id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06669v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06669v1
|
Instruction-Guided Bullet Point Summarization of Long Financial Earnings Call Transcripts
| 2024-05-03T16:33:16 | 2024-05-03T16:33:16 |
Subhendu Khatuya, Koushiki Sinha, Niloy Ganguly, Saptarshi Ghosh, Pawan Goyal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CE, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
While automatic summarization techniques have made significant advancements,
their primary focus has been on summarizing short news articles or documents
that have clear structural patterns like scientific articles or government
reports. There has not been much exploration into developing efficient methods
for summarizing financial documents, which often contain complex facts and
figures. Here, we study the problem of bullet point summarization of long
Earning Call Transcripts (ECTs) using the recently released ECTSum dataset. We
leverage an unsupervised question-based extractive module followed by a
parameter efficient instruction-tuned abstractive module to solve this task.
Our proposed model FLAN-FinBPS achieves new state-of-the-art performances
outperforming the strongest baseline with 14.88% average ROUGE score gain, and
is capable of generating factually consistent bullet point summaries that
capture the important facts discussed in the ECTs.
|
[
-0.031729571521282196,
-1.0573585033416748,
0.38470742106437683,
0.18059997260570526,
-0.3507649302482605,
0.1978255957365036,
-0.30047088861465454,
-0.5918311476707458,
0.5108211040496826,
0.6824730038642883,
-0.3228646516799927,
-0.7795723080635071,
-0.5566942691802979,
-0.03113703243434429,
-0.44289910793304443,
1.387719750404358,
0.10713618993759155,
-0.24222272634506226,
0.2334836721420288,
0.046699751168489456,
-0.13838766515254974,
-0.1461353451013565,
-0.676133394241333,
0.07537250220775604,
0.27222198247909546,
0.6796223521232605,
0.2423737794160843,
0.7802586555480957,
0.6359164118766785,
0.34284263849258423,
0.06911447644233704,
0.3065301775932312,
-0.13697758316993713,
-0.15867561101913452,
-0.016303036361932755,
-0.3815091848373413,
-1.0784389972686768,
-0.2994360327720642,
0.46016234159469604,
0.6582281589508057,
-0.12330430746078491,
0.4699658155441284,
0.10992177575826645,
0.9970524907112122,
-0.40993475914001465,
0.6218695044517517,
-0.21904517710208893,
-0.1884474903345108,
-0.06404769420623779,
-0.621345579624176,
-0.7012441754341125,
-0.4568842947483063,
0.3027733862400055,
-0.4478377103805542,
0.1929977685213089,
-0.011140718124806881,
0.7042908668518066,
-0.23240062594413757,
-0.4971616268157959,
-0.613241970539093,
-0.6485568284988403,
0.6054514646530151,
-0.7459623217582703,
0.04197639599442482,
0.17872199416160583,
0.26048216223716736,
0.1317816525697708,
-0.7322105765342712,
0.23278698325157166,
0.29779455065727234,
-0.10268725454807281,
0.30235543847084045,
-0.2904106676578522,
0.3688254654407501,
0.1330505609512329,
0.05144384875893593,
-0.39621061086654663,
0.10315613448619843,
-0.8060387969017029,
0.05430006608366966,
1.0127254724502563,
0.12009536474943161,
-0.1737607717514038,
-0.11561976373195648,
-0.4803522825241089,
-0.23935282230377197,
-0.5072535276412964,
0.31881141662597656,
0.6373317241668701,
0.6048320531845093,
-0.02635861374437809,
0.4139344394207001,
-0.40736302733421326,
0.49048110842704773,
0.013815438374876976,
-0.3024766147136688,
0.013020258396863937,
-0.04575448855757713,
-0.057859841734170914,
0.5528552532196045,
0.33173322677612305,
0.7445207238197327,
0.29339542984962463,
0.17680275440216064,
-0.3094732165336609,
-0.8245879411697388,
0.17578241229057312,
-1.0716915130615234,
-0.10921726375818253,
0.5967885851860046,
-0.48135581612586975,
-0.13194085657596588,
0.6008471250534058,
-0.9105156064033508,
0.2017117142677307,
-0.4748588502407074,
0.37955209612846375,
-0.45884397625923157,
0.00020832875452470034,
0.23716001212596893,
-0.4096515476703644,
0.3021296560764313,
0.46117785573005676,
-0.914335310459137,
0.4576784372329712,
0.9077022075653076,
0.902133047580719,
0.14358647167682648,
0.022082248702645302,
-0.8428796529769897,
0.3355192542076111,
-0.15657423436641693,
1.0155550241470337,
-0.40278419852256775,
-0.5019035339355469,
-0.034951429814100266,
0.06759672611951828,
-0.02918049693107605,
-0.4233075976371765,
0.048455387353897095,
-0.365328311920166,
-0.06514673680067062,
-0.24913208186626434,
-0.8940954208374023,
-0.33627820014953613,
-0.14276304841041565,
-0.23671525716781616,
0.6000257730484009,
0.07780052721500397,
-0.5349240303039551,
0.2819691598415375,
-1.0040167570114136,
-0.3367235064506531,
0.05361764132976532,
-0.06520096212625504,
-0.5730060935020447,
-0.20179419219493866,
0.2355939894914627,
0.6962676048278809,
0.21571815013885498,
0.02054179459810257,
-0.0504676029086113,
-0.453572154045105,
0.27027028799057007,
-0.23181572556495667,
0.35310110449790955,
-0.20374973118305206,
-0.5928806662559509,
0.045923586934804916,
-0.7954096794128418,
0.15213407576084137,
-0.1734914779663086,
-0.07634570449590683,
-0.45521190762519836,
0.025722747668623924,
-0.2285962551832199,
-0.07472056150436401,
0.2336975485086441,
-0.39674872159957886,
0.1841808557510376,
-0.08167123049497604,
0.23102864623069763,
0.8166145086288452,
0.19964836537837982,
0.034437377005815506,
-0.30657899379730225,
0.36511099338531494,
0.0449342206120491,
0.008863219060003757,
-0.7241947650909424,
-0.08411379158496857,
-0.6630090475082397,
-0.7063442468643188,
0.3097885251045227,
0.7199921011924744,
-0.13351280987262726,
0.7218454480171204,
-0.13750821352005005,
-0.5249571204185486,
-0.16224579513072968,
0.030284952372312546,
0.3259790539741516,
0.44044139981269836,
0.6194212436676025,
-0.1013396680355072,
-0.2000361979007721,
-1.3577266931533813,
-0.41559091210365295,
0.020885532721877098,
-0.31926223635673523,
-0.16245204210281372,
0.5651491284370422,
0.4424874484539032,
0.8882207870483398,
-0.9854046106338501,
-0.12190346419811249,
-0.420218288898468,
0.6509008407592773,
0.29597043991088867,
0.2595326006412506,
0.4260426461696625,
-0.5482689142227173,
-0.12572336196899414,
-0.16598868370056152,
-0.35140570998191833,
-0.03548039495944977,
-0.53680819272995,
-0.10647972673177719,
-0.06333811581134796,
0.5222859978675842,
-0.3489536941051483,
0.7542733550071716,
-0.22552546858787537,
-0.5200976133346558,
0.5816468000411987,
-0.3470422029495239,
0.2630269229412079,
-0.9398980140686035,
0.17116765677928925,
0.25490960478782654,
-0.5311579704284668,
-0.46655115485191345,
-0.3998929262161255,
0.27969878911972046,
0.06305123120546341,
-0.40379199385643005,
0.17331111431121826,
-0.4469001293182373,
-0.34652984142303467,
-0.5626522302627563,
0.2934434115886688,
-0.010288539342582226,
0.6906669735908508,
0.15853244066238403,
0.38392943143844604,
0.30032336711883545,
-0.6865493655204773,
0.28084149956703186,
0.22429710626602173,
-0.18758273124694824,
0.6590461730957031,
-0.7213841080665588,
-0.17319071292877197,
-0.058189261704683304,
0.3857692778110504,
-0.7266725897789001,
-0.10275192558765411,
-0.13907933235168457,
-0.036209408193826675,
0.5180459022521973,
-0.04166707396507263,
-0.12437479943037033,
-0.07642067223787308,
-0.6735848784446716,
0.1628006249666214,
0.5841015577316284,
-0.42862439155578613,
0.36722302436828613,
0.18573439121246338,
-0.91685551404953,
-0.5400567054748535,
-0.4855976402759552,
-0.2531414330005646,
-0.21144399046897888,
-0.4108542203903198,
0.38744911551475525,
0.3540162444114685,
-0.38390013575553894,
-0.22800645232200623,
-0.23926685750484467,
0.16042540967464447,
-0.10891246050596237,
0.07449362426996231,
0.6336961388587952,
-0.40218496322631836,
-0.046172771602869034,
0.2563942074775696,
-0.29408061504364014,
0.16109530627727509,
-0.11349157243967056,
0.11500892788171768,
-0.48714345693588257,
-0.39509934186935425,
-0.5136240124702454,
0.8115856051445007,
0.3337193727493286,
-0.2203724980354309,
0.4107166826725006,
0.34080979228019714,
-0.06256484240293503,
-0.37865492701530457,
-0.4131995141506195,
-0.109978087246418,
-0.4836943745613098,
0.6187843084335327,
0.05845971778035164,
-0.5187601447105408,
0.7967613935470581,
-0.2158852219581604,
0.6184513568878174,
0.6297414302825928,
0.26038962602615356,
0.020833831280469894,
0.6855401396751404,
0.5865150094032288,
0.32743173837661743,
0.48012635111808777,
-0.5340258479118347,
0.23396103084087372,
-0.42644017934799194,
-0.3147970139980316,
-0.1822843998670578,
-0.43071508407592773,
-0.3729497790336609,
-0.02127928100526333,
0.4669622480869293,
0.015695545822381973,
0.041748035699129105,
0.41462090611457825,
-0.3322266936302185,
0.7454769611358643,
0.44825881719589233,
0.24975460767745972,
0.3060246407985687,
-0.36502572894096375,
0.36946210265159607,
0.278076708316803,
-0.46276694536209106,
-0.632320761680603,
1.129879355430603,
0.3767068386077881,
0.5069563388824463,
-0.04381038621068001,
0.755330502986908,
0.5016301274299622,
0.16209757328033447,
-0.6872159838676453,
0.5441911816596985,
-0.17816387116909027,
-0.03192657232284546,
-0.3407343029975891,
-0.4784626066684723,
-0.5621452927589417,
0.06072264537215233,
0.16048762202262878,
-0.8145954012870789,
0.17341828346252441,
-0.08266284316778183,
-0.7822042107582092,
0.41082870960235596,
-0.700900673866272,
0.6477595567703247,
-0.3359711468219757,
-0.17045584321022034,
-0.251694917678833,
-0.8791686296463013,
0.4739812910556793,
-0.10585879534482956,
0.32673922181129456,
-0.2062290608882904,
-0.06286318600177765,
1.0801489353179932,
-0.9996018409729004,
0.7229183912277222,
-0.05067139491438866,
-0.16603335738182068,
0.5593951344490051,
-0.41494226455688477,
0.3417956829071045,
0.12702640891075134,
0.13897952437400818,
0.1579074263572693,
0.17496688663959503,
-0.6780911087989807,
-0.637888491153717,
0.26722580194473267,
-0.2254667729139328,
-0.5216857194900513,
-0.40292707085609436,
-0.471163809299469,
0.04212777689099312,
0.08002059906721115,
0.028115402907133102,
0.9683808088302612,
-0.1415288895368576,
0.0811159536242485,
0.4644105136394501,
-0.0034995954483747482,
0.7646706700325012,
0.6185980439186096,
-0.12536607682704926,
-0.3691950738430023,
0.9496803283691406,
0.28130149841308594,
0.3790084719657898,
0.4965050220489502,
0.0351240411400795,
-0.3211726248264313,
-0.37759485840797424,
-0.49965474009513855,
0.19747741520404816,
-0.6606286764144897,
-0.428471177816391,
-0.3519108295440674,
-0.26137879490852356,
-0.37522342801094055,
-0.49468544125556946,
-0.5513024926185608,
-0.7030807733535767,
-0.16190536320209503,
-0.5881301760673523,
0.728952944278717,
0.7360689640045166,
-0.16988657414913177,
0.10126010328531265,
-1.0708825588226318,
0.303801953792572,
0.41675814986228943,
0.2656385898590088,
-0.10898655652999878,
-0.3627268075942993,
-0.579815149307251,
0.1867026388645172,
-0.46225810050964355,
-0.926017701625824,
0.39091914892196655,
0.2223159521818161,
0.11197882890701294,
0.7740846276283264,
0.30846482515335083,
0.9419941902160645,
-0.1560373306274414,
0.6322643756866455,
0.1329651027917862,
-0.8559014797210693,
0.5512041449546814,
-0.44726771116256714,
0.2873290777206421,
0.6645857095718384,
0.26819682121276855,
-0.20114031434059143,
-0.7615399956703186,
-0.8507558703422546,
-1.3536889553070068,
0.7006098628044128,
0.16302679479122162,
-0.12211158126592636,
-0.07532265782356262,
0.25868329405784607,
0.5318605899810791,
0.18977774679660797,
0.03787105530500412,
-0.2195156067609787,
-0.21861132979393005,
-0.24306420981884003,
0.26573920249938965,
-0.1860654652118683,
-0.0422159843146801,
-0.2582734227180481,
0.7733096480369568,
-0.005397159140557051,
0.07884831726551056,
0.3116166591644287,
0.05531524121761322,
0.142417773604393,
0.4610421657562256,
0.7835754156112671,
1.0545876026153564,
-0.5305688977241516,
-0.08806926012039185,
0.1050531342625618,
-0.5549015998840332,
-0.12701325118541718,
0.28408944606781006,
-0.02928994596004486,
0.30878138542175293,
0.38274314999580383,
0.5758368968963623,
0.627915620803833,
-0.9460600018501282,
0.6613799929618835,
0.0593000203371048,
-0.36251330375671387,
-0.6053670644760132,
0.048753999173641205,
-0.156006321310997,
0.3985786437988281,
0.7990763783454895,
-0.1330990195274353,
0.21259090304374695,
-0.5215648412704468,
0.5982470512390137,
0.05804784968495369,
-0.0375569723546505,
-0.2788747549057007,
0.38967981934547424,
0.4291274845600128,
-0.3219987452030182,
0.5476412773132324,
0.0447123758494854,
-0.3633824586868286,
0.7327628135681152,
0.35106131434440613,
0.937287449836731,
-0.13296836614608765,
0.4254685640335083,
0.24657142162322998,
-0.07153423130512238,
-0.23787379264831543,
0.22979646921157837,
-0.2470218986272812,
0.1382819414138794,
-0.36126527190208435,
-0.41521933674812317,
-0.7192079424858093,
-0.1301395297050476,
-1.1552307605743408,
0.5895508527755737,
-0.34072136878967285,
0.0697413980960846,
0.16416321694850922,
-0.1567884236574173,
-0.24739764630794525,
0.05220125615596771,
-0.1147366538643837,
0.9576261043548584,
-0.6003463864326477,
0.12369082868099213,
0.12845128774642944,
-0.304874986410141,
-0.6644827723503113,
-0.4922519624233246,
-0.056970782577991486,
-0.5784766674041748,
0.40355417132377625,
0.3155559003353119,
-0.12665672600269318,
-0.15674693882465363,
-0.27740907669067383,
-0.5061784386634827,
1.334332823753357,
0.23157323896884918,
-0.5485810041427612,
-0.24866712093353271,
0.2284550815820694,
0.05027332529425621,
-0.39625927805900574,
0.6074171662330627,
0.7287339568138123,
0.5481632947921753,
0.06599409878253937,
-0.7021214365959167,
-0.1891530603170395,
-0.3804585039615631,
-0.678111732006073,
0.6683476567268372,
-0.9215508103370667,
0.5903097987174988,
-0.3312630355358124,
0.06479352712631226,
-0.3208947777748108,
0.9916470050811768,
0.05266440659761429,
0.47696754336357117,
0.2757705748081207,
0.16231763362884521,
0.6560289263725281,
-0.01487777940928936,
0.9217226505279541,
-0.3588871657848358,
0.08684030175209045,
1.01328444480896,
0.11365628987550735,
1.047096848487854,
0.28831610083580017,
-0.06159675866365433,
0.58518385887146,
0.5491051077842712,
-0.14285248517990112,
0.07891359180212021,
0.09301862865686417,
-0.18928036093711853,
-0.19003796577453613,
0.3206242322921753,
-0.24806660413742065,
0.7197048664093018,
0.47904372215270996,
-0.584158718585968,
-0.45241740345954895,
-0.37810882925987244,
0.12196084856987,
-0.25068163871765137,
-0.4997710883617401,
0.8326554298400879,
0.348942369222641,
-0.35044753551483154,
-0.0066400449723005295,
0.10547243058681488,
0.5176440477371216,
-1.043604850769043,
-0.19754524528980255,
-0.04588593542575836,
0.026170959696173668,
-0.3252131938934326,
-0.44960033893585205,
0.3671471178531647,
0.41537752747535706,
0.07509274035692215,
-0.3604174852371216,
0.299899160861969,
-0.778069794178009,
-0.6366727948188782,
-0.23766061663627625,
0.27696242928504944,
0.30100131034851074,
0.04721551015973091,
-0.2920144200325012,
-0.6272279024124146,
-0.15590418875217438,
-0.48725661635398865,
0.31290337443351746,
0.2785728871822357,
0.21828120946884155,
0.546600878238678,
0.6184630393981934,
0.10185331106185913,
-0.20401154458522797,
-0.11975199729204178,
0.521649956703186,
-1.0257542133331299,
-0.9991114139556885,
-1.0649876594543457,
0.7021914720535278,
-0.3205402195453644,
-0.5657951235771179,
0.7236056327819824,
0.9360246062278748,
0.4642910063266754,
0.06206969544291496,
0.5599660873413086,
0.49428004026412964,
0.4480527639389038,
-0.8881677389144897,
0.7208222150802612,
-0.20316608250141144,
0.4643993079662323,
-0.3991548418998718,
-0.8363579511642456,
-0.010604381561279297,
0.17260460555553436,
-0.3055669665336609,
-0.037112683057785034,
0.8065179586410522,
0.36909231543540955,
-0.1284940242767334,
0.5502545833587646,
0.11061494797468185,
-0.021199049428105354,
0.20948059856891632,
0.43432122468948364,
0.19788728654384613,
-0.38676780462265015,
0.5127208828926086,
-0.43279939889907837,
-0.288376122713089,
-0.6242566704750061,
-0.9237239956855774,
-0.594302773475647,
-0.3504457175731659,
-0.8522623181343079,
0.03519958257675171,
-0.03819343447685242,
1.086234450340271,
0.28782394528388977,
-0.6891180276870728,
-0.3722074031829834,
0.3190693259239197,
-0.0754043236374855,
-0.3744049072265625,
-0.3095482587814331,
0.9972839951515198,
-0.18036291003227234,
-0.6151588559150696,
0.2527189254760742,
0.7463651299476624,
0.2649039030075073,
0.1383180469274521,
0.3161306083202362,
0.16016943752765656,
0.32023298740386963,
0.5596713423728943,
0.513444721698761,
-0.22200588881969452,
-0.519570529460907,
0.0579041913151741,
0.20254701375961304,
-0.011383678764104843,
0.9465444087982178,
-0.22812698781490326,
0.08395873755216599,
0.2181323617696762,
0.5369060039520264,
0.42365309596061707,
0.652365505695343,
0.6974000334739685,
-0.6938482522964478,
0.08532333374023438,
0.16851070523262024,
0.47008246183395386,
0.05460505932569504,
-0.38837480545043945,
0.04749196767807007,
-0.09412628412246704,
-0.3579309582710266,
-0.5592038631439209,
-0.21657055616378784,
-1.2560561895370483,
-0.17256328463554382,
1.0039962530136108,
-0.2405773103237152,
-0.6334042549133301,
-0.020976075902581215,
-0.14950931072235107,
0.2431875467300415,
-0.6064050793647766,
0.8164606094360352,
0.412712424993515,
-0.5443277359008789,
0.20238421857357025,
-0.4305579662322998,
0.3065358102321625,
0.2783217430114746,
-0.9298744797706604,
0.3929097354412079,
0.5019484162330627,
0.20898927748203278,
0.019611334428191185,
0.5082622170448303,
-0.1776098906993866,
0.46358445286750793,
0.04746256768703461,
-0.179280623793602,
-0.5934033393859863,
-0.25596702098846436,
0.011342530138790607,
0.2489323914051056,
-0.4789956510066986,
-0.5095412135124207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02195v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02195v1
|
Impact of emoji exclusion on the performance of Arabic sarcasm detection models
| 2024-05-03T15:51:02 | 2024-05-03T15:51:02 |
Ghalyah H. Aleryani, Wael Deabes, Khaled Albishre, Alaa E. Abdel-Hakim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The complex challenge of detecting sarcasm in Arabic speech on social media
is increased by the language diversity and the nature of sarcastic expressions.
There is a significant gap in the capability of existing models to effectively
interpret sarcasm in Arabic, which mandates the necessity for more
sophisticated and precise detection methods. In this paper, we investigate the
impact of a fundamental preprocessing component on sarcasm speech detection.
While emojis play a crucial role in mitigating the absence effect of body
language and facial expressions in modern communication, their impact on
automated text analysis, particularly in sarcasm detection, remains
underexplored. We investigate the impact of emoji exclusion from datasets on
the performance of sarcasm detection models in social media content for Arabic
as a vocabulary-super rich language. This investigation includes the adaptation
and enhancement of AraBERT pre-training models, specifically by excluding
emojis, to improve sarcasm detection capabilities. We use AraBERT pre-training
to refine the specified models, demonstrating that the removal of emojis can
significantly boost the accuracy of sarcasm detection. This approach
facilitates a more refined interpretation of language, eliminating the
potential confusion introduced by non-textual elements. The evaluated AraBERT
models, through the focused strategy of emoji removal, adeptly navigate the
complexities of Arabic sarcasm. This study establishes new benchmarks in Arabic
natural language processing and presents valuable insights for social media
platforms.
|
[
-0.5184990167617798,
-0.8767200112342834,
0.19078928232192993,
0.21583758294582367,
-0.5643972158432007,
0.3744477927684784,
-0.22932706773281097,
-0.7270712852478027,
0.3238452076911926,
0.27120769023895264,
-0.5374072790145874,
-0.6467777490615845,
-0.7157361507415771,
0.3428407311439514,
-0.3158702850341797,
1.1456996202468872,
0.04888882488012314,
-0.09153121709823608,
0.22819335758686066,
-0.12707409262657166,
-0.27423593401908875,
-0.5659791827201843,
-0.5911058187484741,
-0.047240376472473145,
0.3303082585334778,
0.3774620294570923,
0.845716118812561,
0.23776842653751373,
0.5144414901733398,
0.2964995503425598,
-0.2094826102256775,
-0.11800384521484375,
-0.33063486218452454,
0.2594667673110962,
0.06012802571058273,
-0.2992091476917267,
-0.27024784684181213,
-0.21323391795158386,
0.7531565427780151,
0.11086967587471008,
0.058536529541015625,
0.05980012193322182,
-0.24240130186080933,
0.4739150404930115,
-1.0091689825057983,
-0.015585930086672306,
-0.4922129213809967,
0.06712021678686142,
-0.20132513344287872,
-0.09032606333494186,
-0.02020394243299961,
-0.3520788848400116,
-0.014494017697870731,
-0.20687337219715118,
0.04408086836338043,
-0.3525411784648895,
0.6868000030517578,
0.4173234701156616,
-0.2227950245141983,
-0.22611010074615479,
-0.8112902641296387,
0.6466032862663269,
-0.5084047317504883,
0.1813352108001709,
0.21848423779010773,
0.2751278877258301,
0.15066462755203247,
-0.5711771249771118,
-0.5189698338508606,
-0.24246738851070404,
-0.08703587204217911,
-0.014681970700621605,
-0.3193749785423279,
0.1806517392396927,
0.2785409986972809,
0.11963798105716705,
-0.4890629053115845,
-0.1181676983833313,
-0.11160510033369064,
-0.07368870079517365,
0.4697240889072418,
-0.23727968335151672,
0.5621450543403625,
-0.22405457496643066,
0.10009875893592834,
0.2840701937675476,
-0.48606887459754944,
0.0364859439432621,
0.30021825432777405,
-0.008876776322722435,
-0.05501629039645195,
0.28896868228912354,
-0.29190748929977417,
0.2632750868797302,
-0.22990183532238007,
0.0018978554289788008,
0.3184385597705841,
-0.24687762558460236,
0.0017377894837409258,
0.13656778633594513,
0.524113655090332,
-0.16529037058353424,
0.9270558953285217,
-0.05309084802865982,
-0.3488214313983917,
0.44599342346191406,
0.11281583458185196,
-0.8335947394371033,
-0.17051978409290314,
-0.04494403675198555,
-0.24171796441078186,
-0.34283187985420227,
0.057857442647218704,
-0.46276628971099854,
-0.28100812435150146,
0.017838584259152412,
0.18423064053058624,
-0.27209964394569397,
-0.19100061058998108,
-0.28258317708969116,
-0.3591839075088501,
0.18286673724651337,
0.5126963257789612,
-0.45994171500205994,
0.4673064053058624,
0.6091798543930054,
0.7249914407730103,
0.37710878252983093,
-0.04454485699534416,
-0.5435327291488647,
0.15659354627132416,
-0.014223090372979641,
0.5539510846138,
-0.9109514355659485,
-0.47714120149612427,
0.01346118375658989,
-0.3575463891029358,
-0.021028995513916016,
-0.5130099058151245,
0.9666110873222351,
-0.5199669599533081,
-0.3698578476905823,
-0.1538725644350052,
-0.39868247509002686,
-0.26894235610961914,
0.09031810611486435,
-0.7633305788040161,
0.8538787961006165,
0.12790822982788086,
-0.8482832312583923,
0.06605547666549683,
-0.7401794195175171,
-0.9888235330581665,
0.18186964094638824,
-0.259930282831192,
-0.32852187752723694,
0.28776127099990845,
0.6036154627799988,
0.20161722600460052,
-0.48867958784103394,
0.2073020190000534,
-0.31646594405174255,
-0.7079607248306274,
0.6263338923454285,
-0.6066818237304688,
0.6374155282974243,
0.3024201989173889,
-0.7443094253540039,
-0.10343137383460999,
-0.49834108352661133,
0.06516958028078079,
-0.07862139493227005,
0.10510596632957458,
-0.3505396246910095,
-0.27485474944114685,
0.5058221817016602,
0.5175933837890625,
-0.03844557702541351,
-0.5120449662208557,
-0.3003716468811035,
-0.5061711072921753,
0.34579870104789734,
0.6862163543701172,
-0.1632920503616333,
0.1356489360332489,
-0.10526461899280548,
0.8864782452583313,
0.07500217854976654,
0.2146928310394287,
-0.1125907376408577,
-0.46285945177078247,
-0.526453971862793,
-0.734804093837738,
0.4259379506111145,
0.6841242909431458,
-0.8217332363128662,
0.3575510084629059,
-0.4920089840888977,
-0.3641653060913086,
-0.605461061000824,
0.013071348890662193,
0.5342040061950684,
0.22124488651752472,
0.15431644022464752,
-0.4143669009208679,
-0.5920702815055847,
-0.7747159600257874,
-0.9474798440933228,
0.004925563931465149,
0.11783568561077118,
0.24363909661769867,
0.6307782530784607,
-0.19279909133911133,
0.9276976585388184,
-0.3209000527858734,
-0.19275414943695068,
-0.4528011679649353,
0.23583512008190155,
-0.12121965736150742,
0.40432795882225037,
0.8409463763237,
-1.0862782001495361,
-0.6899199485778809,
-0.06431210041046143,
-0.5567638278007507,
-0.3334539830684662,
0.14790858328342438,
-0.08633454889059067,
0.34790220856666565,
0.325709730386734,
-0.9356740713119507,
1.1368093490600586,
0.24571733176708221,
-0.2533109486103058,
0.45252764225006104,
0.5580773949623108,
0.5246096253395081,
-0.7374208569526672,
0.2675999701023102,
0.15171977877616882,
-0.32869863510131836,
-0.8981109857559204,
-0.032036080956459045,
-0.14262676239013672,
-0.11234460026025772,
-0.5865315198898315,
0.8216325044631958,
-0.2340078353881836,
-0.019317343831062317,
-0.23453086614608765,
-0.014204499311745167,
0.043457988649606705,
0.14611242711544037,
-0.25677257776260376,
0.653804361820221,
0.482097327709198,
-0.43996018171310425,
-0.17441357672214508,
0.008328649215400219,
-0.24325837194919586,
0.26360058784484863,
-0.7073022127151489,
0.05525890737771988,
-0.1245458722114563,
0.5238950252532959,
-1.2403242588043213,
-0.17877918481826782,
0.8696628212928772,
-0.6882660984992981,
0.2311931848526001,
-0.11280304938554764,
-0.5215331315994263,
-0.2520727813243866,
-0.5356239676475525,
0.7278539538383484,
0.5101413130760193,
-0.28578686714172363,
0.9625040888786316,
0.20468631386756897,
-0.340660035610199,
-0.8821611404418945,
-0.7116081118583679,
-0.08375994116067886,
-0.052893780171871185,
-0.6459477543830872,
0.40732502937316895,
0.22309660911560059,
-0.35788917541503906,
0.08432136476039886,
-0.2737056314945221,
-0.3345412313938141,
0.3364807665348053,
0.39274659752845764,
0.14419181644916534,
0.05764779448509216,
0.12463229149580002,
0.21917420625686646,
0.15666945278644562,
0.12405169010162354,
0.10956868529319763,
0.6716632843017578,
-0.06982821971178055,
-0.35775068402290344,
-1.1961857080459595,
0.29732832312583923,
0.7061729431152344,
-0.32164034247398376,
1.0107203722000122,
1.0563979148864746,
-0.5059204697608948,
0.1519131362438202,
-0.7004972696304321,
-0.2299865484237671,
-0.4937012195587158,
0.5857117176055908,
-0.3040844202041626,
-0.7436927556991577,
0.6497744917869568,
0.02640007995069027,
-0.38297125697135925,
0.3665632903575897,
0.08715267479419708,
0.19480547308921814,
1.1486462354660034,
0.40984636545181274,
-0.48941662907600403,
0.8501139879226685,
0.1794464886188507,
0.41263794898986816,
-0.5205331444740295,
0.15906867384910583,
-0.7650050520896912,
-0.3009207248687744,
-0.6619794368743896,
-0.1808628886938095,
0.14224068820476532,
-0.2521086633205414,
-0.21808044612407684,
-0.3080119788646698,
-0.015477900393307209,
0.6001573204994202,
0.27363622188568115,
0.2896660566329956,
0.09735807031393051,
0.3834362328052521,
0.36540186405181885,
0.006173448637127876,
-0.4631534814834595,
-0.37247300148010254,
0.9224921464920044,
0.13557115197181702,
0.49104681611061096,
0.11156968772411346,
0.6780687570571899,
0.72041916847229,
0.6840795874595642,
-0.6583476662635803,
0.48521479964256287,
-0.30806446075439453,
-0.49043604731559753,
-0.06639381498098373,
-0.6602858304977417,
-0.44203412532806396,
0.18425047397613525,
0.008553878404200077,
-0.6550502777099609,
-0.3042201101779938,
-0.033138781785964966,
-0.2789536714553833,
0.06825561821460724,
-0.6698144674301147,
0.6722748279571533,
-0.13477706909179688,
-0.14119447767734528,
-0.43844151496887207,
-0.7656382918357849,
0.25659751892089844,
0.02903435006737709,
0.4037906527519226,
-0.20075711607933044,
0.20620769262313843,
0.6372376680374146,
-0.24276213347911835,
0.908143937587738,
-0.31882941722869873,
0.2814970910549164,
0.6149937510490417,
0.043368250131607056,
0.4804860055446625,
0.09492898732423782,
-0.06883885711431503,
0.5150665044784546,
-0.29118821024894714,
-0.4084389805793762,
-0.5557430982589722,
0.6014891862869263,
-0.8345252275466919,
-0.6862708926200867,
-0.3709731996059418,
-0.34608450531959534,
0.11316417902708054,
-0.0006346573936752975,
0.17041130363941193,
0.28929105401039124,
-0.4401276111602783,
-0.23486405611038208,
0.12440328299999237,
-0.1653188019990921,
0.4002511203289032,
0.11208454519510269,
-0.016036590561270714,
-0.4953418970108032,
0.6956067085266113,
0.18989408016204834,
0.017161713913083076,
0.29106131196022034,
0.009676491841673851,
-0.3142121434211731,
-0.11941798031330109,
-0.2262766808271408,
0.3430846333503723,
-1.0248050689697266,
0.05337072163820267,
-0.8793421387672424,
-0.2839541733264923,
-0.8770243525505066,
-0.1383008509874344,
-0.10143603384494781,
-0.722486138343811,
-0.6095764636993408,
0.12724606692790985,
0.2869201898574829,
0.5522502660751343,
0.10918273031711578,
0.6293865442276001,
-0.9076144099235535,
0.27127835154533386,
-0.13390956819057465,
-0.07251136004924774,
0.1052667498588562,
-0.8034500479698181,
-0.28061455488204956,
0.11054496467113495,
-0.2589455544948578,
-0.7774461507797241,
0.41846323013305664,
0.49404582381248474,
0.3550460934638977,
0.6296807527542114,
0.008814052678644657,
0.6148735880851746,
-0.27910447120666504,
0.3563832938671112,
0.04331459850072861,
-1.3245227336883545,
0.6560322642326355,
-0.19090084731578827,
0.4782063364982605,
0.6042284965515137,
0.37515294551849365,
-0.5349396467208862,
-0.35244956612586975,
-0.6451694369316101,
-0.7386112809181213,
0.6947106122970581,
0.6487860679626465,
0.07652738690376282,
-0.10281399637460709,
0.6577107310295105,
-0.12287645041942596,
0.5333234667778015,
-0.7247911691665649,
-0.29135507345199585,
0.04087762534618378,
-0.47226426005363464,
0.011844441294670105,
-0.22047819197177887,
0.05165775865316391,
-0.4852823317050934,
0.4820491075515747,
0.24241118133068085,
0.06319896131753922,
-0.004473094828426838,
-0.5249444246292114,
-0.004513225052505732,
0.31588971614837646,
0.4232824444770813,
0.3332502543926239,
0.13871459662914276,
-0.10243862122297287,
-0.036392759531736374,
-0.7101931571960449,
-0.01591692678630352,
0.12985800206661224,
-0.16836804151535034,
0.31987690925598145,
0.2749893069267273,
0.4940882623195648,
0.11361708492040634,
-0.8903833627700806,
0.56360924243927,
-0.12660586833953857,
0.39451441168785095,
-0.3534029424190521,
0.04795287922024727,
-0.4276748299598694,
-0.05041448026895523,
0.43303340673446655,
0.5773520469665527,
0.35636842250823975,
-0.5761237144470215,
0.18987661600112915,
0.42458266019821167,
-0.34399592876434326,
-0.6601956486701965,
0.21182045340538025,
0.17034272849559784,
-0.30562835931777954,
0.5848340392112732,
-0.07445783913135529,
-1.1283540725708008,
1.052577018737793,
0.47861042618751526,
1.1379945278167725,
-0.6191645264625549,
0.48671650886535645,
0.042570967227220535,
0.4948156177997589,
0.11460086703300476,
0.6013197302818298,
-0.11324689537286758,
-0.753867506980896,
-0.15130212903022766,
-0.5118398070335388,
-0.02959386631846428,
-0.4090075194835663,
-0.4205889403820038,
0.33163943886756897,
-0.8233686089515686,
-0.3220718502998352,
0.022627035155892372,
-0.40159767866134644,
-1.0414619445800781,
0.4182594120502472,
0.41369134187698364,
0.5278730988502502,
-1.1490890979766846,
0.49552345275878906,
0.740388035774231,
-0.24874214828014374,
-0.6453388929367065,
0.4647047221660614,
0.0951339527964592,
-0.44424983859062195,
0.7241739630699158,
0.8078779578208923,
-0.5914228558540344,
0.053742945194244385,
-0.525994598865509,
-0.7205325365066528,
0.30894652009010315,
0.5780361294746399,
-0.15502144396305084,
0.4820649325847626,
0.2967921495437622,
0.826370358467102,
-0.3925991952419281,
0.8354513049125671,
0.6669058799743652,
0.47044217586517334,
0.10927537828683853,
-0.6924325227737427,
0.23799720406532288,
-0.4327995777130127,
-0.15552827715873718,
0.14797165989875793,
-0.5030333995819092,
1.0814462900161743,
-0.03891121596097946,
-0.4623483121395111,
0.12577983736991882,
0.35343196988105774,
0.06207234039902687,
0.4175375998020172,
0.354141503572464,
0.4998301863670349,
0.5727975964546204,
-0.02622975967824459,
1.0135949850082397,
-0.27412179112434387,
0.05648433789610863,
0.9161601662635803,
-0.49714040756225586,
0.7309094071388245,
0.3807099759578705,
0.10440553724765778,
0.7045254707336426,
0.44242003560066223,
0.4885327219963074,
0.48391857743263245,
0.13177748024463654,
-0.697060763835907,
-0.15603068470954895,
-0.6885368824005127,
-0.5077890753746033,
0.700295090675354,
0.5602753162384033,
-0.530644953250885,
0.04100191220641136,
-0.019655153155326843,
0.13115398585796356,
-0.17890849709510803,
-0.32985129952430725,
0.46695131063461304,
-0.09313037246465683,
-0.5498167276382446,
0.4697558283805847,
0.09522932022809982,
0.5480741262435913,
-0.3655936121940613,
0.004508061800152063,
-0.07890826463699341,
0.07965056598186493,
-0.3356066644191742,
-0.2370542585849762,
0.2671409845352173,
0.14964626729488373,
0.03529656305909157,
0.34091809391975403,
1.074632167816162,
-0.11363465338945389,
-0.5961408019065857,
0.45950740575790405,
0.5676700472831726,
0.09187022596597672,
-0.5137993693351746,
-0.7163645029067993,
0.13905026018619537,
-0.08723415434360504,
-0.30702945590019226,
0.17578473687171936,
0.65177983045578,
-0.04712183400988579,
0.5439890027046204,
0.6799593567848206,
-0.17456990480422974,
-0.1620168685913086,
0.5724953413009644,
1.258166790008545,
-0.7624948620796204,
-0.8254063129425049,
-1.2334887981414795,
0.3537800908088684,
-0.09890760481357574,
-0.2948459982872009,
0.6108492612838745,
0.18154118955135345,
0.707074761390686,
-0.1189403384923935,
1.0762114524841309,
-0.04130958393216133,
0.09326396137475967,
-0.2122248411178589,
0.7923288345336914,
-0.6287218332290649,
0.3214377760887146,
-0.8235573768615723,
-0.9105833172798157,
-0.554449737071991,
0.5531556010246277,
-0.5050354599952698,
0.6201562881469727,
0.5548906326293945,
0.7120487689971924,
0.1486898958683014,
0.4943067133426666,
0.1437496691942215,
0.18283073604106903,
0.18308590352535248,
0.11974935233592987,
1.1261109113693237,
-0.5411557555198669,
0.32833680510520935,
-0.1456797569990158,
-0.2724928557872772,
-0.34863826632499695,
-0.4071705639362335,
-1.0330184698104858,
0.1473798304796219,
-0.3809095323085785,
-0.16756311058998108,
0.3014783561229706,
1.0783635377883911,
0.2202284038066864,
-0.8123597502708435,
0.01890074461698532,
-0.11017069965600967,
0.23883074522018433,
-0.03561749681830406,
-0.26496562361717224,
0.25483274459838867,
-0.05866729095578194,
-0.462625652551651,
0.05696611851453781,
0.31731969118118286,
-0.016572050750255585,
0.2012113779783249,
-0.000011199229447811376,
-0.33785706758499146,
0.1592341661453247,
0.4632813334465027,
0.2696501910686493,
-0.7248169183731079,
-0.2807396948337555,
-0.018553227186203003,
-0.03753543645143509,
0.044050492346286774,
0.7855808734893799,
-0.8226280212402344,
0.2285153716802597,
0.2957453429698944,
0.6904790997505188,
0.06191470846533775,
0.30205509066581726,
0.17744821310043335,
-0.835405170917511,
0.5485303401947021,
0.434578001499176,
0.1736934632062912,
0.4361647963523865,
-0.6137930750846863,
0.3998274803161621,
0.3740799129009247,
-0.2894309163093567,
-0.832281768321991,
0.2215300053358078,
-0.39103925228118896,
-0.24291115999221802,
1.0706720352172852,
-0.1866510808467865,
-0.2928101420402527,
-0.32780084013938904,
-0.2375645488500595,
0.6546506881713867,
-0.605924129486084,
1.028407096862793,
0.6799089312553406,
0.02988489903509617,
-0.05585364252328873,
-0.20882605016231537,
0.42358630895614624,
0.9502392411231995,
-0.7142544388771057,
-0.2537192404270172,
0.34917357563972473,
0.027000170201063156,
-0.09606000781059265,
0.7253094911575317,
0.12299224734306335,
0.6232654452323914,
-0.1917364001274109,
0.1633753925561905,
0.4883480668067932,
-0.5756672024726868,
-0.4999873638153076,
0.12998588383197784,
-0.1202121153473854,
-0.024814022704958916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02178v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02178v2
|
Assessing and Verifying Task Utility in LLM-Powered Applications
| 2024-05-03T15:26:27 | 2024-05-12T15:52:49 |
Negar Arabzadeh, Siqing Huo, Nikhil Mehta, Qinqyun Wu, Chi Wang, Ahmed Awadallah, Charles L. A. Clarke, Julia Kiseleva
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid development of Large Language Models (LLMs) has led to a surge in
applications that facilitate collaboration among multiple agents, assisting
humans in their daily tasks. However, a significant gap remains in assessing to
what extent LLM-powered applications genuinely enhance user experience and task
execution efficiency. This highlights the need to verify utility of LLM-powered
applications, particularly by ensuring alignment between the application's
functionality and end-user needs. We introduce AgentEval, a novel framework
designed to simplify the utility verification process by automatically
proposing a set of criteria tailored to the unique purpose of any given
application. This allows for a comprehensive assessment, quantifying the
utility of an application against the suggested criteria. We present a
comprehensive analysis of the effectiveness and robustness of AgentEval for two
open source datasets including Math Problem solving and ALFWorld House-hold
related tasks. For reproducibility purposes, we make the data, code and all the
logs publicly available at https://bit.ly/3w3yKcS .
|
[
-0.10615815222263336,
-0.6835096478462219,
0.4992609918117523,
0.32332050800323486,
0.17219291627407074,
0.2304682582616806,
-0.17009000480175018,
-0.4293009340763092,
-0.03372592478990555,
0.6170107126235962,
-0.5003594160079956,
-0.6083513498306274,
-0.40470725297927856,
0.027965862303972244,
-0.3993595838546753,
0.6293081641197205,
-0.30654358863830566,
-0.24590565264225006,
-0.9100862145423889,
-0.2889719009399414,
-0.5887924432754517,
-0.3879125714302063,
-0.27911487221717834,
-0.6862021088600159,
0.1181127279996872,
0.57298344373703,
0.8694614171981812,
0.46523165702819824,
0.8236449360847473,
0.4244488477706909,
0.4860682487487793,
0.3407840430736542,
-0.34113556146621704,
0.5643322467803955,
-0.16291344165802002,
-0.28932422399520874,
-0.9610999226570129,
0.012976346537470818,
0.36261096596717834,
0.4943258464336395,
-0.3294427990913391,
0.5128912329673767,
0.30572542548179626,
0.5423351526260376,
-0.7819141745567322,
0.23735542595386505,
-0.6203623414039612,
-0.32094016671180725,
-0.11660147458314896,
-0.34972643852233887,
-0.2956891655921936,
-0.3621079921722412,
-0.24109560251235962,
-0.4344812035560608,
0.037926819175481796,
0.10999459773302078,
0.7017914056777954,
0.5786846876144409,
-0.5466289520263672,
-0.2851831912994385,
-0.726051390171051,
0.8485446572303772,
-0.404058039188385,
0.330638587474823,
0.5896000266075134,
0.6225125193595886,
-0.18510602414608002,
-0.6669853925704956,
-0.4677388668060303,
-0.6627768874168396,
-0.21064507961273193,
-0.0871381014585495,
-0.17296093702316284,
0.2141551971435547,
0.27660998702049255,
0.23915506899356842,
-0.6478524804115295,
0.01680360734462738,
0.1599993109703064,
-0.3601645529270172,
0.9048092365264893,
0.3591584861278534,
0.39941126108169556,
-0.07052616775035858,
-0.33409062027931213,
-0.042295560240745544,
-0.6576213240623474,
0.28546738624572754,
0.3101981282234192,
0.33029496669769287,
0.025875452905893326,
0.8733769655227661,
-0.09475301951169968,
0.3841538429260254,
-0.3136894404888153,
-0.12018158286809921,
0.2021489292383194,
-0.3988078832626343,
-0.1975872963666916,
-0.0196242593228817,
0.4536583125591278,
0.44860759377479553,
-0.012619288638234138,
-0.25312116742134094,
-0.40709322690963745,
-0.03823358565568924,
0.42652297019958496,
-0.6381589770317078,
0.2236699014902115,
0.6524829268455505,
-0.14206738770008087,
-0.23618698120117188,
-0.10995083302259445,
-0.1792178601026535,
-0.6807317733764648,
-0.3164346516132355,
0.3384852111339569,
-0.10855630785226822,
-0.25616902112960815,
0.11205704510211945,
0.222185418009758,
0.1823701113462448,
0.21862013638019562,
-0.7497090101242065,
0.3957306742668152,
1.2236695289611816,
0.7572605609893799,
-0.3779905438423157,
-0.38693463802337646,
-0.805496335029602,
-0.08690108358860016,
-0.1951722800731659,
0.7755448818206787,
-0.22094231843948364,
-0.2022632211446762,
0.09080709517002106,
0.021420467644929886,
-0.07811704277992249,
-0.48075729608535767,
0.7266589403152466,
-0.5462632179260254,
-0.3943580090999603,
-0.19912011921405792,
-0.6419557332992554,
0.12892575562000275,
0.45520156621932983,
-0.7469465136528015,
1.2733579874038696,
0.2513064742088318,
-0.4786718487739563,
0.3064776659011841,
-0.753977358341217,
-0.3885485529899597,
0.2398749589920044,
-0.03878997638821602,
-0.5277063250541687,
-0.0027553571853786707,
-0.10796189308166504,
0.40126681327819824,
-0.4829980432987213,
0.33292123675346375,
-0.3161426782608032,
-0.11243146657943726,
0.37547457218170166,
-0.42152658104896545,
0.741169810295105,
0.2878911793231964,
-0.41410624980926514,
0.3401417136192322,
-0.831031322479248,
0.17181189358234406,
-0.06648100167512894,
-0.032783836126327515,
-0.47790905833244324,
0.06449083983898163,
0.23690561950206757,
-0.026861228048801422,
0.777392566204071,
-0.6578571796417236,
0.0771586075425148,
-0.12067987769842148,
0.059926990419626236,
0.6258606314659119,
-0.3188669681549072,
0.20166878402233124,
-0.5200445652008057,
0.8776640892028809,
-0.5902342200279236,
0.27649107575416565,
0.04414242506027222,
-0.12790855765342712,
-0.4381573796272278,
-0.3141491115093231,
0.20675988495349884,
0.7862518429756165,
-0.6854287981987,
0.660980224609375,
-0.25248727202415466,
-0.6135279536247253,
-0.3766985237598419,
0.2940012216567993,
0.2448848932981491,
0.34589993953704834,
0.03076622076332569,
0.0032139720860868692,
-0.36113715171813965,
-0.7725546360015869,
-0.3593277633190155,
-0.3466688394546509,
-0.251808762550354,
0.6717396974563599,
0.27394720911979675,
-0.25034084916114807,
1.2097463607788086,
-0.14427289366722107,
-0.1934969127178192,
-0.40023329854011536,
-0.13234415650367737,
0.12772667407989502,
0.23682262003421783,
0.5059682726860046,
-0.6548674702644348,
-0.5800986886024475,
0.31336474418640137,
-0.8888697624206543,
-0.7419694066047668,
-0.08770667761564255,
-0.043327514082193375,
0.14568829536437988,
0.2558669447898865,
-0.49910029768943787,
0.379566490650177,
0.6788018345832825,
-0.5415211319923401,
0.5077653527259827,
-0.34894588589668274,
0.3452288806438446,
-0.8007533550262451,
0.4260547459125519,
-0.2159571498632431,
-0.5174590349197388,
-0.49230846762657166,
0.26881223917007446,
0.1561567783355713,
0.02936386689543724,
-0.32984915375709534,
0.5069376826286316,
-0.32294800877571106,
-0.24976846575737,
-0.4537806212902069,
0.10395526140928268,
0.026398610323667526,
0.059769146144390106,
-0.3768380284309387,
1.0283610820770264,
0.5577064156532288,
-0.28900688886642456,
0.6756570935249329,
-0.05472695454955101,
-0.2378523200750351,
0.5788764357566833,
-0.7459442615509033,
0.20367340743541718,
0.1912599354982376,
-0.1612185686826706,
-1.1243565082550049,
-0.298796683549881,
-0.1934615820646286,
-0.24212804436683655,
-0.1273627132177353,
0.26667702198028564,
-0.5525325536727905,
-0.1642220914363861,
-0.3913426101207733,
0.33435168862342834,
0.356078177690506,
-0.5181025862693787,
1.073297381401062,
0.44772589206695557,
-0.022131310775876045,
-0.690456211566925,
-0.21966594457626343,
0.10781218856573105,
-0.11259232461452484,
-0.8979449272155762,
0.2539730370044708,
0.027969840914011,
-0.6559428572654724,
0.017214370891451836,
-0.12232759594917297,
0.10323689877986908,
0.45653676986694336,
0.5578010082244873,
0.4134388864040375,
0.1272500455379486,
0.04673023894429207,
-0.04021867364645004,
-0.2192085087299347,
0.11503034830093384,
-0.04269077256321907,
0.28080040216445923,
-0.2979038655757904,
-0.8705326318740845,
-0.09210603684186935,
0.10766623169183731,
0.8336586952209473,
-0.18780528008937836,
0.33043619990348816,
0.32205846905708313,
-0.3212352991104126,
-0.1928255707025528,
-0.6134189963340759,
0.08467050641775131,
-0.5651736855506897,
0.29105445742607117,
-0.19355924427509308,
-0.7025899887084961,
0.7365778088569641,
-0.23462669551372528,
0.47988075017929077,
0.20190034806728363,
0.5621165037155151,
0.32670751214027405,
0.9920647740364075,
0.6997488141059875,
0.09210451692342758,
0.29772433638572693,
-0.1511501669883728,
0.10602084547281265,
-0.5789505839347839,
-0.38290032744407654,
-0.5798894762992859,
-0.16171860694885254,
-0.47415074706077576,
-0.27351781725883484,
0.5660117268562317,
-0.28120020031929016,
0.17540396749973297,
0.43989312648773193,
-0.2934142053127289,
0.537757396697998,
0.15553998947143555,
-0.22733426094055176,
0.4358197748661041,
-0.0023789468687027693,
-0.05663921684026718,
0.15541672706604004,
-0.3537410497665405,
-0.7878698110580444,
1.0770623683929443,
0.3861256241798401,
0.8233485221862793,
0.2128927856683731,
0.6544795036315918,
0.7003933191299438,
0.4593108892440796,
-0.9223149418830872,
0.7536686658859253,
-0.11395003646612167,
-0.426889032125473,
-0.5420191884040833,
-0.260129451751709,
-1.3004642724990845,
0.2042142003774643,
-0.06254979223012924,
-0.6963405013084412,
-0.17514953017234802,
0.23896802961826324,
-0.3728383779525757,
0.04759331792593002,
-0.5858067870140076,
0.797055184841156,
-0.5826687812805176,
-0.935899555683136,
-0.3866308629512787,
-0.24609315395355225,
0.12928955256938934,
-0.00686415983363986,
0.2399674355983734,
-0.3895502984523773,
-0.21945174038410187,
0.3332548439502716,
-0.7178260087966919,
0.4954927861690521,
-0.08867935836315155,
-0.4075467884540558,
0.2549757957458496,
0.09470003843307495,
0.5396902561187744,
-0.05009283125400543,
-0.3827053904533386,
0.055245332419872284,
0.14180196821689606,
-0.285688191652298,
-0.7852089405059814,
0.8441541790962219,
-0.5654232501983643,
-0.6516345739364624,
-0.518928587436676,
-0.5806395411491394,
-0.37122827768325806,
0.1567888706922531,
-0.29249897599220276,
0.378393292427063,
-0.3570150136947632,
0.2322743982076645,
0.17751145362854004,
0.23663818836212158,
0.3874540328979492,
0.5741333961486816,
-0.5254917144775391,
-0.055269695818424225,
0.7908521890640259,
-0.09905955940485,
0.1285363733768463,
0.21317245066165924,
0.146438330411911,
-0.4766845405101776,
-0.4632289409637451,
-0.3015400767326355,
-0.15880517661571503,
-0.5672592520713806,
-0.13557876646518707,
-0.2790001928806305,
-0.07977762818336487,
-0.25546008348464966,
-0.1295594573020935,
-0.504306972026825,
-0.36015671491622925,
-0.015331313014030457,
0.022611187770962715,
0.25573813915252686,
0.7187265157699585,
-0.00841926597058773,
0.00021100531739648432,
-0.7468230128288269,
0.21637244522571564,
0.39751672744750977,
0.3543199300765991,
-0.11304385960102081,
-0.04346199706196785,
-0.3081792891025543,
-0.1535327434539795,
-0.44928714632987976,
-0.5324653387069702,
0.3309735357761383,
0.20339177548885345,
0.777499258518219,
0.28519442677497864,
0.3766573965549469,
0.1655208319425583,
-0.25628912448883057,
0.9734225869178772,
-0.0008540854905731976,
-0.9328970313072205,
0.49593618512153625,
-0.0511910617351532,
0.07963701337575912,
0.6334731578826904,
0.12536346912384033,
-0.3076159656047821,
-0.43209490180015564,
-0.5954241752624512,
-0.9332584738731384,
0.374904066324234,
0.41888612508773804,
-0.020831061527132988,
0.2763780653476715,
0.25058114528656006,
0.20050150156021118,
0.0939517542719841,
-0.2954130172729492,
-0.29286903142929077,
-0.08165666460990906,
-0.23585131764411926,
-0.05058171600103378,
-0.025702260434627533,
-0.1860790103673935,
-0.010749719105660915,
0.5685486197471619,
-0.28720492124557495,
-0.17076478898525238,
0.020419053733348846,
-0.16208767890930176,
-0.055927399545907974,
0.35491445660591125,
0.36863964796066284,
0.8671870827674866,
-0.2776252031326294,
0.4332367181777954,
0.12390882521867752,
-0.7461016774177551,
0.4105996787548065,
0.3616271913051605,
0.04210742563009262,
-0.08180899918079376,
0.563852071762085,
0.5052809119224548,
-0.06162111833691597,
-0.9593179821968079,
0.5708766579627991,
-0.2840181589126587,
-0.035956911742687225,
-0.24095243215560913,
0.3811182677745819,
-0.22662651538848877,
0.3126753270626068,
0.4914093315601349,
-0.10192081332206726,
0.3260927200317383,
-0.3187504708766937,
0.2011522799730301,
0.780166745185852,
-0.11989002674818039,
-0.1855439692735672,
0.35046011209487915,
0.3748711347579956,
-0.6527837514877319,
0.22312350571155548,
-0.07341820001602173,
-0.2786041796207428,
0.83473801612854,
0.3286886513233185,
1.174782633781433,
-0.19121335446834564,
0.0974889025092125,
0.007542090956121683,
0.33546820282936096,
0.27701133489608765,
0.3437446355819702,
-0.3216666579246521,
-0.6212236285209656,
-0.5231150984764099,
-0.44816774129867554,
-0.6950975656509399,
-0.01714259199798107,
-0.6429612040519714,
0.1585361808538437,
-0.01279370579868555,
-0.46972760558128357,
-0.037402696907520294,
0.27338099479675293,
-0.5845892429351807,
-0.2942604720592499,
-0.19218192994594574,
0.9014276266098022,
-0.8122397661209106,
0.7592664957046509,
0.9485821723937988,
0.12400386482477188,
-0.7174473404884338,
0.037159234285354614,
0.03276945650577545,
-0.9443492889404297,
0.5007501244544983,
0.09358112514019012,
-0.5606971383094788,
-0.2118120640516281,
-0.4037225544452667,
-0.6507249474525452,
1.3832334280014038,
0.6728616952896118,
-0.5190845131874084,
0.45495155453681946,
0.5195528268814087,
0.5564775466918945,
-0.26581045985221863,
0.40488630533218384,
0.5717942118644714,
0.5221129059791565,
0.2427590936422348,
-1.2832704782485962,
0.15169928967952728,
-0.3855189383029938,
-0.004936295095831156,
-0.00787081103771925,
-0.3344988524913788,
0.3550785779953003,
-0.20738187432289124,
-0.1705619990825653,
-0.002959446981549263,
0.51226407289505,
0.46995922923088074,
0.7529438734054565,
0.6062001585960388,
0.11006101220846176,
1.0198200941085815,
0.22696731984615326,
1.1333121061325073,
-0.7208928465843201,
0.5489599704742432,
0.7166613936424255,
-0.733870267868042,
0.6953878402709961,
0.41972729563713074,
-0.3814442455768585,
0.2699566185474396,
0.34607136249542236,
0.3110961616039276,
0.3238566219806671,
0.05487782135605812,
-0.4039621353149414,
-0.4226049482822418,
-0.4045153558254242,
-0.22508810460567474,
0.48134297132492065,
0.14605647325515747,
0.07281196117401123,
-0.36348268389701843,
0.11111405491828918,
-0.26369571685791016,
0.23988878726959229,
-0.20227734744548798,
0.6406326293945312,
0.020508302375674248,
-0.8306136727333069,
0.496804803609848,
-0.09810381382703781,
0.3911886215209961,
-0.6955603361129761,
-0.15117132663726807,
-0.021238800138235092,
0.343136191368103,
-0.3656596839427948,
-0.8255761861801147,
0.36410799622535706,
-0.031387511640787125,
0.08830481767654419,
-0.2753128707408905,
1.116561770439148,
-0.17291906476020813,
-0.33382388949394226,
0.16085317730903625,
0.6217439770698547,
0.0789601132273674,
0.07977579534053802,
-0.5650832653045654,
0.2223268300294876,
-0.40544557571411133,
-0.11564207822084427,
0.29326483607292175,
0.2386731654405594,
-0.06018051505088806,
1.025970220565796,
0.6004887223243713,
0.12158916890621185,
-0.3780965805053711,
0.07622071355581284,
0.6323589086532593,
-0.13316026329994202,
-0.4686543941497803,
-0.9949046969413757,
0.4167023301124573,
-0.21309800446033478,
0.021999195218086243,
1.1403032541275024,
0.6873639822006226,
0.2456444650888443,
0.16532810032367706,
0.6914758682250977,
-0.020698867738246918,
0.15368081629276276,
-0.4254862666130066,
0.6439050436019897,
-0.5774422287940979,
0.6556797027587891,
0.008348523639142513,
-0.7308934330940247,
-0.280152827501297,
0.5246934294700623,
-0.4187498986721039,
0.06223021447658539,
0.6457055807113647,
0.9532586336135864,
-0.06903116405010223,
0.10249676555395126,
0.4746546149253845,
-0.2739558815956116,
0.40726619958877563,
0.459701806306839,
1.010211706161499,
-0.09795746207237244,
0.2870452404022217,
-0.12202991545200348,
-0.5492968559265137,
-0.3195771872997284,
-1.342672348022461,
-0.7613628506660461,
-0.4806205630302429,
-0.3891054689884186,
-0.5718933343887329,
0.04321833699941635,
1.2930610179901123,
0.6802330613136292,
-0.7244852185249329,
-0.5632742047309875,
-0.20189346373081207,
0.37791571021080017,
-0.5921515822410583,
-0.17773720622062683,
0.44172409176826477,
-0.32514688372612,
-0.3908824622631073,
0.20985820889472961,
0.3151978552341461,
-0.24454933404922485,
-0.6010026931762695,
-0.2664619982242584,
0.3845994472503662,
0.2521716058254242,
0.5720997452735901,
0.24602137506008148,
-0.5951604843139648,
-0.20125602185726166,
0.20888908207416534,
-0.30224382877349854,
-0.19533607363700867,
1.070328712463379,
-0.5988709926605225,
0.2720871865749359,
0.5189049243927002,
0.6715005040168762,
0.10755939036607742,
0.14174237847328186,
0.3096068799495697,
-0.819174587726593,
-0.2579392194747925,
0.1157049909234047,
0.36319777369499207,
0.2870939075946808,
-0.59141606092453,
0.49679964780807495,
-0.10732575505971909,
-0.9160610437393188,
-0.9006137847900391,
0.08154791593551636,
-1.1407949924468994,
0.026379553601145744,
1.238027811050415,
-0.2438667267560959,
-0.24440346658229828,
-0.3366059958934784,
-0.2946219742298126,
-0.1298506259918213,
-0.38677531480789185,
0.8934670686721802,
0.631417453289032,
-0.5581079125404358,
0.04342515394091606,
-0.5338641405105591,
0.4980839192867279,
0.3551791310310364,
-1.060153603553772,
0.5229361057281494,
0.4918327033519745,
0.15353675186634064,
0.26010578870773315,
0.5527585744857788,
0.22717776894569397,
0.2594411373138428,
-0.25158706307411194,
0.015181781724095345,
-0.46758145093917847,
-0.08700964599847794,
-0.25842222571372986,
0.4580390751361847,
0.3760963976383209,
-0.19434726238250732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02175v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02175v2
|
Hoaxpedia: A Unified Wikipedia Hoax Articles Dataset
| 2024-05-03T15:25:48 | 2024-05-15T17:56:25 |
Hsuvas Borkakoty, Luis Espinosa-Anke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Hoaxes are a recognised form of disinformation created deliberately, with
potential serious implications in the credibility of reference knowledge
resources such as Wikipedia. What makes detecting Wikipedia hoaxes hard is that
they often are written according to the official style guidelines. In this
work, we first provide a systematic analysis of the similarities and
discrepancies between legitimate and hoax Wikipedia articles, and introduce
Hoaxpedia, a collection of 311 Hoax articles (from existing literature as well
as official Wikipedia lists) alongside semantically similar real articles. We
report results of binary classification experiments in the task of predicting
whether a Wikipedia article is real or hoax, and analyze several settings as
well as a range of language models. Our results suggest that detecting
deceitful content in Wikipedia based on content alone, despite not having been
explored much in the past, is a promising direction.
|
[
-0.4943646788597107,
-0.7669758796691895,
0.2947000563144684,
0.11733052134513855,
-0.16550269722938538,
-0.03548379987478256,
-0.05431807413697243,
-0.6651920080184937,
0.7371758818626404,
0.5708417892456055,
-0.6946611404418945,
-0.06151571497321129,
-0.2540864646434784,
0.379214346408844,
-1.072488784790039,
0.9066984057426453,
0.25542107224464417,
0.12964196503162384,
-0.001762968604452908,
0.20265448093414307,
-0.013439977541565895,
-0.10248070955276489,
-0.2731936275959015,
0.2338527888059616,
0.7105661034584045,
0.29580438137054443,
0.5551659464836121,
0.29375705122947693,
0.3084750771522522,
0.26935961842536926,
0.23642432689666748,
0.30338239669799805,
-0.7332792282104492,
-0.1621820032596588,
-0.5638554692268372,
-0.2024783343076706,
0.3259376883506775,
0.4905868172645569,
0.32058969140052795,
0.42388391494750977,
-0.2864890396595001,
0.3089871108531952,
-0.22882257401943207,
0.35891270637512207,
-0.6453574895858765,
-0.09169162809848785,
-0.7983933687210083,
-0.12102391570806503,
-0.31883397698402405,
0.023657340556383133,
-0.6682561635971069,
-0.4437084496021271,
-0.0631149485707283,
-0.6314523220062256,
0.5173368453979492,
0.34621819853782654,
0.6542724967002869,
-0.004277929663658142,
-0.178633451461792,
-0.7583049535751343,
-0.8075839281082153,
0.3316861689090729,
-0.5619714260101318,
0.5122824311256409,
-0.004277456551790237,
0.13734933733940125,
-0.48395004868507385,
-0.6625128388404846,
-1.2735899686813354,
-0.31529927253723145,
-0.19735105335712433,
-0.21131034195423126,
-0.42016372084617615,
-0.23388457298278809,
0.2857079803943634,
0.18816140294075012,
-0.631822407245636,
0.11243517696857452,
-0.7005372643470764,
-0.5829852223396301,
0.5918291807174683,
-0.3646117150783539,
0.6068462133407593,
-0.703386664390564,
-0.437044620513916,
0.0011959811672568321,
-0.715852677822113,
-0.45841115713119507,
0.8662786483764648,
-0.25313958525657654,
0.0020224936306476593,
0.4939643144607544,
-0.17639747262001038,
0.44110068678855896,
0.17753084003925323,
-0.41529709100723267,
0.0962635725736618,
-0.193487286567688,
-0.021215738728642464,
0.46910861134529114,
0.6593663096427917,
0.3876674175262451,
0.6114552617073059,
-0.5983811020851135,
-0.0728767141699791,
0.22497931122779846,
0.6373320817947388,
-0.44796022772789,
-0.49222007393836975,
-0.053559914231300354,
-0.33696964383125305,
-0.8506664633750916,
0.5330962538719177,
-0.623903214931488,
-0.5958050489425659,
-0.28327229619026184,
0.5283970236778259,
-0.43968263268470764,
-0.4756699800491333,
-0.014955976977944374,
-0.5698660612106323,
-0.23922179639339447,
0.2991108000278473,
-0.4232093095779419,
0.19330622255802155,
0.6150051355361938,
0.3482881784439087,
-0.16388221085071564,
-0.45190003514289856,
-0.012008117511868477,
0.1648666262626648,
-0.6835548877716064,
1.0133302211761475,
-0.16304142773151398,
-0.02719695493578911,
-0.08963921666145325,
0.18411222100257874,
0.25218597054481506,
-0.20366257429122925,
0.722066342830658,
-0.9294360876083374,
0.404339075088501,
-0.36778533458709717,
-0.5107762813568115,
-0.5089657306671143,
0.25331446528434753,
-1.0528024435043335,
0.7985772490501404,
0.16153405606746674,
-1.1898221969604492,
0.6035699248313904,
-0.29492640495300293,
-0.3664100170135498,
-0.09014095366001129,
-0.16562844812870026,
0.07049140334129333,
0.08906780183315277,
-0.4247495234012604,
0.14889444410800934,
0.01715920865535736,
0.2541872262954712,
-0.18378154933452606,
-0.46054989099502563,
0.49735209345817566,
-0.7900304794311523,
0.8833135366439819,
0.1585351973772049,
-0.6064689755439758,
-0.27630239725112915,
-0.8292169570922852,
-0.31634098291397095,
-0.06078158691525459,
-0.20849379897117615,
-0.666622519493103,
-0.08346575498580933,
0.03926878049969673,
0.1498335748910904,
0.06516705453395844,
-0.5724700093269348,
0.08424685150384903,
-0.3509501814842224,
-0.05332845821976662,
0.6024706959724426,
0.2978864014148712,
0.13297685980796814,
-0.30416014790534973,
-0.09358280897140503,
0.15718182921409607,
0.41291141510009766,
0.11206670850515366,
-0.6066907644271851,
-0.661234974861145,
0.15416711568832397,
0.429800808429718,
0.5013005137443542,
-0.9363172650337219,
0.4236564040184021,
-0.5348201990127563,
-0.6860935091972351,
-0.2972193658351898,
0.028175711631774902,
0.29927271604537964,
0.914795994758606,
0.20871028304100037,
-0.15822657942771912,
-0.5526707172393799,
-1.0660061836242676,
-0.3608957827091217,
-0.356360524892807,
-0.09475835412740707,
-0.19246040284633636,
0.6482453346252441,
-0.1339711993932724,
0.9267421960830688,
-0.20801110565662384,
-0.0023171640932559967,
0.2637682855129242,
0.22656507790088654,
0.07129371911287308,
0.11202341318130493,
0.8936402201652527,
-1.3085278272628784,
-0.4520297050476074,
-0.4015985429286957,
-0.7299006581306458,
0.13435004651546478,
-0.15349029004573822,
-0.049882736057043076,
0.39952847361564636,
0.1740332990884781,
-0.689411997795105,
0.4201428294181824,
0.21117526292800903,
-0.41546425223350525,
0.8802764415740967,
0.025193586945533752,
0.7229474186897278,
-0.7191962599754333,
-0.0339103639125824,
-0.06644709408283234,
0.13629531860351562,
-0.818946361541748,
-0.20423106849193573,
0.28323838114738464,
0.3268226385116577,
-0.6158342361450195,
0.25956302881240845,
-0.18779256939888,
0.20341366529464722,
-0.3835794925689697,
-0.08170688897371292,
-0.02503766305744648,
0.11204826831817627,
0.08347475528717041,
0.5334648489952087,
0.3993358016014099,
-0.5808345675468445,
0.9813742637634277,
0.17261753976345062,
-0.5398841500282288,
0.5198491215705872,
-0.038151632994413376,
0.010964755900204182,
-0.2825591564178467,
0.40014931559562683,
-0.9319280982017517,
-0.6942132115364075,
0.8311987519264221,
-0.5489175915718079,
0.25686219334602356,
-0.09328482300043106,
-0.7501117587089539,
-0.7704823017120361,
-0.5225328803062439,
-0.08713417500257492,
0.3449830114841461,
-0.48957639932632446,
0.2779073119163513,
0.27107730507850647,
0.13836775720119476,
-0.8808092474937439,
-0.6414071321487427,
0.21155056357383728,
-0.18384015560150146,
-0.6507241725921631,
0.24311839044094086,
-0.16097649931907654,
-0.6588960886001587,
0.47917109727859497,
-0.2970822751522064,
-0.3412737548351288,
0.02238839492201805,
0.24934762716293335,
0.02815423719584942,
-0.17030608654022217,
0.04648548737168312,
-0.1690230518579483,
0.27859145402908325,
0.32127487659454346,
-0.21518410742282867,
0.380719929933548,
0.590017557144165,
-0.27795740962028503,
-0.5021375417709351,
-0.024159187451004982,
0.40870511531829834,
0.5102494359016418,
1.0005230903625488,
0.5532469749450684,
-0.5752626657485962,
-0.4971217215061188,
-1.0509978532791138,
-0.3441199064254761,
-0.46027541160583496,
-0.11680292338132858,
0.09318814426660538,
-0.16249562799930573,
0.23950639367103577,
0.3223077654838562,
-0.11826420575380325,
0.8116477727890015,
0.10641171783208847,
-0.14027178287506104,
0.1873866468667984,
0.4683968424797058,
-0.38301244378089905,
0.006063810549676418,
-0.008090862073004246,
-0.022820327430963516,
0.16090190410614014,
-0.5526696443557739,
-0.47497662901878357,
-0.3621431291103363,
-0.4104255735874176,
-0.36012715101242065,
0.11453813314437866,
-0.057437703013420105,
-0.040339551866054535,
0.5302560329437256,
-0.6567124128341675,
0.8797776103019714,
0.7906053066253662,
0.04254244640469551,
0.49683722853660583,
0.6452451348304749,
0.22278040647506714,
0.020014362409710884,
-0.5963941216468811,
-0.49068254232406616,
0.9941613674163818,
-0.1348189413547516,
0.8125770688056946,
0.21655121445655823,
0.3729560673236847,
1.0367852449417114,
0.6867656111717224,
-0.4735548794269562,
0.33641934394836426,
0.1257898360490799,
-1.1017990112304688,
-0.3252497911453247,
-0.49288907647132874,
-0.5531231760978699,
-0.14250726997852325,
-0.29509368538856506,
-0.44655725359916687,
0.2701765298843384,
-0.1420079469680786,
0.06368210166692734,
0.700891375541687,
-0.6448836326599121,
0.2884252369403839,
-0.16148334741592407,
0.05702881142497063,
-0.511189877986908,
-0.4439990818500519,
0.6720863580703735,
-0.5333527326583862,
0.6648507714271545,
0.013005426153540611,
0.024902135133743286,
0.8348817825317383,
0.10040497779846191,
0.8198842406272888,
0.07720116525888443,
-0.21428439021110535,
0.47164803743362427,
0.3643541634082794,
0.20783118903636932,
0.13783396780490875,
-0.1587764173746109,
0.19264356791973114,
0.08030117303133011,
-0.2726677656173706,
-0.39133694767951965,
1.0380216836929321,
-0.5634899735450745,
-0.4773889482021332,
-0.3850525915622711,
-0.0873793289065361,
-0.14616641402244568,
0.5709064602851868,
0.5639527440071106,
0.4250583052635193,
-0.3230211138725281,
-0.17048802971839905,
1.0035940408706665,
-0.04312074929475784,
0.23132900893688202,
0.8035874366760254,
0.05530986189842224,
-0.26210492849349976,
0.9554319381713867,
0.35304826498031616,
-0.16582714021205902,
0.31500059366226196,
0.045060209929943085,
-0.42963021993637085,
-0.5889204144477844,
-0.6406479477882385,
0.31698107719421387,
-0.7850381135940552,
-0.012265047989785671,
-0.22545967996120453,
-0.25824594497680664,
-0.6773804426193237,
0.13882960379123688,
-0.13755379617214203,
-0.5753352046012878,
-0.14169161021709442,
-0.13390225172042847,
0.46416178345680237,
1.3279703855514526,
-0.24748700857162476,
-0.21268971264362335,
-0.6005010008811951,
0.6765134930610657,
0.24760369956493378,
0.37064385414123535,
-0.05762558430433273,
-0.4251309037208557,
0.11842416971921921,
0.2922501564025879,
-0.14840282499790192,
-1.3246628046035767,
-0.02027466893196106,
-0.10630673170089722,
0.7099241018295288,
0.9019418358802795,
0.36767786741256714,
0.18239182233810425,
-0.6423100829124451,
0.7208229303359985,
0.42088788747787476,
-0.4304925799369812,
0.37902238965034485,
-0.2549354135990143,
-0.6541919112205505,
0.46685564517974854,
1.1893506050109863,
-0.430927574634552,
-0.18688060343265533,
-1.108424425125122,
-0.13161955773830414,
0.5152574181556702,
0.32081183791160583,
0.39896705746650696,
-0.129036545753479,
0.4328742027282715,
0.35729900002479553,
0.5680449604988098,
-0.7608745694160461,
-0.6990752220153809,
-0.19631679356098175,
-0.10050436109304428,
0.20217764377593994,
-0.5072958469390869,
-0.4525870680809021,
-0.035311851650476456,
0.6623180508613586,
0.2108793556690216,
-0.0021164105273783207,
0.1545403003692627,
-0.2218148559331894,
-0.34872573614120483,
-0.12105004489421844,
0.46893036365509033,
1.1491385698318481,
0.10338421911001205,
0.4162594676017761,
0.045823995023965836,
-0.8026278018951416,
0.1368643343448639,
0.058457568287849426,
-0.5164899230003357,
0.4956524074077606,
0.47649845480918884,
0.15663863718509674,
0.7824745178222656,
-0.6786603927612305,
0.5598357915878296,
0.22016894817352295,
-0.21543456614017487,
-0.4973128139972687,
0.26326969265937805,
0.11752413213253021,
-0.16638723015785217,
0.7702088952064514,
0.1271229088306427,
0.4775862991809845,
-0.6816232204437256,
0.48897695541381836,
0.3233814239501953,
0.06403268128633499,
-0.47001346945762634,
0.35130444169044495,
0.1820252239704132,
-0.18839195370674133,
0.6169560551643372,
-0.3180507719516754,
-0.53854900598526,
0.49887678027153015,
0.08220597356557846,
0.07661698013544083,
-0.27498966455459595,
0.5827712416648865,
0.33573299646377563,
0.6935030221939087,
-0.23333525657653809,
0.03581616282463074,
0.21064388751983643,
-0.8714039921760559,
-0.06869346648454666,
-0.8026456832885742,
-0.2829257845878601,
0.458659827709198,
-0.14579914510250092,
0.3903774321079254,
-0.25828805565834045,
0.3039659261703491,
0.3990209102630615,
-0.04330633208155632,
-0.24680009484291077,
0.28016024827957153,
0.3887442648410797,
1.5351178646087646,
-0.7308595776557922,
0.612468421459198,
0.2919236123561859,
-0.6018611788749695,
-0.7367137670516968,
0.1545330137014389,
0.18951405584812164,
-0.2521393895149231,
0.3874601423740387,
0.043518878519535065,
0.01366282720118761,
0.038314081728458405,
-0.6985771059989929,
-0.7769306898117065,
0.7046172022819519,
0.33876678347587585,
-0.2971537113189697,
-0.5927353501319885,
0.3664345145225525,
0.16354556381702423,
0.07756907492876053,
-0.2414010465145111,
0.3155401349067688,
0.7185482978820801,
0.04421182721853256,
-0.8837403059005737,
-0.0521773099899292,
0.11532286554574966,
-0.5438634157180786,
0.1601354330778122,
-0.4693799912929535,
0.5029231309890747,
0.09153055399656296,
-0.21740232408046722,
-0.048744603991508484,
0.5720664262771606,
-0.12278101593255997,
0.5622003674507141,
0.6398906111717224,
0.5232890844345093,
0.89036625623703,
-0.07757517695426941,
0.7475194334983826,
-0.23648740351200104,
0.26671847701072693,
0.4060772657394409,
0.1850282847881317,
0.5291961431503296,
0.28186357021331787,
-0.15086756646633148,
0.8802018165588379,
0.6215586066246033,
-0.3212078809738159,
0.40495967864990234,
0.15401680767536163,
-0.2396862953901291,
-0.05597454309463501,
0.1395350992679596,
-0.3568927049636841,
0.2422061562538147,
0.5091701745986938,
-0.32684072852134705,
-0.36908960342407227,
0.05395958945155144,
0.1723785549402237,
0.06909104436635971,
-0.4005207419395447,
0.5575931668281555,
-0.12575633823871613,
-0.5437907576560974,
0.2923361659049988,
-0.014946412295103073,
0.8770498633384705,
-0.5105850696563721,
-0.033057015389204025,
-0.08095205575227737,
-0.2254013568162918,
-0.3829667866230011,
-0.6827366948127747,
0.3647872507572174,
0.08087143301963806,
-0.4627443253993988,
0.17839853465557098,
1.1969901323318481,
-0.12216223031282425,
-0.4711221158504486,
-0.14743201434612274,
0.331503301858902,
0.32993611693382263,
-0.2798388600349426,
-0.4604102373123169,
-0.06815708428621292,
-0.05497949197888374,
-0.3067619800567627,
0.20754273235797882,
0.5912821888923645,
0.0020195075776427984,
0.653843343257904,
0.789932906627655,
-0.0033325457479804754,
0.17826269567012787,
-0.4496692717075348,
0.7850450873374939,
-0.516979455947876,
-0.6131371855735779,
-0.5925534963607788,
0.0731993168592453,
-0.4566635489463806,
-0.06941742449998856,
1.1528290510177612,
0.7706683278083801,
0.8515936136245728,
-0.48403796553611755,
0.6219659447669983,
-0.3329654932022095,
0.6098843216896057,
-0.3715546429157257,
1.1475772857666016,
-0.2678601145744324,
-0.019209932535886765,
-0.16312506794929504,
-0.7309396862983704,
0.11899765580892563,
0.26242461800575256,
0.017057809978723526,
-0.2732613682746887,
0.4450806677341461,
0.7344563603401184,
-0.49649444222450256,
0.37263384461402893,
0.10702572762966156,
0.3571415841579437,
-0.28978830575942993,
-0.20115652680397034,
0.9595686197280884,
-0.12952974438667297,
0.649165153503418,
-0.6336585879325867,
-0.09665373712778091,
-0.25913339853286743,
-0.6649082899093628,
-0.7111724019050598,
-0.6131840348243713,
-0.3521959185600281,
-0.6847608685493469,
-0.10986620932817459,
0.4284951090812683,
0.602661669254303,
-0.8236374258995056,
0.3157942295074463,
-0.04805412143468857,
0.43450164794921875,
0.15401513874530792,
-0.28959500789642334,
0.014366998337209225,
0.0804329439997673,
-0.6294668912887573,
0.5570350885391235,
-0.06609418988227844,
0.009576349519193172,
-0.7393372058868408,
0.09265486150979996,
-0.03404925391077995,
0.5485666990280151,
0.2576049566268921,
0.36635974049568176,
-0.7526291608810425,
-0.42075347900390625,
-0.2204563319683075,
-0.25496503710746765,
-0.5480842590332031,
0.6885651350021362,
-0.999353289604187,
0.0060645765624940395,
0.3801182508468628,
0.03441070765256882,
0.054957758635282516,
-0.06704513728618622,
0.010998275130987167,
-0.7399739027023315,
0.10043118894100189,
0.04371035471558571,
0.023401591926813126,
0.1994287520647049,
-0.6101338267326355,
0.48885807394981384,
0.852363646030426,
-0.15619023144245148,
-1.067023754119873,
0.09046657383441925,
-0.8783348202705383,
-0.6733444929122925,
1.1275684833526611,
0.2651522159576416,
-0.31079205870628357,
-0.33914029598236084,
-0.024547016248106956,
0.05048210918903351,
-0.08817274868488312,
1.209526777267456,
0.8815438747406006,
0.14284740388393402,
0.4283171594142914,
-0.453309029340744,
0.7359454035758972,
-0.6326021552085876,
-0.637740433216095,
-0.3410656750202179,
0.837375819683075,
0.9846517443656921,
0.7672526240348816,
0.2885269820690155,
0.21128715574741364,
0.6610233187675476,
0.1759798675775528,
-0.27598458528518677,
-0.1383017897605896,
-0.5418798923492432,
0.32233095169067383,
0.4622511863708496,
-0.31424251198768616,
0.3398653268814087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02165v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02165v1
|
EEG2TEXT: Open Vocabulary EEG-to-Text Decoding with EEG Pre-Training and Multi-View Transformer
| 2024-05-03T15:14:19 | 2024-05-03T15:14:19 |
Hanwen Liu, Daniel Hajialigol, Benny Antony, Aiguo Han, Xuan Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Deciphering the intricacies of the human brain has captivated curiosity for
centuries. Recent strides in Brain-Computer Interface (BCI) technology,
particularly using motor imagery, have restored motor functions such as
reaching, grasping, and walking in paralyzed individuals. However, unraveling
natural language from brain signals remains a formidable challenge.
Electroencephalography (EEG) is a non-invasive technique used to record
electrical activity in the brain by placing electrodes on the scalp. Previous
studies of EEG-to-text decoding have achieved high accuracy on small closed
vocabularies, but still fall short of high accuracy when dealing with large
open vocabularies. We propose a novel method, EEG2TEXT, to improve the accuracy
of open vocabulary EEG-to-text decoding. Specifically, EEG2TEXT leverages EEG
pre-training to enhance the learning of semantics from EEG signals and proposes
a multi-view transformer to model the EEG signal processing by different
spatial regions of the brain. Experiments show that EEG2TEXT has superior
performance, outperforming the state-of-the-art baseline methods by a large
margin of up to 5% in absolute BLEU and ROUGE scores. EEG2TEXT shows great
potential for a high-performance open-vocabulary brain-to-text system to
facilitate communication.
|
[
-0.2682923376560211,
-1.0038617849349976,
0.6238623857498169,
0.48122265934944153,
-0.40299102663993835,
-0.30128976702690125,
-0.3304964303970337,
-0.6462339162826538,
0.4468323588371277,
0.34598100185394287,
-0.38495534658432007,
-0.46701306104660034,
-0.7986112833023071,
0.010226611979305744,
-0.3249850869178772,
0.6316990256309509,
-0.14752283692359924,
0.07572431117296219,
-0.29418328404426575,
0.024166878312826157,
-0.6759209036827087,
-0.4962195158004761,
-0.49450361728668213,
-0.3155394494533539,
0.3820174038410187,
0.20214037597179413,
0.2262580692768097,
0.15106891095638275,
0.18379417061805725,
0.13524973392486572,
-0.05824076756834984,
0.3667515218257904,
-0.423271507024765,
-0.3268181383609772,
-0.10630246251821518,
-0.5028371810913086,
-0.6637479662895203,
-0.27312391996383667,
0.29025793075561523,
0.6314648389816284,
-0.10167577117681503,
-0.05617119371891022,
0.27495360374450684,
0.6527546048164368,
-0.7089784741401672,
0.21255964040756226,
-0.4223076403141022,
-0.11423926800489426,
-0.1722138524055481,
-0.316005140542984,
-0.7996237277984619,
-0.011057419702410698,
0.13882975280284882,
-0.706393837928772,
-0.07060512155294418,
0.11825163662433624,
0.9378105998039246,
0.02900831587612629,
-0.6423117518424988,
-0.06150920316576958,
-0.6004849076271057,
0.5754271149635315,
-0.18722526729106903,
0.6377421021461487,
0.5927678942680359,
-0.03135436400771141,
0.07638224959373474,
-1.0045408010482788,
-0.7206825613975525,
0.15496596693992615,
-0.26060599088668823,
0.4610009491443634,
-0.20064164698123932,
0.24267578125,
-0.033542755991220474,
-0.031336262822151184,
-0.5789199471473694,
0.17606669664382935,
-0.3408183753490448,
-0.2650300860404968,
0.1883469820022583,
-0.27504634857177734,
0.39716044068336487,
-0.06746182590723038,
-0.327938050031662,
-0.24133345484733582,
-0.40758201479911804,
-0.12381645292043686,
0.2189420908689499,
-0.09128528833389282,
-0.05631551146507263,
0.5645383596420288,
0.19927681982517242,
0.43931248784065247,
-0.015076127834618092,
0.0863921269774437,
0.393870085477829,
-0.27083447575569153,
0.07511717826128006,
0.16934560239315033,
0.519368588924408,
0.6722815632820129,
0.16152514517307281,
-0.4515782296657562,
0.0830252394080162,
-0.04223603010177612,
0.3899066150188446,
-0.7723128199577332,
-0.3206477165222168,
0.2955007255077362,
-0.8557274341583252,
0.15880189836025238,
-0.03184281662106514,
-1.0632752180099487,
-0.281809538602829,
-0.2680220305919647,
0.7530288696289062,
-0.5473913550376892,
-0.36301159858703613,
0.4334813058376312,
-0.17381684482097626,
0.2704711854457855,
0.3440690338611603,
-0.97055584192276,
0.3327312171459198,
0.24797263741493225,
0.9762184023857117,
-0.1357073336839676,
-0.31275224685668945,
-0.30178436636924744,
0.3309796154499054,
-0.18476204574108124,
0.8813425302505493,
-0.06061799079179764,
-0.22208473086357117,
0.039578069001436234,
-0.055734239518642426,
-0.20035621523857117,
-0.1420794427394867,
0.48598942160606384,
-0.5323801636695862,
0.47042980790138245,
-0.06142297014594078,
-0.42029649019241333,
-0.13169845938682556,
-0.0893549844622612,
-0.6985810399055481,
0.6746246218681335,
-0.2751186788082123,
-0.7052597403526306,
0.05006280913949013,
-0.9586511254310608,
-0.6756365895271301,
0.004818141460418701,
-0.20708665251731873,
-0.12865515053272247,
0.13655751943588257,
0.32498931884765625,
0.19423186779022217,
-0.18074312806129456,
-0.24388472735881805,
0.13027936220169067,
-0.23288433253765106,
0.020186996087431908,
-0.5472316145896912,
0.5342430472373962,
0.009296574629843235,
-0.16065119206905365,
-0.10343968868255615,
-0.6997949481010437,
0.33196526765823364,
0.13005554676055908,
-0.12151063978672028,
-0.5279870629310608,
0.27452942728996277,
0.522655725479126,
0.1293850690126419,
0.4784829914569855,
-0.6554247140884399,
-0.2587987184524536,
-0.8118121027946472,
0.4637960195541382,
0.32226699590682983,
-0.29917851090431213,
0.4036657512187958,
0.2278057187795639,
-0.04982113093137741,
0.23605652153491974,
-0.2131967693567276,
-0.48057636618614197,
-0.5786730647087097,
-0.5076225996017456,
-0.050063975155353546,
0.29570749402046204,
0.836481511592865,
-0.9879900217056274,
0.8733006715774536,
-0.40556207299232483,
-0.25112855434417725,
-0.6536208391189575,
-0.3408438563346863,
0.18746225535869598,
0.5449121594429016,
1.0013344287872314,
-0.40321093797683716,
-0.39166685938835144,
-0.8635278344154358,
-0.34087783098220825,
-0.07556963711977005,
-0.5332723259925842,
0.21611207723617554,
0.20768992602825165,
-0.35336822271347046,
0.8280500173568726,
-0.5947402119636536,
-0.6580922603607178,
-0.0970328226685524,
0.45711347460746765,
-0.13952913880348206,
0.2575441896915436,
0.34416723251342773,
-0.7082825899124146,
-0.20394045114517212,
0.2096278816461563,
-0.6560695767402649,
0.017990941181778908,
-0.23746523261070251,
-0.30690550804138184,
0.3160778284072876,
0.5920659303665161,
-0.4606958329677582,
0.6278212666511536,
0.3977166712284088,
-0.6511832475662231,
0.18178069591522217,
-0.7331311106681824,
0.19210924208164215,
-1.08675217628479,
0.11775243282318115,
0.019100049510598183,
0.057261332869529724,
-0.6411699652671814,
-0.26256775856018066,
0.38679033517837524,
0.33724480867385864,
-0.3026534914970398,
0.45594629645347595,
-0.5254731774330139,
0.3033004403114319,
-0.4023955464363098,
0.38444438576698303,
0.03901653364300728,
0.3982009291648865,
0.4162425696849823,
0.6373497843742371,
0.40281224250793457,
-0.45478588342666626,
-0.013634822331368923,
0.691401481628418,
-0.15605829656124115,
0.5170493721961975,
-0.5480454564094543,
0.35584065318107605,
-0.5394130945205688,
0.137538880109787,
-0.9091121554374695,
-0.2564523220062256,
-0.1866641789674759,
-0.5203118324279785,
0.4736972153186798,
0.375346839427948,
-0.4490012228488922,
-0.16278007626533508,
-0.1862945854663849,
0.579296350479126,
0.7266992926597595,
-0.7902631759643555,
0.7212036848068237,
0.4562838673591614,
0.11171511560678482,
-0.4129641652107239,
-1.1326227188110352,
0.5253536701202393,
0.2857682704925537,
-0.7069294452667236,
0.5912880301475525,
0.17695200443267822,
0.26837828755378723,
-0.26672258973121643,
-0.33017998933792114,
-0.24096274375915527,
-0.2342413067817688,
-0.03549587354063988,
0.21754203736782074,
0.15602563321590424,
0.22773174941539764,
0.3991797864437103,
-0.17136754095554352,
0.3452370762825012,
-0.547150731086731,
0.5356414914131165,
0.15912264585494995,
-0.0830800011754036,
-0.328266978263855,
0.49533960223197937,
0.2974970042705536,
-0.3274773359298706,
0.7507163286209106,
0.5958577394485474,
-0.6635355949401855,
-0.026679860427975655,
-0.2628493309020996,
-0.34487706422805786,
-0.4740844964981079,
0.8380663394927979,
-0.4300483167171478,
-0.6801719069480896,
-0.06506887078285217,
-0.3734784722328186,
-0.07755912840366364,
0.18816977739334106,
0.556170642375946,
-0.22136394679546356,
0.8463605642318726,
0.8653890490531921,
0.4044230878353119,
0.3505527973175049,
0.12035847455263138,
0.6248002052307129,
-0.6580643057823181,
-0.7843288779258728,
-0.22618114948272705,
-0.373308390378952,
-0.2804848849773407,
-0.2888747453689575,
0.3880976140499115,
0.0796755701303482,
0.1980012059211731,
0.3851590156555176,
-0.6190218925476074,
0.5428796410560608,
0.3149416148662567,
0.6214542388916016,
0.14113736152648926,
0.42725998163223267,
-0.1529625803232193,
-0.3307260572910309,
-0.40524762868881226,
-0.5949772000312805,
1.076948642730713,
0.37891972064971924,
0.6888573169708252,
0.025121627375483513,
0.4687180519104004,
0.04188225418329239,
-0.06403393298387527,
-0.8467090129852295,
0.5138582587242126,
-0.20452719926834106,
-0.20481052994728088,
-0.15500663220882416,
-0.12944188714027405,
-1.0709950923919678,
0.2553938925266266,
-0.26117032766342163,
-1.1342906951904297,
0.0857110545039177,
0.25204116106033325,
-0.20602937042713165,
0.3668076992034912,
-1.067152500152588,
0.8281030058860779,
-0.2498045563697815,
-0.5075132250785828,
-0.3996220529079437,
-0.923099935054779,
0.1170356273651123,
-0.010735486634075642,
0.23810681700706482,
0.4268074035644531,
-0.337628036737442,
0.8234942555427551,
-0.20795905590057373,
0.6375172734260559,
-0.07734829187393188,
-0.1950996220111847,
0.2186543047428131,
-0.21655292809009552,
0.11023488640785217,
-0.009014679118990898,
0.2959555685520172,
0.6468780636787415,
0.12047300487756729,
-0.4198318421840668,
-0.37426742911338806,
0.475900799036026,
-0.8409697413444519,
-0.09256912022829056,
-0.2821453809738159,
-0.22426307201385498,
-0.3487590253353119,
0.4071175158023834,
0.7857705950737,
0.4045106768608093,
-0.39870578050613403,
0.11249618977308273,
1.1025232076644897,
-0.2756768465042114,
0.5192227363586426,
-0.0375535748898983,
-0.06819334626197815,
-0.45411360263824463,
0.7994711399078369,
0.04736613109707832,
-0.061213742941617966,
0.8680830597877502,
-0.3328927159309387,
-0.4004618525505066,
-0.4709811806678772,
-0.28022459149360657,
0.24636642634868622,
-0.5097355246543884,
-0.024451810866594315,
-0.883283793926239,
-0.014722532592713833,
-0.22775350511074066,
0.014416741207242012,
-0.3053961992263794,
-0.2363060563802719,
-0.34078410267829895,
-0.12660203874111176,
0.139701247215271,
0.3255012035369873,
0.052144598215818405,
0.458761602640152,
-0.7629860639572144,
0.6181870698928833,
0.22970351576805115,
0.616818368434906,
-0.12908422946929932,
-0.3630746304988861,
-0.3925458788871765,
0.18224668502807617,
-0.2361948937177658,
-1.1199129819869995,
0.4219955503940582,
0.12481178343296051,
0.12611152231693268,
0.1675264835357666,
-0.10880858451128006,
0.41757869720458984,
-0.8675270676612854,
0.773849368095398,
0.8174010515213013,
-0.9120934009552002,
0.5507294535636902,
0.03796352818608284,
0.3222019672393799,
0.3037758767604828,
0.23989368975162506,
-0.45958179235458374,
0.20390942692756653,
-0.2149784117937088,
-1.2388432025909424,
0.7655428051948547,
0.3615206480026245,
0.16517765820026398,
-0.04914913326501846,
0.3926238715648651,
0.11449167877435684,
0.06742522865533829,
-0.6301564574241638,
-0.44624394178390503,
-0.5802005529403687,
-0.6019500494003296,
-0.010891251266002655,
-0.4322103261947632,
-0.1501883864402771,
-0.18748176097869873,
0.23637157678604126,
-0.2763969302177429,
1.0995094776153564,
0.2749759256839752,
-0.30625462532043457,
0.08063646405935287,
0.3107479512691498,
0.5222510695457458,
0.3571208119392395,
0.026513230055570602,
0.238285094499588,
0.3179047405719757,
-1.1645421981811523,
-0.051419440656900406,
0.19969582557678223,
0.12632691860198975,
0.07973567396402359,
0.21571871638298035,
0.9185460209846497,
-0.1572866588830948,
-0.6673654913902283,
0.7713334560394287,
-0.35428494215011597,
-0.5327317118644714,
-0.35257649421691895,
-0.41519948840141296,
0.1779123991727829,
-0.019407663494348526,
0.3258714973926544,
0.2614290118217468,
0.11104215681552887,
-0.19321855902671814,
0.040969256311655045,
0.07343115657567978,
-0.23051106929779053,
-0.5404210090637207,
0.8903884887695312,
0.3127533197402954,
-0.351209819316864,
0.49105894565582275,
0.05122431740164757,
-0.15267427265644073,
0.34375500679016113,
0.7257118225097656,
1.0285052061080933,
0.12845970690250397,
-0.14990834891796112,
0.35165369510650635,
0.5239624381065369,
-0.2936381995677948,
0.5214797258377075,
0.0400790311396122,
-0.6972036361694336,
-0.5869209170341492,
-0.4688740372657776,
-0.09843607991933823,
0.19858165085315704,
-0.6031398773193359,
0.3943832516670227,
-0.1538669764995575,
-0.05974005535244942,
-0.19937825202941895,
-0.5436782836914062,
-0.6498285531997681,
0.29304131865501404,
0.2953597903251648,
1.0665061473846436,
-0.4687178432941437,
0.900131344795227,
0.9514985084533691,
-0.1737722009420395,
-0.5400559306144714,
0.38108667731285095,
-0.30130642652511597,
-0.40791428089141846,
0.30460911989212036,
0.47857096791267395,
-0.25040948390960693,
0.31235581636428833,
-0.5409497618675232,
-0.579971194267273,
1.117835283279419,
0.18090583384037018,
-0.569024920463562,
-0.3458156883716583,
0.027168983593583107,
0.4866282641887665,
0.106869176030159,
0.6768926978111267,
0.5498813986778259,
0.6022248268127441,
-0.25915759801864624,
-0.9892660975456238,
-0.1856282502412796,
-0.23969876766204834,
0.011286914348602295,
0.36526596546173096,
-0.5419172644615173,
0.514266848564148,
-0.03139335289597511,
-0.20135881006717682,
-0.0045598819851875305,
0.959481954574585,
-0.25515756011009216,
0.4586329758167267,
0.22218045592308044,
0.2653639316558838,
0.7051121592521667,
-0.2354729175567627,
0.7675952315330505,
-0.2882412374019623,
0.21397069096565247,
0.8177874684333801,
-0.05815192312002182,
0.9775598049163818,
0.6724892258644104,
0.010179639793932438,
0.5431897640228271,
0.1974642425775528,
0.3751869797706604,
0.730124294757843,
-0.13777214288711548,
-0.3239932358264923,
-0.1325807273387909,
0.4204316735267639,
-0.10237858444452286,
0.4595434069633484,
0.5790284872055054,
0.006597697734832764,
-0.29615887999534607,
0.45585542917251587,
-0.05353764817118645,
0.49377432465553284,
-0.3829510807991028,
0.6996270418167114,
0.16520701348781586,
-0.5041314363479614,
0.29100480675697327,
0.3193267285823822,
0.9711290597915649,
-0.7516694068908691,
-0.1226973906159401,
0.27820342779159546,
0.3066962659358978,
-0.2747725546360016,
-0.5819858908653259,
0.2982865571975708,
-0.04209044203162193,
-0.11050903797149658,
-0.36492612957954407,
0.8419002890586853,
-0.6217381954193115,
-0.07548893988132477,
0.565530002117157,
0.5432788729667664,
0.10716147720813751,
-0.15760861337184906,
-0.21649259328842163,
-0.34480464458465576,
-0.16339772939682007,
-0.26129209995269775,
0.29420119524002075,
0.47484537959098816,
-0.023794271051883698,
0.07566144317388535,
0.18215110898017883,
-0.16899490356445312,
-0.03290608525276184,
-0.19054758548736572,
0.520178496837616,
-0.655658483505249,
-0.7374952435493469,
-0.7544539570808411,
0.570997416973114,
-0.19089601933956146,
-0.39235541224479675,
0.6002145409584045,
0.45024678111076355,
0.9268525242805481,
-0.19173596799373627,
0.7987500429153442,
-0.22781653702259064,
0.4792267084121704,
-0.7376440167427063,
0.9641919136047363,
-0.46634528040885925,
-0.15236158668994904,
0.05786862596869469,
-0.7468377351760864,
-0.26592788100242615,
0.7309803366661072,
-0.12326925992965698,
0.06624511629343033,
1.29462730884552,
0.5980332493782043,
-0.04203140735626221,
0.2385426014661789,
0.3870004117488861,
0.2669627070426941,
0.09859170019626617,
0.6177822351455688,
0.3650970757007599,
-0.654017448425293,
0.6892814040184021,
0.14856967329978943,
-0.5443782806396484,
-0.13254576921463013,
-0.740856945514679,
-0.9623063206672668,
-0.5850345492362976,
-0.18212522566318512,
-0.4478835463523865,
-0.029266443103551865,
0.8531705737113953,
0.41497939825057983,
-0.5627492070198059,
-0.2351769059896469,
-0.3690999448299408,
-0.2587040662765503,
-0.32988041639328003,
-0.11623159050941467,
0.4963282644748688,
-0.2755395472049713,
-0.6771166920661926,
0.4287968575954437,
0.3094528019428253,
0.002752006286755204,
0.10233056545257568,
-0.04027126356959343,
-0.2107100933790207,
0.2227073311805725,
1.0434867143630981,
0.1771973967552185,
-0.399752140045166,
-0.2668224573135376,
0.22888751327991486,
-0.11259492486715317,
0.1491973102092743,
0.7163392305374146,
-0.8614282608032227,
0.43889379501342773,
0.44313544034957886,
0.7638996243476868,
0.7191253304481506,
-0.1910925954580307,
0.34449806809425354,
-0.7136116027832031,
0.13444356620311737,
0.12366019934415817,
0.22316306829452515,
0.0677647814154625,
-0.43480241298675537,
0.1269652247428894,
0.1781800240278244,
-0.3692648410797119,
-0.4064803719520569,
0.22019775211811066,
-1.207367181777954,
-0.5316020846366882,
1.0521597862243652,
0.1538849174976349,
-0.438243567943573,
-0.19604435563087463,
-0.6340557932853699,
0.25121960043907166,
-0.2622087895870209,
0.8154129385948181,
0.6901481747627258,
-0.1998954862356186,
-0.17580784857273102,
-0.45967966318130493,
0.3123094439506531,
0.5557748079299927,
-1.0697021484375,
-0.11529657244682312,
0.5655105710029602,
-0.0035411641001701355,
0.3003336489200592,
0.48308253288269043,
-0.23816357553005219,
0.40555232763290405,
0.06405211985111237,
0.4882066249847412,
-0.0713358223438263,
-0.44234499335289,
-0.32987451553344727,
0.33502790331840515,
-0.19030959904193878,
-0.47725245356559753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06668v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06668v1
|
Exposing and Explaining Fake News On-the-Fly
| 2024-05-03T14:49:04 | 2024-05-03T14:49:04 |
Francisco de Arriba-Pérez, Silvia García-Méndez, Fátima Leal, Benedita Malheiro, Juan Carlos Burguillo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI
|
Social media platforms enable the rapid dissemination and consumption of
information. However, users instantly consume such content regardless of the
reliability of the shared data. Consequently, the latter crowdsourcing model is
exposed to manipulation. This work contributes with an explainable and online
classification method to recognize fake news in real-time. The proposed method
combines both unsupervised and supervised Machine Learning approaches with
online created lexica. The profiling is built using creator-, content- and
context-based features using Natural Language Processing techniques. The
explainable classification mechanism displays in a dashboard the features
selected for classification and the prediction confidence. The performance of
the proposed solution has been validated with real data sets from Twitter and
the results attain 80 % accuracy and macro F-measure. This proposal is the
first to jointly provide data stream processing, profiling, classification and
explainability. Ultimately, the proposed early detection, isolation and
explanation of fake news contribute to increase the quality and trustworthiness
of social media contents.
|
[
-0.2708989083766937,
-1.1739782094955444,
0.43508613109588623,
0.4889099597930908,
-0.46342647075653076,
0.5655848383903503,
0.08978372067213058,
-0.8056479692459106,
0.5307202935218811,
0.24887977540493011,
-0.608618438243866,
-0.1570175439119339,
-0.6725391149520874,
-0.1833803951740265,
-0.8370212912559509,
0.7281944155693054,
-0.29005569219589233,
-0.04337705671787262,
0.10618163645267487,
-0.13307712972164154,
-0.10150683671236038,
-0.4299231767654419,
-0.6981735825538635,
0.32842230796813965,
0.500784695148468,
0.29831671714782715,
0.5519884824752808,
0.7479307651519775,
0.11335602402687073,
0.26063647866249084,
0.2114320993423462,
0.5008121132850647,
-0.36668500304222107,
-0.4364580810070038,
-0.20391534268856049,
-0.26704156398773193,
-0.07049838453531265,
0.15349800884723663,
0.20482175052165985,
0.2791678309440613,
-0.07797826081514359,
0.3603980839252472,
0.08540290594100952,
0.2262052744626999,
-0.46005532145500183,
0.01808227226138115,
-0.7491486668586731,
-0.006146094296127558,
-0.08186931163072586,
-0.433706134557724,
-0.2663637697696686,
-0.48174288868904114,
-0.17758671939373016,
-0.8144445419311523,
0.5309249758720398,
0.001296140137128532,
1.1211081743240356,
0.07932307571172714,
-0.3130180537700653,
-0.48459330201148987,
-0.8569848537445068,
0.307224839925766,
-0.27895793318748474,
0.22988498210906982,
0.16551101207733154,
0.8782545924186707,
0.029853178188204765,
-0.7281739711761475,
-0.9976682066917419,
0.2762600779533386,
-0.06386101990938187,
-0.03924998641014099,
-0.11593640595674515,
-0.4452337622642517,
-0.15088975429534912,
0.26757583022117615,
-0.6285401582717896,
0.06569119542837143,
-0.36211323738098145,
-0.5999702215194702,
0.501133143901825,
-0.35428622364997864,
0.32659709453582764,
-0.37564367055892944,
-0.41255053877830505,
0.27646711468696594,
-0.07193063944578171,
-0.10707756876945496,
0.31846269965171814,
0.30252978205680847,
-0.21008475124835968,
0.31497666239738464,
-0.3549482524394989,
0.3389083445072174,
0.27309510111808777,
-0.03755830228328705,
0.145974799990654,
-0.28986987471580505,
-0.27314311265945435,
0.3165222406387329,
0.5672717690467834,
0.2797335386276245,
0.17187026143074036,
-0.06225909665226936,
0.06580248475074768,
0.35929808020591736,
0.47402188181877136,
-0.554951548576355,
0.15056197345256805,
0.14343154430389404,
-0.6764557361602783,
-0.7186233401298523,
0.504696786403656,
-0.6952371597290039,
-0.36812451481819153,
-0.2976176142692566,
0.6807250380516052,
-0.20688340067863464,
-0.44026362895965576,
-0.052088309079408646,
-0.028474610298871994,
-0.05447685346007347,
0.49542614817619324,
-0.16644436120986938,
0.15114928781986237,
0.718833327293396,
1.088542103767395,
0.03627042844891548,
0.2175905704498291,
-0.681371808052063,
0.1580551564693451,
-0.3086768090724945,
0.8537331223487854,
-0.12442172318696976,
0.3901710510253906,
0.15933409333229065,
0.32099980115890503,
0.16977931559085846,
-0.2288738489151001,
0.4884839355945587,
-0.8774136304855347,
0.3983783721923828,
-0.047011543065309525,
-0.5402947664260864,
-0.3654317557811737,
0.17779481410980225,
-0.7377958297729492,
0.7050060033798218,
0.1985878348350525,
-0.9566998481750488,
0.6929032802581787,
-0.7653273344039917,
-0.334978312253952,
0.3445289134979248,
0.5215186476707458,
-0.510139524936676,
0.03502609208226204,
0.5547335743904114,
0.7552399039268494,
0.48604896664619446,
0.5039758682250977,
-0.3735710680484772,
-0.35805246233940125,
0.3459576368331909,
-0.49367615580558777,
0.9215643405914307,
0.5886560082435608,
-0.29055193066596985,
0.09921230375766754,
-0.775851845741272,
-0.15872152149677277,
0.3264792561531067,
-0.08742877840995789,
-0.3124226927757263,
-0.050238437950611115,
0.02797844260931015,
0.3315507471561432,
0.08246830850839615,
-0.5628537535667419,
-0.1640792340040207,
-0.17656657099723816,
0.5437440872192383,
0.4964476227760315,
0.32459941506385803,
0.4062561094760895,
-0.23381377756595612,
0.2662946283817291,
0.24912451207637787,
0.4152771234512329,
0.07513967901468277,
-0.23967811465263367,
-0.7567922472953796,
-0.4152129590511322,
0.3730963468551636,
0.5091673135757446,
-1.0142251253128052,
0.3306252360343933,
-0.22550532221794128,
-0.5302799344062805,
-0.7186466455459595,
0.1400722861289978,
0.24250482022762299,
0.403009295463562,
0.4129868149757385,
0.1002918928861618,
-0.6201578974723816,
-0.6920501589775085,
-0.7168600559234619,
0.0713251382112503,
-0.18001531064510345,
-0.18011616170406342,
0.24025699496269226,
-0.20451025664806366,
0.9619587659835815,
-0.09242109954357147,
-0.07752987742424011,
-0.26879915595054626,
0.41673293709754944,
0.05621447041630745,
0.040191613137722015,
0.47298702597618103,
-1.143380880355835,
-0.42317911982536316,
-0.12880682945251465,
-0.6544976830482483,
-0.18529781699180603,
-0.3250882029533386,
-0.10450087487697601,
0.335764616727829,
0.4387385845184326,
-0.3989846110343933,
0.7574442625045776,
0.2689764201641083,
-0.3172394633293152,
0.3329419791698456,
0.05051564425230026,
0.2157934159040451,
-1.0024241209030151,
-0.3653967082500458,
0.14338195323944092,
-0.7854132652282715,
-0.5869096517562866,
-0.22048375010490417,
0.11158716678619385,
-0.04401818662881851,
-0.6176341772079468,
0.5777647495269775,
-0.3263789713382721,
-0.21520310640335083,
-0.39926445484161377,
0.3100188672542572,
0.053276389837265015,
0.005181530024856329,
-0.07393552362918854,
0.015337714925408363,
0.4125220775604248,
-0.8548587560653687,
0.5160901546478271,
-0.16895855963230133,
-0.591544508934021,
0.17839686572551727,
-0.40216514468193054,
-0.0987081229686737,
-0.3421117961406708,
0.6615828275680542,
-0.8616790175437927,
-0.667016327381134,
0.6967575550079346,
-0.9860031008720398,
-0.21565376222133636,
-0.03220134973526001,
-0.9394385814666748,
-0.437884122133255,
-0.15190938115119934,
-0.18559257686138153,
0.14276118576526642,
-0.9783936142921448,
0.4853266477584839,
0.21257615089416504,
0.1834729015827179,
-0.11486739665269852,
-0.5730572938919067,
-0.13789783418178558,
-0.3842901885509491,
-0.3767238259315491,
0.5186048150062561,
0.28858470916748047,
-0.509139358997345,
0.33213573694229126,
-0.05073702707886696,
-0.11127567291259766,
0.1216721162199974,
0.4020238220691681,
0.15658032894134521,
0.021668370813131332,
0.26186490058898926,
0.1733916699886322,
0.01701340079307556,
-0.15880578756332397,
0.0952964797616005,
0.46371957659721375,
0.08293307572603226,
0.0004982426762580872,
-1.0528267621994019,
0.11884372681379318,
0.3908081352710724,
0.060595907270908356,
1.2286412715911865,
1.131539225578308,
-0.6204463243484497,
-0.4201667010784149,
-0.4688287079334259,
-0.26455920934677124,
-0.38552191853523254,
-0.0007267699693329632,
0.03817020356655121,
-0.5343537330627441,
0.44620662927627563,
0.07908806949853897,
-0.04924817383289337,
0.5577379465103149,
0.4662860631942749,
0.029362507164478302,
0.9259465336799622,
0.6481941938400269,
-0.003238068427890539,
0.36257368326187134,
0.1309182196855545,
0.4339923858642578,
0.2513154149055481,
-0.30688342452049255,
-0.17115506529808044,
-0.24974560737609863,
-0.3901183307170868,
-0.4845541715621948,
0.0004271617508493364,
0.22809073328971863,
0.10302579402923584,
0.43768173456192017,
-0.5991305112838745,
0.43092745542526245,
0.3204845190048218,
0.1870301514863968,
0.387298047542572,
0.2866974472999573,
0.12370439618825912,
0.19883057475090027,
-0.5136993527412415,
-0.5260565280914307,
0.5659750699996948,
0.6966572999954224,
0.26219621300697327,
-0.02219851315021515,
0.20436570048332214,
0.8151963353157043,
0.6017115116119385,
-0.47159263491630554,
0.2982434630393982,
0.10185090452432632,
-0.771752655506134,
-0.185603067278862,
-0.5537437200546265,
-0.44325536489486694,
0.12029924988746643,
-0.3183731138706207,
-0.400701105594635,
-0.11967911571264267,
0.10840918123722076,
-0.3801265358924866,
0.3860202431678772,
-0.8063066005706787,
0.4858340919017792,
-0.43106406927108765,
-0.13656747341156006,
-0.5467352271080017,
-0.5956728458404541,
0.5128981471061707,
-0.27417394518852234,
0.8781077265739441,
-0.1564561426639557,
0.024037376046180725,
0.7394357323646545,
-0.5072218775749207,
0.8754147887229919,
-0.34244340658187866,
0.1432630717754364,
0.3484501838684082,
0.12216980755329132,
0.245589017868042,
0.3288589119911194,
0.25049224495887756,
0.23643708229064941,
-0.194432333111763,
-0.5477949380874634,
-0.57249915599823,
0.7468088269233704,
-0.636859118938446,
0.059295568615198135,
-0.28757381439208984,
-0.18061238527297974,
-0.19163158535957336,
-0.2049051970243454,
0.26462769508361816,
0.2680710554122925,
-0.08570676296949387,
-0.0230421032756567,
0.20624896883964539,
-0.13387688994407654,
0.6153151988983154,
0.6288458704948425,
-0.4002295136451721,
-0.056645717471838,
1.10160231590271,
0.2840469181537628,
-0.15759870409965515,
0.32908686995506287,
0.24719668924808502,
-0.2546306848526001,
-0.1854363977909088,
-0.417784720659256,
0.14741630852222443,
-0.34955400228500366,
0.040027014911174774,
-0.6177643537521362,
-0.42118552327156067,
-0.5400140881538391,
-0.41347387433052063,
-0.20434927940368652,
-0.5745242238044739,
-0.5450988411903381,
-0.2934125065803528,
0.3176942467689514,
0.7223029136657715,
-0.18903261423110962,
0.7058452367782593,
-0.80190110206604,
0.832754909992218,
0.2251964807510376,
0.33055514097213745,
-0.007883589714765549,
-0.6759687662124634,
-0.2602654993534088,
0.29277122020721436,
-0.19864171743392944,
-1.0383681058883667,
0.6552609801292419,
0.1432618945837021,
0.5667709112167358,
0.9168891310691833,
0.22868850827217102,
0.48562079668045044,
0.12334755063056946,
0.5174437761306763,
-0.11424515396356583,
-0.8615676164627075,
0.6651884317398071,
-0.2002539038658142,
-0.2791936695575714,
0.16889534890651703,
0.971960723400116,
-0.2594323754310608,
-0.2529439330101013,
-0.8539915084838867,
-0.5731759667396545,
0.5219874382019043,
0.13986681401729584,
0.03180849924683571,
-0.023656118661165237,
0.32419514656066895,
0.47939372062683105,
0.16087594628334045,
-0.8426432609558105,
0.07607676833868027,
-0.6010200381278992,
-0.05800527334213257,
0.10758799314498901,
-0.19509711861610413,
0.23233377933502197,
-0.35992494225502014,
0.6659755110740662,
0.03401089087128639,
0.1840992271900177,
-0.05757175385951996,
-0.4897386133670807,
-0.10152702778577805,
-0.08521707355976105,
0.4304233193397522,
1.005635380744934,
-0.14958307147026062,
0.18302762508392334,
-0.19855310022830963,
-0.1532077193260193,
-0.29161888360977173,
-0.03793157637119293,
-0.08034578710794449,
0.43832606077194214,
0.5532398819923401,
0.5271283388137817,
0.031423598527908325,
-0.4722442626953125,
0.6825001835823059,
-0.12235783785581589,
-0.4849754571914673,
-0.6000249981880188,
-0.14976932108402252,
-0.003993371967226267,
0.1653822809457779,
0.657248318195343,
0.01158137060701847,
-0.14416730403900146,
-0.8665046095848083,
0.15587908029556274,
0.145501971244812,
-0.4518965482711792,
-0.43410152196884155,
0.5969416499137878,
0.11395058780908585,
-0.2206161469221115,
0.24895451962947845,
-0.3394715189933777,
-0.6701170802116394,
0.47339504957199097,
0.34701311588287354,
0.4653558135032654,
-0.21597297489643097,
0.891303539276123,
0.34284988045692444,
0.041498951613903046,
-0.030694404616951942,
0.02521042339503765,
-0.09791950136423111,
-0.8643559813499451,
-0.4122738242149353,
-0.7972079515457153,
-0.06214858964085579,
0.4358766973018646,
-0.5578392744064331,
0.38864293694496155,
-0.6018201112747192,
0.1454259604215622,
0.4785515367984772,
-0.13145673274993896,
-0.3594157099723816,
0.19522713124752045,
0.1644812822341919,
0.833916425704956,
-1.2040191888809204,
0.4935760498046875,
0.2805813252925873,
-0.1601235568523407,
-0.40885040163993835,
0.34856629371643066,
0.19623354077339172,
-0.8529442548751831,
0.4915940761566162,
0.46805739402770996,
0.21828798949718475,
-0.05818871408700943,
-0.9292812943458557,
-0.24087899923324585,
0.6819953918457031,
0.17070606350898743,
-0.405578076839447,
-0.009239793755114079,
0.10462085902690887,
0.5815109014511108,
-0.40450793504714966,
-0.1798849105834961,
0.04900802671909332,
0.6015769243240356,
0.09450966119766235,
-0.6467788815498352,
-0.014152293093502522,
0.03623596206307411,
-0.41805583238601685,
-0.057865872979164124,
-0.5815908908843994,
0.4105551242828369,
-0.016751525923609734,
-0.5752987265586853,
-0.5467334389686584,
0.8065697550773621,
-0.1282433122396469,
0.8916917443275452,
0.6498101949691772,
0.3420695662498474,
0.6802005171775818,
0.017106659710407257,
0.776121973991394,
-0.013567009009420872,
0.23037970066070557,
0.7016785740852356,
0.14093686640262604,
0.6861029863357544,
0.2684584856033325,
0.03814176470041275,
0.6984593868255615,
0.9047125577926636,
0.04019616171717644,
0.5475667119026184,
0.26895081996917725,
-0.2312726080417633,
-0.2804756462574005,
-0.3294994831085205,
0.03372105211019516,
0.5234658122062683,
0.48726987838745117,
-0.5150730013847351,
-0.3732653260231018,
0.5835903882980347,
0.21784287691116333,
0.23530924320220947,
-0.6729705929756165,
0.6257755160331726,
-0.1459750533103943,
-0.27298668026924133,
0.2420371025800705,
0.1718703955411911,
0.7156745195388794,
-0.2639404535293579,
0.09184715896844864,
0.16077454388141632,
0.2313583791255951,
-0.3785427510738373,
-0.5893959403038025,
0.7428303956985474,
0.004885132424533367,
-0.21053989231586456,
-0.3947712481021881,
0.9845941066741943,
-0.1391308754682541,
-0.5635614395141602,
0.36469218134880066,
0.7083972692489624,
0.1705324798822403,
-0.6759297847747803,
-0.49674516916275024,
-0.11063587665557861,
-0.18433241546154022,
-0.12120241671800613,
0.17950439453125,
0.4863985478878021,
-0.45443958044052124,
0.7584055662155151,
0.8773903846740723,
0.011846981942653656,
0.2005142718553543,
-0.032486043870449066,
0.7812533974647522,
-0.27797454595565796,
-0.7163849472999573,
-0.7686963081359863,
0.0761038064956665,
-0.3992450535297394,
0.0226411372423172,
0.7579519152641296,
0.605915367603302,
0.6323273777961731,
-0.10155059397220612,
0.6927194595336914,
-0.20422028005123138,
1.2165567874908447,
-0.31196150183677673,
0.8753147721290588,
-0.5547066330909729,
-0.03049163706600666,
0.0767744779586792,
-0.6230441331863403,
-0.05601712316274643,
0.344797283411026,
0.04952371492981911,
-0.24798104166984558,
0.5166484117507935,
0.4980510473251343,
-0.27994421124458313,
-0.04454020410776138,
0.07482342422008514,
0.36406394839286804,
0.07953383028507233,
-0.06579632312059402,
0.695568859577179,
-0.050882644951343536,
0.7084090709686279,
-0.4481833577156067,
-0.2709200382232666,
-0.6640645861625671,
-0.8127742409706116,
-0.9206449389457703,
-0.7253272533416748,
-0.4307061731815338,
-0.5385617017745972,
0.15156042575836182,
0.45514851808547974,
0.8663251399993896,
-0.6944275498390198,
0.6046406030654907,
-0.08514756709337234,
0.2204771637916565,
-0.38896092772483826,
-0.45573678612709045,
0.3400435149669647,
0.07675687223672867,
-0.3431066572666168,
0.3412080407142639,
-0.07197493314743042,
-0.02105269767343998,
-0.30891647934913635,
0.1531989574432373,
-0.16994833946228027,
0.34873896837234497,
0.523252546787262,
0.43247753381729126,
-0.6534081101417542,
-0.3946933448314667,
-0.12792184948921204,
0.09146465361118317,
-0.2153465449810028,
0.604149580001831,
-1.0258523225784302,
0.14713254570960999,
0.4953291118144989,
0.4682026505470276,
0.6117329597473145,
0.5646743178367615,
0.09564895182847977,
-0.8294855356216431,
-0.09248548746109009,
-0.14914058148860931,
-0.04655792936682701,
0.3749042749404907,
-0.6194838285446167,
0.26631245017051697,
0.5557677745819092,
-0.13619157671928406,
-0.7069491744041443,
-0.14035704731941223,
-1.1223870515823364,
-0.6110314130783081,
0.9495352506637573,
0.14247635006904602,
-0.443674772977829,
-0.6718809008598328,
0.0022255736403167248,
0.7724058628082275,
-0.2755762040615082,
1.1621726751327515,
0.5818884372711182,
0.07388705015182495,
-0.232446551322937,
-0.8039494752883911,
0.381151020526886,
-0.4621608257293701,
-0.9179369211196899,
-0.23434710502624512,
0.2674117982387543,
0.5089632868766785,
0.16990230977535248,
0.46306684613227844,
-0.1905089169740677,
0.03922295570373535,
-0.17922736704349518,
-0.12732800841331482,
-0.37248462438583374,
-0.4315372109413147,
0.05380477383732796,
0.4397108554840088,
-0.8956683278083801,
-0.4527965784072876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02144v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02144v1
|
MedReadMe: A Systematic Study for Fine-grained Sentence Readability in Medical Domain
| 2024-05-03T14:48:20 | 2024-05-03T14:48:20 |
Chao Jiang, Wei Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Medical texts are notoriously challenging to read. Properly measuring their
readability is the first step towards making them more accessible. In this
paper, we present a systematic study on fine-grained readability measurements
in the medical domain at both sentence-level and span-level. We introduce a new
dataset MedReadMe, which consists of manually annotated readability ratings and
fine-grained complex span annotation for 4,520 sentences, featuring two novel
"Google-Easy" and "Google-Hard" categories. It supports our quantitative
analysis, which covers 650 linguistic features and automatic complex word and
jargon identification. Enabled by our high-quality annotation, we benchmark and
improve several state-of-the-art sentence-level readability metrics for the
medical domain specifically, which include unsupervised, supervised, and
prompting-based methods using recently developed large language models (LLMs).
Informed by our fine-grained complex span annotation, we find that adding a
single feature, capturing the number of jargon spans, into existing readability
formulas can significantly improve their correlation with human judgments. We
will publicly release the dataset and code.
|
[
-0.4747137427330017,
-0.7871178388595581,
0.6000944972038269,
0.11243913322687149,
-0.2789100706577301,
-0.12392277270555496,
-0.23421749472618103,
-1.0462135076522827,
0.185930997133255,
0.394943505525589,
-0.5158219933509827,
-0.6035290360450745,
-0.7489878535270691,
0.4633871018886566,
-0.20118090510368347,
1.0478090047836304,
-0.35032299160957336,
0.0981525182723999,
-0.2628147602081299,
-0.1596403867006302,
-0.3351317048072815,
-0.33784219622612,
-0.2884627878665924,
-0.2424582690000534,
0.5894098877906799,
0.2716359496116638,
0.7259621024131775,
0.7827044129371643,
0.9546242356300354,
0.12772777676582336,
-0.37091103196144104,
0.3701939284801483,
-0.2510271370410919,
0.0384286493062973,
-0.13847948610782623,
-0.35156404972076416,
-0.8173854947090149,
0.03559374809265137,
0.24702191352844238,
0.9402366280555725,
-0.1836826652288437,
0.04632410407066345,
0.16662178933620453,
0.7089431881904602,
-0.4708470404148102,
0.17485541105270386,
-0.030103322118520737,
0.16853509843349457,
-0.5460757613182068,
-0.007568889297544956,
-0.4297010898590088,
-0.43650805950164795,
0.34019899368286133,
-0.8985381722450256,
0.11372304707765579,
0.31656011939048767,
0.6628438830375671,
0.1299160122871399,
-0.2885974943637848,
-0.48905184864997864,
-0.40131625533103943,
0.48707735538482666,
-0.8158575296401978,
0.23880484700202942,
0.5562232732772827,
0.3775608539581299,
-0.03262735530734062,
-0.7745692133903503,
-0.3833325207233429,
-0.3062351942062378,
-0.2064850926399231,
-0.04040339216589928,
-0.24665768444538116,
0.16401632130146027,
0.11986002326011658,
0.7321792840957642,
-0.5092723369598389,
0.03927304595708847,
-0.27369576692581177,
-0.2234167903661728,
0.42878228425979614,
0.34909331798553467,
0.5279883146286011,
-0.24416063725948334,
-0.39286527037620544,
0.2667684555053711,
-0.3643077611923218,
-0.06466997414827347,
-0.15391826629638672,
0.0724918469786644,
-0.2781647741794586,
0.901903510093689,
-0.3340035378932953,
0.5750715136528015,
-0.19459222257137299,
-0.19552917778491974,
0.33359211683273315,
-0.557539701461792,
-0.3627281188964844,
-0.21264997124671936,
0.45332393050193787,
0.572754442691803,
0.6666272282600403,
-0.3103730380535126,
-0.13305310904979706,
0.15588060021400452,
0.34742361307144165,
-0.8854222893714905,
-0.5094344019889832,
0.3044302761554718,
-0.713721752166748,
-0.39640915393829346,
-0.12602636218070984,
-0.6061455011367798,
-0.7127905488014221,
-0.26136401295661926,
0.19881950318813324,
-0.6480699777603149,
0.19599315524101257,
0.6150455474853516,
0.07557142525911331,
-0.17510120570659637,
0.4569481909275055,
-0.8752685189247131,
0.5731433629989624,
0.7360460162162781,
0.8478397727012634,
-0.46900519728660583,
-0.07011232525110245,
-0.4198158383369446,
-0.1704782098531723,
-0.03980949521064758,
0.9585082530975342,
-0.2863626778125763,
-0.18787416815757751,
-0.10293854773044586,
0.04962770640850067,
-0.3973272144794464,
-0.735958456993103,
0.9222846031188965,
-0.14050422608852386,
0.09306634217500687,
0.18544761836528778,
-0.8740629553794861,
-0.14310520887374878,
0.32340434193611145,
-0.46837520599365234,
0.42776796221733093,
0.22016142308712006,
-0.876270592212677,
0.6035752892494202,
-0.5911169648170471,
-0.5338676571846008,
-0.008384526707231998,
0.08203473687171936,
-0.31219929456710815,
0.29056844115257263,
0.4323789179325104,
0.6522628664970398,
-0.23540736734867096,
0.10793667286634445,
-0.19175273180007935,
-0.03798976168036461,
0.12298571318387985,
-0.5735089778900146,
0.2452787309885025,
0.20696395635604858,
-0.021356331184506416,
0.05347111076116562,
-0.8389524221420288,
0.16729736328125,
-0.21619877219200134,
-0.4057101905345917,
-0.5381298065185547,
0.0606776624917984,
0.5302320122718811,
0.14996016025543213,
0.05721934512257576,
-0.5657615661621094,
0.36019381880760193,
-0.7166361808776855,
0.28583618998527527,
0.3239690363407135,
0.03649120032787323,
0.41853073239326477,
-0.3689318895339966,
0.6125769019126892,
0.059075191617012024,
0.40362751483917236,
-0.19882145524024963,
-0.29544055461883545,
-0.11415236443281174,
-0.9430398941040039,
0.3158107399940491,
0.5640866756439209,
-0.3866746127605438,
0.2953454554080963,
0.16133566200733185,
-0.4549260437488556,
-0.7839856147766113,
-0.07080910354852676,
0.7761986255645752,
0.5396074056625366,
0.4806278645992279,
-0.23488616943359375,
0.052952058613300323,
-0.8757385611534119,
-0.5456088185310364,
0.03978659585118294,
-0.11165235936641693,
0.6893425583839417,
0.42422327399253845,
-0.8055992126464844,
0.4444766342639923,
-0.9262204766273499,
-0.2722106873989105,
-0.07660221308469772,
-0.026364967226982117,
0.10823749005794525,
0.2570873200893402,
0.3483792841434479,
-0.3396947681903839,
-0.07641719281673431,
0.20390044152736664,
-0.6239231824874878,
-0.5487908124923706,
0.16987769305706024,
-0.08051757514476776,
-0.054248448461294174,
0.5104449987411499,
-0.29631179571151733,
0.24269802868366241,
0.6390537619590759,
-0.8814775347709656,
0.5674429535865784,
-0.25428834557533264,
0.3047795295715332,
-1.0746350288391113,
0.15351548790931702,
0.3494551479816437,
-0.3827700614929199,
-0.5252010822296143,
0.15125465393066406,
0.13529832661151886,
0.33470579981803894,
-0.3568874001502991,
0.7212129235267639,
-0.2866400480270386,
0.23192955553531647,
-0.021418286487460136,
0.19875653088092804,
0.12613940238952637,
-0.0794624462723732,
-0.39238181710243225,
0.6954589486122131,
0.26661399006843567,
-0.3730095326900482,
-0.05754341930150986,
0.5396902561187744,
-0.6046491265296936,
0.8486425876617432,
-0.7376037240028381,
-0.5506299138069153,
-0.13916617631912231,
0.24312692880630493,
-0.858273446559906,
-0.547156810760498,
0.2574308216571808,
-0.031054791063070297,
0.2535786032676697,
0.2924816906452179,
-0.3809249699115753,
-0.10700640082359314,
-0.11327867209911346,
0.5544208288192749,
0.028517121449112892,
-0.41094672679901123,
0.16123414039611816,
0.48313990235328674,
-0.4498986005783081,
-0.19162127375602722,
-0.46406397223472595,
-0.026479259133338928,
0.11006280779838562,
-0.7560814619064331,
0.07362205535173416,
-0.04899337515234947,
-0.282894492149353,
-0.40178191661834717,
-0.31565597653388977,
-0.39863321185112,
-0.014546316117048264,
0.3694133758544922,
0.33331799507141113,
-0.15885554254055023,
0.15425968170166016,
0.1469571888446808,
-0.23957820236682892,
0.0746174082159996,
0.09126728773117065,
0.47743168473243713,
-0.08952011913061142,
-0.024359289556741714,
-0.4593144357204437,
0.18032056093215942,
0.5876721143722534,
-0.15052910149097443,
0.18674837052822113,
0.34595832228660583,
-0.5632427334785461,
-0.05218176171183586,
-0.1376616209745407,
-0.11704015731811523,
-0.3680705726146698,
0.39357560873031616,
-0.3402447998523712,
-0.9609788060188293,
0.264117032289505,
-0.36761242151260376,
0.19289718568325043,
0.6072561144828796,
0.37802937626838684,
-0.3753494918346405,
0.8751147985458374,
0.4603446424007416,
0.03959888592362404,
-0.05155402421951294,
0.05968101695179939,
-0.14166486263275146,
-0.6801565289497375,
-0.389040470123291,
-0.4298684895038605,
-0.3687133193016052,
-0.2923510670661926,
-0.5811398029327393,
0.2219845950603485,
0.30117732286453247,
0.02241571806371212,
-0.017179837450385094,
-0.4420497417449951,
0.39695656299591064,
-0.004835003055632114,
0.23083160817623138,
0.6782633066177368,
-0.1450381726026535,
-0.5104557871818542,
-0.30211466550827026,
-0.24195586144924164,
-0.7165088653564453,
0.702402651309967,
0.5846737623214722,
1.0483765602111816,
0.01812996156513691,
0.4587347209453583,
0.3964986205101013,
0.244842067360878,
-1.1011462211608887,
0.2719775140285492,
-0.5819417238235474,
-0.5300948619842529,
0.022544454783201218,
-0.5565502643585205,
-0.8797009587287903,
0.1091684028506279,
-0.37143972516059875,
-0.4849749207496643,
0.10260998457670212,
0.14763125777244568,
-0.35493016242980957,
0.11414839327335358,
-0.832783043384552,
0.9242870211601257,
0.12513959407806396,
0.344499796628952,
0.12765905261039734,
-0.7742016315460205,
0.2646470367908478,
-0.1430034041404724,
0.2553689777851105,
-0.1978023201227188,
-0.21057437360286713,
0.5079203248023987,
-0.5513356924057007,
0.7432021498680115,
0.27510857582092285,
-0.2576602101325989,
-0.3176726996898651,
0.18683695793151855,
0.19456538558006287,
0.19922754168510437,
0.2683533728122711,
0.15686361491680145,
0.36164960265159607,
-0.4111384153366089,
-0.18558692932128906,
0.42675644159317017,
-0.367801696062088,
0.013476558960974216,
-0.6245988011360168,
-0.6649543642997742,
-0.458780974149704,
0.37649476528167725,
0.2956358790397644,
0.607811689376831,
-0.5878216028213501,
-0.13546320796012878,
0.682020902633667,
-0.171023890376091,
0.15328428149223328,
0.4076189398765564,
-0.2253263294696808,
-0.39120185375213623,
0.353206068277359,
-0.1429266780614853,
0.3195900619029999,
0.184573233127594,
0.12059510499238968,
-0.1751279979944229,
-0.4723048806190491,
-0.44987940788269043,
0.2658637762069702,
-0.09716796875,
0.023596609011292458,
-0.6346741318702698,
-0.22945807874202728,
0.28502416610717773,
-0.3584164083003998,
-0.019537927582859993,
-0.4127408266067505,
-0.40163499116897583,
0.02124072052538395,
0.4353633522987366,
0.918520450592041,
0.3733038902282715,
0.3586438298225403,
-0.7957785725593567,
0.47893762588500977,
-0.25015130639076233,
0.7138238549232483,
-0.4641421437263489,
-0.4779408276081085,
-0.16682246327400208,
-0.307832807302475,
-0.01741163060069084,
-0.36307278275489807,
0.18534891307353973,
0.09263456612825394,
-0.08626122027635574,
0.5323423147201538,
-0.10738015919923782,
0.5461669564247131,
-0.9557523727416992,
0.5834536552429199,
0.20004378259181976,
-0.8121795058250427,
0.47334644198417664,
-0.2755257189273834,
0.35849443078041077,
0.775445282459259,
0.09736155718564987,
-0.6396554708480835,
-0.46364080905914307,
-0.3241974711418152,
-0.777158260345459,
0.32797732949256897,
0.1256360411643982,
-0.10903697460889816,
-0.14085720479488373,
0.5783084630966187,
0.37725701928138733,
0.03234925493597984,
0.04836294427514076,
-0.26033785939216614,
0.5344621539115906,
-0.5616665482521057,
-0.37474140524864197,
-0.3575776219367981,
-0.07757868617773056,
-0.17281518876552582,
0.24435347318649292,
-0.020776771008968353,
-0.14738106727600098,
0.3326117992401123,
-0.049327027052640915,
-0.016445593908429146,
0.4867285490036011,
0.5885382890701294,
0.6512195467948914,
-0.3232194781303406,
0.15196286141872406,
-0.14479871094226837,
-1.423181176185608,
0.015173908323049545,
0.44809454679489136,
-0.12187527120113373,
0.16503992676734924,
0.5607529282569885,
0.3392520844936371,
0.19112618267536163,
-0.8787871599197388,
0.6452539563179016,
-0.12982769310474396,
-0.2834591269493103,
0.07085036486387253,
0.00893604476004839,
-0.1101568415760994,
0.4500754177570343,
-0.05542688071727753,
0.4630037546157837,
0.4627828299999237,
-0.22628580033779144,
0.5866668224334717,
-0.0016251843189820647,
-0.5929720401763916,
-0.1631363481283188,
0.9104176163673401,
0.3260387182235718,
0.12451940774917603,
0.08017460256814957,
0.15077200531959534,
0.1826939433813095,
0.3909662961959839,
0.45641660690307617,
0.5428458452224731,
0.00996231846511364,
0.31144195795059204,
-0.01234931405633688,
0.33958700299263,
-0.4181533753871918,
0.5022803544998169,
0.5654957890510559,
-0.37291693687438965,
-0.46882155537605286,
-0.5957056879997253,
-0.3314272165298462,
-0.2544526755809784,
-0.7926771640777588,
-0.12332987040281296,
-0.23820282518863678,
-0.24679061770439148,
0.6270983815193176,
0.23759199678897858,
-0.46755197644233704,
0.5725176334381104,
-0.20316492021083832,
1.167611002922058,
-0.6307632327079773,
0.4205404222011566,
0.613707959651947,
-0.2441105991601944,
-0.5456036329269409,
0.18251468241214752,
0.1122155711054802,
-0.7839093804359436,
0.080987349152565,
0.13632315397262573,
0.15521028637886047,
-0.10026456415653229,
-0.2633805274963379,
-0.1345202624797821,
1.1158697605133057,
0.1905250996351242,
-0.9679886698722839,
-0.2271396964788437,
-0.15640638768672943,
0.5857812166213989,
-0.3186810314655304,
0.016042690724134445,
0.8750565052032471,
0.25868815183639526,
-0.31502634286880493,
-1.1358078718185425,
0.0746927261352539,
-0.22800302505493164,
-0.2133074849843979,
0.5310097932815552,
-0.16540148854255676,
0.5584157109260559,
-0.2728779911994934,
0.08145201951265335,
0.10165143758058548,
0.24674805998802185,
0.16364558041095734,
0.7503545880317688,
0.4483352601528168,
0.7112205624580383,
1.0623241662979126,
-0.12146063894033432,
1.2476518154144287,
-0.014546483755111694,
0.4085732102394104,
0.9210836291313171,
-0.07741796225309372,
1.0150635242462158,
0.3333882689476013,
-0.11955160647630692,
0.13185130059719086,
0.4257495403289795,
0.182832270860672,
0.3910265564918518,
0.38989654183387756,
-0.5067713260650635,
-0.042031675577163696,
-0.1160435825586319,
-0.17658065259456635,
0.1827031373977661,
0.2565251588821411,
-0.7446562051773071,
-0.2555595934391022,
0.4094697833061218,
0.5040889978408813,
0.2081202268600464,
-0.5174975991249084,
0.8054296374320984,
0.40229538083076477,
-0.10372602194547653,
0.5253883600234985,
-0.08451364189386368,
0.6951994299888611,
-0.28802555799484253,
0.13130566477775574,
-0.22197657823562622,
0.40076494216918945,
-0.47188040614128113,
-1.119409203529358,
0.2374216467142105,
0.3884299695491791,
-0.6543138027191162,
0.3264181315898895,
0.5586960315704346,
-0.30740976333618164,
-0.4769604802131653,
0.1504734605550766,
0.8145743608474731,
0.3888840079307556,
0.0299092847853899,
-0.33061927556991577,
-0.13543693721294403,
-0.1411883383989334,
-0.24241796135902405,
0.13950097560882568,
0.6184921264648438,
-0.06677883863449097,
0.5943270921707153,
0.33810392022132874,
0.3564835488796234,
-0.0672958642244339,
0.38002675771713257,
0.7508395910263062,
-0.680361807346344,
-0.1830047369003296,
-0.7621351480484009,
0.31684616208076477,
0.015768522396683693,
-0.8290792107582092,
0.4254010319709778,
0.6213201284408569,
0.5415734052658081,
-0.10536253452301025,
0.6216378808021545,
0.10982740670442581,
0.6996315717697144,
-0.38679039478302,
0.921475887298584,
-0.5179497003555298,
0.03631129115819931,
-0.3184592127799988,
-0.5663448572158813,
-0.7451515197753906,
0.4781324863433838,
-0.03998011350631714,
-0.09090493619441986,
0.735858142375946,
0.5491257905960083,
-0.29570457339286804,
-0.004034358076751232,
0.37461888790130615,
0.5315679311752319,
-0.0013719993876293302,
0.5605720281600952,
0.20435693860054016,
-0.22996830940246582,
0.2927062511444092,
0.20388421416282654,
-0.4716748297214508,
-0.4615733325481415,
-0.537610650062561,
-0.8619396090507507,
-0.2091992199420929,
-0.29736801981925964,
-0.6486488580703735,
0.21754427254199982,
0.8474279046058655,
0.36205387115478516,
-0.745975911617279,
0.3387739360332489,
0.034252915531396866,
-0.45417964458465576,
-0.34555941820144653,
-0.17287082970142365,
0.45415323972702026,
-0.3238706588745117,
-0.5825857520103455,
0.0485813207924366,
0.5184644460678101,
-0.061047233641147614,
0.013238685205578804,
0.18239086866378784,
-0.0633348748087883,
0.34524792432785034,
0.8981494903564453,
0.1890568882226944,
-0.5392020344734192,
-0.14118646085262299,
0.13183878362178802,
-0.8714358806610107,
0.05188523232936859,
0.5961692333221436,
-0.34643295407295227,
0.6693008542060852,
0.40702560544013977,
0.7271156311035156,
0.18240061402320862,
0.2021486610174179,
0.2892066240310669,
-0.49566391110420227,
-0.33447960019111633,
0.31722986698150635,
0.334476500749588,
-0.056103046983480453,
-0.26614922285079956,
0.6887642741203308,
0.017175059765577316,
-0.7344232201576233,
-0.4942217469215393,
0.13166208565235138,
-1.3907634019851685,
-0.2780535817146301,
1.1067488193511963,
-0.11010272800922394,
-0.20288053154945374,
-0.36922013759613037,
-0.8533254861831665,
0.029681352898478508,
-0.2117358148097992,
0.7356864213943481,
0.7774066925048828,
-0.19013889133930206,
0.09427791088819504,
-1.0366038084030151,
0.7601950168609619,
0.2935549020767212,
-1.226049542427063,
0.0833619087934494,
0.7477967739105225,
0.43621107935905457,
-0.22473254799842834,
0.7279185056686401,
-0.32219362258911133,
0.30837005376815796,
-0.37265849113464355,
0.11204148828983307,
0.1364051103591919,
-0.25351396203041077,
-0.48389098048210144,
-0.024799546226859093,
-0.14592193067073822,
-0.134797140955925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02134v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02134v1
|
Optimising Calls to Large Language Models with Uncertainty-Based Two-Tier Selection
| 2024-05-03T14:38:59 | 2024-05-03T14:38:59 |
Guillem Ramírez, Alexandra Birch, Ivan Titov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Researchers and practitioners operating on a limited budget face the
cost-performance trade-off dilemma. The challenging decision often centers on
whether to use a large LLM with better performance or a smaller one with
reduced costs. This has motivated recent research in the optimisation of LLM
calls. Either a cascading strategy is used, where a smaller LLM or both are
called sequentially, or a routing strategy is used, where only one model is
ever called. Both scenarios are dependent on a decision criterion which is
typically implemented by an extra neural model. In this work, we propose a
simpler solution; we use only the uncertainty of the generations of the small
LLM as the decision criterion. We compare our approach with both cascading and
routing strategies using three different pairs of pre-trained small and large
LLMs, on nine different tasks and against approaches that require an additional
neural model. Our experiments reveal this simple solution optimally balances
cost and performance, outperforming existing methods on 25 out of 27
experimental setups.
|
[
-0.2927438020706177,
-0.5502684712409973,
0.6010361909866333,
0.2747546434402466,
-0.31963616609573364,
0.14940814673900604,
-0.4222710430622101,
-0.5552006959915161,
-0.019507676362991333,
0.4521580636501312,
-0.6957949995994568,
0.008434675633907318,
-0.43900611996650696,
-0.19080698490142822,
-0.10925036668777466,
0.3970046043395996,
0.230073943734169,
0.4371342062950134,
-0.1799599528312683,
-0.12312336266040802,
-0.16885153949260712,
-0.26778024435043335,
-1.5361603498458862,
-0.7880766987800598,
0.7379464507102966,
0.3573196828365326,
0.9280216693878174,
0.5088433027267456,
0.3318626582622528,
0.17313773930072784,
-0.4547164738178253,
0.19279010593891144,
-0.005275442264974117,
0.04498972371220589,
-0.07058844715356827,
-0.8926968574523926,
-0.2395114004611969,
-0.24616862833499908,
0.44045552611351013,
0.9104502201080322,
-0.21329866349697113,
0.16264338791370392,
0.0010061954380944371,
0.6329312920570374,
-0.6915744543075562,
0.060301560908555984,
-0.6053875684738159,
0.270353227853775,
-0.2752441167831421,
-0.07341455668210983,
-0.5454455614089966,
-0.4048364460468292,
0.5657983422279358,
-0.19214709103107452,
-0.32133984565734863,
0.150044783949852,
0.5049716234207153,
0.2618965208530426,
-0.1759549379348755,
-0.42548513412475586,
-0.7494503259658813,
0.9626864790916443,
-0.7863933444023132,
0.3297390639781952,
0.36456623673439026,
0.16651877760887146,
-0.002244716975837946,
-0.6131486296653748,
-0.23701955378055573,
-0.36748796701431274,
0.2325177639722824,
0.13966141641139984,
-0.2528522312641144,
0.06636659801006317,
-0.028782842680811882,
-0.13164453208446503,
-0.35512158274650574,
0.8564858436584473,
-0.33911287784576416,
-0.19037261605262756,
0.39618980884552,
-0.146659716963768,
0.05369081348180771,
0.06405901908874512,
-0.4113752245903015,
-0.020136097446084023,
-0.8312771320343018,
0.15520529448986053,
0.7111260294914246,
0.46888190507888794,
0.01663927733898163,
0.461804062128067,
-0.06613659858703613,
0.5683483481407166,
0.11613281071186066,
-0.24334748089313507,
-0.04888252541422844,
0.14168474078178406,
-0.03293943405151367,
0.12479907274246216,
0.6307752132415771,
-0.009153980761766434,
0.18494068086147308,
-0.15105976164340973,
-0.28284990787506104,
-0.25949177145957947,
0.19768095016479492,
-0.5950374603271484,
-0.12711094319820404,
0.18734943866729736,
-0.40071314573287964,
-0.40960967540740967,
-0.6381614804267883,
-0.8388224840164185,
-0.036625783890485764,
-0.2483958750963211,
0.6041660308837891,
-0.1960866004228592,
-0.15691468119621277,
-0.034715548157691956,
0.3663455545902252,
0.11588640511035919,
0.4267865717411041,
-0.9261142015457153,
0.5211589932441711,
0.46771058440208435,
0.9088009595870972,
-0.1608586460351944,
-0.24352701008319855,
-0.5487442016601562,
-0.0951457992196083,
-0.6470780968666077,
0.604387104511261,
-0.3740415573120117,
-0.4678320586681366,
-0.03305980563163757,
-0.6418511867523193,
0.02140132337808609,
-0.43348121643066406,
0.696241021156311,
-0.9045922160148621,
0.31453973054885864,
-0.26282596588134766,
-0.08724797517061234,
-0.0990365594625473,
-0.19624119997024536,
-0.8482317924499512,
1.1535048484802246,
0.09758704900741577,
-0.6737121939659119,
0.5039517283439636,
-0.19886893033981323,
-0.645129382610321,
0.10524335503578186,
-0.1513843685388565,
-0.5000653266906738,
0.28870317339897156,
0.024617232382297516,
0.14473791420459747,
-0.7087125182151794,
0.077030248939991,
-0.3510148227214813,
-0.3052547872066498,
-0.01494978554546833,
-0.7226188778877258,
0.8098301887512207,
0.36611273884773254,
-0.4803638458251953,
-0.14515383541584015,
-0.5155846476554871,
0.3964684307575226,
-0.20914410054683685,
-0.7685494422912598,
-0.26757556200027466,
0.30719369649887085,
-0.2012448012828827,
0.441327303647995,
0.10760889947414398,
0.015561530366539955,
-0.0017139744013547897,
-0.5717825293540955,
0.6292417645454407,
0.7480475902557373,
-0.5308636426925659,
0.6822485327720642,
-0.3813976049423218,
0.5914932489395142,
0.04556111991405487,
0.3677397072315216,
0.510269045829773,
-0.35872024297714233,
-1.3164851665496826,
-0.08533147722482681,
0.6588013172149658,
0.435098797082901,
-0.8617665767669678,
0.24498151242733002,
-0.2378367930650711,
-0.20600570738315582,
-0.6484341621398926,
0.19586101174354553,
0.3289515972137451,
0.12030351907014847,
0.36941713094711304,
-0.37360522150993347,
-0.5488312244415283,
-1.040097951889038,
0.07109874486923218,
-0.5596138834953308,
0.3537513315677643,
0.3333519697189331,
0.20779016613960266,
-0.0034437552094459534,
0.9454383850097656,
-0.35149720311164856,
0.00127583765424788,
-0.3472961485385895,
0.21077996492385864,
0.16414429247379303,
0.28694525361061096,
0.3837526738643646,
-0.6565998792648315,
-0.39934587478637695,
-0.03185858204960823,
-0.147391214966774,
-0.1683991700410843,
-0.3863726854324341,
-0.12693187594413757,
0.4226483702659607,
0.31417104601860046,
-0.834148645401001,
0.09779813140630722,
0.6419541239738464,
0.397336483001709,
0.38632088899612427,
-0.29253119230270386,
-0.35572871565818787,
-0.8946675062179565,
-0.16351796686649323,
-0.14945833384990692,
-0.1149258241057396,
-0.5190855264663696,
0.020264076068997383,
0.018139729276299477,
0.13802045583724976,
-0.6021066904067993,
0.5407668352127075,
-0.7008189558982849,
-0.266838014125824,
-0.20144367218017578,
-0.04930262640118599,
-0.2670939564704895,
0.4685298502445221,
0.07002308964729309,
0.8666959404945374,
0.6883474588394165,
-0.4863302707672119,
0.157823845744133,
-0.12019683420658112,
-0.5873861312866211,
0.29596662521362305,
-0.6033751964569092,
0.23187583684921265,
0.09751562774181366,
0.1917499452829361,
-0.8752573132514954,
0.07616275548934937,
0.10484912246465683,
-0.19769158959388733,
0.5235509872436523,
-0.23313872516155243,
-0.47501295804977417,
-0.7070631980895996,
-0.28708237409591675,
0.4000542163848877,
0.6085595488548279,
-0.5501740574836731,
0.6001927256584167,
0.11004696041345596,
-0.4984210431575775,
-0.7011206150054932,
-1.0325193405151367,
0.14501768350601196,
-0.2902979850769043,
-0.6076244115829468,
0.16472762823104858,
-0.01633651740849018,
-0.17286436259746552,
-0.19379596412181854,
-0.4538724720478058,
-0.020928330719470978,
0.1396680772304535,
0.06583668291568756,
0.1491205096244812,
-0.34602293372154236,
0.08549026399850845,
0.19341051578521729,
-0.25445103645324707,
0.000011108782928204164,
-0.6990023255348206,
0.7428941130638123,
0.15443073213100433,
-0.49688053131103516,
-0.25105053186416626,
0.5347215533256531,
0.5723922848701477,
-0.014502149075269699,
0.722009539604187,
0.40328842401504517,
-0.1640312224626541,
-0.7203842997550964,
-0.8149007558822632,
-0.008138547651469707,
-0.47576501965522766,
0.26069751381874084,
-0.5052028894424438,
-0.7950518131256104,
0.5483224391937256,
-0.2618226110935211,
-0.2899603545665741,
0.32800060510635376,
0.5971078872680664,
-0.02454674243927002,
0.8209132552146912,
0.4302729070186615,
-0.21652290225028992,
0.23733124136924744,
-0.10554609447717667,
0.42517316341400146,
-0.6028003692626953,
-0.11999072134494781,
-0.5242219567298889,
-0.24801109731197357,
-0.5901626944541931,
-0.7203266024589539,
0.3788841664791107,
0.3025316894054413,
-0.2781350910663605,
0.18362674117088318,
-0.13792523741722107,
0.4456495940685272,
0.9535204768180847,
0.28977182507514954,
0.2762186825275421,
0.01865931786596775,
-0.26566022634506226,
0.2774020731449127,
-1.0522680282592773,
-0.41164442896842957,
0.9914003014564514,
0.2974035441875458,
0.8524907827377319,
0.3446386456489563,
0.5140676498413086,
0.05080563202500343,
0.04743508994579315,
-0.8840509653091431,
0.5043038129806519,
-0.09662692993879318,
-0.5300447344779968,
-0.447041392326355,
-0.6814282536506653,
-0.8403140902519226,
0.5216264128684998,
-0.18959808349609375,
-0.7782977223396301,
0.15616954863071442,
-0.017581894993782043,
-0.8588328957557678,
0.36260613799095154,
-0.504447877407074,
0.21909920871257782,
-0.5645979642868042,
-0.3929309546947479,
-0.24747411906719208,
-0.8958656191825867,
0.25621268153190613,
-0.4452076256275177,
0.17594121396541595,
0.09154225140810013,
-0.0856773629784584,
0.6188560128211975,
-0.48373064398765564,
0.7581204175949097,
0.2961398661136627,
-0.02933809719979763,
0.32900190353393555,
0.030901798978447914,
0.7345535159111023,
-0.02707083709537983,
-0.3903703987598419,
0.05753210186958313,
-0.16212119162082672,
-0.16358540952205658,
-0.1928524672985077,
0.8132315874099731,
-0.962925910949707,
-0.7342512607574463,
-0.29357367753982544,
-0.26754647493362427,
-0.4261166453361511,
0.2513619661331177,
0.6080317497253418,
0.4289446175098419,
0.17007191479206085,
0.2124897688627243,
0.6027759313583374,
-0.31663402915000916,
0.8141269683837891,
0.37543705105781555,
0.04811093211174011,
-0.3173106908798218,
0.41858041286468506,
0.38474294543266296,
0.7329062819480896,
0.43406620621681213,
0.5058200359344482,
-0.4718801975250244,
-0.8563581109046936,
-0.3611958920955658,
-0.12381363660097122,
-0.6011776924133301,
-0.25239959359169006,
-0.6996232271194458,
-0.26721975207328796,
-0.14255627989768982,
-0.032236386090517044,
-0.6263754963874817,
-0.46099069714546204,
-0.33479583263397217,
-0.09185883402824402,
0.018911367282271385,
0.19674178957939148,
-0.3514993190765381,
0.5436338782310486,
-0.2887612581253052,
0.04598552733659744,
0.5826002359390259,
0.36183860898017883,
0.3634769320487976,
-0.4725829064846039,
-0.25080063939094543,
0.05123497545719147,
-0.2743290066719055,
-0.6693646311759949,
0.3841783404350281,
0.18819108605384827,
0.6294991970062256,
0.22356215119361877,
0.009910023771226406,
0.711755096912384,
-0.6429113149642944,
0.6233131885528564,
0.4074162542819977,
-1.0368648767471313,
0.5591194033622742,
-0.21380585432052612,
0.07837237417697906,
0.7590752840042114,
0.30116167664527893,
-0.19848351180553436,
0.03229594975709915,
-0.5080320835113525,
-1.1508690118789673,
0.9298216104507446,
0.30296725034713745,
0.16623331606388092,
0.1738576889038086,
0.169671893119812,
0.000744318647775799,
0.23505330085754395,
-0.5983120799064636,
-0.29210540652275085,
0.6501559019088745,
0.13056622445583344,
0.08935817331075668,
-0.43521350622177124,
-0.2681128978729248,
-0.0680311769247055,
0.43334299325942993,
-0.059558480978012085,
0.1380937248468399,
-0.238673597574234,
0.000719863164704293,
-0.3921814262866974,
0.18525585532188416,
0.46927693486213684,
0.7574878334999084,
-0.06617468595504761,
0.13470424711704254,
0.5170906782150269,
-0.235635444521904,
0.1965610682964325,
-0.14276380836963654,
-0.38792237639427185,
0.05610843002796173,
0.3635942041873932,
0.9678845405578613,
0.4926789104938507,
-0.4338698089122772,
0.44521331787109375,
0.3008423447608948,
-0.22126169502735138,
-0.3867839574813843,
-0.09413200616836548,
0.15327773988246918,
0.6084027290344238,
0.25453677773475647,
0.31426072120666504,
0.050401363521814346,
-0.3989828824996948,
0.28073641657829285,
0.3299035429954529,
-0.13794900476932526,
-0.0722009614109993,
0.4805319011211395,
0.2406466156244278,
-0.6366673707962036,
0.3772031366825104,
-0.011058746837079525,
-0.4965258240699768,
0.6205196380615234,
0.3011142909526825,
0.8867525458335876,
-0.13748541474342346,
0.43440112471580505,
-0.2082633227109909,
0.3494497835636139,
-0.8244187831878662,
0.15294238924980164,
0.14592453837394714,
-0.6219302415847778,
-0.5577478408813477,
-0.6808726191520691,
-0.6471489667892456,
0.02847961336374283,
-0.9578288197517395,
0.2933506965637207,
-0.4366709887981415,
-0.45285817980766296,
-0.19809839129447937,
0.30777114629745483,
-0.814838707447052,
0.24553050100803375,
0.35082849860191345,
0.9286451935768127,
-0.5218527317047119,
0.8639975786209106,
0.4086197316646576,
-0.16465505957603455,
-0.9688524007797241,
-0.037830717861652374,
0.09100279957056046,
-0.8929364085197449,
0.7369864583015442,
-0.11153566837310791,
-0.43269672989845276,
-0.024751314893364906,
-0.20910577476024628,
-1.1020069122314453,
1.132629156112671,
0.3559391498565674,
-0.7071155309677124,
-0.24846617877483368,
0.0030340373050421476,
0.4138134717941284,
-0.24563312530517578,
0.5054453015327454,
0.6169137954711914,
0.22137784957885742,
0.5031716823577881,
-0.9335137009620667,
-0.15439558029174805,
0.30960994958877563,
0.3625272810459137,
0.24261943995952606,
-1.1568928956985474,
1.018964171409607,
-0.234669491648674,
-0.2855789363384247,
0.26887890696525574,
0.5294092297554016,
0.12777501344680786,
0.05072152987122536,
0.6154651641845703,
0.6338244080543518,
0.8503869771957397,
0.08647210150957108,
0.9623416662216187,
-0.1493411511182785,
0.4882192611694336,
1.431688904762268,
-0.33000731468200684,
1.1779814958572388,
0.663677990436554,
-0.47298136353492737,
0.1539779007434845,
1.0799139738082886,
0.31364089250564575,
0.9090906381607056,
0.5712059736251831,
-0.39296144247055054,
-0.4584210515022278,
0.19337336719036102,
-0.3103924095630646,
0.4864244759082794,
0.19315671920776367,
-0.13750872015953064,
-0.21409332752227783,
-0.29683613777160645,
0.11333634704351425,
-0.3824339807033539,
-0.18508383631706238,
0.5736208558082581,
0.28918126225471497,
-0.7586724758148193,
0.23470433056354523,
0.00346763851121068,
0.7069391012191772,
-0.6500751376152039,
0.5887682437896729,
-0.3558374345302582,
0.12194143980741501,
0.11184604465961456,
-0.45339468121528625,
0.029789723455905914,
-0.30168241262435913,
-0.09194780141115189,
-0.2300809919834137,
0.4436474144458771,
-0.5625731348991394,
-0.6328372359275818,
0.6582238078117371,
0.6545106768608093,
-0.13321352005004883,
0.10154583305120468,
-0.7305585741996765,
0.23155741393566132,
-0.12677091360092163,
-0.3900676965713501,
0.3816974461078644,
0.3940197825431824,
-0.0012443485902622342,
1.030029296875,
0.6765184998512268,
0.6058674454689026,
0.09724030643701553,
0.24945935606956482,
0.7358947396278381,
-0.27902257442474365,
-0.4970252811908722,
-0.9720184206962585,
0.31681036949157715,
0.01895146071910858,
-0.5175394415855408,
0.3925347626209259,
0.42422816157341003,
0.8760135769844055,
0.15462949872016907,
0.7243247628211975,
0.43353796005249023,
0.10458910465240479,
-0.861903965473175,
0.4850832223892212,
-0.49382731318473816,
0.5958552360534668,
-0.09465918689966202,
-0.9451366066932678,
-0.15497204661369324,
0.6792163848876953,
-0.37288615107536316,
0.11770017445087433,
0.696116030216217,
0.7712908387184143,
0.06435425579547882,
0.14373940229415894,
0.37884366512298584,
-0.10359591990709305,
0.022807154804468155,
0.9310406446456909,
0.9109698534011841,
-0.2825582027435303,
0.4603768289089203,
-0.20813961327075958,
-0.11169682443141937,
-0.37330162525177,
-0.763207197189331,
-0.8287325501441956,
-0.1395348757505417,
-0.2529485523700714,
-0.2453170120716095,
0.22063273191452026,
1.010938048362732,
1.0730704069137573,
-0.6163805723190308,
-0.3508172035217285,
0.07846345752477646,
0.11048746109008789,
-0.154642254114151,
-0.07458709180355072,
0.33865049481391907,
-0.49702930450439453,
-0.5288766622543335,
0.3200594186782837,
0.33505135774612427,
0.016309544444084167,
-0.2591395080089569,
-0.013924138620495796,
-0.23130623996257782,
0.44395706057548523,
0.6148481369018555,
0.06703103333711624,
-0.8885863423347473,
-0.34427884221076965,
-0.2921296954154968,
-0.19390526413917542,
-0.05772571638226509,
0.765288233757019,
-0.28737571835517883,
0.17725907266139984,
0.28238368034362793,
0.9343668818473816,
0.7254466414451599,
-0.18318815529346466,
0.5861776471138,
-0.6930257081985474,
0.1337847262620926,
0.39000841975212097,
0.22093132138252258,
0.15857213735580444,
-0.38978999853134155,
0.5624805688858032,
0.052657049149274826,
-0.5078134536743164,
-0.6858783960342407,
0.3490811884403229,
-1.0060336589813232,
-0.351620078086853,
1.3592756986618042,
0.034200262278318405,
0.1534973382949829,
0.08565413951873779,
0.029866419732570648,
-0.03585430979728699,
-0.2907325029373169,
0.49626871943473816,
0.9069021344184875,
-0.10130662471055984,
-0.34663519263267517,
-0.7394051551818848,
0.4566567838191986,
0.7621227502822876,
-0.5755359530448914,
-0.3312114179134369,
0.2872695028781891,
0.07552748173475266,
0.09577786177396774,
0.5440804958343506,
0.25874119997024536,
-0.11869066953659058,
0.10780927538871765,
-0.3102318048477173,
0.33507484197616577,
-0.7019470930099487,
-0.2948175072669983,
0.2154582291841507,
0.24229386448860168,
-0.22926323115825653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02132v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02132v2
|
Unveiling the Potential of LLM-Based ASR on Chinese Open-Source Datasets
| 2024-05-03T14:35:58 | 2024-05-06T08:56:50 |
Xuelong Geng, Tianyi Xu, Kun Wei, Bingshen Mu, Hongfei Xue, He Wang, Yangze Li, Pengcheng Guo, Yuhang Dai, Longhao Li, Mingchen Shao, Lei Xie
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated unparalleled effectiveness in
various NLP tasks, and integrating LLMs with automatic speech recognition (ASR)
is becoming a mainstream paradigm. Building upon this momentum, our research
delves into an in-depth examination of this paradigm on a large open-source
Chinese dataset. Specifically, our research aims to evaluate the impact of
various configurations of speech encoders, LLMs, and projector modules in the
context of the speech foundation encoder-LLM ASR paradigm. Furthermore, we
introduce a three-stage training approach, expressly developed to enhance the
model's ability to align auditory and textual information. The implementation
of this approach, alongside the strategic integration of ASR components,
enabled us to achieve the SOTA performance on the AISHELL-1, Test_Net, and
Test_Meeting test sets. Our analysis presents an empirical foundation for
future research in LLM-based ASR systems and offers insights into optimizing
performance using Chinese datasets. We will publicly release all scripts used
for data preparation, training, inference, and scoring, as well as pre-trained
models and training logs to promote reproducible research.
|
[
-0.055412907153367996,
-0.3545610010623932,
0.1411421149969101,
0.1917956918478012,
-0.22932925820350647,
-0.16074596345424652,
-0.4068431556224823,
-0.6530223488807678,
-0.09241087734699249,
0.5490090847015381,
-0.30721941590309143,
-0.43831461668014526,
-0.48371008038520813,
0.09810046851634979,
-0.6514259576797485,
0.6180782914161682,
-0.12923812866210938,
0.5427058935165405,
-0.0230622049421072,
-0.10900874435901642,
-0.17081595957279205,
-0.573138952255249,
-0.6701011061668396,
-0.5811076164245605,
0.22272731363773346,
0.2812997102737427,
0.3724001348018646,
0.9101182222366333,
0.6021310091018677,
0.10327372699975967,
-0.11087286472320557,
-0.06886520236730576,
-0.2681599259376526,
-0.1301480531692505,
0.21625541150569916,
-0.2746979296207428,
-0.3720305263996124,
-0.03998984768986702,
1.075338363647461,
0.5840533971786499,
-0.3680373430252075,
0.19015978276729584,
0.419267863035202,
0.29279986023902893,
-0.44397908449172974,
0.2315336912870407,
-0.5635745525360107,
0.2885704040527344,
-0.4171806871891022,
-0.18343248963356018,
-0.24649757146835327,
-0.254532128572464,
0.16275323927402496,
-0.4363226890563965,
0.004560932982712984,
-0.18183256685733795,
0.8269040584564209,
0.37575235962867737,
-0.16179794073104858,
-0.4704173505306244,
-0.8297032713890076,
0.5031996369361877,
-0.9670833945274353,
0.5381177067756653,
0.10053230822086334,
0.39558541774749756,
-0.00954054668545723,
-0.6502001285552979,
-0.5812406539916992,
-0.23176060616970062,
0.09707359969615936,
0.05941573902964592,
0.03180514648556709,
0.07139062136411667,
0.24784256517887115,
0.4888860583305359,
-0.6672698855400085,
0.5400397181510925,
-0.36621707677841187,
-0.023730680346488953,
0.704680323600769,
0.07605331391096115,
0.30639857053756714,
-0.03150284290313721,
-0.2508196532726288,
0.014809231273829937,
-0.8763610124588013,
0.10433319956064224,
0.06395641714334488,
0.7283979654312134,
-0.09454897791147232,
0.705849289894104,
-0.09244376420974731,
0.6534488201141357,
-0.13991408050060272,
-0.05504700914025307,
0.22388815879821777,
-0.3749394118785858,
-0.28172096610069275,
0.4569714665412903,
0.9524878859519958,
-0.0797581821680069,
0.20445990562438965,
-0.052569907158613205,
-0.4918009340763092,
0.06699101626873016,
0.0018508528592064977,
-0.6843292117118835,
-0.05817403271794319,
0.12932220101356506,
-0.35074660181999207,
-0.04774218797683716,
0.1782260537147522,
-0.2842140197753906,
-0.5192380547523499,
-0.42333662509918213,
0.5982359051704407,
-0.31005555391311646,
-0.35258933901786804,
0.31838756799697876,
0.22391647100448608,
0.6642327308654785,
0.1526842713356018,
-0.8192408680915833,
0.3725132346153259,
0.7817659974098206,
0.8227638602256775,
-0.28541550040245056,
-0.30112743377685547,
-0.5802497267723083,
0.20075100660324097,
-0.34165719151496887,
0.619804859161377,
-0.3101317584514618,
-0.32236579060554504,
0.28105148673057556,
-0.19128470122814178,
0.016489725559949875,
-0.7672014832496643,
0.48109275102615356,
-0.4703432023525238,
-0.09635665267705917,
-0.2069588303565979,
-0.5141903162002563,
-0.000003792373490796308,
0.17954251170158386,
-0.7252120971679688,
0.8533141016960144,
-0.4398845434188843,
-0.5201103091239929,
0.28874829411506653,
-0.8624552488327026,
-0.5043195486068726,
-0.039042405784130096,
-0.4762307107448578,
-0.2520380914211273,
-0.08168483525514603,
0.09050392359495163,
0.5499804019927979,
-0.5342928171157837,
0.286690890789032,
0.05313568934798241,
-0.6656867861747742,
0.23925656080245972,
-0.3275313377380371,
0.8280259370803833,
0.2617059051990509,
-0.3259156048297882,
0.1962190866470337,
-0.9422236084938049,
-0.16734562814235687,
0.12784509360790253,
-0.6053902506828308,
-0.13554424047470093,
0.21202869713306427,
0.10537659376859665,
0.11635271459817886,
0.26041024923324585,
-0.5955401659011841,
-0.07859159260988235,
-0.6215569972991943,
0.5410935878753662,
0.6375905871391296,
-0.42219865322113037,
0.2621358633041382,
-0.08229821920394897,
0.28666189312934875,
-0.06893061101436615,
0.08958839625120163,
-0.15093444287776947,
-0.15208856761455536,
-0.8268503546714783,
-0.052941225469112396,
0.36522531509399414,
0.4587768614292145,
-0.5177857279777527,
0.3889503479003906,
-0.32425636053085327,
-0.31508806347846985,
-0.6175561547279358,
-0.05413314700126648,
0.40930095314979553,
0.3138982653617859,
0.3049106299877167,
-0.23725339770317078,
-0.6878183484077454,
-0.7189440727233887,
-0.16968590021133423,
-0.20894697308540344,
-0.319735586643219,
0.20824871957302094,
0.30022990703582764,
-0.13368885219097137,
0.8509566783905029,
-0.2011382281780243,
-0.44128507375717163,
-0.39511430263519287,
-0.14062586426734924,
0.420571893453598,
0.4352322220802307,
-0.09452318400144577,
-0.5986927151679993,
-0.4111813008785248,
0.0793122872710228,
-0.7939655184745789,
-0.18476739525794983,
0.13214360177516937,
0.2894962430000305,
0.14475972950458527,
0.6049496531486511,
-0.38475340604782104,
0.14785265922546387,
0.554159939289093,
0.010425982065498829,
0.5736683011054993,
0.039217717945575714,
-0.03269105404615402,
-0.8495901226997375,
0.17324115335941315,
0.0112402169033885,
0.2693422734737396,
-0.931829035282135,
0.0039884611032903194,
0.13557827472686768,
-0.15959657728672028,
-0.5234807133674622,
0.3391987085342407,
-0.3978181779384613,
-0.5772061944007874,
-0.24860642850399017,
0.21487262845039368,
-0.35294100642204285,
0.2483205646276474,
0.11222206801176071,
0.8341525793075562,
0.518231987953186,
-0.6255210638046265,
0.1701032668352127,
0.2809584438800812,
-0.5781800150871277,
0.2173561006784439,
-0.684021532535553,
0.26263514161109924,
-0.007814409211277962,
0.0977327972650528,
-0.7121815085411072,
-0.1862104833126068,
0.34640517830848694,
-0.3973398506641388,
0.25327423214912415,
0.18025274574756622,
-0.7568565011024475,
-0.2352333962917328,
-0.15441277623176575,
0.29146963357925415,
0.3350617587566376,
-0.6203342080116272,
0.635328471660614,
0.4848426580429077,
0.02836650423705578,
-0.653540313243866,
-0.8475823998451233,
0.06960854679346085,
-0.20978763699531555,
-0.5603463649749756,
0.44932183623313904,
0.07834219187498093,
-0.2973507344722748,
-0.15771572291851044,
-0.14420382678508759,
-0.06795067340135574,
-0.011974678374826908,
0.20804736018180847,
0.1789049655199051,
-0.45292627811431885,
0.022632630541920662,
-0.3711322546005249,
-0.11809215694665909,
0.11415044963359833,
-0.4301002323627472,
0.5748535394668579,
-0.05343816801905632,
-0.5658825039863586,
-0.5229666829109192,
-0.09961583465337753,
0.08883216977119446,
-0.40449702739715576,
0.3959692120552063,
0.4206930994987488,
-0.5703518986701965,
-0.22333095967769623,
-0.4697224497795105,
-0.0666314885020256,
-0.47194379568099976,
0.46126726269721985,
-0.2685553729534149,
-0.9085549712181091,
0.36775171756744385,
0.20189307630062103,
0.25320106744766235,
0.19640253484249115,
0.4386066198348999,
-0.01593135856091976,
0.7449925541877747,
0.5556299686431885,
-0.31892552971839905,
0.4903412461280823,
-0.23748688399791718,
0.06901427358388901,
-0.7931326627731323,
-0.2935751676559448,
-0.4864047169685364,
-0.1067800521850586,
-0.3707349896430969,
-0.6281452178955078,
0.26620200276374817,
-0.16511760652065277,
-0.4170231521129608,
0.1775737702846527,
-0.28242507576942444,
0.3950130045413971,
0.38359934091567993,
-0.03818949684500694,
0.5021981596946716,
-0.15743716061115265,
0.19689595699310303,
0.14550501108169556,
-0.6283292770385742,
-0.5535010099411011,
1.116508960723877,
0.5094043612480164,
0.702513575553894,
-0.12906497716903687,
0.45426222681999207,
0.06775546073913574,
0.056942857801914215,
-0.7124270796775818,
0.6587222814559937,
-0.48839595913887024,
-0.32132798433303833,
-0.5820679068565369,
-0.18735280632972717,
-0.8339277505874634,
0.20421931147575378,
0.046972405165433884,
-0.369377464056015,
-0.02648920938372612,
0.006792154163122177,
-0.47343724966049194,
0.1158602312207222,
-0.16242745518684387,
0.6067821979522705,
-0.4290604889392853,
0.05773886293172836,
-0.08395972102880478,
-0.6037609577178955,
0.37039676308631897,
-0.1772931069135666,
0.09983986616134644,
-0.18264469504356384,
0.012566646561026573,
0.8896406888961792,
0.07734252512454987,
0.7107415199279785,
-0.3187694847583771,
-0.32949233055114746,
0.15595491230487823,
-0.37640830874443054,
0.3454310894012451,
-0.30884304642677307,
-0.28395602107048035,
0.6297966837882996,
-0.21213728189468384,
0.021143216639757156,
-0.36261722445487976,
0.4508862793445587,
-0.9405326247215271,
-0.476521760225296,
-0.2571168541908264,
-0.43618690967559814,
-0.25698626041412354,
0.15977616608142853,
0.10788828879594803,
0.43094173073768616,
-0.31265026330947876,
0.340528666973114,
0.8036582469940186,
-0.4360605478286743,
0.276649534702301,
0.7890576720237732,
-0.3370681405067444,
-0.3807821571826935,
0.8652758598327637,
0.5044336318969727,
0.218377947807312,
0.4144659638404846,
0.12929940223693848,
-0.23306764662265778,
-0.8661270141601562,
-0.38651394844055176,
0.22374887764453888,
-0.6232021450996399,
0.026033317670226097,
-0.5005746483802795,
-0.7416782975196838,
-0.4569348394870758,
0.10002469271421432,
-0.45618996024131775,
-0.06990798562765121,
-0.4999631345272064,
-0.06733053177595139,
0.031096965074539185,
0.7355515956878662,
-0.1702776700258255,
0.45118260383605957,
-0.4801563620567322,
0.30710259079933167,
0.17105776071548462,
0.3392278850078583,
-0.014684466645121574,
-0.7193207740783691,
-0.6326225996017456,
0.05113522708415985,
-0.03658266365528107,
-0.4716010093688965,
0.4348362982273102,
0.3044300377368927,
0.6150025129318237,
0.45469796657562256,
-0.09940759837627411,
0.6363034248352051,
-0.6550147533416748,
0.8252128958702087,
-0.029755214229226112,
-0.8947301506996155,
0.7031051516532898,
-0.3401575982570648,
0.16959242522716522,
0.34665772318840027,
0.17950105667114258,
-0.5089738965034485,
-0.2825418710708618,
-0.11378809809684753,
-0.7930875420570374,
0.9954798817634583,
0.07292980700731277,
-0.07332650572061539,
0.4959300756454468,
0.34097668528556824,
0.03981274738907814,
0.13743823766708374,
-0.679068922996521,
-0.2750692367553711,
-0.15060141682624817,
-0.26097723841667175,
-0.3145604431629181,
-0.22554725408554077,
-0.13235346972942352,
0.0003791141207329929,
0.5617654919624329,
-0.05043288320302963,
0.1819673478603363,
-0.06834571808576584,
-0.1411697417497635,
0.022828252986073494,
0.06655580550432205,
0.33266690373420715,
0.28505855798721313,
-0.12514343857765198,
0.04825828969478607,
0.2682221829891205,
-0.3643839955329895,
0.09376248717308044,
0.34203606843948364,
-0.17738471925258636,
-0.12831425666809082,
0.341105192899704,
0.8222194314002991,
0.22455929219722748,
-0.8493726849555969,
0.39661648869514465,
0.09815928339958191,
-0.2399863451719284,
-0.6158260107040405,
0.08161164075136185,
0.06790849566459656,
0.43231427669525146,
0.5058364272117615,
-0.3512208163738251,
0.3391609489917755,
-0.4054647386074066,
0.26264724135398865,
0.4012352526187897,
-0.39783450961112976,
-0.34834256768226624,
0.6185393333435059,
0.0857764184474945,
-0.38998842239379883,
0.6201134920120239,
0.3588367998600006,
-0.3470240533351898,
0.5862770080566406,
0.6488146781921387,
0.8966541290283203,
-0.43304842710494995,
-0.11508788913488388,
0.31310564279556274,
0.32843029499053955,
-0.3603086769580841,
0.24799129366874695,
-0.09189685434103012,
-1.0692639350891113,
-0.47457095980644226,
-0.6805363297462463,
-0.5333033204078674,
0.25497710704803467,
-0.7782994508743286,
0.6180293560028076,
-0.47005441784858704,
0.17640544474124908,
-0.26852089166641235,
0.005646057426929474,
-0.34185993671417236,
0.22254888713359833,
0.556652843952179,
0.9685319066047668,
-0.7254125475883484,
1.0320115089416504,
0.5266883373260498,
-0.29016584157943726,
-0.9817780256271362,
0.41562557220458984,
0.10694079101085663,
-1.0927969217300415,
0.7186625599861145,
0.41289302706718445,
-0.19087481498718262,
0.112398162484169,
-0.47431129217147827,
-1.0980840921401978,
1.2913435697555542,
0.47806036472320557,
-0.6042903065681458,
-0.002188704442232847,
0.4986543655395508,
0.5894819498062134,
-0.35440126061439514,
-0.0009956163121387362,
0.7674565315246582,
0.23282350599765778,
0.1270740032196045,
-1.1666291952133179,
-0.07110604643821716,
-0.3422832787036896,
0.10718200355768204,
-0.18045629560947418,
-0.6456692218780518,
0.655512273311615,
0.05474443733692169,
-0.4653957784175873,
-0.08063691109418869,
0.854295015335083,
0.6231482028961182,
0.29571762681007385,
0.48183444142341614,
0.15869362652301788,
0.552987277507782,
0.05269942432641983,
0.5580016374588013,
-0.3814225196838379,
-0.1434824913740158,
1.1001030206680298,
-0.5332126617431641,
1.183804988861084,
0.315447598695755,
-0.23672474920749664,
0.22718293964862823,
0.6464322209358215,
-0.07789282500743866,
0.5221998691558838,
0.4098222553730011,
-0.24242286384105682,
0.10472626239061356,
-0.4177223742008209,
-0.4671115279197693,
0.7431064248085022,
0.36130112409591675,
-0.20467358827590942,
0.13085059821605682,
0.1616523563861847,
-0.16503170132637024,
-0.05849676579236984,
-0.3161953091621399,
0.7502679824829102,
0.18952041864395142,
-0.14470818638801575,
0.4290679693222046,
-0.09192197024822235,
0.9079369306564331,
-0.7094630002975464,
0.12548689544200897,
-0.09680246561765671,
0.07944828271865845,
-0.16720230877399445,
-0.6890531778335571,
0.3597261905670166,
0.278697669506073,
0.049075979739427567,
-0.28200817108154297,
0.7139612436294556,
-0.5874679684638977,
-0.24289152026176453,
0.4441229999065399,
0.30818742513656616,
0.25261035561561584,
-0.05280395224690437,
-0.40630605816841125,
0.45383521914482117,
-0.11355341970920563,
-0.1737864762544632,
0.48351529240608215,
0.5021951198577881,
0.25854983925819397,
0.629560649394989,
0.6135268211364746,
0.35705214738845825,
-0.16127890348434448,
0.3211923837661743,
0.9086452126502991,
-0.6769581437110901,
-0.45223093032836914,
-0.9230532050132751,
0.507941722869873,
0.19244833290576935,
0.04674498736858368,
0.737199604511261,
0.6613698601722717,
0.9452707171440125,
0.17428600788116455,
0.9057900905609131,
0.21354900300502777,
0.5215752124786377,
-0.6515408158302307,
0.8792992234230042,
-0.5809852480888367,
0.5490628480911255,
-0.161477193236351,
-0.654269814491272,
-0.47307685017585754,
0.543792724609375,
-0.1695789396762848,
-0.19333280622959137,
0.2560793161392212,
0.9250696301460266,
0.35203030705451965,
0.20120865106582642,
0.3545958697795868,
0.35466423630714417,
0.38960152864456177,
0.38885486125946045,
1.1419012546539307,
-0.4638291597366333,
0.6838021874427795,
0.0021620558109134436,
-0.1499776691198349,
-0.12370054423809052,
-0.6418284773826599,
-0.5420988202095032,
-0.6058903336524963,
-0.09739470481872559,
-0.09869978576898575,
0.2293822318315506,
1.0069087743759155,
0.3134104013442993,
-0.9723992943763733,
-0.7905992865562439,
0.017636802047491074,
-0.31288108229637146,
-0.04998650401830673,
-0.1667930781841278,
0.395274817943573,
-0.10166352987289429,
-0.6221928000450134,
0.6459341049194336,
0.29045072197914124,
-0.044642359018325806,
-0.42583638429641724,
-0.38954979181289673,
0.013479417189955711,
-0.03313758969306946,
0.5390958189964294,
0.20609499514102936,
-0.8696467876434326,
-0.1263071447610855,
0.15673401951789856,
-0.1807432472705841,
0.13072742521762848,
0.7427073121070862,
-0.5490971803665161,
0.2900833785533905,
0.2516728937625885,
0.6742163300514221,
0.2924506664276123,
-0.13486842811107635,
0.883123517036438,
-0.44658762216567993,
-0.1459144800901413,
0.2731188237667084,
0.24102488160133362,
0.4260278046131134,
-0.1844971925020218,
0.6958557963371277,
-0.052011460065841675,
-0.5694833397865295,
-1.2302625179290771,
-0.12185237556695938,
-0.7036241888999939,
-0.07686272263526917,
1.3479318618774414,
-0.16407540440559387,
0.2147890031337738,
-0.058360353112220764,
-0.015146712772548199,
0.48869219422340393,
-0.27212369441986084,
0.6971531510353088,
0.5344489216804504,
-0.3352314829826355,
-0.15582452714443207,
-0.6131759881973267,
0.44585976004600525,
0.20344310998916626,
-0.6689195036888123,
0.25773248076438904,
0.44277870655059814,
0.0010094360914081335,
-0.026659086346626282,
0.8793538212776184,
-0.09600504487752914,
0.04656603932380676,
0.05893845111131668,
0.2635326385498047,
-0.07181832194328308,
-0.28977859020233154,
-0.834130585193634,
0.08543878048658371,
0.15521974861621857,
-0.2548997700214386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02128v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02128v1
|
Single and Multi-Hop Question-Answering Datasets for Reticular Chemistry with GPT-4-Turbo
| 2024-05-03T14:29:54 | 2024-05-03T14:29:54 |
Nakul Rampal, Kaiyu Wang, Matthew Burigana, Lingxiang Hou, Juri Al-Johani, Anna Sackmann, Hanan S. Murayshid, Walaa Abdullah Al-Sumari, Arwa M. Al-Abdulkarim, Nahla Eid Al-Hazmi, Majed O. Al-Awad, Christian Borgs, Jennifer T. Chayes, Omar M. Yaghi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cond-mat.mtrl-sci
|
The rapid advancement in artificial intelligence and natural language
processing has led to the development of large-scale datasets aimed at
benchmarking the performance of machine learning models. Herein, we introduce
'RetChemQA,' a comprehensive benchmark dataset designed to evaluate the
capabilities of such models in the domain of reticular chemistry. This dataset
includes both single-hop and multi-hop question-answer pairs, encompassing
approximately 45,000 Q&As for each type. The questions have been extracted from
an extensive corpus of literature containing about 2,530 research papers from
publishers including NAS, ACS, RSC, Elsevier, and Nature Publishing Group,
among others. The dataset has been generated using OpenAI's GPT-4 Turbo, a
cutting-edge model known for its exceptional language understanding and
generation capabilities. In addition to the Q&A dataset, we also release a
dataset of synthesis conditions extracted from the corpus of literature used in
this study. The aim of RetChemQA is to provide a robust platform for the
development and evaluation of advanced machine learning algorithms,
particularly for the reticular chemistry community. The dataset is structured
to reflect the complexities and nuances of real-world scientific discourse,
thereby enabling nuanced performance assessments across a variety of tasks. The
dataset is available at the following link:
https://github.com/nakulrampal/RetChemQA
|
[
0.050384558737277985,
-0.829913854598999,
0.7004469037055969,
0.08088886737823486,
0.16634178161621094,
0.6534244418144226,
-0.10695268213748932,
-0.031176023185253143,
0.3025190234184265,
0.438753217458725,
-0.7199496626853943,
-0.6239920854568481,
-0.07665204256772995,
0.309902161359787,
-0.1270691156387329,
0.7472426891326904,
-0.2421634942293167,
-0.10371027886867523,
-0.44891926646232605,
0.04902272671461105,
-0.2535730302333832,
-0.20885322988033295,
-0.3124399781227112,
-0.015704497694969177,
0.7502163052558899,
0.5472702980041504,
0.4822051227092743,
0.2844160199165344,
0.5948130488395691,
0.3800427317619324,
0.28452807664871216,
-0.08968552947044373,
-0.21144303679466248,
0.630728542804718,
0.015292378142476082,
-0.3462070822715759,
-0.4992141127586365,
0.3573569059371948,
0.747642993927002,
0.6261962652206421,
-0.0921100452542305,
0.4188045263290405,
-0.20179037749767303,
0.5396676063537598,
-0.6501498818397522,
0.008446104824543,
-0.5387653708457947,
0.10073778033256531,
-0.12419721484184265,
0.01796644926071167,
-0.14625634253025055,
-0.48250070214271545,
0.32687562704086304,
-1.1047254800796509,
0.1880149245262146,
0.12354941666126251,
0.6027243733406067,
0.603451669216156,
-0.4047892391681671,
0.20659269392490387,
-0.198281392455101,
0.8918015956878662,
-0.5165361762046814,
0.6595230102539062,
0.04177035391330719,
0.624777615070343,
-0.27014702558517456,
-1.2507020235061646,
-0.39513838291168213,
-0.1515091061592102,
0.15852177143096924,
0.5776495933532715,
-0.05004245787858963,
-0.22554422914981842,
0.11540860682725906,
0.1803796887397766,
-1.084622859954834,
-0.4119929075241089,
-0.35470446944236755,
-0.48106712102890015,
0.23879913985729218,
0.4424270689487457,
0.09952209144830704,
-0.04292340576648712,
-0.2696193754673004,
-0.07726474106311798,
-0.4932323098182678,
-0.05108243227005005,
0.16613595187664032,
0.34847134351730347,
0.1985487937927246,
0.38202667236328125,
-0.42574089765548706,
0.4431856870651245,
-0.26930055022239685,
0.36240342259407043,
0.6151570081710815,
-0.842299222946167,
-0.3527439534664154,
-0.2849186658859253,
0.8718855977058411,
0.1468111127614975,
0.2009851038455963,
-0.3773001432418823,
0.14350344240665436,
-0.06392589956521988,
0.468149334192276,
-1.1217433214187622,
-0.3455980718135834,
0.5606839060783386,
-0.10153724998235703,
-0.3860515058040619,
-0.1813558042049408,
-1.2803599834442139,
0.039959121495485306,
-0.2455984503030777,
0.3213247060775757,
-0.15226760506629944,
-0.24160164594650269,
-0.048712924122810364,
-0.4540151357650757,
0.3554198741912842,
0.19542936980724335,
-0.5998061299324036,
0.37917324900627136,
0.4109411835670471,
0.9114411473274231,
-0.24389149248600006,
-0.7023682594299316,
-0.3829612135887146,
-0.12350701540708542,
-0.3066621720790863,
0.9378061294555664,
-0.8409473299980164,
-0.20755361020565033,
-0.24818867444992065,
0.15666022896766663,
-0.1675361692905426,
-0.83050936460495,
0.6069426536560059,
-0.43916055560112,
0.06693439930677414,
-0.21384398639202118,
-0.23765794932842255,
-0.10401251167058945,
0.28543218970298767,
-0.7547948956489563,
0.9407718181610107,
0.27152755856513977,
-0.5726935267448425,
0.3974590301513672,
-0.43622034788131714,
-0.280907541513443,
0.11931386590003967,
-0.22513818740844727,
-0.4841746985912323,
-0.03423396125435829,
0.29052722454071045,
-0.05323353037238121,
-0.755296528339386,
0.04988783970475197,
-0.4614282548427582,
-0.12307846546173096,
0.46080031991004944,
-0.22257757186889648,
0.5563836097717285,
0.35353654623031616,
-0.058545734733343124,
0.28689253330230713,
-0.6086857318878174,
0.7057550549507141,
-0.10207219421863556,
-0.35695746541023254,
0.20109926164150238,
-0.5614929795265198,
0.22850704193115234,
0.18547888100147247,
0.03581191599369049,
-0.671271800994873,
0.03645097836852074,
-0.027285506948828697,
0.7275992631912231,
0.47941771149635315,
0.4225490987300873,
0.08314898610115051,
-0.12856248021125793,
0.8284279704093933,
0.015414422377943993,
0.11711844056844711,
-0.0750526562333107,
-0.6728229522705078,
-0.21094180643558502,
-0.12503360211849213,
0.530586302280426,
0.6677592396736145,
-0.5799261331558228,
0.13351379334926605,
-0.1854037493467331,
-0.705093502998352,
-0.6962335109710693,
0.16384080052375793,
0.2855879068374634,
0.5246887803077698,
0.38214629888534546,
-0.040894873440265656,
-0.27640199661254883,
-1.1720902919769287,
-0.6221840381622314,
-0.030552174896001816,
-0.012706421315670013,
0.3808140456676483,
0.5813285708427429,
-0.2023923099040985,
0.9806305766105652,
-0.5994935035705566,
0.09296724200248718,
0.07095160335302353,
0.20243790745735168,
0.22022931277751923,
0.2526307702064514,
0.2317139059305191,
-0.858971118927002,
-0.5968611240386963,
-0.27409473061561584,
-0.8015105128288269,
-0.3453960716724396,
0.302432656288147,
-0.4579871892929077,
-0.06413040310144424,
0.3367695212364197,
-0.4857792854309082,
0.3542473316192627,
0.5112146139144897,
-0.15997099876403809,
0.804742157459259,
0.02232270874083042,
0.6661294102668762,
-0.953490138053894,
0.42039018869400024,
-0.006564955692738295,
-0.14258019626140594,
-0.9459202885627747,
-0.027481604367494583,
0.040050286799669266,
-0.31016361713409424,
-0.8036934733390808,
0.35731667280197144,
-0.2387683391571045,
-0.07654650509357452,
-0.10683752596378326,
0.0928371474146843,
0.14206147193908691,
0.5288054347038269,
0.17709630727767944,
1.0608271360397339,
0.7943530082702637,
-0.36585381627082825,
0.4981924295425415,
0.34732675552368164,
-0.21948778629302979,
0.1809518188238144,
-0.9537885785102844,
0.004698209464550018,
0.4219835698604584,
0.47144848108291626,
-1.1293904781341553,
-0.37200918793678284,
0.22139716148376465,
-0.7569512724876404,
0.10267042368650436,
-0.34691643714904785,
-0.5524255633354187,
-0.18234936892986298,
-0.2669164538383484,
0.9399762749671936,
0.3312636613845825,
-0.17148198187351227,
0.8670231103897095,
0.373995840549469,
-0.16402514278888702,
-0.3910858631134033,
-0.6147802472114563,
-0.06095851585268974,
-0.4553638696670532,
-0.8859559893608093,
0.2374700903892517,
-0.05268101766705513,
-0.001218278775922954,
-0.06820479035377502,
-0.2751016616821289,
-0.35464775562286377,
-0.10237043350934982,
0.2998669147491455,
0.22847260534763336,
0.061879951506853104,
0.01086288969963789,
-0.1323065608739853,
-0.46460458636283875,
0.2809963822364807,
-0.2788393497467041,
0.2639208734035492,
-0.2189566045999527,
0.047758206725120544,
-0.5093914270401001,
0.25984153151512146,
0.8348888754844666,
-0.35308101773262024,
0.18949495255947113,
0.4380904734134674,
-0.21818874776363373,
0.041426196694374084,
0.004990254063159227,
-0.4270743429660797,
-0.4616760015487671,
0.3854888677597046,
-0.6899840831756592,
-0.6567681431770325,
0.7328735589981079,
-0.11053433269262314,
0.0051758610643446445,
0.46231311559677124,
0.782228946685791,
0.03480730578303337,
0.5079207420349121,
-0.10754004865884781,
0.027377909049391747,
0.005535693373531103,
-0.07931450009346008,
0.28410792350769043,
-0.804659366607666,
0.01065059658139944,
-0.4746827781200409,
-0.2199779450893402,
-0.7249037027359009,
-0.5587342381477356,
0.49864694476127625,
-0.5046155452728271,
-0.6875693798065186,
0.24959860742092133,
-0.4082775115966797,
0.38461583852767944,
0.6308431625366211,
0.04419206827878952,
0.2115340381860733,
0.11826874315738678,
-0.051158882677555084,
-0.0735081136226654,
-0.6909568309783936,
-0.2849324643611908,
1.4992684125900269,
0.3323683440685272,
0.9255401492118835,
0.27756014466285706,
0.4924277365207672,
0.1800346076488495,
0.03450177237391472,
-0.5774741172790527,
0.3864753246307373,
0.23426707088947296,
-0.7985921502113342,
-0.2344503402709961,
-0.8311401605606079,
-0.8343027830123901,
0.24287725985050201,
-0.18044400215148926,
-0.3676181435585022,
0.05518572777509689,
0.05590759590268135,
-0.4273558557033539,
0.09805159270763397,
-0.7784929871559143,
1.1971404552459717,
-0.4808894395828247,
-0.7946323156356812,
0.13011281192302704,
-0.8265023231506348,
0.22533388435840607,
-0.4026060402393341,
-0.04784843698143959,
-0.12376267462968826,
-0.17750979959964752,
0.8020875453948975,
-0.17798562347888947,
0.3724803030490875,
-0.12908098101615906,
0.1360117793083191,
0.44410040974617004,
0.09151085466146469,
0.08878327906131744,
0.18398170173168182,
0.19995753467082977,
0.234538733959198,
0.29636862874031067,
-0.3803905248641968,
-0.7051547765731812,
0.7869904637336731,
-0.7054153680801392,
-0.39554399251937866,
-0.5233012437820435,
-0.49109727144241333,
-0.41348376870155334,
0.2775759696960449,
0.26267340779304504,
0.395641565322876,
-0.041951943188905716,
0.13344043493270874,
0.26053857803344727,
-0.3840203881263733,
-0.11124078184366226,
0.22384071350097656,
-0.2885618507862091,
-0.5535285472869873,
1.0131887197494507,
-0.03546452522277832,
0.5437585115432739,
0.2317580282688141,
0.005361754447221756,
-0.5934107899665833,
-0.31814393401145935,
-0.5009627938270569,
0.15765266120433807,
-0.6785030364990234,
-0.22577084600925446,
-0.5862735509872437,
-0.062326591461896896,
-0.733714759349823,
0.2833276689052582,
-0.5374346375465393,
-0.531022846698761,
0.26508665084838867,
0.011262900196015835,
0.3324429988861084,
0.3932889401912689,
0.1331373155117035,
-0.010426746681332588,
-0.8171818256378174,
0.42386725544929504,
0.2780981659889221,
0.47647759318351746,
-0.29436787962913513,
-0.5326982140541077,
-0.07971453666687012,
-0.009535484947264194,
-0.2840234935283661,
-0.9860421419143677,
0.1519923061132431,
0.14611941576004028,
0.7402849197387695,
-0.2927088737487793,
-0.053158435970544815,
0.4369007647037506,
-0.5348724126815796,
0.6336990594863892,
-0.2804092466831207,
-0.5597758293151855,
0.53861004114151,
-0.47179824113845825,
0.12368081510066986,
0.9653335809707642,
0.38777580857276917,
-0.4954339563846588,
-0.43260425329208374,
-0.4837128818035126,
-1.1279523372650146,
0.4404519200325012,
0.5642627477645874,
-0.5280319452285767,
0.3152754306793213,
0.46920982003211975,
-0.09403932839632034,
0.27967187762260437,
-0.43096214532852173,
-0.3933783173561096,
-0.5869807600975037,
-0.18623845279216766,
0.06907624751329422,
0.4393673837184906,
-0.04356185346841812,
-0.12956292927265167,
0.8105781674385071,
-0.044837743043899536,
0.2709822356700897,
0.025710072368383408,
-0.09800881147384644,
0.3450678884983063,
0.331716388463974,
0.21273307502269745,
0.5895497798919678,
-0.7393284440040588,
-0.07392605394124985,
0.019320109859108925,
-0.776567816734314,
0.3027517795562744,
-0.03340723365545273,
0.05709294602274895,
-0.3157992959022522,
0.09123536944389343,
0.1227479949593544,
-0.1396215707063675,
-0.8512510657310486,
0.1479552984237671,
-0.32398146390914917,
-0.5304740071296692,
-0.2303832769393921,
0.07432300597429276,
0.12867848575115204,
0.1110650897026062,
0.22878529131412506,
-0.2301197648048401,
0.39909496903419495,
-0.6098234057426453,
0.3723239302635193,
0.16530993580818176,
-0.19972121715545654,
-0.18496161699295044,
0.7191255688667297,
0.19459430873394012,
0.036549706012010574,
1.0159852504730225,
-0.04184933751821518,
-0.6768335103988647,
0.5756794214248657,
0.26895707845687866,
1.0251096487045288,
0.0346597321331501,
0.06602349877357483,
0.6570978164672852,
0.16151680052280426,
0.5764957070350647,
0.31018751859664917,
-0.0189115721732378,
-0.6032699346542358,
-0.10707469284534454,
-0.4529794454574585,
-0.6502984762191772,
-0.07703627645969391,
-0.4886552691459656,
-0.058583855628967285,
-0.4361783266067505,
-0.17394587397575378,
0.37701869010925293,
0.11586020141839981,
-0.573431670665741,
0.19128954410552979,
-0.36553701758384705,
0.89438396692276,
-1.1616923809051514,
0.6125534772872925,
0.7175606489181519,
-0.6358641982078552,
-0.5935515761375427,
0.16148553788661957,
0.3757188618183136,
-0.40145745873451233,
0.7334685325622559,
0.05178848281502724,
-0.3833334743976593,
0.036299191415309906,
-0.5239028334617615,
-0.9449871778488159,
1.1401801109313965,
0.02742331475019455,
-0.18734776973724365,
0.332804411649704,
0.2264113426208496,
0.4924519956111908,
-0.4899939000606537,
0.5264158844947815,
1.0341001749038696,
0.7993882894515991,
0.2826539874076843,
-0.6187966465950012,
0.09091116487979889,
-0.5625308752059937,
-0.39400508999824524,
0.13149526715278625,
-0.6106075644493103,
0.7770698070526123,
0.061172135174274445,
-0.26233139634132385,
0.19975851476192474,
0.2517363727092743,
0.5686613321304321,
0.30120813846588135,
0.20273178815841675,
0.8226966857910156,
0.6055310368537903,
-0.41673821210861206,
0.8158089518547058,
-0.36343494057655334,
0.2980998158454895,
0.9713077545166016,
-0.4848497211933136,
0.742161750793457,
0.4986039996147156,
-0.47464075684547424,
0.15694336593151093,
0.9659513235092163,
-0.13700833916664124,
0.5013225674629211,
0.504306972026825,
-0.22942858934402466,
-0.4308463931083679,
0.21743422746658325,
-0.2805781364440918,
0.3433447480201721,
0.34075990319252014,
0.02669592574238777,
-0.20210593938827515,
-0.3798696994781494,
-0.3476508855819702,
-0.247331902384758,
0.01500815711915493,
0.5117968916893005,
-0.2681065499782562,
-0.7102957367897034,
0.42636653780937195,
-0.2090510129928589,
0.3157822787761688,
-0.48319464921951294,
-0.09070349484682083,
-0.3889807164669037,
0.032741714268922806,
-0.22724895179271698,
-1.056267261505127,
0.14815488457679749,
-0.08072847872972488,
-0.22535838186740875,
0.2113507241010666,
0.4895354211330414,
-0.2990577220916748,
-0.5330217480659485,
0.09534282237291336,
0.8650373816490173,
0.5083399415016174,
-0.21114756166934967,
-0.8771988749504089,
-0.20321981608867645,
0.0666845515370369,
-0.09374179691076279,
0.09816494584083557,
0.41034653782844543,
0.027522018179297447,
0.8844248652458191,
0.6291196942329407,
-0.13746534287929535,
0.10880027711391449,
0.13446654379367828,
0.9761661291122437,
-0.9502505660057068,
-0.13073883950710297,
-0.35818082094192505,
0.27113810181617737,
0.18046608567237854,
-0.33473071455955505,
0.8166868686676025,
0.9904326796531677,
0.434163898229599,
0.027642814442515373,
0.9988473653793335,
0.05666444078087807,
0.7301660180091858,
-0.3715648055076599,
0.516197919845581,
-0.6947008371353149,
0.024779081344604492,
-0.25617772340774536,
-1.0272555351257324,
-0.3033618628978729,
0.43138203024864197,
-0.08021336048841476,
0.5285946726799011,
0.7949983477592468,
0.9959955215454102,
-0.13493405282497406,
0.1211017444729805,
0.08502521365880966,
0.23057420551776886,
0.6332873702049255,
0.73232102394104,
0.9780599474906921,
-0.5103570818901062,
0.5065217614173889,
0.020296597853302956,
-0.23422636091709137,
0.12503992021083832,
-0.5194739103317261,
-0.4909600615501404,
-0.5365051031112671,
-0.3430400490760803,
-0.37912049889564514,
-0.09005813300609589,
0.789469301700592,
0.5311149954795837,
-0.6558001637458801,
-0.1637769490480423,
-0.03134101629257202,
-0.14249083399772644,
-0.05608648434281349,
-0.1870741844177246,
0.4725506603717804,
-0.4881708323955536,
-0.6834340691566467,
0.36577779054641724,
0.3490421175956726,
-0.1593828946352005,
-0.23387306928634644,
0.02446039207279682,
-0.24904225766658783,
-0.2247554063796997,
0.18611057102680206,
0.496671199798584,
-0.42803794145584106,
0.06933549046516418,
0.3630804121494293,
0.1579645723104477,
0.23206457495689392,
0.910266637802124,
-0.8413411974906921,
0.3655298948287964,
0.5134825110435486,
0.82589191198349,
0.4700517952442169,
0.1609800159931183,
0.526256263256073,
-0.6465210318565369,
-0.331117182970047,
0.2461051642894745,
0.2019273340702057,
0.1493523269891739,
0.05313331261277199,
0.5736779570579529,
0.30058929324150085,
-1.046194314956665,
-0.39361482858657837,
0.16308560967445374,
-1.095097303390503,
-0.31776076555252075,
0.9524202346801758,
0.027874628081917763,
-0.42048031091690063,
-0.37700048089027405,
0.08929720520973206,
0.03899603337049484,
-0.6911394596099854,
0.2905583381652832,
0.5241897106170654,
-0.4387049078941345,
-0.09352473169565201,
-0.9301040768623352,
0.4077191650867462,
0.5050837993621826,
-1.0906161069869995,
0.5594185590744019,
0.81569504737854,
0.5303412079811096,
0.11150849610567093,
0.48533526062965393,
-0.17816048860549927,
0.5188501477241516,
0.17732352018356323,
-0.15240484476089478,
-0.07893308997154236,
-0.6758841276168823,
-0.091973215341568,
0.06111070141196251,
-0.19067233800888062,
-0.2774948179721832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02124v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02124v1
|
TIPAA-SSL: Text Independent Phone-to-Audio Alignment based on Self-Supervised Learning and Knowledge Transfer
| 2024-05-03T14:25:21 | 2024-05-03T14:25:21 |
Noé Tits, Prernna Bhatnagar, Thierry Dutoit
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we present a novel approach for text independent
phone-to-audio alignment based on phoneme recognition, representation learning
and knowledge transfer. Our method leverages a self-supervised model (wav2vec2)
fine-tuned for phoneme recognition using a Connectionist Temporal
Classification (CTC) loss, a dimension reduction model and a frame-level
phoneme classifier trained thanks to forced-alignment labels (using Montreal
Forced Aligner) to produce multi-lingual phonetic representations, thus
requiring minimal additional training. We evaluate our model using synthetic
native data from the TIMIT dataset and the SCRIBE dataset for American and
British English, respectively. Our proposed model outperforms the
state-of-the-art (charsiu) in statistical metrics and has applications in
language learning and speech processing systems. We leave experiments on other
languages for future work but the design of the system makes it easily
adaptable to other languages.
|
[
0.04569422826170921,
-0.27951085567474365,
0.24521653354167938,
-0.002395481802523136,
-0.1929554045200348,
-0.02181403525173664,
-0.23086516559123993,
-0.4648537337779999,
0.49664437770843506,
0.41160956025123596,
-0.5327955484390259,
-0.5848479270935059,
-0.3713042736053467,
0.06068171188235283,
-0.49254998564720154,
0.6233505010604858,
0.2102450430393219,
0.13144664466381073,
0.06828206032514572,
-0.36719071865081787,
-0.7699374556541443,
-0.33659598231315613,
-0.6274847388267517,
-0.12116370350122452,
0.1415226310491562,
0.6913628578186035,
0.4563640058040619,
0.8611039519309998,
0.472750723361969,
0.1145796924829483,
0.2092810571193695,
0.040445808321237564,
-0.02222362533211708,
-0.1853000819683075,
-0.021394729614257812,
-0.5323163866996765,
-0.6066418886184692,
0.04972284287214279,
0.45741111040115356,
0.4543204605579376,
-0.17035333812236786,
0.37609922885894775,
0.0014904432464390993,
0.5665830969810486,
-0.36698371171951294,
0.024743130430579185,
-0.7925021648406982,
-0.12902355194091797,
-0.2893678545951843,
-0.24094949662685394,
-0.5356946587562561,
-0.5763327479362488,
0.08536993712186813,
-0.5952637791633606,
-0.02212703414261341,
-0.11335910111665726,
0.5357290506362915,
0.5218344330787659,
-0.6886008381843567,
-0.5266523361206055,
-0.7390103340148926,
0.7090416550636292,
-0.6472488045692444,
0.6775240898132324,
0.47990870475769043,
0.3935900330543518,
0.2258174866437912,
-0.4024796783924103,
-0.4003280699253082,
0.24008360505104065,
0.25850793719291687,
0.3562038838863373,
0.13842327892780304,
-0.3744882643222809,
-0.42842617630958557,
0.14409108459949493,
-0.5822945237159729,
0.2267978936433792,
-0.48256194591522217,
-0.4865649938583374,
0.7430686950683594,
-0.32921579480171204,
0.6904701590538025,
-0.04272060841321945,
-0.7064481973648071,
0.17903612554073334,
-0.7025493383407593,
0.31839519739151,
0.31415149569511414,
0.761202871799469,
-0.4555233418941498,
0.34134039282798767,
0.28221967816352844,
0.5225218534469604,
0.41416701674461365,
-0.23519156873226166,
0.2626025974750519,
-0.3406915068626404,
0.02495194785296917,
0.8787343502044678,
1.1606112718582153,
0.18675576150417328,
0.3610529899597168,
-0.14196594059467316,
0.0922459289431572,
-0.04757510870695114,
0.1017996296286583,
-0.5713229179382324,
-0.2958439290523529,
0.2504013478755951,
-0.39662155508995056,
-0.3749208450317383,
-0.12138014286756516,
-0.22345255315303802,
-0.003922165371477604,
-0.5101242661476135,
0.5194684863090515,
-0.5848586559295654,
-0.38539260625839233,
-0.05616985261440277,
0.2702743709087372,
0.13332875072956085,
0.18030840158462524,
-1.1371811628341675,
0.3139813244342804,
0.13865968585014343,
0.8439474105834961,
-0.4474649727344513,
-0.1564798206090927,
-0.4733673930168152,
0.4082457721233368,
-0.7021591663360596,
0.5061071515083313,
-0.20572084188461304,
-0.3256625533103943,
-0.03936440125107765,
-0.12044189125299454,
-0.21946220099925995,
-0.3185044825077057,
0.778411865234375,
-0.4202222526073456,
0.5497775077819824,
0.06153755262494087,
-0.7206783294677734,
-0.09561119228601456,
-0.46892550587654114,
-0.6607846617698669,
1.0865544080734253,
-0.12874583899974823,
-0.8325929045677185,
0.13789203763008118,
-0.5067915320396423,
-0.5120811462402344,
-0.009338450618088245,
-0.27968961000442505,
-0.34973037242889404,
-0.2751619219779968,
0.3222994804382324,
0.36891481280326843,
-0.3255578875541687,
0.18629483878612518,
-0.11825545132160187,
-0.3601098954677582,
0.23323924839496613,
-0.2902296483516693,
1.1823333501815796,
0.36484500765800476,
-0.23681338131427765,
-0.05220638960599899,
-1.2591112852096558,
0.24925407767295837,
-0.07090069353580475,
-0.149558424949646,
-0.5278822779655457,
-0.16149859130382538,
0.1640627384185791,
0.3340255320072174,
0.6910861730575562,
-0.7126245498657227,
0.12970668077468872,
-0.15372054278850555,
0.5081047415733337,
0.36307260394096375,
-0.2445317655801773,
0.8594952821731567,
0.03825489804148674,
0.08290455490350723,
-0.032223913818597794,
0.05991838127374649,
-0.07870811223983765,
-0.07856519520282745,
-0.444675475358963,
-0.2652515172958374,
0.7423415780067444,
1.0340012311935425,
-0.38154685497283936,
0.54208904504776,
-0.41295483708381653,
-0.3992839455604553,
-0.8862044811248779,
0.23455394804477692,
0.21059909462928772,
0.6951068639755249,
0.5297101140022278,
-0.2698120176792145,
-0.4377252161502838,
-0.882514238357544,
-0.004868656396865845,
-0.4417189061641693,
-0.07582174986600876,
0.014332093298435211,
-0.29028454422950745,
0.05974462255835533,
1.1332627534866333,
0.05586673691868782,
-0.748245358467102,
0.12021137773990631,
0.024130281060934067,
0.18309633433818817,
0.7113672494888306,
0.5528556704521179,
-0.6415529847145081,
-0.2668570876121521,
0.14801648259162903,
-0.8091782927513123,
-0.32135510444641113,
-0.2891460955142975,
0.09650567173957825,
0.014332612045109272,
0.7450171113014221,
-0.28973647952079773,
0.17002010345458984,
0.5990231037139893,
-0.1514829397201538,
0.39340245723724365,
-0.08741258829832077,
0.06779221445322037,
-1.3899097442626953,
-0.05413905531167984,
0.03812861442565918,
-0.4544581472873688,
-0.8114719986915588,
-0.5399136543273926,
0.5600380897521973,
-0.21987338364124298,
-0.4688010513782501,
0.39140233397483826,
-0.5011030435562134,
-0.13183893263339996,
-0.3973800539970398,
0.22301046550273895,
-0.2078505903482437,
0.48552700877189636,
0.2903747856616974,
1.0385034084320068,
0.6608515381813049,
-0.6415041089057922,
0.15530984103679657,
0.5526161789894104,
-0.048791058361530304,
0.673305869102478,
-0.4726990759372711,
0.6037120223045349,
0.4700401723384857,
0.04076942056417465,
-0.8845180869102478,
0.08018898963928223,
0.07469300925731659,
-0.7643292546272278,
0.39201292395591736,
-0.44258031249046326,
-0.03867827355861664,
0.10274991393089294,
0.07826273888349533,
0.6859690546989441,
0.3623477518558502,
-0.7117199301719666,
0.755848228931427,
0.5388725399971008,
-0.5549130439758301,
-0.5329959988594055,
-0.7481717467308044,
0.14713729918003082,
-0.28927597403526306,
-0.7252837419509888,
0.4639603793621063,
0.2176440805196762,
0.03820914030075073,
-0.30519720911979675,
-0.2912560999393463,
-0.5088157057762146,
-0.26059380173683167,
0.15545447170734406,
0.29685044288635254,
-0.2993347942829132,
0.35099461674690247,
0.19153562188148499,
-0.09197428822517395,
0.06298790872097015,
-0.5379239320755005,
0.1882270723581314,
0.048868853598833084,
-0.1981332153081894,
-1.0930383205413818,
0.516609251499176,
0.5223062634468079,
-0.5637851357460022,
-0.03424156829714775,
0.5372771620750427,
-0.24884913861751556,
-0.1409239023923874,
-0.5439286828041077,
0.061109282076358795,
-0.4492902457714081,
0.09944429248571396,
-0.4948540925979614,
-0.5683093070983887,
0.47746074199676514,
-0.06412787735462189,
0.17703495919704437,
0.41198858618736267,
0.36427953839302063,
-0.41857340931892395,
0.6694203615188599,
0.7267290353775024,
-0.23209284245967865,
0.46599745750427246,
0.009747534990310669,
0.04374828189611435,
-0.4968337416648865,
-0.10877542197704315,
-0.37841907143592834,
0.11685294657945633,
-0.5613812208175659,
-0.17627878487110138,
0.014091047458350658,
0.044624656438827515,
-0.06616701930761337,
0.7509086728096008,
-0.43487998843193054,
0.05845196917653084,
0.4277978241443634,
0.06937035918235779,
0.21875622868537903,
0.005285586230456829,
-0.1768476814031601,
0.002725516213104129,
-0.533918559551239,
-0.5549983382225037,
1.118282437324524,
0.5026825070381165,
0.6711681485176086,
0.2835177183151245,
0.9954439401626587,
0.5021666288375854,
-0.5140212178230286,
-0.9320394992828369,
0.41500401496887207,
-0.2473592609167099,
-0.32965707778930664,
-0.434840589761734,
-0.31198620796203613,
-0.7866393327713013,
-0.11445662379264832,
-0.09435483068227768,
-0.7454949021339417,
0.31730854511260986,
-0.01788787543773651,
-0.3810035288333893,
0.08888155221939087,
-0.8480468988418579,
0.45291489362716675,
-0.35620731115341187,
-0.08886808156967163,
-0.1620527058839798,
-0.7470884919166565,
0.10170726478099823,
-0.257548063993454,
0.42923566699028015,
-0.17441391944885254,
0.05065680295228958,
1.0969034433364868,
-0.4293058514595032,
0.8894854187965393,
-0.2591131329536438,
-0.49970436096191406,
0.685595691204071,
0.17526142299175262,
0.2175193578004837,
-0.18342651426792145,
0.08532258123159409,
0.3438441753387451,
0.4377363324165344,
-0.31329214572906494,
-0.4496873915195465,
0.507806122303009,
-0.8812589049339294,
-0.3389339745044708,
-0.025036485865712166,
-0.6400532722473145,
-0.43637165427207947,
0.28827863931655884,
0.21995802223682404,
0.6526653170585632,
-0.11884721368551254,
-0.023738140240311623,
0.5416187047958374,
0.19818216562271118,
0.7104163765907288,
0.48001936078071594,
-0.21115222573280334,
-0.629065752029419,
1.0131776332855225,
0.23640793561935425,
0.11296101659536362,
0.26555949449539185,
0.2940550446510315,
-0.6561374664306641,
-0.6629728078842163,
-0.6441525816917419,
0.20898179709911346,
-0.5890102386474609,
0.031559113413095474,
-0.3096117079257965,
-0.29088571667671204,
-0.615646481513977,
0.16913451254367828,
-0.8031024932861328,
-0.7241243720054626,
-0.4732479155063629,
0.13643436133861542,
0.34407123923301697,
0.41143351793289185,
-0.06101071834564209,
0.5596349835395813,
-0.8968653082847595,
0.27492088079452515,
0.3861018419265747,
0.17033013701438904,
-0.4687204957008362,
-0.997131884098053,
-0.26316359639167786,
-0.06288949400186539,
0.03156246244907379,
-1.0370361804962158,
0.10018795728683472,
0.27174466848373413,
0.31661397218704224,
0.4534008204936981,
0.29209646582603455,
0.44381260871887207,
-0.5733687281608582,
0.5869341492652893,
0.6727010607719421,
-1.1120349168777466,
0.6636384129524231,
-0.507024347782135,
0.11431379616260529,
0.5665535926818848,
0.16512800753116608,
-0.48769888281822205,
-0.0633608028292656,
-0.5865817666053772,
-0.5275110602378845,
0.3890799582004547,
0.21845529973506927,
-0.07823289930820465,
0.2767634689807892,
0.3171018362045288,
0.2945181131362915,
-0.3819953501224518,
-0.6490719318389893,
-0.28840264678001404,
-0.33614858984947205,
-0.7692482471466064,
0.44737449288368225,
-0.11245118826627731,
0.03905228525400162,
-0.05044994503259659,
0.7984740138053894,
-0.3469334840774536,
0.21600793302059174,
0.4458416700363159,
-0.39334583282470703,
0.22166918218135834,
0.3836055397987366,
0.3340447247028351,
0.46782562136650085,
-0.09367404878139496,
-0.038966838270425797,
0.1722434014081955,
-0.4708315134048462,
0.3863012492656708,
0.13982239365577698,
-0.03919576480984688,
0.07510848343372345,
0.3177449405193329,
0.610882580280304,
0.08597996830940247,
-0.06492213904857635,
0.6051483154296875,
-0.12935198843479156,
-0.26721009612083435,
-0.6938088536262512,
-0.16069504618644714,
0.36074069142341614,
0.017924614250659943,
0.7261401414871216,
0.13776515424251556,
0.1438743770122528,
-0.18655750155448914,
0.5030612945556641,
0.17043426632881165,
-0.669620156288147,
-0.3679259717464447,
0.8155645132064819,
0.5361751914024353,
-0.49407699704170227,
0.12008266150951385,
0.18224500119686127,
0.011678474023938179,
0.4132712781429291,
0.6092870235443115,
0.6758003234863281,
-0.8169239163398743,
0.11335010081529617,
0.37908288836479187,
0.054085683077573776,
0.017309853807091713,
0.2843693494796753,
-0.17550969123840332,
-0.6974081993103027,
-0.4989991784095764,
-0.23192504048347473,
-0.3033553957939148,
0.006268955301493406,
-0.8997772932052612,
0.5121607184410095,
-0.2975485324859619,
-0.18517550826072693,
0.08738424628973007,
-0.2144506722688675,
-0.6337057948112488,
0.4718899428844452,
0.23755961656570435,
0.907470703125,
-0.9097287058830261,
1.276432991027832,
0.4189923405647278,
-0.17523442208766937,
-1.0593208074569702,
-0.08614206314086914,
0.14769071340560913,
-0.8517062664031982,
0.6832467913627625,
0.09191814064979553,
-0.5576603412628174,
0.10959439724683762,
-0.21213914453983307,
-1.1638737916946411,
0.996985912322998,
0.2800000011920929,
-0.9589877128601074,
-0.01911323331296444,
0.2004825323820114,
0.33713164925575256,
-0.5110776424407959,
0.1956792026758194,
0.5332722067832947,
0.03917828947305679,
0.03959045186638832,
-1.263861060142517,
-0.11511978507041931,
-0.17229238152503967,
-0.24932369589805603,
0.0919056311249733,
-0.7679829597473145,
0.1784554272890091,
-0.1813141256570816,
-0.42242705821990967,
-0.13152630627155304,
1.0227388143539429,
-0.14071109890937805,
0.15372233092784882,
0.6378016471862793,
0.30508264899253845,
0.8098906874656677,
0.14685587584972382,
0.3209068477153778,
-0.4935102164745331,
0.08446641266345978,
1.3655812740325928,
-0.23522281646728516,
0.9940992593765259,
0.4389539659023285,
-0.27164503931999207,
0.3677034378051758,
0.5508716702461243,
0.16733421385288239,
0.5944606065750122,
-0.2440323531627655,
-0.16180261969566345,
-0.26069119572639465,
-0.09229016304016113,
-0.1249636560678482,
1.0574623346328735,
0.06120067834854126,
-0.030115580186247826,
0.05153414607048035,
-0.08039627224206924,
-0.23669187724590302,
0.12474651634693146,
-0.25190797448158264,
0.9032406806945801,
0.1688641607761383,
-0.30030593276023865,
0.7332784533500671,
-0.35721534490585327,
0.8447704315185547,
-0.5380322933197021,
0.17934490740299225,
-0.08980642259120941,
-0.14413855969905853,
-0.3724297881126404,
-0.5288427472114563,
0.30802229046821594,
-0.1114836186170578,
-0.2855372726917267,
-0.08831010013818741,
0.7668938040733337,
-0.8884488344192505,
-0.4420727491378784,
0.3967148959636688,
0.5787068605422974,
0.35165131092071533,
0.29909273982048035,
-0.692294180393219,
-0.2388940155506134,
0.22529789805412292,
0.2926141023635864,
0.22781683504581451,
0.3791521191596985,
-0.17701254785060883,
0.5509399771690369,
0.6432196497917175,
0.11510517448186874,
0.06762991100549698,
0.40000227093696594,
0.04505645111203194,
-0.7324681878089905,
-0.9232086539268494,
-0.545979380607605,
0.13628451526165009,
0.07920996844768524,
-0.13216593861579895,
0.4668835997581482,
0.6053937077522278,
0.5417075157165527,
0.08453816920518875,
0.9555140137672424,
0.28366029262542725,
0.8159244656562805,
-0.667670488357544,
0.7576459646224976,
-0.36566516757011414,
0.1607397347688675,
-0.06659063696861267,
-0.5768170952796936,
0.08598663657903671,
0.3625359833240509,
-0.10504848510026932,
-0.36279213428497314,
0.5285478830337524,
0.5738841891288757,
-0.13866370916366577,
0.31997063755989075,
0.28535518050193787,
-0.26356399059295654,
0.1886415332555771,
0.47877585887908936,
0.5136868357658386,
-0.694296658039093,
0.910056471824646,
-0.24792584776878357,
-0.22841326892375946,
0.12367281317710876,
-0.7333900332450867,
-0.8236913084983826,
-0.9730328917503357,
-0.6149399280548096,
-0.04017253220081329,
-0.040321964770555496,
0.9349179267883301,
0.7777493000030518,
-0.7799481749534607,
-0.3912494480609894,
0.23597316443920135,
-0.16042304039001465,
-0.3767715096473694,
-0.2154901623725891,
0.9472900629043579,
-0.31427302956581116,
-0.5987253189086914,
0.7869505882263184,
0.11855701357126236,
0.41037827730178833,
0.22277849912643433,
0.06069742515683174,
-0.062385573983192444,
-0.055696845054626465,
0.3156835436820984,
0.4305115342140198,
-0.7356299161911011,
-0.2873326539993286,
-0.11358306556940079,
-0.2365202158689499,
0.5442832112312317,
0.7119064927101135,
-0.6513962149620056,
0.40494173765182495,
0.22774598002433777,
0.8371834754943848,
0.27145352959632874,
0.01206536777317524,
0.587135374546051,
-0.879794180393219,
0.07308053225278854,
0.04091120511293411,
0.38445547223091125,
0.499772846698761,
-0.5526989698410034,
0.33096009492874146,
-0.07502742856740952,
-0.44938841462135315,
-0.3699720799922943,
0.187637597322464,
-1.4313080310821533,
-0.12264888733625412,
1.0887376070022583,
-0.049572937190532684,
-0.17032693326473236,
-0.20484204590320587,
-0.2549838423728943,
0.642370343208313,
-0.5155134797096252,
0.5954350233078003,
0.6050930619239807,
-0.0686831921339035,
-0.42977374792099,
-0.376642644405365,
0.4152025878429413,
0.5798720717430115,
-0.5919367671012878,
0.25578975677490234,
0.3669102191925049,
0.7078619599342346,
0.36099550127983093,
0.726831316947937,
-0.3394213020801544,
0.45093709230422974,
-0.24014930427074432,
0.4888076186180115,
-0.25792109966278076,
-0.2366030216217041,
-0.2900746166706085,
0.040684279054403305,
-0.15596754848957062,
-0.7729437947273254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02105v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02105v1
|
Evaluating Large Language Models for Structured Science Summarization in the Open Research Knowledge Graph
| 2024-05-03T14:03:04 | 2024-05-03T14:03:04 |
Vladyslav Nechakhin, Jennifer D'Souza, Steffen Eger
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT
|
Structured science summaries or research contributions using properties or
dimensions beyond traditional keywords enhances science findability. Current
methods, such as those used by the Open Research Knowledge Graph (ORKG),
involve manually curating properties to describe research papers' contributions
in a structured manner, but this is labor-intensive and inconsistent between
the domain expert human curators. We propose using Large Language Models (LLMs)
to automatically suggest these properties. However, it's essential to assess
the readiness of LLMs like GPT-3.5, Llama 2, and Mistral for this task before
application. Our study performs a comprehensive comparative analysis between
ORKG's manually curated properties and those generated by the aforementioned
state-of-the-art LLMs. We evaluate LLM performance through four unique
perspectives: semantic alignment and deviation with ORKG properties,
fine-grained properties mapping accuracy, SciNCL embeddings-based cosine
similarity, and expert surveys comparing manual annotations with LLM outputs.
These evaluations occur within a multidisciplinary science setting. Overall,
LLMs show potential as recommendation systems for structuring science, but
further finetuning is recommended to improve their alignment with scientific
tasks and mimicry of human expertise.
|
[
-0.14462780952453613,
-0.5686433911323547,
0.6589121222496033,
0.20602795481681824,
-0.2157706469297409,
0.1488460898399353,
-0.45680785179138184,
-0.5502168536186218,
0.40847545862197876,
0.38975897431373596,
0.05158045142889023,
-0.8129499554634094,
-0.7315506935119629,
0.2988259494304657,
-0.41900041699409485,
1.0460875034332275,
-0.2750299274921417,
-0.006789722945541143,
-0.5347592234611511,
-0.07385287433862686,
-0.026258213445544243,
-0.2171926647424698,
-0.2954232394695282,
-0.6657071113586426,
0.5727917551994324,
0.05255758762359619,
0.8076132535934448,
0.8494126200675964,
0.7014150023460388,
0.34606850147247314,
-0.3761026859283447,
0.20741868019104004,
-0.5733917951583862,
0.1797356754541397,
-0.22035101056098938,
-0.18988455832004547,
-0.9509323239326477,
-0.05186232924461365,
0.5724848508834839,
0.8876155018806458,
0.09042365103960037,
0.22927814722061157,
0.26869919896125793,
0.4168758988380432,
-0.3862805664539337,
0.7251381278038025,
-0.3161606192588806,
0.09590531140565872,
-0.16531598567962646,
-0.2691170573234558,
-0.15631142258644104,
-0.3267689645290375,
0.26455456018447876,
-0.7688049077987671,
0.25060027837753296,
0.20132313668727875,
0.42403560876846313,
0.060751352459192276,
-0.25285932421684265,
-0.30641013383865356,
-0.6227450370788574,
0.5463093519210815,
-0.8790998458862305,
0.4026351571083069,
0.27570879459381104,
0.07593385875225067,
-0.4736037254333496,
-0.7555490732192993,
-0.2769273519515991,
-0.5617353916168213,
-0.24913820624351501,
0.2170226126909256,
0.08015509694814682,
0.07725798338651657,
0.109982930123806,
0.38199329376220703,
-0.6504230499267578,
0.1773492991924286,
-0.4678836464881897,
-0.28404515981674194,
0.6008722186088562,
0.25467750430107117,
-0.10384106636047363,
-0.16451121866703033,
-0.03959330543875694,
-0.1709394007921219,
-0.5599391460418701,
0.00026970141334459186,
0.30205532908439636,
0.5794510841369629,
0.10596653819084167,
1.0709161758422852,
-0.44564568996429443,
0.5963179469108582,
-0.18773195147514343,
-0.3878340423107147,
0.15646754205226898,
-0.8409102559089661,
-0.004775878973305225,
0.029079150408506393,
0.9988241195678711,
0.29816657304763794,
0.1564759463071823,
-0.24607780575752258,
0.005198459140956402,
-0.2944629490375519,
0.046694569289684296,
-0.8000012040138245,
-0.3616454601287842,
0.1462136209011078,
-0.49110570549964905,
-0.3082695007324219,
0.06386619806289673,
-0.3995732367038727,
-0.6064339876174927,
-0.30165109038352966,
0.14373953640460968,
-0.30153247714042664,
-0.27600425481796265,
0.17503057420253754,
-0.15585431456565857,
-0.3098200261592865,
0.4678586423397064,
-0.5807428359985352,
0.16188791394233704,
0.7239707112312317,
1.105328917503357,
-0.24518705904483795,
-0.32601994276046753,
0.07973835617303848,
0.2387169450521469,
-0.19071082770824432,
0.8529177308082581,
-0.44867485761642456,
-0.5970284342765808,
-0.240989550948143,
-0.1223260760307312,
0.20432111620903015,
-0.2346712052822113,
0.41470077633857727,
-0.6063043475151062,
0.0849781185388565,
-0.3679177761077881,
-0.4574112892150879,
-0.09605088829994202,
0.11453629285097122,
-0.5742098093032837,
0.9910106658935547,
0.2881816327571869,
-0.8467264175415039,
0.6157230138778687,
-0.884685218334198,
-0.37291666865348816,
0.21120955049991608,
0.04285190999507904,
-0.296573281288147,
-0.06470928341150284,
0.07950839400291443,
0.5419248342514038,
-0.09244287759065628,
0.4836409389972687,
-0.5312886834144592,
-0.1387650966644287,
0.13119614124298096,
0.1618334800004959,
0.4669705331325531,
0.10320153087377548,
0.21438701450824738,
0.45298388600349426,
-0.7079561948776245,
-0.21515531837940216,
0.010024803690612316,
-0.46655431389808655,
-0.4462234377861023,
0.31859061121940613,
-0.021815553307533264,
-0.014640695415437222,
0.3877798318862915,
-0.5687809586524963,
0.42073118686676025,
-0.3745069205760956,
0.6517928838729858,
0.5321508049964905,
-0.2104550451040268,
0.48058098554611206,
-0.16690519452095032,
0.44001683592796326,
-0.2313920110464096,
-0.09054851531982422,
-0.09948830306529999,
-0.3880648612976074,
-0.28177618980407715,
-0.36374497413635254,
0.3674714267253876,
0.17522895336151123,
-0.41879063844680786,
0.5114107131958008,
-0.5610060691833496,
-0.6577222347259521,
-0.34398889541625977,
0.11860934644937515,
0.3272867202758789,
0.6863475441932678,
0.36909568309783936,
-0.3953099548816681,
-0.4517498314380646,
-0.8220791220664978,
-0.1539791226387024,
-0.12393311411142349,
-0.18401874601840973,
0.31061139702796936,
0.7551364302635193,
0.05297454819083214,
1.135777235031128,
-0.6134185194969177,
-0.14922209084033966,
0.030320007354021072,
0.11832493543624878,
0.18796227872371674,
-0.06563638150691986,
0.36472436785697937,
-0.2559274733066559,
-0.27621912956237793,
0.20485910773277283,
-0.8151082992553711,
-0.2577507197856903,
0.8145950436592102,
0.14058806002140045,
0.14215262234210968,
0.3914530873298645,
-0.6556681394577026,
0.3072725534439087,
0.3575558662414551,
-0.38771092891693115,
0.6703974604606628,
-0.1738620549440384,
0.31927797198295593,
-0.793185293674469,
0.4350737929344177,
0.012780296616256237,
-0.2238396257162094,
-0.33215370774269104,
0.05115819349884987,
-0.019202841445803642,
-0.04533601924777031,
-0.2601383328437805,
0.5963826775550842,
-0.42095300555229187,
-0.311290979385376,
-0.25355401635169983,
0.3311462998390198,
0.0840136930346489,
0.07520098984241486,
0.20799414813518524,
0.6019317507743835,
0.3136819899082184,
-0.49128657579421997,
0.3766953647136688,
0.32411977648735046,
-0.5402652621269226,
0.22855016589164734,
-0.8685531616210938,
0.004083330277353525,
-0.04967260733246803,
0.5481846928596497,
-0.9606136083602905,
-0.4725552499294281,
0.026331746950745583,
-0.32590851187705994,
0.19038446247577667,
-0.06049828231334686,
-0.8049950003623962,
-0.35669559240341187,
-0.43993157148361206,
0.3821205794811249,
0.12172030657529831,
-0.11600382626056671,
0.5047087073326111,
0.2619257867336273,
-0.5019326210021973,
-0.39970239996910095,
-0.309895396232605,
0.07966923713684082,
-0.10637327283620834,
-0.8581074476242065,
0.2682715058326721,
0.14649450778961182,
-0.3073231875896454,
0.2597680389881134,
-0.16757965087890625,
0.38510647416114807,
0.05612386390566826,
0.2482060194015503,
0.21429167687892914,
-0.3325001299381256,
0.07810033112764359,
-0.1568531095981598,
0.08437422662973404,
0.16288869082927704,
-0.4086882770061493,
0.3957310616970062,
-0.09632964432239532,
-0.22016097605228424,
0.2429201751947403,
-0.013652822934091091,
0.6354689598083496,
-0.16617564857006073,
0.6904284954071045,
0.44995465874671936,
-0.10503112524747849,
0.04185304045677185,
-0.3493450880050659,
-0.2368716150522232,
-0.3804457187652588,
0.563912034034729,
-0.005721316207200289,
-1.1325955390930176,
0.7355163097381592,
0.15808050334453583,
0.2683725953102112,
0.5149320960044861,
0.5967091917991638,
-0.20368459820747375,
0.8474200963973999,
0.5774280428886414,
-0.14959552884101868,
0.18938753008842468,
-0.08069031685590744,
0.4323751628398895,
-0.7349025011062622,
-0.4836004078388214,
-0.7725422978401184,
-0.08110995590686798,
-0.33604082465171814,
-0.31504306197166443,
0.8409989476203918,
0.0048345220275223255,
-0.08076955378055573,
0.24241025745868683,
-0.5297572612762451,
0.28320595622062683,
0.260754257440567,
-0.03698470816016197,
0.6098164319992065,
0.12260672450065613,
0.06039230525493622,
0.2755737006664276,
-0.7066239714622498,
-0.7152786254882812,
1.1225417852401733,
0.3308488726615906,
0.8019399046897888,
-0.22173002362251282,
0.31806936860084534,
0.2079564481973648,
0.3497137427330017,
-0.7771099209785461,
0.6272432804107666,
-0.056360598653554916,
-0.18414971232414246,
-0.6894370913505554,
-0.3540155291557312,
-0.9868998527526855,
0.2966419756412506,
-0.19340431690216064,
-0.4522743225097656,
-0.21036836504936218,
0.1353946328163147,
-0.30185768008232117,
0.24652636051177979,
-0.36477577686309814,
0.3739190399646759,
-0.024784056469798088,
-0.12287886440753937,
-0.24186964333057404,
-0.5271813273429871,
0.5219589471817017,
-0.15309664607048035,
0.3675827980041504,
-0.14361408352851868,
-0.10074787586927414,
0.8977063298225403,
-0.38634631037712097,
0.5753985643386841,
0.014354534447193146,
-0.22080980241298676,
0.034312378615140915,
0.15641967952251434,
0.3603455424308777,
-0.033399589359760284,
-0.20146305859088898,
0.3317098021507263,
0.18493705987930298,
-0.16850221157073975,
-0.5232501029968262,
0.8151991963386536,
-0.7474001049995422,
-0.5855734348297119,
-0.34784120321273804,
-0.8496712446212769,
-0.14441028237342834,
0.2758365273475647,
0.025777434930205345,
0.26569581031799316,
-0.18938222527503967,
0.25314635038375854,
0.5966963171958923,
-0.10923546552658081,
0.19896042346954346,
0.7118547558784485,
-0.46869808435440063,
-0.2859495282173157,
0.6792765855789185,
0.4001914858818054,
0.07429705560207367,
0.19255061447620392,
0.4535174071788788,
-0.24548394978046417,
-0.8334143757820129,
-0.11012782901525497,
0.3212774395942688,
-0.494950532913208,
-0.3577747642993927,
-0.9063166975975037,
-0.21089822053909302,
-0.8448817133903503,
-0.06684782356023788,
-0.01936931721866131,
-0.6871513724327087,
-0.25255540013313293,
-0.20997488498687744,
0.6871989369392395,
0.8386732339859009,
0.19712112843990326,
-0.06392376124858856,
-0.5582243204116821,
0.17174513638019562,
-0.08547268807888031,
0.5469527840614319,
-0.0016439460450783372,
-0.6205355525016785,
-0.4742627441883087,
-0.08875086158514023,
-0.18915535509586334,
-0.5352240204811096,
0.23807679116725922,
0.06595762819051743,
0.3840596377849579,
0.25334087014198303,
-0.1968267410993576,
0.4571801722049713,
-0.3969835937023163,
0.7662837505340576,
-0.1587504744529724,
-0.48505470156669617,
0.43053749203681946,
-0.7372260093688965,
0.30465415120124817,
0.418173611164093,
0.30246037244796753,
-0.1337522566318512,
-0.552459716796875,
-0.29747846722602844,
-0.96458899974823,
0.5962119698524475,
-0.00731916818767786,
-0.21415415406227112,
0.16993343830108643,
0.24329248070716858,
0.20668166875839233,
0.35545283555984497,
-0.47847482562065125,
0.09892584383487701,
-0.28244727849960327,
0.07672116160392761,
-0.07417061924934387,
-0.19754396378993988,
-0.3303411304950714,
-0.10838103294372559,
0.6516444087028503,
-0.14510968327522278,
-0.06430116295814514,
0.14828474819660187,
-0.0022724145092070103,
-0.13491374254226685,
0.28345614671707153,
0.6293177008628845,
0.9380861520767212,
-0.41442444920539856,
0.15491336584091187,
0.05478867515921593,
-0.4765907824039459,
-0.14803704619407654,
0.13009555637836456,
-0.24708278477191925,
-0.2103329598903656,
0.7244157791137695,
0.42522963881492615,
0.1910134255886078,
-0.47469738125801086,
0.23149043321609497,
0.2482345998287201,
-0.38661977648735046,
0.10280630737543106,
0.061107076704502106,
0.2244512289762497,
0.15746477246284485,
0.19093507528305054,
-0.11778488755226135,
0.21201494336128235,
-0.41755008697509766,
-0.3243694603443146,
0.44182753562927246,
-0.009349033236503601,
-0.4123694598674774,
0.24064095318317413,
-0.005235007964074612,
-0.07829685509204865,
0.48402050137519836,
0.01432150136679411,
-0.32999011874198914,
0.4781453013420105,
0.2609384059906006,
0.5353986024856567,
-0.11055048555135727,
0.019835537299513817,
0.25396180152893066,
0.2834963798522949,
-0.30262142419815063,
0.047744233161211014,
0.018352674320340157,
-0.5332136154174805,
-0.6134129166603088,
-0.7501807808876038,
-0.4422191381454468,
-0.013058347627520561,
-0.5070925354957581,
0.348320335149765,
-0.236210897564888,
-0.2645278573036194,
0.21029582619667053,
0.046497322618961334,
-0.6328702569007874,
-0.23247596621513367,
-0.2299608290195465,
0.9957004189491272,
-0.9857056140899658,
0.6032933592796326,
0.7648590207099915,
-0.24460650980472565,
-0.6996404528617859,
-0.6569610238075256,
-0.006839013658463955,
-0.46304163336753845,
0.588800847530365,
-0.38065585494041443,
-0.2399512082338333,
-0.30807968974113464,
-0.6023427844047546,
-1.107494592666626,
1.4374717473983765,
0.21580788493156433,
-0.3342985510826111,
-0.06760548055171967,
0.01619589887559414,
0.9799123406410217,
-0.24629800021648407,
0.4009653329849243,
0.47410041093826294,
0.722862958908081,
0.06507055461406708,
-1.2613422870635986,
0.08902081102132797,
-0.1862052083015442,
-0.11426402628421783,
0.26131415367126465,
-0.5746901035308838,
0.711409866809845,
-0.031814008951187134,
-0.08515989780426025,
-0.05716332048177719,
0.7666367888450623,
0.4865647852420807,
0.4188650846481323,
0.13943630456924438,
0.4422655403614044,
0.6354436874389648,
-0.038470763713121414,
1.0057365894317627,
-0.3370177447795868,
0.21929745376110077,
0.907956600189209,
-0.6078416705131531,
0.5359264612197876,
0.3569318354129791,
-0.45145612955093384,
0.40707752108573914,
0.4083678126335144,
-0.25600484013557434,
0.3714104890823364,
0.2841927409172058,
0.13642358779907227,
0.1970607042312622,
-0.417836993932724,
-0.4761468470096588,
0.3577768802642822,
0.37721148133277893,
-0.38633838295936584,
-0.37369781732559204,
-0.06822159886360168,
0.20203867554664612,
0.08267829567193985,
-0.33359813690185547,
0.6383720636367798,
0.07232927531003952,
-0.6761779189109802,
0.16851164400577545,
0.13125954568386078,
0.431802898645401,
-0.7823506593704224,
0.0068267760798335075,
-0.12074931710958481,
-0.2903037369251251,
-0.5373846888542175,
-1.0738664865493774,
0.21658223867416382,
-0.012630446814000607,
-0.3196337819099426,
-0.24419353902339935,
0.7884289622306824,
-0.4305812120437622,
-0.3986254036426544,
0.18838268518447876,
0.3624545633792877,
0.2660399079322815,
0.24404245615005493,
-0.23781965672969818,
-0.06129499897360802,
-0.45509931445121765,
-0.4955318570137024,
0.4694545269012451,
0.3467019498348236,
-0.3497006297111511,
0.6952860951423645,
0.5966911911964417,
0.4143553674221039,
-0.1675609052181244,
0.13219377398490906,
0.9852742552757263,
-0.3404529094696045,
-0.2366739958524704,
-0.6131948232650757,
0.1744929850101471,
0.08608333021402359,
-0.028633221983909607,
1.1044440269470215,
0.6794396042823792,
0.7175292372703552,
-0.054557979106903076,
0.8516868948936462,
-0.09594184160232544,
0.3825705051422119,
-0.49967557191848755,
0.7155349850654602,
-0.13346624374389648,
0.2042154222726822,
-0.36500102281570435,
-1.0860419273376465,
-0.3155408203601837,
0.34165436029434204,
-0.4155827462673187,
0.22813835740089417,
0.6527689099311829,
0.9395310878753662,
-0.18507778644561768,
0.04821169748902321,
0.06410373002290726,
0.4500170052051544,
0.3419329524040222,
0.1551830917596817,
0.7889262437820435,
0.2211696058511734,
0.33079051971435547,
0.04937900975346565,
-0.32420870661735535,
-0.2593865692615509,
-1.2373740673065186,
-1.0811151266098022,
-0.4007829427719116,
-0.25416386127471924,
-0.4585234224796295,
-0.013397609815001488,
0.811650276184082,
0.5301868319511414,
-0.6494665145874023,
-0.20926178991794586,
0.25295111536979675,
-0.014193044044077396,
-0.005514076445251703,
-0.2217499315738678,
0.75555020570755,
0.11543766409158707,
-0.21190491318702698,
0.5589759945869446,
0.5453992486000061,
-0.1991196870803833,
-0.6831153631210327,
0.1443159431219101,
0.1977105289697647,
-0.07529737800359726,
0.727300226688385,
0.20301766693592072,
-0.8074326515197754,
-0.28775110840797424,
0.09648985415697098,
-0.18979406356811523,
-0.12479981780052185,
0.9604878425598145,
-0.6025965809822083,
0.41765737533569336,
0.8922762870788574,
0.19766569137573242,
0.41907450556755066,
-0.03912130743265152,
0.3752298057079315,
-0.5632918477058411,
-0.2836012542247772,
0.237935870885849,
0.4458065629005432,
0.2655441462993622,
-0.22987543046474457,
0.569502055644989,
0.001422288129106164,
-0.8022159934043884,
-0.7516489624977112,
-0.1236434057354927,
-1.0586326122283936,
-0.1842096596956253,
1.2004365921020508,
-0.2504548132419586,
-0.027472907677292824,
-0.24457457661628723,
-0.1366937756538391,
0.18079058825969696,
-0.44876596331596375,
0.9027690291404724,
0.9020732045173645,
-0.2029799073934555,
0.20506107807159424,
-0.44715383648872375,
0.35779109597206116,
-0.003526752581819892,
-0.6378915309906006,
0.07998955994844437,
0.47075355052948,
0.3317407965660095,
0.35621944069862366,
0.5483837127685547,
-0.462843656539917,
0.02043645828962326,
-0.46199938654899597,
0.1927645057439804,
-0.7966738343238831,
-0.27810871601104736,
-0.22074739634990692,
0.3172788918018341,
0.17926214635372162,
0.6216962337493896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02079v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02079v1
|
Argumentative Large Language Models for Explainable and Contestable Decision-Making
| 2024-05-03T13:12:28 | 2024-05-03T13:12:28 |
Gabriel Freedman, Adam Dejl, Deniz Gorur, Xiang Yin, Antonio Rago, Francesca Toni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
The diversity of knowledge encoded in large language models (LLMs) and their
ability to apply this knowledge zero-shot in a range of settings makes them a
promising candidate for use in decision-making. However, they are currently
limited by their inability to reliably provide outputs which are explainable
and contestable. In this paper, we attempt to reconcile these strengths and
weaknesses by introducing a method for supplementing LLMs with argumentative
reasoning. Concretely, we introduce argumentative LLMs, a method utilising LLMs
to construct argumentation frameworks, which then serve as the basis for formal
reasoning in decision-making. The interpretable nature of these argumentation
frameworks and formal reasoning means that any decision made by the
supplemented LLM may be naturally explained to, and contested by, humans. We
demonstrate the effectiveness of argumentative LLMs experimentally in the
decision-making task of claim verification. We obtain results that are
competitive with, and in some cases surpass, comparable state-of-the-art
techniques.
|
[
-0.25012004375457764,
-0.628014862537384,
0.9674372673034668,
-0.01854103058576584,
-0.044866323471069336,
0.13668718934059143,
-0.5746705532073975,
-0.26760780811309814,
0.049894366413354874,
0.3145813047885895,
-0.3906651437282562,
-0.23216161131858826,
-0.4335414171218872,
0.30628132820129395,
-0.14671722054481506,
0.698198676109314,
-0.37625107169151306,
-0.0424831323325634,
-0.48191744089126587,
-0.2054062783718109,
-0.5408281683921814,
-0.5767236948013306,
-0.7524756789207458,
-0.7126649022102356,
0.49760937690734863,
0.4213631749153137,
0.7752971053123474,
0.451598584651947,
0.16618362069129944,
0.39267581701278687,
-0.1700156182050705,
0.17945697903633118,
-0.2314770668745041,
0.11318705976009369,
-0.7274887561798096,
-0.7989713549613953,
-0.1901731640100479,
-0.2554508447647095,
0.6019662022590637,
0.6587793827056885,
-0.19931669533252716,
0.07144349813461304,
-0.3106130361557007,
0.488693505525589,
-0.5592231750488281,
0.13386544585227966,
-1.027798056602478,
0.15925972163677216,
-0.14060097932815552,
-0.3660723567008972,
-0.47584009170532227,
-0.2868475914001465,
0.14159102737903595,
-0.24491329491138458,
0.015764102339744568,
0.11003702878952026,
0.9793781638145447,
-0.06233654171228409,
-0.3753681480884552,
-0.507452666759491,
-0.808123767375946,
0.7119327187538147,
-0.8723557591438293,
0.21419283747673035,
0.2572346329689026,
0.4066713750362396,
-0.19723226130008698,
-0.5211277008056641,
-0.6857079267501831,
-0.46140530705451965,
-0.00608439464122057,
0.01659834012389183,
-0.33262184262275696,
0.1317754089832306,
0.25637736916542053,
0.3097982704639435,
-0.3881983458995819,
0.46970340609550476,
-0.14565695822238922,
-0.3783634305000305,
0.7507516741752625,
0.05845686048269272,
0.3223205506801605,
-0.21302029490470886,
-0.29739633202552795,
0.15579332411289215,
-0.9114176034927368,
-0.10016047954559326,
0.41675472259521484,
0.2247229963541031,
0.16166427731513977,
0.7029102444648743,
-0.01301980298012495,
0.7062731385231018,
0.1595573127269745,
-0.14851363003253937,
-0.25628942251205444,
0.04581727460026741,
-0.4068438708782196,
0.23699475824832916,
0.6789259910583496,
0.14927639067173004,
0.16012169420719147,
-0.1312379390001297,
-0.31592732667922974,
0.10877083986997604,
0.04584941267967224,
-0.6388673186302185,
0.13398928940296173,
0.49171897768974304,
-0.5238502621650696,
-0.3598880469799042,
-0.2264767587184906,
-0.6053644418716431,
-0.4925605356693268,
-0.22980380058288574,
0.47701501846313477,
-0.12371080368757248,
-0.3205724060535431,
0.5935057997703552,
-0.17397044599056244,
0.27422231435775757,
0.35695359110832214,
-0.9921926259994507,
0.19600284099578857,
0.589222252368927,
0.6254187226295471,
0.0041563608683645725,
-0.046953022480010986,
-0.268905371427536,
0.2933996617794037,
-0.7738907337188721,
0.8524845242500305,
-0.5222642421722412,
-0.21537791192531586,
0.22418299317359924,
-0.020630938932299614,
0.1677379161119461,
-0.8440738916397095,
1.0992419719696045,
-0.5808660387992859,
0.20391465723514557,
-0.37312573194503784,
-0.6857160925865173,
-0.26247552037239075,
0.6792904734611511,
-0.5784465074539185,
0.5861074924468994,
-0.11310320347547531,
-0.5172348022460938,
0.4412294626235962,
-0.702577531337738,
-0.4092237055301666,
0.30221492052078247,
-0.26873451471328735,
-0.32132211327552795,
0.22510717809200287,
0.041232816874980927,
0.6376076936721802,
-0.5966259837150574,
0.5796463489532471,
-0.534911572933197,
0.13531900942325592,
0.45867764949798584,
-0.35884416103363037,
0.7140636444091797,
0.3268052637577057,
-0.3865872621536255,
0.13587623834609985,
-0.5831289887428284,
-0.14927658438682556,
0.5954067707061768,
-0.6069429516792297,
-0.16052989661693573,
0.36852896213531494,
-0.6182536482810974,
0.12681777775287628,
0.13640911877155304,
-0.433769166469574,
0.14115503430366516,
-0.40404367446899414,
0.6987152695655823,
0.8803353309631348,
-0.29808545112609863,
0.1692429780960083,
-0.29895246028900146,
0.5427338480949402,
-0.07313800603151321,
-0.27270644903182983,
-0.14354830980300903,
-0.1270654797554016,
-0.9275200963020325,
-0.05228953808546066,
0.4997027814388275,
0.46430838108062744,
-0.7158886194229126,
0.1776628941297531,
-0.311581015586853,
-0.1512639820575714,
-0.2341105192899704,
0.06727924942970276,
0.09570787847042084,
0.40998849272727966,
0.025339234620332718,
0.2625598907470703,
-0.9228402376174927,
-1.05192232131958,
-0.4550059735774994,
-0.4827103018760681,
-0.17859989404678345,
0.3985770642757416,
0.5842611789703369,
-0.0931570753455162,
0.9916436076164246,
-0.22949501872062683,
0.26969489455223083,
-0.5292379856109619,
0.05457957461476326,
0.22999440133571625,
0.19458365440368652,
0.316880464553833,
-0.6124733090400696,
0.05115008354187012,
0.18063253164291382,
-0.9112119078636169,
-0.3021969199180603,
-0.48618999123573303,
-0.009009492583572865,
0.1943609118461609,
0.3865199089050293,
-0.6842769384384155,
0.05218982696533203,
0.2875349223613739,
-0.33573487401008606,
0.9239685535430908,
-0.238625168800354,
-0.08101879805326462,
-0.7586133480072021,
-0.227854922413826,
0.03178625926375389,
-0.5834647417068481,
-0.48566749691963196,
0.3174091577529907,
-0.15456771850585938,
-0.18338151276111603,
-0.263355553150177,
0.6792935132980347,
-0.3601977229118347,
0.22453726828098297,
-0.31720054149627686,
0.1907586008310318,
0.16229119896888733,
0.07047276943922043,
0.20221294462680817,
0.36928021907806396,
0.5864384174346924,
-0.552357017993927,
0.48466894030570984,
0.021926620975136757,
-0.4656544327735901,
0.7174001932144165,
-0.8503588438034058,
-0.21973225474357605,
-0.2732877731323242,
0.42001578211784363,
-1.0099308490753174,
-0.3855822682380676,
0.030158523470163345,
-0.15729650855064392,
0.12199084460735321,
-0.23169857263565063,
-0.2774636447429657,
-0.5364899039268494,
-0.07473953068256378,
0.215623140335083,
0.30840346217155457,
-0.9900465607643127,
0.9431709051132202,
0.10460735857486725,
-0.3463439345359802,
-0.4262939989566803,
-0.6137317419052124,
0.5532857775688171,
-0.7629050016403198,
-0.6633686423301697,
0.3865029811859131,
-0.0669766217470169,
-0.7164158821105957,
-0.12316927313804626,
0.07072300463914871,
0.20313425362110138,
0.0931406244635582,
0.1317267119884491,
0.36991238594055176,
-0.45479196310043335,
0.2999113202095032,
-0.22372621297836304,
-0.1017589345574379,
0.4512603282928467,
-0.25504985451698303,
0.213723286986351,
-0.2610950767993927,
-0.6106349229812622,
-0.18386493623256683,
0.5039141178131104,
0.5462191700935364,
0.030048467218875885,
0.4768149256706238,
-0.05174611508846283,
-0.5292873382568359,
-0.526881754398346,
-0.78378826379776,
0.06922132521867752,
-0.4662661552429199,
0.1607818454504013,
-0.48165619373321533,
-0.959148645401001,
0.5122665166854858,
-0.5321336984634399,
0.1276158094406128,
0.6209238767623901,
0.7976917624473572,
0.13553649187088013,
1.0449905395507812,
0.09253765642642975,
0.18740394711494446,
0.01149554643779993,
0.18273325264453888,
0.4118475317955017,
-0.3102072775363922,
-0.1350434571504593,
-0.600035548210144,
-0.13020165264606476,
-0.2250525802373886,
-0.4543083906173706,
-0.07959827780723572,
0.2348281890153885,
-0.24763204157352448,
-0.10037247836589813,
-0.2020687311887741,
0.7501949071884155,
0.07440624386072159,
-0.11444854736328125,
0.2693687081336975,
-0.08478111028671265,
-0.35386428236961365,
0.04719840735197067,
-0.783333420753479,
-0.8591115474700928,
0.7163025736808777,
0.6680833697319031,
0.6366940140724182,
0.28352880477905273,
0.5458996891975403,
0.3220888376235962,
0.40456143021583557,
-1.0288254022598267,
0.5568833947181702,
0.09030378609895706,
-0.8113709688186646,
-0.030453510582447052,
-0.5373656153678894,
-0.8072646856307983,
0.537466824054718,
-0.5229783058166504,
-0.8148057460784912,
0.09764599800109863,
0.14585162699222565,
-0.4723840057849884,
0.585807204246521,
-0.7006595730781555,
0.7814562916755676,
-0.5618060827255249,
-0.45420587062835693,
-0.17527878284454346,
-0.16811344027519226,
0.7423911690711975,
0.04491797089576721,
0.32618600130081177,
0.09270507842302322,
0.16296401619911194,
0.8300755023956299,
-0.5104246139526367,
0.8821969032287598,
-0.018782323226332664,
-0.46103549003601074,
0.4194743037223816,
0.14716678857803345,
0.6648988723754883,
0.010140710510313511,
-0.3821108639240265,
-0.08230728656053543,
-0.0995153859257698,
-0.27591472864151,
-0.7746169567108154,
0.4882647693157196,
-0.33938130736351013,
-1.0018830299377441,
-0.3611948788166046,
-0.34604063630104065,
-0.24612070620059967,
0.09791994839906693,
-0.04436175897717476,
0.3047858774662018,
-0.4146888852119446,
0.0943443551659584,
0.7052809000015259,
-0.40340033173561096,
0.34888485074043274,
0.5114039778709412,
-0.29899072647094727,
-0.2968902885913849,
1.0367642641067505,
0.009108145721256733,
0.27931874990463257,
0.1650063544511795,
0.7961254715919495,
-0.6543990969657898,
-0.7858573198318481,
-0.261555552482605,
0.09235088527202606,
-0.8830494284629822,
-0.16071517765522003,
-0.3987254798412323,
0.03013397566974163,
0.05152026563882828,
-0.36961907148361206,
-0.20402821898460388,
-0.4087688624858856,
0.14125321805477142,
-0.2888890206813812,
-0.030606182292103767,
0.840764582157135,
-0.15138907730579376,
0.020183321088552475,
-0.4783056974411011,
0.3566640615463257,
0.6617149114608765,
0.2936182916164398,
0.15393957495689392,
-0.3819986879825592,
0.04438303783535957,
0.02454121969640255,
-0.19933494925498962,
-0.8165929317474365,
0.07525385171175003,
-0.15779158473014832,
0.7743748426437378,
0.6703135371208191,
0.018484925851225853,
0.6948509216308594,
-0.3943735361099243,
0.8162654638290405,
0.32090601325035095,
-1.1708803176879883,
0.5342662334442139,
-0.23497632145881653,
-0.0061202640645205975,
0.193442240357399,
0.2837055027484894,
-0.28594261407852173,
-0.13093514740467072,
-0.6690954566001892,
-0.7651387453079224,
0.344775527715683,
-0.022122196853160858,
0.05097481608390808,
-0.0808015689253807,
0.30966895818710327,
0.023510627448558807,
-0.1611640751361847,
-0.9755872488021851,
0.1827770173549652,
0.04963027685880661,
0.04844233766198158,
0.17432783544063568,
-0.5814003348350525,
-0.5615750551223755,
-0.1055232435464859,
0.7681412696838379,
-0.2336553931236267,
-0.10100107640028,
0.15812718868255615,
-0.020113004371523857,
0.03241906315088272,
0.7811504602432251,
0.6508455276489258,
0.7875968813896179,
0.01643998548388481,
0.5547617077827454,
0.3928813934326172,
0.3494550585746765,
0.29575446248054504,
0.10972439497709274,
-0.05194925144314766,
0.0759555920958519,
0.5382313132286072,
0.8664687871932983,
0.0631713792681694,
-0.9742984771728516,
0.3951149880886078,
-0.04479413852095604,
-0.6269227862358093,
-0.1710059493780136,
-0.21138620376586914,
0.4992730915546417,
0.4728788137435913,
0.18010669946670532,
-0.22275157272815704,
-0.09620822966098785,
-0.6822775602340698,
-0.12126514315605164,
0.7462137341499329,
0.00272155343554914,
0.06477754563093185,
0.46153873205184937,
0.22578898072242737,
-0.3820685148239136,
-0.015554176643490791,
-0.22056713700294495,
-0.7132700085639954,
0.5185604095458984,
0.8191044330596924,
0.5480965375900269,
0.06143117696046829,
0.33017873764038086,
0.2885710895061493,
0.27700620889663696,
-0.2755100727081299,
0.06301774829626083,
0.011605999432504177,
-0.9004234671592712,
-0.5749121308326721,
-0.45059335231781006,
-0.6677590012550354,
0.37052401900291443,
-0.38148796558380127,
0.09810599684715271,
-0.5324978828430176,
0.024046190083026886,
0.18339663743972778,
-0.14625434577465057,
-0.36835503578186035,
0.14172691106796265,
0.3642336428165436,
0.9151803255081177,
-0.8033873438835144,
0.24013343453407288,
0.5969625115394592,
-0.19551321864128113,
-0.8496341109275818,
0.02390882931649685,
0.03545603156089783,
-0.7512900233268738,
0.6433217525482178,
-0.03465867415070534,
-0.2566012442111969,
-0.62201327085495,
-0.702237069606781,
-0.3879818320274353,
0.6597790718078613,
0.7408212423324585,
-0.5826468467712402,
0.2702028751373291,
0.13647210597991943,
0.3046344220638275,
-0.4242113530635834,
0.17881886661052704,
0.6280824542045593,
0.8404842019081116,
0.32938969135284424,
-0.608158528804779,
0.37198224663734436,
0.09991467744112015,
-0.04235962778329849,
-0.032321229577064514,
-0.2714611887931824,
0.530697762966156,
-0.5988389849662781,
-0.2967536151409149,
-0.054962288588285446,
0.7249337434768677,
0.5434383749961853,
0.17455042898654938,
0.6180472373962402,
0.5554709434509277,
1.083372950553894,
-0.10793566703796387,
1.062253713607788,
0.1909288913011551,
0.2594004273414612,
1.0939226150512695,
-0.4898010492324829,
0.8833388686180115,
0.3882550299167633,
-0.34123772382736206,
0.6877996325492859,
0.7303596138954163,
-0.05269908905029297,
-0.09692166745662689,
0.5980472564697266,
-0.5395117998123169,
-0.8483126759529114,
-0.22682318091392517,
-0.21011988818645477,
0.704001784324646,
0.4911089539527893,
-0.2605305016040802,
-0.42800256609916687,
-0.3140801787376404,
0.2153356373310089,
0.20807527005672455,
-0.37587690353393555,
0.6454141139984131,
-0.0022202993277460337,
-0.8402712941169739,
0.8024700880050659,
0.2455015927553177,
0.5159622430801392,
-0.7201669216156006,
-0.13667073845863342,
0.21757519245147705,
0.11789382994174957,
-0.42620670795440674,
-0.9118497967720032,
0.202426940202713,
0.07138487696647644,
-0.27714356780052185,
-0.21436668932437897,
0.907280683517456,
-0.4590631127357483,
-0.5160951018333435,
0.12508121132850647,
0.43425965309143066,
0.02366216666996479,
0.17314766347408295,
-0.6577418446540833,
0.16355666518211365,
-0.05759109556674957,
-0.1285683661699295,
0.20411576330661774,
0.6037409901618958,
-0.1152457743883133,
0.7683240175247192,
0.6233059763908386,
0.2683351933956146,
-0.432414710521698,
0.10606872290372849,
0.7723955512046814,
-0.48577383160591125,
-0.3042382597923279,
-1.2435945272445679,
0.4085395038127899,
-0.17867256700992584,
0.17058905959129333,
0.4994814097881317,
0.4547659158706665,
0.3705574572086334,
0.053105857223272324,
1.1644067764282227,
-0.04259064048528671,
0.1760358363389969,
-0.7512795925140381,
0.4534456133842468,
-0.39932218194007874,
0.299631267786026,
0.07386427372694016,
-0.42886030673980713,
-0.35241085290908813,
0.7573957443237305,
-0.4121702313423157,
-0.10872570425271988,
0.6051713824272156,
0.650009274482727,
-0.09723231196403503,
0.07191634178161621,
0.23500099778175354,
0.34643465280532837,
0.465517520904541,
0.7627333402633667,
1.2030338048934937,
0.1065375804901123,
0.5806652307510376,
0.29858270287513733,
-0.28969433903694153,
-0.1310768574476242,
-1.498826503753662,
-1.0456745624542236,
-0.17617060244083405,
-0.4111975133419037,
-0.5446088910102844,
-0.06235192343592644,
0.8404221534729004,
0.597987711429596,
-0.7222535610198975,
-0.2051985263824463,
0.008167203515768051,
0.6615660190582275,
-0.01695851981639862,
-0.2035304605960846,
0.12602278590202332,
-0.3922763466835022,
-0.36316245794296265,
0.5804410576820374,
0.1642896831035614,
-0.03681293502449989,
-0.41752558946609497,
-0.34285590052604675,
-0.25322097539901733,
0.7084324359893799,
0.844013512134552,
0.6067934632301331,
-0.9975677728652954,
-0.2980855405330658,
-0.7223586440086365,
0.3324916958808899,
0.03513314202427864,
0.9730585813522339,
-0.5693480968475342,
0.4107113778591156,
0.4270087480545044,
0.8542178273200989,
0.07797146588563919,
-0.09770336747169495,
0.834937334060669,
-0.3382856845855713,
-0.17814625799655914,
0.10688141733407974,
0.8580436706542969,
0.49932804703712463,
-0.10970495641231537,
0.27404385805130005,
0.0035694169346243143,
-0.426822692155838,
-0.8686429858207703,
0.39179474115371704,
-0.8628664016723633,
-0.4671967327594757,
1.316468596458435,
-0.30785131454467773,
-0.03401245176792145,
-0.05679779872298241,
-0.28193679451942444,
-0.1722603142261505,
-0.07010965794324875,
0.8033749461174011,
1.1996421813964844,
0.05980317294597626,
-0.0007384714554063976,
-0.3825344741344452,
0.431062787771225,
0.5488258004188538,
-1.0116788148880005,
0.48327165842056274,
0.5516192317008972,
0.351136177778244,
0.2602860927581787,
0.422623872756958,
-0.24724836647510529,
0.0173675324767828,
-0.07517435401678085,
-0.28851303458213806,
0.022690260782837868,
-0.09375721961259842,
-0.4620530903339386,
0.36686772108078003,
0.501388669013977,
0.11770272254943848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02040v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02040v1
|
Large Multimodal Model based Standardisation of Pathology Reports with Confidence and their Prognostic Significance
| 2024-05-03T12:19:38 | 2024-05-03T12:19:38 |
Ethar Alzaid, Gabriele Pergola, Harriet Evans, David Snead, Fayyaz Minhas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pathology reports are rich in clinical and pathological details but are often
presented in free-text format. The unstructured nature of these reports
presents a significant challenge limiting the accessibility of their content.
In this work, we present a practical approach based on the use of large
multimodal models (LMMs) for automatically extracting information from scanned
images of pathology reports with the goal of generating a standardised report
specifying the value of different fields along with estimated confidence about
the accuracy of the extracted fields. The proposed approach overcomes
limitations of existing methods which do not assign confidence scores to
extracted fields limiting their practical use. The proposed framework uses two
stages of prompting a Large Multimodal Model (LMM) for information extraction
and validation. The framework generalises to textual reports from multiple
medical centres as well as scanned images of legacy pathology reports. We show
that the estimated confidence is an effective indicator of the accuracy of the
extracted information that can be used to select only accurately extracted
fields. We also show the prognostic significance of structured and unstructured
data from pathology reports and show that the automatically extracted field
values significant prognostic value for patient stratification. The framework
is available for evaluation via the URL: https://labieb.dcs.warwick.ac.uk/.
|
[
0.0352625772356987,
-0.2531997561454773,
1.0045957565307617,
0.36587831377983093,
-0.5404290556907654,
-0.3437040448188782,
-0.048250917345285416,
-0.7679896354675293,
0.37060344219207764,
0.45811110734939575,
-0.09103474766016006,
-0.6047741174697876,
-0.9195995330810547,
0.256298303604126,
-0.30269572138786316,
0.8088876605033875,
0.0031914920546114445,
0.3286485970020294,
-0.2430528700351715,
-0.3730011582374573,
-0.20450852811336517,
-0.18173474073410034,
-0.2445238083600998,
-0.11386176198720932,
0.43298816680908203,
0.1716710925102234,
0.8044354915618896,
0.8216638565063477,
0.9069380164146423,
0.2060968279838562,
-0.05021492391824722,
0.43639954924583435,
0.17545466125011444,
0.5438632965087891,
-0.20503586530685425,
-0.07636653631925583,
-0.6969606876373291,
0.22293826937675476,
0.5164095163345337,
0.6119590997695923,
-0.26029855012893677,
-0.033293094485998154,
0.040951937437057495,
0.1712624579668045,
-0.618053674697876,
0.5816285610198975,
-0.11386896669864655,
0.04254990816116333,
-0.04368048161268234,
-0.40432488918304443,
-0.7044754028320312,
-0.3318335711956024,
0.02202177420258522,
-0.5220040082931519,
-0.05345277860760689,
-0.44423264265060425,
0.60637366771698,
-0.25502872467041016,
-0.8308292031288147,
-0.564896285533905,
-0.630607545375824,
0.6467751264572144,
-0.6815474629402161,
0.30711454153060913,
0.2153642177581787,
0.8922693133354187,
-0.11337781697511673,
-0.9871935844421387,
-0.21369820833206177,
-0.37054693698883057,
-0.39021530747413635,
0.3611041009426117,
0.0045603192411363125,
0.2357049435377121,
0.110055111348629,
0.48643046617507935,
-0.19294041395187378,
0.015536648221313953,
-0.46427443623542786,
-0.5092771053314209,
0.762320876121521,
0.3107544779777527,
0.17066985368728638,
-0.29264020919799805,
-0.23525048792362213,
0.15311425924301147,
-0.39809978008270264,
0.05376386642456055,
-0.14040020108222961,
0.3213244676589966,
0.024700069800019264,
0.6312845349311829,
-0.3622158467769623,
0.424472838640213,
-0.07173621654510498,
-0.8778107762336731,
0.262967050075531,
-0.27809426188468933,
-0.017178412526845932,
-0.10768340528011322,
0.8823475241661072,
0.44483742117881775,
-0.0005943983560428023,
-0.16652841866016388,
-0.06915576756000519,
-0.014873499982059002,
0.10456502437591553,
-0.8206309080123901,
-0.1532728224992752,
0.563363254070282,
-0.7784179449081421,
-0.534585177898407,
-0.017279483377933502,
-1.0359941720962524,
-0.7348000407218933,
0.07338471710681915,
0.4437545835971832,
-0.4643581509590149,
-0.32916542887687683,
0.032518528401851654,
0.05615726485848427,
-0.3398507237434387,
0.9300499558448792,
-0.4973829686641693,
-0.08539988845586777,
-0.1450536549091339,
0.5515865683555603,
-0.03538665175437927,
0.17371049523353577,
-0.76006019115448,
0.48725447058677673,
-0.3098682463169098,
0.599261462688446,
-0.8020787239074707,
-0.4146510660648346,
0.07794586569070816,
0.23926864564418793,
0.15780240297317505,
-0.3323920965194702,
0.4614701569080353,
-0.1400667130947113,
0.22841447591781616,
0.2190655767917633,
-0.24571292102336884,
-0.3673417270183563,
0.24998831748962402,
-0.9756565690040588,
0.6442505121231079,
0.15720020234584808,
-0.5304511785507202,
0.45512405037879944,
-0.35677409172058105,
-0.25658202171325684,
0.04365677013993263,
-0.21529091894626617,
-0.14570122957229614,
0.05816202983260155,
0.14227503538131714,
0.6729742884635925,
-0.45336011052131653,
0.590683102607727,
-0.26257067918777466,
0.21238012611865997,
0.10397172719240189,
-0.38151419162750244,
0.5708394050598145,
0.15419712662696838,
-0.09783846139907837,
0.09074205160140991,
-0.927435040473938,
0.09126933664083481,
0.04469936341047287,
-0.4782547354698181,
0.026642806828022003,
-0.04529918357729912,
-0.1411188244819641,
0.6432878971099854,
0.15223334729671478,
-0.7125100493431091,
0.22723233699798584,
-0.27132418751716614,
0.08396309614181519,
0.24243487417697906,
0.2050308883190155,
0.16547031700611115,
-0.3530070185661316,
0.5388125777244568,
0.6753383874893188,
0.3245777189731598,
-0.4549297094345093,
-0.6589689254760742,
-0.04775603860616684,
-0.7878329157829285,
0.6071698069572449,
0.3165836036205292,
-0.4057328402996063,
0.09274289757013321,
-0.34562334418296814,
-0.6335746645927429,
-0.5988205671310425,
-0.10041101276874542,
0.2068861871957779,
0.6435723900794983,
0.47474244236946106,
-0.6198464035987854,
-0.5121967792510986,
-1.0779551267623901,
0.30407270789146423,
0.14212128520011902,
-0.20322582125663757,
0.22882205247879028,
0.4128217399120331,
-0.33579450845718384,
0.7849847078323364,
-0.5187263488769531,
-0.5859250426292419,
-0.2589654326438904,
0.29152292013168335,
0.24607491493225098,
0.3496262729167938,
0.03809461370110512,
-0.8023200035095215,
-0.2503393590450287,
0.049221623688936234,
-1.0186744928359985,
0.02380090393126011,
-0.07229187339544296,
0.3467075228691101,
0.31732064485549927,
0.2209681123495102,
-0.8540834784507751,
0.9136936068534851,
0.4858671724796295,
-0.07442119717597961,
0.7343239188194275,
-0.6247271299362183,
0.4592672884464264,
-0.9818971157073975,
0.2531147003173828,
0.2855340540409088,
-0.7399210929870605,
-0.2804660499095917,
0.08167245239019394,
0.23610329627990723,
0.10042934119701385,
-0.31125959753990173,
0.4283594787120819,
-0.48652446269989014,
0.009543064050376415,
0.21800659596920013,
0.18250010907649994,
0.4352678954601288,
0.08579200506210327,
0.3132088780403137,
0.27068400382995605,
0.44026196002960205,
-0.2817060947418213,
0.22081835567951202,
0.13353508710861206,
-0.2844034433364868,
0.11475849896669388,
-0.33311358094215393,
-0.29293954372406006,
-0.1806785613298416,
0.5435735583305359,
-0.9309832453727722,
-0.5312917828559875,
0.09562887251377106,
-0.38396769762039185,
0.3440144956111908,
-0.15640485286712646,
-0.599195122718811,
-0.16366776823997498,
-0.23782482743263245,
0.1473846137523651,
0.34017497301101685,
0.02225995436310768,
0.9570821523666382,
0.5032933354377747,
-0.40259477496147156,
-0.41155532002449036,
-0.5565506219863892,
0.0022254022769629955,
0.057077400386333466,
-0.6641906499862671,
0.08349002152681351,
-0.02574528567492962,
-0.3790103793144226,
-0.19070841372013092,
-0.0002060361730400473,
-0.43460503220558167,
-0.15418949723243713,
0.4537718892097473,
0.3870791792869568,
-0.17919228971004486,
0.13159199059009552,
-0.15413619577884674,
0.0013059857301414013,
-0.30502766370773315,
0.2645654082298279,
0.3855817914009094,
0.08782300353050232,
-0.5283186435699463,
-0.5188375115394592,
0.5405058860778809,
1.0632480382919312,
-0.20870782434940338,
0.6224144101142883,
0.3235747218132019,
-0.6697381138801575,
0.28562721610069275,
-0.46249327063560486,
-0.22212333977222443,
-0.27141129970550537,
0.191120907664299,
-0.10315350443124771,
-0.3181604743003845,
0.632879376411438,
-0.2607003450393677,
0.12152031809091568,
0.783532977104187,
0.5457831025123596,
-0.2537512481212616,
1.402523398399353,
0.7218087315559387,
0.3670004606246948,
-0.30633363127708435,
0.24328936636447906,
0.047846682369709015,
-0.43919551372528076,
-0.6428536772727966,
-0.4167824983596802,
0.2061825543642044,
-0.24573490023612976,
-0.5094255805015564,
0.6877882480621338,
-0.029133265838027,
0.26565638184547424,
-0.13487638533115387,
-0.6437966227531433,
0.19627150893211365,
0.046783167868852615,
0.4193521738052368,
0.5178704857826233,
-0.13171331584453583,
-0.07590002566576004,
-0.18116775155067444,
-0.38537415862083435,
-0.6688375473022461,
1.2242108583450317,
0.5284262895584106,
0.26938527822494507,
0.4723547101020813,
0.4420507252216339,
0.40410321950912476,
0.49945831298828125,
-0.8119545578956604,
0.345417857170105,
-0.26576173305511475,
-0.8089094758033752,
-0.3763701915740967,
-0.19076603651046753,
-0.8790594339370728,
0.2606552541255951,
-0.4811163544654846,
-0.9058716297149658,
0.21655027568340302,
-0.22321876883506775,
-0.6345222592353821,
0.1866651177406311,
-0.3435922861099243,
0.4646501839160919,
0.03196264058351517,
-0.2218940258026123,
-0.04781947657465935,
-0.9170047640800476,
0.43773117661476135,
-0.16664354503154755,
0.6155111789703369,
-0.09104004502296448,
0.0006813465151935816,
0.7134962677955627,
-0.20952481031417847,
0.8026524782180786,
-0.1336739957332611,
-0.15025289356708527,
0.11170805245637894,
0.3874703645706177,
0.5022702813148499,
0.13118009269237518,
-0.28841865062713623,
0.041524555534124374,
0.45052406191825867,
-0.3318643569946289,
-0.32261210680007935,
0.17953017354011536,
-0.2708892524242401,
-0.31601476669311523,
-0.5042665600776672,
-0.8453249335289001,
-0.41347935795783997,
0.47139856219291687,
0.12897218763828278,
0.8940335512161255,
0.00677452702075243,
0.3080783784389496,
0.521631121635437,
-0.20488694310188293,
0.377740740776062,
0.3794158101081848,
-0.10646997392177582,
-0.35876724123954773,
0.4363689422607422,
0.220457524061203,
0.1538374125957489,
0.3104638457298279,
0.19813764095306396,
-0.3820963501930237,
-0.736527144908905,
-0.58049076795578,
-0.020888371393084526,
-0.9987733364105225,
-0.37844887375831604,
-0.7474321722984314,
-0.35834112763404846,
-0.6256393194198608,
0.09482678771018982,
-0.21136029064655304,
-0.43888771533966064,
-0.005253851879388094,
-0.04044834151864052,
0.06674032658338547,
0.7929588556289673,
-0.20200438797473907,
0.05601710081100464,
-1.2011312246322632,
-0.12895815074443817,
-0.07881345599889755,
0.13414233922958374,
-0.3397880792617798,
-0.4788283705711365,
-0.14338846504688263,
0.05902889370918274,
-0.25712984800338745,
-0.9628697037696838,
0.7235391139984131,
0.20248444378376007,
0.6579513549804688,
0.45704811811447144,
-0.08365276455879211,
0.4283319115638733,
-0.12525112926959991,
0.6273510456085205,
0.5151708126068115,
-0.5588656663894653,
0.563360869884491,
-0.5400620698928833,
0.05114516243338585,
0.5076773166656494,
0.6861683130264282,
-0.26203998923301697,
-0.2512800991535187,
-0.8081743717193604,
-0.6674301624298096,
0.5660266876220703,
-0.20047129690647125,
-0.5108832120895386,
0.09765711426734924,
0.020365551114082336,
0.49515005946159363,
0.10791263729333878,
-0.684937596321106,
0.15373492240905762,
-0.04669995978474617,
-0.5593470931053162,
-0.25340259075164795,
-0.5506550669670105,
-0.8116652369499207,
-0.22274592518806458,
0.2581249177455902,
-0.35837528109550476,
0.23721259832382202,
0.4245493412017822,
-0.3677157163619995,
0.05854756012558937,
0.2508262097835541,
0.5593708753585815,
0.9475247859954834,
-0.4311237335205078,
0.3279227316379547,
0.15721534192562103,
-0.48846685886383057,
0.09731903672218323,
-0.025941995903849602,
0.19597390294075012,
0.1908210963010788,
0.6295400261878967,
-0.027465926483273506,
0.21602493524551392,
-0.6198477745056152,
0.8383359313011169,
0.0398741289973259,
-0.25378140807151794,
-0.16300468146800995,
-0.3513133227825165,
0.09293241798877716,
0.2384166568517685,
0.296893447637558,
0.2648161053657532,
0.3696478009223938,
-0.3805831968784332,
0.43058496713638306,
0.11836416274309158,
-0.7033037543296814,
-0.18080997467041016,
0.27606409788131714,
0.016725948080420494,
0.2194962054491043,
0.46097856760025024,
-0.08634355664253235,
0.09381752461194992,
0.6294388175010681,
0.5603314638137817,
0.13911199569702148,
-0.20786762237548828,
0.37699687480926514,
0.3834170401096344,
0.12711599469184875,
-0.2783220708370209,
0.09687446057796478,
0.48445215821266174,
-0.3526245057582855,
-0.3974163830280304,
-0.7459255456924438,
-0.36774593591690063,
0.19487319886684418,
-0.5886932611465454,
0.24140633642673492,
-0.5636705160140991,
-0.05139261484146118,
0.3996216654777527,
-0.15638135373592377,
-0.13275450468063354,
0.7842202186584473,
0.13999240100383759,
1.180034875869751,
-0.59798264503479,
0.8982682824134827,
0.4529339373111725,
-0.5924213528633118,
-0.9466145038604736,
-0.30856481194496155,
0.18864145874977112,
-0.5389593243598938,
0.6652529239654541,
0.3678017556667328,
0.05048529431223869,
-0.32049739360809326,
-0.2774777412414551,
-0.8277639150619507,
1.280992031097412,
0.18567083775997162,
-0.3746867775917053,
-0.041864022612571716,
0.0982099324464798,
0.5022844672203064,
-0.6472415328025818,
0.7115760445594788,
0.11598595231771469,
0.4721236824989319,
0.49783432483673096,
-1.1554678678512573,
0.38025981187820435,
-0.2962542474269867,
-0.5791320204734802,
0.09248001873493195,
-0.06421899795532227,
0.9176970720291138,
-0.09801588207483292,
-0.24508683383464813,
0.0818050280213356,
0.21080467104911804,
0.11161407083272934,
0.237916961312294,
0.3415127396583557,
0.34127941727638245,
0.9289860129356384,
-0.02195359766483307,
0.9637306332588196,
-0.3154548704624176,
0.11777780205011368,
0.3682757019996643,
-0.2737826108932495,
0.6239653825759888,
0.31208324432373047,
0.14072346687316895,
0.5511260628700256,
0.46019455790519714,
0.050696518272161484,
0.43671566247940063,
-0.21383719146251678,
-0.30728402733802795,
-0.4905419945716858,
-0.18736736476421356,
-0.3809686303138733,
0.6017433404922485,
0.5388510227203369,
-0.7321021556854248,
-0.47347551584243774,
-0.06487362086772919,
-0.032979730516672134,
-0.3222895860671997,
-0.3527485430240631,
0.615440309047699,
-0.08983109891414642,
-0.6386256217956543,
0.2933484613895416,
0.12492549419403076,
0.3948048949241638,
-0.7344195246696472,
-0.11847905814647675,
-0.06397373974323273,
0.30100709199905396,
-0.4420800507068634,
-0.9907111525535583,
0.5279441475868225,
-0.1871761828660965,
-0.2905269265174866,
0.08942140638828278,
0.7807213664054871,
-0.3772570788860321,
-0.5610535144805908,
0.20080697536468506,
0.4496360123157501,
0.24666956067085266,
0.014289792627096176,
-0.14014272391796112,
-0.1450929194688797,
-0.10090547800064087,
-0.08967646956443787,
0.6835690140724182,
0.2435360550880432,
-0.3756808340549469,
0.757741391658783,
0.5569247007369995,
0.3090945780277252,
-0.5534255504608154,
-0.2837739884853363,
0.7956079840660095,
-0.3709040880203247,
-0.2780437171459198,
-0.6063033938407898,
0.8730674386024475,
-0.3549496531486511,
-0.23182334005832672,
0.4114915728569031,
0.2775443494319916,
0.08393413573503494,
0.02595631778240204,
0.5822291970252991,
0.02391694113612175,
0.41732874512672424,
-0.3704862594604492,
0.8280459046363831,
-0.5488346219062805,
0.08011642098426819,
-0.13382935523986816,
-0.27631840109825134,
-0.6107674837112427,
0.1553669273853302,
-0.2791524827480316,
-0.02996443770825863,
0.7965150475502014,
0.8311739563941956,
-0.2471727430820465,
0.11374612152576447,
0.44029027223587036,
0.28834161162376404,
0.21210269629955292,
0.5130159854888916,
0.38612693548202515,
-0.09939952939748764,
0.628466010093689,
-0.3330346643924713,
-0.8208980560302734,
-0.3699098825454712,
-0.94840407371521,
-0.5166369080543518,
-0.7578374743461609,
-0.19267913699150085,
-0.6366533041000366,
0.03162786737084389,
0.7275897264480591,
1.0378512144088745,
-0.7658387422561646,
0.22775454819202423,
0.7203740477561951,
-0.2884151339530945,
-0.07008333504199982,
-0.14724645018577576,
0.5097806453704834,
0.06142286956310272,
-0.29256343841552734,
0.35059234499931335,
0.7268074154853821,
0.031771425157785416,
0.07188478112220764,
0.18882140517234802,
-0.3523107171058655,
0.08016373217105865,
0.7329828143119812,
0.16576962172985077,
-0.3357226848602295,
-0.1843479871749878,
-0.373584121465683,
-0.6074044108390808,
0.3017028272151947,
0.3849078118801117,
-0.6609639525413513,
0.43899086117744446,
0.2835320830345154,
0.1595643162727356,
0.36453598737716675,
-0.20482242107391357,
0.4929838478565216,
-0.5425938963890076,
0.13919715583324432,
0.539429247379303,
0.5260362029075623,
0.10544964671134949,
-0.5398961305618286,
0.39836692810058594,
0.35253608226776123,
-0.30921584367752075,
-0.9450960159301758,
0.3186768889427185,
-1.0766535997390747,
-0.38680335879325867,
1.2190961837768555,
-0.4698178470134735,
-0.24092726409435272,
-0.4068109393119812,
-0.08003005385398865,
0.27060648798942566,
-0.23401668667793274,
0.8894376158714294,
0.4176351726055145,
-0.3324948847293854,
-0.39732882380485535,
-0.4632432758808136,
0.4740637540817261,
-0.016182273626327515,
-0.8260610103607178,
-0.13531984388828278,
0.6375851631164551,
0.47686681151390076,
0.5001814365386963,
0.7994480729103088,
-0.8005292415618896,
0.5351595282554626,
-0.05713292211294174,
0.14503274857997894,
-0.34145668148994446,
-0.5622700452804565,
-0.23081175982952118,
0.8037952780723572,
-0.06973355263471603,
0.08202946186065674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02024v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02024v1
|
Analyzing Narrative Processing in Large Language Models (LLMs): Using GPT4 to test BERT
| 2024-05-03T11:56:13 | 2024-05-03T11:56:13 |
Patrick Krauss, Jannik Hösch, Claus Metzner, Andreas Maier, Peter Uhrig, Achim Schilling
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The ability to transmit and receive complex information via language is
unique to humans and is the basis of traditions, culture and versatile social
interactions. Through the disruptive introduction of transformer based large
language models (LLMs) humans are not the only entity to "understand" and
produce language any more. In the present study, we have performed the first
steps to use LLMs as a model to understand fundamental mechanisms of language
processing in neural networks, in order to make predictions and generate
hypotheses on how the human brain does language processing. Thus, we have used
ChatGPT to generate seven different stylistic variations of ten different
narratives (Aesop's fables). We used these stories as input for the open source
LLM BERT and have analyzed the activation patterns of the hidden units of BERT
using multi-dimensional scaling and cluster analysis. We found that the
activation vectors of the hidden units cluster according to stylistic
variations in earlier layers of BERT (1) than narrative content (4-5). Despite
the fact that BERT consists of 12 identical building blocks that are stacked
and trained on large text corpora, the different layers perform different
tasks. This is a very useful model of the human brain, where self-similar
structures, i.e. different areas of the cerebral cortex, can have different
functions and are therefore well suited to processing language in a very
efficient way. The proposed approach has the potential to open the black box of
LLMs on the one hand, and might be a further step to unravel the neural
processes underlying human language processing and cognition in general.
|
[
-0.2647867202758789,
-0.966761589050293,
0.7057312726974487,
0.34306538105010986,
-0.2223934680223465,
0.18341489136219025,
-0.4616709053516388,
-0.6598265171051025,
0.09639699757099152,
0.4406367838382721,
-0.6657137870788574,
-0.40356454253196716,
-0.549238920211792,
0.20046056807041168,
-0.3520206809043884,
0.9155585765838623,
-0.11002004146575928,
0.018896330147981644,
0.03941560536623001,
0.06851497292518616,
-0.3057878315448761,
-0.6590617299079895,
-0.5918565988540649,
-0.5385881066322327,
0.697877824306488,
-0.06695041060447693,
0.47298887372016907,
0.4803500175476074,
0.3392573297023773,
0.313355416059494,
-0.22355611622333527,
-0.12674978375434875,
-0.6825743317604065,
0.3040737807750702,
0.04385264962911606,
-0.6741199493408203,
-0.3740909993648529,
-0.0850277990102768,
0.6958146691322327,
0.7178325057029724,
0.02928677201271057,
0.10316118597984314,
0.3680824041366577,
0.3692671060562134,
-0.07620369642972946,
0.3520859479904175,
-0.7261812686920166,
0.005961420945823193,
-0.12864574790000916,
-0.18759529292583466,
-0.431670606136322,
-0.29542678594589233,
0.40865853428840637,
-0.26103368401527405,
0.4993648827075958,
0.10154452174901962,
0.56607985496521,
-0.12119611352682114,
-0.2740478515625,
-0.3389637768268585,
-0.6722939014434814,
0.8076549768447876,
-0.693844199180603,
0.10679204761981964,
0.27253034710884094,
-0.017977554351091385,
-0.06015324592590332,
-0.7275792360305786,
-0.578813374042511,
-0.4612385034561157,
-0.266732394695282,
-0.1274288296699524,
-0.3761865496635437,
0.03428467735648155,
0.15316247940063477,
0.17202132940292358,
-0.6759841442108154,
0.28052663803100586,
-0.4357180595397949,
-0.325891375541687,
0.3744296431541443,
0.1373441517353058,
0.38808169960975647,
-0.23689575493335724,
-0.39205190539360046,
-0.020913807675242424,
-0.5848173499107361,
0.08295309543609619,
0.33125749230384827,
0.224747896194458,
-0.012288408353924751,
0.4240840673446655,
0.20133782923221588,
0.40282905101776123,
-0.22536861896514893,
-0.25886067748069763,
0.30504998564720154,
-0.10819121450185776,
-0.21225695312023163,
0.16638319194316864,
0.7301654815673828,
0.22445683181285858,
0.3115790784358978,
-0.21767014265060425,
-0.32526928186416626,
0.1108144223690033,
0.41277015209198,
-0.6506502628326416,
-0.07453598082065582,
-0.010950521565973759,
-0.6480017304420471,
-0.5052395462989807,
-0.536942183971405,
-0.5759256482124329,
-0.39987024664878845,
-0.23384183645248413,
0.5078800320625305,
-0.7229557633399963,
-0.0034836463164538145,
-0.00009722977119963616,
-0.061640940606594086,
0.44549253582954407,
0.19502753019332886,
-1.1572315692901611,
0.33542826771736145,
0.5592974424362183,
0.846369743347168,
-0.3795686364173889,
-0.5009178519248962,
0.09883978217840195,
0.1543186455965042,
-0.2660408914089203,
0.6898325085639954,
-0.5129333138465881,
-0.07829710096120834,
0.07048922032117844,
-0.18716230988502502,
-0.1454066038131714,
-0.37211644649505615,
0.7736155390739441,
-0.661379337310791,
0.022360067814588547,
-0.33291006088256836,
-0.48277977108955383,
-0.2973616421222687,
0.2768765687942505,
-0.6805877089500427,
0.7706670761108398,
-0.18117325007915497,
-0.5510166883468628,
-0.05993027985095978,
-0.586197555065155,
-0.48712870478630066,
0.07469622790813446,
-0.25469037890434265,
-0.2235732227563858,
0.45316365361213684,
0.4242783784866333,
0.4754667580127716,
-0.26983699202537537,
0.28625378012657166,
0.010279680602252483,
-0.5066341757774353,
0.4940594732761383,
-0.7199837565422058,
0.580944836139679,
-0.010890789330005646,
-0.4449402093887329,
-0.01651371456682682,
-0.6225101351737976,
-0.09177515655755997,
0.39759916067123413,
-0.46705371141433716,
-0.1853124350309372,
0.053898993879556656,
0.026369404047727585,
-0.011626461520791054,
0.37802156805992126,
-0.5193963646888733,
0.30802446603775024,
-0.3148747980594635,
0.699811577796936,
0.8157587051391602,
0.028855551034212112,
0.24456962943077087,
-0.3129365146160126,
0.3962323069572449,
-0.10526657104492188,
-0.10825783014297485,
-0.5594360828399658,
-0.646350622177124,
-0.6479345560073853,
-0.25173890590667725,
0.13860267400741577,
0.34915485978126526,
-0.5754894614219666,
0.299376904964447,
-0.1557338982820511,
-0.30472779273986816,
-0.6079661250114441,
-0.188424751162529,
0.14258472621440887,
0.3770676851272583,
0.2745365500450134,
-0.4102482497692108,
-0.37769386172294617,
-1.04269540309906,
-0.1919073760509491,
-0.21178485453128815,
-0.3256054222583771,
0.05030430108308792,
0.2511228024959564,
-0.21379297971725464,
0.8913244605064392,
-0.4265286922454834,
-0.16715523600578308,
-0.49571922421455383,
0.41751256585121155,
0.3067842125892639,
0.12462238222360611,
0.5303537845611572,
-0.48947304487228394,
-0.08537964522838593,
0.0071520451456308365,
-0.7656664848327637,
-0.36977308988571167,
-0.28304216265678406,
0.1546137034893036,
0.150191992521286,
0.5053988695144653,
-0.6918935179710388,
0.3195395767688751,
0.640542209148407,
-0.2136342078447342,
0.6353116631507874,
-0.3576037585735321,
0.07655422389507294,
-0.5839755535125732,
-0.1634448766708374,
-0.0708548054099083,
0.079752117395401,
-0.7284687757492065,
-0.08927156776189804,
-0.01395469717681408,
-0.02341471239924431,
-0.06352059543132782,
0.10528930276632309,
-0.4959428608417511,
-0.2653418779373169,
-0.22863729298114777,
0.1598975509405136,
0.016419222578406334,
0.9508733749389648,
-0.04815547913312912,
0.5324181914329529,
0.4348381757736206,
-0.27471867203712463,
0.21220763027668,
0.04087104648351669,
-0.46670886874198914,
0.2281087189912796,
-0.8266602754592896,
0.23494522273540497,
-0.33532944321632385,
0.176245778799057,
-1.5264434814453125,
0.11654762923717499,
0.005336477886885405,
-0.3940337896347046,
0.3524070084095001,
0.09090226888656616,
-0.71142578125,
-0.16380302608013153,
-0.2748693525791168,
0.22721345722675323,
0.5411652326583862,
-0.3971675634384155,
0.7767950892448425,
0.21697106957435608,
-0.5121376514434814,
-0.22940319776535034,
-0.7003210783004761,
0.18746808171272278,
-0.27480483055114746,
-0.8978797197341919,
0.46459510922431946,
-0.2167135328054428,
-0.2047244906425476,
-0.1927569955587387,
-0.016766754910349846,
-0.05867941305041313,
-0.0852040946483612,
0.10989293456077576,
0.40163177251815796,
-0.42714667320251465,
0.18032899498939514,
0.1532963514328003,
0.09238222241401672,
0.27231448888778687,
-0.26837509870529175,
0.7699706554412842,
-0.30827221274375916,
-0.3701784014701843,
-0.3725418746471405,
0.2206718474626541,
0.6744284629821777,
-0.16618983447551727,
0.699964165687561,
0.7267653942108154,
-0.1699911206960678,
-0.06520973145961761,
-0.6138623952865601,
-0.17095912992954254,
-0.46090903878211975,
0.5792039632797241,
-0.2663024961948395,
-1.1936883926391602,
0.5966625809669495,
-0.08536193519830704,
0.09860434383153915,
0.36086511611938477,
0.9503366351127625,
-0.20948168635368347,
0.7145574688911438,
0.5684352517127991,
-0.15703751146793365,
0.34159424901008606,
-0.03148563206195831,
0.4300794005393982,
-0.8315794467926025,
-0.01757189631462097,
-0.28944167494773865,
-0.5832140445709229,
-0.5593478083610535,
-0.41350817680358887,
0.4492788314819336,
-0.014881591312587261,
-0.13217872381210327,
0.11334221810102463,
-0.26215603947639465,
0.5902070999145508,
0.456094354391098,
0.028479045256972313,
0.5360153317451477,
0.2057276964187622,
-0.42413583397865295,
-0.17535726726055145,
-0.48347440361976624,
-0.7025739550590515,
1.0678205490112305,
0.7165833115577698,
0.695358395576477,
-0.02693197689950466,
0.5405699610710144,
0.27887168526649475,
0.18123550713062286,
-0.7585675120353699,
0.6241503357887268,
0.06173688545823097,
-0.4640007019042969,
-0.4964999258518219,
-0.08075737953186035,
-1.1432456970214844,
0.7152708768844604,
-0.11449182778596878,
-1.0543307065963745,
-0.0199552234262228,
-0.1409829556941986,
-0.2864384353160858,
0.3613278269767761,
-1.0354405641555786,
0.6344853639602661,
-0.29815059900283813,
-0.26321250200271606,
-0.22621330618858337,
-0.6706464886665344,
0.32144349813461304,
-0.3420177102088928,
0.25524622201919556,
0.04898481070995331,
0.0389389805495739,
0.6183017492294312,
0.13429944217205048,
1.231506109237671,
0.2508849799633026,
-0.3600904643535614,
0.3124667704105377,
0.3278237581253052,
0.40383902192115784,
-0.12228521704673767,
0.08197616040706635,
0.41421765089035034,
-0.22833040356636047,
-0.15847738087177277,
-0.3398202061653137,
0.638637125492096,
-1.00894033908844,
-0.5694553256034851,
-0.43227365612983704,
-0.8149397969245911,
-0.1522652506828308,
0.015947997570037842,
0.18372255563735962,
0.2766154706478119,
-0.36277151107788086,
0.02058614045381546,
0.6138166785240173,
-0.29377537965774536,
0.662102997303009,
0.49241921305656433,
-0.3152019679546356,
-0.12067093700170517,
0.5532271862030029,
0.04666769504547119,
0.172962486743927,
0.45976337790489197,
0.16550685465335846,
-0.0602579191327095,
-0.8710402846336365,
0.02960973046720028,
0.4822569489479065,
-0.6164342164993286,
0.1575373411178589,
-0.49471315741539,
-0.24937762320041656,
-0.2651926279067993,
-0.0901125818490982,
-0.03907562419772148,
-0.13491088151931763,
-0.14194460213184357,
-0.23046426475048065,
0.038723137229681015,
1.033918857574463,
0.041669536381959915,
0.4572208821773529,
-0.8045566082000732,
0.2262733429670334,
0.4260832667350769,
0.30977851152420044,
0.3742413818836212,
-0.47899329662323,
-0.12552396953105927,
-0.06742016971111298,
-0.431436151266098,
-0.7972644567489624,
0.5413127541542053,
-0.028183287009596825,
0.5660920143127441,
0.18890388309955597,
-0.4239773750305176,
0.2806672751903534,
-0.9469586610794067,
0.8097314238548279,
0.14327217638492584,
-0.8880572319030762,
0.261726438999176,
-0.5299981236457825,
0.3134247958660126,
0.04702135547995567,
0.32903698086738586,
-0.6806523203849792,
-0.3130773901939392,
-0.5004609227180481,
-0.8528282046318054,
0.8151448369026184,
0.6435683965682983,
0.20935198664665222,
0.027744214981794357,
0.2479729950428009,
0.21811257302761078,
0.16762807965278625,
-0.9287897348403931,
-0.15665139257907867,
0.19569340348243713,
0.14847852289676666,
-0.21609921753406525,
-0.5092940330505371,
-0.10677331686019897,
-0.17759853601455688,
0.2836796045303345,
0.027142606675624847,
0.49407321214675903,
0.16836349666118622,
-0.1364441215991974,
-0.2186671793460846,
0.29534944891929626,
0.47331151366233826,
0.7303212881088257,
-0.20822148025035858,
0.06370414048433304,
0.18556441366672516,
-0.6251501441001892,
-0.20081083476543427,
-0.05936248600482941,
0.031772833317518234,
0.03282201662659645,
0.8251339793205261,
0.9559751152992249,
0.3168684244155884,
-0.5759789347648621,
0.3408091068267822,
-0.3207069933414459,
-0.11328941583633423,
-0.25911450386047363,
-0.06405062973499298,
0.41510850191116333,
0.5876677632331848,
0.5434561967849731,
-0.044772591441869736,
-0.051061853766441345,
-0.6714264750480652,
0.04548241198062897,
0.23108932375907898,
-0.03560619428753853,
-0.4698164165019989,
0.3722294867038727,
0.04018528759479523,
-0.3350687325000763,
0.6986579298973083,
-0.031795158982276917,
-0.5116927623748779,
0.45944690704345703,
0.8149518370628357,
0.8887907862663269,
-0.20053668320178986,
0.17068663239479065,
0.023594480007886887,
0.6849097609519958,
0.18087148666381836,
-0.09726743400096893,
0.11832791566848755,
-0.9421219229698181,
-0.7537893056869507,
-0.9044389128684998,
-0.1721738874912262,
0.332861989736557,
-0.43928661942481995,
0.06596793979406357,
-0.08995666354894638,
0.03987846523523331,
0.2068326771259308,
-0.3661300539970398,
-0.599897563457489,
-0.1582331508398056,
0.5861971378326416,
0.6017419695854187,
-0.8231550455093384,
0.9442323446273804,
0.3970797061920166,
-0.17233537137508392,
-0.6342222690582275,
0.27989208698272705,
0.004939816426485777,
-1.121710181236267,
0.6750821471214294,
0.059303198009729385,
0.1000896766781807,
-0.036587558686733246,
-0.6459047794342041,
-0.8481771349906921,
1.1202688217163086,
0.4362880289554596,
-0.6836748719215393,
-0.3189464509487152,
0.2752799987792969,
0.9063157439231873,
-0.4288875162601471,
0.27274346351623535,
0.9717527627944946,
0.32574084401130676,
0.3145740330219269,
-0.9138842821121216,
-0.10326206684112549,
0.004162239842116833,
0.3394754230976105,
0.18022213876247406,
-0.3652317225933075,
0.9895047545433044,
-0.17792192101478577,
0.017532585188746452,
0.03785403445363045,
0.4874727725982666,
0.3925819396972656,
-0.05543392524123192,
0.3149617910385132,
0.3722657561302185,
0.770417332649231,
-0.038526736199855804,
1.081995964050293,
-0.11364161968231201,
0.4468923509120941,
0.7360730171203613,
-0.2601716220378876,
0.73884117603302,
0.39220553636550903,
-0.39186927676200867,
0.5879719257354736,
0.3800029456615448,
0.017405513674020767,
0.4321753680706024,
0.36249130964279175,
-0.31571492552757263,
-0.033317141234874725,
0.17957507073879242,
-0.13573047518730164,
0.49702852964401245,
0.44114911556243896,
-0.543222963809967,
-0.28567975759506226,
-0.036685165017843246,
0.050291068851947784,
-0.17443236708641052,
-0.3746662735939026,
0.6499615907669067,
0.20404179394245148,
-0.5090242624282837,
0.5065575242042542,
0.042075347155332565,
0.746709406375885,
-0.8840256333351135,
0.013478688895702362,
-0.1123310998082161,
0.02511580102145672,
0.032348696142435074,
-0.8230301141738892,
0.17667439579963684,
0.0436590313911438,
-0.1148473247885704,
-0.3974321782588959,
0.9563922882080078,
-0.40861979126930237,
-0.5198236703872681,
0.4533744156360626,
0.5975561738014221,
0.1923043131828308,
-0.14510264992713928,
-0.44452759623527527,
0.39420589804649353,
0.17731873691082,
-0.4266921877861023,
0.570603609085083,
0.7004062533378601,
-0.03496012091636658,
0.3587395250797272,
0.6178600192070007,
0.14847011864185333,
0.09921032935380936,
0.26303043961524963,
0.8399423360824585,
-0.781005859375,
-0.5839295387268066,
-1.1228101253509521,
0.34698161482810974,
0.15361198782920837,
-0.020993636921048164,
0.5624834299087524,
0.22430072724819183,
0.5893908739089966,
-0.1269511878490448,
0.8208348155021667,
0.1298852115869522,
0.315859317779541,
-0.4178571105003357,
0.7894179224967957,
-0.04808183014392853,
0.44579532742500305,
-0.3278467059135437,
-0.9985385537147522,
-0.19005350768566132,
0.6515811681747437,
-0.39315661787986755,
-0.04510718956589699,
1.0347909927368164,
0.460168719291687,
0.22629696130752563,
0.45530831813812256,
0.41900014877319336,
0.6425679922103882,
0.39412128925323486,
0.5069947242736816,
0.8177043795585632,
-0.05928768590092659,
0.6519606113433838,
-0.08772914111614227,
-0.36216235160827637,
0.0536842904984951,
-0.8403663039207458,
-0.9937742352485657,
-0.5711919665336609,
0.08761795610189438,
-0.06083282083272934,
-0.0772838443517685,
0.7179107666015625,
0.22081707417964935,
-0.5467134714126587,
-0.5421651005744934,
0.18232028186321259,
-0.06337179988622665,
-0.14910854399204254,
-0.21180950105190277,
0.46004101634025574,
-0.4315670430660248,
-0.6052796840667725,
0.37228313088417053,
0.5114781856536865,
-0.05268046259880066,
-0.37686657905578613,
0.23121368885040283,
-0.12963078916072845,
0.054096903651952744,
0.9414359331130981,
-0.23629698157310486,
-0.7880702018737793,
-0.328254759311676,
-0.05147941783070564,
0.003897339105606079,
0.3190527856349945,
1.0831682682037354,
-0.821313202381134,
0.3109103739261627,
0.35567882657051086,
0.6612446308135986,
0.6485742330551147,
-0.36011993885040283,
0.6355006098747253,
-0.8700729608535767,
-0.08139441162347794,
0.37049299478530884,
0.6348453164100647,
0.22516685724258423,
-0.28767260909080505,
0.3416045308113098,
0.12402791529893875,
-0.6672459840774536,
-0.48851513862609863,
0.09435273706912994,
-1.063681960105896,
-0.3795817792415619,
1.041073203086853,
0.003981379326432943,
-0.3202885091304779,
0.01817462407052517,
-0.5803865790367126,
0.17730267345905304,
-0.3614467680454254,
0.8964035511016846,
1.0788843631744385,
-0.4896673262119293,
-0.16327401995658875,
-0.5769979357719421,
0.12242181599140167,
0.11499550938606262,
-0.52884840965271,
0.16849318146705627,
0.408062607049942,
0.23509067296981812,
0.34288129210472107,
0.5773213505744934,
-0.18033955991268158,
-0.17864421010017395,
-0.20972177386283875,
0.18627171218395233,
0.2523765563964844,
-0.07275371253490448,
-0.5585958361625671,
0.5039092302322388,
-0.02106378972530365,
0.039385467767715454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02010v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02010v1
|
The Trade-off between Performance, Efficiency, and Fairness in Adapter Modules for Text Classification
| 2024-05-03T11:18:47 | 2024-05-03T11:18:47 |
Minh Duc Bui, Katharina von der Wense
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current natural language processing (NLP) research tends to focus on only one
or, less frequently, two dimensions - e.g., performance, privacy, fairness, or
efficiency - at a time, which may lead to suboptimal conclusions and often
overlooking the broader goal of achieving trustworthy NLP. Work on adapter
modules (Houlsby et al., 2019; Hu et al., 2021) focuses on improving
performance and efficiency, with no investigation of unintended consequences on
other aspects such as fairness. To address this gap, we conduct experiments on
three text classification datasets by either (1) finetuning all parameters or
(2) using adapter modules. Regarding performance and efficiency, we confirm
prior findings that the accuracy of adapter-enhanced models is roughly on par
with that of fully finetuned models, while training time is substantially
reduced. Regarding fairness, we show that adapter modules result in mixed
fairness across sensitive groups. Further investigation reveals that, when the
standard fine-tuned model exhibits limited biases, adapter modules typically do
not introduce extra bias. On the other hand, when the finetuned model exhibits
increased bias, the impact of adapter modules on bias becomes more
unpredictable, introducing the risk of significantly magnifying these biases
for certain groups. Our findings highlight the need for a case-by-case
evaluation rather than a one-size-fits-all judgment.
|
[
-0.31378135085105896,
-0.19401200115680695,
0.41965463757514954,
0.07611707597970963,
-0.09513644874095917,
-0.4542481303215027,
-0.2320980578660965,
-0.6688006520271301,
-0.424951434135437,
0.41879212856292725,
-0.10095266997814178,
-0.1665974110364914,
-0.8919729590415955,
0.06353650242090225,
-0.2792969346046448,
1.4455955028533936,
0.3105526268482208,
-0.09500789642333984,
-0.26447802782058716,
-0.5662751793861389,
-0.5754467248916626,
-0.4856692850589752,
-0.7869616150856018,
-0.4363957345485687,
0.39795225858688354,
0.26714274287223816,
0.7490193247795105,
0.6460550427436829,
0.6582632660865784,
0.28453561663627625,
-0.3057582378387451,
-0.19610217213630676,
-0.14866000413894653,
-0.12517313659191132,
-0.5684277415275574,
-0.7370757460594177,
-0.6123231649398804,
0.24314360320568085,
0.4910500645637512,
0.5784246921539307,
-0.22909435629844666,
0.3320674002170563,
0.29697027802467346,
0.8493847846984863,
-0.7267254590988159,
0.0007241638377308846,
-0.8031322956085205,
0.33255237340927124,
-0.17771843075752258,
-0.11545631289482117,
-0.5618045926094055,
-0.4796372056007385,
0.4721231758594513,
-0.5813645124435425,
0.44960644841194153,
0.07023798674345016,
0.46821942925453186,
0.3758564889431,
-0.38659772276878357,
-0.19877709448337555,
-0.6166679263114929,
0.9460786581039429,
-0.8239336013793945,
0.1303248405456543,
0.14366236329078674,
0.4763708710670471,
-0.0007424185751006007,
-0.754578173160553,
-0.6199305653572083,
0.3533969223499298,
-0.33863189816474915,
0.22859632968902588,
-0.3095230162143707,
0.2785300016403198,
0.41307416558265686,
0.5028247833251953,
-0.44136273860931396,
0.38931190967559814,
-0.36793816089630127,
-0.18957848846912384,
0.5221124887466431,
0.029988164082169533,
0.17580805718898773,
-0.20387998223304749,
-0.090988889336586,
-0.07263705134391785,
-0.11179368942975998,
0.3527442216873169,
0.5252866148948669,
0.3452679216861725,
0.10130862891674042,
0.5027984380722046,
-0.2588140666484833,
0.9075640439987183,
-0.014492378570139408,
-0.07629809528589249,
0.11532000452280045,
-0.20320580899715424,
-0.12014751881361008,
0.08626508712768555,
0.5240141749382019,
0.614285945892334,
0.2865235209465027,
-0.2723723351955414,
-0.29253488779067993,
0.31347984075546265,
0.4517076015472412,
-0.9255192279815674,
-0.20639728009700775,
0.060967449098825455,
-0.9069177508354187,
-0.3922308087348938,
0.013562947511672974,
-0.9601189494132996,
-0.28755322098731995,
-0.17636102437973022,
0.8999037146568298,
-0.06598041206598282,
-0.1747862845659256,
0.4227997958660126,
-0.4893571734428406,
0.13493607938289642,
0.21412263810634613,
-1.0275026559829712,
0.7305758595466614,
0.8231858611106873,
0.9165728092193604,
-0.5188498497009277,
-0.041683536022901535,
-0.591711699962616,
-0.08634213358163834,
0.16018027067184448,
0.8901637196540833,
-0.6320851445198059,
0.012297697365283966,
0.010059303604066372,
-0.05665964260697365,
-0.17524085938930511,
-0.5217925310134888,
0.9094217419624329,
-0.3426385223865509,
0.506162703037262,
-0.08656694740056992,
-0.631479024887085,
-0.21865729987621307,
0.11734270304441452,
-0.7011944651603699,
0.7255376577377319,
0.022506220266222954,
-0.994752824306488,
0.6383642554283142,
-0.8306690454483032,
-0.458405464887619,
-0.19404074549674988,
-0.07657422870397568,
-0.47062060236930847,
0.25490111112594604,
-0.11150187253952026,
0.5579729676246643,
0.03559566289186478,
0.14120104908943176,
-0.16001729667186737,
-0.5390723347663879,
0.3200540244579315,
-0.6340157985687256,
0.5677549242973328,
0.17938372492790222,
-0.4418691098690033,
-0.15239682793617249,
-0.863400936126709,
-0.09963779151439667,
-0.3355797231197357,
-0.7569437623023987,
-0.5538140535354614,
0.1685919165611267,
0.2171119898557663,
0.3683003783226013,
-0.20367246866226196,
-0.6011818647384644,
-0.10084336251020432,
-0.6380835175514221,
0.19557598233222961,
0.95738685131073,
-0.6137900352478027,
0.9069326519966125,
-0.6518346667289734,
0.3353581428527832,
0.021965373307466507,
0.3393488824367523,
0.21727734804153442,
-0.8041233420372009,
-0.7931964993476868,
-0.1527785062789917,
0.5836643576622009,
0.35961803793907166,
-0.4865637421607971,
0.3809150755405426,
-0.24089448153972626,
-0.3166709244251251,
-0.6886771321296692,
-0.277946412563324,
0.3247622549533844,
0.4318007230758667,
0.285843163728714,
-0.477247953414917,
-0.16573819518089294,
-1.0187009572982788,
-0.8488157391548157,
-0.11026152968406677,
-0.16600337624549866,
0.33136963844299316,
0.20539651811122894,
0.00797881931066513,
1.0509425401687622,
-0.4556777775287628,
-0.33199238777160645,
-0.19517138600349426,
-0.12537965178489685,
0.35655051469802856,
0.48414701223373413,
0.8503373861312866,
-0.8569955825805664,
-0.3551909625530243,
0.16533906757831573,
-0.3433423936367035,
-0.2994147539138794,
0.017225785180926323,
-0.17818570137023926,
0.36510536074638367,
0.06030605360865593,
-0.2880277633666992,
0.6705842614173889,
0.6354674696922302,
-0.6207114458084106,
0.24342341721057892,
-0.14743271470069885,
-0.026287468150258064,
-0.7475828528404236,
0.13741645216941833,
-0.16279448568820953,
-0.24131660163402557,
-0.8910936713218689,
-0.14050619304180145,
0.05384015291929245,
0.37908998131752014,
-0.2642609477043152,
0.5730767846107483,
0.1454223245382309,
-0.022244971245527267,
-0.4350080192089081,
0.12533114850521088,
0.16778212785720825,
0.3149159848690033,
-0.181024968624115,
0.6253461837768555,
0.22345012426376343,
-0.9345837831497192,
-0.2700314223766327,
0.03961232677102089,
-0.27512603998184204,
0.6249586939811707,
-0.3679460287094116,
-0.010978071950376034,
-0.20458321273326874,
0.012799879536032677,
-0.6947821974754333,
0.05110572651028633,
0.14249972999095917,
-0.5030508041381836,
0.2210097759962082,
-0.11010174453258514,
-0.1975511610507965,
0.0032333270646631718,
-0.49259066581726074,
0.5776249170303345,
0.5179187655448914,
-0.8197833895683289,
0.7910708785057068,
0.47306573390960693,
0.031065134331583977,
-0.6665337085723877,
-0.8877273797988892,
-0.3703179359436035,
-0.46953633427619934,
-0.40578776597976685,
0.4965192377567291,
-0.11189474910497665,
-0.24582508206367493,
-0.01949455589056015,
-0.39641332626342773,
-0.30908751487731934,
0.255979984998703,
-0.013018117286264896,
-0.010575481690466404,
-0.013425881043076515,
0.24394263327121735,
0.3327989876270294,
-0.20141521096229553,
0.05715271458029747,
-0.392287939786911,
0.1771600842475891,
0.012765021063387394,
-0.05416034907102585,
-0.3698224127292633,
0.19064471125602722,
0.24706226587295532,
0.16873671114444733,
0.7647672295570374,
0.7174502015113831,
-0.42297452688217163,
-0.1837959587574005,
-0.6379810571670532,
0.04147854819893837,
-0.495118111371994,
0.3596170246601105,
-0.1247190609574318,
-0.9501005411148071,
0.46502581238746643,
0.2750968933105469,
0.35373473167419434,
0.5638559460639954,
0.16750966012477875,
0.2930471897125244,
0.9791320562362671,
0.9277442097663879,
0.06475305557250977,
0.6026004552841187,
0.19873420894145966,
0.3617032468318939,
-0.7367302775382996,
-0.22207526862621307,
-0.8186578154563904,
-0.4193699061870575,
-0.9915628433227539,
-0.10331876575946808,
0.049373775720596313,
-0.13398173451423645,
0.06421129405498505,
0.23484355211257935,
-0.805766761302948,
0.546016275882721,
0.43732699751853943,
0.13768377900123596,
0.6043025851249695,
0.02089916542172432,
0.20469555258750916,
-0.18367506563663483,
-1.0556073188781738,
-0.6768729090690613,
1.2739973068237305,
0.31172290444374084,
0.4470891058444977,
0.42925477027893066,
0.3370533883571625,
0.3039247989654541,
0.4655046761035919,
-0.8523786067962646,
0.29315680265426636,
-0.762782096862793,
-0.670845091342926,
-0.013474967330694199,
-0.644496738910675,
-0.9247299432754517,
0.37837475538253784,
-0.3739742338657379,
-0.56623774766922,
0.41888627409935,
0.26751187443733215,
-0.3385350704193115,
0.3902161419391632,
-0.9322485327720642,
0.7617262601852417,
0.19900193810462952,
-0.21605439484119415,
-0.3042548894882202,
-0.514555037021637,
0.24937492609024048,
-0.2836674749851227,
0.42499327659606934,
-0.08853688091039658,
0.10947597026824951,
1.1609091758728027,
0.01952516660094261,
0.4756864607334137,
-0.27370205521583557,
0.24607780575752258,
-0.016931988298892975,
-0.0811556801199913,
0.018716983497142792,
0.13846716284751892,
-0.5047192573547363,
0.23856016993522644,
0.09798097610473633,
-0.36793091893196106,
-0.5713449716567993,
0.6192367672920227,
-0.6222135424613953,
-0.3798573911190033,
-0.5541762709617615,
-0.49128979444503784,
-0.02597002312541008,
0.14403115212917328,
0.1966957300901413,
0.4408246576786041,
-0.041655510663986206,
0.1490260511636734,
0.7087854743003845,
-0.5013245344161987,
0.631883978843689,
0.5675694942474365,
-0.08388446271419525,
-0.06462300568819046,
0.6836248636245728,
0.26506808400154114,
0.6044405102729797,
0.3818240463733673,
0.43906286358833313,
-0.017001915723085403,
-0.6412765979766846,
-0.25626301765441895,
-0.2995070815086365,
-0.6039937138557434,
-0.45673251152038574,
-0.8943988680839539,
-0.21943782269954681,
-0.25343629717826843,
0.004186341539025307,
-0.2963540256023407,
-0.8893678188323975,
-0.14338545501232147,
-0.012870624661445618,
0.42182210087776184,
0.7728974223136902,
-0.16881349682807922,
0.5265188217163086,
-0.46115410327911377,
0.2647750973701477,
0.5448998808860779,
0.8837450742721558,
0.05024256557226181,
-0.9323873519897461,
-0.2612434923648834,
-0.28405389189720154,
-0.38463616371154785,
-0.36995893716812134,
-0.032326728105545044,
0.32087716460227966,
0.6947615146636963,
0.3050929009914398,
0.08359796553850174,
0.2885586619377136,
-0.6299476027488708,
0.4678610563278198,
0.07428864389657974,
-0.8899090886116028,
0.3650675117969513,
-0.09383886307477951,
0.17783980071544647,
0.7507750988006592,
-0.06060294806957245,
-0.4873770475387573,
-0.27432188391685486,
-0.4089450240135193,
-0.7124285697937012,
1.2215079069137573,
0.4671604335308075,
0.18957313895225525,
0.18495219945907593,
0.6893882751464844,
0.5981137752532959,
0.08401001244783401,
-0.9551238417625427,
-0.26646679639816284,
-0.12504571676254272,
-0.2884562313556671,
0.11833439022302628,
-0.2199157327413559,
0.1733378767967224,
-0.4060460329055786,
0.3972470164299011,
-0.18005481362342834,
0.407892107963562,
0.2482995241880417,
-0.04801778867840767,
0.2628341615200043,
0.5254450440406799,
0.30177226662635803,
0.5026983618736267,
-0.238003209233284,
0.3410448431968689,
0.3868533670902252,
-0.7010886669158936,
-0.13146434724330902,
0.08085141330957413,
-0.12289857119321823,
0.1118864193558693,
0.30267155170440674,
0.5688497424125671,
0.008838187903165817,
-0.35351288318634033,
0.6457177400588989,
-0.6076422333717346,
-0.06377648562192917,
0.28567245602607727,
0.45123374462127686,
-0.3367255926132202,
0.19139458239078522,
0.03255346789956093,
0.7254784107208252,
0.7416799664497375,
-0.3438348174095154,
0.04622497037053108,
0.3528604805469513,
-0.3045945465564728,
-0.2730792164802551,
0.46345165371894836,
0.19295747578144073,
-0.5935700535774231,
0.14174607396125793,
-0.14349347352981567,
-0.47954070568084717,
0.5289154052734375,
0.5014638900756836,
0.8061466813087463,
-0.2484229952096939,
0.0420696884393692,
0.13966794312000275,
0.4417716860771179,
-0.3421160876750946,
-0.15781007707118988,
-0.06558618694543839,
-0.7225366830825806,
-0.3355148136615753,
-0.8323988318443298,
-0.28574979305267334,
-0.19361695647239685,
-1.0490291118621826,
0.14488095045089722,
-0.29704567790031433,
-0.2817820608615875,
0.02016296051442623,
-0.1606651395559311,
-0.8357773423194885,
0.1815524399280548,
-0.10070857405662537,
0.9950498938560486,
-0.785513699054718,
0.5468499064445496,
0.7467679977416992,
0.20006999373435974,
-0.2547488212585449,
0.22658592462539673,
-0.23449577391147614,
-0.36959707736968994,
0.12559166550636292,
0.6824389696121216,
-0.09457731246948242,
-0.3029501438140869,
-0.13826441764831543,
-0.3869815170764923,
0.8343330025672913,
0.2819209098815918,
-0.6026450991630554,
0.24849362671375275,
0.28560951352119446,
0.6534567475318909,
-0.1816636174917221,
0.3558723032474518,
0.9195646643638611,
0.3465827703475952,
-0.5619481205940247,
-1.1151037216186523,
-0.002424362814053893,
-0.24573247134685516,
0.14302335679531097,
-0.013510167598724365,
-0.5666030049324036,
0.5236491560935974,
0.10508963465690613,
-0.01891389675438404,
-0.0809139609336853,
0.2533889710903168,
-0.06643569469451904,
0.6335432529449463,
0.7191585302352905,
0.4324946403503418,
0.6653273701667786,
-0.08190704882144928,
1.0764318704605103,
0.19732961058616638,
0.28771737217903137,
0.7629179358482361,
0.04502975195646286,
0.7502792477607727,
0.4489791691303253,
-0.3191726803779602,
0.31163913011550903,
0.24572458863258362,
0.38434773683547974,
0.6383113861083984,
0.009570995345711708,
-0.3494102358818054,
-0.20541337132453918,
-0.10929307341575623,
-0.3243400454521179,
0.4340353310108185,
0.09542305767536163,
-0.20662984251976013,
0.0007256189128383994,
-0.054266367107629776,
-0.0195799358189106,
0.34324899315834045,
-0.2701512575149536,
0.9047936201095581,
0.12368863075971603,
-0.6531928181648254,
-0.305132657289505,
0.2479206621646881,
1.2897473573684692,
-0.2500048577785492,
0.05891096964478493,
-0.1698266863822937,
0.5759492516517639,
-0.4181053340435028,
-0.9576279520988464,
0.6884899735450745,
0.08944990485906601,
-0.6142557263374329,
-0.0752933919429779,
0.8209241628646851,
-0.053436193615198135,
-0.4250045120716095,
0.5031306147575378,
0.15554314851760864,
-0.04448487609624863,
0.06016959995031357,
-0.4471954107284546,
-0.22369873523712158,
-0.051067449152469635,
-0.18393300473690033,
0.5645508170127869,
0.5166812539100647,
0.22614891827106476,
0.3178147077560425,
0.4749249517917633,
-0.044860001653432846,
0.0893273800611496,
0.11813519150018692,
0.8111300468444824,
-0.5375357866287231,
-0.3635077476501465,
-1.0374760627746582,
0.4818153977394104,
-0.3193717896938324,
-0.46052953600883484,
0.5444695949554443,
0.5718977451324463,
1.0157350301742554,
0.18593482673168182,
0.6934064626693726,
0.09968248009681702,
0.39916762709617615,
-0.6152711510658264,
0.8930004835128784,
-0.4370330572128296,
0.3867477476596832,
-0.330284982919693,
-0.9229345917701721,
-0.6036795973777771,
0.828258752822876,
-0.1961938589811325,
0.051717836409807205,
0.578591525554657,
0.4471924304962158,
-0.30769798159599304,
0.2426779419183731,
0.1833925098180771,
0.04731326550245285,
0.46624109148979187,
0.4312974214553833,
0.6188219785690308,
-0.687654972076416,
0.6820783615112305,
-0.2049574851989746,
-0.42563292384147644,
-0.015358836390078068,
-0.828984797000885,
-1.1244889497756958,
-0.1850435584783554,
-0.1159016415476799,
-0.29275545477867126,
0.21668122708797455,
0.5674464106559753,
0.5589866042137146,
-0.8118212819099426,
-0.07204370200634003,
-0.03140382841229439,
0.3044470250606537,
0.02507111057639122,
-0.26609793305397034,
0.09328609704971313,
-0.30663713812828064,
-0.5524708032608032,
-0.2029799222946167,
0.2953640818595886,
-0.2768212854862213,
0.2550516426563263,
-0.12622755765914917,
0.06396199762821198,
0.09182466566562653,
0.7545440793037415,
-0.2111991047859192,
-0.3668961524963379,
-0.4136432111263275,
-0.20217524468898773,
0.06688347458839417,
0.044372670352458954,
0.7149285674095154,
-0.9167441129684448,
0.4795762896537781,
0.4632553160190582,
0.7722308039665222,
0.21416983008384705,
-0.35868582129478455,
0.4923921823501587,
-0.6172345280647278,
0.11411171406507492,
0.07914730161428452,
0.19280579686164856,
0.23263317346572876,
-0.30005475878715515,
0.4390527307987213,
-0.0244005024433136,
-0.8834284543991089,
-0.9625643491744995,
0.059694260358810425,
-0.8887218236923218,
-0.24637626111507416,
1.1203614473342896,
-0.013704662211239338,
0.12761950492858887,
-0.32623112201690674,
-0.30500203371047974,
0.29120510816574097,
-0.3003743290901184,
1.0218642950057983,
0.6286846995353699,
-0.1260034739971161,
0.4119263291358948,
-0.7807654738426208,
0.6472810506820679,
0.6871911883354187,
-0.8241646885871887,
-0.08542627841234207,
0.12759555876255035,
0.33311229944229126,
0.028394190594553947,
0.41222718358039856,
-0.14570176601409912,
0.2539219558238983,
-0.34450700879096985,
-0.11949460953474045,
0.3158486783504486,
-0.15868718922138214,
-0.7252094149589539,
0.03199020028114319,
0.05590442568063736,
-0.04085899889469147
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01997v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01997v1
|
Exploring Combinatorial Problem Solving with Large Language Models: A Case Study on the Travelling Salesman Problem Using GPT-3.5 Turbo
| 2024-05-03T10:54:14 | 2024-05-03T10:54:14 |
Mahmoud Masoud, Ahmed Abdelhay, Mohammed Elhenawy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are deep learning models designed to generate
text based on textual input. Although researchers have been developing these
models for more complex tasks such as code generation and general reasoning,
few efforts have explored how LLMs can be applied to combinatorial problems. In
this research, we investigate the potential of LLMs to solve the Travelling
Salesman Problem (TSP). Utilizing GPT-3.5 Turbo, we conducted experiments
employing various approaches, including zero-shot in-context learning, few-shot
in-context learning, and chain-of-thoughts (CoT). Consequently, we fine-tuned
GPT-3.5 Turbo to solve a specific problem size and tested it using a set of
various instance sizes. The fine-tuned models demonstrated promising
performance on problems identical in size to the training instances and
generalized well to larger problems. Furthermore, to improve the performance of
the fine-tuned model without incurring additional training costs, we adopted a
self-ensemble approach to improve the quality of the solutions.
|
[
-0.2766447365283966,
-0.6688826680183411,
0.9476303458213806,
0.30524611473083496,
-0.35924032330513,
0.3606533110141754,
-0.5578727722167969,
-0.48511162400245667,
-0.12151671946048737,
0.42936933040618896,
-0.6652902960777283,
-0.025745799764990807,
-0.4155927002429962,
0.2722374200820923,
-0.35575762391090393,
0.7119395136833191,
-0.019218433648347855,
-0.015028716996312141,
0.08346477150917053,
0.15019354224205017,
-0.623822033405304,
-0.5850186944007874,
-0.8008726239204407,
-0.4535110294818878,
0.4025781452655792,
0.3628835678100586,
0.421871542930603,
0.33624646067619324,
0.4402431845664978,
0.29630619287490845,
-0.018670622259378433,
0.1887025386095047,
-0.5431764125823975,
0.2883133292198181,
-0.3225323259830475,
-0.2442319393157959,
0.0038681079167872667,
-0.2818889021873474,
0.6837571859359741,
0.5469897985458374,
-0.26514482498168945,
0.08857684582471848,
0.06982118636369705,
0.34174126386642456,
-0.1851516216993332,
0.14536473155021667,
-0.8456466197967529,
-0.018202971667051315,
0.029005078598856926,
-0.41439637541770935,
-0.2810027599334717,
-0.014647264033555984,
0.11764869093894958,
-0.40252622961997986,
0.22686126828193665,
0.0035272990353405476,
0.5032748579978943,
0.1634906679391861,
-0.4387730658054352,
-0.44007614254951477,
-1.0892308950424194,
0.9608968496322632,
-0.8644410371780396,
0.19471922516822815,
-0.0052413251250982285,
0.1661849170923233,
-0.32846957445144653,
-0.5431947708129883,
-0.5984886288642883,
-0.03613005578517914,
0.23067599534988403,
-0.062035176903009415,
-0.12326392531394958,
-0.3455173373222351,
0.21050746738910675,
0.24770356714725494,
-0.8779831528663635,
0.33548182249069214,
-0.3735261857509613,
0.19421496987342834,
0.6984242796897888,
0.42999303340911865,
0.2178499549627304,
0.11891589313745499,
-0.1229286715388298,
-0.05001431703567505,
-0.6592122316360474,
-0.3007231056690216,
0.15317964553833008,
0.4686509966850281,
0.06306640803813934,
0.26877954602241516,
-0.1097261905670166,
0.875491738319397,
-0.24720609188079834,
-0.14678345620632172,
-0.008971689268946648,
-0.29422950744628906,
-0.3661941587924957,
-0.11543536931276321,
0.7904170155525208,
-0.04556591808795929,
0.6650766134262085,
-0.343560129404068,
-0.1908111870288849,
-0.41947051882743835,
0.06432494521141052,
-0.8286575675010681,
0.01452544517815113,
0.057620298117399216,
-0.23513655364513397,
-0.3594714105129242,
-0.31351304054260254,
-0.6498425602912903,
-0.030430972576141357,
-0.287896066904068,
0.41670018434524536,
-0.5930204391479492,
-0.3007984757423401,
0.19652248919010162,
0.06179548054933548,
0.4926891028881073,
0.18966558575630188,
-0.9744809865951538,
0.12195247411727905,
0.7569137215614319,
1.0927773714065552,
-0.18639029562473297,
-0.5520094633102417,
-0.42158475518226624,
0.3930235803127289,
-0.3107088506221771,
0.8403410911560059,
-0.6767788529396057,
-0.5542947053909302,
-0.09592177718877792,
-0.21491986513137817,
-0.3314432203769684,
-0.6155964136123657,
0.18517421185970306,
-0.3789414167404175,
0.17452305555343628,
0.02609383687376976,
-0.5924549698829651,
-0.06788156181573868,
0.49907368421554565,
-0.37136730551719666,
0.7797420620918274,
0.14596496522426605,
-0.3800044655799866,
-0.10317418724298477,
-0.41755086183547974,
-0.5928995013237,
0.3708975613117218,
-0.309943288564682,
-0.42907553911209106,
0.44266170263290405,
0.17447909712791443,
0.5249025225639343,
-0.3158522844314575,
0.19002293050289154,
-0.10736440122127533,
-0.48534104228019714,
0.1878785789012909,
-0.3464248776435852,
0.7724151015281677,
0.20257890224456787,
-0.34944334626197815,
0.04467993602156639,
-0.35731232166290283,
0.20704150199890137,
0.4726105332374573,
-0.21485434472560883,
-0.14075763523578644,
0.08925367146730423,
-0.09533487260341644,
0.2455962747335434,
0.07602092623710632,
-0.2729697823524475,
0.6979522705078125,
-0.34690892696380615,
0.7457726001739502,
0.768519401550293,
0.24478544294834137,
0.045602574944496155,
-0.13246862590312958,
0.6823617815971375,
-0.14299069344997406,
-0.15616345405578613,
0.027836797758936882,
-0.5974968671798706,
-0.7626081109046936,
0.2964473068714142,
0.2647065222263336,
0.3523663580417633,
-0.7682271599769592,
0.02366654947400093,
-0.3506666123867035,
-0.33853742480278015,
0.24317005276679993,
0.05151887610554695,
-0.03133310005068779,
0.25852617621421814,
0.14988161623477936,
0.023703591898083687,
-0.30008527636528015,
-0.6923156380653381,
-0.15659689903259277,
-0.026885204017162323,
-0.05372222885489464,
0.4090767800807953,
0.740297794342041,
-0.2859562933444977,
0.710102915763855,
-0.8207481503486633,
-0.33983278274536133,
-0.4499049782752991,
0.2356228083372116,
0.17346200346946716,
0.4251605272293091,
0.4247433543205261,
-0.32173243165016174,
-0.6272047162055969,
0.08489596843719482,
-0.3508149981498718,
0.01623135432600975,
-0.3037702441215515,
0.1477438062429428,
0.23263590037822723,
0.5109319090843201,
-0.50321364402771,
0.12482225894927979,
0.45922839641571045,
-0.04739471152424812,
0.7253402471542358,
-0.4495496153831482,
-0.32036516070365906,
-1.0482183694839478,
-0.23488357663154602,
0.0872710719704628,
-0.2876502275466919,
-0.5351660847663879,
0.18426315486431122,
-0.22601467370986938,
-0.2846200466156006,
-0.38963648676872253,
0.3492146134376526,
-0.4302579164505005,
-0.1919807344675064,
-0.5073991417884827,
-0.08349578827619553,
-0.2871561646461487,
0.7018234729766846,
0.2975558042526245,
1.1885255575180054,
0.4763214588165283,
-0.5945413708686829,
0.26166853308677673,
-0.006139400415122509,
-0.34535637497901917,
0.2875003516674042,
-0.41812917590141296,
0.3861245810985565,
-0.017601946368813515,
0.3543431758880615,
-0.5963045358657837,
-0.04011169448494911,
-0.08145877718925476,
-0.16281068325042725,
0.11735822260379791,
-0.13103505969047546,
-0.7720809578895569,
-0.5493652820587158,
-0.10072238743305206,
0.672710120677948,
0.4888422191143036,
-0.42899632453918457,
0.40433669090270996,
0.09138137847185135,
-0.19649992883205414,
0.041907425969839096,
-0.5915958285331726,
0.24274969100952148,
-0.4174709618091583,
-0.5061554312705994,
0.336130291223526,
-0.19725526869297028,
0.008684525266289711,
-0.3626675605773926,
-0.061852261424064636,
-0.08432001620531082,
0.15476474165916443,
-0.39841538667678833,
-0.09769593924283981,
-0.11767841130495071,
0.2002154290676117,
-0.38752269744873047,
-0.17834481596946716,
0.10355092585086823,
-0.7702612280845642,
1.005243182182312,
-0.47001680731773376,
0.01862109825015068,
0.03451579809188843,
0.564822793006897,
0.3056873083114624,
-0.3685658276081085,
0.5627819895744324,
0.5307597517967224,
-0.31540077924728394,
-0.664766788482666,
-0.3791147768497467,
0.03786969929933548,
-0.5259777903556824,
0.38713333010673523,
-0.42520442605018616,
-0.9909934401512146,
0.48736947774887085,
-0.15789252519607544,
-0.29831209778785706,
0.35429200530052185,
0.9966106414794922,
-0.05372360348701477,
1.0768909454345703,
0.655523955821991,
-0.12686677277088165,
0.3724130094051361,
-0.5783262848854065,
0.6104942560195923,
-0.9097616076469421,
-0.19681331515312195,
-0.495130330324173,
-0.2155286967754364,
-0.7093128561973572,
-0.5639577507972717,
0.5689584612846375,
-0.06513965874910355,
-0.4040543735027313,
0.340739369392395,
-0.5422019362449646,
0.8751956820487976,
0.6985814571380615,
0.012536236084997654,
0.5306774377822876,
-0.030558567494153976,
-0.06376414000988007,
0.42939913272857666,
-0.784716784954071,
-0.22478601336479187,
1.0809613466262817,
0.03565781190991402,
0.5735015869140625,
0.2693960964679718,
0.7255348563194275,
-0.016606980934739113,
-0.03287223353981972,
-0.8982312083244324,
0.7272633910179138,
-0.18462610244750977,
-0.32220086455345154,
-0.31806957721710205,
-0.669293224811554,
-1.101966381072998,
0.20706376433372498,
0.23684275150299072,
-1.1677720546722412,
-0.08803200721740723,
-0.16293206810951233,
-0.5491745471954346,
0.4974738359451294,
-0.49972134828567505,
0.6678323745727539,
-0.7343004941940308,
-0.3918014466762543,
-0.31180697679519653,
-0.38378992676734924,
0.42466697096824646,
-0.2574009895324707,
0.019558101892471313,
-0.07114467769861221,
0.016975710168480873,
0.6579499244689941,
-0.4708520174026489,
0.5487236380577087,
0.3221099078655243,
-0.18864434957504272,
0.21860748529434204,
0.25703164935112,
0.5776550769805908,
-0.09806576371192932,
-0.01785172149538994,
0.016139835119247437,
0.04854939132928848,
-0.26907315850257874,
-0.546192467212677,
0.9131910800933838,
-0.7042691707611084,
-0.6703386306762695,
-0.6927545070648193,
-0.8089239597320557,
-0.6282004117965698,
0.32623305916786194,
0.17182281613349915,
0.43603309988975525,
0.15527521073818207,
0.11718376725912094,
0.5289196968078613,
-0.19634884595870972,
0.8521319031715393,
0.4929831624031067,
-0.2008783519268036,
-0.13757148385047913,
1.254791021347046,
0.13729095458984375,
0.17473481595516205,
0.16869041323661804,
0.4906157851219177,
-0.28322386741638184,
-0.9608713984489441,
-0.38713598251342773,
0.3086598217487335,
-0.46403968334198,
-0.2590940296649933,
-0.3763936758041382,
-0.4781861901283264,
-0.2772361934185028,
-0.0863489955663681,
-0.07751727849245071,
-0.21608436107635498,
-0.23437054455280304,
0.22947004437446594,
0.1841629594564438,
0.858050525188446,
0.0452723428606987,
0.6085584163665771,
-0.5776492357254028,
0.06037244573235512,
0.512978196144104,
0.7162171006202698,
0.3822857439517975,
-0.26225346326828003,
-0.4679233431816101,
-0.15112395584583282,
-0.549393892288208,
-0.7546784281730652,
0.660240650177002,
-0.0630856454372406,
0.41161343455314636,
0.10085251927375793,
-0.26784732937812805,
0.7416983842849731,
-0.5326048135757446,
0.7572055459022522,
-0.15077762305736542,
-0.80625319480896,
0.3054227828979492,
-0.9047004580497742,
0.44538256525993347,
0.4537135660648346,
0.21289335191249847,
-0.46201497316360474,
-0.14858371019363403,
-0.799620509147644,
-0.8437964916229248,
0.6331523656845093,
0.5449378490447998,
-0.05332185700535774,
0.05985875055193901,
0.3334745168685913,
-0.12323591858148575,
0.2695261240005493,
-0.8712947368621826,
0.07770338654518127,
0.1282956898212433,
-0.039313528686761856,
-0.27645909786224365,
-0.09223009645938873,
0.22194428741931915,
-0.32943129539489746,
0.9131437540054321,
-0.162139430642128,
0.24702808260917664,
-0.009995263069868088,
-0.08899091184139252,
-0.026780566200613976,
0.32318705320358276,
0.8841744065284729,
0.8212493062019348,
-0.2372739166021347,
-0.06663776189088821,
0.17568610608577728,
-0.23408669233322144,
0.16836662590503693,
-0.1460593342781067,
-0.1154940202832222,
-0.38212522864341736,
0.2572590708732605,
0.601631224155426,
-0.24046307802200317,
-0.803529679775238,
0.38822922110557556,
0.030216248705983162,
-0.30552250146865845,
-0.3839137852191925,
0.02015356905758381,
0.22555102407932281,
0.19912588596343994,
0.4246053695678711,
-0.3513777256011963,
0.14904752373695374,
-0.6269776225090027,
0.02974836528301239,
0.7267046570777893,
-0.042523764073848724,
-0.0009735578205436468,
0.38378050923347473,
0.3180798292160034,
-0.7446157336235046,
0.8599981665611267,
-0.35150253772735596,
-0.9831449389457703,
0.7841542959213257,
0.9897080063819885,
1.051198959350586,
0.02315945364534855,
0.2684944272041321,
0.029037663713097572,
0.43208321928977966,
-0.21445897221565247,
0.008277378976345062,
-0.1775645762681961,
-0.695976972579956,
-0.7359318137168884,
-0.45878171920776367,
-0.6421322226524353,
0.6702718138694763,
-0.18096254765987396,
0.0038907607086002827,
-0.32251638174057007,
0.32416921854019165,
-0.38102057576179504,
0.3176731765270233,
-0.7269275784492493,
0.049658775329589844,
0.42725256085395813,
0.589806079864502,
-0.5869718790054321,
0.9164981245994568,
0.4103895127773285,
-0.2510456144809723,
-1.1649173498153687,
0.4012730121612549,
-0.3034609854221344,
-0.832144021987915,
0.39980843663215637,
0.31357139348983765,
-0.2046128362417221,
0.27496305108070374,
-0.4206998646259308,
-0.9949696063995361,
0.935967206954956,
0.18552862107753754,
-0.76650071144104,
-0.04788976535201073,
0.5301717519760132,
0.4917352795600891,
-0.44506072998046875,
0.23446941375732422,
0.8345177173614502,
0.3091730773448944,
0.20232358574867249,
-0.933078408241272,
-0.12533076107501984,
0.020173246040940285,
0.2332727313041687,
0.3916281461715698,
-0.9409887790679932,
0.8557904958724976,
0.0036136640701442957,
0.07873506098985672,
0.16264192759990692,
0.4047684371471405,
0.41188955307006836,
-0.033716753125190735,
0.5296488404273987,
0.6076698303222656,
0.7033717036247253,
0.12099700421094894,
0.9918510317802429,
-0.19278386235237122,
0.6716002225875854,
1.2779934406280518,
-0.47817644476890564,
0.726746141910553,
0.5203347206115723,
-0.17293645441532135,
0.6177653074264526,
0.6377320885658264,
-0.11845533549785614,
0.36538273096084595,
0.6128259897232056,
-0.3172796666622162,
-0.4223664700984955,
0.22408954799175262,
-0.3602212965488434,
0.47344425320625305,
0.3324379026889801,
-0.14496998488903046,
-0.5630112290382385,
0.07804824411869049,
-0.2671835124492645,
-0.28960293531417847,
-0.49401065707206726,
0.7242433428764343,
0.08293864876031876,
-0.7372639179229736,
0.4137103855609894,
0.09910845011472702,
0.4906081557273865,
-0.551516056060791,
0.13378022611141205,
-0.21446850895881653,
0.28266701102256775,
0.01766580156981945,
-0.7646881341934204,
0.3823578953742981,
-0.008958975784480572,
0.11645368486642838,
-0.3066033720970154,
0.5812967419624329,
-0.28973209857940674,
-1.0228602886199951,
0.004354552365839481,
0.5844435691833496,
0.13193576037883759,
-0.2933317720890045,
-0.539271354675293,
0.034700874239206314,
0.09958754479885101,
-0.17462953925132751,
0.43001100420951843,
0.3789604604244232,
-0.08245687931776047,
0.8929821252822876,
0.49664050340652466,
0.10445452481508255,
-0.010080349631607533,
0.08457071334123611,
0.7306063771247864,
-0.8855229616165161,
-0.6630297303199768,
-0.9775161147117615,
0.09553927183151245,
0.02513863705098629,
-0.22849278151988983,
0.6355832815170288,
0.7654338479042053,
0.8442854881286621,
-0.05694357678294182,
0.7997502684593201,
0.2713748514652252,
0.25533464550971985,
-0.5209442377090454,
0.22671687602996826,
-0.4744918942451477,
0.6176111102104187,
-0.11998843401670456,
-0.9191567301750183,
-0.30077892541885376,
0.6677672863006592,
-0.4601634442806244,
0.08300361782312393,
0.8113457560539246,
0.47556132078170776,
-0.14406222105026245,
0.12130117416381836,
0.06622853130102158,
0.2308434098958969,
0.572014570236206,
1.0597646236419678,
0.8873453140258789,
-0.14877009391784668,
0.8401408791542053,
-0.3505999445915222,
0.12146572768688202,
-0.13893525302410126,
-1.0879734754562378,
-0.8368186354637146,
-0.42533957958221436,
-0.2845999300479889,
-0.2702315151691437,
0.013144193217158318,
0.8529109358787537,
0.6411808133125305,
-0.4185328185558319,
-0.5953817963600159,
-0.5664138197898865,
0.23253214359283447,
-0.26977992057800293,
-0.2661166489124298,
0.2235872894525528,
-0.4394616484642029,
-0.5997332334518433,
0.441850870847702,
0.2226056009531021,
0.19311846792697906,
-0.47150304913520813,
0.1498924195766449,
-0.06547041237354279,
0.18719600141048431,
0.6077467799186707,
0.15825627744197845,
-0.47500208020210266,
-0.4071630835533142,
-0.07185027748346329,
0.2783907949924469,
0.1087004765868187,
1.230220913887024,
-1.0366970300674438,
-0.06160181015729904,
0.28920742869377136,
0.6216354966163635,
1.0685832500457764,
0.006153229158371687,
0.7789929509162903,
-0.6731873750686646,
0.03578924387693405,
0.48385369777679443,
0.42330315709114075,
0.15315765142440796,
-0.31293004751205444,
0.6715957522392273,
0.15010222792625427,
-0.7496020197868347,
-0.8087917566299438,
0.4277178645133972,
-1.2313661575317383,
-0.6502392888069153,
1.3764251470565796,
0.4707155227661133,
-0.1877189576625824,
0.061436742544174194,
-0.02368977665901184,
-0.16853474080562592,
-0.19594651460647583,
0.5923740863800049,
0.6555957794189453,
-0.5095270276069641,
-0.22131064534187317,
-0.4535196125507355,
0.2232995480298996,
0.36425307393074036,
-0.7319075465202332,
0.11537561565637589,
0.23459620773792267,
0.38034552335739136,
-0.059929512441158295,
0.6235681772232056,
0.45071715116500854,
-0.11592364311218262,
-0.364063024520874,
-0.45678800344467163,
-0.19653768837451935,
-0.2435535341501236,
-0.38286092877388,
0.28152328729629517,
-0.0014454988995566964,
0.010862641967833042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01988v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01988v1
|
Joint sentiment analysis of lyrics and audio in music
| 2024-05-03T10:42:17 | 2024-05-03T10:42:17 |
Lea Schaab, Anna Kruspe
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
Sentiment or mood can express themselves on various levels in music. In
automatic analysis, the actual audio data is usually analyzed, but the lyrics
can also play a crucial role in the perception of moods. We first evaluate
various models for sentiment analysis based on lyrics and audio separately. The
corresponding approaches already show satisfactory results, but they also
exhibit weaknesses, the causes of which we examine in more detail. Furthermore,
different approaches to combining the audio and lyrics results are proposed and
evaluated. Considering both modalities generally leads to improved performance.
We investigate misclassifications and (also intentional) contradictions between
audio and lyrics sentiment more closely, and identify possible causes. Finally,
we address fundamental problems in this research area, such as high
subjectivity, lack of data, and inconsistency in emotion taxonomies.
|
[
-0.6244667172431946,
-0.5792405605316162,
0.5713229179382324,
0.668045699596405,
-0.1826276034116745,
0.3586146831512451,
-0.12270025908946991,
-0.6744211912155151,
0.5086419582366943,
0.3239310383796692,
-0.7181283831596375,
-0.6526732444763184,
-0.7719250321388245,
0.18294869363307953,
-0.28610754013061523,
1.2136809825897217,
0.13208438456058502,
0.30712270736694336,
-0.30565550923347473,
-0.5415393114089966,
-0.7772813439369202,
-0.5135905742645264,
-0.5579522252082825,
-0.005180957727134228,
0.7402337789535522,
0.36552727222442627,
0.5121556520462036,
-0.2621809244155884,
0.9359094500541687,
0.3192523121833801,
-0.08093230426311493,
-0.22525881230831146,
-0.1095232143998146,
0.38433772325515747,
0.16247223317623138,
-0.37005332112312317,
-0.5852376222610474,
0.3340641260147095,
0.2682814598083496,
0.5279645919799805,
-0.004742754623293877,
0.28357648849487305,
-0.043049219995737076,
0.94558185338974,
-0.36319270730018616,
0.12770816683769226,
-0.35729408264160156,
0.40656113624572754,
-0.3319346308708191,
-0.35739749670028687,
0.07659488916397095,
-0.39086177945137024,
0.3829694986343384,
-0.4253080487251282,
0.02259230427443981,
0.018347332254052162,
0.733111560344696,
0.4734896421432495,
-0.3931192457675934,
-0.6945034861564636,
-0.8771845102310181,
0.8507052063941956,
-0.6138763427734375,
0.19313688576221466,
0.019062761217355728,
0.1945028305053711,
0.1700398474931717,
-0.20317773520946503,
-0.6828402876853943,
-0.04241907596588135,
-0.04105481877923012,
0.7967137694358826,
-0.3598286509513855,
0.06962120532989502,
0.30862173438072205,
0.7471970319747925,
-0.3574700653553009,
-0.40917345881462097,
-0.2434065043926239,
-0.005639242473989725,
0.7703814506530762,
0.34720027446746826,
0.8949400186538696,
-0.6335222125053406,
-0.5018970370292664,
-0.18374384939670563,
-0.4418959319591522,
0.4884134829044342,
0.7949708700180054,
0.34876224398612976,
-0.17650561034679413,
0.6541962027549744,
0.2172269970178604,
0.5737526416778564,
-0.04073265194892883,
-0.24803292751312256,
0.3177544176578522,
-0.4085674285888672,
-0.16322214901447296,
0.20088717341423035,
1.2133413553237915,
0.551687479019165,
-0.10570992529392242,
-0.14322426915168762,
-0.6558011174201965,
0.6258687973022461,
0.16306225955486298,
-0.09665477275848389,
-0.17049114406108856,
0.5104974508285522,
-0.576257586479187,
-0.20726196467876434,
0.1698145568370819,
-1.1026393175125122,
-0.45854127407073975,
-0.8438377976417542,
0.940885603427887,
-0.21233753859996796,
-0.45625585317611694,
0.17010699212551117,
-0.4635872542858124,
-0.1618867665529251,
-0.12742581963539124,
-0.457636296749115,
0.31615525484085083,
0.7279139757156372,
0.8502935767173767,
0.054573941975831985,
0.054609980434179306,
-0.24501964449882507,
-0.3282155990600586,
-0.23068788647651672,
0.9151548743247986,
-0.4681376814842224,
-0.46028316020965576,
-0.31038451194763184,
-0.24712559580802917,
-0.199432373046875,
-0.5812221169471741,
0.7736181616783142,
-0.21788494288921356,
0.349793016910553,
-0.6965274214744568,
-0.5726203322410583,
-0.16134542226791382,
-0.15611550211906433,
-0.9867742657661438,
0.7881947755813599,
0.07224410772323608,
-1.0535893440246582,
0.3547830879688263,
-0.7689087986946106,
-0.37404775619506836,
-0.47000402212142944,
-0.07444705069065094,
-0.4939572513103485,
0.5564079880714417,
-0.016463903710246086,
0.24386826157569885,
-0.15459398925304413,
0.12842191755771637,
-0.48593640327453613,
-0.5504646301269531,
0.5981902480125427,
0.06260016560554504,
0.6290587782859802,
0.3049580454826355,
-0.26865923404693604,
0.18203142285346985,
-0.7053913474082947,
-0.26915085315704346,
-0.08127111941576004,
-0.17969249188899994,
-0.6554937958717346,
0.4328065812587738,
0.5039941668510437,
0.2187460958957672,
0.10167668014764786,
-0.5705199241638184,
-0.019747985526919365,
-0.5062053799629211,
0.14223040640354156,
0.42224645614624023,
0.2437252402305603,
0.38898733258247375,
-0.2953890562057495,
0.6904352903366089,
0.16446378827095032,
0.13811133801937103,
0.40698060393333435,
-0.37862086296081543,
-0.41393664479255676,
0.11260534077882767,
0.3206401765346527,
0.6286150813102722,
-0.1548204869031906,
0.3139794170856476,
-0.025966834276914597,
-0.27157706022262573,
-0.9101654291152954,
0.03457920253276825,
0.15392445027828217,
0.461615651845932,
0.4352877736091614,
-0.39137202501296997,
-0.9278810620307922,
-0.6776008009910583,
-0.6308611035346985,
-0.13900229334831238,
0.31645849347114563,
0.15313847362995148,
0.025664471089839935,
0.0735340416431427,
1.019987940788269,
-0.19241701066493988,
-0.5296918749809265,
-0.1619682013988495,
0.5122538805007935,
0.4502332806587219,
0.3663427233695984,
0.8289515972137451,
-0.8588313460350037,
-0.5380939245223999,
-0.2685534656047821,
-0.6083999276161194,
-0.5531694889068604,
-0.0895608440041542,
-0.0865509882569313,
-0.12122713029384613,
0.08231839537620544,
-0.44596636295318604,
0.09085368365049362,
0.556013822555542,
-0.34148186445236206,
0.2523598372936249,
0.5781505703926086,
0.5387718677520752,
-0.7057715058326721,
-0.34969550371170044,
0.2584906816482544,
0.15711122751235962,
-0.5344033241271973,
-0.5179084539413452,
-0.48330941796302795,
-0.024522127583622932,
-0.044080231338739395,
-0.17550207674503326,
-0.2138841450214386,
-0.5187187194824219,
-0.4238913357257843,
0.3321605920791626,
0.11505252122879028,
0.15391883254051208,
-0.2460646778345108,
0.4642344117164612,
0.8254812359809875,
-0.057660870254039764,
0.7757041454315186,
0.05356921628117561,
-0.39670437574386597,
0.8583799600601196,
-0.6802056431770325,
0.030862988904118538,
-0.3905865550041199,
0.003508330788463354,
-1.3995126485824585,
-0.23521295189857483,
0.4178345501422882,
-0.6233842372894287,
0.44490134716033936,
-0.16490012407302856,
-0.4039662480354309,
-0.19177882373332977,
-0.12693199515342712,
0.34258759021759033,
0.35965853929519653,
-0.2449517548084259,
0.44045811891555786,
0.7190492153167725,
-0.27022069692611694,
-0.5406449437141418,
-0.42410117387771606,
0.011795537546277046,
-0.8692246079444885,
-0.6300612688064575,
0.12204848974943161,
0.02053520269691944,
-0.8674474954605103,
0.15534792840480804,
-0.3090863823890686,
0.06465210020542145,
0.005807210225611925,
0.5062922835350037,
0.2158805876970291,
-0.22046151757240295,
0.48908448219299316,
0.13754211366176605,
-0.15072934329509735,
0.458368182182312,
-0.014784562401473522,
0.26868435740470886,
-0.23141483962535858,
-0.016966449096798897,
-0.5792723298072815,
0.8200674653053284,
0.6786447167396545,
-0.25161880254745483,
0.2546171247959137,
0.61434006690979,
0.0644862949848175,
0.14606784284114838,
-0.23563914000988007,
0.27294251322746277,
-0.3646375238895416,
-0.053345974534749985,
-0.21833555400371552,
-0.42370474338531494,
0.551447868347168,
0.17827340960502625,
-0.26520079374313354,
0.653824508190155,
0.37119293212890625,
-0.8980345129966736,
1.3789503574371338,
0.42994076013565063,
-0.20110861957073212,
0.4988008439540863,
-0.16729994118213654,
0.21186216175556183,
-0.8317854404449463,
-0.14751720428466797,
-0.6547592878341675,
-0.6143919229507446,
-0.9053720235824585,
0.37695783376693726,
0.618213951587677,
0.1564173400402069,
0.00824127160012722,
0.08742077648639679,
-0.5828335285186768,
0.3820785582065582,
0.2751285135746002,
-0.006456058472394943,
0.004623375367373228,
-0.2791837751865387,
0.10186416655778885,
-0.05661586672067642,
-0.2030719369649887,
-0.4665292501449585,
0.9306816458702087,
0.3186257481575012,
0.4212159812450409,
0.3830455243587494,
0.7931995391845703,
0.19529451429843903,
0.09617360681295395,
-1.2522730827331543,
0.08576460927724838,
-0.2831460237503052,
-0.628947913646698,
-0.12697871029376984,
-0.34434521198272705,
-0.5802010893821716,
0.08568022400140762,
-0.37858110666275024,
-0.6260058283805847,
0.22851459681987762,
-0.0025219754315912724,
-0.32006680965423584,
0.0370885394513607,
-0.7085687518119812,
0.9352255463600159,
-0.05368014797568321,
0.07407668232917786,
0.07268589735031128,
-0.6352657675743103,
0.4369862973690033,
0.13191910088062286,
0.6630281805992126,
-0.5314878821372986,
0.19535428285598755,
1.0341628789901733,
-0.20028144121170044,
0.5273219347000122,
-0.45570045709609985,
-0.2774323523044586,
0.37610840797424316,
-0.06525587290525436,
0.006032572593539953,
0.16808059811592102,
0.12193001806735992,
0.016076665371656418,
0.3294112980365753,
-0.1046680212020874,
-0.8397714495658875,
0.8655766248703003,
-0.9405018091201782,
-0.41233178973197937,
-0.2841571867465973,
-0.5831361413002014,
-0.692548930644989,
-0.32991835474967957,
0.4672130346298218,
0.5620788335800171,
0.3204062879085541,
0.03197476640343666,
0.26338857412338257,
-0.17627693712711334,
0.4946201741695404,
-0.047539837658405304,
-0.2994675636291504,
-0.6112673282623291,
0.7804821729660034,
0.09403359889984131,
0.22268855571746826,
0.19204729795455933,
0.5005497932434082,
-0.4209756851196289,
-0.3185017704963684,
-0.22744643688201904,
0.011632450856268406,
-0.8525136113166809,
-0.10673430562019348,
-0.571330726146698,
0.5010409355163574,
-0.2838355302810669,
0.36904436349868774,
-0.39046573638916016,
-0.4131065607070923,
-0.09037208557128906,
-0.0033314351458102465,
0.6274484395980835,
0.7142626047134399,
-0.31325358152389526,
0.3392690122127533,
-1.1438648700714111,
0.5562272667884827,
0.21540206670761108,
0.3833717703819275,
-0.1651681810617447,
-0.01906684599816799,
-0.1842135190963745,
-0.08862246572971344,
-0.2894214987754822,
-1.638136625289917,
0.2087911069393158,
-0.03939171880483627,
0.1837853193283081,
0.273192822933197,
0.01963072642683983,
0.8288728594779968,
-0.06157652661204338,
0.8290207982063293,
0.2900904715061188,
-1.3160457611083984,
0.7109676003456116,
-0.5745988488197327,
-0.27959558367729187,
0.6787353754043579,
0.28093212842941284,
-0.5458635091781616,
-0.5892460346221924,
-0.4858649969100952,
-0.880803108215332,
0.5573256015777588,
0.2312033325433731,
0.1277862936258316,
0.21297934651374817,
0.14387208223342896,
0.12267229706048965,
0.17540904879570007,
-0.7227051258087158,
-0.4601011574268341,
-0.6495428681373596,
-0.40847617387771606,
-0.2652794420719147,
0.011998294852674007,
-0.44772350788116455,
-0.42420724034309387,
0.2649712562561035,
0.34182196855545044,
0.46036654710769653,
0.21681948006153107,
0.22546075284481049,
-0.6428879499435425,
0.4790700078010559,
0.2863632142543793,
0.4286015033721924,
-0.42080157995224,
-0.010253443382680416,
-0.13719148933887482,
-0.31007593870162964,
0.19288592040538788,
-0.4973309636116028,
0.24620476365089417,
0.11610379070043564,
0.40457475185394287,
0.9393109083175659,
0.24785320460796356,
-0.33029767870903015,
0.6765735149383545,
-0.10633562505245209,
-0.023298274725675583,
-0.5007562637329102,
0.1357419192790985,
0.3075350821018219,
0.2657147943973541,
0.20750153064727783,
0.34937599301338196,
0.6500657200813293,
-0.8865014910697937,
0.08323222398757935,
0.42459917068481445,
-0.907586395740509,
-0.35632213950157166,
0.35536450147628784,
-0.1742047369480133,
-0.02688620239496231,
0.21835610270500183,
0.05609115585684776,
-0.5808812379837036,
0.8071920275688171,
0.17804363369941711,
1.0702619552612305,
0.04520945996046066,
-0.04490162432193756,
0.18918369710445404,
-0.14207403361797333,
0.2360716462135315,
0.7747390270233154,
-0.14238078892230988,
-0.40523096919059753,
-0.5409941077232361,
-0.8291608691215515,
-0.4019356369972229,
-0.03702983632683754,
-1.2058682441711426,
0.09709369391202927,
-0.15479707717895508,
-0.4525884985923767,
0.41875165700912476,
-0.08062854409217834,
-0.4842166602611542,
0.5797967314720154,
-0.013239387422800064,
0.32117363810539246,
-1.1714556217193604,
0.3340455889701843,
0.8770116567611694,
-0.6187730431556702,
-1.0173375606536865,
0.17398573458194733,
0.08088981360197067,
0.018833504989743233,
0.8395094275474548,
0.05180644616484642,
-0.45623546838760376,
-0.20573200285434723,
-0.7631879448890686,
-0.6163156628608704,
0.5923154354095459,
-0.33131760358810425,
-0.5336257815361023,
0.2645926773548126,
-0.07774963974952698,
0.8447976112365723,
-0.32524412870407104,
0.041918493807315826,
0.6989971995353699,
0.8088439106941223,
0.26524612307548523,
-0.72989422082901,
-0.5279699563980103,
-0.21515731513500214,
-0.3760024905204773,
0.4423779845237732,
-0.47615793347358704,
1.1155834197998047,
0.33411386609077454,
-0.47381845116615295,
-0.1086050271987915,
0.4659236669540405,
-0.05854997783899307,
0.7730187773704529,
0.8784579038619995,
0.6279189586639404,
0.36257317662239075,
-0.6894239187240601,
1.0224500894546509,
-0.1272289752960205,
0.5920664668083191,
0.6130883097648621,
-0.24099741876125336,
0.716728925704956,
0.5588806867599487,
-0.639822781085968,
0.5682622194290161,
0.681469202041626,
0.1315738707780838,
0.6628180742263794,
0.1570393592119217,
-0.3907303214073181,
-0.4050612449645996,
0.07670614123344421,
-0.36699622869491577,
1.0280694961547852,
0.3360762596130371,
-0.18018579483032227,
0.13658025860786438,
0.2194976657629013,
-0.21141274273395538,
0.0887160673737526,
-0.30505841970443726,
0.912000298500061,
0.23624739050865173,
-0.45944949984550476,
-0.08229630440473557,
-0.2432956099510193,
0.5246391892433167,
0.0223392341285944,
0.030137669295072556,
0.043707121163606644,
-0.2797676622867584,
-0.5857390761375427,
-0.9053783416748047,
0.7808548212051392,
-0.0061326660215854645,
-0.3266189694404602,
-0.06838078051805496,
0.5816274881362915,
-0.18205949664115906,
-0.269087016582489,
0.5876069664955139,
0.3567405045032501,
-0.09111975878477097,
-0.06446593999862671,
-0.5593238472938538,
0.20095883309841156,
-0.24852445721626282,
-0.023032531142234802,
0.011972353793680668,
0.5594028830528259,
0.4775168299674988,
0.11305660754442215,
0.5878444314002991,
0.5291638970375061,
0.043217238038778305,
0.28259822726249695,
0.6150040030479431,
-0.9211296439170837,
-0.388851135969162,
-0.750999927520752,
0.5195457935333252,
-0.009952498599886894,
-0.10298804938793182,
0.6897770762443542,
0.3139941692352295,
0.49147897958755493,
-0.1400737166404724,
0.8439387679100037,
-0.057943474501371384,
0.9190102815628052,
-0.7698910236358643,
0.6390070915222168,
-0.9452723860740662,
0.4167241156101227,
-1.1048709154129028,
-1.1313362121582031,
-0.33294275403022766,
0.503853440284729,
-0.366369366645813,
-0.04911106079816818,
0.5603370666503906,
0.29139986634254456,
-0.10170584172010422,
0.47911927103996277,
-0.007052633445709944,
0.047030746936798096,
-0.06219994276762009,
0.5938981175422668,
1.6083141565322876,
-0.5786934494972229,
0.2502037286758423,
-0.4920642673969269,
0.043797679245471954,
0.024200526997447014,
-0.7408995032310486,
-0.4747035503387451,
-0.6036555171012878,
-0.44290265440940857,
-0.13865281641483307,
-0.3190070390701294,
0.8517253994941711,
0.3425644636154175,
-0.858722448348999,
-0.18612973392009735,
0.10212160646915436,
0.4265761077404022,
-0.17345279455184937,
-0.3186529874801636,
0.3282531499862671,
-0.495995432138443,
-0.8665048480033875,
0.42902177572250366,
0.32754892110824585,
0.19759467244148254,
-0.20698732137680054,
0.14040251076221466,
0.4008016586303711,
0.346013605594635,
0.4018052816390991,
0.006512331310659647,
-0.7339547872543335,
-0.42725223302841187,
-0.010885660536587238,
-0.03025256097316742,
0.3461746573448181,
1.0433801412582397,
-0.40518414974212646,
0.520261824131012,
0.891533613204956,
-0.1578928530216217,
-0.11906009912490845,
0.08560439199209213,
0.219365194439888,
-0.660969078540802,
-0.368205726146698,
0.23167584836483002,
0.433743417263031,
0.32009974122047424,
-0.15338969230651855,
-0.05195381119847298,
0.31083211302757263,
-0.5167902112007141,
-0.7951290607452393,
0.13979992270469666,
-1.5247564315795898,
-0.012480340898036957,
0.8839672803878784,
-0.07387905567884445,
0.059728819876909256,
-0.0653216764330864,
-0.19715043902397156,
0.6128456592559814,
-0.13056723773479462,
0.818139374256134,
1.0780901908874512,
-0.48023733496665955,
0.048737019300460815,
-0.6657944321632385,
0.6726406216621399,
0.2957109212875366,
-0.5894097685813904,
-0.3120349645614624,
0.7749541401863098,
0.23043707013130188,
0.4817262589931488,
0.28050991892814636,
-0.36135047674179077,
0.2241324931383133,
0.00683952309191227,
-0.0329638347029686,
0.4246827960014343,
-0.5172972083091736,
-0.45540866255760193,
0.45749035477638245,
-0.015512624755501747,
-0.3311513066291809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01976v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01976v1
|
Conformal Prediction for Natural Language Processing: A Survey
| 2024-05-03T10:00:45 | 2024-05-03T10:00:45 |
Margarida M. Campos, António Farinhas, Chrysoula Zerva, Mário A. T. Figueiredo, André F. T. Martins
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The rapid proliferation of large language models and natural language
processing (NLP) applications creates a crucial need for uncertainty
quantification to mitigate risks such as hallucinations and to enhance
decision-making reliability in critical applications. Conformal prediction is
emerging as a theoretically sound and practically useful framework, combining
flexibility with strong statistical guarantees. Its model-agnostic and
distribution-free nature makes it particularly promising to address the current
shortcomings of NLP systems that stem from the absence of uncertainty
quantification. This paper provides a comprehensive survey of conformal
prediction techniques, their guarantees, and existing applications in NLP,
pointing to directions for future research and open challenges.
|
[
-0.48821404576301575,
-0.70573890209198,
0.763285219669342,
0.46480607986450195,
0.07606188952922821,
-0.3183276057243347,
-0.3945365250110626,
-0.927584707736969,
0.09585089981555939,
0.44079500436782837,
-0.6353580951690674,
-0.46855807304382324,
-0.8456129431724548,
0.07959996908903122,
-0.3984362483024597,
0.5307412147521973,
0.26950839161872864,
0.00798576045781374,
-0.23894605040550232,
-0.028450418263673782,
-0.6258050799369812,
-0.5921367406845093,
-0.6674310564994812,
-0.1109485775232315,
0.05284551531076431,
0.035076264292001724,
1.0618304014205933,
0.4031255543231964,
0.6054096817970276,
0.22029124200344086,
-0.2425488531589508,
-0.3233531415462494,
0.2167935073375702,
0.8082000017166138,
0.025186888873577118,
-0.5367931723594666,
-0.33562251925468445,
-0.07252935320138931,
0.763647198677063,
0.8898500204086304,
-0.5031636357307434,
0.028873687610030174,
-0.12970879673957825,
1.0024884939193726,
-0.6977629661560059,
0.28816354274749756,
-0.9193011522293091,
0.25413790345191956,
-0.18898652493953705,
0.38625630736351013,
-0.48910292983055115,
-0.6358999609947205,
0.5007060766220093,
-0.5546340346336365,
0.37638765573501587,
0.2881278395652771,
0.3349100351333618,
0.5760989785194397,
-0.10895776748657227,
-0.4540574550628662,
-1.0806641578674316,
0.8075957894325256,
-0.8659874796867371,
0.8543679118156433,
0.7193601727485657,
0.6495374441146851,
-0.34603774547576904,
-0.7661612629890442,
-0.5103272199630737,
-0.305581659078598,
0.23201987147331238,
-0.006357465870678425,
-0.24810370802879333,
0.220956951379776,
-0.029976364225149155,
0.42223629355430603,
-0.6018000245094299,
-0.04946988448500633,
-0.45993539690971375,
-0.11482241004705429,
0.5051842331886292,
-0.06099124997854233,
0.02664598636329174,
-0.0015598308527842164,
-0.009308510459959507,
0.025202065706253052,
-0.24381518363952637,
0.013592193834483624,
0.16363166272640228,
0.3269529640674591,
0.0534152016043663,
0.5170603394508362,
-0.4236683249473572,
0.9765923023223877,
-0.03864762932062149,
0.23699821531772614,
-0.10975806415081024,
-0.12282544374465942,
-0.43129873275756836,
0.0847448855638504,
0.9118887186050415,
0.10662779211997986,
0.5277099609375,
-0.20388171076774597,
-0.1014191210269928,
0.20067036151885986,
0.2648935616016388,
-0.29437747597694397,
-0.31346216797828674,
0.4081001579761505,
-0.07889960706233978,
-0.25551915168762207,
0.20926029980182648,
-1.0423815250396729,
-0.49884530901908875,
-0.22593440115451813,
-0.40255171060562134,
-0.7516521215438843,
-0.1917513906955719,
0.4983125627040863,
0.029928285628557205,
-0.21248109638690948,
0.3640776574611664,
-1.153568148612976,
0.2965436279773712,
0.6670092940330505,
0.9829577207565308,
-0.23486775159835815,
0.0735509842634201,
-0.19444437325000763,
0.36124181747436523,
-0.19587013125419617,
1.0787819623947144,
-0.7416005730628967,
-0.23381738364696503,
0.16709837317466736,
-0.30175796151161194,
0.06149286776781082,
-0.5453585386276245,
0.9232268929481506,
-0.4019920825958252,
-0.17094820737838745,
0.2198120653629303,
-0.5537075400352478,
-0.34627142548561096,
0.22978316247463226,
-1.1617214679718018,
0.662981390953064,
0.11657167226076126,
-0.6645981669425964,
0.3512263894081116,
-0.41677695512771606,
-0.25699636340141296,
-0.0847458690404892,
0.13950665295124054,
-0.4915951192378998,
0.2348378449678421,
0.19649770855903625,
0.4378727972507477,
-0.35004621744155884,
0.19613726437091827,
-0.5195639729499817,
0.0963391661643982,
0.23520009219646454,
-0.558494508266449,
0.4591071605682373,
0.25135141611099243,
-0.02934977225959301,
0.06108322739601135,
-0.714775562286377,
0.34845542907714844,
-0.31154733896255493,
-0.020773988217115402,
-0.2208336740732193,
0.05838694050908089,
0.008827519603073597,
0.07401072233915329,
0.14724944531917572,
-0.3317089080810547,
0.08028413355350494,
-0.7689951062202454,
0.31581106781959534,
0.6916982531547546,
0.16955748200416565,
0.6795521974563599,
-0.03905915096402168,
0.7527343034744263,
-0.15378373861312866,
0.357118159532547,
0.2945796549320221,
-0.9984094500541687,
-0.29514622688293457,
0.10445418953895569,
0.3061974048614502,
0.5639402866363525,
-0.3024577498435974,
0.4022209048271179,
0.06576630473136902,
-0.7016928195953369,
-0.4187028706073761,
0.03572729602456093,
0.12647520005702972,
0.14284588396549225,
0.4110974967479706,
0.3485833704471588,
-0.9344481229782104,
-0.7547115683555603,
-0.4255519211292267,
-0.49584686756134033,
-0.3254498243331909,
-0.40296342968940735,
-0.041869740933179855,
-0.40434834361076355,
1.101569652557373,
-0.6996273994445801,
-0.6516686081886292,
-0.15552708506584167,
0.13413141667842865,
0.28490903973579407,
0.3228755295276642,
0.40412819385528564,
-0.9971696734428406,
-0.6205334663391113,
-0.03689579665660858,
-0.6164402961730957,
0.12533439695835114,
-0.07191458344459534,
0.2469184249639511,
0.49093782901763916,
0.5906373858451843,
-0.40401360392570496,
0.4444160759449005,
1.0106531381607056,
-0.16057726740837097,
0.6094140410423279,
-0.21514199674129486,
-0.35641106963157654,
-0.7719243168830872,
-0.23508985340595245,
0.3208211362361908,
-0.3809951841831207,
-0.7153018712997437,
-0.20579569041728973,
-0.08774664252996445,
0.2653684914112091,
-0.0650733932852745,
0.334644615650177,
-0.35551950335502625,
0.27517959475517273,
-0.024495678022503853,
0.04799817502498627,
-0.2652411162853241,
-0.06215563789010048,
0.44167426228523254,
0.6124822497367859,
0.6282616853713989,
-0.6781420111656189,
0.11870262026786804,
0.3501080274581909,
-0.23973888158798218,
0.34525489807128906,
-0.6122934222221375,
-0.2589000463485718,
-0.26011478900909424,
0.12534089386463165,
-0.8768081068992615,
-0.12125471979379654,
0.05182940140366554,
-0.6285770535469055,
0.1561623364686966,
0.22228215634822845,
-0.2205941081047058,
-0.35389310121536255,
-0.3284965455532074,
0.22137451171875,
0.458516389131546,
0.08708830922842026,
0.3058815002441406,
0.533386766910553,
-0.2536311745643616,
-0.5076242089271545,
-0.7696691751480103,
-0.10955432802438736,
0.057081837207078934,
-0.45359066128730774,
0.06957034766674042,
-0.3228018581867218,
-0.2979886829853058,
-0.3353938162326813,
-0.23494857549667358,
-0.2766651213169098,
0.04297579824924469,
0.5873128175735474,
0.3185456693172455,
-0.0820397362112999,
-0.032088667154312134,
0.052909813821315765,
-0.2449766993522644,
0.15737347304821014,
-0.3685617446899414,
0.24995394051074982,
-0.7009320855140686,
-0.1892278790473938,
0.00755320442840457,
0.07195887714624405,
0.3811255097389221,
0.17867109179496765,
0.8721905946731567,
0.5463295578956604,
-0.6893490552902222,
-0.10898236930370331,
-0.6220516562461853,
-0.048643115907907486,
-0.4645916819572449,
0.04716901853680611,
0.020687799900770187,
-0.6990537047386169,
0.2860754430294037,
0.006109521724283695,
-0.1334378719329834,
0.4683362543582916,
0.41160836815834045,
0.023066293448209763,
0.9238578081130981,
0.7223283052444458,
0.11715883761644363,
0.2639681398868561,
-0.05138333886861801,
0.402168869972229,
-0.6525943279266357,
-0.11701305210590363,
-0.6105930805206299,
0.16704963147640228,
-0.6146461963653564,
-0.30650317668914795,
0.4838205575942993,
0.17460693418979645,
0.20904694497585297,
0.3229682743549347,
-0.7628397345542908,
0.3757113814353943,
0.48513051867485046,
-0.5159292817115784,
0.5504571795463562,
-0.2227938175201416,
-0.005080932751297951,
-0.2128169983625412,
-0.14338229596614838,
-0.6035183668136597,
0.9318231344223022,
0.4641367197036743,
0.45765820145606995,
0.07566869258880615,
0.2668652832508087,
0.47456270456314087,
0.4440031051635742,
-0.7483059763908386,
0.3924862742424011,
-0.012336925603449345,
-0.751551628112793,
-0.8302481770515442,
0.00920205470174551,
-0.826140284538269,
-0.024753447622060776,
-0.4817686975002289,
-0.9938560128211975,
0.152920201420784,
0.15046186745166779,
-0.36337992548942566,
0.28871846199035645,
-0.4094092845916748,
0.46259215474128723,
0.4007340669631958,
0.22216348350048065,
0.10689390450716019,
-0.8639604449272156,
0.4661526381969452,
-0.3639046549797058,
0.2585926055908203,
-0.34369969367980957,
0.06841801851987839,
0.5348858833312988,
0.012540285475552082,
0.6595048904418945,
-0.117021843791008,
-0.1738199144601822,
0.3036439120769501,
0.29649287462234497,
0.3376191556453705,
0.414151668548584,
-0.7464261054992676,
0.5445966124534607,
0.535248875617981,
0.11032187193632126,
-0.5131943225860596,
0.34703919291496277,
-0.3782607913017273,
-0.4634416401386261,
-0.6422553062438965,
-0.48091012239456177,
-0.6312354803085327,
0.22210168838500977,
0.4853639006614685,
-0.2657129764556885,
-0.3366253674030304,
0.25395467877388,
0.5559828877449036,
0.20051100850105286,
0.548941969871521,
0.051036667078733444,
-0.20697984099388123,
-0.6138252019882202,
0.4550711214542389,
0.01281241700053215,
0.2913661599159241,
0.36805787682533264,
0.2643260657787323,
-0.5316910743713379,
-0.9509676098823547,
-0.03414120152592659,
0.03967098146677017,
-0.6241328120231628,
-0.48188066482543945,
-0.46390819549560547,
-0.20241039991378784,
-0.8369598388671875,
-0.38598838448524475,
-0.3928929567337036,
-0.8174242973327637,
-0.03916742652654648,
-0.22670619189739227,
0.2226858288049698,
0.9374059438705444,
-0.07185530662536621,
0.2980602979660034,
-0.787320613861084,
0.4874698221683502,
0.10899629443883896,
0.7578547596931458,
-0.10831084102392197,
-0.02547006495296955,
-0.199122354388237,
0.35910123586654663,
-0.4246911406517029,
-0.8033992648124695,
0.7048676609992981,
0.38314011693000793,
0.5368690490722656,
0.4096575379371643,
0.4743826687335968,
0.25695371627807617,
-0.5128898024559021,
0.8414740562438965,
0.38075634837150574,
-0.8586276173591614,
0.6742623448371887,
-0.30565145611763,
0.08003730326890945,
0.722274124622345,
0.4899778962135315,
-0.8834469318389893,
-0.8311355710029602,
-0.6146832704544067,
-0.8071786761283875,
0.4009110927581787,
0.38010871410369873,
-0.2980760335922241,
-0.08664380759000778,
0.34436988830566406,
0.3683045506477356,
0.3108600080013275,
-0.7522033452987671,
-0.16520164906978607,
-0.2695853114128113,
-0.2452242374420166,
-0.0008739111362956464,
-0.15932659804821014,
0.283607542514801,
-0.34536853432655334,
0.7210275530815125,
-0.20634698867797852,
0.3267623484134674,
0.3276015818119049,
0.13499729335308075,
-0.43440011143684387,
0.2640995383262634,
0.6317710280418396,
0.7254431247711182,
-0.6707476377487183,
0.00017368570843245834,
0.23322607576847076,
-0.834331750869751,
0.07815740257501602,
-0.21092768013477325,
-0.15831151604652405,
0.18855278193950653,
0.0904877707362175,
0.37054187059402466,
-0.13340994715690613,
-0.6538755297660828,
0.3860790729522705,
-0.21194039285182953,
-0.048530999571084976,
-1.0814744234085083,
-0.14994686841964722,
0.13073499500751495,
0.06758766621351242,
0.3418484032154083,
0.3063925802707672,
0.4897977411746979,
-0.1902756243944168,
0.2263464331626892,
0.5346969962120056,
-0.7806509733200073,
-0.5423445701599121,
1.0307255983352661,
-0.4622872769832611,
-0.3228214383125305,
0.39996039867401123,
0.13186649978160858,
-0.0460348017513752,
0.37260136008262634,
0.6850912570953369,
1.321433186531067,
-0.4073818027973175,
0.26962989568710327,
0.36002084612846375,
0.25964927673339844,
-0.375668466091156,
-0.07112544775009155,
0.2801938056945801,
-0.8059356808662415,
-0.06996390223503113,
-1.1217660903930664,
-0.661029040813446,
-0.051103267818689346,
-0.6818701028823853,
0.36314478516578674,
-0.7557779550552368,
-0.39168626070022583,
0.22450391948223114,
-0.2893087565898895,
-0.25443682074546814,
0.23378901183605194,
0.5584916472434998,
1.1050571203231812,
-0.6894344091415405,
0.8057166337966919,
0.5625726580619812,
-0.1403350532054901,
-0.3563409447669983,
0.2369920313358307,
0.03739219158887863,
-0.28778892755508423,
0.42017433047294617,
0.17070873081684113,
-0.19497013092041016,
-0.3888329267501831,
-0.38429078459739685,
-0.8338181376457214,
0.8161076903343201,
0.5947888493537903,
-0.3461974561214447,
-0.3582060635089874,
0.4773566722869873,
0.6780546307563782,
-0.08830418437719345,
-0.01992225833237171,
0.7022778391838074,
0.8225592970848083,
0.3124849796295166,
-0.8843016624450684,
0.18550507724285126,
0.13458646833896637,
0.32453015446662903,
0.2599572241306305,
-0.17194227874279022,
0.6724117398262024,
-0.14156924188137054,
-0.24108801782131195,
0.04513197019696236,
1.1831108331680298,
0.2901269197463989,
0.3058200776576996,
0.6332302093505859,
0.18859004974365234,
0.849929690361023,
-0.022743118926882744,
0.976037859916687,
-0.3317008912563324,
0.27346450090408325,
0.8328668475151062,
-0.21856629848480225,
1.0387980937957764,
0.5858888626098633,
-0.4087837338447571,
0.492127925157547,
0.41963326930999756,
0.2170088291168213,
0.43658602237701416,
-0.012528741732239723,
-0.35034385323524475,
-0.11618484556674957,
0.08282724022865295,
-0.28683459758758545,
0.23131799697875977,
0.8472332954406738,
0.056160084903240204,
-0.0869111493229866,
-0.07687598466873169,
-0.25195369124412537,
0.3873921036720276,
-0.12747934460639954,
0.7495267987251282,
0.1716568022966385,
-0.7189328670501709,
0.6192827820777893,
-0.10138063132762909,
0.8715831637382507,
-0.6350664496421814,
-0.05035660043358803,
0.3789926767349243,
0.1715259701013565,
-0.18402360379695892,
-0.9564611911773682,
1.00182044506073,
-0.7994766235351562,
-0.3960708677768707,
-0.34131425619125366,
0.7584674954414368,
-0.20129752159118652,
-0.5307387709617615,
0.16781044006347656,
0.18976935744285583,
-0.24300384521484375,
-0.46552774310112,
-0.4635654389858246,
-0.4208469092845917,
-0.029098423197865486,
-0.4310642182826996,
0.0981820598244667,
0.4901166558265686,
-0.16219462454319,
1.049560785293579,
0.4820917248725891,
0.5114210247993469,
0.3364403247833252,
-0.34680497646331787,
0.5521573424339294,
-0.6816105246543884,
-0.5217030644416809,
-0.7767267823219299,
0.19484619796276093,
0.11194121092557907,
-0.07147834450006485,
0.5274443626403809,
0.21686886250972748,
0.5268685221672058,
-0.3297806978225708,
0.9658830165863037,
0.09064611792564392,
0.45231425762176514,
-0.5307957530021667,
0.613869309425354,
0.04245249554514885,
0.07616523653268814,
-0.2531040608882904,
-1.0065937042236328,
-0.7994977235794067,
0.5811651349067688,
-0.28500697016716003,
-0.3297572135925293,
0.9006125330924988,
0.33053770661354065,
0.1333761364221573,
0.6332976818084717,
0.49985748529434204,
-0.07141721248626709,
0.30041012167930603,
0.3329034745693207,
0.40257528424263,
-0.36941105127334595,
0.39889153838157654,
-0.4504997134208679,
0.033470138907432556,
-0.141389399766922,
-1.110041856765747,
-0.5184407234191895,
-1.1472305059432983,
-0.13750402629375458,
-0.2694239020347595,
-0.16301889717578888,
0.7141223549842834,
0.5690281391143799,
-1.1809889078140259,
-0.10073129087686539,
-0.5678361654281616,
0.2843734622001648,
-0.4185507297515869,
-0.22383642196655273,
0.0055792746134102345,
-0.5336297750473022,
-0.8877804279327393,
0.20678602159023285,
0.3179846704006195,
0.42593079805374146,
-0.2754518389701843,
0.01473192498087883,
-0.3123985230922699,
0.2359399050474167,
0.4272356331348419,
0.5073609352111816,
-0.6883448362350464,
-0.24625292420387268,
0.005463393870741129,
0.10385160893201828,
-0.020023616030812263,
0.6741064190864563,
-0.7925378084182739,
0.1741897612810135,
0.5578513741493225,
0.41723981499671936,
0.1213993951678276,
-0.05730549991130829,
1.050485610961914,
-0.8726856708526611,
0.4005773961544037,
0.6203362941741943,
0.36477482318878174,
0.23645295202732086,
-0.6482329964637756,
0.6810139417648315,
-0.0565924271941185,
-0.5846503376960754,
-0.847779393196106,
0.40200358629226685,
-1.1485036611557007,
-0.19594420492649078,
1.1190778017044067,
0.1013837456703186,
-0.21743302047252655,
-0.49195924401283264,
0.020647909492254257,
0.151286318898201,
-0.3752913475036621,
0.8256848454475403,
0.7681484222412109,
-0.045170579105615616,
0.05277657508850098,
-0.8798406720161438,
0.8419324159622192,
0.28863072395324707,
-0.639253556728363,
0.5270008444786072,
0.47940996289253235,
-0.1823148876428604,
0.5069454908370972,
0.4130456745624542,
-0.006714151240885258,
-0.0636826679110527,
-0.42321038246154785,
0.0896105244755745,
0.09476318955421448,
-0.2985494136810303,
-0.4439654052257538,
0.3625389039516449,
0.29496461153030396,
0.20401760935783386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01972v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01972v3
|
A quantitative and typological study of Early Slavic participle clauses and their competition
| 2024-05-03T09:54:10 | 2024-05-08T18:01:50 |
Nilo Pedrazzini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, 68T50, 68U15, 68T35, (Primary), 86A32, 15A03 (Secondary), I.2.7
|
This thesis is a corpus-based, quantitative, and typological analysis of the
functions of Early Slavic participle constructions and their finite competitors
($jegda$-'when'-clauses). The first part leverages detailed linguistic
annotation on Early Slavic corpora at the morphosyntactic, dependency,
information-structural, and lexical levels to obtain indirect evidence for
different potential functions of participle clauses and their main finite
competitor and understand the roles of compositionality and default discourse
reasoning as explanations for the distribution of participle constructions and
$jegda$-clauses in the corpus. The second part uses massively parallel data to
analyze typological variation in how languages express the semantic space of
English $when$, whose scope encompasses that of Early Slavic participle
constructions and $jegda$-clauses. Probabilistic semantic maps are generated
and statistical methods (including Kriging, Gaussian Mixture Modelling,
precision and recall analysis) are used to induce cross-linguistically salient
dimensions from the parallel corpus and to study conceptual variation within
the semantic space of the hypothetical concept WHEN.
|
[
-0.5307694673538208,
-0.4995843470096588,
0.767681896686554,
0.2340201586484909,
-0.12195606529712677,
0.1327676624059677,
-0.10582573711872101,
-0.4322545826435089,
0.5229083299636841,
0.5094274282455444,
-0.3184870183467865,
-0.6434821486473083,
-0.2865311801433563,
0.24415741860866547,
-0.07595137506723404,
0.7104687690734863,
0.07174212485551834,
0.253923237323761,
-0.4482402503490448,
-0.08711894601583481,
-0.12374754250049591,
-1.017006516456604,
-0.0812409445643425,
0.05949729308485985,
0.5075220465660095,
0.34090474247932434,
0.642266035079956,
0.30223512649536133,
0.24521088600158691,
0.4142288565635681,
-0.1123470589518547,
-0.2171020358800888,
-0.033568140119314194,
0.7426939606666565,
-0.28589609265327454,
-0.8569843173027039,
-0.20622557401657104,
0.1813916563987732,
0.6362717151641846,
0.9581803679466248,
-0.11950211971998215,
0.24442848563194275,
-0.10586182028055191,
0.6676852107048035,
-0.5910540223121643,
0.6185295581817627,
-0.884643018245697,
-0.12084706127643585,
-0.7743408679962158,
-0.40121978521347046,
-0.3471234142780304,
-0.22303089499473572,
0.1985238492488861,
-0.7419843673706055,
0.06417927891016006,
0.22615164518356323,
1.0246777534484863,
0.16439951956272125,
-0.2923428416252136,
-0.404041051864624,
-0.35329511761665344,
0.7831261157989502,
-0.2815712094306946,
0.10482268035411835,
0.3602583408355713,
0.2431410849094391,
-0.5072752833366394,
-0.5336762070655823,
-0.2448674440383911,
-0.3634665012359619,
-0.293191134929657,
0.17892664670944214,
0.05084019526839256,
0.21213771402835846,
0.16259656846523285,
0.267723023891449,
-0.8247730135917664,
-0.2585476040840149,
-0.5541197657585144,
-0.31406956911087036,
0.5605403184890747,
0.011817367747426033,
0.4512726962566376,
-0.47846719622612,
-0.1636577844619751,
0.127799391746521,
-0.4661506414413452,
-0.17963556945323944,
0.7984548211097717,
0.4409874975681305,
0.14507117867469788,
0.9098889827728271,
-0.4373807907104492,
0.7899585366249084,
-0.08752916753292084,
-0.0980173870921135,
0.3357396423816681,
-0.4428388774394989,
-0.22045095264911652,
0.02087489143013954,
0.38411736488342285,
-0.11117176711559296,
0.6201016306877136,
-0.23275306820869446,
0.13670040667057037,
0.3387454152107239,
0.23408760130405426,
-0.14721986651420593,
-0.1643988937139511,
0.04525968059897423,
-0.49205267429351807,
-0.288715124130249,
-0.01580483838915825,
-0.7408565878868103,
0.1442965865135193,
-0.5614965558052063,
0.07974603027105331,
-0.5243778824806213,
-0.296236127614975,
0.2564252018928528,
0.0446268767118454,
0.22360368072986603,
-0.21210452914237976,
-0.6600152254104614,
0.5384036302566528,
0.8528305888175964,
0.5549283027648926,
-0.09647418558597565,
-0.46829819679260254,
-0.28287774324417114,
-0.0931229293346405,
-0.2916989028453827,
0.9978078603744507,
-0.6782885193824768,
-0.09921183437108994,
0.1871589869260788,
0.1819181740283966,
-0.26380571722984314,
-0.7352390885353088,
0.6296206116676331,
-0.666839063167572,
0.558340847492218,
0.021464955061674118,
-0.6695792078971863,
-0.28989389538764954,
0.22467854619026184,
-0.6348804235458374,
0.7613844275474548,
0.31395453214645386,
-0.7124997973442078,
0.5370359420776367,
-0.15046177804470062,
-0.45651501417160034,
0.5459775924682617,
-0.31710776686668396,
-0.11654620617628098,
0.4451298713684082,
-0.521556556224823,
0.14073826372623444,
-0.33709976077079773,
0.028337303549051285,
-0.3370899260044098,
0.10905450582504272,
0.17626972496509552,
0.2979067862033844,
0.9321247339248657,
0.17075121402740479,
-0.13605929911136627,
0.07965308427810669,
-0.837359607219696,
0.3446103632450104,
0.06568187475204468,
-0.0794268399477005,
-0.7292394638061523,
0.06379816681146622,
-0.3045065104961395,
0.11868754774332047,
0.21149621903896332,
-0.5165186524391174,
0.1886591911315918,
-0.5259829759597778,
0.014305387623608112,
0.026816915720701218,
0.21801865100860596,
0.5406255722045898,
-0.08267872035503387,
0.9236533641815186,
-0.04312080889940262,
0.3432283401489258,
0.1738891750574112,
-0.5951882600784302,
-0.43176352977752686,
-0.13451173901557922,
0.8040032982826233,
0.5116888880729675,
-0.9924090504646301,
0.15994997322559357,
0.05805289372801781,
-0.3224465250968933,
-0.2726653218269348,
-0.31276220083236694,
0.41970279812812805,
-0.15137261152267456,
-0.04800160229206085,
-0.08258949220180511,
-0.8148865699768066,
-1.1616047620773315,
-0.09011972695589066,
-0.661636471748352,
0.20094016194343567,
-0.029994433745741844,
0.43698132038116455,
0.7451145648956299,
0.6390681862831116,
-0.3866347372531891,
-0.2033020257949829,
-0.10658033937215805,
0.05555933341383934,
0.04365719482302666,
0.16515524685382843,
0.80199134349823,
-1.0074741840362549,
-0.6302233338356018,
-0.027605511248111725,
-0.39100396633148193,
-0.5300147533416748,
0.034892819821834564,
-0.3329792022705078,
0.5028089284896851,
0.48360103368759155,
-0.7695731520652771,
0.31903505325317383,
0.42437636852264404,
-0.7706530690193176,
1.1268765926361084,
-0.13801757991313934,
0.31847500801086426,
-0.8685690760612488,
-0.11941910535097122,
-0.3763962388038635,
-0.06857030093669891,
-0.5388703942298889,
0.39811453223228455,
-0.2782055735588074,
0.029779376462101936,
-0.5342376828193665,
0.0036021163687109947,
-0.6601342558860779,
-0.07392850518226624,
-0.20915468037128448,
0.17789660394191742,
-0.4239535927772522,
0.282085120677948,
-0.10829540342092514,
0.5423352718353271,
0.49799004197120667,
-0.3469209372997284,
-0.05248076468706131,
0.027287913486361504,
-0.2929799258708954,
0.3952544629573822,
-0.4813857972621918,
-0.273743599653244,
-0.10350196808576584,
-0.22915440797805786,
-1.0730602741241455,
-0.3974889814853668,
0.14160317182540894,
-0.7821892499923706,
0.13585318624973297,
-0.6152108907699585,
-0.7885275483131409,
-0.0692550539970398,
-0.05483265966176987,
0.5544136762619019,
0.4240471422672272,
0.240422785282135,
0.47958964109420776,
0.604537308216095,
-0.41574445366859436,
-0.23302307724952698,
-0.23899850249290466,
-0.07851517200469971,
-0.519231915473938,
-0.7104019522666931,
0.48540785908699036,
0.29390865564346313,
-0.7098028659820557,
0.08987822383642197,
0.009742073714733124,
-0.15356633067131042,
0.002138764364644885,
0.07892157882452011,
0.6314398646354675,
-0.3045269846916199,
-0.08275071531534195,
-0.08870838582515717,
-0.2581554353237152,
0.17714335024356842,
-0.47182872891426086,
0.7409936189651489,
0.10335935652256012,
0.03567620366811752,
0.24055801331996918,
0.5530677437782288,
0.6793859601020813,
-0.0429418571293354,
0.6067640781402588,
-0.03033350221812725,
-0.33323365449905396,
-0.07346423715353012,
-0.40068891644477844,
0.22809520363807678,
-0.32790592312812805,
0.22979676723480225,
-0.6441916227340698,
-0.629557728767395,
0.6407697200775146,
0.27566009759902954,
-0.42349112033843994,
0.6942776441574097,
0.6463179588317871,
0.06024140492081642,
0.512171745300293,
0.29069337248802185,
0.3372683823108673,
0.1893429309129715,
0.17162209749221802,
-0.18047985434532166,
-0.4813116192817688,
-0.4088208079338074,
-0.668492317199707,
-0.09023039788007736,
-0.9603370428085327,
-0.4723667502403259,
0.2753956615924835,
0.030827879905700684,
-0.18141096830368042,
0.5011137127876282,
-0.24125196039676666,
0.6540833711624146,
0.45222726464271545,
-0.43635472655296326,
0.007549847010523081,
-0.04502255842089653,
-0.38488757610321045,
-0.62434321641922,
-0.4905581474304199,
-0.4022028148174286,
0.9549492001533508,
-0.10378389060497284,
0.31288737058639526,
0.3428443968296051,
0.5917923450469971,
0.22616933286190033,
-0.3458840847015381,
-0.47912248969078064,
0.8017377257347107,
-0.1397927850484848,
-0.7526103258132935,
0.01319685485213995,
-0.23287330567836761,
-0.9962378144264221,
0.5288108587265015,
-0.10872402787208557,
-0.9151312112808228,
0.42993518710136414,
-0.08768285810947418,
-0.29424235224723816,
-0.02710575796663761,
-0.8143502473831177,
0.7249543070793152,
-0.0017431522719562054,
-0.4869755804538727,
-0.06034863740205765,
-0.83954918384552,
0.23599261045455933,
0.1684693843126297,
-0.017891857773065567,
-0.09520189464092255,
-0.14395618438720703,
0.5679934620857239,
-0.1373949646949768,
0.6226181983947754,
-0.30622944235801697,
0.17645353078842163,
0.5282605290412903,
0.5138730406761169,
0.1154174953699112,
-0.12745647132396698,
0.09061234444379807,
-0.2512187063694,
0.6073648929595947,
-0.5843844413757324,
-0.5421719551086426,
0.42065101861953735,
-0.2817787230014801,
-0.483864963054657,
-0.6167082190513611,
-0.20981465280056,
-0.3438139259815216,
0.09239903837442398,
0.43839600682258606,
0.19558922946453094,
-0.17361366748809814,
0.3276989758014679,
0.40311285853385925,
-0.005656234920024872,
0.26606231927871704,
0.40557870268821716,
-0.527493417263031,
-0.445381760597229,
0.7720813155174255,
0.25335249304771423,
0.3497487008571625,
0.3149911165237427,
-0.1256886124610901,
-0.2994226813316345,
-0.5923497676849365,
0.04538208991289139,
0.2960762083530426,
-0.5628160238265991,
-0.19123424589633942,
-0.33545276522636414,
-0.1592153012752533,
-0.24909481406211853,
0.14495447278022766,
-0.336348295211792,
-0.675912618637085,
-0.12458520382642746,
0.2317618578672409,
-0.3030269742012024,
0.5061103105545044,
0.058087561279535294,
0.010568618774414062,
-0.2577586770057678,
-0.09430906921625137,
-0.1947186142206192,
0.14684903621673584,
-0.19532786309719086,
-0.08205123990774155,
-0.17614693939685822,
-0.6427713632583618,
-0.012468830682337284,
-1.152626395225525,
0.3551097512245178,
-0.21510140597820282,
0.629030168056488,
-0.2547358274459839,
0.08791850507259369,
0.11052359640598297,
-0.38021770119667053,
0.8845221400260925,
-0.08250083029270172,
-0.6915057897567749,
0.09922204166650772,
-0.4681386649608612,
0.2687875032424927,
0.6870712637901306,
0.31635957956314087,
-0.25374430418014526,
-0.4396306276321411,
-0.7928870320320129,
-1.0713759660720825,
0.44978728890419006,
0.681731641292572,
-0.5127127766609192,
-0.06412594765424728,
0.3849009573459625,
0.28609099984169006,
0.24441222846508026,
-0.6902568340301514,
-0.2770276665687561,
0.16399438679218292,
-0.0870148092508316,
0.3611730933189392,
-0.46454286575317383,
0.03598150238394737,
-0.16310207545757294,
0.5844526886940002,
-0.05971983075141907,
0.22295716404914856,
0.13888542354106903,
-0.24883319437503815,
0.3728545904159546,
0.43064337968826294,
0.7816314101219177,
0.6743025183677673,
0.0799066424369812,
0.18666641414165497,
-0.10608839243650436,
-0.3344275951385498,
0.15604646503925323,
0.32540854811668396,
-0.2917918264865875,
0.3394662141799927,
0.3713032007217407,
0.5981806516647339,
0.2678103744983673,
-0.4586395025253296,
0.21297289431095123,
0.28582343459129333,
-0.4081766605377197,
-0.7771819829940796,
-0.27732083201408386,
0.05845576897263527,
0.41188716888427734,
0.478488564491272,
-0.23772145807743073,
0.3172295391559601,
-0.6469352841377258,
0.3033023476600647,
0.3359193205833435,
0.08936929702758789,
-0.5683976411819458,
0.4044050872325897,
-0.3306455910205841,
-0.2806066870689392,
-0.10008669644594193,
-0.47771155834198,
-0.9287158846855164,
0.6215562224388123,
0.4523538053035736,
0.8056824803352356,
-0.05960412323474884,
0.6281313300132751,
0.17175506055355072,
0.12377708405256271,
0.41195425391197205,
0.5678297281265259,
-0.12180659174919128,
-0.3341686725616455,
-0.601328432559967,
-0.6408945322036743,
-0.044294245541095734,
-0.011251064017415047,
-0.7663012146949768,
0.3954574465751648,
0.14337384700775146,
-0.2807832360267639,
0.4184752106666565,
0.02107565477490425,
-0.43513181805610657,
-0.006474113091826439,
0.4335470199584961,
0.5873253345489502,
-0.509602427482605,
0.6466555595397949,
0.8253685235977173,
-0.4667825400829315,
-0.5568026304244995,
0.4331226646900177,
-0.07020429521799088,
-0.437890887260437,
0.8898040652275085,
-0.40571966767311096,
-0.16840654611587524,
-0.3306330740451813,
-0.29487717151641846,
-1.0092499256134033,
0.49598756432533264,
0.3940137028694153,
-0.25351065397262573,
-0.445645272731781,
0.2611987292766571,
0.765344500541687,
-0.5646951794624329,
0.02364090085029602,
0.7049118876457214,
0.4458180069923401,
-0.09677180647850037,
-0.8192775249481201,
0.010137440636754036,
-0.21548506617546082,
-0.0292222797870636,
0.5706179141998291,
-0.5121523141860962,
0.74805748462677,
0.13622428476810455,
-0.4040813148021698,
0.48566290736198425,
0.5240184664726257,
0.17069360613822937,
0.16853153705596924,
0.5519326329231262,
0.20462335646152496,
0.2170451283454895,
-0.3533859848976135,
0.852746307849884,
-0.5855721831321716,
0.4272320568561554,
1.21234130859375,
-0.23879271745681763,
0.7803673148155212,
0.6111380457878113,
-0.4455101788043976,
0.6503951549530029,
0.6134177446365356,
0.08250432461500168,
0.6810035109519958,
0.7554402351379395,
-0.40112337470054626,
-0.21326735615730286,
0.10838032513856888,
-0.2569422721862793,
0.7700187563896179,
0.21347849071025848,
-0.17308185994625092,
-0.22300247848033905,
-0.008110505528748035,
0.04749545827507973,
0.24426299333572388,
0.053675875067710876,
0.8356682658195496,
-0.2521478533744812,
-0.9847286939620972,
0.34323814511299133,
-0.20621861517429352,
0.10710182040929794,
-0.7677282094955444,
0.17568059265613556,
-0.19133806228637695,
0.025349434465169907,
-0.10003934800624847,
-0.7885080575942993,
0.47413313388824463,
-0.20061548054218292,
-0.09179076552391052,
0.22199609875679016,
0.7411494255065918,
-0.6233866810798645,
-0.32404446601867676,
0.46957969665527344,
0.5617708563804626,
0.21085762977600098,
-0.04140399768948555,
-0.2955765128135681,
0.08346114307641983,
0.03889433667063713,
-0.33406880497932434,
0.24698233604431152,
0.678236186504364,
-0.001734427292831242,
0.17626971006393433,
0.16766078770160675,
0.5106362104415894,
0.30228251218795776,
0.05430179461836815,
0.6432002782821655,
-0.7819804549217224,
-0.5289902687072754,
-0.7046164870262146,
0.4630996882915497,
-0.1962045580148697,
-0.43149277567863464,
0.6815153360366821,
0.7887357473373413,
0.7708716988563538,
-0.171112522482872,
0.5100536346435547,
-0.34100577235221863,
0.49677741527557373,
-0.6561851501464844,
0.4896101951599121,
-0.5650206804275513,
-0.18315716087818146,
-0.25240325927734375,
-0.9480771422386169,
-0.3357160985469818,
0.1312676966190338,
-0.3538362681865692,
-0.18967044353485107,
1.2017146348953247,
0.25491705536842346,
0.0963178426027298,
0.10132478177547455,
0.5811020135879517,
0.2277560830116272,
-0.13667157292366028,
0.3002828359603882,
0.8939628005027771,
-0.07418312877416611,
0.5506035089492798,
-0.09509223699569702,
-0.13449765741825104,
0.10397281497716904,
-0.4503425657749176,
-0.41338762640953064,
-1.161178469657898,
-0.2687419652938843,
-0.6921268701553345,
0.17435604333877563,
0.9222155809402466,
0.5287740230560303,
-0.8074296712875366,
-0.383609414100647,
-0.017049524933099747,
-0.10187457501888275,
0.10796971619129181,
-0.29120802879333496,
0.19776538014411926,
-0.7530179023742676,
-0.7941212058067322,
0.3108404576778412,
0.24419285356998444,
0.17632971704006195,
-0.3960709273815155,
0.18445807695388794,
-0.3405504822731018,
0.20954205095767975,
0.5777308940887451,
0.2902967929840088,
-0.6608703136444092,
-0.08267565071582794,
0.0455271452665329,
0.1324298232793808,
0.0012238591443747282,
1.1918436288833618,
-0.6857131123542786,
0.18285346031188965,
0.5772785544395447,
0.11916771531105042,
0.3878192603588104,
-0.013149849139153957,
0.6463973522186279,
-0.6530193090438843,
0.6128112077713013,
0.4477219581604004,
0.521458625793457,
0.2068997472524643,
-0.15085569024085999,
0.6456639766693115,
0.5580779910087585,
-0.5451968312263489,
-0.7580607533454895,
0.39170968532562256,
-0.976449191570282,
-0.5247461795806885,
0.9713892936706543,
-0.14331990480422974,
-0.4998135566711426,
-0.40445876121520996,
-0.145127072930336,
0.006650478113442659,
-0.07700058817863464,
0.7634384632110596,
1.348914384841919,
-0.08978375792503357,
0.23243872821331024,
-0.7464701533317566,
0.6275039315223694,
0.4521053433418274,
-0.7148351073265076,
-0.019877122715115547,
0.5584294199943542,
0.1405021697282791,
0.48776188492774963,
0.2865513861179352,
-0.4363459348678589,
0.15850529074668884,
0.40274742245674133,
-0.10793270915746689,
0.32652443647384644,
-0.5984475016593933,
0.11659085750579834,
0.8551710844039917,
-0.09402105212211609,
-0.5644744634628296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06667v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06667v1
|
Sentiment Polarity Analysis of Bangla Food Reviews Using Machine and Deep Learning Algorithms
| 2024-05-03T09:49:46 | 2024-05-03T09:49:46 |
Al Amin, Anik Sarkar, Md Mahamodul Islam, Asif Ahammad Miazee, Md Robiul Islam, Md Mahmudul Hoque
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The Internet has become an essential tool for people in the modern world.
Humans, like all living organisms, have essential requirements for survival.
These include access to atmospheric oxygen, potable water, protective shelter,
and sustenance. The constant flux of the world is making our existence less
complicated. A significant portion of the population utilizes online food
ordering services to have meals delivered to their residences. Although there
are numerous methods for ordering food, customers sometimes experience
disappointment with the food they receive. Our endeavor was to establish a
model that could determine if food is of good or poor quality. We compiled an
extensive dataset of over 1484 online reviews from prominent food ordering
platforms, including Food Panda and HungryNaki. Leveraging the collected data,
a rigorous assessment of various deep learning and machine learning techniques
was performed to determine the most accurate approach for predicting food
quality. Out of all the algorithms evaluated, logistic regression emerged as
the most accurate, achieving an impressive 90.91% accuracy. The review offers
valuable insights that will guide the user in deciding whether or not to order
the food.
|
[
-0.3440577983856201,
-0.9037976861000061,
0.13472341001033783,
0.42714083194732666,
-0.42908790707588196,
0.12056224048137665,
0.18275466561317444,
-0.7300349473953247,
0.36335182189941406,
0.4557214677333832,
-0.4950712025165558,
-0.5036404728889465,
-0.5428341627120972,
0.3340533673763275,
-0.36470988392829895,
1.1079096794128418,
0.1779741793870926,
0.5904945731163025,
-0.15607906877994537,
-0.00008557223191019148,
-0.47340381145477295,
-0.3238796293735504,
-0.4521316587924957,
-0.32713019847869873,
0.47174301743507385,
0.11500369012355804,
0.998435378074646,
-0.055334318429231644,
0.5668696165084839,
0.2790704369544983,
-0.24669745564460754,
0.29291626811027527,
-0.3229350745677948,
0.193113312125206,
-0.43145424127578735,
-0.5363125801086426,
-0.4152701497077942,
-0.08904174715280533,
-0.04193985462188721,
0.8185961246490479,
-0.056184377521276474,
0.43401944637298584,
0.1062641367316246,
1.3948678970336914,
-0.38144636154174805,
0.29746365547180176,
-0.3359907865524292,
0.573514997959137,
0.4135078191757202,
0.12022366374731064,
-0.24252142012119293,
-1.1152222156524658,
-0.006977202836424112,
-0.622900664806366,
-0.12988746166229248,
-0.04491961747407913,
1.0478633642196655,
0.42407408356666565,
-0.27413004636764526,
-0.5412034392356873,
-0.8734608888626099,
0.7943703532218933,
-0.9067010879516602,
0.27080294489860535,
0.6246405839920044,
0.18569180369377136,
-0.426954984664917,
-0.21917520463466644,
-0.6079782247543335,
-0.03321534022688866,
0.09078583121299744,
0.3913789689540863,
-0.061494916677474976,
-0.04723517596721649,
-0.19697560369968414,
0.4878932237625122,
-0.6188375949859619,
-0.11263837665319443,
-0.36383652687072754,
0.30880090594291687,
0.6740016341209412,
0.23562556505203247,
0.3078365623950958,
-0.43457481265068054,
-0.6115956902503967,
-0.32572057843208313,
-0.3185167610645294,
0.6198314428329468,
0.5513343811035156,
0.3581176996231079,
0.05333750322461128,
0.755023717880249,
-0.4921703040599823,
0.8883732557296753,
0.3309004306793213,
-0.13200224936008453,
0.44299495220184326,
-0.47586333751678467,
-0.3738306164741516,
-0.04537623003125191,
0.7288140654563904,
0.8748739957809448,
0.07730356603860855,
0.3782854974269867,
-0.2543618083000183,
0.189877450466156,
0.328500896692276,
-0.6196238994598389,
-0.11105547100305557,
0.6254956722259521,
-0.7171316742897034,
-0.4628743529319763,
0.26645833253860474,
-0.9698270559310913,
-0.8321210741996765,
-0.292549729347229,
0.07961231470108032,
-0.07374172657728195,
-0.29174819588661194,
-0.062439605593681335,
-0.05756359547376633,
0.48493051528930664,
0.3060581088066101,
-0.6323213577270508,
0.06576202809810638,
0.6577863693237305,
0.8638235926628113,
0.11170598119497299,
0.16016621887683868,
-0.15281569957733154,
-0.26093873381614685,
-0.42059242725372314,
1.0025343894958496,
-0.5502771139144897,
-0.3379404544830322,
-0.18486076593399048,
-0.010951703414320946,
0.31302523612976074,
-0.7209221124649048,
0.7257891297340393,
-0.6418615579605103,
-0.19763892889022827,
-0.583793044090271,
-0.7578592300415039,
-0.7119455933570862,
0.6092663407325745,
-0.5612479448318481,
0.4955545663833618,
0.05491640791296959,
-0.6556451320648193,
0.5858062505722046,
-0.22444553673267365,
-0.7725726962089539,
0.3736063838005066,
0.041872359812259674,
-0.7122016549110413,
0.3110547363758087,
0.45664674043655396,
0.6815881729125977,
-0.2850520610809326,
0.22714155912399292,
-0.7851132750511169,
-0.14427576959133148,
0.7299103140830994,
-0.03671395033597946,
0.9615433812141418,
0.542063295841217,
-0.34876716136932373,
0.15851996839046478,
-0.3561423718929291,
0.1797109693288803,
0.2746012210845947,
-0.36485785245895386,
-0.09049318730831146,
0.283873587846756,
0.09978871792554855,
0.06046596169471741,
0.04331224784255028,
-0.4715064465999603,
0.27240291237831116,
-0.7556310892105103,
0.3470062017440796,
0.7552729845046997,
0.0978294312953949,
0.15434086322784424,
-0.31752097606658936,
0.5874315500259399,
0.27646398544311523,
0.7557874321937561,
0.38243091106414795,
-0.7988937497138977,
-0.3605908751487732,
0.16930019855499268,
0.27146121859550476,
0.688718318939209,
-0.3187774121761322,
0.7527046203613281,
-0.009243794716894627,
-0.4334716498851776,
-0.6648558378219604,
0.16993126273155212,
0.051358044147491455,
0.2976978123188019,
0.3086497485637665,
-0.49049925804138184,
-0.37893742322921753,
-0.6631456613540649,
-0.08725354820489883,
-0.14539434015750885,
0.15034285187721252,
0.24871377646923065,
-0.07446306198835373,
-0.5800946354866028,
1.0691933631896973,
-0.6563389301300049,
-0.3056272864341736,
-0.48589447140693665,
0.05615861713886261,
0.7183312177658081,
0.23696216940879822,
0.4504891335964203,
-1.2045553922653198,
-0.7463720440864563,
0.26650306582450867,
-0.9045113921165466,
0.10956068336963654,
0.12746740877628326,
0.17258329689502716,
0.28469371795654297,
-0.24759434163570404,
-0.5150455236434937,
0.44628748297691345,
0.6843405961990356,
-0.30253875255584717,
0.5178542137145996,
0.2634422779083252,
0.3451097905635834,
-1.08967924118042,
-0.15674126148223877,
0.1956995278596878,
0.1513608694076538,
-0.536281168460846,
-0.07547717541456223,
-0.23141765594482422,
-0.3415645956993103,
-0.16079650819301605,
0.3110804557800293,
-0.04028705507516861,
-0.20906305313110352,
-0.2944946587085724,
-0.36362120509147644,
0.2355688065290451,
0.2214444875717163,
-0.17570996284484863,
0.363994300365448,
0.4293864071369171,
-0.2723903954029083,
0.6904072165489197,
0.007762927561998367,
-0.5122584700584412,
0.5068769454956055,
-0.6698471307754517,
-0.26356881856918335,
-0.22343182563781738,
0.3839092552661896,
-1.241094708442688,
-0.21559982001781464,
0.7982184290885925,
-0.5754001140594482,
0.08672688901424408,
-0.08318581432104111,
-0.5248968601226807,
-0.5564173460006714,
-0.26939618587493896,
0.2582888901233673,
0.3026602268218994,
-0.34341758489608765,
0.5375440120697021,
0.6077563762664795,
-0.14529280364513397,
-0.5568662881851196,
-0.6280631422996521,
-0.12321130186319351,
0.06226221099495888,
-0.2951209843158722,
-0.4950290620326996,
-0.1867000013589859,
-0.33944186568260193,
0.00792904756963253,
-0.0662853866815567,
-0.1563297063112259,
0.0967792198061943,
0.7514559030532837,
0.1518813818693161,
-0.01728729158639908,
-0.2879730463027954,
0.02960021235048771,
-0.03822441026568413,
0.2109937071800232,
-0.1644618958234787,
0.5637460947036743,
-0.38859713077545166,
-0.09460373222827911,
-0.7115374803543091,
0.26483938097953796,
0.5719605684280396,
0.035786230117082596,
0.7320144176483154,
0.9707435369491577,
-0.23577331006526947,
0.07609181851148605,
-0.5391082167625427,
-0.055456604808568954,
-0.4919363558292389,
0.09770192950963974,
0.046183325350284576,
0.013591904193162918,
0.3967556655406952,
0.06214813515543938,
-0.2545221745967865,
0.14361049234867096,
0.39319583773612976,
-0.3824472427368164,
1.067267656326294,
0.315405935049057,
-0.22651541233062744,
0.30281513929367065,
-0.12284626811742783,
0.6711532473564148,
-0.31756728887557983,
-0.5929015278816223,
-0.32383593916893005,
-0.17597901821136475,
-0.7695225477218628,
-0.08239377290010452,
0.2968716621398926,
-0.025509418919682503,
-0.07323852181434631,
0.04325051233172417,
-0.7575191259384155,
0.48520442843437195,
0.3180764317512512,
0.616107702255249,
0.029571177437901497,
0.18596139550209045,
-0.09419874101877213,
0.19878621399402618,
-0.2537558078765869,
-0.3927328884601593,
0.7380678057670593,
0.34914442896842957,
0.9621150493621826,
0.002086326014250517,
0.4719483256340027,
0.6280860304832458,
0.2395666390657425,
-0.9262871742248535,
0.3625458776950836,
-0.12344039231538773,
-0.6856791377067566,
-0.13838201761245728,
-0.7114191651344299,
-0.9056539535522461,
-0.09067315608263016,
-0.21614544093608856,
-0.2346404492855072,
0.11161966621875763,
0.15496011078357697,
-0.46006113290786743,
0.21909363567829132,
-1.119539737701416,
0.6950801610946655,
-0.5635644793510437,
-0.6453037261962891,
-0.021621115505695343,
-0.8357433676719666,
0.15634097158908844,
0.3528994023799896,
0.37303274869918823,
-0.315956711769104,
0.36066415905952454,
0.6169191598892212,
-0.1479095071554184,
1.0014562606811523,
-0.35032570362091064,
-0.05444067344069481,
0.393699049949646,
0.22688913345336914,
0.3652190566062927,
0.2696433961391449,
-0.23026321828365326,
0.43500030040740967,
-0.04757929593324661,
-0.6113519072532654,
-0.561655580997467,
0.801285445690155,
-1.1082525253295898,
-0.2846951186656952,
-0.5461319088935852,
-0.1308927685022354,
-0.28713488578796387,
0.3011440336704254,
-0.013476566411554813,
-0.1560344099998474,
0.14337249100208282,
-0.07429280877113342,
0.34676215052604675,
-0.31354495882987976,
0.2540946900844574,
-0.0015321731334552169,
-0.554436206817627,
-0.8268938064575195,
1.3306795358657837,
0.12624850869178772,
-0.18877607583999634,
0.5121446847915649,
0.6349038481712341,
-0.2754421830177307,
-0.35269105434417725,
-0.5342430472373962,
-0.06437067687511444,
-0.6763343214988708,
-0.5724374055862427,
-0.6307656764984131,
-0.19322113692760468,
-0.34013861417770386,
-0.41131532192230225,
-0.5110125541687012,
0.013704986311495304,
-0.43072187900543213,
-0.1895972192287445,
0.009664005599915981,
1.2931504249572754,
0.18059492111206055,
-0.1790846735239029,
-0.7823028564453125,
0.20633061230182648,
0.33855998516082764,
0.2982237935066223,
0.301139235496521,
-0.01176783349364996,
-0.1731835901737213,
0.17377719283103943,
-0.4485267102718353,
-1.027114987373352,
0.8102242946624756,
-0.23179741203784943,
0.11945199221372604,
0.8029727339744568,
-0.011964601464569569,
0.4540320932865143,
0.38636040687561035,
0.8521460294723511,
0.546700119972229,
-0.6896383166313171,
0.5227130055427551,
-0.2888687252998352,
0.2874893844127655,
0.5128958225250244,
0.9206559658050537,
-0.24253642559051514,
-0.06817848980426788,
-0.08055514097213745,
-1.0892828702926636,
0.16204866766929626,
0.07089367508888245,
-0.12378709018230438,
0.07626330107450485,
0.24231159687042236,
0.75129234790802,
0.5802199244499207,
-1.155982255935669,
-0.13296441733837128,
-0.945115327835083,
-0.06772921234369278,
0.018215345218777657,
-0.29079821705818176,
0.3562593162059784,
-0.5288544297218323,
0.5796064734458923,
0.2419014424085617,
0.09526018053293228,
-0.14858892560005188,
0.19798988103866577,
-0.3975100815296173,
0.3855726718902588,
0.5277894735336304,
0.8976284861564636,
-0.6683180332183838,
-0.023061657324433327,
-0.2044689655303955,
-0.5315405130386353,
0.1774342805147171,
-0.42011865973472595,
-0.316067636013031,
-0.20011448860168457,
0.07552807033061981,
0.4402466118335724,
-0.15210653841495514,
-0.5718868970870972,
0.5278425216674805,
-0.1500244140625,
0.05916112661361694,
-0.45170584321022034,
-0.027043107897043228,
-0.053420256823301315,
0.1449051946401596,
0.4841301441192627,
0.38140901923179626,
0.4888484477996826,
-0.5283361673355103,
-0.042649999260902405,
0.2909848690032959,
-0.41125839948654175,
-0.4265486001968384,
-0.0824323520064354,
0.44123220443725586,
-0.2445550113916397,
0.8817757964134216,
-0.3574637770652771,
-0.5770168304443359,
0.4665415287017822,
0.4177638590335846,
0.9344856142997742,
-0.32703664898872375,
0.6482313275337219,
0.5310028791427612,
0.20328685641288757,
0.06280399113893509,
0.3192209303379059,
-0.058060575276613235,
-0.5361534357070923,
-0.19039222598075867,
-1.2458312511444092,
-0.4710111618041992,
0.17667873203754425,
-0.7914368510246277,
0.019749784842133522,
-0.7492358088493347,
-0.45430392026901245,
-0.12955687940120697,
0.1472727656364441,
-0.6236159801483154,
0.37861865758895874,
0.13568463921546936,
0.19473904371261597,
-1.1712794303894043,
0.2039886862039566,
0.8745331168174744,
-0.3862414062023163,
-0.5204721689224243,
0.2065223902463913,
-0.1470729112625122,
-0.5655627250671387,
0.6317458748817444,
0.35809335112571716,
-0.16203999519348145,
-0.4682227373123169,
-0.5977145433425903,
-0.7671463489532471,
0.3775504529476166,
-0.0581481046974659,
-0.6189181804656982,
0.23492172360420227,
0.22403095662593842,
0.6297100782394409,
-0.037044838070869446,
0.3815082609653473,
0.022669732570648193,
0.7239765524864197,
-0.06531865149736404,
-0.3527272939682007,
-0.16672027111053467,
-0.2787873148918152,
0.014685523696243763,
-0.008821162395179272,
-0.7141091227531433,
0.706154465675354,
-0.14975151419639587,
-0.2030702829360962,
-0.26745325326919556,
0.43993502855300903,
-0.15928588807582855,
0.6797921657562256,
0.3585200607776642,
0.5561229586601257,
0.4783307611942291,
0.1483435332775116,
0.8645983934402466,
-0.018473271280527115,
0.585192859172821,
0.6711110472679138,
-0.5113413333892822,
0.7906736135482788,
0.516237735748291,
-0.5269924998283386,
0.41221946477890015,
1.1058144569396973,
-0.2236272096633911,
0.8063755035400391,
0.09605425596237183,
0.09276637434959412,
-0.1963970810174942,
-0.460878849029541,
-0.3258165121078491,
0.2933448255062103,
0.37512871623039246,
-0.3633808195590973,
-0.056311190128326416,
0.21963433921337128,
-0.3096405565738678,
-0.09637157618999481,
-0.4520001709461212,
1.0557479858398438,
0.02606305480003357,
-0.502937912940979,
0.5900254249572754,
-0.15326331555843353,
0.30528512597084045,
-0.09662873297929764,
-0.17083609104156494,
-0.4201841354370117,
0.35393500328063965,
-0.6813360452651978,
-0.9812622666358948,
0.1915181279182434,
-0.3462790548801422,
-0.4299059212207794,
-0.11403200775384903,
0.4111124873161316,
0.16711683571338654,
-0.9441447854042053,
0.4991459250450134,
0.35189369320869446,
0.05025419965386391,
0.14890217781066895,
-1.1059622764587402,
0.4367271959781647,
0.0572744719684124,
-0.227717787027359,
0.24248144030570984,
-0.14282482862472534,
0.526688277721405,
0.5618107318878174,
0.5566433668136597,
0.12794969975948334,
0.13105912506580353,
-0.13415968418121338,
0.8129456043243408,
-0.5797781348228455,
-0.6842070817947388,
-0.8149484395980835,
0.18169619143009186,
-0.1427532583475113,
-0.03250362351536751,
0.7850809097290039,
0.5375654697418213,
1.1083509922027588,
-0.3179382383823395,
0.7040428519248962,
-0.0901608020067215,
0.33253759145736694,
-0.3702390193939209,
0.5863421559333801,
-0.4746079444885254,
0.2585286498069763,
-0.43209266662597656,
-1.019803524017334,
-0.27640408277511597,
0.8578323721885681,
-0.6032185554504395,
0.04010346904397011,
0.4910792112350464,
0.8312854766845703,
-0.10683071613311768,
0.26058998703956604,
0.3149817883968353,
0.3343382179737091,
0.04326935112476349,
0.13241837918758392,
1.0094654560089111,
-0.35745969414711,
0.22743196785449982,
-0.4269889295101166,
-0.27643853425979614,
-0.7903751730918884,
-0.47344863414764404,
-0.7760807275772095,
-0.5081828236579895,
-0.17836527526378632,
-0.4985095262527466,
0.10591696202754974,
1.218671441078186,
0.6689193844795227,
-1.1302047967910767,
-0.38466906547546387,
-0.10560628771781921,
0.513992190361023,
-0.6485654711723328,
-0.310329407453537,
0.44517895579338074,
-0.25577256083488464,
-0.2536051869392395,
0.14851014316082,
0.43529385328292847,
-0.09490981698036194,
-0.23052114248275757,
0.0864209309220314,
-0.2960684597492218,
0.1545790284872055,
0.6866762638092041,
0.25789132714271545,
-0.8642427325248718,
0.12135972827672958,
-0.15813013911247253,
-0.06927838176488876,
0.3251760005950928,
0.4350244700908661,
-0.3066027760505676,
0.7264578342437744,
0.49523261189460754,
0.7731244564056396,
0.09643340855836868,
0.3665066957473755,
0.10477498918771744,
-0.25902825593948364,
-0.2212371528148651,
0.4052540361881256,
0.1483766734600067,
0.5591058135032654,
-0.5803319811820984,
0.26575788855552673,
0.2550329267978668,
-0.6689503788948059,
-0.6840415596961975,
0.0722450390458107,
-1.2228302955627441,
-0.4294736385345459,
1.124433159828186,
-0.31880345940589905,
-0.6845405101776123,
-0.049888767302036285,
-0.02966979332268238,
0.18441395461559296,
-0.6275710463523865,
1.4287214279174805,
0.3714894950389862,
-0.2804468870162964,
0.2409507781267166,
-0.2410946637392044,
0.17508575320243835,
0.5165985226631165,
-0.8798362016677856,
-0.21770261228084564,
0.3876684904098511,
0.35183072090148926,
0.26728811860084534,
0.021039504557847977,
0.18391376733779907,
0.1657327264547348,
-0.12740685045719147,
0.14343346655368805,
0.18275098502635956,
-0.3602674901485443,
-0.08983933925628662,
0.7387507557868958,
0.013507361523807049,
-0.13627231121063232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01943v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01943v2
|
Dependency-Aware Semi-Structured Sparsity: Declining Roles of Outliers in Pruning GLU-based LLMs
| 2024-05-03T09:13:13 | 2024-06-20T06:57:29 |
Zhiyu Guo, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Wanatnabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The rapid growth in the scale of Large Language Models (LLMs) has led to
significant computational and memory costs, making model compression techniques
such as network pruning increasingly crucial for their efficient deployment.
Recent LLMs such as LLaMA2 and Mistral have adopted GLU-based MLP
architectures. However, current LLM pruning strategies are primarily based on
insights from older LLM architectures, necessitating a reevaluation of these
strategies to suit the new architectural characteristics. Contrary to
traditional beliefs, we find that outliers play a diminished role in the input
projections of GLU-based MLPs. Leveraging this new insight, we propose
Dependency-aware Semi-structured Sparsity (DaSS), a novel pruning method for
GLU-based LLMs. DaSS balances the flexibility of unstructured pruning and the
structural consistency of dependency-based structured pruning by considering
both of weight magnitude and corresponding intermediate activation norms in
weight pruning metric. Empirical evaluations on the Mistral, Gemma, and LLaMA2
model families demonstrate the consistent effectiveness of DaSS in the
prevailing GLU variants.
|
[
-0.28656211495399475,
-0.5821295976638794,
0.45125579833984375,
0.33138617873191833,
-0.04101240634918213,
0.003443238791078329,
-0.15885333716869354,
-0.2860403060913086,
0.41656723618507385,
0.1971128284931183,
-0.47969263792037964,
-0.34046414494514465,
-0.6620995402336121,
0.03965364769101143,
-0.5087012052536011,
1.024401307106018,
-0.06119378283619881,
-0.07215889543294907,
-0.359861820936203,
-0.10624583810567856,
-0.4875762462615967,
-0.5763289332389832,
-0.5048598647117615,
-0.11400371789932251,
0.23647639155387878,
0.34208744764328003,
0.8767993450164795,
0.4812636971473694,
0.055327802896499634,
0.31458085775375366,
-0.6134654879570007,
0.29452279210090637,
-0.5133285522460938,
0.14609698951244354,
0.08947619050741196,
-0.36788231134414673,
-0.20768176019191742,
-0.2813802659511566,
0.9634275436401367,
0.8210423588752747,
-0.492048054933548,
0.08376046270132065,
0.6142076253890991,
0.8456604480743408,
-0.6428031325340271,
-0.012741424143314362,
-0.5083279609680176,
0.0900670662522316,
-0.386219322681427,
-0.36884546279907227,
-0.48987987637519836,
-0.009434529580175877,
-0.2701660990715027,
-0.4101715683937073,
0.4123140573501587,
-0.08099482953548431,
0.879547119140625,
0.7060449719429016,
-0.3014512360095978,
-0.10651006549596786,
-0.882338285446167,
0.7501291632652283,
-0.7949452996253967,
0.3911665976047516,
0.33626246452331543,
0.24882057309150696,
-0.738166332244873,
-0.49980875849723816,
0.05122559517621994,
-0.1375504732131958,
-0.28301116824150085,
-0.12424593418836594,
-0.2161543071269989,
0.11127504706382751,
0.058707345277071,
0.44784507155418396,
-0.41149723529815674,
0.18027666211128235,
-0.3425943851470947,
-0.3245929777622223,
0.2281927764415741,
0.14614036679267883,
0.1961287409067154,
0.09715114533901215,
-0.6038678884506226,
0.6016576290130615,
-1.2487499713897705,
-0.0055608986876904964,
0.4422655999660492,
0.25814685225486755,
-0.1484212577342987,
0.562078595161438,
0.28620657324790955,
0.9609634280204773,
-0.09685672074556351,
-0.14722950756549835,
-0.04320526123046875,
-0.27061712741851807,
-0.40813061594963074,
-0.09478598833084106,
0.43522536754608154,
0.01866976171731949,
0.3895644247531891,
-0.1768752932548523,
-0.28974491357803345,
0.21048057079315186,
0.14026832580566406,
-0.7147454619407654,
-0.40750542283058167,
0.20031856000423431,
-0.5108147859573364,
-0.2468731850385666,
-0.20574265718460083,
-0.47730782628059387,
-0.5799984335899353,
-0.17123128473758698,
0.09404494613409042,
-0.29264724254608154,
-0.4123787581920624,
0.010510030202567577,
-0.04986070469021797,
-0.27981555461883545,
0.3899317979812622,
-1.0248605012893677,
0.5734884142875671,
0.48024222254753113,
1.1085463762283325,
-0.23981742560863495,
-0.18653175234794617,
-0.7291102409362793,
0.34035852551460266,
-0.2896099090576172,
0.7721094489097595,
-0.36973610520362854,
-0.450867623090744,
-0.20221881568431854,
-0.08774753659963608,
-0.14453595876693726,
-0.8500884771347046,
0.4103935956954956,
-0.4422870874404907,
-0.17126993834972382,
-0.2556607723236084,
-0.5642668604850769,
-0.17695952951908112,
0.3331374526023865,
-0.6073949337005615,
1.3016003370285034,
0.48974132537841797,
-0.8498328924179077,
0.22749680280685425,
-0.0747070387005806,
-0.4730634093284607,
0.1428472250699997,
-0.478577584028244,
-0.5729734897613525,
0.43352121114730835,
-0.1022098958492279,
0.5014558434486389,
-0.22587071359157562,
0.7419680953025818,
-0.48448559641838074,
-0.599449098110199,
-0.11615892499685287,
-0.45931199193000793,
0.7695738673210144,
-0.13979414105415344,
-0.06353028118610382,
0.2985575199127197,
-0.8287597298622131,
-0.21965299546718597,
0.005377254914492369,
-0.538899302482605,
-0.5180510878562927,
0.34560421109199524,
0.05288960039615631,
0.13220898807048798,
-0.03089107759296894,
-0.2873256504535675,
0.053255341947078705,
-0.5836321115493774,
0.6249105334281921,
0.9978755712509155,
-0.016847362741827965,
0.522246778011322,
-0.2588648200035095,
0.5015448331832886,
0.12363354861736298,
0.1745850145816803,
0.2884463369846344,
-0.5274574160575867,
-0.5418328642845154,
-0.6627240777015686,
0.11911308020353317,
0.22812247276306152,
-0.48942527174949646,
0.5469285249710083,
-0.0488717220723629,
-0.3633544445037842,
-0.20127932727336884,
0.38830602169036865,
0.18254444003105164,
0.6637372970581055,
0.36182406544685364,
-0.2923434376716614,
-0.5734484195709229,
-0.8562795519828796,
-0.05627543479204178,
-0.15168707072734833,
0.14723266661167145,
0.03930383920669556,
0.3214755058288574,
-0.038584087044000626,
1.099266767501831,
-0.1836835891008377,
-0.5734306573867798,
-0.3784482181072235,
-0.10383927822113037,
0.09526555985212326,
0.3184190094470978,
0.6285014152526855,
-0.7680172920227051,
-0.5074144005775452,
-0.2560710906982422,
-0.32694342732429504,
-0.06329145282506943,
0.10026794672012329,
0.4003317654132843,
0.22992415726184845,
0.37884944677352905,
-0.59243243932724,
0.6827442049980164,
0.6886190176010132,
-0.3875301480293274,
0.8232372999191284,
-0.42451101541519165,
-0.45546597242355347,
-0.9724971055984497,
0.006229620426893234,
0.25341400504112244,
-0.259365439414978,
-0.8125922679901123,
-0.5552501678466797,
0.14025868475437164,
0.1632033735513687,
-0.378564715385437,
0.47755172848701477,
-0.8703206777572632,
-0.6733099818229675,
-0.09989485144615173,
-0.3313141465187073,
0.10080572217702866,
0.678335964679718,
-0.020007768645882607,
1.0401077270507812,
0.6197559833526611,
-0.8610633015632629,
-0.04923776537179947,
0.08824819326400757,
-0.49031171202659607,
0.09011706709861755,
-0.648199200630188,
-0.42559632658958435,
-0.13552138209342957,
0.3076675832271576,
-0.866594672203064,
0.14525289833545685,
0.32635921239852905,
-0.16303232312202454,
0.5892794728279114,
-0.5837728381156921,
-0.3837786316871643,
0.08014426380395889,
-0.42696017026901245,
0.5240370631217957,
0.16978205740451813,
-0.520574152469635,
0.4449869692325592,
0.5238514542579651,
-0.18854987621307373,
-0.7430474758148193,
-0.6737207174301147,
0.19602763652801514,
-0.519503116607666,
-0.47873735427856445,
0.4627172350883484,
-0.12425778061151505,
-0.14961305260658264,
0.06669270992279053,
-0.35168835520744324,
0.21325573325157166,
0.3363683521747589,
0.21087990701198578,
0.44549867510795593,
0.017360275611281395,
-0.20781071484088898,
-0.10361096262931824,
-0.24545443058013916,
-0.08478442579507828,
-0.23532256484031677,
0.4722716510295868,
-0.023106148466467857,
-0.514821469783783,
-0.1461041271686554,
0.36014309525489807,
0.5542697906494141,
-0.061996329575777054,
0.654325544834137,
0.32014182209968567,
-0.30978474020957947,
-0.44160008430480957,
-0.3833788335323334,
0.0401257686316967,
-0.494937002658844,
0.4065152108669281,
-0.13406996428966522,
-1.1797873973846436,
0.5606611967086792,
-0.24763795733451843,
0.009629614651203156,
0.08499003201723099,
0.7268962860107422,
0.003338033566251397,
0.9770501852035522,
0.9188576340675354,
-0.3387130796909332,
0.5830531716346741,
-0.23114727437496185,
0.28426870703697205,
-0.8331977128982544,
-0.01226503774523735,
-0.6104071736335754,
-0.37385010719299316,
-0.36318016052246094,
-0.3440733551979065,
0.4945753216743469,
0.18237890303134918,
-0.13181781768798828,
0.20163853466510773,
-0.5768997669219971,
0.296417236328125,
0.18733938038349152,
-0.2572484612464905,
0.15265609323978424,
0.2773108184337616,
0.171609565615654,
-0.08228063583374023,
-0.8993290662765503,
-0.299485445022583,
0.5333475470542908,
0.411962628364563,
0.6789100170135498,
0.17638446390628815,
0.3529506027698517,
0.4930102825164795,
0.27205145359039307,
-0.9213666319847107,
0.5226397514343262,
0.04275650903582573,
-0.39993923902511597,
-0.32564690709114075,
-0.6894901990890503,
-0.8935143351554871,
0.06022975966334343,
0.05103126913309097,
-0.9455682039260864,
0.5472874641418457,
0.31881269812583923,
-0.447770893573761,
0.4602021872997284,
-0.677077054977417,
0.627934992313385,
-0.010413864627480507,
-0.23762542009353638,
-0.10749500244855881,
-0.5279391407966614,
0.3054054379463196,
0.2508840560913086,
0.30776193737983704,
-0.1409078687429428,
-0.32006749510765076,
0.6587030291557312,
-0.7345912456512451,
1.0319541692733765,
-0.42995694279670715,
-0.2125532180070877,
0.3050062358379364,
0.2937791645526886,
0.8375925421714783,
-0.02800685539841652,
0.10274071991443634,
0.20763719081878662,
-0.017629355192184448,
-0.33412036299705505,
-0.6930548548698425,
0.7400060296058655,
-0.6181914806365967,
-0.6049721837043762,
-0.31494346261024475,
-0.5039371848106384,
-0.5363498330116272,
0.031546302139759064,
0.23951442539691925,
0.6345046758651733,
-0.08960946649312973,
-0.1454172134399414,
0.6299303770065308,
0.05362933501601219,
0.46953150629997253,
0.4346410930156708,
-0.006944246590137482,
-0.4305683374404907,
1.0541799068450928,
0.4907792806625366,
0.20516884326934814,
0.11110556125640869,
0.05350768193602562,
-0.14130952954292297,
-0.9881418347358704,
-0.5919603705406189,
0.20500341057777405,
-0.5002629160881042,
-0.4757698178291321,
-0.2704673707485199,
-0.39554157853126526,
-0.20218491554260254,
-0.19544363021850586,
-0.3370409607887268,
-0.43405231833457947,
-0.21996214985847473,
-0.20271611213684082,
0.3039373457431793,
0.9197019934654236,
-0.09592783451080322,
0.1381208449602127,
-0.8533308506011963,
0.020429322496056557,
-0.09284523129463196,
0.4974221885204315,
0.17615604400634766,
-0.627071738243103,
-0.4851621389389038,
-0.26371946930885315,
0.07831553369760513,
-0.9299364686012268,
0.528410792350769,
0.16461007297039032,
0.4422188103199005,
0.4940839409828186,
-0.01602485217154026,
0.7195321917533875,
-0.3386039733886719,
0.557296633720398,
0.3232611417770386,
-0.564461350440979,
0.23373723030090332,
-0.13209836184978485,
-0.17873236536979675,
0.45846402645111084,
0.07933518290519714,
-0.3663675785064697,
-0.2884027659893036,
-0.602644145488739,
-0.8671327233314514,
0.6389421224594116,
0.09563139826059341,
-0.2046966254711151,
0.05564923956990242,
0.16585947573184967,
0.06938320398330688,
0.10312841087579727,
-0.584378719329834,
-0.23975269496440887,
0.2144058346748352,
-0.10336912423372269,
-0.07625237852334976,
-0.7688789963722229,
-0.27458909153938293,
-0.13393060863018036,
0.810073971748352,
-0.04551547020673752,
-0.03615261986851692,
0.09681535512208939,
-0.0232878215610981,
-0.17470824718475342,
0.2941937744617462,
0.5052455067634583,
0.3363132178783417,
-0.09407572448253632,
0.30091577768325806,
0.2010350078344345,
-0.5658226013183594,
0.37367895245552063,
0.010402632877230644,
-0.6566483378410339,
0.13151611387729645,
-0.008325373753905296,
0.6049498319625854,
0.4227908253669739,
-0.3858835697174072,
0.5023255348205566,
-0.03484313189983368,
0.00003789152469835244,
-0.3720490336418152,
-0.1108681708574295,
0.13010989129543304,
-0.015677480027079582,
0.07125979661941528,
0.5602794289588928,
0.1537913978099823,
-0.20467469096183777,
-0.11833388358354568,
0.6196678876876831,
-0.5359106659889221,
-0.36202046275138855,
0.27896353602409363,
0.04856540635228157,
-0.2386237382888794,
0.28557682037353516,
-0.10449200868606567,
-0.15763777494430542,
0.5173193216323853,
0.566512942314148,
0.7247687578201294,
-0.21344813704490662,
0.1979057937860489,
0.09367529302835464,
0.3800188899040222,
-0.44708681106567383,
0.02126891538500786,
-0.4216063320636749,
-0.7855557203292847,
-0.6295067071914673,
-0.5895524024963379,
-0.21709558367729187,
0.1751352697610855,
-0.4777587056159973,
0.44724032282829285,
-0.531991720199585,
-0.12759661674499512,
-0.3769608438014984,
0.010479599237442017,
0.014652371406555176,
0.11944819986820221,
-0.012219083495438099,
1.0491275787353516,
-1.0704864263534546,
0.9784270524978638,
0.8450886607170105,
-0.143095463514328,
-0.9109655618667603,
-0.057520121335983276,
0.19091355800628662,
-0.6054239869117737,
-0.008133689872920513,
0.2586769759654999,
-0.26231974363327026,
0.07109829038381577,
-0.2725851535797119,
-1.0399051904678345,
0.9677033424377441,
0.8359997272491455,
-0.47680529952049255,
-0.21068191528320312,
0.032329149544239044,
0.24436898529529572,
0.10522900521755219,
0.036958761513233185,
0.5875096917152405,
0.3718395531177521,
0.22496441006660461,
-0.6663879156112671,
0.11235573142766953,
-0.5079510807991028,
0.15196681022644043,
0.6015657782554626,
-0.6753728985786438,
0.41417670249938965,
-0.14513073861598969,
-0.5300334692001343,
0.023041019216179848,
0.758635938167572,
0.5333287715911865,
0.25805309414863586,
0.7171313166618347,
0.6169729232788086,
0.7400976419448853,
0.13219010829925537,
0.5416138172149658,
-0.3300367295742035,
0.16487328708171844,
1.0581283569335938,
-0.2586691677570343,
0.487870991230011,
0.751315176486969,
-0.31025364995002747,
0.25839763879776,
0.7425912618637085,
0.07498385012149811,
0.5121100544929504,
0.35339608788490295,
-0.22522595524787903,
-0.1920740157365799,
-0.2031053602695465,
-0.4845742881298065,
0.09309705346822739,
0.5137324333190918,
-0.01129179634153843,
-0.5341209769248962,
-0.2201482504606247,
0.27901992201805115,
0.09774862974882126,
-0.23649653792381287,
0.600894570350647,
0.3043179512023926,
-0.5662158727645874,
0.7264461517333984,
0.10526298731565475,
0.8641294240951538,
-0.8216498494148254,
0.08612002432346344,
-0.30480995774269104,
0.13657739758491516,
-0.5844773650169373,
-0.5962795615196228,
0.7765535712242126,
0.04922118037939072,
-0.3069218695163727,
-0.41573774814605713,
1.1477285623550415,
-0.22100304067134857,
-0.28887659311294556,
0.6523390412330627,
0.5743773579597473,
0.14521658420562744,
0.03646440431475639,
-0.5114730000495911,
0.07816164940595627,
0.005185401998460293,
-0.5973146557807922,
0.9231346845626831,
0.4463988244533539,
-0.2591409683227539,
0.762612521648407,
0.35750868916511536,
0.5430616140365601,
-0.16290122270584106,
0.2610801160335541,
1.2217026948928833,
-0.17093908786773682,
-0.47241708636283875,
-0.8463557362556458,
0.5188537836074829,
-0.03411867842078209,
-0.12461576610803604,
0.6697858572006226,
0.6374836564064026,
0.634021520614624,
0.30632534623146057,
0.6033170819282532,
-0.036127351224422455,
0.4168053865432739,
-0.37997472286224365,
0.514576256275177,
-0.6148175001144409,
0.6579265594482422,
0.026537220925092697,
-0.7830018401145935,
-0.24444282054901123,
0.15281496942043304,
-0.1848423182964325,
0.016986936330795288,
0.19383558630943298,
1.2191420793533325,
-0.07770263403654099,
-0.007323592435568571,
0.44340816140174866,
0.12541697919368744,
0.17840580642223358,
0.23511318862438202,
0.8206576108932495,
0.01561568584293127,
0.6768842935562134,
-0.08024051785469055,
-0.45286667346954346,
-0.0042993975803256035,
-0.7837470173835754,
-0.6569194793701172,
-0.6182782649993896,
-0.26536500453948975,
-0.42143192887306213,
-0.03343333303928375,
0.6667502522468567,
0.5575298070907593,
-0.8488622903823853,
-0.28003793954849243,
-0.4030086398124695,
0.22727541625499725,
-0.37377581000328064,
-0.21663108468055725,
0.41725170612335205,
-0.36755862832069397,
-0.2773903012275696,
0.8537858128547668,
0.8063650727272034,
0.09553748369216919,
-0.39633241295814514,
-0.23046687245368958,
-0.16237246990203857,
-0.03302272409200668,
0.3239465057849884,
0.6038653254508972,
-0.46124234795570374,
-0.14003145694732666,
-0.1920158863067627,
-0.04431857168674469,
0.07896386831998825,
0.8848127126693726,
-0.8274621963500977,
-0.06997281312942505,
0.3970962464809418,
0.45571184158325195,
0.21056509017944336,
-0.007216444704681635,
0.5735723376274109,
-0.9583654403686523,
0.29115572571754456,
0.2077951282262802,
0.6851963400840759,
0.4931805729866028,
-0.49058669805526733,
0.5059864521026611,
0.5840470790863037,
-0.5443625450134277,
-1.101717233657837,
0.32140374183654785,
-0.6380285024642944,
-0.25585436820983887,
1.2772661447525024,
-0.195887491106987,
-0.25225549936294556,
-0.5062994956970215,
-0.11242202669382095,
0.13569441437721252,
-0.14469793438911438,
0.7391059994697571,
0.5106080174446106,
0.08636549115180969,
-0.09700524806976318,
-0.24347878992557526,
0.811599850654602,
0.7257435917854309,
-0.4367615878582001,
0.4781554937362671,
0.5638124346733093,
0.15537519752979279,
-0.08037539571523666,
1.014081358909607,
-0.10618459433317184,
-0.07626551389694214,
-0.2109740823507309,
-0.09156624972820282,
-0.33418819308280945,
-0.6614673137664795,
-0.3449285924434662,
0.27025270462036133,
0.14458361268043518,
0.009032629430294037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01942v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01942v1
|
CRCL at SemEval-2024 Task 2: Simple prompt optimizations
| 2024-05-03T09:10:40 | 2024-05-03T09:10:40 |
Clément Brutti-Mairesse, Loïc Verlingue
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present a baseline for the SemEval 2024 task 2 challenge, whose objective
is to ascertain the inference relationship between pairs of clinical trial
report sections and statements. We apply prompt optimization techniques with
LLM Instruct models provided as a Language Model-as-a-Service (LMaaS). We
observed, in line with recent findings, that synthetic CoT prompts
significantly enhance manually crafted ones.
|
[
-0.1540258377790451,
-0.7384534478187561,
1.1255968809127808,
0.37605005502700806,
-0.3083149790763855,
-0.12158149480819702,
-0.13435688614845276,
-0.4932814836502075,
-0.23516331613063812,
0.6714645028114319,
-1.1246098279953003,
-0.3200105130672455,
-0.3099925220012665,
0.4528774917125702,
-0.054898329079151154,
0.8493176698684692,
-0.23367324471473694,
0.5727319121360779,
-0.6529380679130554,
-0.1600365936756134,
-0.7723761200904846,
-0.5767435431480408,
-0.8147290349006653,
-0.24978169798851013,
0.6483491659164429,
0.726747989654541,
0.15928144752979279,
0.3672812283039093,
0.4512973427772522,
0.18033252656459808,
-0.11232057213783264,
0.30047911405563354,
-0.3616114556789398,
0.36097851395606995,
-0.003089378820732236,
-0.41448163986206055,
-0.1951654851436615,
-0.15626491606235504,
0.15418483316898346,
0.7233909964561462,
0.10655145347118378,
0.20474788546562195,
0.013371467590332031,
0.5538407564163208,
-0.44434258341789246,
-0.15524812042713165,
-0.3802751898765564,
-0.04670950025320053,
0.02352176420390606,
-0.42152300477027893,
-0.6743373274803162,
-0.4102451503276825,
0.25217512249946594,
-0.5681926012039185,
0.2802262008190155,
0.25470414757728577,
0.7180067300796509,
0.33430230617523193,
-0.7264885902404785,
-0.6939098834991455,
-0.38121697306632996,
0.7815518975257874,
-0.37759676575660706,
0.13537420332431793,
0.3098895251750946,
0.30069655179977417,
-0.29430460929870605,
-1.0212123394012451,
-0.08748651295900345,
-0.2622826397418976,
-0.11160091310739517,
0.031336717307567596,
0.024049850180745125,
0.2424078732728958,
0.3550557494163513,
-0.07252165675163269,
-0.6572110652923584,
0.11700504273176193,
-0.534558892250061,
-0.49520143866539,
0.5854750871658325,
0.6506065726280212,
0.2811739146709442,
0.03870346024632454,
-0.6845422387123108,
0.12201282382011414,
-0.9084184765815735,
0.2749596834182739,
-0.05064591392874718,
0.2769511044025421,
-0.27587053179740906,
0.5914625525474548,
-0.0716574564576149,
0.3923858106136322,
-0.05168914794921875,
0.13346056640148163,
0.26489847898483276,
-0.885333240032196,
0.03345616161823273,
0.24176445603370667,
0.3497570753097534,
0.5672065615653992,
-0.1252066045999527,
0.09585922211408615,
-0.31139788031578064,
0.2503458559513092,
0.2695431411266327,
-0.7340144515037537,
-0.18957370519638062,
0.40210190415382385,
-0.4385203421115875,
-0.4754505455493927,
-0.3929194509983063,
-0.8364317417144775,
-0.3082469701766968,
-0.6010804176330566,
0.6809995770454407,
-0.10302304476499557,
0.509306013584137,
0.00555864442139864,
-0.15620580315589905,
0.2668640911579132,
0.7155766487121582,
-0.394024133682251,
0.329318106174469,
0.5227741599082947,
0.5609835982322693,
-0.34472858905792236,
0.06270132958889008,
-1.0340553522109985,
-0.08832206577062607,
-0.17646797001361847,
1.1782020330429077,
-0.45665085315704346,
-0.8355599045753479,
0.060240212827920914,
0.3068823218345642,
0.12049967050552368,
-0.3127167522907257,
0.9667998552322388,
-0.3979935348033905,
0.4437063932418823,
-0.7666890621185303,
-0.4219813942909241,
0.11142836511135101,
0.13489505648612976,
-0.37758874893188477,
0.9826369285583496,
0.29683175683021545,
-0.4095050096511841,
0.08416200429201126,
-0.6049618721008301,
-0.32145431637763977,
0.05995328351855278,
-0.26080721616744995,
-0.43867477774620056,
0.040242165327072144,
0.28278452157974243,
-0.15808166563510895,
-0.7067198157310486,
0.1368766725063324,
0.019105706363916397,
-0.17552295327186584,
0.1602036952972412,
-0.05676333233714104,
0.7313203811645508,
0.5733424425125122,
-0.36190667748451233,
0.25797900557518005,
-0.5509381890296936,
0.21622465550899506,
0.23975546658039093,
-0.30516260862350464,
0.020594419911503792,
-0.1708594709634781,
-0.1278986632823944,
-0.02866262011229992,
0.5199165940284729,
-0.41697975993156433,
0.20646530389785767,
-0.2574683129787445,
0.24660369753837585,
0.7303948998451233,
0.6861274838447571,
0.45086219906806946,
-0.20530515909194946,
0.9069029688835144,
-0.17838087677955627,
0.3705136179924011,
-0.22709278762340546,
-0.5185295939445496,
-0.6484543085098267,
-0.11341612040996552,
0.32535549998283386,
0.495355486869812,
-0.566425085067749,
-0.1388881802558899,
0.37368515133857727,
-0.27986031770706177,
-0.21748672425746918,
0.021016454324126244,
0.5374696850776672,
0.6725640892982483,
0.2558022737503052,
-0.10005319863557816,
-0.8431742191314697,
-1.095284104347229,
-0.1882285624742508,
0.1825062483549118,
0.3165402412414551,
0.2761971652507782,
0.33063259720802307,
-0.329356849193573,
0.6208486557006836,
-0.44369369745254517,
-0.0037571133580058813,
-0.37622660398483276,
0.1463681161403656,
0.2503145933151245,
0.4571690559387207,
0.6462178230285645,
-0.5823505520820618,
-0.5119088292121887,
-0.41348400712013245,
-0.5582692623138428,
-0.9338123202323914,
-0.19478283822536469,
-0.20360000431537628,
0.3157776892185211,
0.8218486309051514,
-0.2779906094074249,
0.48689308762550354,
0.3164845407009125,
-0.45900800824165344,
0.7270269393920898,
-0.3194713890552521,
0.39886632561683655,
-0.7217977643013,
-0.1265215426683426,
-0.346945196390152,
-0.26606398820877075,
-0.7415174841880798,
-0.08618547767400742,
0.01368496660143137,
-0.3163723051548004,
-0.41252124309539795,
0.7418133616447449,
-0.6453590989112854,
-0.14592960476875305,
-0.4240454435348511,
0.18157202005386353,
0.18980978429317474,
0.428244024515152,
-0.10739704966545105,
1.1756031513214111,
0.3618925213813782,
-0.6256276965141296,
-0.05112696811556816,
0.45383939146995544,
-0.0878356397151947,
0.31990018486976624,
-1.0906585454940796,
0.34387555718421936,
0.017317751422524452,
0.17717215418815613,
-1.0082690715789795,
-0.2891150116920471,
0.17997436225414276,
-0.39529597759246826,
-0.06934183835983276,
0.1291201412677765,
-0.29768088459968567,
-0.41458335518836975,
-0.3778885006904602,
0.690528929233551,
0.5584884881973267,
-0.4702155888080597,
0.3753628432750702,
0.13695383071899414,
-0.3659513592720032,
-0.12637294828891754,
-0.5809155106544495,
0.013217540457844734,
-0.09027132391929626,
-0.535463809967041,
0.3801940083503723,
-0.26781797409057617,
-0.2837701737880707,
-0.2120124101638794,
-0.0174945667386055,
0.22282791137695312,
0.03157629445195198,
0.4001498818397522,
0.4969716966152191,
-0.20544593036174774,
0.030071726068854332,
0.26737943291664124,
-0.11888552457094193,
0.39469555020332336,
0.0816202461719513,
0.6987114548683167,
-0.038652289658784866,
-0.48798397183418274,
-0.5530605912208557,
0.642753541469574,
0.07581459730863571,
-0.16223880648612976,
0.2912996709346771,
0.13153742253780365,
-0.25623369216918945,
-0.21768970787525177,
-0.3730419874191284,
-0.3625192940235138,
-0.5589256882667542,
0.021124565973877907,
-0.47003450989723206,
-0.9531992077827454,
0.5475372672080994,
-0.19879524409770966,
-0.03594734147191048,
0.44824832677841187,
0.8284135460853577,
0.06230763718485832,
1.3003880977630615,
0.19904202222824097,
0.600789487361908,
0.3236697018146515,
-0.054972514510154724,
0.08863544464111328,
-0.7610095143318176,
-0.5490825772285461,
-0.9317679405212402,
0.0382111631333828,
-0.2546606659889221,
-0.5330328941345215,
0.946280837059021,
0.08919259905815125,
-0.4612853527069092,
0.30467167496681213,
-0.5950882434844971,
0.3153703808784485,
0.6878674626350403,
0.346932590007782,
-0.03976592794060707,
-0.07574065029621124,
-0.43036407232284546,
-0.006638955790549517,
-0.6650443077087402,
-0.5840423703193665,
1.0488276481628418,
0.2116837054491043,
0.4696090519428253,
-0.05123761668801308,
0.7931259274482727,
0.3655235171318054,
-0.19992192089557648,
-0.5574367046356201,
0.6420506238937378,
0.2812250256538391,
-0.38721969723701477,
0.01881380006670952,
-0.13040432333946228,
-1.0494855642318726,
-0.2447223663330078,
0.010821611620485783,
-0.716359555721283,
0.2911769151687622,
0.07359189540147781,
-0.5494686365127563,
-0.5956277847290039,
-0.6137858629226685,
0.8128802180290222,
-0.4732216000556946,
-0.32171234488487244,
-0.23224849998950958,
-0.8084222674369812,
0.12266864627599716,
-0.050737716257572174,
0.21732141077518463,
-0.0752919614315033,
-0.3493674695491791,
0.5019198656082153,
-0.7269048690795898,
0.6816716194152832,
-0.22262373566627502,
0.034834444522857666,
0.7239145636558533,
0.0674143061041832,
0.870785117149353,
0.2502056658267975,
-0.0505765825510025,
-0.6023387908935547,
0.4559730887413025,
-0.588158905506134,
-0.612886369228363,
0.61319500207901,
-0.7396829724311829,
-0.6417339444160461,
-0.417325884103775,
-0.18430070579051971,
-0.3972178101539612,
-0.02347707189619541,
0.3320954144001007,
0.9253809452056885,
-0.22255876660346985,
-0.08566978573799133,
0.4437277615070343,
-0.5057462453842163,
0.374927818775177,
0.4137696921825409,
0.024433299899101257,
-0.6012185215950012,
0.3804084062576294,
-0.5200334191322327,
0.4866143465042114,
0.11994113028049469,
0.22089292109012604,
-0.5616338849067688,
-0.7760586738586426,
-0.17781205475330353,
0.22830437123775482,
-0.9426554441452026,
-0.2929569184780121,
-0.7278589606285095,
-0.12686683237552643,
-0.5068869590759277,
-0.5513891577720642,
-0.14215722680091858,
-0.5041563510894775,
-0.6470033526420593,
0.06209119036793709,
0.27749165892601013,
0.6815153956413269,
-0.08719833195209503,
0.31751441955566406,
-0.9615874290466309,
0.08122169971466064,
0.20257222652435303,
-0.4270813763141632,
-0.4483509957790375,
-0.6649948358535767,
0.0030176241416484118,
0.04411948472261429,
-0.28314346075057983,
-0.6587125658988953,
0.29420986771583557,
0.06144646555185318,
0.687458872795105,
0.22873394191265106,
0.22028911113739014,
0.5708150863647461,
-0.4892648160457611,
1.1983517408370972,
0.33539023995399475,
-0.7687512040138245,
1.0150221586227417,
-0.3171762228012085,
0.22378627955913544,
0.8440346717834473,
0.18120746314525604,
-0.1649646908044815,
-0.0337439626455307,
-0.5395960211753845,
-0.5721356272697449,
0.7169952988624573,
0.23650182783603668,
-0.04687253013253212,
-0.1072520762681961,
0.5124276280403137,
0.06779395788908005,
0.09709817171096802,
-0.3039284348487854,
-0.0936494991183281,
0.31081849336624146,
-0.20879849791526794,
0.21948698163032532,
-0.6999378800392151,
-0.4205091893672943,
-0.14066515862941742,
0.48484158515930176,
-0.2108648270368576,
0.6009314656257629,
0.5444419384002686,
0.05283273383975029,
-0.25255104899406433,
0.18538562953472137,
1.1208852529525757,
0.697563648223877,
-0.024179883301258087,
0.11926048249006271,
0.6024668216705322,
-0.18399478495121002,
0.24687281250953674,
-0.15152566134929657,
-0.11510273069143295,
-0.08606996387243271,
0.5637142658233643,
0.8500873446464539,
0.27098286151885986,
-1.0333797931671143,
0.4830288589000702,
-0.06861457973718643,
-0.4031732678413391,
-0.5228701233863831,
0.12962228059768677,
-0.13010664284229279,
0.4783497154712677,
0.24504773318767548,
0.05326371267437935,
0.333386093378067,
-0.5579532980918884,
0.41843926906585693,
0.260010302066803,
-0.46050962805747986,
-0.2883540093898773,
0.9571104049682617,
0.3325101137161255,
-0.5234459042549133,
0.12348288297653198,
-0.2890116274356842,
-0.8531914353370667,
0.8582165241241455,
0.5589770674705505,
0.661487340927124,
0.035944826900959015,
0.1306084394454956,
0.5549650192260742,
-0.10352703183889389,
-0.04167058318853378,
0.641527533531189,
0.15621091425418854,
-0.3937075138092041,
-0.2160605788230896,
-0.36321917176246643,
-0.4735250771045685,
-0.23073871433734894,
-0.7481352686882019,
0.8432949781417847,
-0.3723612129688263,
-0.036479055881500244,
-0.024895016103982925,
0.23948466777801514,
-0.7112504839897156,
0.18265540897846222,
-0.0662483349442482,
1.0073617696762085,
-0.3469671607017517,
0.5314920544624329,
0.5978546142578125,
-0.3109072148799896,
-0.9671065211296082,
-0.5701508522033691,
0.4112183749675751,
-0.9287840127944946,
0.7507109642028809,
0.027378326281905174,
-0.00440225750207901,
-0.1752905696630478,
-0.701901912689209,
-0.5493896007537842,
1.272759199142456,
0.20304714143276215,
-0.6557720303535461,
-0.12982821464538574,
0.15295632183551788,
0.4344528913497925,
-0.7534286379814148,
0.1758187860250473,
0.5164446234703064,
0.41270384192466736,
0.3052695393562317,
-0.8098289370536804,
0.2503938376903534,
-0.10774395614862442,
-0.13552385568618774,
0.014773726463317871,
-0.626934826374054,
0.6285054087638855,
-0.44632673263549805,
-0.14369767904281616,
0.5131196975708008,
0.6332390904426575,
0.536594033241272,
0.8569875955581665,
0.5641583204269409,
0.20945534110069275,
0.6537193655967712,
0.03371301293373108,
1.1399928331375122,
-0.36509326100349426,
0.24236233532428741,
1.2931677103042603,
-0.4457007050514221,
0.3260360360145569,
0.6506971716880798,
-0.26680096983909607,
0.3318060040473938,
1.0903396606445312,
-0.008063077926635742,
0.8717504143714905,
0.08398906886577606,
-0.45237478613853455,
-0.453765332698822,
-0.43428394198417664,
-0.48669561743736267,
0.21855179965496063,
0.39614734053611755,
-0.42300400137901306,
-0.24383102357387543,
0.010261128656566143,
-0.11960312724113464,
0.08957558870315552,
-0.13270021975040436,
0.8546366095542908,
0.21228547394275665,
-0.995231032371521,
0.49217239022254944,
-0.08419343829154968,
-0.02613816224038601,
-0.39888453483581543,
0.03129640966653824,
-0.2553200423717499,
-0.02645527757704258,
0.12016420066356659,
-0.3609429895877838,
0.1638021618127823,
-0.11434349417686462,
0.011415058746933937,
-0.06876284629106522,
0.8519243597984314,
-0.3391591012477875,
-0.4358803331851959,
0.12707550823688507,
0.39159953594207764,
0.08011686056852341,
0.1395958960056305,
-0.7762749791145325,
0.3446383774280548,
0.2601749897003174,
-0.32939913868904114,
0.20032073557376862,
0.4705978035926819,
-0.18744952976703644,
0.5555199384689331,
0.4862581491470337,
0.13596738874912262,
-0.051040686666965485,
0.27868416905403137,
1.0029853582382202,
-0.5438714623451233,
-0.30676957964897156,
-0.5562911033630371,
0.28636398911476135,
-0.05950603634119034,
-0.332051157951355,
0.3787533938884735,
0.6340431571006775,
0.14993242919445038,
-0.14074406027793884,
0.7375105023384094,
0.08339976519346237,
0.6776930689811707,
-0.8263853192329407,
-0.02387889288365841,
-0.6691663861274719,
0.3842617869377136,
0.10382333397865295,
-0.7546039819717407,
0.060627326369285583,
0.08285566419363022,
-0.20514985918998718,
-0.18579740822315216,
1.0436519384384155,
1.115456223487854,
0.3085576295852661,
0.28380918502807617,
0.057750262320041656,
-0.13176538050174713,
0.41705599427223206,
0.6876635551452637,
0.8821755051612854,
-0.33386239409446716,
0.4393188953399658,
-0.3149392306804657,
-0.13210910558700562,
-0.410781592130661,
-0.7904108762741089,
-1.0267232656478882,
-0.6269944310188293,
-0.3495207726955414,
-0.5652819871902466,
0.190825417637825,
1.3843379020690918,
0.3371090590953827,
-1.09919011592865,
0.07225940376520157,
-0.25972089171409607,
-0.1759759485721588,
0.26010000705718994,
-0.15237504243850708,
0.35161909461021423,
-0.8259825110435486,
-0.6708979606628418,
0.5922896265983582,
0.2230156511068344,
0.282339870929718,
-0.027097230777144432,
-0.25778934359550476,
-0.11271396279335022,
0.34018614888191223,
0.5379557609558105,
0.014235802926123142,
-0.5846620202064514,
-0.5793903470039368,
0.2246139496564865,
-0.34101271629333496,
-0.05495138093829155,
1.182510495185852,
-0.5691335201263428,
0.26649975776672363,
0.6534356474876404,
0.6557145714759827,
0.5060359239578247,
0.3700930178165436,
0.9720361232757568,
-0.5000021457672119,
0.25010251998901367,
0.4809168875217438,
0.2969394028186798,
-0.04876606538891792,
-0.5631452202796936,
0.840833842754364,
0.23643729090690613,
-1.0121701955795288,
-1.1206248998641968,
0.20345459878444672,
-1.354816198348999,
-0.3240148425102234,
1.2908358573913574,
-0.009479331783950329,
-0.3366173803806305,
-0.15719838440418243,
-0.636880099773407,
0.04774800315499306,
-0.3458302319049835,
0.36639153957366943,
0.4778245985507965,
-0.5074952244758606,
-0.45171624422073364,
-0.6755931377410889,
0.8199717998504639,
0.8218005299568176,
-0.9160995483398438,
-0.3814235329627991,
0.5610892176628113,
0.1551448106765747,
-0.24782657623291016,
0.6735587120056152,
-0.07152967900037766,
0.6217167973518372,
-0.02653675712645054,
-0.2650514841079712,
0.02596621960401535,
-0.24535015225410461,
-0.20250298082828522,
-0.009291522204875946,
0.17296606302261353,
-0.18544858694076538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01930v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01930v1
|
OARelatedWork: A Large-Scale Dataset of Related Work Sections with Full-texts from Open Access Sources
| 2024-05-03T08:49:22 | 2024-05-03T08:49:22 |
Martin Docekal, Martin Fajcik, Pavel Smrz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces OARelatedWork, the first large-scale multi-document
summarization dataset for related work generation containing whole related work
sections and full-texts of cited papers. The dataset includes 94 450 papers and
5 824 689 unique referenced papers. It was designed for the task of
automatically generating related work to shift the field toward generating
entire related work sections from all available content instead of generating
parts of related work sections from abstracts only, which is the current
mainstream in this field for abstractive approaches. We show that the estimated
upper bound for extractive summarization increases by 217% in the ROUGE-2
score, when using full content instead of abstracts. Furthermore, we show the
benefits of full content data on naive, oracle, traditional, and
transformer-based baselines. Long outputs, such as related work sections, pose
challenges for automatic evaluation metrics like BERTScore due to their limited
input length. We tackle this issue by proposing and evaluating a meta-metric
using BERTScore. Despite operating on smaller blocks, we show this meta-metric
correlates with human judgment, comparably to the original BERTScore.
|
[
-0.27310264110565186,
-0.13813439011573792,
0.658814549446106,
0.19115950167179108,
-0.2539256513118744,
-0.2605687379837036,
-0.2400541603565216,
-0.7359182834625244,
0.5223748683929443,
0.5346059203147888,
-0.3935638666152954,
-0.5396547317504883,
-0.6870297193527222,
0.20883364975452423,
-0.48486849665641785,
1.163191556930542,
-0.04307648539543152,
-0.38404688239097595,
-0.3094782531261444,
-0.303866982460022,
-0.27217742800712585,
-0.09322424232959747,
-0.29310163855552673,
-0.35634827613830566,
0.9291681051254272,
0.5171224474906921,
0.3596971929073334,
0.6527170538902283,
0.742952287197113,
0.23457153141498566,
0.21920229494571686,
0.2798357307910919,
-0.6428458094596863,
0.2234572172164917,
-0.4017501175403595,
-0.35425645112991333,
-0.7964667677879333,
-0.07069235295057297,
0.44882652163505554,
0.5423771739006042,
0.09513313323259354,
0.5813573002815247,
0.15798838436603546,
0.7792657613754272,
-0.9254010915756226,
0.5046955943107605,
-0.16130892932415009,
-0.07715971022844315,
-0.4890958070755005,
0.08051683753728867,
-0.26254138350486755,
-0.39353838562965393,
-0.2664192318916321,
-0.5608401298522949,
0.09459096938371658,
-0.2361157387495041,
0.5986997485160828,
0.09137539565563202,
-0.4033707082271576,
-0.4155365526676178,
-0.6347120404243469,
0.7202537059783936,
-0.4363250136375427,
0.02216203138232231,
0.3167121112346649,
0.329397052526474,
0.25908878445625305,
-0.7991730570793152,
-0.31898051500320435,
0.20896662771701813,
-0.22960476577281952,
0.5644546151161194,
-0.1235644593834877,
-0.061924658715724945,
0.015162323601543903,
0.5966853499412537,
-0.45678719878196716,
-0.1321428120136261,
-0.7446380853652954,
0.08314760774374008,
0.7845761179924011,
0.26311439275741577,
-0.029524490237236023,
-0.20392188429832458,
0.05283496901392937,
-0.09289870411157608,
-0.626627504825592,
-0.37976953387260437,
0.39525237679481506,
0.09546147286891937,
0.12498592585325241,
0.8963922262191772,
-0.3079194128513336,
0.5954410433769226,
-0.10580141097307205,
-0.06389443576335907,
0.4127381443977356,
-0.4558066725730896,
-0.09227211773395538,
0.04361295700073242,
0.9113683104515076,
0.3902522623538971,
0.1960727423429489,
-0.09595029801130295,
0.050539128482341766,
-0.4813159108161926,
0.3309197425842285,
-0.7844831347465515,
-0.02774001471698284,
0.2790183126926422,
-0.6117369532585144,
-0.19981424510478973,
0.5393656492233276,
-0.552139937877655,
-0.3828693926334381,
-0.35268986225128174,
0.17710883915424347,
-0.4796103239059448,
-0.28711503744125366,
-0.06041814014315605,
-0.29235997796058655,
-0.17421460151672363,
0.46899592876434326,
-0.4434140622615814,
0.0056881653144955635,
0.7153327465057373,
1.0481473207473755,
-0.29263779520988464,
-0.4786314368247986,
-0.7095038890838623,
0.27012714743614197,
-0.3044220805168152,
0.7684340476989746,
-0.20326679944992065,
-0.21552105247974396,
0.2538335621356964,
0.08833599090576172,
0.09425915032625198,
-0.5260741710662842,
0.49645301699638367,
-0.45011135935783386,
0.1515626758337021,
-0.09560446441173553,
-0.11406772583723068,
-0.0007352742250077426,
0.18786710500717163,
-1.0684759616851807,
0.9975149631500244,
0.2718892991542816,
-0.7657507061958313,
0.5351685881614685,
-1.0138812065124512,
-0.5960502028465271,
-0.31909042596817017,
-0.05326827988028526,
-0.39383047819137573,
0.24409647285938263,
-0.09996022284030914,
0.41122183203697205,
-0.2829533517360687,
0.07028094679117203,
-0.012357710860669613,
-0.14915277063846588,
-0.009580890648066998,
0.15167120099067688,
0.7185633182525635,
0.26316705346107483,
-0.08576361835002899,
0.17110057175159454,
-0.6794162392616272,
-0.3141622245311737,
-0.008140956982970238,
-0.33012688159942627,
-0.6674641966819763,
-0.1039305031299591,
-0.07277452945709229,
0.12568290531635284,
0.3998526632785797,
-0.9673039317131042,
0.06637965887784958,
-0.08633710443973541,
0.0008972974610514939,
0.3998684287071228,
-0.07609807699918747,
0.3079400956630707,
-0.5083714723587036,
0.3436850905418396,
-0.05896570906043053,
-0.08837095648050308,
-0.5886631608009338,
-0.32432544231414795,
-0.3505682647228241,
-0.5052653551101685,
0.5294185876846313,
0.2060546576976776,
-0.6106898188591003,
0.6911253929138184,
-0.7609251737594604,
-0.657590389251709,
-0.4648074209690094,
0.07096949219703674,
0.3094388246536255,
0.48010554909706116,
0.5302188992500305,
-0.3341065049171448,
-0.3580140471458435,
-0.901587724685669,
-0.08540935814380646,
0.07210873812437057,
-0.4186744689941406,
-0.08735331147909164,
0.5863209366798401,
0.09297206252813339,
0.944727897644043,
-1.0455509424209595,
-0.8825029730796814,
-0.13881373405456543,
0.5677879452705383,
0.27195170521736145,
0.34341350197792053,
0.6499606370925903,
-0.4175165593624115,
-0.7000623345375061,
-0.004042166750878096,
-0.8245823383331299,
-0.06765017658472061,
0.03162046894431114,
-0.3310225009918213,
0.07663199305534363,
0.6337434649467468,
-0.6134347319602966,
0.3265262246131897,
0.37880757451057434,
-0.1661616563796997,
0.5601772665977478,
-0.1348663866519928,
0.18465858697891235,
-1.1742241382598877,
0.6555215120315552,
-0.19471964240074158,
-0.3186139464378357,
-0.06835048645734787,
0.1923195719718933,
0.04391130805015564,
-0.14619018137454987,
-0.2734749913215637,
0.42267468571662903,
-0.6434474587440491,
-0.1689608246088028,
-0.22453871369361877,
0.15940816700458527,
0.046209610998630524,
0.3533008098602295,
0.16240915656089783,
0.5550876259803772,
0.03716713935136795,
-0.3188452124595642,
0.3407343626022339,
0.41337743401527405,
-0.3348357379436493,
0.7176581621170044,
-0.5954350829124451,
0.064978688955307,
-0.36483898758888245,
0.5676129460334778,
-0.8385379910469055,
-0.5016113519668579,
-0.09862702339887619,
-0.4948089122772217,
0.16299213469028473,
0.03641849756240845,
-0.6581007838249207,
-0.31134480237960815,
-0.7320958971977234,
0.3232862949371338,
0.47137635946273804,
-0.5023108720779419,
0.4980158805847168,
0.22129729390144348,
-0.5457490086555481,
-0.49510279297828674,
-0.7667600512504578,
-0.029966525733470917,
0.17115245759487152,
-0.6652908325195312,
0.48436594009399414,
0.19665051996707916,
-0.3588543236255646,
0.4350341558456421,
-0.012586783617734909,
-0.16532719135284424,
-0.5213985443115234,
0.35771751403808594,
0.14713405072689056,
-0.13288253545761108,
0.20441894233226776,
0.1334303617477417,
-0.03679737448692322,
0.07173793762922287,
-0.12085600942373276,
0.3069598078727722,
0.36042118072509766,
-0.4303056597709656,
0.17113074660301208,
0.6088547110557556,
0.5992389917373657,
-0.26775211095809937,
0.774738073348999,
0.6990376114845276,
-0.21639089286327362,
0.1513272076845169,
-0.3346848785877228,
0.12933239340782166,
-0.2950142025947571,
0.49083584547042847,
-0.0632656067609787,
-0.6064163446426392,
0.4293108284473419,
0.14321433007717133,
0.8624749183654785,
1.016198992729187,
0.47273123264312744,
0.00806050281971693,
0.5025458931922913,
0.3308350741863251,
-0.1602102667093277,
0.4508870840072632,
-0.39282000064849854,
-0.04453907161951065,
-0.8197769522666931,
-0.2639368772506714,
-0.7611935138702393,
-0.3410941958427429,
-0.12937484681606293,
-0.5986365675926208,
0.46634185314178467,
-0.28340694308280945,
0.061526454985141754,
0.47008034586906433,
-0.42268499732017517,
0.4139637053012848,
0.5379735231399536,
0.22430667281150818,
0.7321696281433105,
-0.12736143171787262,
0.3203772008419037,
0.13202951848506927,
-0.24156445264816284,
-0.1939234584569931,
1.4385570287704468,
0.02501937933266163,
0.5315571427345276,
0.22263403236865997,
0.9278439879417419,
0.4923209249973297,
0.6910415291786194,
-0.7923799157142639,
0.1468953639268875,
-0.30803611874580383,
-0.8240326046943665,
-0.70182204246521,
-0.4095119833946228,
-1.261243462562561,
0.18123973906040192,
-0.20608900487422943,
-0.4859079420566559,
-0.03376717120409012,
0.047292016446590424,
-0.22903220355510712,
0.14963531494140625,
-0.37837663292884827,
0.3605169355869293,
0.05816780775785446,
-0.5796342492103577,
-0.4764638841152191,
-0.5539292693138123,
0.5368552207946777,
-0.34101414680480957,
0.40145212411880493,
0.18089427053928375,
-0.0029981103725731373,
0.9770257472991943,
-0.5836120247840881,
0.587459921836853,
-0.21154636144638062,
-0.19636934995651245,
0.5568115711212158,
-0.20718492567539215,
0.32339534163475037,
-0.06468614190816879,
-0.3304912745952606,
0.2718202471733093,
-0.11800839006900787,
-0.5242998600006104,
-0.29695791006088257,
0.6243281960487366,
-0.4920732080936432,
-0.1591004878282547,
-0.5897018313407898,
-0.555900514125824,
-0.15381041169166565,
0.575389564037323,
0.3619139492511749,
0.4860944449901581,
-0.41588354110717773,
0.6092170476913452,
0.44659096002578735,
-0.04786806181073189,
0.41012176871299744,
0.35363441705703735,
-0.0951642096042633,
-0.5580678582191467,
0.8609529137611389,
0.3558082580566406,
0.04766496643424034,
0.5814417600631714,
-0.16301025450229645,
-0.23976421356201172,
-0.22297582030296326,
-0.43387195467948914,
0.34775370359420776,
-0.31777700781822205,
-0.5346267819404602,
-0.4849288761615753,
-0.21449702978134155,
-0.3239593505859375,
-0.0871075913310051,
-0.22737008333206177,
-0.4694952964782715,
-0.13079632818698883,
-0.24963977932929993,
0.12967801094055176,
0.9898412823677063,
-0.3997582495212555,
-0.04104189574718475,
-1.0746290683746338,
0.4760027527809143,
0.338136225938797,
0.5555721521377563,
0.2100839763879776,
-0.11404820531606674,
-0.754843533039093,
-0.08865398913621902,
-0.4555865526199341,
-0.6387258768081665,
0.06889397650957108,
0.18982039391994476,
0.3920782506465912,
0.4516015648841858,
0.14757423102855682,
0.3356512784957886,
-0.37702885270118713,
0.7899700999259949,
0.5003750920295715,
-0.5222670435905457,
0.17894364893436432,
-0.5466735363006592,
0.6318197250366211,
0.9138185977935791,
0.4977312982082367,
-0.1880052238702774,
-0.24376536905765533,
-0.5996689796447754,
-1.042477011680603,
0.7349550724029541,
0.41706815361976624,
-0.05622308701276779,
0.018601907417178154,
-0.09283851087093353,
0.5177053213119507,
0.26947009563446045,
-0.43954572081565857,
-0.000935810967348516,
-0.06420885771512985,
-0.4215843379497528,
-0.11249367147684097,
-0.00931063573807478,
-0.2627406418323517,
0.0871448963880539,
0.4378630816936493,
-0.21924185752868652,
0.3778815269470215,
0.3946499526500702,
-0.2861562669277191,
-0.10870109498500824,
0.17984405159950256,
0.5333007574081421,
0.9775819182395935,
-0.45197346806526184,
0.045402783900499344,
-0.17030827701091766,
-0.6956387162208557,
-0.1492030918598175,
0.12877348065376282,
0.08023739606142044,
0.27873656153678894,
0.8610320687294006,
0.3449867367744446,
-0.12145429104566574,
-0.7159202694892883,
0.7020837664604187,
0.11219778656959534,
-0.6413170695304871,
-0.5593274831771851,
-0.05056729167699814,
0.07355094701051712,
-0.09388813376426697,
0.6434812545776367,
0.06662232428789139,
0.17222361266613007,
-0.7970989942550659,
0.09123146533966064,
0.15111546218395233,
-0.6559461951255798,
-0.3873824179172516,
0.5619368553161621,
0.27755600214004517,
0.15219317376613617,
0.41114675998687744,
0.08566480129957199,
0.051701534539461136,
0.6701542139053345,
0.09905388206243515,
0.8791511058807373,
0.09913099557161331,
0.016528205946087837,
0.618263304233551,
0.1917387992143631,
-0.04143426939845085,
0.20157833397388458,
-0.1458042860031128,
-0.24055911600589752,
-0.70598304271698,
-0.5313432812690735,
-0.23292230069637299,
0.2903003394603729,
-0.8982258439064026,
0.20923222601413727,
-0.02543303556740284,
-0.05788237228989601,
-0.014112497679889202,
-0.36425742506980896,
-0.5173510909080505,
0.19031156599521637,
-0.27749213576316833,
1.0117995738983154,
-0.8294423222541809,
0.4435511529445648,
0.8583177924156189,
-0.5877407193183899,
-0.2940669655799866,
0.15621116757392883,
-0.22567692399024963,
-0.5290846824645996,
0.38580164313316345,
0.06048741564154625,
0.03343430906534195,
-0.32745155692100525,
-0.21979880332946777,
-0.720956027507782,
1.310782551765442,
0.24083860218524933,
-0.3725476562976837,
-0.3310644030570984,
0.07550998777151108,
0.5295418500900269,
-0.26432058215141296,
0.3423784077167511,
0.45525670051574707,
0.6946011185646057,
0.029364414513111115,
-0.9759358763694763,
0.029113592579960823,
-0.34334370493888855,
-0.6214276552200317,
0.6346964836120605,
-0.8373134732246399,
0.8026372194290161,
0.06621652096509933,
0.12010230123996735,
-0.015194441191852093,
0.5313717126846313,
0.09348222613334656,
0.34755462408065796,
0.4990215599536896,
0.4632788300514221,
0.38149380683898926,
-0.013078656978905201,
0.790581464767456,
-0.2608044445514679,
0.13840802013874054,
1.380095362663269,
-0.19061684608459473,
0.7313277721405029,
0.4162103235721588,
-0.05672241002321243,
0.6058003902435303,
0.15009377896785736,
0.19152987003326416,
0.41233184933662415,
0.07881759107112885,
-0.06422785669565201,
0.10706990957260132,
-0.2636764347553253,
-0.5641236305236816,
0.4268586337566376,
0.11865798383951187,
-0.7244722843170166,
-0.4765371084213257,
-0.19016018509864807,
0.2202044278383255,
0.17273178696632385,
-0.3425051271915436,
0.9891093373298645,
0.13396166265010834,
-0.9391588568687439,
0.08083302527666092,
-0.029635032638907433,
0.45086121559143066,
-0.7358797788619995,
-0.12771059572696686,
-0.150191992521286,
0.02681320533156395,
-0.6471672058105469,
-0.9521621465682983,
0.7380592226982117,
0.08313021808862686,
-0.22568151354789734,
-0.2146424502134323,
0.6896814703941345,
-0.34231260418891907,
-0.3822351396083832,
0.1729525774717331,
0.5999302268028259,
0.029092147946357727,
-0.310336709022522,
0.2143675833940506,
-0.3311671316623688,
-0.192788764834404,
-0.2128985971212387,
0.6005861163139343,
0.6029861569404602,
-0.03199019283056259,
-0.03729058802127838,
0.4665679335594177,
0.21090242266654968,
-0.30490395426750183,
-0.2662091553211212,
0.8775119185447693,
-0.5566856861114502,
-0.596943736076355,
-0.48758167028427124,
0.7636047005653381,
-0.5528467297554016,
-0.4320043623447418,
0.5003162622451782,
0.9969759583473206,
0.5612657070159912,
-0.41976791620254517,
1.1068400144577026,
-0.5563780069351196,
0.6598543524742126,
-0.33320847153663635,
0.5771326422691345,
-0.7975707650184631,
-0.39367079734802246,
-0.3975362181663513,
-1.0952966213226318,
-0.11950262635946274,
0.11512266844511032,
-0.3105318546295166,
-0.3716459572315216,
0.87465500831604,
0.15131661295890808,
-0.39893487095832825,
-0.14607565104961395,
0.15379288792610168,
-0.2376696616411209,
0.018215205520391464,
0.2923332750797272,
0.2726347744464874,
-0.23798474669456482,
0.9405908584594727,
-0.06172715872526169,
-0.5412554740905762,
-0.44502267241477966,
-0.8541389107704163,
-0.8389277458190918,
-0.7433079481124878,
-0.13550880551338196,
-0.29610949754714966,
-0.15717338025569916,
0.608771026134491,
0.5974589586257935,
-0.7510135769844055,
-0.2984001934528351,
0.1090300977230072,
-0.1286577433347702,
-0.3281739354133606,
-0.2504401206970215,
0.4492957592010498,
0.011979957111179829,
-0.6849663853645325,
0.12574224174022675,
0.28165745735168457,
-0.47787734866142273,
-0.2886136472225189,
0.06825555860996246,
-0.23820608854293823,
0.10699997842311859,
0.8899458646774292,
0.34994813799858093,
0.13842301070690155,
-0.02254153974354267,
-0.1354064643383026,
-0.022886572405695915,
0.04788219556212425,
0.9005663394927979,
-0.4034733474254608,
0.23578223586082458,
0.8827281594276428,
0.3864658772945404,
0.9151362776756287,
0.4416801333427429,
0.6348986625671387,
-0.7627094388008118,
0.017920171841979027,
0.207566037774086,
0.3021305501461029,
0.005401186179369688,
-0.2262730598449707,
0.8911323547363281,
0.015950016677379608,
-0.4026324152946472,
-0.5099313855171204,
0.21289724111557007,
-0.7201653122901917,
-0.16530801355838776,
0.733721911907196,
-0.28721359372138977,
-0.2929230332374573,
-0.16251853108406067,
-0.3710121512413025,
0.249690443277359,
-0.7309864163398743,
0.9320876002311707,
0.5231119990348816,
-0.3527332544326782,
0.325064480304718,
-0.16113916039466858,
0.20555731654167175,
0.05396616831421852,
-1.0483773946762085,
0.12070456892251968,
0.8389023542404175,
0.07724058628082275,
0.8190073370933533,
0.8626914024353027,
-0.3586867153644562,
0.3652481734752655,
0.06744434684515,
0.25267666578292847,
-0.48259514570236206,
-0.3977431654930115,
0.21048909425735474,
0.7301324605941772,
0.01330616045743227,
-0.22292079031467438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01924v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01924v1
|
Semi-Parametric Retrieval via Binary Token Index
| 2024-05-03T08:34:13 | 2024-05-03T08:34:13 |
Jiawei Zhou, Li Dong, Furu Wei, Lei Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
The landscape of information retrieval has broadened from search services to
a critical component in various advanced applications, where indexing
efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and freshness are increasingly important yet
remain less explored. To address these demands, we introduce Semi-parametric
Vocabulary Disentangled Retrieval (SVDR). SVDR is a novel semi-parametric
retrieval framework that supports two types of indexes: an embedding-based
index for high effectiveness, akin to existing neural retrieval methods; and a
binary token index that allows for quick and cost-effective setup, resembling
traditional term-based retrieval. In our evaluation on three open-domain
question answering benchmarks with the entire Wikipedia as the retrieval
corpus, SVDR consistently demonstrates superiority. It achieves a 3% higher
top-1 retrieval accuracy compared to the dense retriever DPR when using an
embedding-based index and an 9% higher top-1 accuracy compared to BM25 when
using a binary token index. Specifically, the adoption of a binary token index
reduces index preparation time from 30 GPU hours to just 2 CPU hours and
storage size from 31 GB to 2 GB, achieving a 90% reduction compared to an
embedding-based index.
|
[
-0.2208687663078308,
-0.6704239249229431,
0.34123101830482483,
0.15886421501636505,
-0.7472718358039856,
0.530709981918335,
0.0400383397936821,
-0.1212063878774643,
0.3254059851169586,
-0.05508645623922348,
-0.03768080100417137,
-0.6007022261619568,
-0.36188042163848877,
-0.012956048361957073,
-0.6282300353050232,
0.8297116160392761,
0.19165541231632233,
0.297281950712204,
-0.47663477063179016,
-0.17572537064552307,
0.05352203547954559,
-0.6533045172691345,
-0.3933921754360199,
0.14764538407325745,
0.5816748142242432,
0.04619608819484711,
0.6431654095649719,
0.6910111904144287,
0.7742931842803955,
0.26618170738220215,
-0.4051264524459839,
-0.09082183986902237,
-0.5302874445915222,
-0.0839158371090889,
-0.2517918050289154,
-0.38374248147010803,
0.18383778631687164,
-0.19758200645446777,
0.7590442895889282,
0.5664474368095398,
-0.512628972530365,
0.3749144971370697,
-0.10037822276353836,
0.8143570423126221,
-0.7771024107933044,
-0.05291157215833664,
-0.6007766127586365,
0.32543379068374634,
-0.5203194618225098,
-0.4258154034614563,
-0.027957893908023834,
-0.22757425904273987,
0.31369632482528687,
-0.45111414790153503,
0.49859750270843506,
0.13286834955215454,
0.7015009522438049,
0.3469945788383484,
-0.3459286689758301,
-0.03523891046643257,
-0.724500834941864,
0.6143194437026978,
-0.44987720251083374,
0.6827366352081299,
0.20330137014389038,
0.44168922305107117,
0.16393396258354187,
-1.0904302597045898,
-0.7639222145080566,
0.15134982764720917,
0.1366475224494934,
-0.09742125123739243,
-0.36973875761032104,
0.13370583951473236,
0.1389608085155487,
0.4129188358783722,
-0.5090829133987427,
-0.12062898278236389,
-0.571402907371521,
-0.46000760793685913,
0.17837804555892944,
0.4107986092567444,
0.07501576095819473,
-0.5431357026100159,
-0.662689208984375,
0.03385842591524124,
-0.4304792284965515,
0.0352812185883522,
0.326246440410614,
0.2383754551410675,
0.16171500086784363,
0.983141303062439,
-0.06316745281219482,
0.7310294508934021,
0.03692823648452759,
-0.019803330302238464,
0.2714821398258209,
-0.7755957841873169,
0.2424042522907257,
0.05838819965720177,
0.41881540417671204,
0.4460204243659973,
-0.5101937651634216,
-0.6534317135810852,
-0.49707862734794617,
0.008043965324759483,
0.31713682413101196,
-0.7084064483642578,
-0.12773825228214264,
0.08155987411737442,
-0.6966006755828857,
-0.21441110968589783,
0.22492758929729462,
-1.010689616203308,
-0.19609636068344116,
-0.15520337224006653,
0.6850062012672424,
-0.25301575660705566,
-0.21244454383850098,
0.057465314865112305,
-0.8779082298278809,
0.4114289879798889,
-0.11534126847982407,
-0.7535058259963989,
0.3498901128768921,
0.9704033732414246,
1.1885340213775635,
-0.6593934893608093,
-0.03643373027443886,
-0.6014602184295654,
0.08911587297916412,
-0.5173209309577942,
0.6224303841590881,
-0.8656781911849976,
-0.4681398272514343,
-0.03151557222008705,
-0.42546066641807556,
0.21927015483379364,
-0.6278612613677979,
0.2452942430973053,
-0.9425674080848694,
-0.27373242378234863,
-0.4787101745605469,
-0.35362204909324646,
0.3360346555709839,
0.14637255668640137,
-0.6606588959693909,
1.5727083683013916,
0.1034630537033081,
-1.0773632526397705,
0.3650059998035431,
-0.2250930517911911,
-0.21039727330207825,
0.4114808142185211,
-0.45377761125564575,
-0.020915765315294266,
0.2460956573486328,
-0.15480868518352509,
0.20325614511966705,
-0.5097676515579224,
0.12866675853729248,
-0.2623439431190491,
-0.6950341463088989,
-0.04926181584596634,
-0.41133686900138855,
0.2923685908317566,
0.16448266804218292,
-0.3763381540775299,
-0.3246023952960968,
-0.755605161190033,
-0.02640172466635704,
-0.0902651846408844,
-0.4757046401500702,
-0.9026370644569397,
0.008084329776465893,
0.11819477379322052,
0.19619929790496826,
0.7933578491210938,
-0.9821191430091858,
-0.27697882056236267,
-0.29702290892601013,
0.6446457505226135,
0.8577200174331665,
0.20009444653987885,
0.5033576488494873,
0.02072514407336712,
0.3055652976036072,
0.5929978489875793,
0.39265158772468567,
0.5363083481788635,
-0.279053270816803,
-0.5108852386474609,
-0.3649550974369049,
0.6982269883155823,
0.13044394552707672,
-1.1703184843063354,
0.22292158007621765,
-0.2936752140522003,
-0.7200081944465637,
-0.8420077562332153,
0.08822928369045258,
0.4383394420146942,
0.68138188123703,
0.3311602771282196,
-0.27638572454452515,
-0.4130276143550873,
-0.9665506482124329,
-0.05377604439854622,
-0.14830417931079865,
-0.09203416109085083,
0.4073941111564636,
0.5166219472885132,
0.03259161487221718,
1.0357599258422852,
-0.6107128858566284,
-0.057210441678762436,
0.06155163794755936,
0.24408157169818878,
0.19832514226436615,
0.12979286909103394,
0.39024150371551514,
-1.4572468996047974,
-0.6206068396568298,
-0.3895586431026459,
-0.40765073895454407,
0.6176855564117432,
0.3642420768737793,
-0.34238946437835693,
0.21556134521961212,
0.4211581349372864,
-0.6645920872688293,
0.5544306635856628,
0.05933767557144165,
-0.18236106634140015,
0.1922379732131958,
-0.805129885673523,
-0.07463901489973068,
-0.9585240483283997,
0.4658662974834442,
0.09170928597450256,
0.005754887592047453,
-0.3514855206012726,
-0.1837386190891266,
0.44054535031318665,
-0.31203240156173706,
-0.47010111808776855,
0.17706964910030365,
-0.44844159483909607,
-0.2895149290561676,
0.2769933044910431,
0.16524343192577362,
-0.21465004980564117,
0.373503178358078,
-0.31933411955833435,
1.3117809295654297,
0.4573393166065216,
-0.831418514251709,
0.15955480933189392,
0.3696531057357788,
-0.46674612164497375,
0.41977041959762573,
-0.889366626739502,
0.20985621213912964,
-0.6237713098526001,
0.020082682371139526,
-1.1160235404968262,
0.29964911937713623,
-0.12278256565332413,
-0.29337573051452637,
0.2710288166999817,
-0.1041894406080246,
-0.7640799283981323,
-0.3425237238407135,
-0.7687183022499084,
0.2742612659931183,
0.42392265796661377,
-0.6633221507072449,
0.4890211820602417,
0.7573495507240295,
-0.027728132903575897,
-1.1283742189407349,
-0.23351818323135376,
0.07934007048606873,
-0.050719041377305984,
-0.054471809417009354,
0.7881664633750916,
-0.14704057574272156,
0.12792599201202393,
0.30913105607032776,
-0.6841727495193481,
-0.02583376318216324,
-0.08153046667575836,
-0.1541115939617157,
0.47588539123535156,
0.09660299122333527,
0.11473187804222107,
0.2103556990623474,
-0.2537410855293274,
-0.16766521334648132,
-0.3002529740333557,
0.5302691459655762,
0.08185019344091415,
-0.3736366629600525,
-0.1243862435221672,
0.46784675121307373,
0.7269061803817749,
-0.5492227673530579,
0.7810074090957642,
0.38072624802589417,
-0.40001872181892395,
-0.03557860478758812,
-0.5179429650306702,
0.010761797428131104,
-0.4976859390735626,
0.37694746255874634,
-0.35054442286491394,
-0.7761228084564209,
0.45462632179260254,
0.008837927132844925,
-0.15873250365257263,
0.3464653193950653,
0.4459197223186493,
-0.27671241760253906,
1.2957032918930054,
0.6146611571311951,
-0.2105693221092224,
0.6091057658195496,
-0.35903507471084595,
0.4057926535606384,
-0.8362113237380981,
-0.7105331420898438,
-0.7073206901550293,
-0.46629589796066284,
-0.8061830997467041,
-0.6638048887252808,
0.6249300241470337,
-0.001959945075213909,
-0.11088244616985321,
0.2411811649799347,
-0.695918619632721,
0.28180915117263794,
0.685534656047821,
0.42962461709976196,
0.0035827853716909885,
0.02111200988292694,
-0.534241795539856,
-0.08793053030967712,
-0.504432201385498,
-0.09611040353775024,
1.3404381275177002,
0.0879095047712326,
0.8650181889533997,
0.20599839091300964,
0.6974642872810364,
0.45097509026527405,
-0.3903719484806061,
-0.25982704758644104,
0.7189019322395325,
-0.34534263610839844,
-0.8149396181106567,
-0.4058572053909302,
-0.42936208844184875,
-0.5995804667472839,
0.1373923420906067,
-0.17352502048015594,
-0.5914245843887329,
0.42114999890327454,
-0.14202691614627838,
-0.15116555988788605,
0.12743563950061798,
-0.5116602182388306,
0.623017430305481,
-0.20498374104499817,
-0.36017340421676636,
-0.3066980242729187,
-0.7956770658493042,
-0.38873767852783203,
-0.18743041157722473,
-0.38877996802330017,
0.008375056087970734,
-0.6949906945228577,
0.9590443968772888,
-0.27632936835289,
0.4327130615711212,
-0.6559520363807678,
0.551144540309906,
-0.09396249055862427,
-0.33852723240852356,
0.4855799973011017,
0.24256554245948792,
-0.21472308039665222,
0.387534499168396,
0.5454186201095581,
-0.4366432726383209,
-0.9131640791893005,
0.6586677432060242,
-0.7582449316978455,
-0.6369005441665649,
-0.520108699798584,
-0.1544729471206665,
-0.02558126673102379,
0.4016807973384857,
0.08629170805215836,
0.5130147933959961,
-0.09327341616153717,
0.5610300302505493,
0.9555229544639587,
-0.04180576279759407,
0.3128284513950348,
0.6583914160728455,
0.2665974199771881,
-0.48006385564804077,
1.1356563568115234,
0.39403069019317627,
-0.13730427622795105,
0.915837287902832,
0.1440098136663437,
-0.9711199998855591,
-0.7223177552223206,
-0.4009188115596771,
0.2917454242706299,
-0.6070839762687683,
-0.19537091255187988,
-0.6122390031814575,
-0.13428384065628052,
-0.21417339146137238,
0.44045934081077576,
-0.3570120930671692,
-0.5157480835914612,
-0.2716946601867676,
-0.13535892963409424,
0.24117963016033173,
0.3664138615131378,
-0.16652125120162964,
-0.5087010264396667,
-0.5222995281219482,
0.5214176774024963,
0.09880653768777847,
0.637999415397644,
0.19205060601234436,
-0.27720916271209717,
-0.15758025646209717,
-0.07972278445959091,
-0.011168235912919044,
-0.5695993900299072,
0.022686488926410675,
0.16864632070064545,
0.8841291069984436,
0.24905775487422943,
0.5723042488098145,
1.0637805461883545,
-0.7706480026245117,
0.7556235790252686,
0.13581570982933044,
-0.6659101247787476,
0.2133418172597885,
0.13731801509857178,
-0.2035103589296341,
0.7598330974578857,
0.7377179265022278,
-0.5000620484352112,
-0.1334497183561325,
-0.3077687621116638,
-1.0981255769729614,
0.6291813254356384,
0.10357999801635742,
0.5313423275947571,
-0.32209986448287964,
0.576510488986969,
0.03333945944905281,
0.5975016951560974,
0.11764928698539734,
-0.7376011610031128,
-0.16525238752365112,
-0.42911192774772644,
-0.4064173102378845,
-0.41806167364120483,
-0.21791289746761322,
-0.6331945657730103,
0.3813430666923523,
0.022868184372782707,
0.8945577144622803,
0.37945976853370667,
-0.10611200332641602,
0.17933984100818634,
-0.13128453493118286,
0.24259990453720093,
0.8080953359603882,
-0.41478756070137024,
0.3361513912677765,
0.035338323563337326,
-0.625930905342102,
0.09097151458263397,
0.484371542930603,
-0.09211469441652298,
0.4507554769515991,
-0.32501062750816345,
0.6019968390464783,
0.4534561038017273,
-0.6279174089431763,
0.8168768286705017,
-0.26047924160957336,
0.012719827704131603,
-0.23320908844470978,
-0.2874930500984192,
0.22174371778964996,
0.3658805191516876,
0.8493473529815674,
-0.12676966190338135,
0.431617796421051,
-0.229451522231102,
0.3413170278072357,
0.756256639957428,
-0.2778647243976593,
-0.1436411291360855,
0.7330958247184753,
0.0011546239256858826,
-0.4398302733898163,
0.7508833408355713,
0.03257910907268524,
-0.35105621814727783,
0.3065582513809204,
0.444097638130188,
0.6343834400177002,
0.2222582846879959,
0.3576229512691498,
0.05368920788168907,
-0.0004281498841010034,
0.028935972601175308,
0.5420800447463989,
-0.6749410033226013,
-0.23050028085708618,
0.2586463391780853,
-0.9186406135559082,
-0.4146261215209961,
-0.1510184407234192,
-0.9681072235107422,
0.22147539258003235,
-0.38769614696502686,
-0.1963062733411789,
0.4760531187057495,
0.09984466433525085,
-0.6572203040122986,
-0.2038099467754364,
-0.29810434579849243,
1.4135856628417969,
-0.48317697644233704,
0.46554550528526306,
0.8711060285568237,
-0.5613524317741394,
-0.44802117347717285,
0.1585720181465149,
-0.45502960681915283,
-0.5139150023460388,
0.5822299122810364,
-0.0825083777308464,
-0.013649561442434788,
0.33324259519577026,
-0.16088531911373138,
-0.9096778035163879,
1.3703984022140503,
0.27926746010780334,
-0.26644596457481384,
-0.5585290193557739,
0.26493728160858154,
0.7840476632118225,
0.3176811933517456,
0.2162913829088211,
0.4004073441028595,
0.028574753552675247,
0.08374715596437454,
-0.5534086227416992,
-0.022535210475325584,
-0.38802817463874817,
0.8063625693321228,
0.5286620855331421,
-0.6786537766456604,
0.5848218202590942,
0.20999792218208313,
-0.3557230532169342,
-0.04036298021674156,
0.6836628913879395,
-0.05076156184077263,
0.4266229271888733,
0.612456202507019,
0.4567340314388275,
0.7473554015159607,
0.15993916988372803,
0.7606853246688843,
-0.7787009477615356,
0.4625589847564697,
0.28321418166160583,
0.006986669264733791,
1.2675198316574097,
1.045433521270752,
-0.16159991919994354,
0.18944813311100006,
0.6840238571166992,
0.10084474831819534,
1.2811516523361206,
0.0335613489151001,
-0.5592121481895447,
-0.1845533400774002,
-0.005340763833373785,
-0.24543364346027374,
0.3706134259700775,
0.0643375962972641,
-0.08059066534042358,
-0.5125406980514526,
0.17790840566158295,
-0.49360454082489014,
-0.1538933664560318,
-0.1250619888305664,
0.8836377859115601,
-0.14421093463897705,
-0.5063861012458801,
0.48539331555366516,
0.13977190852165222,
0.7498263120651245,
-0.7941360473632812,
-0.1476409137248993,
-0.2765863239765167,
0.29247426986694336,
0.02720039151608944,
-0.6542695760726929,
0.15649349987506866,
0.13342046737670898,
-0.23722906410694122,
-0.01746327616274357,
0.5679692625999451,
-0.2959102392196655,
-0.3446298837661743,
0.24913161993026733,
0.3212665021419525,
0.220086470246315,
0.27374696731567383,
-0.9707584381103516,
-0.1750643104314804,
-0.2288879156112671,
-0.13400836288928986,
0.6553481221199036,
0.4321731626987457,
-0.07007519900798798,
0.5623035430908203,
0.7030329704284668,
-0.012589464895427227,
0.1988462507724762,
-0.25382640957832336,
1.3111708164215088,
-0.6408600211143494,
-0.6242791414260864,
-0.6284575462341309,
0.2593458592891693,
-0.15744410455226898,
-0.3046174943447113,
0.7290603518486023,
1.0757386684417725,
0.8965184688568115,
0.13204164803028107,
0.5559893846511841,
-0.3603432774543762,
0.6369642019271851,
-0.22337861359119415,
0.8099724054336548,
-0.762413501739502,
0.05588879436254501,
-0.419737845659256,
-0.7965006232261658,
0.07135111838579178,
0.28173866868019104,
-0.08179614692926407,
-0.1472049057483673,
0.5090658068656921,
1.1996856927871704,
-0.12659738957881927,
-0.33445483446121216,
0.3100384473800659,
-0.14148816466331482,
0.19705528020858765,
0.027251875028014183,
0.6461684703826904,
-0.22744840383529663,
0.8003646731376648,
-0.6178420782089233,
-0.2137080281972885,
-0.08715993165969849,
-0.5632638931274414,
-0.697304904460907,
-1.041078805923462,
0.027853921055793762,
-0.1999398022890091,
0.28182828426361084,
0.6411153674125671,
0.26889508962631226,
-0.4957313537597656,
0.24833497405052185,
0.012125828303396702,
0.0413828007876873,
-0.29051893949508667,
-0.17113181948661804,
0.5336622595787048,
-0.2775731682777405,
-0.7711799740791321,
0.17126119136810303,
0.5428617596626282,
-0.2282901108264923,
-0.43313270807266235,
-0.14077456295490265,
-0.36595556139945984,
0.05194654315710068,
0.19217079877853394,
0.1166948527097702,
-0.36505115032196045,
-0.34241142868995667,
0.4163515269756317,
-0.3647323548793793,
0.0018700899090617895,
0.6803343892097473,
-0.5863126516342163,
0.7332648038864136,
0.6628174185752869,
0.976553738117218,
0.8594079613685608,
0.20427024364471436,
0.2110716700553894,
-0.714378833770752,
0.02557278424501419,
0.3406863212585449,
-0.09143738448619843,
0.08195306360721588,
-0.4280543625354767,
0.13710840046405792,
0.4862299859523773,
-0.16736185550689697,
-1.249414086341858,
-0.3778398334980011,
-0.861081600189209,
0.06959056854248047,
0.8146343231201172,
0.023624038323760033,
-0.5224649310112,
-0.1589442640542984,
0.1000807136297226,
0.3579806387424469,
-0.2902108430862427,
0.8453062772750854,
0.4906947910785675,
0.12468572705984116,
0.1360526978969574,
-0.42196837067604065,
0.3529745042324066,
0.22436435520648956,
-0.1350458264350891,
-0.21973788738250732,
0.04625380411744118,
0.5973349809646606,
0.15545183420181274,
0.647771954536438,
-0.5039157867431641,
0.34027040004730225,
0.07200679928064346,
-0.20879293978214264,
-0.2363240271806717,
-0.4235844314098358,
-0.27739495038986206,
0.0732247531414032,
0.01630810648202896,
-0.7483254671096802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01886v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01886v1
|
Aloe: A Family of Fine-tuned Open Healthcare LLMs
| 2024-05-03T07:14:07 | 2024-05-03T07:14:07 |
Ashwin Kumar Gururajan, Enrique Lopez-Cuena, Jordi Bayarri-Planas, Adrian Tormos, Daniel Hinjos, Pablo Bernabeu-Perez, Anna Arias-Duart, Pablo Agustin Martin-Torres, Lucia Urcelay-Ganzabal, Marta Gonzalez-Mallo, Sergio Alvarez-Napagao, Eduard Ayguadé-Parra, Ulises Cortés Dario Garcia-Gasulla
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) in healthcare and
medicine continue to advance, there is a growing need for competitive
open-source models that can safeguard public interest. With the increasing
availability of highly competitive open base models, the impact of continued
pre-training is increasingly uncertain. In this work, we explore the role of
instruct tuning, model merging, alignment, red teaming and advanced inference
schemes, as means to improve current open models. To that end, we introduce the
Aloe family, a set of open medical LLMs highly competitive within its scale
range. Aloe models are trained on the current best base models (Mistral, LLaMA
3), using a new custom dataset which combines public data sources improved with
synthetic Chain of Thought (CoT). Aloe models undergo an alignment phase,
becoming one of the first few policy-aligned open healthcare LLM using Direct
Preference Optimization, setting a new standard for ethical performance in
healthcare LLMs. Model evaluation expands to include various bias and toxicity
datasets, a dedicated red teaming effort, and a much-needed risk assessment for
healthcare LLMs. Finally, to explore the limits of current LLMs in inference,
we study several advanced prompt engineering strategies to boost performance
across benchmarks, yielding state-of-the-art results for open healthcare 7B
LLMs, unprecedented at this scale.
|
[
-0.05214391276240349,
-0.5044189095497131,
0.5424082279205322,
-0.31056496500968933,
-0.026109207421541214,
-0.17374612390995026,
-0.10703407973051071,
-0.8070237040519714,
0.19228436052799225,
0.9755386114120483,
-0.4784955382347107,
-0.6868764758110046,
-0.37333622574806213,
0.017288243398070335,
0.11939220875501633,
0.9819597005844116,
-0.30218037962913513,
0.10266246646642685,
-0.05597630888223648,
-0.718397855758667,
-0.053890082985162735,
-0.2896628677845001,
-0.5249762535095215,
-0.2805529236793518,
0.5960027575492859,
0.7917839884757996,
1.0263479948043823,
1.055574893951416,
0.5349715948104858,
0.17767710983753204,
0.08690636605024338,
0.37933215498924255,
-0.49232640862464905,
0.3633936941623688,
-0.1542610377073288,
-0.5808970928192139,
-0.7763317227363586,
0.04043757542967796,
0.2300356775522232,
0.6350691914558411,
-0.4137144088745117,
0.3437480032444,
-0.22579289972782135,
0.9223875999450684,
-0.9088840484619141,
-0.20690526068210602,
-0.7133865356445312,
-0.05185544118285179,
-0.11322199553251266,
-0.16242989897727966,
-0.3449212908744812,
-0.5948251485824585,
-0.003754478180781007,
-0.7233409285545349,
0.005726807750761509,
0.3792971968650818,
0.8884129524230957,
0.4982111155986786,
-0.4224000871181488,
-0.4545873701572418,
-0.6289675831794739,
0.5874990820884705,
-0.7453595995903015,
0.44067829847335815,
0.2388896942138672,
0.23312042653560638,
-0.29666006565093994,
-0.6143225431442261,
-0.11999157816171646,
-0.43902161717414856,
0.09980075061321259,
0.18301312625408173,
-0.3513418436050415,
0.4991093873977661,
-0.2584618926048279,
0.5524081587791443,
-0.2507126033306122,
0.6616062521934509,
-0.1535196602344513,
0.25664424896240234,
0.44022393226623535,
-0.029268179088830948,
0.3040315806865692,
0.35499414801597595,
-0.3800644874572754,
0.15291902422904968,
-0.8757333755493164,
-0.19471308588981628,
0.000324367661960423,
0.06012217700481415,
-0.05004797503352165,
0.7114154696464539,
-0.31033870577812195,
0.5493184924125671,
-0.01932833530008793,
-0.23340420424938202,
0.08151521533727646,
0.07034549117088318,
-0.6032289862632751,
0.40884941816329956,
0.6285810470581055,
0.5544145703315735,
0.13043609261512756,
-0.08866582810878754,
-0.07062748819589615,
0.3573788106441498,
0.017976311966776848,
-0.6440621018409729,
-0.3271600306034088,
0.6172259449958801,
-0.5798543095588684,
-0.45927318930625916,
-0.026782728731632233,
-0.6410868167877197,
-0.35335344076156616,
-0.37811869382858276,
0.07358106225728989,
-0.25229158997535706,
-0.23542235791683197,
0.39871492981910706,
0.4061812162399292,
-0.08364000171422958,
0.33436331152915955,
-0.8450673818588257,
0.56441330909729,
0.6566755175590515,
0.6126101613044739,
-0.25301873683929443,
-0.08267569541931152,
-0.7112728357315063,
0.4064439833164215,
-0.5769105553627014,
0.49196767807006836,
-0.453279584646225,
-0.36597561836242676,
0.006184549070894718,
-0.02651044726371765,
0.02559836395084858,
-0.9138259887695312,
0.343049019575119,
-0.5509704351425171,
0.10920975357294083,
-0.10267063975334167,
-0.47145405411720276,
0.010955129750072956,
0.17337946593761444,
-0.8192816376686096,
0.6906220316886902,
0.20906105637550354,
-0.5870938897132874,
0.4363185167312622,
-0.9903031587600708,
-0.1455361545085907,
0.12490370124578476,
-0.2213837206363678,
-0.4943852424621582,
0.2998560070991516,
0.2699650228023529,
0.150888130068779,
-0.5354626774787903,
-0.0537550151348114,
-0.40963172912597656,
-0.016311079263687134,
0.0023088224697858095,
-0.10516729205846786,
0.7870174646377563,
0.25432777404785156,
-0.27145257592201233,
0.8443665504455566,
-0.80763179063797,
0.12283775955438614,
-0.12391801923513412,
-0.10328345745801926,
-0.42610466480255127,
-0.28792017698287964,
-0.3331701457500458,
-0.023198025301098824,
0.08143789321184158,
-0.2875233590602875,
0.30334389209747314,
-0.3347160816192627,
0.43863508105278015,
0.7505174279212952,
0.2519488036632538,
0.5005268454551697,
-0.3787142038345337,
0.8150597810745239,
-0.18270301818847656,
0.7182760834693909,
0.0814598873257637,
-0.4967803359031677,
-0.6923782229423523,
-0.5892708897590637,
0.17103789746761322,
0.6352078914642334,
-0.3673722445964813,
0.4048076570034027,
-0.002670555142685771,
-0.5763689279556274,
-1.134125828742981,
0.09343165159225464,
0.2775043845176697,
0.6327329277992249,
0.5414440631866455,
-0.11616960167884827,
-0.22259345650672913,
-1.1045267581939697,
-0.028781982138752937,
-0.14855919778347015,
0.15122154355049133,
0.5450127720832825,
0.27091553807258606,
-0.6131783127784729,
0.5950106382369995,
-0.39483150839805603,
-0.09880201518535614,
0.05982784926891327,
-0.34182119369506836,
0.1530897170305252,
0.33065611124038696,
0.3877450227737427,
-0.4789740741252899,
-0.2754320204257965,
0.5676242113113403,
-0.7297108173370361,
-0.05628609284758568,
0.2959422171115875,
-0.5893744826316833,
0.2100556194782257,
0.46491748094558716,
-0.6034215092658997,
0.33546727895736694,
0.731514036655426,
-0.31975552439689636,
0.43117162585258484,
-0.2649064064025879,
0.41085636615753174,
-0.8237022757530212,
0.06661205738782883,
-0.12838801741600037,
-0.14004799723625183,
-0.46624597907066345,
0.4921087324619293,
0.17801882326602936,
0.03964828699827194,
-0.6736841797828674,
0.6984560489654541,
-0.6454442143440247,
0.11278770118951797,
-0.2614413797855377,
-0.41404950618743896,
-0.13622631132602692,
0.13340851664543152,
-0.2143934667110443,
0.5099033117294312,
0.6035956144332886,
-0.7480815649032593,
0.38552939891815186,
0.1765250563621521,
-0.2547253370285034,
0.34124886989593506,
-0.601607084274292,
0.12483368813991547,
0.038649458438158035,
0.030385350808501244,
-0.3694762587547302,
-0.5306867957115173,
0.3722366988658905,
0.11058299988508224,
0.18081632256507874,
-0.03277682140469551,
-0.3135084807872772,
-0.36747175455093384,
-0.07925913482904434,
0.4387299716472626,
0.571110725402832,
-0.6460186839103699,
0.6756155490875244,
0.2371463030576706,
-0.03504778817296028,
-0.5808617472648621,
-0.23755255341529846,
-0.3024305999279022,
-0.39931201934814453,
-0.5426703095436096,
0.4233453869819641,
0.2306492030620575,
-0.7127121686935425,
0.25301462411880493,
-0.3268563747406006,
0.07504289597272873,
0.05993509292602539,
0.396625816822052,
0.4202791750431061,
-0.41975313425064087,
0.13388289511203766,
0.21458423137664795,
-0.013832644559442997,
-0.20516014099121094,
-0.4922756552696228,
0.266112744808197,
-0.2257705181837082,
-0.5218377113342285,
-0.44900691509246826,
0.3185375928878784,
0.8157692551612854,
-0.4452641010284424,
0.8162587881088257,
-0.03412410244345665,
-0.474104642868042,
0.05076303333044052,
-0.6663876175880432,
-0.07340867817401886,
-0.4388241469860077,
0.2537064254283905,
0.003017948241904378,
-0.8400236368179321,
0.36634936928749084,
-0.0897233709692955,
0.34067198634147644,
0.4844174087047577,
0.6060697436332703,
0.05538741126656532,
0.47813788056373596,
0.6843468546867371,
0.04013296961784363,
0.20775087177753448,
0.07510992884635925,
-0.3290749490261078,
-0.5335596799850464,
-0.3971271812915802,
-0.30420026183128357,
-0.23811237514019012,
-0.5384541153907776,
-0.39029160141944885,
0.6778522729873657,
0.23658311367034912,
-0.4475197196006775,
0.039017293602228165,
-0.48834657669067383,
0.5551130771636963,
0.7425956726074219,
0.5585947632789612,
0.5515625476837158,
-0.1186046302318573,
0.042549073696136475,
0.43871304392814636,
-0.6752181053161621,
-0.5750662088394165,
1.0903308391571045,
0.5770582556724548,
0.8940758109092712,
0.12387716770172119,
0.7824112772941589,
-0.025633854791522026,
0.7459469437599182,
-0.6206536293029785,
0.32661736011505127,
-0.19073887169361115,
-0.4152977466583252,
-0.20229989290237427,
-0.44999265670776367,
-1.261536955833435,
-0.06342000514268875,
-0.28463757038116455,
-0.5413175225257874,
0.1913066804409027,
0.6282914876937866,
-0.6650080680847168,
0.4170069694519043,
-0.602544367313385,
0.7587735652923584,
-0.5925360918045044,
-0.5176950097084045,
-0.20020712912082672,
-0.7101805210113525,
0.438141793012619,
0.24382297694683075,
0.10182547569274902,
-0.19647423923015594,
-0.47013434767723083,
0.4617873728275299,
-0.49289554357528687,
0.5436087250709534,
0.11742717027664185,
-0.2181992083787918,
0.32900553941726685,
0.05874964967370033,
0.30727264285087585,
0.02868514321744442,
-0.19753991067409515,
0.1598791480064392,
-0.2528723180294037,
-0.5395426154136658,
-0.4371286928653717,
0.9240272641181946,
-0.8280776739120483,
-0.5522191524505615,
-0.1707407832145691,
-0.4526166319847107,
-0.5219727158546448,
0.27622613310813904,
0.4460155665874481,
0.08118648827075958,
-0.269292414188385,
-0.05713396146893501,
0.7883591055870056,
-0.34781351685523987,
0.007048584055155516,
0.3952985405921936,
-0.2734562158584595,
-0.7783127427101135,
0.43517133593559265,
-0.1965969204902649,
0.6452181339263916,
0.2904875576496124,
0.2584571838378906,
-0.061272505670785904,
-0.4773855209350586,
-0.4967895746231079,
0.4086255729198456,
-0.6134712100028992,
-0.31459471583366394,
-0.4692847430706024,
-0.043266505002975464,
-0.3024321496486664,
-0.17891614139080048,
-0.3632693588733673,
-0.20566949248313904,
-0.4573237895965576,
-0.30286359786987305,
0.4669482111930847,
1.0916717052459717,
0.23979076743125916,
0.40556585788726807,
-0.8606339693069458,
0.3432740867137909,
0.06575662642717361,
0.5796842575073242,
-0.11421143263578415,
-0.009772023186087608,
-0.21687400341033936,
-0.20303833484649658,
-0.2861793339252472,
-1.1341822147369385,
0.22629940509796143,
-0.10148489475250244,
0.7543013095855713,
0.5785775780677795,
-0.15484605729579926,
0.3332687318325043,
-0.5473935008049011,
0.3190031349658966,
0.5462260246276855,
-0.5664008855819702,
0.6995511651039124,
-0.313426673412323,
0.023718200623989105,
0.815073549747467,
0.5443289875984192,
-0.14688068628311157,
0.07340283691883087,
-0.7377987504005432,
-0.8363343477249146,
0.17030547559261322,
0.017423661425709724,
-0.5590651631355286,
0.005946040619164705,
0.5745290517807007,
0.33863383531570435,
0.4319877624511719,
-0.47552159428596497,
-0.3039928078651428,
0.1661975234746933,
-0.5168923735618591,
0.12221090495586395,
-0.01554717868566513,
-0.4753969609737396,
0.007453495636582375,
0.7739710807800293,
-0.02331939898431301,
-0.20770318806171417,
0.12170061469078064,
0.15789374709129333,
-0.5359857082366943,
0.2507402002811432,
0.3277738392353058,
0.4480951726436615,
-0.046355899423360825,
-0.22548295557498932,
-0.0471017025411129,
-0.3735092878341675,
0.29789015650749207,
0.11616143584251404,
-0.009959743358194828,
-0.16253767907619476,
0.40429332852363586,
0.8800239562988281,
0.1444769948720932,
-0.7333288192749023,
0.00916591752320528,
0.32367926836013794,
-0.10668273270130157,
0.21111947298049927,
0.4166773855686188,
-0.0154507365077734,
0.0758635401725769,
-0.07741734385490417,
0.31263768672943115,
0.05796867609024048,
-0.7966132164001465,
0.17217634618282318,
0.45382124185562134,
-0.3995528519153595,
0.031705379486083984,
0.7457031607627869,
0.39704498648643494,
-0.27135103940963745,
0.5019919872283936,
0.2910573184490204,
-0.0679401382803917,
0.6527360081672668,
0.2409067302942276,
0.5999296307563782,
-0.6336240768432617,
-0.21566052734851837,
0.07902578264474869,
0.37479156255722046,
-0.2731228172779083,
0.20716072618961334,
0.32720187306404114,
-0.5224943161010742,
-0.2660645544528961,
-0.4250919222831726,
-0.6913890242576599,
0.13552948832511902,
-0.9008363485336304,
0.3954228162765503,
-0.41122332215309143,
-0.15170742571353912,
-0.3105141222476959,
-0.19548124074935913,
-0.7830396890640259,
0.17817968130111694,
0.037537794560194016,
1.0916216373443604,
-0.6497185826301575,
0.6443766951560974,
0.7265331149101257,
-0.05763232707977295,
-0.7085126638412476,
0.0016355646075680852,
-0.1307409256696701,
-1.011867642402649,
0.16576114296913147,
0.1976005584001541,
-0.11525952070951462,
-0.13383899629116058,
-0.3475032150745392,
-0.8320139050483704,
1.1685237884521484,
0.758065402507782,
-0.9832591414451599,
-0.5014064908027649,
-0.1609654575586319,
0.24930351972579956,
-0.48744234442710876,
0.11546669155359268,
0.6923090815544128,
0.24273256957530975,
-0.13124777376651764,
-1.082887053489685,
-0.03739134222269058,
0.00499312300235033,
-0.42839741706848145,
0.4373472034931183,
-0.6496084928512573,
0.7469847798347473,
-0.6378893256187439,
0.07445132732391357,
0.32300865650177,
0.5958633422851562,
0.6914840936660767,
0.5507723093032837,
0.448868989944458,
0.6013456583023071,
1.247606635093689,
0.0810556635260582,
1.1111657619476318,
-0.4140477180480957,
-0.09862406551837921,
1.2919557094573975,
-0.5539634823799133,
0.7409102916717529,
0.3792453110218048,
-0.03292379528284073,
0.5472041964530945,
0.7153612971305847,
0.2869362533092499,
0.4058840870857239,
0.2589135766029358,
-0.5158894062042236,
-0.0915665477514267,
-0.21403326094150543,
-0.6625922918319702,
0.23546262085437775,
0.4762951731681824,
-0.5684674978256226,
0.17037098109722137,
0.07183519750833511,
-0.014921067282557487,
0.11616013944149017,
-0.8239412307739258,
0.7995617985725403,
0.05833355709910393,
-0.842768132686615,
0.22248215973377228,
-0.23608164489269257,
0.4144395589828491,
-0.7111771106719971,
-0.1407943218946457,
-0.008710949681699276,
0.16096173226833344,
-0.48009949922561646,
-0.403957724571228,
-0.20276838541030884,
-0.26734739542007446,
-0.018237462267279625,
0.11395415663719177,
0.6407684683799744,
-0.4360468089580536,
-0.48256126046180725,
0.362354040145874,
0.4761766195297241,
-0.07536879181861877,
0.13934814929962158,
-0.4661736786365509,
0.16672565042972565,
-0.03228573128581047,
-0.22573183476924896,
0.114705890417099,
0.5707940459251404,
-0.10200797766447067,
0.603096604347229,
0.5353034138679504,
0.4648202061653137,
-0.0018988647498190403,
0.04148449748754501,
0.7770013213157654,
-0.538651168346405,
-0.4978416860103607,
-0.9128322601318359,
0.26855310797691345,
0.1101454347372055,
-0.464371919631958,
0.3563653528690338,
0.4910707175731659,
0.5318953990936279,
-0.022952595725655556,
0.6903954744338989,
0.5931621193885803,
0.3932497203350067,
-0.8608382940292358,
0.5321171879768372,
-0.4065534770488739,
0.12339729070663452,
0.002514313906431198,
-0.6887964010238647,
-0.2208978235721588,
0.3559849262237549,
-0.11760807037353516,
0.08534494787454605,
0.43432560563087463,
0.505559504032135,
0.01906326599419117,
0.23491571843624115,
0.21023344993591309,
0.3052612543106079,
0.35443469882011414,
0.5830486416816711,
0.4588964283466339,
-0.05365438386797905,
0.2965548634529114,
-0.2810502350330353,
-0.7848057150840759,
-0.3351376950740814,
-0.8518946170806885,
-0.6097065806388855,
0.027025364339351654,
-0.4062909483909607,
-0.5898463726043701,
0.439836710691452,
1.3580341339111328,
0.7196649312973022,
-0.8722311854362488,
-0.14091622829437256,
-0.2942412197589874,
-0.19263510406017303,
-0.3186773359775543,
-0.11544422060251236,
0.3261701762676239,
0.046255987137556076,
-0.3921222686767578,
0.4591328799724579,
0.4798038601875305,
0.3082672953605652,
-0.12571872770786285,
-0.20704086124897003,
0.03974929451942444,
0.04139108955860138,
0.3791303336620331,
0.4890879690647125,
-0.855456531047821,
0.11123910546302795,
0.18163524568080902,
-0.1156352087855339,
0.2330189347267151,
0.8457277417182922,
-0.6564902663230896,
0.22319799661636353,
-0.23080630600452423,
0.6201659440994263,
0.04911395162343979,
0.13435183465480804,
0.652168869972229,
-0.04065634682774544,
-0.026473525911569595,
0.6197050213813782,
0.6647573709487915,
0.23264986276626587,
-0.6398537158966064,
0.7425199151039124,
-0.2316562384366989,
-0.7062162160873413,
-0.7867180109024048,
0.42188820242881775,
-1.0140951871871948,
-0.27802175283432007,
1.323683261871338,
0.14913368225097656,
-0.1921709030866623,
0.11187833547592163,
-0.25001463294029236,
0.32590964436531067,
-0.38683831691741943,
0.42928624153137207,
0.3890323042869568,
-0.6297252178192139,
0.09183365106582642,
-0.5399377346038818,
0.4521969258785248,
0.4063853323459625,
-1.2393006086349487,
0.07242361456155777,
0.44911158084869385,
0.16587577760219574,
0.05153878778219223,
0.6866060495376587,
-0.04296038672327995,
0.42199909687042236,
-0.3377569615840912,
0.16497834026813507,
-0.16650086641311646,
-0.6140449643135071,
-0.13285386562347412,
0.20978093147277832,
0.3207348883152008,
-0.3787728250026703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01884v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01884v2
|
Beyond Single-Event Extraction: Towards Efficient Document-Level Multi-Event Argument Extraction
| 2024-05-03T07:04:35 | 2024-06-16T13:26:37 |
Wanlong Liu, Li Zhou, Dingyi Zeng, Yichen Xiao, Shaohuan Cheng, Chen Zhang, Grandee Lee, Malu Zhang, Wenyu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent mainstream event argument extraction methods process each event in
isolation, resulting in inefficient inference and ignoring the correlations
among multiple events. To address these limitations, here we propose a
multiple-event argument extraction model DEEIA (Dependency-guided Encoding and
Event-specific Information Aggregation), capable of extracting arguments from
all events within a document simultaneouslyThe proposed DEEIA model employs a
multi-event prompt mechanism, comprising DE and EIA modules. The DE module is
designed to improve the correlation between prompts and their corresponding
event contexts, whereas the EIA module provides event-specific information to
improve contextual understanding. Extensive experiments show that our method
achieves new state-of-the-art performance on four public datasets (RAMS,
WikiEvents, MLEE, and ACE05), while significantly saving the inference time
compared to the baselines. Further analyses demonstrate the effectiveness of
the proposed modules.
|
[
-0.45856770873069763,
-0.8210961818695068,
0.7027813196182251,
-0.06274066120386124,
-0.3713890314102173,
-0.4878790080547333,
0.07141587138175964,
-0.24241463840007782,
0.20731176435947418,
0.03873416408896446,
-0.662309467792511,
-0.46311771869659424,
-0.5415073037147522,
0.32821398973464966,
-0.13715456426143646,
0.8871046900749207,
0.1485385149717331,
-0.11823918670415878,
-0.1484820544719696,
-0.14068767428398132,
-0.4446731507778168,
-0.386404424905777,
-0.8325311541557312,
0.17225328087806702,
0.92093425989151,
0.6123504042625427,
-0.056662023067474365,
0.47588345408439636,
0.1904716193675995,
0.24740834534168243,
-0.08870762586593628,
0.3160431981086731,
0.0037708294112235308,
0.20895643532276154,
-0.10300442576408386,
-0.28667083382606506,
-0.7243847846984863,
0.16661851108074188,
0.6962384581565857,
0.24158522486686707,
0.05302610620856285,
0.06404577940702438,
-0.16936185956001282,
0.30335187911987305,
-0.9080169200897217,
0.10392498970031738,
-0.508811354637146,
-0.2528514564037323,
-0.4398512542247772,
-0.23375344276428223,
-0.6137899160385132,
-0.14296843111515045,
0.047162096947431564,
-0.8066304922103882,
-0.04777265712618828,
-0.33548030257225037,
0.9751296639442444,
0.12078016996383667,
-0.35245418548583984,
-0.1894627958536148,
-0.3457687795162201,
0.8282009363174438,
-0.8755248188972473,
0.036083467304706573,
0.058330073952674866,
0.04488988593220711,
-0.0070931389927864075,
-0.8284488320350647,
-0.553458034992218,
0.24130773544311523,
0.01316966861486435,
0.29637330770492554,
-0.2540896236896515,
-0.05650092661380768,
0.4751266837120056,
-0.182413712143898,
-0.20004111528396606,
0.1970885545015335,
-0.15981833636760712,
0.13622350990772247,
0.5073795318603516,
0.12437304854393005,
0.29157721996307373,
-0.5532445311546326,
-0.3414098620414734,
-0.00895178597420454,
-0.4535839557647705,
0.04351959750056267,
0.4836066961288452,
0.217343270778656,
-0.28517431020736694,
0.04714386537671089,
-0.11863312125205994,
0.7272690534591675,
0.36511892080307007,
-0.2943856716156006,
0.014003557153046131,
-0.41066864132881165,
-0.1359996646642685,
-0.05815059319138527,
0.9053584933280945,
0.24420066177845,
-0.05457602068781853,
-0.04700195789337158,
0.3593483567237854,
-0.023319760337471962,
0.01743742637336254,
-0.9835827946662903,
-0.0246984101831913,
0.548900306224823,
-0.665877103805542,
-0.327394962310791,
0.23708760738372803,
-1.674643635749817,
-0.5950398445129395,
-0.2819688022136688,
0.07097496837377548,
-0.20824968814849854,
-0.4346429705619812,
-0.04236770048737526,
-0.7282078862190247,
0.1675485521554947,
0.5029910206794739,
-0.7903839349746704,
-0.0337495394051075,
0.5900463461875916,
0.6204264163970947,
-0.42088237404823303,
-0.17450055480003357,
-1.130042552947998,
0.34992554783821106,
-0.0753994807600975,
1.238917350769043,
-1.0527393817901611,
-0.08413520455360413,
0.010941514745354652,
-0.1352880299091339,
-0.18730314075946808,
-0.22549819946289062,
0.8726871609687805,
-0.5533135533332825,
0.4162943661212921,
-0.4277728199958801,
-0.4682723581790924,
-0.2432706505060196,
0.12044741213321686,
-0.9751792550086975,
0.7237318754196167,
-0.44117334485054016,
-0.7121715545654297,
0.8116080164909363,
-0.9127228856086731,
-0.3618250787258148,
-0.04468652978539467,
-0.4626736640930176,
-0.16396379470825195,
0.0575016587972641,
0.7230674028396606,
0.4302816390991211,
-0.4533175528049469,
0.3130187690258026,
-0.5251227617263794,
0.21738748252391815,
-0.13877277076244354,
-0.5480009317398071,
0.7618929147720337,
0.10138241946697235,
-0.2807515859603882,
0.22229355573654175,
-1.2438832521438599,
-0.3696891665458679,
-0.16119593381881714,
-0.35088154673576355,
-0.47533681988716125,
0.18862304091453552,
-0.16398727893829346,
0.3759543299674988,
0.21651171147823334,
-0.6941379904747009,
0.3394183814525604,
-0.25088566541671753,
0.11690632253885269,
0.698707640171051,
0.3247988522052765,
0.4135182797908783,
0.12434603273868561,
0.5785057544708252,
0.4664847254753113,
0.0930800661444664,
-0.5315910577774048,
-0.6620992422103882,
-0.21974070370197296,
-0.8678312301635742,
0.04393600672483444,
0.30735474824905396,
-0.4154393970966339,
0.20899704098701477,
-0.1181071475148201,
-0.12609747052192688,
-0.30033913254737854,
-0.1177147701382637,
-0.013201824389398098,
0.6433698534965515,
0.16626191139221191,
0.15151762962341309,
-0.6939235925674438,
-0.5312967300415039,
-0.17224866151809692,
-0.1397532820701599,
0.21577109396457672,
-0.04600859060883522,
0.2084154337644577,
0.05428143963217735,
1.0187602043151855,
-0.37939831614494324,
-0.018383754417300224,
-0.29597270488739014,
0.6119169592857361,
0.4137602150440216,
0.20398564636707306,
0.6242369413375854,
-0.7541469931602478,
-0.33753323554992676,
0.05996708571910858,
-0.961220920085907,
-0.3892643451690674,
-0.5365332961082458,
-0.2563892900943756,
0.08201321214437485,
0.26948612928390503,
-0.6496946215629578,
0.6009882688522339,
0.029524145647883415,
-0.27463534474372864,
0.4724730849266052,
0.04732755199074745,
0.3040628731250763,
-1.2883906364440918,
0.07094156742095947,
0.043039992451667786,
0.2642708420753479,
-0.7512615323066711,
-0.17307332158088684,
0.12075065821409225,
0.06746556609869003,
-0.33773767948150635,
0.7099088430404663,
-0.5836443305015564,
0.22124788165092468,
-0.27623841166496277,
0.5862183570861816,
0.6398318409919739,
0.4319978654384613,
0.06776940077543259,
0.3624226748943329,
0.8127398490905762,
-0.7503529787063599,
0.23187589645385742,
0.29933100938796997,
0.02215740457177162,
0.7874599695205688,
-0.28202709555625916,
0.16666105389595032,
-0.45369523763656616,
0.07471675425767899,
-1.0014209747314453,
-0.07684512436389923,
0.26447823643684387,
-0.16867102682590485,
0.30422765016555786,
-0.22513742744922638,
-0.17369462549686432,
0.09858797490596771,
-0.5509727001190186,
0.12516120076179504,
-0.17992959916591644,
-0.8014832735061646,
1.1747444868087769,
0.5174631476402283,
-0.14555639028549194,
-0.6917553544044495,
-0.32218796014785767,
0.1947762370109558,
-0.6778701543807983,
-0.5941624641418457,
0.20665422081947327,
0.02820480987429619,
-0.40637996792793274,
-0.11632522195577621,
-0.02012825198471546,
-0.3343071937561035,
0.108361154794693,
0.27024126052856445,
0.31472936272621155,
-0.31886279582977295,
0.20276901125907898,
0.18145813047885895,
-0.2768166661262512,
-0.004060809034854174,
-0.13678742945194244,
0.07640120387077332,
0.2523919939994812,
-0.3322221338748932,
-0.8486642241477966,
1.1434329748153687,
0.6566198468208313,
-0.4616732597351074,
0.7096201777458191,
0.6200290322303772,
-0.5016445517539978,
-0.09829864650964737,
-0.6205799579620361,
-0.1609417200088501,
-0.3903820812702179,
0.2151738852262497,
-0.7403295636177063,
-0.16431517899036407,
0.6519891023635864,
-0.336999773979187,
0.6612868905067444,
0.6049250960350037,
0.35721802711486816,
0.21276138722896576,
1.0616072416305542,
0.18759119510650635,
0.015440212562680244,
0.6446319818496704,
-0.12699143588542938,
0.10245922207832336,
-0.7259901762008667,
-0.10649443417787552,
-0.7712544798851013,
0.05570107698440552,
0.02708214893937111,
-0.10056006908416748,
0.16306333243846893,
0.33424195647239685,
0.11974690854549408,
0.14316552877426147,
-0.18675965070724487,
0.300773561000824,
0.4090344309806824,
-0.16601364314556122,
0.4371655583381653,
0.00574727775529027,
0.0528968870639801,
0.04130960628390312,
-0.8348361253738403,
-0.7866530418395996,
0.9166268110275269,
0.06969714909791946,
0.2906171679496765,
0.26527121663093567,
0.9593167304992676,
0.18429777026176453,
0.3240731954574585,
-0.5881473422050476,
0.34336918592453003,
-0.1868741512298584,
-0.7200508713722229,
-0.20286999642848969,
-0.12765006721019745,
-1.0318207740783691,
0.5461136102676392,
0.012262897565960884,
-1.1419289112091064,
0.7504082918167114,
-0.3431699573993683,
-0.6406701803207397,
0.553594708442688,
-0.8088172078132629,
1.0241326093673706,
0.16651739180088043,
-0.44217386841773987,
-0.25586825609207153,
-0.25815242528915405,
0.18899422883987427,
-0.09480045735836029,
0.43359532952308655,
-0.19232328236103058,
-0.01307253073900938,
0.9650135040283203,
0.057057250291109085,
0.7598668336868286,
-0.2719142436981201,
-0.30251258611679077,
0.5819489359855652,
-0.27823686599731445,
0.5404629111289978,
0.25540098547935486,
-0.5658848285675049,
0.03775510936975479,
0.269728422164917,
-0.18315866589546204,
-0.6150847673416138,
0.594413697719574,
-0.44015249609947205,
-0.5997100472450256,
-0.06510769575834274,
-0.3838804066181183,
0.005125913769006729,
0.13479387760162354,
-0.057225584983825684,
1.1935404539108276,
-0.18200187385082245,
-0.17556272447109222,
0.3152678310871124,
-0.11609791964292526,
1.0439908504486084,
0.5668919682502747,
0.4070969820022583,
-0.5286555290222168,
0.6681734323501587,
-0.012828478589653969,
-0.20165598392486572,
0.3425535261631012,
0.43490907549858093,
-0.3618008494377136,
-0.3067323565483093,
-0.7543091177940369,
0.06888462603092194,
-1.163191556930542,
-0.09029732644557953,
-1.2114182710647583,
0.5137251615524292,
-0.5467298030853271,
-0.02056773193180561,
-0.06393872201442719,
-0.4795543849468231,
-0.7345306277275085,
-0.36088672280311584,
0.16357073187828064,
0.7797978520393372,
-0.3560786843299866,
0.25816401839256287,
-1.0908849239349365,
0.6800811290740967,
0.2516971826553345,
-0.004807178862392902,
0.18369673192501068,
-0.22591806948184967,
-0.024838590994477272,
-0.5089899897575378,
-0.25765758752822876,
-1.5869319438934326,
0.17154672741889954,
0.2306196689605713,
0.9056190848350525,
0.9386507272720337,
0.17248812317848206,
0.7911090850830078,
-0.37557917833328247,
0.8836715221405029,
0.23384833335876465,
-0.6964959502220154,
0.6709767580032349,
-0.22449186444282532,
0.13824902474880219,
0.46851596236228943,
0.27762433886528015,
-0.14229774475097656,
-0.13185672461986542,
-0.5828951001167297,
-0.5974679589271545,
1.0683866739273071,
-0.2929704189300537,
-0.24938338994979858,
-0.44578230381011963,
0.365262895822525,
0.41913989186286926,
-0.18500342965126038,
-0.5628621578216553,
-0.07769949734210968,
0.18590570986270905,
-0.3714667856693268,
0.4735128879547119,
-0.5458220839500427,
-0.33609655499458313,
-0.07828076183795929,
0.42851531505584717,
-0.15873314440250397,
-0.05347861722111702,
0.21030378341674805,
-0.016095392405986786,
-0.005810064729303122,
0.5187269449234009,
0.3819628357887268,
0.867423415184021,
0.04560204967856407,
0.09309734404087067,
0.244835764169693,
-0.23146691918373108,
0.0030050761997699738,
0.3008083999156952,
-0.08308872580528259,
0.24542975425720215,
0.47639933228492737,
0.6524417400360107,
0.010296186432242393,
-0.2502627968788147,
0.3762804865837097,
-0.3209998607635498,
0.030495865270495415,
0.09008606523275375,
-0.3040314018726349,
-0.14918778836727142,
0.3806424140930176,
0.31393131613731384,
-0.235190287232399,
0.3024180829524994,
-0.4455130100250244,
0.4916703999042511,
0.23587578535079956,
-0.09454120695590973,
-0.3220890760421753,
0.6747580170631409,
0.47029635310173035,
0.05385297164320946,
0.05853234976530075,
-0.08100657165050507,
0.015753692016005516,
0.6681063175201416,
0.3625311553478241,
1.0173592567443848,
0.07639751583337784,
0.3866358697414398,
0.7161986231803894,
0.055438973009586334,
0.2600117325782776,
0.41387325525283813,
-0.19153696298599243,
-0.5042113065719604,
-0.5271229147911072,
-0.4749129116535187,
-0.25399506092071533,
0.11060013622045517,
-0.7240877747535706,
0.26901698112487793,
-0.09544838219881058,
-0.2569977045059204,
0.3788953721523285,
-0.09539898484945297,
-0.4544026553630829,
-0.20038026571273804,
0.4388914108276367,
0.7242165207862854,
-0.8743205666542053,
0.7111616134643555,
0.7003747224807739,
-0.6256131529808044,
-0.5005365014076233,
-0.01760733313858509,
0.05561937019228935,
0.1542949229478836,
0.5664733052253723,
0.3094518184661865,
-0.20038199424743652,
-0.18645592033863068,
-0.20050287246704102,
-0.7363888025283813,
0.697158694267273,
0.2996898889541626,
-0.4175706207752228,
0.028372714295983315,
-0.33533206582069397,
0.11982066929340363,
-0.5454369187355042,
0.562386155128479,
0.639807403087616,
0.8177520036697388,
-0.18231216073036194,
-0.3267660439014435,
0.14642482995986938,
-0.13032938539981842,
-0.4068150818347931,
-0.05315791815519333,
-0.346550315618515,
0.7050390839576721,
-0.1285790205001831,
-0.6035561561584473,
-0.17231959104537964,
0.8237067461013794,
0.2965782582759857,
0.5564298629760742,
0.3906445801258087,
0.44458088278770447,
1.092166543006897,
0.14277425408363342,
1.0013240575790405,
-0.24535001814365387,
-0.12269824743270874,
1.088247537612915,
-0.44735437631607056,
0.5309144854545593,
0.5033774971961975,
0.2873297333717346,
0.7285040616989136,
0.4035187065601349,
0.39350512623786926,
0.533160924911499,
-0.3642912209033966,
-0.37826162576675415,
-0.5164391994476318,
-0.05798867717385292,
-0.1539199948310852,
0.31598520278930664,
0.4397292137145996,
-0.012228851206600666,
-0.46509501338005066,
-0.067823626101017,
0.08461041003465652,
-0.13713228702545166,
-0.10149820894002914,
1.0025296211242676,
-0.08510791510343552,
-0.9272692203521729,
0.21294336020946503,
0.022528698667883873,
0.41147366166114807,
-0.45831939578056335,
-0.31183671951293945,
-0.16802971065044403,
0.08863570541143417,
-0.16097696125507355,
-0.3500072658061981,
0.20377899706363678,
0.33449894189834595,
-0.34115612506866455,
0.03145933523774147,
0.7597131729125977,
-0.19874636828899384,
-0.2576447129249573,
0.41724735498428345,
0.6728366017341614,
0.22990895807743073,
-0.06859733164310455,
-0.3986201286315918,
0.030842281877994537,
-0.287212997674942,
-0.46394607424736023,
0.14406795799732208,
0.859299898147583,
0.025050325319170952,
0.04779259115457535,
0.6121953129768372,
-0.02969900146126747,
0.28653860092163086,
0.4662948250770569,
0.8465462923049927,
-0.535675585269928,
-0.5369938015937805,
-1.0930405855178833,
0.7353124022483826,
-0.5777175426483154,
-0.46163085103034973,
0.5601631999015808,
0.21399706602096558,
-0.036152347922325134,
0.10475140064954758,
0.7579625844955444,
-0.14493428170681,
0.18428130447864532,
-0.35366198420524597,
0.17880988121032715,
-0.4801711440086365,
0.06017331779003143,
-0.3375605642795563,
-0.3999176323413849,
-0.19941739737987518,
0.20097853243350983,
-0.22639818489551544,
-0.345563143491745,
0.8541767001152039,
0.5768483281135559,
-0.011052589863538742,
0.3504659831523895,
0.24561499059200287,
-0.2639206349849701,
0.7096692323684692,
0.44760042428970337,
0.8115389943122864,
-0.3368571102619171,
0.4748170077800751,
0.07010619342327118,
-0.43632033467292786,
0.11154040694236755,
-1.118185043334961,
-0.881105363368988,
-0.5876820683479309,
-0.7165370583534241,
0.09178772568702698,
-0.11066222190856934,
0.5369968414306641,
0.795731246471405,
-0.890444278717041,
0.10606114566326141,
0.16181837022304535,
0.3582237660884857,
-0.41964656114578247,
-0.19066238403320312,
0.6069369912147522,
-0.7057507634162903,
-0.8295554518699646,
0.8453845977783203,
0.3517002761363983,
-0.6013734936714172,
0.16929472982883453,
0.2517063617706299,
-0.7088106274604797,
0.3574114441871643,
0.6057696342468262,
0.15764358639717102,
-0.5468358397483826,
-0.19240377843379974,
-0.48785969614982605,
0.07040740549564362,
0.3501977324485779,
0.597374677658081,
-0.5066173672676086,
0.4829116761684418,
0.7870032787322998,
0.619222104549408,
0.33278512954711914,
0.14314787089824677,
0.5810348391532898,
-0.7682806253433228,
0.31534749269485474,
-0.21193023025989532,
0.541296124458313,
0.07959605008363724,
-0.3498494029045105,
0.23270483314990997,
0.16991828382015228,
-0.1279391050338745,
-0.5964763760566711,
0.2632303535938263,
-1.0299440622329712,
-0.4127338230609894,
1.3698762655258179,
-0.3828822076320648,
-0.24549302458763123,
-0.30571699142456055,
-0.29217952489852905,
0.49523428082466125,
-0.5374301075935364,
0.6782958507537842,
0.7242383360862732,
-0.06760033220052719,
-0.29449015855789185,
-0.570186972618103,
0.30202633142471313,
0.2487853467464447,
-1.2013447284698486,
0.20081886649131775,
0.8140531182289124,
-0.11460503190755844,
0.42769655585289,
0.6724068522453308,
-0.2565637528896332,
0.2884402871131897,
0.23261652886867523,
0.044741470366716385,
-0.13075372576713562,
-0.7749033570289612,
-0.6924295425415039,
0.7700272798538208,
-0.39219823479652405,
-0.6358792781829834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01883v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01883v1
|
DALLMi: Domain Adaption for LLM-based Multi-label Classifier
| 2024-05-03T07:04:26 | 2024-05-03T07:04:26 |
Miruna Beţianu, Abele Mălan, Marco Aldinucci, Robert Birke, Lydia Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) increasingly serve as the backbone for
classifying text associated with distinct domains and simultaneously several
labels (classes). When encountering domain shifts, e.g., classifier of movie
reviews from IMDb to Rotten Tomatoes, adapting such an LLM-based multi-label
classifier is challenging due to incomplete label sets at the target domain and
daunting training overhead. The existing domain adaptation methods address
either image multi-label classifiers or text binary classifiers. In this paper,
we design DALLMi, Domain Adaptation Large Language Model interpolator, a
first-of-its-kind semi-supervised domain adaptation method for text data models
based on LLMs, specifically BERT. The core of DALLMi is the novel variation
loss and MixUp regularization, which jointly leverage the limited positively
labeled and large quantity of unlabeled text and, importantly, their
interpolation from the BERT word embeddings. DALLMi also introduces a
label-balanced sampling strategy to overcome the imbalance between labeled and
unlabeled data. We evaluate DALLMi against the partial-supervised and
unsupervised approach on three datasets under different scenarios of label
availability for the target domain. Our results show that DALLMi achieves
higher mAP than unsupervised and partially-supervised approaches by 19.9% and
52.2%, respectively.
|
[
-0.39968162775039673,
-0.5424990653991699,
0.2003047913312912,
0.636311948299408,
-0.2618817687034607,
0.5037650465965271,
-0.2931073307991028,
-0.3338058292865753,
-0.22715285420417786,
0.30619463324546814,
-0.5177230834960938,
-0.5633153319358826,
-0.7182279825210571,
0.008423893712460995,
-0.14270704984664917,
1.2238619327545166,
-0.11532914638519287,
-0.02284996397793293,
-0.2519184350967407,
-0.18415383994579315,
-0.44622576236724854,
-0.8062845468521118,
-0.5492845177650452,
-0.39483240246772766,
0.5161269307136536,
0.16392308473587036,
0.34615036845207214,
-0.15591783821582794,
0.38734906911849976,
0.18944406509399414,
0.09893343597650528,
0.4674655795097351,
-0.5915230512619019,
0.03380265831947327,
-0.20270630717277527,
-0.26147329807281494,
-0.44980379939079285,
-0.09162921458482742,
0.7449596524238586,
0.5093185901641846,
0.042604394257068634,
-0.06966841220855713,
0.17522011697292328,
0.6456247568130493,
-0.6973031163215637,
0.13211701810359955,
-0.8291592001914978,
-0.0741143748164177,
-0.07181672751903534,
-0.2829223871231079,
-0.747342050075531,
-0.22401782870292664,
0.04319695383310318,
-0.5685780644416809,
0.04891045764088631,
0.16822251677513123,
0.6184303760528564,
0.25669625401496887,
-0.5209956169128418,
-0.28687748312950134,
-0.7838468551635742,
1.0250093936920166,
-0.8705751299858093,
0.24692991375923157,
0.1699652224779129,
0.2044050246477127,
-0.26485538482666016,
-0.41438448429107666,
-0.6620111465454102,
0.14595255255699158,
0.1174444630742073,
0.23862160742282867,
-0.10743573307991028,
-0.17489980161190033,
-0.09276945888996124,
0.19485951960086823,
-0.39524364471435547,
0.34320494532585144,
0.021171612665057182,
-0.08622637391090393,
0.5890341401100159,
-0.047758929431438446,
0.06185714155435562,
0.4671308696269989,
-0.6661232709884644,
-0.16663680970668793,
-0.43139341473579407,
-0.20838704705238342,
0.21617235243320465,
0.35357174277305603,
-0.1748811900615692,
0.30965545773506165,
0.09658035635948181,
0.9326143264770508,
0.01735999621450901,
-0.277454137802124,
0.3387949764728546,
-0.3526706099510193,
-0.10707159340381622,
0.16401271522045135,
0.4441218674182892,
0.5612178444862366,
0.26586610078811646,
-0.04586362838745117,
-0.29060137271881104,
-0.056344978511333466,
0.18435998260974884,
-0.7674003839492798,
-0.34935250878334045,
0.1794360727071762,
-0.22184540331363678,
-0.017467765137553215,
-0.10218295454978943,
-0.7329291105270386,
-0.713442862033844,
-0.16387900710105896,
0.40465274453163147,
-0.2800697684288025,
0.11689857393503189,
0.0724949836730957,
0.08207324147224426,
0.33620622754096985,
0.6097150444984436,
-0.6392027735710144,
0.22971859574317932,
0.39379510283470154,
0.8122231364250183,
-0.6751452684402466,
-0.3728543519973755,
-0.38638898730278015,
0.3755955696105957,
-0.050831858068704605,
0.8155001401901245,
-0.40888240933418274,
-0.36755555868148804,
0.19932322204113007,
0.1417216956615448,
-0.26598989963531494,
-0.5912285447120667,
0.8223488330841064,
-0.8126751780509949,
0.036339327692985535,
0.4384494125843048,
-0.7448294758796692,
-0.15900768339633942,
0.39998942613601685,
-0.5687628984451294,
0.8261155486106873,
0.053262513130903244,
-0.7109711766242981,
0.20087116956710815,
-0.5353206992149353,
-0.5242587327957153,
-0.07324149459600449,
0.42565807700157166,
-0.7340627908706665,
0.0827590748667717,
0.31201088428497314,
0.5145092010498047,
-0.25753748416900635,
0.36471620202064514,
-0.4994755983352661,
-0.21719177067279816,
0.7331330180168152,
-0.5492662191390991,
0.4981815218925476,
0.1463821828365326,
0.3179386556148529,
0.019980818033218384,
-0.8882465362548828,
0.3174874782562256,
0.03415898233652115,
-0.7325443625450134,
-0.5511035323143005,
-0.09062733501195908,
0.6160348653793335,
0.2832854986190796,
0.10029511898756027,
-0.4743807017803192,
0.3570675253868103,
-0.030484329909086227,
0.1771268993616104,
0.8398932218551636,
0.08615510910749435,
0.33481043577194214,
-0.42354846000671387,
0.24516457319259644,
0.16294732689857483,
0.11932650208473206,
0.027585767209529877,
-0.4672892093658447,
-0.7963100075721741,
-0.5764155983924866,
0.91288161277771,
0.507312536239624,
-0.912277340888977,
0.45271191000938416,
-0.4175778031349182,
-0.3254583179950714,
-0.5525942444801331,
0.02243954874575138,
0.2817917466163635,
0.020174721255898476,
0.18339240550994873,
-0.2962581515312195,
-0.49150550365448,
-0.7715795040130615,
-0.19380150735378265,
0.1514049619436264,
0.12086392939090729,
0.37527233362197876,
0.3674521744251251,
-0.5224735736846924,
0.8312408924102783,
-0.4751224219799042,
-0.5590375661849976,
-0.1049586609005928,
0.21936842799186707,
0.42932331562042236,
0.246046245098114,
0.4944542646408081,
-0.9193342328071594,
-0.8493036031723022,
0.04862077534198761,
-0.4614750146865845,
-0.40071502327919006,
-0.31082189083099365,
-0.17235822975635529,
0.39706912636756897,
-0.006710498593747616,
-0.12832671403884888,
0.15294310450553894,
0.9010645151138306,
-0.09028944373130798,
0.25626036524772644,
-0.41546961665153503,
-0.0124440286308527,
-1.0010710954666138,
-0.3160644769668579,
0.16551578044891357,
-0.17613868415355682,
-0.8163898587226868,
-0.29558461904525757,
0.1321599781513214,
0.1731860339641571,
-0.5058019161224365,
0.6395453214645386,
-0.3421608507633209,
0.061807502061128616,
-0.4931541979312897,
0.2090294510126114,
0.13490675389766693,
0.4155605435371399,
0.070195272564888,
0.8771185874938965,
0.4656303822994232,
-0.7813981771469116,
0.15087522566318512,
0.20572394132614136,
-0.32631415128707886,
0.4842037260532379,
-0.17134588956832886,
0.24723736941814423,
0.10317368805408478,
0.40346723794937134,
-1.0696754455566406,
-0.0019147690618410707,
0.12719349563121796,
-0.17388762533664703,
0.4462266266345978,
-0.11519476771354675,
-0.4642127752304077,
-0.2029847949743271,
-0.36047428846359253,
0.4889657199382782,
0.3472456634044647,
-0.9962596893310547,
0.7109910249710083,
0.571368932723999,
-0.17173266410827637,
-0.3873019516468048,
-0.39106038212776184,
0.15118154883384705,
-0.06889081001281738,
-0.3885817229747772,
0.539980947971344,
-0.5027484893798828,
0.06091342121362686,
-0.09394211322069168,
-0.13126997649669647,
-0.4456993639469147,
-0.18214952945709229,
0.1999422162771225,
0.404727578163147,
-0.037689365446567535,
0.08441437780857086,
0.15515737235546112,
0.15005837380886078,
-0.17478390038013458,
-0.33380529284477234,
0.4730551540851593,
0.07584287226200104,
-0.08198801428079605,
-0.17946477234363556,
0.18202535808086395,
0.576108992099762,
0.10457785427570343,
0.6213870644569397,
0.46889549493789673,
-0.2983309030532837,
-0.6312904357910156,
-0.2969178557395935,
0.27080869674682617,
-0.3843463659286499,
0.48525044322013855,
-0.5582982301712036,
-0.6438406705856323,
0.09327695518732071,
-0.6539302468299866,
-0.07758325338363647,
0.1823376715183258,
0.7787309288978577,
-0.16350342333316803,
0.588516891002655,
0.6005018353462219,
-0.24817243218421936,
0.2979063093662262,
-0.22136418521404266,
0.3619856536388397,
-0.85381019115448,
-0.05743709206581116,
-0.358539879322052,
-0.375372052192688,
-0.4058420956134796,
-0.5823209285736084,
0.17613430321216583,
-0.036328963935375214,
0.2665950059890747,
0.07594763487577438,
-0.39926448464393616,
0.48464667797088623,
0.48288974165916443,
0.043177586048841476,
0.2839636504650116,
0.2467202991247177,
0.25569814443588257,
-0.06889566779136658,
-0.6034364700317383,
-0.42247167229652405,
0.9619722962379456,
0.3382597267627716,
1.174539566040039,
0.33533021807670593,
0.44871923327445984,
0.882651686668396,
0.5202858448028564,
-0.7860585451126099,
0.4111173748970032,
-0.5381227731704712,
-0.43885549902915955,
-0.09615471959114075,
-0.1249345913529396,
-0.6814001202583313,
0.4002215266227722,
-0.36807766556739807,
-0.20888058841228485,
0.40463787317276,
-0.23837882280349731,
0.18708546459674835,
0.27168357372283936,
-0.9067200422286987,
0.44219109416007996,
-0.3262275457382202,
-0.2931461036205292,
0.12325986474752426,
-0.36253049969673157,
0.23257486522197723,
-0.9198572635650635,
0.5657209753990173,
-0.1800764948129654,
-0.008459753356873989,
0.6696885228157043,
-0.07253765314817429,
1.1253447532653809,
-0.16353894770145416,
-0.427254319190979,
0.2777917683124542,
-0.21584974229335785,
0.5574062466621399,
-0.11758676916360855,
-0.056657277047634125,
0.4013546109199524,
0.02311147004365921,
-0.4957053065299988,
-0.6830629706382751,
0.8370109796524048,
-0.9042471647262573,
-0.3960728943347931,
-0.6268139481544495,
-0.8284056186676025,
-0.47019773721694946,
-0.01991509273648262,
-0.14021536707878113,
0.02477751486003399,
-0.256276935338974,
-0.10787219554185867,
0.5374875664710999,
-0.22453252971172333,
0.3973347842693329,
0.5486501455307007,
-0.3348458409309387,
-0.4880463182926178,
1.1143943071365356,
-0.23509030044078827,
0.22542960941791534,
0.37353798747062683,
-0.07384634763002396,
-0.29360511898994446,
-0.5985055565834045,
-0.40813276171684265,
0.41257578134536743,
-0.9055603742599487,
-0.34796053171157837,
-0.4663688838481903,
-0.5250278115272522,
-0.1605108231306076,
-0.15279948711395264,
-0.040337663143873215,
-0.37840530276298523,
-0.28769412636756897,
0.3528497517108917,
0.2644578218460083,
0.5848820805549622,
0.30746355652809143,
0.37763869762420654,
-0.6299091577529907,
0.20960773527622223,
0.2739220857620239,
0.29338833689689636,
-0.29438769817352295,
-0.9295874238014221,
-0.3275035619735718,
-0.15845850110054016,
-0.24114935100078583,
-0.5832751989364624,
0.4183763265609741,
0.6559756398200989,
0.4559454917907715,
0.03551410883665085,
0.46361055970191956,
0.3439469635486603,
-0.5595267415046692,
0.3750332295894623,
0.21536706387996674,
-0.7875479459762573,
0.20614425837993622,
0.12748321890830994,
0.32858896255493164,
0.07923714816570282,
0.370375394821167,
-0.2751307487487793,
-0.1903587430715561,
-0.008342095650732517,
-0.6863049864768982,
0.8618797063827515,
0.21554476022720337,
0.2870263159275055,
0.3948975205421448,
0.2809904217720032,
0.39520666003227234,
0.0462290421128273,
-0.8868119120597839,
-0.3459031879901886,
-0.016877394169569016,
-0.35298359394073486,
-0.19580544531345367,
-0.4424077272415161,
-0.1765073984861374,
-0.12371253967285156,
1.0794881582260132,
-0.3183564245700836,
0.20103880763053894,
-0.10061516612768173,
-0.3778918981552124,
0.18475580215454102,
0.6111164689064026,
0.4934841990470886,
0.4209395945072174,
-0.35531213879585266,
0.2330205887556076,
0.22165697813034058,
-0.5725219249725342,
0.4587444067001343,
0.21121945977210999,
-0.27883490920066833,
0.11391051113605499,
0.24742983281612396,
1.0016206502914429,
-0.15713204443454742,
-0.7186074256896973,
0.4125033915042877,
-0.09166085720062256,
-0.18148073554039001,
0.10364235937595367,
-0.060564398765563965,
-0.19059698283672333,
0.2734944522380829,
0.31715184450149536,
0.07897480577230453,
-0.02147720381617546,
-0.38051512837409973,
0.18956778943538666,
0.3213454782962799,
-0.352455198764801,
-0.2028476893901825,
0.3846414387226105,
0.11602777987718582,
-0.3807150423526764,
0.19150882959365845,
0.030238185077905655,
-0.43146005272865295,
0.2930464446544647,
1.1563658714294434,
0.6319049596786499,
-0.1928022801876068,
0.3446323871612549,
0.025226816534996033,
0.11477842181921005,
0.3347243368625641,
-0.121416375041008,
0.18389669060707092,
-0.9759253263473511,
-0.34650570154190063,
-0.6662865877151489,
-0.5966112613677979,
0.06436320394277573,
-0.4124123454093933,
0.2132994383573532,
-0.3191738426685333,
-0.2634228765964508,
0.22002220153808594,
-0.22023646533489227,
-0.3371976315975189,
0.43717625737190247,
0.3947542607784271,
0.737740159034729,
-0.8310030698776245,
1.3198033571243286,
1.010758876800537,
0.11596780270338058,
0.03103557787835598,
0.3420429825782776,
-0.38489872217178345,
-0.6700065732002258,
0.6906308531761169,
-0.01881464198231697,
-0.19282019138336182,
0.16541454195976257,
-0.4242473542690277,
-0.6702643036842346,
0.7309390902519226,
0.055506668984889984,
-0.6817449927330017,
0.20507727563381195,
0.03299524635076523,
0.5389294028282166,
-0.6330670714378357,
-0.1671876162290573,
0.36975738406181335,
0.41648563742637634,
0.2174302190542221,
-0.573468804359436,
-0.13275520503520966,
-0.16388840973377228,
0.2898869812488556,
0.04575318098068237,
-0.537872314453125,
0.5939586758613586,
-0.20352184772491455,
-0.028628652915358543,
0.0364973247051239,
0.4400468170642853,
0.36074116826057434,
0.7244446873664856,
0.589381754398346,
0.25114837288856506,
0.6755112409591675,
-0.0960930660367012,
0.9153285622596741,
-0.19390130043029785,
0.5610246658325195,
1.282307505607605,
-0.7264525294303894,
0.7654804587364197,
0.6268123388290405,
-0.45443469285964966,
0.37077999114990234,
0.7705829739570618,
-0.21547840535640717,
0.9309254288673401,
0.34306803345680237,
-0.5636778473854065,
-0.12201157957315445,
-0.23330023884773254,
-0.19284610450267792,
0.07251693308353424,
0.45784804224967957,
-0.19897769391536713,
-0.10149261355400085,
0.4074132740497589,
-0.300117552280426,
-0.00019646929285954684,
-0.021819552406668663,
0.7330062389373779,
-0.04547853767871857,
-0.3447433412075043,
1.006251573562622,
0.2261701077222824,
0.6224548816680908,
-0.3736206889152527,
-0.031690146774053574,
-0.08311869204044342,
0.5374636650085449,
-0.0066592940129339695,
-0.7567707300186157,
-0.15992511808872223,
-0.12136401236057281,
-0.5809932351112366,
-0.017442449927330017,
0.8324674367904663,
-0.4632968604564667,
-0.550977349281311,
0.5223300457000732,
0.3213116526603699,
0.14323613047599792,
0.13056443631649017,
-0.8139859437942505,
0.4503963887691498,
0.14319150149822235,
-0.01895296201109886,
0.5357931852340698,
0.47445574402809143,
-0.2408147007226944,
0.552344799041748,
0.5299425721168518,
-0.10320640355348587,
0.3317388594150543,
0.17982372641563416,
0.9669584631919861,
-0.357658326625824,
0.01352035254240036,
-0.5878391265869141,
0.23585903644561768,
-0.006817749701440334,
-0.029517659917473793,
0.7140721678733826,
0.6784424781799316,
0.7897921800613403,
-0.5602028369903564,
0.9520323872566223,
0.14435188472270966,
0.34430256485939026,
-0.7367775440216064,
0.5332479476928711,
-0.636701762676239,
0.3893800675868988,
-0.2321195900440216,
-1.2770953178405762,
-0.6658974289894104,
0.24095599353313446,
-0.14909733831882477,
0.006145218387246132,
0.6307817101478577,
0.6268904209136963,
-0.09228682518005371,
-0.14981520175933838,
0.5793600678443909,
0.44590720534324646,
0.17787671089172363,
0.5038025379180908,
0.9562082886695862,
-0.5628712177276611,
0.5324921011924744,
-0.05352570116519928,
-0.33129820227622986,
-0.23099154233932495,
-0.7867408990859985,
-1.0463236570358276,
-0.5411623120307922,
-0.6582042574882507,
-0.40667375922203064,
0.3349830210208893,
0.39877092838287354,
0.7073919177055359,
-1.153900146484375,
-0.1576038897037506,
0.37843772768974304,
0.16125895082950592,
-0.08684590458869934,
-0.22048784792423248,
0.577377438545227,
-0.27243345975875854,
-1.1309072971343994,
0.3256448805332184,
0.37830108404159546,
0.1375986635684967,
0.11335337907075882,
-0.14517651498317719,
-0.5395333170890808,
0.4027678668498993,
0.8470957279205322,
-0.027618302032351494,
-0.7892749905586243,
-0.017564240843057632,
-0.37744754552841187,
-0.04265329986810684,
0.18139047920703888,
0.5645626187324524,
-0.4831727147102356,
0.6583448648452759,
-0.02298840880393982,
0.8998507261276245,
0.5311093330383301,
0.08726019412279129,
0.1431402862071991,
-0.9900447130203247,
0.03584896773099899,
-0.06636573374271393,
0.15666702389717102,
0.3457508981227875,
-0.2850605547428131,
0.519615113735199,
0.2670442759990692,
-0.6005039811134338,
-0.8182874917984009,
0.037045110017061234,
-1.2280536890029907,
-0.4283345341682434,
1.1565897464752197,
-0.23433777689933777,
-0.2171451300382614,
-0.16540049016475677,
-0.6382445096969604,
-0.011146489530801773,
-0.3890993893146515,
0.7959738373756409,
0.8346973657608032,
0.013707207515835762,
-0.15531779825687408,
-0.3207910358905792,
0.06689997017383575,
0.2480224072933197,
-0.8771467208862305,
0.07949047535657883,
0.3985265791416168,
0.07484543323516846,
0.11219818890094757,
0.5093560814857483,
0.0773422047495842,
-0.21017733216285706,
-0.35600918531417847,
0.40684133768081665,
0.27518633008003235,
-0.2981891930103302,
-0.4815414845943451,
0.06431801617145538,
0.23614072799682617,
-0.3745114505290985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01873v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01873v1
|
Enhancing Bangla Language Next Word Prediction and Sentence Completion through Extended RNN with Bi-LSTM Model On N-gram Language
| 2024-05-03T06:06:01 | 2024-05-03T06:06:01 |
Md Robiul Islam, Al Amin, Aniqua Nusrat Zereen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Texting stands out as the most prominent form of communication worldwide.
Individual spend significant amount of time writing whole texts to send emails
or write something on social media, which is time consuming in this modern era.
Word prediction and sentence completion will be suitable and appropriate in the
Bangla language to make textual information easier and more convenient. This
paper expands the scope of Bangla language processing by introducing a Bi-LSTM
model that effectively handles Bangla next-word prediction and Bangla sentence
generation, demonstrating its versatility and potential impact. We proposed a
new Bi-LSTM model to predict a following word and complete a sentence. We
constructed a corpus dataset from various news portals, including bdnews24, BBC
News Bangla, and Prothom Alo. The proposed approach achieved superior results
in word prediction, reaching 99\% accuracy for both 4-gram and 5-gram word
predictions. Moreover, it demonstrated significant improvement over existing
methods, achieving 35\%, 75\%, and 95\% accuracy for uni-gram, bi-gram, and
tri-gram word prediction, respectively
|
[
-0.11856991052627563,
-0.9439132213592529,
0.2873772084712982,
0.5295841693878174,
-0.3774164319038391,
0.21465367078781128,
-0.3001556098461151,
-0.7632009983062744,
0.27810248732566833,
0.5688191652297974,
-0.3909189999103546,
-0.19007612764835358,
-0.42032530903816223,
0.5579531788825989,
-0.3048863410949707,
0.8973733186721802,
0.11923741549253464,
0.098797507584095,
-0.12745438516139984,
0.31385689973831177,
-0.8662958145141602,
-0.18312780559062958,
-0.3463885188102722,
-0.4386925995349884,
0.8297229409217834,
0.33050814270973206,
0.507622241973877,
0.2697444558143616,
0.45767202973365784,
0.22598321735858917,
-0.3466810882091522,
0.42882591485977173,
-0.4535902142524719,
0.15688763558864594,
-0.10546251386404037,
-0.5373317003250122,
-0.38073089718818665,
-0.31255728006362915,
0.7224586009979248,
0.7707228064537048,
0.23947131633758545,
0.02638290822505951,
0.019166631624102592,
0.9091809391975403,
-0.27023449540138245,
0.10225410759449005,
-0.6838350892066956,
-0.15045832097530365,
-0.28881600499153137,
-0.414041131734848,
-0.5037208199501038,
-0.9481641054153442,
0.2100531905889511,
-0.09737129509449005,
-0.3319253921508789,
0.04246892035007477,
0.8700977563858032,
-0.1408143937587738,
-0.4819818437099457,
-0.1749529242515564,
-0.6764650940895081,
0.3590010702610016,
-0.8724851012229919,
0.5652203559875488,
0.6698775887489319,
0.11851311475038528,
-0.3060190677642822,
-0.5638972520828247,
-0.538881778717041,
-0.30523598194122314,
0.07629264146089554,
0.2690106928348541,
0.2036239504814148,
0.05661258473992348,
-0.20716501772403717,
0.2081507444381714,
-0.5918394923210144,
-0.1312054693698883,
-0.669092059135437,
0.005482910200953484,
0.3725651204586029,
0.05807046964764595,
0.12803587317466736,
-0.4120616614818573,
-0.5316205620765686,
0.3862171769142151,
-0.762493371963501,
-0.0631655752658844,
0.42990994453430176,
0.6542816758155823,
0.048616230487823486,
0.8102333545684814,
-0.37001487612724304,
1.0376006364822388,
-0.05856522172689438,
-0.02496202662587166,
0.48219746351242065,
-0.7475945353507996,
-0.21085385978221893,
0.22717539966106415,
0.5345932245254517,
0.6320861577987671,
0.658474862575531,
-0.1129186749458313,
0.13589799404144287,
-0.07048558443784714,
0.20481495559215546,
-0.7921419739723206,
-0.10370434820652008,
0.13466264307498932,
-0.4199833273887634,
-0.10254713147878647,
-0.22432845830917358,
-0.8463330864906311,
-0.4437231421470642,
-0.23418593406677246,
0.1301032155752182,
-0.6769787669181824,
-0.12342013418674469,
0.23869721591472626,
0.39868253469467163,
0.16651266813278198,
0.31092992424964905,
-0.48857200145721436,
-0.24848125874996185,
0.3119681179523468,
1.1875211000442505,
0.10201036185026169,
-0.1351349800825119,
-0.4878626763820648,
0.30527016520500183,
-0.3044014573097229,
0.8928000330924988,
-0.5504110455513,
-0.28995850682258606,
0.17976854741573334,
-0.2782316207885742,
-0.07933246344327927,
-0.09046047180891037,
0.611376941204071,
-0.7571797966957092,
0.3368985056877136,
0.18128518760204315,
-0.8729115724563599,
-0.5485491156578064,
0.4000649154186249,
-0.6015149354934692,
0.7851095199584961,
0.11596497148275375,
-0.9408800005912781,
0.24422268569469452,
-0.38103359937667847,
-0.7507075071334839,
0.29014986753463745,
0.23517660796642303,
-0.5841095447540283,
0.2145008146762848,
0.15277555584907532,
0.6964737772941589,
-0.08439287543296814,
0.3586951196193695,
-0.4276745915412903,
-0.42702433466911316,
0.30554255843162537,
-0.22840136289596558,
0.4846422076225281,
-0.09720764309167862,
0.04487179219722748,
0.1769837886095047,
-0.8551813960075378,
0.2581004202365875,
-0.2712715268135071,
-0.6742482781410217,
-0.1354275643825531,
-0.42037537693977356,
0.4028570055961609,
0.2589389979839325,
0.47817566990852356,
-0.7406825423240662,
0.15179497003555298,
-0.7235696911811829,
-0.044570233672857285,
0.7580632567405701,
-0.04565287381410599,
0.19891513884067535,
-0.19588206708431244,
0.36852598190307617,
-0.37415438890457153,
-0.08137832581996918,
-0.29074999690055847,
-0.8191660046577454,
-0.2520430088043213,
0.030794665217399597,
0.592964231967926,
0.7159590721130371,
-0.5054345726966858,
0.5612649321556091,
-0.4686635434627533,
-0.4870981276035309,
-0.4057103395462036,
0.22864985466003418,
0.3114924430847168,
0.3375246822834015,
0.2911889851093292,
-0.010038585402071476,
-1.146303415298462,
-0.6952582597732544,
-0.4362548291683197,
-0.2376319020986557,
0.42132776975631714,
-0.07229037582874298,
-0.004437856841832399,
-0.4595860540866852,
1.069138765335083,
-0.1421482264995575,
-0.4294796288013458,
-0.9835255146026611,
0.1449710577726364,
0.44500666856765747,
-0.0027150555979460478,
0.13098928332328796,
-0.9934431910514832,
-0.7580206990242004,
0.25476542115211487,
-0.5002686977386475,
-0.44531524181365967,
-0.07371443510055542,
0.1278124749660492,
0.6525751948356628,
0.4917749762535095,
-0.24662089347839355,
0.8133966326713562,
0.48961734771728516,
-0.3964400291442871,
0.6012689471244812,
-0.2903922200202942,
-0.2891171872615814,
-1.5231419801712036,
-0.12927158176898956,
-0.08891430497169495,
-0.5327064990997314,
-0.8026371598243713,
-0.35603067278862,
0.049898259341716766,
0.33583053946495056,
-0.17555318772792816,
0.48244377970695496,
-0.7302219271659851,
-0.08177363872528076,
-0.8502368330955505,
0.2473948746919632,
-0.2825399339199066,
0.1894250512123108,
0.040271565318107605,
0.46042731404304504,
0.2452029287815094,
-0.4516048729419708,
0.3580308258533478,
0.32723143696784973,
-0.6945071816444397,
-0.1550205945968628,
-0.7354603409767151,
-0.2977648675441742,
-0.11090284585952759,
0.37533897161483765,
-1.0154342651367188,
-0.08008816093206406,
0.0014765879604965448,
-0.5920677781105042,
0.272341787815094,
0.15725205838680267,
-0.7180707454681396,
-0.3919285535812378,
-0.09235256910324097,
0.29867711663246155,
0.24451056122779846,
-0.2142549753189087,
0.5095788240432739,
0.022806545719504356,
-0.4337237477302551,
-0.4760262668132782,
-0.954707145690918,
0.3915790915489197,
0.021011698991060257,
-0.5308561325073242,
0.06425558775663376,
-0.15750724077224731,
0.2229894995689392,
0.07160332798957825,
0.31820687651634216,
0.24616222083568573,
-0.18892426788806915,
0.33785349130630493,
0.6054217219352722,
0.20550113916397095,
-0.07065394520759583,
-0.1460351049900055,
-0.11925441026687622,
-0.29321709275245667,
-0.01749812439084053,
0.9950116276741028,
-0.19703583419322968,
-0.036402009427547455,
-0.46235859394073486,
0.40618911385536194,
0.13727320730686188,
-0.11255737394094467,
0.7120829224586487,
0.9772404432296753,
-0.3560450077056885,
0.17083488404750824,
-0.6332521438598633,
-0.018214520066976547,
-0.346186101436615,
0.71197110414505,
-0.13996079564094543,
-0.8021262288093567,
0.2888728678226471,
-0.08869548887014389,
-0.048083651810884476,
-0.15824158489704132,
0.8628875017166138,
0.19529911875724792,
0.7445017695426941,
0.867173969745636,
-0.057291463017463684,
0.6814566254615784,
-0.020492875948548317,
0.7546260356903076,
-0.8242744207382202,
-0.4024876356124878,
0.03130856901407242,
-0.18949079513549805,
-0.7211208939552307,
-0.35842087864875793,
0.23370306193828583,
0.16176679730415344,
0.11737854778766632,
0.6149730682373047,
-0.13290467858314514,
0.17881090939044952,
0.6394016146659851,
0.23903276026248932,
0.32516905665397644,
0.11887877434492111,
-0.1642666608095169,
0.21246983110904694,
-0.4925183355808258,
-0.4445357024669647,
1.1869025230407715,
0.0633331835269928,
0.5040876865386963,
-0.039151277393102646,
0.8676007986068726,
0.328923761844635,
0.21061936020851135,
-0.43232855200767517,
0.6522137522697449,
-0.013310570269823074,
-0.5056970715522766,
-0.07883670181035995,
-0.40433600544929504,
-0.9584071636199951,
0.058672573417425156,
-0.26132920384407043,
-0.8938029408454895,
0.03219154477119446,
-0.3137318789958954,
-0.453676700592041,
0.25219324231147766,
-0.5271876454353333,
0.30519863963127136,
-0.1298627257347107,
-0.5679935216903687,
-0.07334160059690475,
-0.9247703552246094,
0.4683452546596527,
-0.10616546124219894,
0.2975451350212097,
-0.2463286817073822,
-0.06694357097148895,
0.4653173089027405,
-0.29077401757240295,
0.9179516434669495,
0.20510786771774292,
-0.08966485410928726,
0.28155073523521423,
-0.19777436554431915,
0.4651520252227783,
0.04055015742778778,
-0.255136102437973,
-0.016073264181613922,
-0.29170849919319153,
-0.3064384162425995,
-0.35595178604125977,
0.4580806791782379,
-0.323606014251709,
-0.10814490914344788,
-0.5280585885047913,
-0.8645643591880798,
-0.3139716386795044,
0.4125298857688904,
0.4178827702999115,
0.5397942662239075,
0.12481480091810226,
0.31108227372169495,
0.2825706899166107,
-0.06974004954099655,
0.7222875952720642,
0.2675885856151581,
-0.9056557416915894,
-0.63992840051651,
0.8031015396118164,
0.1258120983839035,
0.149820476770401,
0.5388525128364563,
0.2873118817806244,
-0.5787316560745239,
-0.8115400671958923,
-0.34357476234436035,
0.07451227307319641,
-0.20044276118278503,
-0.5184734463691711,
-0.8110953569412231,
-0.39997413754463196,
-0.6730093359947205,
-0.1604185849428177,
0.039930928498506546,
-0.29968956112861633,
0.05551358312368393,
-0.3188290596008301,
0.5146988034248352,
0.7206026911735535,
-0.14969664812088013,
0.2851158380508423,
-1.0016579627990723,
0.2919991910457611,
-0.2500714659690857,
0.2960430383682251,
-0.14775383472442627,
-0.7291926145553589,
-0.5734816193580627,
0.1608615666627884,
-0.17727427184581757,
-0.9379395842552185,
0.5949674844741821,
0.30329641699790955,
0.16747161746025085,
0.3030458688735962,
-0.23714657127857208,
0.6078510284423828,
-0.6417418718338013,
0.5894648432731628,
0.4609901010990143,
-0.5402358770370483,
0.592566192150116,
-0.35857465863227844,
0.4287467896938324,
0.44806626439094543,
0.1359144002199173,
-0.5850977301597595,
-0.4083988070487976,
-0.13472552597522736,
-1.0875760316848755,
0.2609643340110779,
0.3409360647201538,
0.12809845805168152,
-0.11694076657295227,
0.13705824315547943,
0.40693050622940063,
0.20703944563865662,
-1.032549262046814,
-0.06395402550697327,
0.0706297904253006,
-0.04956376552581787,
-0.01991977170109749,
-0.525321900844574,
0.5910337567329407,
-0.329989492893219,
0.9573432207107544,
0.139252170920372,
0.2268405258655548,
0.029148483648896217,
0.022710327059030533,
0.15198726952075958,
0.243520587682724,
0.6307995319366455,
0.6476906538009644,
-0.4779588580131531,
-0.3317665457725525,
0.004260703455656767,
-0.384634405374527,
-0.12269755452871323,
0.25016340613365173,
-0.3007459342479706,
0.3999604284763336,
0.54390549659729,
0.8756870627403259,
0.13786645233631134,
-0.8088707327842712,
0.40882790088653564,
0.156357079744339,
-0.047841619700193405,
-0.5832252502441406,
-0.3286774754524231,
0.2512379586696625,
0.316367506980896,
0.21203237771987915,
0.1147223636507988,
0.15292377769947052,
-0.7386927008628845,
0.2981084883213043,
0.06242073327302933,
-0.18743281066417694,
-0.1594007909297943,
0.34477338194847107,
-0.03752341866493225,
-0.24428731203079224,
0.3183845281600952,
-0.33664175868034363,
-0.7590526938438416,
0.2106851041316986,
0.8802329897880554,
0.7974812984466553,
-0.4860949218273163,
0.22121943533420563,
0.4046373665332794,
0.18718388676643372,
-0.14633455872535706,
0.8139406442642212,
0.392642080783844,
-0.7204134464263916,
-0.7167242765426636,
-0.910071611404419,
-0.11748842895030975,
0.0006995995645411313,
-0.36097437143325806,
0.43179211020469666,
-0.31231245398521423,
-0.17492391169071198,
-0.46881452202796936,
0.24585600197315216,
-0.3538496792316437,
0.3261447250843048,
0.2721428871154785,
0.8323612213134766,
-0.5261967182159424,
0.8984807729721069,
0.7807238698005676,
-0.44996023178100586,
-0.7854353785514832,
-0.045948807150125504,
-0.3025975525379181,
-0.6659106016159058,
0.5830049514770508,
0.6117302775382996,
-0.06284546107053757,
-0.2511293888092041,
0.0346282534301281,
-0.8479604721069336,
1.0014853477478027,
0.031579501926898956,
-0.8103909492492676,
-0.2803759276866913,
0.35815367102622986,
0.5568628907203674,
-0.460986465215683,
0.4438773989677429,
0.2867126166820526,
0.7516012191772461,
0.20489619672298431,
-0.8195557594299316,
-0.09798173606395721,
-0.4508332908153534,
0.378271222114563,
0.189259871840477,
-0.4559782147407532,
0.7622324228286743,
-0.39742323756217957,
0.006157379597425461,
0.30426689982414246,
1.1041542291641235,
0.23658223450183868,
0.5452058911323547,
0.32931941747665405,
0.41520851850509644,
0.661994993686676,
0.14435307681560516,
0.8900585174560547,
-0.4121447205543518,
0.027414381504058838,
1.458005428314209,
-0.40476515889167786,
1.037535309791565,
0.2981764078140259,
-0.20373472571372986,
0.7062910199165344,
0.7429049611091614,
0.09031260758638382,
0.5685881972312927,
0.3556385636329651,
-0.4083326756954193,
-0.09137905389070511,
-0.31851595640182495,
-0.5231492519378662,
0.7527409791946411,
0.2736215591430664,
-0.26103684306144714,
-0.17283563315868378,
0.24114271998405457,
-0.1407255083322525,
0.3049440383911133,
-0.46704572439193726,
0.7194726467132568,
0.03826393932104111,
-0.3059740960597992,
0.374181866645813,
-0.044108785688877106,
0.7854758501052856,
-0.46548745036125183,
0.19585266709327698,
-0.10458771884441376,
0.2534424960613251,
-0.2747448682785034,
-0.7288413643836975,
0.5873677134513855,
-0.03929934650659561,
-0.2701651453971863,
-0.15968278050422668,
1.0929487943649292,
-0.8941748142242432,
-1.0216318368911743,
0.5554346442222595,
0.6453826427459717,
0.25017163157463074,
-0.14465241134166718,
-0.25136798620224,
-0.09976986050605774,
0.08234629780054092,
-0.16407807171344757,
0.1696588397026062,
0.41349080204963684,
0.013753460720181465,
0.8735349774360657,
0.5773671269416809,
0.5518679022789001,
0.5929542183876038,
0.1721758395433426,
0.555336594581604,
-0.5085026621818542,
-0.6669719815254211,
-0.7895784378051758,
0.12587770819664001,
-0.255138635635376,
-0.13389165699481964,
0.7966103553771973,
0.8868507742881775,
0.8656525015830994,
-0.02232194133102894,
1.086932897567749,
-0.1718367040157318,
0.859414279460907,
-0.47136443853378296,
0.5438887476921082,
-0.39180687069892883,
0.011151352897286415,
-0.3149508535861969,
-1.071668028831482,
-0.32623791694641113,
0.39895305037498474,
-0.24207264184951782,
0.2557232975959778,
0.713348388671875,
0.6226238012313843,
0.1246480643749237,
0.42901575565338135,
0.37826642394065857,
0.16062769293785095,
0.007958833128213882,
0.6071195602416992,
0.6344422698020935,
-0.392490953207016,
0.6476311087608337,
-0.22667212784290314,
-0.090978242456913,
-0.5907087922096252,
-0.9035161137580872,
-1.144623875617981,
-0.6433697938919067,
-0.018876900896430016,
-0.4189009964466095,
0.07950206100940704,
0.8689509034156799,
0.339964359998703,
-0.6003412008285522,
-0.12321805953979492,
-0.34898141026496887,
0.0986492931842804,
-0.053328175097703934,
-0.2516196668148041,
0.41412949562072754,
-0.2825133502483368,
-0.685777485370636,
0.4168168604373932,
0.4206443727016449,
-0.27336829900741577,
0.09455939382314682,
0.17422084510326385,
-0.9441152811050415,
0.19904230535030365,
0.8827943205833435,
0.020351141691207886,
-0.5765255093574524,
-0.20039066672325134,
-0.17823630571365356,
0.028472425416111946,
-0.07991538941860199,
0.6785526871681213,
-0.8481960892677307,
0.3451058566570282,
0.6440670490264893,
0.8687871098518372,
0.1758735626935959,
-0.010859777219593525,
0.7479516863822937,
-0.4257126748561859,
-0.16534097492694855,
0.18396705389022827,
0.4181615710258484,
0.6123858690261841,
-0.38029372692108154,
0.6074106097221375,
0.21007007360458374,
-0.5706756114959717,
-0.6858062744140625,
0.40212294459342957,
-1.1479467153549194,
-0.13320395350456238,
1.2929041385650635,
-0.15641072392463684,
-0.38027092814445496,
-0.2881883382797241,
-0.3410702347755432,
0.7308660745620728,
-0.3090967833995819,
0.7553158402442932,
0.42310768365859985,
-0.01611534133553505,
-0.26317915320396423,
-0.47802165150642395,
-0.038819968700408936,
0.5122906565666199,
-0.7007835507392883,
0.13903962075710297,
0.4129598140716553,
0.030112411826848984,
0.04952551797032356,
0.49046218395233154,
0.020985262468457222,
0.2314697951078415,
-0.46767303347587585,
0.045743297785520554,
-0.4771454334259033,
-0.39117056131362915,
-0.08246602863073349,
0.15549543499946594,
-0.5097018480300903,
-0.207233726978302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01868v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01868v1
|
Incorporating External Knowledge and Goal Guidance for LLM-based Conversational Recommender Systems
| 2024-05-03T05:42:57 | 2024-05-03T05:42:57 |
Chuang Li, Yang Deng, Hengchang Hu, Min-Yen Kan, Haizhou Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper aims to efficiently enable large language models (LLMs) to use
external knowledge and goal guidance in conversational recommender system (CRS)
tasks. Advanced LLMs (e.g., ChatGPT) are limited in domain-specific CRS tasks
for 1) generating grounded responses with recommendation-oriented knowledge, or
2) proactively leading the conversations through different dialogue goals. In
this work, we first analyze those limitations through a comprehensive
evaluation, showing the necessity of external knowledge and goal guidance which
contribute significantly to the recommendation accuracy and language quality.
In light of this finding, we propose a novel ChatCRS framework to decompose the
complex CRS task into several sub-tasks through the implementation of 1) a
knowledge retrieval agent using a tool-augmented approach to reason over
external Knowledge Bases and 2) a goal-planning agent for dialogue goal
prediction. Experimental results on two multi-goal CRS datasets reveal that
ChatCRS sets new state-of-the-art benchmarks, improving language quality of
informativeness by 17% and proactivity by 27%, and achieving a tenfold
enhancement in recommendation accuracy.
|
[
-0.21801431477069855,
-0.4199490547180176,
0.6461684703826904,
-0.03014824166893959,
-0.11607574671506882,
0.003234193194657564,
-0.6227990388870239,
-0.3118782341480255,
0.05609322711825371,
0.6148022413253784,
-0.7353045344352722,
-0.5229033827781677,
-0.5458056330680847,
-0.2715504765510559,
-0.043119676411151886,
1.076735019683838,
0.03974176570773125,
0.24833723902702332,
-0.2871291935443878,
0.3120812177658081,
-0.8981255888938904,
-0.4185445308685303,
-0.7452226281166077,
-0.3845639228820801,
0.5019745230674744,
0.6742619276046753,
0.6172381639480591,
0.10123579949140549,
0.6247595548629761,
0.26278766989707947,
-0.07482445240020752,
0.6403311491012573,
-0.7611908316612244,
0.40496864914894104,
-0.27604007720947266,
-0.5286060571670532,
-0.20756524801254272,
-0.47472503781318665,
0.28457024693489075,
0.23853297531604767,
-0.3922882676124573,
-0.042690426111221313,
0.42237433791160583,
0.6304078698158264,
-0.28991976380348206,
0.7504436373710632,
-0.7218104004859924,
-0.13225769996643066,
0.3789825439453125,
-0.3651233911514282,
-0.37392207980155945,
-0.48467135429382324,
0.49403175711631775,
-0.5239126682281494,
-0.1165868416428566,
0.16647541522979736,
0.4331474006175995,
0.14214783906936646,
-0.39544567465782166,
-0.6502084136009216,
-0.721798837184906,
0.7831218242645264,
-0.6382301449775696,
0.7384392023086548,
0.39938604831695557,
0.5644629001617432,
-0.2913518249988556,
-0.4068430960178375,
-0.21741728484630585,
-0.3686343729496002,
-0.20038960874080658,
-0.03138928860425949,
-0.12933912873268127,
0.23978187143802643,
-0.02959166280925274,
0.2906862199306488,
-0.2745380997657776,
-0.33158841729164124,
-0.33765310049057007,
-0.2649863660335541,
0.40528902411460876,
0.21796831488609314,
-0.08418380469083786,
0.07116492092609406,
-0.2624887526035309,
0.15237221121788025,
-0.7413792014122009,
0.399404376745224,
0.17704090476036072,
0.7833603620529175,
-0.04957709461450577,
0.7400626540184021,
-0.6042762994766235,
0.40519312024116516,
0.09652246534824371,
-0.2519087493419647,
-0.2336164116859436,
-0.5914440751075745,
-0.010636440478265285,
-0.18008816242218018,
0.6465094685554504,
0.6429536938667297,
0.4369961619377136,
-0.26049530506134033,
-0.0037637492641806602,
-0.26251304149627686,
0.1461872011423111,
-0.6997743248939514,
-0.20053823292255402,
0.06566254794597626,
-0.3090137243270874,
0.05348723754286766,
-0.21476894617080688,
-0.4598887860774994,
-0.4379440248012543,
-0.7185462117195129,
0.24344591796398163,
-0.7180640697479248,
0.09807402640581131,
0.07552073895931244,
-0.07865896075963974,
0.008994700387120247,
0.4988155961036682,
-0.5837470293045044,
0.2156832069158554,
0.510018527507782,
0.7615272402763367,
-0.13419334590435028,
0.23917818069458008,
-0.3974451422691345,
0.18274718523025513,
-0.14014466106891632,
0.9831143617630005,
-0.7447438836097717,
-0.5529651045799255,
0.1998044103384018,
-0.007890124805271626,
0.0372297428548336,
-0.24322867393493652,
0.6652733087539673,
-0.56854248046875,
0.2604709267616272,
-0.5201086401939392,
-0.44106167554855347,
-0.597370445728302,
0.5505226850509644,
0.07791352272033691,
0.7822529077529907,
0.0061567737720906734,
-0.2638242244720459,
0.1914224475622177,
-0.465704083442688,
-0.3149756193161011,
0.03417417034506798,
-0.12401141226291656,
0.21846938133239746,
-0.14198079705238342,
0.24733413755893707,
0.691045343875885,
-0.7033787965774536,
0.5750033259391785,
-0.11411737650632858,
-0.27766141295433044,
0.07184937596321106,
-0.32262471318244934,
0.06145467236638069,
0.07236387580633163,
0.029212472960352898,
0.4617749750614166,
-0.36285221576690674,
0.30581724643707275,
-0.17178785800933838,
-0.5359525084495544,
-0.12171340733766556,
0.26422083377838135,
-0.31925463676452637,
0.24519921839237213,
0.5630918145179749,
-0.39166659116744995,
0.149774432182312,
-0.35149723291397095,
0.24283568561077118,
0.6704767346382141,
0.16803275048732758,
0.30521509051322937,
-0.6799579858779907,
0.31689658761024475,
-0.009160688146948814,
0.15236321091651917,
-0.388139009475708,
-0.588998556137085,
-0.9216122627258301,
-0.07998428493738174,
-0.22121559083461761,
0.6165059804916382,
-0.5716584324836731,
0.6340668201446533,
-0.2710529565811157,
-0.7608503699302673,
-0.14980238676071167,
0.1779835969209671,
0.472413569688797,
0.34129929542541504,
0.497250497341156,
-0.10828007757663727,
-0.5985912084579468,
-0.8891139626502991,
-0.277344286441803,
-0.21982084214687347,
0.08445914834737778,
0.5845935344696045,
0.12574350833892822,
-0.24685128033161163,
0.8596910834312439,
-0.629176914691925,
-0.803685188293457,
-0.48281121253967285,
-0.47920987010002136,
0.3135872781276703,
0.3527963161468506,
-0.00010525261313887313,
-0.4670943021774292,
-0.5554303526878357,
0.08515845984220505,
-0.5810431241989136,
0.03966815397143364,
0.1503104567527771,
-0.056207068264484406,
-0.17025460302829742,
0.42201313376426697,
-0.6777884364128113,
0.22683821618556976,
0.324862003326416,
-0.31598013639450073,
0.7355443835258484,
-0.3086552321910858,
0.3687672019004822,
-0.9279695153236389,
-0.2318592369556427,
0.36043086647987366,
-0.20641469955444336,
-0.6100674867630005,
-0.12236679345369339,
-0.24354752898216248,
0.14771723747253418,
-0.32243600487709045,
0.3289908170700073,
-0.1851886510848999,
0.14220061898231506,
-0.28887084126472473,
0.32133013010025024,
0.06043730303645134,
0.9557024240493774,
0.118483766913414,
0.5551008582115173,
0.438700795173645,
-0.8364706635475159,
0.49637189507484436,
0.5546106696128845,
-0.46217623353004456,
0.6581423282623291,
-0.6089360117912292,
-0.053650133311748505,
-0.09009657800197601,
0.3949449062347412,
-0.9189823865890503,
0.1864200383424759,
0.3511580228805542,
-0.08623199164867401,
-0.02969755418598652,
-0.3771874010562897,
-0.25196486711502075,
-0.057315096259117126,
-0.04791434854269028,
0.09072764217853546,
0.43122178316116333,
-0.2311873883008957,
0.7100340127944946,
0.3507744371891022,
-0.3814641833305359,
-0.45684048533439636,
-0.25952786207199097,
0.04388588294386864,
-0.058385785669088364,
-0.5847400426864624,
0.39560285210609436,
-0.3495878279209137,
-0.36078304052352905,
-0.15042075514793396,
0.03679454326629639,
0.3278782069683075,
-0.538993239402771,
0.45600900053977966,
0.13196463882923126,
-0.12137288600206375,
0.126052126288414,
-0.025342168286442757,
-0.007628080900758505,
-0.08099967241287231,
-0.5106703639030457,
0.693274199962616,
0.015430104918777943,
-0.595488965511322,
-0.6835073232650757,
0.16332760453224182,
0.4660055637359619,
-0.114700548350811,
0.5392283797264099,
0.3816138207912445,
-0.058591991662979126,
-0.1125720664858818,
-0.910348117351532,
-0.20545116066932678,
-0.5340325832366943,
0.40881437063217163,
-0.6334474086761475,
-0.8912811875343323,
0.4461798667907715,
-0.03902360424399376,
0.22303394973278046,
0.23627620935440063,
0.5132591724395752,
0.13075917959213257,
0.9088818430900574,
0.43385225534439087,
-0.08535541594028473,
0.7048028707504272,
-0.31482958793640137,
0.2940664291381836,
-0.9788780808448792,
-0.6555957198143005,
-0.43368780612945557,
0.015428964048624039,
-0.22914156317710876,
-0.7130147814750671,
0.311995267868042,
0.02874288149178028,
-0.2538436949253082,
0.47228679060935974,
-0.5140150785446167,
0.2386436015367508,
0.6761496663093567,
0.44117677211761475,
0.580142617225647,
-0.14187641441822052,
-0.27519649267196655,
-0.008587073534727097,
-0.8235604763031006,
-0.5285811424255371,
0.8908398747444153,
0.28541648387908936,
0.7352966070175171,
-0.08896134793758392,
0.27137291431427,
0.405854195356369,
0.0499238483607769,
-1.1363531351089478,
0.8087233304977417,
0.04933128133416176,
-0.2730196416378021,
-0.281724214553833,
-0.25456610321998596,
-0.47010475397109985,
0.2821424603462219,
-0.18339397013187408,
-0.8740434050559998,
0.056804556399583817,
0.016929589211940765,
-0.14263564348220825,
0.1366516798734665,
-0.6568921208381653,
0.44030797481536865,
-0.19304201006889343,
-0.3209324777126312,
-0.6085014343261719,
-0.32545363903045654,
0.22060588002204895,
0.17916543781757355,
0.39591044187545776,
-0.3204764425754547,
0.12367536872625351,
0.6601067185401917,
-0.23631997406482697,
0.8478553891181946,
-0.3610914349555969,
-0.4261481761932373,
0.6882039904594421,
0.3044637441635132,
1.0020033121109009,
-0.03331470116972923,
-0.35812175273895264,
0.12478671222925186,
0.2766714096069336,
0.12855379283428192,
-0.6275045871734619,
0.8659942746162415,
-0.445688933134079,
-0.9417523741722107,
0.026348380371928215,
-0.5930815935134888,
-0.4656945765018463,
0.16227838397026062,
-0.21065424382686615,
0.5697050094604492,
-0.245392844080925,
0.3052217364311218,
0.3149721026420593,
-0.254332959651947,
0.0174277164041996,
0.8322545289993286,
-0.12577974796295166,
-0.4788273572921753,
0.9566654562950134,
-0.07650791853666306,
0.23560106754302979,
0.5436760187149048,
0.27604591846466064,
-0.5093824863433838,
-0.8557407855987549,
-0.20380550622940063,
0.09772609174251556,
-0.9987865090370178,
-0.256157249212265,
-0.5820916295051575,
-0.07115603983402252,
-0.5691018104553223,
-0.0543108768761158,
-0.15051621198654175,
-0.05902756005525589,
-0.20617292821407318,
0.05971118435263634,
0.42275089025497437,
0.9039248824119568,
0.24407120048999786,
0.432155966758728,
-0.9405343532562256,
0.15307897329330444,
0.00594727648422122,
0.3747885227203369,
-0.03917649760842323,
-0.7783018350601196,
-0.35866686701774597,
0.45147064328193665,
-0.3121911883354187,
-0.3257303237915039,
0.29279541969299316,
0.07760220766067505,
0.6735149621963501,
0.5908688902854919,
0.15778779983520508,
0.7819934487342834,
-0.5825921297073364,
0.7569239735603333,
0.2675464451313019,
-0.5898111462593079,
0.5529877543449402,
-0.5729384422302246,
0.32081156969070435,
0.549403727054596,
0.16694365441799164,
-0.7204143404960632,
-0.46953216195106506,
-0.23112773895263672,
-0.6130726933479309,
0.787457287311554,
0.2574042081832886,
0.15307451784610748,
0.20765164494514465,
0.24713736772537231,
0.18217000365257263,
0.24554170668125153,
-0.39185622334480286,
-0.07629592716693878,
0.1617041975259781,
-0.36869534850120544,
-0.24422912299633026,
-0.38276323676109314,
-0.10774917155504227,
0.07341527193784714,
1.1474404335021973,
-0.41688233613967896,
0.24259895086288452,
0.267263799905777,
0.042008548974990845,
-0.1600855588912964,
0.39378079771995544,
0.36780303716659546,
0.4699610471725464,
-0.004516028333455324,
-0.23148538172245026,
0.3605143427848816,
-0.05425842106342316,
-0.11454381048679352,
0.01016464363783598,
0.16846469044685364,
-0.401856392621994,
0.1324312686920166,
0.591306209564209,
0.4076291024684906,
-0.9667193293571472,
0.3303152322769165,
-0.21545487642288208,
-0.00786107499152422,
-0.4194011688232422,
0.3344360888004303,
0.18204106390476227,
0.654902994632721,
0.49841660261154175,
0.12780307233333588,
0.00900984089821577,
-0.5342608690261841,
0.1220562756061554,
0.8867126107215881,
-0.8183992505073547,
-0.14864936470985413,
0.09476181119680405,
0.3504679799079895,
-0.4095710515975952,
-0.08086387068033218,
0.02911515347659588,
-0.5916786193847656,
0.22607694566249847,
0.3175746202468872,
0.3399895131587982,
-0.02610194683074951,
0.12136883288621902,
0.25162434577941895,
0.09893821179866791,
-0.35099297761917114,
0.17894761264324188,
-0.2831847071647644,
-0.8622968196868896,
-0.3302694857120514,
-0.5980995297431946,
-0.6018285155296326,
-0.1342594027519226,
-0.16532589495182037,
0.5918278694152832,
-0.24495986104011536,
-0.14279301464557648,
-0.30933281779289246,
-0.029707573354244232,
-0.7632290124893188,
0.33948013186454773,
-0.2752799689769745,
0.5285589098930359,
0.02467474341392517,
0.6027716398239136,
0.3646053075790405,
-0.15821360051631927,
-0.7944651246070862,
-0.2540018558502197,
-0.1296778917312622,
-0.9076852202415466,
0.7486796975135803,
-0.041101519018411636,
-0.49025145173072815,
0.03207011893391609,
-0.036564018577337265,
-1.1908173561096191,
1.0014787912368774,
0.4196915626525879,
-0.7861533761024475,
-0.45517343282699585,
0.1319872885942459,
0.5491203665733337,
-0.42673760652542114,
0.46590131521224976,
0.25019243359565735,
0.5338552594184875,
0.394302099943161,
-1.1303163766860962,
0.21332448720932007,
0.010558958165347576,
-0.3636179566383362,
0.18605467677116394,
-0.7897325158119202,
0.14405453205108643,
-0.3751021921634674,
-0.101646289229393,
0.16552472114562988,
0.36081111431121826,
0.13930314779281616,
0.010837017558515072,
0.4714537262916565,
0.10874703526496887,
0.4189091622829437,
-0.10864616185426712,
0.735220193862915,
-0.626531183719635,
-0.06614059209823608,
1.1337950229644775,
-0.18660150468349457,
0.6259589791297913,
0.2779771387577057,
-0.2129344344139099,
0.7803651094436646,
0.3697643578052521,
0.03844519704580307,
0.383076548576355,
0.09749819338321686,
-0.20764125883579254,
-0.3579704463481903,
-0.5409790277481079,
-0.23975124955177307,
0.49923714995384216,
0.6633425354957581,
-0.49950024485588074,
0.05671504884958267,
0.034599773585796356,
-0.2696119248867035,
-0.05497271567583084,
-0.15096890926361084,
1.0921945571899414,
0.14701983332633972,
-1.1279773712158203,
0.30461499094963074,
-0.019244030117988586,
0.7578903436660767,
-0.957136332988739,
-0.1042492464184761,
0.20995350182056427,
0.43060359358787537,
-0.17062664031982422,
-0.7266761660575867,
0.07625459134578705,
-0.21425224840641022,
-0.0006082773907110095,
-0.32845863699913025,
1.045125961303711,
-0.5734949111938477,
-0.393163800239563,
0.3837275803089142,
0.7217531800270081,
0.017898069694638252,
-0.2441135048866272,
-0.5071136951446533,
-0.2851715385913849,
0.19373096525669098,
-0.3382417559623718,
0.25964826345443726,
0.463430255651474,
0.1265481561422348,
1.2355698347091675,
0.8015068769454956,
0.3056904673576355,
-0.42414551973342896,
-0.04725596681237221,
0.9512690901756287,
-0.6133363246917725,
-0.6675177812576294,
-0.538013219833374,
0.3451727628707886,
0.14206697046756744,
0.016057433560490608,
0.9174758791923523,
0.4957786500453949,
0.6667019724845886,
0.18674476444721222,
0.9378209114074707,
0.049883585423231125,
0.5452192425727844,
-0.5177599787712097,
0.27557307481765747,
-0.20743893086910248,
0.6295159459114075,
-0.09413822740316391,
-0.9276469945907593,
-0.020659491419792175,
0.21176980435848236,
-0.6688106060028076,
0.18508698046207428,
0.6361749768257141,
0.9698953628540039,
0.17767396569252014,
0.2286754697561264,
0.3769366443157196,
-0.2911345362663269,
0.5355098843574524,
0.5156571269035339,
0.9038498401641846,
-0.13949286937713623,
1.0398153066635132,
-0.09103984385728836,
0.04210445284843445,
-0.25375235080718994,
-0.4891061782836914,
-0.9997110366821289,
-0.6455395817756653,
-0.25289878249168396,
-0.19611135125160217,
0.38270339369773865,
1.2707481384277344,
0.9027993083000183,
-0.9360930323600769,
-0.3023582696914673,
-0.18326018750667572,
0.19511710107326508,
-0.17253278195858002,
-0.26625341176986694,
0.23246730864048004,
-0.49809420108795166,
-0.658735990524292,
0.8329493999481201,
0.09542346745729446,
0.0036915706004947424,
-0.244701087474823,
-0.23608461022377014,
-0.0038787696976214647,
0.007452006451785564,
0.791347861289978,
-0.1328948736190796,
-0.7977367639541626,
-0.45400482416152954,
-0.1030259057879448,
0.07766486704349518,
-0.017422804608941078,
1.2087424993515015,
-0.8464425206184387,
0.21823041141033173,
0.3883669972419739,
0.30711719393730164,
0.37857288122177124,
0.059623826295137405,
0.835088312625885,
-0.5425410866737366,
-0.2240227460861206,
0.15506170690059662,
0.5092009902000427,
0.3108310103416443,
-0.4499513506889343,
0.31587252020835876,
-0.09184159338474274,
-0.6042753458023071,
-0.44189345836639404,
0.33079808950424194,
-0.838162362575531,
-0.2174280732870102,
1.5260294675827026,
-0.2949422299861908,
0.3824072778224945,
-0.32942694425582886,
-0.8935951590538025,
0.45057839155197144,
-1.1066908836364746,
0.5549169182777405,
0.5944548845291138,
-0.33791738748550415,
-0.08979436755180359,
-0.39092057943344116,
0.656616747379303,
0.14714676141738892,
-0.7182966470718384,
0.48431381583213806,
0.6773333549499512,
0.16685417294502258,
0.13358913362026215,
0.4637286067008972,
0.18970584869384766,
-0.25397223234176636,
-0.3946871757507324,
-0.08401130884885788,
-0.23113283514976501,
-0.24317392706871033,
0.1695648580789566,
0.40266895294189453,
0.19765515625476837,
0.17315079271793365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01858v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01858v1
|
SUKHSANDESH: An Avatar Therapeutic Question Answering Platform for Sexual Education in Rural India
| 2024-05-03T05:19:09 | 2024-05-03T05:19:09 |
Salam Michael Singh, Shubhmoy Kumar Garg, Amitesh Misra, Aaditeshwar Seth, Tanmoy Chakraborty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Sexual education aims to foster a healthy lifestyle in terms of emotional,
mental and social well-being. In countries like India, where adolescents form
the largest demographic group, they face significant vulnerabilities concerning
sexual health. Unfortunately, sexual education is often stigmatized, creating
barriers to providing essential counseling and information to this at-risk
population. Consequently, issues such as early pregnancy, unsafe abortions,
sexually transmitted infections, and sexual violence become prevalent. Our
current proposal aims to provide a safe and trustworthy platform for sexual
education to the vulnerable rural Indian population, thereby fostering the
healthy and overall growth of the nation. In this regard, we strive towards
designing SUKHSANDESH, a multi-staged AI-based Question Answering platform for
sexual education tailored to rural India, adhering to safety guardrails and
regional language support. By utilizing information retrieval techniques and
large language models, SUKHSANDESH will deliver effective responses to user
queries. We also propose to anonymise the dataset to mitigate safety measures
and set AI guardrails against any harmful or unwanted response generation.
Moreover, an innovative feature of our proposal involves integrating ``avatar
therapy'' with SUKHSANDESH. This feature will convert AI-generated responses
into real-time audio delivered by an animated avatar speaking regional Indian
languages. This approach aims to foster empathy and connection, which is
particularly beneficial for individuals with limited literacy skills.
Partnering with Gram Vaani, an industry leader, we will deploy SUKHSANDESH to
address sexual education needs in rural India.
|
[
-0.171443909406662,
-0.7330471277236938,
-0.032052889466285706,
0.33004263043403625,
-0.6227051019668579,
0.10824532806873322,
0.10508411377668381,
-0.26286280155181885,
0.5410030484199524,
0.3911151885986328,
-0.4500783085823059,
-0.22574004530906677,
-0.6032426953315735,
0.0759042426943779,
-0.41457217931747437,
0.6425852179527283,
0.18009741604328156,
0.2244039922952652,
-0.6232423782348633,
-0.09818444401025772,
-0.5205036401748657,
-0.17398682236671448,
-0.4513462483882904,
0.19271910190582275,
0.005844280123710632,
0.39227691292762756,
0.2635222375392914,
0.4140380322933197,
0.5530863404273987,
0.4174680709838867,
-0.09918370097875595,
0.06356901675462723,
-0.3485972285270691,
0.4464530050754547,
-0.16600820422172546,
-0.36489543318748474,
-0.3637138605117798,
-0.6337049007415771,
0.3892737627029419,
0.34302717447280884,
-0.6473774313926697,
0.4892747104167938,
-0.03539929911494255,
0.6655900478363037,
-0.8700760006904602,
-0.24208572506904602,
0.04058804363012314,
0.1855417937040329,
-0.6266430020332336,
-0.07000726461410522,
0.1077556237578392,
-0.42542263865470886,
-0.05847465246915817,
-0.2902432680130005,
-0.1098795160651207,
-0.1251373589038849,
0.34736597537994385,
0.2461634874343872,
-0.7648694515228271,
-0.2453724443912506,
-0.7677448391914368,
0.6181104779243469,
-0.4652426540851593,
0.41573086380958557,
0.6488890647888184,
0.6335656642913818,
-0.22121499478816986,
-0.5818103551864624,
-0.3352369964122772,
-0.08557581156492233,
-0.1188298687338829,
0.3000434935092926,
0.07864940166473389,
-0.06438034772872925,
0.013059394434094429,
0.3267146348953247,
-0.6276012659072876,
-0.24701984226703644,
-0.9445671439170837,
-0.11693284660577774,
0.7153559923171997,
0.3036451041698456,
0.7661517858505249,
-0.4177052974700928,
-0.5507608652114868,
0.301122784614563,
-0.5073443651199341,
0.4475341737270355,
0.34371820092201233,
0.022243008017539978,
-0.0853031650185585,
0.508773922920227,
-0.06530212610960007,
0.4032987654209137,
0.04406294599175453,
0.058836448937654495,
-0.23849327862262726,
-0.15558604896068573,
-0.04666908085346222,
0.20412524044513702,
0.46646633744239807,
0.5651283264160156,
-0.2457481473684311,
0.18909217417240143,
-0.07837740331888199,
0.6214786767959595,
0.4920070767402649,
-0.9279959201812744,
0.10967642813920975,
0.11401175707578659,
-0.6362773180007935,
-0.41581398248672485,
-0.669471025466919,
-1.1555638313293457,
-0.5342344641685486,
-0.16673162579536438,
0.19239601492881775,
-0.3433956801891327,
-0.6952379941940308,
-0.12492039054632187,
-0.015486751683056355,
0.32482463121414185,
0.18917161226272583,
-1.5539923906326294,
0.4781617522239685,
0.41675621271133423,
0.6428965926170349,
0.08023693412542343,
0.20976786315441132,
-0.1770387887954712,
-0.08261043578386307,
-0.25628748536109924,
0.7743207812309265,
-1.1376827955245972,
-0.829653799533844,
-0.07453993707895279,
-0.15184593200683594,
0.0013165032723918557,
-0.21010896563529968,
0.2808036804199219,
-0.5713306069374084,
-0.28779008984565735,
-0.17336545884609222,
-0.337749183177948,
0.1575191468000412,
0.4338527023792267,
0.19299806654453278,
0.817901074886322,
-0.1674254685640335,
-0.7512884736061096,
-0.07540873438119888,
-0.6543269753456116,
-0.3626305162906647,
0.4577181339263916,
-0.3691679537296295,
-0.11540280282497406,
-0.051427777856588364,
0.334462970495224,
0.31677260994911194,
-0.25674447417259216,
0.22020642459392548,
0.09603574126958847,
-0.4035627245903015,
0.0958685576915741,
-0.17723461985588074,
0.48879486322402954,
0.3068583011627197,
-0.014469001442193985,
0.434727281332016,
-0.5937848687171936,
0.08669828623533249,
-0.22055737674236298,
0.3371809422969818,
-0.7201274037361145,
-0.2876138687133789,
0.3667231798171997,
-0.034819625318050385,
0.23050525784492493,
-0.8052169680595398,
-0.06901022046804428,
-0.6802319884300232,
0.49079078435897827,
0.7929537892341614,
0.23464305698871613,
0.35792937874794006,
-0.33865728974342346,
1.16428804397583,
-0.06864261627197266,
0.5245888233184814,
0.10175078362226486,
-0.4145669639110565,
-0.3400645852088928,
-0.04755200445652008,
0.16510863602161407,
0.40743517875671387,
-1.0027621984481812,
-0.3054984211921692,
0.0658247098326683,
-0.8208103179931641,
-0.5476428866386414,
0.07903771102428436,
0.585812509059906,
0.4638139009475708,
0.2790910303592682,
-0.5605079531669617,
-0.46876201033592224,
-0.8774639368057251,
-0.13572430610656738,
0.029667828232049942,
0.13851869106292725,
0.16662797331809998,
0.5158931612968445,
-0.14716960489749908,
0.5483015179634094,
-0.27641594409942627,
-0.41725799441337585,
-0.09078701585531235,
0.09687279164791107,
-0.2886189818382263,
0.5003378987312317,
0.5034356713294983,
-1.287007212638855,
-0.9694732427597046,
-0.024849798530340195,
-0.7473071813583374,
0.13356737792491913,
0.24003781378269196,
-0.24783065915107727,
-0.22606322169303894,
0.3122064769268036,
-0.5982472896575928,
0.8139711022377014,
0.4459596574306488,
-0.17110459506511688,
0.673166036605835,
-0.4197394847869873,
0.47680068016052246,
-1.2094106674194336,
0.012315676547586918,
-0.4168151915073395,
0.13327756524085999,
-0.6818906664848328,
0.1601390540599823,
-0.19526900351047516,
-0.4774946868419647,
-0.5369985103607178,
0.3931519389152527,
0.08557909727096558,
-0.049456723034381866,
-0.416429340839386,
0.29193708300590515,
-0.5923755168914795,
0.3215382397174835,
-0.28171244263648987,
1.2600197792053223,
0.8113041520118713,
-0.5435003638267517,
0.5373417735099792,
0.8366166353225708,
0.1548904925584793,
1.2519593238830566,
-0.7997745275497437,
0.2533316910266876,
-0.3035375475883484,
0.34559905529022217,
-0.47643420100212097,
-0.56675785779953,
0.23744502663612366,
-0.9079581499099731,
-0.07751048356294632,
-0.020860746502876282,
0.17238150537014008,
0.01421284582465887,
-0.3501597046852112,
0.7514356970787048,
0.5429638624191284,
-0.2409648448228836,
0.7311042547225952,
0.6226614713668823,
-0.45698511600494385,
-0.921884298324585,
-0.17359143495559692,
0.08544669300317764,
-0.37459808588027954,
-0.3870490789413452,
-0.16316518187522888,
0.030498897656798363,
-0.23098349571228027,
0.25373324751853943,
-0.36441701650619507,
-0.27585792541503906,
-0.09670460224151611,
0.6365528106689453,
0.13753171265125275,
0.052063118666410446,
0.2666875720024109,
0.48829686641693115,
-0.5082777142524719,
0.16310343146324158,
0.13466928899288177,
0.3356621265411377,
-0.3095683455467224,
-0.31101104617118835,
-0.4673214256763458,
0.9342839121818542,
0.3584859371185303,
-0.5188285112380981,
0.6592242121696472,
0.49589255452156067,
-0.5880852341651917,
-0.06359615921974182,
-0.028851203620433807,
-0.34526365995407104,
-0.5128046274185181,
0.21617251634597778,
-0.04859429970383644,
-0.8135017156600952,
0.1531817466020584,
-0.40303555130958557,
-0.049575041979551315,
0.2747483253479004,
0.38004016876220703,
-0.32044586539268494,
0.9992096424102783,
0.7797127962112427,
0.5974606871604919,
-0.12957467138767242,
-0.01467039156705141,
0.42889851331710815,
-0.7494435906410217,
-0.35566866397857666,
-0.11951698362827301,
-0.39750275015830994,
-0.6609172821044922,
-0.2762213349342346,
0.29215729236602783,
-0.08179033547639847,
-0.3497510850429535,
0.19954510033130646,
-0.8467276096343994,
0.31119444966316223,
0.516638994216919,
0.11717776209115982,
0.012958788312971592,
-0.3042181730270386,
-0.24405953288078308,
-0.5902466773986816,
-0.320603609085083,
-0.7668560743331909,
0.9532491564750671,
-0.22524391114711761,
0.5758687257766724,
0.33116415143013,
0.4004960358142853,
0.47067615389823914,
0.6895870566368103,
-0.3201747238636017,
0.7114812731742859,
-0.3348010778427124,
-0.7741075158119202,
-0.2782774567604065,
-0.11569970101118088,
-0.9291682243347168,
0.14824151992797852,
-0.3545825183391571,
-0.8489883542060852,
0.1132357269525528,
0.021567407995462418,
-0.6383076906204224,
0.1930193305015564,
-0.3176058530807495,
0.4908839762210846,
-0.12350267171859741,
-0.36423125863075256,
-0.4129931628704071,
-1.0445359945297241,
0.5338781476020813,
-0.09478997439146042,
0.27080634236335754,
-0.1779487431049347,
0.21819882094860077,
0.7070869207382202,
-0.4202621579170227,
0.7531527876853943,
-0.2271547019481659,
0.4298849403858185,
0.06486700475215912,
-0.013025709427893162,
-0.14594459533691406,
0.4115431606769562,
0.26199865341186523,
-0.0667257085442543,
0.5142512321472168,
-0.4383981227874756,
-0.6424256563186646,
0.9484239220619202,
-0.9998060464859009,
-0.7043645977973938,
-0.7117074728012085,
-0.23476414382457733,
-0.3583635091781616,
0.32793542742729187,
0.08876945078372955,
0.6060333847999573,
0.10708283632993698,
0.4566391706466675,
0.6003411412239075,
-0.3257024884223938,
0.06948548555374146,
0.12441956251859665,
-0.5550627112388611,
-0.500159502029419,
0.7654968500137329,
-0.09282234311103821,
0.07152197510004044,
-0.12326830625534058,
0.050820108503103256,
-0.6869953274726868,
-0.1271349936723709,
-0.7372602224349976,
0.06277444958686829,
-0.7859774231910706,
-0.23280665278434753,
-0.5220898985862732,
-0.6132410168647766,
-0.44599637389183044,
-0.46439236402511597,
-0.5090847015380859,
-0.09617473185062408,
0.22091351449489594,
-0.2232844978570938,
0.5711123943328857,
0.7991522550582886,
-0.17201299965381622,
0.3454737067222595,
-0.9396319389343262,
0.45502611994743347,
0.7609447240829468,
0.3975697159767151,
-0.22278887033462524,
-0.1240914836525917,
0.26436716318130493,
0.23671913146972656,
-0.39770516753196716,
-0.5168647170066833,
0.38905128836631775,
0.1589459329843521,
0.07386866211891174,
0.4696173369884491,
0.5335516929626465,
0.8267379403114319,
-0.21916736662387848,
0.7838099002838135,
0.20039726793766022,
-0.6503774523735046,
0.9084641933441162,
-0.27690592408180237,
0.0832170769572258,
0.5871335864067078,
0.4947177767753601,
-0.9001812934875488,
-0.09334456920623779,
-0.40537557005882263,
-0.8729920387268066,
0.4559268653392792,
0.5928651094436646,
0.6489614248275757,
0.050966776907444,
0.4812457263469696,
0.26582038402557373,
0.36247530579566956,
-0.3939906358718872,
-0.4553360641002655,
-0.2949244976043701,
-0.12149159610271454,
0.1922745704650879,
-0.5125882625579834,
-0.42054107785224915,
-0.06965240091085434,
0.6249321103096008,
0.3869888484477997,
0.2774198353290558,
0.13976280391216278,
0.2798795998096466,
-0.21756993234157562,
0.5010506510734558,
0.7039984464645386,
0.730438768863678,
0.04180041328072548,
0.11636891961097717,
0.3337710201740265,
-1.0369269847869873,
0.5090696215629578,
-0.160635843873024,
-0.20815342664718628,
-0.2210347205400467,
-0.030816104263067245,
0.5429452657699585,
0.2283424437046051,
-0.6431617736816406,
0.49004024267196655,
-0.4722820222377777,
-0.04055362939834595,
-0.5803883075714111,
0.1239510178565979,
0.17002572119235992,
0.27989766001701355,
0.19413913786411285,
0.3930264711380005,
0.141143798828125,
-0.02740711346268654,
0.25788331031799316,
0.12619073688983917,
-0.7551237940788269,
-0.27515169978141785,
1.2229281663894653,
0.37209904193878174,
-0.9613432288169861,
0.6489631533622742,
0.07518234103918076,
-0.2712263762950897,
0.8011629581451416,
0.4872501790523529,
0.4854238033294678,
-0.5928658246994019,
0.5921108722686768,
0.44631192088127136,
0.11370308697223663,
0.19187036156654358,
0.5077962875366211,
-0.10750053822994232,
-0.1946946084499359,
-0.2062959522008896,
-0.8499002456665039,
-0.43396857380867004,
-0.1346638798713684,
-0.6376749873161316,
0.16885504126548767,
-0.712851881980896,
-0.26707255840301514,
-0.48361989855766296,
-0.2264339178800583,
-0.11970934271812439,
0.3746585249900818,
-0.17625224590301514,
0.7376453876495361,
-0.8301643133163452,
0.4337638318538666,
1.045069694519043,
-0.3774453103542328,
-0.773321807384491,
-0.2593083381652832,
-0.014375239610671997,
-0.4878057539463043,
0.46189388632774353,
0.22392681241035461,
-0.48218730092048645,
0.13164514303207397,
-0.451259046792984,
-0.8433318734169006,
1.0228345394134521,
0.10172252357006073,
-0.28787779808044434,
0.4499748647212982,
0.3127202093601227,
0.7838405966758728,
-0.18495617806911469,
0.29934340715408325,
0.29442164301872253,
0.1224140003323555,
0.46124422550201416,
-0.7486684322357178,
-0.0930933728814125,
-0.7689213752746582,
0.47187280654907227,
0.3131471872329712,
-0.5903103351593018,
0.39249828457832336,
0.1170606017112732,
-0.2216147631406784,
0.1952441930770874,
0.4659331738948822,
0.4812541902065277,
0.4894087612628937,
0.5130236148834229,
0.3235751986503601,
0.28896063566207886,
0.24531416594982147,
0.6395277976989746,
-0.3010726273059845,
0.12277969717979431,
0.612135648727417,
0.10438679903745651,
1.002050757408142,
0.5507940649986267,
-0.19670899212360382,
0.20883871614933014,
0.7471465468406677,
0.5668240189552307,
0.6319181323051453,
0.10157796740531921,
-0.5391727089881897,
-0.32310616970062256,
-0.7374674081802368,
-0.8750838041305542,
0.9570984840393066,
0.5112058520317078,
0.35208943486213684,
-0.3759109675884247,
0.5215011239051819,
-0.41060805320739746,
0.6868215203285217,
-0.21735790371894836,
0.25023290514945984,
0.35475215315818787,
-0.1434335857629776,
0.07981815934181213,
-0.061453476548194885,
0.4472111165523529,
-0.7477795481681824,
-0.3184049725532532,
-0.4697358012199402,
0.2500971853733063,
-0.13922184705734253,
-0.34158483147621155,
0.5565990209579468,
0.06221719831228256,
0.522506594657898,
-0.4405108690261841,
1.1088520288467407,
-0.4770984351634979,
-0.6095758676528931,
-0.18161991238594055,
0.06752359122037888,
0.25365450978279114,
0.459200918674469,
-0.5614470839500427,
-0.11903766542673111,
-0.5310524106025696,
0.361818790435791,
0.5612263679504395,
0.17915788292884827,
-0.33316507935523987,
1.0244284868240356,
0.7905159592628479,
0.14275652170181274,
-0.27827900648117065,
-0.37527599930763245,
0.7908703088760376,
-0.3791466951370239,
-0.905224621295929,
-0.44766634702682495,
0.49709171056747437,
-0.21338501572608948,
-0.45337429642677307,
0.9911924600601196,
0.13375483453273773,
0.36387497186660767,
-0.015511310659348965,
0.48881787061691284,
-0.1900498867034912,
0.3818294107913971,
0.1310255378484726,
1.1144084930419922,
-0.6632192134857178,
0.2114621251821518,
0.05974750220775604,
-0.6956740617752075,
-0.4396803081035614,
0.666257917881012,
-0.3041572570800781,
-0.08802689611911774,
0.21852047741413116,
0.7957786321640015,
0.15770076215267181,
0.38870152831077576,
0.3847372829914093,
0.1304200291633606,
0.13003087043762207,
0.18028970062732697,
1.2272058725357056,
-0.33477604389190674,
0.29004812240600586,
-0.3157559633255005,
-0.2345074713230133,
-0.2004212588071823,
-0.4436721205711365,
-0.6626176238059998,
-0.6497914791107178,
-0.053088873624801636,
0.12007386237382889,
0.26995375752449036,
1.1504664421081543,
0.3153547942638397,
-0.6481226086616516,
-0.22096411883831024,
-0.09191875904798508,
-0.23731696605682373,
-0.15334928035736084,
-0.15225814282894135,
0.572808563709259,
0.26171088218688965,
-0.38149845600128174,
0.14840063452720642,
0.7378059029579163,
-0.3235723376274109,
-0.6286186575889587,
0.24483977258205414,
-0.4151495695114136,
0.1803760677576065,
0.25195086002349854,
0.3947107493877411,
-0.32554885745048523,
-0.24557451903820038,
0.1924535036087036,
-0.14455316960811615,
-0.20255136489868164,
0.3940025269985199,
-0.48928505182266235,
0.8607574701309204,
0.01985342428088188,
0.9326614737510681,
0.2900368273258209,
-0.09561732411384583,
0.4991133511066437,
-0.5049095749855042,
0.2343018501996994,
0.3442103862762451,
-0.1987101286649704,
0.2804848849773407,
-0.7210573554039001,
0.2693917751312256,
0.20495712757110596,
-0.6584023833274841,
-0.8198426961898804,
0.2537596523761749,
-0.42951998114585876,
0.13519160449504852,
0.7143880128860474,
-0.22941915690898895,
-0.48182055354118347,
-0.39280831813812256,
-0.6915319561958313,
0.23718097805976868,
-0.07158607244491577,
1.219278335571289,
0.4676683247089386,
-0.16459377110004425,
-0.24009893834590912,
-0.9247767925262451,
0.7217864394187927,
0.5672847628593445,
-0.8097761869430542,
-0.19027817249298096,
0.055354174226522446,
0.18290193378925323,
-0.25014978647232056,
1.0479682683944702,
-0.041225288063287735,
0.5042948126792908,
0.1267753541469574,
-0.19466084241867065,
0.12504173815250397,
-0.16726283729076385,
-0.019262289628386497,
0.04330877587199211,
-0.4340038597583771,
-0.5157858729362488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02363v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02363v1
|
LLM as Dataset Analyst: Subpopulation Structure Discovery with Large Language Model
| 2024-05-03T05:09:54 | 2024-05-03T05:09:54 |
Yulin Luo, Ruichuan An, Bocheng Zou, Yiming Tang, Jiaming Liu, Shanghang Zhang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
The distribution of subpopulations is an important property hidden within a
dataset. Uncovering and analyzing the subpopulation distribution within
datasets provides a comprehensive understanding of the datasets, standing as a
powerful tool beneficial to various downstream tasks, including Dataset
Subpopulation Organization, Subpopulation Shift, and Slice Discovery. Despite
its importance, there has been no work that systematically explores the
subpopulation distribution of datasets to our knowledge. To address the
limitation and solve all the mentioned tasks in a unified way, we introduce a
novel concept of subpopulation structures to represent, analyze, and utilize
subpopulation distributions within datasets. To characterize the structures in
an interpretable manner, we propose the Subpopulation Structure Discovery with
Large Language Models (SSD-LLM) framework, which employs world knowledge and
instruction-following capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) to
linguistically analyze informative image captions and summarize the structures.
Furthermore, we propose complete workflows to address downstream tasks, named
Task-specific Tuning, showcasing the application of the discovered structure to
a spectrum of subpopulation-related tasks, including dataset subpopulation
organization, subpopulation shift, and slice discovery. Furthermore, we propose
complete workflows to address downstream tasks, named Task-specific Tuning,
showcasing the application of the discovered structure to a spectrum of
subpopulation-related tasks, including dataset subpopulation organization,
subpopulation shift, and slice discovery.
|
[
-0.4280937612056732,
-0.7702150344848633,
0.19966518878936768,
-0.16195937991142273,
-0.2573605179786682,
0.19192452728748322,
0.0004278809064999223,
-0.17180773615837097,
0.27916085720062256,
0.516105055809021,
-1.009853720664978,
-0.7188431024551392,
-0.4454091191291809,
-0.0777667909860611,
-0.48098281025886536,
0.6053873896598816,
0.06723561137914658,
-0.07472237199544907,
-0.44088014960289,
0.20486262440681458,
-0.24028153717517853,
-0.44840291142463684,
-0.33244210481643677,
-0.3297220766544342,
0.3379586935043335,
0.4482306241989136,
0.5256247520446777,
1.1055976152420044,
0.6561785936355591,
0.27658510208129883,
-0.385132759809494,
0.09554120153188705,
-0.7694457769393921,
0.0566127747297287,
-0.13529294729232788,
-0.5620675683021545,
-0.26317328214645386,
-0.27434679865837097,
0.6941962838172913,
1.0197572708129883,
-0.026210425421595573,
0.23965014517307281,
-0.27825167775154114,
0.8006165623664856,
-0.20166808366775513,
0.45534220337867737,
-0.5630456805229187,
0.3022339940071106,
-0.7844213843345642,
-0.26014190912246704,
-0.2913404107093811,
0.12354118376970291,
0.024316471070051193,
-0.28803884983062744,
0.4739663600921631,
0.327483206987381,
0.5083004832267761,
0.5075680017471313,
-0.29748180508613586,
0.13578274846076965,
-0.3840285837650299,
0.7525871396064758,
-0.3422686457633972,
0.2672331631183624,
0.10572554916143417,
0.22716763615608215,
-0.5545333027839661,
0.01666375622153282,
-0.1429169625043869,
-0.06898172199726105,
-0.04297885671257973,
-0.0860864520072937,
-0.08298508077859879,
-0.002417839365079999,
0.21678747236728668,
0.6631529331207275,
-0.6196412444114685,
0.6145057082176208,
-0.3224422037601471,
-0.23874397575855255,
0.7253493070602417,
0.21532143652439117,
0.6088993549346924,
-0.16504624485969543,
-0.24459876120090485,
0.19811667501926422,
-0.9985858201980591,
-0.20378006994724274,
0.43215304613113403,
0.44291406869888306,
-0.38937416672706604,
0.8740140795707703,
-0.20717719197273254,
0.3724740147590637,
-0.3684252202510834,
-0.2422337681055069,
0.4288189113140106,
-0.3412598669528961,
-0.2354673147201538,
-0.12087362259626389,
0.3885135352611542,
0.08229710906744003,
0.6139234304428101,
0.17103241384029388,
-0.06552152335643768,
-0.10177183896303177,
0.009963714517652988,
-0.447487473487854,
-0.36523374915122986,
0.18778695166110992,
-0.711133599281311,
-0.3658885657787323,
-0.1933896392583847,
-0.45114555954933167,
-0.4576267600059509,
-0.2720464766025543,
-0.38769328594207764,
-0.288338303565979,
-0.620171070098877,
-0.15581679344177246,
0.004331538919359446,
0.2030433714389801,
0.18020285665988922,
-1.022265076637268,
0.1952473670244217,
0.7222794890403748,
0.8320268392562866,
-0.6117737293243408,
-0.2814876437187195,
-0.14292925596237183,
0.13829925656318665,
-0.5565032958984375,
1.0998663902282715,
-0.6532984972000122,
-0.121211938560009,
-0.14468887448310852,
0.26002568006515503,
-0.31234994530677795,
-0.7791149020195007,
0.21115055680274963,
-0.43175098299980164,
-0.367178738117218,
-0.025851167738437653,
-0.8005616068840027,
-0.10679396986961365,
0.0024703633971512318,
-0.9301005005836487,
1.0556055307388306,
0.19588761031627655,
-0.846538245677948,
0.31189754605293274,
-0.8817089796066284,
-0.4164416491985321,
0.47508296370506287,
-0.23254986107349396,
-0.28291410207748413,
0.33277344703674316,
0.386268675327301,
0.5844078063964844,
-0.2264632284641266,
0.16551309823989868,
-0.22943443059921265,
-0.2558116316795349,
-0.005667496472597122,
-0.009620774537324905,
0.7629339694976807,
0.10362134873867035,
0.015186192467808723,
0.06815230846405029,
-0.2901703417301178,
-0.25073644518852234,
0.0010106037370860577,
-0.08806441724300385,
-0.30865225195884705,
0.16329772770404816,
-0.015021131373941898,
-0.17341938614845276,
0.1914721131324768,
-0.2759506404399872,
0.4253949224948883,
-0.23908519744873047,
0.2788485288619995,
0.6278682947158813,
0.24351264536380768,
0.5685504078865051,
-0.11724767088890076,
0.7977636456489563,
0.5268377661705017,
0.26551011204719543,
-0.288631796836853,
-0.2597685158252716,
-0.31762728095054626,
-0.6011579036712646,
0.20908568799495697,
0.6768893599510193,
-0.5460693836212158,
0.43422257900238037,
-0.3150629997253418,
-0.4455799162387848,
-0.41101330518722534,
0.24499696493148804,
0.2881912291049957,
0.44646480679512024,
0.09570407122373581,
-0.11994855850934982,
-0.7968851327896118,
-1.4233033657073975,
0.23829326033592224,
0.148018941283226,
0.3124825954437256,
0.08554397523403168,
0.6322946548461914,
-0.4935256838798523,
0.7233691811561584,
-0.6519885063171387,
-0.4656802713871002,
-0.7833252549171448,
-0.11820247024297714,
0.3353728652000427,
0.4687894582748413,
0.49047768115997314,
-0.8660162091255188,
-0.24125026166439056,
-0.05866970494389534,
-0.554299533367157,
-0.2786152958869934,
0.19414488971233368,
-0.27191007137298584,
0.3203604817390442,
0.7050445079803467,
-0.46140551567077637,
0.3357500731945038,
0.43195152282714844,
0.2087440937757492,
0.4322430193424225,
0.12162544578313828,
-0.2722034454345703,
-1.1783673763275146,
-0.2896336019039154,
0.0733516663312912,
-0.003047356614843011,
-0.4247559607028961,
0.16346769034862518,
-0.039560891687870026,
0.2048404961824417,
-0.40229225158691406,
0.19677193462848663,
-0.7133920788764954,
-0.7641281485557556,
-0.05753294378519058,
-0.08878295123577118,
-0.5140471458435059,
0.24133464694023132,
0.18672727048397064,
0.6381082534790039,
0.9419363737106323,
-0.4063318073749542,
0.4386986494064331,
0.35804206132888794,
-0.8821712732315063,
0.3778112828731537,
-0.286037415266037,
-0.3430097699165344,
-0.3547583222389221,
0.39276641607284546,
-1.1069451570510864,
-0.34365442395210266,
-0.12157469242811203,
-0.14658227562904358,
0.06842498481273651,
-0.5950666666030884,
-0.6441430449485779,
-0.28077441453933716,
-0.13912591338157654,
0.2598806619644165,
0.25900813937187195,
-0.4026123583316803,
0.27881473302841187,
0.9313600659370422,
-0.30685949325561523,
-0.451801598072052,
-0.6881076097488403,
-0.0982053354382515,
-0.25747403502464294,
-0.8616443276405334,
0.18125700950622559,
-0.06637882441282272,
-0.27479326725006104,
-0.061494696885347366,
-0.23288296163082123,
0.15111365914344788,
0.16265766322612762,
0.3328564763069153,
0.34782135486602783,
-0.3034918010234833,
0.19563736021518707,
0.11000881344079971,
-0.23275890946388245,
-0.1606849730014801,
-0.14616528153419495,
0.6472349762916565,
0.16327206790447235,
-0.19041569530963898,
-0.1958075761795044,
0.44765183329582214,
0.5586705207824707,
-0.2387695610523224,
0.7211936712265015,
0.3821617066860199,
-0.40071362257003784,
-0.4871600568294525,
-0.32603952288627625,
0.09742481261491776,
-0.40542715787887573,
0.6918278932571411,
-0.5547805428504944,
-0.8119705319404602,
0.6810286641120911,
-0.3615419268608093,
0.0793507844209671,
0.3184029459953308,
0.6694011092185974,
-0.20581547915935516,
1.0961904525756836,
0.8372254371643066,
-0.29247528314590454,
0.6473590731620789,
-0.46776828169822693,
0.22797097265720367,
-0.9941829442977905,
-0.36741548776626587,
-0.31771227717399597,
-0.5145434141159058,
-0.5062975287437439,
-0.6350929141044617,
0.39968642592430115,
-0.1671561896800995,
0.019330475479364395,
0.09701737016439438,
-0.2482517957687378,
0.7314903140068054,
0.4262467324733734,
-0.17768223583698273,
0.2624298334121704,
0.39372116327285767,
-0.30670279264450073,
-0.0744457021355629,
-0.5079067945480347,
-0.3763037621974945,
0.7251858115196228,
0.3613615930080414,
1.070887804031372,
-0.012977013364434242,
0.8700272440910339,
0.4738800823688507,
0.3540648818016052,
-1.0519382953643799,
0.7089053392410278,
-0.5238102674484253,
-0.3472677767276764,
-0.43442100286483765,
-0.5655462145805359,
-0.944678008556366,
0.23531833291053772,
-0.012259693816304207,
-0.7106395363807678,
0.0832386165857315,
0.12986552715301514,
0.1826898455619812,
0.2878773808479309,
-0.7697128653526306,
0.8804038763046265,
-0.25610142946243286,
0.22459664940834045,
0.007268256042152643,
-0.44570285081863403,
0.486950546503067,
-0.02264985628426075,
0.6199139952659607,
-0.3083517849445343,
-0.04628681764006615,
0.6117128729820251,
-0.2442736178636551,
0.8433770537376404,
-0.15498566627502441,
-0.41845613718032837,
-0.01990903727710247,
0.24458032846450806,
0.45814570784568787,
-0.20177853107452393,
-0.011830502189695835,
-0.04516523331403732,
0.023172304034233093,
-0.30111145973205566,
-0.5075526833534241,
0.7368083596229553,
-0.7626221776008606,
-0.41339293122291565,
-0.17659039795398712,
-1.0197041034698486,
0.053452033549547195,
0.162720188498497,
0.1958993375301361,
0.3344626724720001,
-0.0492081493139267,
0.36471450328826904,
0.8104611039161682,
-0.012595048174262047,
0.13927331566810608,
0.4088518023490906,
-0.30359983444213867,
0.040186524391174316,
0.6384743452072144,
0.21090415120124817,
0.14476481080055237,
0.8000101447105408,
0.1313294768333435,
-0.5936278700828552,
-0.9507468938827515,
-0.3834797739982605,
0.2984544038772583,
-0.6145625114440918,
-0.0925217866897583,
-0.4808216094970703,
-0.3119482696056366,
-0.40260225534439087,
-0.03173963725566864,
-0.2568231225013733,
-0.318413108587265,
-0.15712545812129974,
-0.5275458693504333,
0.3120580017566681,
0.6658254265785217,
0.08704997599124908,
0.18750178813934326,
-0.5614843368530273,
0.4453757703304291,
-0.21133965253829956,
0.1246960386633873,
-0.13678717613220215,
-0.42208191752433777,
-0.38464856147766113,
0.08789802342653275,
0.2879002094268799,
-0.7167885899543762,
0.5119813084602356,
0.11284609138965607,
0.8651065826416016,
0.17626027762889862,
-0.1135304793715477,
0.7309277057647705,
-0.31573525071144104,
0.4910000264644623,
-0.21094004809856415,
-0.6656602025032043,
0.5697139501571655,
-0.35959669947624207,
0.22825761139392853,
0.19679775834083557,
0.3388752043247223,
-0.48979294300079346,
-0.2388828992843628,
-0.44224312901496887,
-1.098646640777588,
0.8565464019775391,
-0.07550814002752304,
-0.11145097017288208,
0.26343104243278503,
0.23816776275634766,
0.15491406619548798,
0.1750376671552658,
-0.6863732933998108,
-0.26656052470207214,
0.1464226096868515,
-0.3786170482635498,
-0.13678154349327087,
-0.04005980119109154,
-0.28743770718574524,
-0.17282618582248688,
0.5502015352249146,
-0.35167965292930603,
-0.19040650129318237,
-0.16240555047988892,
-0.43956977128982544,
-0.3103089928627014,
0.2937420904636383,
0.2882327735424042,
0.6716898083686829,
-0.15947292745113373,
0.2566741406917572,
-0.12261536717414856,
-0.5200883746147156,
0.04922458902001381,
0.011793013662099838,
-0.38416221737861633,
-0.3187965154647827,
0.6110734939575195,
0.7289451956748962,
0.18208517134189606,
-0.8030921816825867,
0.19475223124027252,
0.24909751117229462,
-0.2968985438346863,
-0.4639860689640045,
0.3067951202392578,
0.46616077423095703,
0.41675567626953125,
0.6247320175170898,
-0.2700660526752472,
-0.037988901138305664,
-0.665618360042572,
0.2953025996685028,
0.558681070804596,
-0.06588885188102722,
-0.09930671751499176,
0.08078712970018387,
-0.05561791732907295,
-0.03695729747414589,
0.8329119682312012,
0.09306696802377701,
-0.4264528155326843,
1.08669912815094,
0.4862995743751526,
0.6256064772605896,
-0.0714283362030983,
0.6367868781089783,
-0.049802955240011215,
0.47785553336143494,
-0.1291835904121399,
0.3775283694267273,
0.07233580201864243,
-0.8923643827438354,
-0.49853476881980896,
-0.7196102738380432,
-0.34578490257263184,
0.3165685832500458,
-0.5862014889717102,
0.03101687878370285,
-0.019691210240125656,
0.40258508920669556,
0.17484578490257263,
-0.015548677183687687,
-0.36717382073402405,
0.12759080529212952,
0.2415151298046112,
0.9977497458457947,
-1.0886149406433105,
0.7731018662452698,
0.9207190871238708,
-0.08153053373098373,
-0.6430078744888306,
-0.16548795998096466,
0.2261444330215454,
-0.9909069538116455,
0.8272585272789001,
0.04496878758072853,
0.08127916604280472,
0.09455955773591995,
-0.7160109877586365,
-1.2261013984680176,
1.0955530405044556,
0.4418708086013794,
-0.639389157295227,
0.23184674978256226,
0.2323070764541626,
0.7094940543174744,
-0.898912787437439,
-0.004045622423291206,
0.6540168523788452,
0.4442845582962036,
0.4057667851448059,
-0.579849362373352,
0.07716488838195801,
-0.3213559091091156,
0.2614942491054535,
0.4228294789791107,
-0.40192708373069763,
0.8438689112663269,
-0.40742599964141846,
-0.3498130142688751,
-0.06281658262014389,
0.4258303642272949,
0.4576829671859741,
0.013329300098121166,
0.6321954727172852,
0.464966744184494,
0.6456910967826843,
-0.031726736575365067,
0.8417493104934692,
-0.043905116617679596,
0.4186886250972748,
0.8015173077583313,
-0.382662296295166,
0.8339346647262573,
0.3985257148742676,
-0.24366948008537292,
0.40034082531929016,
1.0939875841140747,
-0.20168016850948334,
0.4813668727874756,
0.6174830794334412,
0.13561347126960754,
-0.43821024894714355,
-0.27293434739112854,
-0.262499064207077,
0.3182419240474701,
0.6976304054260254,
-0.374576210975647,
-0.39163151383399963,
-0.14454707503318787,
-0.2983698546886444,
-0.25338587164878845,
-0.3637317717075348,
0.5634399652481079,
-0.031045760959386826,
-0.4512808918952942,
0.5358049869537354,
-0.28591829538345337,
0.4486919939517975,
-0.5920321941375732,
0.014505289494991302,
-0.5904096364974976,
0.07849282771348953,
-0.5298725366592407,
-0.8349665403366089,
0.2191915214061737,
-0.1613600254058838,
-0.396088570356369,
-0.35763975977897644,
0.5965169072151184,
-0.4477526843547821,
-0.6148717999458313,
0.21366550028324127,
0.7612854838371277,
0.47871941328048706,
0.08357461541891098,
-0.5514071583747864,
0.2779194116592407,
0.11077775806188583,
-0.37802278995513916,
0.38758400082588196,
0.42901846766471863,
-0.4625667631626129,
0.8465315103530884,
0.6892685294151306,
0.1786016821861267,
0.18552783131599426,
0.5653371810913086,
0.8003708720207214,
-0.6194856762886047,
-0.4953099489212036,
-0.6452251076698303,
0.29503920674324036,
-0.07252203673124313,
0.21080565452575684,
0.6246395111083984,
0.9364309310913086,
0.8133252859115601,
-0.33575934171676636,
1.095935583114624,
-0.18733461201190948,
0.7027771472930908,
-0.6514008045196533,
0.2679700255393982,
-0.4800739288330078,
0.5359718799591064,
-0.1095370277762413,
-0.9245109558105469,
-0.3105456829071045,
0.5289596915245056,
-0.5040868520736694,
-0.26237016916275024,
0.6790462732315063,
1.0559886693954468,
-0.29210418462753296,
-0.06574122607707977,
0.10007294267416,
0.5482257008552551,
0.2555120885372162,
0.31381961703300476,
0.8791730403900146,
0.20458775758743286,
0.571607232093811,
-0.16880075633525848,
-0.3854391574859619,
-0.2368672639131546,
-0.8106538653373718,
-0.9546390175819397,
-0.6891635060310364,
-0.32017502188682556,
0.3828069269657135,
-0.1347236931324005,
0.743030309677124,
0.8638647198677063,
-0.7995482087135315,
-0.39675983786582947,
-0.24339209496974945,
0.38531485199928284,
-0.3763783872127533,
-0.32235825061798096,
0.44667482376098633,
-0.07878777384757996,
-0.8012910485267639,
0.5770578980445862,
0.48079460859298706,
0.198381245136261,
-0.5201765894889832,
0.36439192295074463,
-0.17946648597717285,
-0.19356447458267212,
0.506137490272522,
0.15835829079151154,
-0.5134907960891724,
0.07335922122001648,
-0.026833077892661095,
0.13386745750904083,
-0.02491549402475357,
0.9171019196510315,
-0.35309410095214844,
-0.06481512635946274,
0.6675606966018677,
0.482420951128006,
0.5771369934082031,
0.08683541417121887,
0.526262640953064,
-0.9940804243087769,
0.09502371400594711,
0.0034699204843491316,
0.5021042823791504,
0.39014509320259094,
-0.5289803743362427,
0.7246821522712708,
0.1914462447166443,
-0.1552373319864273,
-0.8865914344787598,
0.6825438141822815,
-1.0208595991134644,
-0.24411453306674957,
1.0587445497512817,
0.07215539366006851,
-0.4337717592716217,
-0.3267567753791809,
-0.28589171171188354,
-0.040720537304878235,
-0.3157670199871063,
0.6343722343444824,
0.5917510986328125,
-0.5542624592781067,
-0.6478683352470398,
-0.47446367144584656,
0.41568756103515625,
0.1292804628610611,
-1.1674710512161255,
0.3141085207462311,
0.616255521774292,
0.39541560411453247,
0.17340321838855743,
0.5178925395011902,
-0.17550130188465118,
-0.3151555061340332,
-0.29858529567718506,
-0.14654108881950378,
-0.15271669626235962,
-0.398652583360672,
0.2087029069662094,
0.24204972386360168,
-0.43525975942611694,
-0.18815533816814423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01842v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01842v1
|
SGHateCheck: Functional Tests for Detecting Hate Speech in Low-Resource Languages of Singapore
| 2024-05-03T04:18:10 | 2024-05-03T04:18:10 |
Ri Chi Ng, Nirmalendu Prakash, Ming Shan Hee, Kenny Tsu Wei Choo, Roy Ka-Wei Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To address the limitations of current hate speech detection models, we
introduce \textsf{SGHateCheck}, a novel framework designed for the linguistic
and cultural context of Singapore and Southeast Asia. It extends the functional
testing approach of HateCheck and MHC, employing large language models for
translation and paraphrasing into Singapore's main languages, and refining
these with native annotators. \textsf{SGHateCheck} reveals critical flaws in
state-of-the-art models, highlighting their inadequacy in sensitive content
moderation. This work aims to foster the development of more effective hate
speech detection tools for diverse linguistic environments, particularly for
Singapore and Southeast Asia contexts.
|
[
-0.32610955834388733,
-0.9621641635894775,
0.07650552690029144,
0.047971487045288086,
-0.3871046304702759,
0.14272691309452057,
-0.2522061765193939,
-0.552501916885376,
0.635704517364502,
0.746096134185791,
-0.6381477117538452,
-0.39227592945098877,
-0.47394537925720215,
0.09686627238988876,
-0.7077257037162781,
0.9656535983085632,
0.09530960768461227,
0.10778350383043289,
0.2507181167602539,
-0.3986411988735199,
0.25437548756599426,
-0.6674686670303345,
-0.6120150089263916,
0.18710492551326752,
0.49294939637184143,
0.6162786483764648,
0.8125595450401306,
0.2971673309803009,
0.7098049521446228,
0.1672743707895279,
-0.043071892112493515,
-0.3119565546512604,
-0.6088663935661316,
0.41711094975471497,
-0.20446011424064636,
-0.5379751324653625,
0.019684959203004837,
-0.05296986922621727,
0.5147380828857422,
0.22723425924777985,
-0.24637189507484436,
0.2831273674964905,
-0.09796261787414551,
0.03768577054142952,
-0.7333744764328003,
-0.07968566566705704,
-0.6269517540931702,
0.0585048571228981,
-0.73164963722229,
0.1335374265909195,
-0.16417992115020752,
-0.5208688378334045,
-0.3965955674648285,
-0.17405647039413452,
0.21390345692634583,
-0.034544236958026886,
0.6961538791656494,
0.35860922932624817,
-0.43823835253715515,
-0.39346393942832947,
-0.43446359038352966,
0.7848372459411621,
-0.682769238948822,
0.48890355229377747,
0.6675721406936646,
0.597954273223877,
0.2659541070461273,
-0.5950881838798523,
-0.7011262774467468,
-0.5832587480545044,
-0.07092483341693878,
-0.01391147542744875,
-0.06187485530972481,
0.1500362753868103,
0.35022762417793274,
0.7521412968635559,
-0.5641679763793945,
0.2085357904434204,
-0.4908543825149536,
-0.43429720401763916,
0.6569014191627502,
0.16125832498073578,
0.547852635383606,
-0.7118714451789856,
-0.2833264172077179,
0.16180038452148438,
-0.6319134831428528,
0.11493664979934692,
0.7005508542060852,
0.5143804550170898,
-0.049057409167289734,
0.37733322381973267,
-0.291986882686615,
0.33622831106185913,
-0.3060673773288727,
-0.3393990397453308,
0.13935421407222748,
-0.28899630904197693,
-0.259880930185318,
-0.10559874773025513,
0.4792834520339966,
0.2640334367752075,
0.22562165558338165,
0.06033937260508537,
-0.22044092416763306,
0.5503739714622498,
0.28731295466423035,
-0.9407864809036255,
-0.3653821647167206,
-0.03601717948913574,
-0.3776147961616516,
-0.7877349257469177,
-0.33199840784072876,
-1.0844535827636719,
-0.7159831523895264,
0.00536793889477849,
-0.14583562314510345,
-0.33733081817626953,
-0.696891188621521,
-0.35963815450668335,
0.0676240622997284,
0.2756043076515198,
-0.03482258692383766,
-0.8817120790481567,
0.18475116789340973,
0.4688669741153717,
0.5801958441734314,
-0.3773285448551178,
-0.3549586236476898,
-0.6622804999351501,
-0.03826618939638138,
-0.18442493677139282,
0.5225388407707214,
-0.8271807432174683,
-0.53715580701828,
0.23360426723957062,
0.06813327968120575,
0.28796836733818054,
-0.6073111295700073,
1.1683095693588257,
-0.17706620693206787,
-0.19312041997909546,
-0.36763256788253784,
-0.10393023490905762,
-0.21912115812301636,
0.01670117676258087,
-0.3830398619174957,
1.324363350868225,
0.5410828590393066,
-0.7120980024337769,
0.4454764425754547,
-0.7012942433357239,
-0.8307751417160034,
0.2979470491409302,
-0.3231828212738037,
-0.27932971715927124,
-0.027404434978961945,
-0.06401790678501129,
0.533154308795929,
-0.3211575150489807,
0.2240336686372757,
-0.6901165843009949,
-0.3162524700164795,
0.053277939558029175,
-0.10524948686361313,
1.2891995906829834,
0.5672222971916199,
-0.7957141995429993,
0.39066582918167114,
-0.5799776911735535,
-0.4991011917591095,
0.338684618473053,
-0.11330638825893402,
-0.4871150255203247,
-0.03495514392852783,
0.5484869480133057,
0.3282378017902374,
-0.30591556429862976,
-0.8670676946640015,
-0.3410438001155853,
-0.14336465299129486,
0.6504115462303162,
0.8334035277366638,
-0.18155696988105774,
0.23354193568229675,
-0.13572359085083008,
1.0670433044433594,
0.02769443392753601,
0.2052302211523056,
0.008770160377025604,
-0.30024152994155884,
-0.60450279712677,
-0.4339548349380493,
-0.19123080372810364,
0.6111528873443604,
-0.9230709075927734,
0.06370560824871063,
0.04353960603475571,
-0.7665901780128479,
-0.3428339660167694,
0.04189199581742287,
0.20813807845115662,
0.6305987238883972,
0.2731339633464813,
-0.23278172314167023,
-0.7323912382125854,
-1.0203075408935547,
-0.28970101475715637,
-0.3032279312610626,
0.10377119481563568,
0.4015836715698242,
0.4172765612602234,
-0.412680447101593,
0.40937575697898865,
-0.25521859526634216,
-0.11461625248193741,
-0.3106067180633545,
-0.20960783958435059,
-0.3957221806049347,
0.21142858266830444,
1.1556001901626587,
-0.9029856324195862,
-0.4541786015033722,
-0.3827379643917084,
-0.44889330863952637,
-0.4404372274875641,
0.20295743644237518,
-0.023153869435191154,
0.09851989895105362,
0.7549692392349243,
-0.054831840097904205,
0.5005600452423096,
0.7731364965438843,
-0.31421512365341187,
1.0070223808288574,
0.8554760217666626,
0.6610504984855652,
-0.8509652614593506,
0.041420940309762955,
-0.1679016500711441,
-0.35301080346107483,
-0.6010857820510864,
0.7057896852493286,
-0.08393565565347672,
-0.5065481066703796,
-0.6259167194366455,
0.5141473412513733,
0.1675415337085724,
0.23539726436138153,
-0.2001444548368454,
0.2264581322669983,
-0.645012378692627,
0.45006805658340454,
-0.24701379239559174,
0.9526197910308838,
0.32985007762908936,
-0.7398821711540222,
0.4477456510066986,
0.13481895625591278,
-0.4100683629512787,
1.0561444759368896,
-0.21783685684204102,
-0.2018965482711792,
0.1785077303647995,
0.10885082185268402,
-1.2412470579147339,
-0.5608111023902893,
0.5502916574478149,
-0.29527705907821655,
-0.3950059711933136,
-0.16024205088615417,
-0.4083614647388458,
-0.5514610409736633,
-0.39395469427108765,
0.5684149265289307,
0.37992942333221436,
-0.5320765376091003,
0.4757709801197052,
0.9653730988502502,
-0.4594496190547943,
-0.490058571100235,
-1.1190265417099,
-0.044528499245643616,
-0.5683184266090393,
-0.4530913233757019,
0.06661995500326157,
-0.08189194649457932,
-0.19409120082855225,
-0.32422417402267456,
0.03657250478863716,
-0.39169344305992126,
0.3162248730659485,
0.30935442447662354,
-0.12629294395446777,
-0.4161507487297058,
-0.12293494492769241,
0.18014608323574066,
0.221439927816391,
0.1687077283859253,
0.16936427354812622,
0.4759116470813751,
-0.11393776535987854,
-0.40488019585609436,
-0.12136508524417877,
0.24178914725780487,
0.7318695783615112,
-0.17692933976650238,
0.3513402044773102,
0.9543634057044983,
-0.48803818225860596,
-0.10329265147447586,
-0.5362741947174072,
-0.37979480624198914,
-0.5009253025054932,
0.37368062138557434,
-0.31697243452072144,
-1.4042878150939941,
0.6819007396697998,
0.15311257541179657,
-0.05139617621898651,
0.4526629149913788,
0.6163942813873291,
0.14609839022159576,
0.5033966302871704,
0.5574400424957275,
-0.29684606194496155,
0.5584734678268433,
0.4560023248195648,
0.5268222093582153,
-0.33407485485076904,
0.4918909966945648,
-0.6860292553901672,
-0.18958550691604614,
-0.7171221375465393,
-0.34620267152786255,
0.15737849473953247,
-0.05086883530020714,
-0.23395255208015442,
0.4728207588195801,
-0.4109441637992859,
0.5478681325912476,
0.3874903917312622,
-0.20657981932163239,
0.1678314357995987,
0.08757539838552475,
-0.38489705324172974,
-0.6170752048492432,
-0.40993013978004456,
-0.33406224846839905,
0.9160624146461487,
0.25320032238960266,
0.4255879819393158,
0.3890482187271118,
0.45259466767311096,
0.2637924253940582,
0.5825698971748352,
-0.7100396752357483,
0.669903576374054,
-0.3030772805213928,
-0.9056143164634705,
-0.41593655943870544,
-0.21148502826690674,
-0.4681727886199951,
0.21529100835323334,
0.17554162442684174,
-0.6953220367431641,
-0.0221930630505085,
0.19596584141254425,
-0.43199554085731506,
0.6597771048545837,
-0.415533185005188,
0.8840086460113525,
0.033097922801971436,
-0.2361283302307129,
-0.48337554931640625,
-0.25623634457588196,
0.9951379299163818,
-0.005845057778060436,
0.3905392587184906,
-0.3117048442363739,
0.19246451556682587,
0.8527448773384094,
-0.10067499428987503,
1.028359293937683,
-0.40558764338493347,
-0.19084814190864563,
0.5044698119163513,
0.5231668949127197,
0.23063428699970245,
-0.026287052780389786,
-0.13400262594223022,
0.1987254023551941,
0.15443827211856842,
-0.5440811514854431,
-0.20651334524154663,
0.5782580375671387,
-0.22724410891532898,
-0.2928098142147064,
-0.18849706649780273,
-0.0581185482442379,
-0.19140179455280304,
0.3016074001789093,
0.10423017293214798,
-0.02758575975894928,
-0.5112331509590149,
0.29480865597724915,
0.33892685174942017,
-0.2606409788131714,
0.042796168476343155,
0.5091359615325928,
-0.7590763568878174,
-0.31160202622413635,
0.8776777982711792,
-0.17156139016151428,
0.13118886947631836,
-0.07026217132806778,
0.16934426128864288,
-0.2576504349708557,
-0.34628650546073914,
-0.3413650691509247,
0.10363472998142242,
-0.8134718537330627,
-0.1666770726442337,
-0.5632935762405396,
-0.20388436317443848,
-0.5236913561820984,
-0.21548344194889069,
-0.25894004106521606,
-0.41400209069252014,
0.23485253751277924,
-0.21762612462043762,
0.18906906247138977,
0.47362256050109863,
-0.46091803908348083,
0.5671757459640503,
-0.3121863007545471,
0.5305801630020142,
0.15769484639167786,
0.37561777234077454,
-0.21391019225120544,
-0.7766402363777161,
-0.10421452671289444,
-0.01642586477100849,
-0.27144908905029297,
-0.8934327363967896,
0.05283516272902489,
-0.19881588220596313,
0.3587011396884918,
0.5051144957542419,
0.21095483005046844,
0.5212340354919434,
-0.2539069354534149,
1.1114988327026367,
-0.056100573390722275,
-1.0061180591583252,
0.6684799194335938,
-0.5635937452316284,
-0.07836940884590149,
0.7062493562698364,
0.4560222327709198,
-1.1241447925567627,
-0.6633566617965698,
-0.9025656580924988,
-0.6163440346717834,
0.6453695297241211,
0.1899370700120926,
0.15748532116413116,
0.01792319118976593,
0.20109282433986664,
0.003524694126099348,
0.39353039860725403,
-0.8868491053581238,
-0.36672893166542053,
-0.18847180902957916,
-0.12155772000551224,
-0.24251070618629456,
-0.5964922308921814,
-0.22640730440616608,
-0.3283725678920746,
0.6410375237464905,
-0.06360961496829987,
0.21445266902446747,
-0.04599781334400177,
-0.4246516823768616,
-0.22813378274440765,
0.1635269671678543,
0.8868620991706848,
0.4049667418003082,
0.08573997020721436,
0.1431906372308731,
0.1951015740633011,
-0.6410654783248901,
0.18918278813362122,
0.041824959218502045,
-0.3261556327342987,
0.07961791008710861,
0.12474289536476135,
0.45385855436325073,
0.6129753589630127,
-0.7078164219856262,
0.5999587178230286,
0.12694165110588074,
-0.15223920345306396,
-0.2759726941585541,
0.2466975301504135,
0.01874871365725994,
-0.11387017369270325,
0.051288921386003494,
-0.022531963884830475,
0.3344351351261139,
-0.2562907040119171,
0.6136069297790527,
0.1802656203508377,
-0.49982142448425293,
-0.17164407670497894,
0.8036508560180664,
0.3826043903827667,
-0.2296312153339386,
0.26672807335853577,
-0.5093291997909546,
-0.9086229205131531,
0.45041021704673767,
0.28221043944358826,
0.8694038987159729,
-0.8451694250106812,
0.5775628089904785,
0.5382770299911499,
0.7519553899765015,
0.41950032114982605,
0.3118641674518585,
-0.32074597477912903,
-0.6522047519683838,
-0.27402833104133606,
-0.75513756275177,
-0.49755924940109253,
0.41421136260032654,
-0.5786688327789307,
0.35784122347831726,
-0.8186326026916504,
0.1992492973804474,
-0.011824977584183216,
-0.15241502225399017,
-0.3709704875946045,
0.0954386368393898,
0.24755923449993134,
0.766635537147522,
-1.0397520065307617,
0.6038731336593628,
0.4731977581977844,
-0.5042346715927124,
-0.5241252183914185,
0.1662920117378235,
0.48192107677459717,
-1.031578540802002,
0.37266063690185547,
0.07096816599369049,
-0.38743704557418823,
-0.27585336565971375,
-0.7033044099807739,
-0.7011711001396179,
0.5018172264099121,
0.44274285435676575,
-0.3095390796661377,
0.47029513120651245,
0.3367850184440613,
0.6302421689033508,
-0.18694142997264862,
0.05049454793334007,
0.8875393271446228,
0.37834858894348145,
-0.2005663812160492,
-0.9600663185119629,
0.22994592785835266,
-0.10821464657783508,
-0.3300400674343109,
0.14087581634521484,
-0.8899664878845215,
0.7002784013748169,
0.12736570835113525,
-0.3062732517719269,
-0.08343087881803513,
0.5555017590522766,
0.14930933713912964,
0.08922464400529861,
0.6791914701461792,
0.3514578938484192,
0.838400661945343,
-0.0694427341222763,
0.832141637802124,
-0.1665104180574417,
0.22385969758033752,
1.1589432954788208,
-0.18737375736236572,
0.8078542351722717,
0.24568070471286774,
-0.33966362476348877,
0.4324192404747009,
0.6071785092353821,
0.13685902953147888,
0.33236345648765564,
0.4388814866542816,
-0.23581735789775848,
-0.05530385673046112,
-0.5047482848167419,
-0.35348930954933167,
0.6805866360664368,
0.5400744676589966,
-0.04118737578392029,
-0.3218795955181122,
0.2359771430492401,
0.2210012674331665,
0.21816566586494446,
-0.1789732426404953,
0.14373667538166046,
0.016204016283154488,
-0.31587323546409607,
0.6571811437606812,
0.2753330171108246,
1.0267014503479004,
-0.4588322937488556,
0.3869275748729706,
-0.29133155941963196,
0.06568031758069992,
-0.18800656497478485,
-0.6986167430877686,
0.8738418221473694,
0.059232912957668304,
0.2144598364830017,
-0.032640211284160614,
0.7694873213768005,
-0.42970341444015503,
-0.17532481253147125,
0.4107232689857483,
0.09638804197311401,
0.17456680536270142,
-0.3150731921195984,
-1.0990251302719116,
0.29456013441085815,
0.255741149187088,
0.02827669121325016,
0.05848901718854904,
0.165506511926651,
0.056275662034749985,
0.5691713690757751,
0.6620039343833923,
-0.011730562895536423,
0.19679337739944458,
0.10129600018262863,
0.4565368592739105,
-0.7614453434944153,
-1.0269979238510132,
-0.6781389117240906,
0.29388248920440674,
-0.15669937431812286,
-0.5239372253417969,
0.7015506029129028,
0.5334303379058838,
1.1323384046554565,
-0.10346293449401855,
0.9295833110809326,
-0.2129405438899994,
0.9753239750862122,
-0.1457168459892273,
0.6951321959495544,
-0.6049850583076477,
-0.23867858946323395,
-0.6085726618766785,
-0.649561882019043,
-0.35345259308815,
0.7770126461982727,
-0.3064519762992859,
-0.07639133185148239,
0.9178481101989746,
0.9408283233642578,
-0.384865939617157,
0.609329342842102,
0.5318796038627625,
0.39236220717430115,
0.42312541604042053,
0.2827780544757843,
0.8285931348800659,
-0.4812694489955902,
0.6031941771507263,
-0.5317201614379883,
-0.25549569725990295,
-0.3647380471229553,
-0.49287569522857666,
-0.9490814208984375,
-0.7539334893226624,
-0.27427706122398376,
-0.5266972184181213,
-0.1977429836988449,
0.6093185544013977,
0.4221522808074951,
-1.2247282266616821,
-0.37466996908187866,
0.19356508553028107,
0.11457962542772293,
-0.002894106786698103,
-0.34030264616012573,
-0.031579308211803436,
-0.2025749236345291,
-0.5232112407684326,
0.3701971173286438,
0.47444507479667664,
0.018547069281339645,
-0.4553436040878296,
0.05020880326628685,
-0.2981649339199066,
0.004846872761845589,
0.7191393971443176,
0.45325616002082825,
-0.9427728652954102,
-0.35629209876060486,
-0.18520303070545197,
-0.38065314292907715,
-0.18632137775421143,
1.1444178819656372,
-0.3018171489238739,
-0.060230884701013565,
0.2144353687763214,
1.0101163387298584,
0.25155869126319885,
-0.38100969791412354,
0.2401110827922821,
-0.569534420967102,
0.6781832575798035,
0.4605836272239685,
0.23261655867099762,
0.40313759446144104,
-0.33323898911476135,
0.8159833550453186,
0.5751038789749146,
-0.42694011330604553,
-1.1419247388839722,
0.638174295425415,
-0.5886270403862,
-0.0039838263764977455,
1.1368509531021118,
0.11884155124425888,
-0.07783346623182297,
-0.23236557841300964,
-0.3420787453651428,
-0.025820422917604446,
-0.29953160881996155,
0.7667484879493713,
1.036056637763977,
0.13547825813293457,
-0.06624764204025269,
-0.7391932010650635,
1.067840576171875,
0.7899219393730164,
-0.7356335520744324,
0.337782621383667,
0.44845014810562134,
0.2799803614616394,
0.0484740175306797,
0.9466016888618469,
0.03422325477004051,
0.5020536184310913,
-0.01375019084662199,
-0.23461179435253143,
0.5290247797966003,
-0.13057830929756165,
-0.3555574417114258,
0.1475629061460495,
-0.1801755130290985,
-0.02363857440650463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01827v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01827v1
|
SoftMCL: Soft Momentum Contrastive Learning for Fine-grained Sentiment-aware Pre-training
| 2024-05-03T03:15:38 | 2024-05-03T03:15:38 |
Jin Wang, Liang-Chih Yu, Xuejie Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The pre-training for language models captures general language understanding
but fails to distinguish the affective impact of a particular context to a
specific word. Recent works have sought to introduce contrastive learning (CL)
for sentiment-aware pre-training in acquiring affective information.
Nevertheless, these methods present two significant limitations. First, the
compatibility of the GPU memory often limits the number of negative samples,
hindering the opportunities to learn good representations. In addition, using
only a few sentiment polarities as hard labels, e.g., positive, neutral, and
negative, to supervise CL will force all representations to converge to a few
points, leading to the issue of latent space collapse. This study proposes a
soft momentum contrastive learning (SoftMCL) for fine-grained sentiment-aware
pre-training. Instead of hard labels, we introduce valence ratings as
soft-label supervision for CL to fine-grained measure the sentiment
similarities between samples. The proposed SoftMCL is conducted on both the
word- and sentence-level to enhance the model's ability to learn affective
information. A momentum queue was introduced to expand the contrastive samples,
allowing storing and involving more negatives to overcome the limitations of
hardware platforms. Extensive experiments were conducted on four different
sentiment-related tasks, which demonstrates the effectiveness of the proposed
SoftMCL method. The code and data of the proposed SoftMCL is available at:
https://www.github.com/wangjin0818/SoftMCL/.
|
[
-0.6832392811775208,
-0.6969615817070007,
0.47235268354415894,
0.137288898229599,
-0.5629765391349792,
-0.1927594244480133,
-0.3783149719238281,
0.0653885155916214,
0.2618430554866791,
0.2319006472826004,
-0.6384817957878113,
-0.7924294471740723,
-0.614230215549469,
-0.28762349486351013,
-0.050287727266550064,
1.5965285301208496,
-0.08542200922966003,
0.13776518404483795,
-0.10389205068349838,
-0.3534736633300781,
-0.04204864054918289,
-0.7680734395980835,
-0.40669989585876465,
-0.20272128283977509,
0.7536098957061768,
0.24072951078414917,
0.7404149770736694,
-0.05175817757844925,
0.556377112865448,
0.28001150488853455,
-0.34468743205070496,
-0.032503094524145126,
-0.6119592785835266,
-0.012153130024671555,
-0.24375388026237488,
-0.4087996482849121,
-0.6347770690917969,
0.25450399518013,
0.38513055443763733,
0.730502724647522,
0.0037277464289218187,
-0.24795937538146973,
0.32010388374328613,
0.7887954711914062,
-0.9549117088317871,
0.1885569840669632,
-0.533250093460083,
0.523007869720459,
-0.21622240543365479,
0.11319755762815475,
-0.10374180227518082,
-0.32009315490722656,
-0.05598695948719978,
-0.42087167501449585,
0.05179860442876816,
-0.3174654245376587,
0.6967965960502625,
0.11327315121889114,
-0.3199402093887329,
-0.18188230693340302,
-0.47221964597702026,
0.9409234523773193,
-0.827876627445221,
0.1739191710948944,
0.13383567333221436,
0.07707515358924866,
0.13558731973171234,
-0.3655034601688385,
-0.6757417917251587,
-0.1910419464111328,
0.2114998996257782,
0.5448528528213501,
0.2515348494052887,
0.26989468932151794,
0.01638762094080448,
0.5529419779777527,
-0.43985140323638916,
-0.01612253114581108,
-0.07977326959371567,
-0.07750982791185379,
0.37706395983695984,
0.09130897372961044,
-0.027941180393099785,
-0.17822645604610443,
-0.3514285087585449,
-0.2507591247558594,
-0.4190085828304291,
0.08935025334358215,
0.4137214422225952,
0.6661467552185059,
-0.25667235255241394,
0.37577390670776367,
-0.004958059638738632,
0.21900224685668945,
0.15058530867099762,
0.18603767454624176,
0.7418018579483032,
0.017945963889360428,
-0.1966983526945114,
-0.06254555284976959,
0.9576361775398254,
0.26707687973976135,
0.23473085463047028,
0.07491376996040344,
-0.3958844244480133,
0.3340904414653778,
0.18553771078586578,
-1.0323785543441772,
-0.2336084246635437,
0.2888367772102356,
-0.3625558912754059,
-0.4099373519420624,
0.16773973405361176,
-0.7024905681610107,
-0.46932244300842285,
-0.3360365331172943,
0.6576422452926636,
-0.3685450255870819,
-0.4689475893974304,
0.008821405470371246,
0.15607281029224396,
0.20981107652187347,
0.1990419179201126,
-0.4989427924156189,
0.25116121768951416,
0.7537867426872253,
0.7491608262062073,
-0.27402815222740173,
-0.14146068692207336,
-0.7062822580337524,
-0.3629112243652344,
-0.1178400069475174,
0.6469353437423706,
-0.551692545413971,
-0.5468268394470215,
0.19774900376796722,
0.0964832678437233,
0.07540075480937958,
-0.44554340839385986,
0.5785267949104309,
-0.4413580894470215,
0.25718817114830017,
-0.20682857930660248,
-0.38882946968078613,
-0.08814582228660583,
0.6354939937591553,
-0.4285152852535248,
0.5842640995979309,
0.2300267517566681,
-0.9604727029800415,
0.12429521977901459,
-0.19977764785289764,
-0.7043651938438416,
-0.22101077437400818,
-0.24911175668239594,
-0.7450612187385559,
0.37872421741485596,
-0.1305610090494156,
0.830253005027771,
0.28846850991249084,
0.3136054575443268,
-0.8537974953651428,
-0.45142820477485657,
0.3344956040382385,
-0.3987734317779541,
0.4009750485420227,
0.3049063980579376,
-0.28953808546066284,
0.2983822822570801,
-0.6779469847679138,
-0.10608605295419693,
0.030044294893741608,
-0.22938500344753265,
-0.3631809651851654,
-0.01097897905856371,
0.006195180583745241,
0.544555127620697,
0.31192994117736816,
-0.31862592697143555,
0.10363833606243134,
-0.5960310697555542,
-0.013902882114052773,
0.8096739649772644,
-0.3227904736995697,
0.46114644408226013,
0.19146670401096344,
0.56514972448349,
0.8412690162658691,
0.19728241860866547,
-0.09075282514095306,
0.17435219883918762,
-0.8266527056694031,
0.10269663482904434,
0.028160426765680313,
0.6247855424880981,
-0.7974521517753601,
0.4094444811344147,
0.03388342261314392,
-0.44177934527397156,
-0.4955112040042877,
0.5216134786605835,
0.6880168318748474,
0.5104923248291016,
0.5633716583251953,
-0.7227091193199158,
-0.37446269392967224,
-0.6218599081039429,
-0.33517691493034363,
0.009817696176469326,
0.07738304138183594,
0.6622302532196045,
0.2774279713630676,
-0.37482723593711853,
0.6960883736610413,
-0.635493278503418,
-0.5085921883583069,
-0.3340694308280945,
0.4607457220554352,
0.4920789897441864,
0.4321126937866211,
0.19478105008602142,
-0.8280465602874756,
-0.3278319835662842,
-0.21866853535175323,
-0.6084241271018982,
-0.06323079764842987,
0.19108670949935913,
-0.11305850744247437,
0.185965433716774,
0.4695952236652374,
-0.5495337247848511,
0.051661115139722824,
0.678324282169342,
-0.31608110666275024,
0.5181378126144409,
-0.09861581027507782,
-0.04389204829931259,
-1.116579294204712,
-0.073909230530262,
0.2687382400035858,
-0.11803067475557327,
-0.4382225275039673,
-0.3907977044582367,
-0.008081651292741299,
-0.2540889084339142,
-0.820457935333252,
0.28839078545570374,
-0.25561216473579407,
0.06456990540027618,
-0.3652401268482208,
0.303599089384079,
-0.03208581358194351,
0.7008937001228333,
0.2739541828632355,
0.4737341105937958,
0.40704089403152466,
-0.6071937084197998,
-0.28583914041519165,
-0.11968398094177246,
0.09162849932909012,
0.6338517069816589,
-0.4001711308956146,
0.1379404067993164,
-0.49587947130203247,
0.16433222591876984,
-1.000787615776062,
0.18940487504005432,
0.36455830931663513,
-0.24789822101593018,
0.4969642758369446,
-0.20599053800106049,
0.043319497257471085,
-0.13214948773384094,
-0.5675520896911621,
0.3015422523021698,
0.5435090065002441,
-0.3683738708496094,
0.5384809374809265,
0.38501274585723877,
-0.23786738514900208,
-0.49992671608924866,
-0.8038944005966187,
-0.4213654100894928,
-0.16451767086982727,
-0.08390894532203674,
0.08458249270915985,
-0.2627889811992645,
-0.16157841682434082,
0.020534563809633255,
-0.014630160294473171,
-0.03222959116101265,
0.07113614678382874,
0.428791344165802,
0.2596435844898224,
-0.3145348131656647,
0.26290324330329895,
0.06453736126422882,
-0.1648218035697937,
0.11986812204122543,
-0.29275447130203247,
0.5845898985862732,
-0.7095052003860474,
-0.061940208077430725,
0.05391387641429901,
0.14978696405887604,
0.3270646631717682,
-0.09643761068582535,
0.8827969431877136,
1.1823174953460693,
0.0004947923007421196,
-0.06166818365454674,
-0.3442515730857849,
-0.026390107348561287,
-0.5172538161277771,
0.31917744874954224,
-0.2520034909248352,
-1.0388144254684448,
0.23127256333827972,
-0.266288697719574,
-0.21914008259773254,
0.5102672576904297,
0.43622782826423645,
-0.18096548318862915,
1.1669254302978516,
0.5641409158706665,
-0.34721043705940247,
0.6545880436897278,
-0.14926078915596008,
0.09247133135795593,
-0.8501631021499634,
0.011267857626080513,
-0.1867009401321411,
-0.2793792486190796,
-0.43027839064598083,
-0.45998209714889526,
0.00371860945597291,
0.3190504312515259,
-0.31456097960472107,
-0.1357143670320511,
-0.38553836941719055,
0.296144038438797,
0.031734857708215714,
0.17651091516017914,
-0.12014055997133255,
-0.09780670702457428,
-0.16162344813346863,
-0.2041827142238617,
-0.3520453870296478,
-0.27277931571006775,
0.6044822335243225,
0.13806943595409393,
0.7830044627189636,
-0.10222120583057404,
0.8537837862968445,
0.19152705371379852,
0.5180522799491882,
-0.8971845507621765,
0.7897194027900696,
-0.7693297266960144,
-0.1364378184080124,
0.2118842750787735,
-0.6203732490539551,
-0.7780009508132935,
0.3074323534965515,
-0.22766700387001038,
-0.14347508549690247,
0.02672039344906807,
0.37837734818458557,
-0.21784281730651855,
0.17029477655887604,
-0.6539231538772583,
1.0310789346694946,
-0.361266553401947,
-0.673342227935791,
-0.26522496342658997,
-0.7584065198898315,
0.3004026710987091,
0.21938425302505493,
0.2884509265422821,
-0.18910394608974457,
-0.022979581728577614,
0.7076535820960999,
-0.4961819052696228,
1.0370155572891235,
-0.7049502730369568,
-0.0924326553940773,
0.3281518518924713,
0.03420047089457512,
0.31937408447265625,
-0.09125029295682907,
-0.08654091507196426,
0.11850298941135406,
-0.4068450331687927,
-0.28548818826675415,
-0.44203200936317444,
0.7732003927230835,
-0.8497739434242249,
-0.2680702209472656,
-0.2896176874637604,
-0.1804245561361313,
-0.41977542638778687,
0.15708182752132416,
0.06214448809623718,
0.2832956314086914,
-0.28283190727233887,
0.18027286231517792,
0.8063927292823792,
-0.32184115052223206,
0.257609099149704,
0.5212915539741516,
-0.3028557002544403,
-0.37486696243286133,
1.3608448505401611,
0.07546217739582062,
-0.09643258154392242,
0.2916100323200226,
0.43027475476264954,
-0.1294165551662445,
-0.3962787389755249,
0.16583502292633057,
0.07694181054830551,
-0.554166853427887,
-0.17796368896961212,
-0.6824823617935181,
-0.0841737911105156,
-0.29746294021606445,
-0.4409540295600891,
-0.6463524103164673,
-0.2033022791147232,
-0.6362952589988708,
0.1445402055978775,
0.11984390765428543,
0.42699554562568665,
-0.01168823055922985,
0.3414939343929291,
-0.6841073036193848,
0.3444654047489166,
0.22598905861377716,
0.5847374200820923,
-0.08356344699859619,
-0.48611128330230713,
-0.1462838500738144,
-0.14530792832374573,
-0.3278433084487915,
-0.6699436902999878,
0.5920175313949585,
0.18946118652820587,
0.090665802359581,
0.8853853344917297,
0.04057503491640091,
0.5571370720863342,
-0.4435628652572632,
0.7528666853904724,
0.538144052028656,
-1.0309429168701172,
0.7673618197441101,
-0.30734068155288696,
0.5102552175521851,
1.0580323934555054,
0.7420279383659363,
-0.31048905849456787,
-0.2781485319137573,
-0.6256518959999084,
-1.1617987155914307,
0.40112048387527466,
-0.2375991940498352,
0.22563694417476654,
-0.26346203684806824,
0.32801690697669983,
0.2355494499206543,
0.4298403561115265,
-0.8056567311286926,
0.0019975982140749693,
-0.5255379676818848,
-0.5826979875564575,
-0.4468800723552704,
-0.33271360397338867,
0.42071160674095154,
-0.10459430515766144,
0.7596264481544495,
-0.3189734220504761,
-0.05236726999282837,
0.09180857241153717,
-0.3807825446128845,
0.2709527313709259,
0.5892089605331421,
0.22582636773586273,
-0.1022675633430481,
-0.2994227707386017,
0.46828097105026245,
0.2873874008655548,
-0.536756157875061,
-0.03277900069952011,
0.12055540829896927,
0.0990227684378624,
-0.22090132534503937,
-0.20577068626880646,
0.7862595319747925,
0.4621378481388092,
-0.5616405606269836,
0.7953094244003296,
-0.07873273640871048,
-0.09758839011192322,
-0.21249641478061676,
0.0331883430480957,
0.009371858090162277,
0.30698052048683167,
-0.2112143635749817,
-0.02964603714644909,
0.221551775932312,
-0.587416410446167,
0.11056359112262726,
0.6099116802215576,
-1.0326335430145264,
-0.5717994570732117,
0.4516447186470032,
0.3308611512184143,
-0.018061665818095207,
0.5711252689361572,
-0.644076943397522,
-0.8051485419273376,
0.22403976321220398,
0.3907782733440399,
0.8542543053627014,
-0.19526983797550201,
0.09418028593063354,
0.21724244952201843,
-0.1307835429906845,
0.03502005338668823,
0.5299159288406372,
-0.19051936268806458,
-0.7833290696144104,
-0.31463757157325745,
-0.7356346249580383,
-0.5487248301506042,
0.0720047578215599,
-0.6712766885757446,
0.15466850996017456,
-0.776283860206604,
-0.25573593378067017,
-0.4794851243495941,
0.3572891056537628,
-0.766315221786499,
0.5034922361373901,
0.5688084363937378,
0.4947565793991089,
-0.9354544281959534,
0.770332396030426,
0.6493769288063049,
-0.45000502467155457,
-0.645517885684967,
-0.047395266592502594,
0.01443167869001627,
-0.45049554109573364,
0.5694237947463989,
0.6528337001800537,
-0.4759378433227539,
-0.1771584302186966,
-0.6413590908050537,
-0.21078179776668549,
0.7945635318756104,
0.12910914421081543,
-0.6068635582923889,
0.5145391821861267,
0.022691648453474045,
0.5576644539833069,
-0.29352518916130066,
0.3363800644874573,
0.2016933262348175,
0.2771390974521637,
0.0806061178445816,
-0.07241903245449066,
-0.03225916624069214,
-0.5561164021492004,
-0.16646206378936768,
0.1726589947938919,
-0.8296694159507751,
1.0946276187896729,
-0.10304571688175201,
0.04360012710094452,
-0.26729708909988403,
1.121666669845581,
0.2358180582523346,
0.48945438861846924,
0.868514895439148,
0.5335862636566162,
0.6347122192382812,
0.015802113339304924,
0.861475944519043,
-0.2231196016073227,
0.4340275824069977,
1.0887558460235596,
-0.5168443322181702,
1.1389412879943848,
0.460271418094635,
-0.135471373796463,
0.6373810768127441,
0.31224727630615234,
0.04933803528547287,
0.3570196330547333,
0.3123142421245575,
-0.46987342834472656,
-0.35170313715934753,
-0.2572639286518097,
-0.17888882756233215,
0.11683963239192963,
0.5001736879348755,
-0.20289070904254913,
-0.009471648372709751,
0.21471621096134186,
0.20144759118556976,
-0.08362513035535812,
-0.6741359233856201,
0.7417847514152527,
0.4588112235069275,
-0.424127995967865,
0.11836182326078415,
-0.2699580490589142,
1.2153023481369019,
-0.711544394493103,
0.2492685467004776,
-0.36546647548675537,
0.6137586832046509,
-0.3204474449157715,
-1.0100364685058594,
0.16655196249485016,
0.045403365045785904,
-0.012782543897628784,
-0.19290578365325928,
1.137365698814392,
-0.6457298994064331,
-0.4116029143333435,
0.4220759868621826,
0.34319570660591125,
0.2480790913105011,
-0.2343764454126358,
-0.801413893699646,
0.18495051562786102,
-0.33598122000694275,
-0.6137673258781433,
0.6436182260513306,
0.45501571893692017,
0.3555666208267212,
0.2799019515514374,
0.33624929189682007,
0.021688953042030334,
-0.3595121502876282,
0.46721458435058594,
0.9612711668014526,
-0.8782264590263367,
-0.6444668769836426,
-0.8732979893684387,
0.41176149249076843,
0.045186154544353485,
-0.22847265005111694,
0.6533544063568115,
0.39550408720970154,
0.671813428401947,
-0.0707702487707138,
0.6796593070030212,
0.1883884221315384,
0.22175341844558716,
-0.5193547606468201,
0.5732876658439636,
-0.7189038395881653,
-0.011879176832735538,
-0.5226446390151978,
-0.8695464134216309,
-0.3998152017593384,
0.7405380606651306,
-0.5481647849082947,
0.29237860441207886,
0.5254574418067932,
0.6303529739379883,
-0.2515222132205963,
-0.07983499765396118,
0.26488012075424194,
0.49362099170684814,
0.10041084885597229,
0.761797308921814,
0.7097362875938416,
-0.14018936455249786,
0.7272853851318359,
-0.17383350431919098,
-0.04813763126730919,
-0.32918810844421387,
-1.0633885860443115,
-0.9719089865684509,
-0.31671005487442017,
-0.5465417504310608,
-0.5780987739562988,
0.10295147448778152,
0.8508430123329163,
0.5202774405479431,
-0.7692785859107971,
0.08932182192802429,
-0.25283557176589966,
0.013533818535506725,
0.09669824689626694,
-0.27776050567626953,
0.39896830916404724,
-0.7170689702033997,
-0.3891024589538574,
0.05766645073890686,
0.3650927245616913,
0.04102102667093277,
-0.3192414939403534,
-0.1633242964744568,
0.10404345393180847,
0.09374809265136719,
0.8295227885246277,
0.34694716334342957,
-0.11413697898387909,
-0.033048372715711594,
-0.4852652847766876,
-0.23220697045326233,
0.18574810028076172,
0.8741196393966675,
-1.0263692140579224,
0.13634787499904633,
0.452412873506546,
0.548179030418396,
0.4823695123195648,
-0.05705304816365242,
0.1327059417963028,
-0.8463085293769836,
0.30600836873054504,
0.27735796570777893,
0.36326712369918823,
0.4176289439201355,
-0.1720973551273346,
0.13253124058246613,
0.17477761209011078,
-0.30736076831817627,
-0.33296212553977966,
0.22106687724590302,
-1.322136640548706,
-0.40095585584640503,
1.269534707069397,
-0.1811056286096573,
-0.374576210975647,
0.18405935168266296,
-0.3065783679485321,
0.33517295122146606,
-0.32620298862457275,
0.5850635170936584,
0.4136744737625122,
0.09763775765895844,
-0.11060260981321335,
-0.15431350469589233,
0.3863603174686432,
0.794143557548523,
-0.8073476552963257,
-0.06695554405450821,
0.3186282217502594,
0.008892996236681938,
0.052526868879795074,
0.6580861210823059,
-0.2495279461145401,
-0.023983199149370193,
-0.13076388835906982,
0.11283858120441437,
-0.04764570668339729,
-0.2318509966135025,
-0.774592399597168,
0.5242943167686462,
0.016454538330435753,
0.06390498578548431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.05126v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.05126v1
|
Exploring Speech Pattern Disorders in Autism using Machine Learning
| 2024-05-03T02:59:15 | 2024-05-03T02:59:15 |
Chuanbo Hu, Jacob Thrasher, Wenqi Li, Mindi Ruan, Xiangxu Yu, Lynn K Paul, Shuo Wang, Xin Li
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Diagnosing autism spectrum disorder (ASD) by identifying abnormal speech
patterns from examiner-patient dialogues presents significant challenges due to
the subtle and diverse manifestations of speech-related symptoms in affected
individuals. This study presents a comprehensive approach to identify
distinctive speech patterns through the analysis of examiner-patient dialogues.
Utilizing a dataset of recorded dialogues, we extracted 40 speech-related
features, categorized into frequency, zero-crossing rate, energy, spectral
characteristics, Mel Frequency Cepstral Coefficients (MFCCs), and balance.
These features encompass various aspects of speech such as intonation, volume,
rhythm, and speech rate, reflecting the complex nature of communicative
behaviors in ASD. We employed machine learning for both classification and
regression tasks to analyze these speech features. The classification model
aimed to differentiate between ASD and non-ASD cases, achieving an accuracy of
87.75%. Regression models were developed to predict speech pattern related
variables and a composite score from all variables, facilitating a deeper
understanding of the speech dynamics associated with ASD. The effectiveness of
machine learning in interpreting intricate speech patterns and the high
classification accuracy underscore the potential of computational methods in
supporting the diagnostic processes for ASD. This approach not only aids in
early detection but also contributes to personalized treatment planning by
providing insights into the speech and communication profiles of individuals
with ASD.
|
[
-0.3454105257987976,
-1.0937738418579102,
0.10951374471187592,
0.15522323548793793,
-0.008666913956403732,
0.5255504846572876,
-0.005235803779214621,
-0.49269381165504456,
0.46783724427223206,
0.9062739014625549,
-0.7017960548400879,
-0.5023078918457031,
-0.7543933391571045,
0.07880422472953796,
-0.7925663590431213,
0.5790256857872009,
0.15126201510429382,
0.5368834137916565,
0.26637375354766846,
-0.10377003252506256,
-0.43247339129447937,
-0.46014073491096497,
-1.3743996620178223,
-0.3565874993801117,
0.20359990000724792,
0.5875529050827026,
0.34844696521759033,
0.7001461386680603,
0.17650115489959717,
0.2815300524234772,
-0.21573038399219513,
0.0730031430721283,
0.04910878464579582,
0.3288257420063019,
0.34888091683387756,
-0.03748330473899841,
-0.5113927721977234,
0.10379137098789215,
0.5205905437469482,
1.2040947675704956,
-0.2171522080898285,
0.11930785328149796,
0.355270653963089,
0.4794600009918213,
0.042870379984378815,
0.40475398302078247,
0.0028592285234481096,
0.5055602788925171,
-0.6214848756790161,
-0.20893594622612,
-0.20723240077495575,
0.11352889984846115,
-0.08402232825756073,
-0.49082690477371216,
0.29197436571121216,
-0.08337705582380295,
0.41635704040527344,
0.2535566985607147,
-0.5948547124862671,
-0.46018943190574646,
-0.631709098815918,
0.4061533212661743,
-0.4988476037979126,
0.49761712551116943,
0.6136438846588135,
0.5217193365097046,
-0.11488495022058487,
-0.43477293848991394,
-0.3708815276622772,
-0.23293179273605347,
0.09981759637594223,
-0.1684015989303589,
-0.3256295621395111,
-0.037698905915021896,
0.3574565649032593,
-0.12873978912830353,
-0.9553025364875793,
0.33746257424354553,
-0.4060877561569214,
-0.3503739535808563,
0.9032678604125977,
0.23694880306720734,
0.4110305905342102,
0.07136938720941544,
0.18532797694206238,
0.09256543964147568,
-0.19528020918369293,
0.572271466255188,
0.32011502981185913,
0.5981631278991699,
-0.18388445675373077,
0.3043995499610901,
-0.13169749081134796,
0.5071362257003784,
0.19502444565296173,
0.0001806326035875827,
0.4722261130809784,
0.26690760254859924,
-0.0057891011238098145,
0.44826075434684753,
0.5998495817184448,
-0.13935412466526031,
0.19930213689804077,
0.027246100828051567,
-0.007061222102493048,
0.0929080992937088,
0.22378678619861603,
-0.4384732246398926,
-0.3149307370185852,
0.06244754418730736,
-0.6979367733001709,
-0.4295661151409149,
-0.07303504645824432,
-0.5789295434951782,
-0.5318944454193115,
-0.3875148594379425,
0.037566691637039185,
-0.41894182562828064,
-0.4012516438961029,
-0.1444285660982132,
-0.07909046113491058,
-0.08734294772148132,
0.029159171506762505,
-0.8977344036102295,
0.7316118478775024,
0.6291701197624207,
0.5867308974266052,
-0.03610111400485039,
-0.1359335035085678,
-0.9652356505393982,
-0.012487117201089859,
-0.5068672299385071,
0.6879742741584778,
-0.7818571329116821,
-0.38602641224861145,
-0.21654820442199707,
0.06492085754871368,
-0.21488884091377258,
-0.6463803052902222,
0.7292068004608154,
-0.3139391243457794,
-0.33581864833831787,
0.044310059398412704,
-0.4875863194465637,
-0.32233235239982605,
-0.19061952829360962,
-0.6956946849822998,
0.443868488073349,
0.3025241196155548,
-0.34128665924072266,
0.1564551591873169,
-1.1173360347747803,
-0.7033119797706604,
0.4049374461174011,
-0.46270158886909485,
-0.4925026297569275,
-0.10774845629930496,
0.08051332831382751,
0.3010813891887665,
-0.013796613551676273,
0.3848673403263092,
-0.19648617506027222,
-0.29181453585624695,
0.4085875153541565,
-0.3240123689174652,
0.9450811147689819,
0.5708612203598022,
-0.33501699566841125,
0.18086214363574982,
-0.8132573366165161,
-0.011196782812476158,
-0.05035803094506264,
0.047207336872816086,
0.0951002985239029,
0.11588769406080246,
0.1759984791278839,
-0.08885777741670609,
-0.39455288648605347,
-0.3790966272354126,
-0.19221892952919006,
-0.4956286549568176,
0.37161970138549805,
0.46733948588371277,
0.3347552418708801,
-0.16650226712226868,
-0.5786257386207581,
0.9234952330589294,
0.569779634475708,
0.1487949639558792,
-0.23094496130943298,
-1.0628488063812256,
-0.2529975175857544,
-0.40327203273773193,
0.4318004548549652,
0.46982142329216003,
-0.1760406643152237,
0.5692857503890991,
0.153903990983963,
0.002683726605027914,
-0.6392448544502258,
-0.003952861297875643,
0.5036454200744629,
0.7922576069831848,
0.2077159285545349,
-0.7308505773544312,
-0.5349971055984497,
-0.49626561999320984,
-0.16821886599063873,
0.23772366344928741,
0.09619999676942825,
0.34383195638656616,
0.11486586183309555,
-0.3625004291534424,
0.6951815485954285,
-0.10324902087450027,
-0.41863036155700684,
-0.1427425593137741,
0.4819506108760834,
-0.01986364647746086,
0.4349866807460785,
0.5033560395240784,
-0.7955834865570068,
-0.6899369955062866,
0.19355018436908722,
-0.4686746597290039,
-0.4572984576225281,
0.21643005311489105,
0.49703508615493774,
0.3489818871021271,
0.8116382956504822,
-0.1329067051410675,
0.7014176249504089,
0.3549732565879822,
-0.6970883011817932,
0.2606808841228485,
0.283720463514328,
0.2948884963989258,
-0.5400873422622681,
-0.03173381835222244,
0.041311413049697876,
-0.21201907098293304,
-0.83001309633255,
-0.404642254114151,
-0.365888386964798,
-0.4459936022758484,
-0.026063820347189903,
0.10960754752159119,
-0.15257030725479126,
-0.4498797357082367,
-0.08679673075675964,
-0.03598281368613243,
-0.11926352232694626,
0.07844658195972443,
-0.292478084564209,
0.40102341771125793,
0.8540692925453186,
-0.47479724884033203,
0.3880338966846466,
0.28800615668296814,
-0.27047184109687805,
0.23191560804843903,
-0.24239014089107513,
0.11088775843381882,
0.05315767228603363,
0.19125333428382874,
-0.9376692771911621,
-0.1808623969554901,
0.5794915556907654,
-0.8100610375404358,
0.5293657779693604,
-0.06744435429573059,
-0.14371143281459808,
-0.33996522426605225,
0.010552076622843742,
0.38051560521125793,
0.30424830317497253,
-0.08821005374193192,
0.5539955496788025,
0.7114205360412598,
-0.5939054489135742,
-0.5345461368560791,
-0.40404531359672546,
0.10834622383117676,
-0.22035987675189972,
-0.6922340989112854,
0.14309175312519073,
-0.02313287928700447,
-0.25511834025382996,
-0.09566514939069748,
-0.08518099039793015,
-0.07183581590652466,
0.5662316083908081,
0.2512694001197815,
-0.23965328931808472,
-0.41423213481903076,
0.03804989531636238,
0.29749369621276855,
-0.36252281069755554,
0.1389772891998291,
0.06648053973913193,
0.8748840093612671,
0.21332412958145142,
-0.40357792377471924,
-0.7216495275497437,
0.7917772531509399,
0.38563865423202515,
-0.36098459362983704,
0.06958931684494019,
0.4499915540218353,
-0.5167109370231628,
-0.431631475687027,
0.05653654411435127,
-0.2950294017791748,
-0.410650372505188,
0.25998780131340027,
-0.4756219685077667,
-0.5542530417442322,
0.784283459186554,
-0.09176282584667206,
-0.5319588780403137,
0.15029139816761017,
0.3074418008327484,
-0.4946013391017914,
1.533106803894043,
0.5770159959793091,
-0.0748806968331337,
0.48279526829719543,
-0.3234696090221405,
0.13485977053642273,
-0.8197747468948364,
-0.08961153030395508,
-0.580049455165863,
-0.4236358106136322,
-0.4399433434009552,
-0.09709776192903519,
0.39140585064888,
-0.24185173213481903,
-0.5441762804985046,
-0.4395750164985657,
-0.4976780414581299,
0.3413297235965729,
0.288067102432251,
0.06379825621843338,
0.19108976423740387,
-0.08423970639705658,
-0.014173501171171665,
0.01034223660826683,
-0.4542243182659149,
-0.48355627059936523,
1.4582206010818481,
0.27027231454849243,
0.17148295044898987,
0.12117935717105865,
0.5189095139503479,
0.9095951318740845,
0.2106776088476181,
-0.7642897367477417,
0.30253666639328003,
-0.5449640154838562,
-0.2375689595937729,
-0.3689073324203491,
-0.4066835939884186,
-1.3173844814300537,
-0.05482611060142517,
-0.15213708579540253,
-1.0806381702423096,
0.30264875292778015,
0.026918485760688782,
-0.6344220638275146,
-0.1470702737569809,
-0.5138524174690247,
1.0930354595184326,
-0.2971177101135254,
0.3100632429122925,
-0.252392053604126,
-0.8680870532989502,
0.2639402747154236,
-0.3336264491081238,
0.5701436400413513,
0.0382336862385273,
0.21900402009487152,
1.039855718612671,
-0.26645442843437195,
0.7949482202529907,
-0.19017313420772552,
0.1100611463189125,
0.04524650797247887,
-0.039680421352386475,
-0.09256017953157425,
-0.12442426383495331,
-0.16883356869220734,
0.21708683669567108,
0.07581929117441177,
-0.15439467132091522,
-0.5308972001075745,
0.6419568657875061,
-1.050693392753601,
-0.2822190523147583,
-0.6633841395378113,
-0.32674169540405273,
-0.5994072556495667,
0.014817708171904087,
0.008612001314759254,
0.6155266761779785,
-0.1857096254825592,
-0.19803188741207123,
0.5788053274154663,
0.015430141240358353,
0.41086187958717346,
0.6870631575584412,
-0.30128970742225647,
0.0003968393721152097,
0.9495303630828857,
0.3224811553955078,
-0.1506756693124771,
-0.2078133523464203,
0.2555014491081238,
0.005054997745901346,
-0.7636788487434387,
-0.46760836243629456,
0.17316968739032745,
-0.5184710621833801,
-0.001591200940310955,
-0.5129522085189819,
-0.5081234574317932,
-0.7971010804176331,
0.05705547705292702,
0.15723270177841187,
-0.3753136396408081,
-0.550748348236084,
-0.03327419236302376,
0.18448428809642792,
0.8048587441444397,
-0.08181284368038177,
0.41273069381713867,
-0.5816945433616638,
0.6117203831672668,
-0.009274854324758053,
0.24198104441165924,
-0.040544573217630386,
-0.5342038869857788,
-0.014832126908004284,
0.2188730090856552,
-0.7230868339538574,
-1.1392048597335815,
0.8514750003814697,
0.5628048181533813,
0.4974130094051361,
0.6885126233100891,
-0.10043807327747345,
0.536529004573822,
-0.21681812405586243,
0.7620100975036621,
-0.0820799395442009,
-1.0647846460342407,
0.6966769695281982,
-0.00686724204570055,
-0.216680109500885,
-0.02769017219543457,
0.37150928378105164,
-0.6819983124732971,
-0.4131326377391815,
-0.9153984189033508,
-0.6145859360694885,
1.231815218925476,
0.06184878572821617,
-0.38291969895362854,
0.22574612498283386,
0.27712053060531616,
-0.029206251725554466,
0.09096912294626236,
-0.00963757187128067,
-0.5635977983474731,
-0.2691102623939514,
-0.4047229290008545,
-0.5339505672454834,
-0.011245748028159142,
-0.5328593254089355,
-0.5600297451019287,
0.5469998717308044,
-0.29213038086891174,
0.29076918959617615,
-0.1591210663318634,
0.08218108117580414,
-0.6144445538520813,
0.052851371467113495,
0.6811379790306091,
0.37705591320991516,
-0.02290593460202217,
-0.261961430311203,
-0.1120956540107727,
-0.6372523307800293,
0.0022214571945369244,
0.47105711698532104,
0.18418927490711212,
0.15241768956184387,
0.2964904010295868,
0.6590299010276794,
-0.22644996643066406,
-0.7730350494384766,
0.6536925435066223,
-0.1919507086277008,
-0.22546124458312988,
-0.5004435777664185,
0.17823688685894012,
0.06565453112125397,
0.5026389360427856,
0.3110591173171997,
0.3921772539615631,
0.6362498998641968,
-0.5938007831573486,
0.4453783929347992,
0.5188458561897278,
-0.3551892340183258,
-0.2452080398797989,
0.33130520582199097,
0.14733104407787323,
-1.0188615322113037,
0.7386838793754578,
-0.12699325382709503,
-0.3671974241733551,
1.100997805595398,
0.5524068474769592,
0.9002911448478699,
-0.535024106502533,
0.3404710590839386,
-0.31633925437927246,
-0.16096001863479614,
0.39720869064331055,
0.40462571382522583,
-0.3212321996688843,
-0.8401152491569519,
-0.03075614757835865,
-0.4618493914604187,
-0.3016955852508545,
0.18380072712898254,
-0.793098509311676,
0.3722921907901764,
-0.556162416934967,
-0.20376597344875336,
0.6948585510253906,
0.1721438765525818,
-0.12623773515224457,
0.25574496388435364,
0.5576093792915344,
0.5011992454528809,
-0.8851714134216309,
0.9323265552520752,
0.7515780329704285,
-0.2203115075826645,
-1.0018240213394165,
0.014521157369017601,
0.482086718082428,
-0.6489464640617371,
0.5364934802055359,
0.2242792695760727,
-0.3094466030597687,
0.10808965563774109,
-0.5244337320327759,
-0.7628255486488342,
0.8050440549850464,
0.39215797185897827,
-0.41005778312683105,
0.36440804600715637,
0.21611520648002625,
0.579112708568573,
-0.8398816585540771,
0.17362891137599945,
0.8189194798469543,
0.34376028180122375,
0.24776504933834076,
-1.129793643951416,
-0.1930188089609146,
-0.42960238456726074,
-0.3113844394683838,
0.16986097395420074,
-0.192588672041893,
0.6956465840339661,
-0.11665081977844238,
-0.37663334608078003,
-0.05280197039246559,
0.12861639261245728,
0.22310997545719147,
0.903644859790802,
0.40539252758026123,
0.3455699384212494,
1.2372905015945435,
0.08202096819877625,
0.5705298185348511,
-0.5110802054405212,
-0.048193901777267456,
0.6086366772651672,
-0.2802688777446747,
0.7051160335540771,
-0.13238312304019928,
0.10030198842287064,
0.3857352137565613,
0.6550979614257812,
0.2876432240009308,
0.2541816532611847,
0.3154183626174927,
-0.2671326696872711,
-0.155212864279747,
0.0692310631275177,
-0.41483229398727417,
0.5828164219856262,
0.8377349376678467,
-0.3371427357196808,
0.07784111797809601,
0.4677989184856415,
-0.22405026853084564,
0.2613227367401123,
-0.3116653561592102,
0.9777153134346008,
0.123481385409832,
-0.2206275463104248,
0.5652264356613159,
-0.04079987481236458,
0.2835020124912262,
-0.37131839990615845,
-0.12636952102184296,
0.03464318811893463,
0.21055130660533905,
-0.40721380710601807,
-0.5392935872077942,
0.7045201063156128,
0.005437575746327639,
-0.06539101898670197,
-0.4910646080970764,
0.1967078000307083,
-0.20267105102539062,
-0.5181992650032043,
0.14918027818202972,
0.30772629380226135,
0.3168576657772064,
0.10368486493825912,
-0.8980166912078857,
0.16990092396736145,
-0.0957951694726944,
-0.04097200930118561,
0.2896979749202728,
0.5040279626846313,
-0.4231458008289337,
0.8468292355537415,
0.587279736995697,
0.12058792263269424,
-0.14807435870170593,
0.30965614318847656,
0.6362857818603516,
-0.6446928977966309,
-0.7264596223831177,
-0.5463927388191223,
0.2642199397087097,
0.06885301321744919,
-0.35833820700645447,
0.27049964666366577,
0.48091191053390503,
0.4027237892150879,
0.2919939458370209,
0.5470089316368103,
0.25471267104148865,
1.0325090885162354,
-0.16560567915439606,
1.0218738317489624,
-0.39025264978408813,
0.5056551098823547,
-0.28175652027130127,
-0.08830899000167847,
-0.5711678266525269,
0.8087398409843445,
-0.07141748070716858,
0.1412133127450943,
0.608888566493988,
0.7066588997840881,
-0.04601325839757919,
0.7976900339126587,
0.2000424712896347,
0.5740744471549988,
0.4748435616493225,
0.14475424587726593,
0.8076470494270325,
-0.06883829832077026,
0.18776051700115204,
-0.08579207211732864,
-0.5938301086425781,
-0.1956808716058731,
-0.18907512724399567,
-0.3809831142425537,
-0.9014589786529541,
-0.5594239830970764,
-0.08615962415933609,
0.30140936374664307,
0.9403190612792969,
0.7354267239570618,
-0.888907790184021,
-0.5577318668365479,
-0.07982232421636581,
0.20986635982990265,
-0.832160472869873,
-0.2202652096748352,
0.16544955968856812,
-0.21960218250751495,
-0.3610241413116455,
0.7052246332168579,
0.026012256741523743,
-0.015382107347249985,
0.139174222946167,
0.03081207536160946,
0.09110675007104874,
-0.026640424504876137,
0.38552168011665344,
0.49166789650917053,
-0.54615718126297,
-0.14061272144317627,
-0.172971710562706,
0.19751140475273132,
0.13892808556556702,
0.7979010343551636,
-0.9966486096382141,
0.2988753616809845,
-0.06129876524209976,
0.42846739292144775,
0.43558913469314575,
0.2794487178325653,
0.4771498441696167,
-0.43957147002220154,
-0.2594834268093109,
0.898771345615387,
0.07604869455099106,
0.07776486128568649,
-0.4151771366596222,
0.002703203121200204,
0.22415460646152496,
-0.5001785159111023,
-0.9417985081672668,
0.20555029809474945,
-1.3963956832885742,
-0.25963810086250305,
0.8419286608695984,
0.0232843030244112,
-0.17457590997219086,
-0.7338138222694397,
-0.3834795653820038,
0.2552708685398102,
-0.5477436780929565,
0.7222644090652466,
0.43245023488998413,
-1.0535671710968018,
-0.3303142488002777,
-0.2924857437610626,
0.797294557094574,
0.0894513875246048,
-0.3688144087791443,
-0.08453774452209473,
0.4362318515777588,
0.32210010290145874,
-0.015126382000744343,
0.5364214777946472,
-0.013373063877224922,
0.29174745082855225,
-0.17313846945762634,
-0.3985738456249237,
-0.11614116281270981,
-0.2530915439128876,
-0.8043319582939148,
0.35670095682144165,
-0.1417996734380722,
-0.297023743391037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01799v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01799v1
|
Exploiting ChatGPT for Diagnosing Autism-Associated Language Disorders and Identifying Distinct Features
| 2024-05-03T01:04:28 | 2024-05-03T01:04:28 |
Chuanbo Hu, Wenqi Li, Mindi Ruan, Xiangxu Yu, Lynn K. Paul, Shuo Wang, Xin Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Diagnosing language disorders associated with autism is a complex and nuanced
challenge, often hindered by the subjective nature and variability of
traditional assessment methods. Traditional diagnostic methods not only require
intensive human effort but also often result in delayed interventions due to
their lack of speed and specificity. In this study, we explored the application
of ChatGPT, a state of the art large language model, to overcome these
obstacles by enhancing diagnostic accuracy and profiling specific linguistic
features indicative of autism. Leveraging ChatGPT advanced natural language
processing capabilities, this research aims to streamline and refine the
diagnostic process. Specifically, we compared ChatGPT's performance with that
of conventional supervised learning models, including BERT, a model acclaimed
for its effectiveness in various natural language processing tasks. We showed
that ChatGPT substantially outperformed these models, achieving over 13%
improvement in both accuracy and F1 score in a zero shot learning
configuration. This marked enhancement highlights the model potential as a
superior tool for neurological diagnostics. Additionally, we identified ten
distinct features of autism associated language disorders that vary
significantly across different experimental scenarios. These features, which
included echolalia, pronoun reversal, and atypical language usage, were crucial
for accurately diagnosing ASD and customizing treatment plans. Together, our
findings advocate for adopting sophisticated AI tools like ChatGPT in clinical
settings to assess and diagnose developmental disorders. Our approach not only
promises greater diagnostic precision but also aligns with the goals of
personalized medicine, potentially transforming the evaluation landscape for
autism and similar neurological conditions.
|
[
-0.5036699771881104,
-1.0119928121566772,
0.058879926800727844,
0.24309414625167847,
0.05837155878543854,
0.5101035833358765,
-0.5247812271118164,
-0.7110263109207153,
0.3351553678512573,
0.28692445158958435,
-0.38407033681869507,
-0.32826486229896545,
-0.8134997487068176,
-0.0005479637184180319,
-0.6385961174964905,
1.0053452253341675,
0.10229507833719254,
0.07655511051416397,
0.3206588327884674,
0.03167370706796646,
-0.37985360622406006,
-0.4002097249031067,
-1.7548699378967285,
-0.32074978947639465,
0.2949841022491455,
0.2762249708175659,
0.807503879070282,
0.37137964367866516,
0.5747674107551575,
0.20289616286754608,
-0.37188273668289185,
0.19734302163124084,
-0.06373338401317596,
0.019133446738123894,
0.21954625844955444,
0.18095499277114868,
-0.7994881868362427,
-0.1395750641822815,
0.37672609090805054,
0.9923717975616455,
-0.1129205971956253,
-0.0727878212928772,
0.3327330946922302,
0.40427106618881226,
0.022694053128361702,
0.5045951008796692,
-0.05159679800271988,
0.37186306715011597,
-0.34336674213409424,
0.07803961634635925,
-0.10335420817136765,
-0.07163320481777191,
0.28997373580932617,
-0.614013671875,
0.31451910734176636,
-0.08684546500444412,
0.8248499035835266,
0.10618224740028381,
-0.6173141002655029,
-0.35847237706184387,
-0.6284749507904053,
0.18964169919490814,
-0.7789168953895569,
0.38879483938217163,
0.37539389729499817,
0.4898996353149414,
0.03607257083058357,
-0.5235063433647156,
-0.5524324774742126,
-0.4655448794364929,
0.0455298088490963,
0.06494763493537903,
-0.3916443884372711,
-0.010469730943441391,
0.1788385957479477,
0.11335991322994232,
-1.1026833057403564,
0.41970792412757874,
-0.3955073654651642,
-0.45688074827194214,
0.5099912285804749,
-0.05774355307221413,
0.7840858697891235,
0.07273496687412262,
0.059787388890981674,
0.12378674745559692,
-0.4861671030521393,
0.15205329656600952,
0.0770704373717308,
0.5621231198310852,
-0.1529134213924408,
0.2829175293445587,
-0.16525036096572876,
0.30099499225616455,
0.03364395350217819,
0.3034016788005829,
0.4119839668273926,
0.20378164947032928,
0.2551346719264984,
-0.033812906593084335,
0.9201841354370117,
0.04230187460780144,
0.5355364084243774,
-0.24936287105083466,
-0.05441942438483238,
0.040706124156713486,
0.04671982303261757,
-0.4908728003501892,
-0.6141560673713684,
0.24287214875221252,
-0.25767040252685547,
-0.1756400167942047,
-0.5003719329833984,
-0.7542719841003418,
-0.5067318081855774,
-0.03553053364157677,
0.13533347845077515,
-0.8778296113014221,
-0.5728396773338318,
-0.031056083738803864,
0.023565730080008507,
-0.06095046177506447,
0.12141270190477371,
-1.1504226922988892,
0.5232769250869751,
0.667618453502655,
0.7204864621162415,
-0.18523257970809937,
-0.1848268210887909,
-0.5218982100486755,
-0.09551749378442764,
-0.4515133202075958,
1.0111565589904785,
-0.7941654324531555,
-0.05248703062534332,
-0.21813449263572693,
-0.2198164463043213,
-0.15373289585113525,
-0.47133180499076843,
0.5375825762748718,
-0.4265059232711792,
-0.11375954747200012,
-0.09267191588878632,
-0.27487459778785706,
-0.24602290987968445,
0.34554794430732727,
-0.5838239192962646,
0.9029213190078735,
0.2893892228603363,
-0.529347836971283,
0.3000856339931488,
-1.0126274824142456,
-0.4839189946651459,
0.5068578124046326,
0.012851706705987453,
-0.3718540072441101,
-0.20051981508731842,
0.5042808055877686,
0.30245375633239746,
-0.07799382507801056,
0.4045321047306061,
0.0033744238317012787,
-0.25587141513824463,
0.03961089998483658,
-0.65437912940979,
0.6980976462364197,
0.11584839224815369,
-0.1740812212228775,
0.0818425863981247,
-0.5764528512954712,
0.030312713235616684,
0.21863232553005219,
-0.29544782638549805,
0.11283828318119049,
0.08338985592126846,
0.15681253373622894,
-0.1204562783241272,
0.14598146080970764,
-0.35541799664497375,
-0.015012121759355068,
-0.7576522827148438,
0.29276177287101746,
0.2659953534603119,
0.11760041862726212,
-0.00772611191496253,
-0.3873453140258789,
0.8417355418205261,
0.363025039434433,
0.21487222611904144,
-0.24916590750217438,
-0.9251397252082825,
-0.5304821729660034,
-0.4321804344654083,
0.6165317893028259,
0.6220430135726929,
-0.43362393975257874,
0.5536473989486694,
-0.20977365970611572,
-0.18603497743606567,
-0.6604698300361633,
-0.17647835612297058,
0.42663460969924927,
0.5970264077186584,
0.34866082668304443,
-0.7973644733428955,
-0.12798668444156647,
-0.7303667664527893,
-0.07025038450956345,
0.0967104434967041,
-0.10405567288398743,
0.21661821007728577,
0.021187974140048027,
-0.30439555644989014,
0.5327898859977722,
0.032016076147556305,
-0.40315109491348267,
-0.26069971919059753,
0.27577683329582214,
0.0005978802219033241,
0.27598708868026733,
0.5484650135040283,
-0.46908777952194214,
-0.6927177906036377,
0.7185962200164795,
-0.48020943999290466,
-0.2854635715484619,
0.2306513786315918,
0.3972071409225464,
0.16840803623199463,
0.32675185799598694,
-0.4901551902294159,
0.3905004858970642,
0.5642278790473938,
-0.6984634399414062,
0.4833320677280426,
-0.171652689576149,
0.31456005573272705,
-0.6780461072921753,
-0.008235244080424309,
-0.10438480228185654,
-0.4188511371612549,
-0.4680102467536926,
-0.024260209873318672,
-0.12156129628419876,
-0.383040189743042,
0.0034511734265834093,
0.23886443674564362,
-0.2385963797569275,
-0.06842848658561707,
-0.12072461098432541,
0.42863985896110535,
-0.04522131010890007,
0.14111855626106262,
-0.16015471518039703,
0.6416745781898499,
0.9652196764945984,
-0.3581167757511139,
0.39971688389778137,
0.22594383358955383,
0.017358452081680298,
0.26108554005622864,
-0.6217026710510254,
-0.053950969129800797,
-0.006429571658372879,
0.10064087063074112,
-1.1532623767852783,
0.010579311288893223,
0.3817142844200134,
-0.7400290966033936,
0.6190310120582581,
0.01436992734670639,
-0.5262214541435242,
-0.32428571581840515,
0.029625967144966125,
0.4037513732910156,
0.6077120900154114,
-0.41885098814964294,
0.43428876996040344,
0.39276543259620667,
-0.5354259610176086,
-0.5212728381156921,
-0.5446141958236694,
0.19272466003894806,
-0.09347694367170334,
-0.7284952402114868,
0.13190090656280518,
0.12757189571857452,
0.01945355162024498,
-0.01889345422387123,
-0.03300505131483078,
-0.10848090052604675,
0.29530319571495056,
-0.16358709335327148,
-0.09634111821651459,
-0.7046105861663818,
0.37303826212882996,
0.12191133201122284,
-0.42604559659957886,
-0.21120521426200867,
0.2886545956134796,
0.903087854385376,
-0.1795782595872879,
-0.5304099917411804,
-0.2818954586982727,
0.5881591439247131,
0.3438187837600708,
-0.5416712760925293,
0.3137838542461395,
0.6632792353630066,
-0.36906495690345764,
-0.3813912272453308,
-0.11119844019412994,
-0.2962576746940613,
-0.4461784362792969,
0.5187687873840332,
-0.18714985251426697,
-0.7454726099967957,
0.7952326536178589,
-0.17154939472675323,
-0.21003635227680206,
0.3500392436981201,
0.3237033188343048,
-0.12416364997625351,
1.1891454458236694,
0.45512160658836365,
0.007863772101700306,
0.3659053444862366,
-0.041052356362342834,
0.8023431897163391,
-0.9985023736953735,
0.16253353655338287,
-0.30479684472084045,
-0.16407737135887146,
-0.46567729115486145,
-0.22218476235866547,
0.48299935460090637,
-0.32957178354263306,
-0.3557535707950592,
-0.08666833490133286,
-0.5663776993751526,
0.6148799657821655,
0.1364811509847641,
0.15977852046489716,
0.3933861553668976,
-0.27978792786598206,
-0.09998542070388794,
-0.07819255441427231,
-0.7611483335494995,
-0.6902717351913452,
1.3627091646194458,
0.271624892950058,
0.05288945138454437,
0.11567232012748718,
0.3522540330886841,
0.5053731203079224,
0.5792861580848694,
-0.9787929058074951,
0.44100508093833923,
-0.4163495898246765,
-0.5016664266586304,
-0.22538277506828308,
-0.2842952013015747,
-1.2391695976257324,
0.07538101077079773,
0.026626795530319214,
-1.1792711019515991,
-0.018893679603934288,
0.10742004215717316,
-0.7249588966369629,
0.012187914922833443,
-0.9497534036636353,
1.179286241531372,
-0.34809455275535583,
0.2532881200313568,
-0.11742197722196579,
-0.38661324977874756,
0.4457481801509857,
-0.4019283354282379,
0.2369394749403,
-0.3415568768978119,
-0.03217707946896553,
0.7027075886726379,
-0.031489402055740356,
0.8153011202812195,
0.14691296219825745,
-0.0027689579874277115,
-0.1998375505208969,
0.1775597780942917,
-0.16752450168132782,
0.03942244499921799,
0.00781886838376522,
0.28271788358688354,
0.07990238070487976,
-0.19907274842262268,
-0.6594723463058472,
0.703345000743866,
-0.808541476726532,
-0.39211827516555786,
-0.6558891534805298,
-0.5232377648353577,
-0.8651798367500305,
0.06641610711812973,
-0.06519771367311478,
0.5833653211593628,
-0.324665367603302,
-0.3202512264251709,
0.498167484998703,
-0.3779599666595459,
0.4747859537601471,
0.6856334805488586,
-0.4369168281555176,
0.26172640919685364,
0.9552560448646545,
0.027015434578061104,
0.09615156054496765,
-0.0909954085946083,
0.18160858750343323,
0.07199570536613464,
-0.7998539209365845,
-0.2745439112186432,
0.32178547978401184,
-0.5089319348335266,
-0.15836280584335327,
-0.40100640058517456,
-0.609252393245697,
-0.5386865139007568,
-0.0010872340062633157,
-0.5253610610961914,
-0.5067323446273804,
-0.0902320146560669,
0.04956269636750221,
0.38542452454566956,
0.5889034271240234,
-0.08528122305870056,
0.5040934085845947,
-0.6195258498191833,
0.5964227914810181,
0.00337596470490098,
0.5867050290107727,
0.17168347537517548,
-0.5053008198738098,
-0.00283452239818871,
0.46237024664878845,
-0.5638809204101562,
-0.7786909341812134,
0.7012376189231873,
0.6371135115623474,
0.40330567955970764,
0.469360888004303,
-0.12349718809127808,
0.5801337957382202,
-0.40891051292419434,
0.6628885269165039,
-0.14371882379055023,
-0.8886429071426392,
0.5417789220809937,
-0.21314360201358795,
0.1810673177242279,
0.07392575591802597,
0.49497219920158386,
-0.791199803352356,
-0.4919705390930176,
-0.8290148377418518,
-1.0078210830688477,
0.7102279663085938,
0.22872331738471985,
-0.06780871003866196,
-0.15066388249397278,
0.17805397510528564,
-0.03843149170279503,
-0.3477417230606079,
-0.2974182963371277,
-0.15722668170928955,
0.10399289429187775,
-0.3378925919532776,
-0.369698166847229,
-0.02274147979915142,
-0.26399320363998413,
-0.4506799578666687,
0.7273094058036804,
-0.18989889323711395,
0.5397701859474182,
-0.028416506946086884,
0.1914275735616684,
-0.009448308497667313,
0.14198656380176544,
0.12531781196594238,
0.45742934942245483,
0.08676944673061371,
-0.25543150305747986,
0.09147932380437851,
-0.588226318359375,
-0.3546106219291687,
0.6391763687133789,
0.19021764397621155,
0.08548734337091446,
0.40235435962677,
0.5614261031150818,
-0.01197529025375843,
-1.0118236541748047,
0.7679398059844971,
-0.28307899832725525,
0.10537528246641159,
-0.35748106241226196,
0.06730586290359497,
0.3916875422000885,
0.5514930486679077,
0.15388067066669464,
0.31853732466697693,
0.35179007053375244,
-0.3682170510292053,
0.32252565026283264,
0.576632022857666,
-0.26619818806648254,
-0.464173823595047,
0.3753311336040497,
0.09729143232107162,
-0.8165695071220398,
0.8490339517593384,
-0.2862229645252228,
-0.42067357897758484,
0.9104891419410706,
0.5107710957527161,
0.717555582523346,
-0.358421266078949,
0.4692351222038269,
-0.13032788038253784,
0.31225770711898804,
0.15673650801181793,
0.2614805996417999,
-0.08629436045885086,
-1.0510516166687012,
-0.2972162663936615,
-0.5394613742828369,
-0.3279659152030945,
0.1470969319343567,
-0.4145616590976715,
0.3298546373844147,
-0.6526991128921509,
-0.17024625837802887,
0.4744183123111725,
-0.1442602425813675,
-0.3860023021697998,
0.19260336458683014,
0.3785364031791687,
0.5181601643562317,
-0.6584383249282837,
0.7574707269668579,
0.5994359850883484,
-0.4374542236328125,
-0.970368504524231,
0.21788138151168823,
0.10386315733194351,
-0.9355949759483337,
0.2712680697441101,
0.09153584390878677,
0.11551535874605179,
0.1768905520439148,
-0.2667410373687744,
-0.8416392207145691,
0.6124863624572754,
0.4924676716327667,
-0.4029337167739868,
0.1013755202293396,
0.1329585164785385,
0.9701840281486511,
-0.35968005657196045,
0.5529797673225403,
0.9227213263511658,
0.2900790870189667,
0.2771669626235962,
-1.545801043510437,
-0.04272838681936264,
-0.4063344895839691,
-0.3343183994293213,
0.33170172572135925,
-0.3385995030403137,
0.6037319898605347,
-0.16879016160964966,
-0.3729899525642395,
-0.18695802986621857,
-0.0315781831741333,
0.06068481504917145,
0.1900579035282135,
-0.08402428776025772,
0.3700401186943054,
0.9969382882118225,
-0.1186382994055748,
0.9072455763816833,
-0.5844211578369141,
0.2449086308479309,
0.5761887431144714,
-0.13419616222381592,
0.991020143032074,
0.007900722324848175,
-0.06962423771619797,
-0.0262401532381773,
0.6207138299942017,
0.4751048982143402,
0.12216418236494064,
-0.048626579344272614,
-0.4483341872692108,
0.026416057720780373,
-0.008063106797635555,
-0.41857919096946716,
0.5938841104507446,
0.8376275300979614,
-0.19348445534706116,
-0.4738195836544037,
0.1633995622396469,
0.16972242295742035,
0.052845243364572525,
-0.06277979165315628,
0.8219177722930908,
-0.009858065284788609,
-0.32516834139823914,
0.6754207611083984,
-0.15045686066150665,
0.5820676684379578,
-0.5955945253372192,
-0.015649568289518356,
-0.27827611565589905,
0.2373540848493576,
-0.050699688494205475,
-0.6995671391487122,
0.709549069404602,
0.029885347932577133,
0.3331455588340759,
-0.3743157684803009,
0.37722718715667725,
-0.35732999444007874,
-0.5306316018104553,
0.1794315129518509,
0.5239057540893555,
0.22810658812522888,
-0.18867576122283936,
-0.6712490916252136,
0.010906188748776913,
-0.23168626427650452,
-0.23031887412071228,
0.3040962517261505,
0.7647103667259216,
-0.21789346635341644,
0.9356986284255981,
0.48528435826301575,
0.3218231201171875,
-0.05934920907020569,
0.08463740348815918,
0.769045352935791,
-0.4516241252422333,
-0.3721001148223877,
-0.6543286442756653,
0.30783867835998535,
-0.040893878787755966,
-0.4838876724243164,
0.251747190952301,
0.37445640563964844,
0.49827975034713745,
0.1353725790977478,
0.7813427448272705,
-0.05395273491740227,
0.8044407963752747,
-0.021774999797344208,
1.0481288433074951,
-0.3764287829399109,
0.432963103055954,
-0.08162692934274673,
-0.3243332803249359,
-0.6927313208580017,
0.7127707004547119,
-0.4005306363105774,
0.22337594628334045,
0.9427137970924377,
0.6878703236579895,
-0.2823251783847809,
0.3137344419956207,
0.3080669641494751,
0.39125722646713257,
0.5836668014526367,
0.6225443482398987,
0.7123767733573914,
-0.24117393791675568,
0.3303619623184204,
-0.07818206399679184,
-0.540065586566925,
0.09283415228128433,
-0.5035480260848999,
-0.7319658994674683,
-0.5969291925430298,
-0.5617478489875793,
0.15943549573421478,
0.4444616734981537,
0.8667745590209961,
0.6908311247825623,
-0.8429699540138245,
-0.03794896602630615,
0.12537881731987,
-0.04509078711271286,
-0.6186746954917908,
-0.24076656997203827,
0.3910386264324188,
-0.43261709809303284,
-0.49438929557800293,
0.405893474817276,
0.25045183300971985,
-0.13242866098880768,
-0.01347102876752615,
0.2843574583530426,
0.008766938000917435,
-0.01355785597115755,
0.5895019173622131,
0.43305209279060364,
-0.5683370232582092,
-0.41504159569740295,
-0.34944862127304077,
0.15085983276367188,
0.33030471205711365,
0.40457743406295776,
-0.8763567209243774,
0.3255324959754944,
0.046129338443279266,
0.8282209634780884,
0.376852810382843,
0.1093784049153328,
0.7472290992736816,
-0.3955158293247223,
-0.07214772701263428,
0.8553271293640137,
0.14793001115322113,
0.4023008644580841,
-0.4540714621543884,
0.16312935948371887,
0.04332776740193367,
-0.4716060757637024,
-0.49849385023117065,
0.14601191878318787,
-1.3605551719665527,
0.039917632937431335,
1.0201352834701538,
-0.23179477453231812,
-0.11327391862869263,
-0.4676302671432495,
-0.5484237670898438,
0.17597626149654388,
-0.5394342541694641,
1.0350717306137085,
0.6361632943153381,
-0.6754353642463684,
-0.48530274629592896,
-0.6487823724746704,
0.509883463382721,
0.2939552366733551,
-0.523078978061676,
-0.10829821228981018,
0.29338935017585754,
0.39471322298049927,
-0.0859585627913475,
0.7470030188560486,
-0.2550540864467621,
0.4134964346885681,
0.016737433150410652,
-0.020724693313241005,
0.022983763366937637,
0.03451279550790787,
-0.42028945684432983,
0.09123112261295319,
0.12644316256046295,
-0.19979412853717804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01796v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01796v1
|
TOPICAL: TOPIC Pages AutomagicaLly
| 2024-05-03T00:47:16 | 2024-05-03T00:47:16 |
John Giorgi, Amanpreet Singh, Doug Downey, Sergey Feldman, Lucy Lu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DL, cs.IR
|
Topic pages aggregate useful information about an entity or concept into a
single succinct and accessible article. Automated creation of topic pages would
enable their rapid curation as information resources, providing an alternative
to traditional web search. While most prior work has focused on generating
topic pages about biographical entities, in this work, we develop a completely
automated process to generate high-quality topic pages for scientific entities,
with a focus on biomedical concepts. We release TOPICAL, a web app and
associated open-source code, comprising a model pipeline combining retrieval,
clustering, and prompting, that makes it easy for anyone to generate topic
pages for a wide variety of biomedical entities on demand. In a human
evaluation of 150 diverse topic pages generated using TOPICAL, we find that the
vast majority were considered relevant, accurate, and coherent, with correct
supporting citations. We make all code publicly available and host a
free-to-use web app at: https://s2-topical.apps.allenai.org
|
[
-0.42622917890548706,
-0.8262137174606323,
0.8371345400810242,
0.3369411528110504,
-0.23412258923053741,
0.1228623017668724,
-0.15985935926437378,
-0.32293134927749634,
1.0607795715332031,
0.5454450249671936,
-0.5235862135887146,
-0.7695596814155579,
-0.30537736415863037,
0.0251216609030962,
-0.6212385892868042,
1.066431999206543,
0.16672000288963318,
-0.16087791323661804,
-0.4779948592185974,
-0.21939009428024292,
-0.040787164121866226,
0.098675936460495,
-0.503063440322876,
0.1177276223897934,
0.8755464553833008,
0.5562993884086609,
0.37893497943878174,
0.8987274169921875,
0.66487717628479,
0.20169931650161743,
-0.020616313442587852,
0.1280500739812851,
-0.37418895959854126,
0.44898301362991333,
-1.0577338933944702,
0.004458974115550518,
-0.6305522322654724,
0.07903878390789032,
0.48543480038642883,
0.7504069805145264,
-0.14552228152751923,
0.37156251072883606,
-0.4265636205673218,
0.8004725575447083,
-0.38521063327789307,
-0.27172815799713135,
-0.7861752510070801,
-0.06792625039815903,
-0.5701731443405151,
-0.49654388427734375,
-0.15849502384662628,
-0.3943202793598175,
0.13360531628131866,
-0.7561611533164978,
0.7389691472053528,
-0.021016128361225128,
0.8160228729248047,
0.20287905633449554,
-0.49926820397377014,
-0.32071056962013245,
-0.31364816427230835,
0.20250003039836884,
-0.23212815821170807,
0.18120336532592773,
0.38032999634742737,
0.08727028220891953,
-0.07699216902256012,
-0.9084795117378235,
-0.532975971698761,
-0.3476857542991638,
0.1412225216627121,
0.11775970458984375,
-0.12669436633586884,
-0.1102299764752388,
-0.07044830918312073,
0.3656381070613861,
-0.7687267661094666,
-0.26056545972824097,
-0.6137307286262512,
0.0817524790763855,
0.7456584572792053,
0.16128157079219818,
0.49271857738494873,
-0.22272153198719025,
0.09878375381231308,
0.1909027397632599,
-0.8302010893821716,
-0.24917690455913544,
0.2045072317123413,
0.0781584307551384,
0.2175331711769104,
0.7627816200256348,
-0.45670267939567566,
0.43813350796699524,
0.4794195592403412,
0.07146940380334854,
0.14688138663768768,
-0.5143162608146667,
0.4322742521762848,
0.04882108420133591,
0.538584291934967,
0.35608479380607605,
-0.45761314034461975,
-0.48700380325317383,
0.06883561611175537,
-0.18081429600715637,
0.8629376888275146,
-0.7151828408241272,
-0.10978766530752182,
0.6928205490112305,
-0.4865683913230896,
-0.3296855390071869,
-0.010740933008491993,
-0.5964304804801941,
-0.17795652151107788,
-0.33064088225364685,
0.12906968593597412,
-0.33408376574516296,
-0.08235343545675278,
-0.3503391742706299,
-0.35534384846687317,
-0.4043217599391937,
0.47448021173477173,
-0.5401940941810608,
0.027560029178857803,
0.495611310005188,
1.0027353763580322,
-0.5829979777336121,
-0.25570452213287354,
-0.2184392660856247,
0.7071138620376587,
-0.24200519919395447,
1.0375564098358154,
-0.38044703006744385,
-0.6988628506660461,
-0.31634536385536194,
0.23432202637195587,
0.2835833430290222,
-0.5264455676078796,
0.08976469188928604,
-0.6739273071289062,
-0.1101561039686203,
-0.23927746713161469,
-0.5294443368911743,
0.00763406278565526,
-0.2167811095714569,
-0.5883641242980957,
0.7125716209411621,
0.07036466896533966,
-0.7096039652824402,
0.44463229179382324,
-1.0459270477294922,
-0.516578197479248,
0.2822425961494446,
-0.2120537906885147,
-0.030822664499282837,
0.04634498804807663,
-0.238375723361969,
0.3356854319572449,
-0.27982646226882935,
0.4910752475261688,
-0.2490113079547882,
0.1914553940296173,
0.20349180698394775,
0.33034560084342957,
0.3607618808746338,
0.3680373430252075,
-0.5363978147506714,
0.3972165286540985,
-0.8130706548690796,
-0.1924709677696228,
0.19911831617355347,
-0.05072862654924393,
-0.38487759232521057,
0.03685120493173599,
-0.02333090826869011,
-0.030659517273306847,
0.29320529103279114,
-0.44507282972335815,
0.27168700098991394,
-0.3711079955101013,
0.35836708545684814,
0.42370161414146423,
0.4593459367752075,
0.5595969557762146,
-0.10014940798282623,
0.2635277807712555,
0.06079087033867836,
-0.14265933632850647,
-0.3086681067943573,
-0.8851211071014404,
-0.6295865178108215,
-0.23064151406288147,
0.34875112771987915,
0.4907505214214325,
-0.5902807116508484,
0.5984339714050293,
-0.04847352206707001,
-0.8567661643028259,
-0.21841497719287872,
0.14430458843708038,
0.2520191967487335,
0.6812633872032166,
0.44772693514823914,
-0.5777955651283264,
-0.10665479302406311,
-0.9565767645835876,
-0.025501584634184837,
0.024246983230113983,
-0.11766762286424637,
0.5476693511009216,
0.5626221895217896,
-0.6385195255279541,
1.1280479431152344,
-0.761282205581665,
0.033036112785339355,
0.4274216890335083,
0.3374759554862976,
0.03829560428857803,
0.5379297733306885,
0.49260959029197693,
-1.0436310768127441,
-0.4987587332725525,
-0.04933442175388336,
-0.6870431900024414,
-0.1496211588382721,
0.1450873613357544,
-0.6171885132789612,
-0.08354195207357407,
0.18510115146636963,
-0.7918683886528015,
0.47553351521492004,
-0.13781467080116272,
-0.42074519395828247,
0.3672938346862793,
-0.2549687922000885,
0.21565288305282593,
-1.1256309747695923,
0.5351805686950684,
0.3443298041820526,
-0.19794748723506927,
-0.3142138421535492,
0.38929733633995056,
-0.040226612240076065,
-0.5125313401222229,
-0.3499804437160492,
0.8183606266975403,
-0.12702977657318115,
-0.05230099335312843,
-0.3952127993106842,
0.2880951762199402,
0.2215307205915451,
-0.07026064395904541,
0.19884704053401947,
0.9064258933067322,
0.42580270767211914,
-0.7498093247413635,
0.26768019795417786,
0.30799007415771484,
0.42691823840141296,
0.3936866521835327,
-0.7462570071220398,
0.035200085490942,
-0.18284690380096436,
0.4282473921775818,
-0.71063232421875,
-0.6138019561767578,
0.2687821090221405,
-0.4087580144405365,
0.2900923788547516,
0.1668173223733902,
-0.1762075275182724,
-0.4180699586868286,
-0.19604475796222687,
0.17700053751468658,
0.2683711349964142,
0.03354920819401741,
-0.025696763768792152,
0.9722377061843872,
-0.7635732293128967,
-0.17010845243930817,
-0.2758793532848358,
0.18956953287124634,
-0.04844559356570244,
-0.5131478309631348,
1.0053741931915283,
0.02069726027548313,
-0.30629485845565796,
0.5297223925590515,
-0.0022101057693362236,
-0.4839549958705902,
-0.17575600743293762,
0.2877732515335083,
-0.022037653252482414,
-0.168497696518898,
0.36786553263664246,
0.3740229606628418,
-0.252483993768692,
-0.2678329348564148,
-0.6143960952758789,
0.15466298162937164,
-0.1297386884689331,
-0.4542624354362488,
-0.27559688687324524,
0.7558539509773254,
0.6956143975257874,
-0.28827035427093506,
0.5097715258598328,
0.5634180903434753,
-0.3917260766029358,
0.1314336508512497,
-0.522486686706543,
-0.2508946359157562,
-0.42602816224098206,
0.2694282531738281,
0.030670911073684692,
-0.6763554811477661,
0.4323483407497406,
-0.13521859049797058,
0.09836959093809128,
1.0287401676177979,
0.6710920929908752,
-0.3081414997577667,
0.37122130393981934,
0.575908899307251,
0.35403528809547424,
-0.017358405515551567,
-0.21598117053508759,
0.16427122056484222,
-0.48600906133651733,
-0.46881771087646484,
-0.6538174748420715,
-0.12496007978916168,
-0.6464093327522278,
-0.8412409424781799,
0.4032793343067169,
0.03999139741063118,
-0.1120535284280777,
0.3701702058315277,
-1.1432491540908813,
0.25131911039352417,
0.7353236675262451,
0.3059345781803131,
0.04659194126725197,
0.10755753517150879,
0.0400996170938015,
0.020942209288477898,
-0.39363259077072144,
-0.8752650022506714,
1.1087080240249634,
0.15643295645713806,
0.326076865196228,
-0.04992656782269478,
0.8644405007362366,
0.6412675976753235,
0.4970112442970276,
-0.4613712430000305,
0.4738847613334656,
-0.26945292949676514,
-0.8403365612030029,
-0.5599315166473389,
-0.20101195573806763,
-0.8884991407394409,
-0.21095283329486847,
-0.13991209864616394,
-0.5686661005020142,
0.4560199975967407,
0.18343447148799896,
-0.4202499985694885,
0.1273737996816635,
-0.36076900362968445,
0.5918057560920715,
-0.21423524618148804,
-0.7793812155723572,
-0.5461005568504333,
-0.7166529893875122,
0.11776715517044067,
-0.42351382970809937,
0.11477116495370865,
-0.30319681763648987,
-0.2771833837032318,
0.58271324634552,
-0.4830033779144287,
0.5349894165992737,
-0.11336077749729156,
0.005919635761529207,
0.6129521131515503,
-0.1552366465330124,
-0.0719180628657341,
0.5371654033660889,
-0.013040821999311447,
0.28255411982536316,
-0.006705387029796839,
-0.6176924705505371,
-0.33153772354125977,
0.626205325126648,
-0.41483643651008606,
-0.6802769303321838,
-0.23934796452522278,
-0.26110023260116577,
-0.020926423370838165,
0.2978553771972656,
0.25349873304367065,
0.18941102921962738,
-0.24028648436069489,
0.17551106214523315,
0.8819131255149841,
-0.5730218887329102,
0.1266007423400879,
0.6023660898208618,
-0.18505412340164185,
-0.4508100748062134,
1.3203929662704468,
0.01190217211842537,
-0.23671813309192657,
0.5470500588417053,
0.010765166953206062,
-0.1913379430770874,
-0.5520281195640564,
-0.579753041267395,
0.15634821355342865,
-0.4886877238750458,
-0.17169344425201416,
-1.0254414081573486,
-0.12267416715621948,
-0.5023146867752075,
-0.2679700553417206,
-0.44572460651397705,
-0.7565069198608398,
-0.3329106271266937,
0.07849399000406265,
0.47926029562950134,
0.6183116436004639,
-0.21218590438365936,
-0.03315801918506622,
-1.0435081720352173,
0.7064590454101562,
0.36992257833480835,
0.0003104090574197471,
-0.20181912183761597,
-0.033860914409160614,
-0.2108452320098877,
0.027684960514307022,
-0.8146606683731079,
-0.9381071329116821,
0.3785405158996582,
0.32478371262550354,
0.6366568207740784,
0.5485469102859497,
-0.17499645054340363,
0.34208789467811584,
-0.9556342959403992,
0.8635764718055725,
0.3242124617099762,
-0.735388457775116,
1.2558903694152832,
-0.7857919335365295,
-0.1391206681728363,
0.7669967412948608,
0.7292607426643372,
-0.13280095160007477,
-0.5465927720069885,
-0.8335196375846863,
-1.2882323265075684,
0.4162781834602356,
0.27901291847229004,
0.12392769008874893,
-0.2455352395772934,
0.7372336983680725,
0.3686988353729248,
0.5379356145858765,
-0.23535123467445374,
-0.5620750188827515,
-0.5445482134819031,
-0.0906149297952652,
0.14895059168338776,
-0.26955321431159973,
-0.34795427322387695,
-0.3401983082294464,
0.7048006057739258,
-0.1575864553451538,
0.5728906989097595,
0.39564380049705505,
0.07981796562671661,
-0.09123304486274719,
-0.07215408235788345,
0.8942804932594299,
1.081377387046814,
-0.29737725853919983,
-0.17427194118499756,
-0.23833198845386505,
-0.5575801730155945,
0.2632017433643341,
0.23600950837135315,
-0.3658330738544464,
0.37271398305892944,
0.02433972992002964,
0.491582989692688,
0.17680992186069489,
-0.6661720871925354,
0.31912699341773987,
0.1270757019519806,
-0.002242123242467642,
-0.05179498717188835,
0.23500211536884308,
0.3512401878833771,
0.15597255527973175,
0.6210028529167175,
-0.0338970348238945,
0.5893749594688416,
-0.4901309013366699,
0.7320572137832642,
0.11999503523111343,
-0.1203559935092926,
-0.23442155122756958,
0.8022040724754333,
0.43330878019332886,
-0.3269725739955902,
0.3061763644218445,
-0.38251954317092896,
-0.18256635963916779,
0.7746907472610474,
0.3165152072906494,
0.7287626266479492,
-0.12906081974506378,
0.6177453398704529,
0.4541453719139099,
-0.32781562209129333,
0.20988969504833221,
0.007772411219775677,
-0.19882847368717194,
-0.23529188334941864,
-0.18553556501865387,
-0.7402280569076538,
-0.7966976165771484,
-0.313068687915802,
-0.4884905517101288,
0.07851098477840424,
-0.2553654909133911,
-0.5625553131103516,
0.391614705324173,
-0.08650270849466324,
-0.17505167424678802,
0.595129132270813,
-0.18893198668956757,
1.0046632289886475,
-0.3153945803642273,
0.6564054489135742,
1.1969804763793945,
-0.746852695941925,
-0.2956352233886719,
0.11475998163223267,
-0.18296122550964355,
-0.373434841632843,
0.9741274118423462,
-0.2283032238483429,
0.09172140806913376,
-0.035956770181655884,
-0.3910587728023529,
-0.8694382905960083,
1.1193616390228271,
0.03197348862886429,
-0.37696605920791626,
-0.28438645601272583,
-0.12032433599233627,
0.48628535866737366,
-0.2668813169002533,
0.23882336914539337,
-0.21892589330673218,
0.42188936471939087,
0.16440311074256897,
-0.6236479878425598,
0.014055370353162289,
-0.49169090390205383,
-0.16774362325668335,
-0.07306056469678879,
-0.8604723811149597,
0.5783091187477112,
0.026539629325270653,
0.1618233323097229,
-0.07598260790109634,
0.6322556734085083,
0.5486514568328857,
0.8746325969696045,
-0.05742081627249718,
0.43672317266464233,
1.1380544900894165,
0.03703757002949715,
0.9325929284095764,
-0.8857313394546509,
0.15437465906143188,
0.7098535895347595,
-0.2566267251968384,
0.5170121192932129,
0.3819464147090912,
-0.21530625224113464,
0.3370117247104645,
0.862887442111969,
0.0406632274389267,
0.8049744367599487,
0.15867304801940918,
-0.35310447216033936,
-0.027165140956640244,
-0.17740334570407867,
-0.7092140316963196,
0.24625881016254425,
0.6496556401252747,
-0.3923611342906952,
-0.14455294609069824,
-0.00561058335006237,
-0.29230552911758423,
-0.07998541742563248,
-0.19894443452358246,
0.5459843873977661,
0.20953623950481415,
-0.5960158705711365,
0.04755500331521034,
0.33573299646377563,
0.4376310706138611,
-0.4704636037349701,
-0.023231714963912964,
-0.27230483293533325,
-0.4061466157436371,
-0.26280418038368225,
-0.612859308719635,
0.6714103817939758,
0.039890822023153305,
-0.7153679728507996,
-0.3310029208660126,
1.0108273029327393,
-0.19652286171913147,
-0.31213825941085815,
-0.2642575800418854,
0.7330759763717651,
0.27001816034317017,
0.06886831670999527,
-0.7949728965759277,
-0.3539833724498749,
-0.1305762678384781,
-0.26024675369262695,
0.2876288890838623,
0.6502848863601685,
-0.17504119873046875,
0.687480092048645,
0.7689958810806274,
0.41556668281555176,
-0.12907642126083374,
-0.2852955460548401,
0.8531399965286255,
-0.9672276377677917,
-0.4661576747894287,
-0.40798303484916687,
0.42465919256210327,
-0.3539355993270874,
-0.4289313554763794,
0.5495393872261047,
0.7606971859931946,
0.5149996876716614,
-0.23903024196624756,
0.6029952168464661,
-0.2435120791196823,
0.7183750867843628,
-0.3159111440181732,
1.2062591314315796,
-0.9321812391281128,
-0.0599246472120285,
-0.25137126445770264,
-0.6967888474464417,
-0.21132057905197144,
0.6389939188957214,
0.04601016640663147,
-0.11845529824495316,
0.6471251845359802,
0.5427768230438232,
-0.15564149618148804,
-0.01572299189865589,
-0.054801780730485916,
-0.12978732585906982,
0.10569506138563156,
-0.012793591246008873,
0.5816569328308105,
-0.04417026787996292,
-0.24180787801742554,
-0.3986779451370239,
-0.2259773463010788,
-0.6028318405151367,
-0.831245481967926,
-0.5363776683807373,
-0.7889912724494934,
-0.6278229355812073,
-0.3217601180076599,
0.3821038603782654,
0.8864780068397522,
0.9725298881530762,
-0.8900079131126404,
0.05287206918001175,
-0.30892249941825867,
0.12788508832454681,
0.3332182765007019,
-0.26979556679725647,
0.5790957808494568,
-0.40212520956993103,
-0.3713107407093048,
0.41631704568862915,
0.6475124359130859,
-0.16208721697330475,
-0.22299161553382874,
0.09099069982767105,
-0.15240253508090973,
-0.018462682142853737,
0.4124929904937744,
0.4887526035308838,
-0.600962221622467,
0.2854074239730835,
0.1205466166138649,
-0.40889209508895874,
0.12478918582201004,
1.0282701253890991,
-0.5531293749809265,
0.12391438335180283,
0.2830717861652374,
0.7373557090759277,
0.6080265045166016,
0.03560926020145416,
0.5602692365646362,
-0.4502938985824585,
0.22222845256328583,
0.3986482620239258,
0.1377662718296051,
0.19764909148216248,
-0.7245959043502808,
0.6689371466636658,
0.648482084274292,
-0.45720189809799194,
-0.780217170715332,
-0.084035724401474,
-0.9057026505470276,
-0.41394031047821045,
0.9682663679122925,
0.07651153206825256,
-0.14553993940353394,
-0.05916808918118477,
-0.12160533666610718,
0.4798998236656189,
-0.6115803122520447,
0.8420568108558655,
0.32449662685394287,
-0.388470858335495,
0.33557024598121643,
-0.6122545599937439,
0.3315553069114685,
0.14823265373706818,
-1.0057331323623657,
-0.5359975695610046,
0.45474693179130554,
0.29416176676750183,
0.589629590511322,
0.7954765558242798,
-0.04416811466217041,
0.4082098603248596,
-0.06504305452108383,
0.2368832230567932,
0.1203172355890274,
-0.48393741250038147,
0.3518136143684387,
0.3180130124092102,
-0.16163542866706848,
0.11619561165571213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01790v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01790v1
|
Understanding Position Bias Effects on Fairness in Social Multi-Document Summarization
| 2024-05-03T00:19:31 | 2024-05-03T00:19:31 |
Olubusayo Olabisi, Ameeta Agrawal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Text summarization models have typically focused on optimizing aspects of
quality such as fluency, relevance, and coherence, particularly in the context
of news articles. However, summarization models are increasingly being used to
summarize diverse sources of text, such as social media data, that encompass a
wide demographic user base. It is thus crucial to assess not only the quality
of the generated summaries, but also the extent to which they can fairly
represent the opinions of diverse social groups. Position bias, a long-known
issue in news summarization, has received limited attention in the context of
social multi-document summarization. We deeply investigate this phenomenon by
analyzing the effect of group ordering in input documents when summarizing
tweets from three distinct linguistic communities: African-American English,
Hispanic-aligned Language, and White-aligned Language. Our empirical analysis
shows that although the textual quality of the summaries remains consistent
regardless of the input document order, in terms of fairness, the results vary
significantly depending on how the dialect groups are presented in the input
data. Our results suggest that position bias manifests differently in social
multi-document summarization, severely impacting the fairness of summarization
models.
|
[
-0.15837913751602173,
-0.38063812255859375,
0.6734488010406494,
0.513387143611908,
-0.31390565633773804,
0.27763426303863525,
-0.038848645985126495,
-0.5063857436180115,
0.6280534267425537,
0.06583790481090546,
0.0011917890515178442,
-0.5729098916053772,
-1.2349207401275635,
0.061303142458200455,
-0.41918808221817017,
1.2010377645492554,
0.1017565205693245,
0.14698906242847443,
0.04620044678449631,
-0.6489378213882446,
-0.1823735237121582,
-0.6740544438362122,
-0.295158326625824,
-0.15182949602603912,
0.5670433640480042,
0.32633328437805176,
0.9877935647964478,
0.5369281768798828,
0.2475018948316574,
0.2891658544540405,
-0.23491349816322327,
-0.2909460663795471,
-0.7146620154380798,
0.13908647000789642,
-0.18362116813659668,
-0.38745567202568054,
-0.5399152040481567,
0.2385607808828354,
0.7507158517837524,
0.9922909140586853,
0.013082283549010754,
0.18938416242599487,
0.21332480013370514,
0.7256500720977783,
-0.6777065992355347,
-0.21348457038402557,
-0.5577372908592224,
0.0061353216879069805,
-0.2522391676902771,
-0.1365005075931549,
-0.15903928875923157,
-0.7839579582214355,
0.18441247940063477,
-0.47328808903694153,
0.7882723212242126,
-0.30381330847740173,
0.9331580996513367,
-0.03687978908419609,
-0.7398075461387634,
-0.18100859224796295,
-0.3216623067855835,
0.6782767176628113,
-0.6656760573387146,
0.1679990440607071,
0.3283979296684265,
0.22091276943683624,
0.11525081843137741,
-0.16366136074066162,
-0.48581841588020325,
0.5360128283500671,
-0.1908329427242279,
0.32826822996139526,
0.22388137876987457,
-0.009853845462203026,
0.22767530381679535,
0.20877604186534882,
-0.42111343145370483,
0.07411347329616547,
-0.6264070272445679,
-0.07054797559976578,
0.7736440300941467,
-0.16712506115436554,
0.14942562580108643,
-0.4184613823890686,
0.11995099484920502,
0.07978877425193787,
-0.3772239685058594,
0.26671329140663147,
0.7208177447319031,
0.4305550158023834,
-0.27503839135169983,
0.7018656730651855,
-0.47952669858932495,
0.36303356289863586,
0.2864516079425812,
-0.20174680650234222,
0.5168566703796387,
-0.44021087884902954,
-0.027499811723828316,
0.3473314344882965,
0.8488708138465881,
0.9903966784477234,
0.24963261187076569,
0.03243616223335266,
-0.1394607126712799,
0.007081180345267057,
0.1149965152144432,
-0.5319033861160278,
0.3098776936531067,
0.2492319792509079,
-0.9944733381271362,
-0.4904182255268097,
0.36971917748451233,
-0.8802065849304199,
-0.6261662840843201,
-0.06518691033124924,
0.15155424177646637,
0.01973184570670128,
-0.2151443064212799,
-0.04065942391753197,
-0.5559689998626709,
0.17539314925670624,
0.4445880949497223,
-1.1457595825195312,
0.19161564111709595,
0.8278052806854248,
0.9853361248970032,
-0.15985515713691711,
-0.3482986390590668,
-0.5019187331199646,
0.30838528275489807,
-0.08112315833568573,
0.693417489528656,
-0.3512924909591675,
-0.562697172164917,
-0.004665641579777002,
-0.18625758588314056,
0.08198850601911545,
-0.30337730050086975,
0.42515313625335693,
-0.4221486747264862,
0.4689295291900635,
-0.7973736524581909,
-0.3408089876174927,
0.03368508815765381,
-0.11190464347600937,
-0.48702654242515564,
0.4867158830165863,
-0.09905408322811127,
-0.9222020506858826,
0.8449094891548157,
-0.36492884159088135,
-0.983561098575592,
-0.481950044631958,
-0.38501980900764465,
-0.29107412695884705,
0.5472620725631714,
0.31876373291015625,
0.43353819847106934,
0.3316274583339691,
0.24258540570735931,
-0.5536048412322998,
-0.6014351844787598,
0.1683882176876068,
-0.12893716990947723,
0.8502846956253052,
0.03102785535156727,
-0.29122194647789,
-0.14131946861743927,
-0.30281928181648254,
-0.4135225713253021,
0.11317482590675354,
-0.18107005953788757,
-0.6476905941963196,
0.13560603559017181,
-0.1463852971792221,
0.4246692955493927,
0.07102469354867935,
-0.44010233879089355,
-0.1802363097667694,
-0.27872616052627563,
0.12685438990592957,
0.9154698252677917,
0.04896434396505356,
1.0374476909637451,
-0.32326194643974304,
0.33121511340141296,
-0.1804916262626648,
0.30263179540634155,
0.11320435255765915,
-0.486322820186615,
-0.17903614044189453,
0.25490623712539673,
0.37741729617118835,
0.3514050841331482,
-0.384966641664505,
0.07359946519136429,
-0.3270565867424011,
-0.004773388151079416,
-0.5397745966911316,
-0.1295527070760727,
0.11303761601448059,
0.27075520157814026,
0.08360117673873901,
-0.20206469297409058,
0.032651666551828384,
-1.0505990982055664,
-0.5596186518669128,
-0.14862729609012604,
0.015067202039062977,
-0.13418979942798615,
0.18933819234371185,
0.23932228982448578,
0.8277837634086609,
-0.48450374603271484,
-0.19446729123592377,
-0.2822113037109375,
0.25408366322517395,
0.3005882799625397,
0.10160589963197708,
0.7292091846466064,
-0.9276838302612305,
-0.4157053828239441,
-0.2890942096710205,
-0.7081640362739563,
-0.5453580617904663,
0.05731847137212753,
-0.3611993193626404,
0.3785705864429474,
0.3672107458114624,
-0.4205396771430969,
0.6173467040061951,
0.6791613101959229,
-0.3708510100841522,
0.27985361218452454,
0.13295580446720123,
0.5656895637512207,
-1.2482850551605225,
-0.339671790599823,
0.01636882685124874,
-0.09316130727529526,
-0.32549187541007996,
-0.23774322867393494,
0.09463422745466232,
0.15471705794334412,
-0.2564450204372406,
0.40652796626091003,
-0.3900550901889801,
-0.5994718074798584,
-0.2829536199569702,
0.42802396416664124,
0.32181042432785034,
0.2742289900779724,
-0.10040966421365738,
0.5427910685539246,
0.037234216928482056,
-0.3743140995502472,
-0.4721490740776062,
0.06987650692462921,
-0.19771775603294373,
0.6657629013061523,
-0.7847996950149536,
-0.11879163235425949,
-0.516900897026062,
0.3230069577693939,
-0.9654785394668579,
-0.1634567677974701,
-0.12147794663906097,
-0.9078332185745239,
0.08056939393281937,
-0.17516568303108215,
-0.29556146264076233,
0.05673607438802719,
-0.676887571811676,
0.42029887437820435,
0.13346359133720398,
-0.2287304550409317,
0.4877345561981201,
0.8487256765365601,
-0.5374240279197693,
-1.0446292161941528,
-0.7356667518615723,
-0.16473603248596191,
-0.11310259997844696,
-0.6348673701286316,
0.579836368560791,
0.3071354925632477,
-0.7618173360824585,
0.07872874289751053,
-0.3623059391975403,
0.10678347200155258,
0.06897535920143127,
0.15929259359836578,
0.030401941388845444,
0.28278979659080505,
0.15372268855571747,
0.6034107804298401,
0.11603143066167831,
-0.19478346407413483,
0.15813706815242767,
0.32006749510765076,
0.19462880492210388,
-0.25819477438926697,
-0.0030178523156791925,
0.7321385145187378,
0.4028659760951996,
-0.3214552104473114,
1.0346976518630981,
0.4311559498310089,
-0.34991204738616943,
0.07674185931682587,
-0.5626943707466125,
0.02868090569972992,
-0.4381009638309479,
0.30543434619903564,
0.0019502657232806087,
-0.938539445400238,
0.9384652376174927,
0.7539148926734924,
0.48978477716445923,
0.5027623176574707,
0.32390278577804565,
-0.4790480136871338,
1.0323055982589722,
0.41958513855934143,
-0.22975504398345947,
0.7725059986114502,
0.038138993084430695,
0.20929266512393951,
-0.44329768419265747,
-0.021299423649907112,
-0.7635765671730042,
-0.6410360932350159,
-0.7320718765258789,
-0.05681052431464195,
0.30200132727622986,
-0.16354866325855255,
0.19237209856510162,
-0.10740973055362701,
-0.1975097954273224,
0.7137518525123596,
0.4867028594017029,
0.06163439154624939,
0.38160210847854614,
0.07313469797372818,
0.09422653913497925,
-0.06979227066040039,
-0.5849573016166687,
-0.5371534824371338,
1.0334429740905762,
0.13848359882831573,
0.4647873044013977,
0.46377676725387573,
1.0684469938278198,
0.6180061101913452,
0.3054264783859253,
-0.5676670670509338,
0.3079223334789276,
-0.5084186792373657,
-0.5075178742408752,
-0.3538565933704376,
-0.45985281467437744,
-0.9719878435134888,
0.6387099623680115,
-0.19041624665260315,
-0.5273630619049072,
0.6098181009292603,
-0.059565916657447815,
-0.32231953740119934,
0.0414232462644577,
-0.9482271075248718,
0.6782544255256653,
-0.147415891289711,
-0.2264760136604309,
-0.34576621651649475,
-0.6996262073516846,
0.4687668979167938,
-0.006822133436799049,
0.6300882697105408,
-0.4841170310974121,
0.05189545080065727,
0.8606905341148376,
-0.5789006352424622,
0.4349338412284851,
-0.4624796509742737,
-0.0005272068665362895,
-0.09877985715866089,
-0.1426873803138733,
0.16782140731811523,
0.13724276423454285,
-0.26664650440216064,
0.46773561835289,
-0.2912020683288574,
-0.7961673140525818,
-0.414911150932312,
0.6934509873390198,
-0.9272648096084595,
-0.6754091382026672,
-0.5128387212753296,
-0.4448079764842987,
-0.07668505609035492,
0.3365924060344696,
0.500292956829071,
0.5526587963104248,
-0.18115279078483582,
0.00811984483152628,
0.4608875811100006,
-0.37056154012680054,
0.5003232359886169,
0.3344634771347046,
-0.12525825202465057,
-0.3868509829044342,
0.6688790917396545,
0.6845152378082275,
0.3777528405189514,
0.2540530860424042,
-0.03530791401863098,
-0.2949187755584717,
-0.662611722946167,
-0.10034605115652084,
0.33913931250572205,
-0.7185635566711426,
0.08599091321229935,
-0.9139184951782227,
0.12853869795799255,
-0.9553645849227905,
-0.6375359296798706,
-0.10822772234678268,
-0.964151918888092,
0.02004801295697689,
-0.3464677631855011,
-0.13917002081871033,
0.6788944005966187,
0.027007976546883583,
0.44265756011009216,
-0.5730302333831787,
0.7072314023971558,
0.25068119168281555,
0.4188537299633026,
-0.008464370854198933,
-0.548895537853241,
-0.3198414444923401,
-0.14030538499355316,
-0.2892383337020874,
-1.1593443155288696,
0.009152249433100224,
-0.26659634709358215,
0.7174873948097229,
0.23479260504245758,
0.10728798806667328,
0.3148837089538574,
-0.3664226233959198,
0.694651186466217,
0.16304554045200348,
-0.8984856009483337,
0.4431364834308624,
-0.637664794921875,
0.5279003977775574,
0.9362600445747375,
-0.03491182252764702,
-0.7343852519989014,
-0.9444189667701721,
-0.5054094195365906,
-1.0488860607147217,
0.76495361328125,
0.21388103067874908,
-0.010541253723204136,
-0.062124088406562805,
0.11444572359323502,
0.3400367498397827,
0.34018605947494507,
-0.7399226427078247,
-0.24027062952518463,
-0.5678166747093201,
-0.20305001735687256,
-0.08287426829338074,
-0.3875129818916321,
-0.030858393758535385,
0.11244214326143265,
0.45651939511299133,
0.16656966507434845,
0.22574841976165771,
0.13357771933078766,
-0.37177911400794983,
0.0008645845809951425,
0.37582632899284363,
0.8096473813056946,
0.9712742567062378,
-0.3816579282283783,
-0.010615784674882889,
-0.21799105405807495,
-0.33774733543395996,
0.19517898559570312,
0.4255489706993103,
-0.41262000799179077,
0.4640010595321655,
0.36439836025238037,
0.2978723347187042,
-0.020928507670760155,
0.15247789025306702,
0.7245122790336609,
-0.39639419317245483,
-0.17403116822242737,
0.03619570657610893,
-0.04489220678806305,
-0.16341273486614227,
0.2045910805463791,
0.6537935733795166,
0.1534164994955063,
0.5325449705123901,
-0.43595919013023376,
-0.1157967820763588,
0.31230947375297546,
-0.033328328281641006,
-0.1418561190366745,
0.7875427603721619,
0.3942579925060272,
-0.1088564544916153,
0.20913173258304596,
-0.11951393634080887,
-0.4812716245651245,
0.6418542861938477,
-0.008279938250780106,
0.911713182926178,
-0.20070680975914001,
0.4035177230834961,
0.08704685419797897,
0.503287672996521,
-0.05699295923113823,
0.052351437509059906,
0.12923717498779297,
-0.8178537487983704,
-0.3470848500728607,
-0.3520161807537079,
-0.2868167757987976,
-0.5029700994491577,
-0.5988461375236511,
0.12091445922851562,
-0.3580765724182129,
-0.5293155908584595,
0.14730793237686157,
-0.22696445882320404,
-0.4641636610031128,
0.035548195242881775,
0.03925614058971405,
0.5281499624252319,
-0.9578690528869629,
0.3112311065196991,
0.558887779712677,
-0.22017896175384521,
-0.4826629161834717,
0.555797278881073,
0.3242546021938324,
-0.5691028833389282,
0.06646277755498886,
0.2199750542640686,
-0.10914269089698792,
-0.5453856587409973,
-0.3058348000049591,
-0.6854913830757141,
1.0219542980194092,
0.42858338356018066,
-0.15594512224197388,
-0.09510917961597443,
0.16243325173854828,
0.5058364868164062,
-0.08567071706056595,
0.1175045296549797,
0.2550020217895508,
0.12205179780721664,
-0.3414682149887085,
-0.9917594790458679,
-0.045834001153707504,
-0.29608723521232605,
0.0019125487888231874,
0.2623094916343689,
-1.07156240940094,
0.7419824600219727,
-0.23026737570762634,
-0.1791282594203949,
-0.7174437046051025,
0.6144601702690125,
0.3662687838077545,
0.7029867768287659,
0.39384597539901733,
0.12364663928747177,
0.8419753909111023,
-0.2805290222167969,
1.2963753938674927,
0.003920682705938816,
0.07755139470100403,
1.2491347789764404,
-0.49148839712142944,
0.2689596712589264,
0.46969103813171387,
0.07436545938253403,
0.32016289234161377,
0.568835437297821,
0.5015552639961243,
0.5978408455848694,
-0.1541779339313507,
-0.104051873087883,
0.30940836668014526,
-0.23466569185256958,
-0.6893853545188904,
0.14988085627555847,
0.19002209603786469,
-0.5577880144119263,
-0.17700481414794922,
-0.3949432373046875,
0.12776364386081696,
0.2905723750591278,
-0.45162323117256165,
0.5810619592666626,
0.15903310477733612,
-0.7141637206077576,
-0.15963776409626007,
0.3296548128128052,
0.771476686000824,
-0.36344844102859497,
0.27516207098960876,
-0.6197863221168518,
-0.15766862034797668,
-0.4053191542625427,
-0.9283713698387146,
0.44103553891181946,
-0.07597905397415161,
-0.5739805698394775,
-0.32098376750946045,
0.6160088181495667,
-0.3374066948890686,
-0.3412292003631592,
0.47688746452331543,
0.54457688331604,
-0.04660024866461754,
0.01661667227745056,
-0.4754190146923065,
-0.0013294103555381298,
-0.15819856524467468,
-0.17190159857273102,
0.44748562574386597,
0.5059040784835815,
-0.12087291479110718,
0.09643153101205826,
0.4230390787124634,
-0.006934347562491894,
0.09537134319543839,
0.5912265777587891,
0.5342662334442139,
-0.5069145560264587,
-0.9031282067298889,
-0.966719925403595,
0.42425405979156494,
-0.5432100892066956,
-0.08451870083808899,
1.0197020769119263,
0.5142980813980103,
0.8634181618690491,
0.33441999554634094,
0.9755436182022095,
-0.10544019192457199,
0.4827347695827484,
-0.34850358963012695,
0.9276114106178284,
-0.5162047147750854,
0.18965956568717957,
-0.737706184387207,
-1.000542402267456,
-0.22068525850772858,
0.43041884899139404,
-0.5419887900352478,
0.36377936601638794,
0.5411953330039978,
0.4342816472053528,
0.07980860024690628,
0.027562296018004417,
0.06060643121600151,
0.09586640447378159,
0.28266897797584534,
0.08038408309221268,
0.6113985776901245,
-0.23088711500167847,
0.415602445602417,
-0.09683162719011307,
-0.2466421276330948,
-0.2560112774372101,
-0.7266011834144592,
-0.7799842357635498,
-0.20691101253032684,
-0.060473859310150146,
-0.5385755300521851,
0.12779600918293,
0.8283295035362244,
0.4096210300922394,
-0.7418684959411621,
-0.2683102786540985,
0.577934980392456,
0.7867005467414856,
0.008315997198224068,
-0.33127155900001526,
0.3942287862300873,
0.05396755784749985,
-0.6897745728492737,
-0.2018251121044159,
0.33530551195144653,
0.10799037665128708,
0.27686628699302673,
-0.003889641957357526,
-0.14775967597961426,
-0.06767740100622177,
0.7132169008255005,
0.0012172393035143614,
-0.4049490690231323,
-0.2910495698451996,
0.05067041516304016,
-0.46447673439979553,
0.060527872294187546,
0.7110790610313416,
-0.2741751968860626,
0.29983681440353394,
0.6355867385864258,
0.3202306926250458,
0.2571347653865814,
0.4177248477935791,
0.8403785228729248,
-0.9087339043617249,
0.09220943599939346,
-0.1790035367012024,
0.5284018516540527,
0.3524073660373688,
-0.5581403970718384,
0.38130125403404236,
0.28356754779815674,
-0.4920448660850525,
-0.6154197454452515,
-0.1464971899986267,
-0.8945558071136475,
-0.31929606199264526,
1.1776894330978394,
0.28871744871139526,
0.10897540301084518,
-0.3343411087989807,
-0.035755764693021774,
0.4947763979434967,
-1.0011420249938965,
1.1344022750854492,
0.9208335876464844,
0.05119669437408447,
0.01793362945318222,
-0.4920857846736908,
0.21699954569339752,
0.39525413513183594,
-0.6913796067237854,
-0.04989292100071907,
0.786123514175415,
0.10932938754558563,
-0.03027866594493389,
1.1815338134765625,
-0.3432460129261017,
0.3937339186668396,
-0.47281625866889954,
-0.15993745625019073,
0.33738335967063904,
0.0032817304600030184,
-0.4887457489967346,
0.515902042388916,
-0.2061021476984024,
-0.16984979808330536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01783v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01783v1
|
Layers of technology in pluriversal design. Decolonising language technology with the LiveLanguage initiative
| 2024-05-02T23:52:39 | 2024-05-02T23:52:39 |
Gertraud Koch, Gábor Bella, Paula Helm, Fausto Giunchiglia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language technology has the potential to facilitate intercultural
communication through meaningful translations. However, the current state of
language technology is deeply entangled with colonial knowledge due to path
dependencies and neo-colonial tendencies in the global governance of artificial
intelligence (AI). Language technology is a complex and emerging field that
presents challenges for co-design interventions due to enfolding in assemblages
of global scale and diverse sites and its knowledge intensity. This paper uses
LiveLanguage, a lexical database, a set of services with particular emphasis on
modelling language diversity and integrating small and minority languages, as
an example to discuss and close the gap from pluriversal design theory to
practice. By diversifying the concept of emerging technology, we can better
approach language technology in global contexts. The paper presents a model
comprising of five layers of technological activity. Each layer consists of
specific practices and stakeholders, thus provides distinctive spaces for
co-design interventions as mode of inquiry for de-linking, re-thinking and
re-building language technology towards pluriversality. In that way, the paper
contributes to reflecting the position of co-design in decolonising emergent
technologies, and to integrating complex theoretical knowledge towards
decoloniality into language technology design.
|
[
-0.6631813049316406,
-0.8904011249542236,
0.037172798067331314,
0.23752795159816742,
-0.27825498580932617,
0.8412098288536072,
-0.3614301383495331,
-0.5951826572418213,
0.3606361746788025,
0.4097687602043152,
-0.40674400329589844,
-0.43871787190437317,
-0.28315985202789307,
0.006266888231039047,
-0.22088371217250824,
0.5275586247444153,
-0.19047114253044128,
-0.3344809114933014,
0.1504659801721573,
-0.14071860909461975,
-0.6169076561927795,
-0.28087317943573,
-0.5646740198135376,
-0.3720855414867401,
0.051186151802539825,
0.539422333240509,
0.9626328945159912,
0.1332458108663559,
0.282649427652359,
0.3053857386112213,
-0.24958553910255432,
0.25965121388435364,
-0.2271321564912796,
-0.08295177668333054,
-0.07249971479177475,
-0.40496954321861267,
-0.35052797198295593,
-0.05715440213680267,
0.3137797713279724,
0.8593047261238098,
0.02155030518770218,
0.1727256327867508,
0.17998768389225006,
0.2914746105670929,
-0.20550855994224548,
0.35879504680633545,
0.02557697892189026,
0.4094330072402954,
-0.0038982313126325607,
0.08782059699296951,
-0.26183757185935974,
-0.41541802883148193,
0.09236368536949158,
-0.5937731862068176,
-0.015346454456448555,
-0.05193369835615158,
0.5494450330734253,
0.19176509976387024,
-0.26957064867019653,
-0.34201061725616455,
-1.1552269458770752,
0.5532749891281128,
-0.4373709559440613,
0.3764720857143402,
0.4137081205844879,
0.25345316529273987,
0.10742191970348358,
-0.6325939893722534,
-0.37607672810554504,
-0.1597820520401001,
-0.09943441301584244,
0.023755040019750595,
0.10945706069469452,
-0.13746410608291626,
-0.10421361774206161,
0.433224081993103,
-0.32186880707740784,
0.2317444533109665,
-0.5348121523857117,
-0.3300286531448364,
0.48394596576690674,
-0.105853371322155,
0.7726938128471375,
0.08629211038351059,
-0.2500530183315277,
0.062268346548080444,
-0.7632289528846741,
0.0020456688944250345,
0.48584601283073425,
0.4265022575855255,
-0.5373105406761169,
0.23697501420974731,
-0.06946539878845215,
0.4636211097240448,
-0.21320275962352753,
-0.10751037299633026,
0.3387708067893982,
-0.7407504916191101,
0.11155112087726593,
0.20229288935661316,
0.5784292221069336,
-0.05217123404145241,
0.44295716285705566,
-0.3066382110118866,
-0.1585245132446289,
0.02739892341196537,
0.4491235017776489,
-0.34921473264694214,
-0.13477765023708344,
0.12610352039337158,
-0.24209347367286682,
-0.11220221221446991,
0.06041263788938522,
-0.5866460800170898,
-0.42444589734077454,
-0.18586978316307068,
0.2566335201263428,
-0.34393811225891113,
-1.0153769254684448,
0.24725815653800964,
-0.174334317445755,
0.03923601284623146,
0.08691179007291794,
-0.7996984720230103,
0.3935330808162689,
0.808761477470398,
0.8874385356903076,
0.31163471937179565,
-0.26542142033576965,
0.32836562395095825,
0.21748702228069305,
-0.22753413021564484,
0.5947796702384949,
-0.48788073658943176,
-0.8177733421325684,
0.19962000846862793,
0.04084828495979309,
0.23298044502735138,
-0.7087003588676453,
0.3904966413974762,
-0.5711577534675598,
0.19687628746032715,
-0.19986912608146667,
-0.057041656225919724,
-0.28994858264923096,
0.21263432502746582,
-0.9609404802322388,
0.7805317044258118,
0.10030707716941833,
-0.5191612839698792,
0.464839369058609,
-0.8722860813140869,
-0.9117437601089478,
0.6394602060317993,
-0.39739206433296204,
-0.5231054425239563,
0.14181676506996155,
-0.026835547760128975,
-0.03235900029540062,
-0.30983567237854004,
0.5892050862312317,
-0.02814028039574623,
-0.48368167877197266,
-0.0736648291349411,
-0.1501322090625763,
1.068337321281433,
0.3472079932689667,
-0.7275790572166443,
0.0672168955206871,
-0.8191006183624268,
-0.3229336738586426,
-0.009233999066054821,
-0.5319079160690308,
-0.5077863335609436,
-0.054746050387620926,
-0.06522924453020096,
0.2052101194858551,
0.32913804054260254,
-0.6708901524543762,
-0.07794154435396194,
-0.4909709692001343,
0.7982710003852844,
0.3156551718711853,
-0.25964924693107605,
0.8702096343040466,
-0.4276109039783478,
0.6991913318634033,
-0.03613819181919098,
0.48005765676498413,
0.13073207437992096,
-0.6649792790412903,
-0.6913505792617798,
-0.23783673346042633,
0.0552733913064003,
0.5315552949905396,
-0.9853375554084778,
0.42351043224334717,
-0.3333374261856079,
-0.4511798024177551,
-0.8241299986839294,
-0.13825024664402008,
0.3222917914390564,
0.031008316203951836,
0.260143518447876,
-0.3907129764556885,
-0.5750789046287537,
-0.8895581960678101,
-0.18388502299785614,
-0.19119903445243835,
0.15099647641181946,
0.28801125288009644,
0.3363761603832245,
-0.1497233361005783,
0.8060753345489502,
0.14480452239513397,
-0.20040525496006012,
-0.33858567476272583,
0.2821754515171051,
0.13904070854187012,
0.6325687766075134,
0.3988442122936249,
-0.9588900208473206,
-0.4356215000152588,
0.28667426109313965,
-0.9879379868507385,
-0.09539052844047546,
-0.11604108661413193,
0.17336982488632202,
0.09454848617315292,
0.3791710436344147,
-0.49949267506599426,
0.31278595328330994,
0.36230024695396423,
-0.13514696061611176,
0.013850218616425991,
-0.25677114725112915,
0.137149840593338,
-1.139182686805725,
0.036572810262441635,
-0.3856936991214752,
0.2764582335948944,
-0.7738007307052612,
0.5986044406890869,
-0.07096806168556213,
-0.3780456781387329,
-0.5653409957885742,
0.6514235734939575,
-0.6871982216835022,
-0.2409868687391281,
-0.0926537960767746,
0.1319376826286316,
0.0655285194516182,
0.025102507323026657,
-0.04747810214757919,
0.9096269011497498,
0.23393765091896057,
-0.41085124015808105,
0.39002254605293274,
0.21303704380989075,
-0.7128464579582214,
0.28807365894317627,
-0.5728498697280884,
0.15987466275691986,
0.124882273375988,
-0.04538946598768234,
-0.7293918132781982,
0.024491876363754272,
0.15633049607276917,
-0.2060743123292923,
0.06669945269823074,
0.17741762101650238,
-0.6358475685119629,
-0.3942328691482544,
-0.21550330519676208,
0.7822312116622925,
0.3867962956428528,
-0.2968635559082031,
0.8066685199737549,
0.9828758239746094,
-0.2938326299190521,
-0.47379669547080994,
-1.1950984001159668,
0.4274110198020935,
-0.1126735508441925,
-1.0114903450012207,
0.43221399188041687,
-0.14571154117584229,
-0.7131657600402832,
-0.0782984122633934,
0.23418743908405304,
0.018100086599588394,
0.543192446231842,
0.20126654207706451,
-0.1819315403699875,
-0.2452739030122757,
-0.0689978078007698,
0.252446711063385,
-0.04433700069785118,
-0.008747398853302002,
-0.418159157037735,
0.8243809938430786,
-0.06935540586709976,
-0.21658262610435486,
-0.44159963726997375,
0.6873570084571838,
0.5562808513641357,
-0.1639222949743271,
0.827419638633728,
0.5824569463729858,
-0.3501736521720886,
-0.35139280557632446,
-0.5268489122390747,
0.12421467155218124,
-0.5230483412742615,
-0.03468967229127884,
-0.716302216053009,
-1.1766237020492554,
0.9082686901092529,
-0.1960398256778717,
0.04035014659166336,
-0.027511026710271835,
0.5370113849639893,
0.1548677533864975,
0.48735836148262024,
1.0259819030761719,
0.18865860998630524,
0.5939379930496216,
-0.4103831648826599,
0.621881365776062,
-0.5082833170890808,
-0.5371130704879761,
-0.18404632806777954,
-0.2889741361141205,
-0.6699008345603943,
-0.3531421720981598,
0.49878814816474915,
-0.08143123984336853,
-0.27443286776542664,
0.4137304425239563,
-0.40229716897010803,
0.1722283959388733,
0.8267858028411865,
0.2132679969072342,
0.29766497015953064,
0.1868448704481125,
-0.3469744026660919,
0.18160907924175262,
-0.715985894203186,
-0.4146457314491272,
0.6254695057868958,
0.22515274584293365,
0.6668232679367065,
0.38898420333862305,
0.9014003872871399,
0.38810738921165466,
0.10735468566417694,
-0.6045225858688354,
0.6020482182502747,
-0.27289876341819763,
-0.5662625432014465,
-0.09046025574207306,
-0.06880683451890945,
-0.8007778525352478,
-0.08979231864213943,
0.09387046098709106,
-0.06293609738349915,
0.4633939266204834,
-0.19859641790390015,
-0.4759393334388733,
0.26565122604370117,
-0.8615416288375854,
0.6525944471359253,
-0.1339729130268097,
-0.4374332129955292,
-0.4459558427333832,
-0.5741227269172668,
0.3159131407737732,
-0.062074508517980576,
0.784674346446991,
0.19133643805980682,
0.03920631855726242,
0.5069296956062317,
-0.26327019929885864,
1.1963666677474976,
0.05533910542726517,
-0.5611457228660583,
0.6184977889060974,
0.3880167007446289,
0.00803140364587307,
-0.08114437013864517,
-0.23128703236579895,
0.30463331937789917,
-0.2807868421077728,
-0.45229172706604004,
-0.08532978594303131,
0.652844250202179,
-1.241127371788025,
-0.7572898864746094,
-0.006321078632026911,
-0.6144570708274841,
0.06487027555704117,
0.2507062554359436,
-0.11883777379989624,
0.2923441529273987,
-0.4781794250011444,
0.10287780314683914,
0.5476986765861511,
-0.49390771985054016,
0.5398640036582947,
0.4077119827270508,
0.0241494532674551,
-0.3539068400859833,
0.8964818716049194,
0.416774719953537,
0.3003861904144287,
0.40976792573928833,
0.08664098381996155,
-0.019521549344062805,
-0.4309132397174835,
-0.23150108754634857,
0.07274308055639267,
-0.8570214509963989,
0.3288779854774475,
-0.4503636658191681,
-0.428001344203949,
-0.6720886826515198,
-0.3374193608760834,
-0.20955798029899597,
-0.34569162130355835,
-0.36479660868644714,
-0.18085628747940063,
-0.007204453460872173,
1.0475510358810425,
-0.31676360964775085,
0.2432815432548523,
-0.6729123592376709,
0.10332094132900238,
0.15131016075611115,
0.25319814682006836,
-0.18792159855365753,
-0.35173535346984863,
-0.2682884931564331,
0.017150618135929108,
0.18547335267066956,
-0.38008201122283936,
0.4179583787918091,
-0.001733950455673039,
0.719978928565979,
-0.12122450768947601,
-0.012853610329329967,
0.3486854135990143,
-0.3906498849391937,
0.8992343544960022,
-0.16358211636543274,
-0.7192209362983704,
0.487276554107666,
-0.22040243446826935,
0.48035213351249695,
0.43185707926750183,
0.38584616780281067,
-0.6883522868156433,
-0.3517395257949829,
-0.6560969948768616,
-0.9795515537261963,
0.3886794447898865,
-0.33311277627944946,
0.31546977162361145,
0.13151536881923676,
0.17399834096431732,
0.5947706699371338,
0.34751084446907043,
-0.6765366196632385,
0.2322472482919693,
-0.29903197288513184,
-0.23096305131912231,
0.08292900770902634,
-0.1979697346687317,
-0.3701622188091278,
0.03778601437807083,
0.37470653653144836,
-0.005885504186153412,
0.16045290231704712,
-0.22626368701457977,
-0.2836071848869324,
0.03113033063709736,
0.2544674277305603,
0.627566397190094,
0.6864194869995117,
0.17724281549453735,
0.5277757048606873,
-0.3146364092826843,
-0.5346722602844238,
0.2239788919687271,
-0.06710846722126007,
-0.531526505947113,
-0.3048210144042969,
0.40863779187202454,
0.5936188101768494,
0.07780639827251434,
-0.19074662029743195,
0.06331226229667664,
-0.09903557598590851,
-0.10327742993831635,
-0.5183616280555725,
-0.06542344391345978,
0.24306753277778625,
0.40778982639312744,
0.03191070631146431,
0.11247602850198746,
-0.2518949508666992,
-0.8728040456771851,
0.23762226104736328,
0.3902895450592041,
-0.17931336164474487,
-0.5765605568885803,
0.6435310244560242,
0.8278557062149048,
-0.9743561148643494,
0.3261584937572479,
-0.13276468217372894,
-0.25399288535118103,
0.5756926536560059,
0.3965141177177429,
0.9557346105575562,
-0.22287483513355255,
0.5005642771720886,
0.08074941486120224,
0.6898899674415588,
0.13509562611579895,
0.7227058410644531,
-0.37645477056503296,
-0.8344292640686035,
-0.20890776813030243,
-0.48919677734375,
-0.17424960434436798,
-0.11648757010698318,
-0.19904610514640808,
0.15471148490905762,
-0.6871880888938904,
-0.2049388885498047,
-0.3671855926513672,
0.015145361423492432,
-0.5146723389625549,
-0.19421516358852386,
0.2877522110939026,
0.8019043207168579,
-1.0769562721252441,
0.7455830574035645,
0.6831617951393127,
-0.7734196782112122,
-0.37573426961898804,
0.018459968268871307,
-0.03799784556031227,
-0.9856086373329163,
0.8802712559700012,
-0.24431097507476807,
-0.3463550806045532,
0.29848819971084595,
-0.21101737022399902,
-0.8283473253250122,
1.0347509384155273,
0.2468159794807434,
-0.3162858188152313,
0.05956871807575226,
0.6132849454879761,
0.5727438926696777,
-0.28396064043045044,
0.11210894584655762,
0.4726162552833557,
0.4042809009552002,
-0.2536708414554596,
-1.2263855934143066,
0.15936504304409027,
-0.2701820731163025,
0.04540058225393295,
0.14529825747013092,
-0.8722559809684753,
0.9615686535835266,
0.04908575862646103,
-0.6407912373542786,
0.18977896869182587,
0.40155330300331116,
-0.11030816286802292,
-0.0018247801344841719,
0.27081140875816345,
0.5071296691894531,
0.3795784115791321,
-0.03168000653386116,
0.8469440340995789,
-0.6433498859405518,
0.16740372776985168,
0.6301107406616211,
-0.17549754679203033,
0.386190265417099,
0.357362300157547,
-0.08522669970989227,
0.6008514761924744,
0.5266174674034119,
0.3877827525138855,
0.48940059542655945,
0.10914096981287003,
-0.6025719046592712,
-0.11032937467098236,
-0.6911765933036804,
-0.33119821548461914,
0.3343878984451294,
0.52291339635849,
-0.12621359527111053,
-0.1390235722064972,
0.2655985653400421,
0.1503410041332245,
0.3457335829734802,
-0.08913987874984741,
0.7761286497116089,
0.09197472780942917,
-0.7911991477012634,
0.547936201095581,
-0.05789201706647873,
0.6821954846382141,
-0.20356278121471405,
-0.00791869405657053,
-0.5035799145698547,
0.26201939582824707,
-0.052423134446144104,
-0.9309548735618591,
0.32135242223739624,
-0.49131953716278076,
0.13096579909324646,
-0.4953259229660034,
0.720816969871521,
-0.5100633502006531,
-0.39680561423301697,
0.5414009094238281,
0.902806282043457,
0.0338398702442646,
0.41188469529151917,
-0.5982744693756104,
0.4201762080192566,
-0.2809942662715912,
0.28290411829948425,
0.1424257755279541,
0.5122029781341553,
-0.3521251082420349,
0.6198539733886719,
0.25062087178230286,
0.18006068468093872,
0.1303482949733734,
0.5651360750198364,
0.8217481970787048,
-0.5982980728149414,
-0.7416697144508362,
-0.6287999749183655,
0.37207692861557007,
-0.0982392281293869,
-0.22712185978889465,
0.6064234375953674,
0.3940715789794922,
1.2295657396316528,
0.07767869532108307,
1.00605309009552,
-0.26332345604896545,
0.060862358659505844,
-0.1809116005897522,
0.6841650009155273,
-0.27655842900276184,
0.3635600805282593,
0.05490095168352127,
-0.4822295904159546,
-0.43921035528182983,
0.3826351463794708,
-0.2800990045070648,
0.041435856372117996,
0.4866984486579895,
0.8541237711906433,
-0.11387356370687485,
0.3677157163619995,
0.29678672552108765,
0.2793901264667511,
0.48879897594451904,
0.37637582421302795,
1.1380302906036377,
-0.22489194571971893,
0.23549050092697144,
-0.5289596319198608,
-0.33451399207115173,
-0.16420671343803406,
-0.4495563805103302,
-0.7656099200248718,
-0.567229151725769,
-0.2027527540922165,
-0.19131264090538025,
0.04110386222600937,
0.7362626194953918,
0.5044599175453186,
-0.6755722165107727,
-0.6659525632858276,
-0.23200497031211853,
0.08646151423454285,
-0.14204366505146027,
-0.23928320407867432,
0.029132915660738945,
0.05393644794821739,
-0.667984127998352,
0.6210588216781616,
0.6438406109809875,
-0.13176709413528442,
-0.9599288702011108,
0.23676155507564545,
-0.5278180241584778,
-0.2846733331680298,
0.7545549869537354,
0.3788282573223114,
-0.810876727104187,
-0.4800705313682556,
0.004880114924162626,
0.10635769367218018,
0.004090395290404558,
1.174896001815796,
-0.8633938431739807,
0.570556104183197,
0.6712321639060974,
0.7438361644744873,
0.18450477719306946,
-0.3144330680370331,
0.6404629945755005,
-0.871681809425354,
0.5839229226112366,
0.40824875235557556,
0.20131729543209076,
0.5733001828193665,
-0.19620421528816223,
0.468002051115036,
0.6313410997390747,
-0.31611743569374084,
-0.7071558833122253,
0.5906807780265808,
-0.5115839838981628,
-0.48834073543548584,
1.0711393356323242,
-0.12802235782146454,
-0.35172170400619507,
-0.6289606690406799,
-0.09503432363271713,
0.4856405258178711,
-0.0949881374835968,
0.9044986963272095,
0.5764528512954712,
-0.005181984510272741,
-0.35095879435539246,
-0.5559518337249756,
0.33468157052993774,
0.3245975077152252,
-0.6632636785507202,
-0.1873081624507904,
0.10726957768201828,
0.23436035215854645,
0.6358141303062439,
0.6407089829444885,
-0.10380641371011734,
0.10061030089855194,
0.30431026220321655,
0.11398281902074814,
-0.039973821491003036,
-0.42087987065315247,
-0.13497230410575867,
0.46512648463249207,
0.05808902904391289,
-0.04143963009119034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01557v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01557v1
|
AI Governance and Accountability: An Analysis of Anthropic's Claude
| 2024-05-02T23:37:06 | 2024-05-02T23:37:06 |
Aman Priyanshu, Yash Maurya, Zuofei Hong
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
As AI systems become increasingly prevalent and impactful, the need for
effective AI governance and accountability measures is paramount. This paper
examines the AI governance landscape, focusing on Anthropic's Claude, a
foundational AI model. We analyze Claude through the lens of the NIST AI Risk
Management Framework and the EU AI Act, identifying potential threats and
proposing mitigation strategies. The paper highlights the importance of
transparency, rigorous benchmarking, and comprehensive data handling processes
in ensuring the responsible development and deployment of AI systems. We
conclude by discussing the social impact of AI governance and the ethical
considerations surrounding AI accountability.
|
[
-0.33706143498420715,
-0.682239830493927,
0.526865541934967,
-0.13006500899791718,
0.3237612247467041,
-0.12302274256944656,
0.3876035809516907,
-0.875540018081665,
0.14421239495277405,
0.7584069967269897,
-0.26423341035842896,
0.06329015642404556,
-0.9988982081413269,
0.028602495789527893,
-0.5296370983123779,
0.795179009437561,
-0.19068746268749237,
-0.3321119546890259,
-0.48862192034721375,
-0.23640625178813934,
-0.6583545804023743,
-0.41825103759765625,
-0.730202853679657,
-0.2490750104188919,
0.6533982753753662,
0.20595265924930573,
0.8879337906837463,
1.0460025072097778,
0.6720473766326904,
0.42352357506752014,
-0.22445465624332428,
-0.20698057115077972,
-0.439486026763916,
-0.23474529385566711,
-0.24589325487613678,
-0.1276552379131317,
-0.7277202010154724,
0.5616117715835571,
0.5849424600601196,
0.5398027896881104,
-0.28183963894844055,
0.427663654088974,
0.10407394915819168,
0.5378259420394897,
-0.8886405825614929,
0.5367566347122192,
-0.004446141421794891,
-0.22603833675384521,
0.020554829388856888,
0.0705261081457138,
-0.10727416723966599,
-0.5435837507247925,
0.4212149977684021,
-0.7722288370132446,
-0.5746720433235168,
0.2666231393814087,
0.6182262301445007,
0.49091836810112,
-0.6759469509124756,
-0.33144593238830566,
-0.9622721672058105,
0.6367564797401428,
-0.054883867502212524,
-0.05541699752211571,
0.40408217906951904,
0.4251180589199066,
0.2645595669746399,
-0.9471343755722046,
-0.47304633259773254,
0.08702708780765533,
-0.02106436900794506,
0.14407499134540558,
-0.4031830430030823,
-0.08582227677106857,
-0.07349696010351181,
0.3350594639778137,
-0.21405959129333496,
0.07873205840587616,
-0.8295175433158875,
-0.6497918367385864,
0.8903939723968506,
0.22845777869224548,
0.34729069471359253,
-0.007015360053628683,
-0.41772139072418213,
-0.3782699406147003,
-0.5864647030830383,
0.40710800886154175,
0.5973603129386902,
0.07080785930156708,
-0.4741525948047638,
0.28234735131263733,
0.04060766100883484,
0.4595959782600403,
-0.40566402673721313,
0.47948741912841797,
-0.12284646928310394,
-0.11201667040586472,
0.026713142171502113,
0.43149080872535706,
0.465471476316452,
0.4532899558544159,
0.5214679837226868,
-0.15111267566680908,
-0.045007895678281784,
0.527385950088501,
0.8594631552696228,
-0.5555376410484314,
-0.1652572602033615,
0.6207507848739624,
-0.34456971287727356,
-0.6810687780380249,
0.685817539691925,
-0.5537037253379822,
-0.4411751329898834,
-0.5420892834663391,
0.6351684927940369,
-0.11628756672143936,
-0.20611968636512756,
-0.12788620591163635,
-0.1147654801607132,
0.5256983041763306,
0.49094489216804504,
-0.5102188587188721,
0.16640017926692963,
0.7728268504142761,
0.5156866908073425,
0.24812692403793335,
-0.3054552674293518,
-0.8407059907913208,
0.35376784205436707,
-0.7651859521865845,
0.290025919675827,
-0.5152187943458557,
-0.3462255895137787,
0.08808218687772751,
0.1885041445493698,
0.245901420712471,
-0.24017120897769928,
0.1791023164987564,
-0.32348302006721497,
-0.005675042048096657,
-0.2869448959827423,
-0.4051584303379059,
-0.724416971206665,
0.49747055768966675,
-0.4134262800216675,
0.3688904345035553,
-0.01156594417989254,
-0.43911466002464294,
0.33208638429641724,
-1.0580159425735474,
-0.0741155594587326,
0.12306700646877289,
-0.24313805997371674,
-0.3374024033546448,
0.0731518417596817,
0.07936891913414001,
0.1675761491060257,
-0.1822572499513626,
0.14969530701637268,
-0.39426085352897644,
-0.517017662525177,
-0.11593440920114517,
-0.20302119851112366,
1.2874292135238647,
-0.020389972254633904,
-0.3340972065925598,
0.32156091928482056,
-0.6238764524459839,
0.13386113941669464,
-0.18038310110569,
-0.03701694309711456,
-0.19619035720825195,
0.28869619965553284,
0.013009575195610523,
0.015409009531140327,
0.1923314779996872,
-0.4354023337364197,
0.00782601349055767,
-0.039005864411592484,
0.9000881314277649,
1.1206178665161133,
0.24767906963825226,
0.4489688575267792,
-0.4765458405017853,
0.3498480021953583,
-0.4813492000102997,
0.7731847763061523,
0.017199968919157982,
-0.3491881489753723,
-0.3183490037918091,
-0.31771647930145264,
0.6740526556968689,
0.8880290985107422,
-0.2859712839126587,
0.4549069106578827,
-0.24930177628993988,
-0.6098694205284119,
-0.547336995601654,
-0.5572540760040283,
-0.09199462831020355,
0.32792049646377563,
-0.07657156884670258,
-0.6134713292121887,
0.15129272639751434,
-1.1846590042114258,
-0.029147550463676453,
-0.6453208923339844,
0.155461385846138,
0.5756543278694153,
0.7632667422294617,
-0.7919918894767761,
0.6325812339782715,
0.135493665933609,
-0.3915725648403168,
0.31040969491004944,
0.3355485796928406,
-0.1571427881717682,
0.9581294655799866,
0.6417761445045471,
-0.903846025466919,
-0.05818682163953781,
0.039610717445611954,
-1.0477553606033325,
0.25559717416763306,
0.3067001700401306,
-0.08267004042863846,
-0.3607126474380493,
0.5034096837043762,
-0.3207070231437683,
0.7719511985778809,
0.3213624358177185,
-0.34472694993019104,
0.37468406558036804,
-0.3355083465576172,
0.4065589904785156,
-0.563854992389679,
0.6663861870765686,
-0.642895519733429,
-0.41186943650245667,
-0.6645335555076599,
0.41107165813446045,
-0.07013490796089172,
-0.444813072681427,
-0.45407503843307495,
0.3134527802467346,
-0.06577924638986588,
-0.32433873414993286,
-0.01575118489563465,
0.22497785091400146,
0.09434162825345993,
-0.177059605717659,
-0.26797574758529663,
0.7295997142791748,
0.9467630386352539,
-0.9492788910865784,
0.39691421389579773,
0.658582329750061,
-0.13902345299720764,
0.8328723311424255,
-1.0066628456115723,
0.05828527361154556,
-0.304118275642395,
0.19575025141239166,
-0.6492742896080017,
-0.24883641302585602,
0.26049724221229553,
-0.6072590351104736,
0.22896569967269897,
0.09616070985794067,
-0.49184948205947876,
-0.042641837149858475,
-0.37426161766052246,
0.3294640779495239,
0.2631438374519348,
-0.27968937158584595,
0.9015679955482483,
0.9290890693664551,
-0.07070396840572357,
-0.5497196912765503,
-0.6545660495758057,
0.22990287840366364,
-0.4483143389225006,
-0.6085431575775146,
-0.04174087941646576,
0.08181146532297134,
-0.6997826099395752,
0.1752052754163742,
0.07811102271080017,
0.2512449324131012,
0.5651146769523621,
0.26538971066474915,
-0.0798817053437233,
0.06482943147420883,
-0.3603939712047577,
-0.5049809813499451,
-0.5935225486755371,
0.5763106346130371,
-0.17462868988513947,
-0.124688059091568,
-0.31643012166023254,
0.05841156467795372,
-0.811668872833252,
0.6576756834983826,
1.100590705871582,
-0.38893792033195496,
0.6677383780479431,
0.5243107080459595,
-0.422288179397583,
0.3169790506362915,
-0.10758762061595917,
-0.43370136618614197,
-0.44242966175079346,
-0.16530436277389526,
0.20869086682796478,
-0.3742280602455139,
0.8666769862174988,
-0.15723267197608948,
0.4782792329788208,
0.7075923085212708,
0.40200960636138916,
-0.37234005331993103,
0.6627892851829529,
1.183944582939148,
-0.3621116280555725,
0.26139360666275024,
-0.38555002212524414,
0.2571898102760315,
-0.7066377401351929,
-0.08020221441984177,
-0.507154643535614,
-0.372445672750473,
-1.3279616832733154,
-0.03549117222428322,
0.7863607406616211,
-0.27330508828163147,
-0.6783352494239807,
0.01871369034051895,
-0.6829981207847595,
0.30294814705848694,
0.9147343039512634,
-0.05620022118091583,
0.1281224489212036,
-0.18282637000083923,
0.3429807722568512,
0.3373854160308838,
-0.7004359364509583,
-0.869560956954956,
0.8940027356147766,
0.36745312809944153,
0.5293299555778503,
0.46120935678482056,
0.6211026310920715,
0.8705114722251892,
0.45210590958595276,
-0.19916032254695892,
0.15867431461811066,
0.08237844705581665,
-0.995452344417572,
-0.5062587261199951,
-0.21850107610225677,
-0.937727689743042,
-0.026231059804558754,
-0.2856843173503876,
-1.132595419883728,
0.4930785596370697,
0.4226309657096863,
-0.37168240547180176,
0.2700018584728241,
-0.4154132306575775,
0.8867196440696716,
0.07371564954519272,
-0.5458258986473083,
-0.4988676607608795,
-0.9990200996398926,
0.2520345449447632,
0.32784461975097656,
0.37291842699050903,
0.0379694439470768,
0.04584461450576782,
0.5211542248725891,
-0.47390085458755493,
0.7391687631607056,
-0.07719194144010544,
0.13640770316123962,
0.6104097366333008,
0.22284159064292908,
0.7806950807571411,
0.26664477586746216,
0.06925402581691742,
0.2979559004306793,
0.2836010158061981,
-0.6599524617195129,
-0.19620907306671143,
0.5284538269042969,
-1.0800317525863647,
-0.5356658697128296,
-0.8902895450592041,
-0.31721171736717224,
0.029908562079072,
0.05130913853645325,
0.17222033441066742,
0.5901254415512085,
-0.4045757055282593,
0.3992469012737274,
0.8471986055374146,
-0.30450499057769775,
0.45168158411979675,
0.2621394991874695,
0.12305913120508194,
-0.42853420972824097,
0.9278300404548645,
0.12241265922784805,
0.14769437909126282,
0.017388364300131798,
0.14590148627758026,
-0.009020580910146236,
-0.14742785692214966,
-0.6170355081558228,
-0.34091314673423767,
-0.4532647430896759,
-0.08291022479534149,
-0.3916883170604706,
-0.18455365300178528,
-0.19111405313014984,
-0.4631495773792267,
-0.5264326930046082,
-0.1990187168121338,
-0.026087993755936623,
0.11863884329795837,
0.2742067277431488,
1.0264664888381958,
-0.5200977921485901,
0.25777629017829895,
-0.2602425217628479,
0.11358518153429031,
0.5234565734863281,
0.32354187965393066,
-0.3006870150566101,
0.042298927903175354,
0.08587232232093811,
-0.07350943237543106,
-0.33979544043540955,
-0.5235657095909119,
-0.12769533693790436,
-0.03039349988102913,
0.46562033891677856,
0.5080966949462891,
0.09322504699230194,
0.30310818552970886,
-0.41297081112861633,
0.7555211782455444,
-0.06101858615875244,
-1.0034887790679932,
0.5284595489501953,
-0.5385169386863708,
0.04143434390425682,
0.5136403441429138,
0.016230059787631035,
-0.40164321660995483,
-0.505280077457428,
-0.8769820928573608,
-1.04719078540802,
0.6965128779411316,
0.5748193860054016,
0.3066062927246094,
0.5654674768447876,
0.42746108770370483,
-0.14622485637664795,
0.37652909755706787,
-0.6238123178482056,
-0.285451740026474,
-0.03364327922463417,
0.37766554951667786,
-0.3382342457771301,
-0.004639343824237585,
-0.3868633508682251,
-0.004173271358013153,
0.7638652920722961,
0.2579779326915741,
0.29964372515678406,
0.3281603455543518,
0.2011653333902359,
0.02055751532316208,
0.011021757498383522,
0.5531588196754456,
0.8735011219978333,
-0.053660567849874496,
-0.020891334861516953,
-0.23408973217010498,
-0.3361206650733948,
0.16533192992210388,
0.16564886271953583,
-0.34064245223999023,
-0.7048863768577576,
0.7605630159378052,
0.3287088871002197,
-0.2614748477935791,
-0.45251134037971497,
0.3264385163784027,
0.19692325592041016,
-0.3067971467971802,
-0.47165805101394653,
0.13822993636131287,
-0.22123873233795166,
0.3068370819091797,
0.17864647507667542,
0.08243431895971298,
0.36228111386299133,
-0.9879671931266785,
0.4553258419036865,
0.2073877900838852,
-0.677385151386261,
-0.15882150828838348,
1.173424243927002,
0.3217100203037262,
-0.25610116124153137,
0.7847145199775696,
0.12634550034999847,
-0.33834946155548096,
1.1279240846633911,
-0.23337522149085999,
0.7694312930107117,
-0.33402687311172485,
0.2921973764896393,
0.12311272323131561,
1.1012085676193237,
0.15116693079471588,
0.3569800853729248,
0.12950055301189423,
-0.36331430077552795,
-0.31302356719970703,
-0.16101598739624023,
-0.8033589124679565,
0.08734861016273499,
-0.8468853831291199,
-0.10981452465057373,
-0.467307984828949,
-0.1593121886253357,
0.19600436091423035,
0.112592414021492,
-0.4429404139518738,
0.1701909452676773,
-0.03597411513328552,
0.5329705476760864,
-0.7332428097724915,
0.12508784234523773,
0.8196018934249878,
-0.1475992202758789,
-0.31001901626586914,
0.08759577572345734,
0.32469838857650757,
-0.6802727580070496,
0.16229960322380066,
0.08065630495548248,
-0.11178278177976608,
-0.09894020110368729,
-0.6887723207473755,
-0.8510600328445435,
1.0131139755249023,
0.5098275542259216,
-0.166559636592865,
0.623519241809845,
-0.002684687962755561,
0.5001035928726196,
-0.3989001214504242,
-0.17449422180652618,
0.21675272285938263,
1.076317548751831,
-0.546351969242096,
-0.7684460282325745,
-0.3907487988471985,
0.014884915202856064,
-0.07255212962627411,
0.14902901649475098,
-0.8979845643043518,
0.6448377966880798,
-0.20700030028820038,
-0.015129742212593555,
-0.37259361147880554,
0.4312279224395752,
-0.1290198117494583,
0.3902631402015686,
0.36773332953453064,
0.23536035418510437,
0.5528401136398315,
-0.06240710988640785,
1.5141713619232178,
-0.4009571969509125,
0.1318637579679489,
0.3438452482223511,
-0.09774792194366455,
0.43471741676330566,
0.3690326511859894,
-0.06416685879230499,
0.19877752661705017,
0.8195818066596985,
0.1889813393354416,
0.4011511206626892,
0.25812187790870667,
0.24496394395828247,
-0.07302676886320114,
-0.2879161834716797,
0.08960988372564316,
0.936287522315979,
0.31612586975097656,
-0.10854990035295486,
-0.07233146578073502,
-0.09619397670030594,
-0.3113878071308136,
0.3179841637611389,
-0.6335495114326477,
0.8424567580223083,
-0.1137891486287117,
-0.3354794681072235,
-0.01024727150797844,
-0.01928161270916462,
-0.3971642255783081,
-0.28817352652549744,
-0.21155858039855957,
0.08488497138023376,
0.02549542672932148,
0.1524110734462738,
-0.422573059797287,
0.610771894454956,
-0.20270539820194244,
-0.09059736132621765,
-0.44590646028518677,
0.07836403697729111,
-0.01498202420771122,
-0.5150084495544434,
0.33045870065689087,
0.5839956402778625,
0.0005236331489868462,
0.20890845358371735,
-0.6265841126441956,
0.3251584768295288,
-0.391018271446228,
-0.0708615630865097,
-0.20241832733154297,
0.21271757781505585,
-0.4306560754776001,
0.912234902381897,
0.07859672605991364,
-0.01711869426071644,
-0.4731465280056,
-0.6986216306686401,
0.49780112504959106,
-0.2897651791572571,
-1.0321872234344482,
-0.7321740388870239,
0.47688552737236023,
-0.13731418550014496,
-0.369445264339447,
0.3177262246608734,
0.3367554545402527,
0.18773111701011658,
0.3871099650859833,
0.8248479962348938,
-0.5147285461425781,
-0.006969669833779335,
-0.19688187539577484,
0.8566755652427673,
-0.6789236664772034,
0.20170845091342926,
-0.06757423281669617,
-0.9175853133201599,
-0.22352460026741028,
0.57272869348526,
-0.19871719181537628,
-0.04844147711992264,
0.07006499171257019,
0.3230508863925934,
-0.1673198789358139,
-0.08612295240163803,
0.1310630887746811,
0.3767170011997223,
0.2802152633666992,
-0.07088515162467957,
0.6285111904144287,
-0.6190954446792603,
0.16381633281707764,
-0.004264327697455883,
-0.35388535261154175,
-0.19244427978992462,
-0.9367625713348389,
-0.5297783017158508,
-0.6221887469291687,
-0.636506199836731,
-0.34938299655914307,
0.26579710841178894,
0.18623247742652893,
0.898339569568634,
-1.0616661310195923,
-0.09727733582258224,
-0.10278961807489395,
0.3937215209007263,
-0.6573671102523804,
-0.22745199501514435,
0.5738203525543213,
0.12055305391550064,
-0.7357051968574524,
0.028791651129722595,
0.659770131111145,
-0.11767805367708206,
-0.3483070433139801,
0.07838153839111328,
0.03413933888077736,
0.40910178422927856,
0.45100224018096924,
0.3130207359790802,
-0.6312428712844849,
-0.94456946849823,
-0.3741665780544281,
-0.0359087735414505,
-0.2542613744735718,
0.6387283205986023,
-0.369562029838562,
0.5536320805549622,
0.248813197016716,
0.6415578722953796,
0.11406683176755905,
-0.009962346404790878,
1.0793250799179077,
-0.10604999214410782,
0.1545620709657669,
0.3272332549095154,
0.11540645360946655,
0.01603834703564644,
-0.6006502509117126,
0.9382991790771484,
-0.11550113558769226,
-0.8316811323165894,
-0.9247274994850159,
0.18046443164348602,
-0.7874745726585388,
-0.04702470824122429,
0.4438440501689911,
-0.004535140935331583,
-0.21999682486057281,
-0.13358847796916962,
0.09252879023551941,
-0.19334371387958527,
-0.2619364261627197,
1.2026928663253784,
0.7789515256881714,
-0.2268897145986557,
-0.09944630414247513,
-1.0497217178344727,
0.41912075877189636,
-0.20572297275066376,
-0.6038739681243896,
0.2919459640979767,
0.3615599274635315,
0.007236534729599953,
0.4009803533554077,
0.398477166891098,
-0.19922618567943573,
0.42061880230903625,
0.0674087181687355,
-0.07196944206953049,
0.06847066432237625,
-0.4709396958351135,
-0.175713449716568,
0.09913002699613571,
-0.40442901849746704,
-0.18575690686702728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16890v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16890v1
|
TextAge: A Curated and Diverse Text Dataset for Age Classification
| 2024-05-02T23:37:03 | 2024-05-02T23:37:03 |
Shravan Cheekati, Mridul Gupta, Vibha Raghu, Pranav Raj
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Age-related language patterns play a crucial role in understanding linguistic
differences and developing age-appropriate communication strategies. However,
the lack of comprehensive and diverse datasets has hindered the progress of
research in this area. To address this issue, we present TextAge, a curated
text dataset that maps sentences to the age and age group of the producer, as
well as an underage (under 13) label. TextAge covers a wide range of ages and
includes both spoken and written data from various sources such as CHILDES,
Meta, Poki Poems-by-kids, JUSThink, and the TV show "Survivor." The dataset
undergoes extensive cleaning and preprocessing to ensure data quality and
consistency. We demonstrate the utility of TextAge through two applications:
Underage Detection and Generational Classification. For Underage Detection, we
train a Naive Bayes classifier, fine-tuned RoBERTa, and XLNet models to
differentiate between language patterns of minors and young-adults and over.
For Generational Classification, the models classify language patterns into
different age groups (kids, teens, twenties, etc.). The models excel at
classifying the "kids" group but struggle with older age groups, particularly
"fifties," "sixties," and "seventies," likely due to limited data samples and
less pronounced linguistic differences. TextAge offers a valuable resource for
studying age-related language patterns and developing age-sensitive language
models. The dataset's diverse composition and the promising results of the
classification tasks highlight its potential for various applications, such as
content moderation, targeted advertising, and age-appropriate communication.
Future work aims to expand the dataset further and explore advanced modeling
techniques to improve performance on older age groups.
|
[
0.008031424134969711,
-0.7293787002563477,
0.230962872505188,
0.41789332032203674,
-0.07693762332201004,
0.18016761541366577,
-0.2263949066400528,
-0.6291835904121399,
-0.40972161293029785,
0.617096483707428,
-0.5457308888435364,
-0.7823230028152466,
-0.46289148926734924,
-0.03804636746644974,
-0.5589409470558167,
0.8976753354072571,
0.1307353973388672,
-0.12250112742185593,
-0.3343221843242645,
0.06964027881622314,
-0.74996018409729,
-0.3160909414291382,
-0.7903639674186707,
-0.42027321457862854,
0.4063810110092163,
0.8128030896186829,
0.21268382668495178,
0.83502197265625,
0.13327279686927795,
0.350563645362854,
-0.25776737928390503,
0.32728609442710876,
-0.6178715825080872,
0.2767416834831238,
-0.23283611238002777,
-0.341823935508728,
-0.2542053163051605,
0.0633164793252945,
0.42143526673316956,
0.8610854148864746,
0.057679615914821625,
-0.12447977811098099,
0.06858821213245392,
0.748113751411438,
-0.4855453670024872,
0.07326915115118027,
-0.6736816167831421,
0.0887679010629654,
-0.6261703968048096,
-0.25265905261039734,
-0.5341910719871521,
-0.3995705544948578,
0.043315935879945755,
-0.40151840448379517,
0.0010264673037454486,
0.17028798162937164,
0.4211113154888153,
-0.10246392339468002,
-0.6554924249649048,
-0.4555402398109436,
-0.6363502144813538,
0.9763646125793457,
-0.43976324796676636,
0.14906369149684906,
0.9169427156448364,
0.1292174607515335,
0.02775348350405693,
-0.669801652431488,
-0.13800795376300812,
-0.005319257732480764,
-0.15173226594924927,
-0.11373601853847504,
-0.3935864567756653,
-0.2644190192222595,
-0.14916680753231049,
0.31014329195022583,
-0.850466251373291,
0.3291017413139343,
-0.6581971645355225,
-0.11339722573757172,
0.6120181679725647,
0.31034764647483826,
0.7859094738960266,
-0.3155164122581482,
-0.2095009982585907,
0.13485558331012726,
-0.5088303089141846,
0.07395444810390472,
0.5713703036308289,
0.6806016564369202,
-0.2493669092655182,
0.5174987316131592,
-0.5280266404151917,
0.6259382963180542,
-0.21564021706581116,
0.22006532549858093,
0.3482518196105957,
-0.23647096753120422,
0.0903548076748848,
0.2580774128437042,
0.8989996910095215,
0.4597969949245453,
0.8118665218353271,
-0.0945199728012085,
-0.1612870842218399,
0.07361215353012085,
0.1730363667011261,
-0.7296555638313293,
-0.46839696168899536,
-0.0011142579605802894,
-0.6930590271949768,
-0.5543513298034668,
-0.025429757311940193,
-1.152597427368164,
-0.4996185600757599,
-0.164426788687706,
0.018987203016877174,
-0.4818693995475769,
-0.06102542579174042,
0.3499218225479126,
-0.13720843195915222,
-0.22918400168418884,
0.16168245673179626,
-1.0031324625015259,
0.5002598762512207,
0.40299826860427856,
0.6389907002449036,
-0.4227757751941681,
-0.04637245833873749,
-0.3190183639526367,
-0.11071553081274033,
-0.31056347489356995,
0.7445425987243652,
-1.0225105285644531,
-0.5622669458389282,
0.20089998841285706,
0.19137024879455566,
-0.1381155252456665,
-0.5743756890296936,
0.6769302487373352,
-0.3026471734046936,
0.5979594588279724,
0.30453649163246155,
-0.4428730607032776,
-0.021075736731290817,
-0.07540709525346756,
-0.5951361060142517,
0.8716675043106079,
-0.10296764969825745,
-0.698980987071991,
0.5304479002952576,
-0.6136455535888672,
-0.4027389883995056,
0.38817620277404785,
-0.047455545514822006,
-0.31488940119743347,
-0.10002610087394714,
0.3515578508377075,
0.3933773338794708,
0.10820814967155457,
0.3507381081581116,
-0.05506223812699318,
-0.4186508357524872,
0.31316661834716797,
-0.765569269657135,
0.6619527339935303,
0.3743649423122406,
-0.08516918867826462,
0.021245304495096207,
-0.9161232113838196,
0.22379480302333832,
0.06995942443609238,
-0.4005812108516693,
-0.7482158541679382,
0.30016568303108215,
0.4522438049316406,
-0.14070674777030945,
0.28072822093963623,
-0.5617414712905884,
0.2788805067539215,
-0.1280217319726944,
0.6834465861320496,
0.2785947322845459,
-0.14227397739887238,
0.4976152181625366,
-0.5312262773513794,
0.4981074631214142,
0.08484810590744019,
0.11563262343406677,
-0.4957788586616516,
-0.6323462724685669,
-0.4009822607040405,
0.200766459107399,
0.1899150311946869,
0.8096035718917847,
-0.8598721027374268,
0.5647897124290466,
-0.5367884635925293,
-0.6223565340042114,
-0.05280764400959015,
0.17158199846744537,
0.3191485106945038,
-0.045956339687108994,
0.49914276599884033,
-0.17913822829723358,
-0.5689880847930908,
-0.5390323400497437,
-0.15011228621006012,
-0.1880200058221817,
-0.02798193134367466,
0.2666735351085663,
0.07061231136322021,
-0.5335659384727478,
0.8386170864105225,
-0.5332313776016235,
-0.46293893456459045,
-0.36176538467407227,
0.46643516421318054,
-0.10003940761089325,
0.9123513698577881,
0.4533560872077942,
-0.8599901795387268,
-0.4038751721382141,
0.20053312182426453,
-0.30933934450149536,
-0.5993351936340332,
0.08257698267698288,
0.019132167100906372,
0.0634649246931076,
0.5767215490341187,
-0.06888734549283981,
0.5020074844360352,
0.7630221843719482,
-0.7660086154937744,
0.0700557753443718,
-0.09642914682626724,
0.235481858253479,
-0.7495626211166382,
-0.11086854338645935,
0.08715163171291351,
-0.348111629486084,
-0.7776129841804504,
-0.5961910486221313,
-0.1446724385023117,
-0.20938487350940704,
-0.32759398221969604,
0.3566657602787018,
-0.28075945377349854,
0.4663987457752228,
-0.5324457287788391,
-0.06208058074116707,
0.05184929072856903,
-0.010906719602644444,
0.0460103303194046,
0.8524718880653381,
0.3894432485103607,
-0.28373414278030396,
0.21185769140720367,
0.14761608839035034,
-0.4096059799194336,
0.4722437262535095,
-0.6057740449905396,
0.3495790362358093,
-0.3864801824092865,
0.09331107139587402,
-0.9194280505180359,
-0.08873564004898071,
0.3359462022781372,
-0.4739725887775421,
0.13748836517333984,
-0.16232578456401825,
-0.1270630806684494,
-0.10398463159799576,
-0.23890848457813263,
0.5713669657707214,
0.2833952009677887,
-0.10223902016878128,
0.6036956310272217,
0.35055553913116455,
-0.5464450716972351,
-0.2827106714248657,
-0.9513697028160095,
0.001762145897373557,
-0.4029458165168762,
-0.49573376774787903,
0.41173550486564636,
0.018773742020130157,
-0.09780891984701157,
0.33933427929878235,
-0.009420000948011875,
-0.6357370615005493,
-0.1650489717721939,
0.2894304692745209,
-0.003936520777642727,
-0.1106451079249382,
0.36338120698928833,
0.3304443657398224,
-0.03386988490819931,
-0.21109050512313843,
-0.1207658126950264,
0.8167474865913391,
0.07177811115980148,
0.15086053311824799,
0.0064947353675961494,
0.6376429200172424,
0.3315550982952118,
-0.1481899619102478,
0.721152663230896,
0.4297025501728058,
-0.3607645034790039,
-0.5910515785217285,
-0.17152254283428192,
0.11677535623311996,
-0.48709118366241455,
-0.02608441188931465,
-0.22346721589565277,
-0.9715468287467957,
0.4203037619590759,
0.13820508122444153,
-0.1951146274805069,
0.308724045753479,
-0.0405413955450058,
-0.05696588382124901,
0.6800124049186707,
0.6930581331253052,
-0.017951227724552155,
0.6882873773574829,
-0.012744820676743984,
-0.2761227488517761,
-0.4626237750053406,
-0.36136335134506226,
-0.7525202631950378,
-0.24447864294052124,
-0.7526487708091736,
-0.2931423485279083,
-0.33267778158187866,
-0.15578293800354004,
0.032652534544467926,
0.3334096074104309,
-0.5516171455383301,
0.818053126335144,
0.3355284631252289,
0.18692265450954437,
0.4773619472980499,
-0.04050467908382416,
0.25980594754219055,
-0.220521479845047,
-0.5738734006881714,
-0.7792869210243225,
1.0129066705703735,
0.13073904812335968,
1.1004217863082886,
-0.05869080126285553,
0.41955843567848206,
0.8709045648574829,
0.3791326880455017,
-0.5887413620948792,
0.5246782302856445,
-1.0739216804504395,
-0.653905987739563,
-0.2587968707084656,
-0.8148231506347656,
-1.509997844696045,
-0.14993901550769806,
-0.14010734856128693,
-1.1206064224243164,
0.5612925291061401,
-0.04875370115041733,
-0.037097007036209106,
0.032282754778862,
-0.8845140933990479,
0.8905968070030212,
-0.057106465101242065,
-0.072838693857193,
-0.009636948816478252,
-0.6981258392333984,
0.35595640540122986,
-0.4659593403339386,
0.3902682960033417,
-0.3585143983364105,
0.1317921280860901,
0.7628415822982788,
-0.21195119619369507,
1.0229259729385376,
0.13144558668136597,
-0.11256656050682068,
0.3543969392776489,
-0.03607151657342911,
-0.02635342814028263,
-0.13448429107666016,
0.1502285599708557,
0.004203455988317728,
0.16936194896697998,
-0.1432495415210724,
-0.2925035357475281,
1.0070677995681763,
-0.7990741729736328,
0.028313228860497475,
-0.3206842839717865,
-0.46832844614982605,
0.04310789704322815,
0.3586643636226654,
0.09033898264169693,
0.7783570885658264,
0.07399645447731018,
0.7042372822761536,
0.6626912355422974,
-0.6162378191947937,
0.5198830366134644,
0.5100637078285217,
-0.41226544976234436,
-0.38908112049102783,
1.0498833656311035,
0.3038192391395569,
0.14340093731880188,
0.45502781867980957,
0.3159158229827881,
-0.21402272582054138,
-0.42432481050491333,
-0.17648261785507202,
-0.01840152218937874,
-0.7562468647956848,
-0.0338142104446888,
-0.5869410634040833,
-0.2642565071582794,
-0.2563314437866211,
0.05418592318892479,
-0.0068260421976447105,
-0.20559750497341156,
-0.2921195924282074,
0.02254522033035755,
0.35191673040390015,
0.6052530407905579,
-0.005547406617552042,
0.5216130018234253,
-0.9861840009689331,
0.2821788191795349,
0.5348513126373291,
0.36652639508247375,
-0.23046952486038208,
-0.11633516103029251,
-0.17490477859973907,
-0.04666583985090256,
-0.2665678858757019,
-0.9819439649581909,
0.2943505346775055,
0.536812424659729,
0.49160584807395935,
0.12513825297355652,
0.12010058015584946,
0.3176629841327667,
-0.5120617747306824,
0.7766620516777039,
-0.33753764629364014,
-1.0964775085449219,
0.6895363330841064,
-0.6740114688873291,
0.48213809728622437,
0.6055691838264465,
0.2111542671918869,
-0.8860310912132263,
-0.10642194747924805,
-0.4983382523059845,
-1.014897346496582,
0.7301103472709656,
0.4626197814941406,
0.44572368264198303,
0.13641215860843658,
0.06466309726238251,
0.2410416603088379,
0.3129940927028656,
-0.6637749671936035,
-0.17482315003871918,
-0.18594472110271454,
-0.6695742607116699,
0.08492925018072128,
-0.12586605548858643,
0.2058965116739273,
-0.018380895256996155,
0.34653303027153015,
-0.09396067261695862,
0.1648429036140442,
-0.16824041306972504,
0.003256363794207573,
-0.27390554547309875,
0.3143996000289917,
0.41744911670684814,
0.7241606116294861,
-0.052526094019412994,
0.31964612007141113,
-0.06751107424497604,
-0.66240394115448,
0.247104212641716,
0.44742903113365173,
-0.22257289290428162,
-0.1099049523472786,
0.48916974663734436,
0.6398860812187195,
0.03190156817436218,
-0.8780936598777771,
0.2571098804473877,
-0.26538240909576416,
0.09255705773830414,
-0.11041294783353806,
0.15285639464855194,
-0.21597333252429962,
0.03493021801114082,
0.5254965424537659,
-0.15937010943889618,
0.22562746703624725,
-0.4630790948867798,
0.5674957633018494,
-0.12176217138767242,
-0.5460019707679749,
0.07263379544019699,
0.5943624973297119,
0.21942006051540375,
-0.3125925064086914,
0.6014601588249207,
0.14889706671237946,
-0.1710483282804489,
0.5774065852165222,
0.33761635422706604,
0.8404901623725891,
-0.24074439704418182,
0.4689592719078064,
-0.2020745575428009,
0.37289130687713623,
0.06306591629981995,
0.21080611646175385,
0.011803438887000084,
-1.1018593311309814,
-0.701428234577179,
-0.27330562472343445,
-0.001930539496243,
0.276251882314682,
-0.6620418429374695,
0.11988996714353561,
-0.05958257243037224,
-0.24669188261032104,
-0.0610390231013298,
-0.012202151119709015,
-0.47791746258735657,
0.6549379229545593,
0.2799144983291626,
0.7521877884864807,
-1.1763161420822144,
0.691626787185669,
0.7522203922271729,
-0.012103584595024586,
-0.4592571258544922,
0.006227121688425541,
0.02737046778202057,
-0.5883170366287231,
0.6341513991355896,
0.4558827579021454,
0.00609038770198822,
0.16039396822452545,
-0.8065474629402161,
-0.5129083395004272,
0.6275042295455933,
-0.4373090863227844,
-0.4460054934024811,
0.12613023817539215,
0.12044749408960342,
0.5420361161231995,
-0.47118908166885376,
-0.08607073128223419,
0.4901149272918701,
0.3635371923446655,
-0.026453275233507156,
-0.5160300731658936,
-0.22263695299625397,
-0.5798609852790833,
0.15837633609771729,
0.2970221936702728,
-0.4234330654144287,
0.5749791860580444,
0.43684616684913635,
-0.29754915833473206,
0.1878260225057602,
0.5912627577781677,
0.24487408995628357,
0.5222671031951904,
0.7065317630767822,
0.3547378182411194,
0.3521231710910797,
-0.48197779059410095,
0.48667478561401367,
-0.07670537382364273,
0.12210729718208313,
0.9566922187805176,
0.10872294753789902,
0.46330365538597107,
0.0525972954928875,
0.06863884627819061,
0.5671356916427612,
0.5003174543380737,
0.1278131604194641,
0.5666964650154114,
0.3664722442626953,
-0.028805995360016823,
-0.20730973780155182,
-0.45644959807395935,
-0.10056941211223602,
0.4307166039943695,
0.5740664005279541,
-0.36313921213150024,
-0.1852927953004837,
0.2196076661348343,
0.3168511986732483,
0.44934380054473877,
-0.10714966803789139,
0.7007908821105957,
0.09662314504384995,
-0.0780348926782608,
0.01757296361029148,
-0.004060240928083658,
0.7077169418334961,
-0.6833279728889465,
-0.04253728687763214,
-0.30212482810020447,
0.025114677846431732,
-0.2003159523010254,
-0.9961413145065308,
0.21220630407333374,
0.176308274269104,
-0.1429033875465393,
-0.44145020842552185,
1.1190950870513916,
-0.9589574337005615,
-0.5265120267868042,
0.02529703453183174,
0.5647123456001282,
0.049213819205760956,
0.28055575489997864,
-0.49637654423713684,
0.38657671213150024,
-0.10185018181800842,
-0.1217741146683693,
-0.1449575573205948,
1.0307904481887817,
-0.22462056577205658,
0.7674469947814941,
0.5395690202713013,
0.20429909229278564,
0.19032688438892365,
0.29555755853652954,
0.7176961898803711,
-0.5205309987068176,
-0.35855892300605774,
-0.7726823687553406,
0.8716803193092346,
-0.2699948847293854,
-0.6273407936096191,
0.7576159834861755,
0.450611412525177,
0.6527490615844727,
0.06965189427137375,
0.7411448955535889,
-0.14068034291267395,
0.33275067806243896,
-0.5196202397346497,
0.6042056679725647,
-0.4253076910972595,
-0.014405053108930588,
-0.308610200881958,
-0.7813655734062195,
-0.37196436524391174,
0.5820285081863403,
-0.4689028263092041,
0.29652079939842224,
0.45702722668647766,
0.35386088490486145,
0.08845873177051544,
0.2593892514705658,
0.16123637557029724,
-0.25336748361587524,
0.6174065470695496,
0.4303536117076874,
1.0638447999954224,
-0.15289239585399628,
0.5296512842178345,
-0.23752234876155853,
-0.24712444841861725,
-0.04988254979252815,
-0.8085697889328003,
-1.005454182624817,
-0.40875306725502014,
-0.3258047103881836,
0.11076810210943222,
0.2109328806400299,
0.7781851887702942,
0.7051202058792114,
-0.7898525595664978,
-0.11460620909929276,
-0.1730879545211792,
-0.18782302737236023,
-0.24559621512889862,
-0.29993936419487,
-0.06376823782920837,
-0.20397444069385529,
-0.9551340341567993,
0.650737464427948,
-0.1268000453710556,
0.5438055992126465,
-0.20342159271240234,
0.41497036814689636,
-0.02472732961177826,
0.028333954513072968,
0.42396464943885803,
0.002543168840929866,
-0.09385800361633301,
-0.18070730566978455,
0.03340121731162071,
-0.13464374840259552,
-0.13677877187728882,
0.9235844016075134,
-0.5686240792274475,
0.5734701752662659,
0.7294415235519409,
0.5994651317596436,
0.3517005741596222,
0.3951862156391144,
0.7029391527175903,
-0.859225332736969,
0.090473972260952,
0.2812695801258087,
0.08236890286207199,
0.5496034622192383,
-0.37970441579818726,
0.3462488055229187,
0.21565939486026764,
-0.7940328121185303,
-0.4615136682987213,
0.1560131311416626,
-0.8115242719650269,
-0.43819907307624817,
1.0852272510528564,
0.061964020133018494,
0.1104310154914856,
-0.5307649374008179,
-0.5066454410552979,
0.07496008276939392,
-0.7022629380226135,
0.6631194353103638,
0.7727441787719727,
0.3030179440975189,
-0.45746973156929016,
-0.45522138476371765,
0.3740581274032593,
0.1850186437368393,
-1.088517427444458,
-0.02215888537466526,
0.5737110376358032,
0.011724275536835194,
0.1453505903482437,
0.41651400923728943,
-0.09699049592018127,
-0.2571508288383484,
-0.224630668759346,
-0.25066179037094116,
0.07306549698114395,
-0.5731518268585205,
-0.1242377758026123,
0.239400252699852,
-0.3598841428756714,
-0.32484498620033264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02353v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02353v1
|
Early Transformers: A study on Efficient Training of Transformer Models through Early-Bird Lottery Tickets
| 2024-05-02T23:03:45 | 2024-05-02T23:03:45 |
Shravan Cheekati
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The training of Transformer models has revolutionized natural language
processing and computer vision, but it remains a resource-intensive and
time-consuming process. This paper investigates the applicability of the
early-bird ticket hypothesis to optimize the training efficiency of Transformer
models. We propose a methodology that combines iterative pruning, masked
distance calculation, and selective retraining to identify early-bird tickets
in various Transformer architectures, including ViT, Swin-T, GPT-2, and
RoBERTa. Our experimental results demonstrate that early-bird tickets can be
consistently found within the first few epochs of training or fine-tuning,
enabling significant resource optimization without compromising performance.
The pruned models obtained from early-bird tickets achieve comparable or even
superior accuracy to their unpruned counterparts while substantially reducing
memory usage. Furthermore, our comparative analysis highlights the
generalizability of the early-bird ticket phenomenon across different
Transformer models and tasks. This research contributes to the development of
efficient training strategies for Transformer models, making them more
accessible and resource-friendly. By leveraging early-bird tickets,
practitioners can accelerate the progress of natural language processing and
computer vision applications while reducing the computational burden associated
with training Transformer models.
|
[
-0.32437872886657715,
-0.3351585268974304,
-0.06183075159788132,
0.0012597506865859032,
-0.2941923141479492,
-0.1876230686903,
-0.23449178040027618,
-0.3551332950592041,
-0.13900774717330933,
0.23092643916606903,
-0.5624152421951294,
0.09015671908855438,
-0.4088444411754608,
0.006258193403482437,
-0.6773566007614136,
0.6441880464553833,
0.1308669149875641,
-0.266144335269928,
0.24014438688755035,
0.1387171745300293,
0.013602559454739094,
-0.3653532862663269,
-0.6717928647994995,
-0.3807167708873749,
0.6361889243125916,
0.11144360899925232,
0.6779828667640686,
0.6737518906593323,
0.9190436005592346,
0.321880966424942,
-0.18586641550064087,
-0.016410140320658684,
-0.5087608098983765,
-0.15706340968608856,
0.06423589587211609,
-0.8169856071472168,
0.10767083615064621,
0.1152014434337616,
0.4964226484298706,
0.6146045327186584,
-0.3080180585384369,
0.30773210525512695,
0.1617954671382904,
0.6103760004043579,
-0.6361889839172363,
0.38655444979667664,
-0.8659842014312744,
0.5301439762115479,
-0.645118772983551,
-0.5136607885360718,
-0.6794750094413757,
-0.008097869344055653,
-0.0403638631105423,
-0.9516326189041138,
0.7372647523880005,
0.1807474046945572,
1.1874903440475464,
0.40389472246170044,
-0.0651346743106842,
0.22224664688110352,
-1.163025975227356,
0.6891670823097229,
-0.07088850438594818,
0.5767670273780823,
-0.17446449398994446,
0.9391370415687561,
0.05301051214337349,
-0.8471089005470276,
-0.7419514060020447,
-0.007107744459062815,
-0.3600907325744629,
0.16156317293643951,
-0.5596640110015869,
-0.033074431121349335,
0.335287481546402,
0.2826882302761078,
-0.45201829075813293,
0.07480209320783615,
-0.5371865630149841,
-0.24587678909301758,
0.22621671855449677,
0.10658709704875946,
-0.20691217482089996,
-0.13997316360473633,
-0.26705202460289,
-0.6533336043357849,
-0.49119383096694946,
0.37613409757614136,
0.3474941551685333,
0.5143404006958008,
-0.09088651090860367,
0.5034487247467041,
-0.13965748250484467,
0.8173010349273682,
0.24530525505542755,
-0.10859042406082153,
-0.03617406263947487,
-0.29633596539497375,
-0.13522669672966003,
-0.26653239130973816,
0.47015905380249023,
0.11370538920164108,
0.6793370842933655,
-0.5168001055717468,
-0.25362032651901245,
0.05436459183692932,
0.5544734001159668,
-0.7183224558830261,
-0.47344696521759033,
-0.2966422736644745,
-0.750417947769165,
-0.581818699836731,
0.09620801359415054,
-0.45168378949165344,
-0.14054052531719208,
-0.3866841793060303,
0.38522475957870483,
-0.19923754036426544,
-0.42831745743751526,
-0.1384875774383545,
-0.11499644070863724,
0.5623510479927063,
0.16373859345912933,
-0.958614706993103,
-0.10474613308906555,
0.7716611623764038,
0.825419545173645,
-0.006039923056960106,
-0.43192723393440247,
-0.44146472215652466,
0.03952427953481674,
-0.20780202746391296,
1.013429880142212,
-0.4643271863460541,
-0.34169864654541016,
-0.07244842499494553,
0.027992287650704384,
-0.3391483724117279,
-0.6388557553291321,
0.6506776809692383,
-0.7308651208877563,
-0.18795131146907806,
0.4049064815044403,
-0.04338836669921875,
0.053100138902664185,
0.08730003982782364,
-0.9359135031700134,
0.8127571940422058,
0.27693629264831543,
-0.6781542301177979,
0.7080976963043213,
-0.6461623311042786,
-0.5193870067596436,
0.01163999643176794,
-0.13105787336826324,
-0.5365282893180847,
0.44039466977119446,
0.312700480222702,
0.3372716009616852,
-0.2142636924982071,
-0.0918528214097023,
0.1311189830303192,
-0.5862811207771301,
-0.00427877577021718,
-0.5655919909477234,
0.5222978591918945,
0.20517964661121368,
-0.2646123766899109,
0.015322361141443253,
-0.7577865719795227,
-0.21917635202407837,
0.4087164103984833,
-0.2745937407016754,
-0.10136900842189789,
0.0016875040018931031,
0.0916820764541626,
-0.040001124143600464,
-0.27896660566329956,
-0.29457348585128784,
0.31330642104148865,
-0.8400523066520691,
0.14983773231506348,
0.8384318947792053,
-0.25430208444595337,
0.8124790191650391,
-0.31865715980529785,
0.4735994040966034,
0.4947175681591034,
0.8503080606460571,
-0.6092639565467834,
-0.3514673411846161,
-0.8460858464241028,
0.23403774201869965,
0.06608473509550095,
0.24884149432182312,
-0.724251925945282,
-0.03956592082977295,
-0.6464295983314514,
-0.5670378804206848,
-0.48645973205566406,
0.007798532489687204,
-0.05193410813808441,
0.38806766271591187,
0.12207313627004623,
-0.11841463297605515,
-0.6337776184082031,
-1.005850076675415,
-0.5369678735733032,
-0.19703172147274017,
-0.06599339842796326,
0.16553594172000885,
0.2520654499530792,
0.15573178231716156,
1.2110050916671753,
-0.4587875008583069,
-0.5044710636138916,
-0.24110615253448486,
0.05339985713362694,
0.5019314289093018,
0.27534592151641846,
0.46674948930740356,
-1.0463364124298096,
-0.5546969771385193,
0.05129796266555786,
-0.21653003990650177,
0.24115419387817383,
-0.17974747717380524,
-0.016788072884082794,
0.06869252026081085,
0.1518804430961609,
-0.4250222146511078,
0.7961373329162598,
0.26839545369148254,
-0.18744690716266632,
0.22906698286533356,
0.04827945679426193,
-0.08823151886463165,
-0.5140201449394226,
0.013203278183937073,
0.08077076077461243,
0.12325036525726318,
-0.687846839427948,
-0.275359570980072,
0.039507124572992325,
-0.1505827158689499,
-0.60094153881073,
0.36474984884262085,
-0.36257657408714294,
0.21844029426574707,
-0.453465074300766,
-0.35026660561561584,
-0.16206225752830505,
0.48238974809646606,
0.0336812399327755,
0.9027509093284607,
0.4038415551185608,
-0.5795590281486511,
-0.06565412133932114,
0.14215783774852753,
-0.4873609244823456,
0.357435941696167,
-0.4166980981826782,
0.09833554923534393,
-0.4647594094276428,
0.15063762664794922,
-0.4600880444049835,
0.03336384892463684,
0.28646188974380493,
-0.2732542157173157,
0.2785916030406952,
-0.29931098222732544,
-0.27909234166145325,
-0.7053868770599365,
0.05786799639463425,
0.33323413133621216,
0.5642066597938538,
-0.7152303457260132,
0.8895584344863892,
0.14481805264949799,
0.25425800681114197,
-0.44718846678733826,
-0.32615065574645996,
-0.0633830651640892,
-0.038313739001750946,
-0.613020658493042,
0.625518262386322,
0.5579217672348022,
-0.06320326775312424,
-0.0016833439003676176,
-0.07247854024171829,
-0.01806134171783924,
0.07748017460107803,
0.20518912374973297,
0.0560261607170105,
-0.19009530544281006,
0.011866079643368721,
-0.5688831806182861,
-0.8355462551116943,
-0.29152753949165344,
-0.4399905502796173,
0.4207381308078766,
-0.13553676009178162,
-0.5144318342208862,
-0.3094010353088379,
-0.013685447163879871,
0.3487268090248108,
-0.26502007246017456,
0.7337135076522827,
0.9409420490264893,
-0.3390677273273468,
-0.13322356343269348,
-0.7352421879768372,
-0.6865354180335999,
-0.46972590684890747,
0.3516310453414917,
-0.5013124942779541,
-0.46342727541923523,
0.27988100051879883,
-0.14212393760681152,
0.24510686099529266,
0.6192256808280945,
0.302243709564209,
0.11156035959720612,
0.7515069842338562,
0.8706257939338684,
-0.04815548285841942,
0.7670955657958984,
-0.5089915990829468,
0.5967594981193542,
-0.6860761642456055,
-0.34416332840919495,
-0.739851176738739,
-0.4918578267097473,
-0.3647572994232178,
-0.6250403523445129,
0.4441530704498291,
-0.038343336433172226,
-0.29654815793037415,
0.23320269584655762,
-0.7633240222930908,
0.8826594948768616,
0.7628217339515686,
0.004992253612726927,
0.33127036690711975,
0.14629948139190674,
0.06075988709926605,
-0.06137015298008919,
-1.02144455909729,
-0.44491273164749146,
1.2638880014419556,
0.2632921636104584,
0.6862059831619263,
-0.2718719244003296,
0.5672234296798706,
-0.04182276129722595,
0.6617562770843506,
-0.6370301842689514,
0.32406309247016907,
-0.13450844585895538,
-0.5976123809814453,
-0.3888690769672394,
-0.4118616282939911,
-0.9121894836425781,
0.22269722819328308,
-0.2100725769996643,
-0.4937155544757843,
0.2698522210121155,
0.23086749017238617,
-0.5002796053886414,
0.5552530884742737,
-0.7428784966468811,
0.8309046626091003,
-0.3124908208847046,
-0.33236977458000183,
-0.13503432273864746,
-0.49813520908355713,
0.3204282224178314,
-0.41898593306541443,
-0.01684539020061493,
0.16211818158626556,
0.18916551768779755,
0.9760635495185852,
-0.4497814178466797,
0.7946316003799438,
-0.4500577747821808,
0.4097962975502014,
0.45680898427963257,
-0.17985637485980988,
0.8356396555900574,
-0.2701726257801056,
-0.09667345136404037,
0.3081497848033905,
-0.4386887550354004,
-0.2229912281036377,
-0.6542260646820068,
0.14307577908039093,
-0.9167775511741638,
-0.3594032824039459,
-0.25505566596984863,
0.04279099777340889,
0.20711606740951538,
0.02017243020236492,
0.22914206981658936,
0.3275318443775177,
0.1479858011007309,
0.3610836863517761,
0.12549859285354614,
-0.027629997581243515,
0.7674269080162048,
0.5978841781616211,
0.12562470138072968,
-0.0497925765812397,
0.6248553991317749,
0.04722849652171135,
-0.1645360291004181,
0.5515792369842529,
0.379635214805603,
-0.26561564207077026,
-0.6741403937339783,
0.02412329986691475,
-0.0794876366853714,
-0.6158273220062256,
-0.322210431098938,
-0.6152309775352478,
-0.29604798555374146,
-0.06511826813220978,
-0.10526927560567856,
-0.5850813984870911,
-0.27958419919013977,
0.024262094870209694,
0.13875296711921692,
0.15248623490333557,
0.4872841238975525,
-0.015554854646325111,
0.861387312412262,
-0.6408706903457642,
0.29659613966941833,
0.26505938172340393,
0.5845263004302979,
0.517573893070221,
-0.4593732953071594,
-0.5767319798469543,
-0.2393033653497696,
-0.6914291381835938,
-0.6172440052032471,
0.12067469209432602,
0.41332149505615234,
0.7772893309593201,
0.6182353496551514,
0.01896519958972931,
0.7418172359466553,
-0.6715662479400635,
0.6392839550971985,
0.47043436765670776,
-0.5183700919151306,
0.5777357220649719,
0.0190591923892498,
0.12367912381887436,
0.5987331867218018,
-0.04007144644856453,
-0.20450998842716217,
-0.1592404693365097,
-0.657508373260498,
-0.8334696888923645,
1.1036428213119507,
0.5143126845359802,
-0.07193052023649216,
0.2880396842956543,
0.27362462878227234,
0.15793268382549286,
0.08782992511987686,
-0.8128042817115784,
-0.22785890102386475,
-0.489955872297287,
0.0269324891269207,
-0.3379538655281067,
0.08876356482505798,
0.03879223391413689,
-0.5995511412620544,
0.5215305685997009,
-0.20292946696281433,
0.39825737476348877,
-0.027688736096024513,
-0.222619891166687,
-0.28476235270500183,
0.08369433134794235,
0.359836608171463,
0.45547738671302795,
-0.11862029135227203,
0.03675822913646698,
0.031602468341588974,
-0.7391373515129089,
0.2861160635948181,
0.11268006265163422,
-0.2156788557767868,
0.10530691593885422,
0.34702545404434204,
0.9141893982887268,
0.5096464157104492,
-0.15783648192882538,
0.6805464625358582,
-0.11384724825620651,
0.12160905450582504,
-0.37368202209472656,
0.09941447526216507,
-0.26987308263778687,
0.41075584292411804,
0.803907036781311,
0.2550356090068817,
-0.24486035108566284,
-0.18951408565044403,
0.3531275689601898,
0.3738057613372803,
-0.19527417421340942,
-0.27351102232933044,
0.7670003771781921,
0.3872975707054138,
-0.7985969185829163,
0.796633780002594,
-0.04080372676253319,
-0.6127358675003052,
0.4307650923728943,
0.29136425256729126,
1.1446317434310913,
-0.037564728409051895,
-0.008642401546239853,
0.45001766085624695,
0.5972448587417603,
0.004808865487575531,
-0.34918954968452454,
-0.3375459909439087,
-0.7485814094543457,
-0.5525521039962769,
-0.9584818482398987,
-0.26225078105926514,
-0.032239291816949844,
-0.3852929472923279,
0.5450550317764282,
0.09750049561262131,
-0.30949294567108154,
0.007136830128729343,
-0.0008678209851495922,
-1.3711433410644531,
-0.08023544400930405,
0.14011596143245697,
1.1581045389175415,
-0.6947848200798035,
0.5619258880615234,
0.6079972982406616,
-0.22309982776641846,
-1.2327988147735596,
0.024085044860839844,
-0.2063121646642685,
-0.7649738192558289,
1.0328962802886963,
0.26658493280410767,
0.2629493176937103,
0.17961972951889038,
0.08173798024654388,
-0.46279674768447876,
1.0333902835845947,
-0.03053080476820469,
-0.9959867000579834,
-0.31645169854164124,
0.5222191214561462,
0.09704980999231339,
-0.1941375434398651,
0.9771868586540222,
0.5534384846687317,
0.6771770119667053,
0.34312620759010315,
-0.8631818890571594,
-0.38865217566490173,
-0.283249169588089,
-0.022243570536375046,
0.3543529212474823,
-0.5651103258132935,
0.7248826026916504,
-0.3038356900215149,
-0.3970138430595398,
-0.42871156334877014,
0.6210129261016846,
-0.04072847589850426,
0.24431072175502777,
1.1139271259307861,
0.30566176772117615,
0.5005953907966614,
-0.492988258600235,
0.9320365190505981,
-0.7198507785797119,
0.3905804455280304,
0.4049086272716522,
-0.00831830408424139,
0.6073310375213623,
0.7029889225959778,
-0.4828287363052368,
-0.0027831827756017447,
0.43948301672935486,
-0.12033231556415558,
0.6605246067047119,
0.2684507668018341,
0.047672826796770096,
-0.4422980546951294,
0.2890150249004364,
-0.39856216311454773,
0.7697886228561401,
-0.379734069108963,
-0.13553926348686218,
-0.5628821849822998,
0.3236546516418457,
-0.5674566030502319,
-0.4523089528083801,
-0.12749327719211578,
0.8590050935745239,
0.10703357309103012,
-0.5541425347328186,
0.46080902218818665,
-0.08681223541498184,
0.8737447261810303,
-0.6039853096008301,
0.28464287519454956,
-0.27386054396629333,
0.4264061152935028,
-0.04871409386396408,
-0.360263466835022,
0.4981178641319275,
0.13907171785831451,
-0.1027522012591362,
-0.41339001059532166,
0.8927119970321655,
0.15421649813652039,
-0.63233882188797,
-0.09140032529830933,
0.4390217661857605,
-0.08344481140375137,
-0.4820561707019806,
-0.45309123396873474,
0.1587945520877838,
-0.16622161865234375,
-0.606963574886322,
0.05429445207118988,
0.2367134988307953,
0.15550696849822998,
0.5405811667442322,
0.8549025058746338,
0.2660941779613495,
0.29017046093940735,
0.3252147436141968,
0.8687071204185486,
-0.6374592185020447,
-0.8280439972877502,
-0.8835852742195129,
0.7324413061141968,
-0.19337667524814606,
-0.19917826354503632,
0.4319811761379242,
0.8167820572853088,
0.7544808387756348,
-0.26132404804229736,
0.4827289879322052,
0.3208667039871216,
0.3614998161792755,
-0.24387705326080322,
0.7163572907447815,
-0.4626612067222595,
0.2997936010360718,
-0.06374477595090866,
-1.2180509567260742,
-0.15234221518039703,
0.7703246474266052,
-0.3058357238769531,
-0.06659884005784988,
0.5240318775177002,
0.8580008149147034,
-0.3780476152896881,
0.39476194977760315,
0.04977555572986603,
-0.05812414363026619,
0.6489323377609253,
0.7208389043807983,
1.0418083667755127,
-0.6370203495025635,
0.8918954133987427,
-0.6593965888023376,
-0.34224218130111694,
-0.5020415186882019,
-0.8239692449569702,
-0.6357892751693726,
-0.66682368516922,
-0.2338685393333435,
-0.02997956983745098,
0.05843207240104675,
0.538008451461792,
0.8806105256080627,
-0.425496369600296,
-0.06757152825593948,
-0.16207368671894073,
-0.017171625047922134,
-0.36246663331985474,
-0.25269338488578796,
0.3165397047996521,
-0.3070942461490631,
-0.4269314408302307,
0.11722401529550552,
0.2314009815454483,
0.39976227283477783,
-0.3477431535720825,
-0.0865752324461937,
0.38474875688552856,
-0.07631989568471909,
0.517320454120636,
0.09183618426322937,
-0.4898570775985718,
-0.2115044891834259,
0.3544214367866516,
0.2857092618942261,
0.10500144958496094,
1.1807942390441895,
-1.1029832363128662,
0.34623879194259644,
0.18202993273735046,
0.3742680847644806,
0.7084600329399109,
-0.08145064115524292,
0.3606768846511841,
-0.5309317111968994,
0.5971078872680664,
0.39218971133232117,
0.09544625878334045,
0.13911780714988708,
0.042049672454595566,
0.51430743932724,
0.4431137144565582,
-0.25990188121795654,
-1.0949615240097046,
0.008736014366149902,
-0.8302722573280334,
0.20380260050296783,
0.824657142162323,
0.3951718807220459,
-0.47483986616134644,
0.06177607923746109,
0.09636139124631882,
0.37078773975372314,
0.14451579749584198,
1.0223945379257202,
0.45270293951034546,
0.11776864528656006,
-0.23646868765354156,
-0.3928107023239136,
0.5558857321739197,
0.1356079876422882,
-0.5591641664505005,
-0.08645337074995041,
-0.3432348668575287,
-0.18325674533843994,
0.42693525552749634,
0.4815211594104767,
-0.046979453414678574,
0.08679930120706558,
0.15721578896045685,
-0.12830057740211487,
-0.4481107294559479,
-0.6167818903923035,
-0.08604245632886887,
0.47871264815330505,
-0.16692598164081573,
-0.36894363164901733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01769v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01769v1
|
A Survey on Large Language Models for Critical Societal Domains: Finance, Healthcare, and Law
| 2024-05-02T22:43:02 | 2024-05-02T22:43:02 |
Zhiyu Zoey Chen, Jing Ma, Xinlu Zhang, Nan Hao, An Yan, Armineh Nourbakhsh, Xianjun Yang, Julian McAuley, Linda Petzold, William Yang Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the fast-evolving domain of artificial intelligence, large language models
(LLMs) such as GPT-3 and GPT-4 are revolutionizing the landscapes of finance,
healthcare, and law: domains characterized by their reliance on professional
expertise, challenging data acquisition, high-stakes, and stringent regulatory
compliance. This survey offers a detailed exploration of the methodologies,
applications, challenges, and forward-looking opportunities of LLMs within
these high-stakes sectors. We highlight the instrumental role of LLMs in
enhancing diagnostic and treatment methodologies in healthcare, innovating
financial analytics, and refining legal interpretation and compliance
strategies. Moreover, we critically examine the ethics for LLM applications in
these fields, pointing out the existing ethical concerns and the need for
transparent, fair, and robust AI systems that respect regulatory norms. By
presenting a thorough review of current literature and practical applications,
we showcase the transformative impact of LLMs, and outline the imperative for
interdisciplinary cooperation, methodological advancements, and ethical
vigilance. Through this lens, we aim to spark dialogue and inspire future
research dedicated to maximizing the benefits of LLMs while mitigating their
risks in these precision-dependent sectors. To facilitate future research on
LLMs in these critical societal domains, we also initiate a reading list that
tracks the latest advancements under this topic, which will be continually
updated: \url{https://github.com/czyssrs/LLM_X_papers}.
|
[
0.043592244386672974,
-0.9168713688850403,
0.9412254095077515,
-0.11379143595695496,
0.03326786309480667,
0.23050187528133392,
-0.3366870880126953,
-0.6560255289077759,
-0.16849972307682037,
0.8736986517906189,
-0.21286581456661224,
-0.5109755396842957,
-0.8295392394065857,
-0.20194905996322632,
-0.309429794549942,
0.967881977558136,
0.08865143358707428,
0.382303386926651,
-0.23055529594421387,
-0.05166946351528168,
0.04651881009340286,
-0.8793972134590149,
-0.6769682168960571,
-0.44992488622665405,
0.47690460085868835,
-0.01874370686709881,
0.7007047533988953,
0.4496508836746216,
0.8388546705245972,
0.3652244806289673,
-0.11565106362104416,
-0.05605176463723183,
-0.45573779940605164,
0.05578460544347763,
-0.08112235367298126,
-0.1717934012413025,
-0.7245480418205261,
0.11625860631465912,
0.5858468413352966,
0.7878807187080383,
-0.27319711446762085,
0.07889224588871002,
0.0029398566111922264,
0.6263821721076965,
-0.4483287036418915,
0.5177866220474243,
-0.353376567363739,
-0.1628459393978119,
-0.2766311466693878,
-0.15999138355255127,
-0.14239682257175446,
-0.6093809008598328,
0.3440069258213043,
-0.39469510316848755,
-0.19589199125766754,
0.13778197765350342,
0.5088087916374207,
0.30851519107818604,
-0.6018654108047485,
-0.4324164092540741,
-0.9350707530975342,
0.889627993106842,
-0.8083658814430237,
0.33712124824523926,
0.3193170726299286,
0.24534133076667786,
-0.23606446385383606,
-1.0746405124664307,
-0.36435750126838684,
-0.3022940754890442,
0.23413711786270142,
-0.05984697863459587,
-0.3007524609565735,
0.28016600012779236,
0.10223450511693954,
0.28287696838378906,
-0.340459406375885,
0.40888601541519165,
-0.44646206498146057,
-0.16877581179141998,
0.7700744867324829,
0.3211437165737152,
0.2994360029697418,
0.18117639422416687,
0.06652931869029999,
0.13578544557094574,
-1.009338140487671,
-0.03964467719197273,
0.1636604219675064,
0.09768164157867432,
-0.3300414979457855,
0.4106910526752472,
0.1751270592212677,
0.5089702010154724,
-0.43269068002700806,
-0.38320672512054443,
0.2758403718471527,
-0.3820491135120392,
-0.27770090103149414,
-0.1573677957057953,
0.9117355942726135,
0.2908099293708801,
0.3339572548866272,
0.0955795869231224,
-0.2422412782907486,
-0.12228450179100037,
0.1731148213148117,
-0.5035076141357422,
0.1050916537642479,
0.27081361413002014,
-0.5396285057067871,
-0.3274923861026764,
-0.2869989275932312,
-0.6513410210609436,
-0.6994635462760925,
-0.6638616323471069,
-0.02364608831703663,
-0.18704436719417572,
-0.2601473033428192,
0.4130779206752777,
0.17919431626796722,
0.46563810110092163,
0.2568841576576233,
-0.8008877038955688,
0.3916478753089905,
1.1009857654571533,
0.6533896923065186,
0.2360452264547348,
0.0012849377235397696,
-0.308100163936615,
0.3473207354545593,
-0.3604992628097534,
0.40539607405662537,
-0.49471867084503174,
-0.5593594312667847,
0.3926631510257721,
-0.16432076692581177,
0.14675229787826538,
-0.5720555782318115,
0.5477424263954163,
-0.47835323214530945,
-0.2832969129085541,
-0.2332650125026703,
-0.5242857933044434,
-0.1928238570690155,
0.37015047669410706,
-0.5779752731323242,
0.5133464336395264,
0.1264675259590149,
-0.4464973211288452,
0.252532958984375,
-1.0741102695465088,
-0.45126181840896606,
0.4365019202232361,
-0.5717134475708008,
-0.447041392326355,
-0.06582362949848175,
-0.034472230821847916,
0.7566983699798584,
-0.8682787418365479,
0.8427135348320007,
-0.5295419692993164,
-0.13811665773391724,
0.28152909874916077,
-0.5009568333625793,
0.7052672505378723,
0.07924029231071472,
-0.45346954464912415,
0.3800789415836334,
-0.4493420422077179,
-0.2567799389362335,
0.295569509267807,
0.07263095676898956,
-0.2887077331542969,
0.2961369752883911,
0.3247900903224945,
0.08107250183820724,
0.4543694853782654,
-0.40856805443763733,
0.21668599545955658,
-0.3411100506782532,
1.2503077983856201,
0.9643329381942749,
0.03409210219979286,
0.2419104278087616,
-0.500535786151886,
0.5153673887252808,
-0.1888761967420578,
0.3659690320491791,
0.05542214214801788,
-0.4892050325870514,
-0.23423928022384644,
-0.3378748297691345,
0.13766513764858246,
0.5546337962150574,
-0.4432882070541382,
0.17062698304653168,
-0.3467930257320404,
-0.4996992349624634,
-0.5091421604156494,
-0.12454163283109665,
0.056059736758470535,
0.36011815071105957,
0.05797222629189491,
0.19552820920944214,
-0.2743526101112366,
-1.0725213289260864,
-0.2893928289413452,
-0.2737268805503845,
0.03234493359923363,
0.679526686668396,
0.5649939775466919,
-0.591901957988739,
0.7045021653175354,
-0.3783039152622223,
-0.23894813656806946,
-0.33448609709739685,
-0.06586729735136032,
0.2514919638633728,
0.41950854659080505,
0.5561026930809021,
-1.0565099716186523,
-0.07110756635665894,
0.1512334793806076,
-0.7700603604316711,
0.2172236293554306,
-0.03358980640769005,
0.11989880353212357,
0.030788321048021317,
0.57414710521698,
-0.5268263816833496,
0.15680614113807678,
0.4808732867240906,
-0.24549007415771484,
0.5464274883270264,
-0.164718896150589,
0.1914403736591339,
-1.0537842512130737,
0.21091300249099731,
0.29593518376350403,
-0.25294023752212524,
-0.6316973567008972,
0.23638683557510376,
-0.09473920613527298,
0.13253065943717957,
-0.42956432700157166,
0.7916133999824524,
-0.3687983453273773,
-0.06734103709459305,
-0.07354171574115753,
-0.02083798497915268,
-0.400980681180954,
-0.028797602280974388,
-0.20615875720977783,
0.7685180306434631,
0.7013920545578003,
-0.4142588675022125,
0.4749206304550171,
0.2232079654932022,
-0.4738457202911377,
0.3778305947780609,
-0.7490885853767395,
0.032929155975580215,
0.09572876244783401,
0.3283712863922119,
-0.37116193771362305,
-0.3968508839607239,
0.20653557777404785,
-0.1912514865398407,
0.1338827759027481,
0.06801023334264755,
-0.7794269323348999,
-0.3869944214820862,
-0.14385268092155457,
0.6599777936935425,
0.7346541881561279,
0.008494789712131023,
0.5784545540809631,
0.9370245933532715,
-0.6884541511535645,
-0.4864591658115387,
-0.7171408534049988,
0.4147658348083496,
-0.31927090883255005,
-0.5095226168632507,
0.10022687911987305,
0.054291363805532455,
-0.7144725322723389,
-0.06529230624437332,
0.25684240460395813,
-0.0625646784901619,
0.2474488615989685,
0.1635548621416092,
0.577870786190033,
-0.21159952878952026,
-0.052562080323696136,
-0.0576912946999073,
-0.0011165690375491977,
0.383606493473053,
-0.6524956822395325,
0.47106754779815674,
-0.3103991150856018,
-0.3865663409233093,
-0.33575108647346497,
0.5217073559761047,
0.9952881336212158,
-0.25556084513664246,
0.5143089294433594,
0.37453144788742065,
-0.6489800810813904,
0.21658389270305634,
-0.7139248847961426,
0.0037875112611800432,
-0.5270613431930542,
0.4906480312347412,
0.03515331819653511,
-1.5348907709121704,
0.5102258324623108,
-0.30068713426589966,
0.2859343886375427,
0.5190831422805786,
1.0670560598373413,
0.20030660927295685,
0.7370922565460205,
0.7772336006164551,
-0.42228519916534424,
0.2456815242767334,
-0.19119633734226227,
0.6003706455230713,
-0.6841667890548706,
-0.2833440601825714,
-0.5591490268707275,
-0.018177393823862076,
-0.8081793189048767,
-0.4464395046234131,
0.9179694056510925,
-0.4183827340602875,
-0.43716511130332947,
-0.26087823510169983,
-0.3064746856689453,
0.3326245844364166,
0.39909201860427856,
-0.06276007741689682,
0.4172859787940979,
-0.3374038636684418,
0.1297655552625656,
0.07973812520503998,
-0.35483184456825256,
-0.7723967432975769,
1.2746318578720093,
0.6468995809555054,
0.789537787437439,
0.06560677289962769,
0.5042784810066223,
0.47154948115348816,
0.49245917797088623,
-0.8555967807769775,
0.44655850529670715,
-0.22763848304748535,
-0.6288252472877502,
-0.4797492027282715,
-0.5676760077476501,
-0.8311842679977417,
-0.1810079962015152,
0.11843755096197128,
-0.7581653594970703,
0.059874676167964935,
-0.07851090282201767,
-0.5437692403793335,
0.539883553981781,
-0.21813355386257172,
0.6565333008766174,
-0.3173881769180298,
-0.3013361990451813,
-0.35486525297164917,
-0.7101281881332397,
0.4298448860645294,
-0.29599207639694214,
0.6150046586990356,
-0.20698024332523346,
-0.09404967725276947,
0.6131914258003235,
-0.16208474338054657,
0.9743245840072632,
0.006739126984030008,
-0.49060726165771484,
0.25360381603240967,
-0.1604975312948227,
0.5505708456039429,
0.2515948712825775,
-0.08802880346775055,
0.4853503704071045,
0.1332176774740219,
-0.378945529460907,
-0.1608077436685562,
0.7214008569717407,
-0.8151061534881592,
-0.6434940099716187,
-0.5916117429733276,
-0.7347316741943359,
-0.529841423034668,
0.29833725094795227,
-0.06309416890144348,
0.371594101190567,
-0.34264075756073,
0.16302582621574402,
0.6510059833526611,
-0.2262992411851883,
0.30223700404167175,
0.5199472308158875,
0.06584976613521576,
-0.37362924218177795,
0.8790964484214783,
0.09840080142021179,
0.15252897143363953,
0.08206281065940857,
0.1384432017803192,
-0.45577937364578247,
-0.8856579065322876,
-0.23930880427360535,
0.5230352878570557,
-0.5416343808174133,
-0.12090253829956055,
-0.6888334155082703,
-0.42688676714897156,
-0.7330328226089478,
-0.42313963174819946,
-0.22912994027137756,
-0.05356322601437569,
-0.35008665919303894,
-0.04345402494072914,
0.5008872747421265,
1.0429726839065552,
0.03784531354904175,
-0.017037594690918922,
-0.9821304678916931,
0.17253796756267548,
0.017538532614707947,
0.48256900906562805,
-0.08254005759954453,
-0.18153592944145203,
-0.009247584268450737,
-0.04422175511717796,
-0.06267283111810684,
-0.35562148690223694,
0.28660622239112854,
-0.0779348835349083,
0.5531933903694153,
0.36243295669555664,
-0.06149551272392273,
0.39613083004951477,
-0.8347430229187012,
0.7985495924949646,
0.2973015010356903,
-0.8762779235839844,
0.11671064049005508,
-0.7516707181930542,
0.014094041660428047,
0.4516049921512604,
0.5026983022689819,
-0.856839120388031,
-0.4644770622253418,
-0.5169917345046997,
-1.0892765522003174,
0.3106847107410431,
-0.020862456411123276,
0.35803788900375366,
0.20355328917503357,
0.5565015077590942,
0.006018286105245352,
0.34489724040031433,
-0.44755563139915466,
-0.10679736733436584,
0.39529088139533997,
-0.4164053797721863,
-0.11351309716701508,
-0.13533104956150055,
-0.40189746022224426,
-0.1786709874868393,
0.5290840864181519,
-0.14666299521923065,
0.03665177896618843,
0.13545368611812592,
0.32735946774482727,
0.06932028383016586,
0.3934434652328491,
0.688671350479126,
0.8024126291275024,
0.21579794585704803,
-0.2863493263721466,
-0.2307097166776657,
-0.7010473012924194,
0.33122363686561584,
0.1803998500108719,
-0.17209653556346893,
-0.5013373494148254,
0.3780701458454132,
0.46615633368492126,
0.18122681975364685,
-0.9245414137840271,
0.5632602572441101,
0.023862041532993317,
-0.48340246081352234,
-0.6579107046127319,
-0.1532706767320633,
0.14048905670642853,
0.5372408032417297,
0.32119783759117126,
-0.07839685678482056,
0.36611080169677734,
-0.6955879926681519,
0.1354530155658722,
0.43085139989852905,
-0.3743742108345032,
-0.14707013964653015,
0.7017741799354553,
0.28576332330703735,
-0.1515517681837082,
0.4949401617050171,
0.05151785537600517,
-0.39485350251197815,
0.6843683123588562,
0.38684067130088806,
0.9765226244926453,
0.10196176171302795,
0.049370892345905304,
-0.1749085932970047,
0.30355215072631836,
-0.3521915376186371,
0.2355385571718216,
0.29580429196357727,
-0.6567875742912292,
-0.5738022327423096,
-0.6257374882698059,
-0.8157503008842468,
0.4170679748058319,
-0.46325019001960754,
0.08457827568054199,
-0.6673120260238647,
-0.19904497265815735,
0.1656288206577301,
-0.15995097160339355,
-0.4982075095176697,
-0.05614567920565605,
0.31937864422798157,
0.6357281804084778,
-0.40686434507369995,
0.6962299346923828,
0.6655847430229187,
-0.08996783196926117,
-0.5537263751029968,
0.035867929458618164,
0.3758506178855896,
-0.853681743144989,
0.26246997714042664,
-0.133417546749115,
-0.16395826637744904,
0.021065540611743927,
-0.7133961319923401,
-0.7852717638015747,
0.9347924590110779,
0.3720574676990509,
-0.8063260912895203,
-0.3659312129020691,
0.28361716866493225,
0.5099079012870789,
-0.3044780492782593,
0.07501615583896637,
0.9273927807807922,
0.6307086944580078,
-0.13877318799495697,
-1.054889440536499,
-0.04806522652506828,
-0.17706085741519928,
-0.07529730349779129,
0.36323922872543335,
-0.9283551573753357,
0.7322322130203247,
-0.1486300677061081,
0.16331645846366882,
0.18367473781108856,
0.39423027634620667,
0.25738051533699036,
0.4828185439109802,
0.20323361456394196,
0.18482378125190735,
0.7345590591430664,
-0.10639385879039764,
1.2088234424591064,
-0.5050754547119141,
0.3987245261669159,
0.6321081519126892,
-0.7511013746261597,
0.4157290756702423,
0.31466764211654663,
-0.348553329706192,
0.13306361436843872,
0.7269575595855713,
-0.05530191585421562,
-0.05927920341491699,
0.4447714388370514,
-0.39598679542541504,
-0.14125077426433563,
-0.3856443166732788,
-0.39684104919433594,
0.3623505234718323,
0.7276343107223511,
-0.280168741941452,
0.0951308012008667,
0.047142479568719864,
0.16969668865203857,
0.058402545750141144,
-0.45575305819511414,
0.6751242876052856,
0.47303497791290283,
-0.25528350472450256,
0.1093226745724678,
0.09398461878299713,
0.6660712957382202,
-0.7486841678619385,
-0.038936927914619446,
0.131782665848732,
0.13900163769721985,
0.05336325615644455,
-0.7348780035972595,
0.2711610198020935,
0.12721043825149536,
-0.0968579351902008,
-0.39997053146362305,
0.5137606859207153,
-0.08343255519866943,
-0.635235071182251,
0.3992489278316498,
0.4857911765575409,
0.03051505982875824,
0.10576910525560379,
-0.7326974272727966,
0.09549973905086517,
-0.2752056419849396,
-0.14377844333648682,
0.33761852979660034,
0.4655316174030304,
-0.24130494892597198,
0.8194752335548401,
0.7170667052268982,
0.3497263789176941,
-0.22517094016075134,
0.23352958261966705,
0.9182390570640564,
-0.977340817451477,
-0.47945353388786316,
-1.0591497421264648,
0.17884604632854462,
0.08122199773788452,
-0.416021466255188,
0.26995977759361267,
0.42586928606033325,
0.6733174920082092,
0.19179777801036835,
1.0650891065597534,
0.13586318492889404,
0.3973829746246338,
-0.5252896547317505,
1.058599829673767,
-0.500449001789093,
0.2337302267551422,
-0.3636324405670166,
-0.4807404577732086,
-0.5692985653877258,
0.15043602883815765,
-0.5571494102478027,
0.09484521299600601,
0.31787899136543274,
0.4013091027736664,
0.2870362401008606,
0.04992431774735451,
0.4212855398654938,
0.38896483182907104,
0.566373348236084,
0.4310598075389862,
0.7249870896339417,
-0.00021637670579366386,
0.14458824694156647,
0.2764665186405182,
-0.2985990643501282,
-0.2845262587070465,
-0.6338115334510803,
-0.5125935077667236,
-0.460187166929245,
-0.2435356080532074,
-0.10695350915193558,
0.021775763481855392,
1.013351321220398,
0.5353522300720215,
-0.6560394763946533,
-0.4217625856399536,
0.06653287261724472,
-0.010848205536603928,
0.029336577281355858,
-0.1682663857936859,
0.23591448366641998,
-0.049550510942935944,
-0.7770959734916687,
0.20224349200725555,
0.7479271292686462,
0.04246557131409645,
-0.5960500836372375,
0.055246543139219284,
0.05359041318297386,
0.24410493671894073,
0.7264536023139954,
0.22073449194431305,
-0.9013106822967529,
-0.17449672520160675,
-0.0035564913414418697,
-0.3737448453903198,
-0.06865150481462479,
1.146127462387085,
-0.3110637664794922,
-0.07494504749774933,
0.21639658510684967,
1.067573070526123,
0.10116205364465714,
-0.3089296221733093,
0.6512424349784851,
0.14442221820354462,
0.10555534809827805,
0.8771964311599731,
0.5590611100196838,
0.17448937892913818,
-0.6414778232574463,
0.46374067664146423,
0.2526247501373291,
-0.9625094532966614,
-0.8975727558135986,
0.2638034522533417,
-0.8738048672676086,
-0.2739503085613251,
1.114669680595398,
-0.07093998044729233,
-0.32933783531188965,
-0.2935422956943512,
-0.01061764732003212,
-0.027363765984773636,
-0.4510788917541504,
0.7112171053886414,
0.6403335332870483,
-0.053971972316503525,
0.024802492931485176,
-1.0218862295150757,
0.5193277597427368,
0.19536980986595154,
-0.9498215913772583,
0.19936588406562805,
0.6219423413276672,
0.23994722962379456,
-0.152211993932724,
0.9266166090965271,
-0.5389109253883362,
0.1467716097831726,
-0.4229631721973419,
-0.025878017768263817,
0.156467467546463,
-0.10981238633394241,
-0.4475043714046478,
0.0776955634355545,
0.11912695318460464,
0.4233262836933136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01768v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01768v1
|
CoS: Enhancing Personalization and Mitigating Bias with Context Steering
| 2024-05-02T22:37:38 | 2024-05-02T22:37:38 |
Jerry Zhi-Yang He, Sashrika Pandey, Mariah L. Schrum, Anca Dragan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
When querying a large language model (LLM), the context, i.e. personal,
demographic, and cultural information specific to an end-user, can
significantly shape the response of the LLM. For example, asking the model to
explain Newton's second law with the context "I am a toddler" yields a
different answer compared to the context "I am a physics professor." Proper
usage of the context enables the LLM to generate personalized responses,
whereas inappropriate contextual influence can lead to stereotypical and
potentially harmful generations (e.g. associating "female" with "housekeeper").
In practice, striking the right balance when leveraging context is a nuanced
and challenging problem that is often situation-dependent. One common approach
to address this challenge is to fine-tune LLMs on contextually appropriate
responses. However, this approach is expensive, time-consuming, and not
controllable for end-users in different situations. In this work, we propose
Context Steering (CoS) - a simple training-free method that can be easily
applied to autoregressive LLMs at inference time. By measuring the contextual
influence in terms of token prediction likelihood and modulating it, our method
enables practitioners to determine the appropriate level of contextual
influence based on their specific use case and end-user base. We showcase a
variety of applications of CoS including amplifying the contextual influence to
achieve better personalization and mitigating unwanted influence for reducing
model bias. In addition, we show that we can combine CoS with Bayesian
Inference to quantify the extent of hate speech on the internet. We demonstrate
the effectiveness of CoS on state-of-the-art LLMs and benchmarks.
|
[
-0.5800893306732178,
-0.9797289967536926,
0.24232268333435059,
0.3264175355434418,
-0.19177472591400146,
0.15601272881031036,
-0.3128240704536438,
-0.3965407907962799,
0.06686794012784958,
0.3996675908565521,
-0.694882333278656,
-0.36119386553764343,
-0.439212828874588,
-0.1804795116186142,
-0.37810805439949036,
1.0357189178466797,
0.323739618062973,
0.19702617824077606,
-0.28621748089790344,
0.0017392890295013785,
-0.6222193837165833,
-0.7299955487251282,
-0.9377546906471252,
-0.11835752427577972,
0.5396827459335327,
0.5088555812835693,
0.491725891828537,
0.47364673018455505,
0.20439717173576355,
0.18533815443515778,
-0.38077688217163086,
-0.057678140699863434,
-0.7128046154975891,
0.4340393543243408,
-0.521992564201355,
-0.3264865279197693,
-0.2432548850774765,
-0.11004643887281418,
0.13267353177070618,
0.9349818229675293,
-0.041124552488327026,
-0.035383306443691254,
0.20292890071868896,
0.4272707402706146,
-0.803809404373169,
-0.15851008892059326,
-0.7148178219795227,
0.04256144165992737,
-0.1820274442434311,
-0.4797072410583496,
-0.40406912565231323,
0.002352525945752859,
0.49773848056793213,
-0.7270804643630981,
0.3379885256290436,
0.4487244188785553,
0.44405651092529297,
0.3621252179145813,
-0.7513772249221802,
-0.4884919226169586,
-0.7667461633682251,
1.0249457359313965,
-0.32478082180023193,
0.5032488107681274,
0.3647984266281128,
0.3173399269580841,
-0.21749447286128998,
-0.227713480591774,
-0.3086792826652527,
-0.18680280447006226,
-0.1740608811378479,
0.12153862416744232,
-0.12133266031742096,
-0.03834569826722145,
0.11180493980646133,
-0.004771303851157427,
-0.29365208745002747,
0.31053876876831055,
-0.10892345756292343,
-0.3615489602088928,
0.6982033252716064,
0.16428612172603607,
0.3571985065937042,
0.1118394285440445,
-0.5455454587936401,
0.03964781016111374,
-0.9007488489151001,
0.3744889199733734,
0.2879220247268677,
0.394122838973999,
-0.4155324101448059,
0.5226529836654663,
-0.44750311970710754,
0.6483571529388428,
0.6422650218009949,
0.10552652180194855,
-0.052192382514476776,
-0.29348304867744446,
-0.1345854103565216,
0.20670844614505768,
0.4900905191898346,
0.45053622126579285,
0.10954860597848892,
-0.31694355607032776,
0.17452101409435272,
-0.04597223922610283,
0.25650182366371155,
-0.7304249405860901,
0.22806136310100555,
0.06214001029729843,
-0.05941186845302582,
-0.23967245221138,
-0.09302166104316711,
-0.829683244228363,
-0.4725378155708313,
-0.5609909296035767,
-0.02384282648563385,
-0.26054638624191284,
0.1417236328125,
-0.08588205277919769,
-0.06891445815563202,
0.08286947757005692,
0.6023200750350952,
-1.1156365871429443,
0.3707197904586792,
0.6583790183067322,
0.69645756483078,
-0.6082274317741394,
0.11215624213218689,
-0.5886210203170776,
0.5533474087715149,
-0.3245881497859955,
0.430855929851532,
-0.4913722276687622,
-0.47374215722084045,
0.04629264771938324,
-0.13116808235645294,
0.2108561098575592,
-0.5345058441162109,
0.48591604828834534,
-0.6880415678024292,
0.33101844787597656,
-0.46547916531562805,
-0.46057838201522827,
-0.041592005640268326,
0.18913258612155914,
-0.27121004462242126,
0.7785815596580505,
0.04124409332871437,
-0.8188276886940002,
0.5348802208900452,
-0.5975916385650635,
-0.6601352691650391,
-0.003274583490565419,
-0.3269873559474945,
-0.3430451452732086,
0.22160620987415314,
0.20854023098945618,
0.40861976146698,
-0.2318088710308075,
0.6262766718864441,
-0.44790661334991455,
-0.20530501008033752,
-0.08165820688009262,
-0.2520428001880646,
0.7035959959030151,
0.3903856873512268,
-0.4853239953517914,
0.4410821497440338,
-0.41443946957588196,
-0.40973928570747375,
-0.11633586138486862,
-0.14207421243190765,
-0.8226047158241272,
0.23590630292892456,
0.03407469019293785,
0.16613416373729706,
0.2504940330982208,
-0.40146249532699585,
-0.14687910676002502,
-0.4932851195335388,
0.22116446495056152,
0.7199015021324158,
-0.05240151658654213,
0.9305342435836792,
-0.2450951188802719,
0.4335300326347351,
0.14642871916294098,
0.021655423566699028,
-0.05750378593802452,
-0.29990890622138977,
-0.6310081481933594,
-0.18645821511745453,
-0.22551938891410828,
0.49044591188430786,
-0.646256148815155,
0.4806293249130249,
-0.1347799301147461,
-0.2749543786048889,
0.10542844980955124,
0.2034406214952469,
0.28545260429382324,
0.7515679001808167,
0.4394489526748657,
-0.42941391468048096,
-0.8771377205848694,
-0.8601923584938049,
-0.7108673453330994,
0.1347033679485321,
-0.09778423607349396,
0.5812416076660156,
0.134357288479805,
-0.15966558456420898,
1.4504508972167969,
-0.39039114117622375,
-0.22901782393455505,
-0.18233436346054077,
0.06973398476839066,
-0.3082486689090729,
0.47611314058303833,
0.4248935580253601,
-0.8830412030220032,
-0.5913575887680054,
-0.03576809912919998,
-0.545219898223877,
-0.4868464767932892,
-0.03756067529320717,
-0.19290457665920258,
0.14607961475849152,
0.6180461049079895,
-0.0302936639636755,
0.4061918258666992,
0.5484067797660828,
-0.7369915843009949,
0.28682583570480347,
-0.009003149345517159,
-0.06437022238969803,
-1.041608214378357,
0.0267000962048769,
0.25204235315322876,
-0.285675972700119,
-0.7541148066520691,
-0.11419284343719482,
-0.25168266892433167,
0.1462290734052658,
-0.5939397215843201,
0.7881835103034973,
-0.22899897396564484,
-0.006083234678953886,
-0.25094178318977356,
0.0811062753200531,
-0.15656334161758423,
0.2590517997741699,
0.15734608471393585,
0.9098114967346191,
0.2017647922039032,
-0.7987449169158936,
0.04265856742858887,
0.10114070028066635,
-0.2415418177843094,
0.9433178305625916,
-0.4644124209880829,
0.10549808293581009,
-0.1460176408290863,
0.39913955330848694,
-0.8207554817199707,
-0.25624582171440125,
0.28844112157821655,
-0.12729021906852722,
0.025093108415603638,
-0.1271110326051712,
-0.08749499917030334,
0.019426198676228523,
-0.06863927841186523,
0.3346309959888458,
0.15185227990150452,
-0.5077874660491943,
0.5197900533676147,
0.630928635597229,
-0.2903437614440918,
-0.5835973024368286,
-0.5881786942481995,
0.16904713213443756,
-0.5262851715087891,
-0.5703251361846924,
0.6601099967956543,
-0.40956515073776245,
-0.38211876153945923,
-0.3095684349536896,
-0.10203783959150314,
-0.08307234942913055,
0.38188406825065613,
0.3212185502052307,
0.09937261044979095,
0.12559956312179565,
0.03870315104722977,
0.5343504548072815,
-0.026087306439876556,
-0.07153294235467911,
-0.1702880561351776,
0.7684547901153564,
-0.025912342593073845,
-0.2862718105316162,
-0.4416562616825104,
0.3618672490119934,
0.40827125310897827,
0.026676498353481293,
0.5634762644767761,
0.48470374941825867,
-0.13621656596660614,
-0.09090579301118851,
-0.5145464539527893,
-0.3198140263557434,
-0.4766719341278076,
0.33890220522880554,
-0.31390437483787537,
-1.4107853174209595,
0.46261346340179443,
-0.19940638542175293,
-0.16183090209960938,
0.06260902434587479,
0.777239978313446,
-0.1269657164812088,
1.1455676555633545,
0.7179456949234009,
-0.2021740972995758,
0.8892782926559448,
-0.027522258460521698,
0.17495816946029663,
-0.8460065722465515,
-0.38849520683288574,
-0.4495331943035126,
-0.19656425714492798,
-0.5416123867034912,
-0.3469098210334778,
0.5060615539550781,
0.12061368674039841,
-0.5152535438537598,
0.10707049816846848,
-0.3158511221408844,
0.2538468837738037,
0.5795445442199707,
0.011430643498897552,
0.32903873920440674,
0.21262507140636444,
-0.1949894279241562,
0.0017757798777893186,
-0.8083261847496033,
-0.37021538615226746,
0.8369420766830444,
0.20032884180545807,
0.9779426455497742,
0.1362772136926651,
0.49609047174453735,
0.41499173641204834,
0.4570947289466858,
-0.7562144994735718,
0.47221308946609497,
-0.11474556475877762,
-0.8830517530441284,
-0.42463254928588867,
-0.308276891708374,
-0.9838812351226807,
0.3188585638999939,
-0.26931920647621155,
-0.8771496415138245,
0.23151840269565582,
0.48173344135284424,
-0.48977142572402954,
-0.011193030513823032,
-0.5927776098251343,
0.5851081013679504,
-0.35706275701522827,
-0.942533016204834,
-0.40600571036338806,
-0.6059549450874329,
0.10229906439781189,
0.0815146267414093,
0.5342289209365845,
-0.02120320126414299,
-0.29561856389045715,
0.6270822882652283,
-0.3056109547615051,
1.2296581268310547,
-0.243740975856781,
-0.15255588293075562,
0.2546425461769104,
0.14837774634361267,
0.5192918181419373,
-0.032203126698732376,
0.057294584810733795,
0.12930482625961304,
-0.02825290337204933,
-0.25934305787086487,
-0.5257079005241394,
0.8256036043167114,
-0.7098873257637024,
-0.7528363466262817,
-0.20382849872112274,
-0.6881797909736633,
-0.27593278884887695,
0.2085091471672058,
0.29332998394966125,
0.04732770100235939,
-0.48075544834136963,
0.39195242524147034,
0.5658825635910034,
-0.3031154274940491,
0.44429880380630493,
0.6210612654685974,
-0.16100412607192993,
-0.37494227290153503,
0.5472902655601501,
0.018509475514292717,
0.1729002743959427,
0.39510640501976013,
0.5596563220024109,
-0.3444778621196747,
-0.28753840923309326,
-0.3804416060447693,
-0.1785225123167038,
-0.5083044171333313,
0.051341764628887177,
-0.6424282789230347,
0.2168019413948059,
-0.4691687524318695,
-0.4923991560935974,
-0.16109327971935272,
-0.22213619947433472,
-0.3034009337425232,
0.1857367902994156,
0.030989406630396843,
0.5479617714881897,
0.16717341542243958,
0.8121463656425476,
-0.11287999153137207,
-0.028652943670749664,
0.2383882999420166,
0.264433890581131,
-0.006118257995694876,
-0.5583467483520508,
-0.3644384741783142,
0.01996501535177231,
-0.37187448143959045,
-0.8339974284172058,
0.48796212673187256,
-0.06516779959201813,
0.49427443742752075,
0.5087807178497314,
0.018844222649931908,
0.6202077269554138,
-0.4108823835849762,
0.7596614956855774,
0.25364425778388977,
-1.1832650899887085,
0.581667423248291,
-0.3914814591407776,
0.1335863471031189,
0.4844977557659149,
0.4590139091014862,
-0.8487808108329773,
-0.23825663328170776,
-0.4647758901119232,
-0.8881418704986572,
0.5923829674720764,
-0.04375166445970535,
0.3108134865760803,
0.08704578131437302,
0.38236767053604126,
0.08265279233455658,
0.3791438937187195,
-0.4540315568447113,
-0.17344677448272705,
-0.0771889016032219,
-0.3440156877040863,
-0.17689841985702515,
-0.39198482036590576,
-0.27391740679740906,
-0.3294202983379364,
0.6693916320800781,
-0.34674081206321716,
-0.2678845524787903,
0.1738594025373459,
-0.14857949316501617,
-0.20563137531280518,
0.3141617774963379,
0.7763147950172424,
0.4757136106491089,
-0.002182139316573739,
0.2303135246038437,
0.35913172364234924,
-0.24770155549049377,
0.07673120498657227,
-0.29063284397125244,
-0.6873631477355957,
-0.3160296380519867,
0.05432084947824478,
0.7809484004974365,
0.4173179268836975,
-0.5110893249511719,
0.5499846935272217,
0.007775007281452417,
0.17634333670139313,
-0.32966649532318115,
0.139204204082489,
0.08665591478347778,
0.14290255308151245,
0.323159784078598,
0.019227871671319008,
0.18225672841072083,
-0.4332137405872345,
0.11842046678066254,
0.793316125869751,
-0.617235004901886,
-0.3904404938220978,
0.66026371717453,
0.46227067708969116,
-0.34408867359161377,
-0.04727979004383087,
0.007612111512571573,
-0.36309030652046204,
0.4125159680843353,
0.6657465696334839,
0.712444543838501,
-0.37561851739883423,
-0.12271078675985336,
0.2355821579694748,
0.018194155767560005,
0.14607641100883484,
-0.10283384472131729,
-0.29348281025886536,
-0.831866443157196,
-0.2880374789237976,
-0.44754061102867126,
-0.5510801672935486,
0.09468156099319458,
-0.6467867493629456,
0.43587425351142883,
-0.568620502948761,
-0.29267415404319763,
-0.12455451488494873,
-0.08434304594993591,
-0.6818991899490356,
0.4750650227069855,
0.11778995394706726,
0.8308604955673218,
-0.8098077774047852,
0.6054288744926453,
0.6815000772476196,
-0.15343129634857178,
-0.28848811984062195,
0.04323672875761986,
0.21205314993858337,
-0.6748285293579102,
0.8977600932121277,
-0.024455929175019264,
-0.3504634201526642,
-0.05787103995680809,
-0.7932290434837341,
-0.9238311648368835,
1.055434226989746,
0.32738184928894043,
-0.8208008408546448,
0.07549943029880524,
0.18215222656726837,
0.5340288877487183,
-0.7600090503692627,
0.12088300287723541,
0.4014178216457367,
0.15792392194271088,
0.19889754056930542,
-0.7007171511650085,
0.17730985581874847,
0.2434510886669159,
0.1205204650759697,
-0.32640573382377625,
-0.6717264652252197,
0.5033735632896423,
-0.18173836171627045,
-0.15832465887069702,
-0.11458799988031387,
0.669619083404541,
0.31531643867492676,
0.7040311694145203,
0.7285230755805969,
0.2543557286262512,
0.6707122921943665,
0.016644630581140518,
1.031520128250122,
-0.6368811130523682,
0.22115375101566315,
1.450095295906067,
-0.16280654072761536,
0.6089639067649841,
0.9025653600692749,
0.14041680097579956,
0.4942423105239868,
0.5494229793548584,
0.38707733154296875,
0.6016036868095398,
0.3528747856616974,
-0.4715406596660614,
-0.2650982737541199,
-0.4515589773654938,
-0.13116876780986786,
0.439311683177948,
0.46756553649902344,
-0.3350074887275696,
-0.15184949338436127,
0.15329059958457947,
0.2232484519481659,
0.23431655764579773,
-0.16034795343875885,
0.8072242140769958,
0.09897174686193466,
-0.7282166481018066,
0.18987074494361877,
0.13724716007709503,
0.9760856628417969,
-0.47133228182792664,
0.35396066308021545,
-0.18777544796466827,
-0.06059621274471283,
-0.1375245749950409,
-0.43447235226631165,
0.5307329893112183,
0.10946265608072281,
-0.31804463267326355,
-0.3638317584991455,
0.6906923651695251,
-0.44340842962265015,
-0.11683005839586258,
0.4187152087688446,
0.5894250869750977,
-0.17893511056900024,
-0.02023831568658352,
-0.48617246747016907,
0.19066911935806274,
-0.1481281965970993,
-0.19764825701713562,
0.34490349888801575,
0.10276186466217041,
-0.4503802955150604,
0.9395427107810974,
0.7208806276321411,
0.04493645951151848,
0.04048170894384384,
0.1319095939397812,
0.6975453495979309,
-0.6032006740570068,
-0.7533290386199951,
-0.8769696354866028,
0.30530625581741333,
-0.14981774985790253,
-0.26480287313461304,
0.8851526379585266,
0.7747132778167725,
1.1518374681472778,
0.11523249000310898,
0.9984676837921143,
-0.032281264662742615,
0.589363694190979,
-0.21004663407802582,
0.5607430338859558,
-0.5472347736358643,
0.4341007471084595,
-0.0645972490310669,
-0.4710651636123657,
-0.2873696982860565,
0.3440455198287964,
-0.8455923199653625,
0.07596997916698456,
0.25332993268966675,
0.6977646946907043,
0.017937075346708298,
0.044730573892593384,
0.3802447021007538,
0.10227905958890915,
0.5171626806259155,
0.19438040256500244,
0.8261565566062927,
0.01270523201674223,
0.142557293176651,
-0.3286378085613251,
-0.30590522289276123,
-0.5053253173828125,
-0.9092257618904114,
-0.9184617400169373,
-0.3512667417526245,
-0.19354484975337982,
-0.33132418990135193,
0.15387071669101715,
1.0718131065368652,
1.133315920829773,
-0.9864546060562134,
-0.48156023025512695,
-0.3073432147502899,
0.20010784268379211,
-0.025567688047885895,
-0.2212994247674942,
0.05782226473093033,
-0.4363062381744385,
-0.9132021069526672,
0.43146848678588867,
0.30101075768470764,
0.1491025984287262,
-0.33720290660858154,
-0.25934386253356934,
-0.03754656761884689,
0.22091756761074066,
0.9069638848304749,
0.1400083601474762,
-0.8428112864494324,
-0.3902239203453064,
0.04522158205509186,
-0.11828809231519699,
0.04433196783065796,
1.0352342128753662,
-0.7230582237243652,
0.5397641658782959,
0.4735645055770874,
0.5481992363929749,
0.5190064907073975,
0.14968715608119965,
0.6559812426567078,
-0.806428849697113,
0.22280071675777435,
0.14612533152103424,
0.18013735115528107,
0.493012011051178,
-0.6527569890022278,
0.351178914308548,
0.40533748269081116,
-0.22564245760440826,
-0.5201050043106079,
0.46734797954559326,
-1.0517033338546753,
-0.30155372619628906,
1.048380970954895,
0.13356918096542358,
-0.053216602653265,
-0.3609422445297241,
-0.3035249412059784,
0.4358302652835846,
-0.6094082593917847,
0.8853085041046143,
0.5164799690246582,
-0.26424992084503174,
0.02436278574168682,
-0.3866463005542755,
0.5909678339958191,
0.8085528612136841,
-0.7367591857910156,
-0.0027728311251848936,
0.40466415882110596,
0.5589349269866943,
0.06905361264944077,
0.47085902094841003,
0.19639477133750916,
-0.18179559707641602,
-0.5248046517372131,
-0.029646649956703186,
0.0755598247051239,
-0.2237331122159958,
-0.43619492650032043,
0.1978023201227188,
-0.215365469455719,
0.20233254134655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01744v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01744v1
|
ALCM: Autonomous LLM-Augmented Causal Discovery Framework
| 2024-05-02T21:27:45 | 2024-05-02T21:27:45 |
Elahe Khatibi, Mahyar Abbasian, Zhongqi Yang, Iman Azimi, Amir M. Rahmani
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ME
|
To perform effective causal inference in high-dimensional datasets,
initiating the process with causal discovery is imperative, wherein a causal
graph is generated based on observational data. However, obtaining a complete
and accurate causal graph poses a formidable challenge, recognized as an
NP-hard problem. Recently, the advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) has
ushered in a new era, indicating their emergent capabilities and widespread
applicability in facilitating causal reasoning across diverse domains, such as
medicine, finance, and science. The expansive knowledge base of LLMs holds the
potential to elevate the field of causal reasoning by offering
interpretability, making inferences, generalizability, and uncovering novel
causal structures. In this paper, we introduce a new framework, named
Autonomous LLM-Augmented Causal Discovery Framework (ALCM), to synergize
data-driven causal discovery algorithms and LLMs, automating the generation of
a more resilient, accurate, and explicable causal graph. The ALCM consists of
three integral components: causal structure learning, causal wrapper, and
LLM-driven causal refiner. These components autonomously collaborate within a
dynamic environment to address causal discovery questions and deliver plausible
causal graphs. We evaluate the ALCM framework by implementing two
demonstrations on seven well-known datasets. Experimental results demonstrate
that ALCM outperforms existing LLM methods and conventional data-driven causal
reasoning mechanisms. This study not only shows the effectiveness of the ALCM
but also underscores new research directions in leveraging the causal reasoning
capabilities of LLMs.
|
[
-0.2454962283372879,
-0.9494507312774658,
0.9642332196235657,
0.01222565770149231,
0.05804293975234032,
0.0679321140050888,
-0.05197838321328163,
-0.48417529463768005,
0.3199354410171509,
0.4729798138141632,
-0.49641504883766174,
-0.6789653897285461,
-0.572384774684906,
0.09586945921182632,
-0.48699429631233215,
0.46486252546310425,
-0.24998708069324493,
0.04007115960121155,
-0.33137136697769165,
-0.17494505643844604,
-0.2562374174594879,
-0.3025951087474823,
-0.7981079816818237,
-0.4442920386791229,
0.9143431186676025,
0.3283083736896515,
0.5452560782432556,
1.1784310340881348,
0.49404439330101013,
0.3455534875392914,
0.31386539340019226,
0.5837507843971252,
0.0057181911543011665,
0.0461459644138813,
-0.2949022948741913,
-0.4537763297557831,
-0.6380640268325806,
-0.1936347633600235,
0.5445582866668701,
0.8463611602783203,
-0.15389128029346466,
0.0003859481366816908,
-0.03867403417825699,
0.5927040576934814,
-0.5952349305152893,
0.5619859099388123,
-0.6502467393875122,
-0.17435245215892792,
-0.14109383523464203,
-0.4094568192958832,
-0.28341373801231384,
-0.22123675048351288,
-0.22806382179260254,
-0.6327207088470459,
0.21093250811100006,
0.2596173584461212,
0.2974509298801422,
0.4410838782787323,
-1.050123691558838,
-0.5082430243492126,
-0.7598890066146851,
0.5411452054977417,
-0.5578086376190186,
0.4083399474620819,
0.24487778544425964,
0.34871286153793335,
-0.4382072985172272,
-0.8044416904449463,
-0.4394318163394928,
-0.11351874470710754,
-0.1279970407485962,
-0.06769023835659027,
-0.1374586820602417,
0.09093188494443893,
-0.1207490786910057,
0.2297879010438919,
-0.38305777311325073,
0.598156750202179,
-0.009324663318693638,
-0.1960362195968628,
0.5371598601341248,
0.47662198543548584,
0.1197565421462059,
-0.009627414867281914,
-0.47379961609840393,
0.17763195931911469,
-0.9682809710502625,
-0.3008687198162079,
0.2732011377811432,
0.5126186609268188,
-0.12951649725437164,
0.49966660141944885,
-0.2664637565612793,
0.6722768545150757,
-0.15821658074855804,
-0.17698054015636444,
-0.012804726138710976,
-0.27273765206336975,
-0.23879408836364746,
0.2531478703022003,
0.7439238429069519,
0.11894860863685608,
-0.26488566398620605,
0.04338997229933739,
-0.08695503324270248,
0.04569835588335991,
-0.14836803078651428,
-0.4234470725059509,
-0.33538076281547546,
0.19178199768066406,
-0.47910013794898987,
-0.14940139651298523,
-0.03585703298449516,
-0.38922572135925293,
-0.5866826176643372,
-0.6113913655281067,
0.44963720440864563,
-0.0691615492105484,
-0.1423906832933426,
0.16487887501716614,
0.277371346950531,
-0.03778513893485069,
0.5300573110580444,
-0.54156494140625,
0.2617820203304291,
0.5662567615509033,
0.6158846020698547,
-0.344789981842041,
-0.2787773907184601,
-0.5988747477531433,
0.5525069236755371,
-0.5101072788238525,
1.003953218460083,
-0.18148212134838104,
-0.11670301854610443,
-0.09895672649145126,
0.06281083822250366,
-0.046598948538303375,
-0.4777492880821228,
0.39937373995780945,
-0.6108860373497009,
-0.013831255957484245,
-0.2489428073167801,
-0.5930936336517334,
-0.2921837270259857,
0.12596820294857025,
-0.7497044205665588,
0.6629789471626282,
-0.358543336391449,
-0.5997529029846191,
0.37975603342056274,
-0.553085446357727,
-0.4540298879146576,
0.0681062787771225,
-0.4293191730976105,
-0.38095542788505554,
-0.14082549512386322,
0.25986605882644653,
0.4119977653026581,
-0.7141547799110413,
0.7655565142631531,
-0.4212249219417572,
-0.2150934338569641,
0.13117405772209167,
-0.5558022856712341,
0.6732155084609985,
0.08728670328855515,
-0.4367087483406067,
0.35288095474243164,
-0.9910224080085754,
-0.314496785402298,
0.09663229435682297,
-0.22303546965122223,
-0.3488275706768036,
0.38103213906288147,
-0.4062083959579468,
0.10118380188941956,
0.37886500358581543,
-0.26479125022888184,
0.19303016364574432,
-0.17767688632011414,
0.13702668249607086,
0.9449123740196228,
0.2031673789024353,
0.30952686071395874,
-0.19658376276493073,
0.2389298677444458,
-0.004097334109246731,
0.2651805579662323,
-0.32328861951828003,
-0.13083818554878235,
-0.9153010845184326,
-0.5355022549629211,
-0.22669437527656555,
0.5231137871742249,
-0.7420270442962646,
0.6629013419151306,
0.06631945073604584,
-0.38744333386421204,
-0.2167549431324005,
0.3033421039581299,
0.13841281831264496,
0.7403634190559387,
0.5098495483398438,
0.04973025992512703,
-0.6613168120384216,
-0.8916861414909363,
-0.2900647521018982,
-0.32363995909690857,
0.11878117173910141,
0.3619469404220581,
0.37309756875038147,
-0.5722309350967407,
0.8404239416122437,
-0.5581422448158264,
-0.36375749111175537,
-0.09591170400381088,
0.0759902149438858,
0.350093275308609,
0.33961233496665955,
0.10835229605436325,
-0.4345988929271698,
-0.06007533147931099,
-0.0752076730132103,
-1.132697582244873,
-0.2518072724342346,
-0.1597518026828766,
-0.12299741059541702,
0.024246690794825554,
0.8935281038284302,
-0.43565669655799866,
0.4021003544330597,
0.24225430190563202,
-0.3649468719959259,
0.5295770764350891,
-0.33516186475753784,
0.06596393138170242,
-0.766593337059021,
0.016310861334204674,
-0.2930087149143219,
-0.07256340980529785,
-0.3142414689064026,
0.047539904713630676,
0.027614129707217216,
0.2565656304359436,
-0.2785385847091675,
0.7728055119514465,
-0.5986401438713074,
0.030859271064400673,
-0.5499148368835449,
-0.0039722369983792305,
-0.09207005798816681,
0.40821370482444763,
-0.15305759012699127,
0.2556353509426117,
0.5278434753417969,
-0.6918826699256897,
0.5142653584480286,
0.034820180386304855,
-0.4198208451271057,
0.41097137331962585,
-0.5463632345199585,
-0.18827226758003235,
-0.22937488555908203,
0.4089094400405884,
-0.8642700910568237,
-0.4058836102485657,
0.14559948444366455,
-0.006310875527560711,
0.07580957561731339,
0.1130918338894844,
-0.8867799639701843,
-0.21108566224575043,
0.07295028865337372,
0.5257719159126282,
-0.034737467765808105,
-0.9035322070121765,
0.9583303928375244,
0.1906929761171341,
-0.00030536192934960127,
-0.47532662749290466,
-0.3819728195667267,
0.1736074984073639,
-0.2821679413318634,
-0.461359441280365,
0.1341003030538559,
-0.08323070406913757,
-0.4118303954601288,
-0.0190360676497221,
0.01701415702700615,
0.3456239402294159,
0.3174479603767395,
0.4814501702785492,
0.28787127137184143,
-0.04713526368141174,
0.23447805643081665,
0.08186738938093185,
-0.31875014305114746,
0.29520198702812195,
-0.29849714040756226,
0.4386787414550781,
0.06290370225906372,
-0.8150540590286255,
-0.31800204515457153,
0.2676665484905243,
0.564818263053894,
-0.17522943019866943,
0.6307795643806458,
0.37705275416374207,
-0.5161522030830383,
-0.07026698440313339,
-0.7250593900680542,
-0.16367171704769135,
-0.5045591592788696,
0.2942914068698883,
0.03765769302845001,
-0.9551616907119751,
0.7202451825141907,
-0.34229445457458496,
-0.025676285848021507,
0.5897846221923828,
0.6905909180641174,
0.33594635128974915,
1.1232420206069946,
0.40655356645584106,
-0.16127072274684906,
0.215683713555336,
-0.06504448503255844,
0.2993203103542328,
-0.614457905292511,
-0.5958724021911621,
-0.3021461069583893,
-0.0749567300081253,
-0.42221444845199585,
-0.4573729932308197,
0.6875266432762146,
-0.0056544882245361805,
-0.685930609703064,
0.006246906239539385,
-0.08530426025390625,
0.22188568115234375,
0.5167402029037476,
0.17479826509952545,
0.8576512336730957,
-0.18554332852363586,
-0.2899259626865387,
0.3550218939781189,
-0.672670304775238,
-0.2529727518558502,
0.9344808459281921,
0.2866857349872589,
0.9590292572975159,
0.17788326740264893,
0.47238093614578247,
0.2864462733268738,
0.450470507144928,
-0.5283316969871521,
0.6534830331802368,
0.20810477435588837,
-0.5304519534111023,
-0.03410731256008148,
-0.6159391403198242,
-0.9619781970977783,
-0.06879062205553055,
-0.27286434173583984,
-0.4055931270122528,
0.4229375720024109,
0.25771018862724304,
-0.22744068503379822,
0.40204763412475586,
-0.4799971878528595,
0.47240036725997925,
-0.5309381484985352,
-0.5972685217857361,
-0.269834965467453,
-0.5809504389762878,
0.5577353835105896,
-0.2185952067375183,
0.551148533821106,
-0.20645613968372345,
-0.17505504190921783,
0.5420924425125122,
-0.4729834198951721,
1.0118457078933716,
-0.15432848036289215,
-0.369247168302536,
0.38551583886146545,
0.23868052661418915,
0.6791999340057373,
0.22284211218357086,
0.055125799030065536,
0.15105317533016205,
-0.6027289628982544,
-0.14532247185707092,
-0.6923298835754395,
0.9763718843460083,
-0.5432859659194946,
-0.5764366984367371,
-0.3822726607322693,
-0.7518894076347351,
-0.18103604018688202,
0.3949008584022522,
-0.2135312259197235,
0.47755491733551025,
-0.07757750898599625,
-0.002762129995971918,
0.3237108886241913,
-0.34553632140159607,
0.3279682993888855,
0.9615062475204468,
-0.3270113468170166,
-0.6155127882957458,
0.6744042634963989,
-0.07260377705097198,
0.0874670073390007,
0.4003857672214508,
0.13708487153053284,
-0.2672589421272278,
-0.530021071434021,
-0.026068950071930885,
0.33605602383613586,
-0.7633166909217834,
-0.48846375942230225,
-0.7504228353500366,
-0.03085438348352909,
-0.24820496141910553,
-0.14002537727355957,
-0.47890254855155945,
-0.37193432450294495,
-0.20022279024124146,
-0.38343101739883423,
0.45883357524871826,
0.680694043636322,
-0.4555933475494385,
0.2262876331806183,
-0.418841153383255,
0.3854486644268036,
0.42053699493408203,
0.2042188197374344,
0.31696033477783203,
0.07489520311355591,
-0.46588626503944397,
-0.14168666303157806,
-0.04225149378180504,
-0.46633172035217285,
0.3140489161014557,
-0.17582079768180847,
0.5662971138954163,
0.6827609539031982,
0.005631613079458475,
0.6410616040229797,
-0.5241859555244446,
0.31679317355155945,
0.2121865600347519,
-0.5881541967391968,
0.43549299240112305,
-0.5156918168067932,
0.12159758806228638,
0.29452213644981384,
0.3261830508708954,
-0.08425407856702805,
-0.3642473816871643,
-0.5450668334960938,
-1.1379966735839844,
0.18057267367839813,
-0.08419157564640045,
-0.47902911901474,
-0.36599281430244446,
0.45422056317329407,
0.07083884626626968,
0.2548620402812958,
-0.4843534231185913,
-0.5121639370918274,
0.3253447413444519,
-0.29496175050735474,
-0.12179352343082428,
-0.0813693106174469,
-0.27397558093070984,
-0.3700811266899109,
0.660483717918396,
-0.30204251408576965,
0.19798807799816132,
0.2379646897315979,
0.0022653143387287855,
-0.27275460958480835,
-0.10100399702787399,
0.17039743065834045,
0.5252645015716553,
-0.14124877750873566,
0.5125764608383179,
-0.018853751942515373,
-0.031643714755773544,
0.14082582294940948,
0.44289258122444153,
0.04392480105161667,
-0.3269830346107483,
0.7386911511421204,
0.6737000942230225,
0.28618916869163513,
-0.8548004031181335,
0.20801468193531036,
0.06558424234390259,
0.001665922929532826,
-0.5862775444984436,
0.21071377396583557,
0.17294153571128845,
0.5131524205207825,
0.7701866626739502,
0.009653742425143719,
0.23985005915164948,
-0.5963163375854492,
0.28078803420066833,
0.5861490368843079,
-0.028328469023108482,
-0.10491608083248138,
0.9185417294502258,
0.10164850950241089,
0.0452578067779541,
0.4284858703613281,
0.03599230945110321,
-0.3602621257305145,
0.7235636115074158,
0.41469117999076843,
0.59172523021698,
-0.3123762905597687,
-0.17527532577514648,
0.3034609854221344,
0.35346847772598267,
-0.21721220016479492,
-0.010478300042450428,
-0.05282380431890488,
-0.811477780342102,
-0.4654451310634613,
-0.3372496962547302,
-0.37001174688339233,
0.024286359548568726,
-0.5796515941619873,
0.4172382056713104,
-0.39022713899612427,
0.13096392154693604,
-0.1949707418680191,
0.02628740295767784,
-0.5406311750411987,
0.15133889019489288,
-0.20523330569267273,
0.7121192216873169,
-0.8261243104934692,
0.5201436877250671,
0.2946569323539734,
-0.009495615027844906,
-0.6741957664489746,
-0.4444653391838074,
0.3125189542770386,
-1.0672434568405151,
0.4902314841747284,
0.025702422484755516,
-0.1987631916999817,
0.08609601855278015,
-0.46956363320350647,
-0.9999868869781494,
1.4795185327529907,
0.44442299008369446,
-0.5904533863067627,
0.055894628167152405,
0.13452757894992828,
0.3145029842853546,
-0.5570838451385498,
0.20642422139644623,
0.40001970529556274,
0.4773613512516022,
0.09248308837413788,
-0.5312855839729309,
0.25137218832969666,
-0.15888747572898865,
-0.4312678277492523,
0.25303754210472107,
-0.5601722598075867,
0.7790101170539856,
-0.32088908553123474,
0.07892942428588867,
0.04555796831846237,
0.8751355409622192,
0.5983433127403259,
0.65777987241745,
0.4717329740524292,
0.5140119194984436,
0.8096124529838562,
0.1831481009721756,
0.8465620279312134,
-0.35307812690734863,
0.2090855985879898,
1.3418900966644287,
-0.42693963646888733,
0.44534802436828613,
0.3485160171985626,
0.03328365087509155,
0.7922128438949585,
0.49124905467033386,
0.033818814903497696,
0.44765979051589966,
0.0017365722451359034,
-0.5814613699913025,
-0.38796570897102356,
-0.2695496380329132,
-0.1470736265182495,
0.36401766538619995,
0.5003052949905396,
-0.5780250430107117,
-0.2643298804759979,
0.078982412815094,
0.11351024359464645,
-0.04928981885313988,
-0.4506600797176361,
0.5533176064491272,
0.16623328626155853,
-0.3948679566383362,
0.23764124512672424,
0.21384567022323608,
0.3634348511695862,
-0.6146736741065979,
-0.1602906882762909,
-0.2773510217666626,
0.36813944578170776,
-0.25880277156829834,
-0.23447014391422272,
0.17544537782669067,
-0.21692462265491486,
-0.1080792024731636,
-0.11753429472446442,
0.846985399723053,
-0.5096449255943298,
-0.5956067442893982,
0.5477086901664734,
0.8238465785980225,
-0.155495747923851,
0.0905410572886467,
-0.3053782284259796,
0.057194191962480545,
-0.279043972492218,
-0.00255022244527936,
0.27201417088508606,
0.47931140661239624,
-0.09134017676115036,
0.8698595762252808,
0.7404192686080933,
-0.08968142420053482,
-0.20994874835014343,
0.01509819645434618,
0.9411653876304626,
-0.6810836791992188,
-0.31299033761024475,
-0.9494361281394958,
0.18461354076862335,
0.16231034696102142,
0.30628079175949097,
1.0365890264511108,
0.711983323097229,
0.4379112422466278,
0.22154320776462555,
0.6482250690460205,
0.24749599397182465,
0.5443694591522217,
-0.6248511075973511,
0.5255765914916992,
-0.6352584958076477,
0.6577556133270264,
-0.1655089408159256,
-0.6789835095405579,
-0.4853137135505676,
0.37462711334228516,
-0.19761401414871216,
0.12217748910188675,
0.6483138799667358,
0.7534087300300598,
-0.044621992856264114,
-0.16364465653896332,
-0.09273352473974228,
0.5761531591415405,
0.5660719871520996,
0.5062512755393982,
0.646970272064209,
-0.19015738368034363,
0.2847933769226074,
-0.03126823902130127,
-0.3763105273246765,
-0.05540008097887039,
-1.1149253845214844,
-0.8077455163002014,
-0.4375223219394684,
-0.3416021168231964,
-0.2540639340877533,
-0.006370206363499165,
0.9896158576011658,
0.3076477646827698,
-0.4545767307281494,
-0.3207104504108429,
-0.5457146167755127,
0.38027969002723694,
-0.14720775187015533,
-0.25692689418792725,
0.7222738862037659,
0.05495932325720787,
-0.44250959157943726,
0.802063524723053,
0.4332544803619385,
-0.1037626639008522,
-0.4289766550064087,
-0.06753501296043396,
-0.2907904088497162,
0.15123692154884338,
0.5568695664405823,
0.2909448742866516,
-0.3820127844810486,
-0.14985156059265137,
-0.0994633287191391,
0.20954005420207977,
-0.2339082509279251,
0.9426073431968689,
-0.9360544085502625,
0.29972344636917114,
0.08898238092660904,
0.5230986475944519,
0.3629319369792938,
-0.25254708528518677,
0.6036242246627808,
-0.3989723324775696,
0.11021636426448822,
-0.08323050290346146,
0.6115002036094666,
0.24630382657051086,
-0.3749698996543884,
0.4634685814380646,
0.4454864263534546,
-0.5181368589401245,
-0.8899295330047607,
0.3531711995601654,
-0.8435482978820801,
-0.4523963928222656,
0.9758366942405701,
0.15871016681194305,
-0.04672258347272873,
-0.18066367506980896,
0.21530674397945404,
0.4294062554836273,
-0.08920818567276001,
0.8334036469459534,
0.21498098969459534,
-0.5281522274017334,
0.008116673678159714,
-0.298251211643219,
0.25785598158836365,
0.26090145111083984,
-1.0489875078201294,
0.12504802644252777,
0.6145898103713989,
0.1966664046049118,
-0.01015783753246069,
0.6017933487892151,
-0.24684688448905945,
-0.010024355724453926,
-0.31398242712020874,
0.0066121891140937805,
-0.4188910722732544,
-0.5822604894638062,
-0.09367750585079193,
0.07693241536617279,
-0.024840204045176506,
0.3175446689128876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01740v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01740v1
|
The Psychosocial Impacts of Generative AI Harms
| 2024-05-02T21:21:06 | 2024-05-02T21:21:06 |
Faye-Marie Vassel, Evan Shieh, Cassidy R. Sugimoto, Thema Monroe-White
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rapid emergence of generative Language Models (LMs) has led to growing
concern about the impacts that their unexamined adoption may have on the social
well-being of diverse user groups. Meanwhile, LMs are increasingly being
adopted in K-20 schools and one-on-one student settings with minimal
investigation of potential harms associated with their deployment. Motivated in
part by real-world/everyday use cases (e.g., an AI writing assistant) this
paper explores the potential psychosocial harms of stories generated by five
leading LMs in response to open-ended prompting. We extend findings of
stereotyping harms analyzing a total of 150K 100-word stories related to
student classroom interactions. Examining patterns in LM-generated character
demographics and representational harms (i.e., erasure, subordination, and
stereotyping) we highlight particularly egregious vignettes, illustrating the
ways LM-generated outputs may influence the experiences of users with
marginalized and minoritized identities, and emphasizing the need for a
critical understanding of the psychosocial impacts of generative AI tools when
deployed and utilized in diverse social contexts.
|
[
-0.18224385380744934,
-0.7382198572158813,
0.4313918352127075,
0.4624730944633484,
0.038264647126197815,
-0.06617280095815659,
0.15574492514133453,
-0.7919610142707825,
0.11243870854377747,
0.34981629252433777,
-0.44362470507621765,
-0.4293881356716156,
-0.5135360360145569,
0.35283979773521423,
-0.37402525544166565,
1.0721489191055298,
0.19621002674102783,
-0.024139804765582085,
-0.43857574462890625,
-0.03951345011591911,
-0.7161405682563782,
-0.6728130578994751,
-0.3963576555252075,
0.06064905971288681,
0.8827155232429504,
0.28948670625686646,
0.8198956847190857,
0.34702664613723755,
0.36149969696998596,
0.264911025762558,
-0.1136593222618103,
-0.27950263023376465,
-0.4514240622520447,
0.3671231269836426,
0.14304207265377045,
-0.601576030254364,
-0.17996200919151306,
0.33282873034477234,
0.4343007504940033,
0.8052340745925903,
-0.007797694765031338,
0.1972217857837677,
0.2860977351665497,
0.5429186224937439,
-0.6526205539703369,
-0.09989449381828308,
-0.16190524399280548,
0.35063254833221436,
-0.2144872546195984,
0.3086863160133362,
-0.47888973355293274,
-0.6863431334495544,
-0.04871857166290283,
-0.4865966737270355,
0.017083793878555298,
-0.11580722033977509,
0.5733981728553772,
0.3062431514263153,
-0.22814767062664032,
-0.5829538106918335,
-0.8549615740776062,
0.5453381538391113,
-0.3597908616065979,
0.129750594496727,
0.3365379571914673,
0.23292790353298187,
0.12988319993019104,
-0.3651721775531769,
-0.5970641374588013,
-0.06949044018983841,
-0.33400148153305054,
0.09633085131645203,
-0.3973052501678467,
0.21880607306957245,
0.4069547653198242,
0.16016151010990143,
-0.4864562749862671,
0.4991353750228882,
-0.9602848291397095,
0.11583003401756287,
0.6673944592475891,
0.6158818006515503,
0.7667198181152344,
-0.1619124412536621,
-0.15993160009384155,
-0.027280747890472412,
-0.7773755788803101,
0.05521000921726227,
0.7972553968429565,
0.2889018654823303,
-0.32798001170158386,
0.822878360748291,
0.39226046204566956,
0.4712960124015808,
-0.3225054144859314,
0.12857358157634735,
0.11866156756877899,
-0.23251983523368835,
-0.08061741292476654,
0.2004602998495102,
0.9654479622840881,
0.41520676016807556,
0.7714883089065552,
0.009915565140545368,
0.21419568359851837,
0.24679872393608093,
0.364626407623291,
-0.5468365550041199,
0.20262737572193146,
0.14262385666370392,
-0.3045673966407776,
-0.4730278551578522,
-0.03905094042420387,
-0.8075221180915833,
-0.955599844455719,
-0.022809922695159912,
0.019104795530438423,
-0.5718526840209961,
0.0158525537699461,
-0.07267919182777405,
-0.32520586252212524,
-0.004210531245917082,
0.31221631169319153,
-0.6704323291778564,
-0.12828968465328217,
0.5567843317985535,
0.9584276676177979,
0.09071806073188782,
-0.2343130260705948,
-0.15367314219474792,
0.04422528296709061,
-0.3449593782424927,
0.4146134555339813,
-0.4576142132282257,
-0.8571439385414124,
0.0961836650967598,
-0.38630324602127075,
0.012400582432746887,
-0.8373199105262756,
0.558527410030365,
0.11457151174545288,
0.19344675540924072,
-0.16303503513336182,
-0.1647585928440094,
0.14332950115203857,
-0.13895820081233978,
-0.3301626741886139,
0.5869168639183044,
-0.00452105887234211,
-0.3792870044708252,
0.3257412910461426,
-0.4561612606048584,
-0.6063755750656128,
0.3440910279750824,
-0.20382660627365112,
-0.2092587947845459,
0.22135360538959503,
-0.06787022948265076,
0.6364006996154785,
-0.0050131878815591335,
0.1399804949760437,
-0.08434649556875229,
-0.35454803705215454,
0.23698626458644867,
-0.5220245718955994,
1.2044788599014282,
0.32310059666633606,
-0.07346668094396591,
0.18027988076210022,
-0.5984829068183899,
-0.3498404324054718,
0.27869874238967896,
-0.13265246152877808,
-0.7821586728096008,
-0.22666075825691223,
-0.013226065784692764,
0.26754865050315857,
-0.16991721093654633,
-0.5062958598136902,
-0.17632268369197845,
-0.21374335885047913,
0.13524334132671356,
0.9895472526550293,
0.04839504510164261,
0.07945466041564941,
-0.4325304627418518,
0.9006081223487854,
0.0917673334479332,
0.48249369859695435,
-0.3167327642440796,
-0.5292438864707947,
-0.14736056327819824,
-0.41974174976348877,
-0.3387559950351715,
0.2611021101474762,
-0.635838508605957,
0.16924048960208893,
0.016866488382220268,
-0.61581951379776,
-0.7375767230987549,
-0.023577427491545677,
0.47491613030433655,
0.29257282614707947,
0.056517887860536575,
0.0742296501994133,
-0.4217800796031952,
-1.0161813497543335,
-0.7595067024230957,
-0.5217736959457397,
-0.26402947306632996,
0.4856722056865692,
0.2973078191280365,
-0.26085546612739563,
0.9567946791648865,
-0.4433874785900116,
-0.6058766841888428,
-0.03150409087538719,
0.10808629542589188,
-0.2639225125312805,
0.27506059408187866,
0.6252937912940979,
-0.39437371492385864,
-0.5882934927940369,
-0.5886512994766235,
-1.0304509401321411,
-0.3604012429714203,
-0.42617014050483704,
0.09262008965015411,
0.036665476858615875,
0.3515492379665375,
-0.709496796131134,
0.37933549284935,
0.42494165897369385,
-0.4233194887638092,
0.8609569668769836,
0.09208960831165314,
-0.12092333287000656,
-0.9760029911994934,
-0.24868494272232056,
0.2971805930137634,
0.31733250617980957,
-0.5150421261787415,
0.08606788516044617,
-0.2367211878299713,
-0.36376887559890747,
-0.5229084491729736,
0.31577903032302856,
-0.4930465817451477,
0.14406029880046844,
0.45242273807525635,
0.02382698468863964,
-0.15863005816936493,
-0.02180912345647812,
-0.15148532390594482,
0.8311224579811096,
0.29868125915527344,
-0.4205818474292755,
0.028202516958117485,
0.252421498298645,
-0.4069640636444092,
0.4332438111305237,
-0.8085591793060303,
0.16847999393939972,
-0.5387139320373535,
0.07189268618822098,
-0.5994060039520264,
-0.09904298931360245,
0.5077207684516907,
-0.33281418681144714,
-0.18294182419776917,
0.28124383091926575,
-0.6223925948143005,
-0.1709996610879898,
-0.43963122367858887,
0.5500227212905884,
0.48819199204444885,
-0.48257333040237427,
0.1562153548002243,
0.30688902735710144,
-0.2726430892944336,
-0.2792953550815582,
-0.6352437138557434,
0.3990907371044159,
-0.43613970279693604,
-0.3968338072299957,
-0.06752626597881317,
-0.05487414821982384,
-0.6865260601043701,
-0.1873597353696823,
0.39538559317588806,
0.4126709997653961,
0.19302435219287872,
0.7209839820861816,
0.17907172441482544,
0.062420718371868134,
0.21608567237854004,
0.042909108102321625,
0.12610502541065216,
0.31287914514541626,
0.5347786545753479,
0.45023101568222046,
-0.20089012384414673,
-0.2873328924179077,
-0.15627992153167725,
0.5677631497383118,
0.5581349730491638,
-0.10199279338121414,
1.0457653999328613,
0.29011034965515137,
-0.2531712055206299,
-0.10254403948783875,
-0.0596853643655777,
-0.028614670038223267,
-0.4720391631126404,
0.5245710015296936,
-0.08106770366430283,
-0.7655381560325623,
0.2476385235786438,
0.2322290539741516,
0.16647835075855255,
0.15875078737735748,
0.31857720017433167,
-0.3430914282798767,
0.9688354134559631,
0.5339633822441101,
-0.11592909693717957,
0.6344984173774719,
0.00802394188940525,
0.48651692271232605,
-0.6134833097457886,
-0.5134586691856384,
-0.6070045828819275,
-0.10227453708648682,
-0.5491238832473755,
-0.24712328612804413,
0.7602468729019165,
0.12242702394723892,
-0.2500627338886261,
0.01467858161777258,
-0.5703919529914856,
0.46891072392463684,
0.4198204278945923,
-0.0772976204752922,
0.4004749357700348,
0.07288726419210434,
0.13561579585075378,
-0.2377159744501114,
-0.5220263600349426,
-0.7592686414718628,
0.9333953261375427,
0.584376871585846,
1.1390039920806885,
0.39691269397735596,
0.8121560215950012,
0.46787822246551514,
0.6035511493682861,
-0.8343340158462524,
0.5179605484008789,
0.10805532336235046,
-0.7117185592651367,
-0.41623204946517944,
-0.1960350126028061,
-0.9201486706733704,
0.10940661281347275,
0.028077375143766403,
-1.0463786125183105,
0.20726624131202698,
-0.018178800120949745,
-0.42916470766067505,
0.05381939932703972,
-0.7011663317680359,
0.5997923612594604,
-0.24816671013832092,
-0.21762095391750336,
-0.16932480037212372,
-0.6263043880462646,
0.5009961128234863,
-0.01097501628100872,
0.4551715850830078,
-0.05083455890417099,
0.20840035378932953,
0.6219403743743896,
-0.36588504910469055,
1.2872936725616455,
-0.15878207981586456,
-0.2778327167034149,
0.35838913917541504,
0.23107123374938965,
0.14257623255252838,
-0.1503838300704956,
-0.061686351895332336,
0.5192480087280273,
-0.07332181185483932,
-0.1361003965139389,
-0.4738059341907501,
0.45456361770629883,
-0.9932353496551514,
-0.891265332698822,
-0.4618383049964905,
-0.6601384878158569,
-0.08859892934560776,
-0.10338350385427475,
0.30193138122558594,
0.018913976848125458,
-0.3821949064731598,
-0.09909680485725403,
0.29127490520477295,
-0.6372041702270508,
0.4116225242614746,
0.2892739474773407,
-0.27326786518096924,
-0.10958648473024368,
1.055257797241211,
0.04315894469618797,
0.39283645153045654,
-0.4233826696872711,
0.05388135835528374,
0.0707215890288353,
-0.19543591141700745,
-0.46320533752441406,
0.305350661277771,
-0.5913019180297852,
0.05114337056875229,
-0.7713321447372437,
-0.1788264811038971,
-0.6599947214126587,
-0.4457690715789795,
-0.13305573165416718,
0.03333695977926254,
-0.5485411882400513,
-0.2645663022994995,
0.08716072142124176,
0.9896727204322815,
-0.10027678310871124,
0.20009592175483704,
-0.7996300458908081,
0.08929450064897537,
0.1936952769756317,
0.2364712506532669,
0.10874302685260773,
-0.1280592530965805,
-0.27569082379341125,
-0.02730446495115757,
-0.2458008974790573,
-1.0078368186950684,
0.15908879041671753,
0.18321044743061066,
0.3625449538230896,
0.6585420370101929,
0.20477961003780365,
0.39069098234176636,
-0.4160383641719818,
0.9494339823722839,
0.3207602798938751,
-0.4135773777961731,
0.42507150769233704,
-0.24641604721546173,
0.3045635521411896,
0.29365795850753784,
0.7476685047149658,
-1.1034377813339233,
-0.7129737734794617,
-0.2068711519241333,
-0.8324204683303833,
0.8030981421470642,
0.1810610592365265,
0.6793157458305359,
-0.4005151391029358,
0.19765092432498932,
0.4444301128387451,
0.07174793630838394,
-0.7430287003517151,
-0.6293753385543823,
-0.26793551445007324,
-0.3052339255809784,
-0.22244663536548615,
-0.49063047766685486,
0.043895140290260315,
-0.2605297565460205,
0.5574793815612793,
0.14982178807258606,
0.24761874973773956,
-0.03489456698298454,
-0.11573272943496704,
-0.2906777560710907,
0.2996496558189392,
0.43113774061203003,
-0.0368943065404892,
-0.026014328002929688,
0.045191988348960876,
-0.29896023869514465,
-0.48555609583854675,
0.27173393964767456,
-0.008336074650287628,
-0.4172702431678772,
-0.012441753409802914,
0.4688953757286072,
0.7799073457717896,
-0.23014892637729645,
-0.7974582314491272,
0.21566151082515717,
-0.013094916939735413,
0.0945473164319992,
-0.33964499831199646,
0.14189183712005615,
-0.010123522020876408,
0.11160753667354584,
0.11518172174692154,
-0.008261567912995815,
0.09648317098617554,
-1.0688787698745728,
-0.20778581500053406,
0.41519463062286377,
-0.5527291893959045,
-0.323988139629364,
0.5033936500549316,
0.136698916554451,
-0.7591254115104675,
0.5706812143325806,
0.19558726251125336,
-0.340210497379303,
0.6413823962211609,
0.6103795766830444,
1.1368576288223267,
-0.38694536685943604,
0.7177895307540894,
0.19292069971561432,
0.4918999671936035,
0.5382776260375977,
-0.19852814078330994,
0.044767655432224274,
-0.9007911086082458,
0.4267435073852539,
-0.6809619069099426,
-0.2616853415966034,
0.13545286655426025,
-0.7026629447937012,
0.0561448410153389,
-0.5930224061012268,
-0.03669055923819542,
0.12877339124679565,
-0.8273598551750183,
-0.5258358120918274,
0.008838267996907234,
0.40314438939094543,
0.27195504307746887,
-1.1435489654541016,
0.10356096178293228,
0.8931567668914795,
-0.7509981393814087,
-0.5576452016830444,
0.374250203371048,
0.290840208530426,
-0.702525794506073,
0.6670117974281311,
0.09030439704656601,
0.04941064864397049,
0.05408591777086258,
-0.22328534722328186,
-0.485501766204834,
0.5649774670600891,
0.3253931999206543,
-0.5534220933914185,
-0.2151990532875061,
0.9074440002441406,
1.03963303565979,
-0.21918226778507233,
0.26289471983909607,
0.29821157455444336,
0.16805748641490936,
-0.25743553042411804,
-0.7252529859542847,
0.20643426477909088,
-0.1323860138654709,
0.11793436855077744,
-0.037831470370292664,
-0.7685320973396301,
0.7262334823608398,
-0.5760608911514282,
-0.4427826702594757,
-0.09851676970720291,
0.2361789494752884,
0.3102351129055023,
0.27501383423805237,
0.2884684205055237,
0.1551486700773239,
0.42749640345573425,
0.3899919092655182,
1.1425206661224365,
0.10572212189435959,
-0.1999976634979248,
0.9421562552452087,
-0.15217801928520203,
0.23672805726528168,
0.5230553150177002,
-0.37901002168655396,
0.5299612283706665,
0.41307973861694336,
0.1384536772966385,
0.21425208449363708,
0.5618117451667786,
-0.5676280856132507,
0.23948286473751068,
-0.5952209234237671,
-0.28070756793022156,
0.3779017925262451,
0.39007967710494995,
-0.6561000943183899,
-0.23668569326400757,
0.4639890193939209,
0.10902229696512222,
0.23883244395256042,
-0.13314205408096313,
0.8435778021812439,
0.45219701528549194,
-0.5117051005363464,
0.26813679933547974,
-0.03626072779297829,
0.6878476738929749,
-0.17537464201450348,
-0.08640848845243454,
-0.3399798572063446,
-0.03626725450158119,
-0.28059589862823486,
-0.7357307076454163,
0.22685082256793976,
0.27205801010131836,
-0.25658583641052246,
-0.4352652132511139,
0.7242375016212463,
-0.3206518590450287,
-0.5614464282989502,
0.2982909083366394,
0.8060421347618103,
0.3871997892856598,
-0.10701097548007965,
-0.33436253666877747,
-0.0327136293053627,
-0.1367315948009491,
-0.17372505366802216,
0.576238214969635,
0.2132178097963333,
-0.37787479162216187,
0.5690746903419495,
0.3348856270313263,
-0.07950110733509064,
0.14956754446029663,
0.3855661451816559,
0.6049256324768066,
-0.5392234921455383,
-0.3730577826499939,
-0.8353931307792664,
0.5832277536392212,
0.21255037188529968,
-0.49378037452697754,
0.7023525238037109,
0.4821591079235077,
0.7759031653404236,
-0.10999994724988937,
0.9710103869438171,
-0.060356102883815765,
0.06974463909864426,
-0.0562615729868412,
0.9726114273071289,
-0.3989940285682678,
0.5965094566345215,
-0.6018440127372742,
-0.6969780921936035,
-0.022726334631443024,
0.17028604447841644,
-0.4044170677661896,
0.2949689030647278,
0.3296215534210205,
0.5126088261604309,
0.4809187948703766,
0.1123175099492073,
0.6278453469276428,
0.37954169511795044,
0.2584541440010071,
0.18675397336483002,
1.1420576572418213,
-0.18746061623096466,
0.27962934970855713,
-0.35034143924713135,
-0.14748415350914001,
-0.0014891292667016387,
-0.32750242948532104,
-0.9254924654960632,
-0.630690336227417,
-0.3979012072086334,
-0.2284257560968399,
0.26868849992752075,
0.7429152131080627,
-0.08953829109668732,
-0.44254133105278015,
-0.23396797478199005,
0.05799455568194389,
0.3226783275604248,
0.19847050309181213,
-0.42188453674316406,
0.092007115483284,
-0.18509386479854584,
-0.7588708400726318,
0.07205134630203247,
0.05179286748170853,
0.19698357582092285,
-0.4794861674308777,
-0.14012137055397034,
0.07022830843925476,
0.00727413035929203,
0.8519056439399719,
0.08977016061544418,
-0.6638219356536865,
-0.38381117582321167,
-0.19404812157154083,
-0.2694145739078522,
-0.15750613808631897,
0.7140262126922607,
-0.6971099972724915,
0.3905532658100128,
0.023411938920617104,
0.20637907087802887,
-0.134535551071167,
-0.03950326517224312,
0.7659542560577393,
-0.9183915853500366,
-0.1523708701133728,
0.4649790823459625,
0.04063984006643295,
0.14356079697608948,
-0.9434800744056702,
0.41147226095199585,
0.4036865830421448,
-0.003294583410024643,
-1.1437656879425049,
0.08695196360349655,
-0.12783460319042206,
-0.46953171491622925,
1.1155881881713867,
-0.24587103724479675,
0.12540392577648163,
-0.06632189452648163,
-0.329646497964859,
0.30425241589546204,
-0.2623271048069,
1.0142736434936523,
0.6546139121055603,
-0.2879926860332489,
-0.39949682354927063,
-0.38820189237594604,
0.507350504398346,
0.6010115146636963,
-0.806069016456604,
0.16743189096450806,
0.8953880071640015,
0.21870778501033783,
0.06693895161151886,
0.42824649810791016,
-0.23075804114341736,
0.08310596644878387,
0.29299789667129517,
0.5220808982849121,
-0.3152179419994354,
-0.2807632386684418,
-0.39781248569488525,
0.18237602710723877,
-0.05842854082584381,
0.10101480036973953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01738v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01738v1
|
Question Suggestion for Conversational Shopping Assistants Using Product Metadata
| 2024-05-02T21:16:19 | 2024-05-02T21:16:19 |
Nikhita Vedula, Oleg Rokhlenko, Shervin Malmasi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Digital assistants have become ubiquitous in e-commerce applications,
following the recent advancements in Information Retrieval (IR), Natural
Language Processing (NLP) and Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI). However,
customers are often unsure or unaware of how to effectively converse with these
assistants to meet their shopping needs. In this work, we emphasize the
importance of providing customers a fast, easy to use, and natural way to
interact with conversational shopping assistants. We propose a framework that
employs Large Language Models (LLMs) to automatically generate contextual,
useful, answerable, fluent and diverse questions about products, via in-context
learning and supervised fine-tuning. Recommending these questions to customers
as helpful suggestions or hints to both start and continue a conversation can
result in a smoother and faster shopping experience with reduced conversation
overhead and friction. We perform extensive offline evaluations, and discuss in
detail about potential customer impact, and the type, length and latency of our
generated product questions if incorporated into a real-world shopping
assistant.
|
[
-0.7254610061645508,
-1.134954571723938,
0.492809534072876,
0.31223493814468384,
-0.2533130645751953,
-0.008722057566046715,
-0.2133597880601883,
-1.0477360486984253,
0.4566410481929779,
0.7001164555549622,
-0.9076623320579529,
-0.3980141580104828,
-0.023636961355805397,
0.2227427214384079,
-0.3123339116573334,
0.8637702465057373,
0.2623691260814667,
0.0017591888317838311,
-0.6019546985626221,
0.0034419801086187363,
-0.6659292578697205,
-0.22017955780029297,
-1.1919522285461426,
-0.04612530767917633,
0.37153714895248413,
0.7261973023414612,
0.6691408753395081,
-0.09129180014133453,
0.29962459206581116,
0.3979727029800415,
-0.15285171568393707,
0.7672699689865112,
-0.08740003407001495,
0.6297411918640137,
-0.10914866626262665,
-0.5215509533882141,
-0.5830431580543518,
-0.30331912636756897,
-0.10598970949649811,
0.7669830918312073,
-0.1484801024198532,
0.40800100564956665,
0.005805541295558214,
0.499693900346756,
-0.5546537041664124,
-0.022445598617196083,
-0.741041362285614,
0.1918831169605255,
0.3898259997367859,
-0.3182365298271179,
-0.2726998031139374,
-0.27239686250686646,
0.42382752895355225,
-0.8558663129806519,
0.24585503339767456,
0.08004695177078247,
0.8025211691856384,
0.29669541120529175,
-0.1193404570221901,
-0.6142412424087524,
-1.3250529766082764,
0.48291388154029846,
-0.5418010950088501,
0.318606972694397,
0.8882265686988831,
0.425657719373703,
-0.14138339459896088,
-0.6204056739807129,
-0.5590324997901917,
-0.3122347295284271,
-0.219168558716774,
0.18861928582191467,
-0.35544776916503906,
-0.1438390165567398,
0.25401270389556885,
0.2404993772506714,
-0.46644318103790283,
-0.24179059267044067,
-0.14414124190807343,
0.24781644344329834,
0.7799206972122192,
0.35908013582229614,
0.03899603709578514,
0.11987239867448807,
-0.11049899458885193,
0.23427079617977142,
-0.23374757170677185,
0.05827260762453079,
0.3314040005207062,
0.16056454181671143,
0.14333844184875488,
0.5133970379829407,
-0.8278131484985352,
0.9815271496772766,
0.48177477717399597,
-0.1186387911438942,
-0.009191269986331463,
-0.5358942747116089,
-0.009515272453427315,
-0.14788727462291718,
0.5082118511199951,
0.7932649254798889,
0.08055470138788223,
-0.39654216170310974,
-0.038769062608480453,
-0.48978739976882935,
0.3573972284793854,
-0.4375656247138977,
-0.019001705572009087,
0.43546798825263977,
-0.24075695872306824,
-0.14244185388088226,
0.21609698235988617,
-0.8611968755722046,
-0.22237826883792877,
-0.5160799622535706,
0.13906444609165192,
0.12887153029441833,
0.10205193608999252,
0.15033170580863953,
-0.010104497894644737,
0.09982790797948837,
0.29988113045692444,
-0.9846046566963196,
0.48250046372413635,
0.4158213138580322,
0.41008859872817993,
0.041960857808589935,
0.19446149468421936,
-0.370540589094162,
0.3941728472709656,
-0.10218026489019394,
1.0898573398590088,
-0.7117980718612671,
-0.5512268543243408,
0.21099479496479034,
0.3740848898887634,
0.235735684633255,
-0.8631648421287537,
0.324504017829895,
-0.6662442088127136,
0.338058203458786,
-0.2917538583278656,
-0.32523348927497864,
-0.03607477992773056,
0.8580441474914551,
-0.4920124113559723,
0.9631302356719971,
-0.09166696667671204,
-0.5968563556671143,
0.5718221068382263,
-0.6163809895515442,
-0.5194987058639526,
0.4107615351676941,
0.2083953320980072,
-0.5504891276359558,
-0.15204213559627533,
0.5108093023300171,
0.42978915572166443,
-0.2617979347705841,
0.10405779629945755,
-0.341988742351532,
-0.28025999665260315,
0.4585690498352051,
-0.27226507663726807,
0.3620454668998718,
0.39686641097068787,
-0.5006672739982605,
0.12674663960933685,
-0.8795254826545715,
-0.030387569218873978,
0.18697582185268402,
-0.3737739622592926,
-0.11533141881227493,
-0.1477186381816864,
0.16885781288146973,
-0.01876164972782135,
0.5212501287460327,
-0.30466964840888977,
0.43315252661705017,
-0.36144939064979553,
0.06517574936151505,
0.5830429196357727,
0.226898655295372,
0.3587145507335663,
-0.38057929277420044,
0.8899384140968323,
-0.29404908418655396,
0.5973355174064636,
-0.28478705883026123,
-0.8079392910003662,
-1.1141642332077026,
0.18979625403881073,
0.1871401071548462,
0.5852241516113281,
-0.9333251118659973,
0.5402483344078064,
-0.012266194447875023,
-0.47930312156677246,
-0.20367515087127686,
0.32132217288017273,
0.14175257086753845,
0.49125179648399353,
0.3189345598220825,
-0.2461054027080536,
-0.41495540738105774,
-0.9228426218032837,
-0.056920137256383896,
-0.25755760073661804,
-0.3823450207710266,
1.0478744506835938,
-0.038201309740543365,
-0.36193037033081055,
1.4140868186950684,
-1.1043635606765747,
-0.45281898975372314,
-0.4357928931713104,
0.09386101365089417,
-0.12148761749267578,
0.1229669600725174,
0.28930407762527466,
-0.8609246611595154,
-0.6266965270042419,
-0.06241369619965553,
-0.13396018743515015,
-0.2570497393608093,
-0.33718934655189514,
-0.09364504367113113,
0.4118305444717407,
0.4239742159843445,
-0.7247117757797241,
0.24160026013851166,
0.13804315030574799,
-0.20503099262714386,
0.28342148661613464,
-0.5789890885353088,
0.13891813158988953,
-1.585234522819519,
0.07848574966192245,
0.12727421522140503,
-0.16628146171569824,
-0.6265586018562317,
-0.25116094946861267,
-0.3192865252494812,
-0.14958308637142181,
-0.6378372311592102,
0.5551381707191467,
0.05626707896590233,
-0.27659374475479126,
-0.03695047274231911,
-0.0069605209864676,
0.3042815327644348,
0.535330593585968,
0.3036315143108368,
0.7764905095100403,
0.1948690414428711,
-1.147931456565857,
0.3314635753631592,
0.6618109345436096,
-0.18176360428333282,
0.9581279158592224,
-0.7813098430633545,
0.21990789473056793,
-0.06710225343704224,
0.41306355595588684,
-0.880946695804596,
-0.2166861742734909,
0.45627743005752563,
-0.2612539529800415,
-0.05986104905605316,
-0.1459806263446808,
-0.6970429420471191,
-0.49904680252075195,
-0.0788697749376297,
0.40334126353263855,
0.31000176072120667,
-0.7400866150856018,
0.48287907242774963,
0.42315077781677246,
-0.30466383695602417,
-0.10633505880832672,
-0.5359206795692444,
0.30234450101852417,
-0.40584561228752136,
-0.8195657730102539,
0.32927075028419495,
-0.530890166759491,
-0.22932453453540802,
-0.32454273104667664,
0.2879053056240082,
-0.05887731909751892,
0.28843456506729126,
0.00654457276687026,
0.19549691677093506,
0.07092266529798508,
0.4388817846775055,
-0.24495555460453033,
-0.18578732013702393,
0.0017226734198629856,
-0.43399494886398315,
0.6978111863136292,
-0.1381150186061859,
-0.32605794072151184,
-0.23915566504001617,
0.5316794514656067,
0.19503678381443024,
-0.22998297214508057,
0.4346514046192169,
0.6767200827598572,
-0.08711909502744675,
-0.059648361057043076,
-0.6113313436508179,
-0.2906108796596527,
-0.5843764543533325,
0.08410473167896271,
-0.30613183975219727,
-0.7318205833435059,
0.5528767704963684,
-0.08160103112459183,
-0.1428128331899643,
-0.013618498109281063,
0.6934056878089905,
-0.24837730824947357,
1.5717384815216064,
0.6376816630363464,
0.2633580267429352,
0.5530542135238647,
-0.2878425717353821,
0.5769027471542358,
-0.5925751328468323,
-0.7046090960502625,
-0.6020401120185852,
-0.4040442109107971,
-0.4910305142402649,
-0.23028753697872162,
0.2517161965370178,
-0.1658441424369812,
0.013116318732500076,
0.4305580258369446,
-0.41472354531288147,
0.40721461176872253,
0.9370559453964233,
0.2057485729455948,
0.3109404742717743,
0.007041600067168474,
0.23887822031974792,
0.28705769777297974,
-0.48564934730529785,
-0.39220187067985535,
0.7325251698493958,
0.1190432757139206,
0.8458886742591858,
0.019275903701782227,
0.425428181886673,
0.06530090421438217,
-0.24194100499153137,
-1.1943073272705078,
0.6713165044784546,
0.07021272927522659,
-0.42443394660949707,
0.026700640097260475,
-0.12085113674402237,
-1.335944414138794,
-0.45317381620407104,
-0.2532997727394104,
-0.883363664150238,
0.2788655459880829,
0.27948957681655884,
-0.807195782661438,
0.046060096472501755,
-0.5285276770591736,
0.6377460956573486,
-0.5209434032440186,
-0.5651739239692688,
0.12967424094676971,
-0.4289448857307434,
-0.03877086937427521,
0.177614226937294,
-0.038649529218673706,
-0.06371068209409714,
0.03870057314634323,
0.7086141705513,
-0.27213871479034424,
0.602867066860199,
0.13691534101963043,
-0.34916073083877563,
0.447695255279541,
0.03643735870718956,
0.43808257579803467,
0.17287342250347137,
0.37839043140411377,
-0.20002585649490356,
-0.07674883306026459,
-0.19050078094005585,
-0.8037756085395813,
0.5151277780532837,
-0.28434187173843384,
-0.7102300524711609,
-0.023056285455822945,
-0.6019582152366638,
-0.8726455569267273,
0.05462276563048363,
0.006853738334029913,
0.11164112389087677,
-0.12407625466585159,
0.20601190626621246,
0.674081563949585,
-0.21589921414852142,
0.4716208577156067,
0.5664560198783875,
-0.25004342198371887,
-0.12365971505641937,
0.9489240050315857,
-0.1082715094089508,
0.18035709857940674,
0.3350018560886383,
0.25265827775001526,
-0.38148242235183716,
-0.18243172764778137,
-0.580947756767273,
-0.07281184941530228,
-0.6979696750640869,
-0.26197999715805054,
-0.8917142748832703,
0.32340556383132935,
-0.4538920521736145,
-0.17478880286216736,
-0.09274809807538986,
-0.4628249406814575,
-0.5721510052680969,
-0.10585033148527145,
0.655523419380188,
0.727789580821991,
0.3418494164943695,
0.39069297909736633,
-1.013667106628418,
0.29875504970550537,
0.8535951972007751,
0.38100627064704895,
0.0012752511538565159,
-0.155901700258255,
-0.415662556886673,
0.19520072638988495,
-0.4019196927547455,
-0.3725571632385254,
0.4796479046344757,
0.05159557983279228,
0.4070706367492676,
0.8184493184089661,
0.25732192397117615,
0.7808545827865601,
-0.24657119810581207,
1.0623352527618408,
0.023619161918759346,
-0.39562711119651794,
0.5909339189529419,
-0.3244520127773285,
0.43575096130371094,
0.6626948118209839,
0.47518664598464966,
-0.6063784956932068,
-0.1267005354166031,
-0.6060506105422974,
-1.1468350887298584,
0.6267111301422119,
-0.008691089227795601,
0.43778902292251587,
-0.3429279029369354,
-0.1698836088180542,
0.2712969481945038,
0.33377939462661743,
-0.19180932641029358,
-0.1985275149345398,
0.1682037115097046,
0.03421642258763313,
0.051955245435237885,
-0.2119293361902237,
-0.00946772750467062,
-0.18688909709453583,
0.44070881605148315,
-0.5174559950828552,
0.3179304599761963,
0.03168860450387001,
0.18878307938575745,
-0.29282090067863464,
0.33419790863990784,
0.6166737079620361,
0.6472965478897095,
-0.35790351033210754,
-0.3593038320541382,
0.32501474022865295,
-0.12321154773235321,
-0.23442843556404114,
-0.0906798467040062,
-0.3101978003978729,
-0.1534881889820099,
-0.34592318534851074,
0.4974665343761444,
0.16140401363372803,
-0.9663561582565308,
0.2213067263364792,
-0.536751389503479,
-0.17249444127082825,
-0.5809884071350098,
-0.056278474628925323,
0.22255562245845795,
0.1960076093673706,
0.1364915519952774,
0.022751308977603912,
0.544579029083252,
-0.76875901222229,
0.22812189161777496,
0.7768141031265259,
-0.45524880290031433,
0.08180750906467438,
0.33655333518981934,
0.38413456082344055,
-0.7458224892616272,
0.48763078451156616,
-0.1607876867055893,
-0.5453906655311584,
0.5372682809829712,
0.5794845819473267,
1.1052942276000977,
0.061770517379045486,
0.6453943252563477,
0.14117677509784698,
-0.07665126025676727,
0.029917731881141663,
0.27615541219711304,
-0.5958214402198792,
-0.5655951499938965,
-0.017829909920692444,
-0.6056876182556152,
-0.6085447072982788,
0.09544358402490616,
-0.6204099655151367,
0.48578503727912903,
-0.3326566219329834,
-0.17621421813964844,
-0.10958855599164963,
0.0937732383608818,
-0.7334165573120117,
0.4808175265789032,
0.3061211109161377,
0.6351822018623352,
-0.4700075387954712,
0.4788605570793152,
0.41762030124664307,
-0.5658001899719238,
-0.6710028052330017,
0.15924127399921417,
-0.49606257677078247,
-0.4807230830192566,
0.5015559196472168,
0.16941167414188385,
-0.2968529462814331,
-0.49496275186538696,
-0.37589535117149353,
-0.6475856304168701,
1.1497677564620972,
0.01804700493812561,
-0.5252681374549866,
-0.10202697664499283,
0.6453028321266174,
0.6375762820243835,
-0.49407297372817993,
0.6205122470855713,
0.587067186832428,
0.4689882695674896,
0.5880666375160217,
-0.8137103915214539,
-0.18635053932666779,
-0.41541728377342224,
-0.06820584088563919,
-0.07819996774196625,
-0.5744997262954712,
0.5217397212982178,
0.10504195839166641,
0.12862525880336761,
0.44417956471443176,
0.1381937861442566,
-0.020521797239780426,
0.8071568608283997,
0.6858484148979187,
0.7044210433959961,
0.7169991731643677,
0.22365324199199677,
1.0115454196929932,
-0.3485729694366455,
-0.10248477756977081,
1.2065335512161255,
-0.2952876687049866,
0.889019787311554,
0.416633665561676,
-0.16823917627334595,
0.41328832507133484,
0.9277594685554504,
-0.1320112943649292,
0.340131551027298,
0.030734818428754807,
-0.21183618903160095,
-0.34595590829849243,
-0.466154545545578,
-0.24923042953014374,
0.4801856279373169,
0.2632772922515869,
-0.30050939321517944,
-0.06649108231067657,
-0.008148283697664738,
-0.3115618824958801,
-0.15436063706874847,
-0.22429051995277405,
1.3848025798797607,
-0.2271803915500641,
-0.8499226570129395,
0.5013280510902405,
-0.1128062978386879,
0.5862820744514465,
-0.5657305121421814,
-0.22288523614406586,
-0.4213452637195587,
0.14772072434425354,
-0.3418337404727936,
-0.51668381690979,
0.2859918475151062,
0.03755902126431465,
-0.12727808952331543,
-0.11830747872591019,
0.6606485247612,
-0.530535101890564,
-0.7131574749946594,
0.08377217501401901,
0.429561585187912,
0.1039310097694397,
-0.051667917519807816,
-0.9788313508033752,
-0.469292551279068,
-0.13025029003620148,
-0.21815504133701324,
0.2152942717075348,
0.000781304610427469,
-0.11872100085020065,
0.9654021263122559,
0.8560900688171387,
-0.1616744101047516,
-0.1358310580253601,
0.13561856746673584,
0.649989902973175,
-0.3993554413318634,
-0.67195725440979,
-0.37986770272254944,
0.5346434712409973,
-0.30361834168434143,
-0.3339816927909851,
0.9415580034255981,
0.4951315224170685,
1.0073230266571045,
-0.0878475084900856,
0.4705536365509033,
0.3211077153682709,
0.27851223945617676,
-0.40410396456718445,
0.578400194644928,
-0.6671825647354126,
0.6905927658081055,
-0.3708018958568573,
-1.2220869064331055,
-0.2564544081687927,
0.542046844959259,
-0.34034937620162964,
0.10625839233398438,
0.38144493103027344,
0.8413665890693665,
-0.16981667280197144,
0.20895765721797943,
0.29861167073249817,
-0.14351089298725128,
0.3838963210582733,
0.26899346709251404,
0.7184695601463318,
-0.1265266090631485,
0.7571844458580017,
-0.39642560482025146,
0.17532022297382355,
-0.454913467168808,
-0.7913821339607239,
-0.746758222579956,
-0.5781025290489197,
-0.46360012888908386,
-0.22005008161067963,
-0.1311189979314804,
1.2644591331481934,
0.8024727702140808,
-0.7162261009216309,
-0.2275838553905487,
-0.12170295417308807,
-0.06027655303478241,
-0.12377627938985825,
-0.2457486242055893,
0.1330278366804123,
-0.3217720687389374,
-0.9593389630317688,
0.39645788073539734,
0.19862832129001617,
0.2860907018184662,
-0.41884949803352356,
-0.0551283024251461,
-0.24809600412845612,
0.496883362531662,
0.6132846474647522,
0.03133868798613548,
-0.5877307057380676,
-0.054187189787626266,
0.3482206463813782,
0.38761526346206665,
0.031388118863105774,
0.8310766816139221,
-0.9437339305877686,
0.6385650038719177,
0.4094354510307312,
0.6661097407341003,
0.4894343316555023,
0.0835702195763588,
0.6943954229354858,
-0.6262180805206299,
0.11142810434103012,
0.4183661639690399,
0.19525185227394104,
0.4123772978782654,
-0.560668408870697,
0.3260686695575714,
-0.21654565632343292,
-0.41714754700660706,
-0.5201117992401123,
0.559132993221283,
-0.9726448059082031,
-0.4154050052165985,
1.1495999097824097,
-0.10823489725589752,
-0.20450277626514435,
-0.38253313302993774,
-0.7187342047691345,
-0.08434177935123444,
-0.3012179732322693,
1.2552127838134766,
0.4014899730682373,
-0.18589213490486145,
-0.11572886258363724,
-0.030065376311540604,
0.5370336771011353,
0.4841003715991974,
-0.9576285481452942,
-0.06301160156726837,
0.3002876341342926,
-0.09290529042482376,
0.3058503270149231,
0.4086543023586273,
0.5306479930877686,
0.3283955454826355,
-0.3346398174762726,
-0.3463052213191986,
-0.026396270841360092,
-0.30474212765693665,
0.05856576934456825,
0.1234450712800026,
0.16924552619457245,
-0.12652309238910675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01724v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01724v1
|
Large Language Models are Inconsistent and Biased Evaluators
| 2024-05-02T20:42:28 | 2024-05-02T20:42:28 |
Rickard Stureborg, Dimitris Alikaniotis, Yoshi Suhara
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50 (Primary) 68T01, 68T37, 91F20 (Secondary), I.2; I.2.7; I.7
|
The zero-shot capability of Large Language Models (LLMs) has enabled highly
flexible, reference-free metrics for various tasks, making LLM evaluators
common tools in NLP. However, the robustness of these LLM evaluators remains
relatively understudied; existing work mainly pursued optimal performance in
terms of correlating LLM scores with human expert scores. In this paper, we
conduct a series of analyses using the SummEval dataset and confirm that LLMs
are biased evaluators as they: (1) exhibit familiarity bias-a preference for
text with lower perplexity, (2) show skewed and biased distributions of
ratings, and (3) experience anchoring effects for multi-attribute judgments. We
also found that LLMs are inconsistent evaluators, showing low "inter-sample"
agreement and sensitivity to prompt differences that are insignificant to human
understanding of text quality. Furthermore, we share recipes for configuring
LLM evaluators to mitigate these limitations. Experimental results on the RoSE
dataset demonstrate improvements over the state-of-the-art LLM evaluators.
|
[
-0.2784772515296936,
-0.3977084755897522,
0.7109771966934204,
0.14096751809120178,
-0.03241928666830063,
0.09981905668973923,
-0.33920347690582275,
-0.34025776386260986,
0.12556949257850647,
0.3892388939857483,
-0.26016104221343994,
-0.40584394335746765,
-0.8644115924835205,
0.1411585807800293,
-0.39226511120796204,
1.24452805519104,
-0.0070157041773200035,
0.014658757485449314,
-0.47649508714675903,
-0.5160852670669556,
-0.37632012367248535,
-0.6768888235092163,
-0.17532409727573395,
-0.612568736076355,
0.5426908135414124,
0.3048408329486847,
0.8028815984725952,
0.21927884221076965,
0.5297726392745972,
0.21041814982891083,
-0.12799160182476044,
-0.012071244418621063,
-0.455079048871994,
0.2473703771829605,
-0.418648362159729,
-0.5025324821472168,
-0.6666159629821777,
0.09182053804397583,
0.5781325101852417,
0.6891095638275146,
-0.03890861198306084,
0.13144011795520782,
0.1392233818769455,
0.6251286268234253,
-0.9151833057403564,
-0.015820419415831566,
-0.8205242156982422,
-0.17372745275497437,
-0.0191605594009161,
-0.13481813669204712,
-0.32460227608680725,
-0.31672143936157227,
0.13964737951755524,
-0.18437638878822327,
0.11891937255859375,
-0.07391277700662613,
0.7125275135040283,
0.589146614074707,
-0.42997613549232483,
-0.23537346720695496,
-0.6250320076942444,
1.2315175533294678,
-1.0595121383666992,
0.27700915932655334,
0.3688722252845764,
0.08905962109565735,
-0.058201029896736145,
0.005802292842417955,
-0.4491519629955292,
-0.256422221660614,
0.04226436838507652,
0.16519992053508759,
-0.3354848623275757,
-0.1938779503107071,
0.09764732420444489,
0.2637263834476471,
-0.697088360786438,
0.46723222732543945,
0.013656439259648323,
-0.18010418117046356,
0.6769480109214783,
0.1677056849002838,
0.1112845242023468,
-0.1679229438304901,
-0.2998080551624298,
0.1984184980392456,
-0.7349395155906677,
0.025138521566987038,
0.48489809036254883,
0.2058858871459961,
-0.07191292941570282,
0.7530003786087036,
-0.21107037365436554,
0.8449870944023132,
-0.16065669059753418,
-0.22228488326072693,
0.3013388514518738,
-0.16900378465652466,
-0.2629558742046356,
-0.15282069146633148,
1.071390986442566,
0.4539780616760254,
0.5141807198524475,
-0.1172497570514679,
-0.33831581473350525,
0.1354275941848755,
0.17376284301280975,
-0.601725161075592,
-0.11066105961799622,
0.38174968957901,
-0.132797509431839,
-0.4522903859615326,
-0.10470827668905258,
-0.6920669078826904,
-0.3903440833091736,
-0.2354670763015747,
0.33839151263237,
-0.16512756049633026,
-0.15337668359279633,
0.06592902541160583,
0.0003887731290888041,
0.06721355766057968,
0.3147045969963074,
-0.80623459815979,
0.3685741126537323,
0.6037124991416931,
0.652925431728363,
-0.4014345705509186,
-0.41463714838027954,
-0.5855324268341064,
-0.21979501843452454,
-0.3186993896961212,
0.8916801810264587,
-0.5673971772193909,
-0.1952270269393921,
-0.07192742824554443,
-0.22998236119747162,
0.06328543275594711,
-0.434506893157959,
0.6444202065467834,
-0.37109827995300293,
0.2885790467262268,
-0.38906916975975037,
-0.6034078598022461,
-0.02881229855120182,
0.30920249223709106,
-0.5020312070846558,
0.8793763518333435,
0.0801687017083168,
-0.7469693422317505,
0.43406549096107483,
-0.40453287959098816,
-0.09626946598291397,
-0.1430479735136032,
-0.21740074455738068,
-0.22737912833690643,
0.29081088304519653,
0.33917471766471863,
0.6415006518363953,
-0.33792147040367126,
0.3603956699371338,
-0.25175368785858154,
-0.490213543176651,
0.5159074664115906,
-0.6718202829360962,
0.6427010297775269,
0.05295157805085182,
-0.12499828636646271,
0.05499503016471863,
-0.9401912093162537,
-0.1653847098350525,
-0.026601258665323257,
-0.4117347300052643,
-0.4461296796798706,
0.06730971485376358,
-0.008966883644461632,
0.006035421509295702,
0.17499203979969025,
-0.46393120288848877,
0.26727497577667236,
-0.3426503837108612,
0.22174155712127686,
0.838371753692627,
-0.11849497258663177,
0.4266197979450226,
-0.42853567004203796,
0.5543221235275269,
0.0014193588867783546,
-0.3836626410484314,
-0.3194751739501953,
-0.3011535406112671,
-0.7116349339485168,
-0.071890689432621,
0.34325364232063293,
0.4444614052772522,
-0.5421317219734192,
0.532792329788208,
-0.3704652488231659,
-0.38120099902153015,
-0.3779958188533783,
0.4032467305660248,
0.4178798198699951,
0.3934386670589447,
0.26173126697540283,
-0.20063331723213196,
-0.2593218982219696,
-0.8581257462501526,
-0.43982818722724915,
-0.14174127578735352,
-0.21398626267910004,
0.22987373173236847,
0.5382688045501709,
0.025348655879497528,
1.070777416229248,
-0.392251193523407,
-0.1260993778705597,
-0.3552795946598053,
0.11295443028211594,
0.41853997111320496,
0.25322386622428894,
0.6944328546524048,
-0.25080549716949463,
-0.3445926010608673,
-0.32191720604896545,
-0.5649818778038025,
-0.4698195457458496,
-0.009664105251431465,
0.11330831050872803,
0.208462193608284,
0.24087631702423096,
-0.4745159447193146,
0.017053883522748947,
0.8021075129508972,
-0.28574827313423157,
0.7754693627357483,
0.06342623382806778,
0.0038293576799333096,
-0.9478270411491394,
0.07831532508134842,
0.36895179748535156,
-0.4197590947151184,
-0.5180920362472534,
-0.06509538739919662,
0.020002331584692,
0.3810725212097168,
-0.34430763125419617,
0.6452828645706177,
-0.341094434261322,
0.03293347358703613,
-0.3205541670322418,
0.4564642310142517,
0.24791407585144043,
0.4679359793663025,
-0.1268956959247589,
0.7596558928489685,
0.408779501914978,
-0.5283472537994385,
0.4152887463569641,
0.0599028505384922,
-0.6422523856163025,
0.826033353805542,
-0.806739091873169,
0.27386653423309326,
-0.17982423305511475,
0.16569076478481293,
-1.0497304201126099,
-0.3364139199256897,
-0.003719375468790531,
-0.4283130466938019,
0.5114656686782837,
0.0015804969007149339,
-0.20934881269931793,
-0.01703532598912716,
-0.5533404350280762,
0.5092834234237671,
0.3919614255428314,
-0.390026718378067,
0.43381986021995544,
0.3391478657722473,
-0.1563621312379837,
-1.078804612159729,
-0.8684535622596741,
0.09854939579963684,
-0.1135346069931984,
-0.28805050253868103,
-0.14866004884243011,
-0.07371421158313751,
-0.5625969171524048,
-0.06586194038391113,
-0.1641608029603958,
0.0547698438167572,
0.043630000203847885,
0.26121199131011963,
0.32418352365493774,
-0.25664377212524414,
0.19320762157440186,
-0.22980856895446777,
-0.05968175828456879,
-0.03464830666780472,
-0.04553939029574394,
0.38542497158050537,
-0.016439951956272125,
-0.6584749817848206,
-0.040214184671640396,
0.018913304433226585,
0.7247358560562134,
-0.12195035815238953,
0.6803560853004456,
0.32909995317459106,
-0.06748991459608078,
-0.1835048645734787,
-0.8611858487129211,
0.08680684864521027,
-0.33117252588272095,
0.4645869731903076,
-0.2919241189956665,
-0.9536638259887695,
0.48291173577308655,
0.2476959526538849,
0.33646637201309204,
0.53023761510849,
0.7038358449935913,
-0.0285841953009367,
0.802318811416626,
0.44852718710899353,
-0.46524402499198914,
0.05716399475932121,
0.11322461813688278,
0.07557445764541626,
-1.104882836341858,
0.09281592816114426,
-0.6642264127731323,
-0.4050767123699188,
-0.3304406404495239,
-0.15304338932037354,
0.2352672964334488,
0.0820261761546135,
-0.1915583312511444,
0.060302186757326126,
-0.3429929316043854,
0.6367912888526917,
0.27813711762428284,
-0.14099819958209991,
0.3266323506832123,
-0.12277151644229889,
-0.24261349439620972,
-0.16661565005779266,
-0.6531551480293274,
-0.6402174830436707,
1.1945804357528687,
0.5311086177825928,
1.0886290073394775,
0.1586015820503235,
0.29764050245285034,
0.16239024698734283,
0.3788962662220001,
-0.9816426038742065,
0.30041471123695374,
-0.1241246685385704,
-0.45668280124664307,
-0.27558425068855286,
-0.35616302490234375,
-0.620242178440094,
0.3533744215965271,
-0.262408584356308,
-0.900382399559021,
0.151650533080101,
0.01416154857724905,
-0.4373610317707062,
0.276944100856781,
-0.5125321745872498,
0.6114432215690613,
-0.23232412338256836,
-0.3723427355289459,
0.1515665203332901,
-0.33234894275665283,
0.6103845834732056,
-0.3822498917579651,
0.2568189203739166,
-0.361764132976532,
-0.03703978657722473,
0.5670545697212219,
-0.20710298418998718,
0.7541293501853943,
0.13010090589523315,
-0.18427926301956177,
-0.010725771076977253,
0.14995060861110687,
0.35946738719940186,
-0.25258588790893555,
-0.3662000894546509,
0.3793959319591522,
-0.16812732815742493,
-0.44775569438934326,
-0.6894927024841309,
0.8367850184440613,
-0.9253040552139282,
-0.591610848903656,
-0.537316620349884,
-0.6067333221435547,
-0.46477460861206055,
-0.12640069425106049,
0.1823086142539978,
0.3599434792995453,
-0.18885844945907593,
0.48629462718963623,
0.5105783343315125,
-0.37441179156303406,
0.46782004833221436,
0.6826682090759277,
-0.3073403537273407,
-0.20555701851844788,
0.7332536578178406,
0.08174308389425278,
0.3886430263519287,
0.434459388256073,
0.33171743154525757,
-0.18872854113578796,
-0.48007187247276306,
-0.5034508109092712,
0.12617245316505432,
-0.66425621509552,
-0.2670045793056488,
-0.6096559762954712,
-0.2526325285434723,
-0.305852472782135,
-0.006622353568673134,
-0.36782076954841614,
-0.5000026822090149,
-0.1941179633140564,
-0.23144541680812836,
0.19197183847427368,
0.8836629986763,
0.21050801873207092,
0.2432635873556137,
-0.7071317434310913,
0.09171455353498459,
0.21621114015579224,
0.33998286724090576,
0.16551640629768372,
-0.855125904083252,
-0.24019387364387512,
-0.0998869463801384,
-0.2201114445924759,
-0.8086442351341248,
0.16444909572601318,
0.16901078820228577,
0.594596266746521,
0.5435388088226318,
0.04352441057562828,
0.19693922996520996,
-0.4533427357673645,
1.0239149332046509,
0.13713227212429047,
-0.9205801486968994,
0.24713952839374542,
-0.31694546341896057,
0.636298656463623,
0.5074841380119324,
0.4060707986354828,
-0.4570821523666382,
-0.6576508283615112,
-0.32891198992729187,
-0.6476553082466125,
0.6666426062583923,
0.16333618760108948,
0.22025588154792786,
0.20649829506874084,
0.20812714099884033,
0.26218530535697937,
0.2526669502258301,
-0.8724331855773926,
-0.14145520329475403,
-0.14094345271587372,
-0.2762419283390045,
-0.3166774809360504,
-0.7332879304885864,
-0.07143928855657578,
-0.03410967439413071,
0.5860248804092407,
-0.15477830171585083,
-0.24295087158679962,
-0.06536597013473511,
-0.09147094935178757,
-0.23234616219997406,
0.5939858555793762,
0.7587041854858398,
1.0674809217453003,
-0.26717713475227356,
0.34357914328575134,
0.38168954849243164,
-0.39491188526153564,
0.24327212572097778,
-0.24968096613883972,
-0.2747740149497986,
0.12813395261764526,
0.7112897634506226,
0.8207330107688904,
0.2826027274131775,
-0.5798491835594177,
0.7649675607681274,
0.0658162459731102,
-0.2235192507505417,
-0.1173185259103775,
0.2636491060256958,
0.18247808516025543,
0.02634722739458084,
0.3389818072319031,
0.08808153122663498,
-0.19726450741291046,
-0.3340364694595337,
0.059457626193761826,
0.7036987543106079,
-0.5277862548828125,
-0.3044659197330475,
0.6165616512298584,
0.2066716104745865,
-0.21788784861564636,
0.3380930423736572,
0.00265269516967237,
-0.5198044180870056,
0.3286612331867218,
0.18904097378253937,
0.8493420481681824,
-0.2890227138996124,
0.058609940111637115,
0.15135811269283295,
0.46508243680000305,
-0.03281057998538017,
0.07694205641746521,
0.005919712595641613,
-1.0243879556655884,
-0.6061080098152161,
-0.9328097105026245,
-0.5689425468444824,
0.2963789701461792,
-0.5562999248504639,
0.3310174345970154,
-0.1390022337436676,
-0.1265285164117813,
-0.01457345113158226,
-0.23348960280418396,
-0.6514708995819092,
0.09864391386508942,
-0.063829705119133,
0.8357011079788208,
-0.922879695892334,
0.7621947526931763,
0.5744119882583618,
-0.4077187478542328,
-0.7258435487747192,
0.05436095967888832,
0.2781165540218353,
-0.7455326914787292,
0.5339222550392151,
-0.11470945179462433,
-0.07161262631416321,
-0.38141095638275146,
-0.4700658917427063,
-0.7657181620597839,
0.7130649089813232,
0.3134087026119232,
-0.7880351543426514,
0.026994386687874794,
0.2546098232269287,
0.6213961839675903,
-0.3353387713432312,
0.8680647611618042,
0.5915777683258057,
0.30067768692970276,
0.10410308837890625,
-1.03184974193573,
-0.05400889739394188,
-0.06606331467628479,
-0.1387607455253601,
-0.0036225675139576197,
-0.7317975759506226,
0.6471239924430847,
-0.024149509146809578,
0.22690579295158386,
-0.11982464045286179,
0.32200878858566284,
0.18743719160556793,
0.1683453470468521,
0.3083174526691437,
0.5517075061798096,
0.5140877962112427,
-0.021253470331430435,
1.041603446006775,
-0.3742621839046478,
0.3619678318500519,
1.3708796501159668,
-0.40724706649780273,
1.0058472156524658,
0.3585783541202545,
-0.4513179659843445,
0.43431633710861206,
0.28700411319732666,
-0.03002137504518032,
0.07424411922693253,
0.08084788173437119,
-0.16410312056541443,
-0.19970758259296417,
-0.1726308912038803,
-0.03443383798003197,
0.5955694913864136,
0.0539189875125885,
-0.3621768355369568,
-0.3594891428947449,
-0.20352178812026978,
0.09472771733999252,
0.010323827154934406,
-0.08116515725851059,
0.6734181046485901,
0.2391471564769745,
-0.6159506440162659,
0.46570757031440735,
-0.01994362473487854,
0.8671371936798096,
-0.47568851709365845,
0.1708022654056549,
-0.36221298575401306,
0.10858044028282166,
-0.40339964628219604,
-0.9781759977340698,
0.22922305762767792,
0.27032554149627686,
-0.2708347737789154,
-0.10762728005647659,
0.8060757517814636,
-0.3164929449558258,
-0.48082196712493896,
0.13859546184539795,
0.8147426247596741,
0.4643506407737732,
-0.14576305449008942,
-0.43412381410598755,
0.1318238079547882,
-0.03762718662619591,
-0.4933875501155853,
0.43876564502716064,
0.2671530544757843,
0.07038375735282898,
0.5660853981971741,
0.5214728116989136,
0.3522183895111084,
-0.1032174825668335,
0.39597970247268677,
0.6267823576927185,
-0.5615957975387573,
-0.015605052001774311,
-1.2675548791885376,
0.5407944917678833,
0.11324407905340195,
-0.45101624727249146,
0.9173823595046997,
0.48796090483665466,
0.7113354206085205,
0.15659435093402863,
0.8013485074043274,
0.4499722123146057,
0.6379220485687256,
-0.48587319254875183,
0.7751659154891968,
-0.6319870948791504,
0.48235654830932617,
-0.42976540327072144,
-1.3858929872512817,
-0.19875192642211914,
0.4007479250431061,
-0.19670823216438293,
0.16172239184379578,
0.491296648979187,
0.5812178254127502,
-0.11238719522953033,
-0.16156375408172607,
0.6269186735153198,
0.3110460340976715,
0.4002859890460968,
0.6154596209526062,
0.9023826718330383,
-0.1773679405450821,
0.37254253029823303,
0.0777352899312973,
-0.3880175054073334,
-0.21628807485103607,
-1.0894101858139038,
-1.1045094728469849,
-0.25710439682006836,
-0.12397867441177368,
-0.144231915473938,
-0.1772773712873459,
1.029754400253296,
0.4581086337566376,
-1.0205960273742676,
-0.3009940981864929,
0.18810899555683136,
0.2561529576778412,
0.16221632063388824,
-0.25220295786857605,
0.22591432929039001,
-0.39693742990493774,
-0.7960061430931091,
0.21419772505760193,
0.5089935064315796,
-0.23316690325737,
-0.7243328094482422,
-0.033051736652851105,
0.029159998521208763,
0.2813594937324524,
0.5350403189659119,
-0.017585445195436478,
-0.9442498087882996,
-0.38158169388771057,
-0.1267230212688446,
-0.22571656107902527,
0.0423281155526638,
0.6313697695732117,
-0.7337186336517334,
0.47024813294410706,
0.540547251701355,
0.6585333943367004,
-0.03301529958844185,
0.21173551678657532,
0.5771424174308777,
-0.7274640798568726,
-0.10107392072677612,
0.2662990391254425,
0.36985471844673157,
0.39169400930404663,
-0.16268955171108246,
0.47567474842071533,
0.045947104692459106,
-0.8239997029304504,
-0.7579590082168579,
0.1223435029387474,
-0.8432608246803284,
-0.23725689947605133,
1.3943066596984863,
-0.1369304358959198,
-0.12489370256662369,
0.0049141873605549335,
0.0000428997736889869,
-0.22325025498867035,
-0.3931960165500641,
0.7298499941825867,
1.276962161064148,
-0.3086591958999634,
-0.15412241220474243,
-0.5965474247932434,
0.37151041626930237,
0.6543267369270325,
-0.5345206260681152,
-0.06889805197715759,
0.5446208715438843,
0.45460042357444763,
0.3200197219848633,
0.6213355660438538,
0.09247418493032455,
-0.08488447219133377,
-0.11469313502311707,
-0.035509105771780014,
0.11298534274101257,
-0.26329469680786133,
-0.5802317261695862,
0.12189211696386337,
0.3049725592136383,
0.1446264535188675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01686v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01686v1
|
Automatically Extracting Numerical Results from Randomized Controlled Trials with Large Language Models
| 2024-05-02T19:20:11 | 2024-05-02T19:20:11 |
Hye Sun Yun, David Pogrebitskiy, Iain J. Marshall, Byron C. Wallace
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Meta-analyses statistically aggregate the findings of different randomized
controlled trials (RCTs) to assess treatment effectiveness. Because this yields
robust estimates of treatment effectiveness, results from meta-analyses are
considered the strongest form of evidence. However, rigorous evidence syntheses
are time-consuming and labor-intensive, requiring manual extraction of data
from individual trials to be synthesized. Ideally, language technologies would
permit fully automatic meta-analysis, on demand. This requires accurately
extracting numerical results from individual trials, which has been beyond the
capabilities of natural language processing (NLP) models to date. In this work,
we evaluate whether modern large language models (LLMs) can reliably perform
this task. We annotate (and release) a modest but granular evaluation dataset
of clinical trial reports with numerical findings attached to interventions,
comparators, and outcomes. Using this dataset, we evaluate the performance of
seven LLMs applied zero-shot for the task of conditionally extracting numerical
findings from trial reports. We find that massive LLMs that can accommodate
lengthy inputs are tantalizingly close to realizing fully automatic
meta-analysis, especially for dichotomous (binary) outcomes (e.g., mortality).
However, LLMs -- including ones trained on biomedical texts -- perform poorly
when the outcome measures are complex and tallying the results requires
inference. This work charts a path toward fully automatic meta-analysis of RCTs
via LLMs, while also highlighting the limitations of existing models for this
aim.
|
[
-0.09698359668254852,
-0.7960818409919739,
0.9300553798675537,
0.46290239691734314,
-0.2396111637353897,
-0.0851900577545166,
-0.3602340817451477,
-0.3664577901363373,
0.25133398175239563,
0.6205064654350281,
-0.1790299117565155,
-0.7274898290634155,
-0.9688129425048828,
0.5264134407043457,
-0.4187838137149811,
1.1543934345245361,
-0.1710876226425171,
0.44608744978904724,
-0.12959884107112885,
-0.09219331294298172,
-0.27948981523513794,
-0.3069314956665039,
-0.3495787978172302,
-0.41746985912323,
0.8314030766487122,
0.2400757372379303,
0.5549296140670776,
0.4729868769645691,
0.9025136828422546,
0.2823922634124756,
0.09981045871973038,
-0.014272616244852543,
-0.16820654273033142,
-0.009827449917793274,
-0.051777713000774384,
-0.3045370876789093,
-0.6138519644737244,
0.032494764775037766,
0.6092396378517151,
0.7945759296417236,
-0.2875136435031891,
0.012178130447864532,
-0.1728658378124237,
0.5338307023048401,
-0.6172967553138733,
0.19639194011688232,
-0.527973473072052,
0.1443370133638382,
-0.02550153248012066,
-0.31199541687965393,
-0.5156571865081787,
-0.6035395860671997,
0.12730205059051514,
-0.35528564453125,
-0.01113726943731308,
-0.24088230729103088,
0.5013979077339172,
0.20978696644306183,
-0.5061801075935364,
-0.7545122504234314,
-0.715609610080719,
0.6941384673118591,
-1.1937376260757446,
0.018163828179240227,
0.246334508061409,
0.4398605525493622,
-0.30836769938468933,
-0.8153606653213501,
-0.2210165411233902,
-0.42403262853622437,
-0.28186288475990295,
0.11728318780660629,
-0.17914192378520966,
0.3505643308162689,
0.5184000134468079,
0.2882819175720215,
-0.4708661735057831,
0.03950238600373268,
-0.3965400159358978,
-0.09550557285547256,
0.7528823614120483,
0.39031052589416504,
0.5359817743301392,
-0.34299638867378235,
0.09271696954965591,
0.13597068190574646,
-0.4461425244808197,
-0.2628658711910248,
-0.10275419801473618,
0.3112308084964752,
-0.20246413350105286,
0.9141089916229248,
-0.18900544941425323,
0.6427692770957947,
-0.19946838915348053,
-0.433245986700058,
0.11095269024372101,
-0.2910040616989136,
-0.40709346532821655,
-0.06085054948925972,
1.2618154287338257,
0.25762200355529785,
0.2406543642282486,
-0.4633466899394989,
-0.19238662719726562,
-0.05930747836828232,
0.10553717613220215,
-0.948172390460968,
-0.11414539068937302,
0.4078108072280884,
-0.40517860651016235,
-0.477956622838974,
-0.04216911643743515,
-0.8243058919906616,
-0.13204512000083923,
-0.20752984285354614,
0.5516818761825562,
-0.18292570114135742,
-0.15121035277843475,
0.4933982491493225,
-0.22368349134922028,
-0.09889373928308487,
0.28843793272972107,
-0.6140542030334473,
0.46966928243637085,
0.5418777465820312,
0.9526375532150269,
-0.4298802316188812,
0.07526679337024689,
-0.5590735673904419,
0.060781486332416534,
-0.3176828920841217,
0.7259098291397095,
-0.6570377349853516,
-0.49521443247795105,
0.010998900048434734,
0.09941074252128601,
-0.22669310867786407,
-0.35494059324264526,
0.6918608546257019,
-0.5733264088630676,
0.2829124629497528,
-0.3587431013584137,
-0.5174390077590942,
0.027458548545837402,
0.10837122797966003,
-0.7167018055915833,
0.3727949857711792,
-0.1769523024559021,
-0.759767472743988,
0.399715393781662,
-0.7779475450515747,
-0.6074209213256836,
-0.12145616114139557,
-0.353292316198349,
-0.5317708849906921,
0.38449791073799133,
0.27207642793655396,
0.37421146035194397,
-0.49269112944602966,
0.6235465407371521,
-0.6472220420837402,
-0.2257654070854187,
0.38360172510147095,
-0.5036980509757996,
0.7412407398223877,
0.2251185029745102,
-0.5744639039039612,
-0.1309751719236374,
-0.6062564253807068,
-0.12630659341812134,
0.044767942279577255,
-0.3790883421897888,
-0.27950674295425415,
0.051554564386606216,
-0.16398213803768158,
0.19603201746940613,
0.054190296679735184,
-0.6322664022445679,
0.4059995114803314,
-0.24419978260993958,
0.20314079523086548,
0.3934948146343231,
0.03779745101928711,
0.40962350368499756,
-0.2142004817724228,
0.5721829533576965,
-0.34967467188835144,
0.06601656973361969,
-0.047564100474119186,
-0.25458258390426636,
-0.35697391629219055,
-0.583231508731842,
0.7740858197212219,
0.43227624893188477,
-0.7958324551582336,
0.260324627161026,
-0.5667029023170471,
-0.12990407645702362,
-0.15646228194236755,
-0.19788111746311188,
0.30676671862602234,
0.3634190857410431,
0.09310586005449295,
-0.24442657828330994,
-0.39234524965286255,
-1.0233147144317627,
-0.2670804560184479,
0.09246565401554108,
-0.12877671420574188,
0.2718442380428314,
0.7355529069900513,
-0.18647104501724243,
0.8857828378677368,
-0.699026882648468,
-0.09944542497396469,
-0.1934989094734192,
0.6894181966781616,
0.29493916034698486,
0.07844758033752441,
0.25545504689216614,
-0.6326615214347839,
-0.5289372205734253,
0.11285494267940521,
-1.077521562576294,
-0.5884643793106079,
-0.1628536731004715,
0.031124062836170197,
-0.18810899555683136,
0.41829872131347656,
-0.5914411544799805,
0.44004061818122864,
0.41839084029197693,
0.15420253574848175,
0.5989668369293213,
-0.3128216564655304,
0.22233647108078003,
-0.5118494629859924,
0.4026592969894409,
-0.04922335222363472,
-0.2480241060256958,
-0.4179774820804596,
-0.3627385199069977,
0.07826455682516098,
0.0669240951538086,
-0.10184741765260696,
0.637432873249054,
-0.4358356297016144,
-0.15938721597194672,
-0.3678443431854248,
-0.033282775431871414,
-0.15912537276744843,
0.30062898993492126,
0.41464272141456604,
0.5588768720626831,
0.1014677882194519,
-0.39731600880622864,
-0.006913510151207447,
-0.026836052536964417,
-0.09517465531826019,
0.021360162645578384,
-0.9680071473121643,
-0.23798492550849915,
-0.24369359016418457,
0.5653083920478821,
-0.9149183034896851,
-0.6020455360412598,
0.18657085299491882,
-0.31143900752067566,
0.2806396186351776,
-0.2607841491699219,
-0.4123542606830597,
-0.5327503085136414,
-0.31813377141952515,
0.22286751866340637,
0.3112088739871979,
0.09148375689983368,
0.5997626185417175,
0.47150978446006775,
-0.5700936913490295,
-0.44162559509277344,
-0.5588573813438416,
0.2921357750892639,
0.032038379460573196,
-0.27593889832496643,
0.07706131786108017,
-0.05750735476613045,
-0.39903414249420166,
0.0444134920835495,
0.21296417713165283,
-0.18086087703704834,
-0.11655550450086594,
0.18461501598358154,
0.26673269271850586,
0.0026570078916847706,
0.12175332754850388,
0.22911317646503448,
-0.1503685861825943,
0.2447114735841751,
0.0898379310965538,
0.23230701684951782,
0.1377534568309784,
-0.6562617421150208,
-0.3467892110347748,
0.3628016412258148,
0.9568907618522644,
-0.15001343190670013,
0.5606438517570496,
0.3077169358730316,
-0.4126095771789551,
-0.06003367900848389,
-0.5381879210472107,
-0.10137802362442017,
-0.34922805428504944,
0.227704256772995,
-0.048378366976976395,
-0.619781494140625,
0.29913297295570374,
-0.03391856700181961,
0.48630619049072266,
0.580156147480011,
0.6648391485214233,
-0.05093127861618996,
1.20901358127594,
0.3785363435745239,
0.16008855402469635,
0.3788774609565735,
-0.12589608132839203,
0.07632014155387878,
-0.6211621165275574,
-0.14904475212097168,
-0.42741426825523376,
-0.18375778198242188,
-0.4165765345096588,
-0.4690406620502472,
0.8582287430763245,
-0.3034398555755615,
0.13212229311466217,
-0.023776400834321976,
-0.36358559131622314,
0.3946535885334015,
0.03542669862508774,
0.18418675661087036,
0.5180742740631104,
0.21624726057052612,
-0.03067782148718834,
-0.22287137806415558,
-0.6463810205459595,
-0.5664382576942444,
1.424966812133789,
0.29660239815711975,
0.6023319959640503,
-0.11201674491167068,
0.6664567589759827,
0.3423774242401123,
0.947581946849823,
-0.6915814876556396,
0.3774438798427582,
-0.2468889206647873,
-0.7398741841316223,
-0.18419981002807617,
-0.7147855162620544,
-0.9010009765625,
0.29319533705711365,
-0.277715802192688,
-0.23755112290382385,
0.049636874347925186,
-0.2007586508989334,
-0.7114681005477905,
0.23246784508228302,
-0.5470409989356995,
0.42493826150894165,
-0.49850717186927795,
-0.3380281329154968,
0.006388670299202204,
-0.5268380641937256,
0.7654314041137695,
-0.485627681016922,
0.5395663976669312,
-0.04924430698156357,
-0.10573790222406387,
0.8476446270942688,
-0.36615124344825745,
0.8357886672019958,
-0.09106937050819397,
-0.22148865461349487,
0.18983691930770874,
0.09104707837104797,
0.4907207190990448,
0.10610045492649078,
-0.1326524168252945,
0.20137916505336761,
0.22994709014892578,
-0.4011353552341461,
-0.6987074017524719,
0.4836238920688629,
-0.3445757329463959,
-0.22795884311199188,
-0.5642561912536621,
-0.5285465717315674,
-0.07679703831672668,
0.16622164845466614,
0.16823939979076385,
0.5160722732543945,
-0.2517814338207245,
0.07350069284439087,
0.5570753812789917,
-0.5431516766548157,
0.3912496566772461,
0.8671480417251587,
-0.29153794050216675,
-0.8451102375984192,
0.6243440508842468,
0.3138181269168854,
0.15340542793273926,
0.3235795497894287,
0.35882455110549927,
-0.22759613394737244,
-0.7918976545333862,
-0.31119537353515625,
0.4448432922363281,
-0.2721990942955017,
-0.131831094622612,
-0.914839506149292,
-0.15293185412883759,
-0.2834206819534302,
-0.1303330361843109,
-0.23980389535427094,
-0.35521966218948364,
0.16302034258842468,
0.10500311106443405,
0.1350073516368866,
0.9453810453414917,
-0.3913750648498535,
0.2982589602470398,
-1.0360815525054932,
0.5731385946273804,
0.36748746037483215,
0.22144831717014313,
-0.05309199541807175,
-0.4525200128555298,
-0.17468087375164032,
0.2107996791601181,
-0.13085809350013733,
-0.6757612228393555,
0.4750176966190338,
0.031150033697485924,
0.3356629014015198,
0.20950758457183838,
-0.09400513768196106,
0.6175115704536438,
-0.6183565855026245,
0.4260097146034241,
0.3920864760875702,
-0.5308312773704529,
0.29783281683921814,
-0.6763031482696533,
0.2504017949104309,
0.6092211008071899,
0.4759869873523712,
-0.44087743759155273,
-0.14130714535713196,
-0.5759226083755493,
-0.6705822944641113,
0.6596470475196838,
0.2894018888473511,
-0.24304966628551483,
-0.2143259346485138,
0.4201146960258484,
0.24279539287090302,
0.2841165363788605,
-0.7346457839012146,
0.07899070531129837,
0.616221010684967,
-0.40785592794418335,
-0.09244954586029053,
-0.3742968738079071,
-0.4634495675563812,
-0.1895270049571991,
0.3505762815475464,
-0.0673263818025589,
0.26560238003730774,
0.3366563022136688,
-0.2087320238351822,
-0.2955929934978485,
0.22854241728782654,
0.5843386650085449,
0.7938939332962036,
-0.3926648795604706,
0.15098018944263458,
0.34226205945014954,
-0.5125530362129211,
0.04956768825650215,
-0.03451249375939369,
-0.2332313358783722,
0.09416559338569641,
0.9343582987785339,
0.3109877407550812,
0.469198614358902,
-0.7439514994621277,
0.7601244449615479,
-0.3543389141559601,
-0.2762787342071533,
-0.22258113324642181,
-0.1353975087404251,
-0.1400781273841858,
0.019420180469751358,
0.2589256763458252,
-0.09480928629636765,
0.37343060970306396,
-0.37544575333595276,
0.5416179895401001,
0.6495263576507568,
-0.23036447167396545,
-0.40975937247276306,
0.40437620878219604,
0.26852530241012573,
-0.12289600074291229,
0.22563502192497253,
0.0941268652677536,
-0.21754492819309235,
0.6372663974761963,
0.3360064923763275,
1.0179511308670044,
0.19621004164218903,
0.3543833792209625,
0.5396669507026672,
0.2542480230331421,
-0.3137821853160858,
0.07050538063049316,
0.21185307204723358,
-0.10392031073570251,
-0.9476547241210938,
-0.8347872495651245,
-0.5333929657936096,
0.03888653218746185,
-0.5436530709266663,
0.2924789786338806,
-0.45640435814857483,
-0.23963989317417145,
0.1293300986289978,
-0.08581685274839401,
-0.46818092465400696,
0.19952870905399323,
0.19349269568920135,
0.7513020634651184,
-1.013594388961792,
0.5064738392829895,
0.35134029388427734,
-0.3804985284805298,
-0.44289058446884155,
-0.18576668202877045,
-0.09094029664993286,
-0.5184358358383179,
0.4853709042072296,
-0.15036651492118835,
-0.1093229353427887,
-0.3292624056339264,
-0.6570199131965637,
-0.768304705619812,
0.9111572504043579,
0.5079936385154724,
-0.8759660720825195,
-0.26292911171913147,
0.4415851831436157,
0.6957529187202454,
-0.3304523229598999,
0.6822769045829773,
0.589099645614624,
0.6415825486183167,
0.19465315341949463,
-0.9977068901062012,
-0.12631729245185852,
-0.0009920443408191204,
-0.5532068610191345,
0.15927758812904358,
-0.3668018877506256,
0.6092654466629028,
-0.1677931547164917,
-0.04338056594133377,
-0.10133495926856995,
0.4352763593196869,
0.0625741258263588,
0.5513653755187988,
0.30436214804649353,
0.49977293610572815,
0.6183512806892395,
-0.05523699149489403,
1.035460114479065,
-0.22320115566253662,
0.4396042227745056,
0.9017921686172485,
-0.2653687000274658,
0.7123087048530579,
0.1725480556488037,
-0.40796634554862976,
0.3669079542160034,
0.3923683762550354,
0.2679854929447174,
0.40263667702674866,
0.04288902506232262,
-0.21290001273155212,
-0.5028031468391418,
0.10830560326576233,
-0.21595801413059235,
0.20503617823123932,
0.24167343974113464,
-0.5299670696258545,
-0.4052971601486206,
-0.10900954157114029,
0.18255144357681274,
-0.2857368290424347,
-0.03742910921573639,
0.8245826363563538,
0.3679712414741516,
-0.6294218301773071,
0.567025899887085,
-0.06022317707538605,
0.4675300419330597,
-0.9581623077392578,
-0.16192300617694855,
-0.1304505169391632,
0.024956392124295235,
-0.37900686264038086,
-0.5519697666168213,
0.4352017045021057,
0.29169192910194397,
-0.07710901647806168,
0.12899897992610931,
0.5707159042358398,
-0.41311824321746826,
-0.9271219372749329,
0.21786564588546753,
0.37656664848327637,
0.26125404238700867,
0.13282136619091034,
-0.5465838313102722,
0.21228459477424622,
-0.02534002996981144,
-0.26100778579711914,
0.3435136675834656,
0.47824496030807495,
-0.11592211574316025,
0.5245078206062317,
0.7288544178009033,
0.57205730676651,
-0.1007096990942955,
-0.01322404108941555,
0.8110607266426086,
-0.7464693784713745,
0.18385855853557587,
-1.0853161811828613,
0.523130476474762,
-0.21340203285217285,
-0.06412887573242188,
0.6815944910049438,
0.4858017563819885,
0.009357491508126259,
0.12087897956371307,
1.0100749731063843,
-0.136781707406044,
0.3038298189640045,
-0.4771316349506378,
0.5210910439491272,
-0.623276948928833,
0.23569932579994202,
-0.35430628061294556,
-0.6968759894371033,
-0.6033465266227722,
0.16827206313610077,
-0.8139207363128662,
-0.04925164952874184,
0.681485116481781,
0.41183143854141235,
-0.19159336388111115,
-0.08576010167598724,
0.24854739010334015,
0.3887958824634552,
0.6221206188201904,
0.31545987725257874,
0.3854752480983734,
-0.3860000967979431,
0.38988006114959717,
-0.009114735759794712,
-0.5984481573104858,
-0.2828143835067749,
-1.084218144416809,
-0.7871564030647278,
-0.06163075193762779,
-0.10197185724973679,
-0.08820416778326035,
0.0809783861041069,
0.9171488285064697,
0.453043133020401,
-0.8041360378265381,
-0.21933428943157196,
0.04715551435947418,
0.14796338975429535,
0.1153077706694603,
-0.11910416930913925,
0.49969711899757385,
-0.33679908514022827,
-0.6527329683303833,
0.25596553087234497,
0.523939847946167,
-0.13789430260658264,
-0.11312853544950485,
0.09388893842697144,
0.039052028208971024,
0.2340165078639984,
0.6405791640281677,
0.26435741782188416,
-0.41361045837402344,
0.10868198424577713,
-0.052467286586761475,
-0.328298419713974,
-0.16293415427207947,
0.9173481464385986,
-0.4858575463294983,
0.5529354214668274,
0.5637080669403076,
0.5189294219017029,
0.4327692687511444,
0.04285696893930435,
0.8465043902397156,
0.014482765458524227,
-0.14656558632850647,
0.3088052272796631,
0.3741443455219269,
0.07128868997097015,
0.05642807483673096,
0.4471522271633148,
0.11658860743045807,
-0.6073341369628906,
-0.892703652381897,
-0.18775925040245056,
-0.6180487871170044,
-0.1970726102590561,
1.4158517122268677,
-0.07840939611196518,
-0.4004318416118622,
-0.06482482701539993,
-0.2854607403278351,
0.19662059843540192,
-0.17596124112606049,
1.0028252601623535,
0.7796700596809387,
0.007888990454375744,
0.2730101943016052,
-0.7732961177825928,
0.453872948884964,
0.2631188631057739,
-0.8209013342857361,
0.30029940605163574,
0.4403001070022583,
0.45459988713264465,
0.027465732768177986,
0.8403998017311096,
-0.4905695915222168,
0.14150887727737427,
-0.2527596950531006,
0.1158481314778328,
0.10715419799089432,
-0.38857150077819824,
-0.5658183693885803,
0.24320833384990692,
-0.19448816776275635,
0.3395305275917053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01682v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01682v2
|
Leveraging Prompt-Learning for Structured Information Extraction from Crohn's Disease Radiology Reports in a Low-Resource Language
| 2024-05-02T19:11:54 | 2024-05-22T09:36:25 |
Liam Hazan, Gili Focht, Naama Gavrielov, Roi Reichart, Talar Hagopian, Mary-Louise C. Greer, Ruth Cytter Kuint, Dan Turner, Moti Freiman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Automatic conversion of free-text radiology reports into structured data
using Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques is crucial for analyzing
diseases on a large scale. While effective for tasks in widely spoken languages
like English, generative large language models (LLMs) typically underperform
with less common languages and can pose potential risks to patient privacy.
Fine-tuning local NLP models is hindered by the skewed nature of real-world
medical datasets, where rare findings represent a significant data imbalance.
We introduce SMP-BERT, a novel prompt learning method that leverages the
structured nature of reports to overcome these challenges. In our studies
involving a substantial collection of Crohn's disease radiology reports in
Hebrew (over 8,000 patients and 10,000 reports), SMP-BERT greatly surpassed
traditional fine-tuning methods in performance, notably in detecting infrequent
conditions (AUC: 0.99 vs 0.94, F1: 0.84 vs 0.34). SMP-BERT empowers more
accurate AI diagnostics available for low-resource languages.
|
[
0.016323940828442574,
-0.609031081199646,
0.6367826461791992,
-0.05616191774606705,
-0.29740530252456665,
-0.05382760986685753,
-0.43425339460372925,
-0.49032288789749146,
0.2269483357667923,
0.2227073609828949,
-0.45083513855934143,
-0.5258450508117676,
-0.8200601935386658,
0.5774224400520325,
0.002146997954696417,
1.272174596786499,
0.2993123233318329,
0.5982934236526489,
-0.16658280789852142,
-0.22523866593837738,
-0.31537023186683655,
0.005754436831921339,
-0.7301040291786194,
-0.2541782557964325,
0.8355211615562439,
0.8214395046234131,
0.9267076849937439,
0.6851465106010437,
0.6138316988945007,
0.18703098595142365,
0.18198886513710022,
0.2035115510225296,
-0.1595308482646942,
0.5628973841667175,
0.004819388501346111,
-0.2345379889011383,
-0.09993996471166611,
-0.11744347959756851,
0.4688005745410919,
1.0641698837280273,
0.012983428314328194,
0.04792659729719162,
0.2406471222639084,
0.9705599546432495,
-0.36945635080337524,
0.3977484703063965,
-0.11902835965156555,
0.3448595404624939,
-0.3057703375816345,
-0.4914100766181946,
-0.7194280028343201,
-0.37431633472442627,
0.2976800799369812,
-0.7087077498435974,
0.19208598136901855,
0.09081678837537766,
0.9309607744216919,
0.13712207973003387,
-0.5440380573272705,
-0.6899698376655579,
-0.5352522730827332,
0.7355425953865051,
-0.5578836798667908,
0.25012826919555664,
0.49855098128318787,
0.5042140483856201,
-0.16430968046188354,
-0.9333445429801941,
-0.14863088726997375,
-0.3768000900745392,
-0.24272552132606506,
0.029256140813231468,
-0.15346316993236542,
0.04145911708474159,
0.35405585169792175,
0.2107146978378296,
-0.9684004187583923,
0.06512025743722916,
-0.4708805978298187,
-0.10975836217403412,
0.40460050106048584,
0.23182229697704315,
0.5592065453529358,
-0.49339085817337036,
-0.24887551367282867,
-0.1273159682750702,
-0.5078232884407043,
0.07810256630182266,
-0.3326171040534973,
0.7603223919868469,
-0.12752699851989746,
0.5167067050933838,
-0.35781440138816833,
0.5394295454025269,
0.14617611467838287,
-0.34309035539627075,
0.4920205771923065,
0.11727970093488693,
-0.19492806494235992,
0.2619100511074066,
0.6860752701759338,
0.06411697715520859,
-0.09901490807533264,
-0.02721725031733513,
-0.1385689377784729,
-0.20644508302211761,
-0.04108376055955887,
-0.8098385334014893,
-0.5242783427238464,
0.3146435618400574,
-0.8227059245109558,
-0.17732103168964386,
-0.15036641061306,
-0.7245845198631287,
-0.6326918601989746,
-0.1956622153520584,
-0.010987688787281513,
-0.6666849851608276,
0.12993398308753967,
-0.057223010808229446,
0.028945520520210266,
0.40517303347587585,
0.44466596841812134,
-0.7586486339569092,
0.16923917829990387,
0.3779853284358978,
0.8250428438186646,
-0.08679597824811935,
0.10984764993190765,
-1.27817702293396,
0.051635973155498505,
-0.2433282881975174,
1.0089571475982666,
-0.6914095282554626,
-0.3850178122520447,
0.06225023418664932,
0.00039965315954759717,
-0.13385601341724396,
-0.6282135248184204,
0.47425150871276855,
-0.3347510099411011,
0.3018181324005127,
-0.33307087421417236,
-0.4763587713241577,
0.032015323638916016,
0.07711796462535858,
-0.6386035680770874,
0.9374393224716187,
0.4443490207195282,
-0.8463134765625,
0.42214012145996094,
-0.5008437037467957,
-0.7983580231666565,
0.7645385265350342,
-0.4731461703777313,
-0.42247751355171204,
0.041688449680805206,
0.4358559548854828,
0.46502742171287537,
-0.2813434302806854,
0.5280439853668213,
-0.02424514852464199,
0.06935647130012512,
0.0001989621960092336,
-0.016352172940969467,
0.8485956788063049,
0.6317424178123474,
-0.16334031522274017,
0.30100250244140625,
-0.46583107113838196,
0.10286915302276611,
0.30999886989593506,
-0.2829762101173401,
-0.1635732650756836,
0.08320436626672745,
-0.2037104070186615,
0.13526496291160583,
0.09792785346508026,
-0.2740691900253296,
0.42893463373184204,
-0.46795228123664856,
0.08849749714136124,
0.5649480223655701,
0.01216362789273262,
0.5489569306373596,
-0.7868148684501648,
0.8006138801574707,
0.0755506381392479,
0.17905683815479279,
-0.32819777727127075,
-0.9237646460533142,
-0.4172399044036865,
-0.4342605471611023,
0.2984521985054016,
0.7451629042625427,
-0.9967260360717773,
0.3519660234451294,
-0.39932581782341003,
-0.323517769575119,
-0.5455154180526733,
0.07615633308887482,
0.1532590389251709,
0.9254414439201355,
0.28724533319473267,
-0.18104520440101624,
-0.3594292104244232,
-0.6610560417175293,
-0.1784636378288269,
0.14537832140922546,
-0.5410899519920349,
0.5390188694000244,
0.09751281142234802,
-0.33393725752830505,
0.75743567943573,
-0.654746949672699,
-0.7107358574867249,
-0.7694384455680847,
0.3420751988887787,
0.28669315576553345,
0.4615371525287628,
0.5291443467140198,
-0.6113705039024353,
-0.8465438485145569,
0.2936154305934906,
-0.8225855827331543,
-0.28913965821266174,
-0.27586743235588074,
0.34072354435920715,
0.4056795835494995,
0.34554657340049744,
-0.31311872601509094,
0.524165689945221,
0.4825728237628937,
-0.32261547446250916,
0.40533074736595154,
-0.4375420808792114,
0.0918264389038086,
-0.8211399912834167,
0.06251842528581619,
0.1254136562347412,
-0.4881426692008972,
-0.375040203332901,
-0.008840127848088741,
0.11197128146886826,
-0.49495255947113037,
-0.3721359074115753,
0.3467258810997009,
-0.5414486527442932,
-0.0300462543964386,
-0.13103120028972626,
0.14151068031787872,
0.11503765732049942,
0.2612408697605133,
0.02312680333852768,
0.5134852528572083,
0.6539949774742126,
-0.6468852758407593,
0.20988239347934723,
0.2559717893600464,
-0.4429498612880707,
0.21370461583137512,
-0.5089877843856812,
-0.03592454269528389,
-0.3498223125934601,
0.3518475592136383,
-0.769047200679779,
-0.38020214438438416,
0.4893433153629303,
-0.662251353263855,
0.5105592012405396,
-0.2007475048303604,
-0.4348464608192444,
-0.15858060121536255,
-0.22343406081199646,
0.26846441626548767,
0.41474470496177673,
-0.41647011041641235,
0.8150554299354553,
0.29289379715919495,
-0.767223060131073,
-0.4382850229740143,
-0.5112466216087341,
0.04489634558558464,
0.17442335188388824,
-0.6540826559066772,
-0.0056699542328715324,
-0.19393177330493927,
-0.13234083354473114,
-0.06988734006881714,
-0.014872943982481956,
-0.36142221093177795,
0.15927782654762268,
0.13816416263580322,
0.18635697662830353,
-0.47525307536125183,
0.13863496482372284,
0.08009344339370728,
-0.20909899473190308,
-0.21003147959709167,
-0.0069710006937384605,
0.6566607356071472,
-0.325249046087265,
-0.16839176416397095,
-0.6522702574729919,
0.45034828782081604,
0.24585363268852234,
0.033794958144426346,
0.5617874264717102,
0.46127721667289734,
-0.388005793094635,
-0.15908172726631165,
-0.005700050853192806,
-0.3980805575847626,
-0.4853764772415161,
0.14538639783859253,
-0.020146649330854416,
-0.6072083711624146,
0.4995371997356415,
-0.11722226440906525,
0.006591989193111658,
0.4521566927433014,
0.34780439734458923,
-0.4681275486946106,
0.9848345518112183,
0.43189552426338196,
0.034207623451948166,
0.4241775572299957,
0.014675350859761238,
0.3003680408000946,
-0.3661823868751526,
-0.2801678776741028,
-0.7412617802619934,
-0.22951874136924744,
-0.5326930284500122,
-0.24483880400657654,
0.6587535738945007,
-0.5214077830314636,
0.16838304698467255,
-0.07327002286911011,
-0.38826751708984375,
0.38708755373954773,
0.5034301280975342,
0.3920660614967346,
0.22934594750404358,
-0.21695442497730255,
-0.12053290009498596,
-0.35830965638160706,
-0.987339198589325,
-0.3547864556312561,
0.9529242515563965,
0.09794443845748901,
0.5859887599945068,
-0.13482119143009186,
0.5339171290397644,
0.8567579984664917,
0.28933852910995483,
-1.0047385692596436,
0.3049499988555908,
-0.2988117039203644,
-0.17341938614845276,
-0.43094512820243835,
-0.4884268343448639,
-1.374186396598816,
0.11500180512666702,
-0.2408548891544342,
-0.3147071599960327,
-0.015385561622679234,
0.18296083807945251,
-0.4731425344944,
0.07384272664785385,
-0.6483603715896606,
0.6911358833312988,
-0.08796847611665726,
0.050944700837135315,
-0.049863334745168686,
-1.0523821115493774,
0.12208747863769531,
0.3534764349460602,
0.45082777738571167,
-0.17474697530269623,
0.16832351684570312,
0.5696849226951599,
-0.4584082067012787,
0.8457133769989014,
-0.2632446885108948,
0.008323365822434425,
0.0023395854514092207,
0.2890607416629791,
0.6308969855308533,
0.37977561354637146,
0.12747381627559662,
0.02079934813082218,
-0.18461205065250397,
-0.6008678674697876,
-0.4468272924423218,
0.5158689618110657,
-0.5220624208450317,
-0.2508808970451355,
-0.8592337965965271,
-0.43099236488342285,
-0.2005036473274231,
0.3815474510192871,
0.30987316370010376,
0.5803054571151733,
0.0004504852695390582,
0.1854059398174286,
0.7979212999343872,
-0.4530694782733917,
0.23632961511611938,
0.4905600845813751,
0.0717768520116806,
-0.24370963871479034,
0.7775456309318542,
-0.04782777279615402,
-0.11966167390346527,
0.49498045444488525,
0.5763742923736572,
0.08976403623819351,
-0.4714893102645874,
-0.45768362283706665,
0.21779383718967438,
-0.7277635931968689,
-0.6809214949607849,
-0.6658264994621277,
-0.20113994181156158,
-0.6652426719665527,
-0.49162572622299194,
-0.18412859737873077,
-0.36161044239997864,
-0.5008887648582458,
0.044587716460227966,
0.17438413202762604,
0.5265272855758667,
-0.22631336748600006,
0.377524197101593,
-1.106946587562561,
0.49589166045188904,
-0.031446103006601334,
0.10783835500478745,
-0.12206052988767624,
-0.6418886184692383,
-0.32117411494255066,
-0.005511951167136431,
-0.2450769990682602,
-0.8191339373588562,
0.9040855765342712,
0.4763622581958771,
0.4223159849643707,
0.7274506092071533,
0.5478328466415405,
0.43766874074935913,
-0.3266797959804535,
0.7206761837005615,
0.14008976519107819,
-0.8448687195777893,
0.7931656837463379,
-0.45305246114730835,
0.4356602430343628,
0.5290457010269165,
0.6358485817909241,
-0.7861770391464233,
-0.5853384137153625,
-0.5481702089309692,
-1.0205861330032349,
0.8103020787239075,
-0.26251596212387085,
-0.20689110457897186,
-0.35420405864715576,
0.06745687127113342,
0.29802778363227844,
-0.10625103861093521,
-0.6965433359146118,
-0.21727995574474335,
-0.01661798544228077,
-0.3494040369987488,
0.11054905503988266,
-0.45021548867225647,
-0.11914163082838058,
-0.391959547996521,
0.6566746234893799,
-0.4535498321056366,
0.23603028059005737,
0.6090778708457947,
-0.6537520289421082,
-0.24875637888908386,
0.22548456490039825,
0.6269422173500061,
0.7403296232223511,
-0.0674816146492958,
0.11094941198825836,
-0.0036617040168493986,
-0.46231573820114136,
-0.38682103157043457,
0.03470687195658684,
-0.15112414956092834,
0.22699737548828125,
0.542365312576294,
0.2966129183769226,
0.34325090050697327,
-0.892377495765686,
0.7954834699630737,
-0.21536558866500854,
-0.0040887100622057915,
-0.3824212849140167,
-0.1548667699098587,
-0.24629490077495575,
0.0913047194480896,
0.7529951930046082,
0.1100585088133812,
0.2687399685382843,
-0.07362771779298782,
0.4875414967536926,
0.2708946466445923,
-0.3893841803073883,
-0.3045203983783722,
0.34500738978385925,
0.2648560404777527,
-0.08585180342197418,
1.160881519317627,
-0.18865564465522766,
-0.06904727965593338,
0.6312070488929749,
0.4820430874824524,
0.669099748134613,
-0.3166804611682892,
0.4865383505821228,
0.3943311274051666,
0.2607583701610565,
0.04508121311664581,
0.26856645941734314,
-0.14440220594406128,
-0.4009350836277008,
-0.39272409677505493,
-0.32994475960731506,
-0.261385440826416,
0.17128421366214752,
-1.07758367061615,
0.3546096086502075,
-0.6951772570610046,
0.08225221186876297,
0.12335269898176193,
0.07068122923374176,
-0.5138179659843445,
0.06637860089540482,
0.2597224712371826,
0.8031929731369019,
-0.8428718447685242,
0.868872344493866,
0.5195035934448242,
-0.3044673204421997,
-0.5150495767593384,
-0.051168911159038544,
0.02005098946392536,
-0.9320054054260254,
0.6278154850006104,
0.3472650349140167,
0.19336660206317902,
-0.25239455699920654,
-0.7913124561309814,
-0.7852246761322021,
0.7813916206359863,
0.3705037534236908,
-0.5543150305747986,
-0.18834906816482544,
-0.01008970569819212,
0.37329980731010437,
-0.35451847314834595,
-0.02966264635324478,
0.2844143211841583,
0.43051132559776306,
0.06085535138845444,
-0.8820574879646301,
0.092282734811306,
-0.08396866917610168,
-0.3584785461425781,
0.18557573854923248,
-0.34736505150794983,
0.5852615833282471,
-0.7677227854728699,
-0.5518091917037964,
-0.0689580887556076,
0.7764307260513306,
-0.010909713804721832,
0.5638186931610107,
0.288995623588562,
0.22847068309783936,
1.0977001190185547,
0.12303455173969269,
1.139726161956787,
-0.3961656093597412,
0.1845037192106247,
0.9364089369773865,
-0.5064666867256165,
0.4670146107673645,
0.25379857420921326,
0.21343934535980225,
0.5261955261230469,
0.5612962245941162,
0.05537540093064308,
0.6546471118927002,
-0.07782936096191406,
-0.24448513984680176,
-0.32447782158851624,
-0.20833738148212433,
-0.21896657347679138,
0.37883105874061584,
0.5642397403717041,
-0.38553741574287415,
-0.3862190246582031,
0.27792489528656006,
0.16443386673927307,
0.02835392951965332,
-0.19206279516220093,
0.9945552945137024,
0.023973559960722923,
-0.41267165541648865,
0.5665286183357239,
-0.15278394520282745,
0.4339998662471771,
-0.8942978382110596,
-0.08948764950037003,
-0.3267737627029419,
-0.07943104207515717,
-0.26368772983551025,
-0.47948983311653137,
0.46223944425582886,
-0.19593964517116547,
-0.33411747217178345,
-0.41396111249923706,
0.6186692118644714,
-0.2543124854564667,
-0.31325089931488037,
0.1466216742992401,
0.4440271854400635,
0.1335124671459198,
0.3511682152748108,
-0.5688954591751099,
-0.08034009486436844,
0.07115038484334946,
-0.152080237865448,
0.5802227258682251,
0.5233393907546997,
-0.03700041025876999,
0.9808487296104431,
0.6848939657211304,
0.2230704128742218,
-0.3227676451206207,
-0.08316919952630997,
0.9551253914833069,
-0.6870830655097961,
-0.6663258075714111,
-0.5003188848495483,
0.2533153295516968,
0.13875961303710938,
-0.25132355093955994,
0.4807792603969574,
0.6408841013908386,
0.7280816435813904,
-0.1900259107351303,
0.7614553570747375,
-0.120371975004673,
0.6014564037322998,
-0.5111812949180603,
0.7928110361099243,
-0.3661608099937439,
0.08175525814294815,
-0.037719644606113434,
-0.11958635598421097,
-0.550409197807312,
0.6279224753379822,
-0.1255515217781067,
-0.2054075449705124,
0.9466147422790527,
0.29695016145706177,
0.2296169400215149,
-0.06487110257148743,
0.29101091623306274,
0.3423713147640228,
0.25275716185569763,
0.3211442232131958,
0.37265413999557495,
-0.024199428036808968,
0.5778245329856873,
-0.27984631061553955,
-0.34443801641464233,
-0.4951869547367096,
-0.8814256191253662,
-0.6041103601455688,
-0.6534523367881775,
-0.4424747824668884,
-0.42817485332489014,
0.11897815018892288,
1.1120697259902954,
0.674830436706543,
-0.9256317615509033,
0.030032940208911896,
0.3967576026916504,
0.2329321950674057,
-0.4137430489063263,
-0.2796039879322052,
0.4206644594669342,
-0.8555163145065308,
-0.46872055530548096,
0.6343042850494385,
0.2450329214334488,
0.05607346445322037,
0.3967083692550659,
-0.019648391753435135,
-0.0021667357068508863,
-0.2645106017589569,
0.6455788612365723,
0.657538890838623,
-0.374032199382782,
-0.047857992351055145,
-0.054106179624795914,
-0.43534883856773376,
0.5630525946617126,
1.008562445640564,
-0.8840047121047974,
0.3995583653450012,
0.36438578367233276,
0.6373885869979858,
0.19243332743644714,
-0.08575424551963806,
0.5922102332115173,
-0.8504814505577087,
0.22393904626369476,
0.8362296223640442,
0.39685386419296265,
0.2700759470462799,
-0.6409518122673035,
0.06546356528997421,
0.33154618740081787,
-0.6660760045051575,
-0.8160611987113953,
0.17387911677360535,
-1.223972201347351,
-0.5043925642967224,
1.1127222776412964,
-0.07012876123189926,
-0.30545008182525635,
-0.39590492844581604,
-0.03276653215289116,
0.2349787950515747,
-0.7409012317657471,
0.9783254861831665,
0.14369750022888184,
-0.494196355342865,
-0.04529054835438728,
-0.4284057319164276,
0.8150425553321838,
0.22158725559711456,
-0.6258016228675842,
0.03989941626787186,
0.6153558492660522,
0.36481773853302,
-0.21320730447769165,
0.8695650696754456,
-0.06423121690750122,
0.5702091455459595,
-0.37025296688079834,
-0.029047541320323944,
0.026500854641199112,
-0.5620204210281372,
-0.4499436914920807,
0.06019387021660805,
0.0959211140871048,
-0.10979146510362625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01678v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01678v1
|
1-Diffractor: Efficient and Utility-Preserving Text Obfuscation Leveraging Word-Level Metric Differential Privacy
| 2024-05-02T19:07:32 | 2024-05-02T19:07:32 |
Stephen Meisenbacher, Maulik Chevli, Florian Matthes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The study of privacy-preserving Natural Language Processing (NLP) has gained
rising attention in recent years. One promising avenue studies the integration
of Differential Privacy in NLP, which has brought about innovative methods in a
variety of application settings. Of particular note are $\textit{word-level
Metric Local Differential Privacy (MLDP)}$ mechanisms, which work to obfuscate
potentially sensitive input text by performing word-by-word
$\textit{perturbations}$. Although these methods have shown promising results
in empirical tests, there are two major drawbacks: (1) the inevitable loss of
utility due to addition of noise, and (2) the computational expensiveness of
running these mechanisms on high-dimensional word embeddings. In this work, we
aim to address these challenges by proposing $\texttt{1-Diffractor}$, a new
mechanism that boasts high speedups in comparison to previous mechanisms, while
still demonstrating strong utility- and privacy-preserving capabilities. We
evaluate $\texttt{1-Diffractor}$ for utility on several NLP tasks, for
theoretical and task-based privacy, and for efficiency in terms of speed and
memory. $\texttt{1-Diffractor}$ shows significant improvements in efficiency,
while still maintaining competitive utility and privacy scores across all
conducted comparative tests against previous MLDP mechanisms. Our code is made
available at: https://github.com/sjmeis/Diffractor.
|
[
-0.6391792893409729,
-1.0691577196121216,
0.269810289144516,
0.2554234266281128,
-0.4275873303413391,
0.17691251635551453,
0.061543554067611694,
-0.3716737926006317,
0.14364677667617798,
0.5456811189651489,
-0.1572524458169937,
-0.401841938495636,
-0.9201979637145996,
0.058804530650377274,
-0.6907119750976562,
0.8537055253982544,
0.03622366115450859,
-0.27763381600379944,
0.04728066176176071,
-0.087785504758358,
0.11129184812307358,
-0.493564635515213,
-0.5429636240005493,
-0.17380693554878235,
0.5083813071250916,
-0.09129930287599564,
0.695943295955658,
0.6358217597007751,
0.6311196088790894,
0.44245192408561707,
-0.3125931918621063,
0.07601267844438553,
-0.5078422427177429,
0.3615245819091797,
-0.2769368290901184,
-0.1469658464193344,
-0.3567044734954834,
-0.04149260371923447,
0.7400611639022827,
0.6326296925544739,
-0.36134639382362366,
-0.015949586406350136,
0.44089260697364807,
0.9390938878059387,
-1.0027987957000732,
-0.06280366331338882,
-0.6818452477455139,
0.2959919571876526,
-0.5073127150535583,
-0.2761111855506897,
-0.23205846548080444,
-0.4795492887496948,
-0.012799452058970928,
-0.4463912546634674,
0.28716710209846497,
-0.10940227657556534,
0.6690437197685242,
0.7630067467689514,
0.11812503635883331,
-0.03166551887989044,
-0.9524996876716614,
0.5718709826469421,
-0.5724742412567139,
0.3387112617492676,
0.7328717708587646,
0.19444923102855682,
0.0049282643012702465,
-0.7999897599220276,
-0.6753617525100708,
0.029102403670549393,
-0.25307032465934753,
0.11896424740552902,
-0.8149626851081848,
0.1667986810207367,
0.2812560796737671,
0.7010174989700317,
-0.5338742733001709,
0.1738407015800476,
-0.16655570268630981,
-0.13250680267810822,
0.4715484082698822,
0.02973046898841858,
-0.1464589536190033,
0.07487724721431732,
-0.3406144380569458,
0.05292561650276184,
-0.20688936114311218,
-0.3071800768375397,
0.7507694363594055,
-0.20788906514644623,
-0.008965450339019299,
0.3163367807865143,
-0.29642581939697266,
0.4896314740180969,
0.21042057871818542,
-0.07094930112361908,
0.23988023400306702,
-0.1721830815076828,
-0.14152051508426666,
0.07296536862850189,
0.7799822688102722,
0.1276765614748001,
-0.14768753945827484,
-0.42651358246803284,
-0.038940053433179855,
0.24376752972602844,
0.17420834302902222,
-1.0192068815231323,
-0.23155584931373596,
0.18200045824050903,
-0.36074480414390564,
-0.44889211654663086,
0.12130773067474365,
-1.0686973333358765,
-0.7716988921165466,
0.10665452480316162,
0.4822029173374176,
-0.39514878392219543,
-0.3172891139984131,
0.7725086808204651,
-0.3195113241672516,
-0.20109009742736816,
0.20221301913261414,
-0.7998417019844055,
0.7766665816307068,
0.74946528673172,
0.9359676837921143,
-0.22716757655143738,
-0.0851961150765419,
-0.7503600716590881,
-0.10719742625951767,
0.21587586402893066,
0.4342600405216217,
-0.5626992583274841,
-0.5362724661827087,
0.05151069909334183,
-0.19488346576690674,
0.22402769327163696,
-0.40318551659584045,
0.4726833701133728,
-0.4800329804420471,
0.410739004611969,
-0.15085506439208984,
-0.52800053358078,
-0.14817407727241516,
0.09829747676849365,
-0.9622771739959717,
1.0147541761398315,
0.057190727442502975,
-1.221998929977417,
0.11291835457086563,
-1.023422122001648,
-0.3135187327861786,
0.16909755766391754,
0.16784752905368805,
-0.502975583076477,
0.11679550260305405,
0.018252428621053696,
0.3297586739063263,
-0.00767573993653059,
-0.276756227016449,
-0.09280113130807877,
-0.5605641007423401,
0.1639348715543747,
-0.7824452519416809,
0.9017877578735352,
0.2950972020626068,
-0.4825498163700104,
-0.4922642111778259,
-0.9089532494544983,
-0.46945399045944214,
0.0716153010725975,
-0.32567715644836426,
-0.7816081047058105,
-0.0339585579931736,
-0.2076842188835144,
-0.15946976840496063,
0.40250083804130554,
-1.0202317237854004,
-0.003203042084351182,
-0.4168495237827301,
0.2991182208061218,
0.8255024552345276,
-0.027053743600845337,
0.831505298614502,
-0.26174166798591614,
0.6524251699447632,
0.15539032220840454,
0.34304261207580566,
0.03991600498557091,
-0.4803634285926819,
-0.48268136382102966,
-0.5324994921684265,
0.5188294649124146,
0.40244030952453613,
-0.7603141069412231,
0.5081843733787537,
0.09332787245512009,
-0.4921399652957916,
-0.5867921710014343,
0.07834615558385849,
0.3277471363544464,
0.4444683790206909,
0.3524474501609802,
-0.2638069987297058,
-0.18209433555603027,
-0.608305811882019,
-0.35508283972740173,
0.24087516963481903,
0.04704993590712547,
-0.2418648600578308,
0.04181115701794624,
-0.07723333686590195,
0.9216465950012207,
-0.7604146003723145,
-0.49448081851005554,
-0.06007034331560135,
0.11333271116018295,
-0.01905224286019802,
0.6153823137283325,
0.7014752626419067,
-0.84478360414505,
-0.6814131736755371,
-0.24903878569602966,
-0.37527328729629517,
-0.31934061646461487,
0.1584518998861313,
-0.3848333954811096,
0.20486484467983246,
0.46828773617744446,
-0.5169111490249634,
0.833713710308075,
0.8946266174316406,
-0.4214351177215576,
0.1808701455593109,
-0.5473235249519348,
-0.004638237413018942,
-0.870091438293457,
0.05881798267364502,
0.08161898702383041,
-0.367806077003479,
-0.8705465793609619,
0.02734222263097763,
-0.05508388578891754,
0.24097885191440582,
-0.49405476450920105,
0.5089899301528931,
-0.5138751268386841,
0.46027982234954834,
-0.32905471324920654,
0.3168056905269623,
0.21866847574710846,
0.2528868019580841,
-0.2834179103374481,
0.4377259910106659,
0.7615504264831543,
-0.8047438263893127,
-0.03005983494222164,
0.25137054920196533,
-0.09260524064302444,
0.3487558364868164,
-0.4533369541168213,
0.49644288420677185,
-0.46151793003082275,
-0.036367516964673996,
-0.8866308927536011,
0.47375786304473877,
0.5506393909454346,
-0.23089471459388733,
0.4308868944644928,
-0.12657098472118378,
-0.8984633088111877,
-0.09036248177289963,
-0.7065136432647705,
0.18022534251213074,
0.6531159281730652,
-0.6717835068702698,
0.40964120626449585,
0.4324389100074768,
-0.0010115881450474262,
-0.8471649885177612,
-0.9045182466506958,
-0.09305284917354584,
-0.2599174380302429,
-0.21887172758579254,
0.7152107954025269,
-0.13688766956329346,
-0.3816587030887604,
0.1838868260383606,
-0.3410792052745819,
-0.2789249122142792,
0.28789061307907104,
0.2633776366710663,
0.13443511724472046,
0.32328033447265625,
-0.01185314729809761,
0.5964922904968262,
-0.44417598843574524,
-0.09345870465040207,
-0.13119739294052124,
0.5834357142448425,
0.2019805908203125,
-0.41886746883392334,
-0.45623624324798584,
0.44753581285476685,
0.2159365862607956,
-0.48618581891059875,
0.9767983555793762,
0.8393549919128418,
-0.398944616317749,
-0.27377864718437195,
-0.6971178650856018,
-0.17641304433345795,
-0.6063690185546875,
0.30607569217681885,
-0.027463633567094803,
-0.9833082556724548,
0.4587527811527252,
-0.10235275328159332,
0.3074156939983368,
-0.010589526034891605,
0.2338278740644455,
0.14770621061325073,
0.6690441966056824,
0.6978952884674072,
-0.28266435861587524,
0.7382307052612305,
-0.24388371407985687,
0.5231865644454956,
-0.7095810770988464,
0.16871918737888336,
-0.7472838163375854,
-0.559263288974762,
-0.9271804690361023,
-0.6257517337799072,
0.279641330242157,
0.24031078815460205,
0.10352349281311035,
0.3167175352573395,
-0.9821497201919556,
0.6751856803894043,
0.5420601963996887,
0.0067252181470394135,
0.7077847719192505,
0.1781117469072342,
0.09194503724575043,
-0.09019733965396881,
-0.5041232109069824,
-0.576715886592865,
0.7974122166633606,
0.4365067481994629,
1.0156925916671753,
0.23290015757083893,
1.2057368755340576,
0.21329808235168457,
0.10716436803340912,
-0.41596719622612,
0.697679340839386,
-0.7366911172866821,
-0.509641170501709,
-0.4581006169319153,
-0.4341827929019928,
-1.0025010108947754,
0.5896260738372803,
-0.1152467131614685,
-0.9818668961524963,
0.24606725573539734,
0.26876676082611084,
-0.1101885661482811,
0.6252861022949219,
-0.3871105909347534,
0.4045342803001404,
0.3430316746234894,
-0.7469894886016846,
-0.09378102421760559,
-0.46189457178115845,
0.14422813057899475,
-0.1860525906085968,
0.030842330306768417,
-0.12326586991548538,
-0.06857708096504211,
0.4770803451538086,
-0.2954704165458679,
0.6218764185905457,
-0.8454626798629761,
-0.22428859770298004,
-0.21523398160934448,
0.4375324249267578,
0.523654580116272,
0.2190384566783905,
-0.3247685432434082,
0.547816276550293,
-0.001506747561506927,
-0.10830873250961304,
-0.5558886528015137,
0.7336242198944092,
-0.12640151381492615,
-0.6575261354446411,
-0.4463416635990143,
-0.3566751480102539,
0.12812747061252594,
0.24073709547519684,
0.26564475893974304,
0.34387245774269104,
-0.02569049596786499,
0.21814829111099243,
0.8604136109352112,
-0.34665611386299133,
0.7935810685157776,
0.7154339551925659,
-0.1449347734451294,
-0.042938411235809326,
0.6830530166625977,
0.00798751786351204,
0.21423624455928802,
0.7370167374610901,
0.5092726349830627,
-0.44496339559555054,
-0.5830425024032593,
-0.1261858344078064,
0.07699014246463776,
-0.4971845746040344,
-0.228896826505661,
-0.8103961944580078,
-0.284239262342453,
0.0638117715716362,
-0.120880626142025,
-0.5276823043823242,
-0.6180741786956787,
-0.18301519751548767,
-0.0390070416033268,
0.5168893933296204,
0.41600748896598816,
-0.513669490814209,
0.0970192402601242,
-0.5961291790008545,
0.569158136844635,
-0.02628244087100029,
0.5824064016342163,
-0.11449778079986572,
-0.25256720185279846,
0.005879280623048544,
-0.06821275502443314,
-0.40209636092185974,
-0.6273854970932007,
0.2291894257068634,
0.00458834134042263,
0.5998802185058594,
0.4181835353374481,
0.581840455532074,
0.5919836163520813,
-0.6537454128265381,
0.7391026020050049,
0.12182262539863586,
-1.0776927471160889,
0.23326475918293,
0.2675146162509918,
0.28706252574920654,
0.8122907280921936,
0.25134244561195374,
-0.3668365478515625,
-0.9698444604873657,
-0.27397269010543823,
-0.9469232559204102,
0.6466074585914612,
0.5668460726737976,
0.36731472611427307,
0.032359778881073,
0.3748432397842407,
0.5448927283287048,
0.2584897577762604,
-0.4994707405567169,
-0.7990655899047852,
-0.34364715218544006,
-0.06823987513780594,
0.08132197707891464,
-0.1697191745042801,
-0.08816048502922058,
-0.2176222950220108,
0.3800276815891266,
0.2432238608598709,
0.3027958273887634,
0.47481775283813477,
0.02548675425350666,
0.3176173269748688,
0.3804451823234558,
0.46848130226135254,
0.22606875002384186,
-0.17819584906101227,
0.45360642671585083,
-0.045267969369888306,
-1.013082504272461,
0.17614099383354187,
0.6922207474708557,
-0.3922915458679199,
0.49140316247940063,
-0.13788114488124847,
0.3784661591053009,
-0.09230007976293564,
-0.024897141382098198,
0.44740012288093567,
-0.2880263328552246,
-0.5291963219642639,
-0.0065869493409991264,
0.07455983757972717,
-0.054418474435806274,
0.09392836689949036,
0.17906178534030914,
0.17179124057292938,
0.6086352467536926,
0.026126641780138016,
0.022900838404893875,
0.38402092456817627,
-0.22467589378356934,
-0.2449750304222107,
0.7766904830932617,
0.1968960464000702,
-0.4394114017486572,
0.03881469741463661,
-0.6527690887451172,
-0.3965928256511688,
-0.058582853525877,
0.28760087490081787,
1.0969090461730957,
-0.3601904809474945,
0.23467311263084412,
0.06939071416854858,
0.2309701293706894,
-0.11199072003364563,
0.12551119923591614,
-0.5810807347297668,
-0.5470039248466492,
-0.17303627729415894,
-0.7824886441230774,
-0.40917038917541504,
0.0033033585641533136,
-0.7271166443824768,
-0.15171745419502258,
-0.38222670555114746,
-0.2534458339214325,
0.14287976920604706,
-0.1073581650853157,
-0.6026307344436646,
-0.38855576515197754,
0.040665991604328156,
0.7880922555923462,
-0.24510522186756134,
0.9589669704437256,
0.335783451795578,
0.09494220465421677,
-0.20992064476013184,
0.2937808334827423,
0.014464178122580051,
-0.26681891083717346,
0.437652587890625,
-0.021603485569357872,
-0.6238335371017456,
-0.12057808041572571,
-0.09223282337188721,
-0.5975298285484314,
0.9884864091873169,
0.5379296541213989,
-0.9645313620567322,
0.18030138313770294,
0.46738725900650024,
0.5977776050567627,
0.3386492431163788,
-0.12773826718330383,
0.4001529812812805,
0.6418997645378113,
-0.3545578122138977,
-0.8396608233451843,
0.29350677132606506,
-0.07594984024763107,
0.0517190620303154,
0.5010935068130493,
-0.515438437461853,
0.6282572746276855,
0.20124895870685577,
-0.4881156086921692,
0.024655409157276154,
0.10662681609392166,
0.11168021708726883,
0.3725219964981079,
0.6448583006858826,
0.5984265208244324,
0.7155987024307251,
-0.12488242238759995,
0.8877390027046204,
-0.40045875310897827,
0.5068174004554749,
1.0923360586166382,
-0.43350332975387573,
0.5534606575965881,
0.8071120977401733,
-0.28787678480148315,
0.4075780510902405,
-0.3130209445953369,
0.2182106226682663,
0.9285851716995239,
0.5460324883460999,
-0.5148542523384094,
0.3632989525794983,
0.1883237510919571,
-0.33140233159065247,
0.4877772033214569,
-0.15607687830924988,
-0.2871522009372711,
-0.41633257269859314,
-0.03903607279062271,
0.3083641827106476,
0.3533395528793335,
0.04357128590345383,
0.7127946615219116,
-0.0666910782456398,
-0.15424685180187225,
0.258599191904068,
0.15742605924606323,
1.141822338104248,
-0.7486763000488281,
-0.08434566855430603,
-0.308453232049942,
0.44077175855636597,
-0.20769265294075012,
-0.5523486733436584,
0.6203513741493225,
0.14027002453804016,
-0.02203805185854435,
-0.39989182353019714,
0.6487823128700256,
-0.35464799404144287,
-0.23889444768428802,
0.4743289053440094,
0.2553729712963104,
-0.004091542214155197,
-0.2062249332666397,
-0.5644137859344482,
0.1756349802017212,
-0.23237891495227814,
-0.3827037811279297,
0.37236303091049194,
0.43134889006614685,
0.5945636630058289,
0.28021562099456787,
0.6006879806518555,
0.1817597895860672,
0.08828487992286682,
0.336748868227005,
0.9822078943252563,
-0.3451876640319824,
-0.6469242572784424,
-1.2662724256515503,
0.5920555591583252,
-0.34403255581855774,
-0.24267910420894623,
0.9781928658485413,
0.6332848072052002,
0.7292803525924683,
0.13168711960315704,
0.642503023147583,
-0.0767253190279007,
0.5315883755683899,
-0.4830389618873596,
1.1105737686157227,
-0.3852788805961609,
0.5279058218002319,
-0.5448190569877625,
-0.8833191394805908,
-0.3718012571334839,
0.7066066861152649,
0.0823819562792778,
-0.3485546112060547,
0.8153672218322754,
0.8852319717407227,
0.03380609676241875,
0.061268940567970276,
0.4712383449077606,
0.040961842983961105,
0.3843982517719269,
0.0467512384057045,
0.6039265394210815,
-0.46782076358795166,
0.3348403573036194,
-0.9337885975837708,
-0.41155657172203064,
0.2217840552330017,
-0.8901013135910034,
-0.8255727887153625,
-0.6221542954444885,
-0.541717529296875,
-0.1793135106563568,
0.06684281677007675,
0.3000558614730835,
0.7975825071334839,
-0.2821398377418518,
0.20358781516551971,
-0.4585261642932892,
0.11997798830270767,
-0.24620410799980164,
-0.26207858324050903,
0.20800212025642395,
0.064643494784832,
-1.0070900917053223,
0.17438867688179016,
0.5618646740913391,
0.03145859017968178,
-0.6786918640136719,
0.058477774262428284,
0.16323286294937134,
0.21589069068431854,
0.5123246908187866,
-0.11139799654483795,
-0.46284666657447815,
-0.05079283565282822,
-0.278786838054657,
0.1044689416885376,
-0.11766999959945679,
0.8078493475914001,
-0.571692705154419,
0.47808679938316345,
0.49559882283210754,
0.5021865367889404,
0.7991043329238892,
0.06479427218437195,
0.05394743010401726,
-0.7493702173233032,
0.4428098201751709,
0.41168150305747986,
0.2827437222003937,
0.1844681054353714,
-0.6636508107185364,
0.3929785490036011,
-0.1100262850522995,
-0.5393454432487488,
-1.0597829818725586,
0.07331499457359314,
-1.0127427577972412,
-0.2594811022281647,
0.9688743352890015,
-0.2591044306755066,
0.03218943253159523,
-0.2204505354166031,
-0.3098820745944977,
0.06012976914644241,
-0.6483426690101624,
1.0117489099502563,
0.5045583248138428,
0.029911013320088387,
-0.033175788819789886,
-0.35916075110435486,
0.6924800276756287,
0.10886622220277786,
-0.7119366526603699,
0.27677953243255615,
0.08719299733638763,
0.2862262725830078,
0.41977769136428833,
0.7655236124992371,
-0.4929680824279785,
-0.09994114935398102,
0.33311203122138977,
-0.20359130203723907,
-0.45993638038635254,
-0.07127649337053299,
-0.5950403213500977,
0.1884375512599945,
-0.3013843595981598,
-0.7756004333496094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01660v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01660v1
|
Investigating Wit, Creativity, and Detectability of Large Language Models in Domain-Specific Writing Style Adaptation of Reddit's Showerthoughts
| 2024-05-02T18:29:58 | 2024-05-02T18:29:58 |
Tolga Buz, Benjamin Frost, Nikola Genchev, Moritz Schneider, Lucie-Aimée Kaffee, Gerard de Melo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown the ability to generate
content that is difficult or impossible to distinguish from human writing. We
investigate the ability of differently-sized LLMs to replicate human writing
style in short, creative texts in the domain of Showerthoughts, thoughts that
may occur during mundane activities. We compare GPT-2 and GPT-Neo fine-tuned on
Reddit data as well as GPT-3.5 invoked in a zero-shot manner, against
human-authored texts. We measure human preference on the texts across the
specific dimensions that account for the quality of creative, witty texts.
Additionally, we compare the ability of humans versus fine-tuned RoBERTa
classifiers to detect AI-generated texts. We conclude that human evaluators
rate the generated texts slightly worse on average regarding their creative
quality, but they are unable to reliably distinguish between human-written and
AI-generated texts. We further provide a dataset for creative, witty text
generation based on Reddit Showerthoughts posts.
|
[
-0.18527202308177948,
-0.9516114592552185,
0.8951559066772461,
0.3081304430961609,
-0.3700399398803711,
0.13075704872608185,
-0.5033585429191589,
-0.6294626593589783,
0.2641187906265259,
0.44985756278038025,
-0.6765477061271667,
-0.4301329255104065,
-0.5372980237007141,
0.43977516889572144,
-0.2598411440849304,
1.1447160243988037,
-0.015204206109046936,
-0.28351038694381714,
-0.20416894555091858,
0.2136625498533249,
-0.42804691195487976,
-0.35048431158065796,
-0.32668352127075195,
-0.08420179784297943,
0.8846542239189148,
0.36599117517471313,
0.5606257319450378,
0.08845268189907074,
0.6826326847076416,
0.24456052482128143,
0.2349115014076233,
0.3052395284175873,
-0.6621242165565491,
0.1715354323387146,
-0.6598684191703796,
-0.3469933271408081,
-0.6108187437057495,
0.017219725996255875,
0.3910220265388489,
0.42366740107536316,
0.17394967377185822,
0.11689521372318268,
0.04140016809105873,
0.5850452780723572,
-0.4469878077507019,
-0.11611129343509674,
-0.8410335779190063,
-0.14193715155124664,
-0.19431951642036438,
-0.602863609790802,
-0.42140230536460876,
-0.4390966594219208,
0.04709029942750931,
-0.39157208800315857,
0.4491916596889496,
0.16220293939113617,
0.48838722705841064,
-0.03352794796228409,
-0.20094390213489532,
-0.49228814244270325,
-1.0142695903778076,
0.8397075533866882,
-0.6818825006484985,
0.0034397055860608816,
0.179107666015625,
0.06696251034736633,
-0.2208114117383957,
-0.7588959336280823,
-1.072911024093628,
-0.017250588163733482,
0.020803263410925865,
0.05983368679881096,
-0.349227637052536,
-0.29357773065567017,
0.16396790742874146,
0.22773674130439758,
-0.8214254975318909,
-0.15103115141391754,
0.016938289627432823,
0.16457663476467133,
0.9269769787788391,
0.16616518795490265,
0.512385904788971,
-0.06559035181999207,
-0.04809834808111191,
0.04580029472708702,
-0.6127360463142395,
-0.2501395344734192,
0.4892226755619049,
0.11936891078948975,
0.19858624041080475,
0.5319115519523621,
-0.1013350710272789,
0.44373777508735657,
-0.3530474305152893,
-0.24298414587974548,
0.12236305326223373,
-0.3073745667934418,
-0.07674656808376312,
-0.35294654965400696,
0.9680284857749939,
0.6043784022331238,
0.5811779499053955,
-0.3193601071834564,
-0.41294625401496887,
-0.09626109153032303,
0.4319414794445038,
-0.7329479455947876,
-0.5075517892837524,
-0.12463332712650299,
-0.26142075657844543,
-0.3429342806339264,
0.14032825827598572,
-0.2530544102191925,
-0.7310376763343811,
-0.16481328010559082,
0.5402440428733826,
-0.33759257197380066,
-0.3154872953891754,
0.2167237102985382,
-0.5141404271125793,
0.000997941242530942,
0.3748319447040558,
-0.9563658237457275,
0.020960327237844467,
0.7946084141731262,
0.6605478525161743,
-0.32888108491897583,
-0.44914355874061584,
0.10069229453802109,
-0.030340293422341347,
-0.3452947735786438,
1.1394308805465698,
-0.3494475781917572,
-0.2557377517223358,
-0.22893871366977692,
-0.08895418047904968,
-0.2110782116651535,
-0.4510330855846405,
0.695300281047821,
-0.5187049508094788,
0.23550981283187866,
-0.32693448662757874,
-0.5053879618644714,
-0.0017979760887101293,
0.08147023618221283,
-0.30152368545532227,
0.42014989256858826,
0.2808074355125427,
-1.1512458324432373,
0.4186110198497772,
-0.6931102275848389,
-0.6800863742828369,
0.2820292115211487,
-0.05367778241634369,
-0.40980517864227295,
0.21915490925312042,
-0.07530690729618073,
0.5166769027709961,
-0.1903485506772995,
0.05857398360967636,
-0.48925697803497314,
-0.5822921395301819,
0.9021576046943665,
-0.6933186650276184,
0.5854346752166748,
0.1559879183769226,
-0.3683050572872162,
0.28250160813331604,
-0.6530637741088867,
0.11604348570108414,
0.5450237393379211,
-0.23904171586036682,
-0.2617238759994507,
0.012459208257496357,
0.1942218840122223,
0.16072651743888855,
0.21463142335414886,
-0.6545183062553406,
0.21956293284893036,
-0.22423355281352997,
0.7781235575675964,
0.7145031094551086,
0.2036404013633728,
0.13752587139606476,
-0.7272999882698059,
0.4422623813152313,
-0.23720286786556244,
-0.08157281577587128,
0.06882917135953903,
-0.6758360266685486,
-0.48752230405807495,
-0.21888235211372375,
-0.12592463195323944,
0.5485067963600159,
-0.633110761642456,
0.3708834946155548,
-0.4103706479072571,
-0.6196309328079224,
-0.37320420145988464,
0.4534023404121399,
0.28216758370399475,
0.31548014283180237,
0.07954765856266022,
-0.202468603849411,
-0.43330201506614685,
-0.7619076371192932,
-0.7755222320556641,
-0.01617438532412052,
-0.144771009683609,
0.30428346991539,
0.6059175133705139,
-0.3821786940097809,
0.8179541230201721,
-0.5348802208900452,
0.12853041291236877,
-0.5618516206741333,
0.39717185497283936,
-0.04562944546341896,
0.20895972847938538,
0.6457281708717346,
-0.8259715437889099,
-0.7213954925537109,
-0.04225806146860123,
-0.6086466908454895,
-0.22468771040439606,
-0.22066165506839752,
-0.16808268427848816,
0.28300413489341736,
0.31151580810546875,
-0.6862508058547974,
0.49671390652656555,
0.26597926020622253,
-0.5329526662826538,
0.7936921715736389,
-0.04057151451706886,
0.15567080676555634,
-1.10836923122406,
0.07197780162096024,
0.047799594700336456,
-0.12422476708889008,
-0.5015271306037903,
-0.09478770941495895,
0.02728135697543621,
0.18722757697105408,
-0.25240558385849,
0.6910514831542969,
-0.3180479407310486,
0.04458550363779068,
-0.48754066228866577,
0.31611013412475586,
0.16802677512168884,
0.44258245825767517,
0.09093077480792999,
0.8350377678871155,
0.20860819518566132,
-0.29228031635284424,
0.35539525747299194,
0.08704803884029388,
-0.5419118404388428,
0.4591962397098541,
-0.5715068578720093,
0.5657532811164856,
-0.035243768244981766,
0.23636801540851593,
-1.20712149143219,
-0.445907860994339,
-0.00788811780512333,
-0.48409757018089294,
0.17338941991329193,
0.1441228836774826,
-0.7816792726516724,
-0.4356556832790375,
-0.4376468360424042,
0.21198730170726776,
0.48859965801239014,
-0.2804912030696869,
0.29813435673713684,
0.14265970885753632,
-0.7857732176780701,
-0.27770042419433594,
-0.754950761795044,
0.4286699593067169,
-0.2247859090566635,
-0.6410514116287231,
0.245346337556839,
-0.29434794187545776,
-0.47357386350631714,
0.06926105171442032,
0.361073762178421,
0.2215242087841034,
0.1880853921175003,
0.26274555921554565,
0.19916872680187225,
-0.23462837934494019,
-0.07232464849948883,
-0.0991266518831253,
0.3425389230251312,
0.2060944139957428,
-0.3087974190711975,
0.5179251432418823,
-0.17548294365406036,
-0.43338173627853394,
-0.4832819998264313,
0.3709063231945038,
0.5447604060173035,
0.05875682830810547,
0.6413751840591431,
0.8654142022132874,
-0.05099925771355629,
-0.6013147830963135,
-0.505066990852356,
-0.22918544709682465,
-0.48117902874946594,
0.4709470570087433,
-0.13591347634792328,
-0.8593786954879761,
0.48141762614250183,
0.3881304860115051,
0.09981784969568253,
0.4269683063030243,
0.7357938289642334,
-0.34481295943260193,
0.9195567965507507,
0.8047641515731812,
0.32562944293022156,
0.5388697981834412,
0.02330939657986164,
0.6918507814407349,
-0.7837493419647217,
0.11601606011390686,
-0.2527258098125458,
-0.5775880813598633,
-0.6055220365524292,
-0.08243202418088913,
-0.04626042768359184,
-0.2174544632434845,
-0.14472229778766632,
0.16820159554481506,
-0.4708433151245117,
0.5993053317070007,
0.7508265972137451,
-0.0022560865618288517,
0.33435314893722534,
-0.12570372223854065,
0.32816803455352783,
-0.13119198381900787,
-0.5724493861198425,
-0.6116438508033752,
1.1048833131790161,
0.22581897675991058,
0.8029311299324036,
0.4004327654838562,
0.6077059507369995,
0.4364652633666992,
0.6076362133026123,
-0.7980471253395081,
0.5838003158569336,
-0.2805074155330658,
-0.2849324345588684,
-0.1712414175271988,
-0.5111215114593506,
-0.63165682554245,
-0.22621066868305206,
-0.20877878367900848,
-0.7521654963493347,
-0.1555926352739334,
-0.08476141095161438,
-0.26036307215690613,
0.5225603580474854,
-0.9597843885421753,
0.6900667548179626,
-0.045960359275341034,
-0.40153661370277405,
-0.02936483547091484,
-0.3293754458427429,
0.30505645275115967,
-0.2186897099018097,
0.12657395005226135,
-0.06238627806305885,
0.13859917223453522,
0.7973183989524841,
-0.046956490725278854,
0.9719616174697876,
0.16760128736495972,
-0.3784906268119812,
0.5537363290786743,
0.3327118456363678,
0.28717315196990967,
0.03046715445816517,
0.2572842538356781,
-0.056547585874795914,
-0.33312270045280457,
-0.25217872858047485,
-0.6456989645957947,
0.9107672572135925,
-0.7664774656295776,
-0.8014021515846252,
-0.12107309699058533,
-0.8607059717178345,
-0.30097076296806335,
0.3310011327266693,
0.48624446988105774,
0.34668853878974915,
-0.17029625177383423,
0.06783080101013184,
0.3660556972026825,
-0.05877792462706566,
0.6381747126579285,
0.2791866958141327,
-0.0342106856405735,
-0.21818867325782776,
1.099708080291748,
-0.0023523776326328516,
0.29072797298431396,
0.3145974278450012,
0.23639771342277527,
-0.2689533233642578,
-0.7205427885055542,
-0.3749378025531769,
0.29749807715415955,
-0.7493152618408203,
-0.09699331223964691,
-0.6418048143386841,
-0.32164472341537476,
-0.6377349495887756,
-0.43072980642318726,
-0.034239187836647034,
-0.5818725228309631,
-0.4540863335132599,
0.04262273386120796,
0.4296227693557739,
1.0907502174377441,
0.232522115111351,
0.04932987689971924,
-0.6725795269012451,
0.005564705468714237,
0.5357947945594788,
0.18323568999767303,
0.0242763701826334,
-0.8002656698226929,
-0.0458843968808651,
-0.028919152915477753,
-0.4108061194419861,
-0.5418751239776611,
0.40425148606300354,
0.16109587252140045,
0.11531668156385422,
0.41407129168510437,
-0.03406018763780594,
0.1904083639383316,
-0.41679906845092773,
0.855972170829773,
-0.00906955637037754,
-0.5890234112739563,
0.4426003098487854,
-0.6870725154876709,
0.2830321490764618,
0.22316165268421173,
0.12246768921613693,
-0.570667564868927,
-0.5727265477180481,
-0.618642270565033,
-0.5878095626831055,
0.23732824623584747,
0.15916423499584198,
0.5249818563461304,
-0.23434767127037048,
0.44223204255104065,
0.25407612323760986,
0.19763301312923431,
-0.592531144618988,
0.19030876457691193,
-0.1480095535516739,
-0.3241453766822815,
-0.10126828402280807,
-0.35290268063545227,
-0.15171276032924652,
-0.045908622443675995,
0.5248189568519592,
-0.18152926862239838,
0.36367619037628174,
0.12292283028364182,
-0.05269591882824898,
-0.13968481123447418,
0.5395437479019165,
1.0388102531433105,
0.8361696600914001,
-0.17192910611629486,
0.38790878653526306,
-0.1340930312871933,
-0.7074536681175232,
-0.18482308089733124,
-0.1811704784631729,
-0.2142673134803772,
-0.20902970433235168,
0.8144455552101135,
0.8119376301765442,
0.08285274356603622,
-0.7975631952285767,
0.6527156233787537,
-0.2936417758464813,
-0.36856645345687866,
-0.24277450144290924,
0.5860021710395813,
0.29511985182762146,
0.27253738045692444,
0.271236777305603,
0.34952089190483093,
-0.05630731210112572,
-0.8770131468772888,
-0.05222359672188759,
0.5583544373512268,
-0.19273118674755096,
-0.7257543206214905,
0.5392533540725708,
0.1548982560634613,
-0.705423891544342,
0.30759936571121216,
-0.6594892740249634,
-0.4784148633480072,
0.2649160921573639,
0.8391401171684265,
1.1128045320510864,
0.4212263524532318,
0.16478033363819122,
0.052141252905130386,
-0.09949874132871628,
0.13385386765003204,
0.4976573586463928,
0.06595964729785919,
-0.9387510418891907,
-0.3478573262691498,
-0.6267549395561218,
-0.3431174159049988,
0.15395931899547577,
-0.3777979016304016,
0.21574868261814117,
-0.6032201051712036,
-0.3460049331188202,
0.21737675368785858,
-0.05042918026447296,
-0.6492849588394165,
-0.12521401047706604,
0.02488892152905464,
0.6589775681495667,
-0.8511958718299866,
0.5744938254356384,
0.8800088167190552,
-0.15729594230651855,
-0.545550525188446,
0.2749340832233429,
-0.02631106600165367,
-0.6339077353477478,
0.41750451922416687,
-0.07186924666166306,
-0.4193320572376251,
0.05617035925388336,
-0.7455160617828369,
-0.27109959721565247,
1.0397876501083374,
0.17563848197460175,
-0.39140263199806213,
-0.07461272925138474,
0.09909483790397644,
0.7400566339492798,
-0.34680309891700745,
0.0531010739505291,
0.561772346496582,
0.26815202832221985,
-0.005697084590792656,
-0.9927387833595276,
-0.1387343555688858,
-0.36914587020874023,
0.023658735677599907,
-0.11587386578321457,
-0.6373478770256042,
0.907806932926178,
-0.6565128564834595,
-0.2983523905277252,
0.1798083633184433,
0.5396521091461182,
0.20838934183120728,
0.3621778190135956,
0.10892580449581146,
0.4643953740596771,
0.7307169437408447,
0.04683512821793556,
1.009850263595581,
-0.012876474298536777,
0.28950101137161255,
1.09473717212677,
-0.3541712164878845,
1.068527102470398,
0.4386502802371979,
-0.0049745915457606316,
0.7406161427497864,
0.16318126022815704,
0.0643170103430748,
0.42904889583587646,
0.05835777148604393,
-0.4100717008113861,
-0.019192222505807877,
-0.037850357592105865,
-0.05369566008448601,
0.3226095139980316,
0.18432609736919403,
-0.3672408163547516,
0.16542842984199524,
0.049644410610198975,
0.14752238988876343,
0.2467581331729889,
-0.14511282742023468,
1.0953984260559082,
0.1764322817325592,
-0.6693874001502991,
0.3882540166378021,
-0.05166402831673622,
0.8465105295181274,
-0.15918193757534027,
0.1128549799323082,
-0.1529168337583542,
0.37157294154167175,
-0.16928653419017792,
-1.2913596630096436,
0.15143929421901703,
0.22181017696857452,
-0.30151599645614624,
-0.20700427889823914,
0.9593898057937622,
-0.20402838289737701,
-0.46755144000053406,
-0.08571749180555344,
0.5307185053825378,
0.021025149151682854,
-0.2285597324371338,
-0.4102766811847687,
-0.07439600676298141,
-0.016536498442292213,
-0.37094753980636597,
0.2922605276107788,
0.9587305784225464,
0.10067193955183029,
0.6722574830055237,
0.5946798324584961,
0.23431655764579773,
-0.21777085959911346,
0.4126271605491638,
0.6191404461860657,
-0.8056207299232483,
-0.44644004106521606,
-1.0263786315917969,
0.29639121890068054,
-0.0851452425122261,
-0.5726321339607239,
0.8838380575180054,
0.26633962988853455,
0.7316628694534302,
-0.37894144654273987,
1.06429123878479,
0.002920470666140318,
0.6152420043945312,
-0.4058036804199219,
1.0519490242004395,
-0.40016841888427734,
0.2408299297094345,
-0.48657503724098206,
-0.9875255823135376,
-0.2723897397518158,
0.51652991771698,
-0.4331143796443939,
0.23571543395519257,
0.688858687877655,
0.7414623498916626,
-0.08344592154026031,
0.2612108588218689,
0.21954192221164703,
0.09590702503919601,
0.4130546748638153,
0.5346066355705261,
0.9736179709434509,
0.009469824843108654,
0.239955335855484,
-0.1667000651359558,
-0.20125821232795715,
-0.3917655944824219,
-0.9543178677558899,
-1.1169415712356567,
-0.7262763381004333,
-0.36879822611808777,
-0.2905673682689667,
-0.2588482201099396,
0.7169424295425415,
0.3574925661087036,
-0.6009737253189087,
0.2524058222770691,
-0.2598426938056946,
0.08897172659635544,
0.001407775329425931,
-0.3066466450691223,
0.2588789761066437,
-0.14139308035373688,
-0.5390313863754272,
0.21497516334056854,
0.4391953647136688,
0.21453434228897095,
-0.46910199522972107,
0.10291488468647003,
0.21565645933151245,
0.424776554107666,
0.8323798775672913,
0.09504453092813492,
-0.5707738399505615,
-0.6408902406692505,
0.2118251919746399,
-0.3043714463710785,
-0.15052363276481628,
0.9009706974029541,
-0.19940415024757385,
0.16656644642353058,
0.6097594499588013,
0.3860332667827606,
-0.004766946658492088,
0.0937729999423027,
0.23911969363689423,
-0.7365182638168335,
-0.10704456269741058,
0.544631838798523,
0.21526312828063965,
0.6535149812698364,
-0.3005322217941284,
0.16196995973587036,
0.6482864022254944,
-0.8309776186943054,
-0.7576568722724915,
0.20173801481723785,
-0.9156018495559692,
-0.41869866847991943,
1.4593054056167603,
-0.045783016830682755,
-0.38970741629600525,
-0.041514430195093155,
-0.3550594449043274,
-0.17002543807029724,
-0.12197639048099518,
1.0510541200637817,
0.80367112159729,
-0.3543378412723541,
-0.059270501136779785,
-0.6061352491378784,
0.5942134261131287,
0.11081487685441971,
-0.7191641330718994,
0.30725497007369995,
0.21400560438632965,
0.5742531418800354,
0.21264390647411346,
0.8141047358512878,
0.17201001942157745,
0.3912995755672455,
0.05558409541845322,
-0.03856945410370827,
0.03935864940285683,
-0.3075031340122223,
0.08871681988239288,
0.07388009876012802,
0.3895602822303772,
0.30830225348472595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02347v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02347v2
|
COPAL: Continual Pruning in Large Language Generative Models
| 2024-05-02T18:24:41 | 2024-06-14T18:06:47 |
Srikanth Malla, Joon Hee Choi, Chiho Choi
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Adapting pre-trained large language models to different domains in natural
language processing requires two key considerations: high computational demands
and model's inability to continual adaptation. To simultaneously address both
issues, this paper presents COPAL (COntinual Pruning in Adaptive Language
settings), an algorithm developed for pruning large language generative models
under a continual model adaptation setting. While avoiding resource-heavy
finetuning or retraining, our pruning process is guided by the proposed
sensitivity analysis. The sensitivity effectively measures model's ability to
withstand perturbations introduced by the new dataset and finds model's weights
that are relevant for all encountered datasets. As a result, COPAL allows
seamless model adaptation to new domains while enhancing the resource
efficiency. Our empirical evaluation on a various size of LLMs show that COPAL
outperforms baseline models, demonstrating its efficacy in efficiency and
adaptability.
|
[
-0.26616719365119934,
-0.9083321690559387,
0.3032228350639343,
0.7128747701644897,
-0.3981736898422241,
0.26220831274986267,
-0.45320650935173035,
-0.25206226110458374,
-0.42260465025901794,
0.43187040090560913,
-0.5609166622161865,
-0.4533836841583252,
-0.5409619212150574,
0.17418938875198364,
-0.18522050976753235,
1.1658384799957275,
0.0728408694267273,
-0.300498366355896,
-0.2336326241493225,
-0.17583227157592773,
-0.8014817237854004,
-0.6581469774246216,
-1.0158194303512573,
-0.09663307666778564,
0.365908682346344,
0.24426603317260742,
0.6059138774871826,
0.4209803342819214,
0.5668665170669556,
0.2662332355976105,
-0.025722254067659378,
-0.04144308343529701,
-0.6569891571998596,
0.421229749917984,
-0.20734821259975433,
-0.6844234466552734,
-0.42398297786712646,
-0.3263421654701233,
1.0586923360824585,
0.7066372036933899,
-0.2419918328523636,
-0.016651153564453125,
0.5281361937522888,
0.6421726942062378,
-0.7684906125068665,
-0.03686489909887314,
-1.0683388710021973,
-0.03637165576219559,
-0.2314663976430893,
-0.20903049409389496,
-0.6214966773986816,
-0.2999460697174072,
0.16485536098480225,
-0.6892703175544739,
0.5804598331451416,
0.1477769911289215,
0.8330317139625549,
0.5354249477386475,
-0.012542441487312317,
0.03979445621371269,
-0.968254804611206,
0.9785141944885254,
-0.6091036796569824,
0.28488415479660034,
0.03585163131356239,
0.0526360459625721,
-0.26913440227508545,
-0.8125138282775879,
-0.3816455602645874,
-0.5305899381637573,
0.31398963928222656,
0.1429850459098816,
-0.38054659962654114,
0.07117040455341339,
0.0743151381611824,
0.35841798782348633,
-0.4029327929019928,
0.13264958560466766,
-0.2955465316772461,
-0.10687728971242905,
0.39904746413230896,
0.03937574476003647,
0.28913962841033936,
0.4993378520011902,
-0.39183515310287476,
0.1268848478794098,
-0.8959822058677673,
-0.22499915957450867,
0.06737950444221497,
0.32821643352508545,
-0.009072286076843739,
0.21653211116790771,
0.36048927903175354,
1.1353769302368164,
0.19707530736923218,
-0.07805555313825607,
-0.10770969092845917,
0.020157773047685623,
-0.4495028853416443,
-0.0811908170580864,
0.5823665261268616,
0.23705801367759705,
0.5025624632835388,
-0.17314989864826202,
-0.09785055369138718,
0.04515254870057106,
0.7082102298736572,
-0.5218193531036377,
-0.553172767162323,
0.26271289587020874,
-0.13701841235160828,
-0.12284767627716064,
-0.3305039405822754,
-0.610724687576294,
-0.23231792449951172,
-0.33725351095199585,
0.24166542291641235,
-0.5257508158683777,
-0.21568399667739868,
0.11334321647882462,
0.19379159808158875,
0.07657039910554886,
0.26914656162261963,
-0.6802969574928284,
0.6844128370285034,
0.8098787665367126,
1.2741398811340332,
-0.6991370320320129,
-0.4028039276599884,
-0.6902468800544739,
0.08644355833530426,
-0.5581389665603638,
0.828816294670105,
-0.5390088558197021,
-0.42009368538856506,
-0.08985988795757294,
0.252209335565567,
-0.6049153804779053,
-0.8456470966339111,
0.7191246747970581,
-0.7070178389549255,
-0.23687979578971863,
-0.01918994076550007,
-0.4317740499973297,
0.11647539585828781,
0.21885031461715698,
-0.7450361251831055,
0.7888284921646118,
0.3900850713253021,
-0.7932142615318298,
0.3275109827518463,
-0.7589623332023621,
-0.5275242328643799,
0.21343994140625,
0.41203469038009644,
-0.7144315838813782,
0.4163949489593506,
-0.02083742618560791,
0.29746079444885254,
-0.42653781175613403,
0.3918137550354004,
-0.29951968789100647,
0.0015212735161185265,
0.4157107472419739,
-0.3864811658859253,
0.7792336344718933,
0.2843160033226013,
0.283772349357605,
0.4561859667301178,
-0.4662652611732483,
-0.270831435918808,
0.21104365587234497,
-0.47872447967529297,
-0.40523263812065125,
0.22571837902069092,
0.0362890399992466,
0.07981573045253754,
0.07756773382425308,
-0.2927703261375427,
0.3109321892261505,
-0.4914839565753937,
0.5069020986557007,
0.903112530708313,
0.2543160617351532,
0.2828809916973114,
-0.5566424131393433,
0.7853303551673889,
-0.21869726479053497,
0.23448725044727325,
0.22177745401859283,
0.009585977531969547,
-1.2142161130905151,
-0.2616286873817444,
0.3967272639274597,
0.43492960929870605,
-0.6055936217308044,
0.5156165361404419,
-0.48844268918037415,
-0.39204785227775574,
-0.4081053137779236,
0.18039222061634064,
0.2751719355583191,
0.24475064873695374,
0.25599199533462524,
-0.7476258873939514,
-0.4939245879650116,
-0.6215713620185852,
-0.05684862285852432,
-0.13929355144500732,
-0.29909032583236694,
0.03940794989466667,
0.48474812507629395,
0.3010411262512207,
0.9567919373512268,
-0.4676809310913086,
-0.18065741658210754,
-0.2858998775482178,
0.0943961888551712,
0.07367713004350662,
0.43047383427619934,
0.49056509137153625,
-0.8690658807754517,
-0.6881018877029419,
-0.038617368787527084,
-0.3865814507007599,
-0.1366945058107376,
-0.46379584074020386,
-0.05216693505644798,
0.19308343529701233,
0.5605818033218384,
-0.3209906816482544,
-0.10091482847929001,
0.8681410551071167,
0.022878091782331467,
0.9495788216590881,
-0.3325408399105072,
-0.3498266637325287,
-0.8656796216964722,
0.22915975749492645,
0.045984890311956406,
-0.24567261338233948,
-0.8625302910804749,
0.10060088336467743,
-0.14764517545700073,
-0.11304640024900436,
-0.39155298471450806,
0.2845102846622467,
-0.5883743166923523,
0.007561090402305126,
-0.37654009461402893,
-0.004694405943155289,
-0.012640053406357765,
0.34027087688446045,
0.32923993468284607,
1.0721091032028198,
0.74897301197052,
-1.1919567584991455,
0.5039583444595337,
0.0035031342413276434,
-0.2551843225955963,
0.5661981105804443,
-0.7605132460594177,
0.30570510029792786,
-0.017906365916132927,
0.18286877870559692,
-0.5529800653457642,
-0.10733962059020996,
0.39901161193847656,
-0.1994307041168213,
0.42536747455596924,
-0.5662344694137573,
-0.0064351377077400684,
-0.25825297832489014,
-0.1883823424577713,
0.29372406005859375,
0.24905988574028015,
-0.5196138620376587,
0.4743686020374298,
0.5012367367744446,
-0.5553398728370667,
-0.1291053742170334,
-0.27386096119880676,
0.2381673902273178,
-0.442078560590744,
-0.42598727345466614,
0.6334379315376282,
-0.4201541543006897,
-0.26597359776496887,
0.04987439513206482,
-0.19243305921554565,
-0.15756015479564667,
0.3597363531589508,
0.12565810978412628,
0.4219595789909363,
-0.28249892592430115,
0.2645821273326874,
-0.44891563057899475,
-0.08470118045806885,
0.06780308485031128,
-0.4543894827365875,
0.8640580773353577,
-0.12627282738685608,
-0.1338805854320526,
-0.17125721275806427,
0.03434315323829651,
0.6139647364616394,
-0.39290159940719604,
0.8963162302970886,
0.31431564688682556,
-0.18811435997486115,
-0.5005289316177368,
-0.30176079273223877,
0.24645642936229706,
-0.450334370136261,
0.3708815574645996,
-0.6867102384567261,
-1.0714956521987915,
0.1971299797296524,
-0.28764256834983826,
0.26493850350379944,
0.48061299324035645,
0.6706743836402893,
0.216450497508049,
0.47315138578414917,
1.0678287744522095,
-0.4275452792644501,
0.5200298428535461,
0.11811928451061249,
0.21097135543823242,
-1.255665898323059,
0.13004110753536224,
-0.7288427352905273,
0.15169808268547058,
-0.4163591265678406,
-0.5041939616203308,
0.18441687524318695,
0.20728598535060883,
-0.05570174381136894,
0.37417009472846985,
-0.6531741619110107,
0.32246214151382446,
0.3073570430278778,
-0.2509534955024719,
0.10319057106971741,
0.0029787190724164248,
0.2653956711292267,
0.06041886284947395,
-0.9199796915054321,
-0.2349831610918045,
0.8077440857887268,
0.3369373679161072,
0.6795873641967773,
0.2543913424015045,
0.17057302594184875,
0.3458118140697479,
0.6569122672080994,
-0.9091871380805969,
0.26492658257484436,
-0.19739820063114166,
-0.44800201058387756,
-0.37491148710250854,
-0.403852254152298,
-1.2253379821777344,
0.232911616563797,
-0.1632893681526184,
-0.7844332456588745,
0.09946726262569427,
0.3013896644115448,
-0.6748668551445007,
0.14809900522232056,
-0.4779698848724365,
0.7535570859909058,
-0.190163254737854,
-0.6116116642951965,
-0.14752326905727386,
-0.36681684851646423,
0.29083991050720215,
-0.4713977873325348,
0.0030738108325749636,
-0.1683146059513092,
-0.04009842500090599,
0.7726538777351379,
-0.15510275959968567,
0.8253633975982666,
-0.007684460841119289,
-0.03058757074177265,
0.49012085795402527,
0.4310813844203949,
0.5970273613929749,
-0.17724904417991638,
-0.03973885253071785,
-0.06807098537683487,
0.09032038599252701,
-0.4733644425868988,
-0.3589692711830139,
0.7522710561752319,
-0.5551750659942627,
-0.7513174414634705,
-0.5763522386550903,
-0.5849457383155823,
-0.49195826053619385,
-0.1223868876695633,
0.18432289361953735,
-0.03740006312727928,
-0.5296764969825745,
0.2582232654094696,
0.6896229386329651,
-0.4356682300567627,
0.2581150531768799,
0.5021997690200806,
-0.04194866865873337,
-0.06271267682313919,
0.9462456107139587,
0.0049035316333174706,
0.5713304877281189,
0.280776709318161,
0.0785772055387497,
-0.04644603282213211,
-0.8723472952842712,
-0.05316001549363136,
0.18718159198760986,
-0.2548460364341736,
-0.16904395818710327,
-0.4688912332057953,
-0.4979828894138336,
-0.4130275547504425,
-0.24684640765190125,
-0.2760796546936035,
-0.03796301409602165,
-0.21012334525585175,
0.0740569606423378,
0.3957851827144623,
0.18532992899417877,
0.14610593020915985,
0.5550616979598999,
-0.728627622127533,
0.4049345552921295,
0.2963288724422455,
0.41597869992256165,
-0.15981696546077728,
-0.8943668603897095,
0.03380538895726204,
-0.38564902544021606,
-0.12602069973945618,
-0.6409164667129517,
0.6535772681236267,
0.6634714603424072,
0.3203585743904114,
0.2289615273475647,
0.21719512343406677,
0.6273602247238159,
-0.39595499634742737,
0.5889250636100769,
0.1479019969701767,
-0.8656129240989685,
0.407304048538208,
-0.21519702672958374,
0.5626097917556763,
0.4553343951702118,
0.4809534251689911,
-0.8748438358306885,
-0.23322521150112152,
-0.5037664771080017,
-0.8548183441162109,
0.5104466676712036,
0.10885659605264664,
0.1685149371623993,
0.05670378729701042,
0.39877936244010925,
-0.012416848912835121,
-0.045263636857271194,
-0.8201894164085388,
0.24353687465190887,
0.07397137582302094,
-0.10182642936706543,
-0.10374627262353897,
-0.4672836661338806,
-0.2038384974002838,
-0.02813381887972355,
0.8116216063499451,
-0.22858628630638123,
0.11591994762420654,
0.05006955564022064,
-0.4075620770454407,
0.005896481219679117,
0.3252544403076172,
0.15399254858493805,
0.7439296245574951,
-0.1606651246547699,
0.2699224650859833,
0.5465184450149536,
-0.5015913844108582,
-0.014952501282095909,
-0.13097195327281952,
-0.22851046919822693,
-0.21894922852516174,
0.5765764713287354,
0.7726504802703857,
0.012072968296706676,
-0.6088247895240784,
0.245835080742836,
-0.11539755761623383,
-0.008342315442860126,
-0.48832979798316956,
0.3448534309864044,
-0.012625576928257942,
-0.31177017092704773,
0.046223368495702744,
0.09473446011543274,
-0.25976845622062683,
-0.42528021335601807,
0.256756454706192,
0.23464931547641754,
-0.6032185554504395,
-0.35309356451034546,
0.3194655478000641,
0.13880981504917145,
-0.2873157262802124,
0.6735647916793823,
-0.05327514559030533,
-0.555963397026062,
0.51124107837677,
1.0002739429473877,
0.8522399663925171,
-0.6004870533943176,
0.07948175072669983,
0.5079038739204407,
0.4238349199295044,
-0.06717614084482193,
-0.36732909083366394,
0.06660616397857666,
-1.0404552221298218,
-0.6676172614097595,
-1.0065340995788574,
-0.26020246744155884,
0.30858466029167175,
-0.5982087254524231,
-0.08522000908851624,
-0.8041001558303833,
-0.15689755976200104,
0.05541590228676796,
0.025035012513399124,
-0.38458094000816345,
0.25282642245292664,
-0.2530750036239624,
0.9099751114845276,
-1.0559967756271362,
1.1100127696990967,
0.3504445552825928,
-0.12590019404888153,
-0.38098612427711487,
0.19284994900226593,
-0.01980152167379856,
-0.5842056274414062,
0.09657806903123856,
-0.1243835985660553,
-0.27205321192741394,
0.22939522564411163,
-0.5211780071258545,
-0.8094311356544495,
0.7275767922401428,
0.4108336567878723,
-0.8462982773780823,
0.32680201530456543,
-0.08805889636278152,
0.5290275812149048,
-0.3502158224582672,
-0.5762673616409302,
1.035203456878662,
0.36888954043388367,
0.02972620353102684,
-0.6137704849243164,
-0.003673538565635681,
-0.35033005475997925,
0.1725964993238449,
0.2268955409526825,
-0.6229406595230103,
0.7092592716217041,
0.03886973857879639,
-0.5637005567550659,
0.07521606981754303,
0.6150215864181519,
0.3255346119403839,
-0.056719060987234116,
0.8981356024742126,
0.2245616465806961,
0.8232113718986511,
-0.1969473510980606,
1.043200969696045,
-0.4136868119239807,
0.2411169707775116,
1.3751941919326782,
-0.5556682348251343,
0.625099778175354,
0.43316909670829773,
-0.5115606188774109,
0.22000524401664734,
0.5988847613334656,
-0.3066062033176422,
0.264270544052124,
0.4833117127418518,
-0.7601237297058105,
-0.37710514664649963,
-0.4601059854030609,
-0.05578911677002907,
0.15137465298175812,
0.4593640863895416,
0.053255319595336914,
0.06524155288934708,
0.030621802434325218,
0.13247254490852356,
0.016538185998797417,
-0.25980883836746216,
0.6840305328369141,
0.2060796320438385,
-1.0232038497924805,
0.6253930330276489,
0.2317299246788025,
0.5523648858070374,
-0.7400878667831421,
0.22161903977394104,
-0.1141127198934555,
0.23896576464176178,
-0.032048508524894714,
-0.4172152876853943,
0.6271717548370361,
0.1679019033908844,
-0.0690624788403511,
-0.018196316435933113,
0.9347303509712219,
-0.1163899153470993,
-0.6092973351478577,
0.30191150307655334,
0.18630941212177277,
0.04563974216580391,
-0.371065229177475,
-0.8229705095291138,
0.3942340016365051,
0.01421091053634882,
-0.13847601413726807,
0.3804120719432831,
0.2692969739437103,
-0.3660122752189636,
0.938636064529419,
0.8537229895591736,
0.3481334447860718,
0.02592444233596325,
0.2729296386241913,
0.8459526300430298,
-0.3986579477787018,
-0.08975972980260849,
-0.7654303908348083,
0.1843041032552719,
-0.014291327446699142,
-0.34855934977531433,
0.5042142271995544,
0.48813942074775696,
0.7045466899871826,
-0.07827106863260269,
0.9054383039474487,
-0.15563657879829407,
0.18341724574565887,
-0.6739574670791626,
0.5219857096672058,
-0.2011001855134964,
0.2509472370147705,
0.09385989606380463,
-1.0007926225662231,
-0.775931179523468,
0.6808998584747314,
-0.4430299699306488,
-0.051863666623830795,
0.8418388962745667,
0.9128002524375916,
-0.034298159182071686,
-0.3826814889907837,
0.2990351617336273,
0.4944702982902527,
0.22345612943172455,
0.6704827547073364,
0.6412712931632996,
0.2789718508720398,
0.48897698521614075,
-0.061392903327941895,
-0.2972496747970581,
-0.047909755259752274,
-0.8695889711380005,
-0.5587056875228882,
-0.7323680520057678,
-0.5345539450645447,
-0.26531362533569336,
0.3516312539577484,
0.7040804028511047,
0.7573855519294739,
-0.9255858063697815,
-0.2401486188173294,
-0.3819105327129364,
-0.031942810863256454,
-0.43322446942329407,
-0.20259515941143036,
0.6204720139503479,
-0.6021056175231934,
-0.6460885405540466,
0.45961999893188477,
0.5192601680755615,
-0.18336859345436096,
-0.030032172799110413,
-0.02233358658850193,
-0.2242121696472168,
0.13296262919902802,
0.5675690770149231,
0.5045592188835144,
-0.3918692171573639,
-0.49686455726623535,
-0.2890203297138214,
0.11059504002332687,
0.1909738928079605,
0.9238101840019226,
-0.5468881726264954,
0.45085012912750244,
0.07029231637716293,
0.580573320388794,
0.5968371629714966,
0.1013217642903328,
0.7869629263877869,
-0.859645426273346,
0.16427357494831085,
0.3517674207687378,
0.18740209937095642,
0.48060518503189087,
-0.012351498939096928,
0.4166624844074249,
0.13691240549087524,
-0.45664483308792114,
-0.5772262811660767,
0.5187587738037109,
-1.0482378005981445,
-0.5428817868232727,
1.1303085088729858,
-0.4018966555595398,
-0.42574363946914673,
-0.4384807050228119,
-0.27274996042251587,
0.35990291833877563,
0.12588827311992645,
1.0113389492034912,
0.8005064129829407,
0.17446118593215942,
-0.3092360496520996,
-0.4973512291908264,
0.5277445316314697,
0.3901107907295227,
-0.8280037045478821,
0.47274020314216614,
0.4421055018901825,
0.5627918243408203,
-0.031547997146844864,
0.8046097755432129,
-0.07702185958623886,
0.08062849938869476,
0.025996185839176178,
0.12705890834331512,
0.17822498083114624,
-0.5732122659683228,
-0.5791370868682861,
0.47289156913757324,
0.7872563004493713,
0.016286253929138184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01649v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01649v3
|
Improving Complex Reasoning over Knowledge Graph with Logic-Aware Curriculum Tuning
| 2024-05-02T18:12:08 | 2024-05-08T18:21:04 |
Tianle Xia, Liang Ding, Guojia Wan, Yibing Zhan, Bo Du, Dacheng Tao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Answering complex queries over incomplete knowledge graphs (KGs) is a
challenging job. Most previous works have focused on learning entity/relation
embeddings and simulating first-order logic operators with various neural
networks. However, they are bottlenecked by the inability to share world
knowledge to improve logical reasoning, thus resulting in suboptimal
performance. In this paper, we propose a complex reasoning schema over KG upon
large language models (LLMs), containing a curriculum-based logical-aware
instruction tuning framework, named LACT. Specifically, we augment the
arbitrary first-order logical queries via binary tree decomposition, to
stimulate the reasoning capability of LLMs. To address the difficulty gap among
different types of complex queries, we design a simple and flexible logic-aware
curriculum learning framework. Experiments across widely used datasets
demonstrate that LACT has substantial improvements~(brings an average +5.5% MRR
score) over advanced methods, achieving the new state-of-the-art. Our code and
model will be released at GitHub and huggingface soon.
|
[
-0.24106445908546448,
-0.996351420879364,
0.584976077079773,
-0.17540426552295685,
-0.043990664184093475,
0.18914161622524261,
-0.07567931711673737,
-0.25586310029029846,
-0.13458287715911865,
0.6144471168518066,
-0.7686130404472351,
-0.6414908170700073,
-0.6333415508270264,
-0.23664595186710358,
-0.0246870219707489,
0.8453701138496399,
0.14780022203922272,
0.04567011073231697,
-0.2033069133758545,
-0.14700807631015778,
-0.5850529670715332,
-0.28039801120758057,
-0.7061211466789246,
-0.2641913592815399,
0.48056039214134216,
0.3129027485847473,
0.5169585943222046,
0.5655999183654785,
0.30197206139564514,
0.2163906991481781,
-0.14439013600349426,
0.7069412469863892,
-0.5857590436935425,
0.24824783205986023,
-0.5071859955787659,
-0.40729084610939026,
-0.48585331439971924,
-0.3365037739276886,
0.3282540440559387,
0.9761354327201843,
-0.18574677407741547,
0.04425136372447014,
-0.21207986772060394,
0.883510947227478,
-0.720833957195282,
0.8578004240989685,
-0.8705639243125916,
0.02542082779109478,
0.10641758888959885,
-0.06492746621370316,
-0.6541040539741516,
-0.5568972826004028,
0.17153601348400116,
-0.7756040692329407,
0.02684435062110424,
0.35115236043930054,
0.44695520401000977,
0.3771877884864807,
-0.6077656149864197,
-0.31181010603904724,
-0.371913880109787,
0.5767170786857605,
-0.5056665539741516,
0.5167022943496704,
0.1758389174938202,
0.4101031720638275,
-0.44381675124168396,
-0.6020397543907166,
-0.37861454486846924,
0.12317784875631332,
-0.03419748321175575,
0.26906299591064453,
-0.025114353746175766,
0.27092283964157104,
0.4929688274860382,
0.07687541097402573,
-0.3217158317565918,
-0.1505601555109024,
-0.42921364307403564,
-0.3008999526500702,
0.36248937249183655,
0.33024048805236816,
0.043466050177812576,
0.08239037543535233,
-0.049508851021528244,
0.12974852323532104,
-0.956439197063446,
0.13280168175697327,
0.25645625591278076,
0.27071043848991394,
0.3848605453968048,
0.6374640464782715,
-0.307362824678421,
1.2959033250808716,
-0.15300647914409637,
-0.023488514125347137,
-0.07630255818367004,
0.041510432958602905,
-0.21080811321735382,
0.24462424218654633,
0.24453136324882507,
0.40831246972084045,
0.4486159384250641,
-0.08206971734762192,
-0.23089604079723358,
0.24420814216136932,
0.05755132436752319,
-0.8239977359771729,
-0.5379191040992737,
-0.079439677298069,
0.08537677675485611,
0.038527071475982666,
0.019771747291088104,
-0.13221828639507294,
-0.214246466755867,
-0.6274707913398743,
0.3327353000640869,
-0.843625009059906,
-0.11432661861181259,
0.542338490486145,
0.18371222913265228,
0.1449327915906906,
0.739218533039093,
-0.6881873607635498,
0.17038090527057648,
0.7835940718650818,
0.2850048243999481,
0.13942456245422363,
0.15850608050823212,
-0.6214840412139893,
0.34701642394065857,
-0.2625803053379059,
0.652093768119812,
-0.6713066101074219,
0.08604992181062698,
-0.2507277727127075,
-0.1494320034980774,
-0.36418724060058594,
-0.621371865272522,
0.7107740044593811,
-0.9065372943878174,
0.009474676102399826,
-0.3501177430152893,
-0.8749017119407654,
-0.3356132209300995,
0.5029851198196411,
-0.46017661690711975,
0.8184728026390076,
0.41297465562820435,
-0.6799780130386353,
0.025364018976688385,
-0.6651946902275085,
-0.6389673948287964,
-0.15210218727588654,
-0.058863792568445206,
-0.2987511157989502,
-0.2980930209159851,
0.33646154403686523,
0.34898823499679565,
-0.3487619459629059,
0.48641717433929443,
-0.27640122175216675,
-0.3823755979537964,
-0.12387113273143768,
-0.016206396743655205,
0.8416746854782104,
0.2541893422603607,
-0.03216221183538437,
0.037341080605983734,
-0.7257416844367981,
0.49000486731529236,
-0.11609510332345963,
-0.30916962027549744,
-0.20278921723365784,
0.14616627991199493,
-0.479565292596817,
0.13148662447929382,
-0.03142719343304634,
-0.4559567868709564,
0.42937201261520386,
-0.6109630465507507,
0.5767314434051514,
0.8032072186470032,
-0.12991012632846832,
0.23428218066692352,
-0.35261648893356323,
0.2721588611602783,
0.36528220772743225,
0.05381788685917854,
-0.11302042007446289,
-0.5130677223205566,
-0.8907214999198914,
-0.29982855916023254,
0.2804871201515198,
0.6808656454086304,
-0.7944202423095703,
0.46190008521080017,
-0.13426347076892853,
-0.23367704451084137,
-0.532389223575592,
0.01266450248658657,
0.45500704646110535,
0.9140139818191528,
0.6220704317092896,
-0.010946838185191154,
-0.3594530522823334,
-0.8315053582191467,
-0.26927468180656433,
-0.11374752968549728,
0.0418848916888237,
0.29263028502464294,
0.2988588809967041,
-0.09076923131942749,
1.096260666847229,
-0.9420410394668579,
-0.12732984125614166,
-0.20030838251113892,
-0.1411997228860855,
0.2047482132911682,
0.38122665882110596,
0.2739870846271515,
-0.6889553070068359,
-0.24354279041290283,
-0.01281361561268568,
-0.6725581288337708,
-0.1955200731754303,
0.3040787875652313,
-0.42929160594940186,
0.13289180397987366,
0.4061623215675354,
-0.6209986209869385,
0.2756693959236145,
-0.013753854669630527,
-0.3264681398868561,
0.6400803923606873,
0.03447190672159195,
-0.07883413881063461,
-0.8409337997436523,
-0.41953322291374207,
-0.15328411757946014,
-0.14536525309085846,
-0.21029210090637207,
0.19360196590423584,
0.19025295972824097,
0.012546001933515072,
-0.2843405604362488,
0.22167116403579712,
-0.17169752717018127,
0.11546263843774796,
0.1763286292552948,
0.3191862106323242,
0.22569487988948822,
0.4540853202342987,
-0.21659356355667114,
0.43854066729545593,
0.5293421745300293,
-0.5404676795005798,
0.37405282258987427,
0.13156677782535553,
-0.4682590663433075,
0.5820146203041077,
-0.4345831871032715,
-0.18736419081687927,
-0.2606412172317505,
0.4920474886894226,
-0.687796950340271,
-0.20859158039093018,
0.2795173227787018,
-0.08004161715507507,
0.4027954638004303,
-0.2889704704284668,
-0.597106397151947,
-0.242998868227005,
-0.01616089604794979,
0.25535833835601807,
0.19298039376735687,
-0.37662994861602783,
0.809570848941803,
0.03725031018257141,
0.17873726785182953,
-0.6354575753211975,
-0.26706355810165405,
-0.2676059603691101,
0.3540782332420349,
-1.007126808166504,
0.08143418282270432,
-0.24438358843326569,
-0.06883367151021957,
0.21582749485969543,
-0.4894154965877533,
-0.09799506515264511,
0.08092629164457321,
-0.027184080332517624,
0.20909884572029114,
-0.5420984625816345,
0.26362645626068115,
0.6899610161781311,
-0.1586846113204956,
0.1652694046497345,
-0.7680341601371765,
0.32913491129875183,
-0.4698413908481598,
-0.709034264087677,
-0.20040073990821838,
0.08082868903875351,
0.557370126247406,
-0.44810882210731506,
0.6009752154350281,
0.4584968686103821,
-0.26759740710258484,
-0.41643980145454407,
-0.6325510144233704,
-0.3144190013408661,
-0.41649895906448364,
0.4597020745277405,
-0.5136099457740784,
-1.186604380607605,
0.31854042410850525,
-0.5116174221038818,
0.01571466773748398,
0.2625006139278412,
0.3170919418334961,
-0.11588305979967117,
0.9083061218261719,
0.12837766110897064,
0.26121604442596436,
0.06754284352064133,
-0.42168471217155457,
0.449339359998703,
-0.7914467453956604,
-0.40647247433662415,
-0.1282355636358261,
-0.17677387595176697,
-0.2991988956928253,
-0.3861733376979828,
0.4528823494911194,
0.2785513401031494,
-0.7742449641227722,
0.07129208743572235,
-0.5282418131828308,
0.8608793020248413,
0.6036639213562012,
0.38437700271606445,
0.4599651098251343,
-0.16170634329319,
-0.33457741141319275,
0.0367276668548584,
-1.0372624397277832,
-0.12106361985206604,
0.7144057750701904,
-0.22795899212360382,
0.6780457496643066,
0.26448506116867065,
0.3954896032810211,
-0.05490988492965698,
0.3738769590854645,
-0.8247748017311096,
0.6663274765014648,
-0.18914155662059784,
-0.6174508929252625,
-0.14829620718955994,
-0.6938956379890442,
-0.5829763412475586,
0.26790711283683777,
-0.3215894103050232,
-0.6634253859519958,
-0.3483371138572693,
0.11344961076974869,
-0.1506613790988922,
0.4485916793346405,
-0.9485834240913391,
0.8396778702735901,
-0.1575939953327179,
-0.45265573263168335,
0.007597297430038452,
-0.9306576251983643,
0.6006033420562744,
-0.06692953407764435,
0.16258111596107483,
-0.23234321177005768,
0.3301517069339752,
0.2849224805831909,
-0.5442898273468018,
0.7490077018737793,
-0.20093432068824768,
0.14125113189220428,
0.459338903427124,
0.5093691945075989,
0.5304934978485107,
-0.006470455788075924,
-0.40231311321258545,
-0.28430983424186707,
0.050353892147541046,
-0.4931688904762268,
-1.036814570426941,
0.6388944387435913,
-0.727013349533081,
-0.9345219135284424,
-0.09454764425754547,
-1.0234452486038208,
-0.4506722092628479,
0.3429245948791504,
-0.1983359456062317,
0.4260402321815491,
0.28197887539863586,
0.280110239982605,
1.065192461013794,
-0.13096070289611816,
-0.17675794661045074,
0.4286188781261444,
-0.11242792755365372,
-0.10877236723899841,
0.8768388032913208,
0.3204135596752167,
0.47748175263404846,
0.5926291942596436,
0.3531810939311981,
-0.23067273199558258,
-0.24101759493350983,
-0.6058394312858582,
0.00796791072934866,
-0.9239915013313293,
-0.5034877061843872,
-0.6968521475791931,
-0.41825345158576965,
-0.3518913686275482,
-0.367021769285202,
-0.2627856731414795,
-0.7336589097976685,
-0.004058721009641886,
-0.1860833466053009,
0.4378284215927124,
0.4138709604740143,
0.4768829941749573,
0.25251179933547974,
-0.6652175784111023,
0.10644610226154327,
0.2534911632537842,
0.35175079107284546,
0.07010763883590698,
-0.41369855403900146,
0.029362838715314865,
0.029790028929710388,
-0.43885937333106995,
-0.3854290843009949,
-0.09061073511838913,
0.24724143743515015,
0.4145263135433197,
0.31903666257858276,
0.4329914450645447,
0.7740190029144287,
-0.35139140486717224,
0.25098150968551636,
0.1313031017780304,
-0.8510745763778687,
0.6417680382728577,
-0.49514204263687134,
0.3571529984474182,
0.40494462847709656,
0.2668265700340271,
-0.16648679971694946,
-0.4423593580722809,
-0.46161365509033203,
-0.9049843549728394,
0.8964319825172424,
0.2136988490819931,
-0.13131451606750488,
0.10864299535751343,
0.4873523414134979,
-0.02492610178887844,
0.15283562242984772,
-0.5816380381584167,
-0.2925181984901428,
-0.254280149936676,
-0.5411194562911987,
0.6330670714378357,
0.04996149241924286,
-0.15430009365081787,
-0.6130273938179016,
0.7800069451332092,
-0.2416718304157257,
-0.27643999457359314,
-0.1629675179719925,
-0.13352784514427185,
0.0753781720995903,
0.3469254970550537,
0.19759465754032135,
0.6590104699134827,
-0.3083101212978363,
0.2211637645959854,
0.16845281422138214,
-0.2147216796875,
0.0062866960652172565,
0.08252247422933578,
-0.3629636764526367,
-0.5837299227714539,
0.3467821180820465,
0.6090843081474304,
0.38837766647338867,
-0.8155195713043213,
0.4267565906047821,
0.025274567306041718,
-0.17632104456424713,
0.08777204155921936,
0.6306257843971252,
0.5769587159156799,
0.37540969252586365,
0.12663468718528748,
0.2309894859790802,
-0.15331779420375824,
-0.337495893239975,
0.23345553874969482,
0.2541336715221405,
-0.29754167795181274,
0.15845096111297607,
0.6652682423591614,
0.057662732899188995,
-0.1774558424949646,
0.8444825410842896,
-0.32400259375572205,
-0.6414530277252197,
0.7173165082931519,
0.8628981709480286,
0.20665858685970306,
-0.005297164898365736,
0.06006595864892006,
0.463293194770813,
0.45264357328414917,
0.05830284208059311,
0.2562702000141144,
-0.04128820821642876,
-0.8520659804344177,
-0.45528826117515564,
-0.6707538962364197,
-0.46962252259254456,
-0.31327593326568604,
-0.4492330551147461,
0.35156306624412537,
-0.6186447739601135,
0.22506728768348694,
-0.061517369002103806,
-0.08870738744735718,
-0.4450286626815796,
0.325529545545578,
-0.3222862184047699,
0.8556101322174072,
-0.4822283983230591,
0.9025340676307678,
0.6872341632843018,
-0.36193233728408813,
-1.2209113836288452,
-0.3714427649974823,
-0.06752192229032516,
-0.7090125679969788,
0.7944819927215576,
0.19281549751758575,
-0.4738130271434784,
0.19356586039066315,
-0.4453548789024353,
-0.5971631407737732,
1.235350251197815,
0.7158107757568359,
-0.7080541253089905,
0.11963272094726562,
0.09952528029680252,
0.3606417775154114,
-0.4899791181087494,
0.2853483557701111,
0.5006459951400757,
0.5032449960708618,
0.51014643907547,
-0.24385471642017365,
0.06156769394874573,
-0.029211120679974556,
-0.373462975025177,
0.367120623588562,
-0.6748824119567871,
0.7465358972549438,
-0.445817232131958,
0.07835543155670166,
-0.3139526844024658,
0.5411689877510071,
0.5068774819374084,
0.5928711295127869,
0.5715556740760803,
0.7956300973892212,
0.9119868278503418,
-0.36443907022476196,
0.6858566999435425,
-0.4434927999973297,
0.38535863161087036,
1.3022875785827637,
-0.3812639117240906,
0.46688586473464966,
0.1661280244588852,
-0.061225298792123795,
0.5103680491447449,
0.6266904473304749,
0.3009379208087921,
0.22978346049785614,
0.4593963921070099,
-0.3972479999065399,
-0.753307580947876,
-0.032501012086868286,
-0.4398361146450043,
0.33330410718917847,
0.7828622460365295,
-0.13437582552433014,
-0.4404864013195038,
-0.2592279314994812,
0.05765848606824875,
0.05265779793262482,
-0.3871425986289978,
0.42213523387908936,
0.060486651957035065,
-0.6315348148345947,
0.4910969138145447,
-0.013618472963571548,
0.13541677594184875,
-0.6661293506622314,
-0.22316548228263855,
-0.10064534842967987,
0.2431769222021103,
-0.3866139054298401,
-0.8016108870506287,
0.20828230679035187,
-0.2857600748538971,
-0.24094030261039734,
0.08288342505693436,
0.7240870594978333,
-0.4235708713531494,
-0.656572699546814,
0.426330029964447,
0.6239703893661499,
-0.2697336971759796,
0.09612830728292465,
-0.6812248826026917,
-0.09415696561336517,
0.05904374644160271,
-0.26509130001068115,
0.2533620595932007,
0.9958153963088989,
-0.2142280638217926,
0.8525103330612183,
0.7480567693710327,
-0.262605220079422,
0.037415146827697754,
0.1725853681564331,
1.163831114768982,
-0.4000403881072998,
-0.07177790999412537,
-0.5868882536888123,
0.24976809322834015,
0.03195476531982422,
0.003680389141663909,
0.30306196212768555,
0.7070944905281067,
1.0657364130020142,
-0.06264840066432953,
0.5774717330932617,
-0.14853303134441376,
0.2816838324069977,
-0.6728535294532776,
0.6058985590934753,
-0.4591578245162964,
0.5922255516052246,
-0.2027767449617386,
-0.9682623744010925,
-0.7000153660774231,
0.6527636647224426,
-0.3951123356819153,
-0.11446703225374222,
0.6691940426826477,
1.018127679824829,
-0.42733684182167053,
0.31071582436561584,
0.272436261177063,
0.3961692154407501,
0.3155785799026489,
0.7151416540145874,
0.6676661372184753,
-0.20558063685894012,
0.4752613306045532,
-0.15125145018100739,
-0.16864553093910217,
-0.15046553313732147,
-0.815410315990448,
-0.6502205729484558,
-0.19272741675376892,
-0.2009367048740387,
-0.4299244284629822,
0.3565616309642792,
1.1562585830688477,
0.48785650730133057,
-0.6540442109107971,
0.0759921446442604,
-0.06078394874930382,
0.6279234886169434,
-0.09768877178430557,
-0.24045227468013763,
0.6577529311180115,
-0.3320198655128479,
-0.3880998492240906,
0.1339346468448639,
0.44733619689941406,
-0.5476815104484558,
0.13706502318382263,
0.004904476460069418,
-0.32469308376312256,
0.060781434178352356,
1.11293363571167,
-0.05687941610813141,
-0.6074181795120239,
-0.6051972508430481,
0.037021420896053314,
0.056625816971063614,
-0.00939994677901268,
0.7705327272415161,
-0.6774460673332214,
0.6154505014419556,
0.260647177696228,
0.8947044014930725,
0.5874450206756592,
-0.08504047989845276,
0.09189926087856293,
-0.6309573650360107,
-0.10656898468732834,
0.42551276087760925,
0.4440594017505646,
0.12174864113330841,
-0.2320028394460678,
0.652851402759552,
0.5582392811775208,
-0.3362279236316681,
-0.558846652507782,
0.6234133243560791,
-1.2698465585708618,
-0.27684301137924194,
0.7953884601593018,
-0.2891045808792114,
-0.21514970064163208,
-0.31177735328674316,
-0.28747594356536865,
0.3621087670326233,
-0.2821004092693329,
0.7069658637046814,
0.6798962354660034,
-0.4455495774745941,
0.13062387704849243,
-0.5113059878349304,
-0.10590635240077972,
0.40462741255760193,
-0.7458071112632751,
0.10027561336755753,
0.7203371524810791,
0.38897010684013367,
-0.1891053020954132,
0.520183801651001,
-0.09557149559259415,
0.2129313051700592,
-0.3135850727558136,
-0.26373037695884705,
-0.3784487843513489,
-0.3946183919906616,
0.6501086354255676,
0.3345322608947754,
-0.07945428788661957,
0.40329495072364807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01535v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01535v1
|
Prometheus 2: An Open Source Language Model Specialized in Evaluating Other Language Models
| 2024-05-02T17:59:35 | 2024-05-02T17:59:35 |
Seungone Kim, Juyoung Suk, Shayne Longpre, Bill Yuchen Lin, Jamin Shin, Sean Welleck, Graham Neubig, Moontae Lee, Kyungjae Lee, Minjoon Seo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Proprietary LMs such as GPT-4 are often employed to assess the quality of
responses from various LMs. However, concerns including transparency,
controllability, and affordability strongly motivate the development of
open-source LMs specialized in evaluations. On the other hand, existing open
evaluator LMs exhibit critical shortcomings: 1) they issue scores that
significantly diverge from those assigned by humans, and 2) they lack the
flexibility to perform both direct assessment and pairwise ranking, the two
most prevalent forms of assessment. Additionally, they do not possess the
ability to evaluate based on custom evaluation criteria, focusing instead on
general attributes like helpfulness and harmlessness. To address these issues,
we introduce Prometheus 2, a more powerful evaluator LM than its predecessor
that closely mirrors human and GPT-4 judgements. Moreover, it is capable of
processing both direct assessment and pair-wise ranking formats grouped with a
user-defined evaluation criteria. On four direct assessment benchmarks and four
pairwise ranking benchmarks, Prometheus 2 scores the highest correlation and
agreement with humans and proprietary LM judges among all tested open evaluator
LMs. Our models, code, and data are all publicly available at
https://github.com/prometheus-eval/prometheus-eval.
|
[
-0.24068967998027802,
-0.5630570650100708,
0.6716516017913818,
0.07876474410295486,
-0.19783060252666473,
0.09124265611171722,
-0.4104333221912384,
-0.6958739757537842,
-0.07446330785751343,
0.4479970633983612,
-0.09625192731618881,
-0.3679482638835907,
-0.47810104489326477,
0.012924646958708763,
-0.13712787628173828,
0.8884645700454712,
0.055626917630434036,
0.0694955438375473,
-0.22221402823925018,
-0.6828286647796631,
-0.44715437293052673,
-0.35954293608665466,
-0.6637877225875854,
-0.4846413731575012,
0.6715547442436218,
0.35736191272735596,
1.3055734634399414,
0.3116777837276459,
0.7519834637641907,
0.28520166873931885,
0.010906185023486614,
0.11078571528196335,
-0.5650435090065002,
-0.12184268236160278,
-0.6862654089927673,
-0.2886684834957123,
-0.6259539127349854,
0.39023107290267944,
0.5841773748397827,
0.3750341236591339,
0.025934647768735886,
0.37499168515205383,
0.19768953323364258,
0.6514497399330139,
-0.5136814713478088,
0.09044286608695984,
-0.42266276478767395,
-0.04551979526877403,
-0.2240544706583023,
-0.057679399847984314,
-0.344212144613266,
-0.8519197702407837,
0.23172324895858765,
-0.4584270417690277,
-0.21701876819133759,
-0.10275467485189438,
0.5159543752670288,
0.19556891918182373,
-0.15722133219242096,
-0.19437330961227417,
-0.7931301593780518,
1.039338231086731,
-0.7435500025749207,
0.5568678379058838,
0.538068950176239,
0.5102634429931641,
0.12416688352823257,
-0.9719485640525818,
-0.37649089097976685,
-0.6540005207061768,
0.015648405998945236,
0.31817626953125,
-0.3518090844154358,
-0.1973331719636917,
-0.23489513993263245,
0.4510383605957031,
-0.7550457715988159,
0.59243243932724,
-0.5984859466552734,
-0.2115103304386139,
0.4551873803138733,
0.055703043937683105,
0.21932843327522278,
-0.11256318539381027,
-0.33258911967277527,
-0.04456247016787529,
-0.6313299536705017,
0.18638505041599274,
0.4897539019584656,
0.30697837471961975,
-0.17428340017795563,
0.4993411898612976,
0.1349906474351883,
0.20352795720100403,
-0.28117725253105164,
0.2518092691898346,
0.5528795123100281,
-0.1657370775938034,
-0.060925278812646866,
-0.3390448987483978,
1.0688061714172363,
0.6343264579772949,
-0.12540122866630554,
-0.1972731500864029,
-0.33761322498321533,
0.2508114278316498,
0.4788477420806885,
-0.6477289795875549,
-0.12580570578575134,
0.594054102897644,
-0.5860604643821716,
-0.41863465309143066,
-0.004360350780189037,
-0.7314940094947815,
-0.6083260774612427,
-0.21072573959827423,
0.5852578282356262,
-0.3799234926700592,
-0.5451898574829102,
0.0019192324252799153,
0.02931474894285202,
0.1541321575641632,
0.3453902304172516,
-0.6238518953323364,
0.6864951252937317,
1.0183700323104858,
1.0723589658737183,
-0.34504973888397217,
-0.23183976113796234,
-0.8088148236274719,
-0.43984177708625793,
-0.42091652750968933,
0.6736547350883484,
-0.6592726707458496,
-0.4046606719493866,
-0.06991135329008102,
-0.19701077044010162,
0.268236368894577,
-0.5492631793022156,
1.0556923151016235,
-0.421913743019104,
0.49998509883880615,
-0.2890113592147827,
-0.5968424677848816,
-0.15222913026809692,
0.09655619412660599,
-0.7923259735107422,
1.039644718170166,
0.5013344287872314,
-0.8331953883171082,
0.031213359907269478,
-0.8921922445297241,
0.08269355446100235,
0.532106339931488,
-0.39599910378456116,
-0.3849045932292938,
0.07664287835359573,
-0.2796333432197571,
-0.0779193565249443,
-0.6166951656341553,
0.004251937381923199,
-0.4392795264720917,
-0.525709867477417,
0.1519179493188858,
-0.01341482438147068,
0.5396722555160522,
0.41997602581977844,
-0.32760265469551086,
0.4606691598892212,
-0.43244248628616333,
0.3225407600402832,
0.17882739007472992,
-0.23665323853492737,
-0.45135506987571716,
0.09612222760915756,
0.06180226057767868,
0.086210697889328,
0.3939046859741211,
-0.5317527055740356,
-0.08985712379217148,
-0.5681259036064148,
0.3783920109272003,
0.8023453950881958,
-0.4180903434753418,
0.5154241919517517,
-0.4495665431022644,
0.515072762966156,
-0.4212242662906647,
0.2877557575702667,
0.14471760392189026,
-0.6138303875923157,
-0.43660494685173035,
0.0024385706055909395,
0.17323115468025208,
0.5815846920013428,
-0.31482911109924316,
0.378540962934494,
-0.10930611193180084,
-0.9262195825576782,
-0.6193774342536926,
0.19317109882831573,
0.6748167872428894,
0.28894659876823425,
0.2841859459877014,
-0.41823115944862366,
-0.5335099697113037,
-0.984282910823822,
-0.5131978988647461,
-0.4395354688167572,
-0.1433066874742508,
0.3408139944076538,
0.2812737822532654,
-0.32141900062561035,
0.9803327322006226,
-0.13962937891483307,
-0.25701043009757996,
-0.3849470615386963,
0.04040955752134323,
0.37412917613983154,
0.48095703125,
0.6089597344398499,
-0.6637191772460938,
-0.13444675505161285,
0.24706728756427765,
-0.7345336675643921,
-0.1379794031381607,
0.40496644377708435,
0.020871175453066826,
-0.14156626164913177,
0.02832264080643654,
-0.4633580148220062,
-0.19637523591518402,
0.6509907245635986,
-0.48478788137435913,
0.6945408582687378,
-0.4400160014629364,
0.16023005545139313,
-0.9100277423858643,
0.23419825732707977,
0.13083113729953766,
-0.32826799154281616,
-0.5637151598930359,
0.41931289434432983,
0.2963183522224426,
0.05656296759843826,
-0.6455519795417786,
0.5921943783760071,
0.05920121818780899,
-0.18030987679958344,
-0.2649041712284088,
0.4255202114582062,
-0.09477519989013672,
0.18718567490577698,
-0.12264926731586456,
0.6705621480941772,
0.31982484459877014,
-0.5606517791748047,
0.5293972492218018,
0.36791279911994934,
-0.33780133724212646,
0.4463030695915222,
-0.9002273678779602,
0.6458877921104431,
0.0006988994427956641,
-0.07808247208595276,
-0.6547643542289734,
-0.07957994192838669,
0.27722564339637756,
-0.4990803897380829,
-0.1370534598827362,
-0.021162671968340874,
-0.4632117450237274,
-0.43082669377326965,
-0.8719914555549622,
0.22838683426380157,
0.8677406907081604,
-0.5493189692497253,
0.1804933249950409,
0.45315995812416077,
-0.22199802100658417,
-0.31813758611679077,
-0.534505307674408,
-0.05021432787179947,
-0.39111948013305664,
-0.5052902102470398,
0.1167982742190361,
-0.1984396129846573,
-0.5730727314949036,
-0.03628766909241676,
-0.11278107017278671,
0.02774168737232685,
0.20867910981178284,
0.23607037961483002,
0.3382084369659424,
-0.19896124303340912,
0.020653337240219116,
-0.13487718999385834,
-0.31834784150123596,
0.05654945224523544,
-0.3051379323005676,
0.3363576829433441,
-0.5397447347640991,
-0.42248427867889404,
-0.4249507188796997,
-0.02156512439250946,
0.7201830744743347,
-0.3758450746536255,
0.3036963939666748,
0.6738462448120117,
-0.43811315298080444,
0.08982329070568085,
-0.436521053314209,
-0.03180362656712532,
-0.49612748622894287,
0.46137580275535583,
-0.27190089225769043,
-0.9198349714279175,
0.30485445261001587,
0.009772415272891521,
0.48918142914772034,
0.42554739117622375,
0.6193740963935852,
0.09855223447084427,
0.7849107384681702,
0.4152154326438904,
-0.02724921703338623,
0.19119179248809814,
0.04009728506207466,
0.02615283615887165,
-0.8845394849777222,
-0.2702752351760864,
-0.6734788417816162,
-0.18750126659870148,
-0.7013551592826843,
-0.3476922810077667,
0.44277238845825195,
0.022784681990742683,
-0.18017306923866272,
0.49942100048065186,
-0.38904082775115967,
0.48384299874305725,
0.6267068386077881,
0.06076458469033241,
0.20624110102653503,
-0.1080474853515625,
-0.23540522158145905,
-0.26847347617149353,
-0.09495282173156738,
-1.011926293373108,
1.1096324920654297,
0.890131413936615,
0.6829124093055725,
0.5304439067840576,
0.5091004967689514,
0.5944482088088989,
0.21666909754276276,
-0.6332551836967468,
0.4979625642299652,
-0.21143962442874908,
-0.32627272605895996,
-0.3076125979423523,
-0.5198686122894287,
-0.8927464485168457,
0.4836418628692627,
0.05052858591079712,
-1.0669866800308228,
-0.2885224223136902,
-0.03173251450061798,
-0.4862428903579712,
0.15843693912029266,
-0.5783689022064209,
0.9554983377456665,
-0.25879791378974915,
-0.7834020853042603,
-0.46954435110092163,
-0.42068326473236084,
0.2691628336906433,
-0.4169640839099884,
0.5255273580551147,
-0.2154294103384018,
-0.09599075466394424,
0.7870213389396667,
-0.5239557027816772,
0.5616085529327393,
-0.13582779467105865,
-0.27244868874549866,
0.3041256368160248,
0.3367885649204254,
0.5054043531417847,
0.21146981418132782,
-0.4064367115497589,
0.11079031974077225,
0.0837327316403389,
-0.19941353797912598,
-0.6232755184173584,
1.0451101064682007,
-0.9257915019989014,
-0.49735116958618164,
-0.24712948501110077,
-0.27535688877105713,
-0.3092472553253174,
0.17983734607696533,
0.17464610934257507,
0.39815500378608704,
-0.33478498458862305,
0.04487118870019913,
0.2586495578289032,
-0.46385228633880615,
0.1936347633600235,
0.7058040499687195,
-0.5354068279266357,
-0.6489930748939514,
0.8493798971176147,
-0.2539282739162445,
0.0891546979546547,
0.13751666247844696,
0.5760781764984131,
-0.6420205235481262,
-0.5109666585922241,
-0.4404251277446747,
0.09218721836805344,
-0.6751513481140137,
0.04435836523771286,
-0.41813924908638,
0.01554742269217968,
-0.1920408308506012,
0.11805127561092377,
-0.6231964826583862,
-0.5984746217727661,
0.06890986859798431,
-0.2826569676399231,
0.21596211194992065,
0.9912800192832947,
-0.2036118060350418,
-0.055643677711486816,
-0.9123599529266357,
0.36935630440711975,
0.2082316130399704,
0.6051573157310486,
-0.45594504475593567,
-0.5763123631477356,
-0.1177038699388504,
-0.05183732509613037,
-0.4967595040798187,
-0.7795066833496094,
0.04215950891375542,
0.006296222563832998,
0.5507127046585083,
0.5057563185691833,
0.04398017004132271,
0.2574768662452698,
-0.4177338182926178,
1.0311236381530762,
0.3848508298397064,
-0.9877395629882812,
0.5264074206352234,
-0.24155886471271515,
0.11984643340110779,
0.5572035312652588,
0.1492038518190384,
-0.5272483229637146,
-0.6530171036720276,
-0.3718499541282654,
-0.5456302165985107,
0.9374717473983765,
0.721156120300293,
0.19059985876083374,
0.15000532567501068,
0.27473536133766174,
0.5282094478607178,
0.053160540759563446,
-0.731341540813446,
-0.17472413182258606,
-0.19157597422599792,
-0.09695683419704437,
-0.22462111711502075,
-0.2502111494541168,
0.06192513182759285,
-0.04433262348175049,
0.620252251625061,
0.1695307195186615,
-0.031763955950737,
0.06303528696298599,
-0.04073445498943329,
-0.23200573027133942,
0.5112663507461548,
0.30323371291160583,
0.7463032007217407,
-0.28922563791275024,
0.44156593084335327,
0.22072285413742065,
-0.4212799072265625,
0.06683845818042755,
0.2220451682806015,
-0.12210194021463394,
0.12314505130052567,
0.2700466215610504,
0.6741450428962708,
0.22029559314250946,
-0.741347074508667,
0.5137434601783752,
-0.05726692080497742,
-0.051998790353536606,
-0.3388950526714325,
0.11968633532524109,
0.005274609196931124,
0.4247085750102997,
0.16593211889266968,
0.01567319594323635,
0.2805626392364502,
-0.41362321376800537,
0.12783485651016235,
0.2823900878429413,
-0.5102773904800415,
-0.6645075082778931,
0.933570384979248,
0.41735419631004333,
-0.40915563702583313,
0.3643626272678375,
-0.3877604901790619,
-0.33434727787971497,
0.3563705086708069,
0.3323657214641571,
0.9325872659683228,
-0.5890424251556396,
0.31935444474220276,
0.4539434015750885,
0.5426356196403503,
-0.13545945286750793,
0.41355186700820923,
0.05017056688666344,
-0.4560997784137726,
-0.10041643679141998,
-0.6318288445472717,
-0.7805683612823486,
0.5290756821632385,
-0.5636113286018372,
0.37805184721946716,
-0.37892115116119385,
-0.44741758704185486,
-0.029682911932468414,
-0.00972078274935484,
-0.5395081639289856,
-0.12836742401123047,
0.23653724789619446,
0.9391410946846008,
-0.5091668963432312,
0.6437556147575378,
0.9946568608283997,
-0.5456563830375671,
-0.6081250905990601,
-0.3823086619377136,
-0.0649501234292984,
-0.41238442063331604,
0.4729468822479248,
0.3778018355369568,
-0.22842811048030853,
-0.21111920475959778,
-0.1254720538854599,
-0.6781057119369507,
1.0080318450927734,
0.6478636264801025,
-0.6738023161888123,
-0.030872968956828117,
0.4519466459751129,
0.5259483456611633,
0.10910366475582123,
0.6593354344367981,
0.6649615168571472,
0.6610246300697327,
-0.3815231919288635,
-1.5234187841415405,
0.1605520248413086,
-0.3547822833061218,
-0.023209549486637115,
0.044158365577459335,
-0.6610614061355591,
0.7047024369239807,
-0.35880908370018005,
-0.1843203902244568,
0.4230564832687378,
0.4427918493747711,
0.2491316944360733,
0.5284963250160217,
0.38394251465797424,
0.5069546699523926,
0.8295360803604126,
-0.016530977562069893,
1.0017104148864746,
-0.21085156500339508,
0.6470907926559448,
1.198026418685913,
-0.4930019676685333,
0.8530526757240295,
0.1919565051794052,
-0.4580170810222626,
0.45614510774612427,
0.5291184186935425,
0.05153092369437218,
0.4907763600349426,
0.044450707733631134,
-0.18564824759960175,
-0.02468084543943405,
0.08987371623516083,
-0.3034863770008087,
0.24818100035190582,
0.11402548849582672,
-0.37699320912361145,
-0.36921998858451843,
-0.21753741800785065,
-0.07864267379045486,
0.26748451590538025,
-0.21414391696453094,
0.5203284025192261,
0.29689857363700867,
-0.6935606002807617,
0.45361804962158203,
0.3515956997871399,
0.3864683508872986,
-0.6677850484848022,
0.0727890133857727,
-0.18852658569812775,
0.35618504881858826,
-0.34307152032852173,
-0.8351954221725464,
0.26068422198295593,
0.22921031713485718,
0.3510158360004425,
0.059149764478206635,
0.6761486530303955,
-0.012733938172459602,
-0.09651024639606476,
0.5296695828437805,
0.6423832178115845,
0.3796917796134949,
-0.04998002573847771,
-0.6873155832290649,
0.2961907982826233,
-0.28832313418388367,
-0.32578006386756897,
0.03375495597720146,
-0.1321820765733719,
-0.08511904627084732,
0.6549480557441711,
0.6146334409713745,
-0.15958872437477112,
-0.30679842829704285,
0.29004716873168945,
0.7302935123443604,
-0.5435683131217957,
-0.6404613256454468,
-1.0061442852020264,
0.25401198863983154,
0.06719987094402313,
-0.2465040236711502,
0.8112677335739136,
0.8665317296981812,
0.5473735928535461,
-0.010931561700999737,
0.9756244421005249,
0.15773865580558777,
0.6110035181045532,
-0.35115453600883484,
0.5888988971710205,
-0.35327884554862976,
0.2661578953266144,
-0.36311614513397217,
-1.1140564680099487,
-0.10600496828556061,
0.4936780035495758,
-0.25158947706222534,
0.008270340040326118,
0.6957594752311707,
0.5166218876838684,
-0.1505008488893509,
0.17092490196228027,
0.49485453963279724,
0.2538018226623535,
0.44883599877357483,
0.5976726412773132,
1.2290804386138916,
-0.12985427677631378,
0.4873480200767517,
-0.023975064978003502,
-0.41446539759635925,
-0.15849250555038452,
-0.601511538028717,
-0.9309055209159851,
-0.48541688919067383,
-0.3675934970378876,
-0.37427347898483276,
0.11820272356271744,
1.1643116474151611,
0.5459702014923096,
-0.6623536944389343,
-0.18908371031284332,
-0.2711389660835266,
-0.08748535811901093,
-0.15899676084518433,
-0.2214038074016571,
0.32302147150039673,
-0.278922438621521,
-0.9009647965431213,
0.689112663269043,
0.41154950857162476,
-0.15220539271831512,
-0.5138722658157349,
-0.5694354772567749,
0.6659795045852661,
0.1588716059923172,
0.5412043333053589,
0.218161478638649,
-0.8010709285736084,
-0.33425164222717285,
-0.287669837474823,
-0.178086057305336,
0.011737839318811893,
0.6869692206382751,
-0.86174076795578,
0.36931198835372925,
0.3671858310699463,
0.35234948992729187,
0.01807985082268715,
-0.15736445784568787,
0.5493803024291992,
-0.19492508471012115,
-0.0032202396541833878,
0.3683626651763916,
0.4852744936943054,
0.3862195312976837,
-0.10195257514715195,
0.6571680903434753,
-0.10542667657136917,
-0.6009784936904907,
-0.8017330765724182,
0.3674987256526947,
-1.0118650197982788,
-0.03786657005548477,
1.3624587059020996,
-0.302232950925827,
0.07500211894512177,
-0.0103378314524889,
-0.32870253920555115,
0.0250452421605587,
-0.4490887224674225,
0.6002551317214966,
0.30260276794433594,
-0.019527174532413483,
0.09555235505104065,
-0.6749281883239746,
0.30652034282684326,
0.39859625697135925,
-0.830747663974762,
-0.08345969021320343,
0.3973941206932068,
0.5384517312049866,
0.33345362544059753,
0.6526402831077576,
-0.4849681258201599,
0.516863226890564,
-0.2435229867696762,
-0.11203602701425552,
-0.20824970304965973,
0.09922277182340622,
-0.415779709815979,
0.2790687084197998,
0.5377691388130188,
-0.3225574493408203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01525v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01525v1
|
FLAME: Factuality-Aware Alignment for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-02T17:54:54 | 2024-05-02T17:54:54 |
Sheng-Chieh Lin, Luyu Gao, Barlas Oguz, Wenhan Xiong, Jimmy Lin, Wen-tau Yih, Xilun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Alignment is a standard procedure to fine-tune pre-trained large language
models (LLMs) to follow natural language instructions and serve as helpful AI
assistants. We have observed, however, that the conventional alignment process
fails to enhance the factual accuracy of LLMs, and often leads to the
generation of more false facts (i.e. hallucination). In this paper, we study
how to make the LLM alignment process more factual, by first identifying
factors that lead to hallucination in both alignment steps:\ supervised
fine-tuning (SFT) and reinforcement learning (RL). In particular, we find that
training the LLM on new knowledge or unfamiliar texts can encourage
hallucination. This makes SFT less factual as it trains on human labeled data
that may be novel to the LLM. Furthermore, reward functions used in standard RL
can also encourage hallucination, because it guides the LLM to provide more
helpful responses on a diverse set of instructions, often preferring longer and
more detailed responses. Based on these observations, we propose
factuality-aware alignment, comprised of factuality-aware SFT and
factuality-aware RL through direct preference optimization. Experiments show
that our proposed factuality-aware alignment guides LLMs to output more factual
responses while maintaining instruction-following capability.
|
[
-0.24912592768669128,
-0.8821367621421814,
0.8077700138092041,
0.13063693046569824,
-0.08134950697422028,
0.05253610759973526,
-0.5130762457847595,
-0.3593238592147827,
0.19880078732967377,
0.6672715544700623,
-0.583498477935791,
-0.47732675075531006,
-0.45255497097969055,
0.07016169279813766,
-0.25390753149986267,
1.4213550090789795,
-0.043383464217185974,
-0.2260141670703888,
-0.4467853605747223,
-0.20464535057544708,
-0.7663417458534241,
-0.33745577931404114,
-0.4238036870956421,
-0.22243325412273407,
0.7589901089668274,
0.541135847568512,
0.9270743727684021,
1.0405744314193726,
0.5810582637786865,
0.3388115167617798,
0.1512550711631775,
0.4022592008113861,
-0.7809526324272156,
0.18180006742477417,
-0.3137405812740326,
-0.4046861231327057,
-0.40279141068458557,
0.004218831192702055,
0.48056352138519287,
0.29689207673072815,
-0.12628737092018127,
0.033197224140167236,
-0.0593169704079628,
0.843207061290741,
-0.5866903066635132,
0.022782525047659874,
-0.7689388990402222,
0.015785181894898415,
0.05188259854912758,
-0.4115423262119293,
-0.5790839791297913,
-0.7708536386489868,
0.1545255035161972,
-0.7327473163604736,
0.35644039511680603,
0.20741711556911469,
0.8814873099327087,
0.7791102528572083,
-0.46491965651512146,
-0.49103856086730957,
-1.0161147117614746,
0.5743507146835327,
-0.6213781237602234,
0.6457235813140869,
0.08530741184949875,
0.18978199362754822,
-0.05096561834216118,
-0.2639785706996918,
-0.7392024397850037,
-0.3429887890815735,
-0.34578749537467957,
-0.01635058969259262,
0.35513004660606384,
0.22020697593688965,
0.4326423704624176,
0.11926251649856567,
-0.8271303772926331,
0.2020879089832306,
-0.14337123930454254,
-0.38780710101127625,
0.7169974446296692,
0.11272181570529938,
0.14232046902179718,
0.08822868019342422,
-0.3855096995830536,
-0.14721772074699402,
-0.665352463722229,
-0.15522123873233795,
0.32735028862953186,
0.37331387400627136,
0.030595550313591957,
0.7309970855712891,
-0.20770826935768127,
0.7609874606132507,
0.44636064767837524,
-0.3702225685119629,
0.1568560153245926,
-0.32893189787864685,
-0.22700852155685425,
0.6947852373123169,
0.5340550541877747,
0.27708861231803894,
0.162667915225029,
-0.3041422665119171,
-0.20375213027000427,
0.2742111384868622,
0.4628244936466217,
-0.8238523006439209,
-0.17207345366477966,
0.3754052519798279,
-0.07830897718667984,
-0.46019473671913147,
0.008829130791127682,
-0.5682824850082397,
-0.703152060508728,
-0.8679527044296265,
0.5667961835861206,
-0.5201672911643982,
-0.08366761356592178,
0.22230175137519836,
0.24187220633029938,
0.27398481965065,
0.44682323932647705,
-1.1039711236953735,
0.09073138236999512,
0.9694094657897949,
0.5314565896987915,
-0.20059478282928467,
-0.23446868360042572,
-0.8482757806777954,
0.20488066971302032,
-0.3834506869316101,
0.7230806350708008,
-0.539203405380249,
0.09735524654388428,
-0.021737584844231606,
-0.12401367723941803,
-0.1268661767244339,
-0.424863338470459,
0.7932556867599487,
-0.6642773151397705,
0.4066220223903656,
-0.6766766905784607,
-0.792456328868866,
-0.32839590311050415,
0.283814013004303,
-0.5344680547714233,
0.8710273504257202,
-0.3408954441547394,
-0.9062709808349609,
0.5784546732902527,
-0.2880922257900238,
-0.4658372700214386,
-0.3245846927165985,
-0.39137738943099976,
-0.5148919820785522,
0.11190205067396164,
0.15951138734817505,
0.4960373044013977,
0.043931979686021805,
0.6881366968154907,
-0.18223978579044342,
-0.4856420159339905,
0.17847244441509247,
-0.43679362535476685,
0.5393450260162354,
0.0625806599855423,
-0.6023651361465454,
0.5922815799713135,
-0.7634943127632141,
-0.32506853342056274,
-0.21107949316501617,
-0.319818913936615,
-0.12635013461112976,
0.21070000529289246,
-0.3054381310939789,
0.21911750733852386,
0.29577675461769104,
-0.31623271107673645,
0.3850122094154358,
-0.4195385277271271,
-0.28797808289527893,
0.971915066242218,
-0.19839094579219818,
0.4286809265613556,
-0.43102002143859863,
0.18235214054584503,
-0.1803312450647354,
-0.0961640253663063,
0.2770845592021942,
0.04151026904582977,
-1.0403531789779663,
-0.3144821226596832,
0.14429035782814026,
0.708628237247467,
-0.6084823608398438,
0.8322322964668274,
-0.3785846531391144,
-0.41591471433639526,
-0.5666635632514954,
0.21636071801185608,
0.3392021656036377,
0.8745695352554321,
0.2670884430408478,
0.06096759811043739,
-0.6843764781951904,
-0.8693690299987793,
-0.1562437266111374,
-0.23800183832645416,
0.40695247054100037,
0.048048995435237885,
0.3188076913356781,
-0.23336417973041534,
0.8756260275840759,
-0.552570641040802,
-0.2370554655790329,
0.043889258056879044,
0.15829429030418396,
0.0035333617124706507,
0.3762579560279846,
0.2626895606517792,
-0.8486199975013733,
-0.4686046242713928,
0.28844401240348816,
-0.8361650705337524,
-0.009057164192199707,
-0.45398959517478943,
-0.23760360479354858,
0.4669992923736572,
0.5411393642425537,
-0.6710191965103149,
0.22424913942813873,
0.37412330508232117,
-0.3866731822490692,
0.6290935277938843,
-0.19807514548301697,
0.28288882970809937,
-0.8396834135055542,
0.0034793212544173002,
-0.10913721472024918,
-0.25891321897506714,
-0.5230433344841003,
-0.11876064538955688,
-0.0016304139280691743,
0.22640427947044373,
-0.09527873992919922,
0.392829567193985,
-0.23932166397571564,
-0.026529379189014435,
-0.2838882803916931,
0.21985836327075958,
-0.13325044512748718,
0.5351920127868652,
0.4239182472229004,
0.7979037761688232,
0.4274844825267792,
-0.6663132905960083,
0.5036145448684692,
0.28468453884124756,
-0.2774481773376465,
0.47172126173973083,
-0.3794448971748352,
-0.0019950992427766323,
-0.24537691473960876,
0.12291953712701797,
-0.8872353434562683,
-0.3915722370147705,
0.19554133713245392,
-0.28207382559776306,
0.44520050287246704,
0.2750498950481415,
-0.43079930543899536,
0.11859674751758575,
-0.19765879213809967,
0.21305586397647858,
0.4147893190383911,
-0.6829220056533813,
0.5798064470291138,
-0.07334449887275696,
0.03630521893501282,
-0.8627758026123047,
-0.22335082292556763,
-0.2095864713191986,
-0.37119337916374207,
-0.6501902341842651,
0.1933363527059555,
-0.1472150981426239,
-0.17582440376281738,
-0.012706979177892208,
-0.2770783007144928,
0.3135696053504944,
0.05074922740459442,
0.09691982716321945,
0.43944239616394043,
-0.32799676060676575,
0.31734856963157654,
-0.11706654727458954,
-0.03005760721862316,
0.08792618662118912,
-0.1735919713973999,
0.4495818018913269,
-0.07962056994438171,
-0.3985365331172943,
-0.6168951988220215,
-0.023761289194226265,
0.5529924035072327,
-0.22837397456169128,
0.977293848991394,
0.6902188658714294,
-0.2248414307832718,
0.045712076127529144,
-0.9754828810691833,
-0.38397154211997986,
-0.47851353883743286,
0.29804882407188416,
-0.019468557089567184,
-0.9817414283752441,
0.32118743658065796,
0.04309144988656044,
0.2749955654144287,
0.3109315037727356,
0.5912365317344666,
-0.10047712922096252,
1.045528531074524,
0.6229782700538635,
-0.05957217141985893,
0.34322598576545715,
0.2570416033267975,
0.42384669184684753,
-0.5932756066322327,
-0.3047085106372833,
-0.46887731552124023,
-0.30740901827812195,
-0.6996486783027649,
-0.38785192370414734,
0.15559165179729462,
-0.11374688893556595,
-0.33076202869415283,
0.23810230195522308,
-0.590517520904541,
0.5357570648193359,
0.2690093517303467,
0.06367351859807968,
0.31926941871643066,
-0.01113959588110447,
-0.07209695130586624,
-0.1553584188222885,
-0.5113217830657959,
-0.5096147656440735,
0.7682382464408875,
0.20089691877365112,
0.7491033673286438,
0.1044502705335617,
0.8051312565803528,
0.058853961527347565,
0.2766781449317932,
-0.7597785592079163,
0.4491971433162689,
0.1286412924528122,
-0.7178387641906738,
-0.4944630265235901,
-0.49217185378074646,
-0.5036352872848511,
0.028539692983031273,
-0.5113839507102966,
-0.5848792195320129,
0.03990703821182251,
0.3444254696369171,
-0.44143491983413696,
0.15160147845745087,
-0.5708326697349548,
0.8731855750083923,
-0.5121395587921143,
-0.47970297932624817,
-0.2903861105442047,
-0.6428176164627075,
0.5972724556922913,
-0.13652046024799347,
0.14253643155097961,
-0.033804751932621,
0.19591103494167328,
0.5325299501419067,
-0.17831195890903473,
0.8360303044319153,
-0.061251118779182434,
-0.3055225908756256,
-0.0428709015250206,
0.13152171671390533,
0.9213395714759827,
0.016317522153258324,
-0.01063739974051714,
-0.4928165078163147,
-0.25562676787376404,
-0.18761266767978668,
-0.8752681612968445,
0.7783339619636536,
-0.6943524479866028,
-0.85978102684021,
-0.5704953670501709,
-0.599696159362793,
-0.42248818278312683,
0.023935597389936447,
0.23195874691009521,
0.24279555678367615,
-0.3235834538936615,
0.16524915397167206,
1.328776240348816,
-0.23984158039093018,
0.00750228576362133,
0.4039234220981598,
-0.4292614161968231,
-0.2280815988779068,
1.2207244634628296,
0.023641513660550117,
0.2666141092777252,
0.5728877782821655,
0.18893960118293762,
-0.41431543231010437,
-0.47877946496009827,
-0.2295750230550766,
0.4172171354293823,
-0.6469670534133911,
-0.1436983197927475,
-0.6652761101722717,
-0.24231363832950592,
-0.6358290910720825,
-0.4743310511112213,
-0.3340241312980652,
-0.3592337369918823,
-0.25214922428131104,
-0.42443713545799255,
0.5120699405670166,
0.5000283122062683,
-0.11851882934570312,
0.2271968424320221,
-0.5870181322097778,
0.40056777000427246,
0.45143648982048035,
0.25432097911834717,
-0.14442571997642517,
-0.6342889070510864,
-0.21927030384540558,
-0.030162468552589417,
-0.20559430122375488,
-0.5327243804931641,
0.03627103567123413,
-0.0035370131954550743,
0.3132786154747009,
0.7320466041564941,
0.11614470928907394,
0.7915855646133423,
-0.5183087587356567,
0.4036617577075958,
0.1813436597585678,
-0.7601231336593628,
0.4399966597557068,
-0.20441298186779022,
-0.047637104988098145,
0.7727047801017761,
0.34902769327163696,
-0.6281062960624695,
-0.4197075664997101,
-0.4941782057285309,
-0.4181961119174957,
0.6522586941719055,
0.16883568465709686,
0.034791119396686554,
0.10731286555528641,
0.3371536135673523,
0.36238089203834534,
0.24300286173820496,
-0.7378158569335938,
-0.10218283534049988,
-0.09594079107046127,
-0.4168236255645752,
-0.15499262511730194,
-0.24705781042575836,
-0.3395163416862488,
-0.4632672369480133,
1.081775188446045,
-0.10434398055076599,
0.026493703946471214,
0.15586259961128235,
-0.15722720324993134,
-0.18642987310886383,
0.18222269415855408,
0.9406059980392456,
0.5327972173690796,
-0.3553760051727295,
0.14924639463424683,
0.053438786417245865,
-0.2152555286884308,
0.22904016077518463,
-0.01713201031088829,
-0.20022708177566528,
-0.0977463498711586,
0.4797035753726959,
1.1223150491714478,
0.20464250445365906,
-0.5052689909934998,
0.333065927028656,
0.08498705923557281,
-0.13045759499073029,
-0.11937408894300461,
0.4600505828857422,
0.17556729912757874,
0.298832505941391,
-0.061788592487573624,
0.1988050639629364,
0.027137702330946922,
-0.5495055317878723,
0.337958961725235,
0.579023540019989,
-0.29707756638526917,
-0.19303151965141296,
0.6465693712234497,
0.2617950737476349,
-0.12985193729400635,
0.5640057921409607,
-0.22536733746528625,
-0.6606395840644836,
0.4265071153640747,
0.469547837972641,
0.8216750621795654,
-0.1367271989583969,
0.41560596227645874,
0.45659154653549194,
0.3714521527290344,
-0.267116904258728,
0.0698300153017044,
0.0666583925485611,
-0.8896304965019226,
-0.6149029731750488,
-0.5538116097450256,
-0.25596702098846436,
0.015719130635261536,
-0.541732668876648,
0.5611799359321594,
-0.48083704710006714,
0.17255637049674988,
-0.08512257784605026,
0.12614567577838898,
-0.5162522792816162,
0.41847604513168335,
0.1347222626209259,
0.6135507225990295,
-0.9921031594276428,
0.7849822640419006,
0.34687191247940063,
-0.2574794590473175,
-0.9799127578735352,
0.13102011382579803,
0.21431781351566315,
-0.7434930205345154,
0.5234212279319763,
0.2134997546672821,
-0.21985505521297455,
-0.10507261008024216,
-0.60989910364151,
-0.9080856442451477,
0.9475117325782776,
0.572898805141449,
-0.6769354343414307,
-0.1439117193222046,
0.09300428628921509,
0.5544861555099487,
-0.3092896342277527,
-0.07394220679998398,
0.6953665614128113,
0.6912186741828918,
0.4397251009941101,
-0.6489107012748718,
0.3077476918697357,
0.2864702045917511,
-0.2640780508518219,
0.24321088194847107,
-0.6997720003128052,
0.4008669853210449,
-0.3226769268512726,
-0.1832897663116455,
-0.1735944300889969,
1.0149189233779907,
0.34534406661987305,
0.3217974603176117,
0.43896129727363586,
0.7230674624443054,
1.1890748739242554,
-0.03553758189082146,
0.783746600151062,
-0.0024062381125986576,
0.18641753494739532,
1.2964855432510376,
-0.5404337644577026,
0.5664830803871155,
0.5350551009178162,
0.20372051000595093,
0.4295614957809448,
0.6260135769844055,
0.009944599121809006,
0.5884261727333069,
-0.050543587654829025,
-0.27710261940956116,
-0.3347843885421753,
-0.09261924773454666,
-0.3664308190345764,
0.3310289680957794,
0.11545215547084808,
-0.11334117501974106,
-0.05134376510977745,
-0.2122717648744583,
0.07539118826389313,
0.21173357963562012,
0.03680312633514404,
1.0320528745651245,
-0.38318416476249695,
-0.8864188194274902,
0.7069284915924072,
-0.25973087549209595,
0.6233859062194824,
-0.5296354293823242,
-0.07933048903942108,
-0.17394204437732697,
-0.05288003757596016,
-0.5838281512260437,
-0.47503870725631714,
0.39122289419174194,
0.027559854090213776,
-0.33803778886795044,
-0.03731769323348999,
0.5484214425086975,
-0.6830280423164368,
-0.4552921652793884,
-0.004775625187903643,
0.1510302871465683,
0.016753116622567177,
0.06559977680444717,
-0.4500923156738281,
0.31823599338531494,
0.2762753963470459,
-0.15830498933792114,
0.3152749538421631,
0.6532887816429138,
0.07274249196052551,
0.4902743101119995,
0.5879126191139221,
0.1526317000389099,
0.01242007315158844,
-0.21881596744060516,
0.6795670390129089,
-0.5938553810119629,
-0.2144918441772461,
-0.9288257956504822,
0.47088107466697693,
-0.1827773004770279,
-0.0991714671254158,
0.6604068279266357,
0.7026304006576538,
0.8065980672836304,
-0.018226943910121918,
0.72786945104599,
-0.06822830438613892,
0.3326667547225952,
-0.9334126114845276,
0.608981192111969,
-0.4483483135700226,
0.3064066469669342,
-0.17784936726093292,
-1.2074528932571411,
-0.2820402979850769,
0.6990296840667725,
-0.36654701828956604,
-0.20217767357826233,
0.7544562816619873,
1.0119074583053589,
-0.06194659695029259,
0.07187511771917343,
0.27277806401252747,
0.23565532267093658,
0.29707297682762146,
0.2500002980232239,
0.5885123610496521,
-0.07974758744239807,
0.3701007068157196,
-0.27112916111946106,
-0.04129182919859886,
-0.4530520439147949,
-1.0088694095611572,
-0.8183072805404663,
-0.5426041483879089,
-0.6184773445129395,
-0.4138510525226593,
-0.048152994364500046,
1.2350581884384155,
0.4138483703136444,
-0.9132871031761169,
-0.14167359471321106,
-0.17052564024925232,
0.4303111433982849,
-0.19403067231178284,
-0.23071423172950745,
0.5111633539199829,
-0.5866692066192627,
-0.5082615613937378,
0.26858991384506226,
0.2717934548854828,
0.023594463244080544,
-0.07508532702922821,
-0.3013016879558563,
-0.3365556299686432,
0.22677139937877655,
0.4716517925262451,
0.31710875034332275,
-0.7838314175605774,
-0.7004533410072327,
0.003461157437413931,
-0.32022973895072937,
0.23875758051872253,
0.796206533908844,
-0.6755319237709045,
0.4943315088748932,
0.4274735152721405,
0.9635226130485535,
0.1388666033744812,
0.13642314076423645,
0.559979259967804,
-0.7034994959831238,
0.047065168619155884,
0.27090802788734436,
0.005450370721518993,
0.41762199997901917,
-0.7950169444084167,
0.38681715726852417,
0.1666579693555832,
-0.7326166033744812,
-0.8673015236854553,
0.1534193754196167,
-1.0066193342208862,
-0.15601257979869843,
1.1185261011123657,
0.28980475664138794,
-0.10159655660390854,
0.05123187229037285,
-0.5028235912322998,
0.5782357454299927,
-0.3137246370315552,
1.1405855417251587,
0.9859205484390259,
-0.27260738611221313,
0.10033521801233292,
-0.3681604862213135,
0.9307270646095276,
0.5587201118469238,
-0.8564798831939697,
0.4023764729499817,
0.7358458638191223,
0.14815294742584229,
0.17008300125598907,
0.3673440217971802,
0.23969347774982452,
0.22268356382846832,
-0.3577415943145752,
0.060995690524578094,
0.12241952866315842,
-0.6081498861312866,
-0.32994985580444336,
-0.1677706390619278,
0.17558610439300537,
0.08428451418876648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01511v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01511v1
|
D2PO: Discriminator-Guided DPO with Response Evaluation Models
| 2024-05-02T17:44:41 | 2024-05-02T17:44:41 |
Prasann Singhal, Nathan Lambert, Scott Niekum, Tanya Goyal, Greg Durrett
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Varied approaches for aligning language models have been proposed, including
supervised fine-tuning, RLHF, and direct optimization methods such as DPO.
Although DPO has rapidly gained popularity due to its straightforward training
process and competitive results, there is an open question of whether there
remain practical advantages of using a discriminator, like a reward model, to
evaluate responses. We propose D2PO, discriminator-guided DPO, an approach for
the online setting where preferences are being collected throughout learning.
As we collect gold preferences, we use these not only to train our policy, but
to train a discriminative response evaluation model to silver-label even more
synthetic data for policy training. We explore this approach across a set of
diverse tasks, including a realistic chat setting, we find that our approach
leads to higher-quality outputs compared to DPO with the same data budget, and
greater efficiency in terms of preference data requirements. Furthermore, we
show conditions under which silver labeling is most helpful: it is most
effective when training the policy with DPO, outperforming traditional PPO, and
benefits from maintaining a separate discriminator from the policy model.
|
[
-0.27308568358421326,
-0.3647863268852234,
0.4327205419540405,
-0.009575492702424526,
0.021698657423257828,
0.26688411831855774,
-0.14885857701301575,
-0.3640558421611786,
-0.20362889766693115,
0.3977729082107544,
-0.41996946930885315,
-0.07417123019695282,
-0.6992833614349365,
0.1347544938325882,
0.19714471697807312,
1.1261258125305176,
0.11545690894126892,
0.08634815365076065,
-0.3003598749637604,
0.29913419485092163,
-0.598617672920227,
-0.5255641341209412,
-0.8324260711669922,
-0.8768084645271301,
0.4833846092224121,
0.5209968686103821,
0.6029249429702759,
0.7383615374565125,
0.3177138566970825,
0.28826019167900085,
-0.22294645011425018,
0.5568893551826477,
-0.6877914667129517,
-0.2149646133184433,
-0.19671931862831116,
-0.6659066677093506,
-0.5529462099075317,
0.34330201148986816,
0.25447386503219604,
0.5356278419494629,
-0.3762015998363495,
0.0015467868652194738,
0.10661587864160538,
0.9268359541893005,
-0.9461267590522766,
0.22387684881687164,
-0.628262996673584,
0.3442920446395874,
0.2748786509037018,
-0.10647105425596237,
-0.6594441533088684,
-0.45330265164375305,
0.30774709582328796,
-0.870720624923706,
0.029467085376381874,
-0.17237064242362976,
0.6995320916175842,
0.25257840752601624,
-0.45709431171417236,
-0.5237138271331787,
-0.9944858551025391,
0.907343864440918,
-0.37494781613349915,
0.24781739711761475,
0.7668511867523193,
0.4332304894924164,
-0.08983659744262695,
-0.6663495898246765,
-0.5240249037742615,
-0.11787674576044083,
-0.1971484124660492,
0.5157665014266968,
-0.1185961589217186,
0.24226762354373932,
0.044013794511556625,
0.41275858879089355,
-0.45217397809028625,
0.4829232096672058,
-0.0652090534567833,
-0.017745990306138992,
0.7953769564628601,
-0.05475512892007828,
-0.23985251784324646,
0.21122907102108002,
-0.2841894030570984,
-0.2555333077907562,
-0.2537645995616913,
0.08906026184558868,
0.746428370475769,
0.4418097734451294,
0.057550325989723206,
0.36848363280296326,
-0.25061947107315063,
0.936761200428009,
0.5820188522338867,
-0.416919082403183,
0.3034088611602783,
0.07506248354911804,
0.1612442433834076,
0.16617561876773834,
0.6095638275146484,
0.5611426830291748,
0.30372512340545654,
-0.14054839313030243,
-0.2613058090209961,
0.4039076268672943,
0.2341746687889099,
-0.7902159690856934,
-0.20546746253967285,
0.3974258601665497,
-0.4465584456920624,
-0.5347827076911926,
-0.0462462417781353,
-0.994698166847229,
-0.4568823575973511,
-0.39808207750320435,
0.11869040876626968,
0.06284217536449432,
-0.4692600667476654,
0.3542972207069397,
-0.38286569714546204,
0.0721234381198883,
0.17756855487823486,
-1.5201003551483154,
0.615001916885376,
1.0860600471496582,
0.7258238792419434,
-0.2383348047733307,
0.07183922827243805,
-0.9377807378768921,
0.0696316733956337,
-0.3068448305130005,
0.852222740650177,
-0.7714940309524536,
-0.4471718668937683,
0.21856452524662018,
-0.4160372316837311,
-0.06670305132865906,
-0.6920441389083862,
0.4469930827617645,
-0.5489107966423035,
0.32788777351379395,
-0.230061873793602,
-0.679204523563385,
0.2667081356048584,
0.40364721417427063,
-0.6429274678230286,
0.9900071620941162,
0.1999034732580185,
-0.8023812174797058,
0.5777140259742737,
-0.7347996830940247,
-0.14125341176986694,
0.026053491979837418,
-0.079831063747406,
-0.3828987181186676,
0.031914956867694855,
0.05514949932694435,
-0.056497398763895035,
0.03693152591586113,
0.2624322175979614,
-0.4941153824329376,
-0.5155652761459351,
0.48864319920539856,
-0.22078001499176025,
0.4226507842540741,
0.30217209458351135,
-0.2077624350786209,
-0.07028700411319733,
-0.8550376296043396,
-0.10946375131607056,
0.10515416413545609,
-0.6396583318710327,
-0.3965633809566498,
0.35705670714378357,
-0.38914188742637634,
0.27926185727119446,
0.28781867027282715,
-0.7572928667068481,
0.2782610356807709,
-0.660212516784668,
0.4231748878955841,
1.019999384880066,
-0.3238200843334198,
0.4748438894748688,
-0.16033247113227844,
0.5510389804840088,
-0.20387618243694305,
0.3803918957710266,
0.6839284300804138,
-0.29313036799430847,
-0.5748966336250305,
-0.3389682471752167,
0.49471160769462585,
0.6378015279769897,
-0.5966291427612305,
0.45232558250427246,
-0.13246744871139526,
-0.213130921125412,
-0.6850988268852234,
-0.08438354730606079,
0.5047716498374939,
0.6359006762504578,
0.08971428126096725,
-0.16728252172470093,
-0.5120128393173218,
-0.8605417013168335,
0.027946636080741882,
-0.45698413252830505,
0.0343933179974556,
0.5214312076568604,
0.3055350184440613,
-0.042181987315416336,
1.2253711223602295,
-0.9257989525794983,
-0.24465443193912506,
-0.2535477578639984,
0.0513434000313282,
-0.05708014965057373,
0.17475813627243042,
0.4520222842693329,
-0.8508201837539673,
-0.70074462890625,
0.06437349319458008,
-0.38215336203575134,
-0.2883238196372986,
0.14748378098011017,
-0.049409542232751846,
0.12215425074100494,
-0.17072436213493347,
-0.22444580495357513,
-0.10354874283075333,
0.647527813911438,
-0.1141343042254448,
0.2052815705537796,
-0.3672933578491211,
0.06066509708762169,
-0.6573674082756042,
0.04043799638748169,
-0.037553757429122925,
-0.24998632073402405,
-0.8257083296775818,
-0.3330320417881012,
-0.26230353116989136,
-0.29480573534965515,
-0.5114381909370422,
0.6799784898757935,
-0.014527281746268272,
-0.23318126797676086,
-0.5805177688598633,
0.3003814220428467,
0.16279147565364838,
0.3986542820930481,
0.4188074469566345,
0.8220157623291016,
0.19973333179950714,
-0.6454230546951294,
0.307571142911911,
0.673079252243042,
-0.05720549821853638,
0.6851240396499634,
-0.6943293213844299,
0.46436628699302673,
-0.27705830335617065,
0.3475777208805084,
-1.0248181819915771,
-0.10559062659740448,
0.45112529397010803,
-0.22571222484111786,
0.3127075731754303,
-0.342313289642334,
-0.5014858841896057,
-0.42412275075912476,
-0.5053318738937378,
0.10486041754484177,
0.4142496883869171,
-0.7369493842124939,
0.06227489188313484,
0.6284897923469543,
0.07822743058204651,
-0.6062964200973511,
-0.49967601895332336,
-0.22109591960906982,
-0.5817859172821045,
-0.07265341281890869,
0.6260401606559753,
-0.15669484436511993,
-0.23636095225811005,
-0.367910772562027,
-0.025825154036283493,
-0.06750185787677765,
0.40194937586784363,
0.011372050270438194,
0.16984643042087555,
0.48164886236190796,
0.16223645210266113,
-0.11149817705154419,
-0.517645537853241,
-0.19712668657302856,
-0.10517676174640656,
0.6393762826919556,
0.08414586633443832,
-0.028451260179281235,
-0.5487838983535767,
0.5320367813110352,
-0.03556324169039726,
-0.44068285822868347,
0.4932568073272705,
0.3195330798625946,
-0.10771290212869644,
-0.1810549944639206,
-0.16133448481559753,
-0.22348059713840485,
-0.5228222012519836,
0.19418710470199585,
-0.5172870755195618,
-0.7793220281600952,
0.12511003017425537,
-0.31787049770355225,
0.22870689630508423,
0.15988239645957947,
0.4554292857646942,
-0.08832165598869324,
1.8348019123077393,
0.63818359375,
0.27015647292137146,
0.7858166098594666,
-0.10382422804832458,
0.0351896807551384,
-0.7669498920440674,
-0.22409634292125702,
-0.3823762834072113,
-0.2798393666744232,
-0.6756543517112732,
0.17394621670246124,
0.09581784158945084,
0.11592644453048706,
-0.23377491533756256,
0.025194188579916954,
-0.8724098801612854,
0.466135174036026,
0.4537796676158905,
0.3170461058616638,
0.22110381722450256,
0.11351758986711502,
0.3756091594696045,
-0.15305881202220917,
-0.7352486848831177,
-0.728904128074646,
1.014392375946045,
0.5185940265655518,
0.7027323842048645,
-0.04234687238931656,
0.7791222333908081,
0.4861358106136322,
0.12146537750959396,
-0.9740675091743469,
0.39747047424316406,
-0.5806294679641724,
-0.3950989246368408,
0.13594019412994385,
-0.4250941276550293,
-1.1083557605743408,
0.3286270201206207,
-0.15537084639072418,
-0.7979047894477844,
0.3582618832588196,
0.5907992720603943,
-0.4724719822406769,
-0.1536686271429062,
-0.7157130241394043,
0.8568542003631592,
-0.4997296631336212,
-0.19088652729988098,
-0.21949009597301483,
-0.4294918477535248,
0.12201838940382004,
0.08584582805633545,
-0.011918210424482822,
-0.20867662131786346,
0.0025773816742002964,
0.7655211091041565,
-0.35801929235458374,
0.9276115298271179,
-0.37634220719337463,
-0.21856388449668884,
0.2632977068424225,
-0.22890673577785492,
0.5180932283401489,
-0.0835438072681427,
-0.3583277761936188,
-0.22504861652851105,
0.032330624759197235,
-0.03525141254067421,
-0.6127413511276245,
0.6100073456764221,
-1.0022251605987549,
-0.4456234574317932,
-0.5190412402153015,
-0.6108795404434204,
-0.320654034614563,
-0.16310833394527435,
-0.08149395138025284,
0.21550805866718292,
0.011687309481203556,
-0.21711860597133636,
0.621967077255249,
-0.20566612482070923,
0.05021708458662033,
0.7055361866950989,
-0.08144944906234741,
-0.5777378082275391,
1.0660481452941895,
0.10562270134687424,
0.5574322938919067,
0.3566494286060333,
0.6904293894767761,
-0.5609210729598999,
-0.262847363948822,
-0.29102662205696106,
0.21282696723937988,
-0.721086859703064,
-0.04169628769159317,
-0.31441250443458557,
0.06499244272708893,
-0.3408753275871277,
-0.06700761616230011,
-0.4696636497974396,
-0.4820181429386139,
-0.3683033585548401,
-0.10211076587438583,
0.310798704624176,
0.4050467014312744,
-0.23928502202033997,
0.6033033728599548,
-0.36278337240219116,
0.277698278427124,
0.6814828515052795,
0.5439918041229248,
-0.377956360578537,
-0.46335291862487793,
-0.06960802525281906,
0.39192506670951843,
-0.48237818479537964,
-0.7557123899459839,
0.25306060910224915,
0.38807618618011475,
0.6150482296943665,
0.34039145708084106,
0.3165592849254608,
0.749432384967804,
-0.4230656921863556,
0.5495887398719788,
-0.08833674341440201,
-0.5136919021606445,
0.8694434762001038,
-0.043581273406744,
0.02744227461516857,
0.7487809658050537,
0.3748002052307129,
-0.3168741762638092,
-0.015214895829558372,
-0.5232312679290771,
-0.5544420480728149,
0.9857093691825867,
-0.032124608755111694,
0.1348380297422409,
-0.26341134309768677,
0.45238634943962097,
0.3107828199863434,
0.450874388217926,
-0.5320016145706177,
-0.18968868255615234,
-0.22706390917301178,
-0.09614541381597519,
0.15821927785873413,
-0.37477368116378784,
-0.5539228320121765,
0.2380693107843399,
0.6607159376144409,
-0.32460808753967285,
0.3403225839138031,
-0.11299195140600204,
0.10509445518255234,
0.05039380490779877,
0.1968056857585907,
0.3437265157699585,
0.6554324626922607,
-0.4071544110774994,
-0.002296114806085825,
-0.17372390627861023,
-0.09002472460269928,
0.18674170970916748,
0.35787874460220337,
-0.4174153506755829,
-0.21915008127689362,
-0.11185455322265625,
1.0474421977996826,
-0.16510185599327087,
-0.6861500144004822,
0.39328256249427795,
-0.11791776865720749,
-0.2825571298599243,
-0.10136529058218002,
0.1936531364917755,
-0.36478620767593384,
0.19199010729789734,
-0.0025783211458474398,
-0.5054678916931152,
0.4222520887851715,
-0.5898016095161438,
0.04192811995744705,
0.4826451241970062,
-0.363076388835907,
-0.13824251294136047,
0.5685747861862183,
0.3766903579235077,
-0.4189818203449249,
0.5062524080276489,
-0.2400963008403778,
-0.5987839698791504,
0.4474424421787262,
0.941690981388092,
0.5325368046760559,
-0.10460764169692993,
0.7413407564163208,
0.334729939699173,
-0.33911457657814026,
-0.2462492734193802,
0.26022642850875854,
-0.1743745058774948,
-0.8014906048774719,
-0.22493068873882294,
-0.5882567763328552,
-0.6406806707382202,
0.08393311500549316,
-0.8395916223526001,
0.21288642287254333,
-0.41948452591896057,
-0.4770370125770569,
0.1416180431842804,
0.2229716181755066,
-0.4018864035606384,
0.21621732413768768,
0.4170646071434021,
0.38849377632141113,
-1.050660252571106,
0.5963179469108582,
0.6383460164070129,
-0.2183329463005066,
-0.3547855615615845,
-0.3327827751636505,
-0.02287585847079754,
-0.7511401772499084,
0.7047184109687805,
0.31863847374916077,
-0.06262901425361633,
0.1650058478116989,
-0.11647652089595795,
-0.6722897291183472,
0.9765046834945679,
0.5569707751274109,
-0.5394196510314941,
0.11160437762737274,
0.4283880293369293,
0.6099937558174133,
-0.29939791560173035,
0.30747488141059875,
0.8968819379806519,
0.3190898895263672,
0.2110094279050827,
-0.906019926071167,
-0.4006856083869934,
0.08655700832605362,
0.2175568789243698,
0.2514963150024414,
-0.8449199199676514,
0.4115402102470398,
0.1257624626159668,
-0.3065429925918579,
-0.22783203423023224,
0.36486002802848816,
0.5598142743110657,
0.17349889874458313,
0.7358555197715759,
0.4997434616088867,
0.7911463975906372,
-0.16481278836727142,
1.0764286518096924,
-0.18260504305362701,
0.48952144384384155,
1.225298285484314,
-0.6111361980438232,
0.78301602602005,
0.5775889754295349,
-0.3917713165283203,
0.42842450737953186,
0.950118899345398,
-0.030189557000994682,
1.0771576166152954,
0.2535409927368164,
-0.34971219301223755,
-0.2645375728607178,
-0.6565917134284973,
-0.17116187512874603,
0.6389585137367249,
0.14367319643497467,
-0.08822331577539444,
-0.08139784634113312,
0.044164758175611496,
-0.04539100080728531,
0.3704940676689148,
-0.3031066358089447,
1.0271357297897339,
-0.17050442099571228,
-1.0419502258300781,
0.4489050805568695,
-0.03827986493706703,
0.5557230114936829,
-0.7501599192619324,
-0.2818686366081238,
-0.2613474130630493,
0.6583867073059082,
-0.33920714259147644,
-0.8885946273803711,
0.2985312342643738,
0.11619795113801956,
-0.18876667320728302,
-0.4887278079986572,
0.6050549745559692,
-0.5489504337310791,
-0.3717014491558075,
0.24575680494308472,
-0.014202553778886795,
-0.003577717114239931,
0.1939341425895691,
-0.8737977743148804,
0.08108644932508469,
-0.17243513464927673,
-0.23316173255443573,
0.5934737324714661,
-0.05411767587065697,
0.04592813551425934,
0.5752019882202148,
0.5175212025642395,
0.14515632390975952,
-0.352294385433197,
0.26855912804603577,
0.7361166477203369,
0.18354323506355286,
-0.6688410639762878,
-0.8040125370025635,
0.5793027281761169,
-0.2796800136566162,
-0.2752254605293274,
0.4930306673049927,
0.6351211667060852,
0.9486284255981445,
0.017445942386984825,
0.6812359690666199,
0.027916578575968742,
0.48060306906700134,
-0.31806281208992004,
0.1144532859325409,
-0.41255080699920654,
0.15822210907936096,
0.005152157042175531,
-0.711990237236023,
-0.05125700309872627,
0.9969053864479065,
-0.44497931003570557,
-0.14907309412956238,
0.07567334175109863,
0.6275486350059509,
0.10816093534231186,
-0.366804301738739,
0.00975268054753542,
-0.429835706949234,
0.523076593875885,
0.6086394786834717,
0.7767872214317322,
-0.2358947992324829,
0.6681708097457886,
-0.47662603855133057,
-0.5781120657920837,
-0.05803568288683891,
-0.794354259967804,
-0.8919395804405212,
-0.3231143355369568,
-0.5620209574699402,
-0.2669694125652313,
0.14148549735546112,
0.8941737413406372,
0.587452232837677,
-0.5897544026374817,
-0.3456664979457855,
-0.04839923977851868,
-0.12576259672641754,
-0.5544981956481934,
-0.20417086780071259,
0.2232576310634613,
-0.28204309940338135,
-0.9792280197143555,
0.27931639552116394,
0.03307802230119705,
0.080925352871418,
-0.1663692593574524,
-0.3926439881324768,
-0.20433983206748962,
-0.09758420288562775,
0.7432081699371338,
0.30371981859207153,
-0.5773430466651917,
-0.4687776267528534,
-0.1018901914358139,
-0.003440636210143566,
0.11597946286201477,
0.6074494123458862,
-0.8355518579483032,
0.9071487188339233,
0.4312397241592407,
0.5671617984771729,
0.7095877528190613,
0.3075815737247467,
0.755661129951477,
-0.6209254860877991,
0.19305019080638885,
0.21355676651000977,
0.03776795044541359,
0.40348097681999207,
-0.41543129086494446,
0.5856272578239441,
0.018248526379466057,
-0.6482006311416626,
-0.9444723129272461,
0.567678689956665,
-0.7129395008087158,
-0.12979432940483093,
1.3748815059661865,
-0.21890473365783691,
0.1674303561449051,
0.07065556198358536,
-0.4315243065357208,
0.3312692940235138,
-0.4123561978340149,
1.1650784015655518,
0.5156300067901611,
-0.3691551387310028,
-0.009569651447236538,
-0.532332181930542,
0.5897050499916077,
0.18514427542686462,
-0.9262253642082214,
0.1945820301771164,
0.5535246729850769,
0.14081959426403046,
0.032998014241456985,
0.8706029653549194,
0.07875307649374008,
0.07210204005241394,
0.006774904206395149,
-0.15449896454811096,
-0.23769696056842804,
-0.31713181734085083,
-0.39729559421539307,
-0.11064260452985764,
0.3933207094669342,
-0.7164343595504761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01502v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01502v1
|
Analyzing the Role of Semantic Representations in the Era of Large Language Models
| 2024-05-02T17:32:59 | 2024-05-02T17:32:59 |
Zhijing Jin, Yuen Chen, Fernando Gonzalez, Jiarui Liu, Jiayi Zhang, Julian Michael, Bernhard Schölkopf, Mona Diab
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Traditionally, natural language processing (NLP) models often use a rich set
of features created by linguistic expertise, such as semantic representations.
However, in the era of large language models (LLMs), more and more tasks are
turned into generic, end-to-end sequence generation problems. In this paper, we
investigate the question: what is the role of semantic representations in the
era of LLMs? Specifically, we investigate the effect of Abstract Meaning
Representation (AMR) across five diverse NLP tasks. We propose an AMR-driven
chain-of-thought prompting method, which we call AMRCoT, and find that it
generally hurts performance more than it helps. To investigate what AMR may
have to offer on these tasks, we conduct a series of analysis experiments. We
find that it is difficult to predict which input examples AMR may help or hurt
on, but errors tend to arise with multi-word expressions, named entities, and
in the final inference step where the LLM must connect its reasoning over the
AMR to its prediction. We recommend focusing on these areas for future work in
semantic representations for LLMs. Our code:
https://github.com/causalNLP/amr_llm.
|
[
-0.498506635427475,
-0.5576224327087402,
0.7595928907394409,
0.26691463589668274,
-0.36164823174476624,
-0.12253179401159286,
-0.3049461245536804,
-0.790067732334137,
0.32827824354171753,
0.5629578828811646,
-0.5231040120124817,
-0.3317382335662842,
-0.7923305034637451,
0.42623695731163025,
-0.4576472043991089,
0.8401837348937988,
-0.24045363068580627,
0.03536581993103027,
-0.2826901972293854,
0.021545210853219032,
-0.6299548149108887,
-0.6278514862060547,
-0.608339250087738,
-0.6767975091934204,
0.7810443043708801,
-0.1888817399740219,
0.6663626432418823,
0.49584096670150757,
0.24386243522167206,
0.3090440332889557,
-0.07817909866571426,
0.07587841153144836,
-0.17139364778995514,
0.5204469561576843,
-0.28605741262435913,
-0.47579842805862427,
-0.2801969051361084,
-0.12518785893917084,
0.8055723309516907,
0.8306097388267517,
-0.010666587390005589,
0.02300029620528221,
0.013102428056299686,
0.5815832614898682,
-0.704125165939331,
0.3181975483894348,
-0.8171647191047668,
0.11652761697769165,
-0.11904384195804596,
-0.39817771315574646,
-0.5784186124801636,
0.12277226150035858,
0.17383931577205658,
-0.4252469539642334,
-0.12394165247678757,
0.3480484187602997,
0.5009903907775879,
0.3252714276313782,
-0.4997199475765228,
-0.5622222423553467,
-0.7224275469779968,
0.9154599905014038,
-0.6608863472938538,
0.12974610924720764,
0.01245838962495327,
0.13490645587444305,
-0.5299810171127319,
-0.3961294889450073,
-0.7232577204704285,
-0.06674333661794662,
-0.11027194559574127,
0.022076893597841263,
-0.3445175290107727,
0.27314677834510803,
0.3979395031929016,
0.2538997232913971,
-0.17876936495304108,
0.11500456184148788,
-0.20026357471942902,
-0.06637963652610779,
0.3091765344142914,
0.32451102137565613,
0.2611900568008423,
-0.3333343267440796,
-0.3675515651702881,
-0.23851378262043,
-0.7569922804832458,
-0.2197311520576477,
0.09391678124666214,
0.22792959213256836,
0.2116282731294632,
0.9210379719734192,
-0.019354328513145447,
0.8895153403282166,
-0.3334357738494873,
0.3180559277534485,
0.15455208718776703,
-0.11713381856679916,
-0.08590257912874222,
0.31498482823371887,
0.7235279679298401,
0.1824936717748642,
0.507556676864624,
-0.06391050666570663,
-0.3745463192462921,
0.40235915780067444,
0.46817341446876526,
-0.4715910851955414,
0.20546768605709076,
0.07746929675340652,
-0.2522730827331543,
0.0008245258941315114,
0.14805859327316284,
-0.5246021747589111,
-0.3820337951183319,
-0.503803014755249,
0.2496965378522873,
-0.39230188727378845,
-0.11650801450014114,
0.43145856261253357,
-0.3773144483566284,
0.36690688133239746,
0.40686288475990295,
-1.0161863565444946,
0.5096157193183899,
0.586158037185669,
0.5694572925567627,
-0.029391447082161903,
-0.2194773554801941,
-0.296499103307724,
0.5244873762130737,
-0.25865331292152405,
0.85382080078125,
-0.7826884984970093,
-0.24467593431472778,
0.09251857548952103,
-0.05247151851654053,
-0.16745564341545105,
-0.4857306480407715,
0.1848004013299942,
-0.6871870160102844,
-0.11113574355840683,
-0.4576082229614258,
-0.6714250445365906,
-0.334073543548584,
0.3592197895050049,
-0.9103906154632568,
0.7637898921966553,
-0.2221498042345047,
-0.8311048746109009,
0.20234663784503937,
-0.7526677250862122,
-0.11910807341337204,
-0.047080785036087036,
-0.5196039080619812,
-0.0366690531373024,
0.40173429250717163,
0.19292497634887695,
0.6430047154426575,
-0.31418588757514954,
-0.14927658438682556,
-0.09613913297653198,
-0.24464882910251617,
0.5377009510993958,
-0.2314201146364212,
0.19141989946365356,
-0.15265215933322906,
-0.2077300101518631,
-0.03430541232228279,
-0.5373900532722473,
0.08147948235273361,
0.11081846803426743,
-0.35533297061920166,
-0.5259329080581665,
0.1699965000152588,
-0.22298765182495117,
0.4644777774810791,
0.11750698834657669,
-0.6135823130607605,
0.03386124223470688,
-0.5341061949729919,
0.28576526045799255,
0.8100692629814148,
0.1910952776670456,
0.3180987536907196,
-0.1544310450553894,
0.6476774215698242,
0.14350366592407227,
-0.5613659620285034,
-0.35795530676841736,
-0.6642921566963196,
-0.803888201713562,
0.24684618413448334,
0.3463476002216339,
0.307280570268631,
-0.4968931972980499,
0.33731967210769653,
-0.31921806931495667,
0.07907836139202118,
-0.5002234578132629,
0.11095654964447021,
0.3146144449710846,
-0.06178649514913559,
0.46793901920318604,
-0.19358281791210175,
-0.6590074300765991,
-0.8375212550163269,
-0.2828555107116699,
-0.19427719712257385,
-0.20612750947475433,
-0.06258159875869751,
0.8020113110542297,
-0.3023018538951874,
1.0889571905136108,
-0.4297240972518921,
-0.24113067984580994,
-0.3550357222557068,
0.2766064703464508,
0.09117452055215836,
0.33108052611351013,
0.23423394560813904,
-0.5505753755569458,
-0.020670361816883087,
-0.10148648917675018,
-0.6716797351837158,
-0.16393433511257172,
-0.08102262020111084,
-0.08229419589042664,
0.1759161502122879,
0.4600328803062439,
-0.8953230381011963,
0.4053506851196289,
0.6129733920097351,
-0.34630557894706726,
0.6595818996429443,
-0.4598109722137451,
-0.11765245348215103,
-0.8748364448547363,
-0.006186696235090494,
-0.17962130904197693,
-0.01696195639669895,
-0.2804999351501465,
-0.06547453999519348,
-0.0621514730155468,
-0.1474742293357849,
-0.18877013027668,
0.5192107558250427,
-0.5654459595680237,
-0.2178705781698227,
-0.27796807885169983,
0.23314091563224792,
-0.003898019203916192,
0.32161611318588257,
0.1773008108139038,
0.4380221962928772,
0.2483890801668167,
-0.7624562382698059,
0.25955522060394287,
-0.031600870192050934,
-0.19172567129135132,
0.20179735124111176,
-0.7583459615707397,
0.1053103432059288,
-0.4038388729095459,
0.43221044540405273,
-0.7485852241516113,
-0.175737664103508,
0.10049233585596085,
-0.3757045865058899,
0.24867630004882812,
0.14364813268184662,
-0.9611256122589111,
-0.273815780878067,
-0.20275288820266724,
0.3801323175430298,
0.4290698170661926,
-0.34027528762817383,
0.5868727564811707,
0.26833388209342957,
0.17296792566776276,
-0.34048330783843994,
-0.9106942415237427,
0.1466078758239746,
-0.18282365798950195,
-0.7392609119415283,
0.581244707107544,
0.45912158489227295,
-0.27091896533966064,
0.1920022964477539,
-0.07138348370790482,
0.40197885036468506,
-0.10129334777593613,
0.1609918773174286,
0.025709763169288635,
-0.09709594398736954,
0.36748751997947693,
0.005354632623493671,
-0.5148856043815613,
0.4673250913619995,
-0.44507265090942383,
0.6625779271125793,
-0.08704113215208054,
-0.5417521595954895,
0.013100025244057178,
0.669756293296814,
0.33653557300567627,
-0.36211952567100525,
0.8313570022583008,
0.2706598937511444,
-0.410567969083786,
-0.5148823857307434,
-0.40906572341918945,
-0.18843673169612885,
-0.43152880668640137,
0.3039999306201935,
-0.06166558340191841,
-0.9017981886863708,
0.6539790630340576,
-0.07312190532684326,
0.012296592816710472,
0.38266775012016296,
0.6705862879753113,
-0.07477538287639618,
1.0782393217086792,
0.29655614495277405,
0.25744926929473877,
0.37495872378349304,
-0.2966378629207611,
0.29795852303504944,
-1.1466147899627686,
-0.27770283818244934,
-0.31163114309310913,
-0.34530743956565857,
-0.6996534466743469,
-0.7999461889266968,
0.39683520793914795,
-0.09841824322938919,
-0.07778075337409973,
0.19042503833770752,
-0.2663038372993469,
0.26399746537208557,
0.3613007962703705,
-0.12585218250751495,
0.312129408121109,
-0.10657557100057602,
-0.23830823600292206,
-0.09110789746046066,
-0.5433727502822876,
-0.7751716375350952,
0.721737802028656,
0.42343413829803467,
1.035415768623352,
0.02454036846756935,
0.8423087000846863,
0.15333744883537292,
-0.21729159355163574,
-0.9774491190910339,
0.8058573007583618,
-0.11473064124584198,
-0.3392859399318695,
0.00535986665636301,
-0.05078522488474846,
-1.193917155265808,
0.5002013444900513,
-0.23193234205245972,
-0.6329652070999146,
0.010143342427909374,
0.2401699274778366,
-0.1793166697025299,
0.20203834772109985,
-0.4487980902194977,
0.6411324143409729,
0.16030004620552063,
-0.03948500007390976,
-0.5018662810325623,
-0.5023439526557922,
0.17519566416740417,
0.20468278229236603,
0.15929700434207916,
-0.009663245640695095,
-0.22518470883369446,
0.8866412043571472,
-0.5000027418136597,
0.9595699906349182,
-0.14070118963718414,
-0.08287430554628372,
0.34524476528167725,
-0.03806648403406143,
0.6993447542190552,
-0.31113386154174805,
-0.003977139946073294,
-0.16169653832912445,
-0.12009461224079132,
-0.20652596652507782,
-0.8559890389442444,
0.6828383207321167,
-0.33709582686424255,
-0.6750774383544922,
-0.44567903876304626,
-0.4372205436229706,
-0.2701443135738373,
-0.034817520529031754,
0.11308838427066803,
0.5194973945617676,
0.022756755352020264,
0.20562058687210083,
0.7474113702774048,
-0.12019019573926926,
0.41623881459236145,
0.046443499624729156,
-0.3039053976535797,
0.003701380919665098,
0.6169866323471069,
0.15848663449287415,
0.450325071811676,
0.4366496503353119,
0.15004001557826996,
-0.2924484312534332,
-0.5982003211975098,
-0.3349648416042328,
0.31553852558135986,
-1.1170274019241333,
-0.11794785410165787,
-0.7419508695602417,
-0.020599016919732094,
-0.03977058455348015,
-0.04358337074518204,
-0.19338737428188324,
-0.3942607343196869,
-0.1342240273952484,
-0.1721794456243515,
0.5676230192184448,
0.9948282837867737,
0.2325594276189804,
0.31887999176979065,
-0.6238585710525513,
0.008165661245584488,
0.30124908685684204,
0.1750173568725586,
0.3930642008781433,
0.05596721172332764,
-0.32712140679359436,
-0.1274261474609375,
-0.28628596663475037,
-0.9096820950508118,
0.283576101064682,
0.049280885607004166,
0.4895537793636322,
0.058965157717466354,
0.02315565012395382,
0.6361339688301086,
-0.7047134637832642,
0.8813830018043518,
0.20270565152168274,
-0.8140622973442078,
0.4358888864517212,
-0.21259865164756775,
0.6814572811126709,
0.19699376821517944,
0.15013128519058228,
-0.7828531861305237,
-0.861120879650116,
-0.42866000533103943,
-0.942160427570343,
0.46718546748161316,
0.1200597807765007,
0.48567917943000793,
-0.5475621819496155,
0.10920409858226776,
-0.09775015711784363,
0.10775728523731232,
-0.8443409204483032,
-0.22266492247581482,
-0.024460764601826668,
-0.13043341040611267,
0.27679187059402466,
-0.4091682434082031,
0.3953498303890228,
0.17816032469272614,
0.40483424067497253,
-0.015747597441077232,
0.6437758207321167,
0.28425905108451843,
-0.0781492367386818,
-0.034621525555849075,
0.5785982608795166,
0.22125603258609772,
0.4420231580734253,
0.0666181892156601,
0.48954203724861145,
0.06930198520421982,
-0.22615563869476318,
-0.0918659046292305,
-0.08917941898107529,
0.14801596105098724,
0.12765535712242126,
0.6971497535705566,
0.7445254921913147,
0.5817621946334839,
-0.7527758479118347,
0.29398244619369507,
0.2734667956829071,
0.17306295037269592,
-0.527670681476593,
0.05044286325573921,
0.16417327523231506,
0.05604021996259689,
0.3914707601070404,
-0.061346061527729034,
0.20762202143669128,
-0.6079804301261902,
0.03876228630542755,
0.5132823586463928,
-0.3539822995662689,
-0.25735628604888916,
0.5075995326042175,
-0.11991924792528152,
0.04908246174454689,
0.5519886612892151,
-0.18789176642894745,
-0.6980041861534119,
0.3518028259277344,
0.6979967355728149,
0.7624439597129822,
-0.14973002672195435,
-0.10994494706392288,
0.27376678586006165,
0.057547375559806824,
0.039968591183423996,
0.1433146446943283,
0.06693466752767563,
-0.869620680809021,
-0.9105589985847473,
-0.7208583950996399,
-0.21520116925239563,
-0.24874605238437653,
-0.5642306804656982,
0.3267402946949005,
-0.40601810812950134,
-0.17872782051563263,
0.009609530679881573,
-0.20966260135173798,
-0.5053752660751343,
0.01695892959833145,
0.42254549264907837,
0.7812172174453735,
-0.6933732628822327,
0.6996394395828247,
0.7591277956962585,
-0.2446381002664566,
-0.5741888880729675,
-0.07705489546060562,
0.0429137721657753,
-0.7862332463264465,
0.8673323392868042,
0.34161698818206787,
-0.3642822206020355,
-0.052791353315114975,
-0.3769114911556244,
-0.696120023727417,
0.9434522390365601,
0.2622098922729492,
-0.40616574883461,
-0.31376686692237854,
0.338988721370697,
0.6648903489112854,
-0.7416231036186218,
-0.009853901341557503,
0.26122599840164185,
0.4495892822742462,
0.3273879587650299,
-0.6213217973709106,
0.43454495072364807,
-0.15164050459861755,
0.5083811283111572,
0.5477114915847778,
0.022241666913032532,
0.7546632885932922,
-0.178304061293602,
-0.29495036602020264,
-0.09393391013145447,
0.6909436583518982,
0.5476179718971252,
-0.19808635115623474,
0.40052756667137146,
0.37624436616897583,
0.6093796491622925,
0.0327591635286808,
1.4307060241699219,
-0.001796669908799231,
-0.02243337780237198,
1.010053277015686,
0.1634918600320816,
0.9285024404525757,
0.9358702301979065,
-0.07594247907400131,
0.7702152729034424,
0.3637266457080841,
-0.011117961257696152,
0.5260683298110962,
0.699076771736145,
-0.38886165618896484,
-0.2861506938934326,
-0.10135038942098618,
-0.27704402804374695,
0.339445561170578,
0.732040286064148,
-0.5379350781440735,
-0.5701403617858887,
0.026679839938879013,
-0.021714018657803535,
0.08895088732242584,
-0.3234845697879791,
0.7669407725334167,
0.39716413617134094,
-0.5869762301445007,
0.4596986472606659,
0.027023104950785637,
0.698746919631958,
-0.7718634605407715,
-0.42599019408226013,
0.4128873944282532,
0.08792077749967575,
-0.13447920978069305,
-0.8689205646514893,
0.5116473436355591,
-0.28575634956359863,
-0.29285913705825806,
-0.42629921436309814,
0.7658047676086426,
-0.44778504967689514,
-0.3539927899837494,
0.7685437202453613,
0.4165800213813782,
0.04005345329642296,
-0.15913203358650208,
-0.4601697623729706,
0.33895522356033325,
-0.2543701231479645,
-0.33428534865379333,
0.3355672359466553,
0.748216986656189,
-0.3083778917789459,
0.6626784801483154,
0.30365803837776184,
0.10496221482753754,
0.2799741327762604,
0.02119087241590023,
0.9244897365570068,
-0.9574912786483765,
-0.24348734319210052,
-1.0366307497024536,
0.6065347790718079,
0.09081699699163437,
-0.05713530257344246,
0.6346245408058167,
0.14047816395759583,
0.6650769710540771,
-0.13618898391723633,
0.6779571175575256,
-0.2492600381374359,
0.1313108205795288,
-0.92002272605896,
0.3629593253135681,
-0.1868313103914261,
0.48013418912887573,
-0.33818912506103516,
-0.8851066827774048,
-0.36608225107192993,
0.5386632084846497,
-0.4399462640285492,
-0.06991203874349594,
0.7933977246284485,
0.4751649498939514,
0.11910014599561691,
0.2031306028366089,
0.19183015823364258,
0.21964401006698608,
0.29030442237854004,
0.5837671756744385,
1.148363471031189,
-0.17673639953136444,
0.2844916880130768,
-0.025760548189282417,
0.04018661752343178,
0.06201271340250969,
-1.0741305351257324,
-0.7961762547492981,
-0.6276476979255676,
-0.233098104596138,
-0.24245025217533112,
-0.1655709147453308,
1.1510891914367676,
0.3276219069957733,
-0.659692108631134,
-0.3112576901912689,
-0.21820485591888428,
0.18873414397239685,
-0.07774785161018372,
-0.15626926720142365,
0.34379681944847107,
-0.8071333169937134,
-0.5989271998405457,
0.17265261709690094,
0.12322205305099487,
0.11994487047195435,
-0.5221223831176758,
0.01686333864927292,
-0.1477692723274231,
-0.17122581601142883,
0.8912810683250427,
-0.16285987198352814,
-0.9707172513008118,
-0.4036198556423187,
-0.15190604329109192,
0.2843639552593231,
0.008682029321789742,
0.9924415349960327,
-1.007546305656433,
0.45274701714515686,
0.3776220977306366,
0.5697243213653564,
0.463243693113327,
-0.31571656465530396,
1.0371589660644531,
-0.6881850361824036,
-0.017938874661922455,
0.37103939056396484,
0.5797715783119202,
0.34189245104789734,
-0.19027844071388245,
0.21719898283481598,
-0.03405078500509262,
-0.2383263260126114,
-0.49787434935569763,
0.3203904628753662,
-0.9105077385902405,
-0.21204423904418945,
1.210775375366211,
-0.027656733989715576,
-0.5112706422805786,
-0.3177146315574646,
-0.08449232578277588,
-0.07524976879358292,
-0.502668023109436,
0.3482961654663086,
1.0125746726989746,
-0.33703336119651794,
-0.16548766195774078,
-0.8659763336181641,
0.3835771977901459,
0.2339310497045517,
-0.3937629759311676,
0.40548691153526306,
0.470865935087204,
-0.10812892764806747,
0.42001354694366455,
0.3479743003845215,
-0.48533084988594055,
-0.014941062778234482,
-0.10173340141773224,
0.03643689304590225,
0.124569833278656,
0.11544219404459,
-0.36267903447151184,
-0.0528130829334259,
0.34580084681510925,
0.010669891722500324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01490v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01490v1
|
Controllable Text Generation in the Instruction-Tuning Era
| 2024-05-02T17:24:30 | 2024-05-02T17:24:30 |
Dhananjay Ashok, Barnabas Poczos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While most research on controllable text generation has focused on steering
base Language Models, the emerging instruction-tuning and prompting paradigm
offers an alternate approach to controllability. We compile and release
ConGenBench, a testbed of 17 different controllable generation tasks, using a
subset of it to benchmark the performance of 9 different baselines and methods
on Instruction-tuned Language Models. To our surprise, we find that
prompting-based approaches outperform controllable text generation methods on
most datasets and tasks, highlighting a need for research on controllable text
generation with Instruction-tuned Language Models in specific. Prompt-based
approaches match human performance on most stylistic tasks while lagging on
structural tasks, foregrounding a need to study more varied constraints and
more challenging stylistic tasks. To facilitate such research, we provide an
algorithm that uses only a task dataset and a Large Language Model with
in-context capabilities to automatically generate a constraint dataset. This
method eliminates the fields dependence on pre-curated constraint datasets,
hence vastly expanding the range of constraints that can be studied in the
future.
|
[
-0.19278085231781006,
-0.7834028601646423,
0.17991238832473755,
0.35219067335128784,
0.041799549013376236,
-0.09229675680398941,
-0.5697748064994812,
-0.22847795486450195,
-0.310776948928833,
0.7033060789108276,
-0.9639586806297302,
-0.4518366754055023,
-0.2715747356414795,
0.2883073389530182,
-0.2408865988254547,
0.9554734230041504,
-0.22491338849067688,
-0.17230232059955597,
-0.22003968060016632,
0.051760487258434296,
-0.8530375361442566,
-0.42078834772109985,
-0.5429165363311768,
-0.3829350471496582,
0.3242027461528778,
0.6421988010406494,
0.5333879590034485,
0.9547739028930664,
0.2985769808292389,
0.24397847056388855,
0.06443719565868378,
0.38660886883735657,
-0.2970416247844696,
0.36151841282844543,
-0.12436080724000931,
-0.2610825002193451,
-0.18942058086395264,
0.1525876224040985,
0.5398819446563721,
0.5693359375,
-0.03071160800755024,
0.005061333067715168,
0.260368287563324,
0.6114238500595093,
-0.7315484285354614,
0.0027407584711909294,
-0.553070068359375,
-0.06510864198207855,
-0.4838912785053253,
-0.38203468918800354,
-0.8346255421638489,
-0.43084239959716797,
-0.21940003335475922,
-0.5702433586120605,
0.47942599654197693,
0.41165944933891296,
0.8409307599067688,
0.5900135636329651,
-0.32156696915626526,
-0.44596067070961,
-0.4638887047767639,
0.8280482292175293,
-0.45907583832740784,
0.4245630204677582,
0.46321165561676025,
0.017063098028302193,
-0.316598504781723,
-0.4779720902442932,
-0.27074283361434937,
-0.513384222984314,
-0.08022650331258774,
0.12580527365207672,
0.0730273425579071,
0.16141265630722046,
0.4511726200580597,
0.21786215901374817,
-0.6192406415939331,
0.23826904594898224,
-0.05210128054022789,
-0.22080343961715698,
0.46983420848846436,
0.10333716869354248,
0.23923838138580322,
-0.452925443649292,
-0.24839097261428833,
-0.41751202940940857,
-0.8235334157943726,
0.2010105401277542,
0.4925944209098816,
0.36863741278648376,
-0.08599120378494263,
0.5572656393051147,
-0.2287558615207672,
1.0880610942840576,
0.4677674174308777,
0.24808639287948608,
-0.15370067954063416,
-0.35366344451904297,
-0.14505380392074585,
0.0411863774061203,
0.7667225003242493,
0.3680257797241211,
0.2708708643913269,
-0.022017918527126312,
-0.15150730311870575,
-0.03653150424361229,
0.2670174837112427,
-0.5671539306640625,
-0.5035226941108704,
-0.049424611032009125,
-0.12237382680177689,
-0.28621748089790344,
-0.05975378677248955,
-0.6391346454620361,
-0.3076968491077423,
-0.5073757767677307,
0.04119131714105606,
-0.5876611471176147,
0.1579606980085373,
-0.2992526888847351,
-0.1834784746170044,
0.13866262137889862,
-0.0253201462328434,
-1.1428256034851074,
0.12317541241645813,
0.6056705713272095,
0.5715222954750061,
-0.6306838393211365,
-0.04363343492150307,
-0.554866373538971,
0.18054145574569702,
-0.6101778149604797,
0.47665032744407654,
-0.6768823862075806,
-0.6047772765159607,
0.08596732467412949,
0.033366233110427856,
-0.0729178935289383,
-0.6440114378929138,
0.2889541685581207,
-0.4120444059371948,
0.25688278675079346,
-0.3037966787815094,
-0.7041829228401184,
0.3158869445323944,
0.12704673409461975,
-0.6525766253471375,
1.1910464763641357,
0.3122080862522125,
-0.47895434498786926,
0.5613342523574829,
-0.256968230009079,
-0.4625259339809418,
0.17531925439834595,
-0.43874502182006836,
-0.42525961995124817,
0.034387294203042984,
-0.06117257475852966,
0.2901023328304291,
-0.4201269745826721,
0.6231560111045837,
0.22828702628612518,
-0.057181861251592636,
0.1038103848695755,
-0.40652701258659363,
0.647638201713562,
0.16441836953163147,
-0.6425800919532776,
0.17303693294525146,
-0.8415980339050293,
0.3465283513069153,
-0.2745702564716339,
-0.46208587288856506,
-0.1070617288351059,
0.04616028815507889,
0.047255098819732666,
-0.003835299052298069,
0.5579782128334045,
-0.36909711360931396,
0.1360783576965332,
-0.1679009199142456,
0.26556360721588135,
0.6833211779594421,
0.11595378071069717,
0.4670522212982178,
-0.32852187752723694,
0.6244721412658691,
-0.29767391085624695,
-0.06638923287391663,
-0.3142843544483185,
-0.11491016298532486,
-0.6787248849868774,
-0.014237002469599247,
0.1848805546760559,
0.6676991581916809,
-0.7680144906044006,
0.4857897162437439,
0.13474127650260925,
-0.5150881409645081,
-0.1847005933523178,
0.3005971312522888,
0.9279450178146362,
0.7228989601135254,
0.3706628084182739,
0.06626281887292862,
-0.3898940980434418,
-1.00047767162323,
-0.2631348669528961,
0.09597522765398026,
-0.1695844978094101,
0.4348759651184082,
0.12656691670417786,
0.34680694341659546,
0.7890735268592834,
-0.5615033507347107,
0.18194623291492462,
-0.2519904375076294,
0.41669410467147827,
-0.16941417753696442,
0.9487241506576538,
0.39812788367271423,
-0.7355666160583496,
-0.6333777904510498,
0.016122540459036827,
-0.48587796092033386,
-0.5757684707641602,
-0.2508082687854767,
-0.25325721502304077,
0.368366539478302,
0.9170355796813965,
-0.25151070952415466,
0.17408518493175507,
0.6562570333480835,
-0.3123153746128082,
0.7542874217033386,
-0.20861895382404327,
0.14527030289173126,
-1.0601445436477661,
0.28421634435653687,
-0.06439920514822006,
-0.17110955715179443,
-0.4914710819721222,
-0.006982782389968634,
0.43791842460632324,
-0.3282955586910248,
-0.0880797877907753,
0.49950480461120605,
-0.5941159129142761,
0.4403218626976013,
-0.2836357653141022,
-0.09125319868326187,
0.003500823862850666,
0.5687862038612366,
0.007875984534621239,
0.9688751697540283,
0.29481932520866394,
-0.8518199324607849,
0.19084686040878296,
0.40886157751083374,
-0.3772921562194824,
0.5333459377288818,
-0.7292802929878235,
-0.03467694669961929,
-0.024868588894605637,
0.12316019088029861,
-0.7520778179168701,
-0.6358801126480103,
0.3014499843120575,
-0.12078958749771118,
0.6398958563804626,
0.1528475135564804,
-0.26974886655807495,
-0.31795093417167664,
0.08259931206703186,
0.17754682898521423,
0.5034856796264648,
-0.5006908178329468,
0.06576355546712875,
-0.06904280185699463,
-0.4467143416404724,
-0.40712350606918335,
-0.4915470480918884,
-0.11259935796260834,
-0.10198606550693512,
-0.1844351887702942,
0.6789736151695251,
-0.299513578414917,
-0.14347133040428162,
-0.27394506335258484,
-0.1747780293226242,
0.04885060340166092,
0.07337772101163864,
0.35357412695884705,
0.376406192779541,
0.0024013074580579996,
0.23447185754776,
0.45816612243652344,
-0.08777318894863129,
-0.041146572679281235,
-0.2279668003320694,
0.40688270330429077,
0.3760688006877899,
-0.15675045549869537,
-0.43821629881858826,
0.5095941424369812,
0.10554898530244827,
-0.34941864013671875,
0.4138018488883972,
-0.06358177214860916,
0.08754030615091324,
-0.6681388020515442,
-0.28602346777915955,
-0.14689436554908752,
-0.5806984305381775,
0.22572842240333557,
-0.2628803849220276,
-0.9387248754501343,
-0.011968407779932022,
-0.11238307505846024,
0.4056437015533447,
0.08822152018547058,
0.5115640759468079,
0.10434368252754211,
1.0587152242660522,
0.791467010974884,
0.19950968027114868,
0.888112485408783,
0.3224874436855316,
-0.24020645022392273,
-0.4734812378883362,
-0.09880666434764862,
-0.8531206250190735,
-0.3169538378715515,
-0.8801149725914001,
-0.01790628582239151,
0.21295194327831268,
0.09017256647348404,
-0.29425475001335144,
0.43916821479797363,
-0.9072733521461487,
0.5681341290473938,
0.7360088229179382,
0.07864160090684891,
0.04569156840443611,
-0.24552245438098907,
-0.11779420077800751,
-0.11349201947450638,
-0.6923407316207886,
-0.469565749168396,
0.8223192691802979,
-0.3467811942100525,
0.6385880708694458,
-0.29677340388298035,
0.5647372007369995,
0.24521894752979279,
0.3837438225746155,
-0.48935461044311523,
0.5186818838119507,
-0.4184131324291229,
-0.6742563843727112,
-0.22372402250766754,
-0.5537562370300293,
-0.9124442934989929,
-0.3891852796077728,
-0.030269984155893326,
-0.7932055592536926,
0.09845416992902756,
0.7229226231575012,
-0.190337672829628,
-0.1622483730316162,
-0.7337066531181335,
0.9223275780677795,
-0.1040012314915657,
-0.485330730676651,
0.21672724187374115,
-0.6806690692901611,
0.2855542302131653,
0.08715440332889557,
-0.13858461380004883,
-0.007246249821037054,
-0.007760665379464626,
0.5884668231010437,
-0.36156079173088074,
0.8393166065216064,
-0.20674429833889008,
-0.4048066735267639,
0.28577208518981934,
0.33681321144104004,
0.7244880199432373,
-0.3500808775424957,
-0.14541016519069672,
-0.48069947957992554,
-0.19894437491893768,
-0.2950809895992279,
-0.44993022084236145,
0.8346700072288513,
-0.422638863325119,
-0.6090665459632874,
0.12433487176895142,
-0.8465263247489929,
-0.4965324103832245,
0.30766594409942627,
0.9427165985107422,
0.704317569732666,
-0.2236981838941574,
0.19513662159442902,
0.8295799493789673,
-0.2053375095129013,
0.5258589386940002,
0.2489355504512787,
0.11807113885879517,
-0.30575481057167053,
1.11003839969635,
0.13096053898334503,
0.36478716135025024,
0.5588057041168213,
0.08323989808559418,
-0.22363658249378204,
-0.42350250482559204,
-0.5210972428321838,
-0.10190389305353165,
-0.33386313915252686,
-0.13574127852916718,
-0.27867159247398376,
-0.08996894955635071,
-0.32679852843284607,
-0.5387940406799316,
-0.1811281144618988,
-0.42318272590637207,
-0.3377842903137207,
0.004325456917285919,
0.3014224171638489,
0.6845500469207764,
0.13781651854515076,
0.5490225553512573,
-0.6965238451957703,
0.24235236644744873,
0.22518663108348846,
0.3214634656906128,
-0.37953829765319824,
-0.1901351511478424,
-0.20866234600543976,
-0.18032367527484894,
-0.5290185809135437,
-0.96291184425354,
0.21908412873744965,
0.2541506886482239,
0.344235360622406,
0.2702549993991852,
0.3009977638721466,
0.3229888677597046,
-0.6846191883087158,
0.8301364779472351,
-0.05071888491511345,
-0.8373833298683167,
0.6893938779830933,
-0.5046072602272034,
0.5399488210678101,
0.7010533213615417,
0.2692306339740753,
-0.3302898108959198,
-0.7221848964691162,
-0.6682078838348389,
-0.7635406851768494,
0.7735431790351868,
0.1453654170036316,
0.026424847543239594,
-0.138837993144989,
0.4260912835597992,
0.32500576972961426,
0.5004881620407104,
-0.33621513843536377,
-0.16368618607521057,
-0.1398429274559021,
-0.6274415850639343,
-0.23966842889785767,
-0.002711605280637741,
-0.19111259281635284,
0.19728121161460876,
0.7596890330314636,
-0.1531904935836792,
-0.15862621366977692,
0.08106744289398193,
-0.11896329373121262,
-0.15402357280254364,
0.42248299717903137,
0.6394087672233582,
0.32426080107688904,
0.10148952156305313,
-0.006379523314535618,
-0.2600657343864441,
-0.37434035539627075,
0.27922216057777405,
0.24919837713241577,
-0.7454590797424316,
0.024024508893489838,
0.10260790586471558,
0.9174232482910156,
0.27207624912261963,
-0.6932176947593689,
0.05850514769554138,
0.21671746671199799,
-0.3053455352783203,
-0.008137847296893597,
0.5552574992179871,
-0.2606884837150574,
-0.025743719190359116,
-0.00038741424214094877,
-0.03357306122779846,
-0.13956820964813232,
0.058505166321992874,
0.30376559495925903,
0.3634624481201172,
-0.5649166703224182,
-0.18070831894874573,
1.0508513450622559,
0.3910655677318573,
-0.36924609541893005,
0.44524452090263367,
-0.19609789550304413,
-0.01845771260559559,
0.7265075445175171,
0.6682120561599731,
0.7680539488792419,
-0.21446000039577484,
0.3311704695224762,
0.5415567755699158,
0.2655141353607178,
-0.17217910289764404,
0.3480015695095062,
-0.4249037206172943,
-0.5538769960403442,
-0.4086320698261261,
-0.4110512137413025,
-0.6594206690788269,
0.12590894103050232,
-0.9014056921005249,
0.04876887425780296,
-0.5564573407173157,
-0.18139980733394623,
-0.01979677379131317,
-0.048781730234622955,
-0.2967027425765991,
0.3141370415687561,
-0.12105824053287506,
0.9964714646339417,
-0.6451051235198975,
0.5387657284736633,
0.6512541174888611,
-0.017885398119688034,
-0.8652356266975403,
0.0540582574903965,
0.15025967359542847,
-0.417201966047287,
0.4528164863586426,
0.24913381040096283,
0.01560468040406704,
0.4591236710548401,
-1.0654821395874023,
-0.46643418073654175,
0.7892984747886658,
0.29653626680374146,
-0.7436693906784058,
-0.09330614656209946,
-0.08885424584150314,
0.2833482623100281,
-0.03096572682261467,
-0.34989869594573975,
0.724126398563385,
0.673578143119812,
-0.14419524371623993,
-0.6546669006347656,
0.2058105617761612,
-0.3568817973136902,
0.002470310777425766,
0.5141044855117798,
-0.7561464905738831,
0.7614338994026184,
0.29780566692352295,
-0.2891117036342621,
0.2812744975090027,
0.8182908296585083,
0.42834073305130005,
0.07249733805656433,
0.34272298216819763,
0.2643316388130188,
0.8984910845756531,
-0.24860110878944397,
1.0130809545516968,
-0.6137202382087708,
-0.15905289351940155,
1.358550786972046,
-0.2528403699398041,
0.5585318803787231,
0.41715964674949646,
0.22521016001701355,
0.3963435888290405,
0.5733969211578369,
-0.04655148461461067,
0.39147230982780457,
0.14539499580860138,
-0.2563835680484772,
-0.33652061223983765,
-0.4930332899093628,
-0.14616969227790833,
0.2584076523780823,
0.28173530101776123,
-0.3048993647098541,
-0.10936664789915085,
0.062184542417526245,
0.20362913608551025,
0.39328059554100037,
-0.19481973350048065,
0.699002206325531,
-0.19664965569972992,
-1.35056734085083,
0.6552591919898987,
-0.08216340094804764,
0.5789021253585815,
-0.9393136501312256,
-0.023908616974949837,
-0.19679494202136993,
-0.007701090071350336,
0.17597432434558868,
-0.48150238394737244,
0.00419753510504961,
0.22155526280403137,
-0.33176881074905396,
-0.7369175553321838,
0.5888793468475342,
-0.7160836458206177,
-0.22013819217681885,
-0.2774653732776642,
0.4222835302352905,
-0.19231285154819489,
0.3234784007072449,
-0.3996662199497223,
-0.08359431475400925,
0.2104686200618744,
-0.4951837956905365,
0.22581347823143005,
0.5674441456794739,
-0.2909921705722809,
0.492634654045105,
0.4153044521808624,
0.059340838342905045,
0.3103925585746765,
-0.19938808679580688,
0.6978544592857361,
-0.7300732731819153,
-0.564609169960022,
-0.5241171717643738,
0.3554486036300659,
-0.07613807916641235,
-0.6660053133964539,
0.7382625341415405,
0.3911561071872711,
0.840950071811676,
-0.11580173671245575,
0.906559944152832,
-0.4546830654144287,
0.386218398809433,
-0.7895820736885071,
0.6278674602508545,
-0.4547363817691803,
-0.24160869419574738,
-0.07719819992780685,
-0.5511881113052368,
-0.07066446542739868,
0.12536069750785828,
-0.13612690567970276,
0.08126471191644669,
0.6468355059623718,
1.039802074432373,
0.188077911734581,
-0.03561454638838768,
0.0894990786910057,
-0.03067297488451004,
0.1610717475414276,
0.4623456597328186,
0.6570749282836914,
0.11754123121500015,
0.48255082964897156,
-0.32723358273506165,
-0.3633953034877777,
-0.07613134384155273,
-0.9855268001556396,
-0.8937709331512451,
-0.6027421355247498,
-0.23677536845207214,
-0.22126765549182892,
0.037735067307949066,
0.8292524218559265,
0.6234104037284851,
-0.9411493539810181,
-0.2043251246213913,
-0.6695421934127808,
0.005554053001105785,
-0.48050597310066223,
-0.24762889742851257,
0.29362159967422485,
-0.5937661528587341,
-1.014898657798767,
0.7125471830368042,
-0.023446716368198395,
0.35075438022613525,
-0.003838054370135069,
-0.012381942011415958,
0.13488806784152985,
0.080462247133255,
0.1222451701760292,
0.6140716671943665,
-0.12060337513685226,
-0.15072476863861084,
0.21710340678691864,
-0.332561194896698,
-0.09218642860651016,
1.1978398561477661,
-0.5136128067970276,
0.466264545917511,
0.6072479486465454,
0.6167028546333313,
0.14363549649715424,
0.3126949965953827,
1.0010849237442017,
-1.4254008531570435,
0.2469804733991623,
0.11349046230316162,
-0.16173741221427917,
0.22996960580348969,
-0.4248186945915222,
0.2235931009054184,
-0.027365993708372116,
-0.743073582649231,
-0.5697349905967712,
0.5844902396202087,
-0.7700337767601013,
-0.2874760329723358,
0.8693989515304565,
0.025922968983650208,
-0.310588002204895,
0.03350592777132988,
-0.3503124415874481,
0.41316312551498413,
-0.5162711143493652,
0.6316766142845154,
0.768552839756012,
-0.2758861482143402,
-0.1818786859512329,
-0.5080764293670654,
1.0001881122589111,
0.6825768947601318,
-0.9201111793518066,
0.40538591146469116,
0.9514353275299072,
-0.1805073469877243,
-0.06594415754079819,
0.4511931538581848,
0.21464964747428894,
0.364690363407135,
-0.006255707237869501,
0.14397817850112915,
-0.28146037459373474,
-0.6407042145729065,
-0.00417063944041729,
0.2789810597896576,
-0.13416238129138947,
-0.04382948577404022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01483v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01483v2
|
MANTIS: Interleaved Multi-Image Instruction Tuning
| 2024-05-02T17:14:57 | 2024-05-23T18:57:44 |
Dongfu Jiang, Xuan He, Huaye Zeng, Cong Wei, Max Ku, Qian Liu, Wenhu Chen
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large multimodal models (LMMs) have shown great results in single-image
vision language tasks. However, their abilities to solve multi-image visual
language tasks is yet to be improved. The existing LMMs like OpenFlamingo,
Emu2, Idefics gain their multi-image ability through pre-training on hundreds
of millions of noisy interleaved image-text data from the web, which is neither
efficient nor effective. In this paper, we aim to build strong multi-image LMMs
via instruction tuning with academic-level resources. Therefore, we
meticulously construct Mantis-Instruct containing 721K multi-image instruction
data to train a family of models Mantis. The instruction tuning empowers Mantis
with different multi-image skills like co-reference, comparison, reasoning, and
temporal understanding. We evaluate Mantis on five multi-image benchmarks and
seven single-image benchmarks. Mantis-SigLIP can achieve SoTA results on all
the multi-image benchmarks and beat the strongest multi-image baseline,
Idefics2-8B by an average of 11 absolute points. Notably, Idefics2-8B was
pre-trained on 140M interleaved multi-image data, which is 200x larger than
Mantis-Instruct. We observe that Mantis performs equivalently well on the
held-in and held-out benchmarks, which shows its generalization ability.
Notably, we found that Mantis can even match the performance of GPT-4V on
multi-image benchmarks. We further evaluate Mantis on single-image benchmarks
and demonstrate that Mantis also maintains a strong single-image performance on
par with CogVLM and Emu2. Our results show that multi-image abilities are not
necessarily gained through massive pre-training, instead, it can be gained by
the low-cost instruction tuning. Our work provides new perspectives on how to
improve LMMs' multi-image abilities.
|
[
-0.7414304614067078,
-0.34292855858802795,
0.2147735208272934,
0.16680434346199036,
-0.42068687081336975,
0.1942124217748642,
-0.471887469291687,
-0.3843229115009308,
0.037471190094947815,
0.16119815409183502,
-0.6890166401863098,
-0.4091012477874756,
-0.7277867197990417,
0.11762051284313202,
0.021037286147475243,
0.9106385111808777,
0.14337927103042603,
0.2596243619918823,
-0.09946434199810028,
-0.43325021862983704,
-0.36646631360054016,
-0.04235006123781204,
-0.6154383420944214,
0.12462195008993149,
0.4628349244594574,
0.6464799046516418,
0.730574905872345,
0.6613654494285583,
0.5742758512496948,
0.31901100277900696,
0.1388617306947708,
0.6207674145698547,
-0.39808106422424316,
-0.2284145951271057,
-0.0363365113735199,
-0.32035380601882935,
-0.37903106212615967,
-0.026319485157728195,
0.6490800380706787,
0.055180396884679794,
-0.19303852319717407,
0.20569662749767303,
-0.03990247845649719,
0.6556413173675537,
-0.7926372289657593,
0.22351354360580444,
-0.4020199179649353,
-0.004040997009724379,
-0.35600388050079346,
-0.640135645866394,
-0.6414018273353577,
-0.1550363004207611,
-0.052567388862371445,
-0.936711847782135,
0.14652761816978455,
0.0008213295368477702,
0.9662907719612122,
0.615178644657135,
-0.2832569479942322,
-0.19340801239013672,
-0.4357473850250244,
0.8071024417877197,
-0.5677011013031006,
0.5128369331359863,
0.2781008183956146,
0.5371344089508057,
0.0630432739853859,
-0.5470845103263855,
-0.2242453545331955,
-0.016438795253634453,
-0.007346243131905794,
0.24119968712329865,
0.010853470303118229,
0.06407775729894638,
0.28771764039993286,
0.2019689530134201,
-0.34132489562034607,
0.22586891055107117,
-0.5836082100868225,
-0.12022867798805237,
0.38612809777259827,
0.07103022187948227,
-0.05033011734485626,
0.36346450448036194,
-0.47361475229263306,
-0.5134947896003723,
-0.7099383473396301,
0.026960277929902077,
0.44181689620018005,
-0.09498922526836395,
-0.18000905215740204,
0.26122021675109863,
-0.016923589631915092,
0.6894296407699585,
0.10695488750934601,
-0.575897216796875,
0.09906461089849472,
-0.4187787175178528,
0.009993074461817741,
-0.08553379029035568,
0.5787061452865601,
0.25818613171577454,
0.5133572220802307,
-0.010181020945310593,
-0.059570059180259705,
0.11804018914699554,
0.21132752299308777,
-1.1308497190475464,
-0.17432080209255219,
-0.15893831849098206,
-0.2906644642353058,
0.06410548835992813,
0.05717896670103073,
-0.9664331078529358,
-0.03418857976794243,
-0.46206068992614746,
0.4878905713558197,
-0.7744642496109009,
-0.26244157552719116,
-0.007420174777507782,
-0.030371922999620438,
0.2279675304889679,
0.44790440797805786,
-0.9836918711662292,
0.09702136367559433,
0.25911030173301697,
0.7004252076148987,
0.28355443477630615,
-0.6159707307815552,
-0.6272552609443665,
0.033805567771196365,
-0.43300628662109375,
0.8088881373405457,
-0.863216757774353,
0.022152481600642204,
-0.09369924664497375,
-0.040986813604831696,
-0.1356383115053177,
-0.6077478528022766,
0.22702987492084503,
-0.45764628052711487,
0.18716736137866974,
-0.11822228878736496,
-0.4094111919403076,
-0.2147458791732788,
0.1291300505399704,
-0.422389417886734,
0.5281062126159668,
0.07590445131063461,
-0.5002352595329285,
0.3315192461013794,
-0.9022969603538513,
-0.4162620007991791,
-0.0530068464577198,
-0.4347544312477112,
-0.5717730522155762,
0.012458676472306252,
0.4387044310569763,
0.5929310917854309,
-0.42544347047805786,
0.10399644821882248,
-0.2543463408946991,
-0.4327910542488098,
0.021863052621483803,
-0.41776135563850403,
0.43315833806991577,
0.2212955504655838,
-0.4826434254646301,
0.1651802361011505,
-0.7223570346832275,
0.17995694279670715,
0.14154337346553802,
-0.3669600486755371,
-0.24712152779102325,
-0.13135291635990143,
-0.28606486320495605,
0.010858731344342232,
-0.09508959203958511,
-0.3447348475456238,
0.33790361881256104,
-0.05873137712478638,
0.47808146476745605,
0.8005682826042175,
-0.20831792056560516,
0.4044402539730072,
0.029984410852193832,
0.5182194709777832,
0.3294247090816498,
0.4671110510826111,
-0.7575394511222839,
-0.7966516017913818,
-0.9173795580863953,
-0.5002101063728333,
0.14753417670726776,
0.3052448332309723,
-1.141700267791748,
0.018795400857925415,
-0.16842249035835266,
-0.34707507491111755,
-0.8331719636917114,
0.10051315277814865,
0.9175817966461182,
0.24334971606731415,
0.7022560834884644,
-0.12984612584114075,
-0.14190736413002014,
-1.1339702606201172,
-0.07851716130971909,
0.46241694688796997,
0.17627428472042084,
0.17408625781536102,
0.5304209589958191,
-0.19331423938274384,
0.36345088481903076,
-0.6526787281036377,
-0.4241056740283966,
0.40505900979042053,
0.3725915253162384,
-0.005906871985644102,
0.4038121998310089,
0.7316104173660278,
-0.6335581541061401,
-0.3633049428462982,
0.0211504939943552,
-0.7304601073265076,
0.34190675616264343,
0.014230223372578621,
0.028723567724227905,
0.15180577337741852,
0.4394725561141968,
-0.2517721354961395,
0.3670172393321991,
0.5667028427124023,
-0.38050058484077454,
0.4529125988483429,
-0.7464397549629211,
0.6369652152061462,
-1.0091453790664673,
-0.3416219651699066,
0.3662267327308655,
-0.03306060656905174,
-0.4094878137111664,
0.5192575454711914,
0.44265156984329224,
-0.013693186454474926,
-0.5048178434371948,
0.10424166917800903,
-0.8068546652793884,
-0.18874980509281158,
-0.08331333100795746,
-0.39222660660743713,
-0.07308831810951233,
0.7484028935432434,
-0.14191538095474243,
1.21256422996521,
0.7601652145385742,
-0.6282774209976196,
0.2357136756181717,
0.06018442660570145,
-0.5387135148048401,
0.721928060054779,
-0.2659958600997925,
0.21663258969783783,
-0.24758155643939972,
0.015737291425466537,
-0.585964560508728,
-0.3086075186729431,
0.029311100021004677,
-0.1749628484249115,
0.6694012880325317,
-0.044441383332014084,
-0.5128703713417053,
-0.26925137639045715,
-0.31449809670448303,
0.45212364196777344,
0.2563629448413849,
-0.9112018942832947,
0.4126434326171875,
0.10375089198350906,
0.24465233087539673,
-0.7261584401130676,
-0.36658769845962524,
0.13865520060062408,
-0.07759102433919907,
-0.695115864276886,
0.38186243176460266,
-0.30627039074897766,
-0.07329430431127548,
0.0905710905790329,
0.24397675693035126,
-0.19259589910507202,
-0.13501900434494019,
0.1505121886730194,
0.010375423356890678,
-0.5448527932167053,
0.30709999799728394,
0.35875704884529114,
-0.2940348982810974,
-0.5111300349235535,
-0.16911879181861877,
0.39903056621551514,
-0.641042172908783,
-0.6238563656806946,
-0.6951315402984619,
0.13037915527820587,
0.7165708541870117,
-0.4880140721797943,
0.5643494129180908,
0.9270218014717102,
-0.20549273490905762,
-0.01028103195130825,
-0.5417235493659973,
-0.4140232801437378,
-0.5050392150878906,
0.34811508655548096,
-0.5812437534332275,
-0.760930597782135,
-0.11958928406238556,
-0.2671828866004944,
0.24821101129055023,
0.28208231925964355,
0.4316257834434509,
-0.36046284437179565,
0.9122946262359619,
0.4215339720249176,
0.27561309933662415,
0.4606494605541229,
-0.5530818104743958,
-0.23507891595363617,
-0.6915008425712585,
-0.23960570991039276,
-0.23244106769561768,
-0.6145455241203308,
-0.3002244830131531,
-0.6148746609687805,
0.6615251302719116,
-0.04435489699244499,
-0.1652013659477234,
0.4172535538673401,
-0.6728522181510925,
0.8250332474708557,
0.8387216329574585,
0.4766691029071808,
0.18873408436775208,
0.17134518921375275,
0.06746778637170792,
-0.35348862409591675,
-0.7618573904037476,
-0.2569569945335388,
1.044089674949646,
0.2002972960472107,
1.164963960647583,
0.24477368593215942,
0.374569296836853,
0.2638726234436035,
0.07501944899559021,
-0.3643189072608948,
0.47383758425712585,
-0.6422149538993835,
-0.34981775283813477,
-0.11242538690567017,
-0.11624190211296082,
-0.7922776341438293,
0.3182884752750397,
-0.5273475646972656,
-0.26853710412979126,
0.10116253048181534,
0.36689916253089905,
-0.4320928454399109,
0.4276246130466461,
-1.1169861555099487,
0.7427759170532227,
-0.5954828262329102,
-0.7298795580863953,
-0.634468138217926,
-0.6528847813606262,
0.47774121165275574,
0.1256180852651596,
0.1349150836467743,
0.027093539014458656,
0.022285960614681244,
0.5341700315475464,
-0.3125254809856415,
0.7406747937202454,
-0.19787102937698364,
-0.10687261819839478,
0.19771002233028412,
-0.24451187252998352,
0.20539945363998413,
0.16052760183811188,
0.21264737844467163,
0.34764978289604187,
0.22799448668956757,
-0.44858983159065247,
-0.45241230726242065,
0.719535768032074,
-1.0166603326797485,
-0.444221556186676,
-0.15868395566940308,
-0.4707811176776886,
-0.062286943197250366,
-0.053405072540044785,
0.3777760863304138,
0.9043592214584351,
0.1744748204946518,
0.40984776616096497,
0.8364357352256775,
-0.38309165835380554,
0.5271407961845398,
0.37579238414764404,
0.15352308750152588,
-0.5294015407562256,
1.0736854076385498,
0.05724718049168587,
0.34576013684272766,
0.5677762627601624,
0.1488228440284729,
-0.16852934658527374,
-0.2996950149536133,
-1.1206735372543335,
0.14332030713558197,
-0.7337446212768555,
-0.38177815079689026,
-0.2691849172115326,
-0.03482985123991966,
-0.25648999214172363,
-0.14961834251880646,
-0.6621273756027222,
-0.14861519634723663,
-0.5824800729751587,
0.3759778141975403,
0.37473249435424805,
0.6366394758224487,
0.06762464344501495,
0.6367559432983398,
-0.8054860234260559,
0.347625195980072,
0.47486230731010437,
0.5465697646141052,
-0.12539201974868774,
-0.4806964695453644,
-0.43364402651786804,
0.0563729926943779,
-0.39385420083999634,
-0.7530452013015747,
0.10534652322530746,
0.570448100566864,
0.4154963195323944,
0.968562126159668,
-0.27827101945877075,
1.1968295574188232,
-0.46889206767082214,
0.21886010468006134,
0.32466328144073486,
-0.7362321019172668,
0.5004542469978333,
-0.19282473623752594,
0.4809904992580414,
0.4856496751308441,
0.3142373859882355,
0.1091206893324852,
-0.15915845334529877,
-0.35276809334754944,
-0.18023952841758728,
1.007459044456482,
0.1677345484495163,
-0.183119535446167,
0.381803035736084,
0.45333781838417053,
0.21548636257648468,
0.1443498134613037,
-0.44879013299942017,
-0.055127836763858795,
-0.4908546507358551,
-0.23258791863918304,
-0.09883350133895874,
-0.13215617835521698,
-0.35626789927482605,
-0.5742824673652649,
0.6383917331695557,
-0.5031048059463501,
0.25955647230148315,
-0.11842919886112213,
-0.2236148864030838,
-0.08778004348278046,
0.44736430048942566,
1.1049119234085083,
0.5776388645172119,
-0.06510286778211594,
0.25789937376976013,
0.06999235600233078,
-0.37353670597076416,
0.292827844619751,
-0.055579595267772675,
0.0155970249325037,
-0.3969305157661438,
0.3695667088031769,
1.2436920404434204,
0.4430391192436218,
-0.6628023982048035,
0.5518087148666382,
-0.20541246235370636,
-0.3375990390777588,
-0.10140582919120789,
0.31792160868644714,
0.12440299242734909,
0.5850106477737427,
0.07603306323289871,
0.4902142882347107,
-0.28795304894447327,
-0.49290862679481506,
0.07212349027395248,
0.45578035712242126,
-0.21602050960063934,
-0.6072142720222473,
0.6894077658653259,
0.24885648488998413,
-0.218051016330719,
0.5373629331588745,
-0.5212949514389038,
-0.19976457953453064,
0.7100064158439636,
0.6463151574134827,
0.4966612160205841,
-0.30511078238487244,
0.09470292925834656,
0.6038288474082947,
0.70307457447052,
-0.016376111656427383,
0.22584906220436096,
-0.10211680829524994,
-0.5631147623062134,
-0.3261711597442627,
-0.4408435821533203,
-0.2822509706020355,
0.06396478414535522,
-0.5237785577774048,
0.37209352850914,
-0.6364256739616394,
-0.014529203064739704,
0.021667350083589554,
-0.39245569705963135,
-0.8555208444595337,
0.10224980860948563,
0.05177267640829086,
0.8387219309806824,
-0.5476686358451843,
1.052087426185608,
0.7574012279510498,
-0.4363797605037689,
-0.6163298487663269,
-0.13887451589107513,
0.036245197057724,
-0.9566288590431213,
0.5993278622627258,
0.3507513999938965,
-0.2798435389995575,
0.3081936836242676,
-0.548833429813385,
-0.633992075920105,
1.3808870315551758,
0.6354725956916809,
-0.8868628740310669,
0.029981452971696854,
-0.20684346556663513,
0.44461122155189514,
-0.4365728497505188,
0.40456724166870117,
0.3389458656311035,
0.5653098225593567,
0.08272170275449753,
-0.6959353685379028,
-0.15103334188461304,
-0.080807164311409,
-0.21822264790534973,
0.33621394634246826,
-0.9834103584289551,
1.140578031539917,
-0.7857402563095093,
-0.35418373346328735,
0.09880036860704422,
0.4392853081226349,
-0.06551448255777359,
0.25136083364486694,
0.604532778263092,
0.9258468747138977,
0.4414559006690979,
-0.16561929881572723,
0.8142411112785339,
-0.4182559549808502,
0.021640345454216003,
1.0190571546554565,
0.0797376036643982,
0.6148615479469299,
0.39264369010925293,
-0.04666651040315628,
0.42334967851638794,
0.5737639665603638,
-0.13508059084415436,
0.6510915160179138,
-0.2576889395713806,
-0.1669432371854782,
-0.4694686532020569,
0.06794453412294388,
-0.6318426132202148,
0.6917683482170105,
0.5055050849914551,
-0.34025838971138,
-0.24523307383060455,
0.2371281087398529,
-0.19594816863536835,
0.03467518463730812,
-0.21991366147994995,
0.8513630628585815,
-0.15435707569122314,
-0.7644479870796204,
0.7617567777633667,
0.004782613832503557,
0.9037833213806152,
-0.7945435643196106,
-0.25017744302749634,
-0.014171123504638672,
0.438105046749115,
-0.13617441058158875,
-0.8021338582038879,
0.07081500440835953,
-0.09934616833925247,
0.007177984807640314,
-0.20700348913669586,
0.6393575072288513,
-0.3492003083229065,
-0.30418065190315247,
0.3631976246833801,
0.35953810811042786,
0.16889742016792297,
0.014621767215430737,
-0.5251799821853638,
-0.0573725700378418,
0.05610410124063492,
0.017067594453692436,
0.5189551115036011,
0.1168861985206604,
-0.040955156087875366,
0.5676094889640808,
0.5580488443374634,
-0.11127454042434692,
0.1462891548871994,
0.2383718490600586,
0.8499056100845337,
-0.529577374458313,
-0.21568003296852112,
-0.7038560509681702,
0.18498054146766663,
-0.04501422867178917,
-0.5925384759902954,
0.34977415204048157,
0.4032970666885376,
0.9231852293014526,
-0.28251251578330994,
0.45092809200286865,
0.15616197884082794,
0.008386821486055851,
-0.7135591506958008,
0.5349830985069275,
-0.887735903263092,
-0.0030495377723127604,
0.02508055791258812,
-0.7574731111526489,
-0.18529312312602997,
0.4958258867263794,
0.02056533843278885,
-0.15764185786247253,
0.5945992469787598,
1.0002518892288208,
-0.35748860239982605,
0.07698343694210052,
0.511303722858429,
-0.04874220862984657,
0.23735134303569794,
0.5679423213005066,
0.9918590784072876,
-0.3938775956630707,
0.7092431783676147,
-0.41772663593292236,
-0.46712374687194824,
-0.23313945531845093,
-0.6583421230316162,
-0.8957083821296692,
-0.6937670707702637,
-0.16942356526851654,
0.09465125948190689,
0.16198241710662842,
0.8589556813240051,
1.0498937368392944,
-0.6471314430236816,
-0.04123023897409439,
0.23675306141376495,
-0.1793096959590912,
-0.4267241954803467,
-0.11280173063278198,
0.23164331912994385,
-0.38362669944763184,
-0.9092850089073181,
0.5402340888977051,
0.7743089199066162,
-0.03642741218209267,
-0.5433670878410339,
-0.38345178961753845,
-0.3221587538719177,
-0.22139626741409302,
0.8441932201385498,
0.22580546140670776,
-0.6609843373298645,
-0.1735183745622635,
0.048195648938417435,
0.03549712151288986,
0.2986879348754883,
0.7504060864448547,
-0.5309389233589172,
0.6867752075195312,
0.1277133673429489,
0.6332785487174988,
0.5626230835914612,
-0.19611485302448273,
0.05972936376929283,
-0.9158484935760498,
0.3678603172302246,
-0.1026071161031723,
0.6796841025352478,
0.31235745549201965,
-0.031590595841407776,
0.6096197366714478,
0.2177782654762268,
-0.39508235454559326,
-0.3281031847000122,
0.20302625000476837,
-0.8115289211273193,
-0.5200255513191223,
0.9469643831253052,
-0.00967065803706646,
0.054700013250112534,
0.23591481149196625,
-0.3283780515193939,
0.23186305165290833,
-0.46676012873649597,
0.6497750282287598,
0.38990819454193115,
-0.12682850658893585,
-0.40807661414146423,
-0.4258737862110138,
0.1197160929441452,
0.2914750277996063,
-1.073581576347351,
-0.5161399245262146,
0.4440675675868988,
0.10472359508275986,
0.32221129536628723,
0.5628546476364136,
0.016557440161705017,
0.39387351274490356,
0.08107142150402069,
0.23291745781898499,
-0.3675655722618103,
-0.7439943552017212,
-0.0773661732673645,
0.18347951769828796,
-0.05005757883191109,
-0.4780150353908539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01481v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01481v1
|
NeMo-Aligner: Scalable Toolkit for Efficient Model Alignment
| 2024-05-02T17:13:40 | 2024-05-02T17:13:40 |
Gerald Shen, Zhilin Wang, Olivier Delalleau, Jiaqi Zeng, Yi Dong, Daniel Egert, Shengyang Sun, Jimmy Zhang, Sahil Jain, Ali Taghibakhshi, Markel Sanz Ausin, Ashwath Aithal, Oleksii Kuchaiev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Aligning Large Language Models (LLMs) with human values and preferences is
essential for making them helpful and safe. However, building efficient tools
to perform alignment can be challenging, especially for the largest and most
competent LLMs which often contain tens or hundreds of billions of parameters.
We create NeMo-Aligner, a toolkit for model alignment that can efficiently
scale to using hundreds of GPUs for training. NeMo-Aligner comes with highly
optimized and scalable implementations for major paradigms of model alignment
such as: Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF), Direct Preference
Optimization (DPO), SteerLM, and Self-Play Fine-Tuning (SPIN). Additionally,
our toolkit supports running most of the alignment techniques in a Parameter
Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) setting. NeMo-Aligner is designed for
extensibility, allowing support for other alignment techniques with minimal
effort. It is open-sourced with Apache 2.0 License and we invite community
contributions at https://github.com/NVIDIA/NeMo-Aligner
|
[
-0.3945279121398926,
-0.7881773710250854,
0.3673771917819977,
0.14619357883930206,
-0.17895275354385376,
-0.006901716347783804,
-0.18548369407653809,
-0.1974489688873291,
0.019504133611917496,
0.27893468737602234,
-0.6111165881156921,
-0.16912615299224854,
-0.5107735395431519,
-0.15692174434661865,
-0.1869044452905655,
0.9030193090438843,
-0.035470150411129,
0.24397867918014526,
-0.511687695980072,
-0.2856637239456177,
-0.2927369177341461,
-0.01233708206564188,
-0.7743194699287415,
-0.6035080552101135,
0.5950453281402588,
0.6439651846885681,
0.8355422616004944,
0.8070533275604248,
0.8888704776763916,
0.2805272936820984,
0.08543633669614792,
0.34383800625801086,
-0.46533459424972534,
0.35901063680648804,
-0.44232767820358276,
-0.02498217672109604,
-0.9213301539421082,
-0.12352310121059418,
0.6672385334968567,
0.24414004385471344,
-0.24210204184055328,
0.3314773738384247,
-0.10886441171169281,
0.5231726765632629,
-0.6003338098526001,
-0.21342088282108307,
-0.36678603291511536,
-0.15132495760917664,
-0.11290203034877777,
-0.017718328163027763,
-0.29058679938316345,
-0.5716986656188965,
-0.035645436495542526,
-0.8801100850105286,
-0.22154228389263153,
0.2016642689704895,
1.162880301475525,
0.6899121403694153,
-0.48875191807746887,
-0.02323172427713871,
-0.41406938433647156,
0.9224889874458313,
-0.9418876767158508,
0.25662240386009216,
-0.010972240939736366,
0.6105645895004272,
-0.36850327253341675,
-0.2583187222480774,
-0.6643938422203064,
0.018196571618318558,
0.02049088291823864,
-0.19662609696388245,
-0.07229262590408325,
0.05420497804880142,
0.4009113907814026,
0.34487247467041016,
-0.7555248141288757,
0.5388637185096741,
0.08597275614738464,
-0.19812849164009094,
0.7681655287742615,
0.42500683665275574,
0.5039664506912231,
0.05338847637176514,
-0.3645714223384857,
-0.3668857216835022,
-0.7527017593383789,
-0.4348684251308441,
0.6815637350082397,
0.21746036410331726,
-0.13614422082901,
0.5029657483100891,
-0.1185818687081337,
1.1370642185211182,
0.4215031862258911,
-0.49383679032325745,
0.36811205744743347,
-0.2771611213684082,
-0.27754658460617065,
-0.07179956883192062,
0.9370192885398865,
0.45148220658302307,
-0.19743315875530243,
0.11559665948152542,
-0.3837622106075287,
-0.010709408670663834,
0.34609371423721313,
-0.9057030081748962,
0.04788181558251381,
-0.0038431575521826744,
-0.3133479654788971,
-0.46818041801452637,
-0.2200879156589508,
-0.9216854572296143,
-0.4444873034954071,
-0.49318140745162964,
0.6418323516845703,
-0.1177574023604393,
-0.2158980667591095,
0.08292592316865921,
-0.07586558908224106,
0.6820116639137268,
0.5747430920600891,
-1.3437488079071045,
0.2976956367492676,
0.8758453726768494,
0.8133772611618042,
-0.05986625701189041,
-0.07775191217660904,
-0.7297586798667908,
0.1261805295944214,
-0.18727654218673706,
0.598190188407898,
-0.705219566822052,
-0.14512260258197784,
-0.36199846863746643,
0.06536509841680527,
-0.04432019591331482,
-0.35690832138061523,
0.5175478458404541,
-0.36854472756385803,
0.2865787148475647,
-0.13280315697193146,
-0.6658300161361694,
-0.1395622342824936,
0.4468521773815155,
-0.480516642332077,
1.1191842555999756,
0.14521706104278564,
-0.4367463290691376,
0.23812614381313324,
-0.7114331722259521,
-0.2690507471561432,
0.0324641689658165,
-0.36761292815208435,
-0.5652810335159302,
0.34854963421821594,
0.26880115270614624,
0.3714900016784668,
-0.5964962244033813,
0.4045242965221405,
-0.5931549072265625,
-0.28033381700515747,
-0.04196310415863991,
-0.29573139548301697,
0.5587303042411804,
0.361716628074646,
-0.4438129961490631,
0.46144238114356995,
-0.5108329057693481,
-0.0007068702834658325,
0.09438145905733109,
-0.14853535592556,
-0.09887540340423584,
-0.0778227224946022,
0.2150488942861557,
0.301563024520874,
0.6091053485870361,
-0.6815121173858643,
0.5823366641998291,
-0.3101617395877838,
0.6655516624450684,
0.9168460369110107,
-0.47436925768852234,
0.7211045026779175,
-0.2146219164133072,
0.8393835425376892,
-0.45141443610191345,
0.4463277757167816,
0.14874066412448883,
-0.2983267307281494,
-0.6130045652389526,
-0.31757959723472595,
0.287423700094223,
0.17048396170139313,
-0.25749650597572327,
0.39561110734939575,
-0.4672676920890808,
-0.7771980166435242,
-0.45881572365760803,
0.32780832052230835,
0.5193397998809814,
0.7424298524856567,
0.1488863229751587,
0.04226447269320488,
-0.36323365569114685,
-1.1460199356079102,
0.11557328701019287,
0.003054544795304537,
0.05661202222108841,
0.36144012212753296,
0.47204336524009705,
-0.2954346835613251,
0.8490235805511475,
-0.4460678994655609,
-0.18424662947654724,
0.048825085163116455,
-0.049740225076675415,
0.3012702763080597,
0.791432797908783,
0.5584810376167297,
-0.628092885017395,
-0.5583657026290894,
0.5779324769973755,
-0.4398767650127411,
-0.12796947360038757,
0.20261795818805695,
-0.3614584505558014,
0.2004670947790146,
0.6032126545906067,
-0.3299172818660736,
-0.1637619137763977,
1.1154500246047974,
-0.27994534373283386,
0.14980845153331757,
-0.3865882456302643,
-0.13585908710956573,
-1.165346622467041,
0.3014253079891205,
-0.17097288370132446,
-0.3278910219669342,
-0.18515829741954803,
-0.021967317909002304,
0.39560386538505554,
-0.03437786176800728,
-0.3489450216293335,
0.8116732239723206,
-0.31191322207450867,
-0.12151242792606354,
-0.4414407014846802,
0.10391933470964432,
0.06664151698350906,
0.21784043312072754,
-0.046177107840776443,
0.8308829069137573,
0.37435439229011536,
-0.3392743766307831,
0.417690247297287,
0.14123070240020752,
-0.057966168969869614,
0.835575520992279,
-0.8343636393547058,
0.40502476692199707,
0.07342137396335602,
-0.0011950290063396096,
-0.7570844888687134,
-0.5721110701560974,
0.4100095331668854,
-0.3134922683238983,
0.4108462333679199,
-0.3060263395309448,
-0.44942060112953186,
0.05840352177619934,
-0.10626101493835449,
0.6222642064094543,
0.4536411166191101,
-0.785250723361969,
0.8702889084815979,
0.6616970896720886,
-0.07916882634162903,
-0.8686016201972961,
-0.23361776769161224,
-0.10619649291038513,
-0.3971765637397766,
-0.6155807971954346,
0.5253812074661255,
-0.2209842950105667,
-0.04605179280042648,
0.0322105810046196,
-0.31433209776878357,
0.04967718571424484,
0.17230482399463654,
0.43642598390579224,
0.6093505024909973,
-0.09988024085760117,
0.36856088042259216,
0.23235194385051727,
-0.31893840432167053,
-0.24187302589416504,
-0.3953706622123718,
0.5529080033302307,
-0.39719271659851074,
-0.34436655044555664,
-0.30030202865600586,
-0.026830652728676796,
0.8313552141189575,
-0.12831585109233856,
0.40359604358673096,
0.4655761420726776,
-0.3506346344947815,
-0.06902305781841278,
-0.5925708413124084,
-0.08392494171857834,
-0.46071377396583557,
0.3629831373691559,
-0.0645945742726326,
-1.005678415298462,
0.15588104724884033,
-0.01925048418343067,
0.34083354473114014,
0.43362268805503845,
0.5177819728851318,
0.00190767424646765,
1.372443437576294,
0.6972007751464844,
-0.293753981590271,
0.6627987623214722,
0.23601754009723663,
0.2821124494075775,
-1.0116273164749146,
-0.2583126425743103,
-0.5031758546829224,
-0.8333740234375,
-0.3513774275779724,
-0.49693942070007324,
0.026589354500174522,
-0.13229607045650482,
-0.40715500712394714,
0.5959168076515198,
-0.696696937084198,
0.7026746869087219,
0.3297296166419983,
-0.27326083183288574,
0.039184872061014175,
-0.23332203924655914,
0.012727375142276287,
0.04556624963879585,
-0.6038667559623718,
-0.8119668364524841,
1.232354760169983,
0.25843366980552673,
1.097994089126587,
0.1329435408115387,
0.7754590511322021,
-0.296227365732193,
0.3000132739543915,
-0.8529509902000427,
0.42663678526878357,
-0.10537534207105637,
-0.8514306545257568,
-0.4733547866344452,
-0.2442598193883896,
-0.5931967496871948,
0.23181752860546112,
-0.3896889090538025,
-0.4746805727481842,
0.23446284234523773,
0.3958582580089569,
-0.6540966629981995,
0.1638038009405136,
-0.6520291566848755,
1.239998459815979,
-0.6541475057601929,
-0.584956705570221,
-0.28177955746650696,
-0.4542711079120636,
0.04107391834259033,
-0.011584585532546043,
-0.050524577498435974,
-0.4644702672958374,
-0.36858072876930237,
0.6369957327842712,
-0.3113405108451843,
0.5398308038711548,
-0.06812591105699539,
-0.09551737457513809,
-0.3500613570213318,
-0.17899328470230103,
0.43360358476638794,
0.3618681728839874,
-0.0018685855902731419,
0.0196895282715559,
-0.07276591658592224,
-0.4472672641277313,
-0.7294206619262695,
1.0804558992385864,
-0.851763904094696,
-0.5178532600402832,
-0.4267292320728302,
-0.8828943371772766,
-0.02581975795328617,
0.33133643865585327,
-0.0037464259658008814,
0.23339109122753143,
-0.27380406856536865,
0.2698177099227905,
0.8395200371742249,
-0.008337613195180893,
0.41604357957839966,
0.40011999011039734,
-0.4453616738319397,
-0.6630920767784119,
0.9800161719322205,
-0.11201789230108261,
0.2355750948190689,
0.5133208632469177,
0.1494041532278061,
-0.16599933803081512,
-0.5817787051200867,
-0.5514817237854004,
0.29307788610458374,
-0.33487755060195923,
-0.4275183081626892,
-0.24782606959342957,
0.10412459820508957,
-0.21940161287784576,
-0.3984149396419525,
-0.5827817320823669,
-0.5670764446258545,
-0.2542581856250763,
-0.07196269184350967,
0.2716267704963684,
0.6645784378051758,
0.04507610946893692,
0.404791921377182,
-0.5338464975357056,
0.015072271227836609,
0.4963049590587616,
0.32722604274749756,
-0.3725925087928772,
-0.5941633582115173,
-0.1472097933292389,
-0.23138459026813507,
-0.4075899124145508,
-0.40750768780708313,
0.48665887117385864,
0.10342714935541153,
0.5342029333114624,
0.7330107688903809,
-0.2146168351173401,
1.0142377614974976,
-0.1659322828054428,
0.315461128950119,
0.3320751488208771,
-1.0290991067886353,
0.4947042465209961,
-0.28649866580963135,
0.2686833441257477,
0.7457098960876465,
0.2705444097518921,
-0.47565868496894836,
0.0007970151491463184,
-0.40915030241012573,
-0.7555068135261536,
0.7081834673881531,
-0.2665407061576843,
0.25321081280708313,
0.16338421404361725,
0.3312676250934601,
0.310377836227417,
-0.0194411538541317,
-0.5796884298324585,
0.16383160650730133,
-0.0198679156601429,
-0.352123886346817,
-0.28238922357559204,
-0.25725266337394714,
-0.3404987156391144,
-0.309786319732666,
1.0604993104934692,
-0.4664463698863983,
-0.11990256607532501,
-0.08659879863262177,
-0.3002389073371887,
-0.15019944310188293,
0.08028633147478104,
0.8125384449958801,
0.611221432685852,
-0.2694959342479706,
0.06512986868619919,
0.05935812368988991,
-0.20011785626411438,
0.1808462291955948,
0.009554595686495304,
-0.2048669010400772,
-0.2958337068557739,
-0.017064325511455536,
0.7955832481384277,
0.43392959237098694,
-0.7634214162826538,
0.44538232684135437,
-0.2801920175552368,
-0.3143439292907715,
-0.13679134845733643,
0.23681120574474335,
0.45068737864494324,
0.28564468026161194,
-0.19855080544948578,
0.11652884632349014,
-0.1858297735452652,
-0.058602478355169296,
-0.1367492824792862,
0.6588924527168274,
-0.5402372479438782,
-0.2202208787202835,
0.7633153796195984,
0.3926721215248108,
-0.3203035295009613,
0.8933581113815308,
-0.22888192534446716,
-0.06637565791606903,
0.5071783661842346,
0.5029080510139465,
0.8925187587738037,
-0.16487526893615723,
0.14252547919750214,
0.6306651830673218,
0.23226936161518097,
-0.2956189215183258,
0.06355831027030945,
-0.06686311215162277,
-0.8144010901451111,
-0.5097716450691223,
-0.6661731600761414,
-0.5739786624908447,
-0.21671408414840698,
-0.667060375213623,
0.5317044854164124,
-0.7721205949783325,
-0.34993723034858704,
-0.005599718075245619,
-0.04699790105223656,
-0.38977035880088806,
-0.25651654601097107,
0.3245643079280853,
0.7203510999679565,
-0.8224949240684509,
1.0770461559295654,
0.9489670395851135,
-0.26768335700035095,
-0.8591580986976624,
-0.5173967480659485,
0.34146273136138916,
-0.7459418773651123,
0.6878634095191956,
0.19637620449066162,
-0.13719412684440613,
-0.01233808696269989,
-0.44205841422080994,
-1.0794099569320679,
1.2903611660003662,
0.9263659119606018,
-0.9345329999923706,
-0.12978732585906982,
-0.29042568802833557,
0.23631268739700317,
-0.591120719909668,
0.3781285285949707,
0.3347225785255432,
0.6740456223487854,
0.020053640007972717,
-1.0143229961395264,
0.10895092785358429,
-0.3879525363445282,
-0.025369917973876,
0.5689898729324341,
-0.7117089629173279,
0.826583981513977,
-0.002836497500538826,
0.17247293889522552,
-0.08225161582231522,
0.31842154264450073,
0.05944447964429855,
0.04981295391917229,
0.5026800632476807,
0.9122057557106018,
0.9516248106956482,
-0.12458834797143936,
0.7214024066925049,
-0.3293492794036865,
0.4433102011680603,
1.2393847703933716,
-0.21694640815258026,
0.7247088551521301,
0.8030402660369873,
0.100469671189785,
0.5240527987480164,
0.603564441204071,
-0.12488488107919693,
0.2338150441646576,
-0.10673881322145462,
-0.04713872820138931,
-0.6275610327720642,
-0.004359505604952574,
-0.2511778771877289,
0.35707518458366394,
0.06022754684090614,
-0.24262849986553192,
-0.14663878083229065,
-0.2954237163066864,
0.07059085369110107,
0.024645386263728142,
-0.19299332797527313,
0.6297277212142944,
-0.026887137442827225,
-0.5621417164802551,
0.2979443371295929,
-0.2289923131465912,
0.7890271544456482,
-0.6656228303909302,
-0.04678908362984657,
-0.17578309774398804,
0.33372771739959717,
-0.41278839111328125,
-0.34793621301651,
0.2524348497390747,
-0.19431832432746887,
-0.29490143060684204,
-0.42651045322418213,
0.4678177237510681,
-0.2446296364068985,
-0.29986143112182617,
0.1928693801164627,
0.05120091885328293,
-0.1449197232723236,
0.05709208548069,
-0.7479113340377808,
0.1820673644542694,
-0.1387568861246109,
-0.2174561470746994,
0.6882211565971375,
-0.07446912676095963,
-0.03547019883990288,
0.8274824023246765,
0.6824429035186768,
-0.21221712231636047,
-0.11860211938619614,
-0.13335417211055756,
0.6901121735572815,
-0.5670026540756226,
-0.1733708381652832,
-0.9942283034324646,
0.3683173954486847,
-0.37836068868637085,
-0.5655035376548767,
0.9589800238609314,
0.7467765808105469,
0.9465541839599609,
0.03744016960263252,
0.4690677225589752,
-0.24086269736289978,
-0.05416441336274147,
-0.2700746953487396,
0.5814183950424194,
-0.754310667514801,
0.14106933772563934,
-0.14853918552398682,
-1.073790192604065,
-0.3418966829776764,
0.8067088723182678,
-0.43039849400520325,
-0.3351925313472748,
0.47584396600723267,
1.0393049716949463,
-0.033596329391002655,
-0.18219485878944397,
0.34428519010543823,
-0.20410653948783875,
0.42097264528274536,
0.5915800333023071,
0.679176390171051,
-0.2527962327003479,
0.3995340168476105,
-0.20435260236263275,
-0.0874294564127922,
-0.43144747614860535,
-1.1743992567062378,
-0.6469175815582275,
-0.30681371688842773,
-0.5670042634010315,
0.017429713159799576,
-0.01691257394850254,
1.1765871047973633,
0.981850802898407,
-0.6761495471000671,
-0.3983836770057678,
-0.11655248701572418,
0.4021068215370178,
-0.331318199634552,
-0.14287607371807098,
0.07959678024053574,
-0.4073928892612457,
-1.1840685606002808,
0.4393728971481323,
0.6016233563423157,
-0.1396917700767517,
-0.12551595270633698,
-0.568331241607666,
-0.04587460309267044,
-0.08776623010635376,
0.2353319674730301,
0.4470035433769226,
-0.5806065201759338,
-0.2647319734096527,
0.1401941180229187,
-0.19417423009872437,
0.1579425036907196,
0.6238790154457092,
-0.5961050987243652,
0.6792414784431458,
0.7102273106575012,
0.787584125995636,
0.24983055889606476,
-0.1767989844083786,
0.9134114384651184,
-0.10226025432348251,
-0.05102657526731491,
0.2265201359987259,
0.4160687327384949,
0.26775220036506653,
-0.16753919422626495,
0.4530564248561859,
-0.15381893515586853,
-0.829398512840271,
-1.03609037399292,
0.19394561648368835,
-1.1087008714675903,
0.00100234046112746,
0.8247935771942139,
0.07072177529335022,
-0.39407867193222046,
0.3435942232608795,
-0.331950843334198,
0.02763737551867962,
-0.5124362111091614,
0.41609376668930054,
0.6188987493515015,
-0.18306314945220947,
0.05704835057258606,
-0.46274635195732117,
0.26683974266052246,
0.608923077583313,
-0.7309933304786682,
0.004815090913325548,
0.5748016238212585,
0.5160659551620483,
0.0712641030550003,
0.2671360671520233,
-0.4712557792663574,
0.28509238362312317,
-0.1821581870317459,
0.37770381569862366,
-0.2854900658130646,
0.009099042974412441,
-0.8159226775169373,
0.0229168850928545,
0.2552262544631958,
-0.07224435359239578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01474v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01474v1
|
V-FLUTE: Visual Figurative Language Understanding with Textual Explanations
| 2024-05-02T17:07:25 | 2024-05-02T17:07:25 |
Arkadiy Saakyan, Shreyas Kulkarni, Tuhin Chakrabarty, Smaranda Muresan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
Large Vision-Language models (VLMs) have demonstrated strong reasoning
capabilities in tasks requiring a fine-grained understanding of literal images
and text, such as visual question-answering or visual entailment. However,
there has been little exploration of these models' capabilities when presented
with images and captions containing figurative phenomena such as metaphors or
humor, the meaning of which is often implicit. To close this gap, we propose a
new task and a high-quality dataset: Visual Figurative Language Understanding
with Textual Explanations (V-FLUTE). We frame the visual figurative language
understanding problem as an explainable visual entailment task, where the model
has to predict whether the image (premise) entails a claim (hypothesis) and
justify the predicted label with a textual explanation. Using a human-AI
collaboration framework, we build a high-quality dataset, V-FLUTE, that
contains 6,027 <image, claim, label, explanation> instances spanning five
diverse multimodal figurative phenomena: metaphors, similes, idioms, sarcasm,
and humor. The figurative phenomena can be present either in the image, the
caption, or both. We further conduct both automatic and human evaluations to
assess current VLMs' capabilities in understanding figurative phenomena.
|
[
-0.28832903504371643,
-0.958631694316864,
0.6490155458450317,
0.4610486328601837,
-0.6589340567588806,
-0.13387034833431244,
-0.3253985047340393,
-0.7246347069740295,
0.05563666671514511,
0.7481523752212524,
-0.6850135922431946,
-0.38282597064971924,
-0.6557625532150269,
0.13301993906497955,
-0.4769699275493622,
0.6576937437057495,
0.08684829622507095,
-0.014101052656769753,
-0.48206883668899536,
-0.024595512077212334,
-0.7584989666938782,
0.11847460269927979,
-0.6740085482597351,
-0.16617001593112946,
0.5046875476837158,
0.1129886582493782,
0.8601483106613159,
0.7736878991127014,
0.5866858959197998,
0.4058709442615509,
0.057483356446027756,
0.1210709735751152,
-0.3458411693572998,
0.04993818327784538,
-0.13384227454662323,
-0.6359166502952576,
-0.05148885399103165,
-0.10552744567394257,
0.49912941455841064,
0.5880338549613953,
0.1665923148393631,
0.06126444786787033,
-0.18243944644927979,
0.48310980200767517,
-0.4264509975910187,
0.5825159549713135,
-0.6383407115936279,
0.2549711763858795,
-0.009433340281248093,
-0.38550159335136414,
-0.5863960385322571,
0.042086705565452576,
0.5304816365242004,
-1.0511839389801025,
0.029614171013236046,
0.1574375182390213,
1.1189321279525757,
0.7715693116188049,
-0.463849812746048,
-0.220004141330719,
-0.5453415513038635,
0.859318196773529,
-0.04261663928627968,
0.3907850682735443,
0.4929315745830536,
0.6892873048782349,
0.11989232897758484,
-0.8227140307426453,
-0.6812611818313599,
-0.3957589566707611,
-0.2340354323387146,
0.46730485558509827,
-0.41249480843544006,
-0.1983938366174698,
0.12238061428070068,
0.1808554083108902,
-0.8465551137924194,
-0.12607617676258087,
-0.48204800486564636,
-0.3456445336341858,
0.7299830317497253,
0.06242932379245758,
0.554047167301178,
-0.39062806963920593,
-0.563860297203064,
0.0543169304728508,
-0.43283843994140625,
-0.09380941838026047,
-0.15994153916835785,
-0.09387112408876419,
-0.1566861867904663,
0.8439493775367737,
0.04896387457847595,
1.1326603889465332,
-0.5692312121391296,
-0.18434588611125946,
0.08940176665782928,
-0.4121488928794861,
-0.5597444176673889,
0.35179418325424194,
0.635349452495575,
0.3594430685043335,
0.551983118057251,
-0.01679299771785736,
0.11189506202936172,
0.4417007863521576,
0.19024421274662018,
-0.4652960002422333,
-0.07958951592445374,
0.1957831084728241,
-0.5444253087043762,
-0.46533527970314026,
-0.1356012523174286,
-0.4911893308162689,
-0.6100921630859375,
-0.7889587879180908,
0.5585085153579712,
-0.6310694217681885,
-0.25748807191848755,
0.3951614499092102,
-0.49034959077835083,
0.1993156224489212,
0.7742576599121094,
-0.4326830506324768,
0.08714418113231659,
0.6262418627738953,
0.6469132304191589,
0.07496615499258041,
-0.4581785798072815,
-0.7795014977455139,
0.4770227372646332,
-0.08760866522789001,
0.7833278179168701,
-0.6599217653274536,
-0.1736140251159668,
-0.17994016408920288,
0.11771188676357269,
-0.0555836521089077,
-0.3345504105091095,
0.8043482303619385,
-0.27184829115867615,
0.5350309014320374,
-0.08117075264453888,
-0.5285249948501587,
-0.5668595433235168,
0.07493306696414948,
-0.6277310848236084,
0.5431139469146729,
-0.32435816526412964,
-0.7140682935714722,
0.27065393328666687,
-0.4784226715564728,
-0.4284857213497162,
0.19706343114376068,
-0.5287102460861206,
-0.058630503714084625,
0.260496586561203,
0.4591580629348755,
0.4587700366973877,
-0.5646625757217407,
0.15981152653694153,
-0.07879754155874252,
-0.488031804561615,
0.3787968158721924,
-0.6264137625694275,
1.097490906715393,
0.3184429705142975,
-0.44999071955680847,
0.21685490012168884,
-0.6593358516693115,
-0.19714125990867615,
0.3849148154258728,
0.16214710474014282,
-0.40610581636428833,
-0.05811816826462746,
0.2459830790758133,
0.054648544639348984,
0.20219670236110687,
-0.24755261838436127,
-0.31031090021133423,
-0.10898114740848541,
0.4909604489803314,
0.593832790851593,
-0.35681140422821045,
0.09355898946523666,
-0.1437349021434784,
0.49481630325317383,
0.12459634244441986,
0.049052949994802475,
-0.6555496454238892,
-0.6394544839859009,
-0.5738791823387146,
-0.7023702263832092,
-0.058337241411209106,
0.5694626569747925,
-0.9768586754798889,
0.10613548755645752,
-0.26383543014526367,
-0.26100900769233704,
-0.6756272912025452,
-0.021290810778737068,
0.624207079410553,
0.9161608815193176,
0.24054287374019623,
-0.22554811835289001,
-0.29458221793174744,
-0.9155689477920532,
-0.3373090624809265,
-0.4130741059780121,
-0.13973774015903473,
0.38262003660202026,
0.42801064252853394,
-0.09062858670949936,
0.9016591906547546,
-0.4742187261581421,
-0.44865670800209045,
0.11195619404315948,
0.5121633410453796,
-0.11690215766429901,
0.1632537692785263,
0.6293565034866333,
-1.1693346500396729,
-0.05786437541246414,
0.022069057449698448,
-1.229990005493164,
-0.024260498583316803,
-0.2744460105895996,
-0.11727891117334366,
0.20747941732406616,
0.5450896620750427,
-0.5568812489509583,
0.44344136118888855,
0.290024071931839,
-0.6199482083320618,
0.5708075761795044,
-0.259853720664978,
0.057664401829242706,
-0.6451138257980347,
-0.4468252956867218,
0.4612879753112793,
-0.16663531959056854,
-0.25395557284355164,
0.10318062454462051,
-0.23699745535850525,
-0.1334855854511261,
-0.5363616347312927,
0.6355608701705933,
-0.33053359389305115,
-0.2889953851699829,
-0.057811636477708817,
0.4109562933444977,
0.06435395032167435,
0.25639304518699646,
0.5325373411178589,
0.43688350915908813,
0.9653169512748718,
-0.20619818568229675,
0.6757175326347351,
0.0878661498427391,
-0.22885854542255402,
0.8613046407699585,
-0.9085494875907898,
-0.3233185112476349,
-0.6492146849632263,
0.22521089017391205,
-1.0955723524093628,
-0.532946765422821,
0.187900573015213,
-0.45711442828178406,
-0.010563396848738194,
-0.22259187698364258,
-0.3481889069080353,
-0.2102426439523697,
0.11841614544391632,
0.34949108958244324,
0.5316178202629089,
-0.5832765102386475,
0.6373929977416992,
0.20987628400325775,
0.1361163854598999,
-0.6201711893081665,
-0.7527464032173157,
0.3792116045951843,
-0.5291956663131714,
-1.1282316446304321,
0.21892422437667847,
0.164202481508255,
-0.5700798630714417,
0.39878761768341064,
0.07678750902414322,
-0.18130341172218323,
0.012194293551146984,
0.26894423365592957,
0.25258055329322815,
-0.5115720629692078,
0.4658079743385315,
-0.10054244846105576,
-0.2578149735927582,
0.16539216041564941,
-0.3494372069835663,
0.1670396775007248,
-0.6858401298522949,
-0.5103810429573059,
-0.836540162563324,
0.10359031707048416,
0.7987809181213379,
-0.5428614616394043,
0.5546727180480957,
1.0999385118484497,
-0.4870568811893463,
0.18477851152420044,
-0.24060148000717163,
-0.011384235695004463,
-0.39849796891212463,
0.2553102672100067,
-0.48206180334091187,
-0.8091466426849365,
0.16800785064697266,
0.1619081199169159,
-0.27097001671791077,
0.52342289686203,
0.5341808795928955,
-0.4779978394508362,
0.8400549292564392,
0.44376900792121887,
0.20503266155719757,
0.23811276257038116,
-0.014186465181410313,
-0.04861508309841156,
-0.24528604745864868,
-0.304580956697464,
-0.435359388589859,
0.02156832627952099,
-0.5000213980674744,
-0.5779188871383667,
0.3102617561817169,
-0.02312217466533184,
-0.15182578563690186,
0.21037687361240387,
-0.42499279975891113,
0.6777768135070801,
0.4973858594894409,
0.1371489018201828,
0.628459632396698,
0.2497929036617279,
0.3186046779155731,
-0.18969136476516724,
-0.26253753900527954,
-0.5456053614616394,
0.7219889163970947,
0.3418014943599701,
0.647132396697998,
0.23403902351856232,
0.5672610402107239,
0.19863702356815338,
-0.10904126614332199,
-0.9385525584220886,
0.5595680475234985,
-0.1865815967321396,
-0.3814539611339569,
-0.5976597666740417,
-0.2415519505739212,
-1.0326882600784302,
0.6075387597084045,
-0.23737569153308868,
-0.8211984038352966,
-0.2994386553764343,
0.316910982131958,
0.048776671290397644,
-0.3123190999031067,
-0.930295467376709,
1.1428382396697998,
-0.4160173237323761,
-0.4117121398448944,
-0.4641032814979553,
-0.6669685244560242,
0.8260497450828552,
0.06427214294672012,
0.5008701086044312,
0.024573717266321182,
-0.09327796846628189,
0.4755971431732178,
-0.41501349210739136,
0.783061146736145,
-0.03737756237387657,
-0.15555788576602936,
0.4138411581516266,
0.09083984047174454,
0.23130330443382263,
0.11158540099859238,
0.06751886010169983,
-0.1424577534198761,
-0.07343728095293045,
-0.619757890701294,
-0.9548549056053162,
0.38044479489326477,
-0.6063626408576965,
-0.5774794220924377,
-0.24353207647800446,
-0.5149339437484741,
-0.030042169615626335,
0.08188654482364655,
0.16385029256343842,
0.5453003644943237,
0.021546142175793648,
0.3175799250602722,
0.7226771712303162,
-0.42148932814598083,
0.2843816876411438,
0.07187677919864655,
-0.3675630986690521,
0.008648267947137356,
1.1996521949768066,
-0.20311075448989868,
0.0073211174458265305,
0.2675422430038452,
0.3986404240131378,
-0.47901639342308044,
-0.3210361897945404,
-0.630295991897583,
0.3662923574447632,
-0.7254748940467834,
0.4416082203388214,
-0.3959651589393616,
0.07339852303266525,
0.06535951048135757,
-0.2224099338054657,
-0.054626479744911194,
-0.43195265531539917,
-0.25376564264297485,
0.09765300899744034,
0.6546778678894043,
0.5280790328979492,
0.28930962085723877,
0.18453024327754974,
-0.6433230638504028,
0.601642370223999,
0.5025286078453064,
0.11432138830423355,
-0.09928874671459198,
-0.528018057346344,
0.09021162241697311,
0.025359509512782097,
0.12277258187532425,
-0.8899743556976318,
0.26040834188461304,
0.21839861571788788,
0.44287723302841187,
0.4284963011741638,
-0.11297813802957535,
0.8602256774902344,
-0.409721702337265,
0.8316854238510132,
0.40611496567726135,
-0.9860807061195374,
0.7681816220283508,
-0.6004563570022583,
0.1893787980079651,
0.01761413924396038,
0.37241074442863464,
-0.4718370735645294,
-0.46659722924232483,
-0.56240314245224,
-0.5328000783920288,
0.5310484170913696,
0.6350864768028259,
0.031283922493457794,
0.2947612702846527,
-0.020986445248126984,
0.009311383590102196,
0.23074500262737274,
-0.7187095284461975,
-0.006788924802094698,
-0.5986654162406921,
-0.4367813467979431,
-0.2153392881155014,
0.15262579917907715,
-0.3452827036380768,
-0.36821645498275757,
0.39301273226737976,
-0.2112814486026764,
0.2067795842885971,
0.10920696705579758,
-0.528965950012207,
0.04890556260943413,
-0.04031004011631012,
0.89054936170578,
0.7464737892150879,
0.06499737501144409,
0.5352859497070312,
-0.24828468263149261,
-0.42185795307159424,
-0.17778033018112183,
0.09771320968866348,
0.1524084210395813,
0.10091713815927505,
0.8463560938835144,
1.0263469219207764,
-0.05844516679644585,
-1.1338036060333252,
0.44948771595954895,
-0.3177602291107178,
-0.12128383666276932,
-0.5155475735664368,
-0.0029577966779470444,
0.35589873790740967,
0.26579713821411133,
0.14159806072711945,
-0.10821305215358734,
0.10559181869029999,
-0.7635254263877869,
0.10326077789068222,
0.23722118139266968,
-0.6355606317520142,
-0.09991015493869781,
0.7690415978431702,
-0.05106830224394798,
-0.16321156919002533,
0.5497676730155945,
-0.048303499817848206,
-0.3506811261177063,
0.9582278728485107,
0.4292060136795044,
0.6299323439598083,
0.22803449630737305,
0.6541438698768616,
0.022498207166790962,
0.5116739273071289,
0.18714934587478638,
0.40930840373039246,
-0.017148856073617935,
-0.5007321238517761,
-0.6095178127288818,
-0.4190213084220886,
-0.2603330910205841,
0.02343093976378441,
-0.5530070662498474,
0.3206006586551666,
-0.04839150235056877,
0.357843816280365,
0.5782404541969299,
-0.5542559027671814,
-0.7334977388381958,
0.5200855135917664,
0.1538274586200714,
0.6800714731216431,
-0.9873557090759277,
0.6489742994308472,
0.6716215014457703,
-0.8680402636528015,
-0.4987012445926666,
0.06119867414236069,
0.3552359640598297,
-1.0666861534118652,
1.061278223991394,
0.1268889307975769,
-0.32073336839675903,
-0.1764410436153412,
-0.5765404105186462,
-0.629456639289856,
0.9706234931945801,
0.6761032342910767,
-0.25062525272369385,
0.3038841784000397,
0.1389807015657425,
0.8187662959098816,
-0.3446229100227356,
0.27417895197868347,
0.4366835951805115,
0.7274402379989624,
0.4129244387149811,
-0.8453068733215332,
0.0550808385014534,
-0.13459688425064087,
0.07216832786798477,
-0.20183953642845154,
-0.4885181784629822,
0.5339846611022949,
-0.22482721507549286,
0.04036921635270119,
-0.1429259032011032,
0.9696807265281677,
0.27677491307258606,
0.6149169206619263,
0.6725379228591919,
0.51887047290802,
0.903820276260376,
-0.29936790466308594,
1.2125320434570312,
0.3077973425388336,
0.08216085284948349,
1.2305331230163574,
0.007187724579125643,
0.6485133767127991,
0.6551154851913452,
0.0030427370220422745,
0.3202461004257202,
0.8237074017524719,
0.12525543570518494,
0.31909143924713135,
0.3570655286312103,
-0.2573607265949249,
-0.5267124176025391,
-0.48531293869018555,
-0.3084471821784973,
0.8862815499305725,
0.4075486958026886,
-0.4230879843235016,
-0.20529238879680634,
0.27972835302352905,
-0.26093775033950806,
0.14320766925811768,
-0.27462488412857056,
0.5620775818824768,
0.026329247280955315,
-0.653043806552887,
0.6941177845001221,
-0.2929973304271698,
0.20214372873306274,
-0.07507210224866867,
-0.11869297921657562,
0.17946851253509521,
-0.10535397380590439,
-0.17815770208835602,
-1.0367563962936401,
0.4589520990848541,
-0.06270572543144226,
0.06894370913505554,
-0.08943048119544983,
0.6866528987884521,
-0.5151662826538086,
-0.7169099450111389,
0.10668617486953735,
0.5048954486846924,
0.5027898550033569,
-0.02390797808766365,
-0.6996992826461792,
0.34748974442481995,
-0.2475614994764328,
-0.0920257568359375,
0.013023537583649158,
0.7692540287971497,
-0.3582151532173157,
0.7139456868171692,
0.2566731870174408,
-0.2704404592514038,
0.11245406419038773,
0.2938707768917084,
0.47479742765426636,
-0.5234838724136353,
-0.443197101354599,
-0.7581509351730347,
0.6800083518028259,
-0.21849843859672546,
-0.17123016715049744,
0.5576542615890503,
0.23977774381637573,
0.8467777371406555,
-0.3644915521144867,
0.8082076907157898,
0.20098796486854553,
-0.07738235592842102,
-0.7178447842597961,
0.6480292677879333,
-1.0526983737945557,
0.023883618414402008,
-0.5124129056930542,
-0.6841538548469543,
-0.5107645988464355,
0.9229404330253601,
-0.11845345795154572,
-0.2966664731502533,
0.7436752319335938,
0.5107011795043945,
-0.13536915183067322,
0.559745728969574,
0.30369439721107483,
0.2979484796524048,
0.09598583728075027,
0.3208196759223938,
1.0279186964035034,
-0.19117163121700287,
0.6428096890449524,
-0.14436915516853333,
-0.19249260425567627,
-0.14520405232906342,
-1.169663906097412,
-0.8820699453353882,
-0.8472682237625122,
-0.6125717759132385,
-0.23090122640132904,
0.054513487964868546,
0.6784719824790955,
0.5863020420074463,
-0.32928723096847534,
-0.24482281506061554,
-0.2558254897594452,
0.34184175729751587,
-0.2922855317592621,
-0.23420684039592743,
0.5332372188568115,
-0.24630776047706604,
-0.8109545707702637,
0.28407779335975647,
0.39972519874572754,
0.14575596153736115,
-0.32715940475463867,
-0.20882216095924377,
0.2614041864871979,
0.0021855607628822327,
0.9770007729530334,
0.13967546820640564,
-1.2992889881134033,
-0.3467369079589844,
-0.004180260468274355,
0.20806287229061127,
-0.2221030294895172,
0.5582465529441833,
-0.7872472405433655,
0.7887604236602783,
0.42441847920417786,
0.815235435962677,
0.7173782587051392,
-0.3327327072620392,
0.4802902638912201,
-0.4114604592323303,
0.2986220121383667,
-0.002146755112335086,
0.5637864470481873,
0.09751318395137787,
-0.22534805536270142,
0.7112492918968201,
0.4583803117275238,
0.051826801151037216,
-0.941484808921814,
0.3669072687625885,
-1.405609369277954,
-0.5140911936759949,
0.8641133308410645,
-0.209295853972435,
-0.42486336827278137,
-0.06705981492996216,
-0.667935848236084,
0.2192959189414978,
-0.0843929871916771,
0.6830756664276123,
0.8116484880447388,
-0.294481486082077,
-0.5461326837539673,
-0.66364985704422,
0.30701905488967896,
0.5051414370536804,
-1.0019447803497314,
0.005444706417620182,
0.8177074790000916,
-0.15081745386123657,
0.15212790668010712,
0.3145725429058075,
-0.1275366246700287,
0.5960585474967957,
-0.11709776520729065,
-0.4016975462436676,
-0.21751777827739716,
-0.5636451244354248,
-0.3468021750450134,
0.18531852960586548,
-0.15765796601772308,
-0.2702817916870117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01470v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01470v1
|
WildChat: 1M ChatGPT Interaction Logs in the Wild
| 2024-05-02T17:00:02 | 2024-05-02T17:00:02 |
Wenting Zhao, Xiang Ren, Jack Hessel, Claire Cardie, Yejin Choi, Yuntian Deng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Chatbots such as GPT-4 and ChatGPT are now serving millions of users. Despite
their widespread use, there remains a lack of public datasets showcasing how
these tools are used by a population of users in practice. To bridge this gap,
we offered free access to ChatGPT for online users in exchange for their
affirmative, consensual opt-in to anonymously collect their chat transcripts
and request headers. From this, we compiled WildChat, a corpus of 1 million
user-ChatGPT conversations, which consists of over 2.5 million interaction
turns. We compare WildChat with other popular user-chatbot interaction
datasets, and find that our dataset offers the most diverse user prompts,
contains the largest number of languages, and presents the richest variety of
potentially toxic use-cases for researchers to study. In addition to
timestamped chat transcripts, we enrich the dataset with demographic data,
including state, country, and hashed IP addresses, alongside request headers.
This augmentation allows for more detailed analysis of user behaviors across
different geographical regions and temporal dimensions. Finally, because it
captures a broad range of use cases, we demonstrate the dataset's potential
utility in fine-tuning instruction-following models. WildChat is released at
https://wildchat.allen.ai under AI2 ImpACT Licenses.
|
[
-0.1198815256357193,
-0.8436827063560486,
0.07551917433738708,
0.3514426648616791,
-0.10542982071638107,
0.1269892156124115,
-0.0751931443810463,
-0.6456993222236633,
0.20362509787082672,
0.5820063352584839,
-0.8363692760467529,
-0.39435040950775146,
-0.33959338068962097,
-0.1915101855993271,
-0.306171715259552,
1.4623019695281982,
0.3258828818798065,
-0.24115274846553802,
0.07451064139604568,
-0.07847881317138672,
-0.6520520448684692,
-0.6751131415367126,
-0.5934181213378906,
0.06497633457183838,
0.7940783500671387,
0.6090824007987976,
0.877544641494751,
0.2688870131969452,
0.48219385743141174,
0.2466106414794922,
0.08939339220523834,
0.05732075124979019,
-1.0438423156738281,
0.04961373656988144,
0.06356585770845413,
-0.24154746532440186,
-0.5435819625854492,
0.1438143253326416,
0.1648191213607788,
0.5029879808425903,
-0.19792664051055908,
0.08541928976774216,
0.08382002264261246,
0.34651267528533936,
-0.4096505343914032,
0.32031306624412537,
-0.6342999339103699,
0.130231574177742,
-0.4554840326309204,
-0.17358149588108063,
-0.38457491993904114,
-0.2515292167663574,
0.29942721128463745,
-0.6451905369758606,
0.15165254473686218,
-0.20052573084831238,
0.5564917325973511,
0.3638373017311096,
-0.599470853805542,
-0.16552680730819702,
-0.8296524882316589,
0.4466518759727478,
-0.5004240870475769,
0.20633317530155182,
0.5636844635009766,
0.577778160572052,
-0.40575551986694336,
-0.8318513631820679,
-0.31672754883766174,
-0.15247182548046112,
-0.3761454224586487,
0.20096279680728912,
-0.5341386198997498,
0.19527405500411987,
0.2156686931848526,
0.146079421043396,
-0.7312300205230713,
0.27701666951179504,
-0.7188840508460999,
-0.2812860906124115,
0.7065620422363281,
0.3777620792388916,
0.3176124393939972,
0.19841426610946655,
-0.2740819454193115,
-0.0882568359375,
-0.6727111339569092,
-0.03478870168328285,
0.6156960129737854,
0.20236100256443024,
-0.23586906492710114,
0.6784332990646362,
-0.053043194115161896,
0.6122298240661621,
-0.3535480499267578,
0.4155096411705017,
0.0064469617791473866,
-0.4391399025917053,
-0.11466439068317413,
-0.1787383258342743,
0.843361496925354,
0.6137726306915283,
0.2699865698814392,
-0.15061551332473755,
0.30857694149017334,
-0.17843107879161835,
0.1670750230550766,
-1.0351009368896484,
-0.4782090187072754,
0.14978143572807312,
-0.2045341283082962,
-0.18492038547992706,
-0.031816259026527405,
-0.9128791093826294,
-0.6151692271232605,
0.034954849630594254,
-0.01852709800004959,
-0.24863897264003754,
-0.2097724825143814,
0.016317730769515038,
-0.18482062220573425,
0.24253016710281372,
0.3768048882484436,
-1.0043915510177612,
0.39954856038093567,
0.741971492767334,
0.7718193531036377,
-0.2721904516220093,
-0.16556531190872192,
-0.434023380279541,
-0.2669323980808258,
-0.20237232744693756,
0.5060954689979553,
-0.7182167768478394,
-0.4777730107307434,
-0.0722336694598198,
0.04614871367812157,
0.01967911794781685,
-0.3971654772758484,
0.44411998987197876,
-0.6051289439201355,
0.3521474003791809,
-0.15612156689167023,
-0.4317278563976288,
-0.22331222891807556,
0.06807337701320648,
-0.5652567148208618,
0.8362473249435425,
-0.051126912236213684,
-0.5281982421875,
0.2845908999443054,
-0.9974881410598755,
-0.1644996851682663,
0.4738588035106659,
-0.15169772505760193,
-0.09275991469621658,
-0.2732434868812561,
0.142292320728302,
0.4739540219306946,
0.0767274871468544,
-0.10740359872579575,
-0.3076918125152588,
-0.3507262170314789,
0.2497941553592682,
-0.7518946528434753,
0.9087921977043152,
0.38030099868774414,
-0.17852698266506195,
0.05290555953979492,
-0.5394428968429565,
-0.0325675904750824,
0.026854587718844414,
-0.17382194101810455,
-0.1544463038444519,
0.10738132148981094,
0.18061968684196472,
0.09636420756578445,
0.27724501490592957,
-0.5935382843017578,
0.320063054561615,
-0.1472046822309494,
0.6187511086463928,
0.6933049559593201,
0.1549951583147049,
0.08951064199209213,
-0.094242624938488,
0.537794828414917,
-0.043779101222753525,
0.30102813243865967,
-0.3948448598384857,
-0.7656410932540894,
-0.35531386733055115,
-0.33003056049346924,
0.07339822500944138,
0.6427785754203796,
-0.25328329205513,
0.3063936233520508,
-0.24111241102218628,
-0.6272403597831726,
-0.3389591574668884,
0.01648116298019886,
0.2816530764102936,
0.0878395289182663,
0.13428400456905365,
-0.337761253118515,
-0.4268409013748169,
-0.7020689845085144,
-0.23749437928199768,
-0.18368777632713318,
-0.4137749969959259,
0.8672194480895996,
0.2136182337999344,
-0.30410295724868774,
1.0541729927062988,
-0.601940929889679,
-0.14831672608852386,
-0.07818907499313354,
0.06037379428744316,
0.05746585503220558,
0.3879198133945465,
0.6370783448219299,
-0.7837457656860352,
-0.7686572670936584,
0.059546712785959244,
-0.5498993396759033,
0.07807363569736481,
-0.09582940489053726,
-0.31568285822868347,
0.024603983387351036,
0.1747167557477951,
-0.5696813464164734,
0.5099722743034363,
0.6829937696456909,
-0.4641866981983185,
0.20818999409675598,
-0.18227103352546692,
0.15003307163715363,
-0.646124005317688,
0.04514770954847336,
-0.23555777966976166,
0.009869521483778954,
-0.7340024709701538,
-0.11691877245903015,
-0.11247427016496658,
-0.3370492160320282,
-0.5807385444641113,
0.6284675002098083,
-0.17619776725769043,
0.07727701216936111,
0.12134062498807907,
0.0652848556637764,
-0.45986253023147583,
0.6566740274429321,
-0.2555388808250427,
1.000893235206604,
0.3824114501476288,
-0.20927274227142334,
0.44909438490867615,
0.4890204668045044,
0.06631841510534286,
-0.06572932004928589,
-0.7539809942245483,
0.6577872633934021,
0.0810842290520668,
0.5703580379486084,
-1.1526308059692383,
-0.5978423357009888,
0.5736874938011169,
-0.5553511381149292,
-0.056715138256549835,
-0.47113969922065735,
-0.35665324330329895,
-0.07233907282352448,
-0.15411947667598724,
0.09775742143392563,
0.6175416707992554,
-0.41815754771232605,
0.31074652075767517,
0.4739494025707245,
-0.24875015020370483,
-0.5910601615905762,
-0.54684978723526,
0.35800060629844666,
-0.0538189522922039,
-0.5496848225593567,
-0.1171727105975151,
-0.1701091080904007,
0.057746462523937225,
-0.10394547134637833,
-0.07976716756820679,
-0.2631594240665436,
0.09932690113782883,
0.45790809392929077,
0.2877795696258545,
0.05289361625909805,
-0.06474319100379944,
-0.16414609551429749,
-0.005889054387807846,
-0.014155584387481213,
-0.15327230095863342,
0.6285082697868347,
-0.039800822734832764,
-0.40872055292129517,
-0.295815110206604,
0.39757466316223145,
0.4790104329586029,
-0.13898824155330658,
0.6386831402778625,
0.4979162812232971,
-0.10290546715259552,
0.1751682013273239,
-0.169468954205513,
-0.3130679726600647,
-0.5163911581039429,
0.36883389949798584,
0.05864597111940384,
-1.000989317893982,
0.5617455840110779,
0.15038584172725677,
0.643280029296875,
0.05115629360079765,
0.42472758889198303,
0.06358106434345245,
1.1255663633346558,
0.5481858253479004,
-0.13542330265045166,
0.4861189126968384,
0.01294983271509409,
0.23962640762329102,
-0.11383555829524994,
-0.324065625667572,
-0.3810153603553772,
-0.37146514654159546,
-1.0088694095611572,
-0.30736708641052246,
0.1703033149242401,
-0.3229570984840393,
-0.15302561223506927,
0.29088541865348816,
-0.5664070844650269,
0.8178806304931641,
0.513333261013031,
0.37856802344322205,
0.12374049425125122,
-0.06133778393268585,
0.32785552740097046,
-0.28102585673332214,
-0.6190142035484314,
-0.5749718546867371,
1.1249678134918213,
0.30045709013938904,
0.7814668416976929,
0.21414823830127716,
0.4312337636947632,
0.416348934173584,
0.3417535424232483,
-0.8684832453727722,
0.5971178412437439,
-0.2131824642419815,
-0.8345715999603271,
-0.300075888633728,
-0.49276185035705566,
-1.2970027923583984,
0.01830088347196579,
0.10002262145280838,
-1.032429575920105,
-0.31282490491867065,
0.30545639991760254,
-0.37598541378974915,
0.22279322147369385,
-1.0515836477279663,
0.9917119741439819,
-0.17308349907398224,
-0.33357325196266174,
-0.16376672685146332,
-0.9489766359329224,
0.4298090636730194,
-0.10149234533309937,
-0.04476317763328552,
-0.050112128257751465,
0.08874011039733887,
0.6883878111839294,
-0.3909737169742584,
1.3188787698745728,
-0.22434987127780914,
0.009997643530368805,
0.31001758575439453,
0.0886969342827797,
0.5716937780380249,
0.07393485307693481,
0.20789244771003723,
0.38181161880493164,
-0.07158760726451874,
-0.49409201741218567,
-0.45255839824676514,
0.6260424852371216,
-0.8463196158409119,
-0.5006753206253052,
-0.2534147799015045,
-0.4321735203266144,
-0.10705514252185822,
0.18586130440235138,
0.0866483747959137,
0.34463754296302795,
-0.4641909599304199,
0.3120081126689911,
0.5072470903396606,
-0.37219560146331787,
0.1579008400440216,
0.4847038984298706,
-0.08582130819559097,
0.03671284765005112,
0.8922181129455566,
0.056742988526821136,
0.09322245419025421,
0.1994447261095047,
0.14480476081371307,
-0.04335765540599823,
-0.19895368814468384,
-0.48460686206817627,
-0.10688799619674683,
-0.5541984438896179,
0.07745802402496338,
-0.8535504937171936,
-0.35445931553840637,
-0.20874544978141785,
-0.030178191140294075,
-0.1234770119190216,
-0.42256200313568115,
-0.03520307317376137,
-0.1432952731847763,
0.7497974634170532,
0.7097489237785339,
0.012617158703505993,
0.6599690914154053,
-1.0139387845993042,
-0.02855061925947666,
0.5642606019973755,
0.3536377549171448,
-0.20939850807189941,
-0.17587420344352722,
-0.050340961664915085,
0.22078430652618408,
-0.41265520453453064,
-0.8647134304046631,
0.28593671321868896,
0.3353026211261749,
0.5144492983818054,
0.4724406898021698,
0.17582790553569794,
0.5679510235786438,
-0.6142992973327637,
1.0449000597000122,
-0.15101367235183716,
-0.3949051797389984,
0.283361554145813,
-0.588526725769043,
-0.0012155324220657349,
0.30576586723327637,
0.5465196967124939,
-0.8755794167518616,
-0.46278101205825806,
-0.6355562806129456,
-0.8275979161262512,
0.8995941281318665,
0.47116348147392273,
0.693831741809845,
0.14401893317699432,
0.08694405853748322,
0.3480186462402344,
-0.0902261734008789,
-0.30171141028404236,
-0.31695756316185,
-0.3004322350025177,
-0.17489610612392426,
0.017430396750569344,
-0.010243318043649197,
-0.34241899847984314,
-0.1438770294189453,
0.3322713375091553,
0.07207928597927094,
0.37594202160835266,
-0.407820463180542,
0.1900949627161026,
0.023199891671538353,
0.21206516027450562,
0.666705846786499,
0.5779747366905212,
-0.31689730286598206,
-0.03581664711236954,
0.23309452831745148,
-1.023434042930603,
-0.28148412704467773,
0.23333512246608734,
0.0721297487616539,
-0.04276392608880997,
0.10925498604774475,
0.7337499260902405,
0.25537562370300293,
-0.9342069625854492,
0.5217485427856445,
-0.4304295480251312,
-0.04931334778666496,
-0.20784620940685272,
0.34704920649528503,
0.008485955186188221,
0.16817565262317657,
0.3472781181335449,
0.08051077276468277,
0.23995168507099152,
-0.2526094615459442,
0.2849899232387543,
0.2957119643688202,
-0.48845478892326355,
-0.4996429681777954,
0.6816795468330383,
0.5475785136222839,
-0.3831767737865448,
0.8760473132133484,
-0.002782433060929179,
-0.4128449261188507,
0.5659001469612122,
0.17087402939796448,
0.873112678527832,
0.127951517701149,
0.22139935195446014,
0.35316598415374756,
0.1087653860449791,
0.3200050890445709,
-0.1307133585214615,
-0.13368120789527893,
-0.5004069805145264,
-0.33914169669151306,
-0.0184517540037632,
-0.9885013699531555,
0.2739652097225189,
-0.4416690468788147,
0.33605435490608215,
-0.31396520137786865,
0.06379252672195435,
0.2758502960205078,
-0.055821724236011505,
-0.8389434218406677,
-0.36860594153404236,
-0.0594928152859211,
0.6226456165313721,
-0.8042808771133423,
0.631011426448822,
0.6284143924713135,
-0.2916065454483032,
-0.5085839629173279,
-0.0892261490225792,
0.40905633568763733,
-0.9692167043685913,
0.39240729808807373,
0.26698997616767883,
0.18925906717777252,
0.12174767255783081,
-1.1308321952819824,
-0.4013519287109375,
0.8947954773902893,
0.13403913378715515,
-0.5884101986885071,
0.08249535411596298,
0.20659403502941132,
0.5354602932929993,
0.09413159638643265,
0.5582083463668823,
0.6173003911972046,
0.21697762608528137,
0.2644897997379303,
-0.9474848508834839,
-0.0937206968665123,
-0.2733936607837677,
-0.4872666597366333,
0.2471352219581604,
-0.8410497307777405,
0.43903830647468567,
-0.15240728855133057,
-0.3875623047351837,
-0.24448896944522858,
0.3315628468990326,
0.12592114508152008,
0.3688463866710663,
0.3452833592891693,
0.12388455867767334,
0.6577906608581543,
-0.020627791061997414,
0.697925865650177,
-0.08428511768579483,
0.19639812409877777,
1.092783808708191,
-0.2043198049068451,
0.5581033229827881,
0.2499389350414276,
-0.315098375082016,
0.08161121606826782,
0.8218080401420593,
-0.01867659017443657,
0.5738866329193115,
0.12159544229507446,
-0.4795941412448883,
-0.026748277246952057,
0.03167322278022766,
-0.1446881890296936,
0.3405364751815796,
0.5296769738197327,
0.1862594038248062,
-0.46759793162345886,
-0.06608487665653229,
0.3537977635860443,
-0.41952645778656006,
0.142822265625,
0.9986903667449951,
-0.18780341744422913,
-0.6049090623855591,
0.36183518171310425,
-0.3958633244037628,
0.6314888000488281,
-0.7612090706825256,
-0.2741001546382904,
-0.5921580791473389,
0.10538887232542038,
-0.2250136286020279,
-0.9447222948074341,
0.07593947649002075,
0.3291019797325134,
0.26359254121780396,
-0.191497802734375,
0.6658207774162292,
-0.3032984435558319,
0.06507010757923126,
-0.03745022788643837,
0.48339006304740906,
0.7152108550071716,
0.0510302372276783,
-0.595645010471344,
-0.13364270329475403,
0.0659361407160759,
-0.3518674671649933,
0.48920154571533203,
0.5812467932701111,
-0.2527186870574951,
0.561589777469635,
0.667466402053833,
-0.19622434675693512,
0.19424192607402802,
-0.07718080282211304,
0.9930486083030701,
-0.40929386019706726,
-0.32053834199905396,
-0.7563508152961731,
0.590629518032074,
-0.18491332232952118,
-0.5802916884422302,
0.8269923329353333,
0.5444563627243042,
0.8331526517868042,
0.19383078813552856,
0.9342256188392639,
-0.3771551251411438,
0.35636216402053833,
-0.07274893671274185,
0.7185528874397278,
-0.10258568078279495,
0.2516337037086487,
0.03410031273961067,
-0.5893826484680176,
-0.16855216026306152,
0.2266470044851303,
-0.13889358937740326,
-0.0018744547851383686,
0.14049077033996582,
0.9613032937049866,
-0.24263444542884827,
0.3250414729118347,
0.2914661765098572,
0.066954106092453,
0.6070153713226318,
0.3113135099411011,
0.8337734341621399,
-0.1480797827243805,
0.8873016238212585,
-0.10007213801145554,
-0.4896399974822998,
-0.43183434009552,
-0.7862716913223267,
-0.8947268128395081,
-0.39262738823890686,
-0.14592905342578888,
-0.1392865926027298,
0.1621595174074173,
1.0661259889602661,
0.7750023007392883,
-0.794796884059906,
-0.022652843967080116,
-0.01514449343085289,
-0.2252156138420105,
-0.2376319169998169,
-0.23135074973106384,
0.1579965204000473,
-0.24865096807479858,
-0.7495481967926025,
0.3478677570819855,
-0.07191163301467896,
0.22111481428146362,
-0.16234883666038513,
-0.13462050259113312,
0.09280869364738464,
0.011711527593433857,
0.4921053349971771,
0.612877607345581,
-0.3054167926311493,
-0.2351834625005722,
0.3752594590187073,
-0.22280818223953247,
-0.027042940258979797,
0.7594408988952637,
-0.37484532594680786,
0.49191567301750183,
0.45328786969184875,
0.752533495426178,
0.7094214558601379,
0.05995762348175049,
0.5129961371421814,
-1.018455147743225,
0.22868232429027557,
0.3833332359790802,
-0.1209845170378685,
0.04040104150772095,
-0.5629849433898926,
0.7366613149642944,
-0.04060591012239456,
-0.8097789883613586,
-0.7339236736297607,
-0.1292065680027008,
-0.9929933547973633,
-0.026255972683429718,
1.1167399883270264,
-0.3386482000350952,
0.24612390995025635,
-0.3863615393638611,
-0.6205146908760071,
0.09976092725992203,
-0.7917650938034058,
0.6587031483650208,
0.7398871779441833,
-0.4540780782699585,
-0.22955231368541718,
-1.1209830045700073,
0.5155258774757385,
0.20885246992111206,
-0.9451322555541992,
0.4163708984851837,
0.7116832733154297,
0.20120655000209808,
-0.1467011570930481,
0.6754729151725769,
-0.005538743920624256,
0.09128457307815552,
0.03496072441339493,
-0.14958077669143677,
0.029695650562644005,
-0.15762358903884888,
-0.1577274352312088,
-0.1716831773519516,
-0.19415846467018127,
-0.4679330587387085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01458v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01458v1
|
UQA: Corpus for Urdu Question Answering
| 2024-05-02T16:44:31 | 2024-05-02T16:44:31 |
Samee Arif, Sualeha Farid, Awais Athar, Agha Ali Raza
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces UQA, a novel dataset for question answering and text
comprehension in Urdu, a low-resource language with over 70 million native
speakers. UQA is generated by translating the Stanford Question Answering
Dataset (SQuAD2.0), a large-scale English QA dataset, using a technique called
EATS (Enclose to Anchor, Translate, Seek), which preserves the answer spans in
the translated context paragraphs. The paper describes the process of selecting
and evaluating the best translation model among two candidates: Google
Translator and Seamless M4T. The paper also benchmarks several state-of-the-art
multilingual QA models on UQA, including mBERT, XLM-RoBERTa, and mT5, and
reports promising results. For XLM-RoBERTa-XL, we have an F1 score of 85.99 and
74.56 EM. UQA is a valuable resource for developing and testing multilingual
NLP systems for Urdu and for enhancing the cross-lingual transferability of
existing models. Further, the paper demonstrates the effectiveness of EATS for
creating high-quality datasets for other languages and domains. The UQA dataset
and the code are publicly available at www.github.com/sameearif/UQA.
|
[
-0.20402155816555023,
-0.5057089328765869,
0.46480095386505127,
0.3095649480819702,
-0.007223942317068577,
0.3886871337890625,
0.32273149490356445,
-0.29283496737480164,
-0.07916692644357681,
0.5631797909736633,
-0.41865071654319763,
-0.33717021346092224,
-0.22057896852493286,
0.4774153530597687,
-0.6193824410438538,
0.6857905387878418,
-0.09821668267250061,
0.30717772245407104,
-0.07386773824691772,
-0.24161218106746674,
-0.18641290068626404,
-0.49377962946891785,
-0.5242058038711548,
0.03326266631484032,
0.15739277005195618,
0.6865791082382202,
0.9184999465942383,
0.40351471304893494,
0.3046101927757263,
0.26863333582878113,
-0.1735237091779709,
0.16086000204086304,
-0.15254294872283936,
0.08194814622402191,
-0.08917185664176941,
-0.2329215556383133,
-0.20682363212108612,
-0.3643476366996765,
0.635071873664856,
0.6689483523368835,
-0.16238358616828918,
0.4679454565048218,
-0.15339060127735138,
0.7575681209564209,
-0.6554765701293945,
-0.4186977744102478,
-0.5199872255325317,
-0.021802227944135666,
-0.07631228119134903,
0.2030034214258194,
-0.4514138102531433,
-0.2856796085834503,
-0.16555699706077576,
-0.5938534140586853,
-0.2173789143562317,
-0.01668737083673477,
0.7280879616737366,
0.3763102889060974,
-0.8507875204086304,
-0.15791171789169312,
-0.6552683711051941,
0.7503933906555176,
-0.7939414381980896,
0.6692376136779785,
0.46351587772369385,
0.30731651186943054,
-0.16421912610530853,
-0.7402532696723938,
-0.7592058777809143,
0.06696418672800064,
0.01784602180123329,
0.19199903309345245,
-0.12436240911483765,
-0.22145776450634003,
-0.20494961738586426,
0.38606885075569153,
-0.9570231437683105,
-0.1695009171962738,
-0.4673573672771454,
-0.20782072842121124,
0.39896515011787415,
0.29217422008514404,
0.7378975749015808,
-0.4929084777832031,
-0.4714256823062897,
-0.16446158289909363,
-0.7118442058563232,
0.4412946403026581,
0.08980100601911545,
0.10262960195541382,
0.1295296549797058,
0.8053315281867981,
-0.736334502696991,
0.6843392848968506,
-0.2705879509449005,
0.1922347992658615,
0.13539791107177734,
-0.49607640504837036,
-0.1576118916273117,
-0.15757685899734497,
0.7513353228569031,
0.2641846835613251,
0.294325053691864,
-0.1510569304227829,
0.13833914697170258,
-0.2883877456188202,
0.06956411898136139,
-0.5642202496528625,
-0.24074329435825348,
0.5618020296096802,
-0.07606985419988632,
0.12126392126083374,
-0.08332403749227524,
-0.8615745306015015,
-0.10483630746603012,
0.07507049292325974,
0.24694858491420746,
-0.24742813408374786,
-0.16868026554584503,
0.1239902675151825,
-0.025121835991740227,
0.5078301429748535,
-0.0003852269146591425,
-0.8222823739051819,
0.2869241535663605,
0.21636244654655457,
0.5722578167915344,
-0.11445851624011993,
-0.33989405632019043,
-0.4520440697669983,
0.1385752409696579,
-0.4627627730369568,
0.9937894344329834,
-0.3438705801963806,
-0.1433054655790329,
-0.09649477899074554,
-0.010248026810586452,
-0.31487205624580383,
-0.5211719870567322,
0.8354984521865845,
-0.8707518577575684,
0.17579059302806854,
-0.38263851404190063,
-0.2887565791606903,
-0.47975724935531616,
0.093952476978302,
-0.7658707499504089,
1.490614891052246,
0.5830775499343872,
-0.6552023887634277,
0.06592884659767151,
-0.7784484028816223,
-0.17060434818267822,
0.11031664162874222,
0.09621839225292206,
-0.03824394941329956,
-0.29226693511009216,
0.7199693322181702,
0.18468652665615082,
-0.31447795033454895,
-0.0254803579300642,
0.014884970150887966,
-0.18357309699058533,
0.6425347328186035,
-0.22879323363304138,
0.9782679080963135,
0.5740286111831665,
-0.08469390124082565,
0.08848835527896881,
-0.5463840365409851,
0.653972864151001,
-0.11773928254842758,
-0.3342568874359131,
-0.08397520333528519,
-0.14767573773860931,
0.44487321376800537,
0.3590279817581177,
0.016133125871419907,
-0.7123252749443054,
-0.023687610402703285,
-0.5368648767471313,
0.6675496697425842,
0.2847619950771332,
0.06433748453855515,
0.46197330951690674,
-0.16160063445568085,
0.735482931137085,
-0.008280561305582523,
0.06240253522992134,
0.057647526264190674,
-0.5692257285118103,
-0.4484248757362366,
-0.25833237171173096,
0.6764904260635376,
0.9605187773704529,
-0.8290384411811829,
-0.25564947724342346,
0.11333010345697403,
-0.2995358109474182,
-0.7929219007492065,
0.3994695544242859,
0.40844041109085083,
0.37404143810272217,
0.618341863155365,
0.06785470247268677,
-0.544148325920105,
-0.8404911756515503,
-0.27060431241989136,
-0.16202041506767273,
-0.28233689069747925,
0.07388073205947876,
0.5083706378936768,
-0.25137731432914734,
0.8696028590202332,
-0.306102991104126,
0.008060017600655556,
-0.6062549352645874,
0.030516434460878372,
0.04563288390636444,
0.2634122371673584,
0.49442505836486816,
-1.2947306632995605,
-0.7173798084259033,
-0.160968616604805,
-0.5238144993782043,
-0.04945465922355652,
0.03641434386372566,
-0.3835580348968506,
0.23979374766349792,
0.4075790047645569,
-0.5112518668174744,
0.36219245195388794,
0.5810004472732544,
-0.5558011531829834,
0.539445698261261,
0.2551038861274719,
0.6656344532966614,
-1.498732089996338,
0.04404507949948311,
-0.3297295570373535,
-0.21003423631191254,
-0.5440616607666016,
0.49660542607307434,
0.17915073037147522,
-0.07247430831193924,
-1.119882345199585,
0.845018208026886,
-0.2653897702693939,
-0.15857523679733276,
0.08290833234786987,
0.07302724570035934,
0.22565259039402008,
0.38755255937576294,
-0.1639445573091507,
1.3938400745391846,
0.08039043098688126,
-0.5507094860076904,
0.34633028507232666,
0.7880378365516663,
-0.37703168392181396,
0.2359911948442459,
-0.8715036511421204,
0.14894528687000275,
0.30702683329582214,
0.05212399736046791,
-1.2296714782714844,
-0.4722757339477539,
0.3086276352405548,
-0.6980910301208496,
-0.2486194670200348,
0.19546422362327576,
-0.46745216846466064,
-0.5036597847938538,
-0.2241096794605255,
0.6469094157218933,
0.27185356616973877,
-0.42747899889945984,
0.5198092460632324,
0.39938777685165405,
-0.32717013359069824,
-0.6328186392784119,
-0.740036129951477,
0.05024412274360657,
-0.1280776709318161,
-0.42385539412498474,
0.11339318007230759,
-0.2957513928413391,
-0.3654424250125885,
0.24922123551368713,
-0.0776565819978714,
-0.7571418285369873,
0.18189407885074615,
0.11176667362451553,
0.0854373499751091,
-0.35370898246765137,
-0.06604089587926865,
0.35274168848991394,
0.10796628147363663,
-0.11586591601371765,
-0.00018407842435408384,
0.33537474274635315,
-0.17756377160549164,
-0.07002304494380951,
-0.4469485878944397,
0.8658668994903564,
0.5905013680458069,
-0.33664920926094055,
0.7190690636634827,
0.5702956914901733,
-0.29850390553474426,
-0.03284721449017525,
-0.19759686291217804,
0.07617335766553879,
-0.4486415386199951,
0.4091622829437256,
-0.5620334148406982,
-0.7345551252365112,
0.7087481021881104,
0.07807647436857224,
-0.07880381494760513,
0.6712520122528076,
0.61860591173172,
-0.2947826087474823,
1.159681797027588,
0.5398785471916199,
-0.17707720398902893,
-0.21334773302078247,
-0.12945464253425598,
0.027055874466896057,
-1.089047908782959,
-0.008240903727710247,
-0.8069281578063965,
0.1751108467578888,
-0.319058895111084,
-0.35468536615371704,
0.45112091302871704,
0.26567211747169495,
-0.34890034794807434,
0.3345016539096832,
-0.4453512728214264,
0.6902387142181396,
0.6337234377861023,
-0.1046970933675766,
0.37928441166877747,
-0.2404801994562149,
-0.2470243126153946,
0.08338195085525513,
-0.654244601726532,
-0.6299466490745544,
1.2397881746292114,
-0.007470315787941217,
0.4075740575790405,
0.5164005160331726,
0.24677950143814087,
0.5481654405593872,
0.051156193017959595,
-0.48374539613723755,
0.4275279641151428,
-0.005021350923925638,
-0.9077867865562439,
-0.5992746949195862,
-0.5262036919593811,
-0.7614781856536865,
0.30416160821914673,
-0.13474933803081512,
-0.8924943804740906,
-0.16609740257263184,
-0.04439516365528107,
-0.6743016242980957,
0.17779392004013062,
-0.6776385307312012,
1.037224531173706,
-0.2142840325832367,
-0.1445728987455368,
0.3324715495109558,
-0.5634616613388062,
0.36534565687179565,
0.025001881644129753,
0.2336750626564026,
-0.09714164584875107,
0.0453600212931633,
0.9712375402450562,
-0.11349550634622574,
0.37596771121025085,
0.2437102347612381,
0.13364867866039276,
0.5757222175598145,
0.1349390298128128,
-0.17502252757549286,
0.47192174196243286,
-0.26884377002716064,
0.01839158497750759,
1.011282205581665,
-0.8343774676322937,
-0.6209959387779236,
0.4166700839996338,
-1.0034712553024292,
-0.22469061613082886,
-0.635930061340332,
-0.751125693321228,
-0.5400883555412292,
0.2681610882282257,
0.2605116367340088,
0.3912613093852997,
-0.2353256493806839,
0.2740570604801178,
0.5092812180519104,
-0.2551071345806122,
0.17497693002223969,
0.5933797955513,
-0.279593288898468,
-0.42459535598754883,
0.5320580005645752,
-0.16242414712905884,
0.1923770308494568,
0.5360667109489441,
-0.08403891324996948,
-0.7128999829292297,
-0.3984856605529785,
-1.2087699174880981,
0.05575018748641014,
-0.5999894142150879,
-0.3952881991863251,
-0.6213657259941101,
-0.38216885924339294,
-0.6453597545623779,
0.022423410788178444,
-0.45726022124290466,
-0.5154385566711426,
0.007064451929181814,
-0.004016471561044455,
0.2676072418689728,
0.8241562247276306,
0.07470568269491196,
0.29459112882614136,
-0.9706401824951172,
0.6557562947273254,
0.28114286065101624,
0.01800500974059105,
-0.31579235196113586,
-0.6850877404212952,
-0.15475739538669586,
0.33936554193496704,
-0.48028019070625305,
-1.2692004442214966,
0.5104307532310486,
0.24442408978939056,
0.4575355350971222,
0.030963154509663582,
0.42517074942588806,
0.3479067385196686,
-0.2807586193084717,
0.9475060701370239,
-0.3021763861179352,
-1.0140695571899414,
0.1703648418188095,
-0.3191879987716675,
0.6520196795463562,
0.8809732794761658,
0.8173703551292419,
-0.8068053126335144,
-0.4096667766571045,
-0.05787433683872223,
-0.9627290368080139,
0.307169109582901,
0.2273644506931305,
0.029702719300985336,
0.06797992438077927,
0.5730348825454712,
-0.06669100373983383,
0.1279449760913849,
-0.6828043460845947,
-0.16640795767307281,
-0.05554358661174774,
-0.4572850465774536,
-0.016858920454978943,
-0.49765267968177795,
0.20936442911624908,
-0.4776933193206787,
0.711021900177002,
-0.1796368807554245,
0.2576127350330353,
0.2996126711368561,
-0.27162957191467285,
-0.03725019469857216,
0.604877769947052,
0.547020673751831,
0.7723922729492188,
-0.2551478445529938,
-0.06884638220071793,
0.30015915632247925,
-0.5325742959976196,
0.2945626378059387,
-0.18801701068878174,
-0.30802232027053833,
-0.27935245633125305,
0.16173787415027618,
0.10765350610017776,
0.4260842800140381,
-0.9870970249176025,
0.2085438072681427,
-0.30554842948913574,
-0.26674124598503113,
-0.39884305000305176,
-0.18772919476032257,
0.16683536767959595,
0.1742030829191208,
0.6928372383117676,
-0.3972659409046173,
0.5733814835548401,
-0.6030275821685791,
0.4964817762374878,
0.11199136823415756,
-0.2508205771446228,
-0.17319615185260773,
0.7308643460273743,
0.10866609215736389,
-0.05213156342506409,
0.8966869115829468,
-0.3267127275466919,
-0.9911535978317261,
0.5876362919807434,
0.4744131565093994,
0.42049267888069153,
-0.3970943093299866,
0.7831266522407532,
0.47043395042419434,
0.3858143985271454,
0.12677167356014252,
0.620430052280426,
-0.07765454798936844,
-0.632568895816803,
-0.5152367353439331,
-0.7774388194084167,
-0.8737861514091492,
0.15152665972709656,
-0.835580587387085,
-0.32270747423171997,
0.2012563794851303,
0.2394738495349884,
-0.09142553061246872,
0.09343183040618896,
-0.4710356295108795,
0.20599645376205444,
-0.2093137949705124,
1.0213940143585205,
-0.9010152816772461,
0.7934136390686035,
0.9672766327857971,
-0.48383599519729614,
-1.1139552593231201,
-0.02328154817223549,
-0.07370549440383911,
-0.4745592772960663,
0.5065575242042542,
-0.14811214804649353,
-0.03455232456326485,
0.20258115231990814,
-0.3141392469406128,
-1.0554451942443848,
0.7513547539710999,
0.1983885020017624,
0.0267862007021904,
-0.08001258224248886,
0.5522322654724121,
0.36441338062286377,
-0.07109280675649643,
0.4656772017478943,
0.5132383704185486,
0.4533115029335022,
0.11051955819129944,
-0.802162230014801,
-0.17183050513267517,
-0.42499810457229614,
-0.27862900495529175,
0.07712698727846146,
-0.3595843017101288,
0.8649907112121582,
-0.310007244348526,
-0.22894316911697388,
0.6756091117858887,
0.8641122579574585,
-0.04163739085197449,
0.4031978249549866,
0.16612035036087036,
0.5552253723144531,
0.42688998579978943,
0.032061126083135605,
0.86568683385849,
-0.11196202039718628,
0.09307008981704712,
1.2007306814193726,
-0.291441947221756,
1.3466594219207764,
0.5310441255569458,
-0.33093270659446716,
0.4387502074241638,
0.8759474754333496,
0.4734404981136322,
0.4190566837787628,
0.05922771990299225,
0.01958008110523224,
-0.3326188623905182,
-0.0906713679432869,
-0.349521666765213,
0.8183572888374329,
0.023686781525611877,
0.14107899367809296,
-0.383326917886734,
0.12382187694311142,
-0.1681285798549652,
0.5334210395812988,
-0.20347827672958374,
0.6223885416984558,
-0.10451662540435791,
-0.6341713070869446,
0.6582766771316528,
0.035479459911584854,
0.15881389379501343,
-0.3351047933101654,
-0.22309471666812897,
-0.4919315278530121,
-0.029305221512913704,
-0.06956683099269867,
-0.9493781924247742,
0.5565277338027954,
0.12881672382354736,
-0.17206665873527527,
0.033327456563711166,
0.16545401513576508,
-0.44056436419487,
-0.6972192525863647,
0.16497348248958588,
0.7649898529052734,
0.34163951873779297,
-0.19481894373893738,
-0.8297117352485657,
0.029573306441307068,
-0.033119894564151764,
-0.304477721452713,
0.30778613686561584,
0.33154192566871643,
-0.17561915516853333,
0.7071271538734436,
0.5105776190757751,
-0.1328420341014862,
0.23394863307476044,
-0.3025362491607666,
0.7227491736412048,
-0.6765754222869873,
-0.47152361273765564,
-0.3168196380138397,
0.44702568650245667,
0.13851509988307953,
-0.4893234968185425,
0.9221154451370239,
0.6293185353279114,
0.9197970628738403,
-0.07784140855073929,
0.5020802617073059,
0.04060707241296768,
0.9190083742141724,
-0.5085090398788452,
0.887394905090332,
-0.6737709045410156,
-0.127219557762146,
-0.18302325904369354,
-0.6812701225280762,
-0.15469799935817719,
0.4089334309101105,
-0.1498132199048996,
-0.043618813157081604,
0.7537184953689575,
0.7480089664459229,
0.042054954916238785,
-0.029218165203928947,
0.5416692495346069,
0.057288892567157745,
-0.1626453399658203,
0.8348674774169922,
0.853591799736023,
-0.7839499115943909,
0.6390719413757324,
-0.15224634110927582,
-0.019027916714549065,
-0.02227756939828396,
-0.40063712000846863,
-0.6927512884140015,
-1.1408172845840454,
-0.010386115871369839,
-0.18101941049098969,
0.14993751049041748,
0.7113516330718994,
0.673312783241272,
-1.1172654628753662,
-0.23166538774967194,
0.3183891475200653,
0.3027445077896118,
-0.33167803287506104,
-0.22581519186496735,
0.4223484396934509,
-0.0033711264841258526,
-0.6499335169792175,
0.4483776092529297,
-0.0852249413728714,
-0.2314189225435257,
-0.09644729644060135,
-0.08226854354143143,
-0.6868406534194946,
0.368036687374115,
0.5013068914413452,
0.7756481170654297,
-0.6418849229812622,
-0.11679807305335999,
0.47276946902275085,
-0.25211623311042786,
-0.07572728395462036,
0.36264047026634216,
-0.6661509275436401,
0.20833498239517212,
0.25598013401031494,
0.9119570255279541,
0.1002626046538353,
0.2502612769603729,
0.36019429564476013,
-0.2162187695503235,
-0.07091574370861053,
0.237220898270607,
0.07653498649597168,
0.3865201473236084,
-0.42883729934692383,
0.502701997756958,
-0.37058547139167786,
-0.6776185035705566,
-1.0360984802246094,
0.23433904349803925,
-0.9504299163818359,
-0.31478604674339294,
1.1579973697662354,
-0.10237468034029007,
-0.5620052218437195,
-0.41047635674476624,
-0.2781536877155304,
0.13522756099700928,
-0.39365002512931824,
0.729675829410553,
0.5031701326370239,
-0.06489796936511993,
-0.3162517249584198,
-0.8945972919464111,
0.6285820603370667,
0.7331904768943787,
-0.9380050897598267,
-0.23333106935024261,
0.196769118309021,
0.3006420135498047,
-0.0628470778465271,
0.8174578547477722,
-0.11658195406198502,
0.6688387393951416,
-0.2512356638908386,
0.05856630951166153,
0.05064425244927406,
-0.4970757067203522,
-0.016683977097272873,
0.18145489692687988,
0.1546081155538559,
-0.2123887836933136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01413v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01413v1
|
MiniGPT-3D: Efficiently Aligning 3D Point Clouds with Large Language Models using 2D Priors
| 2024-05-02T16:04:30 | 2024-05-02T16:04:30 |
Yuan Tang, Xu Han, Xianzhi Li, Qiao Yu, Yixue Hao, Long Hu, Min Chen
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large 2D vision-language models (2D-LLMs) have gained significant attention
by bridging Large Language Models (LLMs) with images using a simple projector.
Inspired by their success, large 3D point cloud-language models (3D-LLMs) also
integrate point clouds into LLMs. However, directly aligning point clouds with
LLM requires expensive training costs, typically in hundreds of GPU-hours on
A100, which hinders the development of 3D-LLMs. In this paper, we introduce
MiniGPT-3D, an efficient and powerful 3D-LLM that achieves multiple SOTA
results while training for only 27 hours on one RTX 3090. Specifically, we
propose to align 3D point clouds with LLMs using 2D priors from 2D-LLMs, which
can leverage the similarity between 2D and 3D visual information. We introduce
a novel four-stage training strategy for modality alignment in a cascaded way,
and a mixture of query experts module to adaptively aggregate features with
high efficiency. Moreover, we utilize parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods
LoRA and Norm fine-tuning, resulting in only 47.8M learnable parameters, which
is up to 260x fewer than existing methods. Extensive experiments show that
MiniGPT-3D achieves SOTA on 3D object classification and captioning tasks, with
significantly cheaper training costs. Notably, MiniGPT-3D gains an 8.12
increase on GPT-4 evaluation score for the challenging object captioning task
compared to ShapeLLM-13B, while the latter costs 160 total GPU-hours on 8 A800.
We are the first to explore the efficient 3D-LLM, offering new insights to the
community. Code and weights are available at
https://github.com/TangYuan96/MiniGPT-3D.
|
[
-0.43282145261764526,
-0.5988526940345764,
0.7440509796142578,
0.02345256134867668,
-0.37363070249557495,
-0.3819873332977295,
0.12161001563072205,
-0.31704631447792053,
-0.26052239537239075,
0.19140610098838806,
-0.4008435308933258,
-0.2887767255306244,
-0.5363861322402954,
-0.008395207114517689,
0.037130702286958694,
0.4953889846801758,
-0.03956575691699982,
0.1777217835187912,
0.003695295425131917,
0.0717090293765068,
-0.22158798575401306,
-0.17660018801689148,
-1.0874484777450562,
0.07755043357610703,
0.354769766330719,
0.6289255023002625,
0.7188432812690735,
1.0868685245513916,
0.7399610280990601,
0.2419416457414627,
0.2205241173505783,
0.21831229329109192,
-0.5233657956123352,
-0.5917952656745911,
-0.05534190312027931,
-0.2835317850112915,
-0.5833806395530701,
-0.22465258836746216,
0.5422130227088928,
0.39159512519836426,
-0.12535543739795685,
-0.027798043563961983,
0.1991676390171051,
0.8647598028182983,
-0.5442537069320679,
0.20737963914871216,
-0.31361475586891174,
0.0023275837302207947,
-0.35140520334243774,
0.11224396526813507,
0.08528171479701996,
-0.39501842856407166,
0.21348924934864044,
-1.0299086570739746,
0.23389790952205658,
0.14492015540599823,
0.7238219976425171,
0.6945869326591492,
-0.26347601413726807,
-0.0823831707239151,
-0.3307584822177887,
0.5683503150939941,
-0.6589099168777466,
0.5639228820800781,
0.0001798793819034472,
0.7227139472961426,
0.07593124359846115,
-0.6923717260360718,
-0.845855176448822,
0.026798753067851067,
-0.10676275938749313,
0.348499059677124,
-0.10250692814588547,
0.07210376113653183,
0.4376169741153717,
0.17735296487808228,
-0.8976384401321411,
0.2942618727684021,
-0.26258373260498047,
0.09780140966176987,
0.4360608458518982,
0.042275555431842804,
0.07916748523712158,
-0.3824627995491028,
-0.7520136833190918,
-0.23486635088920593,
-0.9843255877494812,
-0.1184551939368248,
0.11138203740119934,
0.3311094045639038,
-0.388069212436676,
0.6999781131744385,
0.010912499390542507,
0.9126368761062622,
0.33345508575439453,
-0.25564485788345337,
-0.13708063960075378,
-0.4163036644458771,
-0.3291555345058441,
-0.015726307407021523,
1.013654351234436,
0.3444907069206238,
0.010807204060256481,
0.512667179107666,
-0.14191415905952454,
-0.13097424805164337,
-0.01643180288374424,
-0.7593242526054382,
-0.41911837458610535,
-0.10944118350744247,
-0.17847923934459686,
0.20401133596897125,
-0.11506658792495728,
-0.6347692608833313,
-0.5465721487998962,
-0.3095780611038208,
0.6308962106704712,
-0.45387929677963257,
-0.16402588784694672,
0.15643522143363953,
0.1318291574716568,
0.10822977870702744,
0.6520256996154785,
-1.0051429271697998,
0.045753829181194305,
0.606501579284668,
0.9145849347114563,
-0.01644803211092949,
-0.40806081891059875,
-0.4179162085056305,
0.41809070110321045,
-0.38599786162376404,
0.8659301400184631,
-0.20386488735675812,
-0.08648253232240677,
-0.09163861721754074,
-0.3170050382614136,
-0.16824805736541748,
-0.5348723530769348,
0.062131647020578384,
-0.22099393606185913,
0.4327298104763031,
-0.16756756603717804,
-0.29800498485565186,
-0.14064906537532806,
0.43809786438941956,
-0.6315563917160034,
1.1090600490570068,
0.18240799009799957,
-0.7071295976638794,
0.21265926957130432,
-0.49540361762046814,
-0.017351370304822922,
0.08161626011133194,
-0.7273933291435242,
-0.352944552898407,
0.03605541214346886,
0.4926159679889679,
0.5162860155105591,
-0.3559132218360901,
-0.19443516433238983,
-0.05265381559729576,
-0.4430989623069763,
-0.525017499923706,
0.12328211218118668,
0.44728729128837585,
0.10988081246614456,
-0.6862431764602661,
0.14492267370224,
-0.40756598114967346,
-0.30584609508514404,
0.10284778475761414,
-0.13936784863471985,
-0.1676221489906311,
-0.20165535807609558,
-0.20137424767017365,
0.2648025155067444,
0.37184467911720276,
-0.2640477120876312,
0.3362070918083191,
-0.4686686396598816,
0.24349571764469147,
0.5510943531990051,
-0.4535973072052002,
0.6369295716285706,
-0.19602899253368378,
0.40771302580833435,
-0.1347959339618683,
0.13033832609653473,
0.2797476649284363,
-0.38332605361938477,
-0.6394109725952148,
-0.5408535003662109,
-0.08603674173355103,
0.3928655982017517,
-0.9691385626792908,
0.24621428549289703,
-0.7958719730377197,
-0.3851933181285858,
-0.2679271399974823,
0.18931405246257782,
0.45953693985939026,
0.5766885876655579,
0.3253134489059448,
0.19455483555793762,
-0.5139936208724976,
-1.131946325302124,
0.17264753580093384,
-0.03754454106092453,
-0.3295610845088959,
0.1931591033935547,
0.23896819353103638,
0.03870508074760437,
0.8446553349494934,
-0.40953174233436584,
-0.8146725296974182,
-0.16784752905368805,
-0.2986927628517151,
0.1290735900402069,
0.5149825811386108,
0.6625140309333801,
-0.6660274863243103,
-0.9402520060539246,
0.23333919048309326,
-0.525133490562439,
0.007881412282586098,
0.03631466627120972,
-0.10433994978666306,
0.13537262380123138,
0.6811660528182983,
-0.5157907605171204,
0.061120036989450455,
0.8206151127815247,
-0.12855367362499237,
0.119893878698349,
-0.021944640204310417,
0.08839669823646545,
-1.0349256992340088,
-0.07019902765750885,
0.0020789350382983685,
-0.29609718918800354,
-0.4180520474910736,
-0.22246666252613068,
0.15317481756210327,
-0.2682044208049774,
-0.7771636843681335,
0.659554660320282,
-0.6581276059150696,
-0.033302370458841324,
-0.2943584620952606,
0.7772316336631775,
0.032573651522397995,
0.6501113772392273,
0.4774344563484192,
0.5681771636009216,
0.539271891117096,
-0.39335206151008606,
0.19703806936740875,
0.33650264143943787,
-0.3637058436870575,
0.7705361247062683,
-0.2934492826461792,
0.3613143861293793,
0.044057827442884445,
0.1355472356081009,
-0.7112120985984802,
0.04937326908111572,
0.40262526273727417,
-0.05548412352800369,
0.14662182331085205,
-0.5015473961830139,
-0.4144822955131531,
-0.0891510546207428,
-0.2582608759403229,
0.6335599422454834,
0.19400663673877716,
-0.7999351024627686,
0.7625762224197388,
0.29881522059440613,
-0.20852111279964447,
-0.4399285316467285,
-0.5688439607620239,
-0.09582618623971939,
-0.0900215283036232,
-0.6644619107246399,
0.40751883387565613,
0.061144281178712845,
0.10954969376325607,
0.10558243095874786,
-0.33003342151641846,
0.29197758436203003,
-0.40750131011009216,
0.12930333614349365,
0.05330359563231468,
-0.30623114109039307,
-0.38985273241996765,
-0.13569210469722748,
-0.3298376500606537,
-0.49850618839263916,
-0.4704728424549103,
0.5115002989768982,
-0.5108392834663391,
-0.40818482637405396,
-0.4325929880142212,
0.2743037939071655,
0.2753973603248596,
0.27659472823143005,
0.35884150862693787,
0.5316691398620605,
-0.6320444345474243,
0.09562207758426666,
-0.6182422041893005,
0.09655329585075378,
-0.43366748094558716,
0.7374091744422913,
-0.7398228049278259,
-0.9684574604034424,
-0.00667478796094656,
0.12660802900791168,
0.00554147781804204,
0.41105449199676514,
0.4558030366897583,
-0.2757096588611603,
1.1523411273956299,
0.7647464871406555,
0.1719507873058319,
0.6229847073554993,
-0.39524662494659424,
0.45163679122924805,
-0.8723831176757812,
-0.20924820005893707,
-0.23291288316249847,
-0.35569897294044495,
-0.24419541656970978,
-0.7318874597549438,
0.6198105812072754,
0.6162024140357971,
-0.4666825234889984,
0.30125686526298523,
-0.3918358087539673,
0.5321963429450989,
0.499157577753067,
0.03140992298722267,
0.17761072516441345,
0.03416336700320244,
0.12143675237894058,
-0.009659630246460438,
-1.0305213928222656,
-0.5587538480758667,
0.7213585376739502,
0.18750084936618805,
0.6968207955360413,
0.35882171988487244,
0.3936516046524048,
-0.19407036900520325,
0.11521229892969131,
-0.7151256203651428,
0.6191916465759277,
-0.4893122911453247,
-0.13239678740501404,
-0.3608628213405609,
-0.39154577255249023,
-0.6014817357063293,
0.4821479916572571,
-0.18969838321208954,
-0.36782437562942505,
0.23160497844219208,
0.5522474646568298,
-0.7779125571250916,
0.3409055471420288,
-0.8099524974822998,
1.189027190208435,
-0.5562770962715149,
-0.2007981687784195,
-0.12584452331066132,
-0.5378624796867371,
0.3465140163898468,
-0.1362420618534088,
0.09265074133872986,
-0.35749176144599915,
-0.2941359281539917,
0.566325306892395,
-0.5018491148948669,
0.7072518467903137,
-0.44250521063804626,
0.01619485765695572,
-0.01337685901671648,
0.19746199250221252,
0.5391871333122253,
0.16546021401882172,
0.3486689329147339,
0.4137532114982605,
0.3747537136077881,
-0.42111602425575256,
-0.7168469429016113,
0.8349661827087402,
-0.7618713974952698,
-0.7321701049804688,
-0.39949458837509155,
-0.5049199461936951,
-0.33291465044021606,
0.5648280382156372,
0.3171835243701935,
0.17297005653381348,
0.04246838763356209,
0.07481295615434647,
0.40162965655326843,
0.025230780243873596,
0.32391491532325745,
0.4571221172809601,
-0.34722256660461426,
-0.5804388523101807,
0.7105116844177246,
-0.18685759603977203,
0.21892735362052917,
0.7909561395645142,
0.4917057752609253,
-0.3881414830684662,
-0.8524576425552368,
-0.8822776675224304,
0.29976794123649597,
-0.4436165988445282,
-0.4791094660758972,
-0.4355403184890747,
-0.07187029719352722,
-0.5907551050186157,
-0.4326770305633545,
-0.6819002032279968,
-0.5106398463249207,
-0.020745104178786278,
-0.015641601756215096,
0.03307418152689934,
0.6456931829452515,
-0.3100971281528473,
0.6863573789596558,
-0.722470760345459,
0.46311452984809875,
0.5386472940444946,
0.19240565598011017,
-0.37611985206604004,
-0.32372429966926575,
-0.293814480304718,
0.20956523716449738,
-0.037626784294843674,
-0.36632150411605835,
0.14805960655212402,
0.1943926364183426,
0.322190523147583,
0.5033485293388367,
-0.41481032967567444,
1.131495714187622,
-0.5485802292823792,
0.7438967823982239,
0.5012097954750061,
-0.9161407351493835,
0.43502458930015564,
-0.29173025488853455,
0.3565830588340759,
0.584206759929657,
0.38367730379104614,
-0.4037923812866211,
0.03455505892634392,
-0.24773089587688446,
-0.4442102015018463,
0.9170830845832825,
-0.0834876075387001,
-0.3296665549278259,
0.16050975024700165,
0.38888052105903625,
-0.04183250665664673,
-0.10471245646476746,
-0.6042824387550354,
0.014451008290052414,
-0.586681067943573,
-0.5322497487068176,
-0.17814205586910248,
-0.39202263951301575,
-0.29913732409477234,
-0.1413746029138565,
0.5876280069351196,
-0.4906834661960602,
0.11200807988643646,
0.13140389323234558,
-0.23549489676952362,
0.10565827041864395,
-0.26677265763282776,
0.8000465631484985,
0.6545857787132263,
-0.08750990033149719,
0.43196508288383484,
0.18518394231796265,
-0.500274658203125,
-0.09098095446825027,
0.30036938190460205,
0.0025891794357448816,
-0.37592434883117676,
0.09506838023662567,
0.7928992509841919,
0.2865390479564667,
-0.4414733052253723,
0.86204594373703,
-0.10076434165239334,
-0.31685808300971985,
-0.1683913916349411,
-0.2909885048866272,
0.08181528747081757,
0.5064871907234192,
0.09233357012271881,
0.15274713933467865,
-0.20705819129943848,
-0.13005948066711426,
-0.035526324063539505,
0.39549294114112854,
-0.387511283159256,
-0.3244510591030121,
0.6886352300643921,
0.17865081131458282,
0.0013269961345940828,
0.6143144369125366,
0.10185682773590088,
-0.36036887764930725,
0.21401768922805786,
0.5048662424087524,
0.6373023986816406,
-0.19386038184165955,
-0.10014175623655319,
0.4358803331851959,
0.25969940423965454,
-0.23998001217842102,
0.18980760872364044,
0.07920438796281815,
-0.8663471341133118,
-0.39587804675102234,
-0.5970348119735718,
-0.1978314369916916,
-0.014328500255942345,
-0.22422868013381958,
0.4371984302997589,
-0.5849329829216003,
0.09551992267370224,
-0.43011388182640076,
0.0832400992512703,
-0.6756710410118103,
0.0701121911406517,
0.34726065397262573,
0.8362619876861572,
-0.7557070255279541,
1.1190491914749146,
0.7014786601066589,
-0.3446492850780487,
-0.9488630890846252,
-0.3452235162258148,
0.2535642683506012,
-1.0015133619308472,
0.47565826773643494,
0.07737759500741959,
-0.455599308013916,
0.3284408450126648,
-0.10032383352518082,
-1.0657563209533691,
1.0585187673568726,
0.5702669620513916,
-0.9823779463768005,
-0.20112648606300354,
0.4365595877170563,
0.283547580242157,
-0.3244009017944336,
0.044605012983083725,
0.5772239565849304,
0.4472258985042572,
0.25737592577934265,
-0.8553609251976013,
0.08760393410921097,
-0.17289313673973083,
0.21629101037979126,
0.15624746680259705,
-0.5725175142288208,
0.47278743982315063,
-0.19855904579162598,
-0.4059622883796692,
0.03176764398813248,
0.6513705253601074,
0.5358597636222839,
-0.18963181972503662,
0.8802428841590881,
0.7411344051361084,
0.4399859607219696,
-0.1944204866886139,
0.8264050483703613,
-0.17272616922855377,
0.13878534734249115,
1.1683130264282227,
-0.04509617015719414,
0.7966379523277283,
0.6372414827346802,
0.0515759252011776,
0.12348301708698273,
0.8885934352874756,
0.08189395070075989,
0.6973090171813965,
-0.007649930659681559,
0.09695650637149811,
-0.24293090403079987,
0.32740795612335205,
-0.40753307938575745,
0.22455869615077972,
0.19266915321350098,
0.3200257420539856,
-0.12063907086849213,
0.13390617072582245,
-0.07435163855552673,
-0.061921220272779465,
-0.3680245280265808,
0.812936544418335,
0.2138204574584961,
-0.2944827675819397,
0.5165958404541016,
-0.2759755551815033,
0.6191460490226746,
-0.7144647240638733,
0.03306609019637108,
-0.4994572401046753,
0.3236071765422821,
-0.4037088453769684,
-0.5096936225891113,
0.21920685470104218,
-0.09021859616041183,
-0.06799770146608353,
-0.3458310663700104,
-0.1093115285038948,
-0.5406007170677185,
-0.4772363305091858,
-0.004801747854799032,
0.38618290424346924,
-0.02240883558988571,
-0.3745064437389374,
-0.7372145652770996,
0.015458608977496624,
0.04204581305384636,
-0.09922046959400177,
0.31992247700691223,
0.34430038928985596,
-0.1266898810863495,
0.294254869222641,
0.4113882780075073,
0.19308288395404816,
0.1907888650894165,
0.2091258466243744,
0.6037405133247375,
-0.4407765567302704,
-0.40213409066200256,
-0.6946389079093933,
0.386077880859375,
0.09514416009187698,
-0.04279404133558273,
0.7349529266357422,
1.039180874824524,
1.152860164642334,
-0.0005280692130327225,
0.6705241799354553,
-0.23041459918022156,
0.35871464014053345,
-0.9267163872718811,
0.3989006578922272,
-0.8656649589538574,
0.3591366112232208,
0.044920023530721664,
-1.2494124174118042,
-0.6296961903572083,
0.6496627926826477,
-0.3781610429286957,
-0.06298419833183289,
0.974204957485199,
0.9067193865776062,
-0.22976833581924438,
-0.2975780963897705,
0.35231414437294006,
0.15771757066249847,
0.5477951765060425,
0.6869931221008301,
0.9408442974090576,
-0.46522897481918335,
0.9349997043609619,
-0.6518344879150391,
-0.40261155366897583,
-0.0687134861946106,
-0.8491604328155518,
-0.620832622051239,
-0.4826449453830719,
-0.4511144161224365,
0.07230211049318314,
-0.03144392743706703,
0.6535710692405701,
0.8075680732727051,
-0.7565637826919556,
-0.2560691237449646,
0.0842672809958458,
-0.15221722424030304,
-0.5294760465621948,
-0.11801557242870331,
0.9709703922271729,
0.05341697856783867,
-1.193618893623352,
0.5940734148025513,
0.49050256609916687,
0.128248929977417,
0.052195098251104355,
-0.16356922686100006,
-0.009989132173359394,
-0.4854139983654022,
0.5649266839027405,
0.2627387046813965,
-0.7292386889457703,
-0.6041558980941772,
-0.10194439440965652,
-0.41046029329299927,
0.30407091975212097,
0.8642674088478088,
-0.3757525086402893,
0.48195260763168335,
0.5685639381408691,
0.4346546232700348,
0.8235927224159241,
0.20451346039772034,
0.5685224533081055,
-0.5007503628730774,
0.24459630250930786,
0.25258153676986694,
0.5189808011054993,
0.39116570353507996,
-0.17623189091682434,
0.5503301620483398,
0.036156605929136276,
-0.3708330988883972,
-0.43165668845176697,
0.2484939694404602,
-1.1885992288589478,
-0.02931050769984722,
0.9503585696220398,
0.19161561131477356,
-0.10946497321128845,
0.15468499064445496,
-0.4167657494544983,
-0.13192109763622284,
0.1355004757642746,
0.6088495254516602,
-0.028510645031929016,
-0.4651941955089569,
-0.5221996903419495,
-0.44901981949806213,
0.9033491015434265,
0.3174123466014862,
-0.5967198610305786,
-0.08787413686513901,
0.5814860463142395,
0.26690375804901123,
0.016139309853315353,
0.771784245967865,
-0.2684277892112732,
0.1945301592350006,
0.07220899313688278,
0.23980827629566193,
-0.3432543873786926,
-0.3015410006046295,
-0.32008662819862366,
0.0714699923992157,
-0.03106994740664959,
-0.285362184047699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01403v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01403v1
|
Unsupervised Flow Discovery from Task-oriented Dialogues
| 2024-05-02T15:54:36 | 2024-05-02T15:54:36 |
Patrícia Ferreira, Daniel Martins, Ana Alves, Catarina Silva, Hugo Gonçalo Oliveira
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The design of dialogue flows is a critical but time-consuming task when
developing task-oriented dialogue (TOD) systems. We propose an approach for the
unsupervised discovery of flows from dialogue history, thus making the process
applicable to any domain for which such an history is available. Briefly,
utterances are represented in a vector space and clustered according to their
semantic similarity. Clusters, which can be seen as dialogue states, are then
used as the vertices of a transition graph for representing the flows visually.
We present concrete examples of flows, discovered from MultiWOZ, a public TOD
dataset. We further elaborate on their significance and relevance for the
underlying conversations and introduce an automatic validation metric for their
assessment. Experimental results demonstrate the potential of the proposed
approach for extracting meaningful flows from task-oriented conversations.
|
[
-0.3650231659412384,
-0.5144917964935303,
0.9115981459617615,
-0.18978643417358398,
-0.4265674352645874,
0.39152050018310547,
0.06705205142498016,
0.03521626815199852,
0.27971014380455017,
0.9566137194633484,
-1.007773518562317,
-0.6899536848068237,
-0.5467225313186646,
-0.39380449056625366,
-0.6942111253738403,
0.8233106136322021,
-0.16573293507099152,
-0.15876148641109467,
-0.3090193271636963,
-0.23540358245372772,
-0.4753216803073883,
-0.3637773394584656,
-0.3662661015987396,
-0.509039044380188,
0.39122843742370605,
0.1678348034620285,
0.12027274072170258,
0.23030011355876923,
0.058520570397377014,
0.39638951420783997,
-0.23738515377044678,
0.35420727729797363,
-0.46162149310112,
0.5696219205856323,
-0.13053655624389648,
-0.17754825949668884,
-0.06269659101963043,
-0.253254771232605,
0.42863738536834717,
0.9173871874809265,
-0.3165595531463623,
-0.01867322251200676,
0.29212602972984314,
0.6456727385520935,
-0.43007954955101013,
0.6465625762939453,
-0.3863161504268646,
0.20203961431980133,
-0.5503673553466797,
-0.47651857137680054,
-0.41853243112564087,
0.026452286168932915,
0.39120912551879883,
-0.5095615386962891,
0.25303149223327637,
-0.1278330385684967,
0.2565957009792328,
0.3579756021499634,
-0.5144358277320862,
-0.5089538097381592,
-0.8779918551445007,
0.7059017419815063,
-0.5043386816978455,
0.2404804229736328,
0.0030624994542449713,
0.35599133372306824,
-0.7404900789260864,
-0.7653459906578064,
-0.48844432830810547,
0.31603214144706726,
-0.1457400768995285,
0.21017926931381226,
-0.2963990867137909,
0.10817459225654602,
0.025611167773604393,
0.015667418017983437,
-0.536832332611084,
-0.30601781606674194,
-0.2665587365627289,
-0.5143694877624512,
0.47766971588134766,
0.6027795672416687,
0.19709904491901398,
-0.2526209056377411,
-0.26451072096824646,
-0.09104897081851959,
-0.3819364607334137,
0.27141639590263367,
0.1001504436135292,
0.42028048634529114,
-0.12468218058347702,
0.5157152414321899,
-0.5270622968673706,
0.8212637901306152,
-0.20742034912109375,
-0.3786237835884094,
0.3081316351890564,
-0.3261248469352722,
0.055980388075113297,
-0.10629890859127045,
0.8825626969337463,
0.33835676312446594,
0.26033076643943787,
-0.1630643904209137,
0.10969047248363495,
-0.1726333051919937,
0.31947875022888184,
-0.6810010671615601,
-0.2779582440853119,
-0.05868416279554367,
-0.48512667417526245,
0.0072512393817305565,
0.12960034608840942,
-0.643431544303894,
-0.6900965571403503,
-0.3747726082801819,
-0.010907601565122604,
-0.07541760802268982,
-0.4112073481082916,
-0.43247535824775696,
-0.6855855584144592,
-0.005744485184550285,
0.6650814414024353,
-0.30445006489753723,
-0.0417720228433609,
0.7871043086051941,
0.8503820300102234,
-0.4128122627735138,
-0.023334288969635963,
-0.29415449500083923,
0.16846424341201782,
-0.5687397122383118,
1.167020559310913,
-0.7140687704086304,
-0.6534191966056824,
0.042834799736738205,
-0.021176835522055626,
-0.023250844329595566,
-0.4955247938632965,
0.6583960652351379,
-0.23483991622924805,
-0.03773166239261627,
0.13775864243507385,
-0.6220282316207886,
-0.20650237798690796,
-0.07725062966346741,
-0.3634216785430908,
0.671028196811676,
0.12779922783374786,
-0.8305261135101318,
0.269826203584671,
-1.022379755973816,
-0.31237491965293884,
0.04809284582734108,
-0.5098933577537537,
-0.18620015680789948,
0.11498362571001053,
-0.06618054211139679,
0.4823691248893738,
-0.3164384365081787,
0.40925246477127075,
-0.16550593078136444,
-0.12355875223875046,
0.2187231183052063,
-0.42157843708992004,
0.7475771307945251,
0.3111359179019928,
-0.25830668210983276,
0.2061290144920349,
-0.8252741694450378,
0.13527052104473114,
-0.20450903475284576,
0.15349642932415009,
-0.45268601179122925,
0.3424622714519501,
-0.526350200176239,
0.028430480509996414,
-0.10942693054676056,
-0.897855281829834,
0.026280781254172325,
-0.18294905126094818,
0.5155945420265198,
0.779355525970459,
0.2967868745326996,
0.3396691679954529,
-0.13675282895565033,
0.27761441469192505,
0.5349331498146057,
0.17831864953041077,
-0.29934456944465637,
-0.8601828813552856,
-0.8551945090293884,
-0.20689813792705536,
-0.2501840591430664,
0.30763164162635803,
-0.7829986810684204,
0.1063368171453476,
0.021601242944598198,
-0.38879698514938354,
-0.012058459222316742,
-0.0323779433965683,
0.17370428144931793,
0.6662474870681763,
-0.03330906480550766,
-0.26139017939567566,
-0.3368622660636902,
-0.8224403858184814,
-0.026975220069289207,
-0.24577680230140686,
-0.12480234354734421,
0.5236667990684509,
0.05835432931780815,
-0.33965587615966797,
1.1389763355255127,
-0.8186753392219543,
-0.038958728313446045,
-0.12492190301418304,
0.7175973057746887,
0.19589956104755402,
0.39369967579841614,
0.4093687832355499,
-0.6213625073432922,
-0.30262890458106995,
0.14462316036224365,
-0.6261722445487976,
-0.1416841447353363,
0.2049613744020462,
-0.39573216438293457,
-0.1306048035621643,
0.753201961517334,
-0.3003017008304596,
0.8026992082595825,
0.4914211332798004,
-0.5318357348442078,
0.12598150968551636,
0.07199034839868546,
0.06267489492893219,
-1.0356837511062622,
-0.11502818018198013,
-0.14218994975090027,
-0.2793859541416168,
-0.8178007006645203,
-0.4561809301376343,
-0.29381805658340454,
-0.3155774474143982,
-0.3817264139652252,
0.3601134717464447,
-0.42663440108299255,
-0.06701952964067459,
-0.436221718788147,
0.03126122057437897,
-0.1866838037967682,
0.8711260557174683,
0.1920497566461563,
0.3650209307670593,
0.9034678339958191,
-0.6502248048782349,
0.48484715819358826,
0.29150211811065674,
-0.41343992948532104,
0.7693438529968262,
-0.3711462914943695,
0.5022631287574768,
-0.36575669050216675,
0.4940110445022583,
-0.9002386331558228,
0.07263174653053284,
0.264614075422287,
-0.3776330053806305,
-0.1741746962070465,
-0.6798698902130127,
-0.18186959624290466,
-0.2064085155725479,
0.06728807836771011,
0.2848323881626129,
0.23405461013317108,
-0.4902828633785248,
0.79906165599823,
0.9138053059577942,
-0.39086779952049255,
-0.2470153570175171,
0.012745530344545841,
-0.12589013576507568,
-0.12816374003887177,
-0.5991201400756836,
0.060847267508506775,
-0.03750161826610565,
-0.1788015216588974,
-0.1046609953045845,
-0.19687925279140472,
-0.5657578706741333,
0.07366463541984558,
0.9073015451431274,
0.018607549369335175,
0.11308125406503677,
-0.03517865762114525,
0.04956066608428955,
-0.05084235966205597,
0.11811304837465286,
-0.4719483554363251,
0.6386001110076904,
0.07869105786085129,
-0.4685758650302887,
-0.5354179739952087,
0.7838289141654968,
0.8411917686462402,
-0.06077494099736214,
0.07993342727422714,
0.584304928779602,
-0.3255694806575775,
-0.3548523485660553,
-0.18290632963180542,
0.006320341024547815,
-0.4085438847541809,
-0.0772094801068306,
-0.2085709571838379,
-1.0212910175323486,
0.5891817808151245,
-0.543319046497345,
0.23666390776634216,
0.44462764263153076,
0.44639429450035095,
-0.3252568542957306,
1.1543365716934204,
0.7389010190963745,
0.3135594427585602,
0.6225329637527466,
-0.4096886217594147,
0.34198105335235596,
-0.7727193236351013,
-0.7537528276443481,
-0.5924996137619019,
-0.2630915641784668,
-0.5349147915840149,
-0.6195880770683289,
0.6818752288818359,
-0.13193339109420776,
0.07620007544755936,
0.22087699174880981,
-0.0649213194847107,
0.17015108466148376,
0.6782844066619873,
-0.25992733240127563,
0.47351086139678955,
-0.3125970661640167,
-0.35862621665000916,
0.28946444392204285,
-0.6759759783744812,
-0.3220435678958893,
0.9095208048820496,
0.06386367976665497,
0.6772676706314087,
-0.012280820868909359,
0.6770515441894531,
0.332710862159729,
0.18252679705619812,
-0.8060498833656311,
0.6108875274658203,
-0.09903973340988159,
-0.35845351219177246,
-0.5476594567298889,
-0.5114642977714539,
-1.3565986156463623,
0.13955670595169067,
-0.08603251725435257,
-0.9508800506591797,
0.23431432247161865,
-0.036658868193626404,
-0.2573355734348297,
0.1487741321325302,
-0.5514456629753113,
0.8613723516464233,
0.25901615619659424,
0.27153003215789795,
-0.42437389492988586,
-0.4463719129562378,
0.11983148008584976,
0.11550131440162659,
0.0887499749660492,
-0.3187561333179474,
0.6266222596168518,
0.8968151211738586,
-1.0156221389770508,
0.8821598887443542,
-0.36242473125457764,
-0.1373717039823532,
0.8854894638061523,
0.011439836584031582,
0.37604114413261414,
-0.002227339893579483,
0.6192662715911865,
0.12732051312923431,
-0.028245490044355392,
-0.08713271468877792,
-0.9911318421363831,
0.686548113822937,
-0.4788658618927002,
-0.48854580521583557,
-0.1405329704284668,
-0.580438494682312,
-0.5102480053901672,
0.1579834520816803,
-0.0885564312338829,
0.9742740392684937,
-0.3004360496997833,
0.020738698542118073,
0.26689061522483826,
0.24151292443275452,
0.754286527633667,
0.5977653861045837,
-0.027155833318829536,
0.10347557812929153,
0.6146161556243896,
-0.13804499804973602,
-0.15975183248519897,
0.22664520144462585,
0.34580984711647034,
-0.563421905040741,
-0.6893317699432373,
-0.8083038926124573,
-0.06932265311479568,
-0.47824427485466003,
-0.25984275341033936,
-0.5905449390411377,
-0.08645854145288467,
-0.37165966629981995,
0.5201377272605896,
-0.5262808799743652,
-0.5123369693756104,
-0.2382010519504547,
0.11925511062145233,
0.3278038501739502,
1.217543125152588,
0.09756258875131607,
-0.010031781159341335,
-0.8842654228210449,
0.1271459460258484,
0.6109387278556824,
0.4528680741786957,
-0.009232799522578716,
-0.1429090052843094,
-0.03860388323664665,
0.1633468121290207,
-0.5894913673400879,
-0.7416771054267883,
0.2626219093799591,
0.029179727658629417,
0.7423998117446899,
0.6850870847702026,
0.3955993950366974,
0.6442146301269531,
-0.5716384053230286,
0.8102369904518127,
0.27468109130859375,
-0.9417588114738464,
0.7675773501396179,
-0.20444287359714508,
0.10096163302659988,
0.08443129062652588,
0.13758759200572968,
-0.5890860557556152,
-0.6609779596328735,
-0.7420501708984375,
-0.5040215849876404,
0.43010634183883667,
0.2711685299873352,
-0.13175906240940094,
-0.013057177886366844,
0.0595962218940258,
0.12545111775398254,
0.24493864178657532,
0.05032820254564285,
-0.3565317988395691,
-0.39149904251098633,
-0.009285868145525455,
-0.0023148134350776672,
0.19095611572265625,
-0.4098619222640991,
0.07606342434883118,
0.06731031090021133,
-0.336725115776062,
0.3350159227848053,
0.35109245777130127,
0.07857539504766464,
0.033475108444690704,
0.35839587450027466,
0.5389503836631775,
0.8392418026924133,
0.09801678359508514,
0.19446095824241638,
-0.33598554134368896,
-0.2641863524913788,
-0.0036092959344387054,
-0.2668617367744446,
0.05800079554319382,
0.45912930369377136,
0.24257870018482208,
1.0679700374603271,
-0.07917183637619019,
-0.9170956611633301,
0.7163454294204712,
-0.12635768949985504,
-0.20929467678070068,
-0.30649319291114807,
0.11847348511219025,
-0.09283726662397385,
0.6938385367393494,
0.39599117636680603,
0.2642993628978729,
0.5352808237075806,
-1.0796306133270264,
0.08990241587162018,
0.6094776391983032,
-0.535944402217865,
-0.2658901810646057,
0.059220168739557266,
0.5597431063652039,
-0.3152778148651123,
0.5892386436462402,
-0.3110406696796417,
-0.5472711324691772,
0.09992778301239014,
-0.022856418043375015,
0.9461222290992737,
0.21527105569839478,
0.47843122482299805,
0.16748380661010742,
-0.49794673919677734,
0.06608721613883972,
-0.04672154411673546,
-0.48779258131980896,
-0.7951403856277466,
-0.5807839035987854,
-0.22775673866271973,
-0.5179823040962219,
-0.019212234765291214,
-0.7735512256622314,
-0.14581598341464996,
-0.14440865814685822,
-0.3201744258403778,
0.006346903275698423,
-0.3419610857963562,
-0.5675352811813354,
-0.12985850870609283,
0.18941380083560944,
0.3848161995410919,
-0.9070418477058411,
0.6207572221755981,
0.5321596264839172,
0.38281893730163574,
-0.49742674827575684,
-0.01410769298672676,
0.24924130737781525,
-0.7258155345916748,
0.6513810753822327,
-0.3321012556552887,
-0.5377054810523987,
-0.2630887031555176,
-0.1916981190443039,
-0.7714190483093262,
1.0011881589889526,
0.05004054680466652,
-0.47878655791282654,
0.14654499292373657,
-0.03565691038966179,
0.6785309314727783,
-0.5035839080810547,
0.13042518496513367,
0.3758080303668976,
0.19946973025798798,
0.4790961444377899,
-1.1077525615692139,
-0.1852443963289261,
-0.3289638161659241,
-0.024904225021600723,
0.5367053747177124,
-0.33326128125190735,
0.6682972311973572,
-0.2591494023799896,
-0.7353739142417908,
0.07662670314311981,
0.6469002366065979,
0.04977058619260788,
0.658079981803894,
0.8415979743003845,
0.4501361548900604,
0.8749463558197021,
-0.2193804383277893,
0.6401805877685547,
0.06343722343444824,
0.16440951824188232,
0.9107931852340698,
-0.030510736629366875,
0.6521720290184021,
0.4162180721759796,
0.04418760910630226,
0.8671215772628784,
0.2677491307258606,
0.546022355556488,
0.6571806073188782,
0.4885219633579254,
-0.12257149815559387,
-0.2940942049026489,
-0.46816009283065796,
0.05393407493829727,
0.6947163939476013,
0.3904608488082886,
-0.07533358782529831,
-0.246071457862854,
0.0961616188287735,
-0.15055103600025177,
-0.15161192417144775,
-0.461023211479187,
1.1539537906646729,
-0.209972083568573,
-0.8991204500198364,
0.37571612000465393,
-0.48100557923316956,
0.3978368043899536,
-0.2232019454240799,
-0.25260528922080994,
-0.23772719502449036,
-0.11280829459428787,
0.038036417216062546,
-1.1484659910202026,
0.43751418590545654,
0.21300935745239258,
-0.02608725242316723,
-0.5268614292144775,
0.4905639886856079,
-0.4268319606781006,
-0.1986459493637085,
0.19795334339141846,
0.9595279693603516,
0.4357406198978424,
-0.1552787870168686,
-0.24653360247612,
-0.05493105202913284,
0.15672041475772858,
0.2766711711883545,
0.12344817817211151,
0.8031174540519714,
-0.24099458754062653,
0.8003407120704651,
0.47438159584999084,
-0.22183392941951752,
0.13068342208862305,
0.5158828496932983,
0.9160773754119873,
-0.6489754319190979,
-0.554806113243103,
-0.3910461962223053,
0.5373817682266235,
-0.3515750467777252,
-0.3403322100639343,
0.4044148623943329,
0.4405882656574249,
0.7667269110679626,
0.12774717807769775,
0.87430340051651,
0.15899658203125,
1.045792579650879,
-0.592724084854126,
0.4470653831958771,
-0.327385812997818,
-0.09968426823616028,
-0.48792707920074463,
-0.44248026609420776,
0.13858285546302795,
0.6724998950958252,
0.3708556592464447,
-0.42458653450012207,
0.6963681578636169,
0.7916709184646606,
0.15058569610118866,
0.338290274143219,
0.21030455827713013,
0.04362369328737259,
0.4866584241390228,
0.5200760364532471,
1.4254661798477173,
0.12339844554662704,
0.675652801990509,
-0.24653038382530212,
-0.333429753780365,
-0.018028676509857178,
-0.9198882579803467,
-1.066442847251892,
-1.3477182388305664,
-0.5771304965019226,
0.05048864334821701,
-0.08876721560955048,
0.5440108776092529,
0.9160224795341492,
-0.6521413922309875,
-0.34235966205596924,
-0.31581705808639526,
0.3277738690376282,
-0.23509755730628967,
-0.18756715953350067,
0.009274004958570004,
-0.08997443318367004,
-0.7955541014671326,
0.7410144805908203,
0.46475276350975037,
0.3594931960105896,
-0.3016400635242462,
-0.04070450738072395,
0.540156364440918,
-0.008884288370609283,
0.7035951018333435,
0.2806439995765686,
-0.6747768521308899,
-0.2963978052139282,
-0.2880861163139343,
0.5363433361053467,
0.12960469722747803,
1.8105272054672241,
-0.6595842838287354,
0.4362233579158783,
0.6527954936027527,
0.24393786489963531,
0.7987279295921326,
-0.04181254655122757,
0.7526962757110596,
-0.7337668538093567,
0.13117796182632446,
0.3385085463523865,
0.5707024335861206,
0.092597097158432,
0.17622755467891693,
0.1497282236814499,
0.32815197110176086,
-0.26664987206459045,
-0.5861112475395203,
0.5404401421546936,
-1.3433188199996948,
-0.2787700891494751,
0.8150763511657715,
-0.33494022488594055,
0.10718478262424469,
-0.6359133720397949,
-0.3220522701740265,
0.14853355288505554,
-0.5350966453552246,
0.5363314747810364,
0.4852067232131958,
-0.8750022053718567,
-0.1336957961320877,
-0.16688960790634155,
0.5698496103286743,
-0.10670740902423859,
-0.800412654876709,
0.29600629210472107,
0.549909770488739,
0.034459084272384644,
0.5187313556671143,
0.6780730485916138,
-0.2034882754087448,
-0.19300176203250885,
-0.24938206374645233,
-0.5182714462280273,
0.11207201331853867,
-0.6355951428413391,
0.3735653758049011,
0.17514634132385254,
-0.18429511785507202,
-0.34291964769363403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01379v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01379v2
|
Verification and Refinement of Natural Language Explanations through LLM-Symbolic Theorem Proving
| 2024-05-02T15:20:01 | 2024-05-08T03:05:04 |
Xin Quan, Marco Valentino, Louise A. Dennis, André Freitas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Natural language explanations have become a proxy for evaluating explainable
and multi-step Natural Language Inference (NLI) models. However, assessing the
validity of explanations for NLI is challenging as it typically involves the
crowd-sourcing of apposite datasets, a process that is time-consuming and prone
to logical errors. To address existing limitations, this paper investigates the
verification and refinement of natural language explanations through the
integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) and Theorem Provers (TPs).
Specifically, we present a neuro-symbolic framework, named Explanation-Refiner,
that augments a TP with LLMs to generate and formalise explanatory sentences
and suggest potential inference strategies for NLI. In turn, the TP is employed
to provide formal guarantees on the logical validity of the explanations and to
generate feedback for subsequent improvements. We demonstrate how
Explanation-Refiner can be jointly used to evaluate explanatory reasoning,
autoformalisation, and error correction mechanisms of state-of-the-art LLMs as
well as to automatically enhance the quality of human-annotated explanations of
variable complexity in different domains.
|
[
-0.20269058644771576,
-0.9545890092849731,
0.6814048886299133,
0.19622011482715607,
-0.17903867363929749,
-0.06976958364248276,
-0.6000164151191711,
-0.4119440019130707,
0.009215923957526684,
0.3938586115837097,
-0.8050029873847961,
-0.3648148477077484,
-0.31039369106292725,
0.4867404103279114,
-0.44644543528556824,
0.72312992811203,
-0.44792255759239197,
-0.02848980762064457,
-0.2472408562898636,
0.11812090873718262,
-0.7224279642105103,
-0.1976228654384613,
-0.703249454498291,
-0.5760186910629272,
0.3523241877555847,
0.23458120226860046,
0.5853059887886047,
0.5813254117965698,
0.09400378912687302,
0.3972149193286896,
0.1591673642396927,
0.47242650389671326,
-0.08841124922037125,
0.27629777789115906,
-0.4483780860900879,
-0.5807768106460571,
-0.19486024975776672,
-0.3435264527797699,
0.45501184463500977,
0.6421348452568054,
-0.23354855179786682,
0.11326084285974503,
-0.12844394147396088,
0.4780908226966858,
-0.5391035079956055,
0.30703988671302795,
-0.5616514086723328,
-0.0911991149187088,
0.17863646149635315,
-0.4057481288909912,
-0.5085002779960632,
-0.6650649309158325,
0.2584525942802429,
-0.6925196051597595,
0.3847283720970154,
0.06251092255115509,
1.0592944622039795,
0.5928014516830444,
-0.3805129826068878,
-0.38295799493789673,
-0.915205717086792,
0.8845071792602539,
-0.8212817907333374,
0.2865613102912903,
0.1490195244550705,
0.6488831639289856,
-0.35936328768730164,
-0.6383092999458313,
-0.7749736905097961,
-0.17480351030826569,
-0.4323461949825287,
-0.19264692068099976,
-0.26110395789146423,
-0.030184432864189148,
0.3080272078514099,
0.3078598976135254,
-0.6586560010910034,
0.1454748511314392,
-0.08317902684211731,
-0.4020390808582306,
0.6871707439422607,
0.02745896205306053,
0.30167248845100403,
-0.24135422706604004,
-0.13047252595424652,
0.22783263027668,
-0.6047018766403198,
-0.30254876613616943,
0.1261087954044342,
0.1788116991519928,
0.07920611649751663,
0.5959764122962952,
-0.18952471017837524,
0.9406353235244751,
-0.05438237637281418,
-0.02311629429459572,
-0.16026470065116882,
-0.5688670873641968,
-0.4575873911380768,
0.24441124498844147,
0.6361766457557678,
0.2865756154060364,
0.5582912564277649,
-0.3605959713459015,
-0.25897926092147827,
0.1632998138666153,
0.13208064436912537,
-0.702678382396698,
-0.0028533146250993013,
0.6288642287254333,
-0.3758808970451355,
-0.14526131749153137,
-0.19009044766426086,
-0.7660046815872192,
-0.3400757610797882,
-0.7771148681640625,
0.5282574892044067,
-0.551516592502594,
-0.36805474758148193,
0.49141159653663635,
-0.21812117099761963,
0.11046261340379715,
0.5796668529510498,
-0.8557136058807373,
0.3780806362628937,
0.9097347855567932,
0.5547007322311401,
0.3439529240131378,
-0.2503495514392853,
-0.43053489923477173,
0.3334731161594391,
-0.2398001253604889,
0.8764070272445679,
-0.39472198486328125,
0.08031750470399857,
0.10400932282209396,
0.003643345320597291,
-0.032777007669210434,
-0.5575238466262817,
0.6152788400650024,
-0.6393352746963501,
0.5030178427696228,
-0.24453340470790863,
-0.5031152367591858,
-0.6690366864204407,
0.3008856177330017,
-0.4680308997631073,
0.9789264798164368,
-0.15994246304035187,
-0.5666195750236511,
0.4015497863292694,
-0.9726513624191284,
-0.49299466609954834,
-0.11071458458900452,
0.01933155581355095,
-0.05233530327677727,
0.20292125642299652,
0.42780375480651855,
0.28700190782546997,
-0.603299617767334,
0.7364618182182312,
-0.16679467260837555,
-0.27399536967277527,
0.47228652238845825,
-0.4853029251098633,
0.9054921269416809,
0.04193435609340668,
-0.5109906792640686,
0.21909098327159882,
-0.8881853222846985,
0.09912712872028351,
0.22997254133224487,
0.005786103196442127,
-0.20825372636318207,
0.030369214713573456,
-0.4253776967525482,
0.14565303921699524,
0.32326194643974304,
-0.4081602394580841,
-0.03727038577198982,
-0.4906230568885803,
0.8390371203422546,
0.7020410895347595,
0.08351541310548782,
0.1709858924150467,
-0.1442454606294632,
0.4205326437950134,
-0.20703557133674622,
0.14852342009544373,
-0.5785227417945862,
-0.21472269296646118,
-0.8066505789756775,
-0.20803610980510712,
0.331243097782135,
0.3758758008480072,
-0.6082425713539124,
0.527051568031311,
-0.4324343204498291,
-0.20742866396903992,
-0.38613641262054443,
0.015455617569386959,
0.17037035524845123,
0.6357160210609436,
0.3590158224105835,
0.10414482653141022,
-0.7469512820243835,
-0.9601232409477234,
-0.49769410490989685,
-0.38754981756210327,
-0.3312583267688751,
0.07375837862491608,
0.6237769722938538,
-0.18474406003952026,
1.225079894065857,
0.006985760759562254,
0.3165120780467987,
-0.1785002499818802,
0.3227214217185974,
0.45087164640426636,
0.1897190809249878,
0.20607620477676392,
-0.466106653213501,
0.055781759321689606,
-0.21558581292629242,
-0.8351656794548035,
-0.5926810503005981,
-0.3617790937423706,
-0.1377493143081665,
0.26700982451438904,
0.32317566871643066,
-0.6486995220184326,
0.4589352309703827,
0.29497188329696655,
-0.31610748171806335,
0.7959808111190796,
-0.3683966398239136,
0.024676889181137085,
-0.660681426525116,
-0.07609373331069946,
0.0880826786160469,
-0.30553004145622253,
-0.5600894093513489,
0.21737121045589447,
-0.17618301510810852,
0.1335459053516388,
0.13315923511981964,
0.44966796040534973,
-0.4102596640586853,
0.06273547559976578,
-0.33149397373199463,
0.46577364206314087,
0.33834972977638245,
0.2941572666168213,
-0.031496983021497726,
0.2661595642566681,
0.6032357811927795,
-0.6780928373336792,
0.5159787535667419,
-0.13155440986156464,
0.02640574239194393,
0.508893609046936,
-0.9533913731575012,
-0.018180739134550095,
-0.21806028485298157,
0.44129276275634766,
-1.3309950828552246,
-0.3225495517253876,
0.20927421748638153,
-0.23335883021354675,
0.04379645735025406,
-0.32513025403022766,
-0.966697633266449,
-0.3239222764968872,
-0.020391175523400307,
0.19411787390708923,
0.20186488330364227,
-0.9339082837104797,
1.1052148342132568,
-0.24827401340007782,
0.1649249941110611,
-0.4598362147808075,
-0.7363308072090149,
0.3272204101085663,
-0.24549975991249084,
-0.8852921724319458,
0.3271939158439636,
0.11957422643899918,
-0.6312803030014038,
-0.09137625247240067,
-0.2402990609407425,
-0.025286050513386726,
0.25619053840637207,
0.2774621248245239,
0.3771437704563141,
-0.4199240505695343,
0.39020857214927673,
0.06452731788158417,
-0.38333940505981445,
0.5296949744224548,
-0.4613576829433441,
0.4470266103744507,
-0.20467673242092133,
-0.6552438735961914,
-0.6555488705635071,
0.17878098785877228,
0.517816424369812,
-0.25145822763442993,
0.6292538642883301,
0.5208870768547058,
-0.6406861543655396,
-0.24466145038604736,
-0.77032071352005,
-0.49941015243530273,
-0.4367406368255615,
-0.047305162996053696,
-0.3768123984336853,
-0.6773664355278015,
0.4480327069759369,
-0.3062802851200104,
0.31258565187454224,
0.6566043496131897,
0.5016380548477173,
0.36168065667152405,
0.8691622614860535,
0.22874289751052856,
0.43959900736808777,
-0.10592231154441833,
-0.03649668022990227,
0.616667628288269,
-0.3160189092159271,
-0.3608611226081848,
-0.7312008738517761,
-0.1988346427679062,
-0.5165331363677979,
-0.4632708728313446,
-0.15028701722621918,
0.11257875710725784,
-0.41109833121299744,
0.18610607087612152,
-0.4755552411079407,
0.677574098110199,
0.4071989059448242,
-0.1804949790239334,
0.6610103249549866,
0.12285155802965164,
-0.21575437486171722,
-0.11524699628353119,
-0.4472464323043823,
-0.8614320158958435,
0.5939532518386841,
0.46597474813461304,
0.5392850041389465,
0.2769915461540222,
0.6216680407524109,
0.04058929160237312,
0.48706158995628357,
-0.7277678847312927,
0.6165086030960083,
0.10061173141002655,
-0.6411252617835999,
-0.3137179911136627,
-0.44460269808769226,
-0.5508857369422913,
0.3314601182937622,
-0.15925252437591553,
-0.8619717955589294,
0.12477460503578186,
0.21949855983257294,
-0.35521140694618225,
0.15176710486412048,
-0.9639532566070557,
0.8497220277786255,
-0.45294713973999023,
-0.4550498127937317,
-0.5420680642127991,
-0.4051603376865387,
0.5135277509689331,
-0.08201587200164795,
0.21664415299892426,
-0.03679962083697319,
0.022007465362548828,
0.5060241222381592,
-0.827333390712738,
0.8166621923446655,
-0.33765125274658203,
-0.45801833271980286,
0.149149551987648,
0.34541410207748413,
0.519099771976471,
0.21069438755512238,
-0.4570421278476715,
0.2023269087076187,
-0.17890074849128723,
-0.13285529613494873,
-1.1204966306686401,
0.4993918836116791,
-0.3542941212654114,
-0.7189913392066956,
-0.22892679274082184,
-0.3534521460533142,
-0.02950243651866913,
0.25730782747268677,
-0.13890792429447174,
0.5287702083587646,
0.18616509437561035,
-0.3008301258087158,
0.6125718355178833,
-0.39480912685394287,
0.31659820675849915,
0.7195371389389038,
-0.49819374084472656,
-0.23411384224891663,
0.7612193822860718,
-0.2695693373680115,
0.09974484145641327,
0.4660216271877289,
0.4318661093711853,
-0.5252296328544617,
-0.7244588732719421,
-0.38002485036849976,
0.5236743092536926,
-0.8716045618057251,
0.07479704916477203,
-0.4360920190811157,
0.03302975371479988,
-0.03911401331424713,
-0.025481069460511208,
-0.0772462859749794,
-0.578467845916748,
-0.009688474237918854,
-0.01493990607559681,
0.6823568940162659,
0.752501368522644,
-0.0398942232131958,
0.15054431557655334,
-0.48025450110435486,
0.5516564249992371,
0.29544344544410706,
0.42239999771118164,
0.25410449504852295,
-0.601172149181366,
-0.018284333869814873,
0.2313317209482193,
0.056832168251276016,
-0.8034728765487671,
0.3488572835922241,
0.04951651766896248,
0.28089776635169983,
0.5142755508422852,
-0.14899587631225586,
1.0557777881622314,
-0.5010350346565247,
0.6672071218490601,
0.02132311835885048,
-1.1368157863616943,
0.6478121876716614,
-0.11241152137517929,
0.12185131013393402,
0.3937218487262726,
0.12656821310520172,
-0.5840150713920593,
-0.4626465439796448,
-0.5709102749824524,
-0.9291326403617859,
0.42090240120887756,
0.035286832600831985,
-0.20235790312290192,
-0.06427813321352005,
0.664741575717926,
0.16740909218788147,
0.06813561916351318,
-0.6163507103919983,
-0.15003471076488495,
-0.24368353188037872,
-0.17961697280406952,
0.17819997668266296,
-0.1295706331729889,
-0.33582988381385803,
-0.10167699307203293,
0.7740423083305359,
-0.22420066595077515,
0.2557283937931061,
0.2212996631860733,
-0.28371620178222656,
-0.01832200028002262,
0.4445635676383972,
0.631870448589325,
1.074436902999878,
-0.12157236039638519,
0.3646393418312073,
0.12071245163679123,
0.06597200036048889,
0.03056565672159195,
0.35284706950187683,
0.08548644185066223,
0.4257591664791107,
0.5304639339447021,
0.5693685412406921,
0.07666903734207153,
-0.7293564081192017,
0.18476618826389313,
-0.4369101822376251,
-0.12273839861154556,
-0.4384905993938446,
-0.07569027692079544,
0.19535651803016663,
0.10531643778085709,
0.46028220653533936,
-0.07064951211214066,
0.05525683984160423,
-0.22318193316459656,
0.008214982226490974,
0.3382181227207184,
0.008499231189489365,
-0.2765953540802002,
0.6462029814720154,
-0.17419548332691193,
-0.3599264323711395,
0.5035408735275269,
-0.1137460470199585,
-0.4938735067844391,
0.5307726860046387,
0.5243706107139587,
0.9259650111198425,
0.13327433168888092,
0.22972358763217926,
0.4366165101528168,
0.4800400137901306,
-0.004614285659044981,
0.2082037329673767,
-0.07713790982961655,
-0.5624974966049194,
-1.1686031818389893,
-0.4239973723888397,
-0.5291397571563721,
0.12265933305025101,
-0.41451749205589294,
0.18487203121185303,
-0.4441060423851013,
0.26410964131355286,
0.3599340319633484,
-0.28098776936531067,
-0.4528166651725769,
0.08036204427480698,
-0.06230669096112251,
1.0258110761642456,
-0.7801859974861145,
0.37441208958625793,
0.4663354754447937,
-0.291811466217041,
-0.9058573246002197,
0.10860100388526917,
0.10380182415246964,
-0.9567328095436096,
0.9954215288162231,
0.2941122353076935,
-0.2990831732749939,
-0.4183337986469269,
-0.42778435349464417,
-0.5013273358345032,
0.8103339672088623,
0.6968883275985718,
-0.640259861946106,
0.14356008172035217,
0.2805279493331909,
0.841517984867096,
-0.07876601070165634,
0.5735938549041748,
0.6155191659927368,
0.8540554046630859,
0.029499845579266548,
-0.7272365093231201,
0.5128129720687866,
-0.18886920809745789,
-0.08088205009698868,
0.21903446316719055,
-0.07686539739370346,
0.3212311565876007,
-0.31720396876335144,
-0.21077589690685272,
-0.026172472164034843,
0.7640196681022644,
0.4156683385372162,
0.1916932463645935,
0.7985142469406128,
0.6181015372276306,
1.0458054542541504,
-0.3656993508338928,
1.2324222326278687,
-0.24499423801898956,
0.05680873990058899,
1.2052985429763794,
-0.18414537608623505,
0.6093804240226746,
0.658125638961792,
-0.054290637373924255,
1.0861289501190186,
0.7715507745742798,
-0.010971673764288425,
0.0654417872428894,
0.6497434973716736,
-0.4109438359737396,
-0.3142920136451721,
-0.3113173842430115,
0.04894229397177696,
0.32164454460144043,
0.3425499200820923,
-0.43654701113700867,
-0.4851827323436737,
-0.3580751419067383,
-0.0514494925737381,
0.05101122707128525,
-0.0745471715927124,
0.5159192085266113,
-0.17734567821025848,
-0.9744383692741394,
0.8786867260932922,
0.17095501720905304,
0.37849122285842896,
-0.3953491151332855,
-0.29070818424224854,
-0.0015185860684141517,
0.2960849702358246,
-0.39250925183296204,
-0.5996995568275452,
0.4127364456653595,
0.1537034809589386,
-0.14134298264980316,
-0.409758597612381,
0.6122247576713562,
-0.35309651494026184,
-0.28501754999160767,
0.16573630273342133,
0.3252788484096527,
0.23653140664100647,
-0.030655821785330772,
-0.6741909980773926,
-0.1781207025051117,
-0.0567471943795681,
0.0634869784116745,
-0.2120688408613205,
0.8105219602584839,
-0.13241803646087646,
0.8274493217468262,
0.6956869959831238,
-0.030207088217139244,
-0.16996179521083832,
0.5519633293151855,
0.5133960843086243,
-0.47097596526145935,
-0.2256009727716446,
-1.3725749254226685,
0.48381146788597107,
-0.06264146417379379,
0.18699869513511658,
0.7620474696159363,
0.43759575486183167,
0.39204487204551697,
-0.0009086599457077682,
0.7272405028343201,
0.06315743178129196,
0.34625229239463806,
-0.5884928107261658,
0.17625443637371063,
-0.36778444051742554,
0.620975136756897,
0.07720999419689178,
-0.6825339198112488,
-0.5124993324279785,
0.7132173776626587,
-0.392903596162796,
0.0634193941950798,
0.9374657273292542,
0.8865926265716553,
-0.09101980179548264,
0.5334317684173584,
-0.40637725591659546,
0.460359126329422,
0.3712388575077057,
0.5155844688415527,
0.9357035756111145,
-0.18547648191452026,
0.5309300422668457,
-0.25593045353889465,
-0.12644407153129578,
-0.06844466179609299,
-1.5268914699554443,
-0.7511228322982788,
-0.1292574554681778,
-0.7824565172195435,
-0.5906266570091248,
-0.03687644377350807,
0.7702887058258057,
0.5201743841171265,
-0.7789586186408997,
-0.16293378174304962,
-0.46576565504074097,
0.49723154306411743,
-0.4048464000225067,
-0.3139418363571167,
0.3859042823314667,
-0.36147716641426086,
-0.5508819818496704,
0.3565714359283447,
0.4052921235561371,
-0.19722360372543335,
-0.6154885292053223,
0.046114832162857056,
-0.018381569534540176,
0.12273460626602173,
0.44805681705474854,
0.24557505548000336,
-1.04716157913208,
-0.23397892713546753,
-0.1449078619480133,
0.343978613615036,
-0.006887055933475494,
0.9632575511932373,
-0.8058597445487976,
0.426388144493103,
0.5026847720146179,
0.5960567593574524,
0.2100476324558258,
-0.26890525221824646,
0.91475909948349,
-0.6017475724220276,
-0.2804888188838959,
-0.0886664167046547,
0.5838192701339722,
0.4774574339389801,
-0.17026197910308838,
0.521451473236084,
0.03695246949791908,
-0.4235486388206482,
-0.9284377694129944,
0.21150226891040802,
-0.8491222262382507,
-0.1859002411365509,
1.018365502357483,
-0.19828370213508606,
-0.3039022386074066,
-0.380508154630661,
-0.1177203357219696,
0.30113959312438965,
-0.20793908834457397,
0.981808066368103,
0.8981847763061523,
-0.0035715776029974222,
-0.06274066120386124,
-0.5736841559410095,
0.3064180314540863,
0.48003801703453064,
-1.0488834381103516,
0.6236681938171387,
0.4730413854122162,
0.2899787127971649,
0.41563859581947327,
0.025187166407704353,
-0.28035223484039307,
0.3165743350982666,
-0.4678446352481842,
-0.015438234433531761,
-0.15072405338287354,
0.056750379502773285,
-0.6310299038887024,
0.01946122758090496,
0.03523753583431244,
0.10560974478721619
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01376v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01376v1
|
Topics in the Study of the Pragmatic Functions of Phonetic Reduction in Dialog
| 2024-05-02T15:18:42 | 2024-05-02T15:18:42 |
Nigel G. Ward, Carlos A. Ortega
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Reduced articulatory precision is common in speech, but for dialog its
acoustic properties and pragmatic functions have been little studied. We here
try to remedy this gap. This technical report contains content that was omitted
from the journal article (Ward et al. 2024, submitted). Specifically, we here
report 1) lessons learned about annotating for perceived reduction, 2) the
finding that, unlike in read speech, the correlates of reduction in dialog
include high pitch, wide pitch range, and intensity, and 3) a baseline model
for predicting reduction in dialog, using simple acoustic/prosodic features,
that achieves correlations with human perceptions of 0.24 for English, and 0.17
for Spanish. We also provide examples of additional possible pragmatic
functions of reduction in English, and various discussion, observations and
speculations
|
[
-0.8263729810714722,
-0.6338363289833069,
0.3006904423236847,
-0.036798521876335144,
-0.22806605696678162,
-0.39989423751831055,
-0.48282378911972046,
-0.39761945605278015,
0.5834639072418213,
0.436113178730011,
-0.3700435161590576,
-0.535140335559845,
-0.0829814076423645,
0.36091527342796326,
-0.28299975395202637,
0.6089888215065002,
0.07026376575231552,
0.14262792468070984,
0.13175471127033234,
-0.10648425668478012,
-0.5183769464492798,
-0.8160723447799683,
-0.5541543364524841,
-0.20730061829090118,
0.4281329810619354,
0.31024008989334106,
0.4464804530143738,
0.5158605575561523,
0.8118477463722229,
0.2890866994857788,
-0.27137526869773865,
-0.20986402034759521,
-0.3125477433204651,
0.012065980583429337,
0.23019708693027496,
-0.8062903881072998,
-0.4425691068172455,
0.2964731752872467,
1.0771803855895996,
1.2378312349319458,
-0.2087092399597168,
0.00446018623188138,
-0.08176638185977936,
0.6002448797225952,
-0.23340927064418793,
0.5661418437957764,
-0.30409759283065796,
0.17534731328487396,
-0.2317163199186325,
-0.14565178751945496,
-0.3634873926639557,
-0.09129465371370316,
0.44971364736557007,
-0.991183340549469,
0.4400828182697296,
0.009688826277852058,
0.9346840977668762,
0.3122710585594177,
-0.37806403636932373,
-0.2978717088699341,
-0.9322330951690674,
0.7802215814590454,
-0.4651558995246887,
0.22037282586097717,
0.8555789589881897,
-0.06648147851228714,
0.1356111615896225,
-0.543583869934082,
-0.42398393154144287,
-0.3839436173439026,
-0.07361045479774475,
0.0833575427532196,
-0.03269515186548233,
0.67430180311203,
0.12470704317092896,
0.6331387758255005,
-0.15721727907657623,
-0.16145354509353638,
-0.8044108152389526,
-0.6304258108139038,
0.4602455794811249,
-0.04385533928871155,
0.1555202603340149,
-0.06253675371408463,
0.4456009268760681,
-0.0603339783847332,
-0.6355317831039429,
0.008399523794651031,
0.42916932702064514,
0.22327102720737457,
0.07135938107967377,
0.2811906039714813,
0.08197052031755447,
0.49741101264953613,
-0.21944911777973175,
-0.6531546115875244,
0.39870959520339966,
-0.24638570845127106,
-0.010796927846968174,
0.08637998253107071,
0.14454112946987152,
0.7521771192550659,
0.3645184636116028,
0.2529536485671997,
0.19603636860847473,
0.013426579535007477,
0.03274174779653549,
-0.5221017003059387,
-0.4441647529602051,
-0.44856953620910645,
-0.5944887399673462,
-0.20910434424877167,
0.02805188298225403,
-0.03933922201395035,
-0.20751696825027466,
-0.33601972460746765,
-0.11424639075994492,
-0.20345206558704376,
-0.26974207162857056,
-0.14260663092136383,
-0.23863403499126434,
-0.11150169372558594,
0.5411182045936584,
-0.3424355387687683,
0.5323454737663269,
0.47735127806663513,
0.8595271110534668,
0.16497665643692017,
-0.0633574053645134,
-0.17743727564811707,
0.02660650759935379,
-0.5583885312080383,
0.6651709079742432,
-0.7594466805458069,
-0.8252439498901367,
0.07167624682188034,
0.1745838075876236,
-0.34435349702835083,
-0.9846196174621582,
0.8906370997428894,
0.2571195065975189,
0.037860460579395294,
-0.48907214403152466,
-0.5153351426124573,
-0.8365598320960999,
-0.25495103001594543,
-0.8577030897140503,
0.4096904695034027,
-0.030147284269332886,
-0.37246376276016235,
0.17647609114646912,
-0.20547957718372345,
-0.7790387272834778,
-0.028956566005945206,
0.1359759271144867,
-0.031168336048722267,
0.43618518114089966,
-0.16911721229553223,
-0.1705370843410492,
-0.10863200575113297,
-0.05353735014796257,
-0.25575169920921326,
-0.4928930103778839,
0.20770478248596191,
-0.3887414038181305,
0.41591063141822815,
0.3945600092411041,
0.027276933193206787,
-0.08729089051485062,
-0.7488412857055664,
-0.29748716950416565,
-0.10190865397453308,
-0.25511276721954346,
-0.2447178065776825,
-0.07274225354194641,
0.029417652636766434,
-0.2271157056093216,
-0.029696056619286537,
-0.49917900562286377,
0.03360459581017494,
-0.6616767644882202,
0.7485917210578918,
0.14654991030693054,
0.3677338659763336,
0.7007251977920532,
-0.549667477607727,
0.567817747592926,
-0.2841131091117859,
0.07785516232252121,
-0.08414982259273529,
-0.595895528793335,
-0.9269788861274719,
-0.6029244661331177,
0.4231298267841339,
0.7231440544128418,
-0.23966296017169952,
0.17165496945381165,
0.3383198380470276,
-0.17501182854175568,
-0.8653165698051453,
0.052024345844984055,
0.5203730463981628,
0.7516225576400757,
0.012309139594435692,
-0.5061013698577881,
-0.4596623182296753,
-1.0675160884857178,
-0.005634236615151167,
-0.7649542689323425,
-0.1674344390630722,
0.149370014667511,
0.17717953026294708,
0.4615649878978729,
0.6434602737426758,
-0.31627777218818665,
-0.7078484892845154,
-0.09938781708478928,
0.3634450435638428,
-0.03260022774338722,
0.21351344883441925,
0.5789279937744141,
-0.6383789777755737,
-0.21198692917823792,
-0.1304842233657837,
-0.3885837495326996,
-0.34639644622802734,
0.007956561632454395,
0.32240766286849976,
0.2482348382472992,
0.6892183423042297,
-0.8674958348274231,
0.994160532951355,
0.028222128748893738,
0.22556069493293762,
0.5285167694091797,
-0.02918964810669422,
0.3703409433364868,
-0.4717637598514557,
0.03194883093237877,
0.2179570347070694,
-0.11007574200630188,
-1.0077800750732422,
-0.37029165029525757,
-0.29472649097442627,
-0.30709534883499146,
-0.34689295291900635,
0.34355074167251587,
-0.3374706506729126,
0.0010837961453944445,
-0.15703608095645905,
0.2711866497993469,
0.17763063311576843,
0.2354055643081665,
0.3724195063114166,
0.8550399541854858,
0.29808056354522705,
-0.9434275031089783,
-0.07989121228456497,
0.38076356053352356,
0.03523373603820801,
0.6114832162857056,
-0.6801447868347168,
0.09079266339540482,
-0.10734681785106659,
0.22974362969398499,
-1.1026966571807861,
-0.1455487161874771,
0.37958961725234985,
-0.5479062795639038,
0.23086166381835938,
-0.36462870240211487,
-0.27564021944999695,
-0.19665952026844025,
-0.3884216845035553,
0.14906489849090576,
0.5815881490707397,
0.1648707389831543,
0.08202559500932693,
0.6730304956436157,
-0.6543429493904114,
0.23825743794441223,
-0.7466270327568054,
-0.04469485208392143,
-0.34095335006713867,
-0.5153393149375916,
0.3930979073047638,
-0.06425578147172928,
-0.9477406740188599,
-0.2880021929740906,
-0.3227330148220062,
-0.20954585075378418,
0.053542669862508774,
0.144309863448143,
-0.03239123895764351,
-0.029646150767803192,
0.579220175743103,
-0.07299217581748962,
-0.17437437176704407,
0.05296885222196579,
0.16587355732917786,
0.17240387201309204,
-0.17155924439430237,
-0.011287524364888668,
-0.9770236611366272,
0.22471743822097778,
0.347234308719635,
0.07483212649822235,
0.5375474095344543,
0.3966202139854431,
-0.25141170620918274,
0.3876263201236725,
-0.4566476047039032,
-0.28556784987449646,
-0.36564189195632935,
0.2794986069202423,
-0.33744800090789795,
-0.7536015510559082,
0.8091956973075867,
0.19357803463935852,
-0.05744490027427673,
0.38089048862457275,
0.26908114552497864,
-0.34162718057632446,
0.7607748508453369,
0.2802126705646515,
0.3687543570995331,
0.694532036781311,
0.05840330943465233,
0.6194228529930115,
-0.7493909001350403,
0.007722700946033001,
-0.731088399887085,
-0.05865579843521118,
-0.6270195245742798,
-0.2366112768650055,
0.4037454426288605,
0.26992326974868774,
0.22021108865737915,
-0.17627495527267456,
-0.5556402206420898,
0.07261651754379272,
0.5857531428337097,
0.0033257207833230495,
0.20751520991325378,
-0.22856459021568298,
0.29890432953834534,
-0.6489399075508118,
-0.47506827116012573,
-0.559119462966919,
0.743281900882721,
0.7558487057685852,
0.26434412598609924,
-0.09310125559568405,
0.7393546104431152,
0.32810211181640625,
-0.0812099352478981,
-0.9818549156188965,
0.7534420490264893,
0.11974570900201797,
-0.5256783962249756,
-0.4255075454711914,
-0.4788646101951599,
-0.7871547341346741,
0.12009137868881226,
0.14786891639232635,
-0.34143131971359253,
0.020782748237252235,
0.20665742456912994,
-0.35934755206108093,
-0.0781758576631546,
-1.1762213706970215,
0.2645142674446106,
0.39451220631599426,
0.1489000767469406,
-0.22595523297786713,
-0.4400925040245056,
0.09014637768268585,
0.30568212270736694,
0.4794832468032837,
-0.35645174980163574,
-0.06138289347290993,
1.1357537508010864,
-0.6436468958854675,
0.9049864411354065,
-0.5514116287231445,
-0.036944832652807236,
0.7155923843383789,
0.40964898467063904,
0.24786388874053955,
0.017063278704881668,
0.12142757326364517,
0.1634313315153122,
0.052845560014247894,
-0.10487855225801468,
-0.4305132329463959,
0.32848528027534485,
-0.43993279337882996,
-0.825289785861969,
-0.10946214199066162,
-0.5517317056655884,
-0.08829575031995773,
-0.010654623620212078,
0.21950268745422363,
0.5175023674964905,
-0.30404695868492126,
0.21301808953285217,
0.5349825620651245,
0.01123468205332756,
0.580966591835022,
0.08263416588306427,
-0.053401995450258255,
-0.5274873375892639,
0.6575164198875427,
0.6667953133583069,
0.21827878057956696,
0.22518125176429749,
0.24138261377811432,
-0.36629587411880493,
-0.9476523399353027,
0.2111436128616333,
0.6258215308189392,
-1.0551644563674927,
0.27413734793663025,
-0.2566673755645752,
0.13809752464294434,
-0.8063721656799316,
-0.059646233916282654,
-0.04379982873797417,
-1.0384440422058105,
-0.6224451661109924,
-0.3282867968082428,
0.5019216537475586,
0.768399178981781,
-0.07621891796588898,
0.6016972064971924,
-0.5739530324935913,
0.04585546627640724,
0.11527823656797409,
-0.12166130542755127,
-0.2543312907218933,
-0.8545562624931335,
-0.09149916470050812,
-0.11651229858398438,
0.06464845687150955,
-0.6653816103935242,
0.8195838332176208,
0.518092930316925,
0.5079074501991272,
0.12490419298410416,
0.33432671427726746,
0.8316322565078735,
-0.32580360770225525,
0.7824355959892273,
0.17234034836292267,
-1.1903636455535889,
0.6041551828384399,
-0.4841613471508026,
0.04938925802707672,
0.7617371678352356,
-0.0008202262688428164,
-0.515587329864502,
-0.4930015206336975,
-0.8442055583000183,
-0.835486888885498,
0.2785966694355011,
0.46257448196411133,
-0.36384153366088867,
-0.19547075033187866,
0.4664514660835266,
0.11731085181236267,
0.570558488368988,
-0.3798554539680481,
-0.5267549753189087,
0.043400656431913376,
-0.0780261754989624,
-0.21089597046375275,
-0.13695736229419708,
-0.34081727266311646,
-0.6137656569480896,
0.45331069827079773,
0.09747003018856049,
0.24435177445411682,
0.6147261261940002,
-0.3942083418369293,
0.10273832082748413,
0.2417622208595276,
1.0608946084976196,
0.8340471982955933,
-0.24852299690246582,
0.11883065849542618,
0.260124534368515,
-0.8331002593040466,
-0.19953563809394836,
-0.1437138468027115,
-0.23222868144512177,
0.46811649203300476,
0.6585585474967957,
0.7070053219795227,
0.19017496705055237,
-0.25957730412483215,
0.1286323219537735,
-0.0389135405421257,
-0.38662877678871155,
-0.5707912445068359,
-0.3665660321712494,
-0.11023496091365814,
-0.12974460422992706,
0.3341628313064575,
0.1520993858575821,
0.462658554315567,
-0.6472961902618408,
0.19554312527179718,
0.021045848727226257,
-0.4754554033279419,
-0.6711206436157227,
0.2611595690250397,
0.8119327425956726,
-0.5810520648956299,
0.31328272819519043,
-0.38777977228164673,
-0.44685399532318115,
0.5160344839096069,
0.15775811672210693,
0.812975287437439,
-0.1520918309688568,
0.2717401385307312,
0.2162773311138153,
0.5149995684623718,
0.0877133384346962,
0.012822229415178299,
-0.33937162160873413,
-0.4094235897064209,
-0.30256345868110657,
-0.31994932889938354,
-0.6755573749542236,
-0.15176476538181305,
-1.055451512336731,
-0.0006504753255285323,
-0.6559428572654724,
-0.4594584107398987,
0.13505132496356964,
0.11605954170227051,
-0.5360700488090515,
-0.028984667733311653,
0.07759398221969604,
0.4522545337677002,
-0.7310822606086731,
0.6669257879257202,
0.7421432733535767,
-0.5945814251899719,
-0.575140118598938,
0.08555911481380463,
0.2638991177082062,
-0.6811850070953369,
0.6017048358917236,
0.16179123520851135,
-0.28590384125709534,
-0.12913501262664795,
-0.23220786452293396,
-0.437002569437027,
0.5039516091346741,
0.7335968613624573,
-0.8240659236907959,
0.12133538722991943,
0.03282235562801361,
0.7602226734161377,
-0.28742435574531555,
0.21535134315490723,
0.823279082775116,
0.7706171274185181,
-0.05459672212600708,
-1.7239325046539307,
-0.28948497772216797,
-0.19253017008304596,
0.06881842017173767,
0.2037397027015686,
-0.7372518181800842,
0.8643956780433655,
0.04907864332199097,
-0.4906781315803528,
0.0615193173289299,
0.19609570503234863,
-0.03181537240743637,
0.6150844097137451,
0.30299466848373413,
0.4065746068954468,
0.857743501663208,
-0.33524447679519653,
0.8836366534233093,
-0.11224664747714996,
0.25905323028564453,
0.5200475454330444,
-0.5405468344688416,
0.6175028085708618,
0.663438618183136,
-0.21475929021835327,
0.11203479766845703,
0.5568804144859314,
0.6141912937164307,
0.5262268781661987,
0.2662568688392639,
-0.3337196409702301,
-0.22212998569011688,
-0.4881301820278168,
-0.26005280017852783,
0.46211177110671997,
0.4992550313472748,
-0.197430819272995,
0.32869255542755127,
0.13206064701080322,
0.39654088020324707,
0.22800993919372559,
-0.5503688454627991,
0.9152093529701233,
0.18015462160110474,
-0.6207809448242188,
0.8486876487731934,
-0.34409099817276,
0.22701816260814667,
-0.3149782419204712,
-0.40677693486213684,
-0.0410783477127552,
0.05317610502243042,
-0.18550322949886322,
-0.6896029710769653,
0.5457724928855896,
-0.4812764525413513,
-0.11015580594539642,
-0.1624162644147873,
0.7491524815559387,
-0.22423481941223145,
-0.08908166736364365,
0.1162533089518547,
0.13009227812290192,
0.39939212799072266,
-0.07914961129426956,
-0.2706942558288574,
0.33937564492225647,
0.378721684217453,
-0.16091732680797577,
0.018413150683045387,
0.42002439498901367,
0.014003279618918896,
0.6932135224342346,
0.43851298093795776,
0.3883599042892456,
0.08513626456260681,
0.40823546051979065,
0.32387933135032654,
-0.9620707631111145,
-0.5736122727394104,
-0.06848341971635818,
0.09940874576568604,
-0.08497801423072815,
-0.505148708820343,
0.6001032590866089,
0.06796685606241226,
0.8859180808067322,
0.0000959647077252157,
1.0418812036514282,
0.06960706412792206,
0.7173119187355042,
-0.6677118539810181,
0.329193115234375,
-0.05456353351473808,
0.3014964461326599,
-0.15272216498851776,
-0.8632605075836182,
-0.5235651731491089,
1.0709768533706665,
-0.42555540800094604,
0.09608541429042816,
1.043521523475647,
0.7446549534797668,
0.760461151599884,
0.0767022967338562,
0.7020143866539001,
0.054616138339042664,
0.08982430398464203,
0.06593500077724457,
0.6785619854927063,
-0.2851138710975647,
0.5745077133178711,
-0.7183712720870972,
-0.24117115139961243,
-0.3752624988555908,
-0.4109179377555847,
-1.0837284326553345,
-0.751584529876709,
-0.567207396030426,
0.033833686262369156,
0.187950998544693,
0.6803643107414246,
0.7499178647994995,
-0.6581507921218872,
-0.275759756565094,
-0.027618402615189552,
-0.022284964099526405,
-0.11428467184305191,
-0.18033982813358307,
0.1175139918923378,
-0.017800165340304375,
-0.591903567314148,
0.39793190360069275,
0.502849280834198,
0.0985073670744896,
-0.02444608509540558,
-0.043893732130527496,
0.10192413628101349,
-0.03812897205352783,
0.26709577441215515,
0.5581291317939758,
-0.921400785446167,
-0.5807687044143677,
-0.020312542095780373,
0.4144340455532074,
0.26941928267478943,
0.8766652345657349,
-0.4326431155204773,
0.24922895431518555,
0.4204881489276886,
-0.2573213577270508,
0.2568749785423279,
0.06745138764381409,
0.4746211767196655,
-0.8628993034362793,
0.7875218391418457,
0.7473055720329285,
0.30249056220054626,
0.313871294260025,
-0.22623980045318604,
0.4175136685371399,
0.7627661228179932,
-0.3651820421218872,
-1.0837939977645874,
0.42356076836586,
-0.976182758808136,
0.13764022290706635,
1.0889359712600708,
-0.028775686398148537,
-0.3902839124202728,
-0.5215907692909241,
-0.5910831093788147,
0.17033521831035614,
-0.7533344626426697,
0.3585151731967926,
1.0422711372375488,
-0.3097863495349884,
-0.6049146056175232,
-0.6487579345703125,
0.5823282599449158,
0.5652894973754883,
-0.51335209608078,
0.3185339570045471,
0.7081830501556396,
-0.0862644612789154,
0.4098643660545349,
0.5528638958930969,
-0.04798178747296333,
0.3971679210662842,
0.37941572070121765,
0.2759842872619629,
0.0361873134970665,
-0.5051779747009277,
-0.5178200006484985,
0.1903844177722931,
0.7711493372917175,
-0.29194176197052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01359v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01359v1
|
GAIA: A General AI Assistant for Intelligent Accelerator Operations
| 2024-05-02T15:06:18 | 2024-05-02T15:06:18 |
Frank Mayet
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, physics.acc-ph
|
Large-scale machines like particle accelerators are usually run by a team of
experienced operators. In case of a particle accelerator, these operators
possess suitable background knowledge on both accelerator physics and the
technology comprising the machine. Due to the complexity of the machine,
particular subsystems of the machine are taken care of by experts, who the
operators can turn to. In this work the reasoning and action (ReAct) prompting
paradigm is used to couple an open-weights large language model (LLM) with a
high-level machine control system framework and other tools, e.g. the
electronic logbook or machine design documentation. By doing so, a multi-expert
retrieval augmented generation (RAG) system is implemented, which assists
operators in knowledge retrieval tasks, interacts with the machine directly if
needed, or writes high level control system scripts. This consolidation of
expert knowledge and machine interaction can simplify and speed up machine
operation tasks for both new and experienced human operators.
|
[
-0.4373983144760132,
-1.0589582920074463,
0.923662006855011,
-0.04734420403838158,
-0.007382131181657314,
0.06870082020759583,
0.28732016682624817,
-0.3668815791606903,
0.24899478256702423,
0.10606343299150467,
-0.40036994218826294,
-0.008704752661287785,
-0.5712391138076782,
0.015364227816462517,
-0.7099995017051697,
0.9703183770179749,
0.001012289896607399,
0.04484459385275841,
-0.3539069890975952,
0.14272473752498627,
-0.41410374641418457,
-0.4970887303352356,
-1.3153245449066162,
-0.47631269693374634,
0.19071273505687714,
0.3583497107028961,
0.8792432546615601,
0.4267616868019104,
0.5237844586372375,
0.46068063378334045,
0.08598634600639343,
0.3977026343345642,
-0.087871253490448,
0.013486338779330254,
-0.5608036518096924,
-0.49646854400634766,
-0.8327391147613525,
-0.49262747168540955,
0.4048364460468292,
0.2813055217266083,
-0.14939044415950775,
0.02817227877676487,
-0.46721455454826355,
0.44804632663726807,
-0.7375242710113525,
0.07209409028291702,
-0.2478472888469696,
0.11518526077270508,
-0.03334438055753708,
-0.44294798374176025,
-0.41201135516166687,
-0.138795867562294,
-0.30290597677230835,
-0.9789078235626221,
0.07235563546419144,
0.2697822153568268,
1.0089994668960571,
0.6192219853401184,
-0.2583867013454437,
-0.35457345843315125,
-1.029379963874817,
0.6168580651283264,
-0.3531830906867981,
-0.018712934106588364,
0.2193513661623001,
0.6183153986930847,
-0.307847261428833,
-0.8221336603164673,
-0.6764287352561951,
-0.0498676560819149,
-0.09427545964717865,
-0.011398116126656532,
-0.43017953634262085,
0.205479696393013,
0.35620447993278503,
0.30769452452659607,
-0.24281248450279236,
0.04778377711772919,
-0.2932628095149994,
0.10030660033226013,
0.46860235929489136,
0.350990891456604,
0.7052075862884521,
0.34436383843421936,
-0.392835408449173,
-0.054961610585451126,
-0.531130850315094,
-0.19771605730056763,
0.3911265730857849,
-0.07419285178184509,
0.010691080242395401,
0.2519473135471344,
-0.5786904096603394,
0.6742507815361023,
0.16178083419799805,
0.14956647157669067,
0.2886790335178375,
0.08184035122394562,
-0.6397391557693481,
-0.36761775612831116,
0.9453142881393433,
-0.029484892264008522,
0.42181849479675293,
-0.20105673372745514,
-0.1254049837589264,
0.02059600129723549,
0.5717045664787292,
-0.5928362011909485,
-0.07007768005132675,
0.14515045285224915,
-0.11879220604896545,
-0.28633174300193787,
0.10022282600402832,
-0.9061418771743774,
-0.5971865653991699,
-0.36783286929130554,
0.6844180226325989,
-0.18462778627872467,
-0.07390765100717545,
-0.005439162719994783,
-0.2866227626800537,
0.3396538197994232,
0.49526989459991455,
-1.0624350309371948,
0.49343031644821167,
0.6562662124633789,
0.530168890953064,
0.24459391832351685,
-0.22965538501739502,
-1.2646560668945312,
0.25045111775398254,
-0.3621598780155182,
0.6098220944404602,
-0.7894386053085327,
-0.5051878690719604,
-0.11879555881023407,
-0.2035486102104187,
-0.09156626462936401,
-0.340385377407074,
0.5480644106864929,
-0.9150860905647278,
0.21587234735488892,
0.026424165815114975,
-0.19941549003124237,
-0.5177062749862671,
0.012912120670080185,
-0.3635622262954712,
0.902320384979248,
0.009337708353996277,
-0.30828791856765747,
0.2628072202205658,
-0.8088577389717102,
-0.5366811752319336,
0.15531927347183228,
-0.661663293838501,
-0.21715480089187622,
0.1416446715593338,
0.5447750687599182,
0.451583594083786,
-0.42715442180633545,
0.3240983784198761,
-0.03547336161136627,
-0.28522905707359314,
0.10391494631767273,
-0.15297965705394745,
0.39279088377952576,
0.4036729633808136,
-0.3234882354736328,
0.5682656764984131,
-0.5638764500617981,
-0.13056577742099762,
0.026088016107678413,
-0.06143154576420784,
-0.0350101999938488,
0.14630718529224396,
-0.4859658479690552,
0.3622509241104126,
0.4534173607826233,
-0.22563959658145905,
0.49010658264160156,
-0.2075391411781311,
0.07773833721876144,
0.775061845779419,
0.13939231634140015,
0.5343310236930847,
0.03882507234811783,
0.9230813384056091,
-0.3318687975406647,
0.2428436577320099,
-0.0295436829328537,
-0.5972267389297485,
-0.9574860334396362,
-0.16272632777690887,
0.014773831702768803,
0.7621698379516602,
-1.0035984516143799,
0.1993391066789627,
0.06298968195915222,
-0.0596398301422596,
-0.7182808518409729,
0.30711376667022705,
0.5424243211746216,
0.7451012134552002,
0.41123902797698975,
0.09239201247692108,
-0.3721875548362732,
-1.0781469345092773,
0.2163694053888321,
-0.09815190732479095,
-0.3142869174480438,
0.3953997492790222,
0.4065665900707245,
-0.3126780390739441,
0.6578344702720642,
-0.49532410502433777,
-0.145303413271904,
-0.16831570863723755,
0.5164980888366699,
0.3194693922996521,
0.3113681972026825,
0.3292236328125,
-0.8201755285263062,
-0.32911616563796997,
0.5384898781776428,
-1.0661144256591797,
0.0362260527908802,
-0.007413369137793779,
-0.3183463513851166,
0.3329753279685974,
0.7788570523262024,
-0.6327285170555115,
0.5569193959236145,
0.403743177652359,
-0.10546492040157318,
0.4173545241355896,
-0.709669291973114,
0.4828517735004425,
-0.9401615262031555,
0.6341783404350281,
-0.2856541574001312,
0.020631516352295876,
-0.8603824973106384,
0.44757363200187683,
-0.10963377356529236,
-0.30589058995246887,
-0.48074838519096375,
0.7307239770889282,
-0.37122437357902527,
-0.5266258120536804,
-0.6233286261558533,
0.21066957712173462,
-0.15742821991443634,
0.5690248608589172,
-0.1569376289844513,
1.321297526359558,
0.7943780422210693,
-1.0847986936569214,
0.26357218623161316,
0.3251342475414276,
0.013412252068519592,
0.590623676776886,
-0.8266706466674805,
0.5603940486907959,
-0.10444585978984833,
-0.1890399307012558,
-0.6073581576347351,
-0.5864672660827637,
0.31764382123947144,
-0.6787652969360352,
0.25653383135795593,
0.01264489907771349,
-0.5816049575805664,
-0.41564279794692993,
0.3223225176334381,
0.2780539393424988,
0.6566408276557922,
-0.5088096261024475,
1.102368712425232,
0.46562063694000244,
-0.3258807063102722,
-0.7606092691421509,
-0.3239496648311615,
0.13242629170417786,
0.005726361647248268,
-0.6584733724594116,
-0.10187918692827225,
-0.11493393778800964,
-0.5022922158241272,
0.008566278032958508,
0.34446069598197937,
-0.10884762555360794,
0.38722869753837585,
0.12053879350423813,
0.42505496740341187,
0.18962439894676208,
0.32579177618026733,
0.1866251677274704,
-0.35674795508384705,
0.037172891199588776,
0.057089973241090775,
0.7065744996070862,
-0.2484540492296219,
-0.5160515904426575,
-0.7388269305229187,
0.43809273838996887,
0.6052881479263306,
-0.4868234097957611,
0.6777415871620178,
0.5660416483879089,
-0.28531092405319214,
0.06318633258342743,
-0.1863253116607666,
-0.08372995257377625,
-0.5350921154022217,
0.23075394332408905,
-0.5610305070877075,
-0.45964887738227844,
0.5264821648597717,
-0.10894924402236938,
0.11820011585950851,
0.5346577763557434,
0.7561177611351013,
0.19847695529460907,
1.730268120765686,
0.7240481972694397,
-0.5484093427658081,
0.27850598096847534,
-0.19064325094223022,
0.27058520913124084,
-0.8737469911575317,
-0.2042519599199295,
-0.7357115149497986,
-0.44302546977996826,
0.12259252369403839,
-0.45812132954597473,
0.5898594856262207,
-0.07942382991313934,
-0.41136741638183594,
-0.1718423068523407,
-0.5597966909408569,
0.2855910360813141,
0.6108262538909912,
-0.13239961862564087,
0.09471183270215988,
-0.12365834414958954,
0.10609357804059982,
0.7382777333259583,
-0.6716160178184509,
-0.3844076097011566,
0.7499719858169556,
0.12093640118837357,
0.7826741337776184,
-0.04466500133275986,
0.5189433097839355,
0.4417656362056732,
0.06518634408712387,
-0.7698149085044861,
0.6608070135116577,
-0.010847807861864567,
-0.5960060954093933,
-0.26422449946403503,
-0.14183683693408966,
-1.1598842144012451,
-0.0640711635351181,
-0.19078151881694794,
-0.92936772108078,
0.060817375779151917,
0.37546855211257935,
-0.7070932388305664,
0.4136446416378021,
-0.6607398986816406,
0.3710932731628418,
-0.11505920439958572,
-0.2241809070110321,
-0.5639187693595886,
-0.6257823705673218,
0.26234498620033264,
0.1667235940694809,
0.4327811896800995,
0.26756152510643005,
-0.1336761862039566,
0.5692020654678345,
-0.39398759603500366,
0.37203845381736755,
-0.22141720354557037,
0.12311400473117828,
0.3053475022315979,
0.10805531591176987,
0.7419185638427734,
-0.2610413730144501,
-0.2663978040218353,
-0.3705173134803772,
-0.8231354355812073,
-0.1520930528640747,
-0.7579317688941956,
0.7867538928985596,
-0.947613537311554,
-0.781679630279541,
-0.3268829584121704,
-0.7347469925880432,
-0.17357507348060608,
0.3004303574562073,
-0.16157624125480652,
0.4602796137332916,
0.16106656193733215,
0.038956478238105774,
0.8254895210266113,
-0.08782916516065598,
0.30305323004722595,
0.28371748328208923,
-0.28668856620788574,
-0.3292681872844696,
0.8290003538131714,
-0.32374677062034607,
0.2192201316356659,
0.5049259662628174,
0.02946152538061142,
0.07377453148365021,
-0.4169015884399414,
-0.8635990023612976,
0.022941436618566513,
-0.6183812022209167,
-0.15995094180107117,
-0.7345508933067322,
-0.03534482792019844,
-0.34657034277915955,
-0.5711005330085754,
0.10128573328256607,
-0.2667311429977417,
-0.4602792263031006,
-0.15496230125427246,
0.4465835988521576,
0.9282411932945251,
0.16778632998466492,
0.6024208664894104,
-0.7049917578697205,
0.5332697629928589,
0.5737073421478271,
-0.028469685465097427,
0.041105177253484726,
-0.30600255727767944,
-0.37451931834220886,
-0.2668975591659546,
-0.181915283203125,
-0.7514618635177612,
0.40510448813438416,
0.05075792595744133,
0.8560246229171753,
0.569234311580658,
-0.37998658418655396,
0.35318440198898315,
-0.3931240141391754,
0.7134563326835632,
0.019420579075813293,
-0.8936823606491089,
0.501478910446167,
-0.4576321840286255,
0.2010921686887741,
0.3612239956855774,
0.361458420753479,
-0.2911737561225891,
-0.2955332398414612,
-0.8522588014602661,
-0.7969537973403931,
0.8108874559402466,
-0.2485463172197342,
-0.09321702271699905,
0.00039825018029659986,
0.2063496708869934,
-0.18455003201961517,
0.455093652009964,
0.09346005320549011,
-0.11825325340032578,
0.32075735926628113,
-0.20639680325984955,
0.04215781390666962,
0.18967847526073456,
-0.47310882806777954,
0.23849357664585114,
1.0511622428894043,
-0.4135001599788666,
0.3392516076564789,
0.038442060351371765,
-0.0016982986126095057,
-0.3599906861782074,
0.37991562485694885,
0.6930950880050659,
0.7590019702911377,
0.1555577665567398,
-0.2971857786178589,
0.3408147692680359,
-0.13548369705677032,
0.1295594424009323,
0.13246750831604004,
-0.3663441836833954,
-0.4897940754890442,
-0.11380106955766678,
0.9375952482223511,
0.05893734097480774,
-0.5763381719589233,
0.04968743771314621,
-0.0423312708735466,
-0.13280600309371948,
-0.1727827936410904,
0.5350313782691956,
0.02608633227646351,
0.18576742708683014,
0.47606533765792847,
0.22324220836162567,
0.39324113726615906,
-0.5871193408966064,
0.17465278506278992,
0.4486994743347168,
-0.07463125884532928,
-0.12113158404827118,
0.8980550169944763,
0.3195694088935852,
-0.6166600584983826,
0.6754759550094604,
-0.33266952633857727,
-0.3785687983036041,
0.7979047298431396,
0.1263570487499237,
0.9798762798309326,
-0.23542627692222595,
0.2412201166152954,
0.2569828927516937,
0.08279672265052795,
0.14086754620075226,
0.4154600501060486,
0.21019884943962097,
-0.4531567394733429,
-0.6524270176887512,
-0.5674431324005127,
-0.7360508441925049,
0.02299216389656067,
-0.6347341537475586,
0.39151230454444885,
-0.857109546661377,
0.016386596485972404,
-0.09300968796014786,
-0.08234752714633942,
-0.7460587024688721,
0.4331999123096466,
0.14973077178001404,
0.8262576460838318,
-0.8693075180053711,
0.6806655526161194,
1.0178042650222778,
-0.5906223058700562,
-0.9624778032302856,
-0.4602777361869812,
-0.06517510861158371,
-0.9237101674079895,
0.6384509801864624,
-0.2668667435646057,
-0.26058220863342285,
-0.015229327604174614,
-0.3311314284801483,
-0.7683495283126831,
1.09160315990448,
0.12465263158082962,
-0.35633090138435364,
-0.0017619350692257285,
-0.3336831331253052,
0.695754885673523,
-0.308136910200119,
0.48576056957244873,
0.5984424948692322,
0.6211522817611694,
0.10960278660058975,
-0.9413305521011353,
-0.05998600274324417,
-0.44841787219047546,
-0.36133742332458496,
0.5739904046058655,
-0.736644446849823,
1.116637110710144,
-0.1570451855659485,
-0.02184101939201355,
0.1886705905199051,
0.937376081943512,
0.3118145763874054,
0.30790993571281433,
0.45285657048225403,
0.6664237976074219,
0.972410261631012,
0.1623857468366623,
1.419336199760437,
-0.38693612813949585,
-0.10903056710958481,
0.8541241884231567,
-0.2635621130466461,
0.5939854383468628,
0.36455291509628296,
-0.04689120501279831,
0.7036275863647461,
-0.07491498440504074,
0.15755042433738708,
0.05673126503825188,
-0.14796975255012512,
-0.47832250595092773,
-0.22444400191307068,
-0.07036861032247543,
-0.2213800996541977,
0.1763283759355545,
0.5307838320732117,
-0.25243696570396423,
-0.2599325478076935,
0.094535231590271,
0.32013657689094543,
0.025898916646838188,
-0.6790562272071838,
0.9180005788803101,
-0.1399938315153122,
-0.8582236766815186,
0.1689484417438507,
-0.015411497093737125,
0.22447645664215088,
-0.7883008718490601,
-0.21001973748207092,
0.08564537763595581,
0.34344029426574707,
-0.25012385845184326,
-0.7132041454315186,
0.14554284512996674,
0.05874639004468918,
-0.25756368041038513,
0.09284108132123947,
0.8998373746871948,
-0.11074580997228622,
-0.3990546762943268,
0.05975254252552986,
0.324972540140152,
0.43099454045295715,
0.23798757791519165,
-0.608031153678894,
0.08008488267660141,
-0.12315341085195541,
-0.1534567028284073,
0.506987988948822,
0.2470291256904602,
-0.39019620418548584,
1.0007364749908447,
0.530602216720581,
0.07444210350513458,
-0.131776824593544,
0.2238558530807495,
0.9415950179100037,
-0.2344827800989151,
-0.4894573986530304,
-0.4968993365764618,
0.5423396825790405,
-0.15324266254901886,
-0.35782456398010254,
0.6750434637069702,
0.19328062236309052,
0.36942723393440247,
-0.12077634036540985,
0.9680251479148865,
-0.33332231640815735,
0.3636457920074463,
-0.5066705346107483,
0.522799015045166,
-0.6619200706481934,
-0.20480483770370483,
-0.17051245272159576,
-0.2866067588329315,
-0.02020079456269741,
0.36322981119155884,
-0.42586860060691833,
0.1555231362581253,
0.34140682220458984,
0.7917155027389526,
0.025756794959306717,
-0.22130705416202545,
0.3776599168777466,
0.07112763822078705,
0.7387557625770569,
0.5089863538742065,
0.40241992473602295,
-0.27865350246429443,
0.5004319548606873,
0.10971174389123917,
-0.3623659908771515,
-0.42836108803749084,
-0.6835096478462219,
-0.6437456011772156,
-0.17148256301879883,
-0.09251590818166733,
0.22743873298168182,
0.2707473337650299,
0.7148264050483704,
0.5159921646118164,
-0.7522317171096802,
-0.17702725529670715,
-0.1881597340106964,
-0.0368940569460392,
-0.3417005240917206,
-0.22108599543571472,
0.3303150534629822,
-0.710956335067749,
-1.2256219387054443,
0.8316142559051514,
0.15737326443195343,
-0.3750854730606079,
-0.4169418215751648,
-0.3886514902114868,
-0.47230756282806396,
0.2581786513328552,
0.2603514492511749,
0.7372657656669617,
-0.1966489851474762,
-0.346902459859848,
0.041810210794210434,
0.05470806732773781,
-0.20310547947883606,
0.5244799852371216,
-0.8715386390686035,
0.713630199432373,
0.9288462400436401,
0.9502123594284058,
0.1912589967250824,
0.21707430481910706,
0.9567195773124695,
-0.6361657381057739,
0.18104064464569092,
0.11337539553642273,
0.455612450838089,
0.2022165060043335,
-0.6377086639404297,
0.5930905342102051,
-0.02899966388940811,
-1.0154584646224976,
-0.4523242115974426,
0.08305485546588898,
-0.7505379319190979,
-0.04026704654097557,
0.8859402537345886,
-0.10590381175279617,
-0.32799285650253296,
0.1270558089017868,
-0.5372552275657654,
0.3373740613460541,
-0.5145403742790222,
0.6900849938392639,
0.4571520686149597,
-0.431814581155777,
0.08350532501935959,
-0.7943976521492004,
0.36099839210510254,
0.49209117889404297,
-1.2505784034729004,
-0.365914911031723,
0.47782737016677856,
0.0007237032987177372,
0.6269568204879761,
0.7292373180389404,
-0.026319684460759163,
0.7534261345863342,
-0.02353435754776001,
0.5195721387863159,
-0.4757087826728821,
-0.9001999497413635,
-0.47446662187576294,
0.19024015963077545,
-0.018058834597468376,
-0.31487399339675903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01345v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01345v2
|
The Power of Question Translation Training in Multilingual Reasoning: Broadened Scope and Deepened Insights
| 2024-05-02T14:49:50 | 2024-06-29T15:45:24 |
Wenhao Zhu, Shujian Huang, Fei Yuan, Cheng Chen, Jiajun Chen, Alexandra Birch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Bridging the significant gap between large language model's English and
non-English performance presents a great challenge. While some previous studies
attempt to mitigate this gap with translated training data, the recently
proposed question alignment approach leverages the model's English expertise to
improve multilingual performance with minimum usage of expensive, error-prone
translation. In this paper, we explore how broadly this method can be applied
by examining its effects in reasoning with executable code and reasoning with
common sense. We also explore how to apply this approach efficiently to
extremely large language models using proxy-tuning. Experiment results on
multilingual reasoning benchmarks mGSM, mSVAMP and xCSQA demonstrate that the
question alignment approach can be used to boost multilingual performance
across diverse reasoning scenarios, model families, and sizes. For instance,
when applied to the LLaMA2 models, our method brings an average accuracy
improvements of 12.2% on mGSM even with the 70B model. To understand the
mechanism of its success, we analyze representation space, chain-of-thought and
translation data scales, which reveals how question translation training
strengthens language alignment within LLMs and shapes their working patterns.
|
[
-0.42434215545654297,
-0.5759695172309875,
0.7456386089324951,
-0.11704149842262268,
-0.3656424283981323,
-0.08491761982440948,
-0.11018579453229904,
-0.40500277280807495,
-0.059792712330818176,
0.34359827637672424,
-0.510360836982727,
-0.2636159360408783,
-0.48439958691596985,
0.11638903617858887,
-0.341606467962265,
0.744831919670105,
-0.22948302328586578,
0.4312419295310974,
-0.37835025787353516,
-0.41969260573387146,
-0.48998889327049255,
-0.37487882375717163,
-0.5669601559638977,
-0.2978284955024719,
0.5274388790130615,
0.4764476418495178,
0.8407787084579468,
0.6846911311149597,
0.50565105676651,
0.25401827692985535,
-0.09060052037239075,
0.5728399157524109,
-0.303748220205307,
0.00404651602730155,
-0.4017605781555176,
-0.8923056721687317,
-0.18713845312595367,
-0.025492515414953232,
0.64903324842453,
0.7115527391433716,
-0.10953401029109955,
0.07927292585372925,
-0.14017346501350403,
0.41624075174331665,
-0.3831714391708374,
-0.0966389924287796,
-0.8836899399757385,
-0.1332101821899414,
-0.07550214976072311,
-0.14610092341899872,
-0.3070508539676666,
-0.26227617263793945,
-0.050930000841617584,
-0.7013808488845825,
-0.010060600005090237,
0.3677147328853607,
0.862743079662323,
0.4683557152748108,
-0.7304456830024719,
-0.1755952537059784,
-0.46843835711479187,
0.8644863367080688,
-0.7256905436515808,
0.5489571690559387,
0.1414460390806198,
0.4968183636665344,
0.004745111800730228,
-0.3256980776786804,
-0.6752185821533203,
0.4281468987464905,
-0.08846135437488556,
0.04659237340092659,
0.08533240109682083,
-0.25699493288993835,
0.26041945815086365,
0.1696738600730896,
-0.871381938457489,
-0.06902892887592316,
-0.3133656084537506,
-0.07425758987665176,
0.6616909503936768,
-0.026441380381584167,
0.2881282866001129,
0.053517915308475494,
-0.28849539160728455,
-0.09717433154582977,
-0.6019156575202942,
0.1408819854259491,
0.461859792470932,
0.5115867853164673,
0.11855470389127731,
0.5023825764656067,
-0.14512944221496582,
0.7386125326156616,
-0.17720095813274384,
-0.1686365306377411,
0.02908657118678093,
-0.35193610191345215,
0.195962056517601,
0.16890741884708405,
0.35775524377822876,
0.49029067158699036,
0.4274141490459442,
-0.2428916096687317,
0.17788323760032654,
-0.07368148118257523,
0.2379954606294632,
-0.5125424265861511,
0.3475310504436493,
0.41602569818496704,
0.10127696394920349,
0.34160101413726807,
0.05709541216492653,
-0.3993493616580963,
-0.16656829416751862,
-0.5769742131233215,
0.3374022841453552,
-0.2559334337711334,
-0.4166501760482788,
0.6088746786117554,
-0.22062048316001892,
0.6299216151237488,
0.427535742521286,
-0.7314153909683228,
-0.08299846947193146,
0.9050212502479553,
0.45744800567626953,
-0.1473330408334732,
-0.576944887638092,
-0.48416343331336975,
0.3516061007976532,
-0.43180376291275024,
0.8525910377502441,
-0.5643804669380188,
0.09439998120069504,
0.02902207151055336,
0.015821469947695732,
-0.4487694203853607,
-0.46207502484321594,
0.2558234632015228,
-0.6446027755737305,
0.3197203576564789,
-0.5519567728042603,
-0.5458945035934448,
-0.17922483384609222,
0.4957667291164398,
-0.42796018719673157,
0.9769300222396851,
-0.2653082013130188,
-0.6557074785232544,
0.33245784044265747,
-0.18259699642658234,
-0.3018060624599457,
-0.23079432547092438,
-0.028804047033190727,
-0.1142139658331871,
-0.08815458416938782,
0.5758628249168396,
0.3396478593349457,
-0.38965335488319397,
0.38581955432891846,
-0.28523144125938416,
-0.420245885848999,
0.40283021330833435,
-0.29836687445640564,
0.4867928922176361,
0.20135651528835297,
-0.15560437738895416,
-0.14316757023334503,
-0.44621556997299194,
0.3149714469909668,
0.09772883355617523,
-0.21810121834278107,
-0.46045589447021484,
-0.28731921315193176,
-0.5480863451957703,
0.39274364709854126,
0.16030123829841614,
-0.3785470128059387,
0.3199694752693176,
-0.5446394085884094,
0.2916129231452942,
0.3596729338169098,
-0.08167558163404465,
0.590190052986145,
-0.11873114109039307,
0.5941303372383118,
0.10067860782146454,
0.09650371968746185,
-0.05368112400174141,
-0.6285563111305237,
-0.7403724789619446,
0.17960870265960693,
0.3587166666984558,
0.7105807662010193,
-0.9026914238929749,
-0.10459831357002258,
-0.23260225355625153,
-0.39642462134361267,
-1.0235342979431152,
0.2495938539505005,
0.48182743787765503,
0.5598320960998535,
0.7035261988639832,
0.12096874415874481,
-0.2607209086418152,
-0.9344409704208374,
-0.5354856252670288,
-0.36119580268859863,
0.14475202560424805,
0.17418071627616882,
0.49286746978759766,
0.07050254195928574,
0.6097254157066345,
-0.5404008030891418,
0.3513108193874359,
-0.3483378291130066,
-0.015258047729730606,
0.13559746742248535,
0.47067511081695557,
0.25706201791763306,
-0.9520010948181152,
-0.3095170557498932,
0.2009107619524002,
-0.6019683480262756,
-0.21908853948116302,
-0.22210584580898285,
-0.7138369083404541,
0.046628352254629135,
0.5740379095077515,
-0.6167575716972351,
0.09764181077480316,
0.5441920161247253,
-0.17951549589633942,
0.406753271818161,
0.0272042378783226,
0.4618569016456604,
-1.2639604806900024,
-0.04494790360331535,
-0.1711103618144989,
-0.11128544062376022,
-0.6628671884536743,
0.3988793194293976,
0.3704175055027008,
-0.07342951744794846,
-0.5829625725746155,
0.6495702266693115,
-0.2880856394767761,
-0.02752559818327427,
0.0993238016963005,
0.447879433631897,
0.41409409046173096,
0.4804086685180664,
0.02990669570863247,
0.9203112125396729,
0.19122512638568878,
-0.5051702857017517,
0.17010821402072906,
0.4933834969997406,
-0.2564900815486908,
0.8077062964439392,
-0.4719398319721222,
0.3945065140724182,
-0.14447875320911407,
-0.1685546636581421,
-1.168562650680542,
-0.14300985634326935,
0.03408792242407799,
-0.455470472574234,
0.39609217643737793,
-0.14641079306602478,
-0.31015321612358093,
-0.22489383816719055,
0.017402229830622673,
0.6362136006355286,
0.11304564028978348,
-0.7019389271736145,
0.4140663743019104,
0.10847264528274536,
-0.20592635869979858,
-0.7588109970092773,
-0.862410306930542,
-0.09909678250551224,
-0.372637003660202,
-0.9294284582138062,
0.19867704808712006,
-0.08769577741622925,
-0.4044581651687622,
-0.3106577694416046,
-0.2986609637737274,
-0.09905462712049484,
0.14113740622997284,
-0.3213452696800232,
0.09028246998786926,
-0.2722409665584564,
0.38355880975723267,
0.5149192810058594,
-0.07636021822690964,
-0.04648125171661377,
-0.15783806145191193,
0.3956414759159088,
-0.20988072454929352,
-0.7495081424713135,
0.019188351929187775,
0.5649415254592896,
0.46474963426589966,
-0.5031231641769409,
0.7981892228126526,
0.10641553997993469,
-0.03274373337626457,
-0.21328288316726685,
-0.6910480856895447,
0.08952309191226959,
-0.371963769197464,
0.36180323362350464,
-0.4721330404281616,
-0.908507227897644,
0.4545833170413971,
-0.2123548686504364,
-0.07235752791166306,
0.22164121270179749,
0.31143856048583984,
0.02946431376039982,
1.500827431678772,
0.22937190532684326,
0.08965480327606201,
-0.001142832450568676,
-0.050917528569698334,
0.3444523811340332,
-0.8610126972198486,
-0.3429955244064331,
-0.5524694919586182,
-0.2915693521499634,
-0.17353132367134094,
-0.795935332775116,
0.26845425367355347,
0.3574349582195282,
-0.3327474594116211,
0.3686859905719757,
-0.23874196410179138,
0.5856838226318359,
0.3249559700489044,
-0.17059548199176788,
0.38380351662635803,
-0.1250041425228119,
-0.38561609387397766,
-0.033199816942214966,
-0.8228976130485535,
-0.5768725872039795,
0.808530867099762,
0.1881159394979477,
0.4670755863189697,
0.24294747412204742,
0.5020580291748047,
-0.4768071174621582,
0.06263235956430435,
-0.6840848922729492,
0.45352014899253845,
0.155705988407135,
-0.7175874710083008,
-0.3774714767932892,
-0.3458203375339508,
-0.7977485060691833,
0.6245311498641968,
0.00508331460878253,
-0.4505472183227539,
0.049184639006853104,
-0.06579791754484177,
-0.12488056719303131,
0.35506534576416016,
-0.9035248756408691,
0.888318657875061,
-0.5936475992202759,
-0.4140084981918335,
0.014995360746979713,
-0.7558605670928955,
0.16032423079013824,
-0.05425261706113815,
0.40012890100479126,
-0.03451823815703392,
-0.06621301174163818,
0.3949822783470154,
-0.148110494017601,
0.4247816801071167,
-0.06106952577829361,
-0.3400789201259613,
0.19209052622318268,
-0.03361520916223526,
0.36860179901123047,
0.20575428009033203,
-0.2101098746061325,
0.3359667658805847,
0.19170518219470978,
-0.561919093132019,
-0.9044345021247864,
0.34558215737342834,
-0.6829879283905029,
-0.9966019988059998,
-0.1870722472667694,
-1.117192268371582,
-0.715998649597168,
0.13933677971363068,
0.03776641935110092,
-0.09513566642999649,
0.0611751414835453,
-0.0031526759266853333,
0.7720344662666321,
-0.22051386535167694,
0.08483655750751495,
0.740543007850647,
-0.3418162167072296,
-0.31745636463165283,
0.665141224861145,
0.18885286152362823,
0.585449755191803,
0.5534706115722656,
-0.05507362261414528,
-0.46474558115005493,
-0.28746065497398376,
-0.795525074005127,
0.5080520510673523,
-0.772404670715332,
-0.28630244731903076,
-0.5202774405479431,
0.033437903970479965,
-0.5197135210037231,
-0.11282215267419815,
-0.297586590051651,
-0.45914697647094727,
0.06794767826795578,
-0.206722229719162,
0.04417672008275986,
0.2362375110387802,
0.3457871675491333,
0.09530261904001236,
-0.556512713432312,
0.14216451346874237,
0.47431498765945435,
0.17569327354431152,
-0.12183650583028793,
-0.5275278687477112,
-0.2996944785118103,
0.30123206973075867,
-0.17964689433574677,
-0.9749390482902527,
0.1360338032245636,
0.03509541600942612,
0.603202223777771,
0.25487402081489563,
-0.13668310642242432,
1.0607681274414062,
-0.44621413946151733,
0.6905207633972168,
-0.020954318344593048,
-0.9609788656234741,
0.5383259057998657,
-0.22573281824588776,
0.5846119523048401,
0.6289386749267578,
0.608703076839447,
-0.7062466144561768,
-0.5922988057136536,
-0.2998650372028351,
-0.6848758459091187,
0.5823048949241638,
-0.050388019531965256,
0.13966475427150726,
-0.14396265149116516,
0.5503140091896057,
0.14600884914398193,
0.3034660220146179,
-0.40432727336883545,
0.000016985490219667554,
-0.00601737666875124,
-0.16312339901924133,
-0.10855478793382645,
0.08109668642282486,
-0.22181682288646698,
-0.5056152939796448,
0.7739056944847107,
-0.5745991468429565,
-0.015950007364153862,
0.12180029600858688,
-0.26358211040496826,
-0.022338172420859337,
0.531548261642456,
0.44323843717575073,
0.7499434947967529,
0.24713855981826782,
0.11022093147039413,
0.5437130331993103,
0.058292973786592484,
0.22778631746768951,
0.11181582510471344,
-0.022194424644112587,
-0.25224199891090393,
0.2680666148662567,
0.7151322960853577,
0.15393970906734467,
-0.6861112713813782,
0.49281564354896545,
-0.136174738407135,
-0.3152744472026825,
0.1716163009405136,
0.15929175913333893,
0.4691419005393982,
0.5668601989746094,
0.15541359782218933,
-0.20314928889274597,
-0.16127613186836243,
-0.41491642594337463,
-0.12073562294244766,
0.5217529535293579,
-0.179202601313591,
0.0008777657640166581,
0.6981121301651001,
-0.17337262630462646,
0.07339562475681305,
0.5543226599693298,
-0.1994759440422058,
-0.660313069820404,
0.6995961666107178,
0.6948560476303101,
0.3685607314109802,
-0.32388022541999817,
0.1618841141462326,
0.34961074590682983,
0.4312315583229065,
-0.2782423794269562,
0.5780383944511414,
0.049612533301115036,
-1.0106110572814941,
-0.8013509511947632,
-0.495699018239975,
-0.47890758514404297,
-0.20448529720306396,
-0.8571664094924927,
0.23871667683124542,
-0.010269918479025364,
0.17776057124137878,
-0.21458208560943604,
-0.2146725058555603,
-0.4214390516281128,
0.21110717952251434,
0.30112403631210327,
1.029842734336853,
-1.0548675060272217,
0.7459440231323242,
0.9909065961837769,
-0.33691567182540894,
-1.3683873414993286,
-0.007665771525353193,
-0.16182181239128113,
-0.944695234298706,
0.2873724400997162,
0.31011414527893066,
-0.06526400148868561,
-0.027500079944729805,
-0.6264336705207825,
-1.0691335201263428,
1.0631139278411865,
0.8075238466262817,
-0.4951407313346863,
0.05659867450594902,
0.5643092393875122,
0.5864773988723755,
-0.3179691731929779,
0.09869465976953506,
0.7762030363082886,
0.460470974445343,
0.3305181860923767,
-0.7618305087089539,
-0.03430916741490364,
-0.44592124223709106,
-0.03460249677300453,
0.5408881902694702,
-0.7030620574951172,
0.6128332614898682,
-0.15931954979896545,
-0.09278035908937454,
0.021882984787225723,
0.5742319226264954,
0.2821774482727051,
0.38632121682167053,
0.3250577747821808,
0.8378968834877014,
1.1161056756973267,
-0.2658478021621704,
1.0205601453781128,
-0.37512409687042236,
0.1467149406671524,
0.8963212370872498,
-0.5775890350341797,
0.7444455027580261,
0.881215512752533,
-0.13530319929122925,
0.49687376618385315,
0.40190157294273376,
0.15355940163135529,
0.3391515016555786,
0.030960386618971825,
0.08835463970899582,
-0.5812720656394958,
-0.18587052822113037,
-0.5172386169433594,
0.42207783460617065,
0.14439888298511505,
0.036057859659194946,
-0.19014936685562134,
-0.0011633364483714104,
0.06689637154340744,
0.151403546333313,
-0.35445937514305115,
0.7183988690376282,
0.08723331242799759,
-1.1632673740386963,
0.6610697507858276,
-0.0346355140209198,
0.32656246423721313,
-0.6812781095504761,
-0.15119260549545288,
-0.37420082092285156,
-0.009996642358601093,
-0.17597343027591705,
-0.7073510885238647,
0.46025049686431885,
0.034914080053567886,
-0.12208434194326401,
-0.2830785810947418,
0.4545356035232544,
-0.7798190116882324,
-0.34707581996917725,
0.2871679365634918,
0.8194848895072937,
0.2668072283267975,
-0.1038299947977066,
-0.716312825679779,
-0.2099708467721939,
0.024526996538043022,
-0.025469200685620308,
0.4471770226955414,
0.607223391532898,
-0.19054242968559265,
0.5275480151176453,
0.6121249794960022,
0.02533990703523159,
0.03650924563407898,
0.20102058351039886,
0.7523936629295349,
-0.47971197962760925,
-0.3593842685222626,
-0.6785421967506409,
0.6172682046890259,
-0.011507031507790089,
-0.48425036668777466,
0.807367205619812,
0.5664653182029724,
1.1635172367095947,
0.2579944431781769,
0.5283035039901733,
0.3139651417732239,
0.49334976077079773,
-0.69913250207901,
0.3225336968898773,
-0.9502704739570618,
0.3997870981693268,
-0.2185230702161789,
-0.7413120269775391,
-0.30073946714401245,
0.3975774347782135,
-0.7585073709487915,
-0.13512423634529114,
0.9620177745819092,
0.9914456605911255,
-0.012795157730579376,
0.1225505843758583,
0.3689362406730652,
-0.1431526094675064,
0.12102024257183075,
0.722495436668396,
0.8873341083526611,
-0.4907594919204712,
0.8275729417800903,
-0.044754549860954285,
0.12477364391088486,
0.23727957904338837,
-0.6634253859519958,
-0.7902528643608093,
-0.2758094370365143,
-0.32718104124069214,
-0.22015202045440674,
-0.05039016157388687,
0.6571810245513916,
0.38566312193870544,
-0.8419023156166077,
-0.14343050122261047,
0.035709135234355927,
0.13984274864196777,
-0.4145687520503998,
-0.15076063573360443,
0.20736055076122284,
-0.5158871412277222,
-0.7633026838302612,
0.303388774394989,
0.25439196825027466,
-0.15527524054050446,
-0.04655842483043671,
-0.28169071674346924,
-0.6281739473342896,
0.23269370198249817,
0.3345431387424469,
0.09435682743787766,
-0.6599864959716797,
-0.1720448136329651,
0.2828400433063507,
-0.14079506695270538,
0.01305125281214714,
0.6277293562889099,
-0.32946810126304626,
0.5588454008102417,
0.4898245632648468,
0.9468718767166138,
0.4232313632965088,
0.3271167576313019,
0.641608715057373,
-0.8408445715904236,
0.15584075450897217,
-0.012613951228559017,
0.44908687472343445,
0.42124250531196594,
-0.28638148307800293,
0.5352611541748047,
-0.05256201699376106,
-0.5228701233863831,
-0.7468770146369934,
0.32262933254241943,
-0.5363422632217407,
-0.5256213545799255,
1.2765063047409058,
-0.11376477777957916,
-0.12880955636501312,
-0.07992998510599136,
-0.37550514936447144,
0.3876596987247467,
-0.06526567041873932,
0.652228832244873,
1.0121965408325195,
-0.12111973017454147,
-0.16123977303504944,
-0.6345672607421875,
0.11457247287034988,
0.9498783349990845,
-0.7578863501548767,
-0.13828150928020477,
0.3271280527114868,
0.049702227115631104,
0.21239109337329865,
0.07992056012153625,
-0.18253007531166077,
0.3438878059387207,
-0.27580174803733826,
-0.12135153263807297,
0.09206291288137436,
-0.314157098531723,
-0.4734475314617157,
0.1026618704199791,
0.13226783275604248,
0.28239765763282776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02565v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02565v1
|
Sequence-to-sequence models in peer-to-peer learning: A practical application
| 2024-05-02T14:44:06 | 2024-05-02T14:44:06 |
Robert Šajina, Ivo Ipšić
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.MA, eess.AS
|
This paper explores the applicability of sequence-to-sequence (Seq2Seq)
models based on LSTM units for Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) task within
peer-to-peer learning environments. Leveraging two distinct peer-to-peer
learning methods, the study simulates the learning process of agents and
evaluates their performance in ASR task using two different ASR datasets. In a
centralized training setting, utilizing a scaled-down variant of the Deep
Speech 2 model, a single model achieved a Word Error Rate (WER) of 84\% when
trained on the UserLibri dataset, and 38\% when trained on the LJ Speech
dataset. Conversely, in a peer-to-peer learning scenario involving 55 agents,
the WER ranged from 87\% to 92\% for the UserLibri dataset, and from 52\% to
56\% for the LJ Speech dataset. The findings demonstrate the feasibility of
employing Seq2Seq models in decentralized settings, albeit with slightly higher
Word Error Rates (WER) compared to centralized training methods.
|
[
0.21485783159732819,
-0.42805442214012146,
0.31933850049972534,
0.17147354781627655,
-0.14880886673927307,
0.1533825546503067,
-0.08805228769779205,
-0.3803652822971344,
-0.18666525185108185,
0.26311278343200684,
-0.17496536672115326,
-0.18727242946624756,
-0.4983268082141876,
0.1908283829689026,
-0.749587893486023,
0.5016077160835266,
0.24340061843395233,
0.5841413140296936,
-0.16896627843379974,
-0.08230988681316376,
-0.5379987359046936,
-0.6763426065444946,
-1.0219335556030273,
-0.4009094536304474,
0.26284992694854736,
0.6666894555091858,
0.5243765115737915,
0.5635481476783752,
0.43043166399002075,
0.3048403859138489,
-0.09677291661500931,
-0.02982953004539013,
-0.5637667775154114,
0.278220534324646,
-0.4260547161102295,
-0.377613365650177,
-0.18779554963111877,
-0.09102670103311539,
0.9660441279411316,
0.6946136951446533,
-0.333042174577713,
0.26154059171676636,
0.2694990336894989,
0.9388031363487244,
-0.18052898347377777,
0.11932704597711563,
-0.4231126606464386,
0.08990801125764847,
-0.0698830783367157,
0.12468447536230087,
-0.5834512710571289,
-0.32754915952682495,
0.48161581158638,
-0.24541997909545898,
0.23133906722068787,
0.05189255625009537,
0.4537709951400757,
0.237855464220047,
-0.35529208183288574,
-0.4046010971069336,
-0.7225726842880249,
0.43542781472206116,
-0.779628336429596,
0.5814584493637085,
0.3168387711048126,
0.45477208495140076,
0.15302270650863647,
-1.061240315437317,
-0.4904992878437042,
0.10191775858402252,
0.006472812034189701,
0.04283386096358299,
0.019354160875082016,
-0.0724581778049469,
0.38925087451934814,
0.39058491587638855,
-0.6332060098648071,
0.23810258507728577,
-0.6393845677375793,
0.05523987486958504,
0.8586465716362,
0.17229945957660675,
0.08081817626953125,
-0.26422837376594543,
-0.3981749713420868,
-0.23208604753017426,
-0.44036346673965454,
0.6663095951080322,
0.1329801380634308,
0.7598096132278442,
-0.027846431359648705,
0.6207041144371033,
-0.27055221796035767,
0.5745311379432678,
0.3757880926132202,
0.040894486010074615,
0.3969181776046753,
-0.3620532155036926,
-0.15679225325584412,
0.26802730560302734,
0.6973463296890259,
0.00876077450811863,
-0.034854989498853683,
-0.2906334698200226,
-0.5642110705375671,
-0.07587514817714691,
0.3826628625392914,
-0.6063130497932434,
-0.15162622928619385,
0.21688446402549744,
-0.5250217318534851,
-0.2309076339006424,
-0.012707014568150043,
-0.4009115993976593,
-0.4467296302318573,
-0.4911206066608429,
1.1018459796905518,
-0.21516293287277222,
-0.05852125212550163,
0.027619581669569016,
-0.1946934461593628,
0.3537523150444031,
0.34653526544570923,
-0.32055941224098206,
0.8626413941383362,
0.661534309387207,
1.1259937286376953,
-0.3151688575744629,
-0.45099806785583496,
-0.7450731992721558,
-0.01529531367123127,
-0.14942240715026855,
0.5280764698982239,
-0.1917504221200943,
-0.5737223625183105,
-0.13520780205726624,
0.0699109211564064,
-0.19287826120853424,
-0.42892786860466003,
0.3011316955089569,
-0.679125964641571,
0.17274999618530273,
-0.3997538685798645,
-0.9199720621109009,
-0.2649499773979187,
-0.19510197639465332,
-0.5724204182624817,
0.8012397885322571,
-0.15140150487422943,
-0.46245965361595154,
-0.22578966617584229,
-0.5953408479690552,
-0.6662070155143738,
0.030676519498229027,
-0.1402387171983719,
-0.6116729378700256,
0.041184570640325546,
-0.2235301285982132,
0.7102582454681396,
-0.20230251550674438,
0.3062485456466675,
-0.017268488183617592,
-0.5150719881057739,
0.2189825475215912,
-0.18719324469566345,
0.7273876667022705,
0.33199432492256165,
-0.40093594789505005,
0.07871711254119873,
-0.44337964057922363,
0.020498039200901985,
0.3402229845523834,
-0.34501171112060547,
-0.2843490540981293,
0.3485747277736664,
0.04941454529762268,
0.29624608159065247,
0.06716421991586685,
-0.36513644456863403,
-0.14256024360656738,
-0.4295937120914459,
0.7435828447341919,
0.509183943271637,
-0.01883580908179283,
0.6282190680503845,
-0.6148897409439087,
0.13153336942195892,
-0.011840681545436382,
-0.11947182565927505,
-0.16645501554012299,
-0.5384812355041504,
-0.58424311876297,
-0.09752113372087479,
0.3601398468017578,
0.685797929763794,
-0.6909106969833374,
0.278746098279953,
-0.3350242078304291,
-0.5620394945144653,
-0.4333404302597046,
-0.13751810789108276,
0.6414502859115601,
0.5418453812599182,
0.36503148078918457,
-0.7190117239952087,
-0.535627007484436,
-0.3746867775917053,
-0.23155897855758667,
-0.12236320972442627,
-0.0020130882039666176,
0.6516148447990417,
0.28875651955604553,
-0.08162032812833786,
0.9920963048934937,
-0.004345491994172335,
-0.28400489687919617,
-0.2914237380027771,
0.006466839928179979,
0.22766131162643433,
0.45050013065338135,
-0.07302559167146683,
-0.6539819240570068,
-0.4696042537689209,
-0.5286179184913635,
-0.47692909836769104,
-0.06944122910499573,
0.06819996237754822,
0.32056063413619995,
0.09870734810829163,
0.40370842814445496,
-0.07997888326644897,
0.42329978942871094,
0.6662148833274841,
-0.4460769593715668,
0.29929009079933167,
-0.2795015275478363,
0.06344637274742126,
-1.6058244705200195,
-0.07678830623626709,
0.07452154904603958,
-0.5845223069190979,
-1.0313612222671509,
0.07240892946720123,
0.030389800667762756,
-0.4098930060863495,
-0.5273321270942688,
0.31325143575668335,
-0.45337623357772827,
-0.7992777228355408,
-0.20117254555225372,
0.10096440464258194,
-0.08735095709562302,
0.24811196327209473,
0.4751974940299988,
1.0909161567687988,
0.34672078490257263,
-0.6425190567970276,
0.2740991413593292,
0.6040813326835632,
-0.2338450402021408,
0.12116961926221848,
-1.196975827217102,
0.43477436900138855,
-0.020714420825242996,
0.3350697159767151,
-1.0432817935943604,
-0.11566692590713501,
-0.026211228221654892,
-0.5641319751739502,
0.39205002784729004,
0.0700669065117836,
-0.4132011830806732,
-0.11689997464418411,
-0.11539677530527115,
0.6104787588119507,
0.6045581698417664,
-0.5812650322914124,
0.34510645270347595,
0.5564758777618408,
-0.22244442999362946,
-0.42380794882774353,
-0.4592767655849457,
-0.044509049504995346,
-0.2189953774213791,
-0.5323719382286072,
0.2746827006340027,
0.2348339706659317,
-0.052787166088819504,
-0.3133459687232971,
0.1289338320493698,
0.04538693279027939,
0.014411471784114838,
0.7414368987083435,
-0.07758194208145142,
-0.08088279515504837,
0.20029346644878387,
-0.2346239984035492,
-0.01638181507587433,
-0.0058481739833951,
-0.2956732213497162,
0.5830786824226379,
-0.3448545038700104,
-0.4225497245788574,
-0.618245542049408,
0.3091612756252289,
-0.016171259805560112,
-0.21775971353054047,
0.5313751101493835,
0.25579124689102173,
-0.5229789018630981,
-0.16055014729499817,
-0.4987407326698303,
-0.4211878776550293,
-0.4809868335723877,
0.3785382807254791,
-0.25519195199012756,
-1.0016230344772339,
0.3680296838283539,
-0.14777350425720215,
-0.2940269112586975,
0.155869722366333,
0.4671376347541809,
-0.33105406165122986,
0.5002375245094299,
0.23570089042186737,
-0.2809579372406006,
0.5202847123146057,
-0.3600999712944031,
0.05404900759458542,
-0.8735768795013428,
-0.2549836039543152,
-0.7106497287750244,
-0.4227009117603302,
-0.3414323031902313,
-0.9553362131118774,
0.4525046646595001,
0.17807583510875702,
-0.64316326379776,
0.595211923122406,
-0.22038912773132324,
0.3744230270385742,
0.868914008140564,
0.5119225978851318,
0.3550540804862976,
0.31213346123695374,
0.025315381586551666,
0.14384722709655762,
-0.8000016808509827,
-0.39133116602897644,
1.0305641889572144,
0.6303231120109558,
0.5102011561393738,
0.30908632278442383,
0.8089243769645691,
0.7405493259429932,
-0.33902785181999207,
-0.9268261194229126,
0.4554218649864197,
-0.3235926032066345,
-0.37572869658470154,
-0.8938181400299072,
-0.3228780925273895,
-0.815392017364502,
-0.18315456807613373,
-0.020242935046553612,
-0.5827029943466187,
0.44108548760414124,
0.035678185522556305,
-0.49269726872444153,
0.017938274890184402,
-0.4418639540672302,
0.6209818124771118,
-0.03188120573759079,
-0.3317873775959015,
-0.373624324798584,
-1.1023929119110107,
-0.15957005321979523,
-0.10233557224273682,
0.09848122298717499,
0.16383744776248932,
-0.018748972564935684,
0.7896245718002319,
-0.533981442451477,
0.9734684228897095,
-0.24818243086338043,
0.2329430729150772,
0.529391884803772,
-0.09122806787490845,
0.8693419098854065,
-0.0950087159872055,
-0.26194772124290466,
0.45382753014564514,
-0.11338541656732559,
-0.301205039024353,
-0.1989946961402893,
0.29127034544944763,
-1.376875400543213,
-0.3389021158218384,
-0.426954060792923,
-0.2347956746816635,
-0.30612796545028687,
-0.14290550351142883,
0.2678302228450775,
0.7921668887138367,
0.07426800578832626,
0.27890342473983765,
0.6490153670310974,
-0.2177615910768509,
0.5092318654060364,
0.8487412333488464,
0.09840834140777588,
-0.6325078010559082,
0.9315997958183289,
0.1857704073190689,
0.5245115160942078,
0.3198360800743103,
0.16738466918468475,
-0.6898673176765442,
-0.5834707617759705,
-0.25547173619270325,
0.10999032109975815,
-0.5904833078384399,
-0.26528000831604004,
-0.6756977438926697,
-0.6614806652069092,
-0.42709147930145264,
0.09274543821811676,
-0.46033111214637756,
-0.555180013179779,
-0.4824158549308777,
0.1121678575873375,
0.28777459263801575,
0.6991087794303894,
-0.2951766550540924,
0.3054778277873993,
-0.9036266207695007,
0.1593029648065567,
0.6123086214065552,
0.17355556786060333,
0.09968217462301254,
-1.214459776878357,
-0.08052543550729752,
0.23972028493881226,
-0.11266449838876724,
-1.1155024766921997,
0.43942680954933167,
0.7600589990615845,
0.2744220197200775,
0.1016421839594841,
0.19819563627243042,
0.7558009028434753,
-0.848638653755188,
0.8223235011100769,
0.08017422258853912,
-1.2170459032058716,
0.7375933527946472,
-0.2948186993598938,
-0.023531002923846245,
0.5535399913787842,
0.46809837222099304,
-0.8120434284210205,
-0.0010722291190177202,
-0.33818069100379944,
-0.8166512846946716,
0.8644700050354004,
0.24765872955322266,
0.05864335969090462,
0.29397788643836975,
0.625744104385376,
0.06799597293138504,
0.1565447747707367,
-0.4539177715778351,
-0.370552659034729,
-0.33838239312171936,
-0.15078815817832947,
-0.6293919086456299,
-0.3482825458049774,
0.20894956588745117,
-0.15611714124679565,
0.7681317329406738,
-0.04998363181948662,
0.3933406472206116,
0.4220758378505707,
-0.19663609564304352,
-0.32737094163894653,
0.3005175292491913,
0.4476734697818756,
0.31196510791778564,
-0.02969149500131607,
-0.034084975719451904,
0.14803577959537506,
-0.33083486557006836,
0.3566673994064331,
0.32735633850097656,
-0.22408202290534973,
-0.00887314323335886,
0.016031689941883087,
0.8820107579231262,
0.1425100713968277,
-0.7251086235046387,
0.9106159806251526,
-0.044909700751304626,
-0.03626358509063721,
-0.45339590311050415,
-0.1175699457526207,
0.11821326613426208,
0.9433879852294922,
0.3146190643310547,
0.00807261560112238,
0.7033188939094543,
-0.3824268579483032,
0.43340060114860535,
0.30969685316085815,
-0.5501484274864197,
-0.36381128430366516,
0.691005289554596,
0.3070727288722992,
-0.7055159211158752,
0.8023071885108948,
-0.17239691317081451,
-0.4800669848918915,
0.646117627620697,
0.7870332598686218,
0.8193396925926208,
-0.4229471683502197,
0.28436800837516785,
0.3956388235092163,
-0.08253948390483856,
-0.6989946365356445,
0.45453521609306335,
-0.17074237763881683,
-0.8404912352561951,
-0.29839491844177246,
-0.5986689925193787,
-0.6614386439323425,
-0.03458020091056824,
-0.9764732718467712,
0.28235524892807007,
-0.23923657834529877,
-0.11761059612035751,
-0.23071467876434326,
0.0983685627579689,
-0.5246282815933228,
0.12529483437538147,
0.4353751242160797,
0.8421332836151123,
-0.8516204953193665,
1.018891453742981,
0.9920600652694702,
-0.09158133715391159,
-1.4020764827728271,
-0.17141981422901154,
0.07066261768341064,
-0.8723694086074829,
0.48956605792045593,
0.1936304122209549,
0.10888253152370453,
0.4461866319179535,
-0.2802729308605194,
-1.0394325256347656,
1.5475091934204102,
-0.18749035894870758,
-0.9662753939628601,
-0.19318901002407074,
0.41016584634780884,
0.5616840124130249,
-0.3050800859928131,
0.07159443944692612,
0.26332780718803406,
-0.32322603464126587,
0.3022877275943756,
-1.2682271003723145,
-0.007947429083287716,
-0.1640034317970276,
0.40934979915618896,
-0.11492078006267548,
-0.6830511093139648,
0.907762885093689,
-0.5272330045700073,
-0.09633778780698776,
0.13500431180000305,
0.7070382833480835,
0.5740211009979248,
0.7508916258811951,
0.5557711720466614,
0.39201369881629944,
0.631541907787323,
0.09031449258327484,
0.5324564576148987,
-0.2479519098997116,
0.46844547986984253,
1.3945040702819824,
-0.4193659722805023,
1.3372915983200073,
0.1804424524307251,
-0.3308558762073517,
0.21536538004875183,
0.7257927656173706,
0.11356570571660995,
0.6893044114112854,
0.15650950372219086,
-0.25748002529144287,
-0.1370306760072708,
-0.1768164485692978,
-0.5002023577690125,
0.407034695148468,
0.36021167039871216,
-0.48718106746673584,
0.16078056395053864,
0.06607019156217575,
-0.4847596287727356,
0.13335420191287994,
-0.6522547602653503,
1.1377108097076416,
0.39521610736846924,
-0.17706219851970673,
0.18930381536483765,
-0.021097907796502113,
0.44776296615600586,
-0.18602417409420013,
0.19605888426303864,
-0.06420481950044632,
0.2023174911737442,
-0.14413321018218994,
-0.5497361421585083,
0.17011703550815582,
0.0029439274221658707,
-0.2368866205215454,
-0.35491877794265747,
0.9028443694114685,
-0.4495236277580261,
-0.2800772488117218,
-0.013496458530426025,
0.7049673199653625,
0.21908964216709137,
-0.1318603903055191,
-0.6374887228012085,
-0.204565167427063,
-0.2889498472213745,
-0.0125054270029068,
0.3219265043735504,
0.16739027202129364,
0.0989992618560791,
0.5355783104896545,
0.41453465819358826,
0.0066558485850691795,
-0.008003645576536655,
0.022565187886357307,
0.6616697907447815,
-0.5229777693748474,
-0.6563960909843445,
-0.6048207879066467,
0.41748085618019104,
0.11909033358097076,
0.20549115538597107,
0.7129272222518921,
0.5088492035865784,
0.9591151475906372,
-0.020169535651803017,
0.7126050591468811,
0.08272096514701843,
1.02197265625,
-0.28101980686187744,
0.5971125364303589,
-0.415304571390152,
0.3776278793811798,
-0.22696569561958313,
-0.6512013673782349,
0.20511096715927124,
0.73392254114151,
-0.23293164372444153,
-0.015402408316731453,
0.3704543709754944,
0.5766016244888306,
0.3398549556732178,
0.37889429926872253,
0.3783007860183716,
0.10089278221130371,
0.009647456929087639,
0.5600940585136414,
1.0360052585601807,
-0.8326576948165894,
0.11022337526082993,
-0.43580362200737,
0.05874702334403992,
-0.17113468050956726,
-0.5584052801132202,
-0.8311603665351868,
-0.7923633456230164,
-0.3268330991268158,
-0.677969217300415,
0.5525150895118713,
1.4947476387023926,
0.5163460373878479,
-0.9964527487754822,
-0.6080757975578308,
-0.12204819917678833,
-0.2189084142446518,
-0.23861423134803772,
-0.11950778216123581,
0.28763943910598755,
-0.3626759946346283,
-0.45897912979125977,
0.48457908630371094,
-0.1453406810760498,
0.15588529407978058,
0.02380872704088688,
-0.5058138370513916,
0.008168126456439495,
-0.08290087431669235,
0.49215763807296753,
0.3165735900402069,
-0.5480457544326782,
-0.21588757634162903,
0.0418882891535759,
-0.23106279969215393,
-0.05279424414038658,
0.6616018414497375,
-0.9124901294708252,
0.3456151783466339,
0.5434126853942871,
0.7482243776321411,
0.33680349588394165,
0.4064815938472748,
0.5776907801628113,
-0.8031465411186218,
-0.03326945751905441,
0.25547006726264954,
0.10905902087688446,
0.3608200252056122,
-0.22572030127048492,
0.604222297668457,
0.3109084665775299,
-0.8771979212760925,
-0.7809947729110718,
0.02153880149126053,
-0.9300076961517334,
0.033579450100660324,
1.4092706441879272,
-0.37100982666015625,
0.19927452504634857,
-0.037429291754961014,
0.03382498770952225,
0.5143696069717407,
-0.613497257232666,
0.7341315746307373,
0.07481861859560013,
0.05110122635960579,
-0.18068431317806244,
-0.31154850125312805,
0.5593465566635132,
0.054802220314741135,
-0.5650723576545715,
-0.3811803162097931,
0.45286837220191956,
0.40061163902282715,
-0.03461328148841858,
0.6552866101264954,
0.22947818040847778,
0.36812564730644226,
-0.16719192266464233,
-0.2156343162059784,
-0.13592001795768738,
-0.28057408332824707,
-0.9670562744140625,
0.09837602823972702,
0.2472476214170456,
-0.3200806677341461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06665v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06665v1
|
Enhancing Language Models for Financial Relation Extraction with Named Entities and Part-of-Speech
| 2024-05-02T14:33:05 | 2024-05-02T14:33:05 |
Menglin Li, Kwan Hui Lim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
The Financial Relation Extraction (FinRE) task involves identifying the
entities and their relation, given a piece of financial statement/text. To
solve this FinRE problem, we propose a simple but effective strategy that
improves the performance of pre-trained language models by augmenting them with
Named Entity Recognition (NER) and Part-Of-Speech (POS), as well as different
approaches to combine these information. Experiments on a financial relations
dataset show promising results and highlights the benefits of incorporating NER
and POS in existing models. Our dataset and codes are available at
https://github.com/kwanhui/FinRelExtract.
|
[
-0.20906962454319,
-0.6016702055931091,
0.30871930718421936,
0.07669413089752197,
-0.40199393033981323,
0.18873514235019684,
-0.15042129158973694,
-0.9895411133766174,
0.35040855407714844,
0.9567386507987976,
-0.21741820871829987,
-0.18195153772830963,
-0.6304340362548828,
0.08981966227293015,
-0.4824282228946686,
1.3700287342071533,
0.18995316326618195,
0.2844037413597107,
-0.09653280675411224,
0.07568035274744034,
-0.2650059759616852,
-0.5477145314216614,
-1.1962640285491943,
-0.3025059998035431,
0.5619743466377258,
0.3700897693634033,
0.5454226136207581,
0.5784520506858826,
0.856234073638916,
0.3285374343395233,
0.0158586036413908,
-0.12125249952077866,
-0.2183958739042282,
0.15258531272411346,
-0.30075401067733765,
-0.29293549060821533,
-0.7960437536239624,
-0.15640683472156525,
0.41542136669158936,
0.6652523279190063,
-0.24604785442352295,
0.14351466298103333,
-0.1861753612756729,
0.5855433940887451,
-0.6139377951622009,
0.8969652652740479,
-0.2736230790615082,
-0.3718525171279907,
-0.43532851338386536,
-0.137948676943779,
-0.268161803483963,
-0.11461545526981354,
0.7879927158355713,
-0.7300165891647339,
0.08148206770420074,
0.11274250596761703,
1.1441220045089722,
0.010797828435897827,
-0.36507174372673035,
-0.255956768989563,
-0.9824692010879517,
0.5686049461364746,
-0.6645765900611877,
0.8661841750144958,
0.4546414911746979,
0.36027050018310547,
0.061457253992557526,
-0.942115068435669,
-0.32192477583885193,
-0.15238472819328308,
-0.3521248996257782,
0.09185630083084106,
-0.37956371903419495,
0.18495938181877136,
0.26453888416290283,
0.4580273926258087,
0.12342768162488937,
-0.20601129531860352,
-0.4011336863040924,
-0.2649093568325043,
0.6330666542053223,
-0.3677360713481903,
0.3329406976699829,
-0.05804145708680153,
-0.5419744849205017,
-0.35060593485832214,
-0.7292341589927673,
0.05032872408628464,
0.4724994897842407,
0.7022079229354858,
0.16535553336143494,
0.5557662844657898,
-0.03128167614340782,
0.7348784804344177,
0.09467335790395737,
-0.5599761605262756,
0.17538712918758392,
-0.27626579999923706,
-0.3785149157047272,
0.4854966104030609,
0.3675146698951721,
0.00033031124621629715,
0.36314353346824646,
-0.28996917605400085,
-0.7671193480491638,
-0.32576510310173035,
-0.13435782492160797,
-0.5535333156585693,
-0.5169610381126404,
-0.018917642533779144,
-0.4438241720199585,
-0.1525583267211914,
0.3435988128185272,
-0.7770254611968994,
-0.1526871770620346,
-0.5351230502128601,
0.38892513513565063,
-0.3884682059288025,
-0.5551601052284241,
0.13321812450885773,
-0.5994090437889099,
0.36929959058761597,
0.14337468147277832,
-1.0389539003372192,
0.8941856026649475,
0.9814252257347107,
0.31216517090797424,
0.415754109621048,
-0.028930852189660072,
-1.1764048337936401,
0.3362473249435425,
0.08983885496854782,
1.011210322380066,
-0.6787696480751038,
-0.24306200444698334,
-0.328102171421051,
-0.19317594170570374,
-0.10846039652824402,
-0.6756976246833801,
0.23027819395065308,
-0.6173104643821716,
0.21305370330810547,
-0.20398980379104614,
-0.7585412263870239,
-0.017179442569613457,
-0.2484893798828125,
-1.0898139476776123,
0.9074196219444275,
0.4336220622062683,
-0.9435654878616333,
0.2757469713687897,
-0.8628730773925781,
-0.6384801268577576,
0.210720032453537,
-0.15729409456253052,
-0.3309623599052429,
0.11893196403980255,
0.37679523229599,
0.3950827419757843,
-0.6378974914550781,
0.31082242727279663,
-0.09457800537347794,
-0.021195892244577408,
0.405411958694458,
-0.14247556030750275,
0.38632336258888245,
0.042591243982315063,
-0.07420672476291656,
0.0540580190718174,
-0.8836758732795715,
-0.5666149854660034,
0.2600807547569275,
-0.01157284714281559,
-0.9846165776252747,
0.17287959158420563,
0.24627195298671722,
-0.13315702974796295,
0.4680059552192688,
-0.5501129031181335,
-0.06277818977832794,
-0.8555559515953064,
0.5339006185531616,
0.40499597787857056,
0.183476060628891,
0.6732828617095947,
-0.18770600855350494,
0.5025315880775452,
-0.04158398509025574,
0.08072599768638611,
-0.3431994616985321,
-0.186991348862648,
-0.8110959529876709,
-0.38522008061408997,
0.8159971237182617,
0.6778208613395691,
-0.735597550868988,
0.03732328489422798,
-0.1620641052722931,
-0.4112829566001892,
-0.19804614782333374,
-0.09894672781229019,
0.40397128462791443,
0.8490520119667053,
0.31418511271476746,
-0.20697666704654694,
-0.8522728681564331,
-1.0630567073822021,
-0.33500537276268005,
-0.44578611850738525,
-0.11004079878330231,
0.2609526515007019,
0.22813835740089417,
0.3535151481628418,
1.183887004852295,
-0.7050915360450745,
-0.24026848375797272,
-0.2658242881298065,
0.18606847524642944,
0.16515399515628815,
0.5069558620452881,
0.6826574802398682,
-1.3299444913864136,
-0.22958502173423767,
0.0870470255613327,
-0.22620731592178345,
0.08836837112903595,
-0.14741382002830505,
-0.030181681737303734,
-0.21070310473442078,
0.6029534935951233,
-0.3619364798069,
0.4382469058036804,
0.254794716835022,
-0.3736538290977478,
0.44712427258491516,
-0.13083416223526,
-0.11864257603883743,
-1.067957878112793,
0.026202598586678505,
0.40830498933792114,
-0.5393024682998657,
-0.7943416237831116,
-0.18427537381649017,
-0.004567318595945835,
-0.14812296628952026,
-0.28635671734809875,
0.8327767848968506,
-0.6845874190330505,
-0.35957950353622437,
-0.28098607063293457,
0.31098586320877075,
-0.015899762511253357,
0.23102732002735138,
0.3713516592979431,
0.7060390114784241,
0.6530566811561584,
-0.544165849685669,
0.45023903250694275,
0.27225005626678467,
-0.38300755620002747,
0.5978944301605225,
-0.802020788192749,
-0.07223214954137802,
-0.02406950667500496,
-0.03185240924358368,
-0.8894031047821045,
-0.18708768486976624,
0.4142095148563385,
-0.14661693572998047,
0.6867966651916504,
-0.2629337012767792,
-0.3607756495475769,
-0.02152068540453911,
0.26414135098457336,
0.24510079622268677,
0.09355392307043076,
-0.5015578269958496,
1.1172473430633545,
0.8074852824211121,
-0.9151121973991394,
-0.6057302951812744,
-0.41893279552459717,
0.11139299720525742,
-0.3595241606235504,
-0.3153168857097626,
0.7250758409500122,
0.42092132568359375,
-0.473570853471756,
0.24607089161872864,
-0.3177747428417206,
-0.4225150942802429,
0.20792752504348755,
0.020699426531791687,
0.8489924073219299,
-0.41526758670806885,
0.3641698956489563,
-0.13391698896884918,
-0.45043516159057617,
0.02016843855381012,
-0.3062201738357544,
0.3211738169193268,
-0.016355104744434357,
0.019306158646941185,
-0.3255065381526947,
0.3844846785068512,
0.33820822834968567,
-0.8612545728683472,
0.6358920335769653,
0.13597850501537323,
-0.6789417266845703,
0.17208795249462128,
-0.6267814636230469,
-0.1810922622680664,
-0.4789847135543823,
0.2655840516090393,
-0.5756754279136658,
-0.8717251420021057,
0.7051092386245728,
-0.30379581451416016,
-0.08104421198368073,
0.681749701499939,
-0.08615674823522568,
0.1724984496831894,
0.4395312964916229,
1.091867208480835,
-0.26922762393951416,
1.0106892585754395,
0.04889531433582306,
0.590004026889801,
-0.7648727297782898,
-0.38931894302368164,
-0.6323221325874329,
0.05849781632423401,
-0.27206653356552124,
-0.08789195865392685,
-0.17853598296642303,
0.43454068899154663,
0.024555495008826256,
0.9516394734382629,
-0.1095234677195549,
0.5098908543586731,
0.2959336042404175,
-0.15432646870613098,
0.2984287738800049,
-0.05789738893508911,
0.0301827359944582,
-0.033756598830223083,
-0.3527786135673523,
-0.42990782856941223,
0.705934464931488,
0.524951696395874,
0.6335238814353943,
-0.05929241329431534,
0.9680659174919128,
-0.019878676161170006,
0.5829125642776489,
-0.6542572379112244,
0.3120361864566803,
-0.40169528126716614,
-0.3927951753139496,
-0.3281388580799103,
-0.7344338893890381,
-0.8042033910751343,
-0.19816352427005768,
-0.26709750294685364,
-0.9050434827804565,
0.6362736821174622,
-0.0693468376994133,
-0.6771528720855713,
0.05314388871192932,
-0.4671572744846344,
0.7545523643493652,
-0.34945163130760193,
0.2087026983499527,
0.19295036792755127,
-0.423214316368103,
0.2219393402338028,
-0.32113581895828247,
0.29798513650894165,
-0.0003084736526943743,
-0.06800860911607742,
1.0142621994018555,
-0.6254763007164001,
0.5562771558761597,
-0.19098486006259918,
-0.45242324471473694,
0.3067338466644287,
-0.3607686161994934,
0.6803296208381653,
0.13232222199440002,
-0.026840517297387123,
0.161692813038826,
0.010620835237205029,
-0.12163175642490387,
-0.7647602558135986,
0.467032253742218,
-0.21732327342033386,
-0.2814875841140747,
-0.3402465879917145,
-0.3847285509109497,
-0.307956337928772,
0.2591710388660431,
-0.12619827687740326,
0.569888710975647,
-0.26334989070892334,
0.013551034964621067,
0.39831727743148804,
0.004130272660404444,
0.4901633560657501,
0.5571302771568298,
-0.4624820351600647,
-0.9386563897132874,
0.9874184131622314,
0.09254588186740875,
0.10556001961231232,
0.6720466017723083,
-0.0003458761493675411,
-0.5732662677764893,
-0.25673994421958923,
-0.06281775236129761,
0.4123101532459259,
-0.47538891434669495,
-0.41825738549232483,
-0.5066497921943665,
-0.35834652185440063,
-0.6847261786460876,
0.2627761960029602,
-0.5934531688690186,
-0.6454510688781738,
-0.4035637676715851,
-0.3121455907821655,
0.5176665782928467,
0.7193041443824768,
-0.158538356423378,
0.3481123745441437,
-1.1526955366134644,
0.22013549506664276,
0.29617583751678467,
0.2927739918231964,
0.044605106115341187,
-0.22876271605491638,
-0.32584697008132935,
-0.1255517601966858,
0.4933284521102905,
-1.0532408952713013,
0.43270164728164673,
0.2569551169872284,
0.5682125687599182,
0.7285776138305664,
0.009591253474354744,
1.1267149448394775,
-0.3208479881286621,
0.19672563672065735,
0.4379311800003052,
-1.064845323562622,
0.5883818864822388,
-0.14713908731937408,
-0.3097735643386841,
0.6603450775146484,
0.258884072303772,
-0.49652916193008423,
-0.34480229020118713,
-0.8816536068916321,
-0.986646294593811,
0.6277627348899841,
0.37189334630966187,
-0.09472633898258209,
-0.12241646647453308,
0.5654358863830566,
-0.008462478406727314,
0.32553350925445557,
-0.44127532839775085,
-0.3339492678642273,
0.09668799489736557,
-0.060375817120075226,
-0.03243125230073929,
-0.42533373832702637,
0.09267356991767883,
-0.13112688064575195,
0.7780954837799072,
0.3011321425437927,
0.0497216172516346,
0.2806786894798279,
0.13568295538425446,
-0.04766019061207771,
0.08351405709981918,
0.20331332087516785,
0.6309375762939453,
-0.3133677840232849,
-0.11384263634681702,
-0.09831494092941284,
-0.33825138211250305,
-0.1644572913646698,
0.849577784538269,
0.12815310060977936,
0.13816772401332855,
0.46547412872314453,
0.7061299085617065,
0.9194502234458923,
-0.7051409482955933,
0.49179351329803467,
-0.32374003529548645,
-0.07638655602931976,
-0.5167616009712219,
-0.024343902245163918,
0.20917698740959167,
0.6710749268531799,
0.7635951638221741,
0.08183251321315765,
0.15538692474365234,
-0.6162035465240479,
0.5423564910888672,
0.04935041069984436,
-0.49272146821022034,
-0.1949438750743866,
0.6421145796775818,
0.19419044256210327,
-0.5244276523590088,
0.8479502201080322,
-0.11288924515247345,
-0.5893154740333557,
0.601368248462677,
0.6939567923545837,
0.8539875745773315,
-0.2543557286262512,
0.2293834090232849,
0.3110256493091583,
0.038377683609724045,
-0.3535322844982147,
0.37756192684173584,
-0.24761928617954254,
-0.7186557650566101,
-0.7921575903892517,
-0.7924647927284241,
-0.3662301301956177,
0.12260948866605759,
-1.149960994720459,
0.45201584696769714,
-0.4000658690929413,
-0.3304752707481384,
0.6152871251106262,
-0.0561959370970726,
-0.46410876512527466,
0.15529175102710724,
0.3463403880596161,
0.8905582427978516,
-0.5993567705154419,
0.9262999296188354,
0.6718288660049438,
-0.6077089905738831,
-1.0731489658355713,
-0.2350529134273529,
-0.4110166132450104,
-0.1964424103498459,
0.9806687831878662,
-0.10801727324724197,
-0.0011844481341540813,
0.07725445181131363,
-0.15289077162742615,
-1.1198712587356567,
0.9092074632644653,
0.6284302473068237,
-1.111839771270752,
-0.2831290066242218,
-0.07833102345466614,
0.22550420463085175,
-0.6286736726760864,
-0.014069758355617523,
0.5955443978309631,
0.5045398473739624,
0.13456106185913086,
-1.075359582901001,
-0.2243598997592926,
-0.26350894570350647,
-0.2053164839744568,
0.7584185600280762,
-0.34532108902931213,
1.078386902809143,
-0.0968543216586113,
-0.5142329335212708,
0.042723022401332855,
1.0609023571014404,
0.032769616693258286,
0.3758006989955902,
0.8529626727104187,
0.403105765581131,
1.149078369140625,
-0.185507133603096,
0.9764642715454102,
-0.3804786801338196,
0.37347671389579773,
1.67870032787323,
-0.5317339301109314,
1.1053149700164795,
0.45645034313201904,
-0.07975982874631882,
0.5282483696937561,
0.6540355086326599,
-0.11346767842769623,
0.46000224351882935,
0.09398612380027771,
-0.3635315001010895,
-0.4019961953163147,
-0.2125862091779709,
-0.20701099932193756,
0.6701591610908508,
0.27951791882514954,
-0.5345282554626465,
-0.23744791746139526,
0.1074652299284935,
0.019807016476988792,
-0.10517329722642899,
-0.14831142127513885,
0.9397501349449158,
0.3152095079421997,
-0.34680917859077454,
-0.40185290575027466,
0.05440016835927963,
0.337723970413208,
-0.7837101221084595,
-0.3828332722187042,
0.054179295897483826,
0.017196906730532646,
0.11403072625398636,
-0.19896744191646576,
0.26909470558166504,
0.16748517751693726,
-0.2647293210029602,
-0.22179530560970306,
1.1860897541046143,
-0.6468826532363892,
-0.5811799764633179,
0.5155078172683716,
0.49419963359832764,
0.0706673264503479,
-0.2776019871234894,
-0.4555482864379883,
-0.5605483055114746,
-0.17059841752052307,
-0.08279304206371307,
0.4026024639606476,
0.4370185136795044,
0.13412229716777802,
0.38197505474090576,
1.0852400064468384,
0.2676258087158203,
-0.5078877210617065,
0.2545357346534729,
0.8589288592338562,
-0.8974684476852417,
-0.4584886133670807,
-0.9189481735229492,
0.15687638521194458,
-0.36419522762298584,
-0.2848126292228699,
0.6121148467063904,
0.8500087857246399,
0.9471937417984009,
0.1271997094154358,
0.47312429547309875,
0.2011319249868393,
0.44587206840515137,
-0.45887696743011475,
0.6005908846855164,
-0.27492809295654297,
0.42901867628097534,
-0.6332353353500366,
-1.0757406949996948,
-0.32312631607055664,
0.7474640607833862,
-0.47733765840530396,
-0.29355546832084656,
0.5085097551345825,
0.453237384557724,
-0.08479218184947968,
0.28897878527641296,
0.08303048461675644,
0.010116509161889553,
0.07586557418107986,
0.18618322908878326,
0.8373844027519226,
-0.5658622980117798,
0.5058932900428772,
-0.5119211077690125,
0.019032670184969902,
0.0526549257338047,
-1.0607285499572754,
-0.4659276306629181,
-0.5033746957778931,
-0.713352620601654,
-0.1241677924990654,
-0.08071710914373398,
0.6649997234344482,
0.5084452629089355,
-0.6834356188774109,
-0.387451171875,
0.11486608535051346,
0.01969211921095848,
-0.3565613031387329,
-0.1880565583705902,
0.38946884870529175,
-0.010773398913443089,
-0.8644475936889648,
0.5929290056228638,
0.5905345678329468,
0.38800540566444397,
-0.07712914794683456,
0.02681657113134861,
-0.2239014357328415,
0.22679473459720612,
0.44624683260917664,
0.33731895685195923,
-0.2764171063899994,
-0.12829770147800446,
0.041240569204092026,
0.15005932748317719,
-0.1323673129081726,
1.0476500988006592,
-0.5302474498748779,
0.2112356573343277,
0.36926713585853577,
0.5752274394035339,
0.4669589102268219,
0.2270859330892563,
0.8386312127113342,
-0.4612064063549042,
0.05032920092344284,
0.2204120010137558,
0.6400547623634338,
0.27254828810691833,
-0.4574035704135895,
0.5548953413963318,
0.008664330467581749,
-0.2952638864517212,
-0.6809713840484619,
-0.04449717700481415,
-0.9549485445022583,
-0.1832776963710785,
0.6777485609054565,
-0.3385147750377655,
-0.6313941478729248,
-0.09447717666625977,
-0.15740163624286652,
0.3267267942428589,
-0.5758689641952515,
0.15714725852012634,
0.7112835049629211,
-0.07511864602565765,
-0.089642234146595,
-0.430851012468338,
0.40129679441452026,
0.10554715991020203,
-0.6540191769599915,
0.10457457602024078,
0.34983721375465393,
0.3345978558063507,
0.3415406048297882,
0.7844983339309692,
-0.10049775242805481,
0.16249729692935944,
0.1023281067609787,
-0.05930408462882042,
-0.13707630336284637,
-0.4761721193790436,
-0.12009290605783463,
-0.016864122822880745,
-0.11040004342794418,
-0.008040877059102058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01310v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01310v1
|
Overcoming LLM Challenges using RAG-Driven Precision in Coffee Leaf Disease Remediation
| 2024-05-02T14:19:25 | 2024-05-02T14:19:25 |
Dr. Selva Kumar S, Afifah Khan Mohammed Ajmal Khan, Imadh Ajaz Banday, Manikantha Gada, Vibha Venkatesh Shanbhag
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
This research introduces an innovative AI-driven precision agriculture
system, leveraging YOLOv8 for disease identification and Retrieval Augmented
Generation (RAG) for context-aware diagnosis. Focused on addressing the
challenges of diseases affecting the coffee production sector in Karnataka, The
system integrates sophisticated object detection techniques with language
models to address the inherent constraints associated with Large Language
Models (LLMs). Our methodology not only tackles the issue of hallucinations in
LLMs, but also introduces dynamic disease identification and remediation
strategies. Real-time monitoring, collaborative dataset expansion, and
organizational involvement ensure the system's adaptability in diverse
agricultural settings. The effect of the suggested system extends beyond
automation, aiming to secure food supplies, protect livelihoods, and promote
eco-friendly farming practices. By facilitating precise disease identification,
the system contributes to sustainable and environmentally conscious
agriculture, reducing reliance on pesticides. Looking to the future, the
project envisions continuous development in RAG-integrated object detection
systems, emphasizing scalability, reliability, and usability. This research
strives to be a beacon for positive change in agriculture, aligning with global
efforts toward sustainable and technologically enhanced food production.
|
[
0.08503097295761108,
-0.9515332579612732,
0.71450275182724,
-0.255585253238678,
-0.13983331620693207,
0.125286266207695,
-0.0478367879986763,
-0.8988363742828369,
0.32793012261390686,
0.5250669717788696,
-0.371822327375412,
-0.7987621426582336,
-0.8210484385490417,
0.15829534828662872,
-0.35782504081726074,
0.8405724763870239,
0.04250406473875046,
-0.16366469860076904,
-0.3243543803691864,
-0.11981881409883499,
-0.44086113572120667,
-0.2516704201698303,
-0.8483142256736755,
-0.47591474652290344,
0.8239138126373291,
0.6427364945411682,
0.7141543030738831,
0.7114294767379761,
0.7483473420143127,
0.3505726158618927,
-0.06778606027364731,
0.389833927154541,
-0.2880598306655884,
0.5221205949783325,
-0.16105973720550537,
-0.5803555846214294,
-0.39130017161369324,
-0.14863282442092896,
0.23945452272891998,
0.6765375733375549,
0.1902870386838913,
0.41056182980537415,
-0.02215443179011345,
0.5480355620384216,
-0.6416153311729431,
0.23727796971797943,
-0.7136417627334595,
0.44447553157806396,
-0.284018874168396,
-0.39842894673347473,
-0.21843469142913818,
-0.055973418056964874,
-0.4561268985271454,
-0.866782009601593,
0.19347533583641052,
0.0006105108186602592,
1.073740005493164,
0.7662636041641235,
-0.28305548429489136,
0.05236612632870674,
-0.8319197297096252,
0.7544591426849365,
-0.6006282567977905,
-0.08671081811189651,
0.3992345631122589,
0.7197795510292053,
-0.5683642625808716,
-0.8472298383712769,
-0.2402791529893875,
0.04179442301392555,
-0.12329991161823273,
0.11861898005008698,
0.0876990556716919,
-0.4140048921108246,
0.015812115743756294,
0.012622570618987083,
-0.28335660696029663,
0.19542120397090912,
-0.2545383870601654,
-0.15125200152397156,
0.505620539188385,
0.44235867261886597,
0.2160513699054718,
-0.21799886226654053,
-0.11104391515254974,
0.2161664217710495,
-0.27666857838630676,
0.07340537011623383,
0.16958588361740112,
0.39633870124816895,
0.2946564257144928,
0.26594027876853943,
-0.49345138669013977,
0.7303978800773621,
-0.21908101439476013,
-0.6175199747085571,
0.2957826852798462,
0.01558145135641098,
-0.4961089491844177,
-0.2511467933654785,
0.710776150226593,
0.5321359634399414,
-0.20123036205768585,
-0.2338629513978958,
-0.2156570553779602,
0.36325597763061523,
0.48726075887680054,
-0.574366569519043,
-0.10657432675361633,
0.39491042494773865,
-0.4963761866092682,
-0.7152754068374634,
-0.1899181455373764,
-1.0618802309036255,
-0.5510185360908508,
-0.32737427949905396,
0.2018800675868988,
-0.22662384808063507,
-0.3668477237224579,
0.041012953966856,
-0.2217157781124115,
0.560435950756073,
0.34791332483291626,
-0.6989109516143799,
0.22790105640888214,
1.0086897611618042,
0.6474944353103638,
-0.37701845169067383,
0.24782034754753113,
-0.38840433955192566,
0.28063154220581055,
-0.4049529433250427,
0.9526237845420837,
-0.7104147672653198,
-0.6259905099868774,
-0.3245560824871063,
0.27240240573883057,
0.044701606035232544,
-0.9774994254112244,
0.9082373380661011,
-0.2842506170272827,
-0.47743043303489685,
-0.18879422545433044,
-0.075499027967453,
-0.23122480511665344,
0.7019302845001221,
-0.3357028663158417,
1.1225241422653198,
0.16077587008476257,
-0.838194727897644,
0.4760138988494873,
-0.35142967104911804,
-0.48329025506973267,
0.5085716247558594,
-0.5053293704986572,
-0.9356558918952942,
0.03832358121871948,
-0.13385604321956635,
0.4683190584182739,
-0.33160483837127686,
0.5119447112083435,
-0.4403175413608551,
-0.16544054448604584,
-0.09078605473041534,
-0.6568446755409241,
0.5948205590248108,
0.3745480179786682,
-0.2581751048564911,
0.4347008466720581,
-0.9636763334274292,
0.18025019764900208,
0.473349004983902,
0.08361729234457016,
-0.28272655606269836,
-0.06510991603136063,
0.07453662902116776,
-0.40114906430244446,
0.2443666160106659,
-0.41498488187789917,
0.3105701804161072,
0.029519110918045044,
0.19288340210914612,
0.6017435193061829,
0.10045494884252548,
-0.0017498802626505494,
-0.4303019940853119,
0.5218291282653809,
0.09924105554819107,
0.5197660326957703,
-0.16490234434604645,
-0.6483194828033447,
-0.5405567288398743,
-0.46351882815361023,
0.3320736587047577,
0.9589459896087646,
-0.32736021280288696,
0.5644319653511047,
-0.23509372770786285,
-0.5496472120285034,
-0.3910331428050995,
-0.3354915380477905,
0.16050690412521362,
0.9002782106399536,
0.1679394245147705,
-0.29918497800827026,
-0.2334470897912979,
-1.0254309177398682,
-0.11893008649349213,
0.23768873512744904,
0.12545640766620636,
0.1625542789697647,
0.49541857838630676,
-0.664706289768219,
1.0315700769424438,
-0.9298425912857056,
-0.49350348114967346,
0.20728453993797302,
0.017605219036340714,
0.36704832315444946,
0.458828866481781,
0.456947386264801,
-1.028412103652954,
-0.7271077632904053,
0.6534764766693115,
-1.039040207862854,
-0.15193603932857513,
0.4179210364818573,
0.057188697159290314,
0.3325677812099457,
0.651202380657196,
-0.41460680961608887,
0.9443045258522034,
0.29600390791893005,
-0.2587185204029083,
0.7772160768508911,
-0.48842015862464905,
0.4714319109916687,
-0.9212536811828613,
0.27083322405815125,
0.0010815039277076721,
-0.789387047290802,
-0.5373036861419678,
0.23891572654247284,
-0.16529785096645355,
-0.13131245970726013,
-0.3653000295162201,
0.05070624127984047,
-0.1809055656194687,
-0.25480467081069946,
-0.5679553151130676,
-0.20491334795951843,
0.3039434552192688,
0.09389205276966095,
-0.3473205268383026,
0.7044645547866821,
0.6699509024620056,
-0.5051568746566772,
0.32606977224349976,
-0.3937150835990906,
-0.17649662494659424,
0.9299010634422302,
-0.47305721044540405,
-0.30065611004829407,
-0.22842608392238617,
0.11233318597078323,
-0.8538914918899536,
-0.33818867802619934,
1.0246042013168335,
-0.6961193084716797,
0.47383439540863037,
-0.0021360863465815783,
-0.4430333375930786,
-0.37924924492836,
0.18025647103786469,
0.36249953508377075,
0.5341387987136841,
-0.25855496525764465,
0.8651539087295532,
0.4617656469345093,
0.16021408140659332,
-0.40593820810317993,
-0.7190874218940735,
0.01948987878859043,
-0.6464694142341614,
-0.3335317373275757,
0.19602765142917633,
0.12969279289245605,
-0.38807374238967896,
0.1826825737953186,
-0.3189604580402374,
-0.28406205773353577,
0.4472600221633911,
0.32080739736557007,
-0.13495735824108124,
0.09268573671579361,
0.003607879625633359,
0.023037580773234367,
-0.42065563797950745,
0.09304395318031311,
-0.250893771648407,
0.3325031101703644,
0.13859347999095917,
-0.508378267288208,
-0.8693234324455261,
0.3695053160190582,
0.7580302357673645,
-0.21082164347171783,
0.4917835593223572,
0.7921881675720215,
-0.5831241607666016,
0.016119197010993958,
-0.07818321138620377,
-0.07890784740447998,
-0.5388796925544739,
0.22755882143974304,
-0.6656151413917542,
-0.49082109332084656,
0.5954365134239197,
-0.5715011954307556,
-0.10707977414131165,
0.5359402894973755,
0.09990011900663376,
-0.11829157918691635,
0.4395867884159088,
0.5656071901321411,
-0.12235318124294281,
-0.12191631644964218,
-0.35453134775161743,
0.4626372754573822,
-0.9941563010215759,
-0.6295762658119202,
-0.7396355867385864,
-0.3298049867153168,
-0.4124254882335663,
-0.927828848361969,
0.5530797243118286,
-0.16625957190990448,
0.031023016199469566,
-0.15020966529846191,
-0.9468824863433838,
0.48262929916381836,
0.3836178183555603,
0.2583179175853729,
0.5914076566696167,
-0.3996445834636688,
0.03130766749382019,
-0.07134868204593658,
-0.6534792184829712,
-0.6682136654853821,
0.9537831544876099,
0.3591160178184509,
0.44994744658470154,
-0.24930472671985626,
0.6873349547386169,
0.7234607934951782,
0.5139561891555786,
-1.2122689485549927,
0.40652358531951904,
-0.11317852139472961,
-0.2768477499485016,
-0.4238215386867523,
-0.1057688295841217,
-1.4145454168319702,
0.2964872419834137,
-0.0523475706577301,
-0.6924670934677124,
-0.01842787303030491,
0.2201405167579651,
-0.21948915719985962,
0.4818733036518097,
-0.5899817943572998,
0.7736881971359253,
-0.4787636995315552,
-0.5224382877349854,
0.029937051236629486,
-0.4719146192073822,
0.2676072418689728,
-0.10620319098234177,
0.6373443603515625,
-0.3315310776233673,
-0.0472637377679348,
0.3311934471130371,
-0.4131156802177429,
1.1023412942886353,
-0.12949606776237488,
-0.294932097196579,
0.224709615111351,
0.0259647648781538,
0.47918474674224854,
0.20890644192695618,
0.028226615861058235,
0.2266896665096283,
-0.4102785289287567,
-0.3755256235599518,
-0.4115670919418335,
0.9402684569358826,
-0.6068090200424194,
-0.889862060546875,
-0.7909627556800842,
-0.5897071957588196,
0.19397196173667908,
0.5333575010299683,
-0.1478600800037384,
-0.01392300147563219,
-0.1169685572385788,
0.10277620702981949,
1.0161608457565308,
-0.16183289885520935,
0.2473105937242508,
0.31256046891212463,
-0.5062586069107056,
-0.3173360228538513,
1.0708659887313843,
0.29079240560531616,
0.020982423797249794,
0.4215651750564575,
0.26840224862098694,
0.26376888155937195,
-0.6214076280593872,
-0.24757063388824463,
-0.2506353557109833,
-0.5198569893836975,
-0.6010886430740356,
-0.8534112572669983,
-0.029738305136561394,
-0.5504372119903564,
-0.02540471963584423,
-0.38453012704849243,
0.01885388232767582,
-0.7582732439041138,
-0.04174713045358658,
0.6647177934646606,
0.715465247631073,
0.0760870948433876,
0.5355057120323181,
-0.36794641613960266,
0.595598578453064,
-0.07170343399047852,
0.41029828786849976,
-0.1815813183784485,
-0.46479618549346924,
-0.041119277477264404,
0.05641968548297882,
-0.5478760004043579,
-0.8418666124343872,
0.8330349922180176,
-0.19562257826328278,
0.4168876111507416,
0.4585074186325073,
0.03165523335337639,
0.6151284575462341,
-0.5428972840309143,
0.46513283252716064,
0.09905584156513214,
-0.5788082480430603,
0.36395320296287537,
-0.5932127237319946,
0.33518344163894653,
0.39182260632514954,
0.45350903272628784,
-0.4550101161003113,
-0.41886118054389954,
-0.4363320469856262,
-1.201817274093628,
0.24103514850139618,
-0.11205773800611496,
-0.5341383218765259,
0.18055282533168793,
0.49915429949760437,
0.4148630201816559,
-0.22584907710552216,
-0.2548387348651886,
-0.3309163749217987,
0.05716407671570778,
-0.1870119422674179,
0.0921245887875557,
0.057817429304122925,
-0.23542653024196625,
-0.388709157705307,
0.6613993644714355,
-0.08916553854942322,
0.03963317722082138,
0.49022945761680603,
0.06115834414958954,
-0.22367730736732483,
0.011745795607566833,
0.3726317286491394,
0.7357001900672913,
-0.04592619463801384,
-0.031381022185087204,
0.051361385732889175,
-0.24255909025669098,
0.07597464323043823,
-0.06578337401151657,
-0.5916000008583069,
0.01441451907157898,
-0.016078896820545197,
0.6066948771476746,
0.02950247935950756,
-0.37079018354415894,
0.026955682784318924,
0.1993400603532791,
-0.4116920828819275,
-0.9004655480384827,
0.0778910294175148,
0.13000139594078064,
0.22832661867141724,
0.6980240345001221,
0.2885197103023529,
0.5040868520736694,
-0.16167928278446198,
0.3993774354457855,
0.5349445939064026,
-0.2281130850315094,
0.050571780651807785,
0.6453759670257568,
0.17884045839309692,
-0.7342790365219116,
0.33521410822868347,
-0.2599920332431793,
-0.32306721806526184,
1.1691391468048096,
0.5040863752365112,
0.5428110361099243,
-0.11991484463214874,
0.3177633285522461,
0.21061353385448456,
0.42836228013038635,
0.16512295603752136,
-0.007056295406073332,
0.250642329454422,
-0.5546858310699463,
-0.3318151831626892,
-0.6561494469642639,
-0.3331005871295929,
0.46904903650283813,
-0.6173851490020752,
0.36273840069770813,
-0.48477256298065186,
-0.38483214378356934,
0.31446924805641174,
-0.0790213793516159,
-0.4573058784008026,
0.38001471757888794,
-0.10405733436346054,
0.6061953902244568,
-1.3356698751449585,
0.8819704055786133,
0.5663657784461975,
-0.06437145173549652,
-0.41104593873023987,
0.09188318997621536,
0.04118318110704422,
-0.6040422916412354,
0.41652750968933105,
0.5576454997062683,
-0.2376021146774292,
-0.12079954892396927,
-0.44378194212913513,
-0.8642650842666626,
1.304618000984192,
-0.03180049732327461,
-0.57909095287323,
0.6520504951477051,
0.22934170067310333,
0.6047428250312805,
-0.29382917284965515,
0.21413002908229828,
0.6124008297920227,
0.9410558938980103,
0.16758857667446136,
-0.7734325528144836,
-0.2690143883228302,
0.016412876546382904,
0.09618374705314636,
0.3976668417453766,
-1.0716891288757324,
0.21561934053897858,
0.006369065027683973,
-0.11457565426826477,
0.003059359034523368,
0.9928610920906067,
0.22984930872917175,
0.6791709065437317,
0.35665568709373474,
1.141686201095581,
0.8793514370918274,
-0.16719858348369598,
0.9064839482307434,
-0.08223872631788254,
0.05923141539096832,
0.9983212947845459,
-0.4386470317840576,
0.4430576264858246,
0.7244883179664612,
-0.13538196682929993,
0.2627864181995392,
0.7786900401115417,
0.03190965577960014,
0.28078266978263855,
0.45871514081954956,
-0.4404412508010864,
-0.04877588525414467,
-0.5449183583259583,
-0.23806732892990112,
0.41364312171936035,
0.6696155667304993,
-0.2818629741668701,
-0.1400686502456665,
0.23406969010829926,
0.15347139537334442,
0.5823544859886169,
-0.3307231664657593,
0.38875433802604675,
-0.14712193608283997,
-0.4803914427757263,
0.2856394648551941,
0.18343205749988556,
0.8647472858428955,
-0.5524411797523499,
-0.22049938142299652,
-0.06767640262842178,
0.3839879035949707,
-0.3095211088657379,
-0.596743643283844,
0.9819608926773071,
-0.4195941984653473,
-0.6058675050735474,
-0.17084723711013794,
0.9818697571754456,
-0.25933006405830383,
-0.8331161737442017,
0.3776102364063263,
0.142582505941391,
0.36657509207725525,
0.16454146802425385,
-0.37102919816970825,
0.794439435005188,
-0.002202938310801983,
0.1448066532611847,
0.16797342896461487,
0.6670975089073181,
-0.4535866379737854,
0.8358702063560486,
0.3777379095554352,
0.06108381971716881,
-0.023225706070661545,
-0.21808268129825592,
0.7440717816352844,
-0.43276000022888184,
-0.01054411381483078,
-0.5102820992469788,
0.4286332130432129,
-0.2050693780183792,
0.060558028519153595,
0.5282357335090637,
0.6107710003852844,
0.8367611765861511,
-0.35996466875076294,
0.9158449769020081,
-0.3084104657173157,
0.36039799451828003,
0.082525834441185,
0.5567627549171448,
-0.6426723003387451,
-0.024217139929533005,
0.14704632759094238,
-0.32887864112854004,
-0.6127461194992065,
0.3295876681804657,
-0.22161364555358887,
-0.09448225051164627,
0.6479434967041016,
0.8587113618850708,
-0.06683266907930374,
-0.5125856995582581,
0.4906684160232544,
0.16825418174266815,
0.5554622411727905,
0.2081669718027115,
0.1374276727437973,
-0.46825090050697327,
0.3004205822944641,
-0.11453288793563843,
-0.5629287362098694,
-0.4347197115421295,
-1.120208740234375,
-0.2929544746875763,
-0.1793583184480667,
-0.5397047400474548,
0.08293783664703369,
0.30070942640304565,
0.5835055112838745,
0.5464263558387756,
-0.7238264083862305,
-0.006807378958910704,
-0.21490539610385895,
0.16577742993831635,
-0.3962193429470062,
-0.3067297041416168,
0.31588318943977356,
-0.5207028388977051,
-0.8907110691070557,
0.29811155796051025,
0.49078094959259033,
-0.24644692242145538,
-0.22923646867275238,
0.14598815143108368,
-0.3644610345363617,
-0.3839956223964691,
0.49761882424354553,
0.5905582904815674,
-0.7233672738075256,
-0.26214131712913513,
-0.1745287925004959,
0.0981452688574791,
0.11505966633558273,
0.4521670937538147,
-0.6801361441612244,
0.47538596391677856,
0.40366679430007935,
0.9869827628135681,
0.060423221439123154,
0.06629282236099243,
0.378197580575943,
-0.37112247943878174,
0.4399108588695526,
0.401709645986557,
0.01215978804975748,
0.4114402234554291,
-0.9688454866409302,
0.4354139268398285,
0.663864254951477,
-0.8075872659683228,
-0.6643474102020264,
0.42333221435546875,
-0.9654553532600403,
-0.27667316794395447,
0.9891529083251953,
-0.23221632838249207,
-0.8699157238006592,
-0.31995341181755066,
-0.07942712306976318,
0.48249468207359314,
-0.2612786591053009,
0.7702741026878357,
0.33834487199783325,
-0.107577383518219,
0.028017202392220497,
-0.46284839510917664,
0.13124880194664001,
0.4393152892589569,
-0.8823946118354797,
-0.1478901207447052,
0.44928815960884094,
0.37780043482780457,
0.2936113178730011,
0.6549750566482544,
-0.20054367184638977,
-0.19451725482940674,
-0.1957719624042511,
0.2688518464565277,
-0.08790171891450882,
-0.6630154252052307,
-0.073886938393116,
0.1003761813044548,
0.09771586209535599,
-0.5895179510116577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01299v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01299v1
|
The Effectiveness of LLMs as Annotators: A Comparative Overview and Empirical Analysis of Direct Representation
| 2024-05-02T14:00:22 | 2024-05-02T14:00:22 |
Maja Pavlovic, Massimo Poesio
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful support tools across
various natural language tasks and a range of application domains. Recent
studies focus on exploring their capabilities for data annotation. This paper
provides a comparative overview of twelve studies investigating the potential
of LLMs in labelling data. While the models demonstrate promising cost and
time-saving benefits, there exist considerable limitations, such as
representativeness, bias, sensitivity to prompt variations and English language
preference. Leveraging insights from these studies, our empirical analysis
further examines the alignment between human and GPT-generated opinion
distributions across four subjective datasets. In contrast to the studies
examining representation, our methodology directly obtains the opinion
distribution from GPT. Our analysis thereby supports the minority of studies
that are considering diverse perspectives when evaluating data annotation tasks
and highlights the need for further research in this direction.
|
[
-0.39200112223625183,
-0.43157151341438293,
0.6757379174232483,
0.14814701676368713,
-0.28294137120246887,
0.08010417968034744,
-0.4521986246109009,
-0.8118781447410583,
0.11061225831508636,
0.4018206000328064,
-0.04830312356352806,
-0.6828199625015259,
-0.8534713983535767,
0.533088743686676,
-0.34985777735710144,
0.8995516300201416,
-0.10964060574769974,
0.39546945691108704,
-0.290592223405838,
-0.19397760927677155,
-0.3150489330291748,
-1.0544748306274414,
-0.6414371728897095,
-0.6475698947906494,
0.9455224871635437,
-0.11869003623723984,
0.7170426845550537,
0.7425541281700134,
0.8022773861885071,
0.2347821146249771,
-0.15819063782691956,
-0.08503209799528122,
-0.20432667434215546,
0.20712564885616302,
-0.04982098191976547,
-0.4736826419830322,
-0.4351290166378021,
0.3502234220504761,
0.7057953476905823,
0.9962372183799744,
0.23138336837291718,
0.0424153096973896,
0.17260046303272247,
0.5692829489707947,
-0.3837848901748657,
0.24070297181606293,
-0.46450376510620117,
0.15774457156658173,
-0.33946916460990906,
0.08850646018981934,
-0.5070533156394958,
-0.5142138600349426,
0.28365519642829895,
-0.4337165653705597,
-0.07512776553630829,
0.14273010194301605,
0.669183611869812,
0.2836434841156006,
-0.5327737927436829,
-0.48156943917274475,
-0.9037168622016907,
0.8991926312446594,
-0.821928858757019,
0.562847375869751,
0.2725544571876526,
0.26998963952064514,
0.0274142287671566,
-0.5281286239624023,
-0.2794332504272461,
-0.4813418686389923,
-0.125333771109581,
-0.047005217522382736,
0.042577169835567474,
0.06240084394812584,
0.4660671651363373,
0.4726344347000122,
-0.3005507290363312,
0.6035344004631042,
-0.02160702459514141,
-0.24385100603103638,
0.8034458756446838,
0.0687917098402977,
0.15577207505702972,
-0.14299538731575012,
-0.3682774007320404,
0.00865244958549738,
-0.9666479229927063,
-0.2212236523628235,
0.4602597951889038,
0.40051907300949097,
0.06228014826774597,
0.8692983388900757,
-0.19614404439926147,
0.6943950057029724,
-0.14036139845848083,
-0.22156241536140442,
0.34942370653152466,
-0.004228875506669283,
-0.2749539315700531,
0.00022138854546938092,
1.0850348472595215,
0.3558402359485626,
0.4359009861946106,
-0.2303461879491806,
-0.3322181701660156,
-0.09144457429647446,
-0.022585084661841393,
-0.6786789894104004,
-0.07817817479372025,
0.02074282430112362,
-0.35035642981529236,
-0.13069216907024384,
0.23395992815494537,
-0.5431976914405823,
-0.9125034213066101,
-0.67775559425354,
0.03502915799617767,
-0.052927229553461075,
-0.25918230414390564,
-0.0294589102268219,
0.01789029873907566,
0.202874094247818,
0.4091523587703705,
-0.7846492528915405,
0.23689348995685577,
0.8162053823471069,
0.8468642234802246,
-0.4064999520778656,
0.10604089498519897,
0.06763063371181488,
0.09894847869873047,
-0.3274698257446289,
0.8165618181228638,
-0.7492326498031616,
-0.42839470505714417,
0.22116273641586304,
-0.11841912567615509,
0.1517324000597,
-0.7406739592552185,
0.6406795978546143,
-0.39316326379776,
0.03826089948415756,
-0.7226850986480713,
-0.8238864541053772,
-0.22924049198627472,
0.23337483406066895,
-0.9705596566200256,
1.0201103687286377,
-0.2133270502090454,
-0.909977376461029,
0.6014370322227478,
-0.47272369265556335,
-0.18131974339485168,
0.08866413682699203,
-0.47542741894721985,
-0.3074205815792084,
0.07286275178194046,
0.2580878734588623,
0.807033360004425,
-0.4483882188796997,
0.37030619382858276,
-0.3209909200668335,
-0.23717229068279266,
0.6471185684204102,
-0.3799715042114258,
0.4290616810321808,
0.14538384974002838,
-0.38892799615859985,
0.07188345491886139,
-0.6504855751991272,
-0.6137818694114685,
0.23976312577724457,
-0.46853888034820557,
-0.4409900903701782,
0.16514351963996887,
0.02261217124760151,
0.04063872620463371,
0.13395096361637115,
-0.5154522061347961,
0.38926106691360474,
0.03898197412490845,
0.24233897030353546,
0.718126654624939,
-0.0815599262714386,
0.4492768347263336,
-0.023391101509332657,
0.4994194507598877,
-0.04901181161403656,
-0.15393231809139252,
0.02585894800722599,
-0.470721572637558,
-0.5469675064086914,
-0.44178465008735657,
0.7780098915100098,
0.39346951246261597,
-0.4146513342857361,
0.2553304135799408,
-0.35820722579956055,
-0.3554740846157074,
-0.6839658617973328,
0.151524618268013,
0.18623605370521545,
0.20491445064544678,
0.14757481217384338,
-0.18738797307014465,
-0.6589050889015198,
-1.257756233215332,
-0.15839610993862152,
-0.18569166958332062,
-0.07254505157470703,
0.1175873726606369,
0.416517049074173,
-0.24885480105876923,
0.9271407723426819,
-0.25755199790000916,
-0.21336768567562103,
-0.3246007263660431,
0.17526404559612274,
0.08499644696712494,
0.04969248175621033,
0.5080472230911255,
-0.6774274110794067,
-0.3724643588066101,
0.08652118593454361,
-0.8655279874801636,
-0.34760287404060364,
-0.020960474386811256,
0.12341680377721786,
0.28182753920555115,
0.1933019608259201,
-0.5265291929244995,
0.38583460450172424,
0.4891006648540497,
0.029563067480921745,
0.3515993356704712,
0.05980418995022774,
0.2549269497394562,
-0.5406489372253418,
0.08395278453826904,
0.3026033043861389,
-0.29591238498687744,
-0.5497749447822571,
-0.43599733710289,
0.07180223613977432,
0.08288294821977615,
-0.21571700274944305,
0.4987390637397766,
-0.6548680663108826,
-0.13465413451194763,
-0.22595074772834778,
0.3673475980758667,
-0.2765136659145355,
0.00939112901687622,
0.30023476481437683,
0.7507535219192505,
0.21575553715229034,
-0.27265891432762146,
0.4288846552371979,
0.06234642490744591,
-0.34741950035095215,
0.3683246076107025,
-0.6865847706794739,
0.23131826519966125,
-0.24116265773773193,
0.3499380648136139,
-1.1796965599060059,
-0.2687857449054718,
0.42384839057922363,
-0.1330290138721466,
0.3933809697628021,
-0.09094274789094925,
-0.8156566023826599,
-0.37116214632987976,
-0.49776819348335266,
0.01222949381917715,
0.5229371786117554,
-0.445904016494751,
0.2680071294307709,
0.5044885277748108,
-0.25225141644477844,
-0.39881569147109985,
-0.8572924733161926,
0.25803184509277344,
-0.5087979435920715,
-0.2508998215198517,
-0.04018634930253029,
0.1971246749162674,
-0.6470204591751099,
-0.006194422021508217,
0.005088191479444504,
0.27971088886260986,
0.07449819147586823,
0.40653732419013977,
0.26144224405288696,
-0.12857156991958618,
0.2915588319301605,
-0.35918381810188293,
-0.25100964307785034,
0.08200784772634506,
0.09846807271242142,
0.23486734926700592,
0.245388463139534,
-0.4641505777835846,
-0.28839874267578125,
0.33069807291030884,
0.18427689373493195,
-0.16487626731395721,
0.6953862905502319,
0.43197140097618103,
-0.32094454765319824,
-0.005654781125485897,
-0.8736622333526611,
0.07575871050357819,
-0.34005007147789,
0.2023382931947708,
-0.2209406942129135,
-0.8866286873817444,
0.3933277428150177,
-0.00178672990296036,
0.19104500114917755,
0.5021579265594482,
0.6084465980529785,
0.0030084154568612576,
0.917884111404419,
0.3254934847354889,
-0.3510662019252777,
0.5273741483688354,
0.04184998199343681,
0.2496037632226944,
-0.9111615419387817,
-0.22798629105091095,
-0.5497335195541382,
-0.37117817997932434,
-0.5247825980186462,
-0.3594610095024109,
0.003336489899083972,
0.04848244786262512,
-0.09853380918502808,
-0.11371439695358276,
-0.623945951461792,
0.2862846255302429,
0.3322415053844452,
-0.14677096903324127,
0.43018993735313416,
0.004832159727811813,
0.2219255417585373,
-0.30962005257606506,
-0.32884395122528076,
-1.178648829460144,
1.283015489578247,
0.5823383331298828,
0.7933009266853333,
-0.12081671506166458,
0.6588569283485413,
0.26357945799827576,
0.8953966498374939,
-0.7169440984725952,
0.6896377801895142,
-0.13295438885688782,
-0.721255362033844,
-0.163426473736763,
-0.2094554752111435,
-0.861671507358551,
0.40130501985549927,
-0.26126542687416077,
-0.8199669718742371,
-0.022252866998314857,
-0.033134203404188156,
-0.11598629504442215,
0.39987123012542725,
-0.7217527031898499,
0.4836478531360626,
-0.2927098572254181,
-0.2851508855819702,
0.37699171900749207,
-0.4464761018753052,
0.28425073623657227,
-0.1370585709810257,
0.234648197889328,
-0.4095223546028137,
-0.21204905211925507,
1.1638797521591187,
-0.010125257074832916,
1.0414897203445435,
-0.3543507754802704,
-0.5232487916946411,
0.3789009749889374,
-0.331227570772171,
0.5226635932922363,
-0.11563962697982788,
-0.3698139488697052,
0.24704836308956146,
-0.3253103494644165,
-0.07786142081022263,
-0.539059579372406,
0.6054794788360596,
-0.5897244215011597,
-0.7385558485984802,
-0.5708728432655334,
-0.5571342706680298,
-0.23773205280303955,
0.012681042775511742,
-0.05376175418496132,
0.31675097346305847,
-0.07086221128702164,
0.22448816895484924,
0.46323415637016296,
-0.1370030790567398,
0.4184224307537079,
0.062473148107528687,
-0.5321454405784607,
-0.43198370933532715,
0.4986019730567932,
0.5606975555419922,
0.11274870485067368,
0.4311847388744354,
0.08055023849010468,
-0.44308117032051086,
-0.8887184262275696,
-0.23253512382507324,
0.469971239566803,
-0.9136155247688293,
-0.09034647047519684,
-0.6321403980255127,
0.09526325762271881,
-0.3061036467552185,
-0.02795787900686264,
-0.13026513159275055,
-0.39562299847602844,
-0.10296546667814255,
-0.4887067377567291,
0.5155676603317261,
1.294848918914795,
0.019025739282369614,
0.28960636258125305,
-0.2870730459690094,
0.06278535723686218,
0.22930121421813965,
0.30441203713417053,
-0.06583016365766525,
-0.06641830503940582,
-0.2007620930671692,
0.050775978714227676,
-0.16591455042362213,
-1.074385643005371,
0.022789524868130684,
-0.2155376672744751,
0.6582700610160828,
0.29105344414711,
-0.23896697163581848,
0.5535646677017212,
-0.4805048406124115,
1.0044434070587158,
0.10092125087976456,
-0.779168963432312,
0.23778404295444489,
-0.4136790931224823,
0.06835957616567612,
0.5107038617134094,
0.675794780254364,
-0.43265917897224426,
-0.3611312806606293,
-0.30223503708839417,
-0.966975748538971,
0.35477975010871887,
0.10364677011966705,
-0.14387929439544678,
0.015017952769994736,
0.40132883191108704,
0.44502487778663635,
0.13454459607601166,
-0.8242092132568359,
-0.397875040769577,
0.20207877457141876,
-0.3671412765979767,
-0.36965426802635193,
-0.4509109556674957,
0.10141772776842117,
-0.16700799763202667,
0.5619852542877197,
0.1917078047990799,
0.28209903836250305,
0.24525687098503113,
-0.17416010797023773,
0.21483507752418518,
0.4524158537387848,
0.3979698121547699,
0.6929718255996704,
-0.29703497886657715,
0.3953740894794464,
0.19039030373096466,
-0.403626948595047,
0.20753751695156097,
0.23733152449131012,
-0.3067866265773773,
0.22095686197280884,
0.6785314679145813,
0.8483431339263916,
0.11591758579015732,
-0.4201158881187439,
0.3036888837814331,
0.1120179146528244,
-0.06749327480792999,
-0.16239967942237854,
-0.267315536737442,
0.4420781433582306,
0.1694968044757843,
0.3282605707645416,
-0.56276935338974,
0.18150515854358673,
-0.4105682671070099,
-0.1128554418683052,
0.5145463943481445,
-0.26807260513305664,
-0.3549482524394989,
0.6600450873374939,
0.2717256546020508,
-0.20684653520584106,
0.23151125013828278,
0.03358018398284912,
-0.3195440471172333,
0.3882274329662323,
0.32595211267471313,
0.7262856960296631,
-0.21154248714447021,
0.044842518866062164,
0.1092807948589325,
0.2773991525173187,
-0.17757698893547058,
-0.0990995392203331,
0.05238771066069603,
-0.4187127649784088,
-0.5680915713310242,
-0.5222910642623901,
-0.6757844090461731,
0.019327346235513687,
-0.5798551440238953,
0.11984585225582123,
-0.2122206687927246,
-0.5922520160675049,
0.3345835208892822,
0.07877759635448456,
-0.9291942715644836,
0.21780690550804138,
0.578274130821228,
0.5793521404266357,
-0.9103166460990906,
0.6899942755699158,
0.9929876923561096,
-0.45079702138900757,
-0.692711591720581,
-0.14244306087493896,
0.08200928568840027,
-0.5568072199821472,
0.9873971939086914,
0.2233763039112091,
0.07571503520011902,
-0.31128355860710144,
-0.4757483899593353,
-0.6411871314048767,
1.0863277912139893,
0.37582719326019287,
-0.868492066860199,
0.17391031980514526,
0.5712506771087646,
0.6390899419784546,
-0.5179625153541565,
0.4151977598667145,
0.6887063980102539,
0.7454282641410828,
-0.05163315683603287,
-0.8311746120452881,
0.23773081600666046,
0.17064803838729858,
0.11778939515352249,
0.20258812606334686,
-0.2868025600910187,
0.5794898271560669,
0.0642569288611412,
-0.3731105923652649,
-0.1494784653186798,
0.616140604019165,
0.12865068018436432,
0.18134714663028717,
0.3488374352455139,
0.2120104730129242,
0.8409820795059204,
-0.2676617205142975,
1.3046406507492065,
0.13094356656074524,
0.39765459299087524,
0.9881693124771118,
-0.6236979961395264,
0.8104078769683838,
0.6985353231430054,
-0.606793224811554,
0.21649284660816193,
0.8025103807449341,
0.02043670229613781,
0.30794602632522583,
0.5889455080032349,
-0.2083769142627716,
-0.13806913793087006,
-0.38371777534484863,
-0.40958207845687866,
-0.04988742619752884,
0.15345437824726105,
-0.5080379843711853,
-0.10520388185977936,
-0.04210207238793373,
0.17579224705696106,
0.0043493215925991535,
-0.29647859930992126,
0.9000704288482666,
0.37547990679740906,
-0.18905770778656006,
0.2696211040019989,
-0.3268750011920929,
0.8402047157287598,
-0.43266987800598145,
0.039088182151317596,
-0.1885700821876526,
-0.05254586040973663,
-0.4104728400707245,
-0.9316949844360352,
0.1426863670349121,
0.22261863946914673,
-0.0005800764192827046,
-0.25546565651893616,
0.8575714826583862,
-0.38689807057380676,
-0.4948368966579437,
0.33037108182907104,
0.48003557324409485,
0.22221799194812775,
-0.015477129258215427,
-0.3407810628414154,
0.5466925501823425,
-0.02501058392226696,
-0.6468026638031006,
0.1246727928519249,
0.5014591813087463,
-0.14988629519939423,
0.5901098251342773,
0.28115925192832947,
0.3501301407814026,
0.18443669378757477,
0.1789649873971939,
0.6293280720710754,
-0.8617920279502869,
0.11479245871305466,
-1.1206250190734863,
0.6322813630104065,
-0.2550727427005768,
-0.06948552280664444,
1.0875294208526611,
0.5593885183334351,
0.6220539808273315,
-0.122333824634552,
1.116707444190979,
0.12840300798416138,
0.5680963397026062,
-0.48134931921958923,
0.39319556951522827,
-0.11861654371023178,
0.32028478384017944,
-0.3348330557346344,
-1.2493518590927124,
-0.7749917507171631,
0.4871823489665985,
-0.9246656894683838,
0.0072557576932013035,
0.5692220330238342,
0.4470609426498413,
0.16086558997631073,
0.023907728493213654,
0.1730489581823349,
0.07904194295406342,
0.5020264983177185,
0.24080555140972137,
1.2042150497436523,
-0.10016277432441711,
-0.02577950246632099,
-0.22536008059978485,
-0.031118707731366158,
-0.05895776301622391,
-0.9844732284545898,
-1.2159069776535034,
-0.49252352118492126,
-0.5211877822875977,
0.05668395385146141,
0.023420926183462143,
1.153233528137207,
0.49822312593460083,
-0.711452066898346,
-0.1634434014558792,
0.4522114098072052,
-0.023168038576841354,
0.2626388370990753,
-0.14734460413455963,
0.545965850353241,
-0.17771580815315247,
-0.7414354085922241,
0.044184163212776184,
0.19822478294372559,
0.17713695764541626,
-0.34233611822128296,
0.005270120222121477,
-0.0585760623216629,
0.04324695095419884,
0.7216519117355347,
-0.06051360070705414,
-0.8917485475540161,
-0.4559716284275055,
-0.3451472520828247,
-0.2160625457763672,
0.18683408200740814,
0.8701285123825073,
-0.563913881778717,
0.12234211713075638,
0.3238600492477417,
0.8517796397209167,
0.3169311583042145,
0.07486998289823532,
0.47423359751701355,
-0.48369652032852173,
0.10194586962461472,
0.12604327499866486,
0.4587717652320862,
0.8748506903648376,
-0.2246682047843933,
0.8561108708381653,
-0.0733933374285698,
-0.6025639176368713,
-0.8547258377075195,
-0.026667917147278786,
-1.0612565279006958,
0.08300817757844925,
1.6618202924728394,
-0.09019395709037781,
-0.0848032757639885,
-0.04802512004971504,
-0.5268987417221069,
0.1408941000699997,
-0.5224049687385559,
0.4459426701068878,
0.8987204432487488,
-0.22803369164466858,
0.004221362993121147,
-0.853029727935791,
0.3804296553134918,
0.12180343270301819,
-0.8427801728248596,
0.23978084325790405,
0.5471015572547913,
0.22267559170722961,
0.16316604614257812,
0.5841656923294067,
-0.1709514707326889,
-0.6086102724075317,
-0.38364604115486145,
0.266704261302948,
-0.05345463380217552,
0.09172175079584122,
-0.5663111805915833,
0.09562002867460251,
0.5614131093025208,
-0.07468681782484055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01293v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01293v1
|
Low-resource speech recognition and dialect identification of Irish in a multi-task framework
| 2024-05-02T13:54:39 | 2024-05-02T13:54:39 |
Liam Lonergan, Mengjie Qian, Neasa Ní Chiaráin, Christer Gobl, Ailbhe Ní Chasaide
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
This paper explores the use of Hybrid CTC/Attention encoder-decoder models
trained with Intermediate CTC (InterCTC) for Irish (Gaelic) low-resource speech
recognition (ASR) and dialect identification (DID). Results are compared to the
current best performing models trained for ASR (TDNN-HMM) and DID (ECAPA-TDNN).
An optimal InterCTC setting is initially established using a Conformer encoder.
This setting is then used to train a model with an E-branchformer encoder and
the performance of both architectures are compared. A multi-task fine-tuning
approach is adopted for language model (LM) shallow fusion. The experiments
yielded an improvement in DID accuracy of 10.8% relative to a baseline
ECAPA-TDNN, and WER performance approaching the TDNN-HMM model. This multi-task
approach emerges as a promising strategy for Irish low-resource ASR and DID.
|
[
-0.46428585052490234,
-0.4639272689819336,
0.19834120571613312,
-0.08042236417531967,
-0.15408547222614288,
0.3192453682422638,
-0.4382992088794708,
-0.5095505118370056,
0.48571348190307617,
0.5443793535232544,
-0.40058276057243347,
-0.20110565423965454,
-0.5199226140975952,
0.38558992743492126,
-0.1551145613193512,
0.6867169737815857,
0.09507309645414352,
0.32587701082229614,
0.36502504348754883,
-0.37293851375579834,
-0.34641793370246887,
-0.4857496917247772,
-0.8385933041572571,
-0.24423420429229736,
0.5238083600997925,
0.6502044200897217,
0.12824894487857819,
0.5128770470619202,
0.4937099814414978,
0.3469233512878418,
-0.30375006794929504,
0.29547688364982605,
-0.40430396795272827,
-0.28362900018692017,
-0.06488680094480515,
-0.2924330532550812,
-0.33789506554603577,
-0.07597379386425018,
0.5380252599716187,
0.6322495341300964,
-0.13053491711616516,
0.3340514600276947,
0.3072670102119446,
0.43121176958084106,
-0.901206910610199,
0.21248096227645874,
-1.0185893774032593,
-0.11316866427659988,
-0.5442718267440796,
-0.034350864589214325,
-0.2453450709581375,
0.2136216163635254,
0.11070239543914795,
-0.4642275869846344,
0.3738013505935669,
0.08420944213867188,
0.4848141074180603,
0.08042258769273758,
-0.45771461725234985,
-0.3177889883518219,
-0.6859604120254517,
0.8449618816375732,
-0.6497043967247009,
0.6203377842903137,
0.4544345736503601,
0.16564646363258362,
0.09190480411052704,
-0.2191399335861206,
-0.8395302295684814,
-0.35310831665992737,
-0.019953325390815735,
0.3222616910934448,
-0.0005277001764625311,
0.36265355348587036,
0.18297776579856873,
0.5402071475982666,
-0.4610534906387329,
0.28678348660469055,
-0.9193187952041626,
-0.29658931493759155,
0.40896326303482056,
0.1748717576265335,
-0.012667177245020866,
-0.09583158791065216,
-0.3084987699985504,
0.09175993502140045,
-0.41673344373703003,
0.26288726925849915,
0.3145107328891754,
0.9293506145477295,
-0.30747732520103455,
0.7282248139381409,
-0.4425296187400818,
0.6334570646286011,
0.4855937361717224,
-0.5131819248199463,
0.12306083738803864,
-0.6089837551116943,
-0.18555136024951935,
0.5074114799499512,
0.6795676946640015,
-0.23261292278766632,
0.04517463967204094,
-0.049620769917964935,
-0.3339346647262573,
0.3503795266151428,
0.1326155960559845,
-0.22764772176742554,
-0.0054863919503986835,
0.035610735416412354,
-0.5075545907020569,
0.24956052005290985,
-0.08285436779260635,
-0.5690145492553711,
0.0996684581041336,
-0.6144453287124634,
0.5925812125205994,
-0.30921751260757446,
-0.34839752316474915,
0.1546754390001297,
-0.04205333814024925,
0.21950243413448334,
0.32530272006988525,
-0.8260033130645752,
0.568325936794281,
0.4284234046936035,
0.9391559958457947,
-0.18757620453834534,
-0.19818122684955597,
-0.8224520087242126,
0.1461654156446457,
0.010339097119867802,
0.34250473976135254,
-0.3810073137283325,
-0.3098507523536682,
-0.168718159198761,
0.2225216180086136,
-0.38047754764556885,
-0.8648159503936768,
0.32447054982185364,
-0.4159921407699585,
-0.11197695881128311,
0.008835452608764172,
0.09280326962471008,
-0.2008058726787567,
0.08951818943023682,
-0.9916322827339172,
0.9759315252304077,
0.1404123157262802,
-0.7756970524787903,
0.1338888555765152,
-0.8426982760429382,
-0.42128312587738037,
0.09641638398170471,
0.21617330610752106,
-0.06902869045734406,
0.1215004101395607,
0.15507915616035461,
0.6466207504272461,
-0.6484379768371582,
0.028010614216327667,
-0.21128565073013306,
-0.17930090427398682,
-0.12508244812488556,
-0.45091012120246887,
1.0435752868652344,
0.5985791087150574,
-0.32538965344429016,
-0.1908164769411087,
-0.9929302930831909,
-0.008576233871281147,
-0.2214408814907074,
-0.5658350586891174,
-0.2551749050617218,
-0.4622320234775543,
0.4044506251811981,
0.22231607139110565,
0.2267846167087555,
-1.003326654434204,
-0.45322149991989136,
-0.2813440263271332,
0.6142035722732544,
0.1716318577528,
-0.44835349917411804,
0.4593271017074585,
-0.35516995191574097,
0.26937195658683777,
0.5065117478370667,
-0.14230993390083313,
0.14866718649864197,
-0.41499486565589905,
-0.9322696924209595,
-0.47802501916885376,
0.4580785036087036,
0.9466846585273743,
-0.8491066098213196,
0.4481257498264313,
-0.03302597999572754,
-0.4202921688556671,
-0.8599537014961243,
0.15918859839439392,
0.7204890251159668,
0.5867175459861755,
0.44450676441192627,
-0.698947548866272,
-0.5331007838249207,
-0.935390293598175,
-0.009940817952156067,
-0.4643901288509369,
0.02546382136642933,
0.29886892437934875,
0.39610037207603455,
-0.30215612053871155,
0.6851639151573181,
0.15138976275920868,
-0.4829486608505249,
-0.48302382230758667,
0.12461341172456741,
0.19070936739444733,
0.5087918639183044,
0.20914089679718018,
-0.8026469945907593,
-0.47241973876953125,
0.4505041241645813,
-0.15136200189590454,
-0.08504240214824677,
0.15740692615509033,
0.21962757408618927,
0.013321008533239365,
0.11896561086177826,
-0.2391517013311386,
0.3429071307182312,
0.5268608927726746,
0.23291641473770142,
0.4147196114063263,
-0.03884853050112724,
0.4643646776676178,
-0.9876658320426941,
-0.1519709974527359,
0.3101220428943634,
-0.12208396196365356,
-0.8923867344856262,
-0.05294295400381088,
0.004737097304314375,
-0.40880879759788513,
-0.7043560743331909,
0.5461625456809998,
-0.5856683850288391,
0.062134046107530594,
0.19722920656204224,
-0.15050256252288818,
-0.08055387437343597,
0.4333748519420624,
0.38581714034080505,
0.9339178800582886,
0.31720566749572754,
-0.3973672091960907,
0.3256970942020416,
0.06991458684206009,
-0.3306013345718384,
0.5489800572395325,
-0.3936833441257477,
0.3313683271408081,
0.06124142184853554,
-0.05342033877968788,
-0.9721100330352783,
-0.29543185234069824,
-0.14079052209854126,
-0.1482371687889099,
0.3115691542625427,
-0.19423113763332367,
-0.22350583970546722,
-0.36353495717048645,
0.11991418898105621,
0.7262361645698547,
0.30368146300315857,
-0.6000627875328064,
0.8002292513847351,
0.5431272387504578,
-0.2299979031085968,
-0.44613462686538696,
-0.9254310727119446,
-0.03885655477643013,
-0.5672136545181274,
-0.6044244170188904,
0.47288185358047485,
0.17595025897026062,
-0.41184964776039124,
-0.26992785930633545,
0.1811874657869339,
-0.7920408248901367,
-0.3349114954471588,
0.0745803639292717,
-0.06204868480563164,
-0.5737135410308838,
-0.18338948488235474,
-0.23443008959293365,
-0.01272211130708456,
-0.5730457901954651,
-0.19212675094604492,
0.22601720690727234,
-0.13132363557815552,
-0.2881993055343628,
-0.8613141775131226,
0.8764848709106445,
0.5938556790351868,
-0.3918089270591736,
0.5090852379798889,
0.6330140233039856,
-0.38282260298728943,
-0.050290126353502274,
-1.1851757764816284,
-0.137549489736557,
-0.4377692937850952,
0.3233940303325653,
-0.6359063982963562,
-1.093091607093811,
0.7664715647697449,
-0.2938348948955536,
-0.31444475054740906,
0.354984313249588,
0.6466445326805115,
-0.026968689635396004,
0.3001970052719116,
0.7007416486740112,
-0.19278936088085175,
0.6212174892425537,
-0.2524069547653198,
0.07180621474981308,
-0.9750655293464661,
-0.023420119658112526,
-0.6774051785469055,
-0.2595730423927307,
-0.5459619164466858,
-0.36840760707855225,
0.6737926602363586,
0.06362029910087585,
-0.12279069423675537,
0.7228971123695374,
-0.39607158303260803,
0.32965847849845886,
0.8698171973228455,
0.2789839506149292,
0.09972009062767029,
-0.1891711801290512,
-0.1693791002035141,
0.2611643970012665,
-0.9244835376739502,
-0.462804913520813,
0.9127771854400635,
0.11920293420553207,
0.7641710638999939,
0.10262034088373184,
0.8830329179763794,
0.08633106201887131,
-0.4226798415184021,
-0.6162777543067932,
0.3383537530899048,
-0.4873402714729309,
-0.6414693593978882,
-0.45571041107177734,
-0.3787703514099121,
-0.6179169416427612,
0.13106100261211395,
-0.12903636693954468,
-0.7531979084014893,
0.5665675401687622,
0.3448566496372223,
-0.8393279314041138,
0.3864915072917938,
-1.0768773555755615,
0.7179160714149475,
-0.19016826152801514,
-0.20214881002902985,
-0.23031021654605865,
-0.6592661142349243,
0.3176761865615845,
-0.2218468338251114,
0.17358621954917908,
0.053253691643476486,
0.28329265117645264,
0.6880581378936768,
-0.295274555683136,
0.8875552415847778,
-0.09895942360162735,
0.2605142593383789,
0.517930805683136,
-0.26276737451553345,
0.5725334882736206,
-0.07417263090610504,
-0.4526594281196594,
0.5531163811683655,
0.24392907321453094,
-0.21842557191848755,
-0.18031330406665802,
0.47951042652130127,
-0.8789600133895874,
-0.603724479675293,
-0.017670318484306335,
-0.33093997836112976,
-0.20993874967098236,
-0.18704645335674286,
0.26355430483818054,
0.6958557963371277,
-0.09350070357322693,
0.35017603635787964,
0.544397234916687,
0.08363576233386993,
0.553701639175415,
0.48772042989730835,
0.8283722400665283,
-0.6955308318138123,
0.5892133712768555,
0.35017600655555725,
0.540465235710144,
0.4790281355381012,
-0.017294833436608315,
-0.08273216336965561,
-0.6835203170776367,
-0.4823070168495178,
0.07897200435400009,
-0.3328024744987488,
-0.2989298403263092,
-0.5883340239524841,
-0.5141047239303589,
-0.4289672076702118,
-0.16761478781700134,
-0.5084654688835144,
-0.32824695110321045,
-0.6522929072380066,
0.2816256582736969,
0.36443662643432617,
0.6388806700706482,
-0.23342487215995789,
0.7917999625205994,
-0.6983857750892639,
0.4055918753147125,
0.451483815908432,
-0.029618535190820694,
-0.05803950875997543,
-0.6227946877479553,
-0.4837684631347656,
0.03843311592936516,
0.0652279332280159,
-0.7475131750106812,
0.39360320568084717,
0.3678032159805298,
0.3727482557296753,
0.312833696603775,
0.18622063100337982,
0.9479556083679199,
-0.7594186663627625,
0.6962502598762512,
0.4771554470062256,
-0.9809883236885071,
0.2573751211166382,
0.01122661679983139,
0.2928208112716675,
0.8593130111694336,
0.15056179463863373,
-0.3485492765903473,
-0.238590270280838,
-0.21123060584068298,
-0.6219069957733154,
0.9699202179908752,
-0.01984155923128128,
-0.11222768574953079,
0.1061212345957756,
0.31576576828956604,
0.31168079376220703,
0.07293009012937546,
-0.5619990825653076,
0.19114477932453156,
-0.11208008229732513,
-0.4542853534221649,
-0.15025566518306732,
-0.29179131984710693,
-0.20136339962482452,
-0.1838379055261612,
0.4439178705215454,
-0.16800566017627716,
0.23176336288452148,
0.12611298263072968,
-0.1500386893749237,
-0.16857551038265228,
0.5314780473709106,
0.4425560235977173,
0.32882335782051086,
-0.0634332075715065,
0.24662812054157257,
0.6934690475463867,
-0.5526649951934814,
0.43923038244247437,
0.004057017154991627,
0.37428122758865356,
-0.10089427977800369,
0.5416662096977234,
0.9098120927810669,
0.12961743772029877,
-0.36535200476646423,
0.4221796989440918,
0.156032532453537,
-0.09435592591762543,
-0.39374014735221863,
0.23587918281555176,
-0.20191624760627747,
0.5282671451568604,
0.36782461404800415,
-0.016626637428998947,
0.24105523526668549,
-0.5048871636390686,
-0.01965009979903698,
0.5925691723823547,
-0.4755867123603821,
-0.47403764724731445,
0.5649732947349548,
0.43534332513809204,
-0.5184571146965027,
0.2989537715911865,
-0.06897720694541931,
-0.5716885328292847,
0.6788898706436157,
0.5030317306518555,
0.978538990020752,
-0.3683263063430786,
-0.08457418531179428,
0.23201757669448853,
0.2600518465042114,
-0.017794139683246613,
0.4070138931274414,
-0.44740113615989685,
-0.6989660263061523,
-0.3655606210231781,
-0.6702315807342529,
-0.19816231727600098,
0.27140846848487854,
-0.9309630990028381,
0.37043339014053345,
-0.1567770540714264,
-0.35884663462638855,
0.14421623945236206,
0.10856527090072632,
-1.043020248413086,
0.2634854316711426,
0.2080117017030716,
0.7479069828987122,
-0.9658743739128113,
1.103708267211914,
0.5304470062255859,
-0.056306105107069016,
-0.9580097794532776,
-0.05703001841902733,
0.404787540435791,
-0.6367909908294678,
1.0742135047912598,
-0.05706777423620224,
-0.544098973274231,
0.04747367650270462,
0.12513963878154755,
-0.9335612654685974,
1.0096659660339355,
0.34832558035850525,
-1.0368808507919312,
0.017320232465863228,
0.09684178233146667,
0.28516846895217896,
-0.4833989143371582,
0.41684699058532715,
0.5102507472038269,
0.2770920991897583,
0.14711639285087585,
-1.8268978595733643,
-0.5203365087509155,
-0.13734377920627594,
0.0538671538233757,
0.029047423973679543,
-0.9521675705909729,
0.9897914528846741,
-0.05277515575289726,
-0.30496975779533386,
0.045730940997600555,
0.30117690563201904,
0.21801789104938507,
0.3525083363056183,
0.7649937868118286,
0.5704159736633301,
0.438069224357605,
-0.08092497289180756,
0.49281471967697144,
-0.19172915816307068,
-0.04677172005176544,
0.9567827582359314,
-0.6139569282531738,
0.9378589987754822,
0.5350520014762878,
-0.27132439613342285,
0.058665379881858826,
0.6336182951927185,
0.5340377688407898,
0.944580078125,
0.0484595000743866,
-0.4321627914905548,
-0.1567145586013794,
-0.25293344259262085,
-0.1889171451330185,
0.9658520817756653,
0.3445645272731781,
0.0024181692861020565,
-0.02371535636484623,
0.37018120288848877,
-0.41268646717071533,
-0.22977730631828308,
-0.67459636926651,
1.224374771118164,
0.004429720342159271,
-0.15780997276306152,
0.6637514233589172,
-0.08915036916732788,
0.9165276885032654,
-0.6097024083137512,
-0.07210565358400345,
0.0071031032130122185,
0.12160834670066833,
-0.004267528653144836,
-0.2971928119659424,
0.1424265205860138,
-0.032427579164505005,
-0.5156917572021484,
-0.008331610821187496,
0.4794676601886749,
-0.9379288554191589,
-0.5319038033485413,
0.5651171207427979,
0.464573472738266,
0.13705316185951233,
0.27920717000961304,
-0.4349933862686157,
0.13392721116542816,
-0.02801497094333172,
0.33525729179382324,
0.2238355576992035,
0.748063325881958,
0.027223113924264908,
0.178553968667984,
0.5415693521499634,
0.5549533367156982,
0.30205416679382324,
-0.11004257202148438,
0.8096538782119751,
-0.5223113298416138,
-0.6581212878227234,
-0.5147591233253479,
0.4780491888523102,
0.23606133460998535,
-0.34361881017684937,
0.3394961655139923,
0.44276171922683716,
1.1796953678131104,
-0.21657009422779083,
0.6820501089096069,
0.08773787319660187,
0.8615602254867554,
-0.7372180819511414,
0.4592185616493225,
-0.5944507122039795,
-0.07131540775299072,
-0.2292829006910324,
-0.7557932734489441,
-0.05382595583796501,
0.4313194453716278,
-0.11863935738801956,
-0.15339240431785583,
0.5998214483261108,
1.0976327657699585,
-0.48252373933792114,
0.00344993663020432,
0.5069121718406677,
-0.14398154616355896,
-0.2967302203178406,
0.7047843337059021,
0.841701328754425,
-0.0651831105351448,
0.24309109151363373,
-0.38290169835090637,
-0.20288600027561188,
-0.1385539323091507,
-0.4043154716491699,
-0.8476257920265198,
-0.9134598970413208,
-0.15298008918762207,
0.02688884548842907,
0.16625361144542694,
1.2528325319290161,
1.0154047012329102,
-1.320117473602295,
-0.6620227098464966,
0.4890058636665344,
-0.3858417570590973,
-0.29931405186653137,
-0.14468257129192352,
0.2848532795906067,
-0.1274717152118683,
-0.7521452307701111,
0.6805316209793091,
0.505694568157196,
-0.018863501027226448,
-0.22594250738620758,
0.030132003128528595,
-0.3866725265979767,
-0.15650077164173126,
0.4567839503288269,
0.2536114454269409,
-1.328429937362671,
-0.38728198409080505,
-0.2743995189666748,
0.10827767848968506,
0.22759483754634857,
0.9276211261749268,
-0.6734861135482788,
0.6412386894226074,
0.20012858510017395,
0.7724485993385315,
0.3857607841491699,
-0.07016808539628983,
0.3640660047531128,
-0.6483062505722046,
0.6589027643203735,
0.3357732594013214,
0.48901045322418213,
0.28839877247810364,
-0.4341205656528473,
0.42610785365104675,
0.06026916950941086,
-0.27352121472358704,
-0.8111212253570557,
-0.024850687012076378,
-1.0084565877914429,
0.35029399394989014,
0.99205482006073,
-0.1528283953666687,
-0.2759582996368408,
-0.5977431535720825,
-0.14760683476924896,
0.280931681394577,
-0.5143997669219971,
0.48873820900917053,
0.5982913374900818,
-0.18965697288513184,
-0.2423233836889267,
-0.6349298357963562,
0.2591855823993683,
0.06659448146820068,
-0.4821843206882477,
-0.017683258280158043,
0.18137849867343903,
0.03940577432513237,
0.3969554007053375,
0.560962975025177,
0.11597312986850739,
0.07487528026103973,
0.016376743093132973,
-0.06624051183462143,
0.059478484094142914,
-0.5730859041213989,
-0.5071989297866821,
0.27120906114578247,
-0.2632472813129425,
-0.4235686957836151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01280v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01280v2
|
Reinforcement Learning for Edit-Based Non-Autoregressive Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-05-02T13:39:28 | 2024-07-02T13:41:56 |
Hao Wang, Tetsuro Morimura, Ukyo Honda, Daisuke Kawahara
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Non-autoregressive (NAR) language models are known for their low latency in
neural machine translation (NMT). However, a performance gap exists between NAR
and autoregressive models due to the large decoding space and difficulty in
capturing dependency between target words accurately. Compounding this,
preparing appropriate training data for NAR models is a non-trivial task, often
exacerbating exposure bias. To address these challenges, we apply reinforcement
learning (RL) to Levenshtein Transformer, a representative edit-based NAR
model, demonstrating that RL with self-generated data can enhance the
performance of edit-based NAR models. We explore two RL approaches: stepwise
reward maximization and episodic reward maximization. We discuss the respective
pros and cons of these two approaches and empirically verify them. Moreover, we
experimentally investigate the impact of temperature setting on performance,
confirming the importance of proper temperature setting for NAR models'
training.
|
[
-0.18492965400218964,
-0.6562771797180176,
0.25329717993736267,
0.22932711243629456,
-0.021998489275574684,
0.0450814887881279,
-0.30694133043289185,
-0.230690598487854,
0.13206183910369873,
0.35600554943084717,
-0.3235642910003662,
-0.08087538182735443,
-0.55873703956604,
0.31533747911453247,
-0.12050335854291916,
1.1995933055877686,
-0.3374107778072357,
-0.02184213325381279,
-0.07674454152584076,
-0.17439872026443481,
-0.430976539850235,
-0.3960126042366028,
-0.8622356653213501,
-0.5156731605529785,
0.6336000561714172,
0.32918500900268555,
0.6908020377159119,
1.002600908279419,
0.18115019798278809,
0.355506956577301,
-0.0926651880145073,
0.10005812346935272,
-0.27212458848953247,
0.5151772499084473,
-0.3376345634460449,
-0.400603711605072,
-0.4480951726436615,
-0.1644962579011917,
0.4496249556541443,
0.12990599870681763,
-0.44293078780174255,
-0.09754496812820435,
-0.3251439034938812,
0.7923262715339661,
-0.4647006392478943,
0.0037683069240301847,
-0.3593680262565613,
0.4101272225379944,
0.11124471575021744,
-0.3368113338947296,
-0.409700870513916,
-0.31551334261894226,
0.06918716430664062,
-0.5141695737838745,
0.38158202171325684,
0.09432883560657501,
0.5225117206573486,
0.658670961856842,
-0.4636317789554596,
-0.13525459170341492,
-0.7381486296653748,
0.6362489461898804,
-0.8173165321350098,
0.6619777679443359,
0.22568389773368835,
0.13155719637870789,
-0.1195969358086586,
-0.4777398705482483,
-0.49931368231773376,
-0.30054157972335815,
-0.07276495546102524,
0.11547093838453293,
-0.005661841481924057,
0.08751621842384338,
0.31326767802238464,
0.45052215456962585,
-0.7281400561332703,
0.37051892280578613,
-0.2509699761867523,
-0.1419622004032135,
0.700631320476532,
0.3669992983341217,
0.2303071767091751,
-0.21574175357818604,
-0.35567331314086914,
-0.3238987326622009,
-0.29986074566841125,
0.13374380767345428,
0.33571258187294006,
0.32412204146385193,
0.08934902399778366,
0.5251043438911438,
-0.2910008430480957,
0.5249508023262024,
0.5452966094017029,
0.13893583416938782,
0.32308706641197205,
-0.025989564135670662,
-0.09444789588451385,
0.2225155085325241,
0.7870182991027832,
0.16286170482635498,
-0.0831134095788002,
-0.31399762630462646,
-0.821580171585083,
-0.4001634120941162,
0.5278646349906921,
-0.690963089466095,
-0.5834408402442932,
0.11740748584270477,
-0.3216654062271118,
-0.48467108607292175,
-0.3834855556488037,
-0.7882614731788635,
-0.1978258639574051,
-0.17366638779640198,
0.5453194975852966,
-0.24324405193328857,
-0.3194437623023987,
-0.1423339992761612,
-0.12621653079986572,
0.03047511912882328,
0.2409367710351944,
-1.0852266550064087,
0.35324782133102417,
0.004553772509098053,
0.8271201252937317,
-0.3730649948120117,
-0.3778744339942932,
-0.6446120142936707,
-0.06784307211637497,
-0.5313003659248352,
0.6413244605064392,
-0.2739146947860718,
-0.3693748414516449,
-0.3055282235145569,
-0.08552747964859009,
-0.25576213002204895,
-0.5052134990692139,
0.14126479625701904,
-1.0086369514465332,
0.22418570518493652,
0.10887368023395538,
-0.6617466807365417,
0.0031754360534250736,
0.20570431649684906,
-0.8679162859916687,
1.0926026105880737,
0.16010724008083344,
-0.4637507498264313,
0.1455884575843811,
-1.027557373046875,
-0.6775087118148804,
-0.3022990822792053,
0.2320249080657959,
-0.6512951850891113,
0.2362780123949051,
0.3997349739074707,
0.1320212334394455,
0.22266748547554016,
0.31915444135665894,
0.29457584023475647,
0.09180691093206406,
0.42318984866142273,
-0.5477321743965149,
0.037492092698812485,
0.22547659277915955,
-0.5569978356361389,
0.35042187571525574,
-0.5967215895652771,
0.20685595273971558,
0.22160553932189941,
-0.752629280090332,
-0.07809223234653473,
-0.10856588929891586,
0.22135813534259796,
0.6665899157524109,
0.17191381752490997,
-0.44374799728393555,
0.310997873544693,
-0.5643029808998108,
0.28489962220191956,
0.875881016254425,
0.2263839840888977,
0.6039760708808899,
-0.24013079702854156,
0.6980372071266174,
0.31964051723480225,
0.15452414751052856,
0.07469693571329117,
-0.10606837272644043,
-0.9559581279754639,
0.2379690408706665,
0.6130600571632385,
0.7225894927978516,
-1.1294572353363037,
0.06644865870475769,
0.026016931980848312,
-0.4961056709289551,
-0.428666353225708,
0.07223803550004959,
0.6991620063781738,
0.5656534433364868,
0.8190861344337463,
-0.3007580637931824,
-0.3449818193912506,
-0.9404867887496948,
-0.3487255275249481,
0.08951212465763092,
0.08523226529359818,
0.22842980921268463,
0.4519093632698059,
0.12404944002628326,
0.6229037642478943,
-0.25744369626045227,
0.02052389085292816,
-0.3588109612464905,
0.3655295670032501,
0.12198913842439651,
0.6000266075134277,
-0.024372298270463943,
-0.6508590579032898,
-0.6041345000267029,
0.010079383850097656,
-0.4621296226978302,
-0.05077395960688591,
-0.36347177624702454,
0.12729434669017792,
0.6093981862068176,
0.6055353283882141,
-0.20219239592552185,
0.4987976551055908,
0.6266311407089233,
-0.26382410526275635,
0.37546268105506897,
-0.6409826874732971,
0.23211435973644257,
-0.7184767127037048,
0.04483136534690857,
0.07890364527702332,
-0.6172252297401428,
-0.811618983745575,
-0.3784703016281128,
0.12783417105674744,
0.09415697306394577,
-0.5373465418815613,
0.5367990136146545,
-0.37579143047332764,
-0.09657978266477585,
-0.5169171094894409,
-0.15932446718215942,
-0.088039830327034,
0.7663890719413757,
0.534403920173645,
0.8980473279953003,
0.021058829501271248,
-0.7156763672828674,
0.2010885328054428,
0.4280255138874054,
-0.14936359226703644,
0.3180830180644989,
-0.8698568940162659,
0.24770060181617737,
0.04157781973481178,
0.15234336256980896,
-0.4064740836620331,
0.06467746198177338,
0.23081600666046143,
-0.4518188536167145,
0.5384852886199951,
-0.004200381226837635,
-0.3933338522911072,
0.15223558247089386,
0.09957683086395264,
0.36050114035606384,
0.48367777466773987,
-0.5255585312843323,
0.36716797947883606,
0.19705228507518768,
-0.16095200181007385,
-0.4954169690608978,
-0.7746269702911377,
0.08151494711637497,
-0.06855320930480957,
-0.008526184596121311,
0.4847685992717743,
-0.010769476182758808,
0.21809935569763184,
0.12368229776620865,
-0.13994896411895752,
-0.06295514851808548,
-0.015348306857049465,
0.015308703295886517,
0.05191395431756973,
-0.19844377040863037,
0.21228741109371185,
0.011169133707880974,
-0.4484841823577881,
-0.1506606638431549,
-0.22641907632350922,
0.28507792949676514,
-0.16196121275424957,
-0.16855238378047943,
-0.3965512812137604,
0.08468162268400192,
0.29031622409820557,
-0.2423413097858429,
0.8010613322257996,
0.4263143539428711,
0.01707717590034008,
-0.3725651204586029,
-0.3525617718696594,
-0.27592799067497253,
-0.4226594567298889,
0.334469199180603,
-0.1908634454011917,
-0.6000200510025024,
0.21804341673851013,
0.010775432921946049,
0.030524209141731262,
0.46561741828918457,
0.5494877099990845,
0.129108726978302,
0.9707412123680115,
0.6307109594345093,
0.096641905605793,
0.738004744052887,
-0.1341056376695633,
0.043951742351055145,
-1.0752100944519043,
-0.24688886106014252,
0.039799243211746216,
-0.5630034804344177,
-0.6515423059463501,
-0.4055352807044983,
0.4405595660209656,
-0.12046955525875092,
-0.22554782032966614,
0.38422781229019165,
-0.40850144624710083,
0.5378574132919312,
0.6643056273460388,
0.07514042407274246,
0.2773407995700836,
-0.32467120885849,
-0.3118427097797394,
-0.13462693989276886,
-1.1462604999542236,
-0.15110105276107788,
0.9145362377166748,
0.22316370904445648,
0.6621993184089661,
0.005393641069531441,
0.555410623550415,
0.39307624101638794,
0.1373007893562317,
-0.45478254556655884,
0.13213703036308289,
0.18821656703948975,
-0.5040618181228638,
-0.6629964113235474,
-0.4845724105834961,
-0.8537374138832092,
0.33453044295310974,
-0.13859617710113525,
-0.26468393206596375,
0.3891640305519104,
0.38742202520370483,
-0.16746988892555237,
0.5404294729232788,
-0.35286158323287964,
1.0311243534088135,
-0.5520095825195312,
-0.4691263735294342,
-0.09142809361219406,
-0.7745189070701599,
0.10469114035367966,
0.005222389008849859,
0.09928740561008453,
0.31946948170661926,
-0.26892992854118347,
0.5540998578071594,
-0.46554356813430786,
0.5658684372901917,
-0.3345043659210205,
0.17687352001667023,
-0.1843157410621643,
0.3342856466770172,
0.8112711310386658,
0.05856446176767349,
-0.10472293943166733,
0.01398525107651949,
-0.22781269252300262,
-0.23475290834903717,
-0.6733120083808899,
0.5101527571678162,
-0.7948920130729675,
-0.18897299468517303,
-0.6789875030517578,
-0.7288786172866821,
-0.3956242501735687,
-0.05643922835588455,
0.3058060109615326,
0.14554685354232788,
-0.19291061162948608,
-0.1412745714187622,
0.9683167338371277,
-0.43722912669181824,
0.4751987159252167,
0.6333492398262024,
-0.3341137170791626,
-0.6818539500236511,
0.9858150482177734,
0.015375129878520966,
0.4895066022872925,
0.3877706825733185,
0.15603843331336975,
-0.3231341540813446,
-0.5719353556632996,
-0.7224323153495789,
-0.05276802182197571,
-0.5677017569541931,
-0.2155478149652481,
-0.6823729872703552,
-0.44792839884757996,
-0.07308787107467651,
-0.22277674078941345,
-0.6348591446876526,
-0.503696084022522,
-0.1398206204175949,
-0.12996461987495422,
0.5997087359428406,
0.8310007452964783,
-0.6363565921783447,
0.20007933676242828,
-0.6377497315406799,
0.4031980037689209,
0.21520407497882843,
0.42724478244781494,
0.04778413847088814,
-0.664121687412262,
-0.6139764189720154,
-0.12965233623981476,
-0.30402588844299316,
-0.786271333694458,
0.8306663036346436,
0.254678875207901,
0.5237719416618347,
-0.1331847757101059,
0.043107856065034866,
0.34031417965888977,
-0.711031973361969,
0.6530846357345581,
0.11492601782083511,
-0.9241817593574524,
0.587126612663269,
-0.18015156686306,
0.4841706156730652,
0.4712570607662201,
0.2263791412115097,
-0.942232608795166,
-0.4005725085735321,
-0.754203736782074,
-0.8796982169151306,
0.74654620885849,
0.15868856012821198,
-0.0176169965416193,
-0.12367907911539078,
0.22891220450401306,
0.0029662593733519316,
0.31886449456214905,
-0.707331657409668,
-0.3405865728855133,
-0.5260925889015198,
0.10392690449953079,
-0.3134695887565613,
0.07037724554538727,
0.37504902482032776,
-0.21027196943759918,
1.0288208723068237,
-0.017807042226195335,
0.22863075137138367,
0.6579811573028564,
-0.48391416668891907,
-0.39895370602607727,
0.2671692967414856,
0.7426325678825378,
0.3472696840763092,
0.040217719972133636,
-0.16980238258838654,
0.4877358376979828,
-0.019037744030356407,
0.2872571349143982,
-0.27940860390663147,
-0.2227407991886139,
0.05100811645388603,
0.08709882944822311,
1.1455600261688232,
0.47093236446380615,
-0.41859421133995056,
0.34755027294158936,
-0.15265104174613953,
-0.3353727161884308,
-0.06566356122493744,
0.02110619843006134,
0.08948179334402084,
0.4711504876613617,
-0.05989386513829231,
0.2282131016254425,
0.004186918027698994,
-0.01027302723377943,
0.306167870759964,
0.04880687966942787,
-0.543237030506134,
-0.2988691031932831,
0.6515913009643555,
-0.09374253451824188,
-0.43893542885780334,
0.9651569128036499,
-0.09162218868732452,
-0.7023733258247375,
0.5823186635971069,
0.6516076922416687,
0.8017441034317017,
-0.564539909362793,
0.3173324465751648,
0.40224581956863403,
0.3934353291988373,
-0.047588106244802475,
0.20130792260169983,
-0.02239726483821869,
-0.4312693178653717,
-0.42166218161582947,
-0.5746800899505615,
-0.5437850952148438,
0.04852650687098503,
-0.7561492323875427,
-0.030381135642528534,
-0.48711758852005005,
0.02666938118636608,
-0.21896259486675262,
-0.37267377972602844,
-0.6532944440841675,
0.2408819943666458,
-0.1454538255929947,
0.6650745272636414,
-0.8312839269638062,
0.9043170213699341,
0.45225366950035095,
-0.5303109288215637,
-0.7229624390602112,
-0.10925231128931046,
-0.15719375014305115,
-0.5646823644638062,
0.8422201871871948,
-0.34335383772850037,
0.09551319479942322,
0.15221285820007324,
-0.174054816365242,
-0.9350989460945129,
0.8558781743049622,
0.011511193588376045,
-0.4361055791378021,
-0.0713682770729065,
0.004306727554649115,
0.7628881931304932,
-0.09402588754892349,
0.13225826621055603,
0.2468840628862381,
0.4898116886615753,
0.03539247810840607,
-1.0034844875335693,
-0.11325851082801819,
-0.25355687737464905,
0.21631337702274323,
0.48316431045532227,
-0.5186943411827087,
0.8176501989364624,
-0.13115932047367096,
-0.005671534687280655,
-0.22261305153369904,
0.6942963600158691,
-0.18226021528244019,
0.15501369535923004,
0.4469282031059265,
0.6496357917785645,
0.5457448363304138,
0.32142624258995056,
1.0366010665893555,
-0.26314404606819153,
0.2691413462162018,
1.1462699174880981,
0.019208256155252457,
0.9961517453193665,
0.6135802268981934,
0.01820003241300583,
0.5053890943527222,
0.6531462073326111,
-0.03847510367631912,
0.8008873462677002,
0.2647252380847931,
-0.12432615458965302,
-0.2199903279542923,
0.020744478330016136,
-0.19242849946022034,
0.12102127820253372,
0.20012730360031128,
-0.4509970545768738,
-0.2750528156757355,
0.2389296293258667,
-0.1330377757549286,
0.0965665653347969,
-0.21703468263149261,
1.1552480459213257,
0.05061539635062218,
-0.6082396507263184,
0.40918564796447754,
0.2319701761007309,
0.606307327747345,
-0.4108543395996094,
0.022739160805940628,
-0.22508299350738525,
-0.0076749431900680065,
-0.14164477586746216,
-0.5663387179374695,
0.4656877815723419,
0.0663975179195404,
-0.39645642042160034,
-0.5223889946937561,
0.438557893037796,
-0.5954667329788208,
-0.29285407066345215,
-0.0016699599800631404,
0.6578426957130432,
0.08143439143896103,
0.18773269653320312,
-0.9649010896682739,
-0.3937591314315796,
-0.261493057012558,
-0.7278583645820618,
0.5199307203292847,
0.3503955602645874,
0.09952172636985779,
0.5205414295196533,
0.7561587691307068,
0.2624357342720032,
0.2090204805135727,
-0.442352831363678,
0.6523454785346985,
-0.7604111433029175,
-0.5320578217506409,
-0.7824351787567139,
0.4958771765232086,
0.07684770971536636,
-0.3805122673511505,
0.6257217526435852,
0.6164842844009399,
0.7656576633453369,
-0.16323357820510864,
0.6879919171333313,
0.0825958102941513,
0.32098305225372314,
-0.7535030245780945,
0.6168579459190369,
-0.49544015526771545,
-0.12091183662414551,
0.1513100415468216,
-0.7224795818328857,
-0.18476444482803345,
0.630027711391449,
-0.584697425365448,
0.07452280074357986,
0.8898364305496216,
0.7747268676757812,
-0.02831924334168434,
-0.23717179894447327,
0.4675656259059906,
0.02993757836520672,
0.18522191047668457,
0.6910597681999207,
0.7791566848754883,
-0.5022943615913391,
0.31950896978378296,
-0.36363929510116577,
0.1791357547044754,
-0.20643959939479828,
-0.9375707507133484,
-0.622556209564209,
-0.5260903239250183,
-0.37217360734939575,
-0.2926744222640991,
0.22257889807224274,
1.1400353908538818,
0.48549455404281616,
-0.805189847946167,
-0.1399412453174591,
-0.26216283440589905,
0.19502462446689606,
-0.3572794795036316,
-0.15040123462677002,
0.2757892608642578,
-0.6458451747894287,
-0.5407789945602417,
0.7857036590576172,
0.13814802467823029,
0.07707669585943222,
-0.14815500378608704,
-0.40167170763015747,
-0.2956576943397522,
0.22785478830337524,
0.22649794816970825,
0.6600032448768616,
-0.4658931493759155,
-0.009634163230657578,
0.009419754147529602,
-0.16156040132045746,
0.4353870749473572,
0.7386087775230408,
-0.7689533829689026,
0.4739016890525818,
0.4930046498775482,
0.8457926511764526,
0.6463731527328491,
-0.10804956406354904,
0.7054899334907532,
-0.631986141204834,
-0.25822913646698,
0.2815931737422943,
0.047360338270664215,
0.38441503047943115,
-0.43155646324157715,
0.2612575590610504,
-0.07660294324159622,
-1.0649821758270264,
-0.5597493052482605,
0.15503519773483276,
-0.43358492851257324,
-0.11317230015993118,
0.941390872001648,
-0.007938760332763195,
-0.3059019148349762,
-0.029257144778966904,
0.09856321662664413,
0.4801577627658844,
-0.4692689776420593,
0.8277652263641357,
0.49128636717796326,
-0.37760692834854126,
-0.24477210640907288,
-0.9097773432731628,
0.6736031174659729,
0.47586461901664734,
-0.7251539826393127,
-0.05735187977552414,
0.46497395634651184,
0.4657193124294281,
-0.2824020981788635,
0.37925609946250916,
0.012817898765206337,
0.40389832854270935,
-0.18638212978839874,
0.28984251618385315,
-0.42755213379859924,
-0.3462831676006317,
-0.911873459815979,
-0.1623445749282837,
0.29340505599975586,
-0.06499648094177246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01259v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01259v1
|
Identification of Entailment and Contradiction Relations between Natural Language Sentences: A Neurosymbolic Approach
| 2024-05-02T13:06:24 | 2024-05-02T13:06:24 |
Xuyao Feng, Anthony Hunter
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2
|
Natural language inference (NLI), also known as Recognizing Textual
Entailment (RTE), is an important aspect of natural language understanding.
Most research now uses machine learning and deep learning to perform this task
on specific datasets, meaning their solution is not explainable nor explicit.
To address the need for an explainable approach to RTE, we propose a novel
pipeline that is based on translating text into an Abstract Meaning
Representation (AMR) graph. For this we use a pre-trained AMR parser. We then
translate the AMR graph into propositional logic and use a SAT solver for
automated reasoning. In text, often commonsense suggests that an entailment (or
contradiction) relationship holds between a premise and a claim, but because
different wordings are used, this is not identified from their logical
representations. To address this, we introduce relaxation methods to allow
replacement or forgetting of some propositions. Our experimental results show
this pipeline performs well on four RTE datasets.
|
[
-0.367003470659256,
-1.1573749780654907,
0.5422947406768799,
0.08574166148900986,
-0.23302151262760162,
-0.03935183957219124,
-0.10537660866975784,
-0.39859190583229065,
0.336855411529541,
0.6159470677375793,
-0.71809321641922,
-0.2845596373081207,
-0.6191848516464233,
0.5649376511573792,
-0.345341295003891,
0.8270103335380554,
-0.39048320055007935,
-0.32596954703330994,
-0.40534552931785583,
-0.1734355390071869,
-0.43034011125564575,
-0.2699583172798157,
-0.6295492053031921,
-0.7517862915992737,
0.17751267552375793,
-0.027055587619543076,
0.7522584199905396,
0.7651290893554688,
0.2688682973384857,
0.4440649151802063,
-0.049771666526794434,
0.37043166160583496,
-0.024483194574713707,
0.09995851665735245,
-0.17804765701293945,
-0.5352949500083923,
-0.08644881099462509,
-0.10370264202356339,
0.47292956709861755,
0.8586962819099426,
0.03252759203314781,
-0.2284013330936432,
-0.07034189999103546,
0.7415675520896912,
-0.9066593050956726,
0.08618979156017303,
-0.5332590341567993,
0.22972558438777924,
0.0027611139230430126,
-0.43325182795524597,
-0.5092601776123047,
-0.49683284759521484,
0.3630734980106354,
-0.8389191031455994,
0.2460242211818695,
0.1234370544552803,
1.245132565498352,
0.5514646768569946,
-0.7153511643409729,
-0.7311238050460815,
-0.4951956272125244,
0.7074031829833984,
-0.8655328154563904,
0.24794559180736542,
0.38155531883239746,
0.22653815150260925,
-0.16810575127601624,
-0.6528609395027161,
-0.9604583978652954,
-0.043189942836761475,
-0.44023948907852173,
0.24405281245708466,
-0.2671475112438202,
0.061338745057582855,
0.03258805349469185,
0.49476486444473267,
-0.640022873878479,
0.0045789009891450405,
-0.2027331441640854,
-0.2775026261806488,
0.4530560076236725,
0.257264643907547,
0.42901158332824707,
-0.4450586140155792,
-0.4218766987323761,
0.2927630543708801,
-0.45578449964523315,
-0.10364271700382233,
0.45380285382270813,
0.05727152153849602,
-0.07904951274394989,
0.6805764436721802,
-0.11100469529628754,
0.9744037389755249,
-0.045019183307886124,
0.19932964444160461,
0.5016332864761353,
-0.22057582437992096,
-0.4522083103656769,
0.3444361686706543,
0.7870214581489563,
0.12169045954942703,
0.43694257736206055,
-0.2710144519805908,
-0.07550098747015,
0.5107436776161194,
0.1637268215417862,
-0.3692445755004883,
-0.1662493497133255,
0.31526869535446167,
-0.3263228237628937,
-0.04168401286005974,
-0.1048353835940361,
-0.5873994827270508,
-0.3558984696865082,
-0.7892822623252869,
0.3939785659313202,
-0.7637084722518921,
-0.2533571720123291,
0.4230523705482483,
-0.3021875321865082,
0.40221092104911804,
0.23793961107730865,
-0.6611089706420898,
0.611863911151886,
0.7209298014640808,
0.7693014740943909,
-0.10391383618116379,
-0.2790946364402771,
-0.3269982635974884,
0.349522203207016,
-0.19816358387470245,
0.7877477407455444,
-0.8084892630577087,
0.0870036706328392,
0.032082732766866684,
0.025991303846240044,
-0.3094993233680725,
-0.6168950796127319,
0.6217633485794067,
-0.35408347845077515,
0.4951722025871277,
0.09564745426177979,
-0.809208333492279,
-0.40528374910354614,
0.4997073709964752,
-0.6955570578575134,
0.7233410477638245,
-0.2571115493774414,
-1.0983721017837524,
0.022822001948952675,
-0.7039851546287537,
-0.5362657904624939,
-0.23898734152317047,
-0.10188084095716476,
-0.20739147067070007,
0.09743385761976242,
0.3606906831264496,
0.08859141170978546,
-0.16312845051288605,
0.25051724910736084,
-0.2035384625196457,
-0.24517254531383514,
0.3961920738220215,
-0.4935106933116913,
0.9808303117752075,
0.20656684041023254,
-0.07539153099060059,
-0.0007930674473755062,
-0.7718624472618103,
-0.13529112935066223,
-0.11013712733983994,
-0.15389735996723175,
-0.5717198252677917,
0.15083332359790802,
-0.11252564936876297,
0.12432163208723068,
0.08374331146478653,
-0.5933958292007446,
-0.1822982281446457,
-0.9245429039001465,
0.8406289219856262,
0.5913125872612,
0.1356828659772873,
0.4934927821159363,
-0.037471380084753036,
0.310213565826416,
0.29117652773857117,
-0.3228949010372162,
-0.30118200182914734,
-0.4503350853919983,
-0.9327813386917114,
-0.07749343663454056,
0.29019489884376526,
0.7592858672142029,
-0.7472859621047974,
0.48295944929122925,
-0.23554877936840057,
0.11614865809679031,
-0.763501763343811,
-0.0868220403790474,
0.46712708473205566,
0.7489341497421265,
0.4695737659931183,
0.09451235085725784,
-0.6944807767868042,
-1.0951026678085327,
-0.6326379179954529,
0.003733148565515876,
-0.25986647605895996,
0.08440689742565155,
0.650574266910553,
-0.1298353224992752,
1.0922284126281738,
-0.5546160340309143,
-0.36250805854797363,
-0.03947385028004646,
0.5033184289932251,
0.3112391531467438,
0.43266773223876953,
0.02173180691897869,
-0.8969685435295105,
-0.25486841797828674,
0.12846550345420837,
-1.017366886138916,
-0.12285506725311279,
-0.18763412535190582,
-0.14364013075828552,
0.2387627214193344,
0.61031574010849,
-0.6369601488113403,
0.5937265157699585,
0.11022821813821793,
-0.4397527277469635,
0.4061443507671356,
-0.253661185503006,
0.012341237626969814,
-0.9533806443214417,
-0.22179535031318665,
0.1728067547082901,
-0.05414672568440437,
-0.45704934000968933,
-0.0049886638298630714,
-0.2264329195022583,
-0.01818154752254486,
-0.2244601547718048,
0.3596729338169098,
-0.35698261857032776,
0.31994694471359253,
-0.18405066430568695,
0.3729711174964905,
0.19842955470085144,
0.37361884117126465,
0.04424695298075676,
0.4275040626525879,
0.45113879442214966,
-0.6743643879890442,
0.28313693404197693,
0.4415503442287445,
0.10741113871335983,
0.6336511969566345,
-0.6364051699638367,
0.10460931062698364,
-0.531018853187561,
0.3016494810581207,
-1.0241819620132446,
-0.3374066650867462,
0.4068939983844757,
-0.5471093058586121,
0.04618081822991371,
-0.12664160132408142,
-0.3287130892276764,
-0.12917372584342957,
0.07899420708417892,
0.2309301793575287,
0.2690235674381256,
-0.5197529196739197,
0.9853644371032715,
0.23697951436042786,
0.18436719477176666,
-0.6793296933174133,
-0.9989878535270691,
0.2427578866481781,
-0.37165239453315735,
-0.49791309237480164,
0.5125423669815063,
0.3285638689994812,
-0.46870967745780945,
0.4122489094734192,
-0.10748802870512009,
-0.5616069436073303,
-0.16796787083148956,
0.149615079164505,
0.05605804920196533,
-0.42731305956840515,
0.27150848507881165,
0.17019793391227722,
-0.44999960064888,
0.3415658473968506,
-0.3775542080402374,
0.18556128442287445,
-0.2851153314113617,
-0.18179747462272644,
-0.617965042591095,
0.6277514696121216,
0.269203245639801,
-0.25602179765701294,
0.6407545208930969,
0.4034906327724457,
-0.7114536166191101,
-0.17585508525371552,
-0.397937148809433,
-0.034814901649951935,
-0.4699675440788269,
-0.047255270183086395,
-0.5059944987297058,
-0.6562409996986389,
0.4409550130367279,
-0.15590251982212067,
-0.2404925376176834,
0.3679133355617523,
0.34604591131210327,
-0.1430041790008545,
0.6927815079689026,
0.3373611569404602,
0.22282366454601288,
-0.07747773826122284,
-0.1305021345615387,
0.4399464726448059,
-0.6128396391868591,
-0.25935229659080505,
-0.42203569412231445,
-0.35789719223976135,
-0.6654754877090454,
-0.10799675434827805,
0.02395607717335224,
-0.1122022494673729,
-0.26871412992477417,
0.31594088673591614,
-0.41771188378334045,
0.6813252568244934,
0.2093086540699005,
0.11874059587717056,
0.4839724898338318,
-0.17884112894535065,
-0.1385672688484192,
-0.2557922601699829,
-0.28684481978416443,
-0.7221306562423706,
0.5991624593734741,
0.08548631519079208,
0.4735148251056671,
0.19977796077728271,
0.6778467893600464,
0.08969639241695404,
0.10739602148532867,
-0.8396667838096619,
0.5801203846931458,
-0.17619796097278595,
-0.4385533034801483,
-0.13115379214286804,
-0.48808756470680237,
-1.018438458442688,
0.4035941958427429,
-0.26939037442207336,
-0.8093751668930054,
0.11921166628599167,
0.28443533182144165,
0.10812045633792877,
0.24439971148967743,
-1.0365859270095825,
0.8907871246337891,
0.15253496170043945,
-0.3459930419921875,
-0.09018246829509735,
-0.7264565229415894,
0.5043850541114807,
0.2230646312236786,
0.1598614901304245,
0.02397420071065426,
-0.1078379824757576,
0.5281123518943787,
-0.43882009387016296,
0.8341228365898132,
-0.04825148358941078,
-0.020680218935012817,
0.24423477053642273,
0.06927548348903656,
0.33644792437553406,
-0.03226534277200699,
-0.33931785821914673,
-0.27417904138565063,
-0.18031685054302216,
-0.43028122186660767,
-1.042392373085022,
0.633924663066864,
-0.4773330092430115,
-0.42154958844184875,
-0.3316427171230316,
-0.586853563785553,
-0.17997650802135468,
0.21800865232944489,
0.38892045617103577,
0.4782089293003082,
-0.07996990531682968,
-0.009827569127082825,
0.6137651205062866,
-0.1411595195531845,
0.4134693145751953,
0.20401965081691742,
0.11709215492010117,
-0.2780929207801819,
0.9286298751831055,
0.030671607702970505,
0.00893017090857029,
0.6739511489868164,
0.270038366317749,
-0.4997636377811432,
-0.4698546528816223,
-0.18830354511737823,
0.16257335245609283,
-0.7647196650505066,
0.00904141180217266,
-0.7046480178833008,
-0.17690733075141907,
-0.11208707839250565,
-0.2740743160247803,
-0.08729340881109238,
-0.3399994373321533,
-0.3001013696193695,
-0.11341937631368637,
0.3413679897785187,
0.5567474961280823,
0.2694512605667114,
0.06948571652173996,
-0.37203624844551086,
0.46406909823417664,
0.14544788002967834,
0.22092147171497345,
-0.12324704229831696,
-0.28923115134239197,
0.19164825975894928,
0.07720507681369781,
-0.3602437973022461,
-1.1060200929641724,
0.5241661667823792,
0.3871963620185852,
0.3003040850162506,
0.4356822371482849,
0.37926405668258667,
0.7591243386268616,
-0.6239408850669861,
0.46986475586891174,
0.2219020426273346,
-1.1867681741714478,
0.6626585721969604,
-0.18350566923618317,
0.2239568531513214,
0.4197194278240204,
0.5772011876106262,
-0.2902735769748688,
-0.615935206413269,
-0.5363380312919617,
-0.923044741153717,
0.18867328763008118,
0.3873669505119324,
0.15129084885120392,
-0.19315257668495178,
0.3510827422142029,
0.1462024748325348,
0.07458817213773727,
-0.905399739742279,
-0.18604491651058197,
-0.349383682012558,
-0.4576950669288635,
0.1145583912730217,
0.2072795182466507,
-0.13284647464752197,
-0.2072669118642807,
0.4157421886920929,
-0.23570816218852997,
0.3572784960269928,
0.4332490563392639,
-0.2840186059474945,
0.16581296920776367,
0.5149198174476624,
0.23590517044067383,
0.7811886072158813,
-0.14557959139347076,
0.6367281079292297,
0.22140465676784515,
-0.20979882776737213,
0.11571900546550751,
0.09970813989639282,
-0.14073748886585236,
0.11408428847789764,
0.4724421203136444,
0.7675973176956177,
0.1293564885854721,
-0.6813088059425354,
0.419293612241745,
0.2629146873950958,
-0.4045012891292572,
-0.4343031346797943,
-0.13238710165023804,
0.17629705369472504,
0.05446111783385277,
0.20757578313350677,
0.20521195232868195,
0.4334010183811188,
-0.411836177110672,
0.29974251985549927,
0.2691796123981476,
-0.5296013951301575,
-0.23632188141345978,
0.545235276222229,
-0.10547298192977905,
-0.5042681694030762,
0.7577242851257324,
-0.14280156791210175,
-0.46144357323646545,
0.5887731313705444,
0.8771011233329773,
0.8001009225845337,
0.15660004317760468,
0.2559673488140106,
0.2634273171424866,
0.3181675374507904,
0.3223303258419037,
0.1503693014383316,
0.17455236613750458,
-0.7868601083755493,
-0.8092306852340698,
-0.30517345666885376,
-0.314659982919693,
0.09555085003376007,
-0.8845589756965637,
0.20447318255901337,
-0.2737272381782532,
0.21519795060157776,
0.39751482009887695,
-0.3987785875797272,
-0.4800005257129669,
0.2428433895111084,
-0.05992642790079117,
0.7957327961921692,
-1.0848450660705566,
0.6391717195510864,
0.6497870087623596,
-0.45911020040512085,
-0.49825620651245117,
0.3327789306640625,
0.058809127658605576,
-0.5688787698745728,
0.5922474265098572,
0.30409640073776245,
-0.2791312634944916,
0.058369576930999756,
-0.5892066359519958,
-0.14761701226234436,
0.6541637778282166,
0.6725001931190491,
0.04584939032793045,
0.029975201934576035,
0.11984915286302567,
0.572627067565918,
-0.3914528489112854,
0.16936466097831726,
0.5285446047782898,
0.47360020875930786,
0.19873102009296417,
-0.42830243706703186,
0.2575792670249939,
-0.38251155614852905,
-0.20483623445034027,
0.5434280037879944,
-0.010290796868503094,
0.7506406903266907,
-0.16952137649059296,
-0.37959879636764526,
-0.23878370225429535,
0.8126146197319031,
0.20525848865509033,
0.6796832084655762,
0.4581989645957947,
0.9046385884284973,
0.8496920466423035,
-0.15187866985797882,
0.9155001044273376,
0.19730588793754578,
0.21678946912288666,
1.2124500274658203,
-0.09440270811319351,
1.0713109970092773,
0.8768243193626404,
-0.03612950071692467,
0.9018624424934387,
0.4862612783908844,
0.2593495547771454,
0.4168004095554352,
0.31311628222465515,
-0.3337540626525879,
-0.2977411448955536,
-0.0931667685508728,
-0.2074773609638214,
0.3914996087551117,
0.6065942645072937,
-0.3257242739200592,
-0.43403860926628113,
-0.0064370655454695225,
0.017225828021764755,
0.5091442465782166,
0.026640594005584717,
0.7342113852500916,
0.0703839510679245,
-0.7616144418716431,
0.8344451785087585,
-0.12940563261508942,
0.38247910141944885,
-0.5027310252189636,
-0.2684670388698578,
0.07313157618045807,
0.26212477684020996,
-0.34632420539855957,
-0.7782748341560364,
0.7698270678520203,
-0.1804802119731903,
-0.1391575187444687,
-0.09590094536542892,
0.5173216462135315,
-0.31533950567245483,
-0.3680913746356964,
0.22174997627735138,
0.40354442596435547,
0.05587894469499588,
0.301339715719223,
-0.6745399236679077,
-0.2564581334590912,
-0.1464245766401291,
-0.05331524834036827,
-0.0011090816697105765,
0.9711374044418335,
0.1474558562040329,
0.834098219871521,
0.5312866568565369,
-0.2088024914264679,
0.05296565964818001,
-0.21915854513645172,
0.8719382882118225,
-0.6008417010307312,
-0.6070414185523987,
-1.037888765335083,
0.5557765364646912,
-0.21531303226947784,
-0.4068697392940521,
0.6117552518844604,
0.5221804976463318,
0.5109282732009888,
-0.09304533153772354,
0.7298774123191833,
0.022090375423431396,
0.24713434278964996,
-0.884872317314148,
0.2737993597984314,
-0.43934720754623413,
0.26329368352890015,
-0.2024754285812378,
-0.5475635528564453,
-0.5562115907669067,
0.8183718323707581,
-0.5037983059883118,
-0.5421025156974792,
1.1375157833099365,
0.717529833316803,
-0.3646099269390106,
0.4077918529510498,
-0.1905413419008255,
0.308449923992157,
-0.006368264555931091,
0.8337469100952148,
0.8511577844619751,
-0.4471156597137451,
0.5316263437271118,
0.12550733983516693,
-0.07435963302850723,
0.3063518702983856,
-1.1929911375045776,
-0.8001040816307068,
-0.5422502756118774,
-0.561875581741333,
-0.5936861634254456,
0.20797637104988098,
0.8547426462173462,
0.30082985758781433,
-0.9677348136901855,
-0.12436435371637344,
-0.7549681663513184,
0.4201476275920868,
-0.3730817437171936,
-0.2716982364654541,
0.44418126344680786,
-0.5743876695632935,
-0.7249354720115662,
0.3042393624782562,
0.29610341787338257,
-0.10352108627557755,
-0.10621674358844757,
-0.1410367786884308,
-0.5584828853607178,
0.27732381224632263,
0.2770465016365051,
0.29011860489845276,
-1.0437055826187134,
-0.2549636662006378,
-0.2027106136083603,
0.334852397441864,
0.1727900207042694,
0.879542887210846,
-0.9306882619857788,
0.5915852785110474,
0.6543506383895874,
0.8979099988937378,
0.4134018123149872,
-0.18978455662727356,
0.7550182342529297,
-0.6833904981613159,
0.22738635540008545,
0.25314220786094666,
0.27394551038742065,
0.28594139218330383,
-0.12808851897716522,
0.5329824090003967,
0.296796053647995,
-0.1668655425310135,
-0.8750821352005005,
0.5178974270820618,
-0.9947771430015564,
-0.32007917761802673,
0.8012989163398743,
-0.17924411594867706,
-0.3560263514518738,
-0.6831797361373901,
-0.046504776924848557,
0.25531280040740967,
-0.008021433837711811,
0.6017456650733948,
0.6631746292114258,
-0.19513742625713348,
-0.19004109501838684,
-0.6617940068244934,
0.34668922424316406,
0.27030080556869507,
-0.8485016226768494,
0.039333492517471313,
0.34021350741386414,
0.04759359732270241,
0.2508764863014221,
0.3879956305027008,
-0.12880122661590576,
-0.18840031325817108,
-0.0019337247358635068,
-0.3949252665042877,
-0.048764586448669434,
0.06220800057053566,
-0.17071689665317535,
0.2811279296875,
-0.5260337591171265,
-0.3767237663269043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01249v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01249v1
|
Prompt engineering paradigms for medical applications: scoping review and recommendations for better practices
| 2024-05-02T12:52:23 | 2024-05-02T12:52:23 |
Jamil Zaghir, Marco Naguib, Mina Bjelogrlic, Aurélie Névéol, Xavier Tannier, Christian Lovis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Prompt engineering is crucial for harnessing the potential of large language
models (LLMs), especially in the medical domain where specialized terminology
and phrasing is used. However, the efficacy of prompt engineering in the
medical domain remains to be explored. In this work, 114 recent studies
(2022-2024) applying prompt engineering in medicine, covering prompt learning
(PL), prompt tuning (PT), and prompt design (PD) are reviewed. PD is the most
prevalent (78 articles). In 12 papers, PD, PL, and PT terms were used
interchangeably. ChatGPT is the most commonly used LLM, with seven papers using
it for processing sensitive clinical data. Chain-of-Thought emerges as the most
common prompt engineering technique. While PL and PT articles typically provide
a baseline for evaluating prompt-based approaches, 64% of PD studies lack
non-prompt-related baselines. We provide tables and figures summarizing
existing work, and reporting recommendations to guide future research
contributions.
|
[
-0.16639381647109985,
-0.7204213738441467,
0.9067427515983582,
0.7158788442611694,
-0.20709766447544098,
0.053097184747457504,
0.02174065075814724,
-0.3320242464542389,
0.034899357706308365,
0.16167853772640228,
-0.6172771453857422,
-0.23133578896522522,
-0.5394435524940491,
0.5711798071861267,
-0.09415563941001892,
0.6638336181640625,
-0.13228543102741241,
0.5181082487106323,
0.06692353636026382,
0.032219842076301575,
-0.9693478345870972,
-0.546474039554596,
-0.7156252264976501,
-0.17566783726215363,
0.752312958240509,
0.2810467481613159,
0.6282550692558289,
0.5475462675094604,
0.5696598291397095,
0.2540116608142853,
-0.255707323551178,
-0.07430122047662735,
-0.03932733088731766,
0.37707188725471497,
-0.0960201844573021,
-0.1517537385225296,
-0.4594506621360779,
0.18660978972911835,
0.4235283434391022,
1.152793526649475,
0.012744768522679806,
-0.12223339825868607,
0.002236258238554001,
0.7983605861663818,
-0.4807473123073578,
0.05249861255288124,
-0.1850951761007309,
0.13513050973415375,
-0.09666711837053299,
-0.4955536127090454,
-0.5452224016189575,
-0.5028947591781616,
0.2862754762172699,
-0.6244837641716003,
-0.18989765644073486,
0.40484902262687683,
0.40405726432800293,
0.11112815141677856,
-0.4410164952278137,
-0.6105718612670898,
-0.3527596890926361,
0.682524561882019,
-0.6810106039047241,
0.4587750732898712,
0.4688591957092285,
0.30971357226371765,
-0.4615621864795685,
-0.7102804183959961,
-0.05362016335129738,
-0.4700760245323181,
0.11088468879461288,
0.02665184997022152,
0.054041776806116104,
0.6348963975906372,
0.5978280305862427,
0.3224555552005768,
-0.712658166885376,
0.48071280121803284,
-0.5172654390335083,
-0.19307899475097656,
0.3974853754043579,
0.3730986416339874,
0.5338018536567688,
0.012601489201188087,
-0.5379136204719543,
0.38414809107780457,
-1.0527979135513306,
0.05182992294430733,
-0.14303810894489288,
0.1017417311668396,
-0.057986579835414886,
0.593084454536438,
-0.40231332182884216,
0.8491504192352295,
0.09729678928852081,
-0.2660238444805145,
0.18435871601104736,
-0.5155640244483948,
-0.3336080312728882,
-0.054942354559898376,
0.5947354435920715,
0.7807504534721375,
-0.05467890575528145,
-0.022402288392186165,
-0.2324550896883011,
0.04933493584394455,
0.2225847840309143,
-0.6128257513046265,
-0.13872475922107697,
0.3371541500091553,
-0.7059698700904846,
-0.24758680164813995,
-0.523197591304779,
-0.5938137173652649,
-0.6548227071762085,
-0.42021963000297546,
-0.09467092901468277,
-0.34586331248283386,
0.007730960845947266,
0.35099056363105774,
-0.029694678261876106,
0.3288939297199249,
0.356973797082901,
-0.6537459492683411,
-0.04805915802717209,
0.6137446761131287,
0.9798181653022766,
-0.25002047419548035,
-0.1708296686410904,
-0.3375600278377533,
-0.3177328109741211,
-0.6190632581710815,
1.0451017618179321,
-0.38983866572380066,
-0.9694151878356934,
0.31805944442749023,
0.055188968777656555,
-0.10264108330011368,
-0.38620078563690186,
0.8668689727783203,
-0.2544824182987213,
0.2828565537929535,
-0.5522956848144531,
-0.6544352173805237,
0.16280966997146606,
-0.040468744933605194,
-0.4382186830043793,
0.5659996271133423,
0.029242221266031265,
-0.5203683972358704,
0.5249592065811157,
-0.7057482004165649,
-0.4437815248966217,
0.1936827003955841,
-0.2315349131822586,
-0.08874797075986862,
0.28849807381629944,
0.2372892200946808,
0.43183356523513794,
-0.5086874961853027,
0.5055556297302246,
-0.10029879212379456,
-0.20742984116077423,
0.2028712034225464,
-0.10051112622022629,
0.9530230760574341,
0.7680965662002563,
0.19681775569915771,
0.2605563700199127,
-0.5305771231651306,
-0.24186553061008453,
-0.16117024421691895,
0.04744401201605797,
-0.27836525440216064,
-0.15879306197166443,
-0.06939270347356796,
0.3487357497215271,
-0.08056524395942688,
-0.4104163646697998,
0.2953053414821625,
-0.41805538535118103,
0.6504951119422913,
0.5225934386253357,
0.4809398949146271,
0.5315191149711609,
-0.6962150931358337,
0.7791334390640259,
-0.3348276913166046,
0.5043690800666809,
-0.6133547425270081,
-0.6692663431167603,
-0.2588964104652405,
-0.09125517308712006,
0.04171227291226387,
0.5417357683181763,
-1.0831327438354492,
-0.00960120465606451,
0.34790125489234924,
-0.5246323347091675,
-0.32690203189849854,
-0.44677212834358215,
0.14949651062488556,
1.0472283363342285,
0.314096599817276,
-0.19138699769973755,
-0.42326757311820984,
-0.9015346765518188,
-0.4689619839191437,
-0.35499143600463867,
-0.15820682048797607,
0.2532179057598114,
0.026581300422549248,
-0.1578362137079239,
0.793556272983551,
-0.36798834800720215,
0.08626589179039001,
-0.1552482396364212,
0.18553777039051056,
0.4659772217273712,
0.5911637544631958,
0.6788159012794495,
-0.5044624209403992,
-0.42103153467178345,
-0.27319976687431335,
-0.8459864854812622,
-0.46246668696403503,
-0.3649562895298004,
0.14764995872974396,
0.06532202661037445,
0.6085401773452759,
-0.5329139232635498,
0.07469019293785095,
0.20056867599487305,
-0.2822423279285431,
0.658750057220459,
-0.12482372671365738,
0.6022481918334961,
-0.8658360242843628,
0.08420079946517944,
0.2803407311439514,
0.23866324126720428,
-0.7792333364486694,
0.15461114048957825,
0.12234341353178024,
-0.3045676350593567,
-0.6707596182823181,
0.8669518828392029,
-0.5716108679771423,
0.43816646933555603,
-0.5323398113250732,
-0.1819380223751068,
-0.12915866076946259,
-0.13764163851737976,
-0.1076606884598732,
0.9911544919013977,
0.790290117263794,
-0.6424331068992615,
0.2995539903640747,
0.25798436999320984,
-0.28421667218208313,
0.7371131181716919,
-0.8989841938018799,
-0.024980604648590088,
-0.09518560022115707,
0.257155179977417,
-0.8288399577140808,
-0.14677982032299042,
0.28305935859680176,
-0.33407771587371826,
0.42062026262283325,
0.034211333841085434,
-0.292202353477478,
-0.5764075517654419,
-0.4278828799724579,
0.3370561897754669,
0.5991938710212708,
-0.13959051668643951,
0.06904909759759903,
0.4600121080875397,
-0.7646040320396423,
-0.35229364037513733,
-0.3815193772315979,
0.31861719489097595,
-0.24220572412014008,
-0.4172927141189575,
0.3389430046081543,
-0.23488923907279968,
-0.16573549807071686,
-0.6289759874343872,
-0.4397009015083313,
-0.14256605505943298,
0.2794603407382965,
0.08943191170692444,
0.44954797625541687,
-0.005942790303379297,
0.2683129906654358,
0.18906298279762268,
-0.28407931327819824,
0.22174052894115448,
0.15968447923660278,
0.40654221177101135,
0.3536908030509949,
-0.1743183434009552,
-0.5573980212211609,
0.7010189294815063,
0.41219016909599304,
0.10986236482858658,
0.21453821659088135,
0.18034566938877106,
-0.40538591146469116,
0.11269421875476837,
-0.49392300844192505,
-0.46465039253234863,
-0.5042581558227539,
0.23071061074733734,
-0.26865872740745544,
-0.8769619464874268,
0.3045661747455597,
-0.45761430263519287,
0.32267245650291443,
0.20004452764987946,
0.5055859088897705,
-0.5229631066322327,
0.8952365517616272,
0.8060139417648315,
0.17031626403331757,
0.512673020362854,
0.17451007664203644,
0.24570845067501068,
-0.6828455924987793,
-0.06823916733264923,
-0.6833323836326599,
-0.027008334174752235,
-0.5210521221160889,
-0.16421306133270264,
0.753292441368103,
0.013748363591730595,
-0.057337820529937744,
-0.01877693273127079,
-0.531864583492279,
0.2052355855703354,
0.3550189733505249,
0.12185831367969513,
0.14271025359630585,
-0.21647343039512634,
-0.2738778293132782,
-0.07218112051486969,
-0.7955579161643982,
-0.5057523846626282,
1.008064866065979,
0.43013250827789307,
0.8191711902618408,
-0.6670985221862793,
0.4294487237930298,
0.3180364668369293,
0.3047337234020233,
-0.9393573999404907,
0.4292280375957489,
0.33014291524887085,
-0.4816691279411316,
-0.1209835335612297,
0.0014796294271945953,
-1.0047491788864136,
-0.050570327788591385,
-0.03166383504867554,
-0.42743176221847534,
0.17000426352024078,
0.15277080237865448,
-0.6689749956130981,
-0.08174559473991394,
-0.6509528756141663,
0.5011969804763794,
-0.09230243414640427,
-0.16139471530914307,
0.05862828344106674,
-0.9965543150901794,
0.2915622591972351,
-0.038579098880290985,
0.24247853457927704,
0.03188696131110191,
-0.23263366520404816,
0.5649600625038147,
-0.4296915531158447,
0.7928275465965271,
-0.1120864674448967,
-0.33229559659957886,
0.18508417904376984,
-0.05535505339503288,
0.37862372398376465,
0.20202669501304626,
-0.03028232418000698,
0.05661154165863991,
0.15254411101341248,
-0.3924941420555115,
-0.49674203991889954,
0.5956723093986511,
-0.2208002209663391,
-0.7698345184326172,
-0.7433229088783264,
-0.43512049317359924,
-0.5170984268188477,
-0.03569568321108818,
0.4167935848236084,
0.4925643503665924,
-0.08910784870386124,
-0.06514417380094528,
0.6186994314193726,
-0.4739076495170593,
0.5308886170387268,
0.3253113925457001,
-0.010491239838302135,
-0.4100581705570221,
0.5724133849143982,
0.2322632521390915,
0.03486308082938194,
0.17124560475349426,
0.09745436161756516,
-0.22701995074748993,
-0.7931658625602722,
-0.6047197580337524,
0.20967212319374084,
-0.40236252546310425,
-0.24077089130878448,
-0.662261426448822,
-0.308536559343338,
-0.3640032708644867,
-0.49484148621559143,
-0.06923581659793854,
-0.32468143105506897,
-0.09937769174575806,
-0.03325445577502251,
0.30642393231391907,
0.5770326852798462,
0.1362311989068985,
0.4029019773006439,
-0.7283655405044556,
0.16223624348640442,
-0.11321516335010529,
0.3872769773006439,
-0.3115449845790863,
-0.17050237953662872,
-0.16611246764659882,
-0.19134916365146637,
-0.3177397549152374,
-1.0503467321395874,
0.15598194301128387,
-0.0698646828532219,
0.6973163485527039,
0.2869303822517395,
0.15969061851501465,
0.24622522294521332,
-0.7353722453117371,
1.1105384826660156,
0.4364970326423645,
-0.539789080619812,
0.7360685467720032,
-0.3756951689720154,
0.20900285243988037,
0.3857661485671997,
0.7328276634216309,
-0.9190295934677124,
-0.09850767254829407,
-0.2894147038459778,
-1.037516474723816,
0.24335426092147827,
-0.17562058568000793,
-0.15040388703346252,
-0.23719073832035065,
0.5358673334121704,
0.5379300713539124,
0.24180909991264343,
-0.20780538022518158,
-0.3449424207210541,
0.22455565631389618,
-0.20301063358783722,
0.031637560576200485,
-0.32173946499824524,
-0.15418387949466705,
0.04350731894373894,
0.338988333940506,
-0.2251966893672943,
0.4232528507709503,
0.3411848843097687,
0.002233747858554125,
-0.028835544362664223,
0.4321209788322449,
0.7537470459938049,
0.896436870098114,
0.18153023719787598,
-0.06913933157920837,
0.05768471956253052,
-0.6891348958015442,
0.24294795095920563,
0.0159782562404871,
-0.48152923583984375,
-0.01580824889242649,
0.13238933682441711,
0.48513370752334595,
0.13952869176864624,
-0.5589842200279236,
0.17539571225643158,
0.1996483951807022,
-0.059863559901714325,
0.18064121901988983,
-0.1622236967086792,
-0.2572766840457916,
0.11309411376714706,
0.1376277059316635,
0.1432493031024933,
0.5303369760513306,
-0.3137913644313812,
0.1069040521979332,
0.28164002299308777,
-0.39615681767463684,
-0.45335036516189575,
0.6720705032348633,
0.39719700813293457,
-0.20342786610126495,
0.15242476761341095,
0.2823145389556885,
0.07203322649002075,
0.3489888608455658,
0.5506175756454468,
0.8087249398231506,
-0.3246617317199707,
0.2029312700033188,
0.2826981544494629,
0.21658550202846527,
-0.17429378628730774,
0.6524306535720825,
-0.013556853868067265,
-0.0654076486825943,
-0.6898683905601501,
-0.3265458643436432,
-0.5979682803153992,
0.019000070169568062,
-0.25379031896591187,
0.45312410593032837,
-0.5148002505302429,
-0.5195528268814087,
-0.13090060651302338,
-0.13394050300121307,
-0.49537166953086853,
0.06192610040307045,
-0.1267279088497162,
1.272434949874878,
-0.6296228766441345,
0.4936084449291229,
1.0290045738220215,
-0.4415988326072693,
-0.5335259437561035,
-0.2956993579864502,
0.2949155569076538,
-0.681950569152832,
0.30661460757255554,
-0.08991556614637375,
0.25614362955093384,
-0.10849564522504807,
-0.6114086508750916,
-0.6422247886657715,
0.8862231373786926,
0.16561248898506165,
-0.5770857334136963,
-0.5185413360595703,
-0.13796792924404144,
0.23434007167816162,
-0.23840250074863434,
0.4366224706172943,
0.3146546185016632,
0.25876107811927795,
-0.08977748453617096,
-1.1925569772720337,
0.08990423381328583,
-0.21147142350673676,
0.12946784496307373,
-0.11053398251533508,
-0.6200932264328003,
0.593870997428894,
-0.30888256430625916,
-0.36283716559410095,
0.46797508001327515,
0.19785869121551514,
0.7803522944450378,
0.7796531319618225,
0.09208613634109497,
-0.03469371050596237,
0.7177225351333618,
-0.14582756161689758,
0.9716979265213013,
-0.6021326184272766,
-0.03762856870889664,
0.686888575553894,
-0.5867366790771484,
0.25491902232170105,
0.7610321640968323,
-0.2944543659687042,
-0.09256348013877869,
1.07207453250885,
0.3472785949707031,
0.513473629951477,
0.282362699508667,
-0.11649733036756516,
0.04935526102781296,
-0.4334893524646759,
-0.8481820821762085,
-0.14222358167171478,
0.5349957942962646,
-0.3732165992259979,
-0.14235933125019073,
0.4395536780357361,
0.07149621844291687,
-0.030479570850729942,
-0.4352501332759857,
0.7979332208633423,
0.5531295537948608,
-0.5473472476005554,
0.4287291169166565,
-0.17116506397724152,
0.48780307173728943,
-0.4896925389766693,
-0.12234383821487427,
-0.3698342740535736,
-0.39954322576522827,
0.019126389175653458,
-0.6594266295433044,
0.03861929103732109,
-0.13171422481536865,
-0.1658509373664856,
-0.6017577052116394,
0.7902004718780518,
0.22744125127792358,
-0.09117605537176132,
-0.2810470461845398,
0.8659039735794067,
-0.06581581383943558,
0.2766345739364624,
-0.4441124498844147,
0.08942408859729767,
-0.32438328862190247,
-0.3258913457393646,
0.2304507941007614,
0.6026896834373474,
-0.1648898422718048,
0.9117738008499146,
0.6262477040290833,
0.3778965175151825,
0.10031526535749435,
-0.012079020962119102,
1.0912567377090454,
-0.8981702923774719,
-0.5508363842964172,
-0.7088218331336975,
0.44864070415496826,
0.03291405364871025,
-0.5636347532272339,
0.5943288207054138,
0.37289959192276,
0.41964635252952576,
-0.21926723420619965,
0.7276211977005005,
0.15937447547912598,
0.5059835910797119,
-0.7576773166656494,
0.6080898642539978,
-0.09095825999975204,
0.10060685127973557,
-0.324306845664978,
-0.7541919350624084,
-0.7075663805007935,
0.408066064119339,
-0.18712107837200165,
0.0962427482008934,
0.8205221891403198,
0.4804282784461975,
0.35575398802757263,
0.41501331329345703,
0.34079334139823914,
0.2417483776807785,
0.3098079264163971,
0.34723907709121704,
1.1532760858535767,
-0.273848295211792,
-0.32655003666877747,
-0.07160074263811111,
-0.5847565531730652,
-0.3130229711532593,
-0.9508029222488403,
-0.6956431865692139,
-0.5047513246536255,
-0.32468676567077637,
-0.16914668679237366,
0.2831508219242096,
1.2752177715301514,
0.7060188055038452,
-0.6003239750862122,
-0.09491428732872009,
-0.06473898887634277,
0.12501496076583862,
-0.3090633153915405,
-0.07931860536336899,
0.290443480014801,
-0.8100086450576782,
-0.5117466449737549,
0.7975024580955505,
0.5598546862602234,
0.09097851067781448,
-0.027554165571928024,
-0.002493920736014843,
-0.0003642187512014061,
-0.13812249898910522,
0.7589070796966553,
0.48482072353363037,
-0.6189166903495789,
0.08333270251750946,
0.5676331520080566,
-0.25732728838920593,
0.023833919316530228,
1.291488766670227,
-0.7512539625167847,
0.33708444237709045,
0.624435544013977,
0.5668674111366272,
-0.36084118485450745,
-0.19430118799209595,
0.777389407157898,
-0.15204183757305145,
-0.0776323601603508,
0.5081599950790405,
0.6269251108169556,
0.052823733538389206,
-0.31263840198516846,
0.4897472858428955,
0.39816176891326904,
-0.9409286379814148,
-0.9345242381095886,
0.3719516694545746,
-1.0107402801513672,
-0.17941856384277344,
0.9672278165817261,
0.08280423283576965,
-0.14701315760612488,
-0.4648396670818329,
-0.7313477396965027,
0.07134942710399628,
-0.46480992436408997,
0.7584081292152405,
0.5584957599639893,
-0.4523662328720093,
-0.1994452029466629,
-0.929291844367981,
0.8260560035705566,
0.3684077858924866,
-0.6827009916305542,
-0.160857692360878,
0.48321637511253357,
0.13098914921283722,
-0.22309717535972595,
0.8529964685440063,
-0.26688387989997864,
0.42593127489089966,
-0.3523327112197876,
-0.1296422779560089,
0.0729721412062645,
-0.4262540638446808,
-0.4818851053714752,
0.19042687118053436,
0.3169962763786316,
-0.07910535484552383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01229v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01229v1
|
Boosting Jailbreak Attack with Momentum
| 2024-05-02T12:18:14 | 2024-05-02T12:18:14 |
Yihao Zhang, Zeming Wei
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, math.OC
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success across diverse
tasks, yet they remain vulnerable to adversarial attacks, notably the
well-documented \textit{jailbreak} attack. Recently, the Greedy Coordinate
Gradient (GCG) attack has demonstrated efficacy in exploiting this
vulnerability by optimizing adversarial prompts through a combination of
gradient heuristics and greedy search. However, the efficiency of this attack
has become a bottleneck in the attacking process. To mitigate this limitation,
in this paper we rethink the generation of adversarial prompts through an
optimization lens, aiming to stabilize the optimization process and harness
more heuristic insights from previous iterations. Specifically, we introduce
the \textbf{M}omentum \textbf{A}ccelerated G\textbf{C}G (\textbf{MAC}) attack,
which incorporates a momentum term into the gradient heuristic. Experimental
results showcase the notable enhancement achieved by MAP in gradient-based
attacks on aligned language models. Our code is available at
https://github.com/weizeming/momentum-attack-llm.
|
[
-0.3908410668373108,
-0.9093979001045227,
0.38426464796066284,
0.2790132761001587,
-0.1323944330215454,
0.25646862387657166,
-0.4221380352973938,
0.07733482122421265,
0.36541008949279785,
0.49233278632164,
-0.7193735837936401,
-0.5201044082641602,
-0.7720397114753723,
-0.2869947552680969,
-0.2804453670978546,
1.0889763832092285,
0.04180438444018364,
0.019723884761333466,
0.3276101350784302,
-0.2671498656272888,
-0.5846508145332336,
-0.43344393372535706,
-0.7590912580490112,
0.035348717123270035,
0.631813645362854,
0.3123912513256073,
0.8437228202819824,
0.6466562747955322,
0.5391120314598083,
0.2357039898633957,
-0.09738907963037491,
-0.006003682501614094,
-0.5993977189064026,
0.4894005358219147,
0.15135423839092255,
-0.39756864309310913,
-0.22425560653209686,
0.10081396996974945,
0.44744014739990234,
0.3981667160987854,
-0.30161818861961365,
-0.16648541390895844,
-0.10165660828351974,
0.9509905576705933,
-0.9388983249664307,
-0.2794235944747925,
-0.8748080134391785,
-0.013462620787322521,
-0.3583414852619171,
-0.07349643856287003,
-0.3964218199253082,
-0.09441389888525009,
-0.39563024044036865,
-0.4637189507484436,
-0.09131138026714325,
0.18058939278125763,
0.8675974011421204,
0.37272560596466064,
0.10303720831871033,
-0.3007863163948059,
-0.32081687450408936,
0.6025768518447876,
-0.4703746736049652,
0.009558035060763359,
-0.0042927199974656105,
0.3277337849140167,
-0.7556853294372559,
-0.2613670527935028,
-0.13631969690322876,
-0.4917042553424835,
0.48428747057914734,
0.023763516917824745,
-0.36188235878944397,
0.08091676235198975,
0.38169607520103455,
0.09741625934839249,
-0.37473514676094055,
0.2462732046842575,
-0.36504319310188293,
-0.16584229469299316,
0.616736114025116,
0.19151271879673004,
0.5526409149169922,
-0.025764580816030502,
-0.6715895533561707,
-0.2538665533065796,
-0.9266539812088013,
0.2565331757068634,
0.9045494198799133,
0.4923456907272339,
-0.032193560153245926,
0.6545506119728088,
0.024630440399050713,
0.8754197955131531,
0.3573358952999115,
0.06846906989812851,
-0.03600339964032173,
-0.24785080552101135,
0.15323930978775024,
0.18626931309700012,
1.1460055112838745,
0.3962954580783844,
0.4460158050060272,
-0.2382226288318634,
-0.12386085838079453,
-0.05105101317167282,
0.6551486253738403,
-0.9739411473274231,
-0.33823129534721375,
0.2644250988960266,
0.01520991325378418,
-0.45159903168678284,
0.26146045327186584,
-0.8824265599250793,
-0.5842406749725342,
0.3542070984840393,
-0.009004945866763592,
-0.48198726773262024,
0.0886659249663353,
0.2634958326816559,
-0.2638845443725586,
0.049299150705337524,
0.04550212249159813,
-0.97572261095047,
-0.03140408545732498,
0.7476080060005188,
1.032679557800293,
0.01630840077996254,
-0.008023497648537159,
-1.0437184572219849,
-0.04760325700044632,
-0.24185147881507874,
0.32112595438957214,
-0.42196622490882874,
-0.6190544962882996,
0.015521186403930187,
-0.38342469930648804,
-0.1552364081144333,
-0.35145673155784607,
0.8663497567176819,
-0.6802905201911926,
-0.155790776014328,
-0.31206387281417847,
-0.32558104395866394,
0.07298082113265991,
0.4459603428840637,
-0.8191349506378174,
0.8113941550254822,
-0.028810402378439903,
-0.8368889689445496,
0.2568567395210266,
-0.5193946361541748,
-0.520624041557312,
-0.012461083941161633,
-0.010196713730692863,
-0.6388238072395325,
0.37379351258277893,
0.5901438593864441,
0.30919766426086426,
-0.251819908618927,
0.3594225347042084,
-0.5553554892539978,
-0.2762758433818817,
0.1166655644774437,
-0.1217755377292633,
1.0974873304367065,
0.2117154598236084,
-0.2805999517440796,
0.13462841510772705,
-0.5499072074890137,
-0.1529202163219452,
0.4152270555496216,
-0.4723762571811676,
-0.4694824516773224,
0.3534601330757141,
-0.4383617639541626,
0.04264132305979729,
0.153607577085495,
-0.5353081822395325,
0.8082200288772583,
-0.40544164180755615,
0.3883357644081116,
0.7216302156448364,
-0.004713595844805241,
0.5879830718040466,
0.11981937289237976,
0.7417852878570557,
-0.04781098663806915,
0.23396886885166168,
-0.2232569009065628,
-0.4133438169956207,
-0.3450540602207184,
-0.46218153834342957,
0.1314065009355545,
0.7609161734580994,
-0.7698982357978821,
0.255464106798172,
-0.1715715229511261,
-0.48721402883529663,
-0.6353325843811035,
0.5319591760635376,
0.284662663936615,
0.4158324599266052,
0.37444841861724854,
-0.2734580338001251,
-0.36958959698677063,
-0.45927780866622925,
-0.8059950470924377,
-0.23786437511444092,
0.2317875474691391,
0.23038503527641296,
0.2578023374080658,
-0.1809484362602234,
0.6924229860305786,
-0.705049991607666,
-0.21721552312374115,
-0.35167887806892395,
-0.022425303235650063,
0.37168994545936584,
0.5337554812431335,
0.876241147518158,
-0.49444910883903503,
-0.3023355007171631,
-0.4744020700454712,
-0.7353344559669495,
-0.31222647428512573,
-0.18775205314159393,
-0.14704059064388275,
-0.11696691066026688,
0.8055484294891357,
-0.7081528902053833,
0.182212233543396,
0.4668520390987396,
-0.28211328387260437,
0.6558313965797424,
0.052075017243623734,
-0.040699221193790436,
-0.8531058430671692,
-0.2826419472694397,
0.3316887319087982,
0.07056780904531479,
-0.7602201700210571,
0.6032690405845642,
0.077827587723732,
-0.1532735675573349,
-0.5172010064125061,
0.5024462342262268,
-0.6239991784095764,
0.29420214891433716,
-0.22971823811531067,
0.28376060724258423,
-0.24383267760276794,
0.4002637565135956,
-0.49454984068870544,
0.7422246336936951,
0.7230216264724731,
-0.20192892849445343,
0.32858288288116455,
-0.07383040338754654,
-0.22732135653495789,
0.5398468375205994,
-0.7513154149055481,
0.1980751007795334,
-0.18501952290534973,
0.05710999667644501,
-0.9889662861824036,
0.08183806389570236,
0.48281362652778625,
-0.49097317457199097,
0.624798595905304,
-0.3761976957321167,
-0.3839589059352875,
-0.6077519655227661,
-0.8378732800483704,
0.38637927174568176,
0.2746189534664154,
-0.6469659209251404,
0.352343887090683,
0.2878444194793701,
0.14621473848819733,
-1.0219480991363525,
-0.3528059720993042,
0.3305618464946747,
-0.4542236328125,
-0.8075730800628662,
0.1145176887512207,
0.05216023325920105,
-0.4310400187969208,
-0.34294211864471436,
0.07381227612495422,
0.4656962454319,
0.596815288066864,
0.251183420419693,
0.44595766067504883,
-0.13600580394268036,
-0.49509477615356445,
-0.1628534495830536,
-0.06929183006286621,
0.3554002642631531,
-0.6068043112754822,
0.6471155881881714,
-0.14453507959842682,
-0.3338925838470459,
-0.011949040926992893,
0.15518145263195038,
0.5830133557319641,
-0.0998704805970192,
0.8754491209983826,
0.7144144177436829,
0.08339186757802963,
-0.1697889119386673,
-0.29469695687294006,
-0.09479861706495285,
-0.5516974925994873,
0.4096965193748474,
-0.24785134196281433,
-1.066952109336853,
0.5913094878196716,
0.04148590564727783,
-0.08527705073356628,
0.16079683601856232,
0.5122360587120056,
-0.0026989246252924204,
1.099165439605713,
0.3716111183166504,
-0.8474171161651611,
0.6723572611808777,
-0.23198649287223816,
0.3735751807689667,
-1.1017100811004639,
-0.015012752264738083,
-0.6677336096763611,
-0.33048734068870544,
-0.45869332551956177,
-0.24406705796718597,
0.33130499720573425,
0.5481646060943604,
-0.28768038749694824,
0.5020750164985657,
-0.2985735237598419,
0.41959649324417114,
0.5174610614776611,
0.10789375007152557,
-0.137830913066864,
-0.04447096958756447,
-0.30403730273246765,
0.02894008904695511,
-0.8323787450790405,
0.010326755233108997,
1.2172719240188599,
0.2699492871761322,
1.1571835279464722,
0.1311231106519699,
0.7504288554191589,
0.2068885862827301,
0.24219390749931335,
-0.7085327506065369,
0.6845282316207886,
-0.1465281993150711,
-0.37946733832359314,
0.053770359605550766,
-0.45879489183425903,
-0.9540637135505676,
0.27790606021881104,
-0.11034635454416275,
-1.0224099159240723,
-0.07271355390548706,
0.18662366271018982,
-0.3771597445011139,
0.4880090653896332,
-0.45092064142227173,
0.8742926716804504,
-0.36384615302085876,
-0.47548022866249084,
-0.03775816038250923,
-0.6757234334945679,
0.6667522192001343,
0.19261841475963593,
0.2860085368156433,
0.032404303550720215,
0.05298051983118057,
0.5340662002563477,
-0.7276744246482849,
0.7097391486167908,
-0.5641424059867859,
-0.12094434350728989,
0.417567640542984,
0.2297811061143875,
0.9288536906242371,
0.1004234179854393,
0.05892068147659302,
0.0663541704416275,
-0.9365725517272949,
-0.4766581654548645,
-0.6034027934074402,
0.73524409532547,
-0.5286503434181213,
-1.0586720705032349,
-0.18361341953277588,
-0.5715116262435913,
-0.005545875523239374,
-0.16634641587734222,
0.3216076195240021,
0.32065320014953613,
-0.1485499143600464,
-0.15314842760562897,
0.5237227082252502,
-0.25887787342071533,
0.622170090675354,
0.13547781109809875,
-0.07770568877458572,
-0.461640864610672,
0.9902002215385437,
-0.22127403318881989,
0.5760830044746399,
0.05889172479510307,
0.1841295212507248,
-0.010072421282529831,
-0.7081948518753052,
-0.630897581577301,
0.05154598504304886,
-0.5183084607124329,
-0.36389094591140747,
-0.4457215368747711,
-0.11884748190641403,
-0.22369176149368286,
-0.45340171456336975,
-0.1839994341135025,
-0.26332443952560425,
-0.24347560107707977,
-0.009343392215669155,
0.28807532787323,
0.1871645152568817,
-0.05614323914051056,
0.6724310517311096,
-0.6134738922119141,
0.17726421356201172,
-0.08604507148265839,
-0.17312458157539368,
-0.15066620707511902,
-0.3711225092411041,
-0.33151015639305115,
-0.08386603742837906,
-0.49698275327682495,
-1.1356030702590942,
0.43728601932525635,
0.031225332990288734,
0.3596285283565521,
0.6492544412612915,
-0.11653998494148254,
0.549191951751709,
-0.6953193545341492,
0.7167367935180664,
0.4981268048286438,
-0.8366889953613281,
0.62990403175354,
-0.5823242664337158,
0.3201010227203369,
0.7469353079795837,
0.2159445583820343,
-0.1928451657295227,
-0.793018639087677,
-0.6359559297561646,
-1.134119987487793,
0.4215987026691437,
-0.04661555960774422,
0.08913794159889221,
-0.11463373154401779,
0.5273315906524658,
-0.47258493304252625,
0.3631739616394043,
-0.6478806138038635,
-0.36756694316864014,
-0.1391410529613495,
-0.19315986335277557,
0.1041107103228569,
-0.14307552576065063,
-0.11511564999818802,
-0.07876502722501755,
0.596392035484314,
-0.16453205049037933,
-0.000030789331503910944,
-0.04902255907654762,
-0.26423248648643494,
-0.03106989711523056,
0.2860153317451477,
0.6379958987236023,
-0.12853370606899261,
-0.06138412654399872,
0.02012166753411293,
-0.2939681112766266,
-0.8427571654319763,
0.3143507242202759,
0.08252059668302536,
-0.43861764669418335,
-0.34194913506507874,
0.27315691113471985,
0.784275233745575,
0.09071505069732666,
-0.7803336977958679,
0.7198991179466248,
0.045468226075172424,
-0.10986820608377457,
0.09050209075212479,
0.36513233184814453,
-0.1842098981142044,
0.34814003109931946,
0.3574366867542267,
0.1591026484966278,
-0.0734015628695488,
-0.33171185851097107,
0.05194742605090141,
1.0854320526123047,
-0.517261266708374,
-0.1928022801876068,
0.9590157866477966,
-0.025739086791872978,
-0.28506916761398315,
0.6236385107040405,
-0.4108317792415619,
-1.008009433746338,
0.5860326886177063,
0.4904828667640686,
1.0768837928771973,
-0.18381661176681519,
0.0442974716424942,
0.33937400579452515,
0.7341599464416504,
-0.22651320695877075,
0.13879187405109406,
0.02490382082760334,
-0.8401806950569153,
-0.4755215644836426,
-0.4298883378505707,
-0.07045964896678925,
-0.17678385972976685,
-0.6327693462371826,
0.2509414553642273,
-0.9210665225982666,
-0.17104516923427582,
-0.25727176666259766,
-0.17039115726947784,
-0.20444172620773315,
-0.12422385066747665,
0.12057685106992722,
0.8851505517959595,
-0.5118844509124756,
0.687373697757721,
0.3733634054660797,
-0.3353489637374878,
-0.6130536198616028,
-0.01790173351764679,
0.24804244935512543,
-0.9797514081001282,
0.8516654968261719,
0.15583643317222595,
-0.16519558429718018,
-0.18324680626392365,
-0.8060222864151001,
-0.6761416792869568,
0.5871036648750305,
0.5013361573219299,
-0.8365966081619263,
0.12978395819664001,
-0.2816717028617859,
0.10027937591075897,
-0.35066133737564087,
-0.07618797570466995,
0.6916571259498596,
0.5208152532577515,
-0.004762685392051935,
-0.22463904321193695,
0.24456258118152618,
-0.10404264181852341,
-0.12380476295948029,
0.6538069248199463,
-0.5256935358047485,
0.853743851184845,
-0.8413244485855103,
-0.1436425894498825,
0.14171989262104034,
0.7670066356658936,
0.41153615713119507,
-0.20288504660129547,
0.5384701490402222,
1.0079286098480225,
0.6079359650611877,
-0.32708999514579773,
1.3146233558654785,
-0.5013403296470642,
0.2268904745578766,
0.9989538788795471,
-0.25023749470710754,
0.5425558686256409,
0.7054436206817627,
0.11693383753299713,
0.5096226930618286,
0.30982086062431335,
-0.2685549855232239,
0.6175118088722229,
0.7064117789268494,
-0.254734605550766,
-0.03876142576336861,
0.18495269119739532,
-0.029146263375878334,
0.23925691843032837,
0.4289495646953583,
-0.1524992287158966,
-0.3132110834121704,
0.17784494161605835,
0.72379070520401,
0.11707169562578201,
-0.6497660875320435,
0.5121668577194214,
0.05053417757153511,
-0.6615739464759827,
0.7018260359764099,
0.27908796072006226,
0.6805822849273682,
-0.5632262825965881,
0.45384982228279114,
0.027193816378712654,
0.17122377455234528,
-0.012528249993920326,
-0.5285227298736572,
-0.01979009620845318,
0.19581857323646545,
-0.005565153434872627,
0.03478115051984787,
0.7766916155815125,
-0.31629085540771484,
-0.3510816991329193,
0.498311847448349,
0.1473831981420517,
-0.3422934412956238,
-0.1942974328994751,
-0.7856535911560059,
0.2340185046195984,
-0.0329584926366806,
-0.466225802898407,
0.38520437479019165,
0.04845282807946205,
0.027364565059542656,
0.7673256993293762,
0.7634106278419495,
0.31178605556488037,
0.17481602728366852,
0.14163687825202942,
1.0455589294433594,
-0.7090166211128235,
-0.41983941197395325,
-1.5081642866134644,
0.4262131154537201,
-0.09817523509263992,
-0.24289919435977936,
0.8929675221443176,
0.3737104833126068,
0.4983964264392853,
0.257682740688324,
0.7516785860061646,
-0.04517447575926781,
-0.2613317668437958,
-0.8600887656211853,
0.5802499651908875,
-0.347258597612381,
0.5502325892448425,
-0.5497435331344604,
-0.7344698309898376,
-0.3453417420387268,
0.4790492653846741,
-0.37698307633399963,
-0.011911862529814243,
0.586991012096405,
0.8418462872505188,
0.26189950108528137,
-0.04635807126760483,
-0.08961093425750732,
0.27799758315086365,
0.5034307241439819,
0.8888847827911377,
0.820556640625,
-0.40707486867904663,
0.36183494329452515,
0.17924518883228302,
-0.21445058286190033,
-0.26330840587615967,
-1.0503778457641602,
-1.2362492084503174,
-0.19998490810394287,
-0.25234323740005493,
-0.755092442035675,
0.38134047389030457,
0.7569006085395813,
0.4431760907173157,
-0.5388541221618652,
-0.06832356005907059,
-0.23351101577281952,
0.1379241943359375,
-0.09162033349275589,
-0.22874893248081207,
0.19466795027256012,
-0.6525909304618835,
-0.3075612485408783,
0.7951136827468872,
0.4904259145259857,
-0.11723794788122177,
-0.41787925362586975,
-0.14199192821979523,
-0.13768503069877625,
0.16897474229335785,
0.11342036724090576,
0.48724550008773804,
-0.4379499852657318,
-0.20123974978923798,
0.01837051659822464,
-0.13743723928928375,
0.1002536416053772,
1.1722936630249023,
-0.7063763737678528,
0.2435654252767563,
0.11684741824865341,
1.063041090965271,
0.2621361017227173,
0.24788236618041992,
0.7283563017845154,
-0.9400781393051147,
0.406195729970932,
-0.028858546167612076,
0.6996160745620728,
0.3364129960536957,
-0.5003053545951843,
0.2887645959854126,
0.2612442076206207,
-0.3010460436344147,
-0.86461341381073,
0.36010459065437317,
-0.9043808579444885,
-0.39659374952316284,
1.188807725906372,
-0.21778130531311035,
-0.5264422297477722,
0.2991943955421448,
-0.1522030532360077,
-0.17540892958641052,
-0.7157712578773499,
0.5950832962989807,
0.7297104597091675,
0.29632803797721863,
0.09508711844682693,
-0.4289325177669525,
0.48957735300064087,
0.4653797745704651,
-0.5434255003929138,
-0.0028187688440084457,
0.3535217344760895,
-0.04544784873723984,
0.2171710580587387,
0.23785825073719025,
-0.14688341319561005,
0.30673748254776,
-0.18156138062477112,
-0.24549564719200134,
-0.16733933985233307,
-0.4935866594314575,
-0.5533096790313721,
0.6050182580947876,
-0.03600180894136429,
-0.20329363644123077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01216v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01216v1
|
DMON: A Simple yet Effective Approach for Argument Structure Learning
| 2024-05-02T11:56:16 | 2024-05-02T11:56:16 |
Wei Sun, Mingxiao Li, Jingyuan Sun, Jesse Davis, Marie-Francine Moens
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Argument structure learning~(ASL) entails predicting relations between
arguments. Because it can structure a document to facilitate its understanding,
it has been widely applied in many fields~(medical, commercial, and scientific
domains). Despite its broad utilization, ASL remains a challenging task because
it involves examining the complex relationships between the sentences in a
potentially unstructured discourse. To resolve this problem, we have developed
a simple yet effective approach called Dual-tower Multi-scale cOnvolution
neural Network~(DMON) for the ASL task. Specifically, we organize arguments
into a relationship matrix that together with the argument embeddings forms a
relationship tensor and design a mechanism to capture relations with contextual
arguments. Experimental results on three different-domain argument mining
datasets demonstrate that our framework outperforms state-of-the-art models.
The code is available at https://github.com/VRCMF/DMON.git .
|
[
-0.23984870314598083,
-0.9173666834831238,
0.4083864390850067,
0.04323205351829529,
-0.5081648826599121,
0.020150328055024147,
-0.1454268991947174,
-0.10846368968486786,
-0.22159017622470856,
0.024322012439370155,
-0.3828500807285309,
-0.5401785373687744,
-0.6606075167655945,
-0.20897983014583588,
-0.08772973716259003,
0.9550653696060181,
-0.07055754959583282,
0.43666744232177734,
-0.16890566051006317,
-0.4289120137691498,
-0.3593783378601074,
-0.4327816665172577,
-1.2836241722106934,
-0.6172187328338623,
0.7569209933280945,
0.5981829166412354,
0.39629098773002625,
0.8275378346443176,
0.27405765652656555,
0.28440266847610474,
-0.26551273465156555,
0.30213111639022827,
0.0701703429222107,
0.23920562863349915,
-0.07688921689987183,
-0.18050482869148254,
-0.5744627118110657,
-0.14981184899806976,
0.6280092597007751,
0.8746713995933533,
-0.1588626205921173,
0.17132844030857086,
0.023152729496359825,
0.6912579536437988,
-0.16761501133441925,
0.3507436215877533,
-0.7872287034988403,
0.14653280377388,
-0.39245718717575073,
-0.09914108365774155,
-0.2369806468486786,
0.03260543942451477,
0.3377910852432251,
-0.5044957399368286,
0.06731792539358139,
0.17017631232738495,
0.7765035033226013,
0.25645530223846436,
-0.8358579874038696,
-0.6893693804740906,
-0.22077184915542603,
0.5758424401283264,
-0.5701924562454224,
0.23962606489658356,
0.09653771668672562,
0.3338324725627899,
-0.19218099117279053,
-0.9721772074699402,
-0.32051974534988403,
-0.3957682251930237,
-0.29078298807144165,
0.2475389689207077,
-0.16045138239860535,
0.20542322099208832,
0.3862762153148651,
0.3094969093799591,
-0.47328487038612366,
-0.021518005058169365,
-0.505914032459259,
0.05382733792066574,
0.6180782318115234,
0.06468807905912399,
0.16372331976890564,
-0.38991475105285645,
-0.6962334513664246,
-0.09655679017305374,
-0.6015459299087524,
0.2719895839691162,
0.2829206883907318,
0.3948761820793152,
-0.019671181216835976,
0.19158729910850525,
0.3723195791244507,
0.6293662786483765,
0.31409770250320435,
0.2695135474205017,
-0.12126821279525757,
0.06120973825454712,
-0.39031916856765747,
0.5970180034637451,
0.8690471649169922,
0.01898161508142948,
0.19135220348834991,
0.3040332794189453,
0.1536780595779419,
0.20121407508850098,
0.47739797830581665,
-0.8288007378578186,
-0.5499098300933838,
0.19842466711997986,
-0.7070923447608948,
-0.21733161807060242,
-0.11306276172399521,
-0.8305813670158386,
-0.4822779595851898,
-0.4208053946495056,
0.20741504430770874,
-0.5083044767379761,
-0.2776692807674408,
0.22975967824459076,
-0.10481297224760056,
-0.007696657441556454,
0.33636507391929626,
-0.7988807559013367,
0.6317546367645264,
0.6227421760559082,
0.7371504306793213,
0.023430107161402702,
-0.0985393077135086,
-0.8453606367111206,
0.10177675634622574,
-0.20668260753154755,
0.9258046746253967,
-0.48180732131004333,
-0.2738228440284729,
0.06652207672595978,
-0.4805338978767395,
-0.01443612389266491,
-0.6545961499214172,
1.0130655765533447,
-0.5328330397605896,
0.009306048043072224,
0.0839853584766388,
-0.6142553091049194,
-0.418445885181427,
0.5006369352340698,
-0.8161559700965881,
0.6465639472007751,
-0.269013375043869,
-0.658714771270752,
0.12281834334135056,
-0.9208714365959167,
-0.8686153888702393,
0.09019386023283005,
-0.5378881692886353,
-0.7970226407051086,
0.2637312114238739,
0.17349500954151154,
0.6784734725952148,
-0.21465586125850677,
0.36156386137008667,
-0.3887903690338135,
0.017450738698244095,
0.04988124966621399,
-0.3331088125705719,
0.8800084590911865,
0.3362618088722229,
-0.1932399868965149,
0.2414415180683136,
-0.8730122447013855,
-0.26037317514419556,
0.1779659539461136,
-0.46707049012184143,
-0.5297472476959229,
0.22788648307323456,
-0.3007022738456726,
0.16693049669265747,
0.14093095064163208,
-0.6106634736061096,
0.15975812077522278,
-0.48296377062797546,
0.40651935338974,
0.5425178408622742,
-0.08128170669078827,
0.2472340613603592,
0.03455048426985741,
0.16489146649837494,
0.4569441080093384,
-0.2342452108860016,
-0.0015861137071624398,
-0.35052725672721863,
-0.5519221425056458,
-0.11613570153713226,
0.12799838185310364,
0.27278372645378113,
-0.5465924143791199,
0.01003330945968628,
-0.0630006268620491,
-0.18419712781906128,
-0.32948037981987,
0.19744445383548737,
0.6306554079055786,
0.78687983751297,
0.5141875147819519,
0.11331645399332047,
-0.8249707221984863,
-0.9350557923316956,
-0.32487136125564575,
-0.41452857851982117,
0.1359112560749054,
0.30643871426582336,
0.41560813784599304,
-0.013960443437099457,
0.5375967025756836,
-0.6423091888427734,
-0.5169709324836731,
-0.18210731446743011,
0.22918027639389038,
0.2086191177368164,
0.22377106547355652,
0.32958048582077026,
-1.0700443983078003,
-0.8424491286277771,
0.29993200302124023,
-0.9070809483528137,
0.11564184725284576,
-0.03270939737558365,
0.04368479549884796,
-0.14025646448135376,
0.6817875504493713,
-0.5084360241889954,
0.31948575377464294,
0.16878025233745575,
-0.3479526937007904,
0.39523035287857056,
-0.26274892687797546,
-0.20165908336639404,
-1.4650565385818481,
-0.04195600748062134,
0.31419670581817627,
-0.11842440813779831,
-0.7783801555633545,
-0.18629737198352814,
0.28942281007766724,
0.019173365086317062,
-0.36194026470184326,
0.5172610282897949,
-0.4273136854171753,
0.3402610421180725,
-0.13940782845020294,
0.15889474749565125,
0.16627758741378784,
0.6379138231277466,
0.13352017104625702,
0.17166365683078766,
0.3995642066001892,
-0.5067679286003113,
0.6208832263946533,
0.34122374653816223,
-0.13502247631549835,
1.0579215288162231,
-0.7502953410148621,
-0.04112076759338379,
-0.12584622204303741,
0.30861350893974304,
-1.0195311307907104,
0.13179399073123932,
0.24174118041992188,
-0.41617169976234436,
0.672714114189148,
-0.3566613793373108,
-0.12174699455499649,
-0.37732672691345215,
-0.5044616460800171,
0.3783729672431946,
-0.173761785030365,
-0.8561925888061523,
0.5289527177810669,
0.5515696406364441,
0.049598924815654755,
-0.7640965580940247,
-0.5979756712913513,
0.12559613585472107,
-0.6534978151321411,
-0.6124693751335144,
0.6214200854301453,
-0.12455292046070099,
-0.5150772929191589,
0.1823226809501648,
-0.12409821152687073,
-0.07087242603302002,
0.12508513033390045,
0.35177579522132874,
0.028753427788615227,
-0.5725001096725464,
0.5359862446784973,
0.020924344658851624,
-0.09492097049951553,
0.1891106367111206,
-0.29805251955986023,
0.14732354879379272,
-0.28622353076934814,
-0.10076916962862015,
-0.4270429015159607,
0.7339849472045898,
0.6371182203292847,
-0.09574873000383377,
0.29893845319747925,
0.3823820650577545,
-0.6190473437309265,
-0.5553333759307861,
-0.20110970735549927,
-0.1328798234462738,
-0.45041942596435547,
0.5375112891197205,
-0.8726298213005066,
-0.7241241931915283,
0.3781191110610962,
-0.49447059631347656,
0.40409356355667114,
0.5056735277175903,
0.6410337686538696,
-0.11790565401315689,
0.9486217498779297,
0.050626397132873535,
0.056768953800201416,
0.4423067569732666,
-0.2903634309768677,
0.34613457322120667,
-1.119690179824829,
-0.12196828424930573,
-0.24615523219108582,
-0.5876240134239197,
0.021080825477838516,
-0.24374137818813324,
0.27860337495803833,
0.22434112429618835,
-0.42811262607574463,
0.25665780901908875,
-0.49940255284309387,
0.08915618062019348,
0.25319960713386536,
-0.16075541079044342,
0.3287355601787567,
0.3470167815685272,
-0.4219911992549896,
0.08497201651334763,
-0.7049472332000732,
-0.5170857310295105,
0.8723515868186951,
0.520907461643219,
0.5683996677398682,
0.19150656461715698,
0.5397272706031799,
0.25401538610458374,
0.4170587658882141,
-1.192491054534912,
0.4167039096355438,
-0.7293100953102112,
-0.5071457624435425,
-0.1089688390493393,
-0.6071113348007202,
-1.3421399593353271,
0.7211514115333557,
0.08443064987659454,
-0.5056735277175903,
-0.12974780797958374,
0.2534477114677429,
-0.6437976360321045,
0.47895607352256775,
-0.6170079708099365,
1.0670865774154663,
-0.43250033259391785,
-0.39635875821113586,
-0.3708318769931793,
-0.5764050483703613,
0.22895929217338562,
0.27251699566841125,
-0.012164849787950516,
-0.0033759409561753273,
0.31740689277648926,
0.7867301106452942,
-0.3644524812698364,
0.6700740456581116,
-0.2482970505952835,
0.015352986752986908,
0.42507031559944153,
-0.04343338683247566,
0.041944198310375214,
0.4963664412498474,
-0.2119109332561493,
-0.03210590034723282,
0.009470508433878422,
-0.017343489453196526,
-0.8342391848564148,
0.7876226305961609,
-0.71686851978302,
-0.5967986583709717,
-0.3142932951450348,
-0.39614900946617126,
-0.15003202855587006,
-0.06626911461353302,
-0.14827783405780792,
0.9321703314781189,
-0.3598502576351166,
0.3114263713359833,
0.6467234492301941,
0.15236830711364746,
0.5245785713195801,
0.4874143600463867,
0.3100983500480652,
-0.6221485137939453,
0.5630035996437073,
0.2870715260505676,
-0.3926624357700348,
0.3630271255970001,
0.6700218915939331,
-0.5737170577049255,
-0.47142305970191956,
-0.903789222240448,
0.12484855204820633,
-0.7059872150421143,
-0.5181649923324585,
-0.7745638489723206,
-0.34360218048095703,
-0.06193071976304054,
-0.04837118461728096,
-0.3824594020843506,
-0.3907102346420288,
-0.14124254882335663,
-0.1669904738664627,
0.2826724946498871,
0.794246256351471,
0.19089528918266296,
0.18724679946899414,
-0.5166440010070801,
0.2928389012813568,
0.4817207455635071,
0.24771298468112946,
0.3574581742286682,
-0.20420163869857788,
-0.1274598091840744,
0.08029728382825851,
-0.5852769017219543,
-0.7538424134254456,
0.11838600784540176,
0.3273143768310547,
0.6722139716148376,
0.6190832853317261,
0.10258455574512482,
0.8445297479629517,
-0.8203819990158081,
0.5898119211196899,
0.35264745354652405,
-0.7159742116928101,
0.6246634721755981,
-0.038668353110551834,
0.09653224050998688,
0.4604487419128418,
0.28727203607559204,
-0.31443098187446594,
0.23412340879440308,
-0.6664255261421204,
-0.614992618560791,
0.6746289134025574,
-0.22275136411190033,
-0.06851862370967865,
0.013595924712717533,
0.5386267304420471,
0.005190795753151178,
0.2345529943704605,
-0.6343291997909546,
-0.33270153403282166,
-0.10337924212217331,
-0.6220951080322266,
0.13251416385173798,
-0.2643825113773346,
-0.4159974753856659,
-0.45540082454681396,
0.3221317231655121,
-0.20263776183128357,
-0.07803408056497574,
0.22333286702632904,
-0.11630130559206009,
-0.1614612638950348,
0.18322250247001648,
0.6538629531860352,
0.2358824908733368,
-0.1726703941822052,
0.8748608827590942,
0.32872769236564636,
-0.4458751380443573,
0.18780773878097534,
0.21607297658920288,
0.39468348026275635,
0.07080910354852676,
0.20687997341156006,
0.8409209847450256,
0.2756993770599365,
-0.24063409864902496,
0.45694538950920105,
-0.40690597891807556,
-0.5494641065597534,
-0.41840946674346924,
-0.39976733922958374,
0.2605831027030945,
0.44152864813804626,
0.23265276849269867,
0.0008244374766945839,
0.08944470435380936,
-0.6947683691978455,
0.5707097053527832,
0.5932415723800659,
-0.5330622792243958,
-0.4340056777000427,
0.6477690935134888,
0.1472626030445099,
-0.4215683937072754,
0.43279650807380676,
-0.12171042710542679,
-0.8090465664863586,
0.5667901635169983,
0.7694227695465088,
0.7401989102363586,
-0.13688932359218597,
0.2089691460132599,
0.41347208619117737,
-0.17560185492038727,
-0.03213367238640785,
0.0003712270990945399,
-0.22788135707378387,
-0.7080578804016113,
-0.007565853651612997,
-0.6296875476837158,
-0.22048018872737885,
0.2470053732395172,
-0.39105769991874695,
0.2482602298259735,
-0.6562148332595825,
-0.013271067291498184,
0.24899452924728394,
0.7409706115722656,
-0.40417689085006714,
0.081851065158844,
0.2989318370819092,
0.6057369112968445,
-0.5927963256835938,
1.1642645597457886,
1.3036061525344849,
-0.20624977350234985,
-0.8432708382606506,
-0.06660723686218262,
0.13152877986431122,
-0.3446601629257202,
0.8458680510520935,
0.28770923614501953,
-0.35822921991348267,
-0.14226561784744263,
-0.1867886185646057,
-0.46942469477653503,
0.95452481508255,
0.45853036642074585,
-0.12786731123924255,
0.2681969106197357,
-0.14146585762500763,
0.5882213115692139,
-0.6976704001426697,
-0.030400030314922333,
0.2275305539369583,
0.3568611443042755,
0.37088558077812195,
-0.3146406412124634,
0.2795211672782898,
-0.41168197989463806,
-0.11710086464881897,
0.1286591738462448,
-0.6685727834701538,
1.05643892288208,
0.06234797090291977,
-0.36041370034217834,
-0.35190045833587646,
0.8445584774017334,
0.3555734157562256,
0.7181481122970581,
0.7209285497665405,
0.6597142219543457,
0.8376999497413635,
0.30675244331359863,
0.7353367805480957,
-0.1327604353427887,
0.10063628852367401,
1.1929361820220947,
-0.34488624334335327,
0.9553613662719727,
0.4613991677761078,
0.14934112131595612,
0.67647385597229,
0.5852622389793396,
0.04089159518480301,
0.2967442274093628,
0.5620954036712646,
-0.2609761655330658,
-0.19582819938659668,
-0.10948354750871658,
-0.028614114969968796,
0.3932802379131317,
0.8098356127738953,
-0.2811458706855774,
-0.4703867733478546,
-0.37756261229515076,
0.2909836173057556,
0.3455466330051422,
-0.44278934597969055,
0.7293416857719421,
0.574160635471344,
-0.8104372024536133,
0.4940205216407776,
-0.001686123083345592,
0.5039975047111511,
-0.6344962120056152,
-0.21252083778381348,
0.02781614102423191,
0.6819716691970825,
-0.29622119665145874,
-0.6018765568733215,
0.5445305109024048,
-0.09207748621702194,
-0.16068677604198456,
-0.22757786512374878,
0.8136299252510071,
-0.6674767732620239,
-0.41401076316833496,
0.6049700975418091,
0.4774721562862396,
-0.11283084750175476,
0.0414847806096077,
-0.9393764734268188,
-0.1504950374364853,
-0.22044697403907776,
-0.3347429037094116,
0.31151849031448364,
0.4925677478313446,
-0.23369985818862915,
0.2957395315170288,
0.45984938740730286,
0.014794544316828251,
-0.08318924903869629,
0.11648499220609665,
0.8551486730575562,
-0.21196229755878448,
-0.19791707396507263,
-1.3481868505477905,
0.6098665595054626,
-0.6002741456031799,
-0.31537750363349915,
0.7065014839172363,
0.5011639595031738,
0.48550498485565186,
0.1432170271873474,
0.3980286419391632,
0.2552589774131775,
0.1577402502298355,
-0.35799354314804077,
0.7136815786361694,
-0.8395013809204102,
0.02112424746155739,
0.03537282720208168,
-0.5044828057289124,
-0.8097745776176453,
0.9821819067001343,
-0.09476082026958466,
-0.40925338864326477,
0.9201029539108276,
0.4854118525981903,
-0.4241011440753937,
0.1223551407456398,
0.3413940966129303,
0.10089389979839325,
0.5748634338378906,
0.866658627986908,
0.7999179363250732,
-0.4398003816604614,
0.6587319374084473,
0.07242316007614136,
-0.2538187801837921,
-0.17940722405910492,
-0.7762086987495422,
-1.3291152715682983,
-0.6587832570075989,
-0.6780773997306824,
-0.21573887765407562,
-0.07074026018381119,
1.050113320350647,
0.8552997708320618,
-0.7774716019630432,
-0.6109231114387512,
-0.12023274600505829,
0.2580321133136749,
-0.38210615515708923,
-0.1019955724477768,
0.8391487002372742,
-0.42049509286880493,
-0.5153968334197998,
0.5556219816207886,
0.4030281603336334,
-0.3882092833518982,
-0.043430883437395096,
0.010463258251547813,
-0.6911744475364685,
0.26740792393684387,
0.8094559907913208,
0.08100787550210953,
-0.6178269386291504,
-0.3063015639781952,
-0.4330505132675171,
-0.18439064919948578,
0.36897292733192444,
1.0786715745925903,
-0.5019673109054565,
0.5515400767326355,
0.35094642639160156,
0.6587722897529602,
0.3428477346897125,
0.06929057836532593,
0.6110748648643494,
-1.055898904800415,
-0.02926144376397133,
0.05443169176578522,
0.6739007830619812,
0.3047371506690979,
-0.30337437987327576,
0.4606127440929413,
-0.0210970938205719,
-0.34669744968414307,
-0.6626567840576172,
0.4935630261898041,
-1.0732060670852661,
-0.4460523724555969,
1.0718261003494263,
-0.44873443245887756,
-0.22378085553646088,
-0.1894495189189911,
-0.5745485424995422,
0.5414713621139526,
-0.3179965317249298,
0.7868061065673828,
0.522260308265686,
-0.17374375462532043,
-0.15333408117294312,
-0.5460962057113647,
0.8430943489074707,
0.4293912351131439,
-0.5154777765274048,
0.16689187288284302,
0.22441615164279938,
0.012423553504049778,
0.35078373551368713,
0.30360230803489685,
-0.08972135186195374,
0.02501765824854374,
0.027677854523062706,
-0.5232877731323242,
-0.31047874689102173,
-0.33145153522491455,
-0.4773221015930176,
0.8141834139823914,
0.05067377910017967,
-0.4785618782043457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01159v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01159v1
|
TartuNLP at EvaLatin 2024: Emotion Polarity Detection
| 2024-05-02T10:28:52 | 2024-05-02T10:28:52 |
Aleksei Dorkin, Kairit Sirts
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents the TartuNLP team submission to EvaLatin 2024 shared task
of the emotion polarity detection for historical Latin texts. Our system relies
on two distinct approaches to annotating training data for supervised learning:
1) creating heuristics-based labels by adopting the polarity lexicon provided
by the organizers and 2) generating labels with GPT4. We employed parameter
efficient fine-tuning using the adapters framework and experimented with both
monolingual and cross-lingual knowledge transfer for training language and task
adapters. Our submission with the LLM-generated labels achieved the overall
first place in the emotion polarity detection task. Our results show that
LLM-based annotations show promising results on texts in Latin.
|
[
-0.531844973564148,
-0.2095126211643219,
0.5669875741004944,
0.2901097238063812,
-0.49381309747695923,
0.08607583492994308,
-0.4012436270713806,
-0.5525646209716797,
0.648335874080658,
0.3022533655166626,
-0.3645034432411194,
-0.9017541408538818,
-0.5482349395751953,
0.40879127383232117,
-0.22837412357330322,
1.4845882654190063,
-0.41851285099983215,
0.2633487582206726,
-0.035210151225328445,
-0.5615176558494568,
0.020769672468304634,
-0.7392414212226868,
-0.7850996255874634,
-0.4524601697921753,
0.8035539388656616,
0.5311312079429626,
0.31385692954063416,
0.19585596024990082,
0.3667231798171997,
0.21271999180316925,
-0.19459769129753113,
-0.26465561985969543,
-0.3481122851371765,
0.4180273115634918,
-0.1573546975851059,
-0.6961929798126221,
-0.5461853742599487,
0.08573376387357712,
0.5448673367500305,
0.08291184902191162,
0.11440108716487885,
0.21250303089618683,
-0.103953056037426,
0.9295507073402405,
-0.3610493540763855,
0.3841969966888428,
-0.4213334918022156,
0.34146666526794434,
-0.2504029870033264,
-0.24838408827781677,
-0.42581266164779663,
-0.26018399000167847,
-0.24747683107852936,
-0.41471660137176514,
0.3685542047023773,
0.33316969871520996,
0.611500084400177,
0.3586370050907135,
-0.2832382619380951,
-0.2763107120990753,
-0.5503933429718018,
0.6792512536048889,
-0.37514370679855347,
0.29502812027931213,
0.13710255920886993,
-0.05073227733373642,
0.23205983638763428,
-0.46124640107154846,
-0.4179864227771759,
0.14226731657981873,
0.07454941421747208,
0.3319467306137085,
-0.29613789916038513,
-0.014931044541299343,
0.08516129106283188,
0.14899510145187378,
-0.43866196274757385,
0.1600589007139206,
-0.35847917199134827,
-0.0327625572681427,
0.7007697820663452,
-0.05047651752829552,
0.2887798845767975,
-0.15952938795089722,
-0.4608137309551239,
-0.11678476631641388,
-0.6109092235565186,
-0.08586107939481735,
0.6754551529884338,
0.07665245980024338,
-0.4566024839878082,
0.4590598940849304,
0.004065359476953745,
0.24899767339229584,
-0.05991492047905922,
0.4734445810317993,
0.2868160009384155,
-0.16078831255435944,
0.032013535499572754,
0.37678298354148865,
0.9040520787239075,
0.3080756962299347,
0.24806931614875793,
-0.13207510113716125,
-0.2826255261898041,
0.08073864877223969,
0.14786399900913239,
-0.5572092533111572,
-0.25728094577789307,
0.3236437737941742,
-0.14695943892002106,
-0.5089341402053833,
-0.027143139392137527,
-1.2689214944839478,
-0.4519161880016327,
-0.40731731057167053,
0.1295287162065506,
-0.3036399185657501,
-0.17068402469158173,
-0.05574264004826546,
-0.06769482791423798,
-0.02109093964099884,
0.38941359519958496,
-0.9038611650466919,
0.11163380742073059,
0.867161750793457,
0.7582594752311707,
-0.43432846665382385,
-0.09287199378013611,
-0.469525545835495,
-0.18690893054008484,
-0.07483859360218048,
0.9396355152130127,
-0.42800459265708923,
0.09572155773639679,
0.055603258311748505,
0.14252744615077972,
-0.014826320111751556,
-0.20902837812900543,
0.9406231045722961,
-0.36823761463165283,
0.3213609457015991,
-0.34390199184417725,
-0.43269073963165283,
-0.2150566726922989,
0.15047724545001984,
-0.7117124795913696,
1.1356196403503418,
0.23960840702056885,
-1.0557491779327393,
0.2243470847606659,
-0.5651850700378418,
-0.1764174997806549,
0.3137056827545166,
0.06732217967510223,
-0.752734899520874,
0.13301247358322144,
0.03390589728951454,
0.5573404431343079,
-0.14932870864868164,
0.5385762453079224,
-0.3119606673717499,
-0.11239468306303024,
0.1791662573814392,
-0.035204894840717316,
0.6519138216972351,
0.0678468719124794,
-0.814525306224823,
0.48233768343925476,
-0.5226908326148987,
-0.26201629638671875,
-0.002790922997519374,
-0.15932443737983704,
-0.2883610427379608,
-0.19201083481311798,
0.305512011051178,
0.15137994289398193,
0.16255582869052887,
-0.5417429804801941,
0.22203481197357178,
-0.1744532287120819,
0.1616995483636856,
0.8680223226547241,
-0.3555126190185547,
0.426593154668808,
-0.06254488229751587,
1.0148557424545288,
-0.15414263308048248,
0.059857215732336044,
0.1324620246887207,
-0.474723219871521,
-1.0344821214675903,
-0.08207527548074722,
0.23005658388137817,
0.7343260645866394,
-0.8408713936805725,
0.378066748380661,
0.05531227961182594,
-0.48581942915916443,
-0.36128729581832886,
0.08379903435707092,
0.35151779651641846,
0.39167991280555725,
0.5345292091369629,
-0.1314224749803543,
-0.8048456311225891,
-0.9074767231941223,
-0.2803468704223633,
-0.4814070165157318,
0.25178778171539307,
0.27424857020378113,
0.6339967846870422,
-0.05592638626694679,
0.3697529435157776,
-0.191783145070076,
-0.3560011684894562,
-0.46499502658843994,
0.6198534369468689,
0.0038813380524516106,
0.28703901171684265,
0.8502294421195984,
-0.708942711353302,
-0.7293473482131958,
0.10709041357040405,
-0.7848103046417236,
-0.5518284440040588,
0.16207492351531982,
-0.16156010329723358,
0.6459835171699524,
0.3640219271183014,
-0.08076556026935577,
0.20131009817123413,
0.7976599335670471,
-0.5604725480079651,
0.45678409934043884,
0.04873811453580856,
0.31861698627471924,
-1.0946084260940552,
-0.0008708687382750213,
0.19550670683383942,
-0.40685123205184937,
-0.6463595032691956,
-0.4051170349121094,
0.13037490844726562,
0.020643455907702446,
-0.5822009444236755,
0.5461252331733704,
-0.38255178928375244,
0.17897742986679077,
-0.04510747641324997,
0.1186174750328064,
-0.1530027836561203,
0.4435634911060333,
0.28089919686317444,
0.539567768573761,
0.5004031658172607,
0.02214147336781025,
0.574023962020874,
0.2763952910900116,
0.24162793159484863,
0.9370201826095581,
-0.2876962423324585,
0.08640223741531372,
-0.45365995168685913,
0.1776137799024582,
-0.8560842275619507,
-0.07333481311798096,
0.446647584438324,
-0.24981476366519928,
0.40811851620674133,
-0.4563037157058716,
-0.19086124002933502,
-0.32971176505088806,
-0.5487773418426514,
0.597941517829895,
0.3628554940223694,
-0.4796309173107147,
0.7171932458877563,
0.27749302983283997,
-0.4508928060531616,
-0.4212079346179962,
-0.21962273120880127,
0.31177544593811035,
-0.6499089002609253,
-0.5383486747741699,
0.09753716737031937,
0.006200716830790043,
-0.24576634168624878,
-0.18783868849277496,
0.22522743046283722,
0.2244596779346466,
0.018643388524651527,
0.41464295983314514,
0.2955690324306488,
-0.1978304088115692,
0.22189287841320038,
0.1850689947605133,
-0.23455730080604553,
0.2689987123012543,
-0.12175016850233078,
0.5822231769561768,
-0.6354546546936035,
-0.0014203113969415426,
-0.46535491943359375,
0.2965969443321228,
0.41881063580513,
0.0031633139587938786,
0.7402905821800232,
0.9256187677383423,
-0.17198796570301056,
-0.20005278289318085,
-0.6018269062042236,
-0.08129296451807022,
-0.36303460597991943,
0.005901718977838755,
0.036342207342386246,
-0.8151559233665466,
0.5715920925140381,
-0.015828678384423256,
-0.19725002348423004,
0.5378813147544861,
0.7046262621879578,
-0.2924715578556061,
0.7011684775352478,
0.7185083031654358,
-0.3125133812427521,
0.7089806795120239,
-0.18684934079647064,
0.11617332696914673,
-0.9001798629760742,
-0.17242519557476044,
-0.7143580913543701,
-0.4760490953922272,
-0.5779803395271301,
-0.3194475769996643,
0.3825789988040924,
-0.06720732152462006,
0.12672024965286255,
0.34583863615989685,
-0.5636659860610962,
0.33008426427841187,
0.3396352529525757,
-0.027097063139081,
0.23332808911800385,
-0.13314250111579895,
0.17304109036922455,
-0.3514561951160431,
-0.500467836856842,
-0.5987799167633057,
1.1283515691757202,
0.3646385371685028,
0.46100670099258423,
-0.1134694293141365,
1.036532998085022,
0.29196983575820923,
0.9886552691459656,
-0.6277925372123718,
0.41756680607795715,
-0.2024235725402832,
-0.37353283166885376,
-0.07814231514930725,
-0.18160268664360046,
-0.834895670413971,
0.09144312143325806,
-0.3785732090473175,
-0.7530162334442139,
0.11209290474653244,
0.24320167303085327,
0.08064484596252441,
0.34343934059143066,
-0.5911816954612732,
0.901441752910614,
-0.47902005910873413,
-0.3996085226535797,
0.07395332306623459,
-0.5662484765052795,
0.12003093212842941,
0.035893864929676056,
0.30780303478240967,
-0.18883071839809418,
0.01541216392070055,
1.1552562713623047,
0.11579877138137817,
0.9603664875030518,
-0.18463841080665588,
-0.05004351958632469,
0.27425137162208557,
0.11428523063659668,
0.4677780568599701,
0.3500961661338806,
-0.12078408896923065,
0.2909995913505554,
-0.004590893164277077,
-0.1833779215812683,
-0.2112962007522583,
0.5848175883293152,
-0.6373816728591919,
-0.42674919962882996,
-0.7249292135238647,
-0.58840012550354,
0.08599727600812912,
-0.02207314781844616,
0.28601816296577454,
0.02251763828098774,
-0.22475971281528473,
0.06091390922665596,
0.6874403357505798,
-0.10563553869724274,
0.39718449115753174,
0.40704166889190674,
-0.26135900616645813,
-0.6963315606117249,
0.9273561239242554,
-0.198320209980011,
-0.05556705594062805,
0.30344048142433167,
0.22786416113376617,
-0.045522093772888184,
-0.500873327255249,
-0.48354482650756836,
0.5465638041496277,
-0.5881641507148743,
-0.3011418282985687,
-0.7679344415664673,
0.16235113143920898,
-0.377270370721817,
-0.46726733446121216,
-0.573634147644043,
-0.4322068989276886,
-0.6716403365135193,
-0.2648143768310547,
0.5608683228492737,
0.822758674621582,
-0.23373141884803772,
0.26791614294052124,
-0.45050784945487976,
0.19844071567058563,
-0.0810246467590332,
0.24639581143856049,
-0.5943614840507507,
-0.3822348713874817,
-0.17296917736530304,
-0.22427918016910553,
-0.43721798062324524,
-1.0611201524734497,
0.6188260912895203,
0.14636798202991486,
0.18713724613189697,
0.33330148458480835,
0.19413836300373077,
-0.10571031272411346,
-0.2207680493593216,
0.7370426654815674,
0.20265795290470123,
-1.0016844272613525,
0.7304748296737671,
-0.46664881706237793,
-0.030984025448560715,
0.608188807964325,
0.7109354138374329,
-0.6430636048316956,
-0.7048909664154053,
-0.764398992061615,
-1.0560206174850464,
0.8063444495201111,
0.27560165524482727,
-0.07850991189479828,
0.18052400648593903,
0.5852049589157104,
0.30684733390808105,
0.1991545706987381,
-1.0556163787841797,
-0.35638052225112915,
-0.1686812788248062,
-0.7359188199043274,
-0.2379574477672577,
-0.4819471538066864,
-0.35420796275138855,
-0.2912309169769287,
0.8119513988494873,
-0.3847680389881134,
0.25112035870552063,
0.15825727581977844,
-0.01822163723409176,
-0.3514604866504669,
0.5216480493545532,
0.7704808712005615,
0.2674905061721802,
-0.23092536628246307,
0.4090147018432617,
0.1800961047410965,
-0.40403497219085693,
0.12388844043016434,
0.19984905421733856,
-0.2808292508125305,
0.1046309843659401,
0.3776189088821411,
1.100640892982483,
0.0668535828590393,
-0.3905090391635895,
0.5448601245880127,
-0.2609941065311432,
-0.2456662356853485,
-0.6422001719474792,
-0.11149898171424866,
0.05723420903086662,
0.4573012888431549,
0.08887417614459991,
-0.13295039534568787,
0.032074395567178726,
-0.3460336923599243,
0.05719294771552086,
0.4602349102497101,
-0.8346028923988342,
-0.8629863262176514,
0.9597923755645752,
0.24502356350421906,
-0.3648430407047272,
0.11407505720853806,
-0.3063199520111084,
-1.2802824974060059,
0.6004948019981384,
0.3912235498428345,
1.031554102897644,
-0.3339681625366211,
0.6517833471298218,
0.3986843228340149,
0.32496213912963867,
-0.18177440762519836,
0.5730358362197876,
-0.10107916593551636,
-0.6670109629631042,
0.06567686796188354,
-0.6155152320861816,
-0.634797990322113,
-0.07490792125463486,
-0.7201278209686279,
0.6339713931083679,
-0.32712605595588684,
-0.12230194360017776,
-0.08100172132253647,
-0.2669338881969452,
-0.6968854069709778,
-0.008314404636621475,
0.4347091615200043,
0.35934823751449585,
-1.4598749876022339,
0.38967761397361755,
1.013065218925476,
-0.19385771453380585,
-0.3618645966053009,
-0.5873628258705139,
0.1117972880601883,
-0.5476053953170776,
0.7047576904296875,
0.18722355365753174,
0.03675343096256256,
-0.13367998600006104,
-0.6777719855308533,
-0.567609429359436,
0.9646680951118469,
0.4472839832305908,
-0.4292035400867462,
0.2642256021499634,
0.2188570201396942,
1.0014852285385132,
-0.43567243218421936,
0.21528688073158264,
0.4444428086280823,
0.7839291095733643,
-0.1626271903514862,
-0.570391058921814,
-0.045089878141880035,
-0.2883200943470001,
-0.3980165421962738,
0.3839360773563385,
-0.6765275597572327,
0.6765130162239075,
0.05027944967150688,
-0.22057408094406128,
-0.18804065883159637,
0.768317461013794,
0.0199420303106308,
0.6929829716682434,
0.3945852816104889,
0.7420162558555603,
0.4448237717151642,
-0.4029688239097595,
0.8439263701438904,
-0.35308316349983215,
0.4947769045829773,
0.8852112889289856,
-0.08938241004943848,
0.5549954771995544,
0.6759733557701111,
-0.17201104760169983,
0.4789695143699646,
0.5334507822990417,
-0.017925426363945007,
0.028786230832338333,
0.1285729557275772,
-0.4665946960449219,
-0.20496974885463715,
-0.3361561596393585,
-0.17556367814540863,
0.1689663976430893,
0.3390319347381592,
-0.4132026731967926,
-0.15956361591815948,
0.2541079819202423,
0.37168973684310913,
-0.05187073349952698,
-0.13382740318775177,
0.7565855979919434,
0.20145384967327118,
-0.6413572430610657,
0.4355548620223999,
-0.14359427988529205,
0.6473657488822937,
-0.07139650732278824,
0.07568356394767761,
-0.2558983862400055,
-0.024678483605384827,
-0.425974041223526,
-0.8845896124839783,
0.22625195980072021,
0.17210151255130768,
0.0793628841638565,
-0.6197844743728638,
0.5605813264846802,
-0.7448416948318481,
-0.7174441814422607,
0.4929420053958893,
0.2634635269641876,
0.2739880383014679,
-0.0917658805847168,
-0.45580098032951355,
0.11336838454008102,
0.07241124659776688,
-0.4666193723678589,
0.20358963310718536,
0.6579196453094482,
-0.21234498918056488,
0.46445730328559875,
0.2844374179840088,
0.31468433141708374,
0.019130967557430267,
0.28115954995155334,
0.8181649446487427,
-0.6281956434249878,
-0.2532401978969574,
-0.6637108325958252,
0.5147829651832581,
0.06700565665960312,
-0.3992932140827179,
0.3183862864971161,
0.4991198778152466,
0.5172566771507263,
-0.06908626854419708,
0.6122713685035706,
0.015361178666353226,
0.13124172389507294,
-0.5107705593109131,
0.5812394022941589,
-0.42782342433929443,
0.10558227449655533,
-0.49214449524879456,
-1.106248140335083,
-0.47367629408836365,
0.3987594246864319,
-0.2627134621143341,
-0.2602406144142151,
0.9777094125747681,
0.3846885561943054,
0.15755455195903778,
0.2906985580921173,
0.07556580752134323,
0.2185230255126953,
0.4078810214996338,
0.6196413636207581,
0.6489471793174744,
-0.3793341815471649,
0.2682555913925171,
-0.6799609661102295,
-0.3900076448917389,
-0.3657307028770447,
-1.0903997421264648,
-0.9711531400680542,
-0.911849856376648,
-0.6189861297607422,
-0.4109918177127838,
0.08067609369754791,
0.8135119080543518,
0.053076766431331635,
-1.0994656085968018,
-0.0648229718208313,
-0.06642358005046844,
0.4217066168785095,
0.033711519092321396,
-0.2485944926738739,
0.38634803891181946,
-0.20000006258487701,
-0.786419689655304,
0.06522832810878754,
0.5021679401397705,
0.1912270486354828,
-0.1434812992811203,
0.06493115425109863,
0.020362671464681625,
-0.3396848738193512,
0.48634806275367737,
0.3745841979980469,
-0.4963517189025879,
-0.5488896369934082,
-0.22227013111114502,
0.09158813953399658,
0.2972913086414337,
0.8742814660072327,
-0.4870634078979492,
0.3318983018398285,
0.60684734582901,
0.4017578661441803,
0.6438354253768921,
0.05831386521458626,
0.4648406505584717,
-0.46210065484046936,
0.3239816725254059,
0.5415841341018677,
0.5645332336425781,
0.535230815410614,
-0.5834037661552429,
0.7580118775367737,
0.36846214532852173,
-0.689254879951477,
-0.8158096075057983,
0.06856565177440643,
-1.346717119216919,
0.2513643503189087,
1.3033367395401,
-0.15939553081989288,
-0.45168834924697876,
-0.23685406148433685,
-0.34716248512268066,
0.32407283782958984,
-0.5693358778953552,
1.0243695974349976,
0.752699077129364,
-0.4058302342891693,
-0.37349191308021545,
-0.5049009919166565,
0.531715989112854,
0.686332106590271,
-1.033383846282959,
0.0065595246851444244,
0.35844770073890686,
0.18697921931743622,
0.19870057702064514,
0.4341752827167511,
-0.031225882470607758,
0.14011512696743011,
-0.41732847690582275,
0.7035567164421082,
0.07622885704040527,
-0.407113641500473,
-0.4711098074913025,
0.09225206077098846,
-0.11857791990041733,
0.38951680064201355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01139v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01139v2
|
It Couldn't Help But Overhear: On the Limits of Modelling Meta-Communicative Grounding Acts with Supervised Learning
| 2024-05-02T09:55:19 | 2024-05-13T12:18:33 |
Brielen Madureira, David Schlangen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Active participation in a conversation is key to building common ground,
since understanding is jointly tailored by producers and recipients.
Overhearers are deprived of the privilege of performing grounding acts and can
only conjecture about intended meanings. Still, data generation and annotation,
modelling, training and evaluation of NLP dialogue models place reliance on the
overhearing paradigm. How much of the underlying grounding processes are
thereby forfeited? As we show, there is evidence pointing to the impossibility
of properly modelling human meta-communicative acts with data-driven learning
models. In this paper, we discuss this issue and provide a preliminary analysis
on the variability of human decisions for requesting clarification. Most
importantly, we wish to bring this topic back to the community's table,
encouraging discussion on the consequences of having models designed to only
"listen in".
|
[
-0.3696577548980713,
-0.7436604499816895,
0.6284273862838745,
0.09420599788427353,
0.010807942599058151,
-0.18415091931819916,
-0.18358370661735535,
-0.49550890922546387,
0.034745123237371445,
0.7374370694160461,
-0.613926112651825,
-0.18013334274291992,
-0.7283172011375427,
-0.03911262005567551,
-0.4257463812828064,
0.7366880178451538,
0.20328736305236816,
0.13633844256401062,
-0.4222150146961212,
-0.24649471044540405,
-0.7731046080589294,
-0.7286216020584106,
-0.770788848400116,
-0.44940268993377686,
0.31521379947662354,
0.6485354900360107,
0.6016768217086792,
0.4601863920688629,
0.05822838470339775,
0.24833938479423523,
-0.39899566769599915,
-0.002140224678441882,
-0.4593100845813751,
0.21126455068588257,
-0.21338754892349243,
-0.9030072689056396,
-0.18091826140880585,
0.5165071487426758,
0.5337227582931519,
1.2997111082077026,
-0.36856693029403687,
0.025525188073515892,
0.13519014418125153,
0.8545825481414795,
-0.4628724157810211,
0.2853625416755676,
-0.6864871978759766,
0.10311434417963028,
0.08181782811880112,
-0.04424043372273445,
-0.39330387115478516,
0.009697798639535904,
0.5133915543556213,
-0.575231671333313,
0.27861860394477844,
-0.10535038262605667,
0.40502914786338806,
0.6625733375549316,
-0.19412977993488312,
-0.5495019555091858,
-0.6513381004333496,
0.7890239953994751,
-0.3344908058643341,
0.4495101869106293,
0.9964423775672913,
0.21783879399299622,
-0.11877106130123138,
-0.6604251861572266,
-0.224148690700531,
-0.09578990191221237,
-0.07195229083299637,
0.24378640949726105,
-0.1393507421016693,
0.13457831740379333,
0.620928168296814,
0.24177220463752747,
0.14469647407531738,
-0.34788885712623596,
-0.778768002986908,
0.28473180532455444,
0.3832373023033142,
-0.002672062022611499,
-0.024428052827715874,
-0.14683672785758972,
-0.2062726765871048,
0.13117799162864685,
-0.32957279682159424,
0.29425686597824097,
0.21826423704624176,
0.2722032964229584,
-0.03222719207406044,
0.3295450806617737,
-0.3033486306667328,
0.8174687623977661,
0.2291257232427597,
0.22224001586437225,
-0.035200849175453186,
0.2557107210159302,
-0.4533097445964813,
-0.0003519482270348817,
0.42779210209846497,
0.5762364268302917,
0.2741091847419739,
-0.21578609943389893,
0.1839790791273117,
0.2545402944087982,
0.42492616176605225,
-0.56057208776474,
-0.24157221615314484,
0.3701353669166565,
-0.40778082609176636,
-0.3008895218372345,
0.25890979170799255,
-0.7855942845344543,
-0.4310166537761688,
-0.5339275598526001,
0.0679597333073616,
-0.19962717592716217,
-0.38424569368362427,
0.511380136013031,
-0.39187562465667725,
-0.03272997587919235,
0.22678354382514954,
-0.9029785394668579,
0.5301629900932312,
0.6087515354156494,
0.6611971259117126,
0.1742822229862213,
-0.4539954364299774,
-0.33574408292770386,
-0.11597786843776703,
-0.37511107325553894,
0.33812376856803894,
-0.5549429059028625,
-0.6180922985076904,
-0.225557342171669,
0.1186317503452301,
-0.45390135049819946,
-0.5562641024589539,
0.7173930406570435,
-0.22465749084949493,
0.23709802329540253,
-0.6868707537651062,
-0.5734755396842957,
-0.3394912779331207,
0.05869872123003006,
-0.5216652750968933,
0.5841243267059326,
0.08367972820997238,
-0.8136491179466248,
0.7082358598709106,
-0.6160136461257935,
-0.26692092418670654,
-0.10801288485527039,
-0.47681131958961487,
-0.40756914019584656,
0.2708892822265625,
0.2039031833410263,
0.16078589856624603,
-0.18156488239765167,
0.7270697355270386,
-0.4551861882209778,
-0.35037365555763245,
0.5656653046607971,
-0.6535516977310181,
0.9621251821517944,
0.08181613683700562,
-0.4704580307006836,
-0.13811904191970825,
-0.7643153071403503,
0.08715875446796417,
-0.21913926303386688,
-0.17512641847133636,
-0.16118013858795166,
0.2504974901676178,
-0.3182673454284668,
0.5171974301338196,
-0.4465080499649048,
-0.44086259603500366,
-0.01829914003610611,
-0.41924843192100525,
0.7593650817871094,
0.39760300517082214,
-0.11868651211261749,
0.5484679341316223,
-0.8390520215034485,
0.4386923015117645,
-0.20300252735614777,
0.25926434993743896,
-0.2240792065858841,
-0.6859205961227417,
-0.8466655611991882,
-0.20860235393047333,
0.3306439518928528,
0.44616973400115967,
-0.3817213177680969,
0.22054511308670044,
0.016188228502869606,
-0.20976844429969788,
-0.8916649222373962,
-0.019784200936555862,
0.34522783756256104,
0.3748752474784851,
0.3582931160926819,
-0.3148423433303833,
-0.8906505107879639,
-0.5896098017692566,
-0.15418900549411774,
-0.20629271864891052,
-0.10972505807876587,
0.4744013249874115,
0.36881372332572937,
-0.08170470595359802,
1.2474435567855835,
-0.1080341637134552,
-0.4646276533603668,
-0.3019058406352997,
0.30099594593048096,
0.043743133544921875,
0.39569729566574097,
0.5951234698295593,
-0.8636082410812378,
-0.27751144766807556,
-0.3698279559612274,
-0.8537951707839966,
-0.3320833742618561,
-0.26987317204475403,
0.2638359069824219,
-0.005345041397958994,
0.9666187167167664,
-0.9169838428497314,
0.6485381126403809,
0.4350196421146393,
-0.028892744332551956,
0.2072891891002655,
-0.052105147391557693,
-0.11194151639938354,
-0.7315948009490967,
0.25069528818130493,
-0.5792113542556763,
-0.07550417631864548,
-0.6757731437683105,
0.0405692383646965,
-0.1964077353477478,
-0.30728834867477417,
-0.2505132555961609,
0.34651902318000793,
-0.4616740345954895,
0.1622706949710846,
-0.5605100393295288,
0.006027526687830687,
-0.09147252887487411,
0.5232412815093994,
0.43335360288619995,
0.45482945442199707,
0.964570939540863,
-0.60686194896698,
-0.07254941016435623,
0.543671190738678,
-0.35573190450668335,
0.6458185911178589,
-0.8697265982627869,
0.08071156591176987,
-0.18019536137580872,
0.6879321336746216,
-0.7339091897010803,
-0.5930268168449402,
0.3436169922351837,
-0.5351202487945557,
-0.03422877565026283,
-0.6211825609207153,
-0.025846540927886963,
-0.33231160044670105,
-0.0371292307972908,
0.2184033989906311,
0.19708730280399323,
-0.40856388211250305,
0.49630874395370483,
0.6182811260223389,
-0.06029903516173363,
-0.42695534229278564,
-0.6367791295051575,
0.0601004920899868,
-0.2686857581138611,
-0.6339593529701233,
-0.10812073200941086,
0.031303662806749344,
-0.4598478376865387,
-0.3809790015220642,
-0.391611248254776,
-0.2052011638879776,
0.3058726489543915,
0.9606121778488159,
-0.3155955672264099,
-0.016438227146863937,
0.33223164081573486,
-0.24365954101085663,
-0.4142422676086426,
0.4313339591026306,
-0.3935106694698334,
0.3078911304473877,
0.13418227434158325,
-0.7328475117683411,
-0.36956408619880676,
0.7278841733932495,
0.8783431053161621,
0.09113863855600357,
0.5862781405448914,
0.2632920742034912,
-0.15630517899990082,
-0.1400323212146759,
-0.460273414850235,
-0.18967105448246002,
-0.46407878398895264,
-0.03994768485426903,
-0.22499585151672363,
-0.7588337659835815,
0.3892468214035034,
-0.04498632624745369,
0.06804795563220978,
0.15005375444889069,
0.20958974957466125,
-0.30381372570991516,
0.8174466490745544,
0.5895459055900574,
0.008346138522028923,
0.42313486337661743,
-0.22837533056735992,
-0.06869365274906158,
-0.46886903047561646,
-0.046903159469366074,
-0.5278354287147522,
-0.22891725599765778,
-0.5286514759063721,
-0.2644532024860382,
0.21604302525520325,
0.03747199475765228,
0.49847912788391113,
-0.047696128487586975,
-0.2858488857746124,
0.395914763212204,
0.709631085395813,
0.34808969497680664,
-0.03155091404914856,
-0.33769822120666504,
0.13590174913406372,
-0.1795804798603058,
-0.8533951640129089,
-0.29214656352996826,
0.9247930645942688,
0.3559277653694153,
0.630105197429657,
-0.04637335240840912,
0.29827582836151123,
-0.05102108418941498,
0.0643875002861023,
-0.7386643886566162,
0.3622685968875885,
0.25888168811798096,
-0.8926516175270081,
-0.37571245431900024,
-0.21317623555660248,
-0.9408863186836243,
0.2910038232803345,
-0.22264239192008972,
-0.6359311938285828,
0.4334617257118225,
-0.014748463407158852,
-0.5129224061965942,
0.1485576182603836,
-0.6171128749847412,
0.7174316048622131,
0.2548372447490692,
-0.09994867444038391,
-0.1309347301721573,
-1.0359883308410645,
0.14262723922729492,
-0.16221024096012115,
0.4052087068557739,
0.17121711373329163,
0.5794770121574402,
0.7839585542678833,
-0.30258065462112427,
1.4484634399414062,
-0.23935642838478088,
-0.03744246065616608,
0.5868543982505798,
-0.31392067670822144,
0.2078358680009842,
0.05288366600871086,
-0.03803982213139534,
-0.03245854750275612,
-0.1807592362165451,
-0.45704078674316406,
-0.5800858736038208,
0.02864806167781353,
-0.6437352299690247,
-0.7850993871688843,
-0.20939740538597107,
-0.3547443747520447,
-0.11029718816280365,
-0.0040653483010828495,
0.523603081703186,
0.3884129822254181,
-0.15324607491493225,
0.7093406915664673,
0.7293449640274048,
0.15906980633735657,
0.23298999667167664,
0.6270695924758911,
-0.19808349013328552,
-0.21466189622879028,
0.6210044622421265,
0.3098472058773041,
0.3847363591194153,
-0.04572460800409317,
0.28748559951782227,
-0.1959923952817917,
-0.3650842607021332,
-0.28679952025413513,
-0.032759200781583786,
-0.7970901131629944,
0.1877155601978302,
-0.941852867603302,
-0.20306366682052612,
-0.22742387652397156,
-0.14365164935588837,
-0.15121130645275116,
-0.5061146020889282,
-0.4299665093421936,
-0.3892614543437958,
0.18167491257190704,
0.779155433177948,
-0.3577146828174591,
0.42746502161026,
-0.7095286846160889,
0.3261907696723938,
0.6736183762550354,
0.07712552696466446,
-0.05388328805565834,
-0.4849981367588043,
-0.09157480299472809,
0.3691732585430145,
-0.44469282031059265,
-0.8268646597862244,
0.019399233162403107,
0.16879086196422577,
0.5348533391952515,
0.2410770058631897,
0.41486096382141113,
0.7434800267219543,
-0.3820995092391968,
0.7824598550796509,
-0.05437346547842026,
-1.1081407070159912,
0.5098873376846313,
-0.37711259722709656,
0.09221166372299194,
0.6971321105957031,
0.31749486923217773,
-0.6676137447357178,
-0.8297469019889832,
-1.0934457778930664,
-0.9616590142250061,
0.807409942150116,
0.17442947626113892,
0.15955312550067902,
-0.06652264297008514,
0.24035616219043732,
0.12471403181552887,
0.29793524742126465,
-0.609345555305481,
-0.027455778792500496,
-0.31895196437835693,
0.3988875448703766,
0.014620626345276833,
-0.34275203943252563,
-0.44589123129844666,
-0.3392423093318939,
0.25126001238822937,
-0.08424177020788193,
0.010547555051743984,
0.38383811712265015,
-0.18818840384483337,
-0.5344139337539673,
0.33549830317497253,
0.8524788022041321,
0.7633412480354309,
-0.0693366527557373,
0.037012796849012375,
0.4053322672843933,
-0.309635728597641,
-0.14341217279434204,
-0.12512832880020142,
-0.22897715866565704,
0.20262137055397034,
0.46408089995384216,
1.0828275680541992,
0.434458464384079,
-0.4394177198410034,
0.5497305393218994,
-0.08139373362064362,
-0.6253798007965088,
-0.2830062508583069,
0.28911706805229187,
-0.17984147369861603,
0.2025442123413086,
0.33155542612075806,
0.39561620354652405,
-0.08510797470808029,
-0.7420583963394165,
0.7200369238853455,
0.3290102779865265,
-0.571906328201294,
-0.24367669224739075,
0.6748139262199402,
0.175979882478714,
-0.3122766315937042,
0.4951823949813843,
0.2495701164007187,
-0.7323155403137207,
0.4128374457359314,
0.20788909494876862,
0.656535804271698,
-0.1099729984998703,
0.16123242676258087,
0.05311310291290283,
0.06251448392868042,
-0.3461780846118927,
0.2882561981678009,
-0.3832004964351654,
-0.4887329638004303,
-0.35781726241111755,
-0.17385952174663544,
-0.8579201102256775,
0.09646490961313248,
-1.0610387325286865,
0.17131474614143372,
-0.40102529525756836,
-0.2676832377910614,
0.1238764226436615,
-0.13692373037338257,
-0.2535826563835144,
0.3962113559246063,
-0.07008764892816544,
0.9495517015457153,
-1.139704942703247,
0.7218143343925476,
0.4023948013782501,
-0.2207041084766388,
-0.6510602831840515,
0.22873936593532562,
-0.23072706162929535,
-0.46739861369132996,
0.5597303509712219,
0.36930644512176514,
0.014216731302440166,
-0.18661552667617798,
-0.792864978313446,
-0.5005034804344177,
0.5933454632759094,
0.3049696981906891,
-0.2239205241203308,
-0.06799916923046112,
0.09413056820631027,
0.5168697834014893,
-0.11184493452310562,
0.4290222227573395,
0.5280042886734009,
0.564776599407196,
0.1977098137140274,
-1.1836036443710327,
-0.24440798163414001,
0.05892219394445419,
-0.7103301882743835,
-0.0977364033460617,
-0.6699146628379822,
0.9565684199333191,
-0.21592293679714203,
-0.3106100857257843,
0.1672491580247879,
0.23138828575611115,
-0.1288885772228241,
0.5123259425163269,
0.6686862707138062,
0.49738267064094543,
0.7735869288444519,
-0.13438469171524048,
0.8721892833709717,
0.05908259004354477,
0.35506635904312134,
1.284166932106018,
-0.20714879035949707,
0.6420682668685913,
0.42422813177108765,
-0.11140932142734528,
0.02207943983376026,
0.46061789989471436,
0.3192178010940552,
0.5931454300880432,
0.19149285554885864,
-0.043017663061618805,
-0.37515243887901306,
0.047545257955789566,
-0.32304301857948303,
0.7049950957298279,
0.6314457654953003,
-0.29897382855415344,
-0.30147460103034973,
-0.190602645277977,
-0.45980194211006165,
0.10701168328523636,
-0.039843346923589706,
0.9848920702934265,
0.3587785065174103,
-0.8868444561958313,
0.7546597719192505,
-0.4349944591522217,
0.2162298709154129,
-0.20948375761508942,
-0.051470205187797546,
0.08597887307405472,
-0.11914139240980148,
-0.2308390736579895,
-0.6733608245849609,
0.655402421951294,
-0.3411904573440552,
-0.46954846382141113,
-0.5750944018363953,
0.49167120456695557,
-0.4671539068222046,
-0.0022661075927317142,
0.4096822440624237,
0.5719425082206726,
0.3215705454349518,
-0.12571127712726593,
-0.6924183368682861,
0.03567606583237648,
0.07639624178409576,
0.004318348132073879,
0.21743130683898926,
0.6935673952102661,
-0.08594878017902374,
0.8925530910491943,
0.694513738155365,
-0.03342244774103165,
0.07699646055698395,
0.14452774822711945,
0.8288583159446716,
-0.5051925182342529,
-0.5862724781036377,
-0.7587231397628784,
0.5453986525535583,
-0.09737572818994522,
-0.27478569746017456,
0.44078004360198975,
0.10974273830652237,
0.7797408699989319,
0.020559893921017647,
0.913972795009613,
0.058928996324539185,
0.7494269013404846,
-0.7417946457862854,
0.6302681565284729,
-0.23332399129867554,
0.02848532237112522,
-0.28194549679756165,
-0.38348907232284546,
-0.09513812512159348,
0.7663114666938782,
-0.3291330337524414,
-0.07852885127067566,
0.595941960811615,
0.26801326870918274,
-0.2175503969192505,
0.6976897716522217,
0.6652905941009521,
0.04403362423181534,
0.09926019608974457,
0.3596365749835968,
1.1559159755706787,
-0.1819763332605362,
0.4015820324420929,
0.006724666804075241,
-0.09438402950763702,
-0.4114453196525574,
-0.6283946633338928,
-1.2450482845306396,
-0.5775701999664307,
-0.11554347723722458,
-0.13427458703517914,
0.030650755390524864,
0.9366609454154968,
0.9724512100219727,
-0.7574585676193237,
-0.017100322991609573,
-0.5476506948471069,
0.08252902328968048,
-0.23746609687805176,
-0.14997504651546478,
0.1217418983578682,
-0.4860527217388153,
-0.542415976524353,
0.7037705779075623,
-0.24714696407318115,
0.11736708134412766,
0.06911399215459824,
0.1519448608160019,
0.09713032841682434,
-0.05502510443329811,
0.3118082582950592,
0.580211877822876,
-0.7586636543273926,
-0.20234917104244232,
0.01991436630487442,
0.0661521852016449,
0.10932352393865585,
1.0762181282043457,
-0.6606960892677307,
0.27607956528663635,
0.10983306914567947,
0.6776719689369202,
0.25953179597854614,
0.05523915961384773,
0.9218220710754395,
-1.0053601264953613,
0.33305037021636963,
0.03372068703174591,
0.32924386858940125,
0.23455223441123962,
-0.1965862512588501,
0.5109614133834839,
0.31293705105781555,
-0.5996152758598328,
-0.8548337817192078,
0.42423680424690247,
-0.7070657014846802,
-0.2540627121925354,
1.0567786693572998,
-0.2835664749145508,
0.028998401015996933,
-0.7203093767166138,
-0.5021362900733948,
0.23965047299861908,
-0.35234278440475464,
0.948986291885376,
0.9172632694244385,
0.21708866953849792,
-0.17740222811698914,
-0.82294762134552,
0.7319899797439575,
0.669910728931427,
-0.24010048806667328,
0.6243228316307068,
0.29467228055000305,
0.21993334591388702,
0.39004263281822205,
0.8099856376647949,
0.3716414272785187,
0.4766441881656647,
0.05949336290359497,
-0.4290037751197815,
0.16873183846473694,
-0.6921034455299377,
-0.41245245933532715,
0.20786741375923157,
0.017528081312775612,
-0.3080613315105438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01121v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01121v2
|
Efficient Data Generation for Source-grounded Information-seeking Dialogs: A Use Case for Meeting Transcripts
| 2024-05-02T09:35:06 | 2024-06-21T09:10:28 |
Lotem Golany, Filippo Galgani, Maya Mamo, Nimrod Parasol, Omer Vandsburger, Nadav Bar, Ido Dagan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Automating data generation with Large Language Models (LLMs) has become
increasingly popular. In this work, we investigate the feasibility and
effectiveness of LLM-based data generation in the challenging setting of
source-grounded information-seeking dialogs, with response attribution, over
long documents. Our source texts consist of long and noisy meeting transcripts,
adding to the task complexity. Since automating attribution remains difficult,
we propose a semi-automatic approach: dialog queries and responses are
generated with LLMs, followed by human verification and identification of
attribution spans. Using this approach, we created MISeD -- Meeting Information
Seeking Dialogs dataset -- a dataset of information-seeking dialogs focused on
meeting transcripts. Models finetuned with MISeD demonstrate superior
performance compared to off-the-shelf models, even those of larger size.
Finetuning on MISeD gives comparable response generation quality to finetuning
on fully manual data, while improving attribution quality and reducing time and
effort.
|
[
0.010822715237736702,
-0.668391764163971,
0.8183830976486206,
-0.10522585362195969,
-0.2645345628261566,
-0.14965064823627472,
-0.15075048804283142,
-0.35348519682884216,
0.01795407384634018,
0.4916412830352783,
-0.9557141065597534,
-0.46022677421569824,
-0.24707548320293427,
0.3508461117744446,
-0.6494101285934448,
0.8411036133766174,
-0.005532416049391031,
0.06578602641820908,
-0.30743733048439026,
0.14148056507110596,
-0.5666047930717468,
-0.7095017433166504,
-0.5437032580375671,
-0.24113774299621582,
0.5290682315826416,
0.7794690132141113,
0.6292193531990051,
0.7905760407447815,
0.32627761363983154,
0.15458257496356964,
0.10999246686697006,
0.5142492651939392,
-0.7807150483131409,
0.21431803703308105,
-0.09082706272602081,
-0.611707866191864,
-0.18280074000358582,
0.38173484802246094,
0.515264630317688,
0.6438502669334412,
-0.4203709661960602,
0.4172593653202057,
-0.03691370040178299,
0.5570976138114929,
-0.3257898986339569,
0.14560559391975403,
-0.9581668376922607,
0.07217102497816086,
-0.2039446234703064,
-0.6629229187965393,
-0.4641542136669159,
-0.5097006559371948,
0.19852131605148315,
-0.7332727909088135,
0.46924951672554016,
0.4332940876483917,
0.7779723405838013,
0.21065618097782135,
-0.3744261860847473,
-0.8549249768257141,
-0.6215192675590515,
0.7038179636001587,
-0.6365576386451721,
0.47881099581718445,
0.7689045071601868,
0.2734333276748657,
-0.6053983569145203,
-0.5306867361068726,
-0.44110098481178284,
-0.029095131903886795,
-0.10261763632297516,
-0.04425472766160965,
-0.22984614968299866,
-0.18769222497940063,
0.5566102862358093,
0.3989371955394745,
-0.3473987877368927,
-0.17962509393692017,
-0.3212517499923706,
-0.06868715584278107,
0.5580177903175354,
0.37652936577796936,
-0.09459442645311356,
-0.6591435074806213,
-0.10491835325956345,
0.1466619074344635,
-0.810390055179596,
-0.2893144488334656,
0.3877486288547516,
0.5609323382377625,
0.12182585150003433,
0.8981660604476929,
-0.21925698220729828,
0.6332697868347168,
0.21095110476016998,
0.08209674805402756,
-0.16902267932891846,
-0.8320131301879883,
-0.11239954084157944,
0.11179033666849136,
0.6733147501945496,
0.6701368093490601,
0.2668398916721344,
-0.18209901452064514,
-0.2716767489910126,
-0.41353005170822144,
0.27663907408714294,
-0.6154184937477112,
-0.20484736561775208,
0.12767578661441803,
-0.5226378440856934,
-0.4862777590751648,
-0.25077810883522034,
-0.6274569630622864,
-0.3481096029281616,
-0.6527305245399475,
0.08665744960308075,
-0.3175337314605713,
0.019931495189666748,
-0.22524206340312958,
-0.08396878838539124,
0.1434510350227356,
0.6646594405174255,
-0.312466561794281,
0.08940345793962479,
0.10960933566093445,
0.9245825409889221,
-0.17868269979953766,
0.1301097720861435,
-0.9428161382675171,
0.31772202253341675,
-0.3254988193511963,
0.5045857429504395,
-0.34036481380462646,
-0.3924967646598816,
-0.0043204291723668575,
-0.142280712723732,
0.1868656873703003,
-0.759676456451416,
0.643610417842865,
-0.520438551902771,
0.5850189924240112,
-0.42017704248428345,
-0.676151692867279,
0.10121048986911774,
0.22588033974170685,
-0.6409613490104675,
1.0413650274276733,
0.1199580505490303,
-0.6944098472595215,
0.498002290725708,
-0.6803321838378906,
-0.18522916734218597,
0.1248345747590065,
-0.6628119349479675,
-0.20309510827064514,
0.23878224194049835,
0.18255387246608734,
0.5316903591156006,
-0.7106600999832153,
0.5622958540916443,
-0.0953138917684555,
-0.0812397450208664,
0.44090360403060913,
-0.6598012447357178,
0.44604578614234924,
0.35414350032806396,
-0.26075512170791626,
-0.20578549802303314,
-1.036895751953125,
-0.07918921113014221,
0.493014395236969,
-0.7289209365844727,
-0.2530718147754669,
0.44036754965782166,
-0.034133851528167725,
0.17875924706459045,
0.03963499888777733,
-0.5006716847419739,
0.015003630891442299,
-0.20439453423023224,
0.10838654637336731,
0.828607976436615,
0.08051463216543198,
0.09132403880357742,
-0.3802871108055115,
0.28037533164024353,
0.06856094300746918,
-0.2105317860841751,
-0.4067656397819519,
0.041571080684661865,
-0.6513023376464844,
-0.14444105327129364,
0.003572087036445737,
0.4080910086631775,
-0.859933078289032,
0.45315277576446533,
-0.2506099045276642,
-0.1828143298625946,
-0.5160645842552185,
0.2098465859889984,
0.2797999083995819,
0.7302896976470947,
0.2139148861169815,
0.09624357521533966,
-0.578839898109436,
-0.8339908123016357,
-0.3806086778640747,
-0.27437901496887207,
-0.30963751673698425,
0.8080035448074341,
-0.014721051789820194,
-0.1720632165670395,
1.235328197479248,
-0.6074538230895996,
-0.1569809466600418,
-0.14695128798484802,
0.32155439257621765,
0.27745965123176575,
0.23633603751659393,
0.36837369203567505,
-0.6306458711624146,
-0.3277361989021301,
-0.33044350147247314,
-0.8649460673332214,
-0.3861631751060486,
-0.2648399770259857,
-0.16185185313224792,
0.17492814362049103,
0.5431523323059082,
-0.5846771597862244,
0.4096282422542572,
0.23971474170684814,
-0.18272075057029724,
0.4674854576587677,
0.19072650372982025,
0.2867874801158905,
-1.3043276071548462,
0.27705618739128113,
-0.057984333485364914,
-0.7500060796737671,
-0.6254018545150757,
-0.3579942286014557,
-0.1324595957994461,
-0.4053891897201538,
-0.36901581287384033,
0.26536914706230164,
-0.684427797794342,
0.11658310145139694,
-0.23313896358013153,
0.2605154514312744,
-0.21317389607429504,
0.44038742780685425,
0.02659389190375805,
0.9573699235916138,
0.28756436705589294,
-0.6882709860801697,
0.49519655108451843,
0.5205021500587463,
-0.36594119668006897,
0.5657132267951965,
-0.4323030412197113,
0.2760496139526367,
-0.31385764479637146,
0.3033026158809662,
-0.8785440921783447,
-0.7651293873786926,
0.16335318982601166,
-0.3339909613132477,
0.0916677862405777,
-0.25962579250335693,
-0.7015016078948975,
-0.28457263112068176,
-0.22273191809654236,
0.6864343881607056,
0.20943377912044525,
-0.7594332695007324,
0.7168765664100647,
0.14765183627605438,
-0.46570441126823425,
-0.09655606746673584,
-0.44857630133628845,
0.41680362820625305,
-0.335448294878006,
-0.540701150894165,
-0.24917881190776825,
-0.05565055459737778,
-0.25468382239341736,
-0.41489318013191223,
-0.13998357951641083,
0.0764232724905014,
-0.13029207289218903,
0.19801414012908936,
0.3146786391735077,
-0.0739029198884964,
0.10769519954919815,
-0.35969433188438416,
0.04192214831709862,
0.15706588327884674,
-0.09053539484739304,
0.5229936838150024,
0.22225451469421387,
-0.5717619061470032,
-0.56853848695755,
0.6862083673477173,
0.5860753059387207,
0.41721850633621216,
0.38506707549095154,
0.019120745360851288,
-0.46372899413108826,
0.03710445016622543,
-0.8742515444755554,
-0.2665284276008606,
-0.49618861079216003,
0.17273373901844025,
-0.10336485505104065,
-0.6579213738441467,
0.5495859980583191,
-0.12190666049718857,
0.32067742943763733,
0.34114718437194824,
0.4829411506652832,
-0.19166307151317596,
0.8560218811035156,
0.4246300458908081,
-0.1290787011384964,
0.4575076103210449,
0.21239356696605682,
-0.0064095016568899155,
-0.411140501499176,
-0.12852424383163452,
-0.604461133480072,
0.050156399607658386,
-0.08249339461326599,
-0.438411146402359,
0.43541914224624634,
-0.13312208652496338,
0.2942194640636444,
0.15035198628902435,
-0.22295308113098145,
0.3792186379432678,
0.6341413259506226,
0.007531207520514727,
0.6117916107177734,
0.2464744746685028,
0.1522533893585205,
-0.26193541288375854,
-0.7655353546142578,
-0.6569318175315857,
1.157293677330017,
0.36274755001068115,
1.0038217306137085,
0.06106052175164223,
0.34852370619773865,
0.4909150004386902,
0.045409638434648514,
-0.7180615067481995,
0.46913114190101624,
0.36459600925445557,
-0.5970070362091064,
-0.21189351379871368,
-0.8710407614707947,
-0.6433455348014832,
-0.20527493953704834,
-0.18119759857654572,
-0.6556015610694885,
0.002248750999569893,
0.29886773228645325,
-0.34213095903396606,
0.011335330083966255,
-0.6904447078704834,
0.3152194619178772,
-0.1953599452972412,
-0.14889109134674072,
0.03546404466032982,
-0.6764476299285889,
0.28983405232429504,
-0.5583775043487549,
0.2855188250541687,
-0.21596796810626984,
0.49598515033721924,
0.863811194896698,
-0.49413052201271057,
0.7195786237716675,
-0.23167259991168976,
-0.3525678217411041,
0.4446426331996918,
0.16759823262691498,
0.9723151326179504,
0.0984177216887474,
-0.24963906407356262,
-0.06335007399320602,
-0.30320775508880615,
-0.005783164408057928,
-0.44483238458633423,
0.4655980169773102,
-0.3612757623195648,
-0.5102471113204956,
-0.13918089866638184,
-0.6219234466552734,
-0.19601231813430786,
0.32747355103492737,
0.48526567220687866,
0.5325793623924255,
-0.16158127784729004,
0.13987071812152863,
0.6477971076965332,
-0.21542078256607056,
0.08848415315151215,
0.7476609349250793,
-0.0317281149327755,
-0.23080001771450043,
0.7842035293579102,
0.023488495498895645,
0.36225491762161255,
-0.08224989473819733,
-0.06301652640104294,
-0.231915682554245,
-0.34410014748573303,
-0.49860936403274536,
0.20712649822235107,
-0.6073501706123352,
-0.5170691013336182,
-0.6584834456443787,
-0.2628123164176941,
-0.2039087414741516,
-0.046188704669475555,
-0.5212940573692322,
-0.2530289590358734,
-0.7513982057571411,
-0.15096427500247955,
0.4273774325847626,
0.6879003047943115,
0.17092211544513702,
0.2743762135505676,
-0.873863935470581,
0.3442962169647217,
0.05951007828116417,
0.209866002202034,
-0.1952248364686966,
-0.5010942816734314,
-0.3115461766719818,
0.4217982888221741,
-0.27357566356658936,
-0.8277257084846497,
0.12460067123174667,
0.21459200978279114,
0.38890597224235535,
0.08054155111312866,
0.3259614408016205,
0.7870842218399048,
-0.4670808017253876,
0.700261116027832,
0.1750308722257614,
-0.6421992778778076,
0.7624361515045166,
-0.6195310950279236,
0.17111247777938843,
0.7475518584251404,
0.20991039276123047,
-0.5385711193084717,
-0.7154526710510254,
-0.5523920655250549,
-0.9394459128379822,
1.2402145862579346,
0.6612522602081299,
-0.010317075997591019,
-0.05221865698695183,
0.6414085626602173,
0.17614266276359558,
0.3924517035484314,
-0.5541460514068604,
-0.11310011893510818,
0.16733011603355408,
-0.24050502479076385,
0.1020030826330185,
-0.27845874428749084,
-0.42809587717056274,
0.009751198813319206,
0.6639832258224487,
-0.21631334722042084,
0.4484620690345764,
0.4226427674293518,
0.025834817439317703,
-0.617246150970459,
0.1309468001127243,
0.2878190577030182,
0.5262998938560486,
-0.23310212790966034,
0.10831404477357864,
0.20179323852062225,
-0.1339566707611084,
0.06727196276187897,
0.11497443169355392,
-0.041780564934015274,
0.3825337886810303,
0.13733455538749695,
0.6791293025016785,
-0.1380286067724228,
-0.8807116150856018,
0.6713761687278748,
-0.24584823846817017,
-0.2321915477514267,
-0.36648911237716675,
0.0700802430510521,
-0.050474584102630615,
0.168191596865654,
0.6866356730461121,
-0.39575767517089844,
0.19584278762340546,
-0.5747432708740234,
0.3265334963798523,
0.41571563482284546,
-0.10298065841197968,
0.009050159715116024,
0.6094363927841187,
0.18127138912677765,
-0.2679855525493622,
0.9664632678031921,
0.19445255398750305,
-0.1691739708185196,
0.15692846477031708,
0.4578400254249573,
0.623406171798706,
0.08539517968893051,
-0.12491902709007263,
0.2527065575122833,
-0.08679147064685822,
-0.005878043361008167,
0.03831293433904648,
-0.17691676318645477,
-0.383359432220459,
-0.23430027067661285,
-0.5068871974945068,
-0.4673290550708771,
0.3900982141494751,
-0.6369020938873291,
0.47915133833885193,
-0.1405583769083023,
-0.3081257939338684,
-0.14377981424331665,
-0.44324493408203125,
-0.6357627511024475,
0.04196134954690933,
-0.022178566083312035,
0.9426469206809998,
-0.6457604169845581,
0.18708764016628265,
0.35043588280677795,
-0.08445259928703308,
-1.048453450202942,
0.09151457995176315,
0.22764037549495697,
-0.6328800916671753,
0.37944260239601135,
0.08307516574859619,
-0.08241221308708191,
0.044601503759622574,
-0.9393524527549744,
-0.8885383009910583,
1.1123815774917603,
0.5026594996452332,
-0.5677356123924255,
-0.4683832824230194,
0.26766613125801086,
0.19213202595710754,
-0.2682194709777832,
0.025040706619620323,
0.5700247883796692,
0.18413929641246796,
0.4158697724342346,
-1.0120832920074463,
0.1483612209558487,
-0.2082051783800125,
-0.27182286977767944,
0.12195573002099991,
-0.3784000277519226,
0.35810500383377075,
0.17107845842838287,
-0.5270451307296753,
-0.14187897741794586,
0.6961436867713928,
0.3159191608428955,
0.25517740845680237,
0.4894787669181824,
0.10571179538965225,
0.9212686419487,
0.03589113429188728,
0.6773472428321838,
-0.018257150426506996,
0.11337518692016602,
1.3674060106277466,
-0.24085260927677155,
0.3719995617866516,
0.6110907196998596,
0.11318108439445496,
0.06689644604921341,
0.5562928318977356,
-0.05518919229507446,
0.42269012331962585,
0.2535267770290375,
-0.24802614748477936,
-0.20238447189331055,
-0.38112694025039673,
-0.1483628898859024,
0.3096180856227875,
0.20516008138656616,
-0.7185582518577576,
-0.5222883820533752,
-0.0973757654428482,
-0.09148433804512024,
-0.05528295412659645,
-0.03936374559998512,
1.1646393537521362,
0.03649019077420235,
-0.6612268090248108,
0.7023895978927612,
0.02704675868153572,
0.41339534521102905,
-0.5336717963218689,
-0.06277492642402649,
-0.09264685958623886,
-0.1627289354801178,
-0.18465225398540497,
-0.6127943992614746,
0.26225143671035767,
0.5328582525253296,
-0.39862287044525146,
-0.3658066987991333,
0.7064056396484375,
-0.6675575375556946,
-0.346152126789093,
-0.06317088007926941,
0.528358519077301,
0.43093106150627136,
-0.09696169197559357,
-0.2725745737552643,
-0.0993296205997467,
0.3128814101219177,
-0.5116212964057922,
0.05366872623562813,
0.5889571905136108,
-0.07389788329601288,
0.688478410243988,
0.7613940834999084,
-0.00034467378281988204,
0.13035300374031067,
-0.0924556702375412,
1.1678465604782104,
-0.7324500679969788,
-0.3390224277973175,
-0.6518908143043518,
0.22885966300964355,
-0.1572636365890503,
0.05207717418670654,
0.5746443271636963,
0.8809791803359985,
0.49850502610206604,
0.12281996011734009,
0.9136494398117065,
-0.003451575757935643,
1.09849214553833,
-0.7418862581253052,
0.4691332280635834,
-0.6037262082099915,
0.3783136308193207,
-0.3112128973007202,
-0.8680099248886108,
-0.0030641816556453705,
0.5043482780456543,
0.1460188627243042,
-0.09062206745147705,
0.3152731955051422,
0.6901953816413879,
-0.2387128621339798,
0.14987628161907196,
0.004756212700158358,
-0.008556220680475235,
0.7593547105789185,
0.5085362792015076,
0.9562963843345642,
-0.2632087469100952,
0.6180528998374939,
0.3980926275253296,
-0.24077081680297852,
-0.3352484107017517,
-1.0113370418548584,
-0.8519589304924011,
-0.4579826891422272,
-0.10951961576938629,
-0.3546214699745178,
-0.09548240900039673,
1.4033176898956299,
0.46737149357795715,
-0.3761973977088928,
-0.13743774592876434,
-0.25902310013771057,
-0.3397291600704193,
0.7097073793411255,
-0.3192095458507538,
-0.013287478126585484,
-0.31113389134407043,
-0.5466418862342834,
0.6855644583702087,
-0.019955074414610863,
0.4402763247489929,
-0.02272697724401951,
-0.06276650726795197,
-0.2079402208328247,
0.3563094139099121,
0.3140633702278137,
0.1631399244070053,
-0.42486944794654846,
-0.33108076453208923,
-0.128923237323761,
-0.45957744121551514,
0.044237203896045685,
0.9216993451118469,
-0.5225160717964172,
0.31434354186058044,
0.07827411592006683,
0.551185667514801,
0.48553019762039185,
0.5254256129264832,
1.1618322134017944,
-1.0938509702682495,
-0.1554146558046341,
0.2551613450050354,
-0.02246706746518612,
0.4079909324645996,
-0.795632541179657,
0.5721299648284912,
0.1763777732849121,
-0.5539337396621704,
-0.9355074763298035,
0.09661425650119781,
-0.8528128862380981,
0.1696777045726776,
1.3501663208007812,
0.03736172616481781,
0.14011532068252563,
-0.21003012359142303,
-0.43076226115226746,
0.4025120437145233,
-0.6278854608535767,
0.8095740675926208,
1.0370203256607056,
-0.13473175466060638,
0.1507156938314438,
-0.5400488376617432,
0.6927042603492737,
0.46602684259414673,
-0.8537639379501343,
1.0053749084472656,
1.121442198753357,
0.07582813501358032,
0.17745161056518555,
0.9298142194747925,
-0.023910798132419586,
0.16588787734508514,
-0.4048982560634613,
-0.26853233575820923,
-0.15631721913814545,
-0.394705593585968,
0.06412380188703537,
-0.03788065165281296,
0.07213000953197479,
0.06550761312246323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01097v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01097v1
|
Silencing the Risk, Not the Whistle: A Semi-automated Text Sanitization Tool for Mitigating the Risk of Whistleblower Re-Identification
| 2024-05-02T08:52:29 | 2024-05-02T08:52:29 |
Dimitri Staufer, Frank Pallas, Bettina Berendt
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR, cs.SE, H.3; K.4; H.5; K.5; D.2; J.4
|
Whistleblowing is essential for ensuring transparency and accountability in
both public and private sectors. However, (potential) whistleblowers often fear
or face retaliation, even when reporting anonymously. The specific content of
their disclosures and their distinct writing style may re-identify them as the
source. Legal measures, such as the EU WBD, are limited in their scope and
effectiveness. Therefore, computational methods to prevent re-identification
are important complementary tools for encouraging whistleblowers to come
forward. However, current text sanitization tools follow a one-size-fits-all
approach and take an overly limited view of anonymity. They aim to mitigate
identification risk by replacing typical high-risk words (such as person names
and other NE labels) and combinations thereof with placeholders. Such an
approach, however, is inadequate for the whistleblowing scenario since it
neglects further re-identification potential in textual features, including
writing style. Therefore, we propose, implement, and evaluate a novel
classification and mitigation strategy for rewriting texts that involves the
whistleblower in the assessment of the risk and utility. Our prototypical tool
semi-automatically evaluates risk at the word/term level and applies
risk-adapted anonymization techniques to produce a grammatically disjointed yet
appropriately sanitized text. We then use a LLM that we fine-tuned for
paraphrasing to render this text coherent and style-neutral. We evaluate our
tool's effectiveness using court cases from the ECHR and excerpts from a
real-world whistleblower testimony and measure the protection against
authorship attribution (AA) attacks and utility loss statistically using the
popular IMDb62 movie reviews dataset. Our method can significantly reduce AA
accuracy from 98.81% to 31.22%, while preserving up to 73.1% of the original
content's semantics.
|
[
0.17512410879135132,
-0.7487594485282898,
0.2550595998764038,
0.1197923943400383,
-0.3782203197479248,
0.6433583498001099,
0.24857273697853088,
-0.4955293834209442,
0.1011214479804039,
0.6522369980812073,
-0.33661141991615295,
-0.589707612991333,
-0.6733125448226929,
0.10908117890357971,
-0.639671266078949,
1.270787239074707,
-0.013691152445971966,
-0.36531394720077515,
-0.05554002523422241,
0.17193642258644104,
-0.12341006100177765,
-0.3117220103740692,
-0.3891122043132782,
0.03201080858707428,
0.6856592297554016,
0.28840044140815735,
0.36644014716148376,
0.6033784747123718,
0.30026549100875854,
0.2856771647930145,
-0.1570432037115097,
-0.145676389336586,
-0.4633769392967224,
0.05850648507475853,
-0.1329900026321411,
-0.42444902658462524,
0.01550486870110035,
0.12773273885250092,
0.49943795800209045,
0.2921069860458374,
-0.34529200196266174,
0.5030883550643921,
0.04867963865399361,
0.36540651321411133,
-0.8678979277610779,
-0.02361653931438923,
-0.7469269037246704,
0.07380839437246323,
-0.45992621779441833,
-0.5506187677383423,
-0.48893824219703674,
-0.6194465756416321,
0.39600521326065063,
-0.4393302798271179,
0.28480908274650574,
0.4190181791782379,
0.9281129240989685,
0.2866077721118927,
-0.2997163236141205,
-0.042562976479530334,
-0.5427106022834778,
0.9270967245101929,
-0.6089968681335449,
-0.08659440279006958,
0.3486621081829071,
0.13346728682518005,
0.07484540343284607,
-0.7485791444778442,
-0.1763947606086731,
0.08107255399227142,
-0.10972163081169128,
0.18893538415431976,
-0.4819194972515106,
-0.08934900909662247,
0.1535661220550537,
0.03694523498415947,
-0.38632142543792725,
0.2682623267173767,
-0.6082566976547241,
-0.72324538230896,
0.7577142715454102,
-0.10176277160644531,
0.3005484938621521,
-0.24010910093784332,
-0.5800628066062927,
-0.05653496831655502,
-0.6737136244773865,
0.11012335121631622,
0.6532198786735535,
0.017272241413593292,
0.08491118252277374,
0.23521341383457184,
-0.12826430797576904,
0.18321925401687622,
-0.07469018548727036,
-0.578997790813446,
0.27916207909584045,
-0.08951517194509506,
-0.35682982206344604,
0.5936005115509033,
0.6225034594535828,
0.4028276801109314,
0.08965341746807098,
-0.29249486327171326,
-0.17906580865383148,
-0.033632587641477585,
0.4656946361064911,
-0.5689355134963989,
-0.2785741984844208,
0.1588723063468933,
-0.5329810976982117,
-0.8739281892776489,
0.021851593628525734,
-0.9753822088241577,
-0.6425083875656128,
0.016327058896422386,
0.5643113851547241,
-0.24190254509449005,
-0.08401189744472504,
-0.23105838894844055,
-0.6000733375549316,
0.09840653091669083,
0.2953045070171356,
-0.6801012754440308,
0.15050753951072693,
0.33499467372894287,
0.6685949563980103,
-0.01561918668448925,
-0.26051077246665955,
-0.42041534185409546,
0.5955098271369934,
-0.2586246728897095,
0.7253327965736389,
-0.43559730052948,
-0.3796481490135193,
0.1294693946838379,
-0.02010873705148697,
0.12146061658859253,
-0.4531702697277069,
0.5646505951881409,
-0.4795837700366974,
0.32489779591560364,
0.35221928358078003,
-0.32139748334884644,
-0.08523141592741013,
-0.020103327929973602,
-0.5049936771392822,
0.7219595909118652,
0.04738154262304306,
-1.0473744869232178,
0.47219812870025635,
-0.10063428431749344,
-0.6302089095115662,
0.06738046556711197,
0.048085808753967285,
-0.8692049384117126,
0.12571458518505096,
0.023952770978212357,
0.06877972930669785,
-0.3514951765537262,
0.11634846776723862,
-0.06533777713775635,
-0.42936989665031433,
0.03716438263654709,
-0.6138584613800049,
0.8707299828529358,
0.0765848234295845,
-0.3214567303657532,
0.43290048837661743,
-0.4953426420688629,
0.2537442147731781,
-0.12790685892105103,
-0.1231718361377716,
-0.2928972542285919,
-0.18036161363124847,
-0.02566438354551792,
-0.11931825429201126,
0.27724647521972656,
-0.4287235736846924,
-0.3884630799293518,
-0.3685687482357025,
0.4017977714538574,
0.999008297920227,
0.508746862411499,
0.3632553219795227,
-0.6140201091766357,
0.5798985958099365,
-0.36783039569854736,
0.29922956228256226,
-0.05762287601828575,
-0.2073221504688263,
-0.2888234853744507,
-0.6414629220962524,
0.5878877639770508,
0.9918664693832397,
-0.5575094819068909,
0.4126772880554199,
-0.11560231447219849,
-0.8747167587280273,
-0.6525609493255615,
0.10854657739400864,
0.7475622892379761,
0.5126189589500427,
0.3501427471637726,
0.11409265547990799,
-0.6146660447120667,
-0.9841890335083008,
-0.6994075775146484,
-0.1300952136516571,
-0.28603988885879517,
-0.2158854603767395,
0.3133257329463959,
-0.06679285317659378,
0.7598839402198792,
-0.4449942409992218,
-0.44752803444862366,
-0.042850036174058914,
0.524911642074585,
-0.2801907956600189,
0.3848312795162201,
0.1143837720155716,
-0.9302659034729004,
-0.4529711902141571,
-0.35805758833885193,
-0.6145596504211426,
-0.4002409875392914,
-0.2516714632511139,
-0.03192483261227608,
0.17584851384162903,
0.8402214646339417,
-0.031671009957790375,
0.8469237089157104,
0.2084529995918274,
-0.1022600382566452,
0.6587090492248535,
-0.3309793472290039,
0.15472494065761566,
-0.6560595035552979,
0.08519035577774048,
0.039845023304224014,
-0.005961724556982517,
-0.7450416684150696,
-0.1946721225976944,
0.24806270003318787,
-0.08302249759435654,
-0.7680462598800659,
0.45588430762290955,
-0.5786107182502747,
0.48112326860427856,
-0.16810353100299835,
0.0548572912812233,
-0.0035914103500545025,
0.3682083189487457,
-0.018641889095306396,
0.49293798208236694,
0.48986580967903137,
-0.6596792936325073,
0.07095128297805786,
0.16397832334041595,
-0.32212314009666443,
0.6172640919685364,
-0.5973518490791321,
-0.09130460023880005,
-0.09284360706806183,
0.17662423849105835,
-0.7104970216751099,
-0.17068691551685333,
0.2208913415670395,
-0.4274638891220093,
0.2953703999519348,
-0.19800835847854614,
-0.5231339335441589,
-0.05104805901646614,
-0.887110710144043,
0.048380278050899506,
0.551012396812439,
-0.4175325036048889,
0.5238189101219177,
0.7802523374557495,
-0.44468608498573303,
-0.6752724647521973,
-0.75258469581604,
0.4225910007953644,
-0.7952611446380615,
-0.42338380217552185,
0.9879610538482666,
0.05444969981908798,
-0.20070073008537292,
-0.21428799629211426,
-0.4543813169002533,
-0.24811559915542603,
0.2292453944683075,
0.1304798275232315,
0.48540374636650085,
0.5729808807373047,
0.007436455227434635,
0.26209306716918945,
-0.42055660486221313,
0.04553772509098053,
0.21606069803237915,
0.025874052196741104,
0.14524385333061218,
0.07148104906082153,
-0.7243248224258423,
0.4619022607803345,
0.4184773862361908,
-0.2686941623687744,
0.6189993619918823,
0.5348961353302002,
-0.48958322405815125,
-0.21728026866912842,
-0.5354963541030884,
-0.2759072482585907,
-0.46645456552505493,
0.11564614623785019,
-0.09398842602968216,
-0.7309365272521973,
0.433703750371933,
-0.12131258100271225,
0.3212668001651764,
0.1612146943807602,
0.4436050355434418,
-0.10243483632802963,
0.6509160995483398,
0.72104811668396,
-0.18141663074493408,
0.5561181902885437,
0.3097997009754181,
0.5977848768234253,
-0.6301925778388977,
-0.30158132314682007,
-0.41846737265586853,
-0.08338531106710434,
-0.6635512709617615,
-0.010511974804103374,
0.26301121711730957,
-0.13165049254894257,
0.1525830626487732,
0.2754915952682495,
-0.6378284096717834,
0.40916529297828674,
0.6789616346359253,
0.03133808821439743,
0.30506542325019836,
-0.09887240827083588,
0.20217391848564148,
-0.11244917660951614,
-0.45860013365745544,
-0.9067130088806152,
0.8437722325325012,
0.33025673031806946,
1.0146105289459229,
0.2900170385837555,
1.1024340391159058,
0.48231935501098633,
0.3388766646385193,
-0.45755308866500854,
0.6182682514190674,
0.10668692737817764,
-0.6176151633262634,
-0.5229760408401489,
-0.3618515133857727,
-0.9670988321304321,
0.25356781482696533,
-0.31512075662612915,
-1.014156699180603,
0.06985710561275482,
0.1705891340970993,
-0.4257369935512543,
0.0956898182630539,
-1.0348217487335205,
0.7660521864891052,
0.1076880618929863,
-0.42235663533210754,
0.07706140726804733,
-0.7125416994094849,
0.2985249161720276,
-0.48907598853111267,
0.2778708040714264,
-0.015218689106404781,
-0.23081636428833008,
0.8733526468276978,
-0.38694435358047485,
1.136918544769287,
-0.06555871665477753,
-0.1636618822813034,
0.302338182926178,
0.0808074027299881,
0.5507224202156067,
-0.005124521441757679,
0.21369881927967072,
0.17348331212997437,
0.41677770018577576,
-0.2715059816837311,
-0.28098809719085693,
0.4728955328464508,
-0.2512966990470886,
-0.6880986094474792,
-0.6084877252578735,
-0.2507604956626892,
0.11688577383756638,
0.4891047179698944,
0.5444137454032898,
0.3650691509246826,
-0.08768793940544128,
0.41491129994392395,
0.6193211078643799,
-0.19565382599830627,
0.3630017936229706,
0.4553011357784271,
0.3477555513381958,
-0.3444979786872864,
0.9551140069961548,
0.327657550573349,
0.2022210657596588,
0.38031208515167236,
0.3442257344722748,
-0.4288787543773651,
-0.6442186832427979,
0.06160172075033188,
0.06984063982963562,
-0.465902715921402,
-0.37531694769859314,
-0.4715401530265808,
-0.22687621414661407,
-0.5165514945983887,
-0.29321959614753723,
0.13335418701171875,
-0.19898951053619385,
-0.09080434590578079,
-0.19119778275489807,
0.2714582681655884,
0.0473245270550251,
0.19282066822052002,
0.18015460669994354,
-0.5153691172599792,
0.3196696639060974,
0.22761909663677216,
0.023387378081679344,
-0.24943260848522186,
-0.6860987544059753,
-0.01446516066789627,
-0.3914206326007843,
-0.17807984352111816,
-0.9011834859848022,
0.5514616370201111,
-0.14460620284080505,
0.6516140699386597,
0.02528216503560543,
0.6913273334503174,
0.529643177986145,
-0.6968944072723389,
0.5342965126037598,
0.19362872838974,
-1.000592827796936,
0.5678539872169495,
-0.09474479407072067,
0.041051287204027176,
0.6454958915710449,
0.10591757297515869,
-0.44677606225013733,
-0.9670851826667786,
-0.9703872203826904,
-1.197748064994812,
0.5080560445785522,
0.29194891452789307,
-0.03799515962600708,
0.09281090646982193,
-0.05502273887395859,
-0.0735003873705864,
0.42310452461242676,
-0.4694637358188629,
-0.036894384771585464,
-0.05235132575035095,
-0.32292771339416504,
0.3076450824737549,
-0.38093113899230957,
-0.5394641160964966,
0.2563912570476532,
0.8589543104171753,
0.11342255771160126,
0.09141171723604202,
0.30888035893440247,
-0.25891631841659546,
0.1910126805305481,
0.450284868478775,
0.2801860570907593,
0.5397490859031677,
-0.06808602809906006,
0.3562915325164795,
0.26607364416122437,
-0.5783843398094177,
0.06302764266729355,
0.12114708870649338,
-0.35095980763435364,
-0.056286539882421494,
0.5435817241668701,
0.18372617661952972,
0.35445165634155273,
-0.7349432110786438,
0.48809218406677246,
0.08570405840873718,
-0.4213319718837738,
-0.5169156789779663,
0.2088342010974884,
-0.23298253118991852,
0.02339830994606018,
0.5280499458312988,
-0.05585479736328125,
0.3072230815887451,
-0.4403943121433258,
0.3694194555282593,
0.3119618594646454,
-0.27842843532562256,
0.03790005296468735,
0.4755370318889618,
0.26820412278175354,
-0.47361326217651367,
0.16388282179832458,
-0.09763658791780472,
-0.41953495144844055,
0.4708009958267212,
0.48685720562934875,
0.7877290844917297,
-0.41570067405700684,
0.1623886525630951,
0.14233192801475525,
0.533915102481842,
-0.008040611632168293,
-0.11846835911273956,
0.12177571654319763,
-0.4536811113357544,
0.10055447369813919,
-0.2047071009874344,
-0.3548840880393982,
0.00647797342389822,
-0.6259769797325134,
0.22966518998146057,
-0.9344894886016846,
-0.1718772053718567,
0.20074158906936646,
0.009452523663640022,
0.04499414190649986,
0.16719765961170197,
-0.27178388833999634,
0.716538667678833,
-0.8371136784553528,
0.4513700306415558,
0.20089471340179443,
-0.20087508857250214,
-0.5185000896453857,
0.37442734837532043,
0.4764138460159302,
-0.4450328052043915,
0.05507687106728554,
0.3520912528038025,
-0.4316619038581848,
0.14497511088848114,
-0.4287963807582855,
-0.49474021792411804,
1.2976406812667847,
0.3421635329723358,
-0.3473455011844635,
0.13614661991596222,
-0.5012273788452148,
0.36057931184768677,
0.11174426972866058,
-0.2399338185787201,
0.6548396348953247,
0.4685157835483551,
0.04089400917291641,
-0.882561445236206,
0.14342762529850006,
-0.19758333265781403,
-0.20321275293827057,
0.32144907116889954,
-0.5665038824081421,
0.2032080888748169,
-0.13764937222003937,
-0.49462419748306274,
0.021376904100179672,
0.5174969434738159,
0.2943026125431061,
0.38232702016830444,
0.4522021412849426,
0.26164698600769043,
1.165056824684143,
0.042636267840862274,
0.7829610109329224,
0.019640477374196053,
0.14486071467399597,
1.0015612840652466,
-0.17833757400512695,
0.5920970439910889,
0.6904957294464111,
0.0018307276768609881,
0.3551148772239685,
0.42418476939201355,
-0.19548432528972626,
0.7043294310569763,
0.36817795038223267,
-0.49531424045562744,
0.07825002074241638,
-0.21723522245883942,
0.021926816552877426,
0.2642752230167389,
0.023922162130475044,
-0.43567100167274475,
-0.12612579762935638,
-0.13384294509887695,
0.44624847173690796,
0.3231922388076782,
-0.1026294007897377,
0.6285655498504639,
0.011046073399484158,
-0.47583457827568054,
0.2315308302640915,
0.17374932765960693,
0.7050424218177795,
-0.6138357520103455,
0.1336294710636139,
0.180088609457016,
0.047036442905664444,
-0.4381088316440582,
-0.5808948874473572,
0.4644322693347931,
0.230357825756073,
-0.03626241534948349,
-0.5370062589645386,
0.775788426399231,
-0.22930675745010376,
-0.2715896666049957,
-0.010774601250886917,
0.1530020385980606,
0.018713591620326042,
0.06256087869405746,
-0.7411516308784485,
-0.03210803121328354,
0.23323746025562286,
-0.09977737069129944,
0.2935817539691925,
0.42312952876091003,
-0.32506826519966125,
0.7159180641174316,
0.6907034516334534,
-0.005034646950662136,
-0.06715486943721771,
0.24542130529880524,
0.45062053203582764,
-0.5935389399528503,
-0.7566370368003845,
-0.8599093556404114,
0.4521944224834442,
-0.4711242914199829,
-0.34382084012031555,
0.9414728283882141,
0.5094656348228455,
0.36708885431289673,
-0.005792016163468361,
0.6135761141777039,
0.037085361778736115,
0.8038269281387329,
-0.4639950096607208,
0.8096832036972046,
-0.15998020768165588,
0.2740422785282135,
-0.5513226389884949,
-0.5326433181762695,
-0.590815007686615,
0.5270247459411621,
-0.30267977714538574,
-0.09693528711795807,
0.7404304146766663,
0.8981327414512634,
0.3823702037334442,
-0.17154018580913544,
0.28903213143348694,
0.04146449267864227,
0.5585252046585083,
0.23003602027893066,
0.49904727935791016,
-0.32272160053253174,
1.0120412111282349,
-0.11851063370704651,
-0.5750784277915955,
-0.138930082321167,
-1.1123898029327393,
-0.7492681741714478,
-0.32659441232681274,
-0.7534598708152771,
-0.2149805724620819,
0.020814377814531326,
0.14589573442935944,
0.5109359622001648,
-0.2972554564476013,
0.17576457560062408,
-0.0032569067552685738,
0.21849560737609863,
-0.21134130656719208,
-0.2539888620376587,
0.2982631027698517,
-0.011241890490055084,
-0.631023108959198,
0.20809686183929443,
0.4817059338092804,
0.06355556845664978,
-0.17943835258483887,
0.3808787167072296,
-0.11353464424610138,
0.23953546583652496,
0.29106950759887695,
0.3138258457183838,
-0.5660066604614258,
-0.588742733001709,
-0.3027820885181427,
0.004246235825121403,
-0.3814370334148407,
0.34139618277549744,
-0.5688022971153259,
0.2649572789669037,
0.2591942846775055,
0.5845662951469421,
0.2866631746292114,
0.05548962205648422,
0.35477331280708313,
-0.8711389899253845,
0.06519202888011932,
0.3738355040550232,
0.16201698780059814,
0.16527773439884186,
-0.6283199787139893,
0.4102436304092407,
0.17984208464622498,
-0.352801650762558,
-1.1190167665481567,
0.15561798214912415,
-0.7169095277786255,
-0.27053695917129517,
0.800613522529602,
-0.12186912447214127,
-0.6140540242195129,
-0.4456698000431061,
-0.35874176025390625,
0.13477343320846558,
-0.4392137825489044,
1.0347719192504883,
0.6605254411697388,
0.19262579083442688,
-0.13481451570987701,
-0.38752198219299316,
0.5269007086753845,
0.1755015254020691,
-0.7278250455856323,
0.3853849470615387,
0.2433193325996399,
0.5072960257530212,
0.2955697476863861,
0.6135347485542297,
-0.4436067044734955,
0.35863348841667175,
0.030564984306693077,
0.04274141788482666,
0.01839434541761875,
-0.42178142070770264,
-0.21186693012714386,
0.17477700114250183,
-0.33622488379478455,
-0.19829781353473663
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01610v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01610v1
|
Automating the Analysis of Public Saliency and Attitudes towards Biodiversity from Digital Media
| 2024-05-02T08:28:25 | 2024-05-02T08:28:25 |
Noah Giebink, Amrita Gupta, Diogo Verìssimo, Charlotte H. Chang, Tony Chang, Angela Brennan, Brett Dickson, Alex Bowmer, Jonathan Baillie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Measuring public attitudes toward wildlife provides crucial insights into our
relationship with nature and helps monitor progress toward Global Biodiversity
Framework targets. Yet, conducting such assessments at a global scale is
challenging. Manually curating search terms for querying news and social media
is tedious, costly, and can lead to biased results. Raw news and social media
data returned from queries are often cluttered with irrelevant content and
syndicated articles. We aim to overcome these challenges by leveraging modern
Natural Language Processing (NLP) tools. We introduce a folk taxonomy approach
for improved search term generation and employ cosine similarity on Term
Frequency-Inverse Document Frequency vectors to filter syndicated articles. We
also introduce an extensible relevance filtering pipeline which uses
unsupervised learning to reveal common topics, followed by an open-source
zero-shot Large Language Model (LLM) to assign topics to news article titles,
which are then used to assign relevance. Finally, we conduct sentiment, topic,
and volume analyses on resulting data. We illustrate our methodology with a
case study of news and X (formerly Twitter) data before and during the COVID-19
pandemic for various mammal taxa, including bats, pangolins, elephants, and
gorillas. During the data collection period, up to 62% of articles including
keywords pertaining to bats were deemed irrelevant to biodiversity,
underscoring the importance of relevance filtering. At the pandemic's onset, we
observed increased volume and a significant sentiment shift toward horseshoe
bats, which were implicated in the pandemic, but not for other focal taxa. The
proposed methods open the door to conservation practitioners applying modern
and emerging NLP tools, including LLMs "out of the box," to analyze public
perceptions of biodiversity during current events or campaigns.
|
[
-0.9213122725486755,
-0.581599235534668,
-0.01784886233508587,
0.32716208696365356,
-0.6987134218215942,
0.17585529386997223,
-0.3087107539176941,
-0.5732131600379944,
0.8960040211677551,
0.3398521840572357,
-0.4633958339691162,
-0.6297524571418762,
-0.6549767255783081,
0.4836990237236023,
-0.5247936844825745,
1.054202914237976,
0.2755662500858307,
-0.28801390528678894,
-0.1978149265050888,
-0.42526593804359436,
0.027356645092368126,
-0.3910689651966095,
-0.404520720243454,
0.20383037626743317,
0.6762979626655579,
-0.07828907668590546,
0.6553484201431274,
0.28740862011909485,
0.6961442828178406,
0.18572582304477692,
-0.3979318141937256,
0.29261720180511475,
-0.5686338543891907,
-0.05354288965463638,
-0.5398028492927551,
-0.21546034514904022,
-0.15794387459754944,
0.17684824764728546,
0.34841570258140564,
0.5567140579223633,
-0.053199708461761475,
0.46366778016090393,
0.03446400538086891,
0.5905890464782715,
-0.47009357810020447,
-0.061833593994379044,
-0.9476318359375,
-0.009915565140545368,
-0.29780855774879456,
-0.7580364942550659,
0.1086193174123764,
-0.3188474774360657,
0.17021870613098145,
-0.7025092244148254,
0.34627777338027954,
-0.17735525965690613,
0.8671543002128601,
0.24441872537136078,
-0.2644593119621277,
-0.46631085872650146,
-0.454945832490921,
1.0274754762649536,
-0.3665727376937866,
0.09763818234205246,
0.6533254981040955,
-0.09766421467065811,
-0.18157601356506348,
-0.2712491750717163,
-0.6521171927452087,
0.25244054198265076,
0.14929147064685822,
0.15669481456279755,
-0.5507254600524902,
-0.21656955778598785,
0.014563390985131264,
0.4146822392940521,
-0.45587605237960815,
-0.40569207072257996,
-0.46446213126182556,
-0.10600240528583527,
0.8320870995521545,
-0.24640625715255737,
0.2745658755302429,
-0.5762290358543396,
-0.012659752741456032,
-0.020230935886502266,
-0.48098528385162354,
0.3686255216598511,
0.4075620472431183,
0.3236508071422577,
0.03894629329442978,
0.6574058532714844,
-0.22798565030097961,
0.708797037601471,
0.12920017540454865,
-0.036586347967386246,
-0.018867097795009613,
-0.5683541893959045,
-0.1023171991109848,
-0.061835501343011856,
0.5136963725090027,
0.7539111971855164,
-0.012961064465343952,
-0.0406612791121006,
0.05381280183792114,
0.028172746300697327,
0.5747014880180359,
-0.5327417850494385,
-0.02054288424551487,
0.07750078290700912,
-0.4488440155982971,
-0.3973698019981384,
0.15026666224002838,
-1.1253654956817627,
-0.3062301576137543,
-0.4904918372631073,
0.2557096779346466,
-0.10612000524997711,
-0.2969845235347748,
0.2761254906654358,
-0.23522153496742249,
0.30604034662246704,
0.3731403052806854,
-0.4441385567188263,
0.09822772443294525,
0.803169310092926,
1.108412742614746,
-0.2857445776462555,
0.24242717027664185,
-0.38579854369163513,
-0.009257576428353786,
-0.3368178904056549,
0.7204763293266296,
-0.5991754531860352,
-0.5461265444755554,
-0.2967061698436737,
0.20919492840766907,
0.19963428378105164,
-0.4323669970035553,
0.36398160457611084,
-0.7266049385070801,
0.30574455857276917,
-0.46401315927505493,
-0.08706925809383392,
-0.4587523639202118,
0.564534068107605,
-0.6396148204803467,
0.8144944310188293,
-0.011645674705505371,
-1.1754690408706665,
0.49416497349739075,
-0.7323763966560364,
-0.5482790470123291,
-0.2336161583662033,
0.1705102175474167,
-0.3777848184108734,
-0.07157181948423386,
0.40721940994262695,
0.2543736398220062,
-0.212690070271492,
0.4117940068244934,
-0.7394002676010132,
-0.18428736925125122,
0.07235492020845413,
-0.16038966178894043,
0.9741953015327454,
0.04292042553424835,
-0.18255530297756195,
-0.1315850168466568,
-0.410887211561203,
-0.4440515339374542,
-0.2968001663684845,
-0.4949977993965149,
-0.6213212013244629,
0.2684587240219116,
0.006968036759644747,
0.046881385147571564,
-0.09734824299812317,
-0.7152472734451294,
0.2578069269657135,
-0.5213696360588074,
0.5128555297851562,
0.3189709484577179,
0.3221900761127472,
0.1900366097688675,
-0.4013912081718445,
0.3816152513027191,
-0.18358808755874634,
0.34623435139656067,
0.07878219336271286,
-0.6565690636634827,
-0.37811222672462463,
-0.25696679949760437,
-0.08264558017253876,
0.14231504499912262,
-0.43198469281196594,
0.6880843043327332,
-0.5136416554450989,
-0.40081438422203064,
-0.6048950552940369,
0.15754812955856323,
-0.3378537595272064,
0.3748110234737396,
0.4006582200527191,
-0.7434905171394348,
-0.6377561688423157,
-0.5310380458831787,
-0.41421520709991455,
-0.1647852063179016,
0.01004858873784542,
0.4181678593158722,
0.3383367955684662,
-0.3402700126171112,
1.2965672016143799,
-0.29774168133735657,
-0.3313077986240387,
0.22553417086601257,
0.6782888174057007,
0.29662927985191345,
0.17105142772197723,
0.709713876247406,
-1.1561928987503052,
-0.24053679406642914,
-0.022201988846063614,
-0.5890783071517944,
-0.06438761949539185,
0.18864035606384277,
-0.05571794882416725,
0.31540676951408386,
-0.026290254667401314,
-0.5254349708557129,
0.41300714015960693,
0.3583489954471588,
0.11532903462648392,
0.11359100043773651,
0.3957095146179199,
0.35634344816207886,
-0.9691367745399475,
0.4298979938030243,
0.19228021800518036,
-0.021378973498940468,
-0.31778255105018616,
-0.14223186671733856,
-0.548749566078186,
-0.23822306096553802,
-0.3124770224094391,
0.44169631600379944,
-0.2508433163166046,
-0.3421662151813507,
-0.19968239963054657,
0.15449997782707214,
0.2552657723426819,
-0.041559670120477676,
0.35117971897125244,
0.5626392960548401,
0.5482202768325806,
-0.6767805218696594,
0.6346184611320496,
0.32004302740097046,
-0.09422320872545242,
0.5816447734832764,
-0.2650619447231293,
-0.06807665526866913,
-0.3816644847393036,
0.4095388352870941,
-0.8692099452018738,
-0.3110141456127167,
0.1294744610786438,
-0.5961022973060608,
0.22364738583564758,
-0.18465115129947662,
-0.14889828860759735,
-0.6483637690544128,
-0.8172616958618164,
-0.012501943856477737,
0.11145734041929245,
-0.474756121635437,
0.563274085521698,
0.6576241254806519,
-0.41592520475387573,
-0.4595884084701538,
-0.6178574562072754,
0.5987929105758667,
-0.4115999937057495,
-0.6088541746139526,
0.05525810271501541,
0.05870715528726578,
-0.4365823268890381,
0.11369966715574265,
-0.4281635582447052,
-0.04348126798868179,
0.36023297905921936,
-0.0916786789894104,
0.03131094202399254,
-0.20992989838123322,
0.2808370292186737,
-0.13962043821811676,
0.289111465215683,
0.12701834738254547,
-0.4400103688240051,
0.4193633198738098,
-0.15974374115467072,
-0.20163767039775848,
-0.26612919569015503,
0.3550831377506256,
0.5557202100753784,
-0.3547039330005646,
0.4244442284107208,
0.8284249901771545,
-0.2133476436138153,
0.2855997681617737,
-0.39517873525619507,
-0.10349897295236588,
-0.3463522791862488,
0.10328840464353561,
0.2565069794654846,
-0.6494574546813965,
0.12091532349586487,
0.026302367448806763,
0.029898187145590782,
0.39370208978652954,
0.31030789017677307,
-0.2850349247455597,
0.6842662692070007,
0.6128582954406738,
-0.44066330790519714,
0.4099341034889221,
-0.48736807703971863,
0.2796730399131775,
-0.6926369071006775,
-0.16662974655628204,
-0.3705848455429077,
-0.2462376356124878,
-0.564694881439209,
-0.5088911056518555,
0.43623214960098267,
0.1800462305545807,
0.10845058411359787,
0.3086056113243103,
-0.808370053768158,
0.2290891855955124,
0.4753020405769348,
0.07539225369691849,
0.30729836225509644,
0.34784752130508423,
0.5237361788749695,
0.09195460379123688,
-0.27040138840675354,
-0.6529817581176758,
0.9385854601860046,
-0.08650504797697067,
0.6822717785835266,
0.18176695704460144,
0.8301430344581604,
0.6251741647720337,
0.5881277322769165,
-0.9457345604896545,
0.32614582777023315,
-0.20498506724834442,
-0.627372145652771,
-0.5243495106697083,
-0.16794705390930176,
-1.0646381378173828,
0.013175809755921364,
-0.10451080650091171,
-0.5766393542289734,
0.5116899013519287,
-0.17029200494289398,
-0.4734064042568207,
0.38039398193359375,
-0.2724117934703827,
0.19203361868858337,
-0.15749557316303253,
-0.42294222116470337,
-0.5192998647689819,
-0.6277554035186768,
0.48764684796333313,
-0.5240964889526367,
0.4211197793483734,
-0.2898453176021576,
-0.28741881251335144,
0.5692530870437622,
-0.07629120349884033,
0.8471868634223938,
0.08991853147745132,
0.000534488819539547,
0.4717021584510803,
0.06392601877450943,
0.1580590009689331,
0.23527957499027252,
-0.4680995047092438,
0.21844348311424255,
0.23063576221466064,
-0.33542177081108093,
-0.17184895277023315,
0.6132136583328247,
-0.8544291853904724,
-0.7160009741783142,
-0.5095430612564087,
-0.32713583111763,
-0.0377524271607399,
0.00715193385258317,
0.04395684972405434,
0.2151644080877304,
-0.32539841532707214,
0.3992712199687958,
0.5781521201133728,
-0.44442757964134216,
0.5754605531692505,
0.5790638327598572,
-0.18227291107177734,
-0.44124752283096313,
0.9367704391479492,
0.17744681239128113,
0.06323269009590149,
0.5514755845069885,
0.5178074836730957,
-0.36829209327697754,
-0.2290443629026413,
-0.11097408831119537,
-0.07983757555484772,
-0.49549800157546997,
-0.3635750710964203,
-0.9554751515388489,
0.0073371645994484425,
-0.35587432980537415,
-0.21583780646324158,
0.2581726312637329,
-0.16264821588993073,
-0.5999054312705994,
0.18218332529067993,
0.744046151638031,
0.5286585092544556,
-0.46087294816970825,
0.17948593199253082,
-0.7086731791496277,
0.5773857831954956,
0.47408363223075867,
0.2576174736022949,
-0.349428653717041,
-0.2817603647708893,
0.053827933967113495,
0.3112655580043793,
-0.4251525104045868,
-0.819244384765625,
0.7520550489425659,
0.6341457366943359,
0.296049565076828,
0.535831868648529,
0.2710738480091095,
0.6677196025848389,
0.3753746449947357,
0.9387315511703491,
0.03413376212120056,
-0.9366174340248108,
0.6341599822044373,
-0.5810215473175049,
0.00865231640636921,
0.5232214331626892,
0.7792671918869019,
-0.6450069546699524,
-0.40119609236717224,
-0.47370684146881104,
-0.7627108693122864,
0.8034859299659729,
0.06787531822919846,
0.23578877747058868,
-0.2919161319732666,
-0.00619832007214427,
0.08349848538637161,
0.6148998141288757,
-0.46404096484184265,
0.05309656262397766,
-0.6894330978393555,
0.10513011366128922,
-0.12532249093055725,
0.06088632717728615,
-0.255880206823349,
-0.5611209869384766,
0.5831892490386963,
-0.1857481598854065,
0.029163049533963203,
0.4320731461048126,
-0.03708287328481674,
-0.5020798444747925,
0.23264752328395844,
0.32667505741119385,
0.5204606056213379,
-0.4957199990749359,
0.2936352789402008,
-0.06152667477726936,
-0.6307859420776367,
-0.08859622478485107,
0.11528032273054123,
-0.2474963665008545,
0.2415686398744583,
0.17591208219528198,
0.2411445677280426,
0.09839967638254166,
-0.3905888795852661,
0.5828579068183899,
0.1521906703710556,
0.03684992715716362,
0.10367561131715775,
-0.25684070587158203,
0.26640287041664124,
-0.10276957601308823,
0.5347122550010681,
0.29508355259895325,
0.2834307551383972,
-0.8419680595397949,
0.39641237258911133,
0.6836004257202148,
-0.18365368247032166,
-0.4347817897796631,
0.2963123619556427,
0.30771684646606445,
-0.17020809650421143,
0.1904563456773758,
-0.21284136176109314,
-0.5125030875205994,
0.7797436714172363,
0.11717377603054047,
0.8523439168930054,
-0.007472123019397259,
0.44531404972076416,
0.48518306016921997,
0.345695823431015,
0.07882492244243622,
0.26231542229652405,
-0.3666492998600006,
-0.4432317018508911,
-0.2966250479221344,
-1.1348758935928345,
-0.2676145136356354,
0.12860389053821564,
-0.8135491013526917,
0.3687303364276886,
-0.27063310146331787,
-0.5214386582374573,
0.3993808329105377,
0.3101932108402252,
-0.4735206365585327,
0.1725241094827652,
0.14745576679706573,
0.9559347033500671,
-0.7880046963691711,
0.563545823097229,
0.8055145740509033,
-0.5705327987670898,
-0.3051186501979828,
0.3445066213607788,
0.10581710189580917,
-0.7122544646263123,
0.6212054491043091,
0.15351822972297668,
-0.19635435938835144,
0.002049709903076291,
-0.7528522610664368,
-1.1681773662567139,
0.9046474099159241,
0.07824113965034485,
-0.49081364274024963,
0.29939109086990356,
0.14307208359241486,
0.556064784526825,
-0.10598614811897278,
-0.08599395304918289,
0.42455312609672546,
0.7811678647994995,
0.08852355927228928,
-0.7119117975234985,
-0.33089062571525574,
-0.14157634973526,
-0.16790063679218292,
0.18399427831172943,
-0.6613624095916748,
0.4877723157405853,
0.05406371131539345,
-0.35042378306388855,
-0.29987770318984985,
0.2645159065723419,
-0.1203140914440155,
0.4125938415527344,
0.5473777055740356,
0.3765811622142792,
0.7857670783996582,
0.03063628450036049,
0.7494401335716248,
-0.42273232340812683,
0.43629440665245056,
0.5769084095954895,
-0.2544427812099457,
0.8243354558944702,
0.581792950630188,
-0.49555444717407227,
0.21028169989585876,
0.971685528755188,
-0.27650022506713867,
0.5664652585983276,
0.3684057593345642,
-0.42776376008987427,
-0.2594422996044159,
-0.5249971151351929,
-0.22051288187503815,
0.41151291131973267,
0.4848381578922272,
-0.08234746754169464,
-0.6127634644508362,
0.17729416489601135,
-0.21511873602867126,
0.035421766340732574,
-0.5240110158920288,
0.7514429092407227,
0.11280642449855804,
-0.528956413269043,
0.4443950355052948,
-0.22140637040138245,
0.9971135854721069,
-0.514723539352417,
0.24368241429328918,
-0.20305266976356506,
-0.3242124915122986,
-0.47668591141700745,
-1.0234348773956299,
1.0391631126403809,
0.09975037723779678,
-0.3799611032009125,
0.009620655328035355,
0.7577331066131592,
-0.360127717256546,
-0.4167928397655487,
0.14985495805740356,
0.16465143859386444,
0.4650334417819977,
-0.2453668862581253,
-0.6661131381988525,
0.039150454103946686,
0.05618295818567276,
-0.34663325548171997,
0.09575628489255905,
0.26245489716529846,
-0.2067212462425232,
0.6196456551551819,
0.8359394669532776,
0.3894191384315491,
0.03983142599463463,
-0.20611819624900818,
0.874184250831604,
-0.444873571395874,
-0.20511987805366516,
-0.7687687277793884,
-0.06998369842767715,
-0.27443864941596985,
-0.11337055265903473,
0.7993597388267517,
0.7115738987922668,
0.6547245979309082,
0.11630920320749283,
0.9116436839103699,
-0.18491165339946747,
0.49577170610427856,
0.01475364901125431,
0.6532087922096252,
-0.7273260354995728,
0.1594749391078949,
-0.06224614381790161,
-0.6136937141418457,
-0.4055439233779907,
0.2546246349811554,
-0.40979650616645813,
-0.46146148443222046,
0.18400999903678894,
0.9127141237258911,
-0.17992378771305084,
0.09278066456317902,
0.081354521214962,
0.03099304810166359,
0.2167324274778366,
-0.07924958318471909,
0.6731793284416199,
0.07317491620779037,
0.52515709400177,
-0.09632191807031631,
-0.1021813154220581,
-0.3104495108127594,
-1.1192785501480103,
-0.5419989824295044,
-0.33978965878486633,
-0.3633974492549896,
-0.18348973989486694,
0.1575574278831482,
1.1817257404327393,
0.6911412477493286,
-0.923289954662323,
-0.04374467208981514,
-0.08359108120203018,
0.19918490946292877,
-0.1877211034297943,
-0.2542659342288971,
0.5307183861732483,
-0.275542676448822,
-0.47045931220054626,
0.05627063661813736,
0.6184040307998657,
-0.0857088640332222,
-0.5070749521255493,
0.2706456184387207,
-0.46094438433647156,
0.2793550193309784,
0.699616551399231,
0.5816560387611389,
-0.9314972162246704,
-0.1493682712316513,
0.10094457864761353,
-0.03065364435315132,
0.18055641651153564,
0.5127238631248474,
-0.7545677423477173,
0.6725299954414368,
0.4247003197669983,
0.46394509077072144,
0.5908070206642151,
0.33115339279174805,
0.3869119882583618,
-0.6629734039306641,
-0.11841634660959244,
0.4470899999141693,
0.03161853551864624,
0.7931832075119019,
-0.32806524634361267,
0.3887893855571747,
0.6490382552146912,
-0.1810338795185089,
-0.7571107745170593,
0.01964789442718029,
-1.0798391103744507,
-0.16399091482162476,
1.1377696990966797,
0.01157414447516203,
-0.389432430267334,
-0.4133121371269226,
-0.24029211699962616,
0.32533732056617737,
-0.3035571575164795,
1.197709083557129,
0.611100971698761,
0.16520956158638,
0.08921227604150772,
-0.27201515436172485,
0.5385614633560181,
-0.057058755308389664,
-0.763924777507782,
-0.08222678303718567,
0.19251829385757446,
0.4046025276184082,
0.5376158952713013,
0.40495622158050537,
-0.10953515768051147,
0.009886175394058228,
-0.45712944865226746,
0.21972908079624176,
0.17898206412792206,
0.05125783383846283,
-0.3902140259742737,
-0.132390096783638,
-0.21133092045783997,
-0.05795620009303093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01040v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01040v1
|
Few Shot Class Incremental Learning using Vision-Language models
| 2024-05-02T06:52:49 | 2024-05-02T06:52:49 |
Anurag Kumar, Chinmay Bharti, Saikat Dutta, Srikrishna Karanam, Biplab Banerjee
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, eess.IV
|
Recent advancements in deep learning have demonstrated remarkable performance
comparable to human capabilities across various supervised computer vision
tasks. However, the prevalent assumption of having an extensive pool of
training data encompassing all classes prior to model training often diverges
from real-world scenarios, where limited data availability for novel classes is
the norm. The challenge emerges in seamlessly integrating new classes with few
samples into the training data, demanding the model to adeptly accommodate
these additions without compromising its performance on base classes. To
address this exigency, the research community has introduced several solutions
under the realm of few-shot class incremental learning (FSCIL).
In this study, we introduce an innovative FSCIL framework that utilizes
language regularizer and subspace regularizer. During base training, the
language regularizer helps incorporate semantic information extracted from a
Vision-Language model. The subspace regularizer helps in facilitating the
model's acquisition of nuanced connections between image and text semantics
inherent to base classes during incremental training. Our proposed framework
not only empowers the model to embrace novel classes with limited data, but
also ensures the preservation of performance on base classes. To substantiate
the efficacy of our approach, we conduct comprehensive experiments on three
distinct FSCIL benchmarks, where our framework attains state-of-the-art
performance.
|
[
-0.308494508266449,
-0.5488694310188293,
0.35645994544029236,
-0.1686984747648239,
-0.28142163157463074,
0.1607428938150406,
-0.38984209299087524,
-0.5231586694717407,
-0.0580921433866024,
0.2780766487121582,
-0.48132947087287903,
-0.6895961165428162,
-0.6576111316680908,
-0.04820922762155533,
-0.3777027130126953,
0.6317588090896606,
0.04882197082042694,
-0.018115263432264328,
-0.041402388364076614,
-0.26367634534835815,
-0.28556710481643677,
-0.28359267115592957,
-0.23397934436798096,
-0.04406670853495598,
0.27702003717422485,
0.7935316562652588,
0.6216108202934265,
0.5913844704627991,
0.6267350912094116,
0.20126697421073914,
0.2506146728992462,
0.07122909277677536,
-0.5352320075035095,
-0.3116377592086792,
0.08577646315097809,
-0.41279667615890503,
-0.22241255640983582,
-0.06749838590621948,
1.0735316276550293,
0.883451521396637,
0.08264388889074326,
0.11165472865104675,
0.14666534960269928,
0.5561660528182983,
-0.9358202815055847,
0.10307992994785309,
-0.8032076358795166,
0.21083900332450867,
-0.23893477022647858,
-0.018246643245220184,
-0.4368584156036377,
-0.27301979064941406,
0.2219800502061844,
-0.6996555328369141,
0.5783326029777527,
-0.3186611235141754,
1.0390517711639404,
0.32327523827552795,
0.1324416697025299,
0.2419433295726776,
-0.5160855054855347,
0.8665439486503601,
-0.5458364486694336,
0.6660695672035217,
0.27267616987228394,
0.3253849744796753,
0.20106101036071777,
-0.6723394989967346,
-0.5906423926353455,
-0.12434191256761551,
-0.11167904734611511,
-0.07234667986631393,
0.004071393050253391,
0.19996213912963867,
0.2274334579706192,
0.38346701860427856,
-0.7285383939743042,
0.20398789644241333,
-0.22655190527439117,
-0.05275767296552658,
0.38306546211242676,
0.2835136950016022,
-0.08596856147050858,
0.15671642124652863,
-0.5956406593322754,
-0.25344449281692505,
-0.5308607220649719,
0.21504734456539154,
0.002076677978038788,
0.6591395735740662,
-0.2708387076854706,
0.19141137599945068,
-0.40201690793037415,
0.9733970761299133,
-0.06365791708230972,
-0.35755255818367004,
0.2695232331752777,
-0.38997775316238403,
-0.4169386923313141,
-0.17721374332904816,
0.5546751618385315,
0.09701705724000931,
0.2498762011528015,
-0.14538715779781342,
-0.04729389399290085,
0.5639597773551941,
0.026858458295464516,
-0.9979104995727539,
-0.3549938499927521,
-0.19142454862594604,
-0.34788617491722107,
-0.5001266598701477,
0.07900656759738922,
-0.7597073912620544,
-0.20135699212551117,
-0.28224167227745056,
0.2863460183143616,
-0.5647919178009033,
-0.09474349021911621,
0.05557243153452873,
0.11007989943027496,
0.40075570344924927,
0.4378316104412079,
-1.0576927661895752,
0.47818681597709656,
0.5623738169670105,
0.7768057584762573,
-0.37507393956184387,
-0.48805364966392517,
-0.6027284264564514,
-0.05503694340586662,
-0.5185941457748413,
0.795846700668335,
-0.7563936710357666,
-0.1030225083231926,
0.028096605092287064,
-0.13404977321624756,
0.010882000438869,
-0.2956017553806305,
0.05408633127808571,
-0.31158968806266785,
-0.03659006580710411,
0.15764738619327545,
-0.4189351201057434,
-0.012629332020878792,
0.36306414008140564,
-0.266830712556839,
0.8972334265708923,
0.120966836810112,
-0.6560338139533997,
0.6056995391845703,
-0.269771546125412,
-0.2805769741535187,
0.519324004650116,
-0.597619891166687,
-0.5130735039710999,
0.1627979427576065,
0.04901133477687836,
0.5463088750839233,
-0.1196625828742981,
0.034959014505147934,
-0.2835231125354767,
-0.679121732711792,
-0.1015225425362587,
-0.5074314475059509,
0.3806401789188385,
-0.05588062107563019,
-0.09169242531061172,
-0.10435409098863602,
-0.8254703879356384,
0.07660975307226181,
0.051517512649297714,
-0.27885502576828003,
-0.39032793045043945,
-0.2928849458694458,
0.23893409967422485,
0.22214624285697937,
0.1473795473575592,
-0.8548483848571777,
0.3230971395969391,
-0.6040045619010925,
-0.07333742082118988,
0.7479022145271301,
0.05706902593374252,
0.840308427810669,
-0.09971318393945694,
0.5022977590560913,
0.008982272818684578,
0.21630419790744781,
-0.5354992747306824,
-0.405781090259552,
-0.8976461887359619,
-0.5264749526977539,
0.2442500740289688,
0.5749693512916565,
-1.016409158706665,
-0.026380589231848717,
-0.4112679362297058,
-0.389060914516449,
-0.5361165404319763,
0.48542946577072144,
0.4458088278770447,
0.41033634543418884,
0.3878399431705475,
-0.4457634687423706,
-0.34761297702789307,
-0.8613935112953186,
0.00463695777580142,
0.12652897834777832,
0.11841001361608505,
0.29319649934768677,
0.3457149565219879,
-0.24743163585662842,
1.2428479194641113,
-0.6864453554153442,
-0.6060841679573059,
-0.45311811566352844,
-0.039292119443416595,
-0.013881171122193336,
0.610646665096283,
0.8263052105903625,
-0.640264093875885,
-0.48738718032836914,
0.03972089663147926,
-0.8415334820747375,
0.30524513125419617,
-0.24973341822624207,
-0.04840659350156784,
0.12060632556676865,
0.18670222163200378,
0.06074269115924835,
0.8081748485565186,
0.45952409505844116,
-0.02641366235911846,
0.09571772068738937,
0.1623528003692627,
0.058601077646017075,
-0.7234656810760498,
-0.07497408986091614,
0.20956404507160187,
-0.3297431468963623,
-0.7697707414627075,
0.11484838277101517,
0.1329430490732193,
-0.3464706540107727,
-0.7475277185440063,
0.5723083019256592,
-0.08947830647230148,
-0.11451633274555206,
-0.354912668466568,
0.016267262399196625,
-0.020622434094548225,
0.6809366941452026,
0.4101226329803467,
0.4124842882156372,
0.8648809194564819,
-0.5658239722251892,
-0.05632898584008217,
0.41704660654067993,
-0.2783152163028717,
0.39991483092308044,
-0.23910799622535706,
0.006349958945065737,
-0.1932266652584076,
0.12989722192287445,
-0.9967424273490906,
-0.2685662806034088,
0.05419931188225746,
-0.4361901879310608,
0.42561158537864685,
-0.28902703523635864,
-0.5473284125328064,
-0.1164529025554657,
-0.3493727743625641,
0.2930586636066437,
0.40044111013412476,
-0.5199090838432312,
0.46349677443504333,
0.13518133759498596,
0.014139240607619286,
-0.6426894664764404,
-0.9885409474372864,
0.08386258780956268,
0.32057127356529236,
-0.6511856913566589,
0.31805387139320374,
0.052198201417922974,
0.1543806940317154,
-0.10745453834533691,
-0.10315496474504471,
-0.47131940722465515,
0.17464682459831238,
0.3549566864967346,
0.5761724710464478,
-0.3308512568473816,
0.08542141318321228,
0.07234151661396027,
-0.40437304973602295,
-0.5940608978271484,
-0.3929315209388733,
0.3593066334724426,
-0.33554890751838684,
-0.19480471312999725,
-0.8834834098815918,
0.4846976101398468,
0.3317626118659973,
-0.3635418117046356,
0.6543333530426025,
0.49167996644973755,
-0.4915130138397217,
-0.2239660769701004,
-0.6307269930839539,
-0.3770091235637665,
-0.48884695768356323,
0.36917632818222046,
-0.5836685299873352,
-1.1624369621276855,
0.013647302985191345,
-0.12948092818260193,
0.22235450148582458,
0.07209887355566025,
0.29887157678604126,
-0.01590185984969139,
0.7218782901763916,
1.1884407997131348,
-0.10716857016086578,
0.861175000667572,
-0.5761147141456604,
0.09034682810306549,
-0.34405553340911865,
-0.06576886773109436,
-0.10268508642911911,
-0.32592228055000305,
-0.3955874741077423,
-0.39734187722206116,
0.18681040406227112,
-0.08161794394254684,
0.015641314908862114,
0.3728680908679962,
-0.456734836101532,
0.6100837588310242,
0.20374444127082825,
0.21759532392024994,
0.3238692283630371,
0.35569217801094055,
-0.2479247748851776,
-0.34674957394599915,
-1.0572270154953003,
-0.33534112572669983,
0.7236961126327515,
0.532435953617096,
0.9313009977340698,
-0.16883960366249084,
0.9618164300918579,
0.02711040899157524,
0.4862474501132965,
-0.9004138708114624,
0.6640498638153076,
-0.6544639468193054,
-0.23306125402450562,
-0.09003495424985886,
-0.2334863394498825,
-0.5340293049812317,
0.3610830307006836,
-0.45000749826431274,
-0.4711510241031647,
0.775111973285675,
0.194890096783638,
-0.42032212018966675,
0.21058034896850586,
-0.5765000581741333,
0.9239295125007629,
-0.09929368644952774,
-0.8085892796516418,
-0.09792222827672958,
-0.8477908372879028,
0.4065592885017395,
-0.017149776220321655,
0.03840313479304314,
-0.08462360501289368,
-0.008249398320913315,
0.3267327547073364,
-0.3632074296474457,
1.1479942798614502,
-0.4434119462966919,
0.2536899447441101,
0.17181022465229034,
0.10003010183572769,
0.2975759208202362,
-0.1395760178565979,
0.20800122618675232,
0.37106087803840637,
-0.16695202887058258,
-0.5096558928489685,
-0.41852352023124695,
0.6449193358421326,
-0.5783383250236511,
-0.015079430304467678,
-0.47554507851600647,
-0.2984011471271515,
-0.3257346451282501,
0.1548786610364914,
0.3306439518928528,
0.38282525539398193,
-0.17288993299007416,
0.1719125658273697,
0.6336528062820435,
-0.21196070313453674,
0.507787823677063,
0.5883593559265137,
-0.049418091773986816,
-0.37715858221054077,
1.0289723873138428,
-0.07131268084049225,
0.563874363899231,
0.3356282114982605,
-0.014163592830300331,
0.14837932586669922,
-0.4033481478691101,
-0.46055513620376587,
0.16807425022125244,
-0.8691383600234985,
-0.3571794629096985,
-0.5264454483985901,
-0.2174670398235321,
-0.39321109652519226,
-0.5839276909828186,
-0.5375511646270752,
-0.3354611396789551,
-0.31037744879722595,
0.05420718342065811,
0.2050863653421402,
0.3067743480205536,
0.16762852668762207,
0.39205697178840637,
-0.7743048667907715,
0.3948522210121155,
0.29242411255836487,
0.3697063624858856,
-0.05869846045970917,
-0.5228410363197327,
-0.4091518521308899,
-0.16857704520225525,
-0.023749731481075287,
-0.4721159040927887,
0.2743653357028961,
0.499896377325058,
0.4463244080543518,
0.31749820709228516,
-0.2075413465499878,
0.9011096954345703,
-0.6226730942726135,
0.6691088080406189,
0.37411192059516907,
-0.8314225077629089,
0.6607679128646851,
-0.04364028945565224,
0.38467901945114136,
1.0757938623428345,
0.16568557918071747,
-0.3062964975833893,
-0.45240676403045654,
-0.4797441065311432,
-0.7266184687614441,
0.7069828510284424,
0.07050201296806335,
0.156683087348938,
0.13805362582206726,
0.4075414538383484,
0.1468459814786911,
0.16004961729049683,
-0.7273244261741638,
-0.03790014982223511,
-0.3957534432411194,
-0.37755563855171204,
0.18137608468532562,
-0.10127656906843185,
0.35103875398635864,
-0.23165467381477356,
0.4166599214076996,
-0.40858015418052673,
0.07469084858894348,
0.038767505437135696,
-0.484065443277359,
-0.014454211108386517,
0.21152015030384064,
0.5608589053153992,
0.27879446744918823,
-0.08173561841249466,
-0.0025798974093049765,
0.24502040445804596,
-0.6266461610794067,
0.24232658743858337,
-0.00014082701818551868,
-0.36243537068367004,
0.09384574741125107,
0.4153665006160736,
0.7725871801376343,
0.43720099329948425,
-0.5789985060691833,
0.909704327583313,
-0.059289392083883286,
-0.35726043581962585,
-0.1838810294866562,
0.1348201483488083,
-0.6621955633163452,
0.13537640869617462,
0.5683271288871765,
0.5261624455451965,
0.0487256720662117,
-0.26110604405403137,
0.5298001170158386,
0.2816811800003052,
-0.46805304288864136,
-0.2282169610261917,
0.45446154475212097,
0.0839136391878128,
0.10713517665863037,
0.3367390036582947,
-0.2285865843296051,
-0.5010052919387817,
0.2624889612197876,
0.31854236125946045,
0.8769968152046204,
-0.10438915342092514,
0.18654625117778778,
0.410162091255188,
0.49248775839805603,
-0.09862091392278671,
0.23578467965126038,
-0.4031594693660736,
-0.8642441034317017,
-0.48872002959251404,
-0.7453993558883667,
-0.35889652371406555,
-0.17781992256641388,
-0.37821164727211,
0.46090784668922424,
-0.8881304860115051,
0.09313292801380157,
-0.055865269154310226,
-0.19418679177761078,
-0.8684709072113037,
0.22932153940200806,
0.5013060569763184,
0.9652631282806396,
-1.1316109895706177,
1.2121987342834473,
0.6400377750396729,
-0.5593578815460205,
-0.5061655044555664,
0.17093481123447418,
-0.010321885347366333,
-0.4945468008518219,
0.9033933281898499,
0.2147909253835678,
-0.40965765714645386,
0.13341502845287323,
-0.7035209536552429,
-0.6429604887962341,
0.980261504650116,
0.3654489517211914,
-0.6805367469787598,
0.01472326461225748,
0.11920139193534851,
0.4373742341995239,
-0.5457549691200256,
-0.3207569122314453,
0.4991844594478607,
0.2829606831073761,
0.3527999222278595,
-0.5545823574066162,
-0.23348627984523773,
-0.11777173727750778,
0.32377344369888306,
0.12567169964313507,
-0.5495654344558716,
0.5559640526771545,
-0.22488635778427124,
-0.28559741377830505,
0.3282725512981415,
0.7093866467475891,
0.2039199024438858,
0.4290105700492859,
0.4343026578426361,
0.5431666970252991,
0.3474995791912079,
-0.09643007814884186,
0.9973288774490356,
-0.028010521084070206,
0.4718948006629944,
1.2079837322235107,
-0.3799256682395935,
1.0510915517807007,
0.2968865633010864,
-0.02370574325323105,
0.36935561895370483,
0.36969444155693054,
-0.18810735642910004,
0.8931837677955627,
-0.15683408081531525,
-0.430087685585022,
-0.416766881942749,
-0.12637867033481598,
0.008649337105453014,
0.6089441776275635,
0.4254207909107208,
-0.30430737137794495,
-0.39524006843566895,
0.5840789079666138,
-0.33509576320648193,
0.13902857899665833,
-0.19122813642024994,
0.8197095394134521,
-0.16966983675956726,
-0.23897899687290192,
0.6998490691184998,
0.04117750748991966,
0.98099684715271,
-0.661401093006134,
-0.2274225354194641,
-0.2730485200881958,
0.5117349028587341,
-0.4722423851490021,
-0.3799176514148712,
0.1373906135559082,
0.15087629854679108,
-0.10496398061513901,
-0.23220118880271912,
0.879712700843811,
-0.5509252548217773,
-0.5848355889320374,
-0.009725315496325493,
0.14317800104618073,
-0.008762387558817863,
0.20881076157093048,
-0.5402930974960327,
0.2958329916000366,
-0.045174624770879745,
0.4677133560180664,
0.2750958800315857,
0.12437844276428223,
0.03894852101802826,
0.320420503616333,
0.5360016822814941,
-0.02115737460553646,
0.15037399530410767,
0.05652492493391037,
1.0541783571243286,
-0.4072585701942444,
-0.4919764995574951,
-0.7454599738121033,
0.6444166302680969,
-0.06299227476119995,
-0.21723732352256775,
0.5480843782424927,
0.7026103138923645,
0.7638565301895142,
-0.11165273934602737,
0.7672417759895325,
0.16583117842674255,
0.40178099274635315,
-0.5075601935386658,
0.5346181392669678,
-0.48190921545028687,
0.1752910017967224,
-0.5480850338935852,
-0.7335129380226135,
-0.8136307597160339,
0.9946666955947876,
-0.22466865181922913,
-0.21100245416164398,
0.6212656497955322,
0.8258723616600037,
-0.18976713716983795,
-0.1269630640745163,
0.5848977565765381,
-0.01551929209381342,
0.2778482437133789,
0.6856351494789124,
0.7438818216323853,
-0.6127273440361023,
0.3218919038772583,
-0.49059322476387024,
-0.46966424584388733,
-0.27324309945106506,
-0.6728501915931702,
-0.7650995254516602,
-0.40719863772392273,
-0.5792319178581238,
0.05850517004728317,
0.0799185261130333,
0.950753390789032,
0.8867997527122498,
-0.7721386551856995,
-0.0761898085474968,
-0.22758908569812775,
-0.15834090113639832,
-0.033986158668994904,
-0.2568211257457733,
0.1201414242386818,
-0.4045467972755432,
-0.5988376140594482,
0.48898133635520935,
0.699069082736969,
0.24062421917915344,
-0.33360999822616577,
-0.03197336941957474,
-0.3817131519317627,
-0.23498758673667908,
0.6675903797149658,
0.38408362865448,
-0.6837149262428284,
-0.3086220622062683,
0.06879517436027527,
-0.20764724910259247,
0.14325746893882751,
0.9142300486564636,
-1.2747294902801514,
0.5425648093223572,
0.43871909379959106,
0.9400220513343811,
0.7497033476829529,
-0.10741681605577469,
0.10889803618192673,
-1.3372666835784912,
0.8243615031242371,
0.34973952174186707,
0.21690432727336884,
0.46238628029823303,
-0.17444030940532684,
0.5253937244415283,
0.39892178773880005,
-0.06617339700460434,
-0.7899187803268433,
0.26837530732154846,
-0.9151708483695984,
-0.14485594630241394,
0.8109299540519714,
-0.19687992334365845,
0.09227641671895981,
0.12851016223430634,
-0.01656527630984783,
-0.12913373112678528,
-0.27861401438713074,
0.31673315167427063,
0.4152897000312805,
-0.07764390110969543,
-0.5195106863975525,
-0.48768094182014465,
0.3248358368873596,
0.2837899625301361,
-0.7345220446586609,
-0.11870679259300232,
0.7241570353507996,
0.2541164755821228,
0.09773154556751251,
0.6179429292678833,
-0.13416892290115356,
0.5547152161598206,
0.04109539836645126,
-0.04627807065844536,
0.060171809047460556,
-0.6472715139389038,
-0.5465704202651978,
0.30498093366622925,
0.0322764553129673,
-0.5019696354866028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.01022v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.01022v2
|
UniGen: Universal Domain Generalization for Sentiment Classification via Zero-shot Dataset Generation
| 2024-05-02T05:46:13 | 2024-05-03T01:20:28 |
Juhwan Choi, Yeonghwa Kim, Seunguk Yu, JungMin Yun, YoungBin Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Although pre-trained language models have exhibited great flexibility and
versatility with prompt-based few-shot learning, they suffer from the extensive
parameter size and limited applicability for inference. Recent studies have
suggested that PLMs be used as dataset generators and a tiny task-specific
model be trained to achieve efficient inference. However, their applicability
to various domains is limited because they tend to generate domain-specific
datasets. In this work, we propose a novel approach to universal domain
generalization that generates a dataset regardless of the target domain. This
allows for generalization of the tiny task model to any domain that shares the
label space, thus enhancing the real-world applicability of the dataset
generation paradigm. Our experiments indicate that the proposed method
accomplishes generalizability across various domains while using a parameter
set that is orders of magnitude smaller than PLMs.
|
[
-0.46157994866371155,
-0.3690800666809082,
0.31398674845695496,
-0.19555330276489258,
-0.509574294090271,
-0.013153349980711937,
-0.4448038935661316,
0.033333245664834976,
0.0942862331867218,
0.5226678252220154,
-0.696196973323822,
-0.9466421604156494,
-0.397918701171875,
-0.1272875964641571,
0.052748821675777435,
1.2399934530258179,
0.15882794559001923,
-0.1228611171245575,
-0.23112834990024567,
-0.25585001707077026,
-0.23929065465927124,
-0.7541248202323914,
-0.266661137342453,
-0.26301562786102295,
0.47469642758369446,
0.7072126269340515,
0.3499772548675537,
0.1019681766629219,
0.4205264151096344,
0.16933012008666992,
0.44542962312698364,
0.21928291022777557,
-0.32552671432495117,
0.27460765838623047,
-0.21141216158866882,
-0.34436798095703125,
-0.4488825798034668,
0.2351013869047165,
0.45393794775009155,
1.2239958047866821,
0.08673832565546036,
0.5167350769042969,
0.2008957415819168,
0.47827574610710144,
-0.8242141008377075,
-0.0007606587605550885,
-0.7898109555244446,
0.20652706921100616,
-0.32967817783355713,
0.01953137293457985,
-0.35057714581489563,
-0.0965825542807579,
-0.0413135290145874,
-0.7165257930755615,
0.6515145301818848,
-0.04734800010919571,
0.521115243434906,
0.0798596739768982,
-0.5789309740066528,
0.17478062212467194,
-0.8370135426521301,
1.2402234077453613,
-0.5450288653373718,
0.03704205900430679,
-0.06861907243728638,
0.3480929136276245,
0.06762062013149261,
-0.6113982200622559,
-0.6900006532669067,
0.31147682666778564,
0.3911829888820648,
0.2091321051120758,
-0.34728604555130005,
0.2018938660621643,
0.19945579767227173,
0.2107064127922058,
-0.5206763744354248,
-0.2531876266002655,
0.03457546979188919,
-0.0901525691151619,
0.5523495078086853,
0.28145354986190796,
0.10408524423837662,
-0.28090372681617737,
-0.3423473536968231,
0.1255389004945755,
-0.7263093590736389,
0.17199282348155975,
0.09200958907604218,
0.9194431304931641,
0.18332405388355255,
0.3566974401473999,
-0.28419753909111023,
0.7551390528678894,
-0.06967668980360031,
0.12482424080371857,
0.16609406471252441,
0.05662313848733902,
-0.6201682686805725,
-0.28636986017227173,
0.7971470355987549,
0.38846468925476074,
0.42902907729148865,
-0.19528493285179138,
0.15870438516139984,
0.6601288318634033,
0.49356868863105774,
-0.7952428460121155,
-0.09229442477226257,
0.1576165407896042,
-0.3990214765071869,
-0.4544195532798767,
0.19512620568275452,
-0.8250998258590698,
-0.33386901021003723,
-0.2802560329437256,
0.1405511200428009,
-0.10660786926746368,
-0.0698777437210083,
0.2807876169681549,
0.18885965645313263,
0.09737300127744675,
0.19488777220249176,
-0.5543254613876343,
0.28366973996162415,
0.398220032453537,
0.5012093782424927,
-0.27879542112350464,
-0.12270144373178482,
-0.4345921277999878,
0.05116664990782738,
-0.3797138035297394,
0.8983899354934692,
-0.7028710246086121,
-0.5186141133308411,
0.2530253827571869,
-0.24236425757408142,
-0.23322276771068573,
-0.5237157344818115,
0.7770490050315857,
-0.5205202102661133,
0.3131510019302368,
-0.16650615632534027,
-0.6272441744804382,
-0.3137725591659546,
0.1228223592042923,
-0.21136343479156494,
0.7403332591056824,
0.2621052861213684,
-0.7416568398475647,
0.5399698615074158,
-0.748680055141449,
-0.366800993680954,
0.16756504774093628,
-0.263373464345932,
-0.5461374521255493,
0.3650300204753876,
0.0004462254873942584,
0.8998562693595886,
-0.3510843515396118,
0.16636359691619873,
-0.7163944244384766,
-0.2357933670282364,
0.21135355532169342,
-0.15045426785945892,
0.6853496432304382,
0.30983421206474304,
-0.2720285952091217,
-0.22804932296276093,
-0.6336459517478943,
0.3070596754550934,
0.152702197432518,
-0.18604959547519684,
-0.5466130971908569,
-0.3773767650127411,
-0.05426682159304619,
0.3736943304538727,
-0.0063791642896831036,
-1.1085060834884644,
0.39631783962249756,
-0.23925931751728058,
-0.04206743463873863,
0.42947620153427124,
0.45148879289627075,
0.5884149670600891,
-0.06403373926877975,
0.6517317891120911,
0.27961236238479614,
0.1758810132741928,
0.2124989628791809,
-0.3442801833152771,
-0.719492495059967,
-0.4918607473373413,
0.659055769443512,
0.3801361322402954,
-0.7113104462623596,
0.35940685868263245,
-0.34253937005996704,
-0.13167612254619598,
-0.4201224148273468,
0.443798691034317,
0.4161793291568756,
0.5895434021949768,
0.1806604266166687,
-0.5319440960884094,
-0.734869658946991,
-0.7253109216690063,
-0.3247166872024536,
0.2986418306827545,
-0.24461659789085388,
0.43976685404777527,
0.36071768403053284,
-0.16230200231075287,
1.1078559160232544,
-0.7135589122772217,
-0.7377944588661194,
-0.6151543855667114,
0.27688854932785034,
0.37217622995376587,
0.26604536175727844,
0.6113446354866028,
-0.4291493892669678,
-0.771443784236908,
-0.2802792489528656,
-1.0818629264831543,
-0.037667885422706604,
-0.009033328853547573,
-0.3091556131839752,
0.1852555274963379,
0.024915825575590134,
-0.6871278285980225,
0.49494799971580505,
0.10704557597637177,
-0.20935842394828796,
0.1176314651966095,
0.14470645785331726,
-0.1560669094324112,
-1.1402587890625,
0.08406169712543488,
0.35920459032058716,
-0.3250250220298767,
-0.9733004570007324,
-0.15338656306266785,
-0.2886137366294861,
-0.2968790829181671,
-0.5445824265480042,
0.4802764356136322,
-0.29920485615730286,
-0.17467591166496277,
-0.39051738381385803,
0.0453515499830246,
0.08076845109462738,
0.7231298685073853,
0.042698003351688385,
0.41889292001724243,
0.8251511454582214,
-0.6841674447059631,
0.18332242965698242,
0.3647952377796173,
-0.11374524980783463,
0.7798568606376648,
-0.3729231655597687,
0.12970797717571259,
-0.13506552577018738,
0.24498338997364044,
-0.9939244389533997,
-0.22098681330680847,
0.27874353528022766,
-0.6939821839332581,
0.34179019927978516,
-0.19296564161777496,
-0.2734651267528534,
-0.4929746091365814,
-0.6475635170936584,
0.10385971516370773,
0.7850233912467957,
-0.5939225554466248,
0.347898930311203,
0.3079940378665924,
-0.08761826902627945,
-0.6156395673751831,
-0.5293486714363098,
-0.18979768455028534,
-0.33990028500556946,
-0.2524698078632355,
0.125902459025383,
-0.15227068960666656,
-0.12149889022111893,
-0.20258834958076477,
-0.24833503365516663,
-0.0322871133685112,
-0.09287433326244354,
0.5458167791366577,
0.2787008285522461,
-0.12176377326250076,
0.14637313783168793,
0.30938127636909485,
0.008600925095379353,
-0.10766256600618362,
-0.4653787314891815,
0.29971182346343994,
-0.04880169406533241,
-0.13387271761894226,
-0.4193354547023773,
0.5771536827087402,
0.32181888818740845,
0.09420373290777206,
0.44449588656425476,
0.4354017674922943,
-0.2075522541999817,
-0.9210559725761414,
-0.06423578411340714,
-0.0692690908908844,
-0.4387649595737457,
-0.15959055721759796,
-0.5749375224113464,
-0.8365673422813416,
0.36173519492149353,
-0.5789058208465576,
0.07159146666526794,
0.3980000615119934,
0.47953173518180847,
-0.41189301013946533,
1.3019288778305054,
0.7811287641525269,
-0.3431589603424072,
0.05738849565386772,
-0.6864360570907593,
0.20962995290756226,
-1.0116868019104004,
0.052044689655303955,
-0.26088541746139526,
-0.44437578320503235,
-0.28911757469177246,
-0.3331664800643921,
0.3207479417324066,
0.15704573690891266,
-0.4481583535671234,
-0.1037515178322792,
-0.6483166813850403,
0.46736907958984375,
0.5404196977615356,
-0.03571239858865738,
0.14720620214939117,
0.5416123270988464,
-0.3679672181606293,
-0.27499932050704956,
-0.6954066157341003,
-0.6249566078186035,
1.513492465019226,
-0.08692757040262222,
0.525847852230072,
-0.05654103308916092,
0.7959758043289185,
0.9323365092277527,
0.422653466463089,
-0.7078782320022583,
0.6144987344741821,
-0.7500791549682617,
-0.42088353633880615,
-0.06147874891757965,
-0.20452815294265747,
-1.120782494544983,
0.3529263138771057,
0.024761758744716644,
-0.5769394040107727,
0.39360693097114563,
0.13995279371738434,
-0.6442455053329468,
0.4249701201915741,
-0.27159684896469116,
0.8215721845626831,
0.3104184567928314,
-0.12417049705982208,
0.2104066163301468,
-0.7050349712371826,
0.3974835276603699,
0.01057940162718296,
0.17051362991333008,
-0.3626115322113037,
0.0009197837789542973,
0.7048378586769104,
-0.43061068654060364,
1.3676661252975464,
-0.7878545522689819,
0.12037988752126694,
0.708859384059906,
0.14136813580989838,
-0.008479579351842403,
0.00588603550568223,
0.05198769271373749,
0.2587396502494812,
-0.523829996585846,
-0.5776261687278748,
-0.6306607127189636,
0.6296159625053406,
-0.9165999293327332,
-0.1525690257549286,
-0.3186487853527069,
-0.4102552533149719,
-0.9182291626930237,
0.054285887628793716,
0.4522702395915985,
0.4094577133655548,
-0.350931853055954,
-0.08183705806732178,
0.6464305520057678,
0.07783278822898865,
0.35126274824142456,
0.8423691391944885,
-0.04042463004589081,
-0.2406144142150879,
1.211974024772644,
-0.2168015092611313,
-0.1933545172214508,
0.14135533571243286,
-0.1429552584886551,
-0.24328970909118652,
-0.30474117398262024,
-0.4603017568588257,
0.16252237558364868,
-0.6456728577613831,
-0.7852517366409302,
-0.4045332968235016,
0.08496151119470596,
-0.4635229706764221,
-0.2736826241016388,
-0.1999594271183014,
-0.6213312149047852,
-0.44864192605018616,
-0.05256021395325661,
0.23648382723331451,
0.6577171683311462,
-0.3328185975551605,
0.6142827272415161,
-0.6950713992118835,
0.47900834679603577,
0.49796202778816223,
0.3855113685131073,
-0.26108869910240173,
-0.6990611553192139,
-0.0002875921200029552,
0.15111392736434937,
-0.437274694442749,
-0.7135136127471924,
0.5787743330001831,
0.7229650616645813,
0.3850606083869934,
0.5256399512290955,
0.31324318051338196,
0.086314357817173,
-0.3426625728607178,
0.9478740692138672,
0.2358313947916031,
-1.0199551582336426,
0.6288552284240723,
-0.5567875504493713,
0.09807786345481873,
0.6246029734611511,
0.6038031578063965,
-0.39815956354141235,
-0.2694127857685089,
-0.7669057250022888,
-0.6692158579826355,
0.7599931955337524,
-0.07635536044836044,
0.41266852617263794,
0.06597807258367538,
0.511622965335846,
0.401112824678421,
0.5519411563873291,
-0.372360497713089,
-0.4806321859359741,
-0.3598565459251404,
-0.4708794057369232,
-0.024962451308965683,
-0.14330776035785675,
-0.09559065103530884,
-0.3609871566295624,
0.6598914265632629,
-0.488788902759552,
0.5026246905326843,
-0.01657050848007202,
-0.2549740672111511,
-0.3041027784347534,
0.5101515650749207,
0.3315868377685547,
0.12540303170681,
-0.24057574570178986,
0.16972346603870392,
0.03212546184659004,
-0.1779623031616211,
0.29887598752975464,
-0.13443593680858612,
-0.29378512501716614,
0.21341276168823242,
-0.04978432506322861,
0.7876089811325073,
-0.06190081313252449,
-0.3385230600833893,
0.7971736788749695,
-0.025332588702440262,
-0.6584814190864563,
-0.07309605181217194,
-0.0061404225416481495,
-0.3021377623081207,
0.2639697194099426,
0.2482064664363861,
0.1834212690591812,
0.17176756262779236,
-0.3845062255859375,
0.3015824258327484,
0.5297976136207581,
-0.4346773624420166,
-0.5869588255882263,
0.6794559359550476,
0.2342253178358078,
0.3021514117717743,
0.5553516149520874,
-0.5003171563148499,
-0.45179852843284607,
0.3010745644569397,
0.3948037922382355,
1.0615533590316772,
-0.32954034209251404,
0.8583438992500305,
0.03199869394302368,
-0.19958534836769104,
0.3548556864261627,
0.8003721237182617,
-0.2581023573875427,
-1.096232295036316,
-0.30923089385032654,
-0.7359228134155273,
-0.5875647664070129,
0.23296105861663818,
-0.8798558712005615,
-0.26845425367355347,
-0.6782976388931274,
-0.42281150817871094,
0.14569051563739777,
0.11594074219465256,
-0.8082187175750732,
0.48685920238494873,
0.37521684169769287,
0.5642713308334351,
-1.0885347127914429,
1.0263752937316895,
1.099462628364563,
-0.43297407031059265,
-0.4748291075229645,
-0.049899872392416,
-0.028427906334400177,
-0.6590285897254944,
0.9092495441436768,
-0.055299822241067886,
-0.05198821797966957,
0.053799182176589966,
-0.8623153567314148,
-0.4330821931362152,
0.8478091955184937,
0.31988173723220825,
-0.2211298942565918,
0.2722635865211487,
0.5609624981880188,
0.7900383472442627,
-0.8447318077087402,
-0.36170509457588196,
0.5200383067131042,
0.2230038195848465,
0.06716371327638626,
-0.4004283845424652,
0.07650908082723618,
-0.3763186037540436,
0.23284569382667542,
0.08872228860855103,
-0.5599443912506104,
0.8560752868652344,
-0.33387240767478943,
-0.24727283418178558,
-0.2298632562160492,
0.7573170065879822,
0.10995930433273315,
0.3531860411167145,
0.34632834792137146,
0.6679061651229858,
0.6493108868598938,
0.010069528594613075,
0.9930540919303894,
-0.24984806776046753,
0.5529506802558899,
1.0854252576828003,
-0.6521093845367432,
0.772106409072876,
0.060733646154403687,
-0.2949351966381073,
0.567823052406311,
0.4303497076034546,
-0.12055179476737976,
0.656198263168335,
0.22491540014743805,
-0.7375495433807373,
-0.49406999349594116,
-0.40111058950424194,
-0.06779404729604721,
0.48012295365333557,
0.39764538407325745,
-0.21346664428710938,
-0.37232106924057007,
0.3537270724773407,
0.11581309884786606,
0.025352520868182182,
-0.5239253044128418,
0.7817652225494385,
0.1841597557067871,
-0.2830142378807068,
0.6580535769462585,
0.03373971953988075,
0.8781499862670898,
-0.3583477735519409,
0.20554526150226593,
-0.36110633611679077,
0.46119919419288635,
-0.11265667527914047,
-0.5760818719863892,
0.21634440124034882,
0.25377801060676575,
-0.31508776545524597,
-0.28508415818214417,
1.1663612127304077,
-0.39213186502456665,
-0.44560638070106506,
0.0854668989777565,
0.7506427764892578,
0.19319820404052734,
-0.46329933404922485,
-0.7045983672142029,
-0.2022387832403183,
0.11556445062160492,
-0.41752520203590393,
0.6067793965339661,
0.3491855263710022,
0.036649737507104874,
0.33315014839172363,
0.4329347312450409,
0.13898490369319916,
-0.035814136266708374,
0.3031860291957855,
0.82724928855896,
-0.5921682715415955,
-0.11678551137447357,
-0.4580635726451874,
0.4041493237018585,
-0.07889560610055923,
-0.264281302690506,
0.8262786269187927,
0.4458658695220947,
0.7755716443061829,
-0.4548974633216858,
1.522316813468933,
0.10151851177215576,
1.0481988191604614,
0.08388379216194153,
0.3840367794036865,
-0.6172861456871033,
-0.05039948597550392,
-0.08924685418605804,
-0.9063290953636169,
-0.7326606512069702,
0.509596049785614,
-0.23383601009845734,
0.10086783021688461,
0.5312830209732056,
0.25300484895706177,
-0.16397489607334137,
-0.020358318462967873,
0.6158637404441833,
0.06297988444566727,
-0.10391781479120255,
0.6706745624542236,
0.5704161524772644,
-0.3917340636253357,
0.3934653401374817,
-0.3857429623603821,
-0.0338347926735878,
0.004658201243728399,
-0.573897123336792,
-1.0402336120605469,
-0.35458603501319885,
-0.4572928249835968,
-0.1836707442998886,
-0.02844550460577011,
0.8044030070304871,
0.5757095813751221,
-1.1095384359359741,
-0.10906393826007843,
-0.042640987783670425,
-0.25940075516700745,
0.13092611730098724,
-0.3072122037410736,
0.28304746747016907,
-0.5197307467460632,
-0.6366547346115112,
0.3522903621196747,
0.13985079526901245,
0.007044232450425625,
-0.08513767272233963,
0.25438305735588074,
0.2291640043258667,
0.3838832974433899,
0.7866312265396118,
0.5835488438606262,
-0.3912341594696045,
-0.1907651126384735,
-0.05669498071074486,
0.017035938799381256,
0.08207955211400986,
1.1240562200546265,
-0.8966884613037109,
0.1470622718334198,
0.24534878134727478,
0.4634306728839874,
0.18005527555942535,
0.20892933011054993,
0.40882372856140137,
-1.5946695804595947,
-0.02869999036192894,
0.17610937356948853,
0.3410433828830719,
0.37157800793647766,
-0.1969892680644989,
0.4366399645805359,
0.40399909019470215,
-0.38080859184265137,
-0.6222507357597351,
0.30545440316200256,
-1.1364823579788208,
-0.4090102016925812,
1.0684435367584229,
-0.25871098041534424,
-0.12582172453403473,
-0.20926208794116974,
-0.058138955384492874,
0.26076990365982056,
-0.6220327019691467,
0.7115588784217834,
0.17648941278457642,
-0.4821593463420868,
0.2169300764799118,
-0.2577826678752899,
0.6734210848808289,
0.4308203160762787,
-0.9714513421058655,
0.27720707654953003,
0.5130951404571533,
0.46314099431037903,
-0.01737910695374012,
0.8198848962783813,
0.12726999819278717,
0.0506875142455101,
-0.14681203663349152,
0.5452492833137512,
0.04883911460638046,
-0.47468113899230957,
-0.5117921829223633,
0.48878657817840576,
-0.030736815184354782,
-0.5187375545501709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00997v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00997v1
|
The IgboAPI Dataset: Empowering Igbo Language Technologies through Multi-dialectal Enrichment
| 2024-05-02T04:27:35 | 2024-05-02T04:27:35 |
Chris Chinenye Emezue, Ifeoma Okoh, Chinedu Mbonu, Chiamaka Chukwuneke, Daisy Lal, Ignatius Ezeani, Paul Rayson, Ijemma Onwuzulike, Chukwuma Okeke, Gerald Nweya, Bright Ogbonna, Chukwuebuka Oraegbunam, Esther Chidinma Awo-Ndubuisi, Akudo Amarachukwu Osuagwu, Obioha Nmezi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Igbo language is facing a risk of becoming endangered, as indicated by a
2025 UNESCO study. This highlights the need to develop language technologies
for Igbo to foster communication, learning and preservation. To create robust,
impactful, and widely adopted language technologies for Igbo, it is essential
to incorporate the multi-dialectal nature of the language. The primary obstacle
in achieving dialectal-aware language technologies is the lack of comprehensive
dialectal datasets. In response, we present the IgboAPI dataset, a
multi-dialectal Igbo-English dictionary dataset, developed with the aim of
enhancing the representation of Igbo dialects. Furthermore, we illustrate the
practicality of the IgboAPI dataset through two distinct studies: one focusing
on Igbo semantic lexicon and the other on machine translation. In the semantic
lexicon project, we successfully establish an initial Igbo semantic lexicon for
the Igbo semantic tagger, while in the machine translation study, we
demonstrate that by finetuning existing machine translation systems using the
IgboAPI dataset, we significantly improve their ability to handle dialectal
variations in sentences.
|
[
-0.7974495887756348,
-0.4629708528518677,
0.082283616065979,
0.581710159778595,
-0.12741532921791077,
0.029904786497354507,
-0.38406720757484436,
-0.6847286224365234,
0.5752586722373962,
0.5706327557563782,
-0.4477432668209076,
-0.0069262864999473095,
-0.7196139693260193,
0.10247375071048737,
-0.3587888777256012,
0.9903579354286194,
0.44977983832359314,
-0.27960023283958435,
0.05314452946186066,
-0.31904634833335876,
-0.639775812625885,
-0.36922040581703186,
-0.16758212447166443,
-0.10085044801235199,
0.3734188675880432,
0.7428622245788574,
0.8553738594055176,
0.5416340231895447,
0.14537176489830017,
0.26690948009490967,
0.015527075156569481,
0.10133665800094604,
-0.3047637939453125,
-0.076054647564888,
-0.1155167892575264,
-0.2559293210506439,
-0.3298836350440979,
-0.08002384752035141,
0.3750872313976288,
0.8302382230758667,
-0.28483206033706665,
-0.18538632988929749,
0.08770603686571121,
0.603255033493042,
-0.21207304298877716,
0.18255183100700378,
-1.012275218963623,
-0.3124121427536011,
-0.5036046504974365,
0.2635854482650757,
0.1491144448518753,
-0.2985324263572693,
-0.0247420035302639,
-0.5431597828865051,
0.1375410556793213,
0.13601534068584442,
0.8664339780807495,
-0.017169427126646042,
-0.45926547050476074,
-0.3416268825531006,
-0.2433917373418808,
0.38357013463974,
-0.7178738713264465,
0.4319172501564026,
0.550376832485199,
0.36929136514663696,
-0.17615705728530884,
-0.3031660318374634,
-0.6545559167861938,
-0.28445038199424744,
-0.13097505271434784,
-0.012356074526906013,
0.4252614378929138,
-0.018340956419706345,
-0.055209603160619736,
0.28873592615127563,
-0.40811336040496826,
0.3169308304786682,
-0.5349951982498169,
-0.1927885115146637,
0.5191988348960876,
-0.15961620211601257,
0.051975540816783905,
-0.2765614986419678,
-0.4326043128967285,
-0.07912296801805496,
-0.7158045768737793,
-0.20968815684318542,
0.7517914772033691,
0.5861043930053711,
0.06892407685518265,
0.4402708411216736,
-0.3211261034011841,
0.5867119431495667,
-0.4008265733718872,
0.028347956016659737,
0.4356442093849182,
-0.3905770480632782,
0.29975906014442444,
0.28500717878341675,
0.9205368757247925,
0.27000898122787476,
0.2778901159763336,
-0.13825544714927673,
-0.0975305438041687,
-0.32416921854019165,
0.42233601212501526,
-0.7369373440742493,
-0.07509737461805344,
0.34836679697036743,
-0.01103247981518507,
-0.21169373393058777,
0.019190846011042595,
-1.033164381980896,
-0.3774558901786804,
-0.13963216543197632,
0.35536473989486694,
-0.6855071783065796,
-0.33697521686553955,
-0.03522041440010071,
-0.15378493070602417,
-0.01611912064254284,
0.2335902601480484,
-1.3731454610824585,
0.179640993475914,
0.7591325640678406,
0.654193639755249,
0.32666224241256714,
-0.48197102546691895,
0.23839905858039856,
0.20803476870059967,
-0.24358829855918884,
0.6530433893203735,
-0.3291114866733551,
-0.5681290030479431,
-0.08442608267068863,
0.0788157656788826,
0.22734346985816956,
-0.8411968350410461,
0.7127025723457336,
-0.2031516432762146,
-0.05056192725896835,
-0.1252526342868805,
-0.4557934105396271,
-0.3474285900592804,
0.3414381444454193,
-0.8896157145500183,
1.027396559715271,
0.1384139060974121,
0.023371761664748192,
0.32561150193214417,
-0.2688118815422058,
-0.6368219256401062,
0.1563451737165451,
-0.16832338273525238,
-0.4824790358543396,
0.13944286108016968,
0.22856581211090088,
0.6004955768585205,
-0.5104909539222717,
0.5080574750900269,
-0.5098990797996521,
-0.01861104555428028,
0.07384444773197174,
-0.32880470156669617,
0.7495936155319214,
0.27247822284698486,
-0.2125675082206726,
-0.48260241746902466,
-1.0403354167938232,
0.08896471560001373,
0.006914779078215361,
-0.3486820459365845,
-0.272349089384079,
0.09751665592193604,
0.1560937911272049,
0.12919621169567108,
0.27378642559051514,
-0.4749821424484253,
0.21157489717006683,
-0.13203273713588715,
0.4208837151527405,
0.8764299750328064,
-0.4688539206981659,
0.04136544466018677,
-0.2543456256389618,
0.18437010049819946,
0.09716060012578964,
0.07922093570232391,
-0.1608588844537735,
-0.678429365158081,
-0.5971834659576416,
-0.3778529465198517,
0.3804647624492645,
0.6394068002700806,
-0.6115133166313171,
0.9404592514038086,
-0.6077922582626343,
-0.40616750717163086,
-0.7316676378250122,
0.15727652609348297,
-0.07478394359350204,
0.6236256957054138,
0.37403619289398193,
-0.2500133216381073,
-0.3391591012477875,
-1.0985007286071777,
0.0009064548066817224,
-0.07135188579559326,
0.12075739353895187,
0.2641572058200836,
0.18742981553077698,
-0.3172508180141449,
0.7912605404853821,
-0.00873540062457323,
-0.35543498396873474,
-0.18449823558330536,
0.12919339537620544,
0.37541934847831726,
0.7916042804718018,
0.8457176685333252,
-0.7614732384681702,
-0.3368034362792969,
0.37096071243286133,
-0.5399972796440125,
-0.4762086868286133,
-0.016567254438996315,
-0.19555355608463287,
-0.23209339380264282,
0.24944348633289337,
0.02631426602602005,
0.02255828306078911,
0.7474892139434814,
-0.1603160798549652,
0.13034525513648987,
-0.018472686409950256,
0.3894044756889343,
-1.1513789892196655,
-0.03582381457090378,
-0.3047785758972168,
-0.250019907951355,
-0.6864104866981506,
0.03572622686624527,
0.15535055100917816,
-0.2661888599395752,
0.030258648097515106,
0.46468019485473633,
-0.2117140144109726,
0.12044697254896164,
-0.04643266275525093,
0.07436088472604752,
-0.018230341374874115,
0.16217324137687683,
0.07227633893489838,
0.7291761636734009,
0.3686632215976715,
-0.42162835597991943,
0.5005730986595154,
0.31509166955947876,
-0.42918089032173157,
0.7547071576118469,
-0.5186718702316284,
0.004708878230303526,
-0.1450875699520111,
-0.45382681488990784,
-0.8116201162338257,
-0.34240850806236267,
0.2129950225353241,
-0.3662113845348358,
0.4919315576553345,
0.09899923205375671,
-0.2533138394355774,
-0.09376461058855057,
-0.38783878087997437,
0.1952109932899475,
0.06582175195217133,
-0.6685643792152405,
0.2704705595970154,
0.5848588347434998,
-0.5235990285873413,
-0.6701878309249878,
-0.7128305435180664,
0.46621593832969666,
-0.21097387373447418,
-0.51228928565979,
0.06842225790023804,
-0.023825153708457947,
-0.12907083332538605,
0.04263915494084358,
0.11175859719514847,
-0.19474411010742188,
0.24714648723602295,
0.07864031940698624,
-0.0007622289122082293,
0.00025106288376264274,
0.3422709107398987,
0.17904242873191833,
0.10908109694719315,
-0.15740740299224854,
-0.02556128427386284,
0.5664423108100891,
-0.059836793690919876,
-0.06257328391075134,
-0.08878921717405319,
0.6702083349227905,
0.10012584924697876,
0.00380276539362967,
0.8934378027915955,
0.2495102435350418,
-0.2925483286380768,
-0.2300121784210205,
-0.5839598774909973,
0.10229124128818512,
-0.4237267076969147,
0.3884405791759491,
-0.7015313506126404,
-0.4979594349861145,
0.3218420445919037,
-0.4849165678024292,
0.06908242404460907,
0.23232096433639526,
0.12765567004680634,
-0.45540720224380493,
0.3852371573448181,
0.501876950263977,
-0.5195218920707703,
0.7121334671974182,
-0.16499701142311096,
0.2039833664894104,
-0.9522190093994141,
-0.34987786412239075,
-0.7768824100494385,
-0.21796196699142456,
-0.6472218036651611,
-0.10765530169010162,
0.6383377313613892,
0.24273334443569183,
0.30329716205596924,
0.4806516468524933,
-0.12788566946983337,
0.1869121640920639,
0.7408533692359924,
0.4797138571739197,
0.08162839710712433,
0.07716862112283707,
0.26978322863578796,
0.09677795320749283,
-0.5918021202087402,
-0.4874873757362366,
1.2078580856323242,
-0.1477256864309311,
0.6979226469993591,
0.28083348274230957,
0.6148722171783447,
0.3840801417827606,
0.2239041030406952,
-0.8451722860336304,
0.440894216299057,
-0.19761134684085846,
-0.781114935874939,
-0.26132217049598694,
-0.33490514755249023,
-1.0670418739318848,
0.3479677736759186,
-0.32268598675727844,
-0.28765350580215454,
0.33919885754585266,
0.15637917816638947,
0.27839675545692444,
-0.1314166933298111,
-0.6204843521118164,
0.9144339561462402,
-0.3528347909450531,
-0.3152622878551483,
-0.4646422564983368,
-0.8396360874176025,
0.17901985347270966,
-0.1324138194322586,
0.6682451963424683,
-0.34404420852661133,
-0.08782774955034256,
0.24118556082248688,
-0.7992730140686035,
0.4568304419517517,
0.1099606528878212,
-0.10965299606323242,
0.2910744845867157,
-0.11785398423671722,
0.1848766803741455,
-0.01991884969174862,
-0.4918559789657593,
0.5248171091079712,
-0.18473730981349945,
-0.6628751754760742,
-0.13213682174682617,
0.5900138020515442,
-0.5968022346496582,
-0.48076725006103516,
-0.33998116850852966,
-0.5178398489952087,
-0.5669253468513489,
0.122538261115551,
-0.06120480224490166,
0.5231450796127319,
-0.5781587958335876,
0.2771247923374176,
0.4016369581222534,
-0.042233217507600784,
0.3660412132740021,
-0.051640190184116364,
0.05251793935894966,
-0.6992064118385315,
0.9179717898368835,
0.17363311350345612,
0.6308513879776001,
0.1690300554037094,
0.32290118932724,
-0.17805533111095428,
-0.4227243661880493,
-0.9054459929466248,
0.10181517153978348,
-0.7485240697860718,
-0.10172097384929657,
-0.2495926022529602,
0.26477953791618347,
-0.6033017635345459,
-0.2662414014339447,
-0.026995783671736717,
-0.7738292813301086,
-0.023719968274235725,
-0.19771985709667206,
0.421210914850235,
0.5949689149856567,
-0.41262099146842957,
0.5360447764396667,
-0.9572263360023499,
0.44825810194015503,
0.31017905473709106,
0.1746307760477066,
-0.4330891966819763,
-0.2096937596797943,
-0.34228387475013733,
0.05901482328772545,
-0.09189353883266449,
-1.0013917684555054,
0.28817322850227356,
0.6866130828857422,
0.7467701435089111,
0.30246564745903015,
-0.45333048701286316,
0.7399948835372925,
-0.49875208735466003,
0.6868954300880432,
0.005540196783840656,
-0.9872729182243347,
0.6501753926277161,
-0.3679563105106354,
-0.10201223939657211,
0.7163618803024292,
0.6142610907554626,
-0.6853442788124084,
-0.09311916679143906,
-0.4939191937446594,
-0.9054097533226013,
0.7500131726264954,
-0.21182487905025482,
0.18414835631847382,
0.14347867667675018,
0.3515116572380066,
0.5687258839607239,
0.8001249432563782,
-0.7492074966430664,
0.07883041352033615,
-0.6059247255325317,
-0.4873751997947693,
-0.08829342573881149,
-0.1393936574459076,
-0.1785765439271927,
-0.05774717777967453,
1.0159639120101929,
-0.48205888271331787,
0.027802851051092148,
-0.18285244703292847,
-0.17766380310058594,
0.47466734051704407,
0.3186393082141876,
-0.23933880031108856,
0.10210372507572174,
-0.10051247477531433,
0.11449675261974335,
-0.3008347749710083,
-0.5945180058479309,
0.09589501470327377,
0.42329201102256775,
-0.315606027841568,
-0.07766697555780411,
0.2571774423122406,
0.7613747715950012,
-0.2716841399669647,
-0.7226089239120483,
0.20195160806179047,
0.2755792737007141,
0.279938668012619,
0.25496336817741394,
-0.15363606810569763,
0.021153749898076057,
0.03142835199832916,
-0.1268690675497055,
0.03769524395465851,
0.43145203590393066,
-1.1572842597961426,
-0.021719524636864662,
0.5730004906654358,
-0.06495898962020874,
-0.11129385977983475,
0.4989563822746277,
0.4320320188999176,
0.10265976935625076,
0.6962918639183044,
-0.0351722314953804,
-0.48822587728500366,
0.7607235908508301,
0.524334728717804,
0.6592448949813843,
-0.3896962106227875,
-0.08490119129419327,
0.4179806411266327,
0.6887245774269104,
0.16908913850784302,
0.5077126026153564,
-0.3461263179779053,
-0.8968656659126282,
0.40231311321258545,
-0.5315907597541809,
-0.3583822548389435,
-0.044324930757284164,
-0.5673566460609436,
0.3307130038738251,
-0.30363568663597107,
-0.004009703639894724,
-0.26339900493621826,
-0.2459665685892105,
-0.35126984119415283,
0.39338353276252747,
0.053845517337322235,
0.43110063672065735,
-0.7199456095695496,
1.096357822418213,
0.4781250059604645,
-0.09531620889902115,
-0.10306190699338913,
-0.021476691588759422,
-0.1464175134897232,
-1.0083328485488892,
0.23211032152175903,
0.10645145177841187,
-0.018316227942705154,
-0.08815643936395645,
-0.31228792667388916,
-0.7600172162055969,
0.740187406539917,
0.3109465539455414,
-0.6646248698234558,
0.5892379879951477,
0.7008671760559082,
0.2966064214706421,
0.1699543446302414,
-0.07745636999607086,
0.6541358828544617,
0.5629025101661682,
0.0002449190942570567,
-0.9241157174110413,
-0.01325248647481203,
-0.1390276700258255,
0.21952186524868011,
0.4172964096069336,
-0.8252198100090027,
0.6462405323982239,
-0.08897735923528671,
0.072788767516613,
0.2760155498981476,
0.5536971092224121,
-0.303603857755661,
-0.13686490058898926,
0.3952123522758484,
0.7098369002342224,
0.5984276533126831,
-0.5083052515983582,
0.7851029634475708,
-0.30155420303344727,
0.03172888979315758,
1.0924729108810425,
-0.1623324602842331,
0.5966742634773254,
0.4818950295448303,
-0.1754617691040039,
0.14590215682983398,
0.551119863986969,
0.3132377862930298,
0.7998676300048828,
0.04342649132013321,
-0.600233793258667,
-0.07099337875843048,
-0.26960310339927673,
-0.3840143382549286,
0.31844592094421387,
0.9445120096206665,
0.0982026606798172,
0.054377906024456024,
0.07537399977445602,
0.2625674307346344,
0.14294424653053284,
-0.3092595040798187,
0.7514349222183228,
-0.23410910367965698,
-0.4681382477283478,
0.43334633111953735,
-0.34800639748573303,
0.691433846950531,
-0.8841670751571655,
-0.023331129923462868,
-0.18611015379428864,
0.16988487541675568,
-0.22851818799972534,
-0.8607349395751953,
0.3662812411785126,
-0.2625175714492798,
0.28297945857048035,
-0.17228296399116516,
0.4267725646495819,
-0.7468100786209106,
-0.31042584776878357,
0.32992318272590637,
0.2733912467956543,
0.11328303068876266,
0.1052333265542984,
-0.44260963797569275,
0.08106251806020737,
-0.14929062128067017,
-0.027303483337163925,
0.191471129655838,
0.6087386012077332,
-0.05150828883051872,
0.3570004999637604,
0.3661706745624542,
0.22177767753601074,
0.45437511801719666,
0.02497534640133381,
0.7109383940696716,
-0.5542961955070496,
-0.16565003991127014,
-0.5956717133522034,
0.3363528549671173,
-0.2536522150039673,
-0.48431017994880676,
0.7050223350524902,
0.6601617932319641,
1.1034873723983765,
-0.04151204228401184,
1.0467863082885742,
-0.7480722069740295,
0.2827968895435333,
-0.529506504535675,
0.15058107674121857,
-0.740131676197052,
0.09311666339635849,
-0.0534387044608593,
-0.5277830362319946,
-0.12430918961763382,
0.5090851783752441,
0.3739815652370453,
-0.19724078476428986,
0.2769833505153656,
0.8606519103050232,
-0.053071118891239166,
0.20374542474746704,
0.24504901468753815,
0.31547456979751587,
0.3778308033943176,
0.2558650076389313,
0.7858843803405762,
-0.6559526920318604,
0.176870197057724,
-0.7207432389259338,
-0.3601635992527008,
-0.19804954528808594,
-1.151867151260376,
-0.6033754944801331,
-0.7042012810707092,
0.1555802822113037,
-0.22245530784130096,
0.21239610016345978,
0.9701865315437317,
0.46850940585136414,
-0.9308519959449768,
-0.6440454125404358,
0.050677590072155,
-0.04728623107075691,
-0.3916182219982147,
-0.15321733057498932,
-0.24936436116695404,
-0.3789280354976654,
-1.0686105489730835,
0.7140961289405823,
0.19548124074935913,
0.03617056459188461,
-0.06097714230418205,
0.31021204590797424,
-0.3643128573894501,
-0.05316689610481262,
0.8321040868759155,
0.31333228945732117,
-0.2675582766532898,
-0.3871946632862091,
-0.3874911069869995,
0.04855652526021004,
0.31215810775756836,
0.46804165840148926,
-0.8298545479774475,
0.7784672975540161,
0.4560070037841797,
0.7600696086883545,
0.33879679441452026,
-0.2362940013408661,
0.5105132460594177,
-0.823366105556488,
0.5864733457565308,
0.21464625000953674,
0.7215839624404907,
0.4428865909576416,
-0.367123544216156,
0.862087607383728,
0.46630290150642395,
-0.45816439390182495,
-0.37598949670791626,
0.15296758711338043,
-0.8583887815475464,
-0.29612281918525696,
0.775476336479187,
0.08026143908500671,
0.017999060451984406,
-0.08624543249607086,
-0.4221390187740326,
0.006455179303884506,
-0.46372607350349426,
0.9310024976730347,
0.6848095655441284,
-0.05260758846998215,
0.2615380883216858,
-0.5825961232185364,
0.31380710005760193,
0.23927906155586243,
-1.254373550415039,
-0.09366875141859055,
0.6907232403755188,
0.10905082523822784,
0.22604148089885712,
0.41115960478782654,
-0.0436539389193058,
-0.073067806661129,
0.10986927151679993,
0.2479969710111618,
0.23171131312847137,
-0.43455028533935547,
-0.5137764811515808,
-0.05562315881252289,
-0.01381278783082962,
-0.29118481278419495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00988v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00988v1
|
Context-Aware Clustering using Large Language Models
| 2024-05-02T03:50:31 | 2024-05-02T03:50:31 |
Sindhu Tipirneni, Ravinarayana Adkathimar, Nurendra Choudhary, Gaurush Hiranandani, Rana Ali Amjad, Vassilis N. Ioannidis, Changhe Yuan, Chandan K. Reddy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.2.m
|
Despite the remarkable success of Large Language Models (LLMs) in text
understanding and generation, their potential for text clustering tasks remains
underexplored. We observed that powerful closed-source LLMs provide good
quality clusterings of entity sets but are not scalable due to the massive
compute power required and the associated costs. Thus, we propose CACTUS
(Context-Aware ClusTering with aUgmented triplet losS), a systematic approach
that leverages open-source LLMs for efficient and effective supervised
clustering of entity subsets, particularly focusing on text-based entities.
Existing text clustering methods fail to effectively capture the context
provided by the entity subset. Moreover, though there are several language
modeling based approaches for clustering, very few are designed for the task of
supervised clustering. This paper introduces a novel approach towards
clustering entity subsets using LLMs by capturing context via a scalable
inter-entity attention mechanism. We propose a novel augmented triplet loss
function tailored for supervised clustering, which addresses the inherent
challenges of directly applying the triplet loss to this problem. Furthermore,
we introduce a self-supervised clustering task based on text augmentation
techniques to improve the generalization of our model. For evaluation, we
collect ground truth clusterings from a closed-source LLM and transfer this
knowledge to an open-source LLM under the supervised clustering framework,
allowing a faster and cheaper open-source model to perform the same task.
Experiments on various e-commerce query and product clustering datasets
demonstrate that our proposed approach significantly outperforms existing
unsupervised and supervised baselines under various external clustering
evaluation metrics.
|
[
-0.2550925314426422,
-0.9862655997276306,
0.7711837887763977,
0.5093010067939758,
-0.21141700446605682,
-0.095527783036232,
-0.5655909776687622,
-0.494646817445755,
0.41879400610923767,
0.44984400272369385,
-0.5838918685913086,
-0.8382011651992798,
-0.30435556173324585,
0.14733363687992096,
-0.619394838809967,
0.9541823267936707,
-0.03466613590717316,
-0.32680168747901917,
-0.4435980021953583,
-0.13920868933200836,
-0.5046926736831665,
-0.36284634470939636,
-0.5356748104095459,
0.2003553956747055,
0.4772305488586426,
0.41020679473876953,
0.3761645555496216,
0.6256798505783081,
0.3800548017024994,
0.15617389976978302,
-0.07261896878480911,
0.16679567098617554,
-0.3337850570678711,
-0.11714057624340057,
-0.2501632273197174,
-0.5777893662452698,
-0.28720250725746155,
-0.08305049687623978,
0.874080240726471,
0.7680845856666565,
-0.26910704374313354,
0.06187402456998825,
0.17792075872421265,
0.36344432830810547,
-0.6839261054992676,
0.20697833597660065,
-1.0051084756851196,
0.1414324790239334,
-0.121929831802845,
-0.27489572763442993,
-0.472564697265625,
-0.15880554914474487,
0.02443161979317665,
-0.8111890554428101,
0.34234386682510376,
0.16709579527378082,
0.40211689472198486,
0.6230446100234985,
-0.3721410632133484,
-0.15029962360858917,
-0.5584895014762878,
0.8296886086463928,
-0.47384312748908997,
0.24099978804588318,
0.10322713851928711,
-0.12744773924350739,
-0.16328518092632294,
-0.5802655220031738,
-0.7060537934303284,
0.05022215470671654,
-0.26487088203430176,
0.09683775156736374,
-0.009968713857233524,
-0.19774943590164185,
-0.0710844025015831,
0.5186960101127625,
-0.2958154082298279,
0.15572358667850494,
-0.006079640705138445,
-0.043484512716531754,
0.14495202898979187,
-0.08055590838193893,
0.4313390552997589,
0.0385071337223053,
-0.5709404945373535,
0.24720129370689392,
-0.9140654802322388,
-0.19933724403381348,
-0.0766306221485138,
0.4459589719772339,
-0.020171033218503,
0.47294723987579346,
-0.029489275068044662,
0.7450926899909973,
0.09461435675621033,
-0.27123868465423584,
-0.011730160564184189,
-0.3671996295452118,
-0.13448047637939453,
0.3855661451816559,
0.6883618235588074,
0.4347739815711975,
-0.19373804330825806,
-0.259467750787735,
0.1317986398935318,
0.08893134444952011,
0.048619020730257034,
-0.6949635148048401,
-0.10274608433246613,
0.11925575137138367,
-0.3410702049732208,
-0.2696525454521179,
0.10028314590454102,
-0.5145177245140076,
-0.13140925765037537,
-0.08324259519577026,
0.22061964869499207,
-0.21866165101528168,
-0.23674282431602478,
-0.18296438455581665,
0.31135520339012146,
0.04227196052670479,
0.16737020015716553,
-0.9641637802124023,
0.4707010090351105,
0.7781070470809937,
1.0728288888931274,
-0.7128888368606567,
-0.28909048438072205,
-0.4084203243255615,
0.7376960515975952,
-0.36200496554374695,
0.7383019924163818,
-0.4591546356678009,
-0.32530394196510315,
-0.07791928201913834,
0.3435882329940796,
-0.017559144645929337,
-0.46110692620277405,
0.5336248278617859,
-0.532201886177063,
0.02304726094007492,
-0.1586916744709015,
-0.4979482591152191,
-0.2530178427696228,
0.35404062271118164,
-0.6236693263053894,
1.1742911338806152,
-0.07204357534646988,
-0.9582138657569885,
0.6299440264701843,
-0.7497515082359314,
-0.7260980606079102,
0.2291831374168396,
-0.2359461635351181,
-0.43103981018066406,
-0.05978761613368988,
0.5962955951690674,
0.803227961063385,
-0.28723588585853577,
0.3103557229042053,
-0.4380928874015808,
-0.43340951204299927,
-0.10645371675491333,
-0.08352746814489365,
0.5065948963165283,
-0.10478194057941437,
-0.4553402066230774,
0.18515978753566742,
-0.5278259515762329,
-0.1713312566280365,
0.25589606165885925,
-0.2383771687746048,
-0.7271357178688049,
0.17346464097499847,
-0.056539371609687805,
-0.12692564725875854,
0.33519643545150757,
-0.6586089134216309,
0.3277622163295746,
-0.4477173984050751,
0.6160158514976501,
0.5351775288581848,
-0.010309389792382717,
0.5534347891807556,
0.1894705891609192,
0.1366868019104004,
0.05693039298057556,
-0.10953153669834137,
-0.4373098313808441,
-0.37699997425079346,
-0.739510715007782,
-0.29322412610054016,
0.012551155872642994,
0.4099591076374054,
-0.6763730645179749,
0.7917836904525757,
-0.39061957597732544,
-0.40571439266204834,
-0.2861151695251465,
-0.04988739639520645,
0.04465153440833092,
0.7314285635948181,
0.5718072652816772,
0.011624855920672417,
-0.21333734691143036,
-1.115610957145691,
-0.17166785895824432,
0.049284420907497406,
0.03411860018968582,
0.3071622848510742,
0.3322080373764038,
-0.5075633525848389,
1.1656994819641113,
-0.7625938653945923,
-0.7094044089317322,
0.033139243721961975,
-0.18508519232273102,
0.16306687891483307,
0.593935489654541,
0.5021888613700867,
-0.8642658591270447,
-0.3673328161239624,
0.2627559006214142,
-0.5025025606155396,
-0.09794143587350845,
0.15860137343406677,
0.20921237766742706,
0.3613468110561371,
0.5807994604110718,
-0.5649070143699646,
0.4370156526565552,
0.5811932682991028,
-0.01806524768471718,
0.1666850745677948,
-0.30523669719696045,
0.10142208635807037,
-1.2978616952896118,
0.06333097815513611,
0.07571756839752197,
-0.2954980432987213,
-0.3246312141418457,
0.06685753911733627,
0.4105135500431061,
0.017473310232162476,
-0.43952369689941406,
0.3050622344017029,
-0.49313095211982727,
-0.4555594325065613,
-0.32646748423576355,
0.1998707801103592,
0.1034150943160057,
0.5342819690704346,
0.2864864766597748,
0.9546889662742615,
0.5621739625930786,
-0.7429647445678711,
0.23578722774982452,
0.11403518170118332,
-0.21071961522102356,
0.6702253222465515,
-0.5245048403739929,
-0.19652336835861206,
0.03382021188735962,
0.6906557679176331,
-0.6253038644790649,
-0.1992606520652771,
0.20534785091876984,
-0.08326870948076248,
0.1671570986509323,
-0.015271174721419811,
-0.5971063375473022,
-0.4695029854774475,
-0.20150646567344666,
0.6334003806114197,
0.12736712396144867,
-1.06174635887146,
0.4314478635787964,
0.6044353246688843,
-0.20879629254341125,
-0.4975377917289734,
-0.9351933598518372,
0.2838402986526489,
-0.5337971448898315,
-0.6754677891731262,
0.8297087550163269,
-0.22911876440048218,
0.13217121362686157,
0.13194069266319275,
-0.10036949068307877,
-0.04058326035737991,
0.09454616904258728,
0.10486145317554474,
0.00408415449783206,
-0.12048261612653732,
0.5991420149803162,
0.2936093807220459,
-0.21327131986618042,
-0.0396958589553833,
-0.7580742835998535,
0.40032443404197693,
-0.39363688230514526,
-0.4030509889125824,
-0.4144209921360016,
0.42223870754241943,
0.2709195911884308,
-0.35737594962120056,
0.9685705900192261,
0.7407033443450928,
-0.6178042888641357,
-0.27483734488487244,
-0.7489035129547119,
-0.11383318901062012,
-0.40352290868759155,
0.17705431580543518,
-0.31785207986831665,
-1.4165102243423462,
0.38660916686058044,
-0.018115835264325142,
-0.11955302953720093,
0.7269564270973206,
0.6978301405906677,
0.19147531688213348,
0.9826518893241882,
0.8640604019165039,
-0.21912306547164917,
0.23178735375404358,
0.010437947697937489,
0.5009406805038452,
-0.8059205412864685,
-0.16170673072338104,
-0.4596893787384033,
0.09430742263793945,
-0.4676775634288788,
-0.4421859383583069,
0.5303782820701599,
-0.01219765841960907,
0.1340525895357132,
0.2558288276195526,
-0.7470458149909973,
0.7439721822738647,
0.598581850528717,
-0.008614865131676197,
0.6005648374557495,
0.05849815160036087,
0.04486243799328804,
0.13944745063781738,
-0.676292359828949,
-0.3629172146320343,
0.6437738537788391,
0.2283933162689209,
0.5431960225105286,
0.09607493877410889,
0.5474643707275391,
0.15486621856689453,
0.4678182303905487,
-0.8264286518096924,
0.43328800797462463,
0.13168466091156006,
-0.26774218678474426,
-0.3513343334197998,
-0.5077776312828064,
-0.901025652885437,
0.2079765945672989,
-0.05202445387840271,
-0.8320834040641785,
-0.08669297397136688,
0.12578652799129486,
-0.36901944875717163,
0.47725117206573486,
-0.5950018167495728,
0.9098765850067139,
0.0012340765679255128,
-0.4428572356700897,
-0.1860692948102951,
-0.51931232213974,
0.5341910123825073,
-0.378938227891922,
0.33684685826301575,
-0.05558370053768158,
-0.35031193494796753,
0.7156564593315125,
-0.5415060520172119,
0.5916333198547363,
0.08084934949874878,
-0.5054442286491394,
0.40960729122161865,
0.0010799107840284705,
0.43085169792175293,
0.3921818435192108,
0.23393447697162628,
0.23851820826530457,
0.1023605689406395,
-0.3770337402820587,
-0.45137256383895874,
1.469522476196289,
-0.4676840007305145,
-0.600504994392395,
-0.16602957248687744,
-0.44885385036468506,
-0.061090052127838135,
0.39211317896842957,
0.13712692260742188,
0.06882067024707794,
-0.19553136825561523,
0.33290955424308777,
0.5933127999305725,
-0.20573991537094116,
0.665557324886322,
0.4911417067050934,
-0.1645890772342682,
-0.1518370509147644,
0.9177232980728149,
-0.08359074592590332,
-0.08127175271511078,
0.46986791491508484,
0.14612847566604614,
-0.18538175523281097,
-0.4230605661869049,
-0.4944101572036743,
0.14820565283298492,
-0.6259710192680359,
-0.20327918231487274,
-0.8964027762413025,
0.3033768832683563,
-0.5327399969100952,
-0.24230700731277466,
-0.19942134618759155,
-0.19491301476955414,
-0.4483954906463623,
-0.15587295591831207,
0.309787780046463,
0.688563346862793,
0.09914421290159225,
0.4961754381656647,
-0.7838370203971863,
0.13859690725803375,
0.3627796173095703,
0.6429483890533447,
0.05295185744762421,
0.18518954515457153,
-0.3333180248737335,
-0.10832072049379349,
-0.04598303884267807,
-0.790624737739563,
0.3327111005783081,
-0.0316166989505291,
0.3110975921154022,
0.383197158575058,
-0.06943406909704208,
0.6070848703384399,
-0.46777617931365967,
0.8366864919662476,
0.12901116907596588,
-1.009727120399475,
0.6474474668502808,
-0.589849591255188,
0.24887704849243164,
0.3902106285095215,
0.07368381321430206,
-0.5216277241706848,
-0.09058300405740738,
-0.46651047468185425,
-0.927320122718811,
0.9794014096260071,
0.238327294588089,
-0.13569338619709015,
-0.5043947696685791,
0.33046337962150574,
0.04890928044915199,
0.1388256698846817,
-1.1533235311508179,
-0.013266459107398987,
0.11331020295619965,
-0.22019857168197632,
-0.09675639122724533,
-0.10943982750177383,
0.0024561702739447355,
-0.13003799319267273,
0.9245123863220215,
-0.35912024974823,
-0.17503246665000916,
0.3431243896484375,
-0.31036508083343506,
-0.1736922711133957,
0.19881899654865265,
0.3340274691581726,
0.3389096260070801,
-0.11005759984254837,
0.21311664581298828,
0.3194023072719574,
-0.13221390545368195,
-0.0045701912604272366,
0.1722802221775055,
-0.16702938079833984,
-0.3373374938964844,
0.07044348865747452,
0.33523616194725037,
0.34784024953842163,
-0.6903718113899231,
0.7930781245231628,
-0.1805422157049179,
0.2299841046333313,
-0.48784759640693665,
-0.21339932084083557,
0.279391884803772,
-0.08079904317855835,
0.3934065103530884,
-0.13632306456565857,
0.3325996994972229,
-0.3782239556312561,
-0.005723750684410334,
0.4187134802341461,
-0.5415955185890198,
-0.05331698805093765,
0.6178504228591919,
0.2075432538986206,
-0.0016040037153288722,
0.2062855362892151,
0.000053441592172021046,
-0.3731427490711212,
0.6617406010627747,
0.7856979966163635,
0.6684404611587524,
-0.2635060250759125,
-0.08632273226976395,
0.19240091741085052,
0.41463690996170044,
-0.21685773134231567,
-0.3896277844905853,
-0.3801581859588623,
-0.5557955503463745,
-0.6006543636322021,
-0.5654508471488953,
-0.2747526168823242,
-0.12331730127334595,
-0.3626376986503601,
0.13302740454673767,
-0.18369975686073303,
0.13028821349143982,
-0.29240188002586365,
-0.2409127950668335,
-0.3900550305843353,
0.21640552580356598,
-0.12778420746326447,
0.6106390357017517,
-0.638822078704834,
0.5861813426017761,
0.6486011743545532,
-0.2083665430545807,
-0.5097538232803345,
0.038496118038892746,
-0.27002593874931335,
-0.5825040936470032,
0.30412450432777405,
0.6942051649093628,
-0.17788438498973846,
0.11640537530183792,
-0.6013179421424866,
-1.0514382123947144,
1.1572433710098267,
0.03750419244170189,
-0.42355868220329285,
0.0816454291343689,
0.047793179750442505,
0.34703195095062256,
-0.6339066624641418,
0.06760159879922867,
0.6991291642189026,
0.442363977432251,
-0.037652019411325455,
-0.6743806004524231,
0.20828604698181152,
-0.007799914106726646,
0.14349205791950226,
0.47026264667510986,
-0.7302506566047668,
0.8258490562438965,
-0.04504850134253502,
-0.4615127444267273,
0.07347964495420456,
0.8398184180259705,
0.10740677267313004,
0.36804744601249695,
0.6119418144226074,
0.8162571787834167,
0.6762897968292236,
-0.03285733237862587,
0.9663341045379639,
-0.5395299792289734,
0.4618239104747772,
1.0489486455917358,
-0.3528843820095062,
0.6675503849983215,
0.4339987635612488,
-0.030424434691667557,
0.4501070976257324,
0.5853599905967712,
0.2355991154909134,
0.24065889418125153,
0.1140022724866867,
-0.3653622567653656,
-0.1583135426044464,
-0.3351440131664276,
-0.38039904832839966,
0.16068369150161743,
0.7124984264373779,
-0.32782652974128723,
-0.06354419887065887,
0.06571229547262192,
0.0034357192926108837,
0.14982259273529053,
-0.41427427530288696,
0.8476449847221375,
-0.012810811400413513,
-0.7919167876243591,
0.34147655963897705,
0.20351552963256836,
0.7297732830047607,
-0.1417318880558014,
-0.008924676105380058,
0.12426773458719254,
0.1848430037498474,
-0.37399235367774963,
-0.5453786253929138,
0.381203830242157,
-0.15118883550167084,
-0.29705268144607544,
-0.14881174266338348,
0.8402515649795532,
-0.5849754214286804,
-0.6207483410835266,
0.39112764596939087,
0.28065750002861023,
0.09681396186351776,
-0.4096556305885315,
-0.2746109366416931,
-0.062042009085416794,
-0.20357567071914673,
-0.08460232615470886,
0.08584831655025482,
0.2933519780635834,
-0.19964829087257385,
0.5511668920516968,
0.6680620312690735,
-0.2646327316761017,
-0.2043572962284088,
-0.04726105555891991,
0.851108968257904,
-0.6205686330795288,
-0.8534379005432129,
-0.8714587092399597,
0.03633290156722069,
-0.1585487723350525,
0.0688924640417099,
0.6735250949859619,
0.6614142060279846,
0.6637970805168152,
0.09005988389253616,
0.7567785978317261,
0.2532484531402588,
0.786165714263916,
-0.4715416431427002,
0.5482685565948486,
-0.6316341161727905,
0.3753385543823242,
-0.39862123131752014,
-1.3664333820343018,
-0.5387629866600037,
0.2859039008617401,
-0.25663772225379944,
-0.11078961193561554,
0.7552765607833862,
0.7372238039970398,
-0.26203688979148865,
0.1512526422739029,
0.14467523992061615,
0.31494221091270447,
0.35631152987480164,
0.4502301812171936,
0.5928224921226501,
-0.01923293061554432,
0.533157229423523,
-0.12093498557806015,
-0.4903036952018738,
-0.25731024146080017,
-1.018896222114563,
-0.7477858066558838,
-0.5992163419723511,
-0.16032195091247559,
0.1025180071592331,
-0.2933086156845093,
0.7457231879234314,
0.7364921569824219,
-0.5791937112808228,
0.15143856406211853,
-0.3400287926197052,
0.1905902624130249,
0.052964840084314346,
-0.32569950819015503,
0.6646226048469543,
-0.28484347462654114,
-0.6413044333457947,
0.6291889548301697,
0.649518609046936,
-0.019342562183737755,
-0.3725571930408478,
0.28250885009765625,
-0.09551061689853668,
-0.20194010436534882,
0.7811117768287659,
0.06741988658905029,
-1.0314468145370483,
-0.32558339834213257,
-0.1572592556476593,
0.1550675630569458,
0.13658200204372406,
0.6691502928733826,
-1.011124849319458,
0.1467387080192566,
0.04873502999544144,
0.7887049317359924,
0.5066958069801331,
0.007094352971762419,
0.3099145293235779,
-0.8151057362556458,
0.13281148672103882,
0.05788857489824295,
0.6088523864746094,
0.6033307313919067,
-0.46762850880622864,
0.5405453443527222,
0.227992445230484,
-0.47477105259895325,
-0.5016739964485168,
0.1219673827290535,
-1.1482105255126953,
-0.396901398897171,
1.029728651046753,
-0.06387151777744293,
-0.4083606004714966,
0.11333275586366653,
-0.28643909096717834,
0.13143673539161682,
-0.43651720881462097,
0.6406434178352356,
0.36921176314353943,
0.23679159581661224,
0.03506149724125862,
0.004713608417659998,
0.23674020171165466,
0.48511549830436707,
-1.054610013961792,
0.0804821252822876,
0.5560622811317444,
0.1067660003900528,
0.3709963262081146,
0.46993008255958557,
0.08725595474243164,
-0.0026384310331195593,
-0.49446555972099304,
0.2908864915370941,
0.1954355686903,
-0.3385975956916809,
-0.158582404255867,
0.47205352783203125,
-0.20912602543830872,
0.1740548312664032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00982v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00982v2
|
On the Evaluation of Machine-Generated Reports
| 2024-05-02T03:35:23 | 2024-05-10T03:12:20 |
James Mayfield, Eugene Yang, Dawn Lawrie, Sean MacAvaney, Paul McNamee, Douglas W. Oard, Luca Soldaini, Ian Soboroff, Orion Weller, Efsun Kayi, Kate Sanders, Marc Mason, Noah Hibbler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have enabled new ways to satisfy information
needs. Although great strides have been made in applying them to settings like
document ranking and short-form text generation, they still struggle to compose
complete, accurate, and verifiable long-form reports. Reports with these
qualities are necessary to satisfy the complex, nuanced, or multi-faceted
information needs of users. In this perspective paper, we draw together
opinions from industry and academia, and from a variety of related research
areas, to present our vision for automatic report generation, and -- critically
-- a flexible framework by which such reports can be evaluated. In contrast
with other summarization tasks, automatic report generation starts with a
detailed description of an information need, stating the necessary background,
requirements, and scope of the report. Further, the generated reports should be
complete, accurate, and verifiable. These qualities, which are desirable -- if
not required -- in many analytic report-writing settings, require rethinking
how to build and evaluate systems that exhibit these qualities. To foster new
efforts in building these systems, we present an evaluation framework that
draws on ideas found in various evaluations. To test completeness and accuracy,
the framework uses nuggets of information, expressed as questions and answers,
that need to be part of any high-quality generated report. Additionally,
evaluation of citations that map claims made in the report to their source
documents ensures verifiability.
|
[
-0.3101370632648468,
-0.50151526927948,
0.8621326684951782,
0.2829110324382782,
0.03314925730228424,
0.08694230020046234,
-0.20398373901844025,
-0.6241875290870667,
0.20708107948303223,
0.538956880569458,
-0.33802974224090576,
-0.48036256432533264,
-0.5818765163421631,
0.5026426315307617,
-0.6709446310997009,
1.220373511314392,
-0.25081518292427063,
-0.16746258735656738,
-0.2507622539997101,
-0.06036325916647911,
-0.3925507068634033,
-0.4366145133972168,
-0.23476462066173553,
-0.41485708951950073,
0.5908116102218628,
0.396183043718338,
0.7693048715591431,
0.7238565683364868,
0.7209793329238892,
0.31192055344581604,
0.4652133584022522,
0.39988845586776733,
-0.447955459356308,
0.48115310072898865,
0.047900620847940445,
-0.265220582485199,
-0.702333927154541,
0.22806552052497864,
0.675647497177124,
0.7416998744010925,
0.045568522065877914,
0.5187479257583618,
0.22014933824539185,
0.745000958442688,
-0.62496417760849,
0.14045000076293945,
-0.4837527871131897,
0.12726549804210663,
0.09113352000713348,
-0.23671920597553253,
-0.5690280199050903,
-0.5742642283439636,
0.12394868582487106,
-0.3890507221221924,
0.06084761023521423,
0.176858052611351,
0.9400675892829895,
0.0013488648692145944,
-0.5837792158126831,
-0.7749896049499512,
-0.8299548029899597,
0.6725941896438599,
-0.5800157189369202,
0.050682276487350464,
0.3558422327041626,
0.588931143283844,
-0.13104337453842163,
-0.8345241546630859,
-0.23471809923648834,
-0.5100948214530945,
-0.10613658279180527,
0.186552032828331,
-0.14744246006011963,
-0.3111862242221832,
0.2382403314113617,
0.40199995040893555,
-0.5480237007141113,
0.1987106204032898,
-0.3412665128707886,
-0.06224503368139267,
0.934208333492279,
0.6254474520683289,
0.16793742775917053,
-0.19568726420402527,
-0.0532132163643837,
0.24830734729766846,
-0.6893242001533508,
-0.17964385449886322,
0.40541812777519226,
0.2885996997356415,
0.1481323540210724,
0.8006107807159424,
-0.40267205238342285,
0.6640727519989014,
-0.035914741456508636,
-0.23749910295009613,
0.24019286036491394,
-0.39586111903190613,
-0.4363253116607666,
0.08684170246124268,
0.7787449359893799,
0.5086217522621155,
0.1462460458278656,
-0.33736133575439453,
-0.6970186829566956,
0.11907252669334412,
0.48324957489967346,
-0.9248904585838318,
0.14849171042442322,
0.37452903389930725,
-0.502166211605072,
-0.5803796052932739,
0.24169258773326874,
-0.4703413248062134,
-0.5373766422271729,
-0.7155174016952515,
0.4015641212463379,
-0.24991022050380707,
-0.14535538852214813,
-0.0841851532459259,
0.03895328566431999,
0.11664976179599762,
0.5131726861000061,
-0.6470873355865479,
0.2707144320011139,
0.5354331731796265,
0.5332756638526917,
-0.1824648380279541,
-0.28024977445602417,
-0.8979135155677795,
0.3285006284713745,
-0.5257135629653931,
1.0203394889831543,
-0.5000275373458862,
-0.296088844537735,
0.12870116531848907,
-0.1153053566813469,
0.27675217390060425,
-0.6841928958892822,
0.2602355182170868,
-0.34064558148384094,
0.28924205899238586,
-0.21487505733966827,
-0.6124427318572998,
0.07890942692756653,
0.47879841923713684,
-0.6288139820098877,
0.7997872233390808,
0.2141895890235901,
-0.6905707120895386,
0.7095633149147034,
-0.6297618746757507,
-0.5258911848068237,
0.26801472902297974,
-0.2002650797367096,
-0.33981990814208984,
0.12910902500152588,
-0.05973931401968002,
0.47487789392471313,
-0.7115490436553955,
0.467298299074173,
-0.08783184736967087,
-0.2633076608181,
0.30208083987236023,
-0.29249855875968933,
0.38478314876556396,
0.3033461272716522,
-0.6004598140716553,
0.36479273438453674,
-0.9344801306724548,
0.27202141284942627,
0.09249585121870041,
-0.6868726015090942,
0.1535853147506714,
-0.019865505397319794,
0.015769964084029198,
-0.2918265461921692,
0.3100931942462921,
-0.23155930638313293,
-0.06759800761938095,
-0.3876844346523285,
0.1922372430562973,
0.6467700600624084,
-0.07684386521577835,
0.29674121737480164,
-0.5056003928184509,
0.6398121118545532,
-0.22815722227096558,
0.08764872699975967,
-0.6820966601371765,
-0.03806561231613159,
-0.8770189881324768,
-0.31332147121429443,
0.35520032048225403,
0.603458046913147,
-0.22411586344242096,
0.5280853509902954,
-0.29076647758483887,
-0.7965496182441711,
-0.37548723816871643,
0.23171766102313995,
0.2504747211933136,
0.36132583022117615,
-0.07170675694942474,
-0.29856783151626587,
-0.6524423956871033,
-0.921556293964386,
-0.1804007887840271,
-0.006807174067944288,
-0.3216302990913391,
0.14691859483718872,
0.4909619390964508,
-0.3265933394432068,
1.0040677785873413,
-0.3986367881298065,
0.0417594350874424,
-0.28786614537239075,
0.34909218549728394,
0.16056494414806366,
0.08229651302099228,
0.42740142345428467,
-0.5734861493110657,
-0.39594027400016785,
-0.11480115354061127,
-1.1582804918289185,
-0.17821760475635529,
-0.07153855264186859,
0.05727667361497879,
0.29053181409835815,
0.1960180699825287,
-0.4373568892478943,
0.4033166766166687,
0.25656265020370483,
-0.18242166936397552,
0.7227997183799744,
-0.256648451089859,
0.3373871445655823,
-0.8542941808700562,
0.501502275466919,
-0.12616711854934692,
-0.5018666386604309,
-0.25238439440727234,
-0.1345919370651245,
-0.16174004971981049,
-0.3921758532524109,
-0.10795272141695023,
0.4600609838962555,
-0.6199894547462463,
-0.38498687744140625,
-0.2555636167526245,
0.4888092279434204,
0.29838407039642334,
-0.05791585147380829,
-0.4754687249660492,
0.5578482151031494,
0.26290804147720337,
-0.6773849725723267,
0.6010080575942993,
-0.14477257430553436,
-0.7370027899742126,
0.7902512550354004,
-0.5839633941650391,
0.13698247075080872,
-0.22787083685398102,
0.21356026828289032,
-0.8966187834739685,
-0.4642668068408966,
0.020713208243250847,
-0.3664664328098297,
0.28041762113571167,
0.24142201244831085,
-0.7983124852180481,
-0.28134799003601074,
-0.30810970067977905,
-0.11039022356271744,
0.29594355821609497,
-0.1670607477426529,
0.5624569058418274,
0.5669004917144775,
-0.30365875363349915,
-0.46213483810424805,
-0.5543150305747986,
0.5266493558883667,
-0.06265132129192352,
-0.7381300330162048,
0.07769636064767838,
-0.15127839148044586,
-0.5495731830596924,
0.13439297676086426,
0.0468403622508049,
0.0222909078001976,
0.25191327929496765,
0.40050047636032104,
0.3209764063358307,
-0.4422125518321991,
0.0035616217646747828,
-0.052877843379974365,
-0.1320548802614212,
0.07687958329916,
-0.05054376646876335,
0.2474956512451172,
-0.4012308418750763,
-0.5334729552268982,
-0.15781854093074799,
0.6822152733802795,
0.7899638414382935,
-0.2760533392429352,
0.2887653410434723,
0.39879581332206726,
-0.3043794333934784,
-0.25158289074897766,
-0.556290864944458,
0.04045066609978676,
-0.37628045678138733,
0.2548559606075287,
-0.2948389947414398,
-0.7689385414123535,
0.4012158215045929,
-0.027940385043621063,
0.4955857992172241,
0.8043060302734375,
0.778628408908844,
-0.013605262152850628,
1.1026941537857056,
0.6234584450721741,
0.29546958208084106,
0.04462437704205513,
0.06397398561239243,
0.26917123794555664,
-0.48691844940185547,
-0.09970586001873016,
-0.6300174593925476,
-0.02078293077647686,
-0.25140872597694397,
0.15539446473121643,
0.37496617436408997,
-0.1424543559551239,
-0.32239437103271484,
-0.002775557106360793,
-0.6029353141784668,
0.4178955554962158,
0.10248760133981705,
-0.3555205464363098,
0.4490008056163788,
-0.0943935215473175,
0.027087857946753502,
0.09263128787279129,
-0.4133266806602478,
-1.2194864749908447,
1.0568124055862427,
0.3380933701992035,
0.5549615621566772,
-0.1024235263466835,
0.6745003461837769,
0.731723964214325,
0.818431556224823,
-0.8638270497322083,
0.47055017948150635,
0.00136686977930367,
-0.4416297376155853,
-0.4120926856994629,
-0.2663663625717163,
-0.9224168658256531,
0.24898843467235565,
-0.1785249561071396,
-0.5096535682678223,
-0.430370569229126,
0.08361860364675522,
-0.4360724985599518,
-0.22646085917949677,
-0.6574129462242126,
0.7090563178062439,
-0.515047550201416,
-0.2202865183353424,
-0.23128698766231537,
-0.4573409855365753,
0.3956489562988281,
-0.2884220778942108,
0.31251251697540283,
-0.23807314038276672,
0.07084424793720245,
0.7807223796844482,
-0.3789026737213135,
0.9310402870178223,
-0.13495470583438873,
-0.25354117155075073,
0.5010417699813843,
0.33048880100250244,
0.35758525133132935,
-0.04809436574578285,
-0.40222927927970886,
-0.26513004302978516,
0.13506415486335754,
0.015015448443591595,
-0.5840569138526917,
0.4051991105079651,
-0.4119788706302643,
-0.5654182434082031,
-0.3483369052410126,
-0.4648430049419403,
-0.09562121331691742,
0.5219752788543701,
0.09918927401304245,
0.5856572389602661,
-0.4366007149219513,
0.06798192113637924,
0.3927808701992035,
-0.2022078037261963,
0.03245530277490616,
0.59837406873703,
-0.5696207284927368,
-0.5379999876022339,
0.8728317618370056,
0.3662641942501068,
0.09266290813684464,
0.12909354269504547,
0.06329679489135742,
-0.012426597066223621,
-0.4350756108760834,
-0.7261427044868469,
0.16964909434318542,
-0.8679973483085632,
-0.44754186272621155,
-0.37883028388023376,
-0.43082818388938904,
-0.19646848738193512,
-0.26488175988197327,
-0.28192761540412903,
-0.30665725469589233,
-0.2791220247745514,
-0.125273197889328,
-0.05064581707119942,
1.1024435758590698,
0.10710573196411133,
0.0026850439608097076,
-0.9338377118110657,
0.3107408583164215,
0.15944749116897583,
0.1702386736869812,
0.07535342127084732,
-0.3888370096683502,
-0.44694122672080994,
-0.1100977286696434,
-0.422608345746994,
-0.473839670419693,
0.3822546899318695,
-0.12461032718420029,
0.6928096413612366,
0.12388255447149277,
0.07497373223304749,
0.31474119424819946,
-0.5833858251571655,
0.6964492797851562,
0.33282366394996643,
-0.9406156539916992,
0.6764969825744629,
-0.28453177213668823,
0.17753899097442627,
0.6564191579818726,
0.14282678067684174,
-0.1700185388326645,
-0.6855059266090393,
-0.442536860704422,
-1.0779300928115845,
0.47622936964035034,
0.11504705995321274,
0.10049320757389069,
0.08986013382673264,
0.17352181673049927,
0.38219183683395386,
0.41240450739860535,
-0.4360106587409973,
0.08884761482477188,
-0.10503825545310974,
-0.3477976620197296,
0.11273331940174103,
-0.4311670660972595,
-0.3083900809288025,
0.23478834331035614,
0.33810195326805115,
-0.11607952415943146,
0.04976259544491768,
0.22862650454044342,
-0.12572118639945984,
-0.20119993388652802,
0.3565974235534668,
0.5299480557441711,
1.3293802738189697,
-0.1924310177564621,
0.1702912151813507,
-0.024490272626280785,
-0.044971566647291183,
0.21163655817508698,
-0.14355258643627167,
-0.21897363662719727,
0.19582810997962952,
0.4222702085971832,
0.679679811000824,
0.1010466068983078,
-0.7977843284606934,
0.5295374989509583,
-0.004695484414696693,
-0.2487853765487671,
-0.49841856956481934,
0.13104404509067535,
0.06295032799243927,
0.041367147117853165,
0.48806580901145935,
-0.1488906443119049,
0.2353532761335373,
-0.6092118620872498,
0.2475738227367401,
0.20102748274803162,
-0.2541457414627075,
-0.14504918456077576,
0.3068002164363861,
0.4140346348285675,
-0.4064643979072571,
0.6153470873832703,
-0.16936643421649933,
-0.3187222480773926,
0.6492229700088501,
0.5031603574752808,
0.952653706073761,
-0.029976483434438705,
0.22008109092712402,
0.26216089725494385,
0.4112093150615692,
-0.06197977066040039,
0.05012243241071701,
-0.10355079174041748,
-0.35794970393180847,
-0.41321447491645813,
-0.8363582491874695,
-0.5684124231338501,
0.0965258851647377,
-0.5202828049659729,
0.44666680693626404,
-0.5650230050086975,
-0.3743480145931244,
0.17888101935386658,
-0.14650066196918488,
-0.5629920959472656,
0.3702797591686249,
0.04917270317673683,
0.7332208752632141,
-0.5291829705238342,
0.30337488651275635,
0.5087975859642029,
-0.490021288394928,
-0.6532692909240723,
-0.16875343024730682,
-0.13800974190235138,
-0.6505879163742065,
0.9326058030128479,
0.48498407006263733,
-0.5440465807914734,
-0.4680260121822357,
-0.48736125230789185,
-0.763095498085022,
1.0875738859176636,
0.5960779786109924,
-0.5165420770645142,
-0.04093765839934349,
0.14750880002975464,
0.568139910697937,
-0.8026127815246582,
0.27800506353378296,
0.4048003554344177,
0.7456133961677551,
-0.08854763954877853,
-1.101911187171936,
0.1626938134431839,
-0.35703128576278687,
-0.10356256365776062,
-0.03490930795669556,
-0.4670328199863434,
0.401518851518631,
-0.34838083386421204,
-0.38580626249313354,
-0.02820509858429432,
0.5665290951728821,
0.17853374779224396,
0.5290058851242065,
0.44588685035705566,
0.12772820889949799,
0.9599480628967285,
0.25125035643577576,
1.1328409910202026,
-0.3438861072063446,
-0.008071163669228554,
1.265795111656189,
-0.6013894081115723,
0.7079706788063049,
0.19540685415267944,
-0.022773059085011482,
0.4906039834022522,
0.43890106678009033,
-0.42652270197868347,
0.10499200224876404,
0.478490948677063,
0.09595278650522232,
-0.25798702239990234,
-0.20888762176036835,
-0.28393131494522095,
0.4966996908187866,
0.07926802337169647,
-0.6481798887252808,
-0.20476968586444855,
-0.2809309959411621,
-0.02862299233675003,
0.1417737901210785,
0.009023716673254967,
0.6819449663162231,
0.05458647757768631,
-0.8444997668266296,
0.5988208651542664,
0.11783759295940399,
0.1563502997159958,
-0.6414152383804321,
0.015242918394505978,
-0.035797856748104095,
-0.06610680371522903,
-0.5062823295593262,
-0.9422225952148438,
0.630455493927002,
0.5730890035629272,
-0.5248870253562927,
-0.22040975093841553,
0.5737746953964233,
0.10653680562973022,
-0.6875495314598083,
0.12056134641170502,
0.5379009246826172,
0.2709449231624603,
0.121707484126091,
-0.34669187664985657,
0.18467740714550018,
-0.04128531366586685,
-0.5781208276748657,
0.38967791199684143,
0.6012154221534729,
0.19470037519931793,
0.6303689479827881,
0.4843968451023102,
0.04780856519937515,
-0.294577956199646,
0.263627827167511,
0.7261947393417358,
-0.6234011054039001,
-0.37798386812210083,
-0.8289158940315247,
0.7782818675041199,
-0.11412753909826279,
-0.15362726151943207,
0.6470388174057007,
0.9613254070281982,
0.36523357033729553,
0.24283303320407867,
1.201752781867981,
-0.0930372104048729,
0.610637903213501,
-0.44601696729660034,
0.8541247248649597,
-0.6126977205276489,
0.30452948808670044,
-0.17136237025260925,
-1.0691003799438477,
-0.3447495102882385,
0.3466530442237854,
-0.17833378911018372,
-0.06865747272968292,
0.5582699775695801,
0.5271449685096741,
0.10358772426843643,
-0.15228670835494995,
0.3286118507385254,
0.11742960661649704,
0.45035266876220703,
0.203032448887825,
1.0312484502792358,
-0.3271408677101135,
0.7750321626663208,
0.27557572722435,
-0.383812814950943,
-0.19284459948539734,
-1.0877177715301514,
-0.5838713645935059,
-0.5745077133178711,
-0.24318785965442657,
-0.4214312732219696,
-0.1412716805934906,
0.5675666332244873,
0.4963549077510834,
-0.5996204614639282,
-0.5488658547401428,
0.23277930915355682,
0.032380495220422745,
0.3039783239364624,
-0.2616482079029083,
0.2509536147117615,
-0.5999711155891418,
-0.44946739077568054,
0.24732641875743866,
0.7983887791633606,
-0.10716468095779419,
-0.5211322903633118,
-0.08606741577386856,
0.37241458892822266,
0.14538255333900452,
0.8311352729797363,
0.022738458588719368,
-0.5292660593986511,
-0.21302297711372375,
-0.15586629509925842,
-0.512209415435791,
0.13269087672233582,
0.7635458111763,
-0.625773549079895,
0.27688583731651306,
0.33660146594047546,
0.6512108445167542,
0.44708746671676636,
-0.22133293747901917,
0.8385061621665955,
0.031134961172938347,
-0.4417017698287964,
0.37014517188072205,
0.20443610846996307,
0.560756504535675,
-0.3029954433441162,
0.5307338237762451,
-0.13168983161449432,
-0.6812894344329834,
-1.2287150621414185,
0.21235933899879456,
-0.740342915058136,
-0.07506439089775085,
0.9940115809440613,
-0.22225534915924072,
-0.21860094368457794,
0.043083373457193375,
-0.24567747116088867,
0.16717657446861267,
-0.2594341039657593,
0.8283662796020508,
0.6561534404754639,
-0.301162451505661,
0.33332377672195435,
-0.440332293510437,
0.22891353070735931,
0.16815389692783356,
-1.046509027481079,
0.4230039417743683,
0.8357800245285034,
0.3517819046974182,
0.304370641708374,
0.7050535678863525,
-0.15572236478328705,
0.09545894712209702,
0.010777916759252548,
-0.16096489131450653,
-0.05563170462846756,
-0.40850457549095154,
0.046933505684137344,
0.45981565117836,
0.43464529514312744,
0.22443009912967682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00981v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00981v1
|
Bayesian Optimization with LLM-Based Acquisition Functions for Natural Language Preference Elicitation
| 2024-05-02T03:35:21 | 2024-05-02T03:35:21 |
David Eric Austin, Anton Korikov, Armin Toroghi, Scott Sanner
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Designing preference elicitation (PE) methodologies that can quickly
ascertain a user's top item preferences in a cold-start setting is a key
challenge for building effective and personalized conversational recommendation
(ConvRec) systems. While large language models (LLMs) constitute a novel
technology that enables fully natural language (NL) PE dialogues, we
hypothesize that monolithic LLM NL-PE approaches lack the multi-turn,
decision-theoretic reasoning required to effectively balance the NL exploration
and exploitation of user preferences towards an arbitrary item set. In
contrast, traditional Bayesian optimization PE methods define theoretically
optimal PE strategies, but fail to use NL item descriptions or generate NL
queries, unrealistically assuming users can express preferences with direct
item ratings and comparisons. To overcome the limitations of both approaches,
we formulate NL-PE in a Bayesian Optimization (BO) framework that seeks to
generate NL queries which actively elicit natural language feedback to reduce
uncertainty over item utilities to identify the best recommendation. We
demonstrate our framework in a novel NL-PE algorithm, PEBOL, which uses Natural
Language Inference (NLI) between user preference utterances and NL item
descriptions to maintain preference beliefs and BO strategies such as Thompson
Sampling (TS) and Upper Confidence Bound (UCB) to guide LLM query generation.
We numerically evaluate our methods in controlled experiments, finding that
PEBOL achieves up to 131% improvement in MAP@10 after 10 turns of cold start
NL-PE dialogue compared to monolithic GPT-3.5, despite relying on a much
smaller 400M parameter NLI model for preference inference.
|
[
-0.5214353203773499,
-1.0717469453811646,
0.5952112078666687,
0.13108648359775543,
-0.30079221725463867,
0.10782022774219513,
-0.3714897930622101,
-0.23131726682186127,
0.00344946701079607,
0.5878069996833801,
-0.6731633543968201,
-0.6707615852355957,
-0.32221299409866333,
-0.018992330878973007,
0.1087924912571907,
1.0806772708892822,
0.32147619128227234,
-0.3118478059768677,
-0.027086861431598663,
0.08279206603765488,
-0.13272050023078918,
-0.4836787283420563,
-0.9799699783325195,
-0.3776018023490906,
0.25000816583633423,
0.4115508794784546,
0.677510142326355,
0.08504239469766617,
0.2686111032962799,
0.1905490905046463,
-0.07339593023061752,
0.3565659821033478,
-0.39236772060394287,
0.19894210994243622,
-0.00985894724726677,
-0.2265026718378067,
-0.47328850626945496,
-0.22106334567070007,
0.3504040241241455,
0.9238090515136719,
-0.5013672709465027,
-0.14080044627189636,
0.12002163380384445,
0.7920888066291809,
-0.7321628332138062,
0.1981571465730667,
-0.7531591057777405,
-0.06394360959529877,
0.056490764021873474,
-0.1921195536851883,
-0.5853672623634338,
-0.5931205749511719,
0.9650477766990662,
-0.6408111453056335,
0.1049090251326561,
0.2326894849538803,
0.6227299571037292,
-0.09112586826086044,
-0.4181209206581116,
-0.24139341711997986,
-0.7384487390518188,
1.0780045986175537,
-0.8402529954910278,
0.21218374371528625,
0.6488834619522095,
0.006691396702080965,
-0.33599692583084106,
-0.04464266449213028,
-0.4209509491920471,
-0.4132649004459381,
0.12531737983226776,
0.1625785380601883,
-0.25471335649490356,
0.3331599235534668,
0.0655704140663147,
0.04695078730583191,
-0.6738703846931458,
0.12690460681915283,
-0.043463919311761856,
-0.05125585198402405,
0.6287875175476074,
-0.07350784540176392,
-0.10682810842990875,
-0.13791559636592865,
-0.4289371371269226,
-0.07635317742824554,
-0.6535683870315552,
0.2578617036342621,
0.36778801679611206,
0.34640511870384216,
-0.07170816510915756,
0.4387555420398712,
-0.3144102692604065,
0.8946402072906494,
0.28443989157676697,
-0.1129307970404625,
0.15513300895690918,
-0.36563146114349365,
-0.32995954155921936,
0.13823378086090088,
0.8264766335487366,
0.605290412902832,
0.5199928879737854,
-0.20999477803707123,
-0.0012684448156505823,
-0.05905779451131821,
0.10622256249189377,
-0.7394721508026123,
-0.30803319811820984,
0.38577717542648315,
-0.3033868968486786,
-0.19703027606010437,
-0.04493322968482971,
-0.8354434370994568,
-0.2495960146188736,
-0.3069528341293335,
0.4665868282318115,
-0.38122424483299255,
-0.12284209579229355,
0.40429264307022095,
0.1429106742143631,
0.2093995064496994,
0.13962864875793457,
-1.1549615859985352,
0.4053914248943329,
0.4537379741668701,
0.4710797965526581,
-0.25568461418151855,
0.0525355190038681,
-0.550214946269989,
0.16811929643154144,
-0.24998414516448975,
0.9591715931892395,
-0.6600657105445862,
-0.8684674501419067,
0.15348803997039795,
-0.17742325365543365,
0.0007804261986166239,
-0.4733782410621643,
0.5765364766120911,
-0.49649578332901,
0.4274173974990845,
-0.13963542878627777,
-0.3577364385128021,
-0.1743006557226181,
0.21150155365467072,
-0.294174462556839,
0.9900799989700317,
-0.02358873002231121,
-0.4760870337486267,
0.6319187879562378,
-0.648222029209137,
-0.5413922667503357,
-0.07358323037624359,
0.10660193860530853,
-0.4320397973060608,
0.13369226455688477,
0.5436367392539978,
0.5475241541862488,
-0.43810245394706726,
0.4008394777774811,
-0.47129425406455994,
-0.2113037109375,
0.2749311029911041,
-0.425209641456604,
0.656721830368042,
0.05745813995599747,
-0.39137575030326843,
0.0992770865559578,
-0.6295542120933533,
0.0334516204893589,
0.0467824786901474,
-0.35317179560661316,
-0.45074462890625,
0.35018089413642883,
-0.23699073493480682,
-0.33278152346611023,
0.37277156114578247,
-0.6290234327316284,
0.29048168659210205,
-0.8686747550964355,
0.1530800759792328,
0.7666913866996765,
0.2763097286224365,
0.7711132764816284,
-0.2835647165775299,
0.435942143201828,
-0.30623459815979004,
0.20169448852539062,
-0.0337764173746109,
-0.6027785539627075,
-0.4754627048969269,
-0.050487395375967026,
-0.005255542695522308,
0.5594244599342346,
-0.5947534441947937,
0.5695939660072327,
-0.03266606479883194,
-0.42713242769241333,
-0.4366954267024994,
0.0956813171505928,
0.2621423900127411,
0.49984946846961975,
0.3836846649646759,
-0.11472905427217484,
-0.17766401171684265,
-1.077188491821289,
-0.0753452479839325,
-0.5529596209526062,
0.057110100984573364,
0.5416283011436462,
-0.20159907639026642,
-0.0938037857413292,
0.9557982087135315,
-0.4559180438518524,
0.10864675790071487,
-0.5103936195373535,
0.13544961810112,
0.6899905204772949,
0.22898726165294647,
0.6038625836372375,
-0.7562705278396606,
-0.6246127486228943,
0.08146779984235764,
-0.13650943338871002,
-0.41639912128448486,
-0.18203558027744293,
-0.3300558924674988,
0.33138537406921387,
-0.16604149341583252,
-0.537811815738678,
0.40538084506988525,
0.5696005821228027,
-0.15453743934631348,
0.4343835115432739,
-0.3272264003753662,
0.23082642257213593,
-0.9354963302612305,
-0.08393819630146027,
0.30892935395240784,
0.15128973126411438,
-0.6012298464775085,
-0.28921201825141907,
-0.17622794210910797,
0.11046091467142105,
-0.24073100090026855,
0.6051318049430847,
-0.29365435242652893,
0.2606196999549866,
-0.31646159291267395,
0.20971719920635223,
0.04114469140768051,
0.6982317566871643,
0.2726956307888031,
0.5665202736854553,
0.4840644896030426,
-0.7809321284294128,
0.03228788450360298,
0.15865515172481537,
-0.22289453446865082,
0.6608481407165527,
-0.6758673787117004,
0.19575801491737366,
-0.03258613124489784,
-0.004780004266649485,
-1.097580075263977,
0.12842679023742676,
0.2718985676765442,
-0.285832941532135,
0.26221609115600586,
-0.4272524416446686,
-0.4008149802684784,
-0.10472991317510605,
-0.34672752022743225,
0.2019006609916687,
0.5213847756385803,
-0.4807946979999542,
0.39249399304389954,
0.4113720953464508,
-0.38556718826293945,
-0.6171091198921204,
-0.18762607872486115,
-0.16898703575134277,
-0.17834535241127014,
-0.3829954266548157,
0.5085846185684204,
-0.43433594703674316,
-0.2611069679260254,
-0.27097341418266296,
-0.19067972898483276,
-0.054357096552848816,
0.17660386860370636,
0.13097812235355377,
0.5623999238014221,
-0.0294808316975832,
0.1144242137670517,
0.5386786460876465,
-0.25253409147262573,
0.032491326332092285,
-0.4100945293903351,
0.5365947484970093,
-0.13518384099006653,
-0.2264488786458969,
-0.2785254120826721,
0.31914809346199036,
0.2413567751646042,
-0.014835921116173267,
0.47969120740890503,
0.4288233816623688,
-0.14636825025081635,
-0.3026914894580841,
-0.7414838075637817,
-0.287358820438385,
-0.4774651825428009,
0.20344166457653046,
-0.40076494216918945,
-0.8329630494117737,
-0.03280045464634895,
-0.041485171765089035,
0.22383885085582733,
0.10080914199352264,
0.6345175504684448,
-0.13839374482631683,
0.9649763107299805,
0.3188420236110687,
-0.1934480369091034,
0.5052397847175598,
-0.2820301949977875,
0.28167831897735596,
-0.7375496625900269,
-0.20181028544902802,
-0.5085957646369934,
-0.2914218306541443,
-0.6451516151428223,
-0.10795518755912781,
0.43568485975265503,
-0.06772524863481522,
-0.2236606329679489,
0.2958461046218872,
-0.5372985005378723,
0.36711224913597107,
0.810284435749054,
0.2656986713409424,
0.21779265999794006,
0.27729207277297974,
-0.433032363653183,
-0.1771574318408966,
-0.6588443517684937,
-0.4074496626853943,
1.3577072620391846,
0.053959161043167114,
0.8207098245620728,
0.006302305497229099,
0.668299674987793,
0.1237085834145546,
0.26050469279289246,
-0.9785885810852051,
0.5870369672775269,
-0.1117338314652443,
-0.6167084574699402,
-0.20716823637485504,
-0.3129633367061615,
-1.0067822933197021,
0.09502893686294556,
-0.4303407073020935,
-0.9603420495986938,
0.3606109321117401,
0.2862222194671631,
-0.5188506841659546,
0.1567300707101822,
-0.799869179725647,
0.7653211951255798,
-0.4012700021266937,
-0.7125840783119202,
-0.14159461855888367,
-0.6590844988822937,
-0.10867992043495178,
-0.05404204502701759,
0.0929073691368103,
-0.337360143661499,
-0.06095714867115021,
0.538642168045044,
-0.03194059059023857,
0.6404494047164917,
-0.3446815609931946,
0.009231296367943287,
0.349638432264328,
0.3382735848426819,
0.46476832032203674,
0.21526646614074707,
-0.4418433606624603,
0.018693020567297935,
0.1294153481721878,
-0.4056638777256012,
-0.669231116771698,
0.46850287914276123,
-0.6542498469352722,
-0.6959867477416992,
-0.25728580355644226,
-0.09355359524488449,
-0.5812554359436035,
0.04493110999464989,
0.22318392992019653,
0.31382349133491516,
-0.3037777841091156,
0.3440198302268982,
0.6711705923080444,
-0.24924685060977936,
0.4901481568813324,
0.5425704121589661,
-0.2750914394855499,
-0.4477788507938385,
0.6471043229103088,
-0.22669996321201324,
0.3066975176334381,
0.698556661605835,
0.3610478937625885,
-0.35665684938430786,
-0.9807024002075195,
-0.3066346049308777,
0.24624493718147278,
-0.08956905454397202,
-0.02498163841664791,
-0.4921216666698456,
0.2196478694677353,
-0.1422566920518875,
-0.3157932758331299,
-0.15575076639652252,
-0.19468443095684052,
-0.18681712448596954,
-0.1402585208415985,
0.2133820354938507,
0.3512657582759857,
0.07272189110517502,
0.6501566767692566,
-0.6286492347717285,
0.10614482313394547,
0.2524069845676422,
0.06524375081062317,
-0.3532904088497162,
-0.48633891344070435,
-0.23207329213619232,
0.09362170845270157,
-0.3106200098991394,
-0.8963642120361328,
0.7521668076515198,
0.20246157050132751,
0.7425417900085449,
0.6566690802574158,
0.19771209359169006,
0.39889276027679443,
-0.30935823917388916,
0.6895110607147217,
-0.01462866086512804,
-0.7010143995285034,
0.851318359375,
-0.5045674443244934,
0.2581438422203064,
0.7749494314193726,
0.5844667553901672,
-0.22804835438728333,
-0.033972110599279404,
-0.541840672492981,
-0.8181874752044678,
0.48575517535209656,
0.10407452285289764,
0.20092977583408356,
-0.21585431694984436,
0.4376382827758789,
0.33804774284362793,
0.48349058628082275,
-0.45959946513175964,
-0.1420171856880188,
0.1856222003698349,
-0.14634981751441956,
-0.2239636331796646,
-0.3843122124671936,
0.007864104583859444,
-0.0276617631316185,
0.7419490218162537,
-0.3620571792125702,
0.3197537660598755,
0.2025812864303589,
0.1190548911690712,
0.05484720692038536,
0.4400530159473419,
0.24424242973327637,
0.5834632515907288,
-0.7440558075904846,
-0.18632781505584717,
0.15848641097545624,
-0.21438203752040863,
-0.030422095209360123,
0.15085306763648987,
-0.2852442264556885,
-0.15239837765693665,
-0.1941015124320984,
0.7604916095733643,
0.4486374855041504,
-0.6238495707511902,
0.3745957612991333,
0.09080801904201508,
-0.0972202941775322,
-0.24958564341068268,
0.09884922951459885,
-0.09765025973320007,
-0.01747122034430504,
0.44445499777793884,
-0.04044682905077934,
0.32069823145866394,
-0.5191658735275269,
0.01548777986317873,
0.7831872701644897,
-0.15593822300434113,
-0.3626953363418579,
0.2942555546760559,
0.21980248391628265,
-0.29424843192100525,
0.4981456995010376,
-0.0718926340341568,
-0.31996598839759827,
0.37935781478881836,
0.5556327700614929,
1.0190316438674927,
-0.12688104808330536,
0.40568995475769043,
0.3349378705024719,
0.30031663179397583,
0.13628314435482025,
0.19534923136234283,
-0.3931450843811035,
-1.0482860803604126,
-0.21769005060195923,
-0.691728413105011,
-0.749176025390625,
-0.21055223047733307,
-0.6265586614608765,
0.2256554812192917,
-0.6390790343284607,
-0.5061376690864563,
-0.2835478186607361,
0.2569146752357483,
-0.6894029974937439,
0.11295764893293381,
-0.014103401452302933,
0.47737374901771545,
-0.377327561378479,
0.7452191710472107,
0.5477784872055054,
-0.039907921105623245,
-0.4261937439441681,
-0.04351155087351799,
0.007372702471911907,
-0.7760984897613525,
0.36504557728767395,
-0.14283762872219086,
-0.19378691911697388,
0.0871037170290947,
-0.4168487787246704,
-0.4741929769515991,
0.7765318155288696,
0.36623892188072205,
-0.558894157409668,
-0.16447113454341888,
-0.1592050939798355,
0.41982001066207886,
-0.5759562849998474,
0.3294837772846222,
0.6135575175285339,
0.394780695438385,
-0.009922739118337631,
-0.8400022983551025,
-0.2424553483724594,
-0.13779358565807343,
-0.05996917933225632,
0.3262868821620941,
-0.44754189252853394,
0.28359511494636536,
-0.34895506501197815,
-0.0194757878780365,
0.16889716684818268,
0.2818014323711395,
0.5524218082427979,
0.4437224864959717,
0.492855429649353,
0.41490691900253296,
0.5470734238624573,
-0.029044881463050842,
1.2177741527557373,
-0.4136509299278259,
0.23767471313476562,
1.1419651508331299,
-0.2703665494918823,
1.0966652631759644,
0.5586766600608826,
-0.36005041003227234,
0.5793759822845459,
0.8064152598381042,
0.16737526655197144,
0.5945813655853271,
0.09442558139562607,
-0.503863513469696,
-0.3295970559120178,
-0.12149487435817719,
-0.04987228661775589,
0.18183787167072296,
0.5448075532913208,
-0.2702138423919678,
0.05925329029560089,
-0.11712271720170975,
0.054897911846637726,
0.04233131930232048,
0.048156704753637314,
0.9418008923530579,
-0.045679349452257156,
-0.8185656666755676,
0.37203285098075867,
-0.08949839323759079,
0.7498696446418762,
-0.6871832013130188,
0.15598836541175842,
-0.392825186252594,
-0.14751647412776947,
0.10081996768712997,
-0.5684729218482971,
-0.09081234782934189,
-0.1431935578584671,
-0.10524255037307739,
-0.3059159517288208,
0.6538472771644592,
-0.29841411113739014,
-0.40338122844696045,
0.312106192111969,
0.6127130389213562,
0.008210097439587116,
-0.14340271055698395,
-0.7343934774398804,
-0.2138151228427887,
-0.02085663005709648,
-0.4122808277606964,
0.214758038520813,
0.2661087214946747,
0.21809710562229156,
0.7234889268875122,
0.9108272194862366,
0.3560197651386261,
-0.12214197218418121,
0.015335522592067719,
0.3927035927772522,
-0.39592286944389343,
-0.25811341404914856,
-0.9852866530418396,
0.39332038164138794,
-0.037892572581768036,
-0.25288036465644836,
0.5253821015357971,
0.4779849648475647,
0.7883209586143494,
0.004773879889398813,
0.7912976145744324,
0.21982614696025848,
0.4738510847091675,
-0.6019160151481628,
0.4396550953388214,
-0.3224398195743561,
0.4675211012363434,
-0.4557003676891327,
-1.2976104021072388,
-0.1913527101278305,
0.6843991875648499,
-0.6036539673805237,
0.17044052481651306,
0.6041340827941895,
0.9387537240982056,
0.08969198912382126,
-0.04354298114776611,
0.4251627027988434,
-0.008520304225385189,
0.22017721831798553,
0.9093033671379089,
0.6957948803901672,
-0.05665598064661026,
0.484262615442276,
-0.38891565799713135,
-0.4188719391822815,
-0.24965214729309082,
-0.9281085133552551,
-0.8568190932273865,
-0.4220702648162842,
-0.4122462868690491,
-0.2708940804004669,
0.2751382291316986,
1.4612412452697754,
0.7697811722755432,
-0.7876402139663696,
-0.5372082591056824,
-0.03602799028158188,
0.20297771692276,
-0.009501230902969837,
-0.23616939783096313,
0.27787983417510986,
-0.24001958966255188,
-0.9549720287322998,
0.6603533029556274,
0.5430344939231873,
0.05921228975057602,
-0.146872878074646,
-0.10781363397836685,
-0.2089233249425888,
0.2411956638097763,
0.7193504571914673,
0.24326489865779877,
-0.6810457706451416,
-0.14376547932624817,
0.23429207503795624,
0.19607026875019073,
0.11325746774673462,
0.6946196556091309,
-0.9830422401428223,
0.8275499939918518,
0.4037070870399475,
0.757178783416748,
0.6668164134025574,
-0.04078560695052147,
0.8081235885620117,
-0.45409461855888367,
-0.037789370864629745,
0.19786877930164337,
0.2104090005159378,
0.07292915880680084,
-0.2509065866470337,
0.4794059693813324,
0.28318673372268677,
-0.5725555419921875,
-0.5589726567268372,
0.15927335619926453,
-1.3830585479736328,
-0.13414202630519867,
1.1426019668579102,
-0.08465461432933807,
-0.04909049719572067,
-0.08151765912771225,
-0.5442659854888916,
-0.1744414120912552,
-0.8835129141807556,
0.8225145936012268,
0.6080958247184753,
-0.296017050743103,
-0.1404678374528885,
-0.45799294114112854,
0.41751107573509216,
0.6347455978393555,
-0.6414739489555359,
-0.17217569053173065,
0.5274047255516052,
0.04611494392156601,
-0.167226642370224,
0.5849618315696716,
0.10551454871892929,
0.17885145545005798,
-0.4482395052909851,
-0.21378815174102783,
0.14875395596027374,
-0.156720831990242,
-0.13777203857898712,
0.3634362816810608,
0.20629994571208954,
-0.013556997291743755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00980v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00980v1
|
A Hong Kong Sign Language Corpus Collected from Sign-interpreted TV News
| 2024-05-02T03:33:17 | 2024-05-02T03:33:17 |
Zhe Niu, Ronglai Zuo, Brian Mak, Fangyun Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
This paper introduces TVB-HKSL-News, a new Hong Kong sign language (HKSL)
dataset collected from a TV news program over a period of 7 months. The dataset
is collected to enrich resources for HKSL and support research in
large-vocabulary continuous sign language recognition (SLR) and translation
(SLT). It consists of 16.07 hours of sign videos of two signers with a
vocabulary of 6,515 glosses (for SLR) and 2,850 Chinese characters or 18K
Chinese words (for SLT). One signer has 11.66 hours of sign videos and the
other has 4.41 hours. One objective in building the dataset is to support the
investigation of how well large-vocabulary continuous sign language
recognition/translation can be done for a single signer given a (relatively)
large amount of his/her training data, which could potentially lead to the
development of new modeling methods. Besides, most parts of the data collection
pipeline are automated with little human intervention; we believe that our
collection method can be scaled up to collect more sign language data easily
for SLT in the future for any sign languages if such sign-interpreted videos
are available. We also run a SOTA SLR/SLT model on the dataset and get a
baseline SLR word error rate of 34.08% and a baseline SLT BLEU-4 score of 23.58
for benchmarking future research on the dataset.
|
[
0.09816106408834457,
-0.19601798057556152,
0.15828318893909454,
0.18672002851963043,
-0.782970666885376,
0.20343470573425293,
-0.09475407749414444,
-0.5492563247680664,
0.3426308035850525,
0.7535115480422974,
-0.20673798024654388,
-0.5152516961097717,
-0.9818872213363647,
-0.02008739858865738,
-0.4399857521057129,
1.0366796255111694,
-0.122529998421669,
0.32706397771835327,
0.7985634207725525,
-0.3529187738895416,
-0.33267438411712646,
-0.07778526097536087,
-0.7568327784538269,
0.2721943259239197,
0.11204271018505096,
0.3092135190963745,
0.8433790802955627,
0.5615752339363098,
0.5390333533287048,
0.03599994257092476,
0.0958031490445137,
0.20573079586029053,
-0.385924756526947,
-0.4345605671405792,
0.3353051245212555,
-0.19483396410942078,
-0.49022799730300903,
-0.09642860293388367,
0.8316592574119568,
0.6197377443313599,
0.11466941237449646,
0.5245459675788879,
-0.2504671514034271,
0.5521682500839233,
-0.32479041814804077,
0.1851993352174759,
-0.42179322242736816,
0.05437208712100983,
-0.6098896861076355,
0.2335539013147354,
-0.37853530049324036,
-0.3063391149044037,
-0.15540868043899536,
-0.6161620020866394,
0.2568143308162689,
-0.1813260167837143,
0.842717707157135,
0.1322547346353531,
-0.5767931342124939,
-0.333490252494812,
-0.5371246933937073,
0.6522031426429749,
-1.028969645500183,
0.7864390015602112,
0.3956910967826843,
0.4105772078037262,
0.06841132044792175,
-0.5175915360450745,
-0.5994043946266174,
-0.37721630930900574,
0.01702260598540306,
0.2686557471752167,
0.29904916882514954,
-0.1488293558359146,
0.2899627387523651,
0.07967230677604675,
-0.9245243668556213,
0.004776015877723694,
-0.8462938070297241,
-0.47517073154449463,
0.889435887336731,
0.13643044233322144,
0.3369404673576355,
-0.3011270761489868,
-0.41248029470443726,
-0.06828296184539795,
-0.7923954129219055,
0.25747576355934143,
0.1776130497455597,
0.48308950662612915,
-0.5476267337799072,
0.5651894807815552,
0.18438363075256348,
0.9472016096115112,
-0.22801443934440613,
-0.29665541648864746,
0.20687302947044373,
-0.5559569597244263,
0.025967301800847054,
0.3085345923900604,
0.716423749923706,
0.4486772119998932,
0.05535779520869255,
0.4745282828807831,
-0.2984541952610016,
0.1461496204137802,
-0.37947869300842285,
-0.6786132454872131,
-0.2199377864599228,
0.04273444786667824,
-0.5483053922653198,
0.28871408104896545,
0.3260096311569214,
-0.2867601811885834,
-0.6339185833930969,
-0.27984464168548584,
-0.0013493711594492197,
-0.1867423802614212,
-0.6165532469749451,
0.4978277385234833,
-0.22861221432685852,
0.4199075400829315,
0.4170140326023102,
-0.4226493239402771,
-0.01277119293808937,
0.44874343276023865,
0.6918948888778687,
-0.2743614614009857,
-0.03490235656499863,
-0.5872385501861572,
0.11206401139497757,
-0.31336510181427,
0.36889272928237915,
-0.26989901065826416,
-0.21813592314720154,
0.1373724341392517,
0.08447873592376709,
0.07467309385538101,
-0.3083435595035553,
0.6010085940361023,
-0.5443615913391113,
-0.11606967449188232,
-0.06666126847267151,
-0.44093745946884155,
0.17680460214614868,
-0.21070413291454315,
-1.0590453147888184,
0.7037162780761719,
0.31481581926345825,
-0.22684961557388306,
0.6936067938804626,
-0.4828329086303711,
-0.74154132604599,
0.3908228874206543,
-0.2598172426223755,
-0.3244529962539673,
-0.2616390585899353,
0.20086266100406647,
0.33352890610694885,
0.14820772409439087,
0.09166131168603897,
0.010573239997029305,
-0.3608582615852356,
0.357878714799881,
-0.34672823548316956,
1.0161534547805786,
0.4806966185569763,
-0.3318185806274414,
-0.4731998145580292,
-0.805374801158905,
-0.40415677428245544,
-0.20498014986515045,
-0.49869653582572937,
-0.3185385763645172,
-0.31361567974090576,
0.3885341286659241,
0.38978639245033264,
0.7180123925209045,
-1.0527548789978027,
-0.030898330733180046,
-0.1573084443807602,
0.1588858664035797,
0.46014827489852905,
-0.301444947719574,
-0.19214217364788055,
0.0792914405465126,
0.5942893624305725,
0.3815700113773346,
0.4060682952404022,
-0.0673028975725174,
-0.5179501175880432,
-0.42984890937805176,
-0.10863938927650452,
0.2153102159500122,
0.1656082719564438,
-0.4908508062362671,
0.3646380603313446,
-0.25025391578674316,
-0.39117157459259033,
-0.9809789061546326,
0.18446892499923706,
0.5365045666694641,
0.08007662743330002,
0.17490772902965546,
-0.33154335618019104,
-0.8358445763587952,
-0.4822676479816437,
0.14324264228343964,
-0.20028570294380188,
0.09390322118997574,
-0.13591690361499786,
0.08809488266706467,
0.2916591763496399,
0.6809731125831604,
-0.4834332764148712,
-0.45274198055267334,
-0.3585573136806488,
0.06692039221525192,
0.4883025586605072,
0.16131944954395294,
0.26616668701171875,
-1.1733307838439941,
-0.7472773194313049,
0.2369401752948761,
-0.6256531476974487,
0.07525711506605148,
-0.4012705087661743,
0.06284164637327194,
0.1396474540233612,
0.5687304139137268,
-0.48885080218315125,
0.33354446291923523,
0.8553091287612915,
-0.6655630469322205,
0.9590901136398315,
0.11960992962121964,
0.15547841787338257,
-1.0543948411941528,
-0.005455169826745987,
-0.024426961317658424,
-0.242428258061409,
-0.588373601436615,
-0.11362168192863464,
-0.032076146453619,
-0.21803507208824158,
-0.8567833304405212,
0.8894700407981873,
-0.669403612613678,
-0.3159378468990326,
-0.38299936056137085,
0.7485556602478027,
-0.1223234012722969,
0.26094305515289307,
0.3375842571258545,
0.7571201920509338,
0.48447608947753906,
-0.6002565622329712,
0.2913498282432556,
0.5151420831680298,
-0.5710834860801697,
0.2693164646625519,
-0.3252158463001251,
-0.1431187093257904,
0.01374246459454298,
0.16746173799037933,
-1.151964545249939,
0.004619268700480461,
0.1829432249069214,
-0.6192351579666138,
0.18535581231117249,
0.3288925588130951,
-0.16040007770061493,
-0.581408679485321,
-0.07493383437395096,
0.3227229118347168,
0.24226544797420502,
-0.5542492270469666,
0.24397440254688263,
0.6864324808120728,
-0.06508053839206696,
-0.6363853812217712,
-0.5483061671257019,
0.2693648934364319,
0.019397500902414322,
-0.38494041562080383,
-0.03593034669756889,
-0.08732844889163971,
0.004377696663141251,
-0.1730949580669403,
-0.31571173667907715,
-0.16465193033218384,
-0.22333396971225739,
0.06015397980809212,
0.26529115438461304,
-0.44676411151885986,
-0.16326771676540375,
-0.1601686179637909,
0.06119421124458313,
-0.08916017413139343,
0.053668346256017685,
0.2604058086872101,
0.12546509504318237,
-0.4811277687549591,
-0.5297015905380249,
0.0907101109623909,
0.6334253549575806,
-0.08188652247190475,
0.21266379952430725,
0.8619707226753235,
-0.19021421670913696,
0.11285189539194107,
-0.3230196535587311,
0.0014155346434563398,
-0.3835163712501526,
0.49852675199508667,
-0.2648937404155731,
-0.9906247854232788,
0.5447878241539001,
0.30792325735092163,
0.45670077204704285,
0.15663661062717438,
0.5716279149055481,
0.07352150976657867,
1.2532992362976074,
0.27207067608833313,
-0.4939793646335602,
0.5863082408905029,
0.12147592753171921,
0.1347103863954544,
-0.6219249367713928,
0.1891152411699295,
-0.10074560344219208,
-0.2928333282470703,
-0.263426810503006,
-0.4380575716495514,
0.2981874644756317,
-0.06233296915888786,
0.007633326109498739,
1.0020631551742554,
-0.46526408195495605,
-0.008446631953120232,
0.06151923909783363,
0.14823490381240845,
0.5369306802749634,
-0.3948515057563782,
0.323243111371994,
-0.0041691577062010765,
-0.21217849850654602,
-0.5364837646484375,
1.2158763408660889,
0.29307445883750916,
0.6064646244049072,
0.2791256308555603,
0.2703522741794586,
0.5276581048965454,
0.33758997917175293,
-0.44833335280418396,
0.8008379340171814,
-0.6129727363586426,
-0.6493730545043945,
-0.5413982272148132,
-0.09344751387834549,
-1.2256561517715454,
0.012052207253873348,
0.24638091027736664,
-0.3345234990119934,
-0.04837024584412575,
0.09943851828575134,
-0.14553047716617584,
0.11313021928071976,
-0.5216302275657654,
0.6011714339256287,
-0.44882792234420776,
0.251298725605011,
-0.19057990610599518,
-0.9105550646781921,
0.7074454426765442,
-0.391635924577713,
0.29795750975608826,
-0.13237734138965607,
0.3021533787250519,
0.9693530797958374,
-0.4330953061580658,
0.9439757466316223,
-0.4535117447376251,
-0.5727816820144653,
0.480089396238327,
-0.3088393807411194,
0.586935818195343,
0.03479534760117531,
-0.2909564971923828,
0.06399579346179962,
0.1764138638973236,
-0.4626842141151428,
-0.4146977663040161,
-0.03626743331551552,
-0.7053033709526062,
-0.21092669665813446,
-0.2080306112766266,
-0.5477705001831055,
0.05432530865073204,
0.2723618149757385,
0.13203072547912598,
0.5582895278930664,
-0.252566397190094,
0.001691612764261663,
0.30456969141960144,
0.062228407710790634,
0.14783696830272675,
0.9753740429878235,
-0.26920285820961,
-0.22391217947006226,
0.9835339188575745,
0.041240230202674866,
0.23482753336429596,
0.5762137174606323,
0.07384707778692245,
-0.4191020727157593,
-0.6740400195121765,
-0.433118999004364,
0.3857644498348236,
-0.4696981906890869,
-0.05023309588432312,
0.0017564581939950585,
-0.2974260449409485,
-0.6702965497970581,
0.06190622225403786,
-0.1536267101764679,
-0.38314589858055115,
-0.0758671909570694,
-0.3118704855442047,
0.4073726236820221,
0.4999971091747284,
-0.05310222879052162,
0.49808889627456665,
-0.989349365234375,
0.4001094400882721,
-0.09787756204605103,
-0.04597070440649986,
-0.39396610856056213,
-0.7060602307319641,
-0.8073620796203613,
0.3529168963432312,
-0.024791574105620384,
-0.4624728262424469,
0.2888838052749634,
0.0878998339176178,
0.3971109092235565,
0.7073476314544678,
0.20195963978767395,
0.7847610712051392,
-0.180721253156662,
1.219905972480774,
0.5226857662200928,
-0.6491668224334717,
0.21483120322227478,
-0.5400407910346985,
0.4874490797519684,
0.44843199849128723,
0.15738730132579803,
-0.8049132823944092,
-0.8519600033760071,
-0.5210103392601013,
-0.5402597784996033,
0.49922651052474976,
0.030692394822835922,
-0.027131902053952217,
-0.035630639642477036,
0.07599948346614838,
0.4190208315849304,
0.23441751301288605,
-0.6612184047698975,
-0.15466740727424622,
-0.17494231462478638,
-0.20180578529834747,
-0.07440641522407532,
0.20893938839435577,
0.11017842590808868,
-0.3158973157405853,
0.7308335304260254,
-0.29164746403694153,
0.12775929272174835,
-0.147971972823143,
-0.4207603335380554,
-0.1455472856760025,
0.01924761012196541,
0.7288706302642822,
0.7239671349525452,
-0.2851778566837311,
0.08465063571929932,
-0.028919927775859833,
-1.1294976472854614,
-0.135610893368721,
0.02297164499759674,
-0.08699396252632141,
0.4595162868499756,
0.39149174094200134,
1.0605074167251587,
0.10677415877580643,
-1.1313148736953735,
0.6240564584732056,
0.28576111793518066,
-0.280852347612381,
-0.5768699049949646,
-0.29399147629737854,
-0.15077070891857147,
0.14896856248378754,
0.4084363877773285,
-0.3320710361003876,
-0.025188937783241272,
-0.11476599425077438,
0.5634987354278564,
0.301445335149765,
-0.3491171598434448,
-0.544018566608429,
0.658611536026001,
-0.06764335930347443,
0.01876499317586422,
0.5075382590293884,
-0.22201547026634216,
-0.3251999616622925,
0.594087541103363,
0.6017683148384094,
0.5506659746170044,
-0.34240442514419556,
0.49194037914276123,
0.5245795845985413,
0.05817620828747749,
-0.08831770718097687,
0.5806968212127686,
0.0013738787965849042,
-0.8833094239234924,
-0.4852299690246582,
-0.6595199108123779,
-0.46098193526268005,
0.43795478343963623,
-0.6425603032112122,
0.5583280920982361,
-0.16127611696720123,
-0.25613492727279663,
-0.13628533482551575,
0.18094030022621155,
-0.46300363540649414,
0.3805393874645233,
0.500174343585968,
1.0354076623916626,
-1.1611831188201904,
0.923966109752655,
0.6161490678787231,
-0.3948096036911011,
-0.9134831428527832,
-0.16504889726638794,
-0.15480868518352509,
-1.1490638256072998,
0.9259522557258606,
-0.06677926331758499,
-0.0890001654624939,
0.02179493010044098,
-0.5592331886291504,
-0.9039965271949768,
0.9073764681816101,
0.2378988265991211,
-0.585345983505249,
-0.06180315092206001,
0.6327572464942932,
0.5798171162605286,
-0.2591918408870697,
-0.11842696368694305,
0.7616099715232849,
0.7329361438751221,
-0.014496869407594204,
-0.8796589970588684,
0.16071173548698425,
-0.13685645163059235,
-0.3948010802268982,
0.3718481957912445,
-0.8351421356201172,
0.6160665154457092,
-0.0863170400261879,
-0.3065715730190277,
0.1258670836687088,
0.8565660119056702,
0.7164570093154907,
0.3346352279186249,
0.49064117670059204,
0.2573883533477783,
0.6246901750564575,
0.3363640308380127,
0.3342573940753937,
-0.4732082486152649,
0.09682805091142654,
0.8799716830253601,
-0.4416864216327667,
0.7806868553161621,
0.4339788556098938,
-0.43763309717178345,
0.28162863850593567,
0.43382638692855835,
-0.27002373337745667,
0.3483107388019562,
0.24481256306171417,
-0.2646293044090271,
-0.27035295963287354,
-0.25304752588272095,
-0.01684545911848545,
0.3703484833240509,
0.5847741961479187,
-0.18400438129901886,
-0.4393423795700073,
0.43894973397254944,
-0.06693989038467407,
0.06355646997690201,
-0.2567444443702698,
0.19789855182170868,
0.47090068459510803,
-0.40929096937179565,
0.5054619312286377,
-0.35318562388420105,
0.6480135917663574,
-0.9011089205741882,
-0.08595418930053711,
-0.009319680742919445,
0.19704341888427734,
-0.20483815670013428,
-1.0752979516983032,
0.11154210567474365,
-0.2916010320186615,
0.06554076820611954,
-0.3211810886859894,
0.5764909386634827,
-0.560365617275238,
-0.4789256453514099,
0.08689235895872116,
0.32029011845588684,
0.8175227046012878,
0.4399738013744354,
-0.7039201855659485,
0.22558891773223877,
0.11398984491825104,
-0.0883890762925148,
0.35489386320114136,
0.35214266180992126,
-0.38447970151901245,
0.2654489576816559,
0.6954833269119263,
0.5836352109909058,
0.22587698698043823,
0.31911808252334595,
0.4431411027908325,
-0.6700704097747803,
-0.5803586840629578,
-0.3453027606010437,
0.5073531270027161,
0.004834250081330538,
-0.6560809016227722,
0.8884797692298889,
0.8568679690361023,
0.7057539224624634,
-0.24184638261795044,
1.065510630607605,
-0.333748996257782,
0.587349534034729,
-0.6207549571990967,
0.6449130773544312,
-0.390067458152771,
-0.004607937764376402,
-0.2330099195241928,
-0.37507468461990356,
-0.3674831688404083,
0.22758184373378754,
-0.07253768295049667,
-0.33056673407554626,
0.49141785502433777,
0.8817747831344604,
0.14305837452411652,
0.07491856813430786,
0.43576765060424805,
0.02221667394042015,
0.3503686487674713,
0.6236960291862488,
0.3048091530799866,
-0.799560546875,
0.7407274842262268,
0.310311883687973,
0.04453980550169945,
-0.34913086891174316,
-0.6882433891296387,
-0.6095709204673767,
-0.9236138463020325,
-0.5071884989738464,
-0.33270567655563354,
0.08080930262804031,
0.7080790400505066,
0.46870625019073486,
-1.0679254531860352,
-0.6623632311820984,
0.13827195763587952,
-0.14975914359092712,
-0.868400514125824,
-0.27726709842681885,
0.9550371766090393,
0.008964561857283115,
-0.6238377690315247,
0.530246376991272,
-0.21787148714065552,
-0.0973602682352066,
-0.29834815859794617,
-0.33191466331481934,
-0.20202778279781342,
-0.4790381193161011,
0.7457138895988464,
0.6861259341239929,
-0.468335896730423,
-0.3787539303302765,
0.150878444314003,
-0.3053843379020691,
0.09793458133935928,
0.7560082077980042,
-0.3952755630016327,
0.4238646328449249,
0.5668675899505615,
0.44204476475715637,
0.5705029368400574,
0.16566888988018036,
0.4827708601951599,
-0.999984085559845,
-0.060960348695516586,
0.05344046652317047,
0.30984148383140564,
0.2825440764427185,
-0.4466805160045624,
0.37331533432006836,
0.23980574309825897,
-0.3258911371231079,
-0.7731875777244568,
0.29316824674606323,
-1.3699791431427002,
-0.13970649242401123,
1.288743257522583,
0.12048327922821045,
-0.20170165598392487,
-0.7107531428337097,
-0.2810032367706299,
0.646023154258728,
-0.5525400638580322,
0.5115129947662354,
0.5953313112258911,
-0.1833159178495407,
-0.2803647220134735,
-0.6746230721473694,
0.5896922945976257,
0.03417764976620674,
-0.3771471679210663,
0.4483450651168823,
0.41736671328544617,
0.21531882882118225,
0.3560810089111328,
0.9319471716880798,
-0.27701857686042786,
0.6000258922576904,
-0.037703946232795715,
0.19360816478729248,
-0.052886463701725006,
-0.10034571588039398,
-0.10803552716970444,
-0.12104851007461548,
0.13769355416297913,
-0.3009856939315796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00978v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00978v1
|
Language Fairness in Multilingual Information Retrieval
| 2024-05-02T03:30:15 | 2024-05-02T03:30:15 |
Eugene Yang, Thomas Jänich, James Mayfield, Dawn Lawrie
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Multilingual information retrieval (MLIR) considers the problem of ranking
documents in several languages for a query expressed in a language that may
differ from any of those languages. Recent work has observed that approaches
such as combining ranked lists representing a single document language each or
using multilingual pretrained language models demonstrate a preference for one
language over others. This results in systematic unfair treatment of documents
in different languages. This work proposes a language fairness metric to
evaluate whether documents across different languages are fairly ranked through
statistical equivalence testing using the Kruskal-Wallis test. In contrast to
most prior work in group fairness, we do not consider any language to be an
unprotected group. Thus our proposed measure, PEER (Probability of
EqualExpected Rank), is the first fairness metric specifically designed to
capture the language fairness of MLIR systems. We demonstrate the behavior of
PEER on artificial ranked lists. We also evaluate real MLIR systems on two
publicly available benchmarks and show that the PEER scores align with prior
analytical findings on MLIR fairness. Our implementation is compatible with
ir-measures and is available at http://github.com/hltcoe/peer_measure.
|
[
-0.1980629712343216,
-0.33420220017433167,
0.4192323386669159,
0.4451802968978882,
0.24006560444831848,
0.10531548410654068,
-0.3202739953994751,
-0.3877134621143341,
0.1556084156036377,
0.20092405378818512,
0.06612458825111389,
-0.2940387427806854,
-0.8696214556694031,
0.11910395324230194,
-0.31355467438697815,
1.167393684387207,
0.06785153597593307,
0.575668215751648,
-0.18364666402339935,
-0.7745932340621948,
-0.2000175565481186,
-0.6348528265953064,
-0.5691148638725281,
-0.41701409220695496,
0.5709327459335327,
0.5350152254104614,
0.78718101978302,
0.24663524329662323,
1.0083571672439575,
0.3743273615837097,
0.10109727829694748,
-0.3809469938278198,
-0.4206954836845398,
0.17342312633991241,
-0.26315024495124817,
-0.5436680316925049,
-0.48582643270492554,
0.2105635106563568,
1.1610523462295532,
0.8978186845779419,
-0.4713036119937897,
0.5701415538787842,
0.2557034194469452,
1.101886510848999,
-0.743908703327179,
-0.0862417072057724,
-0.5880258679389954,
0.3669773042201996,
-0.516571581363678,
-0.14188437163829803,
-0.4467870593070984,
-0.7818730473518372,
-0.3240993022918701,
-0.3298717737197876,
0.21052390336990356,
0.3190647065639496,
0.7192109823226929,
0.03169379383325577,
-0.26855596899986267,
-0.23565571010112762,
-0.2714264988899231,
0.8486649394035339,
-0.4501687288284302,
0.690192699432373,
0.43908318877220154,
0.7395405769348145,
-0.12753881514072418,
-0.5923685431480408,
-0.650742769241333,
-0.3499242961406708,
-0.26208335161209106,
0.07350220531225204,
-0.21272146701812744,
-0.17197659611701965,
0.16980060935020447,
0.5439455509185791,
-0.9013300538063049,
-0.1109750047326088,
-0.3028278350830078,
-0.19811685383319855,
0.4543514847755432,
-0.07048791646957397,
0.1056470200419426,
-0.14215047657489777,
-0.06926000118255615,
-0.17095941305160522,
-0.4489773213863373,
0.3841921389102936,
1.0152453184127808,
0.46700432896614075,
0.09499020874500275,
0.6351704001426697,
-0.3149197995662689,
0.48488423228263855,
-0.07741741091012955,
-0.3250935673713684,
0.5540640354156494,
-0.2325705736875534,
0.05284130945801735,
0.3342035412788391,
0.6659008264541626,
0.48990562558174133,
0.30249857902526855,
-0.2959040701389313,
-0.3200189471244812,
-0.11678893119096756,
-0.12123379111289978,
-0.8605903387069702,
-0.17751075327396393,
-0.040623944252729416,
-0.957920491695404,
-0.22846582531929016,
0.13964727520942688,
-0.6030884981155396,
-0.29301509261131287,
0.17566704750061035,
0.7167418003082275,
-0.006646055728197098,
-0.5554693937301636,
0.021555667743086815,
-0.24859662353992462,
0.0825076624751091,
-0.21997922658920288,
-0.7173019051551819,
0.5757966637611389,
0.6502872705459595,
0.5964938402175903,
-0.17108076810836792,
-0.6866500377655029,
-1.066076397895813,
-0.07644882798194885,
-0.09773433208465576,
0.6368536353111267,
-0.6946139335632324,
-0.2171521931886673,
-0.1547742486000061,
0.22061483561992645,
-0.009354455396533012,
-0.5082389712333679,
0.6256499886512756,
-0.5172672271728516,
0.5470425486564636,
-0.3868924677371979,
-0.47563132643699646,
0.055214714258909225,
0.3012201189994812,
-0.34919536113739014,
0.9614859223365784,
0.001502310624346137,
-0.9276197552680969,
0.7027153372764587,
-0.4213549792766571,
-0.39708518981933594,
0.03066364862024784,
-0.31135159730911255,
-0.36262190341949463,
-0.40444082021713257,
-0.25912898778915405,
0.24396704137325287,
0.037533439695835114,
0.42976313829421997,
-0.41683903336524963,
-0.6769242882728577,
0.22951756417751312,
-0.31991544365882874,
0.5987783670425415,
0.4516845941543579,
-0.306115984916687,
-0.16442956030368805,
-0.32518401741981506,
0.2560814321041107,
0.06441748142242432,
-0.6017864346504211,
-0.3520659804344177,
0.1484556496143341,
0.1502702236175537,
0.13538385927677155,
0.15979406237602234,
-0.7712904810905457,
-0.005526110529899597,
-0.16927242279052734,
-0.1899174600839615,
0.9041117429733276,
-0.494030624628067,
0.6002476215362549,
-0.45461007952690125,
0.25488102436065674,
-0.2606945037841797,
0.32648903131484985,
0.4068962633609772,
-0.6282467246055603,
-0.7012839317321777,
-0.06173991784453392,
0.5301348567008972,
0.6111927032470703,
-0.4549850523471832,
0.1345248818397522,
-0.3827124536037445,
-0.3498910069465637,
-0.8793064951896667,
0.08945295214653015,
0.4707540273666382,
0.2358727753162384,
0.01267008576542139,
-0.5744050145149231,
-0.016440659761428833,
-1.0558061599731445,
-0.594411313533783,
-0.25256529450416565,
0.18947091698646545,
0.43296152353286743,
0.2513834536075592,
0.22650101780891418,
0.66094571352005,
-0.20647212862968445,
-0.4855246841907501,
-0.06617701798677444,
-0.04287782311439514,
0.6518983244895935,
0.5292291641235352,
0.7481445670127869,
-0.9854897260665894,
-0.8962214589118958,
0.13361923396587372,
-0.6901917457580566,
-0.19778838753700256,
0.6217570900917053,
-0.19589856266975403,
0.2840588092803955,
0.40812787413597107,
-0.006261612754315138,
0.23635824024677277,
0.5880348086357117,
-0.5316222310066223,
0.19499622285366058,
-0.3940778374671936,
0.9010054469108582,
-0.6945276260375977,
0.33304694294929504,
-0.3296360373497009,
-0.3708108365535736,
-0.48152968287467957,
0.28951045870780945,
0.1430497020483017,
-0.04568978399038315,
-0.39644816517829895,
0.769029438495636,
-0.1089823842048645,
-0.3667469620704651,
-0.19808968901634216,
0.1508970707654953,
-0.02333216555416584,
0.31649377942085266,
-0.3125222623348236,
0.6808953881263733,
0.3923613727092743,
-0.40421321988105774,
0.009894448332488537,
-0.09848561882972717,
-0.316191703081131,
0.9378432035446167,
-0.429415225982666,
0.08111069351434708,
-0.6389656066894531,
-0.0181087888777256,
-0.8556680083274841,
0.17000387609004974,
0.451630562543869,
-0.7656075954437256,
0.1912214308977127,
-0.3779161274433136,
-0.5084628462791443,
-0.020315319299697876,
-0.271846741437912,
0.6497832536697388,
0.2710263133049011,
-0.6309254169464111,
0.3858998119831085,
0.6236223578453064,
-0.4607166051864624,
-1.1951675415039062,
-0.6258512735366821,
0.03267665579915047,
-0.2715853750705719,
-0.4560525715351105,
0.13107967376708984,
-0.496731698513031,
-0.5639870166778564,
0.20002907514572144,
0.09517425298690796,
-0.22351911664009094,
0.08911076188087463,
0.14956767857074738,
-0.12742428481578827,
-0.1928091198205948,
0.01847076416015625,
0.08496437221765518,
-0.13224710524082184,
-0.36521658301353455,
-0.03975360095500946,
0.5018134713172913,
-0.4266239404678345,
-0.6503119468688965,
0.0617511123418808,
0.6305628418922424,
0.20451124012470245,
-0.40565112233161926,
0.5854783058166504,
0.7562419176101685,
-0.3367963433265686,
0.3356839120388031,
-0.854781448841095,
0.1576727330684662,
-0.472415953874588,
0.18082699179649353,
-0.6294599771499634,
-0.9280538558959961,
0.422423779964447,
0.5594714283943176,
0.01453789696097374,
0.2693815231323242,
0.41209298372268677,
0.07197249680757523,
0.9997246265411377,
0.6922309994697571,
-0.464954137802124,
0.23085957765579224,
0.30852729082107544,
0.391532301902771,
-0.13156795501708984,
-0.23830991983413696,
-1.0554040670394897,
-0.41675278544425964,
-1.0200048685073853,
-0.1437777727842331,
0.36752861738204956,
0.18405093252658844,
-0.3463565707206726,
-0.06498996913433075,
-0.44904133677482605,
0.7455910444259644,
0.6749248504638672,
-0.13615547120571136,
0.6054618954658508,
0.16800013184547424,
-0.20974278450012207,
-0.24325373768806458,
-0.39616966247558594,
-0.48788052797317505,
0.9962553381919861,
0.19817693531513214,
0.5839551091194153,
0.6143805980682373,
0.7435688376426697,
0.6999528408050537,
0.4707718789577484,
-0.5320168137550354,
0.3251148462295532,
-0.40988537669181824,
-0.6812842488288879,
-0.23147645592689514,
-0.7307301759719849,
-0.9522024393081665,
0.6360636353492737,
-0.22283108532428741,
-0.5110638737678528,
0.3546106815338135,
-0.19997981190681458,
0.19758284091949463,
0.2351321280002594,
-0.6848945617675781,
0.9001825451850891,
-0.1545683741569519,
-0.2428920567035675,
-0.4210536479949951,
-0.4105929434299469,
0.17740879952907562,
-0.18895475566387177,
0.48829448223114014,
-0.5617486238479614,
0.19313405454158783,
0.6514561772346497,
-0.000998293748125434,
-0.06892930716276169,
-0.4403449296951294,
0.3294028639793396,
-0.3433462083339691,
0.2473965734243393,
0.10815046727657318,
0.10500436276197433,
-0.7112212777137756,
0.27268320322036743,
0.17243123054504395,
-0.8122789263725281,
-0.39575499296188354,
0.8398793339729309,
-0.4494973123073578,
-0.3247925639152527,
-0.7286808490753174,
-0.3257262706756592,
0.10177978128194809,
0.45271092653274536,
-0.028627563267946243,
0.0561097115278244,
-0.36600449681282043,
0.13602373003959656,
0.2475060373544693,
-0.2867121398448944,
0.3360338509082794,
1.1622438430786133,
-0.5353825688362122,
-0.09006931632757187,
1.177004337310791,
0.06235681474208832,
0.0750715434551239,
0.39534008502960205,
0.19412927329540253,
-0.15609754621982574,
-0.2823289930820465,
-0.37222760915756226,
-0.07133030891418457,
-0.7825701832771301,
-0.06880680471658707,
-0.705079197883606,
-0.030516542494297028,
-0.4019738435745239,
0.17848274111747742,
-0.16856525838375092,
-0.5709282159805298,
0.6358115077018738,
0.25873899459838867,
0.07171650975942612,
0.686003565788269,
-0.4870713949203491,
-0.1193169578909874,
-0.6089361310005188,
0.3144356608390808,
0.17256362736225128,
0.812060534954071,
-0.09435400366783142,
-0.5298125147819519,
-0.16607505083084106,
-0.17782637476921082,
-0.20413897931575775,
-0.4975840449333191,
0.05482363700866699,
0.5220426321029663,
1.0788013935089111,
0.1717882752418518,
-0.04423517733812332,
0.2865760624408722,
-0.8668143153190613,
0.32447490096092224,
0.08207736164331436,
-0.7710022926330566,
0.3889073431491852,
-0.00415409030392766,
-0.19186994433403015,
0.9771585464477539,
0.49966681003570557,
-0.8198314309120178,
-0.8547514081001282,
-0.15480035543441772,
-0.531927227973938,
0.6021907329559326,
0.3576699197292328,
0.16120928525924683,
-0.06450498849153519,
0.14833034574985504,
0.29702356457710266,
0.335594117641449,
-1.0126923322677612,
-0.5071492791175842,
-0.07669420540332794,
-0.23770761489868164,
-0.29548701643943787,
0.010512792505323887,
0.10584573447704315,
-0.27082929015159607,
0.5386102795600891,
0.019623182713985443,
0.15419717133045197,
0.09297724813222885,
-0.3176228702068329,
-0.21105706691741943,
0.5345843434333801,
0.19280719757080078,
0.7204080820083618,
-0.5398154258728027,
0.21885831654071808,
-0.0667746514081955,
-0.6061413884162903,
0.38304364681243896,
0.46740734577178955,
0.06906447559595108,
0.09104127436876297,
-0.11550204455852509,
0.11258288472890854,
-0.07457376271486282,
-0.5487614274024963,
0.9650919437408447,
-0.61565762758255,
-0.06273175030946732,
-0.08706961572170258,
-0.10938557982444763,
-0.2622004747390747,
0.4386633038520813,
0.4870572090148926,
0.009612410329282284,
0.5897927284240723,
-0.48624733090400696,
0.3908187448978424,
0.5567640066146851,
-0.4368320107460022,
0.17707359790802002,
0.5128777027130127,
0.01357058621942997,
-0.4251113533973694,
0.4428708553314209,
-0.6152970194816589,
-0.4203076660633087,
0.35328516364097595,
0.2271035760641098,
0.2617588937282562,
-0.37785154581069946,
0.2116682082414627,
0.27162429690361023,
0.6614715456962585,
-0.007861192338168621,
0.32084566354751587,
-0.10199559479951859,
-0.7464638352394104,
-0.04517442360520363,
-0.8321532011032104,
-0.42315250635147095,
-0.3791525661945343,
-0.6328355073928833,
0.056026890873909,
0.044713329523801804,
-0.11993386596441269,
-0.03317977115511894,
0.14581122994422913,
-0.6614230275154114,
-0.0672832727432251,
-0.05103405565023422,
0.743726372718811,
-0.844635009765625,
0.8201999664306641,
0.5200371146202087,
-0.426296591758728,
-0.38581836223602295,
-0.029408378526568413,
-0.34327641129493713,
-0.7857387065887451,
0.7078031301498413,
0.20829172432422638,
-0.02962062694132328,
-0.2966699004173279,
0.04824892804026604,
-0.585358202457428,
0.638391375541687,
0.5666235089302063,
-0.2520527243614197,
0.4078556001186371,
0.5135975480079651,
0.25850826501846313,
0.029315385967493057,
0.46101951599121094,
0.40611085295677185,
0.6416804194450378,
-0.5659701824188232,
-1.1783740520477295,
-0.18204224109649658,
-0.6427043676376343,
-0.39173635840415955,
0.38589271903038025,
-0.5358065366744995,
0.8546743392944336,
-0.011465965770184994,
-0.004854594357311726,
0.0812547504901886,
0.45007312297821045,
0.25294628739356995,
0.5897228121757507,
0.7871854305267334,
0.5772278904914856,
1.0251078605651855,
0.013408185914158821,
0.9964837431907654,
-0.2860071361064911,
0.435397207736969,
0.920642077922821,
-0.4397304654121399,
0.893962562084198,
0.5985286831855774,
-0.17844519019126892,
0.20725932717323303,
0.40115079283714294,
0.19204100966453552,
0.64505535364151,
0.28237858414649963,
-0.3027932941913605,
-0.08067295700311661,
-0.38136276602745056,
-0.703742504119873,
0.4016713798046112,
-0.2944285273551941,
-0.133056640625,
-0.32804638147354126,
0.12555213272571564,
0.06809106469154358,
0.3816845118999481,
-0.23338398337364197,
0.47162845730781555,
0.03908943384885788,
-0.5118735432624817,
0.15803246200084686,
0.39194974303245544,
0.8873923420906067,
-0.41200506687164307,
-0.07965420931577682,
-0.5616356730461121,
0.2916765809059143,
-0.14568611979484558,
-1.0785709619522095,
0.04934282600879669,
0.1251465380191803,
-0.4389103353023529,
-0.17466601729393005,
0.5667637586593628,
-0.5823982954025269,
-0.7162110805511475,
0.5748950839042664,
0.6543955206871033,
0.587019681930542,
-0.06010209396481514,
-0.8377326130867004,
-0.1446762979030609,
-0.2725732922554016,
0.0014541115378960967,
0.7020146250724792,
0.20591476559638977,
0.10269099473953247,
0.5532884001731873,
0.458039790391922,
0.10394266247749329,
0.09187348932027817,
0.5386770963668823,
0.4506148099899292,
-0.28982722759246826,
-0.446553111076355,
-0.6389429569244385,
0.2048972100019455,
-0.15874361991882324,
-0.04901491105556488,
0.801238477230072,
0.8557134866714478,
0.9321819543838501,
0.30734989047050476,
0.41585907340049744,
-0.10858164727687836,
0.6568478941917419,
-0.2364606261253357,
1.2843573093414307,
-0.8741804361343384,
-0.23594802618026733,
-0.6315555572509766,
-1.1544208526611328,
-0.14738553762435913,
0.5697533488273621,
0.0041360873728990555,
0.0707462802529335,
0.6076511144638062,
0.9131016135215759,
-0.34111344814300537,
-0.28718048334121704,
0.37504974007606506,
-0.10944391787052155,
0.1886787861585617,
0.3762630522251129,
0.8103716969490051,
-0.5516406893730164,
0.6835544109344482,
-0.11661143600940704,
-0.33830347657203674,
0.18965843319892883,
-0.8697920441627502,
-0.5976587533950806,
-0.5194924473762512,
0.1131817027926445,
-0.4265684485435486,
0.38185828924179077,
0.6846838593482971,
0.4918547570705414,
-0.7742727398872375,
-0.5614948272705078,
0.7005245685577393,
0.47613397240638733,
0.10387983173131943,
-0.25029119849205017,
0.16709409654140472,
-0.4033336639404297,
-0.525786817073822,
0.37145450711250305,
0.2495361715555191,
-0.3717373311519623,
-0.015122335404157639,
-0.5536877512931824,
-0.16473986208438873,
-0.3825605511665344,
0.47489291429519653,
0.0008748313994146883,
-0.2966849207878113,
-0.34028977155685425,
-0.013454106636345387,
-0.4023810625076294,
0.10039319097995758,
0.6235431432723999,
-0.4765302240848541,
0.4237719476222992,
0.46082040667533875,
0.4536875784397125,
0.28210848569869995,
-0.5318652391433716,
0.3007924556732178,
-0.6990619897842407,
0.2996125817298889,
0.03161722049117088,
0.4486069977283478,
0.403921902179718,
-0.2592853009700775,
0.4986055791378021,
0.0024496179539710283,
-0.7904974222183228,
-1.0678319931030273,
0.008318251930177212,
-0.5611911416053772,
-0.14273285865783691,
0.7045095562934875,
-0.021481091156601906,
0.18898071348667145,
-0.05484873801469803,
-0.023428134620189667,
-0.0350559763610363,
-0.353555291891098,
0.6198257803916931,
0.7924842834472656,
0.34429967403411865,
0.17057617008686066,
-0.6877911686897278,
0.2507795989513397,
0.5317874550819397,
-0.44440892338752747,
-0.3756932020187378,
0.0920921117067337,
0.4223766326904297,
-0.03428635373711586,
1.323332667350769,
-0.33206838369369507,
0.4253986179828644,
-0.49715089797973633,
0.2200395166873932,
0.37552449107170105,
-0.21153180301189423,
-0.2729891538619995,
0.15964023768901825,
0.40004706382751465,
0.017577597871422768
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00977v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00977v1
|
Distillation for Multilingual Information Retrieval
| 2024-05-02T03:30:03 | 2024-05-02T03:30:03 |
Eugene Yang, Dawn Lawrie, James Mayfield
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Recent work in cross-language information retrieval (CLIR), where queries and
documents are in different languages, has shown the benefit of the
Translate-Distill framework that trains a cross-language neural dual-encoder
model using translation and distillation. However, Translate-Distill only
supports a single document language. Multilingual information retrieval (MLIR),
which ranks a multilingual document collection, is harder to train than CLIR
because the model must assign comparable relevance scores to documents in
different languages. This work extends Translate-Distill and propose
Multilingual Translate-Distill (MTD) for MLIR. We show that ColBERT-X models
trained with MTD outperform their counterparts trained ith Multilingual
Translate-Train, which is the previous state-of-the-art training approach, by
5% to 25% in nDCG@20 and 15% to 45% in MAP. We also show that the model is
robust to the way languages are mixed in training batches. Our implementation
is available on GitHub.
|
[
-0.26749902963638306,
-0.38397109508514404,
0.42069870233535767,
0.32621991634368896,
-0.25669100880622864,
0.31572407484054565,
-0.4463006556034088,
-0.2953393757343292,
0.051905591040849686,
0.08277422934770584,
-0.09125793725252151,
-0.4760897755622864,
-0.9560880064964294,
0.31265807151794434,
-0.3726000487804413,
1.103046178817749,
-0.09071260690689087,
0.5098250508308411,
-0.1254454106092453,
-0.5144156813621521,
-0.1269114911556244,
-0.8565934300422668,
-0.43623021245002747,
-0.31902700662612915,
0.625059962272644,
0.33026689291000366,
0.40649381279945374,
0.2358541488647461,
0.7270333766937256,
0.28991904854774475,
-0.21003367006778717,
0.17874205112457275,
-0.6483231782913208,
0.243660107254982,
-0.12139075994491577,
-0.525982141494751,
-0.15390464663505554,
-0.007518327794969082,
0.6020211577415466,
0.7007281184196472,
-0.4428654909133911,
0.1750873327255249,
0.35442137718200684,
0.9351921677589417,
-0.682807207107544,
0.07351717352867126,
-0.7290480732917786,
0.04685001075267792,
-0.21309414505958557,
-0.11267883330583572,
-0.6127262711524963,
-0.3378317952156067,
0.025125399231910706,
-0.48007455468177795,
0.2461511492729187,
0.028980590403079987,
0.576323390007019,
0.1523275226354599,
-0.7218411564826965,
-0.4330262243747711,
-0.6760275959968567,
0.8553876280784607,
-0.4015418589115143,
0.6181694269180298,
0.4129731357097626,
0.46135011315345764,
0.15692776441574097,
-0.7813250422477722,
-0.6099832653999329,
-0.27370527386665344,
-0.2152259647846222,
0.04991794005036354,
-0.17625224590301514,
-0.2272186279296875,
0.18153221905231476,
0.5901660323143005,
-0.7441291809082031,
-0.21047760546207428,
-0.4997834265232086,
0.11508367210626602,
0.4398965537548065,
-0.05478764697909355,
-0.12079163640737534,
0.08898729085922241,
-0.49878594279289246,
-0.20188376307487488,
-0.522743284702301,
-0.07007595151662827,
0.43053314089775085,
0.4590720534324646,
0.1143704280257225,
0.33716338872909546,
-0.2219422608613968,
0.5352635383605957,
0.13550016283988953,
-0.07616284489631653,
0.43091973662376404,
-0.39502283930778503,
-0.10137122869491577,
0.2533179521560669,
0.8107243180274963,
0.3877226412296295,
0.15917260944843292,
-0.20752161741256714,
-0.20245952904224396,
-0.26111936569213867,
-0.033227596431970596,
-1.1753201484680176,
-0.3094692528247833,
0.14081837236881256,
-0.45657721161842346,
-0.07035043835639954,
0.012599309906363487,
-0.7645317912101746,
-0.30273082852363586,
-0.3430240750312805,
0.19136150181293488,
-0.381061315536499,
-0.5446569919586182,
0.1617526262998581,
-0.3254859745502472,
-0.09748971462249756,
0.04661383479833603,
-0.7650275826454163,
0.13439582288265228,
0.33384090662002563,
0.9731811881065369,
-0.24984797835350037,
-0.40710780024528503,
-0.7417840361595154,
-0.10678517818450928,
-0.08152865618467331,
0.5211154222488403,
-0.5828699469566345,
-0.4857008457183838,
0.05884819105267525,
0.04565109312534332,
-0.16018345952033997,
-0.7883417010307312,
0.5994583964347839,
-0.5034998655319214,
0.0880376473069191,
-0.5957472920417786,
-0.08258342742919922,
-0.2360209822654724,
0.4039245843887329,
-0.7694419026374817,
1.1922098398208618,
0.057820044457912445,
-1.0340549945831299,
0.4788011908531189,
-0.3460005521774292,
-0.6826074719429016,
-0.2100931853055954,
0.06896855682134628,
-0.24074791371822357,
-0.012041445821523666,
0.3338385224342346,
0.35485124588012695,
-0.392567902803421,
0.47536760568618774,
-0.4212735593318939,
-0.16635598242282867,
0.1437607854604721,
-0.4383997619152069,
0.8338304162025452,
0.48240455985069275,
-0.031886424869298935,
-0.18503965437412262,
-0.7890589237213135,
-0.20973791182041168,
-0.0937725082039833,
-0.6617982983589172,
-0.5829480886459351,
-0.05842309445142746,
0.4106278717517853,
0.4510040283203125,
0.21013028919696808,
-0.6909875869750977,
0.20735257863998413,
0.14722779393196106,
0.49935978651046753,
0.2988455295562744,
-0.4312902092933655,
0.5899085402488708,
-0.17344412207603455,
0.35693255066871643,
0.4417908191680908,
-0.1446865051984787,
0.011032545939087868,
-0.4472176432609558,
-0.55524742603302,
-0.3549041152000427,
0.5069697499275208,
0.7626409530639648,
-0.9753623604774475,
-0.002842649584636092,
-0.4274844229221344,
-0.4496476650238037,
-0.8135017156600952,
0.2630952000617981,
0.4169044494628906,
0.549429178237915,
0.6569117307662964,
-0.0650959387421608,
-0.3870541453361511,
-0.7650270462036133,
-0.04514416679739952,
-0.06860948354005814,
0.231008842587471,
-0.06873878091573715,
0.47735241055488586,
-0.08235989511013031,
0.517941415309906,
-0.33047863841056824,
-0.4117031395435333,
-0.5700402855873108,
0.25648996233940125,
0.3638135492801666,
0.3863014876842499,
0.7683929204940796,
-1.1636532545089722,
-1.1658600568771362,
0.5276352763175964,
-0.7004683017730713,
0.10203906893730164,
0.28030067682266235,
-0.12973207235336304,
0.23590759932994843,
0.37681514024734497,
-0.4119596779346466,
0.4798928499221802,
0.5692028999328613,
0.0925540030002594,
0.19929295778274536,
-0.5468138456344604,
0.54928058385849,
-1.3570963144302368,
0.38217058777809143,
-0.029974574223160744,
-0.38637903332710266,
-0.6690946817398071,
0.10716883093118668,
0.3997267186641693,
-0.12827783823013306,
-0.4930320382118225,
0.3508651852607727,
-0.5388323664665222,
0.3194289803504944,
-0.2688462734222412,
0.04840753600001335,
0.3448147475719452,
0.37026745080947876,
0.2448721081018448,
0.6481543183326721,
0.598802924156189,
-0.6299314498901367,
0.3493504226207733,
0.19644580781459808,
-0.49584540724754333,
0.809749186038971,
-0.548190176486969,
-0.019583873450756073,
-0.32218894362449646,
0.15029063820838928,
-1.02376389503479,
0.3172963857650757,
-0.19456812739372253,
-0.19357535243034363,
0.7059245109558105,
-0.5547482967376709,
-0.5074515342712402,
-0.3632683753967285,
-0.1428108513355255,
0.5119689702987671,
0.3165169954299927,
-0.9239623546600342,
0.5017006397247314,
0.28118836879730225,
-0.12305030971765518,
-1.0875418186187744,
-0.9873947501182556,
0.026215307414531708,
-0.544340193271637,
-0.6671475172042847,
0.4221797287464142,
-0.43291303515434265,
-0.30249887704849243,
-0.1429009586572647,
0.07496818900108337,
-0.3685181140899658,
-0.07660097628831863,
-0.11938999593257904,
0.042587630450725555,
-0.14828963577747345,
0.0066063906997442245,
0.15758946537971497,
-0.04181799292564392,
-0.36081424355506897,
-0.41520339250564575,
0.47368499636650085,
-0.08225709199905396,
-0.11442811787128448,
-0.1792074739933014,
0.7876648306846619,
0.7295764088630676,
-0.5091584324836731,
0.9346619248390198,
0.7751606702804565,
-0.0236066747456789,
0.06051284074783325,
-0.7333939671516418,
-0.10194004327058792,
-0.40062206983566284,
0.4279864728450775,
-0.7475308179855347,
-0.6680409908294678,
0.6246672868728638,
0.06617478281259537,
-0.0408480204641819,
0.19922775030136108,
0.5619082450866699,
-0.04551205039024353,
0.9516298770904541,
0.7091054320335388,
-0.30106085538864136,
0.366818904876709,
-0.46261274814605713,
0.12060879915952682,
-0.7781310081481934,
-0.2041614055633545,
-0.5979463458061218,
-0.5598434209823608,
-0.6683202981948853,
-0.26005634665489197,
0.34760692715644836,
0.22859756648540497,
0.327539324760437,
0.46636369824409485,
-0.4612382650375366,
0.38800156116485596,
0.6207109689712524,
-0.12666083872318268,
0.5835778117179871,
0.2886256277561188,
-0.45987051725387573,
-0.04700447991490364,
-0.7416892647743225,
-0.24181021749973297,
1.2136530876159668,
-0.08984259516000748,
0.7589268088340759,
0.28370314836502075,
0.8277702331542969,
0.08724910765886307,
0.26933765411376953,
-0.5539388656616211,
0.10950613021850586,
-0.5160365700721741,
-0.6695333123207092,
0.05583567172288895,
-0.5217677354812622,
-0.9589249491691589,
0.7605031728744507,
0.0026799787301570177,
-0.4438258707523346,
0.6795840859413147,
0.08478384464979172,
-0.05972420796751976,
0.41521939635276794,
-0.7924959659576416,
0.8714938759803772,
-0.2911394536495209,
-0.4184602200984955,
-0.30164533853530884,
-0.6159850358963013,
0.24429810047149658,
-0.33592987060546875,
0.3148603141307831,
-0.04628077149391174,
0.40630781650543213,
0.3685290813446045,
-0.1718740612268448,
0.2294120192527771,
-0.2714202105998993,
-0.11864551156759262,
0.10930823534727097,
0.1572955846786499,
0.3730214536190033,
0.24774394929409027,
-0.6350254416465759,
0.48395392298698425,
0.305144339799881,
-0.2502667307853699,
-0.48270371556282043,
0.8291196823120117,
-0.604737401008606,
-0.4542306363582611,
-0.551398754119873,
-0.5804211497306824,
0.30938827991485596,
0.16278216242790222,
0.5461190342903137,
0.34832239151000977,
-0.38079217076301575,
0.3631596565246582,
0.5543837547302246,
0.005460219923406839,
0.6039795875549316,
0.7000781297683716,
-0.3894176483154297,
-0.43009424209594727,
0.8684349060058594,
0.2068699449300766,
0.39409807324409485,
0.8733687400817871,
0.0911702811717987,
-0.5034444332122803,
-0.4663323163986206,
-0.5987392067909241,
0.027547411620616913,
-0.791101336479187,
-0.1206965520977974,
-0.6839116811752319,
0.014567814767360687,
-0.3656894266605377,
0.21352533996105194,
-0.31484565138816833,
-0.6272780299186707,
-0.1578776240348816,
-0.004029246047139168,
0.12987308204174042,
0.5163766145706177,
-0.28362977504730225,
0.02494390867650509,
-0.75290846824646,
0.36103910207748413,
0.06501912325620651,
0.07331983000040054,
-0.3101617395877838,
-0.7134966850280762,
-0.4767713248729706,
0.3245241641998291,
-0.30936720967292786,
-0.7045899629592896,
0.5873745679855347,
0.5037235021591187,
0.5973373651504517,
0.24059714376926422,
0.23670735955238342,
0.7857285141944885,
-0.7651684284210205,
0.38998696208000183,
0.2539294958114624,
-0.5331836342811584,
0.32582539319992065,
0.13623103499412537,
0.2447093278169632,
0.992206335067749,
0.763322651386261,
-0.6186716556549072,
-0.205389142036438,
0.03184359893202782,
-0.6683875918388367,
0.6531378626823425,
0.06897112727165222,
0.08340400457382202,
-0.20353339612483978,
0.0535951629281044,
0.39235082268714905,
0.32124456763267517,
-0.795981764793396,
-0.3528347611427307,
-0.26473724842071533,
-0.11780421435832977,
-0.3187718391418457,
-0.1979937106370926,
-0.0027202984783798456,
-0.44137534499168396,
0.6381576061248779,
-0.012263837270438671,
-0.0659656673669815,
0.2995469868183136,
-0.4993142783641815,
0.27521049976348877,
0.42123717069625854,
0.4858390986919403,
0.608751654624939,
-0.47533315420150757,
0.3116464912891388,
-0.016184912994503975,
-0.5273429155349731,
0.3270139992237091,
0.46951913833618164,
0.12234307080507278,
0.163423553109169,
-0.1803884655237198,
0.7258240580558777,
-0.2832004725933075,
-0.4240454435348511,
0.5664154887199402,
-0.3924867808818817,
-0.2757297158241272,
-0.13478949666023254,
-0.3499009609222412,
0.0852714404463768,
0.36581161618232727,
0.4746006429195404,
0.003531043417751789,
0.3821481168270111,
-0.4607480466365814,
0.04852423071861267,
0.3594183325767517,
-0.5342119932174683,
-0.22550049424171448,
0.6466516256332397,
0.17451493442058563,
0.03141750022768974,
0.9288339018821716,
-0.5211695432662964,
-0.4458175301551819,
0.29210442304611206,
0.4562944769859314,
0.6980891227722168,
-0.38188865780830383,
0.016461191698908806,
0.559873104095459,
0.35716545581817627,
-0.16709382832050323,
0.35122182965278625,
-0.30229589343070984,
-0.5312550067901611,
-0.2072238177061081,
-0.750255286693573,
0.01856829784810543,
-0.07792960852384567,
-0.8226537704467773,
0.2764958143234253,
0.21676412224769592,
-0.36139994859695435,
-0.10413207858800888,
-0.14355316758155823,
-0.7082593441009521,
-0.15733151137828827,
0.07129547744989395,
0.7912032008171082,
-0.5995930433273315,
1.2625118494033813,
0.567642092704773,
-0.44317561388015747,
-0.1989641636610031,
-0.15103021264076233,
-0.24466152489185333,
-0.3776584565639496,
1.1684956550598145,
0.24243877828121185,
-0.02811533398926258,
-0.05659007281064987,
0.09096706658601761,
-0.7433990240097046,
1.070510983467102,
0.6629480123519897,
-0.7455658316612244,
0.12126394361257553,
0.38020220398902893,
0.4043004810810089,
-0.34135738015174866,
0.4682244658470154,
0.3485236167907715,
0.41366487741470337,
0.15372364223003387,
-1.210908055305481,
-0.3598674535751343,
-0.5997316241264343,
0.012824585661292076,
0.3307550251483917,
-0.4022948443889618,
1.0032129287719727,
-0.3169775605201721,
-0.3322068154811859,
-0.01494633313268423,
0.451669842004776,
0.035732489079236984,
0.39080265164375305,
0.2113129049539566,
0.733613133430481,
0.8551089763641357,
-0.14162659645080566,
1.1279352903366089,
-0.6700000166893005,
0.3656432628631592,
1.2276986837387085,
-0.5076107978820801,
1.059279441833496,
0.6820247173309326,
-0.08561374992132187,
0.5110160112380981,
0.4276222884654999,
0.29279130697250366,
0.8524396419525146,
0.020348167046904564,
-0.3629527688026428,
-0.0888640284538269,
0.009415390901267529,
-0.5609874129295349,
0.30773934721946716,
0.2043403685092926,
-0.4109252393245697,
-0.3107474446296692,
0.24368831515312195,
-0.08520668745040894,
0.12249938398599625,
0.06505779922008514,
0.6392837166786194,
0.1960447132587433,
-0.7419531941413879,
0.8875845074653625,
0.12292160093784332,
0.7134270071983337,
-0.6382380723953247,
0.049044325947761536,
-0.42154964804649353,
0.46639570593833923,
-0.04430155083537102,
-0.629122793674469,
0.237644225358963,
-0.13510239124298096,
-0.5194658041000366,
-0.3966924846172333,
0.22097815573215485,
-0.9437516331672668,
-0.7676975727081299,
0.703355610370636,
0.4786165654659271,
0.13372395932674408,
-0.31942588090896606,
-0.7106398344039917,
-0.27606531977653503,
0.04564428701996803,
0.00682816281914711,
0.4780678451061249,
0.5697787404060364,
0.08957042545080185,
0.5731271505355835,
0.6702077984809875,
0.0014708128292113543,
0.4064214527606964,
0.19216185808181763,
0.6926562786102295,
-0.13833631575107574,
-0.4198674261569977,
-1.0364125967025757,
0.5473988652229309,
-0.18339386582374573,
-0.10510481894016266,
0.6259962320327759,
0.9523714184761047,
1.054073691368103,
-0.12118420004844666,
0.801487386226654,
-0.1265420764684677,
0.30866867303848267,
-0.4006240665912628,
0.8883789777755737,
-0.7397926449775696,
0.08188032358884811,
0.02542722225189209,
-1.1419126987457275,
-0.1642976999282837,
0.47525542974472046,
-0.11313220113515854,
-0.01565825752913952,
0.9396937489509583,
0.9118017554283142,
-0.445528119802475,
-0.3622569441795349,
0.447527676820755,
-0.09102030098438263,
0.30346786975860596,
0.5936710834503174,
0.8897078037261963,
-0.5195626616477966,
0.8598455190658569,
-0.4319579303264618,
-0.015536417253315449,
-0.06359343975782394,
-0.8647478818893433,
-1.0835777521133423,
-0.8147291541099548,
-0.29366254806518555,
-0.21010106801986694,
-0.023947851732373238,
0.600117027759552,
0.8292707800865173,
-0.8239417672157288,
-0.4932762086391449,
0.27326837182044983,
0.07263161242008209,
-0.275151789188385,
-0.12481869757175446,
0.22027848660945892,
-0.4383416771888733,
-0.9471621513366699,
0.5655572414398193,
0.26608386635780334,
-0.10793156176805496,
-0.1623455435037613,
-0.21292650699615479,
-0.6095457077026367,
-0.35194337368011475,
0.6448442935943604,
-0.0008366057300008833,
-0.5376436710357666,
0.23391388356685638,
0.1013866662979126,
-0.3034839630126953,
0.4678145945072174,
0.8880357146263123,
-0.5597541332244873,
0.7374666929244995,
0.6765420436859131,
0.4564802646636963,
0.9335578680038452,
-0.22767403721809387,
0.5098252892494202,
-0.9090820550918579,
0.42469680309295654,
-0.18246085941791534,
0.5997429490089417,
0.57866370677948,
-0.2660317122936249,
0.41029495000839233,
0.17377673089504242,
-0.5235165357589722,
-0.7399792671203613,
0.014352039434015751,
-0.7790712118148804,
-0.22020454704761505,
1.2146317958831787,
-0.26823726296424866,
0.004635762423276901,
-0.24167345464229584,
-0.26651275157928467,
0.21449127793312073,
-0.44037917256355286,
0.649082362651825,
0.7380213141441345,
0.4312085807323456,
-0.014086795970797539,
-0.693580687046051,
0.28934246301651,
0.1661420613527298,
-0.3391580283641815,
0.09656798094511032,
0.16462285816669464,
0.30450892448425293,
0.3349284827709198,
0.5699241757392883,
-0.11154455691576004,
-0.00822057668119669,
-0.2233353853225708,
0.14489254355430603,
-0.11978694796562195,
-0.4282097816467285,
-0.2878085672855377,
0.13019751012325287,
0.1214805617928505,
-0.19480445981025696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00975v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00975v1
|
PLAID SHIRTTT for Large-Scale Streaming Dense Retrieval
| 2024-05-02T03:28:52 | 2024-05-02T03:28:52 |
Dawn Lawrie, Efsun Kayi, Eugene Yang, James Mayfield, Douglas W. Oard
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
PLAID, an efficient implementation of the ColBERT late interaction bi-encoder
using pretrained language models for ranking, consistently achieves
state-of-the-art performance in monolingual, cross-language, and multilingual
retrieval. PLAID differs from ColBERT by assigning terms to clusters and
representing those terms as cluster centroids plus compressed residual vectors.
While PLAID is effective in batch experiments, its performance degrades in
streaming settings where documents arrive over time because representations of
new tokens may be poorly modeled by the earlier tokens used to select cluster
centroids. PLAID Streaming Hierarchical Indexing that Runs on Terabytes of
Temporal Text (PLAID SHIRTTT) addresses this concern using multi-phase
incremental indexing based on hierarchical sharding. Experiments on ClueWeb09
and the multilingual NeuCLIR collection demonstrate the effectiveness of this
approach both for the largest collection indexed to date by the ColBERT
architecture and in the multilingual setting, respectively.
|
[
-0.37583598494529724,
-0.9997392892837524,
0.12443286180496216,
0.3684782087802887,
-0.3098699152469635,
0.49330416321754456,
-0.44551289081573486,
-0.585780143737793,
0.6993057131767273,
0.04341743886470795,
-0.19468379020690918,
-0.20862694084644318,
-0.5518721342086792,
-0.06049801781773567,
-0.6716507077217102,
1.109848976135254,
0.4115716218948364,
0.05460548773407936,
0.18858353793621063,
-0.04694094881415367,
0.06510094553232193,
-0.4111117124557495,
-0.737872302532196,
-0.28174006938934326,
0.9097641110420227,
0.3957410156726837,
0.8989304304122925,
0.4379185736179352,
0.6516857743263245,
0.39690759778022766,
-0.12068450450897217,
-0.23919717967510223,
-1.0174590349197388,
0.43511462211608887,
-0.15364447236061096,
-0.07608053833246231,
-0.3766349256038666,
0.07886239886283875,
0.8130004405975342,
0.5633384585380554,
-0.19092559814453125,
0.09008775651454926,
0.1822635382413864,
0.7464349269866943,
-0.8849254846572876,
-0.17569361627101898,
-0.5673006176948547,
-0.041401952505111694,
-0.5458263754844666,
-0.3789927661418915,
-0.29570472240448,
-0.5362404584884644,
0.2529592216014862,
-0.524393618106842,
0.3892006278038025,
0.27427905797958374,
0.7054175138473511,
-0.11757775396108627,
-0.3035670816898346,
-0.6024514436721802,
-0.6119937300682068,
0.9210589528083801,
-0.10576405376195908,
0.931546688079834,
0.49356046319007874,
0.1775033175945282,
0.3839702606201172,
-0.7552728652954102,
-0.49337679147720337,
0.019781924784183502,
-0.08796995133161545,
0.2994506359100342,
0.04102439433336258,
-0.03691573813557625,
-0.11231637746095657,
0.7106612324714661,
-0.6772751808166504,
-0.03397504985332489,
-0.3819330334663391,
-0.2527863085269928,
0.6814138293266296,
0.0472092479467392,
-0.22039613127708435,
-0.4497774541378021,
-0.4602038562297821,
-0.11945275217294693,
-0.38836532831192017,
-0.00879080779850483,
0.6391143798828125,
0.100508913397789,
-0.0037979583721607924,
0.7025070786476135,
-0.3810040354728699,
0.43212488293647766,
0.243600532412529,
0.108502596616745,
0.18128374218940735,
-0.4098116457462311,
-0.2724721431732178,
0.2125997692346573,
0.6677383780479431,
-0.056282997131347656,
-0.07335971295833588,
-0.38828524947166443,
-0.2429552972316742,
-0.23816709220409393,
0.06764145940542221,
-0.7683221101760864,
-0.3935082256793976,
0.42452049255371094,
-0.5644081234931946,
-0.29745686054229736,
0.10750655084848404,
-1.2141094207763672,
-0.5164568424224854,
-0.4088726341724396,
0.5053728222846985,
-0.47688689827919006,
-0.4142830967903137,
0.00414090882986784,
-0.18588802218437195,
0.4358079433441162,
0.1925727128982544,
-0.6501027345657349,
0.19913996756076813,
0.7742484211921692,
0.8206070065498352,
-0.21539118885993958,
-0.227632075548172,
-0.8300633430480957,
0.014264869503676891,
-0.3414788246154785,
0.8586969971656799,
-0.8363214135169983,
-0.2829965054988861,
0.23577921092510223,
0.03646841645240784,
-0.09840749204158783,
-0.42729833722114563,
0.5560139417648315,
-0.8132099509239197,
-0.0004367839719634503,
-0.4634679853916168,
-0.5213013291358948,
0.21418555080890656,
0.20355118811130524,
-0.7116051912307739,
1.212384581565857,
-0.07593247294425964,
-0.9245472550392151,
0.2904135584831238,
-0.39005959033966064,
-0.5490713715553284,
0.24411460757255554,
0.02482951059937477,
-0.26712456345558167,
-0.14709998667240143,
-0.1022840067744255,
0.7243050336837769,
-0.24031628668308258,
0.023958679288625717,
-0.4084405303001404,
-0.35784420371055603,
-0.06072910875082016,
-0.05056888982653618,
0.787177324295044,
0.6056994199752808,
-0.20968325436115265,
0.03552258387207985,
-0.6001404523849487,
0.22205215692520142,
-0.10174427181482315,
-0.6205467581748962,
-0.2859286069869995,
0.07735773175954819,
0.7369020581245422,
-0.16663657128810883,
0.3921706974506378,
-0.8290457129478455,
-0.21119506657123566,
0.35627317428588867,
0.609700620174408,
0.6550860404968262,
-0.40054258704185486,
0.5990587472915649,
-0.4896470904350281,
0.4318584203720093,
-0.20507505536079407,
0.024003995582461357,
-0.12216560542583466,
-0.34704142808914185,
-0.8425366282463074,
-0.3289252817630768,
0.10689601302146912,
0.6222336292266846,
-0.9130494594573975,
0.1592259258031845,
-0.598639726638794,
-0.5896590352058411,
-0.27466654777526855,
0.24599358439445496,
0.4497720003128052,
0.08629200607538223,
0.3241301476955414,
0.014730853959918022,
-0.4705488681793213,
-0.7225347757339478,
-0.055376213043928146,
0.19965988397598267,
0.2935267984867096,
0.1419036090373993,
0.39639902114868164,
-0.2519511282444,
0.6887837648391724,
-0.3047742545604706,
-0.12731362879276276,
-0.3476414978504181,
0.5057968497276306,
0.15007007122039795,
0.6204497218132019,
0.12496688216924667,
-0.7425357103347778,
-0.674924910068512,
0.47399601340293884,
-0.44894206523895264,
0.30600208044052124,
0.17783892154693604,
-0.21234042942523956,
0.19243933260440826,
0.719429075717926,
-0.15118686854839325,
0.30642110109329224,
0.784906804561615,
-0.06683026999235153,
0.6702789664268494,
-0.14637674391269684,
0.3021254241466522,
-0.9712003469467163,
0.08126819133758545,
-0.3539445400238037,
-0.500110387802124,
-0.3467976152896881,
0.09938999265432358,
0.17161302268505096,
-0.43660008907318115,
-0.1677486002445221,
0.2684618830680847,
-0.5590450763702393,
-0.096589095890522,
0.23227468132972717,
0.1332962065935135,
-0.052032239735126495,
0.3046455681324005,
0.16475488245487213,
0.8079969882965088,
0.2405817210674286,
-0.6039571762084961,
0.42524290084838867,
0.0050704460591077805,
-0.6572452187538147,
1.0928186178207397,
-0.8150941133499146,
0.4965437054634094,
-0.2163267731666565,
0.11458835005760193,
-0.9774008989334106,
-0.10722455382347107,
-0.5631885528564453,
-0.13998359441757202,
0.66995769739151,
-0.28959935903549194,
-0.28243154287338257,
-0.12431687116622925,
-0.6295868754386902,
0.7013500332832336,
0.25451403856277466,
-0.5997141599655151,
0.24490602314472198,
0.5518481135368347,
-0.2278694361448288,
-0.8492223024368286,
-0.5400325059890747,
0.048120275139808655,
-0.20660173892974854,
-0.8148948550224304,
0.4202195405960083,
-0.23612943291664124,
-0.16249187290668488,
0.02177727036178112,
0.07478784769773483,
-0.24899867177009583,
-0.3635029196739197,
-0.35588547587394714,
-0.24834150075912476,
-0.3154488205909729,
0.21140292286872864,
-0.23331615328788757,
-0.011083992198109627,
-0.4739818274974823,
-0.32814285159111023,
0.936010479927063,
-0.4192964434623718,
-0.025421692058444023,
-0.2420630007982254,
0.7499619126319885,
0.312408983707428,
-0.3603948652744293,
0.5064837336540222,
1.0538606643676758,
-0.12694476544857025,
-0.26908478140830994,
-1.0969717502593994,
0.08501438796520233,
-0.49779531359672546,
0.37564030289649963,
-0.32172703742980957,
-1.0435281991958618,
0.616432249546051,
0.20983469486236572,
-0.1923927217721939,
0.20869360864162445,
0.25822415947914124,
-0.7445670962333679,
0.3352054953575134,
0.3878372609615326,
-0.03902848809957504,
0.9053087830543518,
-0.6786368489265442,
0.2732789218425751,
-1.1597590446472168,
-0.2798803746700287,
-0.8802744150161743,
-0.638118326663971,
-0.871431291103363,
-0.5728939771652222,
0.5739890336990356,
0.23673462867736816,
-0.3200468420982361,
0.37381818890571594,
-0.33984842896461487,
0.48094049096107483,
0.5485939979553223,
0.2901586592197418,
0.3085021674633026,
0.11691515147686005,
0.0629553347826004,
0.029704971238970757,
-0.8086434602737427,
0.07860774546861649,
1.0382684469223022,
-0.11627184599637985,
1.0961414575576782,
0.32707706093788147,
0.6923661231994629,
0.44761744141578674,
0.03567933663725853,
-0.7235714793205261,
0.1912688910961151,
-0.4287184476852417,
-0.7553727030754089,
-0.5371941924095154,
-0.36418724060058594,
-1.3614881038665771,
0.04961239919066429,
-0.29657769203186035,
-0.49839189648628235,
0.6546489596366882,
0.02505526877939701,
0.12543253600597382,
0.2778846025466919,
-0.654704213142395,
0.5912498235702515,
-0.029274053871631622,
-0.8279126882553101,
-0.7001045942306519,
-0.3333413600921631,
0.16690127551555634,
0.08799201250076294,
0.2733398973941803,
0.17455196380615234,
0.06031806021928787,
0.8770620226860046,
-0.3581569194793701,
0.4043620824813843,
0.08677240461111069,
0.2703590989112854,
0.15175524353981018,
0.2756028175354004,
0.6674821972846985,
0.101128950715065,
-0.26958200335502625,
0.2898939549922943,
0.22170302271842957,
-0.7781031727790833,
-0.28041836619377136,
0.9047969579696655,
-0.7171335220336914,
-0.2738374173641205,
-0.43394845724105835,
-0.4735985994338989,
-0.04343416169285774,
0.21562837064266205,
0.557476282119751,
0.9301350712776184,
-0.3661564290523529,
0.9257527589797974,
0.8307942152023315,
-0.13462276756763458,
0.742202639579773,
-0.02613081783056259,
-0.1352957934141159,
-0.6289665699005127,
0.9050323963165283,
0.29247498512268066,
0.3134100139141083,
0.7799893021583557,
0.31331032514572144,
-0.4362981617450714,
-0.6304449439048767,
-0.15011484920978546,
0.2813988924026489,
-0.6516442894935608,
-0.2088296264410019,
-0.7137995958328247,
-0.14045384526252747,
-0.4424764811992645,
-0.5452187657356262,
-0.39465293288230896,
-0.5441815257072449,
0.29098737239837646,
0.12167873233556747,
0.28808683156967163,
0.8962177634239197,
-0.07075130939483643,
0.33533594012260437,
-0.36683517694473267,
0.2538410723209381,
0.5776863694190979,
0.7196739315986633,
-0.13758805394172668,
-0.16976486146450043,
-0.49480077624320984,
-0.23595525324344635,
-0.2054300606250763,
-0.7687073349952698,
0.0225809495896101,
0.4206348657608032,
0.5322131514549255,
0.4815566837787628,
0.0040925610810518265,
1.0316253900527954,
-0.40357154607772827,
0.5708938241004944,
0.10685954988002777,
-0.9922744035720825,
0.23768554627895355,
-0.6816093921661377,
0.27842676639556885,
0.4979621469974518,
0.35568565130233765,
-0.7312183976173401,
-0.06389213353395462,
-0.23139525949954987,
-0.6047896146774292,
0.6742464303970337,
0.1987495720386505,
0.0698278471827507,
-0.24725455045700073,
-0.07452192902565002,
0.028122752904891968,
0.18198004364967346,
-0.39678341150283813,
0.0147714763879776,
-0.42878457903862,
-0.029681093990802765,
-0.42625948786735535,
-0.5659067630767822,
0.049805231392383575,
-0.2796313762664795,
0.7095267176628113,
-0.04288114607334137,
0.4523681700229645,
0.614864706993103,
-0.44835588335990906,
0.010153531096875668,
0.3174995481967926,
0.31852129101753235,
0.6300666332244873,
-0.36756080389022827,
0.20027385652065277,
-0.2725030481815338,
-0.8358615040779114,
-0.2592736780643463,
-0.022063327953219414,
-0.00879967212677002,
-0.06085075065493584,
0.5509576797485352,
0.30435100197792053,
0.597313404083252,
-0.28866225481033325,
0.4240853786468506,
0.23067113757133484,
0.07463822513818741,
-0.3632165789604187,
-0.4025076627731323,
0.1298028975725174,
0.11528272181749344,
0.3767143785953522,
-0.1503576636314392,
0.3032689690589905,
-0.7723017930984497,
0.1661270558834076,
0.7977991104125977,
-0.4056220054626465,
-0.2780084013938904,
0.5920948386192322,
0.3309497535228729,
-0.26207128167152405,
0.8241586685180664,
-0.2345716655254364,
-0.47352269291877747,
0.4034470319747925,
0.2729244828224182,
1.0098625421524048,
-0.4177244305610657,
0.2844058871269226,
0.5649394989013672,
0.5489067435264587,
0.2296341359615326,
0.41486606001853943,
-0.46210741996765137,
-0.6964147090911865,
-0.2662542462348938,
-0.9187954664230347,
-0.06750757992267609,
-0.12251285463571548,
-0.8376572728157043,
0.37200847268104553,
-0.31257757544517517,
-0.04824124276638031,
-0.04637591913342476,
0.2711777687072754,
-1.0730854272842407,
-0.11862815916538239,
-0.07937601953744888,
0.8103713989257812,
-0.42715200781822205,
1.0698509216308594,
0.5941281914710999,
-0.15120430290699005,
-0.4146903157234192,
-0.30098438262939453,
-0.11045322567224503,
-0.700725257396698,
0.4351274073123932,
-0.18521185219287872,
-0.33466804027557373,
0.16755305230617523,
-0.1415996253490448,
-1.0646336078643799,
1.268737554550171,
0.10244448482990265,
-0.5050934553146362,
0.16184023022651672,
0.15249457955360413,
0.37603217363357544,
-0.11884096264839172,
0.567240834236145,
0.23941874504089355,
0.39717763662338257,
0.3174811601638794,
-1.0692214965820312,
-0.48986726999282837,
-0.3377276659011841,
0.006190326530486345,
0.3969495892524719,
-0.7851517796516418,
1.1228587627410889,
-0.015310580842196941,
-0.29829567670822144,
-0.0004050949646625668,
0.40565353631973267,
-0.24163474142551422,
0.4825744330883026,
0.5399096012115479,
0.6844508051872253,
1.0084967613220215,
-0.260842502117157,
1.35129714012146,
-0.17351505160331726,
0.5556187033653259,
0.9965415000915527,
-0.031120872125029564,
1.052390694618225,
0.3162970244884491,
-0.2829301059246063,
0.5491762161254883,
0.4526173174381256,
0.5983922481536865,
0.4792584478855133,
-0.11358034610748291,
-0.13818317651748657,
-0.20288382470607758,
-0.10693568736314774,
-0.4763065576553345,
0.38735878467559814,
0.3760155141353607,
0.1048799604177475,
-0.10162629932165146,
-0.23560486733913422,
0.2331598401069641,
0.00881998147815466,
-0.39985617995262146,
0.678726077079773,
-0.24958999454975128,
-0.44346100091934204,
0.7073656320571899,
-0.2338217794895172,
0.8361655473709106,
-0.6779423952102661,
0.29947787523269653,
-0.4511723816394806,
0.10980185866355896,
-0.39658334851264954,
-0.662372350692749,
0.34712910652160645,
-0.23738841712474823,
-0.13738159835338593,
-0.4441401958465576,
0.3167332112789154,
-0.5671284794807434,
-0.6630211472511292,
0.399179071187973,
0.2957165837287903,
0.13129310309886932,
0.06368878483772278,
-0.6284443140029907,
0.30822187662124634,
-0.35181647539138794,
-0.3679739534854889,
0.22680744528770447,
0.4212782382965088,
-0.09556396305561066,
0.5501298904418945,
0.8102107048034668,
-0.049961309880018234,
0.6668591499328613,
-0.06832113116979599,
0.6937763094902039,
-0.5947631001472473,
-0.7606264352798462,
-0.2788655757904053,
0.28050529956817627,
-0.17520637810230255,
-0.23187941312789917,
0.5395693182945251,
0.9478634595870972,
0.9685360789299011,
0.18207009136676788,
0.4576238691806793,
-0.41220030188560486,
0.28987783193588257,
-0.5695316791534424,
0.6845391392707825,
-0.5752075910568237,
0.021994728595018387,
-0.42667320370674133,
-1.2339476346969604,
0.1007256954908371,
0.5405952334403992,
-0.11704815924167633,
0.019043629989027977,
1.3324753046035767,
0.7140263915061951,
-0.2852589190006256,
0.3031923174858093,
0.3831660747528076,
0.5001193284988403,
0.20044159889221191,
0.32721489667892456,
0.8164485692977905,
-0.35026291012763977,
0.5520367622375488,
-0.6074433326721191,
-0.1904602348804474,
-0.07101567089557648,
-0.8882851600646973,
-0.734186589717865,
-1.0189274549484253,
-0.11822456866502762,
-0.2615382671356201,
0.1340806484222412,
0.596929669380188,
1.0953186750411987,
-0.9054084420204163,
-0.4707700312137604,
0.2796468436717987,
0.15428777039051056,
-0.3326655328273773,
-0.24542243778705597,
0.536468505859375,
-0.6789034605026245,
-0.9760494828224182,
0.31509992480278015,
0.32691100239753723,
-0.6927708983421326,
-0.32233911752700806,
-0.13821527361869812,
-0.46723535656929016,
-0.11605687439441681,
0.8467112183570862,
-0.10252197831869125,
-0.43139249086380005,
-0.34312599897384644,
0.11348498612642288,
-0.05262156203389168,
0.04188711568713188,
1.2543630599975586,
-0.6762753129005432,
0.6062698364257812,
0.9873866438865662,
0.6961722373962402,
1.0597646236419678,
-0.0552067756652832,
0.07892370223999023,
-0.5026671290397644,
0.28607892990112305,
0.3555002510547638,
0.33029913902282715,
0.27880120277404785,
-0.4612022936344147,
0.46681660413742065,
0.3613300025463104,
-0.7722502946853638,
-0.49126848578453064,
0.10375934094190598,
-1.2555090188980103,
-0.001501354738138616,
1.1524014472961426,
0.10414613038301468,
0.015994461253285408,
-0.5696310997009277,
0.10596710443496704,
-0.24444365501403809,
-0.454802930355072,
0.6955917477607727,
0.8334999680519104,
0.22952385246753693,
-0.24344490468502045,
-0.6231662631034851,
0.4492037892341614,
0.3438621163368225,
-0.33967405557632446,
-0.11837535351514816,
0.35072413086891174,
0.21075043082237244,
0.242967426776886,
0.6694050431251526,
-0.20062874257564545,
0.18788105249404907,
-0.17210423946380615,
-0.20781975984573364,
0.04182892292737961,
-0.3033027648925781,
-0.14487290382385254,
0.3508758842945099,
-0.33430683612823486,
0.0027958748396486044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00972v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00972v1
|
CACTUS: Chemistry Agent Connecting Tool-Usage to Science
| 2024-05-02T03:20:08 | 2024-05-02T03:20:08 |
Andrew D. McNaughton, Gautham Ramalaxmi, Agustin Kruel, Carter R. Knutson, Rohith A. Varikoti, Neeraj Kumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, physics.chem-ph, q-bio.QM
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable potential in various
domains, but they often lack the ability to access and reason over
domain-specific knowledge and tools. In this paper, we introduced CACTUS
(Chemistry Agent Connecting Tool-Usage to Science), an LLM-based agent that
integrates cheminformatics tools to enable advanced reasoning and
problem-solving in chemistry and molecular discovery. We evaluate the
performance of CACTUS using a diverse set of open-source LLMs, including
Gemma-7b, Falcon-7b, MPT-7b, Llama2-7b, and Mistral-7b, on a benchmark of
thousands of chemistry questions. Our results demonstrate that CACTUS
significantly outperforms baseline LLMs, with the Gemma-7b and Mistral-7b
models achieving the highest accuracy regardless of the prompting strategy
used. Moreover, we explore the impact of domain-specific prompting and hardware
configurations on model performance, highlighting the importance of prompt
engineering and the potential for deploying smaller models on consumer-grade
hardware without significant loss in accuracy. By combining the cognitive
capabilities of open-source LLMs with domain-specific tools, CACTUS can assist
researchers in tasks such as molecular property prediction, similarity
searching, and drug-likeness assessment. Furthermore, CACTUS represents a
significant milestone in the field of cheminformatics, offering an adaptable
tool for researchers engaged in chemistry and molecular discovery. By
integrating the strengths of open-source LLMs with domain-specific tools,
CACTUS has the potential to accelerate scientific advancement and unlock new
frontiers in the exploration of novel, effective, and safe therapeutic
candidates, catalysts, and materials. Moreover, CACTUS's ability to integrate
with automated experimentation platforms and make data-driven decisions in real
time opens up new possibilities for autonomous discovery.
|
[
-0.005283778999000788,
-0.7104465961456299,
1.1700741052627563,
0.43614134192466736,
0.08076998591423035,
0.32738396525382996,
-0.42810913920402527,
-0.46007657051086426,
0.32729998230934143,
0.23726969957351685,
-0.7263948917388916,
-0.8676209449768066,
-0.41707345843315125,
0.34486159682273865,
-0.22242417931556702,
0.5178965926170349,
-0.003265161532908678,
0.16675503551959991,
-0.5705130696296692,
0.24739192426204681,
-0.22394606471061707,
-0.11826580762863159,
-0.42919567227363586,
-0.29703620076179504,
0.8180445432662964,
0.29518112540245056,
0.9608013033866882,
0.8125865459442139,
0.5610767006874084,
0.3204357922077179,
-0.09209097176790237,
0.15886865556240082,
-0.2643464505672455,
0.08431790769100189,
-0.5411686301231384,
-0.7591926455497742,
-0.5322906374931335,
0.14463813602924347,
0.29750388860702515,
0.7978265285491943,
0.03971412405371666,
0.09482385963201523,
-0.21453481912612915,
0.20085595548152924,
-0.5605646371841431,
0.4542980492115021,
-0.6915491223335266,
0.0768868550658226,
-0.2316790521144867,
-0.12568718194961548,
-0.4259272813796997,
-0.3114369511604309,
0.03701309859752655,
-1.141592264175415,
0.11767122894525528,
-0.1589912623167038,
0.4671159088611603,
0.4664478898048401,
-0.24276818335056305,
-0.35797879099845886,
-0.501447856426239,
0.7884823679924011,
-0.5055344104766846,
0.24446572363376617,
0.0026420399080961943,
0.40506190061569214,
-0.7967880964279175,
-0.9960154294967651,
-0.6973668932914734,
-0.6272009611129761,
0.09524215757846832,
0.18760913610458374,
0.05104741081595421,
-0.025765109807252884,
0.0702379122376442,
0.30672064423561096,
-0.5293041467666626,
0.08979517221450806,
-0.12021402269601822,
-0.5008513331413269,
0.22250506281852722,
0.3278201222419739,
0.46558016538619995,
0.27298253774642944,
-0.2626720070838928,
-0.17975206673145294,
-0.7466923594474792,
0.20244671404361725,
-0.05178237333893776,
0.6123859882354736,
0.26159995794296265,
0.6711416244506836,
-0.14462634921073914,
0.24028995633125305,
-0.15997883677482605,
0.02702748216688633,
-0.09723737090826035,
-0.20797288417816162,
-0.18519145250320435,
0.2934345602989197,
0.8857126235961914,
-0.14279887080192566,
-0.06902807205915451,
-0.040822647511959076,
0.23921984434127808,
0.4465537369251251,
-0.019844161346554756,
-0.8192654252052307,
-0.5315781831741333,
0.6279533505439758,
0.028407640755176544,
-0.19111405313014984,
0.012206613086163998,
-0.5825718641281128,
-0.5929321050643921,
-0.07954633235931396,
0.3771975040435791,
-0.24960242211818695,
-0.20253215730190277,
-0.0952957347035408,
-0.33144789934158325,
-0.024905603379011154,
0.7467371225357056,
-0.6682605147361755,
0.4815320372581482,
0.7600840330123901,
1.0526340007781982,
-0.5523779392242432,
-0.4453967809677124,
-0.6844936013221741,
0.1737762838602066,
-0.4947653114795685,
0.8760032653808594,
-0.8430658578872681,
-0.6230781078338623,
-0.2153022438287735,
0.39132192730903625,
0.07996094971895218,
-0.592093288898468,
0.3227110207080841,
-0.25462019443511963,
-0.31566280126571655,
-0.8039891719818115,
-0.03189540281891823,
0.05454515665769577,
-0.045621223747730255,
-0.8114995956420898,
0.9546977877616882,
0.1386655569076538,
-0.3576286733150482,
0.4241959750652313,
-0.7728039026260376,
-0.18780668079853058,
0.3552496135234833,
-0.09019600600004196,
-0.2286137491464615,
-0.2727475166320801,
0.0513027124106884,
0.3127935826778412,
-0.5427267551422119,
0.20817771553993225,
-0.5332852005958557,
-0.432007759809494,
0.4966249167919159,
0.14136725664138794,
0.7181130647659302,
0.3766079246997833,
-0.17424960434436798,
0.49505141377449036,
-0.5950993299484253,
-0.1382521390914917,
0.16627025604248047,
-0.2397966831922531,
-0.05065373331308365,
-0.14001762866973877,
-0.07160957902669907,
0.2195972502231598,
0.289201945066452,
-0.7948548793792725,
0.4060194790363312,
-0.12352703511714935,
0.6550959348678589,
0.5935551524162292,
-0.2609010636806488,
0.24466517567634583,
-0.06517516076564789,
0.30378246307373047,
0.19410307705402374,
0.17942482233047485,
-0.17541223764419556,
-0.6402491331100464,
-0.5943314433097839,
-0.3809225857257843,
0.1854543834924698,
0.4201629161834717,
-0.46982908248901367,
0.0025399355217814445,
-0.09278912097215652,
-0.9294944405555725,
-0.5464017391204834,
0.4125630557537079,
0.09128385037183762,
0.37684541940689087,
0.511486291885376,
-0.3325693905353546,
0.02081671543419361,
-0.6199846863746643,
-0.28795820474624634,
-0.29617613554000854,
0.1795557737350464,
0.42164647579193115,
0.5649798512458801,
-0.46006783843040466,
0.9646515846252441,
-0.6472368240356445,
-0.17636924982070923,
-0.17531011998653412,
-0.22636862099170685,
0.32349497079849243,
0.1871451884508133,
0.19916683435440063,
-0.606529951095581,
-0.31760185956954956,
0.3324528932571411,
-0.6625577211380005,
-0.33445969223976135,
0.1130293607711792,
-0.3298579156398773,
0.07730607688426971,
0.24485647678375244,
-0.9048161506652832,
0.20437058806419373,
0.23020771145820618,
-0.19683583080768585,
0.49050188064575195,
-0.21182025969028473,
0.09709308296442032,
-0.7603722810745239,
0.2875831723213196,
0.16097861528396606,
-0.019523276016116142,
-0.6982511878013611,
-0.06013895571231842,
0.2778136432170868,
-0.1761990338563919,
-1.0525387525558472,
0.36150163412094116,
-0.3798684775829315,
-0.14245487749576569,
-0.32202523946762085,
-0.04626478627324104,
0.09504581242799759,
0.32362762093544006,
0.4177538752555847,
0.9665754437446594,
0.6270710825920105,
-0.6191366910934448,
0.5433050394058228,
0.0010466588428243995,
0.034677740186452866,
0.13812892138957977,
-0.7115644812583923,
0.03699095919728279,
0.26527124643325806,
0.3514840006828308,
-0.8477144241333008,
-0.45759493112564087,
0.27036187052726746,
-0.16068974137306213,
-0.04822445288300514,
0.06701861321926117,
-0.562421977519989,
-0.3064245581626892,
-0.3000139594078064,
0.41426408290863037,
0.282230406999588,
-0.7495725750923157,
0.7121668457984924,
0.12709538638591766,
-0.053481198847293854,
-0.45849132537841797,
-0.44556987285614014,
0.20665785670280457,
-0.13754107058048248,
-0.7399656772613525,
0.40192654728889465,
-0.28042715787887573,
-0.3260510563850403,
-0.054719243198633194,
-0.21951861679553986,
0.1301543265581131,
0.0644480511546135,
0.4246928095817566,
0.34585949778556824,
-0.06529214233160019,
0.1594570130109787,
0.2208767682313919,
-0.01962835155427456,
0.3242742717266083,
-0.32550355792045593,
0.4595440626144409,
-0.15023569762706757,
-0.31140637397766113,
-0.2903400957584381,
-0.012317121960222721,
0.8795033693313599,
-0.2983209192752838,
0.6725094318389893,
0.32074037194252014,
-0.26812854409217834,
-0.537087082862854,
-0.09024074673652649,
-0.07557972520589828,
-0.544002115726471,
0.05334126949310303,
-0.36212602257728577,
-0.6649041771888733,
0.49252253770828247,
-0.5108996033668518,
-0.2233068346977234,
0.4911470413208008,
0.7453452348709106,
0.2899436354637146,
0.6908105611801147,
0.3240495026111603,
-0.016114898025989532,
0.06082800030708313,
-0.1009989008307457,
0.044824667274951935,
-0.4849223494529724,
-0.6319698691368103,
-0.5221444368362427,
0.23793599009513855,
-0.16961708664894104,
-0.6223311424255371,
0.5431997776031494,
-0.45765140652656555,
-0.18689922988414764,
0.5534307956695557,
-0.6832640171051025,
0.5096994638442993,
0.4704112410545349,
0.014867247082293034,
0.5530341863632202,
-0.3317373991012573,
-0.3470567464828491,
0.3324970602989197,
-0.5243704915046692,
-0.40854257345199585,
0.8109772801399231,
0.3609342575073242,
1.031505823135376,
0.17928332090377808,
0.19491168856620789,
0.38549554347991943,
0.17058804631233215,
-0.8548804521560669,
0.7867403030395508,
0.31777679920196533,
-0.3061646521091461,
-0.1871195137500763,
-0.28613218665122986,
-0.8221685886383057,
0.16488249599933624,
-0.17580761015415192,
-0.4549846649169922,
0.19194522500038147,
-0.05410114675760269,
-0.24526940286159515,
0.08466856926679611,
-0.5721552968025208,
0.7925016283988953,
-0.21132442355155945,
-0.7356997132301331,
-0.07551469653844833,
-0.5408698916435242,
0.40549758076667786,
-0.2651716470718384,
0.15402017533779144,
-0.26790598034858704,
-0.1253664493560791,
0.3476914167404175,
-0.7263271808624268,
0.6478977799415588,
0.2378855049610138,
-0.37051665782928467,
0.4883095622062683,
0.44986647367477417,
0.32400602102279663,
0.03928886353969574,
-0.02889658510684967,
0.27760857343673706,
0.32188865542411804,
-0.2913338243961334,
-0.6555580496788025,
1.3021187782287598,
-0.9585701823234558,
-0.8693760633468628,
-0.7079263925552368,
-0.6759178638458252,
0.0979885458946228,
0.24961771070957184,
-0.1343022584915161,
0.07751961052417755,
-0.18355721235275269,
-0.2468571811914444,
0.4749654531478882,
-0.3316912055015564,
0.3425145149230957,
0.6168258786201477,
-0.15000002086162567,
-0.10132617503404617,
1.0682775974273682,
-0.027818426489830017,
0.3794390559196472,
0.39767688512802124,
0.1028115302324295,
-0.2418031096458435,
-0.2438821643590927,
-0.37903526425361633,
0.29299452900886536,
-0.844572126865387,
-0.002707116771489382,
-0.6589746475219727,
0.071977399289608,
-0.5461943745613098,
-0.07046685367822647,
-0.33441537618637085,
-0.4176757037639618,
-0.37703758478164673,
-0.017082514241337776,
0.5073990225791931,
0.6242641806602478,
0.1318923681974411,
0.13599395751953125,
-0.5102887749671936,
0.1369376927614212,
0.17245960235595703,
0.20930925011634827,
-0.2441037893295288,
0.24096369743347168,
-0.18900421261787415,
-0.05199044197797775,
-0.4714498221874237,
-0.9792290925979614,
0.364727258682251,
0.08765064924955368,
0.535502552986145,
0.23958677053451538,
-0.07697397470474243,
0.4626024067401886,
-0.15144824981689453,
0.9964718222618103,
-0.22229154407978058,
-1.0594381093978882,
0.9000776410102844,
-0.5365495681762695,
0.20445072650909424,
0.2374885082244873,
0.5607813000679016,
-0.24312032759189606,
-0.3719142973423004,
-0.1990574300289154,
-0.557104229927063,
0.7132437825202942,
0.4578459560871124,
-0.5363824963569641,
-0.12318260967731476,
0.37108680605888367,
0.12820950150489807,
0.05503331124782562,
-0.5133715271949768,
-0.11636951565742493,
-0.5044820308685303,
-0.11122587323188782,
-0.03966021537780762,
0.5199753642082214,
-0.026423301547765732,
-0.19401013851165771,
0.8991544842720032,
-0.39995577931404114,
0.020434405654668808,
0.41067031025886536,
-0.3279707431793213,
-0.239698588848114,
0.22309263050556183,
0.28004077076911926,
0.3927742838859558,
-0.31203916668891907,
0.23549224436283112,
0.288524866104126,
-0.7564056515693665,
0.06500022113323212,
0.06368385255336761,
0.359943151473999,
-0.3086386024951935,
0.094110868871212,
0.08026521652936935,
-0.26955798268318176,
-1.1124926805496216,
0.2777291238307953,
-0.025543300434947014,
0.015672629699110985,
-0.14594510197639465,
0.664208710193634,
0.16264505684375763,
0.23352336883544922,
0.11923898756504059,
-0.026090947911143303,
0.3061075806617737,
-0.9712446331977844,
-0.22443079948425293,
0.6074333786964417,
-0.48156076669692993,
-0.30042070150375366,
0.8749516010284424,
-0.054585978388786316,
-0.1775027960538864,
0.40954047441482544,
0.18313272297382355,
-0.31326380372047424,
0.925645649433136,
0.5497900247573853,
0.45507484674453735,
-0.26606133580207825,
0.2187803089618683,
0.10968382656574249,
0.16093198955059052,
0.026161830872297287,
0.08543252944946289,
-0.3387031853199005,
-0.42462432384490967,
-0.05838267505168915,
-0.3846270442008972,
-0.8733192682266235,
-0.19046998023986816,
-0.10468664765357971,
0.5189760327339172,
-0.7672936916351318,
-0.20008370280265808,
0.3680339455604553,
0.3143153190612793,
-0.5122864842414856,
0.0767725482583046,
-0.24562287330627441,
1.2061474323272705,
-0.8062073588371277,
0.9176710844039917,
0.7733452320098877,
-0.5547921657562256,
-0.6895684003829956,
-0.41951799392700195,
0.40443772077560425,
-0.622687816619873,
0.6001226305961609,
0.1818358451128006,
-0.4109291732311249,
-0.24047696590423584,
-0.8171605467796326,
-0.912834107875824,
1.6496394872665405,
0.29436153173446655,
-0.24376563727855682,
0.4663921594619751,
0.4246402978897095,
0.6702413558959961,
-0.5869715213775635,
0.6258319020271301,
0.7872339487075806,
0.5456644892692566,
0.6227883100509644,
-0.8070260882377625,
0.4787618815898895,
-0.6693760752677917,
-0.21323224902153015,
0.2082720249891281,
-0.882951557636261,
0.9360982179641724,
-0.34149637818336487,
-0.24067965149879456,
0.3982556164264679,
0.5945273637771606,
0.4667988419532776,
0.5575987696647644,
0.17113186419010162,
0.283089816570282,
0.8622498512268066,
-0.2934040129184723,
0.9449521899223328,
-0.2971177399158478,
-0.02820204198360443,
0.4767586290836334,
-0.7139742374420166,
0.6047930121421814,
0.30769726634025574,
-0.29203346371650696,
0.6901537179946899,
0.7133875489234924,
-0.2226671576499939,
0.3135509788990021,
0.3267016112804413,
-0.5417896509170532,
-0.40942618250846863,
-0.5283218622207642,
-0.2507452666759491,
-0.057059261947870255,
0.7407934069633484,
-0.23274581134319305,
0.032885801047086716,
-0.3749174177646637,
0.018678758293390274,
-0.007965783588588238,
-0.25527384877204895,
0.522549569606781,
0.0960463359951973,
-0.8718334436416626,
0.1288352757692337,
-0.03703603520989418,
0.16670159995555878,
-0.690567672252655,
-0.2824205756187439,
0.031772367656230927,
0.16897952556610107,
-0.3844161033630371,
-0.8777247667312622,
-0.1494826078414917,
-0.23341065645217896,
0.0637216791510582,
0.34618380665779114,
0.8710134029388428,
-0.26709187030792236,
-0.2595592141151428,
0.34261468052864075,
0.33782243728637695,
0.3997432589530945,
-0.044660281389951706,
-0.23031024634838104,
0.30104145407676697,
-0.4456920623779297,
0.23988968133926392,
0.3345504105091095,
0.2946223318576813,
-0.2835870385169983,
0.9894386529922485,
1.1474363803863525,
0.07134194672107697,
-0.295890748500824,
-0.05805831402540207,
1.309579610824585,
-0.8060731291770935,
-0.17831559479236603,
-0.8728055357933044,
0.21672764420509338,
0.23906309902668,
0.01887836493551731,
0.7909850478172302,
0.569800853729248,
0.47368323802948,
-0.05092109739780426,
0.7735403180122375,
0.4474450647830963,
0.13922767341136932,
-0.3224543631076813,
0.6234246492385864,
-0.3291809558868408,
0.6059072613716125,
-0.49723508954048157,
-1.1324505805969238,
-0.30760636925697327,
0.17034371197223663,
-0.19745774567127228,
-0.07931278645992279,
0.7411472797393799,
1.0826386213302612,
-0.060168955475091934,
0.29265066981315613,
0.0005281264893710613,
0.39323410391807556,
0.7983192801475525,
0.7817199230194092,
0.9479488730430603,
0.13880065083503723,
0.39377593994140625,
-0.03714662790298462,
-0.36727190017700195,
0.0015619591576978564,
-0.7917751669883728,
-1.1315089464187622,
-0.3522084355354309,
-0.14619486033916473,
-0.40475887060165405,
-0.03919109329581261,
1.364015817642212,
0.2870403230190277,
-0.4936182498931885,
-0.33300408720970154,
-0.22087211906909943,
0.11631395667791367,
-0.1054876297712326,
-0.17584680020809174,
0.3618246018886566,
-0.2337481677532196,
-0.683285653591156,
0.7171943187713623,
0.551559567451477,
-0.0752348080277443,
-0.4340357780456543,
-0.21389859914779663,
0.06736671924591064,
0.32079246640205383,
0.5269981622695923,
0.5254366993904114,
-0.8675431609153748,
0.07659836858510971,
0.38137108087539673,
-0.004618101753294468,
0.05589713528752327,
0.8348120450973511,
-1.1502259969711304,
0.4665355086326599,
0.31100156903266907,
0.3916783332824707,
0.4098648130893707,
-0.18354572355747223,
0.4685901403427124,
-0.0017084017163142562,
-0.28507593274116516,
-0.06415864825248718,
0.4244537353515625,
0.24462050199508667,
-0.6078864336013794,
0.4688436686992645,
0.27037885785102844,
-0.5521898865699768,
-0.5996507406234741,
0.09928817301988602,
-1.5092233419418335,
-0.4634152948856354,
1.1886239051818848,
-0.0034577299375087023,
-0.613806962966919,
-0.15870939195156097,
-0.5379162430763245,
0.1879301816225052,
-0.7780004739761353,
0.5297621488571167,
0.5571614503860474,
-0.2811620831489563,
0.11754308640956879,
-0.10606754571199417,
0.48192256689071655,
0.23469235002994537,
-1.003767490386963,
-0.0058773416094481945,
0.42041146755218506,
0.3539941906929016,
0.40185898542404175,
0.37110134959220886,
-0.09296264499425888,
0.5463383197784424,
-0.20792025327682495,
-0.1720590889453888,
-0.46538400650024414,
-0.6299800872802734,
-0.12076537311077118,
0.1262660175561905,
0.19617556035518646,
0.3290966749191284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00970v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00970v1
|
How Can I Get It Right? Using GPT to Rephrase Incorrect Trainee Responses
| 2024-05-02T03:18:03 | 2024-05-02T03:18:03 |
Jionghao Lin, Zifei Han, Danielle R. Thomas, Ashish Gurung, Shivang Gupta, Vincent Aleven, Kenneth R. Koedinger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
One-on-one tutoring is widely acknowledged as an effective instructional
method, conditioned on qualified tutors. However, the high demand for qualified
tutors remains a challenge, often necessitating the training of novice tutors
(i.e., trainees) to ensure effective tutoring. Research suggests that providing
timely explanatory feedback can facilitate the training process for trainees.
However, it presents challenges due to the time-consuming nature of assessing
trainee performance by human experts. Inspired by the recent advancements of
large language models (LLMs), our study employed the GPT-4 model to build an
explanatory feedback system. This system identifies trainees' responses in
binary form (i.e., correct/incorrect) and automatically provides template-based
feedback with responses appropriately rephrased by the GPT-4 model. We
conducted our study on 410 responses from trainees across three training
lessons: Giving Effective Praise, Reacting to Errors, and Determining What
Students Know. Our findings indicate that: 1) using a few-shot approach, the
GPT-4 model effectively identifies correct/incorrect trainees' responses from
three training lessons with an average F1 score of 0.84 and an AUC score of
0.85; and 2) using the few-shot approach, the GPT-4 model adeptly rephrases
incorrect trainees' responses into desired responses, achieving performance
comparable to that of human experts.
|
[
-0.17909422516822815,
-0.8056483864784241,
0.45664137601852417,
0.32131093740463257,
-0.25572216510772705,
0.11547458916902542,
-0.10475127398967743,
-0.2587047517299652,
0.09261836856603622,
0.0066966949962079525,
-0.3734915554523468,
-0.24559536576271057,
-0.5731547474861145,
0.3159148693084717,
-0.30648744106292725,
1.270789384841919,
-0.19691602885723114,
0.4149661362171173,
-0.00163790222723037,
-0.1685657948255539,
-0.7863225340843201,
-0.5277211666107178,
-0.8943857550621033,
-0.12664921581745148,
0.5868151783943176,
0.49837741255760193,
0.20579630136489868,
0.6303946375846863,
0.5747035145759583,
0.26234012842178345,
0.09734649211168289,
-0.38716620206832886,
-0.39012983441352844,
-0.12608644366264343,
-0.17125344276428223,
-0.6641334295272827,
-0.4839392900466919,
0.3525611162185669,
0.3998818099498749,
0.5251918435096741,
-0.283029168844223,
-0.04624751955270767,
0.2813713252544403,
0.3773234188556671,
-0.3497042953968048,
0.22987431287765503,
-0.5014002323150635,
0.24396616220474243,
-0.054148849099874496,
-0.28844839334487915,
-0.3057404160499573,
-0.659581184387207,
0.33763864636421204,
-0.7644423842430115,
0.7910880446434021,
-0.36313989758491516,
0.5248324871063232,
0.2733750343322754,
-0.11678171902894974,
-0.27673617005348206,
-0.5398017764091492,
0.46122118830680847,
-0.9894470572471619,
0.10959377139806747,
0.4364157021045685,
0.6747603416442871,
0.242076113820076,
-0.6458447575569153,
-0.5073375105857849,
-0.27846720814704895,
-0.13561126589775085,
0.4881557822227478,
0.5069659948348999,
-0.002310109091922641,
0.5132750272750854,
0.05016133561730385,
-0.49927473068237305,
0.008108477108180523,
-0.36098751425743103,
-0.11445264518260956,
0.3946840465068817,
0.1368408203125,
-0.07025710493326187,
0.01427260972559452,
-0.2673804759979248,
0.086496502161026,
-0.7359994649887085,
0.0954892709851265,
0.6757891178131104,
0.5098274946212769,
0.05301612988114357,
0.5716485381126404,
-0.04187966138124466,
0.5830428004264832,
0.4037749767303467,
-0.11800862848758698,
-0.06367798149585724,
-0.49752798676490784,
0.07463812083005905,
-0.017830384895205498,
0.5578190684318542,
0.311288446187973,
0.24855566024780273,
-0.3585721254348755,
-0.3493230640888214,
-0.07085932791233063,
0.411502867937088,
-0.6004120111465454,
-0.3833123445510864,
-0.04649949073791504,
0.10938866436481476,
-0.27188965678215027,
-0.0059578814543783665,
-0.8452504277229309,
-0.1275312453508377,
-0.40318891406059265,
0.6475188732147217,
-0.39167824387550354,
-0.23362736403942108,
-0.0995110422372818,
-0.2400706559419632,
0.14498460292816162,
0.6063175201416016,
-0.903947114944458,
0.3187103271484375,
0.4792119264602661,
0.7604662775993347,
0.010208717547357082,
-0.3892599642276764,
-0.5957557559013367,
0.1018330305814743,
-0.2850375473499298,
0.7529804110527039,
-0.37300243973731995,
-0.4597773849964142,
-0.05537141114473343,
-0.2406441569328308,
-0.2607068717479706,
-0.32733550667762756,
0.2445708066225052,
-0.539950430393219,
0.7284563779830933,
-0.4538419246673584,
-0.8327218890190125,
0.1617584377527237,
0.5657966136932373,
-0.5374548435211182,
0.8201912045478821,
0.5681146383285522,
-0.9509599208831787,
0.24932171404361725,
-0.6302900314331055,
-0.13069301843643188,
0.14295785129070282,
-0.47630470991134644,
-0.3557921051979065,
-0.09812048077583313,
0.31110143661499023,
0.19270355999469757,
0.10286460071802139,
0.2430582493543625,
-0.004315652884542942,
-0.5345764756202698,
0.17476479709148407,
-0.48569488525390625,
0.32648003101348877,
-0.20885778963565826,
-0.6306521892547607,
-0.11783293634653091,
-0.5062586069107056,
0.32001709938049316,
-0.08569518476724625,
-0.5670269727706909,
0.18198657035827637,
-0.5845062732696533,
-0.2532542943954468,
0.1857771873474121,
0.06532693654298782,
-0.5378077626228333,
0.55326247215271,
-0.3206656277179718,
0.23169897496700287,
0.9334089159965515,
0.12186570465564728,
0.24759669601917267,
-0.336790531873703,
0.8460866212844849,
-0.08762476593255997,
-0.0060392399318516254,
-0.27443727850914,
-0.384269118309021,
-0.5401087403297424,
-0.08741511404514313,
0.4281283915042877,
0.3784281313419342,
-0.8977068066596985,
0.02568475529551506,
-0.16637270152568817,
-0.41047191619873047,
-0.5561878085136414,
0.22121156752109528,
0.5477653741836548,
0.8442240953445435,
0.49787864089012146,
-0.31170177459716797,
-0.499170184135437,
-0.5812591314315796,
-0.6444655656814575,
-0.43666893243789673,
0.04300820827484131,
-0.06589800119400024,
0.5680370926856995,
0.1694008708000183,
1.0756361484527588,
-0.45661279559135437,
-0.22643549740314484,
-0.24377410113811493,
0.44317665696144104,
0.047533027827739716,
0.48607757687568665,
0.5307961702346802,
-0.45523130893707275,
-0.7280860543251038,
-0.1725049465894699,
-0.5210943818092346,
-0.005964238196611404,
-0.09139059484004974,
0.2369396984577179,
0.07096623629331589,
0.1645141839981079,
-0.37847405672073364,
0.43421635031700134,
0.0019270690390840173,
-0.07648307830095291,
0.973081648349762,
-0.08861339092254639,
0.24500969052314758,
-0.616736114025116,
0.06959418207406998,
-0.08353044837713242,
-0.4371260106563568,
-0.24530009925365448,
-0.08632028102874756,
0.009288407862186432,
0.15405918657779694,
-0.32558539509773254,
0.3512255847454071,
-0.15675529837608337,
0.28344208002090454,
-0.15940289199352264,
-0.108726866543293,
-0.15637992322444916,
0.8260935544967651,
-0.16887517273426056,
0.8496184349060059,
0.28008484840393066,
-0.2768198549747467,
0.5323070883750916,
0.24350938200950623,
-0.1491495668888092,
0.9059165716171265,
-0.9068943858146667,
0.3423512279987335,
-0.001741184969432652,
0.28996580839157104,
-1.1211531162261963,
-0.5122895240783691,
0.44491878151893616,
-0.4410240650177002,
0.5196312069892883,
-0.48638197779655457,
-0.21059775352478027,
-0.425570011138916,
-0.27110153436660767,
0.34891003370285034,
0.11277490109205246,
-0.5435065627098083,
0.466793954372406,
-0.1462038904428482,
-0.6476633548736572,
-0.7205283045768738,
-0.3659915030002594,
0.000006200401458045235,
-0.07654649019241333,
-0.19093649089336395,
0.15218378603458405,
-0.2750304639339447,
0.3082481920719147,
-0.02685385011136532,
-0.31086331605911255,
-0.4004059135913849,
-0.12698052823543549,
0.06865321844816208,
0.24314112961292267,
-0.1500374674797058,
-0.009819526225328445,
-0.25073421001434326,
-0.26795703172683716,
0.15293529629707336,
-0.019297949969768524,
0.20021744072437286,
-0.2648497521877289,
-0.5826048851013184,
-0.5901309847831726,
0.22759805619716644,
0.6278769373893738,
0.16885247826576233,
0.27644070982933044,
0.5130593776702881,
-0.053789880126714706,
0.09494513273239136,
-0.5540707111358643,
-0.430875301361084,
-0.44172951579093933,
0.49479228258132935,
-0.366311252117157,
-0.5601220726966858,
0.2844119071960449,
0.27221256494522095,
0.252859890460968,
0.04245258867740631,
0.30866125226020813,
-0.28735971450805664,
1.252946376800537,
0.6164280772209167,
-0.0633755773305893,
0.5022944211959839,
-0.3963969647884369,
0.16373127698898315,
-0.6048756241798401,
-0.2855307459831238,
-0.48473653197288513,
-0.10664436966180801,
-0.30002886056900024,
-0.022501422092318535,
0.33148595690727234,
0.10404463857412338,
-0.3445737659931183,
0.1747649908065796,
-0.39648598432540894,
0.6242817640304565,
0.6191312670707703,
0.2752562165260315,
0.19099579751491547,
-0.06070653349161148,
-0.25498154759407043,
-0.22037391364574432,
-0.7412055134773254,
-0.639847457408905,
1.0090177059173584,
0.4302796721458435,
0.9298180937767029,
0.19108597934246063,
0.6372345685958862,
-0.1359386146068573,
0.9519234299659729,
-0.7157391905784607,
0.4364716410636902,
0.285668283700943,
-0.8174771666526794,
-0.3136638402938843,
-0.49818041920661926,
-0.5915998220443726,
0.11270735412836075,
0.1952425241470337,
-0.29852235317230225,
-0.4164326786994934,
0.3236415386199951,
-0.5289008617401123,
0.19713148474693298,
-0.7644622325897217,
0.9101874232292175,
-0.4861328601837158,
-0.5419758558273315,
0.11615772545337677,
-0.860798716545105,
0.07833869010210037,
-0.21523623168468475,
-0.12088440358638763,
0.06977502256631851,
0.08860587328672409,
0.8880852460861206,
-0.755429744720459,
1.0684959888458252,
-0.5688765048980713,
-0.03440530598163605,
0.25777891278266907,
-0.10941921919584274,
0.47530242800712585,
0.032488733530044556,
0.04875144734978676,
-0.4256450831890106,
0.2605682611465454,
-0.6238634586334229,
-1.100322961807251,
0.41024377942085266,
-0.9293602705001831,
-0.7564196586608887,
-0.34027987718582153,
-0.15165334939956665,
-0.46612510085105896,
-0.02522057667374611,
0.6460427641868591,
0.6309528946876526,
-0.1320955604314804,
-0.3534138798713684,
0.3393677771091461,
0.199055016040802,
0.22390146553516388,
0.8517260551452637,
-0.21281437575817108,
-0.39770764112472534,
0.9165327548980713,
0.42181527614593506,
0.19299335777759552,
0.018985524773597717,
0.13277225196361542,
-0.5717625021934509,
-0.457528680562973,
-0.6443141102790833,
0.43476590514183044,
-0.8771005868911743,
-0.1708844155073166,
-0.4168359637260437,
-0.004829069599509239,
-0.6622146368026733,
-0.08249257504940033,
-0.28004708886146545,
-0.5264255404472351,
-0.11416595429182053,
-0.3224727511405945,
0.024867866188287735,
1.0816595554351807,
-0.07420385628938675,
0.617534875869751,
-0.6488016247749329,
0.11509255319833755,
0.6910385489463806,
0.5788677930831909,
-0.06989898532629013,
-0.7077565789222717,
-0.31811708211898804,
0.1406424641609192,
-0.5993527173995972,
-1.048404574394226,
0.2675137221813202,
0.06494352966547012,
0.5452961325645447,
0.2354234755039215,
-0.28291669487953186,
0.8302885293960571,
-0.5561777353286743,
0.8547462224960327,
0.3545345664024353,
-0.7460823655128479,
0.5324934720993042,
-0.23614433407783508,
0.11716960370540619,
0.6458090543746948,
0.41421830654144287,
-0.5073797106742859,
-0.5876713395118713,
-0.7136634588241577,
-0.7355016469955444,
0.6859689354896545,
0.022464117035269737,
0.062108445912599564,
0.012779233045876026,
0.6000472903251648,
0.39843520522117615,
0.29683905839920044,
-0.6941052079200745,
-0.11049073934555054,
-0.5980862975120544,
-0.3783665597438812,
0.08183222264051437,
-0.06955750286579132,
-0.32642918825149536,
-0.21161967515945435,
0.8074058294296265,
-0.36268147826194763,
0.5162636637687683,
0.08585283905267715,
-0.02060696668922901,
-0.24973326921463013,
0.4148581326007843,
0.4436804950237274,
0.7772904634475708,
-0.252513587474823,
0.10568345338106155,
0.14320659637451172,
-0.45042479038238525,
0.44324755668640137,
0.028999006375670433,
0.18839900195598602,
0.41156065464019775,
0.5093937516212463,
0.4919610619544983,
0.2443125993013382,
-0.16764457523822784,
0.9554682374000549,
-0.34086576104164124,
-0.1135699674487114,
-0.2078564167022705,
0.20170393586158752,
-0.12224216759204865,
-0.10256160795688629,
0.4044894576072693,
0.2360297590494156,
-0.2928225100040436,
-0.2168770134449005,
0.08627238869667053,
0.16348698735237122,
-0.27663397789001465,
-0.700128436088562,
0.472408652305603,
0.54477858543396,
-0.23365379869937897,
0.5702041387557983,
-0.058163054287433624,
-0.8099629282951355,
0.7207629680633545,
0.7298181056976318,
0.67921382188797,
-0.2769676446914673,
0.31807470321655273,
0.5918788909912109,
0.0544259138405323,
-0.3098955452442169,
0.1176544725894928,
-0.018453825265169144,
-0.4452064633369446,
-0.5990944504737854,
-0.10677976906299591,
-0.7727239727973938,
0.14800891280174255,
-1.0322688817977905,
0.12139655649662018,
-0.5432726144790649,
-0.2665189504623413,
-0.030987098813056946,
0.0008761473000049591,
-1.1077979803085327,
0.25526759028434753,
-0.2816350758075714,
0.9379034638404846,
-0.9049379229545593,
0.5830843448638916,
0.8920570611953735,
-0.7921022772789001,
-1.3516744375228882,
-0.12058090418577194,
0.046015337109565735,
-0.7272308468818665,
0.7539345026016235,
0.1941177099943161,
-0.04253685474395752,
0.23300683498382568,
-0.869549572467804,
-0.3932054042816162,
0.6225735545158386,
0.37691304087638855,
-0.6842249631881714,
-0.3897588551044464,
0.23899155855178833,
0.720123291015625,
-0.1396622657775879,
0.7642594575881958,
0.4701022505760193,
0.3959103226661682,
0.10773652791976929,
-0.9377615451812744,
-0.20553936064243317,
-0.2404562085866928,
-0.1540304720401764,
-0.22276116907596588,
-0.3748147487640381,
0.5563299059867859,
-0.46397408843040466,
-0.2226210981607437,
0.37526649236679077,
0.4229789674282074,
0.01381272729486227,
0.27415481209754944,
0.31757283210754395,
0.6302276253700256,
0.9089682102203369,
-0.23112240433692932,
1.1136555671691895,
-0.10355648398399353,
0.4060235917568207,
1.3678117990493774,
0.0218812245875597,
0.6315794587135315,
0.5706328749656677,
-0.4712314009666443,
0.29381829500198364,
0.6482986807823181,
0.17753282189369202,
0.6584397554397583,
0.0710887461900711,
-0.4323217272758484,
-0.08539841324090958,
0.437597393989563,
-0.595321536064148,
-0.09382910281419754,
0.13680653274059296,
-0.07580903172492981,
-0.25365060567855835,
0.08240674436092377,
-0.2694559395313263,
-0.20365512371063232,
-0.12598007917404175,
0.7802494168281555,
-0.06810080260038376,
-0.8962262272834778,
0.6373435854911804,
-0.06309419125318527,
0.5499901175498962,
-0.6096011400222778,
-0.18630129098892212,
-0.46046048402786255,
0.20481567084789276,
-0.28423556685447693,
-0.8001798987388611,
-0.08136224746704102,
0.34286999702453613,
-0.25428280234336853,
-0.1893032044172287,
-0.040344636887311935,
-0.7240612506866455,
-0.21428182721138,
-0.2292560338973999,
0.7205970287322998,
0.2624584138393402,
0.14472369849681854,
-0.7755409479141235,
-0.3547413647174835,
0.1473018079996109,
-0.03836986422538757,
0.16321678459644318,
0.3634564280509949,
0.28853723406791687,
0.5352137684822083,
0.32811644673347473,
0.041856084018945694,
0.1617514193058014,
0.20754989981651306,
0.8430248498916626,
-0.5946748852729797,
-0.45072367787361145,
-0.6481752991676331,
0.3623950481414795,
0.11413181573152542,
-0.5967593193054199,
0.7046197056770325,
0.32367220520973206,
0.8198249936103821,
-0.21288157999515533,
1.0709716081619263,
0.26289230585098267,
0.9749724864959717,
-0.2928275465965271,
0.14163553714752197,
-0.18237629532814026,
0.5416132807731628,
-0.31850358843803406,
-0.733328640460968,
-0.256634920835495,
0.8777669668197632,
-0.4783799946308136,
0.3057790696620941,
0.8080496191978455,
0.8432390689849854,
0.16212354600429535,
0.40871500968933105,
0.14210614562034607,
0.2095538079738617,
0.7156188488006592,
0.45502418279647827,
1.2317267656326294,
-0.26131555438041687,
0.5731064081192017,
-0.29546061158180237,
-0.11649990826845169,
-0.33130016922950745,
-0.7412020564079285,
-0.6783022880554199,
-0.04097753390669823,
-0.5736114978790283,
-0.5107001066207886,
0.313881516456604,
0.9810215830802917,
0.5041813254356384,
-0.7341107130050659,
0.0818910077214241,
-0.13532988727092743,
-0.056221671402454376,
-0.1769448071718216,
-0.28087615966796875,
0.35073691606521606,
-0.5668110847473145,
-0.6857712268829346,
0.17547714710235596,
-0.12920281291007996,
0.4228920340538025,
-0.15022672712802887,
-0.20846572518348694,
0.23612597584724426,
-0.327960342168808,
0.1908320039510727,
0.36907610297203064,
-0.5337365865707397,
-0.5355390310287476,
0.009731471538543701,
-0.7007395029067993,
0.19790974259376526,
0.9640440940856934,
-0.8987627029418945,
0.598506510257721,
0.1701807975769043,
0.6761972904205322,
0.3958328068256378,
0.17813219130039215,
0.7919198870658875,
-1.047520637512207,
-0.38788074254989624,
0.46738386154174805,
0.19673332571983337,
0.6746861934661865,
-0.2774604558944702,
0.7255733013153076,
0.5790459513664246,
-0.5484323501586914,
-0.5782393217086792,
-0.06831077486276627,
-0.6561410427093506,
-0.07993345707654953,
0.8295309543609619,
-0.5872556567192078,
0.0681111067533493,
-0.3623690903186798,
-0.6583706140518188,
0.41558653116226196,
-0.19933566451072693,
1.051906943321228,
0.8276975750923157,
-0.22747614979743958,
0.07920310646295547,
-0.4262353181838989,
0.41034042835235596,
0.7316547632217407,
-0.5913912057876587,
-0.08727134764194489,
0.35655614733695984,
0.7257667183876038,
0.07209671288728714,
0.8776712417602539,
0.044014692306518555,
0.6514770984649658,
-0.07395739108324051,
-0.34627464413642883,
-0.13347208499908447,
-0.3238959014415741,
-0.33690714836120605,
0.13864868879318237,
0.15034739673137665,
-0.12653474509716034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00966v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00966v1
|
Efficient Compression of Multitask Multilingual Speech Models
| 2024-05-02T03:11:59 | 2024-05-02T03:11:59 |
Thomas Palmeira Ferraz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Whisper is a multitask and multilingual speech model covering 99 languages.
It yields commendable automatic speech recognition (ASR) results in a subset of
its covered languages, but the model still underperforms on a non-negligible
number of under-represented languages, a problem exacerbated in smaller model
versions. In this work, we examine its limitations, demonstrating the presence
of speaker-related (gender, age) and model-related (resourcefulness and model
size) bias. Despite that, we show that only model-related bias are amplified by
quantization, impacting more low-resource languages and smaller models.
Searching for a better compression approach, we propose DistilWhisper, an
approach that is able to bridge the performance gap in ASR for these languages
while retaining the advantages of multitask and multilingual capabilities. Our
approach involves two key strategies: lightweight modular ASR fine-tuning of
whisper-small using language-specific experts, and knowledge distillation from
whisper-large-v2. This dual approach allows us to effectively boost ASR
performance while keeping the robustness inherited from the multitask and
multilingual pre-training. Results demonstrate that our approach is more
effective than standard fine-tuning or LoRA adapters, boosting performance in
the targeted languages for both in- and out-of-domain test sets, while
introducing only a negligible parameter overhead at inference.
|
[
-0.31538188457489014,
-0.20783346891403198,
0.19850921630859375,
0.3394431173801422,
-0.10599862039089203,
0.25943130254745483,
-0.4249309301376343,
-0.5903054475784302,
-0.043303389102220535,
0.07960217446088791,
-0.6283706426620483,
-0.12868474423885345,
-0.7920446395874023,
0.028477903455495834,
-0.1875477135181427,
0.7171416282653809,
0.3059297502040863,
0.11868182569742203,
-0.001819062978029251,
-0.2545175850391388,
-0.45050615072250366,
-0.606807291507721,
-0.5618700385093689,
-0.3879210352897644,
0.1952296644449234,
0.21922887861728668,
0.35252076387405396,
0.42474862933158875,
0.1414831131696701,
0.4121055006980896,
-0.40618014335632324,
0.1468750238418579,
-0.1673881560564041,
0.17510570585727692,
0.21306125819683075,
-0.19933409988880157,
-0.32628384232521057,
-0.2074085921049118,
0.5086347460746765,
0.6598246097564697,
-0.45772233605384827,
0.41471970081329346,
0.5074419379234314,
0.7134050130844116,
-0.8697594404220581,
0.3608454465866089,
-0.7765896916389465,
-0.2727414071559906,
-0.4128437936306,
-0.03426908701658249,
-0.3580736815929413,
-0.11692056059837341,
0.2739845812320709,
-0.44182464480400085,
0.38037732243537903,
-0.14543431997299194,
0.5074504613876343,
0.6731681823730469,
-0.3586433529853821,
-0.2546796202659607,
-0.7689846158027649,
0.9141431450843811,
-0.7984961271286011,
0.5945733785629272,
0.4668320119380951,
0.3828222155570984,
0.24981389939785004,
-0.4335555136203766,
-0.5199267268180847,
0.04528603330254555,
-0.030137043446302414,
-0.038128361105918884,
-0.588507890701294,
0.10275911539793015,
0.3317960202693939,
0.41878464818000793,
-0.5575661659240723,
0.10142622888088226,
-0.4808225929737091,
-0.5130345225334167,
0.5366150140762329,
-0.1353345811367035,
-0.035622596740722656,
-0.17248235642910004,
-0.04946567863225937,
-0.2578614354133606,
-0.3966570496559143,
0.27466294169425964,
0.6125233769416809,
0.5409378409385681,
-0.004136303905397654,
0.33307895064353943,
-0.32087191939353943,
0.7764871716499329,
0.1671890914440155,
-0.442155122756958,
0.2921813726425171,
-0.22478172183036804,
0.1082838848233223,
0.39200979471206665,
0.7955024838447571,
0.11577264219522476,
0.20090854167938232,
0.07053054124116898,
-0.07424820959568024,
0.2536689341068268,
0.009227163158357143,
-0.8546169996261597,
-0.368625670671463,
0.232949897646904,
-0.5103071331977844,
-0.01556415855884552,
-0.21651187539100647,
-0.5956202149391174,
-0.25186678767204285,
-0.23778828978538513,
0.5087922215461731,
-0.44171014428138733,
-0.41069814562797546,
0.3371603190898895,
-0.3994211256504059,
-0.2630282938480377,
0.1589372605085373,
-0.8766695857048035,
0.46669813990592957,
0.4789690673351288,
0.8946498036384583,
0.0669475868344307,
-0.37689757347106934,
-0.7994020581245422,
0.1102050393819809,
0.1289622038602829,
0.690742552280426,
-0.40335583686828613,
-0.5015345811843872,
-0.1612715870141983,
-0.2903776168823242,
-0.05637840926647186,
-0.7251359224319458,
0.5607579350471497,
-0.18652452528476715,
0.0203753262758255,
-0.2201361358165741,
-0.3829304277896881,
-0.16529321670532227,
-0.13914543390274048,
-0.7585048675537109,
0.949794352054596,
-0.12617401778697968,
-0.7246649861335754,
0.3722115755081177,
-0.48549532890319824,
-0.5069977045059204,
-0.03280235826969147,
-0.09924910962581635,
-0.27818191051483154,
0.4382081627845764,
0.4961980879306793,
0.4946693181991577,
-0.31652769446372986,
0.2023749053478241,
0.08503223210573196,
-0.2747707664966583,
0.05811724439263344,
-0.7055569887161255,
0.6817255020141602,
0.28047826886177063,
-0.09076801687479019,
0.1417761594057083,
-0.8328955769538879,
0.255227267742157,
-0.16702979803085327,
-0.46444445848464966,
-0.4872923195362091,
0.01333430502563715,
0.2240915596485138,
0.1996738761663437,
0.2294679880142212,
-0.6273672580718994,
0.07389666885137558,
-0.3370950222015381,
0.7539836168289185,
0.4085473120212555,
-0.3096892833709717,
0.3804127871990204,
-0.3015468120574951,
0.45190104842185974,
-0.039204783737659454,
0.16248087584972382,
-0.21890991926193237,
-0.3723195791244507,
-0.8652825355529785,
-0.5245878100395203,
0.47909244894981384,
0.485089510679245,
-0.8836094737052917,
0.3278466463088989,
-0.45396852493286133,
-0.5458977222442627,
-1.057802677154541,
0.011151024140417576,
0.7244654893875122,
0.3036157786846161,
0.46996966004371643,
-0.04261130839586258,
-0.555881679058075,
-0.9579831957817078,
-0.27705299854278564,
-0.21599125862121582,
-0.2916581630706787,
0.06431818753480911,
0.09654301404953003,
0.057355787605047226,
0.6549703478813171,
-0.684596598148346,
-0.42727330327033997,
-0.3322827219963074,
0.26829832792282104,
0.23354025185108185,
0.4650333523750305,
0.34011340141296387,
-0.755817174911499,
-0.6944659352302551,
-0.14863121509552002,
-0.18753458559513092,
-0.23553237318992615,
0.29951226711273193,
0.38433530926704407,
0.11303094774484634,
0.2856827974319458,
-0.5430458188056946,
0.3009795844554901,
0.9586716890335083,
-0.08078848570585251,
0.5684651732444763,
-0.23059283196926117,
0.08470699191093445,
-0.9940029978752136,
-0.0062591275200247765,
-0.04699145630002022,
-0.2577052414417267,
-0.8987128734588623,
-0.10123641043901443,
0.24397580325603485,
-0.32894566655158997,
-0.47521188855171204,
0.4582246243953705,
-0.5967894792556763,
0.25372177362442017,
-0.36347243189811707,
-0.2776481807231903,
0.09081200510263443,
0.4485696256160736,
0.19835887849330902,
0.9422354698181152,
0.6657907962799072,
-0.6728001832962036,
0.07312783598899841,
0.2233448624610901,
-0.3633400797843933,
0.48247459530830383,
-0.8574841022491455,
0.2574070990085602,
-0.04251442104578018,
0.19460907578468323,
-0.615980863571167,
0.03841147944331169,
-0.34486445784568787,
-0.4152544438838959,
0.5789073705673218,
-0.5435547828674316,
-0.5481425523757935,
-0.4446875751018524,
-0.3622613549232483,
0.46559572219848633,
0.6627878546714783,
-0.6091594696044922,
0.7903619408607483,
0.49142077565193176,
-0.3283238410949707,
-0.5947510600090027,
-0.5793488025665283,
-0.1614612638950348,
-0.46936601400375366,
-0.6443177461624146,
0.454135537147522,
-0.20585107803344727,
-0.20907969772815704,
-0.364973247051239,
-0.45907217264175415,
-0.2197571098804474,
-0.20210346579551697,
0.3517983555793762,
0.02958686836063862,
-0.021282408386468887,
0.01906697079539299,
0.11773590743541718,
-0.3445495069026947,
-0.3108255863189697,
-0.25908392667770386,
0.6773480772972107,
-0.15659776329994202,
-0.26721101999282837,
-0.5194371342658997,
0.5704533457756042,
0.4379338026046753,
-0.37573906779289246,
0.45642656087875366,
0.5861397981643677,
-0.18423989415168762,
-0.2871248424053192,
-0.9041785597801208,
-0.23449315130710602,
-0.5540530681610107,
0.16057683527469635,
-0.6157701015472412,
-1.0402777194976807,
0.5310037732124329,
-0.1198124811053276,
-0.05231776833534241,
0.324813574552536,
0.34471964836120605,
0.19015337526798248,
0.9315165877342224,
0.5956739187240601,
-0.3991411626338959,
0.2710353434085846,
-0.21132422983646393,
-0.06792694330215454,
-0.9206939935684204,
-0.09186605364084244,
-0.8438454866409302,
-0.17429031431674957,
-0.49970176815986633,
-0.5250762701034546,
0.6164805889129639,
0.053715821355581284,
0.1780005246400833,
0.383840948343277,
-0.7328019738197327,
0.3871125876903534,
0.67115318775177,
0.002291908487677574,
0.4572617709636688,
-0.028379393741488457,
0.21559640765190125,
-0.20588849484920502,
-0.9595689177513123,
-0.1997087597846985,
0.8082215785980225,
0.3086281418800354,
0.7651357054710388,
0.37296628952026367,
0.5522251725196838,
0.09123585373163223,
-0.38741153478622437,
-0.8202691674232483,
0.2541445791721344,
-0.5698454976081848,
-0.5110369324684143,
-0.3723618984222412,
-0.5360190272331238,
-0.7554816603660583,
0.3861476182937622,
0.033617451786994934,
-0.6638038158416748,
0.340592622756958,
0.3555954396724701,
-0.6485942006111145,
-0.009145061485469341,
-0.8462159037590027,
0.44213804602622986,
0.09239693731069565,
-0.028686590492725372,
-0.3434959053993225,
-0.6157782077789307,
0.15496988594532013,
-0.30147507786750793,
0.3111337125301361,
-0.21816129982471466,
0.18389803171157837,
0.8207771182060242,
-0.537543535232544,
0.8022592067718506,
-0.32876479625701904,
0.0020897334907203913,
0.1888752281665802,
-0.018299821764230728,
0.4544418454170227,
-0.1754455268383026,
-0.14183975756168365,
0.6065847873687744,
0.23324228823184967,
-0.2474396973848343,
-0.5283530950546265,
0.5213285088539124,
-0.6576082706451416,
-0.4615497589111328,
-0.3443814218044281,
-0.5103291869163513,
-0.4396236836910248,
-0.018940959125757217,
0.49462807178497314,
0.7773758172988892,
0.07715243101119995,
0.027195008471608162,
0.5832902193069458,
-0.17590123414993286,
0.5477501749992371,
0.9122651219367981,
0.10082492232322693,
-0.266240656375885,
0.9941447377204895,
0.33845609426498413,
0.2173110395669937,
0.31566229462623596,
0.5233421921730042,
-0.3475915193557739,
-0.7185868620872498,
-0.5165640711784363,
-0.037164390087127686,
-0.4718279540538788,
-0.33281195163726807,
-0.7902816534042358,
-0.29485809803009033,
-0.4628421366214752,
0.18434904515743256,
-0.6993683576583862,
-0.6143705248832703,
-0.05964610353112221,
0.30988845229148865,
0.5005200505256653,
0.47477987408638,
-0.19528253376483917,
0.41970953345298767,
-0.8993051648139954,
0.44272515177726746,
0.49162399768829346,
0.09948405623435974,
0.142190620303154,
-0.652673602104187,
-0.16442343592643738,
-0.02424735575914383,
-0.12644711136817932,
-0.6211175918579102,
0.3459051251411438,
0.8435093760490417,
0.4251289665699005,
0.3797396123409271,
0.41629087924957275,
1.1499165296554565,
-0.9259613752365112,
0.6649600863456726,
0.23227748274803162,
-1.2065130472183228,
0.6103142499923706,
-0.06455386430025101,
0.644784688949585,
0.7115914821624756,
0.25020959973335266,
-0.3508788049221039,
-0.3782144784927368,
-0.40150055289268494,
-0.8686080574989319,
0.6027683019638062,
0.2129245102405548,
0.11167633533477783,
0.23494462668895721,
0.019746309146285057,
0.347616583108902,
0.403280645608902,
-0.26785025000572205,
-0.2366589456796646,
-0.29143625497817993,
-0.20141246914863586,
-0.13074864447116852,
-0.3578031361103058,
-0.011655706912279129,
-0.37050068378448486,
0.47979047894477844,
-0.2787646949291229,
0.03107115440070629,
0.003050565719604492,
-0.191354900598526,
0.13764092326164246,
0.4173554480075836,
0.4503365755081177,
0.3213852047920227,
0.015500975772738457,
0.3368249237537384,
0.23097579181194305,
-0.6660441756248474,
0.23589389026165009,
0.5245810151100159,
-0.010911179706454277,
0.09809745103120804,
0.5981512069702148,
0.8714568018913269,
0.3645067512989044,
-0.6846535205841064,
0.46045157313346863,
-0.24905985593795776,
0.02057613618671894,
-0.17788636684417725,
0.0848139151930809,
-0.038516752421855927,
0.43498465418815613,
0.5189306139945984,
0.2424713671207428,
0.555184543132782,
-0.3564719557762146,
-0.048411235213279724,
0.4518333077430725,
-0.24919404089450836,
-0.4040776789188385,
0.6148083209991455,
0.28942254185676575,
-0.1648198813199997,
0.44018983840942383,
-0.14377045631408691,
-0.6972621083259583,
0.17461128532886505,
0.26031601428985596,
0.7115742564201355,
-0.6064892411231995,
-0.1451060026884079,
0.30893728137016296,
0.15887880325317383,
-0.3256722092628479,
0.3145356774330139,
-0.4351179897785187,
-0.5898842215538025,
-0.7280616164207458,
-0.6616212129592896,
-0.21699029207229614,
-0.022890884429216385,
-0.9895031452178955,
0.1014830693602562,
0.07697591185569763,
-0.3274296820163727,
0.2690536379814148,
0.0883244201540947,
-0.6645186543464661,
-0.1196398064494133,
0.15603302419185638,
0.8959445953369141,
-0.6552936434745789,
1.0870730876922607,
0.2668761610984802,
-0.0669279620051384,
-0.8745070695877075,
0.07632444053888321,
0.2688252031803131,
-0.6871287822723389,
0.5829237103462219,
0.21365387737751007,
-0.30879494547843933,
0.10518983751535416,
0.05843019858002663,
-0.8489083647727966,
0.8699148893356323,
0.4733099043369293,
-0.9575023055076599,
-0.05969425290822983,
-0.07754726707935333,
0.41122257709503174,
0.15600258111953735,
0.047790367156267166,
0.4244285225868225,
0.2502603828907013,
0.21036583185195923,
-1.764825463294983,
-0.17871248722076416,
-0.242573544383049,
0.09618633985519409,
0.2546690106391907,
-0.6328979730606079,
0.7678297758102417,
-0.12556730210781097,
-0.26149657368659973,
-0.016776524484157562,
0.5009783506393433,
0.3294772207736969,
0.18603456020355225,
0.7398107647895813,
0.3992420732975006,
0.8630774617195129,
-0.035685088485479355,
0.8574052453041077,
-0.38036492466926575,
0.1000361517071724,
1.2868890762329102,
-0.3338099718093872,
1.0284268856048584,
0.4913488030433655,
-0.41705819964408875,
0.09310334920883179,
0.18298999965190887,
0.22057367861270905,
0.7465780377388,
0.1944805532693863,
-0.3865633010864258,
-0.0975155159831047,
-0.2812107801437378,
-0.449018657207489,
0.7186734676361084,
0.12988737225532532,
0.1500762701034546,
-0.04066028445959091,
0.23622266948223114,
0.06160701811313629,
0.022929474711418152,
-0.27870070934295654,
1.0215190649032593,
0.08099599927663803,
-0.37230053544044495,
0.6883570551872253,
-0.09267515689134598,
1.2070635557174683,
-0.8553933501243591,
0.2246003895998001,
0.1850997358560562,
0.16741977632045746,
-0.10251566022634506,
-0.42587438225746155,
0.49828076362609863,
0.12616756558418274,
-0.406930536031723,
-0.3566116690635681,
0.8495371341705322,
-0.5596380233764648,
-0.5837092995643616,
0.2724735736846924,
0.6400856971740723,
0.13081780076026917,
-0.5569512844085693,
-0.47687703371047974,
0.4716593623161316,
-0.05616409704089165,
0.02102763019502163,
0.3388468623161316,
0.3879607021808624,
0.2562744617462158,
0.7726247310638428,
0.6784124970436096,
0.46880966424942017,
0.09892383962869644,
0.18934625387191772,
0.9269092082977295,
-0.23240269720554352,
-0.6104609966278076,
-0.9275386929512024,
0.5009682774543762,
-0.08706805109977722,
-0.23720300197601318,
0.9144537448883057,
0.6174527406692505,
0.6523645520210266,
-0.037746284157037735,
0.7092238068580627,
0.11199033260345459,
0.7038581371307373,
-0.598802924156189,
0.8321342468261719,
-0.4551409184932709,
0.13768908381462097,
-0.37741366028785706,
-0.6832820773124695,
0.01604672707617283,
0.6994227766990662,
0.025613410398364067,
-0.08015859872102737,
0.41852515935897827,
0.47827398777008057,
-0.007055947091430426,
-0.05716332420706749,
0.437304824590683,
0.028441090136766434,
0.15402498841285706,
0.5113056302070618,
0.7948878407478333,
-0.37787002325057983,
0.6059529185295105,
-0.50593101978302,
-0.19238100945949554,
0.09269483387470245,
-0.8524941802024841,
-0.8874799013137817,
-0.8680013418197632,
-0.4585415720939636,
-0.05665260925889015,
-0.07673502713441849,
0.8342092037200928,
1.301894187927246,
-0.6390895843505859,
-0.2634846568107605,
0.3934909701347351,
-0.2734062075614929,
-0.3797958493232727,
-0.13107436895370483,
0.349805623292923,
0.011298875324428082,
-0.7525531649589539,
0.6835381984710693,
0.09798619151115417,
-0.05888564884662628,
-0.3079800009727478,
-0.13479480147361755,
0.3771175146102905,
-0.05216807872056961,
0.7346859574317932,
0.02529408223927021,
-0.6761879920959473,
0.07217738032341003,
-0.1625637263059616,
0.4729033410549164,
-0.1693456619977951,
0.8843106031417847,
-0.872747004032135,
0.5172632932662964,
0.24936597049236298,
0.1831534057855606,
0.5862196683883667,
-0.10913248360157013,
0.47831112146377563,
-1.1033008098602295,
0.6043139100074768,
0.27572017908096313,
0.32947683334350586,
0.4407428503036499,
-0.20642708241939545,
0.3047815263271332,
-0.08563773334026337,
-0.517641544342041,
-0.9673317074775696,
0.27919861674308777,
-0.8469971418380737,
-0.3385262191295624,
1.1528658866882324,
-0.031276095658540726,
0.17774471640586853,
-0.3080677092075348,
-0.2766524851322174,
0.1677377074956894,
-0.7033475041389465,
0.7077537775039673,
0.7263969779014587,
-0.12414991110563278,
-0.29091835021972656,
-0.6308056116104126,
0.7351115345954895,
0.004464912228286266,
-0.4285321533679962,
0.2873317301273346,
0.38915345072746277,
0.2611096501350403,
0.3484335243701935,
0.7142985463142395,
0.1637313812971115,
0.008231427520513535,
0.1601785272359848,
0.11947043985128403,
-0.2349221259355545,
-0.30542129278182983,
-0.5752952694892883,
0.13912460207939148,
0.28453880548477173,
-0.3093700706958771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00949v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00949v1
|
The Role of Model Architecture and Scale in Predicting Molecular Properties: Insights from Fine-Tuning RoBERTa, BART, and LLaMA
| 2024-05-02T02:20:12 | 2024-05-02T02:20:12 |
Lee Youngmin, Lang S. I. D. Andrew, Cai Duoduo, Wheat R. Stephen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, physics.chem-ph, q-bio.BM
|
This study introduces a systematic framework to compare the efficacy of Large
Language Models (LLMs) for fine-tuning across various cheminformatics tasks.
Employing a uniform training methodology, we assessed three well-known
models-RoBERTa, BART, and LLaMA-on their ability to predict molecular
properties using the Simplified Molecular Input Line Entry System (SMILES) as a
universal molecular representation format. Our comparative analysis involved
pre-training 18 configurations of these models, with varying parameter sizes
and dataset scales, followed by fine-tuning them on six benchmarking tasks from
DeepChem. We maintained consistent training environments across models to
ensure reliable comparisons. This approach allowed us to assess the influence
of model type, size, and training dataset size on model performance.
Specifically, we found that LLaMA-based models generally offered the lowest
validation loss, suggesting their superior adaptability across tasks and
scales. However, we observed that absolute validation loss is not a definitive
indicator of model performance - contradicts previous research - at least for
fine-tuning tasks: instead, model size plays a crucial role. Through rigorous
replication and validation, involving multiple training and fine-tuning cycles,
our study not only delineates the strengths and limitations of each model type
but also provides a robust methodology for selecting the most suitable LLM for
specific cheminformatics applications. This research underscores the importance
of considering model architecture and dataset characteristics in deploying AI
for molecular property prediction, paving the way for more informed and
effective utilization of AI in drug discovery and related fields.
|
[
-0.28493639826774597,
-0.46443623304367065,
0.919830858707428,
-0.18967828154563904,
-0.13548503816127777,
0.07915414124727249,
-0.34144410490989685,
-0.5194901823997498,
-0.025638097897171974,
0.42942488193511963,
-0.10337048768997192,
-0.35327932238578796,
-0.8403907418251038,
0.22780542075634003,
-0.20481359958648682,
0.8480631113052368,
-0.10958991199731827,
0.5304820537567139,
-0.3291684687137604,
-0.03073284588754177,
0.03945718705654144,
-0.2694852352142334,
-0.43040212988853455,
-0.5590698719024658,
0.6893834471702576,
0.2526198625564575,
0.7315359711647034,
1.1189160346984863,
0.9506286978721619,
0.2806955575942993,
-0.3864138126373291,
0.06901411712169647,
-0.3526601493358612,
-0.07452456653118134,
-0.2528039813041687,
-0.7512465119361877,
-0.7145525813102722,
0.049951303750276566,
0.4680217206478119,
0.9406591057777405,
-0.05912899225950241,
0.2987681031227112,
-0.05543794482946396,
0.6164154410362244,
-0.5310187339782715,
0.2879805564880371,
-0.6082757711410522,
0.0781891867518425,
-0.07604438066482544,
0.018690455704927444,
-0.20060932636260986,
-0.004770459607243538,
0.2591381072998047,
-0.5242000818252563,
0.16296237707138062,
0.031065847724676132,
0.9420962333679199,
0.29612019658088684,
-0.6170685291290283,
-0.3445174992084503,
-0.6357197761535645,
0.7857034802436829,
-1.0728557109832764,
0.32209497690200806,
0.15666250884532928,
0.40678903460502625,
-0.38779518008232117,
-0.4370066523551941,
-0.30643999576568604,
-0.7534893155097961,
-0.09063727408647537,
-0.2199639528989792,
0.12817610800266266,
0.5157058238983154,
0.09798546880483627,
0.685752809047699,
-0.6047610640525818,
0.437161386013031,
-0.4536961317062378,
-0.23995813727378845,
0.40380823612213135,
0.23968061804771423,
0.12804189324378967,
0.05298742651939392,
-0.3188777565956116,
-0.3642268478870392,
-0.520673394203186,
0.04310193657875061,
0.14421655237674713,
0.843867838382721,
-0.029830988496541977,
0.7281546592712402,
-0.39285963773727417,
0.40189921855926514,
0.11528050154447556,
-0.29486051201820374,
-0.04228764399886131,
-0.336754709482193,
-0.41889533400535583,
0.10114589333534241,
0.681594967842102,
-0.048263661563396454,
0.42025378346443176,
0.04902825504541397,
-0.09414280951023102,
0.07625701278448105,
0.19874341785907745,
-1.049127459526062,
-0.19702503085136414,
0.32497984170913696,
-0.4951857924461365,
-0.5386303067207336,
0.07676506042480469,
-0.6511041522026062,
-0.5314826965332031,
-0.5386425852775574,
0.5766417384147644,
-0.30280011892318726,
0.10489169508218765,
0.12569834291934967,
-0.17052778601646423,
-0.07743153721094131,
0.45773541927337646,
-1.0803877115249634,
0.5080325603485107,
0.6909928321838379,
0.8492698669433594,
-0.29194819927215576,
-0.22180470824241638,
-0.29306933283805847,
-0.015947984531521797,
-0.30281269550323486,
0.5928624868392944,
-0.7479060888290405,
-0.28838875889778137,
-0.4032813012599945,
-0.08911577612161636,
-0.028274713084101677,
-0.7852808237075806,
0.10333661735057831,
-0.4309932589530945,
-0.41287845373153687,
-0.2748531103134155,
-0.5198244452476501,
-0.17033952474594116,
0.09454862773418427,
-0.8806036710739136,
0.4544445276260376,
0.41108834743499756,
-0.3580979108810425,
0.5169276595115662,
-0.3770492970943451,
-0.36440783739089966,
-0.269862562417984,
-0.10888796299695969,
-0.5738762617111206,
0.3889714479446411,
0.130909264087677,
0.6407864093780518,
-0.5087234973907471,
0.20326896011829376,
-0.5494972467422485,
-0.24512770771980286,
0.4332401752471924,
-0.08561480045318604,
0.5188920497894287,
0.2878241539001465,
-0.12297382950782776,
0.2736179828643799,
-1.191515326499939,
-0.03080296330153942,
-0.1589563488960266,
-0.6350958943367004,
0.17897428572177887,
-0.28972098231315613,
0.01662519760429859,
0.20252302289009094,
0.3692237436771393,
-0.5187699198722839,
0.3375595211982727,
-0.08378884196281433,
0.43741872906684875,
0.7927144169807434,
-0.013271614909172058,
0.6055924296379089,
-0.08884619176387787,
0.5897102952003479,
0.22292359173297882,
-0.04244121536612511,
0.07789213210344315,
-0.2069246470928192,
-0.5924216508865356,
-0.3851749897003174,
0.6169865131378174,
0.2873300313949585,
0.12553507089614868,
0.24037796258926392,
-0.2837234437465668,
-0.8616443276405334,
-0.20398323237895966,
0.5321897864341736,
0.5244439244270325,
0.2728962302207947,
0.35595929622650146,
-0.4849574565887451,
-0.40425124764442444,
-1.0446228981018066,
-0.22498707473278046,
-0.1961587369441986,
-0.0764709934592247,
0.39374104142189026,
0.679610013961792,
-0.42315101623535156,
0.3803955614566803,
-0.27329668402671814,
-0.10051391273736954,
-0.3747287392616272,
-0.15751652419567108,
0.14266209304332733,
0.3173362612724304,
0.34557655453681946,
-0.308932363986969,
-0.18841464817523956,
0.38438957929611206,
-0.5849055051803589,
0.20657651126384735,
0.005065499804913998,
-0.1760532259941101,
0.041900862008333206,
0.2966385781764984,
-0.5493127703666687,
0.3141677975654602,
0.6438248157501221,
-0.10441095381975174,
0.48798325657844543,
-0.24252226948738098,
0.14876070618629456,
-0.6953685283660889,
0.08199243992567062,
0.2832188308238983,
0.005988205783069134,
-0.6724566221237183,
-0.011935730464756489,
0.08368813246488571,
-0.01545123104006052,
-0.2674982249736786,
0.41477394104003906,
-0.3048739731311798,
-0.3365667760372162,
-0.14293093979358673,
-0.3948439955711365,
0.20591342449188232,
0.5188936591148376,
0.007457520347088575,
0.7515053153038025,
0.20967702567577362,
-0.6392890810966492,
0.11406966298818588,
-0.0472075454890728,
-0.3721611797809601,
0.3535814583301544,
-0.9013469815254211,
-0.2204361855983734,
0.35005706548690796,
0.2992801070213318,
-1.0277076959609985,
-0.4881635904312134,
-0.2298118770122528,
-0.258569598197937,
0.5387952327728271,
-0.09908849745988846,
-0.5094795227050781,
-0.12360980361700058,
-0.12208672612905502,
0.40135955810546875,
0.15158334374427795,
-0.2744702398777008,
0.6987044811248779,
0.11235037446022034,
0.1703404039144516,
-0.07949881255626678,
-0.6858074069023132,
-0.30455151200294495,
-0.4792795479297638,
-0.5992540717124939,
0.22181814908981323,
-0.013590372167527676,
-0.26714563369750977,
-0.6083096265792847,
-0.3461027145385742,
-0.07319740206003189,
0.2785194516181946,
0.32752755284309387,
0.2417573183774948,
-0.3785504996776581,
0.1306263655424118,
0.006374531425535679,
-0.01535641960799694,
0.04467613995075226,
-0.12180227786302567,
0.513737678527832,
-0.4317072927951813,
0.13085074722766876,
-0.6208443641662598,
-0.16370204091072083,
0.9072732329368591,
-0.3204582631587982,
0.8974858522415161,
0.21677355468273163,
0.054251451045274734,
-0.2585020363330841,
-0.01189404260367155,
-0.39965805411338806,
-0.47088631987571716,
0.3907870650291443,
-0.29308509826660156,
-0.6849250197410583,
0.7756243944168091,
-0.32587775588035583,
-0.3866911232471466,
0.43934234976768494,
0.5504240393638611,
-0.1916915327310562,
0.6509931683540344,
0.6943974494934082,
-0.049716293811798096,
0.3461607098579407,
-0.3080916404724121,
0.19654574990272522,
-0.9310909509658813,
-0.14033594727516174,
-0.5221264958381653,
-0.5642567276954651,
-0.6449487805366516,
-0.4617404043674469,
0.5686129927635193,
-0.0014115000376477838,
-0.706407368183136,
0.48199892044067383,
-0.24111609160900116,
0.0919753834605217,
0.3791194260120392,
0.27538108825683594,
0.25233668088912964,
0.1850389838218689,
0.029212968423962593,
0.30324888229370117,
-0.5190768241882324,
-0.7022896409034729,
1.6553682088851929,
0.5560778975486755,
0.8255835771560669,
-0.09784236550331116,
0.5273674130439758,
0.012087192386388779,
-0.25272682309150696,
-0.8525015115737915,
0.5140450596809387,
-0.09107091277837753,
-0.5552600622177124,
-0.5048137307167053,
-0.4866517186164856,
-0.8026361465454102,
-0.021013978868722916,
-0.11061707884073257,
-0.5301188826560974,
0.5787498950958252,
0.23867517709732056,
-0.49983346462249756,
0.37173375487327576,
-0.4181106984615326,
0.7662085294723511,
-0.45669496059417725,
-0.19289502501487732,
-0.19523902237415314,
-0.8345991373062134,
0.17848362028598785,
-0.11822545528411865,
0.07388170808553696,
-0.21240459382534027,
-0.03816145285964012,
0.44437095522880554,
-0.49148014187812805,
0.6127265691757202,
0.3725641667842865,
-0.31374672055244446,
0.06244465336203575,
0.4976845383644104,
0.27111780643463135,
-0.03835904970765114,
-0.2987323999404907,
0.40465274453163147,
0.1214313879609108,
-0.3322944641113281,
-0.5933998823165894,
0.7720922231674194,
-1.0545400381088257,
-0.3401641249656677,
-0.09534192830324173,
-0.5442848801612854,
-0.27088433504104614,
0.13936427235603333,
0.21106255054473877,
0.35908782482147217,
-0.09443243592977524,
0.24259212613105774,
0.8504053354263306,
0.01152138039469719,
0.01275342982262373,
0.2592378258705139,
0.020273171365261078,
-0.17727473378181458,
0.9319145679473877,
0.23108544945716858,
0.7128732204437256,
0.6837900280952454,
0.2204473614692688,
0.24082016944885254,
-0.7128146886825562,
-0.31996074318885803,
0.07572340220212936,
-0.6564468145370483,
-0.1762203723192215,
-0.3309614956378937,
-0.07734691351652145,
-0.34713369607925415,
-0.11787771433591843,
-0.6685462594032288,
-0.7541698217391968,
-0.4281071722507477,
-0.2666325569152832,
0.6224643588066101,
0.7801573276519775,
0.009770543314516544,
0.4800257980823517,
-0.36800119280815125,
0.2821618914604187,
0.18942146003246307,
0.4726202189922333,
-0.11248115450143814,
-0.5987287163734436,
-0.43010449409484863,
0.09095390886068344,
-0.22976882755756378,
-0.5888015627861023,
0.1350804567337036,
0.29353785514831543,
0.3743447959423065,
0.42103955149650574,
-0.5083097815513611,
0.2847771644592285,
-0.32145926356315613,
0.5543733835220337,
-0.37117576599121094,
-0.6468212604522705,
0.7647389769554138,
-0.599290132522583,
0.15117107331752777,
0.6728582978248596,
0.20561350882053375,
0.11837238073348999,
0.03641965240240097,
-0.4740726053714752,
-0.7859921455383301,
0.3072318434715271,
0.18846173584461212,
-0.2976202368736267,
0.30230847001075745,
0.5392229557037354,
0.15677784383296967,
0.3214097321033478,
-0.4658060073852539,
-0.2275523841381073,
-0.11660376191139221,
-0.29473528265953064,
-0.2310289442539215,
-0.014096301048994064,
-0.08489034324884415,
-0.34051963686943054,
0.6205896139144897,
-0.11698205024003983,
0.14376457035541534,
-0.039054352790117264,
-0.0518452450633049,
-0.06233171373605728,
0.1963369995355606,
0.611372172832489,
0.7067698836326599,
-0.5199297070503235,
-0.030968068167567253,
0.10487813502550125,
-0.6147085428237915,
0.1916002631187439,
-0.06472465395927429,
0.18926948308944702,
-0.4285939335823059,
0.4233185350894928,
0.8093728423118591,
0.060722045600414276,
-0.7853818535804749,
-0.01652938313782215,
0.22391502559185028,
-0.09762165695428848,
0.2392382025718689,
0.4715655744075775,
-0.04696773737668991,
0.3432125747203827,
-0.12040001899003983,
0.17986151576042175,
0.3065808415412903,
-0.7404221892356873,
-0.23018769919872284,
0.40032151341438293,
-0.23963932693004608,
-0.25088202953338623,
0.5386916399002075,
-0.09202612191438675,
0.0454060435295105,
0.6088685989379883,
0.2964836359024048,
-0.16928116977214813,
1.066866397857666,
0.12965118885040283,
0.5941240191459656,
-0.3231397867202759,
0.07382340729236603,
0.3672938048839569,
0.11448772996664047,
-0.07693629711866379,
-0.031503304839134216,
-0.03427379950881004,
-0.5328531265258789,
0.382132887840271,
-0.8945828080177307,
-0.4363062381744385,
0.03583178669214249,
-0.6744878888130188,
0.1852065771818161,
-1.0641835927963257,
-0.1553027182817459,
0.3402795195579529,
0.37338629364967346,
-0.8314068913459778,
0.4922581613063812,
0.210159569978714,
0.8627620935440063,
-0.8055418729782104,
0.7255669832229614,
0.5717635154724121,
-0.4689673185348511,
-0.9312964677810669,
-0.25647035241127014,
0.33657562732696533,
-0.5692135691642761,
0.693472683429718,
0.025513237342238426,
-0.21302244067192078,
-0.2783786356449127,
-0.589195966720581,
-1.370773434638977,
1.4416658878326416,
0.3478447198867798,
-0.733413577079773,
0.034908778965473175,
0.4177565276622772,
0.8435607552528381,
-0.7073755860328674,
0.10366110503673553,
1.0557223558425903,
0.33753740787506104,
0.10663805902004242,
-1.1911829710006714,
0.009394961409270763,
-0.16472908854484558,
0.4461207687854767,
-0.0867585837841034,
-0.7069758176803589,
1.011634111404419,
-0.3219793736934662,
0.16529564559459686,
0.5016871094703674,
0.5247067213058472,
0.6295378804206848,
0.05386538803577423,
-0.06235254555940628,
0.4567088782787323,
0.815264105796814,
-0.04127202928066254,
1.193840742111206,
-0.43116673827171326,
0.08686508983373642,
0.9603286981582642,
-0.2671546936035156,
0.9704931378364563,
0.5891213417053223,
-0.4187251329421997,
0.6334210634231567,
0.649320662021637,
-0.32095426321029663,
0.3981236219406128,
0.6442567706108093,
0.12468017637729645,
-0.20364542305469513,
0.03683663159608841,
-0.24724310636520386,
0.5409846305847168,
0.5936778783798218,
-0.6502074599266052,
0.1238011047244072,
-0.08917130529880524,
-0.036308079957962036,
0.042624909430742264,
-0.46783018112182617,
0.545173704624176,
0.0059081013314425945,
-0.30124056339263916,
0.39441418647766113,
0.07769325375556946,
0.34484943747520447,
-0.563113808631897,
0.07755423337221146,
-0.37468722462654114,
0.37666401267051697,
-0.09642899036407471,
-0.5437037944793701,
-0.3261399269104004,
-0.3450254499912262,
-0.3177340030670166,
0.3034902513027191,
0.5246525406837463,
-0.2139689177274704,
-0.6548336148262024,
0.18767854571342468,
0.06943988054990768,
0.10817058384418488,
-0.03590090572834015,
-0.4291190505027771,
0.33500033617019653,
-0.2661193311214447,
-0.29446834325790405,
0.47793641686439514,
0.45505091547966003,
-0.07399925589561462,
0.8662756085395813,
0.38302820920944214,
0.11781344562768936,
-0.1773640364408493,
-0.09526581317186356,
0.9039936661720276,
-0.6681277751922607,
-0.03141261264681816,
-0.659731388092041,
0.33379265666007996,
0.2722730338573456,
-0.3961540460586548,
0.7234566807746887,
0.5601587891578674,
0.7873838543891907,
-0.19086167216300964,
0.568237841129303,
0.5069184899330139,
0.2862878143787384,
-0.5036975741386414,
0.5625430941581726,
-0.45023074746131897,
0.5745337009429932,
-0.29994410276412964,
-0.9351934790611267,
-0.17952267825603485,
0.5434567332267761,
-0.2406938374042511,
0.49749755859375,
0.428677499294281,
0.994845986366272,
-0.2074241191148758,
-0.1321025788784027,
0.07602369785308838,
0.46149906516075134,
0.5409227013587952,
0.6115647554397583,
0.42046400904655457,
-0.4603026211261749,
0.081577368080616,
-0.2878231704235077,
0.007766129914671183,
-0.48452961444854736,
-0.6171208620071411,
-1.0895013809204102,
-0.2769830822944641,
-0.17899230122566223,
-0.348978191614151,
-0.03385419771075249,
0.8839893937110901,
0.8019607067108154,
-0.8550432324409485,
-0.5879483819007874,
-0.1912693977355957,
-0.3108765184879303,
-0.04875811189413071,
-0.08067874610424042,
0.34243881702423096,
-0.10132474452257156,
-0.35133254528045654,
0.3728780448436737,
0.3765636682510376,
0.3743879199028015,
-0.4881903827190399,
-0.05724398046731949,
0.03415511175990105,
0.3501288890838623,
0.4613463282585144,
0.3935554623603821,
-0.9279361963272095,
0.04918226599693298,
-0.0422726608812809,
-0.45935359597206116,
0.20938917994499207,
0.6570068001747131,
-0.7314461469650269,
0.4127785563468933,
0.30113843083381653,
0.46068352460861206,
0.31536543369293213,
-0.20033268630504608,
0.8899204730987549,
-0.3212428689002991,
-0.04760709032416344,
-0.022117620334029198,
0.4280267357826233,
0.2760276794433594,
-0.7016709446907043,
0.5012582540512085,
-0.34766802191734314,
-0.6847187280654907,
-0.6812159419059753,
0.044778842478990555,
-1.2500094175338745,
-0.43783289194107056,
1.081300139427185,
0.0753045529127121,
-0.28006511926651,
0.35753998160362244,
-0.16750770807266235,
0.10037963092327118,
-0.40322068333625793,
0.7648469805717468,
0.6939342617988586,
-0.3094891905784607,
0.0032174442894756794,
-0.5517386794090271,
0.7357353568077087,
0.4050005376338959,
-0.720541775226593,
0.1401064544916153,
0.3676522970199585,
0.2682071328163147,
0.13425171375274658,
-0.04332645237445831,
-0.04192248359322548,
0.33273759484291077,
-0.11297668516635895,
-0.17276567220687866,
-0.2087450474500656,
-0.7578226327896118,
-0.6146025657653809,
-0.060811758041381836,
0.19351910054683685,
0.37043026089668274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.00948v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.00948v1
|
Modeling Empathetic Alignment in Conversation
| 2024-05-02T02:19:00 | 2024-05-02T02:19:00 |
Jiamin Yang, David Jurgens
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Empathy requires perspective-taking: empathetic responses require a person to
reason about what another has experienced and communicate that understanding in
language. However, most NLP approaches to empathy do not explicitly model this
alignment process. Here, we introduce a new approach to recognizing alignment
in empathetic speech, grounded in Appraisal Theory. We introduce a new dataset
of over 9.2K span-level annotations of different types of appraisals of a
person's experience and over 3K empathetic alignments between a speaker's and
observer's speech. Through computational experiments, we show that these
appraisals and alignments can be accurately recognized. In experiments in over
9.2M Reddit conversations, we find that appraisals capture meaningful groupings
of behavior but that most responses have minimal alignment. However, we find
that mental health professionals engage with substantially more empathetic
alignment.
|
[
-0.40271812677383423,
-0.6067014932632446,
0.6061471700668335,
0.1339198350906372,
0.024093670770525932,
-0.09276538342237473,
-0.09806745499372482,
-0.6660973429679871,
0.6888883113861084,
0.09751290082931519,
-0.5480252504348755,
-0.2730887532234192,
-0.739905595779419,
0.08390817791223526,
-0.25227493047714233,
0.7690454125404358,
0.11722034960985184,
0.10082768648862839,
-0.12987884879112244,
-0.4032445549964905,
-0.3018644452095032,
-0.36000096797943115,
-0.7891110777854919,
-0.5636171102523804,
0.5268717408180237,
0.3852841556072235,
0.8081910014152527,
0.9415909647941589,
0.6151803731918335,
0.20439858734607697,
-0.06801094114780426,
0.04819314554333687,
-0.11292391270399094,
0.07659704983234406,
-0.21881873905658722,
-0.08743365108966827,
-0.8392207622528076,
0.3853791654109955,
0.23134824633598328,
0.6997623443603516,
-0.5112048387527466,
0.04778089001774788,
-0.0759957954287529,
0.5976834297180176,
-0.5460652709007263,
-0.1480313539505005,
-0.3513065278530121,
0.33518069982528687,
0.22648218274116516,
-0.3058140277862549,
-0.3454586863517761,
-0.32968470454216003,
0.3242296576499939,
-0.4175925552845001,
-0.20684091746807098,
0.05940403416752815,
0.6816257238388062,
0.21653234958648682,
-0.37486279010772705,
-0.17601646482944489,
-0.5421521067619324,
0.694830596446991,
-0.7304881811141968,
0.3341517448425293,
0.6065194606781006,
0.23541313409805298,
0.3214758336544037,
-0.3237074911594391,
-0.7097094655036926,
0.2466159611940384,
-0.20259028673171997,
0.1319306641817093,
-0.39593204855918884,
0.0707729160785675,
0.4411793649196625,
0.3214205205440521,
-0.28270938992500305,
0.14966920018196106,
0.1203574687242508,
0.22125482559204102,
0.7973998785018921,
0.5698111057281494,
0.23917295038700104,
-0.1403614729642868,
-0.27511656284332275,
-0.1818648874759674,
0.0820736363530159,
0.13253889977931976,
0.2696790099143982,
0.2939779460430145,
-0.45491135120391846,
0.7012451887130737,
0.33440715074539185,
1.0908890962600708,
0.4435056447982788,
-0.10041418671607971,
0.08505218476057053,
-0.14899595081806183,
-0.2686290442943573,
0.30108267068862915,
0.5899556875228882,
0.9851850271224976,
0.38034772872924805,
0.06782820075750351,
0.26032865047454834,
0.5171353816986084,
0.8665273785591125,
-0.4331446886062622,
-0.3760553300380707,
0.5052725076675415,
-0.45680370926856995,
-0.32640308141708374,
-0.17571376264095306,
-0.7241408824920654,
-0.8443448543548584,
-0.5688149333000183,
0.018620554357767105,
-0.4456590712070465,
-0.36594128608703613,
0.25341689586639404,
-0.05728164315223694,
0.6494771242141724,
0.5578702092170715,
-1.2684621810913086,
0.44962078332901,
1.1054049730300903,
0.8435524702072144,
0.09805544465780258,
-0.4335140585899353,
-0.3488176465034485,
0.07711482048034668,
-0.33576369285583496,
0.9923301339149475,
-0.8421618342399597,
-0.07450288534164429,
-0.07311747968196869,
-0.24392388761043549,
-0.14797669649124146,
-0.20506228506565094,
0.7360707521438599,
0.17548508942127228,
0.12944525480270386,
-0.22293518483638763,
-0.9244076609611511,
-0.012615515850484371,
0.5519447922706604,
-0.39890286326408386,
0.45098161697387695,
0.23279038071632385,
-1.136376976966858,
0.4969654381275177,
-0.5306190848350525,
-0.3026500344276428,
-0.2875060737133026,
-0.300426185131073,
-0.2600318491458893,
0.47768208384513855,
0.12243445217609406,
0.3523251712322235,
-0.0011355102760717273,
0.0749979093670845,
-0.3890974223613739,
-0.1455235779285431,
0.1984325349330902,
-0.13328403234481812,
0.5574864745140076,
0.16422219574451447,
0.030668988823890686,
-0.09351782500743866,
-0.6697984337806702,
0.13672669231891632,
-0.22545017302036285,
0.04183269664645195,
-0.6305088400840759,
0.006607520394027233,
-0.008672844618558884,
0.23382706940174103,
0.030881280079483986,
-0.6884391903877258,
0.3548682928085327,
-0.6564256548881531,
0.4353848993778229,
0.6393752694129944,
-0.12113042920827866,
0.6763460636138916,
-0.5248639583587646,
0.4290880560874939,
0.14785286784172058,
0.3034766912460327,
-0.20337149500846863,
-0.3451662063598633,
-0.34299221634864807,
-0.31264495849609375,
-0.05570352077484131,
0.42067769169807434,
0.293283611536026,
0.6344094276428223,
-0.1617894172668457,
-0.6413721442222595,
-1.0527572631835938,
-0.5117413401603699,
0.3052310645580292,
0.8035567402839661,
0.3594450056552887,
-0.4499458074569702,
-0.6941799521446228,
-0.985870361328125,
-0.7356280088424683,
-0.29198065400123596,
0.09939350932836533,
0.42755430936813354,
-0.01662859320640564,
-0.09380481392145157,
0.8807497024536133,
-0.304592490196228,
-0.3757435977458954,
0.11635191738605499,
0.3271254599094391,
0.09019921720027924,
0.49972063302993774,
0.2671370506286621,
-0.5750604271888733,
-0.3502821624279022,
0.2324671447277069,
-0.6202450394630432,
-0.19921067357063293,
-0.01662406697869301,
-0.2821480929851532,
-0.05790160968899727,
0.1484675407409668,
-0.3244355320930481,
0.3943195641040802,
0.8425238132476807,
-0.6933463215827942,
-0.1816718429327011,
0.05790329352021217,
0.33054211735725403,
-1.2768503427505493,
-0.008504309691488743,
0.23948755860328674,
-0.2680231034755707,
-0.8065211176872253,
-0.37419649958610535,
-0.014723398722708225,
0.3155089020729065,
-0.22112950682640076,
0.555720865726471,
-0.31455546617507935,
-0.1263452172279358,
-0.07128855586051941,
0.5082868933677673,
0.0792330726981163,
0.16038626432418823,
0.2913323938846588,
0.05479661375284195,
0.36039578914642334,
-0.0815514549612999,
0.4401918649673462,
0.714548647403717,
-0.1838959902524948,
1.3912990093231201,
-0.27600958943367004,
0.1556280255317688,
-0.07042520493268967,
0.20525814592838287,
-0.9805377721786499,
-0.34726348519325256,
0.18214420974254608,
-0.6362718343734741,
0.3995971381664276,
-0.059052616357803345,
0.08955152332782745,
-0.1578778475522995,
-0.3765864074230194,
0.5187159180641174,
0.23521895706653595,
-0.472280353307724,
0.8383623361587524,
0.5692899227142334,
-0.1286928802728653,
-0.6481227874755859,
-0.7424029111862183,
0.0316583551466465,
-0.4822908937931061,
-0.4747719168663025,
0.14241942763328552,
0.22752031683921814,
-0.636940598487854,
-0.2089526206254959,
0.03090263158082962,
-0.03670686110854149,
0.09915993362665176,
0.3100467920303345,
-0.11874234676361084,
0.15287266671657562,
0.05641590431332588,
-0.11322052031755447,
-0.191283717751503,
0.026017582044005394,
0.4534462094306946,
0.5100170969963074,
-0.09959323704242706,
-0.5054283142089844,
-0.9130269885063171,
0.4280918538570404,
0.458985298871994,
0.14739198982715607,
0.7707337737083435,
0.4584399163722992,
-0.5759392380714417,
0.416868656873703,
-0.5930918455123901,
-0.34658247232437134,
-0.3067118525505066,
0.14820796251296997,
-0.09853003919124603,
-0.8440670371055603,
0.5578319430351257,
0.1940789669752121,
0.16701921820640564,
0.16774597764015198,
0.5370120406150818,
-0.19310437142848969,
1.6320149898529053,
0.47576919198036194,
-0.15836314857006073,
0.4719739854335785,
0.215611532330513,
0.6661905646324158,
-1.2846046686172485,
-0.12897205352783203,
-0.48618751764297485,
-0.7268181443214417,
-0.6039009690284729,
0.041960228234529495,
0.04382617026567459,
-0.011614599265158176,
-0.3897898197174072,
0.17575249075889587,
-0.6797375082969666,
0.11520382016897202,
0.05001531168818474,
0.07021163403987885,
0.282072514295578,
-0.32477912306785583,
0.3261842131614685,
-0.5140793323516846,
-0.44865182042121887,
-0.6702648997306824,
0.5315373539924622,
0.5522892475128174,
0.8629533648490906,
0.1030397117137909,
0.8873998522758484,
0.14864222705364227,
0.7639199495315552,
-1.0905139446258545,
0.11734627187252045,
0.19834928214550018,
-0.3556362986564636,
-0.3715642988681793,
-0.13822220265865326,
-0.7375051379203796,
0.08375395834445953,
-0.15619821846485138,
-1.0950828790664673,
0.29503434896469116,
0.5380740165710449,
-0.5018768906593323,
0.058829113841056824,
-0.7362701892852783,
0.9327394366264343,
-0.09741944819688797,
-0.20350244641304016,
0.019899236038327217,
-0.8626970052719116,
0.16295045614242554,
0.051914215087890625,
0.32290777564048767,
-0.3641926944255829,
0.10587616264820099,
0.574773907661438,
-0.3058221936225891,
0.8203287124633789,
-0.3017207682132721,
-0.37349429726600647,
-0.10930541902780533,
0.26190438866615295,
0.39914581179618835,
-0.1474929302930832,
0.02920263260602951,
-0.007880814373493195,
0.019654670730233192,
-0.14150100946426392,
-0.7827889323234558,
0.5375660061836243,
-0.4685863256454468,
-0.5115965008735657,
-0.4608619511127472,
-0.4528099596500397,
-0.2886057496070862,
-0.26183947920799255,
0.06145017221570015,
0.021458683535456657,
-0.36764344573020935,
-0.1089925467967987,
0.0641755536198616,
0.14221961796283722,
0.10360843688249588,
0.44148126244544983,
-0.018410759046673775,
-0.35417383909225464,
0.40963125228881836,
-0.17562492191791534,
0.09125060588121414,
0.2952851355075836,
0.3167089521884918,
-0.17053163051605225,
0.1170886680483818,
-0.04030245542526245,
0.36791202425956726,
-0.43201568722724915,
-0.3683799207210541,
-0.7548807263374329,
0.17069587111473083,
-0.45405906438827515,
-0.6425696015357971,
-0.6943538188934326,
-0.6090414524078369,
-0.04480517655611038,
-0.49644455313682556,
0.6553608179092407,
0.6720213294029236,
-0.4932461380958557,
0.2233056128025055,
-0.7016502022743225,
0.010665645822882652,
0.16095001995563507,
0.48175349831581116,
0.3517828583717346,
-0.6360287070274353,
-0.28804531693458557,
0.26628372073173523,
-0.49768367409706116,
-0.9326308965682983,
0.6044279932975769,
0.1964995115995407,
0.13036967813968658,
0.7480753660202026,
0.006450616754591465,
1.0967801809310913,
-0.5766046047210693,
0.8324043154716492,
0.42749348282814026,
-1.2197434902191162,
0.7354434132575989,
-0.2531009912490845,
-0.16014975309371948,
0.46659860014915466,
0.23123708367347717,
-0.8790385723114014,
-0.49709874391555786,
-0.8952010869979858,
-0.87673419713974,
0.7451258301734924,
-0.05255173519253731,
0.22566916048526764,
-0.33310651779174805,
0.4090539216995239,
-0.11433824896812439,
0.10648266971111298,
-0.3182053864002228,
-0.21940454840660095,
-0.05690852180123329,
-0.618250846862793,
-0.24726980924606323,
-0.2535513937473297,
-0.8202754855155945,
-0.37065109610557556,
0.11241327971220016,
-0.13470201194286346,
0.5462665557861328,
0.2732272148132324,
0.33567187190055847,
-0.5087519288063049,
0.06643877178430557,
0.7104266285896301,
0.4792061746120453,
-0.1756548285484314,
0.2509348392486572,
-0.00559845007956028,
-0.22288209199905396,
0.11921017616987228,
-0.06482841819524765,
0.6574946641921997,
-0.32726114988327026,
0.6242747902870178,
0.6125456690788269,
0.33029186725616455,
-0.34350401163101196,
0.8060932159423828,
-0.24498499929904938,
-0.05756693333387375,
-0.07637322694063187,
-0.11708926409482956,
0.21843165159225464,
0.6394531726837158,
-0.23615296185016632,
-0.18777279555797577,
0.1869106888771057,
-0.49026045203208923,
0.19583316147327423,
0.3848770558834076,
-0.5961675047874451,
-0.5116368532180786,
0.7437522411346436,
-0.12735411524772644,
-0.6316922903060913,
0.7063795924186707,
0.5500020980834961,
-0.4037720561027527,
0.30458778142929077,
0.43996089696884155,
1.0404423475265503,
-0.5595657229423523,
0.0695246234536171,
0.2543210983276367,
-0.09791608154773712,
-0.23128700256347656,
0.47045427560806274,
-0.38484707474708557,
-1.111038327217102,
-0.07093149423599243,
-0.5588898062705994,
-0.8752648234367371,
-0.5956961512565613,
-1.3863976001739502,
0.07963792979717255,
-0.208302840590477,
-0.4627504348754883,
0.48789992928504944,
-0.30741819739341736,
-0.5286303162574768,
0.2899916470050812,
0.09210599958896637,
0.6881944537162781,
-1.3295823335647583,
0.4176770746707916,
0.935853123664856,
-0.1805306226015091,
-1.0236916542053223,
0.0011270238319411874,
0.011893847957253456,
-1.1601591110229492,
0.2940851151943207,
0.1446073055267334,
0.07087216526269913,
-0.02230760082602501,
-0.44043728709220886,
-0.4036078155040741,
1.0060279369354248,
0.3554699420928955,
-0.28238558769226074,
0.06693085283041,
-0.22028708457946777,
0.9286396503448486,
-0.8010594248771667,
0.4152408838272095,
0.7316820025444031,
0.5500072836875916,
-0.15472495555877686,
-1.0570036172866821,
-0.2024231106042862,
-0.2274603396654129,
0.053672175854444504,
0.221657395362854,
-0.7641922831535339,
0.6951208114624023,
-0.26094314455986023,
0.02953573688864708,
-0.09066695719957352,
0.18049989640712738,
0.36570924520492554,
0.6703630089759827,
0.20187370479106903,
0.9492177963256836,
0.6793503165245056,
-0.23771284520626068,
0.9902843832969666,
-0.4283854067325592,
0.4379602372646332,
1.236116647720337,
-0.5423872470855713,
1.0437654256820679,
0.909367561340332,
-0.13621313869953156,
0.28725099563598633,
0.7114609479904175,
0.18591882288455963,
0.3635592460632324,
-0.12656906247138977,
-0.20996585488319397,
-0.0624200738966465,
-0.4793863296508789,
-0.14481717348098755,
0.6916133761405945,
0.3193340599536896,
-0.8643865585327148,
0.20164665579795837,
-0.1453191041946411,
0.02978462725877762,
0.3618488013744354,
-0.25299134850502014,
1.1296250820159912,
0.32756951451301575,
-0.6875206828117371,
0.29400745034217834,
-0.21686246991157532,
0.23569384217262268,
-0.09539035707712173,
-0.16506431996822357,
-0.20431190729141235,
0.15059366822242737,
-0.46417418122291565,
-1.1275142431259155,
0.6222586035728455,
-0.011570630595088005,
-0.2040856033563614,
-0.47048237919807434,
0.3982754647731781,
-0.4171847403049469,
0.021550428122282028,
0.47735652327537537,
0.46379631757736206,
0.19727416336536407,
0.2445412129163742,
-0.3705691397190094,
0.11158023029565811,
-0.22737504541873932,
-0.4955156743526459,
0.3765483498573303,
0.6037926077842712,
0.257174551486969,
0.32755568623542786,
0.1327744424343109,
0.07778576016426086,
-0.13909834623336792,
0.26080864667892456,
0.6911442875862122,
-0.7905845046043396,
-0.44051694869995117,
-1.1378730535507202,
0.5284438133239746,
-0.15643790364265442,
-0.3150257468223572,
0.6299163103103638,
0.29447031021118164,
0.7237914800643921,
0.1886093020439148,
0.462787926197052,
-0.01842581294476986,
0.7412278652191162,
-0.25822553038597107,
0.17097929120063782,
-0.6891682147979736,
-0.08076553791761398,
-0.7128661870956421,
-0.9003853797912598,
-0.5054848194122314,
1.4244691133499146,
-0.27160611748695374,
0.05153777077794075,
0.38777807354927063,
0.39808663725852966,
0.22829201817512512,
0.5240175724029541,
0.43744975328445435,
0.29207542538642883,
0.14202351868152618,
0.6281365156173706,
1.0020875930786133,
-0.22657400369644165,
-0.2826172709465027,
-0.2783818542957306,
-0.24191772937774658,
-0.015219828113913536,
-1.1166136264801025,
-0.40247002243995667,
-0.4386541247367859,
-0.31112220883369446,
-0.3722536861896515,
-0.3049700856208801,
1.0821293592453003,
0.30796071887016296,
-0.47709956765174866,
-0.2554938495159149,
-0.10937439650297165,
-0.10543878376483917,
-0.5696178674697876,
-0.21829096972942352,
0.18953190743923187,
0.004684407729655504,
-0.7763314247131348,
-0.16311807930469513,
0.6102085709571838,
0.044100649654865265,
0.0621468722820282,
-0.08169727772474289,
-0.09624190628528595,
0.1295531690120697,
0.4310632050037384,
0.2850366532802582,
-0.5970602035522461,
-0.6980586051940918,
-0.2391888052225113,
-0.007109722588211298,
0.3983622193336487,
0.7987783551216125,
-0.24345941841602325,
0.6189010143280029,
0.1484128087759018,
0.3599352538585663,
0.10570825636386871,
0.6162707805633545,
0.7478397488594055,
-0.732666552066803,
-0.025206780061125755,
0.46052441000938416,
0.2755051255226135,
0.38258373737335205,
-0.4990560710430145,
0.5499258041381836,
-0.07561884820461273,
-0.7677305340766907,
-1.0448344945907593,
0.3555213212966919,
-1.1196682453155518,
0.46939441561698914,
0.8080951571464539,
-0.15990304946899414,
-0.07431977987289429,
0.21419371664524078,
-0.3112104833126068,
0.3306798040866852,
-0.3857042193412781,
0.9954069256782532,
0.9213794469833374,
-1.0182510614395142,
-0.32527559995651245,
-0.0047644623555243015,
0.5546178817749023,
0.38595932722091675,
-0.5287449955940247,
0.44850385189056396,
0.5096989870071411,
-0.19427673518657684,
0.2506650388240814,
0.824612557888031,
-0.0835351049900055,
0.010218995623290539,
-0.025688065215945244,
0.0016792993992567062,
0.4373299479484558,
-0.013185616582632065,
-0.6364117860794067,
-0.06834138184785843,
0.14182378351688385,
-0.05777953192591667
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.