.1561980397,
0.0792380273,
0.4459770918,
-0.1228242815,
0.614551127,
0.638522923,
0.4249303639,
0.1362711638,
0.2881027162,
0.5749887228,
-0.6340827346,
-0.520349443,
-0.8309434652,
0.6231559515,
-0.1364286095,
-0.2784445584,
0.5132752657,
0.7414556742,
0.9120196104,
0.1616597474,
0.7053265572,
-0.0267223157,
0.6430623531,
-0.4692395031,
0.7368706465,
-0.7945604324,
0.2135194689,
-0.3123450875,
-0.7920585871,
-0.8868821263,
0.5172562003,
-0.1826449335,
0.2871000469,
0.5037833452,
0.6419317126,
-0.1227571741,
-0.1802867204,
0.2762656212,
0.0325644873,
0.1693622023,
0.3759900033,
0.66887182,
-0.6516039968,
0.6374595165,
-0.2399356663,
-0.1356140375,
-0.2204229534,
-0.8556411266,
-1.060195446,
-0.5009089112,
-0.5607399344,
-0.5753863454,
0.2512469292,
1.1232128143,
0.7090709805,
-1.0883902311,
0.4770809114,
-0.0029372841,
0.1824602187,
-0.1439026445,
-0.0629740581,
0.6267548203,
-0.3695709407,
-0.406345278,
0.0890454501,
0.2271906883,
0.134564057,
0.3376676738,
-0.1389745176,
0.0701874644,
-0.2345903516,
-0.0226937123,
0.3373020291,
-0.6803815365,
-0.5759187937,
-0.1475140005,
-0.114126496,
0.1680313349,
1.1038944721,
-0.6325930953,
0.4615566134,
0.2961927056,
0.9015391469,
0.4900889099,
0.329960674,
0.7526554465,
-1.2249435186,
0.1769943386,
0.596300602,
0.3246628046,
0.5776517391,
-0.5072759986,
0.4407713711,
0.4540295303,
-0.1172941476,
-1.1344281435,
-0.3508641422,
-0.8395304084,
0.0657198504,
1.0373055935,
-0.1448081881,
-0.3293858469,
-0.195840016,
0.0021195682,
0.9338381886,
-0.2768737078,
1.0486263037,
0.4361797273,
0.1403134465,
0.0979449898,
-0.1068796888,
0.6168178916,
0.7211654186,
-0.2692739964,
-0.2167659849,
0.1502839923,
0.420101881,
0.0653759316,
0.3652741909,
-0.244348228,
0.3959033787,
-0.2344105095,
0.0731727555,
-0.287671119,
-0.3221747875,
-0.330922395,
-0.1087554991,
0.0682424456,
-0.3565994203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18094v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18094v1 | Shimo Lab at "Discharge Me!": Discharge Summarization by Prompt-Driven Concatenation of Electronic Health Record Sections | 2024-06-26T06:10:20 | 2024-06-26T06:10:20 | Yunzhen He, Hiroaki Yamagiwa, Hidetoshi Shimodaira | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we present our approach to the shared task "Discharge Me!" at
the BioNLP Workshop 2024. The primary goal of this task is to reduce the time
and effort clinicians spend on writing detailed notes in the electronic health
record (EHR). Participants develop a pipeline to generate the "Brief Hospital
Course" and "Discharge Instructions" sections from the EHR. Our approach
involves a first step of extracting the relevant sections from the EHR. We then
add explanatory prompts to these sections and concatenate them with separate
tokens to create the input text. To train a text generation model, we perform
LoRA fine-tuning on the ClinicalT5-large model. On the final test data, our
approach achieved a ROUGE-1 score of $0.394$, which is comparable to the top
solutions. | [
-0.2735835314,
-0.7539971471,
0.9904751182,
-0.0832095817,
-0.4194295704,
0.0026114571,
0.3076064587,
-0.3874877989,
0.4107005,
0.738648653,
-0.8723990321,
-0.7868973017,
-0.1977330148,
0.0881005749,
-0.4400137067,
1.4645264149,
0.1437115967,
-0.114105083,
-0.0986585096,
-0.1373354793,
-0.5473780036,
-0.4008041024,
-0.6848194599,
-0.5689356923,
0.8716371655,
0.4830608964,
0.0087918546,
0.4047158659,
0.6168881059,
0.2052857131,
-0.0329122134,
0.1167612374,
-0.078625001,
0.3001028597,
-0.1075729579,
-0.3104273975,
-0.7194820642,
-0.2744008601,
0.2991742492,
0.6730571985,
-0.2375254929,
0.4726910889,
0.0055855741,
0.865653336,
-0.6745108962,
-0.2690119743,
-0.191519469,
0.2036143243,
-0.1749028116,
-0.2770833373,
-0.6720730066,
-0.1534312367,
-0.0256557148,
-0.4904058576,
0.4687111974,
-0.0555292889,
0.463806361,
0.0482127406,
-0.4331993759,
-0.1477368027,
-0.8259334564,
0.6620680094,
-0.7439858317,
-0.1003801301,
0.1682846099,
0.2497731447,
0.0953692347,
-0.9899150729,
-0.2233664542,
0.1107472703,
-0.2237538397,
0.3838113546,
0.0660710558,
0.4153521359,
0.4784281552,
0.287406832,
-0.7626550198,
0.0146946115,
-0.756811738,
0.1073983535,
0.9576755166,
0.6412014365,
0.3080749512,
-0.0701704696,
-0.169999212,
-0.0586296283,
-0.5625769496,
-0.028948037,
-0.1315945834,
0.0777283534,
-0.3879671097,
0.4901283681,
-0.3832305968,
0.2852863073,
0.350641042,
0.0071204207,
0.2701510787,
-0.4779697359,
-0.2557625175,
0.4054848254,
0.9546411037,
0.4977675378,
-0.4318820536,
0.1849717349,
-0.1206103265,
-0.3122843802,
0.476232022,
-0.9116123319,
-0.2419557124,
0.7729827166,
-0.7345428467,
-0.4428579509,
-0.1757797599,
-0.9867162108,
-0.2296676636,
-0.0947299302,
0.6631637216,
-0.5280941129,
0.3649019301,
-0.1059435382,
-0.1519302875,
-0.1645457596,
0.4969090223,
-1.0743658543,
0.4785389304,
0.6204637289,
0.8430924416,
-0.0476000495,
-0.1121811196,
-1.0683630705,
0.2968376577,
0.1130807102,
0.6308947206,
0.0391969085,
-0.6692980528,
0.0887442976,
-0.1832578927,
0.1829893142,
-0.5057822466,
0.4507173002,
-0.1967250556,
0.3258443773,
-0.0571382679,
-0.5690279603,
-0.0536668189,
0.0045533101,
-0.6476706862,
0.4186616242,
0.2907743752,
-0.6708810329,
0.0672202334,
-0.8007861376,
-0.3980902433,
0.3141704202,
-0.2655199468,
-0.4411287606,
0.0006368509,
0.0725307986,
0.5247099996,
-0.1690831482,
0.3002824783,
-0.0433885194,
-0.3280135691,
0.1608120948,
0.1135928258,
0.7668761611,
0.3166159987,
-0.2172549665,
0.3898730874,
-0.9554758668,
0.1886446327,
-0.2960861921,
-0.2854624391,
-0.2767763138,
-0.1774219722,
0.1699487865,
0.0985336304,
0.225307107,
-0.2240930647,
0.1455079913,
-0.4172720313,
0.2120132744,
0.5122790337,
0.5753424764,
0.3135353923,
-0.6461562514,
0.5927721858,
0.1140060127,
0.4385792017,
-0.8447286487,
-0.4023786187,
-0.4019174278,
-0.2863933444,
0.0652581006,
0.4216484129,
-0.2031202018,
0.6290877461,
0.1654104143,
-0.606171906,
-0.2935425341,
-0.0668697506,
0.5618231893,
0.6174924374,
0.7629816532,
-0.1502818018,
-0.3458212018,
-0.9403222799,
0.1345232129,
0.1123730168,
-0.1980018765,
-0.4384691119,
0.4442873299,
-0.2744911313,
0.5258165002,
-0.585292697,
-0.4437426329,
-0.5537359715,
0.5551382899,
0.5212392211,
0.6626159549,
0.1575107872,
-0.4762350917,
-0.4304100275,
0.0842491314,
-0.7759615183,
-0.2289071381,
-0.1937114,
0.1167564392,
-0.2540970147,
0.5165667534,
-0.5581127405,
0.3260760903,
0.2407738864,
-0.2247078121,
0.6263149977,
-0.6781624556,
0.3275214136,
-1.3832660913,
0.2202947885,
-0.0315047093,
-0.2404705286,
-0.5788283944,
0.1317022443,
-0.0438293256,
-0.4210232496,
-0.4072841108,
0.4214738905,
-0.2303897738,
0.2830290496,
-0.1233529821,
-0.1076719314,
0.2980453968,
0.430687815,
-0.4501291513,
0.3644421697,
-0.0766022131,
-0.807751596,
0.2276450545,
0.475677371,
0.0398496613,
0.4176404774,
-0.93519032,
0.0110211335,
-0.0012990324,
0.3921331763,
-0.6499459743,
-0.6491755843,
0.0118417973,
-0.111240685,
0.4100102484,
0.2345708013,
-0.2333626002,
-0.2313434184,
-0.636410892,
0.3260436356,
0.8474463224,
-0.1159867346,
0.5038721561,
0.3630586267,
-0.3453669846,
-0.29078269,
-0.6263826489,
-0.3704394698,
-0.4004203677,
-0.392719388,
0.823141396,
0.0528424159,
-0.3393062651,
-0.1735569686,
0.2495546341,
-0.1168244556,
-0.0814604759,
0.3542100787,
0.244728893,
-0.1297974437,
0.1306672394,
0.4811171293,
-0.2490396947,
0.2878564894,
-0.0690852404,
0.621124804,
0.2660081089,
-0.6304541826,
-0.8845903277,
1.0372319221,
0.456177175,
-0.2405656278,
0.5763404369,
0.4763035476,
-0.5397136211,
-0.0752934217,
-0.3939922154,
-0.3523815572,
-0.4656476378,
0.2299577594,
0.1757039279,
-0.6164619327,
0.6113271713,
-0.2669475973,
0.5337923765,
0.4186961055,
0.4192687273,
-0.562802732,
1.0214159489,
0.634693861,
0.2870471478,
0.3336063027,
-0.3770981133,
0.221997574,
-0.8265147805,
-0.4544130564,
-0.496830523,
-0.3697861731,
-0.482747525,
-0.2756409943,
0.8578543067,
0.0709163845,
-0.1679837108,
0.0624478497,
-0.5574250221,
0.1554203779,
0.491163969,
0.4867038131,
0.3222023249,
-0.280497849,
0.0770444199,
-0.2673161924,
-0.4232178032,
-0.5085506439,
0.9393297434,
-0.0196008086,
0.5383961201,
-0.3142562509,
1.3837039471,
0.4971495569,
0.0380303301,
-0.3140634,
0.6100518703,
-0.387703687,
-0.1692888886,
-0.2343387753,
0.0417473763,
-0.8792181015,
-0.139251098,
-0.24272874,
-0.8992964625,
-0.0813959166,
0.5649034977,
-0.6953260303,
-0.1059836149,
-0.5356360674,
0.9255934358,
-0.0896958485,
-0.4862348735,
-0.618807435,
-0.8844946623,
0.5641053915,
-0.2528728545,
0.4350303113,
0.0515065901,
0.1085642949,
0.7035093904,
-0.833592236,
0.6316396594,
0.0756938383,
0.1674736589,
0.443382889,
-0.2417476773,
0.2985649407,
-0.0857776552,
0.0058845426,
-0.3608632088,
0.0897493064,
-0.1044273227,
-0.6031111479,
0.4549579024,
-0.2643268406,
-0.335314393,
-0.0888678953,
-0.17201823,
-0.0554710291,
0.1940137148,
0.664018333,
0.9384036064,
-0.3829592168,
-0.0381265841,
0.9637970924,
-0.5662097931,
0.3323429525,
0.1936386228,
-0.3987972736,
-0.5591869354,
0.7004175186,
0.075871326,
0.2763624489,
0.7044308782,
0.2414708585,
-0.2226707637,
-0.2958741188,
-0.4318034947,
0.3306621909,
-0.6280604005,
-0.1712674052,
-0.8722962737,
-0.273539871,
-0.2678712308,
-0.549073875,
-0.1605826467,
-0.4313051105,
-0.2510370314,
-0.094979085,
0.3102248311,
0.7742196321,
0.0216596276,
0.6408400536,
-1.388101697,
0.2209920138,
0.0830799788,
-0.3946480453,
-0.1402102262,
-0.4045029879,
-0.4922207296,
-0.1842791736,
-0.8138002157,
-1.0368884802,
0.3904570937,
-0.1060090214,
0.2322238237,
0.4447959065,
0.0857700631,
0.6881412864,
-0.6404700279,
1.0279016495,
0.6634081006,
-0.8626837134,
1.1668666601,
-0.7162131071,
0.326523751,
0.6197592616,
0.2522675991,
-0.3810127676,
-0.6301964521,
-0.9980115891,
-1.1695853472,
0.5044933558,
-0.0580726154,
0.0402056798,
0.0572508015,
0.3238147199,
0.1013558209,
0.1525622606,
-0.3054077327,
-0.2440013587,
0.2518385351,
-0.623149991,
0.2149995416,
-0.3279199302,
-0.246256575,
-0.076332517,
0.5350732803,
0.0352009125,
0.1113194376,
0.2743286192,
0.2102444917,
-0.0059274524,
0.5442387462,
0.624194622,
0.6735432148,
-0.1505227983,
0.0881116018,
0.2001424581,
-0.4391570985,
0.2154061645,
-0.239171654,
-0.3406042457,
0.3741105199,
0.3799113631,
0.3788285851,
0.4110055566,
-0.6942638755,
0.3578018248,
0.1497143954,
-0.3617136478,
-0.2813787758,
0.4638100863,
0.2157512754,
0.1108858585,
0.3439754844,
-0.1861139387,
0.6350567341,
-0.5122009516,
0.4512400627,
-0.0357828811,
-0.333217442,
-0.4097556472,
0.9293176532,
0.3612356186,
-0.3542749584,
0.3538488746,
0.1027161479,
-0.18196024,
0.7745791078,
0.7146315575,
1.0235972404,
-0.2610680461,
0.2884058356,
0.8758701086,
-0.1549032032,
-0.0150296362,
0.336173892,
-0.048529014,
0.0493220203,
-0.3590556681,
-0.51625669,
-0.5849448442,
0.3807192445,
-0.8637949824,
0.6959972382,
-0.6695454121,
-0.0856198072,
0.0072353305,
-0.1873025298,
-0.3354319632,
0.5215032697,
-0.0836734101,
0.6452355981,
-0.8230041265,
0.3941892982,
0.6625059843,
-0.724632442,
-0.972230196,
-0.0879481211,
-0.0379621983,
-0.1603942364,
0.329669416,
0.2986659408,
0.0350452289,
-0.0606858507,
-0.3349925578,
-0.1796847284,
1.2871290445,
-0.0040404843,
-0.6890568137,
-0.0310312547,
-0.2093388289,
0.6987276673,
-0.2492282093,
0.2829117477,
0.293256253,
0.1691259593,
-0.1985396594,
-0.7494776249,
0.0864282399,
-0.3364611864,
-0.2963172793,
0.3097678125,
-0.7030783892,
0.8855500221,
-0.5027003884,
-0.1104742363,
-0.0442779697,
0.5682209134,
0.4477943182,
0.7666994929,
0.0497440249,
0.3112433553,
0.9036545157,
0.3096908331,
0.9860818386,
-0.121793136,
0.0611710958,
1.3887735605,
-0.3592460752,
0.7147895694,
0.5241765976,
-0.3584812582,
0.5222710371,
0.4698782563,
0.3236082792,
0.6316879392,
-0.0571436733,
-0.764226079,
-0.0014258192,
-0.1983192861,
-0.5029903054,
0.0314639919,
0.3067480028,
-0.5545945168,
-0.1279079318,
0.0534093268,
0.0161013249,
0.0197381508,
-0.299587369,
1.0526139736,
0.3524432778,
-0.8148118258,
0.0054622567,
0.0806811601,
0.2120872885,
-0.7944588065,
-0.1887119412,
-0.2665223777,
0.2212292403,
-0.4855207205,
-0.4225637019,
0.4569075406,
0.2003384233,
-0.4056729078,
-0.30346632,
0.5891550779,
-0.3364181817,
-0.2681691349,
-0.085644111,
0.4472404718,
0.238985166,
0.226540342,
-0.4435190856,
-0.1402123272,
0.0016720842,
0.0491991676,
0.5109140873,
0.5233713388,
-0.083398968,
0.4589405954,
0.5387457013,
0.0472428761,
0.0134675046,
0.3805093765,
0.7100531459,
-0.6748639941,
-0.6429119706,
-1.1656177044,
0.9337617159,
-0.1415600926,
-0.4536470473,
0.1417823732,
0.7686746716,
0.3398579359,
-0.3558771014,
0.8468734622,
-0.0617096424,
0.7804823518,
-0.7290603518,
0.7830826044,
-0.6347998381,
0.1553839594,
-0.255194664,
-0.4727205634,
0.0138970977,
0.4105396569,
0.3541958034,
-0.2861570418,
1.0566452742,
0.2120155841,
0.0171325039,
-0.1728177667,
0.315572381,
-0.175943777,
0.4552627206,
0.5670847297,
0.6226331592,
-0.5848901272,
0.0412722342,
-0.5493067503,
-0.1601699293,
-0.3743321896,
-0.7446441054,
-0.7251212001,
-0.6224563122,
-0.5145101547,
-0.2643794715,
0.0374772102,
1.0569450855,
0.3876311481,
-0.8181637526,
-0.1070982516,
-0.0910922289,
-0.0541342758,
-0.1150167584,
-0.1778984964,
0.1524789035,
-0.4445079565,
-0.5502867699,
0.1615869701,
0.4984232485,
-0.0409253202,
-0.0374937132,
0.209837839,
0.0407461673,
-0.3910622299,
0.425649792,
0.0930115283,
-0.3787062466,
0.035984084,
-0.0951039791,
-0.3541994393,
-0.0385346673,
1.0278828144,
-0.5667601228,
0.2527194917,
0.6193167567,
0.3610737622,
0.6555695534,
0.3153991401,
0.8532143235,
-0.6654934287,
0.0392672606,
0.2349820137,
0.2211719453,
0.1396564245,
-0.6301318407,
0.4428781569,
-0.062042091,
-0.7143917084,
-0.6078752279,
-0.037382599,
-1.1241611242,
0.1245827451,
0.5145861506,
-0.0907009766,
-0.2605477273,
-0.1916450262,
-0.3346247375,
0.4724022746,
-0.2460978925,
0.7607747912,
0.3603540957,
-0.5181680918,
-0.0294024069,
-0.7369357944,
0.4876369536,
0.2621166706,
-1.3453774452,
-0.1055633947,
0.6356096864,
0.2180489004,
0.2391700447,
1.2431526184,
-0.0896012783,
0.6237847805,
-0.0324885212,
0.1127762571,
0.108744055,
-0.1973715127,
-0.3221420944,
0.0441679284,
-0.2706716657,
-0.3712837398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18088v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18088v2 | LLM-Driven Multimodal Opinion Expression Identification | 2024-06-26T05:52:47 | 2024-06-29T09:55:50 | Bonian Jia, Huiyao Chen, Yueheng Sun, Meishan Zhang, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Opinion Expression Identification (OEI) is essential in NLP for applications
ranging from voice assistants to depression diagnosis. This study extends OEI
to encompass multimodal inputs, underlining the significance of auditory cues
in delivering emotional subtleties beyond the capabilities of text. We
introduce a novel multimodal OEI (MOEI) task, integrating text and speech to
mirror real-world scenarios. Utilizing CMU MOSEI and IEMOCAP datasets, we
construct the CI-MOEI dataset. Additionally, Text-to-Speech (TTS) technology is
applied to the MPQA dataset to obtain the CIM-OEI dataset. We design a template
for the OEI task to take full advantage of the generative power of large
language models (LLMs). Advancing further, we propose an LLM-driven method
STOEI, which combines speech and text modal to identify opinion expressions.
Our experiments demonstrate that MOEI significantly improves the performance
while our method outperforms existing methods by 9.20\% and obtains SOTA
results. | [
-0.4323298335,
-0.7659860253,
0.7130425572,
0.3115023375,
-0.1192391738,
-0.0337963998,
-0.2182729691,
-0.6105509996,
0.4475036561,
0.1486577094,
-0.8389745355,
-0.4097313881,
-0.5398613811,
0.0123576624,
-0.0915347636,
0.765119493,
0.0046219639,
0.2500556409,
-0.132299915,
-0.2864377499,
-0.1680221111,
-0.4407911897,
-0.6891775131,
-0.1143232957,
0.8412594795,
0.3560530543,
0.3041434884,
0.135759905,
0.2189351469,
0.2610012293,
0.1257303208,
0.3757934868,
-0.2885346711,
0.101437889,
0.0890962705,
-0.4025831819,
-0.6478667259,
0.1111406982,
0.3578769267,
0.2173436433,
-0.1390797645,
0.179997921,
-0.0440448336,
0.349786967,
-0.7326871157,
0.259334147,
-0.3419637978,
0.269664377,
-0.2611721456,
-0.1753493994,
-0.4111087024,
-0.191082567,
0.0088581145,
-0.3960637748,
-0.2594899237,
-0.0293065961,
0.7096917033,
0.1600260884,
-0.6993555427,
-0.6694743037,
-0.6240336299,
1.0174993277,
-0.9434326291,
0.3738511503,
-0.0509382039,
-0.0024486817,
0.1283875704,
-0.3092367351,
-0.9365360141,
0.0577917695,
-0.0100810379,
0.5465148091,
-0.1742565632,
0.0411351696,
0.1317856014,
0.417714119,
-0.310692668,
0.2012151778,
-0.0874284804,
-0.0597658083,
0.4969297945,
0.0888788402,
0.3742772043,
-0.5177500248,
-0.5489376783,
-0.0865708366,
-0.2731548846,
0.1279477477,
0.4187544584,
0.1581185758,
-0.1973333955,
0.7560204268,
-0.1210896224,
0.2908378839,
0.1006922051,
-0.5950036645,
0.5583695173,
-0.217363596,
-0.3029385209,
0.1793506294,
1.1414872408,
0.5326213837,
-0.109500505,
0.1699237674,
-0.3863674104,
0.2293011993,
0.0419160873,
-0.6616936326,
0.3747528791,
0.3843332231,
-0.622405231,
-0.328484714,
0.1441933364,
-1.2038913965,
-0.7130782604,
-0.443382442,
0.4402102232,
-0.5142187476,
-0.5197048783,
-0.1786879897,
-0.0903900787,
0.0866779462,
0.0953135118,
-0.6061947942,
-0.1296964586,
0.5603691936,
0.6582961082,
-0.1209526882,
0.0936515033,
-0.4599844813,
0.1394853443,
-0.1323346794,
0.6064209938,
-0.8748173714,
-0.3131096363,
0.2017663717,
-0.110984534,
-0.2805732489,
-0.5322417021,
0.6559131145,
-0.4004450738,
0.5242367387,
-0.015007237,
-0.3797281086,
-0.1960088909,
0.0666996241,
-0.676127851,
1.0114219189,
-0.1466149837,
-0.6583132744,
0.177380532,
-1.0269867182,
-0.3321422338,
-0.3676136732,
-0.190076977,
-0.3761799932,
0.4861076474,
0.3718435168,
0.6342805028,
-0.3077929914,
0.317677319,
-0.4952868223,
0.2321686447,
0.3932898343,
-0.759642899,
0.4364232719,
0.4262849987,
-0.2877328694,
0.1599051058,
-1.0784950256,
0.1116561815,
-0.0286232252,
-0.2452620864,
-0.360574156,
0.0131392647,
0.2613219619,
0.4243082702,
0.3939877152,
-0.8996071219,
0.2081277221,
-0.2021167576,
0.6915766597,
0.6986880302,
0.0388343409,
0.2012157589,
-0.0893284827,
0.4130762219,
0.2592582405,
0.2448263019,
-0.2152841985,
-0.6117199659,
-0.6417338252,
-0.8026404381,
0.1884551942,
0.7648464441,
-0.9223778844,
0.1314657331,
-0.3476063013,
-0.3714426458,
-1.1200619936,
0.0037998918,
0.3746713996,
0.3853672743,
0.3483767211,
-0.0328228995,
-0.5277594924,
-1.1456660032,
-0.0604955181,
-0.2273926586,
-0.2777278125,
0.6873546839,
0.1516884863,
-0.3669297397,
0.9805403352,
-0.246707648,
-0.5056900382,
-0.1886217147,
0.745747745,
0.2147147208,
0.1537510157,
0.3804128766,
-1.0296062231,
-0.0562055185,
-0.0959752277,
-0.8395779729,
-0.4288348854,
-0.4627521634,
0.0932384357,
0.0316871554,
0.3843371272,
-0.585717082,
0.1873815805,
0.7876721025,
-0.160951063,
0.019762028,
0.0018687521,
0.6145097613,
-1.1905446053,
-0.1279228032,
0.3982882202,
-0.0469068512,
-0.6202014685,
-0.1186360642,
-0.0684817806,
-0.0313497297,
-0.7359409332,
0.3047108054,
-0.233051762,
0.1998791695,
-0.0986788198,
0.3809953034,
-0.0116032017,
0.6405133009,
0.119659625,
0.631071806,
0.4994989336,
-0.3322255313,
0.2599603534,
-0.036217127,
-0.4210140705,
0.8068184257,
-0.4807892442,
0.2799694836,
-0.3910045326,
-0.0970420092,
-1.0582177639,
-0.2733872235,
0.326882869,
-0.1816746891,
0.2482455522,
0.1444672346,
-0.4063124955,
0.1266945899,
-0.2706493735,
0.6138352156,
0.1491106451,
-0.5418902636,
1.4350605011,
0.485822767,
-0.4646216333,
-0.4952124357,
-0.5882325172,
0.0419414453,
-0.348289758,
-0.4589304328,
0.5014150143,
0.0355140008,
-0.300521642,
-0.2490299195,
0.1543539166,
-0.07451047,
-0.2346339524,
0.63010782,
0.4211546481,
-0.2909690738,
0.244630143,
0.1993772686,
0.0014617796,
0.0471030101,
0.2583880126,
0.3150754273,
-0.1248261109,
-0.4720666707,
-0.7749462724,
0.9371542335,
0.896479845,
-0.1789513826,
0.4261273444,
0.9368671775,
-0.1950779855,
0.1529234499,
-0.6803076863,
0.0798984915,
-0.3901879489,
0.4606812,
-0.4789983928,
-0.5860822797,
0.0764871165,
-0.3010710776,
0.044934269,
0.2187700868,
0.5784984827,
-0.3211614192,
1.4043141603,
0.5445487499,
-0.4097702801,
0.751762569,
0.0002453586,
0.4020639956,
-0.9724419117,
-0.1086287126,
-0.2814013958,
-0.5277289748,
-0.3826241493,
-0.3468257189,
0.528439045,
0.0953785107,
0.280399859,
-0.1326514184,
-0.2617058158,
-0.0124655077,
0.5445711017,
0.3271400928,
0.1164423898,
-0.1853939593,
0.1357143074,
-0.1598686576,
-0.4202293456,
-0.6870955229,
0.7415741086,
0.416443944,
0.4738662839,
0.411840409,
0.5008517504,
0.3211959302,
0.7231485248,
-0.9098229408,
0.6672940254,
-0.00173299,
-0.3779179454,
-0.0521701798,
-0.5126237273,
-0.5538885593,
0.3846562207,
-0.5817675591,
-0.79843086,
0.3375727832,
0.0096233543,
-0.3129507303,
0.1524162441,
-1.0069793463,
0.6386280656,
-0.3571248055,
-0.0823142603,
-0.3189344704,
-0.3973489404,
0.1994763613,
0.1166599914,
0.5528260469,
-0.1969123185,
-0.1446096003,
0.7680127621,
0.1475026309,
1.0014061928,
-0.2962469459,
-0.3060565591,
0.0660852715,
-0.4210284054,
0.3263831139,
0.1440324336,
-0.3484708667,
0.3719493747,
-0.0979921445,
-0.0353931077,
-0.7464441061,
0.8438394666,
-0.7122069001,
-0.5771278143,
-0.1662489474,
-0.2986751199,
-0.4623036385,
0.1467538327,
0.2188372761,
0.6211696267,
-0.1621349454,
0.1358043998,
0.7163109779,
-0.2414145321,
0.7652958035,
0.3602364063,
-0.1145401597,
-0.6326442361,
1.0440500975,
-0.1036389917,
0.1247269362,
0.6296228766,
0.2491029352,
-0.3247748315,
-0.1756088883,
-0.4902022779,
0.3300763965,
-0.6346700788,
-0.0305323154,
-0.6277053356,
0.2308512628,
-0.3505190015,
0.1515085697,
-0.3129682839,
-0.1525467932,
-0.3873786926,
-0.1623055488,
0.0117553119,
0.5614470243,
0.1699744463,
0.1134305075,
-0.7924621701,
0.6375838518,
0.493604511,
0.0045105759,
-0.1947586387,
-0.1437205374,
0.2127717435,
0.2339496166,
-0.254006356,
-1.131310463,
0.5086987019,
0.5084834099,
0.4199076593,
0.7197409868,
0.3065061867,
0.7207320333,
-0.3462383151,
0.9939523339,
0.529301703,
-1.0242192745,
0.5230166912,
0.0271639228,
0.191000551,
0.2713924944,
0.5619293451,
-0.3838132322,
-0.5114343762,
-0.3642241061,
-0.9362143874,
0.4924566448,
-0.0029394927,
0.1217898354,
-0.1891186237,
0.1813275814,
0.0392155871,
0.4371001124,
-0.9597653747,
-0.2989502549,
-0.2425892502,
-0.8839835525,
0.081462644,
-0.5355472565,
-0.2419056147,
0.1758453995,
0.6578167081,
-0.3506593704,
0.6223979592,
0.3959874213,
-0.0859801844,
0.0511179231,
0.6814088225,
0.7004466057,
0.158849448,
-0.0624025501,
0.1619481593,
0.0509441011,
-0.0558733605,
-0.0847330093,
-0.2328239828,
0.0667029396,
0.1548864394,
0.3908091784,
1.0381560326,
0.0075691026,
-0.8558374047,
0.7225656509,
-0.0697780102,
-0.0363200381,
-0.3260512054,
-0.1305771023,
-0.106342338,
0.5009114742,
0.300021559,
0.2594868541,
0.3380168676,
-0.8331686258,
-0.2619637251,
0.4960555434,
-0.8589683175,
-0.4537877142,
0.5332155228,
0.2210718393,
-0.2560299337,
0.36082232,
0.1131628305,
-0.1753074676,
0.2302172631,
0.2429137379,
0.8151581883,
-0.244794637,
0.1484725624,
-0.0195622873,
-0.0040829997,
0.3628122807,
0.5650484562,
-0.0344239958,
-0.7416597605,
-0.3375890255,
-0.399689436,
-0.1514412165,
0.302623719,
-1.0278069973,
0.2166861445,
-0.2327645719,
-0.4790981114,
0.2371770442,
-0.7981271744,
-0.4943965077,
0.4295900166,
0.5978403091,
0.4392871261,
-0.9675127268,
0.822973609,
0.7049984336,
-0.2401821315,
-0.5570831895,
0.0649459139,
0.2864743769,
-0.6294983029,
0.6435031295,
0.242084682,
-0.5121549964,
-0.1638171971,
-0.4006427824,
-0.4470876157,
0.9533560276,
0.2832268476,
-0.6024183035,
0.0872594938,
0.1235788465,
0.5002515316,
-0.7319399118,
0.6792243123,
0.1607622951,
0.6749224067,
-0.1200297177,
-0.8104171753,
-0.180078119,
-0.4273044169,
0.0020076206,
0.1188113093,
-0.6005972624,
0.6387821436,
-0.0420527048,
-0.4340211153,
-0.1104924679,
0.872500062,
-0.0373131372,
0.4480378926,
0.9847542048,
0.3952943683,
0.7596857548,
-0.164375037,
0.9050605297,
-0.2726838589,
0.1118703783,
0.9194457531,
-0.377220273,
1.2867416143,
0.8067134619,
0.3309429288,
0.4657937884,
0.2892814279,
0.2313446105,
0.6670601368,
-0.1971745044,
-0.5840787888,
-0.2990621924,
-0.4679965377,
-0.0873433873,
0.4232633114,
0.4663286209,
-0.4562618136,
0.2433929741,
0.6763458252,
0.0686762929,
-0.0617419966,
-0.2327475548,
1.0354536772,
-0.0580732003,
-0.4416843057,
0.1349643767,
-0.0569871999,
0.8940647244,
-0.491555959,
-0.2122553885,
0.1152440012,
0.0841779411,
-0.2618187964,
-0.4851598442,
0.0469819717,
-0.0573910922,
-0.5622430444,
-0.5025876164,
0.2399794757,
-0.5546287894,
-0.5581845641,
0.306858629,
0.389762044,
-0.1844006479,
0.0516086072,
-0.5882361531,
0.1206625998,
0.1724706441,
-0.487487793,
0.3025146127,
0.7215189934,
0.0225144289,
0.6243661046,
0.3833819926,
-0.0212278813,
-0.0614257008,
0.2475428879,
0.7188879848,
-0.5871793628,
-0.2132884115,
-0.6774801612,
0.5794103146,
-0.1852988154,
-0.5246242285,
0.5867786407,
0.3381579816,
0.4931792915,
-0.2937726974,
0.9087483883,
-0.2951802015,
0.6849922538,
-0.8518512845,
0.2848452032,
-0.7534269691,
0.1878499091,
-0.4500617683,
-0.5171716213,
0.0260034148,
0.495241791,
-0.2447114885,
-0.1091840193,
0.7412246466,
0.9367440939,
0.0589971691,
0.2815209627,
0.2730281353,
0.3525687158,
0.311072588,
0.6248246431,
1.0643948317,
-0.3602289259,
0.4760649204,
-0.1715735793,
-0.5079173446,
-0.0753584132,
-0.9974083304,
-0.6354700327,
-0.5807130337,
-0.6957064271,
-0.0189887583,
-0.3011908829,
1.1318645477,
0.8537790179,
-0.9132389426,
0.0816163942,
0.3576316535,
-0.0385937355,
-0.5629332066,
-0.3210256696,
0.1409543008,
0.0141919954,
-1.1631890535,
0.862760365,
0.4348457754,
-0.2455447018,
-0.1755021513,
0.1675339788,
-0.1204644218,
0.438726753,
0.6941696405,
-0.0854961872,
-1.066953063,
-0.4479235113,
-0.0519540794,
-0.0403299406,
0.1882431954,
0.9578298926,
-0.5489945412,
0.4993373156,
0.2511599362,
0.3648353219,
0.0243514683,
-0.1170580015,
0.5185418725,
-0.8960143924,
0.069517009,
0.2363550216,
0.5937660933,
0.0615527667,
-0.3394421041,
0.1612831801,
0.0837100148,
-0.1287708431,
-0.6791282296,
0.3057749867,
-1.3968930244,
-0.1795514524,
1.1445621252,
-0.1961120218,
-0.3060295582,
-0.083800368,
-0.6929708719,
-0.0858990699,
-0.7064691186,
0.8116109967,
0.6693798304,
-0.255143255,
-0.5080583692,
-0.4018447101,
0.0720000193,
0.4011033475,
-0.7838250995,
-0.2216516882,
0.5813767314,
-0.3606166244,
0.6660220027,
0.3268232644,
-0.1201975942,
-0.2685061395,
-0.19319354,
0.3261334598,
-0.0771615878,
-0.1779145598,
-0.1141937003,
0.8422089815,
-0.3418290615,
-0.3731742501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18087v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18087v1 | EHR-Based Mobile and Web Platform for Chronic Disease Risk Prediction Using Large Language Multimodal Models | 2024-06-26T05:51:08 | 2024-06-26T05:51:08 | Chun-Chieh Liao, Wei-Ting Kuo, I-Hsuan Hu, Yen-Chen Shih, Jun-En Ding, Feng Liu, Fang-Ming Hung | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | Traditional diagnosis of chronic diseases involves in-person consultations
with physicians to identify the disease. However, there is a lack of research
focused on predicting and developing application systems using clinical notes
and blood test values. We collected five years of Electronic Health Records
(EHRs) from Taiwan's hospital database between 2017 and 2021 as an AI database.
Furthermore, we developed an EHR-based chronic disease prediction platform
utilizing Large Language Multimodal Models (LLMMs), successfully integrating
with frontend web and mobile applications for prediction. This prediction
platform can also connect to the hospital's backend database, providing
physicians with real-time risk assessment diagnostics. The demonstration link
can be found at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oqmL9DEDFgA. | [
0.0112817027,
-0.9536664486,
0.768214941,
-0.1058837026,
-0.3782150149,
0.1629914045,
0.0667195395,
-0.9225978851,
0.626051724,
0.6284631491,
-0.3547357619,
-0.5358796716,
-0.4363511205,
0.0763790235,
-0.0396024622,
0.8830275536,
-0.0981161073,
0.2949512005,
-0.199048996,
0.0208711643,
-0.4704120457,
-0.5639181733,
-0.7450028062,
-0.4729899466,
0.7342338562,
0.4932065308,
0.5788263083,
0.3861625791,
0.6608460546,
0.1999176443,
0.3243142366,
-0.1043443233,
0.007547223,
0.3922483921,
0.2931854427,
-0.1823185235,
-0.4804979265,
-0.4786412716,
0.2228733003,
0.5066968799,
-0.2542416453,
0.241080448,
-0.2644924223,
0.5783910751,
-0.3523441851,
0.0759456009,
-0.2747543156,
0.3629900813,
-0.4948660731,
-0.4852440059,
-0.3031670153,
-0.3029584885,
0.2547506392,
-0.5088050961,
-0.1276559681,
0.0401467457,
0.6623699069,
0.1317523271,
-0.8554017544,
-0.1592762321,
-0.8940302134,
0.3109100163,
-0.2819580734,
0.5821965337,
0.3609585166,
0.6965079904,
-0.2009139657,
-0.6995135546,
-0.2046613544,
-0.4160714447,
0.0849672928,
0.2748186588,
0.0508835465,
0.0558451638,
-0.0034183289,
0.2725951076,
-0.8430041671,
0.1368239075,
-0.5396569371,
-0.2587173581,
0.7124640346,
0.4303627014,
0.4471782744,
-0.2271135151,
-0.6297638416,
0.2162393928,
-0.7598071694,
0.0516494103,
-0.4600409269,
0.0883247331,
-0.2851419151,
0.6141599417,
-0.0059766239,
0.3460205793,
0.1381408721,
-0.6120334268,
0.556677103,
-0.3204396367,
-0.2193042934,
0.4313045144,
0.582142055,
0.6111534238,
-0.2458256781,
-0.1679398566,
-0.1255502105,
0.0100801298,
0.1246868819,
-0.622688055,
-0.4262057543,
0.6467508078,
-0.6975066066,
-0.0109975105,
-0.1565454751,
-1.0193735361,
-0.5212879181,
-0.0795519799,
0.1791751832,
-0.4594412148,
-0.2689090967,
0.2109034956,
-0.0027259057,
-0.2182890475,
0.4467902482,
-0.4581496119,
0.3873150051,
0.3411841094,
0.7543562055,
-0.2339971215,
0.0981205031,
-0.5053251386,
0.3733243942,
0.015699815,
0.856118381,
-0.1630382985,
-0.7210651636,
-0.0876579583,
0.0179683771,
-0.1138921082,
-0.4890669882,
0.651088953,
-0.2832365036,
-0.3157328665,
0.1781794578,
-0.2976521552,
0.0129905967,
0.2483002841,
-0.954520762,
1.0735317469,
0.0881950855,
-0.7148365974,
0.4018573761,
-0.2943514287,
-0.5793478489,
0.3796922565,
0.0482014455,
-0.9444565177,
-0.0649676397,
-0.1072285622,
0.4851022065,
-0.3489135802,
0.6666961312,
-0.5189951062,
-0.0902408957,
0.3056362271,
-0.1900553852,
0.5525407195,
0.4350611269,
-0.0948442817,
0.4511444271,
-0.7786335945,
0.1063569933,
-0.006182584,
-0.3123178184,
-0.6619997621,
0.1908742189,
0.4515652061,
0.4944220483,
0.2624397278,
-0.4556573927,
0.1041674837,
-0.1387779266,
0.4589306414,
0.4549292624,
0.1354404092,
-0.1625205129,
-0.7240464687,
0.6928274632,
0.1141651794,
0.3995475769,
-0.0907172561,
-0.8194907904,
-0.065481469,
-0.1251878589,
0.2267248183,
0.9665921926,
-0.3716230094,
0.7065212131,
-0.6191789508,
-0.8376687169,
0.0195938945,
-0.19867374,
0.1286934912,
0.3478917181,
0.2466105223,
-0.5780429244,
-0.5846983194,
-0.4098945558,
0.3166920543,
-0.1930421144,
0.0317817815,
0.3889605403,
0.5900479555,
-0.6133467555,
0.3388720453,
-0.5277782679,
-0.4145185947,
-0.3290683031,
-0.1477276981,
0.0857587978,
0.5579832196,
0.3793522418,
-0.9114897251,
-0.7873080969,
0.3097995818,
-0.7512185574,
0.1943361908,
0.1821150333,
-0.0020248303,
-0.0970018879,
0.5132572055,
-0.6194472313,
0.4619821012,
0.9827908874,
-0.3989134133,
0.6038178205,
-0.320458591,
0.0367271081,
-1.0977047682,
0.346981287,
0.1842152178,
-0.4147129357,
-0.6865317822,
-0.0376353525,
-0.1292687356,
-0.5315324664,
-0.0771963522,
0.6312326193,
-0.2051875442,
0.193558529,
0.0589250848,
-0.1329696476,
-0.1019220352,
-0.1976554692,
-0.0069133244,
0.2887461185,
0.3477108777,
-0.5835229754,
0.2681137621,
0.159423545,
-0.4402853847,
0.4544842839,
-0.6509149671,
-0.2150428444,
0.104721196,
0.4621839225,
-0.7495416403,
-0.3351647854,
0.3126981854,
-0.440017581,
0.3070182502,
0.0937449336,
-0.3463825285,
-0.8821238875,
-0.3424161971,
0.3897051215,
0.0505692028,
0.1191381961,
0.8534477353,
0.8227545023,
-0.5913364291,
-0.2083532065,
-0.895339787,
0.0703545883,
-0.2911781967,
-0.4900792241,
0.6686490774,
-0.195521161,
-0.2563135624,
0.1715282351,
0.1586109251,
-0.58684659,
0.259660393,
0.6752871871,
0.544505477,
-0.2510278225,
0.438398689,
-0.0976716653,
-0.1926355213,
-0.0664121509,
-0.107564576,
0.4915287197,
0.2127761841,
-0.5852578878,
-0.6744399071,
0.6201912165,
0.772349298,
-0.2487499267,
0.6286228299,
0.2909635007,
-0.6479834914,
0.5474614501,
-0.643922925,
0.0295209531,
-0.3958143294,
0.2024811059,
-0.1921287626,
-0.7447734475,
0.557533741,
-0.1289412677,
-0.2040859461,
0.3942869306,
0.6828003526,
0.1053244248,
0.9554313421,
0.6033309698,
-0.2203161865,
0.2161379755,
0.2195496708,
0.0073015275,
-0.5450353026,
-0.586849153,
-0.5333710313,
0.1489947289,
-0.8749189973,
-0.3164812028,
1.016392231,
-0.2458494902,
-0.4864263833,
-0.062410105,
-0.4482974112,
-0.1464269012,
0.4243507683,
0.6902148128,
0.4876745343,
-0.2145038247,
-0.1698186547,
0.0080476878,
-0.4931800961,
-0.3971353173,
1.4786177874,
0.3986629844,
0.6006401181,
0.1337394118,
0.7168411016,
0.4328800738,
0.6473096609,
-0.7224177718,
-0.1147434637,
-0.2456799448,
-0.8142575026,
-0.3180792928,
-0.1897882521,
-1.216889739,
-0.1537371874,
-0.4171732962,
-0.6630935669,
0.0904983208,
0.3463108838,
-0.6876754761,
0.3112724125,
-0.6307951212,
0.8879789114,
-0.7222949266,
-0.3258954585,
-0.2381631583,
-0.7970708013,
0.3738899231,
-0.2526918054,
0.4915451705,
-0.0917879492,
0.2419505715,
0.3681811094,
-0.3486613929,
0.8706303239,
0.0207170714,
0.1849845797,
0.1469518691,
-0.1576869637,
0.3565735221,
0.2788990736,
-0.1377593279,
-0.046551995,
0.1993398815,
-0.2076015919,
0.0208090134,
0.7034036517,
-0.6465827227,
-0.2624431551,
-0.6267376542,
0.0027250065,
-0.190136373,
0.5332238078,
0.0376265533,
0.4603590667,
-0.4674319327,
-0.0815833434,
0.4774497449,
-0.366605103,
0.053290356,
0.2914147973,
-0.1282028556,
-0.4813180566,
0.7440827489,
-0.0685509369,
-0.0525774397,
0.6690904498,
0.5567810535,
-0.1274002939,
-0.4407025278,
-0.38637501,
-0.0008908909,
-0.4037071764,
-0.4381353557,
-0.5157174468,
-0.2551639676,
-0.4684503675,
-0.1486515403,
-0.0862227976,
0.1325867474,
-0.084583886,
-0.1333598197,
0.5094869137,
0.7266301513,
-0.0024649606,
0.0818172321,
-1.2918409109,
0.2346346676,
0.0769399554,
0.5029252768,
0.051104296,
-0.0376344696,
-0.4600515664,
-0.0408294871,
-0.5291898847,
-0.8988073468,
0.6966071725,
0.1060163677,
0.5416995287,
0.6575790048,
-0.0267411489,
0.5624850392,
-0.6879132986,
0.590159893,
0.6114320159,
-0.6951894164,
0.4845324755,
-0.434068799,
-0.0052008703,
0.5623165369,
0.5104888678,
-0.8548477888,
0.1162962317,
-0.4635030627,
-0.8265283108,
0.0143064689,
-0.4298844635,
-0.2033591866,
0.129639402,
0.1952025741,
0.1802684367,
-0.0179523844,
-0.7135913968,
-0.3532751203,
-0.4289164245,
-0.2784953713,
-0.3577044606,
-0.2263029814,
0.0029127689,
-0.3905028403,
0.3484370112,
0.0205518454,
0.5176041722,
0.4606048763,
0.0528445877,
-0.5991299748,
0.4009596705,
0.70430094,
0.5987462401,
-0.3716425002,
0.2058128417,
0.0208925363,
-0.564842701,
-0.0693167001,
0.4305763245,
-0.0228524953,
0.0552732013,
0.2452375591,
0.5307947993,
0.4710401595,
-1.1617381573,
0.4702386558,
0.2653064132,
-0.1511542946,
-1.011844635,
-0.4525878727,
0.2531690001,
-0.1133133546,
0.2935706973,
-0.0949189588,
0.2841102481,
-0.4321172237,
0.5226293802,
0.2094148099,
-0.7467725873,
-0.3745292127,
0.8933961987,
0.3208946288,
0.0937186927,
0.4524665177,
0.1428925842,
-0.3841328919,
0.7023229003,
0.5330139995,
0.5387486219,
-0.707339108,
0.0522748753,
0.4531489611,
0.0998731703,
-0.0684658512,
0.3887090981,
0.6662820578,
-0.5604751706,
-0.6189085245,
-0.2445860505,
-0.4267253876,
0.2134690136,
-0.5201152563,
0.5199711919,
-0.4196477234,
-0.4032162428,
0.1622077674,
-0.0257052369,
-0.2659659982,
0.3714324236,
0.4001173675,
0.6997775435,
-0.6525395513,
0.9548424482,
0.5753606558,
-0.3962055743,
-0.6212676167,
-0.1253430992,
0.3740983307,
-0.6502774954,
0.613695085,
0.3064480126,
0.1447815001,
-0.2106223106,
-0.001847845,
-0.9052280784,
1.173048377,
-0.046237234,
-0.6210308075,
-0.1295273751,
-0.0210984331,
0.5120769739,
-0.2261091918,
-0.0069299908,
-0.0071473946,
0.5302940607,
-0.099753879,
-1.4620341063,
0.0637972578,
-0.2704506218,
-0.282545954,
0.4731419683,
-0.4316367209,
0.9418370724,
-0.2359256297,
-0.1473340094,
0.1221194267,
0.2654603124,
0.1666373312,
0.8744763136,
0.1510312408,
0.6742990613,
0.7152063847,
0.2027238309,
1.2438975573,
-0.5665715933,
0.1647962481,
0.8636295199,
-0.6314763427,
1.0217068195,
0.1814664602,
-0.191061601,
0.5339805484,
0.7372179627,
-0.0336408354,
0.3918731511,
0.2115439922,
-0.4773373008,
-0.2132377476,
-0.2433330864,
-0.5160375834,
0.2381536067,
0.7957631946,
-0.3186546266,
-0.048989445,
0.3494029641,
-0.2711771727,
-0.028041387,
-0.3126733303,
0.4797407091,
0.0192269273,
-0.405857712,
0.3476966918,
0.0944882184,
0.6146870255,
-0.5007066131,
-0.1210541129,
0.3933553398,
0.1857551932,
-0.1354665905,
-0.6506681442,
0.4650773704,
-0.5692862272,
-0.0938138366,
0.0178795177,
0.9407710433,
-0.2472237647,
-0.5562586784,
0.3594860733,
0.6385735869,
-0.0574829802,
0.1283860803,
-0.6522148252,
-0.1010740325,
-0.4772542119,
0.0912758708,
0.3336503804,
0.3801791966,
-0.4078615308,
1.0132998228,
0.6469382644,
0.1929783672,
-0.1499755979,
-0.2183312774,
0.7989266515,
-0.7421122789,
-0.2794995606,
-0.5702429414,
0.2985433042,
0.1397563666,
-0.4826691151,
0.2604236901,
0.8229284883,
0.4085560739,
-0.1812450588,
0.9201866388,
-0.1727121025,
0.898121953,
-0.5040723681,
0.6218014359,
-0.6385579109,
-0.1331284046,
-0.1938823611,
0.0823938325,
-0.6387767792,
0.2762513459,
-0.1036916748,
-0.2695296407,
0.8050766587,
0.3989688754,
0.2447632104,
-0.2881920338,
0.2039979398,
0.1797392219,
0.1690459847,
0.7578698993,
0.439900279,
-0.1865276694,
0.2972345054,
-0.4119163454,
-0.1005051136,
-0.847450316,
-0.6412540674,
-0.5137981176,
-0.5089024901,
-0.1941960603,
-0.358897984,
0.3302702606,
1.0743736029,
0.5101784468,
-0.9252649546,
-0.1088874042,
0.0717770457,
-0.0102877617,
-0.4160915911,
-0.1834506541,
0.6114471555,
0.5822473764,
-0.2458175719,
0.0492795669,
0.2875942588,
0.2173703611,
-0.0788545012,
0.1402461231,
-0.1756040752,
-0.6128447056,
0.7486248612,
0.5763299465,
-0.8343911171,
-0.3285494745,
0.1373441517,
-0.4506645203,
0.1277910322,
0.7784593701,
-0.4342179596,
0.3460362852,
0.2252040952,
0.4856277406,
0.3315091431,
-0.0791110769,
0.52876544,
0.2179411948,
0.0880868956,
0.4247306287,
0.3351121247,
0.1701500267,
-0.808765769,
0.152210474,
0.4302443564,
-0.5372930169,
-0.4631583095,
0.057316795,
-1.3983565569,
-0.2171231508,
0.8183159828,
-0.1409321725,
-0.2157749534,
-0.8730578423,
-0.0362923704,
0.2601066828,
-0.4240269959,
0.8330715895,
0.1364931166,
-0.540145874,
0.0039860504,
-1.0054366589,
0.1384744048,
-0.0014898984,
-1.000444293,
-0.1456600875,
0.581078887,
0.4195387959,
0.0918684229,
1.0521399975,
-0.183410272,
0.5624867082,
-0.1965399981,
0.3143854141,
0.1074403301,
-0.0858057365,
0.1130774319,
-0.0511409007,
0.189683333,
0.1131754369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18085v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18085v1 | Multilingual Knowledge Graph Completion from Pretrained Language Models with Knowledge Constraints | 2024-06-26T05:46:35 | 2024-06-26T05:46:35 | Ran Song, Shizhu He, Shengxiang Gao, Li Cai, Kang Liu, Zhengtao Yu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual Knowledge Graph Completion (mKGC) aim at solving queries like
(h, r, ?) in different languages by reasoning a tail entity t thus improving
multilingual knowledge graphs. Previous studies leverage multilingual
pretrained language models (PLMs) and the generative paradigm to achieve mKGC.
Although multilingual pretrained language models contain extensive knowledge of
different languages, its pretraining tasks cannot be directly aligned with the
mKGC tasks. Moreover, the majority of KGs and PLMs currently available exhibit
a pronounced English-centric bias. This makes it difficult for mKGC to achieve
good results, particularly in the context of low-resource languages. To
overcome previous problems, this paper introduces global and local knowledge
constraints for mKGC. The former is used to constrain the reasoning of answer
entities, while the latter is used to enhance the representation of query
contexts. The proposed method makes the pretrained model better adapt to the
mKGC task. Experimental results on public datasets demonstrate that our method
outperforms the previous SOTA on Hits@1 and Hits@10 by an average of 12.32% and
16.03%, which indicates that our proposed method has significant enhancement on
mKGC. | [
-0.5659839511,
-0.5312404633,
0.6882054806,
0.0110243326,
-0.1914304048,
0.363627404,
-0.3740287721,
-0.3498924971,
0.3441987038,
0.6670250893,
-0.7570322752,
-0.705760777,
-0.4919668436,
0.3551103473,
0.4355354905,
0.7335141897,
-0.3355024159,
0.1722475141,
-0.6199170947,
-0.397854358,
-0.4750207961,
-0.7913723588,
-0.492233783,
-0.3122961819,
0.5033381581,
0.5730897784,
0.5046703219,
0.2396272868,
0.1833170503,
0.2053531259,
-0.0801572204,
0.6708946824,
-0.4796644151,
0.036011301,
-0.0262091793,
-0.46994102,
-0.2257194519,
-0.0701809227,
0.5073409081,
1.0502233505,
-0.2333703935,
-0.1343418658,
0.1260618716,
0.6577885747,
-0.7110764384,
0.427649498,
-0.5457106233,
0.1257996857,
-0.1633114517,
-0.0451243147,
-0.4797867835,
-0.4519501626,
-0.028408302,
-1.0132399797,
-0.089513585,
0.0152116278,
0.6336137056,
0.1744546592,
-0.8742617965,
-0.1865219772,
-0.5006773472,
0.6171998978,
-0.5006769896,
0.7737948895,
0.7619293928,
0.3171602786,
-0.039598152,
-0.6296548843,
-0.389077723,
-0.2725679874,
-0.5542165041,
0.1151047349,
0.1442970186,
0.1726123691,
0.3768618107,
0.1056807861,
-0.5203701854,
-0.0853062049,
-0.2249699831,
-0.4788114429,
0.3060796857,
0.0293509196,
0.0544647612,
-0.3515883684,
-0.2007458508,
0.1864274293,
-1.0825022459,
0.0910115466,
0.3710698783,
0.3946653903,
0.1384267211,
0.4059586525,
-0.6207837462,
0.9772320986,
-0.2212845385,
-0.2438738197,
0.2605625689,
-0.6277462244,
0.1782524437,
-0.0935264677,
0.7048574686,
0.045683708,
0.4395593107,
-0.298458606,
0.2204222232,
-0.3935872912,
-0.0505362526,
-0.6947227716,
-0.0534654707,
-0.2047469318,
-0.1329321563,
0.2744295001,
-0.148356989,
-0.4459332228,
-0.2019184083,
-0.4838353097,
0.2107864916,
-0.4504810572,
-0.3587395847,
-0.0429912843,
0.3402248621,
-0.066077739,
0.0871092156,
-0.6382469535,
-0.0541940257,
0.2655602992,
0.6219936013,
0.1350139678,
-0.3823382258,
-0.3383375108,
0.5626199841,
-0.0756261051,
0.6048887968,
-0.6425322294,
-0.390801698,
-0.0831548721,
0.0511252917,
-0.2759799659,
-0.4995104671,
0.4207091331,
-0.713919282,
0.2342221588,
-0.9464707971,
-0.6209391356,
-0.2041581422,
0.4574612677,
-0.4527359307,
0.9266015291,
0.1818498224,
-0.9189004898,
0.4486453533,
-0.3873161972,
-0.7972336411,
0.0019742784,
-0.1681274027,
-0.0528999493,
-0.3697988391,
0.6352854371,
0.3765109181,
-0.2949115634,
0.2830116749,
-0.3407633603,
0.0155925509,
-0.216860503,
0.0680827498,
0.8508784175,
0.3587781489,
-0.0192966592,
0.1248884201,
-0.6342388391,
0.3909490407,
0.0309730023,
-0.3829220831,
-0.3476227522,
-0.046861954,
-0.6302309036,
0.298645407,
0.2929791212,
-0.2803305089,
0.4322277009,
-0.2436636537,
0.5453689694,
0.4120745063,
0.1748577952,
0.482927829,
0.1741929203,
0.8382160068,
-0.0145392586,
0.1968003511,
0.0309948735,
-0.4938334227,
-0.6427947879,
-0.1827103347,
0.490493834,
0.6404916644,
-1.2901772261,
0.1857648343,
-0.3584141433,
-0.4236041307,
-0.4422926903,
0.2193778157,
0.5032038093,
0.6867428422,
0.4125521481,
-0.0914465412,
-0.6658354402,
-0.8409538865,
-0.0493196584,
-0.1142665148,
-0.0404315405,
0.6993179321,
0.2472957671,
0.019868508,
0.9120170474,
-0.7435153127,
-0.4508522749,
-0.3598565757,
0.0241614021,
0.1327452809,
0.4230822921,
0.5124582648,
-0.7223224044,
-0.7835022211,
0.0776138827,
-0.7980373502,
-0.0800396949,
0.2761249244,
-0.365093112,
0.0578750484,
0.6631386876,
-0.7364008427,
0.2201589197,
0.3255802095,
-0.1403084844,
0.5331963897,
-0.2201474458,
0.3460382819,
-1.0281429291,
-0.0198782552,
-0.3716740012,
-0.3784023523,
-0.6080733538,
0.2399580777,
0.0523305014,
-0.2459951341,
-0.2947008908,
0.5205275416,
-0.5147761106,
0.1495130211,
0.0957259461,
0.3102653921,
0.122751683,
0.7067961097,
0.1150001064,
0.6876074076,
0.5421248674,
-0.6661261916,
0.3143955469,
0.2845395505,
-0.4107518196,
0.4789766073,
-0.3532164395,
0.2171115279,
-0.1787001491,
0.2782605588,
-0.672537744,
-0.2898220122,
0.2813965976,
-0.2919381559,
0.3271854222,
-0.3936370313,
-0.4986576736,
-0.4417889714,
0.2429986298,
0.6137148142,
0.1898653656,
-0.4274303317,
0.7837648392,
0.3224163651,
0.0548507348,
-0.8326779604,
-0.4612679482,
-0.1497727782,
-0.0354448296,
-0.674536705,
0.2744521499,
-0.0101994444,
0.0934341252,
0.0094010085,
-0.1063188836,
-0.0637544319,
-0.0561785325,
-0.1879616976,
-0.0713507161,
-0.0994947404,
0.0698336437,
-0.0160509795,
-0.0437307321,
-0.2052472383,
-0.6291168332,
0.682744205,
0.065722324,
-0.6192063689,
-0.0472421125,
0.2616802454,
0.2917910516,
-0.6051047444,
0.9352581501,
0.5371240973,
-0.2710086703,
0.1619560122,
-0.6068637967,
-0.1333851218,
-0.4366140962,
0.3874982893,
-0.6013109088,
-1.1616224051,
0.8191828728,
0.0309310853,
-0.4278981686,
0.1942119598,
0.2118074149,
0.1512968242,
1.1868113279,
0.4500670433,
-0.1353991777,
0.2451137006,
-0.2302267998,
0.2682985067,
-0.6578116417,
-0.4181410968,
-0.5388453007,
0.0086001642,
-0.5419821143,
-0.2750358284,
0.5324007273,
0.7512010336,
-0.116175808,
0.3684068024,
-0.3591367006,
0.5778282285,
0.722628057,
0.0640555099,
0.3082057238,
-0.0073153232,
-0.7569442987,
-0.2504737973,
-1.0064100027,
-0.031767685,
1.0804071426,
-0.301567018,
0.3689411879,
0.2278844714,
0.5275958776,
-0.1783397198,
0.3541691005,
-0.455958277,
0.5023276806,
-0.0653150529,
-0.813508451,
-0.1833213121,
-0.8608554006,
-0.7865229249,
0.2082148492,
-0.060717728,
-0.804115057,
-0.0721729174,
0.1422120333,
-0.156091243,
0.2069634646,
-0.830706358,
1.0450062752,
-0.1880261898,
-0.2248448133,
-0.1324004084,
-0.6131932139,
0.2719692886,
0.0386427864,
0.3281686306,
-0.1913529932,
0.3744679093,
0.5124072433,
-0.6741492152,
0.7502065897,
-0.5927863717,
0.0362428911,
0.5545996428,
-0.1307753623,
0.7517818213,
0.0670051947,
0.0566028804,
-0.0279795788,
-0.0594524033,
-0.5484261513,
-0.7089388371,
0.4582511783,
-0.6116036177,
-0.851778686,
0.0195524804,
-0.6838965416,
-0.6217498183,
0.4674932063,
0.3896003067,
0.260201782,
0.0581897944,
0.062607877,
0.5030223727,
-0.1976761073,
0.0669693723,
0.6621819735,
-0.5050163269,
-0.5093446374,
0.915712297,
0.3784496784,
0.3700457215,
0.4915748537,
-0.0296658557,
-0.4829799831,
-0.5567131639,
-0.4352679253,
0.1936561912,
-0.9482434392,
-0.3948331475,
-0.6552971005,
-0.2453427762,
-0.8164151311,
0.1055275351,
-0.084695369,
-0.4206219018,
-0.0418992117,
-0.1331794113,
0.2214864939,
0.4801888466,
-0.0151182944,
0.3771992028,
-0.7311322689,
0.1948002875,
0.5469724536,
0.4198499024,
0.0438110456,
-0.2093937844,
-0.4166219831,
0.0821027979,
-0.192974478,
-0.9972754717,
0.0481947437,
0.3030590713,
0.7930918336,
0.4515144825,
0.167502895,
0.809877038,
-0.4617626667,
0.5045897961,
0.0565450452,
-0.8150237203,
0.6533532143,
-0.4385401309,
0.4020077884,
0.7100806832,
0.825075686,
-0.576875329,
-0.4864957929,
-0.3562304974,
-0.7712331414,
0.7321187854,
0.1997170448,
-0.1869265586,
-0.0122031486,
0.6070069671,
-0.1629270762,
0.2465751916,
-0.9041801095,
-0.3225931823,
-0.2402721047,
-0.1199567616,
0.0378250219,
-0.3294537961,
-0.0779715851,
-0.4299604595,
0.8887682557,
-0.3671554029,
-0.0331119262,
0.039143201,
-0.2737212181,
0.1072580069,
0.2258748263,
0.4425792992,
0.9245373607,
-0.0486635529,
0.1570825577,
0.3419359624,
-0.3664352,
0.2378831953,
0.3946258128,
-0.3871912658,
-0.1999905258,
0.4178735912,
0.7068778872,
0.0420580395,
-0.4598644972,
0.2992402315,
-0.0052461764,
-0.099486351,
-0.0375635996,
-0.1065654308,
0.3577025235,
0.0776914358,
0.260823667,
-0.0683062971,
-0.2073429078,
-0.1677248925,
0.0041193045,
0.5924656987,
-0.3920164108,
-0.098696202,
0.7836870551,
-0.0030017032,
0.1859824359,
0.7261852622,
-0.7235204577,
-0.8730789423,
0.416277498,
0.5072398782,
0.2497705519,
-0.2719166279,
0.1548928171,
0.5730016828,
0.4769623876,
0.0194819514,
0.423576951,
-0.1930782199,
-0.9518930316,
-0.913972199,
-0.6083056331,
-0.221534133,
0.001317229,
-0.5464532971,
0.2261886597,
-0.2459665835,
-0.1478497684,
-0.1263165176,
0.1183261946,
-0.6677976847,
0.0610400699,
-0.0679898262,
0.7278229594,
-0.6569606066,
1.1405895948,
0.8432070017,
-0.6420018673,
-1.0916775465,
-0.3169128895,
-0.2276032716,
-0.8421131968,
0.660838902,
0.1186899245,
0.0052276971,
0.1917253882,
-0.2608563304,
-1.0816857815,
0.9325419068,
0.7831183672,
-0.3095552921,
-0.0353065506,
0.5052109361,
0.2618014514,
-0.3380618095,
-0.0137748718,
0.5096992254,
0.7316532731,
0.2685287297,
-0.9263461828,
-0.0329589136,
0.023052454,
-0.2453697175,
0.3611778319,
-0.5659922957,
0.6145530343,
-0.1243514568,
-0.0852193385,
-0.2490527779,
0.6928244233,
0.3975588083,
0.0976198167,
0.4883189797,
0.9361398816,
1.0494935513,
-0.280969739,
0.9983135462,
-0.4508185685,
0.3966315091,
1.2035450935,
-0.3650784194,
0.4308740795,
0.1960432231,
-0.4379140735,
0.3934567869,
0.7975842953,
0.3064006567,
0.7251141071,
-0.0279825889,
-0.3619734347,
-0.6006475091,
-0.4852432907,
-0.4838398695,
0.4199505448,
0.2352671325,
0.0543885119,
-0.0725962296,
0.2804295123,
0.3701332211,
-0.0060494244,
-0.483491689,
0.5701034665,
-0.0359772667,
-0.9630367756,
0.5836287141,
-0.0054947739,
0.3786570728,
-0.7723451853,
0.2450827807,
-0.4491427243,
-0.0220924187,
-0.1708920896,
-0.3256826699,
0.333565563,
-0.1997155547,
-0.246699065,
-0.1775229424,
0.8390699029,
-0.7478069067,
-0.6033657789,
0.3927737772,
0.7833369374,
-0.0105982861,
-0.2349829972,
-0.4225833118,
-0.4237710238,
0.3390960395,
-0.0598350689,
0.2031273395,
0.6052215099,
-0.0830508769,
0.6988936067,
0.4107658267,
0.0807266086,
0.1358882934,
0.2221759856,
0.8241413832,
-0.3462760448,
-0.5047556758,
-0.6492960453,
0.1074829251,
0.0652201623,
0.0269448292,
0.8291208148,
0.6145378947,
1.1596639156,
0.0656938329,
0.7260976434,
-0.2428639233,
0.4510999024,
-0.874574542,
0.8591331244,
-0.6455646157,
0.0895956978,
-0.1272770762,
-0.8953999281,
-0.3056855798,
0.4469853342,
-0.5207239985,
0.2763240337,
0.8288433552,
0.6392760277,
-0.0641058013,
-0.1192591041,
0.1958104968,
0.0571068078,
0.138044551,
0.7141857147,
0.8740215302,
0.0258338619,
0.9812669158,
-0.4695927799,
0.1476263255,
0.2583146989,
-0.8955979943,
-0.8789672256,
-0.5972298384,
-0.2359560728,
-0.3480890989,
-0.1773100048,
0.7372074127,
0.9396879077,
-0.9737051129,
0.0087818224,
-0.0027574261,
0.494548291,
-0.0565478876,
-0.1944627613,
0.5411629677,
-0.4713981748,
-0.4520579576,
0.384498179,
0.0031015028,
-0.0461017005,
-0.2000961006,
-0.3146601915,
-0.5131271482,
-0.4241022766,
0.4903404117,
0.2520644963,
-0.5665217042,
-0.4039754868,
0.0849094912,
0.1258943975,
0.1553591341,
1.1197311878,
-0.8786491752,
0.453822732,
0.2642212212,
0.4527284205,
0.6314325929,
-0.2004118562,
0.4705383778,
-1.4695137739,
0.4368291199,
0.1106441915,
0.5930957198,
0.3715211153,
-0.3135886788,
0.6236656308,
0.4409610033,
-0.373960495,
-0.5510878563,
0.5986872911,
-0.463399291,
-0.3528194726,
0.9962041378,
-0.454395324,
-0.0379127339,
-0.2259610742,
0.0127485227,
0.5408142209,
0.0363680422,
0.419457972,
0.9276804328,
-0.1383250952,
-0.1248360947,
-0.5776041746,
0.5738014579,
0.460365504,
-0.859188199,
0.0406905785,
0.6009896398,
0.1543426812,
0.1985531002,
0.9430032969,
0.0240851752,
-0.0609698854,
-0.3295637071,
0.0588276722,
-0.2449162602,
-0.3510508537,
0.1856246889,
0.3404087722,
0.1388734877,
0.3081116676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18082v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18082v1 | Octo-planner: On-device Language Model for Planner-Action Agents | 2024-06-26T05:40:10 | 2024-06-26T05:40:10 | Wei Chen, Zhiyuan Li, Zhen Guo, Yikang Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | AI agents have become increasingly significant in various domains, enabling
autonomous decision-making and problem-solving. To function effectively, these
agents require a planning process that determines the best course of action and
then executes the planned actions. In this paper, we present an efficient
on-device Planner-Action framework that separates planning and action execution
into two distinct components: a planner agent based on Phi-3 Mini, a 3.8
billion parameter LLM optimized for edge devices, and an action agent using the
Octopus model for function execution. The planner agent first responds to user
queries by decomposing tasks into a sequence of sub-steps, which are then
executed by the action agent. To optimize performance on resource-constrained
devices, we employ model fine-tuning instead of in-context learning, reducing
computational costs and energy consumption while improving response times. Our
approach involves using GPT-4 to generate diverse planning queries and
responses based on available functions, with subsequent validations to ensure
data quality. We fine-tune the Phi-3 Mini model on this curated dataset,
achieving a 97\% success rate in our in-domain test environment. To address
multi-domain planning challenges, we developed a multi-LoRA training method
that merges weights from LoRAs trained on distinct function subsets. This
approach enables flexible handling of complex, multi-domain queries while
maintaining computational efficiency on resource-constrained devices. To
support further research, we have open-sourced our model weights at
\url{https://huggingface.co/NexaAIDev/octopus-planning}. For the demo, please
refer to \url{https://www.nexa4ai.com/octo-planner}. | [
-0.6151962876,
-0.7869440317,
0.4506615698,
0.110000059,
-0.1781270057,
-0.3970446289,
0.2000471354,
-0.3488940895,
0.371173799,
0.5970358849,
-0.5547347665,
-0.2465322167,
-0.0774062797,
-0.0725416839,
0.0504713096,
0.5851873159,
-0.1155860648,
-0.3126531243,
0.2829898298,
-0.265286684,
-0.1753735393,
-0.2059588283,
-0.9049690962,
-0.4408156574,
0.4274616241,
0.7607976198,
0.6033130288,
0.6245777607,
0.5641893744,
0.3293768466,
0.2000394613,
0.2685555518,
-0.3318781257,
0.0013242762,
-0.1354445219,
-0.0769626051,
-1.1843110323,
-0.1924516261,
0.4001081288,
0.4388814569,
-0.3482559919,
-0.0433777384,
-0.1964214146,
0.3837556839,
-0.6270112395,
0.2455777675,
-0.6610667706,
0.0690338537,
0.2335158139,
0.1068126857,
-0.2365452945,
-0.2612279654,
0.071298331,
-0.8923288584,
-0.0799072385,
-0.06592758,
0.3362436891,
0.5614321232,
-0.4829379022,
-0.1463629305,
-0.9832809567,
0.5551330447,
-0.3188818097,
0.4556244314,
0.3920723796,
0.2823037803,
0.0082462579,
-0.8101059198,
-0.7905518413,
0.0927095264,
0.3097856343,
0.0584475994,
-0.0167968906,
0.2021238357,
0.3923349679,
-0.0253270045,
-0.6532568336,
0.1374755502,
-0.3740227818,
0.0542746708,
0.8932638168,
0.176810205,
0.0732430071,
0.1795403361,
-0.4648979604,
-0.0590442009,
-0.9261217713,
0.0589479133,
0.3264621198,
0.3022626638,
-0.2403462529,
0.7346819639,
-0.4860465229,
0.4198149741,
-0.0117790606,
-0.5393446088,
0.010255184,
-0.2754663825,
-0.2713044882,
0.1726630777,
0.690323472,
0.3060117364,
-0.0294332355,
0.0858279765,
-0.3867439628,
-0.061345432,
0.3009997308,
-0.9906633496,
-0.3409992158,
0.4009493291,
-0.1672151387,
0.0317311659,
-0.5038888454,
-0.7737229466,
-0.4806185663,
0.0183077436,
0.4308364689,
-0.6892306209,
-0.1979238689,
0.2776983082,
0.1925327927,
0.2916995287,
0.370931536,
-0.9524056315,
0.6405521631,
0.4627336264,
0.6621993184,
-0.0191143565,
-0.4920807183,
-0.7721521854,
0.5264154673,
-0.2276144177,
0.9185268879,
-0.3838177025,
-0.6684035659,
-0.0924078152,
-0.4530930817,
-0.5166311264,
-0.1979219764,
0.6730306149,
-0.6029562354,
0.0473346971,
-0.133090362,
-0.3458879888,
-0.4854498506,
0.340720892,
-0.9242423177,
0.9555341005,
0.0195702519,
-0.4130714834,
0.4144208729,
-1.2451491356,
-0.5460790992,
0.1017276943,
-0.1510484815,
-0.6026921272,
-0.300373137,
0.302495122,
0.4798837304,
-0.3684515357,
-0.2692758143,
-0.3608911633,
-0.2283757478,
-0.1662636846,
0.1029768586,
0.3232669532,
0.152312696,
-0.4353983402,
0.3133039773,
-0.7316036224,
0.2480037957,
0.1613702029,
-0.3989768922,
-0.0217684656,
0.1334600747,
-0.1189898923,
0.2990116477,
0.1245264038,
-0.7073067427,
0.5846991539,
-0.3142985404,
0.4988554418,
0.4414095879,
0.1029986218,
0.5819292068,
-0.3064955771,
0.5210980773,
-0.3476149142,
0.4349253476,
-0.1486510187,
-0.7216963172,
-0.56555444,
-0.2507065535,
-0.1709582657,
0.5628555417,
-1.0176171064,
0.2569030821,
-0.4122143984,
-0.6477304697,
0.0303758699,
0.0708216876,
0.2972493172,
0.4526685476,
0.4127164483,
-0.0829069465,
0.0886330605,
-0.5550009608,
-0.0209116451,
-0.2910714149,
0.1864721477,
0.2974540591,
0.5493882895,
-0.2512057424,
0.9405663013,
-0.6200169921,
-0.5070641041,
-0.7248433828,
0.0666216612,
-0.0250850953,
0.3824850619,
0.637888968,
-1.0358837843,
-0.4371728599,
0.2326514125,
-0.3744772971,
0.0234185457,
0.0242842641,
0.194928363,
0.0673063546,
0.1821774095,
-1.0124802589,
0.403870374,
0.324499011,
-0.2471883297,
0.3439326584,
-0.2131049037,
-0.1523421407,
-1.0619565248,
0.1100239158,
-0.0072713993,
0.1232834235,
-0.7729278207,
0.1033784002,
0.030784227,
-0.4134537876,
-0.7785931826,
0.6699641347,
-0.1872692853,
-0.3428875208,
-0.2241941243,
-0.1050658822,
0.0060744095,
0.9934524298,
0.114883475,
0.8925748467,
0.3246293068,
-0.9578865767,
0.387232244,
0.1385615915,
0.1197299659,
0.6484960318,
-0.7757940292,
0.2593340874,
0.3458825648,
0.0715920478,
-0.5330553651,
-0.3896812499,
0.4447814524,
0.0182902794,
-0.096806787,
-0.4566507936,
-0.5926082134,
-0.1983631402,
-0.3999707699,
0.5207400918,
0.3235369027,
-0.4929016829,
1.3825851679,
0.5762895942,
-0.1511415839,
-0.2164615542,
-0.2996844649,
-0.5371124148,
-0.5019758344,
-0.7309784293,
0.5962499976,
-0.0178382918,
-0.1270506978,
-0.2170066684,
-0.0610821396,
-0.257598877,
-0.1073047221,
0.3358998299,
0.0063205478,
-0.0983502418,
-0.0085133743,
0.2505800426,
-0.2415248454,
-0.1028927043,
-0.4642421007,
0.7632709146,
-0.134684667,
-0.7456528544,
-0.6031236649,
0.2643967569,
0.6051580906,
-0.4078338146,
0.3155007064,
0.4089644253,
-0.5639069676,
-0.2453891784,
-0.3379614055,
-0.1238107309,
-0.5522896647,
0.121004127,
-0.8855599165,
-0.2163073421,
0.4542189837,
-0.2455598116,
0.3158856332,
0.366694659,
0.4524301887,
0.0858408958,
1.1415833235,
0.770501852,
0.0816610232,
0.5660229921,
-0.8019264936,
0.2820664942,
-0.9094921947,
-0.1954997331,
-0.2939094603,
-0.3194427788,
-0.5013971925,
-0.3678090572,
0.7926901579,
-0.0827339366,
-0.3978696465,
0.3775317669,
-0.3428651392,
0.3559364378,
0.4442254603,
-0.1505534798,
0.2468603402,
0.0774793625,
-0.1702262908,
0.3304272294,
-0.8125081658,
-0.5202764869,
1.1850237846,
0.2321006209,
0.8061717749,
0.218775779,
0.5741615295,
0.1622960567,
-0.0444821343,
-0.752170682,
0.8157109022,
0.2606875896,
-0.2601802647,
-0.5474126339,
-0.2699716389,
-0.9508122802,
0.628436029,
0.1014844626,
-1.0125675201,
0.504778564,
0.1577133685,
-0.7430214286,
0.5486927629,
-0.8753018975,
0.9011582732,
-0.4897947311,
-0.612825036,
-0.3956537843,
-0.17146568,
0.1343491673,
0.0202674493,
-0.2148756087,
-0.3897053003,
-0.2907187641,
0.6269608736,
-0.5298691988,
0.5091246367,
-0.2829960585,
0.0420896821,
0.444722712,
0.0656155646,
0.6630779505,
0.2219915688,
-0.3453670144,
-0.034105856,
-0.21215339,
-0.3467079997,
-0.3529766202,
0.6164881587,
-0.8520528078,
-0.1377631575,
-0.3649051189,
-0.4997669458,
-0.2213690579,
0.5725529194,
0.2009511292,
0.4465690255,
-0.2767442167,
-0.2671591938,
0.5925121903,
-0.0515547954,
0.8025926352,
0.5640547872,
-0.3039265275,
-0.2721560001,
1.0397992134,
0.1142227575,
0.1155144498,
0.2601660192,
-0.0153097408,
-0.3925816417,
-0.6937968731,
-0.5934362411,
0.2293263823,
-0.36603266,
-0.1391486377,
-0.7007761002,
-0.0159193929,
-0.3697771728,
-0.2141268551,
-0.7058867812,
-0.5541050434,
0.0367032476,
0.0922692269,
0.2799814343,
0.696200192,
-0.0627870932,
0.8418386579,
-0.3808795214,
0.5425541997,
0.4814272523,
0.2517820895,
-0.4703881443,
0.224328354,
-0.0711191073,
0.0997854397,
-0.7762428522,
-0.7419177294,
0.4774300158,
0.3460970819,
0.449328661,
0.6005674005,
0.1374897063,
0.4705968797,
-0.1730002314,
0.544703126,
-0.0554333329,
-0.5647822618,
0.7782900333,
-0.4776644111,
0.1876154393,
0.4154082835,
0.392611146,
-0.160087958,
0.255764693,
-0.8390226364,
-0.9086964726,
0.9677338004,
0.2257481068,
-0.4137641788,
0.4008105993,
0.2290371954,
-0.1203055903,
0.1932739764,
-0.4715541005,
0.0888275951,
-0.0458583869,
0.2058975101,
0.2693377137,
-0.0111846337,
-0.2684191465,
-0.0496328361,
0.6185894608,
-0.5806494951,
0.3710970581,
0.1183332577,
-0.08138033,
-0.0350953564,
0.0046660793,
0.5951567888,
0.7071014047,
-0.0838335752,
-0.1711497605,
0.3799299896,
-0.7986187339,
0.0067005488,
0.5686032176,
-0.2378763407,
-0.4008740783,
0.2216515839,
0.4504567385,
0.1707018316,
-0.5023981929,
0.2301120013,
-0.2593897879,
0.1013498157,
-0.3781595826,
0.3582282662,
-0.1533145756,
0.2598832548,
0.1858535856,
-0.0119181192,
0.2108385563,
-0.3977377117,
-0.0577629432,
0.0363612697,
-0.271422863,
-0.4697910547,
0.6648792028,
0.5329202414,
-0.4192070663,
0.6474189758,
-0.514693737,
-0.459405303,
0.75440979,
0.3219909072,
0.8182470798,
-0.4621767998,
0.113005951,
0.0056089107,
0.3668583632,
0.1919169575,
0.9921473265,
-0.0293813813,
-0.8187943101,
-0.157344237,
-0.3940665424,
-0.5064424276,
0.0255603213,
-0.1515387893,
0.4297613502,
-0.6048130393,
-0.1682699025,
-0.1556052119,
0.3429445922,
-0.8076756001,
0.0971942246,
-0.1947377622,
0.9779298306,
-0.3934699893,
1.0620157719,
0.9499540925,
-0.484048456,
-0.9439582825,
0.0236763265,
0.1143146232,
-0.7159918547,
0.2780459523,
0.0103056673,
-0.4836194813,
0.0300629605,
0.0629342571,
-0.903535068,
1.2503404617,
0.310208708,
-0.1255615801,
-0.0468739495,
0.3993480802,
0.3950209916,
-0.5743455291,
0.4817111194,
0.4950798154,
0.3702344894,
0.2364914417,
-1.1089332104,
-0.2428617477,
-0.1836314052,
-0.1807983667,
0.3510017097,
-0.712831378,
0.9725666642,
-0.3679600656,
-0.0616900809,
-0.0401699468,
0.3709183037,
0.3803385496,
0.5424230099,
0.5998777151,
0.6574345231,
0.5974699855,
0.0128703807,
1.0039105415,
-0.6369033456,
0.0882379338,
0.8913322687,
-0.8079778552,
0.9077334404,
0.0562574007,
0.1094701514,
0.1578629017,
0.6075662971,
0.5489407778,
0.6411570907,
-0.4174974263,
-0.3780704737,
0.02421478,
-0.1211201549,
-0.2626966238,
0.5746563077,
0.5622627139,
0.1674016863,
-0.1187050566,
0.0052468367,
0.1035583094,
-0.3798301816,
-0.4857092798,
0.7240031958,
-0.0586526543,
-0.6533369422,
0.2047352642,
0.215781793,
0.1290690154,
-0.7266113758,
-0.1116217151,
-0.3020462096,
0.5049058199,
-0.1868917346,
-0.6416240335,
0.1556899101,
-0.247583434,
0.1979075819,
-0.2893567085,
0.858582139,
-0.0285536572,
-0.208755374,
0.2506214678,
0.4937480688,
0.0461555608,
-0.2594370842,
-0.7418973446,
0.1812493652,
-0.2914640605,
-0.2599253058,
0.0841562003,
0.5405914783,
-0.1476335973,
1.0371044874,
0.7143784165,
0.049405653,
0.0392477736,
-0.3003714979,
1.0640056133,
-0.4171409011,
-0.9565777183,
-0.4745313823,
0.4496125281,
-0.2859632671,
-0.6155008674,
0.360032022,
0.9300997853,
0.7858589888,
0.3674236834,
0.5659403205,
-0.0747036487,
0.2145869434,
-0.4894240201,
0.4734420776,
-0.4040820003,
0.5423484445,
0.0165550318,
-1.0627036095,
0.0452228114,
0.6135540605,
-0.5394465923,
0.1931200027,
0.5242725015,
0.6611853838,
-0.4913425148,
0.2781216204,
0.222873956,
-0.0975889713,
0.4798805118,
0.5832323432,
0.5709989071,
-0.3106648326,
0.5741830468,
-0.4724544883,
-0.1580356061,
-0.4032342732,
-0.5297921896,
-0.6146646738,
-0.5801368952,
-0.1766157448,
0.2312022299,
0.1668400317,
0.9462831616,
0.9844455123,
-0.2924961448,
-0.4366589785,
0.0026164972,
0.3934151232,
-0.3634691834,
-0.1283769011,
0.3629080951,
-0.054279644,
-0.6525816917,
0.5924088955,
0.3322761357,
-0.0974700972,
-0.226183787,
-0.3029029071,
0.0248539075,
0.0113557065,
0.7236704826,
0.6455208063,
-0.374427557,
-0.0987342596,
-0.1125871986,
-0.0205649156,
-0.0554264598,
0.9818004966,
-0.6729037166,
0.2725584209,
0.359069854,
0.2931272089,
0.6264082789,
-0.1251184344,
0.603420794,
-0.4078941941,
0.2418975979,
0.4787396789,
0.4896641672,
-0.0172673594,
-0.3872646391,
0.8716872931,
-0.063539423,
-0.5881115794,
-0.568682313,
0.4449986815,
-1.0290583372,
0.0124122333,
1.095091939,
0.0132587478,
-0.1023308039,
-0.179694429,
-0.2650946081,
-0.0675305873,
-0.6696183085,
0.6994943619,
-0.0349232182,
-0.9714733958,
-0.0915859863,
-0.4169508219,
0.5884508491,
0.0608326346,
-1.0178674459,
-0.2424595505,
0.3607542515,
-0.0962816924,
0.3052965403,
0.932081759,
0.3072101772,
0.4286566377,
0.1597363949,
0.2267690301,
-0.0404001772,
-0.5979851484,
0.0273813531,
0.4040443599,
0.0791699663,
-0.3896840215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18078v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18078v1 | Self-Training with Pseudo-Label Scorer for Aspect Sentiment Quad Prediction | 2024-06-26T05:30:21 | 2024-06-26T05:30:21 | Yice Zhang, Jie Zeng, Weiming Hu, Ziyi Wang, Shiwei Chen, Ruifeng Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Aspect Sentiment Quad Prediction (ASQP) aims to predict all quads (aspect
term, aspect category, opinion term, sentiment polarity) for a given review,
which is the most representative and challenging task in aspect-based sentiment
analysis. A key challenge in the ASQP task is the scarcity of labeled data,
which limits the performance of existing methods. To tackle this issue, we
propose a self-training framework with a pseudo-label scorer, wherein a scorer
assesses the match between reviews and their pseudo-labels, aiming to filter
out mismatches and thereby enhance the effectiveness of self-training. We
highlight two critical aspects to ensure the scorer's effectiveness and
reliability: the quality of the training dataset and its model architecture. To
this end, we create a human-annotated comparison dataset and train a generative
model on it using ranking-based objectives. Extensive experiments on public
ASQP datasets reveal that using our scorer can greatly and consistently improve
the effectiveness of self-training. Moreover, we explore the possibility of
replacing humans with large language models for comparison dataset annotation,
and experiments demonstrate its feasibility. We release our code and data at
https://github.com/HITSZ-HLT/ST-w-Scorer-ABSA . | [
-0.5464023948,
-0.1156113669,
0.3147769868,
0.2981382608,
-0.3567036986,
0.2238133103,
0.0859429613,
-0.4657478333,
0.4113892317,
0.4357287884,
-0.5474662781,
-0.725507617,
-0.3894785941,
0.1316205412,
-0.2155584842,
1.415004611,
0.0120180538,
0.108435072,
-0.530524075,
-0.3459240198,
-0.4651203454,
-1.0077215433,
-0.4162938297,
-0.2917542458,
0.3440186083,
0.4491694272,
0.3631702363,
0.3251718283,
0.3282380402,
0.2576656342,
0.0665142834,
-0.0656074136,
-0.3551263511,
0.1760292798,
-0.033473812,
-0.2264140844,
-0.5830884576,
0.399184972,
0.5512573719,
0.2382216752,
0.0634869337,
0.3331867754,
0.2070769966,
0.8381822109,
-0.5860773325,
0.3017106056,
-0.3500852585,
0.2352404594,
-0.1432994604,
-0.0088309757,
-0.1796244681,
-0.3964244425,
-0.2187284082,
-0.259298861,
0.2656415403,
0.1604393423,
0.6035233736,
0.1917633265,
-0.3134504259,
0.0595942326,
-0.716295898,
0.6306542754,
-0.6197445393,
0.4624598324,
0.6055660844,
0.3643205166,
0.0650365278,
-0.4752450585,
-0.4857244492,
-0.1557075083,
-0.0395841636,
0.5353370905,
0.1219139248,
0.238103807,
0.1981031895,
0.5586826801,
-0.5922466516,
0.072866343,
-0.1962931454,
-0.4771871865,
0.8617073894,
0.1423596293,
-0.0775044858,
-0.5664255619,
-0.5949997902,
-0.0824702531,
-0.6182759404,
0.4646655917,
0.5588199496,
0.2169731259,
0.0323053561,
0.4333464205,
-0.5711120963,
0.5658608079,
0.197610572,
0.1613048613,
0.5290074348,
-0.2804777324,
0.1440451592,
0.0489775874,
1.1526165009,
0.555508852,
-0.2301054448,
0.0115841003,
-0.5793872476,
0.0103836255,
0.4925710857,
-0.6105593443,
-0.7692415714,
0.2717382908,
-0.3156639636,
-0.3275097013,
-0.0974828377,
-0.6673597097,
-0.2007050216,
-0.3597698808,
0.6423377395,
-0.4601496458,
-0.0447020978,
-0.2245086282,
-0.0223770756,
0.0246455986,
0.1138350442,
-0.8411548734,
0.0692628995,
0.628681004,
0.7795692682,
-0.0433147587,
-0.4283261895,
-0.6524757147,
-0.4843678772,
-0.3717069626,
1.0725395679,
-0.4128559232,
-0.5199084878,
-0.0449886657,
-0.4999119639,
0.0933601335,
-0.3215289414,
0.6222491264,
-0.3785743713,
0.1305318773,
-0.3401429951,
-0.4888271093,
-0.1705598384,
0.6760669351,
-0.5298529863,
1.3287727833,
0.3165856302,
-0.7473552227,
0.3165135384,
-0.2977511585,
-0.2827085853,
0.1520096958,
-0.2872384489,
-0.999407351,
0.1799084395,
0.2607552111,
0.2769320607,
-0.1884101629,
-0.1384221762,
-0.5792566538,
-0.1355845928,
0.3789468408,
-0.1759052277,
0.3500169516,
0.018878283,
-0.1154216826,
0.2504030764,
-0.65264678,
0.3210233748,
-0.2669193745,
-0.2379229963,
-0.2026862353,
-0.190043509,
-0.075237073,
0.5966781974,
0.3212883174,
-0.6191007495,
0.3878043592,
-0.5259309411,
0.1455719769,
0.6597801447,
0.1997712404,
0.2532372773,
-0.1885314733,
0.7366680503,
0.1699421555,
0.5644066334,
0.269107461,
-0.4814888835,
-0.6411334276,
-0.2065532058,
0.7036638856,
0.2310836315,
-1.1429831982,
0.7331200242,
-0.0426024497,
-0.6715938449,
-0.7066086531,
0.1936680973,
0.9087076783,
0.5035930872,
0.5718972683,
-0.6753416657,
-0.4408809543,
-0.8544977903,
-0.3936306834,
-0.4761056006,
0.1632476151,
0.0088523589,
0.3641620576,
-0.0563641526,
1.2324340343,
-0.6625165343,
-0.763104856,
-0.2629266083,
0.6765385866,
0.0235959254,
0.4037692845,
0.5604200363,
-0.7410632968,
-0.5777139068,
-0.4574263692,
-0.4716744721,
-0.2394990623,
0.0478271283,
-0.0959765986,
0.1332296431,
0.2578350902,
-0.2202917337,
0.5015130043,
0.5556569099,
-0.356821835,
0.9198544621,
-0.2277630419,
0.3436917067,
-0.8244265318,
-0.2576220036,
0.3417406976,
-0.3439725339,
-0.5555267334,
-0.2658123672,
0.0961674377,
-0.0508055612,
-0.4162849486,
0.2942753732,
-0.2068030834,
-0.3119706213,
-0.4609442353,
-0.2711691558,
0.0962619036,
0.7285214663,
0.340482235,
0.710511744,
0.4418573678,
-0.429952085,
0.2475150824,
0.3831605911,
-0.2681651115,
0.6302009225,
-0.3296658099,
0.3182982206,
-0.0317263715,
0.3833573759,
-0.914090097,
0.0817569271,
0.5552869439,
-0.6961805224,
0.3026245236,
-0.3058716655,
-0.4214150906,
-0.6038087606,
-0.571518302,
0.4610629678,
0.3030769229,
-0.5322765708,
0.6435614228,
0.4404679835,
-0.0204658937,
-0.5548881292,
-0.1821579337,
-0.1479143649,
-0.1257800609,
0.0219107643,
0.2857472897,
-0.1638404131,
0.2921184003,
-0.2759506106,
-0.1495704055,
0.1310744882,
0.0147704436,
0.4343697429,
0.2935221493,
0.0584219731,
0.2956728935,
0.0740366504,
-0.5072107315,
0.2812026739,
-0.2823791504,
0.3510684371,
-0.3360663652,
-0.1594263762,
-0.4675628245,
0.1283263266,
0.1245859116,
-0.3506225944,
0.5765702724,
0.3042222559,
-0.0217450075,
-0.2626742423,
-0.3605593443,
-0.1529303938,
-0.4334688187,
0.2940768898,
-0.6393277049,
-0.5756900907,
0.3195624352,
0.0617808551,
-0.1203266829,
0.5710678101,
0.3591112196,
-0.4803963304,
1.2068123817,
0.5469110012,
-0.3943456709,
0.5389764309,
-0.4550109506,
0.1504174024,
-0.962823987,
-0.1463635564,
-0.4019847512,
-0.2605917752,
-0.4686503708,
-0.2710865736,
0.5471274853,
0.2108699977,
-0.1288528293,
0.2990350723,
-0.6805029511,
0.3545050621,
0.7090812325,
0.1343360394,
0.2166371346,
-0.3396588564,
0.1519157439,
-0.2195517272,
-0.5887086987,
-0.2610491216,
1.1420106888,
0.3163234293,
0.4283464849,
-0.1219357327,
1.0249191523,
0.6152092218,
0.4454635382,
-0.8382670879,
0.47645244,
-0.2018187493,
-0.4720986784,
-0.242251873,
-0.6078224182,
-0.3082801402,
0.1406780928,
-0.5761045814,
-0.4680025876,
0.1570162922,
0.5776648521,
-0.3928467929,
-0.0403290391,
-0.4241941273,
1.0768945217,
-0.543900013,
-0.1223948821,
0.0009656289,
-0.7137801647,
0.1595123708,
-0.2147557437,
0.1653607339,
-0.1403100491,
0.3248310089,
0.8843225241,
-0.4848686755,
0.910789907,
-0.3375883698,
0.239386186,
0.4985998571,
0.0064443857,
0.3116663396,
-0.0083446624,
0.0669052973,
0.5250464082,
0.020146165,
-0.2901661098,
-0.6312995553,
0.4996876121,
-1.0521788597,
-0.4283088148,
-0.7842709422,
0.0008961522,
-0.495752871,
-0.0858364329,
0.6295343041,
0.4886040688,
-0.1131971478,
-0.1813572645,
0.3163478971,
0.2503141761,
0.1767698973,
0.4291984737,
-0.3699264526,
-0.6755431294,
1.2394750118,
0.2193033397,
0.0530205332,
0.1931598783,
0.3293354511,
-0.6570237875,
-0.6368117929,
-0.6074148417,
0.124964647,
-0.7325876355,
-0.6460252404,
-0.4341492355,
-0.4535419047,
-0.434515357,
0.1437045187,
-0.7081047893,
-0.3995842338,
-0.1905922592,
-0.125605315,
0.4653896093,
0.7860869765,
-0.1711818576,
0.362611413,
-0.8166003823,
0.2903819084,
0.3739612401,
0.4292263985,
-0.2443922907,
-0.8068342805,
-0.4015165269,
0.0223406553,
-0.5412406325,
-0.8186674714,
0.5081822872,
0.3270865977,
0.2549250722,
0.2932369411,
0.4775153995,
0.4338192344,
-0.2771713138,
0.72993958,
0.4229851663,
-0.9687385559,
0.5534620881,
-0.2328973264,
0.1427159905,
0.8950072527,
0.5445025563,
-0.3607382476,
-0.5772663951,
-0.547219038,
-0.8509087563,
0.8274564743,
0.2586416006,
-0.1804410368,
0.1905399412,
0.5609112382,
0.2342183888,
0.3908141255,
-0.8975467086,
-0.3978478611,
-0.802246809,
-0.3490337729,
-0.3298841417,
-0.3124676347,
0.0807594508,
-0.3820903897,
0.9365130067,
-0.3975546062,
0.29542768,
0.0107661337,
0.0754548833,
0.0456461422,
0.0895910338,
0.0098297466,
0.1618471742,
-0.200369969,
0.0475112572,
0.1219424978,
-0.3382225633,
0.2583689988,
0.1521183252,
-0.2288810611,
-0.2774510384,
0.1947451532,
0.734048605,
0.1988839358,
-0.1205596253,
0.7053695917,
-0.0935510322,
-0.1318642497,
-0.5301624537,
0.061979726,
-0.219533518,
0.317127496,
0.1901142746,
-0.0140882786,
0.4930238724,
-0.5811802149,
0.2240939587,
0.2377452999,
-0.9341698885,
-0.4999152422,
0.5591605306,
0.1994821727,
-0.3790791035,
0.6077854633,
-0.6442692876,
-1.1241753101,
0.3818080425,
0.2574197054,
0.9344598651,
-0.2203008085,
0.6031841636,
0.3800455332,
-0.1377886534,
-0.1703252494,
0.1813410223,
-0.3281593025,
-0.5925492644,
-0.2427949905,
-0.8434470296,
-0.4882212877,
-0.1203831509,
-0.7824494839,
0.2709391713,
-0.4770497978,
-0.4245940745,
-0.0056021172,
0.1231947839,
-0.3813949823,
0.6999519467,
0.2462957501,
0.374194473,
-1.2190737724,
0.9046721458,
0.808292985,
-0.6946964264,
-0.7265897393,
0.2079341412,
-0.1468222588,
-0.37069121,
0.5913813114,
0.3369107246,
-0.247327745,
-0.0283730887,
-0.3457102478,
-0.6529250741,
0.6889894009,
-0.1456148922,
-0.544524312,
0.2125320882,
0.1062868014,
0.8889685869,
-0.3962738216,
0.3025771081,
0.6032962203,
0.0834385231,
0.2781076729,
-0.5975743532,
-0.3081103861,
-0.1825955361,
-0.0490613803,
0.3752660751,
-0.7702621818,
0.5634917617,
0.162485972,
0.1232203841,
-0.1435216814,
1.2173871994,
0.2413802147,
0.5650423169,
0.5611838698,
0.5550314784,
0.2525534034,
-0.1174353585,
0.8077890873,
-0.3145086169,
0.6107612252,
1.2429724932,
-0.1084761247,
1.1306899786,
0.0375593789,
-0.2286499292,
0.5861763358,
0.8313264251,
0.0598146766,
0.6623232961,
-0.0404084772,
-0.2255694419,
-0.6874294281,
0.1737848073,
-0.1987492889,
0.6588161588,
0.1926170886,
-0.2221575081,
0.1606148034,
0.1131537035,
-0.3154684603,
0.1719724238,
-0.6040264964,
1.0057274103,
0.2171309292,
-0.7624533176,
0.2942550778,
-0.0427989475,
0.4873722494,
-0.3530163467,
0.0856604502,
-0.1235428229,
0.0976607054,
-0.2245000899,
-0.9559940696,
0.226786077,
-0.1825448275,
-0.1624581367,
-0.2987763882,
0.6424617767,
-0.4399667084,
-0.6184409857,
0.2842436135,
0.1871820092,
0.1258396953,
-0.3348860443,
-0.9834004045,
-0.204614386,
0.0697389245,
-0.2760543823,
0.5290487409,
0.2249214798,
-0.0709293634,
0.5000982285,
0.4393840134,
0.0475075878,
-0.3617846668,
-0.0120427962,
1.0406746864,
-0.8140051961,
-0.8189602494,
-0.6146100163,
0.3681691885,
-0.1003675684,
-0.6115378737,
0.6601539254,
0.7488998175,
0.6405907869,
0.0210146923,
0.7069265842,
0.1990108341,
0.7271841764,
-0.5600100756,
0.7948043346,
-0.46335724,
0.1897060424,
-0.1763393581,
-1.0314694643,
-0.1594428271,
0.5836361647,
-0.7566550374,
0.1927703619,
0.5373292565,
0.4884395003,
0.1286833435,
0.1300138533,
0.3651362956,
0.1733746678,
0.1768227369,
0.3598814607,
0.933763504,
-0.3780433536,
0.535533905,
-0.5867725015,
-0.2917059064,
-0.3731823564,
-0.6053945422,
-1.0973603725,
-0.7999067903,
-0.6057661772,
-0.5429140925,
0.0909671485,
0.9679858685,
0.4922730625,
-0.7627661228,
0.009052569,
0.1197701469,
-0.126257062,
-0.2357272059,
-0.1583957225,
0.3775396943,
-0.2807231545,
-0.4225206673,
0.0856111646,
0.2479225993,
0.0436709188,
-0.3741811514,
-0.0083451644,
0.1035674438,
-0.0958047882,
0.5246794224,
0.5095760226,
-0.2869989276,
-0.4872227311,
-0.4043396711,
-0.0982789621,
0.3899849355,
0.6698698401,
-1.0100846291,
0.7544513345,
0.3670582175,
0.1724451631,
0.6788144112,
0.4591356814,
0.5148274899,
-0.9300224185,
-0.2718010545,
0.5484906435,
0.2293361425,
0.4540977776,
-0.3427624702,
0.2108239979,
0.1862190366,
-0.6990147233,
-0.5417163372,
0.3228948712,
-0.7127708793,
-0.0592808127,
0.9942346811,
-0.3817332685,
-0.3969329596,
-0.2820159495,
-0.1756850034,
0.2532259226,
-0.5158275962,
1.1972082853,
0.4057531953,
-0.445656538,
0.0441486239,
-0.118760854,
0.9233586192,
0.3179987967,
-0.7987312675,
-0.0388072506,
0.6258497834,
0.1309827864,
0.1203297898,
0.8773548007,
0.2445920259,
0.383420527,
-0.0742166042,
0.5071036816,
-0.0416932218,
-0.6018149257,
-0.4508666098,
0.0886232033,
0.3679600358,
-0.4992142022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18069v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18069v2 | Large Language Models for Cuffless Blood Pressure Measurement From Wearable Biosignals | 2024-06-26T04:54:45 | 2024-06-27T03:58:25 | Zengding Liu, Chen Chen, Jiannong Cao, Minglei Pan, Jikui Liu, Nan Li, Fen Miao, Ye Li | eess.SP | eess.SP, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have captured significant interest from both
academia and industry due to their impressive performance across various
textual tasks. However, the potential of LLMs to analyze physiological
time-series data remains an emerging research field. Particularly, there is a
notable gap in the utilization of LLMs for analyzing wearable biosignals to
achieve cuffless blood pressure (BP) measurement, which is critical for the
management of cardiovascular diseases. This paper presents the first work to
explore the capacity of LLMs to perform cuffless BP estimation based on
wearable biosignals. We extracted physiological features from electrocardiogram
(ECG) and photoplethysmogram (PPG) signals and designed context-enhanced
prompts by combining these features with BP domain knowledge and user
information. Subsequently, we adapted LLMs to BP estimation tasks through
fine-tuning. To evaluate the proposed approach, we conducted assessments of ten
advanced LLMs using a comprehensive public dataset of wearable biosignals from
1,272 participants. The experimental results demonstrate that the optimally
fine-tuned LLM significantly surpasses conventional task-specific baselines,
achieving an estimation error of 0.00 $\pm$ 9.25 mmHg for systolic BP and 1.29
$\pm$ 6.37 mmHg for diastolic BP. Notably, the ablation studies highlight the
benefits of our context enhancement strategy, leading to an 8.9% reduction in
mean absolute error for systolic BP estimation. This paper pioneers the
exploration of LLMs for cuffless BP measurement, providing a potential solution
to enhance the accuracy of cuffless BP measurement. | [
-0.3591620922,
-0.7293405533,
0.8502764106,
0.0580163151,
-0.8189795017,
-0.0193531215,
-0.2443222404,
-0.7895444632,
0.4489324093,
0.4281254709,
-0.6388863325,
-0.6411619782,
-0.5450620055,
0.2079431862,
0.0440776274,
0.8837264776,
-0.0848659575,
0.2832530141,
-0.0058072209,
-0.112716198,
-0.341347456,
-0.3584438264,
-0.1813363582,
-0.5192322731,
0.4594503939,
0.0077760522,
0.3311939538,
0.5416839719,
0.3520777524,
0.1683560908,
-0.390309006,
0.3289880753,
-0.1080706641,
0.2123643011,
0.1219088212,
0.0383865237,
-0.6578073502,
-0.2873723805,
0.9478361011,
0.8083902597,
0.2934256494,
0.7764742374,
0.3714036345,
0.7949804664,
-0.5134453773,
0.2732469141,
0.073496379,
0.0479251556,
-0.2092622817,
-0.5081484914,
-0.1792149097,
0.018215511,
0.3176944554,
-0.0206896998,
0.0200382508,
0.0710404366,
0.2972455621,
0.4525524378,
-0.4163832068,
0.0596252531,
-1.0061810017,
0.714615941,
-0.7799634337,
0.6440249681,
0.180357486,
-0.1210110337,
-0.0977975577,
-0.2666545808,
-0.2021757066,
-0.014880918,
-0.1043266505,
0.1426061243,
-0.0657444373,
0.1175144762,
0.1552860439,
0.2992513478,
-0.6547407508,
0.3387623131,
-0.0847546086,
0.0299141854,
0.4449175,
0.1940518171,
-0.1263816059,
-0.349727124,
-0.3905889392,
0.2136071771,
-0.4904183447,
0.0368584469,
-0.1423947662,
0.178111285,
-0.6608245969,
0.4281298816,
-0.1314607114,
0.9548677802,
-0.2657426596,
-0.3476243019,
0.357401669,
-0.1842290014,
-0.511528194,
0.0301981345,
0.5235536098,
0.1558959782,
-0.0885333866,
-0.2485658675,
-0.1563741267,
-0.1004298776,
-0.0872985348,
-0.865453124,
-0.0245064143,
0.6233955622,
-0.3209092915,
-0.2952555716,
-0.3303176165,
-0.6747061014,
-0.6304695606,
-0.4061583579,
0.0812154636,
-0.2289722264,
-0.21128501,
0.0127724875,
-0.0644646734,
0.0724075511,
0.254426688,
-0.7634379268,
0.0264989752,
0.6270324588,
1.2113813162,
-0.1314971149,
0.2168231159,
-0.2092200369,
0.3712258339,
-0.2379294336,
0.8763074875,
0.0484142154,
-0.7040681243,
-0.2616299987,
0.123052001,
0.1559171081,
-0.3577294946,
0.7162873745,
-0.2190014869,
-0.4024423063,
-0.0060961731,
-0.7223328352,
0.2077349424,
0.3069241643,
-0.4070293605,
0.6201663017,
-0.2528550327,
-0.3805253208,
0.2041400522,
-0.578340888,
-0.49163571,
0.3410637975,
-0.0920463577,
-0.6246182323,
0.1640047431,
0.3297068775,
0.741985023,
-0.3237612545,
0.0752234757,
-0.5880284309,
-0.3071116507,
0.6789343953,
-0.5237361789,
0.4899801314,
-0.1484161615,
-0.305627048,
0.2684238255,
-0.8190339804,
0.1254504323,
-0.1839627326,
-0.1628161967,
-0.3454470634,
0.2363100201,
0.295278579,
-0.0294062477,
0.3611617088,
-1.0183348656,
-0.0464760549,
-0.5117219687,
0.6845719814,
0.9105326533,
0.1821909994,
0.1610747874,
-0.5481758714,
0.1848244369,
-0.5890023708,
0.4078959525,
0.2639190853,
-0.2117109895,
-0.3029823601,
-0.8958790302,
0.0372628197,
0.5793981552,
-0.1188158467,
0.7278260589,
-0.418314904,
-0.8574251533,
-0.1606900096,
0.1891137362,
0.2395498902,
0.8373163342,
0.4847534001,
-0.1188247725,
-0.19178617,
-0.5328226089,
-0.1111042798,
-0.1073022038,
-0.2598201931,
0.515781939,
0.1854965389,
-0.359378159,
0.380592376,
-0.5626319051,
-0.1859059334,
-0.2114082128,
0.1067227796,
0.4558002651,
0.4977219999,
0.3219333589,
-0.3358971179,
-0.0785231963,
-0.2383644134,
-0.5853949189,
-0.2986899316,
0.089570649,
-0.0603381321,
0.4049704969,
0.2621978223,
-0.3873226047,
0.3040510714,
0.8703455329,
-0.4009953141,
0.6373505592,
-0.4081427753,
-0.1717882007,
-0.9469795823,
0.496635586,
0.3208946288,
-0.4350848198,
-0.6794870496,
-0.09560325,
0.1779829413,
-0.3412845731,
-0.410633713,
1.1356534958,
-0.4854993224,
-0.0434221439,
-0.4595592022,
-0.1729227751,
-0.1181189045,
0.3963632584,
0.4791050553,
0.0028220303,
0.3473110497,
-0.5805158615,
0.1584577113,
0.2933349907,
-0.6330792904,
0.3581157029,
-0.8582156897,
-0.0843354985,
-0.1330123544,
0.4459778368,
-1.0901622772,
-0.3273311853,
0.1445915997,
-0.2729724646,
0.2400995046,
-0.1515536904,
-0.4519587159,
-0.3826303482,
-0.3077551126,
0.2554785013,
0.6820371151,
-0.4125371277,
0.4133097529,
0.4091960192,
-0.2446260154,
-0.1645408869,
-0.8006340861,
-0.3193490505,
-0.167420879,
-0.3886395097,
0.3711004853,
-0.2566714585,
0.0804257616,
-0.2450832129,
-0.5503918529,
0.0364247672,
0.0004102843,
0.5867004991,
0.9009488225,
0.1472517848,
0.4602719843,
0.0597195737,
-0.2063349932,
0.0920415968,
-0.2716030777,
0.5538389683,
-0.0972564965,
-0.2643851638,
-0.7817371488,
0.1000265256,
0.6498403549,
-0.2757839859,
0.7974592447,
0.6932908297,
-0.4975659847,
-0.1158630326,
-0.4922042787,
-0.1599686295,
-0.4944649041,
0.1796130687,
0.1342645288,
-1.0531073809,
0.4163250029,
-0.3098078668,
0.0774908438,
-0.098710835,
0.4983885288,
-0.3103992343,
0.8419496417,
0.4120129347,
0.0082696173,
0.6350280643,
-0.0290014036,
0.1034096777,
-1.1500840187,
-0.2717577219,
-0.2858378887,
-0.7349308729,
-0.7069339156,
-0.2205851972,
1.1479877234,
0.0305828061,
-0.5645586848,
-0.1665465981,
-0.4844357669,
0.1719152331,
0.2066574246,
0.7761394978,
0.2004163861,
0.056796845,
-0.0490269959,
0.1143296137,
-0.4494485259,
-0.384088546,
1.0631549358,
0.2124411166,
0.6791014671,
0.1861615032,
0.6367391348,
0.0902386978,
0.5159585476,
-0.8307484984,
0.3664149642,
-0.1825314313,
-0.5053637028,
-0.5634060502,
-0.2622344792,
-0.8338319659,
-0.0020088167,
-0.6540821195,
-0.8399631977,
0.0908644497,
0.5926968455,
-0.7703191042,
0.2959770262,
-0.4647709131,
0.912925303,
-0.6351402402,
-0.6532569528,
-0.0396607108,
-0.6115193367,
0.0685816482,
-0.2766675949,
0.2533870935,
-0.4409947693,
-0.3818361163,
0.4024693668,
-0.3060795367,
1.0704618692,
0.0202243123,
0.0113307061,
-0.0892646462,
-0.1592621058,
0.3791383207,
0.246167317,
-0.2061535418,
0.7006269693,
0.4388127625,
-0.6072479486,
-0.2860728502,
0.8102422953,
-0.6467331052,
-0.2218752354,
-0.6258174181,
-0.492207557,
-0.599332571,
0.2775703073,
0.0672660917,
0.721177578,
-0.2111172825,
0.0700610131,
0.5124271512,
-0.3871920705,
0.5712811947,
0.759850204,
0.3089695573,
-0.3803330958,
0.6092910767,
-0.0319735594,
0.2838008106,
0.5504139066,
0.611515522,
-0.5895225406,
-0.5137649775,
-0.5716276765,
0.5193460584,
-0.1125119999,
-0.1155806407,
-0.2770192027,
0.0230709538,
-0.5794789195,
-0.2916333377,
-0.1124378741,
0.0320441984,
-0.3504898548,
-0.0487721413,
0.4168321788,
0.3332523406,
-0.1944869012,
0.2673226595,
-1.1795196533,
0.2970843315,
-0.0073831729,
0.5750365257,
-0.0623308495,
-0.3802202344,
-0.0905159637,
-0.1239145696,
-0.0292490777,
-0.9603205919,
0.6862382293,
0.0632315055,
0.2057659328,
0.1744807512,
0.0328894071,
0.8442618251,
-0.5764215589,
0.6400790811,
0.2043152303,
-0.9486029744,
0.5676304698,
-0.411098659,
0.527040422,
0.1327827275,
0.3827569187,
-0.6652055979,
0.0016766385,
-0.4697336853,
-0.8903625607,
0.2432281524,
-0.126073584,
-0.1055568904,
0.1865721047,
0.4482633173,
-0.1647241563,
0.2732520401,
-0.5947241187,
-0.2926121652,
0.2942226827,
-0.2111281753,
-0.578815937,
0.0506000295,
-0.0214521792,
-0.4656428397,
0.5979087949,
-0.0672498271,
0.2938914895,
0.524199903,
0.1902851015,
-0.3805505335,
0.464620173,
0.5498797297,
0.6966606379,
-0.2726860046,
0.0053675864,
0.1229986697,
-0.2668949664,
-0.0487508476,
0.388320893,
-0.2245003581,
-0.0942927226,
0.4147950113,
0.6795347929,
0.1242550761,
-1.1802800894,
0.2281306535,
0.3070579171,
0.1921577156,
-0.8214470744,
-0.1655711085,
0.1168142185,
0.3800672889,
-0.0123748593,
0.115503028,
-0.2757334411,
-0.3278770447,
0.1041108146,
0.669495225,
-0.2735178471,
-0.1907056421,
0.6666288376,
0.474580586,
-0.0107257329,
0.0467968844,
0.1126572192,
-0.0260181706,
0.2438344955,
0.4101373255,
0.618704021,
-0.4156902134,
0.0696138367,
0.3296452463,
0.2428615689,
0.084694095,
0.2746896744,
-0.1669875234,
-0.7022125721,
-0.6685672402,
-1.0376714468,
-0.6283485293,
0.4414340854,
-0.4141339958,
0.2818011343,
-0.7536260486,
-0.1994870156,
0.2689634562,
0.2271225154,
-0.5369663835,
0.2294801027,
0.4535435438,
0.6216154695,
-0.8116527796,
0.6742513776,
0.5735419989,
0.0352872461,
-0.6083900928,
-0.061452914,
0.1713580191,
-0.9258158207,
0.2551070154,
-0.066986315,
-0.0473020673,
-0.049413681,
-0.2962374389,
-0.7504588962,
1.1394081116,
0.3347986341,
-0.7110850215,
0.1057327092,
0.3741434216,
0.8841078877,
0.1151414141,
-0.0257447921,
0.3154792488,
0.3710986376,
-0.0666399598,
-1.0006543398,
0.1774086207,
-0.1429974586,
-0.2281595021,
0.4365614653,
-0.7759024501,
0.6177845597,
0.0491612032,
0.0251995008,
0.4272595942,
0.2121570408,
0.4735951126,
0.2535706162,
0.2765972912,
0.3202709556,
0.7756718397,
0.0448471829,
1.2351717949,
-0.5980289578,
0.1796862632,
1.0129971504,
-0.2677871585,
0.970148623,
0.4099806547,
0.1339438707,
0.5068475008,
0.8424267769,
0.1005554125,
0.1226190105,
0.2693808377,
-0.8286162019,
-0.4178935885,
-0.1804127544,
-0.2035461068,
0.2677570283,
0.6212467551,
-0.5560688972,
-0.002878462,
-0.0333355255,
-0.2164919525,
-0.2753015757,
-0.6304011941,
0.4352735877,
0.1542741209,
-0.4557129741,
0.6557355523,
0.0484756157,
0.5330403447,
-0.8437375426,
0.1384920776,
0.0746840388,
0.2973155677,
-0.2588108778,
-0.5795568228,
0.1590496898,
0.1605963111,
0.0307747815,
-0.5790989399,
0.8579803705,
-0.2295808047,
-0.6871776581,
0.0979298949,
0.6871409416,
0.1660938412,
-0.085814178,
-0.445302248,
0.0447394438,
-0.3317645788,
-0.1592134982,
0.2518302202,
-0.1415184587,
0.255276233,
0.5514926314,
0.7196509838,
0.7665040493,
-0.3387407959,
-0.2290819734,
0.3534963131,
-0.6975383759,
-0.6365454793,
-0.9571498632,
0.2027084678,
-0.0257159881,
-0.3207896352,
0.5002753139,
0.2563135028,
0.7063531876,
-0.0681742951,
0.8249632716,
0.1878380775,
0.9785848856,
-0.4505875409,
0.6099542975,
-0.6788029075,
0.1337508559,
-0.4402675927,
-0.6727618575,
-0.3988485932,
0.508356154,
-0.4263251126,
-0.2226219773,
0.4934049249,
0.4797895849,
0.0778667852,
-0.0562258773,
0.1821354777,
0.0831444263,
0.1437266022,
0.5756813884,
0.2406457067,
0.0618778542,
0.2344498634,
-0.3074380457,
-0.5564514399,
-0.1691082865,
-0.949952364,
-0.8733426332,
-0.0906941593,
-0.143351227,
-0.1939848512,
-0.0892668664,
1.1310807467,
0.6947202682,
-0.6569660902,
-0.1960667074,
0.0720810443,
-0.1305766404,
-0.216932416,
-0.0695149153,
0.4836320281,
0.2384497821,
-0.729742229,
0.3849579692,
0.4395795166,
0.5235669017,
-0.3212018013,
0.0763272569,
0.1971448362,
0.0565451942,
0.7001556158,
0.5477983356,
-0.5609743595,
-0.5021592379,
0.1195328385,
0.1220659018,
-0.2109720409,
0.6526334882,
-0.6437780857,
0.2401303798,
0.4754964709,
0.6128624678,
0.4139091372,
0.0719861835,
0.1418817937,
-0.9126188159,
0.2789147496,
0.305290699,
0.4545232356,
0.3982402086,
-0.2584125698,
0.3598694205,
0.4655513167,
-0.6712636352,
-0.6383734345,
0.3130937517,
-1.3233869076,
-0.3398766816,
1.2592766285,
0.1554156393,
-0.3836778104,
0.0049350751,
0.1574670672,
0.4528246522,
-0.1746965349,
0.8329721689,
0.5115411878,
-0.8818029761,
0.1842154264,
-0.6364378929,
0.3988773823,
0.4935235381,
-0.7999902368,
-0.0645221546,
0.6758912206,
0.5493414998,
0.0576620623,
0.5970754027,
-0.0088004731,
0.0668902099,
-0.6575607657,
-0.1319865584,
-0.0818729326,
0.2373900563,
-0.391593188,
-0.0492805615,
-0.0523384176,
-0.1483322084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18067v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18067v1 | Exploring Energy-Based Models for Out-of-Distribution Detection in Dialect Identification | 2024-06-26T04:52:48 | 2024-06-26T04:52:48 | Yaqian Hao, Chenguang Hu, Yingying Gao, Shilei Zhang, Junlan Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | The diverse nature of dialects presents challenges for models trained on
specific linguistic patterns, rendering them susceptible to errors when
confronted with unseen or out-of-distribution (OOD) data. This study introduces
a novel margin-enhanced joint energy model (MEJEM) tailored specifically for
OOD detection in dialects. By integrating a generative model and the energy
margin loss, our approach aims to enhance the robustness of dialect
identification systems. Furthermore, we explore two OOD scores for OOD dialect
detection, and our findings conclusively demonstrate that the energy score
outperforms the softmax score. Leveraging Sharpness-Aware Minimization to
optimize the training process of the joint model, we enhance model
generalization by minimizing both loss and sharpness. Experiments conducted on
dialect identification tasks validate the efficacy of Energy-Based Models and
provide valuable insights into their performance. | [
-0.334112525,
-0.5607385635,
0.5992318988,
-0.3250645697,
-0.1797641069,
-0.1695696414,
-0.6793490052,
-0.2848129272,
0.3806693554,
0.7446759939,
-0.4853304625,
-0.5280336738,
-0.1980033368,
-0.1652928591,
-0.0095195454,
0.4591321349,
0.2997187376,
0.0166300759,
0.0060903784,
-0.3123692572,
-0.3113540709,
-0.524815321,
-0.118315421,
-0.3330028355,
0.015294374,
0.3449121714,
0.6959351301,
0.5543982983,
0.362636447,
0.3328412175,
-0.0555750988,
-0.0536033772,
-0.3896790445,
0.0707019866,
-0.2055550665,
-0.6569238901,
-0.5400218368,
-0.0877171829,
0.570756197,
1.1309803724,
-0.4970577061,
0.1469779313,
-0.0890981704,
0.6674503684,
-0.9740364552,
0.1448820978,
-0.8970531821,
-0.047662057,
-0.7016360164,
0.1452753097,
-0.6640434861,
-0.1280461848,
-0.2284353375,
-0.5703775287,
0.362238735,
0.0241717435,
0.8381884694,
-0.1600608081,
-0.4009770751,
-0.1320608854,
-0.6102232933,
0.8192446232,
-0.8213552237,
0.5721285343,
0.0928333998,
0.3778217137,
-0.1541962773,
-0.0488166697,
-0.727132678,
-0.1226080284,
0.1034093201,
0.3267467916,
-0.135539934,
0.2578288615,
0.0940388069,
0.369636029,
-0.4152936339,
0.0339272209,
-0.1894164532,
0.0352434441,
0.6920053959,
0.1307358891,
0.0319786258,
-0.5529132485,
-0.4096275568,
-0.2168120146,
-0.4139198363,
0.0139158722,
0.9834325314,
0.8244325519,
-0.1735563725,
0.2772636116,
-0.2635675669,
0.6236088276,
0.2257004976,
0.0912228301,
0.2691784799,
-0.0344106406,
-0.2307685614,
-0.0745579675,
0.6106953621,
0.3908118308,
-0.0157944262,
0.0113262627,
-0.4828755856,
-0.4237991273,
-0.126385361,
-0.3883075416,
-0.4989920259,
-0.3155735135,
-0.9203452468,
-0.2031755596,
0.2888883352,
-0.939514935,
-0.5210507512,
0.052679684,
0.457585305,
-0.5522707701,
-1.2441161871,
0.2386877835,
-0.5138302445,
-0.0028414775,
-0.1720394939,
-1.1332048178,
0.3733175695,
0.5015749931,
0.7165599465,
0.2530998886,
0.4481999278,
-0.1815043986,
0.0184921604,
-0.4528734684,
0.3503736854,
-0.7920056581,
-0.3677526712,
0.007325816,
0.0820672959,
-0.3389595449,
-0.7442446351,
0.3425414562,
-0.6230227351,
0.0598139167,
-0.3239168525,
-0.5364490747,
-0.4433290064,
-0.2834842503,
-0.9181416035,
0.9803866744,
0.7297144532,
-0.4429218769,
0.4668775201,
-0.7512660027,
-0.0100098047,
0.06034806,
0.1667658389,
-0.3292921484,
0.9281428456,
-0.1576654166,
0.2892947495,
-0.3056659997,
0.184657231,
-0.5430880785,
-0.0117579531,
-0.1050636321,
-0.7744358778,
0.9369981885,
0.3510358632,
-0.051912494,
-0.3659948111,
-1.2094602585,
0.0776430145,
0.2363145649,
-0.2886204123,
-0.9049632549,
-0.1072675362,
0.0795169398,
-0.2124839276,
0.0754103437,
-0.75384444,
0.1465331912,
-0.4881091118,
-0.0134549206,
0.5543264151,
-0.0741122514,
0.5278717279,
-0.2996560037,
0.5523992777,
-0.2489355505,
0.1514436603,
-0.0295069274,
-0.2623023987,
-0.7955762744,
-0.3786410987,
0.4601011872,
0.6142349243,
-0.7186279297,
0.9741230607,
-0.2444883585,
-0.5350171328,
-0.352483511,
0.105881758,
0.3302736878,
0.5446861386,
0.4052791595,
-0.4630734921,
-0.2329313457,
-0.6359293461,
-0.517796576,
-0.1807754338,
-0.1979754269,
0.3100753427,
0.1421291381,
0.1338222772,
1.0593346357,
-0.2658503056,
-0.1112816259,
-0.6830855608,
-0.0296415165,
0.4889902472,
0.4453123808,
0.8548741341,
-0.6503637433,
-0.3919048309,
0.0758825317,
-0.5614895821,
-0.4822456837,
-0.0439207107,
0.0780351907,
-0.1246971339,
0.3438194096,
-0.212563321,
0.2929154038,
0.4646861851,
-0.2591480017,
0.3633433878,
-0.1309651285,
0.1732521802,
-0.9828078747,
-0.1075175554,
0.0618911944,
-0.122991018,
-0.7347177267,
-0.0598927215,
0.2555212379,
-0.291044265,
-0.3863792717,
0.2068025172,
-0.6497472525,
0.1733738184,
0.0351128578,
-0.1970379651,
0.4500030279,
0.4151485264,
0.1301389933,
0.2566378415,
0.5077630877,
-0.302482456,
0.4398360848,
-0.2226283252,
-0.5056685805,
0.6310002804,
-0.2456632853,
0.2403913289,
-0.1755507737,
-0.0880790129,
-1.225122571,
-0.5515763164,
0.0980893523,
-0.181889534,
0.7799407244,
-0.6130486727,
-0.0202887785,
-0.088018842,
-0.3778243065,
0.3908224702,
0.618971467,
-0.8481565118,
0.880826354,
0.3453800082,
-0.0519590899,
-0.2801477611,
-0.332267046,
-0.3873791695,
-0.6573978066,
-0.7515573502,
0.2334046811,
0.5561721325,
-0.6110788584,
-0.0660068914,
0.0838457644,
-0.0901411176,
0.0939641297,
0.1693632305,
0.0095079811,
-0.2772926092,
0.6096894145,
0.0818552598,
0.0602329932,
0.103106074,
-0.254833132,
0.5292828083,
0.0408754498,
-0.5866334438,
-0.3010840416,
0.8340569139,
0.472732693,
-0.0053342874,
0.7834801674,
0.4759930074,
-0.228575021,
-0.2572681606,
-0.621052742,
-0.0973922014,
-0.5804262161,
0.4609157741,
-0.5658900738,
-0.0120071582,
0.5691999197,
-0.6095563173,
-0.4824844301,
0.6184638143,
0.1601888686,
-0.273260057,
0.9205002785,
0.9387660027,
-0.1331507564,
0.8356063366,
-0.421587348,
0.138049081,
-0.7446883917,
-0.0666833892,
-0.5222560167,
-0.000821588,
-0.5734094977,
-0.3514367044,
0.8227381706,
0.3054445684,
0.2669514716,
0.1701063365,
-0.3522954285,
0.4577410817,
0.6741583943,
0.3055084944,
-0.131005913,
-0.1797949672,
-0.0819292739,
0.2114324421,
-0.7137951255,
-0.3102053404,
1.1274069548,
0.2555146217,
0.8892820477,
0.3415385783,
0.7122148275,
0.3397516906,
-0.049544245,
-0.5293788314,
0.4762433171,
-0.1234426871,
-0.6101076603,
-0.3182935119,
-0.5111546516,
-0.662150085,
0.1522886455,
-0.1684578806,
-0.5901049376,
0.4777648449,
0.2154883146,
-0.4237626791,
0.705145359,
-0.9349407554,
0.9402778149,
-0.2200278491,
-0.3132379949,
-0.3059930503,
-0.5934697986,
0.2828893363,
0.1979186386,
0.4371573329,
-0.4477784932,
0.358777225,
0.7872943282,
-0.869474709,
0.7420255542,
-0.8406789303,
-0.0019688066,
0.5596333742,
-0.2233933359,
0.5848965645,
-0.2464591265,
-0.5870141387,
0.5978732109,
-0.2093041092,
-0.412178278,
-0.5315608978,
0.4887214601,
-0.4610636532,
-0.6614903808,
-0.0514556058,
-0.2892619073,
-0.1614690125,
-0.010491224,
0.6164395213,
0.7378652096,
-0.1334941387,
0.0432709008,
0.4569853842,
-0.2097031474,
0.6057063341,
0.6539537311,
0.1176034808,
-0.2867165208,
0.9450536966,
0.2314591259,
0.7051407099,
0.2714983225,
0.4158442616,
-0.5583139658,
-0.511849165,
-0.7284657359,
-0.0625607371,
-0.7662551403,
-0.0926652923,
-0.0452886112,
0.177719444,
-0.5500088334,
-0.0629892647,
-0.4107205868,
-0.3574393094,
-0.1505348384,
-0.0773720294,
0.3899688423,
0.6925530434,
-0.5257739425,
0.4750564098,
-0.5902353525,
-0.0595345348,
0.0772299394,
0.3546955287,
-0.2518703341,
-0.6037381887,
-0.1895929575,
-0.0711308569,
-0.2138855606,
-1.330830574,
0.5811213851,
0.5183956027,
0.4996801019,
0.9234560132,
0.470959723,
0.3258800209,
-0.2003722638,
0.7378089428,
0.5874143839,
-1.2166600227,
0.4543572366,
-0.4092818797,
-0.0120075103,
0.5901845694,
0.3045144379,
-0.237504527,
-0.0966758355,
-0.4642571509,
-0.8453509212,
0.4823923707,
-0.4197536111,
0.3657015562,
-0.0690149367,
0.2393509448,
0.4529035985,
0.1072841585,
-0.599614799,
0.1739088744,
-0.1746725589,
-0.3622965515,
0.2382876575,
-0.2298891544,
0.2573287785,
-0.0358878747,
0.6539304256,
-0.3079347312,
0.0711965933,
-0.1179039255,
-0.1201345474,
-0.3957270384,
0.413161248,
0.05827659,
0.1316098869,
-0.4415186942,
0.1155231073,
0.2682221532,
-0.2753948271,
0.260848254,
-0.1497144252,
0.1801504195,
0.3888842463,
0.4909150898,
0.6260073781,
-0.2247670889,
-0.4546896517,
0.6138547063,
0.2304321527,
0.1635266542,
-0.2807550132,
0.3845381737,
-0.3357667625,
0.3904122412,
0.3579978645,
0.3832519948,
0.5175059438,
-0.641903162,
-0.235274896,
0.8572981954,
-0.6311762929,
-0.6564808488,
0.3235728443,
0.5862299204,
-0.2261783034,
0.4082075953,
-0.458137989,
-0.5372635722,
0.7008080482,
0.231925264,
0.7871601582,
-0.4803049564,
-0.2304894179,
-0.1001800001,
0.1032049432,
0.2812672555,
0.5290703177,
-0.3891826868,
-0.7979573607,
0.0102505367,
-0.5551468134,
-0.2310351133,
0.193811208,
-1.2916625738,
0.4339245856,
-0.0463509299,
-0.4865452647,
-0.0481017306,
-0.0625651106,
-0.5029829144,
0.0873915404,
0.4872969389,
0.8730769157,
-1.3976789713,
0.8245437741,
0.3281299174,
0.028866617,
-0.8551961184,
0.0953968018,
0.1908986568,
-0.5696097612,
0.2178849578,
0.1271199733,
-0.2446584105,
-0.1133857667,
-0.1775089204,
-0.8504785299,
0.8768320084,
0.4888688624,
-0.8369835615,
0.3097922206,
0.0122028813,
0.1605662853,
-0.0481503643,
0.6745086908,
0.5674269795,
0.4998299778,
-0.1194851622,
-1.0679322481,
-0.2346982211,
-0.1206449717,
-0.0451135635,
0.5719121695,
-0.9183847904,
1.1512969732,
-0.2735302448,
-0.2961936295,
0.1978300512,
0.4208863378,
-0.3812500238,
0.5741143227,
0.9002751112,
0.4489976168,
1.011261344,
-0.1616736948,
0.7540325522,
-0.3242417574,
0.4140883386,
0.6528233886,
-0.4875369966,
0.771298945,
0.2107433081,
-0.2044377178,
0.6285333633,
0.4668192267,
0.3505818844,
1.0932196379,
0.4055458903,
-0.5826509595,
-0.4347932339,
-0.2931889892,
-0.6483749747,
0.7560209036,
0.7541499138,
-0.4947659969,
-0.1365582943,
0.3246425688,
-0.0458610095,
0.2217292041,
-0.4813097417,
0.8163594604,
-0.3687104881,
-0.3298703432,
0.858558476,
0.1209743097,
0.5997409225,
-0.6344527602,
0.0333093926,
-0.2461443543,
0.5061326623,
-0.0276649632,
-0.1966460496,
0.2421124727,
-0.3819036782,
-0.5219128728,
-0.1530005783,
0.6927918196,
-0.5969482064,
-0.5064601898,
0.498876363,
0.4270608127,
0.1876424849,
-0.0521403998,
-0.2371914089,
0.1773365885,
-0.0681809634,
-0.2104394287,
0.1734003127,
0.6214261055,
-0.030514108,
0.1253716499,
0.4246085882,
0.122733295,
0.0038275835,
0.2495987564,
0.8288612962,
-0.4863881469,
-0.4127037525,
-0.7562570572,
0.1281923056,
-0.281050235,
-0.2880480587,
0.7103441358,
0.3819516599,
0.7299700975,
-0.2630503476,
1.0625295639,
-0.0046299025,
0.7097663879,
-0.7231028676,
0.666000545,
-0.5422978401,
0.229084596,
-0.1885987073,
-0.519616127,
0.1812437177,
0.3886073232,
-0.4589724541,
0.1699720174,
0.1871640682,
0.9370127916,
-0.3493255973,
0.050197389,
0.6021787524,
-0.0115510598,
0.1788744777,
0.7082341909,
0.9875253439,
-0.1640108526,
0.206748575,
-0.3904520273,
-0.4360487759,
-0.6237942576,
-0.8569039106,
-0.9267185926,
-0.4372085929,
-0.1422725767,
-0.1246511415,
0.1987578124,
1.1161228418,
1.2343785763,
-0.9816757441,
-0.1726426333,
-0.0693084598,
-0.1328990757,
-0.4885587096,
-0.2948008478,
0.2239776701,
-0.1322581917,
-0.5703549981,
0.9314947128,
0.4130294621,
-0.2533209324,
-0.2382047176,
0.1301144063,
0.0604215115,
0.4790117741,
0.0655692443,
0.1433014125,
-0.5447360277,
-0.4201530218,
-0.1471325457,
0.300575912,
-0.008762327,
0.704269588,
-0.6675720215,
0.8402438164,
0.5137847066,
-0.0352852866,
-0.0090649314,
0.3540657163,
0.5771516562,
-1.2385600805,
0.4873099029,
0.1547901779,
0.6839473248,
0.4275709391,
-0.4259262085,
0.3593825996,
0.5608274341,
-0.1793024838,
-0.8055148125,
0.1657552272,
-0.71614182,
-0.1202438921,
1.0314264297,
-0.4896765649,
-0.3066964149,
-0.4173067808,
0.0132501563,
0.0488756523,
-0.5168245435,
0.5863326788,
0.4574995339,
-0.2183912396,
0.2501400411,
-0.2487100512,
0.436807245,
0.429900974,
-0.4532002807,
0.1229244173,
0.3544434011,
0.2138067335,
0.4980837107,
0.2329700589,
0.4785745442,
0.0611903295,
0.2904724479,
0.1291547418,
-0.1053040549,
-0.3911397755,
-0.445045203,
0.4877177775,
-0.1338860095,
-0.6702830195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18064v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18064v1 | Evaluating Quality of Answers for Retrieval-Augmented Generation: A Strong LLM Is All You Need | 2024-06-26T04:49:41 | 2024-06-26T04:49:41 | Yang Wang, Alberto Garcia Hernandez, Roman Kyslyi, Nicholas Kersting | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a comprehensive evaluation of answer quality in
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) applications using vRAG-Eval, a novel
grading system that is designed to assess correctness, completeness, and
honesty. We further map the grading of quality aspects aforementioned into a
binary score, indicating an accept or reject decision, mirroring the intuitive
"thumbs-up" or "thumbs-down" gesture commonly used in chat applications. This
approach suits factual business settings where a clear decision opinion is
essential. Our assessment applies vRAG-Eval to two Large Language Models
(LLMs), evaluating the quality of answers generated by a vanilla RAG
application. We compare these evaluations with human expert judgments and find
a substantial alignment between GPT-4's assessments and those of human experts,
reaching 83% agreement on accept or reject decisions. This study highlights the
potential of LLMs as reliable evaluators in closed-domain, closed-ended
settings, particularly when human evaluations require significant resources. | [
-0.3551479578,
-0.9080858827,
0.5318077207,
0.2328311056,
-0.2300821841,
0.5328662395,
0.0159560274,
-0.6165509224,
0.0691181198,
0.3873776793,
-0.1227592006,
-0.2974818051,
-0.4213784933,
0.0189525522,
-0.2731356621,
1.2107214928,
0.1087033898,
0.2367048711,
-0.6639837027,
-0.1682885438,
-0.5930352211,
-0.5961550474,
-0.679902792,
-0.5890673995,
0.3505562544,
0.4219279587,
0.7632287741,
0.3033764958,
0.7580036521,
0.2604371905,
-0.2717182934,
0.4261617362,
-0.7315318584,
0.2993886769,
-0.541460216,
-0.1960229725,
-0.879745543,
0.1637305021,
0.394613564,
0.5187243223,
-0.3630854487,
0.7006754279,
-0.0943754315,
0.6841626167,
-0.4886091053,
-0.3308735192,
-0.7963155508,
-0.1892874986,
0.1808986217,
-0.2857298851,
-0.4464162588,
-0.7144092917,
-0.0214936864,
-0.264372468,
0.2862014771,
-0.0078613218,
1.0497490168,
0.1610616446,
-0.2067420781,
-0.4288392067,
-0.8721846938,
0.9213024974,
-0.5272625089,
0.2549338639,
0.4932275116,
0.4107244015,
-0.2318941653,
-0.6861813068,
-0.6607957482,
-0.3960656226,
0.1399174035,
0.4224208593,
0.0545108914,
0.0092620775,
0.0511314757,
0.5931107998,
-0.7365310192,
0.054399576,
-0.5570181608,
-0.0918014869,
0.6809138656,
0.2161943913,
0.0462860763,
-0.2343399674,
-0.5886496305,
-0.0117276991,
-0.7182989717,
-0.0296977255,
0.4883750975,
0.1688608527,
0.3844907284,
0.7374591231,
-0.1930604875,
0.8974053264,
0.2032409906,
-0.2310100794,
0.1747446209,
-0.567273736,
-0.2365133464,
-0.219610393,
0.6968370676,
0.4772055149,
0.0690968409,
-0.0073977732,
-0.505810082,
-0.0768434554,
0.6539769769,
-0.7164565921,
0.1359731257,
0.3811298609,
-0.5327672362,
-0.4297406971,
-0.091367498,
-0.6570929289,
-0.4118363559,
-0.3761928976,
0.6549904346,
-0.1708709747,
-0.3053452969,
0.0216676816,
-0.1046123132,
0.6731988788,
0.4334096611,
-0.5164824724,
0.3776100874,
0.8683779836,
0.6132495403,
-0.2878852189,
-0.0341613218,
-0.7995380759,
-0.3828591704,
-0.436845541,
0.9793845415,
-0.510076642,
-0.6130942702,
-0.1576578319,
-0.6237448454,
0.268418014,
-0.7861300111,
1.0429253578,
-0.8701905608,
0.3350051939,
-0.1517127603,
-0.5526547432,
-0.0704851374,
0.5231291652,
-0.2779934406,
1.1473656893,
0.3736583292,
-0.4965601563,
0.4854823649,
-0.2707459927,
-0.1823322624,
0.3841729462,
-0.0527443253,
-0.4468606412,
0.3874464631,
-0.0339005589,
0.2380412072,
-0.3621745706,
-0.0502910875,
-0.2359029055,
-0.3459891975,
0.5048755407,
-0.5353356004,
0.456494987,
0.4185254574,
0.0467631519,
-0.0470447876,
-0.8189723492,
0.421410203,
-0.0842855945,
-0.6288997531,
-0.2547852695,
-0.0677759796,
-0.0307558421,
0.3590719104,
0.5666940808,
-0.6039148569,
0.2991462946,
-0.2714100182,
-0.1615940481,
0.9000397921,
0.0955689847,
0.2256152183,
-0.181678459,
0.7852099538,
-0.330489248,
0.2928009331,
0.2536073029,
-0.4754568636,
-0.7433600426,
-0.086545378,
0.5796572566,
0.4655031264,
-0.8913214803,
0.2790217698,
-0.355093509,
-0.6906868219,
-0.787576139,
0.3083964288,
0.6750233173,
0.6464010477,
0.1664441079,
-0.5436415672,
-0.2224421352,
-0.775749743,
-0.2569957376,
-0.608790338,
-0.0723361149,
0.3854064047,
0.2738310099,
-0.147650227,
0.9933277965,
-0.2501757145,
-0.0073925168,
-0.1786038876,
0.2071236819,
0.4160209596,
0.0556084812,
0.4344787896,
-0.9805606008,
-0.3643717468,
0.1483825743,
-0.6717934608,
-0.2469363511,
0.1415204108,
-0.2757861018,
0.1303780228,
-0.1025919989,
-0.5611227155,
0.2590464056,
0.6732448339,
-0.5604119301,
0.8566173315,
-0.2974796295,
0.5084492564,
-0.8353266716,
0.1136794984,
-0.0000167587,
-0.5253914595,
-0.5716288686,
0.2147383839,
-0.1762377769,
0.1613907963,
-0.4718306065,
0.6611990929,
-0.2128258049,
-0.3820523918,
-0.4331946373,
0.3049710393,
0.215854466,
0.0864807814,
-0.1738454998,
1.0465695858,
-0.0155154774,
-0.5695796013,
0.420783788,
0.2789390683,
-0.2537528574,
0.9779718518,
-0.7580904961,
0.4185721874,
0.0522233695,
-0.0849513635,
-1.0509136915,
-0.2436057031,
-0.1235461459,
-1.0118472576,
0.4715868235,
-0.0927912369,
-0.3245351017,
-0.5289462209,
-0.357288599,
0.1577276886,
0.7602173686,
-0.6110851169,
0.4269178212,
0.3054257035,
-0.2509840131,
-0.8491834998,
-0.2602341771,
0.119446069,
-0.0414292328,
-0.5790328383,
0.0153658465,
-0.1943691224,
-0.4084880054,
0.0321232043,
-0.2385883331,
-0.2338754237,
0.1134442091,
0.0190590117,
0.4111511111,
-0.0725773126,
-0.1173351631,
-0.1614622325,
-0.1145114899,
-0.0580025762,
0.0534568727,
0.342254281,
-0.232704252,
-0.4348454475,
0.0132856192,
0.1699709147,
0.7548187375,
-0.3080543578,
0.5996505618,
0.602670908,
-0.1421499401,
0.0001842911,
-0.7782022357,
0.0697306991,
-0.4512336254,
0.232918784,
-0.3811612129,
-0.8856666088,
0.460549891,
0.1266515702,
0.146186024,
0.447879374,
0.8445309997,
-0.1842828691,
1.1429646015,
0.4835698307,
0.1461059153,
0.1487851292,
-0.1300165057,
0.2762077749,
-0.8785374165,
-0.1643204391,
-0.5970933437,
-0.0390529335,
-0.5745708942,
-0.3185048997,
0.3796956539,
0.4356059134,
-0.1321589053,
-0.0148843024,
-0.8135272861,
0.4663959146,
0.5419312119,
-0.0473851897,
0.3355045915,
-0.0483730473,
0.2508533299,
0.1755991131,
-0.2863207161,
-0.9052911997,
1.060992837,
0.3819435239,
0.6854632497,
0.2905512452,
0.714322865,
0.612574935,
0.6434448361,
-0.8803668022,
0.6038482785,
-0.0100677963,
-0.6670721173,
-0.1244288161,
-0.6856942177,
-0.7675390244,
0.3672679663,
-0.1434963048,
-0.6168712974,
-0.0380487964,
0.0579072796,
-0.3487715423,
0.0149151441,
-0.8160532713,
0.5589157343,
-0.3869071305,
-0.6084147096,
-0.2303695381,
-0.2980866134,
0.490270108,
-0.2652853429,
0.11501012,
-0.1128811166,
0.0020665103,
0.5926828384,
-0.3985546529,
0.2645963728,
-0.2261091471,
-0.0516900234,
0.6615235806,
0.2406164706,
0.20166336,
-0.0675826445,
-0.4537515044,
0.0273297802,
-0.0559220389,
-0.3695549965,
-0.7240716815,
0.8089922071,
-0.8456873298,
-0.5647590756,
-0.537007153,
-0.0846491233,
-0.1978980601,
0.1257847697,
0.139198184,
0.3411844075,
-0.1830646545,
-0.0200046357,
0.5711842179,
-0.3283839822,
-0.0491335653,
0.5994428992,
-0.4604574144,
-0.5512385964,
1.1298954487,
0.1122710407,
0.4464438558,
0.1290172935,
0.2284697741,
-0.4735987484,
-0.654935956,
-0.5628246665,
0.2529984117,
-0.7170792818,
-0.4575205445,
-0.3583814502,
-0.2105448842,
-0.1815442145,
-0.0843922645,
-0.3390813768,
-0.4715237319,
-0.1370577663,
-0.2896820009,
0.276671201,
1.0494498014,
-0.0894444957,
-0.0890749246,
-0.8483729959,
0.5547293425,
0.4599789679,
0.511811614,
-0.2394475639,
-0.8729125261,
-0.2646823227,
0.035696622,
-0.6524454951,
-0.6596887708,
0.3197268546,
0.1193309501,
0.5614712834,
0.0487338156,
-0.1668705642,
0.5490986705,
-0.4366140664,
1.2204393148,
0.138647452,
-0.7032138705,
0.3477584422,
-0.3011561334,
0.1149106622,
0.6709975004,
0.2134314328,
-0.2396568954,
-0.3708900511,
-0.6405608654,
-0.810233593,
0.4560601115,
0.1955702007,
0.2898297012,
-0.140144974,
0.5626379251,
0.1496207118,
0.3303751945,
-0.4775833488,
-0.2765749097,
-0.0320676155,
-0.0453432165,
0.1911126226,
-0.7164708376,
0.2030626535,
-0.0849184766,
0.7324568033,
0.1438560039,
0.2800795734,
0.101685904,
0.1535092145,
-0.0595459975,
0.4341829419,
0.5692121387,
1.0544006824,
-0.3632524014,
0.0157667398,
0.2339441776,
-0.6028127074,
0.3253543377,
-0.1573715061,
-0.128989622,
0.055484727,
0.1532374471,
0.5007749796,
-0.3812747002,
-0.5870597959,
0.6782361269,
-0.349327594,
0.0070154555,
-0.200065285,
0.0581173934,
-0.2572065294,
0.0120817805,
0.5707522631,
-0.1037248075,
0.335368216,
-0.428067863,
0.1597946137,
0.3923916519,
-0.3745634854,
-0.2565362453,
0.5629127622,
0.296338737,
-0.621008873,
0.6353276968,
-0.4111235738,
-0.5572576523,
0.3917886317,
0.3242881,
1.0062030554,
-0.4380813539,
0.2972350121,
0.2965379953,
0.1127821729,
0.0095148869,
0.3971656859,
0.0001468442,
-0.5941217542,
-0.8496522903,
-1.1780869961,
-0.8919253349,
-0.0137768891,
-0.7666967511,
0.1145705581,
-0.2044523805,
-0.5272268653,
-0.1785941422,
0.0228477716,
-0.8351020217,
0.4044407308,
0.0027020725,
0.5500870347,
-0.5695232153,
0.4217690825,
0.942196846,
-0.6490780711,
-0.6562082171,
-0.2282076925,
-0.3195933998,
-0.650482893,
0.8646562099,
-0.0758921281,
-0.3917825222,
-0.1445556134,
-0.5336213708,
-0.5931135416,
0.8679583669,
0.2831457555,
-0.1463542879,
0.1484838426,
-0.0573248006,
0.9699457288,
0.070313625,
0.763640523,
0.5881549716,
0.2765501142,
0.1413032711,
-1.1167860031,
-0.4615906179,
-0.2106720656,
0.0198759921,
0.0480735339,
-0.695258677,
0.5918989778,
-0.0589290187,
-0.1388351023,
0.1057922691,
0.7491592169,
0.3892787099,
0.3758891821,
0.2073551565,
0.5940790772,
0.6465972066,
-0.1108295023,
1.328299284,
-0.1313279122,
0.4940983653,
0.9279451966,
-0.2816039026,
1.0949921608,
0.4071415663,
-0.3078032732,
0.4815343022,
0.5563972592,
0.3658747673,
0.3586696386,
0.2789187431,
-0.3753887117,
-0.3442463875,
-0.3674235344,
-0.0330449529,
0.5553488135,
0.3869675994,
-0.1043178812,
-0.1541033834,
-0.0884774998,
-0.1465752125,
0.3542774916,
-0.4432429671,
0.8701781034,
0.1836367548,
-0.8022100329,
0.7452498078,
-0.0677200556,
0.4701272845,
-0.2596482933,
-0.3567555845,
-0.353671968,
0.1396032721,
-0.3777807355,
-1.2228232622,
0.0952534899,
0.4514236152,
-0.3194255233,
-0.271554172,
0.7396582961,
-0.1575249732,
-0.4623131752,
0.1705699265,
0.670394361,
0.423430562,
0.3110652566,
-0.7018660307,
0.1357005537,
-0.0328844711,
-0.5162369609,
0.2307763994,
0.2603960633,
0.1195392758,
0.6535679698,
0.5596694946,
0.32220456,
0.0270473398,
0.0798997506,
0.6624789834,
-0.4345263541,
0.0038405971,
-0.6900687218,
0.5606995225,
-0.25025931,
-0.1786551028,
0.9403494,
0.5472018123,
0.7516170144,
0.1464745998,
0.7830955982,
0.0638524592,
0.9387246966,
-0.2873645425,
0.6062090993,
-0.4318772852,
0.2371800691,
-0.2940554321,
-1.1856927872,
-0.0546878986,
0.5169740915,
-0.3867581487,
0.2446015775,
0.3147496879,
0.5485027432,
0.0533267744,
-0.4406316578,
0.5159576535,
0.0283788014,
0.6541790962,
0.2751556337,
1.1148688793,
-0.4036535025,
0.5350891948,
0.1752113849,
-0.3766982555,
-0.2021743208,
-0.6988830566,
-0.6763799787,
-0.3140742183,
-0.2731489837,
-0.6971648335,
0.0467249379,
0.7921449542,
0.3040682673,
-0.5245420337,
-0.1947810054,
0.2334723175,
0.179747656,
-0.001722416,
-0.2916153967,
0.2728742361,
-0.4886970818,
-0.5833236575,
0.3746804595,
0.2560451627,
-0.2695719898,
-0.4550650716,
-0.097029835,
0.0601628646,
0.2967701852,
0.8629322648,
0.259386003,
-0.6257420182,
-0.6182462573,
0.1396431178,
-0.3642918766,
0.0116569912,
0.3879782557,
-0.8308688998,
0.8669974804,
0.6893933415,
0.7239399552,
0.2494057566,
0.6408230662,
0.4277243614,
-0.5685725212,
-0.3737328947,
0.466565907,
0.0452078804,
0.5969916582,
-0.179812029,
0.5733478069,
-0.1044442505,
-1.1368399858,
-0.9912396073,
0.1402962208,
-0.9933932424,
0.1311704963,
1.3894503117,
0.0137151023,
-0.1938616186,
-0.0448448621,
-0.4680828452,
-0.0438558497,
-0.3529718518,
0.8383841515,
0.689239502,
-0.3073190153,
0.0801685974,
-0.6468943357,
0.322755307,
0.1824132055,
-0.6542767882,
-0.0933880731,
0.7133554816,
0.0986251831,
0.4025864303,
0.7054722309,
-0.1653809696,
0.444822073,
-0.1803482026,
0.3229486048,
-0.0444426537,
-0.0848846808,
-0.4037585258,
0.2053134739,
0.7170131207,
-0.1261315793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18060v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18060v1 | AdaZeta: Adaptive Zeroth-Order Tensor-Train Adaption for Memory-Efficient Large Language Models Fine-Tuning | 2024-06-26T04:33:13 | 2024-06-26T04:33:13 | Yifan Yang, Kai Zhen, Ershad Banijamal, Athanasios Mouchtaris, Zheng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) has achieved remarkable performance
across various natural language processing tasks, yet it demands more and more
memory as model sizes keep growing. To address this issue, the recently
proposed Memory-efficient Zeroth-order (MeZO) methods attempt to fine-tune LLMs
using only forward passes, thereby avoiding the need for a backpropagation
graph. However, significant performance drops and a high risk of divergence
have limited their widespread adoption. In this paper, we propose the Adaptive
Zeroth-order Tensor-Train Adaption (AdaZeta) framework, specifically designed
to improve the performance and convergence of the ZO methods. To enhance
dimension-dependent ZO estimation accuracy, we introduce a fast-forward,
low-parameter tensorized adapter. To tackle the frequently observed divergence
issue in large-scale ZO fine-tuning tasks, we propose an adaptive query number
schedule that guarantees convergence. Detailed theoretical analysis and
extensive experimental results on Roberta-Large and Llama-2-7B models
substantiate the efficacy of our AdaZeta framework in terms of accuracy, memory
efficiency, and convergence speed. | [
-0.3672164679,
-0.7832676768,
0.548828125,
0.5572279692,
-0.3328597844,
-0.0892189741,
-0.3345906138,
-0.427783221,
0.2347858995,
0.3232873678,
-0.5167664886,
-0.4526380897,
-0.4264219701,
0.1054963171,
0.1515730917,
0.6062130332,
0.0262603592,
0.1075285673,
0.3492800295,
-0.3217845559,
-0.9025939703,
-0.0777895004,
-0.7659514546,
-0.0050757839,
0.5398467183,
0.6477752924,
0.6861968637,
0.6798083186,
0.2291654944,
0.3237723112,
-0.1656476557,
0.3000381887,
-0.4204191864,
0.4302997887,
-0.1444180161,
-0.7631420493,
-0.9238415956,
-0.4870503247,
0.8344556093,
0.5059391856,
-0.3471189141,
0.0756985247,
-0.2761769295,
0.80946666,
-0.8319252729,
0.0473432913,
-0.7404149175,
-0.0536181927,
0.0333072506,
-0.2245254815,
-0.3493767977,
-0.287315011,
-0.0557681173,
-0.6234270334,
0.285487473,
-0.1182818934,
0.5091845989,
0.3071825504,
0.0769131929,
-0.1270171255,
-0.6716237664,
0.6517856717,
-0.8481656313,
0.5156434178,
0.1732560694,
0.2355974317,
-0.2409864366,
-0.455596,
-0.4272033572,
0.0518380962,
0.4959895313,
0.1224951968,
-0.2486190796,
0.0474688485,
0.0480145812,
0.293528229,
-0.704056263,
0.5807762146,
-0.2241222411,
0.1065750122,
0.4641615748,
0.5859159231,
0.303008914,
0.4294491708,
-0.2244792283,
-0.0595511086,
-0.7786289454,
-0.2491152883,
0.2713033855,
0.5715806484,
0.0096399188,
0.0332124718,
-0.7657188773,
0.9466570616,
0.0433886088,
0.3829336762,
0.2767732441,
-0.2076145411,
-0.31052652,
0.2729547322,
0.7081730366,
0.2594235539,
0.2975588143,
-0.3478778005,
-0.1602019668,
-0.0913818479,
0.3056886196,
-1.3715988398,
-0.1852423549,
0.1767561138,
-0.007026155,
-0.0929935426,
-0.4750575721,
-0.9454565048,
-0.252004385,
-0.1429825723,
0.5619540215,
-0.4079391062,
-0.2870511711,
0.4991272092,
0.2926044762,
0.0970335454,
0.6261842847,
-1.2382467985,
0.2466477603,
0.628764987,
1.2038091421,
0.1328849047,
-0.5216127634,
-0.7705444098,
-0.0818242878,
-0.7506513,
0.8223688602,
-0.4238366485,
-0.0631802231,
-0.1907233596,
0.0206962693,
-0.2500635684,
-0.4706092775,
0.4757849574,
-0.9193228483,
-0.1276356876,
-0.1678011864,
-0.3598453104,
-0.3289909959,
0.1984627843,
-0.514282763,
0.643797636,
0.1601756662,
-0.1247293949,
0.2584237456,
-0.7940738797,
-0.3680866659,
-0.1761596352,
0.2165142,
-0.5051056743,
0.2694577277,
0.2700967789,
0.6127206683,
-0.3577345312,
-0.1187245995,
-0.454647541,
-0.6354525089,
-0.07818681,
-0.4554672241,
0.7255194783,
0.3484367728,
-0.1716017723,
0.3429653943,
-0.9909175038,
0.0211086962,
0.1839893013,
-0.3710997403,
-0.4898971021,
-0.003914448,
-0.1941821426,
0.0198616255,
0.1453111768,
-0.4795985222,
0.3019018173,
-0.5335205793,
0.582089901,
0.7976928949,
-0.2010591179,
0.5097818375,
-0.0621709898,
0.4379162788,
0.0889096037,
-0.0296697766,
-0.2551333606,
-0.4029426575,
-0.6923684478,
-0.3285649717,
0.3818356395,
0.3527897,
-0.4206267297,
0.3051062822,
-0.7279465795,
-0.5753417015,
-0.4852028191,
0.3460965753,
0.161055088,
0.2973078191,
0.5647952557,
-0.2709295452,
-0.3590393364,
-0.4812524915,
-0.0201291461,
0.0328805186,
-0.1271745265,
0.2094003707,
0.1002011374,
-0.0900605321,
0.651037097,
-0.670555234,
-0.2711196244,
0.0466806777,
0.0909190252,
0.3404499888,
0.4340106249,
0.9117311835,
-0.536264956,
-0.5691509843,
0.0174351111,
-0.3916502595,
-0.0026695922,
0.1324397177,
-0.2140989304,
0.3125833273,
0.3100279868,
-0.4721364975,
-0.155276522,
0.5772891641,
-0.6423794031,
0.1797996461,
-0.4147860706,
-0.1086699814,
-1.1989389658,
-0.1749969721,
-0.1977394372,
-0.2232430428,
-0.7176914215,
-0.1687246263,
0.1951953471,
0.0551054813,
-0.0565986894,
0.4298446178,
-0.5274241567,
-0.0244823489,
-0.4759086072,
-0.0672674477,
0.0643944964,
0.4103241563,
-0.1593278646,
0.9834051132,
0.4244584143,
-0.8499147892,
0.2674250901,
0.3999047577,
-0.4005672634,
0.5151575208,
-0.3718699515,
0.3297368586,
-0.0226229578,
-0.1141919047,
-1.0009404421,
0.1656082422,
0.2237361819,
-0.5604482889,
0.4930654168,
-0.4536033571,
-0.2873796225,
0.1402825713,
-0.4551202953,
0.3272182643,
0.330743134,
-0.7019298077,
0.6191160083,
0.085462831,
-0.4438663721,
-0.6760537624,
-0.5300926566,
0.2604808509,
-0.1823599637,
-0.4444025457,
0.2541634738,
-0.2487851679,
0.0647897497,
-0.0839350298,
-0.0396721102,
-0.1744656116,
0.4386966825,
-0.1373839229,
0.2105937153,
-0.7992811799,
0.0151457069,
0.0913399756,
-0.0424956456,
-0.1867634207,
-0.2687476575,
0.8438043594,
-0.2292342931,
0.225406751,
-0.0992023274,
0.0012308634,
0.7920731902,
-0.2096693963,
0.8647292256,
0.6933681965,
-0.2046643943,
-0.3691625595,
-0.5283043385,
-0.0038941791,
-0.4701098502,
0.6762108207,
-0.4417240918,
-0.712343514,
0.6451026201,
0.1295001358,
0.0992388576,
0.2716733515,
0.8876420259,
0.3866772652,
0.8054761887,
0.460162282,
-0.4290391803,
0.8586294055,
-0.1495075673,
-0.0373781025,
-1.0257132053,
0.284966588,
-0.4748244584,
-0.3334965706,
-0.4565414488,
-0.2351509035,
-0.1126691476,
-0.0017724955,
-0.3765434921,
0.3784345388,
-0.2462954521,
0.3798505068,
0.3554469347,
0.0370225497,
0.4343219995,
0.0002729526,
0.2778248489,
0.2477495074,
-0.6735497713,
0.0355851613,
1.0201576948,
0.1416924447,
0.806990087,
0.35019961,
0.3110021651,
0.129631564,
0.2930847704,
-0.9143348932,
0.341848284,
-0.2630007863,
-0.4421355724,
-0.5930228829,
-0.4954015315,
-0.950094223,
0.6499657035,
0.0196613297,
-0.6768596768,
0.5224245787,
0.0821285173,
-0.7292568684,
0.3046587408,
-0.8032072783,
0.6730818152,
-0.1143612787,
-0.586381197,
-0.422662884,
-0.3260588944,
0.0517259799,
0.0440978557,
-0.1474189311,
-0.568736136,
-0.1925537437,
0.6686164737,
-0.2937389016,
0.7285447121,
-0.4007756412,
-0.155635342,
0.08349628,
0.2657586932,
0.5637660623,
-0.0091524795,
-0.3380854726,
0.1999623179,
-0.0699658021,
-0.4174115062,
-0.5796688795,
0.8270893693,
-0.7118583322,
-0.4551791251,
-0.1189848855,
-0.841147244,
-0.5315961242,
0.4851519167,
-0.127859816,
0.4457084239,
-0.1454232484,
0.2435547113,
0.6199807525,
-0.0592680089,
0.5138061643,
1.047059536,
0.0607391596,
-0.5848119855,
1.0738266706,
0.4111890793,
0.1300597042,
0.4881086349,
0.1716120988,
-0.1923019588,
-1.0597029924,
-0.9146450162,
0.0187673122,
-0.4109092951,
-0.5380099416,
-0.4044283926,
0.1191439629,
-0.3626708388,
0.0731096715,
-0.6288781762,
-0.3750308752,
-0.3387348354,
0.0570713915,
0.7823056579,
0.2982700169,
0.0647934526,
0.4536499381,
-0.6804372072,
0.2399271131,
0.1610485017,
0.8378868699,
0.0846258849,
-0.7747985721,
-0.3945464492,
-0.0694709718,
-0.0584363267,
-0.4353598952,
0.3152120709,
0.3000154197,
0.2385539263,
0.3464318514,
0.0922434554,
0.8703107238,
-0.6915342808,
0.1169978604,
-0.0728282258,
-0.5424109697,
0.2398515791,
-0.5513914227,
0.1792700291,
0.6026760936,
0.14338018,
-0.3296602666,
0.0929883197,
-0.2154176831,
-0.8533155322,
0.9368074536,
-0.0465917699,
0.441015929,
0.2224879861,
0.5884330273,
-0.1355618984,
0.0056375456,
-0.1619239897,
-0.0619571693,
-0.1201010942,
-0.4263011217,
-0.3205132782,
-0.4517658055,
0.2195931226,
-0.0165390782,
0.6926302314,
-0.5240367651,
0.1996789277,
0.1100581214,
-0.2221631855,
-0.3570812643,
0.3315921724,
0.7694903016,
0.7662598491,
-0.4755433202,
-0.1911768764,
0.4629447758,
-0.7224971652,
0.1027979255,
0.3115679622,
-0.3479410112,
-0.0932828486,
-0.0855281204,
1.0425229073,
0.3759077191,
-0.6534519792,
0.2417703718,
-0.2694005668,
-0.0507180579,
-0.0465067513,
0.3579689264,
0.2120068818,
0.4344658852,
0.0983445123,
-0.0050941641,
0.1329634935,
-0.3842662573,
-0.1288809329,
0.3850711584,
-0.3644726872,
-0.4950253963,
0.629488647,
-0.0369607285,
-0.2609019876,
0.5259862542,
0.2467333227,
-0.2368150055,
0.479728967,
0.6354982257,
0.9122892618,
-0.656336844,
-0.2492614686,
0.3124315441,
0.1397295147,
-0.2968397737,
0.3813548088,
-0.0957417041,
-1.0067692995,
-0.4498152137,
-0.7580331564,
-0.41759637,
0.1342251897,
-0.6705411673,
0.1488648653,
-0.7286750078,
-0.0137658529,
0.0101742856,
0.0843890086,
-0.2735243738,
0.2227656245,
0.1165539101,
0.972455442,
-0.6244017482,
0.9338943362,
0.6388530731,
-0.2923896313,
-0.4889760911,
-0.0774875805,
-0.4691777825,
-1.0419999361,
0.0344802663,
0.0244785137,
-0.3350070119,
0.4311969578,
-0.1622488052,
-0.9249191284,
1.2343025208,
0.7068458796,
-0.6539541483,
0.0535533503,
-0.1718408465,
0.5513177514,
-0.1430025548,
0.092287153,
0.5553576946,
0.1474950314,
0.067892313,
-0.6081089973,
0.2194061279,
-0.2123332322,
0.2268711925,
0.424228847,
-1.0128496885,
0.7637873888,
-0.2387180179,
0.1224644706,
0.254340142,
0.7275690436,
0.0888815522,
0.0445286036,
0.5594863892,
0.5419792533,
0.6197192073,
0.0509466454,
0.6801991463,
-0.2647721469,
0.3589183986,
1.180133462,
-0.2473145723,
1.0372915268,
0.21980685,
-0.233383432,
0.3570454717,
0.5169606209,
-0.1162556857,
0.4722448587,
-0.0236827396,
-0.1287866086,
-0.1857011765,
0.2067174762,
-0.3600288033,
0.4278579652,
0.4551073611,
-0.1670556664,
-0.3195990622,
-0.3151124418,
0.1486553997,
-0.2523596883,
-0.5582424998,
0.7959679365,
-0.026939949,
-0.4813416004,
0.8295195103,
0.1373178065,
0.5583937168,
-0.4796591997,
-0.000832665,
-0.3938696086,
0.6690986753,
-0.0028246201,
-0.4159899652,
0.1400943398,
-0.0842637122,
-0.2209543437,
0.1771503687,
0.5058370829,
-0.3413753808,
-0.4168682098,
0.4239031076,
0.3354116678,
-0.3096241355,
-0.2174933255,
-0.5556331277,
0.0055095037,
-0.4256377518,
-0.554285109,
0.6024104953,
0.5098785162,
-0.0755027011,
0.5737590194,
0.6143556237,
0.1682694107,
0.2444889098,
0.1065995991,
0.7141317725,
-0.581350565,
-0.7052130103,
-1.0594265461,
-0.0376647636,
0.2894695699,
-0.1894322485,
0.5271924734,
0.5960896015,
0.5877682567,
-0.0413994417,
0.3968433738,
0.0649134219,
0.330178529,
-0.7613407969,
0.8122659326,
-0.6277191043,
0.1809998751,
-0.053933803,
-0.7821110487,
-0.5000092983,
0.5404177308,
-0.3960754871,
0.0149734458,
0.1377566457,
0.7876010537,
-0.2337275445,
-0.0543624833,
0.46464926,
0.701743722,
0.2932622433,
0.5583234429,
0.6254110336,
-0.5667963624,
0.4774565101,
-0.1042510867,
-0.0763750523,
-0.4753095806,
-0.5695118904,
-0.6477717161,
-0.3234896958,
-0.0379375704,
-0.3183131218,
0.3800772727,
0.924808681,
0.5492947102,
-0.9189023972,
-0.1989562064,
-0.1950379461,
0.0238556303,
-0.1544764042,
-0.1462179869,
0.5405737162,
-0.6925480962,
-0.9706354141,
0.5233612061,
0.4200617969,
-0.1349571645,
0.0913234651,
-0.0341474675,
-0.0794286877,
0.0304096602,
0.619261384,
0.4086633921,
-0.198621124,
-0.1387183666,
-0.0423256457,
0.1202413887,
0.5486999154,
0.5868529677,
-0.5446266532,
0.5504743457,
0.5321837664,
0.8382591605,
0.4375075102,
-0.0116311368,
0.723828733,
-0.2496476918,
0.2816040218,
0.0562866069,
0.4657450616,
0.266979605,
-0.3560062349,
0.5692139268,
0.1357352287,
-0.2702105343,
-0.8933466077,
-0.1276270747,
-0.8919565082,
-0.241365388,
0.9245805144,
-0.1121039465,
-0.2559086084,
-0.0877967551,
0.0078035062,
0.2233067304,
-0.3363598883,
0.9456130862,
0.3768858314,
-0.0340082385,
-0.1373354048,
-0.7135581374,
0.2733652592,
0.5919998288,
-0.6131265759,
0.40844962,
0.3092702329,
0.6773875952,
-0.0367886834,
0.7005038261,
-0.0600962974,
0.4302342236,
-0.0701887682,
-0.1575418264,
-0.349322468,
-0.3998862505,
-0.5748082995,
0.0108242584,
0.376383692,
-0.3454283774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18616v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18616v1 | Towards Large Language Model Aided Program Refinement | 2024-06-26T04:29:27 | 2024-06-26T04:29:27 | Yufan Cai, Zhe Hou, Xiaokun Luan, David Miguel Sanan Baena, Yun Lin, Jun Sun, Jin Song Dong | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, K.6.3 | Program refinement involves correctness-preserving transformations from
formal high-level specification statements into executable programs.
Traditional verification tool support for program refinement is highly
interactive and lacks automation. On the other hand, the emergence of large
language models (LLMs) enables automatic code generations from informal natural
language specifications. However, code generated by LLMs is often unreliable.
Moreover, the opaque procedure from specification to code provided by LLM is an
uncontrolled black box. We propose LLM4PR, a tool that combines formal program
refinement techniques with informal LLM-based methods to (1) transform the
specification to preconditions and postconditions, (2) automatically build
prompts based on refinement calculus, (3) interact with LLM to generate code,
and finally, (4) verify that the generated code satisfies the conditions of
refinement calculus, thus guaranteeing the correctness of the code. We have
implemented our tool using GPT4, Coq, and Coqhammer, and evaluated it on the
HumanEval and EvalPlus datasets. | [
-0.370315671,
-0.7125856876,
0.5996789336,
0.2367937714,
-0.1318839788,
0.2308848202,
-0.535717845,
-0.4308054447,
-0.3181712329,
0.6853678226,
-0.4875693321,
-0.5748105645,
-0.1813283861,
0.4253320992,
-0.1058519781,
0.7865331769,
-0.4637891352,
-0.1169004366,
-0.192628324,
0.1338090152,
-0.3555738032,
-0.4383259416,
-0.4189817905,
-0.4570242763,
0.0843857899,
0.459874779,
0.428519249,
0.2469306737,
0.4411408305,
0.4073679447,
0.4082371891,
0.3461628556,
-0.5973693728,
0.0485002808,
-0.1378735453,
-0.3354478776,
-0.4392613173,
0.005197091,
0.4429874122,
0.2784798741,
-0.2223442495,
0.3510007858,
0.2018564939,
0.3743011057,
-0.5070655346,
0.2443128079,
-0.6734358072,
-0.0979277343,
-0.2315440178,
-0.4937909245,
-0.3790061772,
-0.6147504449,
-0.2705989182,
-0.5028142333,
0.2344265878,
0.1954214275,
0.9998791814,
0.3922759295,
-0.2135394365,
-0.1662878394,
-0.9030379057,
0.8418337107,
-1.0522896051,
0.3773352206,
0.2378659993,
0.4726717472,
-0.4876340032,
-0.886085093,
-0.6379109621,
-0.5536499023,
-0.0324905626,
-0.2728717327,
-0.0621221513,
0.2726765871,
0.6691173911,
0.5722013116,
-0.5104087591,
0.0862048715,
-0.4659069777,
-0.4637751877,
0.6692658067,
0.0225150045,
0.2168352157,
0.1343287975,
-0.128676638,
0.22276932,
-1.1178348064,
-0.1426643282,
0.4519655704,
0.1228546351,
-0.0797400102,
0.5218298435,
-0.1936414093,
0.7058307528,
-0.0253666174,
-0.2394304127,
0.2917305827,
-0.4708244503,
-0.2939581573,
-0.1659099758,
0.6093559861,
0.2609541714,
0.2925784886,
0.0399663225,
-0.5983713269,
0.0399085097,
0.2381788045,
-0.8566867709,
-0.3574051559,
0.351999104,
-0.2493105531,
-0.1508962363,
-0.0637451112,
-0.4286405444,
-0.0948962122,
-0.7157974839,
0.2694723904,
-0.310236454,
-0.1591445506,
0.2607772052,
0.2579981387,
0.3974873722,
0.5408661962,
-0.5289420485,
0.1674148291,
0.8642200232,
0.4931107461,
0.2542245388,
0.0028330865,
-0.6500118971,
0.1630762815,
-0.4681106508,
0.4731345177,
-0.4819782376,
-0.1728297472,
0.086668469,
0.0768752098,
0.4123625159,
-0.4743372798,
0.5329309702,
-0.5261372924,
0.1461316198,
-0.130329892,
-0.423279494,
-0.1303203702,
0.5488052964,
-0.4319025576,
1.2509537935,
0.2589555383,
-0.5795371532,
0.1377799064,
-0.6379651427,
-0.188233301,
0.2338047624,
-0.4456689656,
-0.5177585483,
-0.0758342668,
0.2367342412,
0.321739614,
-0.4851576686,
0.3594555259,
-0.3971853256,
-0.4665593207,
-0.0680897683,
-0.1441637427,
0.5987963676,
0.2267905325,
-0.4548677206,
0.3081023097,
-0.7501701713,
0.2924262583,
-0.0415534414,
-0.3379650712,
-0.0025001729,
-0.3007057905,
-0.356357038,
0.3436052203,
0.4471178353,
-0.576284647,
0.4436538517,
-0.4341796041,
0.5680024028,
0.598120153,
0.0617868565,
0.2920560837,
-0.1873961389,
0.743160665,
-0.3860293329,
0.1451734453,
-0.1907759905,
-0.3447723985,
-0.7754402757,
-0.2239171416,
0.3143030703,
0.4713715613,
-0.8805451393,
0.5640884042,
0.0827911049,
-0.3153465986,
-0.5098865628,
0.2898064852,
0.3530091941,
0.455943197,
0.2763684392,
-0.0756825954,
-0.8064860106,
-0.9185869694,
0.2126387656,
-0.1314993799,
-0.1688958704,
0.2003444433,
0.3994425535,
-0.4861332476,
0.7281374931,
-0.3368843794,
0.1134415194,
-0.177529797,
0.3231813312,
0.200639233,
0.4774687886,
0.260258317,
-0.3191991448,
-0.1529812366,
-0.093693465,
-0.4049981236,
-0.701616466,
-0.0191896427,
-0.1088678688,
0.1996839643,
0.8934659958,
-0.2353792936,
0.2814706862,
0.7052640319,
-0.0369109362,
0.9331037402,
-0.5067050457,
0.1214236617,
-0.6838095784,
0.4509315193,
-0.2115130872,
-0.472863555,
-0.3155533075,
0.4280341864,
0.1634144783,
-0.2578548491,
-0.1484565139,
0.4446668327,
-0.7017585635,
-0.225953415,
-0.2503927946,
-0.0427810922,
0.1641957164,
0.2584260106,
-0.0531851277,
0.7237046957,
0.4779529572,
-0.5280907154,
0.4949620366,
-0.0850065425,
-0.2844425738,
0.3208054602,
-0.722335875,
0.4009431303,
-0.0589518771,
0.4376019239,
-0.8864344954,
-0.1118197069,
0.1904762834,
-0.1118469462,
0.2810741961,
-0.3547323942,
-0.6504436731,
-0.5293601751,
-0.2694872022,
0.2899241447,
0.5762705803,
-0.3977915645,
0.5829731226,
-0.0750216693,
-0.3253054023,
-0.5030788779,
-0.4450808764,
0.1313857585,
0.1423748285,
-0.7672966123,
0.3595885634,
-0.2746802866,
-0.3460530639,
-0.2030310631,
0.1299276054,
0.0798766389,
-0.0356195457,
0.3531882763,
0.4170125723,
-0.2560808957,
0.034988448,
-0.1397925466,
-0.1124949977,
-0.0515046194,
-0.1670584828,
0.5764814615,
-0.2665282488,
-0.5090652108,
-0.3366329372,
0.0716272146,
0.5653527975,
-0.7770234942,
0.1256150454,
0.6510498524,
-0.1635364443,
-0.5667604208,
-0.7433493137,
-0.2803539336,
-0.5432898998,
0.1707850695,
-0.4418388009,
-1.0418795347,
0.404796809,
-0.3418586552,
0.4720531702,
0.1002954841,
0.7467079163,
0.4629871845,
0.8790589571,
0.707904458,
0.1782657504,
0.2160497755,
-0.1562849134,
0.3252750337,
-0.6411673427,
-0.1358062774,
-0.7079509497,
-0.2386622876,
-0.3259119093,
-0.6407011151,
0.0196162313,
0.0878926069,
-0.3678778112,
0.1791141182,
-0.445810467,
0.5925406814,
0.3262915313,
-0.1733707339,
0.2161552012,
-0.1683858037,
-0.3663161695,
0.0446753465,
-0.3348211944,
-0.7465008497,
1.0276632309,
0.594314158,
0.6855315566,
0.0303269643,
0.9608299732,
-0.0054951888,
0.7133043408,
-0.6102707982,
0.6754204631,
0.1954444498,
-0.3598159254,
-0.2380213439,
-0.5524535179,
-0.588639617,
-0.1281997412,
-0.1173305362,
-0.499540329,
-0.0034269821,
0.4127883613,
-0.4981725514,
-0.0223178547,
-0.5867313147,
0.7303731441,
-0.1454130113,
-0.4673888087,
-0.2231773734,
-0.3448129892,
0.6473034024,
-0.3137162924,
0.2772003114,
-0.3063134253,
-0.009844251,
0.2757564187,
-0.7228990197,
0.6221263409,
-0.2652629316,
-0.5825703144,
0.2843273878,
0.4501418769,
0.8343326449,
0.0576618053,
-0.228463605,
-0.1005894989,
-0.0421444289,
-0.2122787237,
-0.6249621511,
0.7202426791,
-0.5327749848,
-0.657114625,
-0.0267531965,
-0.341881007,
-0.2494671494,
0.3136983812,
-0.0141828498,
0.4481783807,
-0.0141998287,
-0.0838683546,
0.5183491707,
-0.3665246665,
0.1900644898,
0.6805465221,
-0.5246930122,
-0.1480956078,
0.4567270875,
-0.2255241722,
0.0943448395,
0.1822929233,
0.2312692702,
-0.30465734,
-0.7568976283,
-0.1973706037,
0.2324792892,
-0.581982255,
-0.352609694,
0.0135123236,
-0.131308198,
-0.4023703635,
-0.2120891809,
-0.2446713895,
-0.1622617692,
0.0747223496,
-0.0623313561,
0.2045722753,
0.7210817337,
0.0002671878,
-0.0549640656,
-0.9182591438,
0.3426671922,
0.2051008195,
0.4351509809,
-0.2412381917,
-0.5539591312,
-0.0212585367,
-0.0372952223,
-0.2821826935,
-0.5250964165,
0.2322865129,
0.1376162767,
0.438200295,
0.3780777752,
0.1678185016,
0.5318388343,
-0.7733864188,
0.7237673998,
0.0924719945,
-0.8653416634,
0.3623838425,
-0.2471476793,
0.3522008657,
0.5448149443,
0.2178893387,
-0.4618501663,
-0.6302893162,
-0.5147002339,
-0.6131743789,
0.4180704951,
0.0229332354,
-0.0160692781,
0.183190912,
0.5528615713,
0.0790020227,
0.1312105358,
-0.6014974117,
0.2538819313,
-0.0866723433,
-0.2305577993,
-0.0400348119,
-0.2836076915,
-0.274399817,
-0.129465729,
0.7443406582,
-0.1323096305,
0.0195632838,
0.0294690896,
0.122415185,
-0.2375216484,
0.3976103067,
0.6027609706,
0.9007331729,
-0.2068827003,
0.3232506514,
-0.0399539098,
-0.150899455,
0.2403276414,
0.1554328948,
-0.2019632757,
-0.1163357496,
0.2660771906,
0.4312684536,
0.2041109353,
-0.6969122291,
0.4793850183,
-0.0897636414,
-0.3107658029,
-0.3503690362,
0.0919992775,
-0.0144606885,
0.2735154033,
0.0129771512,
-0.1428360939,
-0.0243322235,
-0.4912528694,
0.3893347681,
0.268869102,
0.0839034766,
-0.3402663171,
0.3948501945,
0.5308350921,
-0.1989187449,
0.7246167064,
-0.474555105,
-0.442713201,
0.2307546139,
0.5834997296,
0.8095590472,
-0.3377780616,
0.0494602248,
0.5767763853,
0.385212183,
-0.1353005022,
0.5365997553,
0.0599394403,
-0.6349301338,
-0.9084038734,
-0.7041240931,
-0.3027531803,
0.488655597,
-0.1125216484,
0.5142899156,
-0.8147917986,
-0.0906259343,
-0.1255518794,
-0.0326412953,
-0.5900275707,
-0.0412902422,
0.2516125441,
0.8734521866,
-0.6393169761,
0.8612160087,
0.621045053,
-0.2455385178,
-1.1331179142,
-0.0261822026,
0.0251587089,
-0.7645511627,
0.8070135713,
0.1734689772,
-0.2352578938,
-0.0148054175,
-0.8117439747,
-0.7445030212,
0.8722225428,
0.5338774323,
-0.9893716574,
-0.0993423015,
0.1359187812,
0.4875760972,
-0.1331493109,
0.1707831472,
0.4538137913,
0.6046958566,
0.2539316416,
-1.1582181454,
0.2647431195,
-0.2131473869,
0.0206718128,
0.3506628573,
-0.2167581469,
0.6684232354,
-0.2845306695,
-0.2061344534,
0.0709425211,
0.5352324247,
0.446097225,
-0.0653098896,
0.2558698654,
0.5864878297,
0.8427578211,
-0.0920317098,
0.8995333314,
-0.6297103167,
0.1336491704,
1.0674904585,
-0.5556098819,
0.8150784373,
0.3021697998,
-0.2069539726,
0.5562264323,
0.4002044797,
-0.1773219556,
0.0140521079,
0.7070707083,
-0.3401454985,
-0.1895942092,
0.2131033242,
-0.3214087784,
0.3231875896,
0.3472533226,
-0.243608892,
-0.3974252343,
-0.2586228848,
0.0062327553,
0.0232963134,
-0.4364513159,
0.4428190589,
0.1347399503,
-0.8492124677,
0.9012646079,
0.5670401454,
0.549559772,
-0.6910958886,
-0.2860155404,
-0.0199604183,
0.3558462858,
-0.4051738381,
-0.5545298457,
0.3172124922,
0.0152816596,
0.1808686256,
-0.2213514,
0.8629273176,
-0.5519990921,
-0.2493104786,
-0.0468693487,
0.2680034637,
0.1080729663,
-0.0389019921,
-0.8508040309,
0.2655103207,
0.1379050463,
-0.0178285334,
-0.044050429,
0.6140298247,
-0.0907480046,
0.6843400002,
0.7584950328,
0.1847341806,
0.0372238979,
0.299287796,
0.7526956797,
-0.3018710911,
-0.5024666786,
-0.7994942069,
0.3148590028,
0.032713078,
0.0517147444,
0.8695069551,
0.551641047,
0.6877605319,
-0.0774763897,
0.700309813,
0.125463888,
0.4153294265,
-0.7058007717,
0.3622526526,
-0.1765197515,
0.4929740727,
-0.1973187774,
-1.0717507601,
-0.3910497129,
0.5011299253,
-0.5732970834,
0.1101117581,
0.4707192481,
1.2101539373,
-0.0495174378,
-0.2925357819,
0.1551080644,
0.1746647358,
0.5197818875,
0.5394909978,
0.7808641195,
0.1071708351,
0.4691172838,
-0.0898373872,
-0.4922706783,
-0.3333395123,
-1.2358222008,
-0.7151024938,
-0.2247839272,
-0.5545723438,
-0.4364030063,
-0.1026802659,
1.1086958647,
0.6995994449,
-0.6597309113,
-0.3110274971,
-0.1971153319,
-0.2243633419,
0.0497715659,
-0.1935243309,
0.2181860507,
-0.4145425856,
-0.44965446,
0.4041555524,
0.3957228959,
0.0913013071,
-0.6488934755,
-0.3565861881,
0.2170279473,
0.1931665689,
0.497725606,
0.5336833,
-0.5953260064,
-0.3135857284,
-0.3671198785,
-0.0800796449,
0.0247797426,
1.0765771866,
-0.6388891339,
0.3487282693,
0.5007615089,
0.5145992637,
0.2658167183,
0.0230605733,
0.9120727777,
-1.0613707304,
0.1013771966,
0.3579401076,
0.5606984496,
0.407568574,
-0.185423255,
0.3368979692,
-0.0680804625,
-0.7108877897,
-0.777839601,
0.4552793503,
-0.5863041878,
-0.1738894731,
1.2791115046,
-0.2458313704,
-0.2320010066,
-0.3593084514,
-0.5333549976,
0.0431833938,
-0.2988623083,
0.6941971779,
0.6571173072,
-0.0641381219,
-0.4299510717,
-0.4477826655,
0.8466131091,
-0.0618945248,
-0.9317933321,
0.4325131476,
0.7326253057,
0.4471298754,
0.2292075157,
0.6677266359,
-0.4161040187,
0.1855514348,
-0.2429366112,
0.5582942367,
-0.4951915741,
-0.0972138494,
-0.2457969338,
0.0356876291,
0.4730557203,
0.3234965205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18049v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18049v1 | Improving Entity Recognition Using Ensembles of Deep Learning and Fine-tuned Large Language Models: A Case Study on Adverse Event Extraction from Multiple Sources | 2024-06-26T03:56:21 | 2024-06-26T03:56:21 | Yiming Li, Deepthi Viswaroopan, William He, Jianfu Li, Xu Zuo, Hua Xu, Cui Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Adverse event (AE) extraction following COVID-19 vaccines from text data is
crucial for monitoring and analyzing the safety profiles of immunizations.
Traditional deep learning models are adept at learning intricate feature
representations and dependencies in sequential data, but often require
extensive labeled data. In contrast, large language models (LLMs) excel in
understanding contextual information, but exhibit unstable performance on named
entity recognition tasks, possibly due to their broad but unspecific training.
This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of LLMs and traditional deep
learning models in AE extraction, and to assess the impact of ensembling these
models on performance. In this study, we utilized reports and posts from the
VAERS (n=621), Twitter (n=9,133), and Reddit (n=131) as our corpora. Our goal
was to extract three types of entities: "vaccine", "shot", and "ae". We
explored and fine-tuned (except GPT-4) multiple LLMs, including GPT-2, GPT-3.5,
GPT-4, and Llama-2, as well as traditional deep learning models like RNN and
BioBERT. To enhance performance, we created ensembles of the three models with
the best performance. For evaluation, we used strict and relaxed F1 scores to
evaluate the performance for each entity type, and micro-average F1 was used to
assess the overall performance. The ensemble model achieved the highest
performance in "vaccine", "shot", and "ae" with strict F1-scores of 0.878,
0.930, and 0.925, respectively, along with a micro-average score of 0.903. In
conclusion, this study demonstrates the effectiveness and robustness of
ensembling fine-tuned traditional deep learning models and LLMs, for extracting
AE-related information. This study contributes to the advancement of biomedical
natural language processing, providing valuable insights into improving AE
extraction from text data for pharmacovigilance and public health surveillance. | [
-0.1322784573,
-0.8353970647,
0.4843840897,
-0.0810582042,
-0.258394897,
0.269551754,
-0.3930993378,
-0.9975061417,
0.2449658662,
0.389619112,
0.0481199734,
-0.607508719,
-0.7948063612,
0.3420264125,
-0.5022261739,
1.1480374336,
-0.1253173798,
0.0242898315,
-0.0452587232,
-0.0150126833,
-0.3275497258,
-0.5066722035,
-0.963501811,
-0.3150382638,
0.4815077186,
0.2818828225,
0.0422305353,
0.4355657101,
0.9031568766,
0.2905956805,
-0.0157685392,
0.3027636707,
-0.32294631,
0.3080427349,
-0.345166862,
-0.1290898323,
-0.3745020628,
-0.127980426,
0.5632287264,
0.2513930798,
-0.2087919712,
0.0396149755,
0.1630841643,
0.2987496555,
-0.7111756206,
-0.040531572,
-0.7458370924,
0.0784779862,
-0.216355592,
-0.1862492859,
-0.3501239121,
-0.0667507872,
0.5703963637,
-0.666746974,
0.1473960131,
-0.0802070796,
1.0779232979,
0.0563682504,
-0.2695129812,
-0.3187001944,
-0.7060157657,
0.6161782742,
-0.640329659,
0.2841014862,
0.1599145979,
0.0174905583,
-0.0928305835,
-0.8561071157,
-0.3404744267,
0.0407990664,
0.2031655908,
0.2108980864,
-0.5587126017,
0.1690727025,
0.0014943,
0.2576206326,
-0.3733595014,
0.7286300659,
-0.454631567,
-0.3743205667,
0.7294197679,
0.1672931612,
0.3922070563,
-0.1368589401,
-0.3005905747,
0.0189016499,
-0.7821102142,
0.1436237097,
-0.0296937488,
0.2558218837,
-0.1548090875,
0.4107445478,
-0.1361327916,
0.4451307058,
0.282487154,
-0.113886483,
0.2637380064,
-0.2650139928,
-0.5336881876,
0.2577502131,
0.9555485845,
0.1428937018,
0.1423874199,
-0.1893357635,
-0.1431746185,
-0.1616215706,
0.2896720767,
-1.0857616663,
-0.3147857189,
0.2556070983,
-0.5697309375,
-0.3990317285,
-0.0474435389,
-1.1406948566,
-0.6988663077,
-0.3271063268,
0.3079819679,
-0.6277654767,
-0.172894612,
0.0570046157,
-0.1403068006,
0.0183316953,
0.5612921119,
-0.7231461406,
0.2740158439,
0.7300349474,
0.7165284157,
-0.4393256605,
0.0623595566,
-0.6872348785,
0.0673696473,
-0.240086019,
0.9286147952,
-0.710771203,
-0.1901609451,
0.0554087982,
-0.0520831421,
-0.241261512,
-0.8230253458,
0.7133087516,
-0.4964402616,
-0.0675960556,
0.0747968405,
-0.7346768379,
-0.1750410795,
0.1707335562,
-0.5617954135,
0.34477368,
-0.5370482206,
-0.581109643,
0.6048057079,
-0.3370001614,
-0.6665303707,
0.1621757597,
-0.5083824992,
-0.6757227182,
0.2495709211,
0.5068449974,
0.7711576223,
-0.3700850904,
0.3777221143,
-0.4790989459,
-0.1556061953,
0.097909674,
-0.5363771319,
0.4467193186,
0.0760331973,
-0.178239122,
0.0360107832,
-1.0121266842,
-0.3096820712,
0.1683242321,
-0.628162384,
-0.395391345,
-0.0320521854,
-0.0193749312,
0.1141972914,
-0.1180320084,
-0.4180085063,
0.1748637408,
-0.6550819874,
0.4654067159,
0.5655506253,
0.4983127713,
0.4815554023,
0.0693543181,
0.3741155267,
0.2311708182,
-0.1578306258,
-0.0462336875,
-0.4381424785,
-0.5345025063,
-0.3971616328,
0.3963519335,
0.5699744821,
-0.6601391435,
0.3408278823,
-0.2045846283,
-0.413356781,
-0.6128661633,
0.0467200391,
0.2607357204,
0.5392405987,
0.4616429508,
-0.237595588,
-0.7103295922,
-0.7768056989,
-0.4355224669,
-0.1838519573,
-0.1009345874,
0.2366870344,
0.6327402592,
-0.4191992283,
0.4639105201,
-0.3926886022,
-0.1557378173,
-0.0558270998,
0.2494161725,
0.0374279507,
0.44774279,
0.3143412173,
-0.5456081629,
-0.0826133192,
0.3457377255,
-0.722649157,
0.156804502,
-0.0855818912,
0.1442259103,
0.1816003472,
0.3946540058,
-0.6897095442,
0.5274347067,
0.2418090701,
-0.0961676985,
0.4318334162,
-0.0470590442,
0.1267619431,
-1.1318479776,
0.1153679341,
0.4514380693,
-0.0314900838,
-0.7018362284,
-0.0636135638,
0.1147277653,
-0.0363985188,
-0.5582049489,
0.4843227863,
-0.3493785858,
0.2839297652,
0.0082154796,
-0.1840365678,
0.2879486978,
0.1292331219,
0.0347499326,
0.4251081645,
0.6210519671,
-0.762298584,
0.1667004675,
0.0224625356,
-0.494084239,
0.2523222268,
-0.4920121133,
0.0149208596,
-0.2868134081,
0.1761814803,
-0.4744959772,
-0.6561720371,
0.4153312445,
-0.2267763317,
0.759724915,
-0.0286359526,
-0.1944979578,
-0.2756328583,
-0.1378171593,
0.278809309,
0.1579619348,
-0.4318239689,
0.5818921924,
0.7317973375,
-0.2268119901,
-0.5577990413,
-0.6851652265,
0.1538448781,
-0.5460861921,
-0.2373351753,
0.5719168186,
0.3875063062,
-0.2505963147,
-0.0520128943,
-0.1410258263,
-0.2623644471,
0.1459549665,
0.1534436494,
0.2514928281,
-0.2808549404,
0.6303643584,
0.1635419279,
0.1424599588,
-0.1076436192,
-0.0558336116,
0.3100353181,
-0.1683473885,
-0.1049090475,
-0.7048805356,
0.4080094993,
0.5318466425,
-0.5151984692,
0.7799611688,
0.6862383485,
-1.0147711039,
0.1628937572,
-0.6245271564,
-0.2054315358,
-0.3319349885,
0.5383924842,
-0.0661646128,
-0.8493930697,
0.5331817269,
-0.1558678448,
-0.0692871809,
0.8287402391,
0.5114437938,
-0.0883904621,
0.7374907136,
0.4613720179,
-0.372877568,
0.4992352128,
-0.0678633824,
0.2460645139,
-0.7301641107,
-0.4246187806,
-0.5072367787,
0.0058288798,
-0.5567219853,
-0.1989656687,
0.3561861515,
0.1956102401,
-0.2240930051,
0.0670772195,
-0.462760359,
0.1797426939,
0.3014192879,
0.3395365179,
0.2024770975,
0.2108721286,
0.0876163319,
0.1557890773,
-0.6412382722,
-0.4848461449,
1.127730608,
0.6579161286,
0.716864109,
0.1406713724,
0.9272916913,
-0.0398848429,
0.1742215753,
-0.6679542065,
0.2322144657,
-0.4279312491,
-0.3820971549,
-0.1637325138,
-0.3794423342,
-1.2299246788,
0.0426398851,
-0.6773878932,
-1.0851255655,
0.6273952723,
-0.0650496259,
-1.0290855169,
0.0980701298,
-0.8442679644,
0.6869422793,
-0.1781198233,
-0.2560917735,
-0.2722565234,
-0.3784968555,
0.3548065126,
-0.246826306,
0.0391971767,
-0.0353855267,
-0.0289205834,
0.7947720885,
-0.1008684784,
0.8141738176,
0.3274638951,
-0.0209553018,
0.4110760093,
-0.2863464653,
0.5349863172,
0.4722535014,
-0.2100489438,
0.3953478038,
-0.1778805554,
0.0338341594,
-0.2135219574,
0.7719618678,
-0.7505726218,
-0.5670833588,
-0.3430999219,
-0.0886917636,
0.1573188454,
0.2871554196,
0.5242146254,
0.5515590906,
-0.3677744269,
0.2813082337,
0.7250030041,
-0.6304357052,
0.5286803842,
0.4567795694,
0.1766996384,
-0.450096935,
0.8762258291,
0.3437850177,
-0.1793360412,
0.5794657469,
0.0592451356,
-0.067368947,
-0.743971467,
-0.3930867612,
-0.0899472982,
-0.5380395055,
-0.607619226,
-1.0642391443,
-0.375063926,
-0.7427802086,
0.2931404412,
-0.3278691769,
-0.113964431,
-0.7363286614,
-0.2759112418,
0.2503891289,
0.6839579344,
0.0726881102,
-0.0975615457,
-0.9253684878,
0.2553117871,
0.1366087198,
0.449504137,
-0.0203809198,
-0.2171042711,
-0.261290282,
-0.1676695943,
-0.3709071577,
-1.0312312841,
0.398543328,
0.4360266328,
0.5562269688,
0.6979801655,
-0.1588135511,
0.7839463949,
-0.5399770141,
0.5147864223,
0.2804124355,
-0.6754614711,
0.7159405947,
-0.2032981068,
0.0412097052,
0.6460335851,
0.2182810009,
-0.2956228852,
-0.2866814137,
-0.5409075022,
-1.0363405943,
0.5126900077,
0.2418728322,
-0.2282782793,
-0.254873246,
0.4196274281,
0.0833977088,
0.0633740127,
-0.4811185002,
-0.0404496379,
0.3933650851,
-0.2068086565,
-0.110857971,
-0.2329274118,
-0.0845254138,
-0.2935463786,
0.6945040226,
0.2395350039,
0.2684338093,
0.4266698062,
-0.1323682815,
-0.1465181559,
0.3241335154,
0.5092546344,
0.2953075469,
-0.0313318819,
0.1433499008,
0.1886093467,
-0.600009799,
-0.0800150484,
0.5617284179,
0.0900954381,
-0.090222396,
0.6880480647,
0.7130216956,
0.0366133265,
-0.834203124,
0.2721483111,
-0.1493799537,
0.1747999489,
-0.1504125744,
0.0402773656,
-0.2276015729,
0.4502523839,
0.3338543773,
0.3406534791,
0.6092873216,
-0.3934473693,
0.3852280378,
0.2881164551,
-0.2159482539,
-0.1863513291,
0.3462395072,
0.2734146118,
-0.1816761494,
0.5511377454,
0.0703167617,
-0.1564046293,
0.8562738299,
0.4711548686,
0.7753708959,
-0.4234507084,
0.1461981088,
0.4197093546,
0.2772218883,
-0.1278085113,
-0.1648146808,
0.4218026102,
-0.7814546227,
-0.3856320083,
-0.5367043614,
-0.0883972198,
0.5506057739,
-0.6396830082,
0.3222705424,
-0.2689102888,
-0.2988826036,
0.5029924512,
-0.0370659046,
-1.0457376242,
0.2312956452,
0.3654597402,
0.7220137715,
-0.8152701259,
0.581692338,
0.8746817708,
-0.483494699,
-0.7351601124,
0.1260969639,
-0.0407087468,
-0.6500008702,
0.2576079965,
0.4491169453,
0.4298086762,
-0.3060826361,
-0.1432175487,
-0.8600302935,
0.9525647759,
0.3208223581,
-1.0242382288,
-0.0243531056,
0.0093484679,
0.7569693327,
-0.4487435222,
0.0483115502,
0.7033700943,
0.0767157897,
-0.255420804,
-0.8240844011,
0.0542285442,
-0.2266696692,
-0.304461509,
0.1896480173,
-0.2571391761,
0.5938174725,
-0.2055047154,
-0.339900285,
-0.1595591754,
0.5470523238,
0.3627552092,
0.7099378705,
0.0391040035,
0.5928341746,
1.1693193913,
0.0931524858,
1.0994794369,
0.0244199205,
0.2871321738,
1.0615110397,
-0.1985016614,
1.0224517584,
0.5571358204,
0.0960432068,
0.318764329,
0.7879639864,
0.0977622792,
0.5610800385,
0.02950418,
-0.2852542102,
-0.2402414083,
-0.1534240842,
-0.3639570177,
0.5937139392,
0.7650655508,
-0.781388402,
-0.1224932894,
0.3043353558,
-0.0940682814,
-0.2571345568,
-0.5099744201,
1.0360935926,
0.3017870784,
-0.6879451275,
0.2291528136,
0.0176719744,
0.4618373811,
0.0064993477,
-0.2317556441,
0.1693688184,
0.2796133757,
-0.2058506757,
-0.6040996909,
0.1538502425,
0.1404668689,
-0.093863599,
0.3572898805,
1.2102608681,
-0.4542115629,
-0.7421606183,
0.2817367017,
0.4013960063,
0.059230797,
-0.0960054025,
-0.7429087162,
0.1547199935,
-0.2020289749,
-0.328165859,
0.2360662222,
0.490932107,
-0.0358912759,
0.3475642204,
0.3753790855,
0.1861158013,
-0.1757824421,
0.1244677007,
0.7667387724,
-0.334621042,
-0.2075869441,
-1.2137988806,
0.4856649041,
-0.4421064854,
-0.3858198822,
0.3655372858,
0.570803225,
0.6277685761,
0.007680119,
0.7306181192,
0.2266362011,
0.3579875231,
-0.5773605108,
0.7125365138,
-0.4178235829,
0.3805857301,
-0.246791631,
-0.4030970335,
-0.549928546,
0.4145869911,
-0.4690365493,
-0.1740809828,
0.4099646211,
0.3988381326,
0.0992591083,
-0.0938696042,
0.0550863519,
0.3000750542,
0.5819071531,
0.5887337923,
0.6182543635,
-0.4885393381,
0.2829450071,
-0.1959674358,
-0.0923204422,
-0.4506549239,
-0.7456159592,
-0.8332867622,
-0.3722759187,
-0.5242197514,
-0.3039833307,
0.3787694871,
1.1239101887,
0.5496245027,
-1.020070076,
0.5399623513,
-0.12624681,
0.0888568759,
-0.1039586961,
-0.2416329682,
0.5197437406,
-0.2661924362,
-0.5552451015,
0.3810994923,
0.4992426932,
0.1317294687,
0.3034298718,
0.1689371467,
-0.2015732229,
-0.0814902708,
0.7698381543,
0.2367669195,
-0.7508431673,
-0.404674381,
-0.1625818163,
-0.2998772562,
-0.0406765044,
0.4672254622,
-0.6317567229,
0.4314127564,
0.3141567111,
1.0498250723,
0.2719923556,
-0.2065590173,
0.6537549496,
-0.5123624802,
-0.1302027702,
0.4456694126,
0.5492985249,
0.1895243675,
-0.6698718071,
0.3527540863,
0.0733903497,
-0.5210995674,
-0.7139661908,
0.0085853459,
-0.8231929541,
-0.277531594,
1.276196003,
-0.0452032909,
-0.0180484131,
-0.1537889242,
-0.0818256587,
0.5797935128,
-0.6639255881,
0.9214844108,
0.5822792649,
-0.2204168737,
-0.1933223754,
-0.5935959816,
0.5117744207,
0.1556536108,
-0.9506534338,
-0.376634717,
0.220291242,
0.2206424773,
0.1011009812,
0.4961351156,
-0.0930690914,
0.2739551663,
-0.3149063289,
0.0980882049,
0.2545083463,
-0.4536701441,
-0.7778615952,
0.2861883044,
-0.227023229,
-0.297560066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18045v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18045v2 | PharmaGPT: Domain-Specific Large Language Models for Bio-Pharmaceutical and Chemistry | 2024-06-26T03:43:09 | 2024-07-03T12:56:40 | Linqing Chen, Weilei Wang, Zilong Bai, Peng Xu, Yan Fang, Jie Fang, Wentao Wu, Lizhi Zhou, Ruiji Zhang, Yubin Xia, Chaobo Xu, Ran Hu, Licong Xu, Qijun Cai, Haoran Hua, Jing Sun, Jin Liu, Tian Qiu, Haowen Liu, Meng Hu, Xiuwen Li, Fei Gao, Yufu Wang, Lin Tie, Chaochao Wang, Jianping Lu, Cheng Sun, Yixin Wang, Shengjie Yang, Yuancheng Li, Lu Jin, Lisha Zhang, Fu Bian, Zhongkai Ye, Lidong Pei, Changyang Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized Natural Language Processing
(NLP) by by minimizing the need for complex feature engineering. However, the
application of LLMs in specialized domains like biopharmaceuticals and
chemistry remains largely unexplored. These fields are characterized by
intricate terminologies, specialized knowledge, and a high demand for precision
areas where general purpose LLMs often fall short. In this study, we introduce
PharmGPT, a suite of multilingual LLMs with 13 billion and 70 billion
parameters, specifically trained on a comprehensive corpus of hundreds of
billions of tokens tailored to the Bio-Pharmaceutical and Chemical sectors. Our
evaluation shows that PharmGPT matches or surpasses existing general models on
key benchmarks, such as NAPLEX, demonstrating its exceptional capability in
domain-specific tasks. This advancement establishes a new benchmark for LLMs in
the Bio-Pharmaceutical and Chemical fields, addressing the existing gap in
specialized language modeling. Furthermore, this suggests a promising path for
enhanced research and development in these specialized areas, paving the way
for more precise and effective applications of NLP in specialized domains. | [
-0.0548055358,
-0.7164074779,
0.7693870068,
0.042987287,
-0.1455700099,
0.4104244709,
-0.3695980906,
-0.3462899625,
0.1606553942,
0.5941883326,
-0.3191643059,
-0.7409565449,
-0.7161725163,
0.1534621119,
-0.0215023328,
1.0518479347,
0.0083386451,
0.2730606794,
0.0594282635,
-0.0823708326,
-0.1994909048,
-0.9823768735,
-0.3657361567,
-0.7232452631,
0.5341525674,
-0.0180489831,
0.4714560211,
0.2615551353,
0.6752792597,
0.1782246083,
-0.0660437644,
0.0955992118,
-0.1877931803,
0.217084825,
-0.5628934503,
-0.0054275943,
-0.8434307575,
-0.1211483777,
0.5552199483,
1.0323249102,
-0.2927510738,
0.0510291308,
-0.0648884252,
0.4034707844,
-0.4956675172,
0.3137797415,
-0.6396526694,
-0.0906208307,
-0.1347221583,
0.2066139281,
-0.2828542292,
0.0510317683,
0.3962130845,
-0.4907372594,
0.1108321548,
0.038277287,
0.8833914995,
0.0629731938,
-0.4743447304,
0.0829174072,
-0.5866184235,
0.7945371866,
-0.9110471606,
0.435870409,
0.0813373551,
0.2622545063,
-0.5691939592,
-1.1253401041,
-0.3264229894,
-0.3169128001,
0.1147520244,
-0.1272958815,
0.0934539363,
0.2461661994,
-0.1010695472,
0.435016036,
-0.9036251307,
0.0910194591,
-0.1653934866,
-0.1606433988,
0.2303528339,
0.1046914384,
0.3933072388,
-0.0252666399,
-0.4763528109,
0.1567492336,
-0.6687975526,
-0.4596444368,
-0.2304648012,
0.4470185637,
0.2166431099,
0.687368691,
-0.1087915152,
0.8460275531,
-0.3116848469,
-0.1099412814,
0.1706064343,
-0.3079567552,
-0.4488567114,
0.0468906835,
0.8788189292,
-0.0720263794,
0.3924271166,
-0.084935613,
0.0754665211,
-0.1451780349,
0.1539789885,
-0.9199578166,
-0.4492639601,
0.6108144522,
-0.146209836,
0.0857580006,
-0.2969926,
-0.8720027804,
-0.4816808999,
-0.2619181871,
0.2365049273,
-0.6442077756,
-0.1804296672,
0.5956670642,
-0.0900540128,
0.2847952247,
-0.0473395251,
-1.2451430559,
0.3905969262,
0.9733039737,
0.9044137001,
-0.7166526914,
-0.4744930267,
-0.3199247718,
0.3731324077,
-0.0428598896,
1.1130616665,
-0.7898604274,
-0.4466470778,
-0.0680607408,
0.0157121923,
-0.187718302,
-0.7812951803,
0.5103291869,
-0.2692281902,
-0.0581189357,
-0.0157880336,
-0.7564477921,
-0.07200519,
0.3051880002,
-0.2441951185,
0.6199421883,
0.2211328745,
-0.3132860959,
0.445969671,
-0.5600421429,
-0.4316842258,
0.5565103889,
-0.1986477524,
-0.4767565727,
0.0556964204,
0.1525648832,
0.4884896278,
-0.3928491473,
0.4532316327,
-0.2317275107,
-0.1354714036,
0.280987829,
-0.0372803845,
0.446487546,
-0.0385479964,
-0.0874135792,
0.3438573182,
-0.8158612251,
0.2295713425,
0.045309037,
-0.6456929445,
-0.2363445461,
-0.3586375117,
0.4046055675,
0.2087087184,
0.2830231488,
-0.3990519643,
0.5011672378,
-0.6714939475,
0.9195907712,
0.5664719939,
0.2191813588,
0.2832927704,
0.1535899341,
0.5473994613,
-0.5184380412,
0.0196999479,
-0.1573968232,
-0.6859268546,
-0.1040237173,
-0.9068233371,
0.5288882852,
0.6725507975,
-0.2074729502,
0.5313632488,
-0.2780301571,
-0.4962533414,
-0.0753400251,
0.1796544194,
0.2160573304,
0.2666634917,
0.3641429842,
-0.457624048,
-0.1155196205,
-0.8846353292,
-0.739359498,
0.0115611432,
-0.2730199099,
0.1340261996,
0.7329471707,
-0.4653944075,
0.6441511512,
-0.734118104,
-0.3188393414,
-0.3929609954,
-0.1594176441,
0.4155023098,
0.2686142623,
0.3560509384,
-0.671215415,
-0.5793103576,
0.2480290085,
-0.4116170704,
-0.2842153013,
0.3301956952,
-0.3448690772,
-0.2377172709,
0.2214602083,
-1.0420039892,
-0.076911442,
0.6538670063,
-0.3919562399,
0.6341025829,
-0.2847951353,
0.0447385944,
-0.9880607724,
0.3959132135,
0.067574665,
-0.3529275954,
-0.8402613401,
0.1482571363,
0.0193692595,
-0.5284501314,
-0.8070983887,
0.7510524392,
-0.2410653979,
0.080828771,
-0.2971474528,
-0.1155821607,
0.2580017149,
0.4932127893,
0.3067187965,
0.7262001038,
0.5053886771,
-0.5113939047,
0.504820168,
0.35264346,
-0.3122549951,
0.516315341,
-0.8254882693,
-0.0576029792,
0.3746697903,
0.3666065037,
-0.7527315021,
-0.6020003557,
0.2965123951,
-0.152302891,
0.4451872408,
-0.2821611166,
-0.6688161492,
-0.0620330349,
0.0774943009,
0.4168898761,
0.6454290748,
-0.1555183679,
0.7578247786,
0.57628721,
-0.598071456,
-0.3132965267,
-0.64564538,
0.1996562332,
-0.2231007516,
-0.2024010867,
0.5350325108,
0.137217015,
-0.0806769878,
-0.2759958506,
-0.0989913195,
-0.2788999379,
-0.4126186967,
0.0969679356,
0.0808491036,
-0.1188331097,
0.3575904071,
-0.1464045346,
-0.2557050884,
-0.1085897908,
-0.8316956758,
0.855258286,
0.0692106113,
-0.355820179,
0.0130925355,
0.4759350717,
0.6303938627,
-0.4898057878,
0.7414169908,
0.3947796226,
-0.2962347865,
-0.384365648,
-0.1425330043,
-0.211113885,
-0.4502466917,
0.6849365234,
-0.1418701559,
-0.7488237023,
0.3388931155,
-0.6432368755,
-0.1173928156,
0.3158316016,
1.0200248957,
0.6269816756,
0.6318247914,
0.5549685359,
0.0834148005,
0.1091395617,
0.1193768308,
0.5450611115,
-0.6302682161,
-0.2163374871,
-0.2810665071,
0.0769104362,
-0.2485393137,
-0.5039219856,
0.5828733444,
-0.3213561773,
-0.4885431826,
0.2808778286,
-0.6775898933,
0.5351586342,
0.5086250305,
-0.1961397976,
0.3529305756,
0.3835383952,
-0.3848638237,
-0.0953218341,
-0.5751546621,
-0.4669266343,
1.1158179045,
0.2574307621,
0.5834710002,
-0.0300545245,
0.2897498012,
0.0220789816,
0.1034632325,
-0.9303394556,
0.5093411803,
-0.4283408523,
-0.7547117472,
-0.1049227342,
-0.1787530631,
-0.9096522331,
0.3754477501,
-0.0613195598,
-0.8158570528,
0.086320132,
-0.0460558049,
-0.3522639275,
0.348480165,
-0.781464994,
1.1233326197,
-0.2171822935,
-0.2924087644,
-0.0073322514,
-0.5537385345,
0.169100672,
-0.5130903721,
-0.0032635941,
-0.4348347783,
-0.2283291668,
0.4081580043,
-0.5125085115,
0.6773166656,
0.2734048069,
-0.2606351674,
0.1228232309,
0.0396351144,
0.1970356554,
0.0149952434,
0.0190470051,
0.4861767888,
0.1105404645,
-0.524890542,
-0.3063064218,
0.9156326652,
-0.2608525157,
-0.4589637518,
-0.6631817222,
-0.4927327037,
-0.5187184811,
0.5781471133,
0.2547082305,
0.2164921463,
-0.1987593025,
-0.2620081306,
0.6134511828,
-0.7830212116,
-0.0075192717,
0.6895383,
-0.3096905053,
-0.4248272181,
0.9077512622,
-0.0779512748,
0.4304848313,
0.5070388317,
0.1433285922,
-0.3228320777,
-0.6470885873,
-0.3430984616,
0.3987239301,
-0.7988016605,
-0.1054115891,
-0.6856589913,
-0.154606238,
-0.6263372898,
0.0456762798,
-0.4331880808,
-0.3930982649,
0.1672041565,
-0.0203290004,
0.5858404636,
0.5036714673,
0.1744387448,
0.2573080063,
-0.9812349677,
0.4134498239,
0.3522996604,
0.6470560431,
-0.4276459515,
-0.246339485,
-0.0752814487,
-0.2965933084,
-0.2382652909,
-0.8125371337,
0.6721047759,
0.6258119345,
0.4507946074,
-0.0663237125,
-0.3668461442,
0.2083369941,
-0.9467647076,
1.0147955418,
-0.1670178175,
-0.7787405849,
0.5105035305,
-0.6546005011,
0.5347656012,
0.345474869,
0.3265040815,
-0.4984320104,
-0.2537935674,
-0.3006988764,
-1.1972333193,
0.1743442416,
0.1621422768,
0.0422832593,
0.1404819787,
0.5625548959,
0.2647619545,
0.2938243151,
-0.483968854,
-0.2800472677,
0.1935280263,
-0.3726225197,
-0.0819642097,
-0.0178575125,
-0.0108547853,
-0.1666187644,
0.611020267,
-0.0797406584,
0.1111097559,
0.1336677372,
0.0840617567,
0.2856246233,
0.667586267,
0.4634635746,
0.7717565298,
-0.1765878201,
-0.0018139997,
0.0189170428,
-1.011089325,
0.2769525647,
0.4902172387,
0.2127266079,
-0.0289224535,
0.3120057881,
0.2281186432,
0.0476315394,
-1.2753868103,
0.1663281322,
0.1648271233,
0.0048896922,
-0.0844340473,
-0.055039119,
0.057447426,
0.2047700882,
0.2812849581,
-0.063412562,
0.2600136697,
-0.5705762506,
0.3743059635,
0.2641112506,
-0.1114857197,
-0.224706158,
0.7180523872,
-0.0059656953,
-0.184477374,
0.3626448214,
0.1869374514,
-0.5427361727,
0.3336743414,
0.4232562482,
0.7034170032,
-0.4513492882,
0.1290472895,
0.1048322096,
-0.0786091536,
-0.043853838,
0.0464131981,
0.3822326064,
-0.4799239039,
-0.5515778065,
-0.9685485363,
-0.5368013978,
0.3188340366,
0.0019166705,
0.2796044052,
-0.6491529346,
-0.4525651932,
0.416015029,
-0.0240192432,
-0.3805907667,
-0.00439406,
-0.0446770228,
0.5795177221,
-0.6773906946,
0.9022746086,
0.9291065931,
-0.2283525914,
-0.5723624229,
-0.1048966348,
-0.0389246196,
-0.8181484342,
0.6171935201,
-0.1497901082,
0.0307439864,
-0.0634024665,
-0.3043866754,
-0.6321149468,
0.7112762928,
0.5824505687,
-0.5956121683,
0.0308289584,
0.6410126686,
0.702162087,
-0.2604468465,
-0.2941178381,
0.8733882308,
0.4063468575,
-0.0718211308,
-1.1565896273,
-0.0023697375,
-0.3057382405,
-0.1606790274,
0.323355794,
-0.4765008092,
1.0195564032,
0.0539203621,
0.0567094535,
0.0935712829,
-0.0417773649,
0.6203179955,
-0.0207598656,
-0.1984399259,
0.3835884631,
0.5388714075,
-0.0800544396,
1.1989991665,
-0.4108864963,
0.2929803431,
0.8566402197,
-0.639261961,
0.8503608704,
0.380771488,
-0.4160182774,
0.2849392891,
0.6898523569,
-0.2625848353,
0.5108372569,
0.3271124363,
-0.6753155589,
-0.3709240854,
-0.2020529658,
-0.3133616149,
0.1933055818,
0.8185656071,
-0.3771829307,
-0.0201120302,
0.0850305334,
-0.0611689985,
-0.0088826185,
-0.2335105389,
0.7572057843,
0.5120386481,
-0.4961050749,
0.5376675129,
0.1457497776,
0.330963552,
-0.9375687838,
-0.1390600204,
0.074269399,
0.5276723504,
-0.0367907658,
-0.6844601035,
0.0308203194,
-0.0823689848,
0.158190757,
0.025028443,
0.8904303312,
-0.545119226,
-0.5027814507,
0.3138607442,
0.4844697714,
0.1009075195,
-0.3861438334,
-0.7153323293,
-0.1041910648,
-0.3683630526,
-0.2409188747,
0.438642174,
0.4527101815,
0.1440723687,
0.6690152287,
0.4967668951,
0.4754479229,
-0.0742169172,
0.115617983,
0.6777319312,
-0.6274564862,
-0.3466331065,
-1.08233428,
0.2913920879,
0.1138064042,
-0.2744751275,
0.6539342999,
0.506654501,
0.4226779938,
-0.4326963127,
0.9044656754,
0.4700368047,
0.5012021661,
-0.5054183602,
0.5486108661,
-0.3866391182,
0.2188498825,
-0.2327301651,
-1.1126708984,
-0.9419056177,
0.3797602654,
-0.327757448,
0.2021207809,
0.7455690503,
0.4853639305,
-0.0867701173,
-0.3507068157,
0.2151306272,
0.1933322698,
0.5774969459,
0.8528420925,
0.5124489069,
-0.2588341236,
0.2255390584,
0.1796144098,
0.0014383793,
-0.1120485291,
-0.7276979089,
-0.9880353212,
-0.2764300406,
-0.3091310263,
-0.349544704,
0.2220468521,
1.1712983847,
0.7056241632,
-1.0163305998,
-0.1147366464,
-0.193678394,
-0.2259679437,
-0.1327981204,
-0.1754392833,
0.5888489485,
-0.0890050903,
-0.7753301263,
0.322454989,
0.8142748475,
0.220141232,
-0.3727011979,
0.1938109398,
-0.1823077202,
0.1878090799,
0.7841921449,
0.5015505552,
-0.6755413413,
0.0955624208,
0.0616716668,
-0.0248496458,
0.2023463845,
1.037199378,
-0.7053115368,
0.2809534371,
0.4690780342,
0.5074188113,
0.2578662932,
-0.1147127822,
1.0963588953,
-0.6915326715,
0.3159375787,
0.4793915451,
0.3165737092,
0.5413734317,
-0.2599937916,
0.4278718233,
0.1864055693,
-0.7911096215,
-0.6563524008,
0.3641388118,
-1.005692482,
-0.6807578802,
1.3130284548,
-0.1091534793,
-0.2140749246,
-0.3357014358,
-0.3646740317,
-0.0830100104,
-0.4183357954,
0.6010391116,
0.7866211534,
-0.1931091696,
-0.0220984817,
-0.8132894039,
0.6827956438,
0.3315217495,
-0.8712722659,
0.1935215592,
0.3048311174,
0.3954909742,
0.0363959596,
0.6630147099,
-0.1995057166,
-0.0884729922,
-0.1299821138,
0.0478625558,
0.3066093028,
-0.0947066247,
-0.4374895096,
0.2493712008,
0.2798695266,
0.26653108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18034v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18034v1 | LLMs for Doctors: Leveraging Medical LLMs to Assist Doctors, Not Replace Them | 2024-06-26T03:08:24 | 2024-06-26T03:08:24 | Wenya Xie, Qingying Xiao, Yu Zheng, Xidong Wang, Junying Chen, Ke Ji, Anningzhe Gao, Xiang Wan, Feng Jiang, Benyou Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recent success of Large Language Models (LLMs) has had a significant
impact on the healthcare field, providing patients with medical advice,
diagnostic information, and more. However, due to a lack of professional
medical knowledge, patients are easily misled by generated erroneous
information from LLMs, which may result in serious medical problems. To address
this issue, we focus on tuning the LLMs to be medical assistants who
collaborate with more experienced doctors. We first conduct a two-stage survey
by inspiration-feedback to gain a broad understanding of the real needs of
doctors for medical assistants. Based on this, we construct a Chinese medical
dataset called DoctorFLAN to support the entire workflow of doctors, which
includes 92K Q\&A samples from 22 tasks and 27 specialists. Moreover, we
evaluate LLMs in doctor-oriented scenarios by constructing the
DoctorFLAN-\textit{test} containing 550 single-turn Q\&A and DotaBench
containing 74 multi-turn conversations. The evaluation results indicate that
being a medical assistant still poses challenges for existing open-source
models, but DoctorFLAN can help them significantly. It demonstrates that the
doctor-oriented dataset and benchmarks we construct can complement existing
patient-oriented work and better promote medical LLMs research. | [
-0.0466901138,
-0.5320124626,
1.0025821924,
-0.024644088,
-0.3600514829,
-0.0255093239,
-0.1211924404,
-0.8015457392,
0.4559408426,
0.5558469892,
-0.3399354815,
-0.2780346572,
-0.7675439715,
0.4017881751,
-0.1187527031,
0.6336945891,
-0.0427959003,
0.7463274598,
-0.5360770226,
-0.041922804,
-0.2415341139,
-0.2570023239,
-1.0371409655,
-0.4076632559,
0.6621815562,
0.5475550294,
0.9356541038,
0.5713723302,
0.561408639,
0.3042278588,
-0.0579114258,
0.7051058412,
-0.1186886281,
0.1878096461,
0.0874220058,
-0.4607236683,
-0.831296742,
-0.0460680872,
0.2154265791,
0.8904332519,
-0.3060978949,
-0.1843250394,
-0.2219402194,
0.707850039,
-0.05348216,
0.1808795035,
-0.2741405964,
0.1097548977,
-0.1831438094,
-0.1956815571,
0.0211740583,
-0.393912226,
-0.0242228825,
-0.7678480744,
0.0610036589,
0.0029015199,
0.5222979188,
0.4285823703,
-0.2975533903,
-0.3285758495,
-0.7174575925,
0.2867559195,
-0.9995977879,
0.2398563325,
0.4383072257,
0.3847440183,
-0.4100362659,
-0.5263528824,
-0.4780229628,
-0.1234494522,
-0.0647184029,
0.299960196,
0.3828550279,
0.0865587145,
0.0115999077,
0.5043047071,
-0.0940837339,
0.4518297613,
-0.4188215435,
0.1838286966,
0.8860436678,
0.582031846,
0.3795054555,
0.3002510667,
-0.1622599363,
0.0480549634,
-0.8851386309,
-0.052218806,
-0.0063445945,
-0.0646074861,
-0.1032372043,
0.5809969306,
0.0132903606,
0.7760831714,
-0.0840731114,
-0.4464929104,
0.1459655762,
-0.4175971746,
-0.2847473919,
-0.2454933375,
0.8140214682,
0.2763888538,
0.4848617017,
-0.0195072386,
-0.3369939327,
-0.3401234448,
0.4156594574,
-0.5549154878,
-0.3585703373,
0.4579412341,
-0.4588535428,
-0.3699011505,
0.1796922833,
-0.5784398913,
-0.9374557734,
-0.2934758365,
0.033075355,
-0.0895583332,
-0.4611068964,
0.2551317215,
0.0881624669,
0.0386034995,
0.5597893596,
-0.7271819115,
0.3396660388,
0.7821987867,
0.7014836669,
-0.1856459528,
-0.1639614552,
-0.4926816523,
0.0640388355,
-0.5680114627,
0.7718641758,
-0.5759467483,
-0.6835857034,
0.0338357911,
0.0691438839,
-0.0559989959,
-1.0375721455,
0.3265609443,
0.0177595653,
0.2374933362,
-0.3735435605,
-0.5539668798,
0.1737519205,
0.2404190749,
-0.6378395557,
0.5569775105,
0.2338849902,
-0.2933735847,
0.2304151803,
-0.7856129408,
-0.6933056712,
0.0941651016,
-0.7005852461,
-0.45754686,
0.3408294916,
0.3716757298,
0.6011065841,
-0.6511482,
0.115817681,
-0.19673343,
-0.2640096843,
0.4144147336,
-0.0416402183,
0.6048183441,
0.0740982592,
0.2527047992,
0.1641022414,
-0.5300204754,
-0.4193878174,
0.3155435324,
-0.4013694525,
-0.277221173,
0.1942398697,
-0.1472289115,
0.2899160683,
-0.0075501581,
-0.5244830847,
0.3332589269,
-0.5555637479,
0.1495435983,
0.6080951095,
0.1253893673,
0.1260586977,
-0.5841477513,
0.7879883647,
0.2036123723,
0.4152549505,
-0.0391543768,
-0.8195989728,
-0.3644076884,
-0.2787099481,
0.1563646793,
0.4750825167,
-0.8218060136,
0.213583678,
-0.0934135616,
-0.3948776424,
-0.9539785981,
0.3819704652,
0.2103199512,
0.8712661862,
0.1932508349,
-0.2927577794,
-0.2648824751,
-0.6510660648,
-0.1910069436,
-0.1223639622,
-0.2896182537,
0.6022479534,
0.0178849921,
-0.118550621,
0.4870083928,
-0.3868699372,
-0.6978402734,
-0.2786589265,
-0.6010280848,
0.340760231,
0.1783316582,
0.3141420186,
-0.7067700028,
-0.4102984667,
0.1374219209,
-0.8467273116,
-0.263304621,
-0.0750188082,
0.2201663554,
0.0336755514,
0.4474935234,
-0.558421731,
0.0606875718,
0.5155563951,
-0.4662913084,
0.3576674461,
-0.4345710874,
0.0027993617,
-1.3190560341,
0.0727873594,
-0.0753472969,
-0.2734995782,
-0.6645243168,
-0.2999251783,
-0.0854104385,
-0.1171615943,
-0.4326121509,
0.7531336546,
-0.5127515793,
-0.0531533398,
-0.5514691472,
0.113411665,
-0.1076024547,
0.0812702626,
0.0259187613,
0.696950376,
0.6235599518,
-0.6038107276,
0.4862948656,
0.3531472683,
-0.245303154,
0.9048268199,
-0.677264452,
0.1322011054,
0.1118387505,
0.1185700372,
-0.5684381127,
-0.3212321401,
0.4435606599,
-0.467389375,
0.3125654459,
0.1014349833,
-0.7733147144,
-0.3594649732,
-0.0043630367,
0.2234421074,
0.4385358989,
-0.4356770515,
0.6384667158,
0.6034601331,
-0.2917663455,
-0.3217719197,
-0.5136302114,
0.2015945911,
0.0957765654,
-0.5308476686,
0.0474220552,
-0.0892994776,
-0.3091861606,
0.0601903647,
-0.1950892955,
-0.0978426635,
0.1748480052,
0.3801607788,
0.1966855377,
-0.0696437284,
0.2059783041,
0.0562950261,
-0.240231052,
0.2941159606,
-0.0758912712,
0.2842972577,
0.4546824992,
-0.713462472,
-0.3972415924,
0.3667203188,
0.6785815954,
-0.2194745392,
0.5781043768,
0.2488426417,
-0.4178640246,
0.1620418578,
-0.5098463893,
-0.2939346135,
-0.4201883972,
0.4343013465,
-0.1598975658,
-0.5700033903,
0.3582719862,
-0.0623035356,
0.4153337777,
0.2579619586,
0.7237409353,
-0.292329967,
0.9361273646,
0.411550492,
-0.202489242,
0.0433061458,
0.0509669818,
-0.0576337427,
-0.6090747714,
-0.5130230784,
-0.2288144827,
-0.2807590365,
-0.2859632671,
-0.2581278086,
0.6904419661,
-0.3580253124,
0.2281999588,
-0.1437784433,
-0.3472869098,
0.3342483938,
0.2576848567,
0.394756496,
0.2741906941,
-0.3230032921,
0.0308469664,
0.3418633938,
-0.6960465908,
-0.2456997037,
1.083419919,
0.407337904,
0.8563589454,
0.0601967052,
0.6769585013,
0.0111834332,
0.2803108394,
-0.7604381442,
0.5250996947,
-0.4598938227,
-0.2807150781,
-0.2190177888,
-0.2876800597,
-0.9593780041,
0.0805586427,
-0.2630519867,
-0.0941513702,
-0.0189964809,
0.2595513463,
-0.3644486666,
0.3201724887,
-0.4836870432,
0.6369747519,
-0.3680188358,
-0.0881288126,
-0.1566196382,
-0.5659282207,
0.2235164493,
-0.2106592655,
0.261415869,
-0.1465163231,
-0.3200508058,
0.4623692036,
-0.6930747032,
0.9666131139,
-0.3585226536,
-0.4563606381,
-0.1016406938,
-0.2508706152,
0.4037349522,
0.2489986867,
-0.0639358982,
0.0595431849,
0.1229894906,
-0.4453747272,
-0.6075981855,
0.6670593619,
-0.5668396354,
-0.839515388,
-0.2116175443,
-0.5224768519,
-0.5832229257,
0.1026333869,
-0.0577227622,
0.1966717243,
-0.0843200386,
-0.1910431385,
0.5100141764,
-0.021104373,
0.093818523,
0.5159435868,
-0.307356447,
-0.2123643309,
0.5246893167,
-0.0418753885,
0.2302084714,
0.1915568262,
0.3106098771,
-0.0699329227,
-0.5010015368,
-0.5909874439,
0.5162073374,
-0.5417072177,
-0.1236942932,
-0.3866975605,
-0.2173362225,
-0.3372443914,
0.0492553376,
-0.2195144445,
-0.0790847763,
-0.5622632504,
0.057911709,
0.4296317399,
0.9638195634,
0.2059508711,
0.1358136535,
-0.8722031713,
0.4207964242,
0.2773153186,
0.4982546866,
-0.1306459159,
-0.3477233648,
-0.4699899256,
-0.1994196624,
-0.0408089682,
-1.0491973162,
0.1852556765,
0.0654357523,
0.7104802728,
0.6677049398,
-0.1891269684,
0.4831142724,
-0.5566455722,
0.8107908964,
0.1022647321,
-0.365190208,
0.3649048805,
-0.0379207134,
0.2759945393,
0.358215481,
0.1465281546,
-0.587970674,
-0.5676667094,
-0.3997311592,
-0.4627710283,
0.3638458252,
-0.1575402766,
0.1329416782,
0.092234008,
0.5591412783,
0.1922062933,
0.0881105289,
-0.2112989575,
-0.2492699921,
0.0810287148,
-0.4368290007,
-0.1853627115,
-0.2596645355,
-0.4697837532,
-0.063755855,
0.4721231163,
-0.1276852041,
0.1961401999,
0.4473032653,
0.2287296355,
-0.2153183073,
0.2053316385,
0.7485796809,
0.7567760348,
0.2087019533,
-0.0279623251,
0.1673235446,
-0.5768025517,
0.0256293528,
0.2112753242,
0.2355882078,
0.1580133438,
0.2796143293,
0.4159131348,
-0.1141479537,
-0.8185497522,
0.5932220817,
-0.0121199917,
-0.2270413935,
-0.4931227267,
0.329133451,
0.2556614876,
0.282278657,
0.1828946173,
-0.1555318385,
-0.0993077382,
-0.2944075763,
0.1028116792,
0.4975903332,
-0.3083316088,
-0.3706092834,
0.6311933398,
0.3908069432,
-0.5770596266,
0.380410552,
0.2490677088,
-0.1508103013,
0.5906764865,
0.4620289505,
0.5761409998,
-0.4290982187,
-0.1378936172,
-0.0197251178,
0.1738446057,
-0.2911891937,
0.5209704638,
0.2017767131,
-0.4463795125,
-0.4126680791,
0.0482620113,
-0.7433801889,
0.1282753944,
-0.3240036368,
0.3125617802,
-0.5453819633,
-0.0320920087,
-0.1384957731,
-0.056581866,
-0.60424155,
0.2481983602,
0.0212834049,
0.9574335814,
-0.6821722388,
1.0361264944,
1.1182284355,
-0.3446558714,
-0.7074128985,
-0.0989516824,
0.0876579136,
-1.0502343178,
0.1484863162,
-0.021713974,
0.1153268367,
-0.4003190994,
-0.4152390063,
-0.1738656163,
1.2886534929,
0.2086447775,
-0.7268434763,
-0.2328273058,
0.2854353189,
0.6977708936,
-0.6043883562,
0.0603423342,
0.2892499864,
0.3272435367,
-0.1409801543,
-1.1879198551,
0.1426264048,
-0.2969912589,
-0.350990802,
0.0420997813,
-0.4891217351,
0.6983465552,
-0.5168321729,
0.1951229721,
0.1700414419,
0.2987398803,
0.3178831935,
0.5034188628,
0.6093820333,
0.3353638649,
0.8336321115,
0.1147293523,
1.1019006968,
-0.2823472023,
-0.2282920182,
0.9505209923,
-0.3501311243,
0.5579360723,
0.7668923736,
-0.1308033615,
0.2157877684,
0.5188979506,
-0.0526748486,
0.1024071276,
0.0979000553,
-0.4462653995,
-0.3369859755,
-0.0869620889,
-0.4970084429,
0.3095934689,
0.5280382633,
-0.6043077111,
0.1599149853,
-0.0144441538,
0.1253678799,
0.2363050729,
-0.2726120949,
1.0544081926,
0.4982272387,
-0.5460764766,
0.2216434628,
-0.2651100755,
0.4095075428,
-0.5174838901,
-0.1750937104,
-0.4411905408,
0.0565977991,
-0.4414225221,
-0.7870181203,
0.1266879439,
-0.1111084893,
-0.0808302909,
-0.0480748937,
0.6155021191,
-0.3974488378,
-0.5532281399,
0.0466783419,
0.8602246642,
0.4959138334,
0.0564678796,
-0.580919981,
-0.2875463367,
-0.1210775003,
0.1104933918,
0.3807097673,
0.3534173071,
0.2263086438,
0.6867858768,
0.5481784344,
0.680624783,
-0.2350591421,
0.3023627996,
0.7869215608,
-0.6111127734,
-0.2410786599,
-0.796250999,
0.3617342412,
-0.0998787507,
-0.2498982698,
0.3239867389,
0.3373143375,
0.4514535666,
-0.1872261316,
0.6505826116,
0.3446268141,
0.8548625708,
-0.6476032734,
0.8454232216,
-0.9183422327,
0.5001865625,
0.0651621148,
-0.3926113248,
-0.350324899,
0.2143660933,
-0.0011188259,
0.1587674469,
0.3165836334,
0.6850091219,
-0.0582165532,
-0.1259676218,
0.6175717711,
0.0272748154,
0.4871354699,
0.6768172383,
0.6418523192,
-0.0594680421,
0.4314729869,
-0.0459778607,
-0.1611934602,
-0.222481817,
-0.4892092943,
-0.876265645,
-0.3624419272,
-0.2475569248,
-0.2215749323,
0.0788068995,
0.9342293739,
0.6581916213,
-0.6510145068,
-0.1038440615,
0.1679430008,
0.1491430253,
-0.3621504605,
-0.1084965914,
0.3307379484,
-0.2122442424,
-0.7507300973,
0.6889612675,
0.3059422374,
0.068807438,
-0.512904346,
-0.3089514077,
0.1104190052,
0.0125996899,
0.2535606623,
0.3742556274,
-0.7328107953,
0.1097109541,
0.2558338344,
-0.2306274623,
0.3932847381,
0.9754409194,
-0.5488818884,
0.5330219269,
0.0645012856,
0.8771530986,
-0.0804724395,
-0.109240748,
0.7782526612,
-0.4519482553,
-0.1851612628,
0.2621375024,
0.5807782412,
0.3470155001,
-0.5350468755,
0.502881825,
0.0514161848,
-0.5198215246,
-0.6401013136,
0.1332727373,
-0.885163784,
-0.3709466755,
1.2154022455,
-0.1876032054,
0.127854988,
-0.3125306368,
-0.3704302013,
0.2940922976,
-0.2671438158,
0.8082650304,
0.4330612719,
-0.4706059098,
-0.3979571164,
-0.5885882378,
0.550996244,
0.6396291256,
-1.2283928394,
-0.1940358877,
0.3801147938,
0.3786365986,
-0.1159123927,
1.0316418409,
-0.3640865088,
0.4677826464,
-0.3613169193,
-0.1583025604,
-0.6519008875,
-0.2408639938,
-0.4520462453,
-0.1117344573,
0.4494280517,
-0.4712870717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18027v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18027v1 | Automated Clinical Data Extraction with Knowledge Conditioned LLMs | 2024-06-26T02:49:28 | 2024-06-26T02:49:28 | Diya Li, Asim Kadav, Aijing Gao, Rui Li, Richard Bourgon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The extraction of lung lesion information from clinical and medical imaging
reports is crucial for research on and clinical care of lung-related diseases.
Large language models (LLMs) can be effective at interpreting unstructured text
in reports, but they often hallucinate due to a lack of domain-specific
knowledge, leading to reduced accuracy and posing challenges for use in
clinical settings. To address this, we propose a novel framework that aligns
generated internal knowledge with external knowledge through in-context
learning (ICL). Our framework employs a retriever to identify relevant units of
internal or external knowledge and a grader to evaluate the truthfulness and
helpfulness of the retrieved internal-knowledge rules, to align and update the
knowledge bases. Our knowledge-conditioned approach also improves the accuracy
and reliability of LLM outputs by addressing the extraction task in two stages:
(i) lung lesion finding detection and primary structured field parsing,
followed by (ii) further parsing of lesion description text into additional
structured fields. Experiments with expert-curated test datasets demonstrate
that this ICL approach can increase the F1 score for key fields (lesion size,
margin and solidity) by an average of 12.9% over existing ICL methods. | [
0.05656996,
-0.5026236773,
0.9306744337,
0.1941484362,
-0.3737429678,
-0.0997868329,
-0.2268355638,
-0.3918372989,
-0.0527986586,
0.7246192098,
-0.1529215872,
-0.6547541618,
-0.7757105231,
-0.0401125737,
-0.2642272413,
0.9737276435,
-0.1226038784,
0.3427001238,
-0.6607661247,
-0.1563743353,
-0.1279209554,
-0.5742529631,
-0.6645932794,
-0.3740644753,
0.1769216657,
0.4473852813,
0.3197006881,
0.502741158,
0.9378718138,
0.2718023658,
0.1732072681,
0.2759656608,
-0.1183099672,
0.2055038959,
-0.0249314569,
-0.1091550216,
-0.1547129899,
-0.262367636,
0.5273680687,
0.7515087724,
-0.093454577,
-0.1517451108,
-0.1349746883,
0.7625486851,
-0.3400788009,
0.168225497,
-0.6693585515,
0.116818361,
0.0071821655,
-0.7133479118,
-0.414504379,
-0.208425954,
0.416873306,
-0.6532873511,
0.1962232739,
-0.1771546751,
0.8559078574,
0.403152287,
-0.5230584741,
-0.513171494,
-0.2966551483,
0.4687669575,
-0.8732424378,
0.4474153519,
0.4251393974,
0.42873016,
-0.2145775408,
-1.0308088064,
-0.1631713808,
-0.2572321296,
-0.5726397038,
0.2781951427,
0.2118614316,
0.2047115266,
0.3509956598,
0.3365837932,
-0.3311050832,
0.0792340636,
-0.5847455859,
-0.1612411141,
0.6901819706,
0.1818310469,
0.412650317,
-0.2248970866,
-0.6094573736,
0.17201671,
-0.7090158463,
0.0698477775,
-0.3287119269,
0.2959868014,
0.0138180666,
0.5660721064,
-0.2406332642,
0.8072134852,
0.185000658,
-0.6435239315,
0.3052451909,
-0.0059208516,
-0.7059363723,
0.2256376594,
0.6760295033,
0.2612091601,
-0.226849556,
-0.3512579799,
-0.2118198574,
-0.2865816653,
0.1414745152,
-0.9662803411,
-0.1946223378,
0.2778052986,
-0.554078877,
-0.5782533884,
0.0490575768,
-0.5663023591,
-0.6376461983,
-0.4121547937,
0.4028875232,
-0.52792871,
-0.0191378072,
0.1378303468,
-0.1100519374,
-0.0893231183,
0.4004878402,
-0.4182489514,
0.3872642219,
0.2988743186,
0.6059905291,
-0.1254028082,
0.3182985187,
-0.9120492935,
0.3016507924,
-0.2563165128,
0.7073832154,
-0.5694946647,
-0.3330767751,
-0.0610394292,
0.1484054327,
-0.3674516678,
-0.7926611304,
0.4522297382,
-0.6678290367,
0.4000524282,
0.008490609,
-0.8012065887,
-0.2649194896,
0.3987445533,
-0.5459919572,
0.8340340853,
0.5543646216,
-0.5811626315,
0.6219587326,
-0.514087677,
-0.4186151624,
0.1436125487,
-0.411557585,
-0.3346710205,
0.0471428484,
0.4588938355,
0.6279634833,
-0.2595819235,
0.7359730005,
-0.2673912644,
0.0063541317,
0.2344794422,
-0.0541531146,
0.7830956578,
0.0849401131,
-0.2930367291,
0.0878297761,
-0.7357501388,
0.108916007,
-0.0815164223,
-0.5425707698,
-0.2228954732,
-0.0136079118,
-0.2660877705,
0.4835504591,
-0.0241830163,
-0.73481071,
0.2283719033,
-0.6575472951,
0.0728476271,
0.3808374107,
0.3633090556,
0.3436480761,
-0.4020081758,
0.3662551641,
0.3997314274,
-0.0450877771,
-0.0255047921,
-0.1328499615,
-0.4917387664,
-0.5970736146,
0.0802840367,
0.4921799302,
-0.5295404196,
0.5361024141,
-0.1583794951,
-0.287890017,
-0.3740048707,
0.3191783726,
0.2958333194,
1.0570524931,
0.3383832574,
-0.1717705727,
-0.554117918,
-0.9096761346,
0.0432728343,
0.0348034762,
-0.1154203489,
0.4087926149,
0.0999413654,
-0.4413142204,
0.722012341,
-0.6661663651,
-0.9408193231,
-0.1347486228,
-0.0626839101,
0.0540589765,
0.4277469218,
0.3350199163,
-0.8102739453,
-0.5954304338,
0.3652176559,
-1.0479950905,
-0.2757303715,
-0.1126964167,
-0.1104371101,
0.3386628926,
1.0409324169,
-0.492521435,
0.607997179,
0.3042077124,
-0.1128243208,
0.0855366886,
-0.2952809334,
0.0927815661,
-0.7776146531,
0.1879498363,
0.0786837861,
-0.3745406568,
-0.348477453,
-0.0133258151,
0.2926993966,
-0.1079721227,
-0.4213139713,
0.7040926814,
-0.3054857552,
0.113536194,
-0.100976415,
-0.0199718587,
0.4676038325,
0.3874004483,
0.3915337622,
0.4044105709,
0.3808272779,
-0.4510693252,
0.0183828436,
0.0870166644,
-0.4328664541,
0.2478872985,
-0.3551531434,
0.0846396908,
-0.1965889931,
0.5063633919,
-0.6276020408,
-0.4877675772,
0.1870845109,
-0.2355235964,
0.6154957414,
-0.291367352,
-0.5222212076,
-0.0775954351,
0.1609173864,
0.3339170516,
0.2064493597,
-0.4422748983,
0.651776731,
0.3751884103,
-0.1369621009,
-0.1562054604,
-0.4486733377,
-0.2745455503,
-0.3652457893,
-0.4412827194,
0.4392965734,
-0.1080989614,
-0.3674585521,
0.135947451,
0.0071067773,
-0.3304232657,
0.0994890556,
0.218930915,
0.1800711006,
-0.2636118531,
0.3431358039,
0.0912679285,
0.1296534985,
0.0725478157,
-0.4465892613,
0.0862372592,
0.0159895774,
-0.5827934146,
-0.3584891856,
0.2965038121,
0.7642073035,
-0.0342550576,
0.5370634794,
0.3371343911,
-0.8605290651,
0.096540235,
-0.6588653326,
-0.1215862259,
-0.381444037,
0.295833081,
-0.2962666452,
-0.4916240275,
0.3271802962,
-0.2218417823,
-0.1220213324,
0.6065356731,
0.4517500699,
-0.3196212053,
1.1004544497,
0.5898038149,
-0.0739358142,
0.0268184934,
-0.2019382864,
0.2241987884,
-1.081112504,
-0.6298288703,
-0.2515591681,
-0.0574700311,
-0.101342313,
-0.3040239811,
0.7241167426,
0.1467191428,
-0.141277656,
-0.317263037,
-0.588694036,
0.259431839,
0.2500908077,
0.7060714364,
0.1949213594,
0.0533480011,
-0.1178315431,
-0.1519903839,
-0.7702182531,
-0.2429958582,
1.2265825272,
0.2002222836,
0.2290311307,
0.0076693199,
0.6862156987,
0.0948897675,
0.7421751022,
-0.8847571611,
0.1734461188,
-0.4261947274,
-0.5456238985,
-0.2591264546,
-0.1979418993,
-0.6944968104,
0.1405394226,
-0.0394535773,
-0.624691546,
0.1178454757,
-0.007603148,
-0.4220586121,
0.3039636612,
-0.5015404224,
0.579057157,
-0.5324296951,
-0.2059933692,
0.0807460621,
-0.8935251236,
0.4818189144,
-0.2659287751,
0.4324519336,
-0.0337875821,
0.0020775422,
0.6111449003,
-0.4304993153,
0.7162533998,
-0.4667469561,
0.0299261026,
0.0942602679,
0.1452555507,
0.3948802352,
0.1913786083,
-0.3567155302,
-0.2363134176,
0.2102943808,
-0.3314992785,
-0.8553194404,
0.6292458773,
-0.525254786,
-0.4529464841,
-0.3249727786,
-0.7152792811,
-0.5129351616,
0.1978002638,
0.4402186871,
0.7355160117,
-0.0698630735,
0.2430006713,
0.677577734,
-0.4498536885,
-0.1377507895,
0.6437880993,
-0.1196127534,
-0.614672184,
0.8664929271,
-0.0542018786,
0.1113947704,
0.5424865484,
0.359785825,
-0.0048803007,
-0.6954700351,
-0.4273273349,
0.1653180271,
-1.0232739449,
-0.5450958014,
-0.8526832461,
-0.547236681,
-0.3933590055,
-0.2360539585,
0.0015444055,
-0.2027181685,
-0.4192002714,
-0.0441953316,
0.1850768179,
0.5269141793,
0.0571207479,
0.2461122721,
-0.9212235212,
0.1203321368,
-0.0982419774,
-0.0014042072,
-0.3837587535,
-0.7258471847,
-0.3984040022,
-0.1985605806,
-0.12722148,
-0.4930095077,
0.7227973342,
0.386005342,
0.6188954711,
0.6405081749,
0.1683577001,
0.7745594382,
-0.1600197405,
0.486015588,
0.0618377626,
-0.4941866398,
0.6276441813,
-0.076602608,
0.0334149338,
0.7388389707,
0.2374193668,
-0.2660041153,
-0.4649285972,
-0.8921397328,
-0.8447698951,
0.6665856242,
-0.2250249386,
-0.3520336151,
0.0199515149,
0.4269028604,
0.2415651232,
0.1198678613,
-0.4870454073,
0.2231782228,
0.0749754459,
-0.6164265871,
-0.0680615902,
-0.1173944846,
-0.6218689084,
-0.5036401749,
0.7718914747,
-0.4770234525,
0.2362255305,
0.7037401199,
-0.5946594477,
-0.2455426604,
-0.2069970071,
0.597984612,
0.6264898181,
-0.4606375098,
0.0544085093,
0.0328610912,
-0.0421625189,
-0.0373998471,
0.1581933051,
0.0403106846,
-0.1819934696,
0.6563503742,
0.4184082448,
0.3208349049,
-0.7960903049,
0.7048713565,
-0.0918718874,
-0.3697389364,
-0.4644475579,
-0.1963422447,
-0.1979659796,
0.2378651649,
0.3003901541,
0.3081750274,
0.255507797,
-0.0246005654,
0.5739813447,
0.5614600182,
-0.7599529028,
-0.0298812296,
0.2388072163,
0.0911280066,
0.1885108054,
0.7350780368,
0.1965886503,
-0.5153051615,
0.8349220157,
0.5813876987,
0.4679351747,
0.2708035111,
0.0320088193,
0.3514267206,
0.1405698657,
0.1491449326,
-0.0571538396,
0.0313219689,
-0.5568079352,
-0.1511678547,
-0.524805069,
-0.2172129303,
0.4774697721,
-0.7233431935,
0.3832531869,
-0.4688007832,
0.1675696373,
-0.1517147571,
0.1945596933,
-0.8125959635,
0.710357666,
0.0125311334,
0.9975273609,
-0.7769242525,
1.0950398445,
0.5847104192,
-0.2947628796,
-1.0329893827,
0.0255884361,
0.166753754,
-0.8054922223,
1.0087795258,
0.3079046607,
0.3581756055,
-0.0630990565,
-0.2080388665,
-0.9434064627,
1.0859808922,
0.3137776852,
-0.3871985376,
0.0280502811,
-0.1500008255,
0.5079282522,
-0.668479979,
0.2847212553,
0.5918284655,
0.3131024539,
0.1512748748,
-0.6858697534,
0.2572825551,
-0.2539165616,
-0.5937595367,
0.0405681133,
-0.3968123198,
0.3133114278,
-0.2380086482,
-0.127016902,
-0.0190644469,
0.4123001993,
0.1828552932,
0.6345607042,
0.47172001,
0.7184820771,
0.9489971995,
0.1411031485,
1.0316886902,
-0.5235475898,
-0.0589821003,
0.8124815822,
-0.4621229768,
0.4975737929,
0.4736370742,
0.1973348558,
0.6492575407,
0.7484965324,
0.3755762279,
0.6941238046,
0.0815360174,
-0.3790420592,
-0.2270237654,
-0.0207917783,
-0.2412302941,
0.3191593587,
0.8204719424,
-0.7492694259,
-0.097192809,
0.244969964,
-0.0661207438,
-0.2446403205,
0.1012199521,
1.2644008398,
0.1588077694,
-0.8586705327,
0.531431973,
-0.205439046,
0.254511863,
-0.8115749955,
-0.0833924562,
-0.2843167782,
0.3123705983,
-0.5004690886,
-0.3894769847,
0.4623776376,
-0.2515397966,
-0.2846875787,
0.0629156604,
0.8102068901,
-0.6424047947,
-0.8253094554,
0.4410068393,
0.2093747109,
0.106278196,
0.0247257017,
-0.4376316071,
0.150990054,
0.1082937047,
-0.1781181693,
0.6419080496,
0.6990428567,
-0.1528987437,
0.5378188491,
0.5461663604,
0.3552951515,
-0.3648855686,
0.025927756,
1.0835336447,
-0.2410348207,
-0.043491289,
-0.4909588099,
0.6242210865,
-0.2892726362,
-0.1239985675,
0.2123698741,
0.6147193313,
0.6554747224,
0.2195349783,
0.9942978621,
0.0986746177,
0.5634940267,
-0.8428803086,
0.599578619,
-0.7921087742,
0.5295453668,
-0.0162644237,
-0.2063183784,
-0.6929343343,
0.3875664473,
-0.3664290905,
-0.3112724125,
0.8115336299,
0.8546407819,
-0.262573719,
-0.3363952339,
0.2651082277,
0.0752995536,
0.6043636799,
0.4701709449,
0.3666797876,
-0.2859113812,
0.4178406894,
-0.6426511407,
-0.5042912364,
-0.2645269334,
-0.78973943,
-0.6115663052,
-0.5841525197,
-0.4538087249,
-0.172529012,
-0.0252031982,
1.0154001713,
0.994931519,
-0.6882612109,
0.0278322846,
0.0453307405,
-0.1059374884,
-0.0885114819,
-0.254278779,
0.8323420286,
-0.6847062707,
-0.3598555326,
0.6978514791,
0.3553373516,
-0.1515091509,
0.1705477834,
-0.1321851164,
0.094536595,
-0.1739941388,
0.7385926247,
0.0604756176,
-0.7180198431,
-0.1412950158,
-0.1175057366,
-0.2856138945,
0.2585426867,
0.969666779,
-1.1175633669,
0.7318524718,
0.1476261318,
0.7265406847,
0.4297481179,
0.1221872866,
0.5853130221,
-0.816090405,
0.2985025346,
0.4424428642,
0.3359104991,
0.4152635038,
-0.864397049,
0.3514137566,
0.2780536115,
-0.6152735949,
-0.9009276032,
-0.0585679337,
-0.7793629169,
-0.419662416,
1.0541853905,
-0.2186712176,
0.0461566448,
-0.134348914,
-0.2725383937,
0.229345113,
-0.1376395077,
0.7723116279,
0.3649668097,
-0.4864084423,
-0.2186783552,
-0.2849990427,
0.7585135698,
0.2388271242,
-0.9085178375,
-0.3199696541,
0.4120750427,
0.45844841,
-0.1833264977,
0.9367731214,
-0.3862755299,
0.1718519032,
-0.5625084639,
-0.0907754675,
-0.1439931691,
-0.2752347887,
-0.1884324253,
0.1815772057,
0.0947269574,
0.0233592596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01599v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01599v1 | JailbreakZoo: Survey, Landscapes, and Horizons in Jailbreaking Large Language and Vision-Language Models | 2024-06-26T02:20:23 | 2024-06-26T02:20:23 | Haibo Jin, Leyang Hu, Xinuo Li, Peiyan Zhang, Chonghan Chen, Jun Zhuang, Haohan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CV, cs.LG | The rapid evolution of artificial intelligence (AI) through developments in
Large Language Models (LLMs) and Vision-Language Models (VLMs) has brought
significant advancements across various technological domains. While these
models enhance capabilities in natural language processing and visual
interactive tasks, their growing adoption raises critical concerns regarding
security and ethical alignment. This survey provides an extensive review of the
emerging field of jailbreaking--deliberately circumventing the ethical and
operational boundaries of LLMs and VLMs--and the consequent development of
defense mechanisms. Our study categorizes jailbreaks into seven distinct types
and elaborates on defense strategies that address these vulnerabilities.
Through this comprehensive examination, we identify research gaps and propose
directions for future studies to enhance the security frameworks of LLMs and
VLMs. Our findings underscore the necessity for a unified perspective that
integrates both jailbreak strategies and defensive solutions to foster a
robust, secure, and reliable environment for the next generation of language
models. More details can be found on our website:
\url{https://chonghan-chen.com/llm-jailbreak-zoo-survey/}. | [
-0.4876181483,
-0.9443640113,
0.5016553402,
0.084529385,
-0.1149949133,
0.4699091613,
-0.1584402919,
-0.8085585237,
0.2607913911,
0.9669090509,
-0.3678349555,
-0.3945586681,
-0.6402872801,
0.0431503691,
-0.420755744,
0.9408114552,
0.1900316477,
0.0814463869,
-0.1380410343,
-0.2834943831,
-0.5680215955,
-0.6747421622,
0.027247576,
-0.0079094581,
0.3560604453,
0.1784959435,
0.6548602581,
0.6620514393,
0.7176563144,
0.3228670657,
-0.2065906525,
-0.051330585,
-0.2509462833,
0.3250786066,
-0.2440683097,
-0.3206535876,
-0.1513153613,
0.0529763959,
0.1797360331,
0.5248919725,
0.0547620654,
0.0058255005,
-0.3142388165,
0.8297867775,
-0.8876616955,
-0.2279300988,
-0.7407560349,
0.1692952067,
-0.4795929492,
0.2104790062,
-0.3791440427,
-0.15267919,
0.0601107068,
-0.4440945089,
-0.3340179622,
0.0815422013,
0.5507724881,
0.0803163499,
-0.2565002441,
-0.125239253,
-0.6771961451,
0.7647053003,
-0.6214080453,
0.1438523233,
0.3937125206,
0.2426836342,
-0.2484847158,
-0.5600830317,
-0.3042725623,
-0.6160414219,
0.3851529062,
-0.0228536017,
-0.2500478923,
0.1405857503,
0.1936519742,
0.2873932719,
-0.2834300697,
0.3873409033,
-0.5896397829,
-0.2076609135,
0.7558737993,
0.2313022017,
0.6569641829,
-0.0340941027,
-0.3480505645,
0.0312673114,
-0.9689021111,
0.1813782901,
0.5485093594,
0.2732662559,
-0.1411171257,
0.7782763839,
-0.13118352,
0.7867494822,
-0.2814456224,
-0.1077849492,
0.2015423179,
-0.3597793877,
-0.1520908624,
-0.0761414841,
0.8651666641,
0.5711249113,
0.3714894652,
-0.3576864004,
-0.2056951225,
-0.1659465283,
0.6399329901,
-0.4284596443,
0.0287552401,
0.277256012,
-0.4837063253,
-0.8158700466,
0.1457547992,
-0.9071573615,
-1.0569722652,
0.0379985794,
0.1012193635,
-0.4365369081,
-0.3000808954,
0.1257309467,
-0.2405018359,
0.511764884,
0.1898826212,
-0.9140272737,
0.2625395358,
0.7930715084,
0.8175333738,
0.0504056625,
-0.4520142674,
-0.3963183761,
-0.0000815554,
-0.3197722733,
0.5216534138,
-0.4420042932,
-0.6658205986,
0.0615227893,
-0.2387571484,
0.1344946176,
-0.5551874042,
0.2730713487,
-0.5828106999,
-0.3023410738,
-0.0878395513,
-0.3781354725,
-0.1404433399,
0.4415009022,
-0.7317977548,
0.4692568183,
-0.0474614576,
-0.7592058182,
0.4393984377,
-0.7107480764,
-0.5450432897,
0.2552000582,
-0.1872031093,
-0.3402003944,
0.07469403,
0.1571532041,
0.1684412509,
-0.0671149269,
0.4166204631,
-0.6322027445,
-0.1883473843,
0.087492384,
-0.1590580046,
1.1532673836,
0.4941613674,
-0.6582710147,
0.3253671825,
-0.5077725649,
-0.2136328965,
0.5303528309,
-0.1618626118,
-0.5517164469,
0.4388933182,
0.1256547123,
0.0307257306,
0.283801347,
-0.6902130842,
0.4299317002,
-0.4028194249,
0.8780759573,
0.674967885,
-0.0776413083,
0.6409367323,
-0.0104687801,
0.3769866228,
0.0748971924,
0.6426003575,
-0.226447016,
-0.2947792411,
-0.3725138009,
-0.0350715667,
0.001102031,
0.847841084,
-0.3065820634,
0.3416174948,
0.0254717786,
-0.6866270304,
-0.3045415282,
0.2697374523,
0.2170459926,
0.2169086933,
0.3425835669,
-0.3372125626,
-0.6926487684,
-0.8946148157,
-0.5196609497,
-0.4101449847,
0.1711429656,
0.1871116161,
0.5209105015,
-0.4197629094,
0.952177763,
-0.0769959092,
-0.2243692875,
-0.4851750135,
-0.3921622336,
-0.1187715009,
0.4905283749,
0.8672915697,
-0.9080184698,
-0.0531333126,
-0.1624301523,
-0.9267753363,
0.1266604364,
0.0089227771,
0.2163401693,
0.0687373504,
0.7178923488,
-0.9044667482,
0.5245928168,
0.1907736212,
-0.5259720683,
0.7176942229,
0.1791874617,
-0.035946954,
-0.7172256708,
-0.2054858208,
0.0085729603,
-0.0644847527,
-0.7902646661,
0.7259976864,
-0.1757197529,
0.0448155031,
-0.4983926415,
0.3568759561,
-0.4520237148,
-0.1862531453,
-0.1983466744,
0.2026065439,
-0.2384206206,
-0.1893796027,
-0.1320976764,
0.667036891,
0.783210814,
-0.1803473234,
0.6970415115,
0.2567367852,
-0.4144244492,
0.0952806026,
-0.4864117801,
0.0623899437,
0.0819557682,
0.2022355497,
-0.5238825679,
-0.2264936864,
0.5069181919,
-0.3479928076,
0.0350542963,
-0.1063260734,
-0.4477475286,
-0.416195035,
-0.6841166019,
0.3095597625,
0.4922177792,
-0.354539752,
0.5308701992,
0.7939139009,
-0.2066946179,
-0.8337106705,
-0.700186193,
0.7293280363,
-0.6185840368,
-0.7086670399,
0.1441130787,
0.2098317295,
-1.0337457657,
-0.2317966521,
0.0677832663,
0.0795062929,
0.4547277391,
0.3430444002,
0.4436092675,
-0.197299391,
-0.358318001,
-0.2493689805,
0.3011615276,
0.4066812992,
-0.302161783,
0.4719586074,
-0.4080592692,
-0.1683445424,
0.0804400295,
0.4535734951,
0.8803771138,
-0.4825056791,
0.8721698523,
0.0873287246,
-0.1207708716,
0.0848191753,
-0.5675287247,
0.035222128,
-0.4620317519,
0.3707866073,
-0.1667434722,
-1.1391479969,
0.522099793,
-0.1274385452,
0.407117337,
0.2440753281,
0.5457267165,
-0.0475906655,
0.5813960433,
1.0030184984,
-0.5738319159,
0.6042954922,
0.0291093215,
0.4323914051,
-0.6323310137,
-0.4589892924,
-0.4224117994,
-0.0438270569,
-0.6179631352,
-0.056473244,
-0.0221685581,
0.1270672083,
-0.2438728213,
0.4460560381,
-0.3878106475,
0.5182979703,
0.4306447804,
-0.1058961004,
0.2786468565,
-0.2597005963,
-0.084594354,
0.2575458288,
-0.3215439618,
-0.6737681627,
1.2368462086,
0.4753220379,
0.6952801347,
0.2093919814,
0.7859963179,
0.4064876139,
0.1677597612,
-0.7781001329,
0.6893412471,
0.0113872262,
-0.7343900204,
-0.4250287116,
-0.060583137,
-0.77168715,
0.3581318259,
-0.0938879773,
-1.3760637045,
-0.0783924311,
-0.0148005718,
-0.3182217777,
0.5445368886,
-0.503390491,
0.791924119,
-0.587128222,
-0.3812142313,
-0.221667394,
-1.1296334267,
0.7920624614,
-0.0717890933,
0.5029405355,
-0.2222863585,
0.0769659951,
0.5376009345,
-0.661816597,
0.7991207838,
-0.3607841134,
-0.0984239355,
0.4535723329,
0.0537823997,
0.2530874014,
0.1642525196,
0.3235552609,
0.1733811349,
-0.0477047339,
-0.2485540211,
-0.0556682311,
0.5066618323,
-0.7140648365,
-0.9890453219,
-0.3239119649,
-0.5909537673,
-0.4141848981,
0.3575392067,
0.3367272019,
0.0882652402,
-0.3472974598,
0.0715666115,
0.7911490798,
-0.3690418005,
0.5111525059,
0.2337341309,
-0.6398702264,
-0.2135671526,
0.5519530773,
-0.1184277683,
0.1306984723,
0.0057594739,
-0.0178246442,
-0.132518515,
-0.9372913837,
-0.5030247569,
-0.1168138385,
-0.4708212614,
-0.1333319098,
-0.5403502584,
-0.5019264817,
-0.5570949316,
-0.3014346659,
-0.3403639793,
-0.227521643,
0.0743236616,
-0.2359198928,
0.6573342085,
0.6960861087,
-0.0948884934,
0.1906874031,
-0.7478746772,
0.4259751439,
0.0041792025,
0.1767325997,
-0.1847046763,
-0.335069865,
-0.0470418595,
-0.1005457193,
-0.2651239038,
-0.8851933479,
0.1694917679,
-0.0752950385,
0.5179306269,
0.3439021111,
0.01294077,
0.4050299823,
-0.7623265982,
0.886199832,
0.2846319079,
-0.8153002858,
0.6945685744,
-0.494889468,
0.0300787557,
0.7099661231,
-0.062156491,
-0.5004867911,
-0.7957749963,
-0.3206632137,
-1.1202553511,
0.3360790014,
-0.0163983088,
0.474352777,
0.3037993014,
0.1906594634,
-0.1143878326,
0.1553723067,
-0.804320693,
-0.0735127851,
-0.2676211894,
-0.0320948996,
0.0493766889,
-0.0471485853,
-0.3573001027,
-0.3086250126,
0.2790759504,
0.2515061796,
-0.1005393341,
-0.1005320102,
-0.3304913342,
0.1630162299,
0.3551621437,
0.7162619829,
0.5343475342,
-0.0054382388,
-0.1073262766,
0.0200685207,
-0.9599357247,
0.3287942708,
0.0098817665,
-0.3619247377,
-0.2547564209,
0.3515618145,
0.61868155,
-0.156202063,
-1.1013231277,
0.6630523801,
0.0884069949,
-0.227077961,
-0.6008722186,
0.1857116967,
-0.1252776831,
0.3435876369,
0.3789153695,
0.1659666598,
0.2310236394,
-0.6013947129,
0.1040617153,
0.6169468164,
-0.1771369576,
0.0322546549,
0.728518188,
0.142809391,
-0.2970340848,
0.9019110203,
0.2238426507,
-0.4330347478,
0.7545277476,
0.3621320426,
0.9518762231,
-0.0395311117,
0.0943855569,
-0.1488936543,
0.8501452208,
-0.0090473033,
-0.0394340046,
-0.114567928,
-0.8586323857,
-0.2813954353,
-0.5295681357,
-0.4423883259,
0.4012099504,
-0.6318466067,
0.0865246654,
-0.8013219833,
-0.2272989452,
-0.0615559146,
-0.2492756993,
-0.0616507903,
-0.0264438093,
0.5117224455,
1.3926475048,
-0.5219146013,
0.7572757602,
0.6382942796,
-0.2919974923,
-0.444655627,
-0.0114223072,
0.4726053476,
-0.5593164563,
0.5121478438,
0.3728329241,
-0.330208689,
-0.3360900879,
-0.869748354,
-0.6878494024,
0.7551862001,
0.1134532318,
-0.6644315124,
-0.0883839577,
0.1729172021,
0.3198701739,
-0.3311135471,
-0.4263200164,
1.0155690908,
0.4832143486,
-0.4216427803,
-0.7271658182,
-0.2422036231,
-0.4027016163,
0.000694973,
0.3822193742,
-0.6543548703,
0.4605122805,
-0.6880630255,
0.1357531548,
0.4101864994,
0.4210132957,
0.6315957904,
0.3339695632,
0.368323952,
0.6757939458,
0.215522185,
-0.1735320389,
0.8754763007,
-0.2511639297,
0.050220035,
0.8387717605,
-0.4371604025,
0.7000337243,
0.8418258429,
-0.0993929133,
0.2812818885,
0.5876213908,
-0.4850988984,
0.6770029664,
0.4379071891,
-0.2339010835,
-0.0044442588,
0.2337161899,
-0.2046613693,
0.7495647073,
0.4539288282,
-0.2879092991,
-0.1821763515,
0.3457230926,
0.1626939923,
0.0573909841,
-0.5409175158,
0.7964901924,
0.1129189581,
-0.4078702033,
0.0753685385,
0.3164774776,
0.7534624338,
-0.6159262657,
0.2449830472,
-0.1682990491,
-0.0395027325,
-0.1417569667,
-0.8379392624,
0.2657873929,
0.5838214755,
0.0862452313,
-0.218652457,
0.7918370366,
0.1506074369,
-0.1135617718,
0.4502285719,
0.343205452,
0.0071112332,
0.1939457357,
-0.736363709,
0.3935310841,
-0.231496796,
-0.3798331916,
0.5173496604,
-0.1350400001,
-0.1592686176,
0.8725089431,
0.4440921545,
0.0424581878,
0.3525240719,
-0.0570764206,
0.930914402,
-0.7562593222,
-0.4024111032,
-1.3485532999,
0.4561278224,
-0.2743539512,
-0.3350876272,
0.8117933273,
0.5819450021,
0.8571452498,
0.0403194427,
0.9959910512,
-0.302950114,
0.0697870776,
-0.599364996,
1.0669212341,
-0.2912757099,
0.2369547933,
-0.5019090176,
-0.7432720065,
-0.2572265565,
0.4415772557,
-0.4230628312,
-0.1399797797,
0.1738795787,
0.3742352724,
0.2661235929,
-0.0861259028,
0.2998793721,
0.0712428465,
0.2007581592,
0.5130153298,
1.2554934025,
-0.1606314331,
0.3940696716,
-0.1297015995,
-0.1841487736,
-0.2557828426,
-0.5514891744,
-0.7458503246,
-0.3143695295,
-0.0528834239,
-0.1923333555,
0.1472972333,
0.6034038067,
0.4579293728,
-0.6789712906,
-0.3980194628,
-0.2124512047,
0.0998035818,
0.0120288366,
-0.2201534957,
-0.3004941344,
-0.3429554999,
-0.2313685715,
0.5433418751,
0.6767878532,
0.0109259663,
-0.503448844,
0.0369670242,
-0.0087911179,
0.2163545638,
0.7337736487,
0.6769264936,
-1.0799925327,
-0.1652974486,
0.0032672917,
-0.271064043,
0.0561339706,
0.7479529977,
-0.7174032927,
0.3382616043,
0.1013884023,
0.8985506892,
0.0150706423,
-0.2066263855,
0.5522045493,
-0.1803455055,
0.3566398621,
0.3162602484,
0.5057713985,
0.2279174179,
-0.3110438883,
0.4220910966,
0.2074926645,
-0.3968973458,
-1.0207149982,
0.6247292757,
-0.7392593026,
-0.5445857048,
0.8104801774,
-0.0896516964,
-0.2831879258,
-0.2278029174,
-0.0725117773,
-0.1734024286,
-0.0464490429,
0.9357070923,
0.7820113301,
-0.0559461042,
-0.3013419509,
-0.6948293447,
0.333337754,
0.0569637008,
-0.9395821095,
0.2589845955,
0.642380178,
0.2632158399,
0.2614515126,
0.3259473145,
-0.5173537731,
0.3914180994,
-0.0031717056,
-0.1049022451,
-0.0804827139,
-0.423840344,
-0.4281925857,
0.1989215165,
0.2175820917,
0.00387702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18002v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18002v1 | Decoding with Limited Teacher Supervision Requires Understanding When to Trust the Teacher | 2024-06-26T01:16:12 | 2024-06-26T01:16:12 | Hyunjong Ok, Jegwang Ryu, Jaeho Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | How can sLLMs efficiently utilize the supervision of LLMs to improve their
generative quality? This question has been well studied in scenarios where
there is no restriction on the number of LLM supervisions one can use, giving
birth to many decoding algorithms that utilize supervision without further
training. However, it is still unclear what is an effective strategy under the
limited supervision scenario, where we assume that no more than a few tokens
can be generated by LLMs. To this end, we develop an algorithm to effectively
aggregate the sLLM and LLM predictions on initial tokens so that the generated
tokens can more accurately condition the subsequent token generation by sLLM
only. Critically, we find that it is essential to adaptively overtrust or
disregard the LLM prediction based on the confidence of the sLLM. Through our
experiments on a wide range of models and datasets, we demonstrate that our
method provides a consistent improvement over conventional decoding strategies. | [
-0.1365654618,
-0.2579389811,
0.6450204253,
0.2132298499,
-0.4951293468,
0.2487394214,
-0.0033608428,
-0.4088036716,
-0.0473052599,
0.4202231467,
-0.330624491,
-0.6545186639,
-1.0837173462,
0.1641186327,
-0.6447398663,
1.0264310837,
0.0560851358,
0.5050978065,
-0.4212382734,
0.028376041,
-0.3522035778,
-0.4735531211,
-0.7192407846,
-0.5571320057,
0.1498952806,
0.3987425268,
0.5033879876,
0.5360959768,
0.3348222673,
0.120521076,
-0.4255215824,
0.7280025482,
-0.7291374803,
0.0790251791,
-0.0516701266,
-0.6829798818,
-0.5534592271,
-0.2583271563,
0.4787699282,
0.4756996036,
-0.2456103563,
0.3439470232,
0.2614422739,
0.329313159,
-0.6963921785,
0.1556007266,
-0.9681962729,
0.2431538105,
0.1201565862,
-0.6067698598,
-0.9593138695,
-0.286559999,
-0.0412495919,
-0.6955667138,
0.1964283884,
0.1194136962,
0.4249727428,
0.0921517909,
-0.4357114136,
-0.3438362479,
-0.4372538924,
0.8818739057,
-0.4920992255,
0.330178231,
0.7912370563,
-0.0483886041,
-0.2700858414,
-0.9026270509,
-0.1426265389,
0.0884922445,
-0.2822954059,
0.2043220997,
0.0719466507,
0.2502148747,
0.2438318729,
0.1786421239,
-0.0353541523,
0.0908495933,
-0.4457344413,
-0.3917580247,
0.3010010123,
0.38083902,
-0.0144116385,
-0.0747101307,
-0.7279840112,
0.0650883541,
-0.7684851885,
0.1296564043,
0.1638607383,
0.1039715484,
0.0322437733,
0.459318459,
0.2938714027,
0.4835067093,
0.1217895746,
-0.3141842186,
-0.0877011269,
-0.3287912309,
-0.3538877964,
0.3821944892,
0.1905446947,
0.5495349169,
0.1766536683,
-0.3900204599,
-0.2866842747,
0.3902677,
0.3199035227,
-0.4875504375,
-0.0682285577,
0.1691354513,
-0.3672896326,
-0.3980042934,
0.0192983579,
-0.6931560636,
-0.6676514745,
-0.2355163693,
0.3663975894,
-0.53135252,
-0.1996599287,
0.1471449584,
-0.150899902,
0.2182453126,
0.3092355132,
-1.0088697672,
0.4947598875,
0.886205554,
0.9319527149,
-0.3778649569,
-0.4857653975,
-0.8556420803,
0.1943504214,
-0.6034244895,
0.1489913017,
-0.2280444503,
-0.6050902009,
-0.0068248729,
-0.2948499322,
-0.0795028135,
-0.1769461185,
0.5896960497,
-0.776091516,
-0.1060890555,
-0.1520471275,
-0.9477723241,
0.2948720455,
0.0329918228,
-0.4363499284,
0.7247657776,
0.3450956941,
-0.9493227005,
0.6587982774,
-0.3471806347,
-0.3709121644,
-0.0806306452,
-0.0728953257,
-0.3749705255,
0.5110801458,
0.5604977012,
0.4412417114,
0.2072154433,
0.3426437974,
-0.2094094902,
-0.7816846967,
0.3683114648,
-0.438739717,
0.9053295851,
0.2978402376,
-0.1470659077,
0.0545310825,
-0.5559691787,
0.2224072814,
-0.0782369152,
-0.3168569505,
-0.2929936349,
-0.0097934427,
-0.2305383384,
-0.4590936899,
0.1162102818,
-0.2971960604,
0.1088125631,
-0.644579947,
0.4119438231,
1.2810980082,
0.1706769615,
0.7357190847,
-0.1877099723,
0.5759916306,
0.1808235496,
0.317903161,
-0.4600067735,
-0.1376611292,
-1.1145629883,
-0.1565852016,
0.2353758514,
0.2646568418,
-0.8937989473,
0.1982096732,
-0.4088871181,
-0.0157830101,
-0.8365045786,
0.3812502027,
0.494774431,
0.3256269693,
0.4551739097,
-0.4210924506,
-0.973798573,
-0.3165054023,
-0.1844394505,
-0.0359474756,
0.1356949359,
0.060882099,
0.295593679,
-0.0332635753,
0.9330986738,
-0.3088511527,
-0.3406585157,
-0.0319244973,
-0.1122598574,
0.4339274764,
0.4934582412,
0.4525097013,
-0.525331676,
-0.6424754858,
-0.1270494759,
-0.7596186399,
0.4066605866,
-0.2601944804,
-0.2230780423,
0.2862927616,
0.6550011635,
-0.6956461072,
0.4436701238,
0.6626764536,
-0.520662725,
0.3188663125,
-0.3319757581,
-0.2352523804,
-0.9237543344,
-0.3978059292,
-0.4107963741,
-0.6224386692,
-0.624740541,
0.3434328437,
0.1117863506,
0.1246531829,
-0.2056103647,
0.197074011,
-0.6963369846,
-0.2091928422,
-0.2611966431,
0.0071033407,
-0.050487265,
0.3531312943,
-0.0618756115,
0.9044575691,
0.950971663,
-0.4090300798,
0.238381505,
0.2017070353,
-0.660348475,
0.461794734,
-0.4423778057,
0.3090700209,
-0.1883815229,
0.2689040899,
-0.8633107543,
-0.050076507,
0.2351714224,
-0.567435503,
0.4499893785,
-0.2894468904,
-0.4942707419,
-0.2779736221,
-0.2369273454,
0.2602662742,
0.7994847894,
-0.9543762207,
0.6766783595,
0.0204004198,
0.3382350802,
-0.7937943339,
-0.8118514419,
0.2442965508,
-0.1733831465,
-0.1981714517,
0.1342248172,
0.0921305567,
-0.1395723373,
0.2389020026,
-0.5289641023,
-0.0728576928,
0.3031896949,
0.4028269053,
0.2382384837,
-0.1731201261,
-0.1422650367,
0.1727786958,
-0.2250627875,
0.2161372751,
-0.5816780925,
0.4448950291,
0.1063946858,
-0.5389635563,
-0.1344563663,
0.2391763926,
0.633730948,
0.0091071753,
0.9116052985,
0.7984979749,
-0.1785937846,
-0.7794382572,
-0.3030444384,
-0.3568832576,
-0.5269855857,
0.1075153723,
-0.3897230029,
-0.8743385673,
0.423831135,
0.1461032778,
-0.0570043251,
-0.1063466817,
0.2953751385,
0.0289080981,
0.9574970007,
0.6121529937,
-0.3299989998,
0.2938963175,
-0.2743026018,
0.0121691357,
-0.8316220641,
-0.3111912012,
0.1078098118,
0.0223153438,
-0.3916542232,
-0.5502302647,
0.3751643598,
0.3446448147,
0.0219850969,
0.1694276929,
-0.6621370912,
0.6369680762,
0.7992201447,
0.5848011971,
0.4242910445,
0.2834671736,
-0.1617740244,
0.0613572486,
-0.8874312639,
-0.2182405293,
1.2988781929,
0.5145841837,
0.8048642874,
0.0928795487,
1.1999505758,
0.4344664514,
0.3862799406,
-0.6341811419,
0.4258753061,
-0.0451398157,
-0.5526525974,
-0.300212115,
-0.3508735597,
-0.8524954319,
0.4534358978,
-0.2319316715,
-0.6023294926,
0.1751602441,
0.3397013247,
-0.2086978108,
0.2703924179,
-0.607919395,
0.2962277234,
0.0097193336,
-0.3327391148,
-0.1790788323,
-0.6545284986,
0.4245251715,
-0.2247453183,
0.1591334641,
0.0892044827,
-0.0634291098,
0.4512937367,
-0.2965945303,
1.149399519,
-0.3403586447,
-0.1085873693,
0.4735929072,
0.0965858027,
0.7916452885,
0.157148093,
-0.1104807109,
-0.1616719067,
0.0578159019,
-0.5649946928,
-0.5995460749,
0.5064262152,
-0.9090198874,
-0.596883297,
-0.449077934,
-0.3930599988,
-0.3750720322,
0.1305048317,
0.5428782701,
0.2139326781,
0.1793929785,
0.2764003277,
0.6542483568,
0.1976529956,
0.373462081,
0.140944168,
-0.1462901086,
-0.5498579741,
0.8539401293,
0.000804081,
0.3573418856,
0.0559462458,
0.0238461588,
-0.3369274139,
-0.9567751884,
-0.0840826258,
-0.2446271181,
-1.0641541481,
-0.6126715541,
-0.201686576,
-0.2468273342,
-0.41138044,
-0.207555756,
-0.0377390459,
0.0108702378,
-0.745770216,
-0.6351952553,
0.4358435869,
0.5661541224,
0.0036777505,
0.501330018,
-0.6624515057,
0.1604584455,
0.30221048,
0.4563364983,
0.261120826,
-0.7173312902,
-0.3364368379,
-0.0085596358,
0.1527197808,
-0.7334669828,
0.2912609577,
0.1601042598,
0.6831459999,
0.4717343748,
0.3834337592,
0.9272953868,
-0.3643012941,
0.7542579174,
0.4851426482,
-1.2810937166,
0.2475661635,
-0.0792318955,
-0.0408732742,
0.3697374165,
0.0757942274,
-0.1068450287,
-0.6383072138,
-0.5296241045,
-0.8993341327,
0.9311287403,
0.3057599664,
0.5004982948,
0.0491410606,
0.4216764271,
0.1181553975,
0.1449497938,
-0.885510087,
-0.2200285196,
-0.5177010298,
-0.3039694428,
-0.3633093238,
-0.9200137258,
-0.5060934424,
-0.2019068003,
0.3246763647,
-0.0640613586,
0.2578881383,
0.218291223,
-0.2670750022,
-0.1805059761,
0.227752015,
0.6458320022,
0.8593617082,
-0.1965019852,
0.6216958165,
0.7233669758,
-0.385692507,
0.2156538665,
-0.5075927973,
-0.2163057178,
0.0681949109,
0.7978586555,
1.1651542187,
0.1501019448,
-0.370200187,
0.5299034119,
0.2756817341,
-0.4046236575,
-0.4622226357,
0.270608753,
-0.0143102054,
0.3849774003,
0.4867907763,
0.0536909737,
-0.1821155101,
-0.2244973183,
0.610712409,
0.2296902686,
-0.2198593765,
-0.1654238701,
0.5200044513,
0.1072809547,
-0.0487551577,
0.5013762712,
-0.2070634067,
-0.4753173888,
0.5238595605,
0.8638551831,
0.642799437,
-0.0493198745,
0.162360698,
0.2287884802,
0.3567226231,
-0.36397928,
0.0527694784,
-0.1441673934,
-0.9721451402,
-0.5123975873,
-0.6669204831,
-0.3556137383,
-0.132025376,
-1.0490909815,
0.0437595211,
-0.7008911967,
-0.3365106881,
-0.574143827,
-0.1252505779,
-0.4966256022,
0.1699314266,
0.0494598113,
0.9453374743,
-0.8747509122,
1.0592665672,
0.2948144674,
-0.050760068,
-0.9696726203,
-0.1641588062,
-0.3169365227,
-1.3288980722,
0.6051104665,
0.0040701921,
-0.3427954316,
0.28333655,
-0.6744285822,
-0.6615387797,
1.267596364,
0.3294803798,
-0.4587356746,
-0.0595231391,
-0.1264727712,
0.6473895907,
-0.4078493714,
-0.1825932115,
0.5571880341,
0.3297909796,
0.2006434053,
-0.5578214526,
0.0149378544,
0.1978576332,
-0.0793788806,
-0.0558418743,
-0.2573525906,
0.7337038517,
-0.3574718237,
-0.4578156769,
0.2018647194,
0.7670645118,
0.0983109474,
0.7119598985,
0.5675186515,
0.4312784672,
0.7605714798,
0.1887352616,
0.9392071962,
-0.4021631777,
0.653190434,
1.4030383825,
0.121648483,
0.6871091723,
0.6964672804,
-0.2919461131,
0.1017721221,
0.6604716778,
-0.3423020244,
0.7431381941,
-0.0710916221,
-0.3746606112,
-0.5491121411,
-0.285567224,
-0.2462058365,
0.3859996796,
0.3375764489,
-0.7195269465,
-0.0866646171,
-0.0436344333,
-0.1918013394,
0.2266273499,
-0.6515069604,
0.8172550201,
0.3227412999,
-0.6171654463,
0.7152740955,
-0.0555450507,
0.647064805,
-0.4863215685,
0.2705951929,
-0.336661011,
0.04532291,
-0.5104564428,
-0.6285973191,
0.1123690754,
-0.1129420176,
0.0763559416,
-0.4288445115,
0.8192234635,
-0.4770185947,
-0.435180217,
0.4743465185,
0.4940628707,
-0.0769052207,
0.4326140881,
-0.1505511403,
0.0981909409,
0.1076958999,
-0.0214360021,
0.3840355575,
0.3417939544,
0.3187671602,
0.6965927482,
0.6582813859,
0.4212630391,
0.3054195046,
-0.0249136817,
0.9139999747,
-0.3142917752,
-0.3830094635,
-1.0937253237,
0.3133552969,
0.0121618332,
-0.006000794,
0.9132079482,
0.2419570833,
0.8597583175,
-0.1576509178,
0.7209573388,
0.4325594008,
0.1602935791,
-0.8992910981,
0.4273833036,
-0.3854624927,
0.2950773239,
-0.0582672246,
-0.6337378025,
-0.3392403722,
0.6935330629,
0.1111779213,
-0.3138576746,
0.5732886791,
0.6332798004,
-0.0682988092,
-0.0724085718,
0.4850484431,
-0.0191406421,
0.1473702937,
0.6353247166,
0.9172524214,
-0.1373333186,
0.7289540768,
-0.2075067014,
0.198746264,
-0.1825848669,
-0.8055984378,
-1.0929516554,
-0.254833132,
0.1153762341,
-0.5057172775,
0.0496522114,
0.8498908281,
0.6020299792,
-0.8357307911,
-0.0111087291,
-0.4101263285,
0.4501643479,
-0.2364285588,
-0.1343160868,
0.4234427512,
-0.5261383653,
-0.6698551178,
0.3633908629,
-0.0349330492,
0.2499219328,
-0.2251751423,
-0.4182328582,
0.4456416368,
0.0645554364,
0.7618584633,
-0.2649224401,
-0.8505769968,
-0.4645388722,
0.0327637382,
-0.239340201,
0.0011710653,
0.9359273314,
-0.3222978115,
0.6586919427,
0.2680874467,
0.7566512227,
0.6181329489,
0.227931574,
0.3928719461,
-1.0835291147,
0.0855158195,
0.3108425438,
0.2283341736,
0.0815067366,
-0.4671179652,
0.5810211301,
0.1609959006,
-0.2497828752,
-1.2561988831,
0.2897842228,
-0.9125334024,
-0.2584418058,
1.1657267809,
-0.5534723401,
-0.0185372382,
-0.0841335729,
-0.0627479106,
0.197395891,
-0.4173103869,
0.7503919601,
0.6681146026,
-0.0008813379,
-0.3477503061,
-0.0909154788,
0.5558211803,
0.4837486446,
-0.2486526072,
0.0862329304,
0.2817257643,
0.279319793,
-0.015769178,
0.7650952935,
0.1556562185,
0.3385486603,
0.3531503975,
-0.5603449941,
-0.4881002307,
-0.4623109996,
-0.4290184081,
0.4366441071,
0.4566658437,
-0.4469948709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17992v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17992v1 | Catching Chameleons: Detecting Evolving Disinformation Generated using Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T00:21:39 | 2024-06-26T00:21:39 | Bohan Jiang, Chengshuai Zhao, Zhen Tan, Huan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite recent advancements in detecting disinformation generated by large
language models (LLMs), current efforts overlook the ever-evolving nature of
this disinformation. In this work, we investigate a challenging yet practical
research problem of detecting evolving LLM-generated disinformation.
Disinformation evolves constantly through the rapid development of LLMs and
their variants. As a consequence, the detection model faces significant
challenges. First, it is inefficient to train separate models for each
disinformation generator. Second, the performance decreases in scenarios when
evolving LLM-generated disinformation is encountered in sequential order. To
address this problem, we propose DELD (Detecting Evolving LLM-generated
Disinformation), a parameter-efficient approach that jointly leverages the
general fact-checking capabilities of pre-trained language models (PLM) and the
independent disinformation generation characteristics of various LLMs. In
particular, the learned characteristics are concatenated sequentially to
facilitate knowledge accumulation and transformation. DELD addresses the issue
of label scarcity by integrating the semantic embeddings of disinformation with
trainable soft prompts to elicit model-specific knowledge. Our experiments show
that \textit{DELD} significantly outperforms state-of-the-art methods.
Moreover, our method provides critical insights into the unique patterns of
disinformation generation across different LLMs, offering valuable perspectives
in this line of research. | [
-0.3959718049,
-0.9163991213,
0.5292382836,
0.0354150273,
-0.5674883127,
0.1595254242,
-0.1979338229,
-0.1595755965,
-0.0456718616,
0.6229203343,
-0.5755331516,
-0.6135011911,
-0.9243929386,
0.0879977196,
-0.483075887,
0.9835845828,
0.3193223774,
-0.4039799869,
-0.1266359687,
0.0264287926,
-0.3408893943,
-0.4490992427,
-0.6585214138,
-0.2880086899,
0.5893293023,
0.4356794655,
0.4052596092,
0.7347591519,
0.28731516,
0.3272179961,
-0.2978631258,
0.6253608465,
-0.4141948819,
0.3886880875,
-0.0906419605,
-0.4333593845,
0.0002836487,
0.0779891461,
0.4063795209,
0.5221999884,
-0.2656387985,
0.1175721586,
0.0228867605,
0.5070950985,
-0.6831060648,
0.2397685498,
-0.9403830171,
-0.1096694022,
-0.569873929,
-0.3788911104,
-0.5746175051,
-0.4295744002,
-0.0695659146,
-0.0259657651,
0.1895240992,
-0.1575565934,
0.5361551046,
0.4311395288,
-0.3847913742,
-0.6420634985,
-0.8036535978,
0.595582068,
-0.9505190253,
0.3000467122,
0.1985336095,
0.1666573137,
-0.4911502898,
-0.7717776299,
-1.0614581108,
-0.3714526892,
0.142322585,
-0.3007448316,
-0.3527265191,
-0.2902731299,
0.3679801822,
0.137833938,
-0.6156108975,
0.5462415814,
-0.0658794791,
-0.0867016241,
0.6021232605,
-0.0785631835,
0.4368923008,
-0.1257683784,
-0.3106633425,
-0.0473945439,
-0.6979487538,
-0.2434242219,
0.3893545866,
0.2334943861,
-0.0606774017,
0.2871840596,
-0.0333192907,
0.623126924,
0.2424204946,
-0.2839396894,
0.3523851633,
0.0054768049,
-0.0606345758,
0.4107441008,
0.6461557746,
0.0289242472,
0.2531895638,
0.057905145,
-0.3872170448,
0.0787656307,
0.0850838795,
-0.5535293221,
-0.4035981297,
0.0610062666,
-0.2966267467,
-0.5417984128,
-0.1606201977,
-1.0829257965,
-0.9253938794,
-0.2154872864,
0.0954149589,
-0.5393707752,
-0.3400404155,
0.2668311894,
-0.0710434616,
0.1411355883,
0.3419487178,
-0.7880241275,
-0.132778585,
0.8535131812,
0.8087035418,
-0.0678833202,
-0.233382374,
-0.6101487279,
0.127870813,
-0.1389106363,
0.7297582626,
-0.5475421548,
-0.3457348347,
0.0621407442,
-0.071281977,
0.1741447747,
-0.768723309,
0.4387375116,
-0.840305388,
0.0885247812,
-0.1249631047,
-0.5467201471,
-0.3125526011,
0.4000066519,
-0.6677699089,
0.702866137,
0.072034657,
-0.9451339245,
0.5606408119,
-0.4436532557,
-0.3872914612,
0.3232316971,
-0.2522770166,
-0.6762894988,
0.0685686618,
0.2458069772,
0.3550896347,
-0.3384805918,
0.3632972538,
-0.4496667683,
0.05523609,
0.4770041108,
-0.6159684062,
0.8069848418,
0.3571092784,
-0.5599216223,
-0.3141098619,
-0.8519178629,
-0.2241236866,
0.2149147093,
-0.4089578986,
-0.7220112681,
0.2369985133,
-0.5939387679,
0.30148983,
0.2786868513,
-0.3185636401,
0.2940862179,
0.0087039061,
0.3829590082,
0.7875367403,
0.5198484063,
-0.0439735502,
-0.2914049029,
0.3353909254,
0.7208494544,
0.1965663433,
-0.3741768003,
-0.2744292617,
-0.9188122749,
-0.3360568881,
0.045765195,
0.4091615379,
-0.908242166,
0.6508215666,
-0.2209846079,
-0.6789063215,
-0.2813239992,
0.31933406,
0.2741765082,
0.5088634491,
0.3828909695,
0.0170179177,
-0.4485556781,
-0.8239628673,
-0.1878603101,
-0.0783108696,
0.1800181121,
-0.195434168,
0.5098859072,
-0.6655961275,
0.8761638403,
-0.5922602415,
0.2561179399,
-0.2241664976,
0.3677200973,
0.1913257241,
0.5499535203,
0.6935911775,
-0.9101184607,
-0.2184187025,
-0.0646422058,
-0.7100813985,
-0.3829723001,
-0.1985042095,
0.2014299333,
-0.0502886809,
0.5371395946,
-0.5527170897,
0.1341551244,
0.3625752628,
-0.0570215173,
0.4193454981,
-0.1377331018,
0.2219041288,
-0.9353775382,
-0.0775224641,
0.1982961297,
-0.0605082326,
-0.7636232972,
-0.1610581428,
0.0517180525,
0.1045837775,
-0.4395566881,
0.1578415781,
-0.438046664,
0.3550057411,
-0.2382308841,
0.369002074,
-0.2253643721,
0.2627934217,
-0.1198249906,
0.3974689543,
0.3714481294,
-1.0180715322,
0.4440190494,
0.026134152,
-0.5388646126,
0.3366558552,
-0.4719272256,
0.3050895631,
-0.5038300157,
0.0804049298,
-0.8767230511,
-0.0680197328,
0.4790832698,
-0.2006726861,
0.5359995365,
-0.2714052796,
-0.6461904645,
-0.4989156425,
-0.2320500016,
0.4354296327,
0.6716141105,
-0.7739272118,
0.0591593273,
0.4766243994,
-0.3978689611,
-0.5434247851,
-0.6291270256,
-0.0954965577,
-0.4823462367,
-0.5753285289,
-0.0759728029,
0.0018061075,
-0.4166854918,
-0.2472542971,
-0.2483351827,
0.0830516145,
0.091238074,
-0.0602595806,
0.0500943214,
-0.1844083071,
0.1432543248,
0.2162616849,
-0.0580879524,
-0.0276487134,
-0.6371631622,
0.8605320454,
0.2446191758,
-0.4557598531,
-0.4595282972,
-0.0387643911,
0.9787726402,
-0.4355420172,
0.8544944525,
0.3357398808,
-0.2938372791,
-0.8363379836,
-0.8070391417,
-0.1235953867,
-0.535674274,
0.432569176,
0.0702353939,
-0.599350512,
0.3896113038,
-0.5322407484,
0.0049447143,
0.2447314709,
0.440040797,
0.2201398313,
0.7949260473,
0.4775711,
0.0343953483,
0.4699728191,
-0.1750967503,
0.2194823474,
-0.5122493505,
-0.578985095,
-0.5669326782,
-0.3479458094,
-0.726098001,
-0.4659254253,
0.1950262636,
0.1547185034,
-0.1504080594,
0.2600177824,
-0.4174506962,
0.5356580615,
0.3221719861,
0.1034866422,
0.443290174,
-0.0786377415,
-0.0056052106,
-0.0055900849,
-0.4800658226,
-0.5805122256,
0.8185377717,
0.2918987572,
0.8816014528,
0.2782518268,
0.7933693528,
0.7750852704,
0.294816941,
-0.3815482259,
0.5666996837,
-0.2284783572,
-0.1148463115,
-0.0834280401,
-0.5399206877,
-0.8651278019,
0.1388147324,
0.101714544,
-0.6911269426,
0.3928387463,
0.1839360297,
-0.0467811264,
0.4676823616,
-0.3527097702,
0.5564823747,
-0.430983454,
-0.1317926943,
-0.2146527022,
-0.4004320204,
0.8308685422,
-0.5793187618,
0.2296949178,
-0.2044559568,
-0.0752416551,
0.5554410815,
-0.3359667361,
0.8572232723,
-0.3450074196,
-0.5021399856,
0.5540078282,
0.2658213079,
0.6691216826,
0.3176769018,
-0.1336512566,
0.0238797013,
-0.37335971,
-0.2547904253,
-0.6661874652,
0.8052908778,
-0.6769652367,
-0.6765629053,
-0.4477183819,
-0.2902942598,
-0.01654757,
0.208976388,
0.378098011,
0.3802650273,
0.0824298263,
0.0101678073,
0.927611053,
-0.4762242436,
0.5041373372,
0.8194177747,
-0.0681740642,
-0.2116530091,
1.0423024893,
0.0020627256,
0.1692287177,
0.372949034,
0.1898335367,
-0.4572404325,
-0.8777699471,
-0.2384334654,
0.3539826572,
-0.6889100671,
-0.2147389054,
-0.5897396803,
-0.1925580651,
-0.2820216417,
0.2127579004,
-0.1771180779,
-0.0553609282,
-0.284470737,
0.1352961808,
0.262103498,
0.7748981118,
0.0342812948,
0.2229337394,
-1.065430522,
0.0720050707,
0.3611739278,
0.0430405885,
0.0681623369,
-0.5927275419,
0.0680626184,
0.3619309664,
-0.3567656577,
-1.0400453806,
0.3801231384,
0.0257202387,
0.7602030039,
0.7709574699,
0.3976072073,
0.2561445534,
-0.2427694798,
0.8458437324,
0.1052537188,
-0.8390647769,
0.7550537586,
-0.2844093144,
0.2497871965,
0.4367330372,
0.5564572811,
-0.6971697211,
-0.327200532,
-0.5184280276,
-0.6251884103,
0.6688273549,
-0.1197449043,
0.0491874628,
-0.4002971351,
0.4115103483,
0.3354123235,
0.5997823477,
-0.5950797796,
-0.1444198936,
-0.0098341694,
-0.025939405,
-0.0909487531,
-0.391107887,
0.0250368658,
0.0791733339,
0.6450143456,
0.1519351453,
-0.2924152911,
-0.1470199972,
-0.3654819727,
0.2935591042,
0.3441167772,
0.7873410583,
0.287962079,
0.2551601529,
0.5367571712,
-0.0214051809,
-0.5099562407,
0.4200138152,
-0.1413055062,
-0.3871634305,
0.1066087633,
0.4169491529,
0.6604187489,
0.0398344286,
-0.8464487791,
0.5312637687,
0.1814487576,
0.086578086,
-0.2722420692,
0.2054238319,
-0.1721683443,
0.281019479,
0.1509567052,
0.0973034278,
-0.1552934647,
-0.4738211036,
0.5100349188,
0.2029938549,
-0.1436291635,
-0.4228363037,
0.3128055036,
0.4064553082,
-0.4212031066,
0.9528666735,
-0.6465280056,
-0.5532619357,
0.5608654022,
0.5917288661,
0.9011623263,
-0.4293672442,
0.3414741158,
0.108165659,
0.3724095523,
-0.1024443656,
-0.0912198126,
-0.102332361,
-0.7776240706,
-0.0320008583,
-0.7383767962,
0.0581647493,
0.8050742149,
-0.3873969018,
0.5893313885,
-0.5162155628,
-0.0688759238,
0.0110470578,
-0.3479556739,
-0.4189404845,
-0.1598357409,
0.3390344679,
0.7513772845,
-0.882237494,
0.7287687659,
0.4656200111,
-0.4385749996,
-0.3707108498,
0.3713749349,
0.4084454775,
-0.6553962827,
0.7414792776,
0.1226280481,
-0.2095639706,
0.0842788517,
-0.5586251616,
-0.6180843711,
0.9888254404,
0.4155579209,
-0.986757338,
0.1741700172,
0.1824103743,
0.3159825504,
-0.1914848089,
-0.0380801447,
0.8267191052,
0.5741313696,
0.1294108033,
-0.4323303401,
0.0663636774,
-0.2149111629,
-0.0117495656,
0.4259935915,
-0.5571415424,
0.9374901652,
-0.3300532103,
-0.5331107974,
-0.1135613024,
0.4925492704,
0.2644250393,
0.5039526224,
0.7465964556,
0.5118944049,
1.0765028,
0.0239202175,
0.5205213428,
-0.4848031998,
0.3767168224,
1.1656918526,
-0.4582660198,
0.4826940298,
0.3295967281,
0.0645247623,
0.6127077341,
0.581764698,
-0.2965654731,
0.6327626109,
0.6049591899,
-0.6377019286,
-0.2387673855,
-0.0264692008,
-0.4199100733,
0.7117288113,
0.4809477627,
-0.3901863098,
-0.4418209195,
0.1204069033,
0.1470241845,
0.2185173184,
-0.1544180661,
0.7397072911,
-0.1372413486,
-0.6363888979,
0.5645942092,
-0.0567122661,
0.8892921209,
-0.6661127806,
-0.0782502741,
-0.3327567577,
0.3928924203,
-0.0904601589,
-0.409722209,
0.0210291538,
0.0735557228,
-0.1824461073,
0.1135395169,
0.5830760002,
-0.7502686977,
-0.0716963261,
0.2000623494,
0.6355009079,
-0.0740998313,
0.133367151,
-0.4176465571,
0.3138947487,
0.0780376494,
-0.0368944369,
0.2448472828,
0.6963974237,
-0.0035883496,
0.8409305811,
0.6466588974,
-0.0163788907,
0.1690974683,
0.0386697873,
0.9542459249,
-0.2986274064,
-0.5292018652,
-1.2943466902,
0.2498612106,
-0.2700813115,
-0.1809918433,
0.7740520239,
0.5161716342,
0.8054368496,
-0.2808081508,
0.9840433002,
0.0222638454,
0.2415099889,
-0.5508236885,
0.8318194151,
-0.3820438087,
0.7498483062,
-0.2728831768,
-0.8545662761,
-0.0096664401,
0.1832213998,
-0.2593943179,
0.0787504241,
0.6321943998,
0.8625384569,
-0.1420543939,
0.2176119238,
0.0764522776,
0.3748592138,
0.6909670234,
0.3840581477,
1.202139616,
0.150401935,
0.3612901568,
-0.0851264969,
-0.3573635221,
-0.2786157429,
-0.9684858322,
-0.8705875278,
-0.6379176974,
-0.708088994,
-0.279597044,
-0.0258031916,
0.8028895855,
0.5436871648,
-0.7073575854,
0.1916667819,
-0.221814543,
0.1330435723,
-0.1569085121,
-0.2196903825,
0.1166115403,
-0.3852471411,
-0.7128359675,
0.3492349088,
0.2598459721,
0.3452637494,
-0.3834896088,
0.0054379534,
-0.2882184386,
0.196917206,
0.530234158,
0.4502650797,
-0.5908408165,
-0.4271867573,
-0.4339305758,
-0.1051461101,
-0.4243040383,
0.9931284189,
-0.664150238,
0.455645591,
0.5738535523,
0.6969240904,
0.2980856299,
-0.0954311565,
0.2797204852,
-0.9797670245,
0.2357651591,
0.3231686652,
0.1490763575,
0.3723654151,
-0.2588683665,
0.1329346001,
0.5068625808,
-0.5319128633,
-1.0010688305,
0.4575665295,
-0.8156577945,
-0.2589869499,
1.087123394,
-0.130739674,
-0.0788037404,
-0.2877373397,
-0.062882565,
0.2798418701,
-0.3197191954,
1.0563025475,
0.3458435535,
-0.0421524979,
-0.0720604882,
-0.2170540541,
0.6336407065,
-0.1967267245,
-0.9608412981,
0.267709136,
0.4493065774,
0.4846439362,
0.472912848,
0.3115256131,
0.0612076856,
0.1728793234,
0.1838006228,
-0.2191897184,
-0.4153521657,
-0.2655972838,
-0.318505615,
0.1111707389,
0.1499158144,
-0.387041986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17990v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17990v1 | Explicit Diversity Conditions for Effective Question Answer Generation with Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T00:12:08 | 2024-06-26T00:12:08 | Vikas Yadav, Hyuk Joon Kwon, Vijay Srinivasan, Hongxia Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Question Answer Generation (QAG) is an effective data augmentation technique
to improve the accuracy of question answering systems, especially in
low-resource domains. While recent pretrained and large language model-based
QAG methods have made substantial progress, they face the critical issue of
redundant QA pair generation, affecting downstream QA systems. Implicit
diversity techniques such as sampling and diverse beam search are proven
effective solutions but often yield smaller diversity. We present explicit
diversity conditions for QAG, focusing on spatial aspects, question types, and
entities, substantially increasing diversity in QA generation. Our work
emphasizes the need of explicit diversity conditions for generating diverse
question-answer synthetic data by showing significant improvements in
downstream QA task over existing widely adopted implicit diversity techniques.
In particular, generated QA pairs from explicit diversity conditions when used
to train the downstream QA model results in an average 4.1% exact match and
4.5% F1 improvement over QAG from implicit sampling techniques on SQuADDU. Our
work emphasizes the need for explicit diversity conditions even more in
low-resource datasets (SubjQA), where average downstream QA performance
improvements are around 12% EM. | [
-0.7273429632,
-0.9049546719,
0.5331503749,
0.3385117054,
-0.3134782016,
0.2313886136,
0.1870376915,
-0.3782987297,
-0.2848030329,
0.2105354816,
-0.6394607425,
-0.4366829693,
-0.2728825212,
0.2147132307,
-0.2359362394,
0.9601097703,
-0.0589088127,
0.1591249406,
-0.257275641,
-0.4539033771,
-0.6045151949,
-0.4883008897,
-0.6801454425,
0.1856270432,
0.4218942821,
0.3741566241,
0.6554064751,
0.1449740529,
0.2256975919,
0.2829005718,
-0.2053148448,
0.4623550177,
-0.6802068949,
0.34614259,
-0.2087904513,
-0.1438822597,
-0.186230585,
-0.2072671354,
0.8444154263,
0.8360251188,
-0.2854771614,
0.1543561369,
-0.244016543,
0.5344024897,
-0.7153532505,
-0.2188271731,
-0.7305850983,
0.0017594433,
0.1440574378,
-0.1484252065,
-0.1553440243,
-0.7761455774,
0.1299656034,
-0.7298555374,
0.4647602737,
0.2384647578,
0.7426376939,
0.0095462557,
-0.8658159971,
-0.165612936,
-0.7730416656,
0.668628633,
-0.5600518584,
0.2419268787,
0.1742619574,
0.2822453976,
-0.3004491031,
-0.562102735,
-0.7409245372,
0.2305234075,
-0.1339607537,
0.2027548254,
-0.2215518504,
0.2415565103,
0.4341393411,
0.4244063199,
-0.7652362585,
-0.1267657578,
-0.5963878036,
0.0378921814,
0.8874953985,
0.2315545678,
0.4259704053,
-0.0102791777,
-0.2023352087,
-0.1956908107,
-0.821428597,
0.2686139941,
0.7024404407,
0.2592234015,
0.0579179265,
0.3827426434,
-0.5799213052,
0.4567312598,
0.2633786201,
0.2206027508,
0.292988658,
-0.8954414725,
-0.1107850522,
-0.2831463516,
0.2719973624,
0.1487055719,
0.0969154835,
-0.153517887,
-0.3426029384,
-0.4714049101,
0.2100244164,
-0.8873560429,
-0.0332201757,
0.5278924108,
-0.206559211,
0.1705746204,
-0.1210409999,
-0.8330937624,
-0.1995141208,
-0.0884561464,
0.2240096778,
-0.094900921,
-0.5100241303,
-0.0012396736,
-0.3602862656,
0.8647664785,
0.2026689798,
-0.6336724162,
-0.023500884,
0.3102017939,
0.3674516678,
-0.1296857893,
-0.0455427095,
-0.6328550577,
0.0285698213,
-0.3982413411,
0.8660637736,
-0.2995669842,
-0.6598960161,
0.1040677279,
-0.3163807392,
0.0136782713,
-0.6133890152,
0.4690127671,
-0.8914746642,
0.4320582747,
-0.5021005273,
-0.3320847154,
-0.1035621017,
0.0946528465,
-0.6828125119,
0.7550128102,
0.4328990579,
-0.4445012808,
0.4689508677,
-0.5235163569,
-0.4460202157,
0.3032321036,
-0.036062751,
-0.4674834013,
-0.125047788,
0.3075573146,
-0.1998594701,
-0.0877252966,
0.2403619885,
-0.4652772248,
-0.2320141345,
0.0112974141,
-0.0824392959,
0.7469816208,
0.4195717871,
-0.2235132158,
0.0775729343,
-0.4966028035,
0.4514161646,
0.0626358837,
-0.4736664891,
-0.1740235835,
0.0787926465,
-0.0839653984,
0.2030614913,
-0.0182266608,
-0.5914393067,
0.0543823093,
-0.252672106,
-0.0031278683,
0.600939393,
0.4049793184,
0.5389415622,
-0.2112000138,
0.9259886146,
-0.1114691794,
0.1083623618,
-0.0229717698,
-0.7043250203,
-0.4366349876,
-0.2195926458,
0.1342464685,
0.4799800515,
-0.955681026,
0.1895176917,
0.0446101464,
-0.1664605886,
-0.5645940304,
0.2452588528,
0.4628807604,
0.358359009,
0.3419578075,
0.149171412,
-0.7670102119,
-0.9848667979,
0.0181879271,
-0.3258419335,
0.1099522784,
0.4698868394,
0.2539063394,
-0.0098486673,
1.1445024014,
-0.5095273256,
0.313773632,
-0.4072297215,
0.1223202273,
0.2113030702,
0.5883752704,
0.928945303,
-1.2452898026,
-0.2302372903,
-0.3593202531,
-0.5718622208,
-0.4174946845,
0.1517094225,
-0.6468230486,
0.301263243,
0.2492738068,
-0.7434436083,
0.2051902413,
0.7409200072,
-0.63259238,
0.3651907444,
0.1775333285,
0.2958290279,
-0.9603297114,
0.1208907589,
-0.1483718157,
-0.2355192304,
-0.7861204743,
0.646795392,
-0.2355805337,
-0.3093706071,
-0.4805587828,
0.6051262021,
-0.2353374958,
0.0594981238,
-0.2419057637,
0.1460216939,
0.0833718553,
0.4098979235,
-0.0038532447,
0.8345012665,
0.2109607309,
-0.592643857,
0.2784885466,
0.3637180924,
-0.0223518256,
0.4875092804,
-1.0868625641,
0.148150295,
-0.4549903572,
0.4874027967,
-1.333439827,
-0.2694424987,
0.079216294,
-0.3387564719,
0.059255477,
-0.0469564684,
-0.3270170689,
-0.2983034253,
-0.2509461045,
1.0197309256,
0.9470930099,
-0.6501691937,
0.461035639,
0.1972874105,
-0.4069196284,
-0.4675641656,
-0.3162191212,
-0.4449792802,
-0.0288724191,
-0.8406197429,
0.0731786191,
-0.3435446918,
-0.210164547,
0.0095197773,
-0.1466452628,
-0.3395895958,
0.1984689683,
-0.0140409889,
0.2402459979,
-0.3994628191,
0.1942074746,
0.4728054702,
0.4300457239,
0.008474133,
-0.2176780701,
0.4632671475,
0.0768229514,
-0.4458112419,
0.2842496932,
1.0044739246,
0.1234497651,
-0.4724332392,
0.7535182834,
0.6578015685,
-0.1627360433,
-0.3318651021,
-0.3578653634,
-0.2177286297,
-0.4877713621,
0.5723272562,
-0.1935016513,
-1.1831287146,
0.6968863606,
0.523345232,
0.4269070923,
0.4517324567,
0.4196407199,
-0.2695896626,
1.3491315842,
0.2414994836,
0.5477902293,
0.2726733387,
0.0730307922,
0.3087416887,
-0.5213370919,
-0.3477471173,
-0.5646896958,
-0.3874494135,
-0.7967081666,
-0.2903124392,
0.470494628,
0.3449295759,
-0.172262013,
-0.2813743949,
-0.1727126092,
0.4237012863,
0.5889261961,
-0.1153278053,
0.0867570564,
-0.0765293539,
0.2672109604,
0.2369544059,
-0.8546330333,
-0.1166414022,
0.9942926168,
0.0500091314,
0.4142752588,
0.3938224912,
0.7655996084,
0.3126114011,
0.2469515055,
-0.3236778677,
0.5112551451,
0.0851298571,
-0.9066463113,
-0.3475469649,
-0.6581045389,
-1.1237180233,
0.5077940226,
-0.3341698349,
-0.0883057714,
0.4138677418,
0.3203321397,
-0.4685572684,
0.0131337931,
-0.9498898983,
0.5813384652,
-0.0410484746,
-0.2470174581,
-0.0646603256,
-0.4353076816,
0.5624659657,
-0.1158067659,
-0.1787598878,
-0.1300312281,
0.0960587487,
0.3621613979,
-0.1531410515,
0.3735856414,
-0.5375633836,
-0.3916580677,
0.6955063939,
-0.1801687181,
0.4824519753,
0.2645760477,
0.0096771177,
-0.0967283919,
-0.146921277,
-1.0278446674,
-0.7506958246,
0.4708429575,
-0.8372638226,
-0.8338712454,
-0.0808437169,
-0.8075054884,
-0.3699726462,
0.0045432616,
0.189187482,
0.4035105407,
0.0532597192,
0.3921374977,
0.7767121792,
-0.4705832601,
0.3215913177,
0.6631807685,
-0.1878077239,
-0.3590193391,
0.6741066575,
-0.0413993783,
0.4139296412,
0.0161273312,
-0.3514831066,
-0.6692657471,
-0.9078007936,
-0.4074434042,
0.1014048085,
-0.6454675198,
-0.1920682043,
-0.5273408294,
-0.2627705634,
-0.5041714907,
0.0721154511,
0.1646930575,
-0.5091549158,
0.0349766836,
-0.1653425246,
0.1353474259,
0.4415852129,
0.2997537851,
0.1042760164,
-0.8807107806,
0.6945992708,
0.7790399194,
0.2010253668,
-0.3789244592,
-0.5171438456,
-0.1131548285,
0.1927872002,
-0.3085025251,
-0.907566309,
0.0864584222,
0.3205149472,
1.0743032694,
-0.04332624,
0.3103677332,
0.4710511565,
-0.0821693018,
0.8273128867,
-0.2455132157,
-0.6775525808,
0.6289493442,
-0.6126255989,
0.5571370125,
0.4994603992,
0.4032982588,
-0.1753196418,
-0.7320592999,
-0.5566703081,
-1.098446846,
0.4895798266,
0.5516611338,
0.3971509933,
-0.1263432652,
0.3521126509,
0.0777117163,
0.3929959238,
-0.7852451801,
-0.1733226031,
-0.3106613457,
-0.1255372912,
0.1459058821,
-0.0844912827,
-0.1965003312,
-0.065823108,
0.6405048966,
-0.2684351206,
0.2004404366,
0.2093557715,
-0.0400625765,
-0.1147095039,
0.3688414395,
0.6416552663,
0.851148665,
-0.250791043,
-0.1328073442,
0.3185348213,
-0.1897228956,
0.3706814051,
0.2894304693,
-0.6291866302,
-0.0168748815,
0.1809628606,
0.7002854943,
-0.3372493982,
-0.9057984948,
0.3133074343,
-0.119846575,
-0.4246579111,
-0.0694680586,
0.4721237719,
-0.1487953514,
0.3255189061,
0.688155055,
-0.2267753929,
0.2448309064,
-0.361387521,
0.0203155298,
0.7287983298,
0.1304147542,
-0.1349210441,
0.4775115252,
0.5839419365,
0.0422816612,
0.7144836783,
-0.7606583834,
-0.3265607953,
0.7952147126,
0.6130729318,
0.871498704,
-0.1769807488,
0.3365864754,
0.5554332137,
0.2701267898,
0.2550238073,
0.6410361528,
-0.1326380819,
-0.7394177318,
-0.4976631999,
-0.5437912345,
-0.3000575602,
0.0593410507,
-0.5750582218,
-0.0771136954,
-0.422504276,
0.0176222064,
-0.4970843792,
-0.1491978765,
-0.4316061139,
0.5007731915,
0.2923211157,
0.5729607344,
-0.7470636964,
0.4054650068,
0.9654770494,
-0.3433374166,
-0.8057528734,
0.0229288321,
-0.5331699252,
-0.5135939717,
0.6331956983,
-0.1756022125,
-0.098740533,
-0.0490234457,
-0.7807026505,
-0.9117053747,
1.0760723352,
0.5107373595,
-0.2133352309,
-0.0116753159,
0.1360889524,
0.66796422,
-0.2554188967,
0.2560077608,
0.4686760306,
0.4083926976,
0.2069869637,
-0.3945915997,
0.1815915853,
-0.6931254864,
0.1627305299,
0.1976220757,
-0.6420670152,
0.8010783195,
-0.1918493956,
-0.387537539,
0.2272560149,
0.8297829032,
0.8057744503,
0.432066232,
0.5898966789,
0.3594178557,
0.6449850202,
-0.2556044757,
1.2400707006,
-0.042757526,
0.125513494,
0.7326284051,
-0.2930822074,
0.5957315564,
0.3791948855,
-0.1528859735,
0.5998206139,
0.738550663,
0.127535373,
0.3868295848,
0.1815534979,
-0.3356673717,
-0.4990328848,
-0.2305146903,
-0.7167565227,
0.4383532703,
-0.0667116344,
-0.0557995215,
-0.1818820536,
-0.3050990105,
-0.2240132093,
0.0997450277,
-0.370552361,
0.5672960877,
-0.3733640909,
-1.0138422251,
0.6676306129,
-0.0885283574,
0.4603406489,
-0.6776895523,
-0.1729427576,
-0.9299499393,
-0.4829698503,
-0.2311707139,
-0.809992969,
0.1280020922,
0.0240912698,
-0.5268748999,
-0.1254544407,
0.5485900044,
-0.7459898591,
-0.3567175269,
-0.1096754223,
0.5308799148,
-0.2803552747,
0.087913923,
-0.3548602164,
-0.4588704705,
0.0708517432,
-0.1431667507,
0.2167002112,
0.2867144942,
-0.0437126905,
0.5252845287,
0.676387012,
0.0671461597,
0.5071106553,
0.0265241526,
0.8037691116,
-0.3163034916,
-0.6754211187,
-0.3433826864,
0.5652956963,
-0.2774374783,
-0.453466922,
0.7864707112,
0.4101439118,
0.5950775743,
-0.0486417785,
0.8183302879,
-0.0602114014,
0.4893003404,
-0.6480082273,
0.4199523628,
-0.6202764511,
0.1000518724,
-0.0989996046,
-1.1408834457,
0.1384133995,
0.1552502662,
-0.1601816118,
0.5435504317,
0.6255934834,
0.7087740302,
0.0264922883,
-0.0673076361,
0.0738482028,
-0.1653263867,
0.4538416564,
0.6774301529,
1.1846159697,
-0.3164383471,
0.8826217055,
0.1343854964,
0.0083420239,
0.0243293345,
-0.5487553477,
-0.5199632645,
-0.3648576736,
-0.4158759415,
-0.3054182231,
0.0437519141,
0.7729788423,
0.8006561399,
-0.9547368288,
0.0398089141,
-0.1370849907,
0.3463822007,
0.1435599774,
-0.2795126736,
-0.0732139871,
-0.564068377,
-0.8586175442,
0.2240627557,
-0.0337726437,
0.2469823062,
-0.2200642973,
-0.1928854436,
-0.2371873111,
0.3345223069,
0.5202684999,
0.5882616639,
-0.2909397483,
-0.1729867309,
0.0269556157,
-0.1532934904,
-0.0998592377,
0.7291314006,
-0.7470539808,
0.2746371925,
0.8590954542,
0.821914196,
0.2065252364,
0.5817718506,
0.8601818681,
-1.1666178703,
0.1653068364,
0.3450916708,
0.2008331269,
0.2408038527,
-0.1674376875,
0.3849827051,
0.3058587015,
-0.5579125881,
-0.776219666,
0.4460350573,
-0.8190367222,
-0.2193208337,
1.6547660828,
-0.1929270625,
0.1171950176,
-0.3761935532,
-0.2936139405,
0.1866340935,
-0.5002451539,
0.6348068118,
0.3660622239,
-0.0912824571,
-0.1040661782,
-0.1974049062,
0.5277542472,
0.8390140533,
-1.2373459339,
-0.3101934493,
0.8838948011,
-0.0387492366,
-0.0604386628,
0.51179111,
0.0784281567,
0.8410042524,
-0.0967316777,
-0.018685475,
-0.0202604905,
0.0655836761,
-0.2228843123,
0.534761548,
0.1662584543,
-0.2884783447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17987v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17987v1 | Multi-step Knowledge Retrieval and Inference over Unstructured Data | 2024-06-26T00:00:45 | 2024-06-26T00:00:45 | Aditya Kalyanpur, Kailash Saravanakumar, Victor Barres, CJ McFate, Lori Moon, Nati Seifu, Maksim Eremeev, Jose Barrera, Eric Brown, David Ferrucci | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) and Generative AI has
revolutionized natural language applications across various domains. However,
high-stakes decision-making tasks in fields such as medical, legal and finance
require a level of precision, comprehensiveness, and logical consistency that
pure LLM or Retrieval-Augmented-Generation (RAG) approaches often fail to
deliver. At Elemental Cognition (EC), we have developed a neuro-symbolic AI
platform to tackle these problems. The platform integrates fine-tuned LLMs for
knowledge extraction and alignment with a robust symbolic reasoning engine for
logical inference, planning and interactive constraint solving. We describe
Cora, a Collaborative Research Assistant built on this platform, that is
designed to perform complex research and discovery tasks in high-stakes
domains. This paper discusses the multi-step inference challenges inherent in
such domains, critiques the limitations of existing LLM-based methods, and
demonstrates how Cora's neuro-symbolic approach effectively addresses these
issues. We provide an overview of the system architecture, key algorithms for
knowledge extraction and formal reasoning, and present preliminary evaluation
results that highlight Cora's superior performance compared to well-known LLM
and RAG baselines. | [
0.0581647865,
-0.9049254656,
0.9915572405,
0.3565199673,
0.2133228183,
0.3789591193,
-0.1064301282,
-0.663017571,
0.3722946942,
0.3086356223,
-0.3686680198,
-0.5640708804,
-0.675326705,
-0.0369103551,
-0.333150804,
0.6633498669,
0.0549315959,
0.1080885604,
-0.6026120186,
-0.1260499954,
-0.6183463335,
-0.4740818143,
-0.7414141893,
-0.7649816871,
0.3811905086,
0.1208942086,
0.6124677658,
0.4628507197,
0.596252203,
0.3952893913,
-0.0920169502,
0.5093363523,
0.0486022457,
0.4067672491,
-0.1979805529,
-0.5822201371,
-0.4713233709,
-0.0721088424,
0.1361843944,
0.7664646506,
-0.3326306343,
-0.0099701695,
-0.2167073786,
0.490000993,
-0.7643787861,
0.4938247204,
-0.6135522723,
0.0626236722,
-0.0208914727,
-0.0182968657,
-0.5818665624,
-0.1051558703,
0.1659080386,
-1.3500930071,
0.0087970886,
0.3583155572,
0.6902216077,
0.7476989031,
-0.3528713286,
-0.3161423802,
-0.762334168,
0.9920757413,
-0.3053171039,
0.3324977458,
0.4041753113,
0.3089950085,
-0.4191737473,
-0.9859140515,
-0.6189674139,
-0.1632163823,
-0.1202354133,
0.0695501268,
-0.26450032,
0.0519794673,
0.2194565982,
-0.0547388084,
-0.3990028501,
-0.0372611582,
-0.0990285948,
-0.2426327765,
0.521795094,
0.1459914744,
0.3167363107,
-0.3638383448,
-0.2371280938,
-0.1964220256,
-0.4748389721,
-0.3892674446,
0.045916684,
0.3799792528,
0.1284667104,
0.5977314115,
-0.3083895147,
0.4908945262,
-0.1160975397,
0.0610159747,
0.355868876,
-0.1269222498,
-0.1562369168,
0.1234698519,
0.7832160592,
-0.1747578681,
0.0169985369,
-0.583509624,
-0.0959458202,
0.4146477282,
0.4558625221,
-0.1926761121,
-0.1894266605,
0.3109174073,
-0.2317912281,
-0.1614251137,
-0.2442866266,
-0.7729213834,
-0.6506226063,
-0.7158070803,
0.5892773867,
-0.6054532528,
-0.0240576118,
0.300216496,
-0.4393862486,
0.1405809671,
0.6593308449,
-0.5277895927,
0.30935359,
0.8705970645,
0.5930287838,
-0.3376864791,
-0.1902286112,
-0.4756780267,
0.2878155708,
-0.1735019982,
0.6628909111,
-0.6224361658,
-0.0393883176,
-0.2755759954,
-0.3576733768,
0.0262794066,
-0.4361252189,
0.7084163427,
-0.703201592,
-0.0114370855,
-0.1262223721,
-0.2865716815,
-0.2250406593,
0.4243963063,
-0.5807315707,
1.1939945221,
-0.2423298955,
-0.6267340183,
0.4603055716,
-0.672246933,
-0.5784614682,
0.1237603799,
-0.498062253,
-0.0113019468,
0.0264590085,
0.1452420801,
0.2251658589,
-0.7059456706,
0.5478389263,
-0.3467079699,
0.0061934567,
-0.1242438927,
-0.3415130377,
0.6489835382,
-0.0033347483,
-0.4125798643,
0.377830416,
-0.9563500881,
-0.0256702248,
0.18848975,
-0.1732029319,
-0.7297741175,
0.2805713713,
-0.1505489051,
0.3333918452,
0.4945432544,
-0.5504647493,
0.1824071854,
-0.2436851859,
0.6523103714,
0.6845263839,
-0.2715500593,
0.536174655,
-0.0952818915,
0.2010684311,
-0.1332757026,
0.1517457962,
0.2858775258,
-0.4735572934,
-0.7184633017,
-0.2189188004,
0.2661382556,
0.6266210675,
-0.9967339039,
0.5520120263,
-0.2226821631,
-0.260443002,
-0.6620919108,
-0.0274964664,
0.3658804595,
0.6558495164,
0.7269369364,
-0.0562698245,
-0.3742734492,
-0.7670403719,
-0.163350299,
-0.2458751798,
-0.1044218168,
0.3280081153,
0.6488682628,
-0.2357902974,
0.8324529529,
-0.4166713953,
-0.2544159293,
0.0177005325,
0.7258750796,
0.1916529089,
0.4716037512,
-0.1632497758,
-0.9072508812,
-0.0471640751,
0.244377926,
-1.1701623201,
0.2004134506,
-0.1835441738,
-0.5218814611,
-0.078746736,
0.4240390658,
-1.2115908861,
0.368893832,
0.2404676825,
-0.1452793926,
0.3247345686,
-0.3451451361,
-0.1071419269,
-1.1154651642,
0.2978330553,
-0.1247024685,
0.0010144154,
-0.4216960669,
0.1377430558,
-0.1253998429,
0.2069000155,
-0.0768629014,
0.5376029015,
-0.3901315033,
-0.1565621793,
-0.1763073206,
0.2567197978,
0.1212587878,
0.5792272687,
0.258776933,
0.5059996843,
0.4751441479,
-0.4529587924,
0.1738591492,
0.5957906842,
-0.0744782686,
0.4859830141,
-0.7085046768,
0.379734844,
-0.1646653712,
0.1842794418,
-0.509386003,
-0.328517437,
0.0623321235,
-0.4352945089,
0.1239180043,
0.0363346823,
-0.654061377,
-0.1607317477,
0.0496810041,
0.4373704493,
0.3679980934,
-0.4413625598,
1.3779619932,
0.5487047434,
-0.0764713064,
-0.9724270701,
-0.4584810138,
0.1026045457,
-0.011310868,
-0.5337705016,
0.4619777799,
0.3071271479,
-0.5119431019,
0.0858253315,
-0.3217910826,
0.0071162586,
0.0019974082,
0.4782832861,
0.3194921315,
0.0402560756,
0.1572022885,
0.1395538747,
-0.2069759071,
0.3622495234,
-0.3661405146,
0.5462787747,
0.0315728113,
-0.5838916302,
-0.2808660567,
0.130185023,
0.7446250916,
-0.4363042414,
0.5031524897,
0.344075948,
-0.5898953676,
-0.3279438317,
-0.4520982802,
-0.2203114182,
-0.4304761589,
0.105532065,
-0.1751830578,
-0.4695673585,
0.277089715,
-0.4794798493,
0.2021275014,
0.6003826857,
0.3041409254,
-0.1667339653,
0.9631026983,
0.4390343726,
-0.1128263921,
-0.0292440578,
-0.2130125314,
0.1773873121,
-0.8386011124,
-0.6568113565,
-0.7152073383,
-0.4604892731,
-0.2203767598,
-0.5337129235,
0.5987372398,
-0.0000013627,
-0.4204190969,
0.1373708397,
-0.5086340904,
0.1127429232,
0.8436794281,
0.2317220271,
0.5737849474,
-0.1542833447,
-0.1916971356,
0.1569353193,
-0.6794627905,
-0.3462687731,
0.9211103916,
0.0078649344,
0.8152775764,
-0.0495094098,
0.4653919637,
0.192383498,
0.2263864428,
-0.8604858518,
0.5321781039,
-0.0047867517,
-0.7851769328,
-0.4387340546,
-0.5249847174,
-0.9811061025,
0.2512532175,
-0.6243613362,
-0.6414756179,
0.1322694272,
0.0206965897,
-0.3801434338,
0.1325000525,
-0.3789937496,
0.5548689365,
-0.3777959049,
-0.466871649,
-0.5199638009,
-0.9695039988,
0.2713182271,
-0.1202950329,
0.1163794324,
-0.0136339348,
0.126187101,
0.6422020197,
-0.1108775511,
0.8535200953,
-0.0381201133,
0.2636563182,
0.0798730776,
0.2021759152,
0.7109437585,
-0.0071270647,
-0.2414692193,
0.1860759407,
-0.2222109884,
-0.1980114579,
-0.8602656722,
0.505528748,
-0.7533652186,
-0.4869584441,
-0.5639577508,
-1.039871335,
-0.4537799358,
0.3097379804,
-0.1306816936,
0.1152900383,
-0.0379289873,
0.2521604896,
0.6360398531,
-0.3191987276,
0.2719881535,
0.3349575698,
0.1525681168,
-0.3368207514,
0.8254950643,
-0.2155405432,
0.0037176101,
0.6002101302,
0.1207531691,
-0.4369457066,
-0.4951252341,
-0.3243360519,
0.1272342056,
-0.5385838151,
-0.1587097645,
-0.7939408422,
-0.0375093147,
-0.2342952639,
-0.0637991875,
-0.4573291838,
-0.526416719,
-0.1069725081,
-0.0064677438,
0.4275259674,
0.7901355624,
0.0821199641,
0.0772573426,
-0.6724832058,
0.5436483622,
0.0458742827,
-0.1943782866,
0.0245339889,
-0.1071446836,
0.1305405051,
-0.1669713408,
-0.3796202242,
-0.4847248793,
0.3178854883,
-0.1866137981,
0.4882863462,
0.0650521219,
0.1171812564,
0.6699515581,
-0.4289302826,
0.3993143737,
0.1945693493,
-0.7830059528,
0.4202869534,
-0.126254499,
-0.0600092374,
0.5938489437,
0.5118131042,
-0.3939960003,
-0.1234064847,
-0.707919538,
-0.9925419092,
0.5325293541,
0.350433588,
-0.3058667779,
0.1252471954,
0.3928759992,
-0.0564364977,
0.3497906923,
-0.2895492017,
-0.2424939424,
0.2350995541,
-0.4573317766,
0.1114541218,
0.4125191867,
-0.3299447298,
-0.2771782279,
0.6194270849,
-0.329387933,
0.0434266478,
0.176978603,
-0.1453528702,
0.1564107835,
0.0213925205,
0.0552208945,
0.4833247066,
0.1308380514,
0.1612060219,
0.1879194081,
-0.3959362507,
-0.048560001,
0.3275503218,
-0.3128108084,
-0.1918979436,
0.502346158,
0.5246335864,
0.2120565474,
-0.7397213578,
0.2140875608,
0.0440810546,
-0.2606738508,
-0.3704474866,
-0.068139568,
0.1936169118,
0.3500454724,
0.213228181,
0.3558076024,
0.2555696666,
-0.5044326186,
0.2002130449,
0.6403332353,
-0.209713906,
-0.2343282402,
0.8408927917,
0.171728164,
-0.185912177,
1.0472160578,
0.0053764787,
-0.2264456302,
0.6681160331,
0.332583338,
0.645407021,
0.1594899297,
0.3112056851,
0.0350310281,
0.241344586,
-0.3360507786,
0.4691769481,
-0.1770820022,
-0.8580566645,
-0.615945816,
-0.8172622919,
-0.5157820582,
-0.0191474333,
-0.5681509376,
-0.0056702215,
-0.4924686849,
-0.0995266885,
0.1560650021,
-0.1266018748,
-0.5267732143,
0.0352949202,
-0.1905244738,
0.8416832685,
-0.605021894,
0.7206977606,
0.6882228851,
-0.5071181655,
-0.832693696,
-0.3272961974,
0.1105903834,
-0.8950482607,
0.8204227686,
-0.1743040532,
-0.2690987587,
-0.1696186364,
-0.4757865965,
-0.7749851942,
1.2513642311,
0.4836858809,
-0.2913970649,
-0.4952206314,
0.1471327841,
0.6140143871,
0.0306857638,
0.2332184613,
0.5842396021,
0.6729351282,
0.3095109463,
-0.7631585002,
-0.0218923949,
-0.165739134,
-0.4263288677,
0.4600382745,
-0.4781611264,
0.82158494,
0.01293361,
0.0264145304,
0.0304103028,
0.7263009548,
0.6068671942,
0.5558791161,
0.3961973488,
0.9779884815,
1.0344276428,
-0.1227666214,
0.9864937663,
-0.4545400441,
-0.0072129788,
1.2339885235,
-0.5335398912,
0.8740463853,
0.7077786326,
0.0780973062,
0.6517640948,
0.3054399192,
0.3184469044,
0.1776464134,
0.0969619751,
-0.3436232507,
-0.4580474794,
-0.4087825119,
0.0983066931,
0.4624943733,
0.6128257513,
-0.1807796806,
-0.1992973983,
-0.3736638427,
-0.2137036026,
0.0442191623,
-0.0597750284,
0.7104082108,
0.2545549572,
-0.7070259452,
-0.0736852214,
-0.1012877598,
0.4071059227,
-0.5390044451,
-0.489133656,
0.0788569674,
0.1308953911,
-0.1146857068,
-0.5779386163,
0.2281675041,
-0.1945731044,
-0.0661976337,
-0.2712642252,
0.8109952807,
-0.0337686092,
-0.3805747032,
0.5186276436,
0.7500604391,
0.0503488556,
-0.2098249644,
-0.7279678583,
-0.1236406416,
-0.5340697765,
-0.1226171851,
0.18706505,
0.667504251,
-0.3591090739,
0.9172310233,
0.8529543281,
0.0831934959,
0.0195998717,
0.0595784932,
0.6740859747,
-0.5761295557,
-0.1469843835,
-0.5665810704,
0.3218089342,
-0.1700470597,
-0.3860845268,
0.454425782,
0.4101577103,
0.5402688384,
0.238545686,
0.6968963742,
-0.2980985045,
0.1130456254,
-0.5482435822,
0.5266914368,
-0.6228502393,
-0.0463175885,
-0.1023864672,
-0.6228877902,
-0.4762765765,
0.6046457291,
-0.20652619,
-0.1368860006,
0.7494746447,
0.7066221237,
-0.0749405846,
0.2212155312,
0.0522425063,
0.229690522,
0.2608237267,
0.5982926488,
0.9213684201,
-0.2084735632,
0.331137985,
-0.1115885526,
-0.108475171,
0.3667986691,
-0.7844911218,
-0.6200144291,
-0.5217293501,
-0.0322477631,
-0.2275417745,
0.0913463011,
1.0414088964,
0.8410646915,
-0.4835428596,
-0.0906284451,
-0.4951513708,
0.1881946176,
-0.2015352249,
-0.1707618833,
0.3498577178,
-0.424583286,
-0.733024776,
0.7520806193,
0.3299366832,
-0.4563084841,
-0.1774194092,
-0.0791397542,
-0.4339769185,
-0.0138764633,
0.6384070516,
0.3177113831,
-0.6673591137,
-0.1268572509,
0.2166150659,
-0.1380896866,
-0.0844471157,
0.7144050002,
-0.8062813282,
0.2248304188,
0.6596506238,
1.1787314415,
0.4875656962,
0.0483249612,
0.6644586921,
-0.4907546043,
-0.012513794,
0.5152677298,
0.417201519,
0.0694652647,
-0.4225496948,
0.6271019578,
0.3766904771,
-0.4873886704,
-0.5111592412,
0.0093381833,
-1.0391674042,
-0.4191440344,
0.9584678411,
0.1372425705,
-0.3283416331,
-0.260281533,
0.0297399592,
0.3790662587,
-0.3881196082,
0.9729809761,
0.6267234087,
-0.4723805785,
0.3086755276,
-0.6301184893,
0.3042015135,
0.7449944615,
-1.1234912872,
-0.0518734232,
0.5624887943,
-0.1469834149,
0.7884985805,
0.3079539537,
-0.1196299866,
0.0972414836,
0.0986906663,
0.4298780262,
0.1020136252,
-0.9374249578,
-0.1349955946,
0.4045119882,
-0.0755779594,
-0.0971417874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17982v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17982v1 | EDEN: Empathetic Dialogues for English learning | 2024-06-25T23:36:16 | 2024-06-25T23:36:16 | Li Siyan, Teresa Shao, Zhou Yu, Julia Hirschberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue systems have been used as conversation partners in English learning,
but few have studied whether these systems improve learning outcomes. Student
passion and perseverance, or grit, has been associated with language learning
success. Recent work establishes that as students perceive their English
teachers to be more supportive, their grit improves. Hypothesizing that the
same pattern applies to English-teaching chatbots, we create EDEN, a robust
open-domain chatbot for spoken conversation practice that provides empathetic
feedback. To construct EDEN, we first train a specialized spoken utterance
grammar correction model and a high-quality social chit-chat conversation
model. We then conduct a preliminary user study with a variety of strategies
for empathetic feedback. Our experiment suggests that using adaptive empathetic
feedback leads to higher perceived affective support, which, in turn, predicts
increased student grit. | [
0.1955186576,
-0.9160391092,
0.7393992543,
0.1781325787,
0.222403571,
0.5079832077,
-0.4389612377,
-0.1378672868,
0.6392416954,
-0.035282068,
-0.4933750629,
-0.6226619482,
-0.4800528288,
0.1129646748,
-0.1292686909,
0.7922688127,
0.0421014689,
0.5927449465,
-0.3080688119,
-0.1248063743,
-0.5377018452,
-0.0628828555,
-1.352481842,
-0.4586987197,
0.752066195,
0.7889936566,
0.5362295508,
0.3235848248,
0.6575741768,
0.3736694455,
0.1249589175,
-0.1909580231,
-0.4152553082,
0.4200298488,
-0.354883343,
-0.6965530515,
-0.4973288774,
-0.1739920676,
0.3545779884,
0.6563234329,
-0.2311926037,
-0.1816896796,
0.4701479077,
0.2785843909,
-0.2454032004,
0.0132700196,
-0.3472441435,
0.346281141,
0.1202496141,
-0.2547062635,
-0.5591898561,
-0.2455556244,
0.079763636,
-0.6232270002,
-0.0766601935,
-0.1167285442,
0.7152084112,
0.1496488154,
0.0496400334,
-0.3082515895,
-0.9196472168,
1.1788150072,
-0.4910450876,
0.5110027194,
0.6575567722,
0.2441733181,
0.1984512508,
-0.6350028515,
-0.366322875,
0.0711286813,
0.1266269237,
0.7137749195,
0.1374804825,
0.2842232585,
-0.1521740854,
0.4510973096,
-0.2713671625,
0.2484606504,
-0.245305419,
-0.0003645574,
0.6522149444,
0.3422388732,
0.3674396276,
0.028403189,
-0.0875906497,
-0.1550363749,
-0.4643855691,
0.6038295627,
0.4498772621,
0.2334388047,
-0.148487553,
0.2156173736,
0.0919316337,
0.3916091621,
-0.1593870074,
-0.4740916491,
0.141370073,
-0.0917883441,
0.0271484125,
-0.1148202866,
0.5138591528,
0.6803276539,
0.2219951451,
-0.093964085,
-0.1967161,
0.2532148361,
0.2826805413,
-0.8398461938,
-0.3253502548,
0.5707914829,
-0.398768276,
-0.2601301968,
-0.0520289131,
-0.6777446866,
-0.1546507329,
-0.1863209307,
0.4816763997,
-0.8085011244,
-0.1503779739,
-0.0331250578,
-0.2375300825,
0.461546123,
0.7589490414,
-0.8125315905,
0.3827551603,
0.6948083639,
1.0167472363,
-0.0570933856,
-0.5131392479,
-0.6019328833,
-0.1637674421,
-0.0641261265,
0.8302296996,
-0.9523799419,
-0.5362244248,
0.2008173317,
0.1001209468,
-0.0218288898,
-0.125159964,
0.3862592578,
0.3930895329,
0.2812875211,
-0.2453785539,
-0.655138135,
-0.0081491834,
0.5000680089,
-0.1699932963,
0.4422336221,
0.3066105247,
-0.3112245202,
0.169992134,
-0.7806447148,
-0.5709934831,
0.3530506492,
-0.2536074221,
-0.1745942682,
-0.0202650409,
-0.1635364294,
0.3924447298,
0.0885428339,
0.0385744609,
-0.1358253956,
-0.3344237506,
0.2173496634,
-0.3892412186,
0.5612639785,
0.0559844859,
-0.4576919377,
-0.0271818899,
-0.3440852761,
-0.1458696574,
0.2176064104,
-0.2452602535,
-0.2889882922,
0.1534964293,
0.016456997,
-0.0556277819,
-0.123003006,
-1.1422775984,
-0.1041869074,
-0.5021096468,
0.2995278537,
0.8676903248,
0.0501693562,
0.0825649649,
-0.6140460372,
0.7338032126,
0.0216190275,
0.3644692898,
-0.5997253656,
-0.6332015395,
-0.9293529391,
0.0112605467,
0.0946625918,
0.5916240811,
-0.4685530663,
0.1416632682,
-0.0793643966,
-0.5189151764,
-1.1846784353,
0.3207758069,
0.6749767661,
0.2180328369,
0.2874052823,
-0.7510802746,
-0.1614622921,
-0.5047816038,
-0.3825197816,
-0.139162451,
0.09573102,
0.8468510509,
0.1760344952,
-0.0443501323,
0.6573246121,
-0.3920600712,
-0.5651933551,
-0.274020195,
-0.2873624563,
-0.1900600344,
0.5154393315,
0.2999145687,
-0.626896441,
-0.9364824295,
0.0931252912,
-0.3911990225,
0.2475105226,
-0.1721335799,
-0.1328493655,
-0.0518930033,
0.3641345203,
-0.0686058328,
0.4857005775,
0.6572438478,
-0.6177018285,
-0.0590758324,
0.2022094578,
0.3109328151,
-1.2679661512,
-0.3943859339,
-0.1690107435,
-0.516022563,
-0.3819588423,
-0.2036854923,
-0.1835490614,
-0.0119326143,
-0.6919053793,
0.4944485128,
0.2297903895,
0.1230832785,
-0.1368980408,
0.5109476447,
0.2030542791,
0.4468851686,
0.0035669997,
0.6837136149,
0.7143951654,
-0.5272207856,
0.5098001361,
0.7255698442,
0.3491146266,
1.1791795492,
-0.7876752615,
0.1123020723,
0.002254135,
0.0020100153,
-1.0253709555,
-0.1753890514,
-0.1745623946,
-0.8654814959,
0.2784191668,
0.0141717019,
0.2151015103,
-0.1563505381,
-0.4830983877,
-0.170164153,
0.6665683985,
-0.5199266076,
0.7895954251,
0.2953826487,
-0.4065423906,
-0.2548288405,
-0.6009984612,
-0.0962636918,
0.1986198872,
-0.4295089543,
0.3245426416,
-0.3563778102,
-0.7419131994,
0.2035407424,
0.2424359918,
0.1986082494,
0.3597825468,
0.5376520753,
-0.0451348275,
-0.1745541692,
0.4626849294,
0.123821348,
-0.071072042,
0.2077662498,
0.0164092407,
0.8632666469,
-0.1972592622,
-0.3015595376,
-0.4935420752,
0.3234669566,
0.2837587297,
-0.1379336566,
0.8115145564,
0.4491665661,
-0.1944860071,
-0.2270858586,
-0.1717741042,
-0.6883143187,
-0.4485034049,
0.1675134748,
-0.2855179906,
-0.970965147,
0.3721049428,
-0.0436175503,
0.4789087176,
0.3757102787,
0.2232707292,
-0.5218052268,
1.0219501257,
0.4733789563,
0.2893041074,
0.6229405403,
-0.1451911777,
0.1934391707,
-0.8548754454,
-0.3377731442,
-0.3252688944,
-0.5464259386,
-0.2593177557,
-0.0323137939,
-0.0164613388,
-0.4928673506,
-0.0254940521,
0.1523326486,
-0.1214759871,
0.4193558693,
0.5284948349,
0.3735862672,
0.0905644894,
-0.2453359812,
-0.0477517843,
-0.3779284656,
-0.4255443215,
-0.366086781,
1.0638483763,
0.5116432905,
0.687741816,
0.2112700492,
0.9045823812,
0.1075495631,
0.5254607797,
-1.0866835117,
0.3023954034,
-0.1657424569,
-0.2093848288,
-0.3596115112,
-0.2430215627,
-1.1684949398,
-0.2719459534,
-0.2547295988,
-0.459694773,
-0.312663734,
0.0596914962,
-0.8138298392,
0.3970647156,
-0.5750451088,
0.5237798095,
-0.1920908839,
-0.8993666172,
-0.3753415942,
-0.5329017043,
-0.3881852329,
-0.0282405168,
0.1831196398,
-0.0095557291,
0.3474800885,
0.7426844835,
-0.2692004144,
1.0184652805,
-0.1598644704,
0.0641376823,
0.335898459,
0.3727141619,
0.2252255529,
0.2231776267,
0.0648307502,
-0.1608704329,
-0.40590927,
-0.5326020718,
-0.5515161753,
0.7480462193,
-0.8629956245,
-0.7915915251,
-0.2060897648,
-0.3896528184,
-0.1381103992,
-0.0753743649,
0.0467615165,
0.241496399,
-0.4985150695,
0.5696511865,
0.6244233847,
-0.2648417652,
0.717952013,
0.659876287,
-0.5533341169,
-0.371068269,
0.816757381,
-0.073812075,
0.6687737703,
0.2268182337,
0.2973732054,
0.2074690312,
-0.0194941927,
-0.2422468066,
0.2349179238,
-0.679635644,
-0.3633621335,
-0.9714080095,
-0.2071468979,
-0.5777923465,
-0.8567958474,
-0.5815558434,
-0.3398309946,
-0.1183423921,
-0.3494335413,
0.7304577827,
1.0915192366,
0.0595190339,
0.6386011839,
-0.8260858059,
-0.5496020317,
0.541389823,
0.3838952184,
-0.2662119269,
-0.6659668684,
-0.1969762444,
0.0815896466,
-0.7466332912,
-0.6446263194,
0.5600381494,
0.5758315921,
0.1205168292,
0.5074446797,
-0.2832252681,
0.4107013941,
-0.2841075957,
1.0153343678,
0.0127988169,
-1.1227961779,
0.9356503487,
-0.220575422,
-0.0030377251,
0.7497606874,
0.5194554925,
-0.5915573239,
-0.6484985352,
-1.0942369699,
-0.80189538,
0.4728165567,
0.0261803567,
0.6049599648,
0.0458661616,
0.1459334642,
0.1897100806,
0.1093989164,
-0.5869847536,
-0.221803084,
-0.1755826771,
-0.4542505145,
-0.1920220405,
0.068890363,
-0.2199327648,
-0.3923749328,
0.7270693183,
-0.1835322976,
0.1549722254,
0.4213323295,
0.0768855587,
-0.4830701649,
0.1685375571,
-0.0068717962,
0.4258967042,
-0.0329326466,
-0.0634933412,
0.2965314686,
-0.7630773783,
-0.0685195848,
-0.4440023899,
-0.0590347685,
0.2029573321,
0.2453590333,
0.7800319195,
0.5283564925,
-0.674356699,
0.9259395599,
-0.3365923762,
-0.1692982614,
-0.5941205025,
0.4260922968,
0.0310822483,
0.1273374856,
-0.1385365725,
0.1266287118,
0.0068687825,
-0.6868597865,
0.3419968486,
0.1692609936,
-0.9083170891,
-0.5278506279,
0.4106213152,
0.775658071,
-1.1811004877,
0.6412523985,
0.0033160292,
-0.7133383751,
0.4086784422,
0.8489441276,
0.897798419,
-0.7848772407,
0.6072590947,
0.3721712232,
0.0885667577,
0.210310325,
0.7006424665,
-0.0880433023,
-0.8376801014,
-0.1154898182,
-0.6505283117,
-1.0500422716,
-0.3012593091,
-0.7556737065,
0.267427057,
-0.6461181641,
0.0085471077,
0.000668395,
-0.0031629633,
-0.930108428,
0.3626505435,
-0.1686915159,
0.6370154619,
-1.2038241625,
0.5365108848,
0.9652904272,
-0.5344594121,
-1.0359243155,
-0.0983129293,
-0.0893612355,
-0.9277033806,
0.2372014076,
0.4069525599,
-0.0346291699,
0.4974807501,
-0.4404628277,
-0.568380475,
1.2063224316,
-0.1065897718,
-0.734691143,
0.3910424709,
-0.1245217994,
0.4486023784,
-0.585498035,
0.6550496221,
0.375335604,
0.2245764434,
0.0336840078,
-0.6430131793,
-0.3741210699,
-0.3624092937,
-0.3001008928,
0.0140548842,
-0.9804233313,
0.7954060435,
-0.2063983828,
-0.0424251929,
-0.2281877249,
0.4737754464,
-0.1629233956,
0.4489306509,
0.4302578866,
0.6365746856,
0.9282910824,
-0.2878834307,
1.0883588791,
-0.5686147809,
0.2867484093,
0.6675080061,
-0.3790746033,
1.1361237764,
0.6366488338,
-0.29229182,
1.0475147963,
0.3860069215,
0.2081831992,
0.0333972983,
-0.1787859052,
-0.4379605651,
-0.3097333908,
-0.6184711456,
0.1169067696,
0.5767081976,
0.5632078052,
-0.6580725312,
0.2216340899,
0.4269903302,
0.3377267122,
0.4388908446,
-0.5037233233,
0.8739344478,
0.1990410835,
-0.8438410759,
-0.1299760342,
-0.2948578298,
0.6613948941,
-0.3712501228,
-0.27729702,
-0.4529460073,
0.3468963504,
-0.4280938506,
-0.9491299987,
0.1373500228,
-0.0341447555,
0.1346369982,
-0.4608238935,
0.5669673085,
-0.7668743134,
-0.2663347423,
0.5877386332,
0.5612546206,
0.4290383458,
0.2754367888,
-0.4571316242,
0.0074547003,
0.0890588537,
-0.2153975517,
0.1787517965,
0.167598173,
0.5708550811,
0.4871675968,
0.6683279276,
0.1987319887,
-0.4703560174,
0.2748855948,
0.7921587825,
-0.6964506507,
-0.2982993722,
-0.8632439375,
0.6560602784,
-0.1000183299,
-0.5687330365,
1.109418273,
0.3584339619,
0.9916843772,
0.0485684015,
0.7509333491,
-0.0208712872,
0.5636367202,
-0.3746925294,
0.4594607651,
-0.5733027458,
-0.038079381,
-0.2419014126,
-0.9018925428,
-0.2165191472,
0.9388432503,
-0.0657857135,
-0.0117976861,
1.0223520994,
0.6517351866,
0.1932029128,
0.4266923368,
0.7291639447,
0.2234201878,
0.2685773373,
0.6480075717,
0.8262451887,
-0.3962047994,
0.1284375936,
-0.324518472,
-0.342793107,
-0.0781072974,
-0.282066673,
-0.9256071448,
-0.4875842333,
-0.3658688962,
-0.788428545,
0.377158612,
1.3480255604,
0.1607362032,
-0.7257146239,
-0.1429661214,
-0.2924399674,
-0.0414305031,
0.0122502418,
-0.2587067187,
-0.0333094336,
-0.8078142405,
-1.2058306932,
0.373906374,
0.5319633484,
0.161701113,
-0.3420515358,
-0.3857164979,
0.0371972658,
0.369048059,
0.4811977148,
0.183191523,
-0.3186261952,
-0.448522836,
0.4307916164,
-0.0398942679,
0.2399350703,
0.6409637928,
-0.5261950493,
0.4572837949,
0.1119183376,
0.8081370592,
0.0284571182,
-0.1559751779,
0.7514249682,
-0.5653119683,
0.0757993013,
0.5633544326,
0.4247726202,
0.5441067815,
-0.4726940691,
0.4958050549,
0.4030408561,
-0.7227677107,
-0.6847649217,
0.1178205982,
-0.5123491883,
0.1241182834,
1.36698699,
-0.7533954978,
-0.4805869758,
-0.2541542649,
-0.3378740251,
-0.001205171,
-0.4734090567,
0.574234724,
0.8175820708,
-0.0230516996,
-0.1282178164,
-0.2164313197,
0.4979820549,
0.9939959049,
-0.735103786,
-0.3125071526,
0.0430554152,
0.061597541,
0.2923312485,
0.491903156,
0.1213642061,
0.3140628636,
0.1983619183,
0.2066483498,
0.3082908988,
-0.6860054731,
-0.4345547557,
-0.1927630901,
0.3697153628,
-0.0731676817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17975v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17975v1 | Inherent Challenges of Post-Hoc Membership Inference for Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T23:12:07 | 2024-06-25T23:12:07 | Matthieu Meeus, Shubham Jain, Marek Rei, Yves-Alexandre de Montjoye | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) are often trained on vast amounts of undisclosed
data, motivating the development of post-hoc Membership Inference Attacks
(MIAs) to gain insight into their training data composition. However, in this
paper, we identify inherent challenges in post-hoc MIA evaluation due to
potential distribution shifts between collected member and non-member datasets.
Using a simple bag-of-words classifier, we demonstrate that datasets used in
recent post-hoc MIAs suffer from significant distribution shifts, in some cases
achieving near-perfect distinction between members and non-members. This
implies that previously reported high MIA performance may be largely
attributable to these shifts rather than model memorization. We confirm that
randomized, controlled setups eliminate such shifts and thus enable the
development and fair evaluation of new MIAs. However, we note that such
randomized setups are rarely available for the latest LLMs, making post-hoc
data collection still required to infer membership for real-world LLMs. As a
potential solution, we propose a Regression Discontinuity Design (RDD) approach
for post-hoc data collection, which substantially mitigates distribution
shifts. Evaluating various MIA methods on this RDD setup yields performance
barely above random guessing, in stark contrast to previously reported results.
Overall, our findings highlight the challenges in accurately measuring LLM
memorization and the need for careful experimental design in (post-hoc)
membership inference tasks. | [
-0.3798308671,
-0.659665525,
0.4071987569,
-0.3411649168,
-0.491628319,
0.1135777161,
-0.1483163238,
-0.406676054,
-0.0371094532,
0.2749790847,
-0.9107670188,
-0.6217644215,
-0.6830976605,
0.088918075,
-0.1629451811,
0.77275455,
0.1301183999,
0.0166081749,
-0.2790743709,
-0.3953953981,
-0.4202183783,
-0.7296276689,
-0.1597916484,
-0.2367322594,
0.5165261626,
-0.0518838093,
0.5823374391,
0.4720181227,
0.5770428777,
0.1276006252,
-0.3093214929,
0.2419136316,
-0.5472174883,
0.0318443887,
-0.0755670816,
-0.7534352541,
-0.3238624036,
-0.0295785069,
0.6036064625,
0.9476913214,
-0.2525193095,
0.0916838124,
-0.0703778043,
0.5040858388,
-0.7812517881,
0.1292940527,
-0.850151062,
-0.0658353642,
-0.3160987794,
-0.0185066741,
-0.5148843527,
-0.3771044314,
0.2582870722,
-0.4424887896,
0.241182968,
-0.0687779635,
0.8826146722,
0.1284613013,
-0.4463816881,
-0.2500521839,
-0.6876072288,
0.8510338664,
-0.8484514952,
0.818143189,
0.6700032949,
0.2333718389,
-0.3445013463,
-0.0834788084,
-0.2891640961,
-0.0572364293,
0.2471473962,
-0.2455905974,
0.0316410996,
-0.0150992218,
0.2259888053,
0.2900737524,
-0.5174795985,
0.4360699058,
-0.0665348172,
0.1755686104,
0.6449077129,
0.0294682477,
-0.0655437708,
0.0469483808,
-0.2979043126,
-0.0604125522,
-1.1257971525,
-0.2110428363,
0.3118625879,
0.3667347431,
-0.2153345346,
0.5883798003,
-0.0504697375,
0.5718175769,
-0.2205097228,
0.0435861759,
0.2945461571,
-0.1908560991,
-0.2858499289,
-0.3533396125,
0.5047411919,
0.215944171,
0.1936555505,
-0.1841912717,
-0.3769589067,
0.0567498021,
-0.1801580936,
-0.5482919216,
-0.2918920517,
0.0563995317,
-0.6264897585,
-0.1717860252,
0.1981089562,
-0.6420118809,
-0.5406212807,
-0.336589396,
0.4823943973,
-0.1593690068,
-0.2720873058,
0.2091562748,
-0.1628081948,
0.1986425668,
0.5501901507,
-0.660666883,
0.1204379499,
0.5946651101,
0.7201268077,
0.0454871468,
-0.1624613851,
-0.5390829444,
-0.0263409074,
-0.3942311406,
0.6501479149,
-0.6519033313,
-0.4767915308,
0.1538880467,
-0.2216530889,
-0.3685614169,
-0.5214418173,
0.1031114981,
-0.6740312576,
0.1365865171,
-0.5790820122,
-0.761670053,
0.2333831787,
0.1316256523,
-0.5019341707,
0.8766419888,
0.2585873306,
-1.0486763716,
0.6092455983,
-0.135727942,
-0.2586742043,
-0.1915283054,
-0.2861663401,
-0.4373284876,
0.5686694384,
-0.0083061811,
0.1821573377,
-0.3132965863,
0.0534224547,
-0.7198190689,
-0.5088703632,
0.6447612643,
-0.3569669425,
0.8559862971,
0.1585885286,
-0.2741042674,
-0.0254859198,
-0.6355363727,
-0.3200226724,
-0.0938214213,
-0.3260650039,
-0.6207922101,
0.4421332777,
-0.1828334779,
0.2777430117,
-0.1787487417,
-0.2838307321,
0.313586086,
-0.3149366677,
0.2215393633,
0.9795095325,
-0.0712253749,
0.455976963,
-0.5001672506,
0.6219809055,
-0.2182776183,
0.2606002688,
0.1552531272,
-0.2619186938,
-0.5723492503,
-0.3738042712,
0.3913865983,
0.2509531081,
-0.7380367517,
0.7165046334,
-0.3639786541,
-0.3753981888,
-0.42498824,
-0.0653865039,
0.256180495,
0.0881197453,
0.2633346021,
-0.0206288192,
-0.2945881188,
-0.6929707527,
-0.0429017954,
-0.3837482035,
-0.4054900408,
0.2636793256,
0.4670706391,
-0.3058344126,
0.848018527,
-0.4060790837,
-0.1191554144,
-0.3383949995,
0.2366707325,
0.0260164719,
0.1799587756,
0.3025530875,
-0.2921807468,
0.1436553448,
0.0722028092,
-0.6214523911,
-0.2751182616,
-0.1464348882,
-0.0568037629,
0.4647575319,
0.5113474131,
-0.8968768716,
0.4841662347,
0.6192613244,
-0.2187567502,
0.6580427885,
0.052610945,
-0.013057882,
-0.8758722544,
0.0754341632,
-0.2547656596,
-0.0763263404,
-0.3468720317,
0.0082679028,
-0.0440438166,
0.1773498654,
-0.376748085,
0.3729898036,
-0.7632101178,
-0.1268353015,
-0.0875554457,
-0.0202741288,
-0.101789251,
0.0896521583,
0.0283578392,
0.3433332741,
0.3782808483,
-0.572414577,
-0.1607047766,
0.4263185859,
-0.6044543386,
0.3807952702,
-0.4357863963,
0.157174021,
-0.2462900728,
0.4409053028,
-1.0401142836,
-0.0760019645,
0.1268894672,
-0.3093827367,
0.4355490804,
-0.1619173288,
-0.3743315935,
-0.2606835961,
-0.6389033794,
0.3976572454,
0.4948132038,
-0.4938650429,
0.236392498,
0.3314551413,
0.108455129,
-0.7130932808,
-0.6369264126,
-0.0837583095,
-0.5509465933,
-0.4969894588,
-0.0749543011,
-0.070444189,
-0.3730389774,
-0.1902538538,
-0.4319935441,
0.1436973661,
0.4797479212,
0.1646645367,
0.1693147719,
-0.1973340809,
0.3156456947,
-0.0565037392,
0.1748537868,
0.0751767382,
0.0646922141,
0.6605446339,
0.3618576825,
-0.4820711315,
-0.5583667755,
0.3096188009,
0.5288276076,
-0.2723861039,
0.9310287237,
0.1273451746,
-0.3404437602,
-0.694491148,
-0.5780182481,
-0.3385512233,
-0.4367592931,
0.3891848624,
-0.2906164527,
-0.9775695801,
0.659142375,
0.0144146783,
0.2577337325,
0.0131471334,
0.3114352226,
-0.3175870478,
0.5026869774,
0.4716183543,
0.0530921407,
0.5889279246,
-0.0659468397,
0.2570878863,
-0.6619020104,
-0.1543652564,
-0.8006296754,
-0.2485362887,
-0.4819966853,
-0.6551908851,
-0.0502431951,
0.2371552885,
-0.0316482559,
0.1984342188,
0.1254986078,
0.3024777174,
0.2672556937,
-0.0243825689,
0.2529303133,
0.0903088897,
0.2792548835,
0.0245446712,
-0.6326236725,
-0.2312835306,
1.0110348463,
0.4158318937,
1.0713117123,
0.1922533661,
0.7315738797,
0.1489324719,
0.4472089708,
-0.7847073078,
0.4228580892,
0.1980818063,
-0.4503775239,
-0.2688240409,
-0.743440032,
-0.9270586967,
0.480661571,
-0.231902346,
-0.7778432369,
0.5695664287,
0.082484141,
-0.0556852892,
0.1400912553,
-0.4878149927,
0.7689718008,
0.1557585746,
-0.1017064154,
0.1874815077,
-0.8499197364,
0.5041421652,
-0.3370710015,
0.4506056905,
-0.2235190272,
0.1573742479,
0.7246579528,
-0.684505403,
0.7437417507,
-0.1408546418,
-0.1894414127,
0.1463420838,
0.3519595265,
0.5785517693,
-0.0125617906,
-0.3256158829,
0.3359139264,
-0.0060804579,
-0.2564446032,
-0.4597768486,
0.3764824569,
-0.7613271475,
-0.7531637549,
-0.331291765,
-0.5370568037,
-0.3348330557,
-0.0688725039,
0.3511855304,
0.4218896627,
-0.2910801768,
0.4533056617,
0.5079593658,
-0.2654440701,
0.5331237316,
0.4308347404,
-0.2187839448,
-0.3185965717,
0.5755867958,
0.328122735,
0.5787732601,
0.3837180734,
0.1868725717,
-0.6355466247,
-1.0730565786,
-0.2764699757,
0.5233929753,
-0.4841508269,
-0.2723869383,
-0.4598034322,
0.1164519861,
-0.3743683994,
-0.1156159639,
-0.3388783634,
-0.3116513491,
-0.3152541518,
-0.3659807444,
0.1422340125,
0.5970315337,
0.1063416675,
0.5879381895,
-0.8105825186,
-0.139105469,
-0.1270409971,
0.1542142332,
-0.1667458564,
-0.6170900464,
-0.3343283236,
0.0798951089,
0.0068686861,
-0.9877562523,
0.1161189675,
0.247858867,
0.5684459805,
0.6954099536,
0.4038094282,
0.6217847466,
-0.3615769744,
0.683449924,
-0.0687204376,
-0.955866456,
0.3048577011,
-0.6261205077,
0.1841987818,
0.7590661049,
0.1721191704,
-0.4600256979,
-0.539809823,
-0.5305302739,
-0.7786872387,
0.9363860488,
0.3877919316,
0.041613277,
-0.1861167103,
0.2251238823,
0.1226578727,
0.3757842779,
-0.6055184007,
-0.1582299173,
0.3213286996,
0.1575814337,
-0.0812535658,
-0.3423365355,
-0.0430449955,
0.0503297076,
0.4388921261,
0.1179325655,
-0.1156724766,
-0.0426197015,
-0.2436005771,
-0.1816151291,
0.063671723,
0.4878606796,
1.1910454035,
-0.4716196954,
0.3140292168,
0.129953891,
-0.0311153457,
0.1688921452,
0.0742004216,
-0.0920449421,
0.2617485225,
0.7591227293,
0.6799035072,
0.124372676,
-0.6338025928,
0.6197189093,
-0.1172549874,
-0.1864391714,
0.0783986002,
-0.1058143079,
0.2844288945,
-0.0069872974,
0.2371255308,
0.0205885619,
-0.1775386184,
-0.527359128,
0.4221315682,
0.687936008,
-0.1382003725,
-0.5536760688,
0.5261254311,
0.0025328754,
-0.3382283151,
0.7040984035,
-0.0090882322,
-0.1844266802,
0.5015926957,
0.451298207,
0.6650380492,
-0.955270052,
0.4165488482,
0.0221971683,
0.4844133556,
-0.1411582083,
0.1034907773,
-0.192369923,
-0.6551935673,
-0.2375932336,
-0.6995440125,
-0.1616466045,
0.2492020726,
-0.8822109699,
0.4582070112,
-0.4233866036,
-0.1006344482,
-0.37602669,
-0.1991532743,
-0.48525244,
-0.0207637809,
0.0982275754,
0.8279080391,
-1.106683135,
0.791074872,
0.3452330232,
0.0793316066,
-0.5050949454,
0.1132834107,
0.2034035027,
-0.3584260046,
0.3112825453,
0.2421725094,
0.0060619768,
-0.3675558567,
-0.0063989307,
-0.7477499247,
0.7328419089,
0.5451629758,
-0.7416940928,
-0.1131187752,
0.2027653903,
0.4743575454,
0.066192098,
0.2343443632,
0.6196776032,
0.2603319287,
0.3033619821,
-0.811449945,
-0.0339615569,
0.0671119019,
0.0122902244,
0.323481828,
-0.4166136682,
1.1088335514,
0.0696593076,
-0.4035764039,
-0.1104484126,
0.4890098572,
0.5261273384,
0.3504575193,
0.5671719909,
0.4720903635,
0.8651582003,
0.0764113814,
1.0843960047,
0.3346843123,
0.5952122211,
1.2362331152,
-0.5656165481,
0.8466822505,
0.4198419154,
-0.3706836998,
-0.1032279879,
0.9662767053,
0.2133142352,
0.5560584068,
0.5914852023,
-0.5350912213,
-0.3003395796,
0.006991344,
-0.7567317486,
0.3908721209,
0.2635417283,
-0.2354549468,
-0.5376130342,
-0.1970988512,
0.1305613667,
-0.2839679718,
0.1437547803,
0.729467392,
0.2954725623,
-0.1785863191,
0.6577682495,
-0.1615810096,
0.4612452388,
-0.6547899246,
0.0110460566,
-0.571803391,
0.2417385876,
-0.1262517571,
-0.1148692444,
0.5030077696,
-0.1610715091,
0.1275390983,
-0.0116768414,
0.0986906961,
-0.4288783371,
-0.504914701,
0.4243275821,
0.6580986977,
0.1840158403,
-0.0759157911,
-0.3135101199,
0.581127584,
-0.0354220122,
-0.6050959826,
0.5548520684,
0.6014466286,
-0.2711945474,
0.4157670736,
0.5486116409,
0.1367626935,
0.0848898143,
0.1207196489,
0.9855142832,
-0.313388437,
-0.3911229372,
-1.0820713043,
0.2952940464,
0.2778246701,
-0.3233171403,
0.8704493642,
0.5838404298,
0.8924484253,
-0.2399045229,
0.6170253158,
0.1518162489,
0.0908678249,
-0.7566403747,
0.8139269948,
-0.631929338,
0.6533634663,
-0.4485987425,
-1.0630373955,
-0.6454474926,
0.7514246106,
-0.3527337611,
0.0027180882,
0.8010691404,
0.86167413,
0.0057998118,
-0.0685620457,
0.4350814223,
0.1234243214,
0.7504167557,
0.4296601117,
1.154534936,
-0.330645442,
0.2509287894,
0.0327652805,
-0.1289046854,
-0.3120012879,
-0.7329702377,
-1.2216988802,
-0.3863678575,
-0.3968939781,
-0.3589185774,
0.1640601158,
1.101031661,
0.6794825792,
-0.6643941998,
-0.2879165113,
-0.1342129856,
0.293733567,
0.011903313,
-0.1876980513,
0.615336895,
-0.1138014719,
-0.6400056481,
0.5038861632,
-0.0543737188,
-0.0555264503,
0.11680834,
0.1695611328,
-0.3482398093,
0.1335584521,
0.5989560485,
0.0549494624,
-0.6885638833,
-0.6242206693,
-0.225549534,
0.1939389855,
0.0203872006,
0.8406741023,
-0.3741976321,
0.2111079693,
0.5468689203,
0.8415958285,
0.278971225,
0.3861483634,
0.5107341409,
-0.8080294132,
0.1790126562,
0.2517779768,
0.2545217574,
0.2132778913,
-0.2266808152,
0.2717630565,
0.3479221761,
-0.4324788153,
-1.2828861475,
0.1899941862,
-0.9283599257,
-0.4153980613,
1.1532349586,
-0.3495848775,
-0.2121217549,
-0.2782657146,
0.0569608137,
0.1464598179,
-0.1797885597,
0.8844441772,
0.9079803824,
-0.0183415189,
-0.189093858,
-0.4117444456,
0.498208195,
0.2864634097,
-0.956348896,
0.6449698806,
0.9072626829,
0.3570173681,
-0.3273841739,
0.6706863642,
-0.0508768857,
0.0131104058,
-0.0492571071,
-0.0038034418,
-0.0433526486,
-0.5349804163,
-0.5238785148,
0.1612092555,
0.1736455858,
-0.3618271053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17974v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17974v1 | Evaluating Fairness in Large Vision-Language Models Across Diverse Demographic Attributes and Prompts | 2024-06-25T23:11:39 | 2024-06-25T23:11:39 | Xuyang Wu, Yuan Wang, Hsin-Tai Wu, Zhiqiang Tao, Yi Fang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Large vision-language models (LVLMs) have recently achieved significant
progress, demonstrating strong capabilities in open-world visual understanding.
However, it is not yet clear how LVLMs address demographic biases in real life,
especially the disparities across attributes such as gender, skin tone, and
age. In this paper, we empirically investigate \emph{visual fairness} in
several mainstream LVLMs and audit their performance disparities across
sensitive demographic attributes, based on public fairness benchmark datasets
(e.g., FACET). To disclose the visual bias in LVLMs, we design a fairness
evaluation framework with direct questions and single-choice
question-instructed prompts on visual question-answering/classification tasks.
The zero-shot prompting results indicate that, despite enhancements in visual
understanding, both open-source and closed-source LVLMs exhibit prevalent
fairness issues across different instruct prompts and demographic attributes. | [
-0.3157984316,
-0.4716834724,
0.6475166082,
0.315658927,
0.0136680771,
-0.3611775339,
-0.1389497966,
-0.3287588656,
-0.4224466085,
0.6737792492,
-0.6540970802,
-0.4884724021,
-0.3018839657,
-0.1169683486,
-0.0276591685,
0.7954324484,
0.2029773444,
0.4578444958,
-0.543155849,
-0.4718079269,
-0.7877873778,
-0.4221625328,
-0.4727241397,
0.029633496,
0.6472860575,
0.2191404253,
0.5121682286,
0.5226385593,
0.4675050378,
0.3030087352,
-0.152461648,
-0.1742875874,
-0.5753807425,
0.017696349,
-0.4302459359,
-0.495195359,
-0.3988306224,
0.0581285805,
0.7691888213,
0.7344071269,
-0.0704811886,
0.6316259503,
0.0529631339,
0.7877627611,
-1.0620191097,
0.1360947937,
-0.6292125583,
0.3858542442,
-0.319586277,
0.0604685247,
-0.4375245869,
-0.4743799865,
0.1905673742,
-0.2886309326,
0.4674769938,
0.1058049202,
0.5824584365,
0.3444798589,
-0.4254879355,
0.0332403257,
-0.3535062969,
0.7902501225,
-0.4433454573,
0.4439365864,
0.0781363994,
0.7718788981,
0.2001363337,
-0.401391536,
-0.6151896119,
-0.0877819061,
0.0241446216,
0.2154216319,
-0.3468443155,
0.0774626881,
0.543236196,
0.2160791159,
-0.7146981359,
0.4165079296,
-0.4329093099,
-0.1961595714,
0.4624887109,
0.3168958724,
0.0511897802,
-0.322180748,
-0.2371556461,
-0.1126541942,
-0.4791637361,
0.4943650365,
0.5064535737,
0.3583925366,
-0.3577207923,
0.6682968736,
-0.4008699358,
0.8625640273,
-0.0714177415,
0.1399546415,
0.4282855392,
-0.2377695292,
-0.2710805237,
-0.1851109713,
0.4525773823,
0.8793263435,
0.5962728262,
0.0754981786,
-0.3034083247,
0.162663281,
0.0333551019,
-0.7317866683,
0.2400778532,
0.0272133686,
-0.6881281734,
-0.1448292881,
-0.0095248157,
-1.1078724861,
-0.9148760438,
-0.2999981046,
0.4334634542,
0.1357426196,
-0.2187510431,
0.1215861142,
-0.4283554852,
0.4295306504,
0.7517160773,
-0.5389128327,
-0.0938465893,
0.6154438853,
0.4432890415,
-0.1012902036,
-0.0741476789,
-1.0012733936,
-0.3486808538,
-0.0371643342,
0.4483183324,
-0.5192174911,
0.0938430056,
0.2079757303,
-0.1111773998,
0.0434666574,
-0.6141232252,
0.2856910825,
-0.447704196,
0.3221159577,
-0.7101194859,
-0.1066669896,
-0.0328202993,
0.1656273603,
-0.537758112,
0.427980423,
0.0366524383,
-0.8559707999,
0.9092307687,
-0.6808535457,
0.084192872,
0.297973305,
-0.518271029,
-0.3619792163,
0.1518969089,
0.3869024217,
0.3103941381,
-0.0647279546,
0.3854675591,
-0.4251458049,
-0.3604603708,
0.2399426103,
-0.9503091574,
0.9470226169,
0.2006420344,
-0.4107250273,
0.2440826893,
-0.5928212404,
-0.2545377314,
0.1663353443,
0.1342608482,
-0.3503277898,
-0.0502338819,
-0.0751726255,
0.2073572129,
0.2503597736,
-0.6528559923,
-0.1060447693,
-0.1051738858,
0.0771499798,
1.2284657955,
-0.4388868511,
0.499556154,
-0.023831984,
0.4154417515,
0.1745562553,
0.6029485464,
-0.157938242,
-0.5455927849,
-0.7022172809,
-0.3767242432,
0.034284465,
0.4795757234,
-1.0039055347,
-0.0313318558,
-0.2694892585,
-0.0174469706,
-0.688180089,
-0.07967861,
0.5738139749,
0.6777274013,
0.0808851272,
-0.5189419985,
-0.0743988529,
-1.143917799,
-0.4330825508,
-0.1155496091,
-0.0999563262,
0.6858959198,
0.5814765096,
0.2438660711,
0.9910486341,
-0.2799357772,
-0.078407675,
0.1234867722,
-0.1164814606,
0.1645864397,
0.232705161,
0.8541275263,
-1.0176645517,
-0.1130042002,
-0.1547858268,
-0.8700154424,
-0.4916558564,
0.3545388579,
-0.0621796139,
0.1184508726,
0.0596828274,
-0.097922124,
0.8374403715,
0.4638312459,
-0.7644523978,
0.462806344,
0.0549354851,
0.5539384484,
-0.115315862,
0.0246867072,
0.2469673008,
-0.2237771749,
-0.3264088929,
0.2218256146,
0.11701262,
-0.077841118,
-0.9183099866,
0.7902693152,
-0.1330523342,
-0.6228779554,
0.2664892673,
0.2510813177,
-0.159988746,
0.4033658803,
-0.0924721062,
0.6900738478,
0.5050416589,
-0.3547128439,
0.236610204,
-0.0217741802,
-0.4068817794,
1.1527585983,
-0.4503229856,
-0.0304837376,
-0.8745977283,
0.2067562342,
-0.7757459879,
-0.0657731816,
0.3117519021,
-0.3094516098,
-0.2970411181,
-0.3872559369,
-0.1703857481,
-0.55511415,
-0.3809978366,
0.7916285992,
0.6106432676,
-0.562497437,
0.4582097232,
0.070603475,
-0.029078763,
-0.9058676362,
-0.5436820984,
-0.0966021344,
-0.2379088104,
-0.7922978401,
-0.2578622997,
-0.104395844,
-0.6652545333,
0.0044088732,
0.095114015,
-0.0141880494,
-0.0018665192,
0.2498751283,
0.2618964612,
-0.2992662191,
0.0025707379,
-0.2909851372,
0.1324965358,
-0.2391789705,
-0.1414881647,
0.4143367112,
-0.2879413962,
-0.7748565674,
-0.1411203593,
0.2239065766,
0.4982798696,
-0.6793690324,
0.6159973145,
0.5747282505,
-0.2288640887,
-0.1484694928,
-0.7941409349,
0.1264043748,
-0.456813097,
0.2797165215,
-0.1895186305,
-1.1631474495,
0.6468552947,
0.6238068342,
0.2963623405,
0.4221018255,
0.6137190461,
-0.011131824,
0.862062633,
0.3901320398,
0.5631385446,
0.5079892278,
0.2052194327,
-0.1992989182,
-0.492146194,
-0.4777353704,
-0.540556252,
-0.2708422542,
-0.5490637422,
-0.6871249676,
0.2968884408,
-0.2483681738,
-0.5910055041,
-0.1956103295,
-0.4180048704,
0.5211747289,
0.6498171687,
0.2167959064,
0.2981669009,
0.0725843906,
0.0206193235,
-0.3816137016,
-0.5629593134,
-0.3749553859,
0.9488025904,
0.4980310798,
0.7389122248,
0.0503262989,
0.4445798695,
0.4373226762,
0.4845179021,
-0.4563719928,
0.5332061648,
-0.6326391697,
-0.6187210679,
-0.3170680106,
-0.8063225746,
-0.7292964458,
0.5531474352,
-0.1800237149,
-0.8086793423,
0.5870594978,
0.3914968073,
-0.215015471,
0.3146443069,
-0.7141466737,
1.105702281,
-0.3716799617,
-0.4848437011,
-0.0610083379,
-0.564306736,
0.6568902731,
-0.0534677207,
0.3230298758,
-0.3295405507,
0.0660175085,
0.4827689826,
-0.2112095207,
0.7543483973,
-0.7387066483,
-0.1340963542,
0.0519136786,
-0.0784789473,
-0.0974968672,
-0.101773344,
-0.1733071655,
0.4735517502,
-0.1816620231,
-0.5313296914,
-0.6347411871,
0.5025416017,
-0.4737124741,
-0.4900599718,
-0.3773407936,
-0.3434549868,
-0.0659739077,
-0.0278376378,
-0.0308243148,
0.5852909684,
-0.2474893928,
0.2776132524,
0.6619617343,
-0.9422547221,
0.2777228057,
0.8039015532,
-0.459184438,
-0.1152627841,
0.7874034047,
0.0922307596,
0.4406731427,
0.1460620165,
0.0617373809,
-0.3174166977,
-0.3465186656,
-0.6912190318,
-0.0285341609,
-0.9241924882,
-0.01851766,
-0.5055391192,
-0.0760391057,
-0.2328617424,
-0.000272488,
-0.1868884414,
-0.1929977238,
0.2144651264,
0.2272588909,
0.2272661179,
0.7417570353,
-0.0091760969,
0.0269852877,
-0.3166852295,
0.6710078716,
0.7764776349,
0.6791318655,
0.2230955213,
-0.4418692589,
0.2026291192,
0.1836862415,
0.0309836231,
-0.6008414626,
-0.1429273188,
-0.1858277917,
0.6592868567,
0.1760712862,
-0.0216473602,
0.5566697717,
-0.751947999,
0.9991728067,
0.4302482307,
-0.8042484522,
0.4460091293,
-0.2176655829,
0.225274846,
0.5814077258,
-0.2217254937,
-0.6039015651,
-0.4313278198,
-0.0753571913,
-0.606254518,
0.6272449493,
0.3225715458,
0.0779652819,
0.0930303186,
0.1109707877,
0.1853538752,
0.4708074629,
-0.9159121513,
-0.3190555871,
-0.4500723779,
-0.2808738649,
0.2546979785,
0.0247260928,
-0.0463468693,
-0.1778530627,
-0.0367574617,
-0.0817446187,
0.01946068,
0.070781745,
-0.2208302319,
-0.0460357293,
0.4612436593,
0.5368660092,
0.8991084695,
-0.2155238092,
0.0082568433,
0.1559677869,
-0.3247734308,
0.1139623746,
-0.0257516615,
-0.3898968697,
-0.175090611,
0.3943364918,
1.0059971809,
-0.1673234105,
-0.7943612933,
1.0523473024,
-0.4701422453,
-0.1129479259,
0.1007316485,
0.1056048647,
-0.3778368831,
0.463595897,
0.4578133523,
0.0112425517,
0.1916773915,
-0.5565718412,
0.0343088247,
0.6501590014,
-0.5411378741,
0.1029103845,
0.8523054123,
0.4325064719,
-0.2599373758,
0.5485809445,
-0.0702938512,
-0.3745858073,
0.782567203,
-0.0638626814,
0.8350013494,
0.0130849695,
0.2857634127,
0.142753005,
0.5147153139,
0.2208851278,
0.120654352,
0.0468594581,
-0.5815019608,
-0.3888603449,
-0.7978905439,
-0.2128864676,
-0.0721093342,
-0.5997702479,
0.145328328,
-0.3931019008,
-0.0861880258,
-0.0062243715,
-0.5181314945,
-1.3506948948,
0.3827278912,
0.5093297362,
0.8684172034,
-0.8248451352,
0.0370057225,
0.4302999079,
-0.5258184671,
-0.2535003424,
-0.0959325209,
0.121045433,
-1.3017607927,
1.0083411932,
0.2723869383,
-0.0317294598,
-0.4808507562,
-0.7466306686,
-0.2417502105,
0.8685473204,
0.709884584,
-0.7790367007,
-0.0241304245,
0.2242150009,
0.4442535043,
-0.2679265141,
0.3793827593,
0.2956159711,
0.5559492111,
-0.0407516137,
-1.2471563816,
-0.137198776,
-0.1510158777,
0.0651986301,
-0.0842657015,
-0.6139690876,
0.9523020387,
-0.1738454998,
-0.2005942166,
-0.1010973752,
0.5087484121,
0.3447320163,
0.7581028342,
0.8763700724,
0.4234020114,
0.6430467963,
-0.2158857137,
1.0620448589,
0.2736829817,
0.2432424724,
0.9083191752,
-0.3604126573,
0.4677937925,
0.3010082245,
-0.1976554543,
0.2301313579,
0.2889963984,
0.0663862824,
0.4082398117,
0.3813327551,
-0.2332748026,
-0.3891610205,
-0.380291611,
-0.4566722512,
0.5350284576,
-0.1557424664,
-0.2942500114,
-0.3565191627,
0.1626524329,
-0.3659978211,
0.2151906639,
-0.7918250561,
0.6126765609,
-0.0009494474,
-0.5347205997,
0.2014843225,
-0.20293203,
0.8582410216,
-0.456040144,
-0.2868135571,
-0.3513965011,
0.0599022359,
-0.09407226,
-1.2687968016,
-0.2953176498,
0.4077901542,
-0.3078703284,
-0.1683287919,
0.4918008745,
-0.3508813977,
-0.4666165709,
0.2638908625,
0.4961263239,
0.1238558888,
-0.0951000303,
-0.7278391123,
0.1272392124,
-0.0509421341,
0.1237810552,
0.2308617234,
0.4902719855,
-0.3361312449,
0.6970718503,
0.4520614743,
-0.023826832,
0.1867466569,
0.6303503513,
0.5574291945,
-0.5425436497,
-0.4674298763,
-0.8790414333,
0.8754637837,
-0.3247018754,
-0.2630068362,
0.7604590058,
0.3208062351,
0.7575576901,
-0.019806087,
0.590218842,
0.0693769529,
0.2433209568,
-0.5307714343,
0.7001262307,
-0.7703667283,
0.102227807,
-0.5039759874,
-1.0556578636,
-0.0501728952,
0.5874310732,
-0.4606725872,
0.3012836277,
0.125695914,
0.6885354519,
0.0010360873,
-0.1971760541,
0.4736433625,
0.0919318795,
0.2874476016,
0.5583668351,
1.0862783194,
0.0267203096,
0.3647156358,
0.1624054462,
-0.4674625397,
-0.0979849547,
-1.0021629333,
-0.9403091669,
-0.2194167078,
-0.0833036751,
-0.2900345623,
0.3649914265,
0.6238332987,
0.4492807686,
-0.5655959845,
-0.0565046407,
0.3784208,
0.2830643356,
0.2121739537,
-0.2813373506,
0.1416332275,
0.0969624817,
-0.5455062389,
-0.2615541816,
0.4864833951,
-0.0582148321,
-0.5914347172,
-0.1599097997,
0.4694541693,
-0.1051208153,
0.7251486182,
0.0668598488,
-0.9054297209,
-0.4662633836,
-0.1003665328,
-0.1432304531,
0.0553272553,
0.6504197717,
-0.8264715075,
0.7400063276,
0.4449868798,
0.4223884046,
0.1997540146,
-0.0156285819,
0.5564354658,
-0.7265048623,
0.2999266088,
0.3095261753,
0.3918518424,
0.5158843398,
-0.129935205,
0.3504276574,
0.262616992,
-0.4004849792,
-0.915392518,
0.2653574049,
-0.8150709271,
-0.147055462,
0.9997243285,
0.0025586328,
-0.1854275316,
-0.0037699314,
-0.3398100436,
-0.1283430457,
-0.3382011354,
0.2957834601,
0.5540172458,
0.3235098422,
-0.3199578822,
-0.9499802589,
0.2264808863,
0.2644819319,
-0.6496037841,
0.2523769736,
0.8896391988,
0.191363439,
-0.2920432091,
0.7560908794,
-0.1678905934,
0.5781437755,
-0.1082833558,
0.0375619046,
0.0257753246,
-0.0850749165,
-0.59123981,
0.1024268419,
-0.0597054027,
-0.0305485614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17972v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17972v1 | LABOR-LLM: Language-Based Occupational Representations with Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T23:07:18 | 2024-06-25T23:07:18 | Tianyu Du, Ayush Kanodia, Herman Brunborg, Keyon Vafa, Susan Athey | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, econ.EM | Many empirical studies of labor market questions rely on estimating
relatively simple predictive models using small, carefully constructed
longitudinal survey datasets based on hand-engineered features. Large Language
Models (LLMs), trained on massive datasets, encode vast quantities of world
knowledge and can be used for the next job prediction problem. However, while
an off-the-shelf LLM produces plausible career trajectories when prompted, the
probability with which an LLM predicts a particular job transition conditional
on career history will not, in general, align with the true conditional
probability in a given population. Recently, Vafa et al. (2024) introduced a
transformer-based "foundation model", CAREER, trained using a large,
unrepresentative resume dataset, that predicts transitions between jobs; it
further demonstrated how transfer learning techniques can be used to leverage
the foundation model to build better predictive models of both transitions and
wages that reflect conditional transition probabilities found in nationally
representative survey datasets. This paper considers an alternative where the
fine-tuning of the CAREER foundation model is replaced by fine-tuning LLMs. For
the task of next job prediction, we demonstrate that models trained with our
approach outperform several alternatives in terms of predictive performance on
the survey data, including traditional econometric models, CAREER, and LLMs
with in-context learning, even though the LLM can in principle predict job
titles that are not allowed in the survey data. Further, we show that our
fine-tuned LLM-based models' predictions are more representative of the career
trajectories of various workforce subpopulations than off-the-shelf LLM models
and CAREER. We conduct experiments and analyses that highlight the sources of
the gains in the performance of our models for representative predictions. | [
-0.1138497889,
-0.3484329879,
0.6334455609,
-0.0901611,
0.0840098709,
0.0729987323,
-0.3668855727,
-0.5945587158,
0.0741756037,
0.8319146633,
-0.6643511653,
-0.3740309477,
-0.5580685735,
-0.047941491,
-0.4600135982,
0.8066785932,
0.2647378445,
0.0383191928,
-0.5848308206,
0.2709800303,
-0.3318630159,
-0.4133451879,
-0.6830686331,
-0.6448131204,
0.4315982163,
0.1963273883,
0.5865934491,
0.6802452803,
0.3500608802,
0.1970697641,
-0.026812328,
-0.069738239,
-0.7231500149,
-0.1241614893,
-0.0181300379,
-0.893828094,
-0.1645573378,
0.179388687,
0.3679191172,
1.2445229292,
-0.1119991392,
0.2218388319,
-0.074011676,
0.7326091528,
-0.4077168107,
0.521135509,
-0.7956610918,
0.0731632262,
-0.168722719,
-0.162864849,
-0.6445116401,
-0.3056131005,
0.1022784561,
-0.0413969383,
0.2101889849,
-0.0354973488,
0.4489886165,
0.1155520454,
-0.8020982742,
-0.065057002,
-0.9319119453,
0.8161190748,
-0.6047067046,
0.6959729791,
0.2862251997,
0.3535450399,
-0.0979485959,
-0.6155467629,
-0.1792002022,
-0.349416554,
-0.0648680702,
0.2036379874,
0.1593665332,
0.172811985,
0.0373592488,
0.4323108196,
-0.2121516019,
0.5027039647,
-0.6286820769,
0.1015858054,
0.627446115,
0.6197339892,
-0.2918920517,
0.4008021057,
-0.2458448112,
-0.1910804212,
-1.0420774221,
0.2208867371,
0.3947138488,
0.4310069382,
-0.1356475204,
0.5369098783,
-0.3264034986,
1.0135625601,
0.1198980287,
-0.4059718251,
0.0498795398,
0.0859976634,
-0.0826748312,
-0.3342367113,
0.4947748184,
0.3436678648,
0.2694966197,
-0.3468808234,
-0.3031558394,
0.2162208408,
0.1908677816,
-0.4190407693,
-0.1534945667,
-0.0610798933,
-0.4163086116,
-0.2462485135,
0.0556191951,
-0.4231017828,
-0.624630332,
-0.5174090862,
-0.1663805544,
0.1691762358,
-0.0649988949,
0.1177475378,
0.2863314152,
0.2531151175,
0.3730020821,
-0.8181276321,
0.1887384653,
0.85036093,
0.5970595479,
-0.6641796827,
-0.0425408222,
-0.2723727822,
0.0215977505,
-0.4555335939,
0.5811912417,
-0.6516873837,
-0.3851871789,
0.4321882427,
0.2439659834,
-0.2053789198,
-0.7431729436,
0.0335585326,
-0.8169324994,
0.1709310859,
-0.0346625336,
-0.5546214581,
-0.1879986376,
0.3418191671,
-0.829424262,
0.789386332,
0.4543617666,
-0.3861433566,
0.3810974956,
-0.47857517,
-0.2416571379,
-0.3709520698,
-0.233870253,
-0.17256473,
0.0629904196,
-0.2656844854,
0.6790372729,
-0.378718257,
0.3961982429,
-0.2437494248,
-0.4162489474,
0.2878474593,
-0.3775879741,
0.7559117675,
0.0110656582,
0.0030064136,
-0.15917252,
-0.4213814735,
-0.4900385439,
-0.2168459296,
-0.62215662,
0.0879963115,
-0.1027802974,
-0.1765737981,
0.3242878616,
0.3682163358,
-0.536955297,
0.0413550921,
-0.6227918267,
-0.0870112553,
0.7393528223,
-0.2052620947,
0.7149762511,
-0.5480331779,
0.8723740578,
-0.0586850345,
0.0068730614,
0.034537781,
-0.3173155487,
-0.5509659052,
0.2625642717,
0.2297653407,
0.6470444202,
-0.5378359556,
0.1794678718,
-0.3809764981,
-0.6225026846,
-0.0150181605,
0.1282425672,
0.0504412875,
0.6300354004,
0.1981581002,
-0.2154570669,
-0.7981385589,
-0.6366176605,
-0.3417060375,
-0.4050964713,
0.1309831589,
0.0679021478,
0.2085996568,
-0.1664829105,
0.9482873082,
-0.5763656497,
-0.1908341199,
-0.3873986006,
-0.0823883265,
0.9890497327,
0.2904345989,
0.2814840376,
-0.7990484834,
-0.5989129543,
0.0125329755,
-0.3833878338,
0.0195832383,
-0.3487600088,
0.0099424403,
-0.0235940181,
0.729064703,
-0.5525137782,
0.1792847961,
0.8031978607,
-0.4102529287,
0.8246856928,
0.1083378568,
-0.2961348593,
-0.936262548,
-0.0326639302,
0.2105578929,
-0.3158022761,
-0.6334097385,
-0.2065761089,
-0.1687678546,
-0.0674151555,
-0.5632222891,
0.8759440184,
-0.554723382,
-0.2900434136,
-0.1706214398,
-0.2622205019,
-0.2795490324,
0.3796114028,
0.219591096,
0.7922079563,
0.394166857,
-0.614541471,
0.450050205,
0.3751808107,
-0.3327413797,
0.4501552582,
-0.2900994122,
-0.0709236264,
-0.2045675218,
0.6013661623,
-0.6494429708,
-0.0815994516,
-0.1692133695,
-0.0230771303,
0.2450303733,
-0.2286580503,
-0.2749086916,
-0.5723000765,
-0.2071953416,
0.0360793397,
0.7428286076,
-0.4452921152,
0.5363317132,
0.3457981944,
-0.248113066,
-0.7267187238,
-1.02295959,
-0.0719978735,
-0.2835842669,
-0.3852744997,
0.6509153247,
0.0691705346,
-0.288913101,
-0.175633803,
-0.1319404691,
-0.3677929044,
0.0093601765,
0.1610395461,
0.7786925435,
-0.2787435353,
0.0768491104,
-0.1968470812,
-0.149199754,
0.3414486051,
-0.0015749091,
0.3917231858,
0.1791347265,
-0.4342313111,
0.2033285201,
-0.2619663179,
0.6681777835,
0.0562399551,
0.8695191741,
0.5786567926,
-0.2477979511,
0.0471369587,
-0.7266865373,
-0.271351248,
-0.4224127233,
0.4266545475,
0.0004894977,
-1.0459114313,
0.4811985195,
-0.4863467515,
0.2090220153,
0.390401721,
0.6316917539,
-0.2015387565,
0.6169123054,
0.8474780321,
-0.1988177747,
0.7651524544,
-0.4905568659,
0.0330188684,
-0.7696300745,
-0.4868447483,
-0.2071322501,
-0.303611666,
-0.4226494133,
-0.3972774446,
0.490175873,
-0.1518223137,
-0.1652646065,
0.2876008153,
-0.0980403274,
0.4789718091,
0.3397758007,
0.0987516791,
0.3165150881,
-0.0887690932,
0.3096215725,
0.0738752857,
-0.5735687613,
-0.3378846943,
1.3204454184,
0.3385696411,
0.8619321585,
-0.1483238339,
0.6184924245,
0.2674709857,
0.678255856,
-0.5870746374,
0.3956054449,
-0.6153860688,
-0.4624737501,
-0.4380260706,
-0.2724482715,
-1.0311006308,
0.271035552,
-0.5744670033,
-0.7438647151,
0.476233989,
0.1922252774,
-0.3665329814,
0.4885326624,
-0.2418916076,
0.6017438769,
-0.146041885,
-0.2419095188,
-0.1902303994,
-0.5038583279,
0.3900539875,
-0.260489583,
0.3828140795,
-0.3382231593,
-0.055522386,
0.6439465284,
-0.3133896291,
1.3151849508,
-0.2405416816,
-0.0584072955,
0.1109511852,
0.0084424783,
0.7909318805,
-0.1697235107,
-0.6394945383,
0.0531839654,
-0.1027783006,
-0.0253970437,
-0.3133943677,
0.4975777268,
-0.5110580325,
-0.6215330958,
-0.0348354392,
-0.6244324446,
-0.7564072609,
0.1279941946,
0.250849545,
0.2870812416,
-0.3097285628,
0.5516100526,
0.5182168484,
0.0641498938,
0.0018673018,
0.3488710225,
-0.1803933531,
0.0714065209,
0.5092782378,
0.178689912,
0.0675308928,
0.4879738092,
0.1461199075,
-0.7778349519,
-0.2624464035,
-0.1323492676,
0.4137127697,
-0.7666769624,
-0.3981644213,
-0.3771916032,
-0.2222763151,
-0.324110508,
-0.3171436787,
-0.236188516,
0.0082405508,
-0.5235004425,
-0.30555287,
0.2842184007,
0.7622444034,
-0.023640899,
0.2822962999,
-0.6227382421,
0.1992133558,
0.4515258968,
0.463335067,
-0.1427116692,
-0.4981622696,
-0.5818520188,
0.1572349072,
-0.1128042564,
-0.8010566831,
0.2803870142,
0.2768268585,
0.6859865189,
0.2420343161,
0.0814524218,
0.3839089572,
-0.2576345205,
0.7971196771,
0.393932879,
-0.4962789416,
0.0439947955,
-0.4368104339,
0.1379389465,
0.6806188226,
0.3674146533,
-0.6530599594,
-0.2565427423,
-0.6017974019,
-0.7192984223,
0.6100594997,
-0.1797133386,
0.4575331211,
0.025855571,
0.1874628365,
0.4958459437,
0.2138823718,
-0.6840624809,
-0.2407135814,
0.2682383955,
-0.2762315869,
-0.2264705747,
-0.221094206,
0.1697586328,
-0.274751395,
0.3854421079,
0.0230935197,
0.2590799928,
-0.3707892001,
-0.0687358603,
-0.1455389708,
0.1362588704,
0.1745254844,
0.9601071477,
-0.0750910938,
0.0452260561,
0.6000651121,
-0.0520684123,
0.1878618896,
-0.0852561295,
0.0549200773,
0.1774467081,
0.3168770075,
0.8948512077,
0.2349809706,
-0.7619417906,
0.5763806701,
0.4800937772,
-0.2914696038,
-0.8839583993,
0.2002355009,
0.4572134912,
0.3649603128,
0.3811659217,
0.0011067527,
-0.002436541,
-0.6804637909,
-0.0543485768,
0.3457500935,
-0.3680321872,
-0.2534628808,
0.7783823013,
0.1305447072,
-0.0951766968,
0.6043895483,
0.2019767165,
-0.1566620618,
0.9837164283,
0.7311837077,
0.4579890072,
-0.240555793,
0.1734208763,
0.1070195362,
-0.0319096707,
-0.7520703077,
0.1104110181,
0.3143011034,
-0.9161932468,
-0.5552499294,
-0.5646982193,
-0.5878839493,
0.176508829,
-0.7142814398,
0.2245578021,
-0.2218095064,
-0.0705821365,
-0.5335817337,
-0.3931055367,
-1.2005505562,
0.6739854813,
0.3236297965,
1.0376832485,
-1.2115647793,
0.699788332,
0.8060549498,
-0.0504328683,
-0.5027036667,
-0.0522953682,
-0.2836350501,
-0.9157651663,
0.6217073798,
0.1561933309,
-0.0344878584,
0.0532002226,
-0.2482522726,
-0.9388231635,
1.2442100048,
0.8780716062,
-0.6346386671,
-0.4122390449,
0.3028493226,
0.5164577365,
-0.6030732989,
0.1501848251,
0.7068648338,
0.3859789073,
-0.1886214018,
-0.9206160307,
-0.1273053586,
0.1092343107,
0.2448055446,
-0.0073553785,
-0.4255633652,
1.0080879927,
-0.1656585783,
-0.1429656595,
-0.0575429201,
0.6599859595,
0.2967926264,
0.2282894552,
0.8042286038,
0.1804382503,
0.7157462835,
-0.0871863514,
1.0559139252,
-0.6639752388,
0.6011995077,
0.8710883856,
0.0305834208,
0.9167356491,
0.3299824297,
-0.672273159,
0.9761425853,
0.6679211259,
-0.1594650447,
0.3191405237,
0.240942955,
-0.1821009517,
-0.4058262408,
-0.071029149,
-0.4051761031,
0.5261042118,
0.3630996346,
-0.4688866138,
-0.0422683954,
-0.0998835787,
-0.2598552704,
0.1715352982,
-0.412273109,
0.5357620716,
0.2994937301,
-0.4351628721,
0.4207235873,
-0.1160695404,
0.9592961669,
-0.5488777161,
-0.2317214161,
-0.3478322327,
-0.2280627787,
-0.355173856,
-0.8664332628,
0.5327678323,
-0.3376600146,
-0.1699990779,
-0.3923155367,
0.7561399341,
-0.6921726465,
-0.5187371373,
0.1292018592,
0.7627090812,
0.122134231,
-0.002735765,
-0.4577637613,
-0.1533092409,
-0.0914355963,
-0.345923245,
0.3267104924,
0.0525360405,
-0.0687147528,
0.6570727229,
0.5768942833,
0.3707806766,
0.0155981956,
-0.0705154166,
0.6105293036,
-0.5801684856,
-0.853831172,
-0.6361131072,
0.4691809118,
0.1065664217,
-0.0722629279,
0.1700348854,
0.4538289607,
0.998683393,
-0.481413424,
0.7487269044,
0.1727594733,
0.5577301383,
-0.6508452892,
0.4243818223,
-0.5124381185,
0.1818507761,
0.1021773666,
-0.9677355886,
-0.0946589559,
0.3074141443,
-0.650496006,
0.3138721883,
0.4789514244,
0.6740421653,
-0.1706121415,
-0.3596512675,
0.502253294,
0.0463560969,
-0.1458003968,
0.4991412461,
0.5848401785,
0.1226117834,
0.5395098925,
-0.288803339,
0.1664149761,
-0.5776973367,
-0.7031487226,
-0.5613321066,
-0.4547357559,
-0.3132721782,
-0.2340018451,
0.025820097,
0.7201509476,
0.7611814737,
-0.7402060628,
-0.6715137959,
-0.0672302991,
-0.0917495266,
-0.2646866441,
-0.268854022,
0.0665953904,
-0.035934858,
-0.5640563369,
0.6524452567,
-0.0804961473,
-0.2528263927,
-0.4875325561,
-0.1437683851,
0.2564324141,
-0.1833461374,
0.5223627687,
0.44123137,
-0.8121626973,
-0.0546721816,
-0.1483352035,
-0.055287905,
0.117358923,
0.8103808761,
-0.9065501094,
0.1200283393,
0.4339280128,
0.7700267434,
0.6110237241,
-0.0271539241,
0.7783209682,
-0.7641262412,
0.0497513451,
0.1393934488,
0.5170388222,
0.3498100042,
-0.764914453,
0.7932602763,
0.1462638378,
-0.1877699196,
-0.6150631309,
0.4166375995,
-0.6093156934,
-0.1791642755,
1.1114374399,
-0.0467276499,
-0.0453118533,
-0.2137190998,
0.1955983043,
0.2875577807,
-0.2737455368,
0.7952224612,
0.358209163,
-0.4261789024,
-0.4089490175,
-0.5946634412,
0.0336840674,
0.2138580382,
-0.6138998866,
0.151377067,
0.3888511062,
0.3874228597,
-0.1144409776,
0.9014120698,
0.0501855835,
0.318146497,
-0.074008733,
0.037497662,
-0.1730890274,
-0.2360391319,
-0.2002051622,
0.1706994474,
0.4284642935,
0.0454230532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17969v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17969v1 | Encourage or Inhibit Monosemanticity? Revisit Monosemanticity from a Feature Decorrelation Perspective | 2024-06-25T22:51:08 | 2024-06-25T22:51:08 | Hanqi Yan, Yanzheng Xiang, Guangyi Chen, Yifei Wang, Lin Gui, Yulan He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | To better interpret the intrinsic mechanism of large language models (LLMs),
recent studies focus on monosemanticity on its basic units. A monosemantic
neuron is dedicated to a single and specific concept, which forms a one-to-one
correlation between neurons and concepts. Despite extensive research in
monosemanticity probing, it remains unclear whether monosemanticity is
beneficial or harmful to model capacity. To explore this question, we revisit
monosemanticity from the feature decorrelation perspective and advocate for its
encouragement. We experimentally observe that the current conclusion by
wang2024learning, which suggests that decreasing monosemanticity enhances model
performance, does not hold when the model changes. Instead, we demonstrate that
monosemanticity consistently exhibits a positive correlation with model
capacity, in the preference alignment process. Consequently, we apply feature
correlation as a proxy for monosemanticity and incorporate a feature
decorrelation regularizer into the dynamic preference optimization process. The
experiments show that our method not only enhances representation diversity and
activation sparsity but also improves preference alignment performance. | [
-0.6740688682,
-0.5435858369,
0.2218607068,
0.4481211901,
-0.4380070269,
0.075044848,
-0.4983950555,
-0.4327435791,
0.9430325031,
0.3804256618,
-0.4718660414,
0.0481628813,
-0.5707184076,
0.0110876923,
-0.2526007593,
1.0181906223,
0.0063316901,
-0.061205171,
-0.5099423528,
-0.4423027635,
-0.4747198522,
-0.8605893254,
-0.7150412202,
-0.502012372,
0.9714246988,
0.223441869,
0.8571045995,
0.6871245503,
0.4727614522,
0.3331079781,
-0.3972479105,
0.1918190569,
-0.5477858782,
0.4415305555,
0.0661139488,
-0.4700155854,
-0.6992872357,
0.0089141559,
0.6379259229,
0.9359269738,
0.0188991521,
0.1256701648,
0.3541853428,
0.9277752042,
-0.4320552051,
0.0868118033,
-0.5192087889,
0.1078763604,
-0.1892940849,
-0.0843766853,
-0.2759980857,
-0.0442247652,
0.2908658087,
-0.4873223007,
0.1978022456,
0.0839713588,
0.8379677534,
0.1959404349,
-0.2060942799,
0.0853991956,
-0.6267486811,
0.8269526958,
-0.3779481351,
0.287450552,
0.1689193249,
-0.1000677049,
0.1697028279,
-0.1223342493,
-0.2725245655,
-0.4639027715,
-0.3990724087,
-0.058811713,
-0.0359644406,
-0.0445652381,
0.4288876355,
0.2876609862,
-0.2542576194,
0.1302884519,
-0.2606711984,
-0.3394995034,
0.5368307233,
0.0581234843,
0.2593479156,
-0.2047998011,
-0.6780864596,
-0.0808629394,
-0.4229429066,
0.3174003065,
0.3237172067,
0.5194786787,
-0.1508649141,
0.4381956756,
0.074913159,
0.266294986,
-0.0196040384,
0.2202087194,
0.2105536312,
-0.4509115815,
0.0554286689,
0.3591473997,
0.8237051368,
0.0921737328,
0.4523519874,
-0.1577464789,
-0.1366849393,
0.1707304418,
0.3927289546,
-0.7886288762,
-0.0663628429,
-0.0196876936,
-0.5543737411,
-0.3803641498,
0.2915045917,
-0.6557137966,
-0.4062671959,
-0.4075650871,
0.0697255656,
-0.477922231,
-0.5672084093,
0.1531488746,
-0.2783759534,
-0.1264303327,
0.3109703362,
-1.3404248953,
0.2874619067,
0.6992026567,
1.04586339,
-0.6373109818,
-0.5389515162,
0.1127871424,
-0.1315129697,
-0.5230894089,
0.5307943225,
-0.4025961459,
-0.1921189576,
-0.3953284323,
0.0215427876,
-0.1820296943,
-0.5235741735,
0.3396401405,
-0.4648689628,
-0.152521804,
-0.4144433439,
-0.2016616315,
-0.2423399091,
0.0935234725,
-1.0000292063,
0.3864533007,
-0.1085612774,
-0.8325307369,
0.6871894598,
-0.646276772,
-0.4794564247,
-0.2755873501,
-0.1591083109,
-0.4636105597,
0.5111281276,
-0.0040844139,
0.0146480072,
0.1704941243,
0.1970513761,
-0.6537547708,
-0.1725722253,
0.3989852667,
-0.5754387379,
0.5059080124,
0.085319303,
-0.0723721832,
0.3363493085,
-0.3977779746,
-0.3756958246,
0.2132175714,
-0.2623944879,
-0.6075106263,
0.2168836296,
-0.2887458205,
0.1065915823,
0.5055581331,
-0.2336717695,
0.2224916369,
-0.3377849162,
0.1602724344,
0.9955787063,
-0.1567883193,
0.6449679732,
-0.4823528528,
0.5545361042,
0.2832890749,
-0.079496026,
-0.1882543713,
-0.2827882767,
-1.0006514788,
-0.6344127059,
0.3604773581,
0.2038696408,
-0.2046900392,
0.6003801227,
-0.3234351873,
-0.1177522168,
-0.3657672405,
0.1082580611,
0.3580079675,
0.1156644151,
0.3108218312,
-0.8047795296,
-0.7320424318,
-1.1320340633,
-0.077410616,
-0.0614622608,
0.3210711479,
0.0888724998,
0.0485813841,
0.0984868258,
0.6971389651,
-0.3077069223,
-0.1601988673,
-0.4039329588,
0.0212740097,
0.3351908326,
0.5788296461,
0.7799787521,
-0.5263983011,
-0.2013475895,
0.017490577,
-0.7187072039,
0.1914499402,
-0.0375793725,
-0.2352373749,
0.2693823874,
0.1938852668,
-0.5575588346,
0.2693891525,
0.4197391272,
-0.2961788177,
0.4786552787,
-0.0576710068,
0.0217877775,
-0.8853402138,
-0.0647753626,
0.0755498037,
-0.1049584076,
-0.6538355947,
-0.0569002628,
-0.2418604791,
-0.0388524048,
-0.1167312115,
0.4710589647,
-0.3813771904,
0.0504409112,
-0.3792072833,
-0.1364747286,
-0.0291328337,
0.2395664603,
0.2866983414,
0.9040156007,
0.6744033694,
-0.6702901125,
0.0289941598,
0.3836652935,
-0.2067388892,
0.0002974396,
-0.4629349709,
-0.0130874338,
-0.1376470774,
-0.2063527703,
-0.9531686902,
-0.0725432485,
-0.2060841471,
-0.3202267289,
0.5454145074,
-0.0769881159,
-0.3372637331,
-0.1239571571,
-0.4813311994,
0.3179757893,
0.4173978269,
-0.4361625612,
0.2318231612,
0.3316683471,
-0.065846242,
-0.3750940263,
-0.6941393614,
-0.0582116693,
-0.2716625035,
-0.8519945741,
0.1483419091,
-0.0313673951,
-0.1313697845,
-0.3502235115,
-0.4257298112,
0.5513576269,
0.4014938176,
0.0909040868,
0.4514714777,
-0.4583091736,
0.1960270852,
0.0068076532,
-0.209521845,
0.1094438285,
-0.0478328466,
0.9836969972,
-0.1579096317,
-0.3363873959,
-0.4604829252,
0.1856598705,
0.7205121517,
-0.346516341,
0.8380122185,
0.2596257031,
0.0733570457,
-0.1233933643,
-0.2257728875,
-0.6975340843,
-0.5075396299,
0.4311557412,
-0.3518341184,
-1.0626147985,
0.494585067,
0.0888352543,
-0.2366401404,
0.1561958343,
0.3518978655,
-0.0059362627,
1.1027718782,
0.5943837762,
-0.3081169426,
0.7756868005,
-0.1107371897,
0.3053075671,
-0.9623991847,
0.1054717451,
-0.1783296168,
-0.6637098193,
-0.8386459947,
0.0058799009,
0.3404890895,
0.1374567449,
-0.2505729496,
0.4440149069,
-0.5851043463,
0.1679282784,
0.4383330941,
0.368366152,
0.0788320303,
0.335998565,
-0.2433784753,
-0.3629795015,
-0.7350837588,
-0.6476632357,
0.8537560105,
0.3923558891,
0.9863026738,
0.1733289659,
0.6500422955,
0.115511246,
0.1173409894,
-0.8923202157,
0.7357083559,
-0.4768777788,
-0.3903350234,
-0.2760920525,
-0.2625673115,
-0.9195733666,
0.271288842,
-0.4338055551,
-0.6568151712,
0.4722975492,
0.3690086007,
-0.1888985336,
0.3022927642,
-0.6687901616,
0.9503057003,
-0.4693332613,
-0.711209476,
-0.2002420574,
-0.2686567307,
0.4555440247,
-0.1473998725,
-0.1356868744,
-0.0985247344,
-0.1883175522,
0.5413706303,
-0.0568287075,
0.7835898995,
0.1786381155,
0.0204137042,
-0.2354234308,
0.418077141,
0.3294537961,
0.0033876891,
-0.4249229729,
0.2782043517,
-0.2858366668,
-0.2989850044,
-0.5967966318,
0.8533523083,
-0.7452894449,
-1.0470198393,
-0.3985034823,
-0.7315460443,
-0.1326726675,
0.1787078083,
-0.0573690198,
0.1731166989,
-0.2353352755,
0.1971880049,
0.8076379895,
0.2088409364,
0.5063078403,
-0.070185557,
-0.539568603,
-0.2610806525,
0.9262766242,
0.1021253914,
0.7852825522,
0.1233456582,
0.3350670934,
0.0371370427,
-0.5890675783,
-0.1431098878,
0.3176887035,
-0.4712893069,
0.3322080374,
-0.6504812241,
-0.353617847,
-0.3878573179,
-0.0650545955,
-0.4049479365,
-0.7044692039,
-0.3875568807,
0.0267914589,
0.238271445,
0.3215416074,
-0.0015063307,
-0.0063459035,
-0.5832262635,
0.0949759781,
0.3248831332,
0.2796296179,
0.0913164467,
-0.6540176272,
-0.3017027378,
0.0057334206,
-0.3045897484,
-0.4221947193,
0.2927951515,
0.0013614787,
0.5452437401,
0.9303416014,
-0.191812247,
0.7754733562,
-0.4716154039,
0.6952303052,
0.3297068477,
-0.7783645988,
0.4579277039,
-0.1401483864,
0.2264240086,
0.4796938002,
0.4448001087,
-0.3721300066,
-0.523263216,
-0.4533825219,
-0.5905979872,
0.8631305695,
0.16662696,
0.5951701999,
-0.0486801043,
-0.0068387967,
0.0336276405,
0.4959192574,
-0.6549243331,
-0.347690016,
-0.3920675218,
0.2470891625,
-0.0365659706,
-0.4149774909,
-0.3379053473,
-0.4660637975,
0.5004696846,
-0.0694762915,
0.3130853176,
0.0815674663,
0.2956667244,
-0.1190326363,
0.3032528758,
0.8562155366,
0.7006382942,
-0.328959018,
0.2059980929,
-0.0879753307,
-0.2693802714,
0.1289722174,
-0.1252140403,
-0.3441114128,
0.0599802844,
0.3924607635,
1.2307888269,
-0.0679955631,
-0.0324071683,
0.3164182007,
0.0954727083,
0.0243907776,
-0.107849583,
0.3247899711,
0.055587206,
0.0076236855,
-0.1337651908,
0.5949288607,
-0.1977532804,
-0.6860458255,
0.1755657047,
0.9652495384,
-0.5414420962,
-0.3241061568,
0.569591403,
0.0328837447,
-0.2039741278,
0.2975117564,
-0.0781027153,
-0.5596287847,
0.814476192,
0.6074445248,
1.086623311,
-0.1759116352,
-0.0264118668,
0.6759393811,
0.4388898909,
-0.2020884603,
-0.0346438102,
-0.1227545366,
-1.1633707285,
-0.1377861649,
-0.6278086901,
-0.2224834561,
-0.1778331399,
-0.7067946196,
0.5020867586,
-0.4815797508,
-0.3419167995,
0.1517428905,
-0.5579385757,
-0.088020578,
-0.2694387436,
0.303737402,
0.7586562634,
-0.6197704077,
0.9340537786,
0.7453417182,
-0.641033411,
-0.6242782474,
0.1914281845,
0.0225380193,
-0.6168184876,
0.8425132036,
0.3334984481,
-0.1767030209,
-0.1887565255,
-0.4966807663,
-0.976025641,
0.9148137569,
0.4466838539,
-0.5519323349,
-0.0628217161,
-0.0140946731,
0.5023095012,
-0.7217898369,
0.0742069855,
0.4616509378,
0.4236169159,
0.072915487,
-0.8868681788,
0.3358095884,
-0.1028780565,
0.2108448893,
0.441835314,
-0.7683953643,
0.7697962523,
-0.3388310075,
-0.3515895307,
0.0863377303,
0.6245540977,
0.3121728599,
-0.1646134406,
0.6348044872,
0.5987776518,
0.4573866129,
-0.0953514352,
0.9920495152,
-0.3852028847,
0.3614030778,
0.9634895921,
-0.297604084,
0.6064830422,
0.9562191367,
-0.2188293636,
0.4872606397,
0.3921522796,
-0.090473935,
0.5248137116,
0.2532158494,
-0.337667346,
-0.6598106623,
-0.1483322829,
-0.1780950427,
0.4509133101,
0.1190428659,
-0.631532371,
-0.0715885088,
0.0357197039,
0.0163162444,
0.0676980019,
-0.144752115,
0.8220377564,
0.217641443,
-0.7573732734,
0.8273133636,
-0.4845186472,
0.8334149122,
-0.9612519741,
0.1640562117,
-0.4524714351,
0.1363582015,
-0.2244921923,
-0.5865907669,
0.3574643731,
-0.4483044147,
-0.558326304,
-0.2691750228,
0.6536376476,
-0.4341190457,
-0.3654909432,
0.4753603041,
0.3690225482,
-0.2674327195,
0.2083346993,
-0.5763588548,
0.0559779555,
0.0032285315,
-0.2105554044,
0.6356034875,
0.2163871229,
0.0044632345,
0.6710833311,
0.7930378914,
0.4803418517,
-0.1657708883,
0.1515596062,
1.0100911856,
-0.4441303909,
-0.2918880284,
-1.0570636988,
0.4358303249,
-0.2861097753,
0.0107523669,
0.766430974,
0.6951620579,
0.7748996615,
-0.1889648736,
0.5225068927,
0.0152724534,
0.1341165602,
-0.4072904885,
0.9295793772,
-0.7483035326,
0.5472609401,
-0.0522413068,
-0.7762820125,
-0.1919250786,
0.4667552412,
-0.263538152,
-0.0340899639,
0.9195338488,
1.0591048002,
-0.3434000611,
-0.0034426437,
0.5934249759,
-0.1037269086,
0.009761516,
0.0891052783,
0.8162453771,
0.0705717653,
0.2271188051,
-0.3308888376,
-0.2059663981,
0.0654244274,
-0.7859710455,
-0.9741899967,
-0.5006510615,
-0.3687306345,
-0.54433465,
-0.168821916,
1.1623976231,
0.8255136013,
-0.8494948745,
-0.5934160948,
-0.1158080027,
0.2993179262,
-0.3827937543,
-0.2505138814,
0.1599065065,
-0.9242157936,
-0.505297482,
0.2724799514,
0.5370262861,
0.0667328537,
-0.4560208619,
0.142952472,
-0.1923091114,
0.2971425653,
0.6652220488,
0.114114739,
-0.6226090193,
-0.2445376515,
0.0351937935,
-0.2331515998,
0.4932500422,
1.0647028685,
-0.3552802801,
0.5984426141,
0.4841990471,
0.5474549532,
0.1918788552,
-0.0927122384,
0.4331337512,
-0.5449698567,
0.3777128458,
-0.0028430081,
0.6185077429,
0.1596100628,
-0.2450736761,
0.3306862116,
0.4268900156,
-0.4617039263,
-0.5876689553,
0.5701444149,
-1.1031577587,
-0.0579268038,
1.0406388044,
0.0320350155,
-0.3824562132,
0.1849964112,
-0.1536733806,
0.0270304214,
-0.5979307294,
0.7999908328,
0.8738932014,
-0.2157673389,
-0.4403474331,
-0.3354979455,
0.5729200244,
0.7920746803,
-0.6558220983,
0.2009323835,
0.287728399,
0.1283709109,
0.5803345442,
0.2818385661,
-0.1357735544,
0.1810427904,
-0.2684362233,
0.2045260966,
-0.0789884478,
-0.1795323193,
-0.4680482149,
-0.0133548081,
0.4229661524,
-0.2746067941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17967v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17967v1 | Unmasking the Imposters: In-Domain Detection of Human vs. Machine-Generated Tweets | 2024-06-25T22:49:17 | 2024-06-25T22:49:17 | Bryan E. Tuck, Rakesh M. Verma | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid development of large language models (LLMs) has significantly
improved the generation of fluent and convincing text, raising concerns about
their misuse on social media platforms. We present a methodology using Twitter
datasets to examine the generative capabilities of four LLMs: Llama 3, Mistral,
Qwen2, and GPT4o. We evaluate 7B and 8B parameter base-instruction models of
the three open-source LLMs and validate the impact of further fine-tuning and
"uncensored" versions. Our findings show that "uncensored" models with
additional in-domain fine-tuning dramatically reduce the effectiveness of
automated detection methods. This study addresses a gap by exploring smaller
open-source models and the effects of "uncensoring," providing insights into
how fine-tuning and content moderation influence machine-generated text
detection. | [
-0.2075751722,
-0.7038981318,
0.4818062186,
-0.0122191869,
-0.3962635398,
0.6439609528,
-0.1360197067,
-0.6130881906,
-0.2938219607,
0.8593036532,
-0.3255268335,
-0.5261948705,
-0.7853703499,
0.3899214268,
-0.7878279686,
0.6626539826,
-0.1987510026,
-0.2140847147,
0.0209339,
0.1136902198,
-0.1237942502,
-0.404979825,
-0.3356920779,
-0.4452171922,
0.1763358116,
0.4974986315,
0.7379209399,
0.5134726763,
0.423401624,
0.1798720062,
0.1002826989,
0.5257205367,
-0.6738209724,
-0.0222165864,
-0.1758907139,
-0.0898813307,
0.0429362692,
0.0255543683,
0.5616019368,
0.4185305536,
0.1270156056,
0.322696507,
0.2632699609,
0.4163471162,
-0.5169839263,
0.0023204396,
-1.0248972178,
-0.3331934214,
-0.2941554487,
-0.5217835307,
-0.5415724516,
-0.4291895628,
0.0060424805,
-0.3967404068,
0.5674019456,
0.0637836531,
0.8979172111,
0.1719081998,
-0.232351616,
-0.4818377793,
-0.8345886469,
0.8199907541,
-0.708717525,
0.1468793899,
0.3273200095,
0.1094738245,
-0.4306756258,
-0.7804013491,
-0.7252865434,
-0.0126182334,
-0.0601419061,
-0.1008821279,
-0.7171940804,
0.0211648531,
0.2136805505,
0.1950114071,
-0.4299895167,
0.4162177145,
-0.2946456373,
-0.159162879,
0.5979129076,
-0.0033523871,
0.4541817009,
-0.0446577258,
-0.146848157,
0.1670788378,
-1.0135937929,
-0.4588185847,
0.5096657276,
0.278986007,
0.0137012489,
0.584803164,
-0.1205367669,
0.4183522463,
0.017400438,
0.0232250318,
-0.0723750442,
0.0121452706,
-0.4407178462,
-0.1828083247,
0.9485484362,
0.3648533523,
0.6846880317,
-0.4108174741,
-0.3792000711,
0.0407887548,
0.0932980999,
-0.801251173,
-0.1839750111,
-0.0047300248,
-0.3885582387,
-0.5247501135,
0.3401907682,
-0.4114828408,
-0.6608531475,
-0.2338253856,
0.6078404188,
-0.2690357864,
-0.1315626353,
0.0869134665,
-0.2137762159,
-0.0441776849,
0.3223557472,
-0.5488897562,
0.2709311545,
0.6203856468,
0.5874341726,
-0.1526942849,
-0.0093268072,
-0.2482673824,
0.2051144838,
-0.5628948212,
0.6169806123,
-0.5558130145,
-0.2964751124,
0.3210939765,
0.1652197391,
0.1639156491,
-0.8221225739,
0.4509693384,
-0.6572396159,
0.1352476329,
-0.2284828275,
-0.677434504,
-0.1067151502,
-0.0931940675,
-0.7060669661,
1.0199494362,
0.3584614992,
-0.6585735679,
0.4018937349,
-0.7126479149,
-0.3848074675,
0.2833856642,
-0.049944561,
-0.4869678319,
0.2448914796,
0.3927078545,
0.7579471469,
-0.4974757731,
0.2922390103,
-0.0885271728,
-0.6180495024,
0.4188088179,
-0.5208874345,
1.0346381664,
0.107320644,
-0.3897119164,
0.1080938503,
-0.5329231024,
-0.3213014007,
0.3563541472,
-0.1304751784,
-0.2509192824,
-0.0402004234,
-0.1313310415,
0.0424583219,
-0.0337181203,
-0.7616168857,
-0.4851068556,
-0.2783156037,
0.6780698895,
0.7343370318,
0.2481630296,
0.4269756973,
-0.3527257442,
0.4663637578,
0.0930140689,
0.1232712418,
-0.2380559891,
-0.6337026954,
-0.5575771928,
-0.1722622365,
0.1563117057,
0.3414294422,
-0.9975646734,
0.1955501735,
-0.1509847343,
-0.4041877985,
-0.7978715897,
0.3971631229,
0.5161488652,
0.3813612759,
0.2715511322,
0.1945658028,
-0.4479428232,
-0.9541121721,
-0.6552551985,
-0.0551104508,
-0.2522938848,
-0.070397906,
0.6486960649,
-0.2168868929,
0.7208156586,
-0.1033134833,
-0.0613544993,
-0.2488229871,
0.0937459022,
-0.1404657662,
0.2008359581,
0.5869373679,
-0.5455443263,
-0.8884755373,
-0.2045894712,
-0.8261805177,
-0.3020141125,
0.1583082974,
0.146280244,
0.4186016619,
0.5784489512,
-0.5936089158,
0.6068164706,
0.4726850092,
0.0992791131,
0.4595231414,
0.0790980905,
0.088383548,
-0.9313717484,
-0.2611997128,
0.1707188189,
-0.3672301769,
-0.7255367637,
0.1465122253,
0.3741129637,
-0.0276547801,
-0.4130343199,
0.5586708784,
-0.6654452085,
0.1623995602,
-0.2246009558,
-0.0131415017,
0.1420511901,
0.1362590194,
-0.3663904071,
0.9086520672,
0.3407415152,
-0.3219520748,
0.0925699994,
-0.1196355671,
-0.5993021727,
0.0671572983,
-0.6970106959,
0.3901570737,
-0.1267392784,
0.2089114636,
-1.1250460148,
-0.5802352428,
0.4783651233,
-0.6913923025,
0.2478301078,
-0.191331327,
-1.2681359053,
-0.4912640154,
-0.5505597591,
0.2020347565,
0.6888539195,
-0.8109443784,
0.2911562324,
0.4674265981,
0.3363391757,
-0.3558549881,
-0.6464766264,
0.324431926,
-0.3091799617,
-0.4667975307,
0.5561414361,
0.1349588633,
-0.5278638601,
0.0050344355,
0.0261666458,
0.0514965579,
0.1262718886,
0.1593899578,
0.0732438415,
-0.0649767667,
-0.0106840041,
0.0809012353,
0.2755840421,
0.0985548869,
-0.2531544268,
0.3323282897,
0.2118434608,
-0.1877542734,
-0.7575504184,
0.2052098811,
0.4902998209,
-0.1214975417,
0.861455977,
0.5470412374,
-0.7389376163,
-0.5186696053,
-0.5227093101,
-0.234121412,
-0.5163897872,
-0.0213083196,
0.0129375765,
-1.0770097971,
0.4286392629,
0.1032816917,
0.0511502586,
0.3849203289,
0.555459857,
-0.1182041988,
1.0814651251,
0.6962032914,
0.158832863,
0.4106170237,
-0.0428583212,
0.293833971,
-0.5114121437,
-0.1410389394,
-0.4486615062,
0.0076898006,
-0.8780505657,
-0.4495797157,
0.2165734023,
-0.1166643575,
-0.3053405881,
0.4209354818,
-0.659824729,
0.6988639832,
0.6882299781,
0.2809296548,
0.3101442158,
0.2436912805,
0.3482815623,
0.0687247217,
-0.4297636747,
-0.9507744908,
1.3895946741,
0.4780303836,
0.7661262155,
0.1331415921,
0.4846280217,
0.548848927,
0.6265405416,
-0.5017810464,
0.56237638,
-0.5086972117,
-0.6605385542,
-0.0662941635,
-0.2549446523,
-0.7128992081,
0.1383915097,
-0.1088640392,
-0.6252247095,
-0.0970910788,
0.0900525525,
-0.1048285812,
0.7255948782,
-0.8034684658,
0.4197357595,
0.0661836714,
-0.2695572376,
0.0648689345,
-0.49674353,
0.5699882507,
-0.3876515031,
-0.036937356,
-0.4000032246,
-0.0827687383,
0.6657840014,
-0.1714266688,
1.175868988,
-0.1049165502,
-0.2322195023,
0.5158833265,
0.2419849485,
0.4625635743,
-0.1255306751,
0.0005581201,
0.3364934921,
-0.3974354267,
-0.3512017429,
-0.1312290281,
0.6687322259,
-0.7382304668,
-0.5750402212,
-0.008984833,
-0.4555747509,
-0.2289776057,
0.293672353,
0.6253367066,
0.3600329459,
-0.299436301,
0.2663769424,
0.7908669114,
-0.261151582,
0.5190067291,
0.6108356118,
0.0132391797,
-0.1608414352,
0.7365136743,
0.0260062125,
0.2392689139,
0.5263604522,
0.2013375461,
-0.2467533946,
-0.8026125431,
-0.4889290333,
0.3079477847,
-0.696754396,
-0.4587520659,
-0.5955516696,
-0.3433019519,
-0.5106128454,
-0.0407903455,
-0.0775523037,
-0.2377084196,
-0.7531588078,
-0.0551584996,
0.2644545138,
1.0795040131,
0.1455794126,
0.7113513947,
-0.5634837151,
0.4330563247,
0.0898687989,
0.2747600973,
-0.0659934655,
-0.8791770935,
-0.2586443424,
0.1996865124,
-0.4493765235,
-0.8588979244,
0.3308368921,
0.0528202951,
0.5077212453,
0.535806179,
0.1761914939,
0.3311578035,
-0.3453373015,
0.617249012,
0.0043410351,
-0.9130725861,
0.2786682248,
-0.5480608344,
0.0081607904,
0.0832882971,
0.3053264022,
-0.1472386271,
-0.6813257337,
-0.5174918175,
-0.474986285,
0.6119021773,
0.4647547901,
0.5067639947,
-0.1827727556,
0.3136586845,
0.3331298828,
0.2811997533,
-0.5844905376,
-0.0350063369,
-0.1722814441,
-0.1385651231,
-0.0384397879,
-0.5281760693,
-0.0681273714,
-0.0976514518,
0.428722918,
0.0500171781,
0.2526956499,
-0.1639598608,
-0.3675382137,
-0.5057225227,
-0.0341506079,
0.6294369102,
0.650349617,
-0.2709468901,
0.1973181516,
-0.239488855,
-0.3124267757,
-0.0600329824,
-0.1004669219,
-0.3662775457,
0.2555006444,
0.5579645634,
0.6097908616,
0.0298021697,
-0.6123992801,
0.4437377453,
0.2155133486,
-0.3336955309,
-0.36783126,
-0.0227190163,
0.0135008022,
-0.010586055,
0.5442519784,
0.0187528431,
-0.0758894607,
-0.5859391093,
0.1299108118,
0.4557744861,
-0.2792702019,
-0.7000921965,
0.8333166838,
0.1633086652,
-0.4778744578,
0.325956434,
-0.1271920949,
-0.4970732331,
0.5783154964,
0.6337951422,
1.0459213257,
-0.2624791563,
0.2614283264,
0.0968029946,
0.8330937624,
-0.1725855172,
0.0294134691,
0.2947516441,
-1.0573378801,
-0.1333284378,
-0.2572199404,
-0.3734333813,
0.5093561411,
-0.3590917587,
0.1375543922,
-0.4959457815,
-0.1170828342,
0.386310935,
-0.2203356624,
-0.7617689967,
-0.0712204203,
0.1464899629,
0.8472489119,
-0.8347209096,
0.7585570812,
0.5016106963,
-0.3790384531,
-0.4736047685,
0.4971293807,
0.1173988059,
-1.0024994612,
0.3397874832,
0.2641915977,
-0.2977770865,
0.2816485763,
-1.1029245853,
-0.3241872191,
0.9153021574,
0.6371040344,
-0.2069801092,
0.0730141103,
0.5806193352,
0.5582867265,
-0.4348276556,
-0.1501741111,
0.6547382474,
0.1970850229,
-0.2092590779,
-0.8894226551,
0.1838707179,
0.1185757369,
-0.0225832257,
0.1569865346,
-0.3276368678,
0.8264812231,
-0.1585138887,
-0.6080367565,
0.0861751139,
0.346085161,
0.0165540259,
0.2106158435,
0.2370684296,
0.2675044835,
0.5375729203,
0.039957691,
0.9266824126,
-0.1197441816,
0.0401352979,
0.8319644928,
-0.3108156025,
0.6217397451,
0.3779193759,
0.0343004577,
0.3810906112,
0.5413258672,
0.0265012681,
0.3245842457,
0.2187685221,
-0.2916747928,
-0.1224568337,
-0.2970161736,
0.0736992136,
0.2787542045,
0.6195119023,
-0.5968313217,
-0.3886351287,
-0.0225001946,
0.3233806193,
0.3062417805,
-0.3205129802,
0.6408974528,
0.0734696388,
-0.4516684413,
0.7173320651,
0.1641696095,
0.7217385173,
-0.1252532303,
-0.0179278459,
-0.2670093477,
0.1564845145,
-0.1606794149,
-1.0513371229,
0.1016067266,
0.3460995555,
0.0551845022,
-0.2862577438,
1.1470977068,
-0.2488597631,
-0.3902885616,
0.5247107148,
0.6669199467,
0.1453731805,
-0.5259275436,
-0.5855529308,
0.0649942234,
-0.0316724256,
-0.0868169889,
0.0897141472,
0.6734421849,
-0.4164807796,
0.7406439185,
0.6741427183,
-0.2246310413,
0.1779320985,
0.2850838304,
0.9444741011,
-0.4482624233,
0.0256110951,
-0.9842113256,
0.1949298531,
-0.1210032478,
0.0633373708,
0.8425269723,
0.4811188877,
1.0483850241,
-0.1876382232,
0.9966489673,
0.2033362687,
0.8593490124,
-0.2561005652,
0.7488287687,
-0.5858561397,
0.4929183424,
-0.3193193376,
-0.6397503018,
-0.4243119359,
-0.0930289105,
-0.0106261345,
0.0505992733,
0.4564383924,
0.9784137607,
-0.2573591769,
-0.1189596802,
0.5424771905,
0.1488770097,
0.3071396947,
0.2088719606,
1.1303747892,
-0.375800848,
0.5146769285,
-0.4177984595,
-0.140095681,
-0.4823446572,
-0.7754383087,
-1.4823226929,
-0.4604998827,
-0.1966729611,
-0.4066288173,
0.1138079092,
0.6105077267,
0.4199816287,
-0.8070021272,
-0.1573957205,
-0.0752472952,
0.0730931833,
0.1516247839,
-0.2358253747,
0.3162257373,
0.0146665964,
-0.6521104574,
0.2813619375,
0.1742748022,
0.2826955318,
-0.2809923291,
0.0991071761,
0.1483601481,
0.5329583883,
0.8106341958,
0.0328677669,
-0.9775801301,
-0.3625471592,
0.265114516,
-0.1360949576,
-0.0840843469,
0.7317426205,
-0.5587038994,
0.2375567555,
0.463998735,
0.289534837,
0.1036016718,
0.2529740632,
0.4944674075,
-0.810141921,
-0.0440622829,
0.1685946435,
0.1814243197,
0.5952813625,
-0.265751332,
0.4815138578,
0.3375853002,
-0.463234514,
-1.146427989,
0.1428452432,
-0.5583408475,
-0.5298423171,
1.2215979099,
0.1354911476,
-0.0090356935,
-0.4658838511,
0.1501322091,
0.3322454393,
-0.5647894144,
0.8054586649,
0.4466375411,
0.0442587063,
-0.183562398,
-0.8305717707,
0.6808917522,
-0.2154788524,
-0.6259272099,
0.1319207698,
0.2479345202,
0.5408511758,
-0.2203302681,
0.6828189492,
-0.1761096567,
0.0681751296,
-0.1969378442,
0.0294360779,
-0.1736097932,
-0.1923932135,
-0.1738114357,
-0.0580745898,
-0.0322077312,
-0.3519675732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17962v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17962v2 | SimsChat: A Customisable Persona-Driven Role-Playing Agent | 2024-06-25T22:44:17 | 2024-06-30T21:15:47 | Bohao Yang, Dong Liu, Chen Tang, Chenghao Xiao, Kun Zhao, Chao Li, Lin Yuan, Guang Yang, Lanxiao Huang, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) possess the remarkable capability to understand
human instructions and generate high-quality text, enabling them to act as
agents that simulate human behaviours. This capability allows LLMs to emulate
human beings in a more advanced manner, beyond merely replicating simple human
behaviours. However, there is a lack of exploring into leveraging LLMs to craft
characters from several aspects. In this work, we introduce the Customisable
Conversation Agent Framework, which employs LLMs to simulate real-world
characters that can be freely customised according to different user
preferences. The customisable framework is helpful for designing customisable
characters and role-playing agents according to human's preferences. We first
propose the SimsConv dataset, which comprises 68 different customised
characters, 1,360 multi-turn role-playing dialogues, and encompasses 13,971
interaction dialogues in total. The characters are created from several
real-world elements, such as career, aspiration, trait, and skill. Building on
these foundations, we present SimsChat, a freely customisable role-playing
agent. It incorporates different real-world scenes and topic-specific character
interaction dialogues, simulating characters' life experiences in various
scenarios and topic-specific interactions with specific emotions. Experimental
results show that our proposed framework achieves desirable performance and
provides helpful guideline for building better simulacra of human beings in the
future. Our data and code are available at
https://github.com/Bernard-Yang/SimsChat. | [
-0.3784657121,
-0.6478930712,
0.4660134912,
0.4349875748,
-0.0320259891,
0.4629956782,
-0.0166181345,
-0.4190097749,
0.6169385314,
0.8859553337,
-0.8982676864,
-0.4620244801,
0.0969575718,
0.1227081642,
0.2600651681,
0.2862717211,
0.4610876739,
-0.0292934831,
-0.3555508554,
0.1036748216,
-0.5206350088,
-0.7734738588,
-0.8380770683,
-0.4145419598,
0.5490243435,
0.499664396,
0.9802007675,
0.5662823915,
0.2293088734,
0.4301786125,
0.0757416114,
0.4569169581,
-0.6655597091,
0.5345078111,
-0.2759483159,
-0.5477477312,
-0.7122089863,
0.0275244359,
0.2039065808,
0.1430942863,
-0.1526262909,
-0.2130176425,
-0.1293165684,
-0.0171748847,
-0.0866938755,
0.3958631456,
-0.3400590718,
0.1018580198,
0.0165361948,
-0.482768029,
-0.3858269751,
-0.2157867253,
-0.1797472686,
-0.7414343357,
-0.2172096968,
0.084283255,
0.6511753798,
0.057816714,
-0.3244190812,
-0.3950043619,
-0.6206231117,
0.8158148527,
-0.9382345676,
0.1774647087,
0.2975381315,
0.8235028982,
-0.3912345767,
-0.4206550717,
-0.1945953369,
-0.6036775112,
-0.1739822626,
0.2051349282,
0.4051069915,
0.2845992148,
0.2681369781,
0.0553946979,
-0.4097875059,
0.0886805579,
0.0619802177,
-0.1149550602,
0.8719475865,
0.6942178607,
0.6028347015,
-0.1932515502,
-0.344950825,
-0.0532064736,
-0.4744001031,
0.2938215435,
0.8346010447,
0.4125981331,
-0.1959803551,
0.4207448661,
-0.2223472297,
0.2493962795,
0.0535850935,
-0.3901575208,
0.0501589626,
0.2848355472,
-0.0773780048,
-0.1079017147,
0.6252415776,
0.1489347517,
0.2767981887,
-0.1317645907,
-0.0610264055,
-0.2669785917,
0.2750304341,
-1.1493092775,
0.0562718473,
0.3798621595,
-0.3152002692,
-0.4921101034,
-0.0948708132,
-0.4414130449,
-0.6594897509,
-0.2712125778,
-0.0252964515,
-0.5628821254,
-0.2711165547,
-0.0612377673,
0.0394101068,
0.1534118056,
0.464361757,
-0.8269681334,
0.2911531925,
0.5425868034,
0.6765572429,
-0.360615164,
-0.2126735598,
-0.3305777311,
0.3169089556,
-0.4428835809,
0.6615433693,
-0.9579481483,
-0.7007462978,
-0.1518682092,
-0.1061790138,
0.1063411459,
-0.3235263824,
0.5100530386,
-0.4189107716,
-0.1314578056,
-0.5119686723,
-0.5804958344,
0.200775817,
0.5678676963,
-0.5670795441,
0.4459389746,
0.1421498209,
-0.4106693268,
-0.0485810526,
-0.8873699903,
-0.2671384215,
0.6042432785,
-0.4564173818,
0.1143445224,
-0.2246471941,
-0.062967971,
0.673684299,
-0.3159183264,
0.1680056453,
-0.340175271,
-0.7598085999,
0.6955693364,
-0.3588087559,
0.6681029201,
0.3939523399,
0.0837713704,
0.1229035482,
-0.5076245666,
0.1749206185,
-0.011324496,
-0.3147533536,
0.0352097377,
0.2519216835,
0.1223615333,
0.2872209549,
0.0341504775,
-0.6557123065,
0.3616097569,
-0.3822912276,
0.4130490422,
0.4580697715,
0.2032794803,
0.3169572651,
-0.6344682574,
0.8425923586,
-0.0430525765,
0.0429680049,
-0.3509330451,
-0.390597254,
-0.4170442522,
-0.6824926734,
-0.0060702525,
0.6366718411,
-0.7487658858,
0.2505420446,
-0.028743986,
-0.6020190716,
-0.4623552263,
-0.1082976162,
0.1736609191,
-0.0216504913,
-0.0935439914,
-0.3297786713,
-0.620988667,
-0.841316998,
-0.2958570123,
-0.3864962459,
-0.0852824152,
0.7919118404,
-0.0260359012,
-0.5203105807,
1.3125817776,
-0.5656475425,
-0.2985006571,
-0.694002986,
-0.1636156291,
-0.295388341,
0.5109441876,
0.559402585,
-0.6968896389,
-0.4949232638,
0.0183471497,
-0.7116087079,
-0.3123486042,
-0.5627004504,
-0.2248859555,
-0.0263992865,
0.637768805,
-0.6730398536,
0.3133800924,
0.4079833925,
-0.2357054204,
0.5837131739,
-0.2525098026,
0.4801431298,
-1.4343717098,
-0.0806811675,
-0.3375224769,
-0.5434622765,
-0.6070832014,
0.0274110269,
-0.4099875391,
-0.3157053292,
-0.7186465859,
0.97351408,
-0.3276232183,
-0.1201317087,
-0.2687711716,
0.2507560849,
-0.1335289031,
0.6327283382,
0.0279463455,
0.8524941206,
0.2364915311,
-0.359746933,
0.456831634,
0.547514677,
-0.1457063407,
0.7662360072,
-0.5798704028,
0.2270614803,
0.0142447874,
0.2781387568,
-0.878284514,
-0.4613913,
0.2272023261,
-0.2653630972,
-0.0256620981,
-0.327596724,
-0.497386992,
0.0263643786,
-0.0594565086,
0.058029037,
0.6572465301,
-0.4222391248,
0.8860266209,
0.4387792349,
-0.2582572401,
-0.2456345707,
-0.6073923111,
0.4302874804,
-0.0548455343,
-0.7997662425,
0.3535898328,
-0.5986281037,
-0.2601000965,
-0.2332618535,
0.4751929045,
-0.1493110955,
-0.0356516391,
0.6398659348,
-0.1117613092,
-0.0114624063,
-0.0249019042,
0.1182980612,
-0.1030258611,
-0.1592587382,
0.3925397396,
0.7356351018,
-0.1342206746,
-0.5772565007,
-0.6332373023,
0.4028223753,
0.4688700736,
-0.0390801989,
0.3938821554,
0.5218391418,
-0.0268308148,
-0.4337023199,
-0.4330351949,
-0.1084112599,
-0.6277056336,
0.4349880219,
-0.6827053428,
-0.9182918668,
0.7588487864,
-0.1152020991,
0.298168838,
-0.2698152661,
0.6696316004,
-0.0669469684,
1.1128504276,
0.3911286294,
0.2087327242,
0.3958152533,
0.0845621899,
0.1718867719,
-0.4746430516,
-0.1199575216,
-0.0132114599,
-0.2169859707,
-0.6782366037,
-0.7041238546,
-0.2385175079,
-0.5146493912,
-0.1446696818,
0.2751467228,
-0.0068111015,
0.7602756023,
0.0664316341,
-0.0177842043,
0.264480114,
-0.3099507987,
0.0567335747,
-0.1700757295,
-0.4375805557,
-1.0043488741,
0.2977613509,
0.3776599765,
0.995608449,
0.1654286385,
0.8234212995,
0.435795188,
0.3696109653,
-0.7530761957,
0.9168399572,
0.128624171,
-0.6714045405,
-0.2836401165,
-0.4784145355,
-0.6206317544,
0.5264421701,
-0.1981134117,
-0.7690143585,
0.0195635408,
0.1707474738,
-0.3494268656,
0.3777433932,
-0.6365421414,
0.5610905886,
-0.1308249682,
-0.3999031782,
-0.0695443451,
-0.3161184788,
0.4143145084,
0.2576032281,
-0.1445670575,
-0.4145768583,
-0.0393429883,
0.19874309,
-0.3012816608,
1.188107729,
-0.1343426108,
0.0740352422,
0.4178691506,
0.6409090161,
0.437631309,
0.2913251817,
-0.2657696307,
-0.0943495035,
0.3164111376,
-0.3598277569,
-0.54207021,
0.8030819893,
-0.8403795362,
-0.8589590192,
-0.3296028972,
-0.8654955029,
-0.5256908536,
-0.0131145678,
-0.1004524007,
0.2841194868,
-1.1219024658,
0.0650171936,
0.3517511487,
-0.5362681746,
0.3434775174,
0.3696000874,
-0.3621091247,
-0.1267405003,
1.1219257116,
-0.0118355425,
0.2829558253,
0.1895550191,
0.0394019186,
-0.0095726028,
0.0205818154,
-0.4239603281,
0.1771951318,
-0.4017786086,
-0.1336457878,
-0.7195807695,
-0.4506395757,
-0.2772212625,
-0.5327982306,
-0.3702014387,
-0.174874723,
-0.3750452697,
-0.0817199275,
0.0786314532,
0.7015314102,
0.2267745435,
0.7016748786,
-0.5904126763,
0.1826508939,
0.4665953517,
0.3596568108,
-0.0702866986,
-0.1595426351,
0.1088085026,
0.2421241105,
-0.303429991,
-0.7269609571,
0.8396894932,
0.0349803306,
0.6197516322,
0.7250629663,
-0.0352649987,
0.6268765926,
-0.4422053397,
0.7947328687,
-0.1328498572,
-0.7790724039,
-0.0729967207,
-0.7062025666,
-0.0010615927,
0.4252752662,
0.0465870164,
-0.964802146,
-0.3859417737,
-0.5634512305,
-0.3057249188,
0.9914374948,
0.5005703568,
0.4980704486,
0.1211988032,
0.5143225193,
0.1842122823,
0.1656827629,
-0.1712230295,
0.0188607294,
-0.1007017046,
-0.2663221061,
-0.0276139453,
-0.401913166,
0.0922399089,
0.2023170739,
0.5269733667,
-0.2023744583,
0.2973272204,
-0.0643450394,
-0.0287307277,
0.1056722924,
0.3751734793,
0.5457724929,
0.461932689,
-0.4712679386,
-0.2056433409,
0.1807357073,
-0.4823842049,
0.1681693047,
-0.3471511006,
-0.0454291552,
-0.2512907684,
0.0031387119,
0.6542903185,
0.2762563825,
-1.043722868,
0.4249987006,
-0.3966126442,
-0.1920723021,
-0.3127417862,
0.4644072652,
0.7451420426,
0.4609900415,
-0.0265953559,
-0.2148595601,
-0.0152316596,
-0.5726236701,
0.1734683812,
0.2829680145,
-0.4432891905,
-0.4766775966,
0.4554163516,
0.5355836153,
-0.8268070221,
0.1574531794,
-0.5140795708,
-0.2006148547,
0.7238205075,
0.7000313997,
0.7560640574,
-0.4865753055,
0.773250401,
-0.1221534237,
0.0989363492,
-0.0277798939,
0.3186886311,
0.2372190505,
-0.6808368564,
-0.0370663963,
-0.4002185762,
-0.9567787051,
0.0015839895,
-0.1338246912,
0.3890515268,
-0.6395860314,
-0.0916684121,
-0.258777976,
0.193253547,
-0.5875566602,
0.0732861757,
0.0092494357,
0.7585784197,
-0.5359805226,
0.6649832129,
0.5167432427,
-0.2936130166,
-0.6075788736,
-0.018190667,
-0.0461236723,
-0.5857384205,
0.4468318224,
0.0747694299,
-0.1180467531,
-0.0258483626,
-0.5416401029,
-0.7031838894,
1.2952959538,
0.7569234371,
-0.3117371798,
-0.224717021,
0.7198429704,
0.7033614516,
-0.9772797823,
0.5750459433,
0.3736883402,
0.2611570656,
0.505864203,
-0.38408494,
0.0225276593,
-0.2643580139,
0.2510791719,
-0.454097122,
-1.0188502073,
0.6337161064,
-0.1144654974,
-0.1738168597,
0.3408048451,
0.6277216673,
0.4109577537,
-0.0617869049,
0.507486701,
-0.1334199607,
0.7116537094,
0.0934226364,
0.8661370277,
-0.243531853,
-0.0710708424,
1.0197820663,
-0.5810278058,
0.4467493296,
0.1857185066,
0.3441815376,
0.4203974903,
0.6668578386,
0.1730233878,
0.1461279094,
0.350212276,
-0.0913068652,
-0.7828376293,
-0.1344560385,
0.1756943166,
0.4275473058,
0.4201599061,
-0.0098220306,
-0.1284626722,
0.0041752402,
-0.094854638,
-0.0174463075,
0.0090757338,
0.621709168,
0.1702963859,
-0.383872807,
0.0756227523,
0.1588996947,
0.5185649395,
-0.7548884153,
-0.2556174397,
-0.3718012869,
0.0995915607,
-0.1927651465,
-0.5155928731,
-0.0721375346,
-0.156017065,
0.3537785113,
-0.2926769257,
0.794337213,
-0.5184206963,
-0.2619944811,
0.0075025782,
0.6581770182,
0.3205111325,
0.0609302744,
-0.7194982171,
0.2184586525,
-0.0079111485,
-0.5054587722,
0.3319323361,
0.5363678932,
-0.2345703542,
0.9190979004,
0.5592237711,
-0.0176991206,
-0.2732101083,
0.0982484967,
0.8500835299,
-0.6824436784,
-1.0032624006,
-0.4653851092,
0.4353131056,
-0.2718340755,
-0.2222919762,
0.6186006665,
0.5686168075,
0.3196712434,
-0.1096290275,
0.9252287745,
0.0347643793,
0.3745475411,
-0.1200814024,
0.9027354121,
-0.3247021437,
0.3562010527,
-0.2283928543,
-0.6127488613,
0.0339113474,
0.5135195851,
-0.0508820154,
0.2425966263,
0.182091713,
1.1766343117,
-0.2907246351,
0.1023980081,
0.9850277305,
0.0968508497,
0.8396463394,
0.2785720825,
1.0006587505,
0.0260470156,
0.3938418627,
0.1669864357,
-0.1002285108,
-0.4855275154,
-0.6359940767,
-1.5898863077,
-0.5647811294,
-0.0692051202,
-0.1821199805,
0.2153866142,
1.4318577051,
0.8051546216,
-0.3380390108,
-0.5378732085,
0.3796133995,
-0.012230996,
-0.0650063306,
-0.2055442631,
-0.010714218,
-0.4508710802,
-0.9213191867,
0.4901707172,
0.1623632759,
0.1931477934,
-0.4215480983,
-0.3851665556,
0.1797149777,
1.0116107464,
0.6386351585,
0.3359831572,
-0.461191535,
-0.114963904,
0.1346623898,
-0.512449801,
0.214790374,
1.0070149899,
-0.5635133386,
0.1919270307,
0.3614721298,
0.5242341757,
0.5562528372,
0.2587718666,
0.6235847473,
-0.8352319002,
0.2327547073,
0.3615070581,
0.0674166828,
0.4226430357,
-0.6975755095,
0.2816102803,
-0.0307181962,
-0.3929383159,
-0.6592382193,
0.5684671998,
-1.2204153538,
-0.2082611769,
1.4310251474,
-0.1916919053,
-0.3811006844,
-0.1495029926,
-0.8803601861,
-0.1231816113,
-0.8179205656,
0.5095154643,
0.4166756868,
-0.3656328619,
-0.0300365034,
-0.3911780119,
0.6686662436,
0.0561639145,
-1.1741441488,
0.3346352577,
0.3271979988,
0.2978495359,
-0.1082334816,
0.848705709,
0.014040703,
-0.0785145238,
-0.128996551,
0.1947682649,
-0.4811729789,
0.024130702,
0.1925083548,
0.2107952237,
0.0642346144,
0.2885860503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17961v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17961v1 | NormTab: Improving Symbolic Reasoning in LLMs Through Tabular Data Normalization | 2024-06-25T22:40:03 | 2024-06-25T22:40:03 | Md Mahadi Hasan Nahid, Davood Rafiei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.IR | In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
capabilities in parsing textual data and generating code. However, their
performance in tasks involving tabular data, especially those requiring
symbolic reasoning, faces challenges due to the structural variance and
inconsistency in table cell values often found in web tables. In this paper, we
introduce NormTab, a novel framework aimed at enhancing the symbolic reasoning
performance of LLMs by normalizing web tables. We study table normalization as
a stand-alone, one-time preprocessing step using LLMs to support symbolic
reasoning on tabular data. Our experimental evaluation, conducted on
challenging web table datasets such as WikiTableQuestion and TabFact,
demonstrates that leveraging NormTab significantly improves symbolic reasoning
performance, showcasing the importance and effectiveness of web table
normalization for enhancing LLM-based symbolic reasoning tasks. | [
-0.1906550676,
-0.9928408861,
0.449780196,
0.4653896093,
-0.4510314167,
-0.029059194,
-0.0841741711,
-0.2998416126,
0.1115642935,
0.3634615839,
-0.4363433123,
-0.9722036719,
-0.2980749607,
0.2998657525,
-0.2504685819,
0.7183855772,
0.0941826776,
0.2005448788,
-0.3078498244,
-0.0506818891,
-0.5624632835,
-0.4116739929,
-0.212455973,
-0.3262247741,
0.4564937949,
0.690495491,
0.9324496984,
1.0159573555,
0.6675596237,
0.2090539932,
0.4065241218,
0.1823264211,
-0.3174240887,
0.4436341524,
0.0360219963,
-0.8316606879,
-0.8960217237,
-0.1829255968,
0.7530657053,
0.6038048267,
-0.3826862872,
0.337359786,
-0.2181028575,
0.7047557235,
-0.2798815668,
0.5364806056,
-0.8709571362,
0.2272037566,
-0.3773363531,
-0.1817899942,
-0.4157575369,
-0.79857409,
-0.498542428,
-0.652240932,
0.0979741439,
0.0252200533,
0.8853836656,
0.5639099479,
-0.2489523143,
0.2885647118,
-0.5121935606,
0.5492402315,
-0.9435844421,
0.8413010836,
0.29794541,
0.4240639508,
-0.4496686161,
-0.8317579627,
-0.7584715486,
-0.4843625128,
-0.1542392373,
-0.3628095388,
-0.5188586116,
0.0709226429,
0.5096600652,
-0.0921871513,
-0.8602290154,
0.219623521,
-0.0661982149,
-0.0744079575,
0.328298986,
0.3568483293,
0.3577714562,
-0.0468596295,
0.0132868066,
-0.1242247894,
-0.7018774748,
0.1238163114,
0.1061885804,
0.5296028256,
0.0314434171,
0.5241560936,
-0.3238723874,
0.9253925681,
-0.2820461094,
-0.1993188262,
-0.0851463974,
0.083273679,
-0.2808950543,
0.0689354911,
0.2921836078,
0.6394225359,
0.5547946095,
-0.2638955116,
-0.2589173317,
0.4603128433,
0.3832603693,
-0.8630906343,
-0.2894870341,
0.2019963413,
-0.3336035311,
-0.0129895583,
0.1647717208,
-0.5458289981,
-0.2238837779,
-0.5020206571,
0.3205507994,
-0.2167414576,
0.2238560468,
-0.0228633787,
-0.0094716968,
0.1704493016,
0.6126792431,
-0.5343400836,
0.5053300858,
0.6615052223,
0.7660672665,
-0.3714690804,
0.0797990933,
-0.53517735,
0.4570011199,
-0.5586180091,
1.0778664351,
-0.5230039358,
-0.2787710726,
-0.2674931288,
-0.2332260609,
0.4465643466,
-0.6802595258,
0.3398180604,
-0.4884923398,
-0.5186770558,
-0.3457111418,
-0.3448041677,
0.0372506641,
0.5707170367,
-1.0394960642,
0.8851445913,
-0.0378281698,
-0.4091273844,
0.6868277192,
-0.7578272223,
-0.6650478244,
0.2472529709,
-0.4542948008,
-0.5665692091,
-0.2649758756,
0.3110449612,
0.621106565,
-0.5032892823,
0.3913313448,
-0.4533759356,
-0.4990834892,
0.3351554573,
-0.0239503849,
0.5826066732,
0.3282529116,
-0.2808522582,
0.268606782,
-0.7624359727,
0.2382659763,
0.1754296124,
-0.2664154768,
-0.1338945478,
-0.058559265,
0.0765316263,
0.0415388122,
0.0026854649,
-0.5578411818,
0.4706019461,
-0.1616787165,
0.1141276732,
0.8335676193,
-0.1572150737,
0.3095420301,
-0.3310607374,
0.4004246294,
0.2155516148,
0.0448389277,
0.6474494934,
-0.2995878756,
-0.578268826,
-0.2184763551,
0.2278969735,
0.5306409001,
-0.379592061,
0.2492390126,
-0.3214909732,
-0.6445841789,
-0.2628163695,
0.2397634685,
0.1299738586,
0.7066751719,
0.6313790083,
-0.1613200158,
-0.8614932895,
-1.1779466867,
-0.5017799139,
-0.1302682459,
-0.185839802,
0.0543945096,
0.1887580901,
-0.4458925724,
1.0765060186,
-0.5933961272,
-0.4813310504,
-0.5975081921,
0.0799660385,
0.2762724757,
0.5211225152,
0.1356082708,
-0.6902539134,
-0.512059629,
-0.0785563067,
-0.7881745696,
-0.4435805976,
-0.3243304193,
-0.0765977129,
0.2437493801,
0.5482956767,
-0.6176291108,
0.652464807,
-0.0358234011,
-0.5639155507,
0.6324088573,
0.1664380431,
0.1583473086,
-0.656499505,
-0.1997137815,
0.0806150883,
-0.2922794521,
-0.6716645956,
-0.2179885209,
0.1587972641,
0.1739717871,
-0.1626357883,
0.5997721553,
-0.3920758963,
-0.0845496431,
0.0854542032,
0.0894726217,
0.0661610439,
0.2952229381,
-0.2282892764,
0.802511096,
0.1482169628,
-0.570268631,
0.3597370386,
0.299680531,
-0.0482841134,
0.5649127364,
-0.5277048349,
-0.2174273133,
0.0074932226,
0.3265541792,
-0.8384273052,
-0.1530836225,
-0.0542640314,
-0.2591042221,
0.1441381127,
0.1543322355,
-0.7250548601,
-0.1108349711,
-0.3192294538,
-0.0028491919,
0.292052567,
-0.3347732425,
0.7394768,
0.5490466356,
0.0297053792,
-0.4980562925,
-0.7173836231,
0.2537325323,
-0.1725120693,
-0.5984999537,
0.3850072324,
0.1499693841,
-0.7990022302,
-0.138424933,
-0.6314427257,
-0.3502351046,
0.17364268,
0.3640925586,
0.3177978992,
-0.1124375761,
0.3497752249,
0.1913572401,
-0.0068178107,
0.1973090172,
0.0322331674,
0.5345557928,
-0.5502191782,
-0.2090345174,
-0.6372873783,
0.0649152845,
0.1485485435,
0.0095722964,
0.6301492453,
0.6398017406,
-0.5626872182,
-0.4270064831,
-0.8198030591,
-0.5524255037,
-0.4475241005,
0.3212189674,
-0.5524137616,
-0.7786551118,
0.456874609,
0.0126328561,
0.292006135,
0.1889228225,
0.5869117379,
-0.3244332075,
0.9301618338,
0.5718134046,
0.1256884634,
0.148151949,
-0.0065726545,
0.1937728524,
-0.1899034083,
-0.3871206641,
-0.6950936913,
-0.5852041245,
-0.5600599051,
-0.4160698056,
0.5358937383,
-0.1435771137,
-0.3596406579,
0.1676675677,
-0.4336206019,
0.5837264061,
0.4389618635,
0.2786026299,
0.7139308453,
-0.0477954634,
-0.0637258068,
-0.1646188945,
-0.6021224856,
-0.8303917646,
1.0098147392,
0.1146024615,
1.0654278994,
0.1237022579,
0.578543365,
0.587859273,
0.5840591788,
-0.5629552007,
0.9763240218,
-0.0861243829,
-0.4517441094,
-0.5307751298,
-0.5216003656,
-0.9357993007,
0.2116332501,
-0.1672293097,
-0.8447926641,
-0.0393456742,
0.3043272793,
-0.1140077859,
0.3044220507,
-0.6827557683,
1.1584076881,
-0.1178567186,
-0.2947545648,
-0.2630562186,
-0.7164550424,
0.2084185332,
0.2109899521,
0.1212181747,
-0.2019172907,
0.0510089584,
0.9294959307,
-0.2821767926,
0.8439276814,
-0.2302467674,
0.0801325664,
0.1360453367,
0.6995664239,
0.4490631819,
0.3254143298,
-0.0265243817,
0.1587289423,
0.1283011138,
-0.3813742697,
-0.7937634587,
0.5397593975,
-0.5078029633,
-0.8752251267,
-0.1956993937,
-1.1063925028,
-0.6437814832,
0.0891765058,
-0.3622300029,
0.0787642598,
-0.1204709113,
0.568831265,
0.5876614451,
0.2440783083,
0.2407076508,
0.1588450819,
-0.153949663,
0.1245421395,
0.3915304542,
0.2367393672,
-0.0749434456,
0.3860635459,
0.1262277961,
-0.4852869511,
-0.4065541923,
-0.3864011467,
0.0452640466,
-0.9030693769,
-0.6764612198,
-0.7227212787,
0.1935068965,
-0.43599087,
-0.1633803248,
-0.1227875128,
-0.8688523769,
-0.164369002,
-0.4098526537,
0.5678878427,
0.299634248,
-0.0617708787,
0.1472490579,
-0.8643389344,
0.5405919552,
0.2879731953,
0.4179454148,
-0.117534481,
-0.3845098913,
0.0150273936,
-0.1833364666,
-0.1308994442,
-1.1247044802,
0.2882245779,
0.0393591896,
0.5969047546,
0.2741238475,
-0.086391747,
0.90908885,
-0.4084791243,
0.3817326427,
-0.1143882945,
-0.9292433262,
0.3884618878,
-0.1811801642,
0.3274474442,
0.3387183547,
0.4280148745,
-0.3283655643,
-0.4045514464,
-0.3998073339,
-0.5918541551,
0.3188716471,
0.1619147062,
-0.1292814612,
0.2337045074,
0.2541935742,
0.1812200546,
0.1921458989,
-1.2093473673,
0.0160042532,
-0.2519432008,
-0.2006922215,
0.2238457501,
-0.0015366485,
-0.2157526463,
-0.6948593259,
0.4552486539,
-0.1203899011,
0.1096879989,
0.0322191454,
-0.4981286824,
-0.2346345186,
0.5429971218,
0.3448219597,
0.8678123951,
-0.2196698785,
0.3339374363,
0.4615475535,
-0.4860159755,
0.1166106388,
0.0921454877,
-0.0496067144,
-0.0098821558,
0.2236808538,
0.2768624723,
-0.060495358,
-0.7944760919,
0.0361101776,
0.0413605385,
0.1309368163,
0.1307328492,
0.0823697299,
0.1894660443,
0.3271201849,
0.318107456,
-0.6200073361,
0.2277366966,
-0.4596910477,
0.6175593734,
0.5139241219,
0.0244386233,
-0.0390820205,
0.5444012284,
-0.377399385,
-0.3359942734,
0.6259427667,
-0.1212088391,
-0.2379228622,
0.718757689,
0.9845021367,
0.478782773,
-0.2468483746,
0.2872405052,
0.2674631178,
0.5303635001,
0.2161845118,
0.6659386158,
-0.0638494343,
-0.7609550357,
-0.0243519042,
-0.8008126616,
-0.4659344554,
-0.08102303,
-0.3384536207,
0.1626200974,
-0.667994976,
-0.2910142839,
-0.1183667406,
-0.170622766,
-0.6285783052,
0.2672809362,
-0.2327683866,
0.7733324766,
-0.7175921798,
0.8741887808,
0.5741844177,
-0.4113070965,
-1.1865916252,
-0.2119496465,
0.0377183557,
-0.4402064085,
0.9385388494,
0.0855043903,
-0.106489107,
0.0118525019,
-0.6265226603,
-0.4994705915,
0.8342987299,
0.4306870699,
-0.5732055902,
-0.0457114317,
0.6646593809,
0.6604387164,
-0.2164704949,
-0.1095954254,
0.9401604533,
1.0109016895,
-0.3270512819,
-0.7218341231,
0.5547327995,
-0.2216308415,
-0.1099986732,
0.2345555425,
0.039880354,
0.9065861702,
-0.2086592019,
-0.0019154147,
-0.5337638855,
0.7988577485,
0.4844608009,
0.2107863724,
0.4637848437,
0.7069551349,
0.5904564261,
-0.283075273,
0.5647839308,
0.1788802445,
-0.0947360918,
0.985082984,
-0.4365916848,
0.6956305504,
0.8328759074,
-0.3144392073,
0.6378192902,
0.4057338834,
-0.2813805044,
0.020249024,
0.4100229144,
0.0757470503,
-0.4523319304,
-0.0176599547,
-0.1064626798,
0.4354816079,
0.4189357758,
0.2474966794,
-0.8364295959,
-0.1917944998,
0.1154540479,
0.4679897726,
-0.211448893,
0.64956218,
0.0411743931,
-0.2137237638,
0.6752587557,
0.0954986736,
0.1833497882,
-0.3495269418,
-0.4608536065,
-0.3838607073,
0.0563155524,
-0.5020879507,
-0.7326314449,
0.5470902324,
0.173116371,
0.1341582686,
-0.2116169333,
0.6237888932,
-0.0440652743,
-0.2392847687,
-0.0241895299,
0.8008846045,
0.0213123094,
-0.1553819329,
-0.6574856043,
0.0762028694,
-0.1408852935,
-0.323928982,
0.3447401226,
0.4594179094,
-0.6390091181,
0.8919180632,
0.9008206129,
-0.0765622556,
0.130777508,
0.3456126451,
1.0909688473,
-0.766848743,
-0.5773513317,
-1.0519002676,
0.4515477717,
-0.0851709843,
-0.002004839,
0.7113894224,
0.7751398087,
0.6112694144,
-0.3529648483,
0.0719265416,
-0.0237873793,
0.1960720122,
-0.4421292841,
0.9649702907,
-0.4711486101,
0.2957041264,
-0.2670635581,
-1.0436836481,
-1.1088358164,
0.8366519809,
-0.3121057153,
-0.1757886857,
0.6307445168,
1.1790983677,
-0.0297730733,
-0.1313120574,
0.3109689355,
0.4792544842,
0.5305191875,
0.1497601122,
0.5032052398,
0.1208635643,
0.4923391938,
-0.14985919,
-0.1815113872,
-0.0549991168,
-0.9278414845,
-0.9352325797,
-0.6080030799,
0.1721664369,
-0.2518852353,
0.2319422066,
1.2304069996,
0.3362281919,
-0.6899867058,
-0.6969584823,
-0.1766898334,
0.3252018988,
-0.0830881894,
-0.3481531143,
0.194284454,
-0.4762126207,
-0.2031583786,
0.2679799199,
0.3418201804,
-0.0786029473,
0.0082516372,
0.2489370257,
-0.544852972,
0.2234331518,
0.4769357741,
0.0814794973,
-0.7239317298,
-0.1595512778,
-0.034943223,
-0.2758964002,
0.5496432185,
0.6166638732,
-0.7334433794,
-0.0182408784,
0.3900526166,
0.6384990215,
0.5046135783,
0.1866419464,
0.2985148728,
-0.6832798123,
0.2120426744,
0.6873403788,
0.3560388088,
0.0863231495,
-0.4198682904,
0.6263124347,
0.0899283215,
-0.2432293594,
-1.259245038,
0.2962901592,
-1.2640368938,
-0.4093818963,
0.9636096358,
0.2086599469,
-0.2106752396,
-0.0953078717,
0.0242563114,
0.5313923955,
-0.4351173341,
1.3048388958,
0.3365558386,
-0.3648864031,
-0.0605581477,
-0.3904812336,
0.6323490739,
0.3915295601,
-1.6442886591,
0.0979861468,
0.7729942799,
0.1722234637,
-0.1124190167,
0.3821651638,
-0.2539559007,
0.5069764853,
-0.2081591487,
0.3121666908,
-0.2958337367,
-0.6053851247,
0.1968082786,
0.2876479924,
0.0662673414,
0.3448355198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17947v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17947v1 | Do they mean 'us'? Interpreting Referring Expressions in Intergroup Bias | 2024-06-25T21:47:53 | 2024-06-25T21:47:53 | Venkata S Govindarajan, Matianyu Zang, Kyle Mahowald, David Beaver, Junyi Jessy Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | The variations between in-group and out-group speech (intergroup bias) are
subtle and could underlie many social phenomena like stereotype perpetuation
and implicit bias. In this paper, we model the intergroup bias as a tagging
task on English sports comments from forums dedicated to fandom for NFL teams.
We curate a unique dataset of over 6 million game-time comments from opposing
perspectives (the teams in the game), each comment grounded in a non-linguistic
description of the events that precipitated these comments (live win
probabilities for each team). Expert and crowd annotations justify modeling the
bias through tagging of implicit and explicit referring expressions and reveal
the rich, contextual understanding of language and the world required for this
task. For large-scale analysis of intergroup variation, we use LLMs for
automated tagging, and discover that some LLMs perform best when prompted with
linguistic descriptions of the win probability at the time of the comment,
rather than numerical probability. Further, large-scale tagging of comments
using LLMs uncovers linear variations in the form of referent across win
probabilities that distinguish in-group and out-group utterances. Code and data
are available at https://github.com/venkatasg/intergroup-nfl . | [
-0.6648504138,
-0.38562271,
0.2353061289,
0.4435020685,
-0.5096910596,
0.2633457184,
0.0441715717,
-0.5724565387,
0.3377893567,
0.2328378111,
-0.681012392,
-0.1151935086,
-0.5100177526,
0.4345583618,
-0.1426445097,
1.1515045166,
0.3995372653,
0.6228044033,
-0.2219242305,
-0.3494383991,
0.2804016173,
-0.5404325128,
-0.2626001537,
-0.6852189302,
0.3623620272,
0.020138273,
0.783010006,
0.4917782843,
0.7275013924,
0.2048877031,
0.0406878218,
-0.0347600877,
-0.5195859075,
0.0962327942,
-0.4893635511,
-0.32257846,
-0.1570951045,
0.4082790911,
0.3647176623,
0.7582015395,
0.1396043301,
0.3283541203,
-0.0452853143,
0.451274842,
-0.0435877815,
0.1997517496,
-1.0395382643,
0.2388977855,
-0.0648538768,
-0.5448446274,
-0.1645625681,
-0.3988283575,
0.128535524,
-0.4025596678,
0.5363957286,
0.2151376903,
0.9688740969,
0.3990604877,
-0.3178116083,
-0.3505779207,
-0.320174545,
0.5843375921,
-0.8950279355,
0.0570086353,
0.5436723828,
0.2457215339,
-0.2902210951,
-0.1859912276,
-0.5375450253,
-0.3757951856,
-0.1905791014,
0.3657219708,
-0.2841279209,
0.0319883861,
0.4134447575,
0.1523120552,
-0.287127167,
0.0665043443,
-0.4339682162,
-0.0092460597,
0.8888455629,
0.0398585089,
0.2224679887,
0.4166240692,
-0.5920883417,
0.4590750337,
-0.754689455,
-0.2001889795,
0.4390687644,
0.4251142144,
0.0687733218,
0.4200403094,
-0.2693003118,
0.373526454,
0.3831594586,
0.0629433915,
0.046843566,
-0.0212318636,
-0.2083456665,
-0.2405610532,
0.6969681382,
1.0272122622,
0.516078949,
-0.912978828,
-0.0224460848,
0.2611777186,
-0.0275777802,
-0.47621876,
-0.0992985293,
-0.3981206417,
-0.4722051024,
-0.1036250144,
0.0700963289,
-0.716801703,
-0.7660501003,
-0.1022550166,
0.3705214858,
0.0697813928,
-0.0528027192,
-0.1358784735,
-0.4977472425,
0.2301061153,
0.0633582845,
-0.699362576,
0.4719332159,
0.4805804789,
0.3960580826,
0.0364299826,
-0.156613186,
-0.4145299494,
0.3902176619,
-0.1924630255,
1.0776817799,
-0.7113094926,
-0.6255353689,
0.0485041104,
-0.1826649755,
0.2774782181,
-0.8256049752,
0.2924977243,
-0.5760592222,
-0.168986395,
-0.6689378619,
-0.7039946318,
-0.0986032039,
-0.0652502775,
-0.5442460775,
0.8384076357,
-0.1592245549,
-0.8911848664,
0.728954494,
-0.4244262278,
-0.3689846098,
0.2828403413,
-0.455211401,
-0.0440061614,
0.5069788098,
-0.0226516053,
0.6384810805,
-0.7334901094,
-0.0379856266,
-0.5323519111,
-0.4607026875,
0.6511592865,
0.1256242543,
0.3830213249,
0.1337323338,
-0.3278751969,
-0.1844743043,
-0.2789700925,
0.0304695405,
-0.1914913207,
-0.2660141885,
-0.4528038204,
0.2137233168,
-0.4525128305,
0.4758402705,
-0.1710543633,
-0.3803067803,
0.2996596098,
0.10661342,
0.4048557281,
0.8878575563,
0.0324248224,
0.7930631042,
-0.2073596567,
0.7360436916,
0.4563339353,
0.1344100684,
0.05699303,
-0.3992455304,
-0.3577526212,
0.1032128781,
-0.0780214518,
0.2926228344,
-0.7832944989,
0.1687595546,
-0.2016667873,
-0.2999044061,
-0.1474110186,
-0.1638445258,
0.3575090766,
0.5876522064,
0.1801133901,
-0.1177076176,
-0.434748292,
-1.2968728542,
-0.6937764883,
-0.4541852176,
0.0672102571,
0.3749707639,
0.3509028256,
-0.0186193939,
0.9319511652,
-0.2563253939,
-0.4636023939,
-0.1089338809,
0.2136936039,
0.2280580699,
-0.0856746212,
0.4091478288,
-0.7889847755,
-0.955308795,
-0.1139959022,
-0.6724444628,
-0.6986910701,
-0.0803769901,
-0.0393008441,
-0.0782580078,
0.7723183632,
-0.2117334604,
0.4627946317,
0.6102058291,
-0.5810255408,
0.280198276,
0.5594266057,
-0.0409465469,
-0.6852663755,
-0.5038275719,
0.474784106,
-0.0896572471,
-0.2948278189,
-0.0831390619,
-0.4428073764,
0.7284156084,
-0.1455324888,
0.3968017697,
-0.7719918489,
-0.2495449334,
0.01528526,
0.1538727731,
-0.1110039428,
0.3691582382,
-0.1106178835,
0.9380630851,
0.4559056163,
-0.7200434208,
0.1427555382,
-0.2265916318,
-0.213769868,
0.6593167186,
-0.2357695848,
0.290343225,
-0.2971333861,
0.4787828028,
-1.0876983404,
-0.2601588964,
0.4137756228,
-0.4637798369,
0.0356485955,
-0.0854415223,
-0.4151875973,
-0.2387607545,
-0.1607378423,
0.3323671222,
0.2039286345,
-0.3319869041,
0.4374671876,
1.0309544802,
0.0045568892,
-0.5895096064,
-0.7873302698,
-0.0081179347,
-0.5426003337,
-0.2869610488,
0.1609160006,
-0.3611177802,
-0.8895910382,
0.1249035373,
-0.4172213376,
-0.7059813738,
-0.21811378,
0.1905130446,
-0.1439685822,
-0.0697892606,
0.2866156995,
-0.2653660476,
0.1964294016,
0.1596552432,
-0.0322117917,
0.1978560239,
-0.0737335682,
0.1309087574,
-0.1647481024,
0.8010479212,
0.0186538193,
0.3471943438,
0.3544106781,
0.1610864699,
0.0254317336,
-0.4641608,
-0.5428778529,
-0.5694357157,
-0.3704937994,
0.576172471,
-0.4687930048,
-0.8872289658,
0.6501618624,
-0.0443649516,
0.1569728255,
0.3596790433,
0.3284208477,
-0.6634270549,
1.0211956501,
0.3742336631,
-0.0104759615,
0.0345293656,
0.1295550317,
-0.1486415118,
-0.6737683415,
-0.0300599113,
-0.523458302,
-0.6186571717,
-0.3608415425,
-0.6209260821,
0.2246555239,
0.0992597267,
0.0261893272,
0.0239396021,
-0.4416086078,
0.9105886221,
0.288351208,
-0.1210238039,
0.1684082299,
-0.1633240283,
0.0226296186,
-0.5912938118,
-0.5595844984,
-0.2476361096,
0.8386151791,
0.2785060704,
0.9535490274,
0.337919116,
0.6261824369,
0.7595121861,
1.0882771015,
-0.8185971379,
0.8743945956,
-0.1863498241,
-0.8789837956,
-0.0309891533,
-0.3106918931,
-0.636888504,
0.452096045,
-0.0599323362,
-0.590587616,
-0.0967630446,
0.362307936,
-0.0803869441,
0.3566551507,
-0.3020093441,
0.0987364128,
0.0130940229,
-0.3550942242,
0.0765540078,
-0.7354769111,
0.4579038322,
0.044583749,
0.455375284,
-0.4827765524,
-0.3340638876,
0.8001568913,
-0.3320795596,
0.9573893547,
-0.0927693322,
-0.3250291646,
0.4611696303,
-0.1231871545,
0.2932432592,
-0.0631409138,
-0.189960584,
0.5292790532,
-0.3702572286,
-0.1271327287,
-0.4561700225,
0.4417994618,
-0.3674134314,
-0.5812020302,
-0.5993614197,
-0.5903297663,
-0.4407285154,
-0.2547330558,
0.6308980584,
0.1258374304,
-0.3868776262,
0.0006071419,
0.5112276673,
0.0089146094,
0.5627214909,
0.7649585009,
-0.2411215752,
-0.2969920635,
0.2733935416,
0.2970444858,
0.0573538281,
0.3732179105,
0.0713149086,
-0.6239888072,
-0.249652043,
-0.2150445133,
0.5755100846,
-0.9057791233,
-0.255019486,
-0.1554783583,
0.3865486383,
-0.3271062374,
0.2083690912,
0.1287413687,
-0.3876654506,
0.0839904323,
-0.183443889,
0.0379306376,
1.0165983438,
-0.2872330844,
0.6548116207,
-0.6502545476,
0.0580512099,
0.1838710159,
0.4012954235,
-0.4664869905,
-0.6588951945,
-0.555234015,
-0.3277490735,
0.0795703307,
-1.4294676781,
0.1370984614,
0.2846437991,
0.6967848539,
0.2777140737,
-0.0447040945,
0.5144791007,
-0.5967857242,
0.8309568167,
0.2665537596,
-0.773545742,
-0.1882239133,
-0.5178864002,
0.120038867,
0.4956988394,
0.3056969345,
-0.4645701051,
-0.3205983043,
-0.6149173379,
-0.5367332697,
0.6983594298,
-0.393832922,
0.2055817246,
-0.4742233157,
0.6005291939,
0.1441535652,
0.4266741574,
-0.9577096701,
-0.6277234554,
0.13916637,
0.2129035294,
-0.083808586,
-0.3679198027,
-0.5332309008,
-0.0374789797,
0.7222775817,
-0.3723403811,
0.2599658966,
0.0763126686,
-0.0703795776,
-0.3614167273,
0.1144763008,
0.6416326761,
0.8523544669,
0.0536223911,
0.2460532784,
0.2162992209,
-0.3815898299,
0.0414839536,
-0.0217084493,
-0.1448900849,
0.4601790905,
0.1398263127,
0.3173082173,
0.0902788937,
-0.3448230326,
0.3518295288,
-0.1949056834,
-0.1573340446,
-0.0299128462,
-0.338024348,
0.0966984779,
0.1507995427,
0.7153927684,
0.0822633207,
0.3013728857,
-0.541906178,
0.2631235421,
0.6690822244,
-0.78473562,
-0.65439713,
0.85502249,
0.4641245604,
0.0496207029,
-0.0534183607,
-0.2841857672,
-0.6690654159,
0.5557873845,
0.5184477568,
1.1087419987,
-0.2901788056,
0.2702305019,
0.0333664529,
0.3856049776,
0.3201754987,
0.2631677687,
-0.108688347,
-0.9475722909,
-0.3995458484,
-0.5661690235,
-0.230588451,
0.0952370539,
-0.753903389,
-0.2710958123,
-0.4922014773,
-0.6283551455,
0.1263735592,
-0.3932386935,
-0.6272707582,
0.5011227727,
0.3742388189,
0.9384699464,
-1.0240962505,
0.7096657157,
1.1781331301,
-0.5109652281,
-0.6906217337,
0.6129264832,
0.0389843583,
-0.7678601146,
1.0988116264,
0.0072912769,
-0.1782666147,
-0.1599604189,
-0.845418334,
-0.5481138825,
0.3076020777,
0.2904466093,
-0.2770048976,
-0.0340035334,
0.3980305195,
0.369184643,
-0.4157013297,
0.2308069468,
0.4639278948,
0.1783248782,
0.1282078475,
-1.000036478,
-0.0941728652,
-0.1007239968,
-0.2119274586,
0.1584720165,
-1.1119481325,
0.9381331801,
0.0313098431,
0.0411114953,
-0.3809851408,
0.8389164805,
-0.1349900067,
0.1906787604,
0.7111788392,
0.1616358161,
0.5207693577,
-0.2693876922,
0.8221387863,
-0.0744127855,
0.100424923,
1.1510802507,
-0.3444970548,
0.3563187718,
0.7748901248,
-0.4991888404,
0.188575089,
0.479367137,
0.2716035247,
0.4204102159,
0.5983846188,
-0.64005059,
-0.3158412576,
-0.2331869453,
-0.310734868,
0.457327038,
0.5606732368,
-0.4710394442,
-0.4797118008,
-0.5867747068,
0.4657838643,
0.3784887195,
-0.4807566404,
0.8451859951,
0.2131672204,
-1.0122121572,
0.0795885772,
-0.266861707,
0.8446798921,
-0.6584085822,
-0.2151807398,
-0.505736053,
0.1692537814,
-0.2811852694,
-0.7439998984,
0.1408841461,
-0.1095094755,
-0.3730808198,
0.0478729084,
0.2781136334,
-0.3946862817,
-0.0763930455,
0.3670341671,
0.2406176031,
0.7019782662,
-0.0002085783,
-0.8700221181,
0.1422292888,
0.2710679471,
-0.2116680443,
0.4316684306,
0.4252760708,
-0.2042208016,
0.4275649488,
0.2394799143,
0.1598250717,
0.6498588324,
0.2246476859,
0.8837295175,
-0.5635405779,
-0.3023487031,
-1.1061348915,
0.4290251136,
-0.2499492317,
-0.4197615385,
0.9786371589,
0.553521812,
0.6215660572,
-0.2048938274,
1.161626339,
-0.0303206481,
0.7936646938,
-0.0805238709,
0.4866661131,
-0.410330385,
0.0947039574,
-0.2527873814,
-0.9549706578,
-0.4368957877,
0.5286197662,
-0.0748020262,
-0.1106363013,
0.3138899803,
0.5941908956,
0.2537189722,
0.0553048588,
0.439042598,
0.4863364398,
0.2213173956,
0.1601987183,
1.0817933083,
0.0564840622,
0.5280052423,
-0.1280233264,
-0.4522904158,
-0.0442924425,
-1.0642309189,
-0.9890552759,
-0.4286120832,
-0.4672886133,
-0.5252913833,
0.0640142262,
0.8749361634,
0.6026802063,
-0.4906560183,
-0.3172870576,
0.3048437834,
-0.2984147072,
-0.2065790743,
-0.2937879264,
-0.1435586959,
-0.3883576095,
-1.0488445759,
0.3855336905,
0.1709280312,
-0.3197397292,
-0.2934308648,
0.1197063103,
-0.125936836,
0.4880183339,
0.3700681925,
0.4929709733,
-0.8333858252,
-0.3197129965,
-0.0611410551,
-0.0137324138,
-0.0167320967,
0.4682765603,
-0.6960899234,
0.3661836386,
0.1581014097,
0.2166984528,
0.1313590705,
0.4550353885,
0.6733173728,
-0.8967938423,
0.4426245093,
0.3832912445,
0.2002718598,
0.3108062446,
-0.19037503,
0.9048222899,
0.4563786387,
-0.656054914,
-0.9180389643,
0.3603096604,
-0.6662169099,
0.0045400318,
1.2681254148,
-0.2614046931,
0.1514127702,
-0.0801455602,
-0.0309135336,
0.1683798432,
-0.3250234723,
0.8276364207,
0.8133040071,
-0.5249291658,
0.2098816037,
-0.4412332475,
0.8992593288,
0.2074455917,
-0.4324297607,
-0.2248552293,
0.6128624082,
0.3478196263,
0.0465286747,
1.0189774036,
0.1488712579,
0.1344747841,
0.0576042235,
0.008753404,
0.4601052999,
0.073531501,
-0.1333622485,
-0.0731704012,
-0.1746038347,
-0.3310917318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17935v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17935v1 | Sequential Editing for Lifelong Training of Speech Recognition Models | 2024-06-25T20:52:09 | 2024-06-25T20:52:09 | Devang Kulshreshtha, Saket Dingliwal, Brady Houston, Nikolaos Pappas, Srikanth Ronanki | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) traditionally assumes known domains, but
adding data from a new domain raises concerns about computational
inefficiencies linked to retraining models on both existing and new domains.
Fine-tuning solely on new domain risks Catastrophic Forgetting (CF). To address
this, Lifelong Learning (LLL) algorithms have been proposed for ASR. Prior
research has explored techniques such as Elastic Weight Consolidation,
Knowledge Distillation, and Replay, all of which necessitate either additional
parameters or access to prior domain data. We propose Sequential Model Editing
as a novel method to continually learn new domains in ASR systems. Different
than previous methods, our approach does not necessitate access to prior
datasets or the introduction of extra parameters. Our study demonstrates up to
15% Word Error Rate Reduction (WERR) over fine-tuning baseline, and superior
efficiency over other LLL techniques on CommonVoice English multi-accent
dataset. | [
-0.1191362292,
-0.6347227097,
0.2843112648,
0.0386483856,
-0.2506915033,
0.2593617439,
-0.3200431466,
-0.390856415,
-0.3003825843,
0.5132001042,
-0.5588702559,
-0.2488712966,
-0.5818029642,
0.1442536563,
-0.2293155938,
0.7705996633,
-0.1832365543,
0.2152975649,
-0.0838474035,
-0.4534220099,
-0.837095201,
-0.6601008773,
-1.2621352673,
-0.4603942335,
0.5429599285,
0.3988689482,
0.3667955697,
0.5124137998,
0.2603751123,
0.3712500632,
-0.1348175406,
0.401573211,
-0.4153729677,
0.2218337357,
-0.2757059336,
-0.1855911613,
-0.5555989742,
-0.2262949347,
1.135351181,
0.9846357703,
-0.1652550399,
-0.023388911,
0.0881115422,
0.7498024702,
-0.4105330706,
-0.2405038029,
-0.9496609569,
0.0392986126,
-0.2024192065,
-0.4163347185,
-0.496740371,
-0.258710891,
0.2188442498,
-0.5582578778,
0.3370582461,
-0.1691519767,
0.5407104492,
0.5656110644,
-0.1861821711,
-0.2057896852,
-0.9942691326,
0.6224253178,
-0.634575069,
0.6566072106,
0.2185746729,
0.1034028232,
-0.1311838925,
-0.7681263685,
-0.6412257552,
-0.1414195001,
0.3084632158,
-0.2455575019,
-0.1156644896,
0.0412004292,
0.3833784461,
0.060673818,
-0.4213320017,
0.1702122092,
-0.4297953546,
-0.2569811344,
0.7730494738,
0.1848036796,
0.1777358204,
0.4302313626,
-0.0675495267,
0.2349188924,
-0.7722201347,
-0.0495824777,
0.1065654531,
0.3231663406,
0.254494369,
0.4121384323,
-0.0214004572,
0.8040214777,
0.3407105803,
-0.1187731996,
0.276178807,
-0.0323205404,
-0.1828857362,
0.0996740535,
0.4575092196,
0.1367232352,
0.5314490199,
-0.181139648,
-0.3603360057,
0.0492816158,
0.3978899419,
-0.3939145803,
-0.3211420774,
0.1688640118,
-0.1940134019,
0.0709758103,
-0.3149009049,
-0.0993561372,
-0.2719281018,
-0.6529068947,
0.6284343004,
-0.5549850464,
0.1811165959,
0.2874453068,
-0.0628873855,
-0.3085466623,
0.5957992673,
-0.6815777421,
0.4593957663,
0.5364179015,
0.8224244118,
-0.2878100276,
-0.7014414668,
-0.780439198,
0.1585492641,
-0.272297889,
0.7872872949,
-0.4226020277,
-0.7982967496,
-0.2100439221,
0.0401268937,
-0.1877607256,
-0.6871167421,
0.339081496,
-0.7608354092,
-0.2391686141,
0.0428101122,
-0.9214985967,
-0.0159125403,
-0.3705053926,
-0.4962594211,
0.8076223731,
-0.2276926637,
-0.3267859519,
0.5449917316,
-0.5085684657,
-0.6859145761,
-0.0255161356,
0.1090344936,
-0.7044789791,
0.0856432095,
0.1987133771,
0.3943333328,
0.3094950914,
0.4900739193,
-0.0614640713,
-0.2652129233,
0.2380308211,
-0.2746870518,
0.3556758761,
0.0874944404,
-0.1588286757,
0.0760768428,
-1.0073606968,
-0.138793543,
-0.1696657687,
-0.4517320991,
-0.4326201677,
0.1420883089,
-0.0295474138,
0.0776343346,
0.3096809685,
-0.4902181923,
0.3530612886,
-0.2617070377,
0.467055589,
0.8672757149,
0.4372218251,
0.3463573158,
-0.6981238723,
0.2604406476,
0.033289142,
0.0042259516,
-0.2282660455,
-0.4077666402,
-0.9713688493,
-0.035457883,
0.2787985206,
0.56578058,
-0.548091948,
0.459888041,
-0.4367139339,
-0.3623350561,
-0.3827513754,
0.3076821566,
0.3740719855,
0.6097688675,
0.4733363986,
-0.5466253161,
-0.8141328692,
-0.4152443111,
-0.3632081747,
0.1699366271,
-0.0611870997,
0.3455563784,
0.5481219292,
-0.3483947814,
1.0227355957,
-0.36079216,
-0.3814916313,
0.1184155121,
0.3795550466,
-0.024890177,
0.7627173066,
-0.0069078766,
-0.6457191706,
-0.6341493726,
-0.1509278715,
-0.5909135938,
0.0687279999,
-0.6639459729,
0.1729426682,
0.3562557399,
0.4811973572,
-0.4890678227,
0.3936992586,
0.1090553403,
0.0477046035,
0.5014824867,
-0.4929234385,
0.0912833512,
-0.5635226369,
0.0703401119,
-0.1940046698,
-0.2659495473,
-0.8901515007,
-0.2886385024,
0.0949704498,
-0.1272981912,
-0.4600874484,
0.7305494547,
-0.569129169,
0.0524836332,
-0.2760401666,
-0.0412474163,
-0.1560657471,
0.4548813701,
0.3227387369,
0.9013134837,
0.4665162265,
-0.8486827612,
0.089094013,
0.620319128,
-0.2219860405,
0.3797284961,
-0.6689729691,
0.6206890345,
-0.1104265228,
0.4017395675,
-0.654820025,
0.0062278481,
-0.0782489032,
-0.5695964694,
0.4850783348,
-0.1950677931,
-0.2291883975,
-0.3457960188,
0.0247506741,
0.1901121736,
0.4587930143,
-0.5559076667,
0.4766901135,
0.4860806465,
-0.4936623573,
-0.5096113086,
-0.5555875897,
0.2257321328,
-0.1391940713,
-0.4786814451,
0.5487229228,
-0.2903061509,
0.0782391876,
-0.098622039,
-0.2781051099,
-0.264092356,
0.051158946,
0.2429722846,
0.1152895764,
-0.0465454496,
0.1464260668,
0.078661561,
-0.2126149386,
-0.2983598113,
-0.4807716906,
0.2635765374,
0.3043166399,
-0.1578559875,
-0.9190681577,
0.4075218737,
0.5686581135,
-0.1906297952,
0.4019263089,
0.2834538519,
-0.5361472368,
-0.3594088852,
-0.7815186977,
0.03306913,
-0.4907208681,
0.233683154,
-0.3680039346,
-1.0075446367,
0.4931979477,
-0.2102527767,
0.2315262407,
0.2805926502,
0.3258791864,
-0.1648517251,
0.5540142059,
0.6462704539,
-0.2255351245,
0.5745332241,
-0.2096779794,
-0.1593041867,
-0.9181744456,
0.0039244955,
-0.3174189627,
-0.2024115771,
-0.0488988087,
-0.4317100644,
0.4176858664,
-0.0599929057,
-0.3405244052,
0.1751697958,
-0.415578723,
0.5342416167,
0.4759632945,
0.348153919,
0.3668073118,
0.0056052464,
0.078816168,
-0.1109582707,
-0.5863202214,
-0.2816722095,
1.3127516508,
0.215130493,
0.6790066957,
-0.0946668386,
0.7981678247,
0.545999527,
0.1438809037,
-0.5735872388,
0.3348525465,
-0.4736112356,
-0.1581854969,
-0.5735915899,
-0.232613802,
-0.7723625898,
-0.102056399,
-0.0567026325,
-0.4853951633,
0.2845411003,
0.7624792457,
-0.8862672448,
0.2208505869,
-0.357658267,
0.4197651744,
-0.0782160461,
-0.4687923789,
-0.3432498276,
-0.7185821533,
0.101289168,
-0.472569257,
0.1622791737,
0.0956324935,
0.0084474562,
0.7883316278,
-0.6396631002,
0.8728317022,
-0.5084440112,
0.1322558969,
0.2304796726,
-0.1630614847,
0.7722910047,
-0.0023617698,
-0.1664153486,
0.1220176518,
-0.2441359758,
0.05088678,
-0.6046506763,
0.4590342641,
-0.6641507745,
-0.388160795,
-0.3720873594,
-0.3486929536,
-0.542521894,
0.1006590351,
0.2182262987,
0.7156345248,
-0.2273208052,
0.0115761748,
0.9243583083,
-0.2156726867,
0.167809546,
0.6558471322,
0.330783993,
-0.4963655174,
0.8837159276,
0.3483183682,
0.3722293973,
0.2575353384,
0.128316313,
-0.1871022433,
-0.9987362027,
-0.3202089071,
0.1594920009,
-0.6169810295,
-0.0686059073,
-0.958769381,
-0.3551494479,
-0.4843684435,
-0.4355176985,
-0.369845897,
-0.5422109962,
-0.5350176692,
0.2615189254,
0.5176889896,
0.5846557021,
-0.3265330791,
0.5977781415,
-0.9687110186,
0.6753243208,
0.4231653512,
0.3056575954,
-0.0248194672,
-1.0318925381,
-0.3339766264,
0.0030769508,
-0.1122990772,
-0.3994932771,
0.5285196304,
0.9910101295,
0.4479770958,
-0.025215121,
-0.2274752259,
1.1631755829,
-1.371273756,
0.7500904799,
-0.1214954332,
-1.0899430513,
0.6103357673,
-0.2773015201,
0.5880154371,
0.7753946185,
0.4653286636,
-0.853243649,
-0.22551094,
-0.5228068233,
-0.77455616,
0.4778473377,
-0.4106998146,
0.1499324739,
0.2097611278,
0.6774077415,
0.2264837772,
0.2315323353,
-0.2782365978,
-0.36570701,
0.0743186101,
0.0449940562,
-0.2888864875,
-0.3990854621,
0.1718739569,
-0.6048107743,
0.9511458278,
0.0467283204,
0.1235743687,
0.1876406521,
-0.4127661884,
-0.216758579,
0.0467299856,
0.7949846983,
0.6424372196,
-0.1555456072,
-0.2752024829,
0.4444312751,
-0.5998864174,
0.2889949977,
-0.0412768908,
-0.1257180721,
0.0598519929,
0.2473864108,
0.9920413494,
0.6310669184,
-0.4880820215,
0.1265465468,
-0.0281813238,
-0.2896147668,
-0.7408794165,
0.2175635546,
-0.1335769296,
0.0337609574,
0.3343868554,
0.6199637651,
0.1612323076,
-0.2405060083,
0.7954066992,
0.068836771,
-0.0761999786,
-0.2058599442,
0.7437164187,
0.2391497046,
-0.4528293312,
0.7013416886,
0.0701461583,
-0.4957798123,
0.2553888559,
0.3050925732,
0.8899621367,
-0.5943530202,
-0.1609914005,
0.4734657109,
-0.0891422629,
-0.3797717988,
0.1321423501,
-0.0649287328,
-0.8443764448,
-0.3612419069,
-0.5745996237,
-0.6969261169,
0.0778663382,
-0.6212974787,
0.2654692829,
-0.6385368705,
-0.0944383666,
0.251886487,
-0.182100296,
-0.5422146916,
0.4295606315,
0.2591668069,
0.784486115,
-0.5234040618,
1.2424402237,
0.2578863204,
-0.0983417183,
-0.5613329411,
-0.1534841359,
0.3419475555,
-0.6232444048,
0.714746356,
-0.0674241334,
-0.3286828399,
0.3335589468,
-0.3399540484,
-0.9941508174,
0.9191069007,
0.0738980994,
-0.8873301744,
-0.2159609199,
-0.0478677265,
0.3606694937,
-0.2565429509,
-0.3688922822,
0.7345325351,
0.1369081736,
0.2499316186,
-1.0545256138,
-0.4129384458,
-0.2437446117,
-0.0227302108,
-0.0519797839,
-0.3908131123,
0.8317290545,
-0.3920967877,
-0.3234937787,
0.1917043924,
0.6622526646,
0.0894922987,
0.1977961361,
0.5898001194,
0.3788310885,
1.0438392162,
0.1727578789,
0.5771062374,
-0.3041426241,
0.1966772527,
1.7685012817,
-0.6228119135,
1.0432035923,
0.2660932839,
-0.1385613084,
0.2436079532,
0.5972300768,
-0.0656065941,
0.5032362938,
0.2316315919,
-0.5277646184,
-0.202531293,
0.2609743774,
-0.1997189075,
0.4234856665,
0.3981788456,
-0.0267990399,
0.2323284596,
0.3542011082,
0.0430704877,
0.0801035911,
-0.2420952171,
0.887875855,
0.1439108998,
-0.4823125303,
0.7951295376,
-0.2010230422,
0.8696088791,
-0.7648376226,
-0.0265081171,
-0.1417595148,
0.2951242328,
-0.0951205343,
-0.295977056,
0.5085330009,
0.2592852116,
-0.2296445072,
-0.4829378426,
0.4453740716,
-0.5592051744,
-0.443910867,
-0.0554434322,
0.0674965084,
-0.021948142,
-0.0257839784,
-0.7265859842,
0.2541412413,
0.0008229204,
-0.0601166822,
0.0801559165,
0.2188102454,
0.0495449416,
0.8458189368,
0.7764270306,
0.3947949409,
0.2141365707,
0.148471877,
0.8740950227,
-0.6111341119,
-0.6288668513,
-0.5296088457,
0.8645882607,
0.0425615646,
-0.298807621,
0.5070689917,
0.3752777576,
0.9449870586,
-0.1452831179,
1.036041975,
0.2549390495,
0.8178943396,
-0.7943490744,
0.9051254988,
-0.5191950798,
0.1785636544,
-0.2387370616,
-0.3841988146,
-0.6729899645,
0.5944314599,
-0.1649872214,
-0.0880585834,
0.6852053404,
0.7081773281,
0.198565051,
0.038396012,
0.4006828964,
0.2806233168,
0.2260870785,
0.5570794344,
0.6401734948,
-0.4828036427,
-0.1128866374,
-0.3232384622,
-0.1330919415,
0.0151017271,
-0.6993267536,
-0.7230781317,
-0.7788778543,
-0.6664731503,
0.0891799629,
0.5900096893,
1.0206769705,
0.6403596997,
-0.9564419985,
-0.2412746251,
0.0967980921,
-0.2110851556,
-0.226814121,
-0.0515339784,
0.3277071416,
-0.4527741969,
-0.6015383601,
0.8071268201,
0.1444304436,
0.0594389327,
0.1362693012,
-0.1209660918,
-0.2924939096,
-0.0295657367,
0.4883903861,
0.6250232458,
-0.6515251398,
-0.6007301211,
-0.3033655882,
0.3218858242,
0.2326684296,
0.9051758051,
-0.8016882539,
0.6701949835,
-0.0147318011,
0.8136690855,
0.358515799,
0.0046093874,
0.6739743352,
-0.7153409123,
0.1560249329,
0.2947105765,
0.3298243284,
0.5051421523,
-0.477668643,
0.2310151309,
0.3569540083,
-0.8318980932,
-0.7679219246,
-0.0861602277,
-0.8385534883,
0.0874159634,
0.8474493623,
-0.1890475303,
0.0682164654,
-0.369174391,
-0.1736668795,
0.2997835279,
-0.2911206484,
0.5190941095,
0.3486373723,
-0.2806355059,
-0.131187737,
-0.441139102,
0.7430078983,
0.1625414491,
-0.5463140607,
0.3587594032,
0.7878944278,
0.5538095832,
-0.2474035323,
0.9953805804,
0.090247348,
0.5221535563,
0.019093452,
0.2175288051,
-0.1522891074,
-0.7487711906,
-0.8423406482,
-0.1192372441,
0.2224751115,
-0.0975355729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17926v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17926v1 | FASA: a Flexible and Automatic Speech Aligner for Extracting High-quality Aligned Children Speech Data | 2024-06-25T20:37:16 | 2024-06-25T20:37:16 | Dancheng Liu, Jinjun Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) for adults' speeches has made significant
progress by employing deep neural network (DNN) models recently, but
improvement in children's speech is still unsatisfactory due to children's
speech's distinct characteristics. DNN models pre-trained on adult data often
struggle in generalizing children's speeches with fine tuning because of the
lack of high-quality aligned children's speeches. When generating datasets,
human annotations are not scalable, and existing forced-alignment tools are not
usable as they make impractical assumptions about the quality of the input
transcriptions. To address these challenges, we propose a new forced-alignment
tool, FASA, as a flexible and automatic speech aligner to extract high-quality
aligned children's speech data from many of the existing noisy children's
speech data. We demonstrate its usage on the CHILDES dataset and show that FASA
can improve data quality by 13.6$\times$ over human annotations. | [
-0.2489636093,
-0.3173530996,
-0.2982993126,
0.0319725759,
-0.3536100388,
0.1343697011,
-0.0062212292,
-0.1981419474,
0.1751754731,
0.2187514752,
-0.6262869239,
-0.1031669751,
-0.6939584613,
0.0734376684,
-0.615662992,
0.692677021,
-0.1194185913,
-0.0157774445,
-0.0853867158,
-0.0756921023,
-0.2775176764,
-0.0936609432,
-0.8717724085,
-0.1839623451,
0.4278720319,
0.684725225,
1.0656476021,
1.0926492214,
0.3767993748,
0.2757751942,
-0.0429785065,
0.3043531477,
-0.1199392304,
0.4579693377,
-0.2498718947,
0.1675958782,
-0.8255063891,
0.0043183905,
0.8347342014,
0.8091010451,
-0.3578324616,
0.1340400726,
0.2525468469,
0.876264751,
-0.4376161695,
0.0141500691,
-0.5472214222,
-0.0182499941,
-0.366992116,
0.4043189883,
0.0207930543,
-0.4090752006,
0.3713968694,
-0.6062412262,
0.1605351269,
-0.3370432258,
1.2323293686,
0.7116451859,
-0.3389357328,
-0.3639388382,
-0.6219929457,
0.5735070109,
-0.5269286036,
0.6700795293,
0.4718948901,
0.4391534626,
-0.2469950169,
-0.5252814293,
-0.7632271051,
0.0870696828,
0.02526615,
-0.2609522045,
-0.3964099586,
-0.2190045863,
0.0234202165,
0.4618119001,
-0.6828542948,
0.2524511218,
-0.1915574968,
-0.3263231218,
1.0581115484,
0.2294989824,
0.379265815,
0.1489223689,
-0.1814122349,
-0.1848573834,
-0.5421236157,
0.0937867984,
0.3246130347,
0.6236075759,
-0.0012902602,
0.4354216754,
-0.3855500817,
0.8822524548,
0.3340491354,
-0.2278345823,
0.4237841964,
-0.0642800704,
-0.3806829751,
0.232601434,
0.7456288338,
0.0721239969,
0.4274957776,
-0.0297790896,
-0.4005435407,
0.3058811426,
0.0394677036,
-0.5358445644,
-0.4051131606,
-0.1171848997,
-0.3198123574,
-0.1992455125,
0.2134568095,
-1.1604245901,
-0.5504915714,
-0.547352016,
0.3044188917,
-0.2157134712,
-0.189318642,
-0.0208954234,
0.2030648291,
0.1645753831,
0.2263941765,
-0.9273229241,
0.5271949172,
0.5485747457,
0.6197720766,
-0.2934971452,
-0.1045630574,
-0.9527026415,
0.0740340501,
-0.3420064747,
0.5758236051,
-0.4638143182,
-0.1732418239,
-0.1807471514,
0.0026586386,
-0.1776310802,
-0.560302496,
0.6824952364,
-0.2638199329,
0.0236594621,
-0.0145266661,
-0.4784846306,
0.1267813444,
-0.5141768456,
-0.7539163232,
0.7559592724,
0.0238402989,
-0.1569654346,
0.7887971401,
-0.5182242393,
-0.7024328113,
-0.0224764831,
-0.3234206736,
-0.668147862,
-0.0685154125,
0.6311289668,
0.3355262876,
-0.3434906602,
0.6226271987,
-0.0468164571,
-0.2179594636,
0.2676815987,
-0.8968773484,
0.8043448329,
0.5631422997,
-0.5073054433,
0.150562644,
-0.6969441772,
-0.2158983052,
0.1015237868,
-0.3659074306,
0.2148462087,
0.1386200637,
-0.0760431513,
0.2741157413,
0.2120537758,
-0.7695093155,
0.1944389939,
-0.4307230413,
0.383646369,
0.5586634278,
-0.3042616546,
0.3237376809,
-0.4813359082,
0.4495163262,
-0.0250381753,
0.2729804516,
0.2115449607,
-0.5458056331,
-0.7970137,
-0.4663737416,
0.5458930731,
0.3446387351,
-0.5571539402,
0.9140771627,
-0.577827394,
-0.4410256445,
-1.0186030865,
0.3810765147,
0.3019985557,
0.6513450742,
0.2923767865,
-0.4026657343,
-0.7586674094,
-0.9214368463,
-0.1110656038,
0.0082624899,
-0.0529274493,
0.1198616326,
0.1072369441,
-0.1065747887,
1.1769405603,
-0.2822816372,
-0.4851332605,
0.1785245091,
0.1558442116,
0.017960323,
0.7440385222,
0.295535475,
-0.8668323755,
-0.5624599457,
-0.2557694316,
-0.2527603507,
-0.3261285424,
0.1368369907,
0.1319788396,
0.2711901665,
0.1109948754,
-0.3515679538,
0.5446479321,
0.7486893535,
-0.4788444936,
0.1568665504,
0.3604640365,
-0.0162154231,
-0.7578268051,
0.2590058744,
-0.1281835288,
-0.3393517137,
-0.6551306844,
-0.4332028925,
-0.0716175511,
-0.3206717372,
-0.2938984036,
0.4521366358,
-0.3478346467,
-0.039781224,
-0.3747235239,
0.1507866681,
0.0345244929,
-0.0949292555,
-0.0294991992,
1.2353963852,
0.5514956117,
-0.3584328592,
0.4305976927,
0.4678804576,
-0.3405802548,
0.5425702929,
-0.4706663787,
0.427406311,
0.0732349902,
0.4502565861,
-1.0144385099,
-0.5783916712,
0.2150937766,
-0.6317846179,
0.6044346094,
0.0229333416,
-0.2183300555,
-0.4807688892,
0.071838364,
0.0563954785,
0.3322711587,
-0.7887563109,
0.6213533878,
0.8703474402,
-0.4998203814,
-0.856592536,
-0.5720607042,
0.2137286365,
-0.0278125051,
-0.6964645386,
0.3834319413,
0.0865099505,
-0.0268857088,
0.124403052,
-0.6140996814,
-0.5112396479,
0.042233739,
0.2324294746,
0.2427487224,
-0.5800504088,
-0.0346682295,
0.3870517015,
-0.3223185539,
-0.3305849731,
-0.0635407045,
0.3979554474,
-0.2371385396,
-0.1455847472,
-1.0295610428,
0.3245433867,
0.7810193896,
-0.0618037283,
0.4221460819,
0.2762458622,
-0.784043014,
0.0791967213,
-0.5927591324,
0.1225742996,
-0.523365736,
-0.0840343982,
-0.2976709902,
-0.6961964369,
0.163088724,
0.1648244113,
0.2366798073,
0.6870640516,
0.016139796,
-0.2475384474,
1.209676981,
0.0427917317,
-0.3815707862,
0.3634280562,
0.1618259251,
-0.2209581435,
-0.6321313381,
-0.1684496701,
-0.5994446874,
-0.5281845927,
0.0765933543,
-0.0007220838,
-0.2974819541,
-0.1389317662,
-0.4594088495,
0.2144210786,
-0.9199677706,
0.3732648194,
0.3657969534,
-0.1313235015,
0.0198197737,
0.1248101741,
0.3627602756,
-0.0431888252,
-0.4273538291,
-0.6507345438,
0.6718057394,
0.3913271725,
0.8370899558,
0.2679026425,
0.4921510518,
0.1894510388,
0.3168435693,
-0.7645989656,
0.4548025429,
-0.9751374722,
-0.7941910625,
-0.5277473927,
-0.334449172,
-0.9976744056,
-0.1203328446,
-0.2711768746,
-0.7360599637,
0.7390803695,
0.41852808,
-0.7200399637,
0.0350421481,
-0.5774356723,
0.4220144451,
-0.0564903952,
-0.0306684449,
0.2238710225,
-0.7664455771,
-0.0647102371,
-0.2045641094,
-0.1310279667,
-0.2976041138,
-0.1567470282,
1.1688139439,
-0.5134754181,
0.7841556072,
-0.5444333553,
-0.0969896093,
0.4456045032,
0.0045708427,
0.2497073263,
-0.3126528263,
-0.1698328108,
0.1253510863,
-0.3575277328,
-0.1902399808,
-0.5516276956,
0.839081347,
-0.843699038,
-0.660220623,
-0.406916976,
-0.4788788855,
-0.3282742798,
0.1993978471,
-0.0020531022,
0.3331197202,
0.1472803801,
0.5965000391,
0.3987428546,
0.3055460453,
0.3420568109,
0.3241474926,
0.1959649473,
-1.0151699781,
0.9683731198,
0.5951378942,
0.0416746624,
-0.1699257493,
0.339327842,
-0.497862041,
-0.3848742843,
-0.6085161567,
0.0545042232,
-0.4366079271,
-0.5365537405,
-0.2981921732,
-0.4305082858,
-0.6331709027,
-0.4674515426,
-0.4790116251,
-0.798189342,
-0.4688248336,
-0.1049230471,
0.2888056636,
0.5281937718,
-0.1180250719,
0.5101066232,
-0.6362826228,
0.4524517655,
0.485899955,
0.3774771094,
-0.0435719453,
-0.686737597,
0.2243621796,
0.0832833722,
-0.1607821882,
-0.6934453845,
0.3536424041,
0.6623069644,
0.4838788211,
0.4794479311,
-0.0089176046,
1.1195416451,
-0.3262573183,
0.8652077317,
0.1786143482,
-1.2962398529,
0.495621264,
-0.1493349224,
0.0576992854,
0.8495061994,
0.049521219,
-0.3289169967,
0.1839571446,
-0.463847816,
-0.880867362,
0.8719120026,
0.1959205866,
-0.1356579661,
0.3724878132,
0.3557037115,
0.4186987877,
0.0607364252,
-0.1153398454,
-0.2653693855,
-0.5579227805,
-0.831766367,
-0.0716348216,
0.042314209,
-0.1857784241,
-0.58578372,
0.8237493634,
-0.041330494,
0.074494876,
0.1693684459,
-0.0630426258,
-0.4716952145,
0.0069738394,
0.4102665186,
0.2223291844,
0.0657457858,
0.0940279812,
0.0842115805,
-0.7069252133,
0.4529643059,
0.5144352317,
-0.2132809013,
-0.1751163006,
0.1539451927,
0.7777824998,
-0.0744057149,
-0.3332575262,
0.5372380018,
-0.1579273045,
-0.277280122,
-0.2707614005,
0.3685029745,
-0.0228458531,
-0.0319050588,
0.6088673472,
0.0583317056,
-0.08605773,
-0.0525809675,
0.8864199519,
0.1981212497,
-0.5533865094,
-0.08121676,
0.7881153822,
0.4982060492,
-0.7423514128,
0.8005729914,
0.2222305685,
-0.069209151,
0.4260243475,
0.5654100776,
1.0265929699,
-0.7665918469,
0.0864635706,
0.0725857094,
0.1481207758,
0.1288549304,
0.4205441475,
0.0330170617,
-0.6263538599,
-0.4592265189,
-0.5773979425,
-0.3003115356,
0.261187315,
-0.8539187908,
0.220177874,
-0.4686187208,
-0.250824213,
0.3845519722,
0.0748303756,
-0.5701931119,
0.6273482442,
0.4119119644,
0.8521251082,
-0.9006856084,
0.9285004735,
0.5025553703,
-0.2705101669,
-0.8850380182,
0.2983270586,
0.4047292769,
-0.6096938252,
0.5434767604,
0.1208588704,
-0.5762532353,
0.1137561724,
-0.546703279,
-1.2082829475,
0.9430539608,
0.4445050359,
-0.7071325183,
0.1416207701,
0.2656904161,
0.3804564774,
-0.6347250938,
-0.4916414618,
0.6437391043,
0.5160931945,
0.072969161,
-0.9957002997,
0.0943188071,
-0.3020409644,
-0.3882213533,
0.1805862635,
-0.4464955926,
0.5876867175,
0.2363356054,
-0.3005569875,
0.1001872346,
1.0563650131,
-0.0065448564,
0.5820764303,
0.9948278069,
0.3109446466,
1.0413000584,
-0.1481487453,
0.3166056871,
0.0739387646,
0.0208084192,
1.1518316269,
-0.4001013041,
0.7760826349,
0.2529295087,
0.0676960424,
0.3748013079,
0.4046755731,
0.1152911633,
0.3548603356,
-0.1028862596,
-0.1990166605,
-0.2163315415,
-0.0556674264,
0.0013501815,
0.5812413692,
0.8346636295,
-0.2254041284,
0.0216363072,
-0.210508734,
0.0704263076,
0.0588366129,
-0.1775417775,
0.8406585455,
0.0467276797,
-0.5716292858,
0.7555426359,
-0.5215523243,
0.5656544566,
-0.3814559877,
0.0168058109,
0.0710229725,
-0.0135217439,
-0.4570749402,
-0.858884275,
0.6512212753,
0.2952913046,
0.0205586925,
-0.0320899747,
0.7272164822,
-0.396360904,
-0.1288099885,
-0.0652166009,
0.152519837,
0.0469088443,
0.3619976342,
-0.9377121925,
0.1502583474,
0.0476521589,
-0.3022940457,
0.0581747331,
0.111924544,
0.0827796385,
0.5235838294,
0.709035337,
-0.0281082317,
0.0430502668,
0.0267348103,
0.8270417452,
-0.4061514735,
-0.0890563279,
-0.6195539236,
0.6454308629,
-0.2928501368,
-0.6229500175,
0.348338455,
0.5274527669,
0.3112485409,
0.2671436667,
0.4553527832,
0.0163147748,
0.792373836,
-0.1512388736,
0.9740507007,
-0.5405002236,
-0.2865967453,
-0.2701077163,
-0.7166153789,
-0.6971904039,
1.0429672003,
-0.037470445,
-0.2927862704,
0.2323759645,
0.6707010269,
-0.1867368668,
0.3747504056,
0.1240155771,
-0.0624762177,
0.5389739275,
0.0028222022,
0.5786088109,
-0.2874106467,
0.4846278429,
-0.3122705817,
-0.4586898685,
-0.1225898564,
-0.6896374822,
-0.2688866854,
-0.7462338805,
-0.4986661971,
-0.1666887105,
0.3304789066,
1.240167737,
0.777297318,
-1.0310899019,
-0.0201717876,
-0.0385478921,
-0.3132590055,
-0.4653586745,
-0.1922775805,
0.5554320216,
0.0512818955,
-0.8501013517,
1.0652626753,
-0.1554899812,
0.1478097737,
0.0551872738,
-0.0543443672,
-0.1391871423,
0.3906912208,
0.0649026632,
0.5162995458,
-0.6736673713,
-0.5120532513,
-0.1412387341,
-0.0958384424,
0.1630981714,
0.5163684487,
-0.6318554878,
0.5214176178,
0.2943025231,
0.8323029876,
0.1822883934,
0.2586664259,
0.6032443047,
-0.7644082904,
-0.1543926895,
0.5173996091,
0.3594829738,
0.500798285,
-0.3128580451,
0.3972412646,
-0.0343248844,
-0.7210736871,
-0.9013033509,
0.1010366678,
-0.853936255,
0.1522497684,
1.0353832245,
-0.1673340946,
-0.1859941185,
-0.536988616,
-0.275782913,
0.6772500277,
-0.8783873916,
0.6347824931,
0.6132231951,
-0.1363232285,
0.2270821929,
-0.08495152,
0.5734887123,
0.4000816047,
-0.4055577517,
0.4533087015,
0.5971637964,
0.2193118483,
0.2460602969,
0.3044994175,
-0.1310127676,
0.296767205,
0.0481989607,
-0.0030838728,
-0.2478033304,
-0.585888803,
-0.7008823752,
0.2675222456,
-0.1288553029,
-0.4987372458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17923v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17923v1 | PAFT: A Parallel Training Paradigm for Effective LLM Fine-Tuning | 2024-06-25T20:11:37 | 2024-06-25T20:11:37 | Shiva Kumar Pentyala, Zhichao Wang, Bin Bi, Kiran Ramnath, Xiang-Bo Mao, Regunathan Radhakrishnan, Sitaram Asur, Na, Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable abilities in diverse
natural language processing (NLP) tasks. The LLMs generally undergo supervised
fine-tuning (SFT) followed by preference alignment to be usable in downstream
applications. However, this sequential training pipeline leads to alignment tax
that degrades the LLM performance.
This paper introduces PAFT, a new PArallel training paradigm for effective
LLM Fine-Tuning, which independently performs SFT and preference alignment
(e.g., DPO and ORPO, etc.) with the same pre-trained model on respective
datasets. The model produced by SFT and the model from preference alignment are
then merged into a final model by parameter fusing for use in downstream
applications. This work reveals important findings that preference alignment
like DPO naturally results in a sparse model while SFT leads to a natural dense
model which needs to be sparsified for effective model merging. This paper
introduces an effective interference resolution which reduces the redundancy by
sparsifying the delta parameters. The LLM resulted from the new training
paradigm achieved Rank #1 on the HuggingFace Open LLM Leaderboard.
Comprehensive evaluation shows the effectiveness of the parallel training
paradigm. | [
-0.7532855868,
-0.8300247192,
0.4107047915,
0.2437784523,
-0.4195335209,
-0.0011391083,
-0.5022854209,
-0.3449037075,
0.0206009876,
0.7587208152,
-0.4560106397,
-0.2561309338,
-0.8038552999,
0.080686152,
-0.2474530786,
0.981364131,
-0.2347666919,
0.1133686602,
0.0029399339,
-0.2545909286,
-0.3691471517,
-0.4656380415,
-0.9299097061,
-0.4661108851,
0.538664937,
0.1638148129,
0.692080915,
0.9689418077,
0.6412313581,
0.3442141712,
0.0017856014,
0.4511154592,
-0.600659132,
-0.1166860983,
-0.1528214961,
-0.358669281,
-0.685649395,
0.068289727,
0.9340649247,
0.8826360703,
-0.1927244812,
-0.1088476777,
0.404602468,
0.8983970881,
-0.4865026772,
0.0170379877,
-0.7975590825,
-0.1250472516,
-0.2700852156,
-0.2599807084,
-0.1620369554,
-0.2689557672,
-0.0021325641,
-0.5139594674,
0.2140434086,
0.1654120684,
0.9899360538,
0.7356735468,
-0.3695226312,
0.1036790982,
-0.5620396733,
0.8022079468,
-0.748517096,
0.5725718737,
0.1020822451,
0.2376920432,
-0.327445358,
-0.3880689144,
-0.6525011659,
0.0969331861,
-0.0215684157,
-0.184447214,
0.1753352731,
0.4313703179,
-0.040319819,
0.5661346316,
-0.2807251513,
0.4605590999,
-0.0589800291,
0.0432985574,
0.5130255818,
0.1148779169,
-0.1587922275,
0.328543067,
-0.5793522,
-0.1072688252,
-0.5739527345,
-0.0877977908,
0.5134093165,
0.7079865932,
-0.1132303029,
0.3296349049,
-0.1990164667,
0.9328619242,
0.502746582,
-0.4001774192,
0.2713985443,
-0.0500436462,
-0.4717700481,
0.0263206251,
0.8058488369,
0.2047275752,
0.2036181837,
-0.1234394386,
-0.2723239958,
-0.1723025143,
0.2437320501,
-0.4706045687,
0.0590389855,
0.0974746719,
-0.4306142032,
-0.2527803481,
-0.0558361895,
-0.6241556406,
-0.4007047415,
-0.9807470441,
0.1550729573,
-0.3438619971,
-0.3310217261,
0.4396615028,
0.173778072,
0.3455855846,
0.4260709584,
-1.2335191965,
0.4683707058,
1.1228400469,
0.6500243545,
-0.4664784968,
-0.6949341297,
-0.7778936625,
0.0610351935,
-0.0765632838,
0.8131697178,
-0.4180919528,
-0.1088775024,
-0.185836941,
-0.209715277,
-0.2904780209,
-0.6223767996,
0.6955744028,
-0.4558672309,
-0.0263871811,
-0.2511994243,
-0.6513083577,
0.0232860427,
0.2846251428,
-0.3762468696,
0.828815937,
0.0274128541,
-0.6860659122,
0.5507934093,
-0.3918647468,
-0.049940601,
-0.1609159112,
-0.0674911439,
-0.4639643133,
0.0077636158,
0.4053171873,
0.5233045816,
-0.3418587446,
0.4491210282,
-0.5261765122,
-0.4615109265,
-0.2971149683,
-0.3141005933,
0.5364190936,
0.1667107642,
-0.1019497365,
0.2310494035,
-0.6726401448,
-0.2480314672,
-0.1413131207,
-0.4956849515,
-0.148885414,
-0.1676675826,
0.0502720848,
0.0697922334,
0.3239325583,
-0.4045890868,
0.3687238693,
-0.6265667677,
0.1504211724,
0.8303470016,
-0.155151248,
0.6980413795,
-0.4699564576,
0.2502246797,
-0.1617667228,
0.0820812583,
0.1417845488,
-0.2157820463,
-0.952128768,
-0.4451726079,
0.3794350028,
0.3873557746,
-0.1494329721,
0.7575283051,
-0.179006964,
-0.4238724411,
-0.591486752,
0.363817066,
0.2333695143,
0.7849644423,
0.3114689291,
-0.2388973534,
-0.5010359883,
-0.8520021439,
-0.4038580954,
0.2037097812,
0.1076001972,
0.1787255704,
0.0864871368,
0.0401639678,
0.8095470071,
-0.216354847,
-0.5598238707,
-0.0554138124,
0.2946015596,
0.3737983704,
0.6529892087,
0.5141225457,
-0.6903201342,
-0.6046665907,
0.0190925226,
-0.3890708685,
-0.1699726284,
-0.1905528903,
-0.2117793113,
0.2698891461,
0.5263978243,
-0.4591964781,
-0.1387803853,
0.4464047253,
0.0086887116,
0.2086147517,
-0.1863944679,
0.197873354,
-0.8481765389,
-0.0289426371,
-0.0644552335,
-0.2915401459,
-0.4141730964,
0.1045138314,
0.0521543063,
0.0462539271,
-0.4617254734,
0.4747028053,
-0.3444053531,
0.11923711,
-0.5130462646,
-0.119411841,
-0.2210044712,
0.5438733101,
0.1305024624,
0.6957436204,
0.3492083251,
-0.4345203638,
0.2135162354,
0.283708781,
-0.0855873451,
0.4935002923,
-0.3905034661,
0.1462742239,
-0.1330649108,
0.2044853121,
-0.8022289872,
-0.2563586831,
0.0051088375,
0.0073627434,
0.5376219153,
-0.1765317917,
-0.7525812984,
0.0511468463,
-0.2277583182,
0.2648831606,
0.4793021381,
-0.7536327839,
0.4319566488,
0.3437926471,
-0.0816781148,
-0.6699400544,
-0.3880826831,
-0.2149461061,
-0.4808368981,
-0.6674075127,
0.5448220968,
0.2051629573,
0.1237125322,
-0.3431454003,
-0.0953831375,
-0.0430741161,
0.0111968266,
0.0537382737,
0.2436104119,
-0.2228465974,
-0.0014569239,
0.1537976116,
-0.1845854372,
-0.3012374341,
-0.0673684329,
0.7645008564,
-0.2926248014,
-0.3632671237,
-0.4576864839,
0.3246695697,
0.380823195,
-0.3523937762,
0.7630990148,
0.6501339674,
-0.1919194609,
-0.1307715923,
-0.8934153914,
-0.05407786,
-0.4896849692,
0.1099543795,
-0.2307845503,
-1.2512933016,
0.2677218616,
-0.3980990648,
0.09877415,
0.2332783043,
0.4266230762,
-0.1282707304,
0.9322705865,
0.966267705,
-0.1730023026,
0.5401826501,
0.130592972,
0.3079550862,
-0.723354876,
0.1173307225,
-0.3780811429,
-0.4539331794,
-0.5975973606,
-0.346228987,
0.3515992761,
0.6103129387,
-0.6109907031,
0.2798834145,
-0.4255638421,
0.6832639575,
0.5050988793,
-0.0399771444,
0.3368644118,
0.1480643004,
-0.0716042593,
-0.0724973083,
-0.4977630377,
-0.4451034665,
1.0037591457,
0.4578505158,
0.4949029684,
-0.2177812457,
0.9610795975,
-0.272480607,
0.0768154711,
-0.5515190959,
0.3169246912,
-0.5217497349,
-0.2244410813,
-0.3162861168,
-0.2042113841,
-0.6291592121,
0.2754861712,
-0.3656740189,
-0.7426713109,
0.2120872736,
0.3205858767,
-0.3823100924,
0.4413648546,
-0.6489102244,
0.752566278,
-0.171236217,
-0.5610414147,
-0.2500178516,
-0.6133279204,
0.5054481626,
-0.3113767803,
-0.1892244071,
-0.3791598678,
-0.1375575662,
0.436167568,
-0.4826924503,
0.7462901473,
-0.1423278898,
-0.0040289373,
-0.2449606061,
-0.2650117874,
0.6431352496,
0.0386129841,
-0.1953592598,
0.2815769613,
-0.1484248489,
-0.3498477936,
-0.4732289016,
0.8392526507,
-0.767780304,
-0.7000142932,
-0.2841237187,
-0.7329887748,
-0.6400142908,
0.2215769738,
0.0503389128,
-0.1412975043,
0.0933410749,
0.0520803705,
0.6859715581,
-0.1376509219,
0.1634332985,
0.4201815128,
-0.1474857777,
-0.4024800658,
0.6247429252,
-0.1046683639,
0.1868387014,
0.401162684,
0.1843504608,
-0.2906279266,
-0.7969247699,
-0.0949079394,
0.4684410095,
-0.3288701475,
-0.2757166028,
-0.6082091331,
-0.3303193152,
-0.3820458055,
-0.4517410994,
-0.6826281548,
-0.1106214523,
-0.1770945638,
0.1934246868,
0.2660230994,
0.3566714823,
-0.0915403143,
0.5561619997,
-0.7830762267,
0.3385921717,
0.2256454229,
0.7674230337,
-0.2768208086,
-0.324400723,
0.0234712791,
-0.0351397172,
-0.3327321708,
-0.3670831323,
0.3553967476,
0.1693420708,
0.4894621074,
0.2513613999,
-0.0775604844,
0.8964701295,
-0.4090061188,
0.426038295,
0.2756031752,
-0.8809222579,
0.3897702098,
-0.7053027153,
0.2701155543,
0.8986582756,
0.3312841654,
-0.2514667809,
-0.2855445445,
-0.3650879264,
-0.8798009157,
0.7878050804,
-0.0946096629,
-0.0326300636,
0.1145737618,
0.3526439369,
0.4885659516,
0.334631741,
-0.4734289646,
-0.13783665,
0.1515800059,
-0.1346070021,
-0.1821960658,
-0.1950275153,
-0.1719717681,
-0.4757020772,
0.7090627551,
-0.1209015474,
0.0865270719,
-0.0552479438,
0.2402407527,
-0.2304961681,
0.1817287058,
0.2234988958,
0.4619449377,
-0.4976081848,
-0.0830101669,
0.1045666635,
-0.1560480446,
-0.0409338921,
0.4110965729,
0.0821695179,
-0.3243955374,
0.1649831831,
0.7932102084,
0.2379238755,
-0.4319097996,
0.4356653094,
0.0848950371,
-0.4171541929,
-0.0574003756,
0.2572683394,
0.2055330276,
0.2203747183,
-0.071927458,
0.3740483522,
0.0160176642,
-0.1510899365,
0.21205917,
0.4270903766,
-0.1105089337,
0.1487097144,
0.6673048139,
0.3557727337,
-0.0701795518,
0.6198691726,
0.0788189918,
-0.32362625,
0.3777395487,
0.3603774905,
0.6874179244,
-0.0314034559,
-0.1368890256,
0.3694407642,
0.0625340641,
-0.3437603116,
0.1041282713,
-0.1941860318,
-0.800429523,
-0.5794833302,
-1.1387261152,
-0.3931357563,
0.4468315244,
-0.4750191867,
0.6451706886,
-0.6679298282,
0.1396599412,
0.118047528,
-0.0378094502,
-0.595210135,
0.0431279987,
0.2618713677,
0.8564620614,
-0.720153451,
1.1725666523,
0.6126102805,
-0.1983253956,
-0.9201593995,
0.123370491,
0.1485300213,
-0.6848929524,
0.5693944097,
0.1967288852,
-0.0258344412,
0.0820610896,
-0.2556072772,
-0.9708471298,
0.8860117793,
0.884247005,
-0.8665929437,
0.1059273556,
0.4605692625,
0.5274783969,
-0.4976699948,
-0.1134951711,
0.9134196043,
0.4383884966,
0.0186839812,
-1.3226205111,
-0.1113386154,
-0.0424075313,
0.0179611556,
0.5365761518,
-0.9222307205,
0.8310140371,
0.2777820826,
-0.0183691699,
0.0264115091,
0.4172055125,
0.4035083652,
0.0189644806,
0.7595592141,
0.7937758565,
0.6726121306,
-0.1814995557,
0.7167600989,
-0.2700799704,
0.3362747729,
1.4165388346,
-0.4096185565,
1.0354866982,
0.9062555432,
-0.2746072412,
-0.151312232,
0.6146703362,
-0.0780485421,
0.4992997348,
0.0941676721,
-0.1568755955,
-0.3950545788,
-0.1186740771,
-0.447904408,
0.6229857206,
0.0874169469,
-0.2304141372,
-0.4424801171,
0.0134706702,
-0.1658386141,
0.3754255772,
-0.2021997869,
0.7972359061,
0.0006409902,
-0.7750199437,
0.7827301621,
0.0025851449,
1.0720236301,
-0.6215668321,
0.0071209883,
-0.2326574475,
0.4075826406,
-0.1735963821,
-0.5690771937,
0.5873494148,
-0.1459107548,
-0.2208703607,
-0.5780354738,
0.5417525172,
-0.5097303987,
-0.2183142006,
0.3841969073,
0.271881789,
-0.0637259707,
-0.2394266278,
-0.7615895271,
0.1186953932,
-0.0930373892,
-0.0919417441,
0.699542582,
0.1214562058,
0.1895451695,
0.3482987583,
0.7090981007,
0.2223784626,
0.0572908744,
0.1005764827,
0.8244228363,
-0.3143470287,
-0.4597815573,
-0.6653159857,
0.3739397228,
-0.1165838465,
-0.4082660973,
0.4815652072,
0.541729331,
1.0140850544,
0.0423948206,
0.5503022075,
0.161109671,
0.6330683827,
-0.5998814702,
0.6917339563,
-0.5994968414,
0.4818631411,
-0.0946367159,
-1.0848400593,
-0.37560606,
0.3267289102,
-0.4770781994,
-0.0938904658,
0.5664204955,
0.7986043692,
-0.411234498,
0.1048505157,
0.2671871483,
-0.0266552623,
0.1080368981,
0.4962498248,
0.4488439858,
-0.347986877,
0.2348927259,
-0.5458452702,
-0.2584737539,
-0.077587679,
-0.9211755991,
-0.766816318,
-0.5988975763,
-0.2132541537,
0.1136730388,
0.1519972384,
1.0407903194,
0.8141171336,
-0.7439755797,
-0.3025966287,
-0.5929481983,
-0.1562714875,
-0.2125510126,
-0.2100432664,
0.3457698822,
-0.8782433867,
-0.9390395284,
0.3515759408,
0.3740284741,
0.0058772461,
0.0739531964,
-0.1249299049,
-0.3894803524,
-0.1458278596,
0.2802261114,
0.1490355432,
-0.8662371039,
-0.1249285489,
-0.4405640662,
0.0181343928,
0.3446717262,
0.7658279538,
-0.6376342773,
0.4238516092,
0.4743452966,
0.9773513079,
0.4614588022,
0.0775587484,
0.9396775961,
-0.7239139676,
0.3160136938,
0.0767950714,
0.3823343515,
0.3332573175,
-0.5159431696,
0.449662298,
0.0080679506,
-0.6609457135,
-0.7917055488,
0.0984347463,
-1.2638078928,
-0.1839681268,
0.955126822,
0.0071958317,
0.0067615453,
0.0923732296,
-0.3336543143,
0.3319634497,
-0.4485434294,
0.7144470811,
0.6722448468,
-0.4145219922,
-0.2953560352,
-0.2544226348,
0.7021473646,
0.7812514305,
-0.6668741703,
0.1710913777,
0.2128063589,
0.1711773574,
-0.1665630341,
0.4991918206,
-0.1403170675,
0.048408743,
-0.0622184649,
-0.1688405871,
-0.3377384543,
-0.0259217136,
-0.5880177021,
0.3375183344,
0.2825418711,
-0.1016732901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17911v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17911v2 | X-ray Made Simple: Radiology Report Generation and Evaluation with Layman's Terms | 2024-06-25T19:52:01 | 2024-06-30T21:53:56 | Kun Zhao, Chenghao Xiao, Chen Tang, Bohao Yang, Kai Ye, Noura Al Moubayed, Liang Zhan, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Radiology Report Generation (RRG) has achieved significant progress with the
advancements of multimodal generative models. However, the evaluation in the
domain suffers from a lack of fair and robust metrics. We reveal that, high
performance on RRG with existing lexical-based metrics (e.g. BLEU) might be
more of a mirage - a model can get a high BLEU only by learning the template of
reports. This has become an urgent problem for RRG due to the highly
patternized nature of these reports. In this work, we un-intuitively approach
this problem by proposing the Layman's RRG framework, a layman's terms-based
dataset, evaluation and training framework that systematically improves RRG
with day-to-day language. We first contribute the translated Layman's terms
dataset. Building upon the dataset, we then propose a semantics-based
evaluation method, which is proved to mitigate the inflated numbers of BLEU and
provides fairer evaluation. Last, we show that training on the layman's terms
dataset encourages models to focus on the semantics of the reports, as opposed
to overfitting to learning the report templates. We reveal a promising scaling
law between the number of training examples and semantics gain provided by our
dataset, compared to the inverse pattern brought by the original formats. Our
code is available at \url{https://github.com/hegehongcha/LaymanRRG}. | [
-0.0353359431,
-0.2678206265,
0.5100056529,
0.00708244,
-0.5086987019,
-0.1735842973,
-0.1550134718,
-0.3655176163,
0.0423118174,
0.4502324164,
-0.3512400389,
-0.5828126073,
-1.0018094778,
-0.0408151299,
-0.1861891598,
1.2005329132,
0.2343031913,
0.2879514396,
-0.101999253,
-0.3429639339,
-0.5207579136,
0.1021186188,
-0.4955598414,
-0.6619810462,
0.4188093245,
0.4268150926,
1.2325917482,
1.2486344576,
0.868177712,
0.0925942063,
0.3692218661,
-0.0383689441,
-0.353654474,
-0.0341096558,
0.0729519278,
-0.3848905861,
-0.5253834724,
0.0816423595,
0.4090842903,
0.979532063,
-0.4659252465,
0.0824388936,
-0.3981401026,
0.9980747104,
-0.8437639475,
0.1883964241,
-0.2611466646,
0.2549230158,
-0.1621823013,
-0.833699882,
-0.6660611033,
-0.4376036525,
0.1927615851,
-0.7736555934,
0.1872042567,
0.104982987,
1.0576223135,
0.1705785245,
-0.4508673847,
-0.6120070219,
-0.5764613152,
0.6794026494,
-0.5009061098,
0.4069126844,
0.2622533441,
0.649757266,
0.0906166583,
-1.0061881542,
-0.0442708097,
-0.4311231077,
-0.3300337195,
0.5906991959,
-0.3393990397,
0.0307579841,
0.4387340844,
0.3656693995,
-0.9835660458,
-0.1020159423,
-0.3782930076,
0.1901678145,
0.7536154985,
0.2748837769,
0.2412107736,
-0.6044871807,
-0.7001558542,
-0.3782844543,
-0.6517596841,
-0.5018301606,
-0.1043755338,
0.2589718997,
-0.2445133477,
0.4032298625,
-0.2366727293,
0.6912391782,
-0.2317782342,
-0.2761059403,
0.5083993077,
-0.0234387051,
-0.3811452687,
0.1635116488,
0.7199995518,
0.4695299864,
0.0515292287,
-0.2735074162,
-0.2680808902,
0.3062124848,
0.2313169241,
-0.7460058928,
-0.332385093,
0.0850054473,
-0.8454289436,
-0.4510458708,
-0.0183527209,
-0.7016744614,
-0.3112089932,
-0.3227802217,
0.6171287298,
-0.5792102814,
-0.1833093911,
0.5658935905,
-0.1302556396,
0.2881392837,
0.2859025002,
-0.3612267673,
0.1865059733,
0.5389456749,
0.6991675496,
0.262334615,
0.0632240698,
-0.9645614624,
0.3402980566,
-0.3184277415,
0.8666407466,
-0.601842165,
-0.6006253958,
-0.1691670567,
-0.5089905262,
-0.0882556215,
-0.4170356393,
0.570289731,
-0.2939587831,
0.6499137878,
0.057393603,
-0.5165781975,
0.0481267869,
0.0628470033,
-0.4322964251,
0.5998863578,
0.2151539028,
-0.8043937087,
0.7774906754,
-0.6943256259,
-0.5098525286,
0.5744559169,
-0.6726359129,
-0.3886821866,
0.1612427086,
0.0881409422,
0.5138532519,
-0.6900269389,
0.2105641365,
0.2623784542,
-0.2230303884,
0.0521029457,
-0.1152011231,
0.5125208497,
0.4016575217,
-0.1663274914,
0.0330954008,
-0.9963980913,
0.4678482115,
-0.0680391192,
-0.2196143419,
-0.3795166016,
-0.0209112,
-0.1613898128,
0.1934803277,
-0.2344581634,
-0.4568752646,
-0.1008400768,
-0.1847703904,
0.0358252786,
0.4558839202,
-0.2856767774,
0.1872281432,
-0.8194270134,
0.8060631752,
-0.0507310182,
0.0677941814,
-0.3929998577,
-0.2985042036,
-0.5829694867,
-0.6400332451,
0.4594828784,
0.4367028177,
-0.6007834077,
0.081520468,
-0.9253032207,
-0.5060425997,
-0.4066522419,
-0.1662728935,
0.5692868829,
0.5592134595,
0.1520353109,
-0.6405704618,
-0.6339510679,
-0.8328373432,
-0.1560162157,
0.037262179,
-0.1601112485,
0.2384837419,
0.1225264966,
-0.1080840304,
0.8119879961,
-0.8655382395,
-0.5737914443,
-0.2979000509,
0.5591919422,
0.1597256213,
0.2407166064,
0.2613918185,
-0.7862920761,
-0.4026845694,
0.2062437087,
-1.1280263662,
-0.0472446717,
-0.1156189069,
-0.0789099783,
0.2043084949,
0.668276608,
-0.4268165529,
0.4179664552,
0.4039137959,
-0.2145154774,
0.3206473589,
-0.3486633301,
0.1236149892,
-0.8830307126,
0.1932589263,
0.2656151056,
-0.4826965928,
-0.4299337566,
0.3112897575,
0.0303929355,
-0.2651466727,
-0.3043921888,
0.397051692,
-0.4338741899,
-0.1102526337,
-0.1471436918,
0.2110920995,
0.1557707638,
0.1819170266,
0.3209974468,
0.186667338,
0.561958015,
-0.4994507432,
0.0602461882,
0.2271697521,
-0.2556973398,
0.5672804713,
-0.5962530971,
0.0973947197,
-0.4480859339,
0.2836038768,
-0.6013206244,
-0.2062377185,
0.1374446005,
-0.4996987581,
0.4363431633,
-0.3105055094,
-0.1150316596,
-0.0074648336,
-0.3567270637,
0.2843547463,
0.7828635573,
-0.3941901922,
0.6678115129,
0.0985058397,
0.1354645044,
-0.5946740508,
-0.5945662856,
0.1769270897,
-0.141253233,
-0.8759588003,
0.2859452665,
0.0475610793,
-0.2808489799,
0.0466508642,
-0.1132748947,
0.1022258252,
-0.238119632,
0.3384265304,
0.1697476506,
-0.5467950106,
-0.0256293695,
-0.4135086834,
-0.4428287446,
0.1430088282,
-0.1474024057,
0.445242703,
-0.1676947176,
-0.1887908727,
-0.036426004,
0.2326262891,
0.247941345,
0.0210501663,
0.1079538167,
0.4800419211,
-0.1948811263,
-0.2256560922,
-0.155001685,
0.1053175628,
-0.4169542789,
0.3846959174,
-0.3383734524,
-0.4152784348,
0.1178018749,
-0.1575386971,
0.0522770472,
0.2641601562,
0.5662297606,
-0.0894223973,
0.8356543183,
0.5631213784,
0.6113658547,
0.0109457783,
-0.2429380864,
0.2230580598,
-0.5676639676,
-0.5115708113,
-0.4453729391,
0.0731437579,
-0.7316155434,
-0.2430928051,
0.5269461274,
-0.1502311677,
0.2897601426,
-0.0641792193,
-0.4375549853,
0.3655702472,
0.1198536903,
0.1669028997,
0.4843285382,
0.0516438223,
0.3033355474,
-0.1575301439,
-1.1383041143,
-0.5677686334,
1.3036648035,
0.4328011274,
1.0501917601,
0.0575379208,
0.8284720778,
0.4441300929,
0.3641509116,
-0.9726311564,
0.4421590567,
-0.6377496719,
-0.0782806799,
-0.0485907309,
-0.627489686,
-1.165755868,
0.3702842593,
-0.0558204316,
0.0208271965,
-0.0023145408,
0.1351889074,
-0.4293652773,
-0.1211451143,
-0.610591352,
0.5356302261,
-0.2858912647,
-0.1343297809,
-0.3263388574,
-0.6747431755,
0.4539666474,
0.1941679269,
0.5737046003,
-0.1934506595,
0.1095662415,
0.8103390336,
-0.5234352946,
0.5490689874,
-0.0202212557,
-0.0156713668,
-0.0787469298,
0.2797302902,
0.1454631984,
0.3045624495,
0.1937317699,
0.0091551477,
0.0801919922,
-0.4890084565,
-0.6602563262,
0.5115548372,
-0.7033532858,
-0.3010791838,
-0.8113889694,
-0.7356966734,
-0.2197434008,
0.0385249592,
0.5393826962,
0.7359166145,
-0.0996279418,
-0.0184962507,
0.5938838124,
-0.1844624281,
0.1304069012,
0.3887625933,
-0.1868133247,
-0.2848872542,
1.0216566324,
0.0220921542,
0.2060592771,
0.3908960819,
0.4970620275,
0.0201870743,
-0.419097662,
-0.5043135285,
0.1040776595,
-0.9363231063,
-0.4672387242,
-0.452121228,
-0.2213745117,
-0.1129439771,
-0.2769968808,
-0.1489647925,
-0.4975318015,
0.1710466743,
0.3400313556,
0.2924799919,
0.7783549428,
-0.3031234443,
0.3941321373,
-0.6854189634,
0.3048626184,
0.1080520898,
0.3845992386,
-0.1534373015,
-0.4798471332,
-0.338858217,
-0.0809522644,
-0.0872076079,
-0.3267896175,
0.4674226642,
0.2239609063,
0.2399592102,
0.253532052,
-0.2020177096,
0.6507499814,
-0.3283754289,
0.3183736801,
0.6760425568,
-0.7670890093,
0.6089777946,
-0.5127875209,
0.2659458518,
0.391179949,
0.3277503252,
-0.6648359299,
-0.0780330598,
-0.7432107925,
-1.0423365831,
0.6871706843,
0.0444116853,
0.0305316374,
-0.1224732921,
0.4749568999,
0.284680903,
0.0449594222,
-0.5954490304,
-0.1600615978,
-0.5027915835,
-0.1419055313,
0.25504601,
-0.3201980293,
-0.600610733,
0.1609524488,
0.5191554427,
-0.3041611314,
0.3386630416,
0.1407061517,
-0.345451504,
-0.2652468383,
0.2591197491,
0.5829506516,
1.0705627203,
-0.5539964437,
0.2981525064,
-0.2603087127,
-0.5069521666,
-0.0000195863,
-0.1778824031,
0.0851180926,
0.2933418751,
0.6992314458,
0.7137007713,
0.1977238059,
-0.6043550968,
0.7087744474,
-0.2325674593,
-0.447845459,
-0.2531121671,
0.090194039,
-0.3482677341,
-0.2198225856,
0.5002865791,
0.1426512152,
0.0666258857,
-0.3885001242,
0.5096939206,
0.2277622223,
-0.4998670816,
0.0580892824,
0.3385546207,
0.1187970638,
0.0142955761,
0.4802575111,
-0.2684991062,
-0.0239463244,
0.5258972645,
0.4990368187,
0.5602860451,
0.1933508068,
0.4479398131,
0.3374839425,
0.1796818078,
-0.2290655673,
0.2192447931,
0.423807472,
-0.5499814749,
-0.6185965538,
-0.3789972961,
-0.2149431854,
0.2118597329,
-1.0572333336,
0.5805593729,
-0.8451693654,
0.1102634817,
0.1003339514,
-0.1100777611,
-0.5594338775,
0.7359378934,
0.1267296076,
0.9489570856,
-0.630644083,
0.4961581826,
0.6491158605,
-0.4762811065,
-0.7695606947,
-0.0405625366,
-0.2496926636,
-1.0780395269,
0.9619686604,
0.0362270027,
-0.1954603642,
-0.2217199206,
-0.1748554856,
-0.6869056225,
1.1755279303,
0.3589565158,
-0.5221467614,
-0.0573327579,
0.1632114947,
0.4403088987,
-0.4883182645,
0.4727921486,
0.366938144,
0.3237129748,
0.3111775517,
-0.6960453987,
0.2432544231,
-0.0569907054,
0.0416594893,
0.2021541595,
-0.5024181008,
0.5173763037,
-0.3194963038,
-0.2895195186,
-0.3036701083,
0.5392996073,
0.1904177517,
0.3728454411,
0.3286991119,
0.7840909958,
0.5863153338,
-0.1091600135,
1.4495592117,
-0.2296738923,
0.3255444765,
1.0631864071,
-0.3189469278,
0.2825906575,
0.1421755105,
0.1220285594,
0.5976852179,
0.2223267406,
-0.1511859596,
0.6315318942,
0.1713045985,
-0.0441373289,
-0.386988014,
-0.1298202425,
-0.3914834261,
0.693329215,
0.1391463131,
-0.3650124073,
-0.6252976656,
-0.0310859345,
0.1464449614,
0.1368039995,
-0.3561996222,
0.6168144345,
0.2862231135,
-0.333688885,
0.8217076659,
0.2279839963,
0.5789015293,
-0.9523769021,
-0.0311587341,
-0.2449149042,
-0.0070904153,
-0.6438784599,
-0.5453277826,
0.4416712523,
-0.3009290695,
-0.1199381799,
-0.1836283505,
0.4170043766,
-0.184222579,
-0.3825650811,
0.151116699,
0.6683865786,
-0.016933592,
0.5219394565,
-0.539485693,
0.0578211434,
-0.0179659445,
-0.0936813578,
0.475902617,
0.3566674292,
-0.181914255,
0.8048200011,
0.451372385,
0.2509866655,
-0.211669594,
0.3170863986,
0.6443263888,
-0.5443575382,
-0.4521936178,
-0.6924684048,
0.3711989522,
0.2235114723,
-0.3577370048,
0.525496006,
0.681647718,
0.6815325022,
0.1609560549,
1.0179913044,
-0.2694910765,
0.2169750333,
-0.8408766985,
0.6219617128,
-0.3868380785,
0.2836683691,
-0.2277972698,
-0.4655697048,
-0.619592607,
0.7356967926,
-0.2802014053,
0.1698117405,
0.8692746758,
0.7174059153,
-0.2845317721,
0.0049866494,
0.6243289709,
0.079564169,
0.2362917215,
0.4452568591,
0.7367115617,
-0.5572946072,
0.6633375287,
-0.0482996702,
-0.3270615637,
-0.1316458285,
-1.0389906168,
-0.580168128,
-0.3235452175,
-0.7815768123,
-0.7334621549,
0.3681493402,
0.8358669281,
0.9292710423,
-0.2732042074,
-0.4623318613,
0.0691703856,
-0.1747810245,
0.0263160784,
-0.2066988498,
0.614855051,
-0.3375356793,
-0.1652735323,
0.2076127976,
0.4101145566,
-0.2427964807,
0.015819354,
-0.226922527,
0.1752162576,
-0.0569080301,
0.5692990422,
0.1417786032,
-0.1828280687,
-0.2386574,
-0.2189256549,
-0.2036147714,
0.4374137521,
1.0727894306,
-0.9879674315,
0.3252124488,
0.1816385239,
0.326131314,
0.4543682039,
-0.1499703526,
0.5878237486,
-0.8273432851,
0.1001567096,
0.3116730154,
0.2163269222,
0.4012635946,
-0.4644367695,
0.6820241213,
0.1497097909,
-0.2722140849,
-0.9214885235,
0.3518260419,
-1.0146113634,
-0.2554315329,
1.1073951721,
-0.0855045021,
-0.0744509399,
0.0287886783,
0.1134626865,
0.0498789437,
-0.2954095006,
0.8341684937,
0.1421056241,
-0.5415368676,
-0.1688384116,
-0.4628579915,
0.699326396,
0.5740709305,
-0.7654443383,
-0.0071505485,
0.5652288198,
0.585108459,
0.1640419662,
0.8497380614,
-0.363879621,
0.8086029291,
-0.1002437174,
0.1141231731,
-0.208518222,
-0.0708444938,
-0.5703014731,
0.2415388376,
0.3225493431,
0.0797693878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17903v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17903v1 | Mapping the Past: Geographically Linking an Early 20th Century Swedish Encyclopedia with Wikidata | 2024-06-25T19:34:00 | 2024-06-25T19:34:00 | Axel Ahlin, Alfred Myrne, Pierre Nugues | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL | In this paper, we describe the extraction of all the location entries from a
prominent Swedish encyclopedia from the early 20th century, the \textit{Nordisk
Familjebok} `Nordic Family Book.' We focused on the second edition called
\textit{Uggleupplagan}, which comprises 38 volumes and over 182,000 articles.
This makes it one of the most extensive Swedish encyclopedias. Using a
classifier, we first determined the category of the entries. We found that
approximately 22 percent of them were locations. We applied a named entity
recognition to these entries and we linked them to Wikidata. Wikidata enabled
us to extract their precise geographic locations resulting in almost 18,000
valid coordinates. We then analyzed the distribution of these locations and the
entry selection process. It showed a higher density within Sweden, Germany, and
the United Kingdom. The paper sheds light on the selection and representation
of geographic information in the \textit{Nordisk Familjebok}, providing
insights into historical and societal perspectives. It also paves the way for
future investigations into entry selection in different time periods and
comparative analyses among various encyclopedias. | [
-0.8020811677,
-0.1735033244,
0.5950043797,
-0.2342548817,
-0.254249543,
-0.2982542813,
0.0107662315,
-0.6268103719,
0.4288363755,
0.4017135501,
-0.4985429049,
-0.7034976482,
-0.2859759033,
0.0839114636,
-0.1917010993,
0.4429602623,
-0.2358964682,
0.054218661,
-0.309882164,
-0.349866271,
-0.0050156843,
-0.8026397228,
-0.1875181645,
-0.2715485394,
0.7254383564,
0.350468725,
0.7679357529,
0.8406205177,
0.2142110318,
0.2990800738,
-0.3719829917,
0.1766780615,
-0.4776771367,
0.3849944472,
-0.5263541341,
-0.5104529858,
-0.166699484,
-0.2292140126,
0.6185880899,
0.789968431,
0.1943978965,
0.1990719438,
-0.1635195762,
0.7643041015,
-0.4778544307,
-0.1411875784,
-0.1761193722,
0.1124833897,
-0.500895381,
-0.316824466,
-0.2215243429,
-0.2296281904,
0.1524256617,
-0.6554698944,
0.5366947055,
0.2639277577,
0.9398280382,
-0.124843806,
-0.6986401081,
-0.3890810907,
-0.8627686501,
0.6141688228,
-0.0525132418,
0.7103037834,
0.5359683037,
0.1415371895,
-0.612332046,
-0.4268221855,
-0.3934577107,
0.1989037544,
-0.032092303,
-0.0962917656,
-0.1202108487,
-0.4040871263,
0.2433715016,
-0.0025056188,
-0.5462863445,
0.138953656,
-0.7585788369,
-0.1397090852,
0.7393806577,
0.3064725995,
0.4212706387,
-0.4832526147,
-0.393281132,
-0.2211825401,
-0.8967472315,
-0.1148900241,
0.6687352061,
-0.024947742,
0.0751447976,
0.6890785098,
-0.1735718995,
0.6639145017,
0.039417427,
-0.1666643322,
0.1841875762,
-0.4790286124,
0.3192813694,
-0.0678773969,
0.4124006033,
0.7121063471,
0.1465301514,
-0.2156487852,
-0.0958756879,
-0.9545428157,
0.4553222954,
-0.1336419582,
-0.4305598438,
-0.0920019448,
-0.8390463591,
-0.0711589679,
0.1445780098,
-0.824015975,
-0.5074294806,
-0.2033392042,
-0.09605515,
-0.0264024828,
-0.3067251444,
-0.5160121322,
-0.4637485147,
0.2063390911,
0.2618145943,
-1.0901249647,
-0.0092709428,
0.6688828468,
1.0001049042,
-0.3438263237,
-0.4061901867,
0.4473775625,
0.3026699424,
-0.4416233599,
1.0280764103,
-0.0343574025,
-0.7222375274,
0.1473001838,
0.1161641628,
0.4616036713,
-0.34768188,
0.2668886483,
-0.904376924,
0.1926205754,
-0.4117637873,
-0.1547596753,
-0.3514944911,
0.0335069112,
-1.0029673576,
1.202280879,
0.5447490215,
-0.7183222175,
0.6621574759,
-0.4407195449,
-0.407122314,
0.086869128,
-0.1068736464,
0.1155214459,
0.1562806666,
0.1449100077,
0.1779622883,
-0.0982785225,
0.0606196448,
-0.4108123481,
-0.2274509519,
-0.1010835618,
-0.1635182947,
1.4050917625,
0.284581989,
-0.147222057,
-0.44704476,
-0.6729643345,
-0.3299037814,
0.0374561287,
-0.5041766167,
-1.0196367502,
-0.1315191686,
-0.0010188561,
0.3559409678,
0.5358165503,
-0.3571780324,
0.5974398255,
-0.3221783638,
-0.1475171894,
0.4848330319,
0.2295023352,
0.8290579915,
-0.0215323139,
0.5548327565,
-0.2100922465,
0.4131481946,
0.1998378187,
-0.6756004691,
-0.5350434184,
0.1364049166,
0.6727854609,
0.4574248791,
-0.5747558475,
0.537969768,
-0.651610136,
-0.6133756042,
-0.1999195814,
-0.076727502,
-0.4374010563,
0.3183079362,
-0.019299563,
-0.0739066601,
-0.7472759485,
-0.8218893409,
0.220421955,
-0.438384831,
-0.3993369341,
0.5261626244,
0.5538608432,
-0.104030773,
0.8113254905,
-0.6119115949,
-0.0099801468,
0.2971846461,
-0.0280813277,
0.3296560943,
0.0804029629,
0.8613363504,
-1.2307020426,
-0.3924732208,
0.2230779827,
-0.5414869189,
-0.047217913,
0.0271804426,
-0.6998893023,
0.4120415151,
0.2081607133,
-0.4795122147,
0.5932947993,
0.2215712219,
-0.5977911949,
0.3804966211,
-0.3638715744,
0.4325399995,
-0.9624506831,
0.3363187313,
-0.6484835744,
-0.0425534472,
-0.0652552843,
-0.1920330077,
0.188711971,
0.0137455761,
-0.3194078207,
0.6319617629,
-0.6146785021,
-0.1122373417,
0.2305473238,
0.1235429347,
-0.1935373098,
0.1691204756,
-0.1552009284,
0.4242313802,
-0.0333504677,
-0.2633662224,
0.5876125693,
0.4424221814,
-0.3454402089,
0.7136464119,
0.2648149133,
0.0633639917,
-0.1889128834,
0.1563756168,
-1.0527560711,
-0.2586759031,
0.1099510938,
-0.5467174649,
0.2916972637,
-0.25690341,
-0.4571790397,
-0.3990383446,
-0.1526091695,
0.152455464,
0.2758376002,
-0.6752578616,
0.9524281621,
0.7824671865,
-0.6904700398,
-0.6966408491,
-0.2553169727,
0.2195490003,
-0.0547192022,
-0.4791021347,
0.0601313375,
0.0380582288,
-0.2801567614,
0.4150273502,
-0.3175191581,
-0.3866128922,
0.2532328367,
0.4721604586,
0.5924836397,
-0.1825501919,
0.1176660657,
0.1360996515,
-0.067209214,
0.0657836422,
-0.3870482147,
0.4417296052,
0.6383638978,
0.2472294122,
0.1096925884,
0.8945845366,
0.5483021736,
0.1536098421,
0.8182583451,
0.0741301328,
-0.5240268707,
0.0498053096,
-0.4433461726,
0.2245380878,
-0.387470305,
0.0824211836,
-0.309442699,
-0.5760946274,
0.5099981427,
-0.1581737995,
0.0650476366,
1.0241024494,
0.3208556473,
-0.677431047,
0.5562911034,
0.4882867038,
-0.057484027,
0.445053041,
-0.2199464589,
0.1623029858,
-0.4870357215,
-0.7314755321,
-0.7782812715,
-0.4838396013,
-0.5099645257,
-0.0692637563,
0.3803658187,
0.1864746362,
-0.0890936628,
0.1839587092,
-0.2113408148,
0.5413591266,
0.5823556781,
-0.2049332559,
0.2936937213,
0.3802791536,
-0.346727699,
-0.1220534071,
-0.8204334974,
-0.4123109281,
1.2744988203,
0.1275202185,
0.4556676447,
0.3445547819,
0.9096546173,
0.3496100307,
0.5919182301,
-0.4742429256,
0.2266488224,
-0.24359487,
-1.1077750921,
-0.437282145,
-0.0464800112,
-1.006482482,
0.0474876128,
-0.3171091676,
-0.5710283518,
0.838694036,
-0.0717595741,
-0.4436150193,
0.1258959621,
-0.5301826,
0.5077542663,
-0.3107075095,
0.0698462129,
0.051167991,
-0.8927907944,
-0.0540419668,
-0.1842742264,
0.4522832334,
0.3728740513,
-0.1522766352,
0.8946743011,
-0.1677085906,
0.5474021435,
-0.212435171,
-0.1995393485,
0.0277281068,
0.2398349792,
0.2268422097,
-0.2742985785,
0.035733223,
0.5617178082,
0.3274229765,
-0.2325713187,
-0.6296463013,
1.0634820461,
-0.7267103791,
-0.3155703545,
-0.4419876039,
-0.3475432992,
0.2193163037,
0.6251785755,
0.4404597878,
0.4959352314,
-0.1024524122,
0.3771179318,
0.7256237268,
0.2613286674,
0.1736911833,
0.3716377914,
-0.2495901883,
-0.5679356456,
0.4779816568,
0.9180418849,
-0.304153949,
0.4441986084,
-0.0566132627,
-0.6183356643,
-0.6224368811,
-0.1739671081,
0.2913306952,
-1.0589240789,
-0.1685940623,
-0.6205520034,
0.1624645293,
-0.4397750199,
-0.4949162304,
-0.0069939513,
-0.5082601309,
-0.3645412028,
-0.202427581,
0.0840042681,
0.95844841,
-0.4448338747,
0.1220428497,
-0.4389232993,
0.3318938017,
-0.0224460997,
0.2642208338,
0.065071471,
0.1545282453,
-0.3966126144,
-0.2884467244,
0.1021656692,
-1.1549021006,
0.089027442,
-0.2041265219,
0.6056699157,
0.3417775631,
0.100008972,
0.4365726709,
-0.714722693,
0.9669403434,
0.052758202,
-0.1182801649,
0.2559352219,
-0.294777751,
0.2873931229,
0.6279111505,
0.7952005267,
-0.5814677477,
0.0792982727,
-0.7990986705,
-1.3143662214,
0.2271475792,
-0.4162194431,
-0.0911110565,
0.0098075029,
0.6443969011,
0.352462709,
-0.1750583649,
-0.1715460867,
-0.5878391266,
0.0377110243,
-0.2772762477,
-0.1255193055,
-0.4953309298,
-0.2408395112,
-0.4116212726,
0.5257958174,
0.3901154101,
0.1997383535,
0.3388716578,
-0.4152222872,
-0.0434467345,
-0.12168549,
0.4426353872,
1.0028326511,
-0.0181400962,
0.3072718084,
0.1382891983,
-0.9383714199,
0.1650496274,
0.0612272471,
-0.6229684949,
0.6313874722,
0.4767275453,
0.507712841,
0.5076031089,
-0.1991800815,
0.385705322,
0.1314469278,
0.1115957573,
-0.7723873854,
0.0590627305,
0.1301673502,
0.6077779531,
0.8648269773,
-0.3928605616,
0.2470241785,
-0.0356025584,
0.219622165,
0.2854646146,
0.0449435003,
-0.0252828449,
0.587631464,
0.2579567432,
-0.5457128882,
0.5928637981,
-0.0069263624,
-0.4985326827,
0.3282238245,
0.3058204651,
0.5676441789,
-0.3582912087,
0.1717534065,
0.6018189788,
0.4409516454,
0.1040145084,
0.307962805,
-0.3750068545,
-0.3169346154,
0.0691767186,
-0.5874340534,
-0.0293847118,
-0.0419124663,
-0.5927688479,
0.1167049333,
0.0235839449,
-0.3217451274,
-0.1145411581,
0.2308425903,
-1.2060163021,
0.1101047248,
0.0523966439,
1.1306415796,
-0.8502058983,
0.4541243911,
0.5754222274,
0.1469423473,
-0.2916590571,
-0.1432085186,
0.1557706147,
-0.4252745509,
0.7982073426,
-0.5635318756,
-0.1866365969,
0.0361701511,
-0.5838090777,
-0.9716759324,
1.2455537319,
-0.3335414231,
-0.4787346423,
-0.3674083948,
-0.3162179887,
0.4461252093,
-0.4245296121,
-0.2225961536,
0.5163558125,
0.5100800395,
-0.2909326553,
-0.6027328968,
-0.2085230052,
-0.1388003081,
0.1067318544,
0.5667954683,
0.0469308794,
0.5619649291,
-0.1399449557,
-0.4570123553,
0.1271471977,
0.5396645069,
-0.2891638577,
0.1734842062,
0.4087103903,
0.3418453336,
0.9896677136,
-0.2096221596,
1.1464768648,
0.1028608382,
0.4839294851,
0.9229871035,
-0.0007869977,
0.9613604546,
0.7335700393,
-0.3710298836,
0.5008159876,
0.9512126446,
-0.0782713071,
0.8870752454,
-0.2839242518,
-0.2685225606,
0.2023907006,
0.1219538003,
-0.3547386527,
0.2278119326,
0.3082458377,
-0.5158586502,
-0.496729821,
0.0581645183,
0.2143094838,
-0.5204527378,
-0.3330511749,
0.8509366512,
-0.2469734848,
-0.4553850293,
0.3982589245,
-0.4576200545,
0.1996836662,
-0.6524829865,
-0.0764305368,
-0.3443476856,
-0.4129691422,
-0.1305613667,
-0.9316142797,
0.1408367753,
-0.2484469712,
-0.5465328693,
0.0372615308,
0.7101098895,
-0.4758999944,
-0.1964698136,
0.0852871239,
0.2490448058,
0.3603801131,
0.5198167562,
-0.0126419086,
0.0770720541,
0.0369666815,
-0.4537346661,
0.1343812943,
0.5224539638,
-0.1390159279,
0.1515007466,
0.6935860515,
0.2188163847,
0.1020228639,
-0.5983440876,
0.4647812545,
-0.910700798,
-0.8139500618,
-0.5889276862,
0.4826601744,
-0.5088368058,
-0.5714010596,
0.7665775418,
0.7039362192,
1.0616312027,
-0.2050080299,
0.7110330462,
-0.2604925632,
0.3759824932,
-0.2770009041,
1.1286354065,
-0.4944138825,
-0.3407950699,
0.2323833257,
-0.9954479337,
-0.4472618699,
0.672113955,
-0.3322972953,
-0.4436669052,
0.5861291289,
0.4227590561,
-0.030479271,
-0.0901191235,
0.1266192496,
0.3493023217,
-0.0736504495,
-0.0490882285,
0.658185184,
0.0090242522,
0.2509304583,
-0.4809983373,
-0.3741846681,
-0.5770632029,
-0.8714506626,
-0.4564794004,
-1.1652879715,
0.1714730561,
-0.4547162056,
0.0804217681,
0.8111853004,
0.3078612983,
-0.6632674932,
0.0159552097,
0.9232688546,
0.4138108492,
-0.0861538351,
-0.1311760545,
0.6458140016,
0.4329846203,
-0.4034626484,
0.3254752755,
0.3060356677,
0.1718947142,
-0.4512858987,
0.0334291421,
-0.2159040272,
-0.193738997,
0.4621755779,
0.3803976774,
-0.491281271,
-0.4756680429,
0.015989203,
-0.177019909,
0.1125032306,
0.8429495096,
-0.4515002668,
0.7583215833,
0.7285807729,
0.279255569,
0.5763602853,
-0.1641151905,
0.4349990785,
-0.4597058296,
0.1332810521,
0.0542378128,
0.1818175167,
0.2006413937,
-0.6731111407,
0.4498774707,
0.2685438991,
-0.5114977956,
-0.8800359964,
-0.1348827332,
-0.6523330212,
-0.2610461116,
0.9945563674,
0.1386204362,
-0.7520554662,
-0.692332685,
-0.3324387968,
0.3213301301,
-0.0331179686,
0.9104009867,
1.4587100744,
-0.1327285618,
0.1857775301,
-0.9674235582,
0.2421997637,
-0.461258471,
-0.4163217545,
-0.3480288088,
0.7870346308,
0.5646783113,
0.4832318723,
0.4675154984,
-0.2362345904,
0.3115967512,
0.1520493776,
0.2567826211,
-0.0291259419,
-0.6193420887,
-0.3077339232,
0.4368300736,
-0.1833928972,
-0.0654668435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17901v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17901v1 | Script-Agnostic Language Identification | 2024-06-25T19:23:42 | 2024-06-25T19:23:42 | Milind Agarwal, Joshua Otten, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language identification is used as the first step in many data collection and
crawling efforts because it allows us to sort online text into
language-specific buckets. However, many modern languages, such as Konkani,
Kashmiri, Punjabi etc., are synchronically written in several scripts.
Moreover, languages with different writing systems do not share significant
lexical, semantic, and syntactic properties in neural representation spaces,
which is a disadvantage for closely related languages and low-resource
languages, especially those from the Indian Subcontinent. To counter this, we
propose learning script-agnostic representations using several different
experimental strategies (upscaling, flattening, and script mixing) focusing on
four major Dravidian languages (Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, and Malayalam). We find
that word-level script randomization and exposure to a language written in
multiple scripts is extremely valuable for downstream script-agnostic language
identification, while also maintaining competitive performance on naturally
occurring text. | [
-0.174502939,
-0.4003171027,
0.4249172509,
0.2673659623,
-0.1542810798,
0.8313111067,
-0.5646413565,
-0.4053402245,
0.3640146852,
0.0164720453,
-0.5261401534,
-0.3095568419,
-0.4527176619,
0.283210814,
-0.4742717743,
0.5789198279,
-0.3741567135,
-0.0525696687,
0.1745036244,
-0.4007412791,
-0.3263247609,
-0.4910983741,
-0.3677284718,
-0.1678096503,
0.4664249718,
0.1249488741,
0.6828010678,
1.1546801329,
0.2810424268,
0.4447381496,
0.3177296221,
0.1484712809,
-0.0173068251,
0.1448295265,
-0.1497560143,
-0.7728126645,
0.383297354,
0.1645077318,
0.8300101161,
0.7261561155,
-0.4122247994,
0.351038307,
-0.5057451725,
0.3475069404,
-0.7169740796,
0.307651937,
-0.5630951524,
0.3052429259,
-0.669981122,
-0.1617829502,
-0.2763996422,
-0.6529114842,
0.1399869025,
-0.5667830706,
0.1926143169,
-0.1364397258,
0.7555494308,
0.2082660943,
-0.0048877015,
-0.7328112125,
-1.0026422739,
0.8918636441,
-0.345266223,
0.1872882396,
0.3540982604,
0.4467969537,
0.1178973317,
-0.2734572291,
-0.9526098371,
-0.0619610026,
-0.1537484229,
0.1953453124,
0.0993895978,
-0.1880292147,
0.1193449348,
0.5580697656,
-0.3984269798,
0.1591994315,
-0.3415028453,
-0.5774865746,
0.3415448368,
0.1090946198,
0.6157693863,
-0.129295662,
-0.2609213591,
-0.3091145158,
-0.2694333196,
0.1767913401,
0.7311815619,
0.4144785702,
0.0024613161,
0.4907721579,
0.1768363118,
0.7812652588,
0.0505367741,
-0.3362976611,
0.2240235955,
-0.352662921,
-0.0786527023,
0.1412267089,
0.5503000617,
-0.1606965214,
0.4350564182,
-0.1713421047,
0.0015442232,
0.7281230092,
0.2356825769,
-0.2841854692,
0.023473097,
0.0128222993,
-0.1997395307,
-0.3152219653,
-0.1924829036,
-0.9077321291,
-0.6549832225,
-0.3223556876,
0.2626837194,
-0.732024312,
-0.6899338365,
-0.1926180273,
-0.3398990929,
0.7383319139,
0.2455047518,
-1.2345763445,
0.3596766889,
0.2540122271,
0.6219146848,
-0.2462662011,
-0.5592631102,
-0.0908246115,
0.1867733449,
-0.4347777963,
0.6726849079,
-1.0152845383,
-0.2460862696,
0.1449798793,
-0.3354744017,
-0.2956769168,
-0.3627219498,
0.0686839521,
-0.603474021,
0.2932668924,
0.0094889188,
-0.256801784,
-0.1282279789,
-0.0989908129,
-0.4160054624,
0.8190853596,
0.4872265756,
-0.6661951542,
0.5042627454,
-0.0971591994,
-0.4120390415,
0.0944033638,
-0.6546619534,
-0.3019959033,
0.3024327457,
-0.2219778299,
0.1320179999,
0.0758342594,
-0.0587026291,
-0.0881819054,
-0.2656378746,
0.1541135609,
-0.5153694749,
0.5229020119,
0.561701417,
-0.2011420876,
0.0027332492,
-0.9766703844,
0.2109709531,
0.1521552652,
-0.2900931537,
-0.5553367138,
-0.2612618208,
-0.0165081192,
0.1236119047,
0.2241871357,
-0.6567625403,
0.2640037239,
-0.3752709925,
0.2780575752,
0.8216822147,
-0.3874279857,
0.5382620096,
-0.1039051563,
0.5463949442,
0.235777989,
-0.2553659976,
-0.3373217881,
-0.1771784425,
-0.7297626734,
-0.5438749194,
0.3679730296,
0.5922630429,
-0.6408339739,
-0.2305684984,
-0.1131728962,
-0.4612454772,
-0.868347168,
0.3920661211,
0.612172246,
0.1559080034,
0.1595528871,
-0.4581243396,
-0.6744908094,
-0.7843726873,
-0.4635646343,
-0.1451589316,
-0.0047857119,
-0.1499608606,
0.0612801239,
-0.2366845757,
0.878913641,
-0.348641932,
-0.2545919716,
-0.4095036089,
0.1597302705,
0.1356322765,
0.0430800542,
0.573378861,
-0.6732734442,
-0.8964493871,
0.1993246675,
-0.6235104799,
-0.0551655702,
-0.1173037738,
0.3025193214,
0.4220331907,
0.4851953387,
-0.3400828838,
0.6140022874,
0.5160367489,
0.0591764413,
0.3975887597,
-0.5975576043,
-0.0359237529,
-1.0379426479,
-0.0809453055,
-0.0909061059,
-0.0558370873,
-0.7158411741,
0.1109657735,
0.344968468,
-0.1730683595,
-0.1826873869,
0.5310066938,
-0.7766166925,
0.0880776793,
-0.2101511508,
0.137707755,
-0.3973889947,
0.5737987757,
0.3114275336,
0.9969640374,
0.8188088536,
-0.4207933545,
0.1788914949,
-0.0000967348,
-0.1327793896,
0.3448391855,
-0.2622715533,
0.0101744309,
-0.4268509746,
-0.0156340413,
-1.0326915979,
-0.5164439082,
0.0048031537,
-0.5621681809,
0.6686372161,
-0.0848688632,
-0.3175106049,
-0.1868665367,
-0.2571953237,
0.3602529466,
0.6000372767,
-0.3162662983,
0.6343380213,
0.6481137276,
0.0715159699,
-0.7373659015,
-0.7031535506,
-0.173152402,
-0.4532507956,
-0.0086766956,
-0.040764939,
0.1651919931,
-0.2529217303,
-0.3286076486,
-0.3821552098,
-0.1454845667,
-0.2022890449,
0.2554450929,
0.2226980031,
0.0204538181,
0.0362906642,
-0.0941121355,
-0.3541211188,
-0.2534893751,
-0.4571619928,
0.600140214,
-0.1682391763,
-0.4697904885,
-0.40249753,
0.558863163,
0.6056818366,
-0.3450977504,
0.5753029585,
0.9253721833,
-0.4073296487,
-0.195771873,
-0.4957627654,
0.215544194,
-0.4697661996,
0.0203112792,
-0.5507240891,
-0.5924919248,
0.8628669977,
-0.3341921568,
-0.3117030263,
0.4289086163,
0.797231257,
0.2567228377,
0.878651917,
0.8498077393,
-0.3079892993,
0.4900278449,
0.0073845093,
0.1864551604,
-0.4653916359,
0.0039327871,
-0.6539286971,
0.030694345,
-0.8661135435,
-0.3849717677,
-0.0170175806,
-0.1630458832,
0.1481167674,
0.689455092,
-0.4866537154,
0.6039863825,
0.5572389364,
-0.2905667722,
0.192188397,
0.2580382824,
-0.6893779039,
-0.0278214402,
-0.347623229,
-0.4719307125,
1.0624529123,
0.1849940866,
0.7863453627,
0.3203583956,
0.8920801878,
0.2850248218,
0.0742769986,
-0.4013736248,
0.3109440804,
-0.0442761667,
-0.6575963497,
-0.2275373042,
-0.29883793,
-0.8272253275,
0.2081333101,
0.0609842427,
-0.9439113736,
0.3071954846,
-0.159797743,
-0.4694969654,
0.1164798737,
-1.2016062737,
0.3937759399,
0.0298937578,
-0.3591243625,
-0.3202253878,
-0.6983810067,
-0.0265643932,
-0.2788442969,
0.4277591705,
0.1088022813,
-0.0800830722,
0.3603077829,
-0.3263986111,
0.8420487046,
-0.0664109364,
0.1212421507,
0.3678845763,
0.1257815212,
0.196423009,
0.2087617964,
-0.1056597531,
0.0405822098,
0.1212606877,
-0.6522498131,
-0.3870356977,
0.7312965989,
-1.2172805071,
-0.4328098297,
-0.8643183708,
-0.2953662574,
-0.0850613564,
0.717762351,
0.0846376121,
0.5670724511,
0.0795772001,
-0.3811605573,
0.734957099,
-0.1408902407,
0.6779913902,
0.5287888646,
-0.2479845136,
-0.3608074486,
1.0339952707,
0.0578235984,
0.3921612501,
0.2296545506,
0.134871155,
-0.4232758284,
-0.7740502357,
-0.8565065861,
0.1694601029,
-0.7836543322,
0.1275914758,
-0.5196411014,
-0.2017285377,
-0.1508158892,
-0.1817911863,
-0.3625487089,
-0.4576776028,
-0.0369145721,
0.043767985,
0.3150754869,
0.670448482,
-0.1378498226,
0.3023804426,
-0.4289214313,
0.3954203129,
0.3006852865,
0.6717373729,
-0.0260621421,
-0.1239695475,
-0.1174876466,
0.0426602885,
-0.0123024341,
-0.8038187027,
0.3463576138,
0.3782150745,
0.8663935661,
0.2791850269,
-0.1180278435,
0.8357368708,
-0.513104558,
0.4065034986,
0.2268521041,
-0.8102707267,
0.4994384944,
-0.5029190779,
0.4109527469,
0.9148060679,
0.5547538996,
-0.4877409041,
-0.5059577227,
-0.3958804607,
-0.7908500433,
0.7316423059,
0.2216215283,
0.2556213737,
-0.1167121232,
0.4044579864,
0.4669777453,
0.375410974,
-0.4650371075,
-0.4012618065,
-0.3983542025,
-0.3256037235,
-0.033476539,
0.2537190318,
-0.0298612919,
-0.2330270857,
0.0298943408,
-0.1383862942,
0.2676349282,
0.2086377293,
-0.3515241146,
-0.3308444619,
0.1850252748,
0.6277341843,
0.5919160843,
-0.1474535465,
0.4179750383,
0.0606928803,
-0.995800674,
0.2367471308,
-0.0361905247,
-0.0561872981,
-0.0304951854,
0.1775610745,
0.5297041535,
-0.2233360559,
-0.4729514122,
0.1610381901,
-0.3827239275,
0.31662938,
-0.7457172871,
0.2648070157,
-0.1106040701,
-0.0778086483,
0.4728994071,
0.4057469964,
-0.1448097378,
-0.8996403813,
0.1246144623,
0.383112222,
-0.5355241299,
-0.4408144355,
0.4450083673,
-0.102824308,
-0.3660592139,
0.4736416638,
-0.3212755919,
-0.4068754911,
0.3608095646,
0.5118111968,
0.8927711844,
-0.4631797671,
0.2160402685,
0.3305785358,
0.1495310515,
-0.0006259574,
0.1678257734,
-0.2762962282,
-0.6109578013,
-0.3434021175,
-1.0373630524,
-0.4998950064,
-0.2949078977,
-0.5167756081,
0.4401848018,
-0.4991491735,
0.0312641822,
0.3463878334,
0.2092449665,
-0.6726573706,
-0.1166640669,
0.3837551773,
0.7174008489,
-0.8934546113,
1.0471621752,
0.7625110149,
-0.691870749,
-0.8285313249,
0.1163689643,
0.2987344265,
-1.1171488762,
0.196329698,
0.2580353618,
-0.2544935346,
0.2746563852,
-0.1098562852,
-0.9771994948,
1.0485703945,
0.0490546227,
-0.0661802739,
0.0958475396,
0.4132260382,
1.1011134386,
-0.496040076,
0.6716483831,
0.461335361,
0.4568254054,
0.1019685939,
-1.0723695755,
0.0117955012,
-0.2625234723,
0.2370685935,
0.3158130944,
-0.7404034734,
0.6996703744,
-0.2424523383,
-0.6393133402,
0.0368856974,
0.60896945,
0.1133596376,
0.1723010838,
0.2586168051,
0.4850471318,
0.7713340521,
-0.0062222839,
0.9384964705,
-0.1209180504,
0.0534996502,
0.6649935842,
-0.4209502637,
0.5251755714,
0.5274760127,
-0.3306750059,
0.7191572189,
0.374237597,
0.1114395931,
0.6811390519,
0.5312486291,
-0.2532380819,
0.0213510599,
0.0265206303,
-0.3050516844,
0.6759996414,
0.5885717869,
-0.1028746217,
-0.516510129,
0.0326821916,
0.1247213706,
0.3654481471,
-0.1464236975,
0.8581228852,
-0.1422509551,
-0.7328211665,
0.7465596199,
-0.2142491788,
0.6836811304,
-0.984567821,
0.0631878078,
-0.1058155298,
0.512234807,
-0.0345978662,
-0.6181156635,
0.6492421627,
-0.1611166447,
-0.1779507697,
-0.3517490327,
0.7967412472,
-0.513740778,
-0.3438047469,
0.3328616619,
0.4439386129,
-0.0398188233,
0.4500861764,
-0.2336105704,
0.1503711045,
-0.0464368053,
-0.0340441316,
0.8109052181,
0.4020993114,
-0.33292979,
0.6857410669,
0.7040684223,
0.2201772183,
0.2380678505,
-0.0828112885,
0.766435802,
-0.5962641835,
-0.3744847476,
-0.7281144857,
0.1382465512,
-0.182362169,
-0.220362857,
1.0625116825,
0.2871949673,
0.93365556,
-0.3289943039,
1.0390329361,
-0.2136500329,
0.6642053127,
-0.0426641814,
0.7150084376,
-0.1701710224,
0.1138692349,
-0.3175876439,
-0.6453685164,
-0.2590126395,
0.5488233566,
-0.015728917,
-0.1998188049,
0.6811109185,
0.4940530062,
-0.0731855407,
-0.0595223494,
0.199391529,
-0.0672852173,
0.0112636816,
0.2792553008,
0.7520023584,
-0.2292608619,
0.6113106012,
-0.2124214023,
-0.6012467146,
0.1160455868,
-0.7419595122,
-0.8247898817,
-0.7234954238,
-0.2438950241,
-0.2648897469,
-0.1153459474,
0.7473241687,
0.3526944518,
-0.9015855789,
-0.3494056165,
-0.1599957645,
0.1623693109,
-0.3346461356,
-0.1415985078,
0.3160017431,
-0.3350328505,
-0.7739777565,
0.2215544432,
0.5214961171,
-0.0374637209,
-0.6691389084,
0.1997319907,
-0.2623224556,
0.27851367,
0.1708090901,
0.7248554826,
-0.5842184424,
-0.4408780932,
0.1872627288,
-0.2569528222,
-0.0387231931,
0.7607442737,
-0.9701812863,
0.6952283978,
0.6268492341,
0.4460127354,
0.1514704823,
-0.2626374662,
0.5528050661,
-0.8793639541,
0.401232928,
-0.079924643,
0.131330207,
0.2917329073,
-0.1127176657,
0.3407463431,
0.3238748908,
-0.2880745232,
-0.7714937329,
0.5241210461,
-0.9867172241,
0.0766277462,
1.0787774324,
-0.0906974599,
-0.4072240293,
-0.6007798314,
-0.1371507645,
0.3790385425,
-0.2068826705,
0.7762301564,
0.8867118955,
0.048794698,
-0.0010587368,
-0.4893574119,
0.7598079443,
0.007069672,
-0.2166748047,
0.1236175373,
0.0968123451,
0.346631974,
0.8015953302,
0.6991782188,
-0.3814233541,
0.0316739641,
0.1498146355,
-0.0398273245,
0.1451789588,
-0.1226924136,
-0.3929572701,
0.0506357849,
0.0403131843,
-0.1615329087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17888v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17888v1 | CTBench: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Evaluating Language Model Capabilities in Clinical Trial Design | 2024-06-25T18:52:48 | 2024-06-25T18:52:48 | Nafis Neehal, Bowen Wang, Shayom Debopadhaya, Soham Dan, Keerthiram Murugesan, Vibha Anand, Kristin P. Bennett | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | CTBench is introduced as a benchmark to assess language models (LMs) in
aiding clinical study design. Given study-specific metadata, CTBench evaluates
AI models' ability to determine the baseline features of a clinical trial (CT),
which include demographic and relevant features collected at the trial's start
from all participants. These baseline features, typically presented in CT
publications (often as Table 1), are crucial for characterizing study cohorts
and validating results. Baseline features, including confounders and
covariates, are also necessary for accurate treatment effect estimation in
studies involving observational data. CTBench consists of two datasets:
"CT-Repo," containing baseline features from 1,690 clinical trials sourced from
clinicaltrials.gov, and "CT-Pub," a subset of 100 trials with more
comprehensive baseline features gathered from relevant publications. Two
LM-based evaluation methods are developed to compare the actual baseline
feature lists against LM-generated responses. "ListMatch-LM" and
"ListMatch-BERT" use GPT-4o and BERT scores (at various thresholds),
respectively, for evaluation. To establish baseline results, advanced prompt
engineering techniques using LLaMa3-70B-Instruct and GPT-4o in zero-shot and
three-shot learning settings are applied to generate potential baseline
features. The performance of GPT-4o as an evaluator is validated through
human-in-the-loop evaluations on the CT-Pub dataset, where clinical experts
confirm matches between actual and LM-generated features. The results highlight
a promising direction with significant potential for improvement, positioning
CTBench as a useful tool for advancing research on AI in CT design and
potentially enhancing the efficacy and robustness of CTs. | [
-0.4580677748,
-0.8015562892,
0.5223262906,
0.0005291144,
-0.3501034677,
0.1578821838,
-0.2920763493,
-0.3473173082,
-0.147674188,
0.4776640832,
-0.2405084074,
-0.8011882305,
-0.5436600447,
0.1363203973,
-0.4745686352,
0.8656913638,
-0.0296566952,
0.3761819303,
-0.022248324,
-0.3711896539,
-0.8071191311,
-0.4441527426,
-0.5287172198,
-0.2948376238,
0.553299129,
0.2887868583,
0.6541796327,
0.625140965,
0.7512659431,
0.2840360105,
-0.1241834536,
-0.3377244174,
-0.5190374255,
0.1139690951,
-0.0656376183,
-0.631082356,
-0.4357427657,
0.1120060012,
0.4228242934,
0.8445613384,
-0.1176975667,
-0.0153771751,
0.1362779438,
0.4008881748,
-0.8117975593,
-0.0359104127,
-0.4553169608,
0.0621118322,
-0.4009367526,
-0.141192764,
-0.350501895,
-0.7065976262,
0.3682969809,
-0.246659562,
0.4579930902,
-0.054777246,
0.8166493773,
-0.0006391382,
-0.4931261837,
-0.1725521237,
-0.187839523,
0.5995474458,
-0.7872086763,
0.18790631,
0.3170913458,
0.7140532136,
-0.3061569333,
-0.8246563673,
-0.3137747645,
-0.692440033,
-0.2116594315,
0.350407511,
-0.1952429116,
0.5103805661,
0.3844922781,
0.4398236275,
-1.0066254139,
0.204398334,
-0.3763164878,
-0.4208854735,
0.3707368374,
0.2407115847,
0.3189185262,
-0.0993409678,
-0.3998318315,
-0.3524980247,
-0.7157405615,
-0.0604407117,
-0.1172146946,
0.3929779232,
-0.1276537478,
0.4890605211,
-0.2023471892,
0.7351821065,
-0.153901577,
0.0363147706,
0.4476649761,
-0.5079147816,
-0.2773673832,
0.1760958582,
0.6640196443,
0.4002447724,
0.0397248194,
-0.1334308386,
0.0293331407,
0.1393046081,
0.4277991652,
-0.7250523567,
-0.0827245489,
0.2815748751,
-0.5580615401,
-0.3065315187,
-0.0064299628,
-0.7336537242,
-0.4708341062,
-0.1485457122,
0.2171340436,
-0.4744406044,
-0.2330935001,
-0.2397834212,
-0.3626483679,
0.2888359129,
0.3155087233,
-0.3679355979,
0.3602754176,
0.6061148047,
0.9651950598,
-0.4411475956,
-0.2228092998,
-0.5065034628,
-0.1828671992,
-0.5419632792,
0.998390317,
-0.4330649674,
-0.6603240371,
0.1991593391,
-0.0688197613,
-0.0662276447,
-0.582780242,
0.5698586702,
-0.2451288849,
0.2997113168,
-0.3592391312,
-0.7501525879,
-0.0299639683,
0.4745033681,
-0.8232268691,
1.0652412176,
0.4279110134,
-0.606423676,
0.6520204544,
-0.5711112618,
-0.2255845815,
0.2464179397,
-0.3737363815,
-0.3156488538,
0.3937083483,
0.0817551613,
0.0531736948,
-0.4679680765,
0.4511080086,
-0.6100420952,
-0.5266157389,
0.1802750081,
-0.2464080006,
0.7398498654,
0.3907396197,
-0.437012881,
0.3208065033,
-0.7127090693,
0.3612572253,
-0.0127130337,
-0.4226023853,
-0.0446658023,
-0.1887212098,
0.3196029365,
0.2028051466,
0.0199366137,
-0.4797123969,
-0.0145191392,
-0.451019913,
0.2281864733,
0.4895759523,
-0.0882042646,
0.055211816,
-0.28050372,
0.6719923615,
-0.366181761,
0.1160768345,
-0.0995889083,
-0.2087462693,
-0.6412805319,
-0.2546256781,
0.5110747218,
0.3627423644,
-0.5515776873,
0.5774707198,
-0.1624486297,
-0.6861860156,
-0.2868337631,
-0.0760228187,
0.7545363307,
0.5019125938,
0.329146415,
-0.6542637944,
-0.3976018429,
-1.2135629654,
-0.2833783329,
-0.0321934558,
-0.1455879807,
0.1199721545,
0.406059742,
0.2885141373,
0.7843077779,
-0.1302946657,
-0.4185995758,
-0.6491622925,
0.3527502716,
0.1256915182,
0.3746755421,
0.7555680871,
-0.2976601124,
-0.5003374815,
-0.1032158136,
-0.745462954,
-0.3594474494,
0.0084546413,
-0.0535791405,
0.1508468091,
0.4953060746,
-0.3326860368,
0.8324022889,
0.5111253858,
-0.1223904938,
0.3419705331,
-0.2773569226,
0.3083045185,
-0.898434341,
0.5300934911,
-0.3161277175,
-0.0590253435,
-0.5081248283,
0.0569616593,
0.0896998197,
-0.140879035,
-0.4006562233,
0.6224182844,
-0.3659071624,
-0.2319855243,
-0.4397867918,
0.4181074798,
-0.1075470597,
0.2266703993,
-0.1080831662,
0.8954840899,
0.2451795042,
-0.1381530762,
0.0404130183,
0.1390321255,
-0.4247100353,
0.8882504106,
-0.7983071804,
0.2468768507,
0.3991179466,
0.350833714,
-1.0745642185,
-0.0767694414,
-0.1904979497,
-0.3572694063,
0.0753096193,
0.0762902051,
-0.6123404503,
-0.5739485025,
-0.4448540807,
0.3094921708,
0.2012313157,
0.0104675442,
0.5966696143,
0.3018051982,
-0.0791393518,
-0.3959353268,
-0.5857722163,
0.3500693738,
-0.0926841274,
-0.3179515004,
0.3631832004,
0.0174769294,
-0.0998179838,
-0.1329891682,
-0.1706988215,
-0.1356547922,
0.1233207509,
0.1657925546,
0.147742331,
-0.2531215549,
0.1995595545,
-0.09159334,
-0.2930147052,
-0.0720477775,
0.2930061519,
0.7997123599,
-0.1934364885,
-0.5449749231,
-0.6151316762,
0.3424779177,
0.3816564083,
-0.1280014515,
0.2365702838,
0.4901622236,
-0.3567641973,
-0.0302207414,
-0.790169239,
-0.236542806,
-0.4136533737,
0.5484644175,
-0.4177693427,
-0.7722834349,
0.4611684382,
-0.0968011692,
-0.0095145022,
0.4218483567,
0.7827689052,
0.0487262607,
0.9836325049,
0.6004804969,
-0.16479972,
0.5508229733,
0.0454252847,
-0.0468287431,
-0.7015176415,
0.0900675356,
-0.7077408433,
-0.4634850919,
-0.5332151055,
-0.2216872424,
0.5916546583,
0.0086219199,
-0.3662596047,
0.3948210776,
-0.4632079899,
0.3659266829,
0.7534182668,
0.2219749689,
0.2572759688,
-0.3093821108,
-0.5591601133,
-0.001679953,
-0.6198125482,
-0.4482691288,
1.4334115982,
-0.0005736412,
0.3448796868,
-0.1454072744,
0.6390612721,
0.5376445055,
0.537155509,
-0.5844095945,
0.5806633234,
-0.075167723,
-0.9075342417,
0.0197441112,
-0.083628349,
-1.1063730717,
0.1939696819,
-0.0913064554,
-0.8338080645,
0.0601537563,
0.1485174596,
-0.4240339398,
-0.0081806416,
-0.5924979448,
1.1421811581,
-0.6654374003,
-0.4078268409,
-0.5859336853,
-0.6813160181,
0.1314907223,
0.0066441903,
-0.0961474329,
-0.2285539657,
0.0359947942,
0.5851288438,
-0.5501183271,
0.8119325638,
-0.1998112798,
0.306871593,
0.1537687778,
0.34360677,
0.1524072886,
-0.2224048674,
-0.1311453581,
0.2910567522,
0.287358433,
-0.3987389505,
-0.4377055168,
0.5780149102,
-0.7269825935,
-0.531259954,
-0.5637128353,
-0.4790119529,
-0.3936959207,
0.4450324476,
0.094776772,
0.3675675094,
-0.6097739935,
0.5663525462,
0.040721938,
-0.3406562209,
0.1814067513,
0.5910913944,
-0.0288575944,
-0.5761376619,
0.4121465981,
-0.0859203711,
0.4078963697,
0.2431329638,
0.2298837304,
-0.1930651218,
-1.0137239695,
-0.1211209595,
0.015543621,
-0.8792644739,
-0.196949482,
-0.2800156176,
-0.3983451724,
-0.0271338932,
-0.2764993608,
-0.3448996842,
-0.1486797482,
0.2351659983,
-0.0980965123,
0.0423748977,
0.4594156444,
0.0753968433,
0.5518047214,
-0.7216823101,
0.0739587471,
-0.1784064919,
0.3717164993,
-0.2260797173,
-0.3467433453,
-0.2436762154,
-0.1364871711,
-0.5757117271,
-0.7900987267,
0.198320806,
0.027732566,
0.9218367338,
0.3970451653,
-0.1602416039,
0.812928021,
-0.201423496,
0.7278926969,
0.1343646199,
-1.010068655,
0.8711220026,
-0.3541764915,
0.3952620327,
1.0309547186,
-0.0516722836,
-0.4827322662,
-0.452644825,
-0.5704771876,
-0.7909130454,
0.7803127766,
0.4278651178,
-0.2136149704,
0.048283793,
0.2643000484,
0.1628728211,
0.2580011189,
-0.3825048208,
0.1922511607,
-0.1078803912,
-0.3675097227,
0.0325270891,
-0.1663491428,
-0.4538976848,
-0.0302719716,
0.1513553411,
-0.3518568277,
0.1583102643,
0.090895012,
-0.1715508103,
0.0572071671,
0.2266773134,
0.5139783621,
0.9521536827,
-0.5501470566,
-0.0244478099,
0.3894992471,
-0.4681487083,
-0.2617678642,
0.2720919251,
0.0966468453,
-0.1259105504,
0.7939147353,
0.5399195552,
0.2399991602,
-0.9435062408,
0.5391706824,
-0.0741210431,
-0.1980724186,
-0.2769755423,
0.2694097757,
-0.1511817724,
0.1605243534,
0.0786618441,
-0.2132903337,
0.2975964248,
-0.404104501,
0.3719252348,
0.3816869557,
-0.5787246823,
-0.189732939,
0.5215058923,
0.214244768,
-0.0978657976,
0.7603168488,
0.4569390714,
-0.1915249079,
0.9078674316,
0.2926047444,
0.9875455499,
-0.1430494189,
0.0081928782,
0.5758253932,
0.1591805518,
0.1243325993,
0.3445557654,
-0.0212855171,
-0.4893812239,
0.1661601812,
-0.3448859751,
-0.5440911055,
0.153982833,
-0.8401711583,
0.5231250525,
-0.49249354,
-0.4221952856,
0.0177005138,
-0.0071242931,
-0.9422524571,
0.0416324362,
0.207032159,
1.109241128,
-0.4892087579,
0.934528172,
0.4414474964,
-0.65246737,
-0.5337654352,
-0.1502643973,
0.5848228931,
-1.1333681345,
0.5179433823,
0.3133763671,
0.0841950327,
-0.1891741306,
-0.3172228932,
-0.8435541391,
1.2949217558,
0.3125355542,
-0.5935893655,
0.0242601074,
0.4467363954,
0.9267926812,
-0.4462462366,
0.7583090067,
0.8834089041,
0.50055933,
0.0430022478,
-1.2681264877,
0.2056575716,
-0.3142281473,
0.2297958881,
-0.148057878,
-0.493917346,
0.5786251426,
-0.0183253195,
-0.2375902534,
0.4591045082,
0.1153206527,
0.5124970078,
0.2171600014,
0.4708087742,
0.5488645434,
0.535189867,
-0.498519659,
1.1538288593,
-0.6272344589,
0.3743231893,
1.1746073961,
-0.485694766,
0.8664323092,
0.332003206,
-0.281239897,
0.3520681262,
0.7268963456,
-0.2174063027,
0.5821428299,
0.4719483852,
0.1604419798,
-0.2922671139,
-0.138058722,
-0.5667966008,
0.6067869663,
0.3612744808,
-0.4873012006,
-0.6888445616,
-0.0260962658,
0.1700889915,
-0.1663959771,
0.2014208883,
0.8619164824,
0.0309648626,
-0.6883987188,
0.7568374872,
-0.3121953309,
0.014396931,
-0.9615437984,
-0.0810468271,
-0.4190453887,
0.596057415,
0.1191008911,
-0.8360827565,
0.1864715815,
-0.0880734399,
0.28866449,
0.2066698074,
0.3004099727,
0.0261181425,
-0.4779073,
0.5084719062,
0.658270359,
0.0402544364,
-0.081008561,
-0.9767861962,
0.3966996372,
-0.1779578775,
-0.3139225841,
0.3664948046,
0.2104335278,
-0.2898243964,
0.613463819,
0.5143557191,
0.0870712399,
-0.283908546,
0.5271890163,
1.0758725405,
-0.8023099303,
-0.2317497581,
-0.6922570467,
0.4925319552,
-0.3575636148,
-0.714453578,
0.5214248896,
0.7244638205,
0.6573672295,
0.2791547179,
0.9288466573,
-0.2140904516,
0.4377843738,
-0.3271295428,
0.7256717682,
-0.5963327289,
0.185876742,
-0.0913875699,
-0.7598975897,
-0.5850334167,
0.3764565587,
-0.4509415329,
0.2906215787,
1.0404214859,
0.8076510429,
0.1150006428,
0.086447373,
0.3468193412,
0.394353658,
0.6329050064,
0.5979682207,
0.6775751114,
-0.161285013,
0.6299257874,
-0.2897985876,
-0.5217045546,
-0.3454724252,
-0.6953324676,
-1.2423747778,
-0.3103735149,
-0.0570637621,
-0.2564000189,
0.3266459703,
0.7993852496,
0.7618697286,
-1.1479305029,
-0.4785805345,
-0.1042981818,
-0.2960759997,
-0.4794746935,
-0.2173379362,
0.8169974089,
-0.5858960748,
-0.5231997371,
0.2107627988,
0.2944060564,
-0.2735138237,
-0.2023784965,
0.1584790498,
-0.0139725199,
-0.1837130338,
0.3679112494,
0.0733349323,
-1.0212843418,
-0.2636951804,
-0.0236346833,
-0.2391652465,
0.2502413392,
0.998560071,
-0.8550820947,
0.9362383485,
0.5121917725,
0.4818487763,
0.3968316913,
-0.1447218657,
0.8337960243,
-0.2863589823,
0.1785064489,
0.3633606732,
0.5385543108,
0.0378689431,
0.0912358835,
0.6540933251,
0.1751935929,
-0.4529075921,
-0.7434705496,
-0.1068633571,
-1.2664097548,
-0.184293434,
0.6934758425,
-0.1811786145,
0.0111575825,
-0.2494712919,
-0.4039523005,
0.189840436,
-0.2976066172,
1.1127046347,
0.7401847839,
-0.2621038258,
-0.2802398503,
-0.8735864162,
0.4762043953,
0.3668284416,
-0.9378474951,
0.0214345735,
0.5530052185,
0.3018867671,
0.005854791,
0.5807831883,
-0.3929505348,
0.5446263552,
-0.0045212326,
0.3248113692,
0.0006629634,
0.067112878,
-0.08441329,
0.221245572,
-0.0023772353,
-0.0189700443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17876v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17876v1 | ET tu, CLIP? Addressing Common Object Errors for Unseen Environments | 2024-06-25T18:35:13 | 2024-06-25T18:35:13 | Ye Won Byun, Cathy Jiao, Shahriar Noroozizadeh, Jimin Sun, Rosa Vitiello | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.RO | We introduce a simple method that employs pre-trained CLIP encoders to
enhance model generalization in the ALFRED task. In contrast to previous
literature where CLIP replaces the visual encoder, we suggest using CLIP as an
additional module through an auxiliary object detection objective. We validate
our method on the recently proposed Episodic Transformer architecture and
demonstrate that incorporating CLIP improves task performance on the unseen
validation set. Additionally, our analysis results support that CLIP especially
helps with leveraging object descriptions, detecting small objects, and
interpreting rare words. | [
-0.3727164268,
-0.4003276527,
0.5771799684,
0.0193378013,
-0.3422507644,
-0.0102189435,
0.106377773,
-0.49884969,
0.2380581051,
0.2297399491,
-0.6710373163,
-0.5539559722,
-0.7193125486,
0.3313427269,
-0.4081025124,
0.5964500904,
-0.2214114219,
-0.2811228037,
-0.3953132033,
-0.1336880773,
-0.4828383625,
-0.5741180778,
-0.1980757266,
-0.0177471675,
-0.0202606153,
0.6006869674,
0.671010375,
0.5994972587,
0.5140586495,
0.2961064875,
-0.0522880778,
0.5556364655,
-0.2823480666,
-0.1031186655,
-0.2085587531,
-0.5192728639,
-0.484954834,
-0.4538705349,
0.4010873735,
0.6112229228,
0.0091428431,
0.0544917136,
0.1893109232,
0.3428273201,
-1.1575204134,
0.1475842595,
-0.2794460654,
0.4268097281,
-0.2181695253,
-0.0614218637,
-0.1486960799,
0.2164310664,
0.1581178904,
-1.1327822208,
0.6293448806,
0.1454348266,
1.0000216961,
0.4006793499,
-0.1079642475,
-0.0695765167,
-0.970925808,
1.0286254883,
-0.1531943679,
0.4638780355,
0.3897861838,
0.3423663974,
0.1338936239,
-1.1874824762,
-0.6281458139,
0.1997484267,
-0.0675338507,
0.2695668042,
-0.7857354879,
0.2758878469,
0.4166823328,
0.1507929415,
0.1693470478,
-0.2536464036,
-0.5656831861,
-0.3259163499,
0.1021884903,
0.269978255,
0.5167802572,
-0.0858564302,
-0.1361208707,
-0.5147601962,
-0.5008544922,
0.171760872,
0.1757395267,
-0.2101851851,
-0.1135562211,
0.5652314425,
-0.1713542342,
0.6526098847,
0.1751260906,
0.0928963199,
0.2204166353,
-0.1511621922,
0.0594744422,
-0.1984184086,
0.1374889463,
0.9518331289,
0.1502256989,
-0.2055488974,
-0.3389588594,
0.3396542072,
0.4669901133,
-0.7592213154,
-0.4844104052,
-0.1075896248,
-0.4601849914,
0.1001761779,
0.2947326601,
-0.5459114313,
0.2843462229,
-0.1235485822,
0.6271299124,
-0.3974895775,
0.185821712,
0.3592831492,
-0.6626176834,
-0.0217267387,
0.714201808,
-0.6924084425,
0.7441404462,
0.7209178805,
0.9843219519,
-0.2568425238,
-0.5041043162,
-0.9409120679,
0.5479286313,
-0.3512583375,
1.0867004395,
-0.4781329334,
-0.4380138516,
0.1441918015,
0.6098262668,
0.2707680762,
-0.7594194412,
0.7115619779,
-0.1966443956,
-0.0029183666,
-0.2849210203,
-0.3935259283,
-0.5663019419,
0.2377374768,
-0.729498446,
0.9681605101,
0.1738260686,
-0.5095384717,
0.507116735,
-0.7812953591,
-0.2935903072,
0.0631094351,
-0.1761364788,
-0.3553038239,
0.2798492908,
0.852176249,
0.3231235445,
0.2869184017,
-0.3035130799,
-0.3501942456,
-0.6927830577,
-0.0153564336,
-0.0972852781,
0.0848373473,
-0.1163568795,
0.0481992289,
0.1820412278,
-0.5830794573,
-0.1236430183,
-0.0298026279,
-0.0598403625,
-0.7229850292,
-0.0509804673,
0.1684723645,
-0.3712836802,
0.1104595959,
-0.7848927379,
0.0655040517,
-0.1315169483,
0.3084966242,
0.6216844916,
0.185216561,
0.392023474,
-0.5426775217,
0.7257103324,
-0.0584395379,
0.1694433242,
-0.2733927369,
-0.4367711842,
-0.680232048,
-0.4272725284,
0.039780017,
0.3208708167,
-0.7052183151,
0.4167187512,
-0.0985133871,
0.0146775907,
-0.4236057997,
-0.115024209,
0.1971362978,
0.3272940516,
0.4730180502,
-0.3422475457,
-0.8757191896,
-0.900408268,
0.0241999384,
0.2857497036,
-0.7369766831,
0.3032588363,
0.5863691568,
-0.481688261,
1.3063777685,
-0.8533920646,
-0.4422262907,
-0.1123315692,
0.0652297586,
0.1616696566,
0.5418138504,
0.5941289663,
-0.6216256618,
-0.1842070222,
-0.2507235706,
-0.6502032876,
0.1351552159,
0.2455726117,
0.1897524297,
-0.2654219866,
0.5244560242,
-0.5729807615,
0.6549813747,
0.1891660392,
-0.0671591684,
0.2544738948,
-0.4726655781,
0.0771873221,
-0.5845969915,
-0.1468409449,
-0.3319467902,
-0.3930871487,
-0.5605326295,
-0.0370880403,
0.1005771384,
-0.305015564,
-0.6713645458,
0.3203882277,
-0.5101448894,
-0.4455878139,
-0.569216311,
-0.1617358327,
0.3452356756,
0.4742462933,
0.2728847861,
0.8816923499,
0.6897167563,
-0.9317091703,
0.2121606469,
0.7660367489,
-0.3244173825,
0.5535513163,
-1.0594038963,
0.5365945697,
-0.581788063,
0.0122692157,
-0.6406652331,
-0.4074159265,
0.3066261113,
-0.2986695468,
0.1500697881,
-0.2758572698,
-0.0752377063,
-0.447012037,
-0.6713655591,
0.4237262607,
0.544670403,
-0.8444969058,
0.8222237825,
0.3264141083,
0.3708360195,
-0.7792806029,
-0.6905032396,
-0.3450615108,
-0.20777753,
-0.4689290524,
0.550450325,
0.0439537019,
-0.1182369664,
0.4382441342,
-0.4979161024,
-0.184160769,
0.2890565693,
0.5415099859,
0.2596027553,
-0.2605492771,
-0.0012745789,
0.0562872179,
0.0096742762,
-0.1300977319,
0.0468571223,
0.4473541081,
-0.2243601084,
-0.5727739334,
-0.2049948573,
0.5286984444,
0.3791051507,
0.1005488932,
0.3244495988,
0.3292093575,
-0.6436682343,
-0.4299176037,
-0.1898430586,
-0.2901913524,
-0.5617604256,
0.8659273982,
-0.3579708934,
-0.7127197385,
0.6097939014,
-0.1640173048,
-0.2632005513,
0.3949618042,
-0.1035660803,
-0.226525262,
0.9309142232,
1.1402343512,
0.1825377047,
0.3791772723,
-0.4811424613,
0.0043970435,
-1.2964465618,
-0.0635290891,
-0.2572112381,
-0.2996141911,
0.0463972874,
-0.7842277288,
0.490683198,
0.7421426177,
-0.1533855647,
0.4745738506,
-0.677550137,
0.7056587338,
0.7712412477,
0.3024409413,
0.2987238765,
0.1429686397,
0.1981388777,
-0.2230462879,
-0.8055679798,
-0.51486516,
1.2035284042,
0.4525284171,
0.935323298,
-0.0539996289,
0.6777781248,
0.5266371369,
0.1947055906,
-1.1161205769,
0.5316846371,
-0.2253519893,
-0.2354573905,
-0.3203020692,
0.3253135681,
-0.9455816746,
0.2698040307,
-0.0789168552,
-0.7309631109,
0.4898347259,
0.3688527644,
-0.7325322628,
0.1628525108,
-0.4631927907,
0.8560749888,
-0.0297419466,
0.0500098281,
-0.1906516701,
-0.1754543185,
0.1179868579,
0.15946275,
-0.1240697429,
0.0421555676,
-0.48670277,
1.0016247034,
-0.4888056517,
0.7673287988,
0.0109713878,
0.4253504872,
0.4725170135,
-0.1296396852,
0.8162157536,
-0.0757302791,
0.5990038514,
0.1828252077,
-0.1005227044,
-0.0777314678,
-0.8193994761,
-0.0868078321,
-0.8048668504,
-0.4882653654,
-0.3346795738,
-0.5239816308,
-0.0956460238,
0.0380531028,
0.6052147746,
0.6278253794,
-0.3077597618,
0.1735967845,
0.3853675425,
-0.0325942151,
0.4400643408,
0.6699976921,
-0.1535921842,
-0.3929442167,
0.5846853852,
-0.141264677,
-0.0439815558,
0.3890065551,
0.0666982234,
-0.0819150731,
-0.7394688129,
-0.2058956474,
-0.1027574465,
-1.12246418,
-0.2456747442,
-0.8320593834,
0.1282736659,
-0.1791026741,
-0.3825079203,
-0.4943357706,
-0.3572470248,
-0.4880504906,
-0.2866775095,
0.453565985,
0.8286371827,
-0.3516302407,
0.5939075947,
-1.1941205263,
0.4576179683,
0.7161122561,
0.0229066629,
-0.0184029788,
-0.4578475356,
-0.0443775803,
-0.1572615802,
-0.2996611595,
-0.516982913,
0.3708668649,
0.5400963426,
0.7535015941,
0.5966575742,
0.2716040909,
0.7542988658,
-0.8259008527,
0.7443187833,
0.2457887977,
-1.1639239788,
0.6434186101,
-0.1221502796,
0.2056081444,
0.3353224099,
0.4512840509,
-0.7199974656,
-0.2904803157,
-0.651006043,
-0.8432999849,
0.8428768516,
0.1727739573,
0.1311534494,
-0.2560524046,
-0.1698754877,
0.0047496068,
0.0853934065,
-0.3956789672,
-0.2572862804,
-0.3105785549,
-0.045174785,
0.1977161169,
-0.3953851461,
-0.400549829,
-0.2782712281,
0.2493031919,
-0.2222887725,
0.6146685481,
0.6255921721,
-0.400877893,
-0.2770376503,
0.0392304882,
0.6786257029,
0.6589651108,
-0.5275751948,
0.1653910726,
0.380485028,
-0.7683176398,
0.1138512567,
-0.1121034622,
-0.3439470828,
0.4469045997,
0.6910567284,
0.9107068181,
0.558903873,
-0.7141955495,
0.6730978489,
0.0884351581,
0.0184383579,
-0.5846839547,
0.0158958603,
-0.2221282423,
0.1541524827,
0.6337500215,
0.4248909354,
0.3157050312,
-0.6260793805,
0.689242363,
0.3150261939,
-0.29776752,
-0.629314959,
0.5876086354,
0.324403882,
-0.4828246832,
0.3811536431,
-0.259373188,
-0.9668534994,
0.7416110635,
0.6808046103,
0.8520537019,
-0.0088821454,
-0.0018618082,
0.2830144465,
0.2837848365,
-0.4849726558,
0.1180101782,
-0.3347637057,
-1.2141450644,
-0.3675573468,
-0.0563785359,
-0.8757255077,
-0.0220069177,
-0.8461965322,
0.2519035637,
-0.3386766315,
0.0987291932,
-0.2939466834,
-0.7097119093,
-0.7951635122,
-0.2031465173,
0.0425108224,
0.7019492388,
-0.8234392405,
0.5604669452,
1.0292630196,
-0.0414000452,
-0.7488132715,
0.0662688091,
-0.3068456948,
-0.8954185843,
0.926609993,
0.3877133429,
-0.386687994,
-0.3540553749,
-0.5629682541,
-1.0449774265,
0.816564858,
0.2107620388,
-0.5123289227,
-0.0566435009,
-0.2625215054,
0.2433545738,
-0.359602809,
0.496561408,
0.2869608998,
0.1244813874,
0.1327003837,
-0.8236072659,
-0.1598114222,
-0.0764027908,
-0.0171784796,
0.1559450626,
-0.2704478502,
1.0774184465,
-0.1098261327,
-0.5661721826,
0.0500197895,
0.9078989029,
0.0673701316,
0.3856061101,
0.5447257757,
0.5613596439,
0.8973462582,
0.2367234826,
1.1139985323,
-0.0973378867,
0.4094614387,
1.3591446877,
-0.2866895795,
0.6565788388,
0.3973070979,
-0.4105818272,
0.3437022865,
0.14475137,
-0.2600871623,
0.9261142612,
-0.068810977,
-0.23442702,
-0.3790766895,
-0.2381284386,
-0.4102214575,
0.5002934337,
0.2764769495,
-0.0652477443,
-0.4353046119,
0.5800071955,
-0.3694548607,
0.1336858869,
-0.7407227755,
0.4190551639,
0.0168697219,
-0.3889537752,
0.3508287966,
-0.0524551906,
1.1434572935,
-0.4703228474,
-0.6157242656,
-0.0817024782,
0.57623595,
-0.0331997722,
-0.694966197,
0.6099268198,
-0.1284464747,
-0.123567678,
0.0235506669,
1.123917222,
-0.0781043544,
-0.3887507319,
0.1926711053,
0.1734885871,
0.2700513303,
-0.3519624174,
-0.0555768237,
0.0396655835,
-0.1579014808,
0.2502831519,
0.0275153629,
0.4824471772,
0.051869344,
0.6123157144,
0.2619379163,
-0.1898243725,
-0.0443850793,
-0.3516946435,
0.8231716752,
-0.6311246753,
-0.6730360389,
-0.4698818326,
0.2387581766,
-0.1836704463,
-0.3080855012,
0.9358344078,
0.5644216537,
1.1104948521,
-0.8908547759,
0.4947572649,
0.0516807474,
0.7878834009,
-0.4575843215,
0.1463957131,
-0.1389055103,
0.1019841656,
-0.3789688945,
-0.9986495972,
0.0081126317,
0.9589085579,
-0.1709986627,
-0.5616189837,
0.8977345824,
0.4617411494,
-0.4203012884,
-0.0656095743,
0.4757013023,
-0.4042411447,
-0.0543079861,
0.7938017249,
1.3641716242,
-0.6494790912,
0.572934866,
-0.5461592078,
0.0328469165,
-0.0292360596,
-0.8694594502,
-1.078858614,
-0.1348145902,
-0.5621752143,
-0.1236705184,
0.0294368267,
0.9845675826,
0.9224476218,
-0.9309905171,
0.0324000008,
-0.1010103226,
0.1429133117,
-0.5460922718,
-0.1668066084,
0.431363523,
0.0834835544,
-0.9917054772,
0.5952028036,
0.1370632648,
0.2708616555,
0.3688319325,
-0.2151031047,
0.4019618928,
-0.2513860166,
0.4856118858,
0.5308822989,
-0.5290543437,
-0.8939002156,
-0.0388957225,
0.4812884629,
0.3078801632,
0.9160778522,
-0.9342277646,
0.1315694749,
0.3223024011,
0.6146954298,
0.7307572365,
0.1860255301,
0.7311796546,
-0.7951253653,
0.5530045033,
0.4507064819,
0.5403819084,
0.2200410068,
-0.3575953543,
0.676324904,
0.3936201632,
-0.161760658,
-0.9121922851,
0.3375698328,
-1.0316005945,
-0.2505653203,
0.6667739153,
-0.4170224667,
-0.5025283694,
-0.3800893128,
-0.1533815414,
-0.0056506619,
-0.4718369246,
0.4476159513,
0.4802251756,
-0.0768347234,
-0.3894278705,
-0.3618143797,
0.6436953545,
0.340067327,
-0.7032319307,
-0.3467153311,
0.3520467877,
0.3823754787,
0.6068378091,
0.4164219499,
0.3073028624,
0.7169572711,
0.1280147135,
0.0910976827,
-0.5277802348,
-0.4353795648,
-0.4321305752,
0.217783913,
-0.1073601171,
-1.2221511602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17875v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17875v1 | Cloaked Classifiers: Pseudonymization Strategies on Sensitive Classification Tasks | 2024-06-25T18:30:25 | 2024-06-25T18:30:25 | Arij Riabi, Menel Mahamdi, Virginie Mouilleron, Djamé Seddah | cs.CL | cs.CL | Protecting privacy is essential when sharing data, particularly in the case
of an online radicalization dataset that may contain personal information. In
this paper, we explore the balance between preserving data usefulness and
ensuring robust privacy safeguards, since regulations like the European GDPR
shape how personal information must be handled. We share our method for
manually pseudonymizing a multilingual radicalization dataset, ensuring
performance comparable to the original data. Furthermore, we highlight the
importance of establishing comprehensive guidelines for processing sensitive
NLP data by sharing our complete pseudonymization process, our guidelines, the
challenges we encountered as well as the resulting dataset. | [
-0.2610291541,
-0.4746588171,
-0.1353425533,
0.2927823067,
0.1797545999,
0.3939112127,
-0.2146229297,
-0.7533491254,
0.0457335897,
0.5858486891,
-0.1407087892,
-0.5562659502,
-0.6642715931,
-0.2041772306,
-0.3793453574,
1.3713618517,
0.153129667,
0.0407141335,
0.2476113886,
-0.030307835,
-0.0105527733,
-0.940308392,
-0.6047328115,
0.2335376889,
0.8343116641,
-0.0128026782,
0.6462269425,
0.7726997137,
0.4315621257,
0.3557296395,
-0.1013395861,
-0.0570903607,
-0.2521503568,
0.3096520901,
-0.2930827439,
-0.5320551991,
-0.2681008875,
0.1333447248,
0.5372601748,
0.618444562,
-0.1980508268,
0.1900370419,
0.0669142678,
0.4809544384,
-0.8244996071,
0.0902875736,
-0.3129453659,
0.3152386248,
-0.5630378723,
-0.0434785262,
-0.4986438453,
-0.5638387799,
-0.0547010861,
-0.5260055065,
0.8230543137,
0.0796403512,
0.6681520939,
0.0246803816,
-0.3081648648,
-0.0599459633,
-1.1326502562,
0.790843606,
-0.2299653143,
0.1897509247,
0.8012743592,
0.4634665549,
0.3265433609,
-0.8525209427,
-0.0241856501,
0.2238426059,
0.0027387396,
-0.0285566803,
-0.246396184,
0.1366877705,
0.5418368578,
0.4604937434,
-0.3898899555,
0.2363402545,
-0.6537060738,
-0.800668478,
1.0019803047,
-0.0137804206,
0.0088102063,
0.103421174,
-0.4341894984,
-0.1473068297,
-0.4660375714,
0.2332254052,
1.1083139181,
0.1489421427,
0.0580362268,
0.5391591191,
-0.2446455359,
0.3422170877,
-0.089961879,
0.0695435107,
0.2775601149,
-0.3714379668,
0.1142386049,
-0.0715200603,
0.702126801,
0.34692204,
0.0431559384,
-0.4317650497,
-0.2960572243,
0.0670184419,
0.4125700891,
-0.6046891212,
-0.3118168712,
0.0853598118,
-0.3895744085,
-0.4380219877,
0.3097915053,
-0.8650910854,
-0.5682338476,
-0.108584024,
0.2682393491,
0.0609513372,
-0.0676830783,
0.3281643689,
-0.4310459793,
0.184884429,
0.2763256431,
-1.0748935938,
0.6775225997,
0.7502045631,
0.6825534701,
-0.3470136821,
0.1860571951,
-0.0505746715,
0.2965221107,
-0.2052643895,
0.1546044946,
-0.1860409677,
-0.2190629244,
0.221631065,
-0.0469638072,
-0.0712025389,
-0.3379555047,
0.7938694954,
-0.6446120739,
0.4212681949,
-0.2800791562,
-0.6287486553,
-0.2323666066,
0.1210840791,
-0.8080503345,
0.9176694751,
0.0832504183,
-1.2627922297,
0.3673349321,
-0.6351266503,
-0.3163049221,
0.3672476709,
-0.0571216606,
-0.7308380604,
-0.2837968171,
-0.016464429,
0.9142858982,
0.297660917,
0.0944100916,
-0.1998642236,
-0.2496350557,
0.4694787562,
-0.2159603089,
1.0957446098,
0.1936440021,
-0.6367510557,
0.1530736536,
-0.4973252714,
-0.1286597997,
-0.0816614479,
-0.1895000041,
-0.3881826103,
-0.0347331874,
0.5559453964,
0.087638855,
0.339237541,
-0.8120151162,
0.0762395412,
-0.2461225688,
0.4192224145,
1.0863856077,
0.1901393831,
0.3766796589,
-0.7544292212,
0.6671047211,
-0.1165758744,
0.6675730348,
0.1856122464,
-0.8366718888,
-0.7356029749,
-0.5414609313,
0.3444465697,
0.6957166195,
-0.4605267644,
0.3941595256,
0.0431814529,
-0.4079555273,
-0.2325311601,
-0.1152024865,
0.4800595045,
0.2994737923,
0.1312845647,
-0.0559098646,
-0.5730864406,
-1.0632275343,
-0.5302001238,
0.1689400077,
-0.1481495351,
0.4772951305,
0.2939619422,
-0.3949014544,
0.5953194499,
-0.5742612481,
-0.5037541986,
-0.1515015364,
0.0425870568,
-0.2189370096,
0.7538004518,
0.5682586432,
-1.1994231939,
-0.4502763152,
0.0477612391,
-0.5634983182,
0.3460920155,
-0.1728211343,
-0.0585403182,
0.0218076166,
0.5430040956,
-0.1283907592,
0.5244522691,
0.1987679154,
-0.2472623587,
0.1389483958,
-0.0330860913,
0.1335308999,
-0.9977886677,
0.0479178168,
-0.0285221953,
-0.6224879026,
-1.1092826128,
0.3600217104,
-0.0897479951,
-0.0017312444,
-0.5123654604,
0.3571232259,
-0.0460622497,
0.3847260475,
0.2053325176,
-0.4317762554,
-0.2710162997,
0.3022347987,
-0.0874487907,
0.5543509722,
0.8329998255,
-0.4816994369,
0.2223248333,
0.249008283,
-0.1875026822,
0.1069202423,
-0.4504852295,
0.3987666965,
-0.1356898397,
-0.052354116,
-0.6083321571,
-0.6085191965,
0.6679233313,
-0.3097365797,
0.5094572902,
0.0175324455,
-0.6220314503,
-0.0213130992,
-0.8594412208,
0.6441258788,
0.4442666173,
-0.3542106748,
0.575209558,
0.780708015,
-0.009485241,
-0.9358400702,
-0.5640445352,
0.0358847044,
-0.6628254652,
-0.2652353346,
0.4769171774,
-0.1935195029,
-0.0834068507,
-0.3732105792,
0.038933102,
-0.349721998,
0.4389605224,
0.6618458033,
0.2744066417,
0.3631876111,
-0.2111521065,
0.0709879473,
-0.1752477437,
0.4411577284,
-0.0275693554,
0.4049969912,
0.0789854974,
-0.0389414392,
-0.760486424,
0.5635109544,
-0.1401528269,
0.1367659867,
0.8862487078,
0.6751476526,
-0.5791537762,
-0.4097966254,
-0.6611870527,
-0.1741196364,
-0.5082393289,
-0.1914184988,
-0.0721116662,
-1.191601038,
0.822840929,
0.0222262498,
0.167006731,
0.2654143274,
0.4035055339,
-0.1340429485,
0.949848175,
1.1226191521,
-0.1746930182,
0.5043754578,
-0.2706671655,
0.2207003236,
-0.5897292495,
-0.6315842867,
-0.6727974415,
-0.2214036733,
-1.1126756668,
-0.2208162397,
0.2927172184,
-0.194979772,
0.0620872565,
0.2740476429,
-0.7407518625,
0.6471272111,
0.5242416263,
0.5415272713,
0.0751584768,
0.1348006129,
0.3093701899,
-0.3068308234,
-0.4868101478,
-0.4411541522,
1.3617827892,
0.516685605,
0.7240030766,
0.0988825634,
0.910199523,
0.4772702157,
0.175190717,
-0.6756590605,
0.5075253248,
0.0132131651,
-0.8409790397,
-0.2798206806,
-0.5390332937,
-1.1120646,
0.0119539546,
0.01692985,
-0.7985524535,
0.4072464705,
-0.0270608868,
-0.1467057317,
0.1321269274,
-0.3584046662,
0.4684431255,
0.3171799481,
-0.295552671,
0.0432169102,
-1.0290704966,
0.3937608004,
-0.4419693351,
0.3752604425,
0.1026100591,
-0.2310586572,
1.2950716019,
-0.0173278581,
1.1865085363,
-0.3931986392,
0.3280111849,
-0.2682262659,
-0.1969794035,
0.1063505486,
-0.0385230556,
0.0720585361,
0.4942192733,
-0.0142622786,
-0.4944853187,
-0.3797986209,
0.4505567551,
-0.886932075,
-0.6717885137,
-0.6380212307,
-0.3693609536,
-0.0903757364,
0.2575621009,
0.5728251338,
-0.0865975693,
-0.0359056443,
0.3374978602,
1.1558178663,
0.1138638183,
0.4719360173,
0.1693982929,
-0.0138676409,
-0.3685193062,
1.0025131702,
0.38784495,
0.1032610014,
0.3033048809,
0.3839488029,
-0.2081879377,
-0.5434072018,
-0.1381282359,
0.1026127562,
-0.8140547276,
-0.2752318978,
-0.7842273712,
-0.4675503671,
-0.3045784235,
-0.3547371924,
-0.0680577978,
-0.8825665712,
-0.3474282324,
-0.2240258008,
0.1967079788,
0.8382112384,
-0.1770303249,
0.1496758759,
-0.4705711603,
0.4402150512,
0.0709614456,
0.1453651786,
-0.4596127272,
-0.3344700038,
-0.2518595159,
-0.152691558,
-0.1734242886,
-0.7087984681,
0.2614459097,
0.450165242,
0.6206874847,
0.6078820825,
0.3731144667,
0.1138689592,
-0.308349818,
0.7752252221,
-0.1368932724,
-0.9829479456,
0.4269152284,
-0.4026612639,
-0.3861153722,
0.4924832284,
0.9840133786,
-0.490604043,
-0.6122589707,
-0.6874170899,
-1.0021669865,
0.5955874324,
0.3714966774,
0.3891132772,
0.2766287923,
0.539840579,
0.3468082845,
0.4276098907,
-0.8951804638,
-0.5668036342,
-0.1742586941,
-0.0583621226,
-0.0294926483,
-0.0895075798,
-0.886294961,
-0.3181884587,
0.5348727107,
0.1307831258,
0.0301013514,
0.0220650211,
0.2116114497,
0.3081376255,
-0.0239123981,
0.3154090941,
0.3457782269,
0.1707656085,
0.2012876123,
-0.189079538,
-1.0190258026,
0.1592654139,
0.1023519039,
-0.6063123345,
-0.1971156895,
0.2204437703,
0.3097100258,
0.1380241662,
-0.2537355125,
1.1071219444,
-0.2482994199,
-0.3270167112,
-0.3793108463,
0.3324955404,
-0.541264236,
-0.0533471219,
0.3393780291,
0.4389545918,
0.6784228683,
-0.0059655537,
0.2900828123,
0.4643988311,
0.1050325856,
-0.4461761713,
0.8464820385,
-0.3740920126,
-0.2970283031,
0.271332562,
-0.0645350739,
-0.6580988169,
0.1908419281,
0.3248683512,
0.9493535757,
-0.8412953615,
0.4765429497,
0.1196959913,
0.3569411039,
-0.1371980906,
0.3607199788,
-0.5376421213,
-0.6253786683,
0.0633686483,
-0.4596737623,
-0.453700155,
-0.2190639079,
-1.2717968225,
0.0288416017,
-1.0939221382,
-0.1992780566,
0.32182917,
-0.1696098149,
-0.4877302945,
0.0738893449,
-0.1497416347,
0.3968120515,
-0.99888587,
0.6003668904,
0.3287623227,
0.0437273234,
-0.539064765,
-0.2922188342,
0.0462815687,
-0.2346259952,
0.3860770464,
0.3120994568,
-0.0725288168,
-0.2269151062,
-0.6702678204,
-0.5952140689,
0.7478628755,
0.2482907921,
-0.4381686151,
0.0185690839,
0.4731668234,
0.6765719652,
0.1925141811,
-0.6006154418,
0.1601157486,
0.3271899819,
-0.0231667645,
-0.6166017652,
0.0501669608,
-0.2281007767,
0.0131247109,
0.1318878829,
-0.6086339951,
0.8368974328,
0.2033857107,
-0.5080131888,
-0.2218592912,
0.3369221985,
-0.4136662483,
0.4370333254,
0.1601384729,
0.3610044122,
1.0269856453,
-0.2148626298,
0.9272249341,
0.067212075,
0.2185708731,
0.8327379227,
-0.1188426092,
0.6343466043,
0.2244012207,
-0.1120539084,
0.0048294412,
0.6052782536,
-0.1920258552,
0.4801491797,
0.0659301803,
-0.7059493661,
0.0682512969,
-0.1012014598,
-0.2763329744,
0.3837231398,
0.2175836861,
-0.3471515477,
0.1792552024,
0.5485490561,
0.169462353,
0.1870277077,
-0.2313734591,
1.0434207916,
-0.4296013117,
0.0407460369,
0.1410186887,
0.3076393604,
0.757835269,
-0.4072853923,
0.2669316828,
0.1295624822,
0.1880352944,
-0.6059889197,
-0.4776486754,
0.6332266927,
-0.1679442972,
-0.2378670722,
-0.5929045081,
0.6091948748,
-0.1213327348,
-0.4170334041,
0.0385594293,
0.0494214408,
0.1800672114,
-0.0022986124,
-0.5887530446,
0.0261659771,
-0.0787551403,
-0.2723815739,
0.6404141188,
0.0307969358,
-0.3194585741,
0.8010110259,
0.8352114558,
0.1647586375,
0.5334428549,
0.0751688853,
1.2071987391,
-0.5143089294,
-0.5398826599,
-0.7515615821,
0.3372049034,
-0.1815506965,
-0.2448939383,
1.3740262985,
1.0105669498,
1.1493031979,
-0.1550548226,
0.5844895244,
0.235485822,
0.6802548766,
-0.2974339128,
1.0822582245,
0.1036720201,
0.2031341046,
0.0014092476,
-0.7845692635,
-0.7969871759,
0.5930903554,
0.0169359148,
-0.0686675534,
0.1511218399,
0.7559985518,
0.1339787245,
0.0399832726,
0.2128764093,
-0.1206263378,
0.4696246982,
-0.0424117893,
0.6896830201,
-0.6603753567,
-0.3002413809,
-0.804620564,
-0.3329178691,
0.1551678628,
-0.5467560291,
-1.0912154913,
-0.879127562,
-0.657974124,
-0.3270608783,
-0.0346114077,
0.4773217142,
0.9484210014,
-0.9184372425,
-0.1337442845,
-0.0307061113,
0.1059547365,
-0.2780969739,
-0.2853166461,
0.1952341795,
0.0742494687,
-0.759482801,
0.1614040434,
0.1176746413,
0.2882380784,
-0.4861608744,
0.2708401084,
0.0599108636,
0.1392419636,
0.3242029846,
0.3967215717,
-0.5432787538,
-0.1506044418,
-0.2216899991,
-0.050033275,
-0.1182301641,
1.0625485182,
-0.4566690028,
0.6636309028,
0.1391827166,
0.7149731517,
0.6657268405,
0.0513255075,
0.0080235517,
-1.0922510624,
0.3927846253,
0.8673362732,
0.0093686255,
0.3691717386,
-0.891331315,
0.3207806945,
0.1029941589,
-0.7291103601,
-1.068505168,
0.1277370304,
-1.07977736,
0.0133444034,
0.8164868355,
-0.67342031,
-0.129503563,
-0.7554761767,
-0.2755857408,
0.0395498686,
-0.1045476794,
0.9168549776,
0.5154892206,
-0.0799027458,
-0.1189399809,
-0.3589842916,
1.0371917486,
-0.1477378458,
-0.8375355005,
0.144502148,
0.2905409932,
0.2610184848,
0.2960079312,
0.3011850119,
-0.232348606,
-0.0038834715,
-0.0902125239,
-0.3215640485,
-0.0019572244,
-0.5196994543,
-0.6496685743,
0.51329422,
-0.2952201962,
-0.1398037374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17873v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17873v1 | Improving Arithmetic Reasoning Ability of Large Language Models through Relation Tuples, Verification and Dynamic Feedback | 2024-06-25T18:21:00 | 2024-06-25T18:21:00 | Zhongtao Miao, Kaiyan Zhao, Yoshimasa Tsuruoka | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Current representations used in reasoning steps of large language models can
mostly be categorized into two main types: (1) natural language, which is
difficult to verify; and (2) non-natural language, usually programming code,
which is difficult for people who are unfamiliar with coding to read. In this
paper, we propose to use a semi-structured form to represent reasoning steps of
large language models. Specifically, we use relation tuples, which are not only
human-readable but also machine-friendly and easier to verify than natural
language. We implement a framework that includes three main components: (1)
introducing relation tuples into the reasoning steps of large language models;
(2) implementing an automatic verification process of reasoning steps with a
local code interpreter based on relation tuples; and (3) integrating a simple
and effective dynamic feedback mechanism, which we found helpful for
self-improvement of large language models. The experimental results on various
arithmetic datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our method in improving
the arithmetic reasoning ability of large language models. The source code is
available at https://github.com/gpgg/art. | [
-0.0539017618,
-0.9799689651,
0.5782262087,
0.2279934734,
-0.1147944629,
0.2950355411,
-0.2594280541,
-0.5323753357,
-0.1110492572,
0.4080614746,
-0.0747389868,
-0.3337309062,
-0.3321408927,
0.3182546496,
-0.2358471304,
0.6046469808,
-0.1077328846,
0.1554521024,
-0.4284571409,
-0.2579785883,
-0.2272158116,
-0.7484347224,
-0.7236058712,
-0.484403789,
0.0013815294,
0.286914587,
0.8571245074,
0.6038898826,
0.358074218,
0.5270765424,
-0.2065063566,
0.5314747095,
-0.3385241926,
0.042651616,
-0.0550652482,
-0.6208183765,
-0.6003898382,
-0.3151631653,
0.9327561855,
0.8709099293,
-0.2315556109,
0.0768581033,
-0.2339546233,
0.8221240044,
-0.4208033681,
0.8552579284,
-0.220332101,
0.0200575609,
0.0894793049,
-0.0408814065,
-0.5475651622,
-0.5174557567,
-0.2769755423,
-0.4181821346,
-0.170847252,
-0.013850254,
0.4805887341,
0.1372737139,
-0.5675025582,
-0.2584410012,
-0.8509999514,
0.5858258009,
-0.8245742917,
0.4079993665,
0.3965520859,
0.2609460056,
-0.4083673954,
-0.5618383884,
-0.4955129027,
-0.6645740867,
-0.3084574938,
-0.3224137723,
-0.1058626473,
0.0267222561,
0.7731997371,
0.6583987474,
-0.2334245443,
-0.274446249,
-0.2105952352,
-0.3170271516,
0.7346582413,
0.0613860376,
0.2359968871,
-0.0893894657,
0.0908897445,
0.1035962403,
-0.8145378828,
0.1865895838,
0.3323204219,
0.0468614884,
-0.2482723296,
0.860253036,
-0.4030305445,
0.9063868523,
0.1903159618,
-0.0225656144,
0.2594572306,
-0.2269062251,
-0.0874309167,
-0.1709149033,
0.7040989399,
0.0998991355,
0.6261262894,
-0.0600805767,
-0.4415215254,
0.3947814703,
-0.1917393208,
-0.7674013376,
-0.3978900909,
0.1438707709,
-0.1888120472,
-0.4491235316,
-0.0562026612,
-0.5720762014,
-0.4482572973,
-0.5035032034,
0.5186699629,
-0.5935065746,
-0.2536423802,
0.395862937,
0.2660905123,
-0.1032902971,
0.5499051213,
-0.7110796571,
0.2436864525,
0.7865638733,
0.6925022602,
0.255467087,
-0.0568577349,
-1.0620911121,
0.1085064858,
-0.3074679077,
0.7474155426,
-0.9737765789,
-0.1828663498,
0.0336228795,
-0.1682804525,
-0.012135203,
-0.4804489017,
0.3458708823,
-0.588536799,
0.2964919806,
-0.0121933445,
-0.7228984237,
-0.239441976,
0.3317053616,
-0.7006006837,
1.1983340979,
0.2544794381,
-0.6424317956,
-0.3334256113,
-0.8076531887,
-0.639977634,
0.0849630088,
-0.3475150168,
-0.4330144823,
0.3059342504,
0.3946100175,
0.1365546435,
-0.3233465254,
0.2290165871,
-0.5359704494,
-0.21388641,
0.1434317529,
-0.1308981478,
0.9197230935,
0.0648332313,
-0.4369812608,
0.1427768469,
-1.1702383757,
0.0287689231,
0.0911324173,
-0.3868212402,
-0.2114809752,
0.0597169101,
-0.7673965096,
0.0831052512,
0.1986775696,
-0.1617230177,
0.7025260329,
-0.4219754636,
0.6436920762,
0.5104127526,
0.2032774687,
0.6758973002,
-0.1674367785,
0.6244663596,
0.0907490477,
-0.0876230001,
-0.2813685238,
-0.4042965174,
-0.8439773321,
0.0981613398,
0.6146300435,
0.4072271883,
-1.0863779783,
0.4145382941,
-0.2032962888,
-0.4456504583,
0.1915389597,
0.0617260076,
0.4476090968,
0.7151904702,
0.0792224556,
-0.0382368937,
-0.3206336796,
-0.3822244406,
-0.1095245332,
-0.7179936171,
-0.0573637709,
-0.07901261,
0.5084753036,
-0.0981733501,
0.4267419875,
-0.4272153676,
0.1187961251,
-0.1811570376,
0.3927387595,
0.2371825278,
0.3502652049,
0.3596482873,
-0.5863721967,
-0.2774976492,
-0.1480097324,
-0.6420646906,
-0.2770467103,
0.0084967138,
-0.280448705,
0.2630888522,
0.4590193033,
-0.6046759486,
0.4680035114,
0.3932843804,
-0.6161928177,
0.686034143,
-0.3649317324,
0.1920307279,
-0.5850844383,
-0.0412871204,
0.0936832055,
-0.6743761897,
-0.4430521727,
0.2993352711,
0.163812831,
-0.0875574201,
-0.1123298481,
0.2853462696,
-0.7259616256,
0.0628243908,
0.0737571493,
-0.3530148566,
0.0467300974,
0.6208354831,
0.2481117845,
0.7395163774,
0.6591312885,
-0.8624685407,
0.7471698523,
0.0880656689,
-0.4248449504,
0.4894263744,
-0.7417408824,
0.2643125951,
-0.0013598242,
0.3555182517,
-0.7620878816,
-0.0648749173,
0.1775483787,
-0.4758719802,
0.3573357761,
-0.5975050926,
-0.7193824053,
-0.2696997821,
-0.1728997529,
0.3210683167,
0.3681196272,
-0.2943527102,
0.9966273904,
0.5909054875,
-0.0976691991,
-0.3136829436,
-0.239752993,
-0.0425130688,
0.0363349691,
-0.9240832925,
-0.0379998982,
0.1236505955,
-0.5120453835,
-0.1247811988,
-0.0973042026,
-0.0181690399,
-0.1069387421,
-0.0295449849,
0.4040953219,
-0.2755003273,
0.3234513104,
-0.3657587171,
-0.2975267172,
0.2931493521,
-0.4350716174,
0.489556551,
-0.5992235541,
-0.4098982513,
-0.1033990458,
0.1969050914,
0.8748620152,
-0.6985816956,
0.51880759,
0.1500565261,
-0.7071046829,
-0.17973423,
-0.4989954531,
-0.0625097901,
-0.4375201464,
0.2476389259,
-0.5185827613,
-0.8454768658,
0.6642346382,
-0.1630161405,
0.0840676278,
0.4895747006,
0.9763371348,
0.0949853659,
1.4128758907,
0.4477511644,
0.1005082354,
0.2788546681,
-0.5002819896,
0.2988223732,
-0.3686371446,
-0.4272696674,
-0.7185102105,
-0.0173851494,
-0.3686722219,
-0.577970922,
0.4315716624,
0.0582188591,
-0.3724389672,
0.1507440656,
-0.3094028831,
0.4353430271,
0.540933013,
0.0973319933,
0.6164613366,
0.0431661271,
-0.4044628739,
0.118914701,
-0.563837707,
-0.4440107346,
0.5477079749,
0.3474673927,
0.9705067873,
0.2363438755,
0.3792636395,
0.2754704058,
0.0473075919,
-0.9283492565,
0.6893375516,
-0.0191692915,
-0.4817620516,
-0.4897390604,
-1.0579037666,
-0.5592783689,
0.0911551639,
-0.2498369366,
-0.5684595108,
0.08732263,
0.4508802295,
-0.3513020575,
0.3523464799,
-0.8143218756,
0.809479475,
-0.4763533175,
-0.5509709716,
-0.3033077717,
-0.4217730761,
0.3445299864,
0.069348298,
0.3795208931,
-0.0431170762,
0.1584124863,
0.3482528925,
-1.2021024227,
0.5892867446,
-0.3180315793,
-0.2971290648,
0.3846630454,
0.5725069642,
1.0027300119,
0.2545482218,
-0.3203105032,
-0.0993137807,
0.2011701018,
-0.1866659075,
-0.9277646542,
0.4697642326,
-0.5069298148,
-0.5195119977,
-0.6130818725,
-0.4553907216,
-0.5108429193,
0.3406271338,
-0.1397127062,
0.775367558,
0.4472590387,
0.2049770504,
0.5956819057,
-0.0295639578,
0.0995279625,
0.5009698272,
-0.5998668671,
-0.4012311399,
0.5568069816,
0.1101846322,
0.2069302648,
0.5026287436,
0.4016011059,
-0.7410011292,
-0.3184292018,
-0.6796145439,
0.4373390377,
-0.5697363615,
-0.2782274187,
-0.3072370589,
-0.1253960133,
-0.5595577955,
0.4529463053,
-0.3185577393,
-0.9684908986,
0.1452083737,
0.0711479858,
0.4231087267,
0.7825382352,
-0.1051065847,
-0.2344455868,
-0.979432404,
0.628354609,
0.3643731773,
0.6066228747,
0.1260871589,
-0.6131060123,
-0.1946140975,
0.1372719705,
0.0125157041,
-0.9359990358,
0.1422756463,
0.179736048,
0.2301833332,
0.3678484857,
0.2982307374,
0.8320316076,
-0.6046476364,
0.4072458744,
0.178632319,
-1.0609605312,
0.4047299027,
-0.1592336744,
0.2093514502,
0.3490598798,
0.0278154425,
-0.313457191,
-0.3379069865,
-0.5592337847,
-0.4563088417,
0.5681878924,
0.418012768,
0.0130347554,
0.1790278554,
0.3641512394,
-0.4289904237,
0.1181897745,
-0.7512809038,
-0.185052067,
-0.0716182142,
-0.0291796271,
0.2835680842,
-0.3891815543,
-0.0582880303,
-0.5784659386,
0.7767392993,
-0.0906940848,
0.2665539384,
-0.1087907255,
-0.0561859496,
-0.3693496287,
0.0899050608,
0.271795243,
0.9615678191,
-0.0255338531,
0.4011709392,
0.0474065132,
-0.3148239553,
0.34429124,
0.2381084263,
-0.1963644922,
0.1473335028,
0.4243100286,
0.4446475506,
0.224777177,
-0.3037521243,
0.5097259283,
-0.157387808,
-0.0039986377,
-0.4429159462,
0.1353003085,
0.1611252129,
0.0508710779,
0.080823116,
-0.1028309539,
0.0710477531,
-0.6759615541,
0.1433824897,
0.2560448349,
0.0388656221,
-0.2438342571,
0.57582587,
0.3540982008,
-0.4867249131,
0.7800463438,
-0.3572709858,
-0.7435792685,
0.5069727898,
0.4815850854,
0.4133083522,
-0.1324435025,
0.2795109153,
0.5907670259,
0.1721816212,
-0.2725857794,
0.3151532412,
-0.1284546107,
-0.5181395411,
-0.9054749012,
-0.552007854,
-0.7163648605,
0.0030626226,
-0.4376494884,
0.6244848967,
-0.4004819989,
0.012248598,
0.230658561,
0.1583781987,
-0.3335093558,
0.147687301,
0.1811246127,
1.0031578541,
-0.6992247701,
0.904912889,
1.1351517439,
-0.5436137319,
-1.1490049362,
-0.3370913565,
-0.1326049417,
-0.7391157746,
0.3229880035,
0.1736081541,
-0.2568911314,
-0.0411158651,
-0.5361626744,
-0.6001740098,
0.4213014245,
0.6153321862,
-0.6660962701,
-0.2444257438,
0.250392437,
0.7062037587,
-0.1126332879,
0.4225886166,
0.3801131845,
0.549452126,
0.5856054425,
-0.7088882327,
-0.0208869558,
-0.5219902992,
-0.1226043105,
0.5433938503,
-0.5241450667,
0.5587217212,
-0.2889689505,
-0.0864831433,
-0.0522342771,
0.8512474298,
0.4279868305,
0.1847647876,
0.900205195,
0.7360708714,
0.8570495248,
-0.1668135822,
1.0820496082,
-0.4400298297,
0.4190218449,
1.0288431644,
-0.1175672412,
0.6516624093,
0.0525024123,
-0.610920608,
0.8014239073,
0.4143078625,
0.0320447572,
0.0044028326,
0.2548450828,
-0.3116297722,
-0.7439994216,
0.2460904717,
-0.355140835,
0.3876544833,
0.3745142817,
-0.1379971355,
-0.1603489816,
-0.5768133402,
0.1537085772,
0.1798488498,
-0.3507467806,
0.5127663612,
0.0721827224,
-0.8383270502,
0.6424043179,
0.2408928275,
0.0809805691,
-0.4992868304,
-0.5779617429,
-0.2393396497,
0.3259764016,
-0.4124208093,
-0.7331113815,
0.38653332,
0.1908018142,
-0.0341488644,
0.1116733924,
0.6664988399,
-0.4633345306,
-1.0224838257,
-0.0633770823,
0.3858112097,
0.0527141318,
-0.187105462,
-0.7282853127,
-0.1000607461,
0.1103361472,
-0.0352824405,
-0.2613157034,
0.9340139627,
-0.3420691192,
0.6656833887,
0.7458010912,
0.3769417405,
-0.0945700854,
0.4091937542,
0.766602397,
-0.5711167455,
-0.5973943472,
-1.0157465935,
0.4878198802,
-0.1955532283,
0.1491762102,
0.5126215219,
0.6977932453,
0.5860193968,
-0.010507239,
0.539411962,
-0.2116063833,
0.5309644938,
-0.5621212721,
0.3900665939,
-0.2899961174,
0.5798869133,
-0.0865898281,
-0.8892628551,
-0.6263454556,
0.9313969612,
-0.3757412732,
0.1492573321,
0.628679812,
0.7937276959,
-0.0486314371,
-0.0245302226,
0.136578545,
0.5124573112,
0.4422385693,
0.7352986336,
1.0370672941,
-0.0879794955,
0.6445906758,
-0.5799245834,
-0.4825267792,
0.0011029789,
-1.2204004526,
-0.9361198545,
-0.2447844297,
-0.6626961231,
-0.7678340077,
-0.2521072924,
0.9036388993,
0.5064432025,
-0.8888005018,
-0.1548547745,
-0.1675566137,
0.3340673745,
-0.1363089085,
-0.1794023365,
0.4183838367,
-0.1724435836,
-0.7033318281,
-0.0243288092,
0.4876644015,
-0.1322719455,
-0.4451557994,
-0.1396426111,
-0.1121052355,
-0.0300569311,
0.6983435154,
0.302523762,
-0.336946249,
-0.2764118016,
-0.0263709556,
0.0637290031,
0.1575694829,
0.8392178416,
-0.7070240378,
0.5669173598,
0.8234294057,
0.4810412824,
0.3758972585,
0.1118784621,
0.8424815536,
-0.2869091332,
-0.0714280456,
0.2536333203,
0.8445883393,
0.3700248003,
-0.3478352427,
0.8782174587,
0.3510554433,
-0.4736052155,
-0.807714045,
0.3876129091,
-0.7390148044,
0.2361677438,
1.2922803164,
-0.3381538093,
-0.2025550902,
-0.0512662381,
-0.2291476429,
0.2884432673,
-0.2422961146,
0.9027907848,
0.7799994946,
-0.3654207885,
-0.2297922522,
-0.0521665215,
0.2486260086,
0.2123585641,
-0.8294275999,
0.1657018065,
0.9518954158,
0.1373909712,
0.1652832329,
0.4004107714,
-0.6969961524,
0.4379459918,
-0.2707806826,
-0.180314824,
-0.3736156821,
-0.1422745138,
-0.2385157347,
0.023224771,
0.1597734392,
0.0357553847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17764v1 | BMIKE-53: Investigating Cross-Lingual Knowledge Editing with In-Context Learning | 2024-06-25T17:48:56 | 2024-06-25T17:48:56 | Ercong Nie, Bo Shao, Zifeng Ding, Mingyang Wang, Helmut Schmid, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) possess extensive parametric knowledge, but this
knowledge is difficult to update with new information because retraining is
very expensive and infeasible for closed-source models. Knowledge editing (KE)
has emerged as a viable solution for updating the knowledge of LLMs without
compromising their overall performance. On-the-fly KE methods, inspired by
in-context learning (ICL), have shown great promise and allow LLMs to be
treated as black boxes. In the past, KE was primarily employed in English
contexts, whereas the potential for cross-lingual KE in current English-centric
LLMs has not been fully explored. To foster more research in this direction, we
introduce the BMIKE-53 benchmark for evaluating cross-lingual KE on 53 diverse
languages across three KE task types. We also propose a gradient-free KE method
called Multilingual In-context Knowledge Editing (MIKE) and evaluate it on
BMIKE-53. Our evaluation focuses on cross-lingual knowledge transfer in terms
of reliability, generality, locality, and portability, offering valuable
insights and a framework for future research in cross-lingual KE. Our code and
data are publicly accessible via the anonymous repository at
https://anonymous.4open.science/r/MIKE. | [
-0.1469323188,
-0.5084967017,
0.3170103729,
0.3137838542,
0.061208345,
0.1924863905,
-0.6400470734,
-0.6101045012,
-0.0020696723,
0.167140916,
-0.4695238173,
-0.6622908711,
-0.4949098825,
0.2532230318,
-0.1588439345,
0.5684793591,
-0.1755578667,
0.4934721887,
-0.2368502617,
-0.2996309996,
-0.4988780022,
-0.2882031202,
-0.5606732368,
-0.1105217263,
0.5416690111,
0.8446985483,
0.4265082777,
0.3728164732,
0.34379673,
0.1625714302,
-0.3199986517,
0.1332515627,
-0.6389247775,
-0.0701432973,
-0.4929973781,
-0.5145376325,
-0.5530928969,
-0.2541777194,
0.998285532,
1.0658080578,
0.1350061595,
0.1705540121,
0.1591484845,
0.7392199636,
-0.8586096168,
-0.037462201,
-0.7655211091,
0.1279302686,
-0.22750175,
0.0589283928,
-0.485578984,
-0.0177547727,
0.242575258,
-0.8289704323,
-0.0992522836,
0.1826897115,
0.5198677778,
0.2394960076,
-0.3629498184,
-0.2561526,
-0.1946325302,
0.7545295954,
-0.7392532229,
1.120216012,
0.4624452293,
0.1040482447,
-0.0519201085,
-0.4074748158,
-0.3410884142,
-0.0536990836,
-0.162912026,
0.1062697321,
-0.1783666164,
-0.1817638278,
0.3774164021,
0.1381260306,
-0.4075456262,
0.3365258574,
-0.2899232805,
-0.2050560266,
0.4975948036,
0.093066521,
0.3362114131,
-0.2775550783,
-0.3400748968,
0.1543382704,
-0.9741048813,
0.0978699028,
0.2303850055,
-0.0195110086,
-0.3214399815,
0.79953444,
-0.443118453,
0.6735315323,
0.2489061058,
-0.1921839416,
0.2141191959,
-0.3351992369,
-0.2583954334,
0.2561339736,
0.7266967893,
0.7461214066,
0.1872070283,
-0.3690901101,
-0.0553465746,
-0.6809814572,
-0.1729900539,
-0.8127867579,
0.1034872681,
-0.062052656,
-0.3186772764,
-0.0126677649,
-0.2833817601,
-0.7339974046,
-0.4343383908,
-0.1026646942,
0.4717454612,
-0.6151703,
-0.0322026536,
0.2779654562,
-0.0879643634,
-0.0819981769,
0.4537780881,
-0.6771688461,
-0.1565355957,
0.5597734451,
0.7625501752,
-0.1061624512,
-0.8014210463,
-0.4392197728,
0.6930158734,
-0.5356640816,
0.3686580658,
-0.5152528882,
-0.5215278268,
-0.0435273498,
0.0656686053,
-0.076881595,
-0.5023998022,
0.1627431661,
-0.4580141902,
0.3539716005,
-0.6311815977,
-0.9078983665,
-0.2505161166,
0.417103529,
-0.5026474595,
1.0738987923,
0.0554974265,
-0.9634287953,
0.6906281114,
-0.6742696762,
-0.5182338357,
-0.0529547781,
0.33452034,
-0.1044593528,
0.0255636945,
0.3346277773,
0.6618916392,
-0.2956243455,
0.1449621022,
-0.3092324734,
-0.342351079,
0.1563417166,
-0.0673748553,
0.8008176088,
-0.135983482,
-0.2934390903,
-0.0312993824,
-0.8394940495,
-0.3950308859,
-0.2623108327,
-0.6078012586,
-0.6889551878,
-0.3169294,
-0.1830629706,
0.2782396972,
0.4142598212,
-0.9464672208,
0.0848611891,
-0.1546662897,
0.0453407951,
0.5284838676,
0.0361381173,
0.4941113591,
-0.2720069587,
0.4409327507,
0.0104207443,
-0.0050731041,
0.0773624778,
-0.4261042476,
-0.6107801795,
-0.3680716753,
0.4907574952,
0.5859204531,
-0.8784374595,
0.0720796138,
-0.46100685,
-0.587189436,
-0.4719760716,
0.4748496115,
0.4263720214,
0.7743117809,
0.50252074,
-0.1224773377,
-0.3433118165,
-0.831997633,
-0.650182426,
0.059863355,
-0.1088848412,
0.2694226205,
0.397698015,
-0.3412795961,
0.7473987341,
-0.2343471944,
-0.1929249316,
-0.2980080545,
-0.1301848292,
-0.3749315739,
0.4411774874,
0.6277102828,
-0.316500634,
-0.8023252487,
0.3611759543,
-0.7954440117,
-0.3144661784,
-0.023409009,
-0.4257799983,
0.1874350905,
0.7348334789,
-0.5391168594,
0.1561755687,
0.6643379927,
-0.2561224103,
0.4441007972,
0.0824152604,
0.3730694056,
-1.1157243252,
0.3086921275,
0.0085995095,
-0.2197773159,
-0.5320619941,
-0.0074713347,
0.5321802497,
-0.086398311,
-0.6427455544,
0.852381587,
-0.3694005907,
-0.0626066849,
0.1791453212,
-0.0390021019,
-0.110769853,
0.650526464,
0.0073876726,
0.6666104794,
0.3465825319,
-0.3167363107,
0.1152365878,
0.2248542309,
-0.7029329538,
0.8529729247,
-0.164319247,
0.0055391528,
-0.0452668108,
0.2840464115,
-0.6670812964,
-0.0521944836,
0.2885489762,
-0.3309094012,
0.2600554228,
-0.2011535913,
-0.5589097142,
0.2875493467,
-0.3434709013,
0.4420844316,
-0.1152438968,
-0.5401784778,
0.4502073228,
0.2340958714,
-0.1457795799,
-0.787772119,
-0.9095592499,
0.2912177145,
-0.1967593431,
-0.5217475891,
0.3707321286,
-0.2331672609,
-0.2398880571,
0.2220306993,
-0.1264812648,
0.0465989597,
0.029726427,
-0.2935361862,
-0.0566717722,
-0.0638690442,
-0.0067846677,
0.4324762225,
0.1588369906,
0.093438223,
-0.1545284986,
-0.0456186607,
0.3224120438,
-0.2622098625,
-0.3637776971,
0.2988749444,
0.813393712,
-0.2531644404,
0.5728312731,
0.5599205494,
-0.5636445284,
-0.4091744125,
-0.4873958826,
0.163254261,
-0.4255175889,
0.6147904992,
-0.5273452401,
-1.1535491943,
0.5125478506,
-0.1433700174,
0.315736562,
0.2347024828,
0.6960402727,
-0.0271215048,
0.4477214813,
0.5376921296,
-0.0196960121,
0.5269212127,
-0.1161325946,
-0.0047218362,
-0.9848140478,
-0.2594395578,
-0.2493755519,
-0.5850952864,
-0.3322289884,
-0.4885139763,
0.5838993192,
-0.0048962324,
-0.0468752682,
0.1733811498,
0.255592674,
0.5415730476,
0.3348039687,
0.1450954974,
0.3735406697,
-0.2821063399,
-0.4971321821,
-0.142480731,
-1.0083072186,
0.2100365758,
1.286903739,
0.3399453461,
0.6929600835,
0.2994197905,
0.4543389678,
0.0970836431,
0.5248861313,
-0.8030067086,
0.6438168287,
-0.2942744792,
-0.7236161828,
-0.4876348972,
-0.56176126,
-0.5872173905,
0.2925638855,
-0.1988954544,
-0.6163077354,
0.3538551033,
0.1978014708,
-0.0926454514,
0.661030829,
-0.7666718364,
1.0361887217,
-0.198246792,
-0.5960888863,
-0.4438147247,
-0.6836597919,
0.4995650053,
-0.3592235744,
0.3895047307,
-0.0122728599,
-0.2434999645,
0.711742878,
-0.3150086999,
0.7871155143,
-0.194431752,
-0.274777025,
-0.1322556883,
0.5154331326,
0.4081344008,
0.1269413084,
-0.1742569953,
0.3441841304,
-0.015089185,
-0.3395624757,
-0.7167613506,
0.625874877,
-0.4828148186,
-0.3985181451,
0.0132539319,
-0.9377194047,
-0.8283894658,
0.2078832984,
0.1399130672,
0.4707699418,
-0.1464554518,
0.4990565777,
0.4536759853,
-0.4492331743,
0.3657467067,
0.6923545003,
-0.2385516465,
-0.4729597569,
0.7731393576,
0.3565116823,
0.3418667614,
0.9471206069,
0.4202379286,
-0.1322688609,
-0.3800497055,
-0.7262356877,
0.1503133774,
-0.7999246716,
-0.0995962322,
-0.6864518523,
0.1720883399,
-0.1253170073,
-0.4884701371,
-0.4179136753,
-0.5348417163,
0.238353014,
-0.010641559,
0.2819356024,
0.6352818012,
-0.3925403357,
0.145138979,
-0.7363781929,
0.0476646833,
0.2736322284,
0.5534443259,
0.2272577286,
-0.3988274932,
-0.9910484552,
0.0680140853,
0.1381747723,
-0.9267877936,
0.0414966531,
0.1033987626,
0.5016513467,
0.0306847841,
-0.1574730426,
0.7572872043,
-0.45703578,
0.6109602451,
0.105969727,
-1.1931654215,
0.074568823,
-0.3985361755,
0.6098741293,
0.6387917995,
0.6139344573,
-1.066463232,
-0.3926112354,
-0.1941655129,
-0.4936484098,
0.5098959804,
-0.3424401581,
-0.1150198281,
0.4482544363,
0.1408461034,
0.3768199086,
0.3911156952,
-0.4475810528,
0.0300757252,
-0.1099982932,
-0.2381383926,
-0.1109249741,
-0.3387384117,
0.1171883419,
-0.6355779171,
0.7704244256,
-0.0798467994,
-0.2517747879,
0.2232330889,
-0.6434470415,
-0.2839250267,
0.2254771739,
0.6033659577,
0.9337174892,
-0.2411899418,
0.0008761394,
0.7329245806,
-0.4624120295,
-0.0644034073,
-0.1299433708,
-0.2664915025,
-0.0461720452,
0.4872581661,
0.6555258632,
0.9820021987,
-0.6663743258,
0.3556248546,
0.0010375088,
-0.2835272253,
0.2729879022,
-0.2864491045,
0.149044469,
0.0232567731,
0.0716092363,
-0.1078521609,
-0.0255195163,
-0.4460399747,
0.0574840009,
0.2311899662,
-0.1346634626,
-0.2838695943,
0.6465069056,
0.3439544737,
-0.0596730597,
0.3119439483,
-0.1869606674,
-0.5580304265,
-0.0879695863,
0.2705875635,
0.7446866632,
-0.2303058803,
-0.1389940232,
0.3422749043,
0.5062267184,
0.3000056446,
0.0159151405,
-0.1275982112,
-0.8583618999,
-0.7607112527,
-0.4159118533,
-0.8283638954,
0.1822888851,
-0.3487401009,
0.3446299732,
-0.4344991148,
0.2463556677,
-0.0305263326,
0.0087756338,
-0.706376195,
0.2118961662,
-0.0882803276,
1.1626689434,
-0.6320180893,
0.7758610845,
0.9866911769,
0.1354629993,
-0.6406496167,
0.2469587177,
0.1849838197,
-0.6366378069,
0.3591577709,
-0.1086420864,
-0.0969979987,
-0.0381981209,
-0.3147268891,
-0.8783452511,
0.9477202296,
0.5898474455,
-0.6760047674,
-0.0173577797,
0.2099826932,
0.2417628914,
0.077081196,
-0.0670451075,
0.3212793469,
0.6488265395,
-0.0984653682,
-1.1658476591,
0.0124993715,
-0.0587880611,
-0.3527180254,
0.0135548338,
-0.8920355439,
0.4929535985,
0.034000773,
0.1821048409,
-0.3355451226,
0.5108816028,
-0.0063430606,
0.1501880735,
0.5734186769,
0.8194666505,
0.6884326339,
0.3814792335,
0.6610726118,
-0.6608031392,
0.201613307,
0.9693179131,
-0.4115980566,
0.7197682261,
0.4863981009,
0.0794085935,
0.452404052,
0.5434527993,
0.1847648323,
0.3338089883,
-0.0069788746,
-0.1918944418,
-0.2437444776,
0.0714544505,
-0.1971150041,
0.6261367202,
0.2787007689,
0.098436974,
-0.2390280068,
0.0923548043,
0.5639600754,
-0.2330788374,
-0.4103832245,
0.5327893496,
0.0071773687,
-0.5855330825,
0.2579660416,
0.3171604872,
0.8235516548,
-0.7735105157,
0.1497954726,
-0.2818003595,
-0.0668764114,
-0.2280336767,
-0.7913748622,
0.3248722553,
0.2411480099,
-0.0772806332,
-0.361550808,
0.5769052505,
-0.6870176196,
-0.6241813898,
0.5072109103,
0.7506600618,
-0.079680644,
0.2005583048,
-0.5638821721,
-0.0098183155,
-0.0249918178,
-0.331818223,
0.4509564042,
0.7796005607,
-0.1150262654,
0.6350943446,
0.6130792499,
0.2232753038,
0.2267292887,
-0.1450964361,
0.5340907574,
-0.5596386194,
-0.6458346844,
-0.6945080757,
0.511611104,
0.1470147967,
-0.5084204674,
0.9877694249,
0.9318961501,
1.4767348766,
-0.0539748073,
0.8592188954,
-0.0701449588,
0.5329547524,
-0.6586839557,
1.0253494978,
-0.9909186959,
-0.0669008344,
-0.4677197635,
-0.6207234263,
-0.3197937012,
0.2087400258,
-0.3768691421,
-0.1991022974,
0.8832919598,
0.8289906979,
-0.2703477144,
-0.0416455977,
0.5085568428,
0.2777119279,
-0.1544338018,
0.6629163027,
0.7224822044,
-0.0504217967,
0.3916876316,
-0.6167396903,
-0.0516599715,
-0.070531778,
-0.7683828473,
-0.9822506905,
-0.4764670432,
-0.2278839052,
0.0115760127,
0.2361643612,
0.9235135913,
0.6120473146,
-0.503973186,
-0.5793477893,
0.4267439544,
0.3753490448,
-0.3337682188,
-0.141698584,
0.3606096506,
-0.1281903237,
-0.7851777077,
0.7633191347,
0.1783966422,
-0.2934599221,
-0.166313827,
-0.0771844536,
-0.3532065153,
-0.1516914964,
0.7076662183,
0.0717215985,
-0.2816303968,
-0.3070243895,
-0.0680607185,
0.0115839252,
-0.0297765806,
0.8402239084,
-0.3618966341,
0.4894946814,
0.5889372826,
1.0724949837,
0.3604575098,
-0.3058413565,
0.7206529379,
-0.9289319515,
0.1346702576,
-0.1416472793,
0.5911661983,
0.57920295,
-0.3124328554,
0.3998574615,
0.4282939136,
-0.3812714815,
-0.8223975301,
-0.0623469241,
-0.7681899071,
-0.3042056561,
1.3462276459,
-0.2584430277,
-0.1039182618,
0.0599863976,
-0.1304364651,
0.2151021361,
-0.1611970067,
0.4637499154,
1.0053673983,
0.1010846272,
-0.2438098788,
-0.5824589729,
0.4414685369,
0.6335026026,
-0.6695171595,
0.2352322787,
0.4848138094,
0.6226141453,
-0.3887578249,
0.2933417857,
0.1043300852,
0.4997484386,
-0.2611823082,
0.1369432211,
-0.2000019401,
-0.3169955611,
-0.1689240187,
0.1133204997,
-0.0471016094,
-0.0149092292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17761v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17761v2 | CaLMQA: Exploring culturally specific long-form question answering across 23 languages | 2024-06-25T17:45:26 | 2024-07-03T16:33:55 | Shane Arora, Marzena Karpinska, Hung-Ting Chen, Ipsita Bhattacharjee, Mohit Iyyer, Eunsol Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are used for long-form question answering
(LFQA), which requires them to generate paragraph-length answers to complex
questions. While LFQA has been well-studied in English, this research has not
been extended to other languages. To bridge this gap, we introduce CaLMQA, a
collection of 1.5K complex culturally specific questions spanning 23 languages
and 51 culturally agnostic questions translated from English into 22 other
languages. We define culturally specific questions as those uniquely or more
likely to be asked by people from cultures associated with the question's
language. We collect naturally-occurring questions from community web forums
and hire native speakers to write questions to cover under-resourced,
rarely-studied languages such as Fijian and Kirundi. Our dataset contains
diverse, complex questions that reflect cultural topics (e.g. traditions, laws,
news) and the language usage of native speakers. We automatically evaluate a
suite of open- and closed-source models on CaLMQA by detecting incorrect
language and token repetitions in answers, and observe that the quality of
LLM-generated answers degrades significantly for some low-resource languages.
Lastly, we perform human evaluation on a subset of models and languages. Manual
evaluation reveals that model performance is significantly worse for culturally
specific questions than for culturally agnostic questions. Our findings
highlight the need for further research in non-English LFQA and provide an
evaluation framework. | [
-0.4794865549,
-0.9042708874,
0.321123004,
0.3146654665,
-0.2182939649,
0.2776736617,
-0.4980904162,
-0.7894076705,
0.0804197416,
0.3683384955,
-0.6671720147,
-0.316406846,
-0.1003095731,
0.3838638663,
-0.0159601755,
0.5006991625,
-0.412396431,
0.2486224174,
-0.0041906689,
-0.4457931817,
-0.1169995517,
-0.5099542737,
-0.6496722698,
-0.1638754457,
0.5650100708,
0.5030879974,
0.6678447127,
0.1135624498,
0.3306506574,
0.2035395354,
-0.3668392897,
0.1012452915,
-0.7052454352,
0.1585098505,
-0.2548053861,
-0.5810770988,
-0.0486563481,
-0.1093913317,
0.3557580709,
0.7451642752,
-0.1025292575,
0.5419462919,
-0.3356333673,
0.3490201235,
-0.6950665712,
-0.199821353,
-0.4088048041,
0.2498655319,
-0.1783408821,
0.0309444051,
-0.2003373653,
-0.6194261312,
-0.0497622974,
-0.3459375501,
-0.0164551437,
-0.2856929898,
0.6859817505,
0.2999450862,
-1.018024683,
-0.2854099572,
-0.7377052903,
0.8538068533,
-0.5602787733,
0.427580595,
0.4877769649,
0.2398358136,
-0.3115765154,
-0.5633584261,
-0.6633252501,
-0.1036977693,
0.16993469,
0.3251336217,
-0.2053075284,
-0.1476962417,
0.1320926249,
0.4951176345,
-0.770354867,
0.283993274,
-0.3439950347,
-0.3631650507,
0.725256443,
0.2562811673,
0.4258440733,
-0.1126957983,
-0.2948333919,
0.1480523497,
-0.6980850101,
0.8175566792,
0.2206539661,
0.0541509353,
-0.1189441532,
0.3296859562,
-0.6718227267,
0.5991501212,
0.030452352,
-0.3346464634,
-0.1461852193,
-0.0030065486,
0.0021822006,
-0.1660049558,
0.6614974737,
0.2868035734,
0.3435781896,
-0.0414317548,
-0.0426656418,
-0.1678588837,
-0.2271904796,
-0.8222466707,
0.0970259756,
0.4734133482,
-0.2598107457,
-0.1742015183,
-0.4588035941,
-0.5170830488,
-0.4551959932,
-0.1213739887,
0.119811222,
-0.0556309037,
-0.4152060747,
0.1672535092,
0.1931150854,
0.7145158648,
0.3342366219,
-0.4940185547,
0.0673862696,
0.4684319794,
0.2051849812,
-0.3106554449,
-0.2046054006,
-0.1546508074,
-0.1432549953,
-0.6039289832,
0.5704879761,
-0.6748278737,
-0.4551535845,
0.2203235328,
0.2992967963,
0.2666742504,
-0.4784920216,
0.7961381674,
-0.8848792911,
0.3790307045,
-0.7016009092,
-0.1499294043,
-0.2293607295,
0.5172385573,
-0.4832220078,
1.1783672571,
0.091406554,
-0.5836949944,
0.2153698504,
-0.1878191382,
-0.4774044454,
0.2607976794,
-0.122474499,
0.0874019638,
0.0300729685,
0.3192075491,
0.4026916325,
-0.7572385669,
0.4721559286,
-0.0861386135,
-0.4450584948,
0.533977747,
-0.4698112905,
0.9583824873,
0.646838069,
-0.5246171355,
-0.0122691756,
-0.516640842,
0.3200705349,
0.1413765848,
-0.5847278833,
-0.112673007,
-0.3436938226,
-0.058986973,
0.5769389868,
0.375017345,
-0.7341539264,
0.0602919646,
-0.0037345886,
0.4395264983,
0.3210806847,
0.2043427676,
0.2623249888,
-0.3560491204,
1.0868593454,
0.0452430695,
0.1092547551,
-0.1269048154,
-0.544072926,
-0.7483392358,
-0.2344439328,
-0.1677550375,
0.694503963,
-0.7344475985,
-0.3290309906,
-0.0013321758,
-0.8000766039,
-0.6150981784,
0.2596755922,
0.2877619863,
0.7035964131,
0.2893053591,
-0.1770569831,
-0.1095187515,
-0.9132016897,
-0.2365019172,
-0.3372552991,
0.056679409,
0.1618557572,
0.3949307203,
-0.0620854124,
0.6411167979,
-0.5355576873,
0.2615860105,
-0.1524613053,
0.1415938139,
0.1649104953,
0.0648983568,
0.3939007521,
-0.7685713768,
-0.4372816384,
-0.1143131182,
-0.7398893237,
0.0202913694,
-0.104124397,
-0.356992811,
0.279683888,
0.5275140405,
-0.6991033554,
0.1936268657,
0.5034621358,
-0.1629541218,
0.539796412,
0.2173074335,
0.4060381651,
-1.2344553471,
0.1669929028,
-0.2094020396,
0.042574577,
-0.6715664864,
0.6112563014,
0.0959446058,
-0.414411366,
-0.615269959,
0.7199575901,
-0.2798594236,
0.4328418374,
0.1100725308,
-0.1733231097,
0.0797660351,
0.5049848557,
0.3627625704,
0.6036925912,
0.4067125618,
-0.3091091514,
0.4180921018,
0.111221537,
-0.4764926732,
0.4830019474,
-0.6036399007,
0.4687295556,
-0.3242897987,
0.4846391976,
-0.9213221073,
-0.454413861,
-0.0672414452,
-0.2824415863,
0.0506507158,
-0.1649054438,
-0.131748125,
-0.416623652,
-0.1160061657,
0.7982138991,
0.5537265539,
-0.3537341952,
0.3152034283,
0.3385246098,
-0.4194734097,
-0.9399795532,
-0.7972576022,
-0.0140326461,
-0.3866966367,
-0.7628057003,
-0.2634194791,
-0.3224460781,
-0.5252237916,
-0.3361692727,
-0.0691471025,
-0.4600308537,
0.3939863443,
-0.003162781,
-0.1728102118,
-0.5194071531,
0.169825539,
-0.0085323127,
0.4674838781,
0.240367502,
-0.07522434,
0.6126890779,
-0.3187364042,
-0.3134225309,
-0.2474231124,
0.8823443651,
0.8218283057,
-0.7879014015,
0.568058908,
0.8561237454,
-0.5484793782,
-0.1593784243,
-0.729029119,
0.0136317192,
-0.4859645367,
0.2986094058,
-0.5988007188,
-1.3558067083,
1.0349149704,
0.1280341744,
0.0190811846,
0.3483794332,
0.8416017294,
-0.2011929452,
0.8059005737,
0.5932369232,
-0.0836941227,
-0.1021932214,
0.1190921292,
0.3131865263,
-0.0203668792,
-0.4807486534,
-0.4828537703,
-0.4012082815,
-0.7766721845,
-0.7197519541,
0.2149396688,
0.2048557401,
-0.4662978351,
-0.2160660625,
-0.2131247967,
0.5411323905,
0.4277289808,
-0.108721219,
0.4255364537,
-0.2314676344,
-0.1022726595,
-0.040630877,
-0.6446860433,
-0.4722266197,
0.6279881597,
0.3917312026,
0.8713203073,
0.5776021481,
0.6469532847,
0.1045549512,
0.473792702,
-0.892418921,
0.4992015958,
0.2464711666,
-0.9123693109,
-0.4083499014,
-0.4445233941,
-0.8171983957,
0.0129636433,
-0.0203251969,
-0.462261349,
0.2872470617,
-0.0718858391,
-0.2469390333,
0.1858294159,
-0.2802786827,
0.5299375653,
-0.4556220472,
-0.3908571005,
-0.0387813747,
-0.6271327734,
0.7474918365,
-0.412741065,
0.1665424705,
-0.3050844371,
0.1000076607,
0.6219198704,
-0.0982488766,
0.6759132147,
0.0516214706,
-0.5076802373,
0.6339921951,
0.4164313078,
0.1377897859,
0.296223253,
-0.3156220913,
-0.0109420661,
0.2761186957,
-0.7674124837,
-0.3811757565,
0.8297962546,
-0.9562979341,
-0.7542921305,
-0.3566899598,
-0.6501456499,
-0.5059726834,
0.1283783466,
0.2575449646,
0.1634024233,
-0.1989114583,
-0.0620424449,
0.6887046099,
-0.5919280648,
0.25848943,
0.8255983591,
-0.139394328,
-0.0722650364,
0.4638846815,
0.000230121,
0.1697593182,
0.3040480018,
0.0936822891,
-0.2706371844,
-0.2978256345,
-0.4586476386,
0.1976980567,
-0.9917721152,
-0.1314590722,
-0.5242208838,
-0.034244284,
-0.3421314359,
-0.3366123438,
-0.1702444255,
-0.4677807391,
0.0730818063,
-0.1397970766,
0.3693835437,
0.6553079486,
0.1949063838,
-0.1081165224,
-0.6688799858,
0.2824086547,
0.6416095495,
0.1085465923,
-0.0920161307,
-0.5225520134,
-0.0218569282,
0.0773515403,
0.065597266,
-1.0736802816,
0.1883953363,
0.257740438,
0.5352390409,
0.4045113325,
0.6105304956,
0.919934392,
-0.2673627138,
1.0016130209,
-0.1374044716,
-0.7343840003,
0.3865160942,
-0.5430678129,
0.8574526906,
0.7982445955,
1.0964397192,
-0.9613866806,
-0.5019541979,
-0.1058063209,
-0.9532288909,
0.2677520812,
-0.2171375751,
0.3933072984,
-0.2144235224,
0.4346748888,
-0.0467788689,
0.0064779324,
-0.6774702072,
-0.0022410066,
0.0221474618,
-0.0259626098,
-0.0631241649,
-0.3155341744,
-0.3034568727,
-0.2081263512,
0.4474834502,
-0.2225244492,
0.0292816106,
0.2976499498,
-0.3262043297,
-0.3981519043,
0.5686459541,
0.4533285499,
0.6607485414,
-0.1093237922,
0.0853211582,
0.6472824812,
-0.4197008312,
0.2909288406,
-0.0016754082,
-0.2786254883,
-0.2500420213,
0.2724762559,
0.1279999763,
-0.1596627086,
-0.9994655252,
0.1294001043,
-0.4757791758,
0.0062175994,
-0.620464921,
-0.3444010913,
0.2869642079,
0.1505207717,
0.4099471569,
-0.3379382193,
0.0656530038,
-0.8615600467,
0.1245368272,
0.2642730474,
-0.6199215055,
-0.3008940518,
0.6316726804,
0.3091313243,
-0.051288981,
0.7843677402,
-0.0725916252,
-0.6508482099,
0.5699875951,
0.3536335826,
0.4923354387,
-0.4905899167,
0.4448418915,
0.4758082628,
0.4516738951,
0.142693609,
1.0259495974,
-0.1286906004,
-0.6128610969,
-0.6089192033,
-0.8065938354,
-0.6445864439,
0.3272436559,
-0.8769618869,
0.2244892269,
-0.3331545889,
-0.1016063541,
-0.3393757045,
0.1954739243,
-0.8334882855,
0.4746492803,
0.4175886214,
1.1601318121,
-1.0049965382,
0.6193560362,
0.9786813259,
-0.2716999352,
-0.9927064776,
0.030456895,
0.1314538866,
-0.5941988826,
0.5098677278,
-0.0200300496,
-0.3371336162,
-0.265124917,
-0.5808625221,
-0.9243084788,
0.954033196,
0.4191736579,
-0.1275690496,
0.2792998552,
0.5084050298,
0.7752025723,
-0.1025151461,
0.2931932807,
0.5005169511,
0.2561991215,
0.0727334991,
-0.8964693546,
0.1446987092,
-0.630656898,
-0.4631614387,
-0.0289579164,
-0.8828009367,
0.6866708994,
-0.2448366731,
-0.0280313157,
0.3364700675,
0.7239288092,
0.3173553944,
0.2431218922,
0.2852622569,
0.3271546066,
1.1399211884,
-0.1238461807,
0.9915471077,
-0.4150331318,
0.056841176,
1.0798496008,
-0.4378534257,
0.970605731,
0.2841938138,
0.1003410742,
0.3256435096,
1.0462249517,
0.4374877512,
0.0576273277,
0.5304815173,
-0.6118263602,
-0.5140800476,
-0.7179768085,
-0.3123559058,
0.9000332952,
0.2432246953,
0.0934310928,
-0.068157576,
-0.1025431603,
0.5134773254,
0.0913173929,
-0.3797166646,
0.3258673549,
0.128945604,
-1.0538973808,
0.8583701849,
0.2460557818,
0.4611845911,
-0.701431632,
0.3421097696,
-0.8638119698,
-0.1136437207,
-0.1617966294,
-0.8302138448,
0.0149811096,
0.4073435664,
0.0285307635,
-0.1205466464,
0.424151957,
-0.6130402088,
-0.504011631,
0.0849717855,
0.7794737816,
0.2676469982,
0.2534560859,
-0.5920434594,
-0.1103478819,
0.0056935716,
-0.3260734975,
0.2282825261,
0.5286564231,
-0.6096951962,
0.8934431672,
0.5334707499,
-0.2583834827,
0.1175044999,
0.0851573423,
0.7189484835,
-0.6732562184,
-0.4714337587,
-0.3250352442,
0.5347645283,
0.1901313365,
-0.7517040372,
0.6838139892,
0.3681870103,
0.7747074366,
-0.0028836064,
0.5945129991,
0.1254369915,
0.2026148885,
-0.3132175207,
0.7966077328,
-0.6595925093,
-0.0360135138,
-0.1226780936,
-0.7579593658,
-0.183304444,
0.2474078089,
-0.2026749104,
-0.1699057221,
0.4086534679,
0.7550883293,
0.1708815545,
0.1066772342,
0.4184775352,
0.2542624772,
0.2800007761,
0.6342160702,
1.2968367338,
-0.024343621,
0.5638672113,
-0.5542268753,
-0.0322013684,
0.2345603257,
-0.6392279863,
-0.7820037603,
-0.5982910991,
-0.4041213989,
-0.218181029,
-0.3025349677,
1.0159515142,
0.4781386554,
-0.8898538351,
-0.388117671,
0.8103197217,
-0.0856259391,
0.1173238754,
-0.2158247083,
0.2917184234,
-0.0176302418,
-0.6718903184,
0.4969246387,
0.0032410405,
0.0016501714,
-0.2366694659,
0.0935704485,
-0.231928736,
0.3413050771,
0.6281655431,
0.6496725082,
-0.6780954003,
-0.1652772725,
0.5987887383,
-0.1650029272,
-0.3056231439,
0.7001606226,
-0.5490005612,
0.42561993,
0.4339814484,
0.6074981093,
0.4349359274,
-0.0629183426,
0.6029087305,
-0.5748671889,
0.4195134938,
0.5529386997,
0.314075768,
0.3732206821,
-0.3918413222,
0.3765210211,
-0.3211898804,
-0.5005409718,
-0.7563787699,
0.6182900667,
-0.9844068885,
-0.2178924531,
1.2364884615,
-0.4199768305,
0.0173843503,
-0.4115586877,
-0.0065732482,
0.0709691569,
-0.0205887388,
0.6896079779,
0.713319838,
-0.0565717518,
-0.2874383032,
-0.4896598756,
0.6093686819,
0.7229599357,
-0.5814138651,
-0.259996593,
0.3858934045,
0.4464330673,
-0.0663168654,
0.6937623024,
-0.0799614713,
0.4773094356,
-0.6185348034,
0.0465999171,
0.4268777966,
0.1030592173,
-0.5249578357,
0.2029309869,
0.4348785877,
0.4609666467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17755v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17755v1 | Accelerating Clinical Evidence Synthesis with Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T17:41:52 | 2024-06-25T17:41:52 | Zifeng Wang, Lang Cao, Benjamin Danek, Yichi Zhang, Qiao Jin, Zhiyong Lu, Jimeng Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic medical discovery by AI is a dream of many. One step toward that
goal is to create an AI model to understand clinical studies and synthesize
clinical evidence from the literature. Clinical evidence synthesis currently
relies on systematic reviews of clinical trials and retrospective analyses from
medical literature. However, the rapid expansion of publications presents
challenges in efficiently identifying, summarizing, and updating evidence. We
introduce TrialMind, a generative AI-based pipeline for conducting medical
systematic reviews, encompassing study search, screening, and data extraction
phases. We utilize large language models (LLMs) to drive each pipeline
component while incorporating human expert oversight to minimize errors. To
facilitate evaluation, we also create a benchmark dataset TrialReviewBench, a
custom dataset with 870 annotated clinical studies from 25 meta-analysis papers
across various medical treatments. Our results demonstrate that TrialMind
significantly improves the literature review process, achieving high recall
rates (0.897-1.000) in study searching from over 20 million PubMed studies and
outperforming traditional language model embeddings-based methods in screening
(Recall@20 of 0.227-0.246 vs. 0.000-0.102). Furthermore, our approach surpasses
direct GPT-4 performance in result extraction, with accuracy ranging from 0.65
to 0.84. We also support clinical evidence synthesis in forest plots, as
validated by eight human annotators who preferred TrialMind over the GPT-4
baseline with a winning rate of 62.5%-100% across the involved reviews. Our
findings suggest that an LLM-based clinical evidence synthesis approach, such
as TrialMind, can enable reliable and high-quality clinical evidence synthesis
to improve clinical research efficiency. | [
0.0750199184,
-0.4488114715,
0.9883951545,
0.0612896904,
-0.2672196329,
-0.1479722708,
-0.2696169615,
-0.2066350132,
0.1878092885,
0.4899401069,
-0.4230964184,
-0.7780795693,
-0.7616757751,
0.002075355,
-0.4740461707,
0.9528875351,
-0.2059468776,
0.5801919699,
0.0736588761,
-0.2170877904,
-0.2883073986,
-0.4399049878,
-0.543073833,
-0.5579842329,
0.5444484949,
0.1429105997,
0.4182670712,
0.4798756838,
0.7620110512,
0.2841204703,
0.2078174353,
0.2498894036,
-0.4575612843,
0.4208070636,
0.0107192853,
-0.6653932929,
-0.5200386643,
-0.1028423086,
0.2741194963,
0.7890494466,
-0.4990468919,
-0.0913501307,
-0.2551659048,
0.9068368077,
-0.3809324801,
0.3545947671,
-0.7178790569,
0.2104899585,
-0.1655153334,
-0.2285105139,
-0.3393987715,
-0.6144303679,
0.4358605444,
-0.7331959009,
0.6362555027,
0.1309463084,
0.4923717976,
0.3097068369,
-0.1730270237,
-0.4794410467,
-0.6101461649,
0.4385730326,
-1.1407335997,
0.0330324434,
0.0797589868,
0.4504812658,
-0.4247517586,
-0.9670869708,
-0.5420392752,
-0.2056647986,
-0.0775415301,
0.2478943765,
0.1849090755,
0.2752042413,
0.4190119207,
0.5162932277,
-0.5778185129,
-0.0673647076,
-0.3830291927,
-0.256627053,
0.8531951308,
0.3144900203,
0.5163559914,
-0.0301785488,
0.2103637606,
-0.2577508688,
-1.060341835,
-0.2209556252,
-0.2768816352,
0.1732855588,
0.4054660201,
0.8057195544,
-0.2341569513,
0.3830054998,
-0.2277164161,
-0.0781119242,
0.2349321991,
-0.3643490374,
-0.2645259202,
0.2601308823,
1.007126689,
0.6129253507,
-0.0610321201,
-0.0198340435,
-0.1170368418,
0.3879748881,
0.4507463872,
-0.9139153957,
-0.5482087731,
0.5329204798,
-0.7193557024,
-0.2898841202,
-0.2451497018,
-0.5015740395,
-0.8399128318,
-0.1382894367,
0.4147341251,
-0.6266261339,
-0.2176478356,
0.309270978,
-0.4467982948,
-0.0332926959,
0.710688889,
-0.538579762,
0.2910803258,
0.567902863,
0.6701506376,
-0.2756031156,
0.0512305424,
-0.3225131035,
0.2145199925,
-0.6947236061,
0.7069741488,
-0.2103624046,
-0.4391250908,
0.2671374381,
-0.036973238,
-0.1332789063,
-0.6214693189,
0.6013090611,
-0.3242985308,
0.3895677328,
-0.1155130938,
-0.936367631,
-0.2041277736,
0.152819097,
-0.5768855214,
0.5307782888,
-0.0679652393,
-0.5599108934,
0.6301056147,
-0.7547798753,
-0.6944173574,
0.2067913264,
-0.4438059628,
-0.4677938223,
0.3614396751,
0.6291236281,
0.2531066835,
-0.4363352656,
0.6800088286,
-0.2782346904,
-0.2835019827,
0.2565512955,
-0.0467797257,
0.6846581697,
0.3348895311,
-0.6521649957,
0.3062742949,
-0.404558301,
-0.1150867566,
0.1532154381,
-0.0725752413,
-0.3646825254,
0.3657487631,
-0.0889591947,
-0.0473319069,
-0.2941062152,
-0.6210210919,
0.3987807631,
-0.4966494739,
0.5468749404,
0.4525310993,
0.1710430533,
0.1082887799,
-0.4681386948,
0.3591509759,
-0.0626315102,
0.1476452947,
-0.3812673688,
-0.6757267714,
-0.8739086986,
-0.1773564965,
0.6097723246,
0.3949348927,
-0.694070816,
0.4555201828,
-0.5470200181,
-0.280726105,
-0.855163753,
-0.1930186152,
0.1875381023,
0.3204818964,
0.3299766481,
-0.766425252,
-0.4500568509,
-0.9016039371,
-0.1005794704,
-0.3870820999,
-0.2947376668,
0.3085035384,
0.3488157392,
-0.3436693847,
0.7944030166,
-0.8022902608,
-0.7882919908,
-0.27241835,
0.3583573997,
0.3925662637,
0.3800520599,
0.0308751874,
-0.6094836593,
-0.3405263126,
0.1058014929,
-1.1185467243,
-0.1735825688,
-0.2629386783,
0.0327635035,
-0.0949354023,
0.6131480932,
-0.7100896835,
0.5261870623,
-0.0028705902,
0.0439448245,
0.1232244372,
-0.1905144155,
0.2119319588,
-0.687905848,
0.299135834,
-0.1989113986,
-0.1258455962,
-0.5389692187,
0.1185302138,
0.0034669645,
-0.0995936096,
-0.0783199444,
0.3459098041,
-0.4477501512,
0.2346806973,
-0.1803501099,
-0.0445087738,
-0.3123052716,
0.3294631839,
0.1728767157,
0.5403292775,
0.2877248526,
-0.2687512636,
0.0308256168,
0.4246861041,
-0.5275790095,
0.1341012716,
-0.7001323104,
-0.1174096018,
-0.0409084298,
0.496003449,
-0.8996352553,
-0.4712402523,
0.226916939,
-0.423001647,
0.3491082191,
-0.3281321526,
-0.4142146409,
-0.4973506331,
-0.2386525124,
0.0628623217,
0.6507307291,
-0.1473289579,
0.6046283245,
0.6563443542,
-0.7337608337,
-0.2034914047,
-0.4966955483,
0.4782051146,
0.1464198381,
-0.3588038087,
0.3816700876,
-0.0493124761,
-0.2099104077,
-0.0055473838,
0.1382774264,
0.1191103682,
-0.2174966931,
0.3180525899,
0.2701558769,
-0.0748651773,
0.1322654039,
0.2556950748,
0.1262703836,
0.350443691,
-0.2050198317,
0.2027764618,
0.2646442652,
-0.6519965529,
-0.1610251963,
0.4315447807,
0.7086473703,
0.0612596534,
0.0622372851,
0.3883628845,
-0.5962167978,
-0.2793491483,
-0.7164849043,
-0.3415595591,
-0.3978720009,
0.2820332646,
-0.0244603846,
-0.832256496,
0.1412956566,
-0.1461998224,
0.4506167471,
0.6081259251,
0.9841439724,
-0.0193408653,
1.3741468191,
0.1900950372,
0.0165863466,
0.2656191289,
-0.2972218692,
0.2910765409,
-0.8747823238,
-0.1339684874,
-0.1361381114,
-0.1882637292,
-0.446691364,
-0.6288715601,
0.8769457936,
-0.5051002502,
0.1214765832,
-0.10993094,
-0.6801429391,
0.0070737959,
0.7263697386,
0.4368175566,
0.423899889,
0.0301123802,
-0.322029978,
-0.2304498255,
-0.9078078866,
-0.277172029,
1.8069684505,
0.2957961261,
0.5719994307,
-0.0362875685,
0.7896488309,
0.5792128444,
1.0560311079,
-0.6992540956,
0.5553519726,
-0.0595055409,
-0.9152651429,
-0.161588788,
-0.2421355695,
-0.9089745283,
0.2879817784,
-0.3793523312,
-0.1604693234,
-0.0384343266,
0.0010173341,
-0.5056044459,
0.0224387553,
-0.7367495298,
0.4478512406,
-0.1680997312,
-0.3539272249,
-0.4865007997,
-0.6783485413,
0.5817006826,
-0.023892181,
0.0763248578,
-0.0141920606,
0.3051453233,
0.7724574208,
-0.7536373138,
0.7152274251,
-0.3016115129,
0.1469626725,
0.242392242,
0.0257902667,
0.4692530036,
0.1782010943,
0.1563504934,
0.049390953,
-0.1606803536,
-0.1711775512,
-0.4093619585,
0.5674609542,
-0.5565502644,
-0.7365295291,
-0.7121676803,
-0.6333174706,
-0.3598355949,
0.2960239649,
0.2215921283,
0.4091204405,
-0.4148359299,
-0.0742708519,
0.6195816398,
-0.3717257082,
0.0249240883,
0.5652727485,
-0.197657153,
-0.5830697417,
0.6795582771,
-0.0266359914,
-0.2223378569,
0.2639419734,
0.1795054823,
-0.2590669692,
-1.3173594475,
-0.5450606346,
0.1814919263,
-0.5186124444,
-0.171797961,
-0.8709800243,
-0.3519325256,
-0.4713715613,
0.1614103615,
-0.2180830389,
-0.3450725973,
0.315192163,
0.0754718333,
0.1272719949,
0.7928799391,
0.2015127689,
0.2478055358,
-0.6356224418,
0.5599763393,
0.3076075315,
0.2160931826,
-0.0349100269,
-0.1886280626,
-0.1534588635,
-0.0787260681,
-0.2744428217,
-0.6193323135,
0.5900012255,
0.1159487218,
0.5221387744,
0.4811812639,
0.063037701,
0.7574945092,
-0.925196588,
0.7822667956,
0.3667380512,
-0.6109032631,
0.5929125547,
-0.468302846,
0.2357810885,
0.8028739095,
0.23757267,
-0.4768001139,
-0.6411876082,
-0.6499673724,
-1.0440254211,
0.6393575668,
0.4187098145,
-0.4781675339,
0.1654522717,
0.1672890335,
0.272205323,
0.3874513507,
-0.3126420975,
-0.058511395,
0.1132750735,
-0.4994845986,
-0.1539916545,
-0.0655713901,
-0.8043821454,
-0.3047070503,
0.6595737338,
-0.3506144583,
0.5955463648,
0.7371683121,
-0.3409064114,
-0.179089129,
0.1046488881,
0.4391072094,
0.8088094592,
-0.4862194955,
-0.0526573695,
-0.1935403645,
-0.7248169184,
-0.0198519323,
0.518122673,
-0.4295720756,
0.1157656088,
0.725523293,
0.5299501419,
-0.1659121662,
-0.9240882397,
0.542966783,
-0.5943076611,
-0.4729327261,
-0.5204411149,
0.2246846557,
0.0328282863,
0.0699817464,
0.5596202016,
0.1853849292,
0.6153745055,
-0.3498251736,
0.2448815703,
0.4307597876,
-0.2790136635,
-0.1744876057,
0.8495305181,
0.2712616324,
-0.0473420359,
0.7975604534,
0.1543648392,
-0.3780688345,
0.5237203836,
0.1202307418,
0.9710027575,
0.1689971834,
0.0772999525,
0.4869334996,
0.2614084482,
-0.3059801757,
0.112764895,
0.2619724274,
-0.4575552046,
-0.5089119673,
-0.323213309,
-0.7449321151,
0.1312260479,
-0.3237581849,
0.0520508736,
-0.38937217,
-0.2154635191,
0.2700940073,
-0.0990106016,
-0.6162262559,
0.2555595636,
0.123644419,
0.7491781116,
-0.7377633452,
0.8786398172,
0.4977203608,
-0.1565904468,
-0.6747032404,
-0.1386666596,
0.2002309412,
-0.7990376949,
0.0858303532,
0.2362837344,
0.2988247871,
-0.2481034249,
-0.5341956615,
-0.5305544734,
1.1782517433,
0.0063644988,
-0.7960394621,
0.0023938457,
-0.0495422482,
1.0117378235,
-0.6998001933,
0.4889957905,
0.4154166579,
0.3287231326,
0.1881856471,
-0.6506865621,
0.234477818,
-0.4407927394,
-0.2002701759,
0.0260497052,
-0.0938959643,
0.4429289401,
-0.3959372342,
-0.2271127701,
0.1451722831,
0.4164233208,
0.3288204968,
0.4766969085,
0.5622705221,
0.6996605396,
0.7997569442,
-0.1842789054,
1.0680155754,
-0.3362247646,
0.0284552481,
0.9954015613,
-0.828341186,
0.6838539839,
0.4569559395,
-0.4037261009,
0.561060369,
0.6838911772,
0.1539986134,
0.5357087851,
0.247291252,
-0.2359422445,
-0.3047681153,
-0.0017418186,
-0.4139361084,
-0.1217582524,
0.5810089707,
-0.6734967232,
0.1167481989,
-0.2272943854,
0.0125667462,
-0.1476281583,
-0.0995144844,
1.0216569901,
0.104317002,
-1.2784782648,
0.6046301126,
-0.2188452184,
0.2399658263,
-0.9566240311,
-0.2393762022,
-0.2814062238,
0.5212255716,
-0.0457045175,
-0.6352522969,
-0.0646857917,
-0.1849914491,
0.1159039959,
-0.0888208523,
0.561971724,
-0.4986748099,
-0.6950344443,
0.0120860748,
0.5511329174,
-0.0286584329,
0.0429426134,
-0.6973382831,
0.0526764877,
0.1462602466,
-0.1370802373,
0.3033548892,
0.4338368177,
-0.3403286636,
0.6911163926,
1.005961895,
0.6083670259,
-0.154859066,
0.1993874758,
1.0494667292,
-0.5619404316,
-0.3003977537,
-0.6294452548,
0.1200008243,
-0.3819611669,
-0.1412733048,
0.4770201743,
0.4804095328,
0.3109821379,
-0.1498680562,
1.1775217056,
-0.3099729419,
0.6264953017,
-0.4892618954,
0.8749747276,
-0.5215980411,
0.1591900587,
-0.1698456705,
-0.5796471238,
-0.5569919348,
0.3186169565,
-0.2248796076,
-0.3217681348,
0.9124305248,
0.7495273352,
0.1454135925,
0.1285774112,
-0.0565840714,
0.5881572962,
0.7938716412,
0.7126370072,
0.5069352388,
-0.53877455,
0.2510363162,
0.1398167759,
-0.5151103735,
-0.1799491495,
-0.7610673308,
-0.9042100906,
-0.2709098756,
-0.3298435807,
-0.3338131607,
0.3101505637,
0.9262977242,
0.8470136523,
-1.1195393801,
-0.2320272475,
-0.3069137931,
-0.0132842567,
-0.4940385222,
-0.1245519891,
0.6558685303,
-0.3187116683,
-0.4657949507,
0.3950729072,
0.3276673853,
-0.3594085872,
-0.2546183467,
-0.1241896823,
-0.3322023451,
-0.1272709221,
0.4144342542,
0.1311392039,
-0.6843857169,
0.1636014879,
-0.1354720145,
-0.1641204655,
0.0745277703,
1.2048027515,
-0.820528388,
0.8422099948,
0.4557577372,
0.6830519438,
0.9290006757,
-0.2081867605,
1.1094529629,
-0.1107412577,
-0.0342356674,
0.4989353716,
0.5063697696,
0.414020896,
-0.0715729371,
0.8305847049,
0.4145765603,
-0.6643189788,
-0.7360932827,
-0.1044678017,
-0.8512880206,
-0.3050456941,
0.9350860119,
-0.1624246091,
-0.3055792749,
-0.1738979816,
-0.4627079666,
0.1276391298,
-0.3809604347,
1.2019395828,
0.5352879763,
-0.2255384773,
0.1396421641,
-0.5957381129,
0.7969522476,
0.5563649535,
-0.7598810196,
0.1145312861,
0.692581892,
0.1997959614,
0.1384480596,
0.9897897243,
-0.4450488687,
0.3913298845,
-0.1561928838,
0.3062629104,
0.1652745306,
0.0202713758,
-0.2023672611,
0.1315189153,
0.1418921351,
0.1892362535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17753v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17753v1 | Measuring and Benchmarking Large Language Models' Capabilities to Generate Persuasive Language | 2024-06-25T17:40:47 | 2024-06-25T17:40:47 | Amalie Brogaard Pauli, Isabelle Augenstein, Ira Assent | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We are exposed to much information trying to influence us, such as teaser
messages, debates, politically framed news, and propaganda - all of which use
persuasive language. With the recent interest in Large Language Models (LLMs),
we study the ability of LLMs to produce persuasive text. As opposed to prior
work which focuses on particular domains or types of persuasion, we conduct a
general study across various domains to measure and benchmark to what degree
LLMs produce persuasive text - both when explicitly instructed to rewrite text
to be more or less persuasive and when only instructed to paraphrase. To this
end, we construct a new dataset, Persuasive-Pairs, of pairs each consisting of
a short text and of a text rewritten by an LLM to amplify or diminish
persuasive language. We multi-annotate the pairs on a relative scale for
persuasive language. This data is not only a valuable resource in itself, but
we also show that it can be used to train a regression model to predict a score
of persuasive language between text pairs. This model can score and benchmark
new LLMs across domains, thereby facilitating the comparison of different LLMs.
Finally, we discuss effects observed for different system prompts. Notably, we
find that different 'personas' in the system prompt of LLaMA3 change the
persuasive language in the text substantially, even when only instructed to
paraphrase. These findings underscore the importance of investigating
persuasive language in LLM generated text. | [
-0.1191964969,
-0.8468214869,
0.6786944866,
0.3679552376,
-0.1842619777,
-0.1226427928,
-0.4155711234,
0.1706708819,
0.1153235734,
0.5886407495,
-0.2257725298,
-0.6741167307,
-0.5252906084,
0.3762501776,
-0.5692762733,
1.0416892767,
-0.141361177,
0.0912773162,
-0.451597631,
0.0902144089,
-0.3238075376,
-0.8973785639,
-0.4887333512,
-0.4967760444,
0.9275752306,
0.5800286531,
0.4519546628,
0.4660730064,
0.3573961556,
0.1947333813,
-0.1694017947,
-0.3845233023,
-0.7211455703,
0.4579761624,
-0.1592761427,
-0.474018544,
-0.1766625047,
0.1320427358,
1.0094147921,
0.5477284193,
0.0458659679,
0.1418071985,
0.268486321,
0.2820052803,
-0.5742669702,
0.0168571956,
-0.8691737652,
-0.1532667279,
-0.2740623653,
-0.2178193033,
-0.3795415461,
-0.5160885453,
-0.0159066804,
-0.2224666774,
-0.0627497882,
-0.0028371112,
0.6023949385,
0.1646223515,
-0.5843620896,
-0.1924475282,
-0.5014998317,
0.8146058917,
-0.767855227,
0.2844770551,
0.2055903226,
-0.0903232545,
-0.1578190774,
-0.7344356775,
-0.6203833222,
-0.4989724159,
0.152093783,
-0.0807047188,
-0.1739235818,
-0.1965315491,
0.3959525526,
0.0674588755,
-0.4940973222,
0.2704153359,
0.1428180337,
-0.2568086088,
0.5545117855,
0.2723216116,
0.1654444039,
-0.2556068301,
-0.4507961571,
-0.3403840363,
-1.0575596094,
-0.0813306868,
0.5358220935,
0.1492192298,
0.027559787,
0.6226317883,
-0.225251317,
0.3155078888,
-0.0837028846,
-0.4051542878,
-0.0181696694,
-0.3045028448,
-0.2160232067,
0.036252737,
0.9556640387,
0.2961209118,
0.2372629941,
0.0456900075,
-0.3342935145,
0.196034506,
-0.1211239174,
-0.9227043986,
-0.2104074359,
-0.1966690123,
-0.5627123117,
-0.2888856828,
-0.126312688,
-0.679957211,
-0.5983834267,
-0.2391296327,
0.3576110601,
-0.2188212872,
-0.1994233429,
0.192402035,
-0.0616232343,
0.1708465964,
0.0729051754,
-0.7464497685,
0.1596744657,
0.8847371936,
0.6276564002,
-0.2298149318,
-0.3600485921,
-0.4677562118,
0.1747835726,
-0.5506530404,
0.8668953776,
-0.8385925889,
-0.403028816,
0.3592590988,
-0.1583299935,
0.0924612656,
-0.6181350946,
0.6857205629,
-0.2323225886,
0.0454317369,
-0.47288993,
-0.6296528578,
0.0826766565,
0.3140341938,
-0.5373351574,
0.7391276956,
-0.2972453535,
-0.6232352257,
0.3534144759,
-0.2626469135,
-0.5284560919,
-0.1671112925,
-0.321605742,
-0.4493532479,
0.1767368168,
-0.0036680093,
0.756429255,
-0.703055203,
0.5924701691,
-0.1868110448,
-0.0337421037,
0.6367451549,
-0.6099213362,
0.3101555109,
0.0600813627,
-0.2020694613,
0.3187473714,
-0.5979312658,
-0.3136778474,
0.2575553358,
-0.6027962565,
-0.5265697241,
-0.0156564843,
0.0787851214,
0.0174531657,
0.5558381081,
-0.3802860677,
0.0794324577,
0.0391579829,
0.3035250902,
0.6644479036,
0.2190733552,
0.0446504802,
-0.2942052484,
0.5476812124,
-0.3154751658,
-0.1001239195,
-0.2902403474,
-0.5178283453,
-0.55222404,
-0.0421929322,
0.123074621,
0.2845101058,
-0.5115873218,
0.0791580006,
-0.1911900043,
-0.4225871563,
-0.1321024001,
0.1893267334,
0.5674721599,
0.5746056437,
0.0525455959,
0.0445496701,
-0.5899804831,
-1.0828560591,
-0.5204770565,
-0.4135967195,
0.0244594626,
0.0726989284,
0.5129901171,
0.0636763796,
0.5309070945,
-0.4774993062,
0.1484920979,
-0.3618405163,
0.3279114068,
0.0495397933,
0.2128950655,
0.3897237778,
-0.7562572956,
-0.585965693,
-0.2983193398,
-0.7405441999,
-0.6431481838,
-0.1771475673,
0.2083542794,
-0.0427704193,
0.6363207102,
-0.2721256912,
0.1136516035,
0.5511085987,
-0.227279529,
0.7902873158,
-0.0471023768,
0.3007500172,
-1.1376909018,
0.0772772878,
0.2814665437,
0.0953329504,
-0.7453127503,
-0.063126348,
-0.0414312817,
-0.0657205507,
-0.4429233372,
0.5675671101,
-0.2357646823,
0.1797699332,
-0.3475524485,
0.0664283484,
-0.0276198406,
0.0785188824,
0.010791095,
0.8500158787,
0.4149086177,
-0.5886974931,
0.3036532104,
0.3285740316,
-0.5194658637,
0.5917106271,
-0.620903194,
-0.0599312223,
-0.0579116158,
0.36361292,
-1.1773062944,
-0.3458282053,
-0.0126728714,
-0.1599602848,
0.0076933042,
-0.0344763994,
-0.5832486153,
-0.1461161822,
-0.1714829952,
0.0840652063,
0.4190300703,
-0.3818064332,
0.2915817797,
0.3434477746,
-0.4271084964,
-0.2882801592,
-0.4565003216,
0.4163983464,
-0.694922328,
-0.3383754492,
0.3389970064,
-0.0743830577,
-0.5760807395,
-0.351593703,
0.0188728087,
0.1672555953,
0.1165022701,
0.3269373477,
0.1388743818,
-0.2756124735,
0.288236618,
-0.0096724201,
-0.1769659668,
0.3981285691,
-0.0594881587,
0.6851868629,
-0.0265657045,
-0.2444937974,
-0.5453933477,
0.4333772361,
0.5072479844,
0.0319395922,
0.7648196816,
0.3052448034,
-0.1409274787,
0.1668322235,
-0.8755212426,
-0.3082036078,
-0.4041984677,
0.3939677179,
-0.4449077845,
-0.8046507239,
0.2154774517,
-0.2284039557,
0.070650965,
0.4107565284,
0.7148993611,
0.2899418175,
0.9285103679,
0.5057002306,
-0.2423809618,
0.5649049878,
0.0042805285,
0.0207114741,
-0.5661315322,
-0.2340747118,
-0.8097481728,
-0.114206627,
-0.3945408463,
-0.2790926397,
0.2507036924,
0.0136396708,
-0.4290768802,
0.2412027568,
-0.2165767103,
0.3145552576,
0.5114123821,
-0.2816683054,
0.3104259372,
0.1775416285,
-0.1359062642,
-0.161056146,
-0.5045215487,
-1.0970373154,
1.1339001656,
0.3552812338,
0.7367859483,
0.0349606127,
0.6889627576,
0.1921126693,
0.630782187,
-0.505417943,
1.0265530348,
-0.1890079826,
-0.3575098217,
-0.1195255518,
-0.4818486571,
-0.9765402079,
0.0976250991,
-0.3997605741,
-0.5630865693,
-0.0910468698,
0.0523035228,
-0.0836113393,
0.4258785546,
-0.5509594083,
0.7174448371,
-0.2633727789,
-0.4368287027,
-0.3528350592,
-0.2397376299,
0.1431336999,
-0.2695168555,
-0.1493384242,
-0.2880410254,
-0.3475859165,
1.0606960058,
0.0252395552,
0.9692656398,
0.0134656662,
-0.4910419285,
0.045148287,
-0.0734406263,
0.4827698171,
-0.0290791653,
-0.4316562414,
0.1025869399,
-0.3072877824,
-0.1984293014,
-0.285628736,
1.014475584,
-0.6268447638,
-0.9703187943,
-0.0829389393,
-0.5022653341,
-0.2137040943,
0.1350603998,
0.1579013914,
0.3212582767,
-0.5891416669,
0.4757333398,
0.6913916469,
-0.3824569285,
0.3324079514,
0.5152648091,
-0.2804402709,
-0.384439081,
0.9687232971,
-0.0543499328,
0.4487337768,
0.7273904681,
0.7004973888,
-0.4271776378,
-0.5939742327,
0.0350342542,
0.387123704,
-0.7034121156,
-0.1196667999,
-0.5528770089,
0.0733753964,
-0.6418620348,
-0.1113827601,
-0.0462920256,
-0.2241929471,
-0.3906390965,
0.0804798678,
0.2091056108,
1.1084303856,
0.0266995002,
0.3426338732,
-0.4808820486,
0.024547467,
0.4011009037,
-0.0845440924,
-0.1497164965,
-0.5179318786,
-0.0430815555,
-0.1084526703,
-0.3623329103,
-0.9378632307,
0.4396204352,
-0.1894099861,
0.696367979,
0.4588383138,
0.0641982257,
0.4582464993,
-0.3630347848,
0.9415824413,
0.3503601849,
-0.9664263725,
0.4444838166,
-0.4225950837,
0.1207915843,
0.3193347454,
0.5319526196,
-0.5615196228,
-0.4565305114,
-0.5565416813,
-0.8219166994,
0.213615641,
-0.0239313841,
0.2690232396,
-0.1594891995,
0.3264498711,
0.263014406,
0.4900041819,
-0.7372519374,
-0.2105933279,
-0.0173980352,
-0.167508617,
-0.3352130055,
-0.5626651645,
-0.1868176311,
0.1536431909,
0.7235062718,
-0.0678930581,
-0.0861852616,
0.002801246,
0.1998588741,
0.0158401821,
0.4318862557,
0.6203112602,
0.4493204951,
0.0615164414,
0.1816600859,
0.126712814,
-0.2986400723,
0.3292544186,
0.0161770117,
-0.2438178807,
-0.0912806615,
0.4060816169,
0.8740959167,
0.1665075421,
-0.6036410928,
0.334995687,
0.0082207341,
-0.4047200978,
0.020949509,
-0.019246703,
0.3225301206,
0.2337952554,
0.4419564307,
-0.445537895,
-0.1433750987,
-0.487198621,
-0.0020691333,
0.5261958241,
0.0355848521,
-0.3245308101,
0.7224662304,
0.3482285738,
-0.54795748,
0.0888157114,
0.1447712779,
-0.409262836,
0.4459192753,
0.7086533308,
0.6477128267,
-0.2880378366,
0.1363593787,
0.2725235522,
0.1483353823,
-0.2003921568,
0.002398625,
0.1653694212,
-0.5449781418,
-0.2904433906,
-0.3571151197,
-0.5412588716,
0.7008473873,
-0.5061311722,
0.0529278032,
-0.4395958483,
-0.2593266368,
0.1628760397,
0.1186761558,
-0.4804188609,
0.1035191268,
0.2733982503,
0.715677321,
-1.2424594164,
0.6728234887,
0.889256835,
-0.3179680407,
-0.5844063759,
0.6352755427,
0.062138319,
-0.6902211905,
0.7211772203,
0.1826493591,
-0.2360098213,
-0.1205444783,
-0.7079057693,
-0.8226186037,
0.7864598036,
0.478526175,
-0.637214005,
0.2622272074,
0.2503936291,
0.4488389492,
-0.671459198,
-0.1339139044,
0.5933234692,
0.6717815995,
-0.0643657818,
-0.6951552629,
0.2289277613,
0.1177959517,
0.090626657,
0.1521584392,
-0.5693825483,
0.8477545381,
-0.0998914018,
-0.2389926612,
0.2873934209,
0.7994062304,
0.2189797312,
0.2746108472,
0.549823761,
0.156730935,
0.6986227632,
0.0462169535,
0.9641239643,
-0.3052297533,
-0.0992344469,
0.9010825753,
-0.6647806168,
1.0402340889,
0.6492022872,
0.1410238892,
0.4750718176,
0.2383337617,
0.2392709404,
0.2528378665,
0.4896438122,
-0.4369878173,
-0.4855227172,
-0.3750551939,
-0.2146843672,
0.298556,
0.4206615388,
-0.4253297746,
-0.0845221728,
0.211601302,
0.2612065673,
0.5958613157,
-0.0082349842,
0.754068315,
0.062486846,
-0.9168806076,
0.5502719283,
0.0033878409,
0.582285881,
-0.5753960013,
0.03129429,
-0.2137971073,
0.1793889254,
0.0402075723,
-0.9263145328,
-0.0393625759,
0.2029760331,
-0.1319816858,
-0.5235425234,
0.5895531774,
-0.5551679134,
-0.3722878993,
0.2365928441,
0.5621048212,
0.3529230952,
0.1046684682,
-0.6008660793,
0.3872195482,
0.1756940186,
-0.4064005911,
0.5051998496,
0.4668189883,
-0.0018837772,
0.6660405397,
0.8340964913,
0.220456928,
-0.3414746225,
0.2914256155,
0.9133893847,
-0.675299108,
-0.1069560125,
-1.002430439,
0.0668404847,
-0.2471632212,
-0.452182889,
1.0378198624,
0.6393162608,
0.644546628,
0.0872531235,
0.8601546884,
0.1126261279,
0.5539212227,
-0.4881337285,
0.4978491664,
-0.5197493434,
0.4042516947,
-0.2562065721,
-0.8074497581,
-0.299518615,
0.5622849464,
-0.6484339237,
-0.1962346137,
0.5931982398,
0.9795638323,
0.3777729273,
-0.0276304651,
0.4657266736,
0.3915032148,
0.4855689704,
0.361643523,
0.9871615171,
-0.016533548,
0.7531684041,
0.0928163826,
-0.1495338082,
-0.1317902505,
-1.1150238514,
-1.0791624784,
-0.6515077353,
-0.5163074136,
-0.4685945213,
0.1956424564,
0.7401890159,
0.2337949276,
-0.3800740242,
-0.4746827781,
0.0770598799,
0.1603445113,
-0.0362341478,
-0.1616806239,
0.236205861,
-0.1204614267,
-0.6265415549,
0.4829574227,
0.205727756,
0.0197131559,
-0.6476922035,
0.0678000972,
-0.2966643274,
0.3418768644,
0.5077995658,
0.2017395943,
-0.8060714006,
-0.1240390912,
-0.1353667974,
-0.3214716315,
-0.0583521724,
1.014292717,
-0.5929893851,
-0.0642860383,
0.5740203857,
0.3662737608,
0.1761735827,
-0.1207886413,
0.646854043,
-0.6092877388,
-0.1925854683,
0.1787849069,
0.3567295969,
0.7176172733,
0.0948414579,
0.2030213773,
0.131056726,
-0.6767001748,
-0.7843929529,
0.2002697736,
-0.4162432849,
-0.3411986232,
1.7447972298,
-0.2060361654,
-0.1835238636,
-0.1016391665,
-0.3479227424,
0.1295576841,
-0.6233915687,
0.5891420245,
0.6261802316,
0.1991126388,
0.180643484,
-0.2071576864,
0.4484051466,
0.5174532533,
-0.8588771224,
0.4216273725,
0.4959284365,
0.4020556211,
0.1582991481,
0.6300937533,
0.2380963564,
-0.1513560861,
0.0942224637,
-0.1385189593,
0.1037548929,
-0.3882005215,
-0.3043438196,
0.2895733416,
0.095464848,
0.084446691
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17746v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17746v1 | Recite, Reconstruct, Recollect: Memorization in LMs as a Multifaceted Phenomenon | 2024-06-25T17:32:16 | 2024-06-25T17:32:16 | USVSN Sai Prashanth, Alvin Deng, Kyle O'Brien, Jyothir S V, Mohammad Aflah Khan, Jaydeep Borkar, Christopher A. Choquette-Choo, Jacob Ray Fuehne, Stella Biderman, Tracy Ke, Katherine Lee, Naomi Saphra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Memorization in language models is typically treated as a homogenous
phenomenon, neglecting the specifics of the memorized data. We instead model
memorization as the effect of a set of complex factors that describe each
sample and relate it to the model and corpus. To build intuition around these
factors, we break memorization down into a taxonomy: recitation of highly
duplicated sequences, reconstruction of inherently predictable sequences, and
recollection of sequences that are neither. We demonstrate the usefulness of
our taxonomy by using it to construct a predictive model for memorization. By
analyzing dependencies and inspecting the weights of the predictive model, we
find that different factors influence the likelihood of memorization
differently depending on the taxonomic category. | [
-0.1579836309,
-0.7458197474,
0.3112062216,
0.0068481211,
-0.0297848936,
0.3421329558,
-0.0725216568,
-0.2031163871,
0.4108825922,
0.7031726241,
-0.4252989888,
-0.1409096569,
-0.2883377969,
-0.1350874901,
-0.7716369629,
1.1699268818,
0.0504793413,
0.0328853279,
-0.1909986287,
-0.2435979098,
-0.3672704101,
-1.0778571367,
-0.4964270294,
-0.7186225653,
0.7220350504,
0.135732919,
0.3118493557,
0.6794168353,
0.3913592398,
0.3063405156,
-0.1964194924,
-0.1276741028,
-0.497697264,
0.0942337513,
-0.2170240134,
-0.9782400131,
-0.2669170797,
0.025185518,
0.9463047385,
1.0429451466,
-0.4936280847,
0.2603564858,
-0.075466983,
0.837765336,
-0.4025446475,
0.1359883696,
-0.773794055,
0.0005172491,
0.0904947817,
-0.549620688,
-0.3695862889,
-0.2391040921,
0.3985544741,
-0.4584623277,
0.5479797125,
-0.0857716575,
0.3747974038,
-0.0885537714,
-0.3249993026,
-0.3660381734,
-1.1776273251,
0.8002818823,
-0.2055197209,
0.5723574162,
0.5474104881,
0.1813815534,
0.1492775083,
-0.8707088232,
-0.4237899482,
-0.1359435469,
-0.0974995494,
-0.0101029975,
0.1340067387,
-0.0882017538,
0.4609898031,
0.7134036422,
-0.1376210898,
-0.3118226528,
-0.5625316501,
-0.486397177,
0.4093289673,
0.3848927915,
0.3971632719,
0.0401027203,
-0.4722941518,
0.3440412581,
-0.7375132442,
0.0279332716,
-0.0320434794,
0.4591888189,
0.3378456533,
0.5801260471,
0.1005804464,
0.3073473871,
-0.0244050995,
-0.6046304107,
0.5716714859,
-0.3221465349,
-0.2090287954,
-0.0102072628,
0.154846102,
-0.0082904808,
0.1915408969,
-0.3865885139,
-0.28085199,
-0.181947276,
0.513830781,
-0.5414200425,
-0.2406235635,
0.2141115963,
-0.6618553996,
0.1256246716,
0.0382858813,
-0.5134782195,
-0.1021582037,
-0.7069340944,
0.648717761,
-0.743553102,
-0.2482072711,
0.0835815668,
-0.1313627213,
-0.3264253736,
0.3261092007,
-0.7867286205,
0.4571092427,
0.7895240784,
0.7649205923,
-0.0169093683,
-0.7769269347,
-0.1851114482,
0.2927935421,
0.0455822796,
0.488376826,
-0.3662140965,
-0.3500930965,
0.1596930325,
0.1343751848,
-0.362523675,
-0.6763255,
0.1359447241,
-0.4455337524,
0.2360778749,
-0.2088759392,
-1.0634970665,
-0.8481644988,
0.1042135507,
-1.0568035841,
0.6437982917,
0.191455856,
-0.8129684925,
0.3625810444,
-0.0086657209,
-0.383915782,
-0.0353650451,
0.0238864906,
-0.5064025521,
0.2339438945,
-0.6534062624,
0.4414206147,
0.0457745381,
0.3910730481,
-0.116272442,
-0.29858163,
0.3137281835,
-0.054690931,
0.3175184131,
0.1488940418,
0.0444778353,
0.13660191,
-1.0111142397,
-0.2051334977,
-0.0064721568,
-0.7785295844,
-0.5709011555,
0.3038130105,
-0.0408088788,
0.2592900991,
0.0259243809,
-0.3768553138,
0.1802763939,
-0.1553132385,
0.3388908207,
0.4122137427,
0.1707235575,
0.6142274737,
-0.8405174613,
0.4943346083,
0.3098403811,
-0.2499625236,
-0.4023919702,
-0.1156515405,
-0.7611647844,
-0.3291268051,
-0.0486574173,
0.6021894217,
-0.5903368592,
-0.1888468266,
-0.2178763747,
-0.3702253699,
-0.2584961057,
0.3191611171,
0.7363398671,
0.2350947112,
0.186433956,
-0.6218215823,
-0.843639791,
-0.8993946314,
-0.1537454128,
-0.2300949693,
0.2131442875,
0.1479197592,
0.6342688203,
-0.1754246801,
0.5905519128,
-0.2476665825,
-0.3752179146,
-0.4068757892,
0.1789026707,
-0.0192985199,
0.2616253495,
0.5310753584,
-0.7689787149,
0.0073585887,
-0.2431932688,
-0.3196006715,
0.2527582943,
-0.2311510295,
0.1778482944,
0.3183455765,
0.8122160435,
-0.5140376687,
0.2258518934,
0.1310147792,
-0.2807915807,
0.3953176439,
-0.2314622253,
-0.2227072865,
-1.0065083504,
0.2313713878,
-0.4037165046,
-0.0284243748,
-0.9260396957,
0.0767307207,
0.0196039751,
0.260741502,
-0.4212778211,
0.1793616265,
-0.4370342195,
-0.162304908,
-0.05258248,
-0.202188015,
-0.1790549308,
0.4133748412,
0.2786631584,
0.4965011775,
0.2723826468,
-0.9111629128,
-0.0065849288,
-0.0705366209,
-0.5362302065,
0.2523731589,
-0.3616802692,
-0.2490921468,
-0.5505726933,
0.0268480368,
-1.0004756451,
-0.0072682798,
-0.1389140636,
-0.2434229106,
0.5191426873,
0.2109981626,
-0.3828296363,
-0.2501171529,
-0.1576271504,
0.3555141687,
0.2223103344,
-0.2226439863,
0.7562974095,
0.3880455494,
-0.0774368942,
-0.6277474761,
-0.501678288,
-0.575086832,
-0.5312582254,
0.2080262005,
0.2795236707,
-0.2793307304,
-0.3258170784,
-0.3202838898,
-0.0320139155,
-0.0295322258,
0.3684520125,
0.6217391491,
0.2484526783,
-0.0548519343,
0.5540040135,
-0.6057063937,
0.1162771285,
0.1344299763,
-0.2120538056,
0.9845756888,
-0.0888502076,
-0.149023816,
-0.032636337,
0.3444680274,
0.757093668,
-0.2341536582,
0.6728546023,
0.552547276,
-0.5981657505,
-0.0814365,
-0.5520125628,
-0.0424543209,
-0.2905135453,
0.6137205362,
-0.4892187417,
-0.7684611678,
0.8041238189,
-0.0187722668,
0.1101923734,
0.2382353842,
0.6168925166,
-0.1379829049,
0.5246273875,
0.6182854176,
-0.2108475715,
0.5224555731,
-0.2209301293,
-0.1351264417,
-0.8743835688,
-0.5638993979,
-0.4506245553,
-0.2101795077,
-0.5487783551,
-0.1649613678,
-0.2190023065,
0.3593993783,
-0.4166901708,
0.3259152472,
0.0246666186,
0.2315123975,
0.7677348256,
0.113224633,
0.4874494374,
0.1309264749,
-0.2066426128,
0.1091814116,
-0.5711804032,
-0.5499344468,
1.2860937119,
0.4778320193,
0.7101893425,
0.2487469316,
1.0693092346,
-0.0458772443,
0.4878461659,
-0.8862013817,
0.5056167841,
-0.1723240316,
-0.863471508,
-0.2422593385,
-0.3763294816,
-1.1591991186,
0.2649305463,
-0.1907715797,
-0.8637753129,
-0.0506729037,
0.2521115243,
-0.4122665226,
0.4699927568,
-0.5648167729,
0.2962666452,
-0.0362488478,
-0.0587104484,
-0.302128315,
-0.4734962285,
0.5978827477,
-0.3334664106,
0.3820336759,
0.0056672227,
-0.0171529632,
0.6121414304,
-0.1309932172,
0.9344348311,
0.1833585948,
-0.069860436,
0.4838256538,
0.588796258,
-0.0689407289,
-0.3582523763,
0.003914088,
-0.2639068365,
0.2781783044,
-0.0872178003,
-0.4167452455,
0.4307131469,
-0.7076150179,
-0.5371498466,
-0.2661100328,
-0.7133210301,
-0.0286174007,
0.1137154698,
0.2893616855,
0.3672759831,
-0.4912599325,
0.066250585,
0.6354154944,
-0.1611501127,
0.4863598049,
0.5973234773,
-0.8744888902,
-0.2621048987,
1.1720933914,
0.6123118401,
0.6864274144,
0.6429356337,
-0.0840338841,
-0.0146958521,
-0.5177288055,
0.3133391142,
0.2291094065,
-0.7856194377,
0.1654207706,
-0.6499967575,
-0.2324216813,
0.0112046404,
0.1914638877,
-0.2430068403,
-0.7851047516,
-0.2949209511,
-0.2458312064,
0.0798277184,
0.8509788513,
0.0361594222,
0.1655672044,
-0.727840066,
0.358889401,
0.2934184074,
0.4840157032,
0.309638232,
-0.5690214038,
-0.1626404077,
-0.2583408952,
-0.2675277591,
-0.4384638369,
0.5812061429,
0.5862402916,
0.7261337042,
0.1840633303,
-0.4824812114,
0.4280213416,
-0.5471986532,
0.5151066184,
0.2423178256,
-0.8823615313,
0.4397901595,
-0.1835454255,
0.3230845034,
0.3860463798,
0.518473208,
-0.674493432,
-0.4066692293,
-0.8625716567,
-0.9267151356,
0.5712018609,
-0.0627492145,
0.140720889,
-0.241794765,
0.4596323371,
0.3597547412,
0.4969139695,
-0.6658553481,
-0.4853522778,
-0.2347264588,
0.1095276549,
-0.6526184678,
-0.6795969605,
-0.0681717321,
-0.3168355227,
0.436314404,
0.2668277621,
0.3072077334,
0.0179085545,
-0.3862143159,
-0.0877501816,
0.4039887488,
0.9187760353,
0.690513134,
-0.5817361474,
0.3105391264,
-0.0056387088,
-0.72917068,
0.0643043295,
-0.2897287607,
-0.3855800927,
0.1521211416,
0.6343916655,
0.5963845849,
0.3501145542,
-0.553735137,
0.0373034552,
0.2775170803,
-0.2477104217,
-0.6516558528,
-0.0254840348,
0.4208133221,
-0.0133078182,
0.2336397022,
0.0692523867,
0.1479495168,
-1.2168526649,
0.4444100857,
0.1469326168,
-0.2908184528,
-0.4213579893,
0.4607977569,
-0.0504970551,
-0.4351154268,
0.6955723166,
0.1339947432,
-0.7854939103,
0.6892095804,
0.7302103043,
0.7469078898,
-0.7046685219,
0.0651879758,
0.82665205,
0.1343909502,
-0.3395793736,
0.6668254137,
0.2128362805,
-0.8083401322,
0.0145824468,
-0.6703705192,
0.012523626,
0.1011821702,
-1.0384594202,
-0.1121706143,
-0.767452836,
-0.2287164927,
0.4464813471,
-0.2565971315,
-0.6582683921,
0.3595605195,
0.3165798485,
0.7999403477,
-0.6816286445,
0.9744573236,
0.4015276134,
-0.7409601212,
-0.8278117776,
-0.2439689487,
0.3319864869,
-0.8956492543,
0.8388225436,
0.190138787,
0.0135476468,
-0.143473044,
-0.1588351578,
-0.9215402603,
1.2448945045,
-0.1648026407,
-0.6684587002,
0.1219827607,
0.057471659,
0.6270809174,
-0.5757167935,
0.1867497712,
0.827498436,
0.0334752575,
0.1649100631,
-1.0924298763,
-0.1801483631,
-0.1089041159,
0.0723568946,
0.3251612782,
-0.5123977065,
1.3056095839,
-0.6595730186,
-0.4293442667,
0.1238777414,
0.2722102702,
0.1017395183,
0.3856294751,
0.3235714138,
0.4851757884,
0.9071191549,
-0.0450049452,
1.1755123138,
-0.1021426916,
0.4085952938,
1.4405252934,
-0.118414335,
1.0767071247,
0.7459331155,
-0.2999592721,
0.4256018102,
0.3924611509,
0.1726927161,
0.3654423952,
0.4304540455,
-0.2805020809,
-0.2588127851,
-0.0774891227,
-0.3428525329,
0.5343066454,
0.6679596901,
-0.8925840855,
0.0437045135,
0.0988450274,
-0.1738963276,
0.1783568561,
-0.7673017979,
0.9261347055,
0.162184909,
-0.8239280581,
0.6555888057,
-0.2238339186,
0.4575771689,
-0.465754807,
0.0217565019,
-0.1826554835,
0.3633648753,
-0.314255774,
-0.8880087137,
0.4855465293,
-0.7403696775,
-0.6003816128,
-0.1787636727,
0.4969474375,
-0.9174730778,
-0.4393058121,
0.4200498462,
0.6364584565,
0.1794864088,
0.0880920887,
-0.3258938789,
-0.3117627501,
0.1415511072,
-0.2519505024,
0.3662896454,
0.2380672693,
-0.1453295648,
1.2816810608,
0.450407207,
-0.0453602299,
0.1386716515,
0.5409659147,
0.4604049921,
-0.86722821,
-0.1033841148,
-0.7814291716,
0.3696231246,
0.4797558784,
-0.1693662703,
0.6625030041,
0.6177829504,
0.9294818044,
-0.4977384508,
0.5814529061,
0.284570694,
1.054464221,
-0.4396470189,
0.5604284406,
-0.441155225,
0.3253567815,
-0.3892226219,
-0.7759540677,
-0.3531336486,
0.3486529887,
0.1077361554,
0.0065895081,
0.7681267262,
0.4763017297,
0.1784835309,
0.0861128792,
0.2654052973,
0.0546427704,
-0.057434164,
0.8093296289,
0.8866937757,
-0.0697073564,
0.4347241521,
-0.4023560286,
0.031835705,
-0.2486667335,
-0.5505104065,
-0.9295576811,
-1.0240740776,
-0.3200127184,
-0.5137968063,
-0.240501985,
1.0284129381,
0.2468318343,
-0.8279342055,
-0.3942773044,
0.0561268963,
0.2484790236,
-0.2908221185,
-0.191041708,
0.2467506975,
-0.274584949,
-0.521239996,
-0.2776893973,
0.1827676147,
0.5175051689,
-0.188711822,
0.0688876361,
-0.3893900216,
0.129148379,
1.0247730017,
0.5880807042,
-0.9840734601,
-0.2774944603,
-0.0248006694,
-0.1973329782,
-0.0278206542,
1.1197725534,
-0.7596214414,
0.4718207121,
0.3981319666,
0.261502862,
0.4058234096,
-0.0536326878,
0.6395703554,
-0.5452245474,
-0.0172750205,
0.0774856582,
0.5896367431,
0.1856952757,
-0.0004276909,
0.4849554002,
0.4185725749,
-0.2369866222,
-0.6150563359,
0.5455923676,
-0.9719400406,
-0.4318006635,
1.0740407705,
-0.3745818138,
-0.0854354724,
-0.3405948281,
-0.2023285925,
0.0964333415,
0.1210083291,
0.8674661517,
1.1018948555,
0.1428651363,
-0.3431059122,
-0.4280647039,
0.4995566905,
0.6009415984,
-0.3655537963,
0.1863784045,
0.5119299293,
0.6191936135,
0.5179969668,
0.637532413,
-0.1310688406,
0.2275591791,
0.0051038237,
0.230084002,
0.1429543942,
-0.4422359765,
-0.3475374877,
0.271885097,
0.2629915774,
-0.0026512314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17744v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17744v1 | Following Length Constraints in Instructions | 2024-06-25T17:29:52 | 2024-06-25T17:29:52 | Weizhe Yuan, Ilia Kulikov, Ping Yu, Kyunghyun Cho, Sainbayar Sukhbaatar, Jason Weston, Jing Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aligned instruction following models can better fulfill user requests than
their unaligned counterparts. However, it has been shown that there is a length
bias in evaluation of such models, and that training algorithms tend to exploit
this bias by learning longer responses. In this work we show how to train
models that can be controlled at inference time with instructions containing
desired length constraints. Such models are superior in length instructed
evaluations, outperforming standard instruction following models such as GPT4,
Llama 3 and Mixtral. | [
-0.206288591,
-0.2797958255,
0.826305747,
0.287512958,
-0.0991635099,
-0.0225849189,
0.1276939064,
-0.6123275757,
0.0691798478,
0.6218397021,
-0.9918859601,
-0.2359781116,
-0.630605638,
0.0710674673,
-0.4007012248,
1.0950239897,
-0.3721959889,
0.3129159808,
-0.3233144581,
-0.1067301258,
-0.7277197242,
-0.480758518,
-0.1667356938,
-0.7137437463,
0.4538061023,
0.1796753556,
0.9356546402,
1.1072201729,
0.3871607482,
0.2473747134,
-0.0288697463,
0.2533963621,
-0.3297849596,
-0.0949501395,
0.0878163949,
-0.6245837212,
-0.2042768598,
0.2188397944,
0.4985826313,
0.7187782526,
-0.1547421664,
0.0024173281,
0.1279724389,
0.5868506432,
-0.5945929289,
-0.0054506604,
0.0904480815,
0.3142852187,
0.0721115693,
-0.2114501595,
-0.4198538065,
-0.6425133348,
0.3790557981,
-0.6052077413,
-0.0136531275,
0.0010443493,
0.8046934009,
0.3971714079,
-0.3957981467,
-0.5233889222,
-0.7591602802,
0.7597087622,
-0.7132106423,
0.6290951967,
0.5265463591,
0.333694607,
-0.0766010806,
-0.688477993,
-0.2231559008,
-0.2229074538,
-0.2183553874,
0.0477222092,
0.3220889568,
0.3909682631,
0.6829158664,
0.058226265,
-0.4089988768,
0.5067308545,
-0.6401140094,
-0.0415048338,
0.6337949038,
0.3052338958,
0.0588455647,
-0.1327577084,
-0.5128054023,
0.0083708242,
-0.809661448,
0.0137026915,
0.7263112664,
-0.2372606397,
-0.2201447636,
0.6451045871,
-0.2944085598,
0.9539328814,
0.3830389678,
0.0700825825,
0.0010827238,
-0.1755857617,
-0.1852402538,
0.0656887665,
0.3915069699,
0.448385179,
0.1517702639,
-0.198082909,
-0.550259769,
0.0589878745,
0.1874957979,
-0.8584246635,
-0.096859552,
-0.0527696535,
-0.4740969241,
0.108415857,
0.1087775156,
-0.5707637668,
-0.1340593547,
-0.6958032846,
0.2975277901,
-0.4512358606,
0.4420189857,
0.0050663524,
-0.1383983493,
0.5538987517,
0.197887972,
-1.2807805538,
0.5142685175,
0.9165465832,
0.7969933748,
-0.0800601989,
-0.2110151798,
-0.8430300355,
0.2287847102,
-0.5979397893,
0.6593598723,
-1.0013362169,
-0.4915706217,
-0.1534083933,
-0.1531123072,
-0.0325172916,
-0.1028031185,
0.24823834,
-0.8312219977,
0.4665906131,
-0.363428086,
-1.0242092609,
-0.2713453174,
-0.1858549863,
-0.6282278299,
0.6956448555,
0.234359324,
-0.8013734221,
0.4691513181,
-0.7946850061,
-0.4219923615,
-0.1911958456,
-0.2190829515,
-0.2762237787,
0.1067689359,
0.6218665242,
0.3414357901,
-0.055065129,
-0.1599110067,
-0.4642641544,
-0.6092161536,
0.0449034609,
-0.3408621252,
0.6828086376,
0.2760946751,
-0.3211788535,
0.4618010223,
-0.6041375399,
0.1487545073,
-0.0144464821,
-0.3661731482,
-0.3715180755,
0.1933966875,
-0.6717268229,
-0.1639455557,
0.2442636043,
-0.344925195,
0.2586242259,
-0.2704254389,
0.641908884,
1.0397213697,
0.1930770129,
0.669585228,
-0.3420625925,
0.7686760426,
-0.4947687685,
0.3362788856,
-0.0397195742,
-0.1232177094,
-0.6979067922,
0.1762727201,
0.3657090068,
0.6272158027,
-0.6086325645,
0.0546846986,
-0.1533161849,
-0.2267246693,
-0.5993672013,
0.3405349851,
0.6842858791,
0.4615554512,
0.3550600708,
-0.3962915242,
-0.636230588,
-0.7604513764,
-0.1047644839,
0.1392987967,
-0.2596955299,
0.3049504459,
0.352121383,
-0.1816411614,
0.504124999,
-0.4869991243,
0.3662007451,
-0.2496724725,
0.0527752712,
0.1992945969,
0.4005650878,
0.4416304529,
-0.6130480766,
-0.570083797,
-0.1538796872,
-0.7160055041,
-0.2851723433,
-0.1258139312,
-0.1403963119,
0.024868872,
0.3697665334,
-0.6045103073,
0.7859460115,
0.4642632306,
0.0394113846,
0.5169513822,
-0.0650435686,
0.0579766966,
-0.6983125806,
-0.4949847758,
-0.0218748376,
-0.3894351721,
-0.4850111306,
-0.0504611656,
0.2513981462,
0.1992841214,
-0.1572311372,
0.308526814,
-1.0558587313,
-0.5101033449,
-0.4058789015,
-0.2216544449,
0.1926953346,
0.5229093432,
0.3767054677,
0.7491371632,
0.4626132846,
-0.6962583661,
0.3843579292,
0.4908501506,
-0.6194819808,
0.3429124057,
-0.8580179214,
0.4801163375,
0.039909862,
0.3363685608,
-0.4727082253,
-0.570730269,
0.0446131453,
-0.2510290742,
0.4505197108,
-0.300406903,
-0.2457229942,
-0.7121616602,
-0.2961784303,
0.1847250313,
0.699295342,
-0.8202899098,
0.3543386161,
-0.1719867289,
0.2338912934,
-0.9954625964,
-0.5897552967,
-0.71213305,
-0.3554045856,
-0.2325630486,
0.3167855144,
-0.0586543791,
-0.0531158186,
-0.130522266,
-0.3055605888,
-0.027651865,
-0.1468209326,
0.4544158876,
0.2905271649,
-0.0848172531,
-0.1368552744,
0.1488285959,
0.2992933691,
0.1310100853,
-0.2030048072,
0.5131109357,
0.326066494,
-0.73697263,
-1.0237698555,
0.4857113957,
0.1013538688,
-0.222992748,
0.4941083789,
0.275269568,
-0.1508096457,
-0.1832878143,
-0.4717826247,
-0.5369520187,
-0.4995370209,
0.2439823449,
-0.3304012418,
-0.8468465805,
0.3693459034,
0.4074203372,
0.2401637733,
0.0479443967,
0.1863913089,
-0.1619739532,
1.3974180222,
1.0520501137,
-0.0295169614,
0.7447478771,
-0.0850471407,
-0.1500883251,
-1.0987113714,
-0.1629102826,
-0.2283364683,
-0.3550284505,
-0.4352180064,
-0.3191358745,
0.0888724551,
0.2289374471,
-0.2577221692,
0.402097106,
-0.5328931808,
0.6664025187,
0.7075660825,
0.395478487,
-0.2924290001,
-0.0886878073,
-0.2461758405,
0.0836229995,
-0.8364108801,
-0.3501476943,
1.0928553343,
0.6564327478,
1.1553727388,
-0.1849245578,
0.7766583562,
0.1115642563,
0.3068192303,
-0.5551159382,
0.3059538305,
0.291543901,
-0.5523966551,
-0.1462522,
-0.450256139,
-0.7185140252,
-0.1615901142,
0.200393185,
-0.926489532,
0.0798040926,
0.3211194873,
-0.6560111046,
0.2735348046,
-0.7900734544,
0.4520112574,
-0.6161327958,
-0.4082088172,
-0.0623577088,
-0.9608005881,
0.149979502,
0.3168170154,
-0.2643331289,
0.092456907,
0.0078707067,
0.7803029418,
-0.6869524717,
0.9885371923,
-0.2266971916,
0.2292098999,
0.5344295502,
-0.0547914989,
0.4908678234,
-0.1643417925,
0.0897421613,
-0.2561641037,
-0.1914863586,
-0.5262508988,
-0.7876726985,
0.6249163747,
-0.8403937817,
-1.0096113682,
-0.1313684881,
-0.6224848628,
-0.3130436838,
0.1566808224,
0.4971680641,
0.3981454968,
0.0832526833,
-0.0875558928,
0.7601379156,
-0.0679005906,
0.5862744451,
0.214060545,
-0.1997694224,
-0.191510126,
0.3456496596,
0.1432514787,
0.581096828,
0.536024332,
0.0634580702,
-0.576693356,
-0.5584586859,
-0.5254189372,
0.1904877275,
-0.8223059773,
-0.2569256723,
-0.3713732064,
-0.4645312428,
-0.4380169809,
-0.2208477855,
-0.1521981955,
-0.3287126422,
-0.4864658713,
-0.5590330362,
0.3531320095,
1.2138700485,
-0.1028747037,
0.899600625,
-0.6952167749,
-0.0064934194,
0.4823803008,
0.6035242081,
0.0985994413,
-0.6717441678,
-0.0978369787,
-0.0982740894,
-0.4924827814,
-1.1685663462,
0.1392744929,
-0.0671417043,
0.5661060214,
0.6984987259,
-0.3544816375,
0.9150192142,
-0.801499784,
0.4913090765,
0.1838367432,
-0.8925409913,
0.6354623437,
0.0005451484,
0.4766224921,
0.1221911311,
1.0016628504,
-0.1576312333,
0.2063167095,
-0.3892058432,
-0.3474168181,
0.6977435946,
-0.0088335704,
0.1714807302,
0.0538854599,
0.7292400599,
0.2641640007,
0.1196149066,
-0.6855071783,
0.2236521691,
-0.2174098343,
-0.1420457214,
0.2645291388,
-0.4989456534,
-0.1498049349,
0.0842570886,
0.5904452801,
-0.0351431966,
0.4573014081,
0.0776416883,
-0.0450083427,
-0.0726151913,
0.0448442288,
0.6664130688,
1.1038672924,
-0.1102668494,
-0.2754425704,
0.3091063201,
-0.0879389644,
0.0094587756,
0.1975647956,
-0.1907306165,
-0.1987823695,
0.6568184495,
1.2279301882,
-0.1462081969,
-0.3486070037,
0.3633064628,
0.1121616364,
-0.1823003441,
-0.2399142534,
0.4586838186,
-0.0545235761,
0.4223344326,
-0.1310444027,
-0.1718264073,
0.2947020829,
-0.1957159936,
0.2138760686,
0.349806428,
-0.8582724333,
-0.3172843158,
0.8743812442,
-0.1017973796,
-0.3253343999,
0.8548883796,
0.3037814498,
-0.7195730209,
0.6299250722,
0.5410869122,
0.4042580128,
-0.5336782336,
0.1121120453,
0.2097922266,
0.2181117088,
-0.2046036422,
0.2742394507,
-0.4583283067,
-0.3924778104,
-0.6052703857,
-0.4656515718,
-0.3266411424,
-0.0380026139,
-1.0380756855,
0.275881052,
-0.9557202458,
-0.0868248791,
-0.0060676662,
-0.1224081591,
-0.6980409622,
0.1361020058,
0.1358501911,
1.0611964464,
-0.6486517191,
0.7260681391,
0.2091824263,
-0.3062857091,
-1.1774386168,
-0.3517367244,
0.1148363277,
-0.9155901074,
0.4937845469,
0.6457227468,
-0.0370036922,
-0.4035638273,
-0.9218286276,
-0.7313585877,
1.0134830475,
0.1101509556,
-0.7648133636,
-0.389097929,
-0.1027381644,
0.442854315,
-0.5107776523,
0.394738704,
0.6810065508,
0.1052122638,
0.1280294657,
-0.8374091387,
-0.1762010008,
0.1175998226,
0.1226068735,
0.3335274458,
-0.6926802397,
0.5863138437,
-0.4839420617,
-0.0218720548,
0.4512894452,
1.1510385275,
0.1045112386,
0.1942074299,
0.3917003274,
0.6904039979,
0.603118062,
0.0506716296,
1.3250768185,
0.1621719301,
-0.0714550316,
1.6068694592,
-0.3678337038,
0.5502567887,
0.3500280976,
0.009176434,
0.7650436163,
1.1800079346,
-0.1505265981,
0.7836276889,
0.2504695654,
0.0877893195,
-0.081455864,
0.1800100207,
-0.3393907249,
0.1363775134,
0.5379453301,
-0.5714544058,
0.2616126537,
-0.1362921,
0.0084336288,
0.1667419821,
-0.4630591869,
0.7895352244,
0.0836185813,
-1.0503399372,
0.5947948694,
-0.1474501491,
0.2955839336,
-0.6787421703,
-0.2561547756,
-0.4163347483,
-0.0447946228,
-0.2166954279,
-0.6809321046,
-0.1207241938,
-0.0170962345,
-0.1411946714,
-0.0149407182,
0.2929108441,
-0.1601736546,
-0.2087499499,
0.3319999278,
-0.0078339269,
0.0766010061,
0.4985641539,
-0.6900260448,
-0.0085647851,
0.3349299729,
-0.4272274077,
0.1232327968,
0.3200027049,
-0.5161730051,
0.9241276383,
0.2818857133,
-0.0753886998,
0.5915605426,
-0.034977261,
0.8133433461,
-0.4133998752,
-0.5041432381,
-0.826162219,
0.1110273674,
-0.2351413071,
-0.0596778281,
0.6165582538,
0.3538843989,
0.9586414695,
-0.0059902179,
0.5885182023,
0.2243539691,
0.6843407154,
-0.9635417461,
0.1289242208,
-0.3219020367,
0.4941095114,
0.0881349593,
-1.1466031075,
-0.086224854,
0.5962029099,
-0.7286569476,
0.3978339434,
0.4809341431,
0.4347011149,
-0.3710398376,
0.2849017978,
-0.0754599497,
-0.1924296319,
0.2677797377,
0.9139025807,
1.175973773,
0.1152976453,
0.2394494265,
-0.5355164409,
-0.3194522262,
-0.0484534279,
-0.7876154184,
-1.2764700651,
-0.0528493188,
0.0030593611,
-0.2053377032,
0.2146529257,
0.8254528642,
1.0156259537,
-0.7316554785,
-0.2563607991,
0.0014403368,
0.198791042,
-0.2466681004,
-0.0979374945,
0.4577171206,
-0.192449078,
-0.7012851834,
0.3232953846,
-0.0550054908,
0.5622004867,
-0.2315040231,
-0.3810341954,
-0.1779104024,
0.2705532312,
0.1182014495,
0.4632156491,
-0.7467309237,
-0.5673525929,
0.0017925501,
0.0089831874,
0.1809424609,
0.7474514246,
-0.3910395801,
0.2944565117,
0.4081659615,
0.659670651,
0.7645543814,
0.2736689746,
0.8717398643,
-0.7236881852,
0.0944323763,
0.2573841512,
0.3326255083,
0.442822963,
-0.63125664,
0.7166370749,
-0.2965556085,
-0.7630682588,
-0.5956080556,
0.4309351444,
-0.5033880472,
-0.1647065729,
1.0040855408,
-0.4759407341,
-0.4055272937,
0.5661312938,
0.0760916695,
0.2720887661,
-0.1368915588,
0.6197832227,
0.7809613347,
-0.7581384182,
-0.2557446361,
-0.821331501,
0.5779064298,
0.5918141007,
-0.5079122186,
-0.2842332721,
0.7725523114,
0.4105559289,
-0.0483898818,
0.3216612339,
-0.0202289876,
0.392611593,
-0.1016842201,
-0.3796596527,
-0.0414685309,
-0.6999260187,
-0.2376440465,
-0.1973633915,
0.006392078,
-0.3609526157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17739v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17739v1 | Find Parent then Label Children: A Two-stage Taxonomy Completion Method with Pre-trained Language Model | 2024-06-25T17:25:02 | 2024-06-25T17:25:02 | Fei Xia, Yixuan Weng, Shizhu He, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Taxonomies, which organize domain concepts into hierarchical structures, are
crucial for building knowledge systems and downstream applications. As domain
knowledge evolves, taxonomies need to be continuously updated to include new
concepts. Previous approaches have mainly focused on adding concepts to the
leaf nodes of the existing hierarchical tree, which does not fully utilize the
taxonomy's knowledge and is unable to update the original taxonomy structure
(usually involving non-leaf nodes). In this paper, we propose a two-stage
method called ATTEMPT for taxonomy completion. Our method inserts new concepts
into the correct position by finding a parent node and labeling child nodes.
Specifically, by combining local nodes with prompts to generate natural
sentences, we take advantage of pre-trained language models for
hypernym/hyponymy recognition. Experimental results on two public datasets
(including six domains) show that ATTEMPT performs best on both taxonomy
completion and extension tasks, surpassing existing methods. | [
-0.3058491051,
-0.4498006999,
0.4665392935,
-0.1742019504,
-0.2725889981,
0.4285311997,
-0.0285735223,
-0.3884813488,
0.1688676775,
0.2902834117,
-0.7456196547,
-0.4807359278,
-0.5702539086,
0.0494113714,
-0.1439007074,
0.7696682215,
-0.2790133655,
-0.4480240643,
-0.3576963544,
0.2995221913,
-0.3540211022,
-0.5057787299,
-0.7099238634,
-0.2919451892,
0.4719169736,
0.4952192008,
0.6032334566,
0.9753065109,
0.4470359087,
0.1805536598,
-0.3954138756,
0.3474583626,
-0.1388071328,
0.0639550686,
-0.4567106068,
-0.3758100867,
-0.4317073226,
0.2409459502,
0.7198768854,
1.1283559799,
-0.1701750308,
0.1494393051,
0.1644081324,
0.2009831816,
-0.6876539588,
0.1729171872,
-0.7527534366,
0.2556827068,
-0.1999525875,
-0.4813623428,
-0.3563047647,
-0.2411325872,
0.4593873918,
-0.7967652082,
0.2469697744,
-0.0237530824,
0.9950898886,
0.098416701,
-0.4216329753,
-0.2911671698,
-0.6320018768,
0.7541368604,
-0.5844281912,
0.41092664,
0.4553546607,
-0.0651269555,
-0.2921038866,
-0.8454262018,
-0.5421604514,
-0.2025952339,
-0.3846392035,
0.075421527,
-0.1736668944,
0.0527734794,
0.3053327799,
0.0814994574,
-0.5320515633,
0.1766717434,
-0.1305966675,
-0.1384432614,
0.0083538415,
-0.1848213524,
0.4228349328,
-0.4708326757,
-0.4769638777,
-0.0662868023,
-0.7350745201,
-0.3137452602,
0.0654498637,
0.531558454,
0.2781239748,
0.6522691846,
-0.2897110581,
0.7960855961,
0.0390365236,
-0.3549619317,
0.3580382168,
-0.5745009184,
-0.0647899732,
-0.1239992976,
0.4959097803,
0.1712928116,
0.1208104268,
-0.2680500746,
-0.2446153313,
0.0145564452,
0.3988105357,
-0.2657392621,
-0.1352044642,
0.1639767289,
-0.1695202291,
-0.2190370411,
-0.2722764015,
-0.643081367,
-0.1209108084,
-0.3303629458,
0.518248558,
-0.4024638236,
-0.3082875907,
-0.1508301497,
-0.1216064245,
0.3432404995,
0.4138696492,
-0.7089373469,
0.3687359393,
0.961648643,
0.8978965878,
-0.1320037544,
-0.640532732,
-0.4978868365,
0.4177846313,
-0.5576981902,
0.5983251333,
-0.5074267387,
-0.0928584635,
0.1315916479,
-0.0858174562,
-0.3262597322,
-0.6442466378,
0.4607207477,
-0.7357020974,
0.2209261954,
0.1736416519,
-0.6740000248,
0.0230711829,
0.3233802319,
-0.3127038777,
1.0383681059,
0.4397878647,
-0.9075375795,
0.6097888947,
-0.5592592359,
-0.4200228453,
0.4018307924,
0.2725951076,
-0.1720636785,
-0.0175123122,
-0.0572432019,
0.3989523053,
0.024559902,
0.3127972782,
0.1329876482,
0.0945521221,
-0.0506668463,
0.1762869954,
0.7673515677,
-0.0360066742,
-0.2489816546,
-0.1448628455,
-0.533125639,
0.0508101732,
0.0083187558,
-0.2231024951,
-0.5726006031,
0.1024512723,
-0.3207946718,
0.2529514432,
0.3920322955,
-0.490467757,
0.5090185404,
-0.3472923636,
0.3170059919,
0.3352218568,
0.1719264984,
0.4242579937,
-0.1619775742,
0.7517830133,
0.0735332891,
0.3770169616,
-0.1393503547,
-0.6282783747,
-0.8744434118,
0.0320408866,
0.7907224298,
0.4798446596,
-1.1388590336,
0.7189015746,
-0.3539452553,
-0.4777366221,
-0.1349385083,
0.113467291,
0.5285814404,
0.5638260841,
0.4455971122,
-0.7548637986,
-0.732896328,
-0.6837159395,
0.2136351764,
-0.5913897753,
0.033903677,
0.1705967337,
0.7052403092,
-0.4996277094,
1.2726106644,
-0.7713640332,
-0.3968392015,
0.0234571956,
0.4678228498,
0.0259347558,
0.5927068591,
0.3102089167,
-0.652397871,
-0.1963397861,
0.0050714244,
-0.4630193114,
0.1992592216,
0.17733486,
-0.200018242,
0.1274599284,
0.1545945108,
-0.6798656583,
0.2178786099,
0.2218405604,
0.0286911912,
0.4642299116,
-0.0667388663,
-0.1492979378,
-1.0714095831,
-0.1407715231,
-0.0649435818,
-0.1411643326,
-0.8455476761,
0.3077394664,
0.0425042026,
0.1435754746,
-0.4786347151,
0.3857479393,
-0.5886688232,
0.1037305221,
-0.176304549,
0.1527145803,
-0.330865413,
0.365908891,
0.2242937833,
0.4650705755,
0.7417430878,
-0.7349464297,
0.3199726641,
0.2362114191,
-0.3130863309,
0.5847731233,
-0.2163719535,
0.1243439838,
-0.2162976265,
0.2982289195,
-0.953337431,
-0.6260616779,
0.5805850625,
-0.5925120115,
0.39572528,
-0.5051684976,
-0.5739096403,
-0.8057941198,
-0.0949252322,
0.5199033618,
0.5277156234,
-0.7164502144,
0.4040386379,
0.5045827627,
-0.2939316034,
-0.6035833359,
-0.3693673313,
0.3471020162,
-0.0580427535,
-0.2399923801,
0.5629193783,
0.2569344342,
0.2765976787,
0.2104257792,
-0.1939532012,
-0.3710190654,
0.108625941,
-0.1548589021,
0.2195696831,
-0.2214240283,
0.1182018369,
0.0857454687,
-0.1945225447,
0.0596200414,
-0.7169862986,
0.5580478311,
0.3650699854,
-0.016643282,
-0.4980905354,
0.1240184605,
0.3370905817,
-0.2646587193,
0.3637542427,
0.0712993145,
-1.020694375,
-0.2575436532,
-0.343923986,
0.0065996447,
-0.4024966657,
0.1774484962,
-0.3718812168,
-0.7310787439,
-0.1343775839,
-0.169440642,
0.0836016163,
0.4292509556,
-0.0005916777,
-0.2081120759,
0.7796843052,
0.6526310444,
0.2339760512,
0.1829127967,
-0.3251111805,
0.1906200647,
-1.0534008741,
-0.3418693244,
-0.5873672366,
0.0259978361,
-0.377635777,
-0.668505013,
0.129930824,
0.3910343051,
0.1597426236,
0.8772681952,
-0.5984319448,
0.2518731654,
0.8620417714,
0.0464398488,
0.5581545234,
0.2520385683,
-0.048974283,
-0.0087302355,
-0.897446394,
-0.5202612281,
0.8634987473,
0.3414732516,
0.4602198899,
0.1083004028,
1.1758129597,
-0.090143092,
0.696488142,
-1.1863899231,
0.439163506,
-0.163063556,
-0.4783252776,
-0.3341575861,
-0.4305844605,
-1.1215885878,
-0.0238284264,
-0.0376561768,
-0.7813402414,
0.3416142464,
0.2293241918,
-0.5049647093,
0.0717297271,
-0.4858357012,
0.6694113612,
-0.069535017,
0.0718148425,
0.1241511926,
-0.6681204438,
0.4384582639,
-0.3202418387,
0.2880659103,
0.1655009687,
-0.4210544527,
1.209499836,
-0.5634971857,
0.8436456323,
-0.2152351737,
-0.28865394,
0.4718536437,
0.0317525491,
0.2996093929,
-0.2805849612,
0.4355812371,
-0.3438676596,
-0.0441859625,
-0.1817943007,
-0.7644612789,
0.3189896047,
-0.4414963126,
-0.4974998236,
-0.778636694,
-0.1890158653,
-0.3776063323,
0.2948299646,
0.1429749429,
0.3962468505,
0.0850798637,
-0.1742518693,
0.627417922,
0.0878017396,
0.2934604883,
0.1661669761,
-0.322019726,
-0.4731462002,
0.8043479323,
0.446750313,
0.3542780876,
0.3798092008,
0.1500719339,
-0.4219937027,
-0.6369960308,
-0.2895384431,
0.2441973686,
-0.4783607721,
-0.5144962668,
-0.9956877232,
-0.4682492912,
-0.40080145,
0.0765188858,
-0.1849869937,
-0.4430267215,
-0.0081382068,
-0.0586559102,
0.2632336915,
0.9183725715,
-0.2021854371,
0.6709213257,
-0.7945131063,
0.522298038,
0.5690899491,
0.2787438631,
0.3144849539,
-0.530230999,
-0.1226915419,
0.2368399501,
-0.1998963505,
-0.8893870115,
0.1498117149,
0.2774390578,
0.422255367,
0.2154275626,
-0.2495590448,
0.7584921122,
-0.6580040455,
0.4598885775,
0.298422724,
-0.9243486524,
1.0496532917,
-0.2948763072,
0.1309003681,
0.4771563709,
0.7811020613,
-0.643602252,
-0.1803867221,
-0.8958048224,
-0.8639622927,
0.8230113387,
0.201723367,
0.158252418,
-0.0466555357,
0.3877684772,
-0.1274330914,
0.2361457944,
-0.4202531576,
-0.2365057617,
0.1817074865,
-0.0970947817,
0.1550289541,
-0.3291650712,
-0.2196214795,
-0.4638879597,
0.7376739383,
-0.1514758915,
-0.0613777041,
0.0437030531,
-0.1338519901,
-0.2338608652,
0.2549341619,
0.1078838333,
0.9830663204,
-0.2021968812,
0.3073745668,
-0.134251669,
-0.3636517823,
0.4324385822,
0.1090676337,
-0.5766747594,
0.2784098387,
0.63742733,
0.4845754206,
0.3961430788,
-0.3077789545,
0.5780672431,
0.3384429514,
-0.3119569719,
-0.0956067294,
0.0204275139,
0.1476059258,
-0.3162449002,
0.5232098103,
-0.046617128,
0.0086040311,
-0.9778603911,
0.6542496681,
0.2896064818,
-0.334221065,
-0.0318085365,
0.3801271021,
-0.0924458802,
-0.517262876,
0.5095236897,
-0.5611299276,
-0.9324060082,
0.6204883456,
0.6271676421,
0.7619197369,
-0.3651832342,
0.7735898495,
0.6030963063,
0.2744293511,
-0.3152329922,
0.27671808,
-0.0674775615,
-0.8085432649,
-0.7292101383,
-0.7725728154,
-0.5678316355,
-0.0877958238,
-0.5882686973,
0.0899463296,
-0.418335408,
-0.3292917013,
0.157744199,
-0.1153626069,
-0.4499838054,
0.5328255892,
0.0804955289,
0.8953903317,
-0.8123141527,
0.7137009501,
0.8098161221,
-0.2322442681,
-0.8967158198,
0.3697020113,
-0.1021723226,
-0.4376440048,
0.6082758904,
0.0040338561,
-0.1128495559,
0.282594651,
-0.5426331758,
-1.2236150503,
0.8498590589,
-0.2307765484,
-0.5061358213,
-0.3413973153,
-0.138175115,
0.5496374369,
-0.4599126875,
0.0147667248,
0.7585189939,
0.5245923996,
0.5842633843,
-0.8683530688,
0.022975795,
0.0453155786,
0.2259759456,
0.3110847771,
-0.1013773754,
0.6043999195,
-0.2269532382,
-0.5197126269,
0.1796411425,
0.8368116021,
0.2533719242,
0.0734919012,
0.8445228338,
0.6847444177,
0.9471037984,
-0.1953994781,
0.5433955193,
-0.1291310042,
0.5769414902,
1.296041131,
-0.3166797459,
0.9488875866,
0.2406523973,
-0.3637979925,
0.3596222699,
1.0992213488,
0.0888615847,
0.4445459545,
0.3149884045,
-0.2359120995,
-0.0828758776,
-0.5590003729,
-0.4411092997,
0.1632643938,
0.4712991714,
0.0642529652,
-0.2452158481,
0.060352508,
0.1983359456,
-0.1385486573,
-0.3745471835,
0.8301615119,
0.0300255232,
-1.0712020397,
0.5984504223,
-0.0621680953,
0.8215048909,
-0.4508139491,
0.0007042346,
-0.0298510324,
-0.3354168534,
-0.3810602427,
-0.7277984619,
0.0772813559,
0.0121361259,
0.0229218937,
-0.2375440001,
0.5207109451,
-0.7334445715,
-0.5851874352,
0.3781482577,
0.6833745837,
0.0061054793,
0.2260083556,
-0.3784890175,
-0.4861323833,
-0.3330453038,
0.0231389161,
-0.2296180427,
0.4065647423,
-0.0391312689,
0.4998986423,
0.4240939915,
0.2388371229,
0.3132997751,
0.0828620791,
0.7646535039,
-0.520395577,
-0.1498378366,
-0.5423802733,
0.26516518,
-0.0355146192,
-0.2556869686,
0.4651557505,
0.7223433852,
1.3461149931,
-0.116689384,
0.8713461161,
-0.4112497866,
0.6627246141,
-0.533670485,
0.2401506007,
-0.7189187407,
-0.2596717179,
-0.3900580406,
-1.1072826385,
-0.5302830338,
0.4337077439,
-0.0076248869,
0.0082802204,
1.151201725,
0.7669174671,
-0.2486490905,
-0.3510338664,
-0.0822252333,
0.2546965182,
-0.1329458505,
0.7243746519,
1.1406927109,
-0.3144676089,
0.2294712812,
-0.6452981234,
-0.6113719344,
0.0508670844,
-0.5703110099,
-0.4853856266,
-0.6794090867,
-0.7539613843,
-0.5302239656,
0.235831961,
1.0365712643,
0.6084345579,
-0.7060816884,
-0.0882823914,
0.0842143446,
0.16547741,
-0.2729010582,
-0.1918010116,
0.4301301241,
-0.598621726,
-0.837703824,
0.3245316744,
0.2713068724,
0.080968909,
-0.0137597788,
0.1911742836,
-0.5879409909,
-0.1496059895,
0.4984602928,
0.2749354243,
-0.7297965884,
-0.415043056,
-0.192837745,
-0.2060721666,
0.1763390303,
0.916325748,
-0.8142723441,
0.3692612052,
0.5435687304,
0.5488391519,
0.2489801198,
0.1400379092,
0.4012632072,
-0.7489723563,
-0.3017005622,
0.2676843405,
0.2973538935,
0.2598678172,
-0.138770774,
0.7842709422,
0.4632812738,
0.1230235696,
-0.808329463,
0.4267473519,
-0.9045334458,
-0.227661103,
1.0491791964,
-0.0486841202,
-0.3535586894,
-0.2869992554,
-0.0774339065,
0.4345631599,
0.1362940669,
0.4535600543,
0.6761077642,
0.0731692985,
0.1039561406,
-0.372217983,
0.6631375551,
0.2636571825,
-0.7707698345,
-0.1104391515,
0.3113487661,
0.0728642195,
0.6017128825,
0.860411942,
0.0723751783,
0.2472073138,
-0.2801384628,
0.1065777913,
0.4315824211,
-0.8389128447,
-0.0858254805,
0.2212274522,
0.2065581679,
-0.2143512517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17737v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17737v1 | LLM Targeted Underperformance Disproportionately Impacts Vulnerable Users | 2024-06-25T17:24:07 | 2024-06-25T17:24:07 | Elinor Poole-Dayan, Deb Roy, Jad Kabbara | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | While state-of-the-art Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown impressive
performance on many tasks, there has been extensive research on undesirable
model behavior such as hallucinations and bias. In this work, we investigate
how the quality of LLM responses changes in terms of information accuracy,
truthfulness, and refusals depending on three user traits: English proficiency,
education level, and country of origin. We present extensive experimentation on
three state-of-the-art LLMs and two different datasets targeting truthfulness
and factuality. Our findings suggest that undesirable behaviors in
state-of-the-art LLMs occur disproportionately more for users with lower
English proficiency, of lower education status, and originating from outside
the US, rendering these models unreliable sources of information towards their
most vulnerable users. | [
-0.0235607233,
-0.8456837535,
0.7572381496,
-0.0114907464,
0.1983326823,
0.2751893699,
-0.2138831168,
-0.6184418797,
-0.0501329303,
0.5698240399,
-0.2924469709,
-0.4088951349,
-0.7265592217,
0.0183960032,
-0.5597767234,
0.8924784064,
0.0696034804,
-0.1545935273,
-0.3997375071,
-0.0400550254,
-0.5663544536,
-0.9711354375,
-0.158240959,
-0.5034840107,
0.535556376,
0.5342609286,
1.0173820257,
0.0580991097,
0.5474059582,
0.2424483299,
0.0280665588,
0.0414946601,
-0.9294700623,
0.0207900256,
-0.4014609158,
-0.7410110831,
-0.4083064497,
0.2782300413,
0.3698068559,
0.6283703446,
-0.3029957712,
0.257774204,
0.4218056202,
0.5111480951,
-0.6758155823,
-0.1108728349,
-0.81256181,
-0.360073477,
-0.1997684687,
-0.0841007531,
-0.5326700807,
-0.4533271492,
-0.0823875889,
-0.4075933993,
0.246777758,
0.0543126054,
0.7121064067,
0.2300822586,
-0.4813190997,
-0.681684196,
-0.8440058827,
0.7483510971,
-0.7364018559,
0.4214290082,
0.6107378006,
0.0457642116,
-0.3361557424,
-0.3696037233,
-0.5122483373,
-0.3427728415,
-0.2964830995,
-0.119176887,
-0.4897414148,
-0.0904391184,
0.4038449824,
0.2274626344,
-0.5089277625,
0.6283717155,
-0.5025706887,
-0.2499684095,
0.797560513,
0.3402763605,
0.2479288578,
-0.1577693224,
-0.2654202282,
0.134558931,
-0.8393297791,
0.3572629392,
0.860259831,
0.4514846802,
0.035252858,
0.8638620973,
0.0202749111,
0.3362074196,
-0.0926383734,
-0.4288434982,
0.1914492995,
-0.0128331846,
-0.0639385357,
0.0163112264,
0.6926004887,
0.5256201625,
0.2533278465,
-0.0734792724,
-0.6288183331,
0.2189854831,
0.4051246941,
-0.6235493422,
0.0951778069,
0.3812759817,
-0.4420950413,
-0.2330560684,
0.1557025462,
-0.5703621507,
-0.5903277397,
-0.1012248173,
0.5949232578,
-0.2794770598,
-0.194846049,
0.1440405995,
0.251670599,
0.0266686734,
0.1874570101,
-0.7391086221,
0.4769230783,
0.3914935887,
0.60110569,
-0.5083042979,
-0.208932519,
-0.2853491604,
-0.10110531,
-0.1785105914,
0.4235949218,
-0.6081921458,
-0.530401051,
0.0680440739,
-0.0789759532,
-0.1067394391,
-0.7501866221,
0.8017520905,
-0.6150444746,
0.1808279008,
-0.5631138086,
-0.371412605,
-0.2119823545,
0.1142834947,
-0.5464612246,
0.8894513249,
0.1121760383,
-0.8336756229,
0.2470639944,
-0.537179172,
-0.4412562847,
-0.1549176574,
-0.0053441972,
-0.221625641,
0.4530361593,
0.0268211123,
0.6624282002,
-0.1540983468,
0.4140923321,
-0.2736430466,
-0.7609083056,
0.7870799899,
-0.7650263309,
0.5783591866,
0.1359508634,
-0.187625885,
-0.1705363393,
-0.9695413113,
-0.2060308307,
0.4471464157,
-0.5074202418,
-0.5212447047,
0.0312388986,
0.1485179216,
0.3301092386,
0.1896678954,
-0.6594996452,
0.0328471772,
-0.4472618103,
0.3338862956,
0.8533981442,
-0.0844314173,
-0.0579829328,
-0.5088934302,
0.4874516726,
0.0916327313,
0.2482341528,
0.283737272,
-0.2358035594,
-0.5104948878,
0.1151797771,
-0.0169026647,
0.5943095088,
-0.5830978751,
-0.0174742863,
-0.3738103807,
-0.2932645977,
-0.6248229146,
0.277975291,
0.4431728423,
0.5231923461,
0.3974761963,
-0.2165409774,
-0.2938750088,
-1.1383649111,
-0.434369415,
-0.5188851953,
-0.130175814,
0.3404251635,
0.6490524411,
-0.387912482,
0.6148428321,
-0.2846625745,
-0.2498658746,
-0.3868661821,
-0.129649207,
0.1286788136,
0.0531272702,
0.3972123563,
-0.6785200238,
-0.2075796127,
-0.385746628,
-0.4772795141,
-0.2399388105,
-0.0193322506,
0.5388572812,
0.5301918387,
0.1261666417,
-0.4180018902,
0.4690204859,
0.800311029,
-0.290017128,
0.4326460361,
0.0244457573,
0.4019184411,
-0.9644882679,
0.0422624201,
0.0086296136,
0.1797527075,
-0.524548471,
-0.1032193378,
-0.0070065209,
0.229800418,
-0.6555151343,
0.2851741016,
-0.2779812515,
-0.1541789621,
-0.2103686482,
0.0523684286,
0.0557693057,
0.1192204729,
-0.2711848319,
1.0477099419,
0.1880613118,
-0.4363544285,
0.3318271339,
0.2564855814,
-0.4481725395,
0.386828512,
-0.7416884303,
-0.0346363038,
-0.2076727599,
-0.1405120045,
-0.9734921455,
-0.4176175296,
0.0116282925,
-0.52580899,
0.2518084943,
0.100161396,
-0.6043287516,
-0.3874942362,
-0.2545577586,
0.2295634747,
0.5766048431,
-0.2348113805,
0.3120393753,
0.2457942218,
0.0243707597,
-0.603720665,
-0.9878928065,
0.1591891795,
-0.3248570859,
-0.4513535798,
0.104449749,
0.0126321213,
-0.5699490905,
-0.0489514768,
0.008127111,
0.0878940001,
0.3851203024,
0.5255146623,
0.1649724394,
-0.1202196851,
-0.0480654836,
-0.3622916639,
0.13815929,
0.3549850881,
0.1949734539,
0.424864769,
0.0699213147,
-0.6598136425,
-0.4430939853,
0.2292529792,
0.6567701697,
0.0418923832,
1.0482288599,
0.1345737129,
-0.1970971078,
-0.2184863538,
-0.6971361637,
-0.3536685407,
-0.4686717093,
0.4542803764,
-0.3839895427,
-0.9668920636,
0.5375846028,
0.2416691035,
-0.0499528758,
0.2605551779,
0.4400059283,
-0.215676412,
0.8614625931,
0.7188780308,
-0.0928927138,
-0.0825387165,
0.0744533613,
0.2354452759,
-0.6128492951,
-0.4967725277,
-0.6313425899,
-0.1477120966,
-0.6840865016,
-0.1730024815,
0.251586616,
-0.0382791869,
-0.010230016,
0.121832788,
-0.1142354384,
0.3889144659,
0.3043158054,
0.3176165521,
0.5098432302,
0.1043038741,
-0.0321434252,
-0.3363116086,
-0.7412147522,
-0.817671597,
1.3191251755,
0.5627944469,
1.2732049227,
0.3709724247,
0.1134184003,
0.5238838196,
0.2456608266,
-0.7541934848,
0.3479893208,
-0.0973679796,
-0.7529778481,
-0.3010127246,
-0.3984079063,
-0.8051565289,
-0.1031907573,
-0.3430883884,
-0.8952919841,
0.1218139306,
0.3819463253,
-0.2142015696,
0.4732104838,
-0.5271434188,
0.3968283236,
-0.4587241113,
-0.4709614813,
-0.0824289322,
-0.5065571666,
0.4958472252,
-0.5384466648,
0.5621395707,
-0.2731712759,
-0.0157329049,
0.4594375193,
0.0167189669,
1.2071949244,
-0.0910894498,
-0.2474821806,
0.0163101982,
0.2789756656,
0.7841932178,
-0.1395078897,
-0.3930428922,
0.3832757771,
-0.3653397858,
-0.4400612414,
-0.5496945977,
0.6994040608,
-0.9991143346,
-0.8744252324,
-0.3789239824,
-0.4244030416,
-0.4604102075,
0.0562811047,
0.3229894936,
0.3601075113,
-0.3305797279,
0.2219854146,
0.7832553983,
-0.4504208565,
0.209755972,
1.0113307238,
-0.1181681976,
-0.0332523473,
0.6798128486,
0.4509761631,
0.5522249341,
0.0661074296,
0.0364450924,
-0.3673408926,
-0.9267171025,
0.0236025918,
0.174471274,
-0.7011096478,
-0.0170912202,
-0.5172125697,
-0.277843833,
-0.3387612402,
-0.0817154124,
-0.4690993726,
-0.0564584844,
-0.3509372175,
-0.2425697893,
0.0544044375,
0.9969881177,
0.1302414387,
0.256898582,
-0.5472965837,
0.1934948713,
0.3046470582,
0.363925606,
-0.1423964947,
-1.0758361816,
-0.199119404,
0.0908043608,
-0.300119698,
-0.6826456189,
-0.0375081934,
0.0435328223,
0.8031358123,
0.2982525229,
0.2737607062,
0.3845657408,
-0.2878051102,
0.7968389988,
-0.0005236591,
-0.7303058505,
0.5480005145,
-0.1995720118,
0.0600365102,
0.6585666537,
0.8399701715,
-0.4478417337,
-0.5006718636,
-0.3042728901,
-0.7546712756,
0.6662822366,
0.2321422845,
0.6072440743,
0.2444854975,
0.3937151432,
0.3817948997,
0.2329092175,
-1.0427542925,
-0.3963688612,
-0.1162000224,
0.0796452835,
-0.0963146687,
-0.8627241254,
-0.1031116173,
0.0159632247,
0.8073592186,
0.0154840052,
-0.2848577201,
0.0566600859,
-0.1666850299,
-0.3273029029,
0.5252828002,
0.5010273457,
0.9343431592,
-0.1380142272,
0.1368533969,
0.1336299628,
-0.6349290609,
0.3133108914,
-0.1031109989,
-0.4724617898,
-0.2779743671,
0.6181690693,
0.7393667102,
0.1942358017,
-0.6422063708,
0.7153165936,
-0.0876989961,
-0.0254871007,
-0.1875337362,
0.3785968721,
-0.1384271234,
0.0921630636,
0.427077055,
-0.0209572073,
0.1470691115,
-0.7028463483,
0.0432938933,
0.4464892149,
-0.3844424784,
-0.4480485618,
0.765014112,
0.1985053271,
-0.3148760796,
0.5239604712,
0.106808126,
-0.2974566519,
0.1045915708,
0.6396701336,
0.51884377,
-0.3012439311,
0.274032861,
0.1332360655,
0.7717602253,
-0.0002514552,
0.2592872083,
0.5084823966,
-0.997205019,
-0.2691695988,
-0.6143358946,
-0.3460507393,
0.5460473895,
-0.7568567395,
0.1356827468,
-0.3309827447,
-0.3704911768,
-0.3158458471,
-0.0687337145,
-0.6948688626,
0.2048625946,
0.1623585075,
0.676213026,
-1.102850914,
0.6578188539,
0.7822011113,
-0.366004616,
-0.7153787017,
0.2770545781,
0.3150908649,
-1.013193965,
0.4240596592,
0.110371016,
-0.1578385532,
-0.1080308184,
-0.5437813401,
-0.8870794177,
0.862739861,
0.6765320897,
-0.6987099648,
0.1353222281,
0.7183410525,
0.4716131985,
-0.0672379509,
0.1178169772,
0.7582446933,
0.2123215348,
0.0787703469,
-1.142504096,
0.136237517,
0.119535923,
0.0870976374,
-0.1264034659,
-0.9378742576,
0.5511285663,
-0.4364012778,
-0.2878221571,
-0.3029738665,
0.3376816809,
0.3037392497,
0.1748946458,
0.3180811703,
0.4855640829,
0.7569441795,
-0.0378749184,
0.8746621013,
-0.0524010174,
0.1056362763,
0.9720768929,
-0.4700996876,
0.8120211959,
0.472225517,
-0.3398565948,
0.4850308001,
0.4193225801,
0.0183840096,
0.3426899612,
0.2218480855,
-0.135145098,
-0.0689925179,
-0.2426788658,
-0.088381052,
0.7539653182,
0.4321169853,
-0.3204165399,
0.0257812142,
0.15540272,
0.1912142038,
0.4697822034,
-0.3440555632,
0.5412855744,
0.0100326361,
-0.305760473,
0.6924861073,
-0.0174154658,
0.8622934818,
-0.4362076521,
0.026012769,
-0.4457182586,
-0.1983097792,
-0.6074220538,
-1.0082616806,
0.2564812601,
0.2167886943,
-0.4628065526,
-0.0999186039,
0.7332425117,
0.0463156737,
-0.5424850583,
0.6068450809,
0.6722960472,
0.3397005498,
-0.1431870461,
-0.6529343724,
0.5141938329,
0.0584099293,
-0.6588555574,
0.3174498081,
0.2873065174,
-0.0600796826,
0.9292481542,
0.5950354934,
0.2997308671,
-0.1206093207,
-0.0984408259,
0.9606351852,
-0.4821065366,
-0.033087749,
-0.9018899798,
0.5904583335,
0.0716200769,
-0.1997411996,
0.9466766715,
0.5589766502,
1.096791625,
0.2848519683,
0.8573761582,
0.1694543809,
0.6664091349,
-0.5648131967,
0.7394210696,
-0.6873375773,
0.8927537799,
-0.221728757,
-0.9433021545,
0.0425254442,
0.0697419271,
-0.3638217151,
0.1249932051,
0.4086214006,
0.8215460777,
-0.0766772032,
-0.3708510101,
0.7301582694,
0.6459059715,
0.2465397865,
0.5097034574,
0.9352501035,
-0.2605265081,
0.4341410697,
-0.1017593741,
-0.0283098295,
-0.3178438842,
-0.5876217484,
-1.0089482069,
-0.2842000425,
-0.1509583741,
-0.5056899786,
0.1574988812,
0.6595887542,
0.34339118,
-0.9731705189,
-0.0403577052,
0.3929289281,
0.1048799977,
0.5842264891,
-0.2578279078,
0.2144475728,
-0.009710486,
-0.4894331396,
0.328572154,
0.0875920877,
0.3595157564,
-0.6460133195,
-0.0164457262,
0.3861430883,
0.2755404413,
0.5760930181,
0.2237987518,
-0.9928762913,
-0.4118807018,
0.0738430396,
-0.4632235467,
-0.0003796344,
0.4851407707,
-0.6820428371,
0.1413187534,
-0.0329480805,
0.3780050278,
-0.1500367969,
0.2984689772,
0.3611624241,
-0.6369173527,
0.0048592179,
0.2730670571,
0.0678539351,
0.483160764,
-0.6087947488,
0.2790790498,
0.301124692,
-0.6101902127,
-1.0145130157,
0.0888499692,
-0.4030704498,
-0.4266938269,
1.2813214064,
-0.015640296,
0.1051792726,
-0.2026122957,
0.0110384645,
-0.1827413291,
-0.4373847544,
1.0375150442,
0.838713944,
-0.2677646279,
-0.0570001006,
-0.8509626985,
0.4425019324,
0.12976937,
-0.5790483356,
0.1908793449,
0.6754533648,
0.4640704691,
-0.1124617532,
0.4578412771,
-0.0689134821,
-0.0156893227,
-0.1095145419,
0.0774030909,
-0.2304748744,
-0.4086527824,
-0.4176829755,
0.3405774832,
0.5822635293,
0.2840641737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17716v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17716v2 | ViANLI: Adversarial Natural Language Inference for Vietnamese | 2024-06-25T16:58:19 | 2024-07-01T15:19:51 | Tin Van Huynh, Kiet Van Nguyen, Ngan Luu-Thuy Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The development of Natural Language Processing (NLI) datasets and models has
been inspired by innovations in annotation design. With the rapid development
of machine learning models today, the performance of existing machine learning
models has quickly reached state-of-the-art results on a variety of tasks
related to natural language processing, including natural language inference
tasks. By using a pre-trained model during the annotation process, it is
possible to challenge current NLI models by having humans produce
premise-hypothesis combinations that the machine model cannot correctly
predict. To remain attractive and challenging in the research of natural
language inference for Vietnamese, in this paper, we introduce the adversarial
NLI dataset to the NLP research community with the name ViANLI. This data set
contains more than 10K premise-hypothesis pairs and is built by a continuously
adjusting process to obtain the most out of the patterns generated by the
annotators. ViANLI dataset has brought many difficulties to many current SOTA
models when the accuracy of the most powerful model on the test set only
reached 48.4%. Additionally, the experimental results show that the models
trained on our dataset have significantly improved the results on other
Vietnamese NLI datasets. | [
-0.1446419656,
-0.9204282761,
0.5220388174,
0.156107679,
-0.1420830488,
-0.1673900932,
-0.0771910325,
-0.3113442659,
0.1259622574,
0.8809437156,
-0.4952208996,
-0.5128688216,
-0.5647734404,
0.3257429302,
-0.1727186739,
1.0770462751,
0.1672089398,
0.1278586686,
0.5275630951,
-0.1964670867,
-0.3246528208,
-0.7723759413,
-0.7702447772,
-0.1634038091,
0.5642143488,
0.017580295,
0.9342727065,
0.517105341,
0.2511586845,
0.2674922943,
-0.0669843107,
0.2331261933,
-0.4555553496,
-0.0584331863,
0.1758266985,
-0.7887580991,
-0.2943512201,
0.0592516027,
0.5341558456,
0.5309178829,
0.1323342174,
-0.080017224,
-0.3278384209,
0.4589271545,
-0.6528019309,
-0.3244539499,
-0.8230021,
0.075406827,
-0.2680820227,
-0.1068603173,
-0.3587452769,
-0.4996494055,
0.4321525991,
-0.7710795999,
0.1490992457,
-0.1600404233,
0.9971857071,
0.4122495651,
-0.3528724611,
-0.284717381,
-0.5929248929,
0.7955629826,
-0.974147737,
0.0108950092,
0.3624038696,
0.2896263897,
-0.2957067788,
-0.4536736906,
-0.664747417,
-0.2655212283,
-0.1374753714,
0.1490063071,
-0.1943607479,
0.0258741155,
0.2573086321,
-0.0574678741,
-0.9199837446,
0.1974195838,
-0.2220427394,
0.09295775,
0.784291625,
-0.27463305,
0.3707819879,
-0.4015111029,
-0.536955595,
0.0631497055,
-0.7950180769,
-0.4530792832,
0.5010128617,
0.3828472197,
0.2982777357,
0.5494219661,
-0.0846528187,
0.7570300698,
-0.5679324269,
0.0313706547,
0.3358221948,
-0.4286649227,
-0.5631294847,
0.3157689869,
0.9075412154,
0.2854681313,
0.4851584136,
-0.1999534369,
-0.1940948665,
0.4563421309,
0.3027659655,
-0.1878852397,
-0.2923796177,
0.24040775,
-0.1298122257,
-0.565417707,
0.2764790356,
-0.5542382002,
-0.4430648088,
-0.3370867074,
0.5730526447,
-0.4371931851,
-0.3894005716,
0.0776892379,
-0.2379814386,
0.0717783421,
0.2616955638,
-0.3015030921,
-0.0117304856,
0.7501314878,
0.7675651312,
-0.0108416434,
-0.5037645698,
-0.5997300148,
0.1206340045,
-0.3238912523,
0.6901130676,
-0.428006053,
-0.3803358674,
0.0110466685,
-0.137696892,
-0.2579346895,
-0.5514947176,
0.7659266591,
-0.5689678788,
0.2867407799,
-0.1045575067,
-0.5617691875,
-0.1967864335,
0.1611032039,
-0.7643424869,
0.9045787454,
-0.2690812051,
-1.0796327591,
0.3028666675,
-0.7175450325,
-0.3035902679,
0.062048424,
0.1196402088,
-0.4957419932,
0.1789093018,
0.1909122765,
0.3238354027,
-0.1766049266,
0.6103794575,
-0.3399195671,
-0.387009114,
0.3843971193,
-0.5866108537,
1.2665570974,
0.2342186868,
-0.3513715863,
0.3744711876,
-0.9655585289,
-0.2106197625,
0.1853418201,
-0.0256126896,
-0.6573246121,
-0.3866068125,
0.2425381988,
0.2323563546,
-0.1773004979,
-0.4620564878,
0.0835958198,
-0.5658974648,
0.4205003679,
0.672618866,
0.0482474416,
0.2217434794,
-0.1619509906,
0.3567136526,
-0.2567877173,
0.0426203161,
-0.0093759419,
-0.7478333712,
-0.6531478763,
-0.2631563246,
0.3395692706,
0.8926217556,
-1.0730422735,
0.5086194277,
-0.1780086011,
-0.4612931907,
-0.8854346275,
0.0178595204,
0.4670431316,
0.4798717499,
0.2656071484,
0.2614626288,
-1.0078932047,
-0.8475390077,
-0.248991549,
-0.2730406225,
-0.6093381047,
0.0956772044,
0.6129399538,
-0.4717639983,
0.7398865223,
-0.4904405475,
-0.2331387252,
-0.4384917319,
0.4841020107,
0.3617787659,
0.1919762492,
0.3367800713,
-1.185752511,
-0.2142879516,
-0.2877225578,
-0.8872051835,
-0.2477057576,
-0.3034329116,
-0.3233489692,
0.3472155929,
0.3660775423,
-0.4272407889,
0.6483059525,
0.5288744569,
-0.3316018283,
0.634657681,
-0.3126195073,
-0.0687996075,
-1.0770727396,
0.1525513828,
0.1206972525,
-0.1036489829,
-0.9613506198,
0.1445329189,
-0.3295669854,
-0.0717253685,
-0.440466702,
0.2735084593,
-0.0114660561,
0.4060836434,
-0.2719158232,
0.1258091778,
-0.0783421248,
0.2091726661,
0.3663448095,
0.7698687911,
0.5340371728,
-0.5980387926,
0.5086678863,
0.193439424,
0.078546986,
0.2453080416,
-0.8414108157,
0.0871968791,
-0.0211771168,
0.2721340656,
-0.9000210166,
-0.0307687242,
0.2679290473,
-0.3062484264,
0.0222903043,
-0.0313316807,
-0.3891181946,
-0.1956320107,
-0.4461534321,
-0.023880817,
0.1475428194,
-0.6156964898,
0.6082999706,
0.4248229563,
0.2186341733,
-0.6420481801,
-0.9166175127,
0.5222646594,
-0.6773909926,
-0.4219555259,
0.232315287,
0.1750584096,
-0.3471547663,
-0.1655088365,
0.3267479837,
-0.2207637727,
0.1944206953,
0.2032244354,
0.4644263089,
-0.5880943537,
0.0206079986,
-0.4797873497,
-0.4876800776,
0.1694229543,
-0.559848547,
0.0848639756,
-0.1112293601,
0.022764029,
-0.5937171578,
0.1528136283,
0.2679302096,
-0.0755834952,
0.8753602505,
0.5647376776,
-0.4207603037,
0.0326104723,
-0.6477642655,
0.0748432726,
-0.3591190279,
0.3612362146,
-0.5453205705,
-0.5310929418,
0.1068899706,
-0.0200926848,
0.0095308507,
0.4283854365,
0.0643832907,
0.143539086,
0.8432649374,
0.5803905725,
-0.4286785424,
0.0565992221,
-0.3385830224,
0.0031588711,
-0.5551918149,
0.3737213016,
-0.5203154087,
0.04092329,
-0.9873241782,
-0.4278701842,
0.0679915473,
-0.180087015,
-0.1229009554,
0.5031844974,
-0.2692303061,
0.1851781607,
0.8494303823,
0.0691218376,
0.3949820697,
-0.1373853683,
0.1046545953,
-0.2296449691,
-0.678555429,
-0.8847848177,
1.3833905458,
0.1371872723,
0.3941760659,
0.2041582167,
0.5325962305,
0.2325275838,
0.3540281057,
-0.296015054,
0.3860124946,
-0.3965956867,
-0.5082150102,
-0.387009263,
-0.6120564938,
-0.7440020442,
0.0876826942,
-0.2866791487,
-0.7070291042,
-0.0941061974,
-0.0428687148,
-0.4011654556,
0.4139599204,
-0.8611023426,
1.0055501461,
-0.2600492239,
-0.0730328932,
0.1733040214,
-0.9860466123,
0.4430322051,
-0.1789304912,
0.0020315337,
0.0963739529,
0.1073818505,
0.5609238744,
-0.2443339676,
0.7739804983,
-0.2033485472,
-0.1315791458,
0.3981840909,
-0.3311231732,
0.3146359324,
0.4123761952,
-0.4946520925,
0.1928576082,
-0.3262834251,
-0.4434927404,
-0.8361408114,
0.532915771,
-0.7782791257,
-0.614700675,
-0.3883624077,
-0.1957504451,
0.0495881252,
0.1039056331,
0.4966399074,
0.2116317749,
-0.3750217557,
-0.1510708481,
0.7318164706,
-0.3674126863,
0.100640215,
0.2521357536,
-0.2266799212,
-0.4423199296,
1.2312209606,
0.088469699,
0.1222596392,
0.6515405178,
0.2900129557,
-0.5298128128,
-0.5745429993,
-0.5072821975,
0.274427712,
-0.3858397603,
0.0845628157,
-0.6560813785,
-0.4365829229,
-0.2454862148,
-0.1467173845,
-0.2500121593,
-0.4165209532,
-0.2857426107,
-0.1993170083,
0.1139940247,
0.9227210879,
0.2931007743,
0.3699412048,
-0.4366119206,
0.4955944419,
0.3958307505,
-0.1155556142,
-0.391410917,
-0.5414390564,
0.3534741402,
0.0152686769,
0.0332034193,
-0.8952233791,
0.4991381764,
0.188638851,
0.2429408282,
0.5272020102,
0.3480281532,
0.6690620184,
-0.3352604508,
0.4424882829,
-0.181851685,
-0.6201781034,
0.8096339703,
-0.1489590406,
0.3281132579,
0.461732626,
0.4307700694,
-0.2178256661,
-0.6888356805,
-0.8438011408,
-0.6896163821,
0.5318222642,
0.5920675993,
-0.136895895,
0.3448407054,
0.407025516,
0.194140777,
0.254024893,
-0.6575968862,
-0.4226371348,
-0.409869194,
-0.2127254605,
-0.4084376395,
-0.3699463308,
0.0905645862,
0.0139623191,
0.9076594114,
-0.1283193529,
-0.1562344283,
0.3283563554,
-0.1700116694,
0.2623048425,
0.1546551138,
0.5902163982,
0.6658117771,
-0.3276370168,
0.3180363774,
0.4694305956,
-0.3550205529,
0.0481771119,
0.6088045835,
-0.582339704,
0.3124239147,
0.4954456389,
1.0208166838,
-0.0302369539,
-0.7144178748,
0.3288173676,
-0.5252608657,
0.0573344119,
-0.5016992092,
0.0634248331,
-0.1442092061,
0.0598488636,
0.4995679259,
0.1734759212,
0.2469485849,
-0.1786491573,
0.3959645033,
0.2886783779,
-0.5941538215,
-0.4028843939,
0.7045401931,
-0.0207329616,
-0.3853338957,
0.5858954191,
-0.2291992158,
-0.74523592,
0.5354074836,
0.3960765898,
0.8061509728,
-0.2214863151,
0.4630022943,
0.3607794046,
0.4402513504,
0.0948117077,
0.1013600454,
0.212750718,
-0.7020074129,
-0.4184429049,
-0.5044286251,
-0.2283945531,
0.5893563628,
-0.4402907193,
0.3528040946,
-0.3511560857,
-0.1983181983,
0.1361030042,
0.1129378751,
-0.2704537809,
0.4868943095,
0.3336022496,
0.7640231848,
-0.9831257463,
0.9907072783,
0.9091350436,
-0.1317678392,
-0.3895737529,
0.2357141525,
0.2623918951,
-0.4889587164,
0.632170558,
0.5182740688,
-0.189908728,
-0.0278043635,
-0.3780317605,
-0.529543519,
0.469493866,
0.4204907119,
-0.1161040291,
0.0736097023,
0.1815871,
0.657047689,
-0.30216524,
0.3341964483,
0.7723425627,
0.453042388,
0.0839715898,
-0.4450440705,
0.1384478509,
-0.3530726135,
0.3586645722,
-0.1327283531,
-0.2496639341,
0.4388320148,
-0.2361706346,
-0.1472225636,
0.129961893,
0.9729837775,
0.5737924576,
0.3777740002,
0.7280608416,
0.5314759016,
0.688275218,
-0.0283739511,
0.9064897299,
0.251444459,
-0.051556889,
1.2366992235,
-0.2727530003,
0.7814337015,
0.3141040802,
-0.126268208,
0.166637674,
0.4037006795,
-0.1483949572,
0.1942586452,
0.214941591,
-0.268117696,
0.0168264806,
-0.4488215446,
-0.1495139897,
0.5645606518,
0.3487278819,
-0.062586315,
0.0652240738,
-0.028515067,
0.1862851977,
0.3536840379,
0.2001967579,
0.739818573,
-0.1259239763,
-0.5762811899,
0.6115133762,
-0.1105982438,
0.8045913577,
-0.767660737,
-0.0861944184,
-0.0291978028,
0.1706506312,
-0.001490213,
-0.4982020557,
0.4982803464,
0.1697175801,
0.1257069558,
-0.0575027764,
0.4545846879,
-0.4197329581,
-0.7392088175,
0.4335756898,
0.1251229644,
0.0133739728,
-0.3799863458,
-0.808863163,
-0.0791010633,
0.0943825096,
-0.339235574,
-0.0127725368,
0.6226226687,
0.0592772476,
0.6089917421,
0.6339623928,
0.3899571002,
0.0620832667,
0.1866692007,
0.7747452259,
-0.5900322199,
-0.4450182319,
-1.0036654472,
0.3671034575,
-0.2617269754,
-0.5988006592,
0.9357256293,
0.5301065445,
0.8123984933,
0.0023929917,
0.9742438793,
0.3567058146,
0.547452867,
-0.6567418575,
0.879902184,
-0.4536700845,
0.1288964599,
-0.4124539495,
-0.5732737184,
-0.6983807683,
0.3946993947,
-0.2965534627,
-0.2385777086,
0.5124848485,
0.7500829697,
0.2052702457,
0.374971658,
0.3245590925,
0.5163793564,
0.34208709,
0.5344327688,
0.8025812507,
-0.6376060247,
0.5730413198,
-0.447424531,
-0.2591338456,
-0.0560296401,
-0.7437241077,
-1.0226761103,
-0.3720551729,
-0.3132067323,
-0.215493992,
0.4717438221,
0.7010392547,
0.5639387965,
-1.3647150993,
-0.1980394125,
-0.4108523726,
0.2891218066,
-0.1444292516,
-0.2172620893,
0.6624662876,
-0.2648203671,
-0.7202891111,
0.5859972835,
0.1108145863,
0.1220760942,
-0.1727630198,
0.0582502112,
-0.8323767781,
-0.2352728248,
0.2782846391,
0.1876862794,
-0.8745322824,
0.0061891777,
-0.1031163111,
-0.0300607048,
-0.0611104034,
0.6510032415,
-0.7928632498,
0.6346719861,
0.1467054933,
0.8763162494,
0.0686545223,
0.0517327897,
0.9882275462,
-0.7185146809,
0.4345380068,
0.1267246157,
0.1889448166,
0.4748434126,
-0.3671174049,
0.7123835683,
0.3628813624,
-0.2382722795,
-0.8803701997,
0.0998970717,
-0.2559067011,
-0.3617793024,
0.8250181675,
-0.2854569852,
-0.4290237427,
-0.4964889288,
-0.3790844679,
0.5127324462,
-0.3219270706,
0.8561179638,
0.3654884398,
0.304333061,
0.1022208929,
-0.8145202398,
0.5824946761,
0.5549892187,
-0.6020075679,
-0.0492190458,
0.073156096,
-0.2807559967,
0.3100127578,
0.3167642653,
0.4318688512,
0.0401869267,
0.0252387691,
-0.2491981983,
0.1842065752,
-0.4443329573,
-0.4568997025,
0.2753124833,
-0.1091488674,
-0.1653286368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17706v1 | FedBiOT: LLM Local Fine-tuning in Federated Learning without Full Model | 2024-06-25T16:45:47 | 2024-06-25T16:45:47 | Feijie Wu, Zitao Li, Yaliang Li, Bolin Ding, Jing Gao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DC | Large language models (LLMs) show amazing performance on many domain-specific
tasks after fine-tuning with some appropriate data. However, many
domain-specific data are privately distributed across multiple owners. Thus,
this dilemma raises the interest in how to perform LLM fine-tuning in federated
learning (FL). However, confronted with limited computation and communication
capacities, FL clients struggle to fine-tune an LLM effectively. To this end,
we introduce FedBiOT, a resource-efficient LLM fine-tuning approach to FL.
Specifically, our method involves the server generating a compressed LLM and
aligning its performance with the full model. Subsequently, the clients
fine-tune a lightweight yet important part of the compressed model, referred to
as an adapter. Notice that as the server has no access to the private data
owned by the clients, the data used for alignment by the server has a different
distribution from the one used for fine-tuning by clients. We formulate the
problem into a bi-level optimization problem to minimize the negative effect of
data discrepancy and derive the updating rules for the server and clients. We
conduct extensive experiments on LLaMA-2, empirically showing that the adapter
has exceptional performance when reintegrated into the global LLM. The results
also indicate that the proposed FedBiOT significantly reduces resource
consumption compared to existing benchmarks, all while achieving comparable
performance levels. | [
-0.3717488945,
-0.5598083138,
0.3797560632,
0.2376772165,
-0.2851910889,
0.1994863003,
-0.3967581987,
-0.4719431996,
0.0231385082,
0.4483499825,
-0.7531714439,
-0.3494635522,
-0.2671293914,
0.2303767949,
0.0619630329,
1.177213192,
-0.1452897638,
-0.0855558068,
-0.4991741478,
-0.2866853178,
-0.3267351687,
0.0899533927,
-0.7151765823,
-0.4410945177,
0.3177780509,
0.6561568379,
0.6094077229,
0.8768990636,
0.861518085,
0.3019804657,
-0.0082232738,
0.4250324667,
-1.014575839,
0.1321440786,
-0.355719775,
-0.5963827372,
-0.6438555121,
-0.122967273,
0.8894885778,
0.6599420309,
-0.1821668893,
0.3310516179,
-0.0714515075,
0.7951907516,
-0.5069827437,
0.4557979107,
-0.6044692993,
0.1423025429,
-0.1900479943,
-0.1512001157,
-0.3066548407,
-0.3093170822,
-0.0913766995,
-0.6696261168,
0.448941201,
0.2412011027,
0.8103305697,
0.4851293862,
-0.2335113883,
0.2681502402,
-0.7327119708,
0.5876932144,
-0.5019444823,
0.4081781805,
0.1039064601,
0.2093281001,
-0.4263007045,
-0.5181901455,
-0.3817091584,
0.2511582673,
-0.1439486593,
0.0674886703,
-0.4951021373,
0.1954494119,
0.0733111724,
0.727327764,
-0.4721737206,
0.3491005003,
0.0218363311,
-0.1814967692,
0.5945414305,
0.0374769121,
-0.120178394,
0.4396685362,
-0.4809601009,
-0.0081300605,
-0.8263465762,
-0.021034725,
0.3621801138,
0.5378074646,
-0.0856710449,
0.2765911818,
-0.4268558621,
0.5980197787,
0.3127757609,
-0.3723025322,
0.1646568924,
-0.2350956947,
-0.4031938314,
-0.1223663464,
0.5594471693,
0.1646974236,
0.0537464768,
-0.42188555,
-0.6892097592,
-0.1977320313,
-0.0496577919,
-1.0382236242,
-0.3154487908,
0.0095266569,
-0.2099001557,
-0.3145493865,
-0.0976410508,
-0.6578831673,
-0.3643901646,
-0.2435540259,
0.3826399446,
-0.081113264,
-0.2341843396,
-0.0984744579,
0.2958874106,
0.0774666071,
0.3808278739,
-1.0315992832,
0.536544323,
0.9243507981,
1.0222666264,
-0.0939738825,
-0.1865203381,
-0.9551125169,
0.0417411774,
-0.1066471934,
0.8763275743,
-0.2985614836,
-0.190016821,
-0.1182709709,
0.2380375564,
-0.0993763506,
-0.600317657,
0.2607842982,
-0.5763608217,
-0.080070965,
-0.2783228755,
-0.7122283578,
-0.0806313679,
0.0878690928,
-0.4567885399,
0.399307698,
0.3543755412,
-0.5848291516,
0.1710782051,
-0.7568289638,
-0.5397764444,
0.1799805164,
0.0428476296,
-0.604303658,
0.1660865247,
0.2607383132,
0.5332679152,
-0.36020872,
0.2719323337,
-0.4125582874,
-0.5299947858,
-0.1503686011,
-0.2100636959,
0.6313734055,
0.2499507964,
-0.1742320806,
0.0546399392,
-0.7921880484,
-0.183729142,
0.2057451606,
-0.4940255582,
-0.1298764497,
-0.07207039,
-0.1412945241,
-0.3060469031,
0.4037725627,
-0.703722775,
0.4168257713,
-0.5337293744,
0.4013993144,
0.8890166283,
-0.0701484382,
0.7249443531,
-0.5760894418,
0.433527261,
-0.1095167994,
0.2620953619,
0.0948596746,
-0.2390268147,
-0.6979570985,
-0.5830035806,
0.1750099063,
0.2810413241,
-0.4680137038,
0.1368395835,
-0.4989991784,
-0.4499994814,
-0.8391273618,
0.4418628216,
0.2427084595,
0.6383969188,
0.3384139836,
-0.1879735887,
-0.2290729433,
-0.934520781,
0.005735775,
0.0746085718,
0.0113640539,
0.4269747138,
0.2270681709,
-0.4905535281,
0.7474207878,
-0.6079255939,
-0.5443621874,
0.0274716262,
-0.0923674032,
0.2488545775,
0.4316069782,
0.5515730977,
-0.5263477564,
-0.4576251507,
0.4778179824,
-0.4405732155,
-0.3598157167,
-0.0804604292,
-0.0811358467,
0.3549503088,
-0.0022049707,
-0.4526981413,
-0.0027464507,
0.713085711,
-0.2529532909,
0.4077538252,
-0.3420399725,
-0.1393482834,
-0.89119488,
0.0230321847,
-0.3034939468,
-0.572751224,
-0.4533829093,
0.3808775246,
0.0903267413,
-0.2230567336,
-0.0276667383,
0.4385864139,
-0.5064893365,
-0.1580588967,
-0.422165066,
0.0729836076,
-0.001908498,
0.4223733246,
-0.2230245471,
1.0613076687,
0.4877384901,
-0.2517359257,
0.4120507538,
0.2967729568,
-0.150248155,
0.599973321,
-0.3518244922,
0.031821087,
-0.0594718382,
0.2098200023,
-0.8060774207,
-0.3576284051,
0.123334296,
0.0711192414,
0.4306028187,
-0.1125619709,
-0.5323962569,
-0.0974256396,
-0.0877228379,
0.3177346587,
0.3756518364,
-0.9332454205,
0.3662096858,
0.2087987661,
0.0037502544,
-0.494720459,
-0.5254299641,
-0.3114249408,
0.0146628795,
-0.8466135859,
0.2368450314,
-0.2059879303,
-0.1194364056,
-0.0243391842,
-0.4059248865,
-0.0509056672,
0.28406021,
0.221380353,
0.0359421298,
-0.6042994857,
0.0230454803,
0.2365409583,
-0.0076538143,
-0.1645203084,
-0.3491995931,
0.3402781487,
-0.6440400481,
-0.2665963471,
-0.4837217033,
0.0852896571,
0.3536105752,
-0.271116972,
0.7550733089,
0.7026880383,
-0.0805886835,
-0.3880251944,
-0.6394947767,
-0.2089833319,
-0.5142077208,
0.0492345467,
-0.1301307082,
-1.2358442545,
0.6484020948,
-0.3570582271,
0.1474388242,
0.0004103071,
0.2894441187,
-0.0609794073,
0.6211816072,
0.9315248132,
-0.2029065341,
0.6259920597,
-0.2818167508,
0.2130425423,
-0.6673072577,
0.0055257725,
-0.1905826777,
-0.6268205643,
-0.6583682299,
-0.3204974234,
0.1942234039,
-0.0218218118,
-0.3506222963,
0.3560908437,
-0.3579061925,
0.9029690027,
0.4632236958,
0.0691524595,
0.4834977388,
-0.0356284603,
-0.0272056498,
0.2588326633,
-0.7257380486,
0.1005275398,
0.7358492017,
0.1501435488,
0.6844824553,
0.2816762924,
0.8852342367,
0.0662548319,
0.4781346917,
-0.5933612585,
0.3587968051,
-0.1418399662,
-0.2907761037,
-0.0940834805,
-0.8482161164,
-0.7172951102,
0.280882597,
-0.3152814507,
-0.656501472,
0.3595017493,
0.1930297166,
-0.31137532,
0.5229144692,
-0.714880228,
0.8133271337,
0.0584360808,
-0.5993363857,
-0.0815566629,
-0.5517208576,
0.4281250536,
-0.4070251286,
0.0656787008,
-0.3147523999,
0.0619693473,
0.4228648245,
-0.4830713868,
0.7887892127,
-0.2777467072,
0.0650914609,
-0.0918486863,
0.2832889259,
0.7993630171,
0.4016919732,
-0.0841968283,
0.2909681797,
-0.0248444714,
-0.5916609168,
-0.4702856243,
0.9357247353,
-0.9383035898,
-0.8111373186,
-0.1451274902,
-0.7870640755,
-0.2699757516,
0.4433014095,
-0.0350308307,
0.1942720413,
-0.1137311831,
0.2723034918,
0.5972902775,
0.0140275983,
0.286785543,
0.9579851627,
-0.0941783488,
-0.3020958006,
0.9124012589,
-0.1059390157,
0.419737041,
0.6582329869,
0.3251481652,
0.0061299088,
-0.5884370804,
-0.1680878699,
0.5862092972,
-0.4144097865,
-0.8519199491,
-0.1587692201,
-0.1096892357,
-0.2979364693,
-0.3798933923,
-0.6178138256,
-0.2348218858,
-0.5195080638,
-0.1304457784,
0.5027048588,
0.4550930262,
-0.4035053253,
0.837592423,
-0.52202636,
-0.0698672831,
-0.0045321533,
0.7393673658,
-0.0999966636,
-0.4108920395,
-0.304794699,
0.114664495,
-0.360319972,
-0.2919654846,
0.2595380843,
0.5448567867,
0.2341875136,
0.7475756407,
0.1421199888,
0.9185822606,
-0.4982320666,
0.209451586,
-0.1683066487,
-0.8012074232,
0.4423097372,
-0.414958328,
0.3047074378,
0.6127311587,
0.1573439538,
-0.3225420713,
-0.471927911,
-0.3800504208,
-0.5533646345,
0.8333813548,
0.0155653441,
0.0420298986,
0.2169836313,
0.509563148,
0.3237282336,
0.0846351832,
-0.5734719038,
-0.2009028345,
0.0206394661,
0.1011775732,
-0.1225675121,
0.0229512528,
-0.2562769055,
-0.3381557465,
0.7266198397,
-0.3116659224,
0.2987501323,
0.0435920693,
0.0054308427,
-0.6544654965,
0.0159944408,
0.4913429022,
0.5349951386,
-0.4782164991,
-0.0011565491,
0.0938278437,
-0.3353967369,
0.0805473551,
0.4267702401,
-0.3163327575,
-0.2589643002,
0.3861979246,
0.9088112712,
0.4289164543,
-0.504712224,
0.637411654,
-0.1522900611,
-0.2586857677,
0.0974380523,
0.2552804351,
0.0788635761,
0.6326344609,
-0.0644690692,
0.3646199405,
-0.1662324071,
-0.2161763906,
0.1825242043,
0.5433931351,
-0.1074744835,
-0.439770788,
0.6732472777,
0.2683154643,
-0.2322833836,
0.7003722787,
-0.1080846414,
-0.1903031915,
0.2892875671,
0.9007876515,
0.7069705129,
-0.2836258709,
0.237200141,
-0.0271030199,
0.3006972075,
-0.0554387718,
0.0851599202,
-0.3607187271,
-0.8319495916,
-0.310177207,
-0.810408473,
-0.3552217185,
-0.0402895585,
-0.5666924715,
0.0361136533,
-0.7137184739,
0.075331673,
-0.1294209063,
0.469460398,
-0.8512811661,
-0.3020303249,
0.031558644,
1.0017744303,
-0.7384831309,
0.8733587861,
0.4590978026,
-0.2274540216,
-0.6918148994,
-0.1897003502,
-0.04180317,
-1.0384764671,
0.212825045,
0.042126745,
-0.0000676398,
0.2036416084,
-0.3861099482,
-0.8665084839,
1.4288538694,
0.6491451859,
-0.8197494745,
0.1552632451,
0.1269566715,
0.6021345854,
-0.3211086094,
-0.1254857481,
0.4600009918,
0.3878639936,
0.0589416437,
-0.8062427044,
0.1539968997,
0.1264049709,
-0.1419868618,
0.4323962033,
-1.083722353,
0.7345712185,
-0.3892408609,
-0.2794522941,
-0.1572736055,
0.7142681479,
-0.2099689096,
0.2444413751,
0.3288817704,
0.4615192711,
1.229735136,
0.0318320841,
0.8482816815,
-0.1769842654,
0.6050427556,
1.147564888,
-0.4906434417,
0.7166668773,
0.4665420055,
0.0128704142,
0.0698857158,
0.4862388074,
-0.1696116924,
0.6685788035,
-0.0138361882,
-0.5343641043,
-0.278747201,
-0.0154970214,
-0.2157044113,
0.4835420847,
0.0324520469,
-0.1819729209,
-0.5092996955,
-0.1315077692,
0.0545333028,
-0.0351194777,
-0.3418021798,
1.0303007364,
0.1306038946,
-0.320520997,
0.6937260628,
0.0771683827,
0.5082744956,
-0.428227365,
0.2721381187,
-0.8619129062,
0.5033666492,
-0.3035977483,
-0.3848280013,
0.4288226068,
0.0411076434,
-0.1738244742,
-0.3247413337,
0.6127843857,
-0.4488324523,
-0.3766742945,
0.3363740146,
0.4757986069,
0.0877733603,
0.15668118,
-0.3978026509,
0.0045128441,
0.0823189318,
-0.2594054043,
0.63252455,
0.5685052276,
0.2111022174,
0.7722741961,
0.720526576,
0.2918173373,
-0.3152066767,
-0.2376774549,
0.9477385879,
-0.0490407459,
-0.2777236104,
-0.7235842347,
-0.1258573085,
0.1685283184,
-0.1612736136,
0.3976364136,
0.5631710887,
1.1119271517,
-0.0710792691,
0.3851243556,
0.2345248759,
0.1751790941,
-0.2801682055,
1.0049057007,
-0.6915804148,
0.2964725196,
0.0747568682,
-0.934424758,
-0.5069352388,
0.5861054659,
-0.3211064041,
-0.5823227763,
0.2971363962,
0.9865529537,
-0.5007744431,
0.3665663898,
0.4396092892,
0.4253814518,
0.3746664822,
0.5028172731,
0.2447335124,
-0.3274845779,
0.3733430207,
-0.5260285735,
-0.3239546418,
-0.3748261034,
-0.8842039704,
-0.8198404312,
-0.3380523026,
-0.2181233466,
0.0908694565,
0.303176254,
1.098998785,
0.556981802,
-0.8104009628,
-0.1790078133,
-0.0486437455,
0.3350737691,
-0.3214845657,
-0.2156815678,
0.1819535196,
-0.3700588048,
-0.4218214154,
0.5495336056,
0.2685579062,
-0.0497973114,
0.0539200865,
0.0155086815,
-0.0407390818,
-0.1328044683,
0.3767641187,
0.199816823,
-0.4235520661,
-0.4883957207,
-0.2360368669,
0.1222584248,
0.2652254999,
0.5801466703,
-0.531957984,
0.3747849166,
0.2756384611,
1.0054434538,
0.4622303843,
0.1138803437,
0.5114562511,
-1.0152529478,
0.1507530212,
0.1432895958,
0.4259886146,
0.3471317589,
-0.5651271939,
0.5385800004,
0.4028305709,
-0.99488765,
-0.9774573445,
0.0692977384,
-0.9484065771,
0.000944828,
0.8747699857,
-0.3770753443,
-0.3763548136,
0.4154666662,
0.1255165637,
0.2611009479,
-0.5223808885,
0.7555371523,
0.4214403033,
-0.2153488547,
-0.0562681258,
-0.3491328657,
0.5045105219,
0.0898651332,
-0.6350896955,
0.3853310049,
0.4676021636,
0.5270512104,
-0.1931151897,
0.5081238151,
0.3013749123,
0.0359530225,
-0.091162689,
-0.133034572,
-0.3734716773,
-0.3304107785,
-0.278206557,
0.0038673191,
0.0008904476,
-0.0978057086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17692v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17692v1 | From Distributional to Overton Pluralism: Investigating Large Language Model Alignment | 2024-06-25T16:32:33 | 2024-06-25T16:32:33 | Thom Lake, Eunsol Choi, Greg Durrett | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The alignment process changes several properties of a large language model's
(LLM's) output distribution. We analyze two aspects of post-alignment
distributional shift of LLM responses. First, we re-examine previously reported
reductions in response diversity post-alignment. Our analysis suggests that an
apparent drop in the diversity of responses is largely explained by quality
control and information aggregation. Alignment suppresses irrelevant and
unhelpful content while shifting the output distribution toward longer
responses that cover information spanning several responses from the base LLM,
essentially presenting diverse information in a single response. Finding little
evidence that alignment suppresses useful information, it is natural to ask the
opposite question: do aligned models surface information that cannot be
recovered from base models? Our second investigation shows this is not the case
and the behavior of aligned models is recoverable from base models without
fine-tuning. A combination of in-context examples and lower-resolution semantic
hints about response content can elicit responses from base LLMs that are as
similar to alignment-tuned LLM responses as alignment-tuned LLM responses are
to each other. Taken together, these results indicate that current alignment
techniques capture but do not extend the useful subset of assistant-like base
LLM behavior, providing further evidence for the Superficial Alignment
Hypothesis. They also show that in-context alignment can go surprisingly far as
a strategy for imitating aligned LLMs without fine-tuning. Our code and data is
available at https://github.com/thomlake/investigating-alignment. | [
-0.3572612107,
-0.6840221286,
0.4582279623,
-0.1833653599,
-0.2065301687,
0.1259566694,
-0.2511951327,
-0.4872358143,
0.340939939,
0.6331589222,
-0.4853112996,
-0.3766365051,
-0.7288235426,
-0.1302158535,
-0.762209475,
1.1083130836,
0.0932238996,
0.0335279368,
-0.0364086516,
-0.4473238289,
-0.4011707008,
-0.4527368546,
-0.4830315709,
-0.1531320512,
0.5541692972,
0.2372053564,
1.0056449175,
0.9561849833,
0.6725093722,
0.3666635156,
-0.2885673344,
-0.1238244846,
-0.6868346334,
0.1771070808,
-0.2085374296,
-0.558734417,
-0.6379987597,
-0.0953887925,
1.1154820919,
0.9242749214,
-0.247880891,
0.15438658,
0.1575137824,
0.6748482585,
-0.7469856143,
-0.494851023,
-0.6785085201,
-0.3157474697,
-0.3321804404,
0.0615615733,
-0.3850444853,
-0.3683567941,
0.1902551651,
-0.4877145588,
0.141340971,
-0.0063123214,
0.7836381197,
0.2339648604,
-0.6307080388,
-0.5440140963,
-0.9943330884,
0.9425038695,
-0.707208097,
0.5244528651,
0.053491693,
0.2599878311,
-0.0636537895,
-0.251416415,
-0.7079033852,
0.0920037404,
0.1034398302,
0.3428815603,
-0.0380462147,
-0.0754280016,
0.0947925374,
0.5475943685,
-0.7295458317,
0.247266829,
-0.372485131,
0.0801310688,
0.7952523828,
0.2363420129,
0.2812575996,
0.1228299066,
-0.3980025947,
-0.1958993673,
-0.8913653493,
-0.0435937233,
0.5969097614,
0.2815925777,
-0.0514858402,
0.7963096499,
0.3684855402,
0.6639254093,
0.2596192956,
-0.0343520343,
0.0988813043,
-0.3147541583,
-0.3110569715,
0.2378035337,
0.6624010205,
0.2773447931,
0.080717355,
0.033363305,
-0.2805520594,
-0.0436930098,
0.215641126,
-0.3623355329,
0.0978913531,
0.1933740675,
-0.4645577073,
-0.0633228645,
0.2378415018,
-0.6048516631,
-0.5620275736,
-0.5802282691,
0.1240142956,
-0.3186299801,
-0.5278984308,
0.1853113025,
-0.1095217541,
0.4334071577,
0.3985116184,
-1.1895558834,
0.4711874425,
1.0593297482,
0.8450273871,
-0.4717775285,
-0.3147090077,
-0.179209426,
0.2892761827,
-0.4969888628,
0.57005018,
-0.5027976036,
-0.19236283,
0.2715205252,
-0.0092453659,
-0.1781678796,
-0.7795317769,
0.143067807,
-0.6872810721,
0.2084143609,
-0.6037862301,
-0.6918753386,
0.1575967968,
0.1834889501,
-0.7074827552,
0.6638408303,
0.0949253067,
-0.7761644125,
0.3696780801,
-0.3033815026,
-0.2280256897,
-0.2905472815,
-0.2326208353,
-0.2348923385,
0.3195472956,
-0.1601011902,
0.0194348395,
-0.0450692028,
0.0769212246,
-0.7724584937,
-0.3725261688,
0.439479202,
-0.259939611,
0.9584341049,
0.1535267532,
-0.066942811,
0.148516044,
-0.6216879487,
-0.2200836092,
0.0054325089,
-0.3140674829,
-0.4097646177,
0.0150592318,
-0.2326494306,
0.1990567446,
0.2270571887,
-0.5792495012,
0.5580427051,
-0.5858969688,
0.2990229428,
0.900363028,
-0.3739639223,
1.0643075705,
-0.303173095,
0.499063015,
0.0338014364,
0.1212913096,
0.2314141095,
-0.2467535585,
-0.5347570777,
-0.1372653544,
0.1983070523,
0.3998045921,
-0.1794656515,
0.4743616581,
-0.4996857643,
-0.0870595202,
-0.8511551023,
0.2495653778,
0.2409150153,
0.2791108787,
0.0862230361,
-0.5310991406,
-0.4924439192,
-0.9163810015,
-0.1761363596,
-0.2592211366,
0.0480191,
0.0269637778,
0.1072498262,
-0.1102361307,
0.9716515541,
-0.447776109,
-0.0665279999,
-0.2534607947,
-0.0381612405,
0.1806608737,
0.2591573894,
0.5250889063,
-0.6156787276,
-0.2931255996,
0.2799358666,
-0.5505114198,
-0.0840178728,
0.1073995456,
-0.2725930512,
0.5272356868,
0.5096902251,
-0.8279122114,
0.2627131641,
0.8248744607,
-0.1300798357,
0.346968323,
0.0789818093,
0.0235256329,
-1.423973918,
-0.0242603626,
-0.1852716953,
-0.018783452,
-0.5750777721,
0.0389253311,
0.0149620092,
0.2428077906,
-0.0399127267,
0.5111855268,
-0.5507342219,
-0.5627545714,
-0.5155347586,
0.1688282192,
-0.1098086685,
0.0716543421,
-0.0182518903,
0.5171285868,
0.3115296662,
-0.3801142573,
0.2362878472,
0.3427806199,
-0.0749329627,
0.5491479635,
-0.5651684403,
0.1362089813,
-0.4403169155,
0.379047215,
-1.5018159151,
-0.3494236767,
0.2855636775,
-0.3169913292,
0.5154743195,
-0.1267138571,
-0.3423043489,
-0.0649979115,
-0.5006008744,
0.5416459441,
0.6151413918,
-0.4518019259,
0.4917652607,
0.4135845304,
-0.260689497,
-0.6479878426,
-0.7843862772,
-0.3231708705,
-0.4330000281,
-0.6844699383,
0.213518694,
-0.1386311352,
-0.5187363029,
-0.2492155135,
-0.2560521066,
-0.0237322599,
0.081830889,
0.0867667124,
0.1968939751,
-0.5235204697,
0.2382548451,
0.0609130487,
0.2846765518,
0.0813508183,
-0.1899348348,
0.678502202,
0.1029502079,
-0.6721741557,
-0.3262159526,
0.4272992015,
0.6393911839,
-0.060607519,
0.8998501897,
0.3829799294,
-0.0993735939,
0.1866390407,
-0.3785037696,
-0.2246207148,
-0.479190588,
0.3229437768,
-0.07919164,
-0.8205908537,
0.7783711553,
0.1584782153,
0.380949825,
0.4622953832,
0.5591027141,
-0.3777829409,
1.3274216652,
0.6095992923,
-0.1104762629,
0.7196706533,
-0.0822224915,
0.3959880471,
-0.9258185029,
0.0908703282,
-0.5134387016,
-0.611557126,
-0.576179266,
0.158118546,
-0.0085504297,
0.3329222202,
-0.1920515895,
0.2192355692,
-0.3942369819,
0.3662243187,
0.3695233762,
-0.2129359692,
0.2068926245,
-0.1741051972,
0.6010505557,
-0.0945884213,
-0.5768651366,
-0.3964975476,
0.9851528406,
0.4293395281,
0.9332696795,
0.6087629795,
0.771648705,
-0.1352683604,
0.4244781733,
-0.7215029597,
0.3794208169,
-0.1630761623,
-0.4034764767,
-0.4563673139,
-0.2533660829,
-1.0464324951,
0.1976751685,
-0.01972422,
-0.8465048671,
0.2665048838,
0.4435984194,
-0.3341287076,
0.0564097054,
-0.779896915,
0.6750439405,
-0.1446909904,
-0.0175444037,
0.0916960016,
-0.8688566089,
0.5534646511,
-0.0436389036,
0.2212810665,
0.0474992208,
0.1236498579,
0.5139935017,
-0.1867469996,
0.9452959895,
0.1811077744,
-0.6600865126,
-0.002419905,
0.1192563325,
0.4770209193,
-0.0823138133,
0.0348111205,
-0.0947983935,
0.0515579544,
-0.4964920878,
-0.8607888222,
0.848767519,
-0.979667902,
-0.7291492224,
-0.1174375117,
-0.7867152691,
0.0049792784,
-0.0031539348,
0.5442723036,
0.3438290358,
-0.0376090296,
0.1782190204,
0.6902672052,
0.1512838304,
0.4359588027,
0.2578851879,
-0.3532072008,
-0.3625008762,
0.6784319878,
0.4254299104,
0.7684916854,
0.3258488774,
0.0928360969,
-0.5939589739,
-0.6448528767,
-0.4658730328,
0.2479758263,
-0.7795271873,
0.0173284952,
-0.4296283424,
-0.1783950627,
-0.8922101855,
-0.1452624947,
-0.4498906136,
-0.5111704469,
-0.2418214828,
0.0006632299,
-0.054563541,
1.0022357702,
0.2838056386,
0.483910054,
-0.7436643243,
-0.0983910188,
0.0905467197,
0.0355993621,
-0.1252169013,
-0.8358335495,
-0.139210701,
0.287887007,
-0.4205441177,
-1.0302827358,
0.1676010936,
0.1569920778,
0.3549642563,
0.6543000937,
-0.0509779267,
0.8110283613,
-0.2967144549,
0.7633128166,
0.1579685509,
-0.9614928365,
0.2572380602,
-0.3397291899,
0.5484765768,
0.2662426829,
0.2674289942,
-0.4730205834,
-0.8263142705,
-0.6391476989,
-0.9229378104,
0.5922612548,
-0.1185093373,
0.3453804553,
-0.0562891886,
0.3322853148,
0.2130931169,
0.2791219056,
-0.7081795931,
-0.0729873851,
-0.116116479,
-0.4997761846,
-0.0859922171,
-0.3191010654,
-0.5195671916,
-0.1175024062,
0.4364511669,
-0.1912098825,
0.1148737967,
0.0120210741,
-0.2858226895,
-0.2772168219,
0.2686246634,
1.0237383842,
0.8563547134,
-0.0357560627,
0.33634004,
-0.0310742762,
-0.2015337348,
0.0311574936,
-0.0952758044,
-0.035767436,
-0.1130916476,
0.6373369098,
0.6219761372,
0.0839464441,
-0.2959869206,
0.6266826391,
0.1890558004,
-0.1940640062,
-0.1826313287,
0.0639178902,
0.1200518906,
0.3830137551,
0.07789471,
-0.0299759153,
0.1943516284,
-0.6683183908,
0.0534848906,
0.8066402674,
-0.2522030473,
-0.6650725603,
0.4491356909,
-0.1506980211,
-0.4061346948,
0.7065415382,
0.0504441634,
-0.2330857515,
0.5996964574,
0.8242179751,
0.6848464012,
-0.4272598326,
0.0861725435,
0.0715509802,
0.1193872243,
-0.173373118,
0.1204455718,
0.1488087326,
-0.9769077301,
-0.4955931008,
-0.3331008852,
0.0211142991,
0.0614836253,
-0.9281173944,
0.1557651758,
-0.5081341863,
-0.0864492506,
0.1409522444,
-0.4150011241,
-0.1288107038,
-0.1754116416,
0.2180324644,
0.5812024474,
-1.1688338518,
0.6154490113,
0.814452529,
-0.2052620351,
-0.8038354516,
0.3271842599,
0.1861587316,
-0.8211343884,
0.3948729038,
0.0818505436,
0.0252863262,
-0.1019321159,
-0.7073626518,
-1.3098996878,
1.0062021017,
0.760035634,
-0.5796260238,
0.0900926739,
0.2639701366,
0.6900926828,
-0.2226278633,
0.2584198415,
0.5685477853,
0.2016121149,
0.3734751344,
-1.0166231394,
0.0340027101,
0.1027848348,
0.1459674984,
0.7662224174,
-0.6685165763,
1.0196949244,
0.0490839034,
-0.361969471,
0.1665284038,
0.5741562843,
0.3489995897,
0.0993452743,
0.4213430285,
0.7550628185,
0.6843278408,
0.0053910599,
1.0406908989,
-0.0476613119,
0.440497607,
0.9857406616,
-0.6976647377,
0.9425321221,
0.9237939119,
-0.0430705547,
0.2695888579,
0.5580993295,
0.2355207354,
0.4965330064,
0.2389993817,
-0.1871959567,
-0.0470644347,
-0.1084941477,
-0.3718073368,
0.2522213757,
0.0947449133,
-0.3827442229,
-0.2645788789,
-0.1982443631,
-0.3335529864,
0.0295440238,
-0.2237983644,
1.0758901834,
0.0564897545,
-0.7977225184,
0.6227529049,
-0.3395450115,
0.4370190501,
-0.367279321,
0.0190315507,
-0.3080447912,
0.2770055234,
-0.335593015,
-1.0521725416,
0.5376020074,
-0.552734971,
-0.5172225237,
-0.2250949144,
0.4643399715,
-0.6861613393,
-0.1821538061,
0.3099561632,
0.3348823488,
0.1028030217,
0.2200975418,
-0.52625072,
0.1462200135,
-0.047528442,
-0.3982077539,
0.5290034413,
0.4701659977,
-0.3773608506,
0.4086813927,
0.4759066105,
0.0683778375,
0.3867537975,
0.2015665919,
0.6919252276,
-0.3403486013,
-0.2730520368,
-1.0540236235,
0.5120306611,
-0.2157790214,
-0.4578051865,
0.5339158773,
0.4451471567,
0.9984917045,
0.0667884275,
0.5787143111,
0.0518442877,
0.2625660002,
-0.7009497285,
0.3563220203,
-0.5960241556,
0.2698531449,
-0.1259429306,
-1.1217663288,
-0.3176816106,
0.3076420724,
-0.3684796393,
0.0136996228,
0.5932008028,
0.7027670145,
-0.3399082422,
-0.0959550515,
0.2626110911,
0.2202316076,
0.2442270815,
0.1420349926,
1.1600512266,
-0.2319878787,
0.453258276,
0.1666692048,
-0.0747941583,
-0.1802570224,
-0.4984601438,
-0.5419466496,
-0.5992054939,
-0.2258784473,
-0.4056236744,
0.0590266176,
0.854254663,
0.6016752124,
-0.8488351703,
-0.3339671195,
-0.2894966602,
0.0214351434,
-0.1157510802,
-0.2249021679,
0.2424678057,
-0.1670705229,
-0.7099621892,
0.0375498943,
0.2789203227,
0.3207108676,
-0.1495704949,
-0.1662949324,
-0.0522958338,
-0.0413165651,
0.3045870066,
0.3219454885,
-0.9080901146,
-0.3705180585,
0.229456991,
-0.454204917,
0.2918761075,
0.6900176406,
0.0304473843,
0.0730465576,
0.6142241955,
0.7258940339,
0.0000969899,
0.3644132018,
0.9574849606,
-1.012753129,
0.0509820469,
0.2341617495,
0.3875310123,
0.2311878949,
-0.3974577188,
-0.0214506555,
-0.0175094046,
-0.6687682867,
-0.9322599769,
0.7330185175,
-0.9907383323,
-0.2395566404,
1.3324820995,
0.1083600298,
-0.3432374001,
0.1500605792,
-0.2685819566,
0.302885592,
-0.3663576245,
0.9136174917,
1.0740809441,
-0.1669926941,
-0.2585880458,
-0.2720018923,
0.3944538236,
0.7800417542,
-0.6780000329,
0.208715573,
0.5098074675,
0.3327996731,
0.4358361661,
0.5815368891,
-0.0343452506,
0.1659796834,
-0.44764328,
0.0079803541,
0.6040805578,
-0.2257709801,
-0.782156229,
0.0681727901,
0.392262727,
-0.2835373878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17681v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17681v2 | VarBench: Robust Language Model Benchmarking Through Dynamic Variable Perturbation | 2024-06-25T16:13:53 | 2024-06-26T15:21:49 | Kun Qian, Shunji Wan, Claudia Tang, Youzhi Wang, Xuanming Zhang, Maximillian Chen, Zhou Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models achieve impressive scores on traditional benchmarks,
an increasing number of researchers are becoming concerned about benchmark data
leakage during pre-training, commonly known as the data contamination problem.
To ensure fair evaluation, recent benchmarks release only the training and
validation sets, keeping the test set labels closed-source. They require anyone
wishing to evaluate his language model to submit the model's predictions for
centralized processing and then publish the model's result on their
leaderboard. However, this submission process is inefficient and prevents
effective error analysis. To address this issue, we propose to variabilize
benchmarks and evaluate language models dynamically. Specifically, we extract
variables from each test case and define a value range for each variable. For
each evaluation, we sample new values from these value ranges to create unique
test cases, thus ensuring a fresh evaluation each time. We applied this
variable perturbation method to four datasets: GSM8K, ARC, CommonsenseQA, and
TruthfulQA, which cover mathematical generation and multiple-choice tasks. Our
experimental results demonstrate that this approach provides a more accurate
assessment of the true capabilities of language models, effectively mitigating
the contamination problem. | [
-0.340051502,
-0.8280424476,
0.3760200441,
0.1689840704,
-0.1390585005,
0.3980206251,
-0.2821321189,
-0.2665879726,
-0.4229383469,
0.8737354279,
-0.6400975585,
-0.4717431068,
-0.4097360373,
-0.3282599151,
-0.4273326397,
0.7348734736,
-0.3006047904,
-0.0489801317,
-0.3462970555,
-0.2313050777,
-0.4095490277,
-0.7219994664,
0.023846088,
-0.1852668375,
0.1649177372,
0.5676262379,
0.5158442855,
0.6740543842,
0.6609284282,
0.3748242557,
-0.0066350433,
-0.2587406933,
-0.6412115693,
0.709180057,
-0.2193281502,
-0.5592096448,
-0.1905382574,
-0.002372263,
0.9246409535,
0.5485726595,
-0.3424534202,
0.473163873,
-0.1339464933,
0.4096170068,
-0.7565364838,
0.2100079507,
-0.7585687637,
-0.021501882,
-0.6601529121,
0.1815175414,
-0.3413285613,
-0.4946816564,
-0.2947078049,
-0.2216394991,
-0.0139882648,
-0.3112151325,
1.0447946787,
0.4897026122,
-0.086811915,
0.3988835216,
-0.8816660047,
0.9082510471,
-0.6631373167,
0.1961245239,
0.3380503654,
0.8541757464,
-0.1631522477,
-0.7469440699,
-0.329081744,
-0.2079214752,
0.4258063734,
-0.19297719,
-0.041880507,
-0.2453032285,
0.260596633,
0.2933418155,
-0.2090822607,
0.1273747683,
0.1249031201,
-0.1912739277,
0.4653939903,
0.2415835708,
0.2240173519,
0.1338537037,
-0.3609465361,
-0.6599216461,
-0.7623918653,
0.0520708114,
0.8059946895,
0.4535408318,
0.1865353584,
0.3050569296,
-0.137530461,
0.5209246874,
0.0314505436,
0.163727358,
0.5645225048,
-0.6823260784,
-0.0588996969,
-0.4124705791,
0.7116447091,
-0.3195589185,
0.1348650604,
-0.03738584,
-0.2952740192,
-0.1320047528,
0.3857373893,
-0.9125450253,
-0.1417316645,
0.1210896298,
-0.1933455169,
-0.7818463445,
0.0790964514,
-1.0309906006,
-0.2594594359,
-0.0590269491,
0.2773721516,
-0.0910284743,
-0.3062695265,
0.1107262373,
0.2593614161,
-0.3646987081,
0.0660139546,
-0.8628087044,
0.5681833029,
0.3491151333,
0.1725122333,
-0.2451636493,
-0.3054365516,
-0.8732172847,
-0.1796951145,
-0.1432350874,
0.8038733602,
-0.9575466514,
-0.3116803467,
0.0964424163,
-0.3053950667,
0.2347651571,
-0.6832405329,
0.4028001428,
-0.3063856065,
0.0077665993,
-0.2303762287,
-0.2891209424,
0.2435744405,
0.0494576953,
-0.7081407309,
1.0747270584,
0.2602724731,
-0.6848099828,
0.2803892791,
-0.2921779156,
0.0220474955,
0.0857851952,
-0.461905539,
-0.7178585529,
0.0779698342,
0.1652844995,
0.1037569493,
-0.2802222967,
0.4102684557,
-0.4499039054,
-0.1877202392,
0.4155962765,
-0.86352247,
0.5559942126,
0.0238858592,
-0.5106019378,
0.29570508,
-0.9364914894,
0.5158099532,
-0.1711669415,
-0.3624969721,
-0.1576530635,
0.1318347901,
0.0493576415,
0.2974975109,
0.0581883863,
-0.284357965,
0.0354374684,
-0.1530024707,
-0.1686728001,
0.7569695711,
-0.0041967193,
-0.0233006254,
-0.2002177089,
0.7659766078,
-0.1131327972,
0.3754090071,
-0.1011941656,
-0.0771128088,
-0.4779249728,
-0.2888511121,
0.6948409081,
0.3481535017,
-0.5047152638,
0.4004674852,
-0.2071789652,
-0.7610700727,
-0.3554492593,
0.1289873719,
0.6463404894,
0.4005264938,
0.2863995135,
-0.4428515434,
-0.3107047081,
-0.7723013163,
-0.5358925462,
-0.077210322,
-0.143258214,
0.3312692344,
0.2594583631,
-0.1487193108,
0.5914040208,
-0.2944812775,
0.0340436064,
0.074019894,
0.4252588749,
0.1727744043,
0.5476585627,
0.5520162582,
-0.5856696367,
-0.5939387679,
-0.2642096579,
-0.4155744016,
-0.5225390792,
0.0580664054,
-0.1929983348,
-0.1712439805,
0.6044083834,
-0.1383573115,
0.3232238889,
0.8115127087,
-0.1777228713,
1.0473743677,
0.0138827059,
0.0740602538,
-0.7088731527,
0.2660564482,
-0.3514066339,
-0.3978061974,
-0.4651622772,
0.1781381667,
-0.008838986,
-0.095271036,
-0.5127078891,
0.3574231565,
-0.2857138515,
0.1819904894,
-0.0588742606,
-0.1030562222,
-0.1788237095,
-0.023778772,
-0.2410247475,
0.6410044432,
0.6033862829,
-0.1506943703,
0.3277918696,
0.1452955604,
-0.4444570839,
0.095336929,
-0.4276731014,
0.1241043955,
0.3042656183,
0.2103605866,
-0.8643176556,
-0.1399511248,
-0.0190681089,
-0.2601995468,
0.405138433,
-0.0184017569,
-0.5726305842,
-0.1660849601,
-0.3515762091,
0.4116514325,
0.1708790511,
-0.4357858896,
0.2790569961,
0.4941455722,
-0.156395793,
-0.847214818,
-0.6352891326,
-0.0808077678,
-0.1029218212,
-0.3063276708,
0.2942632735,
-0.2995292246,
-0.368783772,
-0.0354101136,
-0.5239920616,
-0.2412564903,
0.2735317647,
0.1861926019,
0.2016928941,
-0.1533140391,
0.3035537899,
-0.0859358311,
-0.1641131192,
0.0453253686,
0.0688579008,
0.7400957942,
-0.348215878,
-0.5486022234,
-0.2897259891,
0.2279339731,
0.5781873465,
-0.5536563396,
0.5215924382,
0.4814118147,
-0.3419923484,
-0.2600293458,
-0.5476039648,
-0.0997593477,
-0.562278986,
0.4362055957,
-0.5461261272,
-0.5992400646,
0.578346312,
-0.3442980647,
-0.0884377807,
0.2607012689,
0.5948129296,
0.239122957,
0.7640650272,
0.8272765875,
0.0313102715,
0.8536984324,
0.1250974089,
0.0575789213,
-0.2506455183,
0.0732243508,
-0.7690438032,
0.0722294077,
-0.7860886455,
-0.5811495781,
0.0127885351,
-0.1042741984,
-0.3553572297,
0.1585445553,
-0.2564089298,
0.6324127913,
0.2768457234,
-0.204000622,
0.1104929671,
0.0522234477,
-0.601385057,
-0.1546780914,
-0.3967387676,
-0.5628715158,
1.234164238,
0.2133727223,
0.9035712481,
0.0334246308,
0.791134119,
-0.0320352316,
0.2669600546,
-0.1563805789,
0.4073298275,
-0.3213916123,
-0.6461597085,
-0.5021326542,
-0.6612391472,
-0.7244041562,
0.2060107589,
-0.1911086291,
-1.1912952662,
0.35899508,
-0.0530970991,
-0.2632606328,
0.2823561132,
-0.432884872,
0.7795351148,
-0.3141650856,
-0.7120571136,
-0.055281695,
-0.631416738,
0.3978429437,
-0.5503159761,
0.1843415201,
-0.258985877,
0.1666773707,
0.3876871467,
-0.5608347058,
0.6741366982,
-0.0958431363,
0.0014910946,
0.02145526,
0.2747166455,
0.4169217646,
0.1285927892,
-0.3639214337,
0.1220551133,
0.0801217631,
-0.3557335734,
-0.5021569729,
0.6814695001,
-0.6929961443,
-0.5510912538,
-0.5157801509,
-0.5092198849,
-0.6992141008,
0.4316835701,
0.1695740968,
0.1962052584,
-0.1848526299,
0.4402851462,
0.7069283128,
-0.312472105,
0.4051008821,
0.5796568394,
-0.3423843086,
-0.1719615459,
0.6789928675,
0.0234921761,
0.5993794203,
0.2054197043,
0.3161427677,
-0.0850615874,
-0.5091971159,
-0.001086213,
0.07655821,
-0.596370697,
-0.1895349473,
-0.1463850439,
-0.3663466573,
-0.0981204733,
0.1780303121,
-1.0083462,
-0.1778927594,
0.1109001487,
0.0294607431,
-0.1374983639,
0.5176128149,
-0.0704866573,
0.1747050732,
-0.7114647031,
0.0992235616,
0.2170306295,
0.7696744204,
-0.2703927159,
-0.0769359171,
-0.1513186842,
-0.0096627409,
-0.3239521682,
-0.6450040936,
0.2365336269,
0.0430123992,
0.9145047069,
0.3943226337,
0.1734483242,
0.5039999485,
-0.5248273611,
0.7047789097,
0.1459443867,
-1.3312622309,
0.5418487787,
-0.4328227639,
0.5020045042,
0.9422245622,
0.0837371945,
-0.2714448571,
-0.6894491911,
-0.7823172808,
-1.0942643881,
0.5923342705,
0.3725684881,
0.1062560901,
0.499004364,
0.2085653991,
0.2814792991,
0.5513302088,
-0.4959873855,
-0.1365324557,
-0.2865737081,
-0.0547202602,
-0.1450126618,
-0.3022529781,
-0.2374265492,
-0.166825667,
0.4351426363,
0.080259949,
0.1328061074,
-0.5026043653,
0.0214909185,
-0.3324079812,
0.1028683782,
0.3919410408,
0.8352442384,
-0.2712946534,
0.2402770966,
0.0049753692,
-0.6602143645,
0.2760472,
0.2680282891,
0.1443858594,
0.0119337402,
0.1458704174,
0.5317912698,
0.1239093393,
-0.8622183204,
0.4638811648,
-0.5033205152,
0.041282367,
-0.07725171,
0.2634062469,
-0.0358729474,
0.1696409434,
0.1600962579,
0.1637719423,
-0.1684010327,
-0.5248527527,
0.6286041737,
0.0723926648,
-0.3289273381,
-0.2405962199,
0.7462225556,
-0.0368856713,
-0.1788452119,
0.4683980346,
0.2256804705,
-0.5088540316,
0.5514657497,
0.3595643342,
0.7273726463,
-0.7795897126,
0.2229113877,
0.1192311645,
0.1670365483,
-0.1440082639,
0.3321295977,
0.0802479908,
-0.6569697857,
-0.2850920558,
-0.4697578847,
-0.6568317413,
0.4989131689,
-0.7782521248,
0.2311470658,
-0.279964447,
-0.2210745513,
0.1276891679,
0.2878445387,
-0.6090157628,
0.2283709496,
0.1319873929,
0.6786916852,
-0.9100124836,
1.0709447861,
0.3581864238,
-0.4517532587,
-0.7683298588,
0.5272971988,
0.0364057235,
-0.3501764536,
0.4489808679,
-0.0047935448,
-0.061256215,
-0.3938015401,
-0.4804959893,
-1.2762281895,
0.5563235879,
0.8468750119,
-0.635068059,
0.4373360574,
0.2873145342,
0.6650483608,
-0.0894809067,
0.1934445202,
0.5910440683,
0.7355780602,
-0.2322711051,
-0.8579930663,
0.2298792154,
-0.5430104733,
-0.0328533277,
0.0490261577,
-0.6966329813,
0.9882206917,
0.2937900722,
-0.049684193,
-0.0297907088,
0.2064887881,
0.2941579521,
-0.3681664169,
0.4901652336,
0.0734095946,
1.0410045385,
-0.1341166943,
0.9652175903,
-0.1934062988,
0.3813804686,
1.5507075787,
-0.4189993143,
0.9820688963,
0.4726576805,
-0.2193202823,
0.4222073555,
0.5288047791,
-0.22276932,
0.690689683,
0.7430639863,
-0.2733301222,
-0.2351727039,
0.0633802563,
-0.3133722544,
0.6670245528,
0.2226838619,
-0.1245440766,
-0.3344739377,
-0.0693676099,
0.1524049491,
0.1870143563,
0.3025720417,
0.2381362319,
-0.2201059312,
-0.5825412869,
0.8296039104,
-0.1091491282,
0.1028818414,
-0.809848547,
0.1427312046,
-0.2377239317,
0.4387212694,
0.0260593258,
-0.4442048669,
0.2836537659,
0.0587718524,
0.0080781952,
-0.4712086916,
0.6657269597,
-0.5225548148,
-0.5317627192,
0.347076118,
0.596190691,
-0.0243308023,
0.0103719514,
-0.5319653153,
0.4851244688,
-0.0986335501,
-0.3837106526,
0.5073476434,
0.2467827499,
-0.1648430526,
0.6658729911,
0.4396391809,
0.2940103412,
0.1779431254,
0.2602666616,
1.129049778,
-0.3366754055,
-0.2424990684,
-0.6442317963,
0.4647436738,
-0.1617972106,
-0.270724237,
0.7233734727,
0.3844670355,
0.6016864181,
0.1243847832,
0.9072621465,
0.3512159288,
0.2818598449,
-0.2030834854,
0.859569788,
-0.290397644,
0.5631690621,
-0.4256697297,
-0.7039700747,
-0.5362852812,
0.2914720476,
-0.2727968395,
0.1163624525,
0.8169124722,
0.5681131482,
-0.0949399546,
-0.2726871967,
0.3618545234,
0.3655237854,
0.6770461798,
0.2261735499,
0.5982554555,
-0.1932696849,
0.6187332273,
-0.278672725,
-0.339928925,
-0.2614535987,
-1.0203341246,
-0.5851249099,
-0.4467743635,
-0.4027343392,
-0.2641375363,
0.4251880646,
0.2911283076,
0.7129544616,
-0.8699102998,
-0.3549319506,
-0.2288179249,
0.1075915769,
-0.4748271108,
-0.1965539306,
0.4199650586,
-0.6973742843,
-0.6284553409,
0.47759372,
-0.0910962448,
-0.0977496579,
-0.4687731266,
0.4750988185,
-0.140683651,
0.4050933123,
-0.0246345848,
0.0997190028,
-0.2171712816,
-0.3991381824,
-0.3102780879,
-0.0048124911,
0.1719123274,
0.5806469321,
-0.7622908354,
0.8802075386,
0.5129436851,
0.6411670446,
0.8550867438,
0.0553065538,
0.8097665906,
-0.9129621387,
0.1636336446,
0.3722416162,
0.0748821571,
0.1671991646,
-0.3147170246,
0.2414090633,
0.0466085747,
-0.4470244646,
-1.2113126516,
0.215539813,
-0.5472165346,
-0.3419705331,
1.0410952568,
-0.4437457323,
-0.3374828696,
0.0752975419,
0.3394052088,
0.3350498676,
-0.2131725997,
0.8978998065,
1.0845022202,
0.0756175071,
0.0472847223,
-0.7335735559,
0.5301119685,
0.3256911337,
-1.0441610813,
0.3246204555,
0.2730185986,
0.5350875854,
-0.0075144903,
0.2194041759,
-0.4915367365,
0.151570186,
0.4128555357,
0.2273030132,
-0.030611556,
-0.2916402519,
-0.3361120522,
0.3037795424,
-0.0297188628,
-0.3869168162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17675v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17675v1 | Quantifying AI Psychology: A Psychometrics Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T16:09:08 | 2024-06-25T16:09:08 | Yuan Li, Yue Huang, Hongyi Wang, Xiangliang Zhang, James Zou, Lichao Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional task-solving
capabilities, increasingly adopting roles akin to human-like assistants. The
broader integration of LLMs into society has sparked interest in whether they
manifest psychological attributes, and whether these attributes are
stable-inquiries that could deepen the understanding of their behaviors.
Inspired by psychometrics, this paper presents a framework for investigating
psychology in LLMs, including psychological dimension identification,
assessment dataset curation, and assessment with results validation. Following
this framework, we introduce a comprehensive psychometrics benchmark for LLMs
that covers six psychological dimensions: personality, values, emotion, theory
of mind, motivation, and intelligence. This benchmark includes thirteen
datasets featuring diverse scenarios and item types. Our findings indicate that
LLMs manifest a broad spectrum of psychological attributes. We also uncover
discrepancies between LLMs' self-reported traits and their behaviors in
real-world scenarios. This paper demonstrates a thorough psychometric
assessment of LLMs, providing insights into reliable evaluation and potential
applications in AI and social sciences. | [
-0.4100242853,
-0.7426041961,
0.7899719477,
0.5784057975,
0.3535838723,
0.3125786781,
-0.5807130337,
-0.4769278467,
0.0239104405,
0.1712092459,
-0.728287518,
-0.2377538532,
-0.5886526108,
0.2074388713,
-0.3691756427,
0.7207246423,
0.1547539383,
0.2441271693,
-0.6338183284,
-0.2197879255,
-0.3916924596,
-0.7218486071,
-0.7896572351,
-0.5621416569,
0.5580047369,
0.1033656597,
0.6197844148,
0.4877277315,
0.715408504,
0.3208621442,
0.1243418977,
0.0446691141,
-0.36882177,
0.1971108019,
-0.0608385913,
-0.5030167103,
-0.6411031485,
0.4204614758,
0.5359680057,
0.8279339671,
0.0265373792,
0.5325394273,
0.0313313678,
0.453216821,
-0.5954650044,
0.3505352736,
-0.2292559445,
-0.0841143206,
-0.1451201141,
0.2195590734,
-0.3076613545,
-0.2624102235,
-0.2109249681,
-0.1317077279,
-0.0443653949,
-0.1109846234,
0.411469698,
0.3299448788,
-0.5465916395,
-0.1179121435,
-0.7501832247,
0.872168541,
-0.5750185847,
0.4451898336,
0.5761816502,
0.201633513,
-0.1034195498,
-0.3317374885,
-0.5683812499,
-0.4620334208,
-0.1570628732,
-0.146669507,
-0.1109135151,
-0.0290738065,
0.3189319968,
0.3521520495,
-0.6082243323,
0.3598431349,
0.0352295302,
-0.125378117,
1.1332447529,
0.6587833166,
0.3056234419,
0.2618953586,
0.257217288,
-0.1568263471,
-0.4796819091,
0.1758952588,
0.3111982942,
0.0693388432,
-0.4543888271,
0.4545455873,
-0.1244226918,
0.3774896264,
-0.0138181569,
-0.3660020828,
0.266402483,
-0.1584558487,
-0.0233297516,
-0.3025692999,
0.8030484319,
0.2564364076,
0.511940062,
-0.3017642498,
-0.1475997418,
0.1575494856,
0.2137037069,
-0.6314796209,
0.0113843782,
0.3791040778,
-0.6149247885,
-0.2113349736,
-0.2210858762,
-0.5884731412,
-0.7220441699,
-0.3774231076,
-0.0650777742,
-0.3019403517,
-0.3353684247,
-0.3077644706,
0.0709892213,
0.4936502874,
0.0333013758,
-0.8826687932,
0.3553314805,
0.9534088969,
0.6313683987,
-0.3901949525,
-0.5484296679,
-0.2235325873,
-0.0832501128,
-0.6488233209,
0.5533261895,
-0.7219746709,
-0.2388541549,
0.1815437824,
-0.1936891824,
0.2146918178,
-0.5357639194,
0.3095744848,
-0.2254148573,
-0.0357751325,
-0.3418585658,
-0.5893180966,
0.0961364135,
0.6667039394,
-0.4269174635,
1.0606256723,
0.233273983,
-0.2981700897,
0.3195979893,
-0.7225554585,
-0.3801932633,
0.1366260797,
-0.464872092,
-0.0559986196,
0.3555172384,
0.0845625624,
0.6441698074,
-0.620265305,
0.256313622,
-0.5178965926,
-0.255800426,
0.9209301472,
-0.557916522,
0.7783947587,
0.0435371362,
0.1520989835,
0.1142939255,
-1.0045152903,
0.2049233168,
0.1182748675,
-0.2226723284,
-0.0996712223,
0.2564106584,
0.0161478966,
0.1279925555,
0.6770002246,
-0.484629035,
0.118196547,
-0.073868379,
0.3961368501,
0.711990118,
-0.1505510956,
0.2255346477,
-0.2051977813,
0.6092678308,
-0.3996814489,
0.2092660964,
0.1938448101,
-0.0596029758,
-0.5107519031,
-0.7500312328,
-0.1785977185,
0.4777915478,
0.0254237875,
0.8207470179,
-0.2147193402,
-0.8252649307,
-0.4650316238,
0.3427076936,
0.3343334794,
0.0348209627,
-0.0072050723,
0.0145383747,
-0.3511437178,
-0.9059789777,
-0.4476368129,
-0.3759496808,
-0.4436476827,
0.2982525826,
0.5257703662,
-0.3156000972,
0.7778602242,
-0.223801434,
-0.2490392923,
-0.2556793392,
0.3859312236,
0.2435802072,
0.2054498792,
0.5788555145,
-0.4920550883,
-0.1119357869,
-0.2605610192,
-1.0926939249,
-0.3211263716,
0.0579152368,
0.2274684161,
0.0052273711,
0.5628136992,
-0.6373965144,
0.2495329529,
0.4941893816,
-0.405932337,
0.6182503104,
-0.1618001759,
0.0292985551,
-0.6440056562,
0.19468005,
0.1445135027,
0.0844741091,
-0.4432163835,
0.201060012,
-0.061435014,
0.0672548115,
-0.0652861595,
0.6684541702,
-0.3949639499,
-0.393999517,
-0.1159159988,
-0.0355685279,
-0.2873323262,
0.3787769079,
-0.1438207328,
0.7803277373,
0.4620449245,
-0.2409582138,
0.6974147558,
0.075971745,
-0.4170415103,
0.9732100964,
-0.6223840714,
0.2678729296,
-0.0780581608,
0.1915962696,
-1.0255147219,
-0.3413330317,
-0.3903391659,
-0.4592475593,
-0.1298588514,
0.3439360559,
-0.8504856229,
-0.335814029,
-0.2357551008,
0.4485934675,
0.4258241057,
-0.0979698151,
0.8794772029,
0.3153634965,
-0.3286121786,
-0.2189264297,
-0.5173999667,
0.3248880506,
-0.4502730072,
-0.2834478617,
0.2571124434,
-0.3568059206,
-0.7112150788,
-0.2062970549,
0.2227030993,
0.0062885759,
0.2251191437,
0.3065746427,
0.2684032619,
-0.2050789446,
0.0233728718,
-0.5142737031,
-0.0795408785,
0.5972871184,
0.3154926598,
0.7315376997,
-0.3917970955,
-0.3780157566,
-0.4955087602,
0.2605245709,
0.9077337384,
-0.4450973868,
0.716522038,
0.7828098536,
-0.4556765258,
0.1413587928,
-0.6332885027,
-0.1871020496,
-0.4122408926,
0.6186588407,
-0.4116840363,
-0.5679091215,
0.7742052078,
0.0682620406,
-0.0335887,
0.1170045435,
0.7722367644,
-0.2730499506,
1.4775345325,
0.7498426437,
-0.5452032089,
0.3465684354,
-0.0613355674,
0.4806251228,
-0.8617832065,
-0.4444563687,
-0.5223745704,
-0.5156927109,
-0.6462094784,
-0.0911614224,
0.4225626886,
-0.1582715213,
-0.8634132147,
-0.2115449756,
-0.1671424806,
0.4290380776,
0.4230609536,
-0.1599936783,
0.1035744175,
-0.2553124726,
0.3698528409,
-0.0730908513,
0.0190651156,
-0.6345543861,
1.0387821198,
0.5672115684,
0.9535363913,
0.3000105619,
0.411965847,
0.5064231753,
0.4551843703,
-0.7805039287,
0.797673583,
-0.0555362552,
-0.5204190612,
-0.4980529249,
-0.1874684244,
-0.5650458336,
-0.1062722281,
-0.2723947465,
-1.4035623074,
-0.0847486705,
-0.1624774188,
-0.1201941445,
-0.1836375743,
-0.4251405895,
0.7226904035,
-0.7456138134,
-0.2694600821,
-0.5459705591,
-0.371781975,
0.1909486204,
-0.1158242375,
-0.0068557304,
-0.4597350657,
-0.2955153883,
0.7028489709,
-0.1152831241,
0.7847082019,
0.1064262539,
-0.1436670274,
-0.2375416309,
0.1984991729,
0.2639959455,
-0.0181927625,
-0.2711015046,
0.1947875917,
0.2520727217,
-0.4067964852,
-0.902078867,
0.6560524106,
-1.1423695087,
-0.4704379141,
-0.3259839118,
-0.9158737659,
-0.7707722783,
-0.021602124,
-0.1254086345,
0.1965359002,
-0.4409362078,
0.3148492277,
0.2754133344,
-0.1999794096,
0.3279497027,
0.5782358646,
-0.2471274436,
-0.0967603549,
0.8018818498,
-0.1588268876,
0.0884039775,
0.3239652514,
0.1188180074,
-0.4464769959,
-0.4026626945,
0.0420250222,
0.4557695985,
-0.6953982115,
0.0494014807,
-0.2462510914,
-0.3615923226,
-0.6524167657,
-0.1733265519,
-0.2299996614,
0.2494901568,
-0.0324417949,
-0.0912667215,
0.4043078125,
0.9356817603,
0.0923768282,
0.2977239192,
-0.3800464869,
0.2237088382,
0.1776121408,
0.4007338583,
0.2119692117,
-0.4380350709,
-0.125425756,
0.0345448144,
-0.243815586,
-0.7402905226,
0.4113992751,
0.0858845711,
0.7128615379,
0.7261100411,
-0.187350288,
0.6033309102,
-0.2445217967,
0.9480497241,
-0.0079249674,
-0.9018753767,
0.3609632254,
-0.351947397,
0.0626465976,
0.4367649257,
0.5061829686,
-0.4833150208,
-0.3896557689,
-0.4485676289,
-0.4690498114,
0.4044867754,
0.0176183358,
0.2588135898,
0.0033983162,
0.3221425414,
-0.2918383479,
0.2008002102,
-0.6689388156,
-0.335744977,
0.1965086609,
-0.6410118341,
-0.4621004164,
-0.2247937322,
-0.1694179326,
-0.3507198095,
0.3831487,
-0.1349695027,
0.3306838572,
-0.3086047173,
-0.0256711375,
0.2214049995,
0.1687232703,
0.3546507061,
0.7392570376,
-0.3408876956,
0.1236143485,
0.0964948907,
-0.192750901,
0.4020150602,
-0.0845735893,
0.4454404414,
-0.5944868922,
0.7726481557,
0.3583110273,
-0.2367389947,
-0.9933240414,
0.5290071964,
-0.0783770829,
0.1822558343,
-0.5483064651,
0.1708432585,
0.1383605301,
0.4857704341,
0.4024944901,
-0.5265122056,
0.0237706173,
-0.9209373593,
-0.1325748861,
0.5764904022,
-0.2759907544,
-0.3609904051,
0.2440954,
0.1422073245,
-0.740509212,
0.8613073826,
-0.1015996262,
-0.2917159498,
0.7303928137,
0.4492581189,
0.8510662317,
-0.0970564857,
0.0412889346,
0.0293791816,
0.34565714,
0.1653524339,
0.3017416298,
-0.0207113493,
-0.9261708856,
-0.1918530762,
-0.6114642024,
-0.3683091998,
0.6275256276,
-0.7927407026,
-0.0668416545,
-0.4360816777,
-0.2292908132,
0.0203557704,
0.2348817438,
-1.075732708,
0.2779971659,
0.4169059992,
0.7881067395,
-1.0218764544,
0.5790931582,
0.7741039395,
-0.471624136,
-0.5551112294,
0.0612990931,
0.1500034481,
-1.2431910038,
0.8456844091,
0.0894147977,
0.0648599863,
-0.2087273151,
-0.5238665938,
-0.7324091196,
0.957793653,
0.4110541642,
-0.1631691903,
-0.1693933606,
0.5462935567,
0.8842371702,
-0.6281528473,
0.5798716545,
0.9959863424,
0.5264404416,
-0.5348379612,
-0.7184718847,
0.032365948,
-0.3548528552,
0.1661357433,
-0.1977461725,
-0.7130784988,
0.6250944734,
-0.0080771837,
0.231990993,
0.357970804,
0.668877542,
0.4187491834,
0.1014638618,
0.4212496579,
0.2813018262,
0.7942743897,
0.0270175152,
0.8826200366,
-0.6351749301,
0.0189331472,
0.9368525147,
-0.5060782433,
0.8866737485,
0.4842751324,
-0.4695829153,
0.4461414218,
0.6254631877,
-0.1930811852,
0.1662759483,
0.4645265937,
-0.1774387658,
-0.3611421883,
-0.3821695745,
0.035933394,
0.9096662402,
0.6441650391,
-0.2809819579,
0.1141322404,
0.1674107015,
-0.1515307724,
0.1940932572,
-0.339699626,
0.728677392,
-0.0188577957,
-0.675155282,
0.1613413393,
-0.121570155,
0.5952749252,
-0.5468870997,
0.1066386998,
-0.4983613789,
0.4298036695,
0.0434991159,
-1.1074910164,
0.1123046875,
0.2496833354,
-0.2602813542,
-0.3225379586,
0.3679352403,
-0.1798724532,
-0.7369470596,
0.3382514715,
0.6885961294,
0.3838113546,
-0.0440889411,
-0.5780231953,
0.2619833946,
-0.4674038887,
-0.1616770774,
0.5306025147,
0.4390500784,
-0.0939160138,
0.9825071692,
0.3711782694,
0.3259822428,
-0.2706420422,
0.2012002766,
0.2163174748,
-0.8642582297,
-0.274985522,
-1.0679621696,
0.1411996782,
-0.1368641108,
-0.5111901164,
0.6763470173,
0.4552332759,
0.5756414533,
0.2010890841,
0.7599846721,
0.0222144444,
0.245759517,
-0.1996425539,
0.6355395317,
-0.4913469851,
0.0639981106,
-0.1628372818,
-0.7486604452,
0.0266704895,
0.7246502042,
-0.4837347865,
0.2586864531,
0.3350060582,
0.8194582462,
0.2615803778,
-0.2183620781,
0.4489072263,
0.2607810795,
0.4367986619,
0.4277165532,
1.093304038,
-0.0120396176,
0.0428987555,
-0.0968859568,
-0.3441232741,
-0.1456451118,
-0.8386850953,
-1.0719838142,
-0.618253231,
-0.2456905693,
-0.0917631537,
-0.2527118623,
0.8970369697,
0.7955919504,
-0.4511838555,
-0.6343660355,
0.2713045478,
-0.0774644613,
-0.3471002579,
-0.3140188456,
0.1583442539,
-0.2742418349,
-0.5520555973,
0.1714146584,
0.2871181071,
-0.1152577251,
-0.9135900736,
-0.0671324059,
0.1383764744,
0.3059202135,
0.7159132361,
0.1050355211,
-0.9749561548,
-0.402341187,
0.1168093309,
-0.1943998784,
-0.2468746603,
0.8074302673,
-0.4855323434,
-0.1767775565,
0.4212337136,
0.7304121852,
0.0216629598,
-0.2648071051,
0.662278831,
-0.7290404439,
0.1242501885,
0.1831439137,
0.4513662457,
0.225797832,
-0.3889222145,
0.5558558106,
-0.1111357361,
-0.5898681879,
-1.0142869949,
0.0700249448,
-0.8546897173,
-0.125085175,
0.9339187145,
-0.1390078962,
-0.0917141065,
0.1159741506,
0.1957180202,
-0.127241686,
-0.1649511307,
0.8996344209,
0.9556308389,
-0.5892735124,
-0.3865560591,
-0.3314876258,
0.3014669716,
0.3918758333,
-0.8982726336,
0.2940327227,
0.445636183,
0.1952718645,
0.3146108985,
0.6462441087,
0.0863671377,
0.0502358563,
-0.0832909271,
0.164192602,
0.2048107237,
-0.2012717873,
-0.1810400188,
0.0247770939,
0.3260678649,
0.0671805665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17667v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17667v1 | This Paper Had the Smartest Reviewers -- Flattery Detection Utilising an Audio-Textual Transformer-Based Approach | 2024-06-25T15:57:02 | 2024-06-25T15:57:02 | Lukas Christ, Shahin Amiriparian, Friederike Hawighorst, Ann-Kathrin Schill, Angelo Boutalikakis, Lorenz Graf-Vlachy, Andreas König, Björn W. Schuller | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Flattery is an important aspect of human communication that facilitates
social bonding, shapes perceptions, and influences behavior through strategic
compliments and praise, leveraging the power of speech to build rapport
effectively. Its automatic detection can thus enhance the naturalness of
human-AI interactions. To meet this need, we present a novel audio textual
dataset comprising 20 hours of speech and train machine learning models for
automatic flattery detection. In particular, we employ pretrained AST,
Wav2Vec2, and Whisper models for the speech modality, and Whisper TTS models
combined with a RoBERTa text classifier for the textual modality. Subsequently,
we build a multimodal classifier by combining text and audio representations.
Evaluation on unseen test data demonstrates promising results, with Unweighted
Average Recall scores reaching 82.46% in audio-only experiments, 85.97% in
text-only experiments, and 87.16% using a multimodal approach. | [
-0.4678322673,
-0.5269863605,
0.4967636466,
0.4848813713,
-0.2800941765,
-0.0486404262,
-0.3892517388,
-0.3641065061,
0.4082683027,
0.2952046096,
-0.4944159985,
-0.6308389306,
-0.6309461594,
0.2526171505,
-0.7381821871,
1.0219317675,
0.481311053,
0.0888579711,
-0.1325373799,
-0.1299736947,
-0.3730124831,
-0.518725872,
-0.3502468467,
-0.5498890877,
0.2385942638,
0.520678103,
0.4655911624,
0.4472208619,
0.2092162222,
0.3315629959,
0.0841178,
0.0913389847,
-0.2868367136,
0.3353239298,
0.1948616803,
-0.4970620275,
-0.6252775788,
0.3223436773,
0.2918824553,
0.0170213375,
0.0338808298,
0.0477113612,
0.0715431422,
0.6544963717,
-0.3076056242,
0.5746569633,
-0.9912849665,
0.056966316,
-0.339423418,
-0.5941047668,
-0.3293457627,
-0.2595183849,
-0.0800844431,
-0.4302902818,
0.461396575,
-0.0969741419,
0.6627933383,
0.2694458365,
-0.2781362832,
-0.3886753321,
-0.573217392,
0.9218785763,
-0.5434009433,
0.3657867908,
0.4265282452,
0.2129958421,
0.2144996673,
-0.5804658532,
-0.9557678699,
-0.2754829824,
0.077824004,
0.3307692707,
-0.3381280601,
-0.1210595071,
-0.3236122727,
0.5347015858,
-0.4702697098,
-0.0249903351,
0.0778033212,
-0.1998436004,
0.5648288727,
-0.0723443851,
0.2271509022,
-0.6281682849,
-0.2970377505,
-0.3105125129,
-0.0051723239,
0.0684226528,
0.4595631063,
0.4965566993,
-0.184395209,
0.3703611791,
-0.1881827116,
0.0624218583,
0.1232744306,
0.1641765088,
0.4341129661,
-0.579949677,
0.1139688939,
0.2149762213,
0.9414380193,
0.5513271093,
0.6641460657,
-0.1682749689,
-0.310970366,
0.5413944721,
0.1510234177,
-0.5586207509,
-0.4351627231,
0.15715909,
-0.458396107,
-0.629219234,
0.1552904546,
-0.8379025459,
-0.3920356035,
-0.2453797907,
0.4063236117,
-0.3683262169,
-0.0673631653,
0.1107143834,
-0.337022543,
0.0425432771,
0.0223031305,
-0.9628400207,
0.0294126887,
0.6916535497,
0.6617223024,
-0.1535182148,
-0.1036645696,
-0.5467935205,
-0.0164439902,
0.0205649491,
1.2335698605,
-0.5045781136,
-0.4861041009,
-0.2397833318,
-0.1106091738,
0.0380315483,
-0.4235643744,
1.0719386339,
0.0448231585,
0.6669846177,
0.2899342477,
-0.4209873676,
0.0322340764,
0.3299598098,
-0.7473493814,
1.0203166008,
-0.4266221523,
-0.6584576368,
0.4194458127,
-0.7604801059,
-0.5032042861,
0.1536675841,
-0.1600743234,
-0.7774759531,
-0.0330227166,
0.7689288855,
0.7560356259,
0.0443712287,
0.2331609428,
-0.1516237557,
-0.5477266908,
0.3232723176,
-0.8244167566,
0.3204898834,
-0.0184956118,
-0.6438551545,
0.0968954489,
-0.6502757072,
0.0555681586,
0.0700953528,
-0.2597550154,
-0.4265415668,
-0.3239480555,
0.6272439361,
-0.0826281309,
0.2361258119,
-0.7872811556,
0.2011832744,
-0.3715384007,
0.4121254981,
0.699406743,
-0.3942456245,
0.2896445096,
-0.5459610224,
0.1711145937,
-0.1884261072,
0.2269626409,
-0.4601052999,
-0.6277968287,
-0.3764812648,
-0.6701907516,
0.1888773292,
0.4366447031,
-0.4730713367,
0.9002939463,
-0.4130043983,
-0.5338811874,
-0.8399602771,
-0.1054459512,
0.3779865801,
0.1462607682,
0.4112463295,
-0.3001408577,
-0.5209009647,
-0.7244318128,
-0.7510682344,
-0.3660574257,
-0.2722658217,
0.2684614062,
0.3530494273,
-0.2947279215,
1.0015647411,
-0.22293742,
-1.0121603012,
-0.0619869828,
0.5582648516,
0.0430421606,
0.32344383,
0.5783547759,
-1.1242142916,
-0.495046705,
-0.1249366179,
-0.6912935972,
-0.1349996626,
0.2280505449,
0.6890377402,
0.1434525847,
0.4329248369,
-0.6187984943,
0.5606110692,
0.3695813417,
-0.3234265447,
0.5876178741,
0.0170613937,
0.6313183904,
-1.1315248013,
0.0489833727,
0.0810989812,
-0.3199004531,
-0.5108342767,
-0.5310264826,
-0.2162927091,
0.0266512465,
-0.1445284635,
0.7208627462,
-0.0612410568,
0.1288682669,
-0.0930980146,
0.2201113254,
0.257698983,
0.4761638045,
-0.1711596698,
0.6582035422,
0.2243396044,
-0.2479295731,
0.5631093383,
0.5002990961,
-0.1773600131,
0.9173026085,
-0.5791101456,
0.298078537,
-0.1603646129,
0.3601447046,
-1.4918682575,
-0.2757485509,
-0.271649152,
-1.1307142973,
0.0783426538,
0.0870945603,
-0.5917367339,
-0.2839078009,
-0.7849321365,
-0.0390993319,
0.1564158499,
-0.6635527015,
0.8451046348,
0.2250448018,
-0.3425709903,
-0.3978627026,
-0.6932458878,
0.3506624401,
-0.2070526779,
-0.383376807,
0.4068413079,
-0.1933801919,
0.121301502,
-0.3085124791,
-0.0310464278,
0.0329463705,
-0.1066420004,
0.451990217,
0.0878676474,
0.0041914624,
0.0272737481,
-0.1995091438,
-0.2109782398,
0.000394819,
-0.1529311389,
0.5811362267,
-0.4773996472,
-0.1419084966,
-1.1055858135,
0.2221504003,
1.0406496525,
0.0339906365,
0.1077136099,
1.0385178328,
0.0002589015,
0.1308447868,
-0.7797193527,
-0.6366361976,
-0.503552556,
0.587634027,
-0.1122169569,
-0.4896689057,
0.2644643188,
0.1661363095,
-0.0104891919,
0.1775527894,
0.5033124089,
-0.3386537731,
1.5220221281,
1.0261952877,
-0.419716686,
0.6920965314,
-0.0565207452,
0.0820348263,
-0.4890404642,
-0.3646465242,
-0.8472366929,
-0.2399109751,
-0.6777552962,
0.0245734733,
0.4050982594,
-0.3787035346,
0.0475118309,
0.3391787708,
-0.7810395956,
0.2437812984,
0.4052813649,
0.0827085897,
0.7855047584,
0.4204339981,
-0.0273855124,
-0.2377396077,
-0.2461342514,
-0.6045963168,
1.1082736254,
0.3105767667,
0.6984251738,
0.0302391406,
0.5565507412,
0.8836193681,
0.4854510128,
-1.2372819185,
0.6060180664,
-0.4966760576,
-0.3662447035,
-0.2662786841,
-0.4415096045,
-1.0232867002,
-0.2671343982,
-0.3982179165,
-0.5857442021,
-0.1443267763,
0.1477611661,
0.0374944508,
0.356936276,
-0.6958437562,
0.570489645,
-0.0615948886,
0.0785421133,
0.0017363658,
-0.5811727643,
0.1183548942,
0.0656281412,
0.3936757147,
0.0884837434,
0.3113679588,
0.9362672567,
0.2084410638,
0.5618354082,
0.0512161851,
0.1025413051,
-0.1890573949,
-0.1086258888,
0.1547746211,
0.0091578681,
-0.205980137,
0.2447727472,
-0.0193229951,
-0.3321458995,
-0.6680505276,
0.5585565567,
-0.7115418315,
-0.091039829,
-0.229917258,
-0.6984875798,
-0.4008893967,
0.2224898934,
0.3142948151,
0.5428718328,
-0.2579765022,
0.4156146646,
0.506495595,
0.2334765792,
0.5648201108,
0.3796202242,
-0.122735776,
-0.4776591659,
1.057623744,
-0.4148789346,
-0.1072346494,
0.3701860905,
0.5465909243,
-0.5274857283,
-0.2161808759,
-0.3258384466,
0.1556335092,
-0.5321181417,
-0.0808113068,
-0.9124341607,
0.0560838245,
-0.6100085378,
-0.0165401679,
-0.5923543572,
-0.4269126058,
-0.1717042774,
0.1329792887,
0.5105237365,
0.7945464253,
0.0728182867,
0.3516336977,
-0.7473496795,
0.3944548666,
0.4730851948,
0.2223984748,
-0.0721580461,
-0.4464190304,
0.1497576088,
0.0032426266,
-0.5377168059,
-0.49934569,
0.588571012,
0.3444696367,
0.3829472661,
0.3900752068,
0.0541838221,
0.2389048785,
-0.0077473233,
0.8453713059,
0.4367396235,
-0.8563827872,
0.3727559149,
-0.4063748419,
0.3125933409,
0.6371766329,
0.3502825499,
-0.3378937542,
-0.4790019095,
-0.6302831173,
-0.8534124494,
0.3714572787,
0.4592151344,
0.2682479918,
0.1840492338,
0.1677608639,
0.1139880195,
0.5540924072,
-0.7897562981,
-0.3258824646,
-0.5800232887,
-0.6638285518,
-0.0679771081,
0.1602512747,
0.1021120548,
-0.269028455,
0.6347513795,
-0.3245705366,
0.5803511143,
0.0851871148,
0.1869318038,
0.0964114442,
0.6700528264,
0.3833874762,
-0.107639052,
-0.5654165149,
0.2020678669,
-0.2299975753,
-1.052018404,
-0.019126894,
0.363987565,
0.1433483362,
0.3127405643,
0.2924114168,
0.4629718661,
0.0603174195,
-0.4272055626,
0.7304512262,
-0.4909831882,
-0.041675929,
-0.0080824159,
-0.2790467739,
-0.0197558366,
0.1060175672,
0.7887364626,
0.3943590522,
0.2597518265,
-1.0314586163,
0.6642337441,
0.6581729054,
-1.0659290552,
-0.3955176771,
0.5754173994,
0.3751721382,
-0.5038030148,
0.1520550549,
-0.0830197036,
-0.9645491838,
0.4510776401,
0.1787716597,
0.8204464316,
-0.3398007751,
0.0940751433,
-0.3014300168,
0.049127996,
0.0998392403,
0.2308825999,
-0.3996055424,
-0.6564148664,
0.035315562,
-0.49069947,
-0.4629935324,
0.320555687,
-0.7081755996,
0.4804925025,
-0.1943697482,
-0.4814038873,
0.4717411697,
0.0356953219,
-0.5357592106,
0.140375644,
0.2063318938,
0.3330110013,
-0.9363816381,
0.5827515125,
0.7502756119,
-0.2667485178,
-0.6321005225,
0.4708912075,
0.1651146561,
-0.6690140367,
0.5424829721,
0.6012201905,
-0.5461558104,
0.1413487047,
-0.6883158088,
0.0810891092,
0.7801357508,
0.209320724,
-0.2534671426,
-0.0457567796,
-0.0502337813,
0.5391927361,
-0.2373030782,
0.7127476931,
0.5069718361,
0.5976810455,
0.0266904011,
-1.3802300692,
-0.3114606142,
-0.385176599,
-0.4061906934,
-0.1123839021,
-0.6646664143,
0.8923513293,
-0.0092531396,
-0.0855643898,
0.3623508215,
0.6665987968,
0.3175649941,
0.8386092782,
0.6478681564,
0.1004221067,
0.5131377578,
-0.1882669926,
0.7651543021,
-0.087705031,
0.4063647389,
0.7058018446,
-0.0963373631,
0.73437953,
0.441498965,
0.1609186232,
0.7010340095,
0.0015451994,
-0.0414168686,
0.4830312133,
-0.1285062134,
-0.2208211273,
-0.0829896629,
-0.5127143264,
-0.1343193352,
0.9220209718,
0.2092709392,
-0.2676437497,
-0.1882396042,
0.3385501504,
0.2394163013,
0.5469843745,
-0.2300114036,
0.8018926978,
0.0587521717,
-0.5246013999,
0.5054879189,
-0.0981140584,
1.4388715029,
-0.5076848269,
-0.0991045907,
-0.1712102741,
0.4701540768,
-0.4303671122,
-0.7669001818,
-0.0662183389,
-0.1039386392,
-0.4000377059,
-0.3565885723,
0.5157635808,
-0.4570487738,
-0.2079250813,
0.4296505153,
0.3649202585,
0.190662235,
-0.4054142833,
-0.7585816979,
0.0580415502,
-0.1599721014,
-0.2696256638,
0.164922297,
0.5926425457,
-0.0725397319,
0.6453263164,
0.7111270428,
0.0476071723,
-0.2822241783,
0.3609324098,
0.8280695677,
-0.6277528405,
-0.7726055384,
-0.7336555123,
0.1537432224,
-0.2760227919,
-0.1839970201,
0.9454375505,
0.4248373806,
0.3940508664,
-0.0354166962,
0.8202231526,
0.2649554908,
0.4474409521,
-0.3346770704,
1.0527079105,
-0.5590230227,
0.2829912305,
-0.7439696193,
-0.6855885983,
-0.318490684,
0.585318923,
-0.0820700601,
0.28876248,
0.6862291694,
0.8261971474,
-0.1559894979,
0.6098393798,
0.3077566326,
0.2137877643,
0.4889464974,
0.2659501433,
0.5849730968,
-0.7041471601,
0.85757792,
0.0754476339,
-0.4179204404,
-0.3736592531,
-0.9508748651,
-1.1150134802,
-0.7603253126,
-0.2266889066,
-0.4408414662,
-0.0713786632,
0.8394870758,
0.7701512575,
-0.8016248345,
-0.1559088975,
0.2547056675,
-0.0426815413,
-0.4134369791,
-0.3795856237,
0.3576013148,
0.05760777,
-0.8266949058,
0.5407643914,
0.3630551398,
-0.0949615911,
-0.3356342316,
0.23702766,
-0.3189643323,
0.1887030452,
0.5634886026,
0.054560855,
-0.546333015,
-0.1962015182,
0.0923857391,
-0.1580081731,
0.0596179217,
0.8652835488,
-0.9104868174,
0.4461297393,
0.4000741541,
0.3460899889,
0.4577040374,
0.161955893,
0.2943326533,
-1.0234797001,
0.1840262711,
0.3707424402,
0.0497767664,
0.8612810373,
-0.4969055653,
-0.0203806926,
0.5774387121,
-0.6097303033,
-0.8738360405,
-0.0275986753,
-1.2446534634,
0.0395501442,
0.8041242957,
0.3116062582,
-0.1951029003,
-0.6680040956,
-0.2968850732,
0.3953072429,
-0.8840039372,
1.2540572882,
0.3737976849,
-0.1972637773,
0.2517000139,
-0.4187853932,
0.5797432661,
0.6838704348,
-0.7344242334,
0.0896604732,
-0.0196672045,
0.3233925998,
0.5335350037,
0.5965990424,
-0.2568012774,
0.248077929,
-0.4512989521,
0.2980538011,
-0.3379757702,
-0.4066696167,
-0.2720007896,
0.2884423137,
-0.4285000861,
-0.1798354387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17663v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17663v1 | LLM-ARC: Enhancing LLMs with an Automated Reasoning Critic | 2024-06-25T15:52:15 | 2024-06-25T15:52:15 | Aditya Kalyanpur, Kailash Saravanakumar, Victor Barres, Jennifer Chu-Carroll, David Melville, David Ferrucci | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LO | We introduce LLM-ARC, a neuro-symbolic framework designed to enhance the
logical reasoning capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs), by combining
them with an Automated Reasoning Critic (ARC). LLM-ARC employs an Actor-Critic
method where the LLM Actor generates declarative logic programs along with
tests for semantic correctness, while the Automated Reasoning Critic evaluates
the code, runs the tests and provides feedback on test failures for iterative
refinement. Implemented using Answer Set Programming (ASP), LLM-ARC achieves a
new state-of-the-art accuracy of 88.32% on the FOLIO benchmark which tests
complex logical reasoning capabilities. Our experiments demonstrate significant
improvements over LLM-only baselines, highlighting the importance of logic test
generation and iterative self-refinement. We achieve our best result using a
fully automated self-supervised training loop where the Actor is trained on
end-to-end dialog traces with Critic feedback. We discuss potential
enhancements and provide a detailed error analysis, showcasing the robustness
and efficacy of LLM-ARC for complex natural language reasoning tasks. | [
-0.4803277254,
-0.88231951,
0.5776572227,
0.1145656779,
0.1543267965,
0.3907261193,
-0.4034426808,
-0.4736178815,
0.2708366215,
0.6974871755,
-0.6081261635,
-0.4412282407,
-0.3761365712,
0.4384031296,
-0.4177357256,
0.6716237068,
-0.1323830634,
0.2219110727,
-0.3848057091,
-0.1288308352,
-0.1664912999,
-0.5046342015,
-0.8337164521,
-0.6112731695,
0.4212535322,
0.4024268985,
0.4316060245,
0.3803522587,
0.6640509367,
0.3907143772,
0.2194113135,
0.4027584791,
-0.0501250923,
0.2841225564,
-0.4921105802,
-0.4694718719,
-0.6116988063,
-0.2010487765,
0.4200779796,
0.5853637457,
-0.1747198403,
0.0412365235,
-0.2597890496,
0.716353476,
-0.6626260281,
0.3594255149,
-0.5647987127,
-0.0343702063,
0.3408894539,
-0.1827156246,
-0.5399218798,
-0.4023971856,
-0.0452991612,
-0.7136300802,
-0.2344663292,
0.3483398557,
0.6784597039,
0.8515495062,
-0.4553152323,
-0.2099842876,
-0.7394735217,
0.5917522311,
-0.812720418,
0.048102282,
0.2611164153,
0.498439163,
-0.1786266714,
-0.7207885981,
-0.821516633,
-0.7188233733,
0.0077215889,
0.0609195419,
-0.515676856,
0.5154970288,
0.4704641104,
0.3071297705,
-0.2556322813,
0.2320128083,
0.0313752219,
-0.2711289823,
0.8168806434,
0.2898797691,
0.2583273053,
-0.0557599701,
-0.1761507243,
0.0291992575,
-0.58313483,
-0.1175789237,
0.395911783,
-0.1237507612,
0.4148761332,
0.7716017365,
-0.4860075116,
0.5713424087,
-0.01961869,
0.1164436787,
0.1577747613,
-0.1447888166,
-0.1644438803,
0.1836146265,
0.8144137263,
0.3747160137,
0.7721120715,
0.1470932811,
-0.4289439619,
0.4876110256,
0.3760933578,
-0.573376894,
-0.330611676,
0.117896013,
-0.0055338969,
-0.429176271,
-0.0964908227,
-0.3415762186,
-0.5954040289,
-0.7433091998,
0.3477585316,
-0.5830326676,
-0.2340393066,
0.3886985183,
0.0345967263,
0.3180441558,
0.6092133522,
-0.6181624532,
0.6085426211,
0.7103042006,
0.1719907373,
-0.2479857802,
-0.4068320394,
-0.5919221044,
0.067465052,
-0.4457787871,
1.2606717348,
-0.6452912688,
0.2427796572,
-0.2115661502,
-0.2602717578,
-0.0432837978,
-0.7135270834,
0.5334887505,
-0.3244069219,
0.0374631658,
-0.0839691833,
-0.6984319687,
-0.4031042159,
0.7485434413,
-0.5516289473,
1.1121319532,
0.0468502045,
-0.5330859423,
0.0596378595,
-0.7420041561,
-0.4456491172,
-0.1673291475,
-0.3508622944,
-0.0761801004,
0.0347043313,
0.5620089769,
0.2061431706,
-0.5082269311,
0.2617644966,
-0.430775106,
-0.3465062678,
0.309478581,
-0.3746177256,
0.4945095479,
-0.0367808826,
-0.4840370715,
0.5312947035,
-0.7910090685,
0.1588378847,
0.020917302,
-0.0848158374,
0.1315438002,
0.1351630092,
-0.3836186826,
0.1755060852,
-0.0115469135,
-0.4258903563,
0.2299735099,
-0.6516035199,
0.3707039356,
0.9152101874,
0.0790341049,
0.3880355656,
-0.4037328064,
0.6508692503,
-0.1114783287,
-0.0126259783,
-0.135395959,
-0.1909410805,
-1.307215929,
-0.2408361435,
0.1505008042,
0.7657062411,
-0.8941223025,
0.773716867,
0.0057095024,
-0.3200881481,
-0.4887865782,
0.1738164425,
0.2200694084,
0.6652613878,
0.3196158409,
-0.2932110429,
-0.6669524312,
-0.886944294,
-0.2337820083,
-0.6632373929,
0.1273753643,
0.182062313,
0.5591928363,
-0.4654091895,
0.988396883,
-0.329883188,
-0.2220695019,
-0.5637791157,
-0.0968022346,
0.0067835813,
0.2488433272,
0.0839964077,
-0.0750429109,
-0.2454689145,
-0.0076175118,
-0.9486731291,
-0.4374066591,
-0.1287498921,
-0.0049632648,
0.5377241969,
0.5938248634,
-0.6240186095,
0.3966272771,
0.23254852,
-0.4731322229,
0.9892741442,
-0.1552008688,
0.076306574,
-0.8123238087,
-0.0856710747,
-0.0630478114,
-0.2597215772,
-0.3771719337,
0.062334422,
-0.2588202357,
0.0643621162,
-0.2621433437,
0.5885623693,
-0.3007781506,
-0.1828823984,
-0.449282825,
0.3673671186,
0.0894869938,
0.6727180481,
0.0293894317,
0.546484828,
0.7565941811,
-0.4922780991,
0.9181167483,
-0.0181291606,
-0.3320518732,
0.7511646152,
-0.6051786542,
0.1386515796,
-0.1414667517,
0.4497379363,
-0.7045297623,
-0.1392531544,
0.3501922488,
-0.3123608232,
0.0471338443,
0.2846314609,
-0.6955624223,
-0.3978863358,
-0.2652449608,
0.028975917,
0.2957397401,
-0.5054811239,
1.0493550301,
0.1581987739,
-0.0030418504,
-0.6591945291,
-0.5278064609,
0.2630420029,
0.0226375498,
-0.7435472608,
-0.071736373,
-0.1699557453,
-0.7845326662,
-0.0969882756,
-0.2357687354,
0.0574162006,
0.1396469027,
0.1139187217,
0.2135489434,
-0.3367291689,
0.2879955173,
0.0077764825,
-0.3974421024,
0.4582366347,
-0.291413337,
0.4859641492,
-0.6631112695,
-0.7642916441,
-0.6450728178,
0.1380887181,
0.3543736041,
-0.3293407559,
0.1325853616,
0.3880437315,
-0.3151431084,
-0.5725831389,
-0.7943513989,
-0.476780951,
-0.4660879672,
0.3126712441,
-0.2948960662,
-0.840128541,
0.4678999186,
-0.2260655463,
-0.0800370499,
0.4919194579,
0.4897277057,
-0.2348282635,
1.0022701025,
0.3655747771,
-0.1260850281,
0.2410900146,
-0.3547394872,
0.1641263962,
-0.7780485153,
-0.1743304282,
-0.3226022124,
-0.3069109023,
-0.1805617362,
-0.3825707734,
0.0344592966,
0.0158347115,
-0.5857453942,
0.1859832704,
-0.4828723967,
0.6728227735,
0.3842720389,
-0.0813881382,
0.6676901579,
-0.2083836049,
-0.2281134129,
0.0679855347,
-0.558714807,
-0.6109226346,
0.8767255545,
0.4318076074,
1.05294168,
0.0059924047,
0.4338969588,
0.2660642862,
0.4657273889,
-0.9965925217,
0.8895251155,
0.2498452514,
-0.4050327539,
-0.1621632427,
-0.4234683514,
-0.367623955,
0.2101858109,
-0.2081899345,
-0.6349982619,
-0.1498706639,
0.247614488,
-0.2930055559,
0.3112620115,
-0.67815274,
0.7349070311,
-0.4846123159,
-0.05004289,
-0.475165993,
-0.5233533382,
0.3019824028,
0.1582668871,
-0.2408844978,
-0.3172982335,
-0.1581162065,
0.3809576929,
-0.421048373,
0.8623762131,
0.0902658701,
-0.0280944388,
0.4286954105,
0.294708252,
0.6093404293,
0.2277558744,
-0.1235164702,
-0.0790431499,
-0.271664232,
-0.0474954434,
-1.0649241209,
0.5442290902,
-0.6608198285,
-0.9052196741,
-0.633315146,
-0.6184095144,
-0.3531863689,
0.0736123398,
-0.2161350846,
0.4540414512,
-0.0166345593,
0.0355197862,
0.7645683885,
-0.2329060882,
0.3496399522,
0.5414121151,
-0.3599946797,
-0.5686361194,
0.6122339964,
-0.3494268954,
0.3837215006,
0.3275776505,
0.1729640067,
-0.287897408,
-0.4038175642,
-0.3644511104,
0.2973132432,
-0.9740588665,
-0.2748075426,
-0.6614586115,
-0.4354636073,
-0.2225669175,
-0.0679963827,
-0.4158563018,
-0.675450325,
-0.1191683635,
-0.3098600805,
0.3969659209,
0.7098374963,
0.1373639703,
0.1619781554,
-0.2277333587,
0.2337311655,
0.2834011614,
0.2863239944,
-0.1586074382,
-0.5016158819,
0.112502344,
-0.2777090967,
-0.3505384922,
-0.5490415692,
0.1951724738,
0.2696867883,
0.5583543181,
0.3864512444,
0.2088885158,
0.5260915756,
-0.4116355777,
0.537886858,
0.1377429664,
-0.9500457644,
0.6921620369,
-0.2046137452,
0.4055460095,
0.7260119319,
-0.0848997757,
-0.3666681945,
-0.7451631427,
-0.5624219179,
-0.5325782299,
0.5560539961,
0.1002519727,
-0.0666852295,
0.0001513968,
0.2497603446,
-0.172219798,
0.0675601661,
-0.8052194118,
-0.0745309591,
-0.0417612828,
-0.3112827539,
0.0215928741,
0.0060972795,
-0.2317965478,
-0.508902669,
0.7861266136,
-0.6511657834,
0.1139592752,
0.3546587229,
-0.259642005,
0.0130348979,
0.1683811992,
0.4796839952,
0.6857306957,
-0.0007070788,
0.309830755,
0.5476683974,
-0.1334457397,
0.109574616,
0.1276846081,
0.1035483032,
-0.1607939303,
0.5322084427,
0.8011369705,
0.0154081015,
-1.0430445671,
0.4057480097,
-0.1771300882,
-0.3092440367,
-0.6990244985,
0.3528706133,
0.0287971031,
0.440617919,
0.1066227779,
0.2024301291,
0.0245376285,
-0.4871420264,
0.4670141637,
0.3135209084,
-0.3739987612,
-0.032479737,
0.4700948596,
0.2628951073,
-0.3376081884,
0.8287861943,
-0.1237975657,
-0.6736130118,
0.7188075781,
0.575221777,
1.0417745113,
0.0021955436,
0.1704826802,
0.2877390385,
0.494815141,
-0.0567753203,
0.2332462817,
-0.1535888463,
-0.8929945827,
-0.8148497343,
-0.4480000734,
-0.7229412198,
-0.3722648919,
-0.287895292,
0.3801208436,
-0.716745615,
-0.0052328985,
-0.2402517796,
0.1357204467,
-0.2041986883,
0.1102614179,
0.1666807383,
1.1770926714,
-0.4482574165,
0.9311470389,
0.6447255015,
-0.4424661398,
-0.9595316648,
-0.0851752758,
-0.0079960106,
-0.7181651592,
0.6359120011,
0.3779051006,
-0.4117959738,
0.0156687852,
-0.46965608,
-0.7095071673,
1.0630328655,
0.7142222524,
-0.4697870314,
0.0787663534,
0.0952087194,
0.8072734475,
-0.6133255959,
0.6344129443,
0.7702921629,
0.4955492616,
0.2544873059,
-0.6931941509,
0.0533117615,
-0.4214327335,
-0.1799323559,
0.0916633308,
-0.4140140116,
0.3292814493,
-0.4219608903,
0.0956043229,
-0.0602764748,
0.8563030362,
0.5705039501,
0.2190365195,
0.6624956727,
0.8846195936,
0.7462486625,
-0.2634408474,
1.2316519022,
-0.4005278647,
0.0772026181,
1.2085297108,
-0.5026382208,
0.7545983195,
0.5114488602,
0.1809057593,
0.8917011619,
0.4525217414,
-0.0099550989,
-0.0119964276,
0.5618340373,
-0.4281240702,
-0.4848620594,
-0.1995656937,
0.035866797,
0.3168738484,
0.2918882072,
-0.2004259825,
-0.1101454943,
-0.17827788,
-0.0249113124,
0.3368074894,
-0.3370838761,
0.8452519178,
0.3384599686,
-0.92110008,
0.4065228105,
-0.1357062906,
0.5286971927,
-0.5306305885,
0.0084070796,
-0.2801414132,
0.5206068754,
-0.3888880908,
-0.7926441431,
0.5688422918,
0.0618793368,
0.1453026384,
-0.2460630089,
0.8386682868,
-0.1384057999,
-0.6122600436,
0.4716769159,
0.3545886278,
-0.001104338,
-0.1820406914,
-0.8146279454,
-0.0160033833,
-0.1619462222,
-0.3428759873,
-0.1107515022,
0.3834755421,
-0.0920638293,
1.1949936152,
0.533325851,
0.0999946967,
-0.1923900992,
0.5474197865,
0.9524925351,
-0.7754493952,
-0.1372961104,
-0.9548503757,
0.4773763716,
-0.2608273327,
-0.2537378669,
0.5685452223,
0.3600838184,
0.848406136,
0.2169853002,
0.5500470996,
-0.0390622057,
0.2011940032,
-0.4492790699,
0.6036204696,
-0.3376803994,
0.534240067,
-0.0815480202,
-0.9745195508,
-0.5111593604,
0.7267963886,
-0.4095169008,
-0.061463248,
1.1187154055,
1.0459148884,
0.2379990369,
0.0546578243,
0.1564229727,
0.1470414549,
0.3567122221,
0.6978706717,
1.234057188,
-0.1933829486,
0.554484129,
-0.2384340912,
-0.1354008317,
0.2052562386,
-0.7734850049,
-1.1814268827,
-0.1400151402,
-0.5178400278,
-0.4107522666,
-0.0373459421,
1.1431158781,
0.473767519,
-0.8266856074,
-0.4274306893,
-0.360252887,
0.2687760592,
-0.2698289454,
-0.2341881543,
0.0080277892,
-0.7088211179,
-0.5046652555,
0.4966848195,
0.5742480755,
-0.4493673742,
-0.6218649149,
-0.3187019825,
-0.1302808076,
0.3281570673,
0.5764226317,
0.1223163456,
-0.8708425164,
-0.4652769864,
0.1425623745,
-0.1582691222,
0.1417101622,
0.6482027769,
-0.8915902972,
0.4801115692,
0.4516001046,
0.9114589095,
0.3015145659,
-0.0769613907,
0.9184654355,
-0.4006836414,
-0.031144591,
0.6301141381,
0.5081218481,
0.2700986564,
-0.1027472466,
0.7628433108,
0.3098632991,
-0.5232489109,
-0.8328814507,
0.4842219651,
-1.0912822485,
-0.0879077092,
1.292006731,
0.126154229,
-0.3064779341,
0.0853314474,
-0.3842123151,
-0.0479612537,
-0.3328691423,
0.6885544062,
0.6495957971,
-0.4580774307,
-0.4802715778,
-0.3011014163,
0.4017603397,
0.6344681382,
-1.3548123837,
-0.059087012,
0.5558274388,
0.2302069664,
0.1164160818,
0.4704422355,
-0.0246847589,
0.3438944221,
-0.1566167623,
0.387067467,
-0.1731432527,
-0.3868983388,
-0.4886555374,
-0.0220314488,
0.2613842785,
0.3198096454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17650v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17650v1 | ELIZA Reinterpreted: The world's first chatbot was not intended as a chatbot at all | 2024-06-25T15:41:40 | 2024-06-25T15:41:40 | Jeff Shrager | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC | ELIZA, often considered the world's first chatbot, was written by Joseph
Weizenbaum in the early 1960s. Weizenbaum did not intend to invent the chatbot,
but rather to build a platform for research into human-machine conversation and
the important cognitive processes of interpretation and misinterpretation. His
purpose was obscured by ELIZA's fame, resulting in large part from the
fortuitous timing of it's creation, and it's escape into the wild. In this
paper I provide a rich historical context for ELIZA's creation, demonstrating
that ELIZA arose from the intersection of some of the central threads in the
technical history of AI. I also briefly discuss how ELIZA escaped into the
world, and how its accidental escape, along with several coincidental turns of
the programming language screws, led both to the misapprehension that ELIZA was
intended as a chatbot, and to the loss of the original ELIZA to history for
over 50 years. | [
-0.1384730935,
-1.1764655113,
0.6153231859,
-0.1046566889,
-0.1189256087,
-0.1076654345,
0.197076723,
-0.3208884299,
0.5322879553,
0.3300572336,
-0.8169142008,
0.0090852147,
-0.6370604634,
-0.1765272468,
-0.8593026996,
1.1235685349,
0.2806037962,
-0.7008262873,
-0.0464738235,
0.1545618474,
-0.1721276939,
-0.5507793427,
-0.4261333942,
-0.2228044719,
0.3715824485,
0.3222281039,
0.7224192619,
0.4915737212,
0.5587278605,
0.26826334,
0.0250447169,
0.1923961341,
-0.6562411785,
-0.2485224456,
0.2457625568,
-0.7683746815,
-0.0480903462,
0.2171297967,
0.390189141,
0.6418339014,
0.0014711841,
0.1267456859,
0.1068651676,
0.6978734732,
-0.3363378048,
0.1603617668,
-0.5884792805,
0.156810686,
-0.2701275349,
-0.1860724837,
-0.6108533144,
-0.2043997496,
-0.0758942291,
-0.749352932,
0.0914377272,
0.2964233458,
1.0636180639,
0.3564611673,
-0.1935643703,
-0.2069019973,
-1.1730635166,
0.8352290392,
-0.2346539348,
-0.2259629071,
-0.0758608282,
0.378749758,
-0.5854133368,
-0.9892944694,
-0.8201941848,
-0.2889057398,
0.0245715957,
-0.0782909766,
-0.8393935561,
-0.2869512141,
0.2119107246,
-0.0579056665,
-0.4321060777,
-0.1371418387,
-0.6269942522,
-0.3180860877,
0.4992338717,
0.3091112971,
0.5030446649,
-0.2814680636,
-0.4342736602,
0.2780655921,
-0.4994825721,
0.0643591806,
0.2792069316,
0.3075894415,
-0.1227831915,
0.5620293021,
-0.0607638694,
0.1152613685,
-0.1208157092,
0.093928583,
-0.0612709634,
0.0550496802,
-0.0475341566,
-0.2093302757,
0.9107916355,
0.3637453914,
0.6061734557,
-0.4073376656,
0.3847053945,
0.1772813499,
0.6696486473,
-0.2666418254,
-0.2595977783,
0.2809483707,
-0.6009599566,
-0.3850224018,
0.3299022913,
-0.2101674527,
-0.192758128,
-0.0123930881,
0.1995780915,
-0.4071782529,
-0.2386191487,
-0.3298389912,
-0.4610901475,
0.2858959138,
0.2737095058,
-0.6639086604,
0.2092580646,
1.1927545071,
0.7840904593,
0.1306244284,
-0.5250395536,
-0.0422918648,
-0.1812407225,
-0.5161153674,
0.4648399055,
-0.219319582,
-0.2363600135,
-0.0865933076,
0.3114972413,
0.5945358872,
-0.0955836698,
0.3171353042,
-0.5052940249,
0.2275787741,
0.2535993755,
-0.4453011453,
-0.3021878004,
-0.0634349734,
-0.2400625944,
0.6510924697,
-0.1775945425,
-0.6698100567,
0.4218149185,
-0.6576191783,
-0.6608503461,
0.1588640958,
-0.0326163657,
-0.1804599911,
0.2901612818,
-0.0536606796,
-0.0662952885,
-0.0875675008,
0.5108606815,
-0.3858424723,
-0.6554128528,
0.2916128933,
-0.4877935946,
1.2285541296,
-0.1646748781,
-0.3819137514,
-0.5681151152,
-0.4797154963,
0.150638476,
0.4457568228,
0.144484058,
-0.3927675486,
0.1475214213,
-0.1258325875,
-0.0563494265,
0.3292139471,
-0.819852829,
0.0869684443,
-0.5212593675,
0.7278465629,
0.5863122344,
-0.1663869172,
0.3713307977,
-0.8642886281,
0.4078620076,
-0.3768378794,
0.5514104366,
-0.5094556808,
-0.836019814,
-0.7645559311,
0.0480300896,
0.077083379,
0.5596430898,
-0.1786273867,
0.3368855417,
-0.234058857,
-0.8181992769,
-0.7235430479,
-0.180364415,
-0.039406199,
0.0234291684,
0.1565619856,
-0.0571378767,
-0.6752099395,
-0.9652593136,
-0.397580713,
-0.7267938852,
-0.0835137889,
0.3892872334,
0.417887032,
-0.2028325349,
1.1281926632,
-0.5587235689,
-0.0125131765,
-0.160191834,
-0.036027696,
0.3780765831,
0.6271045208,
0.6325792074,
-0.4721955061,
-0.2815206945,
-0.2300070673,
-0.6666501164,
-0.0108834915,
-0.4707370698,
-0.6171212196,
-0.1307104975,
0.2940093577,
-1.1093822718,
0.8579684496,
0.3354869485,
0.3485256433,
0.5189567208,
-0.2150657624,
-0.0097552789,
-1.0111789703,
0.3879692852,
-0.7525281906,
0.1663192362,
-0.4735233188,
-0.0556276776,
-0.0763838515,
-0.2904408574,
-0.5155562162,
0.676676631,
-0.2878666222,
0.1066708639,
-0.4632804096,
0.4828911424,
0.1051307023,
0.4922002852,
-0.4486983716,
0.2204586416,
0.6337894797,
-0.5554401875,
0.437273562,
0.7151780725,
0.2936474979,
0.4123978615,
-0.5221642256,
0.5653902292,
-0.4492555857,
0.0412388034,
-1.3145234585,
-0.0633808598,
0.4698214829,
-0.8667458296,
-0.0335849524,
-0.2356911451,
-0.1654281616,
-0.5602621436,
0.0761673227,
0.0610656552,
0.685705781,
-0.4791409969,
0.5515072346,
0.6096719503,
-0.3317311704,
-0.2838748991,
-0.9504750371,
0.3522747159,
-0.1648920774,
-0.7165952921,
0.2026382238,
-0.187589854,
-0.5277069807,
-0.3719521463,
-0.0317048244,
-0.1884918511,
0.2482619435,
0.6649516225,
0.4278095663,
-0.184157908,
0.2421765029,
0.0473318771,
-0.2880041897,
0.3016172945,
0.1371104866,
0.3966552317,
0.3421511352,
-0.4831391871,
-0.9419258237,
0.5475206375,
0.5588787198,
0.3645652235,
0.7693845034,
-0.0537514724,
-0.2026645243,
-0.1402235925,
-0.3260601759,
-0.1907540709,
-0.4615029097,
0.1347550452,
0.0425669253,
-0.5805891752,
0.3075156808,
-0.0732687861,
0.5776808262,
0.5154607296,
-0.0227735545,
-0.5283775926,
0.5719892979,
0.7416016459,
-0.2624988258,
0.7691851258,
0.1358375847,
0.430624783,
-0.5827757716,
-0.1444941461,
-0.5530722141,
-0.5908358693,
-0.7957998514,
0.1131145731,
0.3171801865,
-0.5139790177,
-0.4879954457,
0.2157908231,
-0.4355551898,
0.3010409176,
0.8399793506,
0.1999299675,
0.2436561435,
-0.1836180091,
0.4799530506,
-0.1602859795,
-0.713937819,
-0.6902376413,
1.3070352077,
0.0395445861,
0.6710102558,
0.1376330405,
0.8031625748,
0.5012469888,
0.2619309723,
-0.3725061715,
0.5610384345,
-0.0397768542,
-0.7781101465,
-0.1992443502,
-0.0915891752,
-1.5800250769,
-0.0217225961,
0.0458653197,
-0.8567311168,
-0.5016631484,
0.1313801706,
-0.6738615036,
-0.0210589077,
-0.8192731142,
0.7413617373,
-0.3565022349,
0.0021432799,
-0.0452617221,
-0.9139494896,
0.5889415145,
0.2886055708,
0.3438478708,
-0.0849572271,
0.2810231745,
0.5323325396,
-0.4294198453,
0.9312646389,
0.0954378173,
0.5570318103,
0.7507010102,
0.4227654338,
0.3923707604,
-0.1245841831,
0.4456783235,
0.2752366662,
0.1104554981,
-0.4768484235,
-0.4456786811,
0.4339540303,
-0.8363901973,
-0.8555486798,
0.0301332604,
-0.3639375865,
0.41591838,
0.2920754254,
-0.1538761258,
0.3733218014,
-0.5540340543,
0.1238277331,
-0.0213938616,
-0.2147251517,
0.4937790334,
0.2905086875,
-0.4108290672,
0.179456681,
0.3177972138,
-0.1939564794,
0.0992785469,
0.5779881477,
0.2241704464,
0.111506708,
0.0046073711,
-0.2363435775,
0.2150007486,
-0.6290207505,
0.2299267501,
-0.6399576068,
-0.3052139878,
-0.3607473373,
-0.176331535,
-0.3877768517,
-0.3749894202,
-0.5208588839,
0.0496096127,
0.2996665239,
0.6107955575,
0.0968637541,
0.5312785506,
-1.0186611414,
0.1058561206,
0.0936510935,
-0.169514969,
-0.1061721519,
-0.5807111859,
0.0456503592,
0.1936846524,
-0.4079246223,
-0.9243528247,
0.204978317,
0.1932061315,
0.716950655,
0.3992109299,
0.1043297052,
0.4758992493,
-0.3521071374,
0.8576902151,
-0.0955214947,
-0.6354294419,
0.5537348986,
-0.1046958938,
0.4166031182,
-0.0393808484,
-0.058473248,
-0.6806124449,
-0.4898122251,
-0.9558130503,
-0.8610557914,
0.6822605729,
0.3062430322,
0.6951978803,
0.1908312589,
0.480886668,
0.6901838779,
0.206182465,
-0.8848573565,
-0.4490913153,
-0.0415316224,
-0.0381332114,
0.1930781156,
0.1925192326,
-0.1039777249,
-0.0792963877,
0.333293885,
-0.1008421034,
0.5257382989,
-0.1199457571,
-0.2952053249,
-0.1798633933,
0.0431205481,
0.1445947587,
0.5268782377,
0.4259904027,
-0.012302652,
-0.2051485032,
-0.1292140186,
-0.1734534949,
0.1860524267,
-0.4597097933,
0.179130435,
0.5468342304,
0.7235120535,
0.3277991414,
-0.9306201339,
0.3983131051,
0.1591428816,
0.1552914828,
-0.7154728174,
0.3312499523,
-0.0183084738,
0.5712547302,
0.429676801,
0.0146088619,
-0.1188668981,
-0.8183432817,
0.2812672555,
0.6390539408,
0.0032139919,
-0.3448800445,
0.9611610174,
-0.0360727981,
-0.6695918441,
0.9297862649,
0.1809355617,
-0.2722029984,
0.6716087461,
0.3144671023,
0.9936167002,
0.0883313566,
0.3870569766,
0.453186959,
0.7165132165,
0.4315915108,
0.3277851939,
-0.1725856811,
-0.6748023629,
0.218898356,
-0.1737397909,
-0.2705189884,
-0.338825196,
-0.3127190173,
0.1860506237,
-0.4472397864,
-0.3978769183,
0.293469131,
-0.329539448,
-0.7807533145,
-0.1466520876,
0.090941146,
0.876111269,
-0.6824090481,
0.1096105799,
0.2994464636,
-0.2448838055,
-0.294863075,
0.2048753053,
0.1196525022,
-1.1121087074,
0.2899574041,
0.0591249503,
0.2114490271,
0.0998823568,
-0.9995122552,
-0.9994939566,
0.7492513657,
0.1012431383,
-0.4684635997,
-0.1558337212,
0.1565429568,
0.5545895696,
-0.1831140667,
0.2443685085,
0.3337653875,
0.3816460967,
0.025362337,
-0.9213472605,
-0.1951165795,
-0.2466457188,
-0.0530033447,
0.292183876,
-0.8247328997,
0.9576289654,
-0.6541523933,
-0.4006362855,
0.5617790818,
0.4877983332,
-0.2507750094,
0.337317884,
-0.0237423107,
0.0175655596,
0.5359190106,
-0.3579100072,
0.9365931153,
-0.1734422594,
0.1144565046,
0.5745767951,
-0.230017066,
0.491560787,
0.5480650067,
-0.544885695,
0.363948077,
0.5131673217,
0.1457547694,
0.597427845,
-0.131182611,
0.2229202092,
-0.0635769367,
0.2486226261,
0.0121546285,
0.6622574329,
0.2108685672,
-0.2537830472,
-0.0672360435,
-0.1617986858,
0.2682205141,
-0.2348733842,
0.1344115138,
0.8300853968,
0.0927072838,
-0.9470613003,
-0.0021276216,
-0.2902324796,
0.0664566904,
-0.5450507402,
-0.0426299796,
-0.3750371039,
0.0033416492,
0.2123104185,
-0.7044079304,
0.3057304621,
-0.1106211022,
0.1834746003,
-0.0525940359,
0.463373065,
0.0456060767,
-0.3976612389,
-0.1120818853,
0.7068417668,
0.5582976937,
0.013685138,
-0.5293933153,
0.1553684473,
-0.0039210869,
-0.2529407442,
-0.1076908335,
0.7404219508,
0.1694767177,
0.6384236217,
0.6995200515,
-0.4451247752,
0.0702263415,
-0.5199107528,
0.7443240285,
-0.9893962145,
-0.861225307,
-1.0846942663,
0.5940571427,
0.216946885,
-0.403157562,
0.5746881962,
0.3582223654,
0.3647243083,
0.2854566574,
1.126324892,
-0.5242025852,
0.4824296534,
-0.276173383,
0.533860445,
-0.7311410904,
-0.1811231971,
-0.4458689094,
-0.5100739002,
-0.0903018415,
0.3763167262,
0.0405742042,
0.3211725056,
0.6564894915,
0.6097155213,
0.4763691425,
0.3838478923,
0.3607097864,
0.4005014896,
0.1976060122,
0.3711212575,
1.0297163725,
-0.3365117013,
0.9078602791,
0.165475145,
-0.3128051758,
-0.7522351146,
-0.5110351443,
-0.5760454535,
-0.6771755815,
-0.1924178004,
-0.2551703453,
0.2289940417,
0.8170362711,
0.6266953349,
-0.3102087677,
0.2344604582,
0.1136360541,
0.1791974306,
-0.5074455738,
-0.2344414294,
0.0727457702,
0.0205827039,
-0.8459103107,
0.3427270353,
0.3411459327,
0.1110851392,
-0.5144245625,
0.1859571487,
0.148934409,
0.0950444788,
0.1347640306,
0.5173358917,
-0.873534441,
-0.6055178046,
0.2017278224,
-0.0858756229,
0.4316675067,
0.5291879177,
-0.5846729279,
0.4607190192,
0.2320712954,
0.3984505236,
0.2764855027,
-0.0532604679,
0.5526143312,
-0.5544294715,
0.4615383744,
0.30154109,
0.3004493713,
0.1513006985,
-0.4526355565,
0.2088165581,
0.4862079322,
-0.5277687907,
-0.60829252,
0.1688367873,
-0.7146363854,
-0.4037276804,
0.6457838416,
-0.0447618887,
-0.3098939359,
-0.2254750878,
-0.5377739668,
0.36647892,
-0.3518102169,
1.471568346,
0.9310463071,
-0.5485423803,
-0.1204678789,
-0.6833572984,
-0.0685025156,
0.132833302,
-0.6623488665,
0.0275216009,
0.5564189553,
0.0287741516,
0.2478425801,
0.7481203079,
0.2171751559,
0.4160323143,
0.6289535165,
0.3262418807,
0.2259296328,
-0.374901861,
0.3511178792,
0.2426734716,
-0.013860574,
-0.5945065618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17647v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17647v1 | Variationist: Exploring Multifaceted Variation and Bias in Written Language Data | 2024-06-25T15:41:07 | 2024-06-25T15:41:07 | Alan Ramponi, Camilla Casula, Stefano Menini | cs.CL | cs.CL | Exploring and understanding language data is a fundamental stage in all areas
dealing with human language. It allows NLP practitioners to uncover quality
concerns and harmful biases in data before training, and helps linguists and
social scientists to gain insight into language use and human behavior. Yet,
there is currently a lack of a unified, customizable tool to seamlessly inspect
and visualize language variation and bias across multiple variables, language
units, and diverse metrics that go beyond descriptive statistics. In this
paper, we introduce Variationist, a highly-modular, extensible, and
task-agnostic tool that fills this gap. Variationist handles at once a
potentially unlimited combination of variable types and semantics across
diversity and association metrics with regards to the language unit of choice,
and orchestrates the creation of up to five-dimensional interactive charts for
over 30 variable type-semantics combinations. Through our case studies on
computational dialectology, human label variation, and text generation, we show
how Variationist enables researchers from different disciplines to effortlessly
answer specific research questions or unveil undesired associations in language
data. A Python library, code, documentation, and tutorials are made publicly
available to the research community. | [
-0.5805137753,
-0.661773026,
0.3192668557,
0.4639136195,
0.1090514585,
0.4725993276,
-0.3515538573,
-0.2234890461,
0.4992451966,
0.5896214843,
-0.6301583052,
-0.5375632048,
-0.3799675405,
-0.0651166737,
-0.2120394707,
0.9726879597,
-0.1367104352,
0.0114251589,
-0.1517596394,
-0.3891042173,
-0.2224277556,
-0.481490612,
-0.1068611592,
-0.4875144362,
0.7222079039,
0.3742384017,
0.65251261,
0.3167563975,
0.3313239217,
0.2807081044,
-0.0048054974,
-0.0278981049,
-0.2834014893,
0.3384009302,
-0.2114882022,
-0.8782922029,
-0.1124900952,
-0.0494399369,
0.6059023142,
1.0960298777,
-0.0944055021,
0.0238051843,
-0.1481816918,
0.690310359,
-0.6610981226,
0.0964283198,
-0.3485887051,
0.0969753936,
-0.510545969,
-0.0253298599,
-0.0884524509,
-0.2448073924,
0.228419587,
-0.5144305825,
0.5537432432,
-0.2332931906,
0.5175223947,
0.2608728409,
-0.6426092386,
-0.1713449955,
-0.6756433845,
0.8356983662,
-0.6036322117,
0.4719205201,
0.2699435651,
0.3365855515,
-0.0770454258,
-0.5240642428,
-0.5129289031,
-0.276445508,
-0.0650894344,
-0.0399996452,
0.0794032589,
0.0028757376,
0.1691996008,
0.8466769457,
-0.6216439009,
0.1942438483,
0.115450047,
-0.1549884528,
0.4622506797,
0.3421950936,
0.5608276129,
-0.1501597017,
0.3199625015,
-0.195888266,
-0.3235542476,
0.0419328883,
0.8574734926,
0.3627091646,
-0.1937864721,
0.5634279847,
-0.2680548429,
0.7299949527,
-0.3713044822,
0.2814883292,
0.5368350148,
-0.081936866,
0.0091282008,
-0.7426927686,
0.8849585652,
-0.0450294055,
-0.3690542877,
-0.1740932763,
-0.0612113662,
-0.0890774801,
0.0954551101,
-0.3691622913,
-0.4450057745,
0.261080116,
-0.1716386974,
-0.245485574,
0.0578164198,
-1.1041717529,
-0.7594023943,
-0.3753368258,
-0.2135791928,
-0.5089554191,
-0.46813941,
0.3580500484,
-0.3980528414,
0.0491314568,
0.3500750661,
-1.0988932848,
0.2384337783,
0.5908761024,
0.6009204388,
-0.5176833272,
-0.4918499589,
-0.2220736295,
-0.1215175986,
-0.3274957538,
0.5920112133,
-0.6438138485,
-0.4037699699,
0.1558325142,
-0.3879134357,
0.1034741923,
-0.4615611434,
0.4148740768,
-0.2597180903,
0.2729872167,
-0.1029587686,
-0.5550132394,
-0.014724507,
0.2493532598,
-0.969897151,
1.128057003,
0.3373937011,
-1.0043554306,
0.5188760161,
-0.6040844321,
-0.1881818771,
0.2996671498,
-0.7251861095,
-0.2944049835,
0.2463979423,
0.0441801324,
0.1606971771,
-0.2487103343,
0.2461575717,
-0.4092816412,
0.068799369,
0.4908083975,
-0.4391641021,
0.7660791874,
0.0367020331,
-0.2655850351,
0.0207455121,
-0.8516263962,
-0.0457918346,
-0.0075363284,
-0.5970919728,
-0.3812500834,
0.2275062203,
0.5866466165,
-0.1759371608,
0.1855366081,
-0.3949241638,
0.3165298104,
-0.2878897786,
0.1114566401,
0.4522618651,
-0.3174695969,
0.3076038063,
-0.1667764932,
0.7393265367,
-0.0781426877,
-0.080804266,
-0.0981351957,
-0.4198080599,
-0.9070063233,
-0.3330257535,
0.2358963042,
0.2884361148,
-0.678147912,
0.4969263077,
-0.1045799255,
-0.4561527669,
-0.5496794581,
0.1487192512,
-0.0219761115,
-0.018528251,
0.1707093418,
-0.4790605903,
-0.539519906,
-0.9093795419,
-0.5578631759,
-0.016345365,
-0.3042370975,
0.378726989,
0.3670648932,
-0.4958434105,
1.1294219494,
-0.8147117496,
0.0480485149,
-0.4308492243,
0.630548656,
0.2266453058,
0.4070015252,
0.5323159099,
-0.7768713832,
-0.5876600742,
0.1662822813,
-0.3756765425,
-0.292506516,
-0.2785466015,
-0.11049705,
-0.0764175951,
0.2557426989,
-0.259809494,
0.0730848461,
0.5436254144,
-0.1127800196,
0.7579120398,
0.0124246636,
-0.1872586161,
-0.9625973105,
0.187568754,
0.0730111748,
-0.1550230682,
-0.831240952,
0.3629697263,
0.003361752,
0.1520709395,
0.1462514251,
0.145456776,
-0.3229216039,
0.2649800181,
-0.0273463391,
-0.3707874119,
-0.1956774592,
0.1476262212,
0.0764435083,
0.650590241,
0.4658752382,
-0.0137703605,
0.3786263466,
-0.038309209,
-0.3209677935,
0.3260781169,
-0.1700611562,
0.2668393552,
-0.0926690176,
0.0535674542,
-0.7824983597,
-0.5739350915,
0.09008044,
-0.2627463341,
0.2462201416,
-0.010144487,
-0.3810609281,
-0.219466567,
-0.6220799088,
0.4011627138,
-0.0628299639,
-0.2788129747,
0.7030580044,
0.6010130644,
-0.204850629,
-0.8960050941,
-0.6552394629,
0.1417438835,
-0.163172558,
-0.2369149029,
0.1419596821,
-0.4371818304,
-0.2710537612,
-0.1720029116,
-0.1208357885,
-0.4514148235,
-0.0649293363,
-0.0487504937,
0.012619298,
-0.2065223306,
0.0572981387,
0.1327360123,
0.159185648,
-0.0364259444,
-0.0156366844,
0.7726197839,
-0.3790260553,
-0.4584763944,
-0.0408854745,
0.5727526546,
0.3518181145,
0.1854975969,
0.2995914817,
0.5462490916,
-0.1263564825,
-0.2928180099,
-0.5181447864,
0.2295798063,
-0.4416152239,
0.4759628177,
-0.3612491488,
-1.0054273605,
0.5147181153,
-0.0170234758,
0.0533046015,
0.2870557606,
0.6450902224,
0.231967926,
0.6076496243,
0.8626325727,
-0.2000738382,
0.6297932267,
-0.2043022811,
-0.0098368768,
-0.5656815171,
-0.1150481403,
-0.519389689,
0.0401503295,
-0.6394349337,
-0.5868046284,
0.1312984228,
-0.1008346602,
0.1105361134,
0.1201665774,
-0.3904392421,
0.6738427281,
0.3998839259,
-0.1865922511,
0.1347686052,
-0.2826683819,
-0.0033868866,
-0.3607413471,
-0.4052859545,
-0.3796767592,
1.3023041487,
0.3033963144,
1.0317226648,
0.136420235,
0.8546521664,
0.2053374648,
0.2246470749,
-0.8055682182,
0.2539452612,
-0.0652690604,
-0.5104097128,
-0.3198734522,
-0.6040472984,
-0.7526250482,
0.6477288008,
-0.1209663823,
-0.8112944961,
0.4245263934,
0.255303055,
0.0894546956,
0.273642987,
-0.6105993986,
0.6738772988,
-0.0581229031,
-0.147266537,
0.0442448743,
-0.7549660802,
0.44487077,
-0.2398584783,
0.3254727423,
-0.0494842306,
-0.1833724529,
0.4696534276,
-0.1965734214,
1.0170388222,
0.1746357977,
-0.2116554976,
-0.2316782773,
0.3179629147,
0.0854833946,
0.2444538474,
0.0692772418,
0.1001890823,
-0.0491641089,
-0.4420966506,
-0.5522354841,
0.5288999081,
-0.8901032805,
-0.3463229835,
-0.3020958304,
-0.903129518,
-0.3153530359,
0.1513132602,
0.1776518822,
0.0939518809,
-0.568297863,
0.0146835437,
0.6343541741,
-0.401924938,
0.1247983128,
0.3618181646,
-0.2322372198,
-0.2249477953,
1.1401809454,
-0.068191044,
0.2099007368,
0.7427327037,
0.4089047909,
0.0280520748,
-0.3446669877,
-0.2614632547,
0.0567374788,
-0.7252191305,
0.1554720998,
-0.6156818271,
0.0331739299,
-0.2631151676,
-0.159926042,
-0.4404604435,
-0.6553220153,
-0.2525262833,
0.0877072215,
-0.0147013441,
0.7451544404,
-0.234679848,
0.3098002672,
-0.1519533098,
0.2595866621,
0.4811712503,
0.3094070256,
-0.2588006258,
0.0746923834,
-0.0929506347,
-0.2295363247,
-0.4218111038,
-1.0225813389,
0.3540309072,
0.1246907562,
0.6430885196,
0.4597437084,
-0.3035217226,
0.1499580145,
-0.2995356023,
0.8921992779,
0.3717735112,
-1.1832244396,
0.290407598,
-0.4602303803,
0.2275245786,
0.541247189,
0.2669247687,
-1.0927368402,
-0.7720448375,
-0.4437401295,
-1.1976203918,
0.7051879168,
0.1679984629,
0.1483052224,
0.4158821106,
0.0074754837,
0.7224215865,
0.50810045,
-0.8461162448,
-0.4689040184,
-0.578758359,
-0.2993435562,
-0.2143009007,
-0.0312851854,
-0.4074466527,
-0.3745186031,
0.2921352386,
-0.4138750136,
-0.1068850383,
-0.2994706035,
-0.2407812029,
0.2317904532,
0.5345897079,
0.4100322127,
0.7210969925,
-0.186521396,
0.5781055093,
0.0799186826,
-0.4829954207,
0.0072530587,
0.1964660734,
-0.1301321536,
0.0472384058,
0.3839371502,
0.7231032252,
-0.2180799097,
-0.7466509938,
0.4762974083,
-0.1304037124,
-0.0472188406,
0.0451106057,
0.0869120061,
0.20183222,
-0.1118663326,
0.1220897138,
-0.0644096211,
0.5054585338,
-0.3708534837,
0.0982226953,
0.2099379301,
-0.2233264148,
-0.3593428135,
0.383161962,
0.0395184048,
-0.3698761165,
0.1399153024,
-0.0265147332,
-0.3044972718,
0.5391517282,
0.2988981009,
0.89045614,
-0.26934129,
0.6819691658,
-0.2132622451,
0.3496747911,
0.1501762569,
0.2687538266,
-0.0999170542,
-0.8646500111,
-0.3878202438,
-0.3724831939,
-0.8506136537,
0.3924507797,
-0.8536316752,
-0.0435852259,
-0.2907250822,
0.0509002768,
0.4846463501,
-0.2394897491,
-0.6379020214,
-0.0932896659,
0.0702544674,
0.6575917006,
-1.0489501953,
0.5196886063,
0.8574474454,
-0.5449159145,
-0.3350188136,
0.3848226368,
0.0173834823,
-0.6498787403,
0.2614297271,
0.035757497,
-0.0961116999,
-0.3888681531,
-0.6992703676,
-0.5067046285,
0.4570761323,
0.5836187005,
-0.3580067456,
0.3286888003,
0.5620974898,
0.7772411704,
-0.1830403209,
0.4323568046,
0.8679489493,
0.2417528629,
-0.3588581085,
-0.4848736227,
0.0031270275,
-0.3625864685,
0.2436667681,
0.2820844352,
-0.5233418941,
1.0522624254,
0.3003354669,
0.1219718605,
-0.2505822778,
0.3237944245,
-0.0548070408,
-0.0027074239,
0.3914932013,
0.3983260691,
0.8658240438,
0.0365451798,
0.7511672974,
-0.0644251779,
0.5475299954,
1.1475812197,
-0.0899952278,
0.4173336029,
0.6665480733,
-0.4072647095,
0.7729138136,
0.588120997,
0.1202445477,
0.2092013806,
0.5456231236,
-0.580555439,
-0.247810185,
0.1027501822,
-0.2081510723,
0.1147896945,
0.5327180624,
-0.006100263,
-0.2669566572,
-0.0835938379,
-0.1703411788,
0.0514741652,
0.2361595482,
0.5607259274,
-0.1231982559,
-0.1886230707,
0.3305988908,
0.0366999321,
0.8005827069,
-0.5562923551,
0.1884551644,
-0.3792320788,
-0.1030797064,
-0.1614829004,
-0.9272125959,
0.1358259618,
-0.2425097525,
-0.1464360654,
-0.0561674871,
0.3469813466,
-0.4776863158,
-0.2304751873,
0.1815555692,
0.6001409888,
0.0435942411,
0.0772343799,
-0.7065377831,
-0.0219208915,
-0.0044968501,
-0.3591468036,
0.2570017278,
0.480440408,
0.0393253341,
0.7488119006,
0.4205997884,
0.1967880875,
0.2761217356,
0.3817988336,
1.1630854607,
-0.5295606256,
-0.4361835718,
-0.6811044812,
0.3870007396,
-0.3278357387,
-0.6044065952,
0.4451653659,
0.8805665374,
0.8421203494,
-0.1953807622,
1.2744673491,
-0.2699474394,
0.4021348059,
-0.234421581,
0.466013521,
-0.5530405045,
0.1800519228,
-0.279291898,
-0.5459108949,
-0.6130409241,
0.3151334226,
-0.2328709811,
-0.237140283,
0.7109802365,
0.6529200673,
-0.2822680771,
-0.0062519573,
0.1841658056,
-0.1198946834,
0.6214661598,
0.1412775069,
0.9818281531,
0.1935949922,
0.4325633943,
-0.0998870507,
-0.5540812016,
-0.166683346,
-0.5183871388,
-0.8538965583,
-0.5769500136,
-0.0602720082,
0.0087095611,
-0.2124388218,
0.8480790854,
0.4850708842,
-0.803040266,
-0.7758889198,
-0.4375202656,
0.4425888956,
-0.1168614924,
-0.2826345265,
0.1845334768,
-0.6062951088,
-0.8124300241,
0.3711409271,
0.3074826598,
-0.0271572638,
-0.5708367825,
0.1624898612,
0.0379098952,
0.1964804232,
0.1908580512,
0.5119735003,
-0.576084435,
0.0484750941,
-0.3619976044,
-0.1307620555,
0.2837380171,
1.3793332577,
-0.1599196196,
0.8930231929,
0.6915316582,
0.6819948554,
0.5968452692,
-0.4465982616,
0.742203176,
-1.1157523394,
0.2207305431,
0.4275276363,
0.2479433864,
0.4972432554,
-0.2481094748,
0.3784824014,
0.3962001503,
-0.343421489,
-0.8588913083,
0.672829926,
-0.9265046716,
-0.4650036395,
0.9640935063,
-0.0586272478,
0.096469067,
-0.3407084644,
-0.3141855299,
0.034550909,
-0.4629377425,
0.9468314052,
0.8722108006,
-0.3766352236,
-0.0101828016,
-0.5984159708,
0.6658453345,
0.4211094975,
-1.1644883156,
0.1932443678,
0.5451183319,
0.4111078084,
0.2159888893,
0.6836314201,
0.1689919531,
-0.1969121099,
0.173668921,
0.3872036338,
0.5528691411,
0.0230374373,
-0.4934856892,
0.1230809614,
0.07824637,
0.0566120297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17642v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17642v1 | Banishing LLM Hallucinations Requires Rethinking Generalization | 2024-06-25T15:31:01 | 2024-06-25T15:31:01 | Johnny Li, Saksham Consul, Eda Zhou, James Wong, Naila Farooqui, Yuxin Ye, Nithyashree Manohar, Zhuxiaona Wei, Tian Wu, Ben Echols, Sharon Zhou, Gregory Diamos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite their powerful chat, coding, and reasoning abilities, Large Language
Models (LLMs) frequently hallucinate. Conventional wisdom suggests that
hallucinations are a consequence of a balance between creativity and
factuality, which can be mitigated, but not eliminated, by grounding the LLM in
external knowledge sources. Through extensive systematic experiments, we show
that these traditional approaches fail to explain why LLMs hallucinate in
practice. Specifically, we show that LLMs augmented with a massive Mixture of
Memory Experts (MoME) can easily memorize large datasets of random numbers. We
corroborate these experimental findings with a theoretical construction showing
that simple neural networks trained to predict the next token hallucinate when
the training loss is above a threshold as it usually does in practice when
training on internet scale data. We interpret our findings by comparing against
traditional retrieval methods for mitigating hallucinations. We use our
findings to design a first generation model for removing hallucinations --
Lamini-1 -- that stores facts in a massive mixture of millions of memory
experts that are retrieved dynamically. | [
-0.5633643866,
-0.7683013082,
0.570961237,
0.0568149686,
-0.255926609,
-0.0293025281,
-0.362583369,
-0.4921578169,
0.6309787631,
0.9016463757,
-0.3566004932,
-0.3263761401,
-0.6457931995,
-0.1302669644,
-0.5431364179,
0.8201627731,
0.3622812331,
0.1085120887,
-0.1009103134,
-0.0600211062,
-0.4345767498,
-0.8622855544,
-0.7104005814,
-0.4661959112,
0.7381667495,
0.1381329894,
0.691800952,
0.3295551538,
0.4425940514,
0.2325150669,
-0.1542886496,
0.4436386526,
-1.0194810629,
0.0385266803,
0.0257679764,
-0.6989712119,
-0.0503668487,
-0.0960054174,
0.3012425303,
0.8570709825,
-0.4402168691,
-0.4762057662,
-0.0940039381,
0.7359173894,
-0.3848071992,
-0.1121430993,
-1.1726734638,
0.4624355137,
0.1481305063,
-0.5664976835,
-0.6337662339,
-0.2533591986,
0.092884995,
-0.3318920135,
0.2510381639,
0.1350824535,
0.5589921474,
0.5585930347,
-0.0185854286,
-0.5724557638,
-0.9017119408,
0.6206467748,
-0.4181744158,
0.2418322116,
0.7102558613,
0.3109817207,
-0.3016963899,
-0.4222899079,
-0.4504939318,
-0.4937821031,
-0.0153146209,
-0.2470929325,
0.0022121919,
-0.0851799101,
0.3519578874,
0.2702947259,
-0.4082333148,
0.2648886442,
-0.6956454515,
-0.3755174279,
0.3613851666,
0.2452440709,
0.3395510018,
0.0412846543,
-0.3444351256,
0.3962141573,
-0.8146605492,
-0.4385103583,
0.206985876,
0.130450964,
0.511092782,
0.455180943,
0.14767465,
0.1731877327,
0.080798246,
-0.3919306993,
-0.1779724956,
0.2459070832,
-0.2396144569,
0.2483327836,
0.4789102674,
0.3358282149,
0.5785917044,
-0.8927913904,
-0.1982626915,
0.0295136888,
0.6001618505,
-0.670856297,
-0.4275245965,
0.1205675006,
-0.3984731138,
-0.2415897548,
0.0428071208,
-0.791193068,
-1.0431990623,
-0.4676788747,
0.628929913,
-0.5281675458,
-0.18011491,
0.2593354285,
-0.1755270809,
0.1567626446,
0.4212046266,
-0.9600520134,
0.4997345209,
0.6626387835,
0.7716109753,
-0.3239644766,
-0.2812413275,
-0.3152065277,
0.1366216093,
-0.41615206,
0.7324200273,
-0.2513576746,
-0.3603901267,
-0.1603625566,
-0.1456071138,
0.03159073,
-1.2036687136,
0.1569246799,
-0.385484606,
-0.0123461122,
-0.3882502019,
-0.5431091785,
-0.503668189,
0.0160027742,
-0.6489610076,
0.4786956608,
-0.3485527337,
-0.5605862141,
0.2300019413,
0.1482544243,
-0.3627033532,
-0.0674652457,
-0.3384174109,
-0.161994487,
0.5613240004,
0.0858151913,
0.3514073193,
-0.1372723728,
0.4488708973,
-0.1452421099,
-0.7243288159,
0.2614011765,
-0.4293976128,
0.5169547796,
0.238168776,
-0.3822031021,
0.1126800403,
-0.7181229591,
-0.4593708217,
0.1328411549,
-0.1680697054,
-0.4038909972,
0.0509428605,
-0.4976837337,
-0.024615543,
-0.180542618,
-0.1816432774,
0.0454550199,
-0.2864579856,
0.3384588063,
0.8896106482,
0.0006941861,
0.25867787,
-0.830436945,
0.2013151199,
0.3012056351,
-0.0787226558,
0.0795803517,
-0.359102726,
-0.991802156,
-0.2501886189,
-0.3421270847,
0.4396114051,
-0.6218050122,
0.3618360162,
-0.2291040272,
-0.3502945602,
-0.3694069982,
0.3359994888,
-0.1077782214,
0.4778678417,
0.4173078835,
-0.2172160149,
-0.6872578859,
-0.9131507874,
0.0459668189,
-0.0312591419,
-0.1138253286,
0.1794184297,
0.3785509467,
-0.2023723871,
0.5487819314,
-0.146586597,
-0.4228910804,
-0.2059883922,
0.1133024916,
-0.0701201335,
0.4176523089,
0.2757520974,
-0.6288078427,
0.1055756062,
-0.2550612688,
-0.9315596819,
0.1032301113,
-0.4905391037,
0.0402236097,
0.3060505986,
0.441845715,
-0.8160088658,
0.4394645095,
0.003393692,
-0.1456352323,
0.6342766881,
-0.0319276825,
-0.1430729926,
-0.6768345237,
-0.0757919699,
-0.1770054102,
0.0660406649,
-0.6133140326,
-0.0398056842,
-0.423293978,
0.035308823,
-0.2840285599,
0.4265416563,
-0.1981770843,
-0.0049594506,
-0.4689525068,
0.1536947042,
-0.0665724948,
0.4592963755,
0.1808016151,
0.5896336436,
0.422398895,
-0.7845542431,
0.0937153697,
0.049534943,
-0.4143467844,
0.2174054086,
-0.3578292429,
0.3003427386,
-0.3579372466,
0.1520605385,
-0.8748674989,
-0.1304786652,
0.1308806688,
-0.2083429992,
0.2681180835,
0.2747014761,
-0.5183010101,
-0.3143126369,
-0.2809971869,
-0.0350470431,
0.587266624,
-0.7379950881,
0.5894161463,
0.419462949,
0.078346014,
-0.3696288764,
-0.954926312,
0.5186790228,
-0.3685698509,
-0.4905399084,
0.2055386007,
-0.2546915114,
-0.6282578707,
-0.2816454768,
-0.3001558781,
-0.0549089871,
0.1325318217,
0.265764147,
0.183454439,
-0.0150545547,
0.3107113838,
-0.3094033003,
-0.0447900295,
0.4304057956,
-0.2465270311,
0.9009671807,
0.098630324,
-0.3171686828,
-0.2966894507,
0.1452203393,
0.6638100147,
0.275128901,
0.967803061,
0.5289255381,
-0.658628583,
-0.423866421,
-1.1246712208,
-0.5420037508,
-0.428499788,
0.4043106139,
-0.4468016922,
-0.6692909598,
0.754180789,
0.1427097023,
-0.2089764029,
0.0959556401,
0.7068355083,
0.0845704302,
0.6894685626,
0.151702404,
-0.1074437946,
0.0520669855,
-0.3535124063,
0.4303530753,
-0.6544756889,
-0.576860249,
-0.1689484715,
-0.3213165402,
-0.2866612971,
-0.3091236651,
0.0253725648,
0.1108348593,
0.0250165425,
-0.1449793577,
-0.5667309165,
0.6990168691,
0.4733635485,
0.5243246555,
0.2790322304,
0.2744283676,
-0.0566833504,
-0.1208132952,
-0.6121042371,
-0.5088894963,
0.9874640107,
0.3844025433,
0.9091633558,
-0.1749801189,
0.8522747755,
0.1742317975,
0.1918996572,
-0.7954797745,
0.8352568746,
-0.0038782591,
-0.600500226,
-0.2069988847,
-0.5286923647,
-0.5363425612,
0.4479016066,
-0.1166496575,
-0.8659561872,
0.1924429834,
-0.1258745939,
-0.4574085474,
0.8539122343,
-0.4972020686,
0.1525189728,
-0.2377754897,
-0.5714099407,
-0.4180074632,
-0.3552899361,
0.7667281628,
-0.2329274416,
0.174769029,
0.0744656548,
0.1401432455,
0.6814214587,
-0.2552827001,
1.1189250946,
-0.1549188793,
-0.1806263477,
0.4075952172,
0.4447964132,
0.4909808636,
-0.0855937153,
-0.1430696696,
0.1155605689,
-0.4045948982,
-0.331786871,
-0.6849771142,
0.8741698861,
-0.736956656,
-0.8936329484,
-0.0457586721,
-0.7828412056,
0.0207956173,
-0.2877545357,
0.404083997,
0.1417878717,
-0.1259005219,
0.4183436036,
1.0538625717,
-0.3360162079,
0.1774022877,
0.1877861768,
-0.4810029566,
-0.5681369901,
0.9973987341,
0.4894910753,
0.1784639508,
-0.0194333568,
0.1709135324,
-0.0100902999,
-0.8832393885,
0.2511882484,
0.2032138109,
-1.0144996643,
0.1127024591,
-0.9017136693,
-0.3337688446,
-0.2949239612,
-0.1937881112,
-0.1625205129,
-0.5264174342,
-0.4664276242,
-0.3730172515,
0.206081599,
0.7604953647,
-0.1536988318,
0.1083265096,
-0.4177549779,
0.4641810358,
0.4130035639,
0.1514519006,
0.4681042731,
-0.6314708591,
-0.2015122622,
-0.1912504286,
-0.1811944991,
-0.5343613029,
0.5492351055,
-0.1165841147,
0.6452516913,
0.729995966,
-0.0560888872,
0.7440588474,
-0.3027502596,
0.6399068832,
0.1557908505,
-0.5907292366,
0.2474482208,
-0.0328851417,
-0.0623647533,
0.5917229652,
0.4450939298,
-0.445333004,
-0.5107970834,
-0.3522236049,
-0.6704856157,
0.2155932188,
0.0173935927,
0.1828049421,
-0.2828274667,
0.6152340174,
0.538436234,
0.2330357283,
-0.8299019933,
-0.0385247096,
-0.1925122887,
-0.0406774767,
0.1177608371,
-0.4785007238,
-0.1774056107,
-0.5903480053,
0.4790404737,
0.179330945,
0.3244878352,
0.1457608044,
-0.2920771539,
-0.1918436587,
-0.0947733968,
0.7850461006,
0.7117785215,
-0.2761130333,
0.5333907604,
0.3618310988,
-0.3721593618,
0.0497710519,
-0.3542230427,
-0.2992864549,
-0.1767210513,
0.3827717304,
0.8767609596,
0.329856962,
-0.6070823669,
0.0300053321,
0.1665088385,
-0.4036835432,
-0.5755898952,
0.2829882801,
0.238841936,
0.1424176246,
0.5390362144,
0.0949011967,
-0.0372138806,
-0.7069123387,
0.53990376,
0.4439792931,
-0.3043702841,
-0.4145300686,
0.6957888007,
-0.1465934217,
-0.5608453155,
0.6932415962,
-0.0533402711,
-0.5679883361,
0.7443680763,
0.7582313418,
1.0069878101,
0.0383535847,
-0.0006547305,
0.3448852301,
0.5633759499,
-0.2732647955,
0.079525955,
0.2946607769,
-0.7439588904,
-0.0757074282,
-0.5663305521,
-0.2317388654,
0.4330474734,
-0.3222900629,
0.0556502268,
-0.7483147979,
-0.0223719645,
-0.2557727396,
-0.101633966,
-0.567995131,
-0.0249264427,
0.5917723179,
0.6870883107,
-0.5739488006,
0.8884450793,
0.0058731223,
-0.5410476327,
-0.3585709929,
0.1338460147,
0.0334254727,
-0.8710005283,
0.5828986764,
0.5377599597,
-0.0250202622,
0.0502837636,
-0.7249320149,
-0.5549207926,
0.8758876324,
0.1614858955,
-0.5126066804,
-0.1472403556,
0.1290203482,
0.5474484563,
-0.6016037464,
0.0431667902,
0.6413152814,
0.5729510784,
0.3089271784,
-0.4409092069,
0.1545829028,
-0.1089015827,
-0.2858556211,
-0.1580298692,
-0.4938035011,
0.7674126029,
-0.505867064,
-0.1423580348,
0.0291848276,
0.5540968776,
0.3640139103,
0.2688118219,
0.437404722,
0.7304013371,
1.1332707405,
0.1751727909,
0.8761886954,
-0.2996980846,
-0.1831230223,
1.1985285282,
-0.3896358311,
0.5448051095,
0.8045526147,
0.1394765675,
0.3196522593,
0.3483163118,
-0.2140578032,
0.5733551979,
0.5175453424,
-0.1415556669,
-0.3689026237,
-0.1810373068,
-0.1642978042,
0.240023315,
0.4742140472,
-0.3161540926,
0.0377169177,
0.3594990373,
0.0019474307,
0.0381835587,
-0.1796974093,
0.8010467887,
0.3241438568,
-0.5352124572,
0.8646250367,
-0.557739377,
0.6058695316,
-0.2887587249,
0.0899626091,
-0.4212884009,
0.1005832478,
-0.1673080623,
-0.2213540971,
0.4376430809,
-0.3990470171,
-0.0564056486,
0.1193898171,
0.7148059607,
-0.3965790272,
-0.4183298051,
0.5733985901,
0.505659759,
0.3909057677,
-0.2426795959,
-0.1621419638,
0.0758333504,
0.0002385863,
-0.3094933927,
0.4810057878,
0.5448101759,
0.1500396729,
0.9897091389,
0.5584079623,
0.295424968,
0.2611789107,
0.2329484671,
0.9988620281,
-0.8203998208,
-0.1417447031,
-1.0128523111,
0.1392914355,
-0.0468414873,
-0.0125233494,
0.5320494175,
0.4459870458,
0.5435233712,
-0.0746991634,
0.5647317767,
0.3855614066,
0.188334927,
-0.5830136538,
0.8921120167,
-0.4859534204,
0.6518985033,
0.2820312679,
-0.846559763,
-0.4313028455,
0.6744007468,
-0.2332579792,
-0.0589699931,
0.8008189797,
1.0985693932,
0.1556831151,
0.1617161036,
0.6791892052,
0.5384673476,
0.3100819588,
0.5328727365,
1.009717226,
-0.0321748666,
0.5685522556,
-0.5195136666,
-0.0310194269,
-0.287512064,
-0.3944286704,
-1.3155173063,
-0.2360706031,
-0.0907623172,
-0.2366329879,
0.1480963081,
1.0482184887,
0.5014238954,
-0.9060884714,
-0.1522710919,
-0.0603920184,
0.1729670167,
0.004423575,
-0.2332966328,
0.2023404092,
-0.542724371,
-0.346696198,
0.4961109459,
0.3258439302,
0.1677066535,
-0.8175984621,
-0.1805453897,
0.0567113645,
0.3460297585,
0.5611258745,
-0.0513604544,
-1.2311331034,
-0.3606499135,
0.0810722113,
-0.3136510551,
0.2432675511,
0.8647336364,
-0.8681280017,
0.3260467052,
0.420907557,
0.5051766038,
0.2254940718,
-0.2479181439,
0.3405565321,
-0.238339588,
0.3810089529,
0.2765626013,
0.3517792821,
0.1658100635,
-0.5213059187,
0.5878065825,
0.3546938896,
-0.4645402133,
-0.8703181744,
-0.0676222071,
-0.634981513,
-0.6056893468,
0.8938876987,
0.1559232622,
-0.243554607,
-0.2212647945,
-0.3135741949,
0.004308281,
-0.1206910536,
1.637034893,
0.9591515064,
0.1284434199,
-0.1879119724,
-0.6353926659,
0.469186306,
0.5572636127,
-0.6189299822,
0.2221237868,
0.416182071,
-0.0642512143,
0.2147068381,
0.6168293357,
0.0105969599,
-0.0115621975,
0.1410437673,
0.1614261121,
-0.1682103574,
-0.7545081377,
-0.3739843071,
0.4236802161,
-0.0780676603,
0.3329827487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17639v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17639v2 | Mitigate the Gap: Investigating Approaches for Improving Cross-Modal Alignment in CLIP | 2024-06-25T15:24:02 | 2024-06-26T10:58:48 | Sedigheh Eslami, Gerard de Melo | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Contrastive Language--Image Pre-training (CLIP) has manifested remarkable
improvements in zero-shot classification and cross-modal vision-language tasks.
Yet, from a geometrical point of view, the CLIP embedding space has been found
to have a pronounced modality gap. This gap renders the embedding space overly
sparse and disconnected, with different modalities being densely distributed in
distinct subregions of the hypersphere. In this work, we aim at answering two
main questions: 1. Does sharing the parameter space between the multi-modal
encoders reduce the modality gap? 2. Can the gap be mitigated by pushing apart
the uni-modal embeddings via intra-modality separation? We design AlignCLIP, in
order to answer these questions and show that answers to both questions are
positive. Through extensive experiments, we show that AlignCLIP achieves
noticeable enhancements in the cross-modal alignment of the embeddings, and
thereby, reduces the modality gap, while maintaining the performance across
several downstream evaluations, such as zero-shot image classification,
zero-shot multi-modal retrieval and zero-shot semantic text similarity. | [
-0.7055719495,
-0.4455546439,
0.3989665806,
-0.0160232242,
-0.5342981815,
0.1286910027,
-0.2168755233,
-0.6045963168,
0.390678525,
-0.0518657155,
-0.6494749188,
-0.2977848351,
-0.4760288,
-0.0376286097,
0.0868712962,
0.6332874894,
-0.2702444792,
0.2497366369,
-0.5151188374,
-0.4055386484,
-0.7585654259,
-0.3174182773,
0.1841000766,
0.0505125262,
0.1138313562,
0.286901325,
1.0360934734,
0.8077893257,
0.4973548949,
0.1931092143,
0.1067007259,
-0.00122532,
-0.4078997672,
0.0250949804,
-0.1546196491,
-0.2834153175,
-0.1399253756,
-0.0791261792,
0.711482048,
0.6339515448,
0.0859151557,
-0.0236735195,
0.1969373822,
0.1489816308,
-1.0334039927,
-0.2784961164,
-0.3103965521,
0.1404753923,
-0.5463738441,
-0.1701402217,
0.073781319,
0.008803959,
0.1086603329,
-0.8746833801,
0.1954957545,
0.1212642789,
1.0823178291,
0.3160382509,
-0.2712259293,
0.1554836184,
-0.4437755942,
0.9915953875,
-0.5765518546,
0.7015910745,
0.0684941337,
0.1915946305,
0.1722683758,
-0.2319460511,
-0.567440033,
0.4182731807,
0.0903345495,
0.2096532881,
-0.1303882599,
0.027874656,
0.0509649962,
0.3401508331,
-0.5233411193,
0.1729003787,
-0.4136860669,
-0.397169888,
0.1875374615,
0.2265047729,
0.4487525523,
-0.1455311626,
-0.7841245532,
-0.2552562952,
-0.9997854829,
0.2556354702,
0.4626881778,
-0.0152184125,
-0.0546499267,
0.5943748355,
0.1329024136,
0.6884545088,
0.1697299927,
-0.1757517755,
0.1224090606,
-0.685112834,
-0.0976585448,
0.0129643865,
0.7399808168,
0.732232213,
-0.2666501403,
-0.0397644863,
-0.0088108899,
0.3217617571,
0.0375789739,
-0.7901883125,
-0.0797585249,
-0.2150046825,
-0.2425664216,
0.1553308368,
0.2419601977,
-0.6463259459,
0.0495936759,
-0.3550335169,
0.7038472295,
-0.4452954531,
0.0134021286,
0.2264473289,
-0.3019347191,
0.4265752435,
0.4129683971,
-0.6735512614,
0.4238108695,
0.5209914446,
0.8844027519,
-0.1696500629,
-0.3522554636,
-0.2331122607,
0.4495610595,
-0.0311035719,
0.8089674711,
-0.9088611007,
-0.4123708308,
-0.0313295908,
0.0248003434,
-0.2059917599,
-0.4365431368,
0.3265826106,
-0.2377402186,
0.6736368537,
-0.6012886167,
-0.5137262344,
-0.1057692617,
0.3185705841,
-0.6090424061,
0.7516837716,
-0.0269557908,
-0.7936825752,
0.5553181171,
-0.3824404478,
-0.2420299202,
-0.0900222808,
-0.5373591781,
-0.4822820127,
0.0912921876,
0.6878501773,
-0.0181541517,
-0.3847154379,
-0.2226822674,
-0.4942959547,
-0.607177496,
0.2664836943,
-0.2826305628,
0.4528323114,
-0.0031122342,
-0.3757491708,
0.0727718621,
-0.2794368565,
0.1513496339,
-0.2339896411,
0.1996652931,
-0.6866162419,
-0.2655355036,
0.1128226444,
0.4619473815,
0.0185318477,
-0.7648227215,
0.2643938959,
-0.1131741032,
0.3720118105,
0.6759666204,
0.0210366081,
0.5661093593,
-0.4232037365,
0.7579687238,
0.3175958991,
0.3723325729,
-0.3103553951,
-0.1397508681,
-0.5156758428,
-0.7623807788,
0.345656991,
0.310023278,
-0.6290745735,
0.3479785621,
-0.1377816498,
-0.1600177884,
-0.7183615565,
0.1605268717,
0.716239512,
0.4792813659,
0.3706285357,
-0.8934418559,
-0.3822592497,
-0.9177331924,
0.0514197014,
0.3457356989,
0.0586936139,
0.2322280109,
0.2291195393,
-0.0730998069,
0.9876776934,
-0.6026400328,
-0.4046523571,
0.0311834719,
-0.1109765247,
-0.2454075664,
0.6705213189,
0.7163735032,
-0.7179952264,
-0.3341878653,
-0.2511644363,
-0.3463953137,
-0.2376318127,
-0.066602692,
-0.2827495933,
-0.1279965341,
0.6382689476,
-0.4988106191,
0.5809102654,
0.4328209162,
-0.1946219504,
0.2910597324,
0.0790574774,
0.3001274168,
-0.8890460134,
0.0878147781,
-0.317933619,
-0.3696211874,
-0.18237333,
-0.2762172818,
-0.0356670953,
-0.3332670927,
-0.7195463181,
0.2226013839,
-0.670437336,
-0.216381833,
-0.1783266217,
0.4167659879,
0.3974172473,
0.5309726,
0.1137253791,
1.0544016361,
0.7578487396,
-0.3692282736,
-0.2570390105,
0.6041816473,
-0.1981843561,
0.7686254978,
-0.7776944637,
-0.0915795118,
0.0257312898,
0.2716629207,
-1.0565431118,
-0.073858805,
0.3768868744,
-0.1553635746,
0.3736775219,
-0.0055992398,
0.0288105737,
0.0906357616,
-0.8057712913,
1.273884654,
0.347954154,
-0.3602956831,
0.1653004438,
0.4584563673,
-0.096595645,
-0.7469003797,
-0.5797705054,
-0.225512132,
-0.0206857305,
-0.5604972243,
0.646464169,
-0.0228072144,
0.2741945684,
0.4268558621,
-0.3035319448,
-0.0684327111,
-0.2883106768,
0.3522269428,
0.27306512,
-0.3428004086,
0.0156078143,
0.1892715991,
0.0352200717,
-0.3906441927,
-0.109002918,
0.5231456161,
-0.1247032285,
-0.7790200114,
-0.4555722177,
0.6228043437,
0.6191063523,
-0.358178556,
0.3528884947,
0.4323154092,
-0.1532085538,
0.2076610476,
-0.4766429961,
0.0526664145,
-0.4294181764,
0.1512720138,
-0.192314133,
-1.1640985012,
0.3789785802,
-0.1484671533,
-0.2055449635,
0.1050498635,
0.3647645116,
-0.0085612955,
0.9692619443,
1.0188393593,
0.132898137,
0.8781355023,
-0.2337155044,
0.3096152544,
-1.2583135366,
-0.2015268952,
-0.1128374562,
-0.5207777619,
-0.0848444626,
-0.7715538144,
0.3653573096,
0.4265859723,
-0.1123357117,
0.5970613956,
-0.4035730958,
0.8644585609,
0.3610298336,
0.0665964261,
0.1325123459,
-0.2135998756,
-0.1981201917,
-0.6159297824,
-0.8330964446,
-0.17089203,
0.6579122543,
0.137449041,
0.9200026989,
0.1487837136,
0.6239803433,
0.0336740687,
-0.1456957906,
-0.6299393773,
0.3992893398,
0.0191325042,
-0.371237725,
-0.0467403941,
-0.0380953513,
-0.7365922332,
0.4318128228,
-0.4022426605,
-0.5045247674,
0.6264797449,
0.1718819439,
-0.3461461961,
0.1857535094,
-0.4785210788,
1.079199791,
-0.240255639,
-0.5004637837,
-0.1821611822,
-0.902019918,
0.3322085738,
0.177135542,
-0.0253409408,
-0.0884034187,
-0.2651717663,
0.450858891,
-0.6077242494,
0.9050372243,
0.0920201614,
0.2661664486,
0.320617497,
0.1815617532,
-0.2309009582,
-0.0282267332,
0.5292879343,
0.1695381552,
0.2257227153,
-0.4662273824,
-0.7517393827,
0.314026922,
-0.6916775107,
-0.4215131998,
-0.3403982818,
-0.5954095125,
-0.3293367028,
0.2103665471,
0.4851043224,
0.7697359324,
-0.3560486436,
0.2188010067,
0.451486975,
-0.0415803678,
0.6220924258,
0.2742767036,
-0.1138853058,
-0.8375868201,
0.6128695011,
-0.1031155959,
0.5076748133,
0.336038202,
0.0698399395,
-0.3535182178,
-0.1750732362,
-0.5006337762,
0.4302745759,
-0.5970924497,
-0.5319921374,
-0.1608064175,
0.139260307,
-0.445237577,
-0.6740567684,
-0.4871424735,
-0.6288995743,
-0.2080551833,
0.1872879267,
-0.1227345318,
0.3793103099,
-0.216844216,
0.4530237913,
-0.8925650716,
0.0368647091,
0.1895972639,
0.3332750499,
-0.1645119786,
-0.388323456,
-0.1595846117,
-0.1241476908,
-0.5404645801,
-0.6318283081,
0.1831384301,
0.3737234771,
0.5589320064,
0.7436457872,
-0.0041824449,
1.3725614548,
-0.5680870414,
0.9767417908,
0.8329173326,
-1.36320889,
0.3560706973,
-0.1051916629,
0.4280461073,
0.6449955702,
0.4733228087,
-0.5127828717,
-0.4554749727,
-0.4092516899,
-0.8043829203,
0.5397706032,
0.0144251017,
-0.0185648985,
0.0526132509,
-0.0547617152,
0.3814849555,
0.3324116468,
-0.6395649314,
0.2012157291,
-0.540825069,
-0.2421072125,
0.3478239179,
-0.0505214073,
-0.5817039609,
-0.467171371,
0.2198017091,
-0.2146921754,
0.2990133464,
0.4442985952,
-0.4192451537,
-0.2120689005,
0.2441433221,
0.9398800731,
0.81606251,
0.2150601447,
0.3185914755,
-0.0749382377,
-0.5068733096,
0.0977238119,
-0.1356453449,
-0.2026645988,
0.0475222245,
0.3310336471,
0.8337309361,
0.5768448114,
-0.7251772285,
1.2029973269,
0.0711078942,
-0.0898442641,
0.1751893163,
-0.2116066515,
-0.3620380759,
0.3062170148,
-0.0563600138,
0.165835768,
-0.0157830417,
-0.5850445628,
0.3748000264,
0.6645610332,
-0.4776053131,
-0.6500995159,
0.6496848464,
0.1805453449,
-0.0883499235,
0.2269450873,
0.2389027923,
-0.9769791961,
0.098256506,
0.8678408861,
0.6364566088,
0.0311104544,
0.1552083045,
0.0072040879,
0.0896174088,
0.1229840219,
0.1096766591,
-0.5413813591,
-0.6573956609,
-0.4412617981,
-0.2037137896,
-0.6843775511,
-0.3615786433,
-0.710991323,
0.3680377007,
-0.440433234,
-0.0931015983,
-0.4211221039,
-0.3523850441,
-0.6312962174,
-0.1798268408,
0.1767486036,
0.5509459972,
-1.0133143663,
0.5331654549,
0.6570054889,
-0.6468181014,
-0.6882411242,
0.1886220723,
-0.0554038957,
-0.7099063396,
0.4586119652,
0.3511859477,
-0.5394290686,
-0.5247012973,
-0.6450856328,
-1.0514193773,
0.9825213552,
0.4589157701,
-0.426432699,
0.1594404578,
0.1181523874,
0.3335936069,
-0.4024681449,
0.2444654703,
0.1205419376,
0.1098136976,
0.1358500719,
-1.0360847712,
0.1416689605,
-0.0717541724,
0.0514490083,
0.5521557331,
-0.7693279386,
0.8048083186,
0.0284280013,
-0.4779492617,
-0.0691006705,
0.5085570812,
-0.1329821944,
0.2243770212,
0.5458834171,
0.8782592416,
0.3863094151,
0.0753967762,
0.6216323376,
-0.3415198624,
0.2585069835,
1.0883500576,
-0.4871686101,
0.7884885073,
0.8903599381,
0.088013269,
0.5698937178,
0.2741415799,
0.046393957,
0.8054776192,
-0.2415998131,
-0.1815484315,
-0.4220939875,
-0.302007854,
-0.482871443,
0.5411527157,
0.1342601329,
0.1294910908,
-0.4892761707,
0.3013916016,
-0.0014786568,
0.1397168487,
-0.1251839399,
0.511026144,
-0.0476640202,
-0.4609279633,
0.358784318,
-0.4931158125,
0.6927890778,
-0.6825224161,
-0.1280805767,
0.0063961432,
0.225039348,
-0.1282419115,
-0.7635066509,
0.2206015587,
-0.4245021045,
-0.0973375291,
-0.2297501862,
0.5283147693,
-0.7697709203,
0.020836046,
0.1138094664,
0.3431203961,
-0.0358366109,
0.3110625744,
-0.5283699036,
0.4519794583,
-0.2723950148,
0.2024783343,
0.3582521975,
0.4901227951,
-0.1814231724,
0.1497733146,
0.4993303418,
-0.0011556245,
0.2748749256,
-0.1459460557,
1.2815103531,
-0.653681457,
-0.5805314183,
-0.7027142644,
0.2582502365,
-0.1620892435,
-0.6087173223,
0.7818484306,
0.7403531075,
1.1455696821,
-0.0722624809,
0.377255708,
-0.2763418257,
0.3719213903,
-0.6597389579,
0.1511510462,
-0.6743074656,
0.1072431356,
-0.5263491273,
-1.0290871859,
-0.5528222322,
0.5189758539,
-0.1895752102,
-0.2686293721,
0.8871022463,
0.7705276608,
-0.3772665858,
-0.3864742219,
0.3602662385,
-0.4450867772,
0.377519995,
0.7331091166,
1.0156123638,
-0.5873772502,
0.7860276699,
-0.3437542617,
-0.0615666173,
-0.257044673,
-0.9056255817,
-0.6441503763,
-0.5047537088,
-0.3514661193,
0.034070354,
-0.2168070525,
0.7844845653,
0.8017036915,
-0.4807849824,
-0.0889704823,
0.1913409978,
0.0569121055,
-0.1959067583,
-0.1615269631,
0.3493467569,
-0.2651859224,
-0.624499321,
0.3135777712,
0.6678893566,
0.2162407041,
-0.1413567066,
0.0238842536,
-0.090351522,
-0.0289799292,
0.364065975,
0.6678931117,
-0.7224295735,
-0.6339398026,
0.2985011935,
-0.1327322125,
0.3716949821,
1.4449110031,
-0.7749577761,
0.5634778142,
0.5721718073,
0.8200503588,
0.3343032598,
0.3912083805,
0.8414991498,
-0.8064053059,
0.4623761773,
0.2033114284,
0.475702852,
0.3645693958,
-0.0437849239,
0.2332903594,
0.3345814347,
-0.5401899219,
-0.8021428585,
0.4435217083,
-1.3775393963,
-0.3411632776,
0.6957451701,
-0.0025997739,
-0.3403853774,
-0.1277285516,
-0.4733254313,
0.1888767928,
-0.1124940962,
0.4422110617,
0.6361197829,
-0.3914486766,
-0.1752619594,
-0.0624591932,
0.3440150321,
0.8489817977,
-0.4236474931,
-0.1590562761,
0.7514454722,
0.3573801816,
0.2433995456,
0.4610072672,
-0.5309506655,
0.5103424788,
-0.0625424609,
0.0410590656,
-0.235453546,
-0.4663412273,
-0.5308412313,
0.0310817584,
-0.152680099,
-0.7346335649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17633v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17633v1 | Knowledge Distillation in Automated Annotation: Supervised Text Classification with LLM-Generated Training Labels | 2024-06-25T15:20:25 | 2024-06-25T15:20:25 | Nicholas Pangakis, Samuel Wolken | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Computational social science (CSS) practitioners often rely on human-labeled
data to fine-tune supervised text classifiers. We assess the potential for
researchers to augment or replace human-generated training data with surrogate
training labels from generative large language models (LLMs). We introduce a
recommended workflow and test this LLM application by replicating 14
classification tasks and measuring performance. We employ a novel corpus of
English-language text classification data sets from recent CSS articles in
high-impact journals. Because these data sets are stored in password-protected
archives, our analyses are less prone to issues of contamination. For each
task, we compare supervised classifiers fine-tuned using GPT-4 labels against
classifiers fine-tuned with human annotations and against labels from GPT-4 and
Mistral-7B with few-shot in-context learning. Our findings indicate that
supervised classification models fine-tuned on LLM-generated labels perform
comparably to models fine-tuned with labels from human annotators. Fine-tuning
models using LLM-generated labels can be a fast, efficient and cost-effective
method of building supervised text classifiers. | [
-0.3770961761,
-0.6673553586,
0.5092946291,
-0.1335234642,
-0.2438632995,
0.4697453976,
-0.4793132544,
-0.6836443543,
0.010188668,
0.532372117,
-0.2428315431,
-0.5208711028,
-0.7930575609,
0.5341581106,
-0.5291731358,
1.2359570265,
-0.0715872645,
-0.043812409,
-0.3572754562,
0.0854974911,
-0.0281875879,
-0.8116208315,
-0.650475204,
-0.6231200695,
0.6471685767,
0.1966854781,
0.5123311281,
0.7814847231,
0.3715456426,
0.3983953595,
-0.2616919279,
0.4643292725,
-0.4206856191,
-0.0055718166,
-0.2112073302,
-0.3874519169,
-0.2365684509,
0.3230426311,
0.3435742259,
0.7526146173,
0.2262194902,
0.3276937306,
0.4082354009,
0.5728482008,
-0.6751520038,
0.3073313236,
-0.7061247826,
-0.0325527042,
-0.2401990592,
-0.2123647779,
-0.5225116014,
-0.4662266374,
0.0090105031,
-0.7145479918,
0.4530623257,
0.114953801,
0.7524243593,
0.6607974172,
-0.1043304875,
-0.3073079288,
-0.7616856694,
0.6724688411,
-0.3223828971,
0.044987198,
0.6541829109,
0.2428987324,
-0.1582192928,
-0.921228826,
-0.4446675777,
-0.2410840094,
-0.2425755411,
0.0102482783,
-0.0604229867,
0.1345850676,
0.4789731503,
0.3113700151,
-0.1780230552,
0.2753477693,
-0.4969402552,
-0.2362841964,
0.914460063,
-0.0473261178,
0.0460127555,
0.0102517689,
-0.1463294029,
-0.0722912252,
-0.5561543107,
-0.267332077,
0.3695906997,
0.275185585,
0.0929611474,
0.5176997185,
-0.4265328646,
0.7813817263,
0.1876395345,
-0.1105440781,
0.2741589546,
-0.1809216142,
-0.1274396032,
0.0791019276,
0.7934662104,
0.2118029892,
0.5977471471,
-0.2682694495,
-0.1684856862,
0.1522040218,
0.1678669006,
-0.7451899648,
-0.7382432818,
-0.3326827288,
-0.0724630356,
-0.7035815716,
0.0092263464,
-0.3579785228,
-0.7493448257,
-0.8106024861,
0.1776010543,
-0.1352614015,
0.1400629729,
-0.0647364557,
-0.3617053926,
-0.3290274441,
0.5309610367,
-0.9504531026,
-0.0182279181,
0.5911986828,
0.6486790776,
-0.2620856166,
-0.1959377527,
-0.2870601118,
0.1595988274,
-0.358161509,
0.7368224859,
-0.3894913793,
-0.1283727139,
0.1624857038,
0.0304163676,
0.2417824417,
-0.5933408737,
0.5159019232,
-0.5209516287,
-0.0916069746,
-0.3308341503,
-0.7053152919,
0.0354234241,
0.332826823,
-0.6019420624,
1.0832371712,
0.0127795301,
-0.9752928615,
0.7310842276,
-0.3893895149,
-0.379532963,
0.2966610193,
-0.1926140189,
-0.3871063292,
-0.0044342461,
0.2338021845,
0.8214752078,
-0.2452373207,
0.5160759687,
-0.390142709,
-0.3608134389,
0.4059638381,
-0.5299748182,
0.6957285404,
0.1621248573,
-0.1354891956,
-0.1366603523,
-0.9726549387,
-0.2737469077,
-0.1219170541,
-0.5855628252,
-0.6002885103,
0.0215860251,
0.0527132973,
0.059086021,
0.3116597235,
-0.5012230277,
0.2835433185,
-0.0864208713,
0.5704143643,
0.6627494097,
-0.045739606,
0.3764311075,
-0.3941481709,
0.1615345627,
-0.1928809583,
0.048477497,
-0.074095495,
-0.2583446205,
-0.7906922102,
-0.4989024103,
0.475551486,
0.4161005616,
-0.9701554775,
0.5578455925,
-0.1591587663,
-0.7820044756,
-0.486241281,
0.31295681,
0.1972606927,
0.5823929906,
0.5090683103,
0.1040553898,
-0.5569911599,
-0.8389267921,
-0.277739197,
-0.2185673714,
-0.2664712965,
-0.0249351691,
0.6000746489,
-0.3580911458,
1.071819663,
-0.610481739,
-0.3560266495,
0.041674085,
0.7292928696,
-0.3538743854,
0.3230867386,
0.386757791,
-0.6877481341,
-0.5067412853,
-0.0190236233,
-0.7947592139,
-0.5152648687,
-0.0878767967,
0.1431870013,
0.2922333479,
0.8162546158,
-0.0925986916,
0.4674711525,
0.1954423189,
0.0221712627,
0.429515779,
-0.2291726917,
0.2061384767,
-1.0110398531,
-0.0379463769,
0.2933493853,
-0.2956974804,
-0.4830500782,
-0.338294208,
0.0968175307,
0.2756165862,
-0.2487588376,
0.3186695278,
-0.4495718181,
0.2653148472,
-0.489446193,
0.1202878207,
0.0860218257,
0.216662243,
0.1686577052,
0.6536525488,
0.2229999602,
-0.5529639721,
0.408472836,
0.1323852241,
-0.4319091141,
0.513029933,
-0.3696216941,
0.1108436137,
-0.2489096075,
0.3490337133,
-0.9491746426,
-0.5276914835,
-0.0235108957,
-0.3164778948,
0.4204579294,
-0.2667621374,
-0.8902128935,
-0.3045568168,
-0.1897942722,
0.2339355052,
0.4242125154,
-0.6981086135,
0.2693722546,
0.4815944433,
-0.1480596662,
-0.3773108125,
-0.7671800256,
0.1257178932,
-0.3523698747,
-0.2027145922,
0.3673601747,
0.1347791553,
-0.1732652485,
-0.1096408144,
0.2247664481,
-0.1214333847,
0.2905977964,
0.459631294,
0.151912719,
0.3026894331,
0.3437948227,
0.299066335,
-0.0068957964,
0.0503314398,
-0.1746698171,
0.1313460022,
0.1500446349,
-0.2531186342,
-0.4657467306,
-0.1159172729,
0.3447522223,
0.0094282366,
0.5680727363,
0.6696872711,
-0.438893795,
-0.0780698657,
-0.7606267929,
-0.2082269937,
-0.4823662341,
0.2455022633,
-0.1163716465,
-1.1123487949,
0.4076526463,
-0.4239604771,
0.1405134499,
0.4614106417,
0.3489252627,
-0.404230386,
0.907782197,
0.7777855396,
-0.2343487889,
0.587559402,
-0.1307526529,
-0.1922256351,
-0.5687608123,
-0.0485985577,
-0.6668154597,
-0.2306154072,
-0.6882244349,
-0.3092449605,
0.3837257028,
0.2075641006,
-0.1713251919,
0.2113754898,
-0.7803840637,
0.6435480118,
0.5456237197,
0.0608152933,
0.4721245766,
0.0999025851,
0.2837178111,
0.0399547666,
-0.4085015655,
-0.7116501331,
1.1497499943,
0.2854067981,
0.8037890196,
-0.4713622034,
0.9799724817,
0.4294650853,
0.7898943424,
-0.4723789692,
0.3698168099,
-0.2848613858,
-0.5359818935,
-0.2647966146,
-0.313251853,
-0.7746025324,
0.087485753,
-0.386909306,
-0.7551777959,
-0.0369252749,
0.3839415014,
-0.2014301717,
0.1356052458,
-0.6956316233,
0.4815965593,
-0.1872073412,
-0.3651698828,
0.0540012643,
-0.464327544,
0.3144197762,
-0.5197762847,
0.304705888,
-0.0527306497,
0.1954865456,
0.9046586156,
-0.3007238507,
1.1998764277,
-0.1108132005,
-0.176321581,
0.2942818105,
-0.3009188771,
0.4951999485,
-0.0703927279,
0.0150670717,
0.2632422447,
0.0057052048,
-0.0973168239,
-0.474052012,
0.4539728165,
-0.775716722,
-0.6382597685,
-0.3532734811,
-0.4708574116,
-0.078807041,
0.0181587711,
0.4786318541,
0.0319097154,
-0.0127309766,
0.2458201051,
0.633611083,
-0.0178703964,
0.2649280131,
0.2457224578,
-0.0239287242,
-0.5261012316,
0.7092587352,
0.4145503342,
0.183974281,
0.4330037832,
0.16416879,
-0.2529471815,
-0.6552590132,
-0.434114188,
-0.1033442095,
-0.708704114,
-0.4669971466,
-0.5284651518,
-0.2959454954,
-0.3267888427,
-0.326944381,
-0.224557355,
-0.4367574155,
-0.6778810024,
-0.2424061447,
0.670219183,
0.8354175687,
-0.1604306698,
0.426754564,
-0.5914857388,
0.254824549,
0.2082140595,
0.0519522801,
-0.2663897574,
-0.5821099877,
-0.389952451,
0.2132182866,
-0.3542583883,
-0.7831938863,
0.2253065556,
0.1197300255,
0.3258764446,
0.3293774426,
0.3333132267,
0.6707237363,
-0.4397972226,
0.589684546,
0.0932138488,
-0.683976531,
0.5291087627,
-0.3375277519,
0.1443037838,
0.9350411296,
0.4254713655,
-0.2182860225,
-0.6706226468,
-0.3222261965,
-0.9176559448,
0.5510129929,
0.0284377877,
0.0455427021,
-0.0565748587,
0.6725469828,
0.2384319156,
0.2093829215,
-0.6300817132,
-0.1853498369,
0.010406455,
-0.4284346998,
-0.2796693146,
-0.2584854662,
-0.1242074221,
-0.4839286804,
0.7503896952,
-0.2715444267,
-0.3960252106,
0.1101337522,
-0.2434913367,
-0.0202957895,
0.0460113101,
0.3063495159,
0.4517404437,
-0.0183444265,
0.3472735584,
0.3178622127,
-0.4889238775,
0.2419053316,
0.4403525591,
-0.5809066296,
-0.1850596219,
0.3333148062,
0.6097127795,
0.0689328685,
-0.4028141201,
0.2097522765,
-0.0494789593,
-0.4754021764,
-0.438210845,
0.2199327052,
0.1670598537,
0.2774861157,
0.3944835067,
-0.1243529245,
0.2752793133,
-0.2159374207,
0.1881564856,
0.3635569513,
-0.2416411489,
-0.1258917898,
0.627420485,
0.18566522,
-0.0824268535,
0.3154086173,
-0.3628905416,
-0.475472182,
0.3528695703,
0.2741079926,
0.7674422264,
0.0354434215,
0.1849594116,
0.3110635579,
0.3635772467,
-0.4519605637,
-0.2269549519,
-0.2173461318,
-0.4975610077,
-0.5880271196,
-0.8831863403,
-0.4529364407,
0.188212648,
-0.6645404696,
0.3655525446,
-0.3071534932,
-0.2966658473,
0.4535711408,
-0.0374505408,
-0.6503263712,
0.2115254402,
0.3023755848,
0.6567182541,
-1.1906057596,
0.8446424603,
0.9518997669,
-0.3499700725,
-0.5118072629,
-0.1472125202,
-0.0833548829,
-0.3070976138,
0.8414233923,
0.1802918911,
-0.083934024,
0.0389536619,
-0.8141953349,
-0.7224927545,
1.1564980745,
0.4170914888,
-0.692700088,
0.2401430458,
0.4779022038,
0.817340672,
-0.037699718,
-0.0030818353,
0.6664645076,
0.3908488452,
0.0843999311,
-0.9105077386,
-0.0409507714,
-0.0427789539,
0.0743299201,
-0.0726216659,
-0.4119337201,
0.5282602906,
0.0557558872,
-0.1421137005,
-0.0834679753,
0.6627171636,
0.4162965715,
0.4420207739,
0.4611828029,
0.5429520607,
0.9761511087,
-0.2000380754,
0.5211747885,
-0.117751196,
0.2527002096,
1.2042769194,
-0.2503905296,
0.5920420289,
0.5176134706,
-0.156579107,
0.2440106571,
0.8003152013,
-0.1604762077,
0.4076813757,
0.5602369905,
-0.2517111599,
-0.2739884555,
-0.164655298,
-0.107489638,
0.3919321001,
0.353108108,
-0.487783283,
-0.0383952595,
0.1812455654,
0.0629088059,
0.3260708451,
-0.2357042879,
1.1002998352,
0.0027496016,
-0.6660158634,
0.6550732255,
-0.0006636156,
0.8821976185,
-0.1207554489,
0.0134748016,
-0.0545486249,
0.1467772871,
-0.321216017,
-0.5921584368,
0.2307174653,
0.3467650115,
-0.2784157395,
-0.3261067867,
0.9340233803,
-0.5391219258,
-0.6462312937,
0.0939036459,
0.2389251888,
0.2232603431,
-0.1087000892,
-0.346809566,
-0.0047850506,
-0.0925280079,
-0.2978548408,
0.4721549749,
0.6394693851,
-0.2341969758,
0.5926191807,
0.6584708691,
-0.0337195098,
0.0442454554,
0.1102198213,
0.9657665491,
-0.4336098731,
-0.2018688917,
-1.1264568567,
0.3491446376,
-0.3303734362,
-0.1511238366,
0.5240884423,
0.6310005188,
1.0493403673,
-0.0578383207,
1.1678044796,
0.1438183486,
0.4502851367,
-0.356366694,
0.9266790152,
-0.3246955574,
0.1704048812,
-0.3281950057,
-0.6599254012,
-0.4046748579,
0.5322999954,
-0.3653127253,
-0.0868698433,
0.2868164182,
0.5390807986,
0.1122159734,
0.0154879354,
0.1402845532,
-0.1021270379,
0.298353672,
0.2061386704,
0.9732537866,
-0.0930613875,
0.3897476792,
-0.5440974832,
-0.3583249152,
-0.1524420828,
-1.0464173555,
-1.2342318296,
-0.7173844576,
-0.7678954005,
0.0085538179,
0.0608150698,
0.7210609913,
0.6485080719,
-0.6360961795,
0.2021580637,
-0.2391409427,
-0.0734164715,
-0.0145280994,
-0.2209374905,
0.3260696828,
-0.4919787347,
-0.7777447104,
0.0140020344,
-0.0013626897,
0.362745434,
-0.3438306749,
0.1920084655,
0.030137049,
-0.2157113701,
0.6844252348,
0.0680370256,
-0.6080328822,
-0.3186658323,
-0.3455863893,
-0.1717963815,
-0.2998496294,
0.5808132291,
-0.8174599409,
0.2925139666,
0.4188089669,
0.7648888826,
0.5001447201,
0.1826539785,
0.2701414824,
-1.0420424938,
0.0625358,
0.1457941681,
0.2806302607,
0.4980522692,
-0.4192989171,
0.6093156338,
0.1873844415,
-0.6572766304,
-0.9521925449,
-0.081724517,
-0.6529523134,
-0.3271043599,
1.3419072628,
-0.2442914844,
-0.0786073953,
-0.3025779128,
-0.3301471174,
0.6545196772,
-0.2020319253,
1.1145019531,
0.8033317327,
-0.0700400919,
0.0373421162,
-0.6569469571,
0.804802835,
-0.0472220778,
-0.9718567729,
0.4226990938,
0.6409976482,
0.2527055144,
0.3843830526,
0.5671582818,
0.0857555047,
-0.1433028877,
-0.2588953376,
0.3230290115,
-0.3504270911,
-0.2247188687,
-0.0238581151,
0.1121396422,
0.2122321427,
-0.0621973127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17626v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17626v1 | CoSafe: Evaluating Large Language Model Safety in Multi-Turn Dialogue Coreference | 2024-06-25T15:13:02 | 2024-06-25T15:13:02 | Erxin Yu, Jing Li, Ming Liao, Siqi Wang, Zuchen Gao, Fei Mi, Lanqing Hong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As large language models (LLMs) constantly evolve, ensuring their safety
remains a critical research problem. Previous red-teaming approaches for LLM
safety have primarily focused on single prompt attacks or goal hijacking. To
the best of our knowledge, we are the first to study LLM safety in multi-turn
dialogue coreference. We created a dataset of 1,400 questions across 14
categories, each featuring multi-turn coreference safety attacks. We then
conducted detailed evaluations on five widely used open-source LLMs. The
results indicated that under multi-turn coreference safety attacks, the highest
attack success rate was 56% with the LLaMA2-Chat-7b model, while the lowest was
13.9% with the Mistral-7B-Instruct model. These findings highlight the safety
vulnerabilities in LLMs during dialogue coreference interactions. | [
-0.609888494,
-0.7819458842,
0.36176759,
0.275515765,
-0.0959439874,
0.0562514365,
-0.2328684628,
-0.7372442484,
-0.0637019724,
0.942661345,
-0.4765726626,
-0.5658481121,
-0.7513862252,
0.2839241922,
-0.5459000468,
1.032356143,
0.2777528465,
0.114043355,
-0.2296881229,
-0.194951117,
-0.4128049612,
-1.1259169579,
-0.70388937,
-0.1473552585,
0.3942165673,
0.4917066097,
0.6245443225,
-0.2494025677,
0.8798164725,
0.2643146217,
-0.3006754816,
-0.0138910981,
-0.6147151589,
0.2813028097,
-0.1356459409,
-0.378768146,
-0.7118080258,
0.0610818416,
0.3028562963,
0.5060752034,
-0.2317602932,
-0.1167963967,
-0.0856242925,
0.2488893718,
-0.5447029471,
-0.1045031324,
-0.916768074,
-0.1168988794,
-0.012349355,
0.1012354493,
-0.8954936266,
-0.4174923897,
0.3058659732,
-0.0999756753,
-0.0687648505,
0.3570477664,
0.5442580581,
0.0182059538,
-0.4242036641,
-0.6350886226,
-0.3752179742,
0.9454966784,
-0.7107556462,
-0.0211385824,
0.3660752773,
0.4205580354,
-0.5837087631,
-0.4207644463,
-0.5489551425,
-0.4224373102,
0.1035289019,
-0.100407891,
-0.2299009115,
0.3827516735,
0.1224802956,
0.2980227768,
-0.3295847774,
0.3248459697,
-0.0979727805,
-0.1961133182,
0.655064404,
0.2505626678,
0.4833410084,
-0.1311768442,
-0.7594749331,
-0.2090752721,
-0.8781664968,
-0.1502673775,
0.2149478048,
0.347940594,
-0.3202963769,
0.5032479763,
0.0102756312,
0.4740804434,
0.2612780035,
-0.4938079715,
-0.0593107529,
-0.6929209232,
-0.1715331823,
0.183501929,
1.0241800547,
0.6660403013,
0.4603161812,
-0.2883618474,
0.1165622994,
0.0433702171,
0.3537803888,
-0.6579790711,
0.0924304947,
0.3367211521,
0.0099517284,
-0.3359663785,
-0.0405300409,
-0.6996231079,
-0.3014305532,
0.294267118,
0.1240424737,
-0.3013688028,
-0.2881786823,
0.1911366135,
0.1745908558,
0.3789226115,
0.2084800154,
-0.6233764887,
0.3396717906,
0.8440798521,
0.7504051924,
-0.5447191596,
-0.396400094,
-0.6239050031,
0.2162515074,
-0.2685396373,
0.7097884417,
-0.2898709178,
-0.7126965523,
0.1609436423,
-0.0168086905,
-0.0723329931,
-0.4409717321,
0.5549155474,
-0.5030417442,
-0.157637015,
-0.299783498,
-0.3931986094,
-0.1740113497,
0.6942324042,
-0.590531528,
0.6770321727,
-0.5432965159,
-0.8056892753,
0.0596423671,
-0.5250945091,
-0.4859295785,
-0.2201052755,
-0.1378658563,
-0.4062567651,
-0.2682732046,
0.0336578339,
0.5375346541,
-0.494998455,
0.2908940315,
-0.5908686519,
0.0270690452,
0.4449263215,
-0.2714434564,
0.7798464298,
-0.2040275484,
-0.1656132191,
0.1537972987,
-0.4366268218,
-0.0452023931,
0.0230128076,
-0.1822494268,
-0.29451105,
-0.3675864041,
-0.2877713144,
0.3886978626,
0.1220936403,
-0.6397738457,
-0.1389685869,
-0.237961635,
0.3186763823,
0.3770286739,
0.4133824706,
0.5114746094,
-0.1503597796,
0.4118917286,
-0.005334367,
0.4323270321,
-0.1069501191,
-0.529861033,
-0.819191277,
-0.2988127768,
-0.1481707096,
0.4302169681,
-0.4599309266,
0.3481566012,
0.3124169409,
-0.7596328259,
-0.0447934493,
-0.1017061546,
0.7424568534,
0.2850244641,
0.3873997927,
-0.1045511663,
-0.3313014805,
-0.965882957,
0.043998491,
-0.2539138496,
0.4751407206,
0.3653955162,
0.5740674138,
-0.371504426,
0.783295691,
-0.4071950614,
-0.0693076998,
-0.4550688863,
0.1442041248,
0.0990240648,
0.6057890058,
0.7001278996,
-0.5524446964,
-0.4657694399,
-0.3319063485,
-0.6591799855,
0.0413465835,
0.009666861,
-0.3329695165,
0.4151364565,
0.5252341628,
-0.7454689741,
0.2697916329,
0.9662871957,
-0.1861473769,
0.6749377847,
0.2818180621,
0.1737387478,
-1.0729453564,
-0.1858326793,
-0.039520815,
-0.0972355008,
-0.9151229858,
0.173590064,
-0.1319623739,
-0.0148831615,
-0.8698028922,
0.2383595258,
-0.2855603397,
-0.0458093658,
-0.2289817184,
0.0731965899,
-0.1468173265,
0.3816616237,
0.088896364,
0.8053772449,
0.4077441692,
-0.8644447327,
0.2102496475,
0.4113847315,
-0.4905682802,
0.6196556091,
-0.856333673,
0.7250231504,
0.2774361372,
0.4001167417,
-0.9885014296,
-0.2079109251,
0.0229123998,
-0.2630372047,
0.1120971739,
0.0193557907,
-0.3623273373,
-0.1531759053,
-0.1793448627,
0.2471372038,
-0.0281011742,
-0.6514893174,
0.4620249569,
0.9224359393,
-0.3835430443,
-0.7485252619,
-0.5127886534,
0.3759773076,
-0.1361078322,
-0.9051918387,
0.0364963561,
-0.2697843015,
-0.608402133,
-0.495893836,
-0.0748551264,
-0.1582287699,
0.4531125724,
0.5329601765,
0.3036754429,
0.3602102101,
-0.2116599828,
0.0096581308,
-0.2416328639,
0.0756605566,
0.315037787,
0.8655452132,
-0.3499470949,
-0.5500997901,
-0.3795428872,
0.6183567643,
0.7991418839,
-0.1152046472,
0.8467417359,
0.1491390169,
-0.3258146346,
0.0770100355,
-0.7185699344,
-0.3124471009,
-0.4411725402,
0.494001478,
-0.2564592063,
-1.1911326647,
0.2976921201,
-0.0318315551,
0.5098670125,
0.2444016039,
0.8099014759,
-0.2760308385,
0.7360634804,
0.5859370232,
0.0701022446,
0.1290487796,
0.0466609895,
0.1289081424,
-0.5724298954,
-0.4739981592,
-0.7138774395,
0.1615603119,
-0.2398946732,
-0.4278013408,
0.8271744251,
0.1275772303,
-0.2121269703,
0.6304247975,
-0.0999997407,
0.3301522434,
0.3391932249,
-0.2450187653,
0.5120157599,
-0.1736353636,
-0.3325744271,
0.1457120031,
-0.6198351383,
-0.5262662172,
0.8467081785,
0.54921031,
1.1550968885,
0.3418727517,
0.6734489202,
0.1001198441,
0.2704025507,
-0.6268071532,
0.8134538531,
0.1224146113,
-0.8753207326,
-0.5069447756,
-0.1945040226,
-0.7723834515,
0.3038000464,
-0.5245674253,
-0.3971318603,
-0.124258697,
0.2104150802,
-0.3208269477,
0.0776321962,
-0.7402698994,
0.6069796681,
-0.5007802844,
-0.0300820824,
-0.4367525578,
-0.5014690161,
0.6476594806,
-0.1404351592,
0.2565628588,
-0.285877496,
0.2816870809,
0.7843693495,
-0.3526205719,
1.1987663507,
0.1431704611,
-0.0299334619,
0.4378777444,
0.1869586259,
0.6836244464,
0.1793898046,
-0.0908982232,
0.5453194976,
0.0292377379,
-0.1871790141,
-0.1623746753,
0.7677634358,
-0.7951697707,
-0.9605715871,
-0.5669804811,
-0.4899558127,
-0.372633189,
0.0394933857,
0.1830181777,
0.1926350147,
-0.4306372106,
0.4034819305,
0.5387073159,
-0.2613470852,
0.8250319958,
0.5653321147,
-0.0718735382,
-0.7696604133,
0.3177236021,
-0.2333157659,
0.8165295124,
0.0250827242,
0.0662326813,
-0.1844047755,
-0.6337167025,
-0.3408447504,
0.2227427661,
-0.6550796628,
-0.3645904362,
-0.8520466685,
-0.1656125337,
-0.4134373665,
-0.1514734179,
-0.5713154674,
-0.2143470198,
-0.010026589,
-0.191199556,
0.3189741671,
0.6939977407,
0.2626706362,
0.3495150506,
-0.9984524846,
-0.1957766265,
0.4649146795,
-0.1127895042,
-0.0315993764,
-0.2988629639,
-0.2434520274,
-0.2983045876,
-0.1915081739,
-0.8157633543,
0.1747400165,
-0.110169597,
0.6646991372,
0.1641833186,
0.4227293432,
0.2174483836,
-0.4956060946,
0.8662965894,
0.8772395253,
-0.7736868858,
0.1233613044,
-0.2080131024,
0.3591383696,
0.6400100589,
0.4792379141,
-0.6440825462,
-0.3486395776,
-0.4079683721,
-0.6474995613,
0.4610972404,
0.0841236487,
0.0236452073,
-0.2576524913,
0.1801139116,
0.2611426115,
0.2899349034,
-0.5666501522,
-0.2066668123,
0.1448996961,
0.0128685068,
0.0729204267,
-0.588188231,
-0.5571581721,
0.1484473646,
0.4954483509,
-0.2417655885,
0.1329637766,
0.069236353,
-0.2681389749,
-0.0079998896,
0.4219781458,
0.7951709032,
0.444103837,
0.061937917,
0.3709437251,
0.5931360126,
-0.589096725,
0.1764913648,
-0.4913944304,
-0.007311753,
-0.2494699955,
0.5450093746,
0.706204772,
0.5175861716,
-0.6820643544,
0.3915840387,
-0.1384115964,
-0.0969050974,
-0.4848348796,
0.2477964908,
0.1495618671,
0.147296831,
0.2424576879,
0.0138410926,
-0.3359247446,
-0.6095555425,
0.1284435093,
0.7339391112,
-0.2581647038,
-0.3539104164,
-0.024660714,
0.7233658433,
-0.3109236062,
0.1757194698,
0.1108500734,
-0.8006922007,
0.4149097502,
0.5888538957,
0.8639246225,
-0.2410716861,
0.0328701809,
0.4437455833,
0.5296123624,
-0.0054187146,
-0.060661681,
0.3267249167,
-0.8985430002,
-0.3568701148,
-0.4865069091,
-1.1995466948,
0.1445812732,
-0.5359038115,
0.1589802951,
-0.6629053354,
-0.530090034,
-0.2473839372,
-0.2522197664,
-0.2208459079,
0.1172909811,
0.1515681446,
0.9286695123,
-0.5513449311,
0.6473394036,
0.5492805243,
-0.0794552863,
-0.4211708903,
-0.0598868579,
0.0724270195,
-0.6163294315,
0.5567675829,
0.0463383347,
-0.4266587794,
-0.3603964746,
-0.6964150071,
-0.9137498736,
1.0196669102,
0.4636838436,
-0.8895640969,
-0.0328119807,
0.3311097324,
0.1774520129,
-0.5390120149,
0.1173006892,
0.5860401988,
0.3568931222,
0.1592682004,
-1.3252264261,
-0.1647763103,
0.4105115533,
-0.4253987372,
0.0306518413,
-1.0173572302,
0.7147112489,
-0.3056062162,
-0.1941791624,
-0.1096674874,
0.5841972828,
0.4939119816,
0.244596228,
0.7667369246,
0.5782529116,
0.7523870468,
-0.0208794344,
0.9342791438,
-0.3548186123,
0.3058882356,
1.3454903364,
-0.4540966451,
0.9776028395,
0.4621370137,
0.0348302238,
0.2745289803,
0.2095977366,
0.408831954,
0.4064040184,
-0.0912957489,
-0.2571270168,
-0.5755932927,
-0.1198135391,
-0.2744255364,
0.4270866513,
0.3794414699,
-0.0468510948,
-0.1044865847,
0.0758657157,
0.572922647,
-0.0991180018,
-0.2000437379,
0.8472536206,
0.4703205526,
-0.8411669135,
0.5237402916,
-0.1126064882,
0.7481941581,
-0.3597049415,
0.2468683422,
-0.1448023021,
0.211223498,
-0.1913045645,
-0.8672611713,
0.2878625691,
0.1920826137,
-0.1449348927,
0.277648896,
0.746226728,
-0.3456881344,
-0.1349168718,
0.5975117683,
0.2502219677,
-0.0566945225,
0.0437066071,
-0.5409497023,
0.5094012022,
-0.2206593305,
0.0450156406,
0.571624577,
-0.2143345922,
-0.0867206603,
0.7890948057,
0.5327486396,
-0.330637753,
0.211994037,
-0.0797869638,
0.7923881412,
-0.7011647224,
-0.2458812594,
-0.8073206544,
0.1761849076,
-0.1979973912,
-0.2800376415,
0.8826963305,
0.0882982537,
0.6295129061,
0.0507736318,
0.6659862995,
0.2670561373,
0.3938582242,
-0.5358577371,
0.809923768,
0.0928932503,
0.1143078059,
-0.3813432157,
-0.7360292673,
-0.0885934532,
0.232879132,
-0.3846275806,
-0.2865353525,
0.8731817007,
0.7979337573,
0.5244448185,
0.41118747,
0.4412861764,
0.3250546753,
0.6817784309,
0.618701458,
0.8784394264,
-0.1088261828,
0.8519549966,
-0.1888781041,
-0.2916457653,
-0.296454072,
-0.9454040527,
-1.4993058443,
-0.2741461694,
-0.3917141855,
-0.678237915,
0.0425420254,
1.1439212561,
0.7511897087,
-1.0273983479,
-0.3942676187,
0.1392489821,
0.0090787662,
0.1004600525,
-0.0768092871,
0.0512052476,
-0.216594547,
-0.852332294,
0.7605364919,
0.4776143432,
-0.0489360951,
-0.4735893011,
-0.2606370747,
-0.4676452279,
0.1879592091,
0.6460711956,
0.1951564848,
-0.6731912494,
-0.5589975715,
0.0581614152,
-0.4684504271,
-0.1385579854,
0.7034264207,
-0.1453693807,
0.1451595873,
0.3387742043,
0.7911961675,
0.3633761108,
-0.0930369943,
0.5878255367,
-0.3224397898,
0.1000493318,
0.2841577232,
0.2995908558,
0.3938295841,
-0.2995730042,
0.4637121856,
0.249541074,
-0.6272932291,
-0.9142987728,
0.4234073162,
-1.2661030293,
0.0739062726,
1.571796298,
-0.3947131932,
-0.2232936174,
-0.4228221476,
-0.257321775,
0.0266800225,
-0.5298316479,
0.541426003,
0.869304657,
-0.2144807726,
-0.067084007,
-0.1910592616,
0.3167463243,
0.4082981944,
-0.8958209157,
0.009840549,
0.299985975,
0.4246722758,
0.5632169247,
0.2956370413,
-0.1365400255,
0.2972116768,
-0.1749076247,
0.1741195619,
-0.185659349,
-0.5029386878,
-0.0240338221,
0.5977464914,
0.2200557142,
-0.0627523735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17624v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17624v1 | Self-assessment, Exhibition, and Recognition: a Review of Personality in Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T15:08:44 | 2024-06-25T15:08:44 | Zhiyuan Wen, Yu Yang, Jiannong Cao, Haoming Sun, Ruosong Yang, Shuaiqi Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As large language models (LLMs) appear to behave increasingly human-like in
text-based interactions, more and more researchers become interested in
investigating personality in LLMs. However, the diversity of psychological
personality research and the rapid development of LLMs have led to a broad yet
fragmented landscape of studies in this interdisciplinary field. Extensive
studies across different research focuses, different personality psychometrics,
and different LLMs make it challenging to have a holistic overview and further
pose difficulties in applying findings to real-world applications. In this
paper, we present a comprehensive review by categorizing current studies into
three research problems: self-assessment, exhibition, and recognition, based on
the intrinsic characteristics and external manifestations of personality in
LLMs. For each problem, we provide a thorough analysis and conduct in-depth
comparisons of their corresponding solutions. Besides, we summarize research
findings and open challenges from current studies and further discuss their
underlying causes. We also collect extensive publicly available resources to
facilitate interested researchers and developers. Lastly, we discuss the
potential future research directions and application scenarios. Our paper is
the first comprehensive survey of up-to-date literature on personality in LLMs.
By presenting a clear taxonomy, in-depth analysis, promising future directions,
and extensive resource collections, we aim to provide a better understanding
and facilitate further advancements in this emerging field. | [
-0.6057719588,
-0.5301702023,
0.8189172149,
0.4093530178,
-0.1410512775,
0.3265688419,
-0.4880002439,
-0.7021028996,
0.4669864476,
0.373896271,
-0.5188658237,
-0.124079138,
-0.7371989489,
0.2614166439,
-0.6428290009,
0.5286112428,
-0.2086486816,
0.1490338296,
-0.3775296509,
-0.3083357215,
-0.2834202051,
-0.8254492283,
-0.613263011,
-0.4411561787,
0.6887378693,
0.1596408486,
0.1232375354,
0.0944112539,
0.5681601167,
0.3811952174,
-0.1203596592,
-0.1376321763,
-0.3173841238,
0.2953111529,
-0.3990225792,
-0.1171782017,
-0.3070817888,
0.174142912,
0.7884562612,
0.6594982147,
0.2286902368,
0.2303296775,
0.1152352318,
0.7759665847,
-0.514817059,
0.0144936442,
-0.075816825,
0.0316495784,
-0.5298156738,
0.0300990026,
-0.2987884283,
-0.2613020241,
0.3222494423,
0.2154978514,
-0.0867040902,
0.0122509524,
0.4337092638,
-0.3285975158,
-0.728936553,
-0.3872474134,
-0.9824897647,
0.8374099731,
-0.539332509,
0.2305126488,
-0.0880744234,
0.4094038606,
0.0304099265,
-0.3505790532,
-0.6030964851,
-0.2756862938,
-0.0511609986,
0.08062841,
-0.254876703,
-0.3730778694,
0.0417078361,
0.6744542122,
-0.5346471071,
0.4088020325,
-0.1686585546,
-0.1126600653,
0.9792795181,
0.409201026,
0.2282517999,
-0.031189492,
-0.1399483085,
-0.1191452593,
-0.8352040052,
-0.0440113544,
0.5393173099,
0.006161395,
-0.0454414599,
0.4674817026,
-0.5179956555,
0.3535147905,
0.13086088,
-0.26130265,
0.2946273685,
-0.2841354609,
0.0588547327,
-0.2955088019,
1.0257438421,
0.232818529,
0.3381190896,
0.0250523463,
-0.1103770509,
-0.3069148064,
0.1226920336,
-0.8020570874,
0.1868981868,
0.5693035722,
-0.6625239253,
-0.1339693069,
-0.0230225548,
-0.9069775343,
-0.6708003283,
-0.3466765285,
0.2422703505,
-0.0901331306,
-0.6113556027,
-0.0969717652,
0.3264521956,
0.4039577246,
0.4557973146,
-0.8264570236,
0.2080590874,
0.6265818477,
0.723933816,
-0.6516520977,
-0.3427456319,
0.0767182261,
-0.1496628076,
-0.2919591069,
0.8502343893,
-0.3460299671,
-0.4172722697,
0.226081714,
-0.0035935738,
0.2422442883,
-0.5348693132,
0.3144482374,
-0.2382836938,
0.261648953,
-0.5832884312,
-0.407910347,
-0.0269535854,
0.4638855159,
-0.3614577055,
0.6501082778,
0.072790131,
-0.6034777761,
0.0623958707,
-0.4006102085,
-0.2288954854,
0.270996809,
-0.4494751692,
-0.1539799571,
0.2012874782,
-0.224401325,
0.9201669693,
-0.1180201992,
0.2606363595,
-0.3840034306,
-0.0430612713,
0.6612276435,
-0.0401088782,
0.4337264895,
0.1245884523,
-0.2588608861,
0.2871037126,
-0.7611956596,
-0.042313356,
0.2962575555,
-0.1852021515,
-0.2537867129,
0.2166693062,
0.1815473735,
0.3509747982,
0.6545888186,
-0.6060417891,
0.2764132619,
-0.3026328683,
0.3845131099,
0.6888269186,
-0.1897072196,
0.3390884101,
-0.0957652777,
0.5270911455,
-0.07394927,
0.1695518941,
-0.0800296962,
-0.2766244113,
-0.6132488847,
-0.1882772893,
-0.0875055492,
0.2562068403,
-0.0847192332,
0.5416892767,
-0.101590395,
-0.9430735707,
-0.2530402541,
0.1257285327,
0.4012938142,
-0.0101463655,
0.0175138675,
-0.6261809468,
-0.4513497651,
-1.0824028254,
-0.3467583656,
-0.1617763788,
-0.00974961,
0.532528162,
0.6628745794,
-0.3597971797,
0.7252303362,
-0.4000200033,
-0.3442265391,
-0.4450098276,
-0.0569159612,
0.0869593471,
0.1693039984,
0.6248394251,
-0.5020195842,
-0.6507205963,
0.067587167,
-0.6133066416,
0.0809618458,
0.2248241752,
0.1130539551,
0.1876156181,
0.3633244336,
-0.5812263489,
0.2902131975,
0.4394369423,
-0.3279069364,
0.8031234741,
0.0521239266,
-0.0274370965,
-0.6799693108,
0.1148883477,
0.0438757427,
-0.0078647388,
-0.6448555589,
0.2406013608,
-0.0885131061,
0.1878869832,
-0.3131348789,
1.0445964336,
-0.5914208889,
-0.2908062935,
-0.4887125194,
0.2080124021,
-0.1097257957,
0.2205388248,
0.1943486631,
0.4978753328,
0.6125325561,
-0.5442309976,
0.4873526096,
0.3290750682,
-0.5860358477,
0.8697680831,
-0.488953054,
0.2079260051,
-0.1212318763,
0.1460694969,
-1.0310485363,
-0.4731897414,
0.2023686767,
-0.1792285442,
0.5884947777,
0.1636814922,
-0.4351204634,
-0.4780323505,
-0.4043480158,
0.1491555125,
0.4741377532,
-0.4555926621,
0.7730137706,
0.3249836266,
-0.5472288132,
-0.2542859018,
-0.4169005752,
0.177027598,
-0.4458105862,
-0.3380440474,
0.288433075,
-0.4886631966,
-0.7174196839,
-0.5992321372,
-0.0704697594,
-0.0343153253,
0.1703738421,
-0.0050686602,
0.0675618276,
0.0601535179,
-0.0049186894,
-0.4723369181,
0.1348641366,
0.2975765467,
0.2813508809,
0.5203800797,
-0.5690507889,
-0.3849858642,
-0.3486766219,
0.4151825309,
0.5748305321,
-0.1026840135,
0.5947157145,
0.7755538225,
-0.0200241525,
0.0788182095,
-0.8341351151,
0.0253963601,
-0.4434203207,
0.5432447791,
-0.3449988365,
-1.0103726387,
0.5866219401,
-0.0065274062,
-0.0734300613,
0.3385053277,
1.0302333832,
-0.3468662202,
0.9309063554,
0.6757284999,
0.0300126839,
0.4857679307,
0.0591813289,
0.4173590839,
-1.1514246464,
-0.4664717615,
-0.4455595613,
-0.3837527037,
-0.5850098729,
0.1149302423,
0.0864345208,
-0.3552927375,
-0.2415058762,
0.1548564434,
-0.5019191504,
0.1774712503,
0.0293273441,
-0.1468062848,
0.2883173525,
-0.2811854184,
0.2741915882,
-0.2652091384,
0.0484104268,
-0.7946072221,
1.1625266075,
0.6335834861,
0.9651164412,
0.5579500198,
0.6148824096,
-0.0294980034,
0.6694127917,
-0.9098810554,
0.726985991,
0.0641192198,
-0.8078629375,
-0.3257471919,
-0.1915752441,
-0.8138722181,
0.2908152342,
-0.0770070329,
-1.2303807735,
0.109056972,
-0.0016330415,
-0.0776161104,
0.0504287519,
-0.4960437417,
0.6825826764,
-0.5993677378,
-0.358296603,
-0.0938498303,
-0.5095864534,
0.7093031406,
-0.4353398681,
0.2350103706,
-0.4417976737,
0.0218905192,
0.7964019179,
0.1473965496,
0.7147805691,
-0.0338522233,
-0.4743844569,
0.0925644413,
0.3865184188,
0.2213143557,
-0.178007111,
0.1650617868,
0.1566061378,
0.4220246971,
-0.0378078632,
-0.6910148263,
0.7679488659,
-0.6645354629,
-0.8620658517,
-0.6474180222,
-0.3181479275,
-0.5769677162,
0.1132105291,
-0.1799929291,
0.3572486639,
-0.479663372,
0.2283471078,
0.5550237298,
-0.3501217961,
0.4107701778,
0.7473753095,
-0.5887414813,
-0.0936984196,
0.787460506,
-0.0332038738,
0.2714253068,
0.1846870035,
0.2767546475,
-0.5043132305,
-0.8167005181,
0.0327757634,
0.6506540179,
-0.7545785904,
0.3519822955,
-0.5567500591,
-0.1030697376,
-0.5693405867,
0.1490310282,
-0.4413539171,
-0.0298276264,
-0.3657229543,
0.2815680802,
0.0546884388,
1.1022999287,
0.3534192741,
0.3894441128,
-0.4025043845,
0.0282815285,
0.3782207072,
0.5848050117,
0.4065063,
-0.5157124996,
-0.1317130327,
-0.520801127,
-0.5626809001,
-0.7916565537,
0.4054067433,
-0.0313735232,
0.7049454451,
0.8460671306,
-0.2928581238,
0.348539412,
-0.4172993004,
0.7974036932,
0.1222570091,
-0.7490486503,
0.3701948225,
-0.3611790836,
-0.0351286829,
0.5336948633,
0.6819084883,
-0.6215440035,
-0.0814151987,
-0.6075322032,
-0.6089708805,
0.3830357492,
0.175656572,
0.301836729,
0.0420094095,
0.4063490629,
-0.0396617129,
0.4293145835,
-0.9575494528,
-0.322148025,
0.0937124565,
-0.1736570001,
-0.1999124289,
-0.3995960057,
-0.0964703262,
-0.3207058907,
0.6291856766,
-0.3037755787,
0.3763213754,
0.1390228271,
0.1301287711,
0.142018348,
0.57168293,
0.4994906187,
0.7815933824,
-0.3259771168,
-0.0538692921,
-0.0284516495,
-0.3242848516,
0.2096244246,
-0.2856295407,
0.1974430829,
-0.2757644951,
0.3698630929,
0.4351516962,
0.2021194249,
-0.8634598851,
0.7730827332,
0.0113284942,
-0.05917551,
-0.7413083315,
-0.0343739763,
0.3066318631,
0.3697657585,
0.3049655557,
-0.3746677339,
0.0919995531,
-1.0014871359,
-0.3711469173,
0.7643505931,
-0.3259957433,
-0.4975431859,
0.2268879414,
0.2148009241,
-0.3082031012,
0.2391963601,
-0.3046678007,
-0.3767669201,
0.4461831748,
0.245569855,
0.9230909348,
-0.240369156,
-0.0403938405,
0.2357816249,
0.0516407453,
-0.1213041842,
0.2019379884,
-0.0089564249,
-0.8717577457,
-0.2506758571,
-0.8142901063,
-0.7471511364,
0.4657789767,
-0.3945428431,
0.1399233043,
-0.5211382508,
-0.0699220002,
-0.0414105393,
0.2868520319,
-0.5793287754,
-0.0707814917,
0.4468978941,
0.7692625523,
-0.6629327536,
0.4969570041,
0.723493576,
-0.237718761,
-0.4021733105,
-0.1503745764,
0.1454814374,
-0.5117698908,
0.7791307569,
0.1904444993,
0.1610871106,
-0.119136408,
-0.4310947955,
-1.0145517588,
0.9571509361,
-0.0420208871,
-0.4552068114,
-0.1020897031,
-0.1911160499,
0.6586992145,
-0.5866635442,
0.5528343916,
0.7653212547,
0.6850515008,
0.1107555926,
-0.7960878015,
-0.1632797718,
-0.1068074554,
0.059984792,
-0.0354110561,
-1.0765545368,
0.6561050415,
0.0971771181,
-0.2457211316,
0.5803017616,
0.6780646443,
0.4033330083,
0.124931857,
0.2249165624,
0.1899255961,
0.4326315522,
-0.1684567779,
0.9159024954,
-0.1683958471,
0.3470776379,
0.9118353128,
-0.7582185268,
0.9634276628,
0.3698633611,
-0.6872239113,
0.784273386,
0.7157343626,
-0.336771965,
0.170690015,
0.2351283878,
-0.3025620878,
-0.1015303954,
-0.0535041429,
-0.0975025147,
0.6189156771,
0.4574727714,
-0.2958880067,
-0.204780221,
0.1468981057,
-0.0623659901,
0.054350283,
-0.2592453659,
0.4858859777,
0.106363669,
-0.6071713567,
-0.1545753032,
0.025165759,
0.95858109,
-0.7422772646,
0.272456497,
-0.1543519944,
0.0501852557,
-0.3051552773,
-1.1287875175,
0.3789059818,
-0.1694685966,
0.0129483212,
-0.6320289373,
0.9341782928,
-0.1348042786,
-0.1056803688,
0.341912061,
0.7303577065,
0.5492132902,
-0.2223635018,
-0.4802572131,
0.1929871291,
-0.324644953,
-0.3877780139,
0.7606508136,
0.1409580559,
0.1291653961,
0.8868939281,
0.2717783451,
0.0074497066,
-0.2514646053,
0.1410041451,
0.3581437469,
-0.8659477234,
-0.2618081272,
-0.8973916769,
0.1466109455,
0.0672783479,
-0.4140796661,
1.0065701008,
0.3869411349,
0.5929538608,
-0.1474856585,
0.5874837041,
-0.1202813089,
0.5830581188,
-0.2344461977,
0.7048752308,
-0.514493227,
-0.0946374163,
-0.530389607,
-0.8235378861,
0.0583964325,
0.520432353,
-0.4858825505,
0.456574738,
0.6718645096,
0.3915527165,
0.291603893,
-0.144471705,
0.3769794703,
0.4556870759,
0.2112510651,
0.4528612792,
1.1451895237,
-0.0273802988,
0.0357056819,
-0.184173435,
-0.26178056,
-0.4243342578,
-0.9124786258,
-1.1493655443,
-0.7569890618,
-0.5147063732,
-0.1970043629,
-0.6146935225,
0.7108527422,
0.5890907049,
-0.4846699238,
-0.3653834164,
0.4128822684,
0.112793453,
0.1038828641,
-0.2740985751,
0.1611238122,
0.0374350771,
-0.7034925818,
0.261028707,
0.4344585836,
0.2932715714,
-1.2571296692,
0.1107487977,
0.0611946397,
0.1304342449,
0.9259072542,
0.4442985356,
-0.9499403238,
-0.3880259991,
-0.0872823745,
-0.0051932479,
0.0705063716,
0.8155166507,
-0.5284436345,
0.2362299263,
0.3365216851,
0.4552962184,
0.3463831544,
-0.3256183267,
0.2507105768,
-0.5350495577,
-0.3451728821,
0.1959943771,
0.5302006602,
0.564076066,
-0.435088098,
0.3956097364,
0.2475554943,
-0.5199874043,
-0.7994097471,
0.5695204735,
-1.2336165905,
-0.1478476524,
1.2482559681,
0.0444737636,
-0.2037617713,
-0.1070316657,
-0.0553922541,
-0.2817369699,
0.0618899539,
0.7903642058,
1.1814054251,
-0.6109318733,
-0.1650117338,
-0.524784565,
0.2703346014,
0.2598777413,
-0.8954558372,
0.0779782087,
0.2959088385,
0.5981703401,
0.4490194619,
0.81425488,
-0.4133605957,
-0.1144763306,
-0.6953957081,
0.3031039238,
0.3799154758,
-0.2124758214,
-0.5724523664,
0.1848095655,
0.495218128,
0.6324961782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17618v1 | Towards Building an End-to-End Multilingual Automatic Lyrics Transcription Model | 2024-06-25T15:02:32 | 2024-06-25T15:02:32 | Jiawen Huang, Emmanouil Benetos | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Multilingual automatic lyrics transcription (ALT) is a challenging task due
to the limited availability of labelled data and the challenges introduced by
singing, compared to multilingual automatic speech recognition. Although some
multilingual singing datasets have been released recently, English continues to
dominate these collections. Multilingual ALT remains underexplored due to the
scale of data and annotation quality. In this paper, we aim to create a
multilingual ALT system with available datasets. Inspired by architectures that
have been proven effective for English ALT, we adapt these techniques to the
multilingual scenario by expanding the target vocabulary set. We then evaluate
the performance of the multilingual model in comparison to its monolingual
counterparts. Additionally, we explore various conditioning methods to
incorporate language information into the model. We apply analysis by language
and combine it with the language classification performance. Our findings
reveal that the multilingual model performs consistently better than the
monolingual models trained on the language subsets. Furthermore, we demonstrate
that incorporating language information significantly enhances performance. | [
-0.2211655527,
-0.2980416417,
0.1139595807,
0.2257590294,
-0.2522028089,
0.4337735176,
-0.5129516721,
-0.8707209826,
0.3054960668,
0.4829799533,
-0.5668809414,
-0.5290700793,
-0.3751662672,
0.5062385201,
-0.3744635582,
1.1299302578,
-0.1282080263,
0.0480864681,
0.0648821592,
-0.2535606027,
-0.1627374589,
-0.5208642483,
-0.7699908018,
0.1472447664,
0.5745992661,
0.2828602493,
0.7085031271,
0.3389945924,
0.2675914168,
0.30796808,
-0.0527852699,
0.2728862166,
-0.4318056107,
0.2548970282,
0.1708821952,
-0.4396005869,
-0.2781752348,
0.0116220256,
0.7292448282,
0.4522396326,
-0.148770541,
0.4416819513,
-0.1337304413,
0.272872597,
-0.0028116298,
0.0354644582,
-0.8936659098,
0.0607753545,
-0.193896696,
0.0040575974,
-0.4334792495,
-0.1185157448,
0.0157013368,
-0.6044692397,
0.0998253301,
0.2765751481,
0.948636055,
0.2416075021,
-0.3774442077,
-0.5736595392,
-0.788392067,
0.6789793372,
-0.5538827777,
0.7638827562,
0.1592611074,
0.5754572749,
0.3835655153,
-0.5015799999,
-0.3578868806,
-0.3406671286,
-0.1399955153,
0.1646704823,
-0.0354465395,
0.0246546753,
-0.0528976694,
0.2891516387,
-0.5007333159,
-0.0586701818,
-0.6346325278,
-0.2456223071,
0.5473339558,
-0.3776864707,
0.6707190871,
-0.2114555091,
-0.542252183,
0.1134266183,
-0.7521721125,
0.2911303937,
0.7394684553,
0.9230818748,
-0.0517701767,
0.4572156072,
0.2529903948,
0.7755644917,
-0.3135462701,
-0.1540345997,
0.397003442,
-0.1928573549,
-0.0457730293,
0.2465116382,
0.6571356654,
0.0438424535,
0.2724387944,
-0.6709316969,
-0.4569760859,
0.0077771,
0.0228629373,
-0.4036668539,
0.1390770823,
0.2166230232,
-0.35508582,
0.1499828696,
-0.1501785219,
-0.3151780367,
0.0756576434,
-0.8713525534,
0.5399182439,
-0.4583741426,
-0.241757229,
0.1108406782,
-0.0041908505,
-0.2152076662,
-0.0161701143,
-0.4537097514,
0.1408822238,
0.3960764706,
0.7721055746,
0.0234540813,
-0.468144536,
-0.4113692641,
0.2512392402,
-0.2610254586,
0.5433800817,
-0.4698672891,
0.0767454356,
0.0370843336,
0.1905751526,
-0.2465405762,
-0.2220607698,
0.5406780839,
-0.6185142994,
0.338560313,
-0.173069492,
-0.5805665255,
-0.350400418,
0.0327385962,
-1.0634305477,
0.7200610638,
0.1552987397,
-0.4177180827,
0.1048090532,
-0.5387886763,
-0.553096652,
-0.1446084231,
-0.0511444211,
-0.3304442167,
0.1701754779,
0.1719811708,
0.2921975255,
-0.3309802115,
0.1417951435,
0.0381162837,
-0.3865224123,
0.4144208133,
-0.4642026126,
0.7350350022,
0.4283463657,
-0.0538542047,
-0.1376108527,
-0.7610387802,
0.1545880437,
-0.2140426487,
-0.4162434638,
-0.2108659297,
-0.1514147669,
0.6280109286,
0.5614789724,
0.3463386595,
-0.6614726186,
0.1267336309,
-0.2962764502,
0.2808947563,
0.4074585736,
-0.2473398149,
0.1522054076,
-0.3430745304,
0.9418559074,
-0.3217667937,
0.0866079256,
-0.0304535683,
-0.2558758259,
-0.3926773369,
-0.3502460718,
0.6294608116,
0.778920114,
-0.8728208542,
0.1901895851,
-0.421079129,
-0.1746972501,
-1.3601667881,
0.491016686,
0.667140305,
0.2783688903,
0.5353000164,
0.1113664657,
-0.7332779765,
-0.9771084189,
-0.2617634535,
-0.1169055849,
0.0739938468,
0.263533473,
-0.0192402527,
0.0653719306,
0.4938153625,
0.025810156,
-0.5034678578,
-0.6021650434,
0.1712490171,
0.5815794468,
0.3476409912,
0.7537392974,
-0.9032294154,
-0.9050881267,
0.2222173214,
-0.4460511804,
-0.2333776653,
-0.3668917716,
-0.2708620429,
0.0935209543,
0.4094467759,
-0.4248439372,
0.0045205485,
0.7458592653,
-0.2637776434,
0.4862398505,
0.0708874464,
0.4046186209,
-1.1862391233,
0.1755078733,
-0.3722569346,
-0.3268966079,
-0.881768465,
0.0670359209,
0.1634771526,
-0.0106013166,
-0.4452519119,
0.2982691824,
-0.6434727311,
-0.2402990311,
-0.2083402723,
0.0142008187,
0.037846189,
0.465033561,
0.1278176606,
0.7365190387,
0.7819882631,
-0.3693357408,
0.4897944927,
0.0735137239,
-0.4906725287,
0.514392972,
-0.6281309128,
-0.0068020769,
-0.4620402455,
-0.0551112778,
-1.1998745203,
-0.1149451137,
-0.1106765792,
-0.7101169825,
0.8758661151,
-0.40588817,
-0.6048803329,
-0.2789919972,
0.1658263057,
0.4287468493,
0.5112575889,
-0.5917505026,
0.4139209688,
0.2547859848,
-0.2729174197,
-0.5898506641,
-0.5061303377,
0.4505626261,
-0.3852007091,
-0.3610176742,
0.4143622518,
-0.0770864412,
0.0110706771,
-0.0133083332,
0.1776535511,
0.0287554879,
-0.1231836677,
-0.2306102216,
0.1582894921,
-0.19193618,
0.6097401381,
0.0981246084,
-0.0950383097,
-0.1396321654,
-0.3954158127,
0.3607024252,
-0.0204132888,
-0.3666433096,
-0.4520079792,
0.6418142915,
0.6961995959,
-0.490144521,
0.6218752265,
0.5870273113,
-0.4108204842,
-0.2005676031,
-0.433796674,
0.2963341177,
-0.3679594696,
0.3647480309,
-0.5496807694,
-0.388908267,
0.6907459497,
0.2352519631,
0.3756562471,
0.2951842546,
0.2281826586,
-0.2780694664,
1.0379772186,
0.3939941823,
-0.2103075832,
0.2960318923,
-0.2531574667,
0.0288332868,
-0.9011628032,
-0.059828423,
-0.6354197264,
-0.5817834735,
-0.5433775187,
-0.4114366174,
0.6721060872,
0.1132186875,
0.0658755824,
0.5265491009,
-0.4307647645,
0.3224155307,
0.4015851021,
0.1641577035,
0.2109481245,
0.1585915983,
-0.1100247875,
0.0190402828,
-0.5717692375,
-0.38157022,
1.0842972994,
0.2365360707,
0.6711155176,
0.5128318667,
0.6604061723,
-0.0552133173,
0.4913616478,
-0.5245831609,
-0.072210975,
-0.4895127118,
-0.8241046071,
-0.4760046005,
-0.3826344013,
-0.6876745224,
0.1951222271,
0.0453726947,
-0.4544044435,
-0.1924732924,
0.261708647,
-0.2510965466,
0.3364390433,
-0.48272264,
0.6164318919,
-0.7083678246,
-0.239130944,
0.4048056901,
-0.7971524,
0.1082454771,
-0.0239720959,
0.8986859322,
-0.1133613437,
-0.1746420264,
0.6435832381,
-0.0966716856,
0.7700978518,
-0.1564246118,
-0.3516322076,
0.1871550679,
-0.1042311937,
0.502048552,
-0.150153324,
-0.168313399,
-0.1306340098,
-0.1125237569,
-0.231625706,
-0.6038921475,
0.4858029783,
-0.9101451635,
-0.0625694618,
0.1477220654,
-0.5483266711,
-0.3760990202,
0.1046264842,
0.4204468429,
0.5001093149,
0.0692769065,
0.2808443308,
0.4859787524,
-0.2380908132,
0.3162022829,
0.5721540451,
-0.5173363686,
-0.7207257152,
0.8664522171,
0.3452798426,
0.5754290223,
0.753552556,
0.1038430855,
-0.6790565848,
-0.26880005,
-0.910852313,
0.2901720405,
-0.9059243202,
-0.274300009,
-0.692579329,
-0.1220104769,
-0.57913059,
0.1082462594,
-0.4325483143,
-0.653203845,
-0.188259989,
-0.2151942998,
0.5410186648,
0.5028550625,
-0.1430605203,
0.2775420547,
-0.7987035513,
0.5450835228,
0.0027241758,
0.4930492043,
-0.1036924571,
-0.7861061692,
-0.5925411582,
0.1014711782,
0.2020586431,
-1.1250121593,
0.3215164542,
0.7136423588,
0.573635757,
0.151425615,
-0.0595447831,
0.887547791,
-0.6798481345,
0.5483829975,
0.2086786479,
-0.8235926032,
0.2107821405,
-0.1033922285,
0.2757873535,
0.6694356799,
0.5823966861,
-0.957254529,
-0.5184344649,
-0.2208890319,
-0.9474323392,
0.5137354136,
0.1995785385,
0.1916459203,
0.1640802324,
0.3388667405,
0.4029737115,
0.464845717,
-1.0766906738,
-0.3092405498,
-0.252248019,
-0.5753626227,
-0.4750905931,
0.1901167184,
0.0946409404,
-0.3405474722,
0.8985676765,
-0.1356598437,
0.0354502089,
0.1008033603,
-0.2310507745,
-0.2793609202,
0.3084708452,
0.1893082708,
0.2568538487,
0.0638360456,
0.0375867747,
-0.093238771,
-0.09998741,
0.1999730468,
0.1887432933,
-0.3155204654,
0.3048195243,
0.5439304709,
1.1023476124,
0.4808281064,
-0.7221167088,
0.1616056412,
0.0528080389,
0.092569761,
-0.3682658076,
-0.347063899,
0.2309118807,
-0.1710536182,
0.2680513561,
-0.112596266,
0.2623794973,
-0.524328351,
0.3233622611,
0.429645896,
-0.5028737187,
-0.3035532236,
0.7563894987,
-0.1566349864,
-0.2271580994,
0.3427652717,
-0.071839571,
-0.9589883089,
0.546418786,
0.5925267935,
0.8230788112,
-0.670429647,
0.0699786171,
0.4554300904,
0.639750123,
0.2621141076,
0.6680014729,
-0.1359287798,
-0.2772479057,
-0.5795695186,
-0.8897575736,
-0.0950309783,
-0.0252596419,
-0.7125815153,
0.3431806862,
0.3143833876,
0.0653296933,
-0.1972539425,
-0.2758127153,
-0.8969271183,
0.4321342409,
0.1263309121,
0.8366897702,
-1.059512496,
0.4770916104,
0.7602646947,
-0.2347389311,
-0.7628635764,
-0.4217664301,
-0.2425686121,
-0.8083016276,
0.563097477,
0.3158656657,
-0.0776104555,
-0.0590916015,
-0.3576811552,
-1.3302946091,
0.7134106159,
0.1832428277,
-0.5576479435,
-0.1605263054,
0.4829513133,
0.8474217653,
-0.4795716107,
0.1154922098,
0.2781664729,
0.5359044075,
0.4132245779,
-1.0547809601,
-0.4241791964,
-0.4334630072,
-0.2273983806,
0.1374180913,
-0.5186908245,
1.0662078857,
-0.0061778333,
-0.2457730472,
0.3053201139,
0.5850586295,
-0.138704136,
0.1224663407,
0.5879730582,
0.5305297971,
0.6133881807,
-0.0733723417,
0.8869244456,
-0.7356939316,
0.2443462908,
1.2746050358,
-0.3077081442,
0.8492487669,
0.4189054668,
-0.1855802685,
0.1823559552,
0.707185328,
0.2634069622,
0.615378201,
0.345510751,
-0.2100133151,
-0.3368912935,
-0.0782680884,
-0.2520483732,
0.5180833936,
0.3563552499,
-0.6209407449,
-0.1121110842,
0.2649554312,
-0.0753152668,
0.0823953599,
-0.1840426624,
0.850373745,
-0.1775643826,
-0.7643380165,
0.5231359601,
-0.1100496799,
0.4171388447,
-0.7179298997,
0.1321051568,
0.094189927,
-0.0920824334,
-0.0675719082,
-0.4326216578,
0.1891416013,
0.1097692475,
-0.1538517475,
-0.3994940221,
0.1945741773,
-1.2349920273,
-1.0941739082,
0.4278334975,
0.4657173455,
0.2635495067,
0.1495876312,
-0.5433609486,
0.0594684556,
0.0528961271,
-0.0610414222,
0.0179959815,
0.6421932578,
0.2263139933,
0.4706324339,
0.6135995984,
0.5363551378,
0.2337568402,
0.3303201497,
0.4760545194,
-0.3422909677,
-0.6664944887,
-0.5412187576,
0.6052563787,
0.0502461493,
-0.1646297872,
0.6418371797,
0.7870935798,
0.8947687149,
-0.1010952294,
1.1468769312,
0.0776183084,
1.0689328909,
-0.8098357916,
0.7450461388,
-0.9569333196,
0.1917261034,
-0.3335018456,
-0.6161212325,
-0.1900046319,
0.2506044805,
0.3265520334,
0.1873087436,
0.230436489,
0.4846337438,
-0.1636316776,
-0.0528305806,
0.3252118826,
0.1235914305,
0.4093520045,
0.7045426369,
0.8620433211,
-0.6244883537,
0.5703251362,
-0.4397498369,
-0.3160268068,
0.1515334696,
-0.8379790187,
-0.7615879774,
-0.8342964053,
-0.1172111481,
-0.010468943,
-0.1335119307,
1.1111452579,
0.6238996983,
-0.8218220472,
-0.3615960777,
0.4614352882,
0.1317397654,
-0.3590932488,
-0.1632204801,
0.5393782258,
-0.568061769,
-0.8089289069,
0.3842755556,
-0.0034574978,
0.2203578204,
-0.2299396992,
-0.069995977,
-0.2530961931,
-0.0069437842,
0.4917214215,
0.1142393723,
-0.7772769332,
-0.1452085525,
0.2449378669,
0.231765762,
-0.0872122645,
0.6901049018,
-0.3883402646,
0.6825136542,
0.1282980442,
0.5333232284,
-0.0952397063,
0.0010706054,
0.4578372836,
-1.1004521847,
-0.2195533067,
0.2534391284,
0.4933884144,
0.493945092,
-0.4658563733,
0.2420935333,
-0.0985263959,
-0.2876904905,
-0.8328627944,
0.1481347531,
-0.460588038,
-0.1973152608,
1.1566030979,
-0.1676771194,
-0.1566696316,
-0.0113917077,
-0.3202350438,
0.5209507942,
-0.1073785573,
0.7914816141,
0.8168569803,
-0.089023672,
-0.0877823457,
-0.6313375235,
0.6692273617,
0.0889671519,
-0.5428450108,
0.2262669057,
0.5541678071,
0.1497590542,
0.2351181209,
0.3683034182,
-0.0994678363,
0.5001143813,
-0.5132284164,
0.2442728281,
-0.1485637575,
-0.8506545424,
-0.3215963244,
0.1255195588,
0.036970105,
-0.1744935066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17600v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17600v1 | "Seeing the Big through the Small": Can LLMs Approximate Human Judgment Distributions on NLI from a Few Explanations? | 2024-06-25T14:42:17 | 2024-06-25T14:42:17 | Beiduo Chen, Xinpeng Wang, Siyao Peng, Robert Litschko, Anna Korhonen, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human label variation (HLV) is a valuable source of information that arises
when multiple human annotators provide different labels for valid reasons. In
Natural Language Inference (NLI) earlier approaches to capturing HLV involve
either collecting annotations from many crowd workers to represent human
judgment distribution (HJD) or use expert linguists to provide detailed
explanations for their chosen labels. While the former method provides denser
HJD information, obtaining it is resource-intensive. In contrast, the latter
offers richer textual information but it is challenging to scale up to many
human judges. Besides, large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used as
evaluators (``LLM judges'') but with mixed results, and few works aim to study
HJDs. This study proposes to exploit LLMs to approximate HJDs using a small
number of expert labels and explanations. Our experiments show that a few
explanations significantly improve LLMs' ability to approximate HJDs with and
without explicit labels, thereby providing a solution to scale up annotations
for HJD. However, fine-tuning smaller soft-label aware models with the
LLM-generated model judgment distributions (MJDs) presents partially
inconsistent results: while similar in distance, their resulting fine-tuned
models and visualized distributions differ substantially. We show the
importance of complementing instance-level distance measures with a
global-level shape metric and visualization to more effectively evaluate MJDs
against human judgment distributions. | [
-0.6005693674,
-0.4770607948,
0.8427457213,
-0.0838202983,
-0.2716512084,
-0.2148964107,
-0.464635849,
-0.7049162984,
0.2165745497,
0.4964196384,
-0.5806226134,
-0.3975800276,
-0.5189108253,
0.0870674551,
0.1757755131,
0.9385714531,
0.2855277061,
-0.0643766224,
-0.0079609491,
-0.0894153491,
-0.1331727952,
-0.283112973,
-0.4563045502,
-0.4470893145,
0.9363046288,
0.4103589952,
0.8665180802,
0.7924923897,
0.3922223747,
0.2376731485,
-0.4892171025,
0.2964196503,
-0.3281438649,
-0.3920819461,
-0.2209213078,
-0.7862776518,
-0.3542611301,
0.1429219544,
0.7807836533,
1.2079843283,
0.0054533412,
0.2090245634,
0.2837211788,
0.6839590073,
-0.8206107616,
-0.1979149133,
-0.3621563911,
0.2852097154,
-0.2107687294,
0.0886060148,
-0.5718342066,
-0.2050406039,
0.4571626186,
-0.6318967938,
0.2449546903,
0.3789317906,
0.7757229209,
0.4267665446,
-0.4853596985,
-0.1335440576,
-0.6938710809,
1.0927101374,
-0.8927822709,
0.2037916631,
0.2441573739,
0.4582209587,
-0.1130249426,
-0.4558098614,
-0.4759344161,
-0.2205008119,
-0.3120718896,
-0.0668715015,
-0.1083582565,
0.0776812062,
0.4298387766,
0.1734579653,
-0.1577111185,
0.4954965115,
-0.1795373559,
-0.2098746896,
0.7806378007,
0.3082281351,
-0.1508970261,
-0.5616567731,
-0.4027248621,
-0.3272739947,
-0.7386361957,
0.03425771,
0.245458886,
0.2038260847,
-0.2212233394,
0.3995456696,
-0.1047143713,
0.8839950562,
-0.1098812371,
-0.4126585126,
0.2668378353,
-0.2083137333,
-0.5569030046,
-0.0472915098,
0.9263169169,
0.5125873089,
0.2923500836,
0.0066153016,
-0.1106969789,
-0.3199903369,
0.179793179,
-0.7283707857,
-0.2353626788,
-0.2026751935,
-0.759442091,
-0.3012410998,
0.1669203639,
-1.1098573208,
-0.9897047877,
-0.3048133552,
0.2201295942,
-0.0861339644,
-0.1011710986,
0.046392452,
-0.2585948706,
0.0908602625,
0.6300485134,
-0.7841196656,
0.1960904598,
0.6062696576,
0.684886992,
-0.1726607382,
-0.120214425,
-0.39254269,
0.1702016741,
-0.3458432853,
0.6514235735,
-0.4900828004,
-0.370467782,
-0.2510085404,
-0.2930183411,
0.0681874603,
-0.7274442911,
0.5145298243,
-0.2861051261,
-0.082554087,
-0.2444493771,
-0.6152700782,
-0.1883840859,
0.2318745852,
-0.6735501289,
0.6451188922,
-0.0669332892,
-1.0170167685,
0.6672126651,
-0.4444281459,
-0.131962195,
0.0389689282,
-0.2866834998,
-0.34535411,
0.4024816453,
0.3337748349,
0.4342142045,
-0.2956750393,
-0.1028413922,
-0.6065493226,
-0.3735499978,
0.4303621054,
-0.7392577529,
0.6627738476,
0.2180995196,
-0.1459349245,
0.2403963655,
-0.7120614648,
-0.0444638766,
-0.0685721263,
-0.4418554008,
-0.5870323181,
0.0500593409,
0.0859102979,
-0.0087395692,
-0.0594352819,
-0.3204668462,
0.339132905,
-0.5436714888,
0.1781504154,
0.8082029819,
0.2938640416,
0.6921588778,
-0.2052600235,
0.5163789988,
0.0228561535,
0.2637351453,
0.1140248105,
-0.7005457878,
-0.6317622662,
-0.4082532823,
0.6418337226,
0.2470679134,
-0.7167336345,
0.2642297149,
-0.3453620076,
-0.5220870972,
-0.7313403487,
0.1643460095,
0.3609547913,
0.3000462353,
0.2127499878,
-0.2293474674,
-0.5441524386,
-1.14589715,
-0.3832146823,
-0.091915369,
-0.6459274292,
0.458997786,
0.5852627158,
-0.3246268034,
1.0960118771,
-0.575075686,
-0.2911678851,
-0.20347251,
0.2145026624,
0.270237118,
0.232260257,
0.5024806857,
-0.6713345051,
-0.1981621683,
0.0291667562,
-0.5298825502,
-0.1218076572,
-0.2594612539,
-0.188210085,
0.0046245158,
0.2585100532,
-0.4080475569,
0.6861950159,
0.3152120113,
-0.4141722023,
0.6120431423,
-0.3955937028,
-0.1843313128,
-0.5996243358,
-0.3540120423,
0.4150577784,
-0.2278630733,
-0.3835209012,
0.1038476229,
-0.0369461589,
0.53669554,
-0.4674992859,
0.6500616074,
-0.4606065452,
-0.2350905985,
-0.2426288426,
0.2726683021,
0.1435095817,
0.2750706673,
-0.1046060026,
0.4716219902,
0.1908667237,
-0.5609343052,
0.0583802126,
-0.1284701228,
-0.6160876751,
0.5751197934,
-0.4804411232,
-0.1047146022,
-0.1293874532,
0.4265117645,
-0.9086620808,
-0.4349232614,
0.3285855949,
0.0004759671,
0.2170474827,
-0.4053682387,
-0.5242108107,
-0.5199832916,
-0.5164418817,
0.3432168663,
0.6684032083,
-0.7741979361,
0.7881366611,
0.3849489093,
0.1708783358,
-0.3589784503,
-0.8754599094,
0.1939811409,
-0.4647603035,
-0.567281425,
0.0220426768,
-0.1732224673,
-0.6196257472,
-0.2780720592,
-0.1274462491,
0.0564836524,
0.202210173,
0.2991689146,
0.1044773161,
-0.3560841382,
0.0632914901,
-0.0905406103,
0.1474894583,
0.1967209131,
-0.1129942164,
0.0401266739,
-0.1459311247,
-0.3136933446,
-0.5904867053,
0.1553191245,
0.2746978998,
0.144446671,
0.5892018676,
0.5005369186,
-0.3075463474,
-0.2099256217,
-0.6156996489,
-0.1743362248,
-0.4632431269,
-0.0288391691,
-0.4826468825,
-0.669025898,
0.2707748115,
-0.1262663156,
-0.1177074537,
0.4451136291,
0.6186931133,
-0.3979924917,
1.1076310873,
0.5916057229,
-0.0043525188,
0.3330397606,
-0.1798761934,
-0.0958873257,
-0.9839985371,
-0.0750704557,
-0.451110661,
-0.6153268814,
-0.7096759081,
-0.6591723561,
0.4168902934,
0.2393650413,
-0.042982161,
-0.2446862608,
-0.420194149,
0.6880843639,
0.7801983356,
0.3071280718,
0.3138083816,
0.0495764352,
-0.135649398,
-0.2722338736,
-0.8201102018,
-0.7204613686,
0.9235544205,
0.6122598648,
0.888698101,
0.1313795298,
0.787622571,
0.3169059455,
0.7870003581,
-0.7784155011,
0.434830606,
-0.0686238781,
-0.451087594,
-0.3451819122,
-0.6908863783,
-0.9596224427,
0.7425432801,
-0.3479720354,
-0.9014390111,
0.5154093504,
0.3410432339,
-0.4704854488,
0.3162660301,
-1.1012898684,
0.8386565447,
0.0296138301,
-0.226174593,
0.0124694603,
-0.7401332259,
0.505219698,
-0.1225707009,
0.6851775646,
-0.029387759,
-0.0531404838,
0.9689221978,
-0.6525323987,
1.313039422,
-0.2972945571,
-0.2246390134,
0.3752250075,
0.0075216219,
0.3616493642,
0.043209184,
-0.171079427,
0.1697760373,
-0.2311984003,
-0.4500058889,
-0.7541074157,
0.5086167455,
-0.7108854055,
-0.6106413007,
-0.2189534754,
-0.4764292538,
-0.0779286623,
-0.0549328774,
0.172792688,
0.1538200676,
0.0848050565,
0.0504324883,
0.4295343459,
-0.165308252,
0.4074398577,
0.2944334745,
-0.145718649,
-0.2387636751,
0.7018376589,
0.0007357201,
0.1862198263,
0.28201437,
0.6638398767,
-0.3099863529,
-0.5795138478,
-0.6309165955,
0.3760462403,
-0.7823393345,
-0.0488344617,
-0.2194172442,
0.347014904,
-0.1399700046,
-0.0675629973,
-0.144549489,
-0.2944509387,
-0.2595150769,
-0.0853007957,
0.2793229818,
1.0573985577,
-0.1462988704,
0.4111206234,
-0.5023921728,
0.2775434256,
0.4687831104,
0.2460932434,
0.2431660146,
-0.6871241927,
-0.2719736397,
0.3021087646,
-0.0173018202,
-0.9171258211,
0.1871953756,
0.0069196741,
0.3073737919,
0.607029438,
0.0412819609,
0.8797376752,
-0.6176871061,
0.759096384,
0.2867321372,
-0.622666955,
0.4453372359,
-0.0975695848,
0.334928453,
0.4794317186,
0.1140651926,
-0.302169621,
-0.4202910662,
-0.4554529488,
-0.7591971159,
0.735413909,
0.0970858261,
-0.2009620219,
0.113370195,
0.3913292289,
0.0395199731,
-0.0897152349,
-0.6415297985,
-0.2809996605,
0.0535503663,
-0.2235209793,
-0.2316212803,
-0.2836990356,
-0.2670845985,
-0.3085371852,
0.4399856031,
-0.2687050104,
-0.0783408359,
0.1827283502,
-0.1419466734,
-0.0043862187,
0.2920605242,
0.5830779076,
0.6583391428,
-0.2540560365,
0.4317576289,
0.3695521951,
-0.331178546,
-0.0563882217,
-0.1254598498,
-0.2960925698,
0.0240314491,
0.5900197029,
1.0602502823,
0.2569828033,
-0.7428464293,
0.5683503747,
-0.1377918422,
-0.198477298,
-0.0793404728,
0.1663081646,
0.1351435781,
0.5397049785,
0.3965322077,
0.2076293677,
0.211996913,
-0.3028710186,
0.0567353889,
0.2505639791,
-0.4070534706,
-0.101868093,
0.6838613153,
0.095669806,
-0.4562302232,
0.3780323267,
-0.2968455851,
-0.1781967282,
0.6721815467,
0.1163593829,
0.4995039999,
0.174095422,
0.0746954605,
0.1103471518,
0.3448497355,
-0.2623653412,
-0.2474400103,
-0.1483612359,
-0.6181118488,
-0.7291371226,
-0.7026072145,
-0.6551773548,
-0.1713839322,
-0.8692020178,
-0.005123449,
-0.4244164228,
-0.2323366702,
0.3765563965,
-0.1789751947,
-0.8715462089,
0.2975435555,
0.6129390001,
0.9241582155,
-0.7345609069,
0.8290193081,
0.6227295399,
-0.333165586,
-0.8365975618,
0.2758514881,
0.0716990232,
-0.5626462698,
0.6957355738,
0.2062012106,
-0.0923265964,
-0.2723935843,
-0.5094842315,
-0.4825905561,
0.8126907349,
0.2117415816,
-0.8254054785,
0.0870110542,
0.0521593094,
0.6732456088,
-0.3556873798,
0.4234953225,
0.9514807463,
0.7185078263,
-0.0833279192,
-0.801312685,
0.0512286052,
0.0788510516,
0.2400125861,
0.0925649777,
-0.2393897474,
0.4678838253,
-0.649219811,
0.0121275438,
-0.0185295939,
0.6891192198,
0.5383290648,
0.4007738531,
0.9475220442,
0.3844248652,
0.9335264564,
-0.009281029,
1.5372995138,
0.224942252,
0.5909833312,
1.2026873827,
-0.0653662309,
0.8298922181,
0.6572465897,
-0.3781204224,
0.4572484493,
0.7368159294,
-0.1747941524,
0.3715525568,
0.5003966689,
-0.2227740884,
-0.3990100622,
-0.0834785402,
-0.0660734996,
0.2532811165,
0.4260190129,
-0.3512570858,
-0.0636548847,
0.1617441624,
-0.1901331693,
-0.0055293632,
-0.473901242,
0.6610283852,
0.2355091274,
-0.4378217459,
0.6890887618,
0.1652850658,
0.9452834725,
-0.1683344245,
0.1689936072,
-0.1828825474,
0.1772896796,
-0.1765372753,
-0.8686252832,
0.0647408441,
0.0458092541,
-0.2805510759,
-0.1892227083,
0.5371770859,
-0.1700688601,
-0.6493402123,
0.211898759,
0.442541033,
0.4608057141,
-0.0891605914,
-0.5333233476,
0.0325854234,
0.055589851,
-0.5650200248,
0.3317251801,
0.6904864907,
-0.1602026522,
0.5923379064,
0.2683484256,
0.1650150865,
0.2591160834,
0.5520626903,
0.565890789,
-0.7793818116,
-0.3690419197,
-1.0224539042,
0.2453316003,
-0.319265157,
-0.283652693,
0.6696313024,
0.3011078835,
0.731751442,
-0.3220704794,
0.5820840001,
0.223133415,
0.5634999871,
-0.5601082444,
0.5814301372,
-0.7581481934,
0.4069543779,
-0.2637689412,
-0.773679316,
-0.5394762754,
0.6487945914,
-0.4563456774,
0.0592093244,
0.4750117362,
0.576110661,
-0.0516235195,
-0.0568779372,
0.3531468213,
0.4561557174,
0.2306382656,
0.4913106859,
0.9055630565,
-0.1309545636,
0.6253489256,
-0.2397453487,
-0.1653336883,
-0.4017627537,
-0.8094320297,
-0.9683611989,
0.1404700577,
-0.3764621019,
-0.1801541299,
-0.1758303046,
0.8503133059,
0.9502351284,
-0.5711532831,
-0.0768464133,
0.2238108963,
0.4407979548,
-0.1328002363,
-0.2618057132,
0.3878229558,
0.0263905879,
-0.7305249572,
0.3397928476,
0.1212651059,
0.1543999016,
-0.3670718074,
-0.1571859717,
0.1290374696,
-0.0277625937,
0.6702733636,
-0.0723323375,
-1.1360185146,
-0.6866714954,
-0.555115819,
-0.1865594387,
0.1349376142,
0.6685003638,
-0.8057489991,
0.3125839233,
0.3404084444,
0.5733628869,
0.5508708954,
-0.0104136756,
0.2550294399,
-1.0558485985,
0.253762424,
0.1106237695,
0.3857555985,
0.3981491625,
-0.1004741937,
0.5724942088,
0.1962524503,
-0.279542774,
-0.7930980921,
0.3772083223,
-1.0407568216,
-0.4662817121,
1.324405551,
-0.0518326014,
-0.4937080145,
-0.0230060648,
-0.246058017,
-0.1392737925,
-0.3901172876,
0.6950092912,
0.6343604326,
-0.2269506454,
-0.081843175,
-0.7356886268,
0.4005501866,
0.3028262556,
-0.7851917744,
0.01906926,
0.4300199449,
0.3371241689,
0.2906714678,
0.4998216331,
0.293294549,
0.059172444,
-0.0362284593,
0.1482428014,
0.3713986576,
-0.1411212385,
-0.3908807337,
0.2350813448,
0.218166858,
-0.0527692884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17588v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17588v2 | LongIns: A Challenging Long-context Instruction-based Exam for LLMs | 2024-06-25T14:31:26 | 2024-06-26T13:28:04 | Shawn Gavin, Tuney Zheng, Jiaheng Liu, Quehry Que, Noah Wang, Jian Yang, Chenchen Zhang, Wenhao Huang, Wenhu Chen, Ge Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The long-context capabilities of large language models (LLMs) have been a hot
topic in recent years. To evaluate the performance of LLMs in different
scenarios, various assessment benchmarks have emerged. However, as most of
these benchmarks focus on identifying key information to answer questions,
which mainly requires the retrieval ability of LLMs, these benchmarks can
partially represent the reasoning performance of LLMs from large amounts of
information. Meanwhile, although LLMs often claim to have context windows of
32k, 128k, 200k, or even longer, these benchmarks fail to reveal the actual
supported length of these LLMs. To address these issues, we propose the LongIns
benchmark dataset, a challenging long-context instruction-based exam for LLMs,
which is built based on the existing instruction datasets. Specifically, in our
LongIns, we introduce three evaluation settings: Global Instruction & Single
Task (GIST), Local Instruction & Single Task (LIST), and Local Instruction &
Multiple Tasks (LIMT). Based on LongIns, we perform comprehensive evaluations
on existing LLMs and have the following important findings: (1). The
top-performing GPT-4 with 128k context length performs poorly on the evaluation
context window of 16k in our LongIns. (2). For the multi-hop reasoning ability
of many existing LLMs, significant efforts are still needed under short context
windows (less than 4k). | [
-0.3769521415,
-0.7355160713,
0.9319406152,
0.1572524756,
-0.2804450393,
-0.1261049211,
-0.6182854772,
-0.5287649632,
-0.1475986093,
0.3746214509,
-0.554902494,
-0.5591514707,
-0.5304580331,
0.3550895154,
-0.2368391454,
0.8078870773,
-0.5053957701,
-0.2241725922,
-0.4357512593,
-0.1905572265,
-0.5784865022,
-0.405299902,
-0.5233978033,
-0.0432757288,
0.7235119939,
0.2102514356,
0.1672233492,
0.4958541691,
0.3749597669,
0.2523625791,
-0.2583182454,
0.2650901377,
-0.5872232318,
0.0318373777,
-0.1797790974,
-0.0621812157,
-0.5281230211,
-0.0485200956,
0.8099805117,
0.7430992126,
0.1133889928,
0.2108315229,
0.3141355813,
0.8877323866,
-0.7671379447,
0.0877717361,
-0.3099093735,
-0.0582462102,
-0.4174316525,
-0.0497490428,
-0.3959206939,
-0.1975236237,
0.3242228627,
-0.3827031255,
-0.323672086,
-0.100962989,
0.4239730239,
0.0793157443,
-0.8392347693,
-0.5416596532,
-0.4526412189,
1.1592983007,
-0.5877496004,
0.336892873,
0.2212855518,
0.558028698,
-0.2734100819,
-0.717541039,
-0.1242861152,
-0.3707318604,
0.093125686,
0.0278772414,
0.1581121832,
0.1010715514,
0.4150785804,
0.2003740072,
-0.5819997787,
0.3133218586,
-0.481262058,
-0.0893239751,
0.5757915974,
0.4105178714,
-0.2801762223,
-0.2774212658,
-0.786239624,
0.0532543734,
-0.8311427236,
0.2392287552,
0.0686521083,
0.2105418891,
-0.098446846,
0.2478960901,
-0.2428035736,
1.0081439018,
-0.4996970296,
-0.2474105507,
0.2725096047,
-0.1415985972,
-0.2810891569,
-0.0605968684,
0.6438183784,
0.3984091878,
0.1685871184,
-0.1378481984,
-0.4328563511,
-0.2370105684,
0.0117634935,
-1.003195405,
0.4859004915,
0.3288104832,
-0.1824059784,
0.2678670585,
-0.1358050257,
-0.9822288156,
-0.1237458661,
-0.5147600174,
0.4485153854,
-0.3297205269,
0.2432093024,
0.1779656559,
0.2001019716,
0.5185257196,
0.4542615712,
-0.4749472141,
0.4138463438,
1.1031683683,
0.6406750083,
-0.6598801613,
-0.5273516178,
-0.3435394168,
-0.0300882589,
-0.4005190134,
0.4449036419,
-0.5389336348,
-0.2766568959,
-0.0106654977,
0.2864449024,
-0.2018452138,
-0.4661535621,
0.4067554176,
-0.6689026356,
0.1308893859,
-0.4529960752,
-0.9648866653,
-0.0235691871,
0.6217780709,
-0.5671350956,
0.9174044728,
0.174050048,
-0.5298725963,
0.0657267869,
-0.7064554095,
-0.4549498856,
0.021731263,
-0.3782616258,
-0.0476249903,
-0.1090173945,
0.0680365413,
0.6316570044,
-0.5751852989,
0.2765887678,
-0.0621180832,
-0.9197217226,
0.1759322286,
-0.7838359475,
0.577404201,
0.1063378379,
-0.5507019162,
0.0178504661,
-0.5648189187,
0.2673831582,
0.0850824341,
-0.330109179,
-0.287255317,
0.0201242417,
-0.4896459281,
0.0087901242,
0.3355565071,
-0.5317054987,
0.2719941139,
-0.0117511153,
0.3807720244,
1.0183032751,
-0.1268883049,
0.1072781906,
-0.1660176367,
0.4102980793,
-0.1188875586,
0.1524528414,
-0.1412193477,
-0.2762669921,
-0.5972269773,
-0.1695977896,
0.2158519477,
0.5522619486,
-0.5614824891,
0.356998682,
-0.6568316817,
-0.263232708,
-0.0335154831,
0.3975215256,
0.4935672581,
0.3943263888,
0.3104161918,
-0.170795992,
-0.2457446307,
-1.0139142275,
-0.208485797,
0.3191789389,
-0.0987435207,
0.4559549093,
0.8127896786,
-0.2372006178,
0.6343305111,
-0.3959341347,
0.014128508,
-0.0295586307,
-0.1534312814,
0.529968679,
0.1316925883,
0.196432963,
-0.3019655943,
-0.4069108367,
-0.2813513577,
-0.6932520866,
0.2336785197,
0.1287526637,
0.0316093899,
0.1443378478,
0.4599250257,
-0.5458525419,
0.3033415377,
0.6887201667,
-0.0792732015,
0.6734803319,
-0.182607159,
0.2177008092,
-0.9554750323,
-0.0688687563,
-0.0013818803,
-0.2263017744,
-0.248506546,
0.0167546775,
0.3735148609,
-0.1464771181,
-0.581225276,
0.791428864,
-0.6767905951,
-0.1847290844,
-0.1301778704,
0.3120064437,
0.0378185548,
0.5178264976,
-0.2140306383,
1.1280478239,
0.5937108994,
-0.5151105523,
0.5847302675,
-0.1883177906,
-0.8891557455,
0.5610792637,
-0.5084528923,
0.3732049465,
-0.0141479475,
0.572111249,
-0.5830079913,
-0.2251143306,
-0.1266054064,
0.1692458838,
0.4006104469,
-0.0904863551,
-0.4226726592,
-0.50583601,
-0.402990967,
0.673386097,
0.5455630422,
-0.7617486715,
0.2659733593,
-0.1861283928,
-0.0186420195,
-0.7921890616,
-0.4617202878,
0.2096376866,
-0.3631456196,
-0.6363824606,
0.1876859218,
-0.1352517754,
-0.2262766361,
-0.2722249031,
-0.2157617658,
0.0475381874,
-0.0032049322,
0.1140771657,
-0.0325876139,
-0.390491575,
0.2621106803,
-0.1960047781,
-0.0799411535,
0.2531235516,
-0.079400517,
0.1451256722,
-0.5286050439,
-0.5947856307,
-0.3288414776,
0.3793402016,
0.7025253773,
-0.1271964163,
0.4400302172,
0.1773605347,
-0.2162436992,
-0.3906467557,
-0.750023067,
-0.0982936844,
-0.460187465,
0.6456691027,
-0.5797490478,
-0.9985766411,
0.3814978004,
-0.4513317943,
-0.0022139214,
0.3102942109,
0.1389928013,
-0.0558035672,
0.6222750545,
0.0093708457,
-0.3424467146,
0.0223535802,
-0.2221582383,
0.0052843657,
-1.0449640751,
-0.0558517165,
-0.1992627084,
-0.342862606,
-0.4585144818,
-0.6440297365,
0.4417021275,
-0.1149594933,
-0.3984078765,
0.0934934616,
-0.281901896,
0.7024968266,
0.3365159929,
0.236035794,
-0.0457554795,
-0.0877802745,
0.0495367683,
0.0464261323,
-0.3356638551,
-0.5977258086,
1.1378623247,
0.5045381784,
0.7870053649,
0.0497925244,
0.7117324471,
0.088902995,
0.1733477414,
-0.7500885129,
0.8304406404,
-0.1657696962,
-0.6573685408,
-0.4563518465,
-0.6464347839,
-1.0475418568,
-0.0760344267,
0.5307793021,
-0.8469285369,
-0.1877501309,
-0.3295577466,
-0.2248064727,
0.344492197,
-0.6586509347,
0.9911181927,
-0.6412065029,
-0.6325643063,
-0.0303866901,
-0.7250453234,
0.2872768342,
-0.0494662933,
0.1907419562,
-0.2066893429,
-0.2054990381,
0.9657926559,
-0.269651264,
0.8123694062,
-0.1523544341,
-0.1465355307,
0.5257158875,
-0.0283784997,
0.5566444397,
-0.0346665457,
-0.2763063014,
-0.0128798801,
0.0670451149,
-0.6038238406,
-0.8544948101,
0.9694270492,
-0.5571904182,
-0.7722314596,
-0.3808261752,
-0.4166639149,
-0.4568557739,
0.0481139533,
-0.0580415167,
0.6957296729,
-0.2095090002,
0.3507761061,
0.5983207822,
-0.1003638133,
0.3601039946,
0.2543813288,
0.0020629535,
-0.2342456132,
0.8349435329,
0.1795804948,
0.3395789564,
0.1535082608,
0.2557412684,
-0.2834546268,
-0.4578965604,
-0.5550450087,
0.1877939999,
-1.0260099173,
-0.0940474346,
0.0330821462,
-0.3368517756,
0.0683405921,
-0.0847193971,
-0.4887540638,
0.012643151,
-0.0894588307,
0.0477502234,
0.1844517887,
0.8312115669,
0.2359807491,
0.125143975,
-0.6648237705,
-0.017552413,
0.5953890681,
0.7117141485,
0.1075630933,
-0.5668640137,
-0.2354505062,
-0.1176500544,
-0.1990723163,
-0.7611082792,
-0.270578593,
-0.0429906771,
0.4560104311,
0.3215452731,
-0.0842574835,
0.7304304838,
-0.6385932565,
0.9487393498,
-0.0005872265,
-0.713922739,
0.2913962603,
-0.166287303,
0.4177429378,
0.7234541774,
0.4685884118,
-0.3230453134,
0.1530979425,
-0.1451398581,
-0.7520144582,
0.4692311287,
0.0168361887,
0.3586421907,
-0.2160940915,
0.5558591485,
0.1930496544,
-0.0160100088,
-0.6228626966,
-0.1046527103,
0.1773785502,
-0.1142273918,
-0.2265491784,
-0.5589267015,
-0.3406305015,
-0.2663213909,
0.5215910673,
-0.1883973032,
0.2314101458,
0.1552497,
-0.1285025179,
0.3465818763,
0.707372725,
0.8363073468,
1.1867218018,
-0.4755137563,
0.1027900353,
0.5519031882,
-0.1184033528,
0.1760846823,
0.1176498011,
0.2731709182,
-0.2654767036,
0.6215338707,
0.9921810627,
0.3061149418,
-0.6761398315,
0.8155270219,
0.000109587,
-0.0899808928,
-0.4287876189,
-0.0865755603,
0.215646252,
0.0977990851,
0.3818330169,
-0.5177747011,
-0.1593399346,
-0.4275147915,
0.1125681922,
0.3222739697,
-0.5343086123,
-0.1211277395,
-0.0512190312,
0.2253409475,
-0.219092831,
0.8034818769,
-0.2631200254,
-0.4550464749,
0.6811614037,
0.4266443551,
0.630941391,
-0.1705871969,
-0.3513118029,
0.4042982459,
0.2340523452,
-0.1452461332,
0.2057558745,
-0.1236883551,
-0.1850760281,
-0.6401472092,
-0.4169560969,
-0.4491173327,
0.5502443314,
-0.5070313215,
0.2107119411,
-0.4002421796,
-0.097483471,
-0.4775106907,
0.2432654649,
-0.6036216617,
0.2926419377,
0.2212125361,
1.2245824337,
-0.48864609,
0.6555789113,
0.2834647596,
0.1458029598,
-0.6232631207,
-0.0258052815,
-0.031805262,
-0.6153019071,
0.6889837384,
0.6787238717,
0.0404857993,
-0.4654794335,
-0.4622448087,
-0.6695238948,
1.2857749462,
0.1948092729,
-0.8439825177,
-0.2540513873,
0.3937761784,
0.4011208117,
-0.3985750377,
0.3393075764,
0.655508101,
0.6048619151,
-0.0082320953,
-0.9609590173,
0.1557477564,
-0.0172344614,
-0.1132368222,
0.2462418377,
-0.7390552163,
0.7229390144,
0.0391012728,
0.076992169,
0.1635016054,
0.6148305535,
0.4081631303,
0.4093616009,
0.6585983634,
0.4998384118,
0.5220165253,
-0.043179512,
1.216327548,
-0.2778573632,
0.2775836289,
1.2835046053,
-0.4432425797,
0.9625564814,
0.6141764522,
-0.2950076461,
0.4575560987,
0.6896273494,
0.1170501709,
0.1625568867,
0.7300544977,
-0.4022312462,
-0.268399179,
0.3437706828,
-0.501185596,
0.4008965492,
0.4336311519,
-0.1453525126,
-0.4348852634,
-0.0556887165,
-0.0340604894,
-0.1544979811,
-0.1746092141,
0.3782512546,
0.3667714596,
-0.8061718941,
0.7652174234,
-0.0726081654,
0.625636816,
-0.824534297,
0.0241108686,
-0.3057188392,
0.1838635355,
0.1642756611,
-0.9086077809,
-0.0068031182,
0.0923690721,
0.1621966213,
-0.0366844945,
0.5295010805,
-0.1832495481,
-0.3476559222,
0.619373858,
0.3865384758,
0.397144556,
-0.0080775423,
-0.7057744265,
0.2068812102,
-0.2576826513,
-0.6752966046,
0.5354193449,
0.5050930381,
-0.2448902577,
0.6128596067,
0.1575315148,
-0.0347123072,
-0.0939382613,
0.0309256688,
0.7605130076,
-0.8381765485,
-0.1623618752,
-0.8253060579,
0.3489821553,
-0.1302114427,
-0.358143121,
0.5672200322,
0.8041576743,
0.7057362795,
0.1810702682,
0.3748468161,
0.2589206994,
0.6195493937,
-0.6718856096,
0.4132378995,
-0.7630605698,
0.3468863666,
-0.0402624458,
-0.9657493234,
0.0253550112,
0.1025977135,
-0.6209080815,
0.3529964983,
0.8643164039,
0.6152784824,
-0.2475023568,
-0.0242038611,
0.4805271924,
0.0802903473,
0.3205244243,
1.1519906521,
1.0881236792,
-0.4946939647,
0.4780582488,
-0.3078896403,
-0.2981593609,
-0.1259562671,
-1.0616744757,
-1.0390039682,
-0.410967201,
-0.0903245285,
-0.2120392174,
0.4332714677,
0.7996464372,
0.5020642877,
-0.6389558315,
-0.5455277562,
0.3115452528,
0.0691670924,
-0.0139540769,
-0.1640229821,
0.7979653478,
-0.316901356,
-0.563708961,
0.9050596952,
0.1135460064,
-0.0910663605,
-0.253339231,
-0.3108305335,
-0.0119332997,
-0.0244760476,
0.7528486848,
0.1846583486,
-0.7859430909,
-0.6013163328,
0.0725523159,
-0.3045584559,
0.1051640883,
0.6736730933,
-0.6120039225,
0.3841196597,
0.3366541862,
0.9663681388,
0.587099731,
-0.2310430855,
0.2914122939,
-0.7204269171,
0.0170109849,
0.2329269499,
0.3519858122,
0.2307163626,
-0.04304168,
0.5128657222,
0.0100604845,
-0.7412667871,
-0.8041286469,
0.0313686058,
-0.9276715517,
-0.3853926063,
1.2810804844,
-0.3623387516,
-0.4977816045,
0.2380840778,
0.1679859161,
-0.119216077,
-0.0737387985,
0.5031744838,
0.7548885942,
-0.109146975,
0.0585703477,
-0.8994790316,
0.3159046769,
0.6544950008,
-0.7668946385,
0.1752681136,
0.4589563906,
0.4577590823,
0.0643632561,
0.520049274,
-0.1067007035,
0.2178220302,
-0.2573175132,
-0.1810070425,
-0.1249336004,
-0.4325017631,
-0.2777935863,
0.1271278709,
0.0317372456,
-0.0970235318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17574v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17574v1 | Beyond Text-to-SQL for IoT Defense: A Comprehensive Framework for Querying and Classifying IoT Threats | 2024-06-25T14:14:35 | 2024-06-25T14:14:35 | Ryan Pavlich, Nima Ebadi, Richard Tarbell, Billy Linares, Adrian Tan, Rachael Humphreys, Jayanta Kumar Das, Rambod Ghandiparsi, Hannah Haley, Jerris George, Rocky Slavin, Kim-Kwang Raymond Choo, Glenn Dietrich, Anthony Rios | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recognizing the promise of natural language interfaces to databases, prior
studies have emphasized the development of text-to-SQL systems. While
substantial progress has been made in this field, existing research has
concentrated on generating SQL statements from text queries. The broader
challenge, however, lies in inferring new information about the returned data.
Our research makes two major contributions to address this gap. First, we
introduce a novel Internet-of-Things (IoT) text-to-SQL dataset comprising
10,985 text-SQL pairs and 239,398 rows of network traffic activity. The dataset
contains additional query types limited in prior text-to-SQL datasets, notably
temporal-related queries. Our dataset is sourced from a smart building's IoT
ecosystem exploring sensor read and network traffic data. Second, our dataset
allows two-stage processing, where the returned data (network traffic) from a
generated SQL can be categorized as malicious or not. Our results show that
joint training to query and infer information about the data can improve
overall text-to-SQL performance, nearly matching substantially larger models.
We also show that current large language models (e.g., GPT3.5) struggle to
infer new information about returned data, thus our dataset provides a novel
test bed for integrating complex domain-specific reasoning into LLMs. | [
0.0387587957,
-1.0578373671,
0.4636696279,
-0.276653856,
-0.1194973737,
0.2479301244,
0.1267749071,
-0.876275599,
0.0238706116,
0.6889747381,
-0.4249465764,
-0.5931712985,
-0.386308372,
-0.0632157549,
-0.8230490685,
0.967995286,
0.5117632151,
-0.2605419159,
-0.182449311,
0.4158774316,
-0.4275140166,
-0.7225613594,
-0.5760406256,
-0.0246568341,
0.1713383049,
0.2254890651,
0.2716225982,
0.3672915101,
0.8351997733,
0.2248915881,
0.3787858486,
0.2063849419,
-0.2188907713,
0.1604200602,
-0.0855026618,
-0.5791090131,
-0.361279726,
-0.2944572568,
0.337631017,
0.5050577521,
-0.0333361179,
-0.2193950862,
-0.2569975257,
0.7674669623,
-0.3522070348,
-0.1801051646,
-1.265173316,
0.1233589798,
-0.3767492771,
-0.5345400572,
-0.7787290215,
0.0263683926,
0.5012010336,
-0.3076414168,
0.2708068788,
0.4050970078,
0.7697687745,
0.1091735512,
-0.89993608,
-0.0091792662,
-0.8435173035,
0.7033775449,
-0.4142571986,
0.4035505354,
0.5368885398,
0.2654228806,
-0.3914173543,
-0.7096301913,
-0.2730054259,
-0.3293477893,
-0.0242876653,
0.0616345666,
-0.2120509148,
-0.1703212112,
0.1018231362,
0.0063756374,
-0.8269987702,
-0.0341184475,
-0.2475132644,
0.0108362688,
0.9735298157,
0.1469278783,
0.1468317956,
-0.0584131666,
-0.7526506186,
0.2349560857,
-0.9505189657,
-0.1643182486,
0.07608632,
0.5717076659,
0.0299051721,
0.6579616666,
-0.4884260595,
0.806507051,
-0.0748946518,
-0.0201673303,
-0.1547245532,
-0.5234647989,
-0.1864115,
0.2951470912,
0.6782288551,
0.5303228498,
-0.0483435765,
-0.6455416679,
-0.1396700889,
-0.1139216647,
0.4979459345,
-0.7248746753,
-0.3034570515,
0.3998235166,
-0.3518179953,
-0.2760325372,
0.1474629641,
-0.7123413086,
-0.7394375801,
-0.1024882644,
0.2755129337,
-0.3902338445,
-0.3074017465,
0.3097999692,
-0.1676113755,
0.2176193148,
0.2524268329,
-0.6135497093,
0.4664786458,
0.71179533,
0.580499649,
-0.3818151951,
0.0899401084,
-0.3550883234,
0.4554721415,
-0.2041029185,
1.0851554871,
-0.2393024862,
-0.5988169312,
-0.2934811711,
-0.2415243983,
-0.1047518253,
-0.5957077146,
0.4626169801,
-0.7849846482,
0.341360718,
0.2831561565,
-0.5566680431,
-0.0187505037,
0.4601822495,
-0.5410072207,
0.7981014252,
-0.0946623757,
-0.7344668508,
0.5384694934,
-0.8791364431,
-0.9293531179,
0.1351159215,
0.0269181766,
-0.558133781,
0.0121934982,
0.0700853169,
0.6732734442,
-0.6105983257,
0.096519053,
-0.4806076288,
0.0320094116,
0.3253647089,
-0.3233347833,
0.5989605188,
0.3175558448,
-0.3210925758,
-0.0569343306,
-0.9388765097,
0.1997641623,
0.2032527179,
-0.1762601137,
-0.3752486706,
0.6508927345,
-0.2039206177,
-0.3088002205,
0.2546893954,
-0.9385298491,
-0.0764318034,
-0.4927129745,
0.4561186433,
0.414740175,
0.1451868713,
0.1904459745,
-0.2073218226,
0.0510080419,
0.1731625646,
0.2597426772,
0.0208502971,
-0.5337262154,
-0.3584158123,
-0.3221715093,
-0.0650687367,
0.8892585635,
-0.7397688031,
0.2964729369,
-0.5668370724,
-0.3326962292,
0.0357529223,
-0.2657509744,
-0.0020457578,
0.6286990047,
0.4805333018,
0.2181376368,
-0.6946632862,
-0.7255575061,
-0.4126058519,
-0.2216825485,
-0.1341888458,
0.2503582835,
0.3154837191,
-0.1701058447,
1.0623357296,
-0.6950303912,
-0.3272025287,
0.0935345814,
-0.0219798442,
0.1384699941,
0.3669006824,
0.4861114919,
-0.9443435669,
-0.4613173604,
0.5726699829,
-0.697599709,
0.3496525288,
0.0210003499,
-0.0037105437,
0.2595815063,
0.5903729796,
-0.398443073,
0.6433221698,
0.0038527767,
-0.6025253534,
0.3771239221,
0.3668843508,
0.1464381516,
-1.3543475866,
-0.0396109931,
-0.1345793009,
-0.3164795935,
-0.7830253839,
-0.0498535968,
-0.2158571482,
-0.1932970136,
-0.3317916095,
0.5603895783,
-0.1055361852,
0.0319524556,
-0.0628849268,
-0.0447439775,
-0.0601966567,
0.1693977118,
-0.007463282,
0.7440196872,
0.4845147431,
-0.7790127397,
0.7211548686,
-0.0045491518,
-0.3426536024,
0.7484395504,
-0.722974956,
0.0923496112,
0.2269508392,
0.2095541507,
-0.9415656924,
-0.2769801915,
0.0963155627,
-0.634736836,
0.0697978958,
-0.3749889135,
-0.7522345185,
-0.2501288652,
-0.4341160655,
0.289925307,
0.2153941393,
-0.4983753264,
0.7764341235,
0.3498942256,
0.0122097721,
-0.3495405018,
-1.051721096,
0.2555341125,
-0.4719765782,
-0.5556121469,
0.4895671904,
0.1704336405,
-0.3079435527,
0.1349555552,
-0.0272193365,
-0.5725627542,
0.3732469082,
0.2219818532,
0.3605209589,
-0.1790719032,
0.3358225524,
-0.2307430506,
-0.0830652118,
0.3701323569,
-0.6858308911,
0.2053645402,
0.1018577367,
-0.6213923097,
-0.4075995982,
0.6161078215,
0.180200696,
-0.3017790318,
0.6181641817,
0.4608502686,
-0.3616677225,
-0.1280064136,
-0.3207477629,
-0.4337158799,
-0.4482509196,
0.4772998989,
-0.3964314759,
-0.8880264163,
0.2658015192,
-0.0401152782,
0.2497198135,
0.6192314625,
0.0707473159,
-0.5954248309,
0.920179069,
0.6123013496,
0.0541061237,
0.6577324867,
-0.1643192768,
0.6392222047,
-0.6901100874,
-0.4132446945,
-0.5491296053,
-0.0315306149,
-0.6460323334,
-0.071377553,
0.5137236714,
-0.0568128079,
-0.2425019294,
0.2616818547,
-0.5249646306,
0.3501725197,
0.0738351941,
0.3688587546,
0.4728534222,
0.4312957525,
0.2434028387,
0.2182050943,
-0.4851121306,
-0.2930578291,
1.5333259106,
0.0096959369,
0.6257632971,
0.7143924236,
0.5624474883,
0.4201571345,
0.2732993066,
-0.7202798724,
0.7385624051,
-0.3526783884,
-0.8755106926,
-0.16959773,
-0.5934424996,
-1.3528535366,
-0.1290109754,
-0.0189461187,
-0.9566361308,
-0.0769144371,
-0.1034378186,
-0.2665483654,
0.4240314066,
-0.9925528169,
0.2859499753,
-0.41203174,
-0.4970610738,
-0.2744374871,
-0.6671779752,
0.3244725764,
0.0299253277,
-0.0588409528,
-0.0834865719,
-0.0575582497,
0.4807962179,
-0.4023458958,
0.9382514954,
-0.0178135578,
-0.1997356266,
0.5375621915,
-0.0634602904,
0.4384811819,
0.2802550495,
-0.2436694354,
-0.1310510337,
0.1198582053,
-0.4262189865,
-0.5746912956,
0.6145883203,
-0.4189015031,
-0.4901713431,
-0.4205326736,
-0.2859755456,
-0.4342140257,
0.3224023581,
0.2186088115,
0.6414721608,
-0.1440571845,
0.6214162707,
1.0568480492,
0.1542404592,
0.4012737274,
0.5091615319,
-0.1375038773,
-0.1643033773,
1.0480188131,
-0.0194875691,
0.2962315083,
1.1451084614,
0.0493432768,
-0.6686373353,
-0.7793393135,
-0.2513169348,
-0.2980829775,
-0.332764864,
-0.5814455748,
-0.6264052987,
-0.3396060765,
-0.2153923064,
0.0999863222,
-0.1302845776,
-0.38082847,
-0.2769489288,
-0.0147754094,
0.9342380166,
0.7311816216,
0.425809145,
0.2918570042,
-0.8451421857,
0.2141374797,
0.2531899512,
0.4976930618,
-0.214888677,
-0.1967892796,
-0.3172199428,
0.1330194026,
-0.1658201218,
-0.7934677005,
-0.1140697151,
0.1624028832,
0.2784675062,
0.1257079393,
0.3714626431,
0.4172513783,
-0.2079360485,
0.8914002776,
-0.029957179,
-0.4860129058,
0.8213626742,
-0.6497883797,
-0.1502668411,
0.3496319354,
0.1171685681,
-0.0120061431,
0.3269343078,
-0.6098498106,
-0.9085282683,
0.4885040522,
0.0704816356,
0.0194202885,
0.1461309046,
0.2463191003,
-0.2227428406,
0.2529848218,
-0.7241868377,
0.0232317243,
-0.1243827194,
-0.1584339589,
0.4283179343,
0.1644664109,
-0.3491108716,
-0.0301658418,
0.4402893484,
-0.2327624559,
0.727095902,
0.0422891118,
-0.0206245147,
0.4239978194,
0.2124163955,
0.4076945782,
0.1939812899,
-0.2511116266,
0.0956143737,
0.2838257551,
-0.6351907849,
-0.0308544077,
0.2455700338,
-0.0215589292,
-0.2030804753,
0.559902966,
0.5026943684,
-0.3546363413,
-0.7015579939,
0.4892612398,
-0.1368526965,
-0.3127225637,
-0.126060456,
0.0923741236,
-0.3296635151,
0.1093045026,
0.4976104796,
0.1065329388,
0.3734889925,
-0.4766897857,
0.3012708724,
0.642773807,
-0.2309850901,
-0.1854504347,
0.4670780599,
0.3918997049,
-0.1175756678,
0.6281129718,
-0.0477801375,
-0.3246661127,
0.5670621991,
0.4227507114,
1.0345699787,
-0.0892529339,
-0.0973175988,
0.018752465,
0.3812656403,
0.4837141633,
0.6592446566,
-0.126158759,
-0.5194715858,
-0.3463449776,
-0.2567735016,
-0.1068744808,
0.0862350315,
-0.3993512094,
0.1496230215,
-0.7283392549,
-0.2074348778,
-0.1047810763,
0.2086491585,
-0.4012309015,
0.4241462052,
-0.4356606603,
0.7349199057,
-0.4073511362,
0.8265837431,
0.8242077827,
-0.0131454403,
-0.5259631276,
0.1804066896,
0.0807591379,
-0.6459121704,
0.5540139079,
-0.0952335447,
-0.3590386808,
0.01606814,
-0.4826512635,
-0.694514513,
0.9351938367,
0.0300501361,
-0.2282444537,
0.2834050953,
0.4195756316,
0.4715468287,
-0.2747376859,
0.0331248417,
0.1574187875,
0.3440987468,
-0.1680166572,
-0.4745855927,
-0.0649911761,
-0.2388824224,
-0.1402121037,
0.3465271294,
-0.4113449752,
0.4959366322,
-0.2271743268,
-0.20617944,
-0.089847587,
0.6162740588,
-0.1503897905,
0.532468617,
0.2648718059,
0.4888832271,
0.4092665613,
-0.3613486588,
1.1106786728,
-0.0298815016,
-0.0228767991,
1.2864652872,
-0.4281925857,
1.2644474506,
0.3870153725,
-0.4706275463,
0.3621141911,
0.6107295752,
0.0905846879,
0.6596161127,
0.0054317852,
-0.4758662283,
0.1925605983,
-0.3979753256,
-0.43803671,
0.2389029264,
0.6703637242,
-0.0119035915,
-0.1017010584,
-0.0289225522,
-0.2002272606,
-0.0144859273,
0.0694242418,
1.1975368261,
-0.1405458003,
-0.2300001681,
0.2487648129,
0.1230631843,
0.5804850459,
-0.7364367247,
0.1558813602,
0.0142716793,
0.213202104,
-0.4579516947,
-1.0603169203,
0.7847714424,
0.0397645123,
-0.3243801892,
-0.140028581,
0.8211734891,
-0.1466600299,
-0.1013581678,
0.0116909351,
0.1404841542,
-0.0194258336,
-0.2826105356,
-0.5263187885,
-0.185902074,
0.175058797,
-0.0384271033,
0.2990863323,
0.565356493,
-0.2415159941,
0.6633176208,
0.9843123555,
-0.2222435027,
0.1583137959,
-0.1560817957,
0.6846848726,
-0.5496029258,
-0.4191815257,
-0.7604311705,
0.4925834239,
-0.3419567943,
-0.2367935628,
0.6491767764,
0.7088193893,
0.7923919559,
0.082783334,
0.8732845783,
-0.2266750336,
0.7663015723,
-0.6646357179,
0.5065326691,
-0.5607889295,
0.7029154897,
0.1450585723,
-0.4966545999,
-0.2680529952,
0.2657426596,
-0.2471765429,
-0.0057656453,
0.6136806607,
0.8427671194,
0.0876285806,
0.2092727125,
0.0306222811,
0.1312154233,
0.6375947595,
0.4413909912,
0.898463726,
-0.7323054075,
0.5866271853,
0.0032267577,
0.0670382828,
-0.4698120058,
-0.9094067812,
-0.7080364227,
-0.6047416925,
-0.2577437162,
-0.3071427643,
0.1759372354,
0.6738401651,
1.0203803778,
-0.7952560782,
-0.1359571218,
-0.3931002319,
0.2353657186,
-0.137814045,
-0.2458569854,
0.2651738822,
0.0303741973,
-0.2590921223,
0.5448095798,
0.3444607258,
0.3967241943,
0.0144257564,
0.3479710817,
-0.4124424458,
0.0130564086,
0.8936267495,
0.2241291702,
-0.5560369492,
-0.1085111946,
0.0421719812,
-0.205992654,
-0.1991819888,
0.5933261514,
-0.8524467349,
0.3106690347,
0.5263240337,
1.1051659584,
0.3748497963,
-0.3620134294,
0.4882980287,
-1.0401970148,
0.0091833808,
0.3619287908,
-0.0327643603,
0.2601116598,
-0.8728557229,
0.6736423373,
0.2872697413,
-0.2456754446,
-0.8752203584,
0.4980579317,
-0.8484592438,
-0.3113566041,
0.6971815228,
0.1481560469,
-0.1118888855,
-0.4459841847,
-0.0594933331,
-0.1947396398,
-0.406909883,
0.5506777167,
0.3759675622,
-0.4008039534,
-0.0678395107,
-0.4671798944,
0.4994939566,
0.478400588,
-1.5108299255,
0.151673466,
0.2037835866,
0.1070239395,
0.0643268153,
0.2931756079,
-0.1775378585,
0.1047471687,
-0.0026998688,
-0.4797556102,
0.1219359413,
-0.4889752269,
0.2092272788,
0.0096040433,
-0.0497311987,
-0.3606255054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17566v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17566v1 | FrenchToxicityPrompts: a Large Benchmark for Evaluating and Mitigating Toxicity in French Texts | 2024-06-25T14:02:11 | 2024-06-25T14:02:11 | Caroline Brun, Vassilina Nikoulina | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly popular but are also prone to
generating bias, toxic or harmful language, which can have detrimental effects
on individuals and communities. Although most efforts is put to assess and
mitigate toxicity in generated content, it is primarily concentrated on
English, while it's essential to consider other languages as well. For
addressing this issue, we create and release FrenchToxicityPrompts, a dataset
of 50K naturally occurring French prompts and their continuations, annotated
with toxicity scores from a widely used toxicity classifier. We evaluate 14
different models from four prevalent open-sourced families of LLMs against our
dataset to assess their potential toxicity across various dimensions. We hope
that our contribution will foster future research on toxicity detection and
mitigation beyond Englis | [
-0.184262678,
-0.5396701694,
0.6212641001,
0.5555352569,
0.0783822164,
-0.3946968019,
-0.0360471271,
-0.3471401632,
-0.1362147033,
0.8954142928,
-0.40311566,
-0.5285833478,
-0.7653647661,
0.3871143162,
-0.4498146772,
0.8395408988,
0.0603954419,
0.0398767143,
-0.3621431589,
-0.2656192482,
-0.4376696646,
-0.6970465183,
-1.0077519417,
-0.2593631446,
1.1568259001,
0.502800405,
0.4286343455,
-0.2045646161,
0.4833855927,
0.1837349832,
-0.2035895139,
-0.0015708579,
-0.5932791829,
0.3988571465,
-0.6646512151,
-0.13870655,
-0.0479315259,
-0.1071553305,
0.3240411282,
0.4911671579,
0.1597526371,
0.0186345093,
0.3315610588,
0.6956450939,
-0.8403999805,
-0.1458163112,
-0.336057514,
-0.0245604049,
0.0158174448,
-0.4828683138,
-0.7077586055,
-0.5855492353,
-0.0846610069,
-0.1693163365,
-0.3735594451,
-0.1960089505,
0.4096213579,
0.2434310317,
-0.773645699,
-0.3750196993,
-0.6085743904,
0.8524442315,
-0.5430761576,
0.3946520388,
0.1566477269,
0.3336949944,
-0.2497539669,
-0.6788668633,
-0.3605149686,
-0.447499752,
-0.0161699764,
0.0130539238,
-0.2166021019,
-0.2174985111,
0.3038131595,
0.2302365005,
-0.7733932137,
0.2884285748,
-0.1165238842,
-0.5250610709,
0.7498300076,
0.314466089,
0.7003080249,
-0.1197541058,
-0.378413707,
-0.0506739616,
-1.1962256432,
-0.1496577561,
0.508705318,
0.2505000532,
0.0078992192,
0.5130280256,
0.057831984,
0.3445259035,
-0.8272894621,
0.0360452682,
0.1603663117,
-0.2599529624,
0.1010823622,
-0.110252589,
1.1669647694,
0.8453550339,
0.7901856899,
-0.1391730309,
-0.1777185351,
-0.057730075,
0.089830257,
-1.0369807482,
-0.4067376256,
0.4437033534,
-0.1555628777,
-0.4351402223,
-0.4033578932,
-1.0075130463,
-0.7506318688,
0.1394595504,
0.4470730424,
-0.3635394573,
-0.1816556603,
-0.0627932623,
-0.2399337143,
-0.0451448448,
0.2386482656,
-0.4419250488,
0.1984691769,
0.1580780745,
0.8727722764,
-0.496000886,
0.0036024696,
-0.6898593903,
0.0617136993,
-0.180889219,
0.9044535756,
-0.5806750059,
-0.9812754989,
0.0881981924,
0.2072387785,
0.2675628364,
-0.9546214938,
1.0970462561,
0.0369048677,
0.0039125769,
-0.6646161079,
-0.3064822555,
-0.0109401029,
0.1692323983,
-0.9564765096,
1.0863153934,
0.0840375498,
-0.8439965844,
0.1128938943,
-0.2606587708,
-0.5417469144,
0.0617551394,
0.1472185999,
-0.1927152276,
-0.1745786369,
0.0213821456,
0.4884919524,
-0.4692652225,
0.0595326796,
-0.2344029993,
-0.0411808118,
0.2072215676,
-0.5702295899,
0.9102161527,
0.3930743635,
0.0827022493,
0.1637566835,
-0.4483139813,
-0.292434603,
0.2518168092,
-0.2564554513,
-0.4753766656,
0.052359473,
0.4897751212,
0.5541570783,
-0.1212963462,
-0.5465348363,
-0.2024731338,
-0.1420292556,
0.6157255769,
0.689304173,
0.7061778903,
0.0236181486,
-0.6466597915,
0.3597103357,
0.0809332654,
0.3071912229,
-0.1185618043,
-0.507923305,
-0.2702316642,
-0.2345269918,
-0.1528326422,
0.7243642211,
-0.6241036057,
0.4982775152,
-0.2793195546,
-0.649217844,
0.3255296052,
0.0983891264,
0.2663803995,
0.5072990656,
0.2639135122,
-0.245606944,
-0.0389206782,
-0.8892121911,
-0.5409533381,
0.1684809625,
-0.1063374728,
0.4150260985,
0.7217614651,
-0.3184287846,
0.4998365939,
-0.3634331822,
-0.2797016203,
-0.0401886888,
0.0172520895,
-0.103754282,
0.3046865463,
0.8794105053,
-0.4609792233,
-0.5246139169,
-0.2244715542,
-0.6004065275,
-0.5429171324,
0.1410957575,
-0.1432908326,
-0.0850485936,
0.7001767755,
-0.2999387681,
0.0160993487,
0.6591276526,
-0.2350839227,
0.6276648045,
0.12558119,
0.1757018417,
-0.9077802896,
0.0906081274,
0.6092050672,
-0.282564342,
-0.4842716455,
-0.0632284358,
-0.1701828241,
-0.1057176366,
-0.9182083011,
1.0333025455,
-0.0901661366,
0.6455596685,
0.0878263488,
0.2873516977,
0.2527063489,
-0.0384334102,
0.2113109976,
0.9205884933,
0.2896868885,
-0.6277251244,
0.4444259703,
0.1692749709,
-0.1974175572,
0.593162179,
-0.5857313275,
-0.3091634512,
0.0653813928,
0.39529863,
-0.8613135815,
-0.1518772691,
0.148609221,
-0.3015465736,
0.1597076803,
0.0340391546,
-0.7908632159,
-0.4141108096,
-0.2822373807,
0.4513159394,
0.4871339798,
-0.4794071019,
0.2900408208,
0.2484440356,
-0.5362087488,
-0.3597382605,
-0.7411239743,
0.2189269066,
-0.4851931036,
-0.5679355264,
-0.1004973724,
-0.3058803976,
-0.3501555622,
-0.0931533277,
0.0772623867,
0.0859706625,
-0.0084155705,
0.2349975407,
-0.1438927054,
0.2926564217,
0.3083745837,
0.0626629516,
-0.0871015564,
0.3979201019,
0.0725259185,
0.4253730476,
0.3965691626,
-0.2112720907,
-0.0206269175,
0.4397648573,
0.7405323982,
-0.318133086,
0.8418679237,
0.1307896376,
-0.4328700304,
-0.5782794952,
-0.4246382415,
-0.276096344,
-0.4817181528,
0.3606715798,
-0.1135241836,
-0.6524612308,
0.6533498168,
-0.477386564,
-0.1480102986,
0.5027620196,
0.945908308,
0.2516883612,
0.9331080914,
0.2206270397,
-0.3565457165,
0.2152493,
-0.0628199354,
0.2259145379,
-0.5161018968,
-0.2200769782,
-0.6377940178,
0.2361658216,
-0.515260458,
-0.4381514192,
0.5321971178,
-0.1889384836,
-0.6045905352,
0.0980847254,
-0.4307026267,
0.5877119899,
0.1477512717,
0.2218990177,
0.345418036,
-0.0541064031,
-0.3723457158,
-0.1018312797,
-0.6408460736,
-0.8236923814,
1.022035718,
0.5332337022,
0.7114931941,
0.1396440119,
0.5451049805,
0.3628876507,
0.4528200626,
-0.7428039312,
0.442007035,
-0.3115026355,
-0.8770130873,
-0.0330614746,
-0.7050423622,
-0.5234578848,
-0.1555521488,
-0.1081653088,
-1.0342991352,
0.0683362707,
0.0044621532,
-0.3360380232,
0.4250741005,
-0.8097141981,
1.049716115,
-0.3989066184,
-0.9782573581,
0.0078362469,
-0.2950823307,
0.6132454276,
-0.3353677988,
0.6574323773,
-0.3417006731,
0.0303750429,
0.410692811,
-0.348521024,
0.7881994843,
-0.0142640145,
-0.5666000247,
0.3664200604,
0.4153489172,
0.5981353521,
0.2666063607,
-0.375770241,
0.084918566,
-0.0468494669,
-0.3989400566,
-0.1402975917,
1.2078487873,
-0.4832224548,
-0.1603535712,
-0.3654797375,
-0.5446212292,
-0.37980479,
0.0900898874,
0.7224282026,
0.3722331524,
-0.5166734457,
-0.1258260459,
0.7771053314,
-1.0775520802,
0.3422276378,
0.4616098702,
-0.2722679079,
-0.0733252168,
1.2650027275,
0.0049696583,
0.4629472196,
0.1139725745,
0.2638168633,
-0.4842903316,
-0.6039321423,
0.078854613,
0.2770825028,
-1.0747103691,
-0.2157141566,
-0.507134378,
-0.4556238353,
-0.168024078,
-0.1637881547,
-0.2217741162,
-0.0146751245,
-0.2811483443,
-0.2182764858,
0.6211193204,
0.7877500057,
-0.0822112262,
0.0714078546,
-1.353880167,
-0.0080176257,
0.2696206868,
0.5225592256,
-0.335703969,
-0.4725364745,
0.1788291484,
-0.2568022907,
-0.3481853008,
-1.1096251011,
0.4875855744,
0.0639652982,
0.6800941825,
0.3262352943,
0.5484629273,
-0.3862094283,
-0.5110128522,
1.1143318415,
0.2681408823,
-0.7358086109,
0.6030674577,
-0.647703588,
-0.0551840737,
0.4143168628,
0.922300458,
-0.7272881866,
-0.6170300245,
-0.1683752835,
-0.9730480313,
0.2138718218,
0.3955540955,
0.2866835892,
-0.4514670074,
0.1910830736,
0.0599478856,
-0.176703468,
-0.7909932137,
-0.172630474,
0.087372072,
-0.3748797476,
-0.3449788988,
-0.5823796391,
-0.3425711691,
-0.1707854867,
0.7643173337,
0.3016588092,
-0.0391575769,
0.1486487836,
-0.3189361393,
-0.4249702692,
0.3658516109,
0.4548433721,
0.4482659101,
-0.1652026623,
0.0488240942,
0.2896137536,
-0.5592885613,
0.335922569,
-0.0450584404,
-0.0329842977,
-0.2754536271,
0.5881671906,
0.3585228324,
0.0549051017,
-1.0348584652,
0.6064068675,
0.0555156544,
-0.2676918209,
-0.2496718168,
0.0789321437,
0.2610787451,
0.0710388198,
0.0983386934,
-0.1714927703,
0.2920090556,
-0.5706577301,
0.3403099477,
0.3528560996,
-0.5344071984,
-0.0488893501,
0.6062984467,
0.7925131321,
-0.0022770653,
0.2940924466,
-0.1328678131,
-0.5120260119,
0.4141350985,
0.1180479601,
0.7831835747,
-0.5110498071,
0.1910769492,
0.6958143711,
0.5197764635,
0.1576211303,
0.3679649532,
0.714145124,
-0.7425447702,
-0.4797867537,
-0.8376613855,
-0.2134307176,
0.5277485847,
-0.3718706369,
0.3060563505,
-0.3342089355,
0.0187198687,
0.1176536083,
-0.2586152554,
-0.3690332472,
0.0844246373,
0.1533557475,
1.2916016579,
-1.5156929493,
0.6483482122,
0.5685152411,
-0.5851272345,
-0.6098257899,
0.1277279854,
0.3042933345,
-0.372058779,
0.5744062066,
0.2025428414,
0.0073408941,
0.1216294691,
-0.4748318195,
-0.1853386015,
0.7654553652,
0.4442500174,
-0.9225552678,
0.2890885174,
0.2847126126,
0.3686987758,
0.0308960229,
0.3288418055,
0.918217659,
0.7421537042,
0.1524049044,
-0.7851240635,
0.2599869668,
-0.4365658164,
-0.2346522659,
0.1353805661,
-0.5786507726,
0.4950766563,
0.0826886818,
-0.1681693047,
0.0226473082,
-0.1360648721,
-0.0278111603,
0.1657144874,
0.3498313725,
0.7305707932,
0.3789268732,
-0.1706657857,
1.224165678,
-0.2229292542,
0.0548448153,
0.8967779875,
-0.5726928115,
0.796017468,
0.3193938434,
-0.2236513048,
0.3825337291,
0.6624664664,
0.2330958396,
0.4008621573,
0.5145973563,
-0.7097811103,
-0.3720384836,
-0.4877999425,
-0.1507440805,
-0.0372436754,
0.6802303791,
-0.4453024864,
-0.4445482194,
0.3598745167,
-0.0307277665,
0.4271231294,
-0.3085354567,
0.6579169035,
0.3686726987,
-0.347524792,
0.4645028114,
-0.4810245931,
0.4317997694,
-0.4342205822,
-0.1561323553,
-0.2865126431,
0.0794096664,
-0.2329208404,
-1.1745541096,
0.3255538642,
-0.062102057,
0.0845200941,
0.0322457962,
0.7542662024,
-0.2319800258,
-0.4898085594,
0.852743566,
0.567543745,
0.0176995732,
-0.6486921906,
-0.5157485604,
0.0872593448,
-0.3401454687,
-0.3636215329,
0.272903204,
0.5000751019,
-0.3038952947,
0.768243134,
0.3065060377,
0.1333827078,
-0.0473816469,
0.3165703714,
1.1323335171,
-0.4192574322,
0.0676922575,
-0.7277334929,
0.7032387853,
-0.0619462989,
-0.0655297637,
0.765645206,
0.4896425605,
0.4149187207,
0.1261908114,
1.1021418571,
0.2898473144,
0.5119072795,
-0.5041335225,
0.759914279,
-0.6231844425,
0.4997341931,
-0.297744751,
-1.1757093668,
-0.4331584573,
0.1422589272,
-0.3738524318,
0.2055407315,
0.8804264665,
1.0329825878,
0.1456902027,
-0.2573470771,
0.2829860151,
0.5170229673,
0.3170227706,
0.7506717443,
1.0565582514,
-0.0001863969,
0.635271728,
-0.3005377054,
-0.2576543987,
-0.3839174509,
-1.1691675186,
-0.9970232248,
-0.52894032,
-0.2891471088,
-0.5094822049,
0.4084334075,
0.7140232921,
0.181237027,
-1.0652964115,
0.1789180785,
-0.260779649,
0.1488354355,
0.1955434382,
-0.250924021,
0.0968012884,
-0.1504537761,
-0.5780200958,
0.1505292803,
0.2124141604,
0.1373299211,
-0.3389650881,
-0.2642788589,
0.0369324721,
0.3674082458,
1.0586760044,
0.392018795,
-0.3926727176,
-0.6018839478,
-0.1929140538,
-0.4206326008,
-0.4177564085,
0.691445291,
-0.4262407422,
0.4324687719,
0.7812556028,
0.0833023265,
0.1292751729,
-0.4508529902,
0.721855104,
-0.9316484332,
0.156035766,
0.5795662999,
0.4036817253,
0.4134615958,
-0.4839961529,
0.6085349917,
0.0916729271,
-0.6316410303,
-0.7244241238,
0.3838876784,
-0.9229906797,
-0.5285954475,
1.6691166162,
-0.1252567321,
-0.0255445819,
-0.1722657382,
-0.3612921238,
0.023704242,
-0.22979936,
0.3156834245,
0.6879388094,
0.1208633929,
-0.3384171724,
-1.1677476168,
0.7514500618,
0.184055984,
-0.9155088067,
0.3051070869,
0.5818697214,
0.459218353,
-0.0149451876,
0.4396888018,
-0.2991123796,
0.1851038337,
-0.1209352165,
0.2657759488,
0.2811026275,
-0.3866325617,
-0.2171776891,
-0.1555811018,
0.3043469191,
0.4373454452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17563v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17563v1 | Multi-property Steering of Large Language Models with Dynamic Activation Composition | 2024-06-25T14:00:42 | 2024-06-25T14:00:42 | Daniel Scalena, Gabriele Sarti, Malvina Nissim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Activation steering methods were shown to be effective in conditioning
language model generation by additively intervening over models' intermediate
representations. However, the evaluation of these techniques has so far been
limited to single conditioning properties and synthetic settings. In this work,
we conduct a comprehensive evaluation of various activation steering
strategies, highlighting the property-dependent nature of optimal parameters to
ensure a robust effect throughout generation. To address this issue, we propose
Dynamic Activation Composition, an information-theoretic approach to modulate
the steering intensity of one or more properties throughout generation. Our
experiments on multi-property steering show that our method successfully
maintains high conditioning while minimizing the impact of conditioning on
generation fluency. | [
-0.4797535241,
-1.0525544882,
0.3124381304,
0.6274262071,
-0.0624842718,
0.3970870674,
-0.5549331307,
-0.3671956658,
0.1915317476,
0.0592200644,
-0.3642668128,
-0.0268661883,
-0.709839046,
-0.4609039426,
-0.2456568182,
1.0461169481,
0.018298639,
-0.1552144438,
0.1174445227,
-0.2193605602,
-0.2333081514,
-0.4362366796,
-0.4783291519,
-0.6500457525,
0.5620790124,
0.2421480268,
1.1711442471,
0.6985260248,
0.040255826,
0.3715022206,
-0.3328379393,
-0.0209212452,
-0.5428384542,
0.5668430328,
-0.104066737,
-0.3295330405,
-0.5815497041,
-0.0238927621,
1.0732004642,
0.8819167018,
-0.2605521679,
-0.2702821791,
0.1494334191,
0.4077585042,
-0.9702522755,
0.1624192297,
-0.6454640627,
0.0031146256,
-0.0083549609,
-0.5081595182,
-0.6608220935,
0.1479584128,
0.2723493874,
-0.7278392315,
-0.0121376542,
-0.1634622961,
0.5971365571,
-0.0592139438,
-0.8942598701,
-0.2268284559,
-1.2409290075,
1.0554896593,
-0.5065407157,
0.6609557867,
0.3625681996,
0.0465827137,
-0.2104686797,
-0.3709599674,
-0.6235969067,
-0.747600019,
0.1999398321,
0.2461984754,
0.0908936411,
0.3233779371,
0.2817347348,
0.0955412835,
-0.0538391508,
0.1353124678,
-0.1209429204,
-0.1552985311,
0.5323817134,
-0.0466252789,
0.2739920914,
0.061047025,
-0.451474458,
-0.3604431748,
-0.7088520527,
-0.1004483402,
0.7014878988,
0.3726164997,
-0.0537429191,
0.6586154103,
-0.2495424598,
0.6764669418,
0.5460598469,
-0.4279530942,
0.2852501869,
-0.8603940606,
0.0307343062,
0.1361212432,
0.4845837355,
0.1555936486,
-0.0881767124,
-0.2553224862,
-0.4174211621,
-0.1593167335,
0.1679247618,
-0.7153834105,
-0.1402548701,
0.3047776222,
-0.3253518641,
-0.3844287097,
0.095709905,
-0.8540557027,
-0.4499718249,
-0.4986073375,
0.3582411706,
-0.4582720995,
-0.7565599084,
0.1300666481,
-0.1844052821,
0.2926382124,
-0.0421478748,
-1.4539198875,
0.1564139575,
0.4976472855,
0.4455603659,
-0.2154458314,
-0.4132377207,
-0.4888451695,
0.6154353023,
-0.2214804143,
0.5789741278,
-0.7723875642,
-0.143664971,
0.1558677107,
-0.2880233824,
-0.2326639295,
-0.402772069,
-0.0172624961,
-0.6583652496,
-0.0489976257,
-0.0115014501,
-0.3431881666,
0.0057230503,
0.1310048997,
-0.9842053056,
1.0222393274,
0.2957811356,
-0.6079664826,
0.5642530322,
-0.5930175185,
-0.860388577,
-0.3748838007,
0.0772281364,
-0.2688335776,
0.4450720251,
-0.0670237616,
0.2577000856,
0.0306170788,
0.5361649394,
-0.1452586055,
-0.0529972389,
0.492159009,
-0.709982276,
0.4467380643,
0.1562206298,
-0.5179085732,
0.4014341533,
-1.092462182,
-0.1478150636,
-0.0326938182,
-0.7867603302,
-0.2354407459,
0.1204899997,
-0.1615666151,
0.185051173,
0.3814300001,
-0.2104991078,
0.4436911941,
-0.287797749,
0.0680662394,
0.5849901438,
0.258097738,
0.9571710229,
-0.3412660658,
0.8480888605,
0.1577903926,
-0.0413914137,
-0.1813247651,
-0.3247083426,
-0.9535342455,
-0.1900883317,
0.2141269743,
0.3201068938,
-0.8562965989,
0.506118536,
-0.1445986629,
-0.4086276889,
-0.4300811887,
0.2813838422,
0.5785031915,
0.1027588472,
0.3968568444,
0.0393202417,
-0.1584706306,
-0.7399413586,
-0.1555128247,
-0.0397170968,
0.4339846373,
-0.173193112,
0.0818710104,
0.0774922594,
0.4535533786,
-0.2888824642,
0.2574902475,
-0.579988122,
0.5040538311,
-0.0789806619,
0.644233644,
0.7516776323,
-0.7007568479,
-0.5502879024,
0.0962780863,
-0.1411577165,
-0.1046281531,
-0.4586752355,
-0.3256201744,
0.0018080807,
0.4094880819,
-0.7915292978,
0.1959259957,
0.7711411715,
-0.3055196702,
0.7932820916,
-0.3924426138,
0.0248462018,
-0.7035616636,
-0.0096746413,
0.0786302909,
-0.0120191928,
-1.0621256828,
0.1660812944,
-0.1022038162,
0.1397890449,
-0.4363872409,
0.4169321954,
-0.6484498382,
0.1841564476,
-0.3419256806,
-0.0865755156,
0.0002377097,
0.5620538592,
-0.0763240531,
0.5945749879,
0.6194443107,
-0.8337286711,
0.661686182,
0.0127292303,
-0.3005700409,
0.6685248017,
-0.3316047192,
0.0033135279,
-0.2890914679,
-0.0019309234,
-0.9809839129,
-0.1985565424,
0.0981647596,
-0.0561397299,
0.6873375177,
-0.0470609553,
-0.395373702,
0.0755254105,
-0.3524712026,
0.3290814757,
0.2686569691,
-0.3019989133,
0.9212139845,
0.1268966347,
-0.1654150039,
-0.5185636282,
-0.5784039497,
-0.2090919167,
-0.3884908259,
-0.5671297312,
0.7354211211,
-0.1704606563,
-0.2752778232,
-0.0416627415,
0.0296408143,
-0.0398590788,
0.2182273418,
-0.0494591445,
-0.1036597416,
-0.0356265903,
0.2563757598,
0.415961951,
-0.236752376,
-0.1424739808,
-0.142276153,
0.8277795911,
0.2664371133,
-0.5406343341,
-0.4503350854,
0.4234131873,
0.8484639525,
-0.4930971265,
1.134344697,
0.459258616,
0.0643720254,
-0.400691241,
-0.2835938931,
-0.3514840305,
-0.5118770599,
0.6299483776,
-0.5874353647,
-0.2853758037,
0.6871128082,
-0.0264981017,
0.106336318,
0.3400033712,
0.7555410266,
0.046360787,
1.4598209858,
0.5699567199,
-0.1191540807,
1.0990716219,
-0.4724975526,
0.3800053298,
-0.7087500095,
-0.4763384461,
-0.4620696008,
-0.4663961828,
-0.4597669542,
-0.1381096691,
0.2701375186,
0.2482034266,
-0.2752821147,
0.1787718236,
-0.1712323278,
-0.0825434476,
0.7333145142,
0.1744625419,
0.3994410336,
0.0866493285,
-0.3154465854,
0.1527244002,
-0.8865041137,
-0.090523921,
0.9105213284,
0.3384552896,
0.8680022955,
0.1276712865,
0.3753270507,
-0.0966414735,
0.2135707289,
-0.8850013018,
0.4773210585,
0.2278023213,
-0.7161440849,
-0.4842833579,
-0.2731565237,
-1.0811297894,
0.2115474641,
-0.6822577119,
-0.5999031663,
0.1967132539,
0.3248411119,
-0.2231953442,
0.0813717023,
-0.5533493161,
0.7873693705,
-0.6232118011,
-0.5479699969,
-0.5719915032,
-0.4287211597,
0.2927277088,
-0.2454606146,
0.0988223031,
-0.104864195,
-0.1146676242,
0.4077146649,
-0.3065756261,
0.539820075,
-0.3718046546,
-0.2546100318,
0.1953071356,
0.2164435834,
0.7439209223,
-0.3602963388,
-0.4247019291,
-0.6069257855,
-0.4103017747,
-0.3357235789,
-0.9201188087,
0.6538043022,
-0.6394926906,
-0.4231378436,
-0.05453429,
-0.6005146503,
-0.429518342,
0.1494235396,
0.0787590817,
0.5727586746,
-0.0271615535,
0.4159583449,
0.3955948353,
-0.1304388493,
0.4689169228,
0.4348582029,
-0.1570788026,
-0.3721434772,
1.0907785892,
0.175833106,
0.902056098,
0.1923440844,
0.2913181484,
-0.2806792855,
-0.8487942219,
-0.1873897016,
0.1997191906,
-0.6682314873,
0.1071054041,
-0.3797754049,
-0.1498621553,
-0.1513888538,
-0.0240976531,
-0.590768218,
-0.5087282062,
-0.230981186,
-0.4747325778,
0.1067979708,
0.6720393896,
0.0473475084,
0.8536355495,
-0.5589385033,
0.391955018,
0.3408887684,
0.3763945103,
0.2305914015,
-0.4801963866,
-0.4449453652,
0.2355213463,
-0.6207917333,
-1.0720565319,
0.221741721,
0.5075536966,
0.8906435966,
0.8074643612,
0.0182994287,
0.4738591611,
-0.0912899673,
0.7069445252,
0.4097569585,
-0.9307116866,
0.3103666306,
-0.2779083848,
0.3317725658,
0.5610260963,
0.304869324,
-0.1045557708,
-0.7460584641,
-0.6581268311,
-1.0182921886,
0.3530924916,
-0.0024351534,
0.5568329692,
0.142187044,
0.0924205557,
-0.12536861,
0.4603101611,
-0.7512066364,
-0.2602711916,
-0.0703756362,
-0.2081115246,
0.3164072633,
-0.4533299804,
-0.0902030244,
-0.2573288083,
0.801230967,
-0.0645177811,
0.0613584183,
-0.3638994098,
-0.1046717614,
-0.0853067115,
0.2228293121,
0.677290976,
0.8739178181,
0.0630995929,
0.268376261,
0.0105174324,
-0.2281641662,
0.5643314719,
-0.040011134,
-0.3980630636,
-0.2416491657,
0.5572174788,
1.1147631407,
0.3036606312,
-0.2137796581,
0.494817704,
0.5736956596,
-0.0734330416,
0.2139860094,
0.2609971166,
0.0510541424,
0.0932722762,
0.2910010815,
-0.1042160392,
-0.2284278572,
-0.7132898569,
0.0529377572,
0.5440152884,
-0.4138380289,
-0.6157585382,
0.5543966293,
0.244944483,
0.0633682534,
0.667732656,
-0.2325820476,
-0.5554563403,
0.4912087023,
0.6543191075,
0.8382579088,
-0.7146675587,
0.1385273933,
0.1584019214,
0.1050193235,
-0.137074247,
0.4706654847,
-0.2042797804,
-1.096304059,
-0.6785706878,
-0.3855428994,
-0.2311004698,
-0.0097599765,
-0.5113523602,
0.316016376,
-0.3424006104,
-0.5738771558,
0.1123349741,
-0.399459064,
-0.517393887,
0.1046381518,
0.0006639719,
0.5834879875,
-0.9979090095,
0.9023499489,
0.5887613297,
-0.5166610479,
-0.7938421369,
-0.0129207289,
-0.2618433833,
-0.4410929978,
0.7299093604,
-0.1735094041,
-0.2362478673,
0.0095428517,
-0.4738209546,
-0.7505598068,
0.7434715033,
0.4514231384,
-0.2566104233,
-0.0428078733,
0.1349072158,
0.4901606143,
-0.349992156,
0.1477339864,
0.8781644702,
1.1342252493,
0.2300119847,
-0.9629256129,
-0.0778924823,
-0.1884705126,
-0.0829165429,
-0.0018992365,
-0.577937603,
0.5834106207,
-0.0552750155,
-0.1022628695,
0.1339281946,
0.8235782981,
0.2585245073,
-0.1705873311,
0.64052248,
0.3933857083,
0.7064512968,
-0.0627472326,
1.0713541508,
-1.0156441927,
0.1885235012,
0.8710306883,
-0.1277156621,
0.5795143843,
0.571157217,
-0.0993034244,
0.5535900593,
-0.0656614602,
0.1510837525,
0.7671843171,
0.4855498374,
-0.6912949681,
-0.0864420012,
-0.3483021557,
-0.1715445668,
0.6146685481,
0.4597300291,
-0.3160662949,
0.1419122368,
0.3888227046,
0.1100918353,
-0.0560868979,
0.0669594854,
0.8144935369,
-0.2693863809,
-1.0704494715,
0.6086841822,
0.1328711212,
0.4054058194,
-0.8652045727,
0.1544359624,
-0.0656774789,
0.08924862,
-0.1106218472,
-0.7095953226,
0.0314397998,
-0.5263480544,
-0.1903900206,
-0.4967705309,
0.6680136919,
-0.9479250908,
-0.1674539745,
0.504152,
0.307528317,
-0.4211600125,
-0.0699747056,
-0.4281171262,
0.2896505594,
-0.1282330006,
-0.7662107348,
0.1740572304,
0.4274640977,
0.173357591,
0.7157605886,
0.6730359793,
0.554425478,
0.4452459812,
0.2632523477,
0.9098398089,
-0.6053215265,
-0.4878355861,
-0.5674456358,
0.8359033465,
-0.1098892465,
-0.175617218,
0.7373600006,
0.3775248528,
0.4088513255,
0.0060793688,
0.8957509398,
0.13326855,
-0.1214464828,
-0.6678737402,
0.4185481369,
-0.3671326339,
0.2669243217,
-0.1014317721,
-1.5622617006,
-0.2047274709,
0.4553013146,
0.0066886498,
0.3579261899,
0.704529345,
0.9145259857,
-0.1390630901,
-0.3982991874,
0.1417559236,
0.3224064708,
0.6036940217,
0.3629616797,
1.1826092005,
0.0564023331,
0.3348883688,
-0.3343921006,
-0.3283596933,
-0.1811306179,
-1.2308577299,
-0.6267994642,
-0.4267369211,
-0.4192946553,
-0.5925210714,
-0.1320040077,
0.8385398388,
1.1161190271,
-0.8378908038,
-0.2531036437,
-0.0544403717,
0.0875113532,
-0.4012154937,
-0.1775686592,
0.2612583041,
-0.3926700652,
-0.9139774442,
0.8663324118,
0.2993121445,
0.3529866934,
-0.9207273126,
-0.195463106,
-0.2148550898,
0.1909465343,
0.6823655963,
0.263384819,
-0.3543299735,
-0.1848893315,
-0.2338919044,
-0.2030079514,
0.1315741241,
1.1197359562,
-0.4206338525,
0.7923464179,
0.9145609736,
0.4286005795,
0.7360903025,
0.2429062873,
0.899730444,
-0.9136305451,
0.5957475305,
0.0463344343,
0.2672775388,
0.1956387758,
-0.0438939221,
-0.1063537374,
0.2066416293,
-0.1920856237,
-0.4185483754,
0.3605541587,
-1.0139306784,
-0.1487117857,
1.4236366749,
0.0422227569,
0.1344320625,
-0.1423939019,
-0.277671814,
0.2603134215,
-0.4727398157,
0.4773393869,
0.8435304165,
-0.0862554759,
-0.0701930523,
-0.5092939734,
0.3478300571,
0.5546522737,
-0.6193301678,
0.0678692535,
0.4805499315,
-0.0878427476,
0.3057290912,
0.3755685389,
0.0031405671,
-0.0679102093,
-0.0596238822,
-0.0525564589,
-0.0801657215,
-0.8213474154,
-0.2601583898,
0.2128750086,
0.3857164383,
0.1040868014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17557v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17557v1 | The FineWeb Datasets: Decanting the Web for the Finest Text Data at Scale | 2024-06-25T13:50:56 | 2024-06-25T13:50:56 | Guilherme Penedo, Hynek Kydlíček, Loubna Ben allal, Anton Lozhkov, Margaret Mitchell, Colin Raffel, Leandro Von Werra, Thomas Wolf | cs.CL | cs.CL | The performance of a large language model (LLM) depends heavily on the
quality and size of its pretraining dataset. However, the pretraining datasets
for state-of-the-art open LLMs like Llama 3 and Mixtral are not publicly
available and very little is known about how they were created. In this work,
we introduce FineWeb, a 15-trillion token dataset derived from 96 Common Crawl
snapshots that produces better-performing LLMs than other open pretraining
datasets. To advance the understanding of how best to curate high-quality
pretraining datasets, we carefully document and ablate all of the design
choices used in FineWeb, including in-depth investigations of deduplication and
filtering strategies. In addition, we introduce FineWeb-Edu, a 1.3-trillion
token collection of educational text filtered from FineWeb. LLMs pretrained on
FineWeb-Edu exhibit dramatically better performance on knowledge- and
reasoning-intensive benchmarks like MMLU and ARC. Along with our datasets, we
publicly release our data curation codebase and all of the models trained
during our ablation experiments. | [
-0.7350717187,
-0.4349167347,
0.203084141,
-0.1018950492,
-0.3629357219,
0.0973361731,
-0.3429537714,
-0.4022494853,
0.0280305389,
0.5467486382,
-0.4251900613,
-0.6441628933,
-0.5645136833,
0.1823605001,
-0.7254060507,
1.0418471098,
0.1697216481,
0.0159503166,
-0.3869540691,
-0.0931536332,
0.1397977918,
-0.4343872964,
-0.4484606981,
-0.4120191038,
0.5758108497,
0.4886543453,
0.5607350469,
0.9432474375,
0.5875299573,
0.1607204229,
-0.0629067495,
0.3027242422,
-1.0531946421,
-0.3215919435,
-0.4439171553,
-0.4150691628,
-0.2869145572,
0.2789504528,
0.3356845081,
0.8232883215,
-0.2157222331,
0.3234998286,
0.2461163551,
0.70317173,
-0.7376417518,
-0.114577122,
-0.6321377158,
-0.2685946226,
-0.6330716014,
0.003523258,
-0.3551087976,
-0.5458129048,
-0.0362907574,
-0.7700179219,
0.312692374,
0.0220623128,
0.8602742553,
0.2780461013,
-0.3252570927,
-0.2115939558,
-0.4862456024,
0.7605337501,
-0.6623610854,
0.6046255827,
0.5481167436,
-0.0593163371,
-0.2809761763,
-1.0295296907,
-0.550055027,
0.289580375,
0.1145863608,
-0.095106177,
-0.242404744,
0.1111071482,
-0.0211285055,
0.6887655854,
-0.7217491269,
0.6294882298,
-0.3942570686,
-0.3443312347,
0.4670919776,
0.1194461435,
0.1966645867,
0.0576508343,
-0.2092317045,
-0.2805691659,
-0.9472430348,
-0.2804645598,
0.4930393994,
0.4135506749,
-0.0533549897,
0.5254395604,
-0.4334208369,
0.791262269,
-0.1597805768,
-0.2636747956,
0.248803094,
-0.2223600745,
-0.0768396929,
-0.2031339556,
0.7842885256,
0.5082818866,
0.550450027,
-0.2900804281,
-0.3470086455,
0.0245465878,
0.2354927063,
-1.0741930008,
-0.4115591049,
0.2284742445,
-0.5078633428,
-0.1250492781,
0.0224996079,
-0.6227155328,
-0.38896662,
-0.6888220906,
0.2740561664,
-0.3661524355,
-0.110425055,
0.1809632182,
-0.0743658319,
0.0006078627,
0.2863717973,
-0.9414227605,
0.3581092656,
0.757905066,
0.6723383069,
-0.456202805,
-0.4030081928,
-0.3223342896,
0.0063054501,
-0.4169249833,
0.8792605996,
-0.4546790719,
-0.1810757369,
0.2158643603,
-0.1724458933,
0.2903963327,
-0.7260552049,
0.413608849,
-0.7121023536,
-0.0218832418,
-0.0594752133,
-0.727720499,
-0.0309092384,
0.2163926512,
-0.8267233372,
0.8326072693,
0.0665758625,
-0.7824831009,
0.463424921,
-0.4174822271,
-0.5852703452,
-0.0185877848,
-0.0280401111,
0.0247421153,
0.0918083638,
0.3605019748,
0.661777854,
-0.4442280829,
0.3116085529,
-0.3192088306,
-0.4536938369,
-0.0809542462,
-0.4737373292,
0.6430283189,
0.5583743453,
-0.0177549422,
-0.2265339047,
-1.2234429121,
0.0388997123,
0.0699436963,
-0.5747651458,
-0.5586814284,
0.030487651,
0.1315750927,
-0.0538880453,
0.4128600657,
-0.475838542,
0.2255212516,
-0.3464939892,
0.4777542651,
0.8391644955,
-0.3208649158,
0.3946663737,
-0.24428083,
0.3298737407,
-0.0539285168,
0.1309975237,
-0.0917044356,
-0.0110788774,
-0.882245779,
-0.2074271291,
0.4581800699,
0.1503175795,
-0.4741502404,
0.167000562,
-0.4244301021,
-0.7494646311,
-0.6918830872,
0.2796328962,
0.3201165497,
0.1375316381,
0.4594272077,
-0.1666842997,
-0.4763348699,
-0.8005535007,
-0.1614179462,
0.1769739091,
-0.2259990126,
0.1734147519,
0.2661992908,
-0.4654591978,
0.9988846183,
-0.6015353799,
-0.2893267572,
-0.1938290298,
0.0943050981,
0.0898979306,
0.3880495727,
0.3495700955,
-0.5496724248,
-0.2526566386,
-0.1663040668,
-0.498829484,
-0.2690865397,
0.0659423769,
-0.2676864862,
-0.0258723516,
0.6323019862,
-0.4304409027,
0.0765023828,
0.6886897683,
-0.0509214811,
0.5089503527,
-0.0026591949,
-0.0989108086,
-1.081590414,
0.0798712671,
-0.2062417716,
-0.315952301,
-0.27245,
0.2572230399,
-0.0058986787,
-0.010493557,
-0.4943800271,
0.6868420839,
-0.3680694997,
-0.071431309,
-0.2732560337,
0.4898675978,
0.1058000103,
0.2797622979,
-0.3713305295,
0.9174252748,
0.3699344993,
-0.84575212,
0.0575297736,
0.4988193214,
-0.4763549864,
0.2745531797,
-0.314499259,
0.119161509,
0.0400121212,
0.1490439922,
-0.5781672597,
-0.4032135606,
-0.357514739,
-0.2272024751,
0.2065905184,
-0.0171803497,
-0.6102699637,
-0.3345775902,
-0.2231589407,
0.1693428904,
0.3343844712,
-1.0114529133,
0.1592655033,
0.6080403924,
-0.0705512762,
-0.6013831496,
-0.5633593798,
0.0430844352,
0.0130404634,
-0.2749939561,
0.2802057266,
-0.1127469242,
-0.1280872971,
-0.1724679321,
-0.1999054551,
-0.2003365904,
0.3093934655,
0.1941496283,
0.0512405112,
-0.1371875107,
0.0589306168,
-0.1287565678,
-0.0944599584,
0.0357636623,
-0.2512132525,
0.8502113819,
0.0797861964,
-0.4133696854,
-0.4280501902,
-0.0523989797,
0.4121728837,
-0.2009889334,
0.6907299161,
0.5045149922,
-0.3618274033,
-0.4105544984,
-0.5630833507,
-0.1388887167,
-0.4847736955,
0.1066220701,
-0.1318562329,
-1.0101267099,
0.295214802,
-0.2685379088,
0.3526622653,
0.33776021,
0.2358831465,
-0.1664934605,
0.8071674705,
0.647682488,
-0.3930885792,
0.4775529206,
-0.3994800448,
0.0369469039,
-0.5524864793,
-0.2580363452,
-0.7166150212,
-0.3457607627,
-0.6059388518,
-0.2303647995,
-0.2026512176,
0.4920751452,
-0.4319980145,
0.1579243094,
-0.3494718075,
0.7626555562,
0.8622629642,
0.1395134032,
0.5095555186,
0.2293228209,
-0.161238119,
0.136966303,
-0.5602304935,
-0.8515216112,
1.3557726145,
0.0351477228,
1.0971641541,
-0.0674761906,
0.798697114,
0.0873129219,
0.3004783988,
-0.5850598216,
0.6264302731,
-0.6540184617,
-0.5953359008,
-0.2252193838,
-0.369941771,
-1.0689911842,
-0.0314850472,
-0.1345557272,
-0.4631453753,
-0.12680538,
0.2269681096,
-0.1655311435,
0.3259974122,
-0.5250002146,
0.5586028099,
-0.0068107313,
-0.373193711,
-0.3781870306,
-0.4083416462,
0.1057397127,
-0.2917630076,
0.3680669069,
0.0162947048,
0.2067558467,
0.9529904723,
-0.4779857397,
0.7724398971,
0.0738160983,
-0.1288319379,
0.432742089,
0.1746149063,
0.4517278075,
-0.2402118593,
-0.0240701009,
0.4908148348,
-0.1217177212,
-0.3277327418,
-0.1029282585,
0.7180928588,
-1.0204005241,
-0.4196504056,
-0.026640201,
-0.0651712492,
-0.2857491076,
0.5541239381,
0.4379438162,
0.7814484239,
-0.2868196964,
0.6115964651,
0.5777682662,
-0.2887122333,
0.3872590065,
0.5541343689,
-0.2140297741,
-0.2617227137,
1.133713007,
0.1740690917,
0.0960264429,
0.3753146827,
0.1069440767,
-0.2758550048,
-1.0533686876,
-0.2629043162,
0.1055264473,
-0.7581816912,
-0.4931448996,
-0.6062572598,
-0.2610862553,
-0.3211880922,
-0.2001258582,
-0.5247766376,
-0.2962369025,
-0.6223686934,
-0.3245116174,
0.3009719253,
0.8793026805,
-0.3576689065,
0.5930470228,
-0.8889452815,
0.4442746937,
0.1835650653,
0.7140328884,
0.1153533831,
-0.3768672049,
-0.3739395142,
0.1646704823,
-0.2985327542,
-0.0274263807,
0.0877728686,
0.3102471232,
0.5227820277,
0.736815691,
0.1136729643,
0.7888028026,
-0.6414779425,
0.7911854982,
0.0732405633,
-0.7165166736,
0.4275205731,
-0.3995248973,
0.1063594669,
0.8049152493,
0.6237248778,
-0.2802700102,
-0.3951301277,
-0.5484806895,
-0.9544270635,
0.7632859945,
0.0081060529,
0.2673378885,
-0.2105474621,
0.3669378459,
0.4684651792,
0.291636616,
-0.5625121593,
-0.2795552015,
-0.2180033922,
-0.4355520606,
-0.1771887392,
-0.2122763842,
-0.1033265889,
0.0507265031,
0.6645140648,
-0.1173406988,
-0.1503136307,
-0.2600108087,
-0.5053084493,
0.0765569583,
0.0795279592,
0.0962201804,
0.7708460689,
-0.0489519686,
0.3019467592,
-0.1219083145,
-0.897580266,
0.0317539237,
0.0041434271,
-0.0502944216,
-0.2263423651,
0.5679956079,
0.5728765726,
0.0934668481,
-0.9942856431,
0.4922903478,
0.0562965795,
-0.0635590032,
0.1338949054,
0.3546526432,
0.1668971479,
0.1339537501,
0.3348996341,
-0.2170749307,
0.2598267198,
-0.250285238,
0.2541492581,
0.1811701506,
0.0778046399,
-0.2606226802,
0.6584185362,
0.3626103699,
-0.0391469114,
0.93207407,
0.0264068004,
-0.2589689195,
0.3043758273,
0.4279098213,
0.2609953284,
0.0559088551,
0.1495223492,
0.4135623574,
0.2378563136,
-0.3728101254,
0.1613215953,
0.0804467201,
-0.7727959752,
-0.3354149759,
-1.0788937807,
-0.4270434678,
0.5637802482,
-0.6547692418,
0.2905214429,
-0.4980752468,
-0.1164753661,
-0.2599599659,
0.1739838719,
-1.0072882175,
0.6052938104,
0.2192011327,
1.0396256447,
-0.7028231025,
0.5809391737,
0.4095405638,
-0.3042970002,
-0.8859407902,
-0.1365572363,
-0.1412768364,
-0.8649337292,
0.4874165952,
0.3572613299,
0.000325323,
0.5064634085,
-0.7426486611,
-0.9067974687,
0.8017408848,
0.4501872957,
-0.9439968467,
0.0141321141,
0.3269544244,
0.3741358221,
0.1669358164,
0.0873811245,
0.6297300458,
0.2701290548,
-0.1821663678,
-0.7276577353,
-0.2306908667,
0.0429828651,
-0.2926243842,
0.1043242738,
-0.7682217956,
0.7707234621,
-0.1307655275,
-0.2752167583,
-0.0366493613,
0.397215277,
0.151073426,
0.0952319801,
0.2601528466,
0.9259036779,
0.960398674,
-0.2159355432,
0.8168314099,
-0.2559530735,
0.1673105061,
1.2694548368,
-0.0322887413,
1.0600379705,
0.2931607962,
-0.2753510773,
0.3254917264,
0.9941629767,
-0.0257216096,
0.6836002469,
0.2342521548,
0.0422763079,
-0.3220739663,
-0.104382284,
-0.222838372,
0.5841935873,
0.2107104808,
-0.0278464593,
-0.3468580842,
0.1770542562,
0.0214021206,
0.0696863458,
-0.4296965003,
0.914214313,
0.1223104149,
-0.4322193265,
0.6744339466,
-0.1599176228,
0.8272109628,
-0.4086711109,
0.2266469151,
-0.6474022865,
0.1665348411,
-0.3147591949,
-0.7816668749,
-0.0659172013,
0.1703288555,
-0.1149865463,
-0.1826209724,
0.5662088394,
-0.2010225952,
-0.0933271125,
0.3201026618,
0.559081614,
0.5131062865,
-0.0486544631,
-0.3180235326,
0.263012141,
-0.1244447753,
-0.5739588737,
0.5304045677,
0.6966764331,
0.0557882786,
0.8757494688,
0.9528279901,
0.1289401054,
0.1068537757,
0.4426987171,
1.0404866934,
-0.5229195952,
-0.4962767363,
-0.7314386368,
0.1771019995,
0.0242922008,
-0.3765747249,
0.6132463217,
0.8534113169,
1.2515473366,
0.1910536438,
0.8038240671,
0.2450627685,
0.5260786414,
-0.6125589609,
0.9260302186,
-0.6833826303,
0.0414524451,
-0.0145935686,
-1.0277563334,
-0.1892954558,
0.5812014937,
0.2209679931,
-0.1024870872,
0.4543916583,
0.6016336083,
-0.20975326,
0.0581226051,
0.1899885833,
0.3324370682,
0.4037522078,
0.1094335243,
0.7236878276,
-0.2316961139,
0.645231545,
-0.0981392637,
-0.0526883937,
-0.3832200766,
-0.8584116697,
-1.0525606871,
-0.4678778052,
0.0004004946,
-0.0928077772,
-0.0768767297,
0.8540474176,
0.7177671194,
-0.756722033,
-0.0014350754,
-0.2742927969,
-0.0893323123,
0.2144874036,
-0.1278311014,
0.3547143638,
-0.3142217994,
-0.6894537807,
0.410366267,
-0.1830736548,
0.253777802,
-0.3085763156,
0.1461977214,
0.055097647,
0.0333739929,
0.6436164379,
-0.034428753,
-0.4005265236,
-0.2200892419,
-0.1938875467,
-0.3268821537,
-0.027365325,
0.4904727638,
-0.8625686765,
0.1716177464,
0.2558353543,
0.8364630342,
0.4161252081,
-0.0636106879,
0.433908999,
-0.6011924744,
0.0842149258,
0.1339076757,
0.276651144,
0.403082937,
-0.0303290971,
0.6502312422,
-0.0750519708,
-0.50763309,
-0.9314557314,
-0.2187051773,
-0.7562070489,
-0.521391809,
1.1517789364,
-0.042331513,
0.0111149037,
-0.0938311145,
-0.0114230849,
0.3557114899,
-0.2909013033,
0.7024388909,
0.8773512244,
0.3809733391,
0.2554423213,
-0.5247578621,
0.4859289229,
-0.0614275187,
-0.8545171618,
0.3035350144,
0.6456012726,
0.4133786261,
0.0148696704,
0.5197211504,
0.0565203205,
-0.2068460584,
0.0507471077,
0.1473693252,
-0.3057617247,
-0.5964946747,
-0.0039516818,
0.2235034108,
0.1081207246,
-0.0250783004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17553v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17553v1 | Retrieval-Augmented Code Generation for Situated Action Generation: A Case Study on Minecraft | 2024-06-25T13:43:24 | 2024-06-25T13:43:24 | Chalamalasetti Kranti, Sherzod Hakimov, David Schlangen | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the Minecraft Collaborative Building Task, two players collaborate: an
Architect (A) provides instructions to a Builder (B) to assemble a specified
structure using 3D blocks. In this work, we investigate the use of large
language models (LLMs) to predict the sequence of actions taken by the Builder.
Leveraging LLMs' in-context learning abilities, we use few-shot prompting
techniques, that significantly improve performance over baseline methods.
Additionally, we present a detailed analysis of the gaps in performance for
future work | [
-0.2774254084,
-1.204788208,
0.7714689374,
0.2320550382,
0.2017386109,
-0.0319699422,
-0.0168856401,
-0.4391140044,
0.0452628434,
0.5156933665,
-0.6802591085,
-0.5164545178,
-0.2672539055,
-0.0049787904,
-0.2535566986,
0.254533112,
-0.174890846,
-0.2455137223,
-0.4294445515,
0.0520102382,
-0.8264144659,
-0.3091976047,
-0.3869548142,
-0.220816344,
0.2847139835,
0.5930654407,
0.5028591156,
0.5411468148,
0.4500028789,
0.4887210727,
-0.0793413222,
0.3623722792,
-0.5183073282,
0.2586405873,
-0.1708978117,
-0.2171383202,
-0.3840533197,
-0.2038753331,
0.3368140161,
0.4667028189,
-0.0960780233,
0.5721383691,
0.0455523245,
0.411521852,
-0.5815631747,
0.2727258503,
-0.3850277066,
0.2333329171,
0.1205150858,
-0.2318731695,
-0.4807457924,
-0.3954479396,
-0.0142073287,
-0.3162107766,
0.1592115313,
0.22902973,
0.207171157,
0.272009939,
-0.0995664522,
-0.3651101589,
-0.4318317473,
0.7580410242,
-0.6945130229,
0.1344467402,
0.5353838205,
0.1217869297,
-0.5762555003,
-0.8541918993,
-0.4416481256,
-0.2388778776,
-0.1289375126,
0.0262846965,
0.092117995,
0.0000754067,
0.6751353741,
0.1661573797,
-0.668602109,
0.0257509034,
-0.5206601024,
0.0690605044,
0.886787653,
0.3578887582,
0.2276984304,
-0.5776417851,
-0.2698562443,
0.1532942355,
-0.8869842887,
0.0602538437,
0.0783096403,
0.4948158264,
-0.2196017057,
0.9073107839,
-0.0935437605,
0.9317041636,
0.2630713284,
-0.1368635893,
0.0100235855,
-0.2257431448,
-0.4103249609,
0.1132786795,
0.4552292228,
0.2233946472,
-0.1228835285,
0.1712112725,
-0.1304258704,
-0.2837714553,
0.5957028866,
-0.6866738796,
-0.226641506,
0.5050603151,
-0.6005887985,
-0.3190802038,
-0.0098903244,
-0.3555746675,
-0.4170502722,
-0.2953680158,
0.4431097507,
-0.1182347313,
-0.2056034207,
-0.3208819628,
-0.0193696916,
0.1672386378,
0.1319586486,
-0.6027644277,
0.1328460276,
0.6577906013,
0.811168313,
-0.059272632,
-0.3511980772,
-1.1632139683,
0.3576322794,
-0.3135190904,
0.6011930108,
-0.6131820679,
-0.8866748214,
0.3970853984,
-0.3414842486,
0.3477603793,
-0.518863976,
-0.1099326015,
-0.6357249618,
0.4187958241,
-0.1549243629,
-0.5374330878,
-0.2112630606,
0.5555655956,
-0.7893446684,
1.1105847359,
0.2530877888,
-0.4904150367,
0.286088407,
-0.8206548095,
-0.4023089707,
0.367477566,
-0.4796994328,
-0.3005573153,
0.3382535279,
-0.0039106579,
0.7505629659,
0.1475560665,
0.1162898019,
-0.2126411051,
-0.6424186826,
0.0273788068,
0.0905986577,
0.4077418447,
0.0589792505,
-0.3694011867,
0.2136868984,
-0.595369041,
0.1871833354,
-0.0439754538,
-0.5726409554,
0.0746428892,
0.2276822031,
-0.3092958331,
0.5031573176,
0.3229364455,
-0.1882191598,
0.3906532228,
-0.2987924814,
-0.3196797669,
0.6454505324,
0.3837304711,
0.4127709568,
-0.3352398574,
0.6769592762,
-0.2836254835,
-0.0845444798,
-0.2043793201,
-0.4695317149,
-0.093674615,
-0.1988983303,
-0.051547423,
0.5063660145,
-1.127569437,
0.0307278857,
-0.0414740518,
-0.1438907236,
-0.1171898544,
0.4247907102,
0.7146809697,
0.4085667729,
0.1522687972,
-0.286154896,
-0.7725253701,
-0.1791149825,
0.0231364593,
-0.4242834449,
-0.0793433264,
0.7165206075,
0.2402344048,
0.0257824194,
0.8034184575,
-0.6361979842,
0.0690971613,
-0.324434191,
0.1995160729,
0.2481690347,
0.4033305049,
0.560903132,
-0.8282507062,
-0.6639938354,
-0.1011407077,
-0.9702388644,
0.0093034217,
0.0089471266,
-0.1454988867,
0.0679787919,
0.9895141721,
-0.4428738356,
0.5832239389,
0.8018411994,
-0.1428410262,
0.4855684638,
-0.064922601,
0.1838099957,
-1.4499123096,
0.0412906073,
-0.2851463258,
-0.1777140051,
-0.3462389708,
0.3495341539,
-0.3073725104,
-0.276542604,
-0.8441138268,
0.6609149575,
-0.862953186,
-0.3546591699,
-0.3567644954,
0.4659309089,
-0.3108562231,
0.4683943391,
0.3072107136,
0.7803794146,
0.453998059,
-0.7694432139,
0.5127495527,
0.4863391817,
-0.3526696265,
0.4901642799,
-0.6173036695,
0.2747120261,
0.22602126,
-0.0877654627,
-0.9099436998,
-0.6956523061,
-0.166355595,
-0.6007744074,
0.3831675351,
-0.5669324398,
-0.622076273,
-0.6139913797,
-0.250875175,
0.2583092451,
0.5136111379,
-0.6953724027,
0.5117325187,
0.2348013967,
-0.1419855952,
-0.3196778595,
-0.6409275532,
-0.2318482846,
-0.0556345508,
-0.7122761607,
0.2927527428,
-0.2172531635,
-0.5399366021,
0.0447575897,
0.08448264,
-0.1703590304,
0.0977217704,
0.7193834782,
0.2844221294,
-0.3163839281,
0.1279337853,
-0.2829098403,
0.2210940123,
0.1324437559,
0.087937355,
0.4720100164,
0.1167616919,
-0.6556624174,
0.0104043623,
0.6279242635,
0.2730782926,
-0.2757172585,
0.826423943,
0.366920352,
-0.3791026175,
-0.3039298654,
-0.4177273512,
-0.0479467623,
-0.5930168033,
0.2127180845,
-0.429136306,
-1.0442376137,
0.5179360509,
-0.6912896037,
0.3039650619,
0.0264624488,
0.6478562951,
-0.1274413019,
1.0680184364,
0.8430603147,
0.1684708744,
0.9258021116,
-0.2252375931,
-0.0007884671,
-0.8714897633,
-0.3068944514,
-0.2697568834,
-0.5096156597,
-0.6554539204,
-0.690055728,
0.4548995197,
0.2514315248,
-0.1753073633,
0.5493748188,
-0.3246369064,
0.7671720386,
0.3903110027,
0.1627366096,
-0.0806371719,
0.0327225402,
-0.3076766729,
0.1734850556,
-0.8134132028,
-0.5037006736,
0.799572885,
-0.1719454676,
0.499030143,
0.5285233259,
1.2837002277,
0.2909470201,
0.2580091655,
-0.8788730502,
0.6615431905,
0.3243862987,
-0.6114590764,
-0.3120396733,
-0.347356379,
-1.2241408825,
-0.1131627336,
-0.2989845276,
-0.7117162943,
-0.1319678873,
0.1444356889,
-0.7937566042,
0.1132995859,
-0.8466538191,
0.6763710976,
-0.0849469528,
-0.7901105285,
-0.3226515651,
-0.5086994767,
0.3182707727,
0.1397349238,
0.1468441486,
0.2926729918,
0.2412991971,
-0.0705000609,
-0.3341145813,
0.9018439651,
-0.2083617449,
0.0837052763,
0.7701617479,
0.8149849772,
0.7325973511,
-0.0052980124,
-0.3058919311,
-0.5165016651,
-0.4872338772,
-0.4307716191,
-0.5365136862,
0.9870486856,
-0.3855236471,
-0.6405648589,
-0.0649416521,
-0.3368862271,
-0.2595084906,
0.0450668186,
0.0299155172,
0.6339563131,
-0.4898418188,
0.2575391233,
0.5423520803,
-0.3230762184,
0.9722729325,
0.5668826699,
-0.2894339561,
-0.1503872722,
0.3966805637,
-0.0875764787,
0.0918284878,
0.3100056946,
-0.1433826834,
-0.0001120216,
-0.5085759759,
-0.3363108635,
0.0227770172,
-0.4969940484,
-0.458801657,
-0.1880863011,
-0.1123441979,
-0.1447526813,
-0.9088069201,
-0.2311796248,
-0.1846684068,
-0.3249857724,
-0.3157514036,
0.239122957,
1.2297120094,
0.0000687974,
0.062685594,
-1.3166534901,
0.2266900092,
0.5297683477,
0.4738017917,
0.0480517335,
-0.289144665,
-0.4170641601,
-0.3189339042,
-0.2704589963,
-0.7284690738,
0.3700752258,
-0.1807898879,
0.7107619047,
-0.0245986227,
-0.0575536974,
0.7938501239,
-0.7312916517,
1.3063637018,
0.0835430101,
-0.7486789227,
0.928504765,
-0.3083323836,
0.57012707,
0.3113416433,
0.2473777533,
-0.2526957393,
0.0795251578,
-0.8688370585,
-0.7770427465,
0.8013260365,
0.1246080324,
0.2769637108,
-0.4654293656,
0.3360759914,
-0.2386054546,
0.0970356315,
-0.4145261049,
0.1180359125,
0.3076156378,
-0.0394728258,
0.361951977,
-0.297124058,
-0.280018419,
0.2149617821,
0.3924182951,
-0.2280234993,
0.4249539673,
0.157202363,
-0.3316173553,
-0.4676405489,
0.0031464375,
0.7635694742,
0.719353497,
0.0500937216,
0.0532269627,
0.4299773276,
-0.2807199955,
-0.2033374906,
-0.0720524192,
0.3600334227,
-0.1940677762,
0.5761198997,
0.4781304002,
0.2997003198,
-0.6484020352,
0.5947608352,
0.1860745549,
-0.0889967009,
-0.2982954383,
0.1869832128,
0.0763412192,
0.8626197577,
0.0396611877,
-0.1527600437,
0.1805604696,
-0.6566988826,
0.4231325984,
0.19047755,
-0.327845037,
-0.3056534231,
0.486436367,
0.4626909196,
-0.6887188554,
0.6789899468,
-0.3263996243,
-0.3300601244,
0.5925523043,
0.6248546839,
1.1502162218,
-0.1878494769,
0.2473849654,
0.5592343211,
-0.1956346184,
-0.2187657505,
0.6441940069,
-0.236378476,
-0.3911444247,
-0.8424898982,
-0.4975241721,
-0.4895918071,
-0.3427086473,
-0.4911814332,
0.187173754,
-0.6491051912,
-0.1380258948,
-0.585593164,
0.3158791959,
-0.6841078401,
-0.0229780227,
0.4486743808,
0.7073393464,
-0.4451293349,
0.5400707126,
0.9684744477,
-0.5359966755,
-1.000266552,
0.0599750765,
0.3564556837,
-0.4966010451,
0.7166924477,
-0.1768610477,
-0.238535285,
-0.1129452288,
-1.0314151049,
-0.7653248906,
1.3828792572,
-0.0294081084,
-0.3654344082,
0.0799039751,
-0.2821759582,
0.700473249,
-0.2955525219,
-0.0680104867,
-0.1390249431,
0.072848849,
0.3537076116,
-1.0278935432,
0.112615414,
-0.2203401327,
0.1390583813,
0.3199837506,
-0.7088849545,
0.4825192988,
-0.364069432,
0.0470999926,
0.140978545,
0.7811230421,
0.7492696047,
0.2789528668,
0.0406146348,
0.0793687403,
0.6862031221,
0.1878090352,
1.422986269,
-0.3295185268,
0.0877924114,
1.3708453178,
-0.2989617288,
1.3057278395,
0.3546214998,
-0.0773479566,
0.7034736276,
0.3074984252,
0.2703994811,
0.4422177374,
0.1292084605,
-0.422136575,
-0.1829434037,
0.0052916994,
-0.1706485152,
0.5372584462,
0.3362421095,
-0.3976129591,
0.1377823353,
-0.2548451722,
-0.0049540079,
0.22162278,
-0.4568421543,
1.0142717361,
0.0724704489,
-0.7285212278,
0.2238106579,
-0.1956615746,
0.4194967449,
-0.4535519481,
-0.4569343328,
-0.380007267,
-0.0042710085,
-0.4105445743,
-0.926481545,
0.3808396757,
0.1313829273,
-0.2188606262,
-0.3524573147,
0.6757605076,
-0.4897454679,
-0.1768408269,
0.0209412817,
0.6424779296,
0.1361574978,
0.0287588127,
-0.6221118569,
0.1455246359,
-0.0117652444,
-0.3013882041,
0.3446393013,
0.7233601809,
-0.2370958775,
0.4264734685,
0.6080335975,
-0.1769011766,
0.186781019,
0.0018686154,
0.8610342145,
-0.7431364059,
-0.1628096402,
-0.6247524023,
0.8157950044,
-0.2433300018,
0.061902415,
0.8781519532,
0.6266938448,
0.9256718159,
-0.2115134895,
0.3762176931,
-0.3767975867,
0.3216372728,
-0.5461142659,
0.3450049758,
-0.3073426187,
0.4012139738,
-0.4536963999,
-0.9786943793,
-0.5254369974,
0.5784448385,
-0.2646578848,
0.1458219737,
0.4207225144,
0.8609648943,
-0.1085949093,
-0.3878327906,
0.6396675706,
-0.0160229933,
0.2793093324,
0.3567040861,
0.7629837394,
-0.3407957554,
0.4772776663,
0.0497756638,
0.1088164076,
-0.3948329985,
-1.0180559158,
-1.0434066057,
-0.3079034984,
-0.4127948582,
-0.3936625421,
-0.2170257568,
1.2659813166,
0.852006495,
-0.7750158906,
-0.3373914957,
0.0144448476,
0.1884528548,
-0.2583350837,
-0.1847425997,
0.1988343149,
-0.2042464912,
-0.617008388,
0.781693399,
0.2480966598,
0.1372862905,
-0.1007430181,
-0.3734873235,
-0.3557444513,
0.114240706,
1.0626120567,
0.3814200461,
-0.4797867835,
-0.3801617622,
0.1358369291,
-0.1284090281,
-0.1147444621,
0.7530287504,
-0.9155250192,
0.6574643254,
0.9685902596,
0.4308888316,
0.5662014484,
0.409085393,
0.6510140896,
-1.5416183472,
0.1821734607,
0.1462800354,
0.1140172556,
0.2788261175,
-0.431453079,
0.7723590732,
-0.1251300722,
-0.5576501489,
-0.5734512806,
0.1977195144,
-0.624093473,
-0.2319079787,
1.0985733271,
-0.1801407784,
-0.204128772,
0.0587152392,
-0.5226778388,
0.0663683861,
-0.1333942115,
0.7757957578,
0.6624725461,
-0.4629223943,
-0.3020004034,
-0.4748291969,
0.6607962251,
0.0768381804,
-0.6901237369,
-0.1642157137,
1.1615189314,
-0.0164567865,
0.2829434276,
0.4994131625,
-0.0722252652,
0.4327438176,
0.3714425266,
0.1160264462,
-0.1607485861,
-0.3783307672,
-0.1272131205,
0.3310913444,
0.266127646,
-0.1791130155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17542v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17542v2 | CDQuant: Accurate Post-training Weight Quantization of Large Pre-trained Models using Greedy Coordinate Descent | 2024-06-25T13:29:14 | 2024-06-26T07:44:42 | Pranav Ajit Nair, Arun Sai Suggala | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have recently demonstrated remarkable
performance across diverse language tasks. But their deployment is often
constrained by their substantial computational and storage requirements.
Quantization has emerged as a key technique for addressing this challenge,
enabling the compression of large models with minimal impact on performance.
The recent GPTQ algorithm, a post-training quantization (PTQ) method, has
proven highly effective for compressing LLMs, sparking a wave of research that
leverages GPTQ as a core component. Recognizing the pivotal role of GPTQ in the
PTQ landscape, we introduce CDQuant, a simple and scalable alternative to GPTQ
with improved performance. CDQuant uses coordinate descent to minimize the
layer-wise reconstruction loss to achieve high-quality quantized weights. Our
algorithm is easy to implement and scales efficiently to models with hundreds
of billions of parameters. Through extensive evaluation on the PaLM2 model
family, we demonstrate that CDQuant consistently outperforms GPTQ across
diverse model sizes and quantization levels. In particular, for INT2
quantization of PaLM2-Otter, CDQuant achieves a 10% reduction in perplexity
compared to GPTQ. | [
-0.0859524459,
-0.4990292788,
0.5729740858,
0.1884441823,
-0.4125556946,
0.3851807117,
-0.343480885,
0.0191487353,
-0.2795556486,
0.27080217,
-0.2188897878,
-0.5493775606,
-0.8276612759,
-0.3450008035,
-0.4272027612,
1.0853304863,
-0.1702914983,
0.3556490541,
-0.2920663953,
-0.1074933186,
0.0149189075,
-0.8817076683,
-0.9200296402,
-0.3547659516,
0.3533536196,
0.2144193053,
1.1302388906,
0.4309318066,
0.4396785498,
0.2049429268,
0.1207289994,
-0.1128382981,
-0.7001857162,
-0.1254425347,
0.3809428811,
-0.7899836302,
-0.4281589091,
0.1072036177,
0.5541843176,
0.6526655555,
-0.4569741488,
0.0363273025,
0.0344085097,
0.7826215029,
-0.7914842367,
0.0029364997,
-0.3624756634,
0.0364308581,
-0.2563855946,
-0.1224815995,
-0.1648359001,
-0.4603200853,
0.1781256646,
-0.8180178404,
0.3794953525,
-0.2861763835,
0.7816637158,
0.4099011421,
-0.6599352956,
0.0288520325,
-0.6138957739,
0.9003717899,
-0.4950900972,
0.490783304,
0.3803266585,
0.2067498118,
0.195712328,
-0.8692768812,
-0.5429397821,
-0.2418943197,
0.2956580222,
0.1197373495,
-0.1316255033,
0.1967362911,
0.2896850705,
0.6193854213,
-0.8887322545,
-0.058369603,
0.0372902267,
-0.1105524898,
0.4019489288,
-0.228571713,
0.2855087221,
0.1810787767,
-0.4621435106,
-0.4859969914,
-0.9291229844,
0.0254585147,
0.3320865631,
-0.1294822246,
-0.1620259732,
0.5228357315,
-0.2955583632,
0.6498222947,
0.1126548275,
-0.0682198778,
-0.1034684703,
-0.1322747767,
-0.1355084926,
0.1250708997,
0.6731358767,
0.1189613491,
0.148792848,
-0.0932293609,
-0.4577278495,
0.0403840728,
0.0020303761,
-1.0930896997,
-0.9569814801,
0.3947884738,
-0.3667101562,
-0.079714179,
-0.1282265931,
-0.0038103419,
-0.2671644688,
-0.3869399726,
0.6164839268,
-0.6296930909,
-0.2803444862,
0.2912596762,
-0.1223917753,
0.340362221,
0.6594123244,
-0.5685491562,
0.474750191,
0.8948680758,
0.9230350256,
0.1223894656,
0.2371529192,
-0.7872833014,
0.0806059912,
-0.4122602046,
0.6280776262,
-0.3640248775,
-0.3961924911,
-0.12885876,
-0.3897927403,
0.2438705862,
-0.4884256124,
0.7634814382,
-0.9344290495,
-0.0060050916,
-0.4319092631,
-0.5191322565,
-0.0796930045,
0.2431518435,
-0.7059599161,
0.9152954817,
0.4812672138,
-0.9219107628,
0.3392756283,
-0.2781006098,
-0.3701360822,
0.2790894508,
0.1090561226,
-0.6559324265,
0.2149439156,
0.3531340957,
0.1877844334,
-0.8139328957,
0.0640420169,
-0.4160563946,
-0.461964637,
0.0374317877,
-0.2250435501,
0.9396086931,
0.4555491507,
-0.1751985103,
-0.1201568395,
-0.4795481563,
0.4432527423,
0.3548437357,
-0.3223060071,
-0.5652740598,
-0.0147078801,
0.1117694303,
0.0800711215,
0.3888335228,
-0.3782050312,
0.3752066493,
-0.2670378089,
0.516982317,
0.3169520795,
-0.3602115214,
0.6128240228,
-0.2031268775,
0.6718927622,
-0.1156651378,
0.1858925223,
0.3348310888,
-0.1199676991,
-0.6380626559,
-0.426726371,
0.6875239015,
0.5054631829,
-1.1453233957,
0.3873516321,
-0.5930352211,
-0.6356102228,
-0.2525248528,
-0.0395792313,
0.4516988993,
-0.0861502811,
0.112949945,
-0.5979789495,
-0.3235479593,
-0.5676977038,
-0.216886729,
-0.2408792377,
-0.3674107492,
-0.0523170047,
0.069346413,
0.0828052238,
0.8711249232,
-0.5821750164,
-0.0474045463,
-0.1547252685,
0.4422599375,
0.0900064185,
0.6503203511,
0.4749905765,
-0.9724681973,
-0.5326707959,
-0.0685282052,
-0.4806824923,
-0.0301773846,
-0.0267164651,
-0.0822625607,
-0.0048603993,
0.3124383688,
-0.9757435918,
0.1674391329,
0.8193099499,
0.0342469215,
0.5131188631,
-0.3177946508,
0.2281418592,
-0.664162457,
0.0779178217,
-0.1401138008,
-0.375843823,
-0.3565072417,
0.0534985736,
0.3559209406,
-0.2721218765,
-0.2768491507,
0.2496837378,
-0.5986123681,
-0.2596564591,
-0.182348296,
0.1450708508,
0.033712402,
0.1727681458,
0.2130489498,
0.8078582287,
0.530472517,
-0.4187440276,
0.4637930989,
0.1191462129,
-0.3398708403,
0.6621927023,
-0.9700371623,
0.3015172184,
-0.1275271475,
0.5943614244,
-0.8958110809,
0.1168981045,
0.0069020218,
-0.3032717407,
0.3839872479,
-0.4278874099,
-0.8847971559,
-0.4344983399,
-0.538146615,
0.9630867839,
0.5077823997,
-0.6016067266,
0.1888589114,
0.2945259213,
-0.1539201885,
-0.29390347,
-0.3484106362,
0.1700119972,
-0.2094565034,
-0.5222028494,
0.4386753142,
-0.3353579342,
0.0112137953,
-0.3486737609,
-0.2488162667,
-0.2385206372,
0.0778822154,
0.001424324,
0.0275895968,
-0.0943345055,
0.142915681,
0.1099185422,
-0.1829099804,
0.0031800694,
-0.8463162184,
0.7380876541,
0.0446705669,
0.0252597742,
-0.1752471328,
0.0850829631,
0.2017982751,
-0.5520604849,
0.637237072,
0.8491062522,
-0.3145756721,
-0.3649065495,
-0.3450052142,
0.0125974799,
-0.425098002,
0.4751160145,
-0.6377504468,
-0.9575542212,
0.0693143308,
-0.2752628624,
-0.2652038038,
0.1650935709,
0.4977675974,
0.1265232861,
1.1471182108,
0.5946675539,
-0.0369608179,
0.5040027499,
-0.4669837058,
0.2401413023,
-0.7084671259,
0.2570798397,
-0.469648838,
-0.1007155925,
-0.4331101179,
-0.7237523794,
0.6841326952,
0.5391806364,
-0.4723096788,
0.3943937421,
-0.4618899822,
0.5508087277,
0.5854758024,
0.3299311697,
0.2509213686,
0.0358728766,
0.2149680406,
0.0336783081,
-0.8228718042,
-0.3003118336,
1.3639935255,
0.1915724427,
0.7973333001,
0.2050341517,
0.764277041,
0.2232535332,
0.5433407426,
-0.8984600306,
0.282376498,
-0.3267453611,
-0.2479807436,
-0.3655237257,
-0.7296099663,
-0.8238024712,
0.2196946442,
0.0566228144,
-0.3835223019,
-0.0707318708,
0.1951159835,
-0.654204011,
0.1663214415,
-0.6095490456,
0.8779199123,
-0.234990254,
-0.2598908842,
-0.4074172676,
-0.5960726142,
0.6090691686,
-0.3145784736,
-0.0261795986,
0.0230911598,
-0.3038621545,
0.7503264546,
-0.9692622423,
0.2896949351,
-0.2271327078,
-0.6698670387,
0.3432559073,
0.3611554503,
0.7234095931,
0.3002448082,
0.0825412124,
0.2850793302,
0.3834068179,
-0.6295241714,
-0.6238088608,
0.7624653578,
-0.8968632817,
-0.489885509,
-0.4287442267,
-0.50146842,
-0.300650239,
-0.0545852482,
0.2701234519,
0.4479169548,
-0.0964747071,
0.0005641978,
0.6319547296,
-0.346210897,
0.272059083,
0.3131268919,
0.1298454404,
-0.6784309745,
0.8509011269,
0.0716693029,
0.3273997605,
0.7892886996,
0.0310615841,
-0.3571416438,
-0.5484603643,
-0.2095091939,
0.2413051873,
-0.4924120009,
-0.5824851394,
-0.6063851714,
-0.0784785599,
-0.4027825296,
0.006744165,
-0.6243700385,
-0.7484967709,
-0.0263593923,
0.2086987346,
0.1564321518,
0.2945678234,
-0.1423893273,
0.698025167,
-0.9541191459,
0.4025919437,
0.5425990224,
0.1504878849,
-0.1665070802,
-0.5299082398,
-0.4630227089,
0.1986008584,
-0.533336699,
-0.4468714893,
0.4808897376,
0.3337665498,
-0.164872095,
0.4522656202,
0.3083140254,
0.6731289625,
-0.3760310411,
0.7015011311,
0.3084706664,
-1.2468372583,
0.2733982503,
-0.2291258723,
0.3600794673,
0.2332839072,
0.6088235378,
-0.3841085434,
-0.0695905685,
-0.674529016,
-0.6473557353,
0.5809943676,
0.2882228196,
-0.0098228129,
0.2699287534,
0.4364461005,
-0.0952603519,
0.3936007321,
-0.671364069,
-0.1071968749,
-0.1200743243,
-0.1987134069,
-0.2462121099,
-0.3900568187,
-0.099151291,
-0.0709080026,
0.4613917172,
-0.1322131008,
0.2752543688,
0.1966203898,
-0.3564758897,
-0.2956371903,
-0.0509992018,
0.1981998384,
0.4483204186,
-0.1597993076,
0.225712195,
-0.122766532,
-0.3767307997,
0.2083750963,
0.356964767,
-0.0807306617,
-0.1758608371,
0.2539541423,
0.3682765663,
0.2735956013,
-0.5815660954,
0.9076061845,
-0.1651279181,
-0.1687254161,
-0.4064308405,
-0.1118412912,
-0.153908506,
0.2417483479,
0.3189509511,
-0.1604744941,
0.3327670991,
-0.2875375152,
0.2053577602,
0.680277586,
-0.1613867432,
-0.3612081707,
0.9633665085,
0.0271569602,
0.2608343065,
0.6328229904,
-0.1794332862,
-0.6047276258,
0.5608072281,
0.2089693993,
0.7910705805,
-0.3597520292,
0.3799178302,
0.4383655787,
0.1100189686,
-0.3295252025,
0.2543034852,
-0.4142195284,
-0.6795669794,
-0.6704761386,
-0.6388455033,
-0.2053835243,
-0.192472741,
-0.6102377772,
0.131389305,
-0.5311654806,
-0.3452061713,
-0.3518974185,
0.3137133718,
-0.6734442115,
0.3517122865,
0.2108033001,
0.662183702,
-0.3375795782,
1.2494262457,
0.5264986157,
-0.2156298459,
-0.7689707875,
0.0519734919,
-0.165895015,
-0.6618239284,
0.8715173006,
-0.1595085561,
0.2678153515,
0.449837029,
-0.7631418705,
-0.9716697931,
1.0907441378,
0.6808726788,
-0.6300427318,
-0.0301765222,
0.274395436,
0.3727661967,
0.1362275481,
0.4945150614,
0.4958731532,
0.3380268216,
0.1745168418,
-0.9497490525,
0.1011578515,
0.1124139801,
0.367313236,
0.3819952905,
-0.7978050709,
1.0256016254,
-0.3860939145,
-0.452441901,
0.4479660094,
0.5988887548,
0.2894348502,
-0.1250753254,
0.619972229,
0.7631719112,
0.7063395977,
-0.3106743991,
1.2836710215,
-0.5188342333,
0.6708755493,
0.8405916095,
-0.3532298505,
0.6692374945,
0.2576176822,
-0.6268057227,
0.194082424,
0.7821998,
0.3404666483,
0.524962604,
0.6924067736,
-0.5912421346,
-0.5772420764,
-0.0543936938,
-0.2979703546,
0.2193983346,
0.0714462101,
0.2666431069,
-0.1486019939,
-0.0886017904,
0.2147976011,
-0.1290222406,
-0.2940309942,
0.5007289052,
0.2583171129,
-0.4536440372,
1.2104766369,
0.1394548118,
0.5623759031,
-0.723302424,
0.0513730198,
-0.271194011,
0.0802461654,
-0.0525340699,
-0.2931055725,
-0.2274962813,
-0.308617115,
0.0447466299,
-0.3387202919,
0.2786308825,
-0.7100305557,
-0.3416962624,
0.0221749172,
0.4882745445,
-0.0334284306,
-0.752574861,
-0.7169158459,
0.2221434712,
-0.1761018038,
-0.2934974134,
0.2977996171,
0.7830985188,
0.0195131432,
0.7085471153,
0.6405625939,
0.2147604674,
-0.2256280482,
0.0406505093,
0.923338294,
-0.4957667291,
-0.3846691847,
-0.414434731,
0.3059542477,
0.1847157478,
-0.0884499252,
0.6151992679,
0.7152457833,
0.9695984125,
-0.0890294164,
0.7397956848,
-0.0146245379,
0.3497089744,
-0.6312085986,
0.6656405926,
-0.5814463496,
0.274305284,
-0.2589382827,
-1.0743461847,
-0.5359269381,
0.5408483744,
-0.4347518384,
0.2512148023,
0.7857839465,
0.665283978,
0.1355145276,
-0.3451384604,
0.3684162199,
0.1150742024,
0.402133137,
0.9400538802,
0.7978073359,
-0.800547421,
0.7301253676,
-0.2448548824,
-0.3516296744,
0.0470561124,
-0.5755930543,
-0.5367925763,
-0.4985924661,
-0.6614611149,
-0.2151074558,
0.1500668973,
0.6989902854,
1.0011811256,
-0.6789435744,
-0.305639565,
-0.1662596464,
-0.0944351777,
-0.1228016615,
-0.2292718738,
0.5483306646,
-0.2919179499,
-0.9755708575,
0.0393119864,
0.0788685456,
0.0894241482,
0.0574910156,
-0.3218996525,
0.2472560704,
-0.2265869379,
0.7570619583,
0.171416536,
-0.3439713418,
-0.1251899451,
-0.5084847212,
-0.2601380944,
-0.0816199929,
1.0817716122,
-0.9058388472,
0.2087275386,
0.2486515939,
0.5557386875,
0.6460249424,
0.1872831583,
0.7902722955,
-0.5905830264,
0.2995231748,
0.3091563284,
0.1920580417,
0.3815391064,
-0.2285259068,
0.6629588008,
0.2657110691,
-0.5875501633,
-0.6782040596,
0.0813707337,
-1.1223438978,
-0.1502359807,
1.0322089195,
-0.3231173456,
-0.0633990839,
0.2548802197,
-0.3910764158,
0.3503324687,
-0.3524815142,
0.7378665209,
0.4569641948,
0.2042680234,
-0.5368411541,
-0.3466758132,
0.7537514567,
0.6490595341,
-0.7028794885,
0.1190403849,
0.4720754027,
0.0740997046,
-0.3063088655,
0.5582621694,
-0.2033766061,
0.2636061013,
-0.1008072644,
0.321054697,
0.3430121243,
0.1101021692,
-0.2586165071,
0.1733552963,
0.467874676,
0.0191124659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17535v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17535v1 | Disce aut Deficere: Evaluating LLMs Proficiency on the INVALSI Italian Benchmark | 2024-06-25T13:20:08 | 2024-06-25T13:20:08 | Fabio Mercorio, Mario Mezzanzanica, Daniele Potertì, Antonio Serino, Andrea Seveso | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly
enhanced their ability to generate and manipulate human language, highlighting
their potential across various applications. Evaluating LLMs in languages other
than English is crucial for ensuring their linguistic versatility, cultural
relevance, and applicability in diverse global contexts, thus broadening their
usability and effectiveness. We tackle this challenge by introducing a
structured benchmark using the INVALSI tests, a set of well-established
assessments designed to measure educational competencies across Italy. Our
study makes three primary contributions: Firstly, we adapt the INVALSI
benchmark for automated LLM evaluation, which involves rigorous adaptation of
the test format to suit automated processing while retaining the essence of the
original tests. Secondly, we provide a detailed assessment of current LLMs,
offering a crucial reference point for the academic community. Finally, we
visually compare the performance of these models against human results.
Additionally, researchers are invited to submit their models for ongoing
evaluation, ensuring the benchmark remains a current and valuable resource. | [
-0.316257149,
-0.384611845,
0.4869585931,
0.1335215867,
-0.0376200676,
0.2730858922,
-0.4314181209,
-0.6751672626,
-0.1910924464,
0.3001662195,
-0.1884935349,
-0.452336967,
-0.6005327702,
0.5586360693,
-0.5156582594,
0.2915570438,
-0.2741256952,
0.6441280842,
-0.5707939267,
-0.2954537272,
-0.2519793212,
-0.4263472855,
-0.7976002097,
-0.42579934,
0.1485479921,
0.5125658512,
0.1762974709,
0.2676324248,
0.6780332327,
0.3226154745,
-0.2192762345,
0.2488275468,
-0.3921459913,
-0.074176535,
-0.1575354189,
-0.4117864072,
-0.4479756355,
0.0845820978,
0.9805082083,
0.9437057972,
0.0050880807,
0.213945955,
0.4447781742,
0.6490467191,
-0.5522118807,
0.1192767099,
-0.4881081879,
-0.2181415558,
-0.1166056618,
-0.0518190153,
-0.4634287357,
-0.7849428058,
-0.085309498,
-0.1893613189,
-0.176028505,
-0.294072479,
0.5609163046,
0.2653594017,
-0.4652388394,
-0.3481213152,
-0.4951324463,
0.5040460229,
-0.7338888645,
0.7376917601,
0.1861202121,
0.42598176,
-0.2574336529,
-0.724591732,
-0.2871655822,
-0.7785223126,
0.3000820577,
0.0858197138,
-0.0077833901,
-0.1701713353,
0.1586503088,
0.4673870206,
-0.5949525237,
0.4220753014,
-0.1488261521,
0.0231318232,
0.8198570013,
0.4439037442,
0.2479853779,
0.3482273817,
-0.4048725367,
-0.1389334202,
-0.9638751745,
0.208258599,
0.3685052395,
0.2481711507,
-0.0925923064,
0.5503461361,
-0.2625303864,
0.6161267757,
-0.4035965502,
-0.2025093585,
0.1817739457,
-0.4279237092,
0.0145914843,
-0.2413816601,
0.6536887884,
0.4074161947,
0.557051897,
-0.2398975044,
-0.3182744682,
-0.017416114,
-0.0734349191,
-0.8863781095,
0.0960818604,
-0.2075317055,
-0.0317484401,
0.009145665,
0.2064533681,
-0.8520130515,
-0.2511247694,
-0.1425008476,
0.4145878553,
-0.3053729534,
0.1933184713,
0.1585821509,
0.2012082189,
0.1226942018,
0.2888139486,
-0.7385497689,
0.5549885035,
0.6460126638,
0.6765446663,
-0.5216479897,
-0.307263732,
-0.2816757858,
-0.0162706692,
-0.5208004117,
0.7729126811,
-0.6673243046,
-0.6897382736,
0.3082410693,
0.0193652697,
-0.0084289908,
-0.7973495126,
0.7634412646,
-0.3359923661,
-0.0078694951,
-0.2856265903,
-0.8749013543,
-0.2094815522,
0.414526701,
-0.5735079646,
1.2448934317,
0.1846159399,
-0.3856790364,
0.475215435,
-0.53319484,
-0.2685154974,
0.2625344694,
-0.1113806441,
-0.2117874771,
0.1626888216,
-0.0763018429,
0.2428485006,
-0.6802206039,
0.260376811,
-0.2860099971,
-0.6076190472,
0.4317997098,
-0.6337352991,
0.6932203174,
-0.0228801463,
-0.3380033374,
-0.0831534415,
-0.8245534897,
0.1733092666,
-0.1097579896,
-0.5200926661,
-0.2282707095,
0.0140787624,
-0.0669260249,
0.0397239141,
0.3520490527,
-0.5173373818,
0.2077061683,
-0.5528524518,
0.5062460899,
0.5021884441,
-0.0120825917,
0.2227947265,
-0.2152400464,
0.548756063,
-0.3317342401,
0.195429951,
-0.0610903241,
-0.4484722018,
-0.724414587,
-0.4737461209,
0.4496825039,
0.4926443398,
-0.4224648178,
0.3769175112,
-0.4305194616,
-0.6938406825,
-0.5379459858,
0.2614465356,
0.3557236791,
0.270362258,
0.0585706867,
-0.5895428061,
-0.1552563906,
-0.8373439312,
-0.3563509583,
-0.2181000262,
-0.0554592162,
0.1896212995,
0.8579134941,
-0.1896378398,
0.7143501639,
0.1240766123,
-0.0747728795,
-0.2304205149,
-0.089117974,
0.1179135814,
0.3079378009,
0.4537802041,
-0.5635909438,
-0.5098389387,
0.0127106197,
-0.665708065,
-0.1805796176,
0.3481396437,
0.1375695765,
0.2106651813,
0.476543963,
-0.148376748,
0.3813326061,
0.4720924199,
-0.2787415683,
0.4153213501,
-0.2576879561,
0.5485050082,
-0.8646890521,
-0.0974428579,
0.0778098702,
-0.192163378,
-0.2655858397,
0.1926773489,
0.2327762693,
-0.0363134257,
-0.6108715534,
0.8617426157,
-0.4353065193,
-0.394547224,
0.149917081,
0.2732104659,
-0.0898099542,
-0.054178264,
-0.1447604895,
1.2120131254,
0.3349938095,
-0.4124865532,
0.3242956996,
0.063179709,
-0.7804240584,
0.7288833261,
-0.6630040407,
-0.0829430595,
0.3043865263,
0.0326531008,
-1.0505877733,
-0.2009650469,
0.1662197113,
-0.2943145931,
0.2821948528,
0.049697917,
-0.8422176242,
-0.3097985983,
-0.2846747935,
0.359025985,
0.3168264031,
-0.5805538893,
0.3874561489,
0.3363428712,
-0.094966501,
-0.0043935264,
-0.7152218223,
0.3395085037,
-0.3734700382,
-0.6107668877,
0.2340311706,
-0.4016717076,
-0.7247533798,
-0.2190717906,
0.0957889408,
-0.3983737826,
0.4549007714,
-0.0319676548,
0.2242188007,
-0.313416183,
-0.004283323,
-0.1324400008,
-0.0846648812,
0.1034206674,
-0.1856370866,
0.1980955601,
-0.2224064469,
-0.8172391057,
-0.708381772,
0.1142619774,
0.9056510329,
-0.2770368457,
0.4664828181,
0.0513729975,
-0.4705629051,
-0.1886217147,
-0.6312643886,
-0.2383291274,
-0.4311372936,
0.4472520947,
-0.477181375,
-0.7294900417,
0.3461598754,
-0.287691921,
-0.0035457527,
0.2306500524,
0.5543364286,
-0.1066058129,
0.9221870899,
0.6546586752,
-0.2035571933,
0.2582426667,
-0.2679069936,
0.0911103636,
-0.777890265,
-0.360113889,
-0.8328301907,
-0.0697956681,
-0.5906178951,
-0.4593094289,
0.5558488965,
-0.0134822754,
-0.2412497848,
0.2267076969,
-0.1881659627,
0.6061161757,
0.0364941806,
0.0182708818,
0.7013527155,
0.0597248897,
-0.2656430304,
-0.3506260812,
-0.6514188647,
-1.158539772,
1.1351058483,
0.3036940694,
0.7023115754,
0.1160189584,
0.6536746025,
0.1528603584,
0.5000438094,
-0.6754797101,
0.7192245722,
-0.3609747589,
-0.3926293552,
-0.1987303495,
-0.2624416947,
-0.5541260242,
0.348680675,
-0.0665423572,
-0.6555398703,
0.0630659387,
-0.3063195348,
-0.2174199224,
0.382332474,
-0.5815425515,
0.7713826299,
-0.5788100362,
-0.7352053523,
-0.234832719,
-0.0846915916,
0.1830421239,
-0.2021121979,
0.3687338531,
-0.2747843862,
-0.4932269752,
0.5880345106,
-0.0587291233,
0.8783994317,
0.2828480601,
-0.1659470946,
0.1307958513,
-0.0719951764,
0.2047390491,
0.2434969097,
-0.6864749789,
0.1939875633,
-0.0566126555,
-0.4272482097,
-0.3744188249,
0.8141055703,
-0.6584601402,
-0.4021894336,
-0.4772725105,
-0.3876689076,
-0.4402813017,
-0.063234739,
0.1850360334,
0.5926399231,
-0.8435069323,
0.1370939761,
0.7075521946,
0.0179806426,
0.4364666939,
0.8622099757,
0.1042675078,
-0.3709831238,
0.7596082687,
0.1526613683,
0.3951460719,
0.2801876068,
-0.0770679414,
-0.4841904938,
-0.7259905338,
-0.5780804157,
0.267891705,
-0.7847898006,
0.0311074611,
-0.1865663677,
-0.1019497588,
-0.3121644855,
-0.313878715,
-0.3563099205,
-0.2311004102,
-0.340664804,
0.0576448366,
0.0867873877,
1.1531567574,
0.0975333825,
-0.0471411534,
-0.6054173708,
-0.1060481146,
0.4184657931,
0.2667623758,
-0.3165074289,
-0.9809651971,
-0.2003784776,
0.1070478261,
-0.3149857223,
-0.8305442929,
0.275149107,
0.404199928,
0.9088078737,
0.2892597914,
-0.2952255011,
0.631503284,
-0.5073461533,
0.8248802423,
-0.167837292,
-0.9766175747,
0.2543774545,
-0.0635691211,
-0.0193116739,
1.0213278532,
0.5534775257,
-0.2933523655,
-0.3917176723,
-0.4487646222,
-0.6747062206,
0.3104444742,
0.018129861,
0.2228702456,
0.0303366315,
0.5844981074,
0.0438463241,
0.1256616116,
-0.5695328116,
0.021768475,
0.3455951214,
-0.1914339215,
-0.4656023085,
-0.4375830293,
-0.0451284535,
-0.3996049166,
0.6993280649,
-0.0547003597,
-0.0963963494,
0.090854913,
-0.3236620426,
0.0972615853,
0.3574538529,
0.4677600563,
0.909588933,
0.1591956019,
-0.0935877338,
0.82838732,
-0.2124332637,
0.2946254015,
0.0423175842,
-0.2013200521,
-0.0447827131,
0.6070261002,
0.4327228665,
0.8667847514,
-0.9402628541,
0.5076428056,
-0.1473643333,
-0.1166283861,
-0.4996374249,
0.1550242752,
0.1262360066,
0.3966418803,
0.2656470537,
-0.2498624474,
0.033123523,
-0.6737877131,
0.2706843615,
0.4189172089,
-0.4893043637,
-0.340410322,
0.5971047878,
0.4272478223,
-0.4323646128,
0.4332466722,
-0.2077468783,
-0.433103919,
0.6540311575,
0.5121554136,
0.9254469872,
-0.3760185838,
0.1018016562,
0.64443326,
0.5382115841,
-0.2784480751,
0.2206526995,
0.0103724785,
-0.5753286481,
-0.1198626235,
-0.6227160096,
-0.7690989971,
-0.1908912659,
-0.6344190836,
0.4482930899,
-0.2862465382,
0.0153487716,
-0.4584697783,
0.268209517,
-0.4604293406,
0.3216347992,
0.1784860492,
1.2544389963,
-1.1486568451,
0.9370859861,
0.865326643,
-0.4003339112,
-0.4296240807,
-0.0118713155,
-0.1805085987,
-0.7706074715,
0.6147760749,
0.1248240173,
-0.2357037812,
0.0968752578,
-0.3634212613,
-0.6839941144,
1.0283458233,
0.6211292148,
-0.6328906417,
0.1537247598,
0.3181046844,
0.7494409084,
-0.7758339047,
0.6908592582,
0.8738792539,
0.6775886416,
0.1070500091,
-0.7980083227,
-0.3838706911,
-0.1841448396,
0.1661296636,
-0.1585196406,
-0.5466815233,
0.5667593479,
-0.0139021538,
-0.2298237979,
0.4081703126,
0.6449270844,
0.2447169125,
0.2562413812,
0.2116868347,
0.6220858097,
0.794908762,
-0.3324449658,
0.96514678,
-0.4841972589,
0.0408377014,
0.9361768961,
-0.6375640035,
1.1870936155,
0.371347636,
-0.4183500111,
0.5398925543,
0.7325889468,
0.0113366423,
0.1222210228,
0.3399032354,
-0.614489615,
-0.3052295148,
-0.257104665,
-0.3680390418,
0.5759906173,
0.3691778481,
-0.0430860221,
-0.2758482397,
-0.0188661665,
0.0420508236,
0.6560052037,
-0.364623636,
0.6324828267,
0.0402324535,
-0.6441828609,
0.5953903198,
-0.0720055401,
0.5986158252,
-0.5077475309,
0.0305583477,
-0.4624423981,
0.1564339697,
-0.0988810584,
-0.7658191919,
0.2443165928,
0.4726372063,
0.1429535151,
-0.2124064714,
0.1986143589,
-0.6088687181,
-0.7502477765,
0.5986133814,
0.4497742951,
0.4353131652,
0.3059440851,
-0.5819758177,
0.3733083606,
-0.1105940267,
-0.0307858493,
0.3393086195,
0.2234820276,
-0.1605418324,
0.947863102,
0.3520267606,
0.2735082507,
0.0448969491,
0.2545057535,
0.7544855475,
-0.3949377835,
-0.1345054954,
-0.7388345003,
0.503777802,
0.0655158088,
-0.5889959335,
0.8738405704,
0.7621429563,
1.1055254936,
0.1955496073,
0.6156120896,
0.3578693569,
0.3827784359,
-0.4702084959,
0.6747854352,
-0.9402191639,
0.3617400527,
-0.1359350085,
-1.0224257708,
-0.201968044,
0.5237442255,
-0.3790457249,
0.0357572548,
0.7288146615,
0.8334426284,
0.3216311932,
-0.0718776435,
0.6560289264,
0.1676785946,
0.0269619413,
0.6231508851,
1.0764406919,
-0.4829560518,
0.2664362192,
-0.195379287,
-0.2759462595,
-0.0830759555,
-0.9469853044,
-0.9591811299,
-0.5368798971,
-0.327383399,
0.1049677059,
0.4377804101,
0.8618659377,
0.4036314189,
-0.8144779801,
-0.7600007057,
0.1382469535,
0.0411165729,
-0.0414248668,
-0.1191335469,
-0.0541815497,
-0.2716692984,
-1.1562201977,
0.7580831051,
0.3222121,
0.1420651078,
-0.4321095943,
-0.1272964627,
-0.0276027303,
0.1132845357,
0.5128422379,
0.2480473369,
-0.7522093058,
-0.108102113,
-0.0571373478,
-0.3606139719,
-0.0328111053,
0.6136122346,
-0.6689453721,
0.5183782578,
0.5328854322,
0.5343966484,
0.3161660433,
-0.2851199806,
0.4529040158,
-0.1061634123,
0.2561452389,
0.3750111163,
0.5235498548,
0.5984693766,
0.1003431082,
0.6828938127,
0.1140095219,
-0.5215163827,
-0.9587588906,
-0.0234772991,
-0.4949142635,
0.0298539642,
0.8962801099,
-0.4012843966,
0.0044566249,
-0.0749796182,
0.2238050103,
-0.0312799476,
-0.0799819678,
0.732286334,
0.7271001935,
0.2084023654,
0.050705675,
-0.6634942889,
0.2403767705,
0.357124567,
-0.9312918186,
-0.3033403158,
0.2247226983,
0.35652107,
-0.2272139043,
0.4632762969,
-0.4341815412,
0.3145355284,
-0.3191272616,
0.1313254982,
0.1718683243,
-0.4516305625,
-0.7176713347,
0.0591792502,
0.4391747415,
0.123766765
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.