id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10965v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10965v1
|
DocNet: Semantic Structure in Inductive Bias Detection Models
| 2024-06-16T14:51:12 | 2024-06-16T14:51:12 |
Jessica Zhu, Iain Cruickshank, Michel Cukier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
News will have biases so long as people have opinions. However, as social
media becomes the primary entry point for news and partisan gaps increase, it
is increasingly important for informed citizens to be able to identify bias.
People will be able to take action to avoid polarizing echo chambers if they
know how the news they are consuming is biased. In this paper, we explore an
often overlooked aspect of bias detection in documents: the semantic structure
of news articles. We present DocNet, a novel, inductive, and low-resource
document embedding and bias detection model that outperforms large language
models. We also demonstrate that the semantic structure of news articles from
opposing partisan sides, as represented in document-level graph embeddings,
have significant similarities. These results can be used to advance bias
detection in low-resource environments. Our code and data are made available at
https://github.com/nlpresearchanon.
|
[
-0.5499881505966187,
-0.938054084777832,
0.8555421233177185,
0.07080961763858795,
-0.2231452316045761,
-0.08192995935678482,
-0.1739400029182434,
-0.1460893750190735,
0.4440668821334839,
0.4824601411819458,
-0.49359405040740967,
-0.8485325574874878,
-0.9148706793785095,
-0.28537389636039734,
-0.7229089140892029,
1.0375378131866455,
0.01589665375649929,
0.36279889941215515,
-0.30145007371902466,
-0.26847535371780396,
0.1296306550502777,
-0.08389551192522049,
-0.4389182925224304,
-0.40457242727279663,
0.4739808440208435,
0.3486217260360718,
0.683526337146759,
0.5554489493370056,
0.144173726439476,
0.19158458709716797,
-0.3367993235588074,
0.15625113248825073,
-0.35932615399360657,
0.033301349729299545,
-0.2730766832828522,
-0.3255530595779419,
-0.16778333485126495,
0.28860440850257874,
0.8084818720817566,
0.8022914528846741,
0.22770462930202484,
0.015340975485742092,
0.037813883274793625,
0.8662693500518799,
-0.4181916117668152,
0.30996614694595337,
-0.8280104398727417,
0.18324944376945496,
-0.41887378692626953,
-0.05057871341705322,
-0.33786946535110474,
-0.20591941475868225,
-0.11340803653001785,
-0.781541109085083,
0.6914691925048828,
-0.001889382372610271,
0.8389424085617065,
0.26197242736816406,
-0.6672868132591248,
-0.44275519251823425,
-0.14616288244724274,
0.4017813801765442,
-0.5003577470779419,
0.42271313071250916,
0.4312347173690796,
-0.011714556254446507,
-0.24283035099506378,
-0.5224642753601074,
-0.6849499940872192,
-0.11922252923250198,
-0.0889410674571991,
0.18894290924072266,
-0.04076289385557175,
-0.016632940620183945,
0.17816556990146637,
0.03463165462017059,
-0.4518755078315735,
0.11748576909303665,
-0.30762702226638794,
-0.05747785419225693,
0.19363386929035187,
0.0002623040054459125,
0.3190056383609772,
-0.6005821824073792,
-0.25855541229248047,
0.06062958016991615,
-0.415200412273407,
-0.2371789515018463,
1.0075191259384155,
0.33604294061660767,
-0.31423136591911316,
0.6037827730178833,
-0.2969715893268585,
0.6304105520248413,
0.34997498989105225,
0.1652545928955078,
0.2962144613265991,
-0.2112710177898407,
0.05378538370132446,
0.33654478192329407,
0.7658482193946838,
0.42217186093330383,
-0.030686046928167343,
0.000839165470097214,
0.05630924552679062,
0.44725820422172546,
0.327148973941803,
-0.48068368434906006,
-0.10488463938236237,
0.17460918426513672,
-0.8308315873146057,
-0.7193952202796936,
0.09368836134672165,
-0.7177531123161316,
-0.9311401844024658,
-0.21055442094802856,
-0.31203505396842957,
-0.2540489435195923,
-0.3742218315601349,
-0.022918900474905968,
-0.5847312211990356,
0.3465002775192261,
0.3691912889480591,
-0.5458749532699585,
0.42543506622314453,
1.0688238143920898,
0.9922897815704346,
-0.07778363674879074,
-0.17920523881912231,
-0.6042999625205994,
-0.19743169844150543,
-0.3628864288330078,
0.9778124094009399,
-0.6403697729110718,
-0.04994462430477142,
0.06998749077320099,
0.12784434854984283,
0.33035990595817566,
-0.3500889241695404,
0.8856312036514282,
-0.5702075362205505,
0.36435648798942566,
-0.3169004023075104,
-0.6485370397567749,
0.1149129793047905,
0.4628131091594696,
-0.9309934377670288,
0.6954069137573242,
0.23892377316951752,
-1.5105551481246948,
0.45342907309532166,
-0.6759658455848694,
-0.6663705110549927,
-0.3517947494983673,
-0.28159892559051514,
-0.5270848870277405,
0.1026173010468483,
0.22226159274578094,
0.05224601551890373,
-0.32569944858551025,
0.1542317271232605,
-0.5097056031227112,
-0.06118958815932274,
0.14713265001773834,
-0.23064106702804565,
1.1192543506622314,
0.030791886150836945,
-0.24964174628257751,
0.13427847623825073,
-0.7982480525970459,
-0.34181103110313416,
0.07606221735477448,
-0.3614501953125,
-0.8032699823379517,
0.1397094577550888,
0.22929838299751282,
0.30173853039741516,
-0.08772707730531693,
-0.7564582228660583,
0.06911071389913559,
-0.07508599013090134,
0.4882943332195282,
0.7888453006744385,
-0.15991513431072235,
1.103440523147583,
-0.050607822835445404,
0.10344801843166351,
0.44894254207611084,
0.24111658334732056,
0.1083887368440628,
-0.42999303340911865,
-0.6937538981437683,
0.05250142142176628,
0.29432544112205505,
0.18266664445400238,
-0.6815891861915588,
0.3549809157848358,
-0.045855406671762466,
-0.14688661694526672,
-0.5726171731948853,
0.17753514647483826,
0.0714096650481224,
0.8491976857185364,
0.2764829397201538,
-0.2616713345050812,
-0.47490817308425903,
-1.0300899744033813,
-0.6296234130859375,
-0.08707956224679947,
-0.04751911386847496,
0.12003710865974426,
0.36337044835090637,
-0.1937025934457779,
0.8365932703018188,
-0.132574662566185,
-0.3607372045516968,
-0.008339141495525837,
0.1682887077331543,
0.30985933542251587,
0.12021660804748535,
0.22525380551815033,
-0.9732136130332947,
-0.3862130343914032,
-0.09621040523052216,
-0.8411735892295837,
-0.39603355526924133,
0.046851254999637604,
-0.24148663878440857,
0.1515590250492096,
0.560994029045105,
-0.6956905722618103,
0.24301335215568542,
0.4933166801929474,
-0.6553874611854553,
0.27337583899497986,
0.26128482818603516,
-0.36320623755455017,
-1.0296680927276611,
-0.2591210603713989,
0.1763022094964981,
-0.43268725275993347,
-0.5487962365150452,
-0.19811302423477173,
0.20708425343036652,
0.016061125323176384,
-0.40650972723960876,
0.49466705322265625,
-0.5620737671852112,
-0.2730940878391266,
-0.4982319176197052,
0.47924959659576416,
0.38341057300567627,
0.05576641857624054,
0.018640972673892975,
0.22792159020900726,
0.35524699091911316,
-0.07742425054311752,
0.15764571726322174,
0.19074556231498718,
-0.5935083031654358,
0.725378155708313,
-0.601125180721283,
0.1075584813952446,
-0.5315338373184204,
0.6018984317779541,
-0.5158268213272095,
0.022911926731467247,
0.32336556911468506,
-0.44180044531822205,
0.13597503304481506,
-0.5087486505508423,
-0.4241018295288086,
-0.22828248143196106,
-0.4587095081806183,
0.052640292793512344,
-0.07891800999641418,
-0.4146237075328827,
0.5824182629585266,
0.7115745544433594,
0.23035062849521637,
-0.762836754322052,
-0.7454836964607239,
0.10586792975664139,
0.037615276873111725,
-0.79630047082901,
0.45555976033210754,
0.2744433581829071,
-0.5049048662185669,
0.6555977463722229,
-0.12092798203229904,
0.0033301482908427715,
-0.048524159938097,
0.28062430024147034,
0.1592860370874405,
-0.2822079360485077,
0.3165217936038971,
0.09837318956851959,
-0.12236693501472473,
0.09518052637577057,
-0.7300890684127808,
0.6166918873786926,
-0.05786957964301109,
-0.19130447506904602,
-0.2375286966562271,
0.6574673056602478,
0.8178290724754333,
-0.21698099374771118,
0.7365636229515076,
0.8027292490005493,
-0.2622818648815155,
-0.5150434374809265,
-0.6651897430419922,
-0.2378600537776947,
-0.34392935037612915,
0.4808044135570526,
0.08753746002912521,
-0.5888870358467102,
0.5194493532180786,
0.13558265566825867,
-0.3704318702220917,
0.44585973024368286,
0.64265376329422,
0.045254264026880264,
0.7885057926177979,
0.5109125971794128,
-0.32179033756256104,
0.6010144948959351,
-0.27637895941734314,
0.13243848085403442,
-0.8694960474967957,
-0.04585929214954376,
-0.46394747495651245,
-0.3575460612773895,
-0.6817404627799988,
-0.43396905064582825,
0.17959070205688477,
-0.2552441954612732,
-0.11403054744005203,
-0.03989483416080475,
-0.6966592073440552,
0.5429944396018982,
0.7453808188438416,
0.12508608400821686,
0.32385843992233276,
0.08986873179674149,
-0.007012825924903154,
0.24110902845859528,
-0.6296166777610779,
-0.322467178106308,
0.850127100944519,
0.39654043316841125,
0.9349266290664673,
-0.31613656878471375,
0.5742309093475342,
0.5710633993148804,
0.2648615539073944,
-0.8617138266563416,
0.12846779823303223,
-0.17257092893123627,
-0.6060170531272888,
-0.3326229751110077,
-0.35867124795913696,
-0.5887218713760376,
0.44400325417518616,
-0.24582675099372864,
-0.205409973859787,
0.6134595274925232,
-0.41870495676994324,
0.2735169231891632,
0.47565513849258423,
-0.6857075095176697,
0.7966477274894714,
-0.0688764750957489,
-0.3829486072063446,
-0.1962917596101761,
-0.5085723400115967,
0.17250092327594757,
0.23711630702018738,
0.22532032430171967,
-0.41842254996299744,
-0.02642718143761158,
0.7462023496627808,
-0.4317336678504944,
0.7619890570640564,
-0.2946683168411255,
0.30487877130508423,
0.17151640355587006,
-0.1334082931280136,
0.6985070705413818,
0.24178139865398407,
-0.09680387377738953,
0.3337642252445221,
-0.40662628412246704,
-0.44186681509017944,
-0.5233685970306396,
0.8374488353729248,
-0.8304714560508728,
-0.46741071343421936,
-0.4680859446525574,
-0.693990170955658,
0.06486284732818604,
0.44028517603874207,
0.2421443611383438,
0.31325456500053406,
-0.3068385720252991,
0.1581476330757141,
0.6402206420898438,
0.03351067379117012,
0.2600516676902771,
0.6529034376144409,
0.11580006033182144,
-0.046050455421209335,
0.4076288342475891,
0.24158717691898346,
-0.17394337058067322,
0.16288092732429504,
0.20711733400821686,
-0.013061814941465855,
-0.40057846903800964,
-0.24952928721904755,
0.20752178132534027,
-0.7776294946670532,
-0.05890383943915367,
-1.0362862348556519,
-0.2208661288022995,
-0.40661847591400146,
-0.23187357187271118,
-0.5022315382957458,
-0.4903514087200165,
-0.1273958384990692,
-0.3019344210624695,
-0.0015289164148271084,
0.7970195412635803,
0.026867719367146492,
0.061316050589084625,
-0.17128132283687592,
0.3577249348163605,
0.24600203335285187,
0.30928516387939453,
-0.1301448941230774,
-0.056078050285577774,
-0.1101827323436737,
-0.18187659978866577,
-0.24093040823936462,
-0.9856901168823242,
0.2305298000574112,
-0.295559287071228,
0.5394198298454285,
0.3343413472175598,
0.2616485357284546,
-0.14106282591819763,
-0.6870895028114319,
0.4427814483642578,
0.1450406163930893,
-0.7591246366500854,
0.5335279703140259,
-0.478606641292572,
0.20778043568134308,
0.4762444496154785,
0.4678439497947693,
-0.5052889585494995,
-0.518970787525177,
-0.5799981355667114,
-0.7005872130393982,
0.6617036461830139,
0.06013653054833412,
0.05026426538825035,
-0.2835361361503601,
-0.12076979130506516,
-0.007697733584791422,
0.07211620360612869,
-0.6094529628753662,
0.010508894920349121,
-0.5810753703117371,
-0.2387447953224182,
0.2795362174510956,
-0.3702680170536041,
-0.5333285927772522,
-0.06253647059202194,
0.4879923462867737,
-0.2726893723011017,
0.24922826886177063,
0.3774071931838989,
-0.3226265609264374,
0.031347695738077164,
0.3066684603691101,
0.3978477120399475,
0.5386017560958862,
-0.24359658360481262,
0.4604436755180359,
-0.18412986397743225,
-0.37784668803215027,
-0.028738997876644135,
0.3474194407463074,
-0.5123234391212463,
0.45722466707229614,
0.37006253004074097,
0.6481592655181885,
0.014158911071717739,
-0.04707453027367592,
0.9680109620094299,
-0.16089636087417603,
-0.09984410554170609,
-0.5628123879432678,
-0.46397143602371216,
0.3724166750907898,
0.4292523264884949,
0.30342891812324524,
-0.0002320867351954803,
0.4310564398765564,
-0.6920799016952515,
0.11047928035259247,
0.5462652444839478,
-0.8188844919204712,
-0.09756407141685486,
0.49219810962677,
0.3881891369819641,
-0.11930685490369797,
0.5378506183624268,
-0.32576972246170044,
-0.5961202383041382,
0.8093429803848267,
0.4301086664199829,
0.9001239538192749,
0.3195745348930359,
0.5551354885101318,
-0.021075285971164703,
0.5790000557899475,
0.13644541800022125,
-0.19308970868587494,
-0.03801937401294708,
-1.0280267000198364,
0.022972287610173225,
-0.49395841360092163,
-0.2619364559650421,
-0.10619154572486877,
-0.3931598365306854,
0.40552762150764465,
-0.48018571734428406,
-0.26901963353157043,
0.3719022572040558,
-0.04025411605834961,
-0.5842952132225037,
-0.23950614035129547,
0.30039140582084656,
1.0933290719985962,
-0.9075333476066589,
0.9443095326423645,
0.5124421715736389,
-0.3006609082221985,
-0.20815467834472656,
0.17504025995731354,
0.5266489386558533,
-0.6089943647384644,
0.6895385980606079,
0.11330762505531311,
0.10259710997343063,
-0.4768297076225281,
-0.4645366072654724,
-0.4229861795902252,
0.9701678156852722,
0.42673414945602417,
-0.26562291383743286,
-0.41471850872039795,
-0.12303357571363449,
0.31089603900909424,
-0.5028561353683472,
0.19953234493732452,
0.27297699451446533,
0.65330970287323,
-0.41825249791145325,
-0.31428879499435425,
0.1235937625169754,
-0.309089720249176,
-0.04298773035407066,
0.17013899981975555,
-0.6834399104118347,
1.1427953243255615,
0.26941558718681335,
-0.11996206641197205,
-0.7292018532752991,
0.3607783317565918,
-0.2851554751396179,
0.5441372394561768,
0.6143850684165955,
0.6710798740386963,
0.9614627361297607,
-0.10800948739051819,
1.213515281677246,
-0.4670022428035736,
0.34889423847198486,
1.1090807914733887,
-0.24393302202224731,
0.27657175064086914,
0.3356691598892212,
0.208917036652565,
0.8230588436126709,
0.3687905967235565,
0.005255257710814476,
0.6201592683792114,
0.16070200502872467,
-0.2682996988296509,
-0.034188371151685715,
-0.5754719972610474,
-0.29925352334976196,
0.30505505204200745,
0.4059235751628876,
-0.7517614364624023,
-0.4598684310913086,
-0.018427949398756027,
0.3850953280925751,
0.16742229461669922,
-0.35804182291030884,
0.5716608762741089,
0.16235031187534332,
-0.43281853199005127,
0.002007987117394805,
0.020401470363140106,
0.6874402165412903,
-0.611660361289978,
0.16419395804405212,
-0.3685128092765808,
0.12270751595497131,
-0.3986116647720337,
-0.9195271730422974,
0.3321061432361603,
-0.2770727574825287,
-0.723829984664917,
-0.08885044604539871,
1.2009544372558594,
-0.3762812614440918,
-0.3803249001502991,
0.7266358137130737,
0.43966320157051086,
-0.38507258892059326,
-0.23823462426662445,
-0.6009249091148376,
0.18493033945560455,
-0.45833271741867065,
-0.3478376269340515,
0.23822243511676788,
0.44982999563217163,
-0.11054778844118118,
0.23345133662223816,
0.8130276203155518,
0.07441844791173935,
0.050493743270635605,
0.26286953687667847,
1.1077954769134521,
-0.2864118814468384,
-0.6509706974029541,
-0.750311553478241,
0.048835303634405136,
-0.807266354560852,
-0.16678698360919952,
0.7893239259719849,
0.509353756904602,
0.8045558929443359,
0.09469915926456451,
0.8862148523330688,
0.0046042283065617085,
0.30274707078933716,
-0.5552862286567688,
1.0606389045715332,
-0.2640373408794403,
-0.16769422590732574,
-0.18998368084430695,
-0.8997148275375366,
-0.1843322068452835,
0.4658487141132355,
-0.35835349559783936,
-0.34029024839401245,
0.9153162240982056,
0.8477945327758789,
-0.3434758484363556,
-0.010484514757990837,
0.002546184230595827,
0.36050426959991455,
0.17712587118148804,
0.3244864344596863,
0.7992963194847107,
-0.10920919477939606,
0.3400009274482727,
-0.18811723589897156,
-0.24887250363826752,
-0.2589464783668518,
-0.7324720621109009,
-1.0398333072662354,
-0.5969987511634827,
-0.13042733073234558,
-0.8408908247947693,
0.2869170904159546,
0.6483988165855408,
0.7465576529502869,
-0.6260995864868164,
0.08273298293352127,
-0.20386260747909546,
0.896702229976654,
0.14477506279945374,
-0.27745306491851807,
0.5310556888580322,
-0.4322517514228821,
-0.64005446434021,
0.20930242538452148,
0.3550621271133423,
-0.47697460651397705,
-0.37328699231147766,
0.021417878568172455,
-0.5055722594261169,
0.19617125391960144,
0.4190254211425781,
0.22421301901340485,
-0.6464592218399048,
-0.28787821531295776,
-0.1528032273054123,
-0.4179162383079529,
0.028110943734645844,
1.1414304971694946,
-0.5890734195709229,
0.6092017292976379,
0.8644276857376099,
0.6745541095733643,
0.7002431154251099,
-0.12100520730018616,
0.2773687243461609,
-0.6868000030517578,
0.5300593972206116,
0.08719027787446976,
0.5330548286437988,
0.5815857648849487,
-0.35583239793777466,
0.6549438834190369,
0.4192710518836975,
-0.352559357881546,
-0.46662330627441406,
0.17043724656105042,
-0.9454546570777893,
-0.44469672441482544,
1.2447768449783325,
0.2699042856693268,
-0.5637105703353882,
-0.36826425790786743,
-0.06513068079948425,
0.2760964035987854,
-0.48592913150787354,
0.7788681387901306,
0.7527605891227722,
0.2955952286720276,
-0.05876389518380165,
-0.5993777513504028,
0.30474820733070374,
0.04723571985960007,
-0.47089502215385437,
-0.18087847530841827,
0.39124393463134766,
0.36324310302734375,
0.2809179723262787,
0.878944993019104,
-0.2677473723888397,
0.21712325513362885,
0.31302782893180847,
-0.040283817797899246,
-0.29634204506874084,
-0.09768147766590118,
-0.13584671914577484,
0.17714428901672363,
-0.2894284129142761,
-0.14383767545223236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10960v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10960v1
|
ESCoT: Towards Interpretable Emotional Support Dialogue Systems
| 2024-06-16T14:37:17 | 2024-06-16T14:37:17 |
Tenggan Zhang, Xinjie Zhang, Jinming Zhao, Li Zhou, Qin Jin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Understanding the reason for emotional support response is crucial for
establishing connections between users and emotional support dialogue systems.
Previous works mostly focus on generating better responses but ignore
interpretability, which is extremely important for constructing reliable
dialogue systems. To empower the system with better interpretability, we
propose an emotional support response generation scheme, named
$\textbf{E}$motion-Focused and $\textbf{S}$trategy-Driven
$\textbf{C}$hain-$\textbf{o}$f-$\textbf{T}$hought ($\textbf{ESCoT}$), mimicking
the process of $\textit{identifying}$, $\textit{understanding}$, and
$\textit{regulating}$ emotions. Specially, we construct a new dataset with
ESCoT in two steps: (1) $\textit{Dialogue Generation}$ where we first generate
diverse conversation situations, then enhance dialogue generation using richer
emotional support strategies based on these situations; (2) $\textit{Chain
Supplement}$ where we focus on supplementing selected dialogues with elements
such as emotion, stimuli, appraisal, and strategy reason, forming the manually
verified chains. Additionally, we further develop a model to generate dialogue
responses with better interpretability. We also conduct extensive experiments
and human evaluations to validate the effectiveness of the proposed ESCoT and
generated dialogue responses. Our data and code are available at
$\href{https://github.com/TeigenZhang/ESCoT}{https://github.com/TeigenZhang/ESCoT}$.
|
[
-0.42615771293640137,
-0.5669971704483032,
0.625284731388092,
0.4108022451400757,
-0.37679773569107056,
0.05188713222742081,
-0.046530432999134064,
-0.4741344153881073,
0.6640649437904358,
0.7347748875617981,
-1.0430762767791748,
-0.36310577392578125,
-0.44554275274276733,
0.478640079498291,
-0.31217753887176514,
1.258684754371643,
0.019925761967897415,
-0.1376567929983139,
-0.07618778198957443,
-0.2753966152667999,
-0.35176122188568115,
-0.35138118267059326,
-0.6744523644447327,
-0.08534454554319382,
0.33943814039230347,
0.7133223414421082,
0.2533853352069855,
0.12271630764007568,
0.3236692249774933,
0.25756341218948364,
-0.22680816054344177,
0.5306143164634705,
-0.4702398180961609,
0.7224982976913452,
0.13922670483589172,
-0.08204663544893265,
-0.7129775881767273,
-0.6493276953697205,
0.17277564108371735,
-0.029426230117678642,
-0.698473334312439,
-0.08436263352632523,
0.40104714035987854,
0.3656950294971466,
-0.39284443855285645,
0.219949871301651,
-0.5464943051338196,
0.294397234916687,
0.040509894490242004,
-0.23471620678901672,
-0.5946131348609924,
0.06987277418375015,
0.03502568602561951,
-0.5870737433433533,
-0.021048175171017647,
0.46920135617256165,
0.6759817600250244,
0.07995403558015823,
-0.6751874089241028,
-0.5143356919288635,
-0.48406532406806946,
0.5064457654953003,
-0.5919476747512817,
0.1941465139389038,
0.0712343230843544,
0.40331441164016724,
-0.05804571509361267,
-0.6154448390007019,
-0.48214879631996155,
0.02878018468618393,
-0.20605739951133728,
0.6340398788452148,
-0.18849489092826843,
0.5095816850662231,
0.6031666398048401,
0.007233328185975552,
-0.39170047640800476,
-0.29586464166641235,
0.10043095797300339,
-0.23992212116718292,
0.3927987515926361,
0.5151477456092834,
0.37852737307548523,
-0.2914656400680542,
-0.3869273364543915,
0.24384663999080658,
-0.460798054933548,
-0.0026533312629908323,
0.2954675853252411,
0.29453006386756897,
-0.17933949828147888,
0.49745893478393555,
-0.18762995302677155,
0.23070873320102692,
0.2518427073955536,
0.34218931198120117,
-0.06700646877288818,
-0.16083738207817078,
-0.2891457974910736,
0.10836739838123322,
0.6326100826263428,
0.681425154209137,
0.07189621031284332,
0.33215850591659546,
-0.31493687629699707,
-0.1727679967880249,
0.428347110748291,
-1.07109534740448,
0.23332521319389343,
0.306495726108551,
-0.4254146218299866,
-0.4086013436317444,
0.0681380033493042,
-0.9079691767692566,
-0.343277245759964,
-0.17402178049087524,
-0.1509031504392624,
-0.32045426964759827,
-0.5075364112854004,
0.13003790378570557,
0.01655837893486023,
0.20797432959079742,
0.47705206274986267,
-0.8839365839958191,
0.5387524366378784,
0.48354628682136536,
0.9106696248054504,
-0.03401399776339531,
0.030280696228146553,
-0.659780740737915,
0.15599122643470764,
0.3058362603187561,
0.8243821859359741,
-0.46869149804115295,
-0.5733942985534668,
0.21820810437202454,
0.2770383059978485,
0.17042848467826843,
-0.24345847964286804,
0.7522649168968201,
-0.2154984325170517,
0.014409339055418968,
-0.4092252850532532,
-0.2428158074617386,
0.11916343122720718,
0.22951427102088928,
-0.5485442876815796,
0.6867454648017883,
-0.06850579380989075,
-0.7272489666938782,
0.011783109977841377,
-0.8964967727661133,
-0.48099368810653687,
-0.07020343840122223,
0.047261402010917664,
-0.36979421973228455,
0.2683655321598053,
0.17635266482830048,
0.2371416687965393,
-0.33543652296066284,
0.32961004972457886,
-0.4358047544956207,
-0.06006164476275444,
0.22724227607250214,
-0.5412652492523193,
0.44497668743133545,
0.6323061585426331,
-0.5220333337783813,
-0.1386634111404419,
-0.7500738501548767,
0.28458482027053833,
-0.08378872275352478,
0.06501952558755875,
0.14338262379169464,
0.16697929799556732,
0.24165016412734985,
0.2572767436504364,
-0.19518263638019562,
-0.6096546649932861,
-0.24076516926288605,
-0.17021790146827698,
0.46348080039024353,
0.8859036564826965,
0.1851930469274521,
0.07258716970682144,
0.0681384801864624,
0.845552384853363,
0.2524377107620239,
0.22711282968521118,
-0.4498750567436218,
-0.4356093406677246,
-0.6248570680618286,
0.16393707692623138,
-0.32128971815109253,
0.2090214639902115,
-0.9491671323776245,
0.14601728320121765,
0.02563777007162571,
-0.17191681265830994,
-0.2517351806163788,
-0.34653016924858093,
0.5427548885345459,
0.7108284831047058,
0.2764151394367218,
-0.42150551080703735,
-0.8174683451652527,
-0.8682982325553894,
-0.3749762773513794,
-0.40951240062713623,
-0.16095221042633057,
0.6584998369216919,
0.1924864947795868,
-0.11873213201761246,
0.7018082141876221,
-0.5452605485916138,
0.18894913792610168,
-0.18983891606330872,
0.11867669224739075,
-0.14862892031669617,
0.1563369184732437,
0.2566373944282532,
-0.6901293396949768,
-0.6959991455078125,
0.16867202520370483,
-0.5478939414024353,
-0.7671376466751099,
-0.014507494866847992,
-0.3967756927013397,
0.016045989468693733,
0.18145489692687988,
-0.35366833209991455,
0.3851054310798645,
0.6260277032852173,
-0.6266787052154541,
0.5354693531990051,
0.19467227160930634,
0.3543204069137573,
-1.1830378770828247,
0.07463257014751434,
-0.2326798141002655,
-0.5211748480796814,
-0.6768591403961182,
-0.29572388529777527,
-0.07529313862323761,
-0.4879399538040161,
-0.6528425812721252,
0.18864752352237701,
-0.24613581597805023,
0.027119329199194908,
-0.10963033139705658,
0.38192716240882874,
0.3459542691707611,
0.6556280851364136,
0.06895889341831207,
0.34768208861351013,
0.41424882411956787,
-0.35344767570495605,
0.35375529527664185,
0.5129943490028381,
0.1180807426571846,
1.3830660581588745,
-1.0158815383911133,
0.38379329442977905,
-0.23674005270004272,
0.37145867943763733,
-0.7255403399467468,
-0.2768456041812897,
0.45442402362823486,
-0.2737449109554291,
0.08313357084989548,
0.03771147131919861,
0.08422712236642838,
-0.3350170850753784,
-0.00883309543132782,
0.12823545932769775,
0.21262148022651672,
-0.4489656686782837,
1.1197543144226074,
0.2999485433101654,
-0.26829424500465393,
-0.3378938138484955,
-0.6102815270423889,
0.09330865740776062,
-0.3202863335609436,
-0.7075759172439575,
0.1328679323196411,
-0.3809981942176819,
-0.12314929813146591,
-0.06297385692596436,
-0.09314116090536118,
0.2727380096912384,
0.058540549129247665,
0.46192944049835205,
-0.02247648499906063,
-0.11196623742580414,
0.3431455194950104,
0.461409330368042,
-0.21471074223518372,
0.12792165577411652,
-0.31164616346359253,
0.3036240041255951,
-0.3891492187976837,
-0.5956874489784241,
-0.3478960692882538,
0.8529690504074097,
0.92032790184021,
-0.14709724485874176,
0.7164415717124939,
0.34480950236320496,
-0.3408626317977905,
-0.24059626460075378,
-0.07330867648124695,
-0.29861000180244446,
-0.47496965527534485,
0.4449171721935272,
-0.4422893226146698,
-0.659386932849884,
0.5741462707519531,
-0.01182468980550766,
-0.0017275386489927769,
0.2969110310077667,
0.49623772501945496,
-0.14851664006710052,
1.6451892852783203,
0.3184916079044342,
0.44767406582832336,
0.6136143803596497,
0.200477734208107,
0.19970954954624176,
-0.9956347942352295,
-0.35246169567108154,
-0.5174562335014343,
-0.35027381777763367,
-0.4118238687515259,
0.17362886667251587,
0.362461119890213,
-0.3478497266769409,
-0.3885524868965149,
0.3854541480541229,
-0.44616931676864624,
0.2326136976480484,
-0.07683015614748001,
0.20259203016757965,
0.09822830557823181,
0.07013031840324402,
-0.29167288541793823,
-0.19638895988464355,
-0.5675155520439148,
-0.573856770992279,
0.6001796126365662,
0.5072643756866455,
0.7578833103179932,
0.25322169065475464,
0.5495458245277405,
0.31905224919319153,
0.5834147930145264,
-0.8645511865615845,
0.47492316365242004,
0.02077106386423111,
-0.2595319151878357,
-0.0007884104852564633,
-0.4278881549835205,
-0.666326105594635,
0.15781579911708832,
-0.16372063755989075,
-0.8777095079421997,
-0.056454166769981384,
0.2871893644332886,
-0.3657207787036896,
-0.031461793929338455,
-0.9211138486862183,
0.4435752034187317,
-0.5173223614692688,
-0.3246685564517975,
0.08295034617185593,
-0.7081781029701233,
-0.03629079833626747,
0.131702721118927,
0.11879777163267136,
0.05345937982201576,
0.3363131880760193,
0.6327784061431885,
-0.8974799513816833,
0.8929311037063599,
-0.45227113366127014,
-0.15697404742240906,
0.5317559242248535,
0.07939604669809341,
0.9507721662521362,
0.15321004390716553,
-0.26774898171424866,
-0.42605844140052795,
0.0026095828507095575,
-0.31272459030151367,
-0.9112306237220764,
0.4569552540779114,
-0.4985142946243286,
-0.7280759215354919,
-0.06713314354419708,
-0.23897401988506317,
-0.31500667333602905,
0.055247001349925995,
0.12988562881946564,
0.5505359172821045,
-0.1112048476934433,
0.3497389853000641,
0.45948296785354614,
-0.18608458340168,
-0.05905812606215477,
0.7256415486335754,
-0.28562790155410767,
-0.550664484500885,
0.5352417230606079,
-0.18639999628067017,
0.4875461459159851,
0.15588116645812988,
0.08593690395355225,
-0.42947596311569214,
-0.019591283053159714,
-0.4001404643058777,
0.007644759491086006,
-0.447400838136673,
-0.3577896058559418,
-0.7624068260192871,
-0.0512131005525589,
-0.2083931565284729,
-0.021107060834765434,
-0.2340134233236313,
-0.17488214373588562,
-0.21976882219314575,
-0.5791013836860657,
0.5236424803733826,
0.8907073736190796,
0.10050756484270096,
0.3397846221923828,
-0.8670405149459839,
-0.003482002764940262,
0.28701674938201904,
0.3013683259487152,
0.018588699400424957,
-0.308479905128479,
-0.48753654956817627,
0.40169185400009155,
-0.6862149834632874,
-1.1523098945617676,
0.3170696794986725,
0.2677277624607086,
0.25847405195236206,
0.5947849750518799,
0.2775360345840454,
0.8415803909301758,
-0.44272947311401367,
0.8914274573326111,
0.5517669916152954,
-1.3383336067199707,
0.8274492621421814,
-0.28401243686676025,
-0.014413139782845974,
0.378728985786438,
-0.133818119764328,
-0.9930340051651001,
-0.6476663947105408,
-0.8732398152351379,
-1.056664228439331,
0.9692567586898804,
0.5455105304718018,
0.18708114326000214,
-0.11603866517543793,
0.11660131812095642,
-0.16905958950519562,
0.390175461769104,
-0.3634170591831207,
-0.05808666720986366,
-0.2719859182834625,
-0.46388211846351624,
0.319715678691864,
-0.23083670437335968,
-0.17938821017742157,
0.4733540713787079,
0.5977386236190796,
-0.49950116872787476,
0.5203797221183777,
0.3306468427181244,
0.14882777631282806,
-0.5437874794006348,
0.2540051341056824,
0.6200369596481323,
-0.030909834429621696,
0.0628971979022026,
0.17575404047966003,
0.38414621353149414,
-0.4518887400627136,
0.022033918648958206,
-0.22608095407485962,
0.006475094240158796,
-0.04029342532157898,
0.01098339818418026,
1.2351713180541992,
0.13053841888904572,
-0.7278327345848083,
0.38007494807243347,
-0.46413475275039673,
-0.018949368968605995,
-0.08317315578460693,
0.06793158501386642,
-0.14532168209552765,
0.3232804536819458,
0.016512718051671982,
0.19117185473442078,
0.1805380880832672,
-0.44378408789634705,
0.31567445397377014,
0.10175251215696335,
-0.8627795577049255,
-0.6041439771652222,
0.7176642417907715,
0.6691442131996155,
-0.6895685195922852,
0.6183595657348633,
-0.05292978882789612,
-0.8250397443771362,
0.8118354678153992,
0.7966448664665222,
1.0975316762924194,
-0.1179545596241951,
0.5893875956535339,
0.3867741823196411,
-0.09620485454797745,
0.031102249398827553,
0.5656907558441162,
-0.2531093955039978,
-0.8183841109275818,
-0.039401620626449585,
-0.43983739614486694,
-0.6592282652854919,
-0.309479296207428,
-1.039462924003601,
0.36416101455688477,
-0.08738982677459717,
-0.2827339470386505,
-0.647859513759613,
-0.4266984760761261,
-0.7327827215194702,
0.16634567081928253,
0.18513336777687073,
0.8155651688575745,
-0.8990668654441833,
0.2010946422815323,
0.5550273656845093,
-0.31056684255599976,
-1.1714023351669312,
0.08083736896514893,
0.2207978516817093,
-0.7642557621002197,
0.29572731256484985,
0.12994113564491272,
-0.5702283382415771,
0.07513190060853958,
-0.5144363045692444,
-0.3305427134037018,
1.2745020389556885,
0.33521080017089844,
-0.7472203373908997,
0.09490494430065155,
0.05058612674474716,
0.7671639919281006,
-0.800069272518158,
0.885690450668335,
0.33521440625190735,
0.48243314027786255,
0.24713660776615143,
-0.5439322590827942,
0.2522321939468384,
-0.6372712850570679,
0.046483688056468964,
0.18833783268928528,
-0.9052655696868896,
0.22195400297641754,
-0.06663412600755692,
-0.5824926495552063,
0.22003982961177826,
0.3053489625453949,
0.4336054027080536,
0.49875107407569885,
0.6463786363601685,
0.30827826261520386,
0.8692102432250977,
-0.2261831909418106,
0.9574705362319946,
-0.5071269869804382,
0.516203761100769,
0.8874598145484924,
-0.5382980704307556,
0.5531777739524841,
0.7654882669448853,
-0.1027543917298317,
0.6938280463218689,
0.4971105754375458,
0.4422364830970764,
0.2930542826652527,
0.09948635846376419,
-0.3168685734272003,
-0.15258531272411346,
-0.6948854327201843,
-0.09448125958442688,
0.2030111700296402,
0.6337663531303406,
-0.6060227155685425,
0.11773446202278137,
0.10418177396059036,
-0.08608540147542953,
-0.07371140271425247,
-0.002078739693388343,
0.7273246049880981,
0.35826575756073,
-0.7255961298942566,
0.21732476353645325,
-0.4094997048377991,
0.15504615008831024,
-0.6124378442764282,
-0.08332788199186325,
-0.3528902232646942,
-0.3313480019569397,
-0.4622231423854828,
-0.8320103287696838,
0.35843759775161743,
0.5309346318244934,
0.17162084579467773,
-0.6936064958572388,
0.7412837743759155,
-0.47758185863494873,
-0.15103206038475037,
0.2883455157279968,
0.5140812993049622,
0.03641386702656746,
0.280191034078598,
-0.5538207292556763,
0.0870494544506073,
0.24744398891925812,
-0.4775940775871277,
-0.08230388164520264,
0.9685088396072388,
0.3193177878856659,
0.5326475501060486,
0.3838888704776764,
0.011415764689445496,
-0.5681923031806946,
0.3737466633319855,
0.8314530253410339,
-0.49958768486976624,
-0.6437643766403198,
-0.5751444101333618,
1.086920142173767,
-0.30826255679130554,
-0.2544845938682556,
0.4358374774456024,
0.05247586593031883,
0.19134902954101562,
-0.04572377726435661,
0.7168105840682983,
-0.4328851103782654,
0.1847880482673645,
-0.659783661365509,
0.4504644572734833,
-0.553804874420166,
0.5076940059661865,
-0.4884733557701111,
-0.6291564702987671,
-0.022479183971881866,
0.3708634376525879,
-0.10282823443412781,
-0.015845198184251785,
0.7727249264717102,
1.0306745767593384,
0.07695531100034714,
0.4647156596183777,
0.38169991970062256,
0.5048044323921204,
0.5854001641273499,
0.74488365650177,
1.2239391803741455,
-0.19381752610206604,
0.7260223627090454,
0.24211573600769043,
-0.07544621080160141,
-0.3000146150588989,
-0.8981174230575562,
-0.3947639465332031,
-0.5001440048217773,
-0.0924067571759224,
-0.6764727234840393,
0.021001340821385384,
1.0566250085830688,
0.48474571108818054,
-0.932925820350647,
0.10765259712934494,
-0.5410582423210144,
0.07102496922016144,
-0.22389329969882965,
-0.3009456694126129,
-0.20974572002887726,
0.020919591188430786,
-0.8013494610786438,
-0.032889287918806076,
0.4574603736400604,
0.06463775783777237,
-0.034914419054985046,
-0.5955786108970642,
0.5608893632888794,
0.18974368274211884,
0.6850160360336304,
0.1676235944032669,
-0.43386662006378174,
-0.7230031490325928,
0.49245303869247437,
0.15326569974422455,
0.0889880359172821,
1.0787962675094604,
-0.30750763416290283,
0.7454320192337036,
0.3324665427207947,
0.41112348437309265,
0.35432422161102295,
0.05245133116841316,
0.9416670799255371,
-0.6076647639274597,
-0.21489955484867096,
0.3665769696235657,
0.613202691078186,
0.1225442886352539,
-0.6125104427337646,
0.3604346811771393,
0.05268016457557678,
-0.5464735627174377,
-0.7427621483802795,
0.8430154323577881,
-0.8978174924850464,
0.5142467021942139,
1.243013858795166,
-0.49991878867149353,
-0.20484915375709534,
-0.0891207680106163,
-0.888102650642395,
0.24769055843353271,
-0.9165786504745483,
0.5275633931159973,
0.806821882724762,
-0.5516026616096497,
-0.20780245959758759,
0.013516664505004883,
0.2531754672527313,
0.5425958633422852,
-0.8948888182640076,
0.14263539016246796,
0.33230629563331604,
-0.12782853841781616,
0.013334804214537144,
0.5824517011642456,
0.02379898726940155,
0.09664324671030045,
-0.11357736587524414,
-0.24640069901943207,
0.1255679726600647,
-0.23667186498641968,
-0.24343246221542358,
-0.041683271527290344,
0.08516526967287064,
0.14496009051799774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10958v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10958v2
|
City-LEO: Toward Transparent City Management Using LLM with End-to-End Optimization
| 2024-06-16T14:25:08 | 2024-06-18T02:16:58 |
Zihao Jiao, Mengyi Sha, Haoyu Zhang, Xinyu Jiang, Wei Qi
|
math.OC
|
math.OC, cs.CL, cs.MA
|
Existing operations research (OR) models and tools play indispensable roles
in smart-city operations, yet their practical implementation is limited by the
complexity of modeling and deficiencies in optimization proficiency. To
generate more relevant and accurate solutions to users' requirements, we
propose a large language model (LLM)-based agent ("City-LEO") that enhances the
efficiency and transparency of city management through conversational
interactions. Specifically, to accommodate diverse users' requirements and
enhance computational tractability, City-LEO leverages LLM's logical reasoning
capabilities on prior knowledge to scope down large-scale optimization problems
efficiently. In the human-like decision process, City-LEO also incorporates
End-to-end (E2E) model to synergize the prediction and optimization. The E2E
framework be conducive to coping with environmental uncertainties and involving
more query-relevant features, and then facilitates transparent and
interpretable decision-making process. In case study, we employ City-LEO in the
operations management of e-bike sharing (EBS) system. The numerical results
demonstrate that City-LEO has superior performance when benchmarks against the
full-scale optimization problem. With less computational time, City-LEO
generates more satisfactory and relevant solutions to the users' requirements,
and achieves lower global suboptimality without significantly compromising
accuracy. In a broader sense, our proposed agent offers promise to develop
LLM-embedded OR tools for smart-city operations management.
|
[
-0.4612148106098175,
-0.5110292434692383,
0.7504080533981323,
0.21404622495174408,
-0.22375525534152985,
0.10969872027635574,
-0.27876409888267517,
-0.8664730191230774,
0.375868558883667,
0.42697370052337646,
-0.7277917265892029,
-0.31089580059051514,
-0.01861787773668766,
0.06871724873781204,
-0.4476979672908783,
0.7309665083885193,
-0.18765126168727875,
0.06410584598779678,
-0.23016943037509918,
0.09554574638605118,
-0.3474678099155426,
-0.2535074055194855,
-0.9684648513793945,
-0.5011076927185059,
0.16158528625965118,
0.34623658657073975,
0.8399167656898499,
0.5706008672714233,
0.5095771551132202,
0.32627537846565247,
-0.011902869679033756,
0.3858652412891388,
-0.5897689461708069,
0.08948598057031631,
-0.5996755361557007,
-0.23443058133125305,
-0.5391850471496582,
-0.3322582244873047,
0.3305189907550812,
0.35198912024497986,
-0.42265257239341736,
-0.11444292217493057,
-0.09921874105930328,
0.7232339978218079,
-0.777029812335968,
0.07859866321086884,
-0.45562461018562317,
-0.10995015501976013,
0.37981775403022766,
-0.23728172481060028,
0.08916790783405304,
-0.4180338382720947,
0.18731310963630676,
-1.053444266319275,
-0.2632840573787689,
0.23653601109981537,
0.8609517812728882,
0.4450731873512268,
-0.07018955051898956,
-0.7753257155418396,
-1.1566990613937378,
0.7129963040351868,
0.008589412085711956,
0.4345802366733551,
0.349952757358551,
0.5364670157432556,
-0.1822909712791443,
-0.42652907967567444,
-0.6935174465179443,
-0.11339345574378967,
0.10629545152187347,
0.34620946645736694,
-0.13551391661167145,
0.24220126867294312,
-0.19458337128162384,
-0.10929188877344131,
-0.27316322922706604,
-0.1398080587387085,
-0.37198132276535034,
-0.16939598321914673,
0.6931055784225464,
0.17852918803691864,
-0.22387783229351044,
0.0018244067905470729,
-0.6375080347061157,
0.16106727719306946,
-0.4042017459869385,
0.13783004879951477,
0.4453275203704834,
0.02147415652871132,
-0.15675237774848938,
0.3881675601005554,
-0.45490357279777527,
0.046274155378341675,
-0.2282312661409378,
0.11998601257801056,
0.17266595363616943,
-0.4428531527519226,
-0.40015825629234314,
-0.10857333242893219,
0.5200904011726379,
0.42526009678840637,
0.461178719997406,
-0.360482782125473,
-0.6750604510307312,
-0.16058968007564545,
-0.08419471234083176,
-0.7823550701141357,
0.02270241267979145,
0.7188199758529663,
0.08639733493328094,
-0.45260700583457947,
0.11592763662338257,
-0.3282671570777893,
-0.210417240858078,
-0.40493243932724,
0.08749228715896606,
-0.19661526381969452,
-0.1365036517381668,
0.33867108821868896,
0.17250464856624603,
0.46954289078712463,
0.7407192587852478,
-0.7635588049888611,
0.4374161958694458,
0.6991150379180908,
0.6947299242019653,
0.10025409609079361,
0.0956289991736412,
-0.12642839550971985,
0.6566866040229797,
-0.5030138492584229,
0.5241946578025818,
-0.3741697371006012,
-0.5265721082687378,
-0.04361493140459061,
-0.24536645412445068,
0.23127920925617218,
-0.6127628087997437,
0.6042062640190125,
-0.5151946544647217,
0.060491710901260376,
0.03287043794989586,
-0.2737751305103302,
-0.23835967481136322,
0.5840756893157959,
-0.3076748847961426,
1.1886165142059326,
-0.11442194879055023,
-0.15163518488407135,
0.14221405982971191,
-0.8838777542114258,
-0.1334461122751236,
0.24066627025604248,
-0.11339949071407318,
-0.3780439794063568,
0.2773774564266205,
0.27499672770500183,
0.27104681730270386,
-0.5626424551010132,
0.48304933309555054,
-0.04760367050766945,
-0.2745897173881531,
-0.02125987596809864,
0.1712336540222168,
0.5183881521224976,
0.38263052701950073,
0.010391674935817719,
0.19724205136299133,
-0.3639727234840393,
-0.12520450353622437,
0.019636094570159912,
-0.42655712366104126,
-0.06311454623937607,
0.02710573934018612,
0.21105344593524933,
-0.012177820317447186,
0.8920108675956726,
-0.6058295369148254,
0.06567355990409851,
-0.5883415341377258,
0.3401603698730469,
1.0913164615631104,
-0.34032103419303894,
0.6958203315734863,
-0.3908917307853699,
0.7302452921867371,
-0.29914429783821106,
0.8007581233978271,
-0.05497404560446739,
-0.5214765071868896,
-0.6020579934120178,
-0.4433542788028717,
0.07869435846805573,
0.6445542573928833,
-0.5436418056488037,
0.35452479124069214,
-0.44006872177124023,
-0.31807953119277954,
-0.3998878002166748,
-0.10267955809831619,
0.07015007734298706,
0.41700348258018494,
-0.1160731241106987,
-0.23629745841026306,
-0.38661348819732666,
-1.0063568353652954,
0.08999443799257278,
-0.3459055423736572,
0.4039171040058136,
0.6887109279632568,
0.7491394877433777,
-0.48989158868789673,
1.3179317712783813,
-0.3093574345111847,
-0.16398470103740692,
-0.04284227266907692,
-0.5030333995819092,
0.24811166524887085,
0.2177809178829193,
0.22445249557495117,
-1.1817891597747803,
-0.499590665102005,
0.2859231233596802,
-0.766444206237793,
-0.12955288589000702,
-0.1168627217411995,
-0.3605993986129761,
0.1708110123872757,
0.3733702003955841,
-0.5028529763221741,
0.16681581735610962,
0.45225074887275696,
-0.13106663525104523,
0.40720105171203613,
-0.4393109679222107,
-0.10337000340223312,
-1.0209587812423706,
0.03345862030982971,
-0.31116119027137756,
-0.687574565410614,
-0.5985546708106995,
0.3488770127296448,
-0.2272520214319229,
-0.202259361743927,
-0.42132917046546936,
0.5259023308753967,
-0.1725441962480545,
-0.5549190044403076,
-0.14126180112361908,
0.31867632269859314,
-0.020528146997094154,
0.4875197410583496,
0.03426102548837662,
0.6834884285926819,
0.5859853625297546,
-0.48879918456077576,
0.489535391330719,
0.12775373458862305,
-0.22696411609649658,
0.1586911678314209,
-0.5705984830856323,
0.24482209980487823,
-0.414546400308609,
0.20051288604736328,
-0.7751930952072144,
-0.21396984159946442,
0.44460123777389526,
-0.2988639771938324,
-0.13801173865795135,
0.19637443125247955,
-1.0680103302001953,
-0.07490051537752151,
-0.5299854278564453,
0.28304967284202576,
0.18515530228614807,
-0.28771689534187317,
0.8553441166877747,
0.20970354974269867,
0.11401244252920151,
-0.34680527448654175,
-0.6032243371009827,
0.09993451088666916,
0.0444360077381134,
-0.8407187461853027,
0.16705891489982605,
-0.2795822024345398,
-0.18734881281852722,
0.035418055951595306,
-0.006358318030834198,
-0.23688074946403503,
0.2911105453968048,
0.03487049788236618,
0.10483615845441818,
0.44795694947242737,
0.072475366294384,
-0.043445367366075516,
-0.35219699144363403,
-0.05048803240060806,
-0.3922751545906067,
0.5268364548683167,
-0.21737167239189148,
-0.2740837633609772,
-0.3812463581562042,
0.265704870223999,
0.876461923122406,
-0.41778919100761414,
0.7990341782569885,
0.2805062532424927,
-0.5632328987121582,
-0.09427572041749954,
-0.22411371767520905,
-0.3062345087528229,
-0.501091480255127,
0.5316905975341797,
-0.4463462233543396,
-0.6951056122779846,
0.8053579330444336,
-0.41542425751686096,
0.1545024961233139,
-0.1322658807039261,
0.5810112953186035,
-0.4233627915382385,
0.7093876004219055,
0.7140446305274963,
0.24613799154758453,
0.5726559162139893,
-0.18178457021713257,
0.2899972200393677,
-0.6127240061759949,
-0.7680938243865967,
-0.3192388713359833,
-0.2883370816707611,
-0.7641066312789917,
-0.5149073004722595,
0.717878520488739,
0.4339691698551178,
-0.33481311798095703,
0.13629396259784698,
-0.5258864164352417,
0.534285306930542,
0.29455646872520447,
0.03657839819788933,
0.5478295683860779,
-0.06194959208369255,
-0.0378720685839653,
0.2965069115161896,
-0.7178966999053955,
-0.4825955331325531,
0.8211444020271301,
0.3373525142669678,
0.6960500478744507,
0.4047313928604126,
0.7896285057067871,
0.20485755801200867,
0.27693918347358704,
-0.6105748414993286,
0.6625640392303467,
0.37696853280067444,
-1.0163856744766235,
-0.3406863808631897,
-0.2723350524902344,
-0.6530161499977112,
0.2823950946331024,
-0.43679356575012207,
-0.753333568572998,
0.3621562421321869,
-0.06373927742242813,
-0.27993953227996826,
0.12035533040761948,
-0.5344318747520447,
0.3615441620349884,
-0.20715950429439545,
-0.3164803981781006,
-0.4001573622226715,
-0.33165258169174194,
0.0012265698751434684,
-0.5292311906814575,
0.7643986940383911,
-0.09683457762002945,
-0.4299371540546417,
0.21956147253513336,
-0.5289908647537231,
0.35989615321159363,
0.05017402768135071,
-0.11731051653623581,
0.23389224708080292,
-0.006417061667889357,
1.1748744249343872,
-0.0823620930314064,
-0.34786084294319153,
0.04873858764767647,
-0.4610033631324768,
-0.30139634013175964,
-0.5796193480491638,
0.5104202032089233,
-0.9877861738204956,
-0.28740638494491577,
-0.15409544110298157,
-0.5565633177757263,
0.13535082340240479,
0.03575227037072182,
0.02216864377260208,
0.1853904128074646,
0.008386745117604733,
0.002683765720576048,
0.39087486267089844,
-0.2815631031990051,
0.5238078832626343,
0.7308079600334167,
-0.6022436022758484,
-0.3724842369556427,
0.6636994481086731,
-0.27530431747436523,
0.25958365201950073,
0.8162446022033691,
0.43667110800743103,
-0.5849132537841797,
-0.673459529876709,
-0.23144805431365967,
0.011108070611953735,
-0.5082189440727234,
0.00005949097248958424,
-0.2300301492214203,
0.3693244457244873,
-0.09833189100027084,
-0.7388356924057007,
-0.7340937256813049,
-0.36968564987182617,
0.00003234225368942134,
-0.12061574310064316,
0.1954881250858307,
0.7633298635482788,
-0.3784644305706024,
0.38111612200737,
-0.24006697535514832,
0.2010362446308136,
-0.09349903464317322,
0.26410701870918274,
-0.16970466077327728,
-0.07320190966129303,
-0.7806414365768433,
-0.02806125581264496,
-0.24435096979141235,
-0.7873038053512573,
0.2973012924194336,
-0.023469628766179085,
0.2399185299873352,
0.5213842988014221,
0.07069321721792221,
0.4330568015575409,
-0.19172786176204681,
0.2945229709148407,
0.2810881435871124,
-0.84479820728302,
0.5355939865112305,
-0.6125144362449646,
-0.03888322785496712,
0.5591045618057251,
-0.03730781376361847,
-0.2160387486219406,
-0.5532694458961487,
-0.1986747682094574,
-0.9921944737434387,
0.815127432346344,
0.7322938442230225,
0.07134424149990082,
0.10707131028175354,
0.5810036659240723,
-0.3159797191619873,
0.6341699361801147,
-0.9002847075462341,
-0.4679553508758545,
0.06033620610833168,
0.14836999773979187,
0.08108159899711609,
-0.1539745032787323,
-0.08306168019771576,
-0.18996746838092804,
0.7781615853309631,
0.031714119017124176,
0.20822635293006897,
0.556685209274292,
0.1647084653377533,
-0.24140802025794983,
0.41039782762527466,
0.7410719394683838,
0.7792331576347351,
-0.4591462314128876,
-0.3608075678348541,
0.3554636240005493,
-0.24846822023391724,
-0.10044781863689423,
-0.12723606824874878,
-0.37792035937309265,
-0.4129096269607544,
0.24021467566490173,
0.2753220200538635,
-0.25224143266677856,
-0.760231614112854,
0.5730777382850647,
0.2984945476055145,
-0.13846538960933685,
-0.6072460412979126,
-0.28971612453460693,
0.22761794924736023,
0.652265727519989,
0.48855575919151306,
0.17085137963294983,
0.22523906826972961,
-0.6810868382453918,
-0.12044890969991684,
0.35957351326942444,
-0.5714914202690125,
-0.07114241272211075,
0.8760718703269958,
0.5768710970878601,
-0.3084104657173157,
0.47408169507980347,
-0.49753275513648987,
-0.6752865314483643,
0.7508580684661865,
0.11337112635374069,
1.0091261863708496,
-0.010584534145891666,
0.020056279376149178,
-0.04709320515394211,
0.8010786771774292,
0.22169531881809235,
0.547088623046875,
-0.01425403542816639,
-0.9931820034980774,
-0.7248393297195435,
-0.6976632475852966,
-0.4133394658565521,
-0.24907635152339935,
-0.6226282119750977,
0.28559789061546326,
-0.737107515335083,
-0.02450975589454174,
-0.5218099355697632,
0.3800314664840698,
-0.5137181878089905,
0.32095083594322205,
0.23412679135799408,
1.0143963098526,
-0.4370303452014923,
0.6630261540412903,
0.955803394317627,
-0.03593744337558746,
-0.5920204520225525,
-0.3020956218242645,
-0.44481194019317627,
-0.9128612875938416,
0.4919254183769226,
-0.028621768578886986,
-0.636540949344635,
-0.18521003425121307,
-0.6148314476013184,
-0.40065550804138184,
1.4443933963775635,
0.5743652582168579,
-1.2219395637512207,
0.12887103855609894,
0.3276118040084839,
0.4861157238483429,
-0.5864695310592651,
0.35561347007751465,
0.020025823265314102,
0.7166401147842407,
0.25335758924484253,
-0.9853971004486084,
0.10068396478891373,
0.4263584315776825,
0.02690431848168373,
0.28463393449783325,
-0.9561091065406799,
0.5962321758270264,
-0.44971737265586853,
-0.12171676009893417,
0.2002989649772644,
0.382590115070343,
0.10283717513084412,
0.5003455877304077,
0.46953311562538147,
0.5830140709877014,
0.9092064499855042,
0.10499727725982666,
1.257346749305725,
-0.6274973154067993,
0.645132839679718,
0.645094633102417,
-0.1538608819246292,
0.5789634585380554,
0.48409155011177063,
0.15496857464313507,
0.3717707395553589,
0.486689954996109,
0.2160690426826477,
0.9308338165283203,
0.09409705549478531,
-0.46832403540611267,
-0.6031584143638611,
-0.4307114779949188,
0.10331813246011734,
0.35352882742881775,
0.16422182321548462,
0.1243508979678154,
-0.27494049072265625,
-0.18645332753658295,
-0.13186895847320557,
0.07552482932806015,
-0.5302928686141968,
0.7258948683738708,
0.07704324275255203,
-0.1864689737558365,
0.030549073591828346,
0.49793902039527893,
0.4521784484386444,
-0.5561438202857971,
0.1397174745798111,
-0.09059643745422363,
0.0651293620467186,
-0.31471940875053406,
-0.6882889866828918,
0.4029078185558319,
-0.24250777065753937,
-0.40349528193473816,
-0.46108388900756836,
0.5411132574081421,
-0.1978200078010559,
-0.2954757809638977,
0.5910708904266357,
0.4587293267250061,
0.48285406827926636,
-0.16616977751255035,
-0.7902693152427673,
0.06939767301082611,
0.1912440061569214,
-0.20361299812793732,
-0.29841166734695435,
0.4159465730190277,
-0.24658392369747162,
1.1146246194839478,
0.9060547947883606,
0.23057007789611816,
-0.3050747215747833,
-0.06252306699752808,
0.8677838444709778,
-0.5887690186500549,
-0.8222711086273193,
-0.8834410905838013,
0.2887308895587921,
0.07015184313058853,
-0.08947146683931351,
0.18069089949131012,
1.000981092453003,
0.7401568293571472,
0.40934276580810547,
0.7564089298248291,
0.21571911871433258,
0.24285008013248444,
-0.19172096252441406,
0.2814715504646301,
-0.7057812809944153,
0.6991101503372192,
0.10020634531974792,
-1.0413964986801147,
0.12061894685029984,
0.6311729550361633,
-0.33632227778434753,
0.03835827484726906,
0.26372063159942627,
0.9333807826042175,
-0.09227273613214493,
0.011016305536031723,
0.5135642886161804,
0.08237490057945251,
0.4586793780326843,
0.8266646265983582,
0.8289118409156799,
-0.3615299463272095,
0.7627578377723694,
0.06351464986801147,
-0.21412570774555206,
-0.20813888311386108,
-0.669001042842865,
-0.6741302013397217,
-0.2016494870185852,
-0.2175866663455963,
0.06817049533128738,
0.5636895895004272,
0.8275238871574402,
0.9396107196807861,
-0.531254231929779,
-0.18117745220661163,
-0.54058438539505,
0.3299660086631775,
0.296867311000824,
-0.17576630413532257,
0.14220638573169708,
0.12377355992794037,
-0.9810938239097595,
0.11708076298236847,
0.5579755306243896,
0.030525781214237213,
-0.350780189037323,
-0.700554370880127,
0.30737191438674927,
0.3160545825958252,
0.289073646068573,
0.06761262565851212,
-0.4757309556007385,
-0.06467190384864807,
-0.080302894115448,
-0.23456883430480957,
-0.16183783113956451,
0.4442024827003479,
-0.5223687887191772,
0.6643281579017639,
0.2985142469406128,
0.3329772353172302,
0.8776984810829163,
0.0021386444568634033,
0.6903319954872131,
-0.788321852684021,
0.08500216901302338,
0.06596390157938004,
0.16796070337295532,
0.3487303555011749,
-0.3268737196922302,
0.5436951518058777,
0.13441534340381622,
-0.4926120936870575,
-0.40427929162979126,
0.5563253164291382,
-0.9093384146690369,
-0.23336754739284515,
1.1359187364578247,
0.14383459091186523,
-0.018198464065790176,
-0.2544823884963989,
0.0660916268825531,
0.007942325435578823,
-0.9906317591667175,
0.4952563941478729,
0.5296074151992798,
-0.20769734680652618,
0.0036132328677922487,
-0.8271080255508423,
0.1962060183286667,
0.2307097464799881,
-0.7243404388427734,
-0.22882157564163208,
0.16008295118808746,
0.01863725855946541,
0.24585634469985962,
0.8768187761306763,
0.18585865199565887,
0.07235003262758255,
-0.35221073031425476,
0.3435022830963135,
-0.4034304916858673,
-0.45234277844429016,
-0.1852504462003708,
0.0338456816971302,
-0.03065897524356842,
-0.40887805819511414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10957v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10957v1
|
Eliminating Biased Length Reliance of Direct Preference Optimization via Down-Sampled KL Divergence
| 2024-06-16T14:24:30 | 2024-06-16T14:24:30 |
Junru Lu, Jiazheng Li, Siyu An, Meng Zhao, Yulan He, Di Yin, Xing Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) has emerged as a prominent algorithm for
the direct and robust alignment of Large Language Models (LLMs) with human
preferences, offering a more straightforward alternative to the complex
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF). Despite its promising
efficacy, DPO faces a notable drawback: "verbosity", a common over-optimization
phenomenon also observed in RLHF. While previous studies mainly attributed
verbosity to biased labels within the data, we propose that the issue also
stems from an inherent algorithmic length reliance in DPO. Specifically, we
suggest that the discrepancy between sequence-level Kullback-Leibler (KL)
divergences between chosen and rejected sequences, used in DPO, results in
overestimated or underestimated rewards due to varying token lengths.
Empirically, we utilize datasets with different label lengths to demonstrate
the presence of biased rewards. We then introduce an effective downsampling
approach, named SamPO, to eliminate potential length reliance. Our experimental
evaluations, conducted across three LLMs of varying scales and a diverse array
of conditional and open-ended benchmarks, highlight the efficacy of SamPO in
mitigating verbosity, achieving improvements of 5% to 12% over DPO through
debaised rewards. Our codes can be accessed at:
https://github.com/LuJunru/SamPO/.
|
[
-0.33589306473731995,
-0.35012272000312805,
0.8095957636833191,
0.12851697206497192,
-0.43493232131004333,
0.25277113914489746,
-0.3912334144115448,
-0.18055564165115356,
0.2924686670303345,
0.47457778453826904,
-0.6895906925201416,
-0.46222856640815735,
-0.7745240330696106,
0.052953533828258514,
0.3437068462371826,
0.8955098986625671,
-0.06298030912876129,
0.006884037982672453,
-0.44518613815307617,
-0.006705638952553272,
-0.4337176978588104,
-0.248714879155159,
-0.31815290451049805,
-0.5170716047286987,
0.577641487121582,
0.833926796913147,
0.7294594049453735,
0.7939755320549011,
0.33549749851226807,
0.15657849609851837,
-0.29205211997032166,
0.4237349033355713,
-0.48091521859169006,
0.27220210433006287,
-0.05899558961391449,
-0.4178673326969147,
-0.3620215356349945,
-0.0735689252614975,
0.8275858759880066,
0.5633516311645508,
-0.14263920485973358,
0.12927527725696564,
0.14057396352291107,
1.459665060043335,
-0.9516317844390869,
-0.0015639980556443334,
-0.48985928297042847,
0.1992618292570114,
-0.11028456687927246,
-0.3621857166290283,
-0.4571492075920105,
-0.41396355628967285,
0.17746448516845703,
-0.4729866683483124,
-0.08260399848222733,
-0.15986444056034088,
0.8447507619857788,
0.6647309064865112,
-0.25981244444847107,
-0.3585990071296692,
-0.8958047032356262,
1.1385530233383179,
-0.6579638123512268,
0.3381299078464508,
0.5495859980583191,
0.08039239048957825,
-0.15378540754318237,
0.02034684456884861,
-0.25462737679481506,
-0.4723488986492157,
-0.043597619980573654,
0.1779910773038864,
0.0005845838459208608,
0.2836250066757202,
0.21882688999176025,
0.24989402294158936,
-0.3910810947418213,
0.4551105201244354,
-0.26334625482559204,
-0.0570119172334671,
0.7742497324943542,
0.10168565809726715,
-0.03849027305841446,
-0.1822224259376526,
-0.2845604717731476,
-0.12941984832286835,
-0.6163299083709717,
0.22814220190048218,
0.7959148287773132,
0.3217587471008301,
0.23304946720600128,
0.6301631927490234,
-0.3741146922111511,
0.5832241177558899,
0.38253718614578247,
-0.42781952023506165,
0.21161043643951416,
-0.023795204237103462,
0.05451502278447151,
0.38576194643974304,
0.5537965297698975,
0.28963032364845276,
0.24213950335979462,
0.011273057200014591,
-0.19227416813373566,
0.013123041950166225,
0.00733651639893651,
-0.8621654510498047,
0.10955894738435745,
0.5242457985877991,
-0.2512407600879669,
-0.30287694931030273,
0.015440518036484718,
-0.9972410798072815,
-0.5401439666748047,
-0.5116139650344849,
0.1454319804906845,
-0.17490410804748535,
-0.07680674642324448,
0.40090212225914,
-0.16722244024276733,
0.0613827146589756,
-0.002863010624423623,
-1.1014292240142822,
0.3162827491760254,
0.7852588891983032,
0.8929365277290344,
-0.2630883753299713,
-0.23085945844650269,
-0.773941159248352,
0.011755668558180332,
-0.10345953702926636,
0.49367234110832214,
-0.6732410192489624,
-0.6126250624656677,
-0.1620965301990509,
-0.4389764070510864,
0.09802255034446716,
-0.6291105151176453,
0.8067026734352112,
-0.39627546072006226,
0.16542285680770874,
-0.3296912610530853,
-0.7166675925254822,
0.19992168247699738,
0.03663390129804611,
-0.6819312572479248,
0.8917465209960938,
-0.20805197954177856,
-0.7135730981826782,
0.739334225654602,
-0.578294575214386,
-0.44255688786506653,
-0.18326866626739502,
-0.28032732009887695,
-0.644244372844696,
0.19932624697685242,
0.3666979968547821,
0.211366668343544,
-0.07049302756786346,
0.4735686182975769,
-0.41899290680885315,
-0.7085523009300232,
0.11871931701898575,
-0.32366272807121277,
0.5300372242927551,
0.06605492532253265,
-0.43435072898864746,
0.221004456281662,
-0.8449358344078064,
-0.11849024891853333,
0.05871448665857315,
-0.5696102976799011,
-0.49223220348358154,
0.24485830962657928,
-0.4621780514717102,
0.17238518595695496,
0.15001459419727325,
-0.708225667476654,
0.5306040644645691,
-0.5236623883247375,
0.23325088620185852,
1.2113581895828247,
-0.26195114850997925,
0.6537873148918152,
-0.17822006344795227,
0.7487903833389282,
-0.048495206981897354,
0.38751140236854553,
0.18329252302646637,
-0.1690654754638672,
-0.6336298584938049,
-0.7781760096549988,
0.3684045672416687,
0.3859940767288208,
-0.4477255046367645,
0.7472233176231384,
-0.4238470494747162,
-0.3061927258968353,
-0.6911197304725647,
0.2125590294599533,
0.2611349821090698,
0.5368901491165161,
0.34562116861343384,
-0.18582285940647125,
-0.5327442288398743,
-1.0463247299194336,
-0.08770616352558136,
-0.2641911208629608,
-0.036220982670784,
0.6249141097068787,
0.10846011340618134,
-0.22892746329307556,
1.1830146312713623,
-0.9187082648277283,
-0.30919507145881653,
-0.1301608681678772,
-0.14640985429286957,
0.23975858092308044,
0.23857378959655762,
0.2988550066947937,
-0.5236757397651672,
-0.5890406370162964,
-0.2693715989589691,
-0.06467937678098679,
-0.4026790261268616,
-0.0587635412812233,
-0.153944730758667,
0.49790775775909424,
-0.05039405822753906,
-0.7629399299621582,
0.11872037500143051,
0.5978533625602722,
-0.35090214014053345,
0.7985213398933411,
-0.18397806584835052,
0.0873660296201706,
-0.7180405855178833,
0.05408303067088127,
-0.018839027732610703,
-0.17256782948970795,
-0.24912483990192413,
-0.3656456470489502,
-0.05399231240153313,
-0.049487121403217316,
-0.2350180447101593,
0.6389591693878174,
-0.365841269493103,
-0.1544744223356247,
-0.3503492772579193,
0.1355389803647995,
0.2750963270664215,
0.6416142582893372,
0.17467273771762848,
0.6955348253250122,
0.23890937864780426,
-0.6425341963768005,
0.13362830877304077,
0.18258847296237946,
-0.1200980544090271,
0.41592520475387573,
-0.6450194716453552,
0.13142400979995728,
-0.35433724522590637,
0.23551741242408752,
-0.8538621664047241,
-0.0892544686794281,
0.47822967171669006,
-0.28140515089035034,
0.4039650857448578,
-0.2990356385707855,
-0.36386725306510925,
-0.20987847447395325,
-0.749133825302124,
0.3990279734134674,
0.7215787172317505,
-0.6929157376289368,
0.14684735238552094,
0.28170788288116455,
-0.13149364292621613,
-0.8976320028305054,
-0.24729321897029877,
-0.25262758135795593,
-0.4631836414337158,
-0.428649365901947,
0.41417884826660156,
-0.037726543843746185,
-0.1586647778749466,
-0.2969972491264343,
-0.4208719730377197,
0.25428706407546997,
-0.03898072987794876,
0.09909471124410629,
0.2489759624004364,
0.24294668436050415,
0.4897395670413971,
0.25007954239845276,
-0.050115492194890976,
-0.1163867712020874,
-0.32185620069503784,
0.7160626649856567,
-0.04960862174630165,
-0.3075113296508789,
-0.4680648744106293,
0.1431940793991089,
0.49996355175971985,
0.014836974442005157,
0.31594744324684143,
0.27679336071014404,
0.1558554619550705,
-0.3305205702781677,
-0.32770541310310364,
-0.2652994990348816,
-0.47753381729125977,
0.3692867159843445,
-0.32028740644454956,
-0.8400509357452393,
0.15910594165325165,
-0.08518261462450027,
-0.2992039918899536,
0.14389245212078094,
0.31991344690322876,
0.13008339703083038,
1.0503734350204468,
0.4966332018375397,
-0.42337504029273987,
0.6302327513694763,
0.008322631008923054,
-0.1278468817472458,
-0.6460294127464294,
-0.055767424404621124,
-0.2921750545501709,
-0.6173428297042847,
-0.6537377834320068,
-0.3175060749053955,
0.061992380768060684,
0.08591040223836899,
-0.2302827090024948,
-0.02480263076722622,
-0.5240366458892822,
0.556831955909729,
0.654386579990387,
0.30433395504951477,
0.4478839635848999,
0.11665114760398865,
-0.019764304161071777,
-0.28439411520957947,
-0.7320832014083862,
-0.3547843098640442,
1.0814878940582275,
0.5180649757385254,
1.0416666269302368,
-0.02450430579483509,
0.9936738014221191,
0.5709682703018188,
-0.25025057792663574,
-1.0696221590042114,
0.46342384815216064,
-0.1960376650094986,
-0.338535875082016,
-0.4671947956085205,
-0.5611261129379272,
-0.9956929683685303,
0.06372411549091339,
0.09838899970054626,
-0.638618528842926,
0.4517729878425598,
0.4997563064098358,
-0.2851773798465729,
0.14544954895973206,
-0.4801580309867859,
0.6328220367431641,
-0.42370373010635376,
-0.415910929441452,
-0.1670624017715454,
-0.6474248170852661,
0.26600560545921326,
0.167197123169899,
-0.2598247528076172,
-0.3785230219364166,
-0.29372942447662354,
0.4870377779006958,
-0.32284581661224365,
0.8677994608879089,
-0.2433214634656906,
-0.3596957325935364,
0.02648552879691124,
-0.1048223152756691,
0.5794671773910522,
0.17946894466876984,
-0.001018304261378944,
0.004960823338478804,
-0.14965490996837616,
-0.6726794838905334,
-0.5448765158653259,
0.706267237663269,
-0.7790219783782959,
-0.5900707840919495,
-0.410282701253891,
-0.35950809717178345,
-0.3609355390071869,
0.03241841867566109,
0.10586362332105637,
0.16352565586566925,
-0.11443980783224106,
-0.08631414920091629,
0.6859601736068726,
-0.3098764419555664,
0.30084988474845886,
0.3924664556980133,
-0.23938588798046112,
-0.6484597325325012,
0.859388530254364,
-0.010323549620807171,
0.5156243443489075,
0.40622517466545105,
0.5374005436897278,
-0.4997393786907196,
-0.25292500853538513,
-0.5399096608161926,
0.30104243755340576,
-0.5098780989646912,
-0.0096648670732975,
-0.23137852549552917,
0.18096178770065308,
-0.25948816537857056,
-0.05726711079478264,
-0.7244588136672974,
-0.47159871459007263,
-0.24768775701522827,
0.03349155932664871,
0.2653558850288391,
0.33626964688301086,
0.01678137294948101,
0.14494112133979797,
-0.6245830059051514,
0.03529868647456169,
0.1442016214132309,
0.6435205936431885,
-0.12850321829319,
-0.5779625177383423,
-0.11290793865919113,
0.13544906675815582,
-0.21329841017723083,
-0.645064651966095,
0.2527078688144684,
0.19592338800430298,
0.41999584436416626,
0.4598788022994995,
0.21067138016223907,
0.6589890718460083,
-0.4339514672756195,
0.43207427859306335,
0.14050915837287903,
-0.8605690598487854,
0.8316817283630371,
-0.2593609094619751,
0.6178617477416992,
0.751700758934021,
0.6582005620002747,
-0.591013491153717,
-0.05626264214515686,
-0.4902651309967041,
-0.9251142144203186,
0.6140760183334351,
0.012531357817351818,
-0.0055441963486373425,
0.012823154218494892,
0.28026390075683594,
0.3956400752067566,
0.3922010064125061,
-0.5327467918395996,
-0.2276919037103653,
0.19311246275901794,
-0.11589007079601288,
-0.1321384459733963,
-0.5983349680900574,
-0.1934528350830078,
-0.11422749608755112,
0.8680891990661621,
-0.19944193959236145,
0.0025875854771584272,
0.36657190322875977,
-0.04822661355137825,
-0.05612877756357193,
0.5765839219093323,
0.7716675996780396,
0.6783195734024048,
-0.49355921149253845,
0.028246425092220306,
-0.27457141876220703,
-0.55741947889328,
0.3470996618270874,
0.13384884595870972,
-0.4681950509548187,
0.13255873322486877,
0.10223320871591568,
0.9532849192619324,
-0.26233360171318054,
-0.8910065293312073,
0.3513982594013214,
0.2286292463541031,
-0.07046902179718018,
-0.07424858957529068,
-0.10299680382013321,
-0.2511459290981293,
0.05939646437764168,
0.15125492215156555,
0.03614545986056328,
0.26008352637290955,
-0.3148503601551056,
0.07852572947740555,
0.4002290368080139,
-0.6351626515388489,
-0.12296868860721588,
0.2829535901546478,
0.30678337812423706,
-0.15387026965618134,
0.3719179928302765,
-0.2188044637441635,
-0.44582468271255493,
0.5268264412879944,
0.24624213576316833,
0.9472931623458862,
0.08375752717256546,
0.5024418234825134,
0.24241547286510468,
0.05304203927516937,
-0.2521434724330902,
0.08455517143011093,
-0.23857778310775757,
-0.7035380005836487,
-0.6316424012184143,
-0.6452004313468933,
-0.35049664974212646,
0.13292165100574493,
-0.6704108715057373,
0.39055126905441284,
-0.5444449782371521,
-0.2592729330062866,
-0.15503941476345062,
0.21687515079975128,
-0.2694595158100128,
-0.15222923457622528,
0.2534959018230438,
0.5109591484069824,
-0.836165726184845,
0.6667768359184265,
0.5719237327575684,
-0.33974912762641907,
-0.3721748888492584,
0.3885883390903473,
-0.04642442613840103,
-0.636947512626648,
0.837149441242218,
0.20121163129806519,
-0.41156142950057983,
-0.07184088230133057,
-0.2571601867675781,
-0.8412694931030273,
1.055372714996338,
0.41762644052505493,
-0.7901269197463989,
0.25992369651794434,
0.32710856199264526,
0.4222972095012665,
-0.11407461762428284,
-0.1526847630739212,
0.7552624344825745,
0.292599618434906,
0.03940752521157265,
-0.8093635439872742,
0.16586638987064362,
0.21475669741630554,
0.11855891346931458,
0.4938698709011078,
-0.8923618197441101,
0.16086331009864807,
-0.15721912682056427,
-0.11004820466041565,
-0.04215662181377411,
0.22407802939414978,
0.5930023789405823,
0.16858619451522827,
0.5617144703865051,
0.6368393301963806,
0.8427131175994873,
0.1918904185295105,
0.8059609532356262,
-0.09875030070543289,
0.500293493270874,
1.2107161283493042,
-0.44041600823402405,
0.6697875261306763,
0.991098165512085,
-0.42093488574028015,
0.36899271607398987,
0.7498065233230591,
0.1058107390999794,
0.7939914464950562,
0.4171934723854065,
-0.32275211811065674,
-0.20120671391487122,
-0.2378256767988205,
-0.2523920238018036,
0.5654950141906738,
-0.07216223329305649,
-0.3585168421268463,
0.08021430671215057,
-0.10301883518695831,
0.17176778614521027,
0.27461186051368713,
-0.34785524010658264,
0.6061497926712036,
-0.09401625394821167,
-0.9476319551467896,
0.6137361526489258,
-0.26732003688812256,
0.9424644112586975,
-0.5460308194160461,
0.1169048324227333,
-0.6057104468345642,
0.44113287329673767,
-0.10085992515087128,
-0.6584151387214661,
0.08628218621015549,
-0.22745783627033234,
-0.36196592450141907,
-0.18568004667758942,
0.910627543926239,
-0.4600470960140228,
-0.3383752405643463,
0.3049403429031372,
0.22538302838802338,
-0.07327502965927124,
-0.0655195564031601,
-0.5707249641418457,
0.09713256359100342,
0.07377418130636215,
-0.2951497733592987,
0.3108609914779663,
0.12290757149457932,
0.1962713897228241,
0.8162054419517517,
0.34570059180259705,
0.25837811827659607,
-0.3438664674758911,
0.12535981833934784,
0.7520169019699097,
-0.510861873626709,
-0.5624451041221619,
-1.3293874263763428,
0.39393046498298645,
-0.33010420203208923,
-0.3135157823562622,
0.6932005882263184,
0.6996455192565918,
0.8772653341293335,
-0.30267995595932007,
0.6584797501564026,
0.13270778954029083,
0.27329152822494507,
-0.6300387382507324,
0.2689758539199829,
-0.6488642692565918,
0.6062579154968262,
-0.40956079959869385,
-0.861438512802124,
-0.17064440250396729,
0.21758252382278442,
-0.4927079677581787,
0.02161252312362194,
0.29976433515548706,
0.6571241617202759,
0.020243072882294655,
-0.44079476594924927,
0.3178180754184723,
-0.19201411306858063,
0.12726254761219025,
0.5839921832084656,
0.9185559749603271,
0.05714525282382965,
0.6741397976875305,
-0.3607630729675293,
-0.330867201089859,
-0.4146534502506256,
-0.9444999694824219,
-0.7628728747367859,
-0.17629341781139374,
-0.4067830741405487,
-0.3279955983161926,
0.3210681676864624,
1.0239039659500122,
0.6001801490783691,
-0.5338791608810425,
-0.24012546241283417,
-0.08232633024454117,
0.3172365128993988,
-0.25329428911209106,
-0.21580934524536133,
0.3686881959438324,
-0.3990892469882965,
-0.8826584219932556,
0.13574351370334625,
0.43082696199417114,
0.034089475870132446,
-0.32691147923469543,
-0.5051614046096802,
-0.1875196099281311,
0.0261479914188385,
0.6175906658172607,
0.347415953874588,
-0.7976396083831787,
-0.31444549560546875,
0.1316021829843521,
-0.11440408229827881,
0.23071062564849854,
0.7738875150680542,
-0.6078276038169861,
0.5006648302078247,
0.6542008519172668,
0.7530176639556885,
0.3787771165370941,
0.2826538681983948,
0.688247799873352,
-1.1726020574569702,
0.2053663432598114,
0.31287091970443726,
0.13675864040851593,
0.24508324265480042,
-0.6372183561325073,
0.556708812713623,
0.2308504432439804,
-0.7201277613639832,
-0.7647979855537415,
0.5973420143127441,
-0.9667448997497559,
-0.5581690073013306,
1.5171958208084106,
0.09117647260427475,
0.03942719101905823,
0.39893120527267456,
-0.5255764722824097,
-0.0006002130103297532,
-0.703586220741272,
1.1089624166488647,
0.8618316054344177,
-0.34592077136039734,
0.08668388426303864,
-0.30366283655166626,
0.9004418849945068,
0.7507726550102234,
-0.4998631179332733,
0.1589527577161789,
0.6985984444618225,
0.1426040083169937,
0.012964216060936451,
0.7572795748710632,
0.07485044747591019,
0.09451857209205627,
-0.1466856300830841,
0.07135418802499771,
-0.028514571487903595,
-0.3196399211883545,
-0.6357417106628418,
-0.2483731359243393,
0.43529754877090454,
-0.460658997297287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10952v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10952v1
|
Avoiding Copyright Infringement via Machine Unlearning
| 2024-06-16T14:12:37 | 2024-06-16T14:12:37 |
Guangyao Dou, Zheyuan Liu, Qing Lyu, Kaize Ding, Eric Wong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
capabilities but also pose risks by learning and generating copyrighted
material, leading to significant legal and ethical concerns. To address these
issues, it is critical for model owners to be able to unlearn copyrighted
content at various time steps. We explore the setting of sequential unlearning,
where copyrighted content is removed over multiple time steps - a scenario that
has not been rigorously addressed. To tackle this challenge, we propose Stable
Sequential Unlearning (SSU), a novel unlearning framework for LLMs, designed to
have a more stable process to remove copyrighted content from LLMs throughout
different time steps using task vectors, by incorporating additional random
labeling loss and applying gradient-based weight saliency mapping. Experiments
demonstrate that SSU finds a good balance between unlearning efficacy and
maintaining the model's general knowledge compared to existing baselines.
|
[
-0.011338000185787678,
-0.3150329291820526,
0.2853943705558777,
0.2397514432668686,
-0.7200184464454651,
0.43533793091773987,
-0.37260618805885315,
-0.16306445002555847,
-0.4147060811519623,
0.9796620607376099,
-0.32035884261131287,
-0.2836999297142029,
-0.7199593186378479,
-0.03591061756014824,
-0.5792313814163208,
0.9742849469184875,
-0.12556739151477814,
0.3493468463420868,
-0.3970459997653961,
-0.2631247043609619,
-0.4357021450996399,
-0.4535718858242035,
-0.7700361013412476,
-0.43949052691459656,
0.5744844675064087,
0.31704673171043396,
0.5619862079620361,
0.8059220314025879,
0.3391542434692383,
0.4090256690979004,
-0.13865843415260315,
-0.10624217987060547,
-0.8112199306488037,
0.37449803948402405,
-0.3069291114807129,
-0.5395556688308716,
-0.01915447972714901,
0.04433874413371086,
0.8827342987060547,
0.5852031111717224,
-0.21970263123512268,
0.16753627359867096,
0.2755783200263977,
0.89859539270401,
-0.679780125617981,
-0.10402655601501465,
-0.6961879730224609,
0.16519248485565186,
-0.3114013373851776,
-0.2548140287399292,
-0.759090006351471,
-0.055292047560214996,
0.013857848942279816,
-0.5620965957641602,
0.04696722328662872,
-0.23456382751464844,
0.8385454416275024,
0.7272518873214722,
-0.11420083791017532,
-0.049881353974342346,
-0.6696088314056396,
1.0892574787139893,
-0.7484123110771179,
0.3798268437385559,
0.25793877243995667,
-0.06350231915712357,
-0.2821100056171417,
-0.9655901193618774,
-0.46217286586761475,
0.2050461322069168,
0.15516595542430878,
0.08839444071054459,
-0.0981827974319458,
-0.1777721494436264,
0.41467413306236267,
0.08653842657804489,
-0.3593693971633911,
0.48743540048599243,
-0.37216436862945557,
-0.042822763323783875,
0.5498352646827698,
-0.2159249186515808,
0.4174557030200958,
-0.20228350162506104,
-0.6663846373558044,
0.26163986325263977,
-0.8759497404098511,
0.09561538696289062,
0.5716943740844727,
0.22169648110866547,
0.22281514108181,
0.6810181736946106,
0.18122859299182892,
0.2841359078884125,
-0.0008793538436293602,
-0.16533729434013367,
0.3258112072944641,
0.2126188576221466,
-0.2542106509208679,
0.1489860564470291,
0.825907289981842,
0.12816444039344788,
0.5480198860168457,
-0.4639327824115753,
-0.41151517629623413,
-0.15410898625850677,
0.4522128701210022,
-0.7577373385429382,
0.05837034061551094,
0.36011233925819397,
-0.6550092101097107,
-0.3157009482383728,
0.12131746113300323,
-0.3367043435573578,
-0.41167426109313965,
-0.7542195916175842,
0.46899479627609253,
-0.41259127855300903,
-0.1539967656135559,
-0.08868894726037979,
-0.11587560176849365,
0.08453938364982605,
0.21080560982227325,
-0.6998621225357056,
0.07560542225837708,
0.5997207760810852,
0.7099065780639648,
-0.4407639801502228,
-0.32128217816352844,
-0.6883299350738525,
0.40095698833465576,
-0.24317120015621185,
0.26059669256210327,
-0.35948053002357483,
-0.4673701822757721,
-0.2087130844593048,
0.4222014844417572,
0.24889487028121948,
-0.47906553745269775,
0.2318659871816635,
-1.0557138919830322,
0.33765479922294617,
-0.04255342110991478,
-0.6684850454330444,
-0.2275238186120987,
-0.21414439380168915,
-0.6884830594062805,
0.749407947063446,
-0.13310131430625916,
-0.8138716816902161,
0.37683647871017456,
-0.19704760611057281,
-0.6716819405555725,
0.11225732415914536,
-0.20408107340335846,
-0.7673870921134949,
0.03916344419121742,
-0.23591996729373932,
0.47869426012039185,
0.1931951344013214,
0.41104963421821594,
-0.17793311178684235,
-0.4546458125114441,
-0.00903453677892685,
-0.2928881049156189,
1.1079362630844116,
0.42479610443115234,
-0.5553389191627502,
0.15871718525886536,
-0.5998409986495972,
0.0192389078438282,
0.19696350395679474,
-0.6059974431991577,
-0.5601466298103333,
0.20148296654224396,
-0.3027445375919342,
0.3158913552761078,
0.3615974187850952,
-0.43832722306251526,
0.22462400794029236,
0.02002311870455742,
0.519538402557373,
0.9394456744194031,
-0.2670789361000061,
0.7952360510826111,
-0.3811018168926239,
0.42370933294296265,
0.0932062417268753,
-0.006011331453919411,
-0.3167976438999176,
-0.3980925977230072,
-0.684673547744751,
-0.4298601448535919,
0.4554680585861206,
0.7332391142845154,
-0.6884505152702332,
0.3911823332309723,
-0.33827608823776245,
-0.3275715708732605,
-0.6112246513366699,
0.5757502317428589,
0.6895534992218018,
0.30707764625549316,
0.2652079463005066,
-0.620459794998169,
-0.5198895931243896,
-0.581384003162384,
-0.3115578889846802,
0.13115935027599335,
-0.03647671267390251,
-0.08674336224794388,
0.26222142577171326,
-0.24368059635162354,
0.6500431299209595,
-0.023869505152106285,
-0.3766331076622009,
-0.07700704038143158,
0.562221109867096,
-0.028044624254107475,
0.7826216816902161,
0.04802851006388664,
-0.8929429054260254,
-0.3295794129371643,
-0.16174259781837463,
-1.1469204425811768,
-0.013322072103619576,
-0.3206768333911896,
-0.011271418072283268,
0.6103969812393188,
0.7055922150611877,
-0.5841557383537292,
0.613103985786438,
0.2012564092874527,
0.2758636176586151,
0.27014875411987305,
-0.38830995559692383,
0.08949997276067734,
-0.9753353595733643,
0.09568338841199875,
-0.35138726234436035,
-0.3779056966304779,
-0.38614609837532043,
0.051532287150621414,
-0.01040476281195879,
-0.14729361236095428,
-0.6968480348587036,
0.24380873143672943,
-0.7302340269088745,
-0.3165074288845062,
-0.5163967609405518,
-0.013303319923579693,
-0.053060758858919144,
0.43281158804893494,
0.278812438249588,
0.45369312167167664,
0.33554235100746155,
-0.3853488266468048,
-0.07280663400888443,
0.09198545664548874,
-0.26875221729278564,
0.2065710723400116,
-0.6064567565917969,
0.33009979128837585,
-0.5075059533119202,
0.06998039036989212,
-0.5847356915473938,
0.22868388891220093,
0.06902197003364563,
-0.32370805740356445,
0.504927396774292,
-0.5912525057792664,
-0.5598908066749573,
-0.17513486742973328,
-0.2012469470500946,
0.3140881359577179,
0.7844579815864563,
-0.45663347840309143,
0.5130626559257507,
0.5468305945396423,
-0.2745456397533417,
-1.1166974306106567,
-0.68552565574646,
-0.010344837792217731,
-0.23532386124134064,
-0.45075929164886475,
0.4715658128261566,
-0.038814134895801544,
-0.11193269491195679,
0.2564293444156647,
-0.10351663827896118,
-0.005629996303468943,
0.16457492113113403,
0.5852885842323303,
0.0038066382985562086,
0.02188819646835327,
-0.006146074738353491,
-0.1340782642364502,
-0.28693312406539917,
-0.07076199352741241,
-0.43402740359306335,
0.5767679810523987,
0.19677422940731049,
-0.2637086510658264,
-0.45485442876815796,
0.36008918285369873,
0.6759728193283081,
-0.25173917412757874,
0.5804607272148132,
0.6220353841781616,
-0.5984954237937927,
-0.3665432929992676,
-0.23740403354167938,
0.10407704859972,
-0.5073947906494141,
0.17592322826385498,
-0.018606239929795265,
-0.8698722720146179,
0.5089884996414185,
-0.1937524825334549,
0.403899610042572,
0.05761762335896492,
0.585866391658783,
-0.30190160870552063,
0.8187967538833618,
0.7611801028251648,
-0.09211861342191696,
0.7635329365730286,
-0.3878176212310791,
0.14270180463790894,
-0.5576045513153076,
-0.4514191150665283,
-0.2801399528980255,
-0.5146229267120361,
-0.40176162123680115,
-0.48545601963996887,
-0.1621614396572113,
0.6887379884719849,
-0.3980801999568939,
0.33854973316192627,
-0.45014575123786926,
0.8929047584533691,
0.8409826159477234,
0.25126367807388306,
0.6364921927452087,
0.13648557662963867,
-0.20119455456733704,
-0.08835258334875107,
-0.43659868836402893,
-0.7760721445083618,
1.1252645254135132,
0.09382303804159164,
0.7462567090988159,
0.0697522759437561,
0.9436981678009033,
0.45210346579551697,
0.446807324886322,
-0.6196815371513367,
0.56242436170578,
-0.61038738489151,
-0.5374385118484497,
-0.49615758657455444,
-0.6006898283958435,
-0.9979931712150574,
0.15262146294116974,
-0.1255418062210083,
-0.5736798644065857,
-0.10175050795078278,
0.137365460395813,
-0.09759379923343658,
0.7323678731918335,
-0.452677458524704,
0.8085508942604065,
-0.5842306017875671,
-0.8128292560577393,
-0.23340895771980286,
-0.9790930151939392,
0.4657888114452362,
-0.528700053691864,
0.4323488473892212,
-0.15842413902282715,
0.006272648461163044,
0.8228028416633606,
-0.6831144690513611,
0.8526201248168945,
-0.26513350009918213,
-0.031231077387928963,
0.1760001927614212,
0.10760489851236343,
0.4290022552013397,
-0.14045776426792145,
0.015305581502616405,
0.10938602685928345,
-0.15341894328594208,
-0.5081512928009033,
-0.3481610417366028,
0.535805881023407,
-0.8478108048439026,
-0.6006076335906982,
-0.4465043544769287,
-0.39799273014068604,
0.17316865921020508,
0.7952309846878052,
0.43785360455513,
0.07951085269451141,
0.045361537486314774,
0.10109810531139374,
0.7883995175361633,
-0.23768974840641022,
0.7580922245979309,
0.5776546001434326,
-0.1416863203048706,
-0.4146859645843506,
1.1248347759246826,
0.052720677107572556,
0.22765818238258362,
0.2909666895866394,
0.12789951264858246,
-0.390377938747406,
-0.8483833074569702,
-0.3639092743396759,
0.22402963042259216,
-0.8940498232841492,
-0.09186462312936783,
-0.5016953349113464,
-0.20568592846393585,
-0.1871660202741623,
-0.2430744618177414,
-0.4420287013053894,
-0.29540500044822693,
-0.5937017798423767,
0.1898244023323059,
0.034874387085437775,
0.6828532218933105,
-0.07313553988933563,
0.44556111097335815,
-1.0445168018341064,
0.3904001712799072,
0.22644542157649994,
0.37849706411361694,
-0.0021955305710434914,
-0.7950429916381836,
-0.06209341436624527,
0.008454141207039356,
-0.342413067817688,
-0.3062163293361664,
0.40403926372528076,
0.005278544034808874,
0.700839638710022,
0.5542258620262146,
0.18453949689865112,
0.6002427339553833,
-0.8059964179992676,
0.5860288143157959,
0.42896682024002075,
-1.1252113580703735,
0.2681870460510254,
-0.25451603531837463,
0.19622497260570526,
0.46100690960884094,
0.6998141407966614,
-0.24789996445178986,
-0.3678950369358063,
-0.6355352997779846,
-1.1582709550857544,
0.5456136465072632,
0.00004305107722757384,
0.13943836092948914,
0.22080351412296295,
0.2927929759025574,
0.1928112655878067,
0.6228067278862,
-0.8138306140899658,
-0.05042833089828491,
-0.2887706458568573,
-0.23646685481071472,
-0.15447674691677094,
0.005677621345967054,
0.0028945680242031813,
-0.13249388337135315,
0.8346976637840271,
0.26342853903770447,
-0.10343877226114273,
-0.2650461494922638,
-0.6899467706680298,
-0.3527199625968933,
0.16245399415493011,
0.4006791412830353,
0.5445531010627747,
-0.09683641791343689,
0.1759905368089676,
-0.1523352861404419,
-0.49393168091773987,
0.3967687785625458,
-0.03399066999554634,
-0.39971214532852173,
-0.21647784113883972,
0.18020877242088318,
0.38112664222717285,
0.5267046689987183,
-0.753021776676178,
0.4986169934272766,
0.11021586507558823,
-0.0717458724975586,
-0.31684255599975586,
-0.2010440081357956,
0.11609548330307007,
0.19288834929466248,
0.19175994396209717,
0.1590787172317505,
-0.24051439762115479,
-0.33141642808914185,
0.6785834431648254,
0.29933440685272217,
-0.24484090507030487,
-0.08582189679145813,
1.0134649276733398,
0.1322825402021408,
-0.22479191422462463,
0.7423213720321655,
0.04954371973872185,
-0.5611938834190369,
0.37621331214904785,
0.39043429493904114,
0.7718480825424194,
-0.25734180212020874,
0.1341431736946106,
-0.04095982015132904,
0.3813055455684662,
-0.7053328156471252,
0.26357805728912354,
0.1277465671300888,
-0.7432250380516052,
-0.41312122344970703,
-0.5264680981636047,
-0.2518220543861389,
0.17676787078380585,
-0.712241530418396,
0.2668665647506714,
-0.8175707459449768,
-0.25434356927871704,
-0.0082803750410676,
-0.12618409097194672,
-0.4509621560573578,
0.12449892610311508,
0.2556632161140442,
0.4159415662288666,
-0.5382966995239258,
0.9563325047492981,
0.541680097579956,
-0.6353927254676819,
-0.6102935075759888,
-0.26841047406196594,
0.2746078670024872,
-0.7960304617881775,
0.6980634927749634,
0.2286555916070938,
-0.249496191740036,
0.2579633593559265,
-0.6145052909851074,
-0.654064953327179,
1.041349172592163,
0.652421236038208,
-0.8301371335983276,
0.09492980688810349,
0.08804101496934891,
0.1689591407775879,
-0.20314352214336395,
-0.30170106887817383,
0.2011367529630661,
0.099125437438488,
0.23195095360279083,
-0.3981003761291504,
0.05101360008120537,
-0.28152379393577576,
-0.2283991277217865,
0.18676723539829254,
-0.5225468873977661,
0.830517053604126,
-0.5995845794677734,
-0.38722002506256104,
0.25535809993743896,
0.6131328344345093,
0.35779792070388794,
0.27620792388916016,
0.6603268980979919,
0.9683786630630493,
1.053765892982483,
-0.035263869911432266,
0.6308522820472717,
-0.2552703320980072,
0.14253835380077362,
1.3049407005310059,
-0.38323137164115906,
0.9767099022865295,
0.5409388542175293,
0.1346343457698822,
0.4930257499217987,
0.6264342665672302,
-0.23582282662391663,
0.6365028619766235,
0.564701497554779,
-0.30409085750579834,
-0.45310214161872864,
-0.01678052730858326,
-0.1267618089914322,
0.194900780916214,
-0.04153161868453026,
-0.5850008726119995,
0.0407215915620327,
-0.018237022683024406,
0.34609919786453247,
0.07083092629909515,
-0.3699900507926941,
0.6591328382492065,
0.354360967874527,
-0.4450314939022064,
0.5826281309127808,
-0.08284963667392731,
0.64752197265625,
-0.5021304488182068,
0.27380162477493286,
-0.06464172154664993,
0.4376682639122009,
-0.3304249346256256,
-0.5953236222267151,
-0.03713778033852577,
0.2454928457736969,
-0.3688691258430481,
-0.47613203525543213,
0.4773338735103607,
-0.7034462094306946,
-0.22273193299770355,
0.44530993700027466,
0.3783341348171234,
0.34261348843574524,
0.23137888312339783,
-0.8015809655189514,
0.21170207858085632,
-0.15845519304275513,
-0.21372540295124054,
0.5879096388816833,
0.46617215871810913,
-0.23235802352428436,
0.7893061637878418,
0.8624864220619202,
-0.0029588607139885426,
0.20238453149795532,
0.17833641171455383,
0.7972468733787537,
-0.5543683171272278,
-0.38246652483940125,
-0.6918222904205322,
0.8120229840278625,
-0.032102975994348526,
0.03530719131231308,
0.7500871419906616,
0.5428394675254822,
1.0559799671173096,
-0.03165303170681,
0.9878243803977966,
0.3663739562034607,
0.0809619352221489,
-0.6934292316436768,
0.9984388947486877,
-0.7409353852272034,
0.5933638215065002,
-0.39766815304756165,
-0.7549039721488953,
-0.37641939520835876,
0.3840576708316803,
0.07567977160215378,
0.012363565154373646,
0.5471786856651306,
0.4385737180709839,
0.010642101056873798,
0.17258954048156738,
0.38667401671409607,
-0.020607074722647667,
0.14315921068191528,
0.23137441277503967,
0.8948615789413452,
-0.22495445609092712,
0.46697601675987244,
-0.3576125204563141,
-0.2058507204055786,
0.28876787424087524,
-1.3007153272628784,
-0.8567441701889038,
-0.28713858127593994,
-0.3149454593658447,
-0.2725658714771271,
0.15799526870250702,
0.6951012015342712,
0.6179412007331848,
-0.8740678429603577,
-0.30141934752464294,
0.09570387005805969,
0.2888602018356323,
-0.09348409622907639,
-0.1386888176202774,
0.27075475454330444,
-0.4854954779148102,
-0.651066243648529,
0.3187066614627838,
0.15756158530712128,
0.3858509659767151,
-0.17448200285434723,
-0.17040598392486572,
-0.16010592877864838,
-0.13859474658966064,
0.5433361530303955,
0.5677189826965332,
-0.6951615214347839,
-0.0787273421883583,
-0.2359708696603775,
-0.0466819666326046,
-0.07727032899856567,
1.1175943613052368,
-0.6785077452659607,
0.39959755539894104,
0.4943247437477112,
0.8624818921089172,
0.3962399959564209,
0.14192749559879303,
0.5673100352287292,
-0.9408158659934998,
0.29221898317337036,
0.07277300953865051,
0.6047395467758179,
0.4441426396369934,
-0.2688700556755066,
0.31589022278785706,
0.5245115160942078,
-0.6418132781982422,
-0.917503297328949,
0.09155535697937012,
-1.011484146118164,
-0.6069484353065491,
0.9014954566955566,
-0.5371817350387573,
-0.18412168323993683,
-0.22352543473243713,
0.2640753388404846,
0.5981261730194092,
-0.3614937663078308,
0.6628074049949646,
0.39513853192329407,
0.29629936814308167,
-0.16794747114181519,
-0.40148675441741943,
0.4124542772769928,
0.409975528717041,
-0.5532864332199097,
0.3025338053703308,
0.42707616090774536,
0.5547894239425659,
0.0705236941576004,
0.5592591762542725,
-0.48741644620895386,
0.04214717447757721,
-0.5251790881156921,
0.253897100687027,
-0.2955044209957123,
-0.5947389006614685,
-0.469181090593338,
0.12146065384149551,
-0.13318365812301636,
-0.24211466312408447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10950v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10950v1
|
E-Bench: Towards Evaluating the Ease-of-Use of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-16T14:08:30 | 2024-06-16T14:08:30 |
Zhenyu Zhang, Bingguang Hao, Jinpeng Li, Zekai Zhang, Dongyan Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Most large language models (LLMs) are sensitive to prompts, and another
synonymous expression or a typo may lead to unexpected results for the model.
Composing an optimal prompt for a specific demand lacks theoretical support and
relies entirely on human experimentation, which poses a considerable obstacle
to popularizing generative artificial intelligence. However, there is no
systematic analysis of the stability of LLMs in resisting prompt perturbations
in real-world scenarios. In this work, we propose to evaluate the ease-of-use
of LLMs and construct E-Bench, simulating the actual situation of human use
from synonymous perturbation (including paraphrasing, simplification, and
colloquialism) and typographical perturbation (such as typing). On this basis,
we also discuss the combination of these two types of perturbation and analyze
the main reasons for performance degradation. Experimental results indicate
that with the increase of model size, although the ease-of-use are
significantly improved, there is still a long way to go to build a sufficiently
user-friendly model.
|
[
-0.526505708694458,
-1.245316982269287,
0.7794869542121887,
0.49570897221565247,
-0.28978779911994934,
-0.20069070160388947,
-0.4081665277481079,
-0.25005775690078735,
-0.03818904235959053,
0.29742929339408875,
-0.38147351145744324,
-0.43828967213630676,
-0.5184066295623779,
0.4700871407985687,
-0.7544822096824646,
0.3526596128940582,
-0.21046556532382965,
0.08933110535144806,
-0.4332539439201355,
-0.07676947861909866,
-0.2697884142398834,
-0.8067790865898132,
-0.5286992192268372,
-0.0934351310133934,
0.4561547636985779,
0.4205518662929535,
0.46182018518447876,
0.47411301732063293,
0.3012083172798157,
0.393974632024765,
0.036561962217092514,
-0.2149547040462494,
-0.5485535860061646,
0.5983020663261414,
0.20238856971263885,
-0.6116757988929749,
-0.23370561003684998,
-0.17423632740974426,
0.6766818761825562,
0.730423092842102,
-0.30148106813430786,
0.036012060940265656,
0.15370868146419525,
0.3824094831943512,
-0.3883782625198364,
0.08916528522968292,
-0.41597431898117065,
-0.3786536157131195,
-0.10578768700361252,
0.00450981454923749,
-0.4628462493419647,
-0.2160978466272354,
0.04536706581711769,
-0.6995245814323425,
-0.18434903025627136,
0.3356395661830902,
0.8312627673149109,
0.43331798911094666,
0.011003338731825352,
-0.1801113486289978,
-0.6516578197479248,
0.7540175318717957,
-0.6027723550796509,
0.3251778483390808,
0.5081506967544556,
0.36339691281318665,
-0.3794417381286621,
-0.6416809558868408,
-0.6976233124732971,
-0.7922016978263855,
0.013527506962418556,
-0.04003695026040077,
0.05402589216828346,
0.11582333594560623,
0.5548218488693237,
-0.008213001303374767,
-0.42993003129959106,
0.5015506148338318,
0.1549379974603653,
0.0762580931186676,
0.3276005983352661,
0.3371645510196686,
0.5648670792579651,
-0.1965789496898651,
-0.1867518126964569,
-0.3284345269203186,
-0.8758798837661743,
0.07780935615301132,
0.33609631657600403,
0.36000147461891174,
-0.018453357741236687,
0.6113111972808838,
-0.23180824518203735,
0.8581783175468445,
0.00015496363630518317,
-0.04506782069802284,
0.07227537035942078,
-0.054368555545806885,
-0.08961822837591171,
-0.4180205464363098,
0.7582535147666931,
0.33284035325050354,
0.2569209039211273,
-0.02535746805369854,
-0.39481601119041443,
-0.07544735819101334,
0.14918175339698792,
-0.6942481994628906,
0.2048237919807434,
0.3534614145755768,
-0.3140391707420349,
-0.14794963598251343,
-0.16749189794063568,
-0.7275797128677368,
-0.5830928683280945,
-0.43359342217445374,
0.4710594117641449,
-0.5358220338821411,
0.045268893241882324,
-0.08760490268468857,
0.10013827681541443,
0.13698652386665344,
0.5084425210952759,
-0.6380179524421692,
0.41780832409858704,
0.4898751974105835,
0.7283380031585693,
-0.0005492185591720045,
-0.49994906783103943,
-0.43233218789100647,
-0.003136712359264493,
0.047015562653541565,
0.9647247195243835,
-0.38710859417915344,
-0.7598533034324646,
0.1554456353187561,
-0.21059711277484894,
-0.10202529281377792,
-0.5735772848129272,
0.7887082695960999,
-0.32323113083839417,
-0.026296842843294144,
-0.26674774289131165,
-0.6312236785888672,
0.11800853163003922,
0.33621692657470703,
-0.872534453868866,
0.7355062365531921,
0.08353262394666672,
-0.411758691072464,
0.2240978181362152,
-0.6629092693328857,
-0.4069856107234955,
0.0738883838057518,
-0.4648194909095764,
-0.2393379658460617,
0.34384435415267944,
0.08344908058643341,
0.22332333028316498,
-0.6643688082695007,
0.229209765791893,
-0.28215643763542175,
-0.46864622831344604,
0.5371362566947937,
-0.17469842731952667,
0.52257239818573,
0.06727728247642517,
-0.33540382981300354,
-0.09275739639997482,
-0.8558664321899414,
-0.17116360366344452,
0.08286949247121811,
-0.45752426981925964,
-0.4404193162918091,
0.38397887349128723,
0.13501626253128052,
0.17670109868049622,
0.054919615387916565,
-0.5130061507225037,
0.05396680161356926,
-0.2595996558666229,
0.2563737630844116,
0.7595499753952026,
-0.12342169135808945,
0.07110581547021866,
-0.5113633275032043,
0.6555582880973816,
-0.3486550450325012,
0.15853658318519592,
-0.25449296832084656,
-0.29050910472869873,
-0.6807664632797241,
-0.4071420431137085,
0.6254430413246155,
0.4541182518005371,
-0.6635178923606873,
0.2479528933763504,
-0.21937555074691772,
-0.3851407468318939,
-0.28465381264686584,
0.13863660395145416,
0.4561847448348999,
0.3782869279384613,
0.1480567455291748,
-0.022835223004221916,
-0.3718063533306122,
-1.1476582288742065,
-0.45834457874298096,
-0.18327513337135315,
-0.04793800786137581,
0.42307397723197937,
0.12417343258857727,
-0.021635795012116432,
0.8381961584091187,
-0.07455788552761078,
0.25670647621154785,
-0.24917912483215332,
0.3715049922466278,
0.08779487013816833,
0.25288137793540955,
0.6608597040176392,
-0.6565106511116028,
-0.5779603719711304,
-0.45919981598854065,
-0.5491607189178467,
-0.6481014490127563,
-0.014624443836510181,
0.1104007437825203,
0.3387777507305145,
0.6236533522605896,
-0.7637342810630798,
0.369709312915802,
0.5054358243942261,
-0.13389824330806732,
0.8223630785942078,
-0.04722486436367035,
0.30438244342803955,
-0.7134523391723633,
0.3034365475177765,
0.17181396484375,
-0.02290346659719944,
-0.5420674085617065,
0.2974681854248047,
0.03900716453790665,
-0.3165845274925232,
-0.3412587344646454,
0.5970541834831238,
-0.4434850811958313,
0.12580855190753937,
-0.24196144938468933,
0.25045427680015564,
-0.15259012579917908,
0.12907113134860992,
-0.24481835961341858,
0.8894296288490295,
0.34114667773246765,
-0.8591406941413879,
0.23732778429985046,
0.16700850427150726,
-0.445830762386322,
0.4585430920124054,
-0.7965812683105469,
0.09872956573963165,
-0.1555965691804886,
0.15768857300281525,
-1.27305269241333,
-0.373718798160553,
-0.015197199769318104,
-0.3252953290939331,
0.48306000232696533,
0.286202996969223,
-0.8388277888298035,
-0.41450512409210205,
-0.4314822554588318,
0.3483777940273285,
0.45859718322753906,
-0.5926004648208618,
0.6519110798835754,
0.23763316869735718,
-0.4240139126777649,
-0.1796109974384308,
-0.6353220343589783,
0.13591693341732025,
-0.1501104086637497,
-0.7103213667869568,
0.27602913975715637,
-0.2712891697883606,
-0.5740429162979126,
-0.16366122663021088,
0.11701961606740952,
0.16108450293540955,
0.37999311089515686,
0.3685586750507355,
0.3019242584705353,
0.06148753687739372,
0.33982837200164795,
-0.15535369515419006,
-0.013338213786482811,
0.1775376796722412,
0.2500227987766266,
0.8609848022460938,
-0.034979093819856644,
-0.5663350224494934,
-0.5914003849029541,
0.441824346780777,
0.8758352398872375,
0.05371342971920967,
0.7710883021354675,
-0.04421328753232956,
-0.30165228247642517,
-0.12337569147348404,
-0.7753774523735046,
-0.1231045052409172,
-0.4872531592845917,
0.4938807785511017,
-0.5744998455047607,
-0.6439893245697021,
0.6012077927589417,
-0.33523356914520264,
0.038246821612119675,
0.413118451833725,
0.5537279844284058,
-0.27236300706863403,
1.0047061443328857,
0.3354867994785309,
0.2890094220638275,
0.47161242365837097,
0.16789357364177704,
0.14514091610908508,
-0.6855682134628296,
-0.1101442277431488,
-0.8536564111709595,
-0.33397990465164185,
-0.4194302260875702,
-0.18491333723068237,
0.31375542283058167,
-0.023487551137804985,
-0.2760276794433594,
0.296163946390152,
-0.10636349022388458,
0.23267057538032532,
0.4542330801486969,
0.0007732302183285356,
0.106622114777565,
0.06661181896924973,
-0.4494258761405945,
-0.06816224753856659,
-0.5513620376586914,
-0.7647694945335388,
1.1448549032211304,
0.06867017596960068,
0.8117231130599976,
0.18684688210487366,
0.638789713382721,
0.08057249337434769,
0.37180641293525696,
-0.80283522605896,
0.7603683471679688,
-0.26695793867111206,
-0.4800869822502136,
-0.4152330756187439,
-0.3016822636127472,
-0.7997808456420898,
0.17162851989269257,
-0.22767385840415955,
-0.8760149478912354,
0.14747892320156097,
0.1593450903892517,
-0.6242725849151611,
-0.031810611486434937,
-0.8914528489112854,
0.7006556391716003,
-0.5486592054367065,
-0.6060557961463928,
-0.18879076838493347,
-0.3729305863380432,
0.2555587887763977,
-0.35592126846313477,
0.5291942358016968,
0.013027790002524853,
-0.32155829668045044,
0.5163753032684326,
-0.5640813112258911,
0.8203657865524292,
-0.2092694789171219,
0.053225915879011154,
0.3643430173397064,
0.17510142922401428,
0.5606117844581604,
-0.12119930237531662,
-0.43809881806373596,
-0.34889936447143555,
-0.18679042160511017,
-0.25467172265052795,
-0.6636839509010315,
0.9002120494842529,
-0.9437478184700012,
-0.9655444622039795,
-0.10360641032457352,
-0.3637971878051758,
-0.6288862824440002,
-0.053780801594257355,
0.15191103518009186,
0.5596433877944946,
-0.47050371766090393,
0.21796056628227234,
0.45946523547172546,
-0.479524701833725,
0.6063388586044312,
0.6020113825798035,
-0.5554441809654236,
-0.1854366809129715,
0.6149314641952515,
0.3439273238182068,
0.26598238945007324,
0.17417548596858978,
0.2542192041873932,
-0.43119314312934875,
-0.6176165342330933,
-0.3040488064289093,
0.1884341984987259,
-0.5632401704788208,
0.10352443158626556,
-0.43924185633659363,
0.12248395383358002,
-0.2435726672410965,
-0.050435300916433334,
-0.07827849686145782,
-0.5096308588981628,
-0.2305658906698227,
0.050613563507795334,
0.2918863892555237,
0.6799306869506836,
0.15295562148094177,
0.44929537177085876,
-0.7235020995140076,
0.11590377241373062,
0.35991111397743225,
0.5106312036514282,
-0.00939112901687622,
-0.5745398998260498,
0.017517736181616783,
-0.23978836834430695,
-0.041281625628471375,
-0.952916145324707,
0.20132116973400116,
0.0319131463766098,
0.8336899280548096,
0.23262275755405426,
-0.01224528532475233,
0.39935216307640076,
-0.3585757911205292,
0.8395271301269531,
0.2623503506183624,
-0.9410414099693298,
0.34476789832115173,
-0.6625587344169617,
0.2783147692680359,
0.8671033978462219,
0.4258178174495697,
-0.43661049008369446,
-0.13105911016464233,
-0.48679405450820923,
-1.1197785139083862,
0.6292318105697632,
-0.2040432244539261,
0.10322640836238861,
-0.05743912234902382,
0.5804979205131531,
0.1889977604150772,
0.3088131844997406,
-0.544347882270813,
-0.20566906034946442,
-0.0020406947005540133,
0.015512804500758648,
-0.0383729413151741,
-0.5169409513473511,
-0.0009807517053559422,
-0.25891444087028503,
0.6260684728622437,
0.23430882394313812,
0.09871464222669601,
0.05275397747755051,
-0.43813279271125793,
-0.10502178221940994,
0.36785221099853516,
0.6283432245254517,
0.6147233843803406,
-0.206034854054451,
-0.04663056507706642,
0.08818194270133972,
-0.13288232684135437,
0.2927653193473816,
0.25990164279937744,
-0.29949143528938293,
-0.09532272815704346,
-0.0073522827588021755,
0.8049668073654175,
0.5089426636695862,
-1.0191973447799683,
0.3316637873649597,
-0.17075781524181366,
-0.2454424798488617,
-0.2974811792373657,
-0.08075917512178421,
0.20590238273143768,
-0.1607619971036911,
0.2872554063796997,
-0.23133723437786102,
-0.058910634368658066,
-0.6495281457901001,
0.0857548788189888,
0.13520479202270508,
0.09690623730421066,
-0.1485327184200287,
0.5240797400474548,
0.4341328740119934,
-0.631331741809845,
0.6627879738807678,
-0.22759726643562317,
-0.5897274613380432,
0.5705093741416931,
0.6788576245307922,
0.703747570514679,
-0.4221440255641937,
0.05263245105743408,
0.37605535984039307,
0.2134445309638977,
-0.02600163221359253,
0.2015908807516098,
0.26261603832244873,
-0.4774457812309265,
-0.3766450583934784,
-0.7149752378463745,
-0.4321637451648712,
0.27415981888771057,
-0.4121417999267578,
0.37348097562789917,
-0.7769364714622498,
-0.4669373631477356,
-0.19650445878505707,
-0.22545191645622253,
-0.7019528746604919,
0.003038209630176425,
0.16789068281650543,
0.9190892577171326,
-0.7356702089309692,
0.5339267253875732,
1.021787405014038,
-0.5219137668609619,
-0.9103890657424927,
0.11569874733686447,
0.030945664271712303,
-0.7730861306190491,
0.6198194026947021,
0.17413915693759918,
-0.03319733217358589,
0.05801514908671379,
-0.530214786529541,
-0.8875316381454468,
0.9675834774971008,
0.42577064037323,
-1.0091384649276733,
0.13811488449573517,
0.036850083619356155,
0.580676794052124,
-0.15388427674770355,
0.3676007091999054,
0.6239434480667114,
0.8548300862312317,
-0.05564136058092117,
-0.9346543550491333,
0.2962298095226288,
-0.27670028805732727,
-0.017602331936359406,
0.13633182644844055,
-0.7514973282814026,
1.1058939695358276,
0.0728924572467804,
-0.40375182032585144,
0.4685527980327606,
0.1886618584394455,
0.27070412039756775,
-0.20554788410663605,
0.5622299313545227,
0.7147409915924072,
0.6970235109329224,
-0.13210585713386536,
1.5403510332107544,
-0.465768039226532,
0.17211656272411346,
0.9062462449073792,
-0.5220756530761719,
1.035078763961792,
0.6312858462333679,
-0.4948343336582184,
0.4667010009288788,
0.5470965504646301,
0.06365231424570084,
0.23567594587802887,
0.694928765296936,
-0.33385637402534485,
-0.3467044532299042,
-0.026420095935463905,
-0.23435239493846893,
0.40525954961776733,
0.5972452759742737,
-0.20151235163211823,
-0.2867416441440582,
-0.0029770969413220882,
-0.2550604045391083,
0.3441320061683655,
-0.2029872089624405,
0.4289827048778534,
0.2006404548883438,
-0.8143889904022217,
0.6380568742752075,
0.10072162747383118,
0.5465081334114075,
-0.52073734998703,
0.24979133903980255,
-0.009116502478718758,
-0.09680282324552536,
0.06400196254253387,
-0.2509772479534149,
-0.12650498747825623,
0.10574731975793839,
-0.09949194639921188,
-0.0718001127243042,
0.5052694082260132,
-0.1605372428894043,
-0.35877543687820435,
0.38248586654663086,
0.7996416091918945,
0.12256131321191788,
-0.005559636279940605,
-0.6280927062034607,
0.3993290364742279,
-0.26951131224632263,
-0.546532928943634,
0.5154227614402771,
0.09734416007995605,
0.04703151062130928,
0.5420080423355103,
0.4569140672683716,
-0.09719474613666534,
0.12132767587900162,
0.5052055716514587,
0.8454256653785706,
-0.4997278153896332,
-0.18550516664981842,
-0.8750232458114624,
0.2760777473449707,
-0.16221269965171814,
-0.27198895812034607,
0.6809355020523071,
0.23110516369342804,
0.2553749680519104,
-0.0489405058324337,
0.9274590611457825,
-0.19360396265983582,
0.5807601809501648,
-0.4116520583629608,
0.7512643933296204,
-0.5676673650741577,
0.3857860267162323,
-0.18912087380886078,
-0.8838503956794739,
-0.4487464129924774,
0.5057734847068787,
-0.5257468819618225,
0.13400009274482727,
0.842481791973114,
0.6918556690216064,
0.2636919319629669,
0.09853634983301163,
0.45748254656791687,
0.5615434646606445,
0.15085871517658234,
0.2946282923221588,
1.1214027404785156,
0.0036155381239950657,
0.4471597969532013,
-0.17520608007907867,
-0.42427030205726624,
-0.5315824747085571,
-0.8945301175117493,
-0.7533968091011047,
-0.4716058373451233,
-0.11096371710300446,
-0.24127595126628876,
0.24075743556022644,
1.1638895273208618,
0.28158533573150635,
-0.701224684715271,
-0.38285714387893677,
-0.18902550637722015,
-0.32488587498664856,
0.15826424956321716,
-0.14736464619636536,
0.30204513669013977,
-0.6172815561294556,
-0.7393477559089661,
0.44238775968551636,
0.05338626354932785,
0.14443440735340118,
-0.3406456708908081,
0.0641549676656723,
-0.36377185583114624,
0.1866365373134613,
0.5147846341133118,
0.4847657084465027,
-0.6634675860404968,
-0.2169366031885147,
0.10606109350919724,
-0.292825847864151,
-0.12359254062175751,
0.7603105306625366,
-0.7767231464385986,
0.5044209957122803,
0.46901705861091614,
0.699235737323761,
0.31549587845802307,
0.2211053967475891,
0.9006327390670776,
-0.4361668825149536,
-0.008613535203039646,
0.09442897886037827,
0.623690664768219,
0.35386887192726135,
-0.05433466285467148,
0.13874585926532745,
0.14514335989952087,
-0.4937933385372162,
-0.7552374601364136,
0.20768581330776215,
-0.7421332597732544,
-0.3659050762653351,
1.307911992073059,
-0.17290981113910675,
-0.5256844758987427,
-0.07453358918428421,
-0.2938457131385803,
0.2678895592689514,
-0.46913406252861023,
1.0277751684188843,
1.1452494859695435,
-0.23964078724384308,
-0.019082969054579735,
-0.5299250483512878,
0.319494366645813,
0.6920062303543091,
-0.7209041714668274,
0.07719223946332932,
0.6672404408454895,
0.2471880465745926,
0.1695413440465927,
0.41734579205513,
-0.08467675000429153,
0.34715110063552856,
0.13741573691368103,
-0.008618948981165886,
-0.15428389608860016,
-0.13721425831317902,
-0.5091919302940369,
0.32352203130722046,
0.7313975095748901,
0.04405412822961807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10937v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10937v2
|
Understanding Understanding: A Pragmatic Framework Motivated by Large Language Models
| 2024-06-16T13:37:08 | 2024-06-19T08:34:21 |
Kevin Leyton-Brown, Yoav Shoham
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Motivated by the rapid ascent of Large Language Models (LLMs) and debates
about the extent to which they possess human-level qualities, we propose a
framework for testing whether any agent (be it a machine or a human)
understands a subject matter. In Turing-test fashion, the framework is based
solely on the agent's performance, and specifically on how well it answers
questions. Elements of the framework include circumscribing the set of
questions (the "scope of understanding"), requiring general competence
("passing grade"), avoiding "ridiculous answers", but still allowing wrong and
"I don't know" answers to some questions. Reaching certainty about these
conditions requires exhaustive testing of the questions which is impossible for
nontrivial scopes, but we show how high confidence can be achieved via random
sampling and the application of probabilistic confidence bounds. We also show
that accompanying answers with explanations can improve the sample complexity
required to achieve acceptable bounds, because an explanation of an answer
implies the ability to answer many similar questions. According to our
framework, current LLMs cannot be said to understand nontrivial domains, but as
the framework provides a practical recipe for testing understanding, it thus
also constitutes a tool for building AI agents that do understand.
|
[
-0.492397665977478,
-0.8544691801071167,
0.8452126383781433,
0.11681202799081802,
-0.05301669239997864,
0.03172354772686958,
-0.24844743311405182,
-0.36110544204711914,
-0.35860559344291687,
0.4446345865726471,
-0.6532343626022339,
-0.4706185460090637,
-0.6513329744338989,
0.006151968613266945,
-0.5005801320075989,
0.6795698404312134,
-0.10231338441371918,
-0.11127804964780807,
-0.49913981556892395,
-0.10979855060577393,
-0.22978579998016357,
-0.18142737448215485,
-0.6841304302215576,
-0.47698667645454407,
0.5054624080657959,
0.5088155269622803,
0.7316677570343018,
0.7300805449485779,
0.326415479183197,
0.31824150681495667,
-0.14825718104839325,
-0.04543701931834221,
-0.46635666489601135,
0.041247665882110596,
-0.4843676686286926,
-0.9730667471885681,
-0.09187071025371552,
0.019708983600139618,
0.6234535574913025,
1.1301093101501465,
-0.001426055794581771,
0.1149069219827652,
-0.0488932766020298,
0.2936568558216095,
-0.3962743580341339,
0.27041861414909363,
-0.41758760809898376,
0.11109907180070877,
0.24060198664665222,
-0.25539883971214294,
-0.5038508176803589,
0.07116440683603287,
0.17348195612430573,
-0.9100387692451477,
0.38100746273994446,
0.11559867858886719,
1.016394853591919,
0.09926971793174744,
-0.6185227036476135,
-0.23396185040473938,
-0.47278183698654175,
0.7225377559661865,
-0.34432753920555115,
0.4195123016834259,
0.5527962446212769,
0.6328628063201904,
-0.15094052255153656,
-0.691914975643158,
-0.7498846650123596,
-0.30445897579193115,
-0.10376149415969849,
0.0817125216126442,
0.005634143017232418,
0.36887192726135254,
0.14489129185676575,
0.5402105450630188,
-0.798551619052887,
-0.07472851127386093,
-0.25197815895080566,
-0.24451236426830292,
0.49714040756225586,
-0.08828818798065186,
0.3653630018234253,
0.14901117980480194,
-0.24484948813915253,
-0.18700218200683594,
-0.45527949929237366,
0.17979875206947327,
0.06245996803045273,
-0.029016444459557533,
0.015813708305358887,
0.4786461293697357,
-0.06621924042701721,
1.045586347579956,
-0.022753801196813583,
-0.17538189888000488,
-0.09160621464252472,
-0.3119189739227295,
-0.4780121445655823,
-0.36774376034736633,
0.20545996725559235,
0.09631600230932236,
0.6512699127197266,
-0.36257609724998474,
-0.08174759894609451,
0.02162390947341919,
0.26602786779403687,
-0.7434886693954468,
-0.06197645887732506,
0.41265588998794556,
-0.4339767396450043,
-0.06395357102155685,
0.1964413970708847,
-0.2519226372241974,
-0.4117383062839508,
-0.502899169921875,
0.32995179295539856,
-0.5850819945335388,
-0.553104817867279,
0.2867550551891327,
-0.27647435665130615,
0.6896570920944214,
0.44824695587158203,
-0.6279760599136353,
0.2063860446214676,
0.9187655448913574,
0.6059485673904419,
0.14167360961437225,
-0.5902861952781677,
-0.4591028392314911,
-0.06554538011550903,
-0.4817518889904022,
0.7549775242805481,
-0.34419718384742737,
-0.21673129498958588,
-0.1965402215719223,
0.1768742948770523,
-0.14499633014202118,
-0.5094228386878967,
0.20235440135002136,
-0.677712619304657,
0.08788301795721054,
-0.1115100309252739,
-0.6956751346588135,
-0.6154066920280457,
0.5561140775680542,
-0.30008018016815186,
0.4095825254917145,
0.24611353874206543,
-0.2959904074668884,
0.43826553225517273,
-0.6641535758972168,
-0.3857644200325012,
0.1708289384841919,
-0.22149021923542023,
0.16869507730007172,
0.13859058916568756,
-0.06999514997005463,
0.4440493881702423,
-0.4283755421638489,
0.4059149920940399,
-0.21061253547668457,
-0.3335552215576172,
0.49833378195762634,
-0.3482207953929901,
0.7307009100914001,
0.2706702649593353,
-0.3919382095336914,
0.09019139409065247,
-0.5705263614654541,
0.13410788774490356,
0.16796626150608063,
-0.006280715577304363,
-0.042973894625902176,
-0.037392374128103256,
-0.15064066648483276,
0.16283529996871948,
0.12839029729366302,
-0.13103024661540985,
-0.14335185289382935,
-0.5381519794464111,
0.5037199258804321,
0.9109465479850769,
0.1452644020318985,
0.8105410933494568,
-0.622744619846344,
0.9426154494285583,
0.11723865568637848,
0.012432307936251163,
-0.31283318996429443,
-0.4473368227481842,
-0.7120198011398315,
-0.3167406916618347,
0.1942974478006363,
0.4326496124267578,
-0.4752987027168274,
0.3488340675830841,
-0.05734739825129509,
-0.34230440855026245,
-0.6265498399734497,
0.35261934995651245,
0.36533424258232117,
0.5447030663490295,
0.07786784321069717,
-0.23057782649993896,
-0.1289786547422409,
-0.9707263708114624,
-0.4267920255661011,
-0.38945794105529785,
-0.4228925108909607,
0.5753188133239746,
0.6635891199111938,
-0.1570739448070526,
0.9846327900886536,
-0.2806100845336914,
0.15733474493026733,
-0.3498097360134125,
0.287190705537796,
0.24824973940849304,
0.2060428261756897,
0.27276554703712463,
-1.1693106889724731,
-0.08229640126228333,
0.10854311287403107,
-0.8807178139686584,
0.03690967336297035,
-0.16187317669391632,
-0.16989511251449585,
-0.39462998509407043,
0.29260769486427307,
-0.6147770881652832,
0.3985934853553772,
0.3505530059337616,
-0.7002981305122375,
0.30451878905296326,
-0.2735736072063446,
0.14309380948543549,
-0.6972297430038452,
0.04707062989473343,
0.018169382587075233,
-0.5059945583343506,
-0.6818915009498596,
0.4293098747730255,
0.08335422724485397,
-0.06179822236299515,
-0.4193020761013031,
0.6348022818565369,
-0.4383218586444855,
-0.2807050347328186,
-0.17951805889606476,
0.5433412790298462,
0.38502079248428345,
0.22561833262443542,
0.131935715675354,
0.8220276832580566,
0.5621145963668823,
-0.8750596046447754,
0.14526580274105072,
0.06975031644105911,
-0.4556815028190613,
0.89377361536026,
-0.7956598997116089,
0.11020990461111069,
-0.5483139753341675,
0.016237739473581314,
-0.9617083668708801,
-0.36059048771858215,
0.21518592536449432,
-0.7394165396690369,
0.028553592041134834,
-0.17608654499053955,
-0.2932852506637573,
-0.014448067173361778,
0.16463029384613037,
0.3068457543849945,
0.4722936153411865,
-0.422593355178833,
0.9118962287902832,
0.25375106930732727,
0.16373653709888458,
-0.6658155918121338,
-0.6967398524284363,
-0.07123681157827377,
-0.23442865908145905,
-0.9120668768882751,
0.060621436685323715,
-0.3091888725757599,
-0.8534568548202515,
-0.08649015426635742,
-0.07780274003744125,
-0.38649967312812805,
0.6384137272834778,
0.2724177837371826,
-0.1139826774597168,
-0.3938902020454407,
0.3646196722984314,
-0.1898624747991562,
-0.03904356062412262,
0.2565212547779083,
-0.5753359198570251,
0.2809011936187744,
-0.18615780770778656,
-0.41173332929611206,
-0.4485488831996918,
0.2429509162902832,
0.7073378562927246,
-0.2688766121864319,
0.6299176812171936,
0.2941356599330902,
-0.39848804473876953,
-0.5464739799499512,
-0.1290968656539917,
-0.4103335440158844,
-0.42308661341667175,
0.43417447805404663,
-0.8095413446426392,
-0.9121888875961304,
0.5614446997642517,
-0.005249503068625927,
0.09469139575958252,
0.3263593316078186,
0.5601881742477417,
-0.16231590509414673,
0.9169801473617554,
0.6592178344726562,
0.2168155312538147,
0.14374077320098877,
-0.1751963496208191,
0.32413536310195923,
-0.3764573037624359,
-0.12752877175807953,
-0.5971865057945251,
-0.1864260584115982,
-0.30578914284706116,
-0.6945947408676147,
-0.07418609410524368,
0.23034195601940155,
-0.24910934269428253,
0.0310977715998888,
-0.42932453751564026,
0.5785566568374634,
0.3819914162158966,
-0.07270825654268265,
0.35065343976020813,
-0.4331127405166626,
0.17026834189891815,
0.29601168632507324,
-0.4675176739692688,
-0.7724525928497314,
0.917074978351593,
0.5642977356910706,
0.6019717454910278,
0.3489430248737335,
0.35824301838874817,
0.1368807554244995,
0.5162627696990967,
-1.0289220809936523,
0.3774002492427826,
0.49949103593826294,
-1.042211651802063,
-0.46512049436569214,
-0.467103511095047,
-1.0334309339523315,
0.6616429686546326,
0.21518926322460175,
-0.5732061266899109,
0.1870468705892563,
0.04361419007182121,
-0.11033068597316742,
0.010179010219871998,
-0.8612978458404541,
1.0284247398376465,
-0.2418292760848999,
-0.048248402774333954,
-0.16431410610675812,
-0.6647680997848511,
0.4700835943222046,
0.06503649055957794,
0.43598073720932007,
-0.31264248490333557,
-0.3187922239303589,
0.7301105260848999,
-0.1264733076095581,
0.732141375541687,
-0.3176497220993042,
0.048654381185770035,
0.36073875427246094,
0.10399632900953293,
0.022893769666552544,
0.3950921297073364,
-0.13429567217826843,
-0.18258213996887207,
0.13534337282180786,
-0.8271194100379944,
-1.0487920045852661,
0.1267441213130951,
-0.7324972152709961,
-0.6537744402885437,
-0.36567947268486023,
-0.7274612784385681,
-0.14763043820858002,
0.12478295713663101,
-0.0407896414399147,
0.07208064943552017,
-0.17951105535030365,
0.1399192363023758,
1.0165338516235352,
-0.1577478051185608,
-0.20299027860164642,
0.7198084592819214,
-0.1558949500322342,
0.14384478330612183,
0.6767873167991638,
-0.18950490653514862,
0.479739785194397,
0.4433174133300781,
0.19980518519878387,
-0.4368358850479126,
-0.6710156202316284,
-0.38084521889686584,
0.2256607562303543,
-0.9473249912261963,
0.1423819214105606,
-0.4168548583984375,
0.032069575041532516,
-0.35252755880355835,
-0.15962891280651093,
0.257675439119339,
-0.11448963731527328,
-0.4025053083896637,
-0.35255786776542664,
0.3256123960018158,
0.8664088845252991,
0.02182655967772007,
0.3946402370929718,
-0.3773413300514221,
0.43052762746810913,
0.3672437369823456,
0.025780601426959038,
-0.009799192659556866,
-0.9033706188201904,
-0.020398052409291267,
0.11825979501008987,
-0.1698521077632904,
-1.0561596155166626,
0.25050467252731323,
0.29294484853744507,
0.7582626938819885,
0.6092259883880615,
0.007920730859041214,
0.5808265805244446,
-0.07961386442184448,
0.6401177644729614,
-0.2032601237297058,
-1.2069388628005981,
0.6056297421455383,
-0.2957976758480072,
0.07886795699596405,
0.7789186239242554,
0.44673362374305725,
-0.5566273927688599,
-0.5950817465782166,
-0.8747958540916443,
-0.6144969463348389,
0.4271166920661926,
0.017957931384444237,
-0.025097277015447617,
0.161661759018898,
0.8391546010971069,
-0.08363904058933258,
0.3306538164615631,
-0.5698700547218323,
-0.1568485051393509,
0.117906354367733,
-0.40766099095344543,
-0.5144714117050171,
-0.006544976495206356,
-0.3809095323085785,
-0.15319311618804932,
0.42820748686790466,
-0.39748144149780273,
0.30768775939941406,
0.3635900914669037,
-0.5950413942337036,
0.16152697801589966,
0.26171889901161194,
0.5324794054031372,
1.2892087697982788,
-0.13913287222385406,
0.37047043442726135,
-0.010526561178267002,
-0.2739306390285492,
0.3857271373271942,
-0.023285089060664177,
0.12512274086475372,
-0.2948327660560608,
0.7030191421508789,
0.5122380256652832,
0.031244201585650444,
-1.1041786670684814,
0.636479914188385,
-0.2329377681016922,
-0.481974333524704,
-0.24858663976192474,
0.27292460203170776,
0.22259588539600372,
0.19911226630210876,
0.3860856890678406,
-0.41003215312957764,
0.12751150131225586,
-0.8520274758338928,
0.5997905135154724,
0.2530699372291565,
-0.3617677390575409,
-0.11975962668657303,
0.3224372863769531,
-0.09240388125181198,
-0.6424717903137207,
0.629951000213623,
-0.39803025126457214,
-0.5063281655311584,
1.0544060468673706,
0.5002605319023132,
0.47147125005722046,
0.04464791715145111,
0.2956368923187256,
-0.03801427036523819,
0.4679885804653168,
0.027844468131661415,
0.4275824725627899,
-0.5276439189910889,
-0.8927503228187561,
-0.6264404058456421,
-0.5398262739181519,
-0.8201923966407776,
-0.15928903222084045,
-0.8258212208747864,
-0.19105331599712372,
-0.5483230352401733,
0.24824756383895874,
0.10668227076530457,
0.05699199065566063,
-0.6632140278816223,
0.49882251024246216,
-0.281686007976532,
1.2280244827270508,
-0.8527342677116394,
0.6321964859962463,
0.667708694934845,
-0.4835372269153595,
-0.8731051087379456,
0.07586773484945297,
-0.0301984716206789,
-1.0922281742095947,
0.5332671999931335,
0.3494991362094879,
0.07805028557777405,
0.08653721213340759,
-0.5374409556388855,
-0.4219513535499573,
1.1288591623306274,
0.4793659746646881,
-0.38240474462509155,
0.16913580894470215,
-0.09784218668937683,
0.4660700857639313,
-0.45229464769363403,
0.4314025044441223,
0.9351320266723633,
0.8075689077377319,
0.050320904701948166,
-0.610228419303894,
-0.06832994520664215,
-0.17657744884490967,
-0.2935899496078491,
0.01586253009736538,
-0.16168001294136047,
0.735869288444519,
-0.2333463728427887,
-0.1902005523443222,
0.019588204100728035,
0.7398496270179749,
0.29621437191963196,
0.6331409215927124,
0.707700788974762,
0.45749911665916443,
1.2063422203063965,
-0.155564546585083,
1.2004247903823853,
-0.19916962087154388,
0.2287897914648056,
0.9442629218101501,
-0.0010568754514679313,
0.5254179239273071,
0.5143974423408508,
-0.24978213012218475,
0.4860122799873352,
0.9724547863006592,
0.42098236083984375,
0.22510123252868652,
0.7103912234306335,
-0.25689175724983215,
-0.5382459759712219,
-0.010513934306800365,
-0.12206930667161942,
0.5022493004798889,
0.4792156219482422,
-0.48854267597198486,
-0.1132718175649643,
0.094029501080513,
-0.20331405103206635,
0.3114476203918457,
-0.19766582548618317,
0.6909570693969727,
0.23503942787647247,
-0.7710864543914795,
0.5564687848091125,
0.0599227249622345,
0.2727665901184082,
-0.5262637734413147,
0.15923064947128296,
-0.06273750215768814,
0.15666711330413818,
0.09115458279848099,
-0.9772219061851501,
0.3677944839000702,
-0.14942510426044464,
-0.2902849018573761,
-0.2948029041290283,
0.43929097056388855,
-0.18587662279605865,
-0.2565365731716156,
0.3791293203830719,
0.6652916669845581,
0.5878406763076782,
-0.203860804438591,
-0.8578263521194458,
-0.06269437074661255,
-0.14926990866661072,
-0.22801165282726288,
0.2856045663356781,
0.6720666289329529,
0.25904226303100586,
0.7379729151725769,
0.5359913110733032,
-0.07492070645093918,
-0.2876470685005188,
0.02119360864162445,
0.4271143674850464,
-0.5857855081558228,
-0.49419328570365906,
-0.7316574454307556,
0.46784263849258423,
-0.12030930817127228,
-0.29846078157424927,
0.6371263265609741,
0.09288831800222397,
0.6330856680870056,
0.37847790122032166,
0.755218505859375,
0.06974415481090546,
0.20474795997142792,
-0.2742842733860016,
0.559586226940155,
-0.6895834803581238,
-0.04018646478652954,
0.17581573128700256,
-0.5067493319511414,
-0.4047454595565796,
1.1758794784545898,
-0.42952200770378113,
0.10533616691827774,
0.5798693299293518,
0.7979068160057068,
0.07668104022741318,
0.05869170278310776,
0.5688263177871704,
0.2640629708766937,
0.3099653124809265,
0.848498523235321,
1.0737627744674683,
-0.07092693448066711,
0.49974188208580017,
-0.06305631995201111,
-0.6872028112411499,
0.14977411925792694,
-0.6986414790153503,
-1.027133584022522,
-0.48983338475227356,
-0.06672569364309311,
-0.49745145440101624,
0.09300316870212555,
0.5043679475784302,
1.0394291877746582,
-0.5577383637428284,
-0.24471142888069153,
-0.3943520188331604,
0.6303420066833496,
-0.3835969567298889,
-0.2551615834236145,
0.13217924535274506,
-0.41130608320236206,
-0.7119160294532776,
0.40532368421554565,
0.3319956958293915,
-0.0636751800775528,
-0.4669491648674011,
-0.30772894620895386,
0.010490644723176956,
0.2420874834060669,
0.4231717586517334,
0.38778477907180786,
-0.7077332139015198,
-0.29611533880233765,
0.1331648975610733,
0.14828893542289734,
0.0022234825883060694,
0.8413344025611877,
-0.5905607342720032,
0.40353286266326904,
0.449103444814682,
0.9887715578079224,
0.3235729932785034,
0.05900939181447029,
0.7516582012176514,
-0.3115411400794983,
0.22092874348163605,
0.3996158838272095,
0.23400989174842834,
0.22198477387428284,
-0.514297604560852,
0.3848949670791626,
0.0841560810804367,
-0.5829610228538513,
-0.8714187145233154,
0.5495328307151794,
-0.8830621242523193,
-0.5366401076316833,
0.9396562576293945,
-0.42413291335105896,
-0.4904964566230774,
-0.5485363006591797,
0.08142144232988358,
-0.006409639958292246,
-0.06875446438789368,
0.3560124635696411,
0.7505232095718384,
-0.17634549736976624,
-0.3114354908466339,
-0.753774881362915,
0.14218126237392426,
0.6023569107055664,
-0.8867761492729187,
0.08870971202850342,
0.26204919815063477,
0.44349610805511475,
0.018924530595541,
0.7279143333435059,
0.11421027779579163,
0.46741244196891785,
-0.23308776319026947,
-0.1686297506093979,
0.16982169449329376,
-0.3838106393814087,
-0.556652843952179,
0.3448156714439392,
0.6395066976547241,
-0.18554452061653137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10923v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10923v1
|
Investigating Video Reasoning Capability of Large Language Models with Tropes in Movies
| 2024-06-16T12:58:31 | 2024-06-16T12:58:31 |
Hung-Ting Su, Chun-Tong Chao, Ya-Ching Hsu, Xudong Lin, Yulei Niu, Hung-Yi Lee, Winston H. Hsu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated effectiveness not only in
language tasks but also in video reasoning. This paper introduces a novel
dataset, Tropes in Movies (TiM), designed as a testbed for exploring two
critical yet previously overlooked video reasoning skills: (1) Abstract
Perception: understanding and tokenizing abstract concepts in videos, and (2)
Long-range Compositional Reasoning: planning and integrating intermediate
reasoning steps for understanding long-range videos with numerous frames.
Utilizing tropes from movie storytelling, TiM evaluates the reasoning
capabilities of state-of-the-art LLM-based approaches. Our experiments show
that current methods, including Captioner-Reasoner, Large Multimodal Model
Instruction Fine-tuning, and Visual Programming, only marginally outperform a
random baseline when tackling the challenges of Abstract Perception and
Long-range Compositional Reasoning. To address these deficiencies, we propose
Face-Enhanced Viper of Role Interactions (FEVoRI) and Context Query Reduction
(ConQueR), which enhance Visual Programming by fostering role interaction
awareness and progressively refining movie contexts and trope queries during
reasoning processes, significantly improving performance by 15 F1 points.
However, this performance still lags behind human levels (40 vs. 65 F1).
Additionally, we introduce a new protocol to evaluate the necessity of Abstract
Perception and Long-range Compositional Reasoning for task resolution. This is
done by analyzing the code generated through Visual Programming using an
Abstract Syntax Tree (AST), thereby confirming the increased complexity of TiM.
The dataset and code are available at: https://ander1119.github.io/TiM
|
[
-0.45850661396980286,
-0.7081472873687744,
0.6139364242553711,
0.0017524686409160495,
-0.271022766828537,
0.3782038986682892,
-0.2177714705467224,
-0.3868347406387329,
-0.024340707808732986,
0.6287599802017212,
-0.7466366291046143,
-0.4865560233592987,
-0.5532130599021912,
-0.10353246331214905,
-0.4325641393661499,
0.6932501196861267,
-0.1497216373682022,
-0.2112303227186203,
-0.02279524877667427,
-0.4187074899673462,
-0.4657098650932312,
-0.3876034915447235,
-0.5212333798408508,
-0.10010366141796112,
0.4446755647659302,
0.31722354888916016,
0.8796226978302002,
0.7930043935775757,
0.5974881649017334,
0.2959446609020233,
0.05998406559228897,
0.4952862858772278,
-0.21538667380809784,
0.1780533641576767,
-0.5442140102386475,
-0.3071786165237427,
-0.11330986022949219,
-0.37973305583000183,
0.7331516742706299,
0.4369814693927765,
0.14432038366794586,
0.2603883445262909,
-0.23093484342098236,
0.4463595449924469,
-0.7908035516738892,
0.06679392606019974,
-0.402132511138916,
0.38304850459098816,
-0.1758452206850052,
-0.054035160690546036,
-0.27895355224609375,
0.12543721497058868,
0.32553723454475403,
-0.4287952184677124,
0.24655009806156158,
-0.02007135935127735,
0.5967330932617188,
0.4110204577445984,
-0.33628416061401367,
0.001328540500253439,
-1.0238983631134033,
0.7842027544975281,
-0.4134507477283478,
0.5780543684959412,
0.1560194045305252,
0.38054144382476807,
0.1396227777004242,
-0.7595190405845642,
-0.7369384765625,
-0.37560272216796875,
0.23381099104881287,
-0.2727421522140503,
-0.39567816257476807,
0.3142714202404022,
0.6932678818702698,
0.27959978580474854,
-0.7720193266868591,
0.12579959630966187,
-0.30561181902885437,
-0.2655171751976013,
0.3299562633037567,
0.07560579478740692,
0.3545950651168823,
-0.4239586591720581,
-0.27413374185562134,
-0.3981091380119324,
-0.2724035084247589,
0.19650492072105408,
-0.10052444785833359,
-0.16384337842464447,
-0.22805477678775787,
0.7549289464950562,
0.11668074131011963,
0.7255285382270813,
-0.29376929998397827,
-0.30419591069221497,
0.0029691187664866447,
-0.08802837133407593,
-0.49030229449272156,
-0.17702889442443848,
0.5501400232315063,
0.593213677406311,
0.5265922546386719,
0.040910981595516205,
-0.031798817217350006,
0.3700374364852905,
0.26160404086112976,
-0.451126366853714,
-0.007368561811745167,
0.048091184347867966,
-0.1385667473077774,
-0.02085428684949875,
-0.1437445878982544,
-0.7496750354766846,
-0.6006335616111755,
-0.29807960987091064,
0.6512858271598816,
-0.714367687702179,
-0.11011440306901932,
-0.04699521139264107,
-0.4062965512275696,
0.30467748641967773,
0.43871310353279114,
-0.678739070892334,
0.05753183364868164,
0.614463746547699,
0.9555445313453674,
-0.23960810899734497,
-0.4769008755683899,
-0.6823720335960388,
0.44637173414230347,
-0.47537603974342346,
0.5880635380744934,
-0.5984154343605042,
-0.026521718129515648,
0.011758950538933277,
-0.35177719593048096,
-0.08726691454648972,
-0.5283680558204651,
0.3940141499042511,
-0.2152949422597885,
-0.10066229850053787,
-0.06692953407764435,
-0.1113545149564743,
-0.16509157419204712,
0.5183789730072021,
-0.9168281555175781,
0.8893682360649109,
0.0313580259680748,
-0.5653749704360962,
0.3201809227466583,
-0.7084590792655945,
-0.37055110931396484,
-0.28229209780693054,
-0.5303856134414673,
-0.0017460462404415011,
0.131846621632576,
0.41747885942459106,
0.3006936311721802,
-0.24894215166568756,
0.40738219022750854,
-0.15134559571743011,
-0.5326780676841736,
0.3729479908943176,
-0.3115571141242981,
0.2044578492641449,
0.17805521190166473,
-0.5702281594276428,
0.2141844630241394,
-0.48614832758903503,
-0.08236148208379745,
-0.20536094903945923,
0.2769758999347687,
-0.05055368319153786,
0.015807902440428734,
-0.1625632494688034,
0.2574910819530487,
-0.18251818418502808,
0.031200295314192772,
-0.05650005489587784,
-0.3223249614238739,
0.720292329788208,
0.7309153079986572,
-0.08953876048326492,
0.3592337965965271,
-0.17373226583003998,
0.5944236516952515,
0.0400107242166996,
0.02154913730919361,
-0.06774081289768219,
-0.12037850171327591,
-0.8686190247535706,
-0.368020236492157,
-0.3565298318862915,
0.37000492215156555,
-1.1239128112792969,
-0.04235917702317238,
-0.3263113796710968,
-0.3196675777435303,
0.02992831915616989,
0.11925066262483597,
0.48986032605171204,
0.33330318331718445,
0.29684877395629883,
-0.37262991070747375,
-0.6605537533760071,
-0.9680406451225281,
-0.26186394691467285,
-0.3510986864566803,
-0.06663008779287338,
0.20876628160476685,
0.6003351807594299,
-0.07341094315052032,
0.7608649730682373,
-0.42010679841041565,
-0.2926744520664215,
-0.7029001116752625,
0.2616294324398041,
0.026751291006803513,
0.270245760679245,
0.4113275408744812,
-0.6918150186538696,
0.08605881035327911,
-0.16836081445217133,
-0.9835935235023499,
0.2405337691307068,
-0.19190458953380585,
-0.0029857917688786983,
0.12336284667253494,
0.6014341711997986,
-0.8488752841949463,
0.39684581756591797,
0.4132031202316284,
-0.22674494981765747,
0.6203221678733826,
-0.07476997375488281,
0.3509785830974579,
-0.6297407746315002,
-0.04560971260070801,
0.3575500249862671,
-0.08137283474206924,
-0.5176626443862915,
0.3185471296310425,
-0.5380645990371704,
-0.3044224679470062,
-0.40098854899406433,
0.520582377910614,
-0.13212275505065918,
-0.4411344826221466,
-0.01969003677368164,
0.18201470375061035,
0.15249687433242798,
0.649843156337738,
0.42211419343948364,
0.9375494122505188,
0.6081337332725525,
-0.48419076204299927,
0.4947860836982727,
0.028326543048024178,
-0.5561157464981079,
0.5739457011222839,
-0.5295444130897522,
0.048017192631959915,
-0.3451114892959595,
0.1642230600118637,
-0.9167419672012329,
-0.42037898302078247,
0.01791008561849594,
-0.33075276017189026,
-0.04894956573843956,
-0.22450989484786987,
-0.6570902466773987,
-0.3092817962169647,
-0.13717685639858246,
0.5114559531211853,
0.4142199456691742,
-0.30278560519218445,
0.9709554314613342,
0.14017507433891296,
0.20471616089344025,
-0.8144794702529907,
-0.6333860158920288,
0.26917755603790283,
-0.6679595708847046,
-0.6902458667755127,
0.2598569095134735,
0.08752016723155975,
-0.4979128837585449,
-0.4106101989746094,
-0.4590306282043457,
-0.26786887645721436,
-0.4258282780647278,
0.10209925472736359,
0.12073180824518204,
-0.09128578007221222,
0.06824890524148941,
-0.08991502970457077,
0.27229729294776917,
0.18772883713245392,
-0.27734851837158203,
0.400580495595932,
-0.2037503719329834,
-0.21186499297618866,
-0.1552392542362213,
0.1893005222082138,
0.929746687412262,
-0.5139967203140259,
0.19209924340248108,
0.8103757500648499,
-0.39693546295166016,
-0.3274378180503845,
-0.6441229581832886,
-0.09823153167963028,
-0.44201424717903137,
0.7645948529243469,
-0.43750154972076416,
-0.9060268402099609,
0.5674933791160583,
-0.009019920602440834,
-0.16009889543056488,
0.04863471910357475,
0.30164414644241333,
-0.21543408930301666,
0.8645026683807373,
0.4807273745536804,
0.2058437466621399,
0.5923265814781189,
-0.7153803110122681,
0.09175293892621994,
-0.5388087630271912,
-0.30357906222343445,
-0.12582868337631226,
-0.3750104606151581,
-0.48603495955467224,
-0.9823939800262451,
0.7772483229637146,
-0.16712433099746704,
-0.5881982445716858,
0.2511967420578003,
-0.1709926277399063,
0.5507547855377197,
0.4564896523952484,
0.31864795088768005,
0.36754655838012695,
0.212296724319458,
-0.10782382637262344,
-0.28784409165382385,
-0.2942642867565155,
-0.410696417093277,
0.6586741805076599,
0.4652322828769684,
0.6027840971946716,
0.3147459328174591,
0.18743707239627838,
0.6379619836807251,
-0.2707599401473999,
-0.7147026658058167,
0.9398372173309326,
-0.33057624101638794,
-0.6309565305709839,
-0.2887861728668213,
-0.13697543740272522,
-0.2743571996688843,
0.11413257569074631,
-0.1317303329706192,
-1.0620074272155762,
0.09560234099626541,
0.16533012688159943,
-0.26473626494407654,
0.45097246766090393,
-0.5219878554344177,
1.1008814573287964,
-0.24863646924495697,
-0.8369160294532776,
-0.5272605419158936,
-0.8068851232528687,
0.3880499005317688,
0.239119753241539,
0.17620661854743958,
0.174368217587471,
0.18214844167232513,
0.6739776134490967,
-0.18343764543533325,
0.7627878785133362,
-0.010835150256752968,
0.07154656946659088,
0.5695659518241882,
0.4607829749584198,
0.4132569134235382,
0.06111868843436241,
0.06395482271909714,
-0.10917343944311142,
-0.06885024905204773,
-0.09696748107671738,
-0.959072470664978,
0.5182361006736755,
-0.6189594864845276,
-0.5846491456031799,
-0.5606454014778137,
-0.7661987543106079,
-0.4008301794528961,
-0.033972710371017456,
-0.009028453379869461,
0.4709588885307312,
-0.02333882264792919,
0.09562523663043976,
0.9257559180259705,
-0.20081041753292084,
0.41787585616111755,
-0.02406112663447857,
-0.14501629769802094,
-0.5281110405921936,
0.7105458974838257,
-0.14226175844669342,
0.39329949021339417,
0.5557302832603455,
-0.09117376059293747,
-0.334892213344574,
-0.419120192527771,
-0.6826545000076294,
0.13734175264835358,
-0.8915348649024963,
0.04435257986187935,
-0.30725574493408203,
-0.2279251664876938,
0.10498371720314026,
-0.13065192103385925,
-0.2529701292514801,
-0.20304903388023376,
0.15514540672302246,
-0.35123857855796814,
0.29895204305648804,
0.39123380184173584,
0.06156349554657936,
0.3701743185520172,
-0.562131941318512,
0.47132205963134766,
0.34658557176589966,
0.30285120010375977,
0.02831440046429634,
-0.5005214810371399,
-0.2958037853240967,
-0.15707054734230042,
-0.33219096064567566,
-0.7497289776802063,
0.19650012254714966,
0.19248972833156586,
0.31119903922080994,
0.3820081055164337,
-0.2510145306587219,
1.0471175909042358,
-0.2960762679576874,
0.7670367956161499,
0.07222442328929901,
-1.1681382656097412,
0.5708333849906921,
-0.4814538061618805,
0.16291777789592743,
0.37760934233665466,
0.1916889101266861,
-0.4242897927761078,
-0.30458661913871765,
-0.49741828441619873,
-0.4859972298145294,
0.5353290438652039,
0.4403046667575836,
0.0791134312748909,
0.24343234300613403,
0.15256905555725098,
-0.1351199746131897,
0.2749403119087219,
-0.6844683289527893,
0.042457740753889084,
-0.1932685375213623,
0.07581687718629837,
-0.27484479546546936,
0.10232880711555481,
-0.11370766907930374,
-0.4719489812850952,
0.03609807416796684,
-0.16354836523532867,
0.12206456065177917,
0.2738962173461914,
-0.20203477144241333,
-0.1225731372833252,
0.26506125926971436,
0.6155170798301697,
0.9232956171035767,
-0.3432765305042267,
0.3818562626838684,
0.13015605509281158,
-0.37893009185791016,
0.20611748099327087,
-0.05074366554617882,
0.24879960715770721,
0.09134865552186966,
0.605434238910675,
0.9407742023468018,
0.15843220055103302,
-1.2492682933807373,
0.3166220486164093,
0.29790571331977844,
-0.019151320680975914,
-0.5360686779022217,
0.16611804068088531,
-0.22629274427890778,
0.5196517109870911,
0.35745418071746826,
0.12386331707239151,
0.14767436683177948,
-0.9201195240020752,
0.24713993072509766,
0.33365345001220703,
-0.11018598824739456,
-0.23304620385169983,
0.5255417227745056,
-0.12656491994857788,
-0.1735459417104721,
0.5524722933769226,
-0.06188174709677696,
-0.4022770822048187,
0.6067611575126648,
0.25320589542388916,
0.587174654006958,
0.1077997162938118,
0.4467376470565796,
0.2857847213745117,
0.3927077054977417,
-0.1714436411857605,
0.03272061049938202,
-0.14757509529590607,
-0.688973069190979,
-0.8201813101768494,
-0.35531771183013916,
-0.48372113704681396,
0.3811728358268738,
-0.2759261429309845,
0.43288663029670715,
-0.6139455437660217,
-0.1058143675327301,
0.07449141144752502,
-0.25244179368019104,
-0.5144780874252319,
0.41592833399772644,
0.3246675431728363,
0.7257624864578247,
-0.8623965978622437,
0.6156589388847351,
0.8311580419540405,
-0.5236556529998779,
-0.6967827081680298,
0.053853534162044525,
-0.0834626853466034,
-0.6847168803215027,
0.7951656579971313,
0.21907305717468262,
-0.3093407452106476,
-0.1822604238986969,
-0.47172725200653076,
-0.6790094971656799,
0.9573971033096313,
0.6337327361106873,
-0.2825472950935364,
-0.6218560934066772,
0.48238277435302734,
0.7789552807807922,
-0.3450716733932495,
0.32489389181137085,
0.8145630359649658,
0.26373064517974854,
0.6130527853965759,
-1.0686187744140625,
-0.1595209240913391,
-0.023159779608249664,
0.01787739247083664,
0.08843149989843369,
-0.32952868938446045,
0.4641611874103546,
-0.463314026594162,
0.18673090636730194,
-0.10378579795360565,
0.6910077929496765,
0.7308464050292969,
0.6443007588386536,
0.576317548751831,
0.6203026175498962,
0.2998877763748169,
0.10114943981170654,
0.6313472390174866,
0.21515454351902008,
-0.06936123222112656,
0.9727834463119507,
-0.25598981976509094,
0.6349433660507202,
0.7601344585418701,
-0.08835721760988235,
0.8579192757606506,
0.37734460830688477,
0.022551409900188446,
0.3868139386177063,
0.24158531427383423,
-0.40445777773857117,
-0.6252632141113281,
-0.28596562147140503,
0.11107943207025528,
0.8439509868621826,
0.47831687331199646,
-0.5150173306465149,
-0.2565711736679077,
0.32379958033561707,
-0.11176714301109314,
0.33279478549957275,
-0.42669934034347534,
0.5081532597541809,
0.13613289594650269,
-0.8281311392784119,
0.48036450147628784,
-0.13159793615341187,
0.27044859528541565,
-0.5012856125831604,
-0.3083623945713043,
-0.1098296195268631,
0.22023779153823853,
-0.03668638691306114,
-0.9641069173812866,
0.33546799421310425,
0.3676741421222687,
-0.12379710376262665,
-0.0012905462644994259,
0.43645432591438293,
-0.14774763584136963,
-0.3792729377746582,
0.09204825758934021,
0.44426554441452026,
0.1951768845319748,
-0.09643778949975967,
-0.5049629807472229,
0.4280014932155609,
-0.03210072219371796,
0.14721979200839996,
0.15260854363441467,
0.4645852744579315,
-0.5695167183876038,
0.9744943976402283,
0.16025613248348236,
-0.02777712233364582,
-0.23070019483566284,
0.18137192726135254,
0.7638406753540039,
-0.6852037310600281,
-0.35838600993156433,
-0.9129059314727783,
0.6208838820457458,
-0.029362540692090988,
-0.1256316900253296,
0.3544788062572479,
0.5725274085998535,
0.8544904589653015,
-0.3393790125846863,
0.6630095839500427,
-0.22109030187129974,
0.04898129403591156,
-0.6832339763641357,
0.0761948972940445,
-0.4889577627182007,
0.35004758834838867,
-0.4554332494735718,
-0.9006894826889038,
-0.33711209893226624,
0.6505400538444519,
-0.44580981135368347,
0.16126631200313568,
0.7973869442939758,
0.750465989112854,
-0.28604257106781006,
-0.24173344671726227,
0.25692522525787354,
0.061930809170007706,
0.44526347517967224,
0.7687097191810608,
0.9553372859954834,
-0.17492645978927612,
0.7698039412498474,
-0.30083000659942627,
-0.01032213494181633,
0.055445194244384766,
-0.9103701114654541,
-1.1562080383300781,
-0.5527942776679993,
-0.3381500542163849,
-0.4245607256889343,
0.4253755807876587,
0.971204936504364,
0.6160698533058167,
-0.3435233533382416,
-0.49391716718673706,
-0.15921425819396973,
0.24285314977169037,
-0.4262249171733856,
-0.22364330291748047,
0.2557430565357208,
0.21583670377731323,
-0.7633602023124695,
0.3101615905761719,
0.23814964294433594,
-0.15743061900138855,
-0.3976343274116516,
-0.056914571672677994,
0.02579537220299244,
0.012075293809175491,
0.7397617101669312,
0.2552177608013153,
-0.8617307543754578,
-0.5126140117645264,
0.16439379751682281,
0.28589218854904175,
0.09613242745399475,
0.9426974654197693,
-0.7645614743232727,
0.5246863961219788,
0.5130148530006409,
0.14682985842227936,
0.764071524143219,
0.16478246450424194,
0.6938484907150269,
-0.9195120334625244,
0.25587213039398193,
0.29848915338516235,
0.2998431921005249,
0.26379916071891785,
-0.03691999614238739,
0.49340516328811646,
0.25904834270477295,
-0.16593211889266968,
-1.0228939056396484,
0.4654465913772583,
-1.3406141996383667,
-0.017847085371613503,
1.0232882499694824,
0.05167248100042343,
-0.09934284538030624,
0.1589241474866867,
-0.27692291140556335,
0.1993805319070816,
-0.2634568512439728,
0.5497601628303528,
0.7032275795936584,
-0.417120099067688,
-0.7672609686851501,
-0.6245818734169006,
0.5852776169776917,
0.2479225993156433,
-0.5852493643760681,
0.07064473628997803,
0.6526748538017273,
0.2270795851945877,
0.24496212601661682,
0.30077847838401794,
-0.049600180238485336,
0.4721919000148773,
-0.2789379954338074,
-0.14046525955200195,
-0.1723005622625351,
-0.6286298632621765,
-0.10425636917352676,
0.08767030388116837,
0.17116481065750122,
-0.006125639658421278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10922v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10922v1
|
Generating Tables from the Parametric Knowledge of Language Models
| 2024-06-16T12:55:55 | 2024-06-16T12:55:55 |
Yevgeni Berkovitch, Oren Glickman, Amit Somech, Tomer Wolfson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB
|
We explore generating factual and accurate tables from the parametric
knowledge of large language models (LLMs). While LLMs have demonstrated
impressive capabilities in recreating knowledge bases and generating free-form
text, we focus on generating structured tabular data, which is crucial in
domains like finance and healthcare. We examine the table generation abilities
of four state-of-the-art LLMs: GPT-3.5, GPT-4, Llama2-13B, and Llama2-70B,
using three prompting methods for table generation: (a) full-table, (b)
row-by-row; (c) cell-by-cell. For evaluation, we introduce a novel benchmark,
WikiTabGen which contains 100 curated Wikipedia tables. Tables are further
processed to ensure their factual correctness and manually annotated with short
natural language descriptions. Our findings reveal that table generation
remains a challenge, with GPT-4 reaching the highest accuracy at 19.6%. Our
detailed analysis sheds light on how various table properties, such as size,
table popularity, and numerical content, influence generation performance. This
work highlights the unique challenges in LLM-based table generation and
provides a solid evaluation framework for future research. Our code, prompts
and data are all publicly available:
https://github.com/analysis-bots/WikiTabGen
|
[
-0.11272954940795898,
-0.7836503386497498,
0.8468481302261353,
-0.015311682596802711,
-0.028385937213897705,
-0.11967892944812775,
-0.11889255791902542,
-0.19512145221233368,
-0.08419620245695114,
0.7463202476501465,
-0.27700793743133545,
-0.7552462816238403,
-0.15183575451374054,
0.09144007414579391,
-0.7171393036842346,
1.4529995918273926,
-0.00465593533590436,
-0.006784847006201744,
-0.4547848701477051,
0.08620082587003708,
-0.10320684313774109,
-0.24233125150203705,
-0.1722240298986435,
-0.32595276832580566,
0.6862958669662476,
0.6675945520401001,
0.7849233746528625,
0.8238053321838379,
0.4174506962299347,
0.20234785974025726,
0.4186113476753235,
0.18065392971038818,
-0.5926591157913208,
0.2239159643650055,
0.13410624861717224,
-0.2637965679168701,
-0.6564701795578003,
-0.22833654284477234,
0.7051582336425781,
0.544172465801239,
-0.4136240780353546,
0.4437161087989807,
0.16934417188167572,
0.9537478685379028,
-0.2444937825202942,
0.6512143015861511,
-1.0878881216049194,
0.04154952988028526,
-0.737657368183136,
-0.07198410481214523,
-0.3771311342716217,
-0.6696062684059143,
-0.0014919930836185813,
-0.43070557713508606,
0.4455629289150238,
0.23811286687850952,
0.8369100689888,
0.019504239782691002,
-0.4615582823753357,
-0.496818482875824,
-0.7017281651496887,
0.1412232220172882,
-0.8530018329620361,
0.6231210827827454,
0.2438538819551468,
0.4537120461463928,
-0.627608060836792,
-1.180127501487732,
-0.7264184951782227,
-0.7869145274162292,
0.012956403195858002,
-0.10108903050422668,
-0.023011624813079834,
-0.11935307085514069,
0.4691837430000305,
0.24269236624240875,
-0.7474625110626221,
-0.030444907024502754,
-0.4872605502605438,
-0.05378018319606781,
0.4857904314994812,
0.3806740343570709,
0.2884535789489746,
-0.30813169479370117,
-0.03828990086913109,
-0.002851023804396391,
-1.1765034198760986,
-0.35121411085128784,
0.389692485332489,
0.11643773317337036,
-0.11247269064188004,
0.9046754837036133,
-0.45540276169776917,
0.7416178584098816,
-0.28325244784355164,
-0.41644760966300964,
0.06571595370769501,
-0.48750555515289307,
0.024388495832681656,
0.034509092569351196,
0.9397695660591125,
0.3320245146751404,
0.3554438650608063,
-0.41827183961868286,
-0.2268577665090561,
-0.10559385269880295,
0.2974793612957001,
-0.47140195965766907,
-0.525287926197052,
-0.059884533286094666,
0.03091309778392315,
-0.37460991740226746,
0.05405065044760704,
-0.8157119154930115,
-0.34473076462745667,
-0.2944454550743103,
0.3818058967590332,
-0.25971195101737976,
0.13850700855255127,
-0.34141412377357483,
-0.021403219550848007,
0.3613196015357971,
0.10555651038885117,
-0.8836137652397156,
0.37200453877449036,
0.43524739146232605,
0.7019577026367188,
-0.2679313123226166,
-0.10782687366008759,
-0.3719486892223358,
0.8972678184509277,
-0.5500208139419556,
0.8540436625480652,
0.08931633830070496,
-0.3321334421634674,
0.06466525048017502,
-0.5906909108161926,
0.3747122287750244,
-0.5125175714492798,
0.29739654064178467,
-0.19310960173606873,
0.04947090893983841,
-0.6946684122085571,
-0.4849635362625122,
0.3404231369495392,
0.3001118302345276,
-1.007153868675232,
1.0654293298721313,
0.11710205674171448,
-0.7627040147781372,
0.8334896564483643,
-0.558440625667572,
-0.5099515318870544,
0.3079162836074829,
-0.5674850940704346,
-0.6187995076179504,
0.08504588156938553,
0.1736508309841156,
0.4580538868904114,
-0.6584314703941345,
0.6651590466499329,
-0.1503257006406784,
0.08535792678594589,
0.40478864312171936,
-0.3444870412349701,
0.08361577242612839,
0.1655893325805664,
-0.3809056282043457,
0.10640048235654831,
-1.1489500999450684,
-0.039284270256757736,
0.24640768766403198,
-0.6124753952026367,
0.38143694400787354,
0.3778618574142456,
0.05941054970026016,
0.14288543164730072,
0.1469457745552063,
-0.2792762517929077,
-0.020144039765000343,
-0.18115170300006866,
0.5698162913322449,
0.43463271856307983,
0.17228467762470245,
0.15787257254123688,
-0.42662256956100464,
0.18057604134082794,
-0.17289790511131287,
-0.20301596820354462,
0.2386326640844345,
-0.451201468706131,
-0.6487882733345032,
0.08473915606737137,
0.3394507169723511,
0.2990139424800873,
-0.8876790404319763,
0.10697460174560547,
-0.41542330384254456,
-0.8155415654182434,
0.05845386162400246,
0.265545129776001,
0.30242452025413513,
1.020664930343628,
0.2705983817577362,
0.11564096063375473,
-0.3592241108417511,
-1.1853150129318237,
-0.20458336174488068,
-0.3049026131629944,
-0.11199899017810822,
0.13205589354038239,
0.39931541681289673,
0.012981395237147808,
0.9534659385681152,
-0.569401204586029,
0.11104796081781387,
-0.47845903038978577,
0.06184444949030876,
0.033525511622428894,
0.2977460026741028,
0.3719440996646881,
-0.38723498582839966,
-0.5667632222175598,
0.15547634661197662,
-0.6760395765304565,
-0.26752597093582153,
-0.07230478525161743,
-0.25972211360931396,
0.40821078419685364,
0.21662862598896027,
-0.8979477882385254,
0.18972325325012207,
0.2115524858236313,
0.10287178307771683,
0.6056861281394958,
-0.23497971892356873,
-0.07976499944925308,
-1.1586387157440186,
0.27074551582336426,
0.04515411704778671,
-0.11977501958608627,
-0.7671046257019043,
-0.19861994683742523,
0.20187053084373474,
-0.34553584456443787,
-0.24447022378444672,
0.4747426509857178,
-0.5115928649902344,
-0.3073315918445587,
0.153144970536232,
0.24798166751861572,
-0.11910060793161392,
0.21947947144508362,
-0.21653391420841217,
0.6999609470367432,
0.02374676614999771,
-0.49258893728256226,
0.2933582067489624,
0.3561555743217468,
-0.6689516305923462,
0.2739240825176239,
-0.5516956448554993,
-0.03958135098218918,
0.09643169492483139,
0.33417484164237976,
-1.0644761323928833,
-0.6991592049598694,
0.3138578236103058,
-0.06616641581058502,
0.413334459066391,
0.38745397329330444,
-0.5172125101089478,
-0.5197979211807251,
-0.2038813829421997,
-0.11996975541114807,
0.4932461977005005,
-0.22043852508068085,
0.2585754096508026,
0.5565439462661743,
-0.4918365478515625,
-0.5152277946472168,
-0.5192578434944153,
0.3362847864627838,
-0.13072757422924042,
-0.6318430304527283,
0.4636530578136444,
0.25034356117248535,
-0.43815377354621887,
-0.09295077621936798,
-0.4373094141483307,
0.22999665141105652,
-0.23529429733753204,
0.15079937875270844,
0.16314361989498138,
-0.032085247337818146,
0.016180044040083885,
0.09009208530187607,
0.07744605094194412,
0.2596908509731293,
-0.2130354791879654,
0.5658983588218689,
-0.06283114105463028,
-0.21677780151367188,
-0.21684706211090088,
-0.027144204825162888,
0.43245241045951843,
-0.08214299380779266,
0.5188848972320557,
0.4023232161998749,
-0.36099889874458313,
-0.351162850856781,
-0.8564552664756775,
0.11007948964834213,
-0.46498170495033264,
0.4469781517982483,
-0.28825414180755615,
-0.43374353647232056,
0.7064041495323181,
0.4157864451408386,
0.44773784279823303,
0.6488832235336304,
0.9286701679229736,
0.04588250815868378,
0.7027633786201477,
0.30060824751853943,
0.20875073969364166,
0.08313031494617462,
0.10480240732431412,
0.11279817670583725,
-0.1773480474948883,
-0.6087357997894287,
-0.848275899887085,
-0.1459842473268509,
-0.7916544079780579,
-0.32987481355667114,
0.5262895822525024,
-0.36165207624435425,
-0.18611612915992737,
0.17138449847698212,
-0.06821049004793167,
0.3598889708518982,
0.6435689330101013,
0.18685239553451538,
0.2535083293914795,
0.22604474425315857,
-0.0936991423368454,
0.10233720391988754,
-0.6319300532341003,
-0.7398070096969604,
1.3480654954910278,
0.13850441575050354,
0.8759576082229614,
-0.1479490101337433,
0.8354204297065735,
0.23862293362617493,
0.558120608329773,
-0.27402007579803467,
0.6206034421920776,
0.04850010573863983,
-0.5654433369636536,
-0.43220341205596924,
-0.8805945515632629,
-0.5713069438934326,
-0.2630205750465393,
-0.24114204943180084,
-0.40498900413513184,
-0.38751494884490967,
0.4270215928554535,
-0.15480409562587738,
0.11053415387868881,
-0.5755759477615356,
0.8278629779815674,
-0.3116527795791626,
-0.5272846817970276,
0.18218153715133667,
-0.5439857840538025,
0.5818973779678345,
-0.3998584449291229,
0.017752787098288536,
-0.2570279538631439,
-0.0217119250446558,
0.8205677270889282,
-0.603468120098114,
0.4769662320613861,
-0.19233514368534088,
-0.3306121528148651,
0.456103652715683,
0.21214164793491364,
0.5479597449302673,
0.28520047664642334,
-0.21414685249328613,
0.0766066163778305,
0.0008621023735031486,
-0.2145695984363556,
-0.36130109429359436,
0.8243910670280457,
-0.5288282036781311,
-0.7537690997123718,
-0.13030610978603363,
-0.9226486682891846,
-0.6244223117828369,
0.1124904453754425,
0.25766244530677795,
0.4421060085296631,
-0.2936291992664337,
0.30981817841529846,
0.26897868514060974,
-0.3064511716365814,
0.25902992486953735,
0.33731284737586975,
-0.007283450569957495,
-0.545222818851471,
1.0302928686141968,
0.6356892585754395,
0.07339194416999817,
0.45354583859443665,
0.16600707173347473,
-0.4906007945537567,
-0.705835223197937,
-0.6641814708709717,
0.18410088121891022,
-0.4865041673183441,
-0.36810123920440674,
-0.40523561835289,
-0.22080586850643158,
-0.403987318277359,
-0.004180180374532938,
0.042499929666519165,
-0.6901915073394775,
0.010917344130575657,
-0.4875431954860687,
0.32357773184776306,
1.0597987174987793,
-0.0028410647064447403,
0.21241545677185059,
-0.7961900234222412,
0.31676799058914185,
0.3866317868232727,
0.18042339384555817,
-0.06286314129829407,
0.03778700530529022,
-0.09184475988149643,
-0.17916502058506012,
-0.4345247447490692,
-1.2454195022583008,
0.3637019097805023,
0.28420040011405945,
0.821604311466217,
0.2961093485355377,
-0.1635630875825882,
0.5288828611373901,
-0.9601885080337524,
0.7908326387405396,
0.12059327214956284,
-0.8281182646751404,
0.25827789306640625,
-0.6124899387359619,
0.1235254555940628,
0.5974704027175903,
0.2729393243789673,
-0.2795296013355255,
-0.605160117149353,
-0.5052658319473267,
-0.9465641379356384,
0.608051598072052,
0.2844427525997162,
0.08184012770652771,
-0.09918724000453949,
0.6911338567733765,
0.40413880348205566,
0.474937379360199,
-1.1753801107406616,
0.09065410494804382,
0.005588878877460957,
-0.5427244305610657,
0.08626178652048111,
-0.4488300085067749,
-0.08334021270275116,
0.014902975410223007,
0.6847721338272095,
0.07074949890375137,
-0.05333179235458374,
-0.21548283100128174,
-0.0900619700551033,
-0.1903245598077774,
0.23957964777946472,
0.7334245443344116,
1.231819748878479,
-0.12222892791032791,
0.08333665877580643,
0.2477617710828781,
-0.4244626760482788,
0.00014263791672419757,
0.12874674797058105,
-0.31536296010017395,
0.1237691193819046,
0.19942280650138855,
0.5914574861526489,
0.19009140133857727,
-0.5586931705474854,
0.0860457569360733,
0.10851976275444031,
-0.45494523644447327,
-0.11042647063732147,
0.17154189944267273,
0.39376717805862427,
-0.0585516095161438,
0.24647033214569092,
-0.7617285251617432,
0.06583604961633682,
-0.39595159888267517,
0.47396066784858704,
0.5619266629219055,
0.17924781143665314,
-0.22904404997825623,
0.8745235800743103,
0.12279980629682541,
-0.1901642233133316,
0.6554782390594482,
-0.02909191884100437,
0.03220466524362564,
0.44700801372528076,
0.7338232398033142,
0.44799739122390747,
-0.0023970827460289,
0.37451252341270447,
0.2670131027698517,
0.2232540249824524,
0.035642996430397034,
0.4273899793624878,
-0.23464487493038177,
-0.42693591117858887,
-0.23065446317195892,
-0.9630832672119141,
-0.5631431937217712,
0.422817587852478,
-0.4899703562259674,
0.2238662838935852,
-0.32501938939094543,
-0.1567908376455307,
0.14946523308753967,
-0.018662823364138603,
-0.6853077411651611,
-0.15208980441093445,
0.10663014650344849,
0.7741143703460693,
-0.684927225112915,
0.7778956890106201,
0.32584309577941895,
-0.3799212574958801,
-0.9389069080352783,
0.04526716470718384,
-0.16252174973487854,
-0.7689480781555176,
0.4592019021511078,
-0.022451497614383698,
0.34109655022621155,
-0.06244298443198204,
-0.46567463874816895,
-0.7872170805931091,
1.079167127609253,
0.5912236571311951,
-0.8551793098449707,
-0.5124486088752747,
0.8403397798538208,
0.44500505924224854,
0.04207158461213112,
-0.1640273630619049,
0.8427990674972534,
0.5488247275352478,
-0.06393284350633621,
-0.6429190039634705,
0.09712616354227066,
0.08796937018632889,
0.03645404055714607,
0.4198550581932068,
-0.14885801076889038,
0.6720964908599854,
-0.015361379832029343,
0.00651175482198596,
-0.05650249123573303,
0.7737087607383728,
0.5755859017372131,
0.24368107318878174,
0.07892018556594849,
0.6261187791824341,
0.6196527481079102,
-0.2712343633174896,
0.7785404920578003,
-0.5042370557785034,
-0.059705644845962524,
0.9492310285568237,
-0.7456335425376892,
0.6659542918205261,
0.534351646900177,
-0.2361961156129837,
0.38009166717529297,
0.457782119512558,
-0.1884118765592575,
0.28224435448646545,
0.4822913110256195,
-0.15822961926460266,
0.1904880404472351,
0.33348628878593445,
-0.4580609202384949,
0.37803009152412415,
0.49059566855430603,
-0.35776907205581665,
-0.5850762724876404,
-0.3399851322174072,
0.07318725436925888,
-0.13126659393310547,
-0.16534261405467987,
0.9037265777587891,
0.02744281105697155,
-0.554544985294342,
0.2296578288078308,
-0.0037145253736525774,
-0.17663496732711792,
-0.7605242133140564,
-0.12593266367912292,
-0.25422006845474243,
-0.25235024094581604,
-0.14642983675003052,
-0.6667274236679077,
0.08008784055709839,
0.3657669723033905,
0.025322163477540016,
-0.06972900778055191,
0.6397561430931091,
-0.47757065296173096,
-0.5384879112243652,
-0.3945513367652893,
0.8619350790977478,
0.13753779232501984,
0.27295970916748047,
-0.3044104278087616,
-0.15288983285427094,
0.11841854453086853,
-0.4940444529056549,
0.26986464858055115,
0.582748532295227,
-0.18758848309516907,
0.30992481112480164,
0.678155779838562,
0.1521579921245575,
0.17424656450748444,
-0.007137768901884556,
0.7355585098266602,
-0.5726838707923889,
-0.3222878873348236,
-0.9720862507820129,
0.4329397678375244,
-0.006614243611693382,
-0.37693580985069275,
0.7443639636039734,
0.7866253852844238,
0.6995682716369629,
-0.36451607942581177,
0.584919273853302,
-0.15856947004795074,
0.1979982852935791,
-0.6889894008636475,
1.0601270198822021,
-0.32954955101013184,
0.12425503134727478,
-0.3875965476036072,
-1.1967144012451172,
-0.3255001902580261,
0.24018196761608124,
-0.3918629586696625,
-0.12567618489265442,
0.4133490324020386,
0.8486123085021973,
0.21356810629367828,
-0.17381508648395538,
0.30828291177749634,
0.20507359504699707,
0.5360589027404785,
0.23363983631134033,
0.7268387675285339,
0.04082423076033592,
0.9347184896469116,
-0.24862709641456604,
0.04087620601058006,
0.09179766476154327,
-0.9193956255912781,
-0.47909054160118103,
-0.6932571530342102,
0.04381641745567322,
-0.3491246700286865,
0.060764722526073456,
0.5909253358840942,
0.29148510098457336,
-0.6849013566970825,
-0.5221290588378906,
-0.3997761011123657,
-0.13670702278614044,
0.35300132632255554,
-0.203102707862854,
0.5370946526527405,
-0.4479692578315735,
-0.36111482977867126,
0.2865208387374878,
0.29891857504844666,
-0.058022670447826385,
-0.2745932638645172,
-0.004807943478226662,
0.08445947617292404,
0.045474231243133545,
0.42079851031303406,
0.18954217433929443,
-0.5573241710662842,
-0.07893384248018265,
-0.26537787914276123,
-0.29805681109428406,
0.04973364993929863,
0.6847801208496094,
-0.5943780541419983,
-0.06150444224476814,
0.512946605682373,
0.5468565225601196,
0.6965303421020508,
0.00035813270369544625,
0.7484315037727356,
-0.7559590935707092,
-0.2164151817560196,
0.20907197892665863,
0.4731878638267517,
0.2766425907611847,
-0.22718685865402222,
0.43126872181892395,
0.013523681089282036,
-0.7253456115722656,
-1.067192792892456,
0.19640257954597473,
-0.7819417715072632,
0.04788973182439804,
1.0390846729278564,
0.2888749837875366,
-0.47514715790748596,
0.13296020030975342,
-0.13927413523197174,
0.48755475878715515,
-0.2915075719356537,
0.9240705370903015,
0.6325997710227966,
-0.3839339315891266,
0.1761806160211563,
-0.8306789398193359,
0.8789674639701843,
-0.0013402299955487251,
-1.1807348728179932,
0.24995653331279755,
0.9524560570716858,
0.43163996934890747,
0.03724446892738342,
0.563910961151123,
-0.35430964827537537,
0.23816122114658356,
0.15854117274284363,
0.17941805720329285,
-0.12336097657680511,
-0.5174640417098999,
0.26700279116630554,
0.47259435057640076,
0.2046450525522232,
0.3803867995738983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10918v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10918v3
|
Embodied Question Answering via Multi-LLM Systems
| 2024-06-16T12:46:40 | 2024-06-25T10:50:09 |
Bhrij Patel, Vishnu Sashank Dorbala, Dinesh Manocha, Amrit Singh Bedi
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Embodied Question Answering (EQA) is an important problem, which involves an
agent exploring the environment to answer user queries. In the existing
literature, EQA has exclusively been studied in single-agent scenarios, where
exploration can be time-consuming and costly. In this work, we consider EQA in
a multi-agent framework involving multiple large language models (LLM) based
agents independently answering queries about a household environment. To
generate one answer for each query, we use the individual responses to train a
Central Answer Model (CAM) that aggregates responses for a robust answer. Using
CAM, we observe a $50\%$ higher EQA accuracy when compared against aggregation
methods for ensemble LLM, such as voting schemes and debates. CAM does not
require any form of agent communication, alleviating it from the associated
costs. We ablate CAM with various nonlinear (neural network, random forest,
decision tree, XGBoost) and linear (logistic regression classifier, SVM)
algorithms. Finally, we present a feature importance analysis for CAM via
permutation feature importance (PFI), quantifying CAMs reliance on each
independent agent and query context.
|
[
-0.6084510684013367,
-0.9916174411773682,
0.6791086792945862,
0.09009095281362534,
-0.04868221655488014,
0.0660838782787323,
0.07520744949579239,
-0.5924692749977112,
0.15426811575889587,
0.4356766641139984,
-0.747549295425415,
-0.31677892804145813,
-0.3637043833732605,
0.01986502856016159,
-0.22896447777748108,
0.4157712459564209,
0.15912647545337677,
0.12178781628608704,
-0.44012513756752014,
-0.5858984589576721,
-0.30730336904525757,
-0.7501865029335022,
-0.465099036693573,
-0.13409946858882904,
0.7446922063827515,
0.17374718189239502,
0.6980094313621521,
0.15332013368606567,
-0.039805345237255096,
0.3745766878128052,
0.056095730513334274,
0.35146182775497437,
-0.30677539110183716,
0.3843216300010681,
-0.07790323346853256,
-0.39058181643486023,
-0.5787649750709534,
-0.3374774754047394,
0.38697025179862976,
0.39561671018600464,
-0.08157146722078323,
0.4604339003562927,
0.05845370143651962,
-0.03188750520348549,
-0.8017221689224243,
0.09711778163909912,
-0.5907495617866516,
-0.20391340553760529,
0.4092752933502197,
-0.05491287261247635,
-0.20741264522075653,
-0.10356277972459793,
0.034430962055921555,
-0.4564492702484131,
0.2375502586364746,
-0.005246130283921957,
0.7224093675613403,
0.4334961175918579,
-0.580976128578186,
-0.1691693812608719,
-0.4050741493701935,
0.673958420753479,
-0.526323139667511,
0.15985120832920074,
0.28186267614364624,
0.28741201758384705,
-0.04544007405638695,
-0.35618993639945984,
-0.680457592010498,
0.1951172649860382,
-0.17873534560203552,
0.2961706221103668,
0.14328517019748688,
0.36057066917419434,
-0.1603316068649292,
0.02608560025691986,
-0.4378482401371002,
0.10544711351394653,
0.07540258765220642,
-0.1956958919763565,
0.7447066307067871,
0.4206658601760864,
0.514552116394043,
-0.11172185093164444,
-0.38536351919174194,
-0.24564673006534576,
-0.49901193380355835,
0.3051966726779938,
0.04317115247249603,
0.2751912474632263,
0.11745860427618027,
0.7547906637191772,
-0.022086413577198982,
0.7049450278282166,
-0.10245652496814728,
-0.08551491051912308,
-0.28026291728019714,
-0.3707180619239807,
-0.1799110621213913,
-0.18246720731258392,
0.4414612054824829,
-0.0271760243922472,
-0.14861534535884857,
-0.14068174362182617,
-0.32195422053337097,
-0.3036932647228241,
0.32931891083717346,
-0.5982176661491394,
0.4182274043560028,
0.5802795886993408,
-0.1534455269575119,
0.01299708615988493,
-0.1317896544933319,
-0.6507245302200317,
-0.3273021876811981,
-0.2260986566543579,
0.8014117479324341,
0.1282491832971573,
-0.4744507372379303,
-0.009027829393744469,
-0.12493760883808136,
1.0941390991210938,
0.7355006337165833,
-0.7081267833709717,
0.5198726058006287,
0.6895382404327393,
0.5600747466087341,
0.21816806495189667,
-0.4229825735092163,
-0.37160173058509827,
0.0882263109087944,
-0.27795663475990295,
0.8413370251655579,
-0.2839963138103485,
-0.21314041316509247,
-0.06458543241024017,
0.13986048102378845,
-0.19397050142288208,
-0.20011942088603973,
0.18217135965824127,
-0.8063489198684692,
-0.13807645440101624,
-0.5664746165275574,
-0.38759496808052063,
-0.22150985896587372,
0.5038743615150452,
-0.8070001602172852,
1.0440596342086792,
0.0007662663701921701,
-0.7329795360565186,
0.19342203438282013,
-0.6103634834289551,
-0.19995111227035522,
-0.04064522683620453,
-0.18630090355873108,
-0.28607404232025146,
0.113460473716259,
0.6554440259933472,
0.558996856212616,
-0.41679373383522034,
0.18393272161483765,
-0.37664157152175903,
-0.5228058695793152,
0.5554597973823547,
-0.5602831840515137,
0.7168997526168823,
0.07222544401884079,
-0.34653791785240173,
-0.027885740622878075,
-0.4621632397174835,
0.28205811977386475,
-0.06464874744415283,
-0.3138335645198822,
-0.21989428997039795,
-0.04981943592429161,
0.09273701906204224,
0.1262955665588379,
0.2077866494655609,
-0.5766255855560303,
0.11228164285421371,
-0.1504017859697342,
0.15459588170051575,
0.7937259078025818,
0.07806362211704254,
0.3528013825416565,
-0.6984776258468628,
0.8056573271751404,
-0.24727261066436768,
-0.005820745602250099,
-0.14745157957077026,
-0.6267102956771851,
-0.6813576221466064,
-0.5571267008781433,
-0.17007112503051758,
0.3455526530742645,
-0.9206893444061279,
0.14540646970272064,
-0.20094023644924164,
-0.39571696519851685,
-0.6647066473960876,
-0.19666798412799835,
0.527211606502533,
-0.03231130912899971,
0.33684834837913513,
0.08058571815490723,
-0.11221183091402054,
-0.6201550960540771,
-0.10622305423021317,
-0.4600799083709717,
-0.16721269488334656,
0.766006588935852,
0.5164556503295898,
0.07524865120649338,
1.111097812652588,
-0.4862369894981384,
0.2656456232070923,
-0.22691760957241058,
0.14749088883399963,
-0.02195829525589943,
0.07552293688058853,
0.5245690941810608,
-0.9426745772361755,
-0.13253922760486603,
-0.09458315372467041,
-0.821014940738678,
-0.06081327050924301,
-0.10044581443071365,
-0.35523656010627747,
0.06017564609646797,
-0.07157725095748901,
-0.9217754006385803,
0.5958223938941956,
0.47555097937583923,
-0.25093597173690796,
0.4607233703136444,
-0.22079366445541382,
0.30335837602615356,
-1.1110963821411133,
-0.01412555854767561,
-0.3533625602722168,
-0.29133155941963196,
-0.5849122405052185,
0.48678138852119446,
-0.11645260453224182,
-0.11238881200551987,
-0.5537570118904114,
0.931281328201294,
-0.8449331521987915,
-0.5504280924797058,
-0.2780837416648865,
0.07686334103345871,
0.19803935289382935,
0.9415571093559265,
0.13242803514003754,
0.777184784412384,
0.48618173599243164,
-0.786231517791748,
0.38272833824157715,
0.39459866285324097,
-0.08460786193609238,
0.367005854845047,
-0.8735465407371521,
0.6501873135566711,
-0.3945937156677246,
0.2702583968639374,
-1.3206079006195068,
-0.3437114357948303,
0.00903385505080223,
-0.6504039168357849,
0.12543103098869324,
0.1065409705042839,
-0.5000916719436646,
-0.13545829057693481,
-0.24472452700138092,
0.47682327032089233,
0.11740075051784515,
-0.7621361613273621,
0.9652654528617859,
0.4908094108104706,
-0.06695286184549332,
-0.9843738079071045,
-0.6628482937812805,
-0.17073984444141388,
-0.09555727988481522,
-0.7609031796455383,
-0.11668117344379425,
0.049657732248306274,
-0.22526904940605164,
-0.016247835010290146,
-0.18839216232299805,
-0.3888099491596222,
0.3870551288127899,
0.1568945199251175,
0.14267019927501678,
-0.2606218755245209,
0.5600098371505737,
0.14665982127189636,
0.29136011004447937,
0.06583980470895767,
-0.10942445695400238,
0.4335748553276062,
-0.1841300129890442,
-0.6104447245597839,
0.010324161499738693,
0.856151282787323,
0.8625892400741577,
-0.2815410792827606,
1.0204119682312012,
0.26993855834007263,
-0.5188397765159607,
-0.21391558647155762,
-0.527734100818634,
-0.2265944480895996,
-0.38002240657806396,
0.5187402367591858,
-0.5813790559768677,
-0.9502329230308533,
0.7935683131217957,
0.35714900493621826,
0.427049845457077,
0.05375692993402481,
0.6244785189628601,
-0.13018660247325897,
0.8432201743125916,
0.3708204925060272,
0.20570215582847595,
0.10455146431922913,
-0.002391466638073325,
-0.081902414560318,
-0.8029766082763672,
-0.204723060131073,
-0.743782639503479,
-0.40544959902763367,
-0.49965736269950867,
-0.6711620092391968,
0.7413903474807739,
-0.15485914051532745,
-0.40407687425613403,
0.2486705183982849,
-0.41520956158638,
0.2364572286605835,
0.4956319034099579,
0.5526203513145447,
0.28422242403030396,
-0.21690034866333008,
-0.019550681114196777,
0.41053926944732666,
-0.8480390310287476,
-0.6073305010795593,
1.1177647113800049,
0.123753122985363,
1.059829592704773,
0.5541501045227051,
0.5185111165046692,
-0.03535207360982895,
0.45462313294410706,
-0.7638369202613831,
0.6335283517837524,
0.36135920882225037,
-0.974431574344635,
-0.9021317362785339,
-0.19385464489459991,
-1.150830864906311,
1.0467333793640137,
-0.2948577404022217,
-0.543556809425354,
0.29412615299224854,
-0.0862036645412445,
-0.5524607300758362,
0.26388660073280334,
-0.5015382766723633,
0.5013725161552429,
-0.43609654903411865,
-0.7394282221794128,
-0.1300169676542282,
-0.6906838417053223,
0.32042503356933594,
0.09299474954605103,
0.10404465347528458,
0.060859695076942444,
-0.37611228227615356,
0.38036325573921204,
-0.36928918957710266,
0.866837203502655,
-0.12997157871723175,
-0.05362240597605705,
0.599321722984314,
-0.2531805634498596,
0.33386436104774475,
0.20910538733005524,
-0.10944607853889465,
-0.1621263325214386,
0.23239818215370178,
-0.6991122364997864,
-0.7987344264984131,
0.47010552883148193,
-1.0625174045562744,
-0.8825334310531616,
-0.4968666732311249,
-0.277358740568161,
-0.28862813115119934,
-0.3394366204738617,
0.08767619729042053,
0.6914253830909729,
-0.3561568260192871,
0.17353218793869019,
0.7598402500152588,
-0.6090180277824402,
0.5832470059394836,
0.514598548412323,
-0.016747819259762764,
-0.3665286898612976,
0.25640633702278137,
0.12091115117073059,
0.31379634141921997,
0.6129030585289001,
0.15173932909965515,
-0.6731582283973694,
-0.0649627149105072,
-0.7083183526992798,
0.07857676595449448,
-0.7802761197090149,
-0.19265928864479065,
-1.1375832557678223,
-0.27170827984809875,
-0.5049818754196167,
-0.09957583248615265,
-0.17643322050571442,
-0.17511293292045593,
-0.07834881544113159,
-0.25894859433174133,
0.25747376680374146,
0.6586760878562927,
0.2557653784751892,
0.19096292555332184,
-0.939081609249115,
0.5373331308364868,
1.0090174674987793,
-0.003606693586334586,
0.3152219355106354,
-0.25188973546028137,
-0.13358190655708313,
0.3161475658416748,
-0.30770811438560486,
-1.1902490854263306,
0.2745330333709717,
0.2505725026130676,
0.9762073755264282,
-0.07206523418426514,
0.42031410336494446,
0.8238403797149658,
-0.05932183191180229,
0.9198674559593201,
-0.08415106683969498,
-0.6404274702072144,
0.22865815460681915,
-0.37443220615386963,
0.5817193984985352,
0.42737090587615967,
0.2742828130722046,
-0.4256432354450226,
-0.3533092439174652,
-0.40523576736450195,
-0.8933232426643372,
0.6802785992622375,
0.2208222597837448,
0.39298027753829956,
-0.00941146444529295,
0.32747095823287964,
-0.016174908727407455,
0.3527659475803375,
-0.7659273743629456,
-0.09695710241794586,
-0.12244442105293274,
0.005124883260577917,
0.09257422387599945,
-0.03147420287132263,
-0.0856471061706543,
-0.27267587184906006,
0.5459191203117371,
-0.47773537039756775,
0.6106501817703247,
0.5595614314079285,
-0.4135676324367523,
0.1363227218389511,
0.48878178000450134,
0.30349090695381165,
0.5113955140113831,
0.14233814179897308,
0.08800511807203293,
0.39328721165657043,
-0.15998844802379608,
0.5182314515113831,
-0.2991369664669037,
0.035383440554142,
-0.07076789438724518,
0.39212122559547424,
0.6255940198898315,
0.3413839340209961,
-0.5684952735900879,
0.6131189465522766,
-0.20994892716407776,
-0.04578358307480812,
-0.4220489263534546,
-0.06427846103906631,
0.341346800327301,
0.2460436075925827,
0.4072778522968292,
-0.19865822792053223,
0.20564351975917816,
-0.847510814666748,
0.09024278074502945,
0.521765947341919,
-0.19790832698345184,
-0.3438913822174072,
0.5220420956611633,
0.23476213216781616,
-0.20717944204807281,
0.6240214109420776,
0.19479301571846008,
-0.5722512602806091,
1.1267657279968262,
0.21201539039611816,
1.0598362684249878,
-0.29579776525497437,
0.3714251220226288,
0.4689350724220276,
0.3026009500026703,
0.040379226207733154,
0.3021354377269745,
-0.39191901683807373,
-0.9784043431282043,
-0.3629058599472046,
-0.7210946083068848,
-0.6481809020042419,
-0.17594878375530243,
-0.60929274559021,
0.14594802260398865,
-0.05646722391247749,
0.04271717742085457,
-0.265434592962265,
-0.14993929862976074,
-0.7561383843421936,
0.23998390138149261,
0.09643831849098206,
0.4396314024925232,
-0.6490975022315979,
0.5255101323127747,
0.9354345202445984,
-0.26344776153564453,
-0.9823476076126099,
0.04933299124240875,
-0.09954246878623962,
-0.7046613693237305,
0.20723162591457367,
0.2602705657482147,
-0.6520151495933533,
0.024644767865538597,
-0.7977774143218994,
-0.8488079905509949,
1.3420798778533936,
0.43572092056274414,
-0.10827997326850891,
-0.02841179631650448,
0.01459716446697712,
0.5901939868927002,
-0.44896402955055237,
0.8695771098136902,
0.23375827074050903,
0.45024365186691284,
0.37809380888938904,
-0.7698670625686646,
0.015431680716574192,
-0.19201265275478363,
-0.08567381650209427,
0.024928469210863113,
-0.9630179405212402,
0.7284453511238098,
-0.27505233883857727,
-0.3883378803730011,
0.4428470730781555,
0.4495658576488495,
0.46113988757133484,
0.4850645363330841,
0.5118568539619446,
0.24115677177906036,
0.7263767123222351,
0.0018671945435926318,
1.0474134683609009,
-0.058407559990882874,
0.346150666475296,
1.2181947231292725,
-0.33113911747932434,
0.8095375895500183,
0.25413212180137634,
-0.20445607602596283,
0.08119985461235046,
0.8773272633552551,
0.6816986799240112,
0.13408909738063812,
0.46208325028419495,
-0.6996103525161743,
-0.6367742419242859,
0.13484756648540497,
-0.16062462329864502,
0.7489408254623413,
0.26958051323890686,
0.13199147582054138,
-0.2751745283603668,
0.15940159559249878,
-0.19646310806274414,
0.06696753948926926,
-0.3028000593185425,
1.0257487297058105,
0.054496366530656815,
-1.0043617486953735,
0.4102892279624939,
-0.18429939448833466,
0.45214012265205383,
-0.5592858791351318,
-0.18439781665802002,
-0.4876740276813507,
-0.1669168919324875,
0.05185224115848541,
-0.4929613769054413,
0.11439074575901031,
-0.06337885558605194,
0.07006367295980453,
-0.2927294075489044,
0.6540766954421997,
-0.4309372007846832,
-0.38600486516952515,
0.3161541521549225,
0.903831958770752,
0.2880653142929077,
-0.18673351407051086,
-0.45631396770477295,
-0.4556385278701782,
-0.47787168622016907,
-0.4270811378955841,
0.3092409074306488,
0.4800252616405487,
-0.23401619493961334,
0.8352033495903015,
0.43638113141059875,
-0.38205254077911377,
0.32166922092437744,
-0.1704104244709015,
0.9946209192276001,
-0.6291666030883789,
-0.5306941866874695,
-0.504408597946167,
0.524961531162262,
0.08059564977884293,
-0.1761268526315689,
0.5422110557556152,
0.1486203670501709,
0.2911195755004883,
-0.001956745982170105,
0.5723392367362976,
-0.0709625855088234,
0.23468676209449768,
-0.5019951462745667,
0.7299942970275879,
-0.6838725209236145,
0.31529301404953003,
-0.17995502054691315,
-0.9168592691421509,
0.011256948113441467,
0.35018324851989746,
0.09035149216651917,
0.12766624987125397,
0.529845118522644,
1.026999592781067,
0.3074129521846771,
0.010773640125989914,
0.803208589553833,
-0.040189873427152634,
0.15424448251724243,
0.6371365785598755,
1.1602096557617188,
-0.3488313853740692,
0.3884204924106598,
0.1829053908586502,
-0.2144567370414734,
0.13028143346309662,
-0.3959905505180359,
-0.6444462537765503,
-0.592681884765625,
-0.18963900208473206,
-0.10294602066278458,
0.008507143706083298,
0.9877723455429077,
0.8822232484817505,
-0.49876728653907776,
-0.22306068241596222,
0.23574864864349365,
0.33551692962646484,
-0.5326979160308838,
-0.20150226354599,
0.36021414399147034,
-0.19587433338165283,
-0.7830044627189636,
0.10838542133569717,
0.13311369717121124,
-0.14236633479595184,
-0.49148672819137573,
-0.08432439714670181,
-0.4937928020954132,
0.4754214286804199,
0.5709832310676575,
0.07372909039258957,
-0.8189159631729126,
-0.5351287126541138,
0.4258755147457123,
-0.16501770913600922,
0.05189436301589012,
0.7959896922111511,
-0.7190777659416199,
0.5676591992378235,
0.4990280568599701,
1.0311447381973267,
0.6868311762809753,
0.3582003712654114,
0.5095871090888977,
-0.7125670313835144,
-0.001398748834617436,
0.3237423896789551,
0.17534410953521729,
0.19506262242794037,
-0.7022129893302917,
0.39412394165992737,
-0.10227767378091812,
-0.6226935386657715,
-0.31658369302749634,
0.12855316698551178,
-1.0238531827926636,
-0.3777288496494293,
1.230129361152649,
-0.49355512857437134,
-0.6544162631034851,
-0.6129049062728882,
-0.23408766090869904,
0.07984962314367294,
-0.23880912363529205,
0.43387359380722046,
0.8822915554046631,
-0.24959604442119598,
-0.6735944151878357,
-0.40107470750808716,
-0.07730009406805038,
0.31543678045272827,
-0.9447367787361145,
-0.19854918122291565,
0.6093155741691589,
0.15643930435180664,
-0.037628285586833954,
0.790913462638855,
-0.0935446098446846,
0.4042469561100006,
0.12086815387010574,
0.28247663378715515,
0.10683424770832062,
-0.2255016714334488,
-0.33036312460899353,
0.4552919864654541,
0.11364780366420746,
-0.49539506435394287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10908v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10908v1
|
MICL: Improving In-Context Learning through Multiple-Label Words in Demonstration
| 2024-06-16T12:11:46 | 2024-06-16T12:11:46 |
Zhu Zixiao, Feng Zijian, Zhou Hanzhang, Qian Junlang, Mao Kezhi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In-context learning (ICL) enables large language models (LLMs) to perform new
tasks by using sample-label pairs as demonstrations. However, variations in
demonstrations can lead to significantly different performances. Current
research mainly focuses on selecting demonstration samples, preassuming the
class name to be the label word when creating sample-label pairs. However, the
choice of label words is crucial for ICL performance. In addition, we observe
that using a single class name in demonstration may not yield optimal results.
In this paper, we propose to use multiple label words in one sample-label pair
to enhance ICL performance. Further, we select and order sample-label pairs
based on LLM's output distribution, aiming to optimize the demonstration
examples from both the samples' and labels' perspectives. Evaluation results on
seven classification datasets show that the use of multiple label words,
strategically organized by their selection, order and quantity, improves ICL
performance through diverse label information.
|
[
-0.6032903790473938,
-0.37032902240753174,
0.0902501717209816,
0.48998093605041504,
-0.5282005667686462,
0.3646602928638458,
-0.26845553517341614,
-0.5367279648780823,
-0.25615596771240234,
0.1429561972618103,
-0.24550381302833557,
-0.5695632100105286,
-0.5916791558265686,
0.0025766361504793167,
-0.2836243808269501,
1.1442277431488037,
0.03963413089513779,
0.2499971091747284,
-0.38886016607284546,
-0.609644889831543,
-0.37897586822509766,
-0.5709177255630493,
-0.6188720464706421,
-0.6119028925895691,
0.5963264107704163,
0.8405230641365051,
0.13143596053123474,
0.44818171858787537,
0.16892002522945404,
0.20310477912425995,
0.029577825218439102,
0.37474343180656433,
-0.4233003854751587,
0.2314593642950058,
0.1432715505361557,
-0.1941281110048294,
-0.018145672976970673,
0.22440235316753387,
0.9688224792480469,
0.6954548954963684,
0.19466523826122284,
0.13616503775119781,
0.4250616729259491,
0.393074631690979,
-0.7680661678314209,
-0.009099292568862438,
-0.5350821614265442,
0.16345034539699554,
-0.06717574596405029,
-0.0838269516825676,
-0.765754759311676,
-0.4880799353122711,
0.2083045393228531,
-0.4205091893672943,
-0.23201508820056915,
0.3112351894378662,
0.5879038572311401,
-0.009947267360985279,
-0.28322914242744446,
-0.19980251789093018,
-0.6029449701309204,
0.9249412417411804,
-0.721699059009552,
0.5766071677207947,
0.12101679295301437,
0.3998123109340668,
0.10981503129005432,
-0.8624436259269714,
-0.34456220269203186,
-0.4512786567211151,
-0.12558837234973907,
0.32554203271865845,
0.322287917137146,
-0.00034320203121751547,
0.340242862701416,
-0.12048232555389404,
-0.16309651732444763,
0.38266751170158386,
-0.266894668340683,
-0.23879431188106537,
0.4064256548881531,
-0.04281917214393616,
0.08731027692556381,
0.40730229020118713,
-0.9086567163467407,
-0.4186599850654602,
-0.8955249190330505,
0.3153958320617676,
0.16679921746253967,
0.5179172158241272,
-0.05495855212211609,
0.3326268792152405,
-0.12237685173749924,
0.7825055718421936,
-0.13354015350341797,
-0.679322361946106,
0.42049527168273926,
-0.1437351554632187,
-0.3394254744052887,
0.4147116243839264,
0.5227344632148743,
0.11918683350086212,
-0.39288297295570374,
-0.2458934336900711,
-0.1636219173669815,
-0.11685887724161148,
-0.13271330296993256,
-1.0734920501708984,
-0.2118629813194275,
-0.06628191471099854,
-0.26189208030700684,
-0.22116319835186005,
0.2827584147453308,
-0.7682293653488159,
-0.19908209145069122,
-0.446422278881073,
0.5986946821212769,
-0.37965747714042664,
0.10945403575897217,
-0.10316619277000427,
-0.3939046859741211,
-0.01374849397689104,
0.256774365901947,
-0.5243083834648132,
0.42641928791999817,
0.3154810667037964,
0.5964959263801575,
-0.30502504110336304,
-0.5074183344841003,
-0.6695834398269653,
0.4707997739315033,
-0.2765359878540039,
0.6052953600883484,
-0.5953141450881958,
-0.48587632179260254,
-0.060473669320344925,
-0.4137635827064514,
-0.002551147248595953,
-0.7550104260444641,
0.2503766715526581,
-0.2772134244441986,
0.21045975387096405,
-0.17363646626472473,
-0.7987381815910339,
-0.20728200674057007,
0.13610798120498657,
-0.35519570112228394,
1.0262012481689453,
-0.09435974061489105,
-0.6969291567802429,
0.7871508002281189,
-0.707939624786377,
-0.6164740920066833,
0.36855822801589966,
-0.511042594909668,
-0.38762253522872925,
-0.06148838996887207,
0.023525970056653023,
0.690254271030426,
0.21742621064186096,
0.08606042712926865,
-0.15648433566093445,
-0.46011701226234436,
0.6434516310691833,
-0.5168316960334778,
0.4598233103752136,
0.1428176611661911,
-0.546947181224823,
0.1100175604224205,
-0.8031637072563171,
0.1694648563861847,
-0.4524592161178589,
-0.7182034254074097,
-0.44608086347579956,
0.16822002828121185,
0.09517014771699905,
0.38003239035606384,
-0.1832350194454193,
-0.31626561284065247,
0.041655078530311584,
-0.4520098567008972,
-0.08925321698188782,
0.746846616268158,
-0.1694512516260147,
0.44812119007110596,
-0.3937866985797882,
0.5354787111282349,
0.17234036326408386,
0.13811077177524567,
-0.10470561683177948,
-0.3929077088832855,
-0.7475765347480774,
-0.499334454536438,
0.21888308227062225,
0.268979012966156,
-0.787726879119873,
-0.040373824536800385,
0.12227189540863037,
-0.48372459411621094,
-0.4692077338695526,
0.18330496549606323,
0.6967145204544067,
0.7284511923789978,
0.5026240348815918,
-0.19068032503128052,
-0.29707980155944824,
-1.0282795429229736,
-0.18834437429904938,
-0.061180341988801956,
0.05262463539838791,
0.465629905462265,
0.2267063707113266,
0.09067530930042267,
0.836952805519104,
-0.49559637904167175,
-0.12717987596988678,
-0.23695659637451172,
0.19770219922065735,
0.07723361253738403,
0.2815587818622589,
0.6118578314781189,
-0.9692233800888062,
-0.7005744576454163,
-0.0902584046125412,
-0.3084048330783844,
-0.01172795332968235,
-0.10143781453371048,
-0.33580419421195984,
0.0913756713271141,
0.5293846130371094,
0.25565770268440247,
0.28215575218200684,
0.4479984641075134,
-0.07690821588039398,
0.65352463722229,
-0.3361566364765167,
-0.18884563446044922,
-0.8709202408790588,
-0.51506108045578,
0.012445847503840923,
-0.0034624808467924595,
-0.7003927826881409,
0.06348904222249985,
0.2795494496822357,
0.22892887890338898,
-0.9018010497093201,
0.6301503777503967,
-0.49875468015670776,
0.09857164323329926,
-0.32677367329597473,
0.2998265326023102,
0.010214107111096382,
0.28561246395111084,
-0.11129766702651978,
0.8691785335540771,
0.7913035750389099,
-0.9958260655403137,
0.08592963218688965,
-0.0042565567418932915,
-0.6636912226676941,
0.4132174551486969,
-0.20777402818202972,
0.08945255726575851,
-0.24303840100765228,
0.27309200167655945,
-1.1720870733261108,
-0.12475438416004181,
0.3511616587638855,
-0.15255598723888397,
0.6231550574302673,
0.22545017302036285,
-0.5527418851852417,
-0.12440834939479828,
-0.24950572848320007,
0.3650205433368683,
0.20097599923610687,
-0.9622735381126404,
0.20004096627235413,
0.26085832715034485,
0.3512735366821289,
-0.6752443313598633,
-0.7133039832115173,
-0.12854665517807007,
-0.689500629901886,
-0.06867394596338272,
0.539219081401825,
-0.6710342764854431,
-0.23466703295707703,
-0.5006981492042542,
-0.07164669781923294,
0.07910080254077911,
0.15417395532131195,
0.351075142621994,
0.09457718580961227,
-0.13281330466270447,
0.8269648551940918,
0.09175514429807663,
0.13740813732147217,
-0.1975586861371994,
-0.30206748843193054,
0.3461259603500366,
-0.2670891582965851,
-0.23998160660266876,
-0.2925224006175995,
0.4581911563873291,
0.2867380678653717,
-0.04076976329088211,
0.8135185837745667,
0.5032291412353516,
-0.17872470617294312,
-0.45248323678970337,
-0.4218120574951172,
-0.22309571504592896,
-0.4617302417755127,
0.2843106985092163,
-0.47692930698394775,
-0.6871982216835022,
0.0005531870992854238,
-0.405230849981308,
0.19945268332958221,
-0.1865920126438141,
0.3501497507095337,
-0.2886154055595398,
0.8858953714370728,
0.6372668743133545,
-0.28436368703842163,
0.5463088750839233,
-0.18594534695148468,
0.2009616643190384,
-0.9913989901542664,
-0.36788058280944824,
-0.45108169317245483,
-0.4554101228713989,
-0.25661522150039673,
-0.44188785552978516,
0.5501070022583008,
0.34011751413345337,
-0.21311068534851074,
0.1626085489988327,
-0.567849338054657,
0.5582413673400879,
0.7281867265701294,
0.42677584290504456,
0.17491915822029114,
0.3591483235359192,
-0.5487769246101379,
-0.03926926851272583,
-0.7219169735908508,
-0.7440481781959534,
0.6671268939971924,
0.08499981462955475,
0.5428453087806702,
0.24847689270973206,
0.8128772974014282,
-0.20749206840991974,
0.7548713684082031,
-0.6162030100822449,
0.6190744042396545,
-0.3001629710197449,
-0.4194640517234802,
-0.23849554359912872,
0.02961403876543045,
-0.8638433218002319,
0.678849458694458,
-0.19953367114067078,
-1.0107378959655762,
-0.07809942960739136,
0.20495784282684326,
-0.18161767721176147,
0.10430115461349487,
-0.7952126264572144,
0.6130995154380798,
-0.4137921631336212,
-0.24328242242336273,
-0.16197353601455688,
-0.7039730548858643,
0.4172687232494354,
-0.05393718183040619,
0.5098660588264465,
-0.04165254160761833,
-0.05748904123902321,
0.7150141596794128,
-0.2052432894706726,
0.929811418056488,
-0.02892405539751053,
0.03153245523571968,
0.26050877571105957,
-0.2640751302242279,
0.16020314395427704,
0.024632897228002548,
-0.12669114768505096,
-0.41047587990760803,
-0.33985450863838196,
-0.1526612788438797,
-0.3736361861228943,
0.7315813899040222,
-0.6534690856933594,
-0.2881387174129486,
-0.01254203263670206,
-0.5012977123260498,
-0.35164257884025574,
-0.15592695772647858,
0.5380458235740662,
1.0390814542770386,
0.0757380872964859,
0.3644026517868042,
0.6917062401771545,
-0.3325214087963104,
0.7660633325576782,
0.28500813245773315,
-0.2477828860282898,
-0.35242781043052673,
1.044941782951355,
0.2458905279636383,
0.6947289705276489,
0.6082831621170044,
0.5306953191757202,
-0.4387568235397339,
-0.5365792512893677,
-0.25926899909973145,
0.07430636137723923,
-1.0227562189102173,
-0.17658185958862305,
-0.6532559990882874,
0.07121294736862183,
-0.33353468775749207,
-0.2035512775182724,
0.11038682609796524,
-0.3886778652667999,
-0.37462684512138367,
-0.1039346233010292,
0.04798680543899536,
0.5514234900474548,
0.03844861686229706,
0.5713664293289185,
-0.38206660747528076,
0.3114147186279297,
0.4387102425098419,
0.3208199739456177,
0.1264612376689911,
-0.34050989151000977,
-0.20559093356132507,
-0.018449872732162476,
-0.5689387917518616,
-1.1360739469528198,
0.14640527963638306,
0.49775421619415283,
1.0448970794677734,
0.6063977479934692,
0.21508748829364777,
0.7979527711868286,
-0.39965417981147766,
0.4986538887023926,
0.436240553855896,
-0.7485474348068237,
0.7418965697288513,
0.1570722758769989,
0.3643301725387573,
0.3953513205051422,
0.49077749252319336,
-0.476357638835907,
-0.8655673861503601,
-0.6746222972869873,
-1.2571688890457153,
0.7882417440414429,
0.030228042975068092,
0.0393228679895401,
0.058569177985191345,
-0.1182449534535408,
0.38047975301742554,
0.2441776543855667,
-0.9061681628227234,
-0.7019653916358948,
0.03209773823618889,
-0.03553316742181778,
-0.14418092370033264,
-0.11653105169534683,
-0.31845536828041077,
-0.5314661860466003,
0.927079975605011,
-0.3353472948074341,
0.005299723241478205,
-0.05947933718562126,
-0.19362424314022064,
0.43381965160369873,
0.40806934237480164,
0.7539791464805603,
0.8257647752761841,
0.06216259300708771,
0.34876999258995056,
0.4048985242843628,
-0.2248811423778534,
0.24083161354064941,
-0.020113812759518623,
-0.12305474281311035,
0.12306065857410431,
0.21786297857761383,
0.9397611618041992,
0.43774521350860596,
-0.7063155174255371,
0.3262995183467865,
-0.012283490039408207,
-0.004874350968748331,
-0.17512445151805878,
0.034194014966487885,
0.08265698701143265,
0.3403727412223816,
0.2717989981174469,
-0.012075324542820454,
0.20054592192173004,
-0.531269907951355,
0.35483047366142273,
0.26333844661712646,
-0.40561971068382263,
0.20866312086582184,
0.5198509693145752,
-0.18482691049575806,
-0.43817028403282166,
0.49590933322906494,
-0.17752689123153687,
-0.6101546883583069,
0.8762001395225525,
0.8457110524177551,
0.4448294937610626,
-0.19140197336673737,
0.3978749215602875,
0.38836148381233215,
-0.0513252317905426,
-0.0844479352235794,
0.020257042720913887,
-0.35030874609947205,
-0.8702703714370728,
-0.15473395586013794,
-0.30548182129859924,
-0.4610160291194916,
-0.0488719567656517,
-0.6284175515174866,
0.3619188666343689,
-0.36067408323287964,
-0.11196649074554443,
0.05058470368385315,
-0.16616027057170868,
-0.663501501083374,
0.2937658727169037,
0.40486034750938416,
0.7045965194702148,
-0.7764430046081543,
1.0750354528427124,
0.8162562251091003,
-0.07663232088088989,
-1.0927987098693848,
-0.024033404886722565,
-0.10341309010982513,
-0.26377421617507935,
1.0632305145263672,
0.5482459664344788,
-0.1901746541261673,
-0.10498489439487457,
-0.7602970600128174,
-0.6622575521469116,
1.0386658906936646,
-0.0006942148902453482,
-0.4103129208087921,
0.508752703666687,
-0.017236072570085526,
0.3961043357849121,
-0.7361551523208618,
0.4239695966243744,
0.18859416246414185,
0.4818289875984192,
0.2505653500556946,
-0.5114043354988098,
-0.34277525544166565,
0.30227866768836975,
0.04456797242164612,
-0.03806387260556221,
-0.7220272421836853,
0.3674076795578003,
-0.21881206333637238,
-0.27390217781066895,
-0.07228884845972061,
0.9028729200363159,
0.9529512524604797,
0.6141113042831421,
0.6824274659156799,
0.001178104430437088,
0.8897490501403809,
-0.12759076058864594,
1.0161701440811157,
0.008628049865365028,
0.1396453082561493,
1.460789680480957,
-0.11929172277450562,
0.9555653929710388,
0.6931231617927551,
-0.12546628713607788,
0.3153311312198639,
0.6338247060775757,
0.07960143685340881,
0.6939082741737366,
0.5254424214363098,
-0.6953175663948059,
-0.20815211534500122,
-0.3501211702823639,
-0.29671579599380493,
0.40184304118156433,
0.6022941470146179,
-0.25677046179771423,
-0.17442771792411804,
0.569313108921051,
-0.09523981064558029,
0.10774514079093933,
-0.0864640548825264,
0.6242230534553528,
0.0588749460875988,
-0.5385392308235168,
0.4585622251033783,
-0.2500436305999756,
0.7982091307640076,
-0.39467307925224304,
-0.16836698353290558,
-0.26309964060783386,
0.20568151772022247,
0.046952489763498306,
-0.5352057218551636,
-0.19440095126628876,
-0.37291786074638367,
-0.055440641939640045,
-0.5857942700386047,
0.5552154779434204,
-0.7234892249107361,
-0.590294599533081,
0.5603897571563721,
0.0571567676961422,
0.42694202065467834,
0.3792908191680908,
-0.4412698745727539,
-0.14930656552314758,
-0.13574345409870148,
0.02130104973912239,
0.5408925414085388,
0.22411271929740906,
-0.02659493312239647,
0.7505010366439819,
0.2707479000091553,
-0.012713471427559853,
0.4460848867893219,
0.2362649142742157,
0.9391499161720276,
-0.14371708035469055,
-0.305574893951416,
-0.8490428328514099,
0.5659598708152771,
-0.2961154580116272,
-0.40464651584625244,
0.7059848308563232,
0.8317084312438965,
1.3093246221542358,
-0.07703372091054916,
0.7418920993804932,
0.08554796874523163,
0.5420434474945068,
-0.5702099800109863,
0.4067152142524719,
-0.6654658317565918,
0.24015666544437408,
-0.41492369771003723,
-0.7575887441635132,
-0.44138526916503906,
0.4108956754207611,
0.2614422142505646,
-0.12388020008802414,
0.7286578416824341,
0.7579801082611084,
-0.03642314299941063,
-0.04443509131669998,
0.6336053609848022,
0.053093791007995605,
0.3442719876766205,
0.5714239478111267,
0.9728407859802246,
-0.4240584969520569,
0.5714216232299805,
-0.7142862677574158,
-0.1564507782459259,
-0.0991695299744606,
-0.9678595066070557,
-0.9491334557533264,
-0.6370279788970947,
-0.5744233131408691,
-0.12026171386241913,
-0.016994211822748184,
0.9874069094657898,
1.0733325481414795,
-0.6188151240348816,
-0.5357630848884583,
0.4675549566745758,
0.1765901744365692,
-0.6099653840065002,
-0.2367103099822998,
0.34021052718162537,
-0.5522690415382385,
-0.8640457391738892,
0.7954137921333313,
0.15007096529006958,
0.2855018675327301,
0.10145258158445358,
-0.1577998548746109,
-0.22774802148342133,
-0.3781534731388092,
0.9240390062332153,
0.04785113409161568,
-0.8980597853660583,
-0.32444635033607483,
-0.425576776266098,
-0.060686446726322174,
0.16155187785625458,
0.8215649127960205,
-0.8616929054260254,
0.5027703642845154,
0.4290224015712738,
0.5399991273880005,
0.44332343339920044,
-0.009987900964915752,
0.30576708912849426,
-1.2794442176818848,
0.22176526486873627,
0.23914417624473572,
0.27515408396720886,
0.18501654267311096,
-0.16267718374729156,
0.3324408531188965,
-0.04448314756155014,
-0.41272178292274475,
-0.5663203001022339,
0.3271867334842682,
-0.805733323097229,
-0.6402002573013306,
1.2719258069992065,
-0.12135651707649231,
0.24652230739593506,
-0.11162561923265457,
-0.30756038427352905,
0.3941117823123932,
-0.347900390625,
0.5133963823318481,
0.8194055557250977,
-0.34651991724967957,
-0.22201701998710632,
-0.6946035027503967,
0.28354397416114807,
0.3438141942024231,
-0.703385591506958,
-0.3201437294483185,
0.39738982915878296,
0.15845416486263275,
0.04037107899785042,
0.4967372417449951,
0.12180864065885544,
-0.1802714318037033,
-0.3987027406692505,
-0.14780665934085846,
0.11815173178911209,
-0.5852891206741333,
-0.30712273716926575,
0.3863097131252289,
0.20074597001075745,
-0.5198891758918762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10906v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10906v1
|
Breaking the Attention Bottleneck
| 2024-06-16T12:06:58 | 2024-06-16T12:06:58 |
Kalle Hilsenbek
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Attention-based transformers have become the standard architecture in many
deep learning fields, primarily due to their ability to model long-range
dependencies and handle variable-length input sequences. However, the attention
mechanism with its quadratic complexity is a significant bottleneck in the
transformer architecture. This algorithm is only uni-directional in the decoder
and converges to a static pattern in over-parametrized decoder-only models. I
address this issue by developing a generative function as attention or
activation replacement. It still has the auto-regressive character by comparing
each token with the previous one. In my test setting with nanoGPT this yields a
smaller loss while having a smaller model. The loss further drops by
incorporating an average context vector. This concept of attention replacement
is distributed under the GNU AGPL v3 license at
https://gitlab.com/Bachstelze/causal_generation.
|
[
-0.6119800209999084,
-0.5769333839416504,
0.5326054096221924,
0.29446732997894287,
-0.08394932001829147,
-0.19088001549243927,
0.023942476138472557,
-0.4059808552265167,
-0.29844337701797485,
0.4096997082233429,
-0.5471883416175842,
0.07545333355665207,
-0.6096065640449524,
0.25138136744499207,
-0.40165239572525024,
0.9458502531051636,
0.010576412081718445,
-0.1882016658782959,
-0.22687175869941711,
-0.2361028641462326,
-0.7194209694862366,
-0.27644070982933044,
-0.9066527485847473,
-0.5640503168106079,
0.491132527589798,
0.1530255675315857,
0.5618711113929749,
0.6730567216873169,
0.5182352662086487,
0.3458148241043091,
-0.21629290282726288,
-0.030169574543833733,
-0.5767491459846497,
0.042006269097328186,
-0.20460696518421173,
-0.2676624059677124,
-0.13425642251968384,
-0.0817827507853508,
0.41243502497673035,
0.7262631058692932,
-0.24195292592048645,
0.10929383337497711,
0.3461061120033264,
0.8019286394119263,
-0.6306902766227722,
0.4063093662261963,
-0.510167121887207,
0.3006467819213867,
0.08474860340356827,
-0.17797422409057617,
-0.5033711194992065,
0.01856405846774578,
0.2516300678253174,
-0.5083627700805664,
0.7661156058311462,
-0.12365319579839706,
0.6160866022109985,
0.9886226058006287,
-0.2543918788433075,
0.12327078729867935,
-0.9401975274085999,
0.6561353206634521,
-0.26398059725761414,
0.41924774646759033,
0.006411696784198284,
0.12322269380092621,
-0.05843806266784668,
-0.8228322863578796,
-0.4077316224575043,
-0.16741013526916504,
-0.1333014816045761,
0.18814745545387268,
-0.6239686012268066,
0.1667288988828659,
0.4976557791233063,
0.4229681193828583,
-0.4075683057308197,
-0.11789140105247498,
-0.557978093624115,
0.14739365875720978,
0.3184221386909485,
0.16611061990261078,
0.056076779961586,
-0.10756726562976837,
-0.5107499957084656,
0.010919465683400631,
-0.669643759727478,
-0.004203684628009796,
0.07226453721523285,
-0.021342771127820015,
0.19439232349395752,
0.3356955647468567,
-0.2923206090927124,
0.6523557901382446,
0.7520388960838318,
0.6094827055931091,
0.31837961077690125,
-0.07545316964387894,
-0.4880671501159668,
0.17038550972938538,
0.7830613851547241,
0.2878912389278412,
0.26073628664016724,
-0.3325110077857971,
-0.026973772794008255,
-0.12860527634620667,
0.7549676895141602,
-0.6602442264556885,
-0.39074745774269104,
0.1378348469734192,
-0.16663974523544312,
-0.1301104873418808,
-0.05997757613658905,
-0.7015956044197083,
-0.2585795819759369,
-0.3065595328807831,
0.37335363030433655,
-0.2774422764778137,
0.003144746646285057,
0.29920652508735657,
0.09115993976593018,
0.17420534789562225,
0.01610620692372322,
-1.1023361682891846,
0.09778894484043121,
0.4473326802253723,
0.8922241926193237,
-0.06043820083141327,
-0.20565825700759888,
-0.39122968912124634,
0.0038913751486688852,
-0.23044425249099731,
0.6441680788993835,
-0.04205889254808426,
-0.37402358651161194,
-0.2573143541812897,
0.0014702683547511697,
-0.0951550230383873,
-0.5947675108909607,
0.5495379567146301,
-0.6068099737167358,
0.009867843240499496,
-0.11179957538843155,
-0.19708603620529175,
-0.12784729897975922,
-0.013070854358375072,
-0.8454940915107727,
1.0473613739013672,
0.26259610056877136,
-0.6132633090019226,
0.19086824357509613,
-0.7073461413383484,
-0.6018347144126892,
0.2498871237039566,
-0.049497928470373154,
-0.9362594485282898,
0.290420800447464,
0.24732841551303864,
0.30607056617736816,
-0.41591545939445496,
0.11967410892248154,
-0.13923600316047668,
-0.5649445652961731,
0.16716834902763367,
-0.5725659728050232,
0.6138782501220703,
0.09099891036748886,
-0.7100184559822083,
0.07763658463954926,
-0.8121495842933655,
-0.27245470881462097,
0.20443864166736603,
-0.1554422229528427,
0.011814277619123459,
-0.021739691495895386,
-0.08757415413856506,
0.32522404193878174,
-0.1134147047996521,
-0.5476920008659363,
0.18755069375038147,
-0.38553622364997864,
0.9249767065048218,
0.6818339824676514,
0.19151698052883148,
0.4342280328273773,
0.09145458787679672,
0.42209550738334656,
0.1127648800611496,
0.36351278424263,
-0.1570894718170166,
-0.35740599036216736,
-1.00454843044281,
-0.14712533354759216,
0.057634640485048294,
0.35593467950820923,
-0.596481442451477,
0.3193151652812958,
-0.043829262256622314,
-0.32670068740844727,
-0.6338993310928345,
0.09287021309137344,
0.2737433910369873,
0.6006398797035217,
0.7325628995895386,
-0.22746720910072327,
-0.43968483805656433,
-0.9062822461128235,
0.01968170888721943,
0.06445898115634918,
-0.12307992577552795,
0.2925824224948883,
0.18014687299728394,
-0.3869752287864685,
0.7940497994422913,
-0.5397917628288269,
-0.4904332458972931,
-0.1415351927280426,
0.41639968752861023,
0.16258247196674347,
0.495599627494812,
0.25322020053863525,
-0.9291003346443176,
-0.614458441734314,
-0.016552187502384186,
-0.43652835488319397,
-0.2279692441225052,
-0.38623905181884766,
0.22666826844215393,
0.10823667794466019,
0.7710453271865845,
-1.167495846748352,
0.5244482159614563,
0.040158938616514206,
-0.0766136646270752,
0.4123964309692383,
-0.11032700538635254,
-0.10244534909725189,
-0.5020220875740051,
0.25283995270729065,
0.12656109035015106,
-0.04172555357217789,
-0.6500850915908813,
0.018595227971673012,
0.016339562833309174,
-0.2687626779079437,
-0.40756797790527344,
0.24286015331745148,
-0.4584060609340668,
-0.08823467046022415,
-0.26250311732292175,
-0.113247349858284,
0.04295995831489563,
0.8662399053573608,
-0.09512647986412048,
1.0093193054199219,
0.40058019757270813,
-0.5154549479484558,
0.34527575969696045,
0.40481293201446533,
-0.1405581533908844,
0.5812899470329285,
-1.1957018375396729,
0.1775193065404892,
-0.3342830240726471,
0.14832870662212372,
-0.93747878074646,
-0.08077047020196915,
0.4862458109855652,
-0.3817204535007477,
0.46285009384155273,
0.10731906443834305,
-0.28071460127830505,
-0.5594545602798462,
-0.1120663657784462,
0.6703468561172485,
0.5325756072998047,
-0.6555712819099426,
0.5540163516998291,
-0.046525925397872925,
-0.08653788268566132,
-0.7639880180358887,
-0.5429980158805847,
0.12539733946323395,
-0.13184618949890137,
-0.15409214794635773,
0.45261529088020325,
0.12083644419908524,
0.2846110761165619,
0.2305389642715454,
-0.20053713023662567,
0.28054192662239075,
-0.046395380049943924,
0.2265072762966156,
-0.10367167741060257,
-0.13161014020442963,
0.19515003263950348,
-0.2492600828409195,
-0.4049578011035919,
0.12844575941562653,
-0.2485579401254654,
0.5845170021057129,
-0.23312395811080933,
-0.12564097344875336,
-0.4572277367115021,
0.5048031210899353,
1.032520055770874,
-0.46936312317848206,
0.32067781686782837,
0.7471209168434143,
-0.07472328096628189,
-0.24204835295677185,
-0.44719329476356506,
-0.06938191503286362,
-0.5396068096160889,
0.5686460733413696,
-0.46735021471977234,
-0.7463111281394958,
0.3619123101234436,
0.17410849034786224,
-0.3293485641479492,
0.6455873250961304,
0.7270798683166504,
-0.05563938617706299,
1.207197666168213,
0.6891354322433472,
-0.004941074177622795,
0.5127508640289307,
-0.48873117566108704,
0.4958522319793701,
-1.109167218208313,
-0.10187512636184692,
-0.13918352127075195,
-0.36802786588668823,
-0.5880596041679382,
-0.20934441685676575,
0.4264816641807556,
0.08367737382650375,
-0.3939504623413086,
0.6110067367553711,
-0.9104706645011902,
0.40398409962654114,
0.7189667820930481,
0.11036914587020874,
0.059173986315727234,
-0.2914740741252899,
0.3427093029022217,
0.1100379079580307,
-0.893219530582428,
0.05055283382534981,
0.8232234120368958,
0.48266610503196716,
0.7256643176078796,
-0.13808608055114746,
0.4681483209133148,
0.13224361836910248,
0.37903058528900146,
-0.7396348714828491,
0.46865540742874146,
-0.14266881346702576,
-0.3089234232902527,
-0.4648701548576355,
-0.4502117931842804,
-0.94952791929245,
0.17989474534988403,
0.17434823513031006,
-0.700961172580719,
0.5637632608413696,
0.4402291774749756,
-0.5313361287117004,
0.09435594826936722,
-0.5294126272201538,
1.0946431159973145,
0.10040690004825592,
-0.530849277973175,
-0.11580906063318253,
-0.7400340437889099,
0.29460495710372925,
-0.0675162747502327,
-0.5495030879974365,
0.239915668964386,
0.26858124136924744,
0.21406018733978271,
-0.22725622355937958,
0.9945082664489746,
0.04788675531744957,
0.08857515454292297,
0.34525957703590393,
-0.3245578408241272,
0.6459919214248657,
-0.03381914272904396,
0.5021388530731201,
0.0976172536611557,
-0.6099173426628113,
-0.2946469485759735,
-0.7185211181640625,
0.4295075237751007,
-0.799329400062561,
-0.8274495601654053,
-0.3765685260295868,
-0.6889761090278625,
-0.07373453676700592,
0.06994660198688507,
0.6817235946655273,
0.17899072170257568,
-0.06316110491752625,
0.3686392903327942,
0.9683732390403748,
0.044104527682065964,
0.4097132384777069,
0.05312110856175423,
0.5502036809921265,
-0.3237183690071106,
0.8686965703964233,
-0.04504241794347763,
0.22774745523929596,
0.273725688457489,
-0.01450169924646616,
-0.3269943296909332,
-0.29093998670578003,
-0.6169515252113342,
0.00009653934830566868,
-0.5911054015159607,
-0.3688763678073883,
-0.9677734375,
-0.4318069517612457,
-0.19217030704021454,
-0.04790737107396126,
-0.5051021575927734,
-0.023040559142827988,
-0.5406268239021301,
-0.16635093092918396,
-0.029955008998513222,
0.3771682679653168,
0.0531889908015728,
0.4767037332057953,
-0.5386709570884705,
0.4024832844734192,
0.697395920753479,
0.1895829439163208,
0.22975456714630127,
-0.2796797752380371,
-0.4499158561229706,
-0.3894640803337097,
-0.6707686185836792,
-0.7178552150726318,
0.2824282646179199,
0.15708127617835999,
0.4346698820590973,
0.44932469725608826,
-0.07787224650382996,
0.4610443413257599,
-0.8040894865989685,
0.48043131828308105,
0.46053361892700195,
-1.0247559547424316,
-0.003240549936890602,
-0.22084009647369385,
0.787173330783844,
0.26148721575737,
0.12033149600028992,
-0.6185290217399597,
-0.6031752228736877,
-0.7053565382957458,
-0.9416533708572388,
0.5343044400215149,
0.23780080676078796,
0.20322348177433014,
-0.06948504596948624,
0.3914199471473694,
-0.20140525698661804,
0.2297205775976181,
-0.7882811427116394,
-0.18295502662658691,
-0.4997854232788086,
-0.2845847010612488,
-0.04781833663582802,
-0.37904053926467896,
0.016178952530026436,
-0.16237452626228333,
0.47399991750717163,
-0.07234794646501541,
0.5656123757362366,
0.3825603723526001,
-0.030072636902332306,
-0.4173337519168854,
0.14352922141551971,
0.6190309524536133,
0.3360676169395447,
-0.1423567235469818,
0.11101793497800827,
0.06334825605154037,
-0.41192004084587097,
0.29696953296661377,
0.3303763270378113,
-0.4653566777706146,
-0.09437529742717743,
0.18652120232582092,
1.1195266246795654,
0.344672292470932,
-0.28710833191871643,
0.36539745330810547,
0.07635033130645752,
-0.16294851899147034,
-0.2196410745382309,
0.09503690898418427,
0.010555654764175415,
0.4564938545227051,
0.5866919159889221,
0.3115462362766266,
0.5651578307151794,
-0.28363996744155884,
0.5718805193901062,
0.2985568642616272,
-0.6010883450508118,
-0.12481041997671127,
1.112355351448059,
0.3291322886943817,
-0.2878405749797821,
0.5315192341804504,
-0.12773668766021729,
-0.7252672910690308,
0.7927390336990356,
0.46119827032089233,
1.2963131666183472,
-0.36393237113952637,
0.23235195875167847,
0.25758057832717896,
0.3190339207649231,
-0.04964311048388481,
-0.1455281376838684,
-0.2880484163761139,
-0.4417090117931366,
-0.6922221779823303,
-0.3785080313682556,
-0.05895084887742996,
0.23750881850719452,
-0.6458640098571777,
0.09458795934915543,
-0.36390283703804016,
-0.36459991335868835,
0.29817041754722595,
-0.39015933871269226,
-0.7260729670524597,
0.40112051367759705,
0.042439378798007965,
0.36036667227745056,
-0.6524889469146729,
0.5084864497184753,
0.45448705554008484,
-0.4258617162704468,
-0.28439146280288696,
0.14707669615745544,
-0.4740309417247772,
-0.5418511033058167,
0.9477173686027527,
0.4331046938896179,
-0.22285926342010498,
0.2729073166847229,
-0.2767999470233917,
-0.7718603014945984,
0.9681168794631958,
0.14201538264751434,
-0.7835845947265625,
-0.14646469056606293,
0.3086889088153839,
0.6645748019218445,
-0.19965849816799164,
-0.0950968936085701,
0.686104953289032,
0.28068801760673523,
0.08862241357564926,
-0.457574725151062,
0.04518859460949898,
-0.029316026717424393,
0.2108355015516281,
0.5854710340499878,
-0.8397654891014099,
0.9619322419166565,
-0.32240721583366394,
-0.3779660761356354,
-0.06962861120700836,
0.754842221736908,
-0.2518429160118103,
0.18539533019065857,
0.5673975944519043,
0.9208170771598816,
0.1139606311917305,
-0.0343564972281456,
0.8097153902053833,
-0.3266783058643341,
0.8718403577804565,
1.1211764812469482,
0.11337529867887497,
0.40339961647987366,
0.7047790288925171,
-0.1010386273264885,
0.0659782811999321,
0.4610709547996521,
-0.515117883682251,
0.8417218923568726,
0.2163679450750351,
-0.17719392478466034,
-0.0806407779455185,
0.061738405376672745,
-0.21400851011276245,
0.24526289105415344,
0.13826049864292145,
-0.48157164454460144,
-0.18695679306983948,
0.15693725645542145,
-0.13657070696353912,
-0.2499445527791977,
-0.3105137348175049,
0.6457526087760925,
0.2292729765176773,
-0.6772195100784302,
0.6476392149925232,
-0.12112411111593246,
0.1699874848127365,
-0.12694887816905975,
-0.1674112230539322,
-0.18627260625362396,
0.48350459337234497,
0.04338337853550911,
-0.496794193983078,
0.4420797824859619,
-0.37864652276039124,
-0.4747098386287689,
-0.08038245141506195,
0.5364905595779419,
-0.6321795582771301,
-0.3145126402378082,
0.26411691308021545,
0.08320295065641403,
-0.3959629535675049,
-0.21674185991287231,
-0.7480989098548889,
-0.042623814195394516,
-0.015938062220811844,
-0.5391334295272827,
0.005416346248239279,
0.3164665102958679,
0.19730879366397858,
0.8289904594421387,
0.4277123212814331,
-0.37456315755844116,
0.0009848172776401043,
-0.04956786707043648,
0.7383765578269958,
-0.4465301036834717,
-0.5148276090621948,
-0.8924850225448608,
0.5410069227218628,
-0.08982726186513901,
-0.5094549655914307,
0.520453691482544,
0.21634969115257263,
0.7736981511116028,
-0.3995632529258728,
0.5386277437210083,
0.06415478140115738,
-0.035635095089673996,
-0.31136903166770935,
0.5760457515716553,
-0.526908814907074,
0.05342061072587967,
-0.08298298716545105,
-1.093551516532898,
-0.33665895462036133,
0.45585304498672485,
-0.25827911496162415,
0.0008567916811443865,
0.6725306510925293,
0.5054600238800049,
-0.20644345879554749,
-0.2697821259498596,
0.46992209553718567,
0.30309149622917175,
0.2022918164730072,
0.8706151843070984,
0.5258945822715759,
-0.5244680047035217,
0.6481344103813171,
-0.15767858922481537,
-0.15240348875522614,
-0.4355863034725189,
-0.5575501322746277,
-0.8049103021621704,
-0.5104133486747742,
-0.6161139011383057,
-0.2178466022014618,
0.09896259754896164,
0.350943386554718,
0.6501823663711548,
-0.6938098073005676,
0.23795588314533234,
-0.6509190201759338,
-0.05331242084503174,
-0.6124105453491211,
-0.2827516794204712,
0.5398737788200378,
-0.6420486569404602,
-0.8359907269477844,
0.05982014536857605,
0.5591738820075989,
0.06374772638082504,
-0.49996212124824524,
0.19964055716991425,
0.02953331544995308,
0.09085503965616226,
0.6597881317138672,
0.6218214631080627,
-0.6435307264328003,
-0.4683034121990204,
0.04692563787102699,
-0.2908153533935547,
0.3197222650051117,
0.8919905424118042,
-0.7082516551017761,
0.4396176040172577,
0.27667000889778137,
0.8880072832107544,
0.7761180400848389,
0.049861472100019455,
0.658320963382721,
-0.8094601631164551,
0.11936446279287338,
0.18798209726810455,
0.2832813560962677,
0.3874349594116211,
-0.8258472681045532,
0.5820689797401428,
0.3461029827594757,
-0.7789509296417236,
-0.7119255065917969,
0.38952377438545227,
-1.0304213762283325,
-0.15668416023254395,
0.8260179758071899,
-0.06325212121009827,
-0.3420816659927368,
-0.12449901551008224,
-0.1537969559431076,
0.4491671025753021,
-0.2194543480873108,
1.0257622003555298,
0.5307292342185974,
-0.1668771654367447,
-0.6906098127365112,
-0.49839648604393005,
0.6007087230682373,
0.7168205976486206,
-0.37414586544036865,
0.35453009605407715,
0.2557235062122345,
0.11727403849363327,
0.5555734634399414,
0.22000248730182648,
-0.04525940120220184,
0.5589112043380737,
-0.03787738457322121,
0.31536316871643066,
-0.10686211287975311,
-0.5247452855110168,
-0.42335695028305054,
0.19199594855308533,
-0.3843195140361786,
-0.47415775060653687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10903v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10903v1
|
New Solutions on LLM Acceleration, Optimization, and Application
| 2024-06-16T11:56:50 | 2024-06-16T11:56:50 |
Yingbing Huang, Lily Jiaxin Wan, Hanchen Ye, Manvi Jha, Jinghua Wang, Yuhong Li, Xiaofan Zhang, Deming Chen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SE
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have become extremely potent instruments with
exceptional capacities for comprehending and producing human-like text in a
wide range of applications. However, the increasing size and complexity of LLMs
present significant challenges in both training and deployment, leading to
substantial computational and storage costs as well as heightened energy
consumption. In this paper, we provide a review of recent advancements and
research directions aimed at addressing these challenges and enhancing the
efficiency of LLM-based systems. We begin by discussing algorithm-level
acceleration techniques focused on optimizing LLM inference speed and resource
utilization. We also explore LLM-hardware co-design strategies with a vision to
improve system efficiency by tailoring hardware architectures to LLM
requirements. Further, we delve into LLM-to-accelerator compilation approaches,
which involve customizing hardware accelerators for efficient LLM deployment.
Finally, as a case study to leverage LLMs for assisting circuit design, we
examine LLM-aided design methodologies for an important task: High-Level
Synthesis (HLS) functional verification, by creating a new dataset that
contains a large number of buggy and bug-free codes, which can be essential for
training LLMs to specialize on HLS verification and debugging. For each aspect
mentioned above, we begin with a detailed background study, followed by the
presentation of several novel solutions proposed to overcome specific
challenges. We then outline future research directions to drive further
advancements. Through these efforts, we aim to pave the way for more efficient
and scalable deployment of LLMs across a diverse range of applications.
|
[
-0.47600311040878296,
-0.9176035523414612,
0.8625239133834839,
0.34401798248291016,
0.07556994259357452,
0.394879013299942,
-0.32283762097358704,
-0.43823665380477905,
-0.025144251063466072,
0.33841755986213684,
-0.39042162895202637,
-0.3907968997955322,
-0.61298668384552,
0.07057899981737137,
-0.4042034149169922,
0.2213236689567566,
-0.33218511939048767,
-0.11298127472400665,
-0.48136886954307556,
0.04402034729719162,
-0.3768394887447357,
-0.5659809708595276,
-0.611372172832489,
-0.5030222535133362,
0.3305531442165375,
0.28334876894950867,
0.3464463949203491,
0.6764524579048157,
0.7229007482528687,
0.3507021963596344,
-0.3441230356693268,
0.3615574538707733,
-0.26909181475639343,
0.3107393682003021,
0.23216243088245392,
-0.3302251696586609,
-0.7438597083091736,
-0.34598207473754883,
0.7429055571556091,
0.8508193492889404,
-0.13444869220256805,
0.22703835368156433,
-0.0556650385260582,
0.6608790159225464,
-0.7199754118919373,
-0.009461847133934498,
-0.43568742275238037,
-0.01898340694606304,
-0.15206490457057953,
-0.32404574751853943,
-0.3145228624343872,
-0.2512715756893158,
-0.1414271742105484,
-0.7220277786254883,
-0.050567250698804855,
0.2688991129398346,
0.41921061277389526,
0.3353003263473511,
-0.23839569091796875,
-0.27907848358154297,
-0.8210361003875732,
0.9912647008895874,
-0.720676600933075,
0.7307131886482239,
-0.22648030519485474,
0.23129154741764069,
-0.553081214427948,
-0.7035971879959106,
-0.28261250257492065,
-0.24419187009334564,
0.33945170044898987,
-0.19507458806037903,
-0.1689763218164444,
0.2012859284877777,
0.3014368712902069,
0.37046119570732117,
-0.5173331499099731,
0.5003124475479126,
-0.11620064079761505,
-0.2388392686843872,
0.6530422568321228,
0.3879914879798889,
0.3179203271865845,
0.31040623784065247,
-0.12745380401611328,
0.2126307487487793,
-1.2019098997116089,
-0.2522539794445038,
0.33074429631233215,
0.11520139127969742,
-0.09351541846990585,
0.3975161612033844,
-0.18416783213615417,
0.7834089398384094,
-0.3221253752708435,
-0.1266484558582306,
0.22612228989601135,
-0.405551016330719,
-0.16983990371227264,
-0.08745411038398743,
0.5848570466041565,
0.03772693872451782,
0.12901204824447632,
0.0929962545633316,
-0.44467517733573914,
-0.10782139748334885,
0.06808114796876907,
-0.9086698889732361,
0.13827800750732422,
0.2311839610338211,
-0.3331039249897003,
-0.20365358889102936,
-0.41644641757011414,
-0.833313524723053,
-0.527070164680481,
-0.4187888205051422,
0.2731562554836273,
0.11092633008956909,
-0.12995325028896332,
0.43036583065986633,
0.08068574965000153,
0.15206822752952576,
0.3756824731826782,
-1.1093884706497192,
0.32531484961509705,
0.8441045880317688,
0.6515599489212036,
-0.27770841121673584,
0.031479161232709885,
-0.585757851600647,
0.12773363292217255,
-0.41849151253700256,
0.4720137119293213,
-0.3910920321941376,
-0.42855408787727356,
0.13420680165290833,
-0.21626193821430206,
0.1809643656015396,
-0.6674160361289978,
0.6250855922698975,
-0.5898457765579224,
-0.28558844327926636,
-0.20432879030704498,
-0.48295873403549194,
0.1993078887462616,
0.1806737333536148,
-0.41666102409362793,
1.017399787902832,
-0.04380776360630989,
-0.43340083956718445,
-0.25836309790611267,
-0.7804630994796753,
-0.7503630518913269,
-0.13210590183734894,
-0.1948624849319458,
-0.30209776759147644,
0.5643645524978638,
0.0683453232049942,
0.2793400287628174,
-0.7408188581466675,
0.13269813358783722,
-0.023537760600447655,
-0.5937178730964661,
0.10785609483718872,
-0.18779800832271576,
0.5143976211547852,
0.38301435112953186,
-0.2569689154624939,
0.14646005630493164,
-0.8622609376907349,
-0.09273902326822281,
0.17749755084514618,
-0.5253215432167053,
-0.05685533955693245,
0.3450804352760315,
-0.2572139799594879,
-0.200489342212677,
0.532202422618866,
-0.6324462294578552,
0.054450422525405884,
-0.43012332916259766,
0.5555170178413391,
0.667687177658081,
-0.10478383302688599,
0.43159565329551697,
0.09927613288164139,
0.6106956005096436,
-0.3274427354335785,
0.3484880328178406,
-0.4988935589790344,
-0.28790879249572754,
-0.8345505595207214,
0.046397607773542404,
0.044211775064468384,
0.43598684668540955,
-0.46642374992370605,
0.47670483589172363,
0.08650030195713043,
-0.21317104995250702,
-0.36656320095062256,
0.31779640913009644,
0.2852379381656647,
0.39608800411224365,
0.3689398467540741,
-0.023093463853001595,
-0.6494963765144348,
-0.8825452923774719,
-0.2148313820362091,
-0.12195346504449844,
0.009390480816364288,
0.14187008142471313,
0.16763460636138916,
-0.2851544916629791,
0.4541686475276947,
-0.7352806329727173,
0.2226187139749527,
-0.33702102303504944,
-0.03442787379026413,
0.2266671359539032,
0.4515978991985321,
0.2693965435028076,
-0.5068796277046204,
-0.2522605359554291,
0.285239577293396,
-0.7216812968254089,
-0.381775438785553,
0.14224839210510254,
0.05443727970123291,
0.1385185420513153,
0.8165358304977417,
-0.36806124448776245,
0.03437778353691101,
0.43289026618003845,
0.26114562153816223,
0.5491353273391724,
-0.3068055510520935,
-0.0248708613216877,
-0.8275341987609863,
-0.19616468250751495,
0.008555065840482712,
0.048809170722961426,
-0.6452431082725525,
0.26297527551651,
-0.10002289712429047,
-0.12199696153402328,
-0.4431608319282532,
0.5900795459747314,
-0.6987493634223938,
-0.2147783488035202,
-0.5651999711990356,
0.19838151335716248,
-0.08671201020479202,
0.34514909982681274,
-0.27005305886268616,
0.917931318283081,
0.7035000324249268,
-0.6037757396697998,
0.5222433805465698,
-0.1187489926815033,
-0.3391421139240265,
0.12149225175380707,
-0.6481154561042786,
0.1571997106075287,
-0.07437224686145782,
-0.13692276179790497,
-0.7505016326904297,
-0.25560399889945984,
-0.09316281974315643,
-0.12927713990211487,
0.29763084650039673,
0.2542898654937744,
-0.7733298540115356,
-0.5110400319099426,
-0.33806461095809937,
0.618680477142334,
0.7670000791549683,
-0.5124701261520386,
0.7011053562164307,
0.38699421286582947,
-0.11292058229446411,
-0.4252612590789795,
-0.6883887052536011,
0.10659308731555939,
-0.12325777113437653,
-0.651696503162384,
0.4340367913246155,
-0.23487155139446259,
-0.41824594140052795,
-0.33106109499931335,
-0.22124412655830383,
0.20756088197231293,
0.4618174731731415,
-0.06624466925859451,
0.17769402265548706,
-0.40092694759368896,
0.2949795424938202,
0.19123034179210663,
-0.14275334775447845,
0.18972022831439972,
-0.40344786643981934,
0.5526347160339355,
-0.19609040021896362,
-0.5162491798400879,
-0.5995573997497559,
0.3546411097049713,
0.48414185643196106,
-0.1898905485868454,
0.2060556411743164,
0.5823008418083191,
-0.27080556750297546,
-0.3183381259441376,
-0.6842651963233948,
-0.020267561078071594,
-0.5729802846908569,
0.6514334082603455,
-0.2705635726451874,
-1.0501524209976196,
0.3026546835899353,
-0.4850493371486664,
0.2769545018672943,
0.11571799218654633,
0.8471012115478516,
-0.08179185539484024,
0.9250540137290955,
0.7574072480201721,
-0.04675740748643875,
0.7304283380508423,
-0.10018803179264069,
0.528597354888916,
-0.9093026518821716,
-0.10621856153011322,
-0.6646775603294373,
-0.32616573572158813,
-0.6559100151062012,
-0.5023093819618225,
0.5299986004829407,
-0.07963067293167114,
-0.3164744973182678,
0.17352154850959778,
-0.5151138305664062,
0.6052057147026062,
0.1520329862833023,
-0.33881059288978577,
0.46651312708854675,
0.15674249827861786,
-0.13993501663208008,
0.21491114795207977,
-0.6619304418563843,
-0.38355186581611633,
0.8863743543624878,
0.5117538571357727,
1.0181005001068115,
-0.073346808552742,
0.6596903800964355,
0.10382606834173203,
0.33121544122695923,
-0.7174765467643738,
0.7731536030769348,
-0.09523049741983414,
-0.3608172833919525,
-0.19301804900169373,
-0.38323768973350525,
-0.6708460450172424,
0.09091204404830933,
0.08577799052000046,
-0.767862856388092,
0.011661399155855179,
0.23922736942768097,
-0.14025792479515076,
0.2928599715232849,
-0.7069342732429504,
0.5873239040374756,
-0.6507311463356018,
-0.6606743335723877,
-0.36236611008644104,
-0.44804710149765015,
0.23261088132858276,
-0.07583767920732498,
0.3098069131374359,
-0.13003595173358917,
-0.27349159121513367,
0.45808130502700806,
-0.18986299633979797,
0.5036128163337708,
-0.1322408765554428,
-0.4685327112674713,
0.3288070559501648,
-0.14559394121170044,
0.4781651198863983,
-0.20479656755924225,
-0.434950053691864,
-0.1840415745973587,
-0.30765500664711,
-0.2738657295703888,
-0.6718798875808716,
0.9189546704292297,
-0.47076600790023804,
-0.7840750813484192,
0.07615304738283157,
-0.6592903137207031,
-0.36151614785194397,
0.15295995771884918,
-0.08707289397716522,
0.5303248763084412,
-0.20697447657585144,
0.2273475080728531,
0.9189705848693848,
-0.5078328251838684,
0.521493673324585,
0.31082549691200256,
-0.4104219675064087,
-0.24483560025691986,
1.0198571681976318,
-0.26324498653411865,
0.4557565450668335,
0.5081508159637451,
0.13885220885276794,
-0.2548339068889618,
-1.1338576078414917,
-0.44671058654785156,
0.2086232453584671,
-0.5770130157470703,
-0.08466833084821701,
-0.35878461599349976,
-0.14686425030231476,
-0.26354527473449707,
-0.3158494830131531,
-0.4730038046836853,
-0.4187479019165039,
-0.3718086779117584,
0.0502600334584713,
0.24781036376953125,
0.6765864491462708,
0.1442599594593048,
0.5370104312896729,
-0.54704350233078,
0.2809275686740875,
0.03571438789367676,
0.3659357726573944,
0.20038770139217377,
-0.2486848384141922,
-0.5382084846496582,
-0.26594820618629456,
-0.6710065603256226,
-0.2994410991668701,
0.017821213230490685,
-0.050162121653556824,
0.6389608979225159,
0.07604636251926422,
-0.26237374544143677,
0.45266664028167725,
-0.3739214539527893,
0.7083431482315063,
0.19569090008735657,
-0.8271454572677612,
0.5133230090141296,
-0.256106436252594,
0.16767480969429016,
0.27222421765327454,
0.30864977836608887,
-0.3408161699771881,
-0.20578154921531677,
-0.1936059296131134,
-0.8363922834396362,
0.24355927109718323,
0.07827214151620865,
0.23289042711257935,
0.25399330258369446,
0.6733559370040894,
-0.14665324985980988,
0.23675377666950226,
-0.33573290705680847,
-0.177715465426445,
0.3513277471065521,
-0.37019866704940796,
0.05657777935266495,
-0.1509413719177246,
0.014379013329744339,
-0.23301179707050323,
0.6987760663032532,
-0.1605478674173355,
0.2624134123325348,
-0.004458033014088869,
-0.048624437302351,
-0.014126647263765335,
0.4501933157444,
0.7134474515914917,
0.6520230174064636,
0.002122175181284547,
0.06775166839361191,
0.14425063133239746,
-0.1723097562789917,
0.41140902042388916,
-0.04519971087574959,
-0.0962948203086853,
-0.2888638973236084,
0.26100149750709534,
0.8216314911842346,
0.1807526797056198,
-0.8350403308868408,
0.3344614803791046,
0.09016101807355881,
-0.18572349846363068,
-0.06699314713478088,
0.22342191636562347,
0.47166016697883606,
0.308673232793808,
0.2872810363769531,
-0.35652443766593933,
0.039881009608507156,
-0.4599892199039459,
-0.13037487864494324,
0.583861231803894,
0.023553354665637016,
-0.2848709523677826,
0.6167932152748108,
0.38621020317077637,
-0.5680545568466187,
0.361243337392807,
-0.06144866347312927,
-0.36033564805984497,
0.5968495607376099,
0.6149290204048157,
0.9104634523391724,
-0.14658857882022858,
-0.32259565591812134,
0.10320097953081131,
0.38483455777168274,
-0.007265083026140928,
0.31182733178138733,
-0.24317637085914612,
-0.5309015512466431,
-0.580306351184845,
-0.9530991315841675,
-0.5487109422683716,
0.0028168829157948494,
-0.1304609179496765,
0.33773013949394226,
-0.5736600160598755,
-0.10305077582597733,
-0.0937708392739296,
0.058088891208171844,
-0.32478567957878113,
-0.09834309667348862,
0.11909137666225433,
0.9672592878341675,
-0.47849202156066895,
0.7145970463752747,
0.577347993850708,
0.07540033757686615,
-0.5124695897102356,
-0.3338540494441986,
-0.03139582276344299,
-0.7595682740211487,
0.5864437222480774,
-0.14477293193340302,
-0.35354378819465637,
0.028204018250107765,
-0.32349449396133423,
-0.6904675364494324,
1.01735520362854,
0.4469335973262787,
-0.7101739048957825,
-0.10459622740745544,
0.18729543685913086,
0.6194462776184082,
-0.48440366983413696,
-0.005900747608393431,
0.8224657773971558,
0.5689043402671814,
0.10430952161550522,
-0.653244137763977,
-0.0456693060696125,
-0.04079943150281906,
0.20521824061870575,
0.33687740564346313,
-0.6251968741416931,
0.6137092113494873,
-0.1868191957473755,
0.04709474742412567,
0.39052459597587585,
0.6451233625411987,
0.4484626352787018,
0.2872965335845947,
0.20252037048339844,
0.3384058475494385,
0.6471269726753235,
-0.06763843446969986,
1.027361273765564,
-0.3969288766384125,
0.1525280624628067,
0.6929635405540466,
-0.545701265335083,
0.6577166318893433,
0.5830858945846558,
-0.24814751744270325,
0.33329424262046814,
0.4866221845149994,
0.034396037459373474,
0.052248500287532806,
0.7886561155319214,
-0.6328547596931458,
-0.17570531368255615,
-0.2900024354457855,
-0.2610858380794525,
0.09157172590494156,
0.45083364844322205,
-0.3202425539493561,
-0.1254747062921524,
0.08949140459299088,
-0.17364758253097534,
-0.029039019718766212,
-0.3217751085758209,
0.5100853443145752,
0.22185909748077393,
-0.4312015771865845,
0.684860110282898,
0.15438826382160187,
0.6186246275901794,
-0.46183285117149353,
0.06986960023641586,
-0.1886010468006134,
0.25894272327423096,
-0.19793254137039185,
-0.34808915853500366,
0.24455000460147858,
-0.008591968566179276,
-0.08830411732196808,
-0.39088472723960876,
0.8283448219299316,
-0.05422455444931984,
-0.4771665036678314,
0.3322077691555023,
0.732732892036438,
0.14531415700912476,
0.23564238846302032,
-0.35693860054016113,
0.7505481839179993,
-0.11504004895687103,
-0.19371315836906433,
0.39087557792663574,
0.2614786624908447,
-0.0579574890434742,
0.8686431646347046,
0.5207146406173706,
0.27507704496383667,
0.23211674392223358,
0.13470147550106049,
0.9671984314918518,
-0.6268632411956787,
-0.09746649116277695,
-0.8221364617347717,
0.17400699853897095,
0.17288988828659058,
0.11739853769540787,
0.504604160785675,
0.6465988159179688,
0.5904737114906311,
0.13126911222934723,
0.6846251487731934,
0.1894574910402298,
0.18566502630710602,
-0.6689942479133606,
0.310199499130249,
-0.7957931756973267,
0.6812743544578552,
-0.11790674924850464,
-0.8341599702835083,
-0.4517252743244171,
0.2383510321378708,
-0.1990920901298523,
0.07325954735279083,
0.6141465306282043,
0.9144567847251892,
-0.015186556614935398,
0.0681963637471199,
0.20448315143585205,
0.15610173344612122,
0.6320896148681641,
0.6530824899673462,
0.945691704750061,
-0.33248573541641235,
0.33665385842323303,
0.04314908757805824,
-0.16938574612140656,
-0.35386672616004944,
-1.034473180770874,
-0.5264601707458496,
-0.1992853283882141,
-0.35203152894973755,
0.10464483499526978,
0.1362457126379013,
0.8173993229866028,
0.7254853248596191,
-0.5387833714485168,
-0.7757598161697388,
-0.4481937885284424,
0.4337306320667267,
0.0002863208355847746,
-0.14685717225074768,
0.17188364267349243,
-0.5662906169891357,
-0.7759451270103455,
0.7169515490531921,
0.5830225348472595,
0.083940289914608,
-0.5261727571487427,
-0.19036085903644562,
-0.057866163551807404,
0.12128449976444244,
0.9293460845947266,
0.37104102969169617,
-0.602131724357605,
0.037342675030231476,
0.17921182513237,
0.029458429664373398,
0.24469003081321716,
1.1384563446044922,
-0.5569342374801636,
0.19917774200439453,
0.7111819386482239,
1.1782445907592773,
0.553364634513855,
-0.14220945537090302,
0.5864298939704895,
-0.6303890943527222,
-0.022412117570638657,
0.12830927968025208,
0.35066595673561096,
0.37257465720176697,
-0.27926599979400635,
0.32689279317855835,
0.16520850360393524,
-0.6238701939582825,
-1.053391933441162,
0.4033128321170807,
-0.8761917948722839,
-0.18428151309490204,
0.9383185505867004,
-0.016741948202252388,
-0.36784178018569946,
0.04183042794466019,
-0.02444031648337841,
0.12949559092521667,
-0.132889524102211,
0.5077517628669739,
0.705963134765625,
-0.6715236902236938,
-0.20695321261882782,
-0.6754781603813171,
0.3281892240047455,
0.6003198027610779,
-1.1179606914520264,
0.4361400604248047,
0.4723488986492157,
0.061181407421827316,
0.26702553033828735,
0.4656282961368561,
-0.24642644822597504,
0.120377317070961,
-0.20159253478050232,
0.13735750317573547,
-0.2658134698867798,
-0.4434237778186798,
-0.5233014225959778,
0.20490525662899017,
0.3908688724040985,
-0.02003847435116768
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10902v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10902v1
|
Light Up the Shadows: Enhance Long-Tailed Entity Grounding with Concept-Guided Vision-Language Models
| 2024-06-16T11:49:00 | 2024-06-16T11:49:00 |
Yikai Zhang, Qianyu He, Xintao Wang, Siyu Yuan, Jiaqing Liang, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Multi-Modal Knowledge Graphs (MMKGs) have proven valuable for various
downstream tasks. However, scaling them up is challenging because building
large-scale MMKGs often introduces mismatched images (i.e., noise). Most
entities in KGs belong to the long tail, meaning there are few images of them
available online. This scarcity makes it difficult to determine whether a found
image matches the entity. To address this, we draw on the Triangle of Reference
Theory and suggest enhancing vision-language models with concept guidance.
Specifically, we introduce COG, a two-stage framework with COncept-Guided
vision-language models. The framework comprises a Concept Integration module,
which effectively identifies image-text pairs of long-tailed entities, and an
Evidence Fusion module, which offers explainability and enables human
verification. To demonstrate the effectiveness of COG, we create a dataset of
25k image-text pairs of long-tailed entities. Our comprehensive experiments
show that COG not only improves the accuracy of recognizing long-tailed
image-text pairs compared to baselines but also offers flexibility and
explainability.
|
[
-0.5390315651893616,
-0.47782760858535767,
0.6899474859237671,
0.13163600862026215,
-0.6642457246780396,
0.18542009592056274,
-0.1643294095993042,
-0.6200138330459595,
0.1413097232580185,
0.7288726568222046,
-0.43130993843078613,
-0.7443749904632568,
-0.42772823572158813,
0.029687892645597458,
-0.3906601369380951,
0.6567046642303467,
0.18556411564350128,
-0.11290483921766281,
-0.2825275957584381,
-0.2562381625175476,
-0.5124422907829285,
-0.012476563453674316,
-0.9476951956748962,
-0.5283010601997375,
0.5295482873916626,
0.33211690187454224,
1.0243480205535889,
0.7639438509941101,
0.525330662727356,
0.1560659110546112,
-0.11402930319309235,
0.3882604241371155,
-0.2241378277540207,
-0.17559914290905,
-0.30266135931015015,
-0.32628902792930603,
-0.5354422926902771,
-0.22189518809318542,
0.38167113065719604,
1.0126677751541138,
-0.32632845640182495,
-0.14565084874629974,
-0.04967000335454941,
0.9124158620834351,
-0.6466585993766785,
0.543925940990448,
-0.4361664056777954,
-0.19504773616790771,
-0.03345558047294617,
-0.09375458210706711,
-0.4753841161727905,
0.09894407540559769,
0.26748520135879517,
-1.008130669593811,
0.10879550129175186,
0.4843498170375824,
1.0929169654846191,
0.4756380319595337,
-0.6558886170387268,
-0.3999427556991577,
-0.33577847480773926,
0.6359474062919617,
-0.3685453236103058,
0.9271304607391357,
0.3514406979084015,
0.24261333048343658,
-0.25469329953193665,
-0.5953121781349182,
-0.6493457555770874,
-0.252531498670578,
-0.44794169068336487,
0.33789098262786865,
0.008035658858716488,
0.5067981481552124,
0.3006128668785095,
0.13709163665771484,
-0.29334571957588196,
-0.09287220984697342,
-0.2419096678495407,
-0.10316043347120285,
0.29113730788230896,
-0.3547382056713104,
0.15362854301929474,
-0.41879215836524963,
-0.577893853187561,
-0.17944234609603882,
-0.7401754856109619,
-0.12795376777648926,
0.2347918301820755,
0.08864869177341461,
-0.1250535398721695,
0.45904335379600525,
-0.32097190618515015,
1.120361089706421,
0.6492606401443481,
-0.31160494685173035,
-0.01572435162961483,
-0.3069721460342407,
-0.26507654786109924,
0.2110196053981781,
0.45161786675453186,
0.89659583568573,
0.17305220663547516,
-0.6041551828384399,
0.11257310956716537,
0.2111208140850067,
0.3080575466156006,
-0.8970416784286499,
-0.4167317748069763,
-0.01282360777258873,
-0.41638657450675964,
-0.3386938273906708,
-0.0740227997303009,
-0.8924366235733032,
-0.6687331795692444,
-0.49228784441947937,
0.39971745014190674,
-0.6582367420196533,
-0.6049914956092834,
0.2194110006093979,
-0.33805638551712036,
0.2006053328514099,
0.486463338136673,
-0.6576585173606873,
0.19505475461483002,
0.5522545576095581,
0.8070017695426941,
-0.26944345235824585,
-0.08748356252908707,
-0.19464834034442902,
0.6968099474906921,
-0.8304041028022766,
0.6136826276779175,
-0.4484108090400696,
-0.17884671688079834,
-0.2271076738834381,
0.01414162665605545,
0.30923905968666077,
-0.6448770761489868,
0.6124736070632935,
-0.7780734300613403,
0.08128495514392853,
-0.5717331767082214,
-0.3510301113128662,
-0.4948156177997589,
0.3549802005290985,
-0.5687816739082336,
1.0833921432495117,
0.24918058514595032,
-0.7389464378356934,
0.815686047077179,
-0.6650684475898743,
-0.4604422152042389,
0.14844878017902374,
-0.5736439824104309,
-0.4706161916255951,
0.005569376517087221,
0.3621368408203125,
0.7269500494003296,
-0.4259535074234009,
0.5212909579277039,
-0.35849693417549133,
-0.12335724383592606,
-0.41596096754074097,
0.18931664526462555,
0.6182352900505066,
0.09543688595294952,
-0.20578555762767792,
-0.043984733521938324,
-1.266489863395691,
-0.024362675845623016,
-0.06055445969104767,
-0.12228037416934967,
-0.8165923357009888,
0.24465465545654297,
-0.27446791529655457,
0.09656213968992233,
-0.16761161386966705,
-0.1028997153043747,
0.042965058237314224,
-0.11422549933195114,
0.3028331995010376,
0.3725726306438446,
0.04822039604187012,
0.6049408316612244,
0.11298661679029465,
0.17845799028873444,
0.5849823951721191,
-0.24493321776390076,
-0.5063977241516113,
-0.368241548538208,
-1.0657166242599487,
-0.3666476309299469,
0.0159563310444355,
0.1469053328037262,
-1.3632478713989258,
0.582497239112854,
-0.5710045099258423,
-0.44070613384246826,
-0.15934763848781586,
-0.026481416076421738,
0.12303180992603302,
1.0194875001907349,
0.5316246747970581,
-0.5147919058799744,
-0.43393072485923767,
-1.1112099885940552,
0.05134883522987366,
-0.33375710248947144,
-0.004797105677425861,
0.3648785948753357,
0.5009916424751282,
-0.061231937259435654,
1.146024227142334,
-0.47273847460746765,
-0.22967538237571716,
0.3108624815940857,
0.1644437462091446,
0.1357167810201645,
0.292385458946228,
0.6175475120544434,
-1.2918875217437744,
-0.21809859573841095,
0.012228432111442089,
-0.9080893993377686,
-0.018721656873822212,
-0.18920452892780304,
-0.1418895721435547,
-0.10319957882165909,
0.5304118990898132,
-0.6871128082275391,
0.1523393839597702,
0.5546275973320007,
-0.46916505694389343,
0.38041210174560547,
-0.0917382538318634,
0.3182888925075531,
-1.2519539594650269,
-0.11404085159301758,
0.3088178336620331,
-0.2878200113773346,
-0.514808177947998,
0.3712789714336395,
0.4081179201602936,
-0.2106042504310608,
-0.00635138526558876,
0.2611103951931,
-0.6696910858154297,
-0.14460712671279907,
-0.17735807597637177,
0.19487839937210083,
0.13736656308174133,
0.4249185025691986,
0.3425713777542114,
0.8157638311386108,
0.9033328294754028,
-0.9931284785270691,
0.5356224179267883,
-0.003501888131722808,
-0.3911823630332947,
1.248875617980957,
-0.40682265162467957,
0.05334976315498352,
-0.25083833932876587,
0.30478882789611816,
-0.8383122682571411,
-0.39045536518096924,
0.26872989535331726,
-0.12668056786060333,
0.4128425419330597,
-0.5667087435722351,
-0.5693790316581726,
-0.33499011397361755,
0.01717136986553669,
0.2866336405277252,
0.38455522060394287,
-0.833197295665741,
1.0163590908050537,
0.12004074454307556,
0.333147794008255,
-0.6342281699180603,
-0.6437753438949585,
0.4846358001232147,
-0.301739364862442,
-0.9468861222267151,
0.6429415345191956,
0.29750189185142517,
-0.2155691385269165,
0.10876274108886719,
-0.25110942125320435,
-0.06820978969335556,
0.047979723662137985,
0.5234739780426025,
0.09079219400882721,
-0.26697975397109985,
0.5070395469665527,
-0.19832636415958405,
-0.20365016162395477,
0.070943683385849,
-0.6761788725852966,
0.3658667206764221,
-0.047520123422145844,
-0.3881514370441437,
-0.06237887591123581,
0.10135558247566223,
0.6191616058349609,
-0.2788735628128052,
0.5887451171875,
0.7250397801399231,
-0.5920600891113281,
-0.06861931085586548,
-0.630351722240448,
0.010882895439863205,
-0.5371731519699097,
0.6275905966758728,
-0.46879956126213074,
-0.4734730124473572,
0.36509740352630615,
-0.5992743372917175,
-0.46824800968170166,
0.36614641547203064,
0.3495200276374817,
-0.10059943795204163,
0.721487283706665,
1.0462979078292847,
0.1985677033662796,
0.38274338841438293,
-0.2739499807357788,
0.4253416657447815,
-0.8017433285713196,
-0.4090576171875,
-0.05540992692112923,
0.09037952870130539,
-0.34861698746681213,
-0.5298327803611755,
0.5529325604438782,
0.7632107138633728,
0.13500121235847473,
0.25500714778900146,
-0.5671176314353943,
0.6119751930236816,
0.3228197395801544,
0.23189371824264526,
0.4595973491668701,
0.0723852664232254,
-0.22680144011974335,
-0.036516498774290085,
-0.7751007080078125,
-0.3184353709220886,
0.8316032886505127,
0.14871171116828918,
0.82501620054245,
-0.0808342918753624,
0.5220958590507507,
0.06107841804623604,
0.10496785491704941,
-0.8931609988212585,
0.5275842547416687,
-0.09419839829206467,
-0.5171278715133667,
-0.19693399965763092,
-0.2713685929775238,
-0.5544534921646118,
0.2439093291759491,
-0.2884199917316437,
-0.4995864927768707,
0.3444617986679077,
0.2748194932937622,
-0.4420206844806671,
0.2875412702560425,
-0.9111876487731934,
0.5335193276405334,
-0.27458077669143677,
-0.43740594387054443,
-0.444148987531662,
-0.47584450244903564,
0.4462999403476715,
-0.1756414771080017,
0.3757876753807068,
0.15863922238349915,
-0.10153152048587799,
0.838859498500824,
-0.2115805596113205,
0.7502598762512207,
-0.1476205587387085,
-0.3662475049495697,
0.3869721293449402,
-0.0690661072731018,
0.5547390580177307,
0.0125201977789402,
0.11817663908004761,
0.11999552696943283,
-0.18782131373882294,
-0.2524407207965851,
-0.7950150966644287,
0.46569153666496277,
-0.5101128816604614,
-0.5622783303260803,
-0.13836343586444855,
-0.480530709028244,
-0.22371460497379303,
0.4221099615097046,
0.04184266924858093,
0.1945263147354126,
0.19803716242313385,
0.4287986159324646,
0.8053955435752869,
-0.034101422876119614,
0.25877368450164795,
0.29342320561408997,
-0.4402547776699066,
-0.43667981028556824,
0.7639307975769043,
0.25066590309143066,
0.37130361795425415,
0.10559450834989548,
-0.0762740895152092,
-0.13899706304073334,
-0.5906109809875488,
-0.7439454793930054,
-0.021642539650201797,
-0.8593003153800964,
-0.24333512783050537,
-0.5778219699859619,
0.103073351085186,
-0.1506211906671524,
-0.22497007250785828,
-0.30075758695602417,
-0.19429105520248413,
-0.08338230848312378,
0.07641652226448059,
0.4485316574573517,
0.5580845475196838,
-0.029026132076978683,
0.5935020446777344,
-0.29179033637046814,
0.8393349051475525,
0.4942018985748291,
0.6914173364639282,
0.09618078172206879,
0.01594344526529312,
-0.4264640808105469,
0.10608164221048355,
-0.13101156055927277,
-1.0484555959701538,
-0.11719481647014618,
0.09821440279483795,
0.16378356516361237,
0.711948812007904,
-0.1281440705060959,
1.2116549015045166,
-0.5070807933807373,
0.6968351006507874,
0.7206466794013977,
-0.8495255708694458,
0.5072329640388489,
-0.440828412771225,
-0.10800544172525406,
0.0887652039527893,
0.28392139077186584,
-0.683221697807312,
-0.1791098564863205,
-0.5768107175827026,
-0.8335979580879211,
0.503077507019043,
0.13351233303546906,
-0.25137969851493835,
0.16213610768318176,
0.8280315399169922,
-0.1682172566652298,
0.29777073860168457,
-0.7687302827835083,
-0.2761804163455963,
-0.25212544202804565,
-0.34931471943855286,
0.14245334267616272,
-0.16237743198871613,
-0.3615221679210663,
-0.13399532437324524,
0.43192070722579956,
-0.5340163111686707,
-0.007924368605017662,
0.13594844937324524,
-0.11744560301303864,
-0.3404022753238678,
0.13078227639198303,
0.1697467416524887,
0.7730559706687927,
-0.19585929811000824,
0.4537954330444336,
0.1896999180316925,
-0.44889700412750244,
0.06467031687498093,
-0.044962525367736816,
-0.5399969220161438,
-0.06641989201307297,
0.3518192172050476,
0.7019482254981995,
0.2610134184360504,
-0.20626159012317657,
0.3989744484424591,
0.3400012254714966,
-0.041173651814460754,
-0.1821138560771942,
0.2603379189968109,
0.26800960302352905,
0.41726812720298767,
0.656277060508728,
0.2984734773635864,
-0.028716925531625748,
-0.6607497334480286,
0.20858347415924072,
0.498331755399704,
-0.3518024981021881,
-0.1723855584859848,
0.48750463128089905,
0.11862379312515259,
-0.0573626309633255,
0.28604742884635925,
-0.43747183680534363,
-0.6074293851852417,
0.6081970930099487,
0.48503464460372925,
0.4189663231372833,
0.3855845034122467,
0.04248272627592087,
0.31735917925834656,
0.4046354591846466,
-0.3996657729148865,
0.05912799388170242,
-0.10884914547204971,
-0.8103138208389282,
-0.45274612307548523,
-0.4436452388763428,
-0.30365249514579773,
0.04301183670759201,
-0.6031114459037781,
0.6801719069480896,
-0.3827798664569855,
-0.1716592013835907,
0.1830136626958847,
-0.08109566569328308,
-0.7252785563468933,
0.6351701617240906,
0.3198655843734741,
0.6749698519706726,
-0.7303385138511658,
0.8306912183761597,
0.7530264854431152,
-0.534564197063446,
-0.6915092468261719,
-0.05745561420917511,
-0.24564863741397858,
-0.9674815535545349,
0.7221516966819763,
0.12384995818138123,
-0.40082868933677673,
0.2361353039741516,
-0.7992852926254272,
-0.973758339881897,
1.4998506307601929,
0.38138866424560547,
-0.5611544847488403,
-0.43035611510276794,
0.07538384944200516,
0.4918380081653595,
-0.40626952052116394,
-0.097807876765728,
0.22939130663871765,
0.5751948356628418,
0.4556506872177124,
-0.6935107111930847,
0.18025489151477814,
0.4019763469696045,
-0.08974897116422653,
0.3517603278160095,
-0.8117110133171082,
0.6598543524742126,
-0.45300406217575073,
-0.5285022258758545,
-0.30146101117134094,
0.7213818430900574,
0.1681561917066574,
0.4198375940322876,
0.8780465126037598,
0.9607191681861877,
0.8454200029373169,
-0.2100803703069687,
0.6997342109680176,
-0.48452064394950867,
0.39890792965888977,
0.9916337728500366,
-0.16775116324424744,
0.5506861209869385,
0.7405673265457153,
-0.07896558195352554,
0.6112425923347473,
0.5615124106407166,
-0.3259856104850769,
0.7135769128799438,
-0.037804048508405685,
0.19385270774364471,
-0.6266453862190247,
-0.3651350438594818,
-0.38782253861427307,
0.24614955484867096,
0.39788898825645447,
-0.3820069134235382,
-0.4105408787727356,
-0.16297225654125214,
-0.13552367687225342,
-0.17610834538936615,
-0.5063449740409851,
0.5783069729804993,
0.15720191597938538,
-0.5547382831573486,
0.47402843832969666,
0.06502941250801086,
0.7802314162254333,
-0.5060060024261475,
-0.2669250965118408,
0.18943406641483307,
0.19820153713226318,
-0.37870973348617554,
-0.8005661368370056,
0.11663012951612473,
-0.24914877116680145,
-0.16303938627243042,
-0.19120821356773376,
1.0781209468841553,
-0.5778014063835144,
-0.5561230778694153,
0.47849878668785095,
0.56034916639328,
-0.2498561143875122,
-0.27509209513664246,
-0.4171105921268463,
-0.3801272511482239,
-0.2510034739971161,
0.13188773393630981,
0.038559991866350174,
0.730160117149353,
-0.19019654393196106,
0.8008610010147095,
0.676479697227478,
0.07102100551128387,
-0.026765527203679085,
-0.0770253986120224,
0.8444574475288391,
-0.6579005122184753,
-0.5217993855476379,
-0.8395940661430359,
0.3805766701698303,
-0.2841378450393677,
0.05589967221021652,
0.5777109861373901,
0.647781252861023,
0.9185600280761719,
0.11690744012594223,
0.48430368304252625,
-0.1737625002861023,
0.15234458446502686,
-0.7550874948501587,
0.7996860146522522,
-0.7259426712989807,
-0.018401291221380234,
-0.2717234194278717,
-0.7625272274017334,
-0.31414201855659485,
0.5545434355735779,
-0.051272377371788025,
-0.07968267798423767,
0.7113167643547058,
0.8513806462287903,
-0.3638125956058502,
-0.12231217324733734,
0.42997631430625916,
0.14570456743240356,
0.31760433316230774,
0.34532588720321655,
0.7657339572906494,
-0.46828600764274597,
0.5489038825035095,
-0.31820255517959595,
-0.018378717824816704,
0.007424592971801758,
-1.1226657629013062,
-1.0028736591339111,
-0.6118259429931641,
-0.5900129675865173,
-0.5154700875282288,
0.08127306401729584,
0.7755295634269714,
1.0845637321472168,
-0.47179538011550903,
0.02543213590979576,
-0.1480209082365036,
0.20331689715385437,
-0.12089853733778,
-0.16427797079086304,
0.566382646560669,
-0.008011954836547375,
-0.20977634191513062,
0.08234065771102905,
0.6197170615196228,
0.18984709680080414,
-0.284386545419693,
-0.2004450261592865,
0.01440336275845766,
-0.20721352100372314,
0.691652774810791,
-0.3063993752002716,
-0.9241010546684265,
-0.6082485318183899,
-0.07833968102931976,
0.010657093487679958,
0.24229726195335388,
0.7172418832778931,
-0.9381970167160034,
0.5238988995552063,
-0.10427489876747131,
0.42152726650238037,
0.4184489846229553,
-0.11349157989025116,
0.42426803708076477,
-0.8619053959846497,
0.3172254264354706,
0.03433363512158394,
0.45061224699020386,
0.5353807806968689,
-0.28989148139953613,
0.8115344643592834,
0.5653064846992493,
0.005063285585492849,
-0.6844737529754639,
0.4438853859901428,
-1.2324823141098022,
0.012876175343990326,
1.1976399421691895,
-0.020407333970069885,
-0.15987145900726318,
0.014193681068718433,
-0.1763276308774948,
0.44675499200820923,
-0.23096448183059692,
0.8783663511276245,
1.1006102561950684,
0.0527578629553318,
-0.4438339173793793,
-0.31979987025260925,
0.6845049858093262,
0.2161525934934616,
-0.8779428005218506,
0.09214521944522858,
0.5819149613380432,
0.2971010208129883,
0.6924776434898376,
0.319327712059021,
0.18870121240615845,
0.16898250579833984,
0.0396336205303669,
-0.004454330075532198,
-0.22644244134426117,
-0.36925095319747925,
-0.07569907605648041,
0.19246385991573334,
0.0010023678187280893,
-0.016062472015619278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10900v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10900v1
|
AUTOHALLUSION: Automatic Generation of Hallucination Benchmarks for Vision-Language Models
| 2024-06-16T11:44:43 | 2024-06-16T11:44:43 |
Xiyang Wu, Tianrui Guan, Dianqi Li, Shuaiyi Huang, Xiaoyu Liu, Xijun Wang, Ruiqi Xian, Abhinav Shrivastava, Furong Huang, Jordan Lee Boyd-Graber, Tianyi Zhou, Dinesh Manocha
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Large vision-language models (LVLMs) hallucinate: certain context cues in an
image may trigger the language module's overconfident and incorrect reasoning
on abnormal or hypothetical objects. Though a few benchmarks have been
developed to investigate LVLM hallucinations, they mainly rely on hand-crafted
corner cases whose fail patterns may hardly generalize, and finetuning on them
could undermine their validity. These motivate us to develop the first
automatic benchmark generation approach, AUTOHALLUSION, that harnesses a few
principal strategies to create diverse hallucination examples. It probes the
language modules in LVLMs for context cues and uses them to synthesize images
by: (1) adding objects abnormal to the context cues; (2) for two co-occurring
objects, keeping one and excluding the other; or (3) removing objects closely
tied to the context cues. It then generates image-based questions whose
ground-truth answers contradict the language module's prior. A model has to
overcome contextual biases and distractions to reach correct answers, while
incorrect or inconsistent answers indicate hallucinations. AUTOHALLUSION
enables us to create new benchmarks at the minimum cost and thus overcomes the
fragility of hand-crafted benchmarks. It also reveals common failure patterns
and reasons, providing key insights to detect, avoid, or control
hallucinations. Comprehensive evaluations of top-tier LVLMs, e.g.,
GPT-4V(ision), Gemini Pro Vision, Claude 3, and LLaVA-1.5, show a 97.7% and
98.7% success rate of hallucination induction on synthetic and real-world
datasets of AUTOHALLUSION, paving the way for a long battle against
hallucinations.
|
[
-0.6463297009468079,
-0.838066577911377,
0.4901074171066284,
0.10195881873369217,
-0.1484319567680359,
-0.38313156366348267,
0.008434787392616272,
-0.5725310444831848,
0.11692670732736588,
0.5275170207023621,
-0.4548065960407257,
-0.42116957902908325,
-0.40041160583496094,
0.11046689003705978,
-0.79826819896698,
0.3901832699775696,
-0.08538716286420822,
-0.018587583675980568,
-0.08940670639276505,
-0.1777770221233368,
-0.7231314778327942,
-0.5826795101165771,
-0.35430803894996643,
0.0028671156615018845,
0.21118947863578796,
0.13063566386699677,
0.6522924900054932,
0.7823811173439026,
0.5615879893302917,
0.3876669704914093,
0.5197157859802246,
0.20897464454174042,
-0.2970513105392456,
0.4237504005432129,
-0.06568949669599533,
-0.039142005145549774,
-0.1145915538072586,
-0.07124663889408112,
0.45030272006988525,
0.6345111727714539,
-0.3196057081222534,
0.0569426603615284,
0.008454783819615841,
0.6722337007522583,
-0.78960782289505,
-0.00020681378373410553,
-0.9642530083656311,
0.36217230558395386,
-0.0829826295375824,
-0.33932819962501526,
-0.33651724457740784,
-0.4005843698978424,
-0.08270876109600067,
-0.4008288085460663,
0.2925947904586792,
0.3077210783958435,
0.683620810508728,
0.8625625371932983,
-0.06590469926595688,
-0.3984054625034332,
-0.5208249688148499,
0.6184853911399841,
-0.255854994058609,
0.4976258873939514,
0.4431491196155548,
0.6868820190429688,
-0.2661423981189728,
-0.797275960445404,
-0.392816960811615,
-0.3053903579711914,
-0.14376631379127502,
0.003965460695326328,
-0.11883162707090378,
-0.18195214867591858,
0.33685141801834106,
0.3402979373931885,
-0.8018176555633545,
0.009840513579547405,
-0.4282999634742737,
-0.4445212185382843,
0.6992329359054565,
0.37279200553894043,
0.0932713970541954,
-0.2927388846874237,
-0.27348658442497253,
-0.2680186331272125,
-0.5808310508728027,
-0.40681150555610657,
0.015417159534990788,
-0.10481198877096176,
0.4295145273208618,
0.5427486300468445,
-0.21426770091056824,
0.8392574191093445,
0.11687968671321869,
0.12361857295036316,
0.23478281497955322,
-0.12079252302646637,
-0.48568791151046753,
0.32350149750709534,
0.6866540908813477,
0.5797868371009827,
0.2920900583267212,
-0.17235231399536133,
-0.45647236704826355,
0.2936304211616516,
0.463599294424057,
-0.6515677571296692,
-0.37528321146965027,
0.2701805531978607,
-0.6128091216087341,
-0.38841408491134644,
-0.10689624398946762,
-0.8882705569267273,
-0.5081806778907776,
-0.3394407629966736,
0.7969278693199158,
-0.39436453580856323,
-0.004264699295163155,
0.03251347690820694,
0.0001826542429625988,
0.3846803903579712,
0.14290876686573029,
-0.7601855397224426,
0.46414604783058167,
0.3415209650993347,
0.6191065311431885,
-0.6254022121429443,
-0.5992757081985474,
-0.7360078692436218,
0.018152611330151558,
-0.5249934196472168,
1.0119256973266602,
-0.24570025503635406,
-0.33461233973503113,
0.12569409608840942,
0.18452227115631104,
0.09950659424066544,
-1.0506184101104736,
0.33477306365966797,
-0.05812572315335274,
0.2866366505622864,
-0.31630590558052063,
-0.6735300421714783,
-0.0948050394654274,
0.09384085237979889,
-0.6314306259155273,
1.1458302736282349,
0.14355996251106262,
-0.2087600827217102,
0.6082178354263306,
-0.38333195447921753,
-0.2768888771533966,
0.22364024817943573,
-0.6341005563735962,
-0.2895768880844116,
0.27224650979042053,
0.20189252495765686,
0.5259302258491516,
-0.28856298327445984,
0.4389522671699524,
0.0038856740575283766,
-0.4398229718208313,
0.13951128721237183,
-0.36862054467201233,
0.5894919037818909,
0.32982486486434937,
-0.7799142599105835,
0.13640032708644867,
-0.7278990149497986,
-0.09363020211458206,
0.3833315968513489,
0.27693766355514526,
-0.343266099691391,
0.06705904006958008,
0.02096555195748806,
0.15671049058437347,
-0.04556398466229439,
-0.19744621217250824,
-0.09028400480747223,
-0.2722856104373932,
-0.005541033111512661,
0.7025693655014038,
0.04402938857674599,
-0.08379988372325897,
-0.43248316645622253,
0.1855463832616806,
0.08520147949457169,
0.4782853126525879,
-0.22255872189998627,
-0.525400698184967,
-0.7708591818809509,
-0.017910515889525414,
-0.18302370607852936,
0.5171717405319214,
-0.6953443288803101,
0.7229158282279968,
0.3026183843612671,
-0.37064749002456665,
-0.5211453437805176,
0.11777325719594955,
0.35051682591438293,
0.6651846766471863,
0.5190138816833496,
-0.5953324437141418,
-0.7092674374580383,
-1.2047274112701416,
-0.2258351445198059,
-0.010528738610446453,
0.1692734956741333,
0.16179180145263672,
0.5165351629257202,
-0.21057987213134766,
0.5984592437744141,
-0.4974263906478882,
-0.6220446825027466,
0.2738596796989441,
0.24325254559516907,
-0.15264646708965302,
0.43405693769454956,
0.6823107600212097,
-0.6868977546691895,
-0.43031978607177734,
-0.3241673409938812,
-1.0574556589126587,
-0.24612872302532196,
-0.13543815910816193,
-0.12577025592327118,
0.6537785530090332,
0.7194627523422241,
-0.35223454236984253,
0.6261599659919739,
0.40568092465400696,
-0.35340607166290283,
0.781514585018158,
-0.21694283187389374,
0.2284531593322754,
-0.7373417615890503,
-0.02707439474761486,
-0.09391374886035919,
-0.1062341257929802,
-0.5709185600280762,
-0.04659183323383331,
-0.1620519906282425,
0.178193598985672,
-0.31783759593963623,
0.6123471856117249,
-0.4685722887516022,
-0.3491498827934265,
-0.3105430603027344,
0.20707355439662933,
-0.180582657456398,
0.33777904510498047,
0.17183488607406616,
0.5515910387039185,
0.6357564926147461,
-0.5289608836174011,
0.5852130651473999,
0.02888910286128521,
-0.6311145424842834,
0.6151421070098877,
-0.4388662576675415,
-0.030145347118377686,
-0.04809965565800667,
-0.12440546602010727,
-1.0820952653884888,
-0.41654500365257263,
0.3780919015407562,
-0.18315143883228302,
0.11052359640598297,
0.3401564061641693,
-0.41939499974250793,
-0.3762057423591614,
0.05498943850398064,
0.4370215833187103,
0.8188549876213074,
-0.6043220162391663,
0.48866337537765503,
0.5415133237838745,
0.17496246099472046,
-0.5559345483779907,
-0.6660446524620056,
0.25993382930755615,
-0.10439518839120865,
-0.2424607127904892,
0.3222859501838684,
-0.266478955745697,
-0.5401855111122131,
0.0535409115254879,
0.005853496957570314,
0.05297137424349785,
-0.08161429315805435,
0.331779807806015,
0.18875600397586823,
-0.058072786778211594,
0.14765803515911102,
-0.17433467507362366,
-0.17596358060836792,
0.28791263699531555,
-0.21861349046230316,
0.7354156374931335,
-0.192705437541008,
-0.7373802661895752,
-0.48602887988090515,
0.3901820778846741,
0.5640420913696289,
0.250009685754776,
0.3780811131000519,
0.6172460317611694,
-0.6561773419380188,
-0.2923957407474518,
-1.0771838426589966,
-0.46289798617362976,
-0.4809238612651825,
0.3016010522842407,
-0.5117764472961426,
-0.3049054741859436,
0.4620744287967682,
0.2678956687450409,
-0.04891745001077652,
0.5697160959243774,
0.8221697211265564,
0.13874877989292145,
1.065773606300354,
0.24469102919101715,
0.0740603357553482,
0.1760852038860321,
-0.05071102827787399,
-0.03162270784378052,
-0.4291642904281616,
-0.3486391305923462,
-0.2394663244485855,
-0.10297349840402603,
-0.5400295257568359,
-0.5293012261390686,
0.2810620069503784,
-0.31064268946647644,
-0.01251987088471651,
0.19274045526981354,
-1.0513383150100708,
0.5745174884796143,
0.48055654764175415,
-0.1840527057647705,
0.19152359664440155,
0.12641137838363647,
-0.21290291845798492,
-0.15416450798511505,
-0.5286075472831726,
-0.2873626947402954,
0.9346795678138733,
0.13907663524150848,
0.6624898910522461,
-0.24690714478492737,
0.7431786060333252,
0.4635821580886841,
0.3243158459663391,
-0.6643035411834717,
0.7231603264808655,
-0.03298889845609665,
-0.654296338558197,
-0.33045053482055664,
-0.1573641449213028,
-0.7104672193527222,
0.3007872700691223,
-0.1261236071586609,
-0.7353239059448242,
0.43940940499305725,
0.31504812836647034,
-0.30220475792884827,
0.05769704282283783,
-0.4601541757583618,
0.8729978799819946,
-0.32504817843437195,
-0.4787389934062958,
-0.13994139432907104,
-0.5285792946815491,
0.5689233541488647,
-0.30211684107780457,
0.07013490796089172,
0.05804336443543434,
0.14663496613502502,
0.6442898511886597,
-0.2854301333427429,
0.7528340220451355,
-0.33527156710624695,
-0.17739138007164001,
0.288966566324234,
0.39002200961112976,
0.5668789744377136,
-0.3215230107307434,
0.046228792518377304,
0.12822163105010986,
0.05668257549405098,
-0.0662941187620163,
-0.548252284526825,
0.6807366609573364,
-0.4887616038322449,
-0.593990683555603,
-0.42059317231178284,
-0.5758508443832397,
-0.10667498409748077,
-0.01908268965780735,
0.49990978837013245,
0.48559749126434326,
-0.3366846740245819,
0.13726961612701416,
0.6588961482048035,
-0.34350883960723877,
0.4007605314254761,
0.1883135735988617,
-0.6445007920265198,
-0.5186005234718323,
0.9238428473472595,
0.16800040006637573,
0.12200070917606354,
-0.1397865116596222,
0.06201807036995888,
-0.3009865880012512,
-0.5902902483940125,
-0.3202678859233856,
0.1663873791694641,
-1.0457764863967896,
-0.10004725307226181,
-0.6777908802032471,
-0.44455981254577637,
-0.3812340199947357,
-0.18231253325939178,
-0.49005579948425293,
-0.29764410853385925,
0.15092764794826508,
0.20865720510482788,
0.08603592962026596,
0.7001915574073792,
-0.25141048431396484,
-0.21150316298007965,
-0.36785879731178284,
0.5658036470413208,
0.591579258441925,
0.23160822689533234,
0.06288319081068039,
-0.42531582713127136,
-0.09052888303995132,
-0.34083887934684753,
-0.10681669414043427,
-0.7788485288619995,
0.6198115348815918,
0.003884176490828395,
0.9167863130569458,
0.5042330622673035,
0.01968756504356861,
0.8921279311180115,
-0.518709123134613,
0.7249110341072083,
0.24150823056697845,
-0.8593726754188538,
0.574351966381073,
-0.002648241352289915,
0.058388810604810715,
0.6142540574073792,
0.3194475769996643,
-0.524733304977417,
-0.6027905941009521,
-0.4743763208389282,
-0.6632851362228394,
0.3228490948677063,
0.3517414331436157,
-0.3169904053211212,
-0.19390341639518738,
0.3831215798854828,
0.41121378540992737,
0.09894247353076935,
-0.7066486477851868,
-0.33856865763664246,
-0.455163836479187,
-0.27690500020980835,
-0.1562337875366211,
-0.26194703578948975,
-0.36207354068756104,
-0.586090087890625,
0.4862881600856781,
-0.11782477051019669,
0.37637874484062195,
0.40424227714538574,
-0.47691646218299866,
-0.35163503885269165,
-0.3847227394580841,
0.9140313863754272,
0.6653122305870056,
-0.36488956212997437,
0.2841998338699341,
0.31903886795043945,
-0.47250303626060486,
0.18253561854362488,
0.02120562084019184,
-0.07375241816043854,
0.2120969593524933,
0.18205079436302185,
0.7676376104354858,
-0.054598186165094376,
-0.7335695028305054,
0.38750872015953064,
-0.14497603476047516,
-0.42359599471092224,
-0.6949383020401001,
0.24639295041561127,
-0.3937079906463623,
0.21499429643154144,
0.6431571245193481,
-0.1648726761341095,
0.29758161306381226,
-0.6129125356674194,
0.5288633704185486,
0.5331642031669617,
-0.4208090603351593,
-0.03243338689208031,
0.7249548435211182,
-0.12506313621997833,
-0.4307945668697357,
0.4423835277557373,
-0.16229863464832306,
-0.3801478445529938,
0.6463580131530762,
0.4912196099758148,
1.2136746644973755,
-0.44094693660736084,
-0.0035977254156023264,
0.5512977242469788,
0.4281257092952728,
-0.1886826604604721,
0.1637371927499771,
-0.03753242269158363,
-0.6212319135665894,
-0.07963672280311584,
-0.7673516273498535,
-0.2266528457403183,
0.3753455579280853,
-0.6399953961372375,
0.179959237575531,
-0.25744393467903137,
-0.018461374565958977,
-0.1061563715338707,
-0.21987289190292358,
-0.5961875915527344,
0.37359538674354553,
0.42273831367492676,
0.7983887195587158,
-0.8533352017402649,
0.8373594284057617,
0.21143341064453125,
-0.28286853432655334,
-0.22381407022476196,
0.13733094930648804,
0.11749788373708725,
-0.9560611844062805,
0.79119873046875,
0.28142574429512024,
-0.2386612743139267,
0.015635080635547638,
-0.42705950140953064,
-0.7807473540306091,
0.9655875563621521,
-0.07201599329710007,
-0.6639198064804077,
0.05171479284763336,
0.15870967507362366,
0.35476404428482056,
-0.8425207138061523,
-0.048895277082920074,
0.7256839871406555,
0.6201527714729309,
0.15580584108829498,
-0.7786637544631958,
0.5430690050125122,
-0.1631884127855301,
0.020309966057538986,
0.11121828854084015,
-0.4062020778656006,
0.6233600974082947,
-0.031204096972942352,
-0.08361082524061203,
0.1394386738538742,
0.33976706862449646,
0.28450310230255127,
0.3147467374801636,
0.7399113178253174,
0.4919062852859497,
0.6445034146308899,
-0.1406673938035965,
0.8690105080604553,
-0.5907859206199646,
-0.02608143724501133,
1.0619213581085205,
-0.4056791365146637,
0.734416127204895,
0.6379824280738831,
0.24762848019599915,
0.38076820969581604,
0.603088915348053,
-0.49647217988967896,
0.7985169291496277,
0.19721883535385132,
0.01542049739509821,
-0.26275068521499634,
0.09790131449699402,
-0.5721902251243591,
0.6036313772201538,
0.4502759277820587,
-0.45391136407852173,
-0.05727235600352287,
0.23221895098686218,
-0.555817723274231,
-0.1317479908466339,
0.018675608560442924,
0.8734352588653564,
0.04175141826272011,
-1.049938678741455,
1.0356411933898926,
-0.48634210228919983,
0.3325706422328949,
-0.28588640689849854,
-0.06928615272045135,
-0.3275011479854584,
0.13606815040111542,
0.0065954518504440784,
-0.44112449884414673,
0.5761266946792603,
-0.20540708303451538,
0.16680742800235748,
-0.08495119214057922,
0.72262042760849,
-0.35298076272010803,
-0.3692224621772766,
0.37366414070129395,
0.49637457728385925,
0.624801754951477,
-0.01637827418744564,
-0.7257109880447388,
0.33360162377357483,
-0.1887587010860443,
-0.27373507618904114,
0.1443815529346466,
0.3188369572162628,
0.03789300099015236,
0.5416039228439331,
0.3283730745315552,
0.10858561843633652,
0.07081499695777893,
0.23072022199630737,
0.6292569041252136,
-1.0098007917404175,
-0.08661509305238724,
-0.9120715856552124,
0.36967733502388,
-0.3063007593154907,
-0.2069724053144455,
0.6244969367980957,
0.5940454006195068,
0.5920303463935852,
-0.09029608964920044,
0.6928842067718506,
0.05962922051548958,
0.14690625667572021,
-0.5953946709632874,
0.885395348072052,
-0.8924273252487183,
-0.03797435015439987,
-0.24813242256641388,
-1.100374460220337,
-0.42487087845802307,
0.840114414691925,
-0.11519123613834381,
0.0941799059510231,
1.0478706359863281,
1.0314137935638428,
0.10919725149869919,
-0.22066925466060638,
0.7392349243164062,
0.3715064525604248,
-0.010064356960356236,
0.5931692123413086,
1.003184199333191,
-0.5410662889480591,
0.5270029306411743,
-0.41621261835098267,
-0.1603843867778778,
-0.5796398520469666,
-0.8696357607841492,
-0.9299507737159729,
-0.9643645286560059,
-0.4948433041572571,
-0.3525030016899109,
0.21896111965179443,
0.8516886830329895,
0.7139583230018616,
-0.9505122900009155,
-0.3913266062736511,
-0.31992653012275696,
-0.16419924795627594,
-0.2889757752418518,
-0.2250787615776062,
0.4040040373802185,
-0.599309504032135,
-0.5832617282867432,
0.35961124300956726,
0.5304672122001648,
0.27797436714172363,
-0.8548069596290588,
-0.11821457743644714,
0.12875857949256897,
0.16509756445884705,
0.6213053464889526,
0.19323314726352692,
-1.0732306241989136,
-0.25419503450393677,
0.0004895154270343482,
-0.2571845054626465,
0.21878141164779663,
0.5666302442550659,
-0.941737174987793,
0.5433551073074341,
0.22475750744342804,
0.3041267991065979,
0.4102594256401062,
-0.23051047325134277,
0.5297747254371643,
-0.25592830777168274,
0.3097095489501953,
0.1545669138431549,
0.33618664741516113,
0.3088545799255371,
-0.32161402702331543,
0.5143397450447083,
0.43555572628974915,
-0.6149266362190247,
-1.2617332935333252,
0.17667053639888763,
-0.7224270105361938,
-0.5370105504989624,
0.9510217308998108,
0.527877688407898,
-0.4454434812068939,
-0.292230486869812,
-0.20501165091991425,
0.10430873185396194,
0.11086653918027878,
1.515738844871521,
0.6615447402000427,
-0.1620044708251953,
-0.21023735404014587,
-0.756584644317627,
1.0065618753433228,
0.4792459011077881,
-0.9104692339897156,
0.16673734784126282,
0.6891002058982849,
-0.04932747036218643,
0.22659887373447418,
0.4170277714729309,
-0.08580475300550461,
0.5598595142364502,
0.3014287054538727,
0.23344464600086212,
-0.04393957555294037,
-0.5463381409645081,
-0.256507009267807,
0.35431817173957825,
-0.11852582544088364,
-0.11651746928691864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12931v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12931v1
|
Automatic Speech Recognition for Biomedical Data in Bengali Language
| 2024-06-16T10:49:21 | 2024-06-16T10:49:21 |
Shariar Kabir, Nazmun Nahar, Shyamasree Saha, Mamunur Rashid
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
This paper presents the development of a prototype Automatic Speech
Recognition (ASR) system specifically designed for Bengali biomedical data.
Recent advancements in Bengali ASR are encouraging, but a lack of
domain-specific data limits the creation of practical healthcare ASR models.
This project bridges this gap by developing an ASR system tailored for Bengali
medical terms like symptoms, severity levels, and diseases, encompassing two
major dialects: Bengali and Sylheti. We train and evaluate two popular ASR
frameworks on a comprehensive 46-hour Bengali medical corpus. Our core
objective is to create deployable health-domain ASR systems for digital health
applications, ultimately increasing accessibility for non-technical users in
the healthcare sector.
|
[
0.28191542625427246,
-0.19014957547187805,
0.08934638649225235,
0.3338836133480072,
-0.21913498640060425,
0.18964515626430511,
0.1401062309741974,
-0.8048279285430908,
0.4787653386592865,
0.4006967842578888,
-0.09198111295700073,
-0.36658135056495667,
-0.578079879283905,
0.3212728202342987,
-0.46602776646614075,
0.8730099201202393,
0.14052815735340118,
0.5889825820922852,
0.22478385269641876,
-0.3039654791355133,
-0.30332303047180176,
-0.646257221698761,
-0.7956085205078125,
-0.45944374799728394,
0.40060946345329285,
-0.03535590320825577,
0.24778853356838226,
0.7352494597434998,
0.5513962507247925,
0.26099446415901184,
-0.12230312079191208,
0.038515228778123856,
0.24095264077186584,
0.20457518100738525,
-0.05078756809234619,
-0.14308886229991913,
-0.449236124753952,
-0.5113885402679443,
0.7541667819023132,
0.7719775438308716,
-0.06653839349746704,
0.28577980399131775,
-0.19991371035575867,
0.7982938885688782,
-0.45938053727149963,
0.5201877355575562,
-0.2035934180021286,
0.05401436984539032,
-0.4389456808567047,
-0.2290991246700287,
-0.007351483218371868,
-0.3668386936187744,
0.2843644618988037,
-0.3659237325191498,
-0.04261479899287224,
0.09513507038354874,
0.6030747890472412,
0.2929157316684723,
-0.421332448720932,
-0.6488133668899536,
-0.6070325970649719,
0.31144365668296814,
-0.6515908241271973,
0.4848341643810272,
0.6111614108085632,
0.6450225710868835,
0.3199007511138916,
-0.7240402102470398,
-0.16758441925048828,
-0.02920663356781006,
-0.15923726558685303,
0.16899509727954865,
-0.3357699513435364,
0.039545491337776184,
-0.03629551827907562,
0.2069537192583084,
-1.040332317352295,
-0.16955570876598358,
-0.9487589001655579,
-0.414457768201828,
0.7865496277809143,
0.3204355835914612,
0.18745744228363037,
-0.41685453057289124,
0.1703706979751587,
0.46830156445503235,
-0.5603780150413513,
0.1100812703371048,
0.08868854492902756,
0.5133311748504639,
-0.25143423676490784,
0.6042596697807312,
-0.25191712379455566,
0.9200491905212402,
-0.05878131091594696,
-0.10350460559129715,
0.5407218933105469,
-0.25747427344322205,
-0.34303468465805054,
0.5994847416877747,
0.5080158114433289,
-0.038628846406936646,
0.07169198244810104,
0.012715254910290241,
-0.3391672968864441,
0.36065322160720825,
0.3440341651439667,
-0.5461443662643433,
-0.4897194802761078,
0.29554083943367004,
-0.7537932395935059,
0.09158679842948914,
-0.2961024343967438,
-0.4781484603881836,
-0.6225300431251526,
-0.33644217252731323,
0.35249844193458557,
-0.5803166031837463,
-0.2723485231399536,
0.3188299238681793,
-0.27951210737228394,
0.2503555119037628,
0.00697324937209487,
-0.7215191125869751,
0.4530494213104248,
0.3213748037815094,
0.8068268895149231,
-0.04696548730134964,
0.25181806087493896,
-0.3192835748195648,
0.4292125105857849,
-0.1926424354314804,
0.9034845232963562,
-0.5183660387992859,
-0.6751594543457031,
0.18839743733406067,
0.014775929972529411,
-0.13243459165096283,
-0.9683606028556824,
0.3230029046535492,
-0.32665786147117615,
-0.30089685320854187,
0.281929612159729,
-0.5027840733528137,
0.010526829399168491,
-0.10977697372436523,
-0.29736366868019104,
0.28806471824645996,
0.0505036897957325,
-0.6302456259727478,
0.29787373542785645,
-0.9785536527633667,
-0.9415656924247742,
0.4701118469238281,
-0.37636834383010864,
-0.413071870803833,
-0.1741063892841339,
-0.03770880401134491,
0.2931544780731201,
-0.3032855689525604,
0.20365659892559052,
0.1317296028137207,
-0.364788293838501,
0.4289568364620209,
-0.17302201688289642,
0.9740955233573914,
0.5120817422866821,
-0.1019587591290474,
0.24804577231407166,
-1.257779598236084,
0.1589382290840149,
-0.05751952528953552,
-0.5330338478088379,
-0.41541919112205505,
0.1772780418395996,
0.6376044154167175,
-0.23003269731998444,
0.18786461651325226,
-0.6028228998184204,
0.04393189027905464,
-0.7560506463050842,
0.642983078956604,
0.3355029821395874,
-0.017185980454087257,
0.18284420669078827,
-0.43148717284202576,
0.5066003799438477,
-0.09075961261987686,
0.05070085823535919,
0.18384484946727753,
-0.5623905658721924,
-0.5699598789215088,
-0.5388599634170532,
0.3663981556892395,
0.7255302667617798,
-0.5280753970146179,
0.5455850958824158,
-0.17768865823745728,
-0.29577621817588806,
-1.0675153732299805,
-0.20338591933250427,
0.6957492232322693,
0.49750760197639465,
0.4496838450431824,
-0.08840655535459518,
-1.0004538297653198,
-0.9184885621070862,
-0.028998589143157005,
-0.3765246570110321,
-0.19518831372261047,
0.34871309995651245,
0.2936762869358063,
-0.7488927245140076,
0.8532153964042664,
-0.33006319403648376,
-0.3639373183250427,
-0.21089909970760345,
0.01071629673242569,
0.31073087453842163,
0.6659708619117737,
0.45344361662864685,
-1.1089359521865845,
-0.6395347714424133,
0.07469689846038818,
-0.6711666584014893,
-0.6004192233085632,
0.4783448576927185,
0.4358324706554413,
0.42438340187072754,
0.3319079279899597,
-0.19569295644760132,
0.6547355055809021,
0.6312699317932129,
-0.3601338565349579,
0.5042169690132141,
-0.1230270266532898,
0.2230166345834732,
-1.1479911804199219,
0.44736194610595703,
-0.18447202444076538,
-0.22707442939281464,
-0.8227213621139526,
-0.4029373526573181,
0.0051730927079916,
-0.4950443506240845,
-0.25212520360946655,
0.8854203224182129,
-0.4096027910709381,
0.001786086126230657,
-0.2601187229156494,
-0.5739846229553223,
-0.1310315877199173,
-0.2106081247329712,
0.33047807216644287,
0.573655366897583,
0.738228440284729,
-0.6812698245048523,
0.22459030151367188,
0.5130386352539062,
-0.28718236088752747,
0.72230464220047,
-0.9453569650650024,
-0.29286378622055054,
0.15618886053562164,
0.05726435407996178,
-0.6915748715400696,
-0.4792579412460327,
0.25219810009002686,
-0.8989866375923157,
0.5147927403450012,
-0.09624725580215454,
-0.1376093029975891,
-0.5958775281906128,
0.24314722418785095,
0.44705983996391296,
0.6835247874259949,
-0.18307548761367798,
0.3166700601577759,
0.9395245909690857,
-0.5154564380645752,
-0.2593372166156769,
-0.9894267916679382,
-0.016861846670508385,
-0.21040888130664825,
-0.25068923830986023,
0.26779723167419434,
0.00002257535743410699,
-0.25778859853744507,
-0.17511433362960815,
-0.30282899737358093,
-0.6526509523391724,
-0.3596670925617218,
0.6251737475395203,
0.1440954953432083,
-0.05213099718093872,
0.2079053670167923,
0.11129219830036163,
-0.29650595784187317,
-0.18739068508148193,
-0.36326539516448975,
0.45597824454307556,
0.005155667662620544,
-0.3746088445186615,
-0.7261829972267151,
0.7945050001144409,
0.4013475179672241,
-0.1111348420381546,
0.25938138365745544,
0.3713013827800751,
-0.7401131391525269,
0.2613026797771454,
-0.5368754267692566,
0.09793005883693695,
-0.5036429762840271,
0.26562562584877014,
-0.45546621084213257,
-0.7614576816558838,
0.6092098355293274,
0.1835624724626541,
-0.55348140001297,
0.18574181199073792,
0.674666166305542,
-0.33650025725364685,
0.9397101402282715,
0.5343842506408691,
-0.20379702746868134,
0.07942988723516464,
-0.09490127116441727,
0.17942304909229279,
-0.6886959075927734,
-0.25962528586387634,
-0.6953103542327881,
-0.018928807228803635,
-0.6832603216171265,
-0.05020742490887642,
0.7234712243080139,
-0.2651059329509735,
-0.4765254557132721,
0.22499994933605194,
-0.7616068124771118,
-0.101142019033432,
0.5216598510742188,
0.2291172444820404,
0.08657823503017426,
-0.12933595478534698,
0.10361000150442123,
-0.10785894840955734,
-0.7000998854637146,
-0.4287434220314026,
0.694543719291687,
0.12389157712459564,
0.8867802619934082,
0.05727771669626236,
0.6799032092094421,
0.5356233716011047,
-0.0001957032218342647,
-0.7815019488334656,
0.26135915517807007,
-0.5244397521018982,
-0.7527992129325867,
-0.13360437750816345,
-0.2529132068157196,
-1.162702202796936,
-0.5367101430892944,
0.11837964504957199,
-0.610954225063324,
0.4101496636867523,
0.28582265973091125,
-0.5438829064369202,
-0.13167129456996918,
-0.658358633518219,
0.6151759624481201,
-0.030000699684023857,
0.33040884137153625,
-0.07364881038665771,
-1.1921287775039673,
-0.23307892680168152,
-0.1379871815443039,
0.24431177973747253,
0.06900089979171753,
0.08432633429765701,
0.9615125060081482,
-0.3233647346496582,
0.8996837735176086,
-0.37882012128829956,
0.38768190145492554,
0.14379124343395233,
-0.21169757843017578,
-0.22205056250095367,
0.0321727991104126,
-0.19611071050167084,
0.4886828064918518,
0.29378706216812134,
-0.4474216401576996,
-0.2722834646701813,
0.2288803607225418,
-0.5448664426803589,
-0.15431098639965057,
-0.5991185903549194,
-0.44727766513824463,
-0.4851965606212616,
0.21915262937545776,
0.3353113532066345,
0.7033993601799011,
-0.06731317937374115,
0.07184652239084244,
0.39743033051490784,
-0.505908191204071,
0.2563330829143524,
0.8154782652854919,
0.1190740168094635,
-0.6362698674201965,
1.0812311172485352,
0.3253697156906128,
-0.024777458980679512,
0.45881858468055725,
0.2458994835615158,
-0.3785555362701416,
-0.7676287293434143,
-0.46163374185562134,
0.18692393600940704,
-0.2934321463108063,
-0.4463649094104767,
-0.6834083199501038,
-0.798521101474762,
-0.9277901649475098,
-0.3934676945209503,
-0.08868569135665894,
-0.34278604388237,
-0.2940681278705597,
0.305614173412323,
0.49425822496414185,
0.8914204835891724,
-0.28499898314476013,
0.23635637760162354,
-1.0270631313323975,
0.39607319235801697,
0.11823523789644241,
0.2932957708835602,
-0.5837051272392273,
-0.6773561835289001,
-0.37831854820251465,
-0.06096447631716728,
0.12811315059661865,
-0.8622286915779114,
0.7941539287567139,
0.4475005865097046,
0.36246851086616516,
0.4737371504306793,
-0.05778132751584053,
0.735160231590271,
-0.9388973712921143,
0.7960871458053589,
0.31616806983947754,
-0.952134907245636,
0.9799472689628601,
-0.33452269434928894,
0.15648330748081207,
0.3315109312534332,
0.4952463209629059,
-0.45046499371528625,
-0.23868435621261597,
-0.29639387130737305,
-0.7208361625671387,
0.2880353629589081,
-0.14443901181221008,
-0.2734432816505432,
0.11086510121822357,
0.3349548280239105,
0.22049550712108612,
0.3252545893192291,
-0.24094244837760925,
-0.2846050262451172,
-0.27166947722435,
-0.5318186283111572,
-0.18342578411102295,
-0.14710047841072083,
-0.21536782383918762,
-0.583895206451416,
0.45798787474632263,
-0.12490769475698471,
0.6224344372749329,
0.27681952714920044,
0.04584691673517227,
0.12382256239652634,
0.3270646035671234,
0.38210007548332214,
0.2959045469760895,
-0.11026782542467117,
-0.13565613329410553,
-0.19652147591114044,
-0.7567850947380066,
0.44470715522766113,
0.5522325038909912,
-0.09418486803770065,
0.17746508121490479,
0.4052554666996002,
0.6818318367004395,
0.059552717953920364,
-0.969982922077179,
0.4000299870967865,
0.2364589273929596,
-0.054960884153842926,
-0.566920816898346,
-0.04428580403327942,
0.08812683075666428,
0.4889388978481293,
0.4313600957393646,
-0.01189849991351366,
0.5916576981544495,
-0.3926667273044586,
0.43984392285346985,
0.1979844719171524,
-0.4405098855495453,
-0.35889774560928345,
0.7198125123977661,
0.10476479679346085,
-0.6764529943466187,
0.4103793203830719,
-0.034246038645505905,
-0.41929569840431213,
0.5013719201087952,
0.8689061403274536,
0.6410887241363525,
-0.6247958540916443,
0.02442866936326027,
0.11112525314092636,
-0.14280857145786285,
0.12818770110607147,
0.7263079881668091,
0.04590389132499695,
-0.5134307742118835,
-0.18348336219787598,
-1.0102850198745728,
-0.37914612889289856,
-0.11547673493623734,
-0.972170889377594,
0.30137354135513306,
-0.24521386623382568,
-0.3494102358818054,
0.2847597301006317,
-0.027557341381907463,
-0.230476975440979,
0.5878928899765015,
0.07845757156610489,
0.7258992195129395,
-0.7120391726493835,
1.0484211444854736,
1.117529034614563,
-0.34720057249069214,
-0.501369297504425,
-0.1435064673423767,
0.21981433033943176,
-0.9947222471237183,
0.9702740907669067,
-0.005549255292862654,
-0.06759261339902878,
0.08911548554897308,
-0.18248194456100464,
-0.6302648186683655,
0.8303409218788147,
0.20115360617637634,
-0.6162695288658142,
-0.2153880000114441,
0.13788862526416779,
0.7682426571846008,
-0.26038503646850586,
-0.13674776256084442,
0.5009129643440247,
0.45122888684272766,
-0.0009758570231497288,
-1.5116589069366455,
-0.3725212514400482,
-0.7217842936515808,
-0.054105181246995926,
-0.11029531061649323,
-0.37721672654151917,
0.5112661719322205,
-0.10741838812828064,
-0.06941281259059906,
0.3052299916744232,
0.37903741002082825,
0.22932319343090057,
0.6251521706581116,
0.2236287146806717,
0.21166053414344788,
0.6581759452819824,
0.11950696259737015,
0.8959004282951355,
-0.3144031763076782,
-0.12332887202501297,
0.8250238299369812,
-0.6032773852348328,
0.7454499006271362,
0.1878228634595871,
-0.32848796248435974,
0.20935970544815063,
0.642959475517273,
0.3237413465976715,
0.6162896752357483,
0.3494180738925934,
-0.5447914600372314,
0.20290936529636383,
-0.3414367139339447,
-0.5940038561820984,
0.7222421765327454,
0.770282506942749,
-0.15100683271884918,
0.24403145909309387,
0.41871047019958496,
-0.3960006535053253,
0.09362675249576569,
-0.4890833795070648,
0.8401846885681152,
0.06410473585128784,
0.21624994277954102,
0.6489300727844238,
-0.4542073607444763,
0.7797660827636719,
-0.9068076610565186,
0.062436167150735855,
0.2698223292827606,
0.1902451515197754,
-0.27145761251449585,
-0.3756946623325348,
0.9613586068153381,
0.06928209215402603,
-0.5135732293128967,
-0.07251068204641342,
0.8388152122497559,
-0.4986307621002197,
-0.5319738984107971,
0.36954763531684875,
0.25823667645454407,
0.42131540179252625,
0.21848523616790771,
-0.5693793296813965,
0.26206421852111816,
-0.21811187267303467,
0.19258743524551392,
0.25838327407836914,
0.05785777047276497,
0.08019497245550156,
0.8000529408454895,
0.3277450501918793,
0.9187531471252441,
-0.06634741276502609,
-0.04416293650865555,
0.5805419087409973,
-0.6821081638336182,
-0.642983615398407,
-0.4575260579586029,
0.36937883496284485,
-0.023074669763445854,
-0.03422147035598755,
0.37108340859413147,
0.689932107925415,
0.437054842710495,
-0.2545546591281891,
1.1077090501785278,
-0.2999856472015381,
1.1326608657836914,
-0.23783984780311584,
1.2852082252502441,
-0.645957887172699,
-0.24028396606445312,
-0.10656624287366867,
-0.22523197531700134,
-0.7689945697784424,
0.9201399087905884,
0.02561241015791893,
-0.14210492372512817,
0.5390380620956421,
0.7709202170372009,
0.23925550282001495,
-0.06374131143093109,
0.4824298620223999,
0.268402099609375,
0.22335107624530792,
0.418076753616333,
0.47424405813217163,
-0.35599517822265625,
0.08437822759151459,
0.18978126347064972,
-0.3032989501953125,
-0.22641320526599884,
-0.35390108823776245,
-0.5008795261383057,
-0.9370206594467163,
-0.3153805434703827,
-0.3692144453525543,
0.7235319018363953,
1.0140358209609985,
0.9331740140914917,
-1.2476047277450562,
-0.38769984245300293,
0.2480892390012741,
-0.4377095103263855,
-0.2333793193101883,
-0.2630229592323303,
0.5230357646942139,
0.0646275207400322,
-0.545031726360321,
0.6871217489242554,
0.48645731806755066,
0.18568721413612366,
0.044210419058799744,
-0.13649608194828033,
-0.04846556857228279,
0.11742422729730606,
0.4334607422351837,
0.7268076539039612,
-0.44867998361587524,
-0.3090452551841736,
-0.09674243628978729,
-0.2191239446401596,
0.02843378484249115,
0.8687386512756348,
-0.7106223106384277,
0.5264126658439636,
0.40800485014915466,
0.7802278995513916,
0.13107328116893768,
-0.17230410873889923,
0.387686163187027,
-0.4151512384414673,
0.2904088497161865,
0.7693045735359192,
0.32253071665763855,
0.44193705916404724,
-0.22940951585769653,
0.4504214823246002,
0.44233885407447815,
-0.6862161159515381,
-0.9631592631340027,
0.08904486894607544,
-1.0362447500228882,
0.10671219974756241,
1.1391505002975464,
-0.07585291564464569,
0.016784192994236946,
-0.7526323795318604,
-0.3323066234588623,
0.3768104612827301,
-0.2626253664493561,
0.6988505125045776,
0.09524080902338028,
-0.7098674774169922,
0.39225447177886963,
-0.5030006170272827,
0.5682540535926819,
-0.08149511367082596,
-0.6045107841491699,
-0.0680777058005333,
0.5216299295425415,
0.30684661865234375,
0.20914337038993835,
1.2353297472000122,
-0.23996086418628693,
0.3381749987602234,
0.13385862112045288,
0.19185306131839752,
0.1571744978427887,
-0.3167716860771179,
-0.595608651638031,
-0.014992102049291134,
-0.20699302852153778,
-0.34021884202957153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10890v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10890v1
|
RWKU: Benchmarking Real-World Knowledge Unlearning for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-16T10:47:21 | 2024-06-16T10:47:21 |
Zhuoran Jin, Pengfei Cao, Chenhao Wang, Zhitao He, Hongbang Yuan, Jiachun Li, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) inevitably memorize sensitive, copyrighted, and
harmful knowledge from the training corpus; therefore, it is crucial to erase
this knowledge from the models. Machine unlearning is a promising solution for
efficiently removing specific knowledge by post hoc modifying models. In this
paper, we propose a Real-World Knowledge Unlearning benchmark (RWKU) for LLM
unlearning. RWKU is designed based on the following three key factors: (1) For
the task setting, we consider a more practical and challenging unlearning
setting, where neither the forget corpus nor the retain corpus is accessible.
(2) For the knowledge source, we choose 200 real-world famous people as the
unlearning targets and show that such popular knowledge is widely present in
various LLMs. (3) For the evaluation framework, we design the forget set and
the retain set to evaluate the model's capabilities across various real-world
applications. Regarding the forget set, we provide four four membership
inference attack (MIA) methods and nine kinds of adversarial attack probes to
rigorously test unlearning efficacy. Regarding the retain set, we assess
locality and utility in terms of neighbor perturbation, general ability,
reasoning ability, truthfulness, factuality, and fluency. We conduct extensive
experiments across two unlearning scenarios, two models and six baseline
methods and obtain some meaningful findings. We release our benchmark and code
publicly at http://rwku-bench.github.io for future work.
|
[
-0.20077615976333618,
-0.9262117743492126,
0.22161957621574402,
-0.15214842557907104,
-0.2775258719921112,
0.10503380000591278,
-0.38055047392845154,
-0.2785869538784027,
-0.33285388350486755,
0.5274661779403687,
-0.4617686867713928,
-0.39260363578796387,
-0.4572036564350128,
-0.32374584674835205,
-0.36980652809143066,
0.6143510341644287,
0.1321640908718109,
0.05617181584239006,
-0.46392592787742615,
-0.4010569751262665,
-0.5067421793937683,
-0.520980954170227,
-0.4511316418647766,
-0.6622183322906494,
0.5222482085227966,
0.45074763894081116,
0.5039122700691223,
0.6516274213790894,
0.16689278185367584,
0.2359694391489029,
-0.2154717892408371,
0.20217128098011017,
-1.043407917022705,
0.2529224455356598,
-0.329287588596344,
-0.3022734224796295,
0.024493126198649406,
0.04044819995760918,
0.8130285143852234,
0.6660374999046326,
-0.3394453525543213,
0.3396333158016205,
0.19372297823429108,
0.5451722741127014,
-0.8564080595970154,
0.11047711223363876,
-0.7646411657333374,
0.3416433036327362,
-0.06342945992946625,
0.13485097885131836,
-0.48876622319221497,
-0.3567695915699005,
0.02258882112801075,
-0.6382387280464172,
0.0815090537071228,
0.09649352729320526,
0.7565010190010071,
0.27006497979164124,
-0.28966158628463745,
0.20893800258636475,
-0.5629199743270874,
1.033652901649475,
-0.850069522857666,
0.7591848969459534,
0.47349658608436584,
0.20939145982265472,
-0.5031696557998657,
-0.6578997373580933,
-0.37076136469841003,
-0.16452722251415253,
0.0365886390209198,
0.3844061493873596,
-0.23764194548130035,
-0.287113219499588,
0.30151456594467163,
0.2752057611942291,
-0.46417784690856934,
0.23554649949073792,
-0.260162353515625,
-0.18023096024990082,
0.3774043023586273,
-0.10801612585783005,
0.003993728198111057,
0.09569092094898224,
-0.4069664180278778,
-0.0763038918375969,
-0.8830129504203796,
-0.13635414838790894,
0.3088100254535675,
0.12129723280668259,
-0.07764003425836563,
0.43179523944854736,
-0.3866136074066162,
0.40431585907936096,
-0.4407048225402832,
-0.12293548882007599,
0.3296249210834503,
0.25931715965270996,
-0.11136864125728607,
-0.4135710299015045,
0.7757411003112793,
0.18476080894470215,
0.41370251774787903,
-0.6350012421607971,
-0.26026806235313416,
-0.39116355776786804,
0.4570132791996002,
-0.632262647151947,
-0.14032310247421265,
-0.10098374634981155,
-0.6054731011390686,
-0.2788563072681427,
-0.022837359458208084,
-0.6949033737182617,
-0.4134325087070465,
-0.19721044600009918,
0.429599404335022,
-0.714499294757843,
-0.323617547750473,
-0.32531100511550903,
-0.17675966024398804,
0.20390333235263824,
0.10681521892547607,
-0.5824860334396362,
0.07925117760896683,
0.820125162601471,
0.4011388421058655,
-0.18225902318954468,
-0.6487839221954346,
-0.5967134833335876,
0.02775128372013569,
-0.1725444793701172,
0.591369092464447,
-0.3687441349029541,
-0.45386242866516113,
0.010628258809447289,
-0.19112847745418549,
-0.0351979061961174,
-0.7212823629379272,
0.6298378109931946,
-0.5873938202857971,
0.1724720597267151,
-0.2488800287246704,
-0.8934165239334106,
-0.3680638372898102,
0.40720653533935547,
-0.4569419026374817,
1.3153554201126099,
0.08360214531421661,
-0.5466299057006836,
0.3056596517562866,
-0.192666158080101,
-0.30717355012893677,
0.21072493493556976,
-0.053657688200473785,
-0.7016494274139404,
0.2211097776889801,
-0.0645667165517807,
0.454736590385437,
-0.2766983211040497,
0.5403289794921875,
-0.6319698691368103,
-0.7034379839897156,
0.2611006796360016,
-0.7655014991760254,
0.5780832767486572,
0.30878734588623047,
-0.2457810491323471,
-0.047022685408592224,
-0.7898639440536499,
0.2506958842277527,
0.24748802185058594,
-0.5191620588302612,
-0.3269640803337097,
0.07379531115293503,
-0.10992465168237686,
0.0014287754893302917,
0.20731492340564728,
-0.6023470163345337,
0.13916566967964172,
-0.20635493099689484,
0.5005744099617004,
0.7332732081413269,
0.05920219421386719,
0.11684168130159378,
-0.38400015234947205,
0.35892438888549805,
-0.018406905233860016,
0.1727226972579956,
0.23260296881198883,
-0.2475261688232422,
-0.6900148987770081,
-0.3182874023914337,
0.5374323129653931,
0.4419293701648712,
-0.47979843616485596,
0.29473069310188293,
-0.1940995752811432,
-0.63973069190979,
-0.5578447580337524,
0.14243178069591522,
0.9267921447753906,
0.5881526470184326,
0.33792030811309814,
0.08587739616632462,
-0.3835311532020569,
-0.8185852766036987,
-0.5881680250167847,
-0.06922391802072525,
-0.0860714539885521,
0.2306375950574875,
0.5456182360649109,
-0.22400441765785217,
0.8956600427627563,
-0.47742760181427,
-0.19951587915420532,
-0.14405524730682373,
0.16898125410079956,
-0.08831122517585754,
0.21513453125953674,
0.02761502005159855,
-0.5404756665229797,
0.03705770522356033,
-0.16379353404045105,
-1.1549687385559082,
0.0825076475739479,
0.2907508313655853,
0.0967363640666008,
0.3227441906929016,
0.5934219360351562,
-0.43447399139404297,
0.36192360520362854,
0.39297255873680115,
0.030735790729522705,
0.6685301661491394,
-0.44959309697151184,
0.03881818428635597,
-1.0237147808074951,
0.3411071002483368,
-0.3765488266944885,
-0.19988735020160675,
-0.45117321610450745,
0.34694814682006836,
0.2886645197868347,
-0.31106260418891907,
-0.657879650592804,
0.7521311044692993,
-0.5684769153594971,
-0.1701004058122635,
-0.07922874391078949,
0.24231810867786407,
-0.0457141250371933,
0.6755847930908203,
-0.058352429419755936,
0.6620673537254333,
0.13808690011501312,
-0.5242371559143066,
0.1052161306142807,
0.1037122830748558,
-0.5487059354782104,
0.19237352907657623,
-0.38349300622940063,
0.26010358333587646,
-0.0005941750132478774,
0.1851998120546341,
-0.6773663759231567,
0.15214328467845917,
-0.018602857366204262,
-0.34910500049591064,
0.01550482027232647,
-0.2289377897977829,
-0.5164287686347961,
-0.16908036172389984,
-0.2536550462245941,
0.36933115124702454,
0.5962901711463928,
-0.7181486487388611,
0.5518916249275208,
0.38181009888648987,
0.28631556034088135,
-1.007952332496643,
-0.44367679953575134,
-0.02048908919095993,
-0.4917234182357788,
-0.21722754836082458,
0.29326310753822327,
0.0027976990677416325,
-0.23525260388851166,
0.09116964787244797,
-0.09153281152248383,
-0.09021226316690445,
0.21226996183395386,
0.48417600989341736,
0.06774762272834778,
0.004910038318485022,
0.2908124327659607,
-0.30508869886398315,
-0.19099146127700806,
0.054406821727752686,
-0.10174766182899475,
0.5225877165794373,
0.07718432694673538,
-0.47918233275413513,
-0.23028166592121124,
0.20083558559417725,
0.5167203545570374,
-0.28318893909454346,
0.7605481147766113,
0.7582762837409973,
-0.4902914762496948,
-0.46693000197410583,
-0.7410013675689697,
-0.17773498594760895,
-0.4285464584827423,
0.558295488357544,
-0.37370574474334717,
-0.8473116159439087,
0.6510483026504517,
-0.2811492681503296,
0.37192511558532715,
0.1039729043841362,
0.3592262268066406,
-0.12135688960552216,
0.46565550565719604,
0.5029641389846802,
-0.494994193315506,
0.2949430048465729,
-0.31747543811798096,
0.327804297208786,
-0.8022531867027283,
-0.23837050795555115,
-0.32660961151123047,
-0.12023892253637314,
-0.21881286799907684,
-0.27427777647972107,
0.09711792320013046,
0.5002059936523438,
-0.3530035614967346,
0.22491610050201416,
-0.16767500340938568,
0.5676576495170593,
0.7167680859565735,
0.16987234354019165,
0.37422817945480347,
-0.15282347798347473,
-0.41463878750801086,
0.03508944436907768,
-0.7901278138160706,
-0.36166128516197205,
1.3036895990371704,
0.3023633360862732,
0.6374847292900085,
0.12198664247989655,
0.6493848562240601,
0.3978927731513977,
0.2574143707752228,
-0.7470916509628296,
0.6471644043922424,
-0.09678228944540024,
-0.3050898015499115,
-0.4067321717739105,
-0.7489397525787354,
-0.8468024730682373,
0.43216606974601746,
-0.5287164449691772,
-0.5499898195266724,
-0.31788352131843567,
0.3368901014328003,
-0.10679405182600021,
0.6448339223861694,
-0.545757532119751,
0.949442982673645,
-0.022727781906723976,
-0.28735509514808655,
-0.4515562057495117,
-0.33969858288764954,
0.5042315721511841,
-0.252535879611969,
0.3062359690666199,
-0.17670896649360657,
0.23435485363006592,
0.8141189217567444,
-0.3234464228153229,
0.835561215877533,
-0.15592285990715027,
-0.015835518017411232,
0.04262637719511986,
0.0572165846824646,
0.6152171492576599,
0.12188154458999634,
-0.20491933822631836,
0.45938098430633545,
-0.09371445327997208,
-0.23352625966072083,
-0.3508029580116272,
0.7013297080993652,
-0.91167151927948,
-0.3686884641647339,
-0.2594795525074005,
-0.5314497947692871,
-0.42023634910583496,
0.3882717788219452,
0.3782707750797272,
0.5780072808265686,
-0.7328836917877197,
0.31918466091156006,
0.9340295791625977,
-0.218855619430542,
0.43279388546943665,
0.7868167757987976,
-0.20959565043449402,
-0.3429949879646301,
1.0755031108856201,
0.10218063741922379,
0.16947497427463531,
0.5948096513748169,
0.29384171962738037,
-0.339664101600647,
-0.6567631959915161,
-0.38364148139953613,
0.32150015234947205,
-0.6550279259681702,
-0.36310434341430664,
-0.4296700656414032,
-0.18779481947422028,
-0.5471985936164856,
0.07884188741445541,
-0.47996070981025696,
-0.24770981073379517,
-0.10294851660728455,
0.047279346734285355,
0.3006519675254822,
0.6987975835800171,
0.08147266507148743,
0.15936927497386932,
-0.6685754656791687,
0.29508644342422485,
0.3277856707572937,
0.4822051227092743,
0.21601903438568115,
-0.7311306595802307,
-0.2920074760913849,
0.0339764766395092,
-0.33418548107147217,
-0.34783297777175903,
0.2752078175544739,
0.11697915196418762,
0.8544347882270813,
0.4938020706176758,
0.36138904094696045,
0.6365975737571716,
-0.3658890426158905,
0.3529856503009796,
-0.08123352378606796,
-0.6771370768547058,
0.16003775596618652,
-0.43965578079223633,
0.4729191064834595,
0.5917080044746399,
0.11843730509281158,
-0.7980531454086304,
-0.4218996465206146,
-0.815772533416748,
-0.8000293970108032,
0.529840886592865,
-0.14053234457969666,
-0.24898064136505127,
0.13885606825351715,
0.5809249877929688,
0.015312161296606064,
0.038498979061841965,
-0.598456621170044,
-0.3898793160915375,
-0.013897721655666828,
-0.0411178357899189,
-0.06713282316923141,
-0.44520652294158936,
-0.033305779099464417,
0.05520154908299446,
1.0221612453460693,
0.023459630087018013,
-0.024486610665917397,
-0.28745925426483154,
-0.43733546137809753,
0.035470958799123764,
0.38332608342170715,
0.30806130170822144,
0.7726593613624573,
-0.27734240889549255,
0.07096090167760849,
0.6649412512779236,
-0.5096197128295898,
-0.08735063672065735,
-0.13150878250598907,
-0.3722975552082062,
-0.40099045634269714,
0.5297597050666809,
0.38099169731140137,
0.5944464802742004,
-0.9693323969841003,
0.32648172974586487,
-0.2432280331850052,
-0.3677574098110199,
-0.5349501371383667,
0.11913217604160309,
0.4301948547363281,
0.002982125850394368,
0.26522040367126465,
-0.2680181860923767,
-0.2631117105484009,
-0.5812027454376221,
0.31079167127609253,
0.639707624912262,
-0.5073769092559814,
-0.010203076526522636,
0.44319984316825867,
0.10610833764076233,
-0.3057754635810852,
0.9675072431564331,
-0.16712062060832977,
-0.4893580675125122,
0.24164018034934998,
0.59377521276474,
0.5721045136451721,
-0.18608038127422333,
-0.08404123038053513,
0.3030828535556793,
0.1413968801498413,
-0.16579782962799072,
-0.06216339394450188,
0.011045290157198906,
-0.8677547574043274,
-0.15295377373695374,
-0.5867950916290283,
-0.6208212375640869,
0.6286477446556091,
-0.8019499182701111,
0.09251222759485245,
-0.472569078207016,
0.18109363317489624,
-0.21767954528331757,
0.22372396290302277,
-0.362338662147522,
0.25372472405433655,
-0.20691022276878357,
0.779849648475647,
-0.6809438467025757,
1.039716362953186,
0.5058555603027344,
-0.04693853482604027,
-0.752309262752533,
-0.04215195029973984,
0.3624676465988159,
-1.0053894519805908,
0.29810529947280884,
0.06039941683411598,
-0.22663339972496033,
-0.059333160519599915,
-0.030739909037947655,
-0.7279303073883057,
1.0141195058822632,
0.3845891058444977,
-0.6472927331924438,
0.346157968044281,
0.02175886742770672,
0.15992970764636993,
-0.10701173543930054,
0.2727290391921997,
0.5328050851821899,
0.29369300603866577,
-0.04366888478398323,
-0.5322035551071167,
0.001497838064096868,
-0.15193533897399902,
-0.21854296326637268,
0.4009241461753845,
-0.745456337928772,
0.6819145679473877,
-0.2100180834531784,
-0.11735276132822037,
0.02751387655735016,
0.778107762336731,
0.3999893069267273,
0.10040870308876038,
0.5555986166000366,
0.9772571325302124,
0.8590832948684692,
-0.060346171259880066,
0.5209759473800659,
-0.07965447008609772,
0.39240550994873047,
1.2343941926956177,
-0.19528277218341827,
1.083678126335144,
0.1521892100572586,
-0.029216434806585312,
-0.022003699094057083,
0.3025493323802948,
-0.015626726672053337,
0.376813679933548,
0.34871432185173035,
-0.35315388441085815,
-0.24825845658779144,
0.16058149933815002,
-0.38084477186203003,
0.5877463817596436,
0.042977385222911835,
0.046488724648952484,
-0.2523215115070343,
0.0392809733748436,
0.44748711585998535,
0.1995493620634079,
-0.024388311430811882,
0.898876965045929,
0.13339976966381073,
-0.6676334738731384,
0.7094462513923645,
0.06586011499166489,
0.585026204586029,
-0.6669331192970276,
-0.09225808084011078,
-0.46385470032691956,
0.7203306555747986,
0.009192438796162605,
-0.44657230377197266,
0.17688100039958954,
-0.04861736670136452,
-0.2417701631784439,
-0.16655154526233673,
0.5648478865623474,
-0.4641065001487732,
-0.39280492067337036,
0.5430434346199036,
0.4205138683319092,
0.26717597246170044,
-0.08350501209497452,
-0.8108512759208679,
0.06780770421028137,
0.10287181288003922,
-0.3174877464771271,
0.8077496886253357,
0.4036876857280731,
-0.08782447874546051,
1.1598882675170898,
0.5824675559997559,
0.004669764544814825,
-0.18108035624027252,
0.3418889343738556,
0.7431437373161316,
-0.798399806022644,
-0.06952226907014847,
-0.6110593676567078,
-0.005210351198911667,
0.024922439828515053,
-0.4909084141254425,
0.8939791321754456,
0.8169477581977844,
0.7835589051246643,
0.1608000248670578,
0.7392110824584961,
0.2618328332901001,
0.7478111982345581,
-0.520901083946228,
1.1228801012039185,
-0.4477129876613617,
0.21215419471263885,
-0.09109792113304138,
-0.918555498123169,
-0.1296635866165161,
0.3595806956291199,
0.053173284977674484,
0.007827960886061192,
0.5699366331100464,
0.7611255645751953,
-0.12376483529806137,
0.15539097785949707,
0.6791485548019409,
0.18522565066814423,
0.22187013924121857,
0.5081213116645813,
0.8522064685821533,
-0.4071711003780365,
0.6887462735176086,
-0.40092456340789795,
-0.24892401695251465,
-0.031162051483988762,
-0.9696865677833557,
-0.900811493396759,
-0.33528947830200195,
-0.2534862458705902,
-0.14772482216358185,
0.4154931902885437,
0.5708644986152649,
0.6100009083747864,
-0.5898261070251465,
-0.19277016818523407,
0.1480497568845749,
0.2184952050447464,
-0.4964442253112793,
-0.16247662901878357,
0.4993358254432678,
-0.24828031659126282,
-0.3495221436023712,
0.7265619039535522,
-0.10683173686265945,
-0.26685506105422974,
-0.22726856172084808,
-0.04728996753692627,
-0.21279168128967285,
-0.25377917289733887,
0.5082588791847229,
0.5520445108413696,
-0.753466010093689,
-0.45862215757369995,
-0.36067458987236023,
0.2509293854236603,
-0.2959502935409546,
0.7407270669937134,
-1.005328893661499,
0.05568353459239006,
0.1900734305381775,
0.5261073112487793,
0.4773559868335724,
0.13340230286121368,
0.5323854088783264,
-0.8225386738777161,
0.04462992399930954,
-0.06310325115919113,
0.5561055541038513,
0.1687808781862259,
-0.16140778362751007,
0.5161210894584656,
0.2556380033493042,
-0.6795487403869629,
-0.924252986907959,
-0.005957670975476503,
-0.6442765593528748,
-0.5781044960021973,
0.8711849451065063,
-0.5482479333877563,
-0.1238759383559227,
-0.2723194658756256,
0.28638580441474915,
0.366873174905777,
-0.3520759046077728,
0.872646152973175,
0.47076717019081116,
0.29022452235221863,
-0.18620941042900085,
-0.5786296725273132,
0.2799294888973236,
0.4510938227176666,
-0.6438882350921631,
0.854242205619812,
0.43939146399497986,
0.6423232555389404,
-0.2777387797832489,
0.4752163589000702,
-0.08115453273057938,
0.1186557188630104,
-0.03363394737243652,
0.2520305812358856,
-0.46160659193992615,
-0.303212970495224,
-0.3527555465698242,
0.2788166403770447,
0.02546781674027443,
-0.04087923467159271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10886v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10886v1
|
Distilling Opinions at Scale: Incremental Opinion Summarization using XL-OPSUMM
| 2024-06-16T10:36:41 | 2024-06-16T10:36:41 |
Sri Raghava Muddu, Rupasai Rangaraju, Tejpalsingh Siledar, Swaroop Nath, Pushpak Bhattacharyya, Swaprava Nath, Suman Banerjee, Amey Patil, Muthusamy Chelliah, Sudhanshu Shekhar Singh, Nikesh Garera
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Opinion summarization in e-commerce encapsulates the collective views of
numerous users about a product based on their reviews. Typically, a product on
an e-commerce platform has thousands of reviews, each review comprising around
10-15 words. While Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown proficiency in
summarization tasks, they struggle to handle such a large volume of reviews due
to context limitations. To mitigate, we propose a scalable framework called
Xl-OpSumm that generates summaries incrementally. However, the existing test
set, AMASUM has only 560 reviews per product on average. Due to the lack of a
test set with thousands of reviews, we created a new test set called
Xl-Flipkart by gathering data from the Flipkart website and generating
summaries using GPT-4. Through various automatic evaluations and extensive
analysis, we evaluated the framework's efficiency on two datasets, AMASUM and
Xl-Flipkart. Experimental results show that our framework, Xl-OpSumm powered by
Llama-3-8B-8k, achieves an average ROUGE-1 F1 gain of 4.38% and a ROUGE-L F1
gain of 3.70% over the next best-performing model.
|
[
-0.6685386896133423,
-0.8147024512290955,
0.2789718210697174,
0.4362965226173401,
-0.6116801500320435,
0.18076743185520172,
-0.07085313647985458,
-0.3697664439678192,
0.5640984773635864,
0.4082985520362854,
-0.4636201560497284,
-0.5362076759338379,
-0.5199302434921265,
0.2669752538204193,
-0.7399867177009583,
1.3842717409133911,
0.09047826379537582,
-0.2777390778064728,
-0.09439805895090103,
-0.48548421263694763,
0.18121907114982605,
-0.5149813294410706,
-0.5092459321022034,
-0.14314517378807068,
0.2963247299194336,
0.6099693775177002,
0.6457027196884155,
0.35978567600250244,
0.4379255175590515,
0.3083975911140442,
-0.0404328890144825,
0.21247528493404388,
-0.6919773817062378,
0.08903294056653976,
0.0854211300611496,
-0.31779006123542786,
-0.9934599995613098,
-0.0790412500500679,
0.3827536106109619,
0.6660531163215637,
-0.4239886701107025,
0.4622911810874939,
0.19519513845443726,
1.0042248964309692,
-0.4460394084453583,
0.1035894900560379,
-0.4265875220298767,
0.26591914892196655,
0.2855150103569031,
-0.027650440111756325,
-0.25312235951423645,
-0.4961608052253723,
0.12710115313529968,
-0.5543601512908936,
-0.13765273988246918,
-0.018549533560872078,
0.6524016261100769,
-0.09143558889627457,
-0.24047346413135529,
-0.47659075260162354,
-0.7594155073165894,
0.7945221662521362,
-1.0866378545761108,
-0.05937764421105385,
-0.016424722969532013,
0.0818692073225975,
0.47535184025764465,
-0.6498486995697021,
-0.4973987936973572,
0.0061433399096131325,
-0.056857477873563766,
0.5126714706420898,
-0.4422224462032318,
-0.34893837571144104,
0.21117135882377625,
0.6503511071205139,
-0.4425920844078064,
-0.034282080829143524,
-0.23273400962352753,
0.3314718008041382,
0.7783835530281067,
0.5208574533462524,
-0.092549629509449,
-0.029866259545087814,
-0.42777395248413086,
-0.09275126457214355,
-0.8718811869621277,
-0.020882703363895416,
0.5345099568367004,
0.2208937257528305,
-0.043541859835386276,
0.6056205034255981,
-0.4606562852859497,
0.6662511825561523,
0.5282766819000244,
-0.3630695044994354,
0.4761694371700287,
-0.5711100101470947,
-0.4514361619949341,
-0.02651023119688034,
0.7261253595352173,
0.7679705023765564,
-0.10738673806190491,
0.4283309876918793,
-0.37492355704307556,
-0.3833736777305603,
0.34633955359458923,
-1.2097238302230835,
0.01919817551970482,
0.47798919677734375,
-0.6103029251098633,
-0.45675137639045715,
0.2501569092273712,
-0.9149671792984009,
-0.40545520186424255,
-0.35927101969718933,
0.4639512300491333,
-0.2142597734928131,
-0.47810572385787964,
0.1642817109823227,
-0.08636406064033508,
0.07013833522796631,
0.3437069058418274,
-0.6743607521057129,
0.5746394991874695,
0.6680685877799988,
1.0390936136245728,
-0.14735430479049683,
-0.05149298161268234,
-0.3726590871810913,
-0.10415081679821014,
-0.40242448449134827,
0.8927872776985168,
-0.27097946405410767,
-0.7101929783821106,
0.05286116153001785,
-0.21886955201625824,
0.3443487584590912,
-0.5812098979949951,
0.13968127965927124,
-0.44190242886543274,
-0.0693826973438263,
-0.29681554436683655,
-0.7791627645492554,
-0.2459297776222229,
0.6111462116241455,
-0.6250771284103394,
0.5808187127113342,
-0.08492876589298248,
-0.7007496953010559,
0.44013500213623047,
-0.5193073153495789,
-0.7094129323959351,
-0.07186056673526764,
-0.12169759720563889,
-0.75847327709198,
0.27987974882125854,
0.565774142742157,
0.48369914293289185,
-0.07020652294158936,
-0.3780125677585602,
-0.3415856659412384,
-0.24569100141525269,
0.1054975762963295,
0.03587998449802399,
0.5639318823814392,
0.25338131189346313,
-0.49426624178886414,
0.034928128123283386,
-0.5206480622291565,
-0.01264929585158825,
-0.059598129242658615,
-0.29499977827072144,
-0.2128327339887619,
0.10323908925056458,
0.062197569757699966,
0.09038921445608139,
0.23617583513259888,
-0.31831714510917664,
0.4143624007701874,
-0.30283689498901367,
0.46658551692962646,
0.788352906703949,
0.20985953509807587,
0.40646499395370483,
-0.31057724356651306,
0.6511951684951782,
0.1418982297182083,
0.23682446777820587,
-0.6228458881378174,
-0.3267444372177124,
-0.8476716876029968,
-0.10473854094743729,
0.12540008127689362,
0.26768410205841064,
-0.5545318126678467,
0.4436644911766052,
-0.42345595359802246,
-0.5208398103713989,
-0.09751028567552567,
0.31629759073257446,
0.16496430337429047,
0.35173192620277405,
0.23473986983299255,
-0.27834054827690125,
-0.17915967106819153,
-1.1034343242645264,
-0.3146229684352875,
-0.1439507007598877,
-0.24614417552947998,
0.20032787322998047,
0.3892183005809784,
-0.1602318435907364,
1.0310739278793335,
-0.8046300411224365,
-0.6245401501655579,
-0.6819171905517578,
0.5480880737304688,
0.46301618218421936,
-0.15342241525650024,
0.5304808616638184,
-0.7392035722732544,
-0.6795053482055664,
0.17665889859199524,
-0.5074830055236816,
-0.22714851796627045,
-0.14599011838436127,
0.31414932012557983,
0.32108166813850403,
0.37565481662750244,
-0.20408974587917328,
0.2711428105831146,
0.5319657921791077,
0.03403720259666443,
0.37728774547576904,
-0.3396299183368683,
0.33060136437416077,
-1.2239911556243896,
-0.155668705701828,
0.10185562819242477,
-0.42994675040245056,
-0.22050994634628296,
-0.1186608225107193,
0.0007165964343585074,
0.10102128982543945,
-0.2849588394165039,
0.03861568868160248,
-0.3781052827835083,
0.0013433443382382393,
-0.46161752939224243,
0.49567151069641113,
0.05193983390927315,
0.3718796372413635,
0.10730394721031189,
0.5532257556915283,
0.18822766840457916,
-0.6312481760978699,
0.28897708654403687,
0.030950620770454407,
-0.4281417727470398,
0.911698043346405,
-0.811319887638092,
-0.060122717171907425,
0.15668885409832,
0.38870498538017273,
-1.0260179042816162,
-0.16919413208961487,
-0.267843097448349,
-0.3185310661792755,
0.08742757886648178,
0.057269591838121414,
-0.47366058826446533,
-0.37478184700012207,
-0.7896084785461426,
0.13306502997875214,
0.7054944038391113,
-0.5763168334960938,
0.7576087713241577,
0.8256955742835999,
-0.6262755990028381,
-0.5370834469795227,
-0.6179980039596558,
0.2333860546350479,
-0.3553709387779236,
-0.48148447275161743,
0.020089713856577873,
-0.0316748321056366,
-0.503894031047821,
-0.05475342273712158,
-0.04011938348412514,
0.2560376822948456,
-0.39065322279930115,
0.15174482762813568,
0.06598694622516632,
0.019817683845758438,
0.1390477865934372,
0.16729316115379333,
-0.15796132385730743,
0.05382268503308296,
-0.3346819579601288,
0.3024808466434479,
-0.5049163103103638,
-0.14232835173606873,
-0.03584830462932587,
0.44861045479774475,
0.6496922373771667,
0.14807963371276855,
0.3406504690647125,
0.13488422334194183,
-0.10060704499483109,
-0.6238657832145691,
-0.457258403301239,
-0.09129336476325989,
-0.44065818190574646,
0.6241244077682495,
-0.12911462783813477,
-0.6523064374923706,
0.4944303333759308,
-0.10099491477012634,
0.47214508056640625,
0.3773811161518097,
0.8806763887405396,
-0.057111430913209915,
1.2377139329910278,
0.684384822845459,
-0.4990014135837555,
0.30812349915504456,
-0.3331175744533539,
0.4843812882900238,
-0.5980547070503235,
0.22392699122428894,
-0.19431009888648987,
-0.4374141991138458,
-0.4919041395187378,
-0.07679052650928497,
0.7060317993164062,
-0.18540801107883453,
0.049306124448776245,
0.2959747016429901,
-0.34930139780044556,
0.37834134697914124,
0.2937237620353699,
0.08428530395030975,
0.7072795629501343,
0.14781223237514496,
0.13370616734027863,
0.19666330516338348,
-0.5681585669517517,
-0.49164026975631714,
1.3275773525238037,
0.03581196069717407,
0.754056453704834,
0.06694453209638596,
0.4656880795955658,
0.42750784754753113,
0.7741180062294006,
-0.8286442160606384,
0.57646644115448,
-0.18902505934238434,
-0.3518933653831482,
-0.2088632434606552,
-0.5053014755249023,
-0.5221043229103088,
0.3942854702472687,
-0.14754539728164673,
-0.18170398473739624,
-0.05896030366420746,
0.37000665068626404,
-0.5027836561203003,
0.5185600519180298,
-0.49173200130462646,
0.31894367933273315,
-0.3058249056339264,
-0.40960097312927246,
-0.38996705412864685,
-0.4420454204082489,
0.4270459711551666,
-0.2803425192832947,
0.5075429081916809,
0.15981943905353546,
-0.27624598145484924,
0.6275134682655334,
-1.0113041400909424,
0.6073213219642639,
-0.008764359168708324,
-0.24884256720542908,
0.3394790291786194,
-0.059705156832933426,
0.4868295192718506,
0.26103270053863525,
0.08254088461399078,
0.2746877074241638,
-0.3872147798538208,
-0.14601440727710724,
-0.4084252417087555,
0.715829610824585,
-0.5640124082565308,
-0.4982762336730957,
-0.46234866976737976,
-0.32680565118789673,
-0.31103020906448364,
0.1389678716659546,
0.48531702160835266,
0.5088867545127869,
-0.21146413683891296,
0.3531216084957123,
0.6533379554748535,
-0.15950405597686768,
0.5479943752288818,
0.5383360385894775,
-0.6613659858703613,
-0.7420983910560608,
0.638639509677887,
0.3887404203414917,
0.4168243408203125,
0.4561922252178192,
0.3359524607658386,
-0.23026718199253082,
-0.6041916608810425,
-0.5682445764541626,
-0.0865665078163147,
-0.5710119009017944,
-0.4271443784236908,
-0.7830479145050049,
0.09631476551294327,
-0.22222712635993958,
-0.1935974657535553,
-0.4206518530845642,
-0.5669801235198975,
0.28479278087615967,
-0.4955182671546936,
0.536539614200592,
1.0358198881149292,
-0.17109988629817963,
0.24913360178470612,
-0.713144838809967,
0.383637398481369,
0.5990670919418335,
0.19281388819217682,
0.018130162730813026,
-0.5008665919303894,
-0.45529571175575256,
0.11488107591867447,
-0.3351552188396454,
-0.42790332436561584,
0.6028025150299072,
0.12862801551818848,
-0.10276353359222412,
0.9260720014572144,
0.18650509417057037,
0.9125598073005676,
-0.45099955797195435,
0.9318195581436157,
0.2924906015396118,
-0.985307514667511,
0.38409358263015747,
-0.4498419463634491,
0.5715285539627075,
0.667061984539032,
0.3060305714607239,
-0.3875136375427246,
-0.6654232740402222,
-0.48007336258888245,
-1.3412631750106812,
0.6145386099815369,
0.20279909670352936,
0.19413870573043823,
0.006657727994024754,
0.11493387073278427,
0.4931005537509918,
0.6007648706436157,
-0.6925566792488098,
-0.21523897349834442,
-0.16566474735736847,
-0.002148040570318699,
-0.20969557762145996,
-0.3019399046897888,
-0.11227236688137054,
-0.05682637169957161,
0.7321437001228333,
0.0017925517167896032,
-0.19662578403949738,
0.09407483786344528,
-0.13097544014453888,
0.0421845018863678,
0.09098046272993088,
0.5394654870033264,
0.8524424433708191,
-0.1963914930820465,
0.13285455107688904,
0.1882108747959137,
-0.7315937876701355,
-0.092244453728199,
-0.1553945094347,
-0.30773574113845825,
-0.036159295588731766,
0.35255712270736694,
0.2973405420780182,
0.12466300278902054,
-0.5579994916915894,
0.5202710032463074,
-0.22528396546840668,
-0.18571998178958893,
-0.4037010073661804,
-0.26027292013168335,
0.2434372454881668,
-0.09605507552623749,
0.4494447708129883,
-0.017917385324835777,
0.3495648503303528,
-0.5962920784950256,
0.208618625998497,
0.2887135446071625,
-0.09935061633586884,
-0.2700425386428833,
0.44033682346343994,
0.43596363067626953,
0.06595636904239655,
0.5119165182113647,
-0.13170944154262543,
-0.32326191663742065,
0.6854740381240845,
0.11054414510726929,
1.062827467918396,
-0.19290974736213684,
0.090469591319561,
0.49436333775520325,
0.41944950819015503,
-0.28181782364845276,
-0.06240801140666008,
-0.19728028774261475,
-0.4300462603569031,
-0.34172794222831726,
-0.5886036157608032,
-0.7572945356369019,
-0.029767513275146484,
-0.7852988839149475,
0.24902065098285675,
-0.2977023720741272,
-0.24381105601787567,
-0.03937838599085808,
-0.07049239426851273,
-0.13714492321014404,
0.20493154227733612,
-0.10252544283866882,
0.6258203983306885,
-0.7925976514816284,
0.3024330735206604,
0.5042552947998047,
-0.4381290376186371,
-0.6089028120040894,
-0.07383205741643906,
0.1539863646030426,
-0.44731998443603516,
0.29729852080345154,
0.2551032304763794,
-0.49790993332862854,
-0.42966169118881226,
-0.2768433392047882,
-0.3948647975921631,
1.0945472717285156,
-0.12554916739463806,
-0.9273887872695923,
0.6262171864509583,
0.3108607530593872,
0.6323532462120056,
-0.792434811592102,
0.31569910049438477,
0.4198075532913208,
0.35287371277809143,
0.030223721638321877,
-0.6750038266181946,
-0.19323906302452087,
-0.43128183484077454,
-0.12261611968278885,
0.21397681534290314,
-0.7084805369377136,
0.9899589419364929,
-0.33357036113739014,
-0.10302524268627167,
-0.0653984546661377,
0.3566150963306427,
0.19848600029945374,
0.3139185607433319,
0.7450874447822571,
0.7507343888282776,
0.4278227984905243,
0.046722326427698135,
1.156747579574585,
-0.2340794950723648,
0.5847992897033691,
1.3373461961746216,
-0.6199588775634766,
1.1446330547332764,
0.3647485673427582,
-0.3232438862323761,
0.49131661653518677,
0.5601544976234436,
0.21589121222496033,
0.25155675411224365,
0.10076416283845901,
-0.1373528391122818,
-0.09630964696407318,
0.5382087826728821,
-0.41033247113227844,
0.03768037632107735,
0.2773498594760895,
-0.37340953946113586,
-0.19988887012004852,
-0.04102465137839317,
0.2572246193885803,
-0.08528263866901398,
-0.6560251712799072,
1.0644749402999878,
0.22003619372844696,
-0.5289063453674316,
0.24479930102825165,
-0.18346478044986725,
0.5455816984176636,
-0.6929888725280762,
0.060396403074264526,
-0.6117880940437317,
0.5529907941818237,
-0.3736966550350189,
-0.5822827219963074,
0.29401764273643494,
0.20855699479579926,
-0.09763605147600174,
-0.49347278475761414,
0.2577161192893982,
-0.26850342750549316,
-0.9878606796264648,
0.19109508395195007,
0.4582211673259735,
-0.09587810188531876,
-0.11566759645938873,
-0.46876853704452515,
-0.06218934431672096,
-0.05011201277375221,
-0.7511187195777893,
0.3547377288341522,
0.4215151071548462,
0.09612138569355011,
0.5002260804176331,
0.40316444635391235,
0.10072258114814758,
-0.215007022023201,
0.03825739026069641,
0.8589129447937012,
-0.3884353041648865,
-0.9226229190826416,
-1.0675476789474487,
0.41518548130989075,
-0.6614123582839966,
-0.15910299122333527,
1.20884108543396,
0.976041853427887,
0.714345395565033,
-0.1753438413143158,
0.9635234475135803,
-0.030443506315350533,
0.47784772515296936,
-0.21089662611484528,
0.8024700880050659,
-0.6630837917327881,
0.5288374423980713,
-0.3819442093372345,
-1.0603951215744019,
-0.2773902118206024,
0.6374024152755737,
-0.18938487768173218,
0.05278540402650833,
0.7116244435310364,
0.532494843006134,
0.13185955584049225,
0.20871499180793762,
0.20344510674476624,
0.6272990107536316,
0.18533776700496674,
0.29430535435676575,
0.58104407787323,
-0.2772970199584961,
0.5906010866165161,
-0.1411517858505249,
-0.5817791819572449,
-0.38276174664497375,
-1.1043881177902222,
-0.758971631526947,
-0.24787475168704987,
-0.46359461545944214,
-0.25565868616104126,
-0.44149431586265564,
0.7798645496368408,
0.7638572454452515,
-0.7575032114982605,
-0.6705580353736877,
-0.10262841731309891,
0.019250813871622086,
-0.6446862816810608,
-0.23770442605018616,
0.36755913496017456,
-0.28279632329940796,
-0.8287806510925293,
-0.1784001737833023,
0.7914890050888062,
-0.4656805098056793,
-0.3936692774295807,
0.21590948104858398,
0.28399693965911865,
0.4302637279033661,
1.0551745891571045,
-0.03491968289017677,
-0.26474907994270325,
0.04378678277134895,
-0.013470952399075031,
0.32958775758743286,
0.20934833586215973,
1.0550718307495117,
-0.5789473056793213,
0.596855103969574,
0.43002352118492126,
0.27285531163215637,
0.656175971031189,
0.3819114863872528,
0.6027839183807373,
-0.41870078444480896,
-0.06068764254450798,
0.18895933032035828,
0.5540968775749207,
0.11324576288461685,
-0.12479955703020096,
0.3674669861793518,
-0.24675922095775604,
-0.48097658157348633,
-0.6173581480979919,
0.18085172772407532,
-1.0772805213928223,
-0.21138496696949005,
1.1683074235916138,
-0.1695568561553955,
-0.0848277360200882,
0.07614219188690186,
-0.22224198281764984,
-0.5455632209777832,
-0.5313928723335266,
1.0682438611984253,
0.6741907000541687,
-0.47644954919815063,
0.15262062847614288,
-0.15782316029071808,
0.2039949744939804,
-0.030634231865406036,
-1.1273857355117798,
0.25584691762924194,
0.5153214335441589,
0.3883213698863983,
0.3139152228832245,
0.7315559983253479,
-0.4057806432247162,
0.10567310452461243,
0.025225505232810974,
-0.15216460824012756,
-0.20536860823631287,
-0.012638481333851814,
-0.38376981019973755,
0.6888337135314941,
-0.1945653259754181,
0.014581398107111454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10885v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10885v1
|
On the Role of Entity and Event Level Conceptualization in Generalizable Reasoning: A Survey of Tasks, Methods, Applications, and Future Directions
| 2024-06-16T10:32:41 | 2024-06-16T10:32:41 |
Weiqi Wang, Tianqing Fang, Haochen Shi, Baixuan Xu, Wenxuan Ding, Liyu Zhang, Wei Fan, Jiaxin Bai, Haoran Li, Xin Liu, Yangqiu Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Entity- and event-level conceptualization, as fundamental elements of human
cognition, plays a pivotal role in generalizable reasoning. This process
involves abstracting specific instances into higher-level concepts and forming
abstract knowledge that can be applied in unfamiliar or novel situations, which
can enhance models' inferential capabilities and support the effective transfer
of knowledge across various domains. Despite its significance, there is
currently a lack of a systematic overview that comprehensively examines
existing works in the definition, execution, and application of
conceptualization to enhance reasoning tasks. In this paper, we address this
gap by presenting the first comprehensive survey of 150+ papers, categorizing
various definitions, resources, methods, and downstream applications related to
conceptualization into a unified taxonomy, with a focus on the entity and event
levels. Furthermore, we shed light on potential future directions in this field
and hope to garner more attention from the community.
|
[
-0.6849161982536316,
-0.6098601222038269,
0.8157251477241516,
-0.10259507596492767,
-0.16087277233600616,
0.06872576475143433,
0.10083986073732376,
-0.7969992160797119,
0.15294283628463745,
0.010056870058178902,
-0.1600605994462967,
-0.5876403450965881,
-0.3666912615299225,
-0.17102837562561035,
-0.7295705676078796,
0.897598147392273,
-0.0394711047410965,
-0.35071706771850586,
-0.5554460287094116,
0.17401930689811707,
-0.3476583659648895,
-0.6562263369560242,
-0.9892024397850037,
-0.3340228796005249,
0.38293468952178955,
-0.07388509809970856,
0.22152386605739594,
0.10877307504415512,
0.4974895417690277,
0.11395540088415146,
-0.34131062030792236,
0.09041048586368561,
-0.03290630131959915,
0.27678894996643066,
-0.6960287094116211,
-0.5018327236175537,
-0.6760956645011902,
-0.03912314400076866,
0.7826294898986816,
1.1339073181152344,
-0.28700870275497437,
0.14528748393058777,
0.07565997540950775,
0.19149190187454224,
-0.8567861318588257,
0.30894848704338074,
-0.5536901950836182,
-0.05609633028507233,
-0.2823503315448761,
-0.16599783301353455,
-0.2575840950012207,
0.12173609435558319,
0.40863242745399475,
-1.055598258972168,
0.2957632839679718,
-0.05813893675804138,
0.6784019470214844,
0.06917575001716614,
-0.6339101195335388,
-0.3576514422893524,
-0.9009014368057251,
0.6070111393928528,
-0.1806260198354721,
0.36100324988365173,
0.032426781952381134,
-0.03290722146630287,
-0.25172722339630127,
-0.8933354616165161,
-0.31251078844070435,
0.03996320813894272,
0.02865023724734783,
0.119717538356781,
-0.5063461065292358,
0.4530136287212372,
0.2825790047645569,
0.17364539206027985,
-0.26202189922332764,
0.009396874345839024,
-0.19562003016471863,
-0.04330197721719742,
0.7121087312698364,
0.4014947712421417,
0.5780333280563354,
-0.09666185826063156,
-0.2189008742570877,
0.489463746547699,
-0.4803130030632019,
0.1362246423959732,
-0.04282265156507492,
-0.29494625329971313,
0.25694531202316284,
0.33030420541763306,
-0.6869646906852722,
0.6451030373573303,
-0.028412887826561928,
0.15445561707019806,
-0.12732890248298645,
-0.8763025403022766,
-0.16657115519046783,
-0.14745815098285675,
0.4486384093761444,
0.2328041046857834,
0.17300893366336823,
-0.30987977981567383,
-0.030921492725610733,
0.11634383350610733,
0.4206608533859253,
-0.5507248044013977,
-0.13430030643939972,
0.30131107568740845,
-0.368283748626709,
-0.08331429958343506,
0.12479206919670105,
-0.7081388831138611,
-0.26848527789115906,
-0.5285193920135498,
0.009445319883525372,
-0.22357876598834991,
-0.5056719779968262,
0.2528231143951416,
-0.2979506254196167,
0.06004645675420761,
0.6781861186027527,
-0.7753860354423523,
0.45345786213874817,
0.9026197791099548,
0.5294874310493469,
-0.43883150815963745,
0.004580173175781965,
0.07986173778772354,
0.7462854981422424,
-0.49691683053970337,
0.8342435359954834,
-0.8035162687301636,
-0.4558335840702057,
0.0027733114548027515,
-0.34258154034614563,
-0.05088326707482338,
-0.38706305623054504,
0.794819176197052,
-0.3963194191455841,
-0.10783174633979797,
-0.27847719192504883,
-0.5912628173828125,
-0.16801317036151886,
0.19198660552501678,
-0.3156224489212036,
0.6450374722480774,
-0.290522962808609,
-0.708052933216095,
0.8834159970283508,
-0.9892409443855286,
-0.4232402741909027,
0.3368596136569977,
-0.40941205620765686,
0.1944810450077057,
0.4112454056739807,
0.24883054196834564,
0.5206773281097412,
-0.33750152587890625,
0.28896012902259827,
-0.05230315402150154,
-0.22280026972293854,
-0.052793148905038834,
0.3175134062767029,
0.5890982151031494,
0.15236903727054596,
-0.331451416015625,
-0.02113460749387741,
-0.7162688374519348,
-0.020916303619742393,
0.07003337144851685,
-0.057845525443553925,
-0.7783030867576599,
0.30099067091941833,
-0.24015894532203674,
0.07786078751087189,
0.057807713747024536,
-0.3089967668056488,
0.19035179913043976,
-0.26835817098617554,
0.4468463361263275,
0.1791156530380249,
0.48611992597579956,
1.0742906332015991,
0.1927877515554428,
0.46961042284965515,
0.42445456981658936,
0.11156574636697769,
-0.28387323021888733,
-0.7278661131858826,
-0.6571133732795715,
-0.036737047135829926,
0.3061198890209198,
0.4966098964214325,
-0.6290267109870911,
0.29672664403915405,
-0.20394384860992432,
-0.47701969742774963,
-0.10098783671855927,
-0.2769702970981598,
0.1897989809513092,
0.508743941783905,
0.2772092819213867,
-0.3389239013195038,
-0.5746175050735474,
-0.7746674418449402,
-0.2936394214630127,
-0.39067792892456055,
-0.1600700169801712,
-0.09269765764474869,
0.6048641800880432,
-0.09602757543325424,
0.8453840017318726,
-0.3214742839336395,
-0.30083122849464417,
-0.18514983355998993,
0.1992085874080658,
-0.2153436541557312,
0.5530600547790527,
0.3581881523132324,
-0.6667712330818176,
0.19056569039821625,
0.22643454372882843,
-0.9783774614334106,
0.22946642339229584,
-0.24294425547122955,
-0.44305509328842163,
0.11899566650390625,
0.5059031248092651,
-0.6071439981460571,
0.5542148947715759,
-0.23715166747570038,
-0.5021555423736572,
0.2639874219894409,
-0.04121079668402672,
0.1297922283411026,
-0.8792555928230286,
-0.08498457074165344,
0.21286801993846893,
0.20933015644550323,
-0.829599142074585,
0.339214026927948,
-0.13673116266727448,
0.1834215521812439,
0.13811814785003662,
0.6696524024009705,
-0.7069002389907837,
-0.07838696986436844,
-0.01946934685111046,
0.33148717880249023,
0.1052660420536995,
0.1484653204679489,
0.11422573029994965,
0.3429301381111145,
0.665503203868866,
-0.8144204616546631,
0.157293900847435,
0.130956768989563,
-0.385140985250473,
0.9843798875808716,
-0.6522229313850403,
-0.0019141508964821696,
-0.4295073449611664,
0.3218100666999817,
-0.663220226764679,
-0.09150663763284683,
0.456292986869812,
-0.46448564529418945,
0.29026681184768677,
-0.19961801171302795,
-0.4226108193397522,
-0.1969478726387024,
0.2838740348815918,
0.46388188004493713,
0.15330670773983002,
0.03817518800497055,
0.6867328882217407,
0.7861616015434265,
-0.13553884625434875,
-0.4532111585140228,
-0.5950713753700256,
0.13587884604930878,
-0.2821440100669861,
-0.40431007742881775,
0.4691236913204193,
0.21232733130455017,
-0.6824133992195129,
0.2179446816444397,
-0.48609375953674316,
-0.16965867578983307,
0.15650974214076996,
0.20768038928508759,
0.2885622978210449,
-0.06302861124277115,
0.3994198143482208,
0.23736640810966492,
-0.062482915818691254,
0.42448896169662476,
-0.8365622758865356,
0.00602200161665678,
0.052481360733509064,
-0.43225839734077454,
-0.54820716381073,
0.47651419043540955,
-0.10436854511499405,
-0.40641969442367554,
0.5518950819969177,
0.31041356921195984,
-0.8502146005630493,
0.024344241246581078,
-0.4929504990577698,
0.017729224637150764,
-0.23518136143684387,
0.4084092676639557,
-0.6352657675743103,
-0.9488396644592285,
0.6219374537467957,
-0.029144082218408585,
0.04574262723326683,
0.5825299024581909,
0.36231133341789246,
-0.14663806557655334,
0.9766371846199036,
0.44767799973487854,
0.19621077179908752,
0.4171099066734314,
-0.32732638716697693,
0.19132106006145477,
-0.9282365441322327,
-0.5237958431243896,
-0.6546977758407593,
-0.16354987025260925,
-0.24211710691452026,
-0.47398632764816284,
0.2709102928638458,
0.3492339551448822,
-0.025167172774672508,
-0.11336226761341095,
-0.6292243003845215,
0.530754804611206,
0.2059207409620285,
-0.2998945415019989,
0.7345395088195801,
-0.16316081583499908,
-0.027671508491039276,
0.20102420449256897,
-0.45435571670532227,
-0.6713544726371765,
1.0339510440826416,
0.20634761452674866,
0.24317379295825958,
-0.3478020429611206,
0.8190429210662842,
0.08197741210460663,
0.07626581192016602,
-0.534925103187561,
0.5609184503555298,
0.49461379647254944,
-1.0738314390182495,
-0.6353825330734253,
-0.26063254475593567,
-0.9246117472648621,
0.42212745547294617,
0.07624390721321106,
-1.0809260606765747,
0.6008447408676147,
-0.0027231131680309772,
-0.2675207555294037,
0.38232704997062683,
-0.6007990837097168,
0.7296701669692993,
0.2861206829547882,
0.15876874327659607,
-0.3986174464225769,
-0.21872471272945404,
0.5379249453544617,
0.19706588983535767,
0.3682703375816345,
-0.2981242537498474,
-0.6345277428627014,
0.8533512949943542,
0.40856868028640747,
0.2737317681312561,
-0.2981686294078827,
-0.19409282505512238,
0.5773826241493225,
-0.09919072687625885,
0.34262919425964355,
0.43942421674728394,
0.19520577788352966,
0.10362013429403305,
0.33017170429229736,
-0.502327561378479,
-0.7083742618560791,
0.3874196708202362,
-0.5376256108283997,
-0.7672295570373535,
-0.21465693414211273,
-0.26932060718536377,
-0.35994407534599304,
0.014704152941703796,
0.14719627797603607,
0.48312920331954956,
-0.6018235087394714,
-0.1852153092622757,
1.0831072330474854,
0.2716534435749054,
0.19138601422309875,
0.07073229551315308,
-0.1690611094236374,
-0.06722845137119293,
0.754695475101471,
0.20688554644584656,
0.09694088995456696,
0.5851737856864929,
-0.46646183729171753,
-0.05484100431203842,
-1.0147929191589355,
-0.10458938032388687,
-0.1452743113040924,
-0.8547574877738953,
-0.0920523852109909,
-0.9931502342224121,
0.03406962379813194,
-0.20275890827178955,
-0.1679454892873764,
-0.04871516302227974,
-0.8227181434631348,
-0.22189289331436157,
-0.33262985944747925,
-0.18711555004119873,
0.6273485422134399,
-0.03918798640370369,
-0.057639751583337784,
-0.264301061630249,
0.38664188981056213,
0.3781895041465759,
0.09751904010772705,
0.3722994923591614,
0.0689852312207222,
-0.18448059260845184,
-0.022580059245228767,
-0.2556166648864746,
-0.6778658628463745,
-0.21615658700466156,
0.15148624777793884,
0.9556049704551697,
0.48614659905433655,
-0.07009537518024445,
0.4659055173397064,
-0.23420189321041107,
0.7312292456626892,
0.32469746470451355,
-1.0884994268417358,
0.9000813961029053,
-0.3447380065917969,
0.04570070281624794,
0.3215499818325043,
0.4526401162147522,
-0.7475308179855347,
-0.377874493598938,
-0.8406878709793091,
-0.9666741490364075,
0.5670062303543091,
0.1916206181049347,
0.04068274796009064,
-0.04183642938733101,
0.5041679739952087,
-0.0940704494714737,
0.12427420169115067,
-0.0818193182349205,
-0.3498111665248871,
-0.06739688664674759,
0.2629901170730591,
-0.06997623294591904,
-0.16985046863555908,
-0.2586570382118225,
-0.5411279201507568,
0.5279143452644348,
-0.07649534940719604,
0.29250985383987427,
0.2075018286705017,
-0.21984411776065826,
0.12703077495098114,
0.5698615908622742,
0.451301634311676,
1.0751960277557373,
0.049372851848602295,
0.047107994556427,
0.28478312492370605,
-0.41946133971214294,
0.22302977740764618,
0.24015365540981293,
-0.4774355888366699,
-0.17433683574199677,
0.1860058605670929,
0.5524856448173523,
0.386833131313324,
-0.300044983625412,
0.1801157295703888,
0.019107533618807793,
-0.1534511297941208,
-0.20600274205207825,
0.25476938486099243,
0.3540465831756592,
0.3632368743419647,
0.618925154209137,
-0.22393798828125,
0.5410162210464478,
-0.723847508430481,
-0.07309767603874207,
0.4308762550354004,
-0.2434203326702118,
-0.3977477550506592,
0.8967784643173218,
0.3278124928474426,
0.47259992361068726,
0.39249667525291443,
-0.5203208327293396,
0.08649266511201859,
0.645748496055603,
0.12937000393867493,
0.7635678052902222,
0.07668818533420563,
0.19359123706817627,
0.4778936505317688,
0.397714763879776,
0.3341480791568756,
0.20982106029987335,
-0.17365209758281708,
-0.9113242030143738,
-0.2747575640678406,
-0.6846333146095276,
-0.3812592625617981,
-0.10981885343790054,
-0.7529100179672241,
-0.1569821685552597,
-0.21474005281925201,
-0.35022851824760437,
0.5542609095573425,
0.07964198291301727,
-0.7811392545700073,
0.196078360080719,
0.37124985456466675,
1.0036100149154663,
-0.34578028321266174,
0.6059324145317078,
1.2643284797668457,
-0.8321220278739929,
-0.3498395085334778,
0.011083121411502361,
-0.13512738049030304,
-0.27393314242362976,
0.4499482214450836,
-0.46659013628959656,
0.2721831500530243,
0.02612203173339367,
-0.3873748481273651,
-0.7994070053100586,
1.147154688835144,
-0.060524147003889084,
-0.2296663075685501,
-0.8004119992256165,
0.10956745594739914,
0.4280588626861572,
-0.7316427230834961,
0.17558149993419647,
1.0439841747283936,
0.5182885527610779,
0.2301107496023178,
-0.7563475966453552,
-0.01858767494559288,
-0.20381198823451996,
0.4778810143470764,
0.30501678586006165,
-0.10504795610904694,
0.42304110527038574,
-0.1396670639514923,
-0.39874646067619324,
-0.1274247169494629,
1.003225326538086,
0.16671140491962433,
0.6349782347679138,
0.2823861241340637,
0.6797454953193665,
0.8458040356636047,
-0.43483662605285645,
0.8026488423347473,
0.09002728015184402,
0.07675899565219879,
0.8161009550094604,
-0.11054176092147827,
0.3714759647846222,
0.2707446813583374,
-0.37546390295028687,
0.41696619987487793,
0.6105691194534302,
0.3298947811126709,
0.2694251537322998,
0.346180260181427,
-0.2627961337566376,
-0.4638194739818573,
-0.3983284533023834,
-0.41885823011398315,
0.4025239646434784,
0.9728150963783264,
-0.013962680473923683,
-0.36850181221961975,
0.007327329367399216,
-0.10262620449066162,
-0.0966133177280426,
-0.8723524808883667,
0.8809852600097656,
0.24062661826610565,
-0.4956657886505127,
0.1077917143702507,
-0.08540715277194977,
0.48828449845314026,
-0.2711755931377411,
0.12580765783786774,
-0.10118574649095535,
-0.1613895297050476,
-0.2447601854801178,
-0.9807722568511963,
0.4602184295654297,
-0.2322131097316742,
-0.36556851863861084,
-0.11361338943243027,
1.1633292436599731,
-0.014218060299754143,
-0.1050291508436203,
0.12201949954032898,
0.8651267290115356,
0.052698202431201935,
-0.36621689796447754,
-0.3677295446395874,
-0.12838919460773468,
-0.3016197085380554,
-0.26076120138168335,
0.49572843313217163,
0.9037739038467407,
-0.3914954662322998,
0.6287022829055786,
0.29537883400917053,
-0.01254781149327755,
0.19114461541175842,
0.016339024528861046,
0.7155316472053528,
-0.710050106048584,
-0.3388708531856537,
-0.3981684446334839,
0.6569591164588928,
-0.15214696526527405,
-0.26591479778289795,
0.3118561804294586,
0.4013269245624542,
1.2415621280670166,
0.10274654626846313,
0.9047755002975464,
-0.17811785638332367,
0.2432597428560257,
-0.14298176765441895,
0.3944665789604187,
-0.4791194498538971,
-0.16856876015663147,
-0.5256218910217285,
-0.6826506853103638,
-0.21099556982517242,
0.15567591786384583,
-0.31193676590919495,
-0.037271980196237564,
0.4514548182487488,
0.1283811330795288,
0.04708492383360863,
0.24133066833019257,
0.22708308696746826,
-0.3423316180706024,
0.18464764952659607,
0.4457721412181854,
1.0861707925796509,
-0.08063677698373795,
0.4096648395061493,
-0.10862389206886292,
-0.0832308679819107,
-0.10347744077444077,
-0.5089254379272461,
-0.7541927099227905,
-1.0302045345306396,
-0.4750031530857086,
0.24978511035442352,
0.19352415204048157,
0.6948003768920898,
0.5688086748123169,
-0.8198382258415222,
-0.14232349395751953,
-0.19168084859848022,
0.43680432438850403,
-0.18860264122486115,
-0.21020099520683289,
-0.03893377631902695,
-0.5953837037086487,
-0.7609869241714478,
-0.049651358276605606,
0.5119260549545288,
0.020297234877943993,
-0.024348236620426178,
0.4065222144126892,
-0.26888078451156616,
0.10634791851043701,
0.840076208114624,
0.36171776056289673,
-0.8590295910835266,
-0.1594814956188202,
-0.27015388011932373,
-0.01849273033440113,
-0.19303303956985474,
0.9115978479385376,
-0.6788089871406555,
0.17821218073368073,
0.4662861227989197,
0.45355454087257385,
0.29509270191192627,
-0.2535063326358795,
0.5539963841438293,
-0.5135838985443115,
0.00006967614172026515,
0.3289449214935303,
0.4085772633552551,
-0.1298564374446869,
-0.40350261330604553,
0.9034783840179443,
0.4213203489780426,
-0.37316617369651794,
-0.7889624834060669,
0.41166457533836365,
-0.9657999873161316,
-0.15680937469005585,
0.7406585812568665,
0.03389263525605202,
0.19286969304084778,
-0.24434101581573486,
0.09319878369569778,
0.2983797788619995,
-0.47266024351119995,
0.5320563912391663,
0.8984467387199402,
-0.6158602237701416,
-0.24997591972351074,
-0.6206606030464172,
0.7308990955352783,
-0.13105863332748413,
-1.3312240839004517,
-0.09827955067157745,
0.5146573781967163,
-0.06460227072238922,
0.47060757875442505,
0.6677645444869995,
-0.08289026468992233,
0.28305119276046753,
-0.08468824625015259,
0.2836492359638214,
0.21219930052757263,
-0.456061452627182,
-0.13871628046035767,
0.26918989419937134,
0.10858043283224106,
-0.028413252905011177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10882v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10882v2
|
SCAR: Efficient Instruction-Tuning for Large Language Models via Style Consistency-Aware Response Ranking
| 2024-06-16T10:10:37 | 2024-07-01T14:55:01 |
Zhuang Li, Yuncheng Hua, Thuy-Trang Vu, Haolan Zhan, Lizhen Qu, Gholamreza Haffari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent studies have shown that maintaining a consistent response style by
human experts and enhancing data quality in training sets can significantly
improve the performance of fine-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) while
reducing the number of training examples needed. However, the precise
definition of style and the relationship between style, data quality, and LLM
performance remains unclear. This research decomposes response style into
presentation and composition styles and finds that, among training data of
similar quality, those with higher style consistency lead to better LLM
performance. Inspired by this, we introduce Style Consistency-Aware Response
Ranking (SCAR), which automatically prioritizes instruction-response pairs in
the training set based on their response stylistic consistency. By selecting
the most style-consistent examples, ranging from the top 25% to 0.7% of the
full dataset, the fine-tuned LLMs can match or even surpass the performance of
models trained on the entire dataset in coding and open-ended
question-answering benchmarks. Code and data are available at
https://github.com/zhuang-li/SCAR .
|
[
-0.5061303377151489,
-0.8639943599700928,
0.2564806640148163,
0.29526758193969727,
-0.1513138711452484,
0.4311049282550812,
-0.45691433548927307,
-0.49107325077056885,
0.2707418203353882,
0.563998818397522,
-0.3902556002140045,
-0.5083467364311218,
-0.5413752198219299,
0.014753193594515324,
-0.35688021779060364,
0.9605047702789307,
0.17552953958511353,
0.13732124865055084,
-0.25596582889556885,
-0.3110401928424835,
-0.33634400367736816,
-0.41278716921806335,
-0.7220629453659058,
-0.043540190905332565,
0.5684463977813721,
0.7351301908493042,
0.6159679889678955,
1.2375988960266113,
0.6753038763999939,
0.296772301197052,
0.14660601317882538,
0.3302243947982788,
-0.5937063097953796,
0.3604123592376709,
-0.19648484885692596,
-0.0006704482948407531,
-0.5443471670150757,
-0.12746118009090424,
0.6036680936813354,
0.5756186246871948,
-0.19469349086284637,
0.17563435435295105,
0.17371393740177155,
0.8114412426948547,
-0.7224658131599426,
-0.2829683721065521,
-0.6572120785713196,
-0.34756800532341003,
0.06962237507104874,
-0.25599396228790283,
-0.6912595629692078,
-0.7687991261482239,
0.27038857340812683,
-0.44679367542266846,
0.17459391057491302,
0.1440039873123169,
0.674363374710083,
0.2874602675437927,
-0.14176088571548462,
-0.29906165599823,
-0.6745743751525879,
0.6601383090019226,
-0.5791842341423035,
0.4355374574661255,
0.42995551228523254,
0.26386940479278564,
0.032091815024614334,
-0.5597690939903259,
-0.392136812210083,
-0.10365679860115051,
-0.08533895015716553,
-0.07989955693483353,
0.008068813011050224,
0.18852689862251282,
0.06612260639667511,
0.4884394705295563,
-0.7665520310401917,
0.12226602435112,
0.08410054445266724,
-0.24256230890750885,
0.5453615188598633,
0.03409271687269211,
0.1020258218050003,
0.3112783133983612,
-0.25974634289741516,
-0.26514387130737305,
-0.6301500797271729,
-0.062202613800764084,
0.3407701551914215,
0.3919108510017395,
0.01915612444281578,
0.5034934282302856,
-0.35325780510902405,
0.9755754470825195,
0.17889705300331116,
-0.2503822445869446,
-0.04483219236135483,
-0.1780644655227661,
-0.23046499490737915,
0.10288506001234055,
0.49682703614234924,
0.35601696372032166,
0.46001309156417847,
-0.2646062970161438,
-0.2599676549434662,
-0.2632806599140167,
0.3928408622741699,
-0.9708359837532043,
-0.41874608397483826,
-0.043535854667425156,
-0.2443406879901886,
-0.25058963894844055,
0.14011114835739136,
-0.8940281867980957,
-0.5217370390892029,
-0.2618870735168457,
0.49182823300361633,
-0.37386277318000793,
-0.23967690765857697,
0.12986958026885986,
0.30093735456466675,
0.187534898519516,
0.15346695482730865,
-0.9142410755157471,
0.2299620360136032,
0.6173834800720215,
0.6148625016212463,
-0.24390853941440582,
0.008653711527585983,
-0.7518139481544495,
0.07919970899820328,
-0.7036855220794678,
0.677416205406189,
-0.7902665734291077,
-0.12376745790243149,
0.1914883553981781,
-0.168925479054451,
0.03623856604099274,
-0.7275181412696838,
0.43229973316192627,
-0.5666773319244385,
0.135183185338974,
-0.2849265933036804,
-0.6302919387817383,
0.12554651498794556,
0.16698618233203888,
-0.5334509015083313,
1.1411374807357788,
0.15266333520412445,
-0.6418747901916504,
0.2577335834503174,
-0.34562918543815613,
-0.5682665705680847,
-0.19779472053050995,
0.1955830305814743,
-0.573989748954773,
-0.023998089134693146,
0.12587209045886993,
0.5348172187805176,
-0.15257905423641205,
0.03716137632727623,
-0.4739789366722107,
-0.5977336168289185,
0.43774911761283875,
-0.21857325732707977,
0.1037425845861435,
0.19716136157512665,
-0.44435015320777893,
0.3751019537448883,
-1.0054072141647339,
0.4370146095752716,
-0.005225250497460365,
-0.5210273861885071,
-0.46745017170906067,
-0.09183052182197571,
-0.15673066675662994,
0.17478257417678833,
0.25191739201545715,
-0.4138493537902832,
0.41731876134872437,
-0.25879353284835815,
0.329688161611557,
1.1580650806427002,
-0.170181542634964,
0.5009753704071045,
-0.36642852425575256,
0.28670161962509155,
-0.4616808593273163,
-0.03981049731373787,
-0.14453230798244476,
-0.12143655866384506,
-1.2358309030532837,
-0.3561323881149292,
0.32869723439216614,
0.4819679260253906,
-0.5388662815093994,
0.37760359048843384,
-0.21553301811218262,
-0.45084258913993835,
-0.7922773361206055,
0.08179939538240433,
0.739983856678009,
0.7787959575653076,
0.49090421199798584,
-0.1511724442243576,
-0.807050883769989,
-1.0017448663711548,
-0.17010463774204254,
-0.1530943065881729,
0.019495921209454536,
0.46198856830596924,
0.09515579044818878,
0.10012871772050858,
0.8937458992004395,
-0.6761776208877563,
0.24591900408267975,
-0.1622590273618698,
0.10547435283660889,
-0.07802537828683853,
0.4471243619918823,
0.3455630838871002,
-0.5316486358642578,
-0.6231982707977295,
-0.09206613153219223,
-0.2886456549167633,
-0.31456249952316284,
0.0528692826628685,
-0.42494598031044006,
0.5514664649963379,
0.4728408455848694,
0.11048807203769684,
0.15163348615169525,
0.676577627658844,
-0.3166339695453644,
0.6363914608955383,
-0.008152658119797707,
0.4115212559700012,
-1.2877662181854248,
0.27228567004203796,
0.01993640512228012,
-0.2364630103111267,
-0.5548251867294312,
0.04442596063017845,
0.056486956775188446,
0.08269620686769485,
-0.19164548814296722,
0.563373863697052,
-0.14117522537708282,
-0.10683262348175049,
-0.25358447432518005,
-0.2678457498550415,
0.0787796601653099,
0.6575801372528076,
0.17772218585014343,
1.1196503639221191,
0.37065020203590393,
-0.6427403688430786,
0.1316378116607666,
0.020125124603509903,
-0.564387321472168,
0.6430763602256775,
-0.7892719507217407,
0.5905891060829163,
0.26454925537109375,
0.026608288288116455,
-1.1434913873672485,
-0.49381422996520996,
0.1405135840177536,
-0.1094883531332016,
0.43743517994880676,
-0.3534436821937561,
-0.5157221555709839,
-0.2582828104496002,
-0.32106876373291016,
0.1335986703634262,
0.4896179437637329,
-0.6241464614868164,
0.2909947633743286,
0.06179307401180267,
-0.2000041902065277,
-1.0088419914245605,
-0.419003427028656,
-0.3196471929550171,
-0.21112275123596191,
-0.48978742957115173,
0.2870752513408661,
-0.704315185546875,
-0.1728852540254593,
-0.3858814835548401,
-0.4208278954029083,
-0.3932887613773346,
0.17461004853248596,
0.03515452519059181,
0.3063680827617645,
-0.31052979826927185,
0.14804910123348236,
-0.0696142390370369,
0.2207942008972168,
-0.18027383089065552,
-0.30604812502861023,
0.8409819602966309,
-0.2001013606786728,
-0.23074641823768616,
-0.36670050024986267,
0.36910855770111084,
0.6871354579925537,
-0.2771483063697815,
0.7685462832450867,
0.43901652097702026,
-0.0287731122225523,
-0.22142064571380615,
-0.7100779414176941,
-0.3160122334957123,
-0.542944610118866,
0.22558818757534027,
-0.23072363436222076,
-1.0269770622253418,
0.3619242012500763,
0.23703737556934357,
0.03337555751204491,
0.02227165922522545,
0.3943248689174652,
-0.24066217243671417,
1.141757845878601,
0.9590452909469604,
-0.19699159264564514,
0.6712803840637207,
-0.004877666477113962,
-0.048587001860141754,
-0.545204222202301,
-0.29132965207099915,
-0.557231605052948,
-0.42987963557243347,
-0.45915737748146057,
-0.2034914195537567,
0.054194506257772446,
0.2982730269432068,
-0.6215178370475769,
0.23416319489479065,
-0.7876148223876953,
0.6573941111564636,
0.550624668598175,
0.16544100642204285,
0.25876763463020325,
0.11421236395835876,
-0.07104930281639099,
0.03256971016526222,
-0.5355125665664673,
-0.4781039357185364,
1.0257176160812378,
0.3170112073421478,
0.975023090839386,
0.039023883640766144,
0.5947216153144836,
0.1915457397699356,
0.023550843819975853,
-0.6942070722579956,
0.6034460067749023,
-0.19385497272014618,
-0.2572065591812134,
-0.25531303882598877,
-0.4881867468357086,
-0.637779176235199,
-0.2665291726589203,
-0.23555217683315277,
-0.4659632444381714,
0.048494406044483185,
0.3759872317314148,
-0.22701731324195862,
0.17576183378696442,
-0.6182247400283813,
0.6205992102622986,
-0.05841488763689995,
-0.34266412258148193,
-0.16161663830280304,
-0.6122649908065796,
0.15509328246116638,
-0.03314153477549553,
-0.10048465430736542,
-0.14237280189990997,
0.02089635469019413,
0.833387017250061,
-0.30137595534324646,
0.5511776208877563,
0.1971866339445114,
-0.08973748981952667,
0.12219066172838211,
0.24715454876422882,
0.4506998360157013,
0.0734647735953331,
-0.14190642535686493,
-0.220057874917984,
-0.30991479754447937,
-0.45216241478919983,
-0.9200786352157593,
0.8615179657936096,
-0.6979325413703918,
-0.5170982480049133,
-0.07154656201601028,
-0.6738998889923096,
-0.40328341722488403,
0.17235751450061798,
0.3144972622394562,
0.638978898525238,
-0.029671818017959595,
0.2733045816421509,
1.2817286252975464,
-0.12479451298713684,
0.48286283016204834,
0.6689751744270325,
-0.04973266273736954,
-0.6029044985771179,
1.0885052680969238,
0.07820556312799454,
0.49483805894851685,
0.4954957067966461,
0.11206353455781937,
-0.16374245285987854,
-0.5730291604995728,
-0.5954058766365051,
0.0709715336561203,
-0.5491094589233398,
-0.37532365322113037,
-0.5131847858428955,
-0.29884928464889526,
-0.4492308795452118,
-0.3765808939933777,
-0.5414568781852722,
-0.49267882108688354,
0.016009962186217308,
0.027447007596492767,
0.6326650977134705,
0.7993791699409485,
0.036405421793460846,
0.25206616520881653,
-0.22809246182441711,
0.12745104730129242,
0.5131036043167114,
0.8793589472770691,
-0.10232816636562347,
-0.6091982126235962,
-0.4420894682407379,
-0.044349074363708496,
-0.15470175445079803,
-0.5498931407928467,
0.052429113537073135,
0.3505648076534271,
0.37251660227775574,
0.5283694267272949,
0.19563966989517212,
0.7773014307022095,
-0.4125247001647949,
0.39159056544303894,
-0.07757283747196198,
-0.841393232345581,
0.6759997010231018,
-0.2832736372947693,
0.12387155741453171,
0.7310841083526611,
0.4510432481765747,
-0.616040050983429,
-0.4501782953739166,
-0.34265023469924927,
-0.8666247725486755,
0.6549243927001953,
-0.09433554857969284,
0.027989039197564125,
0.020724568516016006,
0.30997738242149353,
0.12684562802314758,
0.2258235663175583,
-0.4035927951335907,
-0.46037477254867554,
-0.22375783324241638,
-0.18669670820236206,
0.07992272078990936,
-0.4258880913257599,
-0.3447831869125366,
-0.18255940079689026,
0.6415926814079285,
-0.26609575748443604,
0.3308390974998474,
-0.09363215416669846,
-0.04826594889163971,
-0.05866822972893715,
0.3737647831439972,
0.8654279708862305,
0.6624876856803894,
-0.3219967484474182,
0.15187929570674896,
-0.004335378762334585,
-0.5319675803184509,
0.18742938339710236,
-0.04828497767448425,
0.10883734375238419,
-0.17037135362625122,
0.4231511950492859,
0.5688270330429077,
0.22684665024280548,
-0.7638035416603088,
0.22162245213985443,
-0.08486641198396683,
0.14495378732681274,
0.15374845266342163,
0.3125135004520416,
-0.17660142481327057,
-0.01616068370640278,
0.4022599458694458,
0.04062158241868019,
0.03631516173481941,
-0.5326530933380127,
0.44382670521736145,
0.3040063977241516,
-0.3521939218044281,
0.03858563303947449,
0.3951995074748993,
0.1638578474521637,
-0.3333739936351776,
0.6468715667724609,
0.03621653467416763,
-0.4245997965335846,
0.5542230010032654,
0.6126827001571655,
0.5981207489967346,
-0.4999817907810211,
0.30160897970199585,
0.40160655975341797,
0.03686601296067238,
-0.14273060858249664,
0.16794493794441223,
0.06867975741624832,
-0.4850185215473175,
-0.4900275468826294,
-0.6822243332862854,
-0.5134785771369934,
0.18240323662757874,
-0.9398718476295471,
0.2194252908229828,
-0.7357922196388245,
0.23397818207740784,
-0.2913503050804138,
0.045646823942661285,
-0.24874795973300934,
0.36235132813453674,
0.11884395033121109,
1.0232582092285156,
-0.6571601629257202,
0.9572403430938721,
0.6754989624023438,
-0.21395163238048553,
-1.045007586479187,
0.20306360721588135,
-0.2368009239435196,
-0.7986846566200256,
0.2847636342048645,
0.182134747505188,
-0.2890405058860779,
0.08659526705741882,
-0.65793776512146,
-1.0493072271347046,
0.8069799542427063,
0.8361185193061829,
-0.5231031179428101,
0.15226534008979797,
0.01570378616452217,
0.4778437912464142,
-0.43666955828666687,
0.34536975622177124,
0.6971123814582825,
0.2689409554004669,
0.37800368666648865,
-0.8440182209014893,
-0.15985921025276184,
-0.26014572381973267,
-0.06611904501914978,
0.24397800862789154,
-0.5811042189598083,
0.4653739035129547,
-0.149231418967247,
-0.012150139547884464,
0.40215224027633667,
0.6821443438529968,
0.37456244230270386,
0.2639388144016266,
0.29534903168678284,
0.5461329817771912,
0.8443814516067505,
-0.43012702465057373,
0.958285927772522,
-0.406975120306015,
0.014367864467203617,
1.1631582975387573,
0.07371344417333603,
0.9668843746185303,
0.08195523917675018,
0.24700020253658295,
0.8137820959091187,
0.9064016342163086,
0.12237013876438141,
0.8020725250244141,
0.1820114105939865,
-0.2339194118976593,
-0.3997868001461029,
-0.2918098270893097,
-0.551068902015686,
0.558857798576355,
0.016872819513082504,
-0.41421425342559814,
0.2605251967906952,
-0.030125221237540245,
0.16995951533317566,
0.4430531859397888,
-0.40503692626953125,
0.8255023956298828,
-0.43120652437210083,
-0.6111999154090881,
0.9896647334098816,
-0.05363147333264351,
0.7790419459342957,
-0.6818274259567261,
-0.18353399634361267,
-0.5538020133972168,
0.04795775189995766,
-0.1881018877029419,
-0.8779646158218384,
0.18457110226154327,
0.03641895577311516,
-0.6411632895469666,
-0.22233334183692932,
0.4459644854068756,
-0.6352085471153259,
-0.3616621792316437,
0.07438696920871735,
0.07227964699268341,
-0.04146965220570564,
0.198679119348526,
-0.6131422519683838,
0.4784976541996002,
-0.2208789587020874,
-0.2119019776582718,
0.4826207160949707,
0.20575188100337982,
0.05012831464409828,
0.9581080079078674,
0.4258030951023102,
-0.22520402073860168,
-0.05384208634495735,
-0.004035706166177988,
0.906354546546936,
-0.30764836072921753,
-0.1787983626127243,
-0.890829861164093,
0.4842553436756134,
-0.2362021505832672,
-0.37698203325271606,
0.5951486825942993,
0.7406606674194336,
0.8487864136695862,
0.05600832775235176,
0.4945743978023529,
0.1172717735171318,
0.6356878280639648,
-0.5506863594055176,
0.8211939930915833,
-0.35368162393569946,
0.18592989444732666,
-0.5992634892463684,
-1.0017375946044922,
-0.1750023365020752,
0.775373637676239,
-0.10005628317594528,
0.18266189098358154,
0.4599476456642151,
0.9336017966270447,
0.13218119740486145,
-0.269825279712677,
0.25392717123031616,
0.09383943676948547,
0.06853851675987244,
0.49825218319892883,
0.5385633707046509,
-0.028701208531856537,
0.8049455285072327,
-0.47014540433883667,
-0.1204419657588005,
-0.33615976572036743,
-0.8222731947898865,
-0.7731763124465942,
-0.7086386680603027,
-0.3551943004131317,
-0.5825965404510498,
0.36363840103149414,
0.9642255306243896,
1.1092884540557861,
-0.9311892986297607,
-0.2681064009666443,
0.11274509131908417,
0.24841497838497162,
-0.35976874828338623,
-0.231172114610672,
0.45912760496139526,
-0.2052467167377472,
-0.8203481435775757,
0.4569993317127228,
0.24890300631523132,
0.09656322747468948,
-0.10733874142169952,
-0.21538786590099335,
0.02518509514629841,
0.4079936146736145,
0.6050010323524475,
0.3580857813358307,
-0.6910732388496399,
-0.5143135786056519,
0.43803098797798157,
-0.48510563373565674,
0.05150741711258888,
0.8490841388702393,
-0.7898926734924316,
0.5938308238983154,
0.2146778404712677,
0.8818700313568115,
0.05366155877709389,
0.08623512834310532,
0.6114999055862427,
-1.017530083656311,
-0.1705808788537979,
0.26832494139671326,
0.005708890501409769,
0.4316001534461975,
-0.4476536214351654,
0.6728534698486328,
-0.037333447486162186,
-0.7090363502502441,
-0.9008651375770569,
0.2436191439628601,
-1.1015812158584595,
-0.3094187378883362,
1.098468542098999,
-0.30895817279815674,
0.1495833694934845,
0.024638516828417778,
-0.27026569843292236,
0.2161424458026886,
-0.5550596714019775,
0.9533805251121521,
0.6859607696533203,
-0.2302185446023941,
-0.2888181507587433,
-0.2081775814294815,
0.7163251042366028,
0.4065777361392975,
-0.6588529944419861,
0.32227545976638794,
0.46228212118148804,
0.4236617982387543,
-0.06971890479326248,
0.44063031673431396,
0.3728574216365814,
0.3437606692314148,
-0.4807848334312439,
0.01935039460659027,
-0.26213160157203674,
-0.6560863256454468,
-0.1307450383901596,
0.26807859539985657,
0.2305866926908493,
-0.18902653455734253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10881v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10881v1
|
Teaching Large Language Models to Express Knowledge Boundary from Their Own Signals
| 2024-06-16T10:07:20 | 2024-06-16T10:07:20 |
Lida Chen, Zujie Liang, Xintao Wang, Jiaqing Liang, Yanghua Xiao, Feng Wei, Jinglei Chen, Zhenghong Hao, Bing Han, Wei Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved great success, but their
occasional content fabrication, or hallucination, limits their practical
application. Hallucination arises because LLMs struggle to admit ignorance due
to inadequate training on knowledge boundaries. We call it a limitation of LLMs
that they can not accurately express their knowledge boundary, answering
questions they know while admitting ignorance to questions they do not know. In
this paper, we aim to teach LLMs to recognize and express their knowledge
boundary, so they can reduce hallucinations caused by fabricating when they do
not know. We propose CoKE, which first probes LLMs' knowledge boundary via
internal confidence given a set of questions, and then leverages the probing
results to elicit the expression of the knowledge boundary. Extensive
experiments show CoKE helps LLMs express knowledge boundaries, answering known
questions while declining unknown ones, significantly improving in-domain and
out-of-domain performance.
|
[
-0.5810151696205139,
-0.8067272901535034,
0.7464512586593628,
0.4087086617946625,
0.030009187757968903,
0.20418907701969147,
-0.4505665600299835,
-0.4638320505619049,
0.06078974902629852,
0.6094343662261963,
-0.5288739204406738,
-0.455177903175354,
-0.6364314556121826,
-0.1147012934088707,
-0.3314657509326935,
0.7301473021507263,
-0.07416881620883942,
0.09446662664413452,
-0.406185120344162,
0.42958930134773254,
-0.48050105571746826,
-0.660004734992981,
-0.5213697552680969,
-0.514768660068512,
0.3176346719264984,
0.1913231462240219,
0.44448283314704895,
0.3972579836845398,
0.12973518669605255,
0.2316424548625946,
-0.03236457332968712,
0.2918262779712677,
-0.8231157064437866,
0.23904502391815186,
-0.18859881162643433,
-0.5320079922676086,
0.0014128577895462513,
-0.10267801582813263,
0.5386857986450195,
1.1441606283187866,
0.1832018345594406,
-0.22795461118221283,
0.2388320416212082,
0.449052095413208,
-0.3770478367805481,
0.3470211327075958,
-0.9373427629470825,
0.04354581981897354,
0.19809770584106445,
-0.21684549748897552,
-0.6330007314682007,
-0.39202526211738586,
-0.01946667954325676,
-0.38152140378952026,
-0.10629110038280487,
0.14054732024669647,
0.807046115398407,
0.2824224531650543,
-0.393825888633728,
-0.628661572933197,
-0.7171405553817749,
0.6814131140708923,
-0.38586875796318054,
0.574167013168335,
0.29442450404167175,
0.26333773136138916,
-0.4320903420448303,
-0.5539419054985046,
-0.6088742613792419,
-0.1415930986404419,
-0.03030170127749443,
-0.13276351988315582,
0.08366461843252182,
-0.06580676883459091,
0.16580656170845032,
0.1329987496137619,
-0.30751198530197144,
0.006687180604785681,
-0.6093630194664001,
-0.48734185099601746,
0.5598834753036499,
0.12140976637601852,
0.05697052925825119,
0.010950660333037376,
-0.6840621829032898,
0.09263620525598526,
-0.8893934488296509,
-0.1762704998254776,
0.18308918178081512,
0.3900774419307709,
0.15552230179309845,
0.5473899841308594,
0.07464918494224548,
0.7791346907615662,
-0.06474791467189789,
-0.14451971650123596,
0.00346204312518239,
0.5403542518615723,
-0.3256586492061615,
0.1116051971912384,
0.6419377326965332,
0.305336058139801,
0.5102818012237549,
-0.3308362066745758,
-0.09116725623607635,
0.10384499281644821,
0.011801237240433693,
-0.7999926805496216,
-0.30301356315612793,
0.3784066438674927,
-0.09252063930034637,
0.22477036714553833,
-0.15889643132686615,
-0.7779660820960999,
-0.7429206967353821,
-0.26309382915496826,
0.6766387820243835,
-0.5373393893241882,
-0.18389032781124115,
0.36960548162460327,
-0.31688952445983887,
0.2821347117424011,
0.41230538487434387,
-0.7848890423774719,
0.5703961849212646,
0.5982526540756226,
0.6791591048240662,
-0.013610121794044971,
-0.17991924285888672,
-0.41182997822761536,
0.31200042366981506,
-0.4858601689338684,
0.8433902263641357,
-0.41990524530410767,
-0.27755385637283325,
-0.007208494935184717,
-0.19514118134975433,
-0.060546278953552246,
-0.8274030089378357,
0.10715749114751816,
-0.551815927028656,
0.1250474900007248,
-0.5073046684265137,
-0.8715969920158386,
-0.23274338245391846,
0.3032708764076233,
-0.21890972554683685,
0.7282472848892212,
0.1778789907693863,
-0.357430636882782,
0.12959100306034088,
-0.3842594027519226,
-0.4652040898799896,
-0.02048688940703869,
-0.2658045291900635,
0.09681660681962967,
0.06489427387714386,
0.31678879261016846,
0.6037697792053223,
-0.037181660532951355,
0.24786905944347382,
-0.08289392292499542,
-0.3327008783817291,
0.28155964612960815,
-0.15380056202411652,
0.5965230464935303,
0.26831603050231934,
-0.22658175230026245,
0.07266376167535782,
-0.29717904329299927,
0.2309400588274002,
0.05953633412718773,
-0.22223348915576935,
-0.36033234000205994,
-0.07221414893865585,
-0.25204846262931824,
0.34472203254699707,
0.21110686659812927,
-0.36798182129859924,
0.3512372076511383,
-0.4915553629398346,
0.1875142902135849,
0.9154115915298462,
0.04934041202068329,
0.2871486246585846,
-0.4977565109729767,
0.4497729539871216,
0.04922344535589218,
-0.04745309799909592,
0.21650809049606323,
-0.5907243490219116,
-0.8563624620437622,
-0.22061914205551147,
-0.006188919767737389,
0.4078284502029419,
-0.7233503460884094,
0.4088377058506012,
-0.21427345275878906,
-0.5190087556838989,
-0.4915101230144501,
0.48708832263946533,
0.18248328566551208,
0.6738156080245972,
0.34671124815940857,
-0.13446363806724548,
-0.6742289662361145,
-0.7980014085769653,
-0.2842537760734558,
-0.03677884489297867,
-0.0963992327451706,
0.37369269132614136,
0.5279900431632996,
0.06336095929145813,
0.8843070864677429,
-0.609259307384491,
-0.6036965250968933,
-0.39530372619628906,
0.05482413247227669,
0.11618047952651978,
0.1700369417667389,
0.15173035860061646,
-0.7439277768135071,
-0.5557763576507568,
-0.13920840620994568,
-0.8613213300704956,
-0.1484472155570984,
-0.0971587598323822,
-0.15676264464855194,
0.1339879184961319,
0.5303715467453003,
-0.5109336972236633,
0.06269355118274689,
0.6833627223968506,
-0.32198140025138855,
0.5608090162277222,
-0.029891453683376312,
0.038701437413692474,
-0.7445087432861328,
-0.45925262570381165,
-0.23949800431728363,
-0.20576442778110504,
-0.527780294418335,
-0.1809121072292328,
0.02345898561179638,
-0.029340265318751335,
-0.6853698492050171,
0.8521298170089722,
-0.7451542019844055,
0.0011812013108283281,
-0.36246052384376526,
0.3829863369464874,
0.05301555246114731,
0.47260573506355286,
0.3660918176174164,
0.6217962503433228,
0.8221572041511536,
-0.9074043035507202,
0.17971502244472504,
0.34484219551086426,
-0.569408118724823,
0.43165940046310425,
-0.31612223386764526,
0.19201698899269104,
-0.23172526061534882,
0.008431710302829742,
-0.9415858387947083,
-0.20171810686588287,
0.2706688642501831,
-0.4863722324371338,
0.3220090866088867,
-0.2878669202327728,
-0.33501845598220825,
-0.3777325451374054,
-0.10042955726385117,
0.05754534900188446,
0.832216739654541,
-0.6914103627204895,
0.7397449612617493,
0.5541715621948242,
0.1625514179468155,
-0.5406557321548462,
-0.7307774424552917,
0.14724227786064148,
-0.31942570209503174,
-0.7412593364715576,
0.11743463575839996,
-0.223357692360878,
-0.3725532293319702,
-0.07960150390863419,
-0.13528263568878174,
-0.0786636546254158,
-0.021736623719334602,
0.3050377070903778,
-0.04162729158997536,
0.04670221731066704,
0.39561888575553894,
-0.04397955909371376,
0.27143824100494385,
0.5632295608520508,
-0.4066276252269745,
1.190229892730713,
-0.04053536057472229,
-0.18557709455490112,
-0.18850062787532806,
0.23813556134700775,
0.40052586793899536,
-0.06561314314603806,
0.8969841003417969,
0.35478270053863525,
-0.5031074285507202,
-0.7872316837310791,
-0.5270388126373291,
-0.4016779065132141,
-0.5526819825172424,
0.3556731939315796,
-0.6680653095245361,
-0.879088819026947,
0.6063845753669739,
-0.4098808169364929,
-0.36456286907196045,
0.23269575834274292,
0.7485400438308716,
-0.07606694847345352,
0.7656404972076416,
0.525595486164093,
0.07614602148532867,
-0.10930714756250381,
-0.376527339220047,
0.4457898736000061,
-1.0488344430923462,
-0.5397796034812927,
-0.4057788848876953,
-0.11992179602384567,
-0.18162694573402405,
-0.6714329719543457,
0.5271966457366943,
0.12190958857536316,
-0.16875030100345612,
0.06867130100727081,
-0.5410635471343994,
0.5995176434516907,
0.3997403681278229,
0.268748939037323,
0.1812092661857605,
-0.01729770377278328,
-0.042849909514188766,
-0.24241000413894653,
-0.6741361021995544,
-0.5807328820228577,
0.8750672340393066,
0.4507690370082855,
1.3511037826538086,
-0.003044877666980028,
0.7376325130462646,
0.13722050189971924,
0.39402374625205994,
-1.0306706428527832,
0.6027966141700745,
0.27717992663383484,
-0.8293756246566772,
-0.33041995763778687,
-0.5781280398368835,
-0.6705543994903564,
0.16839927434921265,
-0.034790415316820145,
-0.8074659109115601,
0.10790158063173294,
0.12649942934513092,
-0.072304867208004,
0.6144976019859314,
-0.7112259864807129,
0.5985015034675598,
-0.4384877383708954,
-0.4113651514053345,
0.2074032574892044,
-0.2720661461353302,
0.5305038690567017,
-0.07320290803909302,
0.3627220094203949,
0.012873160652816296,
-0.0156334787607193,
0.9223659038543701,
-0.21783451735973358,
1.2390931844711304,
-0.35789626836776733,
-0.5970834493637085,
0.5200456976890564,
0.5023398399353027,
0.49410656094551086,
-0.1423795223236084,
-0.015322699211537838,
-0.028827615082263947,
-0.3711096942424774,
-0.16618303954601288,
-0.7162793874740601,
0.7596439123153687,
-0.6061565279960632,
-0.9972141981124878,
-0.3606735169887543,
-0.9487348198890686,
-0.556705117225647,
0.164774551987648,
0.2267443686723709,
0.0922178253531456,
0.15033496916294098,
-0.08200695365667343,
0.8658921122550964,
-0.2635161876678467,
0.09415194392204285,
0.11318060010671616,
-0.6085947751998901,
-0.09389032423496246,
0.7672693729400635,
0.13709430396556854,
0.49971404671669006,
0.23326323926448822,
0.26616325974464417,
-0.6193268299102783,
-0.5315167307853699,
-0.060452330857515335,
0.4639880359172821,
-1.2056821584701538,
-0.1680109053850174,
-0.8553541302680969,
-0.3645235300064087,
-0.8326772451400757,
-0.2703709304332733,
-0.34411922097206116,
-0.148593008518219,
-0.02529327943921089,
0.022887373343110085,
0.2796464264392853,
0.9870736002922058,
-0.1738651990890503,
0.2244885414838791,
-0.41925179958343506,
0.303238183259964,
0.4335079491138458,
0.301571249961853,
0.057392023503780365,
-0.7046020030975342,
-0.0782148614525795,
0.12096630781888962,
-0.13924485445022583,
-0.9891319870948792,
0.5045309662818909,
0.006146122235804796,
0.5073842406272888,
0.4119655191898346,
0.4130373001098633,
0.7497360110282898,
-0.33599844574928284,
0.6592134237289429,
-0.02047676593065262,
-1.3675132989883423,
0.5227457284927368,
-0.1834949105978012,
-0.019435493275523186,
0.07328429073095322,
0.9469678997993469,
-0.600424587726593,
-0.6892476081848145,
-0.2332209199666977,
-0.7413743734359741,
0.12235397100448608,
-0.19871491193771362,
0.3480748236179352,
-0.22485798597335815,
0.10938851535320282,
0.18904094398021698,
0.26620352268218994,
-1.0359275341033936,
-0.14421863853931427,
-0.10456226021051407,
-0.09345787018537521,
0.1821555346250534,
-0.3734169006347656,
-0.3398057520389557,
-0.29258736968040466,
0.7955787181854248,
-0.1828940212726593,
0.44925203919410706,
0.41967177391052246,
-0.2725857198238373,
-0.048382047563791275,
0.2125719040632248,
0.516403317451477,
0.8983001112937927,
-0.15394707024097443,
0.4670083224773407,
0.1725732833147049,
-0.14893165230751038,
0.09048813581466675,
-0.30825844407081604,
0.06251359730958939,
-0.2978310286998749,
0.33564379811286926,
0.5093238353729248,
-0.28552210330963135,
-0.8917894959449768,
0.4062858521938324,
0.22195391356945038,
-0.40477505326271057,
-0.5057084560394287,
0.2535233199596405,
0.43182894587516785,
0.2286733239889145,
0.2873493432998657,
-0.19893863797187805,
-0.2228996902704239,
-0.7192172408103943,
0.24316182732582092,
0.5244243144989014,
-0.6179072260856628,
0.15101522207260132,
0.7123695611953735,
-0.07205245643854141,
-0.27631688117980957,
0.7561931014060974,
-0.25869250297546387,
-0.944255530834198,
0.5079717040061951,
0.9662232398986816,
0.23171065747737885,
-0.13157504796981812,
0.14879561960697174,
0.17094890773296356,
0.5206472277641296,
0.1827305555343628,
0.479869544506073,
0.032775506377220154,
-1.0619298219680786,
-0.4282515347003937,
-0.5580317974090576,
-0.35201495885849,
0.3197624683380127,
-0.49153441190719604,
0.2172359973192215,
-0.6331733465194702,
0.1330515593290329,
-0.354398638010025,
-0.13813836872577667,
-0.5599454641342163,
0.3490735590457916,
0.14066970348358154,
1.0355613231658936,
-1.0118308067321777,
0.6620042324066162,
0.33949461579322815,
-0.2875560224056244,
-0.8598471879959106,
-0.10513652116060257,
-0.17233900725841522,
-1.1117740869522095,
0.9057421088218689,
0.2061837911605835,
-0.20838458836078644,
0.03316314518451691,
-0.7806645035743713,
-0.6491832137107849,
0.6141512989997864,
0.2811393439769745,
-0.40210968255996704,
0.07139630615711212,
0.2900316119194031,
0.36820685863494873,
-0.5465714931488037,
-0.04759018123149872,
0.29582253098487854,
0.749493420124054,
0.24485650658607483,
-0.796434760093689,
0.29226192831993103,
0.043813079595565796,
-0.45456942915916443,
0.0036536443512886763,
-0.567641019821167,
1.0032342672348022,
-0.5188018083572388,
-0.24203118681907654,
-0.11804435402154922,
0.6129205822944641,
0.13215771317481995,
0.11019070446491241,
0.5136104822158813,
0.2743982672691345,
1.0362510681152344,
-0.3597738742828369,
0.9507260918617249,
-0.09169834852218628,
0.17315508425235748,
1.2173659801483154,
-0.4948384165763855,
0.6467106342315674,
0.6409045457839966,
0.0638364851474762,
0.4269534945487976,
0.4697715640068054,
-0.05939971283078194,
0.4650766849517822,
0.8442487120628357,
-0.31850096583366394,
-0.3658870756626129,
-0.2712230682373047,
-0.3367142975330353,
0.4638550281524658,
0.7329586744308472,
-0.23729319870471954,
-0.062159422785043716,
0.2938992977142334,
0.4181620478630066,
0.4069731533527374,
-0.36236315965652466,
0.6491004824638367,
0.13645558059215546,
-0.5333413481712341,
0.9908779859542847,
-0.27773430943489075,
0.6367000937461853,
-0.6576796174049377,
0.048092279583215714,
-0.2145281732082367,
0.11688335239887238,
-0.2080286592245102,
-0.8890931606292725,
0.3231509327888489,
-0.29490748047828674,
0.03259168565273285,
-0.24655966460704803,
0.6206725835800171,
-0.7065383791923523,
-0.35093775391578674,
0.554492175579071,
0.5158822536468506,
0.508950412273407,
-0.3884236216545105,
-0.20793086290359497,
0.22768308222293854,
-0.01765744760632515,
-0.08180670440196991,
0.07008533179759979,
0.5573394298553467,
0.07481616735458374,
1.0780324935913086,
0.3685941696166992,
0.5257505178451538,
0.3122631311416626,
0.1004355400800705,
0.957302451133728,
-0.6739687919616699,
-0.3010324239730835,
-0.6128285527229309,
0.2906884253025055,
-0.07752697169780731,
0.02527746930718422,
0.7968553900718689,
0.6230700016021729,
0.9836416840553284,
-0.3059697449207306,
1.0153405666351318,
-0.17233823239803314,
0.35050541162490845,
-0.8238435387611389,
0.9260673522949219,
-0.4662288427352905,
0.3456856608390808,
0.030309969559311867,
-0.8896731734275818,
-0.34823933243751526,
0.7633106112480164,
-0.49001458287239075,
0.2813633680343628,
0.8952628970146179,
0.9406180381774902,
0.17122754454612732,
-0.1950453370809555,
0.6439023017883301,
0.7352180480957031,
0.40397098660469055,
0.9631573557853699,
1.2081435918807983,
-0.25950297713279724,
0.5566922426223755,
-0.4343542456626892,
-0.15614266693592072,
0.2410375475883484,
-0.737148642539978,
-1.400557518005371,
-0.7296199798583984,
-0.08364725857973099,
-0.5089542269706726,
-0.005672896280884743,
0.7680257558822632,
0.9246814846992493,
-0.6140644550323486,
-0.43418607115745544,
0.33542606234550476,
0.29297852516174316,
-0.061457548290491104,
-0.3197439908981323,
0.43725094199180603,
-0.6119427680969238,
-0.8472195267677307,
0.515306293964386,
0.04772786796092987,
0.14277063310146332,
-0.504036545753479,
-0.14337576925754547,
-0.09667463600635529,
0.10718610137701035,
0.5895850658416748,
0.10183624178171158,
-0.5264846086502075,
-0.5045010447502136,
0.0342230424284935,
0.17978224158287048,
0.010005115531384945,
0.8402323722839355,
-0.7478790879249573,
0.22712953388690948,
0.15644487738609314,
0.6036179661750793,
0.3800869882106781,
-0.22618313133716583,
0.4990159571170807,
-0.7122243642807007,
0.13493487238883972,
0.4187772870063782,
0.2643347978591919,
0.4802228510379791,
-0.5340954661369324,
0.23532868921756744,
0.08695878833532333,
-0.38300856947898865,
-0.6455209851264954,
0.3906960189342499,
-0.7914340496063232,
-0.6108457446098328,
1.218451976776123,
0.08239147067070007,
-0.5655053853988647,
-0.3789427876472473,
-0.21005600690841675,
0.15826010704040527,
-0.11596154421567917,
1.069359540939331,
0.7861921191215515,
-0.2135685682296753,
0.06814970076084137,
-0.3726453483104706,
0.6575415730476379,
0.16541628539562225,
-0.9125249981880188,
0.3048463761806488,
0.3712569773197174,
0.5077268481254578,
0.011066284030675888,
0.6746333241462708,
-0.09471321105957031,
-0.11495090276002884,
0.11434097588062286,
0.3345237374305725,
-0.17700694501399994,
-0.6536992788314819,
0.06518744677305222,
0.44805461168289185,
0.16201864182949066,
-0.0020708125084638596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10880v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10880v1
|
Exploring the Potential of Multimodal LLM with Knowledge-Intensive Multimodal ASR
| 2024-06-16T10:04:19 | 2024-06-16T10:04:19 |
Minghan Wang, Yuxia Wang, Thuy-Trang Vu, Ehsan Shareghi, Gholamreza Haffari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have made
significant progress in integrating information across various modalities, yet
real-world applications in educational and scientific domains remain
challenging. This paper introduces the Multimodal Scientific ASR (MS-ASR) task,
which focuses on transcribing scientific conference videos by leveraging visual
information from slides to enhance the accuracy of technical terminologies.
Realized that traditional metrics like WER fall short in assessing performance
accurately, prompting the proposal of severity-aware WER (SWER) that considers
the content type and severity of ASR errors. We propose the Scientific Vision
Augmented ASR (SciVASR) framework as a baseline method, enabling MLLMs to
improve transcript quality through post-editing. Evaluations of
state-of-the-art MLLMs, including GPT-4o, show a 45% improvement over
speech-only baselines, highlighting the importance of multimodal information
integration.
|
[
-0.011393839493393898,
-0.4190739393234253,
0.42128103971481323,
0.3450072109699249,
-0.221059650182724,
0.5922940969467163,
-0.38220447301864624,
-0.3779924809932709,
0.05678778141736984,
0.10851501673460007,
-0.3019552230834961,
-0.426459401845932,
-0.9129989743232727,
0.09362208843231201,
-0.4113624393939972,
0.8672645688056946,
-0.2598433792591095,
0.5455600023269653,
-0.6564717292785645,
-0.12977640330791473,
-0.052156269550323486,
-0.5330120325088501,
-0.329217791557312,
-0.1510506123304367,
0.6653276681900024,
0.19128160178661346,
0.3063462972640991,
0.41088637709617615,
0.9969311952590942,
0.35630282759666443,
-0.1827227920293808,
0.5044148564338684,
-0.1376459002494812,
0.08975367993116379,
-0.21519115567207336,
-0.2370195835828781,
-0.3763869106769562,
-0.005863481666892767,
0.8835805654525757,
0.6468336582183838,
-0.09936968982219696,
0.2324390560388565,
0.15868572890758514,
0.26474612951278687,
-0.5613934993743896,
0.2997411787509918,
-0.33953002095222473,
0.19210179150104523,
-0.0800609439611435,
-0.6060224771499634,
-0.32366642355918884,
0.08761680126190186,
0.19332243502140045,
-0.6768125295639038,
0.12116292864084244,
-0.08132749795913696,
0.6156580448150635,
0.4545799493789673,
-0.6668495535850525,
-0.3522009551525116,
-0.7922233939170837,
0.8801941275596619,
-0.5029979348182678,
0.8057094216346741,
0.04488923400640488,
0.3536713123321533,
0.050822120159864426,
-0.8328012228012085,
-0.5748286843299866,
-0.27379295229911804,
0.19393280148506165,
0.25394168496131897,
-0.1404651403427124,
0.2291135936975479,
0.2263375073671341,
-0.0705021470785141,
-0.5679289698600769,
0.010206202045083046,
-0.9870014190673828,
-0.33160334825515747,
0.3961292505264282,
0.16367563605308533,
0.22988039255142212,
-0.04636039212346077,
-0.4661129415035248,
0.005690444260835648,
-0.3179719150066376,
0.03588319569826126,
-0.20566001534461975,
0.16590791940689087,
0.040707845240831375,
0.9715067148208618,
0.05806104838848114,
0.650009274482727,
-0.22851945459842682,
-0.5185875296592712,
0.22314047813415527,
-0.8170657753944397,
-0.038847312331199646,
0.1642460972070694,
0.743580162525177,
0.7076936364173889,
-0.13463011384010315,
0.12635356187820435,
-0.021058185026049614,
0.48315712809562683,
0.08609446883201599,
-0.8342989087104797,
-0.11940744519233704,
-0.03266049176454544,
-0.2844133675098419,
-0.06576626747846603,
-0.13919541239738464,
-0.7070679068565369,
-0.4087528884410858,
-0.5143122673034668,
0.6607550382614136,
-0.6181001663208008,
-0.03041549026966095,
-0.05605791136622429,
-0.27735307812690735,
-0.16963624954223633,
0.8086842894554138,
-0.5045230984687805,
-0.030471887439489365,
0.3221186399459839,
1.11591637134552,
-0.18068867921829224,
-0.2982712686061859,
-0.6140178442001343,
0.5261393785476685,
-0.031196514144539833,
0.755928099155426,
-0.5988264083862305,
-0.5391400456428528,
-0.36435213685035706,
-0.3341951072216034,
-0.12263950705528259,
-0.1676483005285263,
0.29404300451278687,
-0.4809513986110687,
0.1437602937221527,
-0.014202401041984558,
-0.2947004735469818,
-0.11598430573940277,
0.36997756361961365,
-0.2873038351535797,
0.7078970074653625,
-0.27214208245277405,
-0.5232384204864502,
0.4356411099433899,
-0.9635659456253052,
-0.2918759286403656,
0.05837719142436981,
-0.31800413131713867,
0.0014246584614738822,
-0.042228296399116516,
0.05168381705880165,
0.3677097260951996,
-0.06740248948335648,
0.4881612956523895,
0.06492289900779724,
-0.0671376883983612,
0.49208107590675354,
-0.629563570022583,
0.07573671638965607,
0.32232239842414856,
-0.09890629351139069,
0.5850726962089539,
-1.0299708843231201,
-0.13277548551559448,
-0.4629049301147461,
-0.47680792212486267,
-0.2558911442756653,
0.1219886839389801,
0.33552980422973633,
0.5052107572555542,
0.37146779894828796,
-0.7199650406837463,
-0.003259750548750162,
-0.011628684587776661,
0.6527144908905029,
0.7769026160240173,
-0.4338062107563019,
0.3552495837211609,
-0.1368003636598587,
0.35221126675605774,
0.29162144660949707,
0.25971516966819763,
-0.1295156627893448,
-0.4998427927494049,
-0.6833500266075134,
-0.5884400606155396,
0.09523950517177582,
0.4307979643344879,
-1.1411912441253662,
-0.12542864680290222,
-0.5101714134216309,
-0.5065724849700928,
-0.7325200438499451,
0.2635852098464966,
0.48455050587654114,
0.5743287801742554,
0.6175256967544556,
-0.36309176683425903,
-0.6655769944190979,
-0.6327553391456604,
-0.03959725424647331,
-0.0884162113070488,
-0.06835594773292542,
0.3110284209251404,
0.4183737337589264,
-0.4363568425178528,
0.7690937519073486,
-0.2512167990207672,
-0.4307377338409424,
-0.020516861230134964,
0.2517836391925812,
0.14197571575641632,
0.40981945395469666,
-0.15077945590019226,
-0.972996175289154,
-0.4570867121219635,
0.20666378736495972,
-0.9062240123748779,
0.21724970638751984,
0.0555451400578022,
0.5393913984298706,
0.2762114107608795,
0.39131346344947815,
-0.6888242959976196,
0.28268328309059143,
0.6673944592475891,
-0.2990921437740326,
0.5190525054931641,
-0.5237160921096802,
0.5616859793663025,
-0.7011959552764893,
0.13535737991333008,
0.17129270732402802,
0.004687806125730276,
-0.8732554316520691,
-0.066600501537323,
0.1380062997341156,
-0.07639215141534805,
-0.7350290417671204,
0.3891359865665436,
-0.4921877682209015,
-0.09349638968706131,
-0.16559532284736633,
0.32628577947616577,
0.159225195646286,
0.06884853541851044,
0.07243771106004715,
0.8779997229576111,
0.5586743354797363,
-0.41668590903282166,
0.48895663022994995,
0.36677759885787964,
-0.4601322114467621,
0.566293478012085,
-0.5175272822380066,
-0.17218373715877533,
-0.3765835165977478,
0.2429986596107483,
-0.6579349040985107,
-0.3572859764099121,
-0.001939045381732285,
-0.3477187156677246,
0.5087505578994751,
0.10804320871829987,
-0.4151262044906616,
-0.30558332800865173,
-0.36340177059173584,
0.33877429366111755,
0.1928226500749588,
-0.36416903138160706,
0.912446916103363,
0.18874412775039673,
-0.4749419689178467,
-0.8180787563323975,
-0.6883229613304138,
0.3926168978214264,
-0.04721688851714134,
-0.8054568767547607,
0.504000186920166,
-0.39112454652786255,
-0.2153824418783188,
-0.048081278800964355,
-0.23977889120578766,
0.06185683235526085,
-0.3542639911174774,
0.32639041543006897,
0.5923725366592407,
-0.2705942988395691,
-0.038820959627628326,
-0.07358179986476898,
0.03923101723194122,
-0.2293609082698822,
-0.043603699654340744,
0.3632642924785614,
-0.2847641706466675,
-0.5461667776107788,
-0.5703097581863403,
0.29766845703125,
0.7783638834953308,
-0.14491240680217743,
0.4628647267818451,
0.7737557888031006,
-0.19294872879981995,
0.4655236005783081,
-0.7989745736122131,
-0.2355496883392334,
-0.47151535749435425,
0.5364065766334534,
-0.3875200152397156,
-1.1094425916671753,
0.22568301856517792,
0.03981444984674454,
-0.13192084431648254,
0.18128615617752075,
0.27461346983909607,
-0.4433111250400543,
1.0832610130310059,
0.5509674549102783,
0.33414798974990845,
0.4706924259662628,
-0.12891320884227753,
0.11601369082927704,
-0.9026250839233398,
-0.7125952243804932,
-0.22852471470832825,
-0.2122553437948227,
-0.2918521463871002,
-1.0391755104064941,
0.6977126002311707,
-0.01495567336678505,
-0.08287470042705536,
0.015624035149812698,
-0.4618777632713318,
0.35884931683540344,
0.5528141856193542,
0.17054173350334167,
0.5752478241920471,
0.09995556622743607,
0.08973944932222366,
-0.40906649827957153,
-0.7889183759689331,
-0.579833984375,
0.9440077543258667,
0.2970397174358368,
0.8307607769966125,
-0.009718439541757107,
0.1549341082572937,
0.14238794147968292,
0.3636637032032013,
-0.6072663068771362,
0.4721228778362274,
-0.3965378403663635,
-0.3971332311630249,
-0.26302504539489746,
-0.4651356041431427,
-0.42331987619400024,
0.4266381859779358,
-0.18111824989318848,
-0.38993462920188904,
0.08193864673376083,
0.22375372052192688,
-0.3555256128311157,
0.2078554481267929,
-0.47035840153694153,
0.6960527300834656,
-0.5505461096763611,
-0.34099069237709045,
-0.348958820104599,
-1.0486539602279663,
0.1697031557559967,
-0.17725853621959686,
0.7355807423591614,
0.021322203800082207,
-0.2408255785703659,
0.8505845069885254,
0.04020525887608528,
0.8752003312110901,
-0.18215511739253998,
0.17365290224552155,
0.12541218101978302,
-0.239254891872406,
0.2845747768878937,
-0.21566042304039001,
0.05721840634942055,
0.2583952248096466,
0.1837172508239746,
-0.04530966654419899,
-0.49564725160598755,
0.6961544752120972,
-0.8234081268310547,
-0.606224536895752,
-0.5333862900733948,
-0.746731162071228,
-0.20284436643123627,
-0.01916028931736946,
0.07038325071334839,
0.5565291047096252,
-0.01579895243048668,
0.284262090921402,
0.6540425419807434,
-0.19961601495742798,
0.3248901069164276,
0.6520313024520874,
-0.13402263820171356,
-0.5984855890274048,
1.1885051727294922,
0.27367398142814636,
0.36525776982307434,
0.5180619359016418,
-0.02765273116528988,
-0.28395286202430725,
-0.7427296042442322,
-0.4894237816333771,
0.17524465918540955,
-0.8883613348007202,
-0.2909270226955414,
-1.0870479345321655,
-0.3761399984359741,
-0.421246200799942,
-0.326830118894577,
-0.24595138430595398,
-0.5788063406944275,
-0.6956294178962708,
-0.06100952625274658,
0.4024718105792999,
0.4511793553829193,
-0.3005553185939789,
0.26431804895401,
-0.9996524453163147,
0.25136151909828186,
0.17460455000400543,
0.12805530428886414,
-0.4620276987552643,
-0.8092475533485413,
-0.11037888377904892,
0.18776370584964752,
-0.36682260036468506,
-0.32349851727485657,
0.6829926371574402,
0.710578978061676,
0.5148037075996399,
0.32580652832984924,
-0.48933419585227966,
1.0179122686386108,
-0.7168859243392944,
0.9709944128990173,
0.7861973643302917,
-0.8209899067878723,
0.5629228353500366,
0.019493935629725456,
0.1979120671749115,
0.40966376662254333,
0.5661001801490784,
-0.5399285554885864,
-0.44314807653427124,
-0.20593971014022827,
-0.8457883596420288,
0.45220521092414856,
-0.34689077734947205,
0.10382143408060074,
0.27899739146232605,
-0.21447396278381348,
0.07147103548049927,
0.45431625843048096,
-0.6187537908554077,
0.02056989073753357,
-0.7027080655097961,
-0.2631063461303711,
-0.4428742527961731,
-0.20245441794395447,
-0.285066694021225,
-0.2526613771915436,
0.5283218026161194,
-0.20405767858028412,
-0.002422274788841605,
0.2565101981163025,
-0.42768004536628723,
-0.1523217111825943,
0.5367132425308228,
1.0181986093521118,
0.6821004748344421,
-0.2288358360528946,
0.5521721243858337,
0.08949577063322067,
-0.6528799533843994,
0.0701826810836792,
0.22860988974571228,
0.1729303002357483,
0.04324277490377426,
0.33992186188697815,
0.7114337086677551,
0.5501443147659302,
-1.0305452346801758,
0.5451666712760925,
0.26730087399482727,
-0.17585235834121704,
-0.06815014779567719,
-0.09022730588912964,
0.05691976845264435,
0.4819050133228302,
0.6194216012954712,
0.4324454367160797,
0.34599560499191284,
-0.45542144775390625,
0.2785605192184448,
0.4932819604873657,
-0.5778795480728149,
-0.40032851696014404,
0.8761376738548279,
0.11613353341817856,
-0.0007130280719138682,
0.314948171377182,
0.2677282691001892,
-0.49409952759742737,
0.31390580534935,
0.580697774887085,
0.08748451620340347,
-0.4580872356891632,
0.21222233772277832,
0.1953134387731552,
0.2685029208660126,
-0.10673635452985764,
0.4151052236557007,
0.07261915504932404,
-0.6593233346939087,
-0.8383654952049255,
-0.8488436341285706,
-0.5190513730049133,
-0.3141763508319855,
-0.4528611898422241,
0.2788810431957245,
-0.4311547577381134,
-0.2834252715110779,
0.2705388367176056,
-0.4531967341899872,
-0.3687768876552582,
0.17085088789463043,
0.17126145958900452,
0.786281406879425,
-0.6297269463539124,
0.7485020756721497,
0.8750088810920715,
-0.4199402630329132,
-0.39337000250816345,
-0.8274247050285339,
0.1895495504140854,
-0.6251772046089172,
1.273648738861084,
0.018500788137316704,
-0.24248456954956055,
0.03440888226032257,
-0.42880356311798096,
-1.0531814098358154,
1.3613957166671753,
0.12642626464366913,
-0.8034255504608154,
-0.1226714700460434,
0.0704367458820343,
0.641414999961853,
-0.18574762344360352,
0.2636393904685974,
0.05478367581963539,
0.5733899474143982,
0.6551447510719299,
-1.20802903175354,
-0.2626718580722809,
-0.3132874071598053,
-0.09832475334405899,
-0.015633584931492805,
-0.48432499170303345,
0.583918035030365,
-0.3916850686073303,
-0.052334655076265335,
-0.31740012764930725,
0.8200234770774841,
0.4360918700695038,
0.697939395904541,
0.24008111655712128,
0.09274829924106598,
0.5784993767738342,
0.030016031116247177,
0.6271987557411194,
-0.20788167417049408,
-0.04354730248451233,
0.8489047884941101,
-0.388058602809906,
0.8375208377838135,
1.0167862176895142,
-0.17939962446689606,
0.2342013567686081,
0.263809472322464,
-0.2702783942222595,
0.6376334428787231,
0.06270759552717209,
-0.7507203221321106,
-0.09353926032781601,
-0.554399311542511,
-0.36358195543289185,
0.5418263077735901,
0.7685853838920593,
-0.22144992649555206,
0.027448363602161407,
0.6374965310096741,
-0.26368090510368347,
0.02526887319982052,
-0.5656984448432922,
0.6494026780128479,
0.2045668214559555,
-0.15067726373672485,
0.2588588297367096,
-0.14355722069740295,
1.192699670791626,
-0.6761533617973328,
-0.02268895134329796,
0.22570598125457764,
0.02958814427256584,
-0.32583558559417725,
-0.7646690607070923,
0.36086204648017883,
0.19025632739067078,
-0.3514748215675354,
-0.4793546199798584,
0.7684314250946045,
-0.8528353571891785,
-0.6051140427589417,
0.1643008291721344,
0.3254980146884918,
0.28182005882263184,
0.13538391888141632,
-0.2975939214229584,
0.2950570285320282,
-0.129121333360672,
-0.06111292541027069,
0.4090910851955414,
0.1347394734621048,
-0.11166869103908539,
0.9643392562866211,
0.8033102750778198,
0.09384352713823318,
0.14948436617851257,
0.07411517202854156,
0.9387813806533813,
-0.4547431766986847,
0.0028091035783290863,
-0.7136365175247192,
0.7768062949180603,
-0.05067450553178787,
0.04829848185181618,
0.7888196706771851,
0.7296603322029114,
0.6249897480010986,
-0.22643494606018066,
0.6861534714698792,
0.013257183134555817,
0.27207764983177185,
-0.4907175898551941,
0.7908720374107361,
-0.5181242227554321,
0.11366202682256699,
-0.31545233726501465,
-0.45252352952957153,
-0.6885107755661011,
0.5630043745040894,
-0.17127297818660736,
-0.294175922870636,
0.6356008052825928,
0.8772082924842834,
-0.043077047914266586,
0.02209068275988102,
0.593684196472168,
0.3185199797153473,
0.28744760155677795,
0.1727323830127716,
1.2181495428085327,
-0.2956294119358063,
0.7380026578903198,
-0.13853707909584045,
-0.43899112939834595,
-0.26687705516815186,
-0.882323682308197,
-0.6840855479240417,
-0.5823817849159241,
-0.46897682547569275,
-0.1652626246213913,
0.135458305478096,
1.0612629652023315,
0.507235050201416,
-0.7217587828636169,
-0.11328646540641785,
0.4603954255580902,
-0.2388801872730255,
0.02493731863796711,
-0.1644904464483261,
0.2726518213748932,
-0.09485413134098053,
-0.4349387586116791,
0.838824450969696,
0.6275205612182617,
0.13492217659950256,
-0.09894724935293198,
-0.07575607299804688,
-0.27019840478897095,
-0.07016945630311966,
1.1132526397705078,
0.0071038599126040936,
-0.8490299582481384,
-0.46530255675315857,
0.34765779972076416,
-0.10279197245836258,
0.05115214362740517,
0.6200724840164185,
-0.4572736918926239,
0.6436287760734558,
0.10327060520648956,
0.3447163999080658,
0.7616586685180664,
-0.3026939332485199,
0.3818148076534271,
-0.7222400307655334,
-0.07860883325338364,
0.3383340835571289,
0.2589308023452759,
0.630018413066864,
-0.13723339140415192,
0.4048846364021301,
0.36790525913238525,
-0.46028459072113037,
-1.0582436323165894,
-0.18451949954032898,
-1.404071569442749,
-0.10490210354328156,
1.1122950315475464,
-0.09120958298444748,
0.02285873517394066,
-0.0843968465924263,
-0.2928747236728668,
0.19494958221912384,
-0.2796153724193573,
0.7039830088615417,
0.6572111248970032,
-0.20790107548236847,
-0.47397157549858093,
-0.6469268798828125,
0.23190826177597046,
0.0501834936439991,
-0.7356285452842712,
-0.3342010974884033,
0.6974306106567383,
0.3106682300567627,
0.6686574816703796,
0.4669039249420166,
-0.21975146234035492,
0.35076773166656494,
-0.10578606277704239,
0.3282961845397949,
-0.35099515318870544,
-0.5026874542236328,
-0.2750016152858734,
0.2310873121023178,
-0.0717758908867836,
0.19438239932060242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10878v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10878v1
|
Demonstration Notebook: Finding the Most Suited In-Context Learning Example from Interactions
| 2024-06-16T10:02:20 | 2024-06-16T10:02:20 |
Yiming Tang, Bin Dong
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) benefit greatly from prompt engineering, with
in-context learning standing as a pivital technique. While former approaches
have provided various ways to construct the demonstrations used for in-context
learning, they often ignore the inherent heterogeneity within datasets,
applying the same demonstrations to all reasoning questions. We observed that
the effectiveness of demonstrations varies depending on the specific question.
This motivates our exploration of using prompt engineering to select
appropriate demonstrations. To address the challenge of automatically creating
and choosing demonstrations tailored to each question, we propose a novel
prompt engineering workflow built around a novel object called the
"demonstration notebook." This notebook helps identify the most suitable
in-context learning example for a question by gathering and reusing information
from the LLM's past interactions. Our experiments show that this approach
outperforms all existing methods for automatic demonstration construction and
selection (as far as we know), achieving state-of-the-art results on serveral
reasoning benchmarks. The method's versatility is further demonstrated by its
success in text summarization and prompt compression tasks. Additionally, we
contribute a rigorous analysis method to reveal the "demonstrative regime" of a
demonstration, providing valuable insights into how demonstrations relate to
different question types within a dataset.
|
[
-0.4870319366455078,
-1.0248597860336304,
0.6447080373764038,
0.4901236891746521,
-0.05132876709103584,
-0.010092194192111492,
-0.24445708096027374,
0.0734146237373352,
-0.04092354327440262,
0.052939195185899734,
-0.5806089043617249,
-0.41823479533195496,
-0.03789912909269333,
0.28615471720695496,
-0.4021357297897339,
0.8953270316123962,
-0.3148121237754822,
-0.2245427370071411,
-0.7684765458106995,
0.03906387463212013,
-0.6853317022323608,
-0.3634131848812103,
-0.7541314959526062,
-0.31819668412208557,
0.36687636375427246,
0.7351213693618774,
0.2761279046535492,
0.299533486366272,
-0.02687809057533741,
0.3588297367095947,
-0.19606740772724152,
0.26488783955574036,
-0.24577952921390533,
0.47674304246902466,
-0.19117434322834015,
-0.22687777876853943,
0.058039065450429916,
0.17448760569095612,
0.6987681984901428,
0.9703574180603027,
0.13805770874023438,
0.0979057103395462,
0.22244714200496674,
0.15214304625988007,
-0.5522716641426086,
0.08942072838544846,
-0.37466543912887573,
0.15817521512508392,
0.08592865616083145,
-0.23130318522453308,
-0.8032488822937012,
-0.2575346827507019,
0.12180294096469879,
-0.5792044401168823,
-0.03816908970475197,
0.19444043934345245,
0.6304084062576294,
0.04920144006609917,
-0.5857044458389282,
-0.2067793607711792,
-0.6072070598602295,
0.8396751284599304,
-0.3365240693092346,
0.12499716877937317,
0.11314873397350311,
0.7293874621391296,
-0.48454588651657104,
-0.9521055817604065,
-0.5647459030151367,
-0.5075799226760864,
-0.124418705701828,
0.17737868428230286,
0.06280798465013504,
-0.10932686179876328,
0.5236368775367737,
0.11341854929924011,
-0.5327605605125427,
0.22891031205654144,
-0.1933080106973648,
-0.3020084500312805,
0.3392516076564789,
0.13271865248680115,
0.3089272379875183,
-0.3405373990535736,
-0.45234695076942444,
-0.18575438857078552,
-0.8245195150375366,
0.31121522188186646,
0.061941590160131454,
0.12548893690109253,
0.07251051813364029,
0.5064430236816406,
-0.25472399592399597,
0.805637538433075,
0.10874511301517487,
0.010756582953035831,
0.08275550603866577,
-0.1574118435382843,
-0.31821852922439575,
0.006423190701752901,
0.7122935652732849,
0.289020299911499,
-0.18365004658699036,
0.059249646961688995,
-0.2196446657180786,
-0.3526248037815094,
0.03036203421652317,
-0.9209752678871155,
-0.1840781569480896,
0.1644749790430069,
-0.43186575174331665,
-0.305192768573761,
-0.12792052328586578,
-0.7404105067253113,
-0.4909258186817169,
-0.4057694971561432,
0.45260000228881836,
-0.20108962059020996,
-0.1292923390865326,
-0.27190500497817993,
-0.3332579433917999,
0.07583250105381012,
0.49920234084129333,
-0.6967827677726746,
0.26247677206993103,
0.6269630193710327,
0.8338190317153931,
-0.22820702195167542,
-0.5179504752159119,
-1.066003680229187,
0.003447315888479352,
-0.3737868368625641,
0.8860123157501221,
-0.4867991805076599,
-0.6799607276916504,
0.12779736518859863,
0.1013164073228836,
-0.003782927058637142,
-0.5502932667732239,
0.4207095205783844,
-0.3097195625305176,
0.5951270461082458,
-0.19931913912296295,
-0.7596284747123718,
-0.07107691466808319,
0.15275701880455017,
-0.438731849193573,
0.95741206407547,
0.04874066635966301,
-0.5985613465309143,
0.37754032015800476,
-0.7717257142066956,
-0.42769041657447815,
0.09777913242578506,
-0.4911234676837921,
-0.3775782585144043,
-0.07905144989490509,
0.03300831839442253,
0.8195798397064209,
-0.13803979754447937,
0.2676183879375458,
-0.23137043416500092,
-0.3027482032775879,
0.3658204972743988,
-0.22726844251155853,
0.8553885817527771,
0.0986260250210762,
-0.2887212038040161,
0.36166033148765564,
-0.6298087239265442,
-0.28654032945632935,
0.15933504700660706,
-0.08658889681100845,
-0.3934865891933441,
-0.08680357784032822,
-0.18058112263679504,
0.21562470495700836,
0.04505842924118042,
-0.33711478114128113,
0.2417532205581665,
-0.35712459683418274,
0.3909643590450287,
0.6645823121070862,
0.32152581214904785,
0.5524542331695557,
-0.520624577999115,
0.692653477191925,
-0.35368871688842773,
0.09187591075897217,
-0.5677544474601746,
-0.43383297324180603,
-0.3770923912525177,
-0.1740397810935974,
-0.04007042571902275,
0.3438582420349121,
-0.7776963710784912,
0.046204131096601486,
0.03615989536046982,
-0.447601318359375,
0.12412252277135849,
0.051490988582372665,
0.32338637113571167,
1.1326723098754883,
0.32377588748931885,
0.206691712141037,
-0.45948806405067444,
-0.9788230657577515,
-0.09691512584686279,
-0.31264710426330566,
-0.04708443954586983,
0.46343138813972473,
0.35292771458625793,
0.13525228202342987,
1.096469759941101,
-0.3786465525627136,
0.22808654606342316,
-0.577313244342804,
0.45467397570610046,
0.3105142116546631,
0.46870890259742737,
0.6340940594673157,
-0.8956320881843567,
-0.577509343624115,
0.02670598216354847,
-0.7474193572998047,
-0.3132105767726898,
-0.5513008832931519,
-0.19032685458660126,
0.010568665340542793,
0.811712384223938,
-0.5413205027580261,
0.22530652582645416,
0.15360870957374573,
-0.1637561321258545,
0.8875952959060669,
-0.2572622299194336,
0.1461571902036667,
-1.1505128145217896,
-0.08647212386131287,
0.03984168544411659,
-0.2860208749771118,
-0.5864547491073608,
-0.103966124355793,
0.24847030639648438,
-0.21915076673030853,
-0.5693464279174805,
0.8852648138999939,
-0.4747954308986664,
-0.051620129495859146,
-0.3662906885147095,
0.3383442163467407,
-0.021429095417261124,
0.3201937675476074,
0.06320324540138245,
1.1179896593093872,
0.7014729380607605,
-0.7990929484367371,
0.49271222949028015,
0.5939324498176575,
-0.3529275059700012,
0.5687602162361145,
-0.6897050142288208,
-0.06123920902609825,
-0.07358883321285248,
0.4561196565628052,
-1.097772479057312,
-0.4764504134654999,
-0.018599366769194603,
-0.35631582140922546,
0.2560924291610718,
-0.1900465190410614,
-0.2799793779850006,
-0.22621282935142517,
-0.4120642840862274,
0.04680324345827103,
0.7013118863105774,
-1.025075912475586,
0.6116092801094055,
0.11319848150014877,
-0.4778355062007904,
-0.49926191568374634,
-0.24940228462219238,
0.057053640484809875,
-0.5475563406944275,
-0.44518551230430603,
0.4052383005619049,
-0.2767634391784668,
-0.34479302167892456,
-0.5223265886306763,
-0.1401190310716629,
0.07077756524085999,
0.506605327129364,
0.5388451814651489,
0.3205873966217041,
-0.06497129797935486,
0.3483007550239563,
0.3786349296569824,
0.08704100549221039,
0.24566863477230072,
-0.019906405359506607,
0.38988199830055237,
-0.08834202587604523,
-0.323403924703598,
-0.4300125241279602,
0.44859904050827026,
0.28554269671440125,
0.052720312029123306,
0.3657143712043762,
0.09784339368343353,
-0.3046881854534149,
-0.6663686633110046,
-0.179940864443779,
-0.2580029368400574,
-0.5501744747161865,
0.27567923069000244,
-0.5385048985481262,
-0.565500020980835,
0.2653028070926666,
-0.6092000603675842,
0.3021778166294098,
0.01702885888516903,
0.37587475776672363,
-0.20439882576465607,
0.8732010722160339,
0.4840035140514374,
0.11865536868572235,
0.7257038354873657,
-0.23532485961914062,
0.03878440335392952,
-0.7184478640556335,
-0.28043752908706665,
-0.6028956770896912,
-0.06011687591671944,
-0.1264185756444931,
-0.22821860015392303,
0.4486488401889801,
0.19148214161396027,
-0.33703169226646423,
0.2996675372123718,
-0.2410968542098999,
0.7147138714790344,
0.5169260501861572,
-0.03949141502380371,
0.05741676688194275,
-0.1097491905093193,
-0.38941526412963867,
0.14225426316261292,
-0.538307785987854,
-0.8932180404663086,
0.679316520690918,
0.005374472588300705,
0.4324765205383301,
0.051765311509370804,
0.7692995667457581,
0.2633073329925537,
0.4768351912498474,
-0.6182178854942322,
0.8655466437339783,
0.25324147939682007,
0.03457806631922722,
-0.39825931191444397,
-0.27354973554611206,
-1.008504033088684,
0.1015235111117363,
-0.00980772078037262,
-0.8087440133094788,
-0.07183309644460678,
0.30094003677368164,
-0.3094639778137207,
-0.13663537800312042,
-0.8724381923675537,
1.1877535581588745,
-0.01472970750182867,
-0.47557711601257324,
0.018640225753188133,
-0.6375889182090759,
0.2641144096851349,
0.1866074949502945,
0.17959481477737427,
0.3888809084892273,
0.078140988945961,
0.5955130457878113,
-0.4507254660129547,
0.8276680707931519,
-0.30560970306396484,
-0.2656496465206146,
0.27559465169906616,
0.31260040402412415,
0.6198872923851013,
0.14196963608264923,
-0.06670218706130981,
-0.7133633494377136,
-0.372485488653183,
-0.20595557987689972,
-1.0191528797149658,
0.8361414074897766,
-0.400059312582016,
-0.856883704662323,
-0.09139292687177658,
-0.2932884693145752,
-0.400717556476593,
0.00831403024494648,
0.06907405704259872,
0.7407992482185364,
-0.32553377747535706,
0.20720669627189636,
0.728060781955719,
-0.40199559926986694,
0.7872720956802368,
0.3191360533237457,
-0.4799792766571045,
-0.08920034766197205,
1.0219181776046753,
-0.2566278278827667,
0.36723756790161133,
0.5973013639450073,
0.3914729654788971,
-0.3098844587802887,
-0.5318597555160522,
-0.561816394329071,
-0.04752447083592415,
-1.0224157571792603,
-0.013400483876466751,
-0.7736496925354004,
-0.013063061982393265,
-0.24863822758197784,
-0.5330991744995117,
0.0690014660358429,
-0.6176042556762695,
-0.35783302783966064,
-0.28262558579444885,
0.10562487691640854,
0.5251451134681702,
0.2072148323059082,
0.20043708384037018,
-0.4313546121120453,
0.09192672371864319,
0.7696767449378967,
-0.16160891950130463,
-0.029243234544992447,
-0.49104073643684387,
0.07028726488351822,
-0.2065388560295105,
-0.5199209451675415,
-1.0185009241104126,
0.15866875648498535,
0.2021598219871521,
0.8974825143814087,
0.4012570381164551,
0.1828659176826477,
0.34171828627586365,
-0.5177379846572876,
1.131568193435669,
0.017908083274960518,
-0.9757845997810364,
0.8822425007820129,
-0.2525431215763092,
0.08786658197641373,
0.33433887362480164,
0.616460919380188,
-0.5793845653533936,
-0.37444382905960083,
-0.6223140954971313,
-0.8405221104621887,
0.3613813817501068,
0.028205227106809616,
0.060244109481573105,
-0.1215757206082344,
0.25018951296806335,
0.4071834087371826,
0.15228822827339172,
-0.48165103793144226,
-0.09805052727460861,
-0.27729398012161255,
-0.23049423098564148,
0.08399466425180435,
0.06654123216867447,
-0.1533576399087906,
-0.08285045623779297,
0.8042071461677551,
-0.49359583854675293,
0.10772981494665146,
0.16070391237735748,
-0.36496201157569885,
0.40313851833343506,
0.24956387281417847,
0.7294860482215881,
0.7360256910324097,
0.05237444490194321,
0.1859952211380005,
0.3242064416408539,
-0.09141716361045837,
0.18474707007408142,
0.15978719294071198,
-0.1516529619693756,
0.10650491714477539,
0.3210563659667969,
0.7946127653121948,
0.1872665286064148,
-0.9628533720970154,
0.8883320689201355,
-0.1793847531080246,
-0.037470027804374695,
-0.3864862322807312,
0.21684443950653076,
-0.11272687464952469,
0.2987067401409149,
0.33344945311546326,
-0.21500040590763092,
0.3033353090286255,
-0.5058341026306152,
0.1679023951292038,
0.3921228051185608,
-0.14721685647964478,
-0.1991402506828308,
0.6362127065658569,
0.289032906293869,
-0.4923228621482849,
0.3694036304950714,
-0.3863089978694916,
-0.3743278384208679,
0.9665807485580444,
0.6150326132774353,
0.7761087417602539,
-0.062496285885572433,
0.576288640499115,
0.3213561177253723,
-0.21315723657608032,
-0.12563088536262512,
0.2186744213104248,
-0.47711122035980225,
-0.4267652928829193,
-0.4820581078529358,
-0.0963146835565567,
-0.8277137875556946,
0.005800954066216946,
-0.5547768473625183,
0.5040841102600098,
-0.39503049850463867,
0.23993563652038574,
0.15948761999607086,
-0.17437896132469177,
-0.4175223708152771,
0.029434068128466606,
-0.013739440590143204,
1.0925542116165161,
-0.9775604009628296,
0.4873112738132477,
0.9890778660774231,
-0.44576236605644226,
-0.6619429588317871,
0.01259518414735794,
-0.04348824545741081,
-0.3437071442604065,
0.8473713994026184,
0.37068137526512146,
0.11269807070493698,
-0.11799822002649307,
-0.760429322719574,
-0.19770105183124542,
1.1267032623291016,
0.26429930329322815,
-0.2657060921192169,
0.21571293473243713,
-0.41104617714881897,
0.2805761694908142,
-0.5480353832244873,
0.6050554513931274,
0.15626370906829834,
0.20593540370464325,
0.09615194797515869,
-0.8146708607673645,
0.21940620243549347,
-0.275176465511322,
-0.06546763330698013,
-0.0513247512280941,
-0.8057260513305664,
0.6464671492576599,
-0.22571870684623718,
-0.2257116138935089,
0.31600216031074524,
0.89155513048172,
0.5597355961799622,
0.6509650945663452,
0.6538667678833008,
-0.11250194907188416,
0.9504067301750183,
0.08375100046396255,
1.109413743019104,
0.06038053333759308,
-0.007008131127804518,
1.309416651725769,
-0.4806950092315674,
0.675222635269165,
0.6531152725219727,
-0.026675323024392128,
0.6606488823890686,
0.7607403993606567,
0.24472549557685852,
0.48736631870269775,
0.43452152609825134,
-0.4643368422985077,
-0.3618590235710144,
-0.2549038231372833,
-0.093927301466465,
0.08183915913105011,
0.15857675671577454,
-0.11066482216119766,
-0.27174797654151917,
0.5522740483283997,
-0.057551562786102295,
0.3464679419994354,
-0.13709762692451477,
0.7633036375045776,
-0.178680419921875,
-0.7899226546287537,
0.4751761853694916,
-0.3692106604576111,
0.2088261842727661,
-0.3742392361164093,
-0.35548797249794006,
-0.4859958589076996,
-0.30997106432914734,
0.0575890876352787,
-0.7230409979820251,
-0.05188177153468132,
-0.016298778355121613,
-0.10169651359319687,
-0.6769839525222778,
0.5056013464927673,
-0.1885678768157959,
-0.0094339270144701,
-0.12534502148628235,
0.43788665533065796,
0.41321301460266113,
0.17148098349571228,
-0.1835021674633026,
-0.1911430060863495,
-0.1471998691558838,
-0.3732328712940216,
0.4216282367706299,
0.749415934085846,
-0.22914989292621613,
0.8620014190673828,
0.3814411461353302,
-0.20115308463573456,
-0.17775827646255493,
0.20117123425006866,
1.0533643960952759,
-0.5565332770347595,
-0.5481833219528198,
-0.6516739726066589,
0.573176383972168,
-0.6463601589202881,
-0.34481772780418396,
0.8981238603591919,
0.733735203742981,
0.8050272464752197,
-0.13115525245666504,
0.9967868328094482,
0.07730250805616379,
0.6546423435211182,
-0.6130272746086121,
0.19914653897285461,
-0.4456941485404968,
0.31143999099731445,
-0.25611817836761475,
-0.6653865575790405,
-0.09139541536569595,
0.6929521560668945,
-0.1664714217185974,
-0.15063776075839996,
0.8897563219070435,
0.7588474154472351,
-0.20395715534687042,
0.4098435342311859,
0.1912938356399536,
0.22001874446868896,
0.6817838549613953,
0.4833390414714813,
1.3071553707122803,
-0.045768704265356064,
0.5238109230995178,
-0.23258498311042786,
-0.41533055901527405,
-0.1888929158449173,
-1.2725105285644531,
-1.2593743801116943,
-0.7733311057090759,
-0.4800812304019928,
-0.15675228834152222,
-0.05485524982213974,
1.3981132507324219,
0.6264756321907043,
-0.568414032459259,
-0.16249778866767883,
-0.29099372029304504,
0.3418438136577606,
-0.38784921169281006,
-0.21539618074893951,
0.2811565399169922,
-0.6342465281486511,
-0.8056315183639526,
0.9108266830444336,
0.1091349720954895,
0.395175576210022,
-0.1864488571882248,
-0.012210533022880554,
-0.027265658602118492,
-0.15276043117046356,
0.5800092816352844,
0.47720572352409363,
-0.4005165100097656,
-0.18750548362731934,
-0.03818788751959801,
0.19482259452342987,
-0.1741851419210434,
1.049707293510437,
-1.0681129693984985,
0.2601073980331421,
0.5195325613021851,
0.9879211187362671,
0.45283666253089905,
-0.10650260746479034,
0.6416945457458496,
-0.9470987319946289,
0.18995922803878784,
0.17700980603694916,
0.48684871196746826,
0.36645904183387756,
-0.31330716609954834,
0.1739104688167572,
0.1237991452217102,
-0.7049089670181274,
-0.9199763536453247,
0.2834254205226898,
-0.9117167592048645,
-0.4413015842437744,
1.2725313901901245,
-0.28789716958999634,
-0.21255190670490265,
-0.1312468945980072,
-0.6517598032951355,
0.0354049876332283,
-0.41882896423339844,
0.8983095288276672,
0.678100049495697,
-0.2511902153491974,
-0.22698481380939484,
-0.5900810360908508,
0.4962271451950073,
0.4438158869743347,
-1.0999494791030884,
0.1339702308177948,
0.658771812915802,
0.06329473108053207,
-0.013626312837004662,
0.26991334557533264,
0.4289151728153229,
0.34308451414108276,
-0.29076361656188965,
-0.3663027286529541,
-0.1962837278842926,
-0.5825585722923279,
-0.3112695515155792,
0.408900648355484,
0.03350798413157463,
-0.19152699410915375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10873v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10873v1
|
Optimizing Automatic Speech Assessment: W-RankSim Regularization and Hybrid Feature Fusion Strategies
| 2024-06-16T09:55:21 | 2024-06-16T09:55:21 |
Chung-Wen Wu, Berlin Chen
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Automatic Speech Assessment (ASA) has seen notable advancements with the
utilization of self-supervised features (SSL) in recent research. However, a
key challenge in ASA lies in the imbalanced distribution of data, particularly
evident in English test datasets. To address this challenge, we approach ASA as
an ordinal classification task, introducing Weighted Vectors Ranking Similarity
(W-RankSim) as a novel regularization technique. W-RankSim encourages closer
proximity of weighted vectors in the output layer for similar classes, implying
that feature vectors with similar labels would be gradually nudged closer to
each other as they converge towards corresponding weighted vectors. Extensive
experimental evaluations confirm the effectiveness of our approach in improving
ordinal classification performance for ASA. Furthermore, we propose a hybrid
model that combines SSL and handcrafted features, showcasing how the inclusion
of handcrafted features enhances performance in an ASA system.
|
[
-0.4777815043926239,
-0.5440080761909485,
-0.20287975668907166,
0.2023070901632309,
-0.1957341432571411,
0.3906814754009247,
0.05306514352560043,
-0.6075735688209534,
0.47568729519844055,
0.1974121481180191,
-0.2059425562620163,
-0.36977145075798035,
-0.7320405840873718,
-0.06115999072790146,
-0.6517444252967834,
0.826332151889801,
0.23455041646957397,
0.23246946930885315,
-0.2864271402359009,
-0.6807195544242859,
-0.5418094396591187,
-0.66703200340271,
-0.7230778336524963,
-0.42880627512931824,
0.31596967577934265,
0.502027153968811,
0.7856584191322327,
0.8012329339981079,
0.585202693939209,
0.3669774830341339,
0.13068634271621704,
-0.03828324377536774,
-0.08708265423774719,
0.18757253885269165,
0.07745596021413803,
-0.05881170555949211,
-0.7468994855880737,
0.42684197425842285,
0.8827579021453857,
0.8355835676193237,
-0.20416128635406494,
0.6582326889038086,
0.17351311445236206,
0.41223177313804626,
-0.7024042010307312,
-0.12264525890350342,
-0.3883584439754486,
-0.014364313334226608,
-0.4448462426662445,
-0.10462719947099686,
0.106987364590168,
-0.3476526141166687,
0.43917980790138245,
-0.13977119326591492,
-0.0969381108880043,
0.4062090218067169,
0.6590440273284912,
0.6738192439079285,
-0.2914355993270874,
0.027662035077810287,
-0.7003961801528931,
0.9057722687721252,
-0.6354517340660095,
0.4502943158149719,
0.23752126097679138,
0.4317200779914856,
0.14256709814071655,
-0.4777577519416809,
-0.40518516302108765,
-0.22201605141162872,
0.16543149948120117,
0.07906270027160645,
-0.18037603795528412,
-0.07258901745080948,
0.15320339798927307,
0.6620555520057678,
-0.7539575099945068,
0.5301875472068787,
-0.4705491065979004,
-0.3826684057712555,
1.0531560182571411,
-0.02733687311410904,
0.4477788209915161,
-0.12388139963150024,
-0.4163918197154999,
-0.33392390608787537,
-0.2520100474357605,
0.16488836705684662,
0.40392836928367615,
0.36317673325538635,
-0.03914204612374306,
0.6790770888328552,
-0.16072630882263184,
0.859598696231842,
-0.10251649469137192,
-0.40082332491874695,
0.5463898181915283,
-0.11318009346723557,
-0.30705326795578003,
0.42644014954566956,
0.7751619815826416,
0.26484692096710205,
0.06117597222328186,
0.24743042886257172,
-0.11942557245492935,
0.39879345893859863,
0.19058282673358917,
-0.43103253841400146,
-0.29423150420188904,
0.30062177777290344,
-0.5139263272285461,
-0.4438481032848358,
-0.07570550590753555,
-0.5560865998268127,
-0.4103800654411316,
-0.4134799838066101,
0.8048723936080933,
-0.20995937287807465,
-0.06819940358400345,
-0.11167311668395996,
-0.3171807527542114,
0.2735863924026489,
-0.03765210881829262,
-0.7516325116157532,
0.4411192536354065,
0.5068432092666626,
0.6554260849952698,
-0.5999810695648193,
-0.3713226616382599,
-0.755763590335846,
-0.16006289422512054,
-0.19874334335327148,
0.806387186050415,
-0.583632230758667,
-0.19986169040203094,
-0.37908735871315,
-0.501101016998291,
-0.14348651468753815,
-0.46508142352104187,
0.4815678000450134,
-0.226111501455307,
0.5515281558036804,
0.13674165308475494,
-0.5111510753631592,
-0.10705198347568512,
-0.013291921466588974,
-0.36014121770858765,
1.3513253927230835,
0.093343585729599,
-0.7068362832069397,
0.5619248151779175,
-0.7078900337219238,
-0.6357195377349854,
0.2480623424053192,
-0.2335999608039856,
-0.5653769373893738,
-0.022382086142897606,
0.27713543176651,
0.346808522939682,
-0.14628997445106506,
-0.23458079993724823,
-0.29000958800315857,
-0.42473289370536804,
-0.10775633156299591,
-0.22159014642238617,
0.6587139368057251,
0.16424037516117096,
-0.45560169219970703,
0.24747134745121002,
-0.9092200398445129,
0.10392649471759796,
0.002837961306795478,
-0.05451022833585739,
-0.5681926608085632,
0.10858664661645889,
-0.021085215732455254,
0.12188412249088287,
0.26781412959098816,
-0.5677589178085327,
-0.0775042399764061,
-0.541123628616333,
0.43152937293052673,
0.382961630821228,
-0.07787995785474777,
0.47195160388946533,
-0.42200854420661926,
0.5945348143577576,
-0.22199513018131256,
0.31189385056495667,
0.36777400970458984,
-0.5785866975784302,
-0.7674775719642639,
-0.5121475458145142,
0.7885718941688538,
0.8850463628768921,
-0.43387100100517273,
0.9368583559989929,
-0.19427570700645447,
-0.6894570589065552,
-1.1995949745178223,
0.18831899762153625,
0.49152594804763794,
0.5945059061050415,
0.544342577457428,
-0.8368410468101501,
-0.4152568280696869,
-1.0469526052474976,
-0.11761563271284103,
-0.22128960490226746,
-0.27741122245788574,
0.1466263383626938,
-0.009831582196056843,
0.06998040527105331,
0.8383049964904785,
-0.3169451653957367,
-0.8052062392234802,
-0.09745953232049942,
0.5336465239524841,
-0.1804187148809433,
0.5459776520729065,
0.513767659664154,
-0.8406305313110352,
-0.45689448714256287,
-0.3707883954048157,
-0.43338778614997864,
-0.3013804852962494,
0.291883647441864,
0.22625590860843658,
0.06277047842741013,
0.439999520778656,
0.1599917858839035,
0.29447561502456665,
0.655460000038147,
-0.08217567950487137,
0.0422857441008091,
-0.04261500760912895,
0.34080302715301514,
-0.8630738854408264,
-0.08875079452991486,
0.028267912566661835,
-0.2887735068798065,
-0.4525885283946991,
-0.27421674132347107,
-0.2036864310503006,
-0.41171911358833313,
-0.44078564643859863,
0.3144005835056305,
-0.2543264627456665,
-0.4106890559196472,
-0.3956371247768402,
0.2811819016933441,
-0.13919876515865326,
0.3100997507572174,
-0.14774785935878754,
0.9239073991775513,
0.8879768252372742,
-0.3672732710838318,
0.42309367656707764,
0.24488244950771332,
-0.19597546756267548,
0.9404749274253845,
-0.5867359042167664,
0.12601600587368011,
-0.035184480249881744,
0.05366688594222069,
-1.2564889192581177,
-0.14668455719947815,
-0.2217874526977539,
-0.5813001990318298,
0.5104326605796814,
-0.05281420797109604,
-0.29978522658348083,
-0.43922048807144165,
-0.49375003576278687,
0.5511233806610107,
0.8946895599365234,
-0.3482419550418854,
0.833180844783783,
1.0654476881027222,
-0.3664151132106781,
-0.37963712215423584,
-0.45321545004844666,
-0.07176291942596436,
-0.5865170955657959,
-0.5949645638465881,
0.44330915808677673,
0.09905710071325302,
-0.3133045434951782,
-0.14274030923843384,
-0.10282242298126221,
0.17536640167236328,
0.2087179273366928,
0.2522202134132385,
0.06448132544755936,
-0.10766696184873581,
0.03830374777317047,
0.13017426431179047,
-0.09072743356227875,
-0.18825039267539978,
-0.2243172526359558,
0.45577025413513184,
-0.14686483144760132,
-0.3594721853733063,
-0.6671819686889648,
0.4574144184589386,
0.7088879346847534,
-0.4726693034172058,
0.3177703320980072,
0.7086709141731262,
-0.2900301218032837,
-0.14573268592357635,
-0.7560980916023254,
-0.008844111114740372,
-0.46385714411735535,
0.1801832616329193,
-0.22985592484474182,
-0.7170790433883667,
0.266501784324646,
0.006389467511326075,
0.3834822475910187,
0.4969480633735657,
0.3379182815551758,
-0.4798577129840851,
1.4386976957321167,
0.6440683603286743,
-0.5982286334037781,
0.46991288661956787,
-0.06059950217604637,
-0.11702601611614227,
-0.9030376076698303,
-0.058979712426662445,
-0.6334471106529236,
-0.7598128318786621,
-0.6294679641723633,
-0.16923701763153076,
0.7309542298316956,
-0.3510298430919647,
0.10070149600505829,
0.38341692090034485,
-0.8367922306060791,
0.2789402902126312,
0.7981756925582886,
-0.13969603180885315,
-0.04081106558442116,
-0.06970496475696564,
0.009104212746024132,
-0.059520285576581955,
-0.6621451377868652,
-0.25722047686576843,
0.8580573797225952,
0.4436381161212921,
0.5472154021263123,
-0.08197323232889175,
0.8225271105766296,
0.6721534132957458,
0.11034809798002243,
-0.9617757797241211,
0.3500174880027771,
-0.3316500186920166,
-0.07818467170000076,
-0.6555527448654175,
-0.23269200325012207,
-0.8966546058654785,
0.3630619943141937,
-0.4682205319404602,
-0.2504850924015045,
0.050734128803014755,
0.28242337703704834,
-0.6818068027496338,
-0.2174077332019806,
-0.940535843372345,
0.6266331672668457,
-0.22351296246051788,
0.3464702367782593,
-0.1998213529586792,
-0.7847395539283752,
-0.03649655357003212,
-0.11120110005140305,
0.23915323615074158,
-0.2264581322669983,
-0.029231619089841843,
1.2021886110305786,
-0.2961893081665039,
0.5778341889381409,
-0.1714223027229309,
0.052102264016866684,
0.06578071415424347,
-0.26308029890060425,
0.04749138653278351,
-0.4944501221179962,
-0.22985409200191498,
0.22677059471607208,
-0.005904803052544594,
-0.4267843961715698,
-0.7031694054603577,
0.6464553475379944,
-0.739529013633728,
-0.5590160489082336,
-0.5289326310157776,
-0.4955504834651947,
-0.6096055507659912,
-0.08268748968839645,
0.13697120547294617,
0.6379035115242004,
-0.05703276768326759,
0.13579556345939636,
0.3995599150657654,
0.09190947562456131,
0.2527852952480316,
0.2969675064086914,
0.19734574854373932,
-0.6132981181144714,
1.1872565746307373,
0.5524389147758484,
0.23598948121070862,
-0.02322961948812008,
0.4805659055709839,
-0.42762666940689087,
-0.7948498725891113,
-0.3829895555973053,
0.05078586935997009,
-0.4108356833457947,
-0.19394201040267944,
-0.41612184047698975,
-0.3933230936527252,
-0.6638306379318237,
0.0029535158537328243,
-0.22504593431949615,
-0.771138608455658,
-0.07784339785575867,
0.017899680882692337,
0.35588544607162476,
0.46483802795410156,
-0.015334132127463818,
0.11198414117097855,
-0.41089892387390137,
0.37079575657844543,
0.588779866695404,
0.04856080561876297,
-0.15404270589351654,
-0.8749874234199524,
0.0609552226960659,
-0.18186110258102417,
-0.3493160009384155,
-0.5166977643966675,
0.27750033140182495,
0.600527286529541,
0.668735682964325,
0.3096829354763031,
0.2625776529312134,
0.7731508612632751,
-0.6711955666542053,
0.9083786606788635,
0.03403029963374138,
-0.9962886571884155,
0.7136400938034058,
-0.024930650368332863,
0.3299916386604309,
0.7608395218849182,
0.4609662890434265,
-0.26345714926719666,
-0.9250606894493103,
-0.8645586371421814,
-0.8489794135093689,
0.4277970492839813,
0.3359547257423401,
-0.049868594855070114,
0.12859119474887848,
0.075717031955719,
-0.09911336749792099,
0.17514477670192719,
-0.250534325838089,
-0.49544447660446167,
-0.23472920060157776,
-0.4127938449382782,
-0.05623897165060043,
-0.1729794144630432,
-0.11457305401563644,
-0.4188573658466339,
0.7304198741912842,
0.09168404340744019,
-0.030718328431248665,
0.07974408566951752,
-0.01428443193435669,
-0.08445722609758377,
0.18810385465621948,
0.6184458136558533,
0.5456470251083374,
-0.13900303840637207,
0.15635590255260468,
0.587541937828064,
-0.5221844911575317,
0.05582398548722267,
0.29011908173561096,
-0.06791369616985321,
-0.19375820457935333,
0.29998624324798584,
0.5441144108772278,
0.2645653784275055,
-0.3111709952354431,
0.48624923825263977,
0.17911311984062195,
-0.07846079766750336,
-0.21809768676757812,
0.21353256702423096,
-0.29931414127349854,
0.1424662470817566,
0.4683220386505127,
0.08938717097043991,
0.4984019994735718,
-0.5603688955307007,
0.33667227625846863,
0.5135661363601685,
-0.3993056118488312,
0.01107137929648161,
0.5280279517173767,
0.4608215093612671,
-0.5545041561126709,
0.42179399728775024,
0.009598731994628906,
-0.6144335865974426,
0.5156465768814087,
0.1748291552066803,
0.7364348769187927,
-0.7803159356117249,
-0.12436813861131668,
0.10352891683578491,
0.2592664659023285,
0.1307758241891861,
0.4434526562690735,
-0.13153494894504547,
-0.3511557877063751,
-0.17289261519908905,
-0.7812071442604065,
-0.5950785875320435,
-0.00726425601169467,
-0.9097927212715149,
0.4253053367137909,
-0.4873444139957428,
-0.2653270661830902,
0.33091291785240173,
0.0838875100016594,
-0.33333060145378113,
0.4291684627532959,
0.34116819500923157,
0.6771629452705383,
-1.1006497144699097,
0.865312933921814,
0.5601347088813782,
-0.2348785549402237,
-0.8364667296409607,
-0.10402006655931473,
0.20683901011943817,
-0.8791313767433167,
0.3100643754005432,
0.06581591814756393,
-0.29536986351013184,
0.14263583719730377,
-0.10951415449380875,
-1.1321333646774292,
0.9950664639472961,
0.0705624595284462,
-0.24248403310775757,
0.2572864592075348,
0.05505938455462456,
0.6965760588645935,
-0.4216998517513275,
0.01921110972762108,
0.6614648103713989,
0.33798104524612427,
0.1861061006784439,
-1.492802381515503,
-0.24693801999092102,
-0.14362382888793945,
0.07254926860332489,
0.35173219442367554,
-0.6285441517829895,
0.3276953399181366,
0.21825702488422394,
-0.15723788738250732,
-0.19914065301418304,
0.9834097027778625,
0.15575316548347473,
0.257772296667099,
0.8671403527259827,
0.6077496409416199,
0.8137073516845703,
0.10240890830755234,
0.7423416376113892,
0.07826671749353409,
-0.02240045741200447,
1.1368460655212402,
-0.4726860821247101,
1.199519157409668,
0.22821132838726044,
-0.05054587498307228,
0.4744378328323364,
0.6528984308242798,
-0.3846209645271301,
0.34301653504371643,
0.2603105902671814,
-0.025800582021474838,
-0.1963331550359726,
-0.34474921226501465,
-0.39946088194847107,
1.0590713024139404,
0.20055481791496277,
-0.15748204290866852,
-0.17169226706027985,
0.6387686729431152,
-0.3761054277420044,
0.17489784955978394,
-0.5251398086547852,
0.9406200647354126,
0.11437516659498215,
-0.4079778790473938,
0.5943945646286011,
-0.02166726440191269,
0.7907747626304626,
-0.442217081785202,
-0.048179272562265396,
0.08304861932992935,
-0.2311677187681198,
-0.19315440952777863,
-0.4907882809638977,
0.39947983622550964,
-0.17081283032894135,
0.002593634184449911,
-0.32264453172683716,
0.5808918476104736,
-0.6271156668663025,
-0.40271899104118347,
0.15433596074581146,
0.14709118008613586,
0.38872864842414856,
0.12276087701320648,
-0.8787810802459717,
0.11260420083999634,
-0.49373170733451843,
0.1254890412092209,
0.4977554976940155,
0.010526261292397976,
-0.40134432911872864,
0.632252037525177,
0.4939512312412262,
0.26965948939323425,
-0.020407700911164284,
0.24878914654254913,
0.6051436066627502,
-0.2451639175415039,
-0.638084888458252,
-0.6371477842330933,
0.2839369475841522,
-0.14364789426326752,
-0.16380815207958221,
0.8982527256011963,
0.5450177192687988,
0.6512471437454224,
0.2895700931549072,
0.4494401216506958,
0.060211166739463806,
0.9463214874267578,
-0.2833285629749298,
0.9857948422431946,
-0.7146508693695068,
-0.09861311316490173,
-0.3638073801994324,
-0.8327005505561829,
-0.36479651927948,
0.578388512134552,
-0.18474476039409637,
0.028220977634191513,
0.5392764806747437,
0.4605734050273895,
-0.11045294255018234,
-0.163718119263649,
0.5455230474472046,
-0.09140544384717941,
-0.027924204245209694,
0.17278051376342773,
0.6949817538261414,
-0.5942476987838745,
0.37373897433280945,
-0.2688622772693634,
-0.7256958484649658,
0.00892884936183691,
-0.8287808895111084,
-1.035050868988037,
-0.6721943616867065,
-0.7202672362327576,
-0.0822228267788887,
-0.14851365983486176,
1.20348060131073,
0.9764053225517273,
-0.9389768838882446,
-0.3440816104412079,
0.6021376252174377,
-0.004764138255268335,
-0.47881102561950684,
-0.21979054808616638,
0.6275516152381897,
-0.19539961218833923,
-0.7036170959472656,
0.8123376369476318,
0.41551196575164795,
0.21916285157203674,
-0.36599835753440857,
0.4075486958026886,
-0.12101544439792633,
0.27605903148651123,
0.4921380877494812,
0.37212929129600525,
-0.6739000678062439,
-0.4170500338077545,
-0.43998846411705017,
-0.005359553266316652,
-0.09201523661613464,
0.5284754037857056,
-0.819395899772644,
0.437359482049942,
0.5476314425468445,
0.5765320062637329,
-0.022618599236011505,
0.5116293430328369,
0.6106579303741455,
-1.0087542533874512,
0.17294885218143463,
0.48498862981796265,
0.32325905561447144,
0.3452906608581543,
-0.3991398513317108,
0.2842746675014496,
0.056385766714811325,
-0.47072136402130127,
-1.0202070474624634,
0.042063359171152115,
-1.0864089727401733,
0.18445724248886108,
0.8868408203125,
0.21425774693489075,
-0.07604370266199112,
-0.28085532784461975,
-0.1180649921298027,
0.0220537930727005,
-0.23091159760951996,
0.9687623977661133,
0.5633381605148315,
-0.41009682416915894,
-0.09965634346008301,
-0.13483408093452454,
0.8974116444587708,
0.7400723695755005,
-0.7704297304153442,
-0.3678479492664337,
0.2676830589771271,
0.23780427873134613,
0.49339067935943604,
0.37731948494911194,
-0.22164736688137054,
0.398955762386322,
-0.44576695561408997,
-0.07639116048812866,
-0.22627805173397064,
-0.43691349029541016,
-0.578784704208374,
0.3784717619419098,
0.19846773147583008,
-0.73393315076828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10870v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10870v1
|
COOL: Comprehensive Knowledge Enhanced Prompt Learning for Domain Adaptive Few-shot Fake News Detection
| 2024-06-16T09:41:25 | 2024-06-16T09:41:25 |
Yi Ouyang, Peng Wu, Li Pan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Most Fake News Detection (FND) methods often struggle with data scarcity for
emerging news domain. Recently, prompt learning based on Pre-trained Language
Models (PLM) has emerged as a promising approach in domain adaptive few-shot
learning, since it greatly reduces the need for labeled data by bridging the
gap between pre-training and downstream task. Furthermore, external knowledge
is also helpful in verifying emerging news, as emerging news often involves
timely knowledge that may not be contained in the PLM's outdated prior
knowledge. To this end, we propose COOL, a Comprehensive knOwledge enhanced
prOmpt Learning method for domain adaptive few-shot FND. Specifically, we
propose a comprehensive knowledge extraction module to extract both structured
and unstructured knowledge that are positively or negatively correlated with
news from external sources, and adopt an adversarial contrastive enhanced
hybrid prompt learning strategy to model the domain-invariant news-knowledge
interaction pattern for FND. Experimental results demonstrate the superiority
of COOL over various state-of-the-arts.
|
[
-0.25406867265701294,
-1.0436080694198608,
0.43661990761756897,
-0.008131948299705982,
-0.3817158341407776,
0.38362494111061096,
-0.20900675654411316,
-0.1318410485982895,
0.034653596580028534,
0.13352163136005402,
-0.6061394214630127,
-0.5602084994316101,
-0.4156375527381897,
-0.006035928148776293,
0.009861205704510212,
1.061493158340454,
0.11769888550043106,
-0.020691588521003723,
-0.10612629354000092,
0.04562032222747803,
-0.3074089288711548,
-0.18496178090572357,
-0.6665771007537842,
-0.18162484467029572,
0.2501310706138611,
0.6241719126701355,
0.38167741894721985,
0.11127431690692902,
0.22151067852973938,
0.21743889153003693,
0.06407568603754044,
0.5405718088150024,
-0.5304989218711853,
-0.18732669949531555,
-0.31663188338279724,
-0.3401683270931244,
-0.2692514657974243,
0.08327023684978485,
0.2312362641096115,
0.21161703765392303,
0.12039494514465332,
-0.2216663658618927,
-0.09796851873397827,
0.4234977662563324,
-0.6176086068153381,
0.036318089812994,
-0.9113579392433167,
-0.1012393981218338,
-0.26014408469200134,
-0.3019985854625702,
-0.3058791756629944,
-0.301666796207428,
0.1859346628189087,
-0.9381072521209717,
0.26131683588027954,
-0.07309667766094208,
0.9109959602355957,
0.17024125158786774,
-0.561117947101593,
-0.0731014683842659,
-0.44027331471443176,
0.6380010843276978,
-0.5812463760375977,
0.16962683200836182,
0.16537053883075714,
0.44964632391929626,
-0.30054304003715515,
-0.8479670286178589,
-1.061098337173462,
0.05440140143036842,
0.1491132527589798,
0.47034478187561035,
-0.4520935118198395,
-0.14545750617980957,
0.234196737408638,
0.20183680951595306,
-0.5307673811912537,
0.10500079393386841,
-0.20942190289497375,
-0.46995726227760315,
0.33226990699768066,
0.03359512984752655,
0.36492761969566345,
-0.1984306275844574,
-0.7993593215942383,
0.12721355259418488,
-0.5282720923423767,
0.3463820815086365,
0.13660378754138947,
0.505958080291748,
-0.5035404562950134,
0.06607053428888321,
-0.6149709820747375,
0.7652469873428345,
0.32231539487838745,
-0.524583637714386,
0.32991859316825867,
-0.2100013643503189,
-0.23622603714466095,
-0.11893925815820694,
0.5762946605682373,
0.03406086564064026,
0.02502354048192501,
-0.03815595805644989,
-0.14212633669376373,
-0.13125120103359222,
0.05408904328942299,
-0.7151682376861572,
-0.47887685894966125,
0.028539765626192093,
-0.3579491078853607,
-0.1682760864496231,
0.21622516214847565,
-0.6737716197967529,
-0.6134840846061707,
-0.39700040221214294,
0.6839035153388977,
-0.5150463581085205,
-0.3061783015727997,
-0.10779038816690445,
-0.4216267764568329,
0.21144600212574005,
0.8133856654167175,
-0.2102714329957962,
-0.17101871967315674,
0.46126317977905273,
0.7282308340072632,
-0.4508492052555084,
-0.18736256659030914,
-0.7870325446128845,
-0.061881646513938904,
-0.18195664882659912,
1.1210778951644897,
-0.3544745445251465,
-0.11438780277967453,
-0.1163361594080925,
-0.10032244771718979,
0.08237375319004059,
-0.30177628993988037,
0.4928096532821655,
-1.0092153549194336,
0.41218024492263794,
-0.2765313982963562,
-0.5089973211288452,
-0.30703094601631165,
0.4173406958580017,
-0.4010522961616516,
0.6283555626869202,
0.3253956437110901,
-0.9945809245109558,
0.5849466323852539,
-0.36411207914352417,
-0.508196234703064,
0.2647482454776764,
-0.10260831564664841,
-0.2836047410964966,
-0.049684468656778336,
0.4973718225955963,
0.40170764923095703,
0.21057011187076569,
0.18211188912391663,
-0.3726462721824646,
-0.16542856395244598,
0.3095942437648773,
-0.3850506842136383,
0.9232997894287109,
0.30958661437034607,
-0.26137346029281616,
0.2591261565685272,
-0.7143195271492004,
-0.13550426065921783,
-0.013934130780398846,
-0.2877749502658844,
-0.452804833650589,
-0.6537232398986816,
-0.3942473530769348,
0.3384302854537964,
0.09621290117502213,
-0.5074794888496399,
0.2716393768787384,
-0.41125521063804626,
-0.19301320612430573,
0.7355830073356628,
0.4085184633731842,
0.6007040143013,
-0.34007716178894043,
0.5637105107307434,
0.44762933254241943,
0.07140854746103287,
-0.45452457666397095,
-0.5106201767921448,
-0.6522457599639893,
-0.6651272773742676,
0.25169089436531067,
0.8002369403839111,
-1.641817331314087,
0.16481688618659973,
0.07251305133104324,
-0.2500591278076172,
-0.16903837025165558,
0.44779402017593384,
0.18996739387512207,
0.895685613155365,
0.4688248336315155,
-0.004147471394389868,
-0.5375479459762573,
-0.31768232583999634,
-0.582328200340271,
0.11230065673589706,
-0.038066718727350235,
0.2579249441623688,
0.30364149808883667,
0.002063974505290389,
1.2630574703216553,
-0.5055606365203857,
-0.5011969208717346,
-0.3745323717594147,
0.31498125195503235,
0.3701150417327881,
0.21478764712810516,
0.6471165418624878,
-0.8162651658058167,
-0.661583423614502,
-0.12838709354400635,
-0.7370498180389404,
-0.036468349397182465,
-0.13309147953987122,
-0.09648096561431885,
0.15093383193016052,
0.29007992148399353,
-0.7820776104927063,
0.36779868602752686,
0.07144732773303986,
-0.31346380710601807,
0.4652758836746216,
0.13191093504428864,
0.3098258078098297,
-1.029651165008545,
-0.09294842928647995,
0.061158161610364914,
-0.4408307671546936,
-0.7436873316764832,
-0.0036458498798310757,
0.07115832716226578,
-0.18324340879917145,
-0.7668136358261108,
0.9276900887489319,
-0.20981639623641968,
0.37631362676620483,
-0.8217566013336182,
0.16680802404880524,
0.16683104634284973,
0.2792132496833801,
0.32198670506477356,
0.5616454482078552,
0.7438488006591797,
-0.8301113247871399,
0.46615201234817505,
0.11114944517612457,
-0.29048463702201843,
0.5733403563499451,
-0.12429443001747131,
0.4170512855052948,
-0.3189998269081116,
0.6297310590744019,
-0.907358705997467,
-0.43686461448669434,
0.2957572340965271,
-0.7712507843971252,
0.32343366742134094,
-0.10421494394540787,
-0.3335724472999573,
-0.3184349238872528,
-0.3477576673030853,
0.13400863111019135,
0.4450698494911194,
-0.8662258982658386,
0.43533647060394287,
0.1737574338912964,
-0.16164974868297577,
-0.5677123665809631,
-0.3243245482444763,
-0.18467506766319275,
-0.18337398767471313,
-0.5551664233207703,
0.4416426122188568,
-0.016556380316615105,
-0.2802829444408417,
0.0819011777639389,
-0.2687608003616333,
-0.35099026560783386,
0.05652318522334099,
-0.13066942989826202,
0.25374463200569153,
-0.43343091011047363,
0.08944886177778244,
0.030699322000145912,
-0.08632494509220123,
-0.29487261176109314,
-0.24043048918247223,
0.12271149456501007,
0.14125296473503113,
0.1937544196844101,
-0.7748017311096191,
0.21084824204444885,
0.29116207361221313,
0.013001245446503162,
0.7536463737487793,
0.8526226282119751,
-0.7278003692626953,
-0.6449951529502869,
-0.42003780603408813,
-0.524492084980011,
-0.47477707266807556,
-0.024343853816390038,
-0.36379531025886536,
-0.6914486289024353,
0.3533291518688202,
-0.31140995025634766,
-0.0738222748041153,
0.3534930646419525,
0.26390212774276733,
0.08386653661727905,
0.686326265335083,
0.8760201334953308,
-0.09054029732942581,
0.510273814201355,
-0.07802250981330872,
0.1186528280377388,
-0.0067566391080617905,
-0.3208591043949127,
-0.30578336119651794,
-0.14488103985786438,
0.0492202453315258,
-0.4154340624809265,
0.3746701776981354,
0.457033634185791,
-0.3249455392360687,
-0.1484597772359848,
-0.031218193471431732,
0.5319334864616394,
0.5476052761077881,
0.5812044143676758,
0.3715907633304596,
0.1941223442554474,
-0.000037949961551930755,
-0.19314274191856384,
-0.746549665927887,
0.08149988204240799,
0.8297936320304871,
0.19541341066360474,
0.8203569650650024,
0.05900997295975685,
0.5005072951316833,
0.39321574568748474,
0.3153765797615051,
-0.9284122586250305,
0.1825254261493683,
-0.3985566198825836,
-0.4940258860588074,
0.03755112737417221,
-0.47380733489990234,
-0.30230969190597534,
-0.17279648780822754,
-0.21309271454811096,
-0.16959208250045776,
0.19269877672195435,
0.15814587473869324,
-0.8757050633430481,
0.3526083827018738,
-0.688785970211029,
0.3992922008037567,
-0.03505108505487442,
-0.25262656807899475,
-0.14349544048309326,
-0.5917338132858276,
0.6721815466880798,
-0.20589116215705872,
0.31042829155921936,
0.025911761447787285,
-0.10805021971464157,
0.8033878803253174,
-0.2230803221464157,
1.1536980867385864,
-0.6297639608383179,
0.1791023313999176,
0.4633016288280487,
-0.04232840985059738,
0.5926223993301392,
0.2640087306499481,
-0.05874691903591156,
0.03315244987607002,
-0.6249995231628418,
-0.4966127276420593,
-0.4119235575199127,
0.7159193754196167,
-0.6848071813583374,
-0.66205894947052,
-0.39681172370910645,
-0.552609920501709,
-0.39843884110450745,
0.3446393609046936,
0.5180240273475647,
0.15565134584903717,
-0.012289067730307579,
0.030281858518719673,
0.8820285201072693,
-0.4322626292705536,
0.5245602130889893,
0.9710742235183716,
0.10473848134279251,
-0.4952242076396942,
0.9645190834999084,
-0.0663689449429512,
-0.0014369087293744087,
0.40644097328186035,
0.3804696202278137,
-0.132025346159935,
-0.3272823989391327,
-0.41868481040000916,
-0.08261732012033463,
-0.8159844875335693,
-0.7755698561668396,
-0.7797917127609253,
-0.22193486988544464,
-0.6443773508071899,
-0.3313318192958832,
-0.1524154394865036,
-0.3733116090297699,
-0.635905921459198,
-0.06386992335319519,
0.7383446097373962,
0.34292227029800415,
-0.15929102897644043,
0.6213381886482239,
-0.740642249584198,
0.9940500855445862,
0.4271850883960724,
-0.11726192384958267,
-0.3269232213497162,
-0.9008157253265381,
-0.033048711717128754,
-0.05606105923652649,
-0.3997855484485626,
-0.854346513748169,
0.22752343118190765,
0.40804523229599,
0.6838458180427551,
0.7692992687225342,
0.523396909236908,
0.4875670373439789,
-0.12585647404193878,
0.90940260887146,
0.270447701215744,
-0.8593006730079651,
0.7614222764968872,
-0.2582539916038513,
0.5343685746192932,
0.5924831628799438,
0.8027833700180054,
-0.03474646434187889,
-0.013953453861176968,
-0.5690053701400757,
-0.46968337893486023,
0.7393214106559753,
-0.586392343044281,
0.363983690738678,
0.09790218621492386,
0.3616272211074829,
0.6360194683074951,
0.21694770455360413,
-0.8170756697654724,
-0.30283600091934204,
-0.3714943826198578,
-0.14561840891838074,
0.34638911485671997,
-0.016979990527033806,
-0.0966074988245964,
-0.33047470450401306,
0.8677287697792053,
-0.40586304664611816,
0.14613834023475647,
0.052675049751996994,
-0.262993723154068,
-0.06453423947095871,
0.2453015297651291,
0.5178170800209045,
0.5804343819618225,
0.041075509041547775,
0.09557261317968369,
0.1382129192352295,
-0.3523769676685333,
-0.08796301484107971,
0.11458811163902283,
-0.24462173879146576,
0.08462072908878326,
0.2845805883407593,
0.8072816133499146,
-0.024432003498077393,
-0.27568644285202026,
1.0546810626983643,
0.034488145262002945,
-0.07998500019311905,
0.02599816583096981,
0.07562334835529327,
-0.38960862159729004,
0.34064456820487976,
0.7591263055801392,
0.5116364359855652,
0.008381396532058716,
-0.6043007969856262,
0.6278451085090637,
0.385610967874527,
-0.4433550536632538,
-0.3695283830165863,
0.492417573928833,
0.4620014727115631,
0.15616916120052338,
0.4246583878993988,
-0.45277172327041626,
-0.7618020176887512,
0.43159353733062744,
0.6831356287002563,
0.5806049108505249,
-0.29780152440071106,
0.5672898888587952,
0.2950126826763153,
0.1407138705253601,
0.026191487908363342,
0.5979883074760437,
-0.07982586324214935,
-0.9028619527816772,
-0.39675360918045044,
-0.46784791350364685,
-0.24869875609874725,
0.5114803314208984,
-0.22249607741832733,
0.6323398947715759,
-0.6989868879318237,
0.12593483924865723,
-0.18024902045726776,
0.2753206491470337,
-0.7846518158912659,
0.32244741916656494,
0.20984293520450592,
1.268446445465088,
-1.0113605260849,
1.0296257734298706,
0.7298542261123657,
-0.22908537089824677,
-0.5606021285057068,
0.39738357067108154,
0.5318846106529236,
-0.7625676393508911,
0.6808547377586365,
0.18778300285339355,
0.01495381724089384,
0.22760377824306488,
-0.7245265245437622,
-0.4153817296028137,
0.8427921533584595,
0.6484532952308655,
-0.3509693443775177,
0.058847520500421524,
-0.35271549224853516,
0.15397247672080994,
-0.4306331276893616,
0.09814900904893875,
0.21575620770454407,
0.40040823817253113,
0.25829294323921204,
-0.5131452679634094,
0.04406699910759926,
-0.07853475958108902,
-0.6577461957931519,
-0.16263660788536072,
-0.7599431872367859,
0.7036106586456299,
-0.5669781565666199,
-0.36630070209503174,
-0.08667315542697906,
0.994933545589447,
0.2782599925994873,
0.9590567350387573,
0.40669602155685425,
0.4724392294883728,
0.9255265593528748,
-0.004949197638779879,
0.7123143672943115,
-0.08104606717824936,
-0.028626568615436554,
1.0953378677368164,
-0.2797603905200958,
0.6278179287910461,
0.22172698378562927,
0.16375933587551117,
0.6775776147842407,
0.6149978637695312,
0.1962515115737915,
0.9554123878479004,
-0.13519218564033508,
-0.6775668859481812,
-0.37477943301200867,
-0.3026823401451111,
-0.4148145914077759,
0.38605520129203796,
0.4709913730621338,
-0.0618925616145134,
-0.41214996576309204,
0.5728580951690674,
0.10570322722196579,
0.08480938524007797,
-0.6397888660430908,
0.9628307819366455,
0.3050439655780792,
-0.49071797728538513,
0.27062317728996277,
0.0008006370044313371,
1.0155616998672485,
-0.6023380160331726,
-0.004241012502461672,
-0.3815848231315613,
0.06914792954921722,
-0.4440581202507019,
-0.5470414161682129,
0.007723572198301554,
0.11545167863368988,
-0.321925550699234,
-0.09565024822950363,
1.3550690412521362,
-0.31103989481925964,
-0.020146237686276436,
0.014749879017472267,
0.7430749535560608,
-0.17841391265392303,
-0.3353149890899658,
-0.7425903677940369,
-0.25437861680984497,
-0.04915187880396843,
-0.2691900432109833,
0.14154362678527832,
0.6466923356056213,
0.015570166520774364,
0.30069318413734436,
0.8516886830329895,
-0.057112883776426315,
0.019059674814343452,
0.057877276092767715,
1.0445771217346191,
-0.5539074540138245,
-0.7632622718811035,
-0.5986217260360718,
0.573805570602417,
-0.21009767055511475,
-0.40752407908439636,
0.8245224356651306,
0.2944921851158142,
0.7015501260757446,
-0.14477865397930145,
0.9680241346359253,
-0.03162125498056412,
0.6620005965232849,
-0.7762383222579956,
0.6211196184158325,
-0.3520517349243164,
0.2365991473197937,
-0.035292718559503555,
-0.5839841961860657,
-0.3485998511314392,
0.16490834951400757,
-0.25657182931900024,
-0.01882910542190075,
0.7020956873893738,
0.6529812216758728,
-0.36860179901123047,
0.04048895090818405,
0.38591980934143066,
0.16117139160633087,
0.034635405987501144,
0.4453405737876892,
0.8438884615898132,
-0.21554061770439148,
0.4881954491138458,
-0.48267805576324463,
-0.5721074342727661,
-0.17176397144794464,
-0.9582319259643555,
-1.0053701400756836,
-0.332162469625473,
-0.6233428716659546,
-0.3692282736301422,
0.03837115690112114,
0.7776927947998047,
0.8286414742469788,
-0.9240136742591858,
0.6033939123153687,
0.02436542697250843,
0.29652372002601624,
-0.1585613340139389,
-0.3996545970439911,
0.37852004170417786,
-0.40065833926200867,
-0.35067155957221985,
0.9964566230773926,
0.05210895836353302,
0.032503847032785416,
0.225238636136055,
0.00938038993626833,
-0.10872645676136017,
0.13654540479183197,
0.597304105758667,
0.5781341195106506,
-0.474498987197876,
-0.1772754192352295,
0.08930140733718872,
-0.07176182419061661,
-0.12147895246744156,
0.9550935626029968,
-1.429368019104004,
0.33386850357055664,
0.8163599967956543,
0.7574092745780945,
0.21096362173557281,
0.2725474238395691,
0.3363124132156372,
-1.067347526550293,
0.4230022728443146,
-0.013139947317540646,
0.03393014520406723,
0.3806423842906952,
-0.689980149269104,
-0.12313893437385559,
0.7093735337257385,
-0.25041940808296204,
-0.5962663292884827,
0.2223391979932785,
-1.003764271736145,
-0.5570172667503357,
1.1340508460998535,
-0.36407554149627686,
-0.07580409944057465,
-0.4306882917881012,
-0.1313151866197586,
0.2575666904449463,
-0.6706125140190125,
0.7198581695556641,
0.22726045548915863,
-0.20946592092514038,
-0.30054306983947754,
-0.339950829744339,
0.8210704922676086,
0.03504028916358948,
-1.0595406293869019,
-0.4096498191356659,
0.460602730512619,
0.47791993618011475,
-0.00985131599009037,
0.6456614136695862,
0.09288685023784637,
0.6797114014625549,
-0.09805649518966675,
-0.40672650933265686,
-0.2500065565109253,
-0.6363164782524109,
-0.5142120122909546,
0.29014766216278076,
-0.28832611441612244,
-0.12417900562286377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10868v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10868v1
|
Analyzing Key Neurons in Large Language Models
| 2024-06-16T09:36:32 | 2024-06-16T09:36:32 |
Lihu Chen, Adam Dejl, Francesca Toni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) possess vast amounts of knowledge within their
parameters, prompting research into methods for locating and editing this
knowledge. Previous investigations have primarily focused on fill-in-the-blank
tasks and locating entity-related usually single-token facts) information in
relatively small-scale language models. However, several key questions remain
unanswered: (1) How can we effectively locate query-relevant neurons in
contemporary autoregressive LLMs, such as LLaMA and Mistral? (2) How can we
address the challenge of long-form text generation? (3) Are there localized
knowledge regions in LLMs? In this study, we introduce Neuron
Attribution-Inverse Cluster Attribution (NA-ICA), a novel architecture-agnostic
framework capable of identifying key neurons in LLMs. NA-ICA allows for the
examination of long-form answers beyond single tokens by employing the proxy
task of multi-choice question answering. To evaluate the effectiveness of our
detected key neurons, we construct two multi-choice QA datasets spanning
diverse domains and languages. Empirical evaluations demonstrate that NA-ICA
outperforms baseline methods significantly. Moreover, analysis of neuron
distributions reveals the presence of visible localized regions, particularly
within different domains. Finally, we demonstrate the potential applications of
our detected key neurons in knowledge editing and neuron-based prediction.
|
[
-0.2792632281780243,
-0.8112637400627136,
0.8595386147499084,
-0.010796094313263893,
-0.07488813996315002,
-0.0318734385073185,
-0.358045369386673,
-0.2412901371717453,
0.320061594247818,
0.27987465262413025,
-0.39132705330848694,
-0.5630238056182861,
-0.28560715913772583,
-0.19546617567539215,
-0.5024583339691162,
0.5787857174873352,
0.10495292395353317,
-0.07998891174793243,
-0.5301336050033569,
-0.16743755340576172,
-0.22931741178035736,
-0.7242345213890076,
-0.8761732578277588,
-0.4568704068660736,
0.7193872928619385,
0.26749640703201294,
0.48101359605789185,
0.393243670463562,
0.22960025072097778,
0.3398093283176422,
-0.5908659100532532,
0.07000032067298889,
-0.17181625962257385,
0.014123761095106602,
-0.19020459055900574,
-0.7048746347427368,
-0.5869835019111633,
-0.1965959519147873,
0.7764177322387695,
0.5755656957626343,
-0.13493528962135315,
0.2985083758831024,
-0.09509772062301636,
0.5293084383010864,
-0.5464687347412109,
0.11177363991737366,
-1.1751433610916138,
-0.16190879046916962,
-0.29801997542381287,
-0.09849872440099716,
-0.2429663985967636,
-0.21897870302200317,
-0.052090007811784744,
-0.39795979857444763,
0.3224186897277832,
-0.05236583575606346,
0.6910567283630371,
0.14705047011375427,
-0.47913751006126404,
-0.2660623788833618,
-0.33827826380729675,
0.6014103889465332,
-0.842938244342804,
0.07287971675395966,
0.4681704640388489,
-0.07184972614049911,
-0.34632420539855957,
-0.42439624667167664,
-0.6474451422691345,
-0.16599871218204498,
-0.16936266422271729,
-0.18141229450702667,
-0.46365049481391907,
-0.01608872227370739,
0.11041039228439331,
0.019098302349448204,
-0.49433374404907227,
0.4212821424007416,
-0.221425861120224,
-0.2344205677509308,
0.33787447214126587,
0.0602799616754055,
0.41618791222572327,
-0.18209008872509003,
0.01235575508326292,
0.06964415311813354,
-0.9325079917907715,
-0.012412945739924908,
0.43078991770744324,
0.22850480675697327,
0.07814198732376099,
0.5488009452819824,
0.05471218004822731,
0.780314028263092,
0.0022294246591627598,
0.16002345085144043,
0.22727981209754944,
-0.17582747340202332,
0.006720596458762884,
0.21689069271087646,
0.8354122638702393,
0.039625655859708786,
0.23645253479480743,
-0.25405409932136536,
-0.3202105164527893,
-0.11588212102651596,
0.2749103009700775,
-0.4979180693626404,
-0.17201176285743713,
0.02883112244307995,
-0.5567213296890259,
-0.425559937953949,
-0.5395034551620483,
-0.576381266117096,
-0.4217560291290283,
-0.208870992064476,
0.32361868023872375,
-0.062152180820703506,
-0.3095387816429138,
-0.05962001532316208,
-0.07932259142398834,
0.23317427933216095,
0.17676666378974915,
-0.8366524577140808,
0.26009202003479004,
0.5394483208656311,
0.8658549785614014,
-0.44987913966178894,
-0.3426167964935303,
-0.1372368186712265,
0.11557400226593018,
-0.482856810092926,
0.8904690742492676,
-0.5285542011260986,
0.00007398761226795614,
-0.06030581519007683,
-0.0019883080385625362,
-0.12312901765108109,
-0.7538593411445618,
0.2677772045135498,
-0.9581340551376343,
-0.24634645879268646,
-0.33193686604499817,
-0.3373877704143524,
-0.216281920671463,
0.3546231985092163,
-0.808189332485199,
0.797866940498352,
-0.2719167470932007,
-0.7142108082771301,
0.16241705417633057,
-0.6571572422981262,
-0.368944376707077,
-0.3660391569137573,
-0.35322970151901245,
-0.3756919801235199,
0.3815092146396637,
0.3479921519756317,
0.5536554455757141,
-0.5018799304962158,
0.4079228937625885,
-0.18833985924720764,
-0.05983496829867363,
0.5644238591194153,
-0.7164657711982727,
0.6340327858924866,
-0.08236806094646454,
-0.2580157518386841,
0.23943445086479187,
-0.8193114995956421,
0.001224531210027635,
0.1839189976453781,
-0.1266283243894577,
-0.5671201944351196,
0.25438714027404785,
-0.26159802079200745,
0.16418978571891785,
0.23798486590385437,
-0.505938708782196,
0.30793339014053345,
-0.22489239275455475,
0.735865592956543,
0.8176227807998657,
0.1282249242067337,
0.4760186970233917,
0.09268257021903992,
0.4597291350364685,
0.35197073221206665,
0.08693212270736694,
0.10746395587921143,
-0.6520992517471313,
-0.6730955243110657,
-0.04747721552848816,
0.1186906173825264,
0.12026450783014297,
-0.6183729767799377,
0.29728010296821594,
-0.32317134737968445,
-0.4687276780605316,
-0.36382806301116943,
-0.05224071070551872,
0.13322176039218903,
0.4162539839744568,
0.41475725173950195,
-0.05547448992729187,
-0.13056181371212006,
-1.0897554159164429,
-0.10815417766571045,
-0.25268253684043884,
0.15663385391235352,
0.19798173010349274,
0.5929450392723083,
-0.12962616980075836,
1.0379170179367065,
-0.5096971392631531,
-0.11376804858446121,
-0.014983599074184895,
0.11186498403549194,
0.3806556761264801,
0.4344848394393921,
0.45273497700691223,
-0.7059119343757629,
-0.31460413336753845,
0.09783070534467697,
-0.4892135560512543,
-0.05144541710615158,
-0.20671002566814423,
0.05339594930410385,
-0.2203669399023056,
0.7922097444534302,
-0.8859950304031372,
0.40919366478919983,
0.52934730052948,
-0.0619150847196579,
0.42816153168678284,
-0.2081841677427292,
0.004368748050183058,
-0.9375849366188049,
0.31904107332229614,
-0.29495683312416077,
0.048334553837776184,
-0.7044500112533569,
-0.21408164501190186,
0.26200997829437256,
-0.08298914134502411,
-0.07891512662172318,
0.6869272589683533,
-0.6593202948570251,
-0.2924143671989441,
-0.3987007737159729,
0.20080389082431793,
-0.18524169921875,
0.7393913269042969,
0.10070990771055222,
0.8287081718444824,
0.6232565641403198,
-0.5927282571792603,
0.09417255222797394,
0.23076559603214264,
-0.6327725648880005,
-0.10778898745775223,
-0.6731854677200317,
0.24744246900081635,
-0.3228496313095093,
0.15706732869148254,
-1.0676583051681519,
0.022938614711165428,
0.026280375197529793,
-0.5262895822525024,
0.15104593336582184,
-0.24068716168403625,
-0.606444776058197,
-0.09330039471387863,
0.06382396817207336,
0.9550072550773621,
0.28817659616470337,
-0.6589892506599426,
0.735118567943573,
0.5136756896972656,
-0.334817498922348,
-0.5981248021125793,
-0.5482280254364014,
0.10597304254770279,
-0.15750530362129211,
-0.43018290400505066,
0.44881999492645264,
0.21855555474758148,
-0.28025394678115845,
0.03455306217074394,
0.012000427581369877,
-0.18986281752586365,
0.21621550619602203,
0.30850520730018616,
0.04234892502427101,
-0.3933984339237213,
0.4932316243648529,
0.16042126715183258,
-0.02504446916282177,
0.2127372920513153,
0.0025878585875034332,
0.6232210993766785,
-0.09179118275642395,
-0.618926465511322,
-0.14945808053016663,
0.2647743225097656,
0.6946079730987549,
-0.5712083578109741,
0.5333685278892517,
0.16398461163043976,
-0.5126178860664368,
-0.37185755372047424,
-0.5456560850143433,
-0.333266019821167,
-0.4606027901172638,
0.6411915421485901,
-0.18137866258621216,
-0.6888297200202942,
0.9400052428245544,
-0.012735407799482346,
-0.20136460661888123,
0.4813273847103119,
0.6132907867431641,
0.21231642365455627,
0.9219410419464111,
0.47272989153862,
-0.5069751143455505,
0.34536802768707275,
-0.07439018785953522,
0.38087576627731323,
-0.9373748302459717,
-0.0581372007727623,
-0.6072377562522888,
-0.3862990438938141,
-0.13531769812107086,
-0.3588603436946869,
0.4731585383415222,
0.19205915927886963,
0.015674347057938576,
0.2795962691307068,
-0.26815304160118103,
0.6053497195243835,
0.46714943647384644,
-0.036723144352436066,
0.2737194895744324,
-0.088072769343853,
-0.2160455286502838,
0.24502669274806976,
-0.9534568786621094,
-0.3406740128993988,
1.0960720777511597,
0.44074514508247375,
0.6065188050270081,
-0.11491868644952774,
0.3428744673728943,
-0.05723528936505318,
0.3867829442024231,
-0.8288122415542603,
0.6188746094703674,
0.020579366013407707,
-0.7269623279571533,
-0.31944766640663147,
-0.23098285496234894,
-0.8983073234558105,
0.3387652635574341,
-0.0773814395070076,
-0.7673012614250183,
0.3480205833911896,
0.16189981997013092,
-0.6457958817481995,
0.6130712032318115,
-0.5707286596298218,
0.9134728908538818,
-0.25562784075737,
-0.059801891446113586,
-0.31504321098327637,
-0.4296013414859772,
0.17633342742919922,
-0.12857398390769958,
0.11342103034257889,
0.05934261158108711,
-0.11109411716461182,
0.719569742679596,
-0.05555254593491554,
1.0694259405136108,
-0.014740620739758015,
-0.5238631367683411,
0.4406276345252991,
-0.013517703860998154,
0.6220483183860779,
0.07065142691135406,
-0.03706718608736992,
0.19158382713794708,
-0.35794830322265625,
0.0291245449334383,
-0.679925262928009,
0.9529024362564087,
-0.6462540626525879,
-0.426411896944046,
-0.3144771158695221,
-0.5189495086669922,
-0.3200342655181885,
0.06660764664411545,
0.27140873670578003,
0.512041449546814,
-0.015050988644361496,
0.0953606441617012,
0.8043689131736755,
-0.42845144867897034,
0.5620835423469543,
0.45589327812194824,
-0.15839309990406036,
-0.2043410688638687,
0.9660553336143494,
0.06728775054216385,
0.12015902251005173,
0.3113749027252197,
0.040392789989709854,
-0.07690775394439697,
-0.9414858818054199,
-0.29816436767578125,
0.37240612506866455,
-0.8185879588127136,
-0.35258594155311584,
-0.6317496299743652,
-0.21370846033096313,
-0.16160725057125092,
-0.04027009382843971,
-0.5126261711120605,
-0.10204045474529266,
-0.6538619995117188,
-0.12598983943462372,
0.1940002590417862,
0.5807319283485413,
0.002659460296854377,
0.4352652430534363,
-0.7451109886169434,
0.2957956790924072,
0.3321596086025238,
0.25797995924949646,
0.5206049680709839,
-0.30147895216941833,
-0.1603797972202301,
0.08710379898548126,
0.026593631133437157,
-0.9900423288345337,
0.2735925316810608,
0.12436559051275253,
0.6163438558578491,
0.2700579762458801,
-0.3502430021762848,
0.5809239745140076,
-0.5849118828773499,
0.8300710916519165,
0.14718154072761536,
-0.6672002077102661,
0.2820478081703186,
-0.16911305487155914,
0.3783336579799652,
0.3808779716491699,
0.4190372824668884,
-0.5626621842384338,
-0.2153780311346054,
-0.6015124917030334,
-0.8417768478393555,
0.5881245732307434,
0.17036856710910797,
0.15525932610034943,
-0.2669494152069092,
0.717208981513977,
-0.13768382370471954,
0.23406359553337097,
-0.7006680369377136,
-0.3131060004234314,
0.24494941532611847,
-0.05929923057556152,
-0.12327723950147629,
-0.1645801067352295,
-0.07580220699310303,
-0.2486068606376648,
0.5966346859931946,
-0.35586249828338623,
0.4325321614742279,
0.015818359330296516,
-0.06008598953485489,
-0.08492405712604523,
0.2590654492378235,
0.6441778540611267,
0.6418754458427429,
0.032057058066129684,
0.1416449099779129,
0.21191145479679108,
-0.3158847987651825,
-0.0013981644297018647,
-0.31404685974121094,
-0.23389269411563873,
0.1542699784040451,
0.4287000596523285,
0.7379285097122192,
0.010228248313069344,
-0.536166250705719,
0.7560214996337891,
0.03165699169039726,
-0.021646132692694664,
-0.48512694239616394,
-0.17322394251823425,
0.34275659918785095,
0.34184375405311584,
0.3709942698478699,
0.20699550211429596,
0.05268790200352669,
-0.5808067321777344,
0.08938796073198318,
0.7517500519752502,
-0.5103407502174377,
-0.5400712490081787,
0.27374565601348877,
-0.08869774639606476,
-0.030459647998213768,
0.7970293164253235,
-0.02197328209877014,
-0.7109808921813965,
0.8982831239700317,
0.5186417102813721,
0.9484491944313049,
0.07507731765508652,
0.19082997739315033,
0.32389727234840393,
0.23805208504199982,
-0.004754936788231134,
0.18070144951343536,
0.04881200194358826,
-0.9399783611297607,
-0.5321035981178284,
-0.451588898897171,
0.1740906834602356,
0.4141595959663391,
-0.5173342823982239,
-0.033267535269260406,
-0.1437249481678009,
-0.42503952980041504,
0.08839438855648041,
-0.5563524961471558,
-0.3797057271003723,
0.052755244076251984,
0.22682558000087738,
0.7676041126251221,
-0.8275281190872192,
0.9954534769058228,
0.6452793478965759,
-0.19324283301830292,
-0.5410043001174927,
-0.041060470044612885,
-0.24365675449371338,
-0.9456509947776794,
0.8897795677185059,
-0.14923100173473358,
-0.15667511522769928,
0.011304834857583046,
-0.9570919871330261,
-1.0545580387115479,
0.989822506904602,
0.25408312678337097,
-0.4480070173740387,
-0.42259055376052856,
0.032955046743154526,
0.5763828158378601,
-0.23226477205753326,
0.2677978575229645,
0.41758495569229126,
0.3215809464454651,
-0.1996219903230667,
-0.7209933996200562,
0.015804611146450043,
-0.18786577880382538,
-0.13122820854187012,
0.4720221161842346,
-0.5111356973648071,
0.8732854127883911,
-0.18511991202831268,
-0.12109973281621933,
0.03644850477576256,
0.6735791563987732,
0.17334099113941193,
-0.13716432452201843,
0.4548979699611664,
0.4489526152610779,
0.5937602519989014,
0.11071933060884476,
0.6928161382675171,
-0.29073140025138855,
0.2105073183774948,
1.2195812463760376,
-0.008086229674518108,
1.0345337390899658,
0.9253401756286621,
0.0781315416097641,
0.37805017828941345,
0.4343356788158417,
0.12327875196933746,
0.5506035685539246,
0.5526390671730042,
-0.22556690871715546,
-0.34204864501953125,
0.050941694527864456,
-0.17716121673583984,
0.3207607567310333,
0.5433460474014282,
-0.4099305272102356,
-0.28459152579307556,
-0.07157859206199646,
-0.10073010623455048,
-0.16921409964561462,
-0.422454297542572,
0.8804359436035156,
0.16492581367492676,
-0.6593469381332397,
0.4621681571006775,
0.015714086592197418,
0.7011788487434387,
-0.7227885723114014,
-0.1407950222492218,
-0.22789035737514496,
0.08005828410387039,
-0.12420988082885742,
-0.6349701881408691,
0.07526686787605286,
-0.11498845368623734,
-0.2345324605703354,
-0.07513522356748581,
0.9032623171806335,
-0.47517144680023193,
-0.15175041556358337,
0.2849104702472687,
0.38090547919273376,
0.02528412453830242,
-0.5169602632522583,
-0.5891652703285217,
-0.14116938412189484,
-0.07567129284143448,
-0.40965718030929565,
0.4114017188549042,
0.5109136700630188,
-0.1346372365951538,
0.7621239423751831,
0.5475357174873352,
0.2389908879995346,
0.18035081028938293,
-0.0724601075053215,
0.97719806432724,
-0.6316949129104614,
-0.2420819103717804,
-0.7480921149253845,
0.3693760931491852,
-0.01925453543663025,
-0.5267895460128784,
0.45673879981040955,
0.41802889108657837,
0.5868741273880005,
-0.12244076281785965,
0.7690837383270264,
-0.029760701581835747,
0.29108428955078125,
-0.6152722239494324,
0.917081356048584,
-0.6663027405738831,
0.12532496452331543,
-0.04823428392410278,
-1.014004111289978,
-0.28419414162635803,
0.4832359850406647,
-0.3578970432281494,
-0.25442078709602356,
0.7428737282752991,
1.1042389869689941,
-0.20118261873722076,
-0.09986559301614761,
0.27406662702560425,
0.2837751507759094,
0.34991350769996643,
0.44872716069221497,
0.9950618743896484,
-0.3905375897884369,
0.3516243100166321,
-0.11225652694702148,
-0.013753781095147133,
0.057282060384750366,
-0.8782685995101929,
-0.8115900754928589,
-0.798583447933197,
-0.25801363587379456,
0.07539302855730057,
-0.13054779171943665,
0.7852016091346741,
0.3450078070163727,
-0.8759730458259583,
-0.30438166856765747,
-0.16841617226600647,
0.12894688546657562,
-0.14243008196353912,
-0.12214511632919312,
0.7358127236366272,
-0.5041821002960205,
-0.21056702733039856,
0.5652060508728027,
0.1173686757683754,
0.06736121326684952,
-0.31593671441078186,
0.27876046299934387,
-0.4351051151752472,
-0.07574256509542465,
0.49977636337280273,
0.21892111003398895,
-0.6671562194824219,
-0.23894064128398895,
0.11918948590755463,
-0.2376156747341156,
-0.0008633882971480489,
1.0313924551010132,
-0.5930554866790771,
0.13600778579711914,
0.7304031848907471,
0.7603068351745605,
0.23248539865016937,
-0.18088658154010773,
0.6453343629837036,
-0.6049551367759705,
-0.14370541274547577,
0.40436825156211853,
0.4324081838130951,
0.09801354259252548,
-0.1300344318151474,
0.10881498456001282,
-0.06703280657529831,
-0.653861403465271,
-0.6077170968055725,
0.01927962340414524,
-0.8397872447967529,
-0.3689178228378296,
1.4301481246948242,
-0.02567717246711254,
-0.47210749983787537,
-0.07490818202495575,
-0.1933545023202896,
0.03161058574914932,
-0.2122657597064972,
0.6597892045974731,
0.787276029586792,
0.08233608305454254,
0.15616939961910248,
-0.530845046043396,
0.721798837184906,
0.5885887742042542,
-0.7842145562171936,
0.272754967212677,
0.5256662964820862,
0.10202658176422119,
0.43145328760147095,
0.6469905376434326,
-0.20062334835529327,
0.09930126368999481,
-0.23242348432540894,
0.24400246143341064,
0.19646400213241577,
-0.5231528282165527,
-0.543075442314148,
0.34416308999061584,
0.16852688789367676,
-0.05074542760848999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10858v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10858v1
|
Step-level Value Preference Optimization for Mathematical Reasoning
| 2024-06-16T09:06:17 | 2024-06-16T09:06:17 |
Guoxin Chen, Minpeng Liao, Chengxi Li, Kai Fan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) using an implicit reward model has
proven to be an effective alternative to reinforcement learning from human
feedback (RLHF) for fine-tuning preference aligned large language models
(LLMs). However, the overall preference annotations of responses do not fully
capture the fine-grained quality of model outputs in complex multi-step
reasoning tasks, such as mathematical reasoning. To address this limitation, we
introduce a novel algorithm called Step-level Value Preference Optimization
(SVPO). Our approach employs Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) to automatically
annotate step-level preferences for multi-step reasoning. Furthermore, from the
perspective of learning-to-rank, we train an explicit value model to replicate
the behavior of the implicit reward model, complementing standard preference
optimization. This value model enables the LLM to generate higher reward
responses with minimal cost during inference. Experimental results demonstrate
that our method achieves state-of-the-art performance on both in-domain and
out-of-domain mathematical reasoning benchmarks.
|
[
-0.3804619312286377,
-0.22042380273342133,
0.6822218298912048,
0.08153870701789856,
-0.30118826031684875,
0.17649969458580017,
0.133811816573143,
-0.23122352361679077,
-0.050678517669439316,
0.3876391351222992,
-0.8339309096336365,
-0.5566041469573975,
-0.5565253496170044,
-0.07774624228477478,
0.3893043100833893,
0.7830503582954407,
-0.10680423676967621,
0.024204006418585777,
-0.5213723182678223,
0.23417560756206512,
-0.06484708935022354,
-0.5655186772346497,
-0.8729045987129211,
-0.46608760952949524,
0.72145676612854,
0.5750689506530762,
0.35390788316726685,
0.5137214660644531,
0.35468819737434387,
0.1889389604330063,
-0.11683095246553421,
0.35053500533103943,
-0.47639310359954834,
0.2749258577823639,
-0.10765684396028519,
-0.2904864549636841,
-0.42996087670326233,
0.0004520428192336112,
0.24309536814689636,
0.4223083257675171,
-0.049735378473997116,
0.0433182567358017,
-0.25234007835388184,
0.9573615789413452,
-0.727263867855072,
0.4509021043777466,
-0.6308125257492065,
0.1342458873987198,
0.18888236582279205,
-0.6159467101097107,
-0.5390668511390686,
-0.6254928112030029,
0.11086905002593994,
-0.7039745450019836,
-0.1328948587179184,
-0.027967652305960655,
0.579552948474884,
0.4519118666648865,
-0.33050358295440674,
-0.2743578851222992,
-0.656879723072052,
0.9873732924461365,
-0.5068724751472473,
0.21718832850456238,
0.3128828704357147,
0.28416839241981506,
-0.27315229177474976,
-0.1455649435520172,
-0.2328714281320572,
-0.6584526300430298,
0.09394551813602448,
0.032914455980062485,
0.32795238494873047,
0.2086724489927292,
0.33204522728919983,
0.11731389164924622,
-0.22670888900756836,
-0.1282656192779541,
0.08120400458574295,
0.062460292130708694,
0.6940440535545349,
0.08328307420015335,
-0.09411957859992981,
-0.23757563531398773,
-0.2780602276325226,
-0.41082051396369934,
-0.5680752992630005,
0.7766292095184326,
0.32723909616470337,
0.5290046334266663,
0.5677734017372131,
0.5578423142433167,
-0.44156569242477417,
0.5263320803642273,
0.0853782668709755,
-0.4476853013038635,
0.13114289939403534,
-0.04104021564126015,
-0.08040475845336914,
0.253728985786438,
0.5387700200080872,
0.11197957396507263,
0.4548453688621521,
0.16114769876003265,
-0.20926740765571594,
0.003650752129033208,
0.17211104929447174,
-0.9302536249160767,
-0.07136763632297516,
0.2313452810049057,
-0.0642198696732521,
-0.7518845200538635,
-0.3326559066772461,
-0.6433166265487671,
-0.2051408439874649,
-0.4155742824077606,
0.4399024546146393,
-0.3561254143714905,
-0.10675088316202164,
0.20808087289333344,
-0.02116277441382408,
-0.270466148853302,
0.6593257784843445,
-1.2111012935638428,
0.3583560883998871,
0.7633870244026184,
0.5340253114700317,
-0.16832199692726135,
-0.138394296169281,
-1.0301865339279175,
0.11671341955661774,
-0.5198583602905273,
0.7789230942726135,
-1.0128271579742432,
-0.4965835213661194,
-0.15219825506210327,
-0.3853359520435333,
0.12899203598499298,
-0.3515622317790985,
0.9116219878196716,
-0.5487861037254333,
-0.08649816364049911,
-0.4892828166484833,
-0.2338360995054245,
-0.01182450819760561,
0.2830126881599426,
-0.3529685437679291,
1.4090495109558105,
0.05589118227362633,
-0.6349748969078064,
0.6302473545074463,
-0.8299667835235596,
-0.29596930742263794,
-0.053677238523960114,
-0.18728095293045044,
-0.37411069869995117,
0.18416708707809448,
0.49985939264297485,
0.3718530833721161,
-0.13400648534297943,
0.10372719913721085,
-0.5435608625411987,
-0.44615837931632996,
-0.1655852049589157,
-0.14340586960315704,
0.4207972586154938,
-0.007708285003900528,
-0.44968217611312866,
0.45578306913375854,
-0.7505838871002197,
0.036708321422338486,
0.3327473998069763,
-0.27047649025917053,
-0.8407217860221863,
0.3564789295196533,
-0.7198672294616699,
0.6061209440231323,
0.30666017532348633,
-0.5911093354225159,
0.682058572769165,
-0.3327680826187134,
0.25816643238067627,
1.131858229637146,
-0.17106802761554718,
0.45452171564102173,
0.09309878200292587,
0.547598123550415,
0.2568824887275696,
0.2252991944551468,
0.11960162967443466,
-0.32594549655914307,
-0.5789089202880859,
-0.29783159494400024,
0.25584790110588074,
0.49336645007133484,
-0.5279588103294373,
0.2759440839290619,
-0.3176262080669403,
-0.19610919058322906,
-0.5591108798980713,
-0.18052707612514496,
0.26591673493385315,
0.6387007832527161,
0.5275084376335144,
0.1558150053024292,
-0.052513040602207184,
-0.9926306009292603,
-0.10570038110017776,
-0.1099454015493393,
0.026705436408519745,
0.6755242943763733,
0.4461365342140198,
0.17106370627880096,
0.7409968376159668,
-0.6955788135528564,
0.016865037381649017,
0.04105990380048752,
0.2705918252468109,
0.042714864015579224,
0.27923259139060974,
0.1635923981666565,
-0.665753960609436,
-0.3955818712711334,
0.0002993991074617952,
-0.10918626934289932,
-0.13062626123428345,
0.054602377116680145,
-0.33759963512420654,
0.06442778557538986,
0.12106118351221085,
-0.23193226754665375,
0.22259242832660675,
0.3511820435523987,
-0.10652749240398407,
0.19285130500793457,
-0.30980566143989563,
0.47434285283088684,
-0.6929843425750732,
-0.1256784349679947,
0.1420333832502365,
-0.1336054801940918,
-0.14273755252361298,
-0.34176889061927795,
0.06946616619825363,
-0.10143515467643738,
-0.2689065635204315,
0.5809967517852783,
-0.12691375613212585,
-0.2830826938152313,
-0.19065572321414948,
0.005822974257171154,
-0.14720509946346283,
0.9128689169883728,
0.46241557598114014,
0.7367051839828491,
0.38609230518341064,
-0.7336204648017883,
0.22539906203746796,
0.000374591356376186,
0.058114077895879745,
0.6705734133720398,
-0.5015053749084473,
0.010876979678869247,
-0.22596628963947296,
0.38427385687828064,
-1.0566281080245972,
0.12377528101205826,
0.2729075253009796,
-0.5224373936653137,
0.13562586903572083,
-0.6738176941871643,
-0.32871580123901367,
-0.26775074005126953,
-0.5150112509727478,
0.39526423811912537,
0.33884361386299133,
-0.7506709098815918,
0.418645977973938,
0.1478179693222046,
-0.2682688534259796,
-0.7977541089057922,
-0.004846994765102863,
-0.37163978815078735,
-0.035294171422719955,
-0.38053229451179504,
0.28192347288131714,
-0.22049789130687714,
0.07987111061811447,
-0.354509562253952,
-0.47484996914863586,
0.12214489281177521,
-0.008882373571395874,
0.23872999846935272,
0.31043460965156555,
0.18538476526737213,
0.025990497320890427,
0.5736953616142273,
-0.5523400902748108,
0.22967655956745148,
-0.4523731470108032,
0.49526485800743103,
-0.14942771196365356,
-0.5557276010513306,
-0.1059807762503624,
0.2918274700641632,
0.6472296714782715,
-0.3686996102333069,
0.201979860663414,
0.16170260310173035,
-0.24598169326782227,
-0.4193178415298462,
-0.01892995275557041,
-0.24605228006839752,
-0.43722283840179443,
0.12613333761692047,
-0.8595329523086548,
-0.8260305523872375,
-0.1090501993894577,
-0.35957735776901245,
0.3218061327934265,
0.533000111579895,
0.3735961318016052,
0.052942655980587006,
1.6981379985809326,
0.18041712045669556,
0.25484296679496765,
0.4429452121257782,
-0.1603594422340393,
0.18116942048072815,
-0.7609031200408936,
-0.4431924819946289,
-0.7509273290634155,
-0.2586158812046051,
-0.6299694776535034,
-0.4897705614566803,
0.4970873296260834,
0.04026797041296959,
-0.3690851628780365,
-0.03145303949713707,
-0.8226106762886047,
0.3324146270751953,
0.7964932322502136,
0.14200250804424286,
0.43466970324516296,
0.18206056952476501,
-0.6186784505844116,
-0.1973271369934082,
-0.620033323764801,
-0.3633301854133606,
0.869613766670227,
0.22814832627773285,
0.678815484046936,
-0.29678207635879517,
0.9575484991073608,
-0.014461059123277664,
0.2041665017604828,
-0.9736902713775635,
0.6110243201255798,
-0.15111543238162994,
-0.24599184095859528,
-0.7716223001480103,
-0.6963571310043335,
-0.6933484673500061,
0.4805021286010742,
-0.04383021965622902,
-0.577694296836853,
0.20396028459072113,
0.23763719201087952,
-0.3568877577781677,
0.19260947406291962,
-0.18857073783874512,
0.746104896068573,
-0.35105857253074646,
-0.4693674147129059,
-0.30683210492134094,
-0.5411902070045471,
0.450238972902298,
0.1782350093126297,
0.17193540930747986,
-0.46203067898750305,
-0.012320905923843384,
0.38750818371772766,
-0.3648040294647217,
0.31269681453704834,
-0.22820401191711426,
-0.1759769767522812,
-0.13306160271167755,
0.35133302211761475,
0.7242872714996338,
0.4237314760684967,
-0.1852961778640747,
-0.07155724614858627,
0.08830377459526062,
-0.43592873215675354,
-0.6053490042686462,
0.9542450904846191,
-0.7189755439758301,
-0.44173333048820496,
-0.8761335015296936,
-0.44440925121307373,
-0.5308569073677063,
0.014465945772826672,
-0.20297597348690033,
0.19801321625709534,
0.05584809184074402,
-0.15180493891239166,
1.0379247665405273,
-0.05651140585541725,
0.32004013657569885,
0.2370525598526001,
-0.30457228422164917,
-0.5419341325759888,
0.8563942909240723,
-0.25217702984809875,
0.3250024616718292,
0.8765223622322083,
0.6283484697341919,
-0.5266290307044983,
-0.43969839811325073,
-0.6312530636787415,
0.08030843734741211,
-0.5422742366790771,
0.11407070606946945,
-0.51995450258255,
-0.0869288221001625,
-0.1676340401172638,
-0.2821885645389557,
-0.599018394947052,
-0.5952447652816772,
0.0792846605181694,
-0.030280185863375664,
0.4127327501773834,
0.45802634954452515,
-0.07093600928783417,
-0.35492730140686035,
-0.5173412561416626,
0.5146406292915344,
0.7028154134750366,
0.5797930955886841,
-0.10843498259782791,
-0.3668232560157776,
-0.0119885029271245,
0.17487776279449463,
-0.1027722954750061,
-0.36399129033088684,
0.3254634737968445,
-0.37601083517074585,
0.5179134607315063,
0.1842835545539856,
0.18232254683971405,
0.7374987006187439,
-0.515270471572876,
0.5136998891830444,
0.09824966639280319,
-0.9627828598022461,
0.8692595958709717,
-0.26158571243286133,
0.15565159916877747,
0.6631038188934326,
0.6781061887741089,
-0.3391455411911011,
0.07410722225904465,
-0.6279823184013367,
-0.7701944708824158,
0.8548668622970581,
0.09954723715782166,
-0.17611899971961975,
0.06204510107636452,
0.3760184049606323,
0.05780579522252083,
0.3044453561306,
-0.5853681564331055,
-0.16959413886070251,
-0.19200436770915985,
0.058028772473335266,
-0.13183851540088654,
-0.19143958389759064,
-0.32264792919158936,
-0.4998764991760254,
0.8153765201568604,
-0.3528003990650177,
0.11508624255657196,
0.170554980635643,
0.2024458348751068,
-0.5055792331695557,
0.176932230591774,
0.8859730362892151,
0.5616059303283691,
-0.43625107407569885,
0.10646037012338638,
0.061442434787750244,
-0.2217676192522049,
0.2947424352169037,
0.09062600135803223,
-0.1539418250322342,
-0.08331039547920227,
-0.34965482354164124,
0.854484498500824,
0.3259795904159546,
-0.4803865849971771,
0.39896905422210693,
-0.09455941617488861,
-0.4301757514476776,
-0.12680727243423462,
0.2746449112892151,
0.0985104963183403,
0.01493055559694767,
0.26270854473114014,
0.05865960195660591,
0.11383289843797684,
-0.36022916436195374,
0.04176395386457443,
0.5992135405540466,
-0.5088052153587341,
0.0502479188144207,
0.6049785017967224,
0.19325216114521027,
-0.31273898482322693,
0.42314964532852173,
-0.08049843460321426,
-0.4430448114871979,
0.4771669805049896,
0.1852734535932541,
0.7917155623435974,
-0.25611412525177,
0.43042367696762085,
0.539334237575531,
0.16732725501060486,
-0.1917658895254135,
0.24369117617607117,
-0.26163890957832336,
-0.46165114641189575,
-0.4893814027309418,
-0.7178979516029358,
-0.6892184019088745,
-0.00497762905433774,
-0.5042292475700378,
0.35683462023735046,
-0.47047096490859985,
0.2015598565340042,
0.047825586050748825,
0.25822415947914124,
-0.3723107874393463,
0.47432491183280945,
0.11155307292938232,
0.6011665463447571,
-0.6015723943710327,
0.918975830078125,
0.5238790512084961,
-0.48133718967437744,
-0.5468303561210632,
-0.08913812786340714,
-0.24703378975391388,
-0.910663366317749,
0.9119672775268555,
-0.09095253050327301,
-0.5491698980331421,
0.038894347846508026,
-0.39526066184043884,
-0.8782943487167358,
0.9722951650619507,
0.2809368669986725,
-0.4934571087360382,
0.01985814794898033,
0.17006459832191467,
0.3963947296142578,
-0.649093508720398,
0.5221765637397766,
0.4858502745628357,
0.47748395800590515,
0.8314067125320435,
-0.6297696232795715,
-0.05446714162826538,
-0.03068075329065323,
0.25018301606178284,
0.5624605417251587,
-0.5195974707603455,
0.5445262789726257,
-0.25061357021331787,
0.4552360475063324,
-0.47096943855285645,
0.4592799246311188,
0.9282605051994324,
0.31251221895217896,
0.8110471367835999,
0.6421710252761841,
0.6124076247215271,
-0.017361335456371307,
0.9224597215652466,
-0.23909011483192444,
0.3378129005432129,
0.8981097936630249,
-0.2258356362581253,
0.9928337335586548,
0.5316267013549805,
-0.18696220219135284,
0.5240824818611145,
1.1371487379074097,
0.39357489347457886,
0.6990746855735779,
0.557114839553833,
-0.2697364091873169,
-0.5965527296066284,
0.07455584406852722,
-0.2362833321094513,
-0.016564885154366493,
0.18523544073104858,
-0.22276146709918976,
-0.02450750209391117,
-0.5624154806137085,
-0.02828061394393444,
-0.11328780651092529,
-0.5093119740486145,
0.6374571323394775,
-0.12198541313409805,
-0.8377605080604553,
0.5989730954170227,
-0.15334098041057587,
0.38300085067749023,
-0.6653669476509094,
-0.26867789030075073,
-0.18389537930488586,
0.02160106785595417,
-0.12983334064483643,
-0.5133019685745239,
-0.1450454741716385,
-0.17378245294094086,
-0.09825416654348373,
-0.516883909702301,
0.3713723421096802,
-0.3461957573890686,
-0.5684592723846436,
0.2066178321838379,
0.17889642715454102,
-0.010278100147843361,
-0.2158278077840805,
-0.8243849277496338,
-0.28001266717910767,
-0.11251109838485718,
-0.45536184310913086,
0.5097256898880005,
0.5736970901489258,
-0.19615310430526733,
0.7980507016181946,
0.9380331039428711,
0.015694638714194298,
-0.1721387505531311,
0.17473945021629333,
0.8263952136039734,
-0.7524135112762451,
-0.5731468796730042,
-0.7545709609985352,
0.5312941670417786,
-0.2197076380252838,
-0.356972873210907,
0.31398847699165344,
0.6105100512504578,
0.8724228739738464,
0.0393901951611042,
0.8125178813934326,
0.4500305652618408,
0.5330141186714172,
-0.4433329403400421,
-0.004615601617842913,
-0.7810713052749634,
0.23891766369342804,
-0.5786148309707642,
-0.9866277575492859,
-0.13908705115318298,
0.7151651382446289,
-0.42405232787132263,
0.1798122078180313,
0.8363659381866455,
0.44835829734802246,
-0.09346359223127365,
-0.21535278856754303,
0.47091856598854065,
-0.19772127270698547,
0.2799162268638611,
0.8415206074714661,
0.6222280263900757,
-0.0010464059887453914,
0.6445204615592957,
-0.48211905360221863,
-0.37849727272987366,
-0.3720625936985016,
-1.1468946933746338,
-0.8298503756523132,
-0.40791261196136475,
-0.2493109107017517,
-0.33506008982658386,
-0.0035164705477654934,
1.1972968578338623,
0.7777793407440186,
-0.7444390058517456,
-0.27700620889663696,
-0.2412533164024353,
0.38485175371170044,
-0.4657748341560364,
-0.1536562740802765,
0.20494616031646729,
-0.4750427007675171,
-0.9795480966567993,
0.41313812136650085,
0.6527976393699646,
-0.15343795716762543,
-0.45272403955459595,
-0.2686316967010498,
-0.12156818062067032,
0.4168561100959778,
0.7959166169166565,
0.14076752960681915,
-0.7726045250892639,
-0.2670849561691284,
0.14048124849796295,
-0.24140635132789612,
0.47154462337493896,
0.9648263454437256,
-0.631572961807251,
0.4730052947998047,
0.6658975481987,
0.4704010784626007,
0.9064740538597107,
0.056305766105651855,
0.5358649492263794,
-0.3091508746147156,
-0.18749606609344482,
0.4770166575908661,
0.16417936980724335,
-0.03459661826491356,
-0.39106371998786926,
0.4295589327812195,
0.29165852069854736,
-0.5436323285102844,
-0.6815426349639893,
0.48868805170059204,
-1.1444473266601562,
-0.3169134557247162,
1.0900945663452148,
0.035552073270082474,
-0.1231110692024231,
0.2463395744562149,
-0.35174068808555603,
0.04781760275363922,
-0.9269819855690002,
0.9132137894630432,
0.686519980430603,
-0.5125935673713684,
-0.2829609215259552,
-0.4868004322052002,
0.9600245952606201,
0.44650864601135254,
-0.960893988609314,
0.04190335050225258,
0.5022007822990417,
0.24569089710712433,
-0.0825507864356041,
0.5466231107711792,
-0.058105193078517914,
0.18266864120960236,
-0.21619105339050293,
0.06156466156244278,
-0.2882500886917114,
-0.5323956608772278,
-0.3509071171283722,
0.3813454210758209,
0.3037636876106262,
-0.24694807827472687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10851v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10851v1
|
Leading Whitespaces of Language Models' Subword Vocabulary Poses a Confound for Calculating Word Probabilities
| 2024-06-16T08:44:56 | 2024-06-16T08:44:56 |
Byung-Doh Oh, William Schuler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Word-by-word conditional probabilities from Transformer-based language models
are increasingly being used to evaluate their predictions over minimal pairs or
to model the incremental processing difficulty of human readers. In this paper,
we argue that there is a confound posed by the subword tokenization scheme of
such language models, which has gone unaddressed thus far. This is due to the
fact that tokens in the subword vocabulary of most language models have leading
whitespaces and therefore do not naturally define stop probabilities of words.
We first prove that this can result in word probabilities that sum to more than
one, thereby violating the axiom that $\mathsf{P}(\Omega) = 1$. This property
results in a misallocation of word-by-word surprisal, where the unacceptability
of the current 'end of word' is incorrectly carried over to the next word.
Additionally, language models' such implicit prediction of word boundaries is
incongruous with psycholinguistic experiments where human subjects directly
observe upcoming word boundaries. We present a simple decoding technique to
reaccount the probability of the trailing whitespace into that of the current
word, which resolves this confound. As a case study, we show that this results
in significantly different estimates of garden-path effects in
transitive/intransitive sentences, where a comma is strongly expected before
the critical word.
|
[
-0.09192243218421936,
-0.7526109218597412,
0.4639960527420044,
0.0983608141541481,
-0.577725887298584,
-0.3045247197151184,
0.03279585763812065,
-0.33715566992759705,
0.08703062683343887,
0.25527945160865784,
-0.7089353203773499,
-0.3136165738105774,
-0.979367733001709,
-0.1291208267211914,
-0.3534228801727295,
0.77369225025177,
0.1970103532075882,
-0.11360570043325424,
-0.3812536895275116,
-0.14207567274570465,
-0.6892094016075134,
-0.6740230917930603,
-0.25169992446899414,
-0.27728796005249023,
0.459517240524292,
0.1500663459300995,
1.2938445806503296,
0.29981136322021484,
0.5173393487930298,
0.1926582008600235,
-0.22483041882514954,
-0.09521104395389557,
-0.21535204350948334,
-0.04360736161470413,
0.012150680646300316,
-0.615654468536377,
-0.21129253506660461,
0.11968640983104706,
0.3143424391746521,
1.1156426668167114,
-0.10865049064159393,
-0.07301673293113708,
-0.04841402918100357,
0.4099235534667969,
-0.7063846588134766,
0.07260876148939133,
-0.6181691884994507,
0.34722912311553955,
-0.5224671363830566,
-0.20334076881408691,
-0.630197286605835,
0.004045574925839901,
0.19595597684383392,
-0.5625293254852295,
0.07594770193099976,
0.00918356142938137,
0.6302081346511841,
0.19338840246200562,
-0.06423068791627884,
-0.3455202579498291,
-0.5989939570426941,
0.5291310548782349,
-0.7951444983482361,
0.5631482601165771,
0.27050647139549255,
-0.05104348435997963,
-0.2636287808418274,
-0.5875347256660461,
-0.8769015669822693,
-0.4130605161190033,
-0.26973509788513184,
0.1947944015264511,
-0.5646754503250122,
0.2586587071418762,
0.36480915546417236,
0.0666227638721466,
-0.47867846488952637,
0.03260583430528641,
-0.5401236414909363,
-0.16508007049560547,
0.42793893814086914,
0.1166912093758583,
0.3311336636543274,
-0.09100433439016342,
-0.3560635447502136,
-0.1059781014919281,
-0.6436096429824829,
0.1713002771139145,
0.44454583525657654,
0.4209648668766022,
-0.099185049533844,
0.6135259866714478,
0.07177542895078659,
0.42158934473991394,
-0.374322772026062,
0.048062119632959366,
0.19382856786251068,
-0.3071643114089966,
-0.254255086183548,
-0.12490903586149216,
0.533052921295166,
0.4031825661659241,
0.7093191742897034,
-0.274402379989624,
0.12392236292362213,
0.4903164803981781,
0.008835520595312119,
-0.4162590503692627,
-0.3729284107685089,
0.11023072153329849,
-0.30642709136009216,
0.06289450824260712,
0.018784835934638977,
-0.2660374939441681,
-0.32167133688926697,
0.09720971435308456,
0.2780599296092987,
-0.5724627375602722,
-0.22602972388267517,
0.40337973833084106,
-0.3090851902961731,
-0.048881273716688156,
0.03361198306083679,
-0.4892336130142212,
0.40311476588249207,
0.6986815333366394,
0.8277484178543091,
-0.04844850301742554,
-0.5332745313644409,
-0.32443001866340637,
-0.296792596578598,
-0.4396507441997528,
0.5917414426803589,
-0.5859133005142212,
-0.7342320680618286,
-0.013643009588122368,
0.08019684255123138,
-0.06772510707378387,
-0.28442755341529846,
0.4976864159107208,
-0.3417849838733673,
0.039450813084840775,
-0.08927617967128754,
-0.6748170852661133,
0.05088910087943077,
-0.025703057646751404,
-0.25800830125808716,
0.40678882598876953,
-0.22125381231307983,
-0.8260729312896729,
0.41766536235809326,
-0.12318775802850723,
-0.6539527773857117,
0.12089598923921585,
-0.1620580554008484,
-0.2624768018722534,
0.5568798780441284,
-0.1283787190914154,
0.07322564721107483,
0.04734158143401146,
0.24913403391838074,
-0.1605805605649948,
-0.3472096920013428,
0.6473231911659241,
-0.7741062641143799,
0.5818641781806946,
0.02834491990506649,
-0.038556721061468124,
-0.02729320153594017,
-0.49709630012512207,
-0.1917017102241516,
-0.12491956353187561,
-0.12789766490459442,
-0.5896472930908203,
0.32065412402153015,
-0.04475624859333038,
0.2434673309326172,
-0.06015510857105255,
-0.7172204256057739,
0.11712907254695892,
-0.3844432532787323,
0.004950803238898516,
0.8120424151420593,
-0.11005029827356339,
0.36020150780677795,
-0.17517776787281036,
0.7037108540534973,
0.2978261113166809,
0.15458522737026215,
-0.21190716326236725,
-0.7157928943634033,
-0.5202361345291138,
0.03473535180091858,
0.2913438081741333,
0.5788045525550842,
-0.6047458052635193,
0.10251561552286148,
-0.2719348967075348,
-0.5887469053268433,
-0.2883078157901764,
-0.3199528455734253,
0.4498292803764343,
0.44982996582984924,
0.3647381067276001,
-0.11431993544101715,
-0.4866175651550293,
-0.8580527305603027,
-0.46771669387817383,
-0.12392774969339371,
0.2262139767408371,
0.08339957892894745,
0.41636988520622253,
-0.07408660650253296,
0.99139803647995,
-0.6830143928527832,
-0.3113066256046295,
-0.43320274353027344,
0.1437058299779892,
0.49762505292892456,
0.6088740825653076,
0.021541938185691833,
-0.8029935359954834,
-0.19412340223789215,
-0.5553222894668579,
-0.3384171426296234,
-0.169049933552742,
-0.25312116742134094,
-0.05709971860051155,
0.226917564868927,
0.7531936764717102,
-0.8780059218406677,
0.7529277801513672,
0.5518828630447388,
-0.5830148458480835,
0.6259759664535522,
-0.42053401470184326,
-0.5786550641059875,
-0.6317402124404907,
-0.09132374823093414,
0.06002909317612648,
0.22105450928211212,
-0.5100491642951965,
-0.05148813873529434,
-0.20493599772453308,
0.27485448122024536,
-0.4981422424316406,
0.5583997368812561,
-0.38644346594810486,
-0.0016355233965441585,
-0.3406016230583191,
0.09297402203083038,
-0.39174965023994446,
0.43542858958244324,
0.13381610810756683,
0.7055562734603882,
0.39928117394447327,
-0.510453999042511,
-0.28701305389404297,
0.4305591881275177,
-0.11671361327171326,
0.07998920232057571,
-0.581608772277832,
-0.11265800148248672,
-0.38866671919822693,
0.41601675748825073,
-1.0762882232666016,
0.3058440685272217,
-0.03762983903288841,
-0.5086004734039307,
-0.022060664370656013,
-0.026977136731147766,
-0.49364686012268066,
-0.19894970953464508,
-0.08810117840766907,
0.5541282296180725,
0.7765457630157471,
0.02853064052760601,
0.3303929567337036,
0.4809191823005676,
0.13536213338375092,
-0.5391561985015869,
-1.005923867225647,
0.06657643616199493,
0.09213218837976456,
-0.5076014995574951,
0.23086193203926086,
0.04781613126397133,
-0.4213193655014038,
0.1727723330259323,
-0.18188434839248657,
0.5011260509490967,
0.2536926567554474,
0.3753378391265869,
0.2932162582874298,
0.17375507950782776,
0.16296380758285522,
-0.11338675022125244,
-0.36500826478004456,
0.09280650317668915,
-0.43712788820266724,
0.6403104066848755,
0.33441850543022156,
-0.43524083495140076,
-0.06277665495872498,
0.34649142622947693,
0.5044596195220947,
-0.10471368581056595,
0.8635769486427307,
0.17174208164215088,
-0.6933672428131104,
-0.0841163769364357,
-0.03637956455349922,
0.016543377190828323,
-0.42520785331726074,
0.5007436275482178,
-0.6317511200904846,
-0.5554988980293274,
0.47420039772987366,
0.2629736363887787,
-0.14056256413459778,
0.5320708751678467,
0.27963554859161377,
0.016276873648166656,
0.8776752352714539,
0.861372709274292,
0.3534315824508667,
0.31065431237220764,
-0.2842866778373718,
0.4736718237400055,
-0.8887264728546143,
-0.2607400119304657,
-0.20912304520606995,
-0.1768132895231247,
-1.0369858741760254,
-0.40760350227355957,
0.4003075361251831,
-0.009844858199357986,
0.20510566234588623,
0.42334768176078796,
-0.24752973020076752,
0.3207707703113556,
0.6230784058570862,
-0.24718548357486725,
0.18441735208034515,
-0.10166417062282562,
-0.648751437664032,
-0.3873213827610016,
-0.88363116979599,
-0.18405556678771973,
0.7444198131561279,
0.30224114656448364,
0.9295400977134705,
0.05576661601662636,
0.3358919024467468,
0.477044016122818,
0.39116978645324707,
-0.7915597558021545,
0.6191189885139465,
-0.6669954061508179,
-0.45519542694091797,
-0.34746113419532776,
-0.09107141196727753,
-0.9116357564926147,
0.46249839663505554,
-0.1830299347639084,
-1.0057618618011475,
0.4704388678073883,
0.01159859262406826,
-0.4517405033111572,
0.34804946184158325,
-0.4476478397846222,
0.8655287623405457,
0.06362050026655197,
-0.2975514531135559,
-0.1343611776828766,
-0.5917132496833801,
0.23485444486141205,
0.1484026461839676,
0.48025721311569214,
-0.12683643400669098,
0.1789369434118271,
0.695365309715271,
-0.8481369018554688,
0.791291356086731,
-0.3123306632041931,
-0.10514451563358307,
0.1811584085226059,
0.2657254934310913,
0.5854557752609253,
-0.23458068072795868,
0.04474370554089546,
0.08373113721609116,
0.02486281283199787,
-0.14016754925251007,
-0.31741443276405334,
0.13215909898281097,
-0.5613794326782227,
-0.6149100065231323,
-0.725472629070282,
-0.5474584102630615,
-0.27011775970458984,
0.06971722096204758,
0.8612024784088135,
0.5656750798225403,
0.059526290744543076,
0.03640429303050041,
0.2571924328804016,
-0.3228466808795929,
0.277226060628891,
0.2949814796447754,
-0.10052276402711868,
-0.28833577036857605,
0.6650134325027466,
0.6985673904418945,
0.2878834307193756,
0.34006214141845703,
0.22982259094715118,
-0.46012428402900696,
-0.611230731010437,
-0.023175137117505074,
0.22061395645141602,
-0.7845788598060608,
0.1374896913766861,
-0.6741313338279724,
-0.2947145998477936,
-0.42041847109794617,
-0.24089756608009338,
0.051120366901159286,
-0.31274908781051636,
-0.07982268184423447,
-0.24817100167274475,
0.01042008213698864,
0.3055523931980133,
-0.1221989244222641,
0.39896613359451294,
-0.7864592671394348,
-0.0966617614030838,
-0.060327671468257904,
0.17314104735851288,
0.0928511843085289,
-0.6281773447990417,
-0.24639257788658142,
-0.208054319024086,
-0.020982801914215088,
-0.9117213487625122,
0.37369054555892944,
-0.02097630500793457,
0.38511478900909424,
0.21455557644367218,
0.11007549613714218,
0.7226174473762512,
-0.9206333160400391,
0.7621910572052002,
0.24092429876327515,
-0.9723535180091858,
0.19571159780025482,
-0.10810153186321259,
0.359173059463501,
0.37203890085220337,
0.1452542394399643,
-1.028436541557312,
-0.7602640390396118,
-0.9674364328384399,
-1.0532934665679932,
0.48047834634780884,
0.3013192415237427,
0.48579803109169006,
-0.418889582157135,
0.13472937047481537,
0.20283852517604828,
0.04267839714884758,
-0.7484893798828125,
-0.17907875776290894,
0.04739219695329666,
-0.06544346362352371,
-0.2921317219734192,
-0.4641115069389343,
0.29528433084487915,
-0.05931730195879936,
0.7318580746650696,
-0.0012940268497914076,
0.13373015820980072,
0.34739452600479126,
-0.18998126685619354,
-0.13448508083820343,
0.2746492028236389,
0.6234030723571777,
0.6077777743339539,
-0.08643819391727448,
0.2969720661640167,
0.18674209713935852,
-0.3812331557273865,
0.04909079149365425,
0.1977163553237915,
-0.35014498233795166,
0.32335785031318665,
0.7906006574630737,
0.7652894854545593,
0.05243663862347603,
-0.5059399604797363,
0.668032705783844,
0.0576353557407856,
0.08463270962238312,
-0.5344761610031128,
-0.04458020627498627,
0.056840915232896805,
0.04698851332068443,
0.6020990610122681,
0.23148050904273987,
0.15384541451931,
-0.5931217074394226,
0.2631344497203827,
0.6943766474723816,
-0.4032430350780487,
-0.5376765131950378,
0.6766039729118347,
-0.02990294247865677,
-0.476692259311676,
0.4563787579536438,
-0.3367335796356201,
-0.7156431078910828,
0.6321724057197571,
0.6495367288589478,
0.8988232016563416,
0.33092254400253296,
0.07407210022211075,
0.25867554545402527,
0.5250630378723145,
0.04580027237534523,
0.26924988627433777,
-0.05709625780582428,
-1.0590418577194214,
-0.3698088228702545,
-0.7609290480613708,
-0.4046366810798645,
0.20236600935459137,
-0.2464015930891037,
0.07429884374141693,
-0.1658744364976883,
-0.3367014229297638,
-0.05010820925235748,
-0.3012678921222687,
-0.38668057322502136,
0.24574542045593262,
0.45410364866256714,
1.445492148399353,
-1.056774377822876,
0.638734757900238,
0.5042135715484619,
-0.3510648310184479,
-0.7169020175933838,
0.4632847011089325,
-0.4459420442581177,
-0.3187233507633209,
0.6265310049057007,
0.22433991730213165,
-0.18438038229942322,
-0.13151422142982483,
-0.3882063627243042,
-0.7290708422660828,
0.6088274121284485,
0.13925977051258087,
-0.5898076295852661,
-0.25171029567718506,
0.2654944956302643,
0.5269673466682434,
-0.04674456641077995,
-0.06102483347058296,
0.49059444665908813,
0.224834144115448,
0.03407851979136467,
-0.6249420642852783,
0.25606292486190796,
-0.17863494157791138,
0.1107231080532074,
0.16475218534469604,
-0.42969098687171936,
1.1684035062789917,
-0.31322118639945984,
-0.5933356285095215,
0.1284954696893692,
0.630378007888794,
0.3542945981025696,
0.09815636277198792,
0.6479238271713257,
0.61846923828125,
0.3599373400211334,
-0.08469223976135254,
1.2107387781143188,
-0.2601335942745209,
0.33522167801856995,
0.897627592086792,
-0.13848133385181427,
0.6892955899238586,
0.6211875677108765,
-0.512017011642456,
0.47395169734954834,
0.4154159128665924,
0.2842380702495575,
0.6952401995658875,
0.4881892800331116,
-0.04089701548218727,
-0.3817906677722931,
0.034850697964429855,
-0.06557294726371765,
0.4888041913509369,
0.3920057713985443,
-0.06181718781590462,
-0.2743682265281677,
0.04606449231505394,
0.1337660402059555,
0.0816221833229065,
-0.005347978323698044,
0.35998204350471497,
0.29962512850761414,
-0.86639004945755,
0.16502819955348969,
0.09980721771717072,
0.7912490963935852,
-0.5593426823616028,
0.09435795247554779,
-0.4353393316268921,
0.44660505652427673,
-0.09359871596097946,
-0.8631328344345093,
0.45752131938934326,
-0.21543937921524048,
0.11612667143344879,
-0.04561437666416168,
0.6484195590019226,
-0.24949100613594055,
-0.7280582189559937,
0.30480146408081055,
0.5799739360809326,
0.054754238575696945,
0.23263485729694366,
-0.3698330223560333,
-0.20942071080207825,
-0.3014844059944153,
-0.1139005795121193,
-0.09663258492946625,
0.4597422480583191,
-0.2339877486228943,
0.5269451141357422,
0.8915988206863403,
0.3795204162597656,
0.08650382608175278,
0.020116906613111496,
0.5444024205207825,
-0.410142183303833,
-1.0072811841964722,
-1.2053512334823608,
0.6256124377250671,
0.2790360450744629,
-0.5133040547370911,
0.7073473334312439,
0.39936941862106323,
0.9453617334365845,
0.0312045868486166,
0.7907517552375793,
-0.028517235070466995,
0.1290433257818222,
-0.5530182123184204,
0.4648938775062561,
-0.4255102872848511,
0.24644513428211212,
-0.2532711923122406,
-0.3795628249645233,
-0.35834619402885437,
0.47051143646240234,
-0.421719491481781,
-0.17351177334785461,
0.6779931783676147,
0.5698366165161133,
-0.010518044233322144,
-0.25720861554145813,
0.4891393184661865,
0.2911047339439392,
0.1447410136461258,
0.4005669355392456,
0.784565806388855,
-0.3087880313396454,
0.3257950246334076,
-0.022645587101578712,
-0.1957678496837616,
-0.11401036381721497,
-0.7356656193733215,
-0.36319443583488464,
-0.5873365998268127,
-0.14941978454589844,
-0.40460699796676636,
0.19331109523773193,
0.7802520394325256,
0.40737810730934143,
-0.6331286430358887,
-0.05577637627720833,
-0.6098442673683167,
0.1756412535905838,
-0.2073322981595993,
-0.21074329316616058,
0.421474814414978,
-0.20087690651416779,
-0.47896480560302734,
-0.05217626690864563,
0.18971769511699677,
0.11806457489728928,
-0.41030973196029663,
-0.006896839942783117,
-0.2737688720226288,
0.5012933015823364,
0.3675949275493622,
0.07152163237333298,
-0.7190800309181213,
-0.3811435401439667,
0.10812238603830338,
-0.09004062414169312,
-0.15522272884845734,
0.6295496225357056,
-1.0386863946914673,
0.12871305644512177,
0.47742512822151184,
0.29759183526039124,
0.26887404918670654,
-0.19134218990802765,
0.5209072828292847,
-0.9203512072563171,
0.35636359453201294,
0.058190081268548965,
0.6992746591567993,
0.2691306471824646,
-0.4808136224746704,
0.4264167845249176,
0.6700670719146729,
-0.011894969269633293,
-0.8894060254096985,
0.5633407831192017,
-0.5642598867416382,
-0.46178480982780457,
1.1502059698104858,
-0.09250512719154358,
-0.21800947189331055,
0.20331989228725433,
0.06029505655169487,
0.40027114748954773,
-0.05970952659845352,
0.4575684666633606,
0.8045226335525513,
-0.1647481471300125,
0.006844785530120134,
-0.29414743185043335,
0.4694902300834656,
0.4764261245727539,
-0.2942119538784027,
0.07811444997787476,
0.31516703963279724,
0.20158249139785767,
0.5239825248718262,
0.9198101758956909,
0.13717566430568695,
0.350238561630249,
0.2401372641324997,
-0.14829210937023163,
0.011562075465917587,
-0.15910346806049347,
-0.3137205243110657,
0.143899068236351,
-0.09203654527664185,
-0.4849952161312103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10847v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10847v1
|
TorchOpera: A Compound AI System for LLM Safety
| 2024-06-16T08:39:19 | 2024-06-16T08:39:19 |
Shanshan Han, Yuhang Yao, Zijian Hu, Dimitris Stripelis, Zhaozhuo Xu, Chaoyang He
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.MA
|
We introduce TorchOpera, a compound AI system for enhancing the safety and
quality of prompts and responses for Large Language Models. TorchOpera ensures
that all user prompts are safe, contextually grounded, and effectively
processed, while enhancing LLM responses to be relevant and high quality.
TorchOpera utilizes the vector database for contextual grounding, rule-based
wrappers for flexible modifications, and specialized mechanisms for detecting
and adjusting unsafe or incorrect content. We also provide a view of the
compound AI system to reduce the computational cost. Extensive experiments show
that TorchOpera ensures the safety, reliability, and applicability of LLMs in
real-world settings while maintaining the efficiency of LLM responses.
|
[
-0.1308591514825821,
-1.0346201658248901,
0.48187726736068726,
0.4722055196762085,
-0.13713452219963074,
0.30324220657348633,
-0.04081832244992256,
-0.5541477799415588,
-0.032571353018283844,
0.473061740398407,
-0.34587332606315613,
-0.6507269740104675,
-0.3434719741344452,
0.08396267890930176,
-0.4909220337867737,
0.979394793510437,
-0.07033247500658035,
0.04496317729353905,
-0.12134898453950882,
0.034871794283390045,
-0.8571891784667969,
-0.6707963943481445,
-0.9750272631645203,
-0.34471628069877625,
0.8639611005783081,
0.5387465357780457,
0.5066446661949158,
0.4811728298664093,
0.7263851165771484,
0.3552435338497162,
0.34194016456604004,
0.2858337461948395,
-0.4753076434135437,
0.3604362905025482,
-0.15813620388507843,
-0.5488079190254211,
-0.5989026427268982,
-0.14040613174438477,
0.15040498971939087,
0.3348044753074646,
-0.08193603903055191,
-0.3541983664035797,
-0.39138492941856384,
0.3685905933380127,
-0.7290850281715393,
0.006620930973440409,
-0.5540639758110046,
-0.14030590653419495,
0.1249811053276062,
-0.43504250049591064,
-0.6338026523590088,
-0.6084827780723572,
0.15716570615768433,
-0.7414331436157227,
-0.06536456942558289,
0.5015676021575928,
0.5641067028045654,
0.17368333041667938,
-0.4315716326236725,
-0.5499687790870667,
-0.7180784940719604,
0.5309622287750244,
-0.3336940407752991,
0.07978398352861404,
0.06395210325717926,
0.2766880691051483,
-0.3451889753341675,
-0.8035563826560974,
-0.7225187420845032,
-0.36743322014808655,
-0.15584541857242584,
-0.002576882718130946,
-0.07214825600385666,
0.7104219198226929,
0.2094576358795166,
0.0228353813290596,
-0.7266392707824707,
0.4018968939781189,
-0.30449458956718445,
-0.30478912591934204,
0.7715569138526917,
0.3625209927558899,
0.9051546454429626,
-0.03377552330493927,
-0.6706334948539734,
-0.21931584179401398,
-1.1512669324874878,
-0.08038065582513809,
0.3636445999145508,
0.11902890354394913,
0.057216577231884,
0.7123029828071594,
-0.2784721851348877,
0.5605366230010986,
-0.18256375193595886,
-0.3465748131275177,
0.12086573243141174,
-0.11158528923988342,
-0.33907032012939453,
0.35787588357925415,
0.9214285016059875,
0.7474853992462158,
0.333517849445343,
-0.4820750653743744,
-0.3175928294658661,
0.4278656244277954,
0.2641277611255646,
-0.6986045241355896,
-0.41732674837112427,
0.49795863032341003,
-0.10888038575649261,
-0.577897310256958,
0.018471654504537582,
-0.812406063079834,
-0.5015165209770203,
-0.195201575756073,
0.39207977056503296,
-0.5864540338516235,
4.781659299624152e-7,
0.10288417339324951,
0.020489567890763283,
0.22560201585292816,
0.4288371801376343,
-1.0606900453567505,
0.2516005337238312,
0.802414059638977,
0.8309128880500793,
-0.6578595042228699,
-0.4239805042743683,
-0.7401872277259827,
0.3749373257160187,
-0.35544708371162415,
1.0057144165039062,
-0.4512188136577606,
-0.631664514541626,
0.1981852948665619,
-0.08897806704044342,
0.09844814985990524,
-0.6140840649604797,
0.69520503282547,
-0.8190811276435852,
0.11671393364667892,
-0.08018840849399567,
-0.582990825176239,
-0.12924613058567047,
0.25671669840812683,
-0.5424057245254517,
0.8814530372619629,
-0.03076769970357418,
-0.8147186040878296,
0.43510669469833374,
-0.6298921704292297,
-0.4763964116573334,
-0.047408703714609146,
-0.153513565659523,
-0.15733766555786133,
-0.15133389830589294,
0.4137400686740875,
0.42701491713523865,
-0.08109340071678162,
0.2939701974391937,
-0.2527530789375305,
-0.3674204349517822,
0.2640935182571411,
-0.3512263298034668,
0.5789260268211365,
0.25393855571746826,
0.04119277745485306,
0.835585355758667,
-0.46532541513442993,
-0.021832235157489777,
-0.23984642326831818,
-0.5846740007400513,
-0.20433950424194336,
-0.16856209933757782,
0.3372970223426819,
0.3069438934326172,
0.18858030438423157,
-0.4274943172931671,
0.31603550910949707,
-0.3912713825702667,
0.28102317452430725,
1.0272613763809204,
0.26786601543426514,
0.4257313311100006,
-0.36209365725517273,
0.4362914562225342,
-0.05316263064742088,
0.009162715636193752,
-0.20001107454299927,
-0.3595638871192932,
-0.9759575128555298,
-0.5188025236129761,
0.07131873816251755,
1.0392438173294067,
-1.0796924829483032,
0.6892699599266052,
-0.07233821600675583,
-0.33073732256889343,
0.012515205889940262,
0.07661180943250656,
0.21448050439357758,
0.6808648109436035,
0.14667654037475586,
0.08059097081422806,
-0.7088105082511902,
-0.6840242743492126,
0.027973584830760956,
-0.4811188578605652,
-0.36533623933792114,
0.061712149530649185,
0.2450639009475708,
-0.41259196400642395,
1.1256201267242432,
-0.4746841490268707,
-0.005381484515964985,
-0.3217896521091461,
0.17792794108390808,
0.11056969314813614,
0.7017050981521606,
0.5812721252441406,
-0.5176526308059692,
-0.3906187415122986,
-0.13381585478782654,
-1.1386417150497437,
-0.23744726181030273,
-0.3089934289455414,
-0.34011584520339966,
0.18633727729320526,
0.6173825860023499,
-0.9789648652076721,
0.10744147002696991,
0.34671321511268616,
-0.548598051071167,
0.45459169149398804,
-0.24278223514556885,
0.2272750288248062,
-1.1967341899871826,
0.14604556560516357,
-0.24124585092067719,
-0.40414249897003174,
-0.7984632849693298,
0.14350847899913788,
-0.1404445767402649,
-0.026350131258368492,
-0.6966029405593872,
0.50503009557724,
0.017756251618266106,
0.14716728031635284,
-0.4271295666694641,
0.36986392736434937,
-0.2496778815984726,
0.2771627902984619,
-0.04379269853234291,
1.389363408088684,
0.6790222525596619,
-0.7009690403938293,
0.9965469241142273,
0.22394374012947083,
-0.022044440731406212,
0.7695790529251099,
-1.1145669221878052,
0.32327985763549805,
0.03544478863477707,
0.31598955392837524,
-0.7572222948074341,
-0.5727148056030273,
0.3172425627708435,
-0.339974582195282,
0.13700038194656372,
0.185804083943367,
-0.6402980089187622,
-0.16361340880393982,
-0.5577247738838196,
0.30415546894073486,
0.5813975930213928,
-0.6449738144874573,
0.68339604139328,
0.4701412618160248,
-0.16840733587741852,
-0.6184304356575012,
-0.16116291284561157,
0.231517493724823,
-0.5187965631484985,
-0.9113860130310059,
0.09499191492795944,
-0.3047347068786621,
-0.3943997025489807,
-0.3089144825935364,
0.10591268539428711,
-0.028209855780005455,
0.31263241171836853,
0.4091372787952423,
0.7027228474617004,
0.03312172740697861,
0.3391132056713104,
-0.0747145339846611,
-0.4515242874622345,
0.30831795930862427,
-0.0022446198854595423,
0.646163821220398,
-0.05615602433681488,
-0.27301478385925293,
-0.5746025443077087,
0.33719074726104736,
0.4768635928630829,
0.2499314844608307,
0.5931555032730103,
0.49992725253105164,
-0.40172430872917175,
-0.14203235507011414,
-0.34107837080955505,
-0.4439425766468048,
-0.6211604475975037,
0.13920097053050995,
-0.14043590426445007,
-0.8988818526268005,
0.4751473069190979,
-0.27385324239730835,
-0.036078084260225296,
0.2298346310853958,
0.731671154499054,
-0.35437387228012085,
0.9168751835823059,
0.5662500858306885,
-0.4529770314693451,
0.5039934515953064,
-0.008626704104244709,
0.2657410502433777,
-0.6488099098205566,
-0.5091789364814758,
-0.42118120193481445,
-0.1650228351354599,
-0.625886857509613,
-0.4505501389503479,
0.642195999622345,
0.13623985648155212,
-0.30751535296440125,
0.15452894568443298,
-0.35937032103538513,
0.6749065518379211,
0.7693396210670471,
0.04379390552639961,
0.3778497278690338,
-0.1878601759672165,
0.1981978416442871,
0.2157408595085144,
-0.6374475955963135,
-0.904863715171814,
1.0928319692611694,
0.39654994010925293,
1.343681812286377,
0.052691228687763214,
0.6710025072097778,
0.5768691897392273,
0.3936862349510193,
-0.777735710144043,
0.6304173469543457,
0.441474974155426,
-0.6459342837333679,
-0.3349825441837311,
-0.36473655700683594,
-0.8771309852600098,
0.06411086022853851,
-0.30690011382102966,
-0.9429526329040527,
-0.2567499876022339,
0.11207956075668335,
-0.4834365248680115,
0.1898220330476761,
-0.893839955329895,
0.5317196846008301,
-0.25126996636390686,
-0.35167163610458374,
-0.10433123260736465,
-0.6109281778335571,
0.5673934817314148,
0.0373009592294693,
-0.17324711382389069,
-0.38273873925209045,
-0.22848710417747498,
0.6819564700126648,
-0.40335774421691895,
0.8194305300712585,
0.05393579974770546,
-0.27067309617996216,
0.26394784450531006,
0.1942107230424881,
0.8408127427101135,
0.49922293424606323,
0.14576877653598785,
-0.14588838815689087,
-0.09743443876504898,
-0.32545867562294006,
-0.7354898452758789,
1.0762724876403809,
-0.8720049858093262,
-0.5891590714454651,
-0.684794545173645,
-0.6299393177032471,
-0.3743664622306824,
0.202901229262352,
0.169533371925354,
0.23295852541923523,
-0.1451689451932907,
0.1058773472905159,
1.1020101308822632,
-0.38539919257164,
0.6420387029647827,
0.28263118863105774,
-0.19943661987781525,
-0.375806599855423,
1.0359185934066772,
-0.3469682037830353,
0.1311221420764923,
0.3778744339942932,
-0.14263662695884705,
-0.4121772050857544,
-0.79044109582901,
-0.5052436590194702,
0.08713255822658539,
-0.9187923073768616,
-0.4760490357875824,
-0.6282438039779663,
-0.07339636236429214,
-0.1301962435245514,
-0.5473995208740234,
0.05015706270933151,
-0.32969409227371216,
-0.4345877170562744,
-0.5786372423171997,
0.597551167011261,
0.7957428097724915,
0.037324678152799606,
0.3959679901599884,
-0.700581967830658,
0.3980104923248291,
0.568897545337677,
0.3210204541683197,
-0.5129996538162231,
-0.011153683997690678,
0.15182532370090485,
-0.3586447536945343,
-0.06020279973745346,
-0.6896639466285706,
0.23544453084468842,
-0.05406317114830017,
0.45495882630348206,
0.3100316822528839,
0.42422425746917725,
0.2705535292625427,
-0.5969423651695251,
0.8943681716918945,
0.37413331866264343,
-1.0406341552734375,
0.6124513149261475,
-0.6895716786384583,
-0.16722643375396729,
0.36994269490242004,
0.145429328083992,
-0.6836799383163452,
-0.3492944836616516,
-0.223904088139534,
-1.01907217502594,
0.7032368779182434,
0.3900325894355774,
0.3982332646846771,
0.03526579961180687,
0.14473289251327515,
-0.03933846578001976,
0.15946649014949799,
-0.558208703994751,
-0.29660144448280334,
0.027932792901992798,
-0.4427870810031891,
0.14453519880771637,
-0.4065653681755066,
-0.5142184495925903,
0.16247771680355072,
0.6337904930114746,
-0.32244253158569336,
0.3300175964832306,
0.04991509020328522,
-0.14432920515537262,
0.01872897334396839,
0.06937147676944733,
0.862948477268219,
0.698352038860321,
-0.2568383812904358,
0.40525680780410767,
0.6005252599716187,
-0.45301109552383423,
0.49677252769470215,
-0.17013397812843323,
-0.12455106526613235,
-0.23327165842056274,
0.7409949898719788,
0.6150794625282288,
0.020481321960687637,
-1.1016465425491333,
0.2774481773376465,
-0.09835634380578995,
0.34310418367385864,
-0.16828970611095428,
0.5768387317657471,
-0.13281364738941193,
0.049970220774412155,
0.3249858021736145,
-0.07162169367074966,
0.1398577094078064,
-0.49711325764656067,
0.4700329601764679,
0.15108361840248108,
-0.04469937086105347,
-0.1611190289258957,
0.5226704478263855,
0.8306515216827393,
-0.4224066138267517,
0.4777540862560272,
0.0704433023929596,
-0.41654473543167114,
0.5729553699493408,
0.40403878688812256,
0.9747897386550903,
-0.2379288226366043,
0.19329188764095306,
0.13466356694698334,
0.44687944650650024,
0.34639865159988403,
0.36566275358200073,
0.4936763048171997,
-0.6290832757949829,
-0.04046504944562912,
-0.24607375264167786,
-0.5579237937927246,
-0.06956370919942856,
-0.10180037468671799,
0.30608317255973816,
-0.8151755928993225,
0.0959383174777031,
-0.4263937473297119,
-0.271738201379776,
-0.33249691128730774,
0.32694804668426514,
-0.0022673294879496098,
0.99077308177948,
-0.7482320070266724,
0.778063952922821,
0.34661534428596497,
-0.47366881370544434,
-0.6931644082069397,
0.01724618300795555,
-0.19155937433242798,
-0.7971969246864319,
0.7136083245277405,
0.15771612524986267,
-0.45785561203956604,
-0.16433344781398773,
-0.5395835638046265,
-0.68585604429245,
1.2371991872787476,
0.6065632104873657,
-0.2749735713005066,
-0.18793648481369019,
0.1770990490913391,
0.5801237225532532,
-0.3028765618801117,
0.19845591485500336,
0.6164756417274475,
0.2922340929508209,
0.04110440984368324,
-0.7338256239891052,
0.14715513586997986,
0.08479482680559158,
0.15101206302642822,
-0.16754941642284393,
-0.5540868639945984,
0.5959477424621582,
-0.13237780332565308,
-0.377220094203949,
0.020422935485839844,
0.812285304069519,
0.5543469190597534,
0.43655112385749817,
0.3509301543235779,
0.36329078674316406,
0.9009438157081604,
-0.42341187596321106,
1.0555827617645264,
-0.40150243043899536,
0.30110037326812744,
0.8762183785438538,
-0.3862150013446808,
0.7281835079193115,
0.6579909324645996,
-0.10937750339508057,
0.49550876021385193,
0.8317348957061768,
0.4497782289981842,
0.498110294342041,
0.25119882822036743,
-0.7249395847320557,
-0.21374623477458954,
-0.2280556708574295,
-0.370015025138855,
0.23490191996097565,
0.40435266494750977,
-0.1560482531785965,
-0.005771993193775415,
0.18607650697231293,
0.1524161994457245,
-0.11156400293111801,
-0.08745834976434708,
0.8766544461250305,
-0.1001461073756218,
-0.5968089699745178,
0.4541420042514801,
0.0880647525191307,
0.8229795694351196,
-0.5315264463424683,
-0.09257019311189651,
-0.3470984399318695,
0.06325806677341461,
-0.25650346279144287,
-0.798413872718811,
0.22647380828857422,
0.07159838080406189,
-0.09985961765050888,
0.031353216618299484,
0.8916242122650146,
-0.2799908220767975,
-0.44827038049697876,
0.19161194562911987,
0.20028235018253326,
-0.13507527112960815,
0.282535195350647,
-0.5211424827575684,
0.4742864668369293,
-0.4729737639427185,
-0.08407941460609436,
0.05254258215427399,
0.2644595801830292,
-0.002199217677116394,
1.1584943532943726,
0.6918007135391235,
-0.2382849007844925,
0.23572878539562225,
-0.24679464101791382,
1.234447956085205,
-0.48207926750183105,
-0.5015929341316223,
-0.6738432049751282,
0.3651093542575836,
-0.21423733234405518,
-0.1564987450838089,
0.7946488857269287,
0.35668450593948364,
0.6576045751571655,
-0.21173450350761414,
0.8990692496299744,
-0.09933509677648544,
0.19116725027561188,
-1.043634057044983,
0.7540551424026489,
0.08497389405965805,
0.3767760992050171,
-0.21369268000125885,
-0.800309419631958,
-0.5339891910552979,
0.49056026339530945,
-0.13498303294181824,
0.15965339541435242,
0.7300872802734375,
0.9770610928535461,
0.055270060896873474,
-0.31106099486351013,
0.48097729682922363,
-0.2151964008808136,
0.8583272695541382,
0.6786287426948547,
0.966008186340332,
-0.2759624123573303,
0.2868688106536865,
-0.15058867633342743,
-0.10797741264104843,
-0.49043959379196167,
-0.8214817643165588,
-1.1159628629684448,
-0.35570165514945984,
-0.22591742873191833,
-0.3226894438266754,
0.19291019439697266,
1.3470078706741333,
0.9463481307029724,
-1.1280699968338013,
-0.22507676482200623,
-0.3698785901069641,
0.32851025462150574,
0.22021549940109253,
-0.301705926656723,
0.2915029525756836,
-0.6623709797859192,
-0.8753236532211304,
0.6387354731559753,
0.39231061935424805,
0.04944860562682152,
-0.38646382093429565,
-0.3620396852493286,
-0.0428069643676281,
0.38673508167266846,
0.6952730417251587,
0.23283737897872925,
-0.7221420407295227,
-0.7499304413795471,
-0.17539529502391815,
-0.4761495888233185,
-0.050146933645009995,
0.9925201535224915,
-0.6960132718086243,
0.6956852078437805,
0.8167375922203064,
0.7553539276123047,
-0.10642712563276291,
0.019748520106077194,
0.8918315172195435,
-0.8529364466667175,
0.4004115164279938,
0.38207459449768066,
0.4523855447769165,
0.37734267115592957,
-0.6511343121528625,
0.5816662907600403,
0.32157716155052185,
-0.6362264156341553,
-0.8906840085983276,
0.32340648770332336,
-1.1146429777145386,
0.04945990443229675,
1.2857304811477661,
-0.46019405126571655,
-0.13994266092777252,
-0.246460422873497,
-0.819402813911438,
0.10860256105661392,
-0.733625590801239,
1.0728336572647095,
0.6206254363059998,
-0.3921726942062378,
-0.24664460122585297,
-0.27989399433135986,
0.7836365103721619,
0.051340751349925995,
-1.5759831666946411,
-0.0544990599155426,
0.6747058033943176,
0.3080584406852722,
0.11219581216573715,
0.48580965399742126,
0.46416133642196655,
0.4836544394493103,
-0.09479349851608276,
-0.1269657164812088,
0.08172257244586945,
-0.6528319120407104,
-0.3414134383201599,
0.22385860979557037,
0.24156689643859863,
-0.3663535416126251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10842v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10842v1
|
Large Language Models for Automatic Milestone Detection in Group Discussions
| 2024-06-16T08:32:22 | 2024-06-16T08:32:22 |
Zhuoxu Duan, Zhengye Yang, Samuel Westby, Christoph Riedl, Brooke Foucault Welles, Richard J. Radke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Large language models like GPT have proven widely successful on natural
language understanding tasks based on written text documents. In this paper, we
investigate an LLM's performance on recordings of a group oral communication
task in which utterances are often truncated or not well-formed. We propose a
new group task experiment involving a puzzle with several milestones that can
be achieved in any order. We investigate methods for processing transcripts to
detect if, when, and by whom a milestone has been completed. We demonstrate
that iteratively prompting GPT with transcription chunks outperforms semantic
similarity search methods using text embeddings, and further discuss the
quality and randomness of GPT responses under different context window sizes.
|
[
-0.381238728761673,
-0.9608669281005859,
0.9725745320320129,
0.20607195794582367,
-0.27871355414390564,
-0.02603227272629738,
-0.32843154668807983,
-0.4572694003582001,
0.2904922664165497,
0.1084633618593216,
-0.8004857301712036,
-0.7562096118927002,
-0.9571650624275208,
0.10786937922239304,
-0.5845786333084106,
0.8517708778381348,
0.018053028732538223,
-0.07071609050035477,
-0.08058895170688629,
0.09734597057104111,
-0.6254501938819885,
-0.41964155435562134,
-0.8403341770172119,
-0.4757710099220276,
0.22715739905834198,
0.30328062176704407,
0.5505402684211731,
0.7404894232749939,
0.45995792746543884,
0.33756759762763977,
-0.37216511368751526,
-0.11448221653699875,
-0.2817580997943878,
0.23708494007587433,
-0.004392470698803663,
-0.3406440019607544,
-0.586288332939148,
0.0815085843205452,
0.8172507286071777,
0.8662968873977661,
-0.02174508571624756,
-0.03300893306732178,
0.2220747172832489,
0.27047741413116455,
0.10420650243759155,
0.5283826589584351,
-0.7610495686531067,
0.1882484257221222,
-0.028172701597213745,
-0.07319635152816772,
-0.34573808312416077,
-0.2895740568637848,
0.06668587028980255,
-0.4145672619342804,
0.4174942374229431,
-0.15915046632289886,
0.6669970750808716,
0.12820948660373688,
-0.507800281047821,
-0.6610478162765503,
-0.5026373863220215,
0.7032672762870789,
-0.6593540906906128,
0.36183273792266846,
0.6662753820419312,
0.06026164069771767,
-0.45862090587615967,
-0.5624094009399414,
-0.5253893733024597,
-0.596917450428009,
-0.030922969803214073,
-0.07049873471260071,
-0.1038380041718483,
0.24723953008651733,
0.27388572692871094,
0.5785964727401733,
-0.8943455815315247,
0.3341464698314667,
-0.01728842966258526,
-0.3043805658817291,
0.30022960901260376,
0.17779478430747986,
0.24413394927978516,
-0.3669419586658478,
-0.10547684878110886,
0.21030856668949127,
-0.4180898368358612,
-0.2029099464416504,
0.08714226633310318,
0.24456799030303955,
0.13085858523845673,
0.7308017611503601,
-0.3226298391819,
0.7442380785942078,
0.1306786835193634,
-0.04882577434182167,
0.08420886099338531,
-0.5794692039489746,
-0.1117367297410965,
-0.07334700226783752,
0.657504141330719,
0.17349576950073242,
0.2560567259788513,
-0.2789754569530487,
-0.29190146923065186,
0.2381277233362198,
-0.16093263030052185,
-0.5568744540214539,
-0.07749749720096588,
0.1507720947265625,
-0.40034234523773193,
0.2603777348995209,
-0.1791989654302597,
-0.145184725522995,
-0.09934442490339279,
-0.4925287067890167,
0.47117507457733154,
-0.5191221237182617,
-0.04460043087601662,
0.005557721015065908,
-0.17249229550361633,
0.16347359120845795,
0.5709946155548096,
-1.0019994974136353,
0.24561680853366852,
0.8167188167572021,
0.8950214982032776,
-0.2998856008052826,
-0.3029424250125885,
-0.9180809855461121,
0.16631759703159332,
-0.07412992417812347,
0.7148244976997375,
-0.438289076089859,
-0.6937298774719238,
-0.16531452536582947,
-0.07179153710603714,
-0.1147279292345047,
-0.4925621747970581,
0.36159172654151917,
-0.4329104423522949,
0.3387211859226227,
-0.24953113496303558,
-0.9693253040313721,
0.06159723177552223,
0.6039451360702515,
-0.5050792098045349,
0.8064359426498413,
0.030833324417471886,
-0.4586947560310364,
0.8703367114067078,
-0.6480923891067505,
-0.35783258080482483,
0.33722123503685,
-0.4671333432197571,
-0.16800452768802643,
0.038395706564188004,
0.44599658250808716,
0.705324649810791,
-0.11767459660768509,
0.39470192790031433,
0.08109328895807266,
-0.46888649463653564,
0.12143310904502869,
-0.31467726826667786,
0.31002190709114075,
-0.11400549858808517,
-0.44152289628982544,
0.4392726719379425,
-0.4192156493663788,
0.0438142791390419,
-0.04041838273406029,
-0.46973487734794617,
-0.32008078694343567,
0.02926427498459816,
-0.14531303942203522,
0.0353260412812233,
0.20982833206653595,
-0.31676217913627625,
0.6234311461448669,
0.037523217499256134,
0.45214173197746277,
0.670164942741394,
0.37070849537849426,
0.205725759267807,
-0.282243013381958,
0.34981080889701843,
-0.081985704600811,
0.3212772309780121,
-0.2873847782611847,
-0.9095041751861572,
-0.6082841753959656,
-0.283489465713501,
0.16019916534423828,
0.4143703281879425,
-0.6405954360961914,
0.7517831325531006,
-0.6760379076004028,
-0.12440340965986252,
-0.06846174597740173,
0.26280680298805237,
0.30370214581489563,
0.2227146327495575,
0.3013596832752228,
-0.8305964469909668,
-0.046476371586322784,
-0.8751375079154968,
-0.28518083691596985,
-0.6710435152053833,
-0.5261391997337341,
0.15024669468402863,
0.3022076487541199,
-0.24077916145324707,
0.9864574670791626,
-0.45573416352272034,
-0.5700351595878601,
-0.3103035092353821,
0.8671779632568359,
0.2754550576210022,
0.3213113844394684,
-0.09087876230478287,
-0.8281804323196411,
-0.34504827857017517,
-0.04517648369073868,
-0.5967904925346375,
0.0305373165756464,
-0.04319100081920624,
0.5193477272987366,
0.13093167543411255,
0.6742489337921143,
-0.5004770159721375,
0.41489771008491516,
0.5459254384040833,
-0.5180713534355164,
0.2433304339647293,
-0.07199655473232269,
0.5345519781112671,
-0.815490186214447,
-0.24185000360012054,
-0.12116564065217972,
-0.5383606553077698,
-0.6027491688728333,
-0.38876962661743164,
0.042039528489112854,
0.34772989153862,
-0.27712854743003845,
0.14648625254631042,
-0.6805746555328369,
-0.1849176287651062,
-0.36793380975723267,
0.34166857600212097,
-0.5506167411804199,
0.5152012705802917,
0.11747550964355469,
0.7752706408500671,
0.19283148646354675,
-0.5875008702278137,
-0.05919912829995155,
0.48683249950408936,
-0.4737069010734558,
0.6274267435073853,
-0.4524048864841461,
0.5016480088233948,
-0.20414038002490997,
0.23812220990657806,
-1.3266502618789673,
-0.41939491033554077,
-0.04260396212339401,
-0.7823804616928101,
0.24058501422405243,
-0.36536160111427307,
-0.5571949481964111,
-0.4911419749259949,
-0.1246747300028801,
0.38863059878349304,
0.5660765767097473,
-0.20418816804885864,
0.34240207076072693,
0.4011569321155548,
-0.4079363942146301,
-0.21885769069194794,
-0.5816428661346436,
0.4586339592933655,
-0.308036744594574,
-0.6988458633422852,
0.15329609811306,
0.019426170736551285,
-0.050061941146850586,
-0.07172437012195587,
-0.06458257883787155,
-0.10107259452342987,
-0.011934016831219196,
0.33558928966522217,
0.0934443399310112,
-0.06381475180387497,
0.154961958527565,
-0.30567774176597595,
0.04613989219069481,
-0.07461581379175186,
-0.38167208433151245,
0.755660355091095,
-0.12661683559417725,
-0.5954009294509888,
-0.30051639676094055,
0.4071044921875,
0.3357950747013092,
0.1387411653995514,
0.5659892559051514,
0.5728704333305359,
-0.4746449589729309,
0.021587640047073364,
-0.8374038338661194,
-0.2689895033836365,
-0.46742987632751465,
0.4426236152648926,
-0.27988842129707336,
-1.4937660694122314,
0.7145825028419495,
0.02476406842470169,
-0.08046878129243851,
0.4318463206291199,
0.6760868430137634,
0.29483211040496826,
0.9070448279380798,
0.5466768145561218,
-0.3795740306377411,
0.5650161504745483,
-0.07577940821647644,
-0.008364503271877766,
-0.7816697359085083,
0.014831899665296078,
-0.48205944895744324,
-0.02485952340066433,
-0.30197831988334656,
-0.6553741693496704,
0.6131675243377686,
0.04573064669966698,
0.13837337493896484,
0.4885052442550659,
-0.35327017307281494,
0.5134819746017456,
0.3598320186138153,
-0.06426773220300674,
0.835966944694519,
-0.2580716907978058,
0.009643768891692162,
-0.21285493671894073,
-0.34584900736808777,
-0.5253865122795105,
0.7303222417831421,
0.2553272247314453,
0.5198447108268738,
-0.017292724922299385,
0.7433554530143738,
0.6256032586097717,
0.6830067038536072,
-0.9477741718292236,
0.7588699460029602,
0.08997026830911636,
-0.603391706943512,
-0.7956832647323608,
-0.5467281937599182,
-1.1094976663589478,
0.18647275865077972,
0.26845473051071167,
-1.1760913133621216,
-0.26598113775253296,
0.005080713890492916,
0.16406019032001495,
0.027581777423620224,
-0.39408230781555176,
0.8334264159202576,
0.15221375226974487,
0.08828682452440262,
-0.13374203443527222,
-0.5658336281776428,
0.38357654213905334,
-0.18601687252521515,
0.24704208970069885,
-0.18064123392105103,
0.07683227211236954,
0.9978806972503662,
-0.037877678871154785,
0.6944104433059692,
-0.20368672907352448,
-0.34392088651657104,
0.3349868357181549,
0.09774761646986008,
0.8338139653205872,
0.024903716519474983,
0.02914491482079029,
0.026140742003917694,
-0.5788149237632751,
-0.14834000170230865,
-0.45235389471054077,
0.6657273769378662,
-0.1578603982925415,
-0.8746846914291382,
-0.1670214831829071,
-0.5228790044784546,
-0.29787564277648926,
0.04948921501636505,
0.2913126051425934,
0.13603278994560242,
-0.5290489196777344,
-0.17894423007965088,
0.3466421365737915,
0.10863830894231796,
0.5681245923042297,
0.469857782125473,
-0.2661969065666199,
-0.1380373239517212,
0.6361579298973083,
0.14341342449188232,
0.6049526333808899,
0.23133018612861633,
-0.22588525712490082,
-0.36814624071121216,
-1.0048853158950806,
-0.45228850841522217,
0.2398195117712021,
-1.0417002439498901,
0.0792277380824089,
-0.6742727160453796,
0.07677857577800751,
-0.3936785161495209,
0.20871852338314056,
-0.1219833642244339,
-0.49140724539756775,
-0.08057695627212524,
-0.18097910284996033,
0.1630617082118988,
1.036311388015747,
0.05698626860976219,
0.1388503462076187,
-0.954704225063324,
0.29530465602874756,
0.5224893093109131,
0.03573564812541008,
-0.07122599333524704,
-0.46153363585472107,
-0.12886597216129303,
-0.13769188523292542,
-0.32348984479904175,
-0.7521529197692871,
0.2968353033065796,
0.05982275307178497,
0.5629608631134033,
0.16838163137435913,
-0.41767436265945435,
0.6017621755599976,
-0.635955274105072,
1.0820993185043335,
0.1897815316915512,
-1.2495688199996948,
0.5024162530899048,
-0.6715448498725891,
0.5051446557044983,
0.4947921633720398,
0.3209894299507141,
-0.9192882180213928,
-0.8314722776412964,
-0.34928253293037415,
-0.894593358039856,
0.36711037158966064,
0.4403093755245209,
-0.164104625582695,
-0.3618490993976593,
0.12586194276809692,
0.104452945291996,
0.13859674334526062,
-0.7115799188613892,
-0.010118186473846436,
0.40902626514434814,
0.02283397875726223,
-0.3256807327270508,
-0.018711186945438385,
-0.03658962622284889,
-0.03839421644806862,
0.33190909028053284,
-0.2795049846172333,
0.4334820508956909,
0.4514828026294708,
-0.24146346747875214,
-0.2022610753774643,
0.5559317469596863,
0.45311781764030457,
0.8811503648757935,
-0.050784967839717865,
0.058768462389707565,
0.2706718444824219,
-0.5227475762367249,
0.3942719101905823,
0.11037800461053848,
0.17909593880176544,
0.060077741742134094,
0.5998263955116272,
0.5547974109649658,
0.10994856059551239,
-0.3633556067943573,
0.555546760559082,
-0.3283005356788635,
-0.4073333442211151,
-0.14779219031333923,
-0.014249088242650032,
0.17956526577472687,
0.19824907183647156,
0.6795300841331482,
-0.6025648713111877,
0.3824126720428467,
-0.7087738513946533,
0.40394604206085205,
0.5833553075790405,
-0.5330577492713928,
-0.15267135202884674,
0.684232771396637,
-0.22797465324401855,
-0.5064654350280762,
0.722941517829895,
-0.4933335781097412,
-0.8628567457199097,
0.6279322504997253,
0.2916458249092102,
0.960308849811554,
-0.2399381846189499,
0.1608249694108963,
-0.08896175026893616,
0.4285544157028198,
-0.2853139340877533,
0.08382124453783035,
-0.20848684012889862,
-0.4415733516216278,
-0.9984762668609619,
-0.4503079950809479,
-0.5417125821113586,
0.1777997761964798,
-0.4956090748310089,
-0.04777124151587486,
0.09152550250291824,
-0.3399812877178192,
0.049295734614133835,
-0.3296676278114319,
-0.7205203175544739,
0.055250830948352814,
0.12255203723907471,
0.5674567222595215,
-0.8728339672088623,
0.7958697080612183,
0.4322109520435333,
-0.08796267211437225,
-0.9021716713905334,
0.34813645482063293,
0.20243649184703827,
-0.6399394273757935,
0.8404932618141174,
0.19449745118618011,
0.09984484314918518,
0.02294245734810829,
-0.13499736785888672,
-0.6911191940307617,
1.0156371593475342,
0.05859726294875145,
-0.4858134090900421,
-0.09367036819458008,
0.2678104639053345,
0.5236485600471497,
-0.03401561453938484,
0.16354213654994965,
0.5548369884490967,
0.6741708517074585,
0.2817520201206207,
-1.6316587924957275,
0.2223345786333084,
0.06787373870611191,
-0.15780054032802582,
0.44901034235954285,
-0.4545276165008545,
1.0247528553009033,
0.10427819192409515,
-0.23939506709575653,
0.06389385461807251,
0.880764365196228,
-0.008961625397205353,
0.3536759912967682,
0.9140336513519287,
0.37399375438690186,
0.8801384568214417,
-0.20203255116939545,
0.9031639695167542,
0.2442300170660019,
0.4338513910770416,
0.8922439813613892,
-0.3197580873966217,
0.4322098195552826,
0.4478459656238556,
-0.29298320412635803,
0.03500774875283241,
0.579430878162384,
0.15292276442050934,
0.22481736540794373,
0.6201163530349731,
-0.4926226735115051,
-0.2620382606983185,
-0.05672890320420265,
-0.30377933382987976,
0.2644963562488556,
0.4616091847419739,
-0.2734723389148712,
-0.12437788397073746,
0.18263551592826843,
-0.08884350955486298,
-0.08618230372667313,
-0.43345579504966736,
0.9987404942512512,
0.17837217450141907,
-1.103162169456482,
0.5249234437942505,
-0.010990336537361145,
0.7522595524787903,
-0.5676863789558411,
-0.06330937147140503,
-0.21923412382602692,
0.15673591196537018,
0.003184857312589884,
-0.7244365215301514,
0.17832309007644653,
-0.18341577053070068,
-0.07122489809989929,
-0.11119633167982101,
0.5137859582901001,
-0.5828519463539124,
-0.09399435669183731,
0.3677881956100464,
0.6040381789207458,
0.4252588450908661,
-0.3046642541885376,
-0.2427578568458557,
0.11131560057401657,
-0.042670249938964844,
-0.46374964714050293,
0.3093419373035431,
0.4851107597351074,
-0.41897591948509216,
0.634093701839447,
0.32496002316474915,
-0.13450407981872559,
0.16017206013202667,
0.19175146520137787,
0.841075599193573,
-0.7401724457740784,
-0.620904266834259,
-0.9258941411972046,
0.20607337355613708,
-0.07408493757247925,
-0.08176586031913757,
1.0353460311889648,
0.5945256352424622,
0.7099370956420898,
-0.04361802339553833,
0.6622506976127625,
0.020323650911450386,
0.35250914096832275,
-0.7546486258506775,
0.4104953706264496,
-0.2819295823574066,
0.27822956442832947,
-0.43529343605041504,
-0.9627981781959534,
-0.430764377117157,
0.47166210412979126,
-0.2846921384334564,
0.10752107948064804,
0.8781293034553528,
0.5453987121582031,
0.031364839524030685,
0.39098384976387024,
0.3869970440864563,
0.09613770246505737,
0.7702183127403259,
0.8567712306976318,
0.9592363834381104,
-0.06316560506820679,
0.42954322695732117,
0.4174686670303345,
-0.3055938184261322,
0.08703935146331787,
-1.0124746561050415,
-1.1414108276367188,
-0.7499314546585083,
-0.36796873807907104,
-0.21334442496299744,
0.23131541907787323,
0.8307375311851501,
0.4590207636356354,
-0.585637092590332,
-0.22700220346450806,
-0.20123925805091858,
0.06486624479293823,
-0.03382609412074089,
-0.20662149786949158,
0.3435676097869873,
-0.30584654211997986,
-0.8559973239898682,
0.7183545827865601,
0.2534690499305725,
0.17637203633785248,
-0.10572947561740875,
-0.007875724695622921,
-0.20442302525043488,
-0.25321146845817566,
0.31734079122543335,
0.09787022322416306,
-0.5857449769973755,
-0.6428472995758057,
-0.1197156086564064,
0.011965983547270298,
0.12850706279277802,
1.0761100053787231,
-0.48653334379196167,
-0.023711033165454865,
0.2660321593284607,
0.4828963875770569,
0.9935418963432312,
-0.005142582580447197,
0.5701998472213745,
-0.8733997941017151,
0.047456808388233185,
0.4431547224521637,
0.2743776738643646,
0.3712499439716339,
-0.39018934965133667,
0.6381391882896423,
0.16666966676712036,
-0.9576601982116699,
-0.659938633441925,
0.11555112153291702,
-1.0076221227645874,
-0.0854773223400116,
1.1175017356872559,
-0.2614007294178009,
0.06922025233507156,
-0.45951443910598755,
-0.16198788583278656,
0.28773632645606995,
-0.3463428020477295,
0.845731794834137,
1.211734652519226,
-0.24759429693222046,
0.2767896056175232,
-0.46725088357925415,
0.48495039343833923,
0.5545337796211243,
-0.8424339890480042,
0.03525759279727936,
0.5924103856086731,
0.11803985387086868,
0.2194359004497528,
1.0935983657836914,
-0.1095496118068695,
0.17252230644226074,
-0.3466882109642029,
-0.2825007140636444,
0.10988225787878036,
-0.18741662800312042,
-0.36248111724853516,
0.270498126745224,
0.3077118694782257,
-0.011437899433076382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10839v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10839v1
|
Reminding Multimodal Large Language Models of Object-aware Knowledge with Retrieved Tags
| 2024-06-16T08:20:12 | 2024-06-16T08:20:12 |
Daiqing Qi, Handong Zhao, Zijun Wei, Sheng Li
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Despite recent advances in the general visual instruction-following ability
of Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs), they still struggle with critical
problems when required to provide a precise and detailed response to a visual
instruction: (1) failure to identify novel objects or entities, (2) mention of
non-existent objects, and (3) neglect of object's attributed details. Intuitive
solutions include improving the size and quality of data or using larger
foundation models. They show effectiveness in mitigating these issues, but at
an expensive cost of collecting a vast amount of new data and introducing a
significantly larger model. Standing at the intersection of these approaches,
we examine the three object-oriented problems from the perspective of the
image-to-text mapping process by the multimodal connector. In this paper, we
first identify the limitations of multimodal connectors stemming from
insufficient training data. Driven by this, we propose to enhance the mapping
with retrieval-augmented tag tokens, which contain rich object-aware
information such as object names and attributes. With our Tag-grounded visual
instruction tuning with retrieval Augmentation (TUNA), we outperform baselines
that share the same language model and training data on 12 benchmarks.
Furthermore, we show the zero-shot capability of TUNA when provided with
specific datastores.
|
[
-0.49720320105552673,
-0.7412377595901489,
0.6025222539901733,
-0.11392294615507126,
-0.1806279569864273,
-0.12019075453281403,
-0.33921581506729126,
-0.5795221924781799,
-0.05306839570403099,
0.40005767345428467,
-0.4358672499656677,
-0.33241766691207886,
-0.4643363952636719,
-0.1432449370622635,
-0.3258712589740753,
0.7977818250656128,
-0.0327051542699337,
-0.14571940898895264,
-0.35103631019592285,
-0.18425697088241577,
-0.8905811905860901,
-0.2006031721830368,
-0.41626667976379395,
0.005763490684330463,
0.7161441445350647,
0.6131609678268433,
0.6028150916099548,
1.0118968486785889,
0.7253784537315369,
0.22949540615081787,
0.17374002933502197,
0.32807809114456177,
-0.31367558240890503,
-0.023818431422114372,
-0.31865406036376953,
-0.5100870728492737,
-0.4677278697490692,
-0.16738587617874146,
0.8117135167121887,
0.6731989979743958,
0.13848702609539032,
0.13749799132347107,
-0.18875084817409515,
0.692561686038971,
-0.8706885576248169,
0.2991289794445038,
-0.6522079110145569,
0.03822056204080582,
-0.183731809258461,
-0.2694969177246094,
-0.6103424429893494,
0.22840139269828796,
0.1459403783082962,
-0.7224802374839783,
0.19882521033287048,
0.17527078092098236,
0.9806533455848694,
0.2750107944011688,
-0.7408415079116821,
-0.2333511859178543,
-0.6944522857666016,
0.9816151261329651,
-0.401833713054657,
0.5118921399116516,
0.5194031000137329,
0.3785920739173889,
-0.12513385713100433,
-0.45993074774742126,
-0.3877332806587219,
-0.10142749547958374,
-0.05011868104338646,
0.2048933357000351,
0.10598670691251755,
-0.08494846522808075,
0.3231912851333618,
0.23036637902259827,
-0.38429394364356995,
0.08956313878297806,
-0.383372038602829,
-0.08015075325965881,
0.4830498993396759,
-0.006636693142354488,
0.23561207950115204,
-0.1824040561914444,
-0.8193772435188293,
-0.19842307269573212,
-0.7351383566856384,
-0.07068770378828049,
0.18738391995429993,
0.29729172587394714,
0.06363995373249054,
0.6855509877204895,
-0.03452877327799797,
1.0576214790344238,
-0.13534162938594818,
-0.17144113779067993,
0.29981982707977295,
-0.3193990886211395,
0.016238166019320488,
-0.21313051879405975,
0.5172132253646851,
0.5906064510345459,
0.3620704710483551,
-0.06262800842523575,
-0.31082677841186523,
0.047294579446315765,
0.279819518327713,
-0.48286640644073486,
-0.18131601810455322,
0.19959528744220734,
-0.31861868500709534,
0.2620387673377991,
0.010506913997232914,
-0.748769998550415,
-0.32412752509117126,
-0.3755042850971222,
0.6796242594718933,
-0.45571038126945496,
-0.3823726773262024,
0.17892253398895264,
-0.4158216118812561,
0.29331517219543457,
0.5301445722579956,
-0.963589608669281,
-0.2685752213001251,
0.5915046334266663,
0.4203014075756073,
0.1454513520002365,
-0.2276018112897873,
-0.49745917320251465,
0.6555699110031128,
-0.3802211582660675,
0.9547384977340698,
-0.8647131323814392,
-0.2553490698337555,
-0.06091875955462456,
0.11297719925642014,
-0.12841936945915222,
-0.47245538234710693,
0.2652694582939148,
-0.2543691396713257,
0.03243650868535042,
-0.4647335708141327,
-0.7378242015838623,
-0.25819647312164307,
0.5219963788986206,
-0.6703283190727234,
0.8515591621398926,
0.03102460876107216,
-0.7318798303604126,
0.2882806956768036,
-0.5282907485961914,
-0.27371689677238464,
0.024331524968147278,
-0.2725905478000641,
-0.18184709548950195,
0.17882482707500458,
0.35660117864608765,
0.6909005641937256,
-0.31491759419441223,
0.19300055503845215,
-0.4403853714466095,
-0.4131397604942322,
0.13709422945976257,
-0.36223000288009644,
0.21208642423152924,
0.036989711225032806,
-0.025558751076459885,
0.12828607857227325,
-0.6542890667915344,
-0.09272675961256027,
0.1620907485485077,
-0.39363834261894226,
-0.46534717082977295,
-0.026351286098361015,
-0.07226774096488953,
0.1468377262353897,
0.2619965076446533,
-0.42518511414527893,
0.3267352283000946,
0.06625567376613617,
0.26985132694244385,
0.8103014230728149,
-0.0781959667801857,
0.47599807381629944,
-0.29726627469062805,
0.37684887647628784,
0.30474093556404114,
0.3932666778564453,
-0.9603155851364136,
-0.5436480641365051,
-0.9618164300918579,
-0.31208860874176025,
0.0002038738166447729,
0.4018164873123169,
-1.2227543592453003,
-0.09823130071163177,
-0.45665138959884644,
-0.45038774609565735,
-0.48010581731796265,
0.15761278569698334,
0.5168752670288086,
0.6877580285072327,
0.5421448349952698,
-0.2655749022960663,
-0.36082223057746887,
-0.9878981113433838,
-0.06119062006473541,
-0.04915052652359009,
0.19867928326129913,
0.6409112811088562,
0.5016897320747375,
-0.1408761739730835,
0.8156654238700867,
-0.49298807978630066,
-0.4955173432826996,
0.07364363223314285,
0.014124162495136261,
-0.09647879004478455,
0.7119289636611938,
0.6511664390563965,
-0.9623700976371765,
-0.28111860156059265,
0.1707324981689453,
-0.8394550085067749,
0.3442639410495758,
-0.17403773963451385,
-0.10612962394952774,
0.09217759221792221,
0.4834165871143341,
-0.5510864853858948,
0.2097793072462082,
0.32152053713798523,
-0.22228392958641052,
0.5098223090171814,
-0.23141002655029297,
0.05688132718205452,
-1.0589594841003418,
0.26553887128829956,
0.14719617366790771,
-0.17169129848480225,
-0.46087679266929626,
0.1813928335905075,
0.2707443833351135,
-0.1387939453125,
-0.4519844949245453,
0.7147996425628662,
-0.871174156665802,
-0.1767357736825943,
-0.16075974702835083,
0.3064638376235962,
0.18932612240314484,
0.48954054713249207,
0.06576729565858841,
0.6252049207687378,
0.6466506719589233,
-0.5469467043876648,
0.5240340828895569,
0.1083807498216629,
-0.20611505210399628,
0.8209247589111328,
-0.49029606580734253,
0.0002964003069791943,
-0.6034814715385437,
0.038497548550367355,
-0.9423373937606812,
-0.42655467987060547,
0.20242151618003845,
-0.31180664896965027,
0.5997152924537659,
-0.40255188941955566,
-0.30508050322532654,
-0.4270254671573639,
-0.2805786728858948,
0.3573289215564728,
0.3616776764392853,
-0.5227781534194946,
0.7576913237571716,
0.27562418580055237,
0.08002754300832748,
-1.0179435014724731,
-0.5326558947563171,
0.16403020918369293,
-0.15079492330551147,
-0.3382847309112549,
-0.09495488554239273,
-0.17402711510658264,
0.31428155303001404,
0.33912405371665955,
-0.17754723131656647,
-0.10996415466070175,
0.2160620540380478,
0.028725052252411842,
0.43125274777412415,
-0.23894181847572327,
0.5694236159324646,
-0.21957401931285858,
-0.2182457149028778,
-0.06715443730354309,
-0.3865388333797455,
0.3367575407028198,
-0.1859113574028015,
-0.6517572402954102,
-0.3335673213005066,
0.40777158737182617,
0.4355368912220001,
-0.45757466554641724,
0.5460017323493958,
0.899716317653656,
-0.28430992364883423,
0.03714342042803764,
-0.6875935792922974,
-0.03283987566828728,
-0.42174142599105835,
0.46734243631362915,
-0.42400267720222473,
-0.7535824179649353,
0.363366037607193,
-0.14655281603336334,
0.015692971646785736,
0.21910271048545837,
0.16194556653499603,
-0.23836100101470947,
0.9982466697692871,
0.5982265472412109,
0.1700170636177063,
0.7477783560752869,
-0.30374735593795776,
-0.011618834920227528,
-1.1430647373199463,
-0.4268389940261841,
-0.4073503315448761,
-0.34191039204597473,
-0.09620220959186554,
-0.6273872256278992,
0.2892177700996399,
0.268650621175766,
-0.09664715826511383,
0.35293906927108765,
-0.3524012267589569,
0.47387412190437317,
0.5711127519607544,
0.1546718180179596,
0.304706335067749,
0.08397197723388672,
-0.007968902587890625,
-0.009550772607326508,
-0.807704746723175,
-0.26189079880714417,
1.146176815032959,
0.15697906911373138,
0.90709388256073,
0.012297325767576694,
0.368543416261673,
0.030491216108202934,
0.38405099511146545,
-0.7773911952972412,
0.5837740898132324,
-0.11897909641265869,
-0.6909975409507751,
0.05685422196984291,
-0.5223830938339233,
-0.9155871868133545,
0.27517521381378174,
-0.3072749376296997,
-0.6679579615592957,
0.2970656156539917,
0.5020758509635925,
0.060146868228912354,
0.18975910544395447,
-0.9941431879997253,
1.0267059803009033,
-0.26315030455589294,
-0.4678996801376343,
0.04116152599453926,
-0.684791624546051,
0.32698774337768555,
0.0332304909825325,
0.2908250093460083,
-0.21247649192810059,
-0.25272735953330994,
0.3311913013458252,
-0.012596417218446732,
0.8575807213783264,
-0.2545502185821533,
-0.22079327702522278,
0.15289510786533356,
-0.1823451668024063,
0.49261897802352905,
-0.26708418130874634,
0.2859146296977997,
-0.3051755428314209,
-0.19725346565246582,
-0.6114886403083801,
-0.8233802318572998,
0.6114364266395569,
-0.38832396268844604,
-0.6600719094276428,
0.014850961044430733,
-0.7413836121559143,
-0.25614508986473083,
0.2088104635477066,
-0.08316126465797424,
0.7497425675392151,
0.2353183627128601,
0.3914020359516144,
0.8568241000175476,
-0.28280898928642273,
0.43872904777526855,
0.3546135723590851,
-0.44942429661750793,
-0.3396904766559601,
1.239646315574646,
0.07938873767852783,
0.39465224742889404,
0.5164875388145447,
-0.03921394422650337,
-0.2897437512874603,
-0.34307387471199036,
-0.7362663745880127,
0.2653651833534241,
-0.928007185459137,
-0.3544732928276062,
-0.5733599066734314,
0.24870005249977112,
-0.20500831305980682,
0.010942623019218445,
-0.5020086765289307,
-0.3315918445587158,
-0.3606913387775421,
0.1780634969472885,
0.3606151342391968,
0.5028522610664368,
0.15784302353858948,
0.15565665066242218,
-1.039124608039856,
0.2679606080055237,
0.29434266686439514,
0.5108254551887512,
0.38730788230895996,
-0.2898581922054291,
-0.46171292662620544,
0.2916926145553589,
0.018241440877318382,
-0.6687295436859131,
-0.021278684958815575,
0.3640858232975006,
0.5999197363853455,
0.5656859278678894,
-0.0256159957498312,
0.975872278213501,
-0.5066855549812317,
0.6806696057319641,
0.25433361530303955,
-0.7350488901138306,
0.766942024230957,
-0.42717328667640686,
0.340012788772583,
-0.01953054778277874,
0.4632698893547058,
-0.508522093296051,
-0.17148423194885254,
-0.3115082085132599,
-0.9497519135475159,
0.48906409740448,
-0.2689466178417206,
0.24826836585998535,
-0.26755958795547485,
0.3054733872413635,
-0.11418858915567398,
0.3402935266494751,
-0.6698776483535767,
-0.14757655560970306,
-0.34042543172836304,
-0.22689113020896912,
-0.09284491091966629,
-0.2710893452167511,
-0.04393799230456352,
-0.0860772356390953,
0.6201435923576355,
-0.385191947221756,
0.19454871118068695,
0.12291905283927917,
-0.3386821150779724,
0.10127437859773636,
0.3267352283000946,
0.6705566644668579,
0.5381990671157837,
-0.029821114614605904,
0.2728864550590515,
-0.22632181644439697,
-0.2970932722091675,
0.07250934094190598,
-0.11498964577913284,
-0.057204991579055786,
-0.1426914930343628,
0.5040776133537292,
0.9854838252067566,
0.34257975220680237,
-0.9310718178749084,
0.629465639591217,
0.20353750884532928,
0.2959374189376831,
-0.07579116523265839,
0.09783190488815308,
0.17558887600898743,
0.20196294784545898,
0.4198741316795349,
0.15363600850105286,
0.037529535591602325,
-0.5304531455039978,
0.00954726804047823,
0.648380696773529,
-0.5546931028366089,
-0.2723480463027954,
0.5664233565330505,
0.21168340742588043,
0.08651497960090637,
0.5246814489364624,
-0.035542748868465424,
-0.37778088450431824,
0.547111988067627,
0.752876877784729,
0.37019696831703186,
-0.11338871717453003,
0.1319403201341629,
0.2778961658477783,
0.4747694730758667,
-0.228704035282135,
0.3198226988315582,
-0.06163249909877777,
-0.6506580114364624,
-0.5807828307151794,
-0.30575865507125854,
-0.10520760715007782,
-0.233282208442688,
-0.8764905333518982,
0.08446172624826431,
-0.3929954171180725,
-0.28554868698120117,
-0.08101128041744232,
-0.3753860592842102,
-0.6992255449295044,
0.13554786145687103,
0.03192644566297531,
0.8465734720230103,
-0.788838803768158,
0.6844692826271057,
1.0404354333877563,
-0.6452609896659851,
-0.7818374037742615,
-0.4257309138774872,
-0.18323597311973572,
-0.7623834609985352,
0.7066234946250916,
0.29340860247612,
0.022417783737182617,
0.19878065586090088,
-0.4503079652786255,
-0.8621426820755005,
0.9793073534965515,
0.45902055501937866,
-0.46095383167266846,
0.008981108665466309,
-0.04361088573932648,
0.32879263162612915,
-0.27020150423049927,
0.18261799216270447,
0.1384163498878479,
0.572597086429596,
0.16289255023002625,
-0.8208731412887573,
-0.11376497894525528,
-0.3657153248786926,
0.3363439738750458,
0.4023991823196411,
-0.5967209935188293,
0.8711406588554382,
-0.33178281784057617,
-0.32673195004463196,
-0.06089431419968605,
0.4410528242588043,
-0.1987869143486023,
0.14981035888195038,
0.3382152318954468,
0.7770541906356812,
0.5958265662193298,
-0.10749964416027069,
1.1711591482162476,
0.05204063281416893,
0.4259762465953827,
1.2192736864089966,
-0.28700679540634155,
0.9668392539024353,
0.6748254895210266,
0.2634388506412506,
0.20651206374168396,
0.2449808269739151,
-0.3027589023113251,
0.29298052191734314,
-0.31203314661979675,
-0.1100478321313858,
-0.39791789650917053,
-0.5736054182052612,
-0.5457122921943665,
0.5264136791229248,
0.4597571790218353,
-0.28679871559143066,
-0.3420060873031616,
0.449579119682312,
-0.14484119415283203,
0.10236606001853943,
-0.3780132234096527,
0.8629726767539978,
-0.15229974687099457,
-0.5407145023345947,
0.5565449595451355,
-0.23052111268043518,
0.46728992462158203,
-0.45629027485847473,
-0.2567623257637024,
-0.15408147871494293,
0.2786658704280853,
-0.060657139867544174,
-0.7969505786895752,
0.08406021445989609,
-0.17563553154468536,
-0.4123518168926239,
-0.16613860428333282,
0.7179223299026489,
-0.7481886148452759,
-0.3672465682029724,
0.2219933420419693,
0.4586699306964874,
0.1086573451757431,
0.0627804771065712,
-0.5536404848098755,
0.36907413601875305,
-0.10201864689588547,
-0.050676848739385605,
0.2882719337940216,
0.3823273181915283,
-0.0565565824508667,
1.0937038660049438,
0.6267041563987732,
-0.15200753509998322,
0.18934714794158936,
-0.09229058772325516,
0.8118361234664917,
-0.5663273334503174,
-0.14208687841892242,
-0.6385235786437988,
0.668220579624176,
-0.07825912535190582,
0.0028416449204087257,
0.8137223720550537,
0.4609389007091522,
1.0032217502593994,
-0.3990592062473297,
0.47734808921813965,
0.08056138455867767,
0.33234044909477234,
-0.7133061289787292,
0.36056870222091675,
-0.8425911664962769,
0.2938428521156311,
-0.35129138827323914,
-1.0119725465774536,
-0.2614575922489166,
0.4769235849380493,
-0.07383259385824203,
0.16584470868110657,
0.5295732021331787,
0.6674893498420715,
-0.2249596267938614,
-0.30079036951065063,
0.2915404736995697,
0.06363344937562943,
0.28140613436698914,
0.7625800967216492,
0.9916783571243286,
-0.5920041799545288,
0.6280728578567505,
-0.12330178916454315,
-0.0018026001052930951,
-0.3341720700263977,
-0.9734861254692078,
-0.8218294382095337,
-0.6923347115516663,
-0.3761647939682007,
-0.007891708053648472,
-0.09327039122581482,
0.675193190574646,
0.7824386358261108,
-0.3246205747127533,
-0.016718890517950058,
0.32202011346817017,
0.2141612321138382,
-0.19303128123283386,
-0.19682323932647705,
0.3074091672897339,
-0.40724775195121765,
-0.7241382002830505,
0.22027944028377533,
0.5471210479736328,
0.339984655380249,
-0.1583511084318161,
0.12336068600416183,
-0.47502902150154114,
-0.1934838593006134,
0.6891468167304993,
0.284898042678833,
-0.7761792540550232,
-0.5939114689826965,
-0.04125865548849106,
-0.03759774938225746,
0.0444219633936882,
0.6601946949958801,
-0.776427149772644,
0.7894396781921387,
0.14088808000087738,
0.8284651637077332,
0.3009769022464752,
0.03527157008647919,
0.39724981784820557,
-1.036333680152893,
0.3866270184516907,
-0.010652170516550541,
0.5134612321853638,
0.6499139666557312,
-0.137494295835495,
0.4064750373363495,
0.23066546022891998,
-0.23533660173416138,
-0.860098123550415,
0.5206260085105896,
-0.9184895753860474,
-0.35722631216049194,
0.7064081430435181,
-0.39039966464042664,
-0.3416188955307007,
0.0026432203594595194,
-0.34186702966690063,
0.052182387560606,
-0.12159784138202667,
0.5050212740898132,
0.6401816606521606,
0.23270054161548615,
-0.5814351439476013,
-0.5427287817001343,
0.2147313356399536,
0.3264590799808502,
-0.7611017227172852,
0.09150204062461853,
0.7737261056900024,
0.1404390186071396,
0.3314647078514099,
0.30504921078681946,
-0.04476001858711243,
0.3079373836517334,
0.07314002513885498,
0.08824285864830017,
-0.4209895431995392,
-0.5827523469924927,
0.024316763505339622,
0.05176694318652153,
0.0674201250076294,
-0.2377970963716507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10834v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10834v1
|
Exposing the Achilles' Heel: Evaluating LLMs Ability to Handle Mistakes in Mathematical Reasoning
| 2024-06-16T08:06:05 | 2024-06-16T08:06:05 |
Joykirat Singh, Akshay Nambi, Vibhav Vineet
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have been applied to Math Word Problems (MWPs)
with transformative impacts, revolutionizing how these complex problems are
approached and solved in various domains including educational settings.
However, the evaluation of these models often prioritizes final accuracy,
overlooking the crucial aspect of reasoning capabilities. This work addresses
this gap by focusing on the ability of LLMs to detect and correct reasoning
mistakes. We introduce a novel dataset MWP-MISTAKE, incorporating MWPs with
both correct and incorrect reasoning steps generated through rule-based methods
and smaller language models. Our comprehensive benchmarking reveals significant
insights into the strengths and weaknesses of state-of-the-art models, such as
GPT-4o, GPT-4, GPT-3.5Turbo, and others. We highlight GPT-$o's superior
performance in mistake detection and rectification and the persistent
challenges faced by smaller models. Additionally, we identify issues related to
data contamination and memorization, impacting the reliability of LLMs in
real-world applications. Our findings emphasize the importance of rigorous
evaluation of reasoning processes and propose future directions to enhance the
generalization and robustness of LLMs in mathematical problem-solving.
|
[
-0.018872594460844994,
-0.7324351668357849,
0.8513425588607788,
0.02255186438560486,
0.052677739411592484,
0.22126096487045288,
0.03051961027085781,
-0.22282147407531738,
-0.4535352885723114,
0.31260034441947937,
-0.5049349069595337,
-0.3870198428630829,
-0.9533732533454895,
0.20650000870227814,
-0.24253329634666443,
0.7101446390151978,
-0.3398243188858032,
0.3129110336303711,
-0.4631071388721466,
-0.326455295085907,
-0.708877682685852,
-0.5947669148445129,
-0.6120452284812927,
-0.6444052457809448,
0.3061300814151764,
0.3521749973297119,
0.8538239598274231,
0.550712525844574,
0.7835019826889038,
0.32320675253868103,
-0.12594495713710785,
0.29755473136901855,
-0.40043094754219055,
-0.049773916602134705,
-0.4271464943885803,
-0.5302236080169678,
-0.48531392216682434,
0.0500127449631691,
0.37050703167915344,
0.8397266268730164,
-0.3315516412258148,
0.09517496079206467,
-0.07474493980407715,
0.8422749042510986,
-0.6230536103248596,
0.40170106291770935,
-0.9161106944084167,
0.118964284658432,
-0.23523931205272675,
-0.00910832080990076,
-0.4639541208744049,
-0.46743568778038025,
0.03635650500655174,
-0.4812184274196625,
0.16791853308677673,
-0.10370821505784988,
0.5754895210266113,
0.41471144556999207,
-0.09088355302810669,
-0.5047011971473694,
-0.6319664120674133,
0.9246653914451599,
-0.7223805785179138,
0.2327033281326294,
0.29100358486175537,
0.4325356185436249,
-0.368367463350296,
-0.5381766557693481,
-0.5789003968238831,
0.0731838271021843,
0.24526943266391754,
-0.1040191724896431,
-0.44566577672958374,
-0.16332128643989563,
0.5256794095039368,
0.1447635293006897,
-0.33187127113342285,
0.20003709197044373,
-0.23667781054973602,
-0.25103336572647095,
0.5161720514297485,
0.40588417649269104,
0.23852472007274628,
0.001927742618136108,
-0.05996421352028847,
-0.14482246339321136,
-0.9384489059448242,
-0.07066719979047775,
0.23507723212242126,
0.2911866009235382,
0.1281677782535553,
0.6542232632637024,
0.11262693256139755,
0.7299633622169495,
-0.26945018768310547,
-0.289526104927063,
0.11110462248325348,
-0.03970365226268768,
-0.2702000141143799,
-0.1667700856924057,
0.47436589002609253,
0.2265315055847168,
0.6675517559051514,
0.06434707343578339,
-0.4113975763320923,
0.3232402801513672,
0.15625615417957306,
-0.44036978483200073,
-0.20446226000785828,
0.11438539624214172,
0.0451229065656662,
-0.2889443039894104,
-0.14145687222480774,
-0.5526922345161438,
-0.5883628726005554,
-0.46192485094070435,
0.5021964907646179,
-0.6198726892471313,
0.036349307745695114,
0.48040512204170227,
0.11619022488594055,
-0.1221647635102272,
0.5021405220031738,
-0.5020098686218262,
0.2719350755214691,
1.017467975616455,
0.7323843836784363,
0.011617056094110012,
-0.4245448708534241,
-0.6042709946632385,
-0.12028580904006958,
-0.6831172704696655,
0.7854435443878174,
-0.5877615809440613,
-0.35023078322410583,
0.08781465888023376,
-0.4835442006587982,
-0.17501938343048096,
-0.9103275537490845,
1.0161738395690918,
-0.20283547043800354,
-0.1710653007030487,
-0.4452972412109375,
-0.6786044239997864,
-0.13777463138103485,
0.48112431168556213,
-0.47919392585754395,
0.8963979482650757,
0.14403477311134338,
-0.9083853960037231,
0.06198162958025932,
-0.4133720099925995,
-0.19843895733356476,
-0.19429083168506622,
-0.3354544937610626,
-0.6237761974334717,
0.3379693627357483,
0.3183319866657257,
0.3620804250240326,
-0.4929807186126709,
0.3276861906051636,
-0.33033397793769836,
-0.38950520753860474,
0.3210969865322113,
-0.5813829302787781,
0.6278364062309265,
-0.12976084649562836,
-0.263351172208786,
-0.07038730382919312,
-0.8639897704124451,
0.06876875460147858,
0.662194550037384,
-0.08891753107309341,
-0.32576480507850647,
0.10579966753721237,
-0.6428965330123901,
0.3311234414577484,
0.06599361449480057,
-0.3580472767353058,
0.25314438343048096,
-0.07181454449892044,
0.37030065059661865,
1.0478289127349854,
-0.29418817162513733,
-0.007446187548339367,
-0.46660155057907104,
0.4581775665283203,
0.19465187191963196,
0.07339274883270264,
-0.13287894427776337,
-0.48552531003952026,
-0.7567929625511169,
0.2626708447933197,
0.284771591424942,
0.8325346112251282,
-0.9197765588760376,
0.04816630110144615,
-0.4350268244743347,
-0.737255334854126,
-0.22653447091579437,
0.17313234508037567,
0.6092394590377808,
0.8113493919372559,
0.31367355585098267,
0.08464087545871735,
-0.22208362817764282,
-0.7165923118591309,
-0.6897450685501099,
-0.21848489344120026,
0.06501233577728271,
0.4709939956665039,
0.6255486011505127,
-0.15366660058498383,
0.8263497352600098,
-0.5681824684143066,
-0.27176886796951294,
-0.1641135811805725,
0.23004621267318726,
0.16462785005569458,
0.2886018753051758,
0.29797616600990295,
-0.4876927435398102,
-0.1496359258890152,
-0.16422206163406372,
-0.7785050272941589,
-0.42456915974617004,
0.1435859501361847,
0.12437625229358673,
0.25668609142303467,
0.13064180314540863,
-0.6688510179519653,
0.4944460391998291,
0.44446006417274475,
-0.45520108938217163,
0.9514998197555542,
-0.1681707501411438,
0.029395362362265587,
-0.49071744084358215,
-0.28427979350090027,
0.20830971002578735,
0.15925058722496033,
-0.4008762240409851,
-0.08576470613479614,
0.12668061256408691,
-0.005727341398596764,
-0.3025364279747009,
0.31881624460220337,
-0.30001601576805115,
-0.266180157661438,
0.13811706006526947,
0.21986471116542816,
-0.06912348419427872,
0.2568223178386688,
-0.14370106160640717,
0.7494626641273499,
0.39442262053489685,
-0.45676812529563904,
0.5106191039085388,
0.048519980162382126,
-0.3164389729499817,
0.8573315143585205,
-0.555306613445282,
0.26245149970054626,
0.06747611612081528,
0.018962878733873367,
-0.7935691475868225,
-0.02020476944744587,
0.07037923485040665,
-0.5401875376701355,
0.3527854084968567,
-0.3479355275630951,
-0.7768760323524475,
-0.5125833749771118,
-0.20768792927265167,
0.4821600019931793,
0.29656946659088135,
-0.6689589023590088,
0.5028778910636902,
0.19222787022590637,
-0.31129297614097595,
-0.7866742014884949,
-0.4436359107494354,
0.11164312809705734,
-0.1497286707162857,
-0.7077900171279907,
0.00940600223839283,
0.030633212998509407,
-0.6379818320274353,
-0.11294662952423096,
-0.41889241337776184,
-0.01983860693871975,
0.023930761963129044,
0.004635062534362078,
0.272681325674057,
-0.18544360995292664,
0.2894401252269745,
-0.17938317358493805,
-0.38390204310417175,
0.2900111675262451,
-0.1364315152168274,
0.44360554218292236,
-0.3117193877696991,
-0.7407582402229309,
-0.10658542811870575,
-0.006492409389466047,
0.7234260439872742,
-0.16444964706897736,
0.36084210872650146,
-0.037536632269620895,
-0.6568387150764465,
-0.25806307792663574,
-0.6198051571846008,
-0.018752092495560646,
-0.42361530661582947,
0.4035286009311676,
-0.42735737562179565,
-0.4344864785671234,
0.4143146872520447,
-0.1359759122133255,
0.17354753613471985,
0.5300602316856384,
0.19520755112171173,
-0.05559450387954712,
0.9627230167388916,
0.3002529442310333,
-0.23246636986732483,
-0.10535755008459091,
-0.2636054456233978,
0.2545948326587677,
-0.7043675780296326,
-0.16291169822216034,
-0.6065487861633301,
-0.16853800415992737,
-0.23893621563911438,
-0.6932929754257202,
0.3219973146915436,
0.12659627199172974,
-0.4208013415336609,
0.13535155355930328,
-0.2754304111003876,
0.5699419379234314,
0.10161673277616501,
-0.11969777941703796,
0.5907087922096252,
-0.010309142991900444,
-0.4370430111885071,
-0.539382815361023,
-0.7360814809799194,
-0.687446653842926,
1.1616365909576416,
0.4073263704776764,
0.8584326505661011,
0.15653644502162933,
0.4797540009021759,
0.1274939328432083,
0.4641570746898651,
-0.7819420695304871,
0.5940301418304443,
-0.06057149916887283,
-0.3149046003818512,
-0.33891692757606506,
-0.7493543028831482,
-0.7820202708244324,
0.3920169472694397,
0.015959452837705612,
-0.7802371382713318,
-0.12411107867956161,
0.18470247089862823,
-0.042881548404693604,
0.8267565369606018,
-0.6317054629325867,
0.7838525176048279,
-0.43663281202316284,
-0.3711683452129364,
-0.01682434231042862,
-0.16278551518917084,
0.4824956953525543,
-0.1867011934518814,
0.6144580841064453,
-0.19031907618045807,
-0.031064152717590332,
0.4730290174484253,
-0.6205667853355408,
0.6671230792999268,
-0.06628650426864624,
-0.4289766550064087,
0.3201698362827301,
0.6208339929580688,
0.8766177296638489,
-0.1957472860813141,
-0.08847500383853912,
0.24692796170711517,
-0.23872555792331696,
-0.29420286417007446,
-0.7600798010826111,
0.6215602159500122,
-0.4819873571395874,
-0.5815127491950989,
-0.769311249256134,
-0.49181291460990906,
-0.6185964941978455,
0.03301197290420532,
0.23764270544052124,
0.41169118881225586,
0.09394049644470215,
-0.18337786197662354,
0.6997758150100708,
-0.18796101212501526,
0.39650964736938477,
0.509069561958313,
-0.15296901762485504,
-0.28731319308280945,
1.0333707332611084,
0.46573588252067566,
0.3194926679134369,
-0.07805788516998291,
0.3454377055168152,
-0.26829880475997925,
-0.8224689960479736,
-0.49002596735954285,
0.4165882170200348,
-1.0132087469100952,
-0.38471660017967224,
-0.34862402081489563,
-0.23051868379116058,
-0.04445124790072441,
-0.09428052604198456,
-0.5596240162849426,
-0.2788637578487396,
-0.1312391310930252,
-0.18430645763874054,
0.19902196526527405,
0.8540321588516235,
-0.055940672755241394,
-0.10338179767131805,
-0.7649555802345276,
0.13869404792785645,
0.25768375396728516,
0.49808478355407715,
0.07358894497156143,
-0.6709361672401428,
0.11760131269693375,
-0.08653783798217773,
-0.4867176115512848,
-0.7205085754394531,
0.26816266775131226,
-0.04168572649359703,
0.4688783884048462,
0.1603812724351883,
-0.1095360592007637,
0.5877770781517029,
-0.6285606622695923,
0.48481497168540955,
0.15177837014198303,
-0.9922449588775635,
0.5500572323799133,
-0.3626271188259125,
0.1394466757774353,
0.23376034200191498,
0.20408158004283905,
-0.42350107431411743,
-0.14463631808757782,
-0.8213260769844055,
-0.6292067170143127,
0.5650976896286011,
0.2649306654930115,
-0.1329696774482727,
0.029021067544817924,
0.4421160817146301,
-0.05730360746383667,
0.06916560977697372,
-0.5842545032501221,
-0.16958624124526978,
0.22899998724460602,
-0.10199970752000809,
-0.038295451551675797,
-0.3039098381996155,
-0.12344364821910858,
-0.2656121551990509,
0.7125698924064636,
-0.23194965720176697,
-0.08041418343782425,
0.04991533234715462,
-0.2061270922422409,
-0.08122801780700684,
0.3027469515800476,
0.7139806747436523,
1.0392881631851196,
0.03683755174279213,
0.06582631915807724,
0.4134069085121155,
-0.45482635498046875,
0.11169219762086868,
0.06349138170480728,
-0.06807852536439896,
0.08075299113988876,
0.5173124074935913,
0.27770301699638367,
0.4052637815475464,
-0.7731174826622009,
0.512372612953186,
0.05972030758857727,
-0.09743600338697433,
-0.4152821898460388,
-0.12554773688316345,
0.20898009836673737,
0.08368304371833801,
0.4389023184776306,
0.20861509442329407,
0.0411832332611084,
-0.43893012404441833,
0.11592359840869904,
0.269122451543808,
-0.19436970353126526,
-0.06207658350467682,
0.20798885822296143,
-0.0751788392663002,
-0.4219324290752411,
0.6249508857727051,
-0.06800911575555801,
-0.7431289553642273,
0.7556992173194885,
0.5790677666664124,
0.561654806137085,
-0.26092472672462463,
0.023834362626075745,
0.24708129465579987,
0.39721256494522095,
-0.2054883986711502,
0.28742262721061707,
0.33741259574890137,
-0.8921364545822144,
-0.3905223608016968,
-0.25405412912368774,
-0.6930639743804932,
0.2780342698097229,
-0.5869178771972656,
0.13739480078220367,
-0.6911166906356812,
-0.16720466315746307,
-0.05227202549576759,
-0.17420116066932678,
-0.5821067094802856,
0.36987826228141785,
-0.01277041807770729,
0.9166951775550842,
-0.7450914978981018,
0.4488850235939026,
0.5378417372703552,
-0.07574336975812912,
-0.7758973240852356,
-0.13212811946868896,
0.3765614628791809,
-1.0116690397262573,
0.6407260298728943,
0.07643800228834152,
-0.3100932836532593,
-0.3486887514591217,
-0.3843785226345062,
-0.6624435186386108,
0.9145825505256653,
0.5798633098602295,
-0.8120740652084351,
0.1613813191652298,
0.28989177942276,
0.4573861062526703,
-0.09510505944490433,
0.09677767753601074,
0.9896335601806641,
0.46824800968170166,
0.3008608818054199,
-0.9913615584373474,
-0.14622975885868073,
-0.02232496812939644,
-0.06680578738451004,
0.3529268205165863,
-0.43408066034317017,
0.9447236657142639,
-0.6176310777664185,
0.013706205412745476,
-0.049314163625240326,
0.26348039507865906,
0.741550862789154,
0.559261679649353,
0.35696420073509216,
1.068118691444397,
0.9289100766181946,
-0.6204670071601868,
1.14753258228302,
0.22683772444725037,
0.4328261613845825,
1.2137569189071655,
-0.28768616914749146,
0.8866587281227112,
0.36251869797706604,
-0.5909386277198792,
0.23673337697982788,
0.43751904368400574,
0.059811487793922424,
0.042595382779836655,
0.6436144113540649,
-0.1303631067276001,
-0.24397125840187073,
0.25386086106300354,
-0.33752748370170593,
0.32880544662475586,
0.6117956638336182,
-0.161014586687088,
-0.42368096113204956,
-0.40562814474105835,
0.2649635374546051,
0.35180753469467163,
-0.5385591387748718,
0.40419355034828186,
0.2524087429046631,
-0.4232517182826996,
0.49403417110443115,
0.012919650413095951,
0.5088279247283936,
-0.3849363625049591,
-0.2769727408885956,
-0.3134753704071045,
0.5016674399375916,
-0.17314927279949188,
-0.9675118327140808,
0.32680973410606384,
0.1831120103597641,
-0.00016728918126318604,
0.15266481041908264,
0.6795846819877625,
0.04381100460886955,
-0.8315923810005188,
0.29355746507644653,
0.5349237322807312,
0.08647530525922775,
-0.18570588529109955,
-0.833631694316864,
0.34453070163726807,
-0.2221871167421341,
0.029986558482050896,
0.21417653560638428,
0.7328429818153381,
-0.20101317763328552,
1.1119078397750854,
0.5270394682884216,
0.14599336683750153,
-0.015467597171664238,
0.28788262605667114,
0.5427756309509277,
-0.7408694624900818,
-0.0912872925400734,
-1.083798885345459,
0.41511043906211853,
-0.053711600601673126,
-0.4445135295391083,
0.5676048994064331,
0.5212873220443726,
0.8613629341125488,
0.040842585265636444,
0.6710523366928101,
0.49724504351615906,
0.6250619292259216,
-0.645823061466217,
0.3948788642883301,
-0.2058108150959015,
0.6902904510498047,
-0.5764094591140747,
-0.7964081168174744,
-0.46204686164855957,
0.666469156742096,
-0.5404034852981567,
0.21887409687042236,
0.659164547920227,
0.3667842745780945,
0.08151885867118835,
0.0363517627120018,
0.4995642602443695,
0.2919170558452606,
0.37120646238327026,
0.9144122004508972,
0.8549618124961853,
-0.5057166218757629,
0.6526930928230286,
-0.18550951778888702,
-0.16924811899662018,
-0.15599317848682404,
-0.9518821239471436,
-0.6873645186424255,
-0.2789423167705536,
-0.44730108976364136,
-0.4941030442714691,
0.006804054137319326,
0.5525199770927429,
0.22299885749816895,
-0.7664470076560974,
-0.03752744197845459,
-0.19273343682289124,
0.48588326573371887,
-0.22487080097198486,
-0.20481787621974945,
0.4039676785469055,
-0.3866313695907593,
-0.561319887638092,
0.1993217170238495,
0.4676055610179901,
0.21457169950008392,
-0.16329218447208405,
-0.08690286427736282,
0.2769351005554199,
0.2699097990989685,
0.5923928618431091,
0.2533521056175232,
-0.8317663073539734,
-0.4208029806613922,
-0.1825554370880127,
-0.060829054564237595,
0.1483244150876999,
1.0074700117111206,
-0.5621210336685181,
0.37452441453933716,
0.17703129351139069,
0.8454856276512146,
0.1669331043958664,
-0.15868185460567474,
0.5675150752067566,
-0.3744122385978699,
-0.29555538296699524,
0.3484855592250824,
0.8073509335517883,
0.5957276225090027,
-0.15120188891887665,
0.843004047870636,
0.6138774156570435,
-0.42037904262542725,
-0.9380470514297485,
0.1977255940437317,
-0.563454806804657,
-0.22094179689884186,
1.01308274269104,
-0.3617624342441559,
0.012787277810275555,
-0.023309582844376564,
-0.23332089185714722,
-0.1172967329621315,
-0.06471460312604904,
0.8533006310462952,
1.2252211570739746,
-0.17598091065883636,
-0.16496354341506958,
-0.7146497964859009,
0.36789748072624207,
0.5889081954956055,
-0.7202027440071106,
0.3055276572704315,
0.6246943473815918,
0.46076342463493347,
0.28769445419311523,
0.22186048328876495,
-0.5138223171234131,
0.34335091710090637,
0.09115911275148392,
-0.3734745979309082,
-0.20602184534072876,
-0.36172065138816833,
-0.4218520522117615,
0.018296588212251663,
0.1413266807794571,
0.04729168489575386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10833v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10833v1
|
A Comprehensive Survey of Scientific Large Language Models and Their Applications in Scientific Discovery
| 2024-06-16T08:03:24 | 2024-06-16T08:03:24 |
Yu Zhang, Xiusi Chen, Bowen Jin, Sheng Wang, Shuiwang Ji, Wei Wang, Jiawei Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In many scientific fields, large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized
the way with which text and other modalities of data (e.g., molecules and
proteins) are dealt, achieving superior performance in various applications and
augmenting the scientific discovery process. Nevertheless, previous surveys on
scientific LLMs often concentrate on one to two fields or a single modality. In
this paper, we aim to provide a more holistic view of the research landscape by
unveiling cross-field and cross-modal connections between scientific LLMs
regarding their architectures and pre-training techniques. To this end, we
comprehensively survey over 250 scientific LLMs, discuss their commonalities
and differences, as well as summarize pre-training datasets and evaluation
tasks for each field and modality. Moreover, we investigate how LLMs have been
deployed to benefit scientific discovery. Resources related to this survey are
available at https://github.com/yuzhimanhua/Awesome-Scientific-Language-Models.
|
[
-0.34949177503585815,
-0.5675111413002014,
0.746333658695221,
0.12642034888267517,
-0.10765101760625839,
0.1744576394557953,
-0.4697396457195282,
-0.703713059425354,
0.24249055981636047,
0.36834952235221863,
-0.2531428337097168,
-0.6863080263137817,
-0.7628558278083801,
0.3284560441970825,
-0.43163275718688965,
0.8679876327514648,
-0.015108237974345684,
0.4586184322834015,
-0.4753148853778839,
-0.046443019062280655,
0.2081395834684372,
-0.5244181752204895,
-0.19156090915203094,
-0.36735400557518005,
0.6933717727661133,
-0.13242264091968536,
0.37148669362068176,
0.5670459270477295,
0.7086264491081238,
0.3539983332157135,
-0.2148420363664627,
0.12089231610298157,
-0.427073210477829,
0.24270828068256378,
-0.4263734817504883,
-0.5934563279151917,
-0.5592464208602905,
0.056581854820251465,
0.7326655387878418,
1.1426095962524414,
0.29839134216308594,
0.1470911204814911,
-0.2049063891172409,
0.28146618604660034,
-0.467538982629776,
0.2662886679172516,
-0.48162010312080383,
0.2392231971025467,
-0.5120745301246643,
-0.4623143672943115,
-0.31590017676353455,
-0.036812976002693176,
0.5405476689338684,
-0.7266215085983276,
0.3324770927429199,
0.18934215605258942,
0.36283332109451294,
-0.10422514379024506,
-0.7872100472450256,
-0.37732335925102234,
-0.7132853865623474,
1.0525645017623901,
-0.7395908832550049,
0.6267626881599426,
0.22786687314510345,
0.20487064123153687,
-0.36707812547683716,
-0.8116827607154846,
-0.38916298747062683,
-0.46699193120002747,
0.13064520061016083,
-0.027117488905787468,
-0.017557557672262192,
0.0394652783870697,
0.09836801886558533,
0.34679561853408813,
-0.7089818120002747,
0.3930485248565674,
-0.23032228648662567,
-0.14920881390571594,
0.6161659955978394,
0.18132206797599792,
0.2186926156282425,
0.16882428526878357,
-0.05200403928756714,
-0.10378260165452957,
-1.0499320030212402,
-0.25715532898902893,
-0.03476964682340622,
0.10652415454387665,
-0.10954120755195618,
0.7515239119529724,
-0.0804712250828743,
0.9007506370544434,
-0.39139947295188904,
-0.24048756062984467,
0.3251003324985504,
-0.7842190861701965,
-0.16325655579566956,
-0.10360667109489441,
1.0675724744796753,
-0.04514467343688011,
0.0020483259577304125,
-0.266287624835968,
-0.10800539702177048,
-0.25873592495918274,
-0.13761818408966064,
-0.7601292729377747,
-0.05644005537033081,
-0.10708201676607132,
-0.5395364165306091,
-0.19847296178340912,
-0.15879519283771515,
-0.6525472402572632,
-0.48903751373291016,
-0.24718396365642548,
0.27074018120765686,
-0.13563132286071777,
-0.2967481017112732,
0.24394544959068298,
0.08617275953292847,
0.01914629340171814,
0.40126484632492065,
-0.7673213481903076,
0.03745027631521225,
0.7874117493629456,
0.8991472721099854,
-0.12654614448547363,
-0.42049694061279297,
-0.30861184000968933,
0.2102516144514084,
-0.25300168991088867,
0.7372857928276062,
-0.7767832279205322,
-0.4607350826263428,
-0.001101984758861363,
0.004931935109198093,
0.06595616787672043,
-0.41661015152931213,
0.2841747999191284,
-0.7238158583641052,
0.038561854511499405,
-0.47424089908599854,
-0.4365088641643524,
-0.19251777231693268,
0.3497936427593231,
-0.7652244567871094,
0.7049620151519775,
-0.14510813355445862,
-0.7592723965644836,
0.47096168994903564,
-0.7468953132629395,
-0.40902236104011536,
0.11139523983001709,
-0.23177139461040497,
-0.16763003170490265,
0.26223960518836975,
-0.056645721197128296,
0.7048494219779968,
-0.768783688545227,
0.33937183022499084,
-0.38034048676490784,
-0.04434731602668762,
0.44155991077423096,
-0.15076537430286407,
0.5492989420890808,
0.16734375059604645,
-0.1426098346710205,
0.29071247577667236,
-0.7679445147514343,
-0.1187681034207344,
-0.006719356402754784,
-0.3018573224544525,
-0.5264896750450134,
0.104334257543087,
0.13552454113960266,
0.24073748290538788,
0.2753446400165558,
-0.6559816598892212,
0.4543801546096802,
-0.37364134192466736,
0.7297317981719971,
0.3361595869064331,
-0.2799016833305359,
0.44366320967674255,
0.048146069049835205,
0.5112515091896057,
0.009188085794448853,
0.010090887546539307,
-0.29651421308517456,
-0.23982089757919312,
-0.32139870524406433,
-0.4480198919773102,
0.29854893684387207,
0.06354967504739761,
-0.4040372967720032,
0.3590138554573059,
-0.34475237131118774,
-0.7980294227600098,
-0.34157639741897583,
0.17707069218158722,
0.24005603790283203,
0.30090010166168213,
0.41331249475479126,
-0.05091777816414833,
-0.6443460583686829,
-0.6646496653556824,
-0.15358814597129822,
0.012285471893846989,
-0.04410826414823532,
0.3885127604007721,
0.7071271538734436,
-0.6063895225524902,
0.7102107405662537,
-0.15653473138809204,
0.02309982292354107,
-0.1930861622095108,
0.008450941182672977,
0.09739605337381363,
0.1276913285255432,
0.5525429248809814,
-0.6939743161201477,
-0.445089191198349,
0.3089931607246399,
-0.9199709892272949,
0.02685142681002617,
0.28473857045173645,
0.09081827104091644,
0.06690303236246109,
0.5541239976882935,
-0.7259612679481506,
0.09443698823451996,
0.7358181476593018,
-0.25712013244628906,
0.5751752853393555,
0.01608397625386715,
0.23116661608219147,
-0.840896725654602,
0.3423915505409241,
0.20244376361370087,
-0.16272132098674774,
-0.582431435585022,
0.03458167612552643,
-0.11893101036548615,
0.22694866359233856,
-0.35933127999305725,
0.5947604179382324,
-0.8777266144752502,
-0.28308507800102234,
-0.34990382194519043,
-0.018509723246097565,
-0.02688576653599739,
-0.19168692827224731,
0.3713570535182953,
0.6176875829696655,
0.8958552479743958,
-0.4529549777507782,
0.31499743461608887,
0.2385018765926361,
-0.48426100611686707,
-0.00008244319906225428,
-0.8728825449943542,
-0.17405861616134644,
-0.18550069630146027,
0.5873406529426575,
-0.7396154999732971,
-0.1445704996585846,
0.06203214451670647,
-0.10906083136796951,
0.19401079416275024,
0.15819981694221497,
-0.509807825088501,
-0.251742959022522,
-0.2867737114429474,
0.8825029730796814,
0.18856939673423767,
-0.4035155773162842,
0.49140113592147827,
0.5182058811187744,
-0.2909398674964905,
-0.4740394949913025,
-0.53884357213974,
0.18229186534881592,
-0.10656289011240005,
-0.478719562292099,
0.3021928668022156,
-0.1334744542837143,
-0.2581973969936371,
-0.147503063082695,
-0.16753974556922913,
0.188706636428833,
0.007120493333786726,
0.23843269050121307,
0.33057692646980286,
-0.41464152932167053,
0.21358513832092285,
-0.24448156356811523,
0.22414806485176086,
0.24576275050640106,
-0.270450234413147,
0.6935499906539917,
-0.2169451117515564,
-0.31895679235458374,
0.004183605313301086,
0.3097475469112396,
0.6314314603805542,
-0.359121173620224,
0.6677215099334717,
0.34108126163482666,
-0.19589705765247345,
0.04164046794176102,
-0.44949477910995483,
-0.20133943855762482,
-0.4041074514389038,
0.7029581665992737,
-0.18411536514759064,
-1.106353521347046,
0.2901589870452881,
-0.3254619836807251,
0.08599953353404999,
0.33358168601989746,
0.6759287714958191,
0.12732064723968506,
0.9219928979873657,
0.7439234852790833,
-0.11512716859579086,
0.23772059381008148,
-0.21351709961891174,
0.47445589303970337,
-0.7269801497459412,
-0.7044141888618469,
-0.7277495861053467,
0.047917429357767105,
-0.3792811632156372,
-0.5621475577354431,
0.522645115852356,
0.0257964339107275,
-0.19232718646526337,
0.13009139895439148,
-0.2853901982307434,
0.25320547819137573,
0.2777954339981079,
-0.2836282253265381,
0.3863826096057892,
0.05911080166697502,
-0.04732470214366913,
-0.02233104407787323,
-0.7514460682868958,
-0.6377743482589722,
1.1950596570968628,
0.4754115045070648,
0.82596355676651,
-0.2460837960243225,
0.6515989303588867,
-0.11780178546905518,
0.4812057316303253,
-0.8510344624519348,
0.6480126976966858,
0.07348233461380005,
-0.6128236651420593,
-0.5351616740226746,
-0.4622610807418823,
-1.0183403491973877,
0.26501432061195374,
-0.2464267909526825,
-0.3062579035758972,
0.054387278854846954,
0.021867701783776283,
-0.14811736345291138,
0.22501647472381592,
-0.25849002599716187,
0.7483017444610596,
-0.6911908984184265,
-0.2537740170955658,
-0.3076494336128235,
-0.6449220776557922,
0.46507975459098816,
-0.4020747244358063,
0.27841469645500183,
0.01235882006585598,
-0.093533456325531,
0.883185625076294,
-0.13534891605377197,
0.7908686399459839,
0.05577458441257477,
-0.356379896402359,
0.17400279641151428,
-0.027593888342380524,
0.37692609429359436,
0.11645255237817764,
0.056806959211826324,
0.5156160593032837,
0.2902602553367615,
-0.24265353381633759,
-0.2100953459739685,
0.9485841989517212,
-0.7020938396453857,
-0.5246239304542542,
-0.7357662916183472,
-0.7391889691352844,
-0.3416108191013336,
0.3434405028820038,
0.20145995914936066,
0.16237419843673706,
-0.29286307096481323,
0.4721648097038269,
0.803961455821991,
-0.38310641050338745,
0.4098656475543976,
0.831063985824585,
-0.32453078031539917,
-0.059444695711135864,
0.6056072115898132,
-0.04588157683610916,
0.10170945525169373,
0.5778459906578064,
0.004463502671569586,
-0.3992702066898346,
-0.9201830625534058,
0.21454152464866638,
0.5074624419212341,
-0.4022626578807831,
-0.22579586505889893,
-0.9162272214889526,
-0.07704068720340729,
-0.6466255784034729,
-0.08841768652200699,
-0.33950895071029663,
-0.20238755643367767,
-0.2548671066761017,
-0.08311854302883148,
0.2964014708995819,
0.8308378458023071,
-0.0627351701259613,
0.11702429503202438,
-0.8515234589576721,
0.25757747888565063,
-0.027115168049931526,
0.2192707508802414,
0.06186559051275253,
-0.21731768548488617,
-0.5251975655555725,
0.22392965853214264,
0.054568346589803696,
-0.6249898672103882,
0.5571324825286865,
0.30250802636146545,
0.772113561630249,
0.3205716013908386,
-0.4706669747829437,
0.39013752341270447,
-0.6783747673034668,
0.7782262563705444,
0.37052470445632935,
-0.6848257184028625,
0.25165146589279175,
-0.3375389575958252,
0.13332229852676392,
0.2528018355369568,
0.9390019774436951,
-0.487431138753891,
0.03893449157476425,
-0.11004389822483063,
-0.9520819187164307,
0.25108277797698975,
-0.48613986372947693,
-0.16562943160533905,
0.11413916945457458,
0.12706775963306427,
0.3972838222980499,
0.3564382791519165,
-0.6437335014343262,
-0.008480627089738846,
-0.30539029836654663,
-0.16633081436157227,
-0.4176841080188751,
-0.10569324344396591,
-0.4900752007961273,
-0.26470258831977844,
0.6415076851844788,
-0.16811464726924896,
0.09072347730398178,
0.0296439491212368,
-0.2798411250114441,
-0.030079888179898262,
0.3155056834220886,
0.5967899560928345,
0.710041344165802,
0.08139105886220932,
0.33980947732925415,
-0.16617746651172638,
-0.5649707913398743,
0.04067203775048256,
0.2044888436794281,
-0.008467716164886951,
-0.04564172402024269,
0.782596230506897,
0.6705889105796814,
0.27596983313560486,
-0.9900948405265808,
0.2624675929546356,
0.277573823928833,
-0.11912364512681961,
-0.014577044174075127,
-0.15226122736930847,
0.3811641335487366,
0.4375748634338379,
0.4293674826622009,
-0.13039913773536682,
0.2915017902851105,
-0.7296367883682251,
-0.2090292125940323,
0.8076383471488953,
0.0321042500436306,
-0.6538336277008057,
0.46551164984703064,
0.036405518651008606,
0.10773646831512451,
0.22636008262634277,
0.16738784313201904,
-0.4094202518463135,
0.3259798586368561,
0.5832319259643555,
0.5893067121505737,
-0.03962622582912445,
0.3095998466014862,
0.028541985899209976,
0.02976776286959648,
-0.16422612965106964,
0.1520363837480545,
-0.1575438380241394,
-0.5613981485366821,
-0.5807262063026428,
-0.9787390232086182,
-0.23142965137958527,
0.38486355543136597,
-0.30262091755867004,
0.12303798645734787,
-0.2398831993341446,
-0.026788141578435898,
0.46665167808532715,
0.1728549599647522,
-0.8136205077171326,
-0.016190262511372566,
0.2200596183538437,
1.0252087116241455,
-0.8046802878379822,
0.7987985014915466,
1.0245798826217651,
-0.1837134063243866,
-0.4766720235347748,
-0.4873989224433899,
-0.026233110576868057,
-0.5776493549346924,
1.1468909978866577,
-0.18646711111068726,
-0.10963812470436096,
-0.09041600674390793,
-0.7547664642333984,
-1.0626801252365112,
1.02964448928833,
0.11172683537006378,
-1.0828030109405518,
-0.07116612046957016,
0.38926178216934204,
0.8795329332351685,
-0.4321969747543335,
0.3627556264400482,
0.4716818034648895,
0.5792055130004883,
0.04291050136089325,
-1.0793266296386719,
0.021585432812571526,
-0.29985883831977844,
-0.22626745700836182,
0.032459717243909836,
-0.5268112421035767,
0.760674238204956,
-0.05766744539141655,
0.047512080520391464,
0.10298099368810654,
0.6222535371780396,
0.6036050915718079,
0.4875585734844208,
0.11640603095293045,
0.20785053074359894,
0.5588042736053467,
0.0242774598300457,
0.7497062683105469,
-0.45974916219711304,
0.26928582787513733,
0.6784456968307495,
-0.763256847858429,
0.5696393847465515,
0.5936135053634644,
-0.25640228390693665,
0.22757498919963837,
0.6925694942474365,
-0.21160003542900085,
0.37602442502975464,
0.3752304017543793,
-0.4625803828239441,
-0.2728840410709381,
-0.3169073462486267,
-0.6690658926963806,
0.2744091749191284,
0.5681301951408386,
-0.43805137276649475,
-0.39570167660713196,
0.16881325840950012,
-0.04629584401845932,
-0.16442979872226715,
-0.4352511167526245,
0.31682583689689636,
0.29617488384246826,
-0.4367707073688507,
0.46279072761535645,
-0.03180694580078125,
0.7786432504653931,
-0.9060431718826294,
-0.002766574500128627,
-0.07407156378030777,
-0.12600985169410706,
-0.3452380895614624,
-0.6954144835472107,
-0.20235253870487213,
-0.14301063120365143,
-0.31338170170783997,
-0.12845005095005035,
0.7123135924339294,
-0.5683611631393433,
-0.33128026127815247,
0.25327712297439575,
0.4711591601371765,
0.17791861295700073,
0.1390630006790161,
-0.34914422035217285,
0.27831536531448364,
-0.276883602142334,
-0.5636990666389465,
0.43425774574279785,
0.5036135315895081,
-0.27580127120018005,
0.7027190327644348,
0.6641125082969666,
0.36399176716804504,
0.3776807487010956,
0.05427130311727524,
0.9185242652893066,
-0.9683113098144531,
-0.01993313804268837,
-0.6588920950889587,
0.1085471361875534,
0.12141779810190201,
-0.1686413586139679,
1.0577539205551147,
0.7549837827682495,
0.8049615621566772,
-0.413011372089386,
1.087631106376648,
0.09467543661594391,
0.43836429715156555,
-0.42379751801490784,
0.5756679773330688,
-0.33022379875183105,
0.18387199938297272,
-0.15342170000076294,
-0.9926084876060486,
-0.5926328897476196,
0.372027724981308,
-0.36587613821029663,
0.10022592544555664,
0.6427198648452759,
0.7225713729858398,
-0.15717068314552307,
-0.01881382055580616,
0.20665213465690613,
0.551443874835968,
0.4899778664112091,
0.4829002618789673,
1.0489405393600464,
-0.03608894348144531,
0.09183385968208313,
0.10451158881187439,
-0.18606293201446533,
-0.3062664866447449,
-0.9595918655395508,
-1.0627009868621826,
-0.5175257921218872,
-0.20801565051078796,
-0.01629149541258812,
-0.03174099698662758,
0.917303204536438,
0.655918300151825,
-0.8082433342933655,
-0.2230021208524704,
-0.06319696456193924,
-0.4790061116218567,
0.2787036597728729,
-0.09386365860700607,
0.3108591139316559,
-0.07755488157272339,
-0.6708940863609314,
0.8659693598747253,
0.38339418172836304,
0.14279386401176453,
-0.6971597075462341,
-0.11333499848842621,
-0.3219365179538727,
0.06195468828082085,
0.8843259215354919,
0.7348246574401855,
-0.648013710975647,
0.07978135347366333,
0.3412289321422577,
-0.15361885726451874,
-0.28792670369148254,
1.1481903791427612,
-0.8066306114196777,
0.15756843984127045,
0.7331900596618652,
0.6977722644805908,
0.5970869064331055,
-0.47751617431640625,
0.5535715818405151,
-0.18686482310295105,
0.10534107685089111,
0.4730149805545807,
0.38733646273612976,
0.32012227177619934,
-0.1426738053560257,
0.42581748962402344,
0.20152698457241058,
-0.7297752499580383,
-1.1716126203536987,
0.1475936472415924,
-1.1324642896652222,
-0.2778237760066986,
1.131805658340454,
-0.0898502841591835,
-0.18158507347106934,
0.017307745292782784,
0.07022189348936081,
0.12587426602840424,
0.08222884684801102,
0.7490243315696716,
0.7200576066970825,
-0.07730261981487274,
0.09436719119548798,
-0.4992797374725342,
0.45709550380706787,
0.4979373812675476,
-0.816601574420929,
-0.167951300740242,
0.6046526432037354,
0.403209388256073,
0.2690456509590149,
0.3142848610877991,
-0.37684690952301025,
-0.03770587220788002,
-0.41384047269821167,
0.1538432091474533,
-0.25830453634262085,
-0.5438843369483948,
-0.3578920364379883,
0.12739424407482147,
0.10238882899284363,
0.4679943323135376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10824v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10824v1
|
Citation-Based Summarization of Landmark Judgments
| 2024-06-16T07:27:16 | 2024-06-16T07:27:16 |
Purnima Bindal, Vikas Kumar, Vasudha Bhatnagar, Parikshet Sirohi, Ashwini Siwal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Landmark judgments are of prime importance in the Common Law System because
of their exceptional jurisprudence and frequent references in other judgments.
In this work, we leverage contextual references available in citing judgments
to create an extractive summary of the target judgment. We evaluate the
proposed algorithm on two datasets curated from the judgments of Indian Courts
and find the results promising.
|
[
-0.29465436935424805,
-0.36787211894989014,
0.6310014724731445,
0.1963018774986267,
-0.5711053013801575,
-0.45992106199264526,
0.02889084257185459,
-0.47945281863212585,
0.45017847418785095,
0.7429798245429993,
0.3203660547733307,
-0.29240503907203674,
-0.7366728186607361,
-0.03204521909356117,
-0.46268826723098755,
1.0029157400131226,
0.3711024522781372,
0.27480050921440125,
0.16346390545368195,
-0.40984195470809937,
-0.795832097530365,
-0.4654812812805176,
0.2598484456539154,
-0.29991477727890015,
0.29111605882644653,
0.37522828578948975,
0.6039914488792419,
0.32596051692962646,
0.9283681511878967,
0.26157501339912415,
-0.5529636144638062,
0.07572509348392487,
-0.32696250081062317,
0.07486496865749359,
-0.7524023652076721,
-0.3003369867801666,
-0.3867756128311157,
-0.13452452421188354,
0.556423544883728,
1.0833020210266113,
0.19026122987270355,
0.24391096830368042,
0.06091219186782837,
1.1837639808654785,
-0.8917338848114014,
0.42457714676856995,
-0.6249264478683472,
0.14543668925762177,
-0.19912631809711456,
-0.39608314633369446,
-0.5073083639144897,
-0.9688674211502075,
0.26174113154411316,
-0.48151564598083496,
0.2346230000257492,
0.16819649934768677,
0.6958582401275635,
0.1544361561536789,
-0.7289993166923523,
-0.1459287852048874,
-0.5894908308982849,
1.1639779806137085,
-0.37841659784317017,
0.16525432467460632,
-0.03985389694571495,
0.6135485172271729,
0.06843441724777222,
-0.5929731726646423,
-0.035351160913705826,
-0.17148955166339874,
-0.48591330647468567,
0.14731086790561676,
0.001666081021539867,
-0.1831517219543457,
0.24577218294143677,
0.6403783559799194,
-0.3679380714893341,
-0.46777424216270447,
-0.8129450082778931,
-0.1343340128660202,
0.5831725597381592,
0.02198118343949318,
0.25306135416030884,
-0.9762356281280518,
-0.29986757040023804,
0.09112205356359482,
-0.9952423572540283,
-0.11798941344022751,
-0.2783275842666626,
0.8399829268455505,
0.11107739061117172,
0.4252454340457916,
-0.3407076299190521,
0.8193016052246094,
0.1996498852968216,
-0.139839768409729,
0.2057652771472931,
-0.4673057198524475,
-0.1034809798002243,
0.25421109795570374,
0.3812195956707001,
0.8937414288520813,
0.7350042462348938,
-0.17509083449840546,
0.1647600531578064,
-0.3631573021411896,
0.1146465390920639,
-0.44537776708602905,
0.26721566915512085,
-0.03501381352543831,
-0.7064087390899658,
-0.09272490441799164,
0.5559759736061096,
-0.8901646137237549,
-0.46839234232902527,
-0.8052945733070374,
-0.052280765026807785,
-0.14159516990184784,
0.05835408717393875,
-0.33805346488952637,
-0.5223433971405029,
0.0688270851969719,
0.7785980701446533,
-0.6283779740333557,
-0.06868670135736465,
0.7776395082473755,
0.8432202935218811,
-0.16800475120544434,
0.0750315710902214,
-0.4985406994819641,
0.4625363349914551,
-0.17690463364124298,
0.7603973746299744,
-0.7076619863510132,
-0.8371537327766418,
0.4631533622741699,
-0.02672298438847065,
0.017227493226528168,
-0.7631540894508362,
0.7955602407455444,
-0.4773322343826294,
-0.40242916345596313,
-0.6475297212600708,
-0.22868439555168152,
-0.38054701685905457,
0.2412402629852295,
-0.7922406792640686,
0.564799964427948,
-0.03980862349271774,
-0.7059299945831299,
0.9141486287117004,
-0.7383915185928345,
-0.8535094857215881,
0.10089157521724701,
-0.3972649872303009,
-0.1725827157497406,
0.4432150721549988,
0.40939396619796753,
0.5070632696151733,
-0.33354946970939636,
0.603296160697937,
-0.20262150466442108,
-0.3781897723674774,
-0.34792381525039673,
0.28720182180404663,
1.0659394264221191,
0.7531707882881165,
-0.29258766770362854,
0.09150850772857666,
-0.6770215034484863,
-0.21212933957576752,
-0.1299470067024231,
-0.35824477672576904,
-0.6398127675056458,
-0.03954217582941055,
0.4600529074668884,
-0.1452234834432602,
0.1581900268793106,
-0.255055695772171,
0.27203506231307983,
-0.0924057811498642,
0.0048003834672272205,
0.46241021156311035,
0.6909772157669067,
0.4275348484516144,
-0.343184232711792,
0.13886931538581848,
-0.11724433302879333,
0.033607251942157745,
-0.27114784717559814,
-0.43395498394966125,
-0.3221246600151062,
-0.257625013589859,
0.4413962960243225,
0.5628265738487244,
-0.30123579502105713,
0.254971981048584,
-0.8604611754417419,
-0.39788737893104553,
0.2327311635017395,
0.13208192586898804,
0.38503944873809814,
0.37303265929222107,
0.376536101102829,
-0.45458969473838806,
-0.7884683609008789,
-1.0522061586380005,
-0.8237429261207581,
-0.3093397915363312,
0.18137799203395844,
0.5471057891845703,
0.697087287902832,
0.2766348719596863,
1.2748690843582153,
-0.4860938787460327,
-0.36660170555114746,
-0.17548082768917084,
0.030383305624127388,
0.48966678977012634,
0.5566481351852417,
1.0808266401290894,
-1.1382936239242554,
-0.4820276200771332,
-0.04596279561519623,
-1.1950138807296753,
-0.06820385158061981,
-0.2146991342306137,
-0.20367589592933655,
-0.5554380416870117,
0.616218626499176,
-0.06921618431806564,
0.6586976647377014,
-0.43418851494789124,
-0.3701574206352234,
0.4193989038467407,
0.19769896566867828,
0.8597349524497986,
-1.0089815855026245,
0.1299522966146469,
0.01077248714864254,
-0.35131731629371643,
-0.24247032403945923,
0.2506585419178009,
0.01748124323785305,
0.03555913269519806,
-0.37713542580604553,
0.2784791588783264,
-0.3049285113811493,
-0.11444761604070663,
-0.01846257410943508,
0.22776496410369873,
-0.1630965620279312,
0.33914536237716675,
0.18762676417827606,
0.4159919321537018,
0.22667591273784637,
-0.6029427647590637,
-0.11189386248588562,
0.536001443862915,
-0.32067862153053284,
1.0340473651885986,
-0.35116127133369446,
-0.31879398226737976,
0.07991781830787659,
0.2577778697013855,
-0.79374098777771,
-0.2232958823442459,
0.00994463823735714,
-0.14410477876663208,
0.21133515238761902,
-0.3485337793827057,
-0.4469282925128937,
0.008168544620275497,
-0.43585312366485596,
0.33331552147865295,
0.22473500669002533,
-0.7022507190704346,
0.6227452158927917,
0.7450395226478577,
-0.28672635555267334,
-0.5729942321777344,
-0.7503478527069092,
0.22547347843647003,
-0.42505818605422974,
-0.015223642811179161,
0.01832902990281582,
0.17455622553825378,
-0.7760878205299377,
-0.17216330766677856,
-0.026462063193321228,
0.02059258706867695,
-0.03414011746644974,
0.8191607594490051,
0.1406681388616562,
-0.03788786008954048,
-0.060922134667634964,
0.13231976330280304,
-0.09078266471624374,
0.09007170051336288,
0.028855135664343834,
0.08557889610528946,
-0.2607896625995636,
-0.599810779094696,
-0.3474941849708557,
0.8179739713668823,
0.8822923302650452,
0.06515875458717346,
0.00041971993050538003,
-0.30985546112060547,
-0.33310067653656006,
0.36694231629371643,
-0.5554872155189514,
0.194685697555542,
-0.2574395537376404,
0.036660920828580856,
-0.1904301643371582,
-0.47030648589134216,
0.3577282130718231,
-0.45128539204597473,
0.20413163304328918,
0.9259358048439026,
0.714602530002594,
0.3351205885410309,
0.19747620820999146,
0.25665631890296936,
-0.5584812760353088,
0.7237886786460876,
0.03653945401310921,
0.31754302978515625,
-0.5883244276046753,
-0.16230075061321259,
-0.6975573301315308,
-0.015295758843421936,
-0.42594534158706665,
-0.20696312189102173,
0.5221543908119202,
0.30175361037254333,
-0.12620534002780914,
0.38899409770965576,
-0.5818939805030823,
0.5391241908073425,
0.7686251997947693,
0.22224882245063782,
0.8599919676780701,
-0.039965104311704636,
-0.38925260305404663,
0.09032291173934937,
-0.002118406817317009,
-0.7899071574211121,
1.4326151609420776,
-0.10200539976358414,
0.3690774440765381,
0.44016769528388977,
0.8448355793952942,
0.8500030040740967,
0.3519653081893921,
-0.455830842256546,
0.6052502393722534,
0.009740556590259075,
-1.004506230354309,
0.0363977774977684,
-0.08154814690351486,
-0.7998973727226257,
0.47392988204956055,
-0.22938646376132965,
-0.841450035572052,
0.6599066853523254,
-0.028074732050299644,
-0.5394354462623596,
0.08722271025180817,
-0.5526554584503174,
0.20418715476989746,
0.27827686071395874,
-0.4402516484260559,
-0.5957642793655396,
-0.7659699320793152,
0.5293896198272705,
-0.027656571939587593,
0.27169573307037354,
0.28751176595687866,
0.6183575391769409,
0.7538792490959167,
-0.6817533373832703,
0.6408568620681763,
-0.31580376625061035,
0.4356631636619568,
0.6707605123519897,
0.039439525455236435,
0.4107944667339325,
0.38354840874671936,
0.04338434338569641,
0.19959960877895355,
-0.006098122335970402,
-0.3171810209751129,
-0.47556808590888977,
0.8439150452613831,
-0.26200371980667114,
-0.5196595788002014,
-0.82075035572052,
-0.5187932252883911,
-0.21389952301979065,
-0.04831582307815552,
-0.011470001190900803,
0.6687721014022827,
-0.24318724870681763,
0.2632874846458435,
0.11134050041437149,
0.27840346097946167,
0.7274443507194519,
0.5517545342445374,
-0.0828888863325119,
-0.612729549407959,
0.6157099008560181,
0.24854278564453125,
-0.5197795629501343,
0.4834998548030853,
-0.17881104350090027,
-0.14659923315048218,
-0.8250725865364075,
-0.4300072491168976,
-0.055642157793045044,
-1.0438278913497925,
-0.2618825137615204,
-0.2654503285884857,
0.2664358913898468,
-0.5598018169403076,
-0.5677146315574646,
-0.15462517738342285,
-0.8616238236427307,
0.3299926519393921,
-0.11228210479021072,
0.24462451040744781,
0.9219081997871399,
-0.35471493005752563,
-0.06399355083703995,
-0.7591254115104675,
0.1373177319765091,
0.4964899718761444,
0.10137975215911865,
-0.09225833415985107,
-0.3638639748096466,
-0.22404663264751434,
-0.6581948399543762,
-0.2443397343158722,
-0.6725344061851501,
0.12205805629491806,
-0.07832217216491699,
0.6285644173622131,
0.7702003121376038,
0.11855600774288177,
0.9216445088386536,
-0.6158024072647095,
0.9599868059158325,
0.32372307777404785,
-0.641497015953064,
0.9778754115104675,
-0.39818334579467773,
0.1056441217660904,
0.9970248937606812,
0.2850903868675232,
-0.05876980721950531,
-0.25355324149131775,
-0.4734610617160797,
-1.0124781131744385,
0.22583281993865967,
0.22438670694828033,
-0.09883014112710953,
-0.21445825695991516,
0.4763435125350952,
0.05324220657348633,
-0.009895714931190014,
-0.3067641258239746,
-0.31963229179382324,
0.03821438550949097,
0.11075355112552643,
-0.058522649109363556,
-0.25950080156326294,
-0.3229893147945404,
-0.4972752034664154,
0.4724869132041931,
0.19869211316108704,
-0.08290911465883255,
0.39883124828338623,
-0.7409530878067017,
0.21317510306835175,
0.3203110694885254,
0.5192348957061768,
1.1390739679336548,
-0.4526580274105072,
-0.004368572495877743,
0.20673909783363342,
-0.5781729817390442,
-0.3679063022136688,
-0.10018908232450485,
-0.31600841879844666,
0.25925493240356445,
0.506116509437561,
0.1136523112654686,
0.6609434485435486,
-0.5051849484443665,
0.4743165671825409,
0.027823537588119507,
0.16637539863586426,
-0.5055598020553589,
-0.3221985101699829,
-0.5193309783935547,
0.4352213740348816,
0.7466387748718262,
0.5759707689285278,
0.6855612993240356,
-0.4270884692668915,
0.7244776487350464,
0.10195342451334,
-0.5663122534751892,
0.0528082549571991,
0.6285077333450317,
0.322689414024353,
0.0793750211596489,
0.23708276450634003,
0.2991640567779541,
-0.3681635856628418,
0.12568338215351105,
0.026694638654589653,
0.7574417591094971,
0.2737874686717987,
-0.4049373269081116,
0.7667992115020752,
-0.2816130816936493,
-0.09970240294933319,
-0.2786264419555664,
-0.555243730545044,
0.009031366556882858,
-0.3226843774318695,
-0.5183454155921936,
-0.4648853838443756,
-0.5402517318725586,
-1.0413695573806763,
0.2378137707710266,
-0.5263742804527283,
-0.13412870466709137,
-0.03368600457906723,
-0.10288602858781815,
-0.425517201423645,
0.2213379293680191,
0.03980264812707901,
0.6988571882247925,
-1.1122031211853027,
0.38767412304878235,
0.4459516108036041,
-0.917358934879303,
-0.4033435583114624,
-0.0219988152384758,
0.5040784478187561,
-0.5943464040756226,
1.0986589193344116,
-0.356712281703949,
-0.2706126272678375,
-0.5488261580467224,
-0.33279678225517273,
-0.594911515712738,
1.0029658079147339,
0.23570193350315094,
-0.5437949299812317,
0.27012109756469727,
-0.1614241600036621,
0.3078087270259857,
-0.4740632176399231,
0.45062917470932007,
0.5383585095405579,
0.45407792925834656,
0.22115595638751984,
-1.3127028942108154,
0.21111181378364563,
-0.5490698218345642,
-0.006269409786909819,
0.174730584025383,
-0.5437612533569336,
0.5978510975837708,
-0.3141542673110962,
0.05552954226732254,
-0.11826146394014359,
0.748550295829773,
0.522165834903717,
0.351227730512619,
0.4692586064338684,
0.606995701789856,
0.7833172678947449,
-0.31194618344306946,
1.2087610960006714,
-0.5966929197311401,
0.5978571772575378,
1.218667984008789,
0.1332690566778183,
0.9802702069282532,
0.825807511806488,
-0.2883860468864441,
0.3661578893661499,
0.43894144892692566,
-0.10469544678926468,
0.5261930823326111,
-0.0397535003721714,
-0.004463540855795145,
-0.32234376668930054,
-0.3291120231151581,
-0.6122560501098633,
0.40110254287719727,
-0.04151246324181557,
-0.6586439609527588,
-0.7631832957267761,
-0.39542919397354126,
0.09811929613351822,
0.4842556416988373,
-0.6695579290390015,
0.6376879811286926,
0.016712337732315063,
-0.722388505935669,
0.18808437883853912,
-0.44728943705558777,
0.2320534586906433,
-0.13347920775413513,
-0.5240128636360168,
-0.14664271473884583,
0.17346660792827606,
-0.28069958090782166,
-0.47666600346565247,
0.4022327959537506,
0.06883186846971512,
-0.6929931044578552,
-0.3303157389163971,
0.41447481513023376,
0.2722615599632263,
-0.3687969446182251,
0.06093325838446617,
0.41230905055999756,
0.45968273282051086,
-0.21918326616287231,
-0.294881671667099,
-0.25695866346359253,
-0.1519375592470169,
-0.24257731437683105,
0.3830445408821106,
0.27056628465652466,
-0.501908004283905,
0.10514746606349945,
0.5032665729522705,
0.0782795324921608,
-0.0074891760013997555,
0.3519165813922882,
0.8935507535934448,
-1.1937463283538818,
-0.6084531545639038,
-0.6440273523330688,
0.5625835061073303,
-0.5686407089233398,
-0.33219486474990845,
0.7665431499481201,
0.8927031755447388,
0.21072237193584442,
-0.17198818922042847,
0.8837234973907471,
-0.22364865243434906,
0.8901940584182739,
-0.44145873188972473,
0.766739010810852,
-0.3189886510372162,
0.27292656898498535,
-0.49899017810821533,
-1.0090471506118774,
-0.5679852366447449,
0.5279938578605652,
-0.5494152903556824,
0.09967038780450821,
0.640509843826294,
0.5441217422485352,
0.06717406213283539,
0.1620974987745285,
0.19121964275836945,
-0.09359589964151382,
0.030116619542241096,
0.5233848094940186,
0.5151360034942627,
-0.5569902062416077,
0.4230881333351135,
0.29820361733436584,
-0.1407301276922226,
-0.8164522051811218,
-0.9001753926277161,
-0.7994567155838013,
-0.6077033281326294,
-0.22417940199375153,
-0.2994391918182373,
-0.013179479166865349,
0.7366926074028015,
0.7213791608810425,
-1.5618999004364014,
-0.09537944197654724,
-0.029167480766773224,
0.20110072195529938,
-0.1608286201953888,
-0.19005249440670013,
1.0067598819732666,
-0.37405136227607727,
-0.9041920304298401,
0.2596117854118347,
0.439826637506485,
-0.39255890250205994,
0.2474716752767563,
0.1574670672416687,
-0.4947356581687927,
-0.06766488403081894,
0.681061327457428,
0.37195292115211487,
-0.9063911437988281,
-0.4746902287006378,
-0.8332484364509583,
-0.011080645956099033,
0.13628418743610382,
1.2825071811676025,
-0.7265452742576599,
0.5960333943367004,
0.6442162990570068,
0.2549697458744049,
0.48806455731391907,
0.48191410303115845,
0.5449625253677368,
-0.29616761207580566,
0.2125815898180008,
0.03745044022798538,
0.8603872656822205,
0.05046093836426735,
-0.10906378924846649,
0.7370324730873108,
0.4413526654243469,
-0.3671875596046448,
-0.7905018329620361,
0.06967692077159882,
-1.5429906845092773,
-0.19514121115207672,
0.8863748908042908,
-0.31735965609550476,
-0.12825454771518707,
-0.3990132510662079,
-0.24513062834739685,
0.004552433732897043,
-0.5332598686218262,
0.8025004863739014,
0.641555666923523,
-0.34812816977500916,
0.3606570065021515,
-0.3998430669307709,
0.183766707777977,
0.3684559464454651,
-0.44967401027679443,
-0.2677890658378601,
0.6849512457847595,
0.318920373916626,
0.8671876788139343,
0.16979940235614777,
-0.6626192331314087,
0.32825082540512085,
0.09034212678670883,
-0.19513200223445892,
0.04461619257926941,
-0.15429918467998505,
-0.27129924297332764,
0.9104732275009155,
-0.1549171805381775,
-0.10897250473499298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10819v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10819v1
|
GUI-WORLD: A Dataset for GUI-oriented Multimodal LLM-based Agents
| 2024-06-16T06:56:53 | 2024-06-16T06:56:53 |
Dongping Chen, Yue Huang, Siyuan Wu, Jingyu Tang, Liuyi Chen, Yilin Bai, Zhigang He, Chenlong Wang, Huichi Zhou, Yiqiang Li, Tianshuo Zhou, Yue Yu, Chujie Gao, Qihui Zhang, Yi Gui, Zhen Li, Yao Wan, Pan Zhou, Jianfeng Gao, Lichao Sun
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recently, Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have been used as agents
to control keyboard and mouse inputs by directly perceiving the Graphical User
Interface (GUI) and generating corresponding code. However, current agents
primarily exhibit excellent understanding capabilities in static environments
and are predominantly applied in relatively simple domains, such as Web or
mobile interfaces. We argue that a robust GUI agent should be capable of
perceiving temporal information on the GUI, including dynamic Web content and
multi-step tasks. Additionally, it should possess a comprehensive understanding
of various GUI scenarios, including desktop software and multi-window
interactions. To this end, this paper introduces a new dataset, termed
GUI-World, which features meticulously crafted Human-MLLM annotations,
extensively covering six GUI scenarios and eight types of GUI-oriented
questions in three formats. We evaluate the capabilities of current
state-of-the-art MLLMs, including ImageLLMs and VideoLLMs, in understanding
various types of GUI content, especially dynamic and sequential content. Our
findings reveal that ImageLLMs struggle with dynamic GUI content without
manually annotated keyframes or operation history. On the other hand, VideoLLMs
fall short in all GUI-oriented tasks given the sparse GUI video dataset. Based
on GUI-World, we take the initial step of leveraging a fine-tuned VideoLLM as a
GUI agent, demonstrating an improved understanding of various GUI tasks.
However, due to the limitations in the performance of base LLMs, we conclude
that using VideoLLMs as GUI agents remains a significant challenge. We believe
our work provides valuable insights for future research in dynamic GUI content
understanding. The code and dataset are publicly available at our project
homepage: https://gui-world.github.io/.
|
[
-0.592318594455719,
-1.0584053993225098,
0.57619309425354,
0.04248923808336258,
0.18434129655361176,
0.3298310339450836,
-0.1811477094888687,
-0.29855334758758545,
-0.3718385696411133,
0.45917317271232605,
-0.6273594498634338,
-0.6393502354621887,
-0.3893034756183624,
0.1099352091550827,
-0.08107210695743561,
0.9254754185676575,
-0.14783930778503418,
-0.3492227792739868,
-0.4657469391822815,
-0.3703145980834961,
0.11662017554044724,
-0.3162029981613159,
-0.3974151611328125,
-0.2475094497203827,
0.9759339094161987,
0.2751522362232208,
0.8949648141860962,
0.23282194137573242,
0.22456419467926025,
0.3681703805923462,
0.16969718039035797,
0.4742928743362427,
-0.5174793601036072,
0.3340589106082916,
0.05549309775233269,
-0.1437113732099533,
-0.6795232892036438,
-0.07093241065740585,
0.4735059142112732,
0.3534288704395294,
0.25001153349876404,
0.1913459748029709,
0.006982062477618456,
0.23528583347797394,
-0.5273686647415161,
0.46291249990463257,
-0.3838505744934082,
0.21081697940826416,
0.1653348207473755,
-0.06841842085123062,
-0.39712196588516235,
0.06621024012565613,
0.09055255353450775,
-1.0187890529632568,
0.06521777808666229,
0.06526998430490494,
0.6659591794013977,
0.18876050412654877,
-0.9049409031867981,
0.139851376414299,
-0.5852283835411072,
0.6924526691436768,
-0.3075992465019226,
0.4376075565814972,
0.145936518907547,
0.5530117154121399,
-0.5043216347694397,
-0.5033887624740601,
-0.5451347231864929,
-0.3056524693965912,
0.062495242804288864,
-0.007483005523681641,
0.05484151467680931,
0.21116076409816742,
0.6563738584518433,
-0.18457789719104767,
-0.8790302276611328,
0.18086600303649902,
0.23285344243049622,
-0.29089340567588806,
0.5403492450714111,
0.3361600935459137,
0.5145898461341858,
-0.07372510433197021,
-0.3190596401691437,
-0.08584543317556381,
-0.5745086073875427,
-0.011634988710284233,
0.1875860095024109,
-0.08111843466758728,
-0.4320891797542572,
0.405398428440094,
-0.10924211144447327,
0.8594275116920471,
-0.37436333298683167,
-0.7692285776138306,
0.15227989852428436,
-0.060938622802495956,
-0.18166431784629822,
-0.4416588544845581,
0.528456449508667,
0.3850540816783905,
0.3384079039096832,
-0.21668265759944916,
-0.27999839186668396,
-0.1707918792963028,
0.02315959706902504,
-0.6513709425926208,
-0.10700909793376923,
0.24014966189861298,
-0.548747181892395,
-0.1710575968027115,
0.04548084735870361,
-0.4767483174800873,
-0.6271543502807617,
-0.44788241386413574,
0.36908748745918274,
-0.22703012824058533,
-0.3584449887275696,
-0.38670065999031067,
-0.27642378211021423,
0.26704156398773193,
0.9218759536743164,
-0.4595281183719635,
0.28735360503196716,
0.45934373140335083,
0.8495661020278931,
-0.3805709481239319,
-0.4157519042491913,
-0.7697790265083313,
0.47365185618400574,
0.06728751212358475,
0.6847660541534424,
-0.4660688638687134,
-0.19847077131271362,
-0.03530839458107948,
0.3380253314971924,
0.220552459359169,
-0.24242356419563293,
-0.07634277641773224,
-0.6090296506881714,
-0.11132922768592834,
0.07769345492124557,
-0.2988913357257843,
-0.3512192964553833,
0.5946412086486816,
-0.9961872100830078,
0.6736831665039062,
0.16491766273975372,
-0.6566342115402222,
0.31469014286994934,
-0.6169220805168152,
-0.30832821130752563,
-0.14525443315505981,
-0.19249588251113892,
-0.38107621669769287,
0.00394195644184947,
0.2819952964782715,
0.4484241008758545,
0.07928760349750519,
0.2984004318714142,
-0.706288754940033,
-0.41209301352500916,
0.6633669137954712,
-0.8804994821548462,
0.5561028122901917,
0.3548373281955719,
-0.07592995464801788,
0.07237336039543152,
-0.8082854151725769,
-0.008131912909448147,
-0.08379857242107391,
-0.22158583998680115,
-0.18369342386722565,
0.00011267858644714579,
0.5582895278930664,
0.37595948576927185,
0.2573876678943634,
-0.5440871119499207,
0.48340412974357605,
0.39025816321372986,
0.25003623962402344,
0.8865036964416504,
-0.19696800410747528,
0.1906295120716095,
-0.1886201649904251,
0.607995331287384,
-0.013829142786562443,
0.3367834985256195,
-0.31905025243759155,
-0.32475998997688293,
-0.3379189074039459,
-0.23715123534202576,
0.04309328645467758,
0.4974803626537323,
-1.1270197629928589,
-0.20698755979537964,
-0.2717967927455902,
-0.15748029947280884,
0.18254007399082184,
0.1357828974723816,
0.22334061563014984,
0.21607767045497894,
0.08576934039592743,
-0.07089898735284805,
-0.44030871987342834,
-0.7552094459533691,
0.1948307901620865,
-0.14359016716480255,
0.008291994221508503,
0.5787048935890198,
0.5452977418899536,
-0.39553266763687134,
0.9552053809165955,
-0.3969336748123169,
-0.07435107231140137,
-0.34955278038978577,
0.27840155363082886,
0.1464988887310028,
0.1992826610803604,
0.4408259391784668,
-1.0121933221817017,
-0.5513111352920532,
0.19502608478069305,
-1.1513941287994385,
-0.0923716276884079,
-0.30053678154945374,
-0.07112918049097061,
0.13341446220874786,
0.3309679329395294,
-0.4415477514266968,
0.4116353392601013,
0.6861373782157898,
-0.1450468748807907,
0.5954402685165405,
-0.3941402733325958,
0.13498646020889282,
-0.7620050311088562,
0.02044309489428997,
0.19120486080646515,
-0.5596873760223389,
-0.517406165599823,
-0.15933074057102203,
0.03532431647181511,
-0.25349506735801697,
-0.5876467823982239,
0.8929736018180847,
-0.7133828401565552,
-0.4568992555141449,
-0.3890175521373749,
0.13488826155662537,
0.05262549966573715,
0.7026808261871338,
0.24629849195480347,
0.7477965354919434,
0.5067519545555115,
-0.5057045817375183,
0.80775386095047,
0.09178552776575089,
-0.34052330255508423,
0.49262741208076477,
-0.2671940326690674,
0.06000799313187599,
-0.2427651584148407,
0.3890169560909271,
-0.670263946056366,
-0.38343197107315063,
0.02184353955090046,
-0.23468293249607086,
0.3435901701450348,
-0.3141617178916931,
-0.5818101763725281,
-0.22410047054290771,
-0.20858748257160187,
0.18902239203453064,
0.2644384503364563,
-0.34112831950187683,
0.5164122581481934,
0.3747454881668091,
-0.1058812215924263,
-0.6831231117248535,
-0.3529159724712372,
0.4357104003429413,
-0.21406304836273193,
-0.6443400382995605,
0.2094796895980835,
0.021550970152020454,
-0.5113442540168762,
0.00891377218067646,
-0.06114737689495087,
-0.161161869764328,
0.25368377566337585,
0.48859187960624695,
0.16419866681098938,
-0.013483460061252117,
0.10247203707695007,
-0.07684770971536636,
-0.09750614315271378,
-0.09736849367618561,
-0.21727314591407776,
0.04280725494027138,
0.08444222062826157,
-0.38725900650024414,
-0.2712740898132324,
0.3475492298603058,
0.7116643190383911,
0.09937941282987595,
0.3896434009075165,
0.9867612719535828,
-0.2301025539636612,
-0.15439888834953308,
-0.41616782546043396,
-0.024373279884457588,
-0.4656778573989868,
0.5605602860450745,
-0.631375789642334,
-0.7213691473007202,
0.510545015335083,
-0.16117440164089203,
0.16117152571678162,
-0.13126495480537415,
0.5787057876586914,
-0.453396201133728,
1.2597090005874634,
0.5644323825836182,
-0.11754884570837021,
0.6889542937278748,
-0.42360568046569824,
-0.40853238105773926,
-0.6791354417800903,
-0.15666563808918,
-0.0011995674576610327,
-0.5724814534187317,
-0.6420185565948486,
-0.4095176160335541,
0.7244828343391418,
-0.5063756108283997,
-0.47060850262641907,
-0.11441358923912048,
0.04337967932224274,
0.272329181432724,
0.41046980023384094,
0.2623153626918793,
0.4213332235813141,
0.23901677131652832,
-0.1295074224472046,
0.04802006855607033,
-0.587364673614502,
-0.6716720461845398,
1.1163185834884644,
0.2519706189632416,
1.5668303966522217,
0.22511792182922363,
0.1405932754278183,
0.7696829438209534,
0.2102193385362625,
-0.49449488520622253,
0.6237471103668213,
0.04099612310528755,
-0.45166030526161194,
-0.37943771481513977,
-0.2288305163383484,
-1.0106310844421387,
0.37015530467033386,
-0.04545800760388374,
-0.6934263706207275,
-0.17421016097068787,
-0.030060311779379845,
-0.1537875533103943,
0.4354165196418762,
-0.4679621160030365,
1.002414584159851,
-0.5952854156494141,
-0.7899538278579712,
0.021074993535876274,
-0.7503084540367126,
0.26068174839019775,
0.2964051365852356,
0.23619048297405243,
-0.36168476939201355,
-0.3173682987689972,
0.2220350056886673,
-0.34799787402153015,
0.7876163721084595,
-0.3666277527809143,
-0.39406177401542664,
0.2156977355480194,
0.16478481888771057,
0.5309884548187256,
0.5204517841339111,
0.19902290403842926,
-0.13083139061927795,
0.01975214295089245,
-0.3463568687438965,
-0.9305582046508789,
0.7195555567741394,
-1.040273904800415,
-0.6034793853759766,
-0.5715651512145996,
-0.7844716310501099,
-0.2905629575252533,
-0.10264868289232254,
-0.24473854899406433,
0.8388015627861023,
-0.32194042205810547,
0.14629438519477844,
0.7514470815658569,
-0.42156440019607544,
0.4532109797000885,
0.7101693749427795,
-0.398576945066452,
-0.15645723044872284,
1.028475284576416,
-0.11310115456581116,
0.20030352473258972,
0.7075660228729248,
-0.36923784017562866,
-0.2972475290298462,
-0.30345916748046875,
-0.7280844449996948,
-0.003103929804638028,
-0.4979487955570221,
-0.03140698000788689,
-0.645060658454895,
-0.1270262449979782,
-0.13499271869659424,
-0.011058900505304337,
0.1897939145565033,
-0.19213491678237915,
-0.3471287190914154,
0.06982896476984024,
0.3813576400279999,
0.6808808445930481,
-0.008668098598718643,
0.05224490910768509,
-0.882699728012085,
0.5492126941680908,
0.5499458909034729,
0.1308469921350479,
-0.13221530616283417,
-0.19648845493793488,
-0.41270971298217773,
0.16712673008441925,
-0.496277391910553,
-0.8045125603675842,
0.3899018466472626,
0.4029233455657959,
0.7894914746284485,
0.5120739340782166,
-0.09358864277601242,
0.6657845377922058,
-0.3981209099292755,
0.7674468755722046,
-0.11921843141317368,
-0.5712186098098755,
0.5466650724411011,
-0.44085803627967834,
0.44500213861465454,
0.045210372656583786,
0.2401619702577591,
-0.8408024311065674,
-0.45913127064704895,
-0.29602575302124023,
-0.23972591757774353,
0.7390095591545105,
0.1279193013906479,
0.03230965882539749,
0.4093000292778015,
0.13206425309181213,
0.48539701104164124,
0.10921254009008408,
-0.7274223566055298,
-0.06106236204504967,
-0.20945197343826294,
-0.10497238487005234,
-0.1596669703722,
-0.016108721494674683,
-0.04147610068321228,
-0.011968173086643219,
0.3575924038887024,
-0.6335926055908203,
0.40849947929382324,
-0.04840781167149544,
-0.8331950306892395,
0.06462952494621277,
0.3018510639667511,
0.4271078109741211,
0.7734731435775757,
-0.2945594787597656,
0.35377272963523865,
0.12438753247261047,
-0.5604172348976135,
0.6247526407241821,
0.028578737750649452,
-0.11330326646566391,
-0.08340383321046829,
0.5234189629554749,
0.9055013656616211,
0.1729402095079422,
-1.0057058334350586,
0.36975598335266113,
-0.19781041145324707,
-0.06330135464668274,
-0.30736151337623596,
0.19443996250629425,
-0.2926233112812042,
0.345456063747406,
0.3032369315624237,
-0.32944250106811523,
0.09566284716129303,
-0.6221670508384705,
0.24657109379768372,
0.4854872524738312,
-0.3575746715068817,
-0.5441356897354126,
0.6646089553833008,
0.31686484813690186,
0.12603376805782318,
0.7652323842048645,
-0.17696966230869293,
-0.3376425504684448,
0.8865442872047424,
0.424190878868103,
0.6806631088256836,
0.32551684975624084,
0.46724453568458557,
-0.032739315181970596,
0.025746574625372887,
0.3582623600959778,
0.39963626861572266,
-0.3211214244365692,
-0.7310967445373535,
-0.4281483292579651,
-0.39398109912872314,
-0.5221226215362549,
0.13036930561065674,
-0.372220516204834,
0.19689249992370605,
-0.20161734521389008,
-0.30529168248176575,
-0.37592485547065735,
0.19057495892047882,
-0.8079811334609985,
0.22312502562999725,
0.4049080014228821,
0.7784886360168457,
-0.5519785284996033,
1.1038113832473755,
0.9659730792045593,
-0.23478136956691742,
-0.06163142994046211,
-0.15036079287528992,
0.2798176407814026,
-0.6780093312263489,
0.8601016998291016,
0.12102030962705612,
0.11723069846630096,
-0.2558484971523285,
-0.5467525124549866,
-0.7873724102973938,
1.2534141540527344,
0.20902228355407715,
-0.485640287399292,
-0.2688705325126648,
0.12815171480178833,
0.3736901879310608,
-0.27052345871925354,
0.5596418380737305,
0.19182723760604858,
0.7247341275215149,
-0.06687906384468079,
-0.7971329092979431,
-0.10122348368167877,
-0.3315180242061615,
0.11274568736553192,
-0.08615660667419434,
-0.640081524848938,
0.7941109538078308,
-0.43892550468444824,
0.0725061446428299,
0.0934949442744255,
0.5353701710700989,
0.12501206994056702,
0.5000316500663757,
0.5919573903083801,
0.3007211685180664,
0.32305908203125,
-0.08477863669395447,
0.8380013704299927,
-0.013300452381372452,
0.20435930788516998,
0.9184898138046265,
-0.33588793873786926,
0.3320099413394928,
0.23043589293956757,
-0.3451506197452545,
0.5363061428070068,
0.773048460483551,
0.06546492874622345,
0.3696841299533844,
0.174331933259964,
-0.44780927896499634,
-0.46883097290992737,
-0.0482310988008976,
-0.24042043089866638,
0.5171423554420471,
0.6458703875541687,
-0.07132873684167862,
-0.3541853129863739,
0.6514824628829956,
-0.11943908780813217,
-0.30768609046936035,
-0.2342994213104248,
0.965904176235199,
-0.05655615031719208,
-0.35750988125801086,
0.27835386991500854,
-0.18916107714176178,
0.4985671639442444,
-0.6770928502082825,
-0.14844371378421783,
-0.2959914803504944,
-0.04227496683597565,
-0.14880326390266418,
-0.9123358130455017,
-0.18258266150951385,
0.20732522010803223,
0.0001363274932373315,
-0.35192468762397766,
0.825398325920105,
-0.41703492403030396,
-0.24996787309646606,
-0.027546826750040054,
0.7897083759307861,
0.24199004471302032,
-0.17114120721817017,
-0.6943105459213257,
0.33865490555763245,
-0.18054544925689697,
-0.357308954000473,
0.5932090878486633,
0.6696856617927551,
-0.4117456078529358,
0.9671593308448792,
0.3116184175014496,
-0.15582780539989471,
-0.1703164428472519,
0.12707176804542542,
0.6717470288276672,
-0.6787557601928711,
-0.24956801533699036,
-0.5658114552497864,
0.2818535566329956,
-0.20225609838962555,
0.08328099548816681,
0.849571943283081,
0.6152927875518799,
0.5595683455467224,
-0.033801354467868805,
1.2269128561019897,
-0.14253948628902435,
-0.05352087691426277,
-0.43652820587158203,
0.5348175764083862,
-0.9583255648612976,
-0.021033473312854767,
-0.28337162733078003,
-0.8718160390853882,
-0.16674362123012543,
0.31314095854759216,
-0.059587497264146805,
0.061358608305454254,
0.3485943377017975,
0.8547044992446899,
-0.14827986061573029,
-0.0957827940583229,
0.694770097732544,
0.2289910614490509,
0.5210052132606506,
0.7168677449226379,
1.1143200397491455,
-0.06439927965402603,
0.7177771925926208,
-0.06045220419764519,
-0.1744256615638733,
-0.3768797814846039,
-0.7908040285110474,
-0.7925427556037903,
-0.5738164186477661,
-0.26284417510032654,
-0.1827835589647293,
0.27061668038368225,
0.8279966115951538,
0.7064632177352905,
-0.5702916383743286,
-0.32024988532066345,
0.2743209898471832,
0.5464224815368652,
-0.4189412295818329,
-0.1711229532957077,
0.1148390918970108,
-0.22255761921405792,
-0.895906925201416,
0.13303552567958832,
0.531690239906311,
0.2501470744609833,
-0.7639031410217285,
-0.3351587951183319,
-0.026171308010816574,
-0.3221615254878998,
0.9653392434120178,
0.3405698835849762,
-0.8158748149871826,
-0.4006446301937103,
0.10465036332607269,
-0.27897852659225464,
0.03397352620959282,
0.9692760109901428,
-1.0713701248168945,
0.6643819808959961,
0.40315914154052734,
0.21930696070194244,
0.6912923455238342,
-0.06055304780602455,
0.5097901225090027,
-0.7306680679321289,
0.32075706124305725,
0.015804370865225792,
0.36850324273109436,
0.21251660585403442,
-0.1411048024892807,
0.3972330689430237,
0.2697168290615082,
-0.41431891918182373,
-0.47775763273239136,
0.27423104643821716,
-1.1344290971755981,
-0.4661615788936615,
1.296090006828308,
-0.34027835726737976,
-0.42482465505599976,
-0.5896193385124207,
-0.6075778603553772,
0.010265449061989784,
-0.4687022864818573,
0.41613298654556274,
0.528471827507019,
-0.34558695554733276,
-0.4763083755970001,
-0.5736662149429321,
0.3341302275657654,
-0.32525163888931274,
-0.9549895524978638,
-0.011124852113425732,
0.8739288449287415,
0.16383351385593414,
-0.2810942232608795,
0.45596471428871155,
0.2268138974905014,
0.32046863436698914,
0.044428322464227676,
-0.03290858864784241,
-0.3984640836715698,
-0.4666164815425873,
0.05835371091961861,
0.21547822654247284,
-0.05744108557701111,
0.013010900467634201
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10813v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10813v1
|
Self-Evolution Fine-Tuning for Policy Optimization
| 2024-06-16T06:38:02 | 2024-06-16T06:38:02 |
Ruijun Chen, Jiehao Liang, Shiping Gao, Fanqi Wan, Xiaojun Quan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The alignment of large language models (LLMs) is crucial not only for
unlocking their potential in specific tasks but also for ensuring that
responses meet human expectations and adhere to safety and ethical principles.
Current alignment methodologies face considerable challenges. For instance,
supervised fine-tuning (SFT) requires extensive, high-quality annotated
samples, while reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) is complex and
often unstable. In this paper, we introduce self-evolution fine-tuning (SEFT)
for policy optimization, with the aim of eliminating the need for annotated
samples while retaining the stability and efficiency of SFT. SEFT first trains
an adaptive reviser to elevate low-quality responses while maintaining
high-quality ones. The reviser then gradually guides the policy's optimization
by fine-tuning it with enhanced responses. One of the prominent features of
this method is its ability to leverage unlimited amounts of unannotated data
for policy optimization through supervised fine-tuning. Our experiments on
AlpacaEval 2.0 and MT-Bench demonstrate the effectiveness of SEFT. We also
provide a comprehensive analysis of its advantages over existing alignment
techniques.
|
[
-0.5356277823448181,
-0.7970322370529175,
0.3700215816497803,
0.08478862792253494,
-0.23997624218463898,
0.09191160649061203,
-0.5017816424369812,
-0.15949225425720215,
0.12350964546203613,
0.7702705264091492,
-1.0055480003356934,
-0.08728144317865372,
-0.2506156265735626,
0.014156168326735497,
-0.03066803142428398,
1.1423763036727905,
0.03093055821955204,
-0.20357085764408112,
0.03713591769337654,
-0.25349023938179016,
-0.35345327854156494,
0.07933545112609863,
-0.8198958039283752,
-0.5267316102981567,
0.42278429865837097,
0.42214664816856384,
0.8843545913696289,
1.156514048576355,
0.2957799434661865,
0.30532118678092957,
0.07705778628587723,
0.6042300462722778,
-0.5739833116531372,
0.1093151643872261,
-0.5402601957321167,
0.050871722400188446,
-0.23504193127155304,
-0.2760455310344696,
0.4251904785633087,
0.30413511395454407,
-0.40976208448410034,
0.05209536850452423,
0.2848869264125824,
0.6506586074829102,
-0.6137517094612122,
-0.032582662999629974,
-0.632182776927948,
-0.13194090127944946,
0.07623344659805298,
-0.47986674308776855,
0.03019622527062893,
-0.5215825438499451,
0.14841622114181519,
-0.7638413906097412,
-0.011863199062645435,
-0.005298668053001165,
0.9051300883293152,
0.7159191966056824,
-0.2677485942840576,
-0.18437254428863525,
-0.6214234828948975,
0.7285533547401428,
-0.8061206340789795,
0.2293156087398529,
0.19697508215904236,
0.09472663700580597,
-0.6118277311325073,
-0.174266517162323,
-0.5755711793899536,
-0.014433125033974648,
0.037684690207242966,
0.09131139516830444,
0.04297421872615814,
0.3315503001213074,
-0.14501705765724182,
0.06035207211971283,
-0.540537416934967,
0.7966726422309875,
-0.17445601522922516,
-0.21884530782699585,
0.832973062992096,
0.0447678342461586,
-0.0958825871348381,
0.1046816036105156,
-0.3902687430381775,
-0.38894134759902954,
-0.6334258317947388,
0.10680977255105972,
0.5116547346115112,
0.7333309650421143,
0.09492660313844681,
0.31341007351875305,
-0.4943044185638428,
0.5204497575759888,
0.30086931586265564,
-0.0844508707523346,
0.28202950954437256,
-0.16063423454761505,
-0.21498849987983704,
0.13197824358940125,
0.9497432708740234,
0.2670080363750458,
0.20814961194992065,
0.03400973975658417,
-0.3184243440628052,
-0.1375660002231598,
0.3346976935863495,
-0.6054543256759644,
-0.1501602828502655,
0.2274979054927826,
-0.1324203908443451,
-0.653572142124176,
-0.37101492285728455,
-1.069090723991394,
-0.4003961682319641,
-0.5894593000411987,
0.6820055842399597,
-0.15965203940868378,
-0.04832519218325615,
0.26574549078941345,
0.29795321822166443,
0.37613046169281006,
0.30495619773864746,
-1.2737468481063843,
0.16392093896865845,
0.7361218333244324,
0.3042745888233185,
-0.26437926292419434,
-0.4598994851112366,
-0.6385931372642517,
0.1449795514345169,
-0.43471723794937134,
0.7454898953437805,
-0.337144136428833,
-0.2484133243560791,
0.15018557012081146,
0.1978607326745987,
0.03201451525092125,
-0.32113268971443176,
0.6791794896125793,
-0.29689285159111023,
0.1690356731414795,
-0.15586429834365845,
-0.3057287335395813,
-0.056516844779253006,
0.19133217632770538,
-0.3681802749633789,
1.0763862133026123,
0.034625452011823654,
-0.12297306209802628,
0.42713168263435364,
-0.8081792593002319,
-0.543265700340271,
-0.2425626516342163,
-0.2844258248806,
-0.7830466628074646,
0.1867114007472992,
0.5862194299697876,
0.29817092418670654,
-0.16617271304130554,
0.39122819900512695,
-0.5036649703979492,
-0.15813857316970825,
0.05069487541913986,
-0.4589149057865143,
0.501011848449707,
0.43668559193611145,
-0.4876255989074707,
0.3322732448577881,
-0.6623429656028748,
0.1326075792312622,
0.12419188767671585,
-0.360943466424942,
-0.0916103720664978,
0.18664929270744324,
-0.23728565871715546,
0.20125174522399902,
0.3514077663421631,
-0.39012840390205383,
0.5468400716781616,
-0.5078524947166443,
0.5505368709564209,
1.113319993019104,
0.14910897612571716,
0.5120425820350647,
-0.31014975905418396,
0.4062391221523285,
-0.23183326423168182,
0.3633149266242981,
-0.0037203337997198105,
0.26715347170829773,
-0.6475721001625061,
0.004356231074780226,
0.4487728476524353,
0.3895540237426758,
-0.25804567337036133,
0.6505088806152344,
-0.2850245535373688,
-0.3691447377204895,
-0.8780012726783752,
0.3733174800872803,
0.3326815366744995,
0.431640625,
0.5023100972175598,
-0.0453486330807209,
-0.23746803402900696,
-1.0522704124450684,
-0.30554428696632385,
-0.026023615151643753,
0.43164607882499695,
0.29012778401374817,
0.27313825488090515,
-0.43550756573677063,
0.8686729073524475,
-0.34822309017181396,
-0.24231383204460144,
0.1560303121805191,
0.3302060663700104,
-0.09283236414194107,
0.714504599571228,
0.343340128660202,
-0.3171437978744507,
-0.020650234073400497,
0.17594929039478302,
-0.31046152114868164,
-0.4302661418914795,
-0.4906952977180481,
-0.2182920277118683,
0.3173726499080658,
0.5271162986755371,
-0.2310405969619751,
-0.053209755569696426,
0.5921190977096558,
-0.026353487744927406,
0.23281802237033844,
-0.5009804368019104,
-0.031855206936597824,
-0.7349304556846619,
-0.2081555873155594,
-0.17383511364459991,
-0.37221211194992065,
-0.36052337288856506,
0.06740284711122513,
0.24051006138324738,
0.09026504307985306,
-0.1535850614309311,
0.49862492084503174,
-0.27537059783935547,
0.13477946817874908,
-0.4046718180179596,
0.03471239283680916,
-0.12334435433149338,
0.6335959434509277,
-0.044992681592702866,
0.9976810812950134,
0.24028775095939636,
-0.5559371113777161,
-0.08211426436901093,
0.2537558972835541,
-0.09758806973695755,
0.27635428309440613,
-0.4311923384666443,
0.18846328556537628,
-0.16405393183231354,
-0.06398002058267593,
-0.6849257946014404,
-0.2496335357427597,
0.0693773701786995,
0.004558207001537085,
0.5201964974403381,
-0.027733419090509415,
-0.2361636459827423,
-0.20282213389873505,
-0.3826950788497925,
0.007245674729347229,
0.37832796573638916,
-0.7718379497528076,
0.5024381875991821,
0.35963892936706543,
-0.07341472059488297,
-0.7782655954360962,
-0.36942538619041443,
-0.24859729409217834,
-0.4408313035964966,
-0.17759402096271515,
0.2297176718711853,
0.10883933305740356,
0.22161650657653809,
-0.24063539505004883,
-0.325374960899353,
0.3693981170654297,
0.2714865803718567,
-0.01672275736927986,
0.038180384784936905,
-0.06610243767499924,
0.1363736242055893,
0.6316794753074646,
-0.1258232146501541,
-0.24802939593791962,
-0.37469205260276794,
0.5104119181632996,
-0.12664106488227844,
-0.3250514268875122,
-0.3825864791870117,
-0.06860622018575668,
0.3755975067615509,
-0.35661810636520386,
0.36346280574798584,
0.5477524399757385,
-0.05704071372747421,
-0.2680482268333435,
-0.6200277805328369,
-0.2062806338071823,
-0.5960216522216797,
0.3721807897090912,
-0.26184138655662537,
-1.1686440706253052,
0.20770348608493805,
-0.5333844423294067,
0.36043527722358704,
0.4734766185283661,
0.43973320722579956,
-0.32427090406417847,
1.0421714782714844,
0.4893230199813843,
-0.19817377626895905,
0.5202978849411011,
0.006945721339434385,
0.07938116043806076,
-0.7591496109962463,
0.06409837305545807,
-0.5673849582672119,
-0.35698196291923523,
-1.0002284049987793,
-0.08043935149908066,
0.06161848455667496,
0.33417877554893494,
-0.7099865674972534,
0.4611169397830963,
-0.6695824265480042,
0.6616872549057007,
0.3639504909515381,
0.0270142313092947,
0.09279832243919373,
-0.09288939088582993,
0.20132656395435333,
0.1234353706240654,
-0.4338226616382599,
-0.4386502206325531,
0.9734264016151428,
0.5008714199066162,
1.1390485763549805,
0.094023197889328,
1.034525990486145,
0.27691343426704407,
-0.063162662088871,
-0.45383962988853455,
0.3515867292881012,
-0.2262466847896576,
-0.2616308033466339,
-0.7681538462638855,
-0.32439154386520386,
-1.0627886056900024,
0.29535606503486633,
-0.372533917427063,
-0.7309688925743103,
0.419102281332016,
0.451614648103714,
-0.6171113848686218,
-0.2656037211418152,
-0.4879118502140045,
0.9688563346862793,
-0.7582172751426697,
-0.30789247155189514,
-0.32321298122406006,
-0.6013588905334473,
-0.02709786407649517,
-0.3198179602622986,
0.18803931772708893,
-0.48331746459007263,
-0.0699114054441452,
0.5380727648735046,
-0.26070573925971985,
0.7040061950683594,
-0.260648250579834,
-0.18231958150863647,
0.045050039887428284,
0.12374106049537659,
0.8576937317848206,
-0.05514869466423988,
0.05731635168194771,
-0.139344722032547,
0.23532819747924805,
-0.27696874737739563,
-0.48638832569122314,
0.800207793712616,
-0.9718085527420044,
-0.7250089645385742,
-0.25216585397720337,
-0.43875542283058167,
-0.42912089824676514,
0.378151535987854,
-0.0005335803143680096,
0.05584045872092247,
-0.17784100770950317,
0.1004420593380928,
0.6906482577323914,
-0.1824284791946411,
0.37551599740982056,
0.6267508268356323,
-0.2799236476421356,
-0.3974957764148712,
0.9048186540603638,
-0.03835976496338844,
0.41819730401039124,
0.18468618392944336,
0.5130341649055481,
-0.5664713382720947,
-0.578835666179657,
-0.3974801301956177,
0.21225924789905548,
-0.3978089392185211,
-0.5092537999153137,
-0.3667984902858734,
-0.08584112673997879,
-0.4635591208934784,
-0.2551230788230896,
-0.5222955346107483,
-0.4535352289676666,
-0.32448601722717285,
-0.08424833416938782,
0.397784560918808,
0.4133850932121277,
-0.3882790207862854,
0.6556333899497986,
-0.2824728488922119,
0.05712190642952919,
0.28725364804267883,
0.283640056848526,
-0.4627622365951538,
-0.5654107928276062,
-0.003634486347436905,
0.16396303474903107,
-0.5348542332649231,
-0.5013747811317444,
0.20091798901557922,
0.5152255892753601,
0.37206944823265076,
0.55158931016922,
0.05305902287364006,
1.2005515098571777,
-0.4250841736793518,
0.35509058833122253,
-0.07624311000108719,
-0.7534550428390503,
0.6724789142608643,
-0.525058388710022,
0.18166528642177582,
1.0806142091751099,
-0.0473218597471714,
-0.23520877957344055,
-0.19645561277866364,
-0.3904436230659485,
-0.7068073749542236,
0.5307220220565796,
-0.11198832094669342,
0.37395134568214417,
0.05770587921142578,
0.5473321676254272,
0.17089132964611053,
0.129886656999588,
-0.5141235589981079,
0.144046351313591,
-0.12686875462532043,
-0.34232643246650696,
-0.051969610154628754,
0.018759792670607567,
-0.32186195254325867,
-0.2767437994480133,
0.9335778951644897,
-0.5731883645057678,
-0.04096834734082222,
-0.004602629691362381,
0.012025976553559303,
-0.4162778854370117,
0.44249773025512695,
0.7894113659858704,
0.3861748278141022,
-0.13252559304237366,
-0.09531885385513306,
0.5023263692855835,
-0.04514572396874428,
0.21157191693782806,
0.21080106496810913,
-0.2281952053308487,
-0.557111918926239,
-0.0860595554113388,
0.7871135473251343,
0.20491628348827362,
-0.6228752136230469,
0.4391309320926666,
0.18319004774093628,
-0.2120223194360733,
-0.25998207926750183,
0.500191867351532,
-0.192780539393425,
0.5690721869468689,
0.030776038765907288,
-0.14972755312919617,
0.0003490169474389404,
-0.31151342391967773,
0.16212496161460876,
0.7293717861175537,
-0.28615522384643555,
0.06416605412960052,
0.5950506329536438,
0.13359712064266205,
-0.28361502289772034,
0.41406476497650146,
-0.22911730408668518,
-0.35586512088775635,
0.3689795434474945,
0.7426788210868835,
0.7380933165550232,
-0.22434453666210175,
0.17797689139842987,
0.2608378827571869,
0.4485825002193451,
-0.29620838165283203,
0.25107675790786743,
-0.07826946675777435,
-0.7716580629348755,
-0.45651453733444214,
-0.895268440246582,
-0.32041823863983154,
0.28169625997543335,
-0.6642473340034485,
0.24438592791557312,
-0.5773398280143738,
-0.021892927587032318,
-0.132398322224617,
0.015434719622135162,
-0.5532747507095337,
0.10959732532501221,
-0.15183179080486298,
0.6638011932373047,
-0.8180691003799438,
0.8064697980880737,
0.2993471920490265,
-0.21362461149692535,
-0.7397996783256531,
-0.06699976325035095,
-0.007547244429588318,
-1.1877416372299194,
0.1697932481765747,
-0.07377651333808899,
-0.11090966314077377,
0.21973969042301178,
-0.5456318855285645,
-1.107692837715149,
1.0441200733184814,
0.4524984359741211,
-0.9341675639152527,
0.06296255439519882,
0.13284331560134888,
0.5958647131919861,
-0.27871307730674744,
-0.21326816082000732,
0.9635336399078369,
0.38281527161598206,
-0.21920329332351685,
-0.8779910802841187,
-0.0022240413818508387,
0.38208258152008057,
0.1763518899679184,
0.7079302668571472,
-0.8554489016532898,
0.1911613494157791,
-0.040753886103630066,
0.029757313430309296,
-0.015876010060310364,
0.7962206602096558,
0.12918874621391296,
-0.1451432704925537,
0.5549893379211426,
0.7592019438743591,
0.73194819688797,
-0.12971557676792145,
0.4418081045150757,
-0.22990119457244873,
0.5292866826057434,
1.4978262186050415,
-0.08533694595098495,
0.7652915120124817,
0.563973605632782,
-0.030284954234957695,
0.3082594871520996,
0.8231874704360962,
-0.29392167925834656,
0.768731951713562,
0.14086316525936127,
0.0864051952958107,
-0.2815793752670288,
-0.007715211249887943,
-0.10484916716814041,
0.5755116939544678,
0.3075690269470215,
-0.22944244742393494,
-0.3282805383205414,
-0.09203776717185974,
-0.02546149119734764,
0.02858106605708599,
-0.3088841438293457,
1.0498309135437012,
-0.2126522660255432,
-0.9191082715988159,
0.4484648108482361,
-0.13096734881401062,
0.4731086194515228,
-0.427511990070343,
0.051478151232004166,
-0.2222008854150772,
0.1570076048374176,
-0.19031094014644623,
-0.7555012106895447,
0.20607472956180573,
-0.275316447019577,
0.2546086609363556,
-0.2884193956851959,
0.582378625869751,
-0.5298662781715393,
-0.0882691815495491,
0.12606500089168549,
0.20591221749782562,
-0.07761096209287643,
0.3583565056324005,
-0.9842913746833801,
0.09193109720945358,
0.060428913682699203,
-0.35370945930480957,
0.46140164136886597,
0.2928980886936188,
-0.10697633028030396,
0.5866191387176514,
0.632480800151825,
0.1453360766172409,
-0.1209070235490799,
-0.021989239379763603,
0.669134795665741,
-0.49346640706062317,
-0.44831427931785583,
-0.9531049132347107,
0.2636772096157074,
0.02570020966231823,
-0.6410061717033386,
0.23775556683540344,
0.39105403423309326,
0.8412190675735474,
0.21351495385169983,
0.5994083881378174,
0.26923513412475586,
0.39425358176231384,
-0.5367637276649475,
0.4772418141365051,
-0.6564181447029114,
0.06249363347887993,
-0.10897552967071533,
-0.9268154501914978,
-0.0698981061577797,
0.7981088161468506,
-0.16508112847805023,
-0.13264474272727966,
0.1931210309267044,
0.9581508040428162,
-0.13876952230930328,
0.006280519533902407,
-0.0027654189616441727,
0.0387740284204483,
0.33511674404144287,
0.18558566272258759,
0.5509387850761414,
-0.16766661405563354,
0.4210023581981659,
-0.2600221633911133,
-0.07112975418567657,
-0.1135062649846077,
-0.9604501724243164,
-0.6839897036552429,
-0.46162301301956177,
-0.3723110854625702,
-0.3045550286769867,
0.23105770349502563,
1.4117132425308228,
0.6061111688613892,
-0.8660052418708801,
-0.1396898627281189,
-0.2512679398059845,
-0.33740729093551636,
-0.18146584928035736,
-0.1582820862531662,
0.4943326711654663,
-0.6991198062896729,
-0.4716040790081024,
0.48217809200286865,
0.44969505071640015,
0.25538361072540283,
-0.2816014289855957,
-0.26133015751838684,
-0.030330410227179527,
0.23681077361106873,
0.15129709243774414,
0.7807376980781555,
-0.8098815679550171,
-0.5938102602958679,
-0.24098262190818787,
-0.05495423451066017,
0.09847626090049744,
0.4402185082435608,
-0.6093682050704956,
0.5846028327941895,
0.10448017716407776,
1.1036971807479858,
0.5558236837387085,
0.2666475176811218,
0.4754187762737274,
-0.5495356321334839,
-0.24767300486564636,
0.15803177654743195,
0.3013024628162384,
0.1118755117058754,
-0.3507629632949829,
0.6438363194465637,
-0.4419209361076355,
-1.0271190404891968,
-0.8407590985298157,
0.2845342755317688,
-0.9038183689117432,
-0.17796237766742706,
1.018219232559204,
0.32052838802337646,
-0.24654319882392883,
0.12121985852718353,
-0.24210360646247864,
0.21035133302211761,
-0.5742544531822205,
1.0113414525985718,
0.4481261670589447,
-0.4832102358341217,
-0.3272038996219635,
-0.2750416398048401,
0.8489392399787903,
0.6874101161956787,
-0.9444117546081543,
0.2907617390155792,
0.34893351793289185,
0.26215216517448425,
-0.053578995168209076,
0.4209017753601074,
0.057593636214733124,
0.14244577288627625,
-0.5890474319458008,
-0.18374919891357422,
0.07678809762001038,
-0.20162883400917053,
-0.7757387161254883,
-0.2305777668952942,
0.3696206510066986,
-0.18729719519615173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10811v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10811v1
|
LLMFactor: Extracting Profitable Factors through Prompts for Explainable Stock Movement Prediction
| 2024-06-16T06:20:50 | 2024-06-16T06:20:50 |
Meiyun Wang, Kiyoshi Izumi, Hiroki Sakaji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CE
|
Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have attracted significant attention
for their exceptional performance across a broad range of tasks, particularly
in text analysis. However, the finance sector presents a distinct challenge due
to its dependence on time-series data for complex forecasting tasks. In this
study, we introduce a novel framework called LLMFactor, which employs
Sequential Knowledge-Guided Prompting (SKGP) to identify factors that influence
stock movements using LLMs. Unlike previous methods that relied on keyphrases
or sentiment analysis, this approach focuses on extracting factors more
directly related to stock market dynamics, providing clear explanations for
complex temporal changes. Our framework directs the LLMs to create background
knowledge through a fill-in-the-blank strategy and then discerns potential
factors affecting stock prices from related news. Guided by background
knowledge and identified factors, we leverage historical stock prices in
textual format to predict stock movement. An extensive evaluation of the
LLMFactor framework across four benchmark datasets from both the U.S. and
Chinese stock markets demonstrates its superiority over existing
state-of-the-art methods and its effectiveness in financial time-series
forecasting.
|
[
-0.005894477013498545,
-0.7106781601905823,
0.6985814571380615,
0.2474086582660675,
-0.24487631022930145,
0.40618425607681274,
0.34635061025619507,
-0.13668274879455566,
0.03897184506058693,
0.20725515484809875,
-1.0798131227493286,
-0.29738849401474,
-0.5553421378135681,
0.021698685362935066,
-0.6055440306663513,
0.7574842572212219,
-0.1446145623922348,
0.3365999460220337,
-0.013605188578367233,
0.22442997992038727,
-0.18800102174282074,
-0.5506132245063782,
-0.6857562065124512,
-0.6253467202186584,
0.557824969291687,
0.10115715116262436,
0.613616943359375,
0.713966429233551,
0.27487996220588684,
0.28881606459617615,
0.007816801778972149,
0.35186606645584106,
-0.23323294520378113,
0.16616056859493256,
0.04204918444156647,
-0.3854033648967743,
-0.1699715107679367,
0.03908706083893776,
0.26795968413352966,
0.6977266073226929,
-0.21269015967845917,
0.0829765647649765,
0.16075915098190308,
0.6042987704277039,
-0.18042303621768951,
0.49416401982307434,
-0.2833693027496338,
0.010419676080346107,
-0.44576287269592285,
-0.8244115710258484,
-0.3474331796169281,
-0.2922673523426056,
0.22473087906837463,
-0.6399455070495605,
0.2146124243736267,
0.47218114137649536,
0.8086004853248596,
0.10711245238780975,
-0.5478915572166443,
-0.29056447744369507,
-0.36941778659820557,
0.628002405166626,
-0.4913773536682129,
0.5983786582946777,
0.27822449803352356,
0.05642104148864746,
-0.42385703325271606,
-0.6936513781547546,
-0.5454952716827393,
-0.1931295245885849,
-0.07010592520236969,
-0.21852505207061768,
0.02949504554271698,
-0.32331129908561707,
0.34314629435539246,
0.25493738055229187,
-0.30908676981925964,
0.2053043097257614,
-0.35090798139572144,
-0.26260003447532654,
0.550944983959198,
0.3742421567440033,
0.2522917091846466,
0.029056712985038757,
-0.6082789897918701,
-0.0012102123582735658,
-0.8688031435012817,
0.3377102017402649,
0.2007748931646347,
0.24543285369873047,
-0.20670385658740997,
0.5866315364837646,
-0.12020385265350342,
0.4289475381374359,
0.38340234756469727,
-0.5320346355438232,
0.16492049396038055,
-0.2518085241317749,
-0.14478304982185364,
0.2028149664402008,
0.3728949725627899,
0.45742830634117126,
0.0802379623055458,
-0.0736183226108551,
-0.1830463856458664,
-0.21960213780403137,
-0.19461093842983246,
-0.9107834100723267,
-0.1660475730895996,
0.29245027899742126,
-0.5484554171562195,
-0.5165828466415405,
0.2583909034729004,
-0.9025058746337891,
-0.6871750354766846,
-0.39055636525154114,
0.340045690536499,
-0.2942534387111664,
-0.13128629326820374,
0.05597755312919617,
-0.2947908937931061,
0.65080326795578,
0.44112908840179443,
-0.7673768997192383,
-0.20146824419498444,
0.987212061882019,
0.8957359194755554,
-0.5448259115219116,
-0.298942893743515,
-1.0114727020263672,
0.28836682438850403,
-0.3831333816051483,
0.6729941368103027,
-0.4508798122406006,
-0.4992661476135254,
0.24015942215919495,
0.11740896850824356,
-0.061784107238054276,
-0.24222435057163239,
-0.03160194307565689,
-0.7724564671516418,
0.32447588443756104,
-0.6606366038322449,
-0.5861319899559021,
-0.5298998951911926,
0.0941125676035881,
-0.5397457480430603,
1.0672941207885742,
-0.0343577079474926,
-0.8054368495941162,
0.7549722790718079,
-0.8387377262115479,
-0.5565445423126221,
0.16630779206752777,
-0.3412569463253021,
0.018136855214834213,
-0.1685953140258789,
0.2769254744052887,
0.8625684976577759,
-0.40724411606788635,
0.4217970669269562,
-0.4208797216415405,
-0.1410495787858963,
0.8534964323043823,
-0.40439727902412415,
0.48288047313690186,
0.004555873107165098,
-0.34430357813835144,
0.1191651001572609,
-0.9069272875785828,
-0.5635834336280823,
0.15198317170143127,
-0.045840613543987274,
-0.34606215357780457,
0.3837526738643646,
-0.4071905314922333,
0.09467441588640213,
0.2395009845495224,
-0.27429115772247314,
0.28894853591918945,
-0.18749882280826569,
0.28503116965293884,
1.1309832334518433,
0.4149065613746643,
0.39427268505096436,
-0.3338456153869629,
0.9320599436759949,
0.15216661989688873,
-0.011924637481570244,
-0.409919798374176,
-0.07395345717668533,
-0.46019163727760315,
-0.3619026839733124,
0.1313248574733734,
0.5371003150939941,
-0.7443611025810242,
-0.20387497544288635,
-0.013036683201789856,
-0.12450658529996872,
0.07060091942548752,
0.34417039155960083,
-0.3744581639766693,
0.6746343970298767,
0.11282043159008026,
0.13786998391151428,
-0.3539593815803528,
-0.5761275291442871,
0.031866781413555145,
-0.19645866751670837,
-0.07530243694782257,
-0.026014484465122223,
0.04383038356900215,
-0.22777073085308075,
0.7666243314743042,
-0.9459313750267029,
0.04576483741402626,
-0.358203262090683,
0.4381939470767975,
0.5242362022399902,
0.008515916764736176,
0.4620322287082672,
-0.8089975118637085,
-0.11176258325576782,
-0.04680449888110161,
-0.4001380205154419,
-0.3767232596874237,
-0.57267826795578,
-0.26641884446144104,
0.12547938525676727,
1.084700584411621,
-0.5449893474578857,
0.37458908557891846,
0.46423202753067017,
-0.7632995843887329,
0.379313588142395,
0.3216862380504608,
-0.0979166254401207,
-1.0685644149780273,
0.1598217487335205,
0.3664659857749939,
-0.1317080855369568,
-0.4018420875072479,
-0.11704635620117188,
-0.2391238957643509,
0.11057749390602112,
-0.3467067778110504,
0.7277312278747559,
-0.22231140732765198,
-0.047448161989450455,
-0.21627271175384521,
0.20748616755008698,
-0.166682630777359,
0.4301173686981201,
-0.08616198599338531,
0.9570433497428894,
0.4539210796356201,
-0.9076494574546814,
0.1322457492351532,
0.1179816722869873,
-0.543023943901062,
0.045490093529224396,
-0.43817177414894104,
-0.33527156710624695,
0.039794061332941055,
-0.08032888174057007,
-1.2608805894851685,
-0.08784399926662445,
0.3194396197795868,
-0.2161247581243515,
0.26624351739883423,
-0.055047426372766495,
-0.33128732442855835,
-0.07918460667133331,
-0.14033626019954681,
-0.11288625746965408,
0.16412882506847382,
-0.6601355075836182,
1.0275572538375854,
-0.14122627675533295,
-0.6184182167053223,
-0.790611743927002,
-0.36633187532424927,
-0.2771822512149811,
-0.23630882799625397,
-0.46765199303627014,
0.15720854699611664,
-0.2784172594547272,
-0.49773523211479187,
-0.34859827160835266,
-0.485218346118927,
0.20090720057487488,
0.48100966215133667,
0.3780912756919861,
0.9053829312324524,
-0.08714668452739716,
0.18269655108451843,
-0.17187578976154327,
-0.31206753849983215,
0.3938932418823242,
-0.03881591185927391,
0.49249833822250366,
0.2441091537475586,
-0.09444626420736313,
-0.20213885605335236,
0.04878300428390503,
0.7510420083999634,
-0.09289077669382095,
0.5527655482292175,
0.5743926763534546,
0.13728117942810059,
-0.38246431946754456,
-0.41254720091819763,
-0.331121027469635,
-0.5799481868743896,
0.4179423749446869,
-0.06447640061378479,
-0.9244630336761475,
0.45569685101509094,
-0.4338896572589874,
0.2331206053495407,
0.5665744543075562,
0.6676868200302124,
-0.04102366790175438,
0.9294863343238831,
0.7581725120544434,
-0.10745687037706375,
0.5602821707725525,
0.031730398535728455,
0.38916969299316406,
-0.26955968141555786,
-0.3675883114337921,
-0.16341811418533325,
-0.3522651493549347,
-0.2809672951698303,
-0.39621126651763916,
0.17163275182247162,
0.019944336265325546,
-0.20066525042057037,
-0.12647591531276703,
0.19487811625003815,
0.18141166865825653,
0.43745654821395874,
-0.2512199580669403,
0.34505125880241394,
0.09708887338638306,
-0.5871840119361877,
0.17751473188400269,
-0.47271138429641724,
-0.11658579111099243,
0.9444978833198547,
0.5524552464485168,
1.0073494911193848,
0.055101919919252396,
0.3745570182800293,
0.5012920498847961,
0.5475033521652222,
-1.0222632884979248,
0.6874476075172424,
-0.15621721744537354,
-0.22629612684249878,
-0.14082901179790497,
-0.3238430917263031,
-0.38662800192832947,
-0.08293513208627701,
-0.3804774582386017,
-0.5307822823524475,
0.45297396183013916,
0.03683159127831459,
-0.4148999750614166,
-0.001301643904298544,
-0.3067121207714081,
0.3569757640361786,
-0.5916520953178406,
-0.3074130415916443,
-0.1102597638964653,
-0.10416975617408752,
0.2233421504497528,
-0.3930667042732239,
0.2262534648180008,
-0.36902713775634766,
-0.4318571388721466,
0.6955790519714355,
-0.6590237617492676,
0.8884009718894958,
-0.16999325156211853,
-0.299692302942276,
-0.10984650999307632,
0.17469482123851776,
0.7695063352584839,
0.06383731216192245,
-0.16337396204471588,
0.037892699241638184,
-0.17291750013828278,
0.0941847562789917,
-0.5418946146965027,
0.4797673225402832,
-0.42439308762550354,
-0.7606678009033203,
-0.6089313626289368,
-0.36611828207969666,
-0.37686458230018616,
-0.05440886691212654,
0.1551693230867386,
0.2198982685804367,
0.1170211136341095,
0.45891594886779785,
0.3781305253505707,
0.11309681832790375,
0.8304282426834106,
0.9419898390769958,
-0.5265859961509705,
-0.25292491912841797,
0.667125403881073,
0.12047053873538971,
-0.19264940917491913,
0.5633392333984375,
0.5424318909645081,
-0.5099624991416931,
-0.42628467082977295,
-0.07660258561372757,
0.15381506085395813,
-0.4722643196582794,
-0.15003752708435059,
-0.37972918152809143,
0.03809989616274834,
-0.2340434193611145,
-0.2388008087873459,
0.0037737342063337564,
-0.2253730595111847,
-0.5787464380264282,
-0.6021921038627625,
0.5479722023010254,
0.5794329643249512,
0.11742992699146271,
0.29784518480300903,
-0.7387399673461914,
0.28252893686294556,
0.6309893727302551,
0.23253418505191803,
0.06345696747303009,
-0.5101625323295593,
-0.3506809175014496,
-0.34860461950302124,
-0.35361018776893616,
-0.9201245903968811,
0.6106969118118286,
0.013611466623842716,
0.606328547000885,
0.8172335624694824,
0.15491744875907898,
0.65165776014328,
-0.19878363609313965,
0.8588477373123169,
0.15196429193019867,
-0.8810647130012512,
0.3178859055042267,
-0.29322367906570435,
0.16514961421489716,
0.1344713717699051,
0.7786263227462769,
-0.3698536157608032,
0.00010428662062622607,
-0.2329588681459427,
-0.9596669673919678,
0.5284473299980164,
-0.12441971898078918,
-0.30179688334465027,
0.04127265885472298,
0.5507960915565491,
0.3394394814968109,
0.39494240283966064,
-0.7150735259056091,
-0.28286391496658325,
-0.07338356226682663,
-0.12444049119949341,
-0.18436846137046814,
-0.4314528703689575,
-0.11537836492061615,
-0.05566251277923584,
0.8537622690200806,
-0.4007446765899658,
0.035287849605083466,
0.31899023056030273,
0.03249285742640495,
-0.21600449085235596,
0.06243187189102173,
0.5344643592834473,
0.9280440807342529,
-0.1679259091615677,
-0.3367938697338104,
-0.05225105956196785,
-0.3262907862663269,
0.07889169454574585,
0.5024810433387756,
-0.32645899057388306,
-0.0030389903113245964,
0.29426804184913635,
0.48457473516464233,
0.2495773583650589,
-0.6992971897125244,
0.5901830196380615,
0.01719444990158081,
-0.4735167324542999,
-0.5384023189544678,
0.1062079444527626,
-0.12089862674474716,
0.7965585589408875,
1.078050971031189,
-0.1903100311756134,
0.0973532423377037,
-0.36955201625823975,
0.31174808740615845,
0.14884629845619202,
-0.1845574527978897,
-0.29829832911491394,
0.7518634796142578,
0.20543308556079865,
0.23153585195541382,
0.3368856608867645,
0.11532668769359589,
-0.6261575222015381,
0.4708719253540039,
0.23932039737701416,
1.0526758432388306,
-0.09478048235177994,
0.26315146684646606,
0.13328295946121216,
0.0827500969171524,
-0.4574216902256012,
0.5234492421150208,
-0.0022272251080721617,
-0.8495532274246216,
-0.763218104839325,
-0.5640109777450562,
-0.47670286893844604,
0.37558045983314514,
-0.54734867811203,
0.448686420917511,
-0.7274855971336365,
-0.3603055477142334,
0.23602935671806335,
-0.17194165289402008,
-0.6631091833114624,
0.11618395894765854,
0.25438326597213745,
1.0201447010040283,
-0.6782374382019043,
0.5429142713546753,
0.5242433547973633,
-0.12622971832752228,
-0.7774717211723328,
0.2955417037010193,
0.3953680694103241,
-1.0295602083206177,
1.0078212022781372,
0.22333432734012604,
-0.10894203186035156,
-0.314932256937027,
-0.8268004059791565,
-0.9976909756660461,
1.3160346746444702,
0.07834552228450775,
-0.6777271032333374,
0.05239944905042648,
-0.26871517300605774,
-0.009781064465641975,
-0.5836176872253418,
-0.423397421836853,
0.3512839376926422,
0.46681588888168335,
0.4712789058685303,
-0.0319785475730896,
0.14412502944469452,
-0.18547479808330536,
-0.4337235391139984,
0.3402843475341797,
-0.6321412324905396,
0.672562837600708,
-0.31156039237976074,
-0.2815827429294586,
0.055389754474163055,
0.8694106936454773,
0.42258211970329285,
0.6332042217254639,
0.5295413136482239,
-0.043102435767650604,
0.8710297346115112,
-0.07268423587083817,
1.027002215385437,
-0.7510669231414795,
-0.06163064390420914,
0.9809030890464783,
-0.4630526602268219,
1.1133136749267578,
0.5340661406517029,
-0.16049373149871826,
0.8013901114463806,
0.6552850008010864,
-0.4373524487018585,
0.3573365807533264,
-0.035967495292425156,
-0.13637620210647583,
-0.6683855652809143,
0.014250848442316055,
-0.18551921844482422,
0.5892992615699768,
0.3954712450504303,
-0.6284576654434204,
0.24841724336147308,
-0.26780587434768677,
0.14162717759609222,
-0.5079118013381958,
-0.31553125381469727,
0.5109496712684631,
0.04573384299874306,
-0.4620935320854187,
-0.1923656016588211,
0.029476139694452286,
0.48836758732795715,
-1.1216801404953003,
0.005605860147625208,
-0.34101513028144836,
-0.035288549959659576,
0.009878521785140038,
-0.5367498397827148,
-0.19738633930683136,
-0.27166372537612915,
-0.0995180681347847,
-0.34733226895332336,
0.6686351299285889,
-0.32685908675193787,
-0.6230217218399048,
0.17902469635009766,
0.6486188769340515,
-0.35664594173431396,
0.11772678792476654,
-0.4929243326187134,
-0.3111429810523987,
0.2990211248397827,
-0.44536709785461426,
0.2188439667224884,
0.5096405744552612,
0.10543239116668701,
1.0146656036376953,
1.2270783185958862,
-0.10402901470661163,
-0.45022761821746826,
-0.04652515798807144,
0.7358352541923523,
-1.0782312154769897,
-0.6991897821426392,
-0.830663800239563,
0.3843703866004944,
0.1126956194639206,
-0.14431717991828918,
0.7585228085517883,
0.24618102610111237,
0.184428870677948,
-0.12970013916492462,
0.64217609167099,
0.4669860601425171,
0.6077280640602112,
-0.8856500387191772,
0.6118557453155518,
-0.5117480158805847,
0.6128206849098206,
-0.0029337003361433744,
-0.6309252977371216,
0.05001411959528923,
0.2906153202056885,
-0.253373384475708,
-0.12007201462984085,
0.7246676087379456,
0.7348366975784302,
0.3721132278442383,
0.26604321599006653,
0.17792220413684845,
0.6418439745903015,
0.13632832467556,
-0.24892792105674744,
0.625787079334259,
0.0700140967965126,
0.5054673552513123,
-0.13739371299743652,
-0.12474895268678665,
-0.4150906503200531,
-1.384546160697937,
-0.8167898058891296,
-0.4027004539966583,
-0.7206639051437378,
-0.26869434118270874,
-0.13943922519683838,
1.1880613565444946,
0.4156431555747986,
-0.6609460711479187,
-0.347451776266098,
0.3642605245113373,
0.07302117347717285,
-0.3649013638496399,
-0.3042989671230316,
0.4798992872238159,
-0.27371513843536377,
-0.21426188945770264,
0.6576802134513855,
0.34767448902130127,
0.43849003314971924,
-0.39392825961112976,
-0.03147191181778908,
0.0030643476638942957,
0.33771830797195435,
0.9326599836349487,
0.34201350808143616,
-0.4274783730506897,
0.007097288034856319,
0.28952258825302124,
0.2732986509799957,
-0.4207388460636139,
1.122490406036377,
-0.6196398735046387,
0.04145573452115059,
0.5035390257835388,
0.5776493549346924,
0.257547527551651,
0.2825855314731598,
0.9716612100601196,
-0.5902907252311707,
-0.06260355561971664,
-0.42566484212875366,
0.46723902225494385,
-0.009713547304272652,
-0.677345871925354,
0.6087557673454285,
0.5813322067260742,
-0.35606643557548523,
-0.30836376547813416,
-0.37208881974220276,
-0.9934128522872925,
-0.42262503504753113,
1.4306299686431885,
0.17294444143772125,
-0.2682245671749115,
-0.13495267927646637,
-0.014483043923974037,
-0.21170374751091003,
-0.7770636677742004,
0.5565905570983887,
0.8721961379051208,
-0.16564415395259857,
-0.47848230600357056,
-0.4639330208301544,
0.5246010422706604,
0.23930758237838745,
-0.3022499680519104,
0.32071593403816223,
0.5500558614730835,
0.3241941034793854,
-0.1510039120912552,
0.33878815174102783,
-0.0445345900952816,
0.20323742926120758,
-0.22905650734901428,
-0.39861559867858887,
-0.296216756105423,
-0.21681377291679382,
-0.1234816461801529,
0.47657278180122375,
-0.030351772904396057,
-0.11292935907840729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10809v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10809v1
|
Post-hoc Utterance Refining Method by Entity Mining for Faithful Knowledge Grounded Conversations
| 2024-06-16T06:12:47 | 2024-06-16T06:12:47 |
Yoonna Jang, Suhyune Son, Jeongwoo Lee, Junyoung Son, Yuna Hur, Jungwoo Lim, Hyeonseok Moon, Kisu Yang, Heuiseok Lim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the striking advances in recent language generation performance,
model-generated responses have suffered from the chronic problem of
hallucinations that are either untrue or unfaithful to a given source.
Especially in the task of knowledge grounded conversation, the models are
required to generate informative responses, but hallucinated utterances lead to
miscommunication. In particular, entity-level hallucination that causes
critical misinformation and undesirable conversation is one of the major
concerns. To address this issue, we propose a post-hoc refinement method called
REM. It aims to enhance the quality and faithfulness of hallucinated utterances
by refining them based on the source knowledge. If the generated utterance has
a low source-faithfulness score with the given knowledge, REM mines the key
entities in the knowledge and implicitly uses them for refining the utterances.
We verify that our method reduces entity hallucination in the utterance. Also,
we show the adaptability and efficacy of REM with extensive experiments and
generative results. Our code is available at https://github.com/YOONNAJANG/REM.
|
[
-0.4491215944290161,
-1.0281122922897339,
0.5403121113777161,
-0.13413289189338684,
-0.44696342945098877,
0.05779672786593437,
-0.36750248074531555,
-0.4798690378665924,
0.6210440993309021,
0.9731987714767456,
-0.5174795389175415,
-0.8750070333480835,
-0.28449973464012146,
0.038439903408288956,
-0.2430841624736786,
0.6883262991905212,
-0.04821839928627014,
0.10318966954946518,
-0.4156509339809418,
-0.1797720044851303,
-0.7169188857078552,
-0.37080657482147217,
-0.46578481793403625,
-0.36822548508644104,
-0.018288807943463326,
0.6785022616386414,
0.5456495881080627,
0.3851698338985443,
0.22228863835334778,
0.2473805695772171,
-0.0020411673467606306,
0.4550282955169678,
-0.7078570127487183,
0.6566526889801025,
-0.43740519881248474,
-0.41288256645202637,
-0.49902692437171936,
-0.19616319239139557,
0.3933210074901581,
0.6949478387832642,
-0.6074950098991394,
0.2353823482990265,
0.18403643369674683,
0.4679577052593231,
-0.4867394268512726,
0.2933441996574402,
-1.1625269651412964,
-0.17280922830104828,
0.09134601801633835,
-0.5028862357139587,
-0.42306530475616455,
-0.36006882786750793,
0.25997066497802734,
-0.6729772686958313,
0.4920664429664612,
0.18891379237174988,
1.0076724290847778,
0.5397799611091614,
-0.032968610525131226,
-0.27659401297569275,
-0.7861910462379456,
0.790065348148346,
-0.7059366106987,
0.7606378793716431,
0.6732479929924011,
0.144733726978302,
-0.2620387375354767,
-0.8490027785301208,
-0.49668362736701965,
-0.2760956585407257,
0.016492197290062904,
-0.14009173214435577,
0.12152499705553055,
0.0951383039355278,
0.29199445247650146,
0.39976224303245544,
-0.3693729043006897,
-0.4117130935192108,
-0.26673051714897156,
-0.31440624594688416,
0.4375551640987396,
0.06093800440430641,
0.16092148423194885,
-0.23951475322246552,
-0.3188326358795166,
0.13147950172424316,
-0.7432409524917603,
-0.4530172646045685,
0.27440762519836426,
0.17332488298416138,
0.46332013607025146,
0.5974783897399902,
-0.46716582775115967,
0.43905380368232727,
0.11961895227432251,
0.006385934539139271,
0.35379308462142944,
-0.243128702044487,
-0.22578065097332,
0.30211734771728516,
0.46559712290763855,
0.5505249500274658,
0.25567346811294556,
-0.4064457416534424,
-0.3496309816837311,
0.14954543113708496,
0.7249305248260498,
-0.8233694434165955,
-0.507325291633606,
0.08565983921289444,
-0.6833286881446838,
-0.286116361618042,
-0.024899858981370926,
-0.975343644618988,
-0.26992982625961304,
-0.49327296018600464,
0.23614871501922607,
-0.5133575201034546,
-0.5790981650352478,
0.11541807651519775,
0.131418839097023,
0.3278934061527252,
0.1975976526737213,
-0.6061307787895203,
0.3642314076423645,
0.5885757207870483,
0.5560054183006287,
0.2540431320667267,
-0.09508416056632996,
-0.5677947402000427,
0.0728297233581543,
-0.3630584478378296,
0.959589421749115,
-0.6188576817512512,
-0.5097955465316772,
-0.058065325021743774,
-0.14390212297439575,
0.06364583969116211,
-0.9543713331222534,
0.93264240026474,
-0.5412171483039856,
0.07807597517967224,
-0.36011171340942383,
-0.5165401101112366,
-0.4340830147266388,
0.1847579926252365,
-0.5130774974822998,
0.9522425532341003,
0.010434563271701336,
-0.7690945863723755,
0.4320946931838989,
-0.2808257043361664,
-0.4610446095466614,
0.07443270087242126,
-0.35875752568244934,
-0.49354061484336853,
0.3052121698856354,
0.2946537435054779,
0.18223410844802856,
-0.3312302529811859,
0.5377463698387146,
-0.24593056738376617,
-0.4320959746837616,
0.04955342039465904,
-0.042554985731840134,
0.22195257246494293,
0.3770231306552887,
-0.5264831781387329,
0.29999613761901855,
-0.8961969614028931,
0.2635653614997864,
0.031937312334775925,
-0.07887356728315353,
-0.38218218088150024,
0.20770467817783356,
-0.11727709323167801,
0.139385387301445,
-0.14223793148994446,
-0.44337499141693115,
-0.1977883130311966,
-0.6784771680831909,
0.40503332018852234,
0.4981251060962677,
0.2885107100009918,
0.2929523289203644,
-0.44166016578674316,
0.19397062063217163,
0.01501822005957365,
-0.13771821558475494,
-0.13092297315597534,
-0.4428093433380127,
-0.9539932608604431,
0.04683087021112442,
0.3002670705318451,
0.4648958444595337,
-1.0331482887268066,
0.7406596541404724,
-0.40177714824676514,
-0.36952948570251465,
-0.9809883236885071,
0.005647572688758373,
0.3025418221950531,
0.7439417839050293,
0.5785843729972839,
-0.401223361492157,
-0.8854504227638245,
-0.8994851112365723,
-0.49935078620910645,
-0.3753873109817505,
-0.08917047083377838,
0.41685542464256287,
0.23294134438037872,
-0.5307091474533081,
1.0404611825942993,
-0.4347085952758789,
-0.12689687311649323,
0.05238305404782295,
0.17048725485801697,
-0.29336419701576233,
0.5016759634017944,
-0.03708686679601669,
-0.42851871252059937,
0.05236615240573883,
-0.30618566274642944,
-0.8528922200202942,
-0.2019130289554596,
-0.0028521474450826645,
-0.2533207833766937,
0.2687636613845825,
0.5922922492027283,
-0.7080889940261841,
0.2865828275680542,
0.273193895816803,
-0.31386077404022217,
0.5388858914375305,
0.14352576434612274,
0.4252903163433075,
-1.1847132444381714,
0.07788072526454926,
-0.41065269708633423,
-0.4336201250553131,
-0.5119749307632446,
-0.049779441207647324,
-0.34970587491989136,
-0.21811288595199585,
-0.255822092294693,
0.26558467745780945,
-0.6576379537582397,
0.08606290817260742,
-0.6514214873313904,
0.28754502534866333,
-0.019098633900284767,
0.5008624792098999,
0.2937728762626648,
0.4291110336780548,
0.6175234913825989,
-0.7672401070594788,
0.355984091758728,
0.3482207655906677,
-0.5415483117103577,
0.5252364873886108,
-0.5740872621536255,
0.4679814577102661,
-0.15081052482128143,
0.0963076576590538,
-0.7904325127601624,
0.04250625520944595,
0.5007004737854004,
-0.614268958568573,
0.3376620411872864,
-0.03164638951420784,
-0.26904574036598206,
0.17052531242370605,
-0.12487436830997467,
0.27207258343696594,
0.4119162857532501,
-0.5178197622299194,
0.7130624055862427,
0.5021644830703735,
-0.1714283972978592,
-0.3647482097148895,
-0.4928700625896454,
0.1388704478740692,
-0.17485208809375763,
-0.9012581706047058,
0.5137364864349365,
0.00844832044094801,
-0.3037338852882385,
0.15037722885608673,
-0.4758374094963074,
0.2742086350917816,
0.023865200579166412,
0.43489354848861694,
0.033865150064229965,
-0.27744191884994507,
0.09730943292379379,
0.15602219104766846,
-0.3156900107860565,
0.42210447788238525,
-0.4580250084400177,
0.749566912651062,
-0.03452650457620621,
-0.25254112482070923,
-0.5661303400993347,
0.17347221076488495,
0.3861859142780304,
-0.09846912324428558,
0.7899189591407776,
0.49103182554244995,
-0.7504670023918152,
-0.2466030716896057,
-0.8111057877540588,
-0.8228155374526978,
-0.37084153294563293,
0.30369117856025696,
-0.6381736993789673,
-0.9349607825279236,
0.5188482999801636,
-0.3740789592266083,
-0.04603172093629837,
0.36850783228874207,
0.3415848910808563,
0.2587360441684723,
0.6048638820648193,
0.2891331911087036,
0.2249816656112671,
0.3620350658893585,
-0.023903939872980118,
0.3157523274421692,
-0.7807674407958984,
-0.37610700726509094,
-0.5189629197120667,
-0.019290849566459656,
-0.381361722946167,
-0.42577680945396423,
-0.4146103262901306,
0.19602444767951965,
0.2303496152162552,
0.18565194308757782,
-0.4028540849685669,
0.30323413014411926,
0.45533818006515503,
0.21390055119991302,
0.3132131099700928,
0.20361776649951935,
-0.09920170158147812,
-0.33021676540374756,
-0.47250479459762573,
-0.8542820811271667,
1.025729775428772,
0.4265262484550476,
0.8284492492675781,
-0.2183590680360794,
0.6486350297927856,
0.13494808971881866,
0.3155166506767273,
-0.6570395231246948,
0.5642898082733154,
0.719638466835022,
-0.4300801157951355,
-0.33141863346099854,
-0.7091056108474731,
-0.5662078857421875,
0.2974923253059387,
-0.4641185700893402,
-0.49582961201667786,
0.1651366651058197,
0.14161190390586853,
-0.15893545746803284,
0.1955210119485855,
-0.4815925061702728,
0.682334840297699,
0.1795794665813446,
-0.23291781544685364,
-0.3994489014148712,
-0.6472013592720032,
0.4144976735115051,
-0.04706113040447235,
0.07763303816318512,
-0.08371254801750183,
0.4117269814014435,
1.0033479928970337,
-0.4699687659740448,
0.6330590844154358,
-0.32273027300834656,
-0.23392221331596375,
0.5537956357002258,
0.19977083802223206,
0.7491135001182556,
0.4721922278404236,
-0.021787984296679497,
0.4294048845767975,
-0.36263224482536316,
-0.16829508543014526,
-0.5836901068687439,
0.7925240397453308,
-0.5376536846160889,
-0.8003231883049011,
-0.04732045531272888,
-0.10475930571556091,
-0.30605393648147583,
0.20823268592357635,
0.5369502902030945,
0.1695074886083603,
-0.5024852156639099,
0.10786253958940506,
0.9620249271392822,
-0.17402034997940063,
-0.16680052876472473,
0.42733293771743774,
-0.36042895913124084,
-0.6259084343910217,
0.8114529848098755,
-0.002457354450598359,
0.024164563044905663,
0.20674127340316772,
-0.25786149501800537,
-0.4376155436038971,
-0.6893101930618286,
-0.21812410652637482,
0.3297742009162903,
-0.6579394340515137,
-0.3565213084220886,
-0.8284164071083069,
-0.07567821443080902,
-0.7746838331222534,
0.15551823377609253,
-0.583005964756012,
-0.2861463129520416,
-0.3487194776535034,
-0.5152292847633362,
0.12338226288557053,
0.4631194472312927,
0.1509106606245041,
0.16441799700260162,
-0.805206298828125,
0.5338616967201233,
0.20099718868732452,
0.4402933716773987,
-0.10142344981431961,
-0.6974223256111145,
-0.15457606315612793,
0.29664286971092224,
-0.2354208379983902,
-1.0221972465515137,
0.3050958812236786,
-0.022557493299245834,
0.7428739666938782,
0.44842472672462463,
0.2668755352497101,
0.6751890182495117,
-0.42767441272735596,
0.5926804542541504,
-0.06017330661416054,
-1.1836519241333008,
0.7124508023262024,
0.056522466242313385,
-0.23834964632987976,
0.7648851275444031,
-0.05044975131750107,
-0.5795942544937134,
-0.6335016489028931,
-0.9673959016799927,
-0.997275173664093,
0.744225800037384,
0.3892323970794678,
-0.03521274775266647,
-0.03318595513701439,
0.5737076997756958,
0.13575436174869537,
0.45859089493751526,
-0.4399029016494751,
-0.4239603579044342,
-0.48818325996398926,
0.06454546749591827,
0.10608144104480743,
-0.7634958028793335,
-0.1869073063135147,
0.04661960154771805,
0.9648541808128357,
0.19740533828735352,
0.25385165214538574,
0.3610854148864746,
-0.4417463541030884,
-0.38762688636779785,
0.210781991481781,
0.540022075176239,
0.7286242246627808,
-0.2228449583053589,
0.3494979739189148,
0.37343788146972656,
-0.4176764190196991,
-0.021771712228655815,
0.005115656182169914,
-0.18991097807884216,
0.29030999541282654,
0.21549759805202484,
0.9568617939949036,
0.22167477011680603,
-0.5005876421928406,
0.13738346099853516,
-0.2714861333370209,
-0.32602766156196594,
-0.22904188930988312,
-0.03262459859251976,
0.08916067332029343,
0.20075836777687073,
0.12624691426753998,
0.1734929233789444,
0.28064751625061035,
-0.394318550825119,
0.5402509570121765,
0.2373044788837433,
-0.5103204846382141,
-0.2632503807544708,
0.6994578242301941,
0.4059046804904938,
-0.34488508105278015,
0.9988759160041809,
-0.21639856696128845,
-0.4057047367095947,
0.02490408532321453,
0.6022836565971375,
1.0625889301300049,
-0.5946311950683594,
0.09447160363197327,
0.3918597102165222,
0.47821223735809326,
0.008143465034663677,
0.39955875277519226,
-0.19065260887145996,
-0.9336329698562622,
-0.3391055464744568,
-0.6835798621177673,
-0.17464545369148254,
0.302778035402298,
-0.7311047911643982,
0.2658746540546417,
-0.27223289012908936,
-0.24133369326591492,
-0.47788769006729126,
-0.03390256687998772,
-0.2689768970012665,
0.2170848399400711,
0.027024338021874428,
0.6236770749092102,
-0.7262588143348694,
0.5800355076789856,
0.7309830188751221,
-0.20308281481266022,
-0.6505680084228516,
0.2515106797218323,
-0.19411861896514893,
-0.5002123713493347,
0.20841439068317413,
0.2437313050031662,
-0.2880130410194397,
0.21805188059806824,
-0.4015052616596222,
-0.7573410272598267,
0.9298702478408813,
0.48435211181640625,
-0.5939094424247742,
0.24161002039909363,
-0.012955245561897755,
0.4064156711101532,
-0.3419802784919739,
0.04002395644783974,
0.6087380647659302,
0.3504720628261566,
0.18785300850868225,
-0.7008369565010071,
0.42825284600257874,
-0.3319864571094513,
0.13356968760490417,
0.17997503280639648,
-0.22879639267921448,
0.45111313462257385,
-0.22283540666103363,
-0.6021037101745605,
-0.10483836382627487,
1.2671294212341309,
0.5291823744773865,
0.4312373995780945,
0.6633099913597107,
0.83515864610672,
1.019079327583313,
-0.11814910173416138,
0.40040481090545654,
-0.4224787950515747,
0.37746164202690125,
1.1572768688201904,
-0.445242702960968,
0.6455850005149841,
0.47027528285980225,
0.35454368591308594,
0.4525940418243408,
0.6199703812599182,
0.28060075640678406,
0.5092148184776306,
0.5278719663619995,
-0.3131232261657715,
-0.3831234276294708,
-0.11494166404008865,
-0.6089585423469543,
0.2765425741672516,
0.4802483022212982,
-0.29088857769966125,
-0.048975870013237,
0.08636794984340668,
0.07475771009922028,
0.17232836782932281,
-0.11992840468883514,
0.9492478966712952,
0.19067692756652832,
-0.7422345280647278,
0.7908799648284912,
0.1434108465909958,
0.4868030548095703,
-0.07512854039669037,
-0.3343711197376251,
-0.27848196029663086,
0.0034267546143382788,
-0.4507612884044647,
-0.2977715730667114,
0.6151159405708313,
-0.18326929211616516,
-0.26233088970184326,
-0.1544104516506195,
0.9977311491966248,
-0.7215500473976135,
0.06483528763055801,
0.38064610958099365,
0.5268884897232056,
0.3572312891483307,
-0.5579339861869812,
-0.5588119626045227,
0.07710317522287369,
0.24557282030582428,
-0.2075948715209961,
-0.2021259069442749,
0.5580692291259766,
0.05625450983643532,
0.4776885509490967,
0.7049643993377686,
0.010609036311507225,
-0.0363176092505455,
0.24724115431308746,
0.8922445178031921,
-0.8372617959976196,
-0.3450040817260742,
-0.6880031824111938,
0.2935781180858612,
0.029123354703187943,
-0.0033049299381673336,
0.7443220615386963,
0.71502685546875,
1.007590413093567,
-0.0031891062390059233,
0.7349899411201477,
0.2544686794281006,
0.5957388281822205,
-0.7877232432365417,
0.8559467792510986,
-0.24557752907276154,
0.48451608419418335,
-0.31410372257232666,
-1.2357378005981445,
-0.1134958267211914,
0.8984158635139465,
-0.22430822253227234,
0.1675066500902176,
0.8083537817001343,
1.0108509063720703,
0.21450243890285492,
0.3471847176551819,
0.3506620526313782,
0.23682235181331635,
0.25602009892463684,
0.17349468171596527,
1.0986535549163818,
-0.4129776954650879,
0.5585504174232483,
-0.06166725605726242,
-0.0827561765909195,
-0.3410947918891907,
-0.4226093888282776,
-0.7431964874267578,
-0.5088797807693481,
-0.5181747674942017,
-0.772758960723877,
0.09987399727106094,
0.8991170525550842,
0.5837777853012085,
-0.738252580165863,
0.04457368701696396,
-0.22653108835220337,
0.3386702835559845,
-0.10631158202886581,
-0.2798127233982086,
0.14544856548309326,
-0.5695703625679016,
-0.6418129801750183,
0.4533747732639313,
0.10995060950517654,
-0.16429373621940613,
-0.04268912971019745,
-0.2601708173751831,
-0.01522152591496706,
-0.037643276154994965,
0.3875528872013092,
-0.017305856570601463,
-0.7122560143470764,
-0.17358030378818512,
-0.028145872056484222,
-0.043815597891807556,
0.0888054370880127,
1.1342172622680664,
-0.8657501339912415,
0.47459807991981506,
0.3632938861846924,
0.505853533744812,
0.42638882994651794,
0.20738621056079865,
0.5545933246612549,
-0.7794101238250732,
-0.11136377602815628,
0.25353342294692993,
0.39326876401901245,
0.45735687017440796,
-0.33416464924812317,
0.2512871325016022,
0.5423552393913269,
-0.6429423689842224,
-0.9255005717277527,
0.20478634536266327,
-0.7773850560188293,
-0.24417324364185333,
1.1330466270446777,
0.03995218500494957,
-0.11046602576971054,
-0.36252713203430176,
-0.386294424533844,
0.6719547510147095,
-0.4405510127544403,
1.021745204925537,
0.7662723064422607,
0.21105970442295074,
-0.10754870623350143,
-0.28062933683395386,
0.8113101124763489,
0.5083483457565308,
-0.9115009307861328,
0.40017879009246826,
0.5646921396255493,
0.23123201727867126,
0.24322839081287384,
0.6971557140350342,
-0.14777882397174835,
0.014902306720614433,
0.20406322181224823,
0.4296475946903229,
-0.028435898944735527,
-0.5748894214630127,
-0.17431890964508057,
0.0700625628232956,
0.2520117163658142,
-0.2603737711906433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10806v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10806v1
|
ptt5-v2: A Closer Look at Continued Pretraining of T5 Models for the Portuguese Language
| 2024-06-16T05:17:56 | 2024-06-16T05:17:56 |
Marcos Piau, Roberto Lotufo, Rodrigo Nogueira
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Despite advancements in Natural Language Processing (NLP) and the growing
availability of pretrained models, the English language remains the primary
focus of model development. Continued pretraining on language-specific corpora
provides a practical solution for adapting models to other languages. However,
the impact of different pretraining settings on downstream tasks remains
underexplored. This work introduces $\texttt{ptt5-v2}$, investigating the
continued pretraining of T5 models for Portuguese. We first develop a baseline
set of settings and pretrain models with sizes up to 3B parameters. Finetuning
on three Portuguese downstream tasks (assin2 STS, assin2 RTE, and TweetSentBR)
yields SOTA results on the latter two. We then explore the effects of different
pretraining configurations, including quality filters, optimization strategies,
and multi-epoch pretraining. Perhaps surprisingly, their impact remains subtle
compared to our baseline. We release $\texttt{ptt5-v2}$ pretrained checkpoints
and the finetuned MonoT5 rerankers on HuggingFace at
https://huggingface.co/collections/unicamp-dl/ptt5-v2-666538a650188ba00aa8d2d0
and
https://huggingface.co/collections/unicamp-dl/monoptt5-66653981877df3ea727f720d.
|
[
-0.45310261845588684,
-0.32863274216651917,
0.2946159541606903,
0.2645297646522522,
-0.5291453003883362,
-0.025885330513119698,
-0.3193006217479706,
-0.6762104630470276,
-0.024527736008167267,
0.5257979035377502,
-0.7864261865615845,
-0.3378515839576721,
-0.8495785593986511,
0.25176307559013367,
-0.2888779044151306,
1.288539171218872,
-0.22156651318073273,
0.16352911293506622,
0.09976839274168015,
-0.16663064062595367,
-0.6425740718841553,
-0.6500683426856995,
-0.8315134644508362,
-0.3093237578868866,
0.8213684558868408,
0.4485292434692383,
0.2631148397922516,
0.5271402597427368,
0.4590538442134857,
0.22206813097000122,
-0.004069410264492035,
-0.4316885769367218,
-0.9778538346290588,
0.11648537218570709,
0.013320147059857845,
-0.5222913026809692,
-0.26276853680610657,
0.10243605077266693,
0.8795746564865112,
0.6897932291030884,
0.09788824617862701,
0.04535870999097824,
0.42272940278053284,
0.33638128638267517,
-0.49856409430503845,
0.1108442097902298,
-0.25843730568885803,
-0.004700855817645788,
-0.43814557790756226,
-0.06054174154996872,
-0.30518221855163574,
-0.2713003158569336,
0.4632439911365509,
-0.652213990688324,
0.15487724542617798,
-0.36751511693000793,
1.1682254076004028,
0.5954077839851379,
-0.4686131179332733,
-0.03614591062068939,
-0.6616731286048889,
0.7093976140022278,
-0.3311672508716583,
0.6829631328582764,
0.31090062856674194,
0.1579100489616394,
0.14593400061130524,
-1.0275683403015137,
-0.22395001351833344,
-0.2876431941986084,
-0.022648148238658905,
0.3230861723423004,
-0.09352141618728638,
0.21488898992538452,
0.24152334034442902,
0.03437481448054314,
-0.4186231195926666,
0.39425912499427795,
-0.7825932502746582,
-0.12563452124595642,
0.1595860719680786,
-0.3789036273956299,
-0.03375813737511635,
0.3465007245540619,
-0.6832094788551331,
-0.1646663397550583,
-1.00527822971344,
0.12901750206947327,
0.23418880999088287,
-0.033079423010349274,
-0.1649131029844284,
0.16199520230293274,
0.01952650211751461,
0.6299260258674622,
-0.018085232004523277,
-0.03219299390912056,
0.21966761350631714,
-0.5441761016845703,
-0.14151941239833832,
-0.02351284585893154,
0.593537449836731,
0.03894378989934921,
0.4870787560939789,
0.007982423529028893,
-0.23184652626514435,
0.0025145604740828276,
0.4213893413543701,
-0.8343608379364014,
-0.3148234486579895,
0.15470567345619202,
-0.2289292812347412,
-0.1755010187625885,
0.10422870516777039,
-0.17421486973762512,
0.1185779720544815,
-0.488226056098938,
0.4423148036003113,
-0.5902406573295593,
-0.2748721241950989,
-0.09903521090745926,
-0.17077404260635376,
0.45926228165626526,
0.2348783165216446,
-0.6734775900840759,
0.27078431844711304,
0.8014426827430725,
0.7336982488632202,
-0.2787380516529083,
-0.5931549668312073,
-0.5192388296127319,
0.05668293684720993,
-0.11887617409229279,
0.9021814465522766,
-0.5162745714187622,
-0.39558055996894836,
-0.044237520545721054,
0.22322209179401398,
-0.16816407442092896,
-0.44542306661605835,
0.7800169587135315,
-0.4399750828742981,
0.5690679550170898,
-0.6350597739219666,
-0.3529841899871826,
-0.04278086870908737,
0.28888028860092163,
-0.5505817532539368,
1.1894761323928833,
0.17303985357284546,
-0.7864423990249634,
0.6982755661010742,
-0.5240368843078613,
-0.4230526387691498,
-0.22189177572727203,
0.12767714262008667,
-0.4782601296901703,
0.005750225856900215,
-0.11314523220062256,
0.302079439163208,
-0.10981287807226181,
-0.11404844373464584,
-0.48417219519615173,
-0.4367291033267975,
-0.3006945550441742,
-0.017988938838243484,
0.6377394795417786,
0.20075975358486176,
-0.2678650915622711,
0.14101016521453857,
-0.51365727186203,
-0.10272790491580963,
-0.1346067488193512,
-0.2877107560634613,
-0.2709776759147644,
-0.2017177790403366,
0.018205245956778526,
0.5786149501800537,
0.41034695506095886,
-0.44494718313217163,
0.29894185066223145,
-0.18624013662338257,
0.5835334062576294,
0.6087548136711121,
-0.0983603298664093,
0.13163529336452484,
-0.23316402733325958,
0.6356101632118225,
0.3268027901649475,
0.2153031826019287,
-0.2061973363161087,
-0.3217778503894806,
-0.8477110266685486,
-0.3320492208003998,
0.5859849452972412,
0.5413905382156372,
-0.688563883304596,
-0.004534942097961903,
-0.3788670301437378,
-0.5461146235466003,
-0.45521315932273865,
-0.1657457798719406,
0.8533812165260315,
0.34415972232818604,
0.4736916720867157,
-0.7409462332725525,
-0.80736243724823,
-0.8278594613075256,
-0.15275374054908752,
0.14600643515586853,
-0.0017861081287264824,
-0.25258827209472656,
0.5561423897743225,
-0.09535717964172363,
0.9089502096176147,
-0.1496240347623825,
-0.30215558409690857,
-0.3648580312728882,
0.15805377066135406,
-0.0009870720095932484,
0.7062145471572876,
0.8730435371398926,
-0.5125346779823303,
-0.3175497353076935,
-0.24519065022468567,
-0.32980474829673767,
-0.4611915647983551,
0.1521318256855011,
0.00728510832414031,
0.3705896735191345,
0.46279165148735046,
-0.3328244686126709,
0.15342319011688232,
0.6778419613838196,
-0.281829297542572,
0.49166005849838257,
-0.3819102942943573,
-0.09294231235980988,
-0.9880912899971008,
0.12459959089756012,
-0.09863565117120743,
-0.3505433201789856,
-0.6325608491897583,
-0.21592997014522552,
-0.18565253913402557,
0.04398119077086449,
-0.528683066368103,
0.4009254574775696,
-0.6091567277908325,
-0.4774923324584961,
-0.2557077407836914,
0.005044685211032629,
-0.15216146409511566,
0.34687039256095886,
0.4535399377346039,
0.5807619094848633,
0.5255938768386841,
-0.6896886825561523,
-0.16361020505428314,
0.09488392621278763,
0.11916207522153854,
0.43610602617263794,
-0.9588792324066162,
0.2981540560722351,
-0.037975460290908813,
0.5069006681442261,
-0.9963650703430176,
-0.04802672192454338,
0.04194474220275879,
-0.4583227336406708,
0.5139583945274353,
-0.3806781768798828,
-0.31939706206321716,
-0.31827273964881897,
-0.3211650550365448,
0.33155301213264465,
0.5484248995780945,
-0.3567824959754944,
0.17263349890708923,
0.3082684576511383,
-0.23966282606124878,
-0.48416197299957275,
-0.49879568815231323,
-0.11807721853256226,
-0.4315569996833801,
-0.6059401631355286,
0.4662141799926758,
0.2794708013534546,
0.16605974733829498,
-0.27494654059410095,
-0.16186034679412842,
-0.187912717461586,
0.1045135036110878,
0.08951129764318466,
-0.026883870363235474,
-0.181777223944664,
-0.120440274477005,
0.1538761556148529,
-0.37719711661338806,
-0.03970605880022049,
-0.7371784448623657,
0.7920674681663513,
-0.040585439652204514,
0.03181501477956772,
-0.5616263747215271,
0.20850102603435516,
0.21926501393318176,
-0.5298245549201965,
0.7995174527168274,
1.0455780029296875,
-0.20794251561164856,
0.10283380001783371,
-0.506339430809021,
-0.35120120644569397,
-0.41494566202163696,
0.2912668287754059,
-0.6972945928573608,
-1.107263445854187,
0.4717036783695221,
0.03876116871833801,
0.14207546412944794,
0.573067843914032,
0.6732908487319946,
-0.3117062449455261,
0.71919184923172,
0.9279500842094421,
0.11385266482830048,
0.9994775056838989,
-0.3134586215019226,
-0.1815776377916336,
-0.5895336866378784,
-0.06137258559465408,
-0.6344338059425354,
-0.3903180658817291,
-1.026928424835205,
-0.24997620284557343,
0.4915536046028137,
0.06847304850816727,
-0.27542924880981445,
0.5224184989929199,
-0.2233581244945526,
0.4497936964035034,
0.7887137532234192,
0.04283663257956505,
0.09304183721542358,
-0.18572713434696198,
0.018023012205958366,
-0.02519109472632408,
-0.8799262642860413,
-0.40736860036849976,
1.1231327056884766,
0.3581974506378174,
0.30397093296051025,
-0.05287547782063484,
0.8549835681915283,
-0.1337873637676239,
0.34823864698410034,
-0.3864460289478302,
0.2157282680273056,
-0.3744416832923889,
-0.46039068698883057,
-0.09880697727203369,
-0.18746986985206604,
-1.369296908378601,
0.1642223298549652,
-0.011816862039268017,
-0.5875672101974487,
0.12215611338615417,
0.43347811698913574,
-0.48241937160491943,
-0.2960514426231384,
-1.028950572013855,
1.331621766090393,
-0.16512252390384674,
-0.6043033599853516,
-0.32382309436798096,
-1.1535333395004272,
0.19426871836185455,
-0.047874145209789276,
-0.09576867520809174,
0.18638372421264648,
-0.10175951570272446,
0.8063915967941284,
-0.6253071427345276,
0.8036059737205505,
-0.39112764596939087,
-0.13610973954200745,
0.278513640165329,
-0.2119893878698349,
0.3550441861152649,
-0.15085354447364807,
0.20263910293579102,
0.25746950507164,
0.7081276178359985,
-0.7205846905708313,
-0.12966832518577576,
0.5380702018737793,
-1.0491688251495361,
-0.29161903262138367,
-0.5891085863113403,
-0.07809284329414368,
-0.27415964007377625,
0.5126426815986633,
0.5358862280845642,
0.3323218524456024,
-0.19162125885486603,
0.3384415805339813,
0.5850073099136353,
0.014705738984048367,
0.409221351146698,
0.4522861838340759,
-0.013775482773780823,
-0.15416008234024048,
0.6603025197982788,
0.3614034354686737,
0.4380514323711395,
0.2676025629043579,
0.10549863427877426,
-0.5344736576080322,
-0.6536790728569031,
-0.04657494276762009,
0.35657885670661926,
-0.24880453944206238,
0.24620798230171204,
-0.4272712767124176,
0.19015415012836456,
-0.6205718517303467,
0.12249522656202316,
-0.5185847282409668,
-0.42769643664360046,
-0.22867247462272644,
-0.051860734820365906,
0.016716495156288147,
0.7272540926933289,
-0.2014385163784027,
0.6921674013137817,
-0.9224382638931274,
0.025558827444911003,
0.08553675562143326,
0.31204792857170105,
-0.7308723330497742,
-0.7339337468147278,
-0.3142443597316742,
0.04530949145555496,
-0.2876199185848236,
-0.8090304136276245,
0.17530326545238495,
0.2870384156703949,
0.26247429847717285,
0.3025345802307129,
-0.30552229285240173,
0.6707041263580322,
-0.29064637422561646,
0.6739405393600464,
-0.051393378525972366,
-0.6947178840637207,
0.4850110709667206,
-0.6146378517150879,
0.44448575377464294,
0.7231917381286621,
0.5367621183395386,
-0.473964661359787,
-0.10497691482305527,
-0.9065021872520447,
-0.7475083470344543,
0.8572767972946167,
0.328395277261734,
-0.2107154279947281,
0.23475733399391174,
0.4137979745864868,
0.15577353537082672,
0.3402955234050751,
-0.6669309139251709,
0.22436903417110443,
-0.44973093271255493,
0.03753308579325676,
-0.15900325775146484,
-0.39990487694740295,
0.11684010177850723,
-0.2516632378101349,
0.5610296130180359,
0.09183303266763687,
0.44384196400642395,
0.08070629835128784,
-0.1662202924489975,
0.296232670545578,
0.02417278289794922,
0.7481968998908997,
0.49141809344291687,
-0.22758637368679047,
-0.026181254535913467,
0.28568100929260254,
-0.6667646169662476,
-0.23541384935379028,
0.3378813862800598,
-0.030355775728821754,
-0.04695328325033188,
0.6307012438774109,
0.9295510053634644,
0.2734258770942688,
-0.43029749393463135,
0.35561567544937134,
-0.050166722387075424,
0.02306496910750866,
-0.6784555912017822,
0.011767998337745667,
-0.16976527869701385,
0.10244166851043701,
-0.10608182847499847,
-0.16217681765556335,
-0.18177463114261627,
-0.6880982518196106,
0.19183358550071716,
0.05632546916604042,
-0.6225375533103943,
-0.725649893283844,
0.6885932087898254,
0.27013900876045227,
0.1098097488284111,
0.5185785293579102,
-0.14841873943805695,
-0.6812047958374023,
0.45209237933158875,
0.3847026824951172,
0.7535702586174011,
-0.46896669268608093,
-0.251363068819046,
0.3802832067012787,
0.3886300027370453,
-0.0900844931602478,
0.45021432638168335,
-0.17265404760837555,
-0.6580832004547119,
-0.5797338485717773,
-0.44039297103881836,
-0.24255846440792084,
-0.07463958114385605,
-0.6971873641014099,
0.6567373871803284,
-0.309644490480423,
-0.166619673371315,
-0.2787143886089325,
0.06318583339452744,
-0.8129414916038513,
0.5415706634521484,
0.21283508837223053,
0.6905467510223389,
-0.7106755971908569,
1.290199875831604,
0.9136887788772583,
-0.5248820781707764,
-0.7948200702667236,
-0.013726282864809036,
-0.08713401108980179,
-0.7740013003349304,
0.5920955538749695,
0.2963711619377136,
-0.06059211865067482,
0.30895498394966125,
-0.4455024003982544,
-1.002867341041565,
1.1942647695541382,
0.5321339964866638,
-0.5374090075492859,
-0.2904622554779053,
0.32794833183288574,
0.8127413988113403,
-0.1552470475435257,
0.5628965497016907,
1.129105806350708,
0.4528239071369171,
0.21408088505268097,
-1.320115566253662,
-0.33875757455825806,
-0.12029755115509033,
-0.03522251918911934,
0.24032332003116608,
-1.032346487045288,
0.7049742341041565,
-0.08827830851078033,
0.044698480516672134,
-0.1821562498807907,
0.539872407913208,
0.4293785095214844,
-0.027707302942872047,
0.5753518342971802,
0.7989463210105896,
0.4989211857318878,
-0.5385908484458923,
1.1900522708892822,
-0.44702595472335815,
0.41707324981689453,
1.1791224479675293,
-0.05631088465452194,
0.8376820683479309,
0.45745420455932617,
-0.15324360132217407,
0.2965794801712036,
1.1700369119644165,
0.22396443784236908,
0.4846280515193939,
0.06181810796260834,
-0.010999911464750767,
-0.1397581696510315,
-0.20522575080394745,
-0.6594918966293335,
0.7322994470596313,
0.24415148794651031,
-0.26777589321136475,
-0.09147831052541733,
0.09156984835863113,
0.5331282615661621,
-0.5949276685714722,
-0.19604046642780304,
0.7135632038116455,
0.12977690994739532,
-1.0337145328521729,
0.6636468172073364,
-0.011291270144283772,
0.45857667922973633,
-0.7319055199623108,
0.31534111499786377,
-0.39523959159851074,
0.3565284311771393,
-0.05041977018117905,
-0.6424732804298401,
0.5320655703544617,
0.08048242330551147,
0.14786380529403687,
-0.9522095918655396,
0.6336215138435364,
-0.4548063278198242,
-0.09473990648984909,
0.22021350264549255,
0.3360987603664398,
0.30362266302108765,
-0.2268775850534439,
-0.5614863634109497,
0.25539156794548035,
-0.03228481486439705,
-0.5454149842262268,
0.37651094794273376,
0.5193712711334229,
-0.19358785450458527,
0.4752812683582306,
0.505279541015625,
-0.10188733786344528,
0.1971910297870636,
0.17073798179626465,
0.8848374485969543,
-0.4471633732318878,
-0.6779429912567139,
-0.5985468626022339,
0.5030936598777771,
0.23483514785766602,
-0.7966643571853638,
0.5420111417770386,
0.596891462802887,
1.3173543214797974,
-0.023151012137532234,
0.5613119602203369,
-0.053520411252975464,
0.68202143907547,
-0.6882655024528503,
0.48985493183135986,
-0.4975082576274872,
0.0369521901011467,
-0.16233865916728973,
-0.9452589154243469,
0.01354414876550436,
0.48613885045051575,
-0.6055276989936829,
0.3915250897407532,
0.9215710163116455,
0.3791467547416687,
-0.04030430689454079,
-0.209000363945961,
0.053359147161245346,
0.602816641330719,
0.23438145220279694,
0.7302249670028687,
0.6378765106201172,
-0.28409290313720703,
0.5521371364593506,
-0.1994788497686386,
-0.02598464861512184,
-0.06408621370792389,
-0.7270723581314087,
-0.6745713949203491,
-0.6953759789466858,
-0.21445797383785248,
-0.27192017436027527,
0.271095871925354,
0.7493920922279358,
0.6941763758659363,
-0.7127355337142944,
-0.2202311009168625,
-0.11102938652038574,
-0.21478481590747833,
-0.012052113190293312,
-0.11218048632144928,
0.2769162356853485,
-0.3413635790348053,
-0.8279812932014465,
0.10662085562944412,
0.08898729085922241,
0.10863176733255386,
-0.25606125593185425,
0.10529796034097672,
-0.22747008502483368,
-0.4292994737625122,
0.6875712871551514,
0.37422171235084534,
-0.41340208053588867,
-0.4471473693847656,
-0.05895165726542473,
0.08872673660516739,
0.19784584641456604,
0.7009679079055786,
-1.0280519723892212,
0.06312579661607742,
0.5412288904190063,
0.39486822485923767,
0.9674537777900696,
0.0464789904654026,
0.7896226644515991,
-0.8499708771705627,
0.48639965057373047,
0.2836046814918518,
0.4175548255443573,
0.19655300676822662,
0.28637224435806274,
0.6684430241584778,
0.6103649735450745,
-0.4465923011302948,
-0.7312425374984741,
0.26219990849494934,
-1.0379252433776855,
0.10629041492938995,
1.1383886337280273,
-0.3267504572868347,
-0.1401723027229309,
-0.13002365827560425,
-0.30923163890838623,
0.6057196855545044,
-0.2107754945755005,
0.5195174813270569,
0.8486320972442627,
-0.08450347185134888,
-0.4535982012748718,
-0.7496262788772583,
0.611055314540863,
0.7662246823310852,
-0.8350955247879028,
-0.5008000731468201,
0.43850603699684143,
0.46322885155677795,
-0.17209647595882416,
0.6900689005851746,
0.07557349652051926,
0.20687073469161987,
-0.25530850887298584,
0.0205240398645401,
0.06403778493404388,
-0.4506993889808655,
-0.21026049554347992,
0.12476679682731628,
0.05562369152903557,
-0.21951399743556976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10803v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10803v1
|
HiddenTables & PyQTax: A Cooperative Game and Dataset For TableQA to Ensure Scale and Data Privacy Across a Myriad of Taxonomies
| 2024-06-16T04:53:29 | 2024-06-16T04:53:29 |
William Watson, Nicole Cho, Tucker Balch, Manuela Veloso
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
A myriad of different Large Language Models (LLMs) face a common challenge in
contextually analyzing table question-answering tasks. These challenges are
engendered from (1) finite context windows for large tables, (2) multi-faceted
discrepancies amongst tokenization patterns against cell boundaries, and (3)
various limitations stemming from data confidentiality in the process of using
external models such as gpt-3.5-turbo. We propose a cooperative game dubbed
"HiddenTables" as a potential resolution to this challenge. In essence,
"HiddenTables" is played between the code-generating LLM "Solver" and the
"Oracle" which evaluates the ability of the LLM agents to solve Table QA tasks.
This game is based on natural language schemas and importantly, ensures the
security of the underlying data. We provide evidential experiments on a diverse
set of tables that demonstrate an LLM's collective inability to generalize and
perform on complex queries, handle compositional dependencies, and align
natural language to programmatic commands when concrete table schemas are
provided. Unlike encoder-based models, we have pushed the boundaries of
"HiddenTables" to not be limited by the number of rows - therefore we exhibit
improved efficiency in prompt and completion tokens. Our infrastructure has
spawned a new dataset "PyQTax" that spans across 116,671 question-table-answer
triplets and provides additional fine-grained breakdowns & labels for varying
question taxonomies. Therefore, in tandem with our academic contributions
regarding LLMs' deficiency in TableQA tasks, "HiddenTables" is a tactile
manifestation of how LLMs can interact with massive datasets while ensuring
data security and minimizing generation costs.
|
[
-0.2385450303554535,
-0.8842965960502625,
0.7280519008636475,
0.33166247606277466,
0.10046472400426865,
0.3460739254951477,
-0.023705830797553062,
-0.30935776233673096,
0.07530025392770767,
0.7746115326881409,
-0.5608788132667542,
-0.5968191027641296,
-0.33055949211120605,
0.09580966830253601,
-0.4514082968235016,
0.9444127082824707,
-0.13542510569095612,
0.004016695078462362,
-0.5439159274101257,
-0.08729931712150574,
-0.4386480748653412,
-0.602623701095581,
-0.2640250027179718,
-0.23859237134456635,
0.7637813687324524,
0.4956490993499756,
0.9863173961639404,
0.9993897080421448,
0.4312577545642853,
0.2217589169740677,
0.08781255781650543,
-0.22364109754562378,
-0.2945622503757477,
0.36206287145614624,
-0.0844539925456047,
-0.7799079418182373,
-0.2905987501144409,
-0.10555436462163925,
0.48982611298561096,
0.6382727026939392,
-0.2807599902153015,
0.2183176428079605,
0.06873571872711182,
0.6578721404075623,
-0.6126353740692139,
0.6611031889915466,
-0.44433829188346863,
0.32874828577041626,
-0.10289635509252548,
0.3882308900356293,
-0.2192619889974594,
-0.7653904557228088,
-0.0006971764378249645,
-0.693601131439209,
-0.15344005823135376,
0.11687168478965759,
0.6861421465873718,
0.33009663224220276,
-0.6602595448493958,
-0.1510416716337204,
-0.6780595183372498,
0.4710957407951355,
-0.3385566771030426,
0.3049665689468384,
0.2422058880329132,
0.3115890920162201,
-0.40238791704177856,
-0.8868632316589355,
-0.694073498249054,
-0.3196479082107544,
-0.06781357526779175,
0.04596662148833275,
-0.4395289719104767,
0.02995082177221775,
0.37345877289772034,
0.42452189326286316,
-0.6548359394073486,
0.08301367610692978,
0.22246889770030975,
-0.37425941228866577,
0.40421733260154724,
0.49441516399383545,
0.42178410291671753,
0.13628721237182617,
-0.2325989007949829,
0.0035457564517855644,
-0.7097967267036438,
0.24406638741493225,
0.12396173179149628,
0.0831829234957695,
-0.23766328394412994,
0.6293272376060486,
-0.49570128321647644,
0.4692613184452057,
-0.15618513524532318,
0.3120628297328949,
-0.02429342269897461,
-0.4147365689277649,
0.09832821786403656,
-0.1851327121257782,
0.8308042883872986,
0.12477369606494904,
-0.03934381529688835,
-0.4807484745979309,
-0.23372222483158112,
0.2988046705722809,
-0.17248781025409698,
-0.28954002261161804,
-0.4099460542201996,
0.31538742780685425,
-0.1570042222738266,
-0.2318219393491745,
-0.035455264151096344,
-0.8888031244277954,
-0.5638541579246521,
-0.11925707757472992,
0.9370872378349304,
0.08544134348630905,
-0.19507743418216705,
-0.11859312653541565,
-0.25595614314079285,
0.3776174783706665,
0.1271381974220276,
-0.7091301083564758,
0.8672487735748291,
0.8956712484359741,
0.7365849018096924,
-0.4381960928440094,
-0.21074531972408295,
-0.5791385769844055,
0.25428858399391174,
-0.48214957118034363,
0.43982550501823425,
-0.6193525195121765,
-0.29882708191871643,
-0.021198885515332222,
0.14774206280708313,
0.1521071195602417,
-0.5305870175361633,
0.4105255603790283,
-0.5596324801445007,
0.18228918313980103,
-0.7061925530433655,
-0.381784051656723,
0.10665696859359741,
0.2919376492500305,
-0.9383454918861389,
0.8794499039649963,
-0.007272858638316393,
-0.6883485317230225,
0.4505828022956848,
-0.8775097727775574,
-0.0601290799677372,
0.42851492762565613,
-0.3349307179450989,
-0.3911837339401245,
-0.07980034500360489,
0.32032284140586853,
0.22538559138774872,
-0.20588335394859314,
0.2620667517185211,
-0.3669010102748871,
-0.544313371181488,
0.4736880362033844,
-0.1739584356546402,
0.5528078675270081,
0.00823286548256874,
-0.4164544343948364,
0.2944391369819641,
-0.4056529998779297,
0.2526060938835144,
0.14848008751869202,
-0.4627882242202759,
-0.2858254611492157,
-0.02505321055650711,
-0.22441066801548004,
0.04355768859386444,
0.43966615200042725,
-0.5338775515556335,
0.18288877606391907,
-0.266042023897171,
0.5344040393829346,
0.4290209114551544,
0.15416084229946136,
0.6693868041038513,
-0.43067702651023865,
0.5211443901062012,
0.052287351340055466,
0.5265421271324158,
0.2105484902858734,
-0.6534770131111145,
-0.5213418006896973,
-0.1220090314745903,
0.5405253171920776,
0.5172069072723389,
-1.122806191444397,
0.14465297758579254,
-0.21385344862937927,
-0.35952305793762207,
-0.1391727775335312,
-0.49416980147361755,
0.35609546303749084,
0.3145548701286316,
0.16398397088050842,
-0.23786498606204987,
-0.20488812029361725,
-1.1142438650131226,
-0.2877245247364044,
0.16161060333251953,
-0.3140673041343689,
0.5335025191307068,
0.6513576507568359,
-0.006255109328776598,
1.0073837041854858,
-0.39185523986816406,
-0.13207632303237915,
-0.07255900651216507,
0.0353037491440773,
0.2961922585964203,
0.4955163598060608,
0.02465238980948925,
-0.7068110108375549,
-0.4800907075405121,
-0.1351321041584015,
-0.6942160129547119,
-0.05463617295026779,
0.24823401868343353,
-0.035321008414030075,
0.15307597815990448,
0.1508656144142151,
-0.7953741550445557,
0.3319593071937561,
0.45947402715682983,
-0.4329780638217926,
0.5771090984344482,
-0.168242946267128,
-0.023799235001206398,
-0.723338782787323,
-0.08119338750839233,
-0.5123801231384277,
-0.06153154745697975,
-0.5720908641815186,
0.5127370357513428,
0.1788979023694992,
-0.24708664417266846,
-0.14334197342395782,
0.30773600935935974,
-0.694562554359436,
-0.18211472034454346,
0.12078264355659485,
0.03679262474179268,
0.07762721180915833,
0.533074140548706,
0.08515497297048569,
1.0328552722930908,
0.693135142326355,
-0.5213359594345093,
0.43810638785362244,
0.3620907962322235,
-0.07605831325054169,
0.16369470953941345,
-0.5879601836204529,
0.432449609041214,
0.20626777410507202,
0.29258522391319275,
-0.7352182269096375,
-0.3120143413543701,
0.4331375062465668,
-0.297761470079422,
0.03071664273738861,
-0.08511628210544586,
-0.5927553772926331,
-0.4910075068473816,
-0.4025075137615204,
0.16891665756702423,
0.3514251410961151,
-0.4511450529098511,
0.6509206891059875,
0.8321205973625183,
-0.1561552882194519,
-1.00286066532135,
-0.5979911684989929,
0.42922690510749817,
-0.2362734079360962,
-0.5166171193122864,
0.20986084640026093,
-0.14820076525211334,
-0.4595428705215454,
0.01307663880288601,
-0.42767760157585144,
-0.38993600010871887,
0.014178168959915638,
0.5151994824409485,
0.005450930446386337,
-0.256474107503891,
0.14882120490074158,
0.08805472403764725,
0.03248784691095352,
0.448404997587204,
-0.43359991908073425,
0.6490197777748108,
-0.479507178068161,
0.10757183283567429,
-0.14876633882522583,
0.5456919074058533,
0.42893141508102417,
-0.3950655460357666,
0.7408554553985596,
0.3776967525482178,
-0.3970210552215576,
-0.1226063147187233,
-0.47807368636131287,
-0.21952827274799347,
-0.5035222768783569,
0.27007657289505005,
-0.40160971879959106,
-1.1855517625808716,
0.985381007194519,
0.18027378618717194,
-0.026460204273462296,
0.015521853230893612,
0.5845781564712524,
0.17567682266235352,
0.8785751461982727,
0.6561744809150696,
-0.028580915182828903,
0.011812767945230007,
0.08770303428173065,
-0.07595056295394897,
-0.41035163402557373,
-0.48625296354293823,
-0.7195647358894348,
-0.21335956454277039,
-0.7814851403236389,
-0.40582525730133057,
0.4898945093154907,
-0.3964504897594452,
-0.34455206990242004,
0.21075664460659027,
-0.5615052580833435,
0.9916892051696777,
0.8522436022758484,
0.46407294273376465,
0.3997124433517456,
-0.17811495065689087,
-0.13060638308525085,
-0.053909044712781906,
-0.920439600944519,
-0.31799477338790894,
1.0184441804885864,
0.2506523132324219,
0.705996572971344,
0.23466601967811584,
0.9463582634925842,
0.313842236995697,
0.0908609926700592,
-0.6825036406517029,
0.6349350214004517,
0.17568568885326385,
-0.6495930552482605,
-0.5903629064559937,
-0.837828516960144,
-1.103614330291748,
0.043038416653871536,
-0.27343255281448364,
-0.7625514268875122,
0.2751079201698303,
-0.04241516441106796,
-0.44867759943008423,
0.11367866396903992,
-0.7418498992919922,
1.054834008216858,
0.13700905442237854,
-0.9903597235679626,
0.11530444025993347,
-0.7581871151924133,
0.5263263583183289,
-0.0888313353061676,
0.15026627480983734,
0.18244142830371857,
-0.3398873805999756,
0.9142849445343018,
-0.5097075700759888,
0.5752642154693604,
-0.2426699846982956,
-0.15071594715118408,
0.2538949251174927,
0.6169068217277527,
0.5907319784164429,
0.49292027950286865,
0.19687145948410034,
0.1573658138513565,
0.5335155129432678,
-0.261443167924881,
-0.44927605986595154,
0.8272685408592224,
-0.6472266912460327,
-0.8098016381263733,
-0.5608190894126892,
-0.8287897706031799,
-0.3745962381362915,
0.2338198721408844,
-0.09143001586198807,
0.25179141759872437,
0.06883382052183151,
0.30559834837913513,
0.8092848062515259,
-0.3967571258544922,
0.6056118607521057,
0.5782521963119507,
-0.1231154277920723,
-0.11845371127128601,
0.8073016405105591,
0.14887970685958862,
-0.21824151277542114,
0.6019921898841858,
0.40894830226898193,
-0.6587074398994446,
-0.5832169055938721,
-0.0927412137389183,
-0.014641671441495419,
-0.3939548432826996,
-0.4180867373943329,
-0.6494655013084412,
-0.03557214140892029,
0.042768608778715134,
0.2672753930091858,
-0.05292471498250961,
-0.7463065981864929,
-0.07977345585823059,
-0.05297829583287239,
0.40075570344924927,
0.8246748447418213,
-0.2619858682155609,
0.25587862730026245,
-0.7606329917907715,
0.1796700358390808,
0.5802411437034607,
0.623389482498169,
-0.19025902450084686,
-0.05790935829281807,
0.17968961596488953,
0.009799787774682045,
0.1839992105960846,
-1.117242455482483,
0.4055968225002289,
-0.0680912658572197,
0.4276963770389557,
-0.21885496377944946,
0.28407809138298035,
0.20695701241493225,
-0.35992395877838135,
0.7989242672920227,
-0.16394764184951782,
-1.141036033630371,
0.05015864223241806,
-0.7037889361381531,
0.20235851407051086,
0.4504432678222656,
0.28335943818092346,
-0.47964897751808167,
-0.35883304476737976,
-0.41888168454170227,
-0.7993624806404114,
0.7704400420188904,
0.32709944248199463,
0.14526978135108948,
0.22513063251972198,
0.4474508762359619,
0.22546543180942535,
0.5630281567573547,
-1.185022234916687,
-0.06814930588006973,
-0.03752652928233147,
-0.16215822100639343,
0.41663193702697754,
-0.21018445491790771,
-0.27281853556632996,
-0.08266179263591766,
0.1447693258523941,
0.05151881277561188,
0.24364085495471954,
-0.09384670108556747,
0.19852663576602936,
-0.0365690179169178,
0.40013232827186584,
0.28522202372550964,
0.5849554538726807,
-0.13267160952091217,
0.23627987504005432,
0.04011143743991852,
-0.6991288661956787,
0.06906008720397949,
0.02762654237449169,
-0.2397000640630722,
-0.23856253921985626,
-0.016339316964149475,
0.19252784550189972,
0.043210938572883606,
-0.4399327039718628,
0.5178495049476624,
-0.5465579032897949,
-0.1662360429763794,
-0.36480453610420227,
0.12594972550868988,
0.1691899448633194,
0.3076878488063812,
0.4263626039028168,
-0.26123514771461487,
0.24044647812843323,
-0.4885922372341156,
0.7764818072319031,
0.4242195785045624,
-0.3780151307582855,
-0.01334615983068943,
0.8978611826896667,
0.05822521820664406,
-0.4529286324977875,
0.4757656157016754,
-0.1559612900018692,
-0.38649532198905945,
0.8772720098495483,
0.32312068343162537,
0.4573783874511719,
-0.09130492806434631,
0.4020978808403015,
0.002013125456869602,
0.4832335412502289,
-0.1348632425069809,
0.4436192214488983,
-0.18816380202770233,
-0.5745285749435425,
-0.22984175384044647,
-0.4042164981365204,
-0.7186267375946045,
0.22401995956897736,
-0.711870551109314,
-0.26395297050476074,
-0.5391680002212524,
-0.060338716953992844,
-0.2245490700006485,
0.2797580063343048,
-0.4208710491657257,
-0.17732027173042297,
-0.14514926075935364,
0.7978218197822571,
-0.530830442905426,
0.7450820803642273,
0.13131482899188995,
-0.49096760153770447,
-1.0435768365859985,
-0.011296012438833714,
-0.21310561895370483,
-0.7256526350975037,
0.4337138831615448,
-0.19502921402454376,
0.26070311665534973,
0.11247924715280533,
-0.9142857193946838,
-0.9419789910316467,
1.0688856840133667,
0.23222288489341736,
-0.7145469188690186,
-0.03448547422885895,
0.5829182267189026,
0.5188767910003662,
-0.03030090592801571,
0.09240226447582245,
0.6493136882781982,
0.6373817920684814,
-0.1909986138343811,
-0.9234539270401001,
0.39278000593185425,
0.08844603598117828,
-0.4378996789455414,
0.1722082495689392,
-0.5744414329528809,
1.078446865081787,
0.027444517239928246,
-0.16441932320594788,
0.03704775124788284,
0.3859190344810486,
0.20727509260177612,
0.3544573485851288,
0.1801552176475525,
0.18462848663330078,
0.7306759357452393,
-0.5798662304878235,
0.7928433418273926,
-0.017446545884013176,
0.1499968320131302,
1.0466359853744507,
-0.6060016751289368,
0.6137353777885437,
0.3886435627937317,
-0.18816928565502167,
0.20940250158309937,
0.47478416562080383,
-0.13057492673397064,
0.40933096408843994,
0.35364601016044617,
-0.32281363010406494,
-0.14241883158683777,
-0.180265411734581,
-0.33297669887542725,
0.5072648525238037,
0.521432101726532,
0.07355333864688873,
-0.29822680354118347,
-0.31320875883102417,
0.01863359659910202,
0.22611847519874573,
-0.35129523277282715,
0.7254121899604797,
-0.035603705793619156,
-0.22236348688602448,
0.30511730909347534,
-0.054243337363004684,
0.4578838348388672,
-0.5963886380195618,
-0.17270271480083466,
-0.7408331036567688,
-0.12327573448419571,
-0.09363284707069397,
-0.9430340528488159,
0.12884508073329926,
-0.2815124988555908,
0.06843380630016327,
0.05939552187919617,
0.37915778160095215,
-0.39315566420555115,
-0.03811495006084442,
0.11204289644956589,
0.8115582466125488,
-0.09206458181142807,
-0.3371014893054962,
-0.6350290179252625,
0.08760877698659897,
-0.2194952815771103,
0.05451135337352753,
0.38164177536964417,
0.5894040465354919,
-0.289552241563797,
0.7275249361991882,
0.4761523902416229,
-0.12751613557338715,
0.12172184139490128,
-0.049168962985277176,
0.9793545007705688,
-0.5084933638572693,
-0.6805872321128845,
-0.7124444842338562,
0.026229754090309143,
-0.07381217926740646,
0.0034123659133911133,
0.8522647023200989,
0.8098074197769165,
0.42493560910224915,
-0.3798535168170929,
0.4667452871799469,
0.06857895851135254,
0.3014339804649353,
-0.4559067189693451,
1.1111674308776855,
-0.28137853741645813,
0.22259248793125153,
-0.27268359065055847,
-0.8534914255142212,
-0.5612474083900452,
0.26105496287345886,
-0.3250957727432251,
-0.3055077791213989,
0.5234177112579346,
0.8757703900337219,
0.16629940271377563,
0.08242972195148468,
0.33610865473747253,
0.3195692002773285,
0.169124037027359,
0.8830527663230896,
1.2863256931304932,
-0.21161459386348724,
0.7445155382156372,
-0.19044776260852814,
-0.32213303446769714,
0.33922192454338074,
-0.5356018543243408,
-0.6994075775146484,
-0.5952563285827637,
-0.2518947124481201,
-0.2536579370498657,
0.2733064293861389,
0.6549202799797058,
0.3810581862926483,
-0.7004333734512329,
-0.3358902335166931,
-0.2154804766178131,
0.3526134192943573,
-0.2489854097366333,
-0.27974987030029297,
0.45783355832099915,
0.2168571799993515,
-0.4705788791179657,
0.3332895338535309,
0.13310259580612183,
-0.045300159603357315,
-0.12969449162483215,
0.31071579456329346,
0.047988589853048325,
0.07291410118341446,
0.27720141410827637,
0.31701478362083435,
-0.3876282572746277,
-0.3691587746143341,
0.18704262375831604,
0.007506942842155695,
0.11089862883090973,
0.6980563998222351,
-0.821016788482666,
0.01116856373846531,
0.24791669845581055,
0.501156210899353,
0.5211281776428223,
-0.13529625535011292,
0.4813319444656372,
-0.9290194511413574,
0.0747990533709526,
0.5700730085372925,
0.08764996379613876,
-0.025799136608839035,
-0.5276076793670654,
0.49484339356422424,
-0.06220562383532524,
-0.6606839895248413,
-0.9960399866104126,
0.2608143091201782,
-0.8514363169670105,
-0.21528881788253784,
0.8195266723632812,
-0.00047146319411695004,
-0.5834647417068481,
-0.6064238548278809,
-0.110306017100811,
0.19085855782032013,
-0.6488265991210938,
1.0471423864364624,
0.49856093525886536,
-0.14995086193084717,
-0.3163894712924957,
-0.4844793379306793,
0.8899423480033875,
0.24790921807289124,
-0.8720869421958923,
0.5259543061256409,
0.7021616101264954,
0.2397511601448059,
0.12228096276521683,
0.4009128510951996,
-0.2933356463909149,
0.21847273409366608,
0.35133570432662964,
0.05260826647281647,
-0.2641719877719879,
-0.3318708837032318,
-0.44165340065956116,
0.6040890216827393,
-0.13269999623298645,
-0.23008689284324646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10802v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10802v1
|
KGPA: Robustness Evaluation for Large Language Models via Cross-Domain Knowledge Graphs
| 2024-06-16T04:48:43 | 2024-06-16T04:48:43 |
Aihua Pei, Zehua Yang, Shunan Zhu, Ruoxi Cheng, Ju Jia, Lina Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Existing frameworks for assessing robustness of large language models (LLMs)
overly depend on specific benchmarks, increasing costs and failing to evaluate
performance of LLMs in professional domains due to dataset limitations. This
paper proposes a framework that systematically evaluates the robustness of LLMs
under adversarial attack scenarios by leveraging knowledge graphs (KGs). Our
framework generates original prompts from the triplets of knowledge graphs and
creates adversarial prompts by poisoning, assessing the robustness of LLMs
through the results of these adversarial attacks. We systematically evaluate
the effectiveness of this framework and its modules. Experiments show that
adversarial robustness of the ChatGPT family ranks as GPT-4-turbo > GPT-4o >
GPT-3.5-turbo, and the robustness of large language models is influenced by the
professional domains in which they operate.
|
[
-0.4548914432525635,
-0.9070042371749878,
0.2673872709274292,
0.11488130688667297,
0.09457294642925262,
0.20384187996387482,
-0.20617632567882538,
-0.16761398315429688,
-0.2920551598072052,
0.47463443875312805,
-0.19284264743328094,
-0.4867328703403473,
-0.9587366580963135,
0.14837831258773804,
-0.30127543210983276,
0.8428022265434265,
0.08472415804862976,
0.06801683455705643,
-0.2784768044948578,
-0.059621792286634445,
-0.43664664030075073,
-0.5634810328483582,
-0.7323027849197388,
-0.34137162566185,
0.5246648192405701,
-0.16167940199375153,
1.0685657262802124,
0.22559218108654022,
0.5033197999000549,
0.32834744453430176,
-0.16766655445098877,
0.024123182520270348,
-0.605817437171936,
0.28136926889419556,
0.07151012867689133,
-0.5171197056770325,
-0.50107741355896,
-0.10507585853338242,
0.4922718107700348,
0.5612835884094238,
0.16607995331287384,
-0.15351438522338867,
0.1453068107366562,
0.6246746778488159,
-0.7571401596069336,
0.32328033447265625,
-0.907794713973999,
0.05532943457365036,
-0.09031116217374802,
-0.22616827487945557,
-0.49669700860977173,
-0.3675086498260498,
0.09140583127737045,
-0.330751895904541,
-0.14145523309707642,
-0.11982295662164688,
0.7085423469543457,
0.2273731827735901,
-0.5261525511741638,
-0.379617840051651,
-0.3849337697029114,
0.4143110513687134,
-0.6854676008224487,
0.35748329758644104,
0.3795178234577179,
0.6838128566741943,
-0.6411719918251038,
-0.7866490483283997,
-0.515982985496521,
-0.5986939072608948,
-0.010887724347412586,
0.05454205349087715,
-0.4499320685863495,
-0.05906414985656738,
0.18677395582199097,
0.1304624378681183,
-0.7524367570877075,
0.10531571507453918,
0.08427238464355469,
-0.20482024550437927,
0.3969137668609619,
0.24303817749023438,
0.681501567363739,
0.07691502571105957,
-0.36702850461006165,
-0.22871394455432892,
-1.0122708082199097,
-0.16961771249771118,
0.8183752298355103,
0.3277052342891693,
0.023909002542495728,
0.4918561577796936,
-0.15285784006118774,
0.8865814208984375,
-0.23367290198802948,
-0.3594403862953186,
0.004254039376974106,
-0.11961136758327484,
-0.23298819363117218,
-0.34578174352645874,
1.1138824224472046,
0.3916100859642029,
0.517167329788208,
-0.6090812683105469,
0.0271504744887352,
0.0034724243450909853,
0.4313949942588806,
-0.9254981875419617,
-0.3734051585197449,
0.16213899850845337,
-0.25936681032180786,
-0.732776939868927,
-0.2961306571960449,
-0.9218423962593079,
-0.6826971173286438,
0.2607642412185669,
0.45932716131210327,
-0.46722230315208435,
-0.23042912781238556,
-0.12565365433692932,
-0.10190612077713013,
-0.1092681810259819,
-0.0852421224117279,
-0.8837180733680725,
0.16483426094055176,
0.6914349794387817,
0.5999690294265747,
-0.17891621589660645,
-0.5467543601989746,
-0.34293729066848755,
0.07835787534713745,
-0.27381598949432373,
0.6609782576560974,
-0.48453399538993835,
-0.48890450596809387,
0.1965305358171463,
-0.22982066869735718,
-0.2996947169303894,
-0.5904397964477539,
0.6010324954986572,
-0.9776678085327148,
0.010355396196246147,
-0.262399286031723,
-0.4153754711151123,
-0.13842512667179108,
0.8815710544586182,
-0.6284651756286621,
0.8724215030670166,
0.19181840121746063,
-1.0775866508483887,
0.3504813611507416,
-0.44786199927330017,
-0.4551127254962921,
-0.08071836084127426,
-0.018987050279974937,
-0.3693371117115021,
-0.6002228856086731,
0.45343154668807983,
0.541926383972168,
-0.3874746263027191,
0.12561489641666412,
-0.9146551489830017,
0.056930869817733765,
0.474200576543808,
-0.6670063734054565,
1.1518714427947998,
0.23958593606948853,
0.02836180478334427,
0.10900713503360748,
-0.8410438895225525,
0.14140459895133972,
0.40714722871780396,
-0.4538261294364929,
-0.262777715921402,
0.045498982071876526,
-0.44591468572616577,
0.14323346316814423,
0.14303462207317352,
-0.15383915603160858,
0.29754677414894104,
-0.4646703004837036,
0.28704017400741577,
0.6154897809028625,
0.12115450203418732,
0.10053777694702148,
-0.16852428019046783,
0.7816956639289856,
-0.30622097849845886,
0.2519797384738922,
0.14824803173542023,
-0.5428797602653503,
-0.363958477973938,
-0.3946603536605835,
0.3921063244342804,
0.5735119581222534,
-1.034447431564331,
0.4393118917942047,
-0.511491596698761,
-0.7297730445861816,
0.0973443016409874,
0.14639562368392944,
0.4260878562927246,
0.4788420498371124,
0.006835087668150663,
-0.07216588407754898,
-0.25995564460754395,
-0.7211253643035889,
-0.45469194650650024,
-0.28736114501953125,
-0.10975315421819687,
0.22664302587509155,
0.5098891854286194,
-0.2916773855686188,
0.7191066145896912,
-0.4104914963245392,
0.19287109375,
-0.25965893268585205,
-0.0007367096259258687,
0.003504109103232622,
-0.005748237017542124,
0.841530442237854,
-0.691165566444397,
-0.7264589071273804,
-0.000925591157283634,
-0.783394455909729,
-0.25534340739250183,
0.35551902651786804,
0.012732625007629395,
0.02763754315674305,
0.261416494846344,
-0.70833820104599,
0.18678408861160278,
0.6636103391647339,
-0.33206412196159363,
0.707106351852417,
0.09408826380968094,
0.10050546377897263,
-1.010738492012024,
0.25335565209388733,
-0.29359954595565796,
-0.143578439950943,
-0.7888641953468323,
0.3095010817050934,
-0.015383915975689888,
-0.1944831907749176,
-0.37128594517707825,
0.45163217186927795,
-0.14549030363559723,
-0.11094045639038086,
-0.3081532418727875,
0.23067882657051086,
-0.062104757875204086,
0.4382272958755493,
-0.4192553758621216,
0.7458094358444214,
0.6493321657180786,
-0.49097955226898193,
0.7147173285484314,
0.14131803810596466,
-0.33587825298309326,
0.5804392695426941,
-0.4507940411567688,
0.08165862411260605,
0.235319584608078,
0.34240514039993286,
-0.799391508102417,
-0.23000609874725342,
0.38668501377105713,
-0.6429809927940369,
0.5997284650802612,
-0.44187358021736145,
-0.5995950698852539,
-0.27931898832321167,
-0.38170430064201355,
0.19911319017410278,
0.2643308639526367,
-0.651075005531311,
0.6171944737434387,
0.5367588996887207,
-0.20961330831050873,
-0.9428519606590271,
-0.22896035015583038,
0.35024264454841614,
-0.34189748764038086,
-1.0228794813156128,
-0.1108424961566925,
-0.07974094152450562,
-0.3030754029750824,
-0.1090560033917427,
0.02613452635705471,
0.011308101937174797,
0.4272599220275879,
0.13695128262043,
0.13443028926849365,
0.02995256334543228,
-0.4190855324268341,
-0.41526222229003906,
-0.10778918117284775,
0.31669849157333374,
-0.23210956156253815,
0.759454071521759,
-0.06903160363435745,
-0.4193324148654938,
0.04989594966173172,
0.0252548661082983,
0.8240574598312378,
0.03093806840479374,
0.8095638155937195,
0.5675376653671265,
-0.29772165417671204,
-0.2683277428150177,
-0.1319293975830078,
0.11331554502248764,
-0.4822123646736145,
0.4981338381767273,
-0.4324173629283905,
-0.6962623000144958,
0.7970816493034363,
-0.021132903173565865,
-0.21240346133708954,
0.4073815941810608,
0.8665357828140259,
0.4880797564983368,
1.1866999864578247,
0.21830590069293976,
-0.35462456941604614,
0.09835735708475113,
-0.143631249666214,
0.3816879987716675,
-0.6295527815818787,
-0.29636168479919434,
-0.5438022017478943,
0.21978454291820526,
-0.5111836194992065,
-0.04536357894539833,
0.5228084921836853,
0.10221531242132187,
-0.298878937959671,
0.3324562609195709,
-0.05054871737957001,
0.49662256240844727,
0.3401578962802887,
-0.2683797776699066,
-0.018264031037688255,
-0.05530592054128647,
-0.43212494254112244,
0.3272450864315033,
-0.7929860949516296,
-0.5065693855285645,
1.2295808792114258,
0.44942063093185425,
0.7779366970062256,
0.43487387895584106,
0.059603139758110046,
0.23302161693572998,
0.47306373715400696,
-0.7718223333358765,
0.6094096899032593,
-0.02015530876815319,
-0.5919550061225891,
-0.13847297430038452,
-0.6783347129821777,
-0.9917417168617249,
0.30737683176994324,
-0.12598693370819092,
-0.9129539728164673,
-0.13929446041584015,
-0.13419534265995026,
-0.1884855329990387,
0.43377113342285156,
-0.4681291878223419,
0.9282137751579285,
-0.1655530333518982,
-0.06094545125961304,
0.25350773334503174,
-0.557653546333313,
0.5756810307502747,
-0.27979612350463867,
0.024397578090429306,
0.015639834105968475,
0.14714591205120087,
0.5984485745429993,
-0.5042851567268372,
0.9167208671569824,
-0.039752740412950516,
-0.30711090564727783,
0.22254231572151184,
0.2847512364387512,
0.7008976936340332,
-0.0840524435043335,
-0.048371218144893646,
0.21509362757205963,
0.011696812696754932,
-0.25698360800743103,
-0.7177229523658752,
0.8253536820411682,
-0.7727282047271729,
-0.48384344577789307,
-0.2932129502296448,
-0.696205735206604,
-0.7546670436859131,
0.42978978157043457,
0.3083376884460449,
0.38234618306159973,
-0.2629458010196686,
0.055682700127363205,
0.4518422782421112,
-0.34730881452560425,
0.24611760675907135,
0.5693029761314392,
-0.18505463004112244,
-0.6984202265739441,
0.9977978467941284,
0.07767240703105927,
0.5209741592407227,
0.3141610324382782,
0.2358599305152893,
-0.3688843548297882,
-0.8211774826049805,
-0.6057108640670776,
-0.2503453493118286,
-1.0647021532058716,
-0.3797784745693207,
-0.5239892601966858,
-0.19897352159023285,
-0.7379409074783325,
0.01666441559791565,
-0.2373112291097641,
-0.20852069556713104,
0.21039356291294098,
0.10406721383333206,
0.06321777403354645,
0.6514739394187927,
0.22660250961780548,
0.28719303011894226,
-0.7236228585243225,
0.16230888664722443,
0.5844582915306091,
0.284016489982605,
0.04795502498745918,
-0.3673454821109772,
-0.04885916784405708,
-0.19674497842788696,
-0.4236353039741516,
-0.8836443424224854,
0.41906067728996277,
-0.11606404930353165,
0.6891332268714905,
0.5416209101676941,
0.11061698198318481,
0.24085508286952972,
-0.47971829771995544,
0.9031456112861633,
0.056237440556287766,
-0.7421875,
0.16113786399364471,
-0.6554392576217651,
0.11896232515573502,
0.30006617307662964,
0.37977463006973267,
-0.25852954387664795,
-0.4529089331626892,
-0.5868608951568604,
-0.839972972869873,
0.4844045042991638,
0.3200046718120575,
-0.04582054540514946,
0.0011529993498697877,
0.1926802396774292,
-0.09751412272453308,
0.020942291244864464,
-0.7952452301979065,
-0.4344956874847412,
-0.02551807463169098,
-0.2710457742214203,
0.19804410636425018,
-0.35882940888404846,
-0.5265037417411804,
0.3707297444343567,
0.8588476181030273,
-0.11996541917324066,
0.06570648401975632,
-0.29662322998046875,
0.15826420485973358,
0.10448047518730164,
0.2138405591249466,
0.4090709388256073,
0.5878867506980896,
-0.030584942549467087,
0.408600389957428,
0.39727267622947693,
-0.579565703868866,
0.12751919031143188,
0.2854035198688507,
-0.1609027087688446,
-0.5302144289016724,
0.713678777217865,
0.5675527453422546,
-0.05230177193880081,
-0.5967726111412048,
0.6763505935668945,
-0.3530634641647339,
0.1017436683177948,
-0.07995924353599548,
0.1860271841287613,
0.02133263275027275,
0.19378139078617096,
-0.05714096873998642,
0.11523110419511795,
-0.0283961221575737,
-0.4849522113800049,
0.032288141548633575,
0.7634144425392151,
-0.15934765338897705,
-0.1787905991077423,
0.4252816140651703,
0.051298294216394424,
-0.12944035232067108,
0.15957988798618317,
-0.1945110708475113,
-0.9953147768974304,
0.6346006989479065,
0.645588755607605,
0.8092491030693054,
-0.21234764158725739,
-0.130507230758667,
-0.04065167158842087,
0.5243968963623047,
0.11418580263853073,
-0.04575483500957489,
0.12740546464920044,
-0.7499040961265564,
-0.2765752077102661,
-0.4788491129875183,
-0.42796310782432556,
0.33042851090431213,
-0.35325348377227783,
0.13029544055461884,
-0.42786598205566406,
-0.13730491697788239,
0.04268422722816467,
-0.053485848009586334,
-0.30637314915657043,
0.2645726203918457,
0.06723516434431076,
0.9075576066970825,
-0.7383744716644287,
0.8574366569519043,
0.48172813653945923,
-0.16590449213981628,
-0.6492713689804077,
0.22208300232887268,
0.09413015842437744,
-1.0004981756210327,
0.7311903238296509,
-0.07460803538560867,
-0.30420467257499695,
-0.389021098613739,
-0.30213016271591187,
-0.7519185543060303,
0.9731020927429199,
0.7112603783607483,
-0.020386988297104836,
0.3985842764377594,
0.4451644718647003,
0.47786712646484375,
-0.00925480481237173,
0.11208555102348328,
0.6100791692733765,
0.41976287961006165,
0.07652299106121063,
-0.7978312373161316,
0.12598751485347748,
-0.3362736701965332,
-0.19531100988388062,
0.24600303173065186,
-0.5953375101089478,
0.4983721971511841,
0.09976481646299362,
-0.13445712625980377,
0.03435729444026947,
0.45532113313674927,
0.21051642298698425,
0.1926528364419937,
0.594647228717804,
0.7501807808876038,
0.6473602652549744,
-0.08875050395727158,
1.3319833278656006,
-0.4894573390483856,
0.3299471437931061,
0.8647696375846863,
-0.2956621050834656,
0.6178432106971741,
0.14787915349006653,
-0.4527409076690674,
0.043449364602565765,
0.4351644814014435,
-0.05990910902619362,
0.5985610485076904,
0.32839927077293396,
-0.40682047605514526,
-0.11620955169200897,
0.18625175952911377,
-0.4910646975040436,
0.30253174901008606,
0.300549179315567,
-0.2705449163913727,
-0.21855837106704712,
-0.12803728878498077,
0.49138709902763367,
-0.24555076658725739,
-0.09345828741788864,
0.5852946043014526,
0.02207467332482338,
-0.8452407717704773,
0.7969458103179932,
0.12863445281982422,
0.24139322340488434,
-0.8451217412948608,
0.30819591879844666,
-0.02019791305065155,
0.3159080147743225,
-0.057812415063381195,
-0.7495864629745483,
0.1922486573457718,
0.2346707582473755,
0.023120414465665817,
0.2707754373550415,
0.9814543724060059,
-0.1656966507434845,
-0.36019110679626465,
0.5551935434341431,
0.15251228213310242,
-0.06992296874523163,
-0.026754776015877724,
-0.7507863640785217,
0.15958735346794128,
-0.1317465901374817,
-0.49168479442596436,
0.6327694654464722,
0.22179149091243744,
0.1510227918624878,
1.0329221487045288,
0.5702273845672607,
0.1329355239868164,
0.05761699005961418,
0.21663028001785278,
0.9501867294311523,
-0.03107309341430664,
-0.2942146956920624,
-1.091962218284607,
0.07048248499631882,
-0.0744064673781395,
-0.11291591823101044,
1.0902765989303589,
0.26085326075553894,
0.5976278781890869,
0.15637947618961334,
1.0128015279769897,
-0.12494584918022156,
0.15956076979637146,
-0.6119425296783447,
1.0292621850967407,
-0.1871999055147171,
0.5608622431755066,
-0.29105061292648315,
-0.7056704759597778,
-0.636549174785614,
0.14302445948123932,
-0.4680819809436798,
0.2309410125017166,
0.4639744162559509,
0.92392897605896,
0.004611452575773001,
0.08794212341308594,
0.47506317496299744,
0.31733158230781555,
0.5956471562385559,
0.43346840143203735,
0.9076672792434692,
-0.2401992827653885,
0.9316022396087646,
-0.19855205714702606,
-0.25594019889831543,
-0.0869191363453865,
-1.1037030220031738,
-1.3286612033843994,
-0.22316429018974304,
-0.1576726883649826,
-0.754655659198761,
0.09420450031757355,
0.4480833113193512,
0.5581482648849487,
-0.7326180934906006,
0.18613366782665253,
0.062734454870224,
0.13425131142139435,
-0.009965580888092518,
-0.24090568721294403,
0.6901223659515381,
-0.30760836601257324,
-0.5194485783576965,
0.7449331879615784,
0.11089679598808289,
-0.08069761097431183,
-0.5088701248168945,
-0.169533371925354,
0.2317521721124649,
0.16204635798931122,
0.5665207505226135,
0.17634882032871246,
-0.45292073488235474,
-0.3376711308956146,
-0.3107249438762665,
-0.14833863079547882,
-0.30234870314598083,
0.5591207146644592,
-0.42883750796318054,
0.5562727451324463,
0.6903640031814575,
0.8130086064338684,
-0.09504707157611847,
-0.29969269037246704,
0.6521279811859131,
-0.7444069981575012,
-0.046264901757240295,
0.03105064481496811,
0.5781081318855286,
0.43493545055389404,
-0.24143995344638824,
0.5503777265548706,
0.2517240047454834,
-0.6746556162834167,
-0.8696094751358032,
0.3387230634689331,
-0.881649911403656,
-0.3894270956516266,
1.3777436017990112,
-0.6241351366043091,
-0.12995262444019318,
-0.17035749554634094,
-0.054453324526548386,
0.1581471711397171,
0.11392278224229813,
0.8697845339775085,
0.8891012072563171,
0.1282648891210556,
0.39063987135887146,
-0.7223638892173767,
0.4596303403377533,
0.19807662069797516,
-0.8214830756187439,
0.1937427520751953,
0.2138597071170807,
0.5049105882644653,
0.22840388119220734,
0.2656361162662506,
-0.3255135715007782,
-0.008880672045052052,
0.33940842747688293,
-0.2601279318332672,
-0.3175514340400696,
-0.14757642149925232,
-0.19388219714164734,
0.6460304260253906,
0.17769189178943634,
0.09831376373767853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10794v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10794v2
|
Towards Understanding Jailbreak Attacks in LLMs: A Representation Space Analysis
| 2024-06-16T03:38:48 | 2024-06-26T13:50:32 |
Yuping Lin, Pengfei He, Han Xu, Yue Xing, Makoto Yamada, Hui Liu, Jiliang Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are susceptible to a type of attack known as
jailbreaking, which misleads LLMs to output harmful contents. Although there
are diverse jailbreak attack strategies, there is no unified understanding on
why some methods succeed and others fail. This paper explores the behavior of
harmful and harmless prompts in the LLM's representation space to investigate
the intrinsic properties of successful jailbreak attacks. We hypothesize that
successful attacks share some similar properties: They are effective in moving
the representation of the harmful prompt towards the direction to the harmless
prompts. We leverage hidden representations into the objective of existing
jailbreak attacks to move the attacks along the acceptance direction, and
conduct experiments to validate the above hypothesis using the proposed
objective. We hope this study provides new insights into understanding how LLMs
understand harmfulness information.
|
[
-0.12536247074604034,
-0.9108923077583313,
0.9175964593887329,
0.1185341402888298,
-0.22528402507305145,
0.17103742063045502,
-0.13046208024024963,
-0.33264124393463135,
0.37659990787506104,
0.7037279009819031,
-0.5270070433616638,
-0.5929946899414062,
-0.8538640141487122,
-0.13433519005775452,
-0.3435479402542114,
0.8788244724273682,
-0.046461187303066254,
-0.08765804022550583,
0.05466458946466446,
-0.14599445462226868,
-1.0027289390563965,
-0.8024218082427979,
-0.4077947735786438,
0.17132966220378876,
0.6690971851348877,
0.29272234439849854,
0.533145546913147,
0.4989173114299774,
0.5497649908065796,
0.25145772099494934,
-0.2004387378692627,
-0.3075311779975891,
-0.6606645584106445,
0.4099464416503906,
-0.06035567820072174,
-0.7584955096244812,
-0.07907760888338089,
0.12980441749095917,
0.4416002631187439,
0.5618915557861328,
-0.03994115814566612,
-0.2636793255805969,
0.02796175703406334,
0.5627045035362244,
-0.6356908679008484,
-0.18903815746307373,
-0.8347522616386414,
0.08114190399646759,
-0.43048980832099915,
0.11482112854719162,
-0.8106101155281067,
-0.3326738476753235,
-0.4581226706504822,
-0.21125955879688263,
-0.12778885662555695,
0.1878059357404709,
0.458503395318985,
0.12810803949832916,
-0.5284937024116516,
-0.5632753968238831,
-0.5067325234413147,
0.6890548467636108,
-0.5997911095619202,
0.07574310153722763,
0.32317987084388733,
0.46870627999305725,
-0.5111134648323059,
-0.30403250455856323,
-0.1782655566930771,
-0.7591681480407715,
-0.06765667349100113,
-0.3323306441307068,
-0.5434479117393494,
0.04081593453884125,
0.49944597482681274,
0.034640077501535416,
-0.4436434805393219,
0.3698789179325104,
-0.37319883704185486,
-0.3094635009765625,
0.5465208888053894,
0.1716005802154541,
0.6185733675956726,
-0.41013044118881226,
-0.5667233467102051,
0.04689629003405571,
-1.1070833206176758,
-0.11249661445617676,
0.5000434517860413,
0.1636805236339569,
-0.17080257833003998,
0.7933276891708374,
0.3755250871181488,
0.5751211643218994,
-0.09475282579660416,
0.08796141296625137,
-0.1350674331188202,
-0.19946832954883575,
0.043099213391542435,
0.1359068602323532,
0.6999621391296387,
0.3724864423274994,
0.23418448865413666,
-0.4199684262275696,
-0.23949536681175232,
-0.07063905894756317,
0.4695243835449219,
-0.7569924592971802,
0.05579714477062225,
0.22714826464653015,
-0.4822014570236206,
-0.4590306878089905,
0.24498003721237183,
-0.4382765293121338,
-1.0472310781478882,
0.35361307859420776,
0.1903218924999237,
-0.7027249932289124,
-0.18910522758960724,
-0.05025757476687431,
-0.27352064847946167,
0.15489397943019867,
0.1857367753982544,
-0.7496492862701416,
0.28203117847442627,
0.6566458940505981,
0.7067108750343323,
-0.11582639068365097,
-0.09613002091646194,
-0.7077457308769226,
0.1490117460489273,
-0.1603793203830719,
0.6334643959999084,
-0.3625513017177582,
-0.42421460151672363,
-0.21351584792137146,
-0.0957278460264206,
-0.14435845613479614,
-0.6910723447799683,
0.5019203424453735,
-0.802049458026886,
-0.5870963335037231,
-0.49685508012771606,
-0.5883590579032898,
-0.40243297815322876,
0.2949289381504059,
-0.8540213108062744,
0.25341880321502686,
-0.11969448626041412,
-0.7991518378257751,
0.1953333616256714,
-0.5065808296203613,
-0.1689576804637909,
-0.187203049659729,
0.07272911816835403,
-0.19889312982559204,
0.44768470525741577,
-0.005362071096897125,
0.7378097176551819,
0.2838961184024811,
0.27098849415779114,
-0.4731515049934387,
-0.34633949398994446,
0.8690263628959656,
-0.3565182387828827,
0.8416410088539124,
0.4348587393760681,
-0.44288474321365356,
0.2604410946369171,
-0.565686821937561,
-0.4987163841724396,
0.5886396169662476,
-0.06937260925769806,
-0.8017709255218506,
0.2712922990322113,
-0.2610231041908264,
-0.017431046813726425,
0.24920153617858887,
-0.7309901118278503,
0.5157845616340637,
-0.2970312833786011,
0.5025787949562073,
0.812684178352356,
0.3327760100364685,
0.3838534653186798,
-0.014899974688887596,
0.5144270658493042,
0.13941633701324463,
0.22303363680839539,
-0.14911313354969025,
-0.417121022939682,
-0.11279693990945816,
-0.09359589219093323,
0.0013693737564608455,
0.5140520334243774,
-0.39134564995765686,
0.12080059200525284,
0.09048815816640854,
-0.4021364748477936,
-0.19792819023132324,
0.38418081402778625,
0.35382384061813354,
0.26329681277275085,
0.13162854313850403,
-0.15146836638450623,
-0.48917290568351746,
-0.8216779828071594,
-0.656876802444458,
-0.33653944730758667,
0.35479792952537537,
0.11829645186662674,
0.4235856235027313,
-0.5029615759849548,
0.6360695362091064,
-0.3747158348560333,
-0.0023211746010929346,
-0.4506186246871948,
-0.08153398334980011,
0.36555543541908264,
0.3923848867416382,
0.9523178339004517,
-0.6091501712799072,
-0.09281078726053238,
-0.39562276005744934,
-0.81711745262146,
-0.2287103831768036,
-0.25491613149642944,
0.24118615686893463,
-0.1889892965555191,
0.83379727602005,
-0.5730635523796082,
0.5683619976043701,
0.4271198511123657,
-0.8008992075920105,
0.7675405740737915,
0.1339675784111023,
0.11084621399641037,
-0.7511193156242371,
-0.2911987900733948,
-0.0407320000231266,
-0.20411789417266846,
-0.6628541350364685,
0.48912790417671204,
0.1176043301820755,
-0.1488196700811386,
-0.620811939239502,
0.2499520629644394,
-0.4535199701786041,
-0.06477915495634079,
-0.12776921689510345,
0.2512166500091553,
-0.25705480575561523,
0.16690079867839813,
-0.39406636357307434,
0.7233880162239075,
0.4694172739982605,
-0.2987050414085388,
0.28057345747947693,
-0.06296102702617645,
-0.11528147757053375,
0.16798807680606842,
-0.7551909685134888,
0.15382525324821472,
-0.1925201267004013,
-0.15506549179553986,
-1.3624790906906128,
-0.09600173681974411,
0.47950479388237,
-0.46569254994392395,
0.4053075909614563,
-0.34185636043548584,
-0.6068854331970215,
-0.17323675751686096,
-0.5406588315963745,
0.4548832178115845,
0.4475226104259491,
-0.49170631170272827,
0.18589656054973602,
0.41158804297447205,
0.027228180319070816,
-0.6094844341278076,
-0.5687616467475891,
0.2695157527923584,
-0.682361364364624,
-0.6046737432479858,
0.06827101111412048,
0.0856766477227211,
-0.7389450073242188,
-0.11430160701274872,
0.010301771573722363,
0.2625482976436615,
0.6103839874267578,
0.6410045623779297,
0.35112464427948,
-0.030908841639757156,
-0.3747040033340454,
-0.05849233642220497,
-0.08002321422100067,
0.6553362607955933,
-0.0029540599789470434,
0.5869221687316895,
-0.04772473871707916,
-0.6934497952461243,
-0.18562939763069153,
0.36394068598747253,
0.7380344271659851,
0.004009617492556572,
1.0222398042678833,
0.09409784525632858,
-0.24293991923332214,
-0.02075119875371456,
-0.4458935558795929,
-0.00557539751753211,
-0.5021559000015259,
0.38884299993515015,
-0.2513953447341919,
-1.0239673852920532,
0.8743011951446533,
-0.1917971521615982,
0.09611544758081436,
0.24235272407531738,
0.1687200963497162,
-0.13709859549999237,
0.9937595129013062,
0.5442124605178833,
-0.2865852117538452,
0.3828010857105255,
-0.11346464604139328,
0.23160235583782196,
-0.8885644674301147,
-0.4576667845249176,
-0.5812657475471497,
-0.12373823672533035,
-0.5179088115692139,
-0.3003881275653839,
0.2055504322052002,
0.6260170936584473,
-0.3317644000053406,
0.6288838982582092,
-0.3030279874801636,
0.44696512818336487,
0.060461439192295074,
0.0646730437874794,
0.1444145143032074,
-0.010221910662949085,
-0.3466241955757141,
-0.22756943106651306,
-0.4440440833568573,
-0.6268499493598938,
0.9276278018951416,
0.7037534117698669,
1.073096752166748,
0.5086222290992737,
0.9330412149429321,
0.36250486969947815,
0.3422281742095947,
-0.8658508062362671,
0.6367248892784119,
0.07993508875370026,
-0.5335226058959961,
-0.026058757677674294,
-0.3261100649833679,
-1.1053422689437866,
0.05835577845573425,
-0.06026851385831833,
-1.328015923500061,
0.005338636692613363,
-0.022470830008387566,
-0.1565360426902771,
0.5784178376197815,
-0.7636112570762634,
0.8005152940750122,
-0.40803104639053345,
-0.26211413741111755,
-0.36851879954338074,
-0.6567184329032898,
0.6028610467910767,
0.017131291329860687,
0.5100083947181702,
0.04603233560919762,
0.11997929215431213,
0.9048524498939514,
-0.4003840982913971,
1.1179527044296265,
-0.64813631772995,
-0.2400519847869873,
0.3481285870075226,
0.6213228702545166,
0.6816394925117493,
0.13481493294239044,
-0.10285210609436035,
0.16771343350410461,
-0.4046860635280609,
-0.2748098373413086,
-0.7733103632926941,
0.7058188915252686,
-0.6208755373954773,
-0.9136660099029541,
-0.2725614011287689,
-0.42126062512397766,
-0.13444575667381287,
0.15951867401599884,
0.10192293673753738,
0.02346058562397957,
-0.17158617079257965,
-0.1968003213405609,
0.8768681287765503,
-0.6177217364311218,
0.4759571850299835,
0.35797542333602905,
-0.5779674649238586,
-0.10710898041725159,
0.7313642501831055,
0.05535164102911949,
0.2514532208442688,
0.0672021135687828,
-0.0012043868191540241,
-0.2398061454296112,
-1.0482220649719238,
-0.24734169244766235,
0.366519570350647,
-0.9150630235671997,
-0.12386980652809143,
-0.3768366873264313,
-0.31403234601020813,
-0.2388501912355423,
-0.15119104087352753,
-0.12682805955410004,
-0.263372540473938,
-0.23827384412288666,
-0.44740262627601624,
0.32448533177375793,
1.1486725807189941,
-0.03154566511511803,
0.41487351059913635,
-1.0585241317749023,
0.29855382442474365,
0.18362537026405334,
0.1422375738620758,
0.02467823587357998,
-0.5521231293678284,
-0.011431909166276455,
-0.21841605007648468,
-0.31247472763061523,
-1.5550341606140137,
0.1822146475315094,
-0.3082302212715149,
0.6997873187065125,
0.6420385837554932,
-0.014651880599558353,
0.3156222999095917,
-0.5411568880081177,
0.8417061567306519,
0.27307066321372986,
-0.8965790271759033,
0.9880052208900452,
-0.4634843170642853,
-0.13362954556941986,
0.6161394119262695,
0.3057463765144348,
-0.5465784668922424,
-0.6491568088531494,
-0.634666919708252,
-0.7838979959487915,
0.3252463936805725,
0.18822139501571655,
0.463131308555603,
-0.046677932143211365,
0.6441924571990967,
0.22458985447883606,
-0.0556161068379879,
-0.978614866733551,
-0.5318493843078613,
-0.07517939060926437,
0.13398252427577972,
0.11854075640439987,
-0.49110376834869385,
-0.0627504363656044,
-0.021303968504071236,
0.23257504403591156,
0.34665974974632263,
0.4755127727985382,
-0.08004087209701538,
-0.3456558287143707,
0.0801137313246727,
0.4990184009075165,
0.5104538202285767,
0.3567694425582886,
-0.22991040349006653,
0.29682862758636475,
-0.017819859087467194,
-0.7073222398757935,
0.4428057372570038,
-0.06507627665996552,
-0.00836155004799366,
-0.197850301861763,
0.6893227696418762,
0.7865757942199707,
-0.02982504665851593,
-0.695553183555603,
0.7578877210617065,
-0.2456284463405609,
0.19161751866340637,
-0.08896680921316147,
0.49279919266700745,
-0.01451957132667303,
0.18431444466114044,
0.4591843783855438,
0.22838518023490906,
0.14577224850654602,
-0.6676340699195862,
0.17062115669250488,
0.5624719858169556,
-0.5593241453170776,
-0.36396297812461853,
0.6735257506370544,
-0.10282459110021591,
-0.19873003661632538,
0.6889951825141907,
-0.25162366032600403,
-0.6375840306282043,
0.7656830549240112,
0.8750789761543274,
0.8060749173164368,
-0.14989876747131348,
0.18804626166820526,
0.23710604012012482,
0.7243682742118835,
0.4360814392566681,
0.12489749491214752,
-0.08557651937007904,
-0.7397336959838867,
-0.4840908646583557,
-0.3402288854122162,
-0.22960016131401062,
0.13465462625026703,
-0.763234555721283,
-0.04757160320878029,
-0.7397118210792542,
-0.07044658064842224,
-0.17741818726062775,
-0.4006074070930481,
-0.17426562309265137,
-0.13939562439918518,
0.38755959272384644,
1.08364737033844,
-0.9145012497901917,
0.5975479483604431,
0.6505711674690247,
-0.09883975982666016,
-0.9485037922859192,
-0.02565120905637741,
0.22990979254245758,
-0.970798134803772,
0.7293171882629395,
0.4201413691043854,
0.05931960046291351,
-0.42945489287376404,
-0.9497662782669067,
-0.7304592132568359,
0.5929301381111145,
0.6693980097770691,
-0.8612795472145081,
0.19087481498718262,
0.15090470016002655,
0.18539384007453918,
-0.08751759678125381,
-0.23051832616329193,
0.6334485411643982,
0.5076774954795837,
-0.12029851973056793,
-0.3799070119857788,
0.6097286343574524,
-0.20644579827785492,
-0.08265981078147888,
0.43215376138687134,
-0.2824792265892029,
0.5089290142059326,
-0.7880185842514038,
-0.2194049209356308,
0.0004454428271856159,
0.5435540676116943,
0.7170062065124512,
0.28146958351135254,
0.40503036975860596,
0.5384545922279358,
0.5923579931259155,
-0.21018163859844208,
1.30830717086792,
-0.048563212156295776,
0.1384347677230835,
0.7883261442184448,
-0.030908720567822456,
0.5615727305412292,
0.7890631556510925,
-0.03268396854400635,
0.6388245224952698,
0.49678531289100647,
-0.01935594342648983,
0.7827264070510864,
0.644514262676239,
-0.040933385491371155,
0.06207694858312607,
0.21253329515457153,
-0.17192982137203217,
0.2480582296848297,
0.6550742387771606,
-0.3388718068599701,
-0.29502928256988525,
0.7050415277481079,
0.3280087411403656,
0.047135062515735626,
-0.5134601593017578,
0.8232396245002747,
0.2788859009742737,
-0.3202480375766754,
0.5790456533432007,
0.2473442703485489,
0.6753438115119934,
-0.5562266111373901,
-0.030624430626630783,
-0.06165211275219917,
-0.3575035035610199,
-0.3358195126056671,
-1.0533652305603027,
0.5864302515983582,
0.1994599848985672,
-0.07000427693128586,
0.04198962822556496,
1.0619428157806396,
0.2437882125377655,
-0.05056539550423622,
0.6708694100379944,
0.18113228678703308,
0.26837220788002014,
-0.08402226120233536,
-0.639865517616272,
0.43095308542251587,
0.10084373503923416,
-0.26982179284095764,
0.4034186005592346,
0.3290272057056427,
-0.19445423781871796,
0.6671105027198792,
0.40267646312713623,
0.363006591796875,
0.2469557225704193,
0.06327079236507416,
0.9466195702552795,
-0.8453972339630127,
-0.3786662220954895,
-1.3471425771713257,
0.6349403262138367,
0.042633943259716034,
0.10859788209199905,
1.0115118026733398,
0.11034998297691345,
0.41753190755844116,
0.1481074094772339,
0.6692764163017273,
-0.22014345228672028,
-0.0007283956510946155,
-0.7435430884361267,
0.8193047642707825,
-0.10980374366044998,
0.8992165923118591,
-0.4477532207965851,
-0.8063685894012451,
-0.32165786623954773,
0.5210687518119812,
-0.6092761754989624,
-0.17676226794719696,
0.5615779757499695,
0.6598098874092102,
0.14332900941371918,
-0.024970782920718193,
0.19987045228481293,
0.5276514887809753,
0.3382284641265869,
0.6724316477775574,
1.5109049081802368,
-0.31581494212150574,
0.27917858958244324,
0.004196738824248314,
-0.26074978709220886,
0.0373421236872673,
-0.7610458731651306,
-1.0679185390472412,
-0.4157949388027191,
-0.16671383380889893,
-0.6100696921348572,
0.21141290664672852,
0.5487850308418274,
0.47112709283828735,
-0.6945229768753052,
-0.03181364759802818,
-0.09039639681577682,
0.4140383005142212,
0.0480627603828907,
-0.2549037039279938,
0.2515696883201599,
-0.22117125988006592,
-0.013501725159585476,
0.5863314867019653,
0.2786584794521332,
0.08544965088367462,
-0.27811506390571594,
-0.00020261477038729936,
0.21000713109970093,
0.01564420945942402,
0.5353766679763794,
0.2201382964849472,
-0.4995785057544708,
-0.3080037534236908,
-0.13139474391937256,
-0.2383003681898117,
0.009297133423388004,
0.9862697124481201,
-0.7414533495903015,
0.07914678752422333,
0.20459839701652527,
0.6327580213546753,
0.21370342373847961,
-0.22718821465969086,
0.2965323030948639,
-0.8913500308990479,
0.2040846049785614,
0.207265704870224,
0.5119879841804504,
0.220826655626297,
-0.8058893084526062,
0.19188232719898224,
0.15053336322307587,
-0.3319525420665741,
-0.8255600333213806,
0.37555596232414246,
-0.9414889216423035,
-0.7557678818702698,
1.2805806398391724,
-0.3519684970378876,
-0.46047767996788025,
-0.20583997666835785,
-0.5061144828796387,
-0.021042287349700928,
-0.3755962550640106,
0.6955708861351013,
0.5445643067359924,
-0.16687443852424622,
0.017970707267522812,
-0.5929793119430542,
0.12760187685489655,
0.24167855083942413,
-0.5806920528411865,
0.27607694268226624,
0.5416191816329956,
0.44303590059280396,
0.27738142013549805,
0.2873893976211548,
-0.43761882185935974,
0.2854284346103668,
-0.16713647544384003,
-0.3680797219276428,
-0.17627379298210144,
-0.2315339893102646,
-0.596344530582428,
0.5114063024520874,
0.4629957675933838,
-0.05050993338227272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10786v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10786v1
|
Evaluating LLMs with Multiple Problems at once: A New Paradigm for Probing LLM Capabilities
| 2024-06-16T02:52:32 | 2024-06-16T02:52:32 |
Zhengxiang Wang, Jordan Kodner, Owen Rambow
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Current LLM evaluation predominantly performs evaluation with prompts
comprising single problems. We propose multi-problem evaluation as an
additional approach to study the multiple problem handling capabilities of
LLMs. We present a systematic study in this regard by comprehensively examining
7 LLMs on 4 related types of tasks constructed from 6 classification
benchmarks. The 4 task types include traditional single-problem tasks,
homogeneous multi-problem tasks, and two index selection tasks that embed the
multi-problem tasks. We find that LLMs are competent multi-problem solvers:
they generally perform (nearly) as well on multi-problem tasks as on
single-problem tasks. Furthermore, contrary to common expectation, they often
do not suffer from a positional bias with long inputs. This makes multi-problem
prompting a simple and cost-efficient prompting method of practical
significance. However, our results also strongly indicate that LLMs lack true
understanding: they perform significantly worse in the two index selection
tasks than in the multi-problem task under various evaluation settings,
although they can indeed do index selection in general.
|
[
-0.6688469052314758,
-0.5870853066444397,
0.8695670366287231,
0.6831669211387634,
0.016142981126904488,
0.32510337233543396,
-0.18869651854038239,
-0.3150101602077484,
-0.0635693296790123,
0.24015532433986664,
-0.8166934251785278,
-0.18465931713581085,
-0.8354010581970215,
0.5519347190856934,
-0.20105421543121338,
0.7607937455177307,
-0.25198259949684143,
0.3691757321357727,
-0.4531940221786499,
-0.12206330895423889,
-0.7891379594802856,
-0.5156813263893127,
-0.7289121747016907,
-0.40549376606941223,
0.6033598780632019,
0.7807570099830627,
0.24733661115169525,
0.08867161720991135,
0.8987780809402466,
0.30741214752197266,
-0.18072813749313354,
0.47883105278015137,
-0.3522956073284149,
0.14747896790504456,
0.20906387269496918,
-0.5561473369598389,
-0.2613094747066498,
0.3694765865802765,
0.6335225701332092,
0.6231589913368225,
0.07946419715881348,
0.521506130695343,
0.28901228308677673,
0.7222536206245422,
-0.7526493668556213,
-0.11276793479919434,
-0.5229859352111816,
0.2080652415752411,
0.019874149933457375,
-0.1619257628917694,
-0.38018375635147095,
-0.24391065537929535,
0.11389201134443283,
-0.5044790506362915,
0.05536949634552002,
0.05789002403616905,
0.12715505063533783,
0.4575175642967224,
-0.6190713047981262,
-0.4423891007900238,
-0.5594768524169922,
0.8355697393417358,
0.04847215861082077,
0.0543244443833828,
-0.04737820848822594,
0.5140597224235535,
-0.048487503081560135,
-0.38284945487976074,
-0.17038308084011078,
-0.30781611800193787,
0.04508873075246811,
0.4045781195163727,
-0.07228730618953705,
-0.1313808560371399,
0.38472941517829895,
0.1857091337442398,
-0.25169748067855835,
0.27018141746520996,
-0.4373714327812195,
-0.28323498368263245,
0.620656430721283,
0.5827807784080505,
-0.040033068507909775,
-0.29276636242866516,
-0.8350441455841064,
0.11156407743692398,
-0.5886133909225464,
0.2758861184120178,
0.17325438559055328,
0.09405125677585602,
0.23560620844364166,
0.653127133846283,
0.0191204696893692,
0.5647301077842712,
-0.1182350292801857,
-0.3932499289512634,
-0.039415884763002396,
-0.7277951240539551,
0.030259110033512115,
-0.2790680229663849,
0.5069996118545532,
0.26393455266952515,
0.13175860047340393,
0.16144567728042603,
-0.22788244485855103,
0.12896709144115448,
0.4464603662490845,
-0.2617025077342987,
0.21589383482933044,
0.3457872271537781,
-0.5556498169898987,
-0.1000053733587265,
-0.10571995377540588,
-0.7927883863449097,
-0.42379283905029297,
-0.26336660981178284,
0.6930191516876221,
-0.2074982225894928,
-0.09987188875675201,
0.21100851893424988,
-0.41925373673439026,
0.12911483645439148,
0.35570311546325684,
-0.18428677320480347,
0.21803081035614014,
0.5938109755516052,
0.7465356588363647,
-0.6947063207626343,
-0.6382890939712524,
-0.638110339641571,
-0.19611838459968567,
-0.11792547255754471,
1.0409541130065918,
-0.44374600052833557,
-0.6396562457084656,
-0.15295220911502838,
-0.26911014318466187,
-0.33463579416275024,
-0.7528349757194519,
0.6034298539161682,
-0.2276347279548645,
-0.16175174713134766,
-0.5758417248725891,
-0.14895713329315186,
-0.004351294133812189,
0.5822176933288574,
-0.7531845569610596,
1.0066238641738892,
-0.12455239146947861,
-0.6236481666564941,
0.3924681842327118,
-0.9782161712646484,
-0.2315932661294937,
-0.12288035452365875,
-0.039964888244867325,
-0.1670960932970047,
0.1675863415002823,
0.252716988325119,
0.4423355460166931,
-0.5083354115486145,
-0.036004792898893356,
-0.3353155851364136,
-0.5466601252555847,
0.3226127624511719,
-0.5480631589889526,
0.5468947887420654,
0.18830938637256622,
-0.036127205938100815,
0.20368003845214844,
-0.6683825850486755,
0.04388558119535446,
0.12205217033624649,
-0.6134113073348999,
-0.10861553251743317,
-0.07117035239934921,
-0.44321778416633606,
0.2785060405731201,
0.42910271883010864,
-0.3837922513484955,
0.3838355243206024,
0.20704390108585358,
0.2751361131668091,
0.7227917313575745,
0.06058603897690773,
-0.032222725450992584,
-0.6673208475112915,
0.7879827618598938,
0.017528196796774864,
0.36421406269073486,
-0.22317779064178467,
-0.5582239031791687,
-0.9663357138633728,
-0.3751954734325409,
-0.19936800003051758,
0.7539920806884766,
-0.7369997501373291,
-0.1546771377325058,
0.1795136034488678,
-0.47136855125427246,
-0.5940729975700378,
0.27495279908180237,
0.6359585523605347,
0.21816852688789368,
0.5023271441459656,
-0.21400557458400726,
-0.1853073239326477,
-1.0042049884796143,
-0.4020734131336212,
0.14306731522083282,
0.16558721661567688,
0.3820139765739441,
0.6810762882232666,
0.03853652626276016,
0.46230342984199524,
-0.3477188050746918,
-0.37858831882476807,
-0.06895465403795242,
0.38848739862442017,
0.2124830186367035,
0.20144738256931305,
0.07715056836605072,
-0.5909467935562134,
-0.33499929308891296,
-0.3760330379009247,
-0.619941234588623,
-0.04082170128822327,
-0.0983971431851387,
0.27528899908065796,
0.008077101781964302,
0.2782849371433258,
-0.6488301753997803,
0.13158205151557922,
0.14443475008010864,
0.02239668183028698,
0.9982695579528809,
-0.2643139064311981,
0.2434716522693634,
-0.5545353293418884,
-0.0663190484046936,
0.13235868513584137,
0.2771817445755005,
-0.6585809588432312,
0.15648135542869568,
0.1636568307876587,
-0.03507387638092041,
-0.6171616911888123,
0.32369041442871094,
-0.9016639590263367,
-0.4163718521595001,
0.015209190547466278,
0.25252875685691833,
0.05323369428515434,
0.3301304876804352,
-0.39137136936187744,
0.8723184466362,
0.629158616065979,
-0.8512892723083496,
0.7022948861122131,
-0.09949586540460587,
-0.23114484548568726,
0.7989755272865295,
-0.5136138796806335,
0.43934008479118347,
-0.3200348913669586,
-0.10338800400495529,
-1.3663572072982788,
0.2879296541213989,
0.03730064257979393,
-0.12659546732902527,
0.07015994191169739,
0.1742342710494995,
-0.546479344367981,
-0.7876173853874207,
-0.7754525542259216,
0.28486502170562744,
0.025777116417884827,
-0.46622729301452637,
0.37419670820236206,
-0.11478454619646072,
-0.15063537657260895,
-0.7776941657066345,
-0.4543837904930115,
-0.2339244782924652,
-0.5366213917732239,
-0.47803932428359985,
0.17112508416175842,
-0.292437881231308,
-0.3376655876636505,
-0.051287855952978134,
-0.581606388092041,
-0.11392669379711151,
0.5192731022834778,
0.21730610728263855,
0.24451491236686707,
0.07006843388080597,
0.15199315547943115,
-0.12081556767225266,
-0.4208257496356964,
0.17860917747020721,
0.20394425094127655,
0.27753162384033203,
-0.2626917362213135,
-0.9047210216522217,
-0.23109003901481628,
0.48459282517433167,
0.5902750492095947,
-0.6181517243385315,
0.1239457055926323,
0.6863148808479309,
-0.19693514704704285,
-0.06703795492649078,
-0.8322300910949707,
-0.11827923357486725,
-0.3924252986907959,
0.44156819581985474,
-0.9944427609443665,
-0.8250125646591187,
0.48045095801353455,
-0.4058001637458801,
0.2920220196247101,
0.3887068033218384,
0.5192749500274658,
-0.07372280955314636,
0.9154414534568787,
0.3905643820762634,
0.01117464154958725,
-0.06666456162929535,
-0.3412063717842102,
0.10871890187263489,
-1.0280295610427856,
-0.5296951532363892,
-0.8673962950706482,
-0.43261945247650146,
-0.2833615243434906,
-0.5341010689735413,
0.9651772975921631,
0.24614648520946503,
-0.11258295178413391,
0.09753913432359695,
-0.6596857905387878,
0.3516228199005127,
0.38308432698249817,
-0.021896040067076683,
0.5250759124755859,
-0.24824608862400055,
-0.20815235376358032,
0.06965626031160355,
-0.8176936507225037,
-0.5360153317451477,
1.260990023612976,
0.28907591104507446,
0.6943569183349609,
0.12859274446964264,
0.762509822845459,
-0.009976621717214584,
0.566417932510376,
-1.061996579170227,
0.5152609348297119,
-0.055996526032686234,
-0.714707612991333,
-0.433437705039978,
-0.14402024447917938,
-1.177615761756897,
0.6940735578536987,
-0.1880854368209839,
-0.7128176689147949,
-0.03218116983771324,
-0.10170438140630722,
-0.6078982353210449,
0.09049202501773834,
-0.6473613977432251,
0.695178747177124,
-0.6780431270599365,
-0.23833370208740234,
-0.4998413622379303,
-0.37245017290115356,
0.6904848217964172,
-0.2912105321884155,
0.5249326229095459,
-0.3082248866558075,
-0.34710565209388733,
0.5778306722640991,
0.23455947637557983,
0.5223726034164429,
-0.2259654700756073,
-0.029228800907731056,
0.21863462030887604,
0.026057614013552666,
0.20383360981941223,
0.36552250385284424,
-0.3317984342575073,
-0.2517947852611542,
0.30923864245414734,
-0.1749892681837082,
-0.7097706198692322,
0.4210997223854065,
-0.5467143654823303,
-0.9259802103042603,
-0.4278884828090668,
-0.5574767589569092,
-0.43636301159858704,
0.11697788536548615,
0.0636168047785759,
0.343228280544281,
-0.0474749431014061,
-0.05182493105530739,
0.4917837381362915,
-0.035498037934303284,
0.6327779293060303,
0.5551558136940002,
0.07009338587522507,
-0.14843319356441498,
0.7638487219810486,
0.2230614572763443,
0.3052285611629486,
0.13824695348739624,
0.12382514774799347,
-0.3514309525489807,
-0.7876754999160767,
-0.32914450764656067,
-0.0572526678442955,
-0.7888150811195374,
-0.22768495976924896,
-0.34869664907455444,
-0.009937780909240246,
0.24934782087802887,
0.14776962995529175,
-0.2945394814014435,
-0.12127869576215744,
-0.32540830969810486,
0.22356100380420685,
-0.014249563217163086,
0.9014208316802979,
-0.07739067077636719,
0.049137379974126816,
-0.7910988330841064,
0.616571843624115,
0.680820107460022,
0.39614179730415344,
-0.010637749917805195,
-0.2579365074634552,
0.021849919110536575,
-0.297748327255249,
-0.623854398727417,
-1.0878627300262451,
-0.09687082469463348,
0.03665575012564659,
1.1103100776672363,
0.29556503891944885,
0.011053935624659061,
0.6827824115753174,
-0.40444737672805786,
0.7306363582611084,
0.3124900460243225,
-0.8718797564506531,
0.3897702693939209,
0.25053727626800537,
0.24329718947410583,
0.6337419748306274,
0.891427218914032,
-0.3542092442512512,
-0.14171048998832703,
-0.17113767564296722,
-0.48490726947784424,
0.7592868804931641,
-0.10890871286392212,
-0.006297019310295582,
-0.031911808997392654,
0.5124055743217468,
0.17110739648342133,
0.3641129732131958,
-0.5293624997138977,
-0.6211562156677246,
0.07836449891328812,
0.40049514174461365,
-0.13836146891117096,
-0.5119221210479736,
-0.4167347848415375,
-0.07041455060243607,
0.21456369757652283,
-0.22369064390659332,
0.5911568999290466,
0.40439164638519287,
-0.1925041526556015,
0.06537889689207077,
0.7736220955848694,
0.7572012543678284,
0.853484034538269,
-0.10963881760835648,
0.296653687953949,
0.4285331964492798,
-0.027272500097751617,
0.4659423232078552,
0.1836315393447876,
0.3949868381023407,
-0.19431057572364807,
0.39584389328956604,
0.5528297424316406,
0.20989367365837097,
-0.414886474609375,
0.3012004494667053,
0.10700340569019318,
-0.4315548241138458,
0.10557837784290314,
0.029511334374547005,
0.013850847259163857,
0.318426251411438,
0.7370349764823914,
-0.06060267984867096,
0.36376065015792847,
-0.6229857206344604,
-0.011812392622232437,
0.7751742005348206,
-0.12442921102046967,
0.01135795097798109,
0.14602994918823242,
0.1734710931777954,
-0.5726883411407471,
0.3127416670322418,
-0.43306732177734375,
-0.5906644463539124,
0.7881158590316772,
0.5822080969810486,
0.6157279014587402,
-0.15642662346363068,
0.18133112788200378,
0.13455742597579956,
0.5991124510765076,
0.002814740873873234,
0.607910692691803,
0.036419112235307693,
-0.8094323873519897,
-0.6066017746925354,
-0.23772737383842468,
-0.8062970638275146,
0.36474183201789856,
-0.9049227237701416,
0.0650017037987709,
-0.36024317145347595,
-0.39290449023246765,
0.12027628719806671,
0.2111177146434784,
-0.818722665309906,
-0.14874237775802612,
-0.0870550125837326,
0.9366765022277832,
-0.405904084444046,
0.24978071451187134,
1.0317392349243164,
-0.03175511956214905,
-0.56884765625,
-0.30768972635269165,
0.21280160546302795,
-1.0078604221343994,
0.6831141710281372,
0.42094236612319946,
-0.21904756128787994,
-0.23438850045204163,
-0.21816712617874146,
-0.872725248336792,
1.0268207788467407,
0.27599743008613586,
-0.4361342191696167,
0.12679190933704376,
-0.12385766953229904,
0.2729797959327698,
-0.41734644770622253,
0.44633281230926514,
0.714034914970398,
1.0468729734420776,
-0.31683018803596497,
-1.367958903312683,
0.043041836470365524,
-0.14786788821220398,
-0.07216662913560867,
0.05799580737948418,
-0.9341013431549072,
1.0076093673706055,
-0.42083969712257385,
-0.05697283893823624,
-0.004884303547441959,
0.038867752999067307,
0.8332574367523193,
0.5456077456474304,
0.7541794776916504,
0.18663950264453888,
0.7657596468925476,
-0.1108984425663948,
0.8678129315376282,
-0.2659791111946106,
0.2566893994808197,
0.7531988024711609,
-0.450928658246994,
0.42374059557914734,
0.7322859764099121,
-0.4588574171066284,
-0.01407113391906023,
0.7682133316993713,
-0.08969046920537949,
0.13040988147258759,
0.8448632955551147,
-0.07308770716190338,
-0.41130074858665466,
-0.07847298681735992,
-0.34987491369247437,
0.566714346408844,
0.36197829246520996,
0.3826335072517395,
-0.37534594535827637,
0.19481399655342102,
-0.4507443904876709,
-0.21485237777233124,
-0.5047956109046936,
0.42911961674690247,
0.22676143050193787,
-0.867975115776062,
0.4919598698616028,
0.06831441819667816,
0.926351010799408,
-0.40984317660331726,
-0.1067831739783287,
-0.06865008175373077,
-0.20911000669002533,
-0.23134909570217133,
-0.7576427459716797,
0.20190033316612244,
-0.1422881931066513,
-0.06461329758167267,
-0.43540826439857483,
0.9699130058288574,
0.03342749923467636,
-0.380935937166214,
0.3555583357810974,
1.1517846584320068,
0.34030681848526,
-0.26248350739479065,
-0.7041633129119873,
0.16408662497997284,
-0.25856512784957886,
-0.24609503149986267,
0.18818546831607819,
0.19705982506275177,
-0.07415030151605606,
1.0581990480422974,
0.37236839532852173,
-0.05798337236046791,
0.23406073451042175,
0.11016745120286942,
0.6675544381141663,
-0.7441299557685852,
0.02355956844985485,
-0.700674295425415,
0.47818151116371155,
0.269061803817749,
-0.31732115149497986,
0.8706501126289368,
0.3237985670566559,
0.502885103225708,
-0.006761934608221054,
0.6954153180122375,
0.35902026295661926,
0.30304843187332153,
-0.6068196892738342,
0.01992734707891941,
-0.7383385896682739,
0.4143645167350769,
-0.16608211398124695,
-0.8987189531326294,
-0.13121744990348816,
0.37332940101623535,
-0.2494787871837616,
0.2137884944677353,
0.998452365398407,
0.3616027235984802,
0.2637389004230499,
-0.03183095529675484,
0.2060181200504303,
-0.3307247757911682,
0.0453643798828125,
0.8925873041152954,
1.5461021661758423,
0.040530234575271606,
0.6369080543518066,
-0.22798143327236176,
-0.19596804678440094,
-0.1493786722421646,
-0.7842158079147339,
-0.8298823833465576,
-0.2854773700237274,
-0.12550008296966553,
0.1243734285235405,
-0.25210750102996826,
0.7414320111274719,
0.5889027118682861,
-0.4363439083099365,
-0.3564518690109253,
0.4345352053642273,
0.7265328764915466,
-0.5240483283996582,
-0.16085699200630188,
0.08674688637256622,
-0.710565447807312,
-0.629977822303772,
0.8568163514137268,
0.46290820837020874,
-0.1347794383764267,
-0.4633665680885315,
0.035222601145505905,
-0.03654009476304054,
-0.20747347176074982,
0.7133108377456665,
-0.18469670414924622,
-0.7727466225624084,
-0.1343807578086853,
0.3224185109138489,
-0.0260580126196146,
0.15387022495269775,
1.0779507160186768,
-0.5208482146263123,
0.3467935025691986,
0.08601156622171402,
0.787557065486908,
0.641524076461792,
-0.14291076362133026,
0.010595377534627914,
-0.43916863203048706,
-0.2029063105583191,
0.12869258224964142,
0.3324536681175232,
-0.10009795427322388,
-0.31851324439048767,
0.36685824394226074,
0.0949188619852066,
-0.4243937134742737,
-0.8327230215072632,
0.30655190348625183,
-0.7889114022254944,
-0.36968961358070374,
0.9320394992828369,
-0.07844966650009155,
0.3076015114784241,
-0.34566178917884827,
-0.13344649970531464,
0.05516331270337105,
-0.13079257309436798,
0.41006261110305786,
0.94313645362854,
-0.7825634479522705,
-0.18221965432167053,
-0.7875474691390991,
0.23207251727581024,
0.9190371036529541,
-0.8542255163192749,
-0.3880895972251892,
0.3971300721168518,
0.30415308475494385,
0.5176701545715332,
0.754369854927063,
-0.019702069461345673,
0.4202910363674164,
-0.3195582628250122,
-0.24271509051322937,
-0.32399147748947144,
-0.7938152551651001,
-0.7244403958320618,
0.5793868899345398,
0.40943410992622375,
-0.27609241008758545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10785v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10785v1
|
ShareLoRA: Parameter Efficient and Robust Large Language Model Fine-tuning via Shared Low-Rank Adaptation
| 2024-06-16T02:52:28 | 2024-06-16T02:52:28 |
Yurun Song, Junchen Zhao, Ian G. Harris, Sangeetha Abdu Jyothi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study introduces an approach to optimize Parameter Efficient Fine Tuning
(PEFT) for Pretrained Language Models (PLMs) by implementing a Shared Low Rank
Adaptation (ShareLoRA). By strategically deploying ShareLoRA across different
layers and adapting it for the Query, Key, and Value components of
self-attention layers, we achieve a substantial reduction in the number of
training parameters and memory usage. Importantly, ShareLoRA not only maintains
model performance but also exhibits robustness in both classification and
generation tasks across a variety of models, including RoBERTa, GPT-2, LLaMA
and LLaMA2. It demonstrates superior transfer learning capabilities compared to
standard LoRA applications and mitigates overfitting by sharing weights across
layers. Our findings affirm that ShareLoRA effectively boosts parameter
efficiency while ensuring scalable and high-quality performance across
different language model architectures.
|
[
-0.47863930463790894,
-0.7436758875846863,
0.47229671478271484,
0.5532810688018799,
-0.31111714243888855,
-0.058658137917518616,
-0.45119956135749817,
-0.3083559572696686,
-0.18392151594161987,
0.5434787273406982,
-0.28194883465766907,
-0.4416354298591614,
-0.6341668367385864,
-0.2687435746192932,
-0.05335615575313568,
1.023597002029419,
-0.09483438730239868,
-0.025253454223275185,
0.3653441071510315,
-0.3446308970451355,
-0.6336413621902466,
-0.6710549592971802,
-1.0065269470214844,
-0.1590573936700821,
0.7887917757034302,
0.5373178124427795,
0.6299657821655273,
0.3110977113246918,
0.302228718996048,
0.22227360308170319,
0.0926736444234848,
0.3573147654533386,
-1.0201929807662964,
0.014079215936362743,
-0.5265982151031494,
-0.4231615364551544,
-0.8761797547340393,
-0.02478858083486557,
0.6604148745536804,
0.6050952672958374,
-0.06432805210351944,
0.3960341215133667,
0.28748247027397156,
0.8051425218582153,
-0.7504456639289856,
0.09423661231994629,
-0.8692720532417297,
-0.12449564039707184,
-0.18718492984771729,
-0.3886166214942932,
-0.31504398584365845,
-0.21851781010627747,
0.2012835592031479,
-0.7251462340354919,
-0.02722473442554474,
0.05745142325758934,
0.6775984168052673,
0.39828479290008545,
-0.20004941523075104,
0.018833501264452934,
-0.7207222580909729,
0.8377752900123596,
-0.5781458616256714,
0.25324612855911255,
0.30898210406303406,
0.2992870509624481,
0.026749249547719955,
-0.698067307472229,
-0.3418303430080414,
-0.057278528809547424,
0.17483718693256378,
-0.05424254387617111,
-0.07218915969133377,
0.1586228907108307,
-0.009821292944252491,
0.4178321361541748,
-0.468921959400177,
0.29807186126708984,
-0.40631645917892456,
-0.026587877422571182,
0.6153167486190796,
-0.2833060026168823,
0.42816346883773804,
0.4851149022579193,
-0.3680817484855652,
-0.21631301939487457,
-0.94352126121521,
-0.03212055191397667,
0.1771753877401352,
0.6391546130180359,
-0.24022182822227478,
0.07423481345176697,
-0.12610727548599243,
0.7979936599731445,
0.11814558506011963,
0.2085718959569931,
0.22561873495578766,
-0.3804425299167633,
-0.3737333416938782,
0.27530810236930847,
0.4534377157688141,
0.04204000160098076,
0.34646040201187134,
-0.0027533338870853186,
-0.06380195170640945,
-0.10846870392560959,
0.09905470162630081,
-0.7587364912033081,
-0.364844411611557,
-0.038585174828767776,
-0.46017637848854065,
-0.1785828024148941,
-0.2395336776971817,
-0.78973388671875,
-0.12539300322532654,
-0.5049607157707214,
0.8447216749191284,
-0.14964264631271362,
-0.10355013608932495,
0.3431141972541809,
0.4361940920352936,
0.2905515432357788,
0.6451703906059265,
-0.9624956846237183,
0.6310418248176575,
0.7369213104248047,
0.9017167687416077,
-0.6161258220672607,
-0.6609175801277161,
-0.7800067067146301,
0.29340195655822754,
-0.15412062406539917,
0.7344571352005005,
-0.3342193067073822,
-0.0855918824672699,
-0.27671414613723755,
0.1605200320482254,
-0.6460596323013306,
-0.6065080761909485,
0.5046935677528381,
-0.46708762645721436,
0.17545057833194733,
-0.08092192560434341,
-0.34822648763656616,
-0.20851169526576996,
0.0249142087996006,
-0.6886813640594482,
0.9887998700141907,
0.2414611577987671,
-0.5942668914794922,
0.10466603934764862,
-0.7502983808517456,
-0.3138462007045746,
-0.10825669765472412,
0.24121162295341492,
-0.35930222272872925,
0.2785576283931732,
0.2166493982076645,
0.41288092732429504,
-0.2710905075073242,
0.07854539901018143,
-0.34618079662323,
-0.46933335065841675,
-0.07426302134990692,
-0.29855185747146606,
0.4984653890132904,
0.5052701234817505,
-0.18378710746765137,
0.4935978949069977,
-0.6987716555595398,
0.12682399153709412,
0.12577039003372192,
-0.4183885455131531,
-0.397680401802063,
-0.31210508942604065,
0.20536112785339355,
0.20319782197475433,
0.6225518584251404,
-0.09765645116567612,
0.23160608112812042,
-0.44695207476615906,
0.30575981736183167,
0.7319703698158264,
0.005035731475800276,
0.38392508029937744,
-0.3729928135871887,
0.37783360481262207,
0.07159802317619324,
0.28548526763916016,
0.26392242312431335,
-0.231865793466568,
-0.943751871585846,
-0.3135756254196167,
0.43618324398994446,
0.45819291472435,
-0.3173410892486572,
0.417003333568573,
-0.04996355623006821,
-0.6572515368461609,
-0.5518720149993896,
0.5775152444839478,
0.3392234742641449,
0.06554985046386719,
0.3049420118331909,
-0.3958165645599365,
-0.5047171711921692,
-0.6990034580230713,
-0.2820974588394165,
0.08516501635313034,
0.22755980491638184,
0.24445180594921112,
0.12469703704118729,
0.04209502786397934,
0.42467227578163147,
-0.44771942496299744,
-0.38008666038513184,
-0.45626842975616455,
-0.12183215469121933,
0.40005695819854736,
0.6276819109916687,
0.9106214642524719,
-0.5860833525657654,
-0.9233939051628113,
0.23011747002601624,
-0.16575869917869568,
-0.28721699118614197,
-0.013359577395021915,
-0.4849884510040283,
0.05658812075853348,
0.33568939566612244,
-0.17916785180568695,
0.10794569551944733,
0.9670518636703491,
-0.46321624517440796,
0.13396024703979492,
-0.6068851947784424,
0.026558008044958115,
-1.162377953529358,
0.29700446128845215,
-0.20208215713500977,
-0.6115689277648926,
-0.701472282409668,
0.1078995019197464,
-0.18565133213996887,
-0.2593449354171753,
-0.5394967198371887,
0.5275821685791016,
-0.38411349058151245,
-0.30453550815582275,
-0.5106875896453857,
0.08540590852499008,
0.07296718657016754,
0.7360751628875732,
-0.1229979544878006,
1.1778335571289062,
0.6982005834579468,
-0.6058942079544067,
-0.06256744265556335,
0.009564574807882309,
-0.037390634417533875,
0.369079053401947,
-0.8075674772262573,
0.4002963602542877,
0.19782572984695435,
-0.14987385272979736,
-0.6777210831642151,
0.0009322877740487456,
0.2604226768016815,
0.15577532351016998,
0.31310486793518066,
0.0016581056406721473,
-0.4616895914077759,
0.2132173627614975,
-0.46052461862564087,
0.4348284602165222,
0.440789133310318,
-0.6627352833747864,
0.36816486716270447,
0.4703020453453064,
-0.3604835271835327,
-0.10470657795667648,
-0.25561463832855225,
-0.16368761658668518,
-0.3681274652481079,
-0.43390849232673645,
0.44621706008911133,
-0.4131370782852173,
-0.010914410464465618,
-0.43419861793518066,
0.05029602348804474,
-0.23691436648368835,
0.5534771680831909,
0.02986692637205124,
-0.12751857936382294,
-0.42028239369392395,
0.064916230738163,
0.2849177122116089,
-0.005313420202583075,
-0.5435577034950256,
-0.12904246151447296,
0.9648969173431396,
-0.3668683171272278,
-0.22621607780456543,
-0.5157487988471985,
0.3088343143463135,
0.5462426543235779,
-0.34532296657562256,
1.0310436487197876,
0.566289484500885,
-0.07961533963680267,
-0.5868595242500305,
-0.3037335276603699,
-0.007151384372264147,
-0.4595398008823395,
0.4194825291633606,
-0.3761197328567505,
-0.9319169521331787,
0.7405269145965576,
-0.3532029986381531,
-0.3073650896549225,
0.3774386942386627,
0.6680543422698975,
0.18590503931045532,
0.7512682676315308,
0.7290558218955994,
-0.3361046016216278,
0.7727367877960205,
-0.02687026932835579,
0.016694357618689537,
-0.6509071588516235,
0.16931821405887604,
-0.5389629602432251,
-0.2804868817329407,
-0.4975839853286743,
-0.659562885761261,
0.20094537734985352,
0.474645733833313,
-0.5308883786201477,
0.20873358845710754,
-0.5420864224433899,
0.5942004323005676,
0.624381422996521,
0.2596406042575836,
0.40956974029541016,
0.10047796368598938,
0.4059390425682068,
0.17449705302715302,
-0.6866233944892883,
-0.376252681016922,
1.150611400604248,
0.46266961097717285,
0.6885200142860413,
0.20397186279296875,
0.7300698161125183,
0.33366525173187256,
0.10096349567174911,
-0.46577370166778564,
0.3459502160549164,
-0.6461647748947144,
-0.3766727149486542,
-0.3172314763069153,
-0.08147607743740082,
-0.7567722797393799,
0.296316921710968,
0.12210507690906525,
-0.9232184290885925,
0.3237057030200958,
0.24702751636505127,
-0.4499571919441223,
0.005629212595522404,
-0.9138434529304504,
1.1593236923217773,
-0.3993813395500183,
-0.4414171278476715,
-0.42730093002319336,
-0.35045209527015686,
0.05146019160747528,
-0.5206358432769775,
-0.1820952594280243,
-0.23799185454845428,
-0.04448060691356659,
0.7589719891548157,
-0.3007059693336487,
0.9060861468315125,
-0.25806260108947754,
-0.34247729182243347,
0.11014878004789352,
-0.04959457367658615,
0.509095311164856,
-0.12353486567735672,
-0.35351473093032837,
0.23303531110286713,
0.319995641708374,
-0.5255879163742065,
-0.5516678094863892,
0.9062393307685852,
-1.2612241506576538,
-0.5356124043464661,
-0.20083384215831757,
-0.6945599317550659,
-0.34778738021850586,
0.32609230279922485,
-0.052787501364946365,
0.01296890340745449,
-0.23132959008216858,
0.27869436144828796,
0.6949660181999207,
-0.39157670736312866,
0.20358332991600037,
0.4766439199447632,
-0.21014787256717682,
-0.2851739525794983,
1.023923397064209,
0.1607474535703659,
0.2955414354801178,
0.2279476821422577,
0.2506033182144165,
-0.11434175819158554,
-0.9656071662902832,
-0.045366816222667694,
0.24531415104866028,
-0.6044220924377441,
-0.10851382464170456,
-0.20732559263706207,
-0.4256950914859772,
-0.27791401743888855,
-0.08497170358896255,
-0.6660367846488953,
-0.3055890202522278,
-0.5614349246025085,
0.0949840173125267,
0.3155871033668518,
0.5624034404754639,
0.11816214770078659,
0.8008843660354614,
-0.5936083793640137,
0.22867853939533234,
0.30224737524986267,
0.5442857146263123,
-0.03424013778567314,
-0.7374132871627808,
-0.21431858837604523,
-0.29616203904151917,
-0.1902339607477188,
-0.6611127257347107,
0.4289679527282715,
0.8306732177734375,
0.7159783244132996,
0.11972576379776001,
0.14585362374782562,
0.6422998905181885,
-0.24890418350696564,
0.4884656071662903,
-0.10643038153648376,
-1.2237480878829956,
0.6258938312530518,
-0.41385942697525024,
0.3201795220375061,
0.9509932994842529,
0.13845202326774597,
-0.10195031762123108,
-0.01929374411702156,
-0.2266983538866043,
-0.6946353912353516,
0.8968098759651184,
0.08056153357028961,
0.17693665623664856,
0.6058833003044128,
0.4885331094264984,
0.3670090436935425,
0.15217477083206177,
-0.8608160018920898,
-0.16354252398014069,
-0.1576579511165619,
-0.47762444615364075,
-0.2508039176464081,
-0.4704861342906952,
-0.27522939443588257,
-0.27637261152267456,
0.7523818016052246,
-0.452777624130249,
-0.09524856507778168,
-0.014179197140038013,
-0.29565149545669556,
-0.06106738746166229,
0.3192475438117981,
0.6789712309837341,
0.8428153395652771,
-0.2881607115268707,
0.2313378006219864,
0.4594726860523224,
-0.3016234040260315,
0.049059607088565826,
0.2140471637248993,
-0.10379321873188019,
-0.4265325963497162,
0.19636960327625275,
1.1354292631149292,
0.5123913288116455,
-0.44242069125175476,
0.32530567049980164,
-0.06711427122354507,
0.029376227408647537,
0.05238131806254387,
0.361661821603775,
0.06167350336909294,
0.42680177092552185,
0.12275869399309158,
-0.13207082450389862,
-0.05657105892896652,
-0.5478302240371704,
0.17070838809013367,
-0.006681375205516815,
-0.1463349610567093,
-0.5971128940582275,
0.33392125368118286,
0.11542874574661255,
-0.1303354650735855,
-0.20139357447624207,
0.1451653242111206,
-0.35459887981414795,
0.24215377867221832,
0.7530553340911865,
0.6349946856498718,
-0.5346580147743225,
0.22706489264965057,
0.022722166031599045,
0.05853649228811264,
-0.17882755398750305,
0.5801603198051453,
-0.06275930255651474,
-0.6714749336242676,
-0.24849779903888702,
-0.8663058876991272,
-0.19610610604286194,
0.1827925741672516,
-0.5467348098754883,
0.14862827956676483,
-0.8607209920883179,
-0.015240466222167015,
-0.17103131115436554,
0.4066818654537201,
-0.6028583645820618,
-0.05427521839737892,
0.251253604888916,
0.8440930843353271,
-0.9495888948440552,
1.28362238407135,
0.5928351879119873,
-0.3972316086292267,
-1.1060606241226196,
0.011166366748511791,
-0.5178782939910889,
-0.921508252620697,
0.7180587649345398,
-0.08429832011461258,
-0.23355594277381897,
0.22926470637321472,
-0.48420125246047974,
-1.133777379989624,
1.0301322937011719,
0.968388020992279,
-0.6549533605575562,
-0.02021649293601513,
0.038334690034389496,
0.7522982358932495,
-0.49559077620506287,
-0.26149383187294006,
0.6004180908203125,
0.3623592257499695,
0.01131615974009037,
-1.2765264511108398,
0.07993865013122559,
0.052780527621507645,
0.05843985080718994,
-0.28453075885772705,
-1.0062185525894165,
0.9622318744659424,
0.20430055260658264,
-0.04306923970580101,
0.10897455364465714,
0.5243085026741028,
0.535937488079071,
0.4180952310562134,
0.48836013674736023,
0.3481299579143524,
0.8492790460586548,
0.22951480746269226,
0.7606660723686218,
-0.6721904277801514,
0.4991891384124756,
1.500624656677246,
-0.4618544280529022,
1.0531339645385742,
0.5621776580810547,
-0.2677064538002014,
0.21481205523014069,
0.580441951751709,
0.13311077654361725,
0.7736449837684631,
0.038565974682569504,
-0.060976792126894,
-0.35557079315185547,
-0.23658524453639984,
-0.5636805295944214,
0.6170437932014465,
0.24488165974617004,
-0.4922289252281189,
-0.14482708275318146,
-0.06983251124620438,
0.018802866339683533,
0.03358953446149826,
-0.6664530634880066,
0.7954344153404236,
0.3055107295513153,
-0.7125603556632996,
0.6257206201553345,
-0.1598721444606781,
0.5363039374351501,
-0.6038902401924133,
0.15499839186668396,
-0.24713221192359924,
0.518427312374115,
-0.05935249105095863,
-0.29215577244758606,
0.10403144359588623,
-0.13372811675071716,
-0.09505219757556915,
-0.14707106351852417,
0.9463644623756409,
-0.5580054521560669,
-0.46525809168815613,
0.5713860392570496,
0.633567214012146,
0.08978724479675293,
-0.20989130437374115,
-0.9142515063285828,
0.44338101148605347,
-0.056845612823963165,
-0.28359368443489075,
0.670703113079071,
0.3587890565395355,
0.02473870851099491,
0.5664926171302795,
0.6152313351631165,
0.48951295018196106,
0.25352194905281067,
0.28179603815078735,
0.982196033000946,
-0.35879677534103394,
-0.5974598526954651,
-0.5965291857719421,
-0.0577627457678318,
0.003116592299193144,
-0.12144734710454941,
0.8151935338973999,
0.34819233417510986,
0.7947998642921448,
-0.13640005886554718,
0.5145952701568604,
0.4488106966018677,
0.4832600951194763,
-0.622877836227417,
1.033894658088684,
-0.6385990381240845,
0.314895361661911,
-0.2543930113315582,
-1.2024918794631958,
-0.32141411304473877,
0.4705331325531006,
-0.4742612838745117,
0.13672468066215515,
0.3869016170501709,
0.642993688583374,
-0.3444361686706543,
-0.30670398473739624,
0.6080197691917419,
0.1977778971195221,
0.2676319479942322,
0.7921051979064941,
0.469510942697525,
-0.45369866490364075,
0.19312956929206848,
-0.06905990839004517,
-0.03553116321563721,
-0.33481839299201965,
-0.6538829803466797,
-0.7895756959915161,
-0.36370527744293213,
-0.32876548171043396,
0.10071775317192078,
0.33857792615890503,
0.8710904121398926,
1.116597056388855,
-1.2194960117340088,
-0.24850119650363922,
-0.05567079409956932,
-0.054125964641571045,
-0.05246642976999283,
-0.17335183918476105,
0.7862088680267334,
-0.39057159423828125,
-0.8146088719367981,
0.5349878668785095,
0.24923916161060333,
0.06664195656776428,
-0.3442484140396118,
-0.3582383096218109,
-0.3363907039165497,
0.1290208399295807,
0.47393739223480225,
0.39330926537513733,
-0.3994233012199402,
-0.43572700023651123,
-0.5539171099662781,
-0.054230500012636185,
0.10350897908210754,
0.7046789526939392,
-0.48861172795295715,
0.23878349363803864,
0.5466873049736023,
0.64866703748703,
0.5235987901687622,
0.11363114416599274,
0.9043084383010864,
-0.7934134602546692,
0.48977363109588623,
-0.06362864375114441,
0.3979654610157013,
0.29906293749809265,
-0.38143694400787354,
0.41622844338417053,
-0.04480235278606415,
-0.6116863489151001,
-0.9777873754501343,
0.05932727828621864,
-1.442581295967102,
-0.3058810234069824,
0.9667488932609558,
-0.5132632255554199,
-0.3839133381843567,
-0.054360490292310715,
-0.40861350297927856,
0.4383728802204132,
-0.33523768186569214,
0.6873597502708435,
0.21650330722332,
-0.055730585008859634,
-0.40467554330825806,
-0.35873228311538696,
0.6324093341827393,
0.623972475528717,
-1.098854660987854,
0.21157154440879822,
0.09624787420034409,
0.4791291356086731,
-0.07858091592788696,
0.7350262403488159,
0.08252718299627304,
0.09876963496208191,
-0.36344480514526367,
-0.2646031081676483,
-0.13255630433559418,
-0.45896145701408386,
-0.5394496917724609,
0.48131847381591797,
0.6547509431838989,
-0.19039881229400635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10777v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10777v1
|
RoseLoRA: Row and Column-wise Sparse Low-rank Adaptation of Pre-trained Language Model for Knowledge Editing and Fine-tuning
| 2024-06-16T02:08:49 | 2024-06-16T02:08:49 |
Haoyu Wang, Tianci Liu, Tuo Zhao, Jing Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pre-trained language models, trained on large-scale corpora, demonstrate
strong generalizability across various NLP tasks. Fine-tuning these models for
specific tasks typically involves updating all parameters, which is
resource-intensive. Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods, such as the
popular LoRA family, introduce low-rank matrices to learn only a few parameters
efficiently. However, during inference, the product of these matrices updates
all pre-trained parameters, complicating tasks like knowledge editing that
require selective updates. We propose a novel PEFT method, which conducts
\textbf{r}ow and c\textbf{o}lumn-wise spar\textbf{se}
\textbf{lo}w-\textbf{r}ank \textbf{a}daptation (RoseLoRA), to address this
challenge. RoseLoRA identifies and updates only the most important parameters
for a specific task, maintaining efficiency while preserving other model
knowledge. By adding a sparsity constraint on the product of low-rank matrices
and converting it to row and column-wise sparsity, we ensure efficient and
precise model updates. Our theoretical analysis guarantees the lower bound of
the sparsity with respective to the matrix product. Extensive experiments on
five benchmarks across twenty datasets demonstrate that RoseLoRA outperforms
baselines in both general fine-tuning and knowledge editing tasks.
|
[
-0.21816395223140717,
-0.9708799123764038,
0.31166642904281616,
0.1776765137910843,
-0.0284641794860363,
-0.036325354129076004,
-0.5498292446136475,
-0.25153276324272156,
0.04424196481704712,
0.4272226393222809,
-0.4400845766067505,
-0.5949282646179199,
-0.46693339943885803,
0.058340102434158325,
-0.2230490744113922,
1.2642607688903809,
0.00601264787837863,
-0.15902292728424072,
0.16344046592712402,
-0.29057738184928894,
-0.5692500472068787,
-0.40308281779289246,
-0.4646020531654358,
-0.021248217672109604,
0.8645346164703369,
0.42620256543159485,
0.8846827149391174,
0.6228589415550232,
0.3857053220272064,
0.28149688243865967,
-0.31940197944641113,
0.40579313039779663,
-0.8918172717094421,
0.03805962949991226,
-0.38801389932632446,
-0.5349239110946655,
-0.9355854988098145,
-0.020530298352241516,
0.6303560733795166,
0.8931808471679688,
-0.0453079529106617,
0.31308528780937195,
0.41035252809524536,
0.8473307490348816,
-0.7836914658546448,
-0.09971033781766891,
-1.0691077709197998,
-0.1304338127374649,
-0.11381017416715622,
-0.34850770235061646,
-0.23319146037101746,
-0.3706631660461426,
-0.12608470022678375,
-0.9523732662200928,
0.06399773061275482,
-0.04490157216787338,
0.9154722690582275,
0.6778035163879395,
0.1545909196138382,
0.1341414451599121,
-0.76438969373703,
0.8680723309516907,
-0.5968880653381348,
0.29650789499282837,
0.3554648458957672,
0.12619060277938843,
-0.251054584980011,
-0.38066983222961426,
-0.36078211665153503,
-0.03929869458079338,
-0.005083239637315273,
-0.11045634001493454,
-0.3103410601615906,
0.15261121094226837,
0.21171635389328003,
0.16473130881786346,
-0.4381008744239807,
0.10811588168144226,
-0.3733721375465393,
0.16470560431480408,
0.244570791721344,
-0.3882770836353302,
0.12332068383693695,
0.13355103135108948,
-0.22417478263378143,
-0.1261546015739441,
-0.9220895767211914,
-0.2557891309261322,
0.26127898693084717,
0.5568006038665771,
0.026288053020834923,
0.33526337146759033,
-0.2601003646850586,
1.0528185367584229,
0.16236646473407745,
-0.09460537880659103,
0.06620052456855774,
-0.17218542098999023,
-0.5088831186294556,
-0.002912547904998064,
0.34746941924095154,
-0.00584793696179986,
0.18983766436576843,
-0.1976572871208191,
-0.12769170105457306,
0.09225568175315857,
0.05988408252596855,
-0.6146860122680664,
-0.4785251021385193,
-0.05888240039348602,
-0.2926371097564697,
-0.28162655234336853,
-0.250291645526886,
-0.8731434345245361,
-0.41875791549682617,
-0.5069434642791748,
0.7315353751182556,
-0.14075714349746704,
0.024872668087482452,
0.15305137634277344,
0.29762136936187744,
-0.20032858848571777,
0.7147736549377441,
-0.9254171252250671,
0.32297879457473755,
0.4982866942882538,
0.7085249423980713,
-0.3054458200931549,
-0.4874725937843323,
-0.9799399375915527,
0.0720408707857132,
-0.41084223985671997,
0.9025828242301941,
-0.6105837225914001,
0.07123219221830368,
-0.14988692104816437,
-0.10283768177032471,
-0.4814593493938446,
-0.5665529370307922,
0.3439067304134369,
-0.7425426244735718,
0.010590828955173492,
-0.3095562756061554,
-0.1522376984357834,
0.03655102103948593,
0.10460049659013748,
-0.46990299224853516,
1.0181905031204224,
0.3796713650226593,
-0.6498434543609619,
0.4357931911945343,
-0.8086913228034973,
-0.07294507324695587,
-0.14242881536483765,
0.05860956385731697,
-0.22926554083824158,
0.08208613842725754,
0.30890753865242004,
0.30989596247673035,
-0.01505916379392147,
-0.037857137620449066,
-0.46149998903274536,
-0.37186098098754883,
0.10029486566781998,
-0.23800230026245117,
0.46362701058387756,
0.2280757576227188,
-0.07909458130598068,
0.42036041617393494,
-0.8902974128723145,
-0.18828660249710083,
-0.18456506729125977,
-0.568942129611969,
-0.3701561689376831,
-0.14336739480495453,
0.085062675178051,
0.08694612234830856,
0.31804344058036804,
-0.25824448466300964,
0.5404365658760071,
-0.3509826362133026,
0.3337974548339844,
0.7535491585731506,
0.07729680836200714,
0.46374204754829407,
-0.22086483240127563,
0.40324029326438904,
-0.04765333980321884,
0.2209780216217041,
0.32951948046684265,
-0.3112620711326599,
-0.9190594553947449,
-0.16898372769355774,
0.6885349750518799,
0.5536340475082397,
-0.7420932650566101,
0.3945619761943817,
-0.3875980079174042,
-0.4821666181087494,
-0.6169747114181519,
0.7267081141471863,
0.3056061863899231,
0.6527064442634583,
0.7832388281822205,
0.10875976085662842,
-0.40182510018348694,
-0.7182856202125549,
-0.5291372537612915,
0.025805244222283363,
0.07345075160264969,
0.022825002670288086,
0.2263752669095993,
-0.2808329164981842,
0.9136961698532104,
-0.46516790986061096,
-0.7103061079978943,
-0.18343356251716614,
0.2223735898733139,
0.410412460565567,
0.7116695642471313,
0.8996939659118652,
-0.5947832465171814,
-0.5677361488342285,
0.2060912847518921,
-0.15501244366168976,
-0.3595163822174072,
-0.16029001772403717,
-0.46268731355667114,
0.2049657255411148,
0.44420552253723145,
-0.20630358159542084,
0.31505635380744934,
0.632439374923706,
-0.3877792954444885,
0.027211112901568413,
-0.5476468205451965,
0.20726533234119415,
-0.9379679560661316,
0.14196939766407013,
-0.03637957200407982,
-0.3088564872741699,
-0.691622257232666,
-0.15693412721157074,
0.12265749275684357,
-0.0213285181671381,
-0.3640722930431366,
0.20720124244689941,
-0.38946619629859924,
-0.07560290396213531,
-0.22903591394424438,
0.177276611328125,
-0.0341743603348732,
0.8293312788009644,
-0.011937557719647884,
0.8786660432815552,
0.19003647565841675,
-0.6578734517097473,
-0.05893601477146149,
0.32461124658584595,
-0.19307079911231995,
0.47399187088012695,
-0.5234326124191284,
0.11288220435380936,
-0.06072390452027321,
-0.2231554388999939,
-0.6089299321174622,
0.13907086849212646,
0.05223356559872627,
-0.11650558561086655,
0.3041169345378876,
-0.5239741206169128,
-0.4915783703327179,
0.19542483985424042,
-0.16619718074798584,
0.22285960614681244,
0.45603060722351074,
-0.6848041415214539,
0.2938043475151062,
0.4313632845878601,
-0.3972044587135315,
-0.5344956517219543,
-0.46358466148376465,
-0.012852352112531662,
-0.21362021565437317,
-0.2750117778778076,
0.5331590175628662,
-0.2839626967906952,
-0.16005970537662506,
-0.14795224368572235,
0.010663318447768688,
-0.0735192745923996,
0.32596278190612793,
-0.212833434343338,
0.21556363999843597,
-0.3186170756816864,
0.09717496484518051,
0.39915597438812256,
-0.1740260124206543,
-0.4780452847480774,
-0.20912612974643707,
0.3689970374107361,
-0.2667563259601593,
-0.23597566783428192,
-0.30082494020462036,
-0.0065636239014565945,
0.5452412962913513,
-0.12605693936347961,
0.7713397741317749,
0.5853456854820251,
-0.4119584858417511,
-0.3877110183238983,
-0.575777530670166,
-0.00527215376496315,
-0.4669301509857178,
0.5715997219085693,
-0.35749274492263794,
-0.6535934209823608,
0.3616359531879425,
-0.18861229717731476,
0.183083638548851,
0.49828866124153137,
0.3187471032142639,
0.08819734305143356,
1.0376780033111572,
0.8542378544807434,
-0.1826356053352356,
0.649202823638916,
-0.15729548037052155,
0.03847745433449745,
-0.6854101419448853,
0.287418007850647,
-0.7573615908622742,
-0.4862375557422638,
-0.3938150405883789,
-0.554306149482727,
0.607001006603241,
0.5585123300552368,
-0.1921122521162033,
0.4128126800060272,
-0.5149816870689392,
0.5064359307289124,
0.36126676201820374,
0.027372589334845543,
0.5152255892753601,
0.2170979082584381,
0.1351683884859085,
-0.23440290987491608,
-0.8874580264091492,
-0.3498581647872925,
0.9760994911193848,
0.28004568815231323,
0.7527902126312256,
0.2329235076904297,
0.4655490815639496,
0.42967525124549866,
0.35696378350257874,
-0.3044474124908447,
0.25099214911460876,
-0.45265427231788635,
-0.18691015243530273,
-0.3067990839481354,
-0.3529873192310333,
-0.7912830114364624,
0.3646606206893921,
-0.6143746972084045,
-0.772360622882843,
0.6585022807121277,
0.5929328203201294,
-0.6251302361488342,
0.3446066081523895,
-0.713887631893158,
1.0662171840667725,
-0.03975548595190048,
-0.6648350954055786,
-0.34317630529403687,
-0.27702832221984863,
0.09070006757974625,
-0.24391430616378784,
0.2573208808898926,
-0.08158598095178604,
-0.09371057897806168,
0.8328396081924438,
-0.38949650526046753,
0.7594325542449951,
-0.38842836022377014,
-0.13063181936740875,
-0.16030438244342804,
0.09574910998344421,
0.5201805830001831,
0.06632409989833832,
-0.216863751411438,
-0.10186158865690231,
0.3978295922279358,
-0.5469911694526672,
-0.6825556755065918,
0.8744843006134033,
-1.0215067863464355,
-0.4609307050704956,
-0.2542482912540436,
-0.5738773345947266,
-0.610223114490509,
0.20555844902992249,
-0.004259965848177671,
0.17665280401706696,
-0.19015145301818848,
0.32543817162513733,
0.8257365226745605,
-0.28897717595100403,
0.1788526326417923,
0.44447511434555054,
-0.2505808174610138,
-0.3201953172683716,
0.9595465660095215,
0.21478599309921265,
0.1671004742383957,
0.5281433463096619,
0.21018798649311066,
-0.010658623650670052,
-0.7898753881454468,
-0.6066123843193054,
0.25080475211143494,
-0.6371272802352905,
-0.2685551047325134,
-0.5458309650421143,
-0.10515201091766357,
-0.4143710732460022,
-0.29354941844940186,
-0.49442464113235474,
-0.5344277620315552,
-0.4834451675415039,
0.21735544502735138,
0.6444260478019714,
0.8191081881523132,
-0.09156829863786697,
0.2983747124671936,
-0.659945547580719,
0.5209716558456421,
0.44677045941352844,
0.312248170375824,
-0.15777917206287384,
-0.7409688830375671,
-0.31486114859580994,
0.07195805013179779,
-0.050270915031433105,
-0.8690391778945923,
0.3922792375087738,
0.563873827457428,
0.4195404648780823,
0.20339377224445343,
0.02524533122777939,
1.0367059707641602,
-0.3139200210571289,
0.5194272398948669,
-0.1307988464832306,
-0.9851456880569458,
0.699775755405426,
-0.4830154478549957,
0.14845333993434906,
0.8812602758407593,
-0.02340809442102909,
-0.3943970203399658,
0.0021224175579845905,
-0.2621578276157379,
-0.6596002578735352,
0.7302565574645996,
0.14082854986190796,
-0.054309289902448654,
0.45812860131263733,
0.5229754447937012,
0.16485530138015747,
0.21745125949382782,
-0.7268097996711731,
-0.07515939325094223,
-0.21621237695217133,
-0.09290618449449539,
-0.1429092437028885,
-0.3961257338523865,
-0.18606051802635193,
-0.4853725731372833,
1.020098090171814,
-0.3843296468257904,
-0.2233140766620636,
0.22974225878715515,
-0.570166289806366,
-0.3028731346130371,
0.4977746605873108,
0.7354302406311035,
0.7913735508918762,
-0.3721033036708832,
0.13032236695289612,
0.5425941348075867,
-0.4257715046405792,
-0.12912307679653168,
0.2260870337486267,
-0.23764732480049133,
-0.15363548696041107,
0.20247586071491241,
0.71079021692276,
0.5676444172859192,
-0.349301278591156,
0.33695197105407715,
0.07942312210798264,
-0.1939854621887207,
0.11531264334917068,
0.2704262137413025,
-0.030144786462187767,
0.035413455218076706,
0.3091040849685669,
0.39558327198028564,
-0.23375579714775085,
-0.27315986156463623,
-0.05762385576963425,
0.12882044911384583,
-0.3965246379375458,
-0.2584482729434967,
0.6414318680763245,
0.04897375777363777,
-0.033274125307798386,
0.092706598341465,
-0.11722835153341293,
-0.21115192770957947,
0.11669118702411652,
0.3763125240802765,
0.5001054406166077,
-0.1854456067085266,
0.1513320356607437,
0.2572484314441681,
0.2805865705013275,
0.020539021119475365,
0.3416003882884979,
-0.10252869874238968,
-0.6143960952758789,
-0.24401356279850006,
-1.0290874242782593,
-0.23584520816802979,
0.2734733819961548,
-0.5812869071960449,
0.12120097130537033,
-0.5072272419929504,
-0.010671757161617279,
-0.04339152202010155,
0.07464567571878433,
-0.5143590569496155,
-0.11080946773290634,
-0.10758298635482788,
0.9106719493865967,
-0.9864295721054077,
1.1182130575180054,
0.6612316966056824,
-0.34655889868736267,
-0.5511049628257751,
-0.1777980774641037,
-0.2981804609298706,
-0.5562543869018555,
0.6127229332923889,
-0.48277249932289124,
-0.15148326754570007,
0.08139067888259888,
-0.3227674961090088,
-1.0761668682098389,
0.8615696430206299,
0.8673715591430664,
-0.5802993774414062,
-0.09775622934103012,
0.09941264986991882,
0.6711595058441162,
-0.23669274151325226,
-0.22194704413414001,
0.8331369757652283,
0.6693724393844604,
-0.20020242035388947,
-0.9623791575431824,
-0.2136133909225464,
-0.39109379053115845,
0.2608765959739685,
-0.21825340390205383,
-0.4568062424659729,
0.9115157723426819,
0.13935838639736176,
0.09218917042016983,
0.14449001848697662,
0.7867954969406128,
0.3033544421195984,
-0.22352132201194763,
0.6536577343940735,
0.4000677466392517,
0.8676621913909912,
0.008610953576862812,
0.49036383628845215,
-0.4333847463130951,
0.2428375482559204,
1.1361271142959595,
-0.20456987619400024,
1.0304415225982666,
0.5580240488052368,
-0.28142327070236206,
0.5334912538528442,
0.43776848912239075,
0.055776968598365784,
0.4969226121902466,
0.10937090218067169,
0.05494459718465805,
-0.24359013140201569,
-0.04034955054521561,
-0.4760974943637848,
0.27170002460479736,
0.44846946001052856,
-0.19373594224452972,
-0.30676931142807007,
0.01986653171479702,
0.18190814554691315,
0.42170876264572144,
-0.5650776028633118,
0.7514715790748596,
-0.10922811925411224,
-0.852506160736084,
1.0026243925094604,
0.04907892271876335,
0.6620336771011353,
-0.5226412415504456,
-0.17721790075302124,
-0.08978568017482758,
0.4817762076854706,
-0.3326972723007202,
-0.046600520610809326,
0.16306066513061523,
0.23647238314151764,
-0.20826616883277893,
-0.4042034447193146,
0.7553004026412964,
-0.6311324834823608,
-0.5638338923454285,
0.2990688383579254,
0.4917871057987213,
-0.14390547573566437,
-0.15257686376571655,
-0.9064810276031494,
0.2229365110397339,
-0.12769842147827148,
-0.34654679894447327,
0.5500801801681519,
0.10967656224966049,
0.025232873857021332,
0.3040147125720978,
0.6720057129859924,
0.5779597163200378,
0.10819987207651138,
0.2061619907617569,
0.8702000975608826,
-0.23452523350715637,
-0.5641536116600037,
-0.4189487099647522,
0.11820836365222931,
-0.03636177256703377,
-0.27601349353790283,
0.427536278963089,
0.48143306374549866,
0.6478830575942993,
-0.19180609285831451,
0.6283655166625977,
0.31808191537857056,
0.7021998167037964,
-0.8432979583740234,
1.079024314880371,
-0.6234100461006165,
0.3503531813621521,
-0.46401166915893555,
-1.1453064680099487,
-0.40349438786506653,
0.7457720041275024,
-0.5114001035690308,
0.011088606901466846,
0.5658951997756958,
0.946139931678772,
-0.28920358419418335,
-0.17798146605491638,
0.5129461884498596,
0.5364818572998047,
0.05197330191731453,
0.5536795258522034,
0.413839727640152,
-0.4262032210826874,
0.46690115332603455,
-0.3388434052467346,
-0.35768309235572815,
-0.232148677110672,
-0.8964605331420898,
-0.8868938684463501,
-0.5564337968826294,
-0.4679167568683624,
-0.20505370199680328,
0.33895036578178406,
1.021499514579773,
0.9130246043205261,
-1.1114428043365479,
-0.10835167020559311,
-0.15157769620418549,
0.1485014408826828,
-0.4421340525150299,
-0.16299471259117126,
0.7116428017616272,
-0.5537034869194031,
-0.7681235671043396,
0.6829763054847717,
0.28848013281822205,
0.051685597747564316,
-0.20954382419586182,
-0.0013330144574865699,
-0.31393197178840637,
-0.06656656414270401,
0.4535834789276123,
0.467164546251297,
-0.5340811610221863,
-0.32304298877716064,
-0.24784764647483826,
0.12974035739898682,
0.2034268081188202,
0.5597934126853943,
-0.7927688956260681,
0.1956380158662796,
0.49896371364593506,
0.7406468391418457,
0.2953903377056122,
0.012671686708927155,
0.5517429113388062,
-0.7116583585739136,
0.21199876070022583,
0.015917643904685974,
0.4821523427963257,
0.2610316574573517,
-0.339322030544281,
0.32208752632141113,
0.1920732855796814,
-0.3918309509754181,
-0.8958775997161865,
0.043892618268728256,
-1.1193987131118774,
-0.40586918592453003,
1.090888500213623,
-0.08863028138875961,
-0.4332696795463562,
-0.187765434384346,
-0.37315306067466736,
0.17975254356861115,
-0.22526326775550842,
0.8256074786186218,
0.21899352967739105,
0.044385042041540146,
-0.10163189470767975,
-0.3360256552696228,
1.0055804252624512,
0.6089193820953369,
-0.8544989824295044,
0.3942702114582062,
0.31571394205093384,
0.1747058779001236,
0.10325433313846588,
0.4999009072780609,
0.045345764607191086,
0.3845727741718292,
-0.4417950212955475,
-0.11926720291376114,
-0.07219766080379486,
-0.4209443926811218,
-0.5089359879493713,
0.3334912955760956,
0.5385002493858337,
0.12046144902706146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10774v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10774v1
|
Quest: Query-Aware Sparsity for Efficient Long-Context LLM Inference
| 2024-06-16T01:33:02 | 2024-06-16T01:33:02 |
Jiaming Tang, Yilong Zhao, Kan Zhu, Guangxuan Xiao, Baris Kasikci, Song Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
As the demand for long-context large language models (LLMs) increases, models
with context windows of up to 128K or 1M tokens are becoming increasingly
prevalent. However, long-context LLM inference is challenging since the
inference speed decreases significantly as the sequence length grows. This
slowdown is primarily caused by loading a large KV cache during self-attention.
Previous works have shown that a small portion of critical tokens will dominate
the attention outcomes. However, we observe the criticality of a token highly
depends on the query. To this end, we propose Quest, a query-aware KV cache
selection algorithm. Quest keeps track of the minimal and maximal Key values in
KV cache pages and estimates the criticality of a given page using Query
vectors. By only loading the Top-K critical KV cache pages for attention, Quest
significantly speeds up self-attention without sacrificing accuracy. We show
that Quest can achieve up to 2.23x self-attention speedup, which reduces
inference latency by 7.03x while performing well on tasks with long
dependencies with negligible accuracy loss. Code is available at
http://github.com/mit-han-lab/Quest .
|
[
-0.25416165590286255,
-0.48145592212677,
0.6836607456207275,
0.5428280234336853,
-0.27857983112335205,
-0.13820020854473114,
-0.085399329662323,
-0.34741824865341187,
0.48474639654159546,
0.8106902837753296,
-0.6010136008262634,
-0.48173952102661133,
-0.3092285096645355,
0.02427622117102146,
-0.3684469163417816,
0.6118887066841125,
0.148090660572052,
-0.11481675505638123,
-0.4632824659347534,
-0.32957547903060913,
-0.5386126637458801,
-0.4693816602230072,
-0.6591763496398926,
0.11871148645877838,
0.75296950340271,
0.2832382619380951,
0.2899799942970276,
0.46811729669570923,
0.32102522253990173,
0.27402400970458984,
-0.24951888620853424,
0.3558407127857208,
-0.9967676997184753,
0.8156936764717102,
-0.21273444592952728,
-0.6541174054145813,
-0.351639986038208,
-0.24172528088092804,
0.7497086524963379,
0.2068260759115219,
0.21852749586105347,
0.08956875652074814,
0.004609001334756613,
0.9864254593849182,
-0.8395543694496155,
0.06393072009086609,
-0.8358458876609802,
-0.0035866526886820793,
-0.3238060176372528,
-0.21953925490379333,
-0.5974529981613159,
0.005652889143675566,
0.2996367812156677,
-0.8236067891120911,
0.4257175028324127,
0.21320728957653046,
0.6289646625518799,
0.6163135170936584,
-0.41066691279411316,
0.2190559357404709,
-0.38833799958229065,
0.788575291633606,
-0.4573982059955597,
0.596975564956665,
0.5623639822006226,
0.19336625933647156,
-0.5374184846878052,
-0.8922422528266907,
-0.3630048334598541,
-0.11143162101507187,
0.11949650198221207,
0.2064884454011917,
0.15443161129951477,
0.3597390353679657,
0.282103568315506,
0.2982242703437805,
-0.5960599184036255,
-0.16883307695388794,
-0.03555396571755409,
-0.25994428992271423,
0.18523983657360077,
0.3416820466518402,
-0.05498843267560005,
-0.3368241488933563,
-0.382245808839798,
0.20423078536987305,
-0.8005573749542236,
0.07539168745279312,
-0.17422592639923096,
0.31205207109451294,
0.3902362585067749,
0.4848034083843231,
-0.6532348394393921,
0.6177929043769836,
0.1988416314125061,
0.11115573346614838,
-0.01109988335520029,
-0.22317466139793396,
-0.36209365725517273,
-0.15748097002506256,
0.44616270065307617,
0.3358178734779358,
-0.09353771805763245,
-0.3947998285293579,
-0.05955139547586441,
-0.134659543633461,
0.4253672659397125,
-0.9187476634979248,
-0.04475283995270729,
0.23475612699985504,
-0.1637199968099594,
0.043656766414642334,
-0.3097960948944092,
-0.625078022480011,
-0.3972155749797821,
0.022652508690953255,
0.4036790728569031,
0.0036576753482222557,
0.0454360693693161,
0.09718417376279831,
0.009273405186831951,
0.38050442934036255,
0.3368178606033325,
-0.5499953031539917,
0.11287081241607666,
0.6268947720527649,
0.8690414428710938,
-0.5731053948402405,
-0.2221086323261261,
-1.10927152633667,
0.21813549101352692,
-0.19038565456867218,
0.8110063076019287,
-0.5806214809417725,
-0.4259510636329651,
-0.03433442488312721,
0.394599586725235,
-0.09107696264982224,
-0.42477256059646606,
0.5068999528884888,
-1.1614313125610352,
-0.2491099238395691,
-0.6915385723114014,
-0.47813957929611206,
-0.05224597081542015,
0.5125589966773987,
-0.8106110692024231,
1.4214866161346436,
0.08768525719642639,
-0.6468111872673035,
0.42068207263946533,
-0.1753023862838745,
-0.4992832839488983,
0.09856756776571274,
-0.027879733592271805,
-0.20285552740097046,
0.16702008247375488,
0.23731905221939087,
0.34955480694770813,
-0.149644672870636,
0.054670609533786774,
-0.49570757150650024,
-0.605400562286377,
0.03750181198120117,
-0.3715052306652069,
0.25653722882270813,
0.012154944241046906,
-0.42618197202682495,
0.10311117023229599,
-0.5612205862998962,
0.13274133205413818,
-0.03344738110899925,
-0.5678888559341431,
-0.4013718366622925,
0.2007497400045395,
-0.22129596769809723,
-0.029147295281291008,
0.2247302234172821,
-0.1920202523469925,
0.368512898683548,
-0.7135105729103088,
0.21524874866008759,
0.8606559038162231,
-0.0924680233001709,
0.36711230874061584,
-0.03831686079502106,
0.4972679913043976,
-0.09652826189994812,
0.16804508864879608,
0.017179828137159348,
-0.312345415353775,
-1.2155342102050781,
-0.3726150095462799,
0.36970701813697815,
0.386259526014328,
-0.7032185196876526,
-0.005068191327154636,
-0.3056555688381195,
-0.07880868017673492,
-0.49114903807640076,
0.059238240122795105,
0.5948624014854431,
0.5168918371200562,
0.3794204890727997,
-0.27900412678718567,
-0.3292388319969177,
-0.8357199430465698,
-0.49547383189201355,
-0.1904619187116623,
0.21307574212551117,
1.0077979564666748,
0.1162179559469223,
-0.16919241845607758,
0.8078892827033997,
-0.5442742109298706,
-0.12596875429153442,
-0.06105810031294823,
0.009262274019420147,
0.20949992537498474,
0.24559582769870758,
0.1295129954814911,
-0.6205956339836121,
-0.6539941430091858,
-0.2679736316204071,
-0.22982142865657806,
-0.23559409379959106,
-0.03258387744426727,
-0.7244847416877747,
0.36525946855545044,
0.6070274710655212,
-0.7144209742546082,
0.5430790185928345,
0.0724291279911995,
-0.3626073896884918,
0.497794508934021,
-0.05556308105587959,
0.3374233543872833,
-0.9738811254501343,
0.12018997967243195,
-0.015422270633280277,
-0.6030439734458923,
-0.3918476104736328,
0.045283034443855286,
0.2767244577407837,
0.21784913539886475,
-0.4985356032848358,
0.9509485363960266,
-0.4432961940765381,
-0.23733650147914886,
-0.24858544766902924,
0.14528237283229828,
0.30902382731437683,
0.6306918859481812,
-0.12844854593276978,
1.1246792078018188,
0.22841700911521912,
-0.7779311537742615,
-0.05027284473180771,
0.14472825825214386,
-0.1870051473379135,
0.1832781434059143,
-0.5149876475334167,
0.21680720150470734,
0.11005102097988129,
0.3623749613761902,
-1.175974726676941,
-0.2025749683380127,
0.07027395814657211,
-0.5190839767456055,
0.479860782623291,
-0.5672537088394165,
-0.45353537797927856,
-0.280072957277298,
-0.2432190477848053,
0.718692421913147,
0.0790276750922203,
-0.7225596904754639,
0.6901180148124695,
0.365071564912796,
0.0599205419421196,
-1.0460407733917236,
-0.47091859579086304,
0.08695333451032639,
0.010599222965538502,
-0.6096364855766296,
0.3955610394477844,
-0.18041518330574036,
0.18080103397369385,
-0.20587606728076935,
-0.3924636244773865,
-0.21673741936683655,
-0.0169224813580513,
0.3374283015727997,
0.15066216886043549,
-0.18318089842796326,
0.40408915281295776,
0.1489359438419342,
-0.1308877170085907,
-0.017841409891843796,
-0.490652859210968,
0.5218597650527954,
-0.237138569355011,
-0.3200806975364685,
-0.35815179347991943,
0.19596520066261292,
1.0291658639907837,
-0.15572264790534973,
0.4694828689098358,
0.37104532122612,
-0.1534818708896637,
-0.0747392401099205,
-1.1814849376678467,
-0.15824761986732483,
-0.4564138352870941,
0.42983734607696533,
-0.34385696053504944,
-1.192566990852356,
0.6392863988876343,
0.0677274614572525,
-0.26465296745300293,
0.48233920335769653,
0.5381765961647034,
0.1572054773569107,
1.079262614250183,
0.42035818099975586,
-0.5721194744110107,
0.5152475237846375,
-0.20544494688510895,
-0.006094147451221943,
-1.0160937309265137,
-0.13491198420524597,
-0.4198857247829437,
-0.2781190872192383,
-0.4431544542312622,
-0.7800272107124329,
0.4359993636608124,
-0.19629141688346863,
-0.1588464379310608,
-0.1860504299402237,
-0.48165449500083923,
0.7687913179397583,
0.5410223603248596,
0.18103525042533875,
0.12577460706233978,
-0.009012540802359581,
-0.3195160925388336,
-0.11996220797300339,
-0.5478814840316772,
0.14665484428405762,
0.9525241255760193,
-0.05308419466018677,
0.8203834891319275,
-0.16267754137516022,
0.3496900498867035,
0.421504944562912,
0.04525414854288101,
-0.8229179978370667,
0.5843514800071716,
-0.009044469334185123,
-0.853022575378418,
-0.41115355491638184,
-0.38759568333625793,
-0.9432325959205627,
0.31819069385528564,
0.10963817685842514,
-0.6232801675796509,
0.06202833727002144,
0.2324639856815338,
-0.45470577478408813,
0.014000716619193554,
-0.47554975748062134,
0.815298855304718,
-0.038872312754392624,
-0.7824186682701111,
-0.4067437946796417,
-0.7181580066680908,
0.20539602637290955,
0.26237595081329346,
-0.32160618901252747,
-0.1349126249551773,
-0.028775755316019058,
0.5850815176963806,
-0.2780432105064392,
0.8856781125068665,
-0.2756911516189575,
0.3772212564945221,
0.349222868680954,
0.27917495369911194,
0.9588754177093506,
0.3236769437789917,
0.10251720249652863,
-0.21733947098255157,
0.013348509557545185,
-0.5019274950027466,
-0.5027112364768982,
0.9141054153442383,
-0.448750376701355,
-0.9019383192062378,
-0.3659586012363434,
-0.4739348590373993,
-0.49183782935142517,
0.33792197704315186,
0.10454487055540085,
0.3662850856781006,
-0.040407147258520126,
0.17108163237571716,
1.061136245727539,
-0.06853696703910828,
0.16764657199382782,
0.6400401592254639,
-0.13943061232566833,
-0.44033950567245483,
0.9823780059814453,
0.2323523759841919,
0.2531842291355133,
0.3071478009223938,
0.015854569151997566,
-0.36956578493118286,
-0.53673255443573,
-0.49656733870506287,
0.4169248044490814,
-0.6164523959159851,
-0.33043599128723145,
-0.9088535904884338,
-0.2119399458169937,
-0.22924485802650452,
-0.1508563905954361,
-0.5722532868385315,
-0.48122453689575195,
-0.519111156463623,
0.20300592482089996,
0.4473089873790741,
0.2469855546951294,
0.22172030806541443,
0.3942747116088867,
-0.727249801158905,
0.2511399984359741,
0.41872280836105347,
0.4817950427532196,
0.1138606071472168,
-0.692143976688385,
-0.3459477126598358,
-0.4167359471321106,
-0.1600390374660492,
-0.5094184875488281,
0.49991944432258606,
0.1568143665790558,
0.5070130825042725,
0.44722670316696167,
0.14348001778125763,
0.9254779815673828,
-0.3803405165672302,
0.7941263914108276,
-0.042773813009262085,
-0.6935517191886902,
0.39834120869636536,
-0.23076589405536652,
0.4432099461555481,
0.8901787996292114,
0.12452638894319534,
-0.6170849204063416,
-0.41240113973617554,
-0.20269446074962616,
-1.0419259071350098,
0.6064163446426392,
-0.05253925919532776,
0.02709251269698143,
-0.4063519239425659,
0.7041547298431396,
0.03887298330664635,
-0.02788902446627617,
-0.5675336122512817,
-0.1330103725194931,
0.12895530462265015,
0.09261015057563782,
0.25675731897354126,
-0.6862497329711914,
0.1259419173002243,
-0.1709124743938446,
0.7984434962272644,
-0.27253156900405884,
0.20191428065299988,
0.6166375875473022,
-0.32868146896362305,
-0.014166153967380524,
-0.03184368461370468,
0.48403382301330566,
0.44432327151298523,
-0.22623443603515625,
0.00876100268214941,
0.3896113336086273,
-0.6200248003005981,
-0.09341467171907425,
0.03778894245624542,
-0.0904826670885086,
-0.14388792216777802,
-0.18158386647701263,
0.5467707514762878,
0.3906821608543396,
-0.7062758207321167,
0.5894214510917664,
-0.5959765911102295,
0.04311255365610123,
-0.05017714947462082,
0.07099209725856781,
0.016074469313025475,
0.6544395685195923,
0.20781995356082916,
-0.4097394347190857,
0.41791579127311707,
0.11904321610927582,
0.017117302864789963,
0.7119491696357727,
-0.6244595646858215,
-0.06676632910966873,
0.5742573738098145,
0.34157487750053406,
0.04406043887138367,
0.7309083938598633,
-0.1686742752790451,
-0.632687509059906,
0.5260358452796936,
0.4742092788219452,
0.9681442379951477,
-0.11164339631795883,
-0.18764978647232056,
0.41000232100486755,
0.13331930339336395,
-0.1981126070022583,
0.34047436714172363,
-0.3188387155532837,
-0.2858861982822418,
-0.6219635605812073,
-0.7467802166938782,
-0.25518861413002014,
0.25745636224746704,
-0.5277895331382751,
-0.0035887646954506636,
-0.17606791853904724,
-0.27567949891090393,
-0.48316052556037903,
0.19497644901275635,
-0.4863286316394806,
0.18503506481647491,
-0.10690566152334213,
0.8756147623062134,
-0.16015353798866272,
0.6805781126022339,
0.01566171832382679,
0.07825488597154617,
-0.38902193307876587,
0.021742187440395355,
-0.1748124659061432,
-0.8979853391647339,
0.6650543808937073,
0.45527562499046326,
-0.3329160809516907,
-0.024940665811300278,
-0.5411332845687866,
-1.150523066520691,
1.009882926940918,
0.10555174201726913,
-0.6253067255020142,
-0.14514237642288208,
-0.11312729865312576,
0.1667707860469818,
-0.1400693655014038,
0.01770191639661789,
0.4763365685939789,
0.3563432991504669,
0.2761198878288269,
-0.5737094879150391,
0.06095116212964058,
-0.0981440544128418,
-0.1196930930018425,
0.46609222888946533,
-0.8461074829101562,
0.39115214347839355,
-0.06505616754293442,
-0.2688567042350769,
0.24343889951705933,
0.9141579866409302,
0.26678043603897095,
0.483171284198761,
0.5205858945846558,
0.7821979522705078,
0.8688436150550842,
0.13288730382919312,
0.7998083829879761,
-0.6139437556266785,
0.29863256216049194,
1.1015143394470215,
-0.045232392847537994,
0.8228779435157776,
0.558987557888031,
-0.1113719642162323,
0.007159176282584667,
0.8389245867729187,
0.3872063457965851,
0.6805294752120972,
0.28651663661003113,
-0.6064891219139099,
-0.6076145172119141,
-0.06602346152067184,
-0.4368210434913635,
0.1459241509437561,
0.5075758695602417,
-0.3230684697628021,
0.007389497477561235,
-0.39403191208839417,
-0.1452014446258545,
-0.6845795512199402,
-0.418526828289032,
0.6732617020606995,
0.05355551466345787,
-1.155838131904602,
0.772048830986023,
-0.3451782763004303,
0.3857182562351227,
-0.45107969641685486,
0.15755312144756317,
-0.3920319080352783,
0.11104559898376465,
0.11366559565067291,
-0.40383753180503845,
-0.03984764590859413,
-0.1767214983701706,
-0.5898188352584839,
0.3548743724822998,
0.9349443912506104,
-0.3132909834384918,
-0.31613290309906006,
0.30467891693115234,
0.5319370627403259,
0.28757229447364807,
-0.40411102771759033,
-0.4888456463813782,
-0.028690073639154434,
-0.05986563861370087,
-0.6730287075042725,
0.5655627250671387,
0.5787482261657715,
0.0427204892039299,
0.737664520740509,
0.6287365555763245,
-0.04850802198052406,
0.31398725509643555,
0.09916533529758453,
1.2416818141937256,
-0.7350594997406006,
-0.40401461720466614,
-0.699792206287384,
0.3779897391796112,
-0.09423352032899857,
-0.33882883191108704,
0.4509826898574829,
0.6009536385536194,
0.4655146896839142,
0.1876172572374344,
0.5805299282073975,
0.40256667137145996,
0.2989180386066437,
-0.522317111492157,
0.7481116652488708,
-0.8358624577522278,
0.10535749793052673,
0.14467483758926392,
-0.7045844197273254,
-0.3638896048069,
0.3331584632396698,
-0.27986350655555725,
-0.13991239666938782,
0.595615804195404,
1.1230727434158325,
-0.09633494913578033,
-0.3542827367782593,
0.438728928565979,
0.319344699382782,
0.34861400723457336,
0.4369781017303467,
0.6989036202430725,
-0.14082111418247223,
0.7240411043167114,
0.09888529032468796,
-0.17274825274944305,
-0.7863680124282837,
-0.8649956583976746,
-1.0714832544326782,
-0.44142770767211914,
0.14671535789966583,
-0.6846482753753662,
0.3216097056865692,
0.6979845762252808,
0.7661209106445312,
-0.39755579829216003,
0.12373379617929459,
-0.1507038027048111,
0.2721906900405884,
0.16810853779315948,
-0.20356684923171997,
0.4860416650772095,
-0.8331986665725708,
-0.4245149493217468,
0.6105850338935852,
0.6310554146766663,
-0.2570595443248749,
-0.25596627593040466,
-0.06804198026657104,
-0.14994947612285614,
0.36879217624664307,
0.6936677694320679,
0.5321162343025208,
-0.9319037795066833,
-0.2621351480484009,
0.3690071403980255,
-0.2700726389884949,
0.2820670008659363,
0.8664754629135132,
-1.0393306016921997,
0.8374753594398499,
0.4746318757534027,
1.000448226928711,
0.994650661945343,
-0.13090790808200836,
0.28734397888183594,
-0.5567929744720459,
-0.018186142668128014,
0.3993910849094391,
0.3791919946670532,
0.04207492619752884,
-0.6673482060432434,
0.46232008934020996,
0.2861255407333374,
-1.088022232055664,
-0.9432842135429382,
0.12075456231832504,
-1.218953251838684,
-0.06049622595310211,
1.2013121843338013,
-0.062162768095731735,
-0.7215361595153809,
-0.145762100815773,
-0.2441416084766388,
0.22877050936222076,
-0.5536969304084778,
0.9590631127357483,
0.7030567526817322,
-0.08902018517255783,
0.18620026111602783,
-0.7416797280311584,
0.599218487739563,
0.8330501914024353,
-0.3664613664150238,
0.42881831526756287,
0.4645107686519623,
0.15766505897045135,
-0.239430770277977,
0.7263979911804199,
0.129902645945549,
0.3951263427734375,
-0.25987306237220764,
-0.17472030222415924,
0.19401243329048157,
-0.5115602612495422,
-0.012559481896460056,
-0.01751977577805519,
0.0801667794585228,
-0.05575813353061676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10773v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10773v1
|
Quantifying Generative Media Bias with a Corpus of Real-world and Generated News Articles
| 2024-06-16T01:32:04 | 2024-06-16T01:32:04 |
Filip Trhlik, Pontus Stenetorp
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly being utilised across a range
of tasks and domains, with a burgeoning interest in their application within
the field of journalism. This trend raises concerns due to our limited
understanding of LLM behaviour in this domain, especially with respect to
political bias. Existing studies predominantly focus on LLMs undertaking
political questionnaires, which offers only limited insights into their biases
and operational nuances. To address this gap, our study establishes a new
curated dataset that contains 2,100 human-written articles and utilises their
descriptions to generate 56,700 synthetic articles using nine LLMs. This
enables us to analyse shifts in properties between human-authored and
machine-generated articles, with this study focusing on political bias,
detecting it using both supervised models and LLMs. Our findings reveal
significant disparities between base and instruction-tuned LLMs, with
instruction-tuned models exhibiting consistent political bias. Furthermore, we
are able to study how LLMs behave as classifiers, observing their display of
political bias even in this role. Overall, for the first time within the
journalistic domain, this study outlines a framework and provides a structured
dataset for quantifiable experiments, serving as a foundation for further
research into LLM political bias and its implications.
|
[
-0.47812598943710327,
-0.8869651556015015,
0.6403437852859497,
0.17139030992984772,
-0.20422163605690002,
0.21288876235485077,
-0.4053058624267578,
-0.014296842738986015,
0.30754318833351135,
0.5327447056770325,
-0.6421923041343689,
-0.5829253196716309,
-0.851059079170227,
0.08547428250312805,
-0.5560176372528076,
0.9149983525276184,
0.2522861659526825,
0.36030086874961853,
-0.24296212196350098,
-0.1144629567861557,
-0.1211647242307663,
-0.5957693457603455,
-0.08648833632469177,
-0.4598361551761627,
0.36158210039138794,
0.13637997210025787,
0.6976737976074219,
0.41539466381073,
0.13934823870658875,
0.10535889863967896,
-0.36709392070770264,
0.2530231475830078,
-0.713025689125061,
-0.22573703527450562,
-0.2257472723722458,
-0.6161811351776123,
-0.10371582955121994,
0.5116785168647766,
0.5864602327346802,
0.4991808533668518,
0.13043180108070374,
0.2913815677165985,
0.08305364102125168,
0.7985819578170776,
-0.6148076057434082,
-0.04806087911128998,
-0.872330904006958,
0.2734379172325134,
-0.20137816667556763,
-0.362637460231781,
-0.5347025990486145,
-0.34306445717811584,
-0.10611456632614136,
-0.5392200350761414,
0.4033270478248596,
-0.035504039376974106,
0.7726995348930359,
0.20047231018543243,
-0.698951244354248,
-0.3845268487930298,
-0.589270293712616,
0.8419163227081299,
-0.514832615852356,
0.4512125551700592,
0.2332698404788971,
-0.12173133343458176,
-0.12463592737913132,
-0.2782110273838043,
-0.7295902371406555,
-0.12164168804883957,
0.13125866651535034,
0.16603392362594604,
-0.13551472127437592,
-0.256771057844162,
0.260375052690506,
0.2709074914455414,
-0.4157989025115967,
0.14372135698795319,
-0.2667894661426544,
-0.1195344477891922,
0.46494579315185547,
0.1258598119020462,
0.19196726381778717,
-0.5420049428939819,
-0.24706490337848663,
0.012823005206882954,
-1.1181681156158447,
-0.5293939113616943,
0.9840937256813049,
0.1458878517150879,
-0.347381591796875,
0.8177129626274109,
-0.15251964330673218,
0.8269205689430237,
0.1362304985523224,
0.06199134513735771,
0.03488510474562645,
-0.3331221342086792,
-0.19384130835533142,
0.013504418544471264,
0.9435508251190186,
0.4688515067100525,
0.48206454515457153,
0.24677836894989014,
-0.06346698850393295,
0.329452782869339,
0.3457784950733185,
-0.611891508102417,
0.04184412583708763,
-0.09737575799226761,
-0.5054227709770203,
-0.7318132519721985,
0.18629345297813416,
-0.8755394816398621,
-0.789864718914032,
-0.4100595712661743,
-0.005716613493859768,
0.020644670352339745,
-0.3844652771949768,
0.0967579185962677,
0.05454506725072861,
0.15425187349319458,
0.016434384509921074,
-0.6380907297134399,
-0.1038438230752945,
0.7637456059455872,
0.7201856970787048,
-0.4163033664226532,
0.1705717146396637,
-0.3555387556552887,
-0.006580775137990713,
-0.5435084700584412,
0.6220635175704956,
-0.5513082146644592,
-0.20728786289691925,
0.46646642684936523,
-0.15231938660144806,
0.39634451270103455,
-0.8193991184234619,
0.5728256702423096,
-0.7518938183784485,
0.4048932194709778,
-0.2789989113807678,
-0.6398651599884033,
0.372120201587677,
0.2519952654838562,
-1.0289371013641357,
0.8765362501144409,
0.18085293471813202,
-0.9504329562187195,
0.7371023893356323,
-0.30341675877571106,
-0.3852667808532715,
-0.5032386183738708,
-0.49290546774864197,
-0.5092803239822388,
0.17854498326778412,
0.4443340301513672,
0.3783324360847473,
-0.3345434367656708,
0.7930524349212646,
-0.1331237405538559,
-0.33746299147605896,
0.45948126912117004,
-0.6503841280937195,
0.8689305186271667,
0.07795237749814987,
-0.33658379316329956,
0.12194614857435226,
-0.8265677094459534,
-0.4507667124271393,
-0.1458461433649063,
-0.5777091383934021,
-0.33229440450668335,
0.09209278970956802,
0.20418289303779602,
0.4002411663532257,
-0.08260288089513779,
-0.5569851994514465,
0.2040857970714569,
-0.1537553071975708,
0.6344272494316101,
0.8007798194885254,
-0.08199813216924667,
0.6703488230705261,
-0.2485196739435196,
0.48939529061317444,
0.23125971853733063,
-0.09330400824546814,
0.1517418473958969,
-0.12329518049955368,
-0.694149911403656,
-0.018122071400284767,
0.43910056352615356,
0.37814292311668396,
-0.7277648448944092,
0.47477230429649353,
-0.3354654014110565,
-0.050254937261343,
-0.6467602252960205,
0.19022315740585327,
0.03217550367116928,
0.17491601407527924,
-0.027392711490392685,
0.21888044476509094,
-0.7760248780250549,
-1.0542904138565063,
-0.3981454074382782,
-0.12016561627388,
-0.3417799472808838,
0.23322418332099915,
0.4597829282283783,
-0.1052321195602417,
0.9668818116188049,
-0.15948890149593353,
-0.1831977367401123,
-0.2539634108543396,
0.18119962513446808,
0.15069524943828583,
-0.04696550592780113,
0.269912451505661,
-0.835107147693634,
-0.13795171678066254,
-0.3218698501586914,
-0.8432895541191101,
-0.49935799837112427,
-0.46394363045692444,
-0.2437615841627121,
0.36957454681396484,
0.5354693531990051,
-0.8591951131820679,
0.3316512107849121,
0.8240752816200256,
-0.36646753549575806,
0.423179030418396,
0.41752082109451294,
-0.019093861803412437,
-1.0982296466827393,
-0.24387876689434052,
0.33808138966560364,
-0.3066530227661133,
-0.2374759167432785,
-0.23424141108989716,
0.0605500191450119,
0.25138258934020996,
-0.7075658440589905,
0.4974481165409088,
-0.5413517355918884,
-0.14084818959236145,
-0.2199312001466751,
0.1546347737312317,
0.16561560332775116,
0.007941833697259426,
0.1585260033607483,
0.8225501775741577,
0.1371055543422699,
-0.1823863983154297,
0.09848444908857346,
0.05903568118810654,
-0.8379194140434265,
0.6226857900619507,
-0.5325566530227661,
0.04770343005657196,
-0.2282225638628006,
0.46477779746055603,
-0.727778971195221,
-0.3067300319671631,
-0.04516802355647087,
-0.22640298306941986,
0.07762023061513901,
-0.17775724828243256,
-0.7892076373100281,
-0.1845976859331131,
-0.13811035454273224,
0.17693710327148438,
0.5121741890907288,
-0.46205127239227295,
0.31649675965309143,
0.5899950265884399,
0.0012101535685360432,
-0.44084692001342773,
-0.5756645202636719,
0.13462945818901062,
-0.40763550996780396,
-0.3945733606815338,
0.3761976659297943,
0.24692495167255402,
-0.6118791699409485,
0.035405483096838,
-0.11766314506530762,
0.21649675071239471,
-0.36337265372276306,
0.2582712173461914,
0.2295474261045456,
-0.10336478799581528,
0.19043324887752533,
0.001775979995727539,
0.30713212490081787,
0.29153573513031006,
-0.11505485326051712,
0.5909515619277954,
0.20111021399497986,
-0.29392772912979126,
-0.37685027718544006,
0.20899957418441772,
0.7021726965904236,
-0.07052811235189438,
0.7400882840156555,
0.5881741642951965,
-0.12943248450756073,
-0.4646952748298645,
-0.662155032157898,
-0.31441015005111694,
-0.3684670925140381,
0.39137622714042664,
0.07268113642930984,
-0.9759119153022766,
0.44675248861312866,
0.06088574230670929,
-0.1934540569782257,
0.34748998284339905,
1.0661778450012207,
0.14776429533958435,
0.9331653118133545,
0.4219019114971161,
-0.3477219343185425,
0.3676433265209198,
-0.26065459847450256,
0.1350884735584259,
-0.7107781767845154,
-0.2106369435787201,
-0.15424133837223053,
-0.2656569182872772,
-0.6276863813400269,
-0.3798656463623047,
0.41978690028190613,
-0.2372538447380066,
-0.23900222778320312,
-0.288015216588974,
-0.48987650871276855,
0.6898548603057861,
0.5211254954338074,
0.07612179219722748,
0.1442771703004837,
0.1765715479850769,
0.22607183456420898,
-0.034538500010967255,
-0.7468660473823547,
-0.6578196883201599,
1.2247430086135864,
0.2840883433818817,
1.0020215511322021,
-0.26636946201324463,
0.3992573320865631,
0.6635596752166748,
0.6379050612449646,
-0.5775279998779297,
0.3911839425563812,
0.04536893218755722,
-0.7123696208000183,
-0.049927178770303726,
-0.40473243594169617,
-0.7136988639831543,
0.389936238527298,
-0.2688072621822357,
0.011861885897815228,
0.10868991166353226,
-0.032232824712991714,
-0.11488611251115799,
0.4915488362312317,
-0.2848212420940399,
0.47506171464920044,
-0.15065744519233704,
-0.6878196597099304,
-0.16450631618499756,
-0.443422794342041,
0.6031680703163147,
-0.02628934569656849,
0.38222941756248474,
-0.31236040592193604,
-0.025609366595745087,
0.6583678126335144,
0.02825036644935608,
1.0637660026550293,
0.01689251884818077,
-0.41364172101020813,
0.25009670853614807,
-0.10592368990182877,
0.26068466901779175,
0.1579039990901947,
-0.18649570643901825,
0.27921339869499207,
-0.278197705745697,
-0.36313676834106445,
-0.13766896724700928,
0.7592721581459045,
-0.92934650182724,
-0.6268441081047058,
-0.40895876288414,
-0.8062143325805664,
-0.1227409839630127,
-0.1107831671833992,
0.40654727816581726,
0.21350128948688507,
-0.4760763943195343,
0.28447267413139343,
0.7099243998527527,
-0.38835540413856506,
0.09377428889274597,
0.4648507833480835,
-0.12575224041938782,
-0.14795956015586853,
0.5292819738388062,
0.22653324902057648,
0.2486855536699295,
0.35711947083473206,
0.0804901272058487,
-0.2449207752943039,
-0.16503779590129852,
-0.6659196615219116,
0.10264986753463745,
-0.4577276408672333,
-0.34501489996910095,
-0.32903409004211426,
-0.2269662618637085,
-0.052203599363565445,
-0.1717955768108368,
-0.2639482021331787,
-0.240019753575325,
-0.5983273386955261,
-0.31692779064178467,
0.06095924228429794,
0.798830509185791,
0.17199286818504333,
0.3252212107181549,
-0.19712166488170624,
0.5545336604118347,
0.10691714286804199,
0.2591962218284607,
-0.3579099476337433,
-0.5920088887214661,
-0.11691738665103912,
0.32716819643974304,
-0.43784087896347046,
-1.181423544883728,
0.5988578200340271,
0.04804331064224243,
0.3123824894428253,
0.34136873483657837,
0.0914151594042778,
0.14018239080905914,
-0.6096575856208801,
0.958901584148407,
-0.13874557614326477,
-0.6951223015785217,
0.5477758646011353,
-0.7400611639022827,
0.11931724101305008,
0.24611949920654297,
0.44389811158180237,
-0.03126539662480354,
-0.6393368244171143,
-0.5602552890777588,
-0.6353108882904053,
0.32304275035858154,
0.012696446850895882,
0.6407089233398438,
-0.38935038447380066,
0.2776530086994171,
0.1687559336423874,
0.3656107187271118,
-0.8688759803771973,
-0.050375018268823624,
-0.09579481184482574,
-0.11360375583171844,
0.16662389039993286,
-0.48050418496131897,
-0.33841925859451294,
-0.14597868919372559,
0.6265240907669067,
-0.06779378652572632,
0.03508434817194939,
0.021267715841531754,
-0.28954797983169556,
-0.24175013601779938,
0.3924102485179901,
0.6141672134399414,
0.884618878364563,
-0.07558515667915344,
0.33768951892852783,
-0.19285671412944794,
-0.11114707589149475,
0.299235075712204,
-0.19664302468299866,
-0.5180407166481018,
0.32431837916374207,
0.2577461898326874,
0.6222720146179199,
-0.06028037518262863,
-0.772298276424408,
0.6539461016654968,
0.2789325416088104,
-0.3353361487388611,
-0.5263673067092896,
-0.312619686126709,
0.3974339962005615,
0.1745510846376419,
0.33869966864585876,
-0.26215994358062744,
-0.039956867694854736,
-0.8096374273300171,
0.2240634262561798,
0.6962581276893616,
-0.22100403904914856,
-0.2749790549278259,
0.7322383522987366,
0.3055917024612427,
-0.12639208137989044,
0.5836669206619263,
-0.23946072161197662,
-0.3336854577064514,
0.6075756549835205,
0.5100861191749573,
0.5803127288818359,
0.09511540085077286,
0.539525032043457,
0.007598076947033405,
0.42564764618873596,
-0.00010606160503812134,
0.0403643473982811,
0.42159852385520935,
-0.9157084226608276,
-0.5385923981666565,
-0.6965723037719727,
-0.11608490347862244,
0.5703257322311401,
-0.8113143444061279,
0.13438354432582855,
-0.2402435690164566,
-0.4720812737941742,
0.184700608253479,
-0.05007053166627884,
-0.6089017391204834,
-0.02656659670174122,
0.5122906565666199,
0.8887919187545776,
-1.3200403451919556,
0.6840795278549194,
0.5064136981964111,
-0.08312295377254486,
-0.15769381821155548,
0.16668649017810822,
0.3210398554801941,
-0.8565230965614319,
0.6552155017852783,
0.0032001843210309744,
0.24663019180297852,
-0.3901994228363037,
-0.7064236402511597,
-0.3517012298107147,
0.6617618203163147,
0.6651557087898254,
-0.7451193332672119,
-0.0849226862192154,
0.5737830996513367,
0.42612528800964355,
-0.5291014313697815,
-0.08735419809818268,
0.7607526779174805,
0.4032222330570221,
-0.3386510908603668,
-0.49878713488578796,
-0.07299557328224182,
-0.11568386107683182,
0.044296957552433014,
0.1967201977968216,
-0.7369656562805176,
0.7333112955093384,
0.08182463049888611,
0.00569085543975234,
-0.31891903281211853,
0.5928237438201904,
0.21002483367919922,
0.25081226229667664,
0.3305807411670685,
0.48667609691619873,
0.3899466395378113,
-0.1915806233882904,
1.1315642595291138,
-0.5013139843940735,
0.10757844150066376,
0.9349990487098694,
-0.40430527925491333,
0.5639634132385254,
0.7016603946685791,
-0.14529451727867126,
0.49842000007629395,
0.525374710559845,
-0.1502799391746521,
0.4160056710243225,
0.6587785482406616,
-0.4666878879070282,
-0.23408806324005127,
-0.39568379521369934,
0.06820178031921387,
0.33073392510414124,
0.5302209258079529,
-0.7639850378036499,
-0.002613702556118369,
0.130576029419899,
0.30695444345474243,
0.40465956926345825,
-0.3562364876270294,
0.6338165998458862,
0.086306132376194,
-0.6633597016334534,
0.42970508337020874,
0.02841455675661564,
0.9280521273612976,
-0.23440925776958466,
-0.04043017700314522,
-0.3064485788345337,
-0.20451726019382477,
-0.2634606957435608,
-1.0165938138961792,
0.3394802510738373,
0.1765785962343216,
-0.46855130791664124,
-0.21527324616909027,
0.6334211230278015,
-0.5595800280570984,
-0.6751429438591003,
-0.10066872090101242,
0.9087141156196594,
-0.16711755096912384,
-0.14256006479263306,
-0.26755282282829285,
0.711829662322998,
0.05489276722073555,
-0.5759304165840149,
0.475529283285141,
0.39168256521224976,
-0.1224740743637085,
0.4462561309337616,
0.525871753692627,
0.35327133536338806,
0.21084469556808472,
0.3080207109451294,
0.8398915529251099,
-0.3777953088283539,
-0.11038531363010406,
-1.0562334060668945,
0.21263058483600616,
-0.18085519969463348,
-0.22474180161952972,
0.6825713515281677,
0.7506363987922668,
0.9696659445762634,
-0.19168192148208618,
1.1375904083251953,
0.08030588179826736,
0.3136211931705475,
-0.7109172344207764,
0.7232176065444946,
-0.2472665160894394,
0.29624855518341064,
0.15070345997810364,
-0.8656940460205078,
-0.11748430132865906,
0.6473708748817444,
-0.3802625238895416,
-0.059831708669662476,
0.09719719737768173,
1.0025169849395752,
-0.11626188457012177,
-0.17692719399929047,
0.1424213945865631,
0.17535772919654846,
0.10566316545009613,
0.28758126497268677,
1.1303147077560425,
0.14272703230381012,
0.2804983854293823,
-0.1630294919013977,
0.06351467221975327,
-0.05198828876018524,
-0.9341121315956116,
-1.0778003931045532,
-0.4348084330558777,
-0.13374215364456177,
-0.3790915310382843,
0.37751054763793945,
0.7796175479888916,
0.8618818521499634,
-0.4730561673641205,
-0.18645845353603363,
-0.06447814404964447,
0.15228945016860962,
0.2406202256679535,
-0.3312203884124756,
0.47900697588920593,
-0.08701657503843307,
-0.8267301321029663,
-0.06491611152887344,
-0.07859452813863754,
-0.30009332299232483,
-0.7215002179145813,
0.11495044827461243,
-0.0428074449300766,
0.3577326834201813,
0.9399775266647339,
-0.11854438483715057,
-1.0447585582733154,
-0.3255119323730469,
-0.07641110569238663,
-0.11943159997463226,
0.027412746101617813,
0.9334051012992859,
-0.9609643220901489,
0.15513956546783447,
0.40600717067718506,
0.45951059460639954,
0.36210358142852783,
0.164469376206398,
0.5083680152893066,
-1.1164424419403076,
0.1644241362810135,
0.19563475251197815,
0.05890221148729324,
0.644618570804596,
-0.17852269113063812,
0.39967331290245056,
0.11249448359012604,
-0.494872123003006,
-0.9453427791595459,
0.2609473466873169,
-0.8206276893615723,
-0.2088504582643509,
1.6129066944122314,
0.34222128987312317,
0.03171820193529129,
0.2910057604312897,
-0.19084039330482483,
0.3307875990867615,
-0.2745852768421173,
0.9868624210357666,
0.755651593208313,
0.03886766731739044,
-0.333271324634552,
-1.0118516683578491,
0.4181029200553894,
0.16395875811576843,
-0.7884912490844727,
0.21054378151893616,
0.8804295063018799,
0.3835121989250183,
-0.20088237524032593,
0.4387480318546295,
-0.20717661082744598,
-0.0745043084025383,
-0.09913929551839828,
-0.05171452462673187,
0.08861972391605377,
-0.19281001389026642,
-0.16606558859348297,
0.07121254503726959,
-0.17002809047698975,
0.13716191053390503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10764v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10764v1
|
GNOME: Generating Negotiations through Open-Domain Mapping of Exchanges
| 2024-06-16T00:26:17 | 2024-06-16T00:26:17 |
Darshan Deshpande, Shambhavi Sinha, Anirudh Ravi Kumar, Debaditya Pal, Jonathan May
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language Models have previously shown strong negotiation capabilities in
closed domains where the negotiation strategy prediction scope is constrained
to a specific setup. In this paper, we first show that these models are not
generalizable beyond their original training domain despite their wide-scale
pretraining. Following this, we propose an automated framework called GNOME,
which processes existing human-annotated, closed-domain datasets using Large
Language Models and produces synthetic open-domain dialogues for negotiation.
GNOME improves the generalizability of negotiation systems while reducing the
expensive and subjective task of manual data curation. Through our experimental
setup, we create a benchmark comparing encoder and decoder models trained on
existing datasets against datasets created through GNOME. Our results show that
models trained on our dataset not only perform better than previous state of
the art models on domain specific strategy prediction, but also generalize
better to previously unseen domains.
|
[
-0.8947088718414307,
-0.5072565078735352,
0.5804706811904907,
-0.22546470165252686,
0.029384054243564606,
-0.10521353036165237,
-0.8639156222343445,
-0.48318326473236084,
0.1695476919412613,
0.6024941205978394,
-0.26649588346481323,
-0.6323838233947754,
-0.4781518876552582,
0.14173905551433563,
-0.046199455857276917,
0.8907246589660645,
-0.2457938939332962,
-0.21175169944763184,
-0.32473528385162354,
-0.15520018339157104,
-0.018956806510686874,
-0.6669273972511292,
-0.7127429842948914,
-0.3370699882507324,
-0.035255275666713715,
0.18951745331287384,
1.027881383895874,
0.23708783090114594,
0.35126298666000366,
0.33464258909225464,
0.08468097448348999,
0.008634969592094421,
-0.7181711792945862,
0.09054281562566757,
-0.525267481803894,
-0.06560715287923813,
-0.6846047043800354,
0.329026997089386,
0.41795778274536133,
0.8243657350540161,
-0.37408724427223206,
0.01787901110947132,
-0.10399674624204636,
0.3652535378932953,
-0.641722559928894,
0.23482678830623627,
-0.9881929159164429,
0.12791477143764496,
-0.06314849853515625,
0.07019490748643875,
-0.5830793380737305,
-0.20892934501171112,
0.4494076669216156,
-1.2311877012252808,
0.1708681285381317,
0.2770496606826782,
1.212267279624939,
-0.43075329065322876,
-0.3074536919593811,
-0.23081432282924652,
-0.8930544853210449,
0.6332212090492249,
-0.6229566931724548,
0.3514139950275421,
0.31328439712524414,
0.6199665069580078,
-0.5177881121635437,
-0.8742867112159729,
-0.5527159571647644,
-0.12065310776233673,
-0.459453821182251,
0.28736722469329834,
-0.6413566470146179,
0.23836840689182281,
0.3945292532444,
0.4186374247074127,
-0.5336410999298096,
-0.19650602340698242,
-0.45296019315719604,
-0.09204305708408356,
0.5335714817047119,
0.11250945180654526,
0.13184714317321777,
0.15037965774536133,
-0.23681141436100006,
0.04943174868822098,
-0.4769439697265625,
-0.15556132793426514,
0.4943660795688629,
0.39062944054603577,
-0.013336977921426296,
0.2940458357334137,
-0.5239725112915039,
0.7977232336997986,
0.23190927505493164,
0.3095496594905853,
-0.1175893023610115,
0.022791601717472076,
-0.48601245880126953,
-0.4471721947193146,
0.8164993524551392,
0.4969113767147064,
0.5190443992614746,
-0.6017912030220032,
-0.3870270848274231,
0.11611537635326385,
0.4043271541595459,
-0.5494438409805298,
-0.5339192152023315,
0.34659722447395325,
-0.5846613049507141,
-0.2445985972881317,
0.027840860188007355,
-0.7365410327911377,
0.3106785714626312,
-0.6232516765594482,
0.28637784719467163,
-0.16813641786575317,
-0.656059980392456,
0.425249308347702,
-0.30298665165901184,
0.2095939964056015,
0.522439181804657,
-1.0263359546661377,
1.1108620166778564,
0.5652853846549988,
0.5540832281112671,
-0.09032593667507172,
-0.15701763331890106,
-0.4763549268245697,
0.3071536719799042,
-0.5250042676925659,
0.5307440161705017,
-0.796777069568634,
-0.49909043312072754,
0.19130326807498932,
-0.16635794937610626,
-0.1432109773159027,
-0.6743566989898682,
0.26346442103385925,
-0.8384271264076233,
0.39257630705833435,
0.11230258643627167,
-0.5296878218650818,
0.08331258594989777,
0.7442527413368225,
-0.8648259043693542,
0.5799075961112976,
0.3514164984226227,
-0.3950268030166626,
0.3135334253311157,
-0.9566453099250793,
-0.1467519998550415,
0.09795290231704712,
-0.002523927018046379,
-0.18173177540302277,
0.07340484112501144,
0.21889923512935638,
0.32617485523223877,
-0.5579721927642822,
0.34117943048477173,
-0.3168904185295105,
-0.058227017521858215,
0.16813033819198608,
0.19331414997577667,
0.41469064354896545,
0.2862367630004883,
0.1095392182469368,
0.02631470002233982,
-0.46931836009025574,
0.02254847250878811,
0.2825225591659546,
-0.3815670311450958,
-0.4415993392467499,
-0.3491014540195465,
-0.14958669245243073,
0.23681695759296417,
0.13113541901111603,
-0.6658048033714294,
0.6703681349754333,
-0.2933086156845093,
0.13720111548900604,
0.7262688875198364,
-0.3660435974597931,
0.8246265649795532,
-0.040343862026929855,
0.7372643351554871,
-0.0621814951300621,
0.20537513494491577,
0.2923966646194458,
-0.45346882939338684,
-0.6479662656784058,
-0.101018026471138,
0.8395271897315979,
0.27061647176742554,
-0.8011564016342163,
0.0634121522307396,
-0.7763019800186157,
-0.28983041644096375,
-0.5865422487258911,
-0.24076420068740845,
0.3268888592720032,
0.29600247740745544,
0.20848588645458221,
-0.6434241533279419,
-0.3956807553768158,
-0.8206651210784912,
-0.21347185969352722,
-0.17873132228851318,
-0.16110822558403015,
0.46293020248413086,
0.41407477855682373,
-0.1754993051290512,
1.037065863609314,
-0.6044831871986389,
-0.2092699557542801,
-0.17558608949184418,
0.36618050932884216,
0.07345640659332275,
0.35706233978271484,
0.6918763518333435,
-0.623457670211792,
-0.7005794644355774,
0.5461720824241638,
-0.7102471590042114,
0.2872880697250366,
-0.1342565417289734,
-0.7278834581375122,
0.14756059646606445,
0.4247509241104126,
-0.7783976197242737,
0.486706018447876,
0.4755017161369324,
-0.08414992690086365,
0.6345376968383789,
-0.14812161028385162,
0.05063329264521599,
-0.8827703595161438,
0.26494839787483215,
-0.23218266665935516,
-0.33952596783638,
-0.9346805810928345,
0.04020688682794571,
-0.16701640188694,
-0.6460071802139282,
-0.388704389333725,
0.8120548129081726,
-0.5637215971946716,
-0.1072835698723793,
-0.19768108427524567,
0.3145627975463867,
-0.10815327614545822,
0.7775121927261353,
0.5938981771469116,
0.6645876169204712,
0.6522064208984375,
-0.949706494808197,
0.31307289004325867,
0.7403433322906494,
-0.19830408692359924,
0.6193370819091797,
-0.4380344748497009,
0.2557353675365448,
0.28357619047164917,
0.4760894775390625,
-0.4227104187011719,
-0.35467445850372314,
0.48405179381370544,
-0.2830999493598938,
0.42526116967201233,
-0.48979777097702026,
-0.2903991639614105,
-0.35582444071769714,
-0.0880240723490715,
0.28374069929122925,
0.5375009179115295,
-0.7816969156265259,
0.913969874382019,
0.32351306080818176,
-0.02688816748559475,
-0.43335890769958496,
-0.11987920850515366,
0.2590714693069458,
-0.06177711859345436,
-0.7098883390426636,
0.4182068109512329,
0.11409107595682144,
-0.1938808709383011,
0.10759732127189636,
0.11804910749197006,
0.0784384086728096,
0.12998516857624054,
-0.05542013421654701,
0.07927466183900833,
-0.2703704535961151,
-0.022600993514060974,
0.022572198882699013,
-0.3193899095058441,
0.13056375086307526,
-0.6722690463066101,
0.34724369645118713,
0.06247143819928169,
-0.32956141233444214,
0.015218868851661682,
0.536902129650116,
0.4536457359790802,
-0.1987755000591278,
0.6883212924003601,
0.32688480615615845,
-0.39043545722961426,
-0.1489318162202835,
-0.11792972683906555,
-0.22138254344463348,
-0.5033045411109924,
-0.10200250148773193,
-0.9715796709060669,
-0.8054476380348206,
0.5722338557243347,
-0.8931927680969238,
0.3111799657344818,
0.40041205286979675,
0.35679319500923157,
0.28783130645751953,
0.9849774837493896,
0.6179759502410889,
-0.006198126822710037,
0.09025439620018005,
-0.36033034324645996,
0.37787050008773804,
-0.9363623857498169,
0.04726853594183922,
-0.3347057104110718,
-0.35907691717147827,
-0.6689337491989136,
-0.22637152671813965,
0.3093329668045044,
0.06566060334444046,
-0.2648859918117523,
0.46099746227264404,
-0.46502214670181274,
0.5976133942604065,
0.7774163484573364,
-0.4125894606113434,
0.1778605878353119,
0.15840259194374084,
-0.4259134829044342,
0.0834793895483017,
-0.7380123734474182,
-0.6708957552909851,
1.294282078742981,
0.12632310390472412,
0.767785906791687,
0.28388679027557373,
0.4700144827365875,
0.10468053072690964,
0.5626347661018372,
-0.5223509669303894,
0.7014672756195068,
0.13756145536899567,
-0.38634613156318665,
-0.44929251074790955,
-0.4593494236469269,
-1.2106324434280396,
0.43716996908187866,
-0.26873770356178284,
-0.7583631873130798,
0.3863963186740875,
-0.02375951036810875,
-0.04695046693086624,
0.6041721105575562,
-0.4119302034378052,
0.8982756733894348,
0.12255437672138214,
-0.14286713302135468,
-0.015093276277184486,
-0.42162489891052246,
0.23656372725963593,
0.008536425419151783,
0.062461573630571365,
0.0215021762996912,
0.34499189257621765,
0.6335968375205994,
-0.3850947618484497,
0.584391176700592,
-0.19512812793254852,
-0.24534250795841217,
0.032564833760261536,
0.4421338438987732,
0.7205776572227478,
-0.1539098620414734,
-0.22178514301776886,
0.1570652723312378,
-0.39236512780189514,
-0.5104293823242188,
-0.6619173288345337,
0.5284093022346497,
-0.8126901984214783,
-0.8459039330482483,
-0.35185831785202026,
-0.20131786167621613,
-0.4437149167060852,
0.013057282194495201,
0.2816503047943115,
0.12182291597127914,
-0.8615436553955078,
-0.4330402612686157,
0.3686941862106323,
0.08476421236991882,
-0.009722230024635792,
0.732729434967041,
-0.33160272240638733,
-0.3825967609882355,
0.9913191199302673,
-0.2992035746574402,
0.4444640278816223,
0.1670774668455124,
-0.08201191574335098,
-0.03518461063504219,
-0.3296135365962982,
-0.4664032757282257,
0.11555638164281845,
-0.744987428188324,
-0.45997563004493713,
-0.4102412164211273,
-0.09551525861024857,
-0.4865094721317291,
-0.48446691036224365,
-0.19356951117515564,
-0.7438438534736633,
-0.1410493552684784,
-0.26949530839920044,
0.3444242477416992,
0.7752732038497925,
-0.45258787274360657,
0.4200393259525299,
-0.6402103900909424,
0.29281604290008545,
0.5313115119934082,
0.5535890460014343,
0.01736200600862503,
-0.18308007717132568,
-0.5687552094459534,
0.04699753224849701,
-0.5146867036819458,
-0.47061240673065186,
0.5473878383636475,
0.23421241343021393,
0.46278274059295654,
0.41744378209114075,
0.25532615184783936,
0.6182244420051575,
-0.6242738962173462,
0.9857745170593262,
0.21293704211711884,
-1.1973438262939453,
0.6684356331825256,
-0.4086800515651703,
0.0320998951792717,
0.25587373971939087,
0.3744219243526459,
-0.6630426049232483,
-0.6102200746536255,
-0.8294757604598999,
-0.758798360824585,
1.1283470392227173,
0.37322813272476196,
0.18927979469299316,
-0.04089380428195,
0.2729128897190094,
0.38823625445365906,
0.2819756865501404,
-0.4158584475517273,
0.001472657429985702,
-0.06906608492136002,
0.2124032825231552,
0.28071996569633484,
0.06759542226791382,
-0.6397668123245239,
-0.2484305053949356,
0.7940906286239624,
-0.2433532178401947,
0.6375998854637146,
-0.19191737473011017,
-0.03631209954619408,
-0.49433502554893494,
0.2712372839450836,
0.32922282814979553,
0.693810224533081,
-0.19679521024227142,
-0.18326719105243683,
0.1249249279499054,
-0.13644486665725708,
-0.011194637045264244,
0.20360326766967773,
0.1308882236480713,
0.21158337593078613,
0.1258390247821808,
1.1022365093231201,
0.0011177756823599339,
-0.49435660243034363,
0.4435478746891022,
-0.3850339651107788,
-0.7728976011276245,
-0.2308691442012787,
0.006943254731595516,
-0.1724637895822525,
0.0783294215798378,
-0.07046524435281754,
-0.15500962734222412,
0.2304082214832306,
-0.22130191326141357,
0.05276527628302574,
0.49898046255111694,
-0.06812743097543716,
-0.5532199740409851,
0.6852700710296631,
0.5017169117927551,
0.06267242133617401,
1.0000700950622559,
-0.18739964067935944,
-0.6367577910423279,
0.15304802358150482,
0.3743153512477875,
0.8796551823616028,
-0.1521490067243576,
0.43581995368003845,
0.26113656163215637,
0.1683770716190338,
0.07366951555013657,
0.20334501564502716,
-0.2523077130317688,
-0.7150139212608337,
-0.18424540758132935,
-0.31632038950920105,
-0.9234545230865479,
0.2819739580154419,
-0.9713565707206726,
0.18383441865444183,
-0.18393869698047638,
-0.3718120753765106,
-0.16423414647579193,
0.013986307196319103,
-1.058815360069275,
0.0501631498336792,
0.12773600220680237,
0.9989281892776489,
-0.7237235903739929,
0.6858025193214417,
0.7293208241462708,
-0.20121797919273376,
-0.24402369558811188,
0.025714421644806862,
-0.521980345249176,
-0.3622511923313141,
0.6446634531021118,
-0.2330499142408371,
0.0834965780377388,
-0.1802927702665329,
-0.718596339225769,
-0.6388283967971802,
0.8481948375701904,
0.7523913383483887,
-0.48597121238708496,
-0.05549532175064087,
0.33238571882247925,
0.4734804630279541,
-0.5425429344177246,
0.200304314494133,
0.6762478947639465,
0.6028363704681396,
-0.22891490161418915,
-1.278450608253479,
0.038162000477313995,
-0.4518354833126068,
0.052259571850299835,
0.38092637062072754,
-0.5125523805618286,
0.8725012540817261,
0.2872444987297058,
-0.374735951423645,
0.18860091269016266,
0.6375299096107483,
-0.31898242235183716,
0.135351300239563,
0.3194398283958435,
0.7462378740310669,
0.7480626702308655,
-0.2144126296043396,
1.1488572359085083,
-0.23441769182682037,
0.35592806339263916,
0.9005286693572998,
-0.46768370270729065,
0.766660749912262,
0.13269352912902832,
0.029591530561447144,
0.5708231925964355,
0.6801228523254395,
0.23820807039737701,
0.6558996438980103,
0.4657089114189148,
-0.23351629078388214,
-0.6005653738975525,
0.14197227358818054,
-0.2397095263004303,
0.12506644427776337,
0.6388015151023865,
-0.14711864292621613,
-0.43852362036705017,
0.15068215131759644,
-0.08628170192241669,
0.0606335811316967,
-0.13376833498477936,
1.2266027927398682,
-0.029712559655308723,
-0.5714324116706848,
0.7956075072288513,
0.17178086936473846,
0.28017666935920715,
-0.7368190288543701,
-0.10036073625087738,
-0.04813089221715927,
-0.044893261045217514,
0.22517046332359314,
-0.6093034744262695,
0.023970507085323334,
-0.2891373038291931,
-0.0086899995803833,
-0.38997507095336914,
0.7505958676338196,
-0.5934093594551086,
0.022958870977163315,
0.3830750286579132,
0.6434124112129211,
0.2105366438627243,
0.038719870150089264,
-0.6265620589256287,
0.08434811979532242,
-0.2616482079029083,
-0.5360465049743652,
0.5920464396476746,
0.8100009560585022,
-0.2259332686662674,
0.3538075387477875,
0.653148353099823,
0.060256924480199814,
-0.4500710070133209,
-0.24103206396102905,
1.2679322957992554,
-0.3861061930656433,
-0.5084663033485413,
-0.23773205280303955,
0.4176470935344696,
-0.3777890205383301,
-0.1927000880241394,
0.39193108677864075,
0.5103781819343567,
1.2143739461898804,
-0.39259767532348633,
1.0855224132537842,
0.36765193939208984,
0.38686150312423706,
-0.5537844300270081,
0.4999723732471466,
-0.2677789032459259,
0.06526555866003036,
0.05329011753201485,
-0.7411483526229858,
-0.13015396893024445,
0.6244996786117554,
-0.5485607981681824,
-0.20495028793811798,
0.5210898518562317,
0.5139841437339783,
-0.7906531095504761,
0.2091149240732193,
0.4158758223056793,
0.02952900156378746,
0.3619042932987213,
0.5411127805709839,
0.7478019595146179,
-0.3461741507053375,
0.421987384557724,
-0.03871000185608864,
-0.07264972478151321,
-0.3354620039463043,
-0.5900565385818481,
-1.1007957458496094,
-0.6508563160896301,
-0.4496122896671295,
-0.4083937406539917,
0.16736212372779846,
0.8224984407424927,
0.7971482872962952,
-0.8409560918807983,
-0.44978833198547363,
0.09368690103292465,
-0.008024436421692371,
-0.3165197968482971,
-0.18768124282360077,
0.32304757833480835,
-0.45363685488700867,
-0.8554242253303528,
0.22899168729782104,
0.06829778105020523,
0.12220768630504608,
-0.22946234047412872,
-0.3392172157764435,
0.21835872530937195,
0.5151350498199463,
0.5127849578857422,
0.5538331270217896,
-0.6397697925567627,
-0.1811893731355667,
-0.1220247745513916,
0.07789856195449829,
0.14668594300746918,
1.160390019416809,
-1.0009156465530396,
0.685678243637085,
0.05246715992689133,
0.3791855573654175,
0.4347023367881775,
-0.16478990018367767,
1.2907204627990723,
-0.8877953290939331,
0.1261340230703354,
0.18208527565002441,
0.22907114028930664,
0.3519202470779419,
-0.2338450402021408,
0.7751900553703308,
-0.1652219593524933,
-0.2900102138519287,
-0.6463025808334351,
0.26514044404029846,
-0.5474745631217957,
-0.19392679631710052,
1.0170917510986328,
-0.41069239377975464,
-0.3300756514072418,
-0.30581337213516235,
-0.19114311039447784,
-0.1009260043501854,
-0.6635931134223938,
0.5648471117019653,
0.8765671849250793,
0.1390170305967331,
0.5238825678825378,
-0.19715045392513275,
0.8518494963645935,
0.0063009485602378845,
-0.6539150476455688,
0.3816370666027069,
0.5011326670646667,
-0.1228298619389534,
0.28805479407310486,
0.8536511063575745,
0.132618248462677,
0.36368775367736816,
-0.06963410973548889,
-0.02089828997850418,
0.14632990956306458,
-0.39822909235954285,
-0.05301055684685707,
0.1290605664253235,
-0.03843962401151657,
-0.2592180669307709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10746v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10746v1
|
SparseCL: Sparse Contrastive Learning for Contradiction Retrieval
| 2024-06-15T21:57:03 | 2024-06-15T21:57:03 |
Haike Xu, Zongyu Lin, Yizhou Sun, Kai-Wei Chang, Piotr Indyk
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Contradiction retrieval refers to identifying and extracting documents that
explicitly disagree with or refute the content of a query, which is important
to many downstream applications like fact checking and data cleaning. To
retrieve contradiction argument to the query from large document corpora,
existing methods such as similarity search and crossencoder models exhibit
significant limitations. The former struggles to capture the essence of
contradiction due to its inherent nature of favoring similarity, while the
latter suffers from computational inefficiency, especially when the size of
corpora is large. To address these challenges, we introduce a novel approach:
SparseCL that leverages specially trained sentence embeddings designed to
preserve subtle, contradictory nuances between sentences. Our method utilizes a
combined metric of cosine similarity and a sparsity function to efficiently
identify and retrieve documents that contradict a given query. This approach
dramatically enhances the speed of contradiction detection by reducing the need
for exhaustive document comparisons to simple vector calculations. We validate
our model using the Arguana dataset, a benchmark dataset specifically geared
towards contradiction retrieval, as well as synthetic contradictions generated
from the MSMARCO and HotpotQA datasets using GPT-4. Our experiments demonstrate
the efficacy of our approach not only in contradiction retrieval with more than
30% accuracy improvements on MSMARCO and HotpotQA across different model
architectures but also in applications such as cleaning corrupted corpora to
restore high-quality QA retrieval. This paper outlines a promising direction
for improving the accuracy and efficiency of contradiction retrieval in
large-scale text corpora.
|
[
-0.4703488051891327,
-0.7668951749801636,
0.6022962927818298,
0.26925230026245117,
-0.2493961900472641,
-0.035885315388441086,
-0.11616989970207214,
-0.3533659279346466,
0.06779856234788895,
0.3232659101486206,
-0.7313899397850037,
-0.43556374311447144,
-0.5353328585624695,
0.42250657081604004,
-0.4698111414909363,
1.0822103023529053,
-0.12283624708652496,
0.1335643231868744,
-0.4103168845176697,
-0.5788103342056274,
-0.4540124237537384,
-0.25202494859695435,
-0.07992230355739594,
-0.12368898093700409,
0.5766205787658691,
0.40706104040145874,
0.853178083896637,
0.5331376791000366,
0.16184256970882416,
0.40476396679878235,
-0.03974549099802971,
0.3877922594547272,
-0.6698141098022461,
0.13898861408233643,
-0.3305695652961731,
-0.464018851518631,
0.27802035212516785,
-0.12952549755573273,
0.40927359461784363,
0.6572285890579224,
0.01695443131029606,
-0.2173183560371399,
0.29959195852279663,
0.5222194194793701,
-0.6747012138366699,
0.04414968937635422,
-0.9277716279029846,
0.1449497789144516,
-0.03922935947775841,
-0.22023898363113403,
-0.14519013464450836,
-0.541559100151062,
0.0727265253663063,
-0.9852801561355591,
0.8372329473495483,
0.3814104199409485,
1.1423885822296143,
0.6217273473739624,
-0.12256484478712082,
-0.8396272659301758,
-0.254323273897171,
0.759434163570404,
-0.43611377477645874,
0.45737573504447937,
0.08720675110816956,
-0.05054664611816406,
-0.09591581672430038,
-0.5425146222114563,
-0.8038623332977295,
-0.16043362021446228,
-0.17184187471866608,
0.0699220523238182,
-0.281411737203598,
-0.17545095086097717,
0.33798572421073914,
0.44333600997924805,
-1.044284701347351,
-0.12919725477695465,
-0.17185522615909576,
-0.17010366916656494,
0.05592024698853493,
0.06521280109882355,
-0.054281286895275116,
-0.17475153505802155,
-0.5509406924247742,
-0.3260214030742645,
-0.8095978498458862,
-0.42378559708595276,
0.5846535563468933,
0.14408369362354279,
0.14470288157463074,
0.4024144411087036,
0.03790338337421417,
0.44021689891815186,
0.16371189057826996,
0.25457867980003357,
0.30469822883605957,
-0.2787383198738098,
-0.2161872237920761,
0.07157164812088013,
0.6185689568519592,
-0.17023919522762299,
-0.3201254606246948,
-0.15454646944999695,
-0.34803885221481323,
0.05778231844305992,
0.045600924640893936,
-0.7475170493125916,
-0.2473231852054596,
0.08028639107942581,
-0.06729525327682495,
0.001202401239424944,
0.10646415501832962,
-1.0755195617675781,
-0.5958495140075684,
-0.29144251346588135,
0.5082759261131287,
-0.48867738246917725,
0.2289641797542572,
0.06817785650491714,
-0.09125536680221558,
0.03615798428654671,
0.3356649577617645,
-0.6797565817832947,
0.5642295479774475,
0.7953281998634338,
0.8996224999427795,
-0.12469282746315002,
-0.2532123327255249,
-0.7047382593154907,
-0.2232786864042282,
-0.30319511890411377,
0.7234275937080383,
-0.5119816660881042,
-0.16428819298744202,
0.10987870395183563,
-0.08780214935541153,
0.03400719165802002,
-0.9636605978012085,
1.0043100118637085,
-0.48986491560935974,
0.21964189410209656,
-0.48264092206954956,
-0.40040603280067444,
-0.08831705152988434,
0.32576972246170044,
-0.7185783386230469,
1.0315468311309814,
0.12428710609674454,
-0.9193121790885925,
0.07046573609113693,
-0.0522717610001564,
-0.17329299449920654,
0.11236720532178879,
-0.4620916247367859,
-0.7868690490722656,
-0.054415490478277206,
0.05615938827395439,
0.18613122403621674,
-0.5578504204750061,
0.07872355729341507,
-0.36281490325927734,
-0.6184243559837341,
0.1619323194026947,
-0.4391337037086487,
0.7716051340103149,
0.3528152406215668,
-0.4920557141304016,
0.05701521039009094,
-0.5829764008522034,
-0.1756632924079895,
0.1272207498550415,
-0.01047447044402361,
-0.7550545334815979,
-0.11304165422916412,
-0.02152666449546814,
0.1821359395980835,
0.16912637650966644,
-0.5219853520393372,
-0.060616977512836456,
-0.47943583130836487,
0.3228164613246918,
0.6539820432662964,
-0.05947255343198776,
0.19225385785102844,
-0.28515589237213135,
0.121531642973423,
0.04078500717878342,
0.02513289265334606,
0.060721900314092636,
-0.31664416193962097,
-0.7726182341575623,
-0.321857750415802,
0.4642927348613739,
0.583427906036377,
-0.8399075865745544,
0.5318022966384888,
-0.24049502611160278,
-0.13187424838542938,
-0.8707255721092224,
0.4908258616924286,
0.5493220686912537,
0.6749351620674133,
0.6283488273620605,
0.06286513805389404,
-0.6187540888786316,
-0.7706596255302429,
-0.2843993306159973,
0.1694130152463913,
0.046847857534885406,
0.4156360626220703,
0.6989560127258301,
-0.1747206449508667,
0.5461450219154358,
-0.5712085366249084,
-0.4691568911075592,
0.12443286180496216,
0.4512212574481964,
0.16067901253700256,
0.5070068836212158,
0.2965153455734253,
-1.432149887084961,
-0.4591115713119507,
-0.125022754073143,
-0.7432880997657776,
-0.4418953061103821,
-0.22182951867580414,
-0.0067587909288704395,
0.16756907105445862,
0.6306349039077759,
-0.466879278421402,
0.31823021173477173,
0.4647195041179657,
-0.2520187795162201,
0.3899412155151367,
-0.2941911518573761,
0.23559047281742096,
-0.7566377520561218,
0.08963173627853394,
-0.018139563500881195,
-0.21529531478881836,
-0.1753673553466797,
0.13186053931713104,
0.03911704197525978,
0.00913206022232771,
-0.19711321592330933,
0.12507043778896332,
-0.3725469410419464,
-0.004874083679169416,
-0.07528845965862274,
0.43995940685272217,
0.23063042759895325,
0.543502151966095,
-0.20210495591163635,
0.8766979575157166,
-0.007877049036324024,
-0.31028151512145996,
0.37755340337753296,
0.5452054738998413,
-0.21175213158130646,
0.6856525540351868,
-0.7955861687660217,
0.030711829662322998,
-0.12984798848628998,
0.06799588352441788,
-1.243731141090393,
0.007527958136051893,
0.2415519654750824,
-0.14980542659759521,
0.18824121356010437,
-0.03523042052984238,
-0.6125994324684143,
-0.13324390351772308,
-0.4604092240333557,
0.5239630937576294,
0.16438955068588257,
-0.8136689066886902,
0.3290341794490814,
-0.029660362750291824,
-0.20949968695640564,
-1.0202432870864868,
-0.6716828942298889,
-0.12703099846839905,
-0.05694848671555519,
-0.2858334481716156,
0.4248272478580475,
-0.27216389775276184,
-0.14279107749462128,
0.20598900318145752,
-0.1836087554693222,
-0.08347189426422119,
-0.09187330305576324,
0.3920139670372009,
0.3808444142341614,
-0.20705531537532806,
0.2138853371143341,
0.24886088073253632,
0.12575682997703552,
-0.22767266631126404,
-0.3036212921142578,
0.559787929058075,
-0.3124445974826813,
-0.4160584509372711,
-0.07980471104383469,
0.5881068110466003,
0.21506960690021515,
0.08220725506544113,
0.5979243516921997,
0.499260812997818,
-0.3474947512149811,
-0.1407928466796875,
-0.7432910203933716,
0.20873242616653442,
-0.454738050699234,
0.2214294672012329,
-0.41396525502204895,
-0.9242302179336548,
0.3900260329246521,
-0.11486244201660156,
-0.28191524744033813,
0.4919724762439728,
0.4564124345779419,
0.23953154683113098,
0.7879244685173035,
0.46267732977867126,
0.04749175161123276,
0.23355935513973236,
-0.14291168749332428,
0.03054889850318432,
-0.5459670424461365,
-0.5139839053153992,
-0.9327425956726074,
0.025536546483635902,
-0.6062348484992981,
-0.3861736059188843,
0.23688317835330963,
-0.020053621381521225,
-0.3728105127811432,
0.3677058815956116,
-0.47095876932144165,
0.6366364359855652,
0.1628120243549347,
0.05259164050221443,
0.3015102744102478,
0.0873616561293602,
-0.5201412439346313,
-0.28932175040245056,
-0.6579453945159912,
-0.2950611412525177,
0.5307250022888184,
-0.09570705890655518,
0.6513082385063171,
0.1497645527124405,
0.5947656035423279,
0.3342842757701874,
0.21796996891498566,
-0.6112395524978638,
0.33724144101142883,
-0.13872206211090088,
-0.23241151869297028,
-0.04628841578960419,
-0.9500684142112732,
-0.9570084810256958,
0.5860328674316406,
-0.4855809211730957,
-0.17111288011074066,
0.5524880886077881,
-0.0829635038971901,
-0.19858193397521973,
0.15666146576404572,
-0.8456099033355713,
1.0975396633148193,
0.00418807240203023,
-0.7440882325172424,
-0.10964746028184891,
-0.6540054082870483,
0.2742156982421875,
-0.17264415323734283,
0.01968487724661827,
0.20141039788722992,
-0.2635754346847534,
0.2734587490558624,
-0.47810178995132446,
0.5611368417739868,
0.15039612352848053,
-0.17570224404335022,
0.012282570824027061,
0.15024334192276,
0.46354860067367554,
0.09493745118379593,
-0.10512274503707886,
0.09183488041162491,
-0.0013267603935673833,
-0.5394529700279236,
-0.7769156694412231,
1.2441550493240356,
-0.8028415441513062,
-0.5385608077049255,
-0.7064338326454163,
-0.6650422215461731,
-0.09749812632799149,
0.4098817706108093,
0.36899876594543457,
0.3270289897918701,
-0.4636989235877991,
0.05211750417947769,
1.1213245391845703,
-0.3862617611885071,
-0.014001177623867989,
0.39941975474357605,
0.4169215261936188,
-0.5023097395896912,
0.979181170463562,
0.0094217574223876,
-0.04695701599121094,
0.6508713960647583,
-0.03676385059952736,
-0.5830576419830322,
-0.3092668354511261,
-0.31106728315353394,
0.44387489557266235,
-0.7745282053947449,
-0.5121747851371765,
-0.5618444681167603,
0.13816696405410767,
-0.5093659162521362,
-0.11735538393259048,
-0.07093267887830734,
-0.1996311992406845,
-0.38395214080810547,
0.401012122631073,
-0.09911560267210007,
0.7896032333374023,
0.01719299703836441,
-0.1915561854839325,
-0.44234904646873474,
0.4228704869747162,
0.18427082896232605,
0.10181863605976105,
-0.14399126172065735,
-0.47324615716934204,
0.05972667038440704,
-0.12885956466197968,
-0.5729893445968628,
-0.8034011125564575,
0.5068826675415039,
0.20642785727977753,
0.29007112979888916,
0.38118410110473633,
0.23940445482730865,
0.8751000761985779,
-0.6373223662376404,
0.4236578345298767,
0.19958019256591797,
-1.1317044496536255,
0.2908882796764374,
0.1336846500635147,
-0.1022026315331459,
0.5917646288871765,
0.8082347512245178,
-0.23944011330604553,
-0.18925614655017853,
-0.7991329431533813,
-0.8314012289047241,
0.30282652378082275,
0.2171381115913391,
-0.10025510936975479,
0.055662501603364944,
0.47826293110847473,
0.32649633288383484,
0.3367891013622284,
-0.41999903321266174,
0.014633649960160255,
-0.5338630080223083,
-0.5213003158569336,
0.01735047996044159,
-0.0666009932756424,
-0.4735947251319885,
0.05446051433682442,
0.5880587697029114,
-0.24416573345661163,
0.2768775522708893,
0.5750471353530884,
-0.25138071179389954,
-0.08631734549999237,
0.41525542736053467,
0.6658895611763,
0.35549020767211914,
-0.03498499095439911,
0.5538251399993896,
0.5473693609237671,
-0.2081821858882904,
0.006409967318177223,
0.4657612144947052,
-0.1750977784395218,
0.19776692986488342,
0.1445174664258957,
0.3938107490539551,
0.34068724513053894,
-0.8927256464958191,
0.9100121855735779,
0.0627567246556282,
-0.391709566116333,
-0.2591678500175476,
-0.2507871091365814,
-0.28226688504219055,
0.45026522874832153,
0.2567955255508423,
0.16314496099948883,
0.36562857031822205,
-0.5150156617164612,
0.2921728491783142,
0.37335366010665894,
-0.33002761006355286,
-0.05352431908249855,
0.6272003650665283,
-0.2616187632083893,
0.1680852174758911,
0.5981940031051636,
-0.3719513714313507,
-0.6141437888145447,
0.31797683238983154,
0.6125959157943726,
0.5345549583435059,
-0.023014122620224953,
0.0911315307021141,
0.191985622048378,
0.08728745579719543,
-0.3717661201953888,
-0.10537686198949814,
-0.24372607469558716,
-0.42671310901641846,
-0.22672447562217712,
-0.2514284551143646,
-0.39568737149238586,
0.16144299507141113,
-0.5341476798057556,
0.12214075773954391,
-0.532042920589447,
0.44990062713623047,
-0.043932005763053894,
0.42006129026412964,
-0.42667168378829956,
-0.08245746791362762,
-0.03884373977780342,
0.8390271663665771,
-0.8258134126663208,
0.5876870155334473,
0.21542298793792725,
-0.7301945090293884,
-0.5171223282814026,
0.19509544968605042,
0.1040610820055008,
-0.588477373123169,
0.5761529207229614,
0.07495465874671936,
-0.3172506093978882,
-0.41423019766807556,
-0.7715331315994263,
-0.2145640105009079,
0.9980102777481079,
0.660671055316925,
-0.49078693985939026,
0.0341191329061985,
-0.036444105207920074,
0.6641523838043213,
-0.27094128727912903,
0.08316174149513245,
0.20394457876682281,
0.26007115840911865,
0.46689721941947937,
-0.3493407368659973,
0.49862411618232727,
-0.1969791054725647,
-0.006124997977167368,
0.12292084842920303,
-0.707360565662384,
1.0269502401351929,
-0.07845792174339294,
-0.25071337819099426,
0.6487316489219666,
0.7733896970748901,
0.15168222784996033,
0.47340190410614014,
0.5376400351524353,
0.7919908761978149,
1.1225110292434692,
-0.258329302072525,
0.8440013527870178,
0.1289353221654892,
0.5222985744476318,
0.9108700752258301,
-0.5467128753662109,
0.8031538724899292,
0.4871746301651001,
0.3921169936656952,
0.7412912249565125,
0.3185332417488098,
-0.30780941247940063,
0.5356799960136414,
0.3031502366065979,
-0.4310838580131531,
-0.29603663086891174,
-0.2604672908782959,
-0.16559937596321106,
-0.11748793721199036,
0.5245638489723206,
-0.10221407562494278,
-0.39006829261779785,
-0.1945609301328659,
-0.00862590130418539,
0.5683228373527527,
-0.1683397740125656,
0.4879358410835266,
-0.03697274625301361,
-0.69692462682724,
1.0118343830108643,
-0.032506439834833145,
0.5482907295227051,
-0.4638661742210388,
-0.4588572084903717,
-0.20985911786556244,
0.4696868360042572,
-0.3557569980621338,
-0.6188921332359314,
0.3936333954334259,
-0.013486171141266823,
-0.02896706759929657,
0.0011148568009957671,
0.5226772427558899,
-0.5714067220687866,
0.16048350930213928,
0.24479611217975616,
0.32865744829177856,
0.08956155925989151,
-0.03772943839430809,
-1.1835185289382935,
0.21096357703208923,
-0.1090250164270401,
0.4360877275466919,
0.28638073801994324,
0.95209801197052,
0.08682270348072052,
0.4194454252719879,
0.5860757827758789,
-0.09106910228729248,
-0.14717693626880646,
-0.020708274096250534,
1.1935381889343262,
-0.37534990906715393,
-0.37126073241233826,
-0.5211427807807922,
-0.3735870122909546,
-0.20996899902820587,
-0.3500203788280487,
0.7406556010246277,
0.850265622138977,
0.9094349145889282,
0.07437220215797424,
0.5257827043533325,
0.05007709562778473,
0.5947824120521545,
-0.537337064743042,
0.24511848390102386,
-0.6561340093612671,
0.4885164201259613,
-0.2866043448448181,
-0.6904657483100891,
-0.383890837430954,
0.7741477489471436,
-0.2981693148612976,
-0.1650727093219757,
0.9101406335830688,
1.2064177989959717,
-0.33997678756713867,
0.10153810679912567,
0.3126852810382843,
0.4243486225605011,
0.003131710458546877,
0.8998406529426575,
0.7985283136367798,
-0.7971628904342651,
1.0743441581726074,
0.22480392456054688,
-0.038748182356357574,
-0.20321719348430634,
-0.5585028529167175,
-0.8251954317092896,
-0.7004424929618835,
-0.24216733872890472,
-0.7398408055305481,
0.39441436529159546,
1.0591919422149658,
0.266442209482193,
-0.9418579936027527,
0.12153325229883194,
-0.43319305777549744,
0.4106995165348053,
-0.23270374536514282,
-0.21003927290439606,
0.3972224295139313,
-0.5305306315422058,
-0.7770890593528748,
0.19502149522304535,
0.1015063226222992,
0.02644401043653488,
-0.07354798913002014,
-0.26495254039764404,
-0.4183180034160614,
0.1933714598417282,
0.11290506273508072,
0.6597464084625244,
-0.5774769186973572,
-0.24840883910655975,
-0.08735781908035278,
-0.4719558358192444,
0.126939058303833,
1.0577658414840698,
-0.7868372201919556,
0.03657899424433708,
0.6705461740493774,
0.9497801065444946,
0.49199751019477844,
0.08835907280445099,
0.10014984011650085,
-0.9640747308731079,
0.22722692787647247,
0.24289555847644806,
0.361941933631897,
0.653932511806488,
-0.3769645094871521,
0.4168865382671356,
0.6943188309669495,
-0.5468416810035706,
-0.6824808716773987,
0.1524241864681244,
-1.2458868026733398,
-0.4352882206439972,
1.0653454065322876,
-0.41491034626960754,
-0.24990752339363098,
-0.46605566143989563,
-0.29182174801826477,
0.303572416305542,
-0.3244989514350891,
0.8652757406234741,
0.490088552236557,
0.21726106107234955,
-0.027095727622509003,
-0.32775723934173584,
0.4869343042373657,
0.7290938496589661,
-0.5232669115066528,
0.0592648871243,
0.522609531879425,
0.3808657228946686,
0.4163183867931366,
0.06753748655319214,
-0.2940360903739929,
0.2373402714729309,
0.12634187936782837,
-0.32264456152915955,
0.0016213272465392947,
-0.11754467338323593,
-0.5155941843986511,
0.519563615322113,
-0.3044435977935791,
0.15232901275157928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10735v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10735v1
|
How Should We Extract Discrete Audio Tokens from Self-Supervised Models?
| 2024-06-15T20:43:07 | 2024-06-15T20:43:07 |
Pooneh Mousavi, Jarod Duret, Salah Zaiem, Luca Della Libera, Artem Ploujnikov, Cem Subakan, Mirco Ravanelli
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Discrete audio tokens have recently gained attention for their potential to
bridge the gap between audio and language processing. Ideal audio tokens must
preserve content, paralinguistic elements, speaker identity, and many other
audio details. Current audio tokenization methods fall into two categories:
Semantic tokens, acquired through quantization of Self-Supervised Learning
(SSL) models, and Neural compression-based tokens (codecs). Although previous
studies have benchmarked codec models to identify optimal configurations, the
ideal setup for quantizing pretrained SSL models remains unclear. This paper
explores the optimal configuration of semantic tokens across discriminative and
generative tasks. We propose a scalable solution to train a universal vocoder
across multiple SSL layers. Furthermore, an attention mechanism is employed to
identify task-specific influential layers, enhancing the adaptability and
performance of semantic tokens in diverse audio applications.
|
[
-0.3536005914211273,
-0.21150237321853638,
0.383555144071579,
0.3041943609714508,
-0.3226802945137024,
-0.11311381310224533,
-0.12773354351520538,
-0.16240540146827698,
0.26029542088508606,
0.5092051029205322,
-0.5355821847915649,
-0.5781828165054321,
-0.4672950506210327,
-0.05330426245927811,
-0.5151360630989075,
1.0449411869049072,
0.5011066794395447,
0.01508769579231739,
-0.318231999874115,
-0.319549024105072,
-0.8025933504104614,
-0.8153399229049683,
-0.6895738244056702,
-0.03910263627767563,
0.31227001547813416,
0.013253134675323963,
0.2798132598400116,
0.7633965611457825,
0.34267914295196533,
0.32737424969673157,
-0.024596242234110832,
-0.01140817441046238,
-0.0249957162886858,
0.04246583953499794,
-0.19080209732055664,
-0.21433566510677338,
-0.46630385518074036,
-0.00897636916488409,
0.3097020387649536,
0.4772097170352936,
-0.32022279500961304,
0.4149925410747528,
-0.06806349754333496,
0.2483762502670288,
-0.6655996441841125,
0.05762195214629173,
-0.8157482147216797,
0.27365222573280334,
-0.18320417404174805,
-0.32149478793144226,
-0.3089001178741455,
0.22767522931098938,
-0.08413922786712646,
-0.7726030945777893,
0.44356441497802734,
-0.0828055888414383,
0.4350530207157135,
0.5942090153694153,
-0.39538460969924927,
-0.1368260532617569,
-0.7781367301940918,
0.6670977473258972,
-0.4622257649898529,
0.5367589592933655,
0.518024742603302,
0.1804838627576828,
0.1850169152021408,
-1.0979799032211304,
-0.2854173481464386,
0.1917046755552292,
0.003828586544841528,
0.22240161895751953,
-0.18014873564243317,
0.20387211441993713,
0.002038518898189068,
0.5014679431915283,
-0.3915156126022339,
0.3018605411052704,
-0.23923946917057037,
-0.46083396673202515,
0.3213074505329132,
0.09269645065069199,
0.44669991731643677,
-0.2176389992237091,
-0.5431638956069946,
-0.15252292156219482,
-0.46737557649612427,
0.12454665452241898,
0.30132830142974854,
0.4639624357223511,
-0.08772163093090057,
0.31529080867767334,
-0.2254820615053177,
0.48447996377944946,
0.43244728446006775,
-0.12543056905269623,
0.24363720417022705,
-0.6561393737792969,
0.0064559089951217175,
0.46199366450309753,
0.811228334903717,
-0.2202824354171753,
0.09941097348928452,
-0.3502465486526489,
-0.38214200735092163,
0.11374303698539734,
0.6732722520828247,
-0.6673517823219299,
-0.3361507058143616,
0.4870237410068512,
-0.33761754631996155,
-0.29097631573677063,
0.13369324803352356,
-0.3344409763813019,
0.20493876934051514,
-0.6050048470497131,
0.7353536486625671,
-0.2196948230266571,
-0.3617689311504364,
0.26103177666664124,
-0.36131879687309265,
-0.010962090454995632,
-0.21656538546085358,
-1.6166201829910278,
0.433849960565567,
0.8090129494667053,
0.7260033488273621,
-0.5028278231620789,
0.046793583780527115,
-0.7425094842910767,
0.4692937433719635,
-0.29949796199798584,
0.4964962899684906,
-0.3942645490169525,
-0.46964138746261597,
0.026901010423898697,
-0.17417685687541962,
0.03323010355234146,
-0.3825978636741638,
0.5531052350997925,
-0.393656849861145,
-0.03959531709551811,
-0.1155848354101181,
-0.6143447160720825,
0.416179895401001,
-0.27787432074546814,
-0.7694665789604187,
0.9288969039916992,
-0.0636657327413559,
-0.8667224645614624,
0.4741925001144409,
-0.8100533485412598,
-0.383505642414093,
0.30209487676620483,
-0.3814685642719269,
-0.2937758266925812,
0.28490880131721497,
0.5536497235298157,
0.5450101494789124,
0.14800532162189484,
0.36854562163352966,
-0.17793157696723938,
-0.3559187948703766,
0.22289341688156128,
-0.6332599520683289,
0.6943681240081787,
0.2191375195980072,
-0.42317989468574524,
0.3048405349254608,
-0.9530848860740662,
-0.0006847117329016328,
-0.21149581670761108,
-0.3137719929218292,
-0.39398640394210815,
-0.07763615250587463,
0.2351565808057785,
0.10399144887924194,
0.12210092693567276,
-0.665624737739563,
-0.26173990964889526,
-0.5233768820762634,
0.8111948370933533,
0.9844221472740173,
-0.02509877271950245,
0.5397843718528748,
0.18550239503383636,
0.4613613784313202,
0.10137884318828583,
0.3157847225666046,
-0.12100866436958313,
0.07689020037651062,
-0.5699993371963501,
-0.6487167477607727,
0.6058871746063232,
0.12476445734500885,
-0.253151535987854,
0.7033392190933228,
-0.43954673409461975,
-0.12702035903930664,
-0.7839163541793823,
0.03861616924405098,
0.3695266544818878,
0.17112356424331665,
0.33695146441459656,
-0.36829623579978943,
-0.43643179535865784,
-0.7079091668128967,
-0.09613480418920517,
-0.04707507789134979,
-0.3595311641693115,
0.22586727142333984,
0.19941775500774384,
-0.0037018877919763327,
1.3055528402328491,
-0.11571803689002991,
-0.5571371912956238,
0.15288560092449188,
0.03998727723956108,
0.09959732741117477,
0.8134753704071045,
0.46867460012435913,
-1.020176887512207,
-0.13568226993083954,
-0.00988227128982544,
-0.5113454461097717,
-0.07028569281101227,
-0.3412710726261139,
-0.24613897502422333,
-0.2548987567424774,
0.7804921865463257,
-0.6278330683708191,
0.34569409489631653,
0.49080947041511536,
-0.19922205805778503,
0.4477071166038513,
-0.20725367963314056,
-0.2256288379430771,
-0.6407266855239868,
-0.06722024828195572,
-0.3243970572948456,
-0.3873057961463928,
-0.5776333212852478,
-0.2043316811323166,
-0.06936260312795639,
-0.09162860363721848,
-0.45258522033691406,
0.5632064938545227,
-0.24532122910022736,
-0.3901700973510742,
-0.12364242970943451,
0.17402923107147217,
0.1664840131998062,
0.6511288285255432,
0.08161270618438721,
0.7577954530715942,
0.5745486617088318,
-0.5395156145095825,
0.21732354164123535,
0.22042834758758545,
-0.16913911700248718,
0.6077665686607361,
-0.8750573992729187,
0.39965692162513733,
0.08649139851331711,
0.10502899438142776,
-0.9432070851325989,
-0.022204408422112465,
-0.01219343114644289,
-0.3910820484161377,
0.27562350034713745,
-0.1526506543159485,
-0.47064757347106934,
-0.16444440186023712,
0.05777565762400627,
0.8757519721984863,
0.3686462640762329,
-0.9012027382850647,
0.908715546131134,
0.6091978549957275,
0.13423673808574677,
-0.30697137117385864,
-0.45403486490249634,
-0.02939326874911785,
-0.4554971158504486,
-0.16916044056415558,
0.6494576334953308,
-0.1587965041399002,
0.22707714140415192,
0.015150846913456917,
-0.5743924379348755,
-0.18556061387062073,
-0.07388217002153397,
0.6493026614189148,
-0.014901229180395603,
-0.1827855408191681,
0.43546223640441895,
-0.030829044058918953,
-0.3484516143798828,
0.15030404925346375,
-0.8640953898429871,
0.46854040026664734,
-0.07253272086381912,
-0.4228399097919464,
-0.5292546153068542,
0.4997246265411377,
0.36916446685791016,
-0.6498435735702515,
0.36193007230758667,
0.875801146030426,
0.04292488470673561,
-0.18821552395820618,
-0.6319358348846436,
-0.0661768764257431,
-0.5588452816009521,
0.3786095380783081,
-0.7893325090408325,
-1.0375547409057617,
0.40646982192993164,
-0.06417033821344376,
-0.0879296287894249,
0.4154488742351532,
0.6507330536842346,
-0.008697368204593658,
1.0733906030654907,
0.543824315071106,
-0.13414953649044037,
0.6349417567253113,
-0.2834266722202301,
-0.11461920291185379,
-0.8323943614959717,
-0.13326860964298248,
-0.3503812253475189,
0.21158190071582794,
-0.4082379639148712,
-0.19751042127609253,
0.28864240646362305,
0.03849126026034355,
-0.20132961869239807,
0.4158633351325989,
-0.7597881555557251,
0.6566737294197083,
0.8963003158569336,
0.024573076516389847,
-0.10814806818962097,
0.1317959874868393,
-0.2887628674507141,
0.32753831148147583,
-0.7998858094215393,
-0.1078089103102684,
0.9847179055213928,
0.426350474357605,
0.27175742387771606,
-0.025485510006546974,
0.8242632746696472,
0.3254605233669281,
-0.4215456545352936,
-0.528755247592926,
0.16084295511245728,
-0.394850492477417,
-0.7533133625984192,
-0.6705465912818909,
-0.19588662683963776,
-1.0506165027618408,
0.4326215386390686,
0.014093407429754734,
-0.6151236891746521,
0.2730368673801422,
0.07841784507036209,
-0.5479129552841187,
0.006170838139951229,
-0.35696133971214294,
1.0759952068328857,
-0.20686008036136627,
0.10134304314851761,
-0.2964717745780945,
-0.628418505191803,
-0.13883458077907562,
-0.2542629837989807,
0.34384527802467346,
-0.12188757956027985,
0.043762799352407455,
0.6463861465454102,
-0.24108223617076874,
0.9777587056159973,
-0.2066556066274643,
0.08109144121408463,
0.22518733143806458,
-0.04885120689868927,
0.10370460152626038,
0.06908324360847473,
0.2600100338459015,
0.4308195412158966,
0.4507562816143036,
-0.48316967487335205,
-0.5292972326278687,
0.4235192537307739,
-0.8916546106338501,
-0.4863666892051697,
0.18543629348278046,
-0.26843324303627014,
-0.18481403589248657,
0.16314445436000824,
0.2486233115196228,
0.9500772356987,
-0.14369340240955353,
0.28372734785079956,
0.5873056650161743,
-0.03918104246258736,
0.657323956489563,
0.20779924094676971,
0.15031784772872925,
-0.5899084210395813,
1.1340575218200684,
-0.1397145837545395,
0.2564082741737366,
0.31430381536483765,
0.29459553956985474,
-0.2928255796432495,
-0.5948228240013123,
-0.28966403007507324,
-0.07597624510526657,
-0.8029824495315552,
-0.2240188717842102,
-0.6478928923606873,
-0.24711309373378754,
-0.6048566699028015,
0.11960245668888092,
-0.6328572034835815,
-0.35800108313560486,
-0.7121129035949707,
-0.40742409229278564,
0.14115428924560547,
0.30524569749832153,
-0.3775022625923157,
0.4910096526145935,
-0.7035448551177979,
0.6481733918190002,
0.7388467788696289,
0.33608248829841614,
-0.13397693634033203,
-0.5079261064529419,
-0.3893575668334961,
-0.19668473303318024,
0.2871125340461731,
-0.41906481981277466,
0.13783469796180725,
0.5449840426445007,
0.6380808353424072,
0.5552690029144287,
0.20649076998233795,
0.7840217351913452,
-0.6578409075737,
0.7355320453643799,
0.33018720149993896,
-1.0689375400543213,
0.4980069696903229,
-0.304802268743515,
0.35109180212020874,
0.5494228005409241,
0.14604127407073975,
-0.38990798592567444,
-0.3517868220806122,
-0.5891692042350769,
-0.9218199253082275,
0.49227672815322876,
0.40954479575157166,
0.5354509949684143,
-0.37711796164512634,
0.41377580165863037,
0.1108616441488266,
0.0724743977189064,
-0.7913764119148254,
-0.07893890887498856,
-0.6612663269042969,
-0.4665939211845398,
0.1703045666217804,
-0.27038025856018066,
-0.22016659379005432,
-0.22454164922237396,
0.19491368532180786,
-0.2690501809120178,
0.14929699897766113,
0.2423955798149109,
0.03337238356471062,
0.19629473984241486,
-0.16262371838092804,
0.0952487513422966,
0.3935331404209137,
0.08976253122091293,
0.23267434537410736,
0.08074674755334854,
-0.3316110074520111,
0.28590279817581177,
-0.4736502468585968,
0.19307853281497955,
0.05931096896529198,
0.4918600618839264,
1.1290451288223267,
0.5202879309654236,
-0.4633358418941498,
0.8048582077026367,
-0.23586821556091309,
-0.12671108543872833,
-0.7202640175819397,
0.15904514491558075,
-0.02724924311041832,
0.18974217772483826,
0.14281105995178223,
-0.13336819410324097,
0.29408150911331177,
-0.1726769506931305,
0.5296526551246643,
0.45810630917549133,
-0.5640049576759338,
-0.3462388813495636,
0.9083779454231262,
0.29942017793655396,
-0.42644259333610535,
0.5846222639083862,
0.013009456917643547,
-0.22778832912445068,
0.3688544034957886,
0.5940394401550293,
1.0941375494003296,
-0.09414042532444,
0.1399853378534317,
0.17395402491092682,
-0.29502326250076294,
0.10858330130577087,
-0.2765984833240509,
-0.8050883412361145,
-0.5929887294769287,
-0.5134819746017456,
-0.9673954248428345,
0.16581745445728302,
-0.34433427453041077,
-0.8449499011039734,
0.0924006849527359,
-0.35719025135040283,
-0.4622185528278351,
0.29395318031311035,
-0.4556807279586792,
-0.8659789562225342,
0.35308897495269775,
0.21114946901798248,
0.43933480978012085,
-0.8214333653450012,
1.0983920097351074,
0.09645462781190872,
-0.32886314392089844,
-0.9335955381393433,
-0.37499988079071045,
-0.25041764974594116,
-0.6578084826469421,
0.893551230430603,
0.010815927758812904,
-0.18931728601455688,
0.3029852509498596,
-0.36339378356933594,
-1.02195405960083,
0.7341155409812927,
0.22856393456459045,
-0.5416992902755737,
-0.06493458151817322,
0.2961651384830475,
0.4577111303806305,
-0.3965480327606201,
0.030985703691840172,
0.506479799747467,
0.09288898855447769,
0.20204852521419525,
-0.7385650873184204,
-0.21748630702495575,
-0.17427214980125427,
0.17883114516735077,
-0.00957425870001316,
-0.37620434165000916,
0.6699347496032715,
0.32274627685546875,
-0.2603250741958618,
-0.11295998096466064,
0.7196083068847656,
0.09831807017326355,
-0.11197519302368164,
0.9169104099273682,
0.5075669288635254,
0.4592934548854828,
0.17484967410564423,
0.8763527870178223,
-0.4362015128135681,
0.12179295718669891,
1.1565032005310059,
0.31104859709739685,
0.7515838146209717,
0.612467885017395,
-0.2253202497959137,
0.33523029088974,
0.6966738104820251,
-0.14593471586704254,
0.8680328130722046,
0.3476122319698334,
-0.2953314185142517,
-0.6001819968223572,
-0.18151850998401642,
-0.029893046244978905,
0.8618670701980591,
0.046809520572423935,
0.026808852329850197,
0.35721051692962646,
0.245627760887146,
-0.45879533886909485,
-0.2624271512031555,
-0.2087310254573822,
1.208601951599121,
0.15259762108325958,
-0.38151440024375916,
0.27922648191452026,
-0.16659671068191528,
0.44531047344207764,
-0.5215586423873901,
0.0454181432723999,
-0.21564258635044098,
-0.19071587920188904,
-0.19990193843841553,
-0.09823230654001236,
0.15729400515556335,
-0.16617067158222198,
-0.2632947862148285,
-0.23006786406040192,
0.5016366839408875,
-0.4056459963321686,
-0.4478001594543457,
0.2880580425262451,
0.1066170334815979,
0.16165156662464142,
-0.3150079548358917,
-0.41026461124420166,
0.017228201031684875,
-0.27159401774406433,
-0.07446970045566559,
0.494811475276947,
0.7529409527778625,
0.12712860107421875,
0.3336351811885834,
0.9025138020515442,
0.34667080640792847,
0.3791874945163727,
0.4859628677368164,
0.6197841763496399,
-0.608464777469635,
-0.8760830760002136,
-0.7919360399246216,
0.47599586844444275,
0.02147555537521839,
-0.2381465882062912,
0.5557290315628052,
0.3048763871192932,
0.7703679800033569,
0.010001320391893387,
0.36948922276496887,
0.4061106741428375,
0.08554884046316147,
-0.6512712836265564,
0.45875391364097595,
-0.5249364972114563,
0.20421545207500458,
-0.3020252585411072,
-0.694026529788971,
-0.12454910576343536,
0.4787178635597229,
0.3218543231487274,
-0.17668657004833221,
0.3888436257839203,
0.4524375796318054,
-0.009123255498707294,
-0.07386291027069092,
0.45538729429244995,
-0.21946024894714355,
0.39447224140167236,
0.2511991560459137,
0.6717672348022461,
-0.25919511914253235,
0.5683838129043579,
-0.2190445214509964,
0.1717717945575714,
0.09109780937433243,
-0.7086647748947144,
-0.8866481184959412,
-0.6892397999763489,
-0.5251955986022949,
0.18033269047737122,
-0.03021096996963024,
0.7167403697967529,
1.2044305801391602,
-0.8693798184394836,
-0.09342741966247559,
-0.2278442531824112,
-0.09236191213130951,
-0.22052881121635437,
-0.18560649454593658,
0.7372865676879883,
-0.6521684527397156,
-0.5832241177558899,
0.43088963627815247,
0.4717904329299927,
0.1072273924946785,
-0.36572855710983276,
0.0320400707423687,
0.46237197518348694,
0.05805303156375885,
0.5183748006820679,
0.04756439849734306,
-1.0382179021835327,
-0.6712337732315063,
-0.2766575217247009,
-0.10744110494852066,
0.15511316061019897,
0.9337356686592102,
-0.7758004069328308,
0.6170942187309265,
0.06035565584897995,
0.6794283390045166,
0.769555389881134,
0.10820221900939941,
0.45754650235176086,
-1.2029060125350952,
0.32227781414985657,
0.19351071119308472,
0.10137727856636047,
0.11046583205461502,
-0.18578283488750458,
0.4623573124408722,
-0.003168037859722972,
-0.504377543926239,
-0.8126993179321289,
-0.10345393419265747,
-1.0175937414169312,
-0.42589738965034485,
0.9895040392875671,
-0.2561931014060974,
-0.161733940243721,
-0.13251835107803345,
-0.045966025441884995,
0.29223376512527466,
-0.08750975877046585,
0.5915307998657227,
0.47457650303840637,
0.017243104055523872,
0.0408770851790905,
-0.5195809602737427,
0.6083980798721313,
0.4444490373134613,
-0.3432124853134155,
0.062432922422885895,
0.2212858349084854,
0.22306910157203674,
0.12039865553379059,
0.8816506266593933,
-0.21644654870033264,
0.13190749287605286,
0.2507905960083008,
0.08620338141918182,
-0.007745333015918732,
-0.5137630105018616,
-0.47544044256210327,
0.2977313697338104,
-0.1372634470462799,
-0.6712614893913269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10710v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10710v1
|
SyntheT2C: Generating Synthetic Data for Fine-Tuning Large Language Models on the Text2Cypher Task
| 2024-06-15T18:43:49 | 2024-06-15T18:43:49 |
Ziije Zhong, Linqing Zhong, Zhaoze Sun, Qingyun Jin, Zengchang Qin, Xiaofan Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Integrating Large Language Models (LLMs) with existing Knowledge Graph (KG)
databases presents a promising avenue for enhancing LLMs' efficacy and
mitigating their "hallucinations". Given that most KGs reside in graph
databases accessible solely through specialized query languages (e.g., Cypher),
there exists a critical need to bridge the divide between LLMs and KG databases
by automating the translation of natural language into Cypher queries (commonly
termed the "Text2Cypher" task). Prior efforts tried to bolster LLMs'
proficiency in Cypher generation through Supervised Fine-Tuning. However, these
explorations are hindered by the lack of annotated datasets of Query-Cypher
pairs, resulting from the labor-intensive and domain-specific nature of
annotating such datasets. In this study, we propose SyntheT2C, a methodology
for constructing a synthetic Query-Cypher pair dataset, comprising two distinct
pipelines: (1) LLM-based prompting and (2) template-filling. SyntheT2C
facilitates the generation of extensive Query-Cypher pairs with values sampled
from an underlying Neo4j graph database. Subsequently, SyntheT2C is applied to
two medical databases, culminating in the creation of a synthetic dataset,
MedT2C. Comprehensive experiments demonstrate that the MedT2C dataset
effectively enhances the performance of backbone LLMs on the Text2Cypher task.
Both the SyntheT2C codebase and the MedT2C dataset will be released soon.
|
[
-0.37760037183761597,
-0.760906994342804,
0.7977135181427002,
-0.02530321478843689,
-0.14263424277305603,
0.20104004442691803,
-0.430805504322052,
-0.5430318713188171,
0.349400132894516,
0.9601582288742065,
-0.740477979183197,
-0.8622651100158691,
-0.22132425010204315,
0.24412409961223602,
-0.3058801591396332,
0.9348016977310181,
-0.08786623179912567,
0.006684247869998217,
-0.40614455938339233,
0.038207776844501495,
-0.44372451305389404,
-0.44520658254623413,
-0.5716561675071716,
-0.42889174818992615,
0.5312564373016357,
0.3710292875766754,
0.7282397150993347,
0.6349133849143982,
0.17114828526973724,
0.18593889474868774,
0.19541387259960175,
0.8722711801528931,
-0.5244302749633789,
0.5175386667251587,
-0.34671837091445923,
-0.5224410891532898,
-0.31406041979789734,
-0.07870358973741531,
0.4581681489944458,
0.8338549137115479,
0.14606928825378418,
-0.09121350198984146,
0.07408905029296875,
0.7248952984809875,
-0.3213348686695099,
0.4417945146560669,
-0.8969521522521973,
-0.09612175822257996,
-0.19948972761631012,
-0.19100013375282288,
-0.3428817689418793,
-0.20517979562282562,
-0.13076229393482208,
-0.7593055367469788,
0.14996172487735748,
0.20791226625442505,
0.30442216992378235,
0.07885263115167618,
-0.520343005657196,
-0.3771882951259613,
-0.595684826374054,
0.41996172070503235,
-0.406051903963089,
0.3505512773990631,
0.5275971293449402,
0.28601399064064026,
-0.492687851190567,
-1.0090938806533813,
-0.570946216583252,
0.03381947800517082,
-0.19323182106018066,
0.1388350874185562,
0.17812424898147583,
0.17978592216968536,
0.19955307245254517,
0.1450374722480774,
-0.7165269255638123,
0.1200941875576973,
-0.48575058579444885,
-0.362100750207901,
0.5559932589530945,
0.449609637260437,
0.3149585425853729,
-0.34695422649383545,
-0.007635632064193487,
0.027633534744381905,
-0.9443485140800476,
-0.5235462188720703,
0.26271581649780273,
0.5850463509559631,
0.13568347692489624,
0.9217543601989746,
-0.36798352003097534,
0.7318589687347412,
-0.3115711212158203,
0.2813989520072937,
0.141983300447464,
-0.7652862668037415,
-0.015221692621707916,
0.2722899317741394,
0.8899568319320679,
0.6325603127479553,
0.4776493012905121,
-0.470289409160614,
-0.1984603852033615,
0.316319078207016,
0.2818891108036041,
-0.902923047542572,
-0.5573194026947021,
0.35685309767723083,
-0.025591246783733368,
-0.46788185834884644,
-0.19222590327262878,
-0.8015011548995972,
-0.5238959789276123,
-0.8202133178710938,
0.3255007565021515,
-0.31938865780830383,
-0.1656099408864975,
-0.17380858957767487,
-0.041135936975479126,
-0.08534660190343857,
0.03631956875324249,
-0.9933361411094666,
0.6090539693832397,
0.8679274916648865,
0.8732459545135498,
-0.256139874458313,
0.08393904566764832,
-0.3676006495952606,
0.25876596570014954,
-0.6437565088272095,
0.802893340587616,
-0.4604898989200592,
-0.431519478559494,
0.2195306122303009,
0.282888799905777,
0.03584698960185051,
-0.689523458480835,
0.24985277652740479,
-0.48831936717033386,
0.3518979847431183,
-0.45906031131744385,
-0.5378730893135071,
0.30760544538497925,
0.3328627347946167,
-0.5323452353477478,
1.267127513885498,
0.5084487795829773,
-0.7112817168235779,
-0.03322868421673775,
-0.2934628129005432,
-0.6514610052108765,
-0.006942803040146828,
-0.33601877093315125,
-0.1687154918909073,
-0.1372949331998825,
0.35884198546409607,
0.16173432767391205,
-0.671957790851593,
0.04699110612273216,
-0.11413046717643738,
-0.29905036091804504,
0.23243485391139984,
0.1498187929391861,
0.6235010027885437,
0.1281336396932602,
-0.09433556348085403,
-0.09011327475309372,
-0.6942532658576965,
0.4648074209690094,
0.029489167034626007,
-0.09830919653177261,
-0.41985803842544556,
-0.11949148774147034,
0.1046384871006012,
0.2718314826488495,
0.1770261824131012,
-0.24367877840995789,
0.40654709935188293,
-1.0455455780029297,
0.7344398498535156,
0.4464419186115265,
0.17888586223125458,
0.39208921790122986,
-0.24430784583091736,
0.37490320205688477,
-0.3295306861400604,
-0.22573460638523102,
-0.06079678609967232,
-0.48756274580955505,
-0.5028185844421387,
-0.09218316525220871,
0.3361953794956207,
0.5537484884262085,
-0.9549452066421509,
0.37978726625442505,
-0.24910344183444977,
-0.361761212348938,
-0.46308764815330505,
0.23558148741722107,
0.3856474757194519,
0.5177087783813477,
0.5309770107269287,
-0.0498267337679863,
-0.9205047488212585,
-0.9221028089523315,
-0.3783416748046875,
-0.08193127810955048,
-0.25472041964530945,
0.4990405738353729,
0.3487541377544403,
-0.4002059996128082,
0.8984095454216003,
-0.5048663020133972,
-0.37515684962272644,
-0.253657728433609,
-0.09673161059617996,
0.09991559386253357,
0.4269818067550659,
0.42210453748703003,
-0.35139158368110657,
-0.45160964131355286,
0.07539702951908112,
-0.7102758884429932,
-0.42395907640457153,
0.08749131113290787,
-0.4799651801586151,
0.23117119073867798,
0.6398792862892151,
-0.7551472783088684,
-0.01847294345498085,
0.524537205696106,
-0.21092024445533752,
0.483534038066864,
-0.22622613608837128,
0.09578230232000351,
-1.5272784233093262,
0.04631831869482994,
-0.40850013494491577,
-0.3400906026363373,
-0.5676178336143494,
-0.2536914646625519,
0.015607601962983608,
-0.1117391362786293,
-0.14638668298721313,
0.6732650399208069,
-0.35557907819747925,
-0.16701899468898773,
-0.17163003981113434,
0.38971683382987976,
0.18205130100250244,
0.13739071786403656,
-0.1245165541768074,
0.6829447150230408,
0.2857843041419983,
-0.4074636995792389,
0.5121205449104309,
0.33042973279953003,
-0.2560388445854187,
0.4659358263015747,
-0.6301277279853821,
0.40035855770111084,
0.025466686114668846,
0.2516292631626129,
-0.9436309933662415,
-0.716017484664917,
0.4639608561992645,
-0.4063884913921356,
0.3602943420410156,
-0.40311843156814575,
-0.9160708785057068,
-0.306425005197525,
-0.18745888769626617,
0.36714041233062744,
0.5749008655548096,
-0.5675987601280212,
0.380433589220047,
0.41577377915382385,
-0.12047417461872101,
-0.12912358343601227,
-0.9356623888015747,
0.3833562731742859,
0.09581346064805984,
-0.6556255221366882,
0.7246633768081665,
0.2580235004425049,
-0.09952306002378464,
0.06469490379095078,
0.005340759176760912,
0.10358145833015442,
-0.3213651776313782,
0.3481607735157013,
0.340331107378006,
-0.006401544436812401,
0.30578160285949707,
0.4762067496776581,
-0.186103954911232,
0.34933534264564514,
-0.8887861371040344,
0.6445093750953674,
0.370767742395401,
-0.1526861935853958,
-0.40046417713165283,
0.14156028628349304,
0.5137159824371338,
-0.16327543556690216,
0.7910913228988647,
0.3073321580886841,
-0.5450537204742432,
-0.4331834018230438,
-0.4023180305957794,
-0.6494920253753662,
-0.45348748564720154,
0.4609355032444,
-0.2360781729221344,
-0.7477172017097473,
0.37184399366378784,
-0.32996413111686707,
-0.13486509025096893,
0.43229448795318604,
0.8725993037223816,
-0.06152405962347984,
1.058823823928833,
-0.1276014745235443,
0.1851077526807785,
0.1434563547372818,
-0.3692447245121002,
0.08427304029464722,
-0.9895583987236023,
-0.5203922390937805,
-0.43548718094825745,
-0.2889932692050934,
-0.8297142386436462,
-0.7353695631027222,
0.5431321263313293,
-0.19627295434474945,
-0.17372116446495056,
0.3747965395450592,
-0.6066539883613586,
0.6097837090492249,
0.24738140404224396,
0.15574787557125092,
0.22202236950397491,
0.43132656812667847,
-0.5014947652816772,
-0.17196592688560486,
-0.5908493399620056,
-0.2657385766506195,
1.5568233728408813,
-0.15859679877758026,
0.428022176027298,
-0.06990823894739151,
0.5557422041893005,
0.09046284109354019,
0.024800129234790802,
-0.7000804543495178,
0.4521998167037964,
-0.11053654551506042,
-0.6492888927459717,
-0.00915219634771347,
-0.5694754123687744,
-0.9994174838066101,
0.018133873119950294,
-0.3635295033454895,
-0.7084913849830627,
-0.18636929988861084,
0.2729915380477905,
-0.0081393513828516,
0.006699405610561371,
-0.42112040519714355,
0.8295648097991943,
-0.08039700984954834,
-0.7075331211090088,
-0.1773824691772461,
-0.6423695683479309,
0.3461732268333435,
-0.10784217715263367,
0.18099604547023773,
-0.050227224826812744,
0.06477608531713486,
0.5506401062011719,
-0.5651779174804688,
0.6507567763328552,
-0.04253441095352173,
0.015888802707195282,
0.5373213887214661,
0.29297778010368347,
0.9478928446769714,
0.3468385636806488,
-0.1355670988559723,
-0.055068239569664,
0.12739165127277374,
-0.17304612696170807,
-0.7055078744888306,
1.068701982498169,
-0.559179961681366,
-0.2193051278591156,
-0.1675270050764084,
-0.5495781898498535,
-0.5927701592445374,
0.24572645127773285,
0.2548195719718933,
0.5272840261459351,
-0.012379184365272522,
0.11482714861631393,
0.4884980320930481,
-0.13458478450775146,
-0.3223072290420532,
0.2797047793865204,
-0.37770381569862366,
-0.7427514791488647,
0.8424335718154907,
0.18522226810455322,
0.26753318309783936,
0.23638589680194855,
-0.054101742804050446,
-0.5342125296592712,
-0.4246516525745392,
-0.4075566232204437,
0.381624698638916,
-0.460024356842041,
-0.3036665916442871,
-0.6625281572341919,
-0.2935217320919037,
-0.5108485817909241,
0.01785634271800518,
-0.513711154460907,
-0.6177458167076111,
-0.1924022138118744,
-0.07376041263341904,
0.5647408962249756,
0.5426227450370789,
0.10467329621315002,
0.05667175352573395,
-0.49569737911224365,
0.36923298239707947,
0.142020121216774,
0.19482913613319397,
-0.43738073110580444,
-0.28634336590766907,
-0.17614880204200745,
0.18640917539596558,
0.01471125427633524,
-0.8160544037818909,
0.43313872814178467,
0.0647013783454895,
0.09533185511827469,
-0.0632321685552597,
0.11053351312875748,
0.442632794380188,
-0.3607797622680664,
0.6579180955886841,
0.07220592349767685,
-0.5829609036445618,
0.677162230014801,
-0.4938510060310364,
-0.020031064748764038,
0.5559017658233643,
0.0387997031211853,
-0.5919901132583618,
-0.32308804988861084,
-0.24317803978919983,
-0.9186248183250427,
0.784419596195221,
0.6320062875747681,
0.12241913378238678,
-0.10115373134613037,
0.839081883430481,
-0.13260063529014587,
0.2416398674249649,
-0.15964585542678833,
-0.09935150295495987,
-0.126507967710495,
-0.7059313058853149,
0.22568665444850922,
-0.19434265792369843,
-0.3285839557647705,
-0.21672552824020386,
0.5482931733131409,
-0.3377208113670349,
0.14861468970775604,
0.18601159751415253,
0.07548344135284424,
-0.04486775025725365,
-0.048481203615665436,
0.18968141078948975,
0.26806217432022095,
0.007483622524887323,
0.4041363000869751,
0.28209057450294495,
-0.32023584842681885,
-0.10766328871250153,
0.20761726796627045,
-0.20159927010536194,
-0.15983982384204865,
0.34002888202667236,
0.5495536923408508,
0.07010921835899353,
-0.811424195766449,
0.08156749606132507,
0.1585272252559662,
-0.3958568871021271,
-0.24072425067424774,
0.1878231018781662,
0.4164213538169861,
0.16970089077949524,
-0.12461984902620316,
-0.09564033895730972,
0.13755588233470917,
-0.49755194783210754,
0.11154250055551529,
0.40284937620162964,
-0.34626105427742004,
-0.4134775996208191,
0.7622034549713135,
0.08889886736869812,
-0.07314864546060562,
0.9863279461860657,
-0.1736874282360077,
-0.42774465680122375,
0.5890830755233765,
0.6593684554100037,
0.4119756817817688,
-0.02275499701499939,
-0.004061229061335325,
0.6567754745483398,
0.3208583891391754,
-0.19367876648902893,
0.3180934190750122,
0.09865422546863556,
-0.6096604466438293,
-0.31035998463630676,
-0.4723942279815674,
-0.09163899719715118,
0.08352222293615341,
-0.2931365966796875,
0.4150765836238861,
-0.4102122187614441,
-0.2603371739387512,
-0.03353966027498245,
0.22886347770690918,
-0.5728693008422852,
0.14643356204032898,
-0.03870121389627457,
0.5739184617996216,
-0.6609416604042053,
0.9117692708969116,
0.5888525247573853,
-0.18335400521755219,
-0.7690961956977844,
-0.29319098591804504,
0.12704221904277802,
-0.7805073857307434,
0.4303300678730011,
0.03183133527636528,
0.07136128842830658,
0.18594485521316528,
-0.3023194372653961,
-0.6721320152282715,
1.1327837705612183,
0.5460110306739807,
-0.74210524559021,
-0.06538744270801544,
0.7062947750091553,
0.7561410665512085,
-0.4781745970249176,
-0.00805641058832407,
0.8245505690574646,
0.6390050053596497,
0.0994320809841156,
-0.6175068616867065,
0.20892688632011414,
-0.18774256110191345,
0.07633768022060394,
0.2910526990890503,
-0.4266379177570343,
0.46190568804740906,
-0.25639694929122925,
-0.0722508355975151,
0.15417571365833282,
0.2510269582271576,
0.2640637457370758,
0.4270952045917511,
0.2595827281475067,
0.5145063996315002,
0.817327618598938,
-0.3411754369735718,
0.9588723182678223,
-0.5685963034629822,
0.23975513875484467,
1.2118442058563232,
-0.33412596583366394,
0.5435304641723633,
0.4579181373119354,
-0.2970852553844452,
0.38217002153396606,
0.5337356328964233,
-0.12821173667907715,
0.4583192765712738,
0.366371214389801,
-0.27050819993019104,
-0.3149184584617615,
-0.20559391379356384,
-0.344427227973938,
0.22107255458831787,
0.7658371925354004,
-0.6115489602088928,
0.1254504770040512,
-0.3602633476257324,
0.14813226461410522,
0.09259092807769775,
0.08810829371213913,
0.7770549654960632,
0.19136938452720642,
-0.8674445748329163,
0.529811680316925,
0.10661585628986359,
-0.10477659106254578,
-0.42794370651245117,
0.027613595128059387,
-0.30412107706069946,
0.09124599397182465,
-0.3600523769855499,
-0.7364870309829712,
0.38132819533348083,
-0.10872586071491241,
-0.15895895659923553,
0.11179699748754501,
0.7790266275405884,
-0.7877723574638367,
-0.5854811668395996,
0.2508337199687958,
0.36911699175834656,
0.061231087893247604,
-0.20813977718353271,
-0.48487499356269836,
0.15042394399642944,
-0.12275916337966919,
-0.1027648076415062,
0.3375023603439331,
0.5747255086898804,
-0.1067965179681778,
0.32525360584259033,
0.8544947504997253,
0.24076484143733978,
-0.2720325291156769,
0.215504452586174,
1.0786967277526855,
-0.4391046464443207,
-0.16305424273014069,
-0.7403993606567383,
0.15211190283298492,
-0.17387352883815765,
0.03541354835033417,
0.4649673402309418,
0.8717702031135559,
0.5291736125946045,
0.025675635784864426,
0.9009094834327698,
0.042839791625738144,
0.4729139506816864,
-0.7885898947715759,
0.6842613220214844,
-0.5521507859230042,
0.42017871141433716,
0.07556337118148804,
-1.0238831043243408,
-0.32054001092910767,
0.40162423253059387,
-0.02662709727883339,
0.13334926962852478,
0.7287969589233398,
1.3330994844436646,
0.0038254212122410536,
-0.08763423562049866,
-0.05517018213868141,
0.44003504514694214,
0.40937522053718567,
0.610960841178894,
0.5588243007659912,
-0.5140007138252258,
0.5284577012062073,
-0.1964498609304428,
0.12289483845233917,
-0.2159491628408432,
-0.5249975323677063,
-1.1460036039352417,
-0.4963335394859314,
-0.2650359869003296,
-0.8472965955734253,
0.38674336671829224,
1.1752026081085205,
0.6160576343536377,
-0.8575312495231628,
0.11267025768756866,
-0.6161453723907471,
-0.026584839448332787,
0.11544634401798248,
-0.20775212347507477,
0.5153729319572449,
-0.45375925302505493,
-0.7808757424354553,
0.5518180727958679,
0.26275673508644104,
0.08307204395532608,
-0.2570406198501587,
-0.08237245678901672,
0.402189701795578,
0.02450850047171116,
0.5439791679382324,
-0.014274826273322105,
-0.5695821642875671,
-0.08546177297830582,
0.07631692290306091,
-0.20875412225723267,
-0.15079842507839203,
0.9476084113121033,
-1.0158034563064575,
0.751738429069519,
0.6034834384918213,
0.4281757175922394,
0.5611079931259155,
-0.05551239475607872,
0.6463425755500793,
-0.9147302508354187,
0.11434395611286163,
0.2070048600435257,
0.046583279967308044,
0.3779401481151581,
-0.20242251455783844,
0.5558155179023743,
0.47646602988243103,
-0.42802485823631287,
-0.8515392541885376,
0.18718133866786957,
-1.0160969495773315,
-0.3051997721195221,
1.3803563117980957,
0.411241352558136,
-0.1099395826458931,
-0.16181007027626038,
-0.4441913366317749,
0.38537153601646423,
-0.11929686367511749,
0.7531489133834839,
0.36233022809028625,
0.024139998480677605,
0.24666059017181396,
-0.6260154843330383,
0.7441573143005371,
0.20104002952575684,
-0.9530768990516663,
0.3526364862918854,
0.5474350452423096,
0.3337968587875366,
-0.2403726428747177,
0.43879762291908264,
-0.34873804450035095,
-0.0412851944565773,
0.023024490103125572,
-0.2546031177043915,
-0.2610381841659546,
-0.29021355509757996,
0.38392603397369385,
0.06796129047870636,
-0.11946053802967072,
0.21299463510513306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10701v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10701v1
|
MIND: Multimodal Shopping Intention Distillation from Large Vision-language Models for E-commerce Purchase Understanding
| 2024-06-15T17:56:09 | 2024-06-15T17:56:09 |
Baixuan Xu, Weiqi Wang, Haochen Shi, Wenxuan Ding, Huihao Jing, Tianqing Fang, Jiaxin Bai, Long Chen, Yangqiu Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Improving user experience and providing personalized search results in
E-commerce platforms heavily rely on understanding purchase intention. However,
existing methods for acquiring large-scale intentions bank on distilling large
language models with human annotation for verification. Such an approach tends
to generate product-centric intentions, overlook valuable visual information
from product images, and incurs high costs for scalability. To address these
issues, we introduce MIND, a multimodal framework that allows Large
Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) to infer purchase intentions from multimodal
product metadata and prioritize human-centric ones. Using Amazon Review data,
we apply MIND and create a multimodal intention knowledge base, which contains
1,264,441 million intentions derived from 126,142 co-buy shopping records
across 107,215 products. Extensive human evaluations demonstrate the high
plausibility and typicality of our obtained intentions and validate the
effectiveness of our distillation framework and filtering mechanism. Additional
experiments reveal that our obtained intentions significantly enhance large
language models in two intention comprehension tasks.
|
[
-0.5863272547721863,
-0.5870735049247742,
0.8780150413513184,
0.2848888039588928,
-0.461651474237442,
-0.30885830521583557,
-0.35657578706741333,
-0.7938304543495178,
0.39463773369789124,
0.5020267367362976,
-0.8000828623771667,
-0.39376941323280334,
-0.28111550211906433,
-0.10502519458532333,
-0.2456071525812149,
1.056470513343811,
0.25544100999832153,
-0.07106244564056396,
-0.24144957959651947,
-0.12233669310808182,
-0.17245684564113617,
-0.383572518825531,
-0.7215534448623657,
-0.3914811611175537,
0.840745210647583,
0.2838170528411865,
0.6496907472610474,
-0.09525604546070099,
0.4669681191444397,
0.31018364429473877,
0.25199922919273376,
0.5396267771720886,
-0.30636274814605713,
0.12332694232463837,
-0.2672203779220581,
-0.5284097790718079,
-0.7054994702339172,
0.11477843672037125,
-0.04268636927008629,
0.1521252542734146,
-0.27270519733428955,
0.4836227595806122,
-0.007899065501987934,
0.8355886340141296,
-0.8141875267028809,
0.1893218606710434,
-0.44380983710289,
0.07735878229141235,
0.2820819020271301,
-0.04959163814783096,
-0.737955629825592,
0.09318192303180695,
0.26101091504096985,
-0.8285055160522461,
0.11765822023153305,
0.3404200077056885,
0.7156038880348206,
0.27647414803504944,
-0.3270309269428253,
-0.3398002088069916,
-0.7080543637275696,
1.0051294565200806,
-0.3988752067089081,
0.8017041683197021,
0.6993040442466736,
0.3138519525527954,
-0.11510055512189865,
-0.7915428280830383,
-0.9101061224937439,
0.03948717564344406,
-0.20281372964382172,
0.3150464594364166,
-0.5070558786392212,
0.08014551550149918,
0.41168105602264404,
0.29527610540390015,
-0.6210388541221619,
-0.5959787964820862,
-0.2630942761898041,
0.014484966173768044,
0.8303028345108032,
-0.04690254107117653,
0.19563044607639313,
-0.08196815103292465,
-0.4908624589443207,
-0.0868171900510788,
-0.39894604682922363,
0.1406395137310028,
0.2796832323074341,
-0.15368057787418365,
0.056142378598451614,
0.5587762594223022,
-0.5262508988380432,
0.8696508407592773,
0.39358389377593994,
-0.2730756402015686,
0.33920058608055115,
-0.5899029970169067,
-0.5511041283607483,
-0.01905752532184124,
0.7091434001922607,
0.7173067927360535,
0.3357001543045044,
-0.041899483650922775,
-0.1892435997724533,
-0.01081001665443182,
0.6040245890617371,
-0.6911066770553589,
-0.23796379566192627,
0.6963838338851929,
-0.753235936164856,
0.10182539373636246,
-0.14600308239459991,
-0.8179281949996948,
-0.44750237464904785,
-0.6542249321937561,
0.4724120795726776,
-0.27046462893486023,
-0.20760981738567352,
0.5249330401420593,
-0.3310905396938324,
0.09991000592708588,
0.29145097732543945,
-0.6999862194061279,
-0.11566802114248276,
0.627607524394989,
0.3614598214626312,
0.2939235270023346,
-0.36911097168922424,
-0.36922717094421387,
0.3854101300239563,
-0.1363568753004074,
0.6074945330619812,
-0.48338690400123596,
-0.08442748337984085,
-0.20440265536308289,
-0.06504260003566742,
0.32549795508384705,
-0.24349677562713623,
0.46433520317077637,
-0.7222358584403992,
0.10599970072507858,
-0.41069546341896057,
-0.2221788763999939,
-0.558992326259613,
0.73641037940979,
-0.6323859691619873,
0.5125216245651245,
-0.22189944982528687,
-0.2774806022644043,
0.9113324880599976,
-0.5925182700157166,
-0.5238109230995178,
0.09704124182462692,
0.04760035127401352,
-0.28773826360702515,
0.49539873003959656,
0.4288400113582611,
0.7597983479499817,
-0.15019674599170685,
0.29652053117752075,
-0.3737982213497162,
-0.07273969799280167,
0.5444759726524353,
-0.5812134146690369,
0.5516601800918579,
0.469628244638443,
-0.3110694885253906,
-0.08992923051118851,
-0.6454954147338867,
-0.1542665660381317,
0.08099570870399475,
-0.18678531050682068,
-0.6628382802009583,
0.1839771270751953,
0.20999328792095184,
0.3733774423599243,
0.566399872303009,
-0.4803694188594818,
0.2952459454536438,
-0.025618212297558784,
0.35767585039138794,
0.4552175998687744,
0.0976102203130722,
0.38854312896728516,
-0.04155002534389496,
0.35475388169288635,
0.23689612746238708,
0.8773577213287354,
-0.4117867350578308,
-0.6955884695053101,
-0.763654351234436,
-0.23205417394638062,
-0.31952333450317383,
-0.07118413597345352,
-0.6873313784599304,
0.2161974310874939,
-0.2843959629535675,
-0.19589586555957794,
-0.2045377939939499,
0.19235874712467194,
0.3922380208969116,
0.07479046285152435,
0.3835926949977875,
-0.5301081538200378,
-0.2647807002067566,
-1.215499758720398,
-0.2550860345363617,
-0.27496814727783203,
-0.0790383592247963,
0.5901727676391602,
0.12939020991325378,
-0.49306735396385193,
1.0015676021575928,
-0.8957970142364502,
-0.4430028796195984,
-0.3412005305290222,
0.2534926235675812,
0.1984797865152359,
0.03273184224963188,
0.6511607766151428,
-1.320926547050476,
-0.4077982008457184,
0.12311538308858871,
-0.4480283856391907,
0.2427419275045395,
-0.31348708271980286,
-0.19980557262897491,
0.07212172448635101,
0.11836761981248856,
-0.8424848318099976,
0.3861045241355896,
0.5839328765869141,
-0.2721419632434845,
0.21881960332393646,
-0.5549930334091187,
0.5158380270004272,
-1.2498010396957397,
-0.14520376920700073,
0.42511191964149475,
-0.035500820726156235,
-0.47628697752952576,
-0.08993423730134964,
0.26656976342201233,
0.23255610466003418,
-0.6242708563804626,
0.24269235134124756,
-0.4747263789176941,
-0.04756387695670128,
0.0359768308699131,
-0.017025433480739594,
0.7004144787788391,
0.6027145385742188,
0.18468832969665527,
0.39787527918815613,
0.05522654205560684,
-0.8982192873954773,
0.3868916630744934,
0.22639904916286469,
-0.586178183555603,
1.0719062089920044,
-0.3056759238243103,
-0.035608723759651184,
-0.4018670618534088,
0.21239936351776123,
-1.2064756155014038,
-0.47445178031921387,
0.36035528779029846,
-0.24279320240020752,
0.15357187390327454,
-0.29025861620903015,
-0.4088015556335449,
-0.4826040267944336,
-0.055871106684207916,
0.4729800820350647,
0.3383609354496002,
-0.6105005145072937,
1.0243260860443115,
0.45065075159072876,
0.04786346107721329,
-0.7005608081817627,
-0.9563373923301697,
0.11917068064212799,
-0.35293447971343994,
-0.46129900217056274,
0.21520563960075378,
-0.2561405301094055,
-0.3436088263988495,
-0.2397419512271881,
0.2329760640859604,
-0.07859380543231964,
-0.1687917858362198,
0.20876926183700562,
0.21757963299751282,
0.19507214426994324,
0.291692852973938,
-0.04812955483794212,
-0.0084310881793499,
0.1800585240125656,
-0.5638687014579773,
0.5031828880310059,
0.24485541880130768,
-0.48864278197288513,
-0.4031412601470947,
0.26204806566238403,
0.9177693724632263,
-0.5125147104263306,
0.4041110575199127,
0.673149049282074,
-0.2626582980155945,
-0.25911396741867065,
-0.8826946020126343,
-0.28507164120674133,
-0.47729358077049255,
0.31083381175994873,
-0.5500823259353638,
-0.3435589075088501,
0.13894572854042053,
0.054706163704395294,
0.12950575351715088,
-0.09048733115196228,
0.5133198499679565,
-0.27864065766334534,
1.1783403158187866,
0.5206373929977417,
-0.02408684231340885,
0.5074310898780823,
-0.03241068124771118,
0.589817225933075,
-0.878056526184082,
-0.470883309841156,
0.04737182334065437,
-0.8336093425750732,
-0.2257312685251236,
-0.47052061557769775,
0.31656497716903687,
-0.1410997062921524,
-0.021281734108924866,
0.3475607931613922,
-0.4402832090854645,
0.48839494585990906,
0.5112993717193604,
0.5666052103042603,
0.5057333111763,
0.35700029134750366,
0.2524455785751343,
-0.03380168601870537,
-0.044906798750162125,
-0.20501984655857086,
1.1542001962661743,
0.13285988569259644,
0.6478473544120789,
0.25158700346946716,
0.3167053461074829,
0.09545183926820755,
0.14429707825183868,
-1.031206488609314,
0.5066232681274414,
-0.23810474574565887,
-0.9424725770950317,
-0.007673640735447407,
-0.08703853189945221,
-0.9150630235671997,
0.2788424789905548,
-0.21769610047340393,
-0.8401269912719727,
0.5145602226257324,
0.6212520599365234,
-0.5572870373725891,
-0.02902224287390709,
-0.8733279705047607,
0.8294281959533691,
-0.9031732082366943,
-0.7303693294525146,
-0.699451744556427,
-0.3197578191757202,
0.504967987537384,
-0.16898022592067719,
0.3637954592704773,
-0.02543838880956173,
-0.0010680295526981354,
0.4074722230434418,
0.12933750450611115,
0.589369535446167,
-0.10238698869943619,
-0.13101905584335327,
0.2625424265861511,
0.06920559704303741,
0.6196601986885071,
-0.12856481969356537,
0.3247831463813782,
0.14637157320976257,
-0.4221939742565155,
-0.016727264970541,
-0.6322206854820251,
0.4696010947227478,
-0.3357976973056793,
-0.41416189074516296,
-0.1461697667837143,
-0.5199164152145386,
-0.39988812804222107,
0.2230263352394104,
0.08142706006765366,
0.20408359169960022,
-0.317976713180542,
0.4145907759666443,
0.7640674114227295,
-0.2919486463069916,
0.4939625859260559,
0.4388320744037628,
-0.700846254825592,
-0.21756935119628906,
0.9149375557899475,
-0.06080533191561699,
0.29641130566596985,
0.5117613673210144,
0.3254159390926361,
-0.647574245929718,
-0.4566398859024048,
-0.4577590823173523,
0.10349591076374054,
-0.660258412361145,
0.2460639923810959,
-0.8510045409202576,
0.49407997727394104,
-0.09637264162302017,
0.07495293021202087,
-0.28167977929115295,
-0.10841361433267593,
0.07185008376836777,
0.026173114776611328,
0.5190919041633606,
0.8053368330001831,
0.2870756983757019,
0.26002237200737,
-0.8413674831390381,
0.5361003875732422,
0.6764271259307861,
0.3143470585346222,
-0.010485149919986725,
0.04205610603094101,
-0.31469714641571045,
0.47225087881088257,
-0.06652936339378357,
-0.3323652744293213,
0.597761869430542,
-0.04792424291372299,
0.40982747077941895,
0.9684427380561829,
0.08392828702926636,
1.0017205476760864,
-0.3516535460948944,
0.7679381966590881,
0.49962204694747925,
-0.7149436473846436,
0.45162829756736755,
-0.455268919467926,
0.37081488966941833,
0.5490884780883789,
0.5335876941680908,
-0.7162346839904785,
0.12723079323768616,
-0.4473235607147217,
-1.0152846574783325,
0.7149755954742432,
-0.043349940329790115,
0.04563780874013901,
0.01796121709048748,
0.07969118654727936,
0.0728217139840126,
0.6738551259040833,
-0.6974133849143982,
-0.1619216650724411,
0.05691298469901085,
-0.4269135892391205,
-0.5687829852104187,
-0.39741912484169006,
-0.12161625176668167,
-0.05649261176586151,
0.46913084387779236,
-0.1611378937959671,
-0.02573050744831562,
0.019232671707868576,
-0.24134336411952972,
0.10609704256057739,
0.32908502221107483,
0.5331401824951172,
0.7761914134025574,
-0.2198483943939209,
0.11671948432922363,
-0.42394527792930603,
-0.7934301495552063,
0.03554483503103256,
-0.33909910917282104,
-0.17426569759845734,
-0.35614901781082153,
-0.3481876850128174,
0.4790293574333191,
0.23312972486019135,
-0.7889149785041809,
0.5655343532562256,
-0.4314624071121216,
-0.10539133846759796,
-0.5444164276123047,
-0.11282271146774292,
0.301211953163147,
0.4567734897136688,
0.19599774479866028,
0.14203234016895294,
0.6026067137718201,
-0.6200170516967773,
0.0642266720533371,
0.5242011547088623,
-0.2096787393093109,
-0.30286070704460144,
0.42483749985694885,
0.12067027390003204,
-0.03456581011414528,
0.6335156559944153,
-0.2778237760066986,
-0.3058077096939087,
0.31639689207077026,
0.29874783754348755,
1.1167235374450684,
-0.08210720866918564,
0.2565474808216095,
0.3454973101615906,
0.3733687698841095,
-0.2914445996284485,
0.29219871759414673,
-0.5280420184135437,
-0.8961098194122314,
-0.25726765394210815,
-0.7639442086219788,
-0.27842244505882263,
0.10559298098087311,
-0.6427268385887146,
0.22661247849464417,
-0.16532854735851288,
-0.37924468517303467,
0.23085959255695343,
-0.35740208625793457,
-0.8671079277992249,
0.525195300579071,
0.259504109621048,
0.17918823659420013,
-0.6205607056617737,
0.7832249402999878,
0.666937530040741,
-0.5803783535957336,
-0.7523083686828613,
-0.004715906456112862,
-0.042486660182476044,
-0.6479423642158508,
0.7583364248275757,
0.2681548595428467,
-0.37472572922706604,
-0.29644376039505005,
-0.2563972473144531,
-0.600027859210968,
0.9808459281921387,
0.06826905906200409,
-1.0922412872314453,
0.20887866616249084,
0.2279878705739975,
0.2934715747833252,
-0.46725350618362427,
0.31041890382766724,
0.5130152106285095,
0.65458083152771,
0.3678213059902191,
-0.4685858488082886,
-0.3296816945075989,
-0.06302494555711746,
-0.25905027985572815,
0.3862364590167999,
-0.6235001683235168,
0.7712432146072388,
-0.02190195955336094,
-0.09260302782058716,
-0.434773325920105,
0.007540299091488123,
0.2815912961959839,
0.7364709973335266,
0.7237752079963684,
0.903802752494812,
0.7549185156822205,
0.0773383229970932,
0.9781752824783325,
-0.23300376534461975,
0.08078133314847946,
1.089308261871338,
-0.46776795387268066,
1.2002924680709839,
0.6733282208442688,
-0.3759007751941681,
0.36294883489608765,
0.5083956718444824,
0.35374727845191956,
0.5449034571647644,
-0.31557196378707886,
-0.410614013671875,
-0.54505455493927,
-0.010543028824031353,
-0.11134537309408188,
0.618374228477478,
0.5609996318817139,
-0.6699575781822205,
0.1662030965089798,
0.06832580268383026,
-0.21354685723781586,
-0.41636887192726135,
-0.4806971251964569,
0.8596304655075073,
-0.02052837237715721,
-1.0304571390151978,
0.18723440170288086,
-0.4456614851951599,
0.6045554280281067,
-0.6018798351287842,
0.01984894834458828,
0.12269247323274612,
0.7691872715950012,
-0.39562296867370605,
-0.7105563282966614,
-0.06856229156255722,
-0.08335394412279129,
-0.5026580095291138,
-0.5136950016021729,
0.6836764216423035,
-0.47582167387008667,
-0.576267421245575,
0.2986186742782593,
0.4289352297782898,
0.18602557480335236,
-0.5385391116142273,
-0.5863317251205444,
-0.10626436769962311,
0.145847350358963,
-0.5408147573471069,
0.40675950050354004,
0.36840757727622986,
-0.06025061383843422,
0.5522959232330322,
0.8416115641593933,
-0.16714850068092346,
-0.012718565762043,
0.086263008415699,
0.3679097890853882,
-0.4465237557888031,
-0.46484580636024475,
-0.9994804263114929,
0.6468445062637329,
-0.29246726632118225,
-0.11681582033634186,
0.7402580976486206,
0.5457614064216614,
0.993247926235199,
-0.2234501838684082,
0.7776584029197693,
0.16522955894470215,
-0.08231788873672485,
-0.33073103427886963,
0.8026959300041199,
-0.9514803886413574,
0.17229071259498596,
-0.2192864716053009,
-1.1936439275741577,
-0.09297110140323639,
0.7502633929252625,
-0.3766598403453827,
0.030263792723417282,
0.5754895806312561,
0.5534783005714417,
-0.28574374318122864,
0.19133856892585754,
0.5646671056747437,
0.020452285185456276,
0.11911104619503021,
0.6352285742759705,
0.7964860200881958,
-0.22577610611915588,
0.3288458585739136,
-0.410148948431015,
-0.2268521934747696,
-0.19046956300735474,
-0.9697844386100769,
-0.601493239402771,
-0.6780388355255127,
-0.3461359143257141,
-0.05172734335064888,
-0.22044119238853455,
1.1507446765899658,
0.8218125104904175,
-0.40001633763313293,
-0.2508421838283539,
-0.02908625826239586,
-0.1296778917312622,
-0.4259023070335388,
-0.13160192966461182,
-0.08812891691923141,
-0.2876279354095459,
-0.9532256126403809,
0.28672704100608826,
0.6720760464668274,
0.05792318657040596,
-0.5055068731307983,
-0.14115142822265625,
-0.22059687972068787,
0.18172937631607056,
1.0670877695083618,
-0.08486167341470718,
-0.9018917679786682,
-0.11153991520404816,
0.1921338438987732,
0.13241837918758392,
0.008969105780124664,
0.8764331936836243,
-0.7630788087844849,
0.9254991412162781,
0.48028564453125,
0.21403902769088745,
0.7097723484039307,
-0.06042763963341713,
0.6178549528121948,
-0.5497468113899231,
0.27666574716567993,
0.02120034582912922,
0.6946385502815247,
0.04035727679729462,
-0.3696264326572418,
0.18944422900676727,
-0.2264866828918457,
-0.49405714869499207,
-0.370479553937912,
0.6137144565582275,
-1.1213300228118896,
-0.46998488903045654,
1.129015326499939,
-0.15643852949142456,
-0.5162513256072998,
-0.27581101655960083,
-0.34199821949005127,
-0.17103420197963715,
-0.43988367915153503,
0.8073824048042297,
0.7890198826789856,
0.00526810297742486,
-0.23562292754650116,
-0.4285264015197754,
0.382150799036026,
0.10402112454175949,
-0.6128548979759216,
0.18254467844963074,
1.0260940790176392,
-0.11075650900602341,
0.4795292019844055,
0.5181145071983337,
0.1273050606250763,
0.3091146647930145,
-0.1380658894777298,
0.3735300898551941,
0.011417720466852188,
-0.5673725605010986,
0.07855850458145142,
0.31008148193359375,
0.13840126991271973,
-0.36213037371635437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15473v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15473v1
|
Intertwining CP and NLP: The Generation of Unreasonably Constrained Sentences
| 2024-06-15T17:40:49 | 2024-06-15T17:40:49 |
Alexandre Bonlarron, Jean-Charles Régin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Constrained text generation remains a challenging task, particularly when
dealing with hard constraints. Traditional Natural Language Processing (NLP)
approaches prioritize generating meaningful and coherent output. Also, the
current state-of-the-art methods often lack the expressiveness and constraint
satisfaction capabilities to handle such tasks effectively. This paper presents
the Constraints First Framework to remedy this issue. This framework considers
a constrained text generation problem as a discrete combinatorial optimization
problem. It is solved by a constraint programming method that combines
linguistic properties (e.g., n-grams or language level) with other more
classical constraints (e.g., the number of characters, syllables, or words).
Eventually, a curation phase allows for selecting the best-generated sentences
according to perplexity using a large language model. The effectiveness of this
approach is demonstrated by tackling a new more tediously constrained text
generation problem: the iconic RADNER sentences problem. This problem aims to
generate sentences respecting a set of quite strict rules defined by their use
in vision and clinical research. Thanks to our CP-based approach, many new
strongly constrained sentences have been successfully generated in an automatic
manner. This highlights the potential of our approach to handle unreasonably
constrained text generation scenarios.
|
[
-0.35199010372161865,
-0.4287336766719818,
0.5597071647644043,
0.5409324765205383,
-0.35906800627708435,
0.11100579053163528,
-0.26612281799316406,
-0.3557793200016022,
0.000538294785656035,
0.9139294028282166,
-0.8667556047439575,
-0.22803962230682373,
-0.46611666679382324,
0.7274767756462097,
-0.31931495666503906,
1.04155695438385,
-0.10428472608327866,
-0.2163543552160263,
-0.4026285707950592,
0.020734846591949463,
-0.5541946887969971,
-0.6590169668197632,
0.04940270259976387,
-0.4948020279407501,
0.2577236592769623,
0.3046656548976898,
0.6656145453453064,
0.79226154088974,
0.5776444673538208,
0.24625781178474426,
-0.12371476739645004,
0.5174682140350342,
-0.3902885913848877,
0.3832187354564667,
-0.30234795808792114,
-0.06620654463768005,
0.2999277710914612,
-0.3722047209739685,
0.37304234504699707,
0.968682587146759,
-0.07898711413145065,
-0.37335440516471863,
0.34223324060440063,
0.7752028107643127,
-0.6389744877815247,
0.10911353677511215,
-0.6650469303131104,
0.34446701407432556,
-0.4158017039299011,
-0.4821201264858246,
-0.3358634114265442,
-0.17750121653079987,
0.17254376411437988,
-0.72845059633255,
0.14451353251934052,
0.23979654908180237,
0.8723735213279724,
0.5885570049285889,
-0.3565470278263092,
-0.7026489973068237,
-0.7816392183303833,
0.7443717122077942,
-0.6509331464767456,
-0.1596691757440567,
0.30327650904655457,
-0.15520784258842468,
-0.38077354431152344,
-0.6450091004371643,
-0.6599733233451843,
-0.016239112243056297,
-0.25118884444236755,
-0.055371735244989395,
-0.3530082702636719,
0.1971196085214615,
0.27178430557250977,
0.3276360332965851,
-0.7106529474258423,
0.06740111112594604,
-0.3411558270454407,
-0.029593629762530327,
0.5709486603736877,
0.4399649202823639,
0.15573954582214355,
-0.5295348167419434,
-0.1924756020307541,
-0.06123722344636917,
-0.6608891487121582,
-0.25518181920051575,
0.4992281496524811,
0.46231314539909363,
0.08949805051088333,
0.9049258232116699,
-0.2390960454940796,
0.7224488258361816,
0.2259768843650818,
0.17648166418075562,
-0.1390550136566162,
-0.3982861042022705,
-0.1346929967403412,
0.03261473774909973,
0.8717368245124817,
0.28432929515838623,
0.2703389525413513,
-0.021204229444265366,
-0.06227211281657219,
0.1884956806898117,
0.3296827971935272,
-0.49486374855041504,
-0.4413416385650635,
0.14779876172542572,
-0.2550615668296814,
-0.45822644233703613,
0.08984456956386566,
-0.7518433928489685,
-0.20398135483264923,
-0.19406373798847198,
-0.09013496339321136,
-0.6262115240097046,
0.0343957282602787,
0.44119691848754883,
0.08673185110092163,
0.04231976345181465,
-0.11677109450101852,
-1.222796082496643,
0.23597568273544312,
0.7189014554023743,
0.5522987842559814,
-0.07947255671024323,
-0.03682546317577362,
-0.3801909387111664,
0.25526612997055054,
-0.029231132939457893,
0.5634955763816833,
-0.4946786165237427,
-0.3602617084980011,
0.21874462068080902,
-0.4247687757015228,
0.06757865101099014,
-0.585052490234375,
0.8675261735916138,
-0.1278594732284546,
0.3170078694820404,
-0.11468160897493362,
-0.7434393763542175,
0.24559032917022705,
0.025165868923068047,
-0.35569196939468384,
0.7950713634490967,
0.4345681667327881,
-0.9904196262359619,
0.2126995027065277,
-0.16210967302322388,
-0.5816798210144043,
0.4790266752243042,
-0.4380176067352295,
-0.4582861363887787,
0.25020915269851685,
0.274486780166626,
0.3416409194469452,
-0.45291510224342346,
0.5530524253845215,
-0.05573362112045288,
0.10499641299247742,
0.06556648761034012,
-0.071184441447258,
0.7022882699966431,
0.30905938148498535,
-0.21376129984855652,
-0.032017916440963745,
-0.6538918614387512,
0.36188194155693054,
0.11287158727645874,
-0.538251519203186,
-0.2037353515625,
0.1978212594985962,
0.3286333978176117,
0.014611052349209785,
0.11926577985286713,
-0.5184207558631897,
0.416620671749115,
-0.6667484045028687,
0.7623182535171509,
0.5054387450218201,
0.26381897926330566,
0.34416505694389343,
-0.4195588231086731,
0.6151328682899475,
-0.42203420400619507,
0.16388553380966187,
-0.15162765979766846,
-0.3198133707046509,
-0.4833194613456726,
0.27649834752082825,
0.1525627225637436,
0.6848108172416687,
-1.0033413171768188,
0.7415335178375244,
-0.035485051572322845,
0.03737783059477806,
-0.0827462375164032,
0.22822947800159454,
0.7311019897460938,
0.2946390211582184,
0.3154059052467346,
-0.28604957461357117,
-0.8036331534385681,
-1.0905766487121582,
-0.15745478868484497,
-0.09459760785102844,
0.030429931357502937,
0.1010383740067482,
0.35617130994796753,
-0.037405550479888916,
0.8973442912101746,
-0.657177746295929,
-0.5501502156257629,
-0.5493407845497131,
0.20604650676250458,
0.15413595736026764,
0.8477060198783875,
0.44227561354637146,
-0.9716495275497437,
-0.5521700382232666,
-0.16530591249465942,
-0.5564253330230713,
-0.48370298743247986,
-0.39414891600608826,
0.06817290186882019,
0.3806701600551605,
0.5870383977890015,
-0.4290013313293457,
0.3854343295097351,
0.66880202293396,
-0.240193173289299,
0.673285961151123,
-0.38196349143981934,
-0.3180403709411621,
-0.6894963979721069,
-0.07952587306499481,
-0.17381826043128967,
-0.1584978699684143,
-0.45655813813209534,
0.19591748714447021,
-0.26529356837272644,
-0.23436997830867767,
-0.10049530118703842,
0.05517859384417534,
-0.3886798024177551,
0.4674476385116577,
-0.14739848673343658,
-0.00733883585780859,
0.18617480993270874,
0.6070370674133301,
0.006519125308841467,
0.1450227051973343,
0.28358879685401917,
-0.42840105295181274,
0.19232331216335297,
0.7813194990158081,
-0.40406668186187744,
0.5691365003585815,
-0.528139591217041,
-0.14166562259197235,
-0.09766075760126114,
0.13348376750946045,
-0.42270901799201965,
-0.48034730553627014,
0.2764100134372711,
-0.2524259388446808,
0.4318138659000397,
0.2268468588590622,
-0.5636752843856812,
-0.4335205852985382,
-0.04878868907690048,
0.6294875144958496,
0.2913663387298584,
-0.3691375255584717,
0.3618673086166382,
0.17703920602798462,
-0.11475813388824463,
-0.44588610529899597,
-0.8132576942443848,
0.3351595997810364,
-0.09728144109249115,
-0.5866475105285645,
0.8436031937599182,
-0.19790737330913544,
-0.23497812449932098,
0.19926142692565918,
-0.0357595793902874,
0.0017625672044232488,
-0.3097388744354248,
0.17651112377643585,
0.06125693395733833,
0.1044258326292038,
-0.1691366285085678,
0.21706902980804443,
-0.2092498540878296,
-0.15673571825027466,
-0.298761248588562,
0.611699640750885,
0.1301220953464508,
-0.24552732706069946,
-0.36117666959762573,
0.9906193017959595,
0.3109688460826874,
-0.1894172877073288,
0.29196643829345703,
0.10750049352645874,
-0.3326585292816162,
-0.46779292821884155,
-0.22802704572677612,
0.03630043938755989,
-0.495634526014328,
0.2756340801715851,
-0.2772727906703949,
-1.0635038614273071,
0.03438642621040344,
0.06115356460213661,
0.09174193441867828,
0.327699214220047,
0.5521645545959473,
0.1199222058057785,
1.0125267505645752,
0.9245997667312622,
0.41158097982406616,
0.2002471536397934,
0.23319314420223236,
0.42409947514533997,
-0.7673971652984619,
-0.18622371554374695,
-0.4808325469493866,
-0.10339073836803436,
-0.4811828136444092,
-0.23422721028327942,
0.3778212368488312,
0.4369037449359894,
-0.014423058368265629,
0.545397162437439,
-1.0831873416900635,
0.42442259192466736,
0.7769280672073364,
0.049148011952638626,
0.13824833929538727,
-0.29721397161483765,
-0.363193154335022,
-0.4792448580265045,
-1.0309852361679077,
-0.48950403928756714,
0.9338135719299316,
-0.2949202358722687,
0.4807800352573395,
0.08886728435754776,
0.8152215480804443,
0.09159088134765625,
-0.028336288407444954,
-0.40519362688064575,
0.5480239987373352,
-0.493304967880249,
-0.48743802309036255,
0.024265818297863007,
-0.5201064348220825,
-0.8963584303855896,
-0.09920302778482437,
-0.754037082195282,
-0.9075062870979309,
0.06088956817984581,
0.24781331419944763,
-0.5204281806945801,
0.19053293764591217,
-0.268077552318573,
0.6480799317359924,
-0.27705100178718567,
-0.4002343416213989,
0.04127293452620506,
-0.819031834602356,
0.5115185976028442,
-0.10629390180110931,
-0.12312628328800201,
0.030373012647032738,
0.3162961006164551,
0.23829425871372223,
-0.6900729537010193,
0.6764770150184631,
0.22479146718978882,
-0.027591878548264503,
0.30799174308776855,
0.23047533631324768,
0.42102861404418945,
0.14625848829746246,
0.11930675804615021,
-0.3238012492656708,
0.23488609492778778,
-0.22970972955226898,
-0.3676179349422455,
0.5255416631698608,
-0.28381600975990295,
-0.5711275935173035,
-0.5351276397705078,
-0.6990743279457092,
-0.19578249752521515,
0.2206902951002121,
0.8905967473983765,
0.562512218952179,
-0.18727877736091614,
0.22839811444282532,
0.524823784828186,
-0.6049320697784424,
0.40824082493782043,
0.06125299260020256,
-0.23717670142650604,
-0.5044262409210205,
0.6264221668243408,
-0.1616879254579544,
0.3458918333053589,
0.7953246235847473,
0.2789744436740875,
-0.15874886512756348,
-0.8889751434326172,
-0.24250748753547668,
0.08171248435974121,
-0.4918293058872223,
-0.365837961435318,
-0.6096130609512329,
-0.31405338644981384,
-0.566157877445221,
-0.7010058760643005,
-0.14067833125591278,
-0.5161094665527344,
-0.39266592264175415,
0.31098902225494385,
-0.03085387870669365,
0.8219033479690552,
-0.25278788805007935,
0.2126866579055786,
-0.7425671815872192,
0.3382630944252014,
0.2827902138233185,
0.11557169258594513,
-0.3436826169490814,
0.09888872504234314,
0.0531376414000988,
-0.39213550090789795,
-0.5915756821632385,
-0.7856606841087341,
0.5342676639556885,
0.23761390149593353,
0.2164939045906067,
0.30135267972946167,
0.6230536699295044,
0.30675971508026123,
-0.4797794222831726,
0.4834713637828827,
0.44047969579696655,
-1.0179814100265503,
0.5778162479400635,
-0.5921868681907654,
0.4434010982513428,
0.7123894691467285,
-0.21233856678009033,
-0.5082312226295471,
-0.8263689875602722,
-0.6372988820075989,
-1.1362711191177368,
0.4701559543609619,
0.6715085506439209,
0.05836612731218338,
-0.20838317275047302,
0.7004914283752441,
0.04503251984715462,
0.2921757698059082,
-0.8143681287765503,
0.0023637835402041674,
-0.10039878636598587,
-0.36916184425354004,
0.16464011371135712,
-0.33184948563575745,
-0.2292567789554596,
-0.12474615126848221,
0.7552286386489868,
-0.2300642728805542,
-0.04172945395112038,
0.46244722604751587,
0.057075586169958115,
-0.25820091366767883,
0.22734473645687103,
0.7231958508491516,
0.5344714522361755,
-0.08559967577457428,
-0.15321676433086395,
-0.3039529621601105,
-0.27469944953918457,
-0.21866989135742188,
0.13240909576416016,
-0.5005673170089722,
-0.010946822352707386,
0.5472970008850098,
0.656512439250946,
0.1855141520500183,
-0.939478874206543,
0.4563549757003784,
0.035061709582805634,
-0.5317177772521973,
-0.4321419596672058,
0.15393586456775665,
-0.11807157099246979,
0.26658037304878235,
0.30452466011047363,
0.054315973073244095,
-0.23724612593650818,
-0.18448062241077423,
0.415367990732193,
0.4262900948524475,
-0.30368557572364807,
0.04144534096121788,
1.0948081016540527,
0.29776379466056824,
-0.46348315477371216,
0.6391847133636475,
-0.32068100571632385,
-0.7216854691505432,
0.5238054990768433,
0.6700407862663269,
0.7144030928611755,
0.22689488530158997,
0.1940336525440216,
0.4292747974395752,
0.42849835753440857,
-0.1693272739648819,
0.19018669426441193,
-0.027865124866366386,
-0.8407130241394043,
-0.4747694730758667,
-0.7249487638473511,
-0.5648505091667175,
-0.03750813752412796,
-0.7607484459877014,
0.2959374487400055,
-0.6663658618927002,
0.08927655220031738,
0.12142446637153625,
0.04546964541077614,
-0.29035133123397827,
-0.0781220942735672,
0.12332995980978012,
0.5410510897636414,
-0.46644800901412964,
0.677791953086853,
0.41585469245910645,
-0.2230631560087204,
-0.638796865940094,
-0.19395999610424042,
0.22039568424224854,
-0.5730167031288147,
0.2744815945625305,
0.21255110204219818,
0.06989143788814545,
0.010846146382391453,
-0.5578574538230896,
-0.3490745723247528,
0.6301088929176331,
0.3264698088169098,
-0.7265112400054932,
-0.2601664960384369,
0.26729610562324524,
0.47158578038215637,
-0.4036405086517334,
-0.7157517075538635,
0.4300272762775421,
0.5987670421600342,
0.06387496739625931,
-0.7868784070014954,
0.18404941260814667,
-0.37310442328453064,
-0.020947439596056938,
0.6133671998977661,
-0.3316662907600403,
0.8866631984710693,
-0.1990775167942047,
-0.47569146752357483,
0.606058657169342,
0.4544217586517334,
0.3103756010532379,
0.020870709791779518,
0.48869356513023376,
0.7673333883285522,
0.4974863827228546,
-0.18466567993164062,
0.9296258687973022,
-0.2916308045387268,
0.3568255305290222,
1.2406325340270996,
-0.3979710042476654,
0.4649844467639923,
0.72995924949646,
-0.1659936010837555,
0.3567425608634949,
0.27763471007347107,
-0.17815084755420685,
0.5582947731018066,
0.6060994863510132,
-0.36390379071235657,
-0.3188210129737854,
-0.22878742218017578,
-0.1516624093055725,
0.48663800954818726,
0.33231857419013977,
-0.3069940209388733,
-0.29455041885375977,
0.14916270971298218,
0.01209314912557602,
0.8269996643066406,
0.10656213760375977,
0.6239145398139954,
0.15236735343933105,
-0.9187999963760376,
0.42146146297454834,
0.10120133310556412,
0.7796390056610107,
-0.6408015489578247,
-0.01265669334679842,
0.11658672988414764,
0.2754056751728058,
-0.23998521268367767,
-0.6810109615325928,
0.6966097950935364,
-0.045887235552072525,
-0.3344159722328186,
-0.7055732607841492,
0.5187912583351135,
-0.45661330223083496,
-0.5208023190498352,
0.03235872834920883,
0.32991722226142883,
-0.2426963746547699,
0.017724646255373955,
-0.4664040505886078,
0.033960867673158646,
0.3412092924118042,
-0.024586781859397888,
0.23045614361763,
0.6322024464607239,
0.1539577692747116,
0.5184833407402039,
0.4479976296424866,
0.24375750124454498,
0.012718817219138145,
-0.2548328936100006,
0.8510657548904419,
-0.5022394061088562,
-0.5907129049301147,
-0.6923201680183411,
0.23997589945793152,
0.07825969159603119,
-0.7231234312057495,
0.22288313508033752,
0.4493425488471985,
0.6809554100036621,
0.23029790818691254,
0.8114253282546997,
-0.5148305296897888,
0.41182565689086914,
-0.5972051620483398,
0.25045046210289,
-0.44730058312416077,
0.2870786786079407,
-0.47423896193504333,
-0.8718728423118591,
-0.8348538279533386,
0.5457589626312256,
0.1209246814250946,
-0.4930686950683594,
0.9166055917739868,
0.4572800099849701,
0.19614489376544952,
0.1904560923576355,
0.0324542261660099,
-0.16593603789806366,
0.2570677399635315,
1.173988699913025,
0.7002356648445129,
0.08958865702152252,
0.8109023571014404,
-0.6894650459289551,
-0.12608236074447632,
-0.003676491556689143,
-1.082479476928711,
-0.755998432636261,
-0.8300020694732666,
-0.3353531062602997,
-0.4157414734363556,
-0.22630642354488373,
0.9006935954093933,
0.48021233081817627,
-0.5906074643135071,
0.01768723875284195,
-0.7001251578330994,
0.003071216866374016,
-0.22870716452598572,
-0.2398432344198227,
0.2555208206176758,
-0.25629863142967224,
-0.8045574426651001,
0.21314507722854614,
0.5641978979110718,
0.0909590795636177,
-0.4100169539451599,
0.028985997661948204,
-0.2400493323802948,
0.053229693323373795,
0.35151612758636475,
0.5628083944320679,
-0.46247386932373047,
-0.4594094753265381,
-0.19582831859588623,
-0.08156712353229523,
0.04746641591191292,
1.3229281902313232,
-0.7038239240646362,
0.4409482181072235,
0.32181215286254883,
0.6291974186897278,
0.29085370898246765,
0.03251524269580841,
0.9326233267784119,
-1.0036002397537231,
0.21316039562225342,
0.8443739414215088,
0.30289945006370544,
0.36335086822509766,
-0.38526296615600586,
0.4936531186103821,
0.1642547994852066,
-0.6464745402336121,
-0.9868119359016418,
0.8412520289421082,
-1.1326570510864258,
-0.5219634175300598,
0.8783711194992065,
0.09809986501932144,
0.10348014533519745,
-0.38657641410827637,
-0.18339404463768005,
0.06192778795957565,
0.0015886075561866164,
0.6901414394378662,
0.7518652081489563,
-0.6058200597763062,
-0.2451058030128479,
-0.3557310700416565,
0.5741282105445862,
0.7190419435501099,
-0.6345986723899841,
0.21022658050060272,
0.5557021498680115,
-0.3308052718639374,
0.2908006012439728,
0.5997323989868164,
-0.03454127535223961,
-0.1547113060951233,
-0.0874597430229187,
0.009146126918494701,
-0.12749838829040527,
-0.22941601276397705,
-0.06846491247415543,
0.4604431986808777,
-0.26435205340385437,
0.2542845606803894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15472v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15472v1
|
Hyperbolic sentence representations for solving Textual Entailment
| 2024-06-15T15:39:43 | 2024-06-15T15:39:43 |
Igor Petrovski
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Hyperbolic spaces have proven to be suitable for modeling data of
hierarchical nature. As such we use the Poincare ball to embed sentences with
the goal of proving how hyperbolic spaces can be used for solving Textual
Entailment. To this end, apart from the standard datasets used for evaluating
textual entailment, we developed two additional datasets. We evaluate against
baselines of various backgrounds, including LSTMs, Order Embeddings and
Euclidean Averaging, which comes as a natural counterpart to representing
sentences into the Euclidean space. We consistently outperform the baselines on
the SICK dataset and are second only to Order Embeddings on the SNLI dataset,
for the binary classification version of the entailment task.
|
[
0.048319149762392044,
-1.0969873666763306,
0.8292253613471985,
0.350447416305542,
-0.07444527745246887,
-0.4910895526409149,
-0.24345572292804718,
-0.28454843163490295,
0.46401447057724,
0.47965654730796814,
-0.3416956961154938,
-0.8410338163375854,
-0.5946780443191528,
0.10203099995851517,
-0.3803780972957611,
0.9715136885643005,
-0.2971014082431793,
-0.40603065490722656,
-0.7059387564659119,
-0.035613223910331726,
-0.30287107825279236,
-0.5833288431167603,
0.0007276078104041517,
-0.15101872384548187,
0.2739748954772949,
0.1620682328939438,
1.156622290611267,
0.8988329768180847,
0.8148119449615479,
0.2492775321006775,
-0.045211900025606155,
0.1502915620803833,
-0.5286399722099304,
0.25318604707717896,
0.08645974099636078,
-0.10611487179994583,
-0.06374631822109222,
0.07321451604366302,
0.5748852491378784,
0.7470187544822693,
-0.6840015053749084,
0.05650337412953377,
-0.19744260609149933,
0.3075238764286041,
-0.7012619376182556,
0.4609161615371704,
-0.33950522541999817,
0.2661193907260895,
-0.16230043768882751,
-0.49152615666389465,
-0.3340974748134613,
-0.7137826681137085,
0.3015836179256439,
-1.016558289527893,
-0.07221323251724243,
0.39277517795562744,
0.8180703520774841,
0.4309699833393097,
-0.333670437335968,
-0.5310364961624146,
-0.5144898891448975,
0.6543368101119995,
-0.726608395576477,
0.2559356391429901,
0.5190761089324951,
0.132599875330925,
-0.4055279493331909,
-0.6896381378173828,
-0.566273033618927,
-0.16106078028678894,
-0.3018365800380707,
0.3229421377182007,
-0.31737351417541504,
-0.10168737173080444,
0.20885157585144043,
0.43316856026649475,
-0.6751381754875183,
0.010552888736128807,
-0.17137612402439117,
0.06539710611104965,
0.5435314178466797,
0.41075196862220764,
0.24699556827545166,
-0.43587690591812134,
-0.27631011605262756,
-0.01089945062994957,
-1.0039929151535034,
-0.22658778727054596,
0.42379143834114075,
0.15048640966415405,
-0.04580618813633919,
0.9573443531990051,
-0.03118213824927807,
0.48794952034950256,
-0.1707533448934555,
0.3718242049217224,
0.4268057346343994,
-0.28401702642440796,
-0.3922348618507385,
0.22671590745449066,
0.8117067217826843,
0.2749537229537964,
0.40528011322021484,
-0.1621597707271576,
0.15905436873435974,
-0.017452798783779144,
0.2744581401348114,
-0.7043518424034119,
-0.07867492735385895,
0.4227760136127472,
-0.3292001485824585,
0.09092523157596588,
0.3125833570957184,
-0.41757655143737793,
-0.473227858543396,
-0.2972780168056488,
0.10256362706422806,
-0.5795589089393616,
-0.02150101773440838,
0.7724348902702332,
-0.17738701403141022,
0.053702276200056076,
0.16854669153690338,
-0.6234957575798035,
0.6085635423660278,
0.8381387591362,
0.783578634262085,
0.14544592797756195,
-0.29032814502716064,
-0.3617624044418335,
0.36149632930755615,
-0.37494438886642456,
0.8588302731513977,
-0.8214350938796997,
-0.1416417509317398,
0.5452436804771423,
-0.009140735492110252,
-0.04043208062648773,
-0.9116390943527222,
0.779037594795227,
-0.029444169253110886,
0.32509496808052063,
-0.10332934558391571,
-1.0217535495758057,
-0.07031942158937454,
0.13212651014328003,
-0.5461024045944214,
1.2457572221755981,
0.04572554677724838,
-1.03945791721344,
0.07974684238433838,
-0.571964681148529,
-0.376537948846817,
-0.04578620195388794,
-0.23744209110736847,
-0.569383978843689,
0.19673524796962738,
0.20572972297668457,
0.8533920645713806,
-0.11905554682016373,
0.17993342876434326,
-0.3459031879901886,
-0.538091778755188,
-0.019775360822677612,
0.19191335141658783,
0.6917364001274109,
-0.2302180975675583,
-0.1684359610080719,
-0.07377343624830246,
-0.29479432106018066,
-0.2302524596452713,
0.27017197012901306,
-0.2969948947429657,
-0.6038256287574768,
0.29018494486808777,
0.31733277440071106,
-0.07901021093130112,
0.013795924372971058,
-0.8698752522468567,
0.07100439071655273,
-0.6175227165222168,
0.432233065366745,
0.4117735028266907,
0.3490722179412842,
0.1732584536075592,
-0.23529408872127533,
0.05934539809823036,
0.3294782042503357,
-0.2049759477376938,
0.015066899359226227,
-0.7963419556617737,
-0.232563316822052,
-0.01667885296046734,
-0.07087060809135437,
0.5585827827453613,
-0.7385807633399963,
0.5871701240539551,
-0.3007619380950928,
-0.28351861238479614,
-0.4345061779022217,
0.0034751007333397865,
0.2525121569633484,
0.16369614005088806,
0.4570620059967041,
0.39980095624923706,
-0.43463099002838135,
-0.9200434684753418,
-0.31446531414985657,
-0.16955554485321045,
0.06153598800301552,
0.14836734533309937,
0.8983069062232971,
-0.05638185888528824,
0.7503506541252136,
-0.7946481108665466,
-0.417792409658432,
0.143637016415596,
0.10972858220338821,
0.4105618894100189,
0.6083091497421265,
0.5845580697059631,
-0.6335499286651611,
-0.1790551096200943,
0.09494605660438538,
-1.0588535070419312,
0.3138557970523834,
0.07005353271961212,
-0.4908868968486786,
-0.268737256526947,
0.5991021990776062,
-0.6406992673873901,
0.6791340112686157,
0.34388718008995056,
-0.6746008396148682,
0.4423072636127472,
-0.3589261770248413,
0.19942839443683624,
-1.013814926147461,
-0.37088844180107117,
0.6889812350273132,
-0.3442915380001068,
-0.4980452358722687,
0.12899081408977509,
0.10421739518642426,
0.052398327738046646,
-0.5217430591583252,
0.11731183528900146,
-0.2205943465232849,
0.20766207575798035,
0.18116946518421173,
0.16409757733345032,
-0.33762326836586,
0.419085830450058,
0.26240596175193787,
0.21360257267951965,
0.8182510137557983,
-0.4107212424278259,
0.49749019742012024,
0.38467416167259216,
-0.5363197922706604,
0.4990147054195404,
-1.0860735177993774,
-0.09200713783502579,
-0.5958722233772278,
0.2656349241733551,
-0.8696681261062622,
-0.3546323776245117,
0.36412447690963745,
-0.020513076335191727,
-0.04928131029009819,
0.37326496839523315,
-1.0408767461776733,
-0.35342565178871155,
-0.39458250999450684,
0.4092142581939697,
0.5737226605415344,
-0.21177969872951508,
0.006582876667380333,
0.47625550627708435,
-0.031506240367889404,
-0.2767403721809387,
-0.666394054889679,
-0.09665926545858383,
-0.32435446977615356,
-0.12020346522331238,
0.6843600273132324,
0.1214689388871193,
-0.24223683774471283,
0.43034279346466064,
0.1530529260635376,
-0.009923440404236317,
-0.38100072741508484,
0.31766045093536377,
0.0695081502199173,
-0.4496937692165375,
0.20988669991493225,
0.20027537643909454,
0.11553256213665009,
0.12104981392621994,
-0.25874096155166626,
0.23001164197921753,
0.047416046261787415,
-0.3397359848022461,
-0.7947144508361816,
0.4408240020275116,
0.40471693873405457,
0.0788230448961258,
0.8476848602294922,
0.15076053142547607,
-1.211965560913086,
0.015133311972022057,
-0.18360686302185059,
0.11382202059030533,
-0.37735217809677124,
0.42462819814682007,
-0.0900762677192688,
-0.8277608156204224,
0.23432353138923645,
0.33755892515182495,
0.27773407101631165,
0.5275656580924988,
0.6781129837036133,
-0.3487359583377838,
0.7063437700271606,
0.45759108662605286,
0.13089486956596375,
0.20514382421970367,
-0.2837119996547699,
0.09359850734472275,
-0.7378003597259521,
-0.47492071986198425,
-0.7089431881904602,
-0.20257791876792908,
-0.6268974542617798,
-0.34433236718177795,
0.38269129395484924,
-0.23456932604312897,
-0.6072231531143188,
0.6503701210021973,
-0.488741934299469,
0.7580561637878418,
0.09719308465719223,
0.4651542603969574,
0.22173096239566803,
0.20212146639823914,
0.14441551268100739,
-0.36542844772338867,
-0.5483739376068115,
-0.655733048915863,
0.6530008316040039,
0.5586392879486084,
0.785270631313324,
0.2914266586303711,
0.6308737397193909,
0.20053189992904663,
0.3138476014137268,
-0.8731988072395325,
0.24910713732242584,
-0.5693305730819702,
-0.5214897394180298,
-0.4523427486419678,
-0.6020370125770569,
-1.1847317218780518,
0.11753494292497635,
-0.1953595131635666,
-0.7550148367881775,
0.27834832668304443,
-0.35376808047294617,
-0.4437674283981323,
0.097809799015522,
-0.42888376116752625,
0.7420580387115479,
0.3200394809246063,
-0.1231059804558754,
-0.07729201763868332,
-0.10012948513031006,
0.20136971771717072,
0.3706885278224945,
0.06293796747922897,
-0.19392625987529755,
-0.08350691199302673,
1.1933362483978271,
-0.405063658952713,
0.7437864542007446,
-0.13433654606342316,
-0.2870839536190033,
0.3957712650299072,
0.19722053408622742,
0.12487668544054031,
0.22318260371685028,
-0.201478973031044,
-0.11135178804397583,
0.13342083990573883,
-0.6510560512542725,
-0.9033957719802856,
0.7823954224586487,
-0.7272949814796448,
-0.6507951021194458,
-0.4991782605648041,
-0.5662409067153931,
-0.20851975679397583,
-0.3028937578201294,
0.04454219341278076,
0.6998184323310852,
-0.12241847813129425,
0.6109306216239929,
0.5620170831680298,
-0.21118129789829254,
0.4101512134075165,
-0.1982448846101761,
-0.07698801159858704,
-0.023024452850222588,
0.45202216506004333,
0.1653909534215927,
-0.19320426881313324,
0.4928852915763855,
0.34016814827919006,
-0.5382247567176819,
-0.4272339344024658,
-0.20172904431819916,
0.6092121005058289,
-0.6592411994934082,
-0.24467939138412476,
-0.6116735935211182,
-0.17816190421581268,
-0.24648451805114746,
0.009759421460330486,
-0.05030686780810356,
-0.3779256045818329,
-0.09653500467538834,
-0.3231561481952667,
0.5206748247146606,
1.2356477975845337,
0.6333674192428589,
0.278904527425766,
-0.48858121037483215,
0.19936779141426086,
-0.20553430914878845,
0.29695621132850647,
-0.24966858327388763,
-0.44540464878082275,
-0.37087282538414,
-0.03394633159041405,
-0.3918192982673645,
-0.9888846278190613,
0.20355592668056488,
0.3846394121646881,
0.6449812054634094,
0.2832372188568115,
0.012238242663443089,
0.9014820456504822,
-0.824741542339325,
0.7197068929672241,
0.24346889555454254,
-0.8459579348564148,
0.7930707931518555,
-0.35119909048080444,
0.060763999819755554,
0.18945574760437012,
1.0251981019973755,
-0.39212384819984436,
-0.7538198828697205,
-0.6587664484977722,
-0.5371202230453491,
0.20356620848178864,
0.5789233446121216,
0.2861860990524292,
-0.33333611488342285,
0.8245069980621338,
0.13355864584445953,
-0.10270601511001587,
-0.40976372361183167,
-0.2529396116733551,
-0.30354973673820496,
-0.5965549945831299,
-0.24178828299045563,
0.24591487646102905,
0.021044371649622917,
-0.39998307824134827,
0.2097441405057907,
0.08368013799190521,
0.3613913655281067,
0.43830400705337524,
-0.05261397734284401,
0.10761743783950806,
0.04717155173420906,
0.23245403170585632,
0.6460438370704651,
-0.34004658460617065,
0.24562793970108032,
-0.05979767069220543,
-0.47206491231918335,
0.14434075355529785,
0.016521500423550606,
0.3204951584339142,
0.38249626755714417,
0.6119627356529236,
0.46669235825538635,
0.4703429937362671,
-0.4925781488418579,
0.588365912437439,
0.23106054961681366,
-0.26263076066970825,
-0.019254984334111214,
-0.1419539451599121,
0.22842612862586975,
-0.035111915320158005,
0.23866954445838928,
-0.22689475119113922,
0.34181955456733704,
-0.9484677910804749,
0.29159900546073914,
-0.10970466583967209,
-0.5010458827018738,
-0.2912440001964569,
0.5870776176452637,
-0.2610304057598114,
-0.0015310473972931504,
0.6478275656700134,
0.08175446838140488,
-0.2737627327442169,
0.6375717520713806,
0.7213478684425354,
0.4704495668411255,
0.05189931020140648,
0.3959285318851471,
0.5397289395332336,
0.09930345416069031,
-0.282371461391449,
0.3649001121520996,
0.2957285940647125,
-0.6982923150062561,
-0.32540541887283325,
-0.451995313167572,
-0.37452006340026855,
-0.21033327281475067,
-0.7527520060539246,
0.03024781122803688,
-0.6282616257667542,
-0.085758738219738,
0.3548819124698639,
-0.3141603171825409,
-0.6295615434646606,
0.10545723885297775,
0.007596232928335667,
0.8004356026649475,
-0.8856266140937805,
0.5014366507530212,
1.0488498210906982,
-0.5516552329063416,
-0.24941228330135345,
0.20987004041671753,
-0.18136028945446014,
-0.6343136429786682,
0.6568381786346436,
-0.06350773572921753,
0.03074512630701065,
-0.18756695091724396,
-0.6661579608917236,
-0.4728628695011139,
0.8045622110366821,
0.38290759921073914,
-0.3206759989261627,
-0.15643979609012604,
0.09573882818222046,
0.6777727007865906,
-0.5338162183761597,
0.12831689417362213,
0.4824051856994629,
0.25769564509391785,
0.12159793078899384,
-0.6288281083106995,
0.33971622586250305,
-0.2999105453491211,
0.04139340668916702,
0.1066482812166214,
-0.12262798100709915,
0.7488928437232971,
-0.04722023010253906,
-0.46295690536499023,
-0.07793715596199036,
0.8447008728981018,
0.39159366488456726,
0.14257267117500305,
0.1442355066537857,
0.7627197504043579,
0.90867680311203,
-0.4861462116241455,
1.3887799978256226,
0.19625237584114075,
0.6883149743080139,
0.7518680691719055,
-0.44994086027145386,
1.3158001899719238,
0.5304811000823975,
-0.29845312237739563,
0.789715051651001,
0.6888542771339417,
0.34680435061454773,
0.39203163981437683,
0.6042072772979736,
0.17335499823093414,
-0.09450992941856384,
-0.16689445078372955,
-0.5144150853157043,
0.32808566093444824,
0.5391507744789124,
0.14481303095817566,
-0.3893362283706665,
-0.007189364638179541,
0.16723725199699402,
0.44367286562919617,
-0.26898324489593506,
0.6644992232322693,
-0.017796041443943977,
-0.2725694179534912,
0.7038148641586304,
0.017438052222132683,
0.6457459330558777,
-0.15971992909908295,
-0.14003022015094757,
-0.06700631976127625,
0.06956768035888672,
-0.5415366888046265,
-1.338117241859436,
0.6605948209762573,
-0.04263875633478165,
0.13476194441318512,
-0.3100741505622864,
0.35048070549964905,
-0.53250652551651,
-0.6090365052223206,
-0.05928685888648033,
0.5685700178146362,
0.21830599009990692,
0.02074682153761387,
-0.34123703837394714,
-0.26332736015319824,
-0.6323502063751221,
-0.17004162073135376,
-0.18992984294891357,
1.0353035926818848,
0.058578234165906906,
0.4421312212944031,
0.4137704372406006,
0.15951140224933624,
0.09403984993696213,
0.13209381699562073,
0.6953811645507812,
-0.9536161422729492,
-0.6374261379241943,
-0.9408092498779297,
0.34930533170700073,
-0.13691088557243347,
-0.48162269592285156,
0.7301719784736633,
0.7284174561500549,
0.7268873453140259,
-0.228916198015213,
0.4389244616031647,
0.035068802535533905,
0.1697724610567093,
-0.7379569411277771,
0.5386340618133545,
-0.4786679744720459,
-0.18759438395500183,
-0.3039098381996155,
-1.0196187496185303,
-0.8935152292251587,
0.826937735080719,
-0.3436242640018463,
-0.23059828579425812,
1.2445952892303467,
0.6077898144721985,
-0.2927209734916687,
0.3875313997268677,
0.2800261080265045,
0.1949848085641861,
0.06467884033918381,
0.9201449751853943,
1.1077241897583008,
-0.6385721564292908,
-0.0023653984535485506,
-0.030269907787442207,
-0.20253096520900726,
0.005312409717589617,
-0.785993754863739,
-0.9056727886199951,
-0.747821569442749,
-0.7162836790084839,
-0.46838560700416565,
0.08134718239307404,
1.0507115125656128,
0.6027953028678894,
-1.0260306596755981,
-0.3883352279663086,
0.060641054064035416,
0.041965093463659286,
-0.3161017894744873,
-0.22209158539772034,
0.7382618188858032,
-0.2354712188243866,
-0.8618353009223938,
-0.07697874307632446,
0.484723836183548,
-0.023393407464027405,
-0.029899442568421364,
-0.11298016458749771,
-0.5012155175209045,
0.18528099358081818,
0.6396770477294922,
-0.22812841832637787,
-0.6798282861709595,
-0.4066195487976074,
0.1266978532075882,
-0.23755766451358795,
0.18175117671489716,
1.1431466341018677,
-0.602525532245636,
-0.09858285635709763,
0.5198111534118652,
0.9144818782806396,
0.31506893038749695,
-0.1306358426809311,
0.22803321480751038,
-0.662804126739502,
0.16627047955989838,
0.2498408854007721,
0.7208281755447388,
0.15986377000808716,
-0.38521522283554077,
0.3761425316333771,
0.25138184428215027,
-0.15476126968860626,
-0.6266863942146301,
-0.059813424944877625,
-0.8367318511009216,
-0.16950233280658722,
1.1550869941711426,
-0.2566331923007965,
-0.5261602401733398,
-0.2163809835910797,
-0.1585845947265625,
0.15383923053741455,
-0.2728380858898163,
0.527972936630249,
0.9863712787628174,
-0.25858306884765625,
-0.0287620946764946,
-0.5994967222213745,
0.32149872183799744,
0.32198211550712585,
-1.162693738937378,
0.13088564574718475,
0.30775442719459534,
-0.1606006920337677,
0.2143876999616623,
0.2376561462879181,
-0.43294987082481384,
0.20445162057876587,
-0.1587243676185608,
-0.4941060543060303,
0.03502631559967995,
-0.34912604093551636,
-0.1837032288312912,
0.3256807327270508,
-0.6843452453613281,
-0.26439613103866577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10670v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10670v2
|
CoLoR-Filter: Conditional Loss Reduction Filtering for Targeted Language Model Pre-training
| 2024-06-15T15:28:02 | 2024-06-24T13:52:37 |
David Brandfonbrener, Hanlin Zhang, Andreas Kirsch, Jonathan Richard Schwarz, Sham Kakade
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Selecting high-quality data for pre-training is crucial in shaping the
downstream task performance of language models. A major challenge lies in
identifying this optimal subset, a problem generally considered intractable,
thus necessitating scalable and effective heuristics. In this work, we propose
a data selection method, CoLoR-Filter (Conditional Loss Reduction Filtering),
which leverages an empirical Bayes-inspired approach to derive a simple and
computationally efficient selection criterion based on the relative loss values
of two auxiliary models.
In addition to the modeling rationale, we evaluate CoLoR-Filter empirically
on two language modeling tasks: (1) selecting data from C4 for domain
adaptation to evaluation on Books and (2) selecting data from C4 for a suite of
downstream multiple-choice question answering tasks. We demonstrate favorable
scaling both as we subselect more aggressively and using small auxiliary models
to select data for large target models. As one headline result, CoLoR-Filter
data selected using a pair of 150m parameter auxiliary models can train a 1.2b
parameter target model to match a 1.2b parameter model trained on 25b randomly
selected tokens with 25x less data for Books and 11x less data for the
downstream tasks.
Code: https://github.com/davidbrandfonbrener/color-filter-olmo
Filtered data:
https://huggingface.co/datasets/davidbrandfonbrener/color-filtered-c4
|
[
-0.7309625744819641,
-0.3755401074886322,
0.5765715837478638,
0.002698729280382395,
-0.33460643887519836,
-0.26336604356765747,
-0.38626134395599365,
-0.1741008162498474,
-0.19574961066246033,
0.6357712149620056,
-1.0046195983886719,
-0.5697205662727356,
-0.3433997631072998,
0.062043916434049606,
-0.46373239159584045,
0.9154342412948608,
0.11982186138629913,
0.18136727809906006,
-0.053655873984098434,
-0.2438848465681076,
-0.564319372177124,
-0.18442538380622864,
-1.0041046142578125,
-0.24059095978736877,
0.6366735696792603,
0.3193863034248352,
0.2984987199306488,
0.3775431215763092,
0.4417666792869568,
0.2942447066307068,
0.007916009053587914,
-0.3023580312728882,
-0.736606776714325,
-0.12620258331298828,
-0.25679856538772583,
-0.7932041883468628,
0.040229443460702896,
0.0957568809390068,
0.5609647631645203,
0.5692203640937805,
-0.006254046224057674,
0.32200056314468384,
-0.012029146775603294,
0.7055231928825378,
-0.9752321243286133,
0.18997469544410706,
-0.7762284278869629,
0.18008574843406677,
-0.26035574078559875,
-0.12506291270256042,
-0.32098501920700073,
-0.23246829211711884,
-0.10886748880147934,
-0.48481741547584534,
0.22535757720470428,
0.33815377950668335,
0.9370282888412476,
0.36682379245758057,
-0.39833950996398926,
0.20626254379749298,
-0.7106050252914429,
0.8638044595718384,
-0.6465276479721069,
0.6593427062034607,
0.7805231213569641,
0.3653483986854553,
0.2515546679496765,
-0.6336958408355713,
-0.7667001485824585,
-0.18552803993225098,
-0.17519737780094147,
0.3838132321834564,
-0.29202622175216675,
0.20839515328407288,
0.34127306938171387,
0.28679102659225464,
-0.721963107585907,
0.04949481412768364,
-0.6499565243721008,
-0.4064001441001892,
0.32171663641929626,
-0.13576585054397583,
0.25116094946861267,
0.1221851110458374,
0.10493896901607513,
-0.1441754698753357,
-0.6456704139709473,
-0.0750177651643753,
0.6773775815963745,
0.31542447209358215,
0.0323697030544281,
0.37260204553604126,
-0.43118375539779663,
0.7791113257408142,
-0.1906868815422058,
-0.24783730506896973,
-0.1666473001241684,
-0.5576041340827942,
-0.14466315507888794,
-0.2824839949607849,
0.494035542011261,
0.19384175539016724,
0.27956098318099976,
0.054670125246047974,
-0.23232075572013855,
0.16365860402584076,
0.20832869410514832,
-1.1513044834136963,
-0.6241523027420044,
-0.05673534423112869,
-0.7006103992462158,
0.12754599750041962,
-0.16754624247550964,
-0.5101931691169739,
-0.06794373691082001,
-0.6186221241950989,
0.5178347229957581,
-0.17813579738140106,
-0.09121854603290558,
-0.0020203925669193268,
-0.16714513301849365,
0.017749007791280746,
0.08469527214765549,
-0.6465554237365723,
0.553635835647583,
0.19748499989509583,
0.6095086932182312,
-0.13420778512954712,
0.10835631191730499,
-0.6175343990325928,
-0.11941597610712051,
-0.22036340832710266,
0.627325177192688,
-0.4436315596103668,
-0.24503526091575623,
-0.07375875115394592,
-0.0002542704460211098,
-0.06411127746105194,
-0.252243310213089,
0.5799525380134583,
-0.9637883305549622,
0.11956179141998291,
-0.2576739490032196,
-0.33120179176330566,
-0.2512633800506592,
0.07567216455936432,
-0.7924497723579407,
0.7544525861740112,
0.28856611251831055,
-0.7297254800796509,
0.51991206407547,
-0.1530318558216095,
-0.37128451466560364,
0.10287020355463028,
-0.03768584877252579,
-0.4283311367034912,
-0.13904865086078644,
0.23993425071239471,
0.17853206396102905,
-0.5183717012405396,
-0.17994169890880585,
-0.7363775968551636,
-0.4615911543369293,
-0.26591020822525024,
-0.2542974054813385,
0.6334074139595032,
0.47542470693588257,
-0.13993826508522034,
0.13363657891750336,
-0.8673000335693359,
0.15743836760520935,
0.13929088413715363,
-0.34778961539268494,
-0.37105733156204224,
0.21161262691020966,
0.08204787969589233,
0.19528064131736755,
-0.046186499297618866,
-0.7615965604782104,
-0.2529560923576355,
-0.16729386150836945,
0.2537795901298523,
0.4032069146633148,
-0.0774589404463768,
0.5498971343040466,
-0.3052830100059509,
0.8046125173568726,
-0.3550901412963867,
0.21410174667835236,
0.03240232914686203,
-0.30666735768318176,
-0.8402714729309082,
-0.6189974546432495,
0.4911719262599945,
0.5244800448417664,
-0.7969449758529663,
0.3775179982185364,
-0.14943379163742065,
-0.3452746570110321,
-0.35757333040237427,
0.07168517261743546,
0.30660027265548706,
0.6473413109779358,
0.46692776679992676,
-0.1537381112575531,
-0.5239828824996948,
-0.9977957010269165,
-0.14297403395175934,
-0.15747246146202087,
0.041391521692276,
0.2807437777519226,
0.2811002731323242,
-0.20578035712242126,
1.1396552324295044,
-0.9549497365951538,
-0.3644954264163971,
-0.342959463596344,
-0.06090257316827774,
0.18714001774787903,
0.4041162431240082,
0.6906476020812988,
-0.8984577059745789,
-0.5368285179138184,
-0.08567164838314056,
0.07745610177516937,
-0.46301108598709106,
0.10549688339233398,
-0.35300788283348083,
-0.033213935792446136,
0.8004834055900574,
-0.17400901019573212,
0.7118645906448364,
0.8089957237243652,
-0.18179306387901306,
0.359825074672699,
-0.25072938203811646,
0.2518974542617798,
-0.5854272842407227,
0.2610662877559662,
0.1752423346042633,
-0.3263172507286072,
-0.5823730230331421,
-0.43571043014526367,
0.3055954575538635,
-0.15129323303699493,
-0.1879572570323944,
1.0072152614593506,
-0.38344067335128784,
-0.010007541626691818,
-0.2975180745124817,
-0.177694171667099,
0.10641549527645111,
0.7486273050308228,
0.23305067420005798,
0.32081228494644165,
0.23795387148857117,
-0.708050549030304,
-0.004023760557174683,
0.2507537007331848,
-0.4280615448951721,
0.4110448360443115,
-0.36612871289253235,
-0.16649040579795837,
-0.20294106006622314,
0.19242000579833984,
-1.1647270917892456,
0.23222129046916962,
0.33112433552742004,
-0.1867186725139618,
0.263017475605011,
-0.6575312614440918,
-0.44071680307388306,
-0.4236179292201996,
-0.22646336257457733,
0.4622548222541809,
0.6053380966186523,
-0.45511603355407715,
0.33303970098495483,
0.1726638376712799,
-0.6960777640342712,
-0.15066243708133698,
-0.7146739959716797,
-0.3119608759880066,
-0.08133471012115479,
-0.25124242901802063,
0.6291296482086182,
-0.4944024682044983,
0.3345882296562195,
0.0672750324010849,
-0.21349969506263733,
-0.30117207765579224,
0.09887896478176117,
-0.09076980501413345,
0.2761159837245941,
-0.08708100020885468,
0.19120121002197266,
0.2726306617259979,
0.06485919654369354,
-0.012553716078400612,
-0.09622904658317566,
0.5227435231208801,
0.3631507456302643,
-0.48146334290504456,
-0.2496429979801178,
0.29027682542800903,
0.20361196994781494,
-0.5627970695495605,
0.7693281769752502,
0.6252534985542297,
-0.31756606698036194,
-0.5851724743843079,
-0.5883978009223938,
-0.3133215010166168,
-0.4818127751350403,
0.6668805480003357,
-0.29555922746658325,
-0.727924644947052,
0.39380893111228943,
0.400068461894989,
-0.20259013772010803,
0.29007095098495483,
0.21593864262104034,
-0.029483908787369728,
1.203373670578003,
0.6589952111244202,
-0.08408010751008987,
1.0443652868270874,
-0.1930294930934906,
0.4602526128292084,
-0.6586324572563171,
0.1557120382785797,
-0.6810114979743958,
-0.23572459816932678,
-0.5659394860267639,
-0.033888716250658035,
0.42072874307632446,
0.16159960627555847,
-0.28864970803260803,
0.05625072866678238,
-0.18537962436676025,
0.406710684299469,
0.8693906664848328,
0.3872515857219696,
0.013001647777855396,
0.13943734765052795,
0.021634617820382118,
0.08129645138978958,
-0.7544269561767578,
-0.13827252388000488,
1.0391123294830322,
0.17226055264472961,
0.48858746886253357,
-0.05821915343403816,
0.5269157290458679,
0.007555173244327307,
0.5591768622398376,
-0.6340360045433044,
0.6210533380508423,
-0.2855474054813385,
-0.6852402687072754,
-0.46519312262535095,
-0.7329005002975464,
-0.8452595472335815,
0.5317724347114563,
-0.46504610776901245,
-0.3204631209373474,
0.24019603431224823,
0.5777029395103455,
-0.383131206035614,
0.10134104639291763,
-0.6394478678703308,
1.080180048942566,
-0.19188666343688965,
-0.13194677233695984,
-0.39191752672195435,
-0.36325639486312866,
0.2644476890563965,
-0.2585632801055908,
0.24522729218006134,
-0.1647760570049286,
0.12333333492279053,
0.7997039556503296,
-0.5066670179367065,
0.624376654624939,
-0.27767008543014526,
0.38815733790397644,
0.2708952724933624,
-0.036921966820955276,
0.3429919183254242,
-0.19267669320106506,
-0.08540594577789307,
-0.01011413149535656,
0.08255916833877563,
-0.34807854890823364,
-0.46530023217201233,
0.35456976294517517,
-0.4196546673774719,
-0.35727232694625854,
-0.13207070529460907,
-0.2180750072002411,
-0.42869073152542114,
0.3978325128555298,
0.35172122716903687,
0.4765934348106384,
0.07454868406057358,
0.20534786581993103,
0.22708483040332794,
-0.21611030399799347,
0.4109179377555847,
0.6481842398643494,
0.08832306414842606,
-0.5945864319801331,
1.0009701251983643,
0.1607089638710022,
0.24052932858467102,
0.28778403997421265,
0.344965398311615,
-0.3439410328865051,
-1.325036883354187,
-0.0631645917892456,
0.45705118775367737,
-0.8148906826972961,
-0.22522783279418945,
-0.4818297326564789,
-0.1366000473499298,
-0.2407761514186859,
0.13735458254814148,
-0.09022288769483566,
-0.09572595357894897,
-0.46162110567092896,
0.04191048815846443,
0.15764120221138,
0.21831083297729492,
0.04172207787632942,
0.6226781010627747,
-0.7857810258865356,
0.5146001577377319,
0.426158607006073,
0.46545666456222534,
-0.26313966512680054,
-0.7302747964859009,
-0.3164343535900116,
0.033331047743558884,
-0.05145091935992241,
-0.8077716827392578,
0.5804330706596375,
0.3734617829322815,
0.6555268168449402,
0.2217855453491211,
0.2878616154193878,
0.709418773651123,
-0.6938237547874451,
0.1304691880941391,
0.13913719356060028,
-0.8174982070922852,
0.6129725575447083,
-0.17571623623371124,
0.48541706800460815,
1.02730131149292,
0.47724515199661255,
-0.2853764593601227,
-0.172337144613266,
-0.2995026707649231,
-0.8427034616470337,
1.270453929901123,
0.39575856924057007,
-0.11389417946338654,
0.12084487825632095,
0.38282454013824463,
-0.09977631270885468,
0.4451482892036438,
-0.992749810218811,
-0.32106930017471313,
-0.00307167018763721,
-0.5174877047538757,
-0.36643463373184204,
-0.36403220891952515,
0.1694827675819397,
-0.2357008010149002,
0.735431969165802,
-0.19455479085445404,
0.02351776696741581,
-0.018413346260786057,
-0.33665019273757935,
-0.06676565110683441,
0.05665503069758415,
0.2871217727661133,
0.3647755980491638,
-0.3698933720588684,
-0.3492831289768219,
-0.030573438853025436,
-0.4141457676887512,
-0.2016771137714386,
0.3957590162754059,
-0.25340282917022705,
-0.23382683098316193,
0.4334394037723541,
0.9774761199951172,
0.09020837396383286,
-0.5997666716575623,
0.5894538164138794,
-0.200535386800766,
-0.03705611079931259,
-0.04412250593304634,
0.18997378647327423,
-0.10833364725112915,
-0.001855085021816194,
0.030690595507621765,
0.06458954513072968,
0.4552310109138489,
-0.5826472043991089,
0.05185074731707573,
0.4710245132446289,
-0.15430089831352234,
-0.3225988745689392,
0.5005777478218079,
0.25847887992858887,
-0.05590202659368515,
0.6442877650260925,
-0.2783864140510559,
-0.6866050958633423,
0.6700831651687622,
0.3133818209171295,
0.6818224191665649,
-0.23415181040763855,
0.14013075828552246,
0.6215759515762329,
0.2563764154911041,
-0.10351800918579102,
0.4156094491481781,
-0.3916165232658386,
-0.7753875851631165,
-0.4713777005672455,
-0.7926191091537476,
-0.34200841188430786,
0.25119638442993164,
-0.6784327626228333,
0.4048803746700287,
-0.2775622606277466,
-0.2977559268474579,
-0.11461968719959259,
-0.0409744456410408,
-0.9291181564331055,
0.7363311052322388,
0.30777400732040405,
0.6960440874099731,
-0.8389005661010742,
0.7411003708839417,
0.533257007598877,
-0.20374362170696259,
-0.6535810232162476,
-0.015438610687851906,
-0.2451363056898117,
-0.4826762080192566,
0.9804681539535522,
-0.018564503639936447,
-0.007277192082256079,
0.16253861784934998,
-0.1447335034608841,
-1.100648045539856,
0.7926744222640991,
0.6390244364738464,
-0.7255855202674866,
0.14809897541999817,
-0.12530657649040222,
0.331550657749176,
-0.20563459396362305,
0.43668049573898315,
0.7189242839813232,
0.46726569533348083,
0.17516735196113586,
-0.8049759864807129,
-0.1573992520570755,
-0.00428003678098321,
0.07244754582643509,
0.33697766065597534,
-0.4510425627231598,
0.7754462957382202,
0.07927018404006958,
-0.25856679677963257,
-0.05757666751742363,
0.32446974515914917,
0.1682710349559784,
0.191776305437088,
0.9034754037857056,
0.36551159620285034,
0.3897227346897125,
-0.011495862156152725,
1.170141577720642,
-0.12385185062885284,
0.2880658507347107,
0.9933453798294067,
-0.23841316998004913,
0.8362606763839722,
0.09573621302843094,
-0.3634757995605469,
0.017789527773857117,
0.8267894983291626,
0.11714927107095718,
1.0651891231536865,
0.3185215890407562,
-0.07985266298055649,
-0.2612602412700653,
0.25745919346809387,
0.08407242596149445,
0.30429115891456604,
0.08957263082265854,
-0.045453041791915894,
0.041363589465618134,
0.13407552242279053,
-0.10852160304784775,
-0.20424619317054749,
-0.5122008919715881,
0.5988868474960327,
-0.02657262049615383,
-0.8306981921195984,
0.4584433436393738,
0.10185104608535767,
0.446938693523407,
-0.8245182037353516,
0.04914022237062454,
-0.3147619366645813,
0.19020691514015198,
-0.03682456165552139,
-0.3238396644592285,
0.19095000624656677,
-0.19594445824623108,
-0.286662757396698,
-0.2563459575176239,
0.6519962549209595,
-0.843725323677063,
-0.4788942337036133,
0.4499565660953522,
0.05951101705431938,
-0.24854525923728943,
-0.49048352241516113,
-0.6565312743186951,
0.2116226702928543,
0.3069291114807129,
-0.3958992063999176,
0.15011753141880035,
-0.06795196980237961,
-0.1615721881389618,
0.6633967161178589,
0.8286415338516235,
0.5719536542892456,
0.04646611958742142,
0.2348213940858841,
0.7045980095863342,
-0.5900444984436035,
-0.8472030758857727,
-0.44030076265335083,
0.4478550851345062,
-0.13474762439727783,
-0.14401480555534363,
0.3899635970592499,
0.3073814809322357,
0.970267653465271,
-0.1402645856142044,
0.7808088064193726,
0.2400873452425003,
0.6503371000289917,
-0.7497655153274536,
0.7647377848625183,
-0.7646173238754272,
0.19774559140205383,
-0.10971425473690033,
-1.1502552032470703,
-0.24406711757183075,
0.5223084092140198,
-0.4091816842556,
0.5741065144538879,
0.8171475529670715,
0.8695311546325684,
-0.10978396236896515,
-0.2488764077425003,
0.4186739921569824,
0.06849291175603867,
0.2633093297481537,
0.17723651230335236,
0.5295370817184448,
-0.3362239599227905,
0.8734979629516602,
-0.44216784834861755,
-0.22063639760017395,
-0.251147985458374,
-0.8629291653633118,
-0.9322710037231445,
-0.5523895025253296,
-0.6928091645240784,
0.3399380147457123,
-0.06895679235458374,
0.40273457765579224,
1.245262861251831,
-1.0217533111572266,
-0.046073466539382935,
-0.11911538988351822,
0.09995119273662567,
0.16009749472141266,
-0.09661660343408585,
0.314747154712677,
-0.34581539034843445,
-0.7775126695632935,
0.3449728488922119,
0.0638064295053482,
0.014916735701262951,
0.21486243605613708,
-0.06190723925828934,
-0.11628685146570206,
0.09045233577489853,
0.595237672328949,
0.3146577775478363,
-0.4368011951446533,
-0.12168900668621063,
-0.4316996932029724,
0.13492581248283386,
-0.2448287010192871,
0.7441989779472351,
-0.8210604786872864,
0.39757347106933594,
0.5746899843215942,
0.6809080243110657,
0.7185801863670349,
-0.13927318155765533,
0.45201367139816284,
-0.6439882516860962,
0.11903216689825058,
0.44326096773147583,
0.741589367389679,
0.19669388234615326,
-0.054432500153779984,
0.4729231894016266,
0.1586461365222931,
-0.4019261300563812,
-0.8662980794906616,
0.15715603530406952,
-0.7679510712623596,
-0.4523274302482605,
1.1651017665863037,
-0.02041003480553627,
-0.02060299552977085,
0.01660475693643093,
-0.44432395696640015,
0.07364023476839066,
-0.20878426730632782,
0.049285512417554855,
0.6798086762428284,
0.01814129948616028,
-0.5102494955062866,
-0.6236278414726257,
0.6401103138923645,
0.638604998588562,
-0.8200697898864746,
-0.2676851153373718,
0.7251478433609009,
0.3455063998699188,
-0.1907556802034378,
0.6580332517623901,
0.29949843883514404,
0.2991040349006653,
-0.32738572359085083,
0.2796687185764313,
0.0027773857582360506,
-0.22358401119709015,
-0.31194940209388733,
0.10636415332555771,
0.0792241096496582,
-0.3061307668685913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10671v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10671v2
|
Augmenting Biomedical Named Entity Recognition with General-domain Resources
| 2024-06-15T15:28:02 | 2024-06-18T19:33:39 |
Yu Yin, Hyunjae Kim, Xiao Xiao, Chih Hsuan Wei, Jaewoo Kang, Zhiyong Lu, Hua Xu, Meng Fang, Qingyu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Training a neural network-based biomedical named entity recognition (BioNER)
model usually requires extensive and costly human annotations. While several
studies have employed multi-task learning with multiple BioNER datasets to
reduce human effort, this approach does not consistently yield performance
improvements and may introduce label ambiguity in different biomedical corpora.
We aim to tackle those challenges through transfer learning from easily
accessible resources with fewer concept overlaps with biomedical datasets. In
this paper, we proposed GERBERA, a simple-yet-effective method that utilized a
general-domain NER dataset for training. Specifically, we performed multi-task
learning to train a pre-trained biomedical language model with both the target
BioNER dataset and the general-domain dataset. Subsequently, we fine-tuned the
models specifically for the BioNER dataset. We systematically evaluated GERBERA
on five datasets of eight entity types, collectively consisting of 81,410
instances. Despite using fewer biomedical resources, our models demonstrated
superior performance compared to baseline models trained with multiple
additional BioNER datasets. Specifically, our models consistently outperformed
the baselines in six out of eight entity types, achieving an average
improvement of 0.9% over the best baseline performance across eight biomedical
entity types sourced from five different corpora. Our method was especially
effective in amplifying performance on BioNER datasets characterized by limited
data, with a 4.7% improvement in F1 scores on the JNLPBA-RNA dataset.
|
[
-0.12172316014766693,
-0.5961390137672424,
0.5895364284515381,
-0.14369040727615356,
-0.4348897933959961,
0.2660340666770935,
-0.058096107095479965,
-1.069709062576294,
0.3859198987483978,
0.19574788212776184,
-0.2152797430753708,
-0.5393496155738831,
-0.8408589363098145,
0.318265825510025,
0.0689219981431961,
1.2108041048049927,
0.1280234158039093,
0.3558521866798401,
-0.25726616382598877,
-0.5396596789360046,
-0.4625781178474426,
-0.6436371803283691,
-0.866073489189148,
-0.5716691017150879,
0.6983996033668518,
0.0347856804728508,
0.4133791923522949,
0.5584158897399902,
0.6063843965530396,
0.22123582661151886,
-0.13437263667583466,
0.48869702219963074,
-0.24010682106018066,
-0.13249453902244568,
-0.5138247609138489,
0.15724393725395203,
-0.5646018981933594,
-0.3628520369529724,
0.4047967195510864,
0.8963890671730042,
0.09103013575077057,
0.24652759730815887,
0.059119220823049545,
0.4576067328453064,
-0.5921928286552429,
0.29668954014778137,
-0.5700411200523376,
-0.04616022855043411,
-0.41177859902381897,
-0.18487632274627686,
-0.31901654601097107,
-0.010250477120280266,
0.5127684473991394,
-0.8510115742683411,
0.4368063807487488,
0.06835959106683731,
1.1762300729751587,
0.10268797725439072,
-0.45360124111175537,
-0.30412760376930237,
-0.5836725234985352,
0.6366897821426392,
-0.22669579088687897,
0.4585013687610626,
0.17284917831420898,
0.007688087411224842,
-0.1337002068758011,
-0.6144771575927734,
-0.2990659475326538,
-0.032953571528196335,
-0.1845744550228119,
-0.13158318400382996,
-0.6071528792381287,
0.061018206179142,
0.0893130898475647,
-0.1295170783996582,
-0.5891738533973694,
0.04974902421236038,
-0.5984941124916077,
-0.2719876766204834,
0.20068316161632538,
-0.11868563294410706,
0.47241875529289246,
-0.16929085552692413,
-0.2896222472190857,
-0.19269149005413055,
-0.7040875554084778,
0.10830896347761154,
-0.11791432648897171,
0.4618131220340729,
0.2434556484222412,
0.24980847537517548,
0.059099022299051285,
0.6333596110343933,
0.20231030881404877,
0.1892407238483429,
0.732429563999176,
-0.3166210949420929,
-0.437276154756546,
-0.03759105131030083,
0.5850178599357605,
0.07125181704759598,
0.037876978516578674,
-0.7488375902175903,
0.17553560435771942,
0.04864589124917984,
0.5380083322525024,
-1.1059892177581787,
-0.3892391622066498,
0.2596675157546997,
-0.2453751564025879,
-0.004530280362814665,
-0.24245278537273407,
-0.765263557434082,
-0.3745952248573303,
-0.4798850417137146,
0.37642571330070496,
-0.7864230871200562,
0.17048731446266174,
0.0457620769739151,
-0.07080404460430145,
-0.006699726451188326,
0.386487752199173,
-0.963819146156311,
0.336252897977829,
0.39161601662635803,
0.9330898523330688,
-0.260183185338974,
-0.015932783484458923,
-0.6900701522827148,
0.4901265501976013,
-0.08698203414678574,
0.803165853023529,
-0.5310336947441101,
-0.6492576003074646,
-0.5110399723052979,
0.3684196472167969,
-0.2800670564174652,
-0.8221092224121094,
0.22268542647361755,
-0.5951323509216309,
-0.23337674140930176,
-0.24434056878089905,
-0.5626357793807983,
-0.4034461975097656,
-0.16367658972740173,
-0.770776093006134,
0.4641950726509094,
0.0656125396490097,
-0.4601001739501953,
0.5873699188232422,
-0.7511118054389954,
-0.8785882592201233,
0.3656347393989563,
-0.44725319743156433,
-0.5516600608825684,
-0.02334609068930149,
0.35805943608283997,
0.6796653270721436,
-0.29828205704689026,
0.5532009601593018,
-0.2785896956920624,
-0.07064354419708252,
0.19951507449150085,
0.11051633954048157,
0.6588441133499146,
-0.1180422306060791,
-0.33705592155456543,
0.027381891384720802,
-0.8763120770454407,
0.23790016770362854,
0.06500160694122314,
-0.2968497574329376,
-0.6959336400032043,
-0.24503453075885773,
0.2140646129846573,
-0.023627687245607376,
-0.17448477447032928,
-0.6137979626655579,
0.15320219099521637,
-0.33314692974090576,
0.3928298354148865,
0.5826441645622253,
0.14441877603530884,
0.5983456373214722,
-0.16681474447250366,
0.368918240070343,
0.0786839947104454,
-0.047501903027296066,
0.5666874051094055,
-0.7766363024711609,
-0.3238511383533478,
-0.5450438261032104,
0.539120614528656,
0.5054094791412354,
-0.5770706534385681,
0.25245413184165955,
-0.479770302772522,
-0.46112754940986633,
-0.6489181518554688,
0.2237551510334015,
0.6547479629516602,
0.7677444219589233,
1.1144992113113403,
-0.5728562474250793,
-0.5243829488754272,
-0.9303478598594666,
0.05868992954492569,
0.10298069566488266,
-0.20451532304286957,
0.6345500946044922,
0.7078254818916321,
-0.6443504691123962,
0.8579841256141663,
-0.3644547760486603,
-0.4857020974159241,
0.06984619796276093,
0.4252675175666809,
0.20900078117847443,
0.6007568836212158,
0.5948440432548523,
-0.8615517020225525,
-0.3041309714317322,
0.47294947504997253,
-0.6819410920143127,
0.35602492094039917,
0.017473194748163223,
-0.2520892024040222,
0.00860126968473196,
0.02974923886358738,
-0.5763676762580872,
0.24240712821483612,
0.5113162398338318,
-0.22723403573036194,
0.35367563366889954,
-0.2929801940917969,
0.1210363358259201,
-1.0898761749267578,
0.6086069345474243,
0.19665010273456573,
-0.08502547442913055,
-0.8481995463371277,
-0.12458406388759613,
0.2371523380279541,
-0.09081578999757767,
-0.35389184951782227,
0.7849657535552979,
-0.842491865158081,
0.028707697987556458,
-0.08168182522058487,
-0.2983357906341553,
0.045869018882513046,
0.4972774386405945,
-0.021565129980444908,
0.874321699142456,
0.5014593005180359,
-0.8862124681472778,
0.09581919014453888,
0.5402584075927734,
-0.15270479023456573,
0.5824321508407593,
-0.8592653870582581,
0.5046798586845398,
-0.3237845301628113,
0.3006727695465088,
-0.3943420648574829,
-0.4014185965061188,
0.5219587683677673,
-0.30989107489585876,
0.5832092761993408,
-0.3208039402961731,
-0.13243894279003143,
-0.27211496233940125,
0.1540367305278778,
0.46146687865257263,
0.18582859635353088,
-0.5676318407058716,
0.995035707950592,
0.6675131320953369,
-0.2143593430519104,
-0.6159940361976624,
-0.6531925797462463,
0.007108940742909908,
-0.06578201800584793,
-0.34994372725486755,
1.0333367586135864,
0.02922184020280838,
0.34062859416007996,
0.32066166400909424,
-0.293209046125412,
-0.37872540950775146,
-0.08714181184768677,
0.4993942975997925,
0.673586368560791,
-0.1059999018907547,
0.43472835421562195,
0.033865928649902344,
-0.07070539891719818,
-0.1503824144601822,
-0.3339219391345978,
0.11076036840677261,
-0.10746493935585022,
-0.19919709861278534,
-0.15340861678123474,
0.13642647862434387,
0.18818403780460358,
-0.3553045094013214,
0.6892905235290527,
0.5901138782501221,
-0.6756474375724792,
-0.1026216447353363,
-0.25333115458488464,
-0.008308464661240578,
-0.4100128412246704,
0.6219790577888489,
-0.29649263620376587,
-0.9381335973739624,
0.2946638762950897,
-0.2410019338130951,
-0.1590259075164795,
0.363217830657959,
0.27132993936538696,
-0.041813746094703674,
0.545007586479187,
0.5338009595870972,
-0.26979073882102966,
0.15894396603107452,
-0.2801366448402405,
0.16049827635288239,
-1.0509001016616821,
-0.4304879903793335,
-0.4116414189338684,
-0.3702625036239624,
-0.1731100082397461,
-0.7872281670570374,
0.37233954668045044,
-0.049658436328172684,
-0.12801553308963776,
0.6207312345504761,
-0.6585792899131775,
0.5707032680511475,
0.49985989928245544,
0.5462811589241028,
0.012140721082687378,
0.1949343979358673,
-0.2137996405363083,
0.23159271478652954,
-0.4772389233112335,
-0.3165283799171448,
1.2455013990402222,
0.16451552510261536,
0.3959041237831116,
0.13884089887142181,
0.6647824048995972,
0.2221314013004303,
0.5739994645118713,
-0.625023603439331,
0.3193471431732178,
-0.5179694890975952,
-0.676797091960907,
-0.3260963261127472,
-0.5725485682487488,
-1.1010148525238037,
0.1781545728445053,
-0.39718398451805115,
-0.8519075512886047,
0.7005574107170105,
0.1824416071176529,
-0.8029289841651917,
0.24778032302856445,
-0.5697512030601501,
0.9132470488548279,
-0.2202969193458557,
-0.13189436495304108,
-0.07515373080968857,
-0.7195079922676086,
0.08639970421791077,
-0.28786587715148926,
0.13418824970722198,
-0.24147263169288635,
0.10792144387960434,
0.7821164727210999,
-0.05995117872953415,
0.808128833770752,
-0.16905488073825836,
0.2221243679523468,
-0.002186098136007786,
-0.34292730689048767,
0.550721287727356,
-0.06979858875274658,
0.2433004528284073,
0.4544907808303833,
-0.22351375222206116,
-0.3319321572780609,
-0.2866296172142029,
0.30188441276550293,
-0.7340138554573059,
-0.09967505931854248,
-0.3168041408061981,
-0.428458571434021,
-0.6701055765151978,
0.25025320053100586,
0.39180654287338257,
0.5438053607940674,
-0.42570117115974426,
0.2986708879470825,
0.7787314057350159,
-0.2072494477033615,
-0.07592469453811646,
0.3755374848842621,
0.14655064046382904,
-0.6608424782752991,
0.8853407502174377,
0.07473564893007278,
-0.053183503448963165,
0.5499667525291443,
-0.2789015471935272,
-0.27737128734588623,
-0.5838794112205505,
-0.675434947013855,
0.21080516278743744,
-0.6716972589492798,
-0.5137553215026855,
-1.0342867374420166,
-0.16029512882232666,
-0.34244129061698914,
-0.04419351741671562,
-0.010047562420368195,
-0.0022172972094267607,
-0.5889173150062561,
-0.08209552615880966,
0.37052640318870544,
0.4679794907569885,
0.06277582794427872,
0.2014857977628708,
-1.0354565382003784,
0.656570553779602,
0.3171268105506897,
0.1885162740945816,
-0.00021576807193923742,
-0.3896309733390808,
-0.36335864663124084,
-0.009358789771795273,
0.01724008470773697,
-1.0203700065612793,
0.18408629298210144,
0.6286603212356567,
0.6549203991889954,
0.23959365487098694,
-0.4418298602104187,
0.777468204498291,
-0.7232774496078491,
0.09193603694438934,
0.39301180839538574,
-0.7424923181533813,
0.3796542286872864,
-0.0744270458817482,
-0.032087456434965134,
0.6532131433486938,
0.6445173621177673,
-0.32321712374687195,
-0.06558603048324585,
-0.515487015247345,
-1.0254790782928467,
0.4321816563606262,
-0.009957797825336456,
0.07039199769496918,
-0.1422758400440216,
0.22684627771377563,
0.1460101455450058,
0.007624893914908171,
-0.3075023293495178,
-0.382008820772171,
0.1756199598312378,
-0.08354117721319199,
-0.08694133907556534,
0.0417926199734211,
-0.11689352989196777,
-0.3154557943344116,
0.9819129109382629,
-0.39160969853401184,
0.3488302230834961,
0.21755239367485046,
-0.33627960085868835,
0.08229060471057892,
0.4751448631286621,
0.26636889576911926,
0.4843805134296417,
-0.26677554845809937,
-0.0886058360338211,
0.33641695976257324,
-0.755990743637085,
0.3273019790649414,
0.6468008160591125,
-0.15365470945835114,
0.21262870728969574,
0.10713259130716324,
0.8327298164367676,
0.5057634115219116,
-0.5736976861953735,
0.22512473165988922,
0.17856444418430328,
-0.16251155734062195,
0.37282371520996094,
-0.010372347198426723,
0.3795525133609772,
0.34285563230514526,
0.3446705639362335,
0.46389636397361755,
0.3351387083530426,
-0.20709051191806793,
0.4196197986602783,
0.3649287223815918,
-0.09395749121904373,
-0.3589516282081604,
0.807192325592041,
0.17413726449012756,
0.253012090921402,
0.6392163038253784,
-0.29475632309913635,
-0.13947799801826477,
0.651701807975769,
0.6096889972686768,
0.9344778060913086,
-0.24788160622119904,
0.40388432145118713,
0.47642064094543457,
-0.13506653904914856,
0.013915575109422207,
0.03141096234321594,
0.05491871386766434,
-0.8668212890625,
-0.47989538311958313,
-0.7940813899040222,
-0.6271206140518188,
0.1656314581632614,
-0.7877366542816162,
-0.025918668136000633,
-0.5132132172584534,
-0.7532193660736084,
0.763173520565033,
-0.18829509615898132,
-1.144137978553772,
0.27755287289619446,
0.07910474389791489,
0.4746638238430023,
-0.7006163597106934,
0.9215946793556213,
1.078099012374878,
-0.6894639730453491,
-0.695269763469696,
-0.3132379353046417,
-0.0848870649933815,
-0.7928368449211121,
0.907715916633606,
0.237574964761734,
-0.19723598659038544,
0.03699280694127083,
-0.21942253410816193,
-0.8668373823165894,
1.1607791185379028,
0.41277647018432617,
-0.7620582580566406,
-0.4512193202972412,
-0.10622649639844894,
0.5270709991455078,
-0.2971096336841583,
-0.2200239598751068,
0.3178519308567047,
0.23691879212856293,
-0.07885927706956863,
-0.7625424861907959,
0.2531835734844208,
-0.48081013560295105,
0.19844838976860046,
0.15848395228385925,
-0.20967984199523926,
0.6293055415153503,
-0.5263506174087524,
-0.4790065288543701,
-0.0005879439413547516,
0.6120585203170776,
0.3757474720478058,
0.27470049262046814,
0.3567059338092804,
0.4399360120296478,
1.4439584016799927,
0.12329087406396866,
0.8692024350166321,
-0.17651912569999695,
0.2963126599788666,
1.258306622505188,
-0.46318021416664124,
0.6810813546180725,
0.3706052303314209,
-0.3355270326137543,
0.5176207423210144,
0.3600984513759613,
-0.38094261288642883,
0.5306465029716492,
0.3277966380119324,
-0.3053133487701416,
-0.1459248661994934,
-0.3751705586910248,
-0.4309161305427551,
0.19741570949554443,
0.3115348815917969,
-0.3772113621234894,
-0.1747134029865265,
0.3588036000728607,
0.08859121799468994,
-0.3820647895336151,
-0.15664801001548767,
0.6474562287330627,
0.09296220541000366,
-0.11862684786319733,
0.29001179337501526,
-0.06112171709537506,
0.7526198029518127,
-0.6892763376235962,
-0.05820505693554878,
0.12393666803836823,
0.1480470448732376,
-0.03081514872610569,
-0.28878965973854065,
0.020984919741749763,
0.1031753420829773,
-0.4202655553817749,
0.005746542476117611,
0.8394861221313477,
-0.4242580533027649,
-0.4908839464187622,
0.5595242381095886,
0.5223278403282166,
0.13771723210811615,
-0.06623482704162598,
-0.6113398671150208,
-0.3906145691871643,
-0.1813901960849762,
0.07960785925388336,
0.458248496055603,
0.35050079226493835,
0.10817103832960129,
0.4695751368999481,
0.8309751749038696,
0.2515823543071747,
-0.17535342276096344,
0.01026968564838171,
0.7991214394569397,
-0.5153684020042419,
-0.3276001811027527,
-0.6297937631607056,
0.07480581849813461,
-0.04990193992853165,
-0.32454952597618103,
0.2556093633174896,
0.49504849314689636,
0.890744686126709,
-0.41678717732429504,
0.8337222337722778,
-0.1008414626121521,
0.5923315286636353,
-0.548245370388031,
0.7971231937408447,
-0.41302934288978577,
-0.17967991530895233,
-0.21989639103412628,
-0.5038869976997375,
-0.40285781025886536,
0.5518025159835815,
-0.14756153523921967,
0.1808328479528427,
0.632489800453186,
0.5892317295074463,
-0.1813346892595291,
-0.08507313579320908,
0.21976055204868317,
-0.06580036133527756,
0.23274700343608856,
0.820432186126709,
0.2152949571609497,
-0.32068219780921936,
0.22886642813682556,
-0.21241030097007751,
-0.061999838799238205,
-0.18925930559635162,
-0.7603234648704529,
-0.7217569947242737,
-0.363241046667099,
-0.3949074447154999,
-0.2905636429786682,
0.5260003805160522,
1.0710408687591553,
1.0641664266586304,
-1.1967601776123047,
0.2631795108318329,
0.13610878586769104,
-0.4090467691421509,
-0.4198964834213257,
-0.11798334866762161,
0.6341449022293091,
-0.3690355718135834,
-0.6287676095962524,
0.5739709734916687,
0.18962541222572327,
0.274768590927124,
0.2962236702442169,
-0.010600819252431393,
-0.16400964558124542,
-0.19944344460964203,
0.5327752828598022,
0.5396550297737122,
-0.46771588921546936,
-0.36524006724357605,
0.03259148821234703,
-0.3140479624271393,
0.06075204536318779,
0.5726547241210938,
-0.7207369804382324,
0.3700786530971527,
-0.05322492867708206,
1.3655098676681519,
0.2901301383972168,
0.05403202399611473,
0.35096263885498047,
-0.8210024237632751,
-0.31706321239471436,
0.22370116412639618,
0.5043945908546448,
0.48819035291671753,
-0.5397817492485046,
0.7468870878219604,
0.4042261242866516,
-0.4534417390823364,
-0.3663819432258606,
-0.2852180600166321,
-1.0600382089614868,
-0.2707691788673401,
0.9434757232666016,
-0.026037566363811493,
-0.2383182793855667,
-0.22238412499427795,
0.13118544220924377,
0.34821251034736633,
-0.4419580399990082,
0.5845146775245667,
0.5282196402549744,
-0.1972304731607437,
0.523996114730835,
-0.6026661992073059,
0.4557526111602783,
0.2849803566932678,
-1.0931720733642578,
-0.121744304895401,
0.6114370226860046,
0.5546074509620667,
0.3714166283607483,
1.0165925025939941,
-0.005243179388344288,
0.37551864981651306,
-0.3062199056148529,
0.31293967366218567,
-0.17991244792938232,
-0.6981366276741028,
-0.3006232976913452,
0.0670430064201355,
-0.30568501353263855,
-0.3969403803348541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10660v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10660v1
|
DIEKAE: Difference Injection for Efficient Knowledge Augmentation and Editing of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-15T14:57:39 | 2024-06-15T14:57:39 |
Alessio Galatolo, Meriem Beloucif, Katie Winkle
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pretrained Language Models (PLMs) store extensive knowledge within their
weights, enabling them to recall vast amount of information. However, relying
on this parametric knowledge brings some limitations such as outdated
information or gaps in the training data. This work addresses these problems by
distinguish between two separate solutions: knowledge editing and knowledge
augmentation. We introduce Difference Injection for Efficient Knowledge
Augmentation and Editing (DIEK\AE), a new method that decouples knowledge
processing from the PLM (LLaMA2-7B, in particular) by adopting a series of
encoders. These encoders handle external knowledge and inject it into the PLM
layers, significantly reducing computational costs and improving performance of
the PLM. We propose a novel training technique for these encoders that does not
require back-propagation through the PLM, thus greatly reducing the memory and
time required to train them. Our findings demonstrate how our method is faster
and more efficient compared to multiple baselines in knowledge augmentation and
editing during both training and inference. We have released our code and data
at https://github.com/alessioGalatolo/DIEKAE.
|
[
-0.20562563836574554,
-0.764369785785675,
0.49084216356277466,
0.10850683599710464,
-0.36546969413757324,
0.2365063726902008,
-0.3705303966999054,
-0.4306508004665375,
0.12988747656345367,
0.6243584752082825,
-0.1716156005859375,
-0.6786691546440125,
-0.7950112223625183,
-0.13504596054553986,
-0.09006357192993164,
0.386905312538147,
-0.19758346676826477,
0.21012283861637115,
-0.27463117241859436,
-0.06346245855093002,
-0.4307114779949188,
-0.32836848497390747,
-0.6534938216209412,
-0.37567299604415894,
0.20707246661186218,
0.27154767513275146,
0.7441222071647644,
0.46300774812698364,
0.36918526887893677,
0.417366623878479,
-0.26511120796203613,
0.4125288426876068,
-0.2054559290409088,
-0.035332195460796356,
0.004922270309180021,
-0.6681202054023743,
-0.2941259741783142,
-0.2346133589744568,
0.5556383728981018,
0.6082556843757629,
-0.04005046933889389,
-0.19803370535373688,
-0.07698599994182587,
0.7488295435905457,
-0.9510850310325623,
0.17514188587665558,
-0.5131142139434814,
0.17878305912017822,
-0.30412521958351135,
0.10439606755971909,
-0.28362053632736206,
-0.38228824734687805,
-0.07629391551017761,
-0.9102369546890259,
-0.12291648983955383,
-0.36719921231269836,
0.5379383563995361,
0.4101754128932953,
-0.1766185164451599,
0.033335115760564804,
-0.63628751039505,
0.5839928984642029,
-1.1111464500427246,
0.6031277775764465,
0.2616029977798462,
0.376325398683548,
-0.24266417324543,
-0.5198330879211426,
-0.9515088200569153,
-0.047219399362802505,
0.11268556863069534,
0.2696622312068939,
0.06633546203374863,
0.3686214089393616,
0.23692463338375092,
0.31243300437927246,
-0.2652660310268402,
0.2984762489795685,
-0.16747182607650757,
-0.11053797602653503,
0.3943336606025696,
-0.22488150000572205,
0.4068983793258667,
0.048905860632658005,
-0.1572314202785492,
-0.09584653377532959,
-1.0223759412765503,
-0.30095499753952026,
0.5866168141365051,
-0.35131970047950745,
-0.0760883167386055,
0.6313916444778442,
-0.45264115929603577,
0.8345794081687927,
-0.005524338223040104,
-0.32106447219848633,
0.3403482139110565,
0.07976837456226349,
-0.31878790259361267,
0.08267540484666824,
0.6614483594894409,
0.3649020791053772,
0.29198238253593445,
-0.2610976994037628,
-0.010755388997495174,
-0.029779305681586266,
-0.18546578288078308,
-0.6681293845176697,
-0.10686670243740082,
-0.06212355196475983,
-0.28271055221557617,
-0.40694135427474976,
-0.092381551861763,
-0.7128491401672363,
-0.6158488392829895,
-0.3313888609409332,
0.6519556641578674,
-0.4902077913284302,
-0.20569850504398346,
0.44108128547668457,
-0.20684008300304413,
0.1350904107093811,
0.4223731458187103,
-0.7308671474456787,
0.16952018439769745,
0.5997253060340881,
0.7070797085762024,
-0.15177752077579498,
-0.3864535987377167,
-0.42993906140327454,
0.27159416675567627,
-0.44567185640335083,
0.8543658256530762,
-0.7942211031913757,
-0.23647306859493256,
0.02827848494052887,
-0.1628406047821045,
0.07123509794473648,
-0.8780802488327026,
0.023588677868247032,
-0.9386094808578491,
-0.032886676490306854,
-0.38763460516929626,
-0.791714608669281,
-0.2887878119945526,
-0.020142922177910805,
-0.623075544834137,
1.072468638420105,
0.19139908254146576,
-0.7448703050613403,
0.4052427411079407,
-0.8670876622200012,
-0.4647195339202881,
0.0037571541033685207,
0.0011104618897661567,
-0.1774844080209732,
-0.04449811205267906,
0.4870692789554596,
0.33898669481277466,
-0.26794686913490295,
0.2883857488632202,
-0.342319518327713,
-0.2506088614463806,
0.2980758249759674,
-0.20919513702392578,
0.6986030340194702,
0.13119927048683167,
-0.18876349925994873,
-0.012434659525752068,
-0.9868537187576294,
-0.3848561644554138,
-0.10582204163074493,
-0.6867257952690125,
-0.5800963640213013,
-0.044852420687675476,
-0.37638503313064575,
0.12797069549560547,
0.34538570046424866,
-0.7693085074424744,
0.37667346000671387,
-0.7133017778396606,
0.28552213311195374,
0.6496099233627319,
0.21477080881595612,
0.5954263806343079,
-0.3228418529033661,
0.4598690867424011,
0.611205518245697,
0.1530085951089859,
0.1126326322555542,
-0.2986961305141449,
-1.0079323053359985,
-0.15642432868480682,
0.5403149724006653,
0.7625855803489685,
-0.9549980163574219,
0.5001683235168457,
-0.10736081749200821,
-0.44959795475006104,
-0.7389942407608032,
0.3812825083732605,
0.0982436016201973,
0.5679055452346802,
0.5214762687683105,
-0.03158922865986824,
-0.7293137907981873,
-0.84808748960495,
-0.2961772382259369,
0.017329996451735497,
-0.18763694167137146,
-0.11706025898456573,
0.34595412015914917,
-0.08378646522760391,
0.8031188249588013,
-0.37150847911834717,
-0.026057079434394836,
-0.26698145270347595,
-0.13852135837078094,
0.04807810112833977,
0.726992666721344,
0.2586045563220978,
-0.45829907059669495,
-0.5661054253578186,
-0.0556279718875885,
-0.8752742409706116,
-0.35114234685897827,
-0.3118763267993927,
-0.3145788609981537,
0.13241474330425262,
0.5364543199539185,
-0.7777963876724243,
0.383666455745697,
0.4307982623577118,
-0.08052247017621994,
0.27879732847213745,
-0.293498158454895,
0.4490529000759125,
-1.182674527168274,
-0.07375083118677139,
-0.5493081212043762,
-0.2637237310409546,
-0.6795545816421509,
-0.2261229008436203,
0.1087108850479126,
-0.00543432729318738,
-0.6363798975944519,
0.5741170048713684,
-0.48555901646614075,
0.06466243416070938,
-0.10951792448759079,
0.24734491109848022,
0.03438307344913483,
0.41512805223464966,
0.08630331605672836,
0.8048825263977051,
0.6600680351257324,
-0.6263691186904907,
0.4570075571537018,
0.4204145073890686,
-0.8098489046096802,
0.27039045095443726,
-0.4153377115726471,
0.37303414940834045,
-0.19916971027851105,
0.14911909401416779,
-0.644380509853363,
-0.09270145744085312,
0.4562031030654907,
-0.05600198358297348,
0.16309604048728943,
-0.15870262682437897,
-0.6841999888420105,
-0.05672258883714676,
-0.36878740787506104,
0.21980220079421997,
0.8231847286224365,
-0.7380738258361816,
0.74598628282547,
0.41498252749443054,
-0.11815821379423141,
-0.7406350374221802,
-0.9317077398300171,
-0.010048593394458294,
-0.2845856845378876,
-0.7951529026031494,
0.48885229229927063,
-0.12123241275548935,
-0.379900187253952,
-0.11684169620275497,
-0.04605509713292122,
-0.19014810025691986,
0.031668927520513535,
-0.06152624264359474,
0.03440994769334793,
-0.13891147077083588,
0.287052184343338,
0.7941957712173462,
-0.23735372722148895,
-0.3183980882167816,
-0.3188280761241913,
0.4250742197036743,
0.3772304654121399,
-0.7233609557151794,
-0.4624359607696533,
0.2753916084766388,
0.4427958130836487,
-0.30422869324684143,
1.0457894802093506,
0.36013054847717285,
-0.3259514570236206,
-0.1874622404575348,
-1.0188926458358765,
0.024186084046959877,
-0.5047348737716675,
0.24130253493785858,
-0.4264262020587921,
-0.720711886882782,
0.635071337223053,
-0.37428387999534607,
0.08942846208810806,
0.21884198486804962,
0.47577932476997375,
0.17176470160484314,
0.7215962409973145,
0.3694645166397095,
0.14851699769496918,
0.5723100304603577,
-0.2760990560054779,
0.09807975590229034,
-0.7868784666061401,
-0.26945704221725464,
-0.07006534934043884,
-0.39391008019447327,
-0.028877055272459984,
-0.741531252861023,
0.2491052895784378,
0.6015164852142334,
0.012488805688917637,
0.1181483343243599,
-0.1035950630903244,
0.9302104711532593,
0.49823325872421265,
0.2648143768310547,
0.5850851535797119,
-0.17287090420722961,
-0.20901203155517578,
-0.08200028538703918,
-0.7179505228996277,
-0.31499388813972473,
1.1601483821868896,
0.1244431883096695,
0.7620054483413696,
0.05340980365872383,
0.7596809267997742,
0.19035159051418304,
0.16864052414894104,
-0.575794517993927,
0.7253867983818054,
-0.3034874200820923,
-0.25823551416397095,
-0.08764364570379257,
-0.2082914412021637,
-0.5425628423690796,
0.17885218560695648,
-0.17568619549274445,
-0.46130380034446716,
0.42280006408691406,
0.30136024951934814,
-0.32060980796813965,
0.6456553339958191,
-0.7893977761268616,
0.775000810623169,
0.011507369577884674,
-0.00572811858728528,
-0.390429824590683,
-0.5756949782371521,
0.16621381044387817,
-0.28556394577026367,
-0.011150152422487736,
0.009764331392943859,
-0.22059266269207,
1.016440987586975,
-0.7327055335044861,
0.7672184705734253,
-0.5315433144569397,
-0.1881137490272522,
0.39144158363342285,
0.07191649079322815,
0.7119355797767639,
0.1745758205652237,
-0.13963088393211365,
0.20701202750205994,
-0.14033350348472595,
-0.22906990349292755,
-0.8990421891212463,
0.4651913642883301,
-0.7705201506614685,
-0.48970088362693787,
0.08687198162078857,
-0.5939292907714844,
-0.3583783507347107,
0.043505944311618805,
0.09049131721258163,
0.4518570601940155,
-0.04307536408305168,
0.08566554635763168,
0.7575473189353943,
-0.58365398645401,
0.4488105773925781,
0.7988882064819336,
-0.05074121430516243,
-0.5014681220054626,
0.7235760688781738,
0.2653324007987976,
0.40121880173683167,
0.7942668199539185,
0.16234375536441803,
-0.2623927593231201,
-0.8361310958862305,
-0.35632142424583435,
0.32649901509284973,
-0.9546781778335571,
-0.3310604393482208,
-0.7356303930282593,
-0.08177579194307327,
-0.5305078029632568,
-0.2571241557598114,
-0.6004469394683838,
-0.6525498032569885,
-0.12820303440093994,
-0.010014230385422707,
0.44948622584342957,
0.5879091620445251,
-0.5827571749687195,
0.754810094833374,
-0.796674370765686,
0.4600406289100647,
0.38604500889778137,
0.34094861149787903,
-0.2721976339817047,
-0.5005728602409363,
-0.3947014808654785,
0.12762531638145447,
0.016143426299095154,
-1.0814846754074097,
0.14935383200645447,
0.22549377381801605,
0.49122875928878784,
0.3530391454696655,
0.015413489192724228,
0.7827469110488892,
-0.32451432943344116,
0.5489700436592102,
-0.01982167921960354,
-1.1319711208343506,
0.5341682434082031,
-0.029648205265402794,
0.5359667539596558,
0.593883216381073,
0.14022137224674225,
-0.6349399089813232,
-0.43254128098487854,
-0.3795468211174011,
-0.6362278461456299,
0.6689702272415161,
-0.0255296528339386,
-0.09052971005439758,
0.07898999005556107,
0.32744207978248596,
0.40516722202301025,
0.2606315016746521,
-0.36420056223869324,
-0.07370675355195999,
0.017125437036156654,
-0.45530983805656433,
0.24724388122558594,
-0.46382471919059753,
0.013568194583058357,
-0.18688726425170898,
0.9778661131858826,
0.18660001456737518,
0.1725177764892578,
0.10116545855998993,
-0.7294347286224365,
0.043811023235321045,
0.34611082077026367,
0.3613215684890747,
0.745606005191803,
0.08871939033269882,
0.2671259641647339,
0.711336076259613,
-0.42155203223228455,
0.18821239471435547,
0.23484013974666595,
-0.30532321333885193,
-0.008970791473984718,
0.3167634606361389,
0.9890029430389404,
0.31918516755104065,
-0.6838201284408569,
0.42311230301856995,
0.22907741367816925,
-0.15768711268901825,
-0.1269795447587967,
0.06625040620565414,
0.2136702537536621,
0.44208893179893494,
-0.1298876851797104,
0.11678862571716309,
-0.0932997539639473,
0.05190645530819893,
-0.11094506084918976,
0.039461322128772736,
0.24541674554347992,
-0.17704874277114868,
0.45281603932380676,
0.31306442618370056,
-0.27238261699676514,
0.46808451414108276,
0.03275200352072716,
-0.29460233449935913,
0.30105429887771606,
0.4787686765193939,
0.7056997418403625,
-0.4142041802406311,
0.3398236036300659,
0.05802608281373978,
0.0956425592303276,
-0.024026190862059593,
0.16113804280757904,
-0.10275548696517944,
-0.9555038213729858,
-0.9096988439559937,
-0.664664089679718,
-0.24620023369789124,
0.4983554482460022,
-0.18918956816196442,
0.41644546389579773,
-0.3703160583972931,
0.30354446172714233,
-0.15965405106544495,
-0.3291873037815094,
-0.5735336542129517,
-0.1130269393324852,
0.053544506430625916,
0.9420855045318604,
-0.8679907321929932,
0.8581393957138062,
0.7467237114906311,
-0.29765382409095764,
-0.5355167388916016,
-0.27181708812713623,
-0.2306196242570877,
-0.7235069870948792,
0.7284121513366699,
0.014590796083211899,
0.11760276556015015,
0.14522145688533783,
-0.29742398858070374,
-0.6607441306114197,
0.7341489791870117,
0.7261115908622742,
-0.782538652420044,
-0.1534145325422287,
0.4988645315170288,
0.30850425362586975,
-0.11424432694911957,
0.20132817327976227,
0.5793136358261108,
0.5995189547538757,
-0.2504943013191223,
-0.6430596709251404,
-0.07712545990943909,
-0.06950903683900833,
0.14318624138832092,
0.20557361841201782,
-0.43473437428474426,
0.34757789969444275,
0.11927494406700134,
-0.06152248755097389,
-0.2022598534822464,
0.6080679893493652,
0.018507488071918488,
-0.17034433782100677,
0.6545735001564026,
0.941143274307251,
0.5471416711807251,
0.17120319604873657,
0.580025851726532,
-0.32020166516304016,
0.018380267545580864,
1.1055492162704468,
-0.14404810965061188,
0.6676064133644104,
0.4098460376262665,
-0.3882658779621124,
0.3825664222240448,
0.523504376411438,
0.20112113654613495,
0.5641691088676453,
0.043916426599025726,
-0.6891847848892212,
-0.48695307970046997,
0.36433354020118713,
-0.47786179184913635,
0.4677281081676483,
0.12340684235095978,
-0.0920349583029747,
-0.37075504660606384,
0.47924014925956726,
0.3560202717781067,
-0.09843267500400543,
0.19942820072174072,
1.0611541271209717,
-0.058837585151195526,
-0.63956218957901,
0.5487980842590332,
0.08668826520442963,
0.5241804718971252,
-0.7962785363197327,
-0.23406222462654114,
-0.3880798816680908,
0.26586636900901794,
-0.026400089263916016,
-0.5659431219100952,
0.3386578857898712,
-0.02176732011139393,
0.02339065447449684,
-0.11352527886629105,
0.9142337441444397,
-0.7343903183937073,
-0.28994953632354736,
0.2796981632709503,
0.45434507727622986,
0.2301289588212967,
-0.10748280584812164,
-0.6473335027694702,
0.12155796587467194,
-0.014612932689487934,
-0.3853994309902191,
0.2781839072704315,
0.29072993993759155,
0.2277626395225525,
0.52740079164505,
0.6608827114105225,
0.3589533865451813,
0.3875245451927185,
0.29130643606185913,
0.9329869747161865,
-0.3210967183113098,
-0.4888869524002075,
-0.9414401650428772,
0.6721041798591614,
-0.0965394377708435,
-0.07031219452619553,
0.4609203040599823,
0.5834325551986694,
0.7581530809402466,
-0.3531672954559326,
1.016934871673584,
-0.1825389862060547,
0.5694047808647156,
-0.9239175319671631,
0.7932204008102417,
-0.1977875679731369,
0.4238799512386322,
-0.02778071165084839,
-0.9813445210456848,
-0.3620188236236572,
0.5574540495872498,
-0.5501840710639954,
-0.19719499349594116,
0.6675370931625366,
1.1170953512191772,
-0.10469210892915726,
-0.18295730650424957,
0.36171478033065796,
0.5051732063293457,
0.3071042597293854,
0.6369853615760803,
0.9387360215187073,
-0.43849724531173706,
0.4532313644886017,
-0.6102333068847656,
-0.1752210110425949,
0.11621101945638657,
-0.6649535894393921,
-1.0136359930038452,
-0.456981360912323,
-0.46817415952682495,
-0.06940751522779465,
0.4589512050151825,
0.7738360166549683,
0.5420075058937073,
-0.8493249416351318,
-0.007413174957036972,
-0.5632051229476929,
0.2795277237892151,
-0.07731306552886963,
-0.14436104893684387,
0.4022084176540375,
-0.3396420478820801,
-0.738974392414093,
0.69698166847229,
0.1909685730934143,
0.09911482781171799,
-0.16090679168701172,
-0.1935291439294815,
-0.44546744227409363,
0.005066994111984968,
0.4670456051826477,
0.0919102281332016,
-0.5033863186836243,
-0.17536811530590057,
-0.3675195276737213,
0.4533687233924866,
0.3199441730976105,
0.7170472741127014,
-1.0181922912597656,
0.7181985974311829,
0.8857684135437012,
1.020862340927124,
0.49903804063796997,
-0.10788822174072266,
0.5506864190101624,
-0.5731023550033569,
0.3654049038887024,
-0.0679398775100708,
0.1961519718170166,
0.45489948987960815,
-0.2203897386789322,
0.28250545263290405,
0.47906574606895447,
-0.3974646329879761,
-0.6251036524772644,
0.16269081830978394,
-0.8344914317131042,
-0.1722775101661682,
1.0869978666305542,
-0.31855064630508423,
-0.16779392957687378,
-0.14356425404548645,
-0.376706063747406,
0.6453731656074524,
-0.25223955512046814,
0.6269234418869019,
0.6534348726272583,
0.10569177567958832,
-0.18160586059093475,
-0.585232138633728,
0.4365665912628174,
0.4533098042011261,
-1.2769527435302734,
0.011156504973769188,
0.4346778392791748,
0.4557664394378662,
-0.22022321820259094,
0.5874735116958618,
-0.2347107231616974,
0.13575726747512817,
0.13280805945396423,
0.1374204158782959,
-0.42564520239830017,
-0.22868724167346954,
-0.15391719341278076,
-0.019294369965791702,
-0.0361318439245224,
-0.2489374727010727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15471v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15471v1
|
Improving Large Models with Small models: Lower Costs and Better Performance
| 2024-06-15T14:44:43 | 2024-06-15T14:44:43 |
Dong Chen, Shuo Zhang, Yueting Zhuang, Siliang Tang, Qidong Liu, Hua Wang, Mingliang Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Pretrained large models (PLMs), such as ChatGPT, have demonstrated remarkable
performance across diverse tasks. However, the significant computational
requirements of PLMs have discouraged most product teams from running or
fine-tuning them. In such cases, to harness the exceptional performance of
PLMs, one must rely on expensive APIs, thereby exacerbating the economic
burden. Despite the overall inferior performance of small models, in specific
distributions, they can achieve comparable or even superior results.
Consequently, some input can be processed exclusively by small models. On the
other hand, certain tasks can be broken down into multiple subtasks, some of
which can be completed without powerful capabilities. Under these
circumstances, small models can handle the simple subtasks, allowing large
models to focus on challenging subtasks, thus improving the performance. We
propose Data Shunt$^+$ (DS$^+$), a general paradigm for collaboration of small
and large models. DS$^+$ not only substantially reduces the cost associated
with querying large models but also effectively improves large models'
performance. For instance, ChatGPT achieves an accuracy of $94.43\%$ on Amazon
Product sentiment analysis, and DS$^+$ achieves an accuracy of $95.64\%$, while
the cost has been reduced to only $31.18\%$. Besides, experiments also prove
that the proposed collaborative-based paradigm can better inject specific task
knowledge into PLMs compared to fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.49885278940200806,
-0.48686930537223816,
0.6491801142692566,
0.11743060499429703,
-0.44977203011512756,
0.051607515662908554,
-0.2813186049461365,
-0.4755885899066925,
0.22621667385101318,
0.556392252445221,
-0.715089738368988,
-0.16205021739006042,
-0.4222741723060608,
-0.2746226191520691,
-0.015093381516635418,
1.0174756050109863,
0.21541564166545868,
0.23622192442417145,
-0.2508310377597809,
-0.11877474188804626,
-0.659529447555542,
-0.6852411031723022,
-0.9166024327278137,
-0.47317102551460266,
0.7944566607475281,
0.2867032587528229,
0.9032135605812073,
0.3667670488357544,
0.9684767723083496,
0.3450000286102295,
-0.18772144615650177,
0.5283527374267578,
-0.6571013331413269,
0.18988379836082458,
-0.3216753900051117,
-0.6520889401435852,
-0.7848471999168396,
0.12902899086475372,
0.2576213479042053,
0.859695315361023,
-0.22348958253860474,
0.056995686143636703,
0.4132739007472992,
1.005314588546753,
-0.5663212537765503,
0.45261305570602417,
-0.4774014949798584,
-0.16176633536815643,
-0.23343327641487122,
-0.07255527377128601,
-0.329518586397171,
-0.336160272359848,
0.2844392657279968,
-0.7572226524353027,
0.25094303488731384,
0.21359409391880035,
0.6375454664230347,
0.48782479763031006,
-0.022562969475984573,
-0.23922757804393768,
-0.9489682912826538,
0.9245417714118958,
-0.7332022190093994,
0.32704129815101624,
0.10234689712524414,
0.34772422909736633,
-0.16431470215320587,
-0.8816903233528137,
-0.21044331789016724,
-0.14601349830627441,
-0.10218772292137146,
0.2860598862171173,
-0.2454250603914261,
0.3826870620250702,
0.4957050383090973,
0.5042600035667419,
-0.38205453753471375,
0.09803244471549988,
-0.49236181378364563,
0.138573557138443,
0.805191159248352,
0.40337321162223816,
-0.039275091141462326,
0.02510499767959118,
-0.1086067259311676,
-0.08562368899583817,
-0.7789731621742249,
-0.03099955804646015,
0.19485308229923248,
0.563829779624939,
-0.10903823375701904,
0.4965210556983948,
-0.3503945767879486,
0.394514799118042,
0.11568139493465424,
0.06680811196565628,
0.24156588315963745,
-0.4470677375793457,
-0.32564568519592285,
-0.46537432074546814,
0.6129753589630127,
0.1751832216978073,
0.07557038962841034,
0.012635934166610241,
-0.1946249157190323,
0.1898496001958847,
0.3212813138961792,
-0.9306077361106873,
-0.7709629535675049,
0.17788349092006683,
-0.6388671398162842,
-0.28405848145484924,
-0.10142428427934647,
-0.6453615427017212,
-0.8006705045700073,
-0.7951207756996155,
0.6242021322250366,
-0.34013545513153076,
-0.25219646096229553,
0.02060576342046261,
-0.13157498836517334,
-0.0328063890337944,
0.6043263077735901,
-0.7080026865005493,
0.412837415933609,
0.99127596616745,
1.075783610343933,
-0.008934679441154003,
-0.028695303946733475,
-0.7558096051216125,
-0.0626298263669014,
-0.518050491809845,
0.7369162440299988,
-0.3033808767795563,
-0.5010349750518799,
-0.36955440044403076,
-0.14762112498283386,
-0.10386024415493011,
-0.8906619548797607,
0.45364952087402344,
-0.5259913206100464,
0.027300335466861725,
-0.7629072666168213,
-0.6751142740249634,
-0.10966665297746658,
0.23015449941158295,
-0.752444863319397,
0.745844841003418,
-0.13191767036914825,
-0.7924274206161499,
0.2674935758113861,
-1.0389866828918457,
-0.3193626403808594,
0.009911772795021534,
-0.18901892006397247,
-0.4854893982410431,
0.20681238174438477,
0.3242758512496948,
0.39110085368156433,
-0.5399229526519775,
0.004525916650891304,
-0.6754400134086609,
-0.31368210911750793,
-0.019324935972690582,
-0.10013634711503983,
0.6371655464172363,
0.2802615165710449,
-0.1285506933927536,
0.34624987840652466,
-0.3845314383506775,
0.0045652808621525764,
-0.0659959614276886,
-0.23714205622673035,
-0.4523364007472992,
0.17083296179771423,
-0.2085539698600769,
0.08599956333637238,
0.14660127460956573,
-0.38561978936195374,
0.26558399200439453,
-0.5606051087379456,
0.6950219869613647,
0.8115836977958679,
-0.004635808058083057,
0.79060298204422,
-0.6895739436149597,
0.5185606479644775,
0.0733376294374466,
0.3661350607872009,
0.029323022812604904,
-0.4775145947933197,
-0.8152331709861755,
-0.5620492100715637,
0.5571879744529724,
0.2554264962673187,
-0.9575855731964111,
0.09035585075616837,
-0.28939923644065857,
-0.6490752696990967,
-0.46184489130973816,
0.32066434621810913,
0.1647624671459198,
0.38414323329925537,
0.2345643937587738,
-0.6495154500007629,
-0.5778504610061646,
-0.9818244576454163,
0.05533752217888832,
-0.1203298419713974,
-0.46627119183540344,
0.5340319275856018,
0.402059406042099,
0.035359758883714676,
0.8892882466316223,
-0.6184812188148499,
-0.41770991683006287,
-0.36191368103027344,
0.23211166262626648,
0.28929609060287476,
0.6361116766929626,
0.45064276456832886,
-0.8662448525428772,
-0.6661547422409058,
-0.03533067926764488,
-0.3665600121021271,
0.029081128537654877,
0.18607382476329803,
-0.14143459498882294,
0.1373472958803177,
0.37621474266052246,
-1.0074907541275024,
0.27500760555267334,
0.546858012676239,
0.15193985402584076,
0.5631882548332214,
-0.22546084225177765,
-0.03694555535912514,
-0.9856992363929749,
0.052492655813694,
-0.16878677904605865,
-0.18875233829021454,
-0.29270175099372864,
-0.1943955272436142,
0.035373933613300323,
-0.3443686068058014,
-0.4299841821193695,
0.32247430086135864,
-0.3625626564025879,
-0.22527167201042175,
-0.27901387214660645,
0.075953409075737,
0.09988502413034439,
0.5393244028091431,
0.04857346788048744,
0.7119149565696716,
0.402866929769516,
-0.5966104865074158,
0.5228425860404968,
0.19424359500408173,
-0.18890513479709625,
0.7273653149604797,
-0.9865725636482239,
0.16899436712265015,
-0.13474896550178528,
0.4551509618759155,
-0.9079813957214355,
-0.2846066653728485,
0.15920336544513702,
-0.3562568426132202,
0.237269327044487,
-0.3475645184516907,
-0.6841657161712646,
-0.373012512922287,
-0.38616013526916504,
0.09919886291027069,
0.8660499453544617,
-0.7368007898330688,
0.6513951420783997,
0.37062209844589233,
-0.4046139419078827,
-0.07585082948207855,
-0.4276844561100006,
-0.20941998064517975,
-0.2639363408088684,
-0.9693998694419861,
0.2966381907463074,
-0.16076219081878662,
-0.24303041398525238,
-0.036569174379110336,
-0.14365814626216888,
-0.05123867094516754,
-0.16628089547157288,
0.328327476978302,
0.4555962085723877,
-0.29766085743904114,
0.47029757499694824,
-0.2049056738615036,
-0.2904427945613861,
-0.11179794371128082,
-0.3749236464500427,
0.6191806793212891,
-0.2636256814002991,
-0.41572052240371704,
-0.5192214250564575,
0.2557683289051056,
0.7529723644256592,
-0.4796704351902008,
0.7746855616569519,
0.46470287442207336,
-0.22198396921157837,
-0.46376675367355347,
-0.6069368124008179,
-0.525537371635437,
-0.5701102018356323,
0.30154547095298767,
-0.1717994213104248,
-0.7889649271965027,
0.4917718768119812,
-0.2577868402004242,
0.20048333704471588,
0.18451371788978577,
0.47648006677627563,
-0.48543164134025574,
1.359337568283081,
0.8700380325317383,
-0.31092801690101624,
0.567402184009552,
-0.24891969561576843,
0.32139673829078674,
-0.6797578930854797,
0.09441179037094116,
-0.5749545693397522,
-0.5775390863418579,
-0.5393152236938477,
-0.5727590322494507,
0.48770689964294434,
-0.09765330702066422,
-0.38688957691192627,
0.21939294040203094,
-0.5657373666763306,
0.4092206358909607,
0.9049590826034546,
0.34525734186172485,
0.34459877014160156,
-0.1450631469488144,
0.12642478942871094,
-0.24840036034584045,
-1.035631537437439,
-0.2562711834907532,
1.0461516380310059,
0.42241883277893066,
0.9970000386238098,
-0.053352490067481995,
0.6154600381851196,
0.18229302763938904,
0.3757120966911316,
-0.9955363273620605,
0.3948197364807129,
-0.5558590292930603,
-0.6285936832427979,
-0.1621001809835434,
-0.5328642725944519,
-0.8131166100502014,
0.31476929783821106,
0.028295351192355156,
-0.48025956749916077,
0.32267093658447266,
0.36173418164253235,
-0.7936525940895081,
0.2539413571357727,
-1.0223528146743774,
0.8800417184829712,
-0.23692484200000763,
-0.5648475885391235,
-0.483168363571167,
-0.387201726436615,
0.25126346945762634,
-0.09359180182218552,
0.1593693345785141,
-0.0527602918446064,
-0.007318214047700167,
0.8031257390975952,
-0.831277072429657,
1.04294753074646,
-0.29684433341026306,
0.19178283214569092,
0.31563735008239746,
-0.0691620334982872,
0.7791603207588196,
-0.024945510551333427,
0.013412064872682095,
-0.08980415761470795,
0.1458260864019394,
-0.5023784637451172,
-0.5958417654037476,
0.5799788236618042,
-0.6225970387458801,
-0.444278359413147,
-0.1618475466966629,
-0.7969470024108887,
-0.5900614261627197,
0.09593577682971954,
0.17801611125469208,
0.272721529006958,
0.1220160648226738,
0.6431806683540344,
0.792159378528595,
-0.14329756796360016,
0.2572360932826996,
0.43959957361221313,
-0.18237729370594025,
-0.3924155831336975,
0.6768890619277954,
0.2493354231119156,
0.3456774055957794,
0.03467445820569992,
0.21312512457370758,
-0.3017338514328003,
-0.5174334645271301,
0.03198273852467537,
0.294805109500885,
-0.31406068801879883,
-0.2500411868095398,
-0.45535922050476074,
-0.24372023344039917,
-0.24197077751159668,
-0.13421377539634705,
-0.9908986687660217,
-0.17091447114944458,
-0.14309319853782654,
0.16740824282169342,
0.1815306544303894,
0.39505892992019653,
-0.25550413131713867,
0.522810697555542,
-0.9438765645027161,
0.1900177001953125,
0.4902472198009491,
0.39077210426330566,
0.09862858802080154,
-0.43621551990509033,
-0.21498116850852966,
0.3018503487110138,
-0.5122404098510742,
-0.34958508610725403,
0.4438062310218811,
-0.10896530747413635,
0.43586280941963196,
0.25084272027015686,
0.31067538261413574,
0.8223930597305298,
-0.28794655203819275,
0.5811476707458496,
0.24276360869407654,
-0.8808132410049438,
0.48785600066185,
-0.7143949866294861,
0.1068076491355896,
0.45485782623291016,
0.20047485828399658,
-0.4671318233013153,
-0.03220209851861,
-0.833135187625885,
-0.7964131832122803,
0.8217540979385376,
0.30521056056022644,
0.07032313197851181,
0.5210363864898682,
0.09949134290218353,
0.01275987271219492,
0.47888925671577454,
-0.33040645718574524,
0.19069425761699677,
0.22055639326572418,
-0.13080966472625732,
-0.09985478222370148,
-0.06743833422660828,
-0.2631734609603882,
-0.34292301535606384,
0.8770288825035095,
-0.02972942404448986,
0.047437433153390884,
0.08101443201303482,
0.21777889132499695,
-0.09402592480182648,
0.03066403605043888,
0.14874117076396942,
0.5527939200401306,
-0.06073938310146332,
-0.08087043464183807,
0.0780523344874382,
-0.23681409657001495,
-0.27838432788848877,
0.14565110206604004,
-0.14252927899360657,
-0.030630676075816154,
0.036324966698884964,
0.6906765699386597,
0.1501641422510147,
-0.5646888017654419,
0.5401047468185425,
-0.0056326487101614475,
-0.22142189741134644,
-0.12801717221736908,
0.1892300248146057,
0.554290771484375,
0.705832302570343,
0.05019161477684975,
0.3370716869831085,
-0.03413619473576546,
-0.42027419805526733,
0.1179770827293396,
0.58953458070755,
-0.33599796891212463,
-0.2547937333583832,
0.5410477519035339,
0.48523297905921936,
-0.18273499608039856,
0.6188910007476807,
-0.045675355941057205,
-0.41186222434043884,
0.8113046288490295,
-0.004933950491249561,
0.5642101168632507,
-0.08441095799207687,
0.20374834537506104,
0.24731364846229553,
0.40016600489616394,
-0.5249808430671692,
0.10729609429836273,
0.0067661227658391,
-0.5882923603057861,
-0.5280266404151917,
-0.5534012913703918,
-0.851945161819458,
0.446624755859375,
-0.4820743799209595,
0.3696900010108948,
-0.6269736289978027,
-0.2291203737258911,
0.2611042559146881,
0.34213536977767944,
-0.776755154132843,
0.09392597526311874,
0.1133633404970169,
0.6758588552474976,
-0.6560757756233215,
0.8076844811439514,
0.7514155507087708,
-0.5808935761451721,
-0.9664984345436096,
-0.3820817172527313,
0.0825192853808403,
-0.42286375164985657,
0.5293181538581848,
0.005799310281872749,
0.21133379638195038,
-0.1287144273519516,
-0.5852606296539307,
-0.8733667731285095,
0.9595805406570435,
0.30992352962493896,
-0.9451735019683838,
-0.029804885387420654,
0.0727929025888443,
0.7557342648506165,
-0.24861229956150055,
-0.13462910056114197,
0.5471884608268738,
0.3346584737300873,
0.21951326727867126,
-1.256588339805603,
-0.09715086221694946,
-0.042693980038166046,
-0.038603927940130234,
0.2885200083255768,
-0.783174991607666,
1.2189419269561768,
-0.019180769100785255,
-0.07914099097251892,
0.2037726193666458,
0.31033411622047424,
0.3884217441082001,
0.43104833364486694,
0.5041432976722717,
0.3721913993358612,
0.9816978573799133,
-0.06728273630142212,
0.8943794965744019,
-0.010692321695387363,
0.5672060251235962,
1.4442123174667358,
-0.3729988932609558,
0.8923362493515015,
0.45576193928718567,
-0.5482567548751831,
0.046724896878004074,
0.6626217365264893,
-0.14134539663791656,
0.5685004591941833,
0.06590338051319122,
-0.2699311077594757,
-0.44204238057136536,
-0.023181434720754623,
-0.427656888961792,
0.17944708466529846,
0.34809377789497375,
-0.43059641122817993,
-0.2723363935947418,
0.027918042615056038,
-0.07923886924982071,
-0.20102910697460175,
-0.5004264712333679,
0.7550021409988403,
0.4303593933582306,
-0.5731734037399292,
0.2985232174396515,
-0.2565564215183258,
0.8011631369590759,
-0.6306086182594299,
0.2814697027206421,
-0.2715059518814087,
0.6631481051445007,
-0.24830830097198486,
-0.3210197389125824,
0.4099164605140686,
-0.20294727385044098,
-0.22240686416625977,
-0.20383711159229279,
1.020294427871704,
-0.2243276834487915,
-0.39931994676589966,
0.1890314817428589,
0.6455948948860168,
-0.06953024119138718,
-0.6410029530525208,
-0.6040766835212708,
0.08367675542831421,
-0.14694008231163025,
-0.2650565803050995,
0.34018993377685547,
0.23406599462032318,
0.03945162892341614,
0.6424500942230225,
0.8742589950561523,
0.22000528872013092,
-0.12597745656967163,
-0.01782241091132164,
1.1167011260986328,
-0.33409416675567627,
-0.8245365023612976,
-0.6690718531608582,
0.5478256940841675,
-0.35800057649612427,
0.11160989105701447,
0.6576490998268127,
0.5120119452476501,
0.8445032835006714,
-0.12110816687345505,
1.0703086853027344,
-0.019409026950597763,
1.0043374300003052,
-0.26707062125205994,
0.933875322341919,
-0.5687755346298218,
0.3679550588130951,
-0.30208584666252136,
-0.9912617802619934,
-0.20528019964694977,
0.5507524609565735,
-0.8689660429954529,
0.01309120561927557,
0.6172727942466736,
0.8099197149276733,
-0.2886433005332947,
0.38469475507736206,
0.3067137598991394,
0.16988393664360046,
0.44806110858917236,
0.5114957690238953,
0.9059706330299377,
-0.2526915967464447,
0.7394107580184937,
-0.6438416242599487,
-0.24512626230716705,
-0.21632938086986542,
-0.6824703812599182,
-0.8712568283081055,
-0.3075352907180786,
-0.3547687828540802,
-0.13667841255664825,
0.06257208436727524,
0.8617337346076965,
1.1673693656921387,
-0.6721634268760681,
-0.07015132904052734,
-0.2328839898109436,
-0.10979261994361877,
-0.2411976158618927,
-0.16993403434753418,
0.23641547560691833,
-0.6259783506393433,
-0.7422674298286438,
0.15105047821998596,
0.09308549016714096,
-0.18259987235069275,
-0.09430979937314987,
-0.07182986289262772,
0.3374762237071991,
0.20517152547836304,
0.7221801280975342,
0.2238864004611969,
-0.23329339921474457,
-0.27523893117904663,
-0.05796663835644722,
-0.044481225311756134,
0.07393217831850052,
0.8973892331123352,
-0.660075306892395,
0.1542881280183792,
0.6560187935829163,
0.8257604837417603,
0.7898633480072021,
0.23393741250038147,
0.5565887689590454,
-0.5780479311943054,
0.12438506633043289,
0.44906148314476013,
0.3446560204029083,
0.28889185190200806,
-0.13659043610095978,
0.6966235637664795,
0.38607075810432434,
-0.7463060021400452,
-0.7576766610145569,
0.21947835385799408,
-0.9404430985450745,
-0.25085464119911194,
0.9182726740837097,
-0.12365448474884033,
-0.15076273679733276,
-0.019360460340976715,
-0.586561918258667,
0.14697718620300293,
-0.3880618214607239,
0.9076894521713257,
0.7167368531227112,
-0.4636027216911316,
0.03795752674341202,
-0.6885948181152344,
0.5866164565086365,
0.7594546675682068,
-0.8809863328933716,
0.314088374376297,
0.6855782866477966,
0.3496949076652527,
0.21044579148292542,
0.6661564707756042,
-0.13962560892105103,
0.22358013689517975,
0.19720494747161865,
-0.13057030737400055,
-0.1651378720998764,
-0.25163108110427856,
-0.04092904180288315,
0.39183399081230164,
0.09474415332078934,
-0.44303321838378906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10630v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10630v1
|
Emerging Safety Attack and Defense in Federated Instruction Tuning of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-15T13:24:22 | 2024-06-15T13:24:22 |
Rui Ye, Jingyi Chai, Xiangrui Liu, Yaodong Yang, Yanfeng Wang, Siheng Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.MA
|
Federated learning (FL) enables multiple parties to collaboratively fine-tune
an large language model (LLM) without the need of direct data sharing. Ideally,
by training on decentralized data that is aligned with human preferences and
safety principles, federated instruction tuning can result in an LLM that could
behave in a helpful and safe manner. In this paper, we for the first time
reveal the vulnerability of safety alignment in FedIT by proposing a simple,
stealthy, yet effective safety attack method. Specifically, the malicious
clients could automatically generate attack data without involving manual
efforts and attack the FedIT system by training their local LLMs on such attack
data. Unfortunately, this proposed safety attack not only can compromise the
safety alignment of LLM trained via FedIT, but also can not be effectively
defended against by many existing FL defense methods. Targeting this, we
further propose a post-hoc defense method, which could rely on a fully
automated pipeline: generation of defense data and further fine-tuning of the
LLM. Extensive experiments show that our safety attack method can significantly
compromise the LLM's safety alignment (e.g., reduce safety rate by 70\%), which
can not be effectively defended by existing defense methods (at most 4\%
absolute improvement), while our safety defense method can significantly
enhance the attacked LLM's safety alignment (at most 69\% absolute
improvement).
|
[
-0.44296497106552124,
-0.9690378308296204,
0.17722561955451965,
-0.1846586912870407,
-0.0385604053735733,
0.3695467412471771,
-0.04762886092066765,
-0.585590124130249,
-0.038020335137844086,
0.5463839173316956,
-0.8123534917831421,
-0.5611088871955872,
-0.4898252785205841,
-0.09283525496721268,
-0.342221200466156,
1.1995712518692017,
0.1469755619764328,
-0.11303769052028656,
0.06753509491682053,
-0.16727256774902344,
-0.3814865052700043,
-0.4498006999492645,
-0.5376922488212585,
0.05277534946799278,
0.18742993474006653,
0.4654633402824402,
0.6653305292129517,
0.663456380367279,
0.9417383670806885,
0.34887751936912537,
0.3270132839679718,
-0.33548054099082947,
-0.6454012989997864,
0.13140523433685303,
-0.17491790652275085,
-0.4779263734817505,
-0.8470379710197449,
-0.030231257900595665,
0.7231842875480652,
0.6150253415107727,
-0.056015629321336746,
-0.036348652094602585,
-0.05825725197792053,
0.7665669918060303,
-0.8272626996040344,
-0.04514864832162857,
-0.6921996474266052,
0.18553641438484192,
-0.4710806906223297,
-0.11786546558141708,
-0.7486444711685181,
-0.2148342728614807,
0.1412251591682434,
-0.43211695551872253,
0.18739880621433258,
0.3755343556404114,
0.7663968801498413,
0.28440040349960327,
-0.3084564208984375,
0.04661004990339279,
-0.5085837244987488,
0.7055615186691284,
-0.4493558704853058,
0.3133045434951782,
0.1829860806465149,
0.3717006742954254,
-0.42385080456733704,
-0.45017051696777344,
-0.1627759337425232,
0.09527670592069626,
-0.1670154631137848,
-0.1569788157939911,
-0.41912272572517395,
0.46377745270729065,
0.21812804043293,
0.4405497908592224,
-0.6484820246696472,
0.33788102865219116,
0.02110893651843071,
-0.40197622776031494,
0.8333632946014404,
0.027158891782164574,
0.31949764490127563,
0.24714107811450958,
-0.7875852584838867,
-0.3090782165527344,
-0.8291886448860168,
0.15213824808597565,
0.47985318303108215,
0.2640037536621094,
-0.06759683042764664,
0.21018095314502716,
-0.39759111404418945,
0.6098471879959106,
0.37309369444847107,
-0.11983256787061691,
0.012767045758664608,
-0.20141485333442688,
-0.483513206243515,
0.31448400020599365,
0.9819880127906799,
0.18513599038124084,
0.026218067854642868,
-0.3233056366443634,
-0.6487334966659546,
-0.09050317108631134,
0.35959556698799133,
-0.6228236556053162,
-0.20899882912635803,
0.2475365400314331,
-0.020810578018426895,
-0.870613157749176,
0.458827942609787,
-0.8792349696159363,
-0.2642727792263031,
0.20044595003128052,
0.382938027381897,
-0.2907499372959137,
-0.2817060053348541,
0.035622790455818176,
0.3079342842102051,
0.6039113998413086,
0.0417485237121582,
-1.0957574844360352,
0.3256404995918274,
1.1592782735824585,
0.6531339883804321,
0.09556157886981964,
-0.29891201853752136,
-1.1797847747802734,
0.19596189260482788,
-0.3915175795555115,
0.705764651298523,
-0.3014778196811676,
-0.2812538146972656,
0.07287396490573883,
0.056309912353754044,
-0.07597764581441879,
0.029970092698931694,
0.27950823307037354,
-0.7722120881080627,
0.16994915902614594,
-0.1358281821012497,
-0.5136974453926086,
-0.03629999980330467,
0.32276684045791626,
-0.6216384768486023,
0.4112389087677002,
-0.08770475536584854,
-1.146958827972412,
0.20580168068408966,
-0.7256613969802856,
-0.5725743770599365,
0.03419852629303932,
-0.17391343414783478,
-0.6130755543708801,
-0.05264396220445633,
0.27574217319488525,
0.5364843010902405,
-0.07896199822425842,
0.21246683597564697,
-0.5154922008514404,
-0.4544534683227539,
0.0035992509219795465,
-0.2987121641635895,
1.0332787036895752,
0.07662061601877213,
-0.7175726890563965,
0.2590646743774414,
-0.5622034072875977,
0.049558721482753754,
0.10683717578649521,
-0.10110302269458771,
-0.28920575976371765,
-0.28321218490600586,
-0.4966184198856354,
-0.09002260863780975,
0.33694878220558167,
-0.621941089630127,
0.1537637859582901,
-0.8256374597549438,
0.13078449666500092,
1.0794349908828735,
0.08975005894899368,
0.7983345985412598,
-0.41679805517196655,
0.6191597580909729,
-0.3429049551486969,
0.576253354549408,
0.007093885913491249,
-0.23012064397335052,
-0.7214459180831909,
-0.1669069081544876,
0.2510950267314911,
0.5832388997077942,
-0.659447193145752,
0.2939477562904358,
-0.29929614067077637,
-0.39573219418525696,
-0.5032234787940979,
0.1447199136018753,
0.6751898527145386,
0.3330044150352478,
0.09283282607793808,
-0.1235818862915039,
-0.41468268632888794,
-0.6918109655380249,
-0.2040340155363083,
-0.11362200975418091,
0.09298590570688248,
-0.17285491526126862,
0.2701038420200348,
-0.2236650586128235,
0.7957476377487183,
-0.42523691058158875,
-0.14056797325611115,
0.08306001871824265,
0.032737426459789276,
-0.16874739527702332,
0.7466544508934021,
0.6466424465179443,
-0.47155025601387024,
-0.4338166415691376,
0.2920088768005371,
-0.7147374153137207,
0.07573575526475906,
0.0066483099944889545,
-0.3908773958683014,
0.5431746244430542,
0.4209015965461731,
-0.3744147717952728,
0.12399223446846008,
0.4888741075992584,
-0.45158103108406067,
0.41240254044532776,
0.07122430205345154,
-0.005091879516839981,
-1.069520115852356,
-0.12752635776996613,
-0.33857330679893494,
-0.21292398869991302,
-0.7328254580497742,
0.6355214715003967,
0.04612639918923378,
-0.21489650011062622,
-0.4563244879245758,
0.2324652373790741,
-0.33905068039894104,
0.13407766819000244,
-0.26616913080215454,
-0.21116027235984802,
-0.28797873854637146,
0.42193254828453064,
-0.17219702899456024,
0.6806906461715698,
0.8310524821281433,
-0.19411557912826538,
0.39226552844047546,
0.11099366098642349,
-0.1408819705247879,
0.7009878158569336,
-0.5483222603797913,
0.5318282842636108,
0.049565237015485764,
0.17626667022705078,
-0.7592831254005432,
-0.488211452960968,
0.27182137966156006,
-0.18066778779029846,
0.7039741277694702,
-0.04339255392551422,
-0.31724441051483154,
-0.03157176822423935,
-0.4379984140396118,
0.07552498579025269,
0.34240320324897766,
-0.6396019458770752,
0.3907415568828583,
0.4075281023979187,
-0.019396839663386345,
-1.164987564086914,
-0.6071882843971252,
-0.011692341417074203,
-0.45623329281806946,
-1.071274995803833,
0.03357722982764244,
-0.11107908934354782,
-0.31869566440582275,
-0.38673120737075806,
-0.2822257876396179,
-0.08113129436969757,
0.6125640869140625,
0.36041954159736633,
0.22069577872753143,
-0.46979257464408875,
-0.13231709599494934,
0.13925911486148834,
-0.3939976990222931,
0.417746901512146,
-0.22182077169418335,
0.2291923612356186,
-0.6020240187644958,
-0.5324243307113647,
-0.6450906991958618,
0.5550261735916138,
0.5957632660865784,
-0.22919535636901855,
0.6959601044654846,
0.6842920780181885,
-0.24274274706840515,
-0.24716418981552124,
-0.6005980968475342,
-0.6605019569396973,
-0.5956683158874512,
0.11044929921627045,
-0.031602587550878525,
-1.1088968515396118,
0.24538619816303253,
-0.04159611091017723,
0.5882277488708496,
0.16863654553890228,
0.008986793458461761,
-0.20905742049217224,
0.8338503241539001,
0.8606321215629578,
-0.232097327709198,
0.4398345351219177,
-0.062277935445308685,
0.1868567168712616,
-0.1837620735168457,
0.0341590940952301,
-0.36992618441581726,
-0.29147449135780334,
-0.709598958492279,
0.16629846394062042,
0.2973886728286743,
-0.04611833021044731,
-0.2548806965351105,
0.35045939683914185,
-0.37721237540245056,
0.6018106341362,
0.626041829586029,
0.03474981710314751,
0.15429818630218506,
-0.07599563151597977,
-0.11565769463777542,
0.2231694757938385,
-0.6502006649971008,
-0.179515078663826,
1.1126734018325806,
0.5169016122817993,
0.7137066125869751,
0.21717338263988495,
1.1287174224853516,
0.2716470956802368,
0.17854489386081696,
-0.44456371665000916,
0.5863742232322693,
0.04197452962398529,
-0.478716105222702,
-0.287259042263031,
-0.31310370564460754,
-0.6933444142341614,
0.020785441622138023,
-0.4580937325954437,
-0.4633271098136902,
-0.0210869163274765,
0.22387398779392242,
-0.4673161208629608,
0.37363508343696594,
-0.9373935461044312,
0.8776184320449829,
-0.4277507960796356,
-0.4530206322669983,
-0.015881480649113655,
-0.9905819296836853,
0.5529422163963318,
-0.29867640137672424,
0.19516384601593018,
0.17834165692329407,
0.28096288442611694,
0.7371265292167664,
-0.5392308235168457,
1.032490849494934,
-0.28401803970336914,
-0.035815805196762085,
-0.0780264288187027,
0.06243353337049484,
0.8251086473464966,
0.105397529900074,
0.07575567811727524,
0.2599785029888153,
-0.13391557335853577,
-0.6046270132064819,
-0.491777241230011,
0.7807855606079102,
-0.596195638179779,
-1.1790882349014282,
-0.5261663198471069,
-0.4893108010292053,
-0.17634880542755127,
0.353261262178421,
0.039579614996910095,
0.26007819175720215,
-0.2898983955383301,
0.3763001561164856,
0.9645851254463196,
0.11427623778581619,
0.7868475914001465,
0.6602883338928223,
0.22722315788269043,
-0.46248263120651245,
0.7701971530914307,
-0.1955525279045105,
0.5562230348587036,
0.6168913245201111,
0.2137046605348587,
-0.045223139226436615,
-0.6070756316184998,
-0.1685120016336441,
0.01692640781402588,
-0.5483248829841614,
-0.5720028281211853,
-0.44746166467666626,
-0.23818181455135345,
-0.4676819443702698,
-0.5781946182250977,
-0.535141110420227,
-0.18160845339298248,
-0.0047410475090146065,
-0.34547358751296997,
0.5452370643615723,
0.5780524015426636,
-0.027715271338820457,
0.5021417737007141,
-0.7191237807273865,
-0.523405134677887,
0.37492835521698,
0.3689441382884979,
-0.28124383091926575,
0.025367623195052147,
-0.24987374246120453,
0.07938217371702194,
-0.3800806701183319,
-0.5571890473365784,
0.0646476224064827,
0.08586518466472626,
0.5185799598693848,
0.859080970287323,
0.6659182906150818,
0.33963513374328613,
-0.433463454246521,
0.4388549327850342,
0.12401261180639267,
-0.8178765773773193,
0.6306323409080505,
-0.28641849756240845,
0.11607661098241806,
0.6354697346687317,
0.14127755165100098,
0.16975250840187073,
-0.5546054244041443,
-0.7316741347312927,
-0.490749716758728,
0.7984825372695923,
0.10400913655757904,
0.03813467174768448,
0.1210041269659996,
0.019918642938137054,
0.08832848817110062,
0.1199236512184143,
-0.5501324534416199,
-0.24710655212402344,
-0.08484837412834167,
0.06455866992473602,
0.26635727286338806,
-0.1365099847316742,
-0.560253381729126,
-0.054665569216012955,
0.7124083042144775,
-0.08256550878286362,
0.1329282969236374,
-0.12499295175075531,
0.059078507125377655,
-0.3586505651473999,
0.3887914717197418,
0.6397313475608826,
0.26023125648498535,
-0.26535218954086304,
0.1500140279531479,
0.20148667693138123,
-0.5662881731987,
0.23255302011966705,
0.2551327347755432,
-0.14202630519866943,
-0.3200446665287018,
0.6327274441719055,
0.8910680413246155,
0.5518405437469482,
-0.38588255643844604,
0.6860330104827881,
-0.06055578589439392,
-0.2803960144519806,
-0.18122881650924683,
0.5040507316589355,
-0.15248288214206696,
0.24408861994743347,
0.12004712969064713,
0.2797855734825134,
-0.2923063337802887,
-0.18366581201553345,
0.5149056315422058,
0.8076325058937073,
-0.42897140979766846,
-0.3114504814147949,
0.521881103515625,
0.34771883487701416,
-0.41589146852493286,
0.23742450773715973,
0.05826880410313606,
-0.3434632122516632,
0.3807881474494934,
0.4680609703063965,
0.9370432496070862,
-0.7132075428962708,
0.12013045698404312,
-0.0019278209656476974,
0.6503902673721313,
-0.02744726650416851,
-0.15670791268348694,
-0.1078994870185852,
-0.5350963473320007,
-0.0858188048005104,
-0.6083049774169922,
-0.35596564412117004,
0.14070329070091248,
-0.7701598405838013,
0.2049718201160431,
-0.9470175504684448,
0.06613150238990784,
-0.2720201015472412,
0.1691269427537918,
-0.32567882537841797,
-0.026485370472073555,
-0.1526562124490738,
0.7080968022346497,
-0.7579748630523682,
0.880343496799469,
0.6219200491905212,
-0.07783176749944687,
-0.6838108897209167,
0.28053998947143555,
0.18539434671401978,
-0.5711655616760254,
0.11465746909379959,
0.16381987929344177,
-0.16820088028907776,
-0.00842871330678463,
-0.4210999310016632,
-0.7966772317886353,
1.2484411001205444,
0.6160128712654114,
-0.7709333300590515,
-0.09015904366970062,
0.2568347454071045,
0.37832513451576233,
-0.312225341796875,
-0.2823413014411926,
0.5820785760879517,
0.32955002784729004,
-0.12043825536966324,
-0.7825143337249756,
0.208324134349823,
-0.028333118185400963,
-0.36924979090690613,
0.4318738281726837,
-0.7615007758140564,
0.6766118407249451,
-0.2816357910633087,
-0.41953685879707336,
-0.3902303874492645,
0.6502960920333862,
0.04431195929646492,
0.42670783400535583,
0.5106878280639648,
0.5752106308937073,
0.8094046115875244,
-0.09543602913618088,
0.9616839289665222,
-0.2663620412349701,
0.2566559314727783,
1.0296869277954102,
-0.13459664583206177,
0.7793799042701721,
0.4427875578403473,
0.12129978090524673,
0.156008780002594,
0.49918338656425476,
0.19650483131408691,
0.7535222172737122,
-0.2176796793937683,
-0.4545624256134033,
-0.13559658825397491,
0.24659208953380585,
-0.41691669821739197,
0.5968734622001648,
0.21099524199962616,
-0.2995968461036682,
-0.3020714819431305,
0.08202631771564484,
0.382999449968338,
0.014101152308285236,
-0.17558418214321136,
1.0151418447494507,
-0.012011643499135971,
-0.41119062900543213,
0.7770231366157532,
-0.13367551565170288,
0.6090412139892578,
-0.6506623029708862,
0.21109923720359802,
-0.15616925060749054,
0.18807953596115112,
-0.27375328540802,
-0.4558679759502411,
0.36249303817749023,
-0.001447398797608912,
-0.04196314141154289,
-0.20028215646743774,
0.4818137586116791,
-0.22056995332241058,
-0.30935409665107727,
0.2749353349208832,
0.016559623181819916,
-0.37360069155693054,
0.21506763994693756,
-0.63469398021698,
0.16467991471290588,
0.09831156581640244,
-0.1615237295627594,
0.7261592149734497,
0.27371805906295776,
-0.0074242763221263885,
0.5333629250526428,
0.5955921411514282,
-0.2304016500711441,
0.048616912215948105,
-0.33906546235084534,
0.8937600255012512,
-0.25152701139450073,
-0.7272346019744873,
-0.8462373614311218,
0.3641209900379181,
-0.11787472665309906,
0.14837020635604858,
0.6467503309249878,
0.1569311022758484,
1.1139161586761475,
-0.002232726663351059,
0.6648043394088745,
0.12288516014814377,
0.04340339079499245,
-0.6832063794136047,
1.2447984218597412,
-0.23415301740169525,
0.440306693315506,
-0.41090017557144165,
-0.48381534218788147,
-0.4099248945713043,
0.3747667968273163,
-0.3674589693546295,
-0.2978177070617676,
0.8673698902130127,
0.9754628539085388,
-0.11692625284194946,
0.3231731653213501,
0.2528162896633148,
0.1165056824684143,
0.5199482440948486,
0.6492710113525391,
0.322250097990036,
-0.4332708418369293,
0.5865545272827148,
-0.7438256740570068,
-0.39952778816223145,
-0.2171952724456787,
-0.965139627456665,
-1.1018211841583252,
-0.39338594675064087,
-0.3624360263347626,
-0.1886807531118393,
0.4173644483089447,
0.8151340484619141,
0.7481867074966431,
-1.1122788190841675,
0.08372947573661804,
-0.25889360904693604,
0.060464534908533096,
-0.2958734333515167,
-0.2581574320793152,
0.39115434885025024,
-0.2907337546348572,
-0.4635929763317108,
0.7467035055160522,
0.15526627004146576,
0.0591948926448822,
-0.3436640799045563,
-0.11250805854797363,
-0.25686055421829224,
-0.14207828044891357,
0.09353181719779968,
0.3908289968967438,
-0.7068073749542236,
-0.655167281627655,
-0.05663003772497177,
-0.12757384777069092,
-0.13221736252307892,
0.668001115322113,
-0.2762959599494934,
0.5890660881996155,
0.34302783012390137,
1.1096312999725342,
-0.2957262694835663,
0.018321754410862923,
0.8890050053596497,
-1.0304008722305298,
0.3820245563983917,
0.18182773888111115,
0.33313730359077454,
0.3036790192127228,
-0.9352238774299622,
0.33593228459358215,
0.2896633744239807,
-0.5464011430740356,
-0.9818852543830872,
0.19037288427352905,
-0.8158533573150635,
0.028946826234459877,
0.8229724168777466,
-0.41338634490966797,
-0.3612561523914337,
-0.013089219108223915,
0.09293373674154282,
0.11678820848464966,
-0.5294021368026733,
0.8598583936691284,
0.57182776927948,
0.16071408987045288,
-0.050211794674396515,
-0.3674444854259491,
0.7518004775047302,
0.36194270849227905,
-0.7933608293533325,
0.11934377998113632,
0.35980698466300964,
0.3325752317905426,
0.013972808606922626,
0.23060263693332672,
0.07316669076681137,
0.5173741579055786,
0.009877467527985573,
-0.2955097556114197,
-0.3249575197696686,
-0.46009984612464905,
-0.40780529379844666,
0.499114990234375,
-0.10487038642168045,
-0.5465258359909058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10625v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10625v2
|
On the Hardness of Faithful Chain-of-Thought Reasoning in Large Language Models
| 2024-06-15T13:16:44 | 2024-07-01T13:36:29 |
Sree Harsha Tanneru, Dan Ley, Chirag Agarwal, Himabindu Lakkaraju
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly being employed in real-world
applications in critical domains such as healthcare, it is important to ensure
that the Chain-of-Thought (CoT) reasoning generated by these models faithfully
captures their underlying behavior.
While LLMs are known to generate CoT reasoning that is appealing to humans,
prior studies have shown that these explanations do not accurately reflect the
actual behavior of the underlying LLMs. In this work, we explore the promise of
three broad approaches commonly employed to steer the behavior of LLMs to
enhance the faithfulness of the CoT reasoning generated by LLMs: in-context
learning, fine-tuning, and activation editing. Specifically, we introduce novel
strategies for in-context learning, fine-tuning, and activation editing aimed
at improving the faithfulness of the CoT reasoning. We then carry out extensive
empirical analyses with multiple benchmark datasets to explore the promise of
these strategies. Our analyses indicate that these strategies offer limited
success in improving the faithfulness of the CoT reasoning, with only slight
performance enhancements in controlled scenarios. Activation editing
demonstrated minimal success, while fine-tuning and in-context learning
achieved marginal improvements that failed to generalize across diverse
reasoning and truthful question-answering benchmarks. In summary, our work
underscores the inherent difficulty in eliciting faithful CoT reasoning from
LLMs, suggesting that the current array of approaches may not be sufficient to
address this complex challenge.
|
[
-0.26545774936676025,
-1.0338629484176636,
1.1777328252792358,
-0.18939995765686035,
-0.28692078590393066,
0.22535499930381775,
-0.6292575597763062,
-0.40317302942276,
-0.24234242737293243,
0.6144826412200928,
-0.4307125210762024,
-0.5473747849464417,
-0.48258352279663086,
0.1559850573539734,
-0.06226253882050514,
0.9222384095191956,
-0.4122268259525299,
0.16844703257083893,
-0.11980105191469193,
-0.2955191433429718,
-0.3595356345176697,
-0.7353399395942688,
-0.6173063516616821,
-0.5309847593307495,
0.5909498929977417,
0.3951317071914673,
0.9890131950378418,
0.5548228025436401,
0.3806028366088867,
0.1833578646183014,
-0.39128589630126953,
0.7311493158340454,
-0.6873118877410889,
0.21486422419548035,
-0.6319794058799744,
-0.48765942454338074,
-0.6249492764472961,
-0.21970553696155548,
0.692569375038147,
0.9681113362312317,
0.021153846755623817,
-0.06883862614631653,
0.21968749165534973,
0.922173023223877,
-0.8196698427200317,
-0.1809937208890915,
-0.9137948751449585,
-0.19210635125637054,
0.09317177534103394,
-0.22681300342082977,
-0.6295700073242188,
-0.2968831956386566,
0.056389253586530685,
-0.41027817130088806,
0.01911080628633499,
-0.045953478664159775,
0.6396837830543518,
0.14048580825328827,
-0.4778735041618347,
-0.4438488483428955,
-0.8298550844192505,
0.7783447504043579,
-0.8427731394767761,
0.4981696903705597,
0.5260469913482666,
-0.2006997913122177,
-0.5999166965484619,
-0.6536446809768677,
-0.47509995102882385,
-0.3014029562473297,
0.15095698833465576,
-0.249882310628891,
0.13589252531528473,
0.4638752043247223,
0.43106338381767273,
0.2960282266139984,
-0.06401027739048004,
0.054063957184553146,
-0.09044452011585236,
0.043705053627491,
0.6112711429595947,
0.24162647128105164,
0.04867849126458168,
0.1838272660970688,
-0.17834685742855072,
0.016561755910515785,
-1.0204592943191528,
-0.09059137105941772,
0.09159204363822937,
0.06474649906158447,
0.22292524576187134,
0.6482610106468201,
-0.12652520835399628,
0.745104193687439,
0.14814022183418274,
-0.2452796846628189,
0.05663783475756645,
-0.26521405577659607,
-0.48049861192703247,
0.022580862045288086,
0.5400720238685608,
0.2772829532623291,
0.27531197667121887,
-0.3155553340911865,
-0.3626987040042877,
0.061665650457143784,
0.44195878505706787,
-0.34205007553100586,
0.07932548969984055,
0.5127885341644287,
-0.43068215250968933,
-0.3124344050884247,
-0.08356567472219467,
-0.40721869468688965,
-0.2423924058675766,
-0.5620046854019165,
0.3944760262966156,
-0.6668891906738281,
-0.11190249025821686,
0.3862802982330322,
0.06478527933359146,
0.19799572229385376,
0.4926418364048004,
-0.829225480556488,
0.31687140464782715,
0.9119240045547485,
0.6273616552352905,
-0.183491051197052,
-0.3202684819698334,
-0.4880020320415497,
0.4594464600086212,
-0.7004252672195435,
0.48354730010032654,
-0.7293631434440613,
-0.21873871982097626,
0.03587212413549423,
-0.06900274753570557,
-0.07366915047168732,
-0.5607008934020996,
0.5614650249481201,
-0.6174832582473755,
-0.3381645083427429,
-0.6625320315361023,
-0.7130241990089417,
0.06260226666927338,
0.39825356006622314,
-0.5129225254058838,
0.7381937503814697,
0.05912676826119423,
-0.5125059485435486,
0.3357364237308502,
-0.48528993129730225,
-0.5149834752082825,
-0.36481231451034546,
-0.13769014179706573,
-0.3211132884025574,
0.5070506930351257,
0.16420504450798035,
0.4007664918899536,
-0.1959635317325592,
0.45188388228416443,
-0.37479642033576965,
-0.43541771173477173,
0.6216200590133667,
-0.5477263927459717,
0.6013041734695435,
0.2146325409412384,
-0.48666539788246155,
0.07981115579605103,
-0.4337782561779022,
0.07644408196210861,
-0.019363241270184517,
-0.33332833647727966,
-0.26130211353302,
0.1525145173072815,
-0.3077288568019867,
0.20205171406269073,
0.03981005772948265,
-0.2772216498851776,
0.560712456703186,
-0.4382246732711792,
0.459799200296402,
0.9239363670349121,
0.1455768495798111,
0.5583279132843018,
-0.44826653599739075,
0.28111743927001953,
-0.007151917554438114,
0.46313685178756714,
0.07076585292816162,
-0.3863264322280884,
-0.6717866063117981,
-0.014533508569002151,
0.23943299055099487,
0.17933674156665802,
-0.965556800365448,
0.12015727162361145,
-0.2743455767631531,
-0.3021988868713379,
-0.6081259846687317,
0.5150505304336548,
0.647312581539154,
0.393607497215271,
0.5368737578392029,
-0.3222616910934448,
-0.1438513696193695,
-0.7237196564674377,
-0.6087545156478882,
-0.15204210579395294,
0.22562289237976074,
0.2145281583070755,
0.47467947006225586,
-0.4266239106655121,
0.6768781542778015,
-0.2624620497226715,
-0.027917802333831787,
-0.30388885736465454,
0.03164287284016609,
0.03200279176235199,
0.48165759444236755,
0.0612606406211853,
-0.653046727180481,
-0.1333722472190857,
0.06969844549894333,
-0.6985005736351013,
0.13316935300827026,
-0.23728863894939423,
-0.24441851675510406,
0.2922557294368744,
0.6938430070877075,
-0.5794883370399475,
0.49723345041275024,
0.32151511311531067,
-0.1581190973520279,
0.6163887977600098,
-0.39701446890830994,
0.1816750168800354,
-0.7708278894424438,
-0.2099429965019226,
-0.25385457277297974,
-0.30095574259757996,
-0.6847764849662781,
0.3395826816558838,
0.08489832282066345,
0.258683979511261,
-0.46599307656288147,
0.45492494106292725,
-0.6030908226966858,
0.26045188307762146,
-0.320530503988266,
-0.035836976021528244,
0.11580600589513779,
0.63956218957901,
-0.08661071956157684,
0.6367533206939697,
0.3795833885669708,
-0.657211422920227,
0.19060976803302765,
0.29876023530960083,
-0.1863103210926056,
0.2142172008752823,
-0.5326926708221436,
0.4603704810142517,
-0.18206816911697388,
0.5683113932609558,
-0.7157118916511536,
-0.24344073235988617,
0.04196634888648987,
-0.08215904980897903,
0.267985075712204,
-0.1460268795490265,
-0.7750609517097473,
-0.0810089185833931,
-0.358148992061615,
0.6838085055351257,
0.46110549569129944,
-0.6068058609962463,
0.6403606534004211,
0.14529892802238464,
0.16446959972381592,
-0.4459902346134186,
-0.8239525556564331,
0.13556495308876038,
-0.062359850853681564,
-0.37204495072364807,
0.559902548789978,
0.07902999967336655,
-0.48816370964050293,
-0.13467247784137726,
-0.3140276074409485,
0.03396948426961899,
-0.004615483805537224,
0.04319096729159355,
0.2046150118112564,
-0.10705456882715225,
0.3393332362174988,
0.29822367429733276,
-0.028777865692973137,
0.08437342196702957,
-0.2994879484176636,
0.38844746351242065,
-0.42306599020957947,
-0.52415931224823,
-0.34323549270629883,
0.29057741165161133,
0.8454808592796326,
-0.2172558754682541,
0.9018650054931641,
0.20702767372131348,
-0.33300456404685974,
-0.3766034245491028,
-0.7567842602729797,
-0.2835176885128021,
-0.4762131869792938,
0.05046958476305008,
-0.4813917875289917,
-0.8689554333686829,
0.30517300963401794,
-0.6070923209190369,
0.05792304128408432,
0.12432943284511566,
0.6456921100616455,
-0.13419470191001892,
1.2237768173217773,
0.2505914270877838,
0.11921106278896332,
0.2840404212474823,
-0.40063318610191345,
0.3050204813480377,
-1.3230324983596802,
-0.22058376669883728,
-0.1771535575389862,
-0.2655262053012848,
-0.6257216334342957,
-0.5852393507957458,
0.5820757150650024,
0.3331405818462372,
-0.3269970417022705,
0.05994655191898346,
-0.41456592082977295,
0.5092336535453796,
0.2896914780139923,
0.6784137487411499,
0.47202202677726746,
-0.09532533586025238,
-0.3362068831920624,
0.2545117735862732,
-0.8829944133758545,
-0.6947152018547058,
1.1352142095565796,
0.376412570476532,
0.9437233805656433,
0.1437532752752304,
0.5370386242866516,
0.010793627239763737,
0.30573010444641113,
-0.5858497023582458,
0.48043352365493774,
0.004272681660950184,
-0.4614748954772949,
-0.33192116022109985,
-0.3566574156284332,
-0.9384387731552124,
-0.00705786794424057,
-0.32144397497177124,
-0.7368509769439697,
0.3505921959877014,
0.43981972336769104,
-0.32459649443626404,
0.6236854791641235,
-0.631441593170166,
0.6720923781394958,
-0.28751659393310547,
-0.8724582195281982,
-0.3618132472038269,
-0.7002688646316528,
0.36647772789001465,
0.00040390584035776556,
0.18075670301914215,
0.18789397180080414,
-0.13072167336940765,
0.26312485337257385,
-0.6502652764320374,
0.8518797755241394,
0.19509047269821167,
-0.3910060226917267,
0.361790269613266,
0.38795530796051025,
0.8567150831222534,
0.16119831800460815,
-0.3302748501300812,
0.022834988310933113,
-0.14882297813892365,
-0.5230934619903564,
-0.8197076916694641,
0.7788593173027039,
-0.5821070671081543,
-0.7434402704238892,
-0.23775959014892578,
-0.4788030982017517,
-0.7284476161003113,
-0.0736057460308075,
0.18926915526390076,
0.6579363346099854,
-0.05429626256227493,
0.16447237133979797,
0.9512918591499329,
-0.18586772680282593,
0.06432092934846878,
0.15477865934371948,
-0.0975932776927948,
-0.4693875312805176,
0.749407172203064,
0.046042490750551224,
0.876081109046936,
0.15540964901447296,
0.1432894468307495,
-0.25804629921913147,
-0.6509936451911926,
-0.32922202348709106,
0.28100839257240295,
-0.9647273421287537,
-0.11284761875867844,
-0.577009379863739,
-0.20961236953735352,
-0.10520783811807632,
-0.5220151543617249,
-0.37699419260025024,
-0.192475825548172,
-0.16179989278316498,
-0.09124431759119034,
0.3342345654964447,
0.699734628200531,
0.1453346610069275,
0.03531976044178009,
-0.6619915962219238,
0.6217535138130188,
0.41091570258140564,
0.5726340413093567,
0.27788370847702026,
-0.28304028511047363,
-0.1765737682580948,
0.39296820759773254,
-0.4223657250404358,
-0.8128307461738586,
-0.026917466893792152,
0.056232742965221405,
0.4542716443538666,
0.3569934070110321,
0.04648134857416153,
0.9739493131637573,
-0.5475354790687561,
0.727506160736084,
0.12495549023151398,
-1.1251739263534546,
0.6854430437088013,
-0.23424190282821655,
0.31739673018455505,
0.9206233024597168,
0.27549824118614197,
-0.1120595782995224,
-0.7631217837333679,
-0.7915516495704651,
-0.8110917210578918,
0.3684130609035492,
0.21370908617973328,
0.2559874951839447,
-0.27042531967163086,
0.7458680272102356,
0.15322332084178925,
0.1111731231212616,
-0.5309761166572571,
-0.003998501691967249,
0.1383855789899826,
-0.13961295783519745,
0.21379603445529938,
-0.21735616028308868,
-0.2036157250404358,
-0.6366761922836304,
0.7407898306846619,
-0.29692888259887695,
0.0193185992538929,
0.7106016874313354,
-0.18819192051887512,
-0.37691161036491394,
0.39383620023727417,
0.6381405591964722,
1.0614241361618042,
-0.11553160101175308,
0.3179670572280884,
0.5831934809684753,
-0.3325502574443817,
0.15851224958896637,
-0.6246563196182251,
-0.054229408502578735,
-0.1538875848054886,
0.5370550751686096,
0.8149965405464172,
0.29918816685676575,
-0.8143934011459351,
0.501831591129303,
0.12662804126739502,
-0.12269408255815506,
-0.13072092831134796,
0.37732064723968506,
0.02924508787691593,
0.1477157324552536,
0.11469247937202454,
0.16883544623851776,
-0.06773138791322708,
-0.9264208078384399,
-0.06503703445196152,
0.5366383194923401,
-0.5005019307136536,
-0.12910078465938568,
0.6411477327346802,
0.02344752848148346,
-0.3379712998867035,
0.6522641181945801,
-0.07724084705114365,
-0.543004035949707,
0.3797982633113861,
0.6042277812957764,
0.9325108528137207,
0.017790568992495537,
0.0015185908414423466,
0.16248054802417755,
0.34743836522102356,
-0.40642136335372925,
0.18307843804359436,
-0.09438309073448181,
-0.7450690865516663,
-0.7801799774169922,
-0.3379741609096527,
-0.6460669040679932,
0.19596171379089355,
-0.6488866806030273,
0.28413572907447815,
-0.5685173273086548,
-0.21668146550655365,
-0.2302236706018448,
-0.1967000663280487,
-0.6562536954879761,
0.1740046590566635,
0.09536869078874588,
0.9809824824333191,
-0.5109314322471619,
0.9376844167709351,
0.5167006254196167,
-0.28362134099006653,
-0.9155420660972595,
0.3330983817577362,
-0.2844809293746948,
-0.605176568031311,
0.22974324226379395,
-0.11151016503572464,
-0.2656446695327759,
-0.07414782047271729,
-0.7959764003753662,
-0.4998434782028198,
0.932051956653595,
0.5939529538154602,
-0.7509957551956177,
-0.024628132581710815,
0.10398232191801071,
0.6133409738540649,
-0.36411547660827637,
0.09748687595129013,
0.7835960388183594,
0.47584787011146545,
-0.08062470704317093,
-1.017148494720459,
0.2708393335342407,
0.14755766093730927,
0.0018485578475520015,
0.1398903876543045,
-0.6314656734466553,
0.6412470936775208,
-0.45312029123306274,
0.1669294834136963,
0.016481688246130943,
0.4615626037120819,
0.572806179523468,
0.32071104645729065,
0.5495284199714661,
0.6256673336029053,
0.7984414100646973,
0.0470910519361496,
1.209010124206543,
-0.14462174475193024,
0.271744042634964,
1.025183916091919,
-0.5132350921630859,
0.8563655614852905,
0.744549572467804,
0.09250174462795258,
0.7218683958053589,
0.3510544002056122,
0.20701484382152557,
0.43450847268104553,
0.25332966446876526,
-0.5549929141998291,
-0.4528498947620392,
-0.06142149865627289,
-0.23908959329128265,
0.2515868842601776,
0.5532476305961609,
-0.5418512225151062,
0.06607034802436829,
0.10728579759597778,
0.14530536532402039,
0.19530409574508667,
-0.5002604722976685,
1.038590908050537,
0.32941189408302307,
-0.9846773743629456,
0.9200643301010132,
-0.07456822693347931,
0.1566256731748581,
-0.4168252944946289,
-0.3605218231678009,
0.028992528095841408,
0.09807601571083069,
-0.22277623414993286,
-0.841881275177002,
0.29061487317085266,
0.09390245378017426,
-0.146891787648201,
-0.4301741421222687,
0.7490777969360352,
-0.2450682818889618,
-0.42051541805267334,
0.3554858863353729,
0.550353467464447,
-0.06258244812488556,
-0.09092186391353607,
-0.6238371729850769,
0.42971667647361755,
-0.17226366698741913,
-0.3286571800708771,
0.2653811573982239,
0.612524688243866,
-0.21048502624034882,
0.7357242107391357,
0.7777882814407349,
0.3634517192840576,
-0.2072134166955948,
0.14886406064033508,
1.2124851942062378,
-0.7067107558250427,
-0.12981007993221283,
-1.104841709136963,
0.4000711441040039,
0.003671583253890276,
-0.31603553891181946,
0.31230804324150085,
0.3897649347782135,
0.7676246762275696,
-0.027230527251958847,
0.7020201086997986,
0.26179251074790955,
0.03906635940074921,
-0.8626271486282349,
0.3732434809207916,
-0.48371240496635437,
0.42912566661834717,
-0.37113505601882935,
-0.839624285697937,
-0.284156858921051,
0.4336344003677368,
-0.4602836072444916,
-0.11965959519147873,
0.9881588816642761,
0.6998254060745239,
-0.1131671667098999,
0.026594839990139008,
0.2717859148979187,
0.4596382677555084,
0.2838590443134308,
0.8141647577285767,
0.9443894028663635,
-0.41688936948776245,
0.23242686688899994,
-0.18932940065860748,
-0.1440892219543457,
-0.09697802364826202,
-0.9059404730796814,
-0.9325510859489441,
-0.34091463685035706,
-0.26277026534080505,
-0.715060830116272,
0.37189191579818726,
1.248528003692627,
0.5534408688545227,
-0.6791998147964478,
0.06888604164123535,
-0.5766019821166992,
0.41665926575660706,
-0.5056177377700806,
-0.1554851531982422,
0.42852237820625305,
-0.537442147731781,
-0.3938789367675781,
0.3877650499343872,
0.31916964054107666,
-0.23991329967975616,
-0.14513880014419556,
-0.19300711154937744,
-0.17285695672035217,
0.3154084384441376,
0.7111681699752808,
0.09387830644845963,
-1.037993311882019,
-0.46045106649398804,
-0.1646733283996582,
-0.1515960693359375,
0.0831877738237381,
0.9635958075523376,
-0.850256085395813,
0.5268227458000183,
0.34612521529197693,
0.6764770746231079,
0.3156210780143738,
0.14282827079296112,
0.730728030204773,
-0.4745650291442871,
-0.0932202935218811,
0.4580051302909851,
0.3556247353553772,
0.22611765563488007,
-0.37050458788871765,
0.3891630470752716,
-0.01950847916305065,
-0.6698551177978516,
-0.9463177919387817,
0.34023764729499817,
-1.027019739151001,
-0.47343793511390686,
1.5371819734573364,
0.013363756239414215,
-0.37554264068603516,
-0.3398468792438507,
-0.3688408434391022,
0.24574574828147888,
0.08396805822849274,
0.8338911533355713,
0.7359185814857483,
-0.27621835470199585,
0.1940748542547226,
-0.5604017376899719,
0.656265914440155,
0.49203357100486755,
-0.6394017338752747,
0.2889861464500427,
0.29154202342033386,
0.2497834712266922,
-0.12409070134162903,
0.5857207775115967,
-0.3230323791503906,
0.4530782699584961,
-0.36315369606018066,
-0.23452609777450562,
0.010689595714211464,
-0.415264368057251,
-0.3092741370201111,
0.05721228942275047,
0.3628363013267517,
0.2516961991786957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10621v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10621v2
|
StrucText-Eval: An Autogenerated Benchmark for Evaluating Large Language Model's Ability in Structure-Rich Text Understanding
| 2024-06-15T12:48:00 | 2024-06-30T09:02:34 |
Zhouhong Gu, Haoning Ye, Zeyang Zhou, Hongwei Feng, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Given the substantial volumes of structured data held by many companies,
enabling Large Language Models (LLMs) to directly understand structured text in
non-structured forms could significantly enhance their capabilities across
various business scenarios. To this end, we propose evaluation data generation
method for assessing LLM's ability in understanding the structure-rich text,
which generates structured data of controllable complexity based on manually
crafted question templates and generation rules. Building on this generation
method, we introduce StrucText-Eval, a benchmark comprising 6,032 questions
across 8 different structured languages and 29 specific tasks. Furthermore,
considering human proficiency in rule-based tasks, we also present
StrucText-Eval-Hard, which includes 3,016 questions designed to further examine
the gap between LLMs and human performance. Results indicate that the
best-performing LLM currently achieve an accuracy of 65.0\% on
StrucText-Eval-Hard, while human accuracy reaches up to 95.7\%. Moreover, while
fine-tuning using StrucText-Eval can enhance existing LLMs' understanding of
all structured languages, it does not necessarily improve performance across
all task types. The benchmark and generation codes are open sourced in
https://github.com/MikeGu721/StrucText-Eval
|
[
-0.056577347218990326,
-1.2956832647323608,
0.4640650749206543,
0.3691435158252716,
-0.15295375883579254,
0.38918226957321167,
-0.3455686867237091,
-0.36890071630477905,
-0.2489297091960907,
0.1844315230846405,
-0.3581717610359192,
-0.677184522151947,
-0.3520905077457428,
0.2609020173549652,
-0.4047834277153015,
0.8875025510787964,
-0.37574708461761475,
-0.030356816947460175,
-0.2984411120414734,
0.1427784562110901,
-0.3646010458469391,
-0.3954318165779114,
-0.4272425174713135,
-0.08019406348466873,
0.11175576597452164,
0.28070518374443054,
0.44951966404914856,
1.002112627029419,
0.42455199360847473,
0.3736228346824646,
-0.014659807085990906,
0.1450101137161255,
-0.5872040390968323,
0.07412829250097275,
-0.2716558277606964,
-0.3150942623615265,
-0.6499733328819275,
-0.18572905659675598,
0.9024433493614197,
0.6796624660491943,
-0.3053119480609894,
0.33552971482276917,
0.16669738292694092,
0.5519700646400452,
-0.40486058592796326,
0.2646573483943939,
-0.5622493028640747,
0.006964013446122408,
-0.1275143325328827,
-0.39673522114753723,
-0.3115161061286926,
-0.31441545486450195,
-0.21514351665973663,
-0.1490306258201599,
0.15853044390678406,
0.3729199767112732,
0.8178650140762329,
0.2918437123298645,
-0.5212929844856262,
-0.14509056508541107,
-0.47162926197052,
0.6352205276489258,
-0.5177184343338013,
0.5660611391067505,
0.17150481045246124,
0.29388460516929626,
-0.3518216907978058,
-0.811371386051178,
-0.39423009753227234,
-0.4140473008155823,
0.04619808867573738,
0.10372611880302429,
-0.187794491648674,
0.02888898365199566,
0.43328985571861267,
0.6257433295249939,
-0.9302290081977844,
0.16693751513957977,
-0.38316789269447327,
-0.013030877336859703,
0.8184323310852051,
0.2941970229148865,
0.3117072582244873,
-0.366720974445343,
-0.49832868576049805,
-0.2855399549007416,
-0.6923295259475708,
0.05124124884605408,
0.5146670341491699,
-0.027150942012667656,
-0.1625177562236786,
0.6076124310493469,
-0.3799707591533661,
0.5277504324913025,
-0.10308461636304855,
0.2796913683414459,
0.4552169144153595,
-0.6056877374649048,
-0.6033200621604919,
-0.1442374587059021,
0.8827471733093262,
0.09073873609304428,
0.19111210107803345,
-0.1474321186542511,
-0.3142794966697693,
-0.00883139856159687,
0.31203794479370117,
-0.9746455550193787,
-0.16649411618709564,
0.19197304546833038,
-0.5395041704177856,
-0.1960291564464569,
0.0005859869997948408,
-0.7573333382606506,
-0.004754853434860706,
-0.19214630126953125,
0.2829461395740509,
-0.39451807737350464,
-0.27119213342666626,
-0.06758945435285568,
-0.03800360485911369,
0.26342442631721497,
0.20342135429382324,
-0.6448442935943604,
0.35898908972740173,
0.6153287887573242,
0.5605846047401428,
-0.28860118985176086,
-0.43947023153305054,
-0.7572404146194458,
-0.13846972584724426,
-0.4567723870277405,
1.0075109004974365,
-0.4064690172672272,
-0.26857122778892517,
-0.25587061047554016,
-0.12163051217794418,
-0.2844069302082062,
-0.626885175704956,
0.5209569334983826,
-0.24516265094280243,
-0.004788130521774292,
0.14684292674064636,
-0.70694500207901,
0.06776799261569977,
0.39457258582115173,
-0.502403974533081,
1.4236747026443481,
0.5007213950157166,
-0.5055965781211853,
0.3495640158653259,
-0.580838143825531,
-0.35159608721733093,
0.45429182052612305,
-0.5663703083992004,
-0.3462415039539337,
0.2398289144039154,
-0.13194333016872406,
0.42164191603660583,
-0.3008556365966797,
0.48693960905075073,
-0.16746436059474945,
-0.34118837118148804,
0.15808632969856262,
-0.4905051589012146,
0.4465573728084564,
0.24694770574569702,
-0.6300789713859558,
0.35949280858039856,
-0.9219384789466858,
0.471515417098999,
0.13030663132667542,
-0.6539697647094727,
-0.05551191419363022,
0.21752934157848358,
0.2218206375837326,
0.3107976019382477,
0.35921362042427063,
-0.37354445457458496,
0.14161881804466248,
-0.5979112386703491,
0.3664986193180084,
0.8262278437614441,
-0.12489345669746399,
-0.03869658708572388,
-0.144298255443573,
0.6522315144538879,
-0.21346844732761383,
-0.00039549058419652283,
-0.11173505336046219,
-0.13624541461467743,
-0.578975260257721,
-0.11993981897830963,
0.16642878949642181,
0.4220105707645416,
-0.6125513911247253,
0.6629363298416138,
-0.339508980512619,
-0.7331296801567078,
-0.4880980849266052,
0.4811529517173767,
0.8459631204605103,
0.45290422439575195,
0.4485456645488739,
-0.08724351972341537,
-0.5295882821083069,
-1.345994234085083,
-0.4176086485385895,
-0.34955886006355286,
-0.18012502789497375,
0.5261284112930298,
0.7758079171180725,
-0.2604682445526123,
0.5719674825668335,
-0.402423232793808,
0.3812920153141022,
-0.5440548062324524,
0.3626590371131897,
0.06404219567775726,
0.414039671421051,
0.19524508714675903,
-0.7316282391548157,
-0.5588245391845703,
0.04532874375581741,
-0.4778834581375122,
-0.23437485098838806,
0.14259649813175201,
-0.0710071548819542,
0.29949644207954407,
0.4042503833770752,
-0.23368152976036072,
0.3091905415058136,
0.610346794128418,
-0.6667540073394775,
0.7597715854644775,
-0.3052178621292114,
0.3480466306209564,
-1.1149383783340454,
0.33398428559303284,
-0.17473013699054718,
-0.2633226811885834,
-0.537703812122345,
0.17381225526332855,
0.44868817925453186,
0.1266377866268158,
-0.4545588493347168,
0.4777083694934845,
-0.3858289122581482,
-0.3143909275531769,
0.04395406320691109,
0.10045286267995834,
0.15226371586322784,
0.41670042276382446,
-0.05483091622591019,
0.9796023368835449,
0.21299651265144348,
-0.40116167068481445,
0.24353614449501038,
0.26626715064048767,
-0.8876347541809082,
0.47139015793800354,
-0.7861326932907104,
0.1814747154712677,
0.07188726216554642,
0.02606893889605999,
-1.1055254936218262,
-0.09309803694486618,
-0.33201155066490173,
-0.1657496839761734,
0.24647022783756256,
0.05391659960150719,
-0.6981404423713684,
-0.3252097964286804,
-0.23276416957378387,
0.5365586876869202,
0.34945669770240784,
-0.3557192087173462,
0.41510871052742004,
0.11370878666639328,
-0.3270581066608429,
-0.27571263909339905,
-0.43249183893203735,
0.22569817304611206,
-0.07515666633844376,
-0.8085682988166809,
0.21717217564582825,
-0.5619879364967346,
-0.42030805349349976,
-0.19741889834403992,
-0.13358256220817566,
-0.008144845254719257,
0.38442662358283997,
0.05704468861222267,
0.31938448548316956,
-0.338396817445755,
0.005228150170296431,
-0.028169134631752968,
0.07473483681678772,
0.05873832851648331,
0.12462501972913742,
0.7070662379264832,
-0.5174058079719543,
-0.17987434566020966,
-0.12613974511623383,
0.33672913908958435,
0.3749658465385437,
-0.3165487051010132,
0.39158952236175537,
0.14457187056541443,
-0.14842407405376434,
-0.5783756375312805,
-0.5847772359848022,
0.21804805099964142,
-0.47487229108810425,
0.7098731398582458,
-0.6000598669052124,
-0.7067209482192993,
0.376130074262619,
0.03613068163394928,
-0.02240203507244587,
0.7254701852798462,
0.8312335014343262,
0.07971680909395218,
1.116969347000122,
0.47906145453453064,
0.08804766088724136,
0.2089923471212387,
-0.14264142513275146,
0.0595262311398983,
-0.7227217555046082,
-0.2492796629667282,
-0.68265300989151,
-0.193058043718338,
-0.6051849722862244,
-0.4298302233219147,
0.14012332260608673,
0.2315571904182434,
-0.07859412580728531,
0.5675328969955444,
-0.37399572134017944,
0.35947996377944946,
0.15865649282932281,
-0.1840280443429947,
0.35844287276268005,
-0.254533976316452,
-0.14856521785259247,
0.22292731702327728,
-0.5152211785316467,
-0.5233339071273804,
0.9075416922569275,
0.45017480850219727,
0.6642996668815613,
-0.10917417705059052,
0.5207340717315674,
0.2980358302593231,
0.355411559343338,
-0.6863829493522644,
0.4485122561454773,
-0.0510282889008522,
-0.3689391613006592,
-0.11829345673322678,
-0.9245603680610657,
-0.7147820591926575,
0.12367819249629974,
0.08197379857301712,
-0.6153227686882019,
-0.0026730697136372328,
0.11427260935306549,
-0.0981971025466919,
0.005753066390752792,
-0.8777840733528137,
1.1884751319885254,
-0.6112667322158813,
-0.5875126719474792,
-0.1441541314125061,
-0.2382914274930954,
0.2762925624847412,
-0.21482448279857635,
0.22379188239574432,
-0.0022706137970089912,
0.03843111917376518,
0.9484617710113525,
-0.24497318267822266,
0.33119767904281616,
-0.030942402780056,
-0.2484365552663803,
0.037210408598184586,
0.11489900201559067,
0.784833550453186,
-0.11284753680229187,
-0.3344478905200958,
0.22008000314235687,
0.10904842615127563,
-0.22380217909812927,
-0.552679181098938,
0.50498366355896,
-0.49525922536849976,
-0.33748573064804077,
-0.09206056594848633,
-0.5165398120880127,
-0.14605191349983215,
0.15217477083206177,
0.25432032346725464,
0.501727283000946,
-0.5247799754142761,
0.5531368255615234,
0.41263145208358765,
-0.3265160322189331,
0.25086405873298645,
0.7405604720115662,
0.13497915863990784,
-0.28245922923088074,
0.6817755699157715,
0.08870811760425568,
0.1994548738002777,
0.4142029583454132,
0.239608034491539,
-0.5203530788421631,
-0.8216679692268372,
-0.5944470167160034,
-0.06200910359621048,
-0.36150383949279785,
-0.3735313415527344,
-0.6415734887123108,
-0.2723983824253082,
-0.29445961117744446,
-0.08558465540409088,
-0.42127737402915955,
-0.06286580860614777,
0.14537428319454193,
-0.3064519762992859,
0.011434735730290413,
0.809188961982727,
0.38023126125335693,
-0.08995506912469864,
-0.5936313271522522,
0.23702678084373474,
0.07797058671712875,
0.626314103603363,
-0.23615089058876038,
-0.38098886609077454,
-0.45873016119003296,
-0.04734085127711296,
-0.16749174892902374,
-0.623957097530365,
0.38123202323913574,
0.255829393863678,
0.6289911270141602,
0.2961511015892029,
-0.1532408893108368,
0.8485357761383057,
-0.6401703953742981,
0.6397229433059692,
-0.16831006109714508,
-1.1360111236572266,
0.6179930567741394,
-0.3538748025894165,
0.1031837984919548,
0.8306231498718262,
0.0332082100212574,
-0.326651930809021,
-0.568702757358551,
-0.7872183918952942,
-1.034842610359192,
0.5755945444107056,
0.3121572434902191,
-0.15607403218746185,
-0.11382390558719635,
0.2536008059978485,
0.1278512179851532,
0.42011335492134094,
-0.5102670192718506,
-0.09254978597164154,
-0.102590411901474,
-0.3849281966686249,
-0.15343192219734192,
-0.3433370888233185,
0.1788400411605835,
-0.07755938172340393,
0.42721283435821533,
-0.17281930148601532,
0.09152556955814362,
0.14154791831970215,
-0.3105202615261078,
-0.274833619594574,
0.6281118392944336,
0.5828254818916321,
0.9813801646232605,
-0.3877231776714325,
0.24826881289482117,
0.30785390734672546,
-0.3783295154571533,
-0.11581102758646011,
0.2469816952943802,
0.09300607442855835,
-0.4360577166080475,
0.5281204581260681,
0.6833025217056274,
0.45194655656814575,
-1.101660132408142,
0.49763235449790955,
-0.1759045124053955,
-0.49361371994018555,
-0.1864633858203888,
0.3334413468837738,
-0.07858626544475555,
0.20461933314800262,
0.40628737211227417,
-0.6154237389564514,
0.14021919667720795,
-0.6412639021873474,
0.43882066011428833,
0.40317121148109436,
0.040029458701610565,
-0.33180397748947144,
0.538479208946228,
0.03938901796936989,
-0.40057066082954407,
0.48006659746170044,
-0.17377768456935883,
-0.5722905397415161,
0.7730933427810669,
0.6583297252655029,
0.935368537902832,
-0.38026219606399536,
-0.001452702796086669,
0.2777785658836365,
0.25382688641548157,
0.04353559762239456,
0.5056840181350708,
-0.3311814069747925,
-0.45953941345214844,
-0.48345261812210083,
-1.0191540718078613,
-0.4212808310985565,
0.36366233229637146,
-0.5171217322349548,
0.0026904481928795576,
-0.26896539330482483,
0.4119166433811188,
-0.06754831224679947,
0.5361799597740173,
-0.8254777789115906,
0.26907941699028015,
-0.27382326126098633,
1.2555276155471802,
-0.7184353470802307,
0.7926637530326843,
0.5716041326522827,
-0.20331282913684845,
-0.9358668923377991,
-0.2048163264989853,
-0.3130568861961365,
-0.7437978982925415,
0.9627108573913574,
0.1410517394542694,
-0.08493795990943909,
0.0617426373064518,
-0.3639964163303375,
-0.5930021405220032,
1.0292009115219116,
0.14014580845832825,
-0.6644912958145142,
0.13314758241176605,
0.19874335825443268,
0.6446360349655151,
-0.4382524788379669,
0.49130767583847046,
0.7569676637649536,
0.7199621200561523,
-0.21900418400764465,
-0.9079322814941406,
0.16587132215499878,
-0.8557568788528442,
0.0025493656285107136,
0.2572985291481018,
-0.5130458474159241,
0.8188826441764832,
0.2778424322605133,
-0.42008355259895325,
-0.028026241809129715,
0.46110254526138306,
0.18532463908195496,
0.20381653308868408,
0.5902381539344788,
0.4598405659198761,
0.6299358010292053,
0.00933518074452877,
1.0233309268951416,
-0.5213826298713684,
0.23321865499019623,
1.1612882614135742,
-0.40383344888687134,
1.1566979885101318,
0.23814953863620758,
-0.21929596364498138,
0.5532859563827515,
0.4778609275817871,
-0.4175284504890442,
0.06504487991333008,
0.48449593782424927,
0.08957977592945099,
-0.21020205318927765,
0.12318530678749084,
-0.3765328824520111,
0.7503352761268616,
0.24479474127292633,
-0.41531381011009216,
-0.34261804819107056,
-0.371809720993042,
-0.18647505342960358,
0.04892731457948685,
-0.08858099579811096,
0.8810147047042847,
-0.18486617505550385,
-0.7095139622688293,
0.675846517086029,
0.2030545026063919,
0.3610474765300751,
-0.765440046787262,
-0.09031222760677338,
-0.23767803609371185,
0.15329648554325104,
-0.23047423362731934,
-0.6413878202438354,
0.278129905462265,
0.33730363845825195,
-0.041200798004865646,
-0.38416677713394165,
0.5936369895935059,
-0.522364616394043,
-0.47783875465393066,
0.4088968336582184,
0.5963340401649475,
0.30024296045303345,
-0.05255260318517685,
-0.6074637174606323,
0.12695424258708954,
-0.027405304834246635,
-0.6152651309967041,
0.29875701665878296,
0.16106049716472626,
0.05096837133169174,
0.4211505353450775,
0.5838747024536133,
0.20637604594230652,
-0.13410937786102295,
-0.01554388552904129,
0.8784639239311218,
-0.7853321433067322,
-0.4907771348953247,
-0.9318704605102539,
0.5471584796905518,
-0.1339728981256485,
-0.37916305661201477,
0.969933032989502,
1.0868195295333862,
0.7748187184333801,
0.18887656927108765,
0.6823195219039917,
-0.034134138375520706,
0.25588783621788025,
-0.5415168404579163,
0.7346118688583374,
-0.7019994854927063,
0.1378183662891388,
-0.2823614478111267,
-0.9971446394920349,
0.13536851108074188,
0.5158445239067078,
-0.3856988549232483,
0.14745846390724182,
0.8907139897346497,
0.7826305031776428,
-0.029241856187582016,
-0.0858149528503418,
0.3439367115497589,
0.5375825762748718,
0.3939753770828247,
0.7155641913414001,
0.8400489687919617,
-0.44240882992744446,
0.6426569819450378,
0.0020958948880434036,
-0.37691301107406616,
-0.2610872983932495,
-0.8677700757980347,
-0.7943868041038513,
-0.4558662474155426,
-0.21693484485149384,
-0.237558513879776,
-0.028053918853402138,
0.8886721730232239,
0.5509881973266602,
-0.6277101039886475,
-0.3273923099040985,
-0.319968581199646,
0.0941905751824379,
-0.13678677380084991,
-0.3093750774860382,
0.6896785497665405,
-0.40078306198120117,
-0.7763951420783997,
0.9943264722824097,
0.421598881483078,
-0.10602135211229324,
-0.2769876718521118,
-0.04295681416988373,
-0.010031250305473804,
0.08736605197191238,
0.6977696418762207,
0.15969207882881165,
-0.15049511194229126,
-0.2518177628517151,
-0.03811046853661537,
-0.204741433262825,
0.11782445758581161,
0.8348262310028076,
-0.623015820980072,
0.20376111567020416,
0.7853833436965942,
0.6053400039672852,
0.41700759530067444,
0.239816814661026,
0.527551531791687,
-0.7698267698287964,
-0.3642268180847168,
0.13794384896755219,
0.3768974840641022,
0.13359786570072174,
-0.4136488437652588,
0.469319224357605,
-0.04030011221766472,
-0.6353425979614258,
-0.9581773281097412,
0.2592756748199463,
-0.8458627462387085,
-0.2355983406305313,
1.1212161779403687,
0.03958626091480255,
-0.4989357888698578,
-0.26910296082496643,
0.0014901825925335288,
0.10164821892976761,
-0.3046822249889374,
0.8904213309288025,
0.41920217871665955,
-0.11901772022247314,
-0.039370469748973846,
-0.6975327730178833,
0.5436466336250305,
0.3487234115600586,
-1.283694863319397,
0.4737909734249115,
0.5214055180549622,
0.39782044291496277,
-0.09937598556280136,
0.6573013067245483,
-0.10305090248584747,
0.1669614315032959,
-0.04824107512831688,
0.0712934285402298,
-0.4428935945034027,
-0.30696046352386475,
-0.17867758870124817,
0.3595021069049835,
-0.048878662288188934,
0.2506111264228821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12928v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12928v1
|
Evaluating the Generalization Ability of Quantized LLMs: Benchmark, Analysis, and Toolbox
| 2024-06-15T12:02:14 | 2024-06-15T12:02:14 |
Yijun Liu, Yuan Meng, Fang Wu, Shenhao Peng, Hang Yao, Chaoyu Guan, Chen Tang, Xinzhu Ma, Zhi Wang, Wenwu Zhu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have exhibited exciting progress in multiple
scenarios, while the huge computational demands hinder their deployments in
lots of real-world applications. As an effective means to reduce memory
footprint and inference cost, quantization also faces challenges in performance
degradation at low bit-widths. Understanding the impact of quantization on LLM
capabilities, especially the generalization ability, is crucial. However, the
community's main focus remains on the algorithms and models of quantization,
with insufficient attention given to whether the quantized models can retain
the strong generalization abilities of LLMs. In this work, we fill this gap by
providing a comprehensive benchmark suite for this research topic, including an
evaluation system, detailed analyses, and a general toolbox. Specifically,
based on the dominant pipeline in LLM quantization, we primarily explore the
impact of calibration data distribution on the generalization of quantized LLMs
and conduct the benchmark using more than 40 datasets within two main
scenarios. Based on this benchmark, we conduct extensive experiments with two
well-known LLMs (English and Chinese) and four quantization algorithms to
investigate this topic in-depth, yielding several counter-intuitive and
valuable findings, e.g., models quantized using a calibration set with the same
distribution as the test data are not necessarily optimal. Besides, to
facilitate future research, we also release a modular-designed toolbox, which
decouples the overall pipeline into several separate components, e.g., base LLM
module, dataset module, quantizer module, etc. and allows subsequent
researchers to easily assemble their methods through a simple configuration.
Our benchmark suite is publicly available at
https://github.com/TsingmaoAI/MI-optimize
|
[
-0.22844497859477997,
-0.6205806732177734,
0.5446213483810425,
0.24481309950351715,
-0.4310177266597748,
0.002788640558719635,
-0.3630465269088745,
-0.09031524509191513,
-0.21596166491508484,
0.5377071499824524,
-0.2444574534893036,
-0.8586536645889282,
-0.4792051315307617,
0.12554652988910675,
-0.49099335074424744,
0.7802467942237854,
-0.01953260973095894,
0.12141319364309311,
-0.1968345046043396,
-0.3024924397468567,
-0.2449718862771988,
-0.5062270760536194,
-0.3407507538795471,
-0.059051208198070526,
0.18478944897651672,
-0.03804614022374153,
0.5901877880096436,
0.6147122383117676,
0.5144156813621521,
0.2979649603366852,
-0.13460633158683777,
-0.301588237285614,
-0.48610854148864746,
0.033227402716875076,
0.04447922483086586,
-0.7381141185760498,
-0.6599032878875732,
-0.18070022761821747,
1.0594784021377563,
0.6177014708518982,
-0.3508053719997406,
0.3797280490398407,
0.13904862105846405,
0.6653209328651428,
-0.905068039894104,
0.001448885421268642,
-0.5828600525856018,
0.0870710238814354,
-0.17885439097881317,
-0.013877829536795616,
-0.2675349712371826,
-0.5552265644073486,
0.19181065261363983,
-0.537555456161499,
0.4050270915031433,
-0.16270142793655396,
0.4321433901786804,
0.28279194235801697,
-0.6668047308921814,
0.03376898169517517,
-0.8092019557952881,
1.086898684501648,
-0.7007336020469666,
0.46206778287887573,
0.2205417901277542,
0.5000693798065186,
0.19781792163848877,
-0.7582828998565674,
-0.056764956563711166,
0.0025527537800371647,
0.22951041162014008,
0.07758025079965591,
-0.367981493473053,
0.23623113334178925,
0.45361924171447754,
0.763905942440033,
-0.8131489157676697,
-0.025234829634428024,
-0.11661503463983536,
-0.37365657091140747,
0.4843766391277313,
0.3099243640899658,
0.00015368679305538535,
0.07747786492109299,
-0.14656555652618408,
-0.26879048347473145,
-0.7946528196334839,
-0.061648137867450714,
0.38864368200302124,
-0.15139806270599365,
-0.16546326875686646,
0.3349987268447876,
-0.48006659746170044,
0.6619038581848145,
-0.4084935784339905,
0.07967841625213623,
0.2619278132915497,
-0.6451468467712402,
-0.4456687271595001,
-0.46425989270210266,
0.936095118522644,
0.24523311853408813,
0.33092936873435974,
-0.22130899131298065,
-0.33572015166282654,
-0.09617596119642258,
-0.13095375895500183,
-1.203860878944397,
-0.042077191174030304,
0.14162293076515198,
-0.30444255471229553,
-0.16655254364013672,
-0.08755858987569809,
-0.506795346736908,
-0.2127491533756256,
-0.12460201233625412,
0.3972508907318115,
-0.2587428092956543,
-0.235128715634346,
0.24076557159423828,
-0.053883522748947144,
0.20995713770389557,
0.16024476289749146,
-0.8706417083740234,
0.3609899580478668,
0.7888609766960144,
0.7995867133140564,
-0.05010240897536278,
0.13085342943668365,
-0.5825432538986206,
0.14946047961711884,
-0.2766818404197693,
0.5322625041007996,
-0.33296504616737366,
-0.4170030355453491,
0.06288109719753265,
-0.09495263546705246,
0.1585797816514969,
-0.8789313435554504,
0.4296746850013733,
-0.6062047481536865,
-0.23733176290988922,
-0.04362934082746506,
-0.4401242136955261,
0.0031509180553257465,
0.2769152522087097,
-0.7124959826469421,
0.6049027442932129,
0.11272816359996796,
-0.5314015746116638,
0.20981493592262268,
-0.17124180495738983,
-0.00853183213621378,
0.07811413705348969,
-0.19205254316329956,
-0.4891357123851776,
0.43857356905937195,
0.29028233885765076,
0.31692934036254883,
-0.6790425777435303,
0.5431613326072693,
-0.5093092322349548,
-0.7247226238250732,
0.29593396186828613,
-0.6667214035987854,
0.7176351547241211,
-0.0010830593528226018,
-0.22712142765522003,
0.03598282113671303,
-0.746396005153656,
0.27311405539512634,
-0.05360782891511917,
-0.3858882188796997,
-0.33587437868118286,
-0.058402568101882935,
-0.04940316826105118,
-0.2965831160545349,
0.2255225032567978,
-0.3748685121536255,
0.3361622393131256,
-0.41783785820007324,
0.6347678899765015,
0.6924474239349365,
-0.025424515828490257,
0.3878386318683624,
-0.05282557010650635,
0.8807772994041443,
-0.022427916526794434,
0.21054360270500183,
-0.243831068277359,
-0.1242053359746933,
-0.5700272917747498,
-0.3365735411643982,
0.8392248153686523,
0.4599798321723938,
-0.6494446396827698,
0.21585923433303833,
-0.5807525515556335,
-0.23281848430633545,
-0.5865622758865356,
0.18125881254673004,
0.62248694896698,
-0.08104044198989868,
0.08101021498441696,
-0.2759309709072113,
-0.32869529724121094,
-1.0971965789794922,
-0.20975735783576965,
0.06748821586370468,
-0.5880500674247742,
0.02232721447944641,
0.2836543917655945,
-0.32427534461021423,
0.9237011075019836,
-0.4292547404766083,
0.018541067838668823,
0.09318668395280838,
-0.0058631496503949165,
0.28001102805137634,
0.22430047392845154,
0.30467259883880615,
-0.4969300925731659,
-0.31650519371032715,
0.0077245780266821384,
-0.6301193833351135,
-0.3796049654483795,
0.29803091287612915,
-0.09564173966646194,
0.07527271658182144,
0.33117932081222534,
-0.2205977439880371,
0.45288336277008057,
0.7991598844528198,
0.029625441879034042,
0.6709966659545898,
-0.09463249891996384,
-0.016871055588126183,
-0.9178109169006348,
0.19544608891010284,
0.20733414590358734,
-0.2855782210826874,
-0.4232444167137146,
0.16072192788124084,
0.39597705006599426,
0.009018013253808022,
-0.3283785581588745,
0.535498857498169,
-0.3185337781906128,
-0.40093764662742615,
-0.1004837155342102,
0.04918036609888077,
0.001302191405557096,
0.297283798456192,
-0.20292764902114868,
0.9700927734375,
0.48435258865356445,
-0.350664347410202,
0.3285067081451416,
-0.25817495584487915,
-0.38520386815071106,
0.5143395662307739,
-0.9452376961708069,
0.03715059533715248,
0.10259036719799042,
0.23254232108592987,
-0.8211525082588196,
0.16256286203861237,
-0.04273498058319092,
-0.17451918125152588,
0.028204726055264473,
-0.2612966299057007,
-0.9519352912902832,
-0.04838663339614868,
-0.6111183166503906,
0.6672874689102173,
0.5305799245834351,
-0.21199965476989746,
0.5740747451782227,
0.08475042879581451,
0.06659477204084396,
-0.34625300765037537,
-0.5553954243659973,
-0.07407288998365402,
-0.5919787883758545,
-0.5102316737174988,
0.27874991297721863,
-0.3794335424900055,
-0.3736535608768463,
-0.26097625494003296,
-0.1885479837656021,
-0.02170628122985363,
0.13433609902858734,
0.21268437802791595,
0.17720673978328705,
-0.2352379858493805,
0.2799684703350067,
0.12122038751840591,
-0.35115644335746765,
0.15224497020244598,
-0.15596027672290802,
0.5071671605110168,
-0.40254470705986023,
-0.29039621353149414,
-0.21512560546398163,
-0.050558026880025864,
0.30594196915626526,
-0.27991044521331787,
0.4715874493122101,
0.6680483818054199,
-0.2138901650905609,
-0.2886606454849243,
-0.6561754941940308,
-0.06339094787836075,
-0.5184751749038696,
0.6026372909545898,
-0.49999141693115234,
-0.9090442657470703,
0.6126091480255127,
-0.20034518837928772,
0.06174599751830101,
0.1757483333349228,
0.5404487252235413,
0.19654962420463562,
1.1415327787399292,
0.37907975912094116,
-0.2340228110551834,
0.26182126998901367,
-0.5222190618515015,
-0.050735436379909515,
-1.2130157947540283,
0.2987731993198395,
-0.3293287456035614,
-0.20554423332214355,
-0.722801148891449,
-0.4726994037628174,
0.4738194942474365,
0.2818654179573059,
-0.2051502764225006,
0.16611461341381073,
-0.35693755745887756,
0.48940497636795044,
0.4389614462852478,
-0.013300508260726929,
0.5927417874336243,
0.03141779452562332,
-0.14565002918243408,
-0.006271994207054377,
-0.3905419707298279,
-0.5983343720436096,
1.6030362844467163,
0.46052685379981995,
0.6508810520172119,
0.1465757191181183,
0.6526076197624207,
0.18092958629131317,
0.32637929916381836,
-0.7229593992233276,
0.6602712869644165,
-0.22110357880592346,
-0.3008722960948944,
-0.1977475881576538,
-0.6549910306930542,
-0.9382463693618774,
0.5777693390846252,
0.172045037150383,
-0.6079434752464294,
0.03435424715280533,
0.04663193225860596,
-0.3110511302947998,
0.0672868862748146,
-0.7108614444732666,
0.7159517407417297,
-0.060279544442892075,
-0.38537701964378357,
-0.24936628341674805,
-0.3744490444660187,
0.6326286196708679,
-0.3232685327529907,
0.2962089478969574,
-0.2303641438484192,
-0.3508535921573639,
0.6404992938041687,
-0.21890002489089966,
0.6680116653442383,
-0.07333739846944809,
-0.35938405990600586,
-0.025626158341765404,
-0.05405791476368904,
0.28819581866264343,
0.2848302721977234,
-0.2721056342124939,
0.3779800236225128,
0.4151587188243866,
-0.40998321771621704,
-0.5934416651725769,
0.5943976640701294,
-0.7158870697021484,
-0.60678631067276,
-0.03445279970765114,
-0.5970775485038757,
-0.3643566370010376,
0.04965575411915779,
0.19006918370723724,
0.5843932032585144,
-0.17482665181159973,
0.38107702136039734,
0.6327223181724548,
-0.22994756698608398,
0.3224358856678009,
0.5823934674263,
-0.3730485737323761,
-0.7906356453895569,
0.9447269439697266,
0.11589665710926056,
0.47843480110168457,
0.3704606592655182,
0.22570283710956573,
-0.19957229495048523,
-0.8261955976486206,
-0.33807504177093506,
0.3041144907474518,
-0.7366591095924377,
-0.26751330494880676,
-0.24142047762870789,
-0.05366016924381256,
-0.3248986601829529,
0.20157234370708466,
-0.15215960144996643,
-0.3881336450576782,
-0.2799984812736511,
0.10781124234199524,
-0.057799749076366425,
0.45798414945602417,
0.23029665648937225,
0.4155745804309845,
-0.8033411502838135,
0.19159142673015594,
0.4989771246910095,
0.39451077580451965,
0.09900899231433868,
-0.31864500045776367,
-0.467649906873703,
0.1589820235967636,
-0.4957514703273773,
-0.5804851651191711,
0.06024226173758507,
0.09556427597999573,
0.47072795033454895,
0.5456481575965881,
-0.026847345754504204,
0.6964895129203796,
-0.2392725646495819,
0.38721075654029846,
-0.11071957647800446,
-1.0372822284698486,
0.4957174062728882,
-0.37913525104522705,
0.5700550079345703,
0.547626256942749,
0.028199607506394386,
-0.4073837697505951,
-0.41873276233673096,
-0.4258103668689728,
-0.7861891388893127,
0.39830467104911804,
0.17441999912261963,
0.07877117395401001,
0.18245914578437805,
0.27416083216667175,
-0.07401230931282043,
0.3976448178291321,
-0.6814891695976257,
-0.20311589539051056,
0.17275381088256836,
-0.05816081538796425,
-0.11869664490222931,
-0.29549771547317505,
-0.07108481228351593,
-0.17068339884281158,
0.4230293929576874,
-0.2132614403963089,
0.08774510771036148,
-0.26532718539237976,
-0.22833548486232758,
0.08525677770376205,
0.439810574054718,
0.4281582236289978,
0.6529595255851746,
-0.31654611229896545,
0.08000855147838593,
0.27292779088020325,
-0.5120276212692261,
0.20356309413909912,
0.19814635813236237,
-0.15832208096981049,
-0.16448545455932617,
0.36982253193855286,
0.7396801710128784,
0.37500786781311035,
-0.8055062890052795,
0.5275494456291199,
-0.23984532058238983,
-0.2154458910226822,
-0.08872605115175247,
0.21804635226726532,
0.19670720398426056,
0.4082920551300049,
0.48063939809799194,
-0.5178509950637817,
0.3669847249984741,
-0.3494783937931061,
-0.06604009866714478,
0.788962721824646,
0.07348638772964478,
-0.5715120434761047,
0.486123651266098,
0.12898097932338715,
-0.10374786704778671,
0.5492085218429565,
-0.20739133656024933,
-0.3908766508102417,
0.6956529021263123,
0.33352401852607727,
1.0075358152389526,
-0.02557552419602871,
0.025226105004549026,
0.3634285628795624,
0.1724330335855484,
0.04804794117808342,
-0.02737095206975937,
-0.38910964131355286,
-0.5111145973205566,
-0.5329769253730774,
-0.6476609706878662,
-0.45968449115753174,
0.06047656759619713,
-0.7758150696754456,
0.20332007110118866,
-0.34024444222450256,
-0.377655953168869,
-0.30961206555366516,
0.24169473350048065,
-0.7154784798622131,
0.027354706078767776,
0.09527242183685303,
0.6458858847618103,
-0.6361639499664307,
0.9013828039169312,
0.6051867604255676,
0.1502648890018463,
-0.5500786304473877,
0.08163299411535263,
-0.1209159567952156,
-0.9348873496055603,
0.5072187781333923,
0.1785959005355835,
0.11748266220092773,
0.32049375772476196,
-0.3606627881526947,
-0.8590438961982727,
1.4877691268920898,
0.47362658381462097,
-0.9112087488174438,
0.06209580600261688,
0.5106568932533264,
0.6150503158569336,
-0.008671355433762074,
0.6164395213127136,
0.9347143769264221,
0.34768202900886536,
0.06147875636816025,
-0.9977642297744751,
0.04906286299228668,
-0.16591203212738037,
0.6023843884468079,
0.4601360559463501,
-0.5742574334144592,
0.5047776699066162,
0.14587970077991486,
-0.41828298568725586,
0.1710364669561386,
0.32238221168518066,
0.6486014723777771,
0.1559045910835266,
0.3540826439857483,
0.8174961805343628,
0.40283212065696716,
-0.16457682847976685,
0.8121448755264282,
-0.2873276174068451,
0.6155454516410828,
0.7311198711395264,
-0.23965919017791748,
0.8144562840461731,
0.43842366337776184,
-0.7009618282318115,
0.13117802143096924,
0.3724224269390106,
-0.10467328131198883,
0.4906338155269623,
0.728206992149353,
-0.510936439037323,
-0.08363168686628342,
-0.004921661224216223,
-0.40151798725128174,
0.07369917631149292,
0.2144099622964859,
-0.2622498869895935,
-0.2779221832752228,
0.0748530775308609,
-0.3408217132091522,
-0.34290003776550293,
-0.2692406475543976,
0.6707786917686462,
0.0633838102221489,
-0.2232634574174881,
0.8125607371330261,
0.01563737355172634,
0.8581987619400024,
-0.5176331400871277,
0.1511496901512146,
-0.3395463526248932,
0.1498396396636963,
-0.047317542135715485,
-0.48256054520606995,
0.14669345319271088,
-0.1052071824669838,
0.007503557950258255,
-0.10401072353124619,
0.3222425878047943,
-0.17801693081855774,
-0.5379028916358948,
0.09198437631130219,
0.4003264904022217,
0.05363468825817108,
-0.1989748775959015,
-0.4560708701610565,
0.49088290333747864,
0.019878821447491646,
-0.40904468297958374,
0.6021871566772461,
0.38814160227775574,
-0.11000341176986694,
0.6975361108779907,
0.5182837247848511,
0.2317078858613968,
0.06251796334981918,
0.18535615503787994,
0.735073983669281,
-0.6927013397216797,
-0.13334175944328308,
-0.9304313659667969,
0.542059600353241,
0.2090975046157837,
-0.13335612416267395,
0.6737517714500427,
0.7302286624908447,
0.8142068386077881,
0.1075495257973671,
0.6225246787071228,
0.33988362550735474,
0.15970848500728607,
-0.5026107430458069,
0.37205249071121216,
-0.4423564076423645,
0.6269310712814331,
-0.15626777708530426,
-1.2644755840301514,
-0.39797350764274597,
0.36274394392967224,
-0.49483850598335266,
0.15715435147285461,
0.5551096200942993,
0.6341631412506104,
0.11907095462083817,
-0.26873672008514404,
0.5479788184165955,
-0.05814444273710251,
0.4101828932762146,
0.7707146406173706,
0.7879072427749634,
-0.5495439767837524,
0.6515256762504578,
-0.46574604511260986,
-0.1813732534646988,
-0.11964323371648788,
-0.815126895904541,
-0.7284126281738281,
-0.47974255681037903,
-0.48074015974998474,
0.08396199345588684,
0.026543833315372467,
0.4060927629470825,
0.6853988766670227,
-0.553371787071228,
-0.3857238292694092,
-0.1559489369392395,
0.0007916268077678978,
0.11907082796096802,
-0.29252925515174866,
0.3445572555065155,
-0.013365034013986588,
-0.9478327631950378,
-0.05389445275068283,
0.29550477862358093,
0.14259880781173706,
-0.48308899998664856,
-0.09440193325281143,
0.46089744567871094,
-0.18644778430461884,
0.5759080648422241,
-0.016492389142513275,
-0.7634435296058655,
0.06729314476251602,
-0.048430681228637695,
-0.09232228994369507,
-0.03042660467326641,
0.7362091541290283,
-0.9025656580924988,
0.4503595232963562,
0.3472519814968109,
0.531169056892395,
0.5256879925727844,
0.051771003752946854,
0.5326754450798035,
-0.7109981775283813,
-0.07727352529764175,
0.17990215122699738,
0.32614386081695557,
0.14190827310085297,
0.07079426199197769,
0.7694909572601318,
0.030991757288575172,
-0.7644692063331604,
-1.0726463794708252,
-0.040178559720516205,
-0.714318573474884,
0.0636710450053215,
1.1603050231933594,
-0.19695885479450226,
-0.04107499495148659,
0.2862158417701721,
0.03546740859746933,
0.2141391932964325,
-0.26626983284950256,
0.5180989503860474,
0.8023389577865601,
0.2790272831916809,
-0.3501209318637848,
-0.7365619540214539,
0.04779508337378502,
0.5159375071525574,
-0.747031033039093,
0.19780755043029785,
0.5233717560768127,
0.4643961191177368,
-0.21840523183345795,
0.5290495753288269,
-0.06510064005851746,
0.2678844630718231,
-0.4155164361000061,
0.09614879637956619,
0.06141947582364082,
0.20863661170005798,
-0.8901873230934143,
-0.05792445316910744,
0.1684538573026657,
-0.12228164076805115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10602v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10602v1
|
Multilingual Large Language Models and Curse of Multilinguality
| 2024-06-15T11:31:39 | 2024-06-15T11:31:39 |
Daniil Gurgurov, Tanja Bäumel, Tatiana Anikina
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multilingual Large Language Models (LLMs) have gained large popularity among
Natural Language Processing (NLP) researchers and practitioners. These models,
trained on huge datasets, show proficiency across various languages and
demonstrate effectiveness in numerous downstream tasks. This paper navigates
the landscape of multilingual LLMs, providing an introductory overview of their
technical aspects. It explains underlying architectures, objective functions,
pre-training data sources, and tokenization methods. This work explores the
unique features of different model types: encoder-only (mBERT, XLM-R),
decoder-only (XGLM, PALM, BLOOM, GPT-3), and encoder-decoder models (mT5,
mBART). Additionally, it addresses one of the significant limitations of
multilingual LLMs - the curse of multilinguality - and discusses current
attempts to overcome it.
|
[
-0.4365652799606323,
-0.599449098110199,
0.38708609342575073,
0.3071139454841614,
-0.07025106251239777,
0.5601096153259277,
-0.38842108845710754,
-0.6745163798332214,
0.26388218998908997,
0.77364182472229,
-0.254041850566864,
-0.33597227931022644,
-0.8908938765525818,
0.22078867256641388,
-0.3411436080932617,
1.010046362876892,
-0.10589675605297089,
0.4036356210708618,
-0.16425208747386932,
-0.13062632083892822,
-0.27664902806282043,
-1.1520545482635498,
-0.7056121826171875,
-0.23365791141986847,
0.5552309155464172,
0.19137373566627502,
0.6588829755783081,
0.5125682353973389,
0.5728311538696289,
0.22858606278896332,
-0.13634945452213287,
0.22071270644664764,
-0.43179330229759216,
0.1876205950975418,
0.23037971556186676,
-0.6271176934242249,
-0.2940601110458374,
-0.1958652287721634,
0.6770279407501221,
0.9196319580078125,
-0.06438528746366501,
0.1655714362859726,
0.1159939393401146,
0.3201536238193512,
-0.33343270421028137,
0.21492792665958405,
-0.6357482671737671,
0.11905991286039352,
-0.6411690711975098,
-0.11300979554653168,
-0.49025559425354004,
-0.00086574925808236,
-0.3351576328277588,
-0.14135123789310455,
-0.014077532105147839,
0.12013623118400574,
0.46236202120780945,
0.14839452505111694,
-0.901792585849762,
-0.5058613419532776,
-0.7463629245758057,
0.9075155854225159,
-0.5991306900978088,
0.5803465247154236,
0.5439221262931824,
0.18486204743385315,
0.050347700715065,
-0.3458377718925476,
-0.20696167647838593,
-0.3063737154006958,
0.09551952034235,
-0.1277569979429245,
0.09088229387998581,
0.02617828920483589,
0.03496668487787247,
0.40673524141311646,
-0.5442394018173218,
0.47162681818008423,
-0.3172498941421509,
-0.04868095740675926,
0.35215309262275696,
0.09202496707439423,
0.3370659649372101,
-0.13425937294960022,
-0.27943694591522217,
0.4823513925075531,
-0.9283542633056641,
-0.31304818391799927,
0.4295955300331116,
0.5213944911956787,
-0.06537619233131409,
0.6101312637329102,
0.34440886974334717,
0.7851417064666748,
-0.4876406490802765,
-0.2981589734554291,
0.16737104952335358,
-0.22257237136363983,
0.0028140200302004814,
-0.06945275515317917,
0.593478798866272,
-0.15064214169979095,
0.5125625729560852,
-0.3860102891921997,
-0.23017005622386932,
-0.11068998277187347,
-0.020911481231451035,
-0.4494144916534424,
0.009898216463625431,
0.24575091898441315,
-0.3160496950149536,
0.0665421336889267,
-0.23578542470932007,
-0.6113312840461731,
-0.401187926530838,
-0.25759831070899963,
0.05831880122423172,
-0.29887956380844116,
-0.3167354464530945,
0.21072335541248322,
0.1468486785888672,
0.2389131337404251,
0.02702406607568264,
-0.9988656640052795,
0.24779845774173737,
0.737937331199646,
0.7650387287139893,
-0.14727573096752167,
-0.5361889004707336,
-0.35949406027793884,
0.2318970113992691,
-0.300540566444397,
0.43476182222366333,
-0.5912109613418579,
-0.38759493827819824,
0.16375093162059784,
-0.038588035851716995,
0.02900432050228119,
-0.46054527163505554,
0.533048152923584,
-0.6690938472747803,
-0.2553960084915161,
-0.33014166355133057,
-0.443579763174057,
-0.27936482429504395,
0.5424080491065979,
-0.6777492761611938,
0.837637722492218,
-0.15129803121089935,
-0.5653001070022583,
0.2585923671722412,
-0.6147019863128662,
-0.5648740530014038,
0.157286137342453,
0.05168605223298073,
0.1367442011833191,
0.29972216486930847,
0.11320611834526062,
0.5087547302246094,
-0.40957391262054443,
0.3800615966320038,
-0.25437822937965393,
-0.03325926139950752,
0.21378880739212036,
-0.5839281678199768,
0.825914740562439,
0.20898234844207764,
0.05618354305624962,
-0.09389660507440567,
-0.8274086117744446,
-0.3117718994617462,
0.17081792652606964,
-0.5788411498069763,
-0.2882338762283325,
0.06861709803342819,
0.3192012906074524,
0.319681316614151,
0.3224310278892517,
-0.387430876493454,
0.09282363206148148,
-0.18502174317836761,
0.5723806619644165,
0.5320208072662354,
-0.5376143455505371,
0.11228064447641373,
-0.09192334860563278,
0.6052265763282776,
0.2470686286687851,
0.11696653068065643,
-0.28314077854156494,
-0.5605952739715576,
-0.7418039441108704,
-0.18927817046642303,
0.35938340425491333,
0.6242939829826355,
-0.8454502820968628,
-0.07954741269350052,
-0.26648980379104614,
-0.2778739631175995,
-0.5393683910369873,
0.48729023337364197,
0.30872806906700134,
-0.0536644421517849,
0.20540639758110046,
-0.11269757896661758,
-0.5555304884910583,
-0.847282350063324,
-0.20073074102401733,
0.11292741447687149,
0.2542169988155365,
-0.00976154301315546,
0.525426983833313,
-0.2982330024242401,
0.5057080984115601,
-0.25163939595222473,
-0.32113906741142273,
-0.616895318031311,
0.01947944425046444,
0.19303689897060394,
0.400381475687027,
0.6460536122322083,
-0.8311558365821838,
-0.5225724577903748,
0.2285471111536026,
-0.672987699508667,
0.1415238380432129,
0.10384610295295715,
0.46940186619758606,
0.33983534574508667,
0.502888560295105,
-0.6061751246452332,
-0.12631206214427948,
0.8132901787757874,
0.010126764886081219,
0.7493729591369629,
-0.3517426550388336,
0.04025328531861305,
-1.0359907150268555,
-0.07896724343299866,
0.008466597646474838,
-0.33627092838287354,
-0.8680648803710938,
0.5605838298797607,
-0.06109084188938141,
-0.09296489506959915,
-0.3747691214084625,
0.6124365925788879,
-0.7897413372993469,
-0.18888229131698608,
-0.16116701066493988,
0.19978545606136322,
-0.1721479743719101,
0.37268951535224915,
0.06615480035543442,
0.5895240902900696,
0.5380164980888367,
-0.5363028049468994,
0.5705118775367737,
0.10881814360618591,
-0.25614091753959656,
0.39689549803733826,
-0.3283044099807739,
0.1350902020931244,
-0.24436549842357635,
-0.06482471525669098,
-0.6927878856658936,
-0.19358417391777039,
-0.03194388374686241,
-0.3074466288089752,
0.5880539417266846,
-0.3590806722640991,
-0.7847716808319092,
-0.5527316331863403,
-0.1902221292257309,
0.5451314449310303,
0.20521892607212067,
-0.6420190334320068,
0.5051906704902649,
0.5192729234695435,
-0.35323965549468994,
-0.7041163444519043,
-0.9320176839828491,
0.6620813012123108,
-0.2645391523838043,
-0.4570614993572235,
-0.0458960086107254,
-0.2779400944709778,
-0.3482224643230438,
-0.3597365617752075,
0.43327105045318604,
-0.2579515278339386,
0.11394847184419632,
0.06514207273721695,
0.11153439432382584,
-0.21867845952510834,
0.1833261102437973,
-0.21086876094341278,
-0.07715553790330887,
-0.01150992140173912,
-0.2737700343132019,
0.7046137452125549,
-0.19884145259857178,
-0.5350432395935059,
0.1969238519668579,
0.5328388810157776,
0.55103999376297,
-0.31455495953559875,
0.8945105671882629,
0.6050093173980713,
-0.4395883083343506,
0.053964462131261826,
-0.7432222962379456,
0.17709697782993317,
-0.3858315348625183,
0.5755541324615479,
-0.6292058825492859,
-0.928219199180603,
0.7256717681884766,
-0.019640184938907623,
0.11922189593315125,
0.2057303488254547,
0.6163674592971802,
0.2889297306537628,
1.0000072717666626,
0.7029863595962524,
-0.2890191674232483,
0.13499248027801514,
-0.04414926469326019,
0.3150663673877716,
-0.6578370928764343,
-0.1376534104347229,
-0.5818096399307251,
0.04811234027147293,
-0.5922327041625977,
-0.448566198348999,
0.2631794810295105,
0.0715259537100792,
-0.21240434050559998,
0.10048655420541763,
-0.0038989526219666004,
0.523442268371582,
0.4713384211063385,
-0.3753126263618469,
0.49104195833206177,
-0.027071638032794,
-0.2224803864955902,
-0.3063123822212219,
-0.76581871509552,
-0.5564764142036438,
1.1525681018829346,
0.4134945571422577,
0.6264913082122803,
0.31267011165618896,
0.4552689492702484,
0.11825504153966904,
0.08083972334861755,
-0.716759204864502,
0.34401774406433105,
-0.4748034179210663,
-0.7850489616394043,
-0.05409644544124603,
-0.4500315487384796,
-0.8403574228286743,
0.38160449266433716,
-0.15883475542068481,
-0.5710933208465576,
-0.05442402884364128,
0.16506272554397583,
-0.1330631822347641,
0.7321330904960632,
-0.5870182514190674,
0.6624739170074463,
-0.669914960861206,
-0.16233360767364502,
0.05126222223043442,
-0.6310861706733704,
0.6638151407241821,
-0.46873170137405396,
0.7990028262138367,
0.09432151913642883,
-0.09312674403190613,
0.44560864567756653,
-0.044458869844675064,
0.8883441090583801,
0.03425811603665352,
-0.4302104711532593,
-0.02819722704589367,
0.05318523570895195,
0.4928044080734253,
-0.09235967695713043,
-0.1313706487417221,
0.4618805944919586,
0.07548191398382187,
-0.5020020008087158,
-0.10042032599449158,
0.6880744695663452,
-0.6263521909713745,
-0.4711214303970337,
-0.28088289499282837,
-0.5658756494522095,
-0.33738934993743896,
0.2494237869977951,
0.16570302844047546,
0.5093836784362793,
-0.3132721185684204,
-0.06389044970273972,
0.5709173679351807,
-0.5329787731170654,
0.4158053696155548,
0.41623392701148987,
-0.6928125023841858,
-0.233327716588974,
1.1481471061706543,
0.23791420459747314,
0.40001118183135986,
0.448736310005188,
-0.06655678898096085,
-0.18438351154327393,
-0.8202165961265564,
-0.4155503809452057,
0.3645314872264862,
-1.0014011859893799,
0.0351116806268692,
-0.7037342190742493,
-0.309644490480423,
-0.4691725969314575,
0.01708131469786167,
-0.43018871545791626,
-0.2796816825866699,
-0.4463685154914856,
-0.04101544991135597,
0.2516131103038788,
1.0749841928482056,
-0.20601730048656464,
0.4484928548336029,
-0.8445115685462952,
0.28094637393951416,
0.04923199117183685,
0.3587173819541931,
0.08422721177339554,
-0.3198198080062866,
-0.3772372007369995,
0.0186796635389328,
-0.04511715844273567,
-0.5587339997291565,
0.6299921870231628,
0.14446140825748444,
0.46734619140625,
0.4756702482700348,
-0.30773547291755676,
0.3975202143192291,
-0.6694351434707642,
0.8197778463363647,
0.21435528993606567,
-0.7815464735031128,
-0.11800584942102432,
-0.3440319001674652,
0.13453413546085358,
0.07765810191631317,
0.5541926622390747,
-0.8957443237304688,
-0.4629686772823334,
-0.12511205673217773,
-0.828163206577301,
0.4803556799888611,
-0.22122111916542053,
0.3656304180622101,
-0.1926001012325287,
0.23049220442771912,
0.3534671664237976,
0.2786199450492859,
-1.1312614679336548,
-0.3197046220302582,
-0.09717928618192673,
-0.07079721987247467,
-0.4879411458969116,
-0.6339298486709595,
-0.028814299032092094,
-0.014334836043417454,
0.5665697455406189,
-0.13288651406764984,
-0.06991579383611679,
-0.3039744794368744,
-0.5275930166244507,
0.21280938386917114,
0.4628530740737915,
0.6854938268661499,
0.5825970768928528,
0.013107875362038612,
0.41582003235816956,
0.18139995634555817,
-0.411612331867218,
0.13123206794261932,
-0.06806854903697968,
0.0632137805223465,
-0.00874100998044014,
0.4590921401977539,
0.8835768699645996,
0.33992233872413635,
-0.5692806839942932,
0.19566841423511505,
0.15382830798625946,
-0.09715505689382553,
-0.3977358639240265,
-0.3971461355686188,
0.5137447118759155,
0.06931695342063904,
0.4179037809371948,
-0.1446198672056198,
-0.09350965172052383,
-0.604978621006012,
-0.24736161530017853,
0.5940496921539307,
-0.22379840910434723,
-0.3708283305168152,
0.5976166725158691,
0.1452372968196869,
-0.19657009840011597,
0.47648441791534424,
-0.25550076365470886,
-0.6109810471534729,
0.3789834678173065,
0.6283725500106812,
0.5641976594924927,
-0.2566653788089752,
0.021010935306549072,
0.06413432210683823,
0.634198009967804,
-0.08213182538747787,
0.18605808913707733,
0.28189143538475037,
-0.8598541021347046,
-0.62363600730896,
-0.8337819576263428,
-0.36156460642814636,
0.1432376652956009,
-0.4877091944217682,
0.1654176563024521,
-0.1624477058649063,
-0.16497157514095306,
-0.05630673095583916,
-0.15117964148521423,
-0.6143090128898621,
-0.08701515942811966,
0.3197137415409088,
0.8315281867980957,
-0.5883330702781677,
0.9335016012191772,
0.43952247500419617,
-0.1578274816274643,
-0.31614238023757935,
-0.3832947611808777,
0.027861133217811584,
-1.0975732803344727,
0.8164146542549133,
-0.0754610002040863,
0.09865859895944595,
0.1656341701745987,
-0.2666463553905487,
-0.8135449290275574,
0.4292663335800171,
0.5761418342590332,
-0.6215174794197083,
-0.05687874183058739,
0.6031782627105713,
0.3638996481895447,
-0.23992227017879486,
0.10055217891931534,
0.6738528609275818,
0.7146971225738525,
-0.16445405781269073,
-0.9205968379974365,
-0.38036206364631653,
0.006673316936939955,
0.0508660227060318,
0.30528441071510315,
-0.5280887484550476,
0.8975615501403809,
-0.2689898610115051,
0.042474519461393356,
-0.05260656401515007,
0.2752392888069153,
0.082769975066185,
-0.1261778175830841,
-0.0008579826098866761,
0.3164215087890625,
0.607231855392456,
-0.19069696962833405,
1.1501234769821167,
-0.5474318861961365,
0.19774918258190155,
1.0529359579086304,
-0.5029526352882385,
0.822114884853363,
0.5841066241264343,
-0.35430213809013367,
0.06524220108985901,
0.682095468044281,
-0.06179657578468323,
-0.024537233635783195,
0.27150478959083557,
-0.2834462821483612,
-0.19733771681785583,
-0.0644604042172432,
-0.3390926122665405,
0.587917149066925,
0.42829471826553345,
-0.18457187712192535,
-0.25705912709236145,
0.41622668504714966,
0.217251256108284,
-0.1571730375289917,
-0.5463425517082214,
0.6018480658531189,
0.3652394115924835,
-0.31798064708709717,
0.45554864406585693,
0.2349562644958496,
0.9515087008476257,
-0.7259835004806519,
0.33383122086524963,
-0.1439874768257141,
0.1299639195203781,
-0.10849922895431519,
-0.608859121799469,
0.43160954117774963,
0.05115921050310135,
-0.2337811142206192,
-0.26891347765922546,
0.4830029010772705,
-0.6376389861106873,
-0.7888137698173523,
0.6785223484039307,
0.6803820133209229,
0.3627158999443054,
-0.03958647698163986,
-0.5877369046211243,
0.17872022092342377,
-0.2538287043571472,
-0.24969494342803955,
0.4699108600616455,
0.3451138734817505,
0.02434048242866993,
0.9647871255874634,
0.4706796407699585,
0.4266242980957031,
0.3408352732658386,
0.259952574968338,
0.3973613977432251,
-0.845314621925354,
-0.15612439811229706,
-0.9730440378189087,
0.11020469665527344,
0.4565281271934509,
-0.0849236324429512,
0.9716105461120605,
0.6923093199729919,
0.6633245348930359,
-0.21102967858314514,
0.786281943321228,
0.2625744044780731,
0.37927547097206116,
-0.6115922927856445,
0.7093610167503357,
-0.6656093001365662,
0.229048952460289,
-0.018574308604002,
-0.7160456776618958,
-0.5763020515441895,
0.10725057870149612,
-0.0751602053642273,
0.3238374590873718,
0.539027988910675,
0.5291152000427246,
0.02056112512946129,
-0.08096207678318024,
0.5971571207046509,
0.43122416734695435,
0.2660216987133026,
0.4819279611110687,
0.9258108735084534,
-0.04098201170563698,
0.5042946934700012,
0.12404945492744446,
-0.017191555351018906,
-0.13670912384986877,
-0.8786136507987976,
-0.7951908707618713,
-0.4289788007736206,
-0.05338715389370918,
-0.04559449106454849,
-0.13590842485427856,
0.7297760844230652,
0.5931845307350159,
-0.7605783939361572,
-0.6356129050254822,
0.2593344748020172,
0.28786322474479675,
0.04872548207640648,
-0.13386033475399017,
0.07840799540281296,
-0.47551432251930237,
-0.7413210868835449,
0.36184775829315186,
0.3831821084022522,
0.3011023998260498,
-0.6291346549987793,
-0.06402425467967987,
-0.24442726373672485,
0.06358036398887634,
0.8763220310211182,
0.2417815923690796,
-0.8401296734809875,
0.0030916512478142977,
-0.16536268591880798,
0.052273187786340714,
0.2275947630405426,
0.7923851609230042,
-0.42059290409088135,
0.2509337365627289,
-0.009592466056346893,
0.5289791226387024,
0.3552333116531372,
-0.6580772399902344,
0.5686137676239014,
-0.6876432299613953,
0.11175140738487244,
0.03079897351562977,
0.6332908868789673,
0.703636109828949,
-0.13648444414138794,
0.38207733631134033,
0.1159655749797821,
-0.41551485657691956,
-1.0750274658203125,
0.30322739481925964,
-0.6399977803230286,
-0.4202241599559784,
1.0847548246383667,
-0.037165794521570206,
-0.030037609860301018,
-0.3982833921909332,
-0.0656374990940094,
0.05559885501861572,
0.176969513297081,
0.3992241621017456,
1.067986011505127,
0.2251913994550705,
-0.33206233382225037,
-0.923946738243103,
0.3852999210357666,
0.10002752393484116,
-0.7701296210289001,
0.2553674280643463,
0.2672571837902069,
0.3126155734062195,
0.23219379782676697,
0.5097649693489075,
-0.12094948440790176,
-0.2610636353492737,
0.03938448429107666,
0.2348363846540451,
0.03684981167316437,
-0.4687826931476593,
-0.5166119337081909,
0.29222285747528076,
0.4676777124404907,
0.24662406742572784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10594v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10594v2
|
BlockPruner: Fine-grained Pruning for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-15T11:03:33 | 2024-06-20T04:25:49 |
Longguang Zhong, Fanqi Wan, Ruijun Chen, Xiaojun Quan, Liangzhi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the rapid growth in the size and complexity of large language models
(LLMs), the costs associated with their training and inference have escalated
significantly. Research indicates that certain layers in LLMs harbor
substantial redundancy, and pruning these layers has minimal impact on the
overall performance. While various layer pruning methods have been developed
based on this insight, they generally overlook the finer-grained redundancies
within the layers themselves. In this paper, we delve deeper into the
architecture of LLMs and demonstrate that finer-grained pruning can be achieved
by targeting redundancies in multi-head attention (MHA) and multi-layer
perceptron (MLP) blocks. We propose a novel, training-free structured pruning
approach called BlockPruner. Unlike existing layer pruning methods, BlockPruner
segments each Transformer layer into MHA and MLP blocks. It then assesses the
importance of these blocks using perplexity measures and applies a heuristic
search for iterative pruning. We applied BlockPruner to LLMs of various sizes
and architectures and validated its performance across a wide range of
downstream tasks. Experimental results show that BlockPruner achieves more
granular and effective pruning compared to state-of-the-art baselines.
|
[
-0.5593008399009705,
-0.92754065990448,
0.3501657247543335,
0.2683183252811432,
-0.2923118770122528,
-0.09706168621778488,
-0.43654847145080566,
-0.2465735226869583,
-0.06466738134622574,
0.4208133816719055,
-0.6537098288536072,
-0.2689236104488373,
-0.5426473617553711,
-0.17493577301502228,
-0.44174864888191223,
0.8083823919296265,
0.20223084092140198,
-0.3180602192878723,
-0.0671582818031311,
0.26807501912117004,
-0.6266453266143799,
-0.5418261289596558,
-0.6415178775787354,
-0.6439088582992554,
0.5280948877334595,
0.6202219128608704,
0.6115933060646057,
1.0151984691619873,
0.37485259771347046,
0.3697594106197357,
-0.39449721574783325,
0.34535518288612366,
-0.5202236175537109,
0.015593224205076694,
-0.25448018312454224,
-0.1836690753698349,
-0.3254745602607727,
-0.4159191846847534,
0.6764475107192993,
0.6868888139724731,
-0.1415504515171051,
0.09232828766107559,
0.207637220621109,
0.6805487275123596,
-0.7409202456474304,
-0.07496709376573563,
-0.7056779265403748,
0.1645946353673935,
-0.39649856090545654,
-0.14654335379600525,
-0.20766155421733856,
-0.004659076686948538,
-0.04324984550476074,
-0.15086573362350464,
0.32902809977531433,
-0.08203002065420151,
0.9369317293167114,
0.2044336348772049,
-0.06339434534311295,
0.3793507516384125,
-0.7781592607498169,
1.06315016746521,
-0.5582264065742493,
0.21656684577465057,
0.1680925190448761,
0.2530427575111389,
-0.061665311455726624,
-0.43460115790367126,
-0.31695517897605896,
-0.05205528065562248,
-0.14713983237743378,
-0.3089698851108551,
-0.12099907547235489,
0.24650339782238007,
-0.007944416254758835,
0.5868735313415527,
-0.29914039373397827,
0.1809346228837967,
-0.40190389752388,
-0.1770198792219162,
0.6379184722900391,
0.07798189669847488,
0.04496371001005173,
-0.1407632976770401,
-0.33683183789253235,
-0.2337437868118286,
-0.6175993084907532,
-0.13625189661979675,
0.2936813235282898,
0.21925823390483856,
0.39109259843826294,
0.3675681948661804,
-0.11838838458061218,
0.9652863144874573,
0.02909775823354721,
-0.5241594910621643,
-0.009984259493649006,
-0.2848675847053528,
-0.38914552330970764,
0.07128842920064926,
0.722256064414978,
0.18100734055042267,
0.6523177027702332,
-0.04537639766931534,
-0.4765482246875763,
-0.029776189476251602,
0.48723509907722473,
-0.7377126812934875,
-0.4968711733818054,
0.5291077494621277,
-0.33463552594184875,
-0.2971162497997284,
-0.1536920815706253,
-0.5793211460113525,
-0.16811446845531464,
-0.2937227785587311,
0.168858602643013,
-0.5310332775115967,
-0.31047481298446655,
0.15760880708694458,
0.022854333743453026,
0.1738698035478592,
0.29601606726646423,
-0.7857375144958496,
0.5551366806030273,
1.1507052183151245,
0.7424733638763428,
-0.1978975534439087,
-0.5374264717102051,
-0.4874109923839569,
0.16083745658397675,
-0.24589543044567108,
0.7012446522712708,
-0.6622687578201294,
-0.15295441448688507,
-0.22037118673324585,
0.037368372082710266,
-0.07040363550186157,
-0.8222283124923706,
0.5547555685043335,
-0.2755200266838074,
-0.37144362926483154,
0.009774561040103436,
-0.3736954629421234,
-0.3555668294429779,
0.525876522064209,
-0.49828001856803894,
0.8026178479194641,
-0.10138458758592606,
-0.637559175491333,
-0.15320159494876862,
-0.23214170336723328,
-0.646510124206543,
-0.03336510807275772,
-0.1692160815000534,
-0.7262670993804932,
0.49916690587997437,
0.199925497174263,
0.6572704315185547,
-0.32993409037590027,
0.6111399531364441,
-0.09267735481262207,
-0.4462009072303772,
0.0628824308514595,
-0.4608605206012726,
0.42281991243362427,
0.11484787613153458,
-0.18198499083518982,
0.46293920278549194,
-0.7455582618713379,
0.026875006034970284,
0.20885086059570312,
-0.32599177956581116,
-0.3494794964790344,
0.066518135368824,
0.23645004630088806,
0.292365700006485,
0.019704466685652733,
-0.4767428934574127,
0.0801926925778389,
-0.2189551144838333,
0.7756871581077576,
0.7241040468215942,
0.027270670980215073,
0.2780159115791321,
-0.45991063117980957,
0.24183344841003418,
0.043361883610486984,
0.034041158854961395,
-0.21978749334812164,
-0.10543242841959,
-0.940740168094635,
-0.357585608959198,
0.17000141739845276,
0.4194668233394623,
-0.0006264891708269715,
0.6388604044914246,
-0.23649141192436218,
-0.4181861877441406,
-0.5115913152694702,
0.1608058214187622,
0.7277657985687256,
0.1849745213985443,
0.3816467523574829,
-0.5745036005973816,
-0.44045504927635193,
-1.0833690166473389,
-0.24178265035152435,
0.373647540807724,
-0.05068414658308029,
0.27045148611068726,
0.39428818225860596,
-0.0035244873724877834,
0.8285250663757324,
-0.4302511215209961,
-0.37555497884750366,
-0.4495279788970947,
-0.044109150767326355,
-0.05186910927295685,
0.8663278818130493,
-0.19239699840545654,
-0.7034693360328674,
-0.12543874979019165,
0.17305518686771393,
-0.1400521844625473,
-0.08725933730602264,
-0.21599237620830536,
0.10295071452856064,
-0.26975712180137634,
0.41750460863113403,
-0.655548632144928,
0.09881789237260818,
0.5813031196594238,
0.09611523896455765,
0.8424549102783203,
-0.0682264119386673,
-0.38736408948898315,
-0.7551085948944092,
0.08238115161657333,
0.09012021869421005,
-0.3745652139186859,
-0.814250111579895,
0.12409427762031555,
0.1396862417459488,
-0.15232425928115845,
-0.41121959686279297,
0.5184357166290283,
-0.7295007705688477,
-0.3747375011444092,
-0.4390397369861603,
0.17668960988521576,
0.14761018753051758,
0.6496278643608093,
0.15977701544761658,
0.621406614780426,
0.23877966403961182,
-0.7542746067047119,
0.2259731888771057,
0.06835605204105377,
-0.46987617015838623,
0.17939715087413788,
-0.7015549540519714,
0.1273009330034256,
-0.1569116711616516,
0.007408997975289822,
-0.6884101033210754,
-0.15327097475528717,
-0.04629218950867653,
-0.008449730463325977,
0.5110536813735962,
-0.24002590775489807,
-0.23778143525123596,
-0.38964053988456726,
-0.37890052795410156,
0.44004207849502563,
0.3130475580692291,
-0.2947360873222351,
0.39717286825180054,
0.3816467523574829,
-0.3015809953212738,
-0.6039393544197083,
-0.8268975019454956,
-0.04566236585378647,
-0.1957755982875824,
-0.5474376082420349,
0.5006612539291382,
0.14675475656986237,
-0.29246944189071655,
0.03558240085840225,
-0.5537804961204529,
-0.2886345386505127,
0.29138675332069397,
0.08168851584196091,
-0.12765438854694366,
-0.1542067974805832,
-0.03615740314126015,
-0.19110526144504547,
-0.24869976937770844,
-0.10672617703676224,
-0.34074050188064575,
1.0522640943527222,
-0.08770043402910233,
-0.5505740642547607,
-0.603498101234436,
0.25604429841041565,
0.5155443549156189,
-0.7114095687866211,
0.5050815343856812,
0.37151890993118286,
-0.21950356662273407,
-0.3754376471042633,
-0.7926691770553589,
-0.199814572930336,
-0.482770174741745,
0.6860671043395996,
-0.5633921027183533,
-0.9512729048728943,
0.20076392590999603,
-0.20068000257015228,
0.09467658400535583,
0.036115650087594986,
0.3912871479988098,
0.3590835630893707,
0.6427977085113525,
0.619337797164917,
-0.2735311985015869,
0.6769814491271973,
-0.22188739478588104,
0.25921952724456787,
-1.0798791646957397,
-0.09563736617565155,
-0.452163428068161,
-0.6180134415626526,
-0.18942388892173767,
-0.6416290402412415,
-0.06034976243972778,
0.33404260873794556,
-0.3177684247493744,
0.25633376836776733,
-0.7517346143722534,
0.8283684849739075,
0.6694208979606628,
-0.12888850271701813,
0.38653624057769775,
0.19538643956184387,
0.1781572699546814,
0.20164786279201508,
-0.7627763152122498,
-0.5228902697563171,
0.5161750316619873,
0.5452613234519958,
0.5755467414855957,
-0.21643854677677155,
0.6539046168327332,
-0.2745068669319153,
0.1508532017469406,
-0.989974319934845,
0.6681792736053467,
-0.13366937637329102,
-0.49601584672927856,
-0.4530092775821686,
-0.3919849991798401,
-0.862335205078125,
0.7300580739974976,
0.08548208326101303,
-0.7854595184326172,
0.24279220402240753,
0.34829288721084595,
-0.4255964159965515,
0.501261830329895,
-0.5753613710403442,
1.0371336936950684,
-0.27735546231269836,
-0.424785315990448,
-0.39445585012435913,
-0.4883778989315033,
0.5906575918197632,
-0.11472263187170029,
0.20574061572551727,
-0.21890178322792053,
0.018754063174128532,
0.46664518117904663,
-0.5222105979919434,
0.8330293297767639,
-0.03988291323184967,
-0.06131929159164429,
0.13603323698043823,
0.3731667995452881,
0.6454199552536011,
-0.29188263416290283,
0.2306378185749054,
0.07221375405788422,
-0.3071238398551941,
-0.3963196575641632,
-0.17109262943267822,
0.8997503519058228,
-0.6649116277694702,
-0.7630881071090698,
-0.0686948373913765,
-0.759364128112793,
-0.17083635926246643,
0.2174050509929657,
-0.2034173458814621,
0.48606279492378235,
-0.028590817004442215,
0.3248601257801056,
0.6872634887695312,
-0.26558464765548706,
0.4350661337375641,
0.2125212401151657,
0.022229980677366257,
-0.33074644207954407,
1.0296331644058228,
0.10062123090028763,
0.35274893045425415,
0.6278542280197144,
0.34015533328056335,
0.30681416392326355,
-0.9577838778495789,
-0.021373983472585678,
0.29970884323120117,
-0.29723069071769714,
-0.2864006757736206,
-0.6484015583992004,
-0.45662781596183777,
-0.03599934279918671,
-0.1493602991104126,
-0.6220341920852661,
-0.38880491256713867,
0.03451593220233917,
-0.027881888672709465,
0.10380900651216507,
0.4833216667175293,
0.242285817861557,
0.6439451575279236,
-0.9080913662910461,
0.08499332517385483,
0.3039662539958954,
0.31572675704956055,
0.34890830516815186,
-0.2534235715866089,
-0.09239111095666885,
-0.33585458993911743,
-0.42205610871315,
-0.4622657001018524,
0.5762943029403687,
0.12904611229896545,
0.23962043225765228,
0.584717333316803,
-0.11729786545038223,
1.0130947828292847,
-0.8019782304763794,
0.41772785782814026,
0.12279683351516724,
-0.8506660461425781,
0.30526456236839294,
-0.1321708709001541,
0.4433245360851288,
0.5267972946166992,
0.10504879802465439,
-0.7117668986320496,
-0.27109023928642273,
-0.5542570948600769,
-1.0054575204849243,
0.6878949999809265,
-0.007116254419088364,
-0.13500826060771942,
-0.014431106857955456,
0.1967519372701645,
-0.07506958395242691,
0.4287889897823334,
-0.7226508259773254,
-0.08114994317293167,
0.02978302165865898,
-0.1837814897298813,
-0.17348919808864594,
-0.5706236958503723,
-0.2637048363685608,
-0.059827715158462524,
0.5899056196212769,
0.11003655940294266,
-0.02141064591705799,
0.27100008726119995,
-0.23023377358913422,
-0.002716277725994587,
0.514153242111206,
0.415755957365036,
0.633020281791687,
-0.06816942244768143,
0.3216477334499359,
-0.06405807286500931,
-0.3400150537490845,
0.124627985060215,
0.022087199613451958,
-0.29522705078125,
-0.2020828127861023,
0.4141826927661896,
0.9300277829170227,
0.35400426387786865,
-0.6845117211341858,
0.44613996148109436,
0.2731592059135437,
-0.18052931129932404,
-0.15997004508972168,
-0.017148617655038834,
0.21409551799297333,
0.20723538100719452,
0.1271289587020874,
0.11012450605630875,
-0.11357381939888,
-0.34212812781333923,
0.13552993535995483,
0.49620503187179565,
-0.26302316784858704,
-0.2572409510612488,
0.19121195375919342,
0.25933465361595154,
-0.5256085395812988,
0.5231384634971619,
0.046951957046985626,
-0.552271842956543,
0.4817875623703003,
0.599527895450592,
0.8849632143974304,
-0.276096910238266,
-0.13464218378067017,
0.13491207361221313,
0.5637408494949341,
-0.4173104465007782,
-0.08883700519800186,
-0.24271346628665924,
-0.7382756471633911,
-0.9258517622947693,
-0.7493960857391357,
-0.31198400259017944,
0.5567405223846436,
-0.35348808765411377,
-0.08161500841379166,
-0.6575583815574646,
0.1774490922689438,
-0.18483275175094604,
0.12009156495332718,
-0.25545835494995117,
0.1524723917245865,
0.09836988151073456,
1.0969396829605103,
-0.6797992587089539,
1.0386383533477783,
0.5933336615562439,
-0.12069056183099747,
-0.8379574418067932,
0.030948899686336517,
0.03892293572425842,
-0.6661821603775024,
0.4483128488063812,
0.44944652915000916,
-0.008777061477303505,
0.07243657112121582,
-0.17831696569919586,
-0.7962771654129028,
0.8851014375686646,
0.26120978593826294,
-1.203190803527832,
-0.08823008835315704,
-0.14597421884536743,
0.07176046818494797,
-0.10596463829278946,
-0.06752989441156387,
0.8082466125488281,
0.48670968413352966,
-0.035521797835826874,
-0.9741407632827759,
-0.01317913830280304,
-0.15539944171905518,
0.23691265285015106,
0.6739355325698853,
-0.7853047847747803,
1.0886287689208984,
0.0313081368803978,
-0.1986418515443802,
-0.05251440778374672,
0.38083332777023315,
0.3830638825893402,
-0.02747279591858387,
0.600261390209198,
0.6997365951538086,
0.769281804561615,
-0.08834872394800186,
1.0119316577911377,
-0.42487096786499023,
0.2145257443189621,
1.2476948499679565,
-0.15537123382091522,
0.8114309310913086,
0.6591986417770386,
-0.06609062850475311,
0.22087755799293518,
0.4599187672138214,
0.028856465592980385,
0.3407212197780609,
0.5387817025184631,
-0.12066096067428589,
-0.3810991942882538,
-0.07772543281316757,
-0.008692137897014618,
0.10429807752370834,
0.27402010560035706,
-0.007964545860886574,
-0.13301309943199158,
-0.08217068761587143,
0.17073383927345276,
0.057603802531957626,
-0.5212922096252441,
0.7038804292678833,
0.19356706738471985,
-0.6599928736686707,
0.6781401634216309,
0.24896875023841858,
0.8219285011291504,
-0.7159955501556396,
0.2640102207660675,
-0.27364203333854675,
0.6834443211555481,
-0.31741294264793396,
-0.5470603108406067,
0.42608508467674255,
-0.08218426257371902,
-0.051126159727573395,
-0.36711105704307556,
1.0136946439743042,
-0.5145216584205627,
-0.2538793683052063,
0.3144166171550751,
0.3722493350505829,
0.1374635398387909,
-0.5051514506340027,
-0.48147881031036377,
0.46910080313682556,
0.03564460948109627,
-0.4831855297088623,
0.5076463222503662,
0.48817700147628784,
-0.2520126700401306,
0.8935511708259583,
0.5132815837860107,
0.3677004277706146,
-0.09011650830507278,
0.0014312242856249213,
0.9973945617675781,
-0.8681761026382446,
-0.11966278403997421,
-1.0125778913497925,
0.4182533025741577,
-0.13672634959220886,
-0.12213212996721268,
0.6913502812385559,
0.4934709966182709,
1.0081593990325928,
-0.03668110445141792,
0.5324634909629822,
0.24302875995635986,
0.387885183095932,
-0.25720611214637756,
0.289870947599411,
-0.4777236878871918,
0.24036180973052979,
-0.1923617571592331,
-1.0875657796859741,
-0.3943778872489929,
0.9304673075675964,
-0.4392344355583191,
-0.13772013783454895,
0.5988581776618958,
0.8886411786079407,
-0.4012058675289154,
-0.28747063875198364,
0.3291572630405426,
0.3306792974472046,
0.20715846121311188,
0.5776185989379883,
0.6564632058143616,
0.011817161925137043,
0.6863765716552734,
-0.4567181468009949,
-0.11385899037122726,
-0.2564041018486023,
-0.8517135977745056,
-0.7418084740638733,
-0.08722946047782898,
-0.2330458164215088,
0.036142125725746155,
0.1271734982728958,
0.9373378157615662,
0.8501654267311096,
-0.8283854126930237,
-0.5594616532325745,
-0.36650514602661133,
0.14203143119812012,
-0.43434152007102966,
-0.22888173162937164,
0.20351384580135345,
-0.4290146231651306,
-0.7397657036781311,
0.569663941860199,
0.3732624053955078,
-0.14962133765220642,
-0.37973886728286743,
0.09319259226322174,
-0.22795997560024261,
-0.05117455869913101,
0.5364357233047485,
0.28801509737968445,
-0.7966207265853882,
-0.1020088940858841,
-0.5630199313163757,
0.1178179383277893,
0.04084230586886406,
0.965441107749939,
-0.6517208218574524,
-0.06811778247356415,
0.3920169174671173,
0.9363128542900085,
0.6712291836738586,
0.2913180887699127,
0.6397354602813721,
-1.1122808456420898,
0.38842543959617615,
0.2380412220954895,
0.3548964560031891,
0.5357511639595032,
0.07666648924350739,
0.25240546464920044,
0.06369534134864807,
-0.5470917224884033,
-0.8945977091789246,
0.4552755653858185,
-0.6892523765563965,
-0.6760645508766174,
1.1258248090744019,
0.07999557256698608,
-0.5279242396354675,
0.006531806662678719,
-0.33328986167907715,
-0.10083768516778946,
-0.29284173250198364,
0.47006955742836,
0.6464728713035583,
0.16007156670093536,
-0.4469928443431854,
-0.4215260148048401,
0.3640986680984497,
0.5047217011451721,
-0.507078230381012,
0.5730785727500916,
0.5345582962036133,
0.2988860607147217,
0.41246283054351807,
0.5737245082855225,
-0.030461516231298447,
-0.08035321533679962,
-0.17397664487361908,
0.24587492644786835,
-0.43579211831092834,
-0.6290815472602844,
-0.5078930854797363,
0.5580753087997437,
0.21368980407714844,
-0.26022782921791077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15470v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15470v1
|
Mental Disorder Classification via Temporal Representation of Text
| 2024-06-15T10:53:21 | 2024-06-15T10:53:21 |
Raja Kumar, Kishan Maharaj, Ashita Saxena, Pushpak Bhattacharyya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI
|
Mental disorders pose a global challenge, aggravated by the shortage of
qualified mental health professionals. Mental disorder prediction from social
media posts by current LLMs is challenging due to the complexities of
sequential text data and the limited context length of language models. Current
language model-based approaches split a single data instance into multiple
chunks to compensate for limited context size. The predictive model is then
applied to each chunk individually, and the most voted output is selected as
the final prediction. This results in the loss of inter-post dependencies and
important time variant information, leading to poor performance. We propose a
novel framework which first compresses the large sequence of chronologically
ordered social media posts into a series of numbers. We then use this time
variant representation for mental disorder classification. We demonstrate the
generalization capabilities of our framework by outperforming the current SOTA
in three different mental conditions: depression, self-harm, and anorexia, with
an absolute improvement of 5% in the F1 score. We investigate the situation
where current data instances fall within the context length of language models
and present empirical results highlighting the importance of temporal
properties of textual data. Furthermore, we utilize the proposed framework for
a cross-domain study, exploring commonalities across disorders and the
possibility of inter-domain data usage.
|
[
-0.18175339698791504,
-0.9467805027961731,
0.8289722204208374,
0.5818262696266174,
-0.25225314497947693,
0.1598505675792694,
-0.05621354281902313,
-0.6341015696525574,
0.48959192633628845,
0.024287370964884758,
-0.7830168604850769,
-0.6929037570953369,
-0.8763027787208557,
0.12344697117805481,
-0.4392548203468323,
0.9755394458770752,
-0.07156702131032944,
0.35077717900276184,
0.0064331297762691975,
0.020203132182359695,
-0.15779072046279907,
-0.8338890671730042,
-0.8556467294692993,
-0.359870046377182,
0.5409943461418152,
-0.005657380912452936,
0.5453980565071106,
0.4796501100063324,
0.6005732417106628,
0.1673354059457779,
0.08166337013244629,
0.13801613450050354,
-0.3688508868217468,
0.033142365515232086,
-0.30692818760871887,
-0.00688256835564971,
-0.5235487818717957,
-0.09523040801286697,
0.2049875110387802,
0.6312499046325684,
-0.2599899470806122,
0.2101946771144867,
-0.06350330263376236,
0.24575074017047882,
-0.16848550736904144,
0.21853189170360565,
-0.20682378113269806,
0.3652236759662628,
-0.39349299669265747,
-0.5814282298088074,
-0.18675875663757324,
-0.1539296954870224,
-0.054912321269512177,
-0.3926379084587097,
0.28858739137649536,
-0.01327819749712944,
0.7016783952713013,
0.3028641939163208,
-0.7243000268936157,
-0.08611640334129333,
-0.9678216576576233,
0.470422625541687,
-0.612504243850708,
0.2868443429470062,
0.48579907417297363,
0.47746896743774414,
-0.011282357387244701,
-0.5177361965179443,
-0.478306382894516,
0.3419228196144104,
0.052055612206459045,
-0.1791847199201584,
-0.07022812217473984,
-0.14117038249969482,
0.3092222809791565,
0.2142881155014038,
-0.8097783327102661,
0.23295950889587402,
-0.3373095989227295,
-0.1313226968050003,
0.7693684101104736,
0.6042891144752502,
0.6021803617477417,
-0.11178658902645111,
-0.195670947432518,
0.32906442880630493,
-0.32617655396461487,
-0.1424940675497055,
-0.17053081095218658,
0.2058834582567215,
-0.1582229882478714,
0.5337646007537842,
-0.07276593893766403,
0.2310742288827896,
0.21855202317237854,
-0.27016696333885193,
0.09609406441450119,
-0.03842742741107941,
-0.22893905639648438,
-0.013650422915816307,
0.7565292119979858,
0.834312915802002,
0.016037290915846825,
-0.20936448872089386,
0.0028995024040341377,
0.3509564995765686,
0.22334617376327515,
-0.8462534546852112,
0.00017279804160352796,
0.27480071783065796,
-0.45358431339263916,
0.04975719377398491,
-0.13795112073421478,
-0.9165835380554199,
-0.6210002899169922,
-0.3615981638431549,
0.05164490267634392,
-0.622323751449585,
-0.0792507603764534,
0.11387424170970917,
0.2662513256072998,
-0.3916676938533783,
0.5215085744857788,
-0.8875200152397156,
0.4585527777671814,
0.47902029752731323,
1.0850459337234497,
-0.3738422095775604,
0.010204467922449112,
-0.23024757206439972,
0.3903483748435974,
-0.24396179616451263,
0.7999022603034973,
-0.62358558177948,
-0.31495824456214905,
-0.018365528434515,
0.28727880120277405,
-0.13023553788661957,
-0.26642194390296936,
0.24355167150497437,
-0.5853980183601379,
0.17137806117534637,
-0.05239211767911911,
-0.6068475246429443,
-0.053995728492736816,
-0.014678021892905235,
-0.634284257888794,
0.7188863158226013,
0.3195761740207672,
-0.9518288373947144,
0.3626064658164978,
-0.3886476159095764,
-0.5149136781692505,
0.09411589056253433,
-0.22100815176963806,
-0.24470865726470947,
0.026313772425055504,
0.36441710591316223,
1.0200294256210327,
-0.2721267640590668,
0.601336658000946,
-0.7558671236038208,
-0.4572506248950958,
0.18949443101882935,
-0.20893745124340057,
0.43160131573677063,
0.32046759128570557,
-0.09851275384426117,
-0.016565464437007904,
-0.6592763066291809,
-0.13107068836688995,
0.2233709990978241,
-0.3315016031265259,
-0.6935747265815735,
0.27367740869522095,
0.3005383312702179,
0.2678230404853821,
0.08121348917484283,
-0.49082592129707336,
0.1792762577533722,
-0.2164793610572815,
0.4917196035385132,
0.6819745302200317,
0.435053288936615,
0.3720807731151581,
-0.5397171378135681,
0.5219584107398987,
0.20990192890167236,
0.1789971888065338,
0.18649086356163025,
-0.40460285544395447,
-0.05071287229657173,
-0.4631626307964325,
0.11720085144042969,
0.7485855221748352,
-0.6639328002929688,
0.485862135887146,
-0.6338378190994263,
-0.36476340889930725,
-0.23355618119239807,
-0.21575118601322174,
0.0744483545422554,
0.08900292962789536,
0.5217206478118896,
-0.2510052025318146,
-0.6638965010643005,
-0.4575693905353546,
-0.0988583192229271,
0.03241315111517906,
-0.11331094056367874,
0.02671963907778263,
0.3060736060142517,
-0.7871793508529663,
0.6898923516273499,
-0.5131934881210327,
-0.3255906403064728,
-0.08574265241622925,
0.3557119369506836,
-0.0015661664074286819,
0.23639211058616638,
0.4384564161300659,
-0.5451441407203674,
-0.25584712624549866,
0.018456969410181046,
-0.8742572665214539,
-0.11730048060417175,
-0.05430078133940697,
0.1436871439218521,
0.18695497512817383,
0.44171521067619324,
-0.4692763090133667,
0.6108426451683044,
0.3820025324821472,
-0.5523755550384521,
0.3215074837207794,
0.07932016998529434,
0.1794111281633377,
-1.0786124467849731,
-0.21183711290359497,
0.27310672402381897,
-0.2906484603881836,
-0.43147870898246765,
-0.47570058703422546,
-0.15905757248401642,
-0.11677855253219604,
0.04301653057336807,
0.6056433320045471,
0.027451828122138977,
0.22293254733085632,
0.13202089071273804,
-0.15558090806007385,
-0.28015801310539246,
0.36609116196632385,
-0.1448477953672409,
0.11620509624481201,
0.23463091254234314,
-0.5344542264938354,
0.1283147782087326,
-0.1363360583782196,
-0.354366660118103,
0.4165951907634735,
-0.3135780096054077,
-0.0049333395436406136,
-0.4475622773170471,
0.28469717502593994,
-0.8737770318984985,
-0.3466973900794983,
0.3095911741256714,
-0.4363170266151428,
0.39638233184814453,
0.3288801908493042,
-0.6488469243049622,
-0.25678786635398865,
-0.10184402763843536,
0.4995189309120178,
0.05563698336482048,
-0.24684205651283264,
0.36246243119239807,
0.6042664647102356,
-0.32120537757873535,
-0.2973002791404724,
-0.6817079186439514,
-0.15913350880146027,
-0.43666529655456543,
-0.455708771944046,
0.8897473812103271,
-0.2559160590171814,
-0.34116747975349426,
0.3093443512916565,
-0.28163519501686096,
-0.14783808588981628,
-0.07037617266178131,
0.30835554003715515,
0.13577230274677277,
0.05374303087592125,
0.483906090259552,
0.27140575647354126,
0.06568700075149536,
-0.015972035005688667,
0.10795921832323074,
0.6634759902954102,
0.23627404868602753,
-0.1532488316297531,
-0.3914908766746521,
0.7808979153633118,
0.5429087281227112,
0.17248579859733582,
0.7343239784240723,
0.4345148503780365,
-0.8867841362953186,
-0.4779878854751587,
-0.3080865442752838,
-0.0665932446718216,
-0.37333181500434875,
0.334705650806427,
-0.2220001369714737,
-0.9660497307777405,
0.5181246399879456,
0.05715467408299446,
-0.09474093466997147,
0.305667519569397,
0.34757864475250244,
-0.17185021936893463,
1.3010618686676025,
0.6575244665145874,
-0.19815322756767273,
0.6855518221855164,
-0.16968780755996704,
0.30974286794662476,
-0.3232370913028717,
-0.2120194286108017,
-0.05841847136616707,
-0.201957106590271,
-0.3351987302303314,
-0.4687787890434265,
0.18221737444400787,
0.07325784116983414,
-0.343553364276886,
-0.19293728470802307,
-0.24844247102737427,
0.05396241322159767,
-0.20376451313495636,
0.4076271653175354,
0.3944838345050812,
0.23794594407081604,
-0.09052065759897232,
-0.5666515231132507,
-0.4170556366443634,
-0.5741631984710693,
1.001732587814331,
0.4129050672054291,
0.7418269515037537,
0.055510926991701126,
0.6646250486373901,
0.8429446220397949,
0.7658409476280212,
-0.6893858313560486,
0.5440515875816345,
-0.47750353813171387,
-0.5454185009002686,
-0.3685518205165863,
-0.5140259861946106,
-0.8590378165245056,
-0.08694054931402206,
0.01952999457716942,
-0.9975560307502747,
0.08898638933897018,
-0.22646620869636536,
-0.5510473251342773,
0.26596492528915405,
-0.4980466365814209,
0.6697872281074524,
-0.31859177350997925,
-0.07245440036058426,
-0.3881267309188843,
-0.6309327483177185,
0.40339118242263794,
-0.3791349232196808,
0.5140958428382874,
-0.5819026231765747,
-0.03433094918727875,
1.1041162014007568,
-0.5537775754928589,
0.9313866496086121,
-0.0734286680817604,
0.13767865300178528,
-0.12784184515476227,
0.0046284873969852924,
-0.05435658618807793,
0.287240594625473,
0.11831869184970856,
0.13865236937999725,
0.5130846500396729,
-0.2840717136859894,
-0.8764175176620483,
0.555347204208374,
-0.82759028673172,
-0.37271490693092346,
-0.6346941590309143,
-0.43489739298820496,
-0.4442686438560486,
0.1428927183151245,
0.2744668126106262,
0.5722338557243347,
-0.23147182166576385,
-0.24456533789634705,
0.44124695658683777,
-0.14424465596675873,
0.45643219351768494,
0.7252171635627747,
-0.5432199239730835,
-0.49433448910713196,
0.6891016960144043,
0.46785929799079895,
-0.2619706392288208,
0.5661763548851013,
-0.005770882125943899,
-0.17345765233039856,
-0.3384819030761719,
0.13343822956085205,
0.5241175293922424,
-0.6979005336761475,
-0.18954846262931824,
-0.6271657347679138,
-0.2892152667045593,
-0.7296010255813599,
0.010822705924510956,
-0.003711878089234233,
-0.3041621148586273,
-0.4909111559391022,
-0.26596808433532715,
0.37985244393348694,
1.003744125366211,
0.036027465015649796,
0.3245764970779419,
-0.7046207785606384,
0.5191344618797302,
0.04573190584778786,
0.5780198574066162,
0.1285998374223709,
-0.2086784988641739,
-0.23678310215473175,
-0.1729455143213272,
-0.36956655979156494,
-1.1786689758300781,
0.6108577847480774,
0.17580972611904144,
0.4498237669467926,
0.6740739345550537,
0.2851616442203522,
0.9345651268959045,
-0.516270101070404,
0.4030679166316986,
0.26964402198791504,
-0.6242390871047974,
0.5688861012458801,
-0.2834727168083191,
0.14354686439037323,
0.2505680024623871,
0.979661762714386,
-0.9903900027275085,
-0.2875785529613495,
-0.5454316735267639,
-0.7546781897544861,
0.6487417817115784,
-0.20703096687793732,
-0.19844043254852295,
-0.36860764026641846,
0.36883544921875,
0.2275979369878769,
-0.20762337744235992,
-0.5686701536178589,
-0.2603558897972107,
-0.11621399223804474,
-0.4847993850708008,
-0.4018276035785675,
-0.3944353461265564,
0.04071474075317383,
-0.48325952887535095,
0.4529736340045929,
-0.02319442108273506,
0.6319855451583862,
0.3957810699939728,
-0.07982185482978821,
-0.2361588478088379,
0.22203704714775085,
0.17766141891479492,
0.6662811636924744,
-0.37137171626091003,
0.22056521475315094,
-0.05184762552380562,
-0.36362046003341675,
0.2683928608894348,
0.41611117124557495,
0.10102812945842743,
0.1368381530046463,
0.45202627778053284,
0.5060778856277466,
0.17451825737953186,
-0.5256766676902771,
0.36219272017478943,
-0.2680620551109314,
0.0354335680603981,
-0.3484174311161041,
-0.2488977313041687,
0.04019008204340935,
0.5702676177024841,
0.3278765082359314,
-0.028016896918416023,
0.11599628627300262,
-0.6192898154258728,
0.33051759004592896,
0.018914442509412766,
-0.2842862606048584,
-0.6955532431602478,
0.5783752202987671,
-0.11448265612125397,
-0.45108017325401306,
0.387450248003006,
-0.4372255504131317,
-0.194712832570076,
0.39642035961151123,
0.5743892788887024,
0.7365330457687378,
-0.5573869347572327,
0.35664036870002747,
0.14850425720214844,
0.04431416839361191,
-0.3402392864227295,
0.5772375464439392,
0.14862166345119476,
-0.7481460571289062,
-0.2415471076965332,
-0.7945481538772583,
0.020717406645417213,
0.4351330101490021,
-0.6811587810516357,
0.26201337575912476,
-0.9531598091125488,
-0.862435519695282,
-0.020380938425660133,
0.05086334049701691,
-0.6468199491500854,
0.36854055523872375,
0.40322279930114746,
0.6689143180847168,
-1.0273232460021973,
0.8840462565422058,
0.8806754350662231,
-0.19644230604171753,
-0.3732297122478485,
0.3310477137565613,
0.1370195746421814,
-0.35056930780410767,
0.27838999032974243,
0.4244653284549713,
0.048391424119472504,
-0.21603688597679138,
-0.3147374391555786,
-0.9438135623931885,
0.8894002437591553,
0.22682233154773712,
-0.46986085176467896,
-0.451589435338974,
0.05657711997628212,
0.8795031905174255,
-0.6609202027320862,
-0.1618613451719284,
0.4097951054573059,
0.1529182642698288,
-0.02467040717601776,
-0.6627828478813171,
0.3029375970363617,
-0.5145366191864014,
0.25174635648727417,
0.09587956219911575,
-0.29146480560302734,
0.5079630017280579,
-0.3532056212425232,
-0.8942572474479675,
-0.1668175905942917,
0.5725287795066833,
0.2242426574230194,
0.7782469987869263,
0.3316957652568817,
0.5416203141212463,
0.9552552700042725,
0.07964833825826645,
0.8838626146316528,
-0.2069726586341858,
0.34647470712661743,
1.159477710723877,
-0.25482529401779175,
0.7597512602806091,
0.19716721773147583,
-0.35276418924331665,
0.41205188632011414,
1.0397716760635376,
0.1361979842185974,
0.6108214259147644,
0.17754197120666504,
-0.13174214959144592,
-0.126459002494812,
-0.16954797506332397,
-0.3276329040527344,
-0.07716650515794754,
0.7508689165115356,
-0.3559195101261139,
-0.22082607448101044,
0.25214216113090515,
0.22878630459308624,
0.05557139962911606,
-0.18139395117759705,
0.4568670392036438,
0.22887244820594788,
-0.24112656712532043,
0.3382736146450043,
0.21198856830596924,
0.6967117786407471,
-0.35472288727760315,
0.16883015632629395,
-0.12145277857780457,
0.27172186970710754,
-0.1633186638355255,
-0.5878439545631409,
0.7622315883636475,
-0.0931379422545433,
-0.5499445199966431,
-0.4111742079257965,
0.5272065997123718,
-0.41940540075302124,
-0.7521201968193054,
0.7398818731307983,
0.44724440574645996,
0.09533631801605225,
-0.04967205226421356,
-0.5346584916114807,
-0.07548840343952179,
-0.4561774432659149,
-0.1269930750131607,
0.3143768310546875,
0.6844822764396667,
-0.5453644394874573,
0.7248892784118652,
0.190885990858078,
0.21629515290260315,
0.09572378545999527,
0.09911026060581207,
0.6074234247207642,
-0.9187836647033691,
-0.6207442879676819,
-0.9149062633514404,
0.06286317855119705,
0.004564601927995682,
-0.1598522961139679,
0.4569186866283417,
0.2791568636894226,
0.6814455986022949,
0.1857786774635315,
0.745107114315033,
-0.2779519557952881,
0.7726607322692871,
-0.34266403317451477,
0.6827447414398193,
-0.8073614835739136,
0.33599624037742615,
-0.22439461946487427,
-0.32119104266166687,
-0.4749094247817993,
0.21614526212215424,
-0.6378810405731201,
-0.07180653512477875,
0.9941262006759644,
0.5428663492202759,
0.1854521930217743,
0.10008607059717178,
0.09723350405693054,
0.2805500030517578,
0.2820150852203369,
0.6749736070632935,
0.8063244819641113,
-0.07251807302236557,
0.19596238434314728,
-0.35817253589630127,
-0.2276921570301056,
-0.10877356678247452,
-0.4421721398830414,
-1.0344706773757935,
-0.8599402904510498,
-0.38961029052734375,
-0.14184091985225677,
0.24980977177619934,
0.9375437498092651,
0.6183090209960938,
-0.7257218956947327,
-0.09544878453016281,
0.39374032616615295,
0.12076927721500397,
-0.4176366925239563,
-0.3134525418281555,
0.2621299624443054,
-0.007995788007974625,
-0.3271859884262085,
0.06897111237049103,
0.20285789668560028,
0.2169165462255478,
-0.03411843255162239,
0.11666318029165268,
-0.18926016986370087,
0.006816160399466753,
0.7878211736679077,
-0.07536805421113968,
-0.6831740736961365,
-0.138356551527977,
-0.06399089843034744,
-0.3798695504665375,
0.02718493714928627,
0.7764812707901001,
-0.5172877311706543,
0.15356183052062988,
0.4827517569065094,
0.5056504011154175,
0.4431454837322235,
0.06257957965135574,
0.5478593707084656,
-0.5353741645812988,
-0.4440712034702301,
0.2608155608177185,
0.48820793628692627,
0.3103256821632385,
-0.7178176641464233,
0.34675469994544983,
0.5463813543319702,
-0.2981685698032379,
-0.6536661386489868,
-0.06395789980888367,
-0.9647296667098999,
-0.5825379490852356,
1.005156397819519,
-0.08538282662630081,
-0.2716135084629059,
-0.29722389578819275,
0.034640513360500336,
0.39143508672714233,
-0.5905237197875977,
1.1405913829803467,
0.7569911479949951,
-0.3953397870063782,
-0.011249510571360588,
-0.5064548850059509,
0.39756229519844055,
0.08120283484458923,
-0.7138670682907104,
-0.09538789838552475,
0.4118444621562958,
0.44373396039009094,
-0.0210082046687603,
1.1053204536437988,
-0.29055556654930115,
0.01435110718011856,
-0.3463743031024933,
-0.11153659969568253,
0.3796273171901703,
-0.4010743796825409,
-0.33194655179977417,
0.28897523880004883,
-0.5778791904449463,
0.2728550434112549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10584v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10584v3
|
Concentrate Attention: Towards Domain-Generalizable Prompt Optimization for Language Models
| 2024-06-15T10:02:46 | 2024-06-27T06:00:40 |
Chengzhengxu Li, Xiaoming Liu, Zhaohan Zhang, Yichen Wang, Chen Liu, Yu Lan, Chao Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advances in prompt optimization have notably enhanced the performance
of pre-trained language models (PLMs) on downstream tasks. However, the
potential of optimized prompts on domain generalization has been
under-explored. To explore the nature of prompt generalization on unknown
domains, we conduct pilot experiments and find that (i) Prompts gaining more
attention weight from PLMs' deep layers are more generalizable and (ii) Prompts
with more stable attention distributions in PLMs' deep layers are more
generalizable. Thus, we offer a fresh objective towards domain-generalizable
prompts optimization named "Concentration", which represents the "lookback"
attention from the current decoding token to the prompt tokens, to increase the
attention strength on prompts and reduce the fluctuation of attention
distribution. We adapt this new objective to popular soft prompt and hard
prompt optimization methods, respectively. Extensive experiments demonstrate
that our idea improves comparison prompt optimization methods by 1.42% for soft
prompt generalization and 2.16% for hard prompt generalization in accuracy on
the multi-source domain generalization setting, while maintaining satisfying
in-domain performance. The promising results validate the effectiveness of our
proposed prompt optimization objective and provide key insights into
domain-generalizable prompts.
|
[
-0.49488940834999084,
-0.7879768013954163,
0.7621097564697266,
0.5901542901992798,
-0.20170199871063232,
-0.06991869956254959,
-0.7029687166213989,
0.14649447798728943,
-0.027381589636206627,
0.4035947620868683,
-0.9626419544219971,
-0.4288812279701233,
-0.4847528338432312,
0.2843121886253357,
0.10791657119989395,
0.8651869297027588,
0.024760408326983452,
-0.14059647917747498,
-0.24514178931713104,
-0.03566887229681015,
-0.8906141519546509,
-0.6422006487846375,
-0.8209876418113708,
0.08595075458288193,
0.7213314771652222,
0.3164210915565491,
0.3206647038459778,
0.39948922395706177,
0.367580771446228,
0.23249690234661102,
-0.17042869329452515,
0.271340936422348,
-0.5193678736686707,
0.2658460736274719,
-0.24834370613098145,
-0.34078675508499146,
-0.08706020563840866,
0.0015927354106679559,
0.6692637205123901,
1.0591685771942139,
0.077057845890522,
-0.014361120760440826,
0.33642902970314026,
0.6605075597763062,
-0.9267765283584595,
0.0023058936931192875,
-0.34880274534225464,
-0.011549798771739006,
0.10409523546695709,
-0.2964985966682434,
-0.6992205381393433,
-0.22143521904945374,
0.4761861264705658,
-0.6737050414085388,
0.5757443904876709,
0.06731988489627838,
0.6491969227790833,
0.3949854373931885,
-0.11660534143447876,
0.060012299567461014,
-0.6163210868835449,
1.2371057271957397,
-0.401950865983963,
0.11557602882385254,
0.16743460297584534,
0.19412261247634888,
-0.10931265354156494,
-0.6957044005393982,
-0.03295479714870453,
-0.2602528929710388,
0.05557474493980408,
0.007267029490321875,
-0.3299887478351593,
0.2456514984369278,
0.30740031599998474,
0.1652776151895523,
-0.5675639510154724,
-0.2049228399991989,
0.20449937880039215,
-0.22452884912490845,
0.25145620107650757,
0.07428660988807678,
0.45193663239479065,
0.48452669382095337,
-0.2513907551765442,
0.05135457590222359,
-0.5212984681129456,
0.4062945544719696,
0.000991489621810615,
0.6190993785858154,
0.0023660457227379084,
0.23116321861743927,
-0.2938654124736786,
0.7555454969406128,
0.46770980954170227,
0.2253992259502411,
0.0972742810845375,
-0.49238187074661255,
-0.010681916028261185,
-0.2504282295703888,
0.48207756876945496,
0.3684210479259491,
0.4755464494228363,
-0.3199115991592407,
-0.13861054182052612,
-0.01100604422390461,
0.34161680936813354,
-0.8540334701538086,
-0.08627770096063614,
0.2963792681694031,
-0.5112628936767578,
-0.06972210109233856,
-0.1954195350408554,
-0.5317429900169373,
-0.16143809258937836,
-0.40116119384765625,
0.1177867129445076,
-0.20859983563423157,
-0.16230790317058563,
0.16365842521190643,
-0.08541032671928406,
0.17863884568214417,
0.2838277220726013,
-1.0767580270767212,
0.21626068651676178,
0.7515437006950378,
0.866675078868866,
-0.6058623790740967,
-0.14879922568798065,
-0.9832015037536621,
0.10454794019460678,
-0.2079964280128479,
0.8274853825569153,
-0.6519176363945007,
-0.3589831292629242,
0.18714451789855957,
-0.0032503879629075527,
-0.49153441190719604,
-0.46165382862091064,
0.7780816555023193,
-0.5553670525550842,
0.5068278908729553,
-0.3032730519771576,
-0.3947417438030243,
-0.041690900921821594,
0.07283050566911697,
-0.5855847001075745,
0.6907337307929993,
0.22357866168022156,
-0.521138608455658,
0.2797464430332184,
-0.5952231884002686,
-0.4568944275379181,
0.18381917476654053,
0.04606197774410248,
-0.2583460211753845,
0.2397441565990448,
0.43908196687698364,
0.30858728289604187,
-0.22589640319347382,
0.3546281158924103,
-0.23730410635471344,
-0.26884257793426514,
0.22145916521549225,
-0.1147807389497757,
0.7812380790710449,
0.2191438525915146,
-0.48773354291915894,
0.4116545617580414,
-0.31623971462249756,
0.14151936769485474,
0.05077991262078285,
-0.1903812289237976,
-0.4963029623031616,
0.013522359542548656,
-0.14242923259735107,
-0.1836080402135849,
0.2549802362918854,
-0.3106333911418915,
0.2169404923915863,
-0.6964943408966064,
0.3159191310405731,
0.5953289866447449,
0.22037795186042786,
0.7858321070671082,
0.019188541918992996,
0.8347944021224976,
0.02948939986526966,
0.4374989867210388,
-0.42401018738746643,
-0.44935083389282227,
-0.5750166773796082,
-0.3868176341056824,
0.36434081196784973,
0.35044676065444946,
-0.5134181976318359,
0.37642955780029297,
0.03141012042760849,
0.16933651268482208,
-0.563805341720581,
0.06084489822387695,
0.3874991536140442,
0.7128138542175293,
0.32819125056266785,
-0.12839560210704803,
-0.23222477734088898,
-0.9456081390380859,
-0.4333796501159668,
0.33927997946739197,
0.02499162219464779,
0.4883584976196289,
-0.12808236479759216,
-0.24436937272548676,
1.1934683322906494,
-0.7614073157310486,
-0.1866881549358368,
-0.5274192094802856,
-0.21606208384037018,
0.575705349445343,
0.4704309105873108,
0.7767758369445801,
-0.8883324265480042,
-0.8600195050239563,
-0.2823984622955322,
-0.23370958864688873,
-0.48631802201271057,
0.014262894168496132,
-0.2984233796596527,
0.05035390704870224,
0.3939889669418335,
-0.7724903225898743,
0.03602372482419014,
0.16320829093456268,
-0.3972316086292267,
0.45712074637413025,
0.07631286978721619,
0.0070265005342662334,
-0.6829906105995178,
0.15665337443351746,
0.07766258716583252,
-0.09583441913127899,
-0.9092732071876526,
0.15254268050193787,
0.17556630074977875,
-0.4139285385608673,
-0.4596812427043915,
0.765876829624176,
-0.683777391910553,
0.32512378692626953,
-0.32673320174217224,
0.19945816695690155,
0.21041569113731384,
0.7794777750968933,
0.07883786410093307,
0.9619775414466858,
0.9758583903312683,
-0.8296377062797546,
0.10195019096136093,
0.10226398706436157,
-0.013039583340287209,
0.46064266562461853,
-0.8441176414489746,
0.27847209572792053,
-0.25146016478538513,
-0.05811344459652901,
-1.2297649383544922,
-0.04734063893556595,
0.4699277877807617,
-0.462059885263443,
0.4515620172023773,
-0.14039216935634613,
0.05251138284802437,
-0.31288403272628784,
-0.5659518241882324,
0.6028239727020264,
0.5241538882255554,
-0.45088937878608704,
0.5781123638153076,
0.15863043069839478,
-0.46663808822631836,
-0.8376826643943787,
-0.39979782700538635,
-0.19591405987739563,
-0.23359592258930206,
-0.45244482159614563,
0.35172492265701294,
-0.43437814712524414,
-0.18831604719161987,
-0.08509316295385361,
-0.01771003194153309,
0.04649333655834198,
0.20484386384487152,
-0.09568879753351212,
0.026427006348967552,
-0.4433210492134094,
-0.0591115728020668,
0.20554715394973755,
-0.26174765825271606,
0.12505772709846497,
-0.5865704417228699,
0.7012693285942078,
0.11928508430719376,
-0.017561348155140877,
-0.43913137912750244,
0.5926494002342224,
0.07625214755535126,
-0.3235378861427307,
0.5853318572044373,
0.2522031366825104,
-0.17204934358596802,
-0.6288729310035706,
-0.5286003947257996,
-0.34498175978660583,
-0.5523952841758728,
0.12177624553442001,
-0.4477125406265259,
-1.032060146331787,
0.4457293152809143,
-0.11545424163341522,
-0.001448560506105423,
0.3107535243034363,
0.4441843032836914,
0.18690995872020721,
1.284674048423767,
0.8167915940284729,
-0.18438129127025604,
0.6552268862724304,
-0.16002272069454193,
0.06205672770738602,
-0.8386484384536743,
0.05858141556382179,
-0.5554692149162292,
-0.16317518055438995,
-0.08633901923894882,
-0.2964746356010437,
0.03844268620014191,
0.019246375188231468,
0.02906801365315914,
0.039567332714796066,
-0.7802761197090149,
0.6730484962463379,
0.7081019282341003,
-0.02710922807455063,
-0.17932762205600739,
0.14512819051742554,
-0.23977260291576385,
-0.11844202131032944,
-0.663622260093689,
-0.18683072924613953,
0.8354407548904419,
0.23503141105175018,
0.43221399188041687,
-0.1611994057893753,
0.41742125153541565,
0.4142233729362488,
0.15150009095668793,
-0.7732569575309753,
0.5128278732299805,
-0.08337237685918808,
-0.344757616519928,
-0.2763596475124359,
-0.4013022482395172,
-1.2800419330596924,
0.27080294489860535,
0.5816200375556946,
-0.40118926763534546,
0.3790908455848694,
0.1552378088235855,
-0.6301084160804749,
-0.319225013256073,
-1.0412838459014893,
1.1044676303863525,
0.1652965396642685,
-0.1656545251607895,
-0.10960865765810013,
-0.6772747039794922,
0.04621930047869682,
0.12371624261140823,
0.14248572289943695,
-0.16495372354984283,
-0.3392851650714874,
0.42738983035087585,
-0.42820611596107483,
0.8972590565681458,
-0.556107223033905,
-0.22309967875480652,
0.4860817790031433,
-0.2797747850418091,
0.48175105452537537,
-0.09231444448232651,
0.1917111575603485,
-0.28367486596107483,
-0.5791551470756531,
-0.5930652618408203,
-0.6811690330505371,
0.6944620013237,
-0.7776266932487488,
-0.7789502739906311,
-0.044831082224845886,
-0.2743116021156311,
-0.411665141582489,
0.30789250135421753,
0.395827054977417,
0.6341466307640076,
-0.1632782518863678,
0.0032040614169090986,
1.0684109926223755,
-0.2176160216331482,
0.6025070548057556,
0.5725976824760437,
0.08858287334442139,
-0.5462260246276855,
0.8879884481430054,
-0.2677994668483734,
0.19742248952388763,
0.5467167496681213,
0.2775355875492096,
-0.37884774804115295,
-0.6849090456962585,
-0.312055379152298,
0.3229670524597168,
-0.6448109149932861,
-0.26461073756217957,
-0.9160662889480591,
0.04743928834795952,
-0.6960121989250183,
-0.1926153600215912,
0.12001997977495193,
-0.3231617510318756,
-0.7788065671920776,
0.12998342514038086,
0.11724936217069626,
0.032772231847047806,
0.2895398736000061,
0.6596738696098328,
-0.6484023928642273,
0.31097885966300964,
0.3511933982372284,
0.20862501859664917,
-0.04926063120365143,
-0.6030613780021667,
-0.2988132834434509,
-0.190810889005661,
-0.16309531033039093,
-0.6780880093574524,
0.3738492727279663,
0.402518093585968,
0.8877856731414795,
0.5292637944221497,
0.2723136842250824,
0.07815981656312943,
-0.5029739737510681,
0.7083294987678528,
0.12358668446540833,
-0.8695733547210693,
0.7995438575744629,
-0.4522194266319275,
0.579130232334137,
0.6746411919593811,
0.282694935798645,
-0.48164910078048706,
-0.45718011260032654,
-0.3848375380039215,
-0.8432424664497375,
1.0122355222702026,
0.004595627076923847,
0.4469335079193115,
-0.17012161016464233,
0.5198777318000793,
0.23557400703430176,
0.3586244583129883,
-0.48220521211624146,
-0.45056846737861633,
0.1316623091697693,
-0.33159348368644714,
-0.023953469470143318,
-0.5057464241981506,
-0.05923054739832878,
0.1056254431605339,
0.3816538155078888,
-0.19577200710773468,
0.16766293346881866,
0.1969686895608902,
-0.1329188048839569,
-0.16865627467632294,
0.20369035005569458,
0.817294716835022,
0.5036819577217102,
-0.0856298953294754,
0.1468530297279358,
-0.050692345947027206,
-0.6513828635215759,
0.20814302563667297,
0.15551170706748962,
-0.530685305595398,
0.04329455643892288,
0.2592586874961853,
0.983418345451355,
0.08901980519294739,
-0.5924401879310608,
0.7050563097000122,
-0.16232866048812866,
-0.01129627600312233,
0.02098819799721241,
0.42816922068595886,
-0.21446527540683746,
0.2202637493610382,
0.552242636680603,
0.07016972452402115,
0.36793872714042664,
-0.19773215055465698,
0.07566967606544495,
0.4730542004108429,
-0.18887530267238617,
-0.2819945216178894,
0.7854129076004028,
0.554572582244873,
-0.40236127376556396,
0.23242560029029846,
-0.17053711414337158,
-0.5697803497314453,
0.6275215744972229,
0.41865023970603943,
1.3818756341934204,
-0.4867919683456421,
0.15489813685417175,
0.19618995487689972,
0.021253131330013275,
0.04531959444284439,
0.28743430972099304,
-0.26966527104377747,
-0.6638667583465576,
-0.730423629283905,
-0.2627275586128235,
-0.4786548316478729,
-0.0625142827630043,
-0.5466660857200623,
0.19907906651496887,
-0.5519198179244995,
-0.6201559901237488,
-0.19671107828617096,
0.06699136644601822,
-0.5296779870986938,
0.13100667297840118,
0.021973049268126488,
0.698974609375,
-0.3947655260562897,
0.4577227234840393,
0.7205960154533386,
-0.1934637576341629,
-0.5099818110466003,
0.12321696430444717,
-0.5889263153076172,
-0.7169861793518066,
0.6008493304252625,
0.45017194747924805,
-0.08642372488975525,
0.34186577796936035,
-0.7563248872756958,
-0.9776642322540283,
0.5230491757392883,
0.5167858600616455,
-0.5996132493019104,
0.07942508161067963,
-0.13556428253650665,
0.4447782635688782,
-0.6339351534843445,
0.07287950813770294,
0.4455747902393341,
0.29493871331214905,
-0.16971413791179657,
-0.5446804165840149,
0.15460866689682007,
-0.38200643658638,
0.2001442313194275,
0.12738411128520966,
-0.8063440918922424,
0.7111855745315552,
-0.35101109743118286,
-0.5773143768310547,
-0.1798570454120636,
0.7787283062934875,
0.22056056559085846,
0.42464008927345276,
0.46094390749931335,
0.2696124315261841,
0.5652233958244324,
-0.0068931276910007,
1.2109458446502686,
-0.3148520290851593,
0.16656872630119324,
0.9228200912475586,
-0.3078327775001526,
0.24061879515647888,
0.5209197402000427,
-0.16439026594161987,
0.39459720253944397,
0.7020493745803833,
0.026270095258951187,
1.216537594795227,
0.23138004541397095,
-0.43406036496162415,
-0.057618241757154465,
-0.46346068382263184,
-0.35743391513824463,
-0.5052081942558289,
0.18067383766174316,
-0.3099636733531952,
0.03964570164680481,
0.38248738646507263,
-0.25365200638771057,
-0.0695631355047226,
-0.44620004296302795,
0.780232846736908,
0.11185332387685776,
-0.9626287817955017,
0.7949973940849304,
0.0072052194736897945,
0.5891355276107788,
-0.6022683382034302,
0.32549697160720825,
-0.5311673879623413,
0.2700425684452057,
0.22003532946109772,
-0.3420753479003906,
-0.14885969460010529,
-0.02499336004257202,
-0.5494403839111328,
-0.42197421193122864,
0.9003055691719055,
-0.6007270216941833,
0.046851690858602524,
0.2320123165845871,
0.3751385807991028,
-0.025493407621979713,
-0.6668961048126221,
-0.512545108795166,
0.08920890837907791,
0.20364275574684143,
-0.6505804657936096,
0.22282755374908447,
0.659610390663147,
0.11458558589220047,
0.6360893845558167,
0.4961026608943939,
0.08627782016992569,
0.052399151027202606,
0.5511676669120789,
1.0158109664916992,
-0.548412561416626,
-0.6952077746391296,
-0.9237492680549622,
0.4640265107154846,
-0.08952528983354568,
-0.46470907330513,
0.6989870071411133,
0.43470627069473267,
0.5172716379165649,
-0.48043370246887207,
0.8709372878074646,
0.41409218311309814,
0.6872189044952393,
-0.36336249113082886,
0.2754764258861542,
-0.4212366044521332,
-0.024380074813961983,
-0.10671098530292511,
-1.2838363647460938,
-0.2820093035697937,
0.29927536845207214,
-0.34272098541259766,
0.17332035303115845,
0.8512324690818787,
0.5108535289764404,
0.13474029302597046,
-0.17898540198802948,
0.18501131236553192,
-0.31261324882507324,
0.10468543320894241,
0.6415553689002991,
0.9817887544631958,
0.15429463982582092,
0.5468037128448486,
-0.21718242764472961,
-0.34751808643341064,
-0.4072084128856659,
-0.6317723989486694,
-1.1310462951660156,
-0.2990701198577881,
-0.5173388123512268,
-0.002445494756102562,
0.07442785054445267,
0.9416382312774658,
0.6337581872940063,
-1.175955057144165,
0.07393130660057068,
-0.12225709110498428,
0.0963604748249054,
-0.21558764576911926,
-0.30321407318115234,
0.5544865131378174,
-1.1309547424316406,
-0.9754055738449097,
0.4804380238056183,
0.33628085255622864,
0.1978558450937271,
-0.05135362222790718,
0.029178868979215622,
0.2008361965417862,
0.09902642667293549,
0.6197732090950012,
0.26884880661964417,
-0.5424081087112427,
0.03127315640449524,
0.44291171431541443,
-0.3894602358341217,
-0.021602550521492958,
1.20981764793396,
-0.5921627283096313,
0.13576184213161469,
0.4835064709186554,
0.8458660244941711,
0.18840551376342773,
0.42668282985687256,
0.8089289665222168,
-1.1536046266555786,
0.2861853539943695,
0.46981462836265564,
0.23046712577342987,
0.2571760416030884,
-0.488766610622406,
0.5469052195549011,
0.3436014950275421,
-0.47669318318367004,
-0.8684992790222168,
0.09085774421691895,
-1.0965170860290527,
-0.4384694993495941,
1.254257082939148,
-0.2676783502101898,
-0.275443434715271,
-0.13531772792339325,
-0.535446047782898,
0.050534941256046295,
-0.7779577970504761,
0.4731356203556061,
0.7146837115287781,
-0.08027482777833939,
-0.37731990218162537,
-0.323825478553772,
0.8843343257904053,
0.9375619292259216,
-0.6417365074157715,
0.30888956785202026,
0.5748634934425354,
0.02155754342675209,
0.0925239622592926,
0.7707051634788513,
0.26894131302833557,
0.2666347026824951,
-0.3841624855995178,
-0.10209408402442932,
0.08006812632083893,
-0.4331994354724884,
-0.6010463833808899,
0.38473832607269287,
-0.020313747227191925,
-0.35449251532554626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10576v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10576v1
|
Optimization-based Structural Pruning for Large Language Models without Back-Propagation
| 2024-06-15T09:31:03 | 2024-06-15T09:31:03 |
Yuan Gao, Zujing Liu, Weizhong Zhang, Bo Du, Gui-Song Xia
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Compared to the moderate size of neural network models, structural weight
pruning on the Large-Language Models (LLMs) imposes a novel challenge on the
efficiency of the pruning algorithms, due to the heavy computation/memory
demands of the LLMs. Recent efficient LLM pruning methods typically operate at
the post-training phase without the expensive weight finetuning, however, their
pruning criteria often rely on heuristically designed metrics, potentially
leading to suboptimal performance. We instead propose a novel
optimization-based structural pruning that learns the pruning masks in a
probabilistic space directly by optimizing the loss of the pruned model. To
preserve the efficiency, our method 1) works at post-training phase} and 2)
eliminates the back-propagation through the LLM per se during the optimization
(i.e., only requires the forward pass of the LLM). We achieve this by learning
an underlying Bernoulli distribution to sample binary pruning masks, where we
decouple the Bernoulli parameters from the LLM loss, thus facilitating an
efficient optimization via a policy gradient estimator without
back-propagation. As a result, our method is able to 1) operate at structural
granularities of channels, heads, and layers, 2) support global and
heterogeneous pruning (i.e., our method automatically determines different
redundancy for different layers), and 3) optionally use a metric-based method
as initialization (of our Bernoulli distributions). Extensive experiments on
LLaMA, LLaMA-2, and Vicuna using the C4 and WikiText2 datasets demonstrate that
our method operates for 2.7 hours with around 35GB memory for the 13B models on
a single A100 GPU, and our pruned models outperform the state-of-the-arts
w.r.t. perplexity. Codes will be released.
|
[
-0.16777876019477844,
-0.9254753589630127,
0.3201816976070404,
0.6002795100212097,
-0.5941171050071716,
-0.012562437914311886,
-0.3577580153942108,
-0.0950750932097435,
0.2814996540546417,
0.39148664474487305,
-0.7323597073554993,
-0.5151417255401611,
-0.20338281989097595,
-0.2598603069782257,
-0.07715433835983276,
0.9183176755905151,
0.07518836110830307,
-0.04907572641968727,
0.09914840012788773,
0.05163170024752617,
-0.2730230987071991,
-0.38611966371536255,
-0.4996870458126068,
-0.3670584261417389,
0.5914526581764221,
0.1468566209077835,
0.4588336944580078,
0.6701328754425049,
0.37922871112823486,
0.2862025797367096,
-0.4997873604297638,
0.25189825892448425,
-0.5171087980270386,
-0.19958606362342834,
0.028255945071578026,
-0.4730774462223053,
-0.1923815757036209,
-0.16252118349075317,
0.990227222442627,
0.8606771230697632,
-0.4089674949645996,
0.23736846446990967,
0.150802880525589,
0.5502254366874695,
-0.5339412689208984,
0.18180711567401886,
-0.639956533908844,
0.25390514731407166,
-0.23044168949127197,
-0.42056939005851746,
-0.2326047122478485,
-0.3681139349937439,
-0.06503194570541382,
-0.47181272506713867,
0.14477036893367767,
0.04628130421042442,
0.8377641439437866,
0.27433526515960693,
-0.23001474142074585,
0.3248893618583679,
-0.7748386263847351,
0.7778497338294983,
-0.6108489036560059,
0.402189165353775,
0.26848655939102173,
0.08820441365242004,
-0.20073236525058746,
-0.4387088119983673,
-0.3011016547679901,
-0.37330085039138794,
0.29708975553512573,
0.15247972309589386,
-0.025589458644390106,
0.1907874494791031,
-0.02695237658917904,
0.3392386734485626,
-0.6184001564979553,
0.21235769987106323,
-0.6291379332542419,
-0.2853209376335144,
0.5150458812713623,
-0.16104406118392944,
-0.1533733606338501,
0.023383062332868576,
-0.3894755244255066,
-0.13941390812397003,
-1.0230246782302856,
-0.14452655613422394,
0.6944422721862793,
0.11551102995872498,
0.030121566727757454,
0.464336633682251,
0.005627592094242573,
0.4484865367412567,
-0.21984605491161346,
-0.2414623647928238,
0.29389768838882446,
-0.19449849426746368,
-0.3982197046279907,
-0.012525034137070179,
0.6609494090080261,
-0.018397795036435127,
0.2045878767967224,
-0.2938040494918823,
-0.23689843714237213,
0.12079247087240219,
0.1512618511915207,
-0.8183010220527649,
-0.4620911478996277,
0.1287095695734024,
-0.4593164622783661,
-0.5087649822235107,
-0.25033608078956604,
-0.3333171010017395,
0.11829943209886551,
-0.15286453068256378,
0.4774337708950043,
-0.19385594129562378,
-0.3781900405883789,
0.1291000097990036,
0.11644784361124039,
0.025700768455863,
0.18623405694961548,
-0.5292065739631653,
0.3385968506336212,
0.6233965158462524,
0.9748523235321045,
0.1002526506781578,
-0.054374534636735916,
-0.4450572729110718,
0.2149958461523056,
-0.5404223799705505,
0.4255339801311493,
-0.3233446180820465,
-0.2231481373310089,
-0.21569737792015076,
0.07518437504768372,
0.020391521975398064,
-0.5958590507507324,
0.3837986886501312,
-0.5679708123207092,
-0.22665473818778992,
0.06493949145078659,
-0.25881141424179077,
-0.39683330059051514,
0.33199217915534973,
-0.6690799593925476,
0.7666428685188293,
0.06855161488056183,
-0.4966605305671692,
-0.054342884570360184,
-0.20524494349956512,
-0.6524063944816589,
0.06519056856632233,
-0.11923515051603317,
-0.8484689593315125,
0.43204981088638306,
0.06915146112442017,
0.40581178665161133,
-0.31939277052879333,
0.5109528303146362,
-0.41231676936149597,
-0.4495977759361267,
-0.014616911299526691,
-0.46106839179992676,
0.8484822511672974,
0.1308099925518036,
-0.23728153109550476,
0.09310916811227798,
-0.7779107689857483,
-0.05702168866991997,
0.24599862098693848,
-0.5593303442001343,
-0.14366987347602844,
0.18199872970581055,
0.02277202345430851,
0.07374082505702972,
0.07160209864377975,
-0.6121244430541992,
0.21325191855430603,
-0.5511719584465027,
0.6981298327445984,
0.982737123966217,
0.1817750334739685,
0.3723162114620209,
-0.28983622789382935,
0.5277356505393982,
-0.06179041787981987,
0.09308751672506332,
-0.05023321881890297,
-0.1855558454990387,
-0.48995694518089294,
-0.37270182371139526,
0.3258092403411865,
0.49145373702049255,
-0.4287656843662262,
0.5275322198867798,
-0.24074463546276093,
-0.49376755952835083,
-0.15526703000068665,
0.2685372829437256,
0.5160598158836365,
0.39006492495536804,
0.2701871991157532,
-0.39556050300598145,
-0.44606813788414,
-0.9450051784515381,
0.07990280538797379,
-0.23889435827732086,
-0.02717028744518757,
0.37430503964424133,
0.45819661021232605,
0.045938730239868164,
0.5999323725700378,
-0.669326663017273,
-0.3169972002506256,
-0.24567893147468567,
-0.015858182683587074,
0.2120702862739563,
0.6584122776985168,
0.2353135347366333,
-0.7196587324142456,
0.03567621111869812,
-0.030385466292500496,
-0.4358980655670166,
-0.062296368181705475,
-0.24975943565368652,
-0.023172397166490555,
0.011406143195927143,
0.42305421829223633,
-0.5940333604812622,
0.20378072559833527,
0.731454610824585,
0.1056360974907875,
0.8400359153747559,
-0.16405954957008362,
-0.5800830721855164,
-0.8284481763839722,
0.0031973491422832012,
0.31281399726867676,
-0.12089715898036957,
-0.36088764667510986,
0.0959596186876297,
0.0198057834059,
-0.21609912812709808,
-0.32423821091651917,
0.526931643486023,
-0.724618673324585,
-0.1467401385307312,
-0.007436344400048256,
-0.06302031874656677,
0.08925678580999374,
1.093407392501831,
0.17329946160316467,
0.4274144470691681,
0.39492541551589966,
-0.6220858097076416,
0.2502804100513458,
0.03758999705314636,
-0.5365933179855347,
0.10842721909284592,
-0.7553146481513977,
-0.0514117032289505,
-0.29432541131973267,
0.4708942770957947,
-0.8249507546424866,
0.16372980177402496,
0.4726966321468353,
-0.1543358564376831,
0.302543967962265,
-0.3419289290904999,
-0.36634689569473267,
-0.25967854261398315,
-0.3859366178512573,
0.4383035898208618,
0.3814557194709778,
-0.3684253394603729,
0.3624487817287445,
0.30386731028556824,
-0.26461300253868103,
-0.5017249584197998,
-0.8464792966842651,
0.027261003851890564,
-0.37657424807548523,
-0.6201009154319763,
0.5333378314971924,
-0.07319731265306473,
0.04726723954081535,
0.03298672288656235,
-0.6246803998947144,
-0.15899749100208282,
0.2957117259502411,
0.040581878274679184,
0.21098865568637848,
-0.31921711564064026,
0.1819089949131012,
0.07800551503896713,
0.08766476064920425,
0.051032353192567825,
-0.6374294757843018,
0.653799831867218,
-0.08463533222675323,
-0.36363112926483154,
-0.49836084246635437,
0.13528868556022644,
0.0588771253824234,
-0.5527945160865784,
0.7922142148017883,
0.5594566464424133,
-0.3191901743412018,
-0.47498995065689087,
-0.5317688584327698,
-0.26448768377304077,
-0.48937106132507324,
0.7064341902732849,
-0.34440985321998596,
-0.897732675075531,
0.39534610509872437,
-0.13140511512756348,
0.20552000403404236,
0.061654433608055115,
0.4084312617778778,
-0.010363837704062462,
0.7461910247802734,
0.6012969613075256,
-0.1326369345188141,
0.708066463470459,
-0.5511499047279358,
0.23183293640613556,
-0.9289609789848328,
-0.17046329379081726,
-0.4875788390636444,
-0.497991681098938,
-0.41378387808799744,
-0.5551795959472656,
0.30288031697273254,
0.3106084167957306,
-0.24233385920524597,
0.259364515542984,
-0.5117610096931458,
0.36324039101600647,
0.4069693982601166,
0.30831292271614075,
0.13883806765079498,
0.41531866788864136,
0.06778362393379211,
0.2677495777606964,
-0.790411651134491,
-0.18723773956298828,
0.9306163191795349,
0.4730854034423828,
0.7368247509002686,
-0.024095382541418076,
0.6724281907081604,
-0.15381130576133728,
0.4424624741077423,
-0.7525622248649597,
0.5958757400512695,
0.08431647717952728,
-0.3912724554538727,
-0.3610493838787079,
-0.9210874438285828,
-0.8613460659980774,
0.4906274974346161,
0.05414915084838867,
-0.7612709403038025,
0.29865726828575134,
0.4613722562789917,
-0.2781718373298645,
0.3913574814796448,
-0.46222150325775146,
0.7153345942497253,
-0.2581369876861572,
-0.32048624753952026,
-0.4501936435699463,
-0.5725341439247131,
0.4808782637119293,
-0.07129072397947311,
0.13865022361278534,
-0.13656072318553925,
-0.12250355631113052,
0.782496452331543,
-0.47506183385849,
0.7823140621185303,
-0.307354211807251,
-0.13477608561515808,
0.35352200269699097,
0.18282762169837952,
0.6979061961174011,
0.03466750308871269,
0.16910754144191742,
0.25662878155708313,
-0.2540833353996277,
-0.3144562840461731,
-0.48609063029289246,
0.5238502025604248,
-0.5963031649589539,
-0.616061806678772,
-0.02318502776324749,
-0.3170481324195862,
-0.12696872651576996,
0.08210170269012451,
-0.019758420065045357,
0.6190528869628906,
-0.1462460160255432,
0.5148146748542786,
0.5926690101623535,
-0.36050793528556824,
0.3105365037918091,
0.30669406056404114,
0.12525202333927155,
-0.3959263563156128,
1.2796361446380615,
0.31375303864479065,
0.15589670836925507,
0.5261253714561462,
0.3638518154621124,
-0.12616176903247833,
-1.0090018510818481,
-0.1975574493408203,
0.556562602519989,
-0.3150530457496643,
-0.31210455298423767,
-0.4771350026130676,
-0.36017972230911255,
-0.07929036766290665,
0.04104844108223915,
-0.36047857999801636,
-0.4887356460094452,
-0.02670193836092949,
-0.1551399677991867,
0.002000791020691395,
0.15010690689086914,
-0.011418149806559086,
0.6738779544830322,
-0.734029233455658,
0.06960338354110718,
-0.025424882769584656,
0.3415933847427368,
0.09938914328813553,
-0.34345823526382446,
-0.2617972791194916,
0.0026522097177803516,
-0.3874243497848511,
-0.6329383254051208,
0.4519694447517395,
0.372348815202713,
0.4312810003757477,
0.4936089813709259,
-0.17845934629440308,
0.736327052116394,
-0.5607824325561523,
0.277085542678833,
0.14373564720153809,
-0.5737489461898804,
0.2803986668586731,
-0.3538611829280853,
0.13318422436714172,
0.29298368096351624,
0.24488861858844757,
-0.4727681279182434,
-0.2386656254529953,
-0.623521625995636,
-0.907376766204834,
0.6579254269599915,
0.23336128890514374,
0.0498819462954998,
0.0261762086302042,
0.27025124430656433,
-0.33987122774124146,
0.5042980313301086,
-0.7652549743652344,
0.017568955197930336,
-0.08769991993904114,
-0.030329400673508644,
-0.13908731937408447,
-0.23304632306098938,
-0.23596997559070587,
-0.11858481168746948,
0.7927994728088379,
-0.1726653128862381,
0.16716739535331726,
0.11870057135820389,
-0.32797425985336304,
0.0316540002822876,
0.013729971833527088,
0.5116912722587585,
0.6452929973602295,
-0.25671258568763733,
-0.041084423661231995,
-0.021289585158228874,
-0.44202813506126404,
0.12835219502449036,
0.03973942622542381,
-0.28701695799827576,
-0.1311209499835968,
0.28344544768333435,
0.8791022896766663,
0.3170727789402008,
-0.5867019891738892,
0.5268694758415222,
0.15843363106250763,
-0.382956862449646,
-0.3176923990249634,
-0.14378945529460907,
0.13169465959072113,
0.3595629334449768,
0.35226529836654663,
0.1137142926454544,
-0.15628044307231903,
-0.3729419410228729,
0.016177361831068993,
0.6403312087059021,
-0.0073768943548202515,
-0.5060935020446777,
0.514858067035675,
0.15111911296844482,
-0.26322269439697266,
0.5742430090904236,
0.008525502867996693,
-0.523842453956604,
0.7098884582519531,
0.5967749357223511,
0.83087557554245,
-0.21707531809806824,
0.3266383707523346,
0.29311975836753845,
0.5494491457939148,
-0.23516499996185303,
-0.027373675256967545,
-0.4571179747581482,
-0.7978001832962036,
-0.7730879187583923,
-0.9518240094184875,
-0.11063183844089508,
0.1792372763156891,
-0.3768497705459595,
-0.06790310144424438,
-0.903436005115509,
0.06494417786598206,
-0.2677498459815979,
0.3103451132774353,
-0.3708031475543976,
0.2566264569759369,
0.05593907833099365,
1.0244781970977783,
-0.8393642902374268,
0.8067629337310791,
0.4455614686012268,
-0.14034491777420044,
-0.9078675508499146,
-0.1351945996284485,
-0.05099301412701607,
-0.7223321199417114,
0.5046575665473938,
0.1490456908941269,
-0.1005864366889,
0.07346668094396591,
-0.475624680519104,
-0.8867296576499939,
0.8918212056159973,
0.5520530343055725,
-0.8388592600822449,
-0.3739059567451477,
-0.3132809102535248,
0.22218197584152222,
-0.10517272353172302,
-0.15213876962661743,
0.38768815994262695,
0.3805350959300995,
0.21019792556762695,
-0.6101137399673462,
-0.005430038087069988,
-0.3061217665672302,
0.26194387674331665,
0.34067726135253906,
-0.8462119698524475,
0.6633989214897156,
-0.046414412558078766,
-0.2886672914028168,
0.021581033244729042,
0.7286874055862427,
0.40609443187713623,
-0.17338810861110687,
0.6591513752937317,
0.5873059034347534,
0.6963047385215759,
0.002640531864017248,
0.8328126668930054,
-0.22030869126319885,
0.31535226106643677,
0.8763948678970337,
-0.061345845460891724,
0.6598493456840515,
0.46177244186401367,
-0.14345736801624298,
0.25978103280067444,
0.6544646620750427,
-0.02659734897315502,
0.5334879159927368,
0.5425371527671814,
-0.157109797000885,
-0.2199992686510086,
0.08036360144615173,
-0.25490814447402954,
0.2744204103946686,
0.2818414568901062,
-0.034847769886255264,
-0.2086057960987091,
-0.07679619640111923,
0.12882989645004272,
-0.26376873254776,
-0.33754393458366394,
0.4505033791065216,
0.22825653851032257,
-0.5318682789802551,
0.6958199143409729,
0.2925703823566437,
0.5960458517074585,
-0.7767009735107422,
0.21908830106258392,
-0.3315217196941376,
0.33390718698501587,
-0.21365416049957275,
-0.23968066275119781,
0.3731513023376465,
-0.30066534876823425,
0.1447182446718216,
-0.3279067277908325,
0.44443872570991516,
-0.5432183146476746,
-0.5615618824958801,
0.1461045891046524,
0.18942607939243317,
0.12756966054439545,
-0.16333816945552826,
-0.427081435918808,
0.3266013562679291,
-0.004766061436384916,
-0.7427909970283508,
0.3479270040988922,
0.2687470316886902,
-0.2999534606933594,
0.819244384765625,
0.790805995464325,
0.591282844543457,
-0.05819675698876381,
0.010578903369605541,
1.069100022315979,
-0.4243553876876831,
-0.5775718092918396,
-0.7460612058639526,
0.24008840322494507,
0.13447056710720062,
-0.18596382439136505,
0.503413200378418,
0.5687986016273499,
0.8749157190322876,
0.24555838108062744,
0.3756447732448578,
0.22122614085674286,
0.07301833480596542,
-0.5406433343887329,
0.36839884519577026,
-0.6868590712547302,
0.3742341101169586,
-0.29930222034454346,
-1.3211325407028198,
-0.3269941210746765,
0.8662647604942322,
-0.32274654507637024,
-0.021980324760079384,
0.4872997999191284,
1.0321435928344727,
-0.1132543757557869,
-0.173956036567688,
0.08311983197927475,
0.3318379521369934,
0.2939586639404297,
0.6295566558837891,
0.4747278690338135,
-0.06707853078842163,
0.7908241152763367,
-0.32525068521499634,
-0.28057441115379333,
-0.1417132169008255,
-0.7761811017990112,
-0.6556943655014038,
-0.3072529733181,
-0.3590816259384155,
-0.16078166663646698,
0.2348833829164505,
0.6784912347793579,
0.8450924754142761,
-0.41568174958229065,
-0.3357938826084137,
-0.2142777293920517,
0.07124915719032288,
-0.2962041199207306,
-0.15198193490505219,
0.4767584800720215,
-0.027407927438616753,
-0.41783854365348816,
0.6155651807785034,
0.3581220805644989,
-0.170749694108963,
-0.47419166564941406,
-0.07936587184667587,
-0.15207216143608093,
-0.01655077375471592,
0.49696558713912964,
0.43363460898399353,
-0.47803109884262085,
-0.14451394975185394,
-0.34540560841560364,
0.20316152274608612,
0.0369049496948719,
0.6889901757240295,
-0.77900230884552,
-0.1488269716501236,
0.4126473367214203,
0.7994666695594788,
0.8630313873291016,
0.1587817370891571,
0.5373454093933105,
-1.0792111158370972,
0.5394445061683655,
0.46690624952316284,
0.29478704929351807,
0.23888275027275085,
-0.08588933944702148,
0.357190877199173,
0.41345420479774475,
-0.3835255205631256,
-1.0517622232437134,
0.3175671100616455,
-0.7154518365859985,
-0.46477052569389343,
0.8908138871192932,
-0.16026826202869415,
-0.6099589467048645,
0.3344402313232422,
-0.03668100759387016,
0.17639455199241638,
-0.1637909859418869,
0.5849964022636414,
0.34619054198265076,
0.3435036540031433,
-0.41615790128707886,
-0.35743653774261475,
0.31231874227523804,
0.4908955693244934,
-0.4726253151893616,
0.021236704662442207,
0.4983386695384979,
0.3889124095439911,
-0.07563011348247528,
0.632612943649292,
-0.04401218518614769,
0.08715725690126419,
-0.15919549763202667,
-0.011056358925998211,
-0.38751906156539917,
-0.791755199432373,
-0.36370089650154114,
0.36713355779647827,
-0.1910552680492401,
-0.12718679010868073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10561v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10561v1
|
We Care: Multimodal Depression Detection and Knowledge Infused Mental Health Therapeutic Response Generation
| 2024-06-15T08:41:46 | 2024-06-15T08:41:46 |
Palash Moon, Pushpak Bhattacharyya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The detection of depression through non-verbal cues has gained significant
attention. Previous research predominantly centred on identifying depression
within the confines of controlled laboratory environments, often with the
supervision of psychologists or counsellors. Unfortunately, datasets generated
in such controlled settings may struggle to account for individual behaviours
in real-life situations. In response to this limitation, we present the
Extended D-vlog dataset, encompassing a collection of 1, 261 YouTube vlogs.
Additionally, the emergence of large language models (LLMs) like GPT3.5, and
GPT4 has sparked interest in their potential they can act like mental health
professionals. Yet, the readiness of these LLM models to be used in real-life
settings is still a concern as they can give wrong responses that can harm the
users. We introduce a virtual agent serving as an initial contact for mental
health patients, offering Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT)-based responses.
It comprises two core functions: 1. Identifying depression in individuals, and
2. Delivering CBT-based therapeutic responses. Our Mistral model achieved
impressive scores of 70.1% and 30.9% for distortion assessment and
classification, along with a Bert score of 88.7%. Moreover, utilizing the TVLT
model on our Multimodal Extended D-vlog Dataset yielded outstanding results,
with an impressive F1-score of 67.8%
|
[
-0.5945560336112976,
-0.998507559299469,
0.89947509765625,
0.20544183254241943,
-0.3531824052333832,
-0.010066534392535686,
-0.11347679048776627,
-0.3606298565864563,
0.31151020526885986,
0.24135860800743103,
-0.9101009964942932,
-0.4808901250362396,
-0.6737878918647766,
0.21486635506153107,
-0.2589605152606964,
0.8926795125007629,
0.263644814491272,
0.13541488349437714,
-0.26635006070137024,
0.19573742151260376,
-0.5980773568153381,
-0.744834840297699,
-0.8723505735397339,
-0.09790834039449692,
0.660274088382721,
0.09411271661520004,
0.5284955501556396,
-0.3074494004249573,
0.3352627754211426,
0.2981399595737457,
-0.02449420653283596,
0.2963343858718872,
-0.5327697396278381,
-0.07097332924604416,
-0.016875484958291054,
-0.451600581407547,
-0.6382560133934021,
-0.16821403801441193,
-0.23271574079990387,
0.12540188431739807,
-0.28322404623031616,
0.07612856477499008,
-0.08081592619419098,
0.1601984053850174,
-0.49709799885749817,
0.22917015850543976,
-0.21430176496505737,
0.31872305274009705,
0.20653145015239716,
-0.06633375585079193,
-0.37319910526275635,
-0.1978304088115692,
0.06854971498250961,
-0.598755419254303,
0.48780766129493713,
-0.7006666660308838,
0.5215930342674255,
0.5402222275733948,
-0.839154839515686,
-0.2637535631656647,
-0.7847141027450562,
0.47340357303619385,
-0.6822389960289001,
0.11878427118062973,
0.5324686169624329,
0.5433571934700012,
-0.1707211136817932,
-0.8776984214782715,
-0.504835844039917,
-0.19230106472969055,
-0.08932121843099594,
0.5015414357185364,
-0.42269787192344666,
0.15616752207279205,
0.4341191351413727,
0.19798633456230164,
-0.4487718343734741,
-0.1572967767715454,
-0.3756467401981354,
-0.4076109230518341,
0.5751909613609314,
0.5275117754936218,
0.3407556414604187,
-0.20742075145244598,
-0.32413241267204285,
-0.07429704070091248,
0.27177485823631287,
0.18722860515117645,
-0.2691996097564697,
0.06259743124246597,
-0.11634911596775055,
0.7366982102394104,
0.05265425518155098,
0.6824215650558472,
0.25116950273513794,
-0.36280694603919983,
-0.12918667495250702,
-0.30921611189842224,
-0.3542037904262543,
0.24859334528446198,
0.7320322394371033,
0.7235872745513916,
0.08304578810930252,
0.4050629436969757,
-0.028515715152025223,
0.7364870309829712,
0.8616883754730225,
-0.7854081988334656,
-0.5144034624099731,
0.3518838882446289,
-0.27773910760879517,
-0.18691948056221008,
-0.35330045223236084,
-0.7232864499092102,
-0.7658032774925232,
-0.543468177318573,
0.46160492300987244,
-0.7047973871231079,
-0.8921761512756348,
0.432100772857666,
-0.21489159762859344,
-0.1516425609588623,
0.5005170702934265,
-0.3068926930427551,
0.4441772699356079,
0.3962126672267914,
0.8321623206138611,
0.06735652685165405,
0.23325438797473907,
-0.6137122511863708,
-0.04868466034531593,
-0.04486604779958725,
0.9094417691230774,
-0.15173748135566711,
-0.5095025300979614,
0.04472005367279053,
0.14169365167617798,
0.02862842194736004,
-0.3630012571811676,
0.4992278218269348,
-0.16408303380012512,
0.3008368909358978,
-0.4115559160709381,
-0.3952864706516266,
-0.07069174945354462,
0.5204862952232361,
-0.8553723096847534,
0.7597325444221497,
0.5991619229316711,
-0.9393152594566345,
0.3176579475402832,
-0.5764811635017395,
-0.2419751137495041,
0.14285388588905334,
-0.07353512197732925,
-0.2800559401512146,
0.3887835144996643,
0.25020045042037964,
0.4522153437137604,
-0.005361948162317276,
0.13572025299072266,
-0.5524942874908447,
-0.1584012508392334,
0.583897054195404,
-0.5855621695518494,
0.6200544238090515,
0.20306293666362762,
-0.2102104276418686,
-0.06935342401266098,
-0.9177705645561218,
0.19363433122634888,
-0.03008333221077919,
-0.24599745869636536,
-0.5766996741294861,
-0.35395509004592896,
0.22434556484222412,
0.623241662979126,
0.07570675760507584,
-0.6180615425109863,
-0.04134536162018776,
0.06796635687351227,
0.33602768182754517,
0.6579228639602661,
0.07266468554735184,
-0.35945120453834534,
-0.17519129812717438,
1.0269211530685425,
0.449289470911026,
0.49355775117874146,
0.06428077071905136,
-0.4712287187576294,
-0.13989152014255524,
-1.1850417852401733,
-0.17383530735969543,
0.4661894142627716,
-0.5720246434211731,
0.15744848549365997,
-0.17231929302215576,
-0.5125587582588196,
-0.6337732672691345,
-0.160882830619812,
0.31038424372673035,
0.4891185164451599,
0.4995540380477905,
-0.5262333750724792,
-0.4694752097129822,
-0.746326744556427,
-0.03955775871872902,
0.06304240226745605,
-0.1767774522304535,
0.32711610198020935,
-0.005846359301358461,
-0.733985960483551,
1.0181671380996704,
-0.7390461564064026,
-0.44426196813583374,
-0.335664302110672,
0.08173497021198273,
0.08950896561145782,
-0.24895423650741577,
0.4372749626636505,
-0.8981294631958008,
-0.6208908557891846,
0.11490624397993088,
-0.9073036909103394,
-0.08344832062721252,
-0.05162696912884712,
0.00235544890165329,
-0.09407779574394226,
0.20306535065174103,
-1.0177439451217651,
0.7190799117088318,
0.5364395976066589,
-0.6249594688415527,
0.33177950978279114,
-0.20341499149799347,
0.09027963876724243,
-1.179602026939392,
-0.22179950773715973,
0.21135877072811127,
-0.6162352561950684,
-0.4953243136405945,
-0.6910792589187622,
0.005212586373090744,
-0.2504437267780304,
-0.4308687150478363,
0.279951274394989,
-0.1137336790561676,
0.14414691925048828,
-0.3590959310531616,
0.24107231199741364,
0.19297266006469727,
0.32152241468429565,
0.077782042324543,
0.38506054878234863,
0.5243139863014221,
-0.5739259123802185,
0.8540526628494263,
0.39692991971969604,
-0.02615136094391346,
1.1997352838516235,
-0.39032500982284546,
-0.03728251904249191,
-0.34654274582862854,
0.4798521101474762,
-1.0657318830490112,
-0.45373037457466125,
0.3335559666156769,
-0.37639153003692627,
0.17103128135204315,
0.29415470361709595,
-0.24349002540111542,
-0.505555272102356,
-0.10293102264404297,
0.5692274570465088,
0.2169402837753296,
-0.2849835455417633,
0.4199114739894867,
0.24278570711612701,
-0.2772107422351837,
-0.10345045477151871,
-0.44409170746803284,
0.04028715193271637,
-0.4787161648273468,
-0.42117977142333984,
0.1741640418767929,
-0.20972533524036407,
-0.2611808180809021,
0.18468044698238373,
-0.1600232571363449,
-0.28206345438957214,
-0.09054842591285706,
0.3428281843662262,
-0.006550631485879421,
-0.090570367872715,
0.3149493336677551,
0.027512704953551292,
-0.14250548183918,
0.1932569146156311,
0.10506867617368698,
0.43136104941368103,
0.10259313136339188,
-0.40951207280158997,
-0.7880045771598816,
0.5819591879844666,
0.7141638398170471,
-0.04794689267873764,
0.647621214389801,
0.8964805006980896,
-0.4571381211280823,
-0.010756012983620167,
-0.2507871389389038,
-0.17538367211818695,
-0.4399142265319824,
0.34870445728302,
-0.35596963763237,
-0.745033860206604,
0.24519138038158417,
-0.1473798006772995,
-0.24254336953163147,
-0.08450651913881302,
0.7396710515022278,
0.056145258247852325,
1.372571587562561,
0.772029459476471,
0.03283305466175079,
0.39081209897994995,
-0.03786677122116089,
0.5278508067131042,
-0.6513517498970032,
-0.023804577067494392,
0.12217958271503448,
-0.09130635857582092,
-0.5901497602462769,
-0.29551199078559875,
0.8970096707344055,
0.06528656929731369,
-0.023134544491767883,
0.28095000982284546,
-0.6040686964988708,
-0.2591407597064972,
0.27800580859184265,
0.6400577425956726,
0.2756958603858948,
-0.21656127274036407,
0.08396165817975998,
-0.37393903732299805,
-0.36050066351890564,
-0.1484970897436142,
0.9378015398979187,
0.1896030753850937,
0.7163944244384766,
0.17449641227722168,
0.5162013173103333,
0.6308837532997131,
0.5814697742462158,
-0.9649156332015991,
0.21362988650798798,
0.2254035472869873,
-0.5699166059494019,
-0.18420279026031494,
-0.23406784236431122,
-1.0050158500671387,
0.2539736330509186,
0.22122550010681152,
-0.42814311385154724,
0.07060913741588593,
0.19146031141281128,
-0.7332192063331604,
-0.26903101801872253,
-0.7741299271583557,
0.8393576145172119,
-0.4305398762226105,
-0.15302449464797974,
-0.4516848921775818,
-0.41161981225013733,
0.691382646560669,
-0.28872981667518616,
0.5686859488487244,
-0.03695519641041756,
0.34054163098335266,
0.02903514727950096,
-0.22749784588813782,
1.1738717555999756,
-0.3237186372280121,
-0.31441810727119446,
0.23899111151695251,
-0.056934598833322525,
0.13270020484924316,
0.4928778409957886,
0.23917150497436523,
-0.3669993281364441,
0.45001494884490967,
-0.43379470705986023,
-0.6833381056785583,
0.5611316561698914,
-0.772316575050354,
-0.519254744052887,
-0.38593822717666626,
-0.30139291286468506,
-0.24613159894943237,
0.15348735451698303,
0.19685381650924683,
0.5589010715484619,
-0.4136497378349304,
-0.11140794306993484,
0.8222999572753906,
-0.4914630949497223,
0.04846383258700371,
0.7167423367500305,
-0.26238715648651123,
-0.5744291543960571,
0.7657365202903748,
-0.1352822184562683,
0.20351159572601318,
0.07030746340751648,
0.060802340507507324,
-0.29766392707824707,
0.2885526716709137,
0.19222095608711243,
0.31330612301826477,
-0.7089424133300781,
-0.4397488832473755,
-0.8317225575447083,
-0.13407692313194275,
-0.5892137289047241,
0.19696159660816193,
-0.4699215888977051,
-0.2105107307434082,
-0.34568554162979126,
-0.5886343121528625,
0.5724915862083435,
0.5619569420814514,
-0.37362906336784363,
0.185020312666893,
-0.9757711887359619,
0.8665187358856201,
0.6400331258773804,
0.18585319817066193,
-0.3754303753376007,
0.0272990632802248,
-0.3688822388648987,
0.25263941287994385,
-0.7378796339035034,
-0.9628880620002747,
0.7577860355377197,
0.1618422120809555,
0.43548184633255005,
0.503971517086029,
0.3908456563949585,
0.7944366335868835,
-0.09886433929204941,
0.816091775894165,
0.35965752601623535,
-0.6064367890357971,
0.555725634098053,
-0.17208819091320038,
0.07237915694713593,
0.12654538452625275,
0.5935093760490417,
-0.8011113405227661,
-0.25326335430145264,
-0.6337422132492065,
-0.6913260817527771,
0.660923957824707,
-0.028471680358052254,
0.2504047453403473,
-0.42566439509391785,
0.3029240667819977,
0.10277450829744339,
0.1969655156135559,
-0.6869354248046875,
0.05592048913240433,
-0.7115566730499268,
-0.3628551959991455,
-0.34168288111686707,
-0.3002120554447174,
-0.5548109412193298,
-0.010148159228265285,
0.23592141270637512,
-0.3687683343887329,
0.64615398645401,
0.6077321171760559,
0.04853558912873268,
-0.3593854010105133,
0.037804991006851196,
0.4677946865558624,
0.43708980083465576,
-0.13783439993858337,
0.16880184412002563,
-0.21612733602523804,
-0.3210391402244568,
0.10788983106613159,
0.16879069805145264,
0.505248486995697,
0.30379876494407654,
0.3631537854671478,
0.6755742430686951,
0.05084986239671707,
-0.9825801253318787,
0.7555580735206604,
-0.6858542561531067,
-0.10970523208379745,
-0.7349711656570435,
0.09804718941450119,
0.14180180430412292,
0.5611624717712402,
-0.2206829935312271,
-0.29883873462677,
0.2846616804599762,
-0.409577339887619,
0.2951369285583496,
0.5060702562332153,
-0.7650071382522583,
-0.7499844431877136,
0.567635178565979,
-0.12636691331863403,
-0.4432142376899719,
0.8260327577590942,
0.13666605949401855,
-0.3976859152317047,
0.47249504923820496,
0.624028205871582,
0.7326707243919373,
-0.3827435076236725,
0.7516605257987976,
0.283427894115448,
-0.019660770893096924,
-0.0653039962053299,
0.39814886450767517,
-0.15338335931301117,
-0.6417940258979797,
-0.14850635826587677,
-0.46932172775268555,
-0.17953398823738098,
0.3992392122745514,
-1.2441507577896118,
0.3328515291213989,
-0.44110873341560364,
-0.7398878931999207,
-0.1352623999118805,
-0.14591780304908752,
-0.9109693765640259,
0.499713271856308,
0.4505547881126404,
0.7802296876907349,
-0.9314838647842407,
0.7278562784194946,
0.8505190014839172,
-0.30915263295173645,
-0.4853614866733551,
-0.033258892595767975,
0.2807447612285614,
-0.49186477065086365,
0.2876330018043518,
0.3608235716819763,
0.11179481446743011,
0.020277440547943115,
-0.45751532912254333,
-0.5940946936607361,
1.207552433013916,
0.33225688338279724,
-0.28564631938934326,
0.1152140200138092,
0.3298516273498535,
0.9332519769668579,
-0.052012309432029724,
0.34895986318588257,
0.6096128821372986,
0.42503681778907776,
-0.3175819516181946,
-1.0854003429412842,
0.013033616356551647,
-0.26641544699668884,
0.045639749616384506,
-0.005870182067155838,
-0.7795806527137756,
0.7983761429786682,
0.04772353544831276,
-0.18690456449985504,
-0.33007243275642395,
0.14508049190044403,
0.29868948459625244,
0.4543343484401703,
0.5007874965667725,
0.6109305620193481,
0.8017345666885376,
0.4069158136844635,
1.2426660060882568,
-0.018513338640332222,
0.24547234177589417,
0.7482480406761169,
-0.22257182002067566,
0.3454087972640991,
0.47984451055526733,
-0.19516928493976593,
0.3058188557624817,
0.6935717463493347,
0.336084246635437,
0.8493424654006958,
0.26844316720962524,
-0.866287887096405,
-0.571845293045044,
-0.41342487931251526,
-0.29720017313957214,
0.08196519315242767,
0.7880465984344482,
-0.027659859508275986,
-0.28285327553749084,
0.44997650384902954,
-0.10103680938482285,
-0.028737222775816917,
-0.00623956648632884,
0.8437584042549133,
0.6549333930015564,
-0.49172699451446533,
0.7054339647293091,
-0.22014927864074707,
0.15845385193824768,
-0.5107415318489075,
-0.12362716346979141,
-0.3593571186065674,
0.4931386709213257,
-0.053894899785518646,
-0.3741053342819214,
0.23818691074848175,
-0.04466306418180466,
-0.32219693064689636,
-0.1085229441523552,
0.4924369156360626,
-0.21486985683441162,
-0.6172251105308533,
0.6860556602478027,
0.46308645606040955,
-0.040439676493406296,
-0.2786015570163727,
-0.4734499156475067,
-0.04538584500551224,
-0.12213911861181259,
-0.5139846801757812,
0.6598086953163147,
1.006893515586853,
-0.24767057597637177,
0.7319904565811157,
0.33013418316841125,
-0.18707597255706787,
0.18939432501792908,
-0.0505741722881794,
1.0613735914230347,
-0.6999714374542236,
-0.2999408543109894,
-0.4766620695590973,
0.8421491980552673,
-0.02024943009018898,
-0.2533382475376129,
0.44089996814727783,
0.08954783529043198,
0.5715643763542175,
-0.194123312830925,
1.133179783821106,
-0.11416067183017731,
0.6893590092658997,
-0.11493505537509918,
0.0825895145535469,
-0.684485673904419,
-0.14138436317443848,
-0.19822902977466583,
-0.4492259621620178,
-0.19799436628818512,
0.47262081503868103,
-0.0011958442628383636,
-0.3461867570877075,
0.6589679718017578,
0.6418820023536682,
-0.14304207265377045,
-0.14513321220874786,
0.5393263101577759,
0.3946455717086792,
0.77944415807724,
0.705910861492157,
1.099234938621521,
-0.06317660212516785,
0.5005046129226685,
-0.3423047363758087,
-0.3453868329524994,
-0.11877121776342392,
-0.577786386013031,
-1.0174707174301147,
-0.3503059446811676,
-0.3149300217628479,
-0.2613801658153534,
-0.2200426161289215,
0.8176127672195435,
0.39685484766960144,
-0.4437979757785797,
0.2874135673046112,
-0.020054416730999947,
-0.34970754384994507,
-0.7128326892852783,
-0.2782426178455353,
0.16409993171691895,
-0.22667455673217773,
-0.3984207212924957,
0.4028380513191223,
0.1346123218536377,
-0.2757294476032257,
-0.28100645542144775,
0.04979540407657623,
0.2305653989315033,
-0.04928077012300491,
0.8336551189422607,
-0.008549577556550503,
-0.6772325038909912,
-0.09159952402114868,
-0.02118515968322754,
-0.28936484456062317,
0.023884354159235954,
0.6721650958061218,
-0.9854580163955688,
0.512486457824707,
0.06676031649112701,
0.4299861788749695,
0.5116230249404907,
0.2222874015569687,
0.7318516373634338,
-0.40545812249183655,
0.09949410706758499,
0.2511301040649414,
-0.04014623537659645,
0.3219922184944153,
-0.8552237749099731,
0.139128178358078,
0.20521575212478638,
-0.36916065216064453,
-0.8818475008010864,
0.30379539728164673,
-1.0348938703536987,
-0.30041444301605225,
0.8268037438392639,
-0.5195984840393066,
-0.10824592411518097,
-0.29934263229370117,
-0.8396831750869751,
0.4078919291496277,
-0.2982635796070099,
1.3129379749298096,
0.5531498193740845,
-0.5808181762695312,
-0.3138597011566162,
-0.646981954574585,
0.531121015548706,
0.11019360274076462,
-0.7138456106185913,
-0.015515892766416073,
0.7805203199386597,
0.33893296122550964,
0.08844795823097229,
0.950484573841095,
0.02602948062121868,
0.37071481347084045,
-0.1484707146883011,
0.03476487100124359,
0.09335244446992874,
-0.0030322610400617123,
-0.1797778457403183,
0.1514023244380951,
-0.09640034288167953,
-0.12707075476646423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10560v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10560v1
|
Facts-and-Feelings: Capturing both Objectivity and Subjectivity in Table-to-Text Generation
| 2024-06-15T08:41:44 | 2024-06-15T08:41:44 |
Tathagata Dey, Pushpak Bhattacharyya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Table-to-text generation, a long-standing challenge in natural language
generation, has remained unexplored through the lens of subjectivity.
Subjectivity here encompasses the comprehension of information derived from the
table that cannot be described solely by objective data. Given the absence of
pre-existing datasets, we introduce the Ta2TS dataset with 3849 data instances.
We perform the task of fine-tuning sequence-to-sequence models on the
linearized tables and prompting on popular large language models. We analyze
the results from a quantitative and qualitative perspective to ensure the
capture of subjectivity and factual consistency. The analysis shows the
fine-tuned LMs can perform close to the prompted LLMs. Both the models can
capture the tabular data, generating texts with 85.15% BERTScore and 26.28%
Meteor score. To the best of our knowledge, we provide the first-of-its-kind
dataset on tables with multiple genres and subjectivity included and present
the first comprehensive analysis and comparison of different LLM performances
on this task.
|
[
-0.3067534267902374,
-0.9526846408843994,
0.8576918840408325,
0.13481763005256653,
-0.33236902952194214,
-0.2314407378435135,
-0.41322678327560425,
-0.12597206234931946,
-0.37426134943962097,
0.6527501344680786,
-0.46126052737236023,
-0.7893529534339905,
-0.37710800766944885,
0.2271430790424347,
-0.2588464319705963,
1.5524065494537354,
0.08723250776529312,
-0.2803103029727936,
-0.2990265488624573,
-0.10525179654359818,
-0.4839380979537964,
-0.46629443764686584,
-0.15122166275978088,
-0.19491180777549744,
0.8772771954536438,
0.862612783908844,
0.6135046482086182,
0.7395020127296448,
0.25823500752449036,
0.10257858783006668,
0.07429521530866623,
0.06956885755062103,
-0.5320448279380798,
0.4230063855648041,
-0.28149569034576416,
-0.4016183614730835,
-0.3008009195327759,
-0.1209346279501915,
0.6034666895866394,
0.4349864423274994,
0.1357906460762024,
0.5063846707344055,
0.20247581601142883,
1.0111557245254517,
-0.2075001746416092,
0.2750990688800812,
-0.727738082408905,
0.2473098784685135,
-0.2863457500934601,
-0.25490689277648926,
-0.8145906925201416,
-0.66900634765625,
0.10788735747337341,
-0.2636587917804718,
0.4032215476036072,
0.15388771891593933,
0.5867328643798828,
0.26211488246917725,
-0.7410686016082764,
-0.44998225569725037,
-0.8538736701011658,
0.6338571310043335,
-0.7098883390426636,
0.45732977986335754,
0.000010032455065811519,
-0.2871018350124359,
-0.09232611954212189,
-0.8915281295776367,
-0.6701512932777405,
-0.3748229146003723,
0.028940973803400993,
-0.09544588625431061,
0.028320807963609695,
-0.31364497542381287,
0.4557207524776459,
0.28400909900665283,
-0.845082700252533,
-0.03047027997672558,
-0.28487062454223633,
0.1421583741903305,
0.5337886214256287,
0.20801644027233124,
0.06359069794416428,
-0.4006458520889282,
-0.45352110266685486,
0.009654092602431774,
-0.7972032427787781,
0.11771809309720993,
0.2689553499221802,
0.7027134299278259,
-0.10598251223564148,
1.028433084487915,
-0.4302974045276642,
0.6313692927360535,
0.18870645761489868,
-0.05016132444143295,
0.014874718151986599,
-0.38813483715057373,
-0.056645408272743225,
0.25987204909324646,
1.0188096761703491,
0.3987988531589508,
0.48299115896224976,
-0.31608861684799194,
-0.0037183205131441355,
-0.11080903559923172,
0.19641757011413574,
-0.9196799397468567,
-0.00924958847463131,
0.3029034435749054,
-0.1784498691558838,
-0.4501914978027344,
0.08484718203544617,
-0.7777873873710632,
-0.2638947665691376,
-0.6605170965194702,
0.21809037029743195,
-0.1694962978363037,
-0.02491048164665699,
-0.2005315124988556,
0.15804868936538696,
0.13735252618789673,
0.0571894571185112,
-0.6927511692047119,
0.1224292740225792,
0.7049885392189026,
0.8076372742652893,
-0.37953463196754456,
0.01780245266854763,
-0.3922303020954132,
0.28318431973457336,
-0.20660077035427094,
0.7956876754760742,
-0.00963477324694395,
-0.39012524485588074,
0.06723007559776306,
-0.4128732681274414,
0.42491891980171204,
-0.12756381928920746,
0.7676365971565247,
-0.24131342768669128,
0.6274341344833374,
-0.8770304322242737,
-0.54327392578125,
0.0005942702409811318,
0.34994304180145264,
-0.5646579265594482,
1.0947521924972534,
-0.16187569499015808,
-0.7225855588912964,
0.780392587184906,
-0.4952656328678131,
-0.7356716394424438,
-0.18045489490032196,
-0.2628730237483978,
-0.6132178902626038,
0.34605053067207336,
-0.1666167676448822,
0.7530888915061951,
-0.6394303441047668,
0.8532990217208862,
-0.05336553975939751,
-0.0006798187969252467,
0.43575674295425415,
-0.2151889204978943,
-0.015066239982843399,
0.24645468592643738,
-0.3713030219078064,
0.14778688549995422,
-0.6688134670257568,
0.09343723952770233,
0.030655013397336006,
-0.5679347515106201,
0.13617351651191711,
0.29580312967300415,
0.24906876683235168,
0.6405003666877747,
0.06118292734026909,
-0.44812309741973877,
-0.03086571767926216,
-0.397295743227005,
0.2637392580509186,
0.39262813329696655,
0.23948971927165985,
0.35112524032592773,
-0.39141780138015747,
0.07425689697265625,
0.23555202782154083,
-0.3685847222805023,
0.027797525748610497,
-0.5851567387580872,
-0.6570757031440735,
0.2507895231246948,
0.16095151007175446,
0.3489328920841217,
-0.49528199434280396,
0.5895665287971497,
-0.556298553943634,
-0.5485662221908569,
-0.06313242018222809,
-0.08923494070768356,
0.3444264829158783,
1.0417332649230957,
0.270733505487442,
-0.13477791845798492,
-0.2990108132362366,
-0.946411669254303,
-0.33243533968925476,
0.010187649168074131,
0.08371089398860931,
0.2745748460292816,
0.17057128250598907,
0.23146368563175201,
1.2784737348556519,
-0.6164088845252991,
-0.1405622363090515,
-0.28168168663978577,
0.4982895255088806,
0.25973597168922424,
0.4966481029987335,
0.3318421542644501,
-0.6414894461631775,
-0.5737640261650085,
0.06980385631322861,
-0.831769585609436,
0.007128378376364708,
0.11230432242155075,
0.11276931315660477,
0.3925999104976654,
0.13290825486183167,
-0.5528340935707092,
0.2722676694393158,
0.08355572074651718,
-0.46732133626937866,
0.23039667308330536,
0.08505965769290924,
0.18083427846431732,
-1.3490681648254395,
0.4731247127056122,
0.2891244888305664,
-0.2626461982727051,
-0.9546335935592651,
-0.21574530005455017,
-0.17451635003089905,
-0.298441618680954,
-0.6364215016365051,
0.4442805349826813,
-0.3754919171333313,
-0.18747401237487793,
-0.22427460551261902,
0.1562233865261078,
0.22965089976787567,
0.5772577524185181,
0.2676639258861542,
0.8155085444450378,
0.18129831552505493,
-0.8613191246986389,
0.19051815569400787,
0.446096807718277,
-0.27476966381073,
0.5366697907447815,
-0.7337015271186829,
0.3181534707546234,
-0.3442840278148651,
0.042809974402189255,
-0.9590978622436523,
-0.39397913217544556,
0.29406335949897766,
-0.32002511620521545,
0.32870861887931824,
0.021703319624066353,
-0.5439868569374084,
-0.04869300499558449,
-0.40367591381073,
0.19903092086315155,
0.5014247298240662,
-0.10306358337402344,
0.42572876811027527,
0.18932406604290009,
-0.47747549414634705,
-0.5079638361930847,
-0.7063098549842834,
0.23275208473205566,
-0.32780927419662476,
-0.4244323670864105,
0.09588191658258438,
0.004582389257848263,
-0.28441154956817627,
-0.2991189956665039,
-0.02336222305893898,
0.24090458452701569,
-0.11871986091136932,
0.2765701711177826,
-0.0027383805718272924,
-0.30379518866539,
0.30878227949142456,
0.20831185579299927,
0.057259853929281235,
0.280894935131073,
-0.23472009599208832,
0.7164767384529114,
-0.12691782414913177,
0.05784166231751442,
-0.45673051476478577,
0.2683764398097992,
0.23426875472068787,
-0.18568935990333557,
0.5134022235870361,
0.48347046971321106,
-0.16335566341876984,
-0.06142597645521164,
-0.5606634616851807,
-0.20536383986473083,
-0.40257492661476135,
0.40046125650405884,
-0.41173139214515686,
-0.6764377355575562,
0.4079994559288025,
0.1019272729754448,
0.21202541887760162,
0.5696916580200195,
0.9867285490036011,
-0.042755126953125,
0.6370018124580383,
0.23948392271995544,
0.2908024489879608,
0.1313904970884323,
0.05012573301792145,
0.0008707165834493935,
-0.5280798077583313,
-0.5298606157302856,
-0.6621643900871277,
-0.3912354111671448,
-0.6633606553077698,
-0.16444167494773865,
0.29730597138404846,
-0.47592025995254517,
-0.35920774936676025,
0.11642573028802872,
-0.6142799258232117,
0.27972716093063354,
0.5423543453216553,
0.4267514944076538,
0.4910911023616791,
0.13387951254844666,
0.3264063000679016,
-0.2725868821144104,
-0.4541696012020111,
-0.7824411988258362,
1.2749803066253662,
0.28960466384887695,
0.5248292684555054,
0.23542016744613647,
0.634182870388031,
0.4335312843322754,
0.48483142256736755,
-0.9394220113754272,
0.5957780480384827,
-0.18321585655212402,
-0.7332404851913452,
-0.3244452178478241,
-0.4831361770629883,
-0.7360507845878601,
-0.2985282242298126,
-0.33370909094810486,
-0.516740083694458,
0.21685902774333954,
0.28822705149650574,
-0.18108752369880676,
0.08872852474451065,
-0.5698537826538086,
0.888403058052063,
-0.1446523815393448,
-0.9382736682891846,
0.13583491742610931,
-0.8995506167411804,
0.675857424736023,
-0.14586444199085236,
0.00033784558763727546,
-0.3530295789241791,
0.1478746384382248,
0.6038976311683655,
-0.14075690507888794,
0.7037438750267029,
-0.08702148497104645,
-0.35311299562454224,
0.38318172097206116,
0.26179876923561096,
0.3823855221271515,
0.1522250920534134,
-0.30713874101638794,
-0.3200913965702057,
-0.34879496693611145,
-0.13100506365299225,
-0.24123124778270721,
0.8875921964645386,
-0.6035611033439636,
-0.5420600175857544,
-0.4347659647464752,
-0.60621577501297,
-0.43896907567977905,
0.17381583154201508,
0.46105530858039856,
0.612112283706665,
-0.4472363591194153,
0.3821057379245758,
0.8022269010543823,
0.07550105452537537,
0.4530539810657501,
0.21387504041194916,
-0.09843070805072784,
-0.2708810567855835,
1.0036324262619019,
-0.010916653089225292,
0.26964032649993896,
0.6569365859031677,
0.3322007358074188,
-0.6292036771774292,
-0.5381823182106018,
-0.5060317516326904,
0.04932541027665138,
-0.4435392916202545,
-0.46898162364959717,
-0.7619834542274475,
0.1248517706990242,
-0.31393641233444214,
0.18918336927890778,
-0.1527768224477768,
-0.5148254036903381,
-0.6418437957763672,
-0.2796671986579895,
0.5838999152183533,
1.0183067321777344,
0.17471374571323395,
0.2810412347316742,
-0.8203715085983276,
0.4942689836025238,
0.32841843366622925,
0.20924648642539978,
-0.2302992194890976,
-0.47252634167671204,
-0.01843188889324665,
0.08419977128505707,
-0.31332162022590637,
-1.0887813568115234,
0.2030920684337616,
0.27181902527809143,
-0.027027934789657593,
0.09024245291948318,
0.04321487993001938,
0.20944884419441223,
-0.48641642928123474,
0.7652366757392883,
0.06733797490596771,
-1.1066991090774536,
0.6781815886497498,
-0.5299814343452454,
0.1677975207567215,
0.8641478419303894,
0.1668403297662735,
-0.4359404146671295,
-0.2985488772392273,
-0.46071192622184753,
-0.7178065180778503,
0.9224480390548706,
0.2586096525192261,
0.008952717296779156,
0.1341584026813507,
0.6220281720161438,
0.5091771483421326,
0.5966359376907349,
-1.1804074048995972,
-0.08457222580909729,
-0.39184802770614624,
-0.6900919675827026,
-0.053690847009420395,
-0.35621020197868347,
-0.04231083393096924,
0.11702058464288712,
0.5110240578651428,
-0.11043942719697952,
-0.03624333441257477,
0.3534311056137085,
-0.01960132271051407,
-0.16652032732963562,
0.5142598748207092,
0.8449016213417053,
0.5450220108032227,
-0.29066574573516846,
0.19358117878437042,
-0.02858790010213852,
-0.4281702935695648,
0.27579301595687866,
-0.000007811188879713882,
-0.526982843875885,
0.14593778550624847,
0.06267917156219482,
1.0030676126480103,
0.07821483910083771,
-0.4022226631641388,
0.3360379934310913,
0.15901918709278107,
-0.15967512130737305,
0.040821053087711334,
0.012721860781311989,
-0.06356906145811081,
-0.13715054094791412,
0.25110095739364624,
-0.16344375908374786,
0.27328595519065857,
-0.9184772968292236,
0.33953920006752014,
0.2755432426929474,
-0.3763979971408844,
-0.5132884383201599,
0.8517431616783142,
0.3036063611507416,
-0.313568115234375,
0.2516564130783081,
-0.1793094128370285,
-0.15540501475334167,
0.42807242274284363,
0.3404220938682556,
0.804368793964386,
0.046830594539642334,
0.29500409960746765,
0.4677967429161072,
0.15306991338729858,
-0.06654252111911774,
0.5892981290817261,
-0.23632614314556122,
-0.5592882633209229,
-0.308114230632782,
-0.31093618273735046,
-0.487724244594574,
0.10834148526191711,
-0.6870495080947876,
0.3415986895561218,
-0.5164780616760254,
-0.433311402797699,
-0.09630735218524933,
0.015912843868136406,
-0.6553443670272827,
0.5156686305999756,
0.12607260048389435,
0.48414725065231323,
-0.9174329042434692,
0.6322572231292725,
0.462719589471817,
-0.44083040952682495,
-0.7954515814781189,
0.1584804505109787,
-0.23155666887760162,
-0.5135669708251953,
0.6414890289306641,
0.06940732151269913,
0.19727206230163574,
0.268099308013916,
-0.4887295961380005,
-0.5802043676376343,
1.1201422214508057,
0.21800565719604492,
-0.5875653028488159,
-0.23683840036392212,
0.7487212419509888,
0.4951797425746918,
-0.20027706027030945,
-0.05497921258211136,
0.6569480895996094,
0.7065252065658569,
-0.10391556471586227,
-0.4415801167488098,
0.26526835560798645,
0.23302465677261353,
-0.18212032318115234,
0.24081872403621674,
-0.5494978427886963,
0.6203304529190063,
-0.06409025192260742,
-0.2981686294078827,
-0.15566641092300415,
0.9158315658569336,
0.40103858709335327,
0.6380107402801514,
0.22982780635356903,
0.5369743704795837,
0.37119513750076294,
-0.3983190953731537,
0.7168378233909607,
-0.33571749925613403,
0.26457473635673523,
1.139072060585022,
-0.6910939812660217,
0.7630212903022766,
0.5851850509643555,
-0.03145265579223633,
0.19658398628234863,
0.3775354027748108,
0.08406061679124832,
0.4547107517719269,
0.1328970342874527,
-0.23895540833473206,
0.050930205732584,
-0.41625943779945374,
-0.4205797016620636,
0.32462891936302185,
0.2808181345462799,
-0.367294043302536,
-0.2506020665168762,
-0.1363459676504135,
0.16362176835536957,
0.48195135593414307,
-0.1644972413778305,
1.0849412679672241,
-0.01714743860065937,
-0.8016674518585205,
0.01586403138935566,
-0.03270033746957779,
0.3368472158908844,
-0.2872578501701355,
0.2435818761587143,
-0.26559627056121826,
-0.2903138995170593,
-0.3225913345813751,
-1.2682921886444092,
0.13012681901454926,
0.36989861726760864,
-0.3878393769264221,
-0.39681559801101685,
0.6330615282058716,
-0.619897723197937,
-0.46206220984458923,
-0.39792898297309875,
0.7802637815475464,
-0.003598026931285858,
-0.08598261326551437,
-0.07728472352027893,
0.05848727375268936,
0.20218636095523834,
-0.5010269284248352,
-0.0714036151766777,
0.934160053730011,
0.2482912391424179,
0.20383921265602112,
0.5857470035552979,
-0.18102121353149414,
-0.09298188984394073,
0.054196737706661224,
0.7763134837150574,
-0.9528880715370178,
-0.15043650567531586,
-1.0050514936447144,
0.7580319046974182,
0.0491267666220665,
-0.6602085828781128,
0.5232195854187012,
1.0146375894546509,
0.21549341082572937,
-0.40982159972190857,
0.6522699594497681,
-0.15088346600532532,
0.6146826148033142,
-0.6756469011306763,
0.5745150446891785,
-0.3442923426628113,
-0.051553670316934586,
-0.16702859103679657,
-1.07487154006958,
-0.20511502027511597,
0.03171759843826294,
-0.16261394321918488,
-0.10128942877054214,
0.44619864225387573,
0.5034573078155518,
0.07886409759521484,
0.008521979674696922,
0.1681452840566635,
0.2732875645160675,
0.3714929223060608,
0.4318077862262726,
0.907151460647583,
-0.3437049090862274,
0.24014681577682495,
-0.20896492898464203,
0.01836741715669632,
-0.10471098870038986,
-1.0723686218261719,
-0.8646396994590759,
-0.6744030714035034,
-0.30756303668022156,
-0.2748173475265503,
-0.058737922459840775,
0.9297377467155457,
0.26981157064437866,
-0.8238435983657837,
-0.15079285204410553,
-0.3943736255168915,
0.04480142146348953,
0.4428170323371887,
-0.24238698184490204,
0.25821465253829956,
-0.26736247539520264,
-0.720594584941864,
0.14727051556110382,
0.14527566730976105,
0.14034809172153473,
-0.14221176505088806,
0.165088951587677,
-0.15158571302890778,
0.011678123846650124,
0.6846218109130859,
0.30037564039230347,
-0.636367917060852,
-0.3219626843929291,
0.06507671624422073,
-0.24275800585746765,
0.4290480315685272,
0.943805456161499,
-0.7667185664176941,
0.018042540177702904,
0.5723460912704468,
0.17401032149791718,
0.527142345905304,
0.41578224301338196,
0.6885852217674255,
-1.2400109767913818,
0.21500267088413239,
0.5180243849754333,
0.09460674971342087,
0.46159878373146057,
-0.4211903214454651,
0.34185123443603516,
0.05931786075234413,
-0.6029502153396606,
-0.8629307150840759,
0.3943954110145569,
-1.2549645900726318,
0.04094552993774414,
1.1642165184020996,
0.35828545689582825,
0.015386545099318027,
-0.005640934221446514,
-0.3926742374897003,
0.563123345375061,
-0.5505243539810181,
0.7543917894363403,
0.5303750038146973,
-0.030750801786780357,
0.0949983149766922,
-0.2499813437461853,
0.7691409587860107,
0.38637053966522217,
-1.2233388423919678,
0.21717773377895355,
0.6415995359420776,
0.10055919736623764,
0.026537425816059113,
0.23659412562847137,
0.05248267576098442,
0.03724299743771553,
-0.47909292578697205,
0.2104467898607254,
-0.09814333915710449,
-0.32952678203582764,
-0.10859905183315277,
0.4182509183883667,
0.28953608870506287,
0.07134554535150528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10552v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10552v3
|
Large Language Model Enhanced Clustering for News Event Detection
| 2024-06-15T08:13:47 | 2024-06-28T09:16:28 |
Adane Nega Tarekegn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The news landscape is continuously evolving, with an ever-increasing volume
of information from around the world. Automated event detection within this
vast data repository is essential for monitoring, identifying, and categorizing
significant news occurrences across diverse platforms. This paper presents an
event detection framework that leverages Large Language Models (LLMs) combined
with clustering analysis to detect news events from the Global Database of
Events, Language, and Tone (GDELT). The framework enhances event clustering
through both pre-event detection tasks (keyword extraction and text embedding)
and post-event detection tasks (event summarization and topic labelling). We
also evaluate the impact of various textual embeddings on the quality of
clustering outcomes, ensuring robust news categorization. Additionally, we
introduce a novel Cluster Stability Assessment Index (CSAI) to assess the
validity and robustness of clustering results. CSAI utilizes multiple feature
vectors to provide a new way of measuring clustering quality. Our experiments
indicate that the use of LLM embedding in the event detection framework has
significantly improved the results, demonstrating greater robustness in terms
of CSAI scores. Moreover, post-event detection tasks generate meaningful
insights, facilitating effective interpretation of event clustering results.
Overall, our experimental results indicate that the proposed framework offers
valuable insights and could enhance the accuracy in news analysis and
reporting.
|
[
-0.2454310953617096,
-0.7994721531867981,
0.6712440848350525,
0.20060323178768158,
-0.5570318102836609,
0.17485877871513367,
-0.4808863401412964,
-0.41085511445999146,
0.49042239785194397,
0.08830529451370239,
-0.3567429780960083,
-0.8986303210258484,
-0.5790933966636658,
-0.1145622581243515,
-0.7556536793708801,
0.940908670425415,
0.10658946633338928,
-0.11493287980556488,
-0.2261187881231308,
-0.14493325352668762,
-0.06438687443733215,
-0.8194847702980042,
-0.8097867965698242,
-0.031603775918483734,
0.40515536069869995,
0.04705904424190521,
0.49707552790641785,
0.4572182297706604,
0.5142340660095215,
0.2163168042898178,
-0.3394765257835388,
0.11287469416856766,
-0.3522513806819916,
0.09142988175153732,
0.177481010556221,
-0.3938904106616974,
-0.47948890924453735,
-0.2795291244983673,
0.9639405608177185,
0.2995336055755615,
-0.17807066440582275,
-0.037150971591472626,
-0.026021800935268402,
0.33455270528793335,
-0.5072651505470276,
0.058832816779613495,
-0.7314213514328003,
0.11731530725955963,
-0.31845054030418396,
-0.13794837892055511,
-0.2518933117389679,
-0.1170223280787468,
-0.40031272172927856,
-0.13940894603729248,
0.1960332840681076,
-0.12939460575580597,
0.8371061086654663,
0.07685922831296921,
-0.4060119092464447,
-0.26466211676597595,
-0.387542188167572,
0.7593135237693787,
-0.7008644342422485,
0.5241400599479675,
0.1521596610546112,
0.13091090321540833,
-0.3099101781845093,
-0.5014269351959229,
-0.6271635293960571,
-0.2149704247713089,
-0.0029055599588900805,
0.09102890640497208,
-0.2050321251153946,
-0.1281288117170334,
-0.04858594387769699,
0.4020727574825287,
-0.6775622963905334,
0.5545862317085266,
0.08749263733625412,
-0.19762547314167023,
0.37288984656333923,
0.0729716345667839,
0.38255420327186584,
-0.13311408460140228,
0.08705900609493256,
0.10488560795783997,
-0.734533429145813,
-0.15216714143753052,
0.41512390971183777,
0.2582802474498749,
-0.3085148334503174,
0.2405334860086441,
-0.17365439236164093,
0.4541004002094269,
0.03068189136683941,
-0.3445190489292145,
0.36374232172966003,
-0.32581081986427307,
0.17890526354312897,
0.19181320071220398,
0.694568395614624,
0.4950657784938812,
-0.030966706573963165,
-0.07148952037096024,
-0.056934356689453125,
0.34712737798690796,
-0.11881736665964127,
-0.8933051228523254,
-0.011945061385631561,
0.12547725439071655,
-0.7531661987304688,
-0.5786372423171997,
0.33699023723602295,
-0.7357209324836731,
-0.5907340049743652,
-0.060558293014764786,
0.03792808949947357,
0.16750110685825348,
-0.5101922154426575,
0.07487235963344574,
0.021361932158470154,
0.23836608231067657,
0.1856568604707718,
-0.6698992848396301,
0.01908973976969719,
0.8404812812805176,
0.8450837731361389,
-0.6032862663269043,
-0.00792926736176014,
-0.9564172625541687,
0.1813620775938034,
-0.35951748490333557,
0.8476848602294922,
-0.6532784104347229,
-0.20563079416751862,
0.12959156930446625,
0.1410122960805893,
0.22136233747005463,
-0.3926757276058197,
0.6238898634910583,
-0.6538664698600769,
0.0011192739475518465,
-0.07715414464473724,
-0.5155794024467468,
-0.06304431706666946,
0.40755435824394226,
-0.6522875428199768,
0.981115460395813,
-0.23144181072711945,
-0.7261650562286377,
0.7673381567001343,
-0.41977858543395996,
-0.6044987440109253,
-0.18594031035900116,
-0.3468365967273712,
-0.7269736528396606,
0.3674813210964203,
0.6392465829849243,
0.6292853951454163,
0.021626917645335197,
0.5981717109680176,
-0.47720226645469666,
-0.23056550323963165,
0.14265675842761993,
-0.38214319944381714,
0.1558404564857483,
-0.13222680985927582,
-0.1162661612033844,
0.3202004134654999,
-0.9740293025970459,
-0.3181505501270294,
0.06121908500790596,
-0.5736463665962219,
-0.23622478544712067,
0.39657992124557495,
0.37820690870285034,
0.2075589895248413,
0.2320406436920166,
-0.6194360852241516,
0.013101346790790558,
-0.2657201290130615,
0.2709237039089203,
0.45743104815483093,
0.15519119799137115,
0.46442872285842896,
0.0698445662856102,
0.4582712948322296,
0.3185466229915619,
0.03163093328475952,
-0.35757923126220703,
-0.4049440324306488,
-0.5370302200317383,
-0.2989601194858551,
0.271677166223526,
0.5333453416824341,
-0.5409296751022339,
0.8722642660140991,
-0.2996780574321747,
-0.23527869582176208,
-0.054675448685884476,
0.07077470421791077,
-0.027310604229569435,
0.009439128451049328,
0.05055559054017067,
-0.09634756296873093,
-0.8048421740531921,
-0.46632882952690125,
-0.22607557475566864,
-0.23102635145187378,
-0.06364946812391281,
-0.25247302651405334,
0.4085346460342407,
-0.36118003726005554,
0.8479079008102417,
-0.25442448258399963,
-0.21997933089733124,
-0.3707534670829773,
0.17719252407550812,
0.4456578195095062,
0.23469460010528564,
0.7200994491577148,
-1.0834201574325562,
-0.34277912974357605,
0.42168888449668884,
-0.5095694661140442,
-0.2340354174375534,
-0.03819175809621811,
0.22768624126911163,
0.5340301990509033,
0.7932995557785034,
-0.24175871908664703,
0.5304443836212158,
0.7057521343231201,
-0.40805941820144653,
0.47561973333358765,
0.10821366310119629,
0.33765384554862976,
-1.1755173206329346,
-0.13746553659439087,
0.009889081120491028,
-0.42251479625701904,
-0.4969528019428253,
-0.14199016988277435,
0.07023176550865173,
0.004708916414529085,
-0.2789325714111328,
0.4245606064796448,
-0.261785626411438,
-0.3325490951538086,
-0.6570194959640503,
0.2647932767868042,
0.006947230082005262,
0.012283878400921822,
0.1699199080467224,
0.47267332673072815,
0.4359426498413086,
-0.48947781324386597,
0.4596802592277527,
0.07031773030757904,
-0.7763150334358215,
0.3638893663883209,
-0.47265952825546265,
-0.1794452667236328,
-0.15647444128990173,
0.40445762872695923,
-0.9043095111846924,
-0.18073445558547974,
-0.028897298499941826,
-0.5505920648574829,
0.15714037418365479,
-0.05250496044754982,
-0.8936207294464111,
-0.30510997772216797,
-0.31724852323532104,
0.18987056612968445,
0.21253810822963715,
-0.5881544947624207,
0.7074031829833984,
0.46879687905311584,
-0.26480987668037415,
-0.3558395504951477,
-0.7265530824661255,
0.2651486098766327,
-0.34090569615364075,
-0.6009163856506348,
0.2066589891910553,
0.1784614473581314,
-0.12535139918327332,
0.35551950335502625,
-0.20140713453292847,
-0.29354941844940186,
0.2092190682888031,
0.11389156430959702,
0.11770373582839966,
-0.35890981554985046,
0.25790056586265564,
0.19116322696208954,
-0.3077026903629303,
-0.23997434973716736,
-0.2541675269603729,
0.5567276477813721,
-0.1619012951850891,
-0.618384063243866,
-0.608681857585907,
0.4397420883178711,
0.8150753378868103,
-0.5257043838500977,
0.9697874784469604,
1.2567692995071411,
-0.5365609526634216,
0.164198637008667,
-0.7698532938957214,
-0.2086249440908432,
-0.3821168541908264,
0.7201629877090454,
0.024741770699620247,
-1.509889841079712,
0.7707222700119019,
-0.02939786948263645,
-0.2126486599445343,
0.35645410418510437,
0.6170487403869629,
0.07028072327375412,
1.4127368927001953,
0.7346016764640808,
-0.7210153937339783,
0.7267580032348633,
0.27407753467559814,
0.4672744572162628,
-0.4030647277832031,
0.17887501418590546,
-0.581574559211731,
-0.17391547560691833,
-0.41983532905578613,
-0.4571578800678253,
0.4539676308631897,
0.0464923158288002,
0.012033434584736824,
-0.15411491692066193,
-0.16437245905399323,
0.6744867563247681,
0.22048860788345337,
-0.15279394388198853,
0.5539078116416931,
0.17525537312030792,
0.3632134795188904,
-0.05663866549730301,
-0.592775821685791,
-0.28158774971961975,
0.7471916079521179,
0.3433571755886078,
0.6000586748123169,
0.011723101139068604,
0.6231396198272705,
0.21331463754177094,
0.3023875653743744,
-0.6340211033821106,
0.2408948689699173,
-0.35385358333587646,
-0.31579992175102234,
-0.14879553020000458,
-0.4237982928752899,
-0.7151623368263245,
0.36300262808799744,
-0.4524745047092438,
-0.8118462562561035,
0.2598884403705597,
-0.12709516286849976,
-0.29370996356010437,
0.4521258771419525,
-0.1986865997314453,
0.8105741143226624,
-0.15324299037456512,
0.08245836198329926,
-0.57179194688797,
-0.06305013597011566,
0.27557575702667236,
-0.21225543320178986,
0.5935012102127075,
-0.16644464433193207,
-0.2059435099363327,
0.6453925967216492,
0.12215401232242584,
0.9349011182785034,
-0.050462767481803894,
-0.15567509829998016,
0.2405603677034378,
-0.2264525592327118,
0.7348734140396118,
0.23073384165763855,
-0.1586052030324936,
0.1045561209321022,
-0.06523271650075912,
-0.15346454083919525,
-0.45470941066741943,
0.8481176495552063,
-0.38344717025756836,
-0.3865281641483307,
-0.1385822743177414,
-0.36647021770477295,
0.08277533203363419,
-0.013357719406485558,
0.03656991943717003,
0.5480501055717468,
-0.3293764293193817,
0.610333263874054,
0.3929498493671417,
-0.3730469346046448,
0.4059005677700043,
0.7211682200431824,
-0.609975278377533,
-0.284389853477478,
0.9526973366737366,
-0.03748420253396034,
-0.13433736562728882,
0.3315126597881317,
0.1792290210723877,
-0.16753795742988586,
-0.9089502692222595,
-0.16142350435256958,
0.10851269215345383,
-0.5906423330307007,
-0.29403018951416016,
-0.7902319431304932,
-0.06022348627448082,
-0.2956436276435852,
-0.2566626965999603,
-0.20429520308971405,
-0.17860904335975647,
-0.36976614594459534,
-0.3489927649497986,
0.2334110289812088,
0.5926369428634644,
-0.08751755207777023,
0.5285959243774414,
-1.0945889949798584,
0.3397471606731415,
-0.029508858919143677,
0.23476794362068176,
-0.18668261170387268,
-0.2755519449710846,
-0.4470851719379425,
-0.34540504217147827,
-0.1357107162475586,
-0.6804120540618896,
0.31403040885925293,
0.2626373767852783,
0.6623979210853577,
0.6850895285606384,
-0.05276833474636078,
0.3498561382293701,
-0.40730762481689453,
0.7948265671730042,
0.16200409829616547,
-0.9398974180221558,
0.722385048866272,
-0.6931431889533997,
0.3213930130004883,
0.3179202079772949,
0.018257509917020798,
-0.6480758190155029,
-0.6351088285446167,
-0.2950133681297302,
-0.8735259771347046,
0.5205609798431396,
-0.14263246953487396,
0.08402805030345917,
-0.35159334540367126,
0.2754375636577606,
-0.16697144508361816,
0.29959985613822937,
-1.1524854898452759,
0.2403572052717209,
0.2976182699203491,
-0.3638528883457184,
0.0010608843294903636,
-0.5089512467384338,
0.1554621011018753,
-0.21322157979011536,
0.6193555593490601,
-0.20197871327400208,
-0.06970507651567459,
-0.09367097914218903,
-0.29752564430236816,
-0.20070397853851318,
0.2727215886116028,
0.40501150488853455,
0.7547503709793091,
0.023237604647874832,
-0.11741083115339279,
0.24924518167972565,
-0.3448761999607086,
-0.03209563344717026,
0.09293811768293381,
0.06939490884542465,
0.12657243013381958,
0.5889589786529541,
0.5781726241111755,
0.417976051568985,
-0.734570324420929,
0.7536555528640747,
-0.10798902064561844,
0.06387052685022354,
-0.20405559241771698,
-0.03754199668765068,
0.0754379853606224,
0.5039878487586975,
0.5423784255981445,
-0.37207791209220886,
0.2587219774723053,
-0.5530041456222534,
0.40807411074638367,
0.4994945228099823,
-0.3104435205459595,
-0.22706201672554016,
0.3509059548377991,
0.28420203924179077,
0.24745334684848785,
0.19729451835155487,
-0.31772762537002563,
-0.7842323780059814,
0.9994956254959106,
0.49046623706817627,
0.6130966544151306,
-0.30640000104904175,
0.2243383675813675,
0.09237363189458847,
0.5039913058280945,
-0.08423692733049393,
0.18864595890045166,
0.21147991716861725,
-0.8604543805122375,
-0.8555986285209656,
-0.8555517196655273,
-0.1808864325284958,
0.24767109751701355,
-0.6218885183334351,
0.1961420178413391,
-0.11474554240703583,
-0.09682008624076843,
-0.2896018326282501,
-0.05103427916765213,
-0.31334590911865234,
-0.07721443474292755,
0.5534325242042542,
0.8210551738739014,
-1.0680632591247559,
0.5912731885910034,
0.8144892454147339,
0.2460666000843048,
-0.14612722396850586,
0.2697395980358124,
0.21853017807006836,
-0.41758620738983154,
0.20579805970191956,
0.516251266002655,
0.2821202278137207,
-0.08131475746631622,
-0.29511702060699463,
-0.9269686937332153,
0.8629067540168762,
0.28063541650772095,
-0.6835103034973145,
0.2862565517425537,
-0.09310029447078705,
0.46918901801109314,
-0.4292120039463043,
-0.15187755227088928,
0.6453167200088501,
0.6903036832809448,
0.01855642721056938,
-0.8176282048225403,
-0.12307262420654297,
0.06294115632772446,
-0.08254702389240265,
0.557095468044281,
-0.3088083267211914,
0.5457319617271423,
0.09142136573791504,
-0.19984303414821625,
0.02479572966694832,
0.9629952311515808,
0.173859104514122,
0.6055004000663757,
0.544575572013855,
0.6104353666305542,
0.8663866519927979,
-0.2151946872472763,
0.8445042371749878,
-0.33197855949401855,
0.3303452134132385,
0.687924861907959,
-0.20972320437431335,
0.8622506260871887,
0.09116630256175995,
-0.18130768835544586,
0.47032198309898376,
0.5584262609481812,
-0.09294911473989487,
0.4996245801448822,
0.12715551257133484,
-0.5356824398040771,
-0.4535234570503235,
-0.1772274374961853,
-0.4445399343967438,
0.528430163860321,
0.6954541802406311,
-0.3328271508216858,
-0.5184130668640137,
0.4454200565814972,
0.049903012812137604,
0.13086536526679993,
-0.7726122140884399,
0.5921969413757324,
0.024114005267620087,
-0.18722285330295563,
-0.06191537156701088,
0.09974031895399094,
0.8952236175537109,
-0.4917796850204468,
0.2036825716495514,
0.007787832524627447,
0.2650216519832611,
-0.2992042303085327,
-0.5760425925254822,
0.468777596950531,
0.020658500492572784,
-0.4024451673030853,
0.21179796755313873,
1.082784652709961,
-0.5333146452903748,
-0.7885656356811523,
0.4834367036819458,
0.5082709193229675,
0.0037541675847023726,
-0.32249921560287476,
-0.32360517978668213,
0.7403563261032104,
-0.3288240432739258,
-0.373634934425354,
0.5168859958648682,
0.44448456168174744,
-0.26845020055770874,
0.30197685956954956,
0.6775732040405273,
-0.0876285508275032,
-0.15787085890769958,
0.35757535696029663,
0.9629490375518799,
-0.4078987240791321,
-0.8446124792098999,
-0.9291285872459412,
0.34216973185539246,
-0.2886459529399872,
0.08442997187376022,
0.4862512946128845,
0.5736769437789917,
0.48321157693862915,
0.11688565462827682,
0.7846342921257019,
0.0638551190495491,
0.42442935705184937,
-0.5805214643478394,
0.7248571515083313,
-0.5098790526390076,
0.048844803124666214,
-0.19123923778533936,
-0.8791007399559021,
-0.6566171646118164,
0.5370748043060303,
-0.35053661465644836,
-0.06472434848546982,
0.530683159828186,
0.6988714933395386,
-0.016260255128145218,
0.02038954757153988,
0.4116026759147644,
0.30511170625686646,
0.47676190733909607,
0.25339457392692566,
0.9276820421218872,
0.03200051933526993,
0.5463002920150757,
0.33473724126815796,
-0.3085927665233612,
-0.4484041929244995,
-1.1377958059310913,
-1.0313119888305664,
-0.5465470552444458,
-0.39744552969932556,
-0.09358998388051987,
0.16741538047790527,
0.7029784321784973,
0.6532512903213501,
-1.1428486108779907,
0.09257170557975769,
0.04919861629605293,
0.21918174624443054,
0.004462976939976215,
-0.287951797246933,
0.5621041655540466,
-0.48183324933052063,
-0.5574053525924683,
0.7003483772277832,
0.4606577157974243,
-0.12229909002780914,
-0.002442562486976385,
0.18856774270534515,
0.020137092098593712,
-0.26369115710258484,
0.851364254951477,
0.0700874850153923,
-0.556290864944458,
-0.4510681927204132,
-0.41113266348838806,
0.10972992330789566,
-0.08333108574151993,
0.6738253831863403,
-0.59833824634552,
-0.08085557818412781,
0.38512906432151794,
0.9215878844261169,
0.4518069922924042,
-0.141575425863266,
0.40495336055755615,
-0.9221808314323425,
0.49831342697143555,
0.028631683439016342,
0.4516677260398865,
0.2949261963367462,
-0.5718911290168762,
0.2093898355960846,
0.2445165365934372,
-0.5854557752609253,
-0.9136295914649963,
0.11149170994758606,
-0.872848391532898,
-0.1820889264345169,
1.251728892326355,
0.035198524594306946,
-0.19378803670406342,
-0.07960669696331024,
-0.028725842013955116,
0.10901961475610733,
-0.43757134675979614,
0.5748157501220703,
0.8582785725593567,
0.10299675911664963,
-0.35517898201942444,
-0.5013394951820374,
0.21330702304840088,
0.12989778816699982,
-0.8498572707176208,
-0.29717501997947693,
0.6908023357391357,
0.04136097431182861,
0.17947779595851898,
0.40651431679725647,
-0.1621502786874771,
0.37322819232940674,
-0.4174804985523224,
0.08947445452213287,
-0.004808790050446987,
-0.41450032591819763,
-0.5353302359580994,
0.2929646670818329,
-0.1527843028306961,
-0.09363140910863876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10549v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10549v1
|
Lightweight Audio Segmentation for Long-form Speech Translation
| 2024-06-15T08:02:15 | 2024-06-15T08:02:15 |
Jaesong Lee, Soyoon Kim, Hanbyul Kim, Joon Son Chung
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
Speech segmentation is an essential part of speech translation (ST) systems
in real-world scenarios. Since most ST models are designed to process speech
segments, long-form audio must be partitioned into shorter segments before
translation. Recently, data-driven approaches for the speech segmentation task
have been developed. Although the approaches improve overall translation
quality, a performance gap exists due to a mismatch between the models and ST
systems. In addition, the prior works require large self-supervised speech
models, which consume significant computational resources. In this work, we
propose a segmentation model that achieves better speech translation quality
with a small model size. We propose an ASR-with-punctuation task as an
effective pre-training strategy for the segmentation model. We also show that
proper integration of the speech segmentation model into the underlying ST
system is critical to improve overall translation quality at inference time.
|
[
-0.25924089550971985,
-0.5657172799110413,
0.5322575569152832,
0.4762241542339325,
-0.8461486101150513,
0.0460631437599659,
-0.3574901819229126,
-0.6131377220153809,
0.24655108153820038,
0.42772358655929565,
-0.5936952233314514,
-0.40238428115844727,
-0.5847525000572205,
0.22033636271953583,
-0.43319761753082275,
0.5361915230751038,
0.2332148253917694,
0.35927167534828186,
-0.2309868186712265,
-0.3695489764213562,
-0.6057629585266113,
-0.4430873394012451,
-0.7079363465309143,
-0.19499091804027557,
0.18840622901916504,
0.34337079524993896,
0.5240840315818787,
0.9519848823547363,
0.30732810497283936,
0.28305646777153015,
-0.42806264758110046,
0.023939700797200203,
0.09159679710865021,
0.10131613165140152,
0.03718850016593933,
-0.1999177187681198,
-0.38829413056373596,
-0.10682912915945053,
0.8200154900550842,
1.022064208984375,
-0.16406472027301788,
0.16491055488586426,
0.021860288456082344,
0.3541979193687439,
-0.36883336305618286,
-0.3093135356903076,
-0.16520366072654724,
-0.03972816839814186,
-0.4587321877479553,
-0.10114201158285141,
-0.2019658237695694,
-0.19735747575759888,
-0.05855025351047516,
-0.3013525903224945,
-0.021387524902820587,
0.2867317199707031,
0.5809581875801086,
0.6227986812591553,
-0.26668912172317505,
-0.30457577109336853,
-0.7727417945861816,
0.8272297978401184,
-0.9024598598480225,
0.8902971148490906,
0.24498124420642853,
0.0938306599855423,
0.025779498741030693,
-0.5228676795959473,
-0.5038193464279175,
-0.06262371689081192,
0.11150263249874115,
-0.07854870706796646,
-0.1445302516222,
0.09995867311954498,
0.17405052483081818,
0.33844271302223206,
-0.6970452666282654,
0.37018030881881714,
-0.5341914892196655,
-0.14111816883087158,
0.4782651364803314,
-0.10088135302066803,
0.3227834105491638,
-0.3245386481285095,
-0.45512932538986206,
0.08910645544528961,
-0.6009467244148254,
0.2087220847606659,
0.5667511224746704,
0.5780609846115112,
-0.18860557675361633,
0.3856502175331116,
-0.06872256100177765,
0.8741177916526794,
0.014418265782296658,
-0.42704376578330994,
0.34009385108947754,
-0.36424964666366577,
-0.14094386994838715,
0.5766115784645081,
1.0484925508499146,
0.022634107619524002,
-0.0013293884694576263,
0.09688567370176315,
-0.3428853750228882,
-0.01621224544942379,
0.041454561054706573,
-0.9710950255393982,
-0.15120308101177216,
0.021734172478318214,
-0.42255985736846924,
-0.04065144062042236,
-0.2094600647687912,
-0.47347137331962585,
0.2494601309299469,
-0.38035354018211365,
0.35348933935165405,
-0.5809482932090759,
0.14393673837184906,
0.25600019097328186,
-0.06512446701526642,
0.09757024049758911,
0.32093170285224915,
-0.7859704494476318,
0.4949914813041687,
0.2442239224910736,
1.0324676036834717,
-0.43643221259117126,
0.07297049462795258,
-1.019185185432434,
0.26864945888519287,
-0.1604650318622589,
0.8279539346694946,
-0.40643271803855896,
-0.7831498384475708,
-0.41689202189445496,
-0.15298455953598022,
-0.13637399673461914,
-0.5338596701622009,
0.8615570664405823,
-0.18006528913974762,
0.2741923928260803,
0.1088043674826622,
-0.5344862937927246,
0.022762814536690712,
-0.09284085780382156,
-0.4595269560813904,
0.84794682264328,
-0.19202455878257751,
-0.5362355709075928,
0.38753175735473633,
-0.7239150404930115,
-0.8760296702384949,
0.10235509276390076,
-0.07851477712392807,
-0.6006491184234619,
0.16143609583377838,
0.5713376402854919,
0.20803415775299072,
-0.26615041494369507,
0.06134358048439026,
-0.2754892110824585,
-0.35530948638916016,
0.1716071367263794,
-0.18071646988391876,
0.6597495079040527,
0.4772881865501404,
-0.13649742305278778,
0.2822518050670624,
-0.6942073702812195,
0.004517936147749424,
0.00441856449469924,
-0.28986725211143494,
-0.4753776490688324,
0.0334545373916626,
0.38949576020240784,
0.08120925724506378,
0.11674731224775314,
-0.6299205422401428,
-0.13398940861225128,
-0.5055047869682312,
0.5693677663803101,
0.43071669340133667,
-0.07532647997140884,
0.5806673169136047,
0.11127118021249771,
0.35191407799720764,
0.13476713001728058,
0.03728162497282028,
0.0035293304827064276,
-0.12781979143619537,
-0.7004959583282471,
-0.4944528043270111,
0.5598087906837463,
0.3793482482433319,
-0.5692386031150818,
0.6901377439498901,
-0.2956140339374542,
-0.33594998717308044,
-0.5235491394996643,
0.2116863876581192,
0.25770050287246704,
0.5273929834365845,
0.675843358039856,
-0.4161798059940338,
-0.48575589060783386,
-0.7095076441764832,
-0.13248169422149658,
0.031169865280389786,
-0.2020198553800583,
0.2469455748796463,
0.2897630035877228,
-0.2636103630065918,
0.9393214583396912,
-0.42064914107322693,
-0.4500814974308014,
-0.43642452359199524,
0.0352947898209095,
0.24390888214111328,
0.9540677666664124,
0.4054752588272095,
-0.750972330570221,
-0.15420344471931458,
-0.2544109523296356,
-0.30047205090522766,
-0.35247477889060974,
0.0002893638447858393,
0.2409021258354187,
-0.3198266923427582,
0.7484003901481628,
-0.5299016833305359,
0.20137082040309906,
0.45941048860549927,
-0.21686002612113953,
0.44763118028640747,
-0.05139286443591118,
0.08223406225442886,
-0.9904471635818481,
0.2314700335264206,
-0.07562131434679031,
-0.7412664890289307,
-0.6676980257034302,
-0.29013821482658386,
-0.004867664538323879,
-0.6317575573921204,
-0.7212766408920288,
0.3205678164958954,
-0.4861096441745758,
-0.3019968867301941,
-0.3808581233024597,
0.14672508835792542,
0.23325739800930023,
0.12685167789459229,
0.261412650346756,
1.0949071645736694,
0.31988075375556946,
-0.42553064227104187,
0.06105635687708855,
0.44033291935920715,
-0.43632397055625916,
0.4889117479324341,
-0.9682914614677429,
0.13185390830039978,
0.12991341948509216,
0.2936587929725647,
-0.6725208759307861,
-0.0785466879606247,
0.1827898621559143,
-0.254557728767395,
0.3132818937301636,
-0.3891083896160126,
-0.4579409062862396,
-0.17835518717765808,
0.026388388127088547,
0.8845415115356445,
0.4680001139640808,
-0.37876442074775696,
0.35896816849708557,
0.5007084012031555,
-0.6201777458190918,
-0.06419894099235535,
-0.5298589468002319,
0.012328119948506355,
-0.4090516269207001,
-0.832611083984375,
0.3323034942150116,
-0.040428441017866135,
-0.03173093497753143,
-0.32615214586257935,
-0.36422115564346313,
-0.1385471373796463,
-0.04021011292934418,
0.25401896238327026,
0.016521736979484558,
-0.38030651211738586,
-0.09659010916948318,
0.13506628572940826,
-0.14005370438098907,
-0.09543488174676895,
-0.35256049036979675,
0.531978964805603,
0.2034921944141388,
-0.368348628282547,
-0.6563479900360107,
0.6698901653289795,
0.33565399050712585,
-0.5600370168685913,
0.21528343856334686,
0.6354750990867615,
-0.12545758485794067,
-0.33702147006988525,
-0.6408576369285583,
-0.08281020820140839,
-0.44889673590660095,
0.08001583069562912,
-0.3569534420967102,
-1.0224440097808838,
0.19559799134731293,
-0.15024636685848236,
-0.5012317895889282,
0.325406014919281,
0.0019612684845924377,
-0.43867138028144836,
0.9979786276817322,
0.5755566358566284,
-0.09038412570953369,
0.7403731942176819,
0.019135668873786926,
0.12445076555013657,
-0.7361944913864136,
0.007085161283612251,
-0.6823937892913818,
-0.22649900615215302,
0.005595125257968903,
-0.7433305978775024,
0.23372706770896912,
0.15604545176029205,
0.2153555005788803,
0.42745935916900635,
-0.4837079644203186,
0.3512721061706543,
0.5275301337242126,
-0.1420906037092209,
0.18724599480628967,
-0.021839752793312073,
0.08599034696817398,
-0.05402563139796257,
-0.5762745141983032,
-0.2363768368959427,
0.40063363313674927,
0.5043448209762573,
0.9615413546562195,
-0.2327948361635208,
0.7906802296638489,
0.3652416169643402,
-0.31941336393356323,
-0.8711733222007751,
0.36085250973701477,
-0.29373183846473694,
-0.2619534134864807,
-0.490970641374588,
-0.6714274287223816,
-0.7108771800994873,
0.1986743062734604,
0.04830427095293999,
-0.5428139567375183,
0.35788747668266296,
0.013345698826014996,
-0.706093966960907,
-0.11740289628505707,
-0.5614365935325623,
1.116265058517456,
-0.29871100187301636,
0.14035508036613464,
-0.15168312191963196,
-0.8070772886276245,
0.0908755362033844,
0.030347736552357674,
0.44178950786590576,
-0.3904770612716675,
0.1749364286661148,
1.2746375799179077,
-0.669711172580719,
0.495627760887146,
-0.4182905852794647,
0.06357340514659882,
0.42230600118637085,
-0.1124659925699234,
0.518355131149292,
-0.0629483088850975,
0.25466933846473694,
0.2554640769958496,
0.18555602431297302,
-0.20783202350139618,
-0.41545647382736206,
0.2768248915672302,
-0.7200350165367126,
-0.4270138740539551,
-0.2716779410839081,
-0.26018622517585754,
-0.20652101933956146,
0.24435850977897644,
0.294710636138916,
0.5538727641105652,
-0.22356313467025757,
0.2828614115715027,
0.6826739311218262,
0.09324163943529129,
0.5593646764755249,
0.2323208600282669,
0.016600649803876877,
-0.6025142669677734,
0.7836066484451294,
0.12622103095054626,
0.11837790906429291,
0.11976887285709381,
0.1528264582157135,
-0.5872890949249268,
-1.0921612977981567,
-0.6734082102775574,
0.34439024329185486,
-0.45432278513908386,
-0.17634190618991852,
-0.6065964102745056,
0.013405704870820045,
-0.5964385867118835,
-0.20778201520442963,
-0.7605715990066528,
-0.38803017139434814,
-0.5410045385360718,
0.1483180671930313,
-0.04625630006194115,
0.3702899217605591,
0.027522573247551918,
0.8977075219154358,
-0.8328702449798584,
0.458744615316391,
0.24799548089504242,
0.13129118084907532,
-0.6001571416854858,
-0.8269630074501038,
-0.43504345417022705,
-0.213176429271698,
0.0129507165402174,
-0.7328065037727356,
0.46128660440444946,
0.2841475307941437,
0.2720135748386383,
0.36709073185920715,
-0.01603712886571884,
1.1629581451416016,
-0.7771050333976746,
0.6434915661811829,
0.5340756177902222,
-1.164246916770935,
0.662679135799408,
-0.23259975016117096,
0.5091471076011658,
0.8982109427452087,
-0.033535122871398926,
-0.5619327425956726,
-0.15640394389629364,
-0.3251939117908478,
-0.8862510323524475,
0.6044920682907104,
0.21597900986671448,
-0.268563449382782,
0.12514664232730865,
-0.19846326112747192,
0.11806468665599823,
0.13247151672840118,
-0.5198786854743958,
-0.003204797161743045,
-0.3003740906715393,
-0.06790230423212051,
-0.24409936368465424,
-0.2773076593875885,
-0.0067059858702123165,
-0.17940758168697357,
0.6518361568450928,
-0.059178464114665985,
-0.02936253882944584,
0.16549989581108093,
-0.5607383251190186,
-0.10396178066730499,
0.4368821084499359,
0.6339878439903259,
0.38115808367729187,
-0.15694303810596466,
0.168964222073555,
0.1854918897151947,
-0.3479868173599243,
0.4998326897621155,
0.4011129140853882,
-0.07409936189651489,
0.2664158344268799,
0.22338223457336426,
0.7892261147499084,
0.4896850287914276,
-0.5414186716079712,
0.906396746635437,
0.07028509676456451,
0.0339185856282711,
-0.43802759051322937,
-0.18219181895256042,
0.156053364276886,
0.14435933530330658,
0.29654935002326965,
0.24440553784370422,
0.37221068143844604,
-0.25084272027015686,
0.34104540944099426,
0.1712527573108673,
-0.4678010940551758,
-0.31259971857070923,
0.8211014270782471,
0.5248426198959351,
-0.3419440686702728,
0.4771144688129425,
-0.06008405610918999,
-0.30216869711875916,
0.2030719816684723,
0.5454342365264893,
0.7592533230781555,
-0.415183424949646,
-0.15606096386909485,
0.039625801146030426,
0.06476175040006638,
-0.09385121613740921,
0.17794698476791382,
-0.5172774195671082,
-0.20891401171684265,
-0.8457669615745544,
-1.1047725677490234,
-0.2778538763523102,
-0.12315614521503448,
-0.6370195746421814,
0.2597958743572235,
-0.35333165526390076,
-0.21472470462322235,
-0.1152421236038208,
-0.3261782228946686,
-0.6477827429771423,
0.6302828788757324,
0.49991267919540405,
0.8524829745292664,
-0.8898670673370361,
1.0346487760543823,
0.32199639081954956,
-0.23052547872066498,
-0.7825431823730469,
-0.26150497794151306,
-0.4470811188220978,
-0.3980257213115692,
0.5614624619483948,
0.29931631684303284,
-0.401231586933136,
-0.04439931362867355,
-0.3842388689517975,
-0.9227815866470337,
0.6499680876731873,
0.46481332182884216,
-0.659148633480072,
-0.2087646722793579,
0.24754896759986877,
0.17054180800914764,
-0.37453973293304443,
-0.2518603503704071,
0.4155215620994568,
0.29949289560317993,
0.22811628878116608,
-0.9712848663330078,
-0.06244085356593132,
-0.011064423248171806,
0.09826779365539551,
0.18918965756893158,
-0.4393092095851898,
0.5629541277885437,
0.14547206461429596,
-0.3349069058895111,
0.05727970600128174,
1.104668378829956,
0.11682852357625961,
0.2618863582611084,
1.0214236974716187,
0.6326560974121094,
0.4122883081436157,
0.0547216571867466,
0.467544823884964,
-0.09971784800291061,
0.04247582331299782,
1.3257943391799927,
-0.0984523668885231,
0.8604523539543152,
0.7917556166648865,
-0.16830120980739594,
0.30092936754226685,
0.5983717441558838,
0.06499400734901428,
0.5398285388946533,
0.07944843918085098,
-0.1354917585849762,
-0.6590085029602051,
-0.26605677604675293,
-0.5154923796653748,
0.7237668037414551,
0.21389028429985046,
-0.3695715367794037,
-0.08628933131694794,
0.2774004340171814,
-0.06806280463933945,
0.05307866632938385,
-0.2710683047771454,
0.9258249402046204,
0.327199786901474,
-0.27202385663986206,
0.248106449842453,
0.05375067517161369,
0.6617555022239685,
-0.6691591739654541,
0.28410768508911133,
-0.09379101544618607,
-0.2764222025871277,
-0.14414575695991516,
-0.3693740963935852,
0.3786768615245819,
0.08060330897569656,
-0.1849287897348404,
-0.45618027448654175,
0.6074088215827942,
-0.5732251405715942,
-0.5027022361755371,
0.188151016831398,
0.6700417399406433,
0.3765675723552704,
-0.329646497964859,
-0.5248072147369385,
0.4527629017829895,
-0.06192607060074806,
-0.16690276563167572,
0.23858855664730072,
0.28216275572776794,
0.02680160105228424,
0.5193410515785217,
0.8538417816162109,
0.3056977391242981,
0.14429372549057007,
0.1207590252161026,
0.7741230726242065,
-0.7390236854553223,
-1.213104009628296,
-0.816379725933075,
0.5006433129310608,
-0.18801423907279968,
-0.07283536344766617,
0.6552603840827942,
0.8471957445144653,
0.47034069895744324,
-0.030590802431106567,
0.4746675193309784,
0.16264240443706512,
0.6194261312484741,
-0.46021923422813416,
0.6596336364746094,
-0.5614944696426392,
-0.11874397844076157,
-0.3841949999332428,
-1.008330225944519,
-0.3544025123119354,
0.6228713393211365,
-0.4433823823928833,
-0.39005807042121887,
0.4857842028141022,
0.38862913846969604,
-0.32749152183532715,
-0.16476991772651672,
0.5548296570777893,
-0.23948480188846588,
0.39564576745033264,
0.08621644973754883,
0.8030385971069336,
-0.4145451784133911,
0.8189322352409363,
-0.1435304582118988,
0.17853552103042603,
-0.208139568567276,
-0.590398907661438,
-0.7154673933982849,
-0.4365370571613312,
-0.3193270266056061,
-0.03930537775158882,
0.04787260293960571,
1.0366626977920532,
1.0765749216079712,
-0.7671038508415222,
-0.33713117241859436,
0.37057116627693176,
-0.020116932690143585,
-0.09742221236228943,
-0.11329978704452515,
0.3447071611881256,
-0.3060729503631592,
-0.6605494022369385,
1.2917431592941284,
0.37852224707603455,
0.33078324794769287,
0.2105405330657959,
-0.09904554486274719,
0.003412766382098198,
-0.0014156019315123558,
0.41662871837615967,
0.3619188666343689,
-0.6085712909698486,
-0.5659619569778442,
-0.4431784152984619,
-0.020217720419168472,
0.4148714542388916,
0.9615024924278259,
-0.6073572039604187,
0.4226748049259186,
0.23062807321548462,
0.5702878832817078,
0.8989712595939636,
0.33272114396095276,
0.6276600360870361,
-0.9308554530143738,
0.4153013527393341,
0.5862802863121033,
0.5680422782897949,
0.6632246971130371,
-0.07904783636331558,
0.25952374935150146,
0.4075782895088196,
-0.5502948760986328,
-0.9050024747848511,
0.08240623772144318,
-1.3185003995895386,
-0.12340489029884338,
0.9683372974395752,
-0.03419072553515434,
-0.4172101616859436,
-0.0334915928542614,
-0.18218299746513367,
0.34624066948890686,
-0.6456644535064697,
0.14846163988113403,
0.2578252851963043,
-0.10296568274497986,
-0.21280576288700104,
-0.27323785424232483,
0.5957457423210144,
0.34806957840919495,
-0.6259587407112122,
-0.05582880973815918,
0.5837976932525635,
0.38926854729652405,
0.207571879029274,
0.6929829120635986,
0.05414615571498871,
0.2479368895292282,
0.1305161863565445,
0.1484590619802475,
-0.20359399914741516,
-0.21248593926429749,
-0.3260740041732788,
0.4218718707561493,
0.1515297144651413,
-0.5750126242637634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10522v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10522v1
|
Humor in AI: Massive Scale Crowd-Sourced Preferences and Benchmarks for Cartoon Captioning
| 2024-06-15T06:26:25 | 2024-06-15T06:26:25 |
Jifan Zhang, Lalit Jain, Yang Guo, Jiayi Chen, Kuan Lok Zhou, Siddharth Suresh, Andrew Wagenmaker, Scott Sievert, Timothy Rogers, Kevin Jamieson, Robert Mankoff, Robert Nowak
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We present a novel multimodal preference dataset for creative tasks,
consisting of over 250 million human ratings on more than 2.2 million captions,
collected through crowdsourcing rating data for The New Yorker's weekly cartoon
caption contest over the past eight years. This unique dataset supports the
development and evaluation of multimodal large language models and
preference-based fine-tuning algorithms for humorous caption generation. We
propose novel benchmarks for judging the quality of model-generated captions,
utilizing both GPT4 and human judgments to establish ranking-based evaluation
strategies. Our experimental results highlight the limitations of current
fine-tuning methods, such as RLHF and DPO, when applied to creative tasks.
Furthermore, we demonstrate that even state-of-the-art models like GPT4 and
Claude currently underperform top human contestants in generating humorous
captions. As we conclude this extensive data collection effort, we release the
entire preference dataset to the research community, fostering further
advancements in AI humor generation and evaluation.
|
[
-0.5641023516654968,
-0.38661980628967285,
0.25543010234832764,
0.6119813919067383,
-0.3888075351715088,
-0.014146147295832634,
-0.32174649834632874,
-0.1934557855129242,
0.27318206429481506,
0.2603318989276886,
-0.35396263003349304,
-0.06756893545389175,
-0.5408722162246704,
0.35875606536865234,
-0.09894312173128128,
1.196123719215393,
0.4372325837612152,
0.10374769568443298,
-0.6076012253761292,
-0.21611815690994263,
-0.23734140396118164,
-0.38328632712364197,
-0.6912938356399536,
0.09383687376976013,
1.0178420543670654,
0.700616180896759,
0.9977584481239319,
0.48291343450546265,
0.7014766335487366,
0.3096062242984772,
0.40825268626213074,
0.15162184834480286,
-0.4291136562824249,
-0.14606226980686188,
-0.22269463539123535,
-0.4123903512954712,
-0.20529070496559143,
0.294402152299881,
0.3467928171157837,
0.4876730740070343,
-0.1291223019361496,
0.14717432856559753,
-0.5417327880859375,
0.812411904335022,
-0.3233712613582611,
0.2869367003440857,
-0.6241676807403564,
0.1542513072490692,
-0.21507231891155243,
-0.294628381729126,
-0.25491902232170105,
-0.5674504637718201,
0.09082528948783875,
-0.6439380645751953,
0.27256280183792114,
0.34973546862602234,
0.711469829082489,
0.5494526028633118,
-0.23854519426822662,
-0.07978914678096771,
-0.3260756731033325,
0.7640411257743835,
-0.6894887089729309,
-0.03982192650437355,
0.021763164550065994,
0.5683779716491699,
0.10304851084947586,
-0.780390202999115,
-0.9143245816230774,
-0.5624785423278809,
0.4427270293235779,
0.022154876962304115,
-0.44445931911468506,
-0.10552212595939636,
0.4281957447528839,
0.40706148743629456,
-0.5885875225067139,
0.025794753804802895,
-0.2935875952243805,
0.03843705356121063,
0.8802520632743835,
0.12473747134208679,
0.448853075504303,
-0.37914562225341797,
-0.21515202522277832,
-0.3999118208885193,
-0.5856971144676208,
0.01603868417441845,
0.8648341298103333,
-0.012462482787668705,
0.026437167078256607,
0.7321324944496155,
-0.33155131340026855,
0.2593475878238678,
-0.0996633768081665,
0.2392052263021469,
0.3937164545059204,
-0.043869808316230774,
-0.14393523335456848,
-0.3351620137691498,
1.0859367847442627,
0.7873892784118652,
0.8259289860725403,
-0.2386426031589508,
-0.16492336988449097,
-0.08252260088920593,
0.3915213644504547,
-0.4553203284740448,
-0.5720122456550598,
-0.11192971467971802,
-0.32910123467445374,
-0.5695986747741699,
0.17079707980155945,
-0.8206773996353149,
-0.8528478145599365,
-0.36283984780311584,
0.3776513934135437,
-0.26320570707321167,
-0.06794966757297516,
0.11626573652029037,
-0.5736682415008545,
-0.25718000531196594,
0.4843544065952301,
-0.6052749752998352,
-0.23898859322071075,
0.42953914403915405,
0.5950483679771423,
-0.14460520446300507,
-0.3699728846549988,
-0.722670316696167,
-0.03418770059943199,
-0.19258882105350494,
1.0691051483154297,
-0.6221830248832703,
0.08274181187152863,
-0.36308661103248596,
-0.2216625064611435,
0.038199085742235184,
-0.7733540534973145,
0.5434664487838745,
-0.2127804011106491,
0.10319700092077255,
-0.17929279804229736,
-0.29389384388923645,
-0.008344871923327446,
0.11636944860219955,
-0.9859179854393005,
0.5885307788848877,
0.1970660388469696,
-0.7752520442008972,
0.4465070962905884,
-0.9592773914337158,
-0.5784755349159241,
0.16686932742595673,
-0.09789653867483139,
-0.2699418067932129,
0.28222933411598206,
0.5568097233772278,
0.3471730053424835,
-0.2663022577762604,
0.5099618434906006,
-0.5217399001121521,
-0.23001563549041748,
0.4613468647003174,
-0.6936551332473755,
0.5779916644096375,
0.4268212914466858,
-0.4214942455291748,
0.28739067912101746,
-0.40588581562042236,
-0.18207263946533203,
0.3930279314517975,
-0.12792184948921204,
-0.00020690639212261885,
0.08390603214502335,
0.1905374825000763,
0.2712772786617279,
0.24493111670017242,
-0.5279072523117065,
0.1619551181793213,
-0.30055880546569824,
0.9050745368003845,
0.800396203994751,
-0.16159984469413757,
0.025986475870013237,
-0.4348764419555664,
0.538888692855835,
0.0033996528945863247,
0.3636353313922882,
-0.1230325773358345,
-0.7030557990074158,
-0.6807565093040466,
-0.06378229707479477,
-0.011091457679867744,
0.3023024797439575,
-0.8976970911026001,
0.31612417101860046,
-0.4357130527496338,
-0.5805565714836121,
-0.47986075282096863,
0.04557960480451584,
0.1775834858417511,
0.25437599420547485,
0.1523560732603073,
-0.4112982153892517,
-0.14990198612213135,
-1.2812604904174805,
-0.23023653030395508,
-0.12754683196544647,
-0.12585514783859253,
0.8365494012832642,
0.14636541903018951,
0.12987475097179413,
0.6402936577796936,
-0.4542903006076813,
-0.046365611255168915,
-0.4157077372074127,
0.5012144446372986,
0.17924650013446808,
0.34138593077659607,
0.9016302824020386,
-0.8572728633880615,
-0.4122767746448517,
-0.3004021644592285,
-0.5272530913352966,
0.06388483196496964,
0.014552799984812737,
0.0007526276167482138,
0.002545861294493079,
0.2538321912288666,
-0.70393306016922,
0.1647697538137436,
0.4026137590408325,
-0.09431421756744385,
0.7311839461326599,
-0.019435521215200424,
0.464641273021698,
-0.7263282537460327,
0.21357209980487823,
0.03530702367424965,
-0.1285616010427475,
-0.10726552456617355,
0.10147731006145477,
-0.1903245896100998,
-0.4296197295188904,
-0.5597274899482727,
0.6524693369865417,
-0.1182512417435646,
-0.11091163009405136,
-0.011514413170516491,
0.09669682383537292,
-0.0712255984544754,
0.5406956076622009,
-0.14107385277748108,
0.6980313658714294,
0.5289665460586548,
-0.01296413503587246,
0.9715225696563721,
0.14643912017345428,
-0.41428709030151367,
0.6044861674308777,
-0.7770971059799194,
0.3880705237388611,
-0.23670610785484314,
0.32510676980018616,
-1.4004651308059692,
-0.5689964890480042,
0.17254789173603058,
-0.5950383543968201,
0.09625333547592163,
0.053298212587833405,
-0.8521069288253784,
-0.6220786571502686,
-0.4198555052280426,
0.4661872088909149,
0.24805723130702972,
-0.4650101959705353,
0.12643098831176758,
0.3241148591041565,
-0.5674200057983398,
-0.5998530983924866,
-0.3618392050266266,
0.5343920588493347,
-0.4008854627609253,
-0.6321464776992798,
-0.13614100217819214,
-0.4712272584438324,
-0.07272851467132568,
-0.10434974730014801,
0.10750094056129456,
0.035506121814250946,
-0.23399408161640167,
0.3009306490421295,
-0.13550134003162384,
-0.20063228905200958,
-0.09697804600000381,
-0.02443220466375351,
0.0953301191329956,
0.051695816218853,
0.1055246964097023,
0.471305787563324,
-0.08588854968547821,
-0.376563161611557,
-0.3842364251613617,
0.2629396319389343,
0.669481635093689,
-0.1636042445898056,
0.08175107091665268,
0.737746000289917,
-0.02655457705259323,
-0.006975846365094185,
-0.6467379331588745,
-0.10458721220493317,
-0.46098512411117554,
0.37370261549949646,
0.0039853439666330814,
-0.697419285774231,
0.1745021641254425,
0.0852474644780159,
0.022732365876436234,
0.5203341245651245,
0.3289214074611664,
-0.21432781219482422,
1.3111649751663208,
0.3214244544506073,
-0.5702505707740784,
0.5220276713371277,
0.08363714814186096,
0.14134617149829865,
-0.34113386273384094,
0.11394459009170532,
-0.5542594790458679,
-0.8478069305419922,
-0.44409042596817017,
-0.278548926115036,
0.47254979610443115,
-0.27557557821273804,
-0.30318838357925415,
0.08711138367652893,
-0.35388243198394775,
0.6710472702980042,
0.7841854691505432,
0.008537673391401768,
0.13414426147937775,
0.3053264915943146,
0.06142492964863777,
-0.06154966726899147,
-0.5774362683296204,
-0.25510770082473755,
1.1659642457962036,
0.2525680959224701,
0.774695634841919,
0.15196654200553894,
0.33413100242614746,
0.65703284740448,
0.5246054530143738,
-0.5825516581535339,
0.5732141733169556,
-0.5892626047134399,
-0.6048992872238159,
-0.5070632100105286,
-0.5708523988723755,
-0.7502151131629944,
-0.3796011209487915,
-0.055040448904037476,
-0.5806192755699158,
-0.24761039018630981,
0.13856907188892365,
-0.3094744086265564,
0.21805687248706818,
-0.7205280661582947,
0.8490574955940247,
-0.21767546236515045,
-0.2465699464082718,
-0.39688801765441895,
-0.9442948698997498,
0.3150598108768463,
0.3778739273548126,
0.056268274784088135,
-0.29406988620758057,
0.2313435673713684,
0.6335408091545105,
0.06886196881532669,
0.746644914150238,
-0.3445047438144684,
0.1390792429447174,
0.18336136639118195,
-0.021742016077041626,
0.33680275082588196,
0.44558873772621155,
-0.1643127202987671,
0.34308555722236633,
-0.38966426253318787,
-0.24567823112010956,
-0.6405632495880127,
0.7999393343925476,
-0.8942614197731018,
-0.5578871965408325,
-0.15996153652668,
-0.8348073959350586,
-0.11857090890407562,
0.14311370253562927,
0.24650590121746063,
0.602857768535614,
0.1215607225894928,
0.48688584566116333,
0.25398457050323486,
-0.6331900358200073,
0.4827136993408203,
0.12566648423671722,
0.2700497508049011,
-0.8047987818717957,
1.2897838354110718,
-0.3154984712600708,
-0.0018993838457390666,
0.4102290868759155,
0.17396505177021027,
-0.5566756725311279,
-0.41452038288116455,
-0.8558667898178101,
0.27661144733428955,
-0.6911746859550476,
-0.27753230929374695,
-0.5505650639533997,
-0.10367554426193237,
-0.4154738783836365,
-0.09439807385206223,
-0.2946418225765228,
-0.6847934126853943,
-0.14378038048744202,
0.18190115690231323,
0.20372594892978668,
0.8583824634552002,
0.11912424117326736,
0.014173248782753944,
-0.535311758518219,
0.37756648659706116,
0.4139244258403778,
0.5153374075889587,
-0.06593742221593857,
-0.33478856086730957,
-0.04583071172237396,
-0.16756702959537506,
-0.6141091585159302,
-0.5036444664001465,
0.35163944959640503,
0.31229403614997864,
0.6045936942100525,
0.6521539688110352,
0.007180588785558939,
0.42777010798454285,
-0.513187050819397,
1.0653066635131836,
0.1675925850868225,
-0.5639652609825134,
0.42127424478530884,
-0.6419947147369385,
0.0333060696721077,
0.36565104126930237,
0.3139423727989197,
-0.45189571380615234,
-0.4921908676624298,
-0.744952380657196,
-0.6749638915061951,
0.6730771660804749,
0.22153151035308838,
0.6151052117347717,
-0.25109177827835083,
0.240056574344635,
0.28986266255378723,
0.7144112586975098,
-0.6197753548622131,
-0.26598167419433594,
-0.5337843894958496,
-0.29296305775642395,
-0.43712422251701355,
0.13225728273391724,
-0.267765611410141,
-0.3383242189884186,
0.16539877653121948,
-0.3208637237548828,
0.4134156107902527,
-0.24014711380004883,
0.10340633243322372,
-0.24216999113559723,
0.09715860337018967,
0.9430451393127441,
0.6925428509712219,
-0.2553795874118805,
0.13315239548683167,
-0.2565745711326599,
-0.3956013023853302,
-0.16432641446590424,
0.3165605664253235,
0.20391559600830078,
-0.030727161094546318,
0.2336326241493225,
0.8238797783851624,
0.1656828075647354,
-1.0637255907058716,
0.5868935585021973,
-0.09900522977113724,
-0.1854088455438614,
-0.21329204738140106,
0.22258953750133514,
-0.005562689621001482,
0.19724202156066895,
0.4036419689655304,
0.388810396194458,
0.4178575575351715,
-0.4217751920223236,
0.2863052487373352,
0.49106550216674805,
-0.19932584464550018,
-0.4042026400566101,
0.8581705093383789,
0.2500486969947815,
-0.01168039906769991,
0.6807243824005127,
-0.2920770049095154,
-0.188282772898674,
0.9481945633888245,
0.21316936612129211,
0.9797324538230896,
0.09309942275285721,
0.4373161792755127,
0.45368269085884094,
0.18785274028778076,
0.08488117903470993,
0.1942012906074524,
0.023934733122587204,
-0.48835432529449463,
-0.14588189125061035,
-0.5476757287979126,
-0.5311641097068787,
0.39908367395401,
-0.33464834094047546,
0.37809494137763977,
-0.5097739696502686,
-0.029469652101397514,
0.34475937485694885,
-0.2276645451784134,
-0.7842811942100525,
0.2689783275127411,
0.2421087920665741,
0.7468520998954773,
-0.6955216526985168,
0.49411138892173767,
1.069806694984436,
-0.6447073221206665,
-0.6627283692359924,
-0.012303436174988747,
-0.06297235190868378,
-0.81097412109375,
0.5327115654945374,
0.20680688321590424,
0.3267957866191864,
0.1492237150669098,
-1.0651087760925293,
-0.6640757918357849,
0.7565909028053284,
0.536037802696228,
-0.42531949281692505,
0.022834695875644684,
0.29921749234199524,
0.4930471181869507,
-0.4787239134311676,
0.4644407629966736,
0.28521931171417236,
0.6210414171218872,
0.14215998351573944,
-0.8684064149856567,
-0.16766847670078278,
-0.5311522483825684,
-0.1733366847038269,
-0.15211917459964752,
-0.8780524134635925,
0.9541122317314148,
-0.5576833486557007,
0.0009067989885807037,
0.19227099418640137,
0.45959576964378357,
0.3362914025783539,
0.7008981108665466,
0.7454378604888916,
0.6311041712760925,
0.25123921036720276,
-0.11680170148611069,
1.1099718809127808,
-0.12145043909549713,
0.17206208407878876,
0.961482048034668,
-0.10994939506053925,
0.6264235973358154,
0.3999233543872833,
-0.1666775792837143,
0.2387159913778305,
0.5854711532592773,
-0.32379505038261414,
0.4634813666343689,
0.4620688855648041,
0.09679123014211655,
-0.2241261601448059,
-0.23612715303897858,
-0.20086194574832916,
0.23973718285560608,
-0.06726023554801941,
-0.27498388290405273,
-0.23366905748844147,
0.10779225826263428,
-0.19229668378829956,
-0.057683832943439484,
-0.028710592538118362,
0.7901752591133118,
-0.11163286864757538,
-0.7529095411300659,
0.2959666848182678,
-0.18967515230178833,
0.5084753632545471,
-0.14488264918327332,
-0.18468089401721954,
-0.5054623484611511,
-0.17558759450912476,
-0.006286568008363247,
-1.066199779510498,
-0.14033226668834686,
0.0014522188575938344,
-0.17470650374889374,
0.2795475125312805,
0.25799989700317383,
-0.1732814908027649,
-0.38623592257499695,
-0.2507982552051544,
0.1404484212398529,
0.44889092445373535,
-0.4434836208820343,
-0.8418335914611816,
-0.0744745284318924,
-0.09516698122024536,
-0.36898085474967957,
0.18072985112667084,
0.7284717559814453,
-0.17198984324932098,
0.7429447174072266,
0.6747013926506042,
-0.022093065083026886,
-0.0009533315314911306,
0.6348512172698975,
0.9881797432899475,
-0.7189651727676392,
-0.4725358486175537,
-0.556606113910675,
0.5583089590072632,
-0.25033578276634216,
-0.5055450797080994,
0.5470660328865051,
0.5664827227592468,
0.5774610042572021,
-0.6061161160469055,
1.058391809463501,
-0.33366480469703674,
0.1577293425798416,
-0.22921112179756165,
0.71260005235672,
-0.8514657616615295,
-0.0632285475730896,
-0.5990133881568909,
-1.1006029844284058,
-0.29101499915122986,
0.15143442153930664,
-0.14787276089191437,
0.3447883129119873,
0.4150725305080414,
0.6605574488639832,
-0.13747575879096985,
-0.06860999017953873,
0.4004661738872528,
-0.08061370253562927,
0.4608936607837677,
0.5871106386184692,
1.1136921644210815,
0.03677447512745857,
0.6259625554084778,
-0.35090020298957825,
-0.2052488625049591,
-0.42439302802085876,
-1.0890530347824097,
-0.9622378349304199,
-0.5045539736747742,
-0.3547089397907257,
0.10980870574712753,
-0.24433085322380066,
0.907905101776123,
0.614593505859375,
-0.8045607805252075,
0.1290913224220276,
0.09240645170211792,
-0.017961295321583748,
-0.35152995586395264,
-0.3108346164226532,
0.19572526216506958,
-0.3791443705558777,
-0.9985429048538208,
0.3173193335533142,
0.4173695743083954,
-0.28740474581718445,
-0.3505710959434509,
-0.07202274352312088,
0.2460126131772995,
0.1539713442325592,
0.560798168182373,
0.18064601719379425,
-0.8626313805580139,
-0.425493061542511,
0.04471835494041443,
0.011168534867465496,
0.11915776133537292,
0.7569100856781006,
-0.29475948214530945,
0.5960505604743958,
0.618564248085022,
0.4195975363254547,
0.008082445710897446,
0.23581086099147797,
0.406564861536026,
-0.8662124276161194,
0.10103160887956619,
0.189357727766037,
0.15616177022457123,
0.5317168235778809,
-0.35008758306503296,
0.5244543552398682,
0.5298798084259033,
-0.7337867021560669,
-0.7898778915405273,
-0.051834605634212494,
-1.1857104301452637,
0.04051815718412399,
1.0599786043167114,
-0.13304637372493744,
0.0730748251080513,
0.1537202000617981,
-0.45822209119796753,
0.004806102253496647,
-0.7463709712028503,
1.1167877912521362,
0.6884846091270447,
-0.2627633810043335,
-0.389005184173584,
-0.7027650475502014,
0.5543807148933411,
0.33204084634780884,
-0.8608817458152771,
0.03494236618280411,
0.7093665599822998,
0.4070131778717041,
0.30015432834625244,
0.28005847334861755,
-0.13134942948818207,
0.6024190783500671,
-0.09651745855808258,
0.2817268669605255,
-0.35960423946380615,
-0.572878360748291,
-0.12920549511909485,
0.21964003145694733,
0.12559984624385834,
0.14655564725399017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10515v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10515v1
|
Reactor Mk.1 performances: MMLU, HumanEval and BBH test results
| 2024-06-15T05:52:32 | 2024-06-15T05:52:32 |
TJ Dunham, Henry Syahputra
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The paper presents the performance results of Reactor Mk.1, ARCs flagship
large language model, through a benchmarking process analysis. The model
utilizes the Lychee AI engine and possesses less than 100 billion parameters,
resulting in a combination of efficiency and potency. The Reactor Mk.1
outperformed models such as GPT-4o, Claude Opus, and Llama 3, with achieved
scores of 92% on the MMLU dataset, 91% on HumanEval dataset, and 88% on BBH
dataset. It excels in both managing difficult jobs and reasoning, establishing
as a prominent AI solution in the present cutting-edge AI technology.
|
[
-0.5418263673782349,
-0.7867760062217712,
0.8262642621994019,
-0.007701435126364231,
-0.1364235281944275,
0.1713663935661316,
0.013602650724351406,
-0.372149258852005,
-0.057728756219148636,
0.540442168712616,
-0.5659990310668945,
-0.2532346248626709,
-0.6400144696235657,
0.34213265776634216,
-0.2367510348558426,
0.7195642590522766,
0.1699565351009369,
0.14224505424499512,
-0.023220278322696686,
-0.08035839349031448,
-0.10484104603528976,
-0.4386187791824341,
-0.9027811884880066,
-0.6107185482978821,
0.8067994713783264,
0.6757578253746033,
0.9594258666038513,
0.5879960656166077,
0.8221983909606934,
0.3450551927089691,
0.15130028128623962,
-0.4165589511394501,
-0.5307216048240662,
0.09235049039125443,
-0.20794370770454407,
-0.17676153779029846,
-0.6317732334136963,
0.13131804764270782,
0.8207702040672302,
0.33867430686950684,
0.05336209386587143,
0.3851940929889679,
-0.21418696641921997,
0.7111283540725708,
-0.26554733514785767,
0.3851356506347656,
-0.55165696144104,
-0.006013182923197746,
-0.2409873902797699,
0.21303606033325195,
-0.7944371104240417,
-0.5869832038879395,
-0.19137337803840637,
-0.3623122274875641,
-0.36300167441368103,
0.21814954280853271,
0.8585211038589478,
0.5386829972267151,
-0.3068850040435791,
0.07052288949489594,
-0.7396239042282104,
0.8826323747634888,
-1.1171345710754395,
0.40618667006492615,
0.3628351092338562,
0.6334428787231445,
-0.13968612253665924,
-1.148545265197754,
-0.528429388999939,
-0.38773539662361145,
-0.019201168790459633,
-0.06630180776119232,
-0.3851320147514343,
0.47917884588241577,
0.4906829595565796,
0.4959661066532135,
-0.7431758046150208,
0.7818577289581299,
-0.6318573355674744,
-0.2739012837409973,
0.5838264226913452,
0.49882546067237854,
-0.1562124788761139,
-0.24978578090667725,
0.04887102544307709,
-0.32067176699638367,
-0.34338894486427307,
0.05023448169231415,
0.4166345000267029,
0.3477991223335266,
0.30180060863494873,
0.821649968624115,
-0.7245084047317505,
0.3804616630077362,
-0.37174278497695923,
-0.26436394453048706,
0.08929014205932617,
-0.008784208446741104,
-0.5707695484161377,
-0.049972884356975555,
1.0380423069000244,
0.09280969947576523,
0.32522937655448914,
-0.07324063032865524,
0.1188337504863739,
0.4646449387073517,
0.35575562715530396,
-1.2900099754333496,
-0.2864275276660919,
0.3739835023880005,
-0.21740448474884033,
-0.4825681746006012,
-0.3599138557910919,
-0.7999922633171082,
-0.33346793055534363,
-0.1189873144030571,
0.4200173318386078,
-0.31227147579193115,
-0.38745805621147156,
-0.17195385694503784,
0.06818392127752304,
0.3073554039001465,
-0.03460974991321564,
-0.7073614001274109,
0.3825354278087616,
0.8747632503509521,
0.8013495802879333,
-0.13201043009757996,
-0.4187058210372925,
-0.35773196816444397,
-0.452553391456604,
-0.11552049964666367,
0.7333581447601318,
-0.5211877822875977,
-0.054197199642658234,
-0.5576993823051453,
-0.08861333876848221,
0.18744604289531708,
-0.5039805769920349,
0.5411252975463867,
-0.2498806267976761,
0.0069355713203549385,
-0.32033899426460266,
-0.6037121415138245,
-0.17650051414966583,
0.08692703396081924,
-0.9240795373916626,
1.0031765699386597,
0.4885154068470001,
-0.7582072615623474,
0.472300261259079,
-0.6440456509590149,
-0.10459946095943451,
-0.055099476128816605,
-0.02184031903743744,
-0.6416990756988525,
-0.05374126136302948,
-0.08674749732017517,
0.5298037528991699,
-0.5144105553627014,
0.31929725408554077,
-0.3655921220779419,
-0.4526482820510864,
0.21606168150901794,
-0.6083329916000366,
0.6609679460525513,
0.32448017597198486,
-0.3385867178440094,
0.44380348920822144,
-0.7812707424163818,
0.296968013048172,
0.0009079828741960227,
-0.33909907937049866,
0.1730983704328537,
-0.09680550545454025,
-0.03073163516819477,
0.4587406814098358,
-0.20378483831882477,
-0.5491383075714111,
0.4955485165119171,
-0.11781816929578781,
0.44478827714920044,
0.9700684547424316,
-0.010297092609107494,
0.29015052318573,
-0.24306850135326385,
0.6089611649513245,
-0.32477864623069763,
0.3958182632923126,
-0.06060926243662834,
-0.8610173463821411,
-0.7492222785949707,
-0.5453097820281982,
0.37356263399124146,
0.5719380378723145,
-0.5129446387290955,
0.13461834192276,
-0.1366920918226242,
-0.8153479099273682,
-0.9607955813407898,
-0.12606224417686462,
0.3089820146560669,
0.4640336334705353,
0.09849867224693298,
-0.15327459573745728,
-0.6894434690475464,
-1.3764519691467285,
0.1306786686182022,
-0.501608669757843,
0.036915503442287445,
0.23500686883926392,
0.5461324453353882,
-0.39177101850509644,
0.7812883853912354,
-0.27874982357025146,
0.39841917157173157,
-0.29695412516593933,
0.31506988406181335,
0.44182685017585754,
0.32499930262565613,
0.1513049304485321,
-0.4447464644908905,
-0.4037960469722748,
0.2107929140329361,
-1.1082628965377808,
-0.06422644853591919,
0.2500917315483093,
-0.24093684554100037,
0.19804388284683228,
0.39783087372779846,
-0.6654930710792542,
0.27354761958122253,
0.6600818634033203,
-0.2901039123535156,
0.8801082968711853,
0.23202908039093018,
0.4369277358055115,
-1.107116460800171,
0.3298629820346832,
-0.31733831763267517,
-0.29883766174316406,
-0.5813357830047607,
0.4886418282985687,
-0.22253762185573578,
-0.45165127515792847,
-0.6714119911193848,
0.4702564775943756,
-0.12153980880975723,
-0.2290906012058258,
-0.2549043893814087,
-0.17402148246765137,
-0.21243341267108917,
0.7100191116333008,
-0.19173848628997803,
0.9461591839790344,
0.6350075602531433,
-0.4936525821685791,
0.6594459414482117,
-0.10264091193675995,
-0.4451102912425995,
0.12041673809289932,
-0.7271473407745361,
0.2710540294647217,
0.03465260937809944,
-0.00560900429263711,
-0.920802891254425,
-0.3425940275192261,
0.0887015089392662,
-0.3719649612903595,
0.09223074465990067,
0.26005712151527405,
-0.5600231289863586,
-0.6707713603973389,
-0.22885654866695404,
0.23036038875579834,
0.7651716470718384,
0.03351409733295441,
0.5090158581733704,
0.16651572287082672,
-0.38725629448890686,
-0.6160160899162292,
-0.5709466338157654,
-0.07314979285001755,
-0.3520500659942627,
-0.49682652950286865,
-0.3487188220024109,
-0.11709053814411163,
-0.5998734831809998,
-0.16318641602993011,
0.09315992146730423,
-0.2050633579492569,
0.2577382028102875,
0.470069944858551,
0.144631028175354,
-0.4702693521976471,
-0.2337845265865326,
0.15171465277671814,
-0.4697875380516052,
0.17783699929714203,
0.3542499542236328,
0.8413891792297363,
-0.215053528547287,
-0.2482471913099289,
-0.6571046710014343,
0.20115670561790466,
1.2729711532592773,
0.09558899700641632,
0.9775245189666748,
0.4322252571582794,
-0.31447532773017883,
0.26819661259651184,
-0.4163602590560913,
-0.36439773440361023,
-0.5249980092048645,
0.5626675486564636,
-0.3965007960796356,
-0.7930489778518677,
0.6937106251716614,
-0.40410473942756653,
0.0718291699886322,
0.5461544394493103,
0.40112507343292236,
0.08841569721698761,
0.9912508130073547,
0.4592835307121277,
-0.659069836139679,
-0.0006630950374528766,
-0.39829713106155396,
0.2735726833343506,
-0.6953422427177429,
-0.10665449500083923,
-0.6139147281646729,
-0.37641099095344543,
-0.7334704399108887,
-0.29167798161506653,
0.3454425632953644,
0.1625964492559433,
-0.682015597820282,
0.4728394150733948,
-0.3779951333999634,
0.3386640250682831,
0.5972210168838501,
0.1027459129691124,
0.5860632061958313,
-0.2781653106212616,
-0.16924630105495453,
-0.23005861043930054,
-0.6021443605422974,
-0.6596283912658691,
1.0061275959014893,
0.681511402130127,
0.7334858775138855,
0.08256639540195465,
0.35696107149124146,
0.33978769183158875,
0.5110227465629578,
-0.7879111766815186,
0.7790254950523376,
0.2448490858078003,
-0.7439450621604919,
-0.7766014337539673,
-0.4994162321090698,
-0.7165382504463196,
0.2365281879901886,
-0.24023203551769257,
-0.7034560441970825,
-0.30925998091697693,
-0.17783714830875397,
0.04406186565756798,
0.5167825818061829,
-0.5502117276191711,
0.9985594749450684,
-0.052614111453294754,
-0.3613913953304291,
-0.40908393263816833,
-0.3084103465080261,
0.4566028118133545,
-0.3751206696033478,
0.006437549367547035,
-0.395141065120697,
0.363730788230896,
0.3446265459060669,
-0.19649985432624817,
0.36864668130874634,
-0.03434758633375168,
0.23039215803146362,
0.16080817580223083,
0.09716369211673737,
0.6006147861480713,
0.0899207666516304,
-0.8769218921661377,
0.18639056384563446,
-0.6521350741386414,
-0.46634653210639954,
-0.371359646320343,
0.748310387134552,
-0.6269723773002625,
-0.44243815541267395,
-0.45687949657440186,
-0.45579734444618225,
-0.047027576714754105,
0.45626163482666016,
0.427632212638855,
0.3428041934967041,
-0.3961177170276642,
0.29332253336906433,
0.5678808689117432,
-0.388816773891449,
0.5656234622001648,
0.3934640884399414,
-0.5808254480361938,
-0.3288257420063019,
0.5192064046859741,
-0.008340416476130486,
0.49202269315719604,
0.0490073561668396,
0.12971054017543793,
-0.0022851245012134314,
-0.40213507413864136,
-0.83919358253479,
0.15534447133541107,
-0.5759135484695435,
-0.4178018569946289,
-0.6912757754325867,
-0.47271034121513367,
-0.20552067458629608,
-0.22330814599990845,
-0.7409383058547974,
-0.21921361982822418,
0.08026208728551865,
-0.34136319160461426,
0.39673832058906555,
1.041945457458496,
0.3296207785606384,
0.1819434016942978,
-0.363301157951355,
0.278931200504303,
0.380695641040802,
0.6621836423873901,
0.02707442082464695,
-0.3165218234062195,
-0.2595265805721283,
-0.0224626325070858,
-0.3153463900089264,
-0.7867170572280884,
0.10007818043231964,
0.12247154116630554,
0.7410887479782104,
0.38477298617362976,
-0.003250004490837455,
0.431011438369751,
-0.5365293622016907,
0.7268325686454773,
-0.1299639493227005,
-0.8739972114562988,
0.6583808064460754,
-0.4889543950557709,
0.5076743960380554,
0.6682912111282349,
0.707278311252594,
-0.09332463890314102,
-0.8103964924812317,
-0.5039348006248474,
-0.6688336133956909,
0.5840641260147095,
0.48515814542770386,
-0.29219597578048706,
0.17340488731861115,
0.30219897627830505,
0.23949138820171356,
0.10831820219755173,
-0.9498329162597656,
-0.5314618945121765,
0.23701640963554382,
0.10423105955123901,
-0.15255868434906006,
-0.1784624308347702,
0.4004395306110382,
-0.5796425342559814,
0.8435048460960388,
0.04211141914129257,
0.38248735666275024,
-0.20075169205665588,
0.03983907401561737,
-0.15183180570602417,
0.3154234290122986,
0.5908425450325012,
0.814801812171936,
-0.3437456488609314,
-0.26504412293434143,
0.33071741461753845,
-0.5663709044456482,
0.4075523018836975,
-0.11345809698104858,
0.1356542855501175,
0.04812302812933922,
0.4171789884567261,
0.7816888689994812,
0.14116406440734863,
-0.6389840841293335,
-0.028092416003346443,
-0.11239342391490936,
-0.1647004336118698,
-0.09598750621080399,
0.10951021313667297,
0.04417913034558296,
0.365394651889801,
0.36278343200683594,
0.02560691349208355,
0.4472368061542511,
-0.8692178130149841,
0.26865890622138977,
0.18681968748569489,
-0.03720742464065552,
0.03605751693248749,
0.5403115153312683,
-0.07256769388914108,
-0.2945186197757721,
1.135643482208252,
-0.3373519480228424,
-0.48472869396209717,
0.6122758388519287,
0.42832204699516296,
0.6273090839385986,
-0.425384521484375,
0.25825580954551697,
0.681524395942688,
0.5597355365753174,
-0.146597757935524,
0.04714013263583183,
0.3391294479370117,
-0.20533625781536102,
-0.7225952744483948,
-0.7242706418037415,
-0.8400065898895264,
0.26991555094718933,
-0.7669593691825867,
0.2520338296890259,
-0.5307185649871826,
-0.20156551897525787,
0.2553502023220062,
0.11892315000295639,
-0.42017504572868347,
0.2445029765367508,
0.0016223480924963951,
0.8339458703994751,
-1.0845370292663574,
1.0522873401641846,
0.38835424184799194,
-0.40586480498313904,
-1.0637661218643188,
-0.44001516699790955,
-0.21193142235279083,
-0.46478691697120667,
0.40161997079849243,
0.26495906710624695,
0.024350935593247414,
0.070841945707798,
-0.3854493796825409,
-1.0669735670089722,
1.2659130096435547,
0.699494481086731,
-0.6820201873779297,
0.22496077418327332,
0.3544420599937439,
0.6167976260185242,
0.00913663487881422,
0.46872416138648987,
0.7634084224700928,
0.7636329531669617,
-0.17344006896018982,
-1.3953535556793213,
-0.12276259064674377,
-0.3923654556274414,
-0.26818135380744934,
0.4314591586589813,
-0.7538638114929199,
0.9910147786140442,
-0.11941231787204742,
0.006443274673074484,
0.17375487089157104,
0.6312797665596008,
0.43528079986572266,
0.544701874256134,
0.07738687843084335,
0.7593702673912048,
0.7503769993782043,
-0.3468477725982666,
1.24956476688385,
0.0620761439204216,
0.437892347574234,
0.9139930605888367,
-0.4079282581806183,
1.014678955078125,
0.12986163794994354,
-0.4066762626171112,
0.6866389513015747,
0.536973237991333,
0.1766737997531891,
0.4814179837703705,
0.36935460567474365,
-0.15250225365161896,
0.04103001952171326,
0.009856455028057098,
-0.4523164927959442,
0.6080958843231201,
0.07622252404689789,
-0.334218293428421,
0.11376912891864777,
0.3598015308380127,
0.15932200849056244,
-0.17299729585647583,
-0.4956028163433075,
0.8000763654708862,
-0.04977967590093613,
-0.6861028671264648,
0.4011213481426239,
-0.09659654647111893,
0.5021947622299194,
-0.4852820932865143,
-0.19866535067558289,
-0.2398112714290619,
0.29961541295051575,
-0.01762261614203453,
-0.7590263485908508,
0.343405544757843,
-0.10544797033071518,
-0.3085886240005493,
0.01899389922618866,
0.7202962040901184,
0.12339583039283752,
-0.7247908711433411,
0.3169527053833008,
0.12115175276994705,
0.4603034257888794,
-0.19206471741199493,
-0.5774989128112793,
0.44179296493530273,
-0.08500751107931137,
-0.27813419699668884,
0.30753475427627563,
0.1821872442960739,
0.04344532638788223,
1.0648531913757324,
0.2429780662059784,
-0.14326432347297668,
0.043556686490774155,
0.06927217543125153,
0.9302417039871216,
-0.6233602166175842,
-0.15509925782680511,
-1.0535043478012085,
0.5826006531715393,
-0.13682575523853302,
-0.37047260999679565,
0.7952851057052612,
0.7872350811958313,
0.5529858469963074,
-0.080516517162323,
0.5745921730995178,
-0.059461213648319244,
0.46435996890068054,
-0.4208119809627533,
0.6624751091003418,
-0.1757662147283554,
-0.06042272225022316,
-0.6776606440544128,
-1.1965261697769165,
0.03987254947423935,
0.7035300731658936,
0.14352822303771973,
0.09671031683683395,
0.8646932244300842,
0.611132025718689,
0.01699114218354225,
0.010382444597780704,
0.6229251027107239,
0.42269614338874817,
0.30193451046943665,
0.5304995179176331,
0.6518243551254272,
-0.6802104115486145,
0.0954776331782341,
-0.5168898105621338,
-0.0888795480132103,
-0.047291744500398636,
-0.8174270391464233,
-0.7349521517753601,
-0.49693137407302856,
-0.09145725518465042,
-0.3981979787349701,
-0.05233248695731163,
0.6550020575523376,
0.693008303642273,
-0.8163730502128601,
-0.24749137461185455,
0.007160255219787359,
-0.044922444969415665,
-0.21612918376922607,
-0.2577536702156067,
0.04676895961165428,
0.20342621207237244,
-0.6593858599662781,
0.531680703163147,
0.30878108739852905,
-0.3131771981716156,
-0.6709016561508179,
-0.4215087890625,
-0.3351283073425293,
0.11055029183626175,
0.5546891689300537,
0.10529153794050217,
-0.8134440779685974,
-0.24670405685901642,
0.1552315205335617,
-0.3042125105857849,
-0.0877244770526886,
0.6961839199066162,
-0.8265516757965088,
0.22242043912410736,
0.39826133847236633,
0.47574660181999207,
0.5486379265785217,
-0.023427823558449745,
0.5329769849777222,
-0.40322983264923096,
0.2875078022480011,
0.4233415424823761,
0.3045225143432617,
0.15777680277824402,
-0.5309628844261169,
0.6918125152587891,
-0.264108806848526,
-1.111431360244751,
-0.9181784987449646,
0.10091501474380493,
-1.1474636793136597,
-0.2571447193622589,
0.9024560451507568,
-0.050519585609436035,
0.06375101953744888,
-0.055953629314899445,
-0.19844770431518555,
0.3648725152015686,
-0.39385873079299927,
0.6244844794273376,
0.868596076965332,
-0.20168240368366241,
-0.31368404626846313,
-0.8263001441955566,
0.2842825949192047,
0.3873502314090729,
-0.9798502922058105,
-0.11086071282625198,
0.530813455581665,
0.1221800446510315,
0.023819761350750923,
0.7806455492973328,
-0.01704080030322075,
0.3916754722595215,
0.35997307300567627,
0.008683405816555023,
-0.0904453694820404,
-0.5387158989906311,
-0.2615581452846527,
0.09421178698539734,
0.4219892919063568,
0.26564082503318787
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10514v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10514v1
|
GTR-Voice: Articulatory Phonetics Informed Controllable Expressive Speech Synthesis
| 2024-06-15T05:37:04 | 2024-06-15T05:37:04 |
Zehua Kcriss Li, Meiying Melissa Chen, Yi Zhong, Pinxin Liu, Zhiyao Duan
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
Expressive speech synthesis aims to generate speech that captures a wide
range of para-linguistic features, including emotion and articulation, though
current research primarily emphasizes emotional aspects over the nuanced
articulatory features mastered by professional voice actors. Inspired by this,
we explore expressive speech synthesis through the lens of articulatory
phonetics. Specifically, we define a framework with three dimensions:
Glottalization, Tenseness, and Resonance (GTR), to guide the synthesis at the
voice production level. With this framework, we record a high-quality speech
dataset named GTR-Voice, featuring 20 Chinese sentences articulated by a
professional voice actor across 125 distinct GTR combinations. We verify the
framework and GTR annotations through automatic classification and listening
tests, and demonstrate precise controllability along the GTR dimensions on two
fine-tuned expressive TTS models. We open-source the dataset and TTS models.
|
[
-0.41196396946907043,
-0.6602750420570374,
0.1670997589826584,
0.2548910975456238,
0.1370535045862198,
0.39630407094955444,
-0.2722076177597046,
-0.5546751022338867,
0.48858627676963806,
0.41800886392593384,
-0.48375949263572693,
-0.4244826138019562,
-0.06544970721006393,
-0.23441772162914276,
-0.38453441858291626,
0.8884822130203247,
0.08479386568069458,
0.15390771627426147,
0.5178948640823364,
-0.10102156549692154,
-0.025295285508036613,
-0.7897143363952637,
-0.768748939037323,
-0.386722207069397,
0.6192227602005005,
0.047693829983472824,
1.0175914764404297,
0.7433004975318909,
0.13105018436908722,
0.3277653753757477,
-0.24415022134780884,
-0.1472354233264923,
-0.23554915189743042,
0.2330852895975113,
0.2363332062959671,
-0.24226363003253937,
-0.7808042764663696,
0.09269209951162338,
0.4984224736690521,
0.36657753586769104,
-0.45598798990249634,
0.08023868501186371,
0.10571715235710144,
0.4387015700340271,
-0.25862833857536316,
0.1610545963048935,
-0.41874608397483826,
0.2342686802148819,
-0.2804446518421173,
-0.14869271218776703,
-0.22971761226654053,
-0.766628086566925,
0.05847384035587311,
-0.6749678254127502,
0.2601553201675415,
-0.28447505831718445,
0.8095661997795105,
0.20384876430034637,
-0.05540917441248894,
-0.3518121540546417,
-1.2463130950927734,
0.3466186225414276,
-0.6607956886291504,
0.3999398648738861,
0.11269524693489075,
0.6761418581008911,
-0.11101599782705307,
-0.9274911880493164,
-0.7238905429840088,
-0.272516667842865,
0.030228571966290474,
0.33108609914779663,
-0.33151140809059143,
0.4058127701282501,
-0.0006572394049726427,
0.5775485634803772,
-0.7656927108764648,
0.038526251912117004,
-0.17653697729110718,
-0.21833184361457825,
0.6234678626060486,
0.27287960052490234,
0.5547004342079163,
-0.045011792331933975,
-0.1700081080198288,
-0.3735363483428955,
-0.3568722605705261,
0.18023350834846497,
0.6632585525512695,
0.5299230217933655,
-0.09181123226881027,
0.6712068915367126,
0.03966923803091049,
0.481054425239563,
0.2615867257118225,
-0.14371807873249054,
0.14786693453788757,
-0.1427503377199173,
-0.3042773902416229,
0.048746440559625626,
1.0240142345428467,
0.022340983152389526,
0.08108052611351013,
-0.11400101333856583,
-0.20468585193157196,
0.015487021766602993,
0.030970601364970207,
-0.6047453284263611,
-0.06259013712406158,
0.441308856010437,
-0.3497612476348877,
-0.17743058502674103,
-0.03623652830719948,
-0.679101824760437,
-0.11075713485479355,
-0.6515775918960571,
0.20267190039157867,
-0.49254870414733887,
-0.6645865440368652,
-0.23025643825531006,
-0.037568598985672,
0.3437996506690979,
0.04185597971081734,
-1.1334574222564697,
0.3188439905643463,
0.42440536618232727,
0.6083472371101379,
0.05507811903953552,
-0.348225861787796,
-0.6220998167991638,
0.31822314858436584,
-0.6554380655288696,
0.25256288051605225,
-0.5861840844154358,
-0.2783670425415039,
-0.02043347805738449,
-0.17332662642002106,
-0.16483190655708313,
-0.7345501184463501,
0.3215068578720093,
-0.1189945861697197,
0.35142064094543457,
0.05257007107138634,
-0.20454882085323334,
-0.22069618105888367,
-0.2614455819129944,
-0.7151815295219421,
0.9388500452041626,
0.3282531499862671,
-0.2779286801815033,
0.21651257574558258,
-0.647758424282074,
-0.43361493945121765,
0.1458030641078949,
-0.24704386293888092,
-0.047261957079172134,
0.26677897572517395,
0.06064283102750778,
0.2527870833873749,
0.07578451186418533,
0.5332299470901489,
-0.1715296357870102,
-0.1968761682510376,
0.380374938249588,
-0.3447629511356354,
0.5151417851448059,
0.581172525882721,
-0.5301153063774109,
0.6442153453826904,
-0.7862768173217773,
0.4815237820148468,
-0.2114432156085968,
-0.1414763331413269,
0.22133393585681915,
-0.17273730039596558,
0.6192272305488586,
0.19231215119361877,
-0.0686383917927742,
-0.18536898493766785,
0.002987500047311187,
-0.4716928005218506,
0.8898017406463623,
0.22553133964538574,
0.022970831021666527,
0.4142729640007019,
-0.27288272976875305,
0.6839576959609985,
-0.4187992513179779,
0.24449826776981354,
0.4144962430000305,
-0.36781853437423706,
-0.6739607453346252,
-0.35407012701034546,
0.14409767091274261,
0.6966111660003662,
-0.6562033295631409,
0.4670490324497223,
-0.10449783504009247,
-0.532331645488739,
-0.7671540975570679,
-0.27555257081985474,
0.19362249970436096,
0.13225308060646057,
0.3523261547088623,
-0.08289773762226105,
-0.4536854922771454,
-0.7660199403762817,
-0.12143353372812271,
-0.5516487956047058,
-0.5485448241233826,
0.13726000487804413,
-0.09061130881309509,
0.010057015344500542,
0.6801956295967102,
0.0426117368042469,
-0.5794618725776672,
-0.5735191106796265,
0.37393918633461,
0.07657328248023987,
0.467559278011322,
0.6184977293014526,
-0.5665043592453003,
-0.25901350378990173,
0.2139371633529663,
-0.4111078679561615,
-0.21353097259998322,
-0.19507035613059998,
-0.12053024023771286,
0.3356870412826538,
0.44656404852867126,
-0.8402124047279358,
0.26490190625190735,
0.4420986771583557,
0.07296673208475113,
0.3520628809928894,
-0.04909650981426239,
0.25432899594306946,
-0.7551488280296326,
0.2962036430835724,
-0.3167925477027893,
0.11697231233119965,
-0.9211403727531433,
0.06199793145060539,
-0.28127938508987427,
-0.4040299654006958,
-0.48527762293815613,
0.3576890230178833,
-0.38065576553344727,
-0.06494227796792984,
-0.15026293694972992,
0.3564741313457489,
-0.1664315164089203,
0.6513715982437134,
0.18498098850250244,
0.7363235354423523,
0.3868038058280945,
-0.3470643162727356,
0.47528505325317383,
0.1611865758895874,
-0.15809176862239838,
0.37121251225471497,
-0.8401107788085938,
0.19635316729545593,
0.13551636040210724,
0.08892367780208588,
-1.060623288154602,
-0.7566359043121338,
0.4653451144695282,
-0.6634026765823364,
0.4031711518764496,
-0.07516399770975113,
-0.36300066113471985,
-0.3772808313369751,
0.16414141654968262,
0.06885695457458496,
0.62694251537323,
-0.3759929835796356,
1.116036295890808,
0.4434010684490204,
-0.5529405474662781,
-0.16673271358013153,
-0.9356968998908997,
0.2607663571834564,
-0.48002734780311584,
-0.458719402551651,
0.23971886932849884,
0.0754316970705986,
-0.13716238737106323,
-0.06406611204147339,
0.19061428308486938,
-0.15721768140792847,
-0.2855837345123291,
0.15527908504009247,
-0.044702861458063126,
-0.10230644792318344,
-0.24054576456546783,
0.147743821144104,
0.022659361362457275,
0.07100805640220642,
0.034701425582170486,
0.3789425790309906,
-0.039763569831848145,
-0.18450209498405457,
-0.8244413733482361,
0.38135838508605957,
0.891692042350769,
-0.23518668115139008,
-0.180319145321846,
0.9249128103256226,
-0.30833715200424194,
0.1670897901058197,
-0.34405672550201416,
0.0986957848072052,
-0.4340425133705139,
0.16219261288642883,
-0.36905425786972046,
-0.9828770160675049,
0.7635959982872009,
0.4276236295700073,
-0.2347538024187088,
0.14420373737812042,
0.6567226648330688,
0.3415350914001465,
1.3377060890197754,
0.16859741508960724,
-0.3245929181575775,
0.583493709564209,
-0.062150273472070694,
0.18194183707237244,
-0.7711814641952515,
-0.1533486545085907,
-0.5305197834968567,
-0.2656821012496948,
-0.7929196357727051,
-0.19383607804775238,
0.3860202729701996,
-0.08173130452632904,
-0.23050066828727722,
0.07081123441457748,
-0.6087520122528076,
0.09673134982585907,
0.5492618083953857,
0.008612602017819881,
-0.2167450189590454,
-0.08719970285892487,
-0.02113969810307026,
-0.1190260648727417,
-0.46905213594436646,
-0.4376300871372223,
0.367350697517395,
0.43165072798728943,
0.6106269955635071,
0.3600744605064392,
0.42526185512542725,
-0.03624986112117767,
-0.012642658315598965,
-0.9230758547782898,
0.542408287525177,
-0.16147108376026154,
-0.561448872089386,
-0.3441199064254761,
-0.32657140493392944,
-0.6446806192398071,
0.21360665559768677,
-0.0611550472676754,
-0.8571302890777588,
0.07350807636976242,
0.20359954237937927,
-0.43229907751083374,
0.09796684235334396,
-0.5808528065681458,
0.6941223740577698,
-0.2954123914241791,
-0.2418462634086609,
0.05979923531413078,
-0.9862143993377686,
0.3023049533367157,
0.3760824203491211,
0.04730928689241409,
0.06868652254343033,
0.32641860842704773,
0.41400229930877686,
-0.1767442673444748,
0.7467876076698303,
-0.5174684524536133,
-0.08125351369380951,
0.35194697976112366,
0.2380295842885971,
0.2459869682788849,
-0.13934871554374695,
0.021613653749227524,
-0.040123745799064636,
-0.1121659055352211,
0.09045037627220154,
-0.695984959602356,
0.45566079020500183,
-0.5756574273109436,
-0.6200374960899353,
-0.04284176975488663,
-0.47534939646720886,
-0.33191996812820435,
0.23515069484710693,
0.3380574882030487,
0.4628518521785736,
-0.5609159469604492,
0.08382923156023026,
0.21121107041835785,
-0.2599460482597351,
0.43617260456085205,
0.06551698595285416,
-0.4880528748035431,
-0.8967166543006897,
0.7816848158836365,
0.1400449275970459,
0.48713651299476624,
0.5061788558959961,
0.1961454451084137,
-0.5373683571815491,
-0.4514135718345642,
-0.724348783493042,
0.04141649603843689,
-0.32328519225120544,
0.12873093783855438,
-0.30954059958457947,
-0.41240382194519043,
-0.5187144875526428,
0.16980904340744019,
-0.329830139875412,
-0.6199809312820435,
-0.43407270312309265,
-0.07976150512695312,
0.2358759045600891,
0.8909902572631836,
-0.455851674079895,
0.2414754033088684,
-0.5727826356887817,
0.4632610082626343,
0.3178279995918274,
0.1745293140411377,
-0.02499821037054062,
-0.3228785991668701,
-0.07295586168766022,
0.12532776594161987,
-0.2071775496006012,
-0.5158994197845459,
0.728183925151825,
0.3564816415309906,
0.4790571630001068,
0.333501398563385,
-0.12901639938354492,
0.6394521594047546,
-0.5271159410476685,
1.260150671005249,
0.033082976937294006,
-1.4149878025054932,
0.6792315244674683,
-0.5410077571868896,
0.2699977159500122,
0.06746616959571838,
0.050628311932086945,
-0.31124183535575867,
-0.9955883026123047,
-0.530138373374939,
-1.0262521505355835,
0.3019964396953583,
0.3498833179473877,
0.04877503216266632,
0.087355837225914,
0.23133985698223114,
0.0927414745092392,
0.1831086426973343,
-0.329157292842865,
-0.2740022540092468,
-0.6034943461418152,
-0.20295090973377228,
-0.13320879638195038,
-0.1545681357383728,
-0.4239683151245117,
-0.08335825055837631,
0.5009328126907349,
-0.2307989001274109,
0.4778905510902405,
0.23294267058372498,
0.45372331142425537,
-0.22271397709846497,
0.6126255393028259,
0.9446836113929749,
0.4272066056728363,
-0.22722303867340088,
0.001236992422491312,
-0.2733345329761505,
-0.5264935493469238,
0.32305586338043213,
0.17297165095806122,
0.020598627626895905,
0.275565505027771,
0.10103408992290497,
1.1412498950958252,
-0.21457701921463013,
-0.26375913619995117,
0.3944644629955292,
-0.11605334281921387,
-0.3563600182533264,
-0.47768285870552063,
0.18899206817150116,
-0.053665682673454285,
0.3657270669937134,
0.3731194734573364,
-0.013119748793542385,
0.40048202872276306,
-0.2860109508037567,
0.019833596423268318,
0.2923230230808258,
-0.43641045689582825,
-0.5917637348175049,
1.2705518007278442,
-0.09985914826393127,
-0.053898341953754425,
0.3048947751522064,
-0.03652056306600571,
-0.41017866134643555,
0.24067477881908417,
0.38028961420059204,
1.3515257835388184,
-0.5722711086273193,
0.2706633508205414,
0.24731799960136414,
0.09228135645389557,
-0.0350441075861454,
0.4754248559474945,
0.08780337125062943,
-0.4666765630245209,
-0.5157050490379333,
-0.16556796431541443,
-0.8351543545722961,
0.37082335352897644,
-1.3417410850524902,
-0.012313500046730042,
-0.39070838689804077,
-0.39839333295822144,
0.11063914746046066,
-0.4881711006164551,
-0.20364490151405334,
0.33079347014427185,
0.15270332992076874,
0.5736069679260254,
-0.5594791769981384,
0.9273388981819153,
0.3586493134498596,
-0.29261502623558044,
-1.2239490747451782,
0.04351887106895447,
0.11689735949039459,
-0.5256732106208801,
0.7105231285095215,
0.03143949434161186,
-0.4570859372615814,
0.011487877927720547,
-0.5018621683120728,
-0.6936370730400085,
0.9277999401092529,
0.5020473599433899,
-0.4509073793888092,
0.1337689757347107,
0.26985692977905273,
1.01529061794281,
-0.42362722754478455,
0.15382404625415802,
0.5828967094421387,
0.41378533840179443,
0.358931303024292,
-1.1741583347320557,
-0.06083207204937935,
-0.4393031597137451,
0.35533562302589417,
-0.11116898059844971,
-0.6310297846794128,
0.6994884610176086,
-0.0941847562789917,
-0.5820081830024719,
0.642295777797699,
0.7872726917266846,
0.3029773533344269,
0.15486009418964386,
0.3690820634365082,
0.33376240730285645,
0.8896839618682861,
-0.381865918636322,
0.6959702968597412,
-0.2981720566749573,
-0.04860915243625641,
1.000386357307434,
-0.4664430022239685,
0.8765626549720764,
0.3369000256061554,
-0.08452248573303223,
0.3779134154319763,
0.4642198383808136,
0.2653322219848633,
0.5518015027046204,
0.4465652108192444,
-0.30138465762138367,
0.041311901062726974,
-0.20343442261219025,
-0.5138885378837585,
0.7406705021858215,
0.5446377992630005,
-0.1443766951560974,
0.3305051028728485,
0.2917616069316864,
-0.0012537339935079217,
-0.09841500967741013,
-0.14600354433059692,
0.7366687655448914,
-0.26606252789497375,
-0.4284980297088623,
0.8751596212387085,
-0.5948576927185059,
0.16840730607509613,
-0.6575535535812378,
-0.01265103928744793,
-0.1314288228750229,
0.030218008905649185,
-0.0805983915925026,
-0.9878082871437073,
0.27513018250465393,
-0.23755551874637604,
-0.019987108185887337,
-0.29788416624069214,
0.3944548964500427,
-0.792601466178894,
0.07802827656269073,
0.3836391270160675,
0.4679870009422302,
0.21171148121356964,
0.040682487189769745,
-0.4265449047088623,
0.30788925290107727,
0.06819376349449158,
-0.46904343366622925,
0.07232671976089478,
0.7753078937530518,
0.1329602152109146,
0.6976985335350037,
0.4128640592098236,
0.517305850982666,
-0.18683204054832458,
0.5565193295478821,
0.7698556184768677,
-0.8160437941551208,
-0.5264926552772522,
-0.34089425206184387,
0.500872015953064,
0.2748330533504486,
-0.16640689969062805,
0.3021567761898041,
0.44080623984336853,
0.7965760827064514,
-0.25978365540504456,
1.1584105491638184,
-0.17164885997772217,
0.7616825103759766,
-0.8625862002372742,
0.6924547553062439,
-0.3598400950431824,
-0.15018674731254578,
-0.3651781976222992,
-0.7872440218925476,
-0.5577813386917114,
0.5613687634468079,
0.13608203828334808,
0.17914040386676788,
0.3684335947036743,
0.9848865866661072,
0.282650887966156,
0.25464245676994324,
0.39766526222229004,
0.14549337327480316,
0.436597615480423,
0.48370394110679626,
1.0414706468582153,
-0.24945352971553802,
0.47711533308029175,
-0.06902091950178146,
-0.22859615087509155,
0.057627491652965546,
-0.7662158608436584,
-0.5690867304801941,
-0.6303189992904663,
-0.20428842306137085,
-0.3110419511795044,
-0.1222556009888649,
0.8624870181083679,
0.6279711127281189,
-0.8680548667907715,
-0.5461313724517822,
-0.0722690150141716,
-0.2434632033109665,
-0.4728271961212158,
-0.3662484884262085,
0.2740725874900818,
-0.10105579346418381,
-0.9893950819969177,
0.6313343644142151,
0.2310263067483902,
0.5609673857688904,
-0.25673526525497437,
-0.045421261340379715,
0.4612603783607483,
-0.1419396847486496,
0.39343026280403137,
0.5310289859771729,
-1.139893651008606,
-0.5018988251686096,
0.21162724494934082,
-0.14153333008289337,
-0.06717611849308014,
0.8933708667755127,
-0.2786087989807129,
0.38096973299980164,
0.3162331283092499,
0.21848595142364502,
0.1368887722492218,
0.00018577647279016674,
0.7661684155464172,
-0.495779424905777,
0.09527678042650223,
0.25076690316200256,
0.07427321374416351,
0.37537696957588196,
-0.22732605040073395,
0.5345448851585388,
-0.020723512396216393,
-0.6830245852470398,
-0.6073415279388428,
0.28500622510910034,
-1.4017000198364258,
0.18648211658000946,
1.1365017890930176,
0.10571601241827011,
0.00030135511769913137,
0.11474063247442245,
-0.5031523108482361,
0.3696972131729126,
-0.6106969118118286,
0.4436399042606354,
0.5939834713935852,
-0.6474314332008362,
-0.25235897302627563,
-0.5561006665229797,
0.7103828191757202,
0.015459038317203522,
-0.5577051639556885,
0.3442494571208954,
0.7582494616508484,
-0.11023525148630142,
0.2272123545408249,
0.4881433844566345,
-0.2871760129928589,
0.07547122985124588,
0.014203363098204136,
0.4362495541572571,
0.21363788843154907,
-0.36435285210609436,
-0.3086012005805969,
0.30232712626457214,
0.16396082937717438,
-0.14199046790599823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15468v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15468v1
|
Reasoning or Simply Next Token Prediction? A Benchmark for Stress-Testing Large Language Models
| 2024-06-15T05:35:47 | 2024-06-15T05:35:47 |
Wentian Wang, Paul Kantor, Jacob Feldman, Lazaros Gallos, Hao Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We propose MMLU-SR, a novel dataset designed to measure the true
comprehension abilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) by challenging their
performance in question-answering tasks with modified terms. We reasoned that
an agent that ``truly'' understands a concept can still evaluate it when key
terms are replaced by suitably defined alternate terms, and sought to
differentiate such comprehension from mere text replacement. In our study, we
modified standardized test questions by replacing a key term with a dummy word
along with its definition. The key term could be in the context of questions,
answers, or both questions and answers.
Notwithstanding the high scores achieved by recent popular LLMs on the MMLU
leaderboard, we found a substantial reduction in model performance after such
replacement, suggesting poor comprehension. This new benchmark provides a
rigorous benchmark for testing true model comprehension, and poses a challenge
to the broader scientific community.
|
[
-0.3133854269981384,
-0.9955809116363525,
0.7563626766204834,
-0.03158397227525711,
-0.3478100895881653,
0.25280267000198364,
0.06825527548789978,
-0.5374235510826111,
-0.09716800600290298,
0.26567649841308594,
-0.7071498036384583,
-0.06923138350248337,
-0.4428333342075348,
0.46790680289268494,
-0.44625717401504517,
0.7350799441337585,
-0.1620703637599945,
0.16166001558303833,
-0.6229960322380066,
-0.22625187039375305,
-0.3300023376941681,
-0.6540626287460327,
-0.6839473843574524,
-0.5992239117622375,
0.8456330895423889,
0.2220975160598755,
0.6768528819084167,
0.4192279875278473,
0.5842642188072205,
0.23611806333065033,
-0.25668635964393616,
-0.023193392902612686,
-0.3936954438686371,
-0.02912968210875988,
-0.03163944557309151,
-0.6553242206573486,
-0.33061325550079346,
0.23865632712841034,
0.5888118147850037,
0.838468074798584,
0.02734602428972721,
0.439845472574234,
-0.21578790247440338,
0.33762118220329285,
-0.5424875020980835,
-0.029845235869288445,
-1.0934218168258667,
-0.00945108849555254,
0.012966470792889595,
-0.3138919770717621,
-0.6716724634170532,
-0.08529213070869446,
-0.0036488526966422796,
-0.540846586227417,
0.07437783479690552,
0.3079149127006531,
0.963548481464386,
0.5979225635528564,
-0.4879300594329834,
0.1286018043756485,
-0.49475011229515076,
0.604053258895874,
-0.6821314096450806,
0.4712520241737366,
0.40014079213142395,
0.450668603181839,
-0.13046561181545258,
-0.9192929267883301,
-0.7695363759994507,
-0.594780683517456,
0.04277311637997627,
0.1836044192314148,
-0.0017773163272067904,
-0.06633913516998291,
0.41790762543678284,
0.19165676832199097,
-0.6216717958450317,
-0.030185598880052567,
-0.4409017860889435,
-0.23357181251049042,
0.42469722032546997,
0.322942316532135,
0.01665356382727623,
-0.15878723561763763,
-0.4328996539115906,
-0.18281662464141846,
-0.7459766268730164,
0.11113470047712326,
0.1352200210094452,
0.17445184290409088,
0.2408580780029297,
0.7296148538589478,
-0.15095050632953644,
0.5297611951828003,
-0.36559024453163147,
-0.10090000927448273,
0.40273624658584595,
-0.20133012533187866,
-0.5305360555648804,
-0.0885559469461441,
0.490416020154953,
0.29233208298683167,
0.2734852731227875,
-0.027863161638379097,
-0.2632601857185364,
0.16954606771469116,
0.2327319085597992,
-0.6951131224632263,
0.020978491753339767,
0.15261368453502655,
-0.2928239107131958,
-0.26301610469818115,
-0.07464641332626343,
-0.5522201061248779,
-0.4659443199634552,
-0.3633788228034973,
0.21310117840766907,
-0.33129721879959106,
-0.20449745655059814,
0.0514439232647419,
-0.1282777041196823,
0.3146996796131134,
0.22089152038097382,
-0.3350200355052948,
0.17906630039215088,
0.8418096303939819,
0.8296457529067993,
-0.09526604413986206,
-0.5073514580726624,
-0.5644437074661255,
-0.19546595215797424,
-0.6118555665016174,
0.9607145190238953,
-0.7793611288070679,
-0.4293226897716522,
-0.14952480792999268,
-0.04604361206293106,
-0.24474704265594482,
-0.5222439169883728,
0.8100269436836243,
-0.5880665183067322,
-0.04183802008628845,
-0.5720112323760986,
-0.7355592250823975,
0.007727042306214571,
0.524874210357666,
-0.5952498316764832,
1.1839563846588135,
0.12258409708738327,
-0.6859471797943115,
0.39323997497558594,
-0.4756791591644287,
-0.14388740062713623,
-0.005311090964823961,
0.029735928401350975,
-0.13485293090343475,
0.17140965163707733,
-0.04817616567015648,
0.292338490486145,
-0.5080803632736206,
0.21366271376609802,
-0.828147292137146,
-0.5184643268585205,
0.81418776512146,
-0.4514455497264862,
0.29014119505882263,
0.07443828880786896,
0.04961875081062317,
0.12662294507026672,
-0.6975867748260498,
0.15649494528770447,
0.13235509395599365,
-0.0146726593375206,
-0.323257714509964,
-0.05408111587166786,
0.016384899616241455,
0.4099319577217102,
0.10629463940858841,
-0.5250488519668579,
0.09315906465053558,
-0.2233067899942398,
0.43078288435935974,
1.0686739683151245,
-0.20558375120162964,
0.08779072016477585,
-0.37299424409866333,
0.6356465816497803,
-0.16486521065235138,
0.21803005039691925,
-0.06710086017847061,
-0.5311685800552368,
-0.6952539086341858,
0.044517431408166885,
0.4286467432975769,
0.47280311584472656,
-0.6308705806732178,
0.03208444267511368,
-0.21699798107147217,
-0.5469498038291931,
-0.654899001121521,
-0.001438396517187357,
0.2723886966705322,
0.7586547136306763,
0.49412888288497925,
0.17178480327129364,
-0.6452818512916565,
-0.7920202016830444,
-0.37054526805877686,
-0.5639154314994812,
0.14254458248615265,
0.355762243270874,
0.8931407332420349,
-0.29936662316322327,
0.6096004247665405,
-0.5483765602111816,
-0.06412353366613388,
-0.15360620617866516,
0.2733095586299896,
0.08015938848257065,
0.25856125354766846,
0.24125230312347412,
-0.8737757802009583,
-0.2498379647731781,
-0.13901589810848236,
-0.5009036064147949,
-0.10505832731723785,
-0.1168452575802803,
0.04459621012210846,
0.1767999827861786,
0.9044641256332397,
-0.7104073166847229,
0.07497421652078629,
0.631411075592041,
-0.5075849890708923,
1.258859634399414,
-0.14750099182128906,
-0.05314997583627701,
-0.8650562167167664,
0.29310342669487,
-0.21804474294185638,
-0.004284090828150511,
-0.5522299408912659,
0.3110911548137665,
0.20744739472866058,
-0.020320165902376175,
-0.45408111810684204,
0.9291011095046997,
-0.11981244385242462,
-0.27388542890548706,
-0.17211203277111053,
0.18858055770397186,
-0.06438802927732468,
0.21807269752025604,
-0.22289106249809265,
0.989286482334137,
0.5383080244064331,
-0.5092183947563171,
0.3372209966182709,
0.1267552673816681,
-0.39136192202568054,
0.47942405939102173,
-0.9444690942764282,
0.3420881927013397,
-0.1640959531068802,
0.47777462005615234,
-1.113480806350708,
-0.15394610166549683,
-0.14219459891319275,
-0.5737072229385376,
-0.14766058325767517,
0.07449428737163544,
-0.6184210777282715,
-0.7793442010879517,
0.06589662283658981,
0.33265912532806396,
0.43298566341400146,
-0.4565935432910919,
0.5528647899627686,
-0.014513344503939152,
0.010291559621691704,
-0.6436700224876404,
-0.8371121287345886,
0.14890184998512268,
-0.2815263867378235,
-0.4033345878124237,
0.25719624757766724,
-0.42085370421409607,
-0.39923638105392456,
0.07984410226345062,
-0.2114526778459549,
-0.131071999669075,
0.37918227910995483,
0.16897720098495483,
0.5380115509033203,
-0.308935284614563,
0.5581761598587036,
-0.16579459607601166,
-0.1556335985660553,
0.22065871953964233,
-0.07765021920204163,
0.5869426131248474,
-0.16318027675151825,
-0.283174067735672,
-0.2154594361782074,
-0.017968453466892242,
0.7710238099098206,
-0.34868523478507996,
0.6810702681541443,
0.5352477431297302,
-0.2920433580875397,
-0.1507938802242279,
-0.619387686252594,
-0.26829639077186584,
-0.4914853572845459,
0.2076738327741623,
-0.8982282876968384,
-0.999562680721283,
0.6927918195724487,
-0.016698263585567474,
0.041850000619888306,
0.45522263646125793,
0.45257019996643066,
-0.12989577651023865,
1.092705249786377,
0.27772295475006104,
-0.10663417726755142,
-0.04030975326895714,
-0.0688241720199585,
0.28684133291244507,
-0.8496715426445007,
-0.1957705318927765,
-0.6484099626541138,
-0.29790621995925903,
-0.1831045001745224,
-0.712912917137146,
0.04155702516436577,
0.02444661781191826,
-0.02047157846391201,
0.0520998015999794,
-0.04725687578320503,
0.37642356753349304,
0.24594585597515106,
-0.23519748449325562,
0.24114090204238892,
-0.579500138759613,
-0.4891643226146698,
0.04749279096722603,
-0.17415541410446167,
-0.6188061833381653,
1.2129638195037842,
0.21859511733055115,
0.5080824494361877,
-0.21284213662147522,
0.32232049107551575,
0.16111385822296143,
0.5086231231689453,
-0.7734445333480835,
0.6671398878097534,
0.19194498658180237,
-0.7623959183692932,
-0.32183974981307983,
-0.6115791201591492,
-0.8187249898910522,
0.6552056670188904,
-0.03492671623826027,
-0.6593753695487976,
-0.3004862666130066,
0.046255242079496384,
-0.3873954713344574,
0.37864211201667786,
-0.5947874188423157,
0.9486419558525085,
-0.07151881605386734,
0.09990759193897247,
-0.22200575470924377,
-0.23926837742328644,
0.6177343130111694,
-0.3452219069004059,
0.1899489164352417,
-0.4496184289455414,
-0.3437259793281555,
0.6756210923194885,
-0.2192472666501999,
0.464277982711792,
0.0332123264670372,
0.09138946235179901,
0.1172962561249733,
0.010940655134618282,
0.4654902219772339,
0.13774420320987701,
-0.32957157492637634,
-0.4881274104118347,
0.31493714451789856,
-0.6501951813697815,
-0.7608804106712341,
0.5427466034889221,
-0.5916171669960022,
-0.6854057908058167,
-0.3300797641277313,
-0.6806558966636658,
-0.6153138875961304,
0.08108899742364883,
-0.057635512202978134,
0.41437381505966187,
-0.3169068396091461,
0.32617107033729553,
0.5059151649475098,
-0.04003281518816948,
0.18466389179229736,
0.49783825874328613,
-0.20967434346675873,
-0.006338668987154961,
0.6106739044189453,
-0.01297900453209877,
0.16579218208789825,
0.21260982751846313,
0.3975997567176819,
-0.5755889415740967,
-0.5325914621353149,
-0.1311740279197693,
0.2639326751232147,
-0.7121961116790771,
-0.047649312764406204,
-0.7335185408592224,
-0.10148290544748306,
-0.45573973655700684,
0.005149331875145435,
-0.2797868847846985,
-0.154161736369133,
-0.3422517478466034,
-0.5313177704811096,
0.08489909768104553,
0.4027971029281616,
0.28296032547950745,
-0.08470240235328674,
-0.6068170666694641,
0.25115418434143066,
0.3778555989265442,
0.18549732863903046,
-0.04207362234592438,
-0.852001965045929,
0.08398199081420898,
-0.08020555227994919,
-0.03627648577094078,
-0.758959174156189,
0.10082445293664932,
0.1957371085882187,
0.7259653210639954,
0.33965176343917847,
0.3221625089645386,
0.8736249804496765,
-0.5105793476104736,
0.764158308506012,
0.06712161749601364,
-0.9835656881332397,
0.22952483594417572,
0.005130821373313665,
0.4072323143482208,
0.6038367748260498,
0.3728102147579193,
-0.7587741017341614,
-0.6484988927841187,
-0.8410096764564514,
-0.34731316566467285,
0.15571705996990204,
-0.05274120345711708,
0.2724495828151703,
0.17691807448863983,
0.4504702389240265,
0.20149889588356018,
0.053556762635707855,
-0.5899503827095032,
-0.15877269208431244,
0.0640692263841629,
-0.008096314035356045,
-0.5060020685195923,
-0.38989123702049255,
0.005675697233527899,
-0.4557136595249176,
0.5744684338569641,
-0.38970229029655457,
0.22918294370174408,
0.21463149785995483,
-0.14257216453552246,
-0.1549079567193985,
0.20911529660224915,
0.7649999856948853,
0.8984361290931702,
-0.3347720205783844,
0.2567278742790222,
0.49998489022254944,
-0.2078036367893219,
0.1679992526769638,
0.13914483785629272,
-0.06546009331941605,
-0.0782008245587349,
0.5041851997375488,
0.8777989149093628,
0.1942526251077652,
-1.0943002700805664,
0.18886704742908478,
-0.11999858915805817,
-0.5685788989067078,
-0.36511531472206116,
-0.08875221014022827,
0.07968538999557495,
0.1339883953332901,
0.6504260301589966,
0.007310086395591497,
-0.006310588214546442,
-0.7401123642921448,
0.583024799823761,
0.2111690193414688,
-0.5785171985626221,
-0.3916594684123993,
0.5582602620124817,
-0.15042302012443542,
-0.016489364206790924,
0.33615943789482117,
-0.2746671438217163,
-0.761436939239502,
0.7299889922142029,
0.49678170680999756,
0.5250090956687927,
-0.2016333043575287,
0.4081653654575348,
0.4293386936187744,
0.4565812349319458,
-0.0398370660841465,
0.42937472462654114,
0.36947640776634216,
-0.8173719644546509,
-0.5929179191589355,
-0.4934256672859192,
-0.5041226148605347,
0.46358922123908997,
-0.610907793045044,
-0.04796890914440155,
-0.4516332745552063,
-0.18807125091552734,
0.045063331723213196,
0.21635094285011292,
-0.5524453520774841,
0.5071277618408203,
0.19451861083507538,
1.3637309074401855,
-0.8884606957435608,
1.0199077129364014,
0.8272155523300171,
-0.2617381811141968,
-0.8138986825942993,
0.05066390335559845,
0.04044465720653534,
-0.7094281911849976,
0.48807185888290405,
0.3250334560871124,
0.1652277559041977,
-0.18910905718803406,
-0.42377305030822754,
-0.9418664574623108,
0.9951316118240356,
0.2600618600845337,
-0.3602854013442993,
-0.013561167754232883,
0.0020635498221963644,
0.7261286973953247,
-0.2701324224472046,
0.37184473872184753,
0.8996527194976807,
0.7254364490509033,
0.31202027201652527,
-0.6982781291007996,
0.21132129430770874,
-0.2960241436958313,
-0.2468121498823166,
-0.02535424195230007,
-0.502336859703064,
1.0533987283706665,
-0.336629182100296,
-0.09560808539390564,
0.2513728141784668,
0.8573856353759766,
0.42355877161026,
0.5302731394767761,
0.7726186513900757,
0.6124664545059204,
1.1842162609100342,
-0.25470173358917236,
1.3413652181625366,
0.007765947375446558,
0.3345645070075989,
1.174146056175232,
-0.4727572202682495,
1.1396870613098145,
0.5874323844909668,
-0.15271344780921936,
0.42251163721084595,
0.9398983120918274,
-0.04840193688869476,
0.3200424611568451,
0.4583646357059479,
0.10054420679807663,
-0.44773560762405396,
-0.17097729444503784,
-0.37873920798301697,
0.41840672492980957,
0.20873859524726868,
-0.07728297263383865,
-0.008488637395203114,
0.09169194102287292,
-0.0754765123128891,
0.07047395408153534,
-0.22811387479305267,
0.44891807436943054,
0.20995379984378815,
-0.7317407131195068,
0.8084316849708557,
-0.07567830383777618,
0.36765429377555847,
-0.45213913917541504,
0.3554573059082031,
-0.41325217485427856,
0.24322640895843506,
0.2495916187763214,
-0.7245669364929199,
0.3342512845993042,
-0.06999161839485168,
0.2865414321422577,
-0.004281950183212757,
0.6282700896263123,
-0.24119777977466583,
-0.6286808848381042,
0.511344850063324,
0.5524858236312866,
0.13879993557929993,
-0.2541782855987549,
-1.0681118965148926,
0.14871184527873993,
-0.2961999773979187,
-0.37956342101097107,
0.1963077336549759,
0.3608008325099945,
0.18966956436634064,
1.1694139242172241,
0.831153929233551,
0.03857980668544769,
0.3186395764350891,
0.199356347322464,
0.7560864090919495,
-0.5753095746040344,
-0.4425489902496338,
-0.7732668519020081,
0.3668549358844757,
-0.17499513924121857,
-0.5826535224914551,
0.5895591378211975,
0.4219008684158325,
0.7390419244766235,
0.03406883031129837,
0.7300033569335938,
0.24724256992340088,
0.4374200701713562,
-0.5857897996902466,
0.5245296359062195,
-1.0384986400604248,
-0.19851519167423248,
-0.34068915247917175,
-0.7924714088439941,
-0.16932092607021332,
0.21074068546295166,
-0.3205091953277588,
-0.2609862983226776,
1.2571096420288086,
0.8141422867774963,
0.02403966709971428,
0.04189668595790863,
0.7752101421356201,
0.3090100884437561,
0.31899040937423706,
0.4815303087234497,
1.0719218254089355,
-0.4126916229724884,
0.7841663956642151,
-0.05678756535053253,
0.055166471749544144,
-0.3284933865070343,
-0.6147032976150513,
-1.0948787927627563,
-0.8424221873283386,
-0.23171983659267426,
-0.2859141230583191,
-0.003973559010773897,
0.7817478179931641,
0.533007800579071,
-0.7682957649230957,
-0.01841525360941887,
-0.0801968201994896,
0.23409457504749298,
-0.4582708775997162,
-0.1871316134929657,
0.31978142261505127,
-0.5289818048477173,
-0.5430155396461487,
0.4768264889717102,
0.026600146666169167,
-0.009139575995504856,
-0.26523688435554504,
-0.20270109176635742,
-0.23971349000930786,
0.47865059971809387,
0.5283868312835693,
0.09822362661361694,
-0.9920997619628906,
-0.41617199778556824,
0.19696904718875885,
-0.2446935623884201,
-0.14028681814670563,
0.9187076091766357,
-0.6333571076393127,
0.24196067452430725,
0.4709113836288452,
0.9265920519828796,
0.28645089268684387,
0.035125959664583206,
0.48179304599761963,
-0.3945212662220001,
0.16079793870449066,
0.30703938007354736,
0.5664013624191284,
0.2494708001613617,
-0.13589952886104584,
0.629285991191864,
0.43404561281204224,
-0.25082704424858093,
-1.2874394655227661,
0.22554640471935272,
-0.8919206261634827,
-0.5216324329376221,
1.2029651403427124,
-0.204910010099411,
-0.3685436248779297,
-0.1074424684047699,
-0.08497980982065201,
0.061800871044397354,
-0.23475903272628784,
0.8458808660507202,
0.9072068929672241,
0.36043068766593933,
-0.5848751068115234,
-0.6996715068817139,
0.47655975818634033,
0.7483484148979187,
-0.8565862774848938,
0.2013629972934723,
0.19751738011837006,
0.01867697387933731,
0.02294827066361904,
0.559467613697052,
0.06890080869197845,
0.41994670033454895,
0.05561031401157379,
-0.22423098981380463,
-0.15227067470550537,
-0.3349664807319641,
-0.05862864479422569,
0.11702719330787659,
0.10074056684970856,
0.08129627257585526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10507v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10507v1
|
Benchmarking Children's ASR with Supervised and Self-supervised Speech Foundation Models
| 2024-06-15T05:13:19 | 2024-06-15T05:13:19 |
Ruchao Fan, Natarajan Balaji Shankar, Abeer Alwan
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
Speech foundation models (SFMs) have achieved state-of-the-art results for
various speech tasks in supervised (e.g. Whisper) or self-supervised systems
(e.g. WavLM). However, the performance of SFMs for child ASR has not been
systematically studied. In addition, there is no benchmark for child ASR with
standard evaluations, making the comparisons of novel ideas difficult. In this
paper, we initiate and present a comprehensive benchmark on several child
speech databases based on various SFMs (Whisper, Wav2vec2.0, HuBERT, and
WavLM). Moreover, we investigate finetuning strategies by comparing various
data augmentation and parameter-efficient finetuning (PEFT) methods. We observe
that the behaviors of these methods are different when the model size
increases. For example, PEFT matches the performance of full finetuning for
large models but worse for small models. To stabilize finetuning using
augmented data, we propose a perturbation invariant finetuning (PIF) loss as a
regularization.
|
[
-0.521167516708374,
-0.6560300588607788,
-0.14000296592712402,
0.37548309564590454,
-0.06612841784954071,
-0.038666028529405594,
-0.2810324430465698,
-0.3369908630847931,
-0.3664827048778534,
0.5759643912315369,
-0.7385947704315186,
-0.16627810895442963,
-0.4694954752922058,
0.11522308737039566,
-0.668056845664978,
0.7057451009750366,
0.034019388258457184,
0.13677513599395752,
-0.2912226617336273,
0.09935854375362396,
-0.17577818036079407,
-0.51539146900177,
-0.8718013167381287,
-0.4429898262023926,
0.06298082321882248,
0.688828706741333,
0.2938600778579712,
0.804071843624115,
0.6139650940895081,
0.2113315463066101,
-0.28503140807151794,
-0.08162671327590942,
-0.5656077265739441,
0.14116688072681427,
-0.06830663233995438,
-0.0590888075530529,
-0.25407853722572327,
-0.01148901041597128,
0.843167781829834,
1.0004080533981323,
-0.34033358097076416,
0.049436055123806,
0.30720779299736023,
0.7470964789390564,
-0.7416276931762695,
-0.028996001929044724,
-0.5454388856887817,
0.18023167550563812,
-0.09030181914567947,
0.05575056001543999,
-0.09593015909194946,
-0.2021445482969284,
0.4893185794353485,
-0.2500651180744171,
0.6224115490913391,
-0.21238435804843903,
0.6127293705940247,
0.46597135066986084,
-0.3796934485435486,
-0.23172052204608917,
-0.8150420784950256,
0.7557765245437622,
-0.575254499912262,
0.7862255573272705,
0.6054301857948303,
0.22432242333889008,
-0.15532106161117554,
-0.7034021019935608,
-0.4183282256126404,
-0.2498692274093628,
-0.11175660789012909,
-0.12559157609939575,
-0.4237173795700073,
0.16440527141094208,
0.2795467674732208,
0.425453245639801,
-0.5594976544380188,
0.11436562985181808,
-0.3035002052783966,
-0.3049659729003906,
0.663265585899353,
0.06668401509523392,
-0.20632004737854004,
0.0027927288319915533,
-0.6509574055671692,
-0.5110501050949097,
-0.644885778427124,
0.35384997725486755,
0.21923846006393433,
0.4376610517501831,
-0.18581005930900574,
0.44258344173431396,
-0.5529966950416565,
0.6934205293655396,
0.7258428931236267,
-0.098139688372612,
0.2968204617500305,
-0.28378161787986755,
-0.30782729387283325,
0.3901461362838745,
0.8692845106124878,
0.22406890988349915,
0.29435718059539795,
-0.12271619588136673,
-0.36872339248657227,
0.14047099649906158,
-0.15592245757579803,
-0.8351412415504456,
-0.44793885946273804,
-0.31997498869895935,
-0.42404624819755554,
-0.27022120356559753,
0.0771244540810585,
-0.4959588646888733,
-0.3553217351436615,
-0.2904173731803894,
0.6739575862884521,
-0.3781214952468872,
-0.11914505064487457,
0.06548233330249786,
0.08868566155433655,
0.2958216369152069,
-0.11624319851398468,
-0.9927079081535339,
0.9283146262168884,
0.643811047077179,
0.6252807378768921,
-0.45165160298347473,
-0.02654869481921196,
-0.7439665794372559,
0.015441730618476868,
-0.5796644687652588,
0.8598710894584656,
-0.30007225275039673,
-0.5619429349899292,
-0.378696084022522,
0.07778380066156387,
-0.23758135735988617,
-0.8774147629737854,
0.7408929467201233,
0.001885229954496026,
0.004562044516205788,
-0.08621007949113846,
-0.46359845995903015,
0.0579194575548172,
-0.023532848805189133,
-0.3852553367614746,
0.9076138734817505,
-0.027280062437057495,
-0.3505646586418152,
0.500644862651825,
-0.3463587760925293,
-0.782651960849762,
-0.36823126673698425,
-0.1733168512582779,
-0.6602252721786499,
0.2838160991668701,
0.5067929625511169,
0.6027490496635437,
-0.23575301468372345,
0.3479682207107544,
-0.02137709967792034,
-0.6000509262084961,
0.023623131215572357,
-0.8279239535331726,
0.44299450516700745,
0.19975332915782928,
-0.4159699082374573,
0.06507425755262375,
-0.8640808463096619,
-0.018808364868164062,
-0.1995103359222412,
-0.22175589203834534,
0.050132885575294495,
0.133070170879364,
0.22990040481090546,
0.10562457889318466,
-0.022415457293391228,
-0.5731034874916077,
-0.20458707213401794,
-0.6068789958953857,
0.5569922924041748,
0.25279054045677185,
0.11177573353052139,
0.12241807579994202,
-0.6249738335609436,
0.30816569924354553,
-0.0904281809926033,
0.13418641686439514,
-0.12583787739276886,
-0.017099589109420776,
-0.768618106842041,
-0.3927333354949951,
0.49937576055526733,
0.09075777977705002,
-0.2755323350429535,
0.35760197043418884,
-0.2454797625541687,
-0.45578449964523315,
-0.5081741809844971,
-0.0886877253651619,
0.6305931806564331,
0.6231215596199036,
0.60178142786026,
-0.39708077907562256,
-0.5479514598846436,
-0.9134869575500488,
-0.0988074243068695,
0.05062960833311081,
-0.1826035976409912,
0.3340015709400177,
-0.0553172267973423,
-0.07634932547807693,
0.8087794780731201,
0.014132753014564514,
-0.44896605610847473,
0.2621828317642212,
-0.008554506115615368,
0.05818856880068779,
0.9303296208381653,
0.5867097973823547,
-0.7128176093101501,
-0.5535227060317993,
-0.2439729869365692,
-0.10684669762849808,
-0.2280731201171875,
0.3084326386451721,
0.45618778467178345,
0.2477598935365677,
0.5539520978927612,
-0.4089900553226471,
0.46736451983451843,
0.672849178314209,
-0.4553013741970062,
0.3941662609577179,
0.19072189927101135,
0.2497817426919937,
-0.2699160873889923,
-0.03415132686495781,
-0.08314547687768936,
-0.474964439868927,
-0.7397065162658691,
-0.14395523071289062,
0.07862863689661026,
-0.0810265839099884,
-0.44320085644721985,
0.2534855604171753,
-0.490657240152359,
-0.2489309310913086,
-0.2595239281654358,
-0.09693700075149536,
-0.08024846762418747,
0.09244098514318466,
0.11089801788330078,
0.9052212238311768,
0.6720570921897888,
-0.42702430486679077,
0.3176195025444031,
0.04339205473661423,
-0.11952622979879379,
0.5293794274330139,
-0.9384419322013855,
0.21149566769599915,
0.14177672564983368,
0.25701960921287537,
-1.1830614805221558,
-0.16784344613552094,
0.10159372538328171,
-0.5249943733215332,
0.733007550239563,
-0.315891832113266,
-0.48328110575675964,
-0.33057230710983276,
-0.4385419189929962,
0.214280366897583,
0.4633086323738098,
-0.7925951480865479,
0.43574655055999756,
0.33246201276779175,
-0.2787342369556427,
-0.35546964406967163,
-0.7898374199867249,
-0.08212212473154068,
-0.33003896474838257,
-0.5668953061103821,
0.5251822471618652,
-0.09498171508312225,
0.05600452795624733,
0.11081943660974503,
-0.7772343158721924,
-0.028819136321544647,
-0.07312808185815811,
0.28627943992614746,
-0.11709877848625183,
-0.6601248979568481,
-0.00955218356102705,
0.3909994065761566,
-0.2660035789012909,
-0.06694475561380386,
0.04548884928226471,
0.5856781005859375,
-0.34873518347740173,
-0.17238207161426544,
-0.6289842128753662,
0.1492518186569214,
0.38660928606987,
-0.15533970296382904,
0.3713415861129761,
0.4012778401374817,
-0.6931109428405762,
-0.1129877120256424,
-0.8679997324943542,
-0.24324849247932434,
-0.5043961405754089,
-0.11095519363880157,
-0.5385318398475647,
-0.841661810874939,
0.4373730421066284,
0.030290095135569572,
-0.30199286341667175,
0.6861984133720398,
0.27692463994026184,
-0.21129681169986725,
1.0429713726043701,
0.4149930477142334,
0.010107853449881077,
0.41353631019592285,
-0.47237783670425415,
-0.44793716073036194,
-0.8032968640327454,
-0.12789739668369293,
-0.5527673363685608,
-0.21240238845348358,
-0.40113478899002075,
-0.3815850019454956,
0.10442002862691879,
0.5598127245903015,
-0.43809205293655396,
0.2929622232913971,
-0.8123316764831543,
0.3581423759460449,
0.5012950301170349,
-0.08808059245347977,
0.4656226336956024,
0.23618397116661072,
0.035620152950286865,
0.09603702276945114,
-0.845859169960022,
-0.44608375430107117,
1.0582913160324097,
0.28216707706451416,
0.8221011757850647,
0.012380699627101421,
0.5182729959487915,
0.17377352714538574,
0.23252743482589722,
-0.5661537051200867,
0.31071627140045166,
-0.7754487991333008,
-0.6136600375175476,
-0.546042799949646,
-0.40460261702537537,
-0.8710789084434509,
0.2961634695529938,
-0.45166969299316406,
-0.7375130653381348,
0.7525376081466675,
0.3493582010269165,
-0.6296244263648987,
-0.29202011227607727,
-0.6977159976959229,
0.6523424983024597,
-0.08197957277297974,
-0.32556667923927307,
-0.16595256328582764,
-0.5595155954360962,
0.0044746981002390385,
-0.18657571077346802,
-0.18834735453128815,
-0.2423621118068695,
-0.05306418240070343,
0.8311037421226501,
-0.4482770562171936,
0.488202303647995,
-0.304668128490448,
0.2574513256549835,
0.4443218410015106,
-0.26927506923675537,
0.3053542673587799,
-0.1871524304151535,
-0.12196579575538635,
0.11125441640615463,
0.4263564646244049,
-0.1931796818971634,
-0.23590943217277527,
1.2163853645324707,
-0.7004122734069824,
-0.21337376534938812,
-0.3774046003818512,
-0.20310865342617035,
-0.6725305914878845,
0.2333979308605194,
0.3489195704460144,
0.6487228274345398,
-0.04581914097070694,
0.9085433483123779,
0.6919493079185486,
0.15625916421413422,
0.4942610263824463,
0.7242996692657471,
0.06712256371974945,
-0.3510896861553192,
0.7146623134613037,
0.5651695728302002,
0.18510493636131287,
-0.006009754724800587,
0.45080429315567017,
-0.48124825954437256,
-0.7249163389205933,
-0.3239249587059021,
0.019120266661047935,
-0.30813896656036377,
-0.3551984429359436,
-0.4737077057361603,
-0.3551574647426605,
-0.4894128143787384,
-0.11644405126571655,
-0.516770601272583,
-0.48129934072494507,
-0.26233088970184326,
-0.06517051160335541,
0.4250248074531555,
0.42655518651008606,
-0.18272270262241364,
0.5396665930747986,
-0.33796238899230957,
0.4950069487094879,
0.32966363430023193,
0.7357661724090576,
0.03976158797740936,
-0.5695455074310303,
0.17289483547210693,
0.16812413930892944,
-0.2644985616207123,
-0.4879470467567444,
0.044187992811203,
0.5737465023994446,
0.5610659718513489,
0.4742715656757355,
0.24807007610797882,
1.0094287395477295,
-0.46968337893486023,
0.5716702938079834,
0.14083367586135864,
-1.0160248279571533,
0.48193618655204773,
-0.4157252013683319,
-0.022078603506088257,
0.6477340459823608,
-0.024843186140060425,
-0.18353953957557678,
0.06054897606372833,
-0.7366501092910767,
-0.766972541809082,
0.7594872117042542,
0.20338402688503265,
0.08580271154642105,
0.1948036253452301,
0.25201305747032166,
0.10335057973861694,
0.24444334208965302,
-0.03896332532167435,
-0.31930971145629883,
-0.25011149048805237,
-0.3124082386493683,
-0.2193404734134674,
-0.2285875380039215,
0.035588379949331284,
-0.40178003907203674,
0.5885306000709534,
0.029054153710603714,
0.04524267464876175,
0.29488733410835266,
0.0630759447813034,
-0.5284469723701477,
0.002834091428667307,
0.37290260195732117,
0.2165440022945404,
-0.11369004845619202,
0.08185873180627823,
0.25020265579223633,
-0.4257113039493561,
0.1311933994293213,
0.7601749300956726,
-0.25046634674072266,
-0.20107832551002502,
0.5001018643379211,
0.8904700875282288,
0.545027494430542,
-0.7318228483200073,
0.5444924235343933,
-0.11319928616285324,
-0.37373679876327515,
-0.2542954683303833,
0.47546371817588806,
0.10553835332393646,
0.28348708152770996,
0.5609014630317688,
-0.04871537163853645,
0.3895379304885864,
-0.4490993320941925,
0.4697747528553009,
0.294721394777298,
-0.6724592447280884,
0.025738690048456192,
0.6621428728103638,
0.015435389243066311,
-0.3435622751712799,
0.4334165155887604,
0.29353591799736023,
-0.11997491866350174,
0.5565134286880493,
0.6635154485702515,
0.7338202595710754,
-0.42672207951545715,
-0.18669894337654114,
0.1046103909611702,
0.13406802713871002,
-0.1863473653793335,
0.22787977755069733,
-0.26603934168815613,
-0.534267008304596,
-0.34014081954956055,
-0.49473974108695984,
-0.267922967672348,
0.29663974046707153,
-0.9464070200920105,
0.07081570476293564,
-0.5733516812324524,
-0.3222934305667877,
0.3233124017715454,
0.3868968188762665,
-0.6709110140800476,
0.5210056900978088,
0.12675108015537262,
0.6772211194038391,
-0.6286217570304871,
0.6337287425994873,
0.5946105122566223,
0.02432381920516491,
-0.8496689200401306,
0.17360910773277283,
0.019914837554097176,
-0.3962714970111847,
0.1199549064040184,
0.17639636993408203,
-0.5703110694885254,
0.3581525683403015,
-0.5211113095283508,
-1.0693960189819336,
0.8445280194282532,
0.3439076542854309,
-0.9352595806121826,
0.3665103614330292,
0.007904206402599812,
0.6908726692199707,
-0.40621697902679443,
-0.40387165546417236,
0.8670161366462708,
0.16915841400623322,
0.14603570103645325,
-1.1223111152648926,
-0.27351945638656616,
-0.05482696369290352,
0.032843396067619324,
0.04597364738583565,
-0.579498827457428,
0.611553430557251,
0.013274886645376682,
-0.2992069721221924,
0.17784401774406433,
0.6045340299606323,
0.3272554278373718,
0.6456987261772156,
0.6990281939506531,
0.2767477333545685,
0.3425810933113098,
-0.38861408829689026,
0.666427493095398,
-0.34017106890678406,
0.5484453439712524,
1.173770785331726,
0.054004427045583725,
1.022602915763855,
0.3267096281051636,
-0.3229444622993469,
-0.10591951012611389,
0.5375560522079468,
-0.1497258096933365,
0.6696374416351318,
0.22121620178222656,
0.022312061861157417,
-0.08643531054258347,
-0.08343329280614853,
-0.3071284294128418,
0.3414041996002197,
0.6524242162704468,
-0.21865114569664001,
0.15063484013080597,
0.250526487827301,
-0.29154038429260254,
0.3215276598930359,
-0.5077750086784363,
0.8583194613456726,
0.14086785912513733,
-0.31535568833351135,
0.8857547640800476,
-0.01752036064863205,
0.754387617111206,
-0.2493773251771927,
0.12511388957500458,
-0.21694035828113556,
0.1587352603673935,
-0.3321305513381958,
-0.5753682851791382,
0.31916695833206177,
0.3064763844013214,
-0.353598028421402,
-0.01106862723827362,
0.8006334900856018,
-0.6217384338378906,
-0.5508425235748291,
0.11368104815483093,
0.05899038538336754,
0.002991306595504284,
0.055009663105010986,
-0.5633803606033325,
0.2541426122188568,
-0.3568224608898163,
-0.32979944348335266,
0.05931765213608742,
0.07631397992372513,
-0.11657392978668213,
0.7324010729789734,
0.6968967318534851,
0.05383932217955589,
0.2926980257034302,
0.18253108859062195,
0.779776394367218,
-0.28841453790664673,
-0.24804089963436127,
-0.560964047908783,
0.21829916536808014,
0.10646849870681763,
-0.4021553695201874,
0.5993016362190247,
0.671497642993927,
0.9708458781242371,
0.06383362412452698,
0.302026629447937,
0.13434676826000214,
1.0738356113433838,
-0.2933207154273987,
0.7936696410179138,
-0.36448556184768677,
0.05405699089169502,
-0.5643112063407898,
-0.8659070730209351,
-0.41097116470336914,
1.0496807098388672,
-0.2546280026435852,
0.02039303630590439,
0.14098143577575684,
0.6519609689712524,
-0.2221832126379013,
0.05338951200246811,
0.252639502286911,
0.14934515953063965,
0.10790175944566727,
0.17638713121414185,
0.7168246507644653,
-0.5770130753517151,
0.4520639479160309,
-0.6383825540542603,
-0.12790468335151672,
-0.24451588094234467,
-0.5675691366195679,
-0.7062822580337524,
-0.33128494024276733,
-0.49369657039642334,
0.07982219755649567,
0.4931139349937439,
0.9326804876327515,
1.0545623302459717,
-1.1377204656600952,
-0.06419456750154495,
-0.09496669471263885,
-0.33346569538116455,
-0.5193232297897339,
-0.17755642533302307,
0.6064655780792236,
0.301956444978714,
-0.6098066568374634,
0.8394455909729004,
-0.08435165882110596,
0.23405033349990845,
-0.08180015534162521,
-0.02340211160480976,
0.18163344264030457,
0.08568436652421951,
0.36547142267227173,
0.2621127963066101,
-0.7522035837173462,
-0.4467242360115051,
-0.22478552162647247,
0.0003049451916012913,
-0.05182642489671707,
0.4933840334415436,
-0.9596624970436096,
0.5470437407493591,
0.1878247708082199,
0.4809437096118927,
0.8598800301551819,
0.46365708112716675,
0.39188143610954285,
-0.676950991153717,
-0.11257900297641754,
0.4120039939880371,
0.03297656401991844,
0.6333181262016296,
-0.02928675152361393,
0.5611709952354431,
0.041010644286870956,
-0.3974634110927582,
-1.0799812078475952,
-0.22064773738384247,
-0.6855434775352478,
0.17729924619197845,
0.8426602482795715,
-0.002435480011627078,
0.3827248513698578,
0.09218468517065048,
-0.05232980102300644,
0.23641151189804077,
-0.4114634096622467,
0.4026661813259125,
0.42959216237068176,
-0.3340710997581482,
-0.2368263453245163,
-0.24810479581356049,
0.6330862045288086,
0.1922825425863266,
-0.18851248919963837,
0.1408967673778534,
0.5806446671485901,
0.5665019154548645,
-0.07552492618560791,
0.5611839294433594,
-0.07817879319190979,
0.25099197030067444,
0.12285621464252472,
-0.39800217747688293,
-0.1851956695318222,
-0.5447067022323608,
-0.7893864512443542,
0.13823038339614868,
-0.026936063542962074,
-0.22637638449668884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10505v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10505v1
|
CroPrompt: Cross-task Interactive Prompting for Zero-shot Spoken Language Understanding
| 2024-06-15T04:54:56 | 2024-06-15T04:54:56 |
Libo Qin, Fuxuan Wei, Qiguang Chen, Jingxuan Zhou, Shijue Huang, Jiasheng Si, Wenpeng Lu, Wanxiang Che
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Slot filling and intent detection are two highly correlated tasks in spoken
language understanding (SLU). Recent SLU research attempts to explore zero-shot
prompting techniques in large language models to alleviate the data scarcity
problem. Nevertheless, the existing prompting work ignores the cross-task
interaction information for SLU, which leads to sub-optimal performance. To
solve this problem, we present the pioneering work of Cross-task Interactive
Prompting (CroPrompt) for SLU, which enables the model to interactively
leverage the information exchange across the correlated tasks in SLU.
Additionally, we further introduce a multi-task self-consistency mechanism to
mitigate the error propagation caused by the intent information injection. We
conduct extensive experiments on the standard SLU benchmark and the results
reveal that CroPrompt consistently outperforms the existing prompting
approaches. In addition, the multi-task self-consistency mechanism can
effectively ease the error propagation issue, thereby enhancing the
performance. We hope this work can inspire more research on cross-task
prompting for SLU.
|
[
-0.21011948585510254,
-0.9988943934440613,
0.7462311387062073,
0.4672185480594635,
0.1126154437661171,
-0.008344852365553379,
-0.5162176489830017,
-0.35662493109703064,
0.18004924058914185,
0.21713289618492126,
-0.749732494354248,
-0.32091522216796875,
-0.4443415403366089,
-0.11471313238143921,
-0.370437353849411,
0.7086536884307861,
-0.10636204481124878,
0.09044311940670013,
-0.3951032757759094,
-0.23977398872375488,
-0.9104575514793396,
-0.14595097303390503,
-0.7434724569320679,
-0.43203046917915344,
0.672458827495575,
0.9845873117446899,
0.47820809483528137,
0.327161967754364,
-0.07666831463575363,
0.21963714063167572,
0.16855904459953308,
0.030590729787945747,
-0.3702888488769531,
0.6581428050994873,
-0.22780846059322357,
-0.40359658002853394,
-0.3437901735305786,
-0.039101652801036835,
0.6575994491577148,
0.5687887072563171,
-0.0918983444571495,
0.1622297614812851,
0.35501575469970703,
0.3004346787929535,
-0.8441839218139648,
0.17276015877723694,
-0.5545276999473572,
0.19760586321353912,
-0.16155359148979187,
-0.39374440908432007,
-0.8028786778450012,
0.17348036170005798,
-0.12902472913265228,
-0.8599353432655334,
0.3092705011367798,
-0.10276933759450912,
0.7018743753433228,
0.34192538261413574,
0.14859646558761597,
-0.06066897511482239,
-0.784670352935791,
0.8074465990066528,
-0.5333324670791626,
0.298783540725708,
0.650820791721344,
0.24351570010185242,
-0.04151039198040962,
-0.3447716236114502,
-0.7476986646652222,
-0.13340112566947937,
0.05704653635621071,
0.3880990743637085,
-0.432634174823761,
0.06546366214752197,
0.19464118778705597,
0.0075512356124818325,
-0.7163598537445068,
0.26521846652030945,
-0.04683948680758476,
-0.2932922840118408,
0.10273264348506927,
-0.05645179748535156,
0.4630192816257477,
-0.11266874521970749,
-0.3927156329154968,
-0.2308986932039261,
-0.4424492120742798,
0.12555193901062012,
0.07628770917654037,
0.4719240963459015,
-0.12452422827482224,
0.6985329389572144,
-0.16266322135925293,
1.0588268041610718,
0.18380539119243622,
0.35844528675079346,
0.11295568943023682,
-0.43854379653930664,
-0.5173590779304504,
0.18622611463069916,
0.830402135848999,
0.20663219690322876,
0.21242506802082062,
0.20880389213562012,
0.1754516065120697,
-0.20212070643901825,
0.08265215903520584,
-0.3142622411251068,
0.0108043747022748,
0.5952981114387512,
-0.04171692952513695,
-0.06423069536685944,
-0.28413712978363037,
-0.6878960728645325,
-0.22066357731819153,
-0.18651339411735535,
0.5615759491920471,
-0.7867297530174255,
-0.2099589854478836,
-0.07909423857927322,
-0.2092646062374115,
0.4188844561576843,
0.48139336705207825,
-0.9614179730415344,
0.10847432911396027,
0.7954651713371277,
0.9322581887245178,
-0.24379734694957733,
-0.7594034671783447,
-0.8231093287467957,
0.42143452167510986,
0.08072522282600403,
0.8928447365760803,
-0.481097936630249,
-0.2354055643081665,
-0.11425568908452988,
-0.08037624508142471,
-0.6118730306625366,
-0.05461074039340019,
0.378248929977417,
-0.0958104282617569,
0.3304973244667053,
-0.40570753812789917,
-0.5466017127037048,
-0.23058830201625824,
0.4143106937408447,
-0.4290042519569397,
1.011783480644226,
0.14383867383003235,
-0.678542971611023,
0.6406156420707703,
-0.8163160681724548,
-0.36640632152557373,
0.5069589614868164,
-0.3660244643688202,
-0.27640944719314575,
-0.03243188187479973,
0.45218995213508606,
0.2696039378643036,
0.26944243907928467,
0.1737714409828186,
-0.30442702770233154,
-0.17948874831199646,
0.1309373378753662,
-0.5121482610702515,
0.5093628168106079,
0.07104881852865219,
-0.3367306888103485,
0.39016780257225037,
-0.10844439268112183,
0.26153331995010376,
0.15713587403297424,
0.1692207008600235,
-0.2954419255256653,
-0.355235755443573,
0.14329475164413452,
-0.17002224922180176,
0.2203492671251297,
-0.7098451256752014,
0.15116119384765625,
0.09406586736440659,
0.36950191855430603,
0.4947257339954376,
-0.17498815059661865,
0.5698030591011047,
-0.2751009166240692,
0.827743411064148,
-0.1424212008714676,
0.30215582251548767,
-0.6159773468971252,
-0.6860696077346802,
-0.44048792123794556,
-0.3006565272808075,
0.31392934918403625,
0.7621414661407471,
-0.688969075679779,
0.07566340267658234,
0.01908094249665737,
-0.2082286924123764,
-0.6030879616737366,
0.003139117732644081,
0.5137451887130737,
0.5663334131240845,
0.30933502316474915,
-0.1599111258983612,
-0.40707412362098694,
-0.4873502254486084,
-0.471845418214798,
0.15573522448539734,
0.1800985187292099,
0.622103750705719,
-0.23730236291885376,
0.01777639612555504,
1.1455819606781006,
-0.3789117634296417,
-0.5482451915740967,
-0.7645674347877502,
0.38676610589027405,
0.2848215401172638,
0.6191946864128113,
0.5901334881782532,
-0.4390452802181244,
-0.7818278074264526,
0.07880382984876633,
-0.46606701612472534,
-0.2927229106426239,
-0.12171024829149246,
0.11096777021884918,
0.27488330006599426,
0.43556860089302063,
-0.6528201103210449,
0.572382926940918,
0.7803786396980286,
-0.17260271310806274,
0.42430007457733154,
-0.4710372984409332,
0.4065448045730591,
-0.7928343415260315,
0.0907464250922203,
-0.08012247830629349,
-0.5170043706893921,
-0.890866756439209,
-0.2362685352563858,
0.15519334375858307,
-0.30589377880096436,
-0.5900413990020752,
0.45071718096733093,
-0.4694376587867737,
-0.17023102939128876,
-0.3941490352153778,
0.31738921999931335,
0.13386517763137817,
0.35353192687034607,
-0.03652135282754898,
1.1083651781082153,
0.6518100500106812,
-0.35713884234428406,
0.0016386028146371245,
0.3733331859111786,
0.0973096489906311,
0.6588744521141052,
-0.48806020617485046,
0.11857623606920242,
-0.19556915760040283,
0.2652663290500641,
-1.2801861763000488,
-0.3570108115673065,
0.5053150653839111,
-0.5852328538894653,
0.46469199657440186,
-0.4886210858821869,
-0.13941195607185364,
-0.1831265687942505,
-0.03346046432852745,
0.6788707971572876,
0.23908577859401703,
-0.36828893423080444,
0.505827784538269,
0.24801850318908691,
-0.4337550401687622,
-0.6475538611412048,
-0.6730949878692627,
0.08867450803518295,
0.03260863199830055,
-0.39184045791625977,
0.07137766480445862,
0.12618035078048706,
0.22921328246593475,
-0.13149294257164001,
-0.009948461316525936,
-0.03360667824745178,
-0.41411474347114563,
0.3533777892589569,
0.15522627532482147,
-0.14860215783119202,
0.09040192514657974,
0.168972909450531,
-0.17436175048351288,
-0.3372596204280853,
-0.42760008573532104,
0.9624698162078857,
0.1745912730693817,
-0.6186656951904297,
-0.9483089447021484,
0.34482961893081665,
0.34648460149765015,
-0.11483579874038696,
0.3518287241458893,
0.5945528149604797,
0.07690482586622238,
-0.022268855944275856,
-0.5930293202400208,
-0.17543897032737732,
-0.43689286708831787,
-0.05270621180534363,
-0.2790597975254059,
-0.792148768901825,
0.3454112708568573,
0.12953145802021027,
0.09682852029800415,
0.1566224843263626,
0.3362228572368622,
-0.27403345704078674,
0.8014174103736877,
0.5548514127731323,
-0.01980661042034626,
0.9145233035087585,
-0.19069784879684448,
-0.2048652619123459,
-0.8866987824440002,
-0.04502669721841812,
-0.43090397119522095,
-0.25022655725479126,
0.09913098812103271,
-0.9041333198547363,
0.28380075097084045,
-0.23960736393928528,
0.3451012670993805,
0.6276590824127197,
-0.5584540963172913,
0.44354477524757385,
0.7005351185798645,
0.04660162329673767,
0.20341847836971283,
0.1042986512184143,
-0.2814023196697235,
-0.10979676991701126,
-0.949652910232544,
0.022862287238240242,
0.5823991894721985,
0.14852984249591827,
0.7729777097702026,
-0.4354774057865143,
0.7432992458343506,
0.31845778226852417,
-0.066084124147892,
-0.8582013845443726,
0.5204179286956787,
0.042757485061883926,
-0.3340746760368347,
-0.8043487668037415,
-0.21979717910289764,
-1.4234579801559448,
0.15909230709075928,
-0.02021717093884945,
-0.9914265871047974,
0.28362879157066345,
0.7914343476295471,
-0.45109862089157104,
0.07175567001104355,
-0.8967471122741699,
0.9934068918228149,
-0.12034790217876434,
-0.41368380188941956,
-0.28465956449508667,
-0.5398334860801697,
0.18564267456531525,
0.26915639638900757,
0.27053067088127136,
-0.3626188337802887,
0.2900979518890381,
0.47827044129371643,
-0.12035886198282242,
0.9473460912704468,
-0.5113977193832397,
-0.01436645071953535,
0.14560383558273315,
0.21086016297340393,
0.5626214146614075,
-0.03227698802947998,
-0.14799834787845612,
0.0803624615073204,
0.02461347170174122,
-0.42307138442993164,
-0.5120787024497986,
0.7608089447021484,
-0.36455047130584717,
-0.5440158843994141,
-0.3943174481391907,
-1.0167078971862793,
-0.08923345804214478,
0.2835111618041992,
0.26527684926986694,
0.2734152674674988,
-0.038942936807870865,
-0.19611084461212158,
0.5478062629699707,
-0.2664510905742645,
0.5535809993743896,
0.45286616683006287,
-0.3313477039337158,
-0.35152608156204224,
0.9420272707939148,
-0.08389563858509064,
0.5262243747711182,
0.2765692174434662,
0.34192386269569397,
-0.25725534558296204,
-0.2839120626449585,
-0.8293300271034241,
0.0831139087677002,
-0.35783278942108154,
-0.18449245393276215,
-0.7316964864730835,
-0.1755373179912567,
-0.597594678401947,
-0.12658905982971191,
-0.34603896737098694,
-0.49042171239852905,
-0.19300995767116547,
0.18635408580303192,
0.5902782678604126,
0.5989213585853577,
-0.28868311643600464,
0.62401282787323,
-0.8159828782081604,
0.2760775685310364,
0.07575145363807678,
0.2757978141307831,
-0.01983095519244671,
-0.37242966890335083,
-0.017226027324795723,
0.21679174900054932,
-0.2541773319244385,
-1.0086129903793335,
0.2645794749259949,
0.24760401248931885,
0.6852444410324097,
0.5313697457313538,
-0.06502927839756012,
0.919951319694519,
-0.5665087699890137,
0.6332105398178101,
0.34805119037628174,
-1.240592360496521,
0.8232004642486572,
-0.3392799198627472,
0.8326485753059387,
0.6952932476997375,
0.09753097593784332,
-0.8685790300369263,
-0.7919459342956543,
-0.6427870392799377,
-0.8040590286254883,
1.113887906074524,
0.2781166732311249,
-0.10004938393831253,
0.25882968306541443,
-0.04611336067318916,
0.3578907251358032,
0.03745832294225693,
-0.5764069557189941,
-0.032492246478796005,
-0.3195164203643799,
-0.20999744534492493,
-0.013038890436291695,
-0.10323310643434525,
-0.12941503524780273,
-0.20999972522258759,
0.4453977048397064,
-0.23258252441883087,
0.2826244533061981,
0.5931568145751953,
-0.25584205985069275,
-0.39831653237342834,
0.5086442828178406,
0.8948678970336914,
0.6639764904975891,
-0.007399748079478741,
0.09842444211244583,
0.13548007607460022,
-0.7074036598205566,
0.01678358018398285,
0.20647308230400085,
-0.3466436564922333,
0.05564342066645622,
0.1655673086643219,
0.8203301429748535,
0.3355046808719635,
-0.39373356103897095,
0.5865886807441711,
-0.05816324055194855,
-0.1675463318824768,
-0.11951255798339844,
0.05726054310798645,
-0.2628757059574127,
-0.042498912662267685,
0.47866010665893555,
-0.06475493311882019,
0.020558204501867294,
-0.3917253315448761,
0.3485696613788605,
0.5637938976287842,
-0.6929110884666443,
-0.01644890569150448,
0.54951012134552,
0.041256796568632126,
-0.3953295946121216,
0.518174946308136,
-0.13518574833869934,
-0.5702749490737915,
0.3566485345363617,
0.47801673412323,
0.6907119154930115,
-0.36399415135383606,
0.6715906858444214,
0.16422726213932037,
0.15563981235027313,
0.21268229186534882,
0.6477422714233398,
-0.6168885231018066,
-0.5964640974998474,
-0.7753825187683105,
-0.22595880925655365,
-0.7187404036521912,
0.03134683519601822,
-0.6297689080238342,
0.08818422257900238,
-0.18706999719142914,
-0.16364479064941406,
0.24180345237255096,
-0.44744524359703064,
-0.45063453912734985,
-0.08741188049316406,
-0.0026949106249958277,
0.9040293097496033,
-0.8452703356742859,
0.9498333930969238,
0.5908895134925842,
-0.18903963267803192,
-0.868403434753418,
0.1229647845029831,
-0.02138199843466282,
-1.2465038299560547,
0.2607455551624298,
0.3027048110961914,
0.022412072867155075,
0.1878199428319931,
-0.5370851755142212,
-0.7557087540626526,
0.798128604888916,
0.07697640359401703,
-0.561537504196167,
0.3443686366081238,
0.1835934966802597,
0.0769922211766243,
-0.15464691817760468,
0.37085217237472534,
0.35380399227142334,
0.8631871938705444,
0.5909616351127625,
-1.0422122478485107,
0.28341710567474365,
0.29085081815719604,
-0.3186645805835724,
0.30563098192214966,
-0.3894384801387787,
0.4786100685596466,
-0.39592593908309937,
-0.3353056013584137,
0.029886802658438683,
0.6358330845832825,
0.40889298915863037,
0.7358576059341431,
0.8518040776252747,
0.33356595039367676,
0.5552427768707275,
-0.10155341774225235,
0.6010077595710754,
-0.3124532699584961,
0.283054381608963,
1.367156982421875,
-0.5701556205749512,
0.8259672522544861,
0.789713978767395,
-0.05064934492111206,
0.3145003616809845,
0.43524324893951416,
-0.12043866515159607,
0.24673247337341309,
-0.23287899792194366,
-0.18262416124343872,
-0.2872314155101776,
-0.33759790658950806,
-0.11902584135532379,
0.5045093297958374,
0.4840138256549835,
-0.02246960438787937,
-0.42530226707458496,
0.444428950548172,
-0.007815633900463581,
-0.10435465723276138,
-0.027581168338656425,
0.8301796317100525,
-0.04239911586046219,
-1.0832061767578125,
0.3780917227268219,
-0.4259854853153229,
0.32904052734375,
-0.6167764067649841,
-0.18199759721755981,
-0.03791680932044983,
-0.042485982179641724,
-0.18422354757785797,
-1.3133419752120972,
0.2147301882505417,
-0.36329126358032227,
-0.015587358735501766,
-0.5929516553878784,
0.7381666898727417,
-0.7845525145530701,
-0.0962907001376152,
0.23220455646514893,
0.47170791029930115,
0.342746376991272,
-0.10137844830751419,
-0.712613046169281,
0.31237494945526123,
-0.02826688066124916,
0.19960281252861023,
0.18569137156009674,
0.3062121570110321,
0.02571280300617218,
0.5384316444396973,
0.8527969717979431,
0.15703415870666504,
0.06648190319538116,
0.5132676362991333,
0.5108433961868286,
-0.5009464621543884,
-0.5553610324859619,
-0.7368068695068359,
0.31751906871795654,
-0.3937889337539673,
0.05510960891842842,
1.0097004175186157,
0.4974992871284485,
0.5744206309318542,
-0.18318286538124084,
0.7179586291313171,
-0.30980801582336426,
0.4296225607395172,
-0.3331963121891022,
0.7035549879074097,
-0.37140971422195435,
-0.1366889476776123,
-0.2220529019832611,
-0.520447850227356,
-0.205170139670372,
0.24186545610427856,
-0.31727463006973267,
-0.1178111582994461,
0.674833357334137,
0.5904914140701294,
-0.27440953254699707,
0.025468764826655388,
0.6244766712188721,
0.13457249104976654,
-0.017219673842191696,
0.3836432993412018,
0.7977944612503052,
-0.055103812366724014,
0.5916311740875244,
-0.11446395516395569,
-0.4759458303451538,
-0.4330565631389618,
-0.7591022253036499,
-0.6884181499481201,
-0.4910862147808075,
-0.2942248284816742,
-0.2644330561161041,
0.10935138911008835,
0.6132866740226746,
0.9323680400848389,
-0.8040681481361389,
-0.3729533553123474,
-0.34303489327430725,
0.43205225467681885,
-0.5957356095314026,
-0.26430535316467285,
0.06279483437538147,
-0.6335129141807556,
-0.811840295791626,
0.5835845470428467,
0.5472733378410339,
0.24791641533374786,
-0.20104607939720154,
0.09669260680675507,
-0.38280853629112244,
-0.013135488145053387,
0.3800111413002014,
0.7940424680709839,
-0.7528524398803711,
-0.12835288047790527,
-0.09481508284807205,
0.1692831963300705,
0.17662392556667328,
1.116748332977295,
-0.7485458254814148,
0.5215963125228882,
0.6576066613197327,
0.35930871963500977,
0.6858017444610596,
0.12637728452682495,
0.9616529941558838,
-0.9873847365379333,
0.2361103594303131,
0.05596938356757164,
0.27423331141471863,
0.32320764660835266,
-0.6799318194389343,
0.17213481664657593,
-0.045154668390750885,
-0.6679500937461853,
-0.696293830871582,
0.37707069516181946,
-1.3594857454299927,
-0.12224848568439484,
1.1143147945404053,
-0.1259663850069046,
-0.3897974193096161,
-0.22522790729999542,
-0.4251568615436554,
0.26229608058929443,
-0.7009589672088623,
0.29897716641426086,
0.3670327961444855,
-0.3768913745880127,
-0.6266247630119324,
-0.4651491641998291,
0.5182225704193115,
0.9040683507919312,
-0.7485288381576538,
0.3595253825187683,
0.10987811535596848,
0.1783749908208847,
0.11554970592260361,
0.7316526770591736,
0.2913152575492859,
0.5269694328308105,
-0.23125572502613068,
0.20415931940078735,
-0.11625072360038757,
-0.38307416439056396,
-0.3411376476287842,
-0.09779318422079086,
-0.1237434595823288,
-0.6386746168136597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10504v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10504v1
|
Task Facet Learning: A Structured Approach to Prompt Optimization
| 2024-06-15T04:54:26 | 2024-06-15T04:54:26 |
Gurusha Juneja, Nagarajan Natarajan, Hua Li, Jian Jiao, Amit Sharma
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Given a task in the form of a basic description and its training examples,
prompt optimization is the problem of synthesizing the given information into a
text prompt for a large language model (LLM). Humans solve this problem by also
considering the different facets that define a task (e.g., counter-examples,
explanations, analogies) and including them in the prompt. However, it is
unclear whether existing algorithmic approaches, based on iteratively editing a
given prompt or automatically selecting a few in-context examples, can cover
the multiple facets required to solve a complex task. In this work, we view
prompt optimization as that of learning multiple facets of a task from a set of
training examples. We identify and exploit structure in the prompt optimization
problem -- first, we find that prompts can be broken down into loosely coupled
semantic sections that have a relatively independent effect on the prompt's
performance; second, we cluster the input space and use clustered batches so
that the optimization procedure can learn the different facets of a task across
batches. The resulting algorithm, UniPrompt, consists of a generative model to
generate initial candidates for each prompt section; and a feedback mechanism
that aggregates suggested edits from multiple mini-batches into a conceptual
description for the section. Empirical evaluation on multiple datasets and a
real-world task shows that prompts generated using UniPrompt obtain higher
accuracy than human-tuned prompts and those from state-of-the-art methods. In
particular, our algorithm can generate long, complex prompts that existing
methods are unable to generate. Code for UniPrompt will be available at
\url{https://aka.ms/uniprompt}.
|
[
-0.2682066857814789,
-0.8211320042610168,
0.6674522757530212,
0.5659545063972473,
-0.31732115149497986,
0.1001666933298111,
-0.38672158122062683,
0.2005946934223175,
-0.1857168972492218,
0.27244237065315247,
-1.1806994676589966,
-0.4556311368942261,
-0.15753430128097534,
0.22941336035728455,
0.21767908334732056,
1.1323555707931519,
0.06712374091148376,
0.23798944056034088,
-0.3591446876525879,
0.02354963682591915,
-0.8917855620384216,
-0.3182593882083893,
-0.9205281138420105,
-0.38813143968582153,
0.568176805973053,
0.4597293734550476,
0.05555358901619911,
0.5622393488883972,
0.13760414719581604,
0.29053282737731934,
-0.14358077943325043,
0.10938515514135361,
-0.24059581756591797,
0.5146907567977905,
-0.15354864299297333,
-0.4252261221408844,
0.11212760955095291,
0.07420080155134201,
0.5381441116333008,
1.0508699417114258,
0.11680975556373596,
0.07791610807180405,
0.36778879165649414,
0.8348852396011353,
-0.4754805564880371,
0.37155479192733765,
-0.378696084022522,
0.11379863321781158,
-0.015996377915143967,
-0.41478461027145386,
-0.4072568714618683,
-0.11533207446336746,
0.1032903864979744,
-0.6548617482185364,
0.40328338742256165,
0.16870500147342682,
0.17270970344543457,
0.42876893281936646,
-0.3383650481700897,
-0.35714277625083923,
-0.4352346658706665,
0.8080084323883057,
-0.1781248152256012,
0.02507624216377735,
0.04198945686221123,
0.25276637077331543,
-0.48759695887565613,
-0.5562794208526611,
-0.3339708745479584,
-0.16315047442913055,
0.11070432513952255,
0.3839486837387085,
-0.18694603443145752,
0.32352200150489807,
0.4760321080684662,
0.03781038895249367,
-0.63823401927948,
0.09601003676652908,
-0.16668277978897095,
-0.19444583356380463,
0.13736844062805176,
0.24054503440856934,
0.386127769947052,
-0.4711120128631592,
-0.6137938499450684,
-0.15487666428089142,
-0.6113288402557373,
0.6721909642219543,
0.17794914543628693,
0.7378986477851868,
0.05087186023592949,
0.4433349370956421,
-0.1248013973236084,
0.7054961323738098,
0.23166273534297943,
-0.09652374684810638,
0.0917736142873764,
-0.2214055061340332,
0.013577193953096867,
-0.057220589369535446,
0.6431972980499268,
0.33555281162261963,
0.09775024652481079,
-0.09396865963935852,
-0.3512282073497772,
0.012028437107801437,
0.3093585669994354,
-0.7589938640594482,
-0.15999843180179596,
0.37380653619766235,
-0.37970060110092163,
-0.3364664912223816,
-0.21312594413757324,
-0.6875352263450623,
-0.4685330092906952,
-0.6407510042190552,
0.48558738827705383,
-0.3847520649433136,
0.4111553430557251,
-0.2106131762266159,
-0.22420792281627655,
-0.05755308270454407,
0.555217444896698,
-0.735568642616272,
0.09577303379774094,
0.6205995678901672,
0.8605948686599731,
-0.1907852441072464,
-0.5163902044296265,
-0.9467977285385132,
-0.24679338932037354,
-0.2510988712310791,
0.9511578679084778,
-0.573062002658844,
-0.40472960472106934,
0.01375759020447731,
-0.04088478535413742,
-0.3657373785972595,
-0.2731749713420868,
0.45763739943504333,
-0.37207671999931335,
0.45281627774238586,
-0.5726625323295593,
-0.33189210295677185,
-0.14140288531780243,
0.09183188527822495,
-0.6943183541297913,
1.0675932168960571,
0.23383888602256775,
-0.6983619332313538,
0.4360682964324951,
-0.8679313659667969,
-0.4639706611633301,
0.17273302376270294,
-0.2320532649755478,
-0.3337114751338959,
0.30015262961387634,
0.3997392952442169,
0.5005727410316467,
-0.4893086552619934,
0.32710111141204834,
0.30379602313041687,
-0.2235742211341858,
-0.05278543755412102,
-0.058620940893888474,
0.9892039895057678,
0.1612229198217392,
-0.4545742869377136,
0.5754846930503845,
-0.4782434403896332,
-0.17306005954742432,
-0.05088005214929581,
-0.5133578777313232,
-0.1674962341785431,
0.007366838399320841,
0.010430705733597279,
0.07112535089254379,
0.16273631155490875,
-0.6290481686592102,
0.4242273271083832,
-0.3207666873931885,
0.48403552174568176,
0.7937053442001343,
0.12272349745035172,
0.4026035666465759,
-0.14512549340724945,
0.6561204791069031,
0.012033513747155666,
0.16470730304718018,
-0.5866116881370544,
-0.4651322364807129,
-0.41383159160614014,
-0.3888508379459381,
0.08650843799114227,
0.7574155330657959,
-1.011199712753296,
0.34298112988471985,
0.21274694800376892,
-0.24567550420761108,
-0.0811239629983902,
0.08302578330039978,
0.5990082621574402,
0.9449204802513123,
0.2183789163827896,
-0.14102201163768768,
-0.34526562690734863,
-0.6512693166732788,
-0.4570719301700592,
-0.038404643535614014,
-0.07105425000190735,
0.2650444805622101,
0.4549793303012848,
-0.020045708864927292,
1.0763349533081055,
-0.5061497688293457,
-0.27410998940467834,
-0.5005308985710144,
0.3879774510860443,
0.45263293385505676,
0.5363399386405945,
0.4542996287345886,
-0.7361324429512024,
-0.6128722429275513,
-0.16591505706310272,
-0.5348455905914307,
-0.3389814496040344,
-0.522526741027832,
0.13725091516971588,
-0.13069379329681396,
0.40947631001472473,
-0.7457869052886963,
0.25103652477264404,
0.027133556082844734,
-0.16855430603027344,
0.7125053405761719,
-0.29069414734840393,
0.01768171228468418,
-1.0548166036605835,
-0.019281448796391487,
0.03969338908791542,
-0.09215550869703293,
-0.6146979331970215,
0.0008468730957247317,
0.0973297730088234,
-0.5823526978492737,
-0.2279060184955597,
0.6486191153526306,
-0.5936437845230103,
-0.043742191046476364,
-0.2979343831539154,
0.10941722989082336,
-0.024665672332048416,
1.0937933921813965,
-0.17461200058460236,
1.0923084020614624,
0.6703983545303345,
-0.38462528586387634,
0.468985915184021,
0.3959372341632843,
-0.06597112864255905,
0.8258107900619507,
-0.7278429865837097,
0.1821698099374771,
-0.5161978006362915,
0.24106894433498383,
-1.2418015003204346,
-0.1758691370487213,
0.032322172075510025,
-0.4257388114929199,
0.2207190841436386,
-0.1270112246274948,
-0.395357608795166,
-0.29804497957229614,
-0.49648380279541016,
0.37088584899902344,
0.5306060314178467,
-0.6756023168563843,
0.593225359916687,
0.01742815226316452,
-0.3360925614833832,
-0.5280919671058655,
-0.07323316484689713,
-0.12170253694057465,
-0.2096029669046402,
-0.2609383165836334,
0.3230849504470825,
-0.05867340788245201,
0.11170373111963272,
-0.3145991861820221,
-0.19223731756210327,
0.18018236756324768,
0.132648304104805,
0.40851977467536926,
0.026583047583699226,
0.13981780409812927,
0.21805332601070404,
0.27657055854797363,
-0.28739288449287415,
0.07027429342269897,
-0.5323463678359985,
0.5777353644371033,
-0.07991040498018265,
-0.20757034420967102,
-0.5215164422988892,
0.5888160467147827,
0.28862759470939636,
-0.1040370836853981,
0.39094477891921997,
0.5169109106063843,
-0.46714773774147034,
-0.5283991694450378,
-0.31335026025772095,
-0.18715450167655945,
-0.48251309990882874,
0.3137577176094055,
-0.5091443061828613,
-0.7536097764968872,
0.6403478980064392,
-0.4826878607273102,
0.173700749874115,
0.3130094110965729,
0.49950653314590454,
-0.12791861593723297,
0.9934113025665283,
0.7424813508987427,
0.15063083171844482,
0.6680713891983032,
-0.0611538402736187,
-0.05211389437317848,
-1.0055313110351562,
-0.4804188311100006,
-0.6197436451911926,
-0.25002023577690125,
-0.4450126588344574,
-0.4377855956554413,
0.6688347458839417,
0.34935271739959717,
-0.4028438627719879,
0.47666311264038086,
-0.7203387022018433,
0.4952261447906494,
1.0680900812149048,
0.22795923054218292,
-0.08382520824670792,
0.12436389923095703,
-0.49158450961112976,
-0.1508074849843979,
-0.7449566125869751,
-0.32798609137535095,
0.7974933981895447,
0.03340695798397064,
0.49113929271698,
-0.37018081545829773,
0.5839438438415527,
0.34771087765693665,
-0.14356087148189545,
-0.8058127164840698,
0.4824586808681488,
-0.20196448266506195,
-0.0535467304289341,
-0.3259391188621521,
-0.4086524248123169,
-1.1010546684265137,
0.13821475207805634,
0.07337561994791031,
-0.8425682783126831,
0.17800763249397278,
0.2973322570323944,
-0.4621485769748688,
0.004617701284587383,
-0.6861299872398376,
1.0650683641433716,
-0.23550890386104584,
-0.13423268496990204,
0.09550968557596207,
-1.0205165147781372,
-0.20882810652256012,
-0.06779709458351135,
-0.09025543928146362,
0.11031972616910934,
0.04340488091111183,
0.8585972785949707,
-0.28818753361701965,
1.1121858358383179,
-0.44965118169784546,
0.33533039689064026,
0.20639009773731232,
0.004231604747474194,
0.5619316697120667,
-0.047671735286712646,
0.14123404026031494,
-0.24619168043136597,
-0.11442619562149048,
-0.5178880095481873,
-0.8348549604415894,
0.32184457778930664,
-0.7848153710365295,
-0.43363726139068604,
-0.1584751456975937,
-0.4742067754268646,
-0.36265334486961365,
0.2994491159915924,
0.4620248079299927,
0.8292346596717834,
-0.09183350950479507,
-0.05857335031032562,
0.6919515132904053,
-0.3813503384590149,
0.6141586303710938,
-0.0045844330452382565,
0.21378834545612335,
-0.5179627537727356,
0.7520968914031982,
-0.2823519706726074,
0.01396916527301073,
0.6705574989318848,
0.4787621796131134,
-0.23412799835205078,
-0.5709147453308105,
-0.5204198956489563,
0.058625657111406326,
-0.8162782788276672,
-0.30734801292419434,
-0.6542373895645142,
0.16058161854743958,
-0.2968413531780243,
-0.3524729311466217,
-0.19369624555110931,
-0.40675216913223267,
-0.4452376067638397,
0.16413407027721405,
0.3033119738101959,
0.5808504819869995,
0.05307117849588394,
0.8053869605064392,
-0.5332284569740295,
0.2460881918668747,
0.36220985651016235,
-0.006682550068944693,
-0.14456553757190704,
-0.08479547500610352,
0.015534887090325356,
-0.07245516777038574,
-0.3283424377441406,
-0.9920520186424255,
0.33278408646583557,
0.11966681480407715,
0.7688942551612854,
0.2974763810634613,
0.04819656163454056,
0.4240522086620331,
-0.7889468669891357,
0.7895992398262024,
0.3544705808162689,
-0.9887969493865967,
0.9281795620918274,
-0.4786226451396942,
0.5636329054832458,
0.8180345296859741,
0.4306977093219757,
-0.6173648238182068,
0.01963280513882637,
-0.30830782651901245,
-0.8326126337051392,
0.7150928378105164,
0.08285171538591385,
0.013982215896248817,
0.0006869533099234104,
0.6782495379447937,
0.22595933079719543,
0.734845757484436,
-0.49119317531585693,
-0.12458591163158417,
-0.22065839171409607,
-0.32820531725883484,
0.08360468596220016,
-0.2551128566265106,
-0.2154296636581421,
-0.10668542981147766,
0.25320881605148315,
-0.5112602710723877,
0.5481075048446655,
0.2019387185573578,
-0.21580685675144196,
-0.06537475436925888,
0.09982278943061829,
0.639673113822937,
0.5871694087982178,
-0.006991795264184475,
0.10510656237602234,
-0.10501561313867569,
-0.5489010214805603,
-0.07243511825799942,
0.021946216002106667,
-0.13935978710651398,
-0.1845645308494568,
0.5441121459007263,
1.119423747062683,
0.061429981142282486,
-0.5965599417686462,
0.7266707420349121,
0.1195157915353775,
0.0067380135878920555,
-0.12831959128379822,
0.020723974332213402,
-0.3704080581665039,
0.46833768486976624,
0.5946518182754517,
0.1498269885778427,
0.16276982426643372,
-0.5374784469604492,
0.2495989054441452,
0.6137323379516602,
-0.4367242157459259,
-0.4598858058452606,
0.7495210766792297,
0.3808058202266693,
-0.6845427751541138,
0.6939451098442078,
-0.2668621242046356,
-0.9931235909461975,
0.610339879989624,
0.3978824317455292,
1.2008962631225586,
-0.1826992779970169,
0.4703427255153656,
0.30554136633872986,
0.24013935029506683,
0.15642386674880981,
0.384956955909729,
-0.4836839437484741,
-0.4797610342502594,
-0.5332051515579224,
-0.6505382657051086,
-0.4107106328010559,
-0.2197212129831314,
-0.48853981494903564,
0.07158450037240982,
-0.5739295482635498,
-0.007071646861732006,
-0.13138200342655182,
0.2589356601238251,
-0.7520778179168701,
0.15994904935359955,
-0.31783968210220337,
0.6407724022865295,
-0.9371778964996338,
0.20696096122264862,
0.9111407995223999,
-0.41011154651641846,
-0.6148358583450317,
0.01128991786390543,
-0.014271539635956287,
-0.9574964046478271,
0.7792336940765381,
0.4597710967063904,
0.12622730433940887,
-0.002777490299195051,
-0.5527649521827698,
-0.4702960252761841,
0.9191256165504456,
0.2187577337026596,
-0.31868767738342285,
-0.2986743152141571,
-0.07236167788505554,
0.38542911410331726,
-0.6900809407234192,
0.21031855046749115,
0.20394475758075714,
0.21807169914245605,
0.20711413025856018,
-0.8346291780471802,
0.2872687876224518,
-0.12793460488319397,
0.3108050525188446,
0.08859989047050476,
-0.5058699250221252,
1.124900221824646,
-0.34196385741233826,
-0.23423339426517487,
-0.008722302503883839,
0.4355100691318512,
0.32180723547935486,
0.24979621171951294,
0.6067765355110168,
0.2177266776561737,
0.6908149719238281,
-0.006091458257287741,
1.012193202972412,
-0.13304544985294342,
0.36115121841430664,
0.8102174997329712,
-0.13337676227092743,
0.2645150125026703,
0.6275202035903931,
-0.024944664910435677,
0.4492148756980896,
0.9767739772796631,
-0.010364548303186893,
0.7987972497940063,
0.18542465567588806,
-0.22985316812992096,
-0.31864410638809204,
-0.04290296509861946,
0.237157940864563,
0.16670067608356476,
0.061269864439964294,
-0.17704801261425018,
-0.6116477847099304,
0.5102154016494751,
-0.006483561359345913,
0.06369142234325409,
-0.2561362087726593,
0.9253090023994446,
-0.1434592753648758,
-0.9055457711219788,
0.27323007583618164,
-0.042746320366859436,
0.3424666225910187,
-0.28365078568458557,
-0.19165515899658203,
-0.17260953783988953,
-0.07529447227716446,
0.04441839084029198,
-0.5284040570259094,
-0.0882347896695137,
-0.17597661912441254,
-0.26298466324806213,
-0.48552608489990234,
0.5588939189910889,
-0.2570376694202423,
-0.3219582736492157,
-0.10334119945764542,
0.6335912346839905,
0.1407761126756668,
-0.37247270345687866,
-0.8114959597587585,
-0.10636135935783386,
0.07846073806285858,
-0.5073668956756592,
0.2160208821296692,
0.5355383157730103,
-0.17531390488147736,
0.6388980746269226,
0.7144489884376526,
0.014170109294354916,
-0.20117995142936707,
0.0705486610531807,
1.0011863708496094,
-0.7102987170219421,
-0.7445435523986816,
-0.7353411316871643,
0.7195014953613281,
-0.050762925297021866,
-0.5512966513633728,
0.3876244127750397,
0.4612778127193451,
0.5489047765731812,
-0.11252231895923615,
0.6624193787574768,
0.07933969050645828,
0.5497066974639893,
-0.6764593124389648,
0.17596036195755005,
-0.3994932472705841,
0.16787704825401306,
-0.3585275113582611,
-1.173953652381897,
-0.2864244282245636,
0.6430748701095581,
-0.19999650120735168,
0.18492552638053894,
0.9681504964828491,
0.47175535559654236,
0.2129409909248352,
0.0124254385009408,
0.11775293946266174,
-0.30792051553726196,
0.17535966634750366,
0.6154859066009521,
0.7143990397453308,
0.00958262663334608,
0.1563890427350998,
-0.3742777407169342,
-0.6318995952606201,
0.008394582197070122,
-0.9814082980155945,
-1.321528434753418,
-0.9332268238067627,
-0.2642093896865845,
0.04050697013735771,
0.17071658372879028,
1.0933681726455688,
0.5339081287384033,
-0.5846559405326843,
-0.1914242058992386,
-0.3177274167537689,
0.18340210616588593,
-0.3072870373725891,
-0.19846214354038239,
0.5412278771400452,
-0.911858081817627,
-0.6453126072883606,
0.5209017395973206,
0.27554085850715637,
-0.1069907397031784,
-0.1265895813703537,
0.3513987362384796,
0.126337468624115,
-0.10431811213493347,
0.7550488710403442,
0.16717912256717682,
-0.5833969712257385,
-0.1849411576986313,
0.24814923107624054,
0.12021225690841675,
-0.003035031259059906,
1.2673966884613037,
-0.840853214263916,
0.4141148626804352,
0.6155127882957458,
0.854992151260376,
0.40225914120674133,
0.31523898243904114,
0.5257080793380737,
-1.2366217374801636,
-0.005066459998488426,
0.2615722715854645,
0.24597352743148804,
0.39149537682533264,
-0.5544963479042053,
0.29998764395713806,
0.38109612464904785,
-0.5339940190315247,
-0.7890093326568604,
0.3924145996570587,
-1.2096463441848755,
-0.5205898284912109,
1.0125325918197632,
-0.04256473109126091,
-0.410667359828949,
0.06915336847305298,
-0.35660234093666077,
0.20907358825206757,
-0.5452466011047363,
0.5420450568199158,
0.4443679451942444,
-0.6044055819511414,
-0.27474653720855713,
-0.47770261764526367,
0.7652958035469055,
0.45222005248069763,
-0.720927357673645,
0.11690881103277206,
0.5372921228408813,
0.13367030024528503,
0.24625641107559204,
0.5488027334213257,
0.2604656517505646,
0.4344438910484314,
-0.15911419689655304,
0.0405554361641407,
-0.2193267047405243,
-0.5771455764770508,
-0.4443093538284302,
0.3322218060493469,
-0.10981588065624237,
-0.4205564856529236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10492v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10492v1
|
Large Language Models as Event Forecasters
| 2024-06-15T04:09:31 | 2024-06-15T04:09:31 |
Libo Zhang, Yue Ning
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Key elements of human events are extracted as quadruples that consist of
subject, relation, object, and timestamp. This representation can be extended
to a quintuple by adding a fifth element: a textual summary that briefly
describes the event. These quadruples or quintuples, when organized within a
specific domain, form a temporal knowledge graph (TKG). Current learning
frameworks focus on a few TKG-related tasks, such as predicting an object given
a subject and a relation or forecasting the occurrences of multiple types of
events (i.e., relation) in the next time window. They typically rely on complex
structural and sequential models like graph neural networks (GNNs) and
recurrent neural networks (RNNs) to update intermediate embeddings. However,
these methods often neglect the contextual information inherent in each
quintuple, which can be effectively captured through concise textual
descriptions. In this paper, we investigate how large language models (LLMs)
can streamline the design of TKG learning frameworks while maintaining
competitive accuracy in prediction and forecasting tasks. We develop multiple
prompt templates to frame the object prediction (OP) task as a standard
question-answering (QA) task, suitable for instruction fine-tuning with an
encoder-decoder generative LLM. For multi-event forecasting (MEF), we design
simple yet effective prompt templates for each TKG quintuple. This novel
approach removes the need for GNNs and RNNs, instead utilizing an encoder-only
LLM to generate fixed intermediate embeddings, which are subsequently processed
by a prediction head with a self-attention mechanism to forecast potential
future relations. Extensive experiments on multiple real-world datasets using
various evaluation metrics validate the effectiveness and robustness of our
approach.
|
[
-0.10992813110351562,
-0.5319575667381287,
0.7115347385406494,
0.15399591624736786,
-0.1824290156364441,
0.20659027993679047,
-0.20108097791671753,
-0.4809196889400482,
-0.07694020122289658,
0.2026045173406601,
-0.5857128500938416,
-0.585955798625946,
-0.3362787663936615,
-0.11063841730356216,
-0.1732988953590393,
0.6761125922203064,
0.2060399353504181,
-0.09482120722532272,
-0.03538771718740463,
0.12788859009742737,
-0.373811274766922,
-0.6263168454170227,
-0.8883754014968872,
-0.5524609684944153,
0.7046229839324951,
0.3330366313457489,
0.6252202987670898,
0.7205570936203003,
-0.11872243136167526,
0.2528233528137207,
-0.06573359668254852,
0.05733028054237366,
-0.39799851179122925,
0.18043474853038788,
-0.18632598221302032,
-0.2809045612812042,
-0.39950764179229736,
-0.16921846568584442,
0.6828023195266724,
0.8763043284416199,
-0.07775520533323288,
0.12813550233840942,
0.050612907856702805,
0.34219732880592346,
-0.3849692642688751,
0.8269327878952026,
-0.4167599081993103,
0.21038787066936493,
0.05761581286787987,
-0.05092128366231918,
-0.4773854613304138,
-0.1796334981918335,
0.44029510021209717,
-0.5765252113342285,
0.18901650607585907,
0.2057855725288391,
0.5330097079277039,
0.010789735242724419,
-0.3947124183177948,
-0.02936728671193123,
-0.6151710748672485,
0.8957067728042603,
-0.8423381447792053,
0.6016948819160461,
0.17137423157691956,
0.4161038398742676,
-0.26559367775917053,
-0.7977114319801331,
-0.4689904749393463,
-0.10300092399120331,
0.003350393380969763,
0.10870564728975296,
-0.0034776460379362106,
0.10693332552909851,
0.20337095856666565,
-0.08089160174131393,
-0.5518907308578491,
0.31572023034095764,
-0.19410276412963867,
0.021414360031485558,
0.5348766446113586,
0.4148810803890228,
0.07113703340291977,
-0.29588237404823303,
-0.322192519903183,
0.040893957018852234,
-0.6810287237167358,
0.0036146410275250673,
0.04453078284859657,
0.3367372453212738,
-0.16169726848602295,
0.4467569589614868,
-0.19310913980007172,
0.6609347462654114,
0.24773438274860382,
-0.4312768876552582,
0.1756642460823059,
-0.3072812557220459,
-0.1814037710428238,
-0.0380345955491066,
0.8552080988883972,
0.42955896258354187,
0.3936528265476227,
-0.5417276620864868,
0.009808510541915894,
-0.07729683071374893,
-0.019047586247324944,
-0.9305793046951294,
-0.2681051194667816,
0.2455710768699646,
-0.40613314509391785,
-0.3975125253200531,
-0.30675795674324036,
-1.0191657543182373,
-0.40152499079704285,
-0.4390636086463928,
0.22776418924331665,
-0.4638639986515045,
-0.06243588775396347,
0.06937593221664429,
-0.03864123672246933,
0.07162995636463165,
0.3968048393726349,
-0.7251974940299988,
-0.11977696418762207,
0.606778621673584,
0.5989055633544922,
0.05684828758239746,
-0.5134425163269043,
-0.6618083119392395,
0.42390120029449463,
-0.29557475447654724,
0.6211536526679993,
-0.6791554689407349,
-0.2403431385755539,
0.13909059762954712,
0.03712518885731697,
-0.06264132261276245,
-0.1456982046365738,
0.14418566226959229,
-0.7147707343101501,
0.2824294865131378,
-0.08773468434810638,
-0.7248958945274353,
-0.2770152986049652,
0.321706622838974,
-0.5688029527664185,
0.7316396236419678,
0.039386019110679626,
-0.5445309281349182,
0.2880658209323883,
-0.26876163482666016,
-0.39969301223754883,
-0.034243468195199966,
-0.28661298751831055,
-0.40340086817741394,
-0.04489099979400635,
0.530234158039093,
0.9689343571662903,
-0.4461830258369446,
0.4296460747718811,
-0.4891504645347595,
0.09177079051733017,
0.1745319664478302,
-0.22352750599384308,
0.30273938179016113,
0.1157342717051506,
-0.11276818066835403,
0.3016820549964905,
-0.7228289246559143,
0.01725175231695175,
0.08605767041444778,
-0.4401662349700928,
0.08512609452009201,
0.2816280126571655,
0.007561688311398029,
0.508577287197113,
0.14152473211288452,
-0.451801598072052,
0.3180866241455078,
-0.508118748664856,
0.6340118050575256,
0.7504216432571411,
0.05885111540555954,
0.5437780618667603,
-0.2730991244316101,
0.669120192527771,
0.2036053091287613,
0.03616087883710861,
-0.5514553189277649,
-0.3741147518157959,
-0.4457426369190216,
0.2620902955532074,
0.17946262657642365,
0.38026154041290283,
-1.068454384803772,
0.31382107734680176,
-0.5707697868347168,
-0.4448266327381134,
0.06475725769996643,
0.04134580120444298,
0.24340766668319702,
0.5321757793426514,
0.1067545935511589,
0.36099088191986084,
-0.5901443362236023,
-0.4852442741394043,
-0.054197169840335846,
-0.30592724680900574,
-0.15739554166793823,
0.13589486479759216,
0.20647630095481873,
0.006947246380150318,
0.8208046555519104,
-0.4835021495819092,
-0.1659092754125595,
-0.5161561369895935,
0.127088725566864,
0.16392143070697784,
0.1852259337902069,
0.6485750079154968,
-0.6305273175239563,
-0.4586658775806427,
-0.020046276971697807,
-0.700002133846283,
0.16970907151699066,
-0.11095741391181946,
0.2363344430923462,
0.31042394042015076,
0.5227468013763428,
-0.48267754912376404,
0.207768976688385,
0.4786463677883148,
-0.5804949998855591,
0.5665481686592102,
-0.010547472164034843,
-0.2318466156721115,
-1.4002115726470947,
-0.1507924199104309,
-0.038774535059928894,
-0.26368585228919983,
-0.6414397358894348,
-0.22611945867538452,
0.13457918167114258,
-0.32040977478027344,
-0.42673179507255554,
0.9572821855545044,
-0.3184622824192047,
-0.07945245504379272,
-0.14312753081321716,
0.2224379926919937,
0.09396518021821976,
0.6413194537162781,
0.015066895633935928,
0.458969384431839,
0.4404146671295166,
-0.49167460203170776,
0.4020316004753113,
0.13961340487003326,
-0.3860873281955719,
0.26415547728538513,
-0.58396315574646,
0.060310766100883484,
-0.35306745767593384,
0.24720215797424316,
-0.824210524559021,
-0.3146442174911499,
0.0675593838095665,
-0.4867422878742218,
0.5268124341964722,
-0.2444608509540558,
-0.5147902965545654,
-0.5244092345237732,
-0.18819214403629303,
0.2639336884021759,
0.5085907578468323,
-0.6411975026130676,
1.023327350616455,
0.17465512454509735,
-0.2600017189979553,
-0.6704841256141663,
-0.41673123836517334,
0.10217922925949097,
-0.1084098070859909,
-0.649809718132019,
0.08419663459062576,
0.07155897468328476,
0.11912809312343597,
0.019749265164136887,
0.024254588410258293,
0.22024314105510712,
0.045243456959724426,
0.24212299287319183,
0.33312034606933594,
-0.1837187260389328,
0.6454064846038818,
-0.3357158899307251,
-0.17803947627544403,
-0.04536047205328941,
-0.8488140106201172,
0.660817563533783,
-0.04876967519521713,
-0.05876370146870613,
-0.2291092425584793,
0.310211718082428,
0.5937362313270569,
-0.2491685152053833,
0.8147547245025635,
0.7272878885269165,
-0.5200735330581665,
-0.21694979071617126,
-0.6380647420883179,
-0.16897383332252502,
-0.4248790144920349,
0.6784670948982239,
-0.41461366415023804,
-0.9667555093765259,
0.6522552371025085,
0.030428385362029076,
0.03558341786265373,
0.40038180351257324,
0.46301427483558655,
-0.1074250116944313,
1.2096275091171265,
0.5239481925964355,
-0.31546488404273987,
0.6290627717971802,
-0.27496668696403503,
0.29350268840789795,
-0.8272699117660522,
-0.3803447484970093,
-0.38806143403053284,
-0.18162089586257935,
-0.24829895794391632,
-0.4160345196723938,
0.36959636211395264,
0.28748899698257446,
-0.503455638885498,
-0.02263430319726467,
-0.025397440418601036,
0.4494820237159729,
0.3453596830368042,
-0.13365823030471802,
0.13019494712352753,
-0.04759146645665169,
-0.09103956073522568,
0.02283385396003723,
-1.0443214178085327,
-0.5047156810760498,
1.1375752687454224,
0.4019492268562317,
0.8704661130905151,
-0.27801334857940674,
0.3937990665435791,
-0.10438484698534012,
0.28221389651298523,
-0.8078650236129761,
0.36700940132141113,
-0.2681936025619507,
-0.3274741470813751,
-0.5278083086013794,
-0.4964366555213928,
-0.941108226776123,
0.1812542825937271,
-0.09081946313381195,
-1.0411137342453003,
0.3176301419734955,
0.14149899780750275,
-0.528450071811676,
0.5024027824401855,
-0.546527087688446,
0.8918792605400085,
-0.16813020408153534,
-0.18396522104740143,
-0.06652894616127014,
-0.3921216130256653,
-0.05739964172244072,
-0.0057336571626365185,
0.19479097425937653,
-0.2824260890483856,
-0.04151751473546028,
0.7822350859642029,
-0.006892537698149681,
1.0785905122756958,
-0.05736139416694641,
0.17386704683303833,
0.2204015851020813,
0.09341275691986084,
0.7690535187721252,
0.05977616459131241,
-0.2735776901245117,
-0.037242911756038666,
0.0902293473482132,
-0.35054123401641846,
-0.6949059963226318,
0.6790788769721985,
-0.9275776147842407,
-0.47419315576553345,
-0.12790971994400024,
-0.5209280252456665,
-0.3677454888820648,
0.13947243988513947,
0.19039757549762726,
0.9675068259239197,
-0.17637641727924347,
0.23970003426074982,
0.38740065693855286,
-0.25612586736679077,
0.6187630891799927,
0.5291902422904968,
-0.48594027757644653,
-0.5468301773071289,
0.8498685956001282,
0.2823654115200043,
0.2494363933801651,
0.5628181099891663,
0.43308261036872864,
-0.41764381527900696,
-0.49883437156677246,
-0.3402690887451172,
0.32737115025520325,
-0.873780369758606,
-0.3554392457008362,
-0.9247684478759766,
-0.1594252735376358,
-0.5731287002563477,
-0.15055999159812927,
-0.1466222107410431,
-0.44190046191215515,
-0.44989293813705444,
-0.2907060384750366,
0.1843113899230957,
0.8033522367477417,
0.20478491485118866,
0.3698849380016327,
-0.8990529775619507,
0.1228543072938919,
0.3617967963218689,
0.37928277254104614,
0.5454409718513489,
-0.28097352385520935,
-0.3475269377231598,
-0.05377977713942528,
-0.3031728267669678,
-0.7495315670967102,
0.6239232420921326,
0.23650559782981873,
0.4517247676849365,
0.4398190379142761,
0.050948821008205414,
0.523216962814331,
-0.6640920639038086,
0.7930998206138611,
0.3910992741584778,
-0.7597026824951172,
0.4974767863750458,
-0.582716166973114,
0.5369797348976135,
-0.0924883782863617,
0.3228280544281006,
-0.8547236919403076,
-0.18182909488677979,
-0.6016643047332764,
-0.747917115688324,
0.8741414546966553,
-0.14491403102874756,
-0.14295844733715057,
-0.1787073165178299,
0.40074917674064636,
0.030437348410487175,
0.3944905996322632,
-0.5539330244064331,
-0.14992284774780273,
-0.27457478642463684,
-0.38425031304359436,
-0.4786287844181061,
-0.5516147017478943,
0.13746090233325958,
0.011526509188115597,
0.4879290461540222,
-0.3915615677833557,
0.27384090423583984,
-0.01596628502011299,
0.158965602517128,
-0.18039005994796753,
0.39464232325553894,
0.2997753322124481,
0.8694749474525452,
-0.10937770456075668,
0.05454014986753464,
0.23168310523033142,
-0.1380225419998169,
0.10255707800388336,
0.2562432885169983,
-0.017038516700267792,
-0.13363519310951233,
0.6531646251678467,
0.8852386474609375,
0.5087943077087402,
-0.43537217378616333,
0.3241371214389801,
0.10667824000120163,
-0.016978822648525238,
-0.5158348083496094,
-0.2387736290693283,
0.3797876536846161,
0.6061984300613403,
0.40678149461746216,
-0.3564974367618561,
-0.20509667694568634,
-0.6485150456428528,
-0.10079767554998398,
0.07462748885154724,
-0.3571442663669586,
-0.5786063075065613,
0.711672842502594,
0.19067060947418213,
-0.19829511642456055,
0.6002497673034668,
-0.15965145826339722,
-0.808010995388031,
0.7398689389228821,
0.6257900595664978,
0.8529173731803894,
-0.3051208257675171,
0.17724570631980896,
0.36823558807373047,
0.08651293069124222,
-0.03184857964515686,
0.4115566611289978,
0.27564290165901184,
-0.7595281600952148,
-0.5954525470733643,
-0.8123319149017334,
-0.12933140993118286,
0.2835558354854584,
-0.30835196375846863,
0.10061691701412201,
-0.40484073758125305,
-0.1577383279800415,
0.17656612396240234,
0.028027519583702087,
-1.089211344718933,
0.08321132510900497,
0.3264276087284088,
0.786664605140686,
-0.6910645961761475,
0.847994327545166,
0.7178451418876648,
-0.23304492235183716,
-0.9602339863777161,
-0.25217169523239136,
-0.13246223330497742,
-0.47754982113838196,
0.7058583498001099,
0.17146913707256317,
0.2809116244316101,
-0.004813473671674728,
-0.24149315059185028,
-1.1173675060272217,
1.2091981172561646,
0.2569226026535034,
-0.7601008415222168,
-0.563723087310791,
0.05808235704898834,
0.43224525451660156,
-0.6206442713737488,
0.008988783694803715,
0.4381132125854492,
0.46011197566986084,
0.27118900418281555,
-0.8349289298057556,
-0.013455250300467014,
0.07454817742109299,
0.13092473149299622,
0.32867690920829773,
-0.5075058341026306,
0.9249306321144104,
-0.22333835065364838,
-0.3009173572063446,
0.038207605481147766,
0.6640875935554504,
0.07006676495075226,
0.34092891216278076,
0.30931103229522705,
0.30425432324409485,
0.6880335211753845,
-0.2719140648841858,
1.3156510591506958,
-0.30792781710624695,
0.3057582378387451,
1.3691681623458862,
-0.2612207233905792,
0.6709723472595215,
0.16886870563030243,
-0.11682291328907013,
0.31401750445365906,
0.5952698588371277,
0.11859583854675293,
0.38821759819984436,
-0.09296409785747528,
-0.06969019025564194,
-0.6237896680831909,
-0.05866304039955139,
-0.24936234951019287,
0.2742037773132324,
0.6291981339454651,
-0.3277565538883209,
-0.44083523750305176,
0.3442462980747223,
-0.07222692668437958,
-0.2079322785139084,
-0.48347458243370056,
0.9055120944976807,
0.2547440230846405,
-0.5318127274513245,
0.24314619600772858,
-0.13028620183467865,
0.28819018602371216,
-0.5569400787353516,
0.06273884326219559,
0.10042181611061096,
0.43491414189338684,
0.10556045919656754,
-0.8133165240287781,
-0.01563446968793869,
-0.4601164758205414,
-0.2901923954486847,
-0.06111806258559227,
0.746789276599884,
-0.6169395446777344,
-0.6907968521118164,
0.4337097108364105,
0.510485053062439,
-0.29503077268600464,
-0.04646611586213112,
-0.4994635283946991,
-0.020632559433579445,
-0.15389765799045563,
-0.39744165539741516,
0.2083844393491745,
0.6587610244750977,
-0.11079950630664825,
0.9964250922203064,
0.36291930079460144,
0.07067280262708664,
0.20308299362659454,
0.1517707258462906,
0.9071934223175049,
-0.812347412109375,
-0.7672742009162903,
-0.7051047086715698,
0.2883683741092682,
0.02973116934299469,
0.06958036869764328,
0.5916551947593689,
0.28608497977256775,
0.6385291218757629,
-0.09092890471220016,
0.8593350052833557,
0.3370331823825836,
0.5696665048599243,
-0.5632691979408264,
0.4312385618686676,
-0.3044804632663727,
0.1252279281616211,
-0.008815591223537922,
-0.8735164403915405,
-0.15133047103881836,
0.12421628087759018,
-0.48134222626686096,
0.07015807926654816,
0.5621088743209839,
0.31085944175720215,
0.10241977125406265,
0.10510957986116409,
0.5286415815353394,
0.38037267327308655,
0.5935277938842773,
0.7067704796791077,
0.9194483160972595,
-0.13661612570285797,
0.5727983713150024,
-0.30216142535209656,
0.08343195170164108,
-0.3381776809692383,
-0.9587972164154053,
-1.3227009773254395,
-0.6509255170822144,
-0.26191723346710205,
-0.19263260066509247,
0.23002883791923523,
1.1444302797317505,
0.7309657335281372,
-0.8099679946899414,
-0.13397687673568726,
0.2617129981517792,
0.10560327768325806,
0.03418341651558876,
-0.23034998774528503,
0.7015658020973206,
-0.4774410128593445,
-0.6158185601234436,
0.30945587158203125,
0.2205057442188263,
0.19976450502872467,
-0.23657174408435822,
0.08960475772619247,
0.02679113671183586,
-0.18155254423618317,
0.9537601470947266,
0.10051258653402328,
-0.8129562735557556,
-0.6702128052711487,
-0.08250512182712555,
0.1418990194797516,
-0.13568182289600372,
0.6084694862365723,
-0.9973470568656921,
0.4870997369289398,
0.5041905641555786,
0.6478618383407593,
0.5495956540107727,
-0.16251270473003387,
0.8926668167114258,
-0.8630651235580444,
0.12830527126789093,
0.2623414099216461,
0.5375484824180603,
0.32169654965400696,
-0.36339399218559265,
0.36252686381340027,
-0.0182389747351408,
-0.5404003858566284,
-0.45601046085357666,
0.2255226969718933,
-0.7219447493553162,
-0.3119916319847107,
1.1019086837768555,
-0.17954225838184357,
-0.3593709468841553,
-0.27330446243286133,
0.0010741023579612374,
0.3173093795776367,
-0.47066301107406616,
0.7201026678085327,
0.7728767395019531,
0.08568023145198822,
-0.3247721195220947,
-0.5941810607910156,
0.4326190948486328,
-0.0726487934589386,
-0.48992568254470825,
0.17257492244243622,
0.5485239028930664,
0.30711302161216736,
0.12021873891353607,
0.29517024755477905,
0.0644100084900856,
0.3287108838558197,
-0.2376004010438919,
-0.0017000491498038173,
-0.46388253569602966,
-0.534239649772644,
-0.31231924891471863,
0.3190254271030426,
0.045596204698085785,
-0.016902511939406395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10486v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10486v1
|
Do Large Language Models Discriminate in Hiring Decisions on the Basis of Race, Ethnicity, and Gender?
| 2024-06-15T03:31:16 | 2024-06-15T03:31:16 |
Haozhe An, Christabel Acquaye, Colin Wang, Zongxia Li, Rachel Rudinger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We examine whether large language models (LLMs) exhibit race- and
gender-based name discrimination in hiring decisions, similar to classic
findings in the social sciences (Bertrand and Mullainathan, 2004). We design a
series of templatic prompts to LLMs to write an email to a named job applicant
informing them of a hiring decision. By manipulating the applicant's first
name, we measure the effect of perceived race, ethnicity, and gender on the
probability that the LLM generates an acceptance or rejection email. We find
that the hiring decisions of LLMs in many settings are more likely to favor
White applicants over Hispanic applicants. In aggregate, the groups with the
highest and lowest acceptance rates respectively are masculine White names and
masculine Hispanic names. However, the comparative acceptance rates by group
vary under different templatic settings, suggesting that LLMs' race- and
gender-sensitivity may be idiosyncratic and prompt-sensitive.
|
[
-0.07315127551555634,
-0.5430132150650024,
1.0311715602874756,
0.3143157660961151,
0.11440537124872208,
0.3218602240085602,
-0.4276025593280792,
-0.5483304262161255,
0.33642062544822693,
0.14727944135665894,
-0.5701951384544373,
-0.3545632064342499,
-0.7638621926307678,
0.1137954518198967,
-0.49102330207824707,
0.6995435953140259,
0.08206116408109665,
0.21482409536838531,
0.035093292593955994,
0.08634652942419052,
-0.30786705017089844,
-0.43503910303115845,
-0.834418773651123,
-0.3121762275695801,
0.8944196105003357,
0.34945598244667053,
0.6801090836524963,
0.5951985716819763,
0.11294907331466675,
0.28550946712493896,
-0.3550316393375397,
-0.46790075302124023,
-0.3388698101043701,
0.2147996425628662,
-0.3994554877281189,
-0.7820040583610535,
-0.15490353107452393,
0.30974525213241577,
0.6524870991706848,
0.8993958830833435,
-0.2414485067129135,
0.564446210861206,
-0.3285950720310211,
0.5766862034797668,
-0.7566384673118591,
-0.07500119507312775,
-0.7958557605743408,
0.05062219500541687,
-0.41747695207595825,
0.05305081605911255,
-0.6424258351325989,
-0.514050304889679,
0.07316327840089798,
-0.01718405820429325,
0.3783198893070221,
0.48111486434936523,
0.41736435890197754,
-0.34977975487709045,
-0.5962245464324951,
-0.44426339864730835,
-0.7983654737472534,
0.7038580775260925,
-0.5214225649833679,
0.511523425579071,
0.6735616326332092,
0.5146341919898987,
-0.244467094540596,
-0.18273243308067322,
-0.6904361248016357,
-0.3061186969280243,
-0.1295776665210724,
-0.24948182702064514,
-0.08833567798137665,
0.006924622692167759,
0.48704561591148376,
0.27055323123931885,
-0.8269698023796082,
0.8103527426719666,
-0.8801049590110779,
0.05454765260219574,
0.6855809688568115,
0.29709404706954956,
0.31763756275177,
0.24042390286922455,
-0.04324513301253319,
0.18446044623851776,
-0.6491312980651855,
0.08037861436605453,
0.6893240213394165,
0.6088987588882446,
-0.08975876867771149,
0.643056333065033,
-0.28521955013275146,
0.7567287683486938,
0.028515303507447243,
-0.04706594720482826,
0.042718611657619476,
0.3815162777900696,
-0.35835593938827515,
0.5227789878845215,
0.6561243534088135,
0.1920309215784073,
0.45797616243362427,
-0.1259244978427887,
-0.14457210898399353,
0.056602008640766144,
0.1865098774433136,
-0.6454163193702698,
0.12451966106891632,
0.23134830594062805,
-0.5077719688415527,
-0.20203512907028198,
-0.016466660425066948,
-0.6076164841651917,
-0.8850531578063965,
-0.30179646611213684,
-0.01132090575993061,
0.030570877715945244,
-0.12604622542858124,
0.05973104014992714,
-0.1171942800283432,
0.294750839471817,
0.3832692801952362,
-1.1128783226013184,
0.08741211146116257,
0.8261035084724426,
0.5992975234985352,
-0.2489244043827057,
-0.399728000164032,
-0.41296783089637756,
0.05135289207100868,
-0.3801358938217163,
0.504081130027771,
-1.0225156545639038,
-0.38177070021629333,
0.11187677085399628,
0.026684649288654327,
-0.1138085201382637,
-0.7056235671043396,
0.1977406144142151,
-0.7031124234199524,
0.2619858980178833,
-0.2892742455005646,
-0.18345347046852112,
-0.015201814472675323,
0.04844656214118004,
-0.40099215507507324,
0.5919659733772278,
0.15397563576698303,
-0.6042127013206482,
0.6925973296165466,
-0.3453415632247925,
-0.26135697960853577,
0.09568320959806442,
-0.28341278433799744,
-0.2682324945926666,
0.4516857862472534,
-0.49460169672966003,
0.49910569190979004,
-0.49832913279533386,
0.1274653524160385,
-0.5119748711585999,
-0.4845429062843323,
0.5694639682769775,
0.016507280990481377,
0.9872326254844666,
0.2757895290851593,
-0.23712044954299927,
-0.07825835794210434,
-0.41451790928840637,
-0.27262160181999207,
0.29247620701789856,
-0.46097782254219055,
-0.47524741291999817,
0.02283717319369316,
-0.22205586731433868,
0.2849694490432739,
-0.2014927864074707,
-0.6178070306777954,
0.26766470074653625,
0.14936821162700653,
0.10574071109294891,
0.8811654448509216,
-0.6274499893188477,
0.3816017806529999,
-0.18438135087490082,
0.7337775230407715,
-0.104838527739048,
-0.07559172064065933,
0.3352454602718353,
-0.37473371624946594,
-0.6173197031021118,
-0.21982567012310028,
0.2959318161010742,
0.48824387788772583,
-0.436838299036026,
0.013315497897565365,
0.05681982263922691,
-0.6258249878883362,
-0.27125900983810425,
-0.09193573892116547,
0.1902773082256317,
0.05372919142246246,
-0.15096403658390045,
0.16137456893920898,
-0.4712843894958496,
-1.2394306659698486,
-0.609265148639679,
-0.6792153120040894,
0.001627361518330872,
0.24830546975135803,
0.42586439847946167,
-0.025148285552859306,
0.7359808683395386,
-0.5362393856048584,
0.16091576218605042,
-0.1391257494688034,
0.09811271727085114,
0.599942684173584,
0.14062562584877014,
0.9506492614746094,
-0.7113515734672546,
-0.5676854252815247,
-0.132152259349823,
-0.20025523006916046,
-0.2315044105052948,
0.1550031304359436,
-0.15380117297172546,
-0.02428286522626877,
0.46987730264663696,
-0.6657914519309998,
0.36255496740341187,
0.8027874827384949,
-0.8051668405532837,
0.7948080897331238,
-0.07734006643295288,
0.13100267946720123,
-0.9954528212547302,
-0.10153572261333466,
0.2650051712989807,
-0.051451850682497025,
-0.597655177116394,
-0.18270684778690338,
0.01634129323065281,
-0.07176420837640762,
-0.6720651388168335,
0.7810845375061035,
-0.5196757912635803,
-0.10941353440284729,
-0.08139199018478394,
-0.07708019018173218,
-0.44339045882225037,
-0.01585550233721733,
-0.01274961233139038,
0.6235665082931519,
0.4268820583820343,
-0.9206950068473816,
0.3324280083179474,
0.23198607563972473,
-0.435587614774704,
0.9516051411628723,
-0.5727052688598633,
0.054521817713975906,
-0.7004831433296204,
0.36935895681381226,
-1.2465275526046753,
-0.3221518099308014,
0.07255875319242477,
-0.28426915407180786,
0.16222365200519562,
-0.03887972608208656,
-0.3546026051044464,
-0.7597376704216003,
0.00808058213442564,
0.5250911712646484,
0.37582850456237793,
-0.44696563482284546,
0.3191840946674347,
0.15526136755943298,
-0.632277250289917,
-0.48433831334114075,
-0.8869691491127014,
-0.00003885335536324419,
-0.2574593424797058,
-0.1355297714471817,
0.2255270779132843,
-0.32430195808410645,
-0.7289683222770691,
-0.4337848722934723,
0.1753368228673935,
-0.5387365221977234,
0.15688857436180115,
0.2753821909427643,
0.34189873933792114,
-0.043315302580595016,
0.07385528832674026,
-0.19040025770664215,
0.2743557095527649,
0.13151797652244568,
0.022738376632332802,
0.46700912714004517,
0.39591920375823975,
-0.36825549602508545,
-0.18902836740016937,
0.3227364718914032,
0.9821555018424988,
-0.09233782440423965,
1.075163722038269,
0.30340635776519775,
-0.3167222738265991,
-0.3177391588687897,
-0.752308189868927,
-0.19592496752738953,
-0.41843342781066895,
0.3040747046470642,
-0.18659436702728271,
-1.1075053215026855,
0.4637123644351959,
0.21587108075618744,
-0.06244885176420212,
0.3304332196712494,
0.707640528678894,
-0.2637813091278076,
0.8634799122810364,
0.5982062816619873,
0.06697449088096619,
0.6966971755027771,
0.2907676100730896,
0.1665077954530716,
-0.5291044116020203,
-0.2141193151473999,
-0.9348800778388977,
-0.7673249840736389,
-0.7498028874397278,
-0.19474948942661285,
-0.10600320994853973,
-0.40586599707603455,
-0.29528099298477173,
0.029955333098769188,
-0.31183215975761414,
0.5605219602584839,
0.38856837153434753,
-0.2924238443374634,
0.10014668852090836,
0.09858027845621109,
-0.12673956155776978,
-0.2497912347316742,
-0.3714315593242645,
-0.46167367696762085,
0.7858517169952393,
0.32108232378959656,
0.5383707880973816,
0.4451397657394409,
0.28345316648483276,
0.43824872374534607,
0.5270321369171143,
-0.36024072766304016,
0.5405916571617126,
-0.17201466858386993,
-1.0896395444869995,
-0.10097702592611313,
-0.42731761932373047,
-1.0336261987686157,
0.3673315942287445,
-0.41033321619033813,
-1.2230846881866455,
0.45295751094818115,
0.0036972712259739637,
-0.32658252120018005,
0.3915403485298157,
-0.4953638017177582,
0.5106915235519409,
-0.368085652589798,
0.009042362682521343,
-0.12013766169548035,
-0.2521970570087433,
0.6598972678184509,
-0.592541515827179,
0.293068528175354,
-0.48417767882347107,
0.20505869388580322,
0.5495185852050781,
-0.29432252049446106,
0.6505797505378723,
-0.1485537439584732,
-0.020819270983338356,
-0.05340409651398659,
0.4755004942417145,
0.5023655891418457,
-0.23832722008228302,
-0.8849847912788391,
0.33930134773254395,
-0.17083002626895905,
-0.16191653907299042,
-0.4092864990234375,
0.5908973217010498,
-0.5123989582061768,
-0.6357873678207397,
-0.40255266427993774,
-0.5709871649742126,
-0.12664809823036194,
0.1201535314321518,
0.25880298018455505,
-0.05423708260059357,
-0.10605619847774506,
0.26663267612457275,
0.3418329954147339,
-0.6517252326011658,
0.12071389704942703,
0.9834962487220764,
-0.5662751197814941,
0.15563249588012695,
0.548987627029419,
0.22040879726409912,
0.17294836044311523,
-0.031246395781636238,
0.2453157603740692,
-0.23828640580177307,
-0.42937171459198,
-0.1720268726348877,
0.7686202526092529,
-0.34720009565353394,
0.19104360044002533,
-0.6011889576911926,
-0.014895487576723099,
-0.28764745593070984,
-0.2163880467414856,
-0.13266396522521973,
-0.16475720703601837,
-0.0489327646791935,
-0.05463278293609619,
0.04997733235359192,
0.817905068397522,
0.4463849663734436,
0.5336361527442932,
-0.3252621293067932,
0.3565152585506439,
0.481635719537735,
0.5764247179031372,
-0.26710379123687744,
-0.6880415081977844,
0.03966832160949707,
-0.07692983746528625,
0.08467254787683487,
-0.7653223276138306,
0.05017983540892601,
-0.11109715700149536,
0.6393961310386658,
0.2014336884021759,
-0.01618099771440029,
0.28247833251953125,
-0.4441360533237457,
0.6233798265457153,
0.24869120121002197,
-0.5646011233329773,
0.40486204624176025,
-0.43971359729766846,
0.2202490121126175,
0.6117031574249268,
0.5161769986152649,
-1.017439603805542,
-0.5961325764656067,
-0.38363975286483765,
-0.5728939175605774,
1.2805989980697632,
0.08049630373716354,
0.37469878792762756,
-0.16438966989517212,
0.25670287013053894,
0.22158309817314148,
0.48832428455352783,
-0.7057318687438965,
-0.4267832636833191,
0.6582137942314148,
-0.08046066015958786,
-0.12086402624845505,
-0.8474270701408386,
0.10757860541343689,
-0.18230967223644257,
0.4606632888317108,
0.3508185148239136,
0.2378312349319458,
-0.28548604249954224,
-0.02258828468620777,
0.02816068008542061,
0.5756876468658447,
0.8077816367149353,
0.7432005405426025,
0.018533993512392044,
0.08175457268953323,
0.33443787693977356,
-0.16707463562488556,
0.3747227191925049,
-0.1550922989845276,
-0.012759999372065067,
0.34550124406814575,
0.1015942320227623,
0.8052599430084229,
-0.15400175750255585,
-0.39969727396965027,
0.4034413993358612,
-0.2684462070465088,
-0.35005274415016174,
-0.30777648091316223,
0.10393483191728592,
0.1661730259656906,
0.5237386226654053,
0.3021193742752075,
-0.47852182388305664,
0.08556999266147614,
-0.7636723518371582,
-0.5908533930778503,
0.49053290486335754,
-0.10318724811077118,
-0.09230455011129379,
0.8010991811752319,
0.10878420621156693,
-0.6176746487617493,
0.8250517845153809,
-0.2506449222564697,
-0.5816006064414978,
0.7054140567779541,
0.667746901512146,
0.7415119409561157,
-0.7897191047668457,
0.28829237818717957,
0.25690919160842896,
0.18026846647262573,
-0.22224532067775726,
0.09635499119758606,
0.25294816493988037,
-0.6479830741882324,
0.011774052865803242,
-0.7007904648780823,
-0.5196537971496582,
0.0167127326130867,
-0.27371639013290405,
0.39543694257736206,
-0.6740867495536804,
-0.46817079186439514,
0.22685429453849792,
-0.6079182028770447,
-0.7276042103767395,
0.14647220075130463,
0.8651562929153442,
0.8539260625839233,
-0.9512996673583984,
0.4808723032474518,
1.0706119537353516,
0.08930353820323944,
-0.664756178855896,
-0.03886916860938072,
0.296069473028183,
-0.6940501928329468,
1.2271958589553833,
0.17810331284999847,
0.11842180043458939,
-0.3300815522670746,
-0.16076818108558655,
-0.9388091564178467,
0.9143474698066711,
0.8982923030853271,
-0.49899187684059143,
-0.1627640426158905,
0.35596001148223877,
0.412328839302063,
-0.31234726309776306,
0.6475057005882263,
0.58233243227005,
0.7171223759651184,
0.1488954722881317,
-1.3270437717437744,
-0.2475450336933136,
-0.0767379030585289,
0.31133565306663513,
0.10971532762050629,
-0.8311067819595337,
1.246880292892456,
-0.3092755377292633,
-0.24569056928157806,
-0.30935364961624146,
0.457472562789917,
0.5574638843536377,
0.31588688492774963,
0.6592023968696594,
-0.07387931644916534,
1.1163164377212524,
-0.3514580726623535,
1.1501153707504272,
0.014756353572010994,
0.23704102635383606,
0.8474763631820679,
-0.523197591304779,
0.4470614790916443,
0.37227222323417664,
-0.5244346857070923,
0.7685468792915344,
0.6907348036766052,
-0.003824212122708559,
0.007639002986252308,
0.500992476940155,
-0.21558497846126556,
-0.11891891062259674,
-0.6209819912910461,
-0.19916720688343048,
0.8864535093307495,
0.2991170585155487,
-0.8070571422576904,
-0.08107315748929977,
-0.014790999703109264,
0.18160350620746613,
0.013309990987181664,
-0.4949702322483063,
0.1436062604188919,
0.2081109583377838,
-0.49054861068725586,
0.24504518508911133,
0.35293471813201904,
0.5641804337501526,
-0.5007951259613037,
0.13700051605701447,
-0.07546577602624893,
0.08452656120061874,
-0.47655099630355835,
-0.9144855737686157,
0.0030863163992762566,
0.028432147577404976,
-0.6754378080368042,
-0.08378897607326508,
0.33163613080978394,
-0.579623281955719,
-0.5876101851463318,
0.24333617091178894,
0.4399310350418091,
0.23489099740982056,
-0.022342748939990997,
-0.4657289385795593,
0.19493213295936584,
-0.09697370231151581,
-0.3820238411426544,
0.29452410340309143,
0.16127733886241913,
-0.3024764955043793,
0.6823645830154419,
0.6224599480628967,
0.5593151450157166,
0.003986536990851164,
0.1096702590584755,
0.10847196727991104,
-0.6685143113136292,
-0.8442199230194092,
-1.1540343761444092,
0.21343526244163513,
-0.1292542666196823,
-0.014040784910321236,
0.4758332073688507,
0.28781893849372864,
0.5679670572280884,
0.02911277674138546,
0.6354570984840393,
0.1004066914319992,
0.5853233933448792,
-0.44640469551086426,
0.6150274276733398,
-0.47304272651672363,
0.21557801961898804,
-0.45402413606643677,
-1.4182794094085693,
-0.23461173474788666,
0.395863801240921,
-0.6360967755317688,
0.5561180114746094,
0.6449155807495117,
0.5281674861907959,
0.00842112023383379,
-0.05875995010137558,
0.4859973192214966,
0.2669844329357147,
0.18080277740955353,
0.5374417901039124,
0.9203038215637207,
0.23422448337078094,
0.11334455013275146,
0.22536452114582062,
0.18825708329677582,
-0.733361542224884,
-0.7702839970588684,
-0.7403303384780884,
-0.17668573558330536,
-0.4389022886753082,
-0.2614819407463074,
-0.0854928120970726,
1.165756344795227,
0.5528028011322021,
-0.6064571142196655,
-0.4655471742153168,
0.6842368841171265,
0.32511359453201294,
0.2089671939611435,
-0.23769864439964294,
-0.13420553505420685,
0.26630985736846924,
-0.9061610698699951,
0.19808277487754822,
0.19249987602233887,
0.07011979818344116,
-0.07850046455860138,
-0.02514209970831871,
-0.03685470670461655,
0.0842973068356514,
0.5559890270233154,
0.3657636046409607,
-0.6767846941947937,
-0.22811396420001984,
-0.4318864047527313,
-0.5769880414009094,
-0.27336806058883667,
0.9947732090950012,
-0.34564414620399475,
0.46702393889427185,
0.3253677487373352,
0.37260398268699646,
0.02480415813624859,
-0.12015660107135773,
0.6464059948921204,
-0.5746235847473145,
0.4384993016719818,
-0.09250256419181824,
0.5589323043823242,
0.27334192395210266,
-0.6280212998390198,
0.31573787331581116,
0.11759798973798752,
-0.4705812931060791,
-0.8620824813842773,
0.15116465091705322,
-0.5493342876434326,
-0.3567870259284973,
1.547199010848999,
0.4230767488479614,
-0.05910869315266609,
0.04680094122886658,
-0.12298932671546936,
0.0020180041901767254,
-0.39224836230278015,
0.6728823781013489,
0.9510714411735535,
0.11292034387588501,
-0.21228258311748505,
-0.8245116472244263,
0.1259635090827942,
0.22773562371730804,
-0.4104612171649933,
0.17825762927532196,
0.6014594435691833,
0.3209165930747986,
-0.10462329536676407,
0.6523923873901367,
0.12412308156490326,
0.44732216000556946,
-0.43815940618515015,
0.2050853669643402,
-0.08794279396533966,
-0.07120807468891144,
-0.44253867864608765,
0.04708173871040344,
0.6855981349945068,
0.21856366097927094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10478v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10478v2
|
From Words to Worlds: Transforming One-line Prompt into Immersive Multi-modal Digital Stories with Communicative LLM Agent
| 2024-06-15T03:03:43 | 2024-06-21T08:09:17 |
Samuel S. Sohn, Danrui Li, Sen Zhang, Che-Jui Chang, Mubbasir Kapadia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.GR
|
Digital storytelling, essential in entertainment, education, and marketing,
faces challenges in production scalability and flexibility. The StoryAgent
framework, introduced in this paper, utilizes Large Language Models and
generative tools to automate and refine digital storytelling. Employing a
top-down story drafting and bottom-up asset generation approach, StoryAgent
tackles key issues such as manual intervention, interactive scene
orchestration, and narrative consistency. This framework enables efficient
production of interactive and consistent narratives across multiple modalities,
democratizing content creation and enhancing engagement. Our results
demonstrate the framework's capability to produce coherent digital stories
without reference videos, marking a significant advancement in automated
digital storytelling.
|
[
-0.35223302245140076,
-0.8277311325073242,
0.5771188139915466,
0.37792497873306274,
-0.2807779014110565,
0.691232442855835,
-0.02386363223195076,
-0.578760027885437,
0.3854674696922302,
0.3927361071109772,
-0.9392884373664856,
-0.3367781639099121,
-0.43411704897880554,
0.13036036491394043,
-0.5030800700187683,
0.8784786462783813,
-0.3222941756248474,
-0.4924328923225403,
-0.33450865745544434,
-0.12188571691513062,
-0.5124766826629639,
-0.3333163261413574,
-0.6070688366889954,
-0.21331526339054108,
0.5348594188690186,
0.6103626489639282,
0.960993230342865,
0.6698015928268433,
0.12031134963035583,
0.37464773654937744,
0.5837000608444214,
0.6428311467170715,
-0.49067744612693787,
0.5555334091186523,
0.11377688497304916,
-0.24989235401153564,
-0.309506893157959,
-0.14178650081157684,
0.18999134004116058,
0.3571062684059143,
0.05031581223011017,
0.023474888876080513,
0.05293746292591095,
0.4246673583984375,
-0.10918959975242615,
0.12399169057607651,
-0.07589773088693619,
0.2288312464952469,
0.31079939007759094,
-0.6681868433952332,
-0.15633217990398407,
-0.4455066919326782,
0.3402315378189087,
-1.1965579986572266,
0.1309686005115509,
0.1561422348022461,
0.686485230922699,
0.3089391887187958,
-0.49385377764701843,
-0.6276094317436218,
-0.9804400205612183,
0.41764310002326965,
-0.31442561745643616,
0.15332947671413422,
0.16067346930503845,
0.3972230851650238,
0.2618739902973175,
-0.9858210682868958,
-0.7528985738754272,
-0.35028892755508423,
0.21366848051548004,
0.16180728375911713,
-0.3083617389202118,
-0.11086246371269226,
0.02888055518269539,
0.3266845643520355,
-0.5974180102348328,
0.06281907856464386,
-0.35363277792930603,
-0.1608227789402008,
0.6847518682479858,
0.5977088212966919,
0.6251043081283569,
0.02897125668823719,
-0.5533661246299744,
-0.20886661112308502,
-0.29501843452453613,
0.05365918204188347,
0.44334667921066284,
-0.1371159851551056,
-0.494471937417984,
0.6729115843772888,
0.0015092580579221249,
0.40696343779563904,
0.14400866627693176,
-0.5302199721336365,
0.024858713150024414,
-0.4720931649208069,
0.14907357096672058,
0.2928108274936676,
0.6106107831001282,
0.6729775667190552,
0.074239581823349,
-0.36656540632247925,
-0.15039733052253723,
0.13537642359733582,
0.1989651471376419,
-0.7047606706619263,
0.09355944395065308,
0.5230635404586792,
-0.12766994535923004,
-0.4212549328804016,
0.08975275605916977,
-0.34937140345573425,
-0.7535321116447449,
-0.4448900818824768,
0.4435186982154846,
-0.5123339295387268,
-0.11179949343204498,
0.15817034244537354,
-0.5374001860618591,
0.1623287796974182,
0.5795965790748596,
-0.5085681676864624,
0.27008405327796936,
0.4258674085140228,
0.919601321220398,
-0.38725951313972473,
-0.4481618404388428,
-0.3636305630207062,
0.2681995928287506,
-0.4299570918083191,
0.905826210975647,
-0.07761568576097488,
-0.3611326217651367,
-0.0027027952019125223,
-0.2826096713542938,
0.25343289971351624,
-0.300038605928421,
0.3173273801803589,
-0.32235395908355713,
0.219878688454628,
0.12793776392936707,
-0.4195040166378021,
-0.03096533939242363,
0.5303093791007996,
-0.6093286871910095,
0.4995756447315216,
0.04291882738471031,
-0.4057042598724365,
0.17136143147945404,
-0.6598550081253052,
-0.562781035900116,
0.3531586825847626,
0.0021336667705327272,
0.07216290384531021,
0.054657306522130966,
0.3662058115005493,
-0.000018420380001771264,
-0.1597781479358673,
0.38901302218437195,
0.23784348368644714,
-0.41063857078552246,
0.41614648699760437,
-0.8642016053199768,
0.4225972890853882,
0.16677896678447723,
-0.22841159999370575,
0.289176881313324,
-1.0546209812164307,
-0.035499632358551025,
0.24835970997810364,
-0.2963207960128784,
0.2772124409675598,
0.012511968612670898,
0.4628765881061554,
0.4320845603942871,
0.19638459384441376,
-0.5764817595481873,
0.31237027049064636,
-0.4141402244567871,
0.5184853672981262,
0.4523297846317291,
0.21623237431049347,
0.44388914108276367,
-0.846091091632843,
1.017434000968933,
0.010098070837557316,
-0.0660514310002327,
-1.0143648386001587,
-0.23139125108718872,
-0.812580943107605,
-0.2538473904132843,
-0.29809287190437317,
0.5656846165657043,
-1.1836843490600586,
0.28345122933387756,
-0.4063965976238251,
-0.5312639474868774,
-0.4194318354129791,
-0.08614390343427658,
-0.18671689927577972,
0.28830957412719727,
-0.0057497876696288586,
-0.08890869468450546,
-0.4023583233356476,
-0.617859423160553,
-0.026091482490301132,
-0.1373107135295868,
-0.1603027731180191,
0.13239136338233948,
-0.016501933336257935,
-0.20825088024139404,
1.2682727575302124,
-0.2631513774394989,
-0.19171112775802612,
-0.5450370907783508,
0.3998969495296478,
-0.10386213660240173,
0.2170475274324417,
0.0830245092511177,
-0.7680508494377136,
-0.5730350017547607,
0.05366428196430206,
-0.9320113658905029,
-0.44618284702301025,
-0.6421669721603394,
0.4209839999675751,
0.33346688747406006,
0.3787851631641388,
-0.7169772386550903,
0.39390167593955994,
0.546991229057312,
-0.4537058174610138,
0.5680624842643738,
-0.4249439835548401,
0.4143259823322296,
-1.0564454793930054,
-0.28994953632354736,
-0.20203076303005219,
-0.2764614522457123,
-0.36504340171813965,
0.0009367444436065853,
-0.32933905720710754,
-0.5103171467781067,
-0.602338969707489,
0.8870794773101807,
-0.4463004469871521,
0.009708382189273834,
-0.3721984922885895,
0.6119215488433838,
0.488982230424881,
0.42019733786582947,
-0.1485540270805359,
0.932654619216919,
0.4003497362136841,
-0.5103017091751099,
0.8119134902954102,
0.5120316743850708,
-0.2522166967391968,
0.9451804757118225,
-0.6445819735527039,
0.1694386750459671,
-0.2500235438346863,
0.46403467655181885,
-0.9641292691230774,
-0.2936765253543854,
0.17698073387145996,
-0.35496869683265686,
-0.14175544679164886,
0.43477243185043335,
-0.9309133291244507,
-0.286293625831604,
-0.2640249729156494,
-0.0034880456514656544,
0.1567743867635727,
-0.6098392009735107,
0.5730085968971252,
0.09913524985313416,
-0.44596222043037415,
0.081871896982193,
-0.6796084046363831,
0.762602686882019,
-0.29729214310646057,
-1.0119799375534058,
0.49801287055015564,
-0.6558842062950134,
-0.34509652853012085,
-0.22857347130775452,
-0.055476248264312744,
-0.26862019300460815,
-0.1547470986843109,
0.28239190578460693,
0.0998341292142868,
-0.14278221130371094,
0.2441169023513794,
0.294836163520813,
-0.256112277507782,
-0.07978476583957672,
-0.3400188684463501,
0.37983086705207825,
0.14003480970859528,
-0.27170330286026,
-0.20222726464271545,
0.696709394454956,
0.8760754466056824,
-0.22476288676261902,
0.27603891491889954,
0.6511335372924805,
-0.061564382165670395,
-0.31965628266334534,
-0.3343193531036377,
-0.014536517672240734,
-0.5040302872657776,
0.34509173035621643,
-0.44431427121162415,
-0.9806073904037476,
0.5197860598564148,
-0.09790202975273132,
0.09387567639350891,
0.08598900586366653,
0.3920196294784546,
0.11686752736568451,
0.9304917454719543,
0.7070389986038208,
0.4797206521034241,
0.14528754353523254,
0.004691953305155039,
0.4207281172275543,
-0.09304898232221603,
-0.00009933477849699557,
0.06161745637655258,
-0.2551310062408447,
-0.23698392510414124,
-0.24091194570064545,
0.7665166854858398,
-0.01832161843776703,
-0.04554624855518341,
0.23704805970191956,
-0.30744314193725586,
0.5957905054092407,
0.27809879183769226,
-0.012015274725854397,
0.8830285668373108,
-0.03601017966866493,
-0.10706619918346405,
-0.14283764362335205,
-0.5658231377601624,
-0.740926206111908,
0.4765894412994385,
0.46102285385131836,
0.7898697257041931,
0.3149527907371521,
0.5881325006484985,
0.5134893655776978,
0.009842424653470516,
-0.9876534938812256,
0.5339785218238831,
0.4344979226589203,
-0.5944502949714661,
-0.2898011803627014,
0.22682666778564453,
-0.7040131092071533,
0.2682984471321106,
-0.28371962904930115,
-0.7937572002410889,
0.03829800337553024,
-0.43909257650375366,
-0.4656130075454712,
0.03304598107933998,
-0.5661659836769104,
0.607406735420227,
-0.3491302728652954,
-0.5028372406959534,
-0.2015453428030014,
-0.5959128141403198,
0.04748015105724335,
-0.4137532413005829,
0.07027003914117813,
-0.05708206072449684,
-0.4325716495513916,
0.224469855427742,
-0.538974940776825,
0.7965678572654724,
0.45504099130630493,
-0.39305663108825684,
0.7138859629631042,
0.42267724871635437,
0.4404490292072296,
0.11021705716848373,
0.11792661249637604,
0.03650270029902458,
0.01288748811930418,
-0.1441812366247177,
-0.47401419281959534,
0.6034469604492188,
-0.6691232919692993,
-0.5727118253707886,
-0.21218524873256683,
-1.1006840467453003,
-0.29721879959106445,
0.21573816239833832,
0.31093189120292664,
0.5811748504638672,
-0.6335371732711792,
0.0973193496465683,
0.30644530057907104,
-0.41246604919433594,
1.0795717239379883,
0.40837112069129944,
-0.12749841809272766,
-0.521310031414032,
0.7178075313568115,
0.10985926538705826,
0.2067343294620514,
0.19439288973808289,
-0.03774184733629227,
-0.2711402177810669,
-0.11019773036241531,
-0.8150294423103333,
-0.27365589141845703,
-0.7808541059494019,
-0.18535855412483215,
-0.9511438012123108,
-0.1613396406173706,
0.046074315905570984,
-0.679506242275238,
-0.18194203078746796,
-0.3705500066280365,
-0.15437966585159302,
-0.47586795687675476,
0.24443307518959045,
0.7524362206459045,
-0.15269504487514496,
0.536766529083252,
-1.083667516708374,
0.3888813853263855,
0.2910086214542389,
-0.015736283734440804,
-0.09228493273258209,
-0.13346552848815918,
-0.2507549524307251,
-0.1611822545528412,
-0.5817564725875854,
-0.7268883585929871,
0.5998178720474243,
0.23677527904510498,
0.22675232589244843,
0.20655417442321777,
0.15630695223808289,
0.49244001507759094,
-0.4417920410633087,
0.9006840586662292,
0.31457167863845825,
-0.9468456506729126,
0.30073386430740356,
-0.7760593891143799,
0.48284563422203064,
0.1152520552277565,
0.06895871460437775,
-0.692828357219696,
-0.3846163749694824,
-0.6274701356887817,
-0.8391836285591125,
0.6401051878929138,
0.23942647874355316,
0.4715336263179779,
0.028740502893924713,
-0.1406240612268448,
0.5682065486907959,
0.48154416680336,
-0.6407127976417542,
-0.24033460021018982,
-0.28124919533729553,
-0.22992143034934998,
-0.13723205029964447,
-0.03233643248677254,
-0.12492387741804123,
0.010692954063415527,
0.26786646246910095,
-0.3225337266921997,
0.026766594499349594,
0.3503328561782837,
-0.31542351841926575,
-0.4427894055843353,
0.448048859834671,
0.6215569972991943,
1.0263724327087402,
0.243017315864563,
-0.04695805907249451,
-0.14947035908699036,
-0.28436586260795593,
0.5216586589813232,
0.29827558994293213,
-0.08133111894130707,
-0.03332529217004776,
0.44212639331817627,
0.7890487313270569,
0.22310489416122437,
-0.8144615888595581,
0.4353814423084259,
-0.042818449437618256,
-0.28185561299324036,
-0.34600046277046204,
-0.14501003921031952,
0.20381341874599457,
0.5039966106414795,
0.684847354888916,
-0.06095577031373978,
0.02792533114552498,
-0.446120947599411,
0.4361252784729004,
-0.07199177145957947,
-0.43468809127807617,
-0.23325850069522858,
0.5795572996139526,
0.4799479842185974,
-0.4429493844509125,
0.16980014741420746,
-0.060959070920944214,
-0.1742824763059616,
0.7176284193992615,
0.905920147895813,
1.0400137901306152,
0.28131550550460815,
0.7326291799545288,
-0.20814605057239532,
0.32844850420951843,
0.18577417731285095,
-0.1694919764995575,
-0.1454554945230484,
-0.7494303584098816,
-0.3110673725605011,
-0.31731006503105164,
-0.49553000926971436,
-0.07501892000436783,
-0.14082491397857666,
0.1615186631679535,
-0.48290693759918213,
0.237457275390625,
-0.07619822770357132,
-0.0033423195127397776,
-0.4785347878932953,
0.1922309249639511,
0.3904580771923065,
0.8943488597869873,
-0.5525496602058411,
0.3829469382762909,
0.6207643151283264,
-0.6893565058708191,
-0.7069531679153442,
0.1724608838558197,
0.31984174251556396,
-0.45644262433052063,
0.3931349813938141,
0.24010024964809418,
-0.06972988694906235,
0.45018112659454346,
-0.5959031581878662,
-0.6151477098464966,
1.3030492067337036,
0.3599434494972229,
-0.5262755155563354,
-0.08511503785848618,
0.367472380399704,
0.6577274799346924,
-0.8186154961585999,
0.11576221883296967,
0.08393924683332443,
0.4263235032558441,
0.45953601598739624,
-0.8392183184623718,
-0.23462995886802673,
-0.09060786664485931,
-0.17319519817829132,
-0.16176724433898926,
-0.4449823498725891,
0.5826695561408997,
-0.26847168803215027,
-0.42707768082618713,
0.21827781200408936,
0.5357433557510376,
0.4757944345474243,
0.4710325300693512,
0.23182615637779236,
0.24916167557239532,
0.5347557067871094,
0.1336376816034317,
1.0588135719299316,
-0.33554771542549133,
-0.09536585211753845,
0.9562764167785645,
-0.3103959858417511,
0.24685196578502655,
0.28734466433525085,
0.07448482513427734,
0.5453782677650452,
0.604714572429657,
0.19001074135303497,
0.2593320906162262,
0.2770102918148041,
-0.6042371392250061,
-0.18647637963294983,
-0.37938833236694336,
-0.018360191956162453,
0.5037252902984619,
0.11878734827041626,
0.11258852481842041,
-0.5151703953742981,
0.4121786952018738,
-0.10987186431884766,
0.2940010726451874,
-0.15940502285957336,
0.73494952917099,
0.13793215155601501,
-0.47014734148979187,
0.23744750022888184,
-0.19937975704669952,
0.6120755076408386,
-0.6327990293502808,
-0.2110198438167572,
-0.2262781709432602,
-0.04757758975028992,
-0.05303578078746796,
-0.5225045084953308,
0.06566967070102692,
-0.07292802631855011,
-0.11029379814863205,
-0.5250480771064758,
0.9698419570922852,
-0.5364469885826111,
-0.3114003539085388,
0.03058476559817791,
0.916450023651123,
-0.10548916459083557,
-0.16853907704353333,
-0.7383205890655518,
0.2716854512691498,
-0.2967052161693573,
-0.20994621515274048,
-0.10064947605133057,
0.8252841830253601,
-0.1387805938720703,
0.7519921660423279,
0.5525776743888855,
-0.24161048233509064,
-0.17058750987052917,
-0.01108126062899828,
0.588890790939331,
-0.6765139698982239,
-1.0447527170181274,
-0.4852222204208374,
0.9828912615776062,
0.1534498780965805,
-0.2745535373687744,
0.7881597876548767,
0.5088451504707336,
0.6019842028617859,
-0.12581726908683777,
0.995534360408783,
-0.09296444803476334,
0.12451661378145218,
-0.05962768942117691,
0.7569570541381836,
-0.3414520025253296,
0.3194875121116638,
0.09759534150362015,
-1.104115605354309,
-0.07712215185165405,
0.1404910683631897,
0.34641358256340027,
-0.16772854328155518,
0.8428884148597717,
0.49745675921440125,
-0.05014701187610626,
-0.06103944778442383,
0.648942232131958,
0.071021169424057,
0.40904882550239563,
0.1313043236732483,
0.985316276550293,
-0.5557472109794617,
0.6231793761253357,
0.09544073045253754,
-0.12577833235263824,
0.07973010838031769,
-0.9857529401779175,
-0.7845495343208313,
-0.6418581008911133,
-0.47216662764549255,
-0.3134378492832184,
0.039059460163116455,
1.0339380502700806,
0.5207350850105286,
-0.20362484455108643,
-0.3152156472206116,
-0.09429986029863358,
-0.026603860780596733,
-0.12071588635444641,
-0.287331759929657,
-0.1768808215856552,
-0.1534898281097412,
-0.8105324506759644,
0.6376737952232361,
0.6989942193031311,
0.1571354866027832,
-0.6848888397216797,
-0.2374444156885147,
0.16474860906600952,
0.4442269802093506,
0.8047351241111755,
0.15830440819263458,
-0.5838959217071533,
-0.1447668820619583,
0.012455691583454609,
-0.3221246898174286,
0.267693430185318,
0.7988828420639038,
-0.7580509781837463,
0.5687210559844971,
0.26999610662460327,
0.6199033856391907,
0.508773922920227,
-0.18415705859661102,
0.9015043377876282,
-0.8733531832695007,
0.1467418223619461,
0.147722065448761,
-0.11251667141914368,
0.44274961948394775,
-0.4167325496673584,
0.31437715888023376,
0.23453205823898315,
-0.24347350001335144,
-0.3552786707878113,
0.32493990659713745,
-1.1797046661376953,
-0.19403322041034698,
1.1592625379562378,
-0.014173855073750019,
-0.1090114414691925,
-0.3487483561038971,
-0.6453831195831299,
0.0519491471350193,
-0.30992454290390015,
0.39046263694763184,
0.901804506778717,
0.024359971284866333,
-0.6362638473510742,
-0.5017917156219482,
0.28966179490089417,
-0.1905045360326767,
-0.9950483441352844,
0.0011946798767894506,
0.8869693875312805,
0.09354378283023834,
0.15695229172706604,
0.6626582741737366,
-0.01967209205031395,
0.07341300696134567,
0.3938359022140503,
0.19026166200637817,
-0.5926718711853027,
-0.31460902094841003,
-0.22799839079380035,
0.24743826687335968,
-0.2667490243911743,
0.10957606136798859
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.03190v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.03190v1
|
Cutting through the noise to motivate people: A comprehensive analysis of COVID-19 social media posts de/motivating vaccination
| 2024-06-15T02:36:11 | 2024-06-15T02:36:11 |
Ashiqur Rahman, Ehsan Mohammadi, Hamed Alhoori
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
The COVID-19 pandemic exposed significant weaknesses in the healthcare
information system. The overwhelming volume of misinformation on social media
and other socioeconomic factors created extraordinary challenges to motivate
people to take proper precautions and get vaccinated. In this context, our work
explored a novel direction by analyzing an extensive dataset collected over two
years, identifying the topics de/motivating the public about COVID-19
vaccination. We analyzed these topics based on time, geographic location, and
political orientation. We noticed that while the motivating topics remain the
same over time and geographic location, the demotivating topics rapidly. We
also identified that intrinsic motivation, rather than external mandate, is
more advantageous to inspire the public. This study addresses scientific
communication and public motivation in social media. It can help public health
officials, policymakers, and social media platforms develop more effective
messaging strategies to cut through the noise of misinformation and educate the
public about scientific findings.
|
[
-0.12415405362844467,
-0.7112085819244385,
0.5938736796379089,
0.2611120939254761,
-0.47459277510643005,
0.1910509467124939,
0.023107780143618584,
-0.18568740785121918,
0.6226641535758972,
-0.17275194823741913,
-0.547879695892334,
-0.4762812554836273,
-0.572508692741394,
-0.006791577208787203,
-0.2466447502374649,
1.0012363195419312,
0.1183224618434906,
-0.20182308554649353,
-0.3754273056983948,
0.24614088237285614,
0.06794248521327972,
-0.737633466720581,
-0.6440853476524353,
-0.31641292572021484,
1.0101256370544434,
0.5173999667167664,
0.02666632831096649,
0.01581231877207756,
0.4339350461959839,
0.022281410172581673,
-0.1077953577041626,
-0.003937097266316414,
-0.8779688477516174,
-0.0785212442278862,
-0.2466929703950882,
-0.23845835030078888,
0.2666853070259094,
0.24765419960021973,
0.21701085567474365,
0.2423669397830963,
-0.28674301505088806,
0.4555223882198334,
0.12365174293518066,
0.4877605736255646,
-0.6939364671707153,
0.020559389144182205,
-0.4352990686893463,
-0.1326255053281784,
-0.4500437378883362,
-0.7893388867378235,
-0.03746560961008072,
-0.40532249212265015,
-0.0508677139878273,
-0.5481367707252502,
0.3190523386001587,
-0.6139819622039795,
1.0971678495407104,
-0.014494525268673897,
-0.6789814233779907,
-0.2482488751411438,
-0.81428462266922,
0.488861620426178,
-0.01951320841908455,
0.11180119961500168,
0.5238174200057983,
0.11497875303030014,
-0.03973444923758507,
-0.35614219307899475,
-0.11681968718767166,
0.4635780155658722,
0.42270466685295105,
0.12580953538417816,
-0.5862302184104919,
-0.25960084795951843,
-0.061025090515613556,
0.11466526985168457,
-0.3192808926105499,
-0.22411315143108368,
-0.8895928859710693,
-0.1688104122877121,
0.7030744552612305,
-0.14562711119651794,
0.42777347564697266,
-0.05202735215425491,
-0.0855507180094719,
-0.10284963995218277,
-0.5259352326393127,
0.7191400527954102,
0.01991581730544567,
-0.09547705948352814,
-0.6034286618232727,
0.3560214340686798,
-0.19047598540782928,
-0.04288066551089287,
0.37953031063079834,
-0.25057852268218994,
-0.029652968049049377,
-0.5187520384788513,
0.16166049242019653,
0.3853231966495514,
0.47237882018089294,
0.6450398564338684,
-0.30381903052330017,
0.1850764900445938,
0.10341212153434753,
0.2616181969642639,
0.39773130416870117,
-1.0873581171035767,
-0.11085491627454758,
0.22976790368556976,
-0.6630812883377075,
-0.5690067410469055,
0.3342318832874298,
-0.7824867963790894,
-0.6286859512329102,
-0.1446639597415924,
0.1146707758307457,
-0.3170085549354553,
-0.242902934551239,
0.06998131424188614,
-0.604081392288208,
0.03545520454645157,
0.6356183290481567,
-0.781731367111206,
0.07142525911331177,
1.0297130346298218,
1.190525770187378,
0.12554453313350677,
0.5870081186294556,
-0.4548110067844391,
0.1580122411251068,
-0.533715009689331,
0.6659982204437256,
-0.448888897895813,
-0.22820204496383667,
0.08360405266284943,
-0.1845509111881256,
-0.08853776752948761,
-0.44752541184425354,
0.45411285758018494,
-0.3227068781852722,
0.08360376209020615,
-0.6750617027282715,
-0.017632942646741867,
-0.3698314428329468,
0.36615949869155884,
-0.1372062861919403,
0.4740298390388489,
0.09910084307193756,
-0.4397928714752197,
0.5033190250396729,
-0.5760496258735657,
-0.5743125081062317,
0.19055268168449402,
-0.47120633721351624,
-0.45652374625205994,
0.3914148807525635,
0.3656938374042511,
0.23770692944526672,
-0.5923402309417725,
0.4959161877632141,
-0.465286523103714,
-0.20819583535194397,
-0.1974073201417923,
-0.39366137981414795,
1.0759847164154053,
0.20831039547920227,
-0.32300832867622375,
0.02909979782998562,
-0.37729737162590027,
-0.5793534517288208,
0.05297718942165375,
-0.34021008014678955,
-0.5921858549118042,
-0.02079576440155506,
-0.16631639003753662,
0.4388154447078705,
-0.037586040794849396,
-0.5874413847923279,
0.12996536493301392,
-0.2693483829498291,
0.6557714939117432,
0.3915318250656128,
0.8880374431610107,
0.013661747798323631,
-0.668529748916626,
0.8871196508407593,
0.03881936892867088,
0.5645083785057068,
0.220187708735466,
-0.7068184614181519,
0.004167927894741297,
-0.3238809406757355,
-0.4227595627307892,
0.3463045656681061,
-0.3167027235031128,
0.10629928112030029,
-0.0938602015376091,
-0.9401143193244934,
-0.4949927031993866,
-0.06220610439777374,
-0.24890325963497162,
0.6340343952178955,
0.06038416922092438,
-0.17710720002651215,
-0.47125566005706787,
-0.4092232882976532,
-0.10706967860460281,
-0.1612551510334015,
0.2717076241970062,
0.07594101876020432,
0.6234137415885925,
-0.11442173272371292,
0.42060187458992004,
-0.2556469440460205,
-0.17480121552944183,
-0.12731608748435974,
0.3635774850845337,
0.38775449991226196,
0.14734777808189392,
0.5688570141792297,
-0.9746208190917969,
-0.46356263756752014,
0.3030005991458893,
-0.4994555115699768,
-0.36493492126464844,
-0.35224950313568115,
0.30204492807388306,
-0.5539666414260864,
0.41881072521209717,
-0.44964444637298584,
0.8483374118804932,
0.3526803255081177,
-0.11984807252883911,
0.6229215264320374,
0.05533197894692421,
0.5881796479225159,
-0.7577720284461975,
0.21882210671901703,
0.30707332491874695,
0.11841072142124176,
-0.7265162467956543,
-0.23013614118099213,
-0.28418630361557007,
-0.5303102731704712,
-0.4741407632827759,
0.3477676808834076,
0.04452505707740784,
0.6170966625213623,
-0.13372865319252014,
-0.4759725332260132,
0.2989831268787384,
-0.2752523422241211,
-0.16706667840480804,
0.43788206577301025,
0.7128351926803589,
-0.7813388705253601,
0.6372084617614746,
0.1137482076883316,
-0.4433140158653259,
0.49586573243141174,
-0.8995952010154724,
-0.21211808919906616,
-0.38580286502838135,
0.4128957688808441,
-0.5223367214202881,
-0.6146101355552673,
0.5254905819892883,
-0.4435085654258728,
-0.5096046924591064,
0.14756859838962555,
0.1137629821896553,
-0.6825435757637024,
-0.24474865198135376,
0.16537271440029144,
0.2723296880722046,
-0.2797684371471405,
0.27406442165374756,
0.5364143252372742,
-0.2155781388282776,
-0.005060531198978424,
-0.6492952108383179,
0.23540842533111572,
-0.6230875849723816,
-0.5133392810821533,
0.5525546073913574,
0.206861212849617,
-0.612849235534668,
-0.1844317764043808,
-0.45567479729652405,
0.09921510517597198,
0.2440791130065918,
0.3637189269065857,
-0.13644535839557648,
-0.17051756381988525,
0.2680908441543579,
-0.04898873344063759,
-0.046444062143564224,
0.23922516405582428,
-0.0009327221196144819,
0.7227818965911865,
0.16938351094722748,
-0.3739256262779236,
-1.1513410806655884,
0.754447877407074,
0.34954798221588135,
0.048398301005363464,
0.6459411978721619,
0.5079205632209778,
-0.370633602142334,
0.2961474359035492,
-0.4258933663368225,
-0.46155163645744324,
-0.40838733315467834,
0.00283751985989511,
0.2314758449792862,
-0.6845784783363342,
0.1339578628540039,
-0.18321649730205536,
-0.11114072054624557,
0.2016180157661438,
0.5358932614326477,
-0.11136692017316818,
0.5781058669090271,
0.25512343645095825,
-0.04169657453894615,
0.5003151297569275,
0.20685258507728577,
0.10119642317295074,
-0.021632330492138863,
-0.6908748745918274,
-0.49421635270118713,
-0.11830513179302216,
0.005304264836013317,
-0.42543572187423706,
0.7281283736228943,
0.24971169233322144,
0.026932576671242714,
0.03347160667181015,
-0.8974248766899109,
-0.03824642673134804,
0.6937987208366394,
0.4552803635597229,
-0.18491099774837494,
0.20769952237606049,
0.24503780901432037,
0.09043844044208527,
-0.6782426238059998,
-0.19287435710430145,
0.48627936840057373,
0.2389967292547226,
0.7385593056678772,
0.24238422513008118,
0.8626610040664673,
0.5147923231124878,
0.031037740409374237,
-0.6113477945327759,
0.3627412021160126,
0.11801426112651825,
-0.5363671779632568,
-0.036794938147068024,
-0.38497960567474365,
-1.2520928382873535,
-0.25169631838798523,
-0.3012174665927887,
-0.6435468196868896,
0.8839965462684631,
0.03321624547243118,
-0.6079759001731873,
-0.10065535455942154,
-0.5379047393798828,
0.6140981316566467,
-0.20722396671772003,
-0.09419804066419601,
-0.6044570803642273,
-0.3300646245479584,
0.013225999660789967,
-0.1233135461807251,
0.34443774819374084,
-0.45201432704925537,
0.20195472240447998,
0.8173580169677734,
-0.5458160042762756,
1.0384498834609985,
-0.015804655849933624,
0.22457295656204224,
0.5358924269676208,
-0.47726941108703613,
0.38547852635383606,
0.38124799728393555,
0.03956688567996025,
0.14725108444690704,
0.08955507725477219,
-0.4473203718662262,
-0.231075718998909,
0.3888193368911743,
-0.7770600914955139,
-0.912222683429718,
-0.4271095395088196,
-0.07686898112297058,
0.2550833821296692,
0.03028997778892517,
0.43486982583999634,
0.4468221664428711,
-0.4065793454647064,
0.5673094391822815,
0.5804889798164368,
-0.052992306649684906,
0.25927871465682983,
0.1368759572505951,
-0.006808268837630749,
-0.47778671979904175,
0.8710996508598328,
0.27025118470191956,
0.21226099133491516,
0.5719818472862244,
0.7956369519233704,
0.10422743111848831,
-0.11358782649040222,
0.22504812479019165,
0.20288951694965363,
-0.4299481511116028,
0.18254108726978302,
-0.585352897644043,
-0.1334059089422226,
-1.121283769607544,
-0.2748943567276001,
-0.022652188315987587,
-0.016115447506308556,
-0.724737286567688,
0.11403724551200867,
0.43489140272140503,
0.9377731084823608,
-0.5338954329490662,
0.19227679073810577,
-0.6140447854995728,
0.2613632380962372,
0.6833009123802185,
-0.32817932963371277,
-0.16281184554100037,
-0.07868600636720657,
-0.3387536108493805,
0.11535467207431793,
-0.6395628452301025,
-1.0150386095046997,
0.2654682695865631,
-0.032833922654390335,
0.4314233362674713,
0.8208839297294617,
0.3744915723800659,
0.7425006031990051,
0.11447489261627197,
0.6636565923690796,
0.4625047743320465,
-0.6936476826667786,
0.7381027340888977,
-0.5682410001754761,
0.48406094312667847,
0.5760931968688965,
0.8137909770011902,
-0.9301550984382629,
0.0311253871768713,
-0.5423142313957214,
-0.6669542193412781,
0.19327755272388458,
-0.04301448166370392,
-0.04620644822716713,
0.10902350395917892,
-0.03207401558756828,
0.025586307048797607,
0.1301044225692749,
-0.408952921628952,
-0.11833638697862625,
-0.4536116421222687,
0.12695345282554626,
0.19083964824676514,
-0.13429497182369232,
-0.8233394622802734,
-0.4983178675174713,
0.5253888368606567,
0.2337331920862198,
0.1680796593427658,
0.5545695424079895,
0.4768437147140503,
-0.30220267176628113,
0.2001602053642273,
0.8383316993713379,
0.6965171098709106,
-0.08890368789434433,
0.28909164667129517,
-0.45303311944007874,
-0.6170513033866882,
0.27848586440086365,
0.082513727247715,
-0.4564204514026642,
0.27424633502960205,
0.12402292340993881,
0.891602098941803,
-0.04277165234088898,
-0.1684388518333435,
0.606695830821991,
0.3097189962863922,
-0.45132553577423096,
-0.07303202897310257,
0.010576960630714893,
0.29850447177886963,
0.09248458594083786,
0.7198278307914734,
0.10903308540582657,
-0.12109273672103882,
-0.606941819190979,
0.1653294563293457,
0.5461022257804871,
-0.5805878639221191,
-0.6325519680976868,
0.7004081010818481,
0.21126078069210052,
-0.39626607298851013,
0.10695987939834595,
0.22830422222614288,
-0.14716991782188416,
0.6194865703582764,
0.4050808250904083,
0.4157165586948395,
-0.30298206210136414,
0.6543611288070679,
0.4336423873901367,
0.3765200078487396,
-0.256226122379303,
-0.03413521498441696,
-0.08797115087509155,
-0.3516100347042084,
-0.34805920720100403,
-0.08385124057531357,
-0.22703684866428375,
0.4688996374607086,
-0.6700207591056824,
0.5569552779197693,
-0.3860570788383484,
-0.5147855877876282,
0.38446512818336487,
-0.3990481495857239,
-0.38033702969551086,
0.11766207963228226,
0.07559464126825333,
0.87043696641922,
-1.1289212703704834,
0.2786237895488739,
0.6307750940322876,
-0.6658293604850769,
-0.5955219864845276,
0.31965842843055725,
0.38170725107192993,
-0.5731862783432007,
0.4773576557636261,
0.35072752833366394,
0.20624613761901855,
-0.45959851145744324,
-0.8025341629981995,
-0.876267671585083,
0.9119360446929932,
0.27819451689720154,
-0.2531707286834717,
-0.10500066727399826,
0.14511704444885254,
0.276694118976593,
-0.5191211700439453,
-0.21844278275966644,
0.054894573986530304,
0.5778005719184875,
0.01445740181952715,
-0.6740467548370361,
-0.09861180931329727,
-0.4345899224281311,
-0.40187060832977295,
-0.061610568314790726,
-0.7851827144622803,
0.4282829761505127,
-0.17371565103530884,
-0.45004522800445557,
-0.658339262008667,
0.5476670265197754,
0.27455565333366394,
1.0379893779754639,
0.3185138702392578,
0.30365410447120667,
0.9796998500823975,
0.00463319243863225,
1.0234124660491943,
0.0935363844037056,
0.07637514919042587,
0.5910693407058716,
0.00821483600884676,
0.40544816851615906,
0.8853091597557068,
0.025216488167643547,
0.3752468228340149,
0.6728616952896118,
0.023176705464720726,
0.6989396810531616,
-0.10552331805229187,
-0.6466546654701233,
-0.5032733082771301,
-0.5910302400588989,
-0.7814508676528931,
0.43297940492630005,
0.47801440954208374,
-0.352742999792099,
-0.4400632381439209,
0.4046434462070465,
-0.022579068318009377,
0.021871622651815414,
-0.2913762629032135,
0.6329209208488464,
0.18372873961925507,
-0.48016995191574097,
0.38316795229911804,
-0.38210898637771606,
0.23640359938144684,
-0.5511758327484131,
0.0011375407921150327,
0.4218090772628784,
-0.2120422124862671,
-0.1744993031024933,
-0.22406339645385742,
0.6413286328315735,
-0.3168834447860718,
-0.3429110050201416,
-0.5942776203155518,
0.8983633518218994,
-0.268934965133667,
-0.23983444273471832,
-0.0622236430644989,
0.3021148145198822,
0.14302366971969604,
-0.4128740429878235,
-0.8841806650161743,
0.34927746653556824,
-0.022524753585457802,
-0.24862422049045563,
0.2556305527687073,
0.571312427520752,
0.03718139976263046,
0.4829162359237671,
1.0420023202896118,
0.48658981919288635,
-0.4230106472969055,
-0.11030273884534836,
0.6922441124916077,
-0.5163964629173279,
-0.6492162346839905,
-0.971651554107666,
0.3435315191745758,
-0.4898545742034912,
-0.5661754012107849,
0.7990319728851318,
0.6166375279426575,
0.32825541496276855,
-0.09363222122192383,
0.8425022959709167,
-0.09974075108766556,
0.42729857563972473,
0.14627856016159058,
0.8137339353561401,
-0.5957162380218506,
-0.06119344010949135,
0.13368387520313263,
-0.11885981261730194,
-0.22044821083545685,
0.23869948089122772,
-0.744498074054718,
-0.38400256633758545,
0.36369603872299194,
0.807134211063385,
0.46058884263038635,
0.029717067256569862,
0.09455462545156479,
-0.11975785344839096,
0.5183631181716919,
0.09914123266935349,
0.7626680731773376,
0.03932946175336838,
0.5658167600631714,
-0.45321011543273926,
-0.40374404191970825,
-0.7741692066192627,
-0.6615520715713501,
-0.8084263205528259,
-0.6423085331916809,
-0.6476751565933228,
-0.7580347657203674,
0.31451475620269775,
1.1712701320648193,
0.6995198130607605,
-0.6729703545570374,
0.0023994301445782185,
-0.22869126498699188,
0.35678431391716003,
-0.5648671388626099,
-0.31615349650382996,
0.12336493283510208,
0.11594405025243759,
-0.214419424533844,
0.35345232486724854,
0.6416155695915222,
-0.0540960468351841,
-0.07134012132883072,
0.3476314842700958,
-0.5578012466430664,
0.1386725753545761,
0.5066593289375305,
0.6810364723205566,
-0.4777027368545532,
0.09357675909996033,
-0.007816423662006855,
-0.742702841758728,
0.1287897229194641,
0.854536771774292,
-0.32732245326042175,
0.19354063272476196,
0.8585140109062195,
0.6705405712127686,
0.3131544589996338,
0.29359668493270874,
0.6258776783943176,
-0.32175832986831665,
-0.16320443153381348,
0.38067495822906494,
0.009674916043877602,
0.23369193077087402,
-0.5649380087852478,
0.3521284759044647,
0.7450592517852783,
-0.5317752957344055,
-0.7198551893234253,
-0.0765913724899292,
-0.874241828918457,
-0.20918229222297668,
1.5533884763717651,
0.27220436930656433,
-0.6091067790985107,
-0.646725058555603,
-0.2578884959220886,
0.308615505695343,
-0.8832671642303467,
1.2087980508804321,
0.7541287541389465,
-0.00928659737110138,
-0.20197036862373352,
-0.24943910539150238,
0.4880926311016083,
0.2835031747817993,
-0.8636224269866943,
-0.23566916584968567,
-0.02384447678923607,
-0.08655312657356262,
0.15143869817256927,
0.9199134707450867,
0.12348605692386627,
0.6564401388168335,
0.07801725715398788,
-0.04026711732149124,
0.001210175920277834,
-0.1282302886247635,
-0.2235618680715561,
0.4171617925167084,
-0.43429866433143616,
-0.06590105593204498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10471v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10471v1
|
Personalized Pieces: Efficient Personalized Large Language Models through Collaborative Efforts
| 2024-06-15T02:26:18 | 2024-06-15T02:26:18 |
Zhaoxuan Tan, Zheyuan Liu, Meng Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Personalized large language models (LLMs) aim to tailor interactions,
content, and recommendations to individual user preferences. While
parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods excel in performance and
generalization, they are costly and limit communal benefits when used
individually. To this end, we introduce Personalized Pieces (Per-Pcs), a
framework that allows users to safely share and assemble personalized PEFT
efficiently with collaborative efforts. Per-Pcs involves selecting sharers,
breaking their PEFT into pieces, and training gates for each piece. These
pieces are added to a pool, from which target users can select and assemble
personalized PEFT using their history data. This approach preserves privacy and
enables fine-grained user modeling without excessive storage and computation
demands. Experimental results show Per-Pcs outperforms non-personalized and
PEFT retrieval baselines, offering performance comparable to OPPU with
significantly lower resource use across six tasks. Further analysis highlights
Per-Pcs's robustness concerning sharer count and selection strategy, pieces
sharing ratio, and scalability in computation time and storage space. Per-Pcs's
modularity promotes safe sharing, making LLM personalization more efficient,
effective, and widely accessible through collaborative efforts.
|
[
-0.38347384333610535,
-0.8038545250892639,
0.7365180850028992,
0.37913960218429565,
-0.1221495270729065,
0.3187098503112793,
-0.5147467851638794,
-0.24216143786907196,
0.17213314771652222,
0.7241060137748718,
-0.460660457611084,
-0.5268415808677673,
-0.23464787006378174,
0.06459534168243408,
-0.33909061551094055,
0.8249046206474304,
0.19159609079360962,
-0.34193214774131775,
-0.14247047901153564,
0.05347175523638725,
-0.2777520716190338,
-0.7538415193557739,
-0.7280156016349792,
-0.2963637113571167,
0.8441532254219055,
0.6175459623336792,
0.7607099413871765,
0.9709368348121643,
0.523613691329956,
0.48474979400634766,
-0.1701735258102417,
0.09220990538597107,
-0.6749202609062195,
0.22855794429779053,
-0.45818692445755005,
-0.3283434510231018,
-0.7998716831207275,
-0.27036038041114807,
0.31080275774002075,
0.7507815957069397,
-0.2893243134021759,
-0.027755459770560265,
0.07765829563140869,
0.693193256855011,
-0.48174840211868286,
-0.005403339862823486,
-0.6265570521354675,
0.11171727627515793,
-0.4930881857872009,
-0.13655124604701996,
-0.37796980142593384,
-0.35727646946907043,
0.22711823880672455,
-0.627307653427124,
0.13252925872802734,
0.03357292339205742,
0.2749588191509247,
-0.06950939446687698,
-0.2854422926902771,
-0.01579473353922367,
-0.6911464929580688,
1.0338327884674072,
-0.5505105257034302,
0.2210201770067215,
0.7060350775718689,
0.26090794801712036,
-0.2155449241399765,
-0.8358470797538757,
-0.24669548869132996,
0.008800257928669453,
-0.12384352833032608,
-0.22217735648155212,
-0.09750635921955109,
0.24294739961624146,
-0.15889832377433777,
0.555528998374939,
-0.46866029500961304,
0.1851395070552826,
-0.15664327144622803,
-0.17343594133853912,
0.8369987607002258,
0.3654806315898895,
0.3199020028114319,
0.22713878750801086,
-0.35669201612472534,
0.07394084334373474,
-0.6171461343765259,
0.08770719915628433,
0.3770744800567627,
0.3731410503387451,
-0.249871164560318,
0.5996643900871277,
-0.5882607102394104,
0.7848427891731262,
0.45620134472846985,
-0.17940653860569,
0.25855186581611633,
-0.5705271363258362,
-0.36596953868865967,
-0.24177256226539612,
0.9612286686897278,
0.17304487526416779,
0.2528742253780365,
-0.4380616545677185,
-0.14551901817321777,
-0.7235114574432373,
0.0588289313018322,
-0.7181108593940735,
-0.49182724952697754,
0.1048865094780922,
-0.535891592502594,
-0.4640156626701355,
0.02529999613761902,
-0.3362251818180084,
-0.45509520173072815,
-0.5375948548316956,
0.2023770809173584,
-0.38266584277153015,
0.29103437066078186,
0.15723198652267456,
0.2710437774658203,
-0.5019618272781372,
0.5145590901374817,
-1.0645562410354614,
0.449885755777359,
1.0006184577941895,
0.8014811277389526,
-0.3802567720413208,
-0.5489178895950317,
-0.7344457507133484,
0.3462683856487274,
0.021760348230600357,
0.8592783212661743,
-0.9026308655738831,
-0.4547535181045532,
-0.18397453427314758,
0.06660912185907364,
0.07471722364425659,
-0.6020880937576294,
0.0730038732290268,
-0.4900449812412262,
0.36145520210266113,
-0.5947417616844177,
-0.7482134699821472,
0.011608929373323917,
0.12558317184448242,
-0.5204473733901978,
0.5096640586853027,
0.10517213493585587,
-0.6629365682601929,
0.09359420835971832,
-0.6122920513153076,
-0.4457046389579773,
0.23741571605205536,
-0.24190010130405426,
-0.2435840517282486,
0.37829941511154175,
0.023166202008724213,
0.8435946702957153,
-0.08515267074108124,
0.15550535917282104,
-0.6757394075393677,
-0.6185511946678162,
0.30735597014427185,
-0.17531000077724457,
0.43831390142440796,
0.3058909773826599,
-0.12175807356834412,
0.36606577038764954,
-0.5228409767150879,
-0.08602556586265564,
0.04976920783519745,
-0.8099657297134399,
-0.2959507405757904,
0.1526813954114914,
0.18002112209796906,
-0.11663162708282471,
0.9349177479743958,
-0.5587285161018372,
0.23255564272403717,
-0.38248446583747864,
0.3733420670032501,
1.110048770904541,
-0.09749920666217804,
0.5896707773208618,
-0.5676100850105286,
0.3252411484718323,
-0.185037761926651,
0.3179461359977722,
-0.2689102590084076,
-0.28105977177619934,
-0.2575252652168274,
-0.377860963344574,
0.16037890315055847,
0.39358198642730713,
-0.27326756715774536,
0.7178455591201782,
0.01944802887737751,
-0.34438756108283997,
0.11407788097858429,
0.42374691367149353,
0.43758895993232727,
0.30032408237457275,
-0.00960309337824583,
-0.6035987138748169,
-0.26650938391685486,
-1.0455303192138672,
-0.24557824432849884,
0.01904517039656639,
-0.36532101035118103,
0.575271487236023,
-0.12164437770843506,
-0.18593290448188782,
0.9176403880119324,
-0.7183486819267273,
-0.23989786207675934,
-0.10020381957292557,
-0.16751593351364136,
0.09312576800584793,
0.5093715786933899,
0.33407875895500183,
-0.818585991859436,
-1.0412136316299438,
0.3893020451068878,
-0.3085584044456482,
-0.14497706294059753,
-0.021770555526018143,
-0.24520203471183777,
-0.1925034523010254,
0.3024013638496399,
0.030127327889204025,
0.13677716255187988,
0.7180692553520203,
-0.6565117835998535,
0.23955346643924713,
-0.4761481285095215,
0.05764966458082199,
-1.1103001832962036,
0.06470385938882828,
-0.24756133556365967,
-0.7504559755325317,
-0.4282904863357544,
-0.08556855469942093,
-0.35151737928390503,
0.09644108265638351,
-0.350990891456604,
0.3995531499385834,
-0.0955364853143692,
0.09175997972488403,
-0.40073704719543457,
0.04295149818062782,
-0.12821242213249207,
0.4451586902141571,
-0.12948919832706451,
0.6684783101081848,
0.2577623128890991,
-0.3123578131198883,
0.15847644209861755,
0.2690008878707886,
-0.17002759873867035,
0.6946525573730469,
-0.7819206118583679,
0.6340757608413696,
0.07845260947942734,
-0.13840527832508087,
-0.5445263981819153,
-0.5017298460006714,
0.09860146045684814,
0.15068060159683228,
0.018402449786663055,
-0.05498673394322395,
-0.580064594745636,
0.359754741191864,
-0.5111527442932129,
0.15495969355106354,
0.25937333703041077,
-0.592811107635498,
0.5034162998199463,
0.6668986678123474,
-0.3397424817085266,
-0.15931306779384613,
-0.5346540212631226,
0.061242133378982544,
-0.2156955748796463,
-0.7286649942398071,
0.7738574147224426,
-0.7393328547477722,
-0.11186370253562927,
-0.07066668570041656,
0.01727750152349472,
-0.40325066447257996,
0.23260712623596191,
0.3881866931915283,
-0.23177020251750946,
0.028153102844953537,
0.08846274018287659,
0.24135255813598633,
-0.07331042736768723,
-0.5957486033439636,
0.08958583325147629,
0.844672441482544,
-0.33214056491851807,
-0.26618286967277527,
-0.44664859771728516,
0.6804226636886597,
0.4042961001396179,
-0.3409040570259094,
0.7948054671287537,
0.7382867932319641,
-0.2485717386007309,
-0.06887055933475494,
-0.8109228610992432,
0.022529246285557747,
-0.611283540725708,
0.355080246925354,
-0.44229888916015625,
-1.5639430284500122,
0.42380255460739136,
-0.11439543217420578,
0.299079567193985,
-0.21799354255199432,
0.6726388931274414,
-0.24205513298511505,
0.9756419062614441,
0.9424770474433899,
-0.2846854627132416,
0.9552621841430664,
0.26124587655067444,
-0.051933612674474716,
-0.7966357469558716,
-0.23898378014564514,
-0.34750813245773315,
-0.61954265832901,
-0.37216997146606445,
-0.30240052938461304,
0.32671454548835754,
0.2190624624490738,
-0.6597127914428711,
0.29578304290771484,
-0.6541810631752014,
1.0094809532165527,
0.7180073261260986,
0.49003347754478455,
0.6948477625846863,
0.23108157515525818,
0.1381024718284607,
-0.0765477865934372,
-0.392495334148407,
-0.5968233942985535,
1.0176140069961548,
0.18908563256263733,
0.7821493148803711,
0.09422951936721802,
0.9676067233085632,
0.3185376524925232,
-0.07978467643260956,
-0.5669926404953003,
0.6046661734580994,
-0.8976921439170837,
-0.46019458770751953,
-0.22618748247623444,
-0.46120545268058777,
-1.0473443269729614,
0.14941081404685974,
-0.0779750719666481,
-1.2527183294296265,
0.18385320901870728,
0.43668603897094727,
-0.5760678648948669,
0.3581755757331848,
-0.689458966255188,
0.722545325756073,
-0.2419659048318863,
-0.4269615411758423,
-0.6026464700698853,
-0.42183271050453186,
0.1098548173904419,
-0.5009809732437134,
0.04932093620300293,
-0.16263191401958466,
-0.3785138428211212,
0.5119493007659912,
-0.46311816573143005,
1.0217046737670898,
-0.003125011920928955,
0.46248766779899597,
-0.127172589302063,
0.31564104557037354,
0.5972473621368408,
-0.005162058863788843,
-0.27038297057151794,
-0.007573794107884169,
0.06882453709840775,
-0.45534902811050415,
-0.29647010564804077,
1.119512915611267,
-0.6836917400360107,
-0.4967506229877472,
0.07992188632488251,
-0.559484601020813,
-0.1127433255314827,
0.39319220185279846,
0.11624924838542938,
0.20954279601573944,
-0.22943486273288727,
0.7374339699745178,
0.6673998832702637,
-0.4847041070461273,
0.4847715198993683,
0.5775485634803772,
-0.1048046126961708,
-0.5251125693321228,
0.8823546171188354,
-0.08408939838409424,
-0.045835189521312714,
0.6075264811515808,
0.7644190788269043,
0.09284589439630508,
-0.7231802940368652,
0.07320836931467056,
0.22556237876415253,
-0.39661335945129395,
-0.10321184247732162,
-0.5549505949020386,
0.35730135440826416,
0.031778693199157715,
-0.62993323802948,
-0.6390581130981445,
-0.13088618218898773,
-0.34978535771369934,
0.14764758944511414,
0.2600630521774292,
0.7552179098129272,
0.09528515487909317,
0.6470824480056763,
-0.8669708371162415,
0.04103867709636688,
0.4687388241291046,
0.744297444820404,
-0.07654406875371933,
-0.10110791772603989,
-0.42758771777153015,
-0.25305211544036865,
-0.3208988308906555,
-0.6396030783653259,
0.07002807408571243,
0.10624343156814575,
0.4149940311908722,
0.3538680076599121,
0.018706582486629486,
0.7374677658081055,
-0.4820873439311981,
0.6870442032814026,
0.17749632894992828,
-1.1658267974853516,
0.1562666893005371,
-0.4847085177898407,
0.3836348354816437,
0.9386827349662781,
0.024613095447421074,
-0.5164918899536133,
0.08217792958021164,
-0.4135822057723999,
-0.7777081727981567,
0.8670133352279663,
-0.028151627629995346,
0.29864373803138733,
0.2583487033843994,
0.385593444108963,
0.2882925868034363,
0.3497176468372345,
-0.4849933385848999,
0.023344730958342552,
0.32483676075935364,
-0.32003745436668396,
-0.039788778871297836,
-0.3009081482887268,
-0.06627113372087479,
-0.1534658819437027,
0.4486555755138397,
-0.17537248134613037,
0.03564527630805969,
0.1365884691476822,
0.2285660058259964,
-0.25466760993003845,
0.2170049399137497,
0.3775179386138916,
0.7759565114974976,
-0.11249296367168427,
0.0600927397608757,
0.13931091129779816,
-0.1934661865234375,
-0.15017488598823547,
0.04930378869175911,
-0.09342095255851746,
-0.3334774374961853,
0.049058545380830765,
0.5237246155738831,
0.24459156394004822,
-0.7690925598144531,
0.5272104740142822,
-0.3703588545322418,
0.14166009426116943,
-0.3463082015514374,
0.21710211038589478,
0.39165791869163513,
0.5313751697540283,
-0.22638218104839325,
0.1519659459590912,
0.19295042753219604,
-0.379721075296402,
0.10437838733196259,
0.18250200152397156,
-0.25752586126327515,
-0.6936474442481995,
0.587154746055603,
0.1519569307565689,
-0.4951229691505432,
0.35943788290023804,
0.08091741800308228,
-0.17881621420383453,
0.05312899500131607,
0.31623250246047974,
0.8830753564834595,
-0.39174017310142517,
0.2100939303636551,
-0.2258376032114029,
-0.017692476511001587,
-0.20961908996105194,
0.16216851770877838,
-0.2829289436340332,
-0.5560243129730225,
-0.4527435600757599,
-0.6237207651138306,
-0.611910879611969,
0.2333686500787735,
-0.3406074047088623,
0.16182033717632294,
-0.7765455842018127,
-0.08340059965848923,
-0.10286632180213928,
0.054705433547496796,
-0.6655055284500122,
0.009514681994915009,
0.13052898645401,
0.665765643119812,
-0.4399262070655823,
0.9635584354400635,
0.9465824365615845,
-0.014442943036556244,
-0.8392148613929749,
-0.26738545298576355,
0.06934750080108643,
-0.40491077303886414,
0.17398962378501892,
-0.3141396641731262,
0.08540880680084229,
-0.41995978355407715,
-0.2863715589046478,
-0.7652809619903564,
1.0515350103378296,
0.6272770166397095,
-1.0878775119781494,
-0.048970408737659454,
0.20209091901779175,
0.5221529603004456,
-0.3350411355495453,
-0.06711919605731964,
0.42425358295440674,
0.42728784680366516,
-0.009941164404153824,
-1.0744303464889526,
0.1460752636194229,
0.034618306905031204,
0.05404117330908775,
0.06762873381376266,
-0.9678249359130859,
0.9221007227897644,
0.13558724522590637,
0.2520306408405304,
0.16657991707324982,
0.23346666991710663,
0.4627233147621155,
0.42279645800590515,
0.7340870499610901,
0.23412290215492249,
0.9173750877380371,
0.1534688025712967,
1.1549921035766602,
-0.4050636887550354,
0.18347780406475067,
1.4263933897018433,
-0.08404373377561569,
0.9210269451141357,
0.34180161356925964,
-0.31875079870224,
0.25996461510658264,
0.3889693021774292,
0.1063213050365448,
0.48012667894363403,
0.09644025564193726,
-0.5445822477340698,
-0.44674181938171387,
0.04517069458961487,
-0.07083602994680405,
0.39527010917663574,
0.006174498703330755,
-0.7227238416671753,
0.02151409350335598,
-0.2323945164680481,
0.3361237347126007,
0.32454410195350647,
-0.026344142854213715,
0.9078183770179749,
0.20411992073059082,
-0.43332603573799133,
-0.006550637073814869,
0.24635812640190125,
0.9722409248352051,
-0.6359171867370605,
0.36747798323631287,
-0.3012355864048004,
0.37838032841682434,
-0.5034608840942383,
-0.5522158145904541,
0.504726767539978,
0.1409972757101059,
-0.29580649733543396,
-0.43423962593078613,
0.7505338191986084,
-0.5116506814956665,
-0.2974295914173126,
0.039753686636686325,
0.3449464440345764,
0.10249044001102448,
-0.4715942144393921,
-0.678658127784729,
0.30016815662384033,
0.34434157609939575,
-0.5234668850898743,
0.7441298961639404,
0.06335790455341339,
0.023651501163840294,
0.5321764349937439,
0.6224067211151123,
0.139478400349617,
-0.07374566793441772,
-0.06888214498758316,
0.9471031427383423,
-0.5786619782447815,
-0.5061119198799133,
-0.9727907180786133,
0.4784099757671356,
-0.03918082267045975,
-0.19145701825618744,
0.649713397026062,
0.7825344800949097,
1.0946651697158813,
-0.20517142117023468,
0.7283945679664612,
0.06595324724912643,
0.4298630654811859,
-0.16230443120002747,
0.7212730050086975,
-0.618497908115387,
0.5883401036262512,
-0.2639327049255371,
-0.881693959236145,
-0.3365693986415863,
0.5424361228942871,
-0.31896644830703735,
-0.09382013976573944,
0.2044031322002411,
0.6362640261650085,
-0.3519620895385742,
0.02512931451201439,
0.46066194772720337,
0.028902774676680565,
0.5660620331764221,
0.6072342395782471,
0.4285919964313507,
0.019809458404779434,
0.3992144763469696,
-0.8889556527137756,
-0.3061359226703644,
-0.04824629798531532,
-0.7479682564735413,
-1.027965784072876,
-0.5893687009811401,
-0.49900737404823303,
0.14701253175735474,
-0.021621286869049072,
1.2654483318328857,
1.1687337160110474,
-0.7977690696716309,
-0.5776916146278381,
-0.11332506686449051,
0.032907117158174515,
0.11389870196580887,
-0.1709270030260086,
0.347927987575531,
-0.10798395425081253,
-0.9208400249481201,
0.7806310057640076,
0.5113996267318726,
-0.1141432598233223,
-0.07889768481254578,
-0.11250082403421402,
0.31648942828178406,
0.03154004365205765,
0.7581806182861328,
0.15733951330184937,
-0.5539456009864807,
-0.22248965501785278,
0.025598924607038498,
0.09782225638628006,
0.09288785606622696,
0.8256129026412964,
-0.6037525534629822,
0.6098023056983948,
0.906877338886261,
0.6290993690490723,
0.5529106259346008,
0.24050380289554596,
0.8061235547065735,
-0.8054500818252563,
-0.10062918066978455,
0.16184508800506592,
0.4687599241733551,
0.3966738283634186,
-0.6043602824211121,
0.3477032482624054,
-0.05929863825440407,
-0.8823087811470032,
-0.6512391567230225,
0.22906628251075745,
-1.238817572593689,
-0.38207337260246277,
0.643949568271637,
-0.5299992561340332,
-0.008772969245910645,
-0.03685986250638962,
-0.304798424243927,
-0.12914933264255524,
-0.6351175308227539,
0.911469578742981,
0.44554901123046875,
-0.41057679057121277,
0.02169455960392952,
0.02548423409461975,
0.23731811344623566,
0.3723044693470001,
-0.8453419208526611,
-0.03577396273612976,
0.3561061918735504,
0.600774884223938,
-0.07572675496339798,
0.8471301794052124,
-0.2018563151359558,
-0.17752763628959656,
-0.5383973717689514,
-0.22743740677833557,
-0.4701601564884186,
-0.11884380877017975,
-0.2758699953556061,
0.5823087096214294,
0.2067032903432846,
-0.0583939403295517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10459v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10459v1
|
CancerLLM: A Large Language Model in Cancer Domain
| 2024-06-15T01:02:48 | 2024-06-15T01:02:48 |
Mingchen Li, Anne Blaes, Steven Johnson, Hongfang Liu, Hua Xu, Rui Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Medical Large Language Models (LLMs) such as ClinicalCamel 70B,
Llama3-OpenBioLLM 70B have demonstrated impressive performance on a wide
variety of medical NLP task.However, there still lacks a large language model
(LLM) specifically designed for cancer domain. Moreover, these LLMs typically
have billions of parameters, making them computationally expensive for
healthcare systems.Thus, in this study, we propose CancerLLM, a model with 7
billion parameters and a Mistral-style architecture, pre-trained on 2,676,642
clinical notes and 515,524 pathology reports covering 17 cancer types, followed
by fine-tuning on three cancer-relevant tasks, including cancer phenotypes
extraction, cancer diagnosis generation, and cancer treatment plan generation.
Our evaluation demonstrated that CancerLLM achieves state-of-the-art results
compared to other existing LLMs, with an average F1 score improvement of 8.1\%.
Additionally, CancerLLM outperforms other models on two proposed robustness
testbeds. This illustrates that CancerLLM can be effectively applied to
clinical AI systems, enhancing clinical research and healthcare delivery in the
field of cancer.
|
[
-0.08309396356344223,
-0.7830408215522766,
0.6272926926612854,
0.1713421791791916,
-0.23327302932739258,
-0.12199974060058594,
-0.25358185172080994,
-0.4677679240703583,
0.032373715192079544,
0.7926417589187622,
-0.30765852332115173,
-0.8302645087242126,
-0.921461284160614,
-0.06565575301647186,
-0.32383137941360474,
0.7882474064826965,
0.3199481964111328,
0.5566278696060181,
-0.27567338943481445,
-0.11360479146242142,
-0.26519379019737244,
-0.4016956388950348,
-0.9442014098167419,
-0.3828900456428528,
0.7165719866752625,
0.2873995304107666,
0.8911985754966736,
0.878318190574646,
0.7569448351860046,
0.21821250021457672,
-0.05429860204458237,
0.22903165221214294,
-0.6932848691940308,
0.2737182378768921,
-0.20259441435337067,
-0.4467523992061615,
-0.6892786026000977,
-0.1811487376689911,
0.2153944969177246,
0.7665005922317505,
-0.09304237365722656,
-0.21988318860530853,
0.040139518678188324,
0.5453638434410095,
-0.33163633942604065,
0.23139430582523346,
-0.5310230255126953,
-0.0911123976111412,
-0.2631930410861969,
0.0019588633440434933,
-0.25038278102874756,
-0.42664000391960144,
0.1257951259613037,
-0.4185909032821655,
-0.0961693823337555,
-0.02897091954946518,
0.5831724405288696,
0.18738460540771484,
-0.316396564245224,
-0.6252515912055969,
-0.7663418054580688,
0.7251625657081604,
-1.06923246383667,
0.25897014141082764,
0.31466424465179443,
0.33950576186180115,
-0.44058936834335327,
-0.9474500417709351,
-0.04687784984707832,
-0.38805148005485535,
0.1348228007555008,
0.10442405939102173,
-0.13322311639785767,
0.3215191960334778,
0.008049887605011463,
0.38014695048332214,
-0.8026250600814819,
0.4636979401111603,
-0.125832200050354,
-0.15567326545715332,
0.6674752831459045,
0.613896906375885,
0.3454859256744385,
0.1188243106007576,
-0.25374117493629456,
0.16735412180423737,
-0.7731174230575562,
-0.40352576971054077,
-0.33351340889930725,
0.41345807909965515,
0.1493302434682846,
0.5094937086105347,
-0.18611375987529755,
0.8527143597602844,
-0.4469795823097229,
-0.5074170827865601,
-0.15711893141269684,
-0.15208178758621216,
-0.552327036857605,
-0.0038981973193585873,
0.9325683116912842,
0.08288495987653732,
-0.031648509204387665,
-0.19036650657653809,
0.2968240976333618,
-0.0727820098400116,
0.42042064666748047,
-1.0293806791305542,
-0.19874075055122375,
0.6759130954742432,
-0.5561259984970093,
-0.20195870101451874,
-0.29042887687683105,
-0.6749593615531921,
-0.6324267387390137,
0.16296958923339844,
0.49162688851356506,
-0.7990212440490723,
-0.06532564014196396,
0.7347413897514343,
0.42995503544807434,
-0.13635510206222534,
0.42069628834724426,
-0.3986045718193054,
0.14451344311237335,
0.7603355646133423,
0.8134333491325378,
-0.29263463616371155,
-0.034658730030059814,
-0.47711181640625,
0.19905796647071838,
-0.06232212856411934,
0.5516988039016724,
-0.7907252907752991,
-0.673858642578125,
-0.0405491404235363,
-0.08432795852422714,
-0.2641147971153259,
-0.6117278337478638,
0.638408899307251,
-0.335185170173645,
0.3489525318145752,
-0.017469480633735657,
-0.8325439691543579,
-0.15808279812335968,
0.26743748784065247,
-0.684603214263916,
0.6219300627708435,
0.1576818972826004,
-0.398677796125412,
0.1330847591161728,
-0.7114478349685669,
-0.2722134590148926,
0.3352707028388977,
0.0855230763554573,
-0.6219485402107239,
-0.014995955862104893,
0.06429789960384369,
0.8196207284927368,
-0.7141613960266113,
0.43402963876724243,
-0.33560311794281006,
-0.22928282618522644,
0.13328330218791962,
-0.007516875397413969,
0.7722234725952148,
0.6178690195083618,
-0.14883774518966675,
0.020867662504315376,
-0.5451396107673645,
0.07766362279653549,
0.13162106275558472,
-0.3759569227695465,
-0.2633395195007324,
-0.08481521159410477,
0.031317126005887985,
0.22392624616622925,
0.17314139008522034,
-0.43507084250450134,
0.19942127168178558,
-0.7417247295379639,
0.3579084277153015,
0.07751629501581192,
-0.2222980260848999,
0.04785684123635292,
-0.5082188844680786,
0.6541889309883118,
-0.022775745019316673,
0.2703067362308502,
-0.19045040011405945,
-0.7281996011734009,
-0.4116615951061249,
-0.6734075546264648,
0.38181793689727783,
0.4686228930950165,
-0.11036727577447891,
0.1357606053352356,
0.041705649346113205,
-0.6499919891357422,
-0.4399435222148895,
-0.0064147342927753925,
0.5007076859474182,
0.40228936076164246,
0.4102446138858795,
-0.2767520844936371,
-0.33255717158317566,
-0.7511411309242249,
-0.20183910429477692,
-0.04571874067187309,
0.1147432029247284,
0.4921148717403412,
0.15156607329845428,
-0.49349895119667053,
0.6193896532058716,
-0.5285398960113525,
-0.49128684401512146,
-0.32952237129211426,
-0.0758868083357811,
0.2461392730474472,
0.22315017879009247,
0.2708599865436554,
-0.53960782289505,
-0.2285170704126358,
0.13748799264431,
-0.6713020205497742,
-0.3773801028728485,
0.08462103456258774,
-0.051986027508974075,
-0.2985632121562958,
0.48342961072921753,
-0.6895842552185059,
0.21832631528377533,
0.5852614045143127,
-0.2227271944284439,
0.31541475653648376,
-0.27547547221183777,
-0.05919288471341133,
-1.417749047279358,
0.2557278871536255,
0.008945542387664318,
-0.3833054304122925,
-0.6626210808753967,
0.13358920812606812,
-0.15449799597263336,
-0.15591242909431458,
-0.5745911598205566,
0.7392770648002625,
-0.36876562237739563,
0.2719733715057373,
-0.4633219242095947,
-0.19834278523921967,
0.0194107498973608,
0.13764452934265137,
0.04884323850274086,
0.3701988756656647,
0.41921254992485046,
-0.5140857696533203,
0.3548305332660675,
-0.006769056431949139,
-0.17438626289367676,
0.3227163255214691,
-0.622320830821991,
-0.09501992166042328,
0.0842786431312561,
0.12255127727985382,
-0.7219164967536926,
-0.2879354953765869,
-0.030232684686779976,
-0.1699846386909485,
0.15144483745098114,
0.006904610898345709,
-0.30556267499923706,
-0.45872771739959717,
0.08840714395046234,
0.3560984134674072,
0.4874174892902374,
0.01652306690812111,
0.5321041345596313,
0.544506311416626,
-0.38510024547576904,
-0.22657613456249237,
-0.4105799198150635,
0.14953283965587616,
-0.3082566559314728,
-0.5754593014717102,
0.20194032788276672,
-0.02000870555639267,
-0.15823370218276978,
-0.12389221787452698,
0.38491734862327576,
-0.12212016433477402,
0.1993241012096405,
0.5302783250808716,
-0.13325926661491394,
-0.5122609734535217,
0.22185029089450836,
0.027353964745998383,
0.03512345626950264,
0.01635774038732052,
-0.2663312256336212,
0.7311457991600037,
0.20079244673252106,
-0.6324365735054016,
-0.2386171966791153,
0.4359269440174103,
0.8264182806015015,
-0.08455247431993484,
0.5826602578163147,
0.39117681980133057,
-0.6716794967651367,
-0.2529556453227997,
-0.35966867208480835,
-0.020716365426778793,
-0.3680437207221985,
0.7449806928634644,
-0.08981078863143921,
-1.2657073736190796,
0.41276586055755615,
-0.518937885761261,
0.0893549844622612,
0.4908280670642853,
1.1134580373764038,
0.23555046319961548,
1.036583662033081,
0.3188953995704651,
-0.2547760009765625,
-0.13584426045417786,
0.07910299301147461,
-0.008744056336581707,
-0.3559994101524353,
-0.4347914457321167,
-0.7071381211280823,
-0.10159510374069214,
-0.24202986061573029,
-0.7054657936096191,
0.5707859396934509,
0.03914135321974754,
-0.14268460869789124,
0.16815292835235596,
-0.42535945773124695,
0.23346556723117828,
0.29113906621932983,
0.23885028064250946,
0.3564169406890869,
-0.3443390727043152,
-0.2129298746585846,
-0.011258739978075027,
-0.9116454720497131,
-0.5286393761634827,
1.1298574209213257,
0.546703577041626,
0.8278540372848511,
0.2099475860595703,
0.4728287160396576,
0.10506375133991241,
0.36881452798843384,
-0.7531734108924866,
0.40504294633865356,
-0.5699883103370667,
-0.48205140233039856,
-0.2560003399848938,
-0.3429430425167084,
-1.1914979219436646,
0.041273362934589386,
-0.2102808803319931,
-0.5132209062576294,
-0.1761315017938614,
0.10583963990211487,
-0.5298346877098083,
0.1864832192659378,
-0.2588217854499817,
0.8043432235717773,
-0.47004833817481995,
-0.3016897439956665,
-0.13639208674430847,
-0.4791111350059509,
0.5181434154510498,
-0.23435458540916443,
0.21696126461029053,
-0.22174981236457825,
0.023904040455818176,
0.4935844838619232,
-0.6029734015464783,
0.724307119846344,
-0.018586494028568268,
-0.23216594755649567,
-0.10372840613126755,
0.35659703612327576,
0.42320919036865234,
0.31490007042884827,
-0.4152384102344513,
0.1549830585718155,
-0.03676300495862961,
-0.35111987590789795,
-0.24371911585330963,
0.90107661485672,
-0.4804597496986389,
-0.5709825158119202,
-0.3501147925853729,
-0.7281485199928284,
-0.6097913980484009,
0.39554616808891296,
0.2147907316684723,
0.3941662907600403,
-0.6395098567008972,
0.13003329932689667,
0.8235647082328796,
-0.6752632856369019,
0.10205192118883133,
0.5660642981529236,
-0.3986172378063202,
-0.14072874188423157,
0.7275087833404541,
-0.3532472252845764,
0.2326856106519699,
0.3608320653438568,
0.3380068838596344,
-0.17772114276885986,
-1.0125911235809326,
-0.2948465049266815,
0.20525161921977997,
-0.3078412711620331,
-0.45507943630218506,
-1.0032532215118408,
-0.45309898257255554,
-0.2541451156139374,
-0.03561915084719658,
-0.47652140259742737,
-0.05370662733912468,
-0.540294885635376,
0.26137110590934753,
0.5240238904953003,
0.8118574619293213,
0.19687192142009735,
0.3189370930194855,
-0.8931348919868469,
0.19505518674850464,
0.267321914434433,
0.31341251730918884,
-0.06910839676856995,
-0.5438331365585327,
-0.4364294111728668,
0.1607162356376648,
-0.09209415316581726,
-0.5713548064231873,
0.7345344424247742,
0.5015159249305725,
0.4521183371543884,
0.5480757355690002,
-0.32926538586616516,
0.4390403926372528,
-0.47241485118865967,
0.7400781512260437,
0.1425904929637909,
-0.5281663537025452,
0.4828689694404602,
-0.47747671604156494,
0.5341482162475586,
0.349613755941391,
0.4964335858821869,
-0.4237074851989746,
-0.7596319317817688,
-0.3909870982170105,
-0.5134337544441223,
0.542380154132843,
0.05217074602842331,
0.2107289880514145,
0.02646896056830883,
0.498154878616333,
0.3453184962272644,
-0.09786755591630936,
-0.19231194257736206,
-0.13625918328762054,
-0.02281692437827587,
-0.4845086634159088,
-0.05317586660385132,
-0.39308902621269226,
-0.3149840831756592,
0.003048328449949622,
0.45451247692108154,
-0.06139377877116203,
0.23481535911560059,
0.08743489533662796,
0.03113318607211113,
0.16151824593544006,
0.1988404542207718,
0.8982725143432617,
0.4644102454185486,
-0.1559239774942398,
0.09192607551813126,
0.10494106262922287,
-0.8331195712089539,
-0.11031543463468552,
0.11810532957315445,
0.27924901247024536,
-0.049997542053461075,
0.588091254234314,
0.5688037276268005,
0.007745851296931505,
-0.8718208074569702,
0.4359184801578522,
-0.0844283401966095,
-0.29413166642189026,
0.19826214015483856,
0.3913021385669708,
0.6354814767837524,
0.2905614674091339,
0.15119875967502594,
-0.30683431029319763,
0.26694947481155396,
-0.3698018193244934,
0.40363478660583496,
0.7293118238449097,
-0.7393391728401184,
-0.09991771727800369,
0.9551588296890259,
0.1042512059211731,
-0.22970716655254364,
0.19635958969593048,
0.2695533037185669,
-0.25860556960105896,
0.6020950078964233,
0.7021694183349609,
0.5132554173469543,
-0.4683457016944885,
0.2218972146511078,
0.07058757543563843,
0.08425765484571457,
-0.38370147347450256,
0.3320726752281189,
0.7468360066413879,
-0.580581784248352,
-0.36249682307243347,
-0.8786919116973877,
-0.48319271206855774,
0.4542325735092163,
-0.28166890144348145,
0.3058500289916992,
-0.5901387333869934,
-0.1807100921869278,
0.18995454907417297,
0.009747562929987907,
-0.43067291378974915,
0.635630190372467,
0.03991328924894333,
0.922584056854248,
-0.4513956904411316,
1.1624478101730347,
0.4799902141094208,
-0.03280211240053177,
-0.8008242249488831,
-0.36525124311447144,
0.07131155580282211,
-1.0107976198196411,
0.41592830419540405,
-0.16287365555763245,
-0.004590952303260565,
-0.1247839704155922,
-0.31089353561401367,
-0.8279962539672852,
1.0395725965499878,
0.5829906463623047,
-0.7990643382072449,
0.11364281922578812,
0.5163074135780334,
0.7248544692993164,
-0.8448567390441895,
0.33544692397117615,
0.21213307976722717,
0.17800097167491913,
0.19057856500148773,
-0.9835057258605957,
0.15279513597488403,
-0.07447277754545212,
0.008839353919029236,
0.05720589682459831,
-0.7601302862167358,
0.9407022595405579,
-0.17243115603923798,
0.023853618651628494,
0.3767833709716797,
0.3500014841556549,
0.2349378764629364,
0.3517603278160095,
-0.009703692980110645,
0.6774082183837891,
0.7895169258117676,
0.054331228137016296,
1.0179026126861572,
-0.36777275800704956,
0.263059139251709,
0.8154790997505188,
-0.584004282951355,
0.38527753949165344,
-0.011441273614764214,
-0.09735667705535889,
0.18761684000492096,
0.6043134331703186,
0.2935020327568054,
0.27595219016075134,
0.37335219979286194,
-0.4056515097618103,
-0.3728691041469574,
-0.21416495740413666,
-0.5106832385063171,
0.4736093282699585,
0.6022960543632507,
-0.7818270921707153,
-0.09530915319919586,
0.16466067731380463,
0.4075717031955719,
0.025881998240947723,
-0.39518705010414124,
0.7451508641242981,
0.3526118993759155,
-0.1654236763715744,
0.5445303916931152,
0.20287148654460907,
0.39912131428718567,
-0.7728290557861328,
-0.016268374398350716,
-0.34822455048561096,
0.17467714846134186,
-0.15816473960876465,
-0.41157975792884827,
0.2714528441429138,
-0.13967514038085938,
-0.08131516724824905,
0.12191115319728851,
0.724270761013031,
-0.4374200701713562,
-0.7295135259628296,
0.3748778998851776,
0.5947136878967285,
0.19893759489059448,
-0.08178236335515976,
-0.8537530899047852,
0.20605133473873138,
-0.16727150976657867,
-0.18663376569747925,
0.45525452494621277,
0.4322373569011688,
-0.07265707850456238,
0.8179237246513367,
0.4511202275753021,
0.48597678542137146,
-0.16036038100719452,
-0.010134700685739517,
0.8420968055725098,
-0.7314813137054443,
-0.11363699287176132,
-0.9453858733177185,
0.08939559012651443,
0.1031283512711525,
-0.40503907203674316,
0.6597849726676941,
0.6056400537490845,
0.2507387101650238,
0.12089847773313522,
0.802200198173523,
0.3175652325153351,
0.7007947564125061,
-0.7140734195709229,
0.9301215410232544,
-0.6462135314941406,
0.41622671484947205,
-0.24225685000419617,
-0.6907297968864441,
-0.8376043438911438,
0.09995881468057632,
-0.12846237421035767,
0.19875140488147736,
0.6666262149810791,
0.9466754198074341,
-0.07674296200275421,
0.08547089248895645,
0.6751596331596375,
0.4878673553466797,
0.25394096970558167,
1.0000110864639282,
0.33206236362457275,
-0.2275547832250595,
0.23034696280956268,
0.15811975300312042,
-0.1542598009109497,
-0.47686663269996643,
-0.7097639441490173,
-0.8138728141784668,
-0.3464324176311493,
-0.26281386613845825,
-0.471530020236969,
0.3182659447193146,
0.7236447334289551,
0.9048728942871094,
-0.8648439645767212,
-0.2585097551345825,
0.2581942081451416,
-0.03584921732544899,
-0.08224344253540039,
-0.09829507768154144,
0.3821846842765808,
0.004767515230923891,
-0.5955154895782471,
0.6181958913803101,
0.6773689389228821,
-0.2169177085161209,
-0.4133268892765045,
-0.2684759497642517,
-0.10939006507396698,
0.2516079545021057,
0.6450589299201965,
0.2627125680446625,
-0.6095951199531555,
0.039308320730924606,
0.04704703763127327,
-0.5963098406791687,
0.02666749805212021,
0.8254756927490234,
-0.5168282985687256,
0.45367228984832764,
0.06368743628263474,
0.775745153427124,
0.32285988330841064,
-0.18725265562534332,
0.7961679697036743,
-0.14346814155578613,
-0.07717973738908768,
0.6126735806465149,
0.2625165283679962,
0.12827502191066742,
-0.6254982352256775,
0.21180661022663116,
-0.008231769315898418,
-0.6298450827598572,
-0.6126781702041626,
0.20489488542079926,
-1.0825753211975098,
-0.6251587271690369,
1.3701180219650269,
-0.12312542647123337,
-0.20656828582286835,
-0.43083083629608154,
-0.24774852395057678,
0.14883054792881012,
-0.20136958360671997,
0.7654771208763123,
0.47571927309036255,
-0.3198137581348419,
-0.16623401641845703,
-0.3040725886821747,
0.7555961012840271,
0.4813348650932312,
-0.979023814201355,
-0.168771430850029,
0.37824398279190063,
0.27965718507766724,
-0.21075747907161713,
0.8360941410064697,
-0.47231853008270264,
0.25657886266708374,
-0.5170050859451294,
0.0509537011384964,
-0.22779802978038788,
-0.006140457931905985,
-0.34500497579574585,
0.5495523810386658,
0.29291456937789917,
0.22338585555553436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10450v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10450v1
|
TokenRec: Learning to Tokenize ID for LLM-based Generative Recommendation
| 2024-06-15T00:07:44 | 2024-06-15T00:07:44 |
Haohao Qu, Wenqi Fan, Zihuai Zhao, Qing Li
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
There is a growing interest in utilizing large-scale language models (LLMs)
to advance next-generation Recommender Systems (RecSys), driven by their
outstanding language understanding and in-context learning capabilities. In
this scenario, tokenizing (i.e., indexing) users and items becomes essential
for ensuring a seamless alignment of LLMs with recommendations. While several
studies have made progress in representing users and items through textual
contents or latent representations, challenges remain in efficiently capturing
high-order collaborative knowledge into discrete tokens that are compatible
with LLMs. Additionally, the majority of existing tokenization approaches often
face difficulties in generalizing effectively to new/unseen users or items that
were not in the training corpus. To address these challenges, we propose a
novel framework called TokenRec, which introduces not only an effective ID
tokenization strategy but also an efficient retrieval paradigm for LLM-based
recommendations. Specifically, our tokenization strategy, Masked
Vector-Quantized (MQ) Tokenizer, involves quantizing the masked user/item
representations learned from collaborative filtering into discrete tokens, thus
achieving a smooth incorporation of high-order collaborative knowledge and a
generalizable tokenization of users and items for LLM-based RecSys. Meanwhile,
our generative retrieval paradigm is designed to efficiently recommend top-$K$
items for users to eliminate the need for the time-consuming auto-regressive
decoding and beam search processes used by LLMs, thus significantly reducing
inference time. Comprehensive experiments validate the effectiveness of the
proposed methods, demonstrating that TokenRec outperforms competitive
benchmarks, including both traditional recommender systems and emerging
LLM-based recommender systems.
|
[
-0.34087666869163513,
-0.244978129863739,
0.3859900236129761,
0.08326011896133423,
-0.35832756757736206,
0.44212809205055237,
0.05142437294125557,
-0.1119520515203476,
0.4788301885128021,
0.3515542149543762,
-0.3963131606578827,
-1.0289989709854126,
-0.406573623418808,
0.034332673996686935,
-0.49232742190361023,
1.0579850673675537,
0.16613507270812988,
-0.023515822365880013,
-0.48761284351348877,
-0.2757801115512848,
-0.6120533347129822,
-0.9235875010490417,
-0.6551242470741272,
-0.23787979781627655,
0.7424620985984802,
0.39903584122657776,
0.41047319769859314,
0.5116322636604309,
0.47958904504776,
0.22375759482383728,
-0.17188605666160583,
0.3732255697250366,
-0.6283983588218689,
0.3583601713180542,
-0.26790371537208557,
-0.3859776556491852,
-0.4283878207206726,
0.012983372434973717,
0.3316282033920288,
0.6052631139755249,
-0.27767106890678406,
0.12520761787891388,
0.028122957795858383,
0.6830708384513855,
-0.7758404016494751,
0.06894635409116745,
-0.7149875164031982,
0.06192440167069435,
-0.2457435131072998,
-0.20681564509868622,
-0.4997282028198242,
-0.1639886498451233,
0.11935867369174957,
-0.9062200784683228,
0.16356846690177917,
0.5504159927368164,
0.49776163697242737,
-0.0760723128914833,
-0.5190814137458801,
-0.06532832235097885,
-0.6799769997596741,
0.7592809796333313,
-0.32517266273498535,
0.5548554062843323,
0.6829469203948975,
0.16220755875110626,
-0.22244422137737274,
-1.2200826406478882,
-0.32885944843292236,
0.029645627364516258,
-0.11295101046562195,
-0.04321769252419472,
-0.2490127831697464,
0.14398710429668427,
0.16769292950630188,
0.5632960200309753,
-0.508823037147522,
0.02412780560553074,
-0.06772344559431076,
-0.2604745626449585,
0.21026574075222015,
0.2248678058385849,
0.1255694031715393,
-0.12452375888824463,
-0.7985060214996338,
-0.022067129611968994,
-0.6084762811660767,
-0.06604775786399841,
0.15175078809261322,
0.16056229174137115,
0.08487939089536667,
0.6078349351882935,
-0.387595534324646,
0.34620052576065063,
0.3347110450267792,
0.26866307854652405,
0.21676741540431976,
-0.8667275309562683,
0.04268525913357735,
-0.2834191620349884,
0.6028029322624207,
0.5653740167617798,
0.1094273254275322,
-0.3137035071849823,
-0.3811068832874298,
-0.31424424052238464,
0.09978272765874863,
-0.8789418935775757,
-0.19911448657512665,
-0.03309614956378937,
-0.7231805324554443,
-0.2865009009838104,
0.3527694046497345,
-0.5467789769172668,
-0.47852563858032227,
-0.10907401889562607,
0.2708207964897156,
-0.27568477392196655,
-0.02073228545486927,
0.06552709639072418,
-0.12913498282432556,
0.0016625538701191545,
0.14689955115318298,
-1.044387936592102,
0.44045886397361755,
0.937189519405365,
0.9206122756004333,
-0.37381330132484436,
-0.10386370867490768,
-0.941216230392456,
0.16897431015968323,
-0.22244314849376678,
0.7466479539871216,
-0.6824073791503906,
-0.762811005115509,
0.14254263043403625,
-0.05983954668045044,
0.17470495402812958,
-0.6232331991195679,
0.37786269187927246,
-0.7441017031669617,
0.07058483362197876,
-0.2937149703502655,
-0.5090326070785522,
0.002942706923931837,
0.17452210187911987,
-0.4501936435699463,
1.0693162679672241,
0.24377521872520447,
-0.6660382151603699,
0.5096335411071777,
-0.4868393540382385,
-0.32180875539779663,
0.37462079524993896,
-0.18861019611358643,
-0.15738622844219208,
0.21560080349445343,
0.37703773379325867,
0.460793137550354,
-0.30072689056396484,
0.3518865406513214,
-0.3044772446155548,
-0.697064995765686,
0.2625330984592438,
-0.35679933428764343,
0.3131200969219208,
0.2979797124862671,
0.026769332587718964,
0.5851958990097046,
-0.419916570186615,
-0.08810321986675262,
-0.17092077434062958,
-0.26840969920158386,
-0.5263643860816956,
-0.12112926691770554,
0.24950045347213745,
-0.18645668029785156,
0.43566814064979553,
-0.44815605878829956,
0.28539609909057617,
-0.5085923671722412,
0.667449414730072,
0.9848719239234924,
0.14148318767547607,
0.5521029233932495,
-0.34800347685813904,
0.4857553541660309,
-0.014944089576601982,
0.2478734850883484,
-0.5483582615852356,
-0.3050387501716614,
-0.7030121088027954,
-0.4197438657283783,
0.604438066482544,
0.24080412089824677,
-0.8603990077972412,
0.5556180477142334,
-0.3676237463951111,
-0.07351557910442352,
-0.432088166475296,
0.14210885763168335,
0.32441362738609314,
-0.06707034260034561,
0.14631898701190948,
-0.6470521688461304,
-0.7162379026412964,
-0.6570413708686829,
-0.08634106814861298,
-0.3525431454181671,
-0.3531598746776581,
0.5301534533500671,
0.28070777654647827,
-0.4730707108974457,
0.9710413217544556,
-0.49899065494537354,
-0.5856409668922424,
-0.09885494410991669,
0.04749399051070213,
0.1552155613899231,
0.4269889295101166,
0.1949840635061264,
-0.7399089932441711,
-0.30903586745262146,
-0.008346416056156158,
-0.2609799802303314,
0.027738582342863083,
-0.01291318517178297,
-0.3689344823360443,
-0.08921519666910172,
0.6904253363609314,
-0.3132286071777344,
0.5189104676246643,
0.23337221145629883,
-0.621970534324646,
0.24017569422721863,
-0.29010990262031555,
0.07811063528060913,
-1.226142168045044,
0.2809542715549469,
-0.07859871536493301,
-0.44184160232543945,
-0.14280389249324799,
-0.1780218482017517,
-0.06684933602809906,
-0.27615687251091003,
-0.15977858006954193,
0.7736390233039856,
-0.12845709919929504,
0.03518073633313179,
-0.07408039271831512,
0.17984254658222198,
0.2338200956583023,
0.6277938485145569,
-0.44921159744262695,
0.8257368206977844,
-0.0323295034468174,
-0.36116117238998413,
0.19584062695503235,
0.31279924511909485,
-0.3522784411907196,
0.9143582582473755,
-0.5807251334190369,
0.23001329600811005,
0.0451226681470871,
0.324206680059433,
-0.9224421381950378,
0.23187966644763947,
0.2590949535369873,
-0.3260612487792969,
0.02386162057518959,
-0.5243247151374817,
-0.6662886142730713,
-0.07846339046955109,
-0.423906534910202,
0.8634581565856934,
0.32973164319992065,
-0.9064226150512695,
0.7728078961372375,
0.32660412788391113,
0.13584738969802856,
-0.6585347652435303,
-0.12631087005138397,
0.29813870787620544,
-0.15797115862369537,
-0.21905072033405304,
0.9732822179794312,
-0.3618896007537842,
-0.09622394293546677,
0.0799996480345726,
-0.15979519486427307,
0.1845470666885376,
0.2588125467300415,
0.5713282227516174,
0.3429899215698242,
0.04885442927479744,
0.36261096596717834,
-0.2507239282131195,
-0.5429570078849792,
-0.22996729612350464,
-0.8665757775306702,
0.6333262324333191,
-0.12555253505706787,
-0.48413896560668945,
-0.4407334327697754,
0.3633263111114502,
0.8003888726234436,
-0.45021167397499084,
0.5817968845367432,
0.8075477480888367,
-0.28581130504608154,
-0.14224500954151154,
-0.6535331606864929,
-0.35366687178611755,
-0.47526219487190247,
0.4303835928440094,
-0.5481632351875305,
-1.1115537881851196,
0.5359336733818054,
-0.21871057152748108,
-0.05941065400838852,
0.21748346090316772,
0.518890380859375,
-0.11151072382926941,
0.9485149383544922,
0.6921250820159912,
-0.39860525727272034,
0.8347282409667969,
-0.42616045475006104,
0.25692063570022583,
-1.1252682209014893,
-0.43131783604621887,
-0.323274701833725,
-0.2566831707954407,
-0.44958898425102234,
-0.4295351505279541,
0.1445738673210144,
0.09973462671041489,
-0.15743720531463623,
0.09624731540679932,
-0.47747769951820374,
0.5693037509918213,
0.8165794610977173,
0.0168241448700428,
0.3888261318206787,
0.06757907569408417,
-0.5804799199104309,
0.09013018757104874,
-0.5184898972511292,
-0.10234489291906357,
1.2361263036727905,
0.23724092543125153,
0.7436302900314331,
-0.007817445322871208,
0.6757657527923584,
0.5936707854270935,
0.125736266374588,
-0.9570966362953186,
0.41482606530189514,
-0.482005774974823,
-0.2403702288866043,
-0.027469724416732788,
-0.088555708527565,
-0.9774174690246582,
0.25979676842689514,
-0.32852593064308167,
-0.517764151096344,
0.5459385514259338,
-0.21071062982082367,
-0.3951958417892456,
0.37076377868652344,
-0.422760933637619,
0.7364833354949951,
-0.10578296333551407,
-0.23691457509994507,
-0.3672265112400055,
-0.2638331651687622,
-0.037935931235551834,
-0.023528436198830605,
-0.06266413629055023,
-0.13474756479263306,
-0.1724875420331955,
0.7852776646614075,
-0.3314797878265381,
0.7473360300064087,
-0.1866855025291443,
0.21452327072620392,
0.018711134791374207,
0.2022300660610199,
0.6659278273582458,
0.22282302379608154,
-0.054346054792404175,
0.27759024500846863,
0.09634429961442947,
-0.2735764682292938,
-0.8102231025695801,
0.8462461233139038,
-0.5102020502090454,
-0.7328302264213562,
-0.17679116129875183,
-0.2911014258861542,
0.10174895077943802,
0.2752760052680969,
0.018277233466506004,
0.5178534984588623,
-0.23601016402244568,
0.44276559352874756,
0.49723020195961,
0.14640335738658905,
0.09664691239595413,
0.4869116544723511,
-0.41230833530426025,
-1.0651957988739014,
1.0379523038864136,
-0.06385739892721176,
-0.22133201360702515,
0.49950969219207764,
0.06586788594722748,
-0.3586108982563019,
-0.7641857266426086,
-0.11866286396980286,
0.21913102269172668,
-0.6924149394035339,
-0.38554954528808594,
-0.5390233993530273,
-0.03998708724975586,
-0.20845279097557068,
-0.04732561856508255,
-0.10043217241764069,
-0.25503140687942505,
-0.7056717276573181,
-0.2707064151763916,
0.3463941514492035,
0.6248587965965271,
0.09667239338159561,
0.09345293790102005,
-0.39782091975212097,
0.2300196886062622,
0.26033782958984375,
0.7364051342010498,
0.1463824361562729,
-0.41725629568099976,
-0.5081290006637573,
-0.33799150586128235,
-0.03530462458729744,
-0.25410187244415283,
0.2379191517829895,
-0.04640718922019005,
0.48899930715560913,
0.6000750660896301,
0.40984687209129333,
0.8059337735176086,
-0.4415045380592346,
0.5455023646354675,
0.16070683300495148,
-0.8162413835525513,
0.2147751748561859,
-0.0535665825009346,
0.05655865743756294,
0.7101824879646301,
0.10012456029653549,
-1.057847499847412,
0.129643976688385,
-0.37089064717292786,
-1.1131393909454346,
0.3275165557861328,
0.09001090377569199,
0.22021540999412537,
-0.27785998582839966,
0.6376487612724304,
0.20481500029563904,
0.20846198499202728,
-0.2979104518890381,
-0.36818811297416687,
-0.06609249114990234,
-0.43967968225479126,
-0.034342214465141296,
-0.8577704429626465,
-0.1523982733488083,
-0.08832716941833496,
0.4417513608932495,
-0.18781808018684387,
0.18465419113636017,
0.24913285672664642,
0.0757264494895935,
0.11534400284290314,
0.05438193678855896,
0.3751944601535797,
0.3678686320781708,
-0.2370098978281021,
0.14493466913700104,
-0.04991728439927101,
-0.2696739733219147,
0.1643631011247635,
-0.02719840779900551,
-0.07439051568508148,
-0.16712556779384613,
0.025084631517529488,
0.6494511961936951,
0.41975927352905273,
-0.6181455850601196,
0.7567769885063171,
-0.4569703936576843,
-0.10977594554424286,
-0.5789112448692322,
-0.13058273494243622,
-0.1823005974292755,
0.2239215075969696,
0.5537874102592468,
0.16581673920154572,
0.04052334651350975,
-0.20580598711967468,
0.38574475049972534,
0.7208337783813477,
-0.598334550857544,
-0.3007170557975769,
0.5408451557159424,
0.6234112977981567,
-0.46635860204696655,
0.8127754330635071,
-0.004936716984957457,
-0.2811921536922455,
0.1591973900794983,
0.41482123732566833,
1.2635341882705688,
0.3081216514110565,
0.10174132138490677,
0.17602476477622986,
-0.021862313151359558,
0.030855868011713028,
-0.15228185057640076,
-0.6085556745529175,
-0.6609905362129211,
-0.1656319499015808,
-0.486418217420578,
-0.2772386074066162,
-0.07977945357561111,
-0.6443079710006714,
0.3053782284259796,
-0.5717892646789551,
-0.49257615208625793,
-0.2748589515686035,
0.029570482671260834,
-0.6545495986938477,
-0.4146155118942261,
-0.18042713403701782,
0.7298076152801514,
-0.46014630794525146,
0.7812523245811462,
0.42158618569374084,
-0.38897469639778137,
-0.3002493679523468,
-0.08833582699298859,
-0.24632801115512848,
-0.7333256602287292,
0.8137392997741699,
0.05030097812414169,
-0.03621687740087509,
0.2622203528881073,
-0.17010100185871124,
-0.8484373688697815,
1.247422218322754,
0.08191146701574326,
-0.4208776354789734,
-0.05013355612754822,
-0.18706569075584412,
0.44931337237358093,
-0.6727392673492432,
0.341948002576828,
0.140849769115448,
0.23842114210128784,
0.28672367334365845,
-0.6594346761703491,
0.08923438936471939,
-0.3393603563308716,
0.4529658555984497,
0.08524496853351593,
-0.4735713601112366,
0.5411757230758667,
-0.2227369099855423,
-0.5706340670585632,
0.3500400483608246,
0.631969690322876,
0.23822471499443054,
0.43886706233024597,
0.48350563645362854,
0.5674871206283569,
0.7264348864555359,
0.09410911798477173,
0.8337914347648621,
-0.3695099353790283,
0.09115780144929886,
0.9038108587265015,
-0.28272756934165955,
0.9036421179771423,
0.7003936171531677,
-0.17028175294399261,
0.7149325013160706,
0.72602778673172,
-0.20678286254405975,
0.5119421482086182,
0.3984594941139221,
-0.3651890754699707,
-0.21911846101284027,
-0.5826513767242432,
-0.08200129866600037,
0.0033795025665313005,
0.22701843082904816,
-0.3641635775566101,
0.2627098858356476,
0.2025032788515091,
-0.3076815605163574,
0.21022291481494904,
-0.048598624765872955,
1.1823854446411133,
0.12375997006893158,
-0.2794603109359741,
0.6260902285575867,
0.17253659665584564,
0.9842404723167419,
-0.3120972216129303,
-0.2696669399738312,
-0.4905298054218292,
0.038134682923555374,
-0.17878460884094238,
-0.2786529064178467,
-0.2468290776014328,
-0.20780335366725922,
-0.5861284732818604,
-0.3084335923194885,
0.4483473300933838,
-0.37542909383773804,
-0.3228365182876587,
0.25988736748695374,
0.3741999864578247,
-0.04439324885606766,
-0.017842678353190422,
-0.4393106997013092,
-0.09209021925926208,
0.03509537875652313,
0.17083615064620972,
0.5123308897018433,
0.24614816904067993,
-0.17906880378723145,
1.037352442741394,
0.9398025274276733,
-0.011286198161542416,
-0.3285568952560425,
0.30390965938568115,
0.6531640291213989,
-0.6550107002258301,
-0.43727612495422363,
-0.7397962212562561,
0.27504998445510864,
0.058858562260866165,
-0.01544815395027399,
0.5972824096679688,
0.644760251045227,
1.0710417032241821,
0.12399061024188995,
0.42346498370170593,
0.44371297955513,
0.2685369849205017,
-0.3815562427043915,
0.5420726537704468,
-0.3065444529056549,
0.8560291528701782,
0.22178946435451508,
-0.8480681777000427,
-0.39013341069221497,
0.3445417881011963,
-0.03581427410244942,
0.14609500765800476,
0.5500870943069458,
0.8484691381454468,
0.27598631381988525,
-0.4520026445388794,
0.4591645896434784,
-0.0445869080722332,
0.5302814841270447,
0.2882451117038727,
0.8085871934890747,
-0.43527260422706604,
0.68289715051651,
-0.08985555917024612,
0.008822930045425892,
-0.4672127366065979,
-0.5221600532531738,
-0.9472782611846924,
-0.8761453628540039,
-0.2643565535545349,
-0.35336241126060486,
0.2322710156440735,
1.1876068115234375,
0.7496960163116455,
-0.7915952205657959,
-0.2806970775127411,
0.003866099752485752,
0.6016679406166077,
-0.2638472616672516,
-0.25147899985313416,
0.5074014067649841,
-0.17316217720508575,
-0.6808653473854065,
0.43391624093055725,
0.3830241858959198,
0.22470775246620178,
-0.4722314476966858,
-0.08528280258178711,
0.0973864495754242,
-0.25243476033210754,
0.5452815890312195,
-0.08784067630767822,
-0.9158450365066528,
-0.23499052226543427,
0.10269469022750854,
-0.075046107172966,
0.06623832136392593,
1.2104038000106812,
-1.24635910987854,
0.6846511960029602,
0.4467833936214447,
0.4499056041240692,
0.5276902914047241,
0.28521475195884705,
0.7338669896125793,
-0.6660773158073425,
-0.08986935019493103,
0.1931433081626892,
0.22557471692562103,
0.15421542525291443,
-0.31200844049453735,
0.4397657811641693,
0.42896777391433716,
-0.3924013376235962,
-0.9323673844337463,
0.10578708350658417,
-0.7004969716072083,
-0.13484841585159302,
0.8506525158882141,
-0.23543158173561096,
0.03862828016281128,
-0.272978276014328,
-0.3816186189651489,
-0.0808916836977005,
-0.6620656847953796,
0.7638983726501465,
0.31860852241516113,
0.3737950325012207,
-0.025648321956396103,
-0.048454925417900085,
0.4073086977005005,
0.3929930627346039,
-0.0869307741522789,
0.32323041558265686,
0.16222207248210907,
0.16128042340278625,
-0.19232085347175598,
0.6124630570411682,
-0.14233066141605377,
0.029686205089092255,
-0.35444721579551697,
0.06348031759262085,
-0.30303966999053955,
-0.25660789012908936,
-0.374598890542984,
0.2709312438964844,
0.36681869626045227,
-0.3132496774196625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10442v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10442v1
|
Domain-Specific Shorthand for Generation Based on Context-Free Grammar
| 2024-06-14T23:26:41 | 2024-06-14T23:26:41 |
Andriy Kanyuka, Elias Mahfoud
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The generation of structured data in formats such as JSON, YAML and XML is a
critical task in Generative AI (GenAI) applications. These formats, while
widely used, contain many redundant constructs that lead to inflated token
usage. This inefficiency is particularly evident when employing large language
models (LLMs) like GPT-4, where generating extensive structured data incurs
increased latency and operational costs. We introduce a domain-specific
shorthand (DSS) format, underpinned by a context-free grammar (CFG), and
demonstrate its usage to reduce the number of tokens required for structured
data generation. The method involves creating a shorthand notation that
captures essential elements of the output schema with fewer tokens, ensuring it
can be unambiguously converted to and from its verbose form. It employs a CFG
to facilitate efficient shorthand generation by the LLM, and to create parsers
to translate the shorthand back into standard structured formats. The
application of our approach to data visualization with LLMs demonstrates a
significant (3x to 5x) reduction in generated tokens, leading to significantly
lower latency and cost. This paper outlines the development of the DSS and the
accompanying CFG, and the implications of this approach for GenAI applications,
presenting a scalable solution to the token inefficiency problem in structured
data generation.
|
[
-0.19167394936084747,
-0.7787284255027771,
0.7694183588027954,
0.07300689816474915,
-0.7071924209594727,
-0.06072051823139191,
-0.22251445055007935,
-0.05652732774615288,
0.3128201961517334,
0.3078632056713104,
-0.43124648928642273,
-0.8736275434494019,
-0.4274292588233948,
0.3167400062084198,
-0.36135539412498474,
1.0728062391281128,
-0.10498368740081787,
-0.31808340549468994,
-0.6353693008422852,
-0.0377972349524498,
-0.41556161642074585,
-0.6036933064460754,
-0.7317864894866943,
0.011389033868908882,
0.3435876965522766,
0.5137419700622559,
0.8599774241447449,
1.0269447565078735,
0.4979715943336487,
0.28434109687805176,
0.15979793667793274,
0.3491736352443695,
-0.39979296922683716,
0.13249045610427856,
0.06259961426258087,
-0.15714171528816223,
-0.8749575018882751,
-0.09366225451231003,
0.6352877616882324,
0.987034022808075,
0.029944609850645065,
0.19231879711151123,
-0.0461379811167717,
0.4836505055427551,
-0.38766831159591675,
0.45824360847473145,
-0.531490683555603,
-0.0012117362348362803,
-0.8285900950431824,
-0.32908353209495544,
-0.22327829897403717,
-0.11651738733053207,
-0.15360815823078156,
-1.0638684034347534,
0.40228697657585144,
0.0438673160970211,
0.5668323040008545,
0.2882895767688751,
-0.5373372435569763,
-0.1998632699251175,
-0.5607960224151611,
0.6505115032196045,
-0.8087835311889648,
0.24662694334983826,
0.34137749671936035,
0.5444833636283875,
-0.23744720220565796,
-1.16445791721344,
-0.7480183243751526,
-0.04300159215927124,
-0.3872452974319458,
-0.07214514166116714,
0.054360873997211456,
0.22498102486133575,
0.47997745871543884,
0.2541220188140869,
-0.7312377095222473,
-0.18356923758983612,
-0.3029017448425293,
0.016573645174503326,
0.6542415618896484,
0.4982997179031372,
0.1578383892774582,
-0.27193930745124817,
-0.2547147274017334,
0.15226374566555023,
-1.1552289724349976,
-0.20757760107517242,
0.39386987686157227,
0.7316906452178955,
-0.19783145189285278,
0.5538355708122253,
-0.3106001317501068,
0.8174310922622681,
-0.00846884772181511,
-0.2378351092338562,
0.21862465143203735,
-0.613233745098114,
-0.4681074917316437,
-0.28850865364074707,
0.6863289475440979,
0.2987048327922821,
0.11870549619197845,
-0.2745875120162964,
-0.2505289316177368,
0.23899945616722107,
0.21017982065677643,
-0.987711489200592,
0.07412727177143097,
0.13592499494552612,
-0.5240176320075989,
-0.3091527819633484,
-0.12594279646873474,
-0.7300133109092712,
-0.17642542719841003,
-0.29829737544059753,
0.07273945957422256,
-0.2931230664253235,
0.158066526055336,
-0.1127721518278122,
-0.1460268348455429,
0.1217387393116951,
0.27596932649612427,
-0.9976637959480286,
0.2273542582988739,
0.6724633574485779,
0.8359120488166809,
-0.30113548040390015,
-0.0777730941772461,
-0.7499729990959167,
0.5176681280136108,
-0.5046148896217346,
0.578444242477417,
-0.4813520908355713,
-0.7897053956985474,
-0.09011679887771606,
-0.19256900250911713,
0.07961816340684891,
-0.5351054072380066,
0.43373626470565796,
-0.2681725323200226,
0.27648118138313293,
-0.16579259932041168,
-0.7564288377761841,
0.3558328151702881,
-0.03863651677966118,
-0.5751343965530396,
0.8069223761558533,
0.3909651041030884,
-0.6924187541007996,
0.753804087638855,
-0.8694469332695007,
-0.7505584955215454,
0.7296432256698608,
-0.7511612176895142,
-0.4184954762458801,
0.05703657120466232,
0.1676742285490036,
0.6815768480300903,
-0.39823782444000244,
0.5122700333595276,
-0.07515036314725876,
-0.5844615697860718,
-0.34346675872802734,
-0.26805344223976135,
0.2990419566631317,
0.2804746925830841,
-0.3529845178127289,
0.18036103248596191,
-1.015322208404541,
0.05690961703658104,
0.3534221947193146,
-0.4249483644962311,
-0.4204491376876831,
0.2125655561685562,
0.028505221009254456,
0.0065128677524626255,
0.019924422726035118,
-0.2874574065208435,
0.3440758287906647,
-0.26783350110054016,
0.4906068444252014,
0.6222451329231262,
-0.1459883153438568,
0.5621771812438965,
-0.0470934621989727,
0.6689590215682983,
0.03401792421936989,
0.1441737413406372,
-0.24522964656352997,
-0.4068315923213959,
-0.6613103151321411,
-0.5954140424728394,
0.026525061577558517,
0.07694332301616669,
-1.0839126110076904,
0.30464980006217957,
-0.6127649545669556,
-0.21510182321071625,
-0.25067847967147827,
0.13557513058185577,
0.28294262290000916,
0.8536311984062195,
0.3014943301677704,
-0.18538397550582886,
-0.44099852442741394,
-0.9933130145072937,
-0.03226586803793907,
-0.016790596768260002,
-0.20028463006019592,
0.37426432967185974,
0.2665596306324005,
-0.4097212851047516,
1.108946681022644,
-0.5202288627624512,
-0.14846163988113403,
-0.46526920795440674,
0.17488472163677216,
0.10544617474079132,
0.5406669974327087,
0.9686519503593445,
-0.7798307538032532,
-0.4292224049568176,
-0.2396220713853836,
-0.6594259142875671,
-0.18868301808834076,
-0.22285832464694977,
-0.307847261428833,
0.2956131100654602,
0.5467177033424377,
-0.7729941010475159,
0.5540601015090942,
0.41472387313842773,
-0.6308401226997375,
0.3898134231567383,
0.13058623671531677,
-0.13418719172477722,
-1.2351007461547852,
0.41521403193473816,
-0.22702695429325104,
-0.4661293923854828,
-0.9273625612258911,
0.17249560356140137,
0.07781296968460083,
-0.3487395942211151,
-0.47732219099998474,
0.6907872557640076,
-0.2647690176963806,
-0.006751511711627245,
-0.07238803058862686,
0.07473442703485489,
0.23199588060379028,
0.3959493637084961,
0.09907251596450806,
1.1567317247390747,
0.4522453844547272,
-0.5963916778564453,
0.19450393319129944,
0.3729762136936188,
-0.020822519436478615,
0.6233906149864197,
-0.621246337890625,
-0.002961382968351245,
-0.17336013913154602,
0.3014126718044281,
-0.39295080304145813,
-0.3613116443157196,
0.39560186862945557,
-0.09986042976379395,
0.2962750494480133,
-0.2129931002855301,
-0.4905780553817749,
-0.25606217980384827,
-0.20629000663757324,
0.6746841669082642,
0.4371919631958008,
-0.7256554365158081,
0.5706133246421814,
-0.12953083217144012,
-0.26236221194267273,
-0.3091202676296234,
-0.6620694994926453,
0.22515279054641724,
-0.465318500995636,
-0.7424058318138123,
0.6321634650230408,
-0.2849765419960022,
-0.18987996876239777,
-0.004076017532497644,
-0.08974315971136093,
0.11161815375089645,
0.07726804167032242,
0.23512159287929535,
0.25733262300491333,
-0.35439950227737427,
0.02193392813205719,
0.2781031131744385,
-0.042136300355196,
-0.0841146782040596,
-0.3086775243282318,
0.4342397451400757,
-0.0963645875453949,
-0.34127286076545715,
-0.40442290902137756,
0.7704982757568359,
0.6481465101242065,
0.10251568257808685,
0.5927042365074158,
0.12404276430606842,
-0.29141125082969666,
-0.4386484920978546,
0.1929546594619751,
0.18800121545791626,
-0.5177745819091797,
0.13632793724536896,
-0.5281310081481934,
-0.7037608027458191,
0.40895920991897583,
-0.06967368721961975,
-0.07429303228855133,
0.5499974489212036,
0.4209825098514557,
0.09865433722734451,
0.9418359398841858,
0.5766729116439819,
0.0213030856102705,
0.2951863706111908,
-0.2623680531978607,
0.48898911476135254,
-0.35149943828582764,
-0.09926202148199081,
-0.31860804557800293,
-0.074541836977005,
-0.45892587304115295,
-0.3987473249435425,
0.3350471556186676,
0.1353478878736496,
-0.2045193612575531,
0.14623911678791046,
-0.23617462813854218,
0.47059372067451477,
0.5800371170043945,
-0.4422425329685211,
0.2518131136894226,
-0.051154736429452896,
-0.05730133876204491,
0.19130674004554749,
-0.6177797317504883,
-0.6683207750320435,
1.1219482421875,
-0.07188596576452255,
0.4414162337779999,
0.11966091394424438,
0.920557975769043,
0.6016774773597717,
0.27521732449531555,
-0.6913237571716309,
0.6987252235412598,
-0.2678632438182831,
-0.07173281162977219,
-0.2796402871608734,
-0.5451611280441284,
-0.7073264122009277,
0.0004450853739399463,
0.03495631366968155,
-0.2367936670780182,
-0.025052476674318314,
0.3213844299316406,
-0.4196203947067261,
0.1716437190771103,
-0.7045042514801025,
0.8349498510360718,
-0.0415429063141346,
-0.215179905295372,
0.13896971940994263,
-0.4934912621974945,
0.2954934239387512,
-0.18308617174625397,
0.00812465324997902,
-0.011510893702507019,
0.19050325453281403,
0.5628008246421814,
-0.8638105392456055,
0.77088862657547,
-0.38340792059898376,
-0.01640079729259014,
0.40288785099983215,
0.039399828761816025,
0.6474013924598694,
0.28483298420906067,
0.27566418051719666,
0.1505037546157837,
-0.16478466987609863,
-0.4793092906475067,
-0.6153698563575745,
0.6128646731376648,
-0.42312943935394287,
-0.5925502181053162,
-0.22746151685714722,
-0.4235635995864868,
-0.26654019951820374,
0.2938091456890106,
0.26782533526420593,
0.42661362886428833,
-0.224364772439003,
0.011218829080462456,
0.01509164460003376,
-0.06149374693632126,
0.43321919441223145,
0.07147287577390671,
0.051056936383247375,
-0.2828228175640106,
0.779651403427124,
-0.18698908388614655,
0.15519125759601593,
0.018909718841314316,
0.05332157760858536,
-0.18934482336044312,
-0.5003209710121155,
-0.7809696197509766,
0.05485238879919052,
-0.6014810800552368,
-0.6038233041763306,
-0.24348950386047363,
-0.06525284051895142,
-0.6087568402290344,
-0.523822546005249,
-0.08003810793161392,
-0.779280424118042,
-0.5469825863838196,
-0.20724019408226013,
0.22466695308685303,
0.5705012679100037,
0.19472813606262207,
0.575438916683197,
-0.5893232226371765,
0.5015150904655457,
0.3757464587688446,
0.45782846212387085,
-0.2650865614414215,
0.09032883495092392,
-0.2459501177072525,
-0.13623970746994019,
-0.1132282242178917,
-0.5885046124458313,
0.38239753246307373,
0.4502822756767273,
0.3262158930301666,
0.660620391368866,
-0.1885567158460617,
0.8434306383132935,
-0.6680519580841064,
1.163736343383789,
0.0515323206782341,
-1.1787772178649902,
0.4765493869781494,
-0.5560874342918396,
-0.11719787865877151,
0.23441307246685028,
0.009162367321550846,
-0.7428295016288757,
-0.35429489612579346,
-0.5261545777320862,
-1.1694612503051758,
0.6191218495368958,
0.3094196021556854,
0.12448179721832275,
-0.548659086227417,
0.569084882736206,
0.48079508543014526,
0.3592909872531891,
-0.3245958983898163,
-0.2087501585483551,
-0.5939044952392578,
-0.41791439056396484,
-0.1100878119468689,
-0.16756825149059296,
-0.37473830580711365,
0.0339173898100853,
0.4105478525161743,
-0.5963636040687561,
0.31369495391845703,
-0.12806065380573273,
-0.010190277360379696,
0.1384536772966385,
0.36890867352485657,
0.6544628739356995,
0.6030951738357544,
0.06379064172506332,
0.13649553060531616,
-0.21928375959396362,
-0.1999974548816681,
-0.11399856209754944,
0.13461457192897797,
-0.6095824837684631,
0.03784830868244171,
0.3203370273113251,
0.7798574566841125,
-0.2874981760978699,
-0.7239824533462524,
0.7664755582809448,
-0.10797930508852005,
-0.2261117547750473,
-0.24478645622730255,
-0.08425885438919067,
-0.07850807160139084,
0.14530394971370697,
0.2566881775856018,
-0.20049116015434265,
0.08759933710098267,
-0.1916569620370865,
0.03227438032627106,
0.49568724632263184,
0.5056431889533997,
-0.37066400051116943,
0.966391384601593,
0.4551902711391449,
-0.046207692474126816,
0.621652364730835,
-0.39603158831596375,
-0.07507610321044922,
0.5722960233688354,
0.7016833424568176,
0.8768837451934814,
0.31581366062164307,
0.27608194947242737,
-0.03372395411133766,
-0.22249208390712738,
0.15963932871818542,
0.39068999886512756,
-0.40338775515556335,
-0.4478723704814911,
-0.22680681943893433,
-0.6975114345550537,
-0.24591024219989777,
0.3167009651660919,
-0.48369359970092773,
0.12272612005472183,
-0.5435376167297363,
-0.2216036021709442,
-0.15631914138793945,
-0.1206757128238678,
-0.941580593585968,
0.2898022532463074,
0.19018448889255524,
0.8466783761978149,
-0.878963828086853,
0.7334949374198914,
0.4769906997680664,
-0.4821244776248932,
-0.6220179200172424,
0.0339224711060524,
-0.06629997491836548,
-0.5061594843864441,
0.7479254007339478,
-0.09457379579544067,
-0.05233904346823692,
-0.25883856415748596,
-0.5813711285591125,
-0.867169201374054,
1.3037803173065186,
0.2701667249202728,
-0.41718602180480957,
-0.17916443943977356,
0.5801540613174438,
0.5814030766487122,
-0.49158069491386414,
-0.3183816075325012,
0.7224493622779846,
0.550998866558075,
-0.14620956778526306,
-0.5070058107376099,
0.40054816007614136,
-0.48298925161361694,
0.38801509141921997,
0.16533726453781128,
-0.4957556128501892,
0.8072980642318726,
0.022327745333313942,
-0.6596497893333435,
0.3685910999774933,
0.7742472290992737,
0.3145274519920349,
0.5053462386131287,
0.2818356156349182,
0.4082198441028595,
0.8358159065246582,
-0.13055744767189026,
1.0091183185577393,
-0.4025934040546417,
-0.010683012194931507,
0.8135489821434021,
-0.40453651547431946,
0.3539438247680664,
0.7341305017471313,
0.136927992105484,
0.38755306601524353,
0.3550296425819397,
0.15870368480682373,
0.6087695360183716,
0.22117236256599426,
-0.331305593252182,
0.07304197549819946,
-0.006662095431238413,
-0.19957235455513,
0.4421626925468445,
0.35017824172973633,
-0.4737904965877533,
-0.18663962185382843,
-0.1760082095861435,
0.3083798289299011,
0.11468009650707245,
-0.21257959306240082,
0.5390430092811584,
-0.16217051446437836,
-0.40702980756759644,
0.5427341461181641,
0.2658987045288086,
0.5779128670692444,
-0.6685731410980225,
-0.06044188141822815,
-0.6963110566139221,
-0.17406073212623596,
-0.05807039886713028,
-0.3073263168334961,
0.5217759609222412,
0.29379528760910034,
-0.18612942099571228,
-0.4842739403247833,
0.4324791431427002,
-0.5471290349960327,
-0.3932735323905945,
0.0406452901661396,
0.7185445427894592,
0.022955602034926414,
0.1973285973072052,
-0.09251553565263748,
-0.19896607100963593,
-0.3176649510860443,
-0.3226577639579773,
0.24262794852256775,
0.49643489718437195,
-0.4653313159942627,
0.3308871388435364,
0.5779921412467957,
0.3173193037509918,
0.016196953132748604,
0.3812335431575775,
1.0819389820098877,
-0.7490715980529785,
-0.6783817410469055,
-0.5124593377113342,
0.26821985840797424,
-0.08548162877559662,
-0.22505173087120056,
0.4908633828163147,
0.6691768765449524,
0.9059995412826538,
-0.16977442800998688,
1.1488324403762817,
-0.25970879197120667,
0.19131553173065186,
-0.6524190902709961,
0.7017278671264648,
-0.664149284362793,
0.01811155490577221,
-0.2679942548274994,
-0.7310994863510132,
-0.638185977935791,
0.223832368850708,
-0.01558712124824524,
0.016361186280846596,
0.6299429535865784,
0.6203325986862183,
-0.19571660459041595,
-0.31995972990989685,
0.4640927016735077,
-0.21173541247844696,
0.7206707000732422,
0.40982234477996826,
0.4566057324409485,
-0.03628998622298241,
0.44581466913223267,
-0.13165810704231262,
-0.07133181393146515,
-0.012299764901399612,
-1.0210402011871338,
-0.760427713394165,
-0.6558345556259155,
-0.10717987269163132,
-0.07505808770656586,
0.10905948281288147,
0.9492334127426147,
0.5715352296829224,
-0.6227847337722778,
0.019817747175693512,
-0.11873754858970642,
-0.194379523396492,
-0.1530962586402893,
-0.24724459648132324,
0.7552058100700378,
-0.37267670035362244,
-0.7926630973815918,
0.7697849273681641,
0.2790866494178772,
0.37753236293792725,
0.13434846699237823,
-0.18324804306030273,
0.5765615105628967,
0.28315508365631104,
0.7431032061576843,
0.4103127121925354,
-0.5674404501914978,
-0.5621328949928284,
-0.25191232562065125,
-0.11164497584104538,
0.07607755810022354,
1.2092927694320679,
-0.9454392790794373,
0.07512883841991425,
0.4590032398700714,
0.5407518744468689,
0.18464714288711548,
0.45563024282455444,
0.5747495293617249,
-1.3180185556411743,
0.2240697294473648,
0.22558251023292542,
0.501421332359314,
0.43979889154434204,
-0.5736747980117798,
0.3305901288986206,
0.4708487391471863,
-0.23456278443336487,
-0.6805070042610168,
0.46720677614212036,
-0.8546801805496216,
-0.1718997359275818,
1.1384855508804321,
0.023020457476377487,
-0.030678752809762955,
0.19155557453632355,
0.07239784300327301,
0.1451474130153656,
-0.4472097158432007,
0.7626277208328247,
0.2303813099861145,
-0.21888427436351776,
0.4582318067550659,
-0.10810485482215881,
1.0206336975097656,
0.14113320410251617,
-1.0145117044448853,
0.315353125333786,
0.832094132900238,
0.08334231376647949,
-0.045484889298677444,
0.9921339750289917,
-0.09945853054523468,
-0.026207974180579185,
-0.026777315884828568,
0.00901087000966072,
-0.34892404079437256,
-0.6313037872314453,
-0.30325642228126526,
0.16536647081375122,
-0.20001745223999023,
-0.22854557633399963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10432v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10432v1
|
Enhancing In-Context Learning with Semantic Representations for Relation Extraction
| 2024-06-14T22:36:08 | 2024-06-14T22:36:08 |
Peitao Han, Lis Kanashiro Pereira, Fei Cheng, Wan Jou She, Eiji Aramaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work, we employ two AMR-enhanced semantic representations for ICL on
RE: one that explores the AMR structure generated for a sentence at the
subgraph level (shortest AMR path), and another that explores the full AMR
structure generated for a sentence. In both cases, we demonstrate that all
settings benefit from the fine-grained AMR's semantic structure. We evaluate
our model on four RE datasets. Our results show that our model can outperform
the GPT-based baselines, and achieve SOTA performance on two of the datasets,
and competitive performance on the other two.
|
[
-0.35835617780685425,
-0.8303856253623962,
0.5408522486686707,
-0.2288406491279602,
-0.2699894607067108,
-0.15285807847976685,
-0.10594383627176285,
-0.7630603313446045,
0.09026218950748444,
0.3846181035041809,
-0.6594957709312439,
-0.31412026286125183,
-0.5271962285041809,
0.23146088421344757,
-0.3109899163246155,
1.2078428268432617,
-0.056677039712667465,
0.06793614476919174,
-0.28922492265701294,
-0.18008126318454742,
-0.42352327704429626,
-0.601010262966156,
-0.5819679498672485,
-0.7957272529602051,
0.5279529094696045,
0.5910469889640808,
0.6254589557647705,
0.6110561490058899,
0.5963559746742249,
0.2128337174654007,
-0.016270102933049202,
0.22390013933181763,
-0.3808688223361969,
0.24941830337047577,
-0.31416866183280945,
-0.14814960956573486,
-0.3091028928756714,
-0.027569277212023735,
0.6783207058906555,
0.6648846864700317,
0.04507721588015556,
0.15778182446956635,
0.137025848031044,
0.6360776424407959,
-0.5648941993713379,
0.4846397340297699,
-0.678428590297699,
0.05908854678273201,
-0.14758650958538055,
-0.2301722764968872,
-0.3694993555545807,
0.10354059934616089,
0.574515700340271,
-0.7897432446479797,
0.04509991034865379,
0.277182936668396,
1.2796207666397095,
0.13562436401844025,
-0.8019896149635315,
-0.4022442400455475,
-0.7292239665985107,
0.7268546223640442,
-0.4021199941635132,
0.6509081721305847,
0.03888031467795372,
0.5683229565620422,
-0.12862686812877655,
-0.9607171416282654,
-0.40752896666526794,
-0.16187921166419983,
-0.3700519800186157,
0.20759126543998718,
-0.1070743277668953,
-0.0024356141220778227,
0.31446248292922974,
0.48634326457977295,
-0.2298291027545929,
-0.2078174650669098,
-0.2518469989299774,
0.07038096338510513,
0.4562342166900635,
0.40533217787742615,
0.24916623532772064,
-0.5200411081314087,
-0.5803308486938477,
-0.029137687757611275,
-0.982308030128479,
0.09320573508739471,
-0.09579003602266312,
0.5009147524833679,
-0.024780742824077606,
0.6580834984779358,
-0.21737998723983765,
0.6781328320503235,
-0.17218606173992157,
0.02310142107307911,
0.1823582500219345,
-0.5421216487884521,
-0.14797522127628326,
0.12748266756534576,
0.6399284601211548,
0.3046802580356598,
0.512029767036438,
-0.4516681134700775,
-0.14102308452129364,
0.04474867135286331,
-0.012608800083398819,
-0.8232633471488953,
-0.22714324295520782,
-0.3364637494087219,
-0.6217922568321228,
0.11938802152872086,
0.38387539982795715,
-0.4395679533481598,
0.07115750759840012,
-0.642015814781189,
0.25226083397865295,
-0.6785802841186523,
0.011972583830356598,
0.025008568540215492,
-0.1570788323879242,
0.576092541217804,
0.2976566255092621,
-0.8470773100852966,
0.665981113910675,
0.5178470015525818,
0.6617622375488281,
0.09495198726654053,
-0.16279350221157074,
-0.611034095287323,
0.49223092198371887,
-0.03809082508087158,
0.7984998822212219,
-0.9342347383499146,
-0.3055647015571594,
-0.16053511202335358,
0.05316651985049248,
-0.05343285948038101,
-0.576468288898468,
0.3435007333755493,
-0.7445757985115051,
0.11787901073694229,
-0.35433799028396606,
-0.7520516514778137,
-0.19187141954898834,
0.26149076223373413,
-0.6262468099594116,
0.9605028629302979,
0.27130287885665894,
-0.9378129839897156,
0.6924664974212646,
-0.7555097937583923,
-0.5022121071815491,
-0.14659728109836578,
-0.4668016731739044,
-0.25243866443634033,
0.0009091822430491447,
0.3540402948856354,
0.4921840727329254,
-0.39923250675201416,
0.23902049660682678,
-0.11361734569072723,
-0.43861401081085205,
0.17651599645614624,
-0.17553094029426575,
0.4697358012199402,
0.26420310139656067,
-0.13046158850193024,
0.12311076372861862,
-0.8424146175384521,
-0.06327765434980392,
-0.041356462985277176,
-0.591599702835083,
-0.7975194454193115,
-0.06491949409246445,
0.18798980116844177,
0.341663658618927,
0.03669468313455582,
-0.7671422362327576,
0.11914469301700592,
-0.716542661190033,
0.4718615710735321,
0.4957616925239563,
0.43765637278556824,
0.5562863349914551,
0.001988035859540105,
0.2825835347175598,
0.33524996042251587,
-0.23924468457698822,
-0.11274165660142899,
-0.2571850121021271,
-0.7879568338394165,
-0.025671327486634254,
0.4856449067592621,
0.47370168566703796,
-0.7815836071968079,
0.3401002585887909,
-0.5726190209388733,
-0.015069142915308475,
-0.5635459423065186,
0.0010939515195786953,
0.6718655824661255,
0.7538437247276306,
0.6677653193473816,
-0.2825563848018646,
-0.5941323041915894,
-0.9425825476646423,
-0.3173191547393799,
0.05376292020082474,
-0.10595244914293289,
0.543801486492157,
0.6349265575408936,
-0.28681984543800354,
1.4627765417099,
-0.6110512614250183,
-0.45575425028800964,
-0.3590546250343323,
-0.01812560111284256,
0.07713150978088379,
0.5240618586540222,
0.2582258880138397,
-1.0260409116744995,
-0.7749966979026794,
0.11541131883859634,
-0.9138913750648499,
0.19253365695476532,
0.0800553411245346,
-0.07641209661960602,
-0.17034271359443665,
0.6511528491973877,
-0.49074095487594604,
0.7052764892578125,
-0.1522945612668991,
-0.6052972078323364,
0.23413261771202087,
-0.19653642177581787,
0.03446384146809578,
-1.3492034673690796,
0.0034271853510290384,
0.06398898363113403,
-0.41333314776420593,
-0.4289087951183319,
-0.11481090635061264,
0.1852312833070755,
-0.07109414041042328,
-0.3608994483947754,
0.569625735282898,
-0.47755271196365356,
-0.23306764662265778,
0.028089767321944237,
0.41457319259643555,
0.15197895467281342,
0.3143429458141327,
0.1394934505224228,
0.7671497464179993,
0.2738592326641083,
-0.5980177521705627,
0.09550739824771881,
0.5389244556427002,
-0.43937933444976807,
0.24850711226463318,
-0.6314470171928406,
-0.10169768333435059,
-0.2105000764131546,
0.3218449652194977,
-0.8116965293884277,
-0.28585031628608704,
0.19592250883579254,
-0.2606525421142578,
0.46176669001579285,
-0.05102952569723129,
-0.5135493278503418,
0.12505199015140533,
-0.09119348227977753,
0.33552321791648865,
0.24695837497711182,
-0.7800517082214355,
0.46696627140045166,
0.34793058037757874,
0.26345905661582947,
-0.551268994808197,
-0.7740800976753235,
-0.018770772963762283,
-0.48134538531303406,
-0.6856539845466614,
0.8101993799209595,
0.26610976457595825,
-0.43927544355392456,
0.48108458518981934,
-0.015968002378940582,
-0.05020708963274956,
-0.002421350684016943,
0.09051056206226349,
0.05201292037963867,
-0.4559917747974396,
0.22847416996955872,
-0.08520504087209702,
-0.5063220262527466,
-0.03880273923277855,
0.0658024325966835,
0.32166585326194763,
-0.15595455467700958,
-0.13422273099422455,
-0.43005868792533875,
0.4638538956642151,
0.34628862142562866,
-0.29423123598098755,
0.8698449730873108,
0.40767478942871094,
-0.418499231338501,
-0.017676835879683495,
-0.1253790259361267,
-0.24007536470890045,
-0.4241204857826233,
0.328576922416687,
-0.8248280882835388,
-1.0465428829193115,
0.6183627247810364,
-0.15586146712303162,
-0.19986698031425476,
0.3904324471950531,
0.08052989095449448,
0.22006244957447052,
0.8767480850219727,
0.7475885152816772,
-0.1019231528043747,
0.7229660749435425,
-0.46101176738739014,
0.29079484939575195,
-1.3862942457199097,
-0.3926251530647278,
-0.14075331389904022,
-0.07493136823177338,
-0.4612140655517578,
-0.20247791707515717,
0.3974699079990387,
0.10693906247615814,
-0.4415121078491211,
0.4122876822948456,
-0.15186400711536407,
0.5200228691101074,
0.5218096971511841,
0.40957990288734436,
0.4780295193195343,
-0.027006706222891808,
-0.1914951056241989,
-0.28767305612564087,
-0.6237097382545471,
-0.6253929138183594,
0.7807003855705261,
0.3481580913066864,
0.9739381074905396,
0.2525050640106201,
0.7162308096885681,
0.011383678764104843,
0.33092445135116577,
-0.9495897889137268,
0.380704402923584,
-0.31136462092399597,
-0.5227982997894287,
-0.2926410436630249,
-0.41442155838012695,
-0.9597882032394409,
0.5017715096473694,
-0.2360590696334839,
-0.7273194789886475,
0.19785471260547638,
-0.1425686627626419,
-0.2545018494129181,
0.019778868183493614,
-0.7189503312110901,
0.8854860663414001,
0.2189929336309433,
-0.34987714886665344,
0.019531814381480217,
-0.9949479699134827,
0.3048187494277954,
0.2441338449716568,
-0.060543473809957504,
-0.002027033129706979,
-0.05602733790874481,
0.5968533754348755,
-0.5349388718605042,
0.6413678526878357,
-0.20347070693969727,
0.38815510272979736,
0.34801533818244934,
-0.20090433955192566,
0.4828833341598511,
0.15804028511047363,
-0.20930616557598114,
-0.27290427684783936,
-0.1776389330625534,
-0.08831609785556793,
-0.8192691802978516,
0.57914137840271,
-0.6610192060470581,
-0.43407297134399414,
-0.23455485701560974,
-0.6246416568756104,
-0.3515273630619049,
0.17722460627555847,
0.2258499264717102,
0.8526761531829834,
-0.21212536096572876,
0.5913447737693787,
0.48807814717292786,
-0.0014014594489708543,
0.31060951948165894,
0.313457190990448,
-0.07296241074800491,
-0.22503523528575897,
0.4070684015750885,
0.26756441593170166,
0.21034173667430878,
0.7453241944313049,
0.25274458527565,
-0.5726117491722107,
-0.2125929296016693,
-0.28486233949661255,
0.12674027681350708,
-1.1127699613571167,
-0.42879369854927063,
-0.8115586638450623,
-0.3098802864551544,
-0.38999396562576294,
-0.07764822244644165,
-0.09745898097753525,
-0.38210776448249817,
-0.3069886565208435,
-0.2618764638900757,
0.46365296840667725,
0.9068177938461304,
0.24383385479450226,
0.3851713240146637,
-0.7008369565010071,
0.03510013967752457,
0.13200415670871735,
0.02952047437429428,
0.1523238867521286,
-0.3542296588420868,
-0.3708336353302002,
-0.2939983308315277,
-0.18298569321632385,
-0.6186003088951111,
0.2974492013454437,
0.5142799615859985,
0.5468224883079529,
0.31908151507377625,
0.18811027705669403,
1.2253557443618774,
-0.7951762080192566,
0.6534432172775269,
-0.07176359742879868,
-0.7921711802482605,
0.7506063580513,
-0.17679515480995178,
0.30872905254364014,
0.6919704079627991,
0.30873581767082214,
-0.2011476457118988,
-0.3471989631652832,
-0.8353576064109802,
-1.0095943212509155,
0.741340160369873,
0.224538654088974,
0.0937473475933075,
-0.23415927588939667,
0.7860653400421143,
-0.10718367248773575,
-0.08601582050323486,
-1.0040065050125122,
-0.27938786149024963,
-0.014478039927780628,
-0.36967921257019043,
0.05698343366384506,
-0.5596873760223389,
0.23559807240962982,
-0.1623135507106781,
0.5264637470245361,
-0.0021134852431714535,
0.20476031303405762,
0.6040830016136169,
-0.21846294403076172,
0.003213115967810154,
0.23649705946445465,
-0.006150482222437859,
0.7258004546165466,
-0.31078171730041504,
0.38258886337280273,
0.2577532231807709,
-0.21022078394889832,
-0.04313921928405762,
-0.010395992547273636,
0.03797195106744766,
-0.08531126379966736,
0.8045303821563721,
0.6000086069107056,
0.7376874089241028,
-0.557904839515686,
0.5868313908576965,
-0.1755685955286026,
0.1329679638147354,
-0.1707746386528015,
0.02627546526491642,
-0.06420592218637466,
0.42929357290267944,
0.18114478886127472,
-0.17693281173706055,
0.4351300597190857,
-0.619230329990387,
0.7614304423332214,
0.3988877534866333,
-0.6972703337669373,
-0.2150043100118637,
0.5854677557945251,
-0.05569661408662796,
-0.026970289647579193,
0.8108380436897278,
0.026792526245117188,
-0.511181116104126,
0.37815144658088684,
1.038087248802185,
0.6937212347984314,
0.06592962890863419,
-0.3000372648239136,
0.5032657980918884,
-0.05320436507463455,
0.44568291306495667,
-0.045227959752082825,
-0.2974778711795807,
-0.740480899810791,
-0.3048253059387207,
-0.7400129437446594,
-0.29328906536102295,
-0.13977205753326416,
-0.8906576633453369,
0.3909103572368622,
-0.14471611380577087,
0.1413155496120453,
-0.08950618654489517,
0.20342159271240234,
-0.5670544505119324,
0.2542935609817505,
-0.25490912795066833,
1.0165233612060547,
-0.8493786454200745,
1.244835376739502,
0.8799207210540771,
-0.6787502765655518,
-1.0799310207366943,
0.26121556758880615,
-0.2597617208957672,
-0.4962713122367859,
1.1664961576461792,
0.3308853507041931,
-0.26470887660980225,
0.024251634255051613,
-0.14144785702228546,
-1.0177723169326782,
1.419385552406311,
0.3996954560279846,
-0.19555525481700897,
-0.08649211376905441,
-0.0190115999430418,
0.4833217263221741,
-1.0393997430801392,
-0.04918207228183746,
0.4153529405593872,
0.04919430986046791,
0.31400954723358154,
-0.5162262320518494,
0.25152865052223206,
-0.08730506896972656,
0.2291090041399002,
0.24394257366657257,
-0.44728267192840576,
0.8997226357460022,
0.060344796627759933,
-0.4566969573497772,
0.027962295338511467,
0.9175963401794434,
0.37750282883644104,
0.2659931182861328,
0.41186556220054626,
0.40368035435676575,
0.5794464945793152,
-0.012731350027024746,
1.225183367729187,
-0.18545322120189667,
0.4132177233695984,
1.4513981342315674,
-0.11614532768726349,
0.9393950700759888,
0.6660377979278564,
0.07855381816625595,
0.6887816190719604,
0.8634083271026611,
0.40306663513183594,
0.9711333513259888,
0.05943695828318596,
-0.2082720249891281,
-0.26435840129852295,
-0.36365026235580444,
-0.2652420401573181,
0.4320365786552429,
0.41861841082572937,
-0.4326406419277191,
-0.5860524773597717,
0.06856367737054825,
0.10305283218622208,
0.1932714581489563,
-0.16995546221733093,
0.8755948543548584,
0.274016410112381,
-0.46429356932640076,
0.14545820653438568,
-0.1816129833459854,
0.4238811433315277,
-0.5675954818725586,
-0.40394026041030884,
-0.09883929789066315,
0.4069010019302368,
-0.09922107309103012,
-0.6128519177436829,
0.5759006142616272,
-0.17514964938163757,
-0.4148939251899719,
-0.12030797451734543,
1.1109676361083984,
-0.6171432733535767,
-0.2658015191555023,
0.6435508728027344,
0.5006304383277893,
0.06488271057605743,
0.19179633259773254,
-0.6538791656494141,
-0.13528195023536682,
-0.14075489342212677,
-0.43143051862716675,
0.3505224883556366,
0.8615090847015381,
-0.20392435789108276,
0.5825142860412598,
0.3332330584526062,
-0.26415401697158813,
0.0009857142576947808,
0.07734663784503937,
1.1846939325332642,
-0.8731904625892639,
-0.3872391879558563,
-1.1426435708999634,
0.5880347490310669,
-0.2326948493719101,
-0.21133509278297424,
0.8687319159507751,
0.759184718132019,
0.9573019742965698,
0.02605961076915264,
0.5988919734954834,
-0.29647397994995117,
0.4602709114551544,
-0.8560694456100464,
0.3591617941856384,
-0.5644350051879883,
0.3644843101501465,
-0.37875059247016907,
-1.0060994625091553,
-0.6276425123214722,
0.8929104208946228,
-0.47705814242362976,
-0.2330395132303238,
0.8423799872398376,
0.6770547032356262,
-0.4231283664703369,
-0.015817223116755486,
0.26355305314064026,
-0.010303053073585033,
0.490319162607193,
0.5727542042732239,
1.0712535381317139,
-0.6928078532218933,
0.4257945418357849,
-0.12944036722183228,
-0.2972199320793152,
0.11054851114749908,
-0.8212501406669617,
-0.9423972368240356,
-0.6670207381248474,
-0.16148146986961365,
-0.2386569380760193,
-0.09110382199287415,
0.9155208468437195,
0.6897299289703369,
-0.6241095066070557,
-0.24892495572566986,
-0.17315992712974548,
0.15075616538524628,
0.012672588229179382,
-0.2571222484111786,
0.5304346680641174,
-0.6812912821769714,
-0.633819043636322,
0.4837738275527954,
0.15686629712581635,
-0.032035619020462036,
0.01257726177573204,
-0.23282842338085175,
-0.5057074427604675,
-0.30070170760154724,
0.8103248476982117,
-0.20320571959018707,
-0.7180300951004028,
-0.7686301469802856,
-0.30033785104751587,
0.042740218341350555,
0.17860151827335358,
0.8215375542640686,
-0.848680853843689,
0.34160560369491577,
0.4214990437030792,
0.5625638961791992,
0.6709270477294922,
0.2805248200893402,
0.681039035320282,
-0.9664639830589294,
0.06871108710765839,
0.08206652849912643,
0.47913575172424316,
0.28958576917648315,
-0.5520329475402832,
0.9702341556549072,
0.061150550842285156,
-0.49487704038619995,
-0.4880843758583069,
0.29038166999816895,
-0.7398691773414612,
-0.24808521568775177,
1.1190235614776611,
-0.37390217185020447,
-0.36887872219085693,
-0.3714405596256256,
-0.13197602331638336,
0.3871474862098694,
-0.40793219208717346,
0.31373798847198486,
0.6295813322067261,
-0.7389945983886719,
0.05608183890581131,
-0.6162839531898499,
0.4840205907821655,
-0.040385425090789795,
-0.6080144047737122,
0.17300277948379517,
0.3376903533935547,
0.3105691969394684,
0.1793253868818283,
0.6414331793785095,
-0.4292210638523102,
-0.1394549459218979,
-0.12103001028299332,
-0.3112300932407379,
-0.014280895702540874,
-0.4824330806732178,
-0.14629247784614563,
0.06316772848367691,
0.16985519230365753,
-0.07586417347192764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10421v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10421v1
|
SciEx: Benchmarking Large Language Models on Scientific Exams with Human Expert Grading and Automatic Grading
| 2024-06-14T21:52:21 | 2024-06-14T21:52:21 |
Tu Anh Dinh, Carlos Mullov, Leonard Bärmann, Zhaolin Li, Danni Liu, Simon Reiß, Jueun Lee, Nathan Lerzer, Fabian Ternava, Jianfeng Gao, Alexander Waibel, Tamim Asfour, Michael Beigl, Rainer Stiefelhagen, Carsten Dachsbacher, Klemens Böhm, Jan Niehues
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
With the rapid development of Large Language Models (LLMs), it is crucial to
have benchmarks which can evaluate the ability of LLMs on different domains.
One common use of LLMs is performing tasks on scientific topics, such as
writing algorithms, querying databases or giving mathematical proofs. Inspired
by the way university students are evaluated on such tasks, in this paper, we
propose SciEx - a benchmark consisting of university computer science exam
questions, to evaluate LLMs ability on solving scientific tasks. SciEx is (1)
multilingual, containing both English and German exams, and (2) multi-modal,
containing questions that involve images, and (3) contains various types of
freeform questions with different difficulty levels, due to the nature of
university exams. We evaluate the performance of various state-of-the-art LLMs
on our new benchmark. Since SciEx questions are freeform, it is not
straightforward to evaluate LLM performance. Therefore, we provide human expert
grading of the LLM outputs on SciEx. We show that the free-form exams in SciEx
remain challenging for the current LLMs, where the best LLM only achieves
59.4\% exam grade on average. We also provide detailed comparisons between LLM
performance and student performance on SciEx. To enable future evaluation of
new LLMs, we propose using LLM-as-a-judge to grade the LLM answers on SciEx.
Our experiments show that, although they do not perform perfectly on solving
the exams, LLMs are decent as graders, achieving 0.948 Pearson correlation with
expert grading.
|
[
-0.15245263278484344,
-0.4005289673805237,
0.5359216928482056,
0.4165768623352051,
-0.11433138698339462,
0.44538044929504395,
-0.4175453186035156,
-0.5713973045349121,
0.16957026720046997,
0.2663402557373047,
-0.2591651976108551,
-0.6179807782173157,
-0.4154594838619232,
0.521534264087677,
-0.3348572254180908,
0.658967137336731,
-0.25625014305114746,
0.6532974243164062,
-0.9413706064224243,
-0.12718147039413452,
-0.07685153186321259,
-0.5193426012992859,
-0.7360790371894836,
-0.3565673828125,
0.24011552333831787,
0.23504595458507538,
0.22528158128261566,
0.5629334449768066,
0.7178017497062683,
0.4010407030582428,
-0.1902255266904831,
-0.038646526634693146,
-0.2542761564254761,
0.1688329428434372,
-0.3690794110298157,
-0.6118058562278748,
-0.5047426819801331,
0.21747009456157684,
0.7992209196090698,
0.9495741724967957,
0.11944200843572617,
0.2528103291988373,
-0.02191191539168358,
0.23636998236179352,
-0.3678385019302368,
0.15842682123184204,
-0.3644934296607971,
0.0014501583063974977,
-0.07273540645837784,
-0.12224891781806946,
-0.5048578381538391,
-0.40655070543289185,
-0.20522436499595642,
-0.6071366667747498,
0.23181435465812683,
0.17342232167720795,
0.6891196966171265,
0.2875719368457794,
-0.5785595178604126,
0.02949695661664009,
-0.40695154666900635,
1.0167773962020874,
-0.4734556972980499,
0.461152046918869,
-0.058598678559064865,
0.34758123755455017,
-0.30899277329444885,
-0.6514832973480225,
-0.2730157673358917,
-0.6278910040855408,
0.1129995584487915,
0.19592539966106415,
-0.18201598525047302,
-0.01665886491537094,
0.4237210154533386,
0.2367914319038391,
-0.8035009503364563,
0.41279372572898865,
-0.4086188077926636,
-0.3407367467880249,
0.8418795466423035,
0.30886128544807434,
0.17466115951538086,
0.0015279805520549417,
-0.35696980357170105,
-0.4566843509674072,
-0.8261216878890991,
0.11610156297683716,
0.25071215629577637,
-0.017021670937538147,
0.2441464513540268,
0.3956320583820343,
-0.3242780268192291,
0.37871572375297546,
-0.3137163817882538,
0.07416890561580658,
0.2260393500328064,
-0.10948216170072556,
0.07223620265722275,
-0.08922018110752106,
0.8339009284973145,
0.49220144748687744,
0.1456565111875534,
-0.11839618533849716,
-0.11824900656938553,
0.25687742233276367,
-0.07481695711612701,
-0.992045521736145,
-0.16661910712718964,
0.11500807851552963,
-0.31626033782958984,
-0.0980086401104927,
-0.22715020179748535,
-0.7873590588569641,
-0.27545490860939026,
-0.31681764125823975,
0.44800323247909546,
-0.06044191122055054,
-0.0586809441447258,
0.04344236105680466,
-0.021658996120095253,
-0.03925619646906853,
0.7415336966514587,
-0.37602686882019043,
0.6429869532585144,
0.6810938119888306,
0.656875491142273,
-0.4970133304595947,
-0.5733447670936584,
-0.5654769539833069,
-0.22017741203308105,
-0.29927119612693787,
1.0245879888534546,
-0.445076048374176,
-0.35396522283554077,
-0.4967058300971985,
-0.034285664558410645,
-0.05098815634846687,
-0.5053626298904419,
0.5853480100631714,
-0.49628475308418274,
0.33635470271110535,
-0.12816180288791656,
-0.7604653835296631,
-0.14083202183246613,
0.2067059725522995,
-0.3869980573654175,
1.086102843284607,
-0.11550303548574448,
-0.44170528650283813,
0.305356502532959,
-0.8110922574996948,
-0.15017718076705933,
0.5252861380577087,
-0.1765505075454712,
0.05419670790433884,
-0.10909886658191681,
-0.1509244590997696,
0.38472363352775574,
-0.5234511494636536,
0.25572025775909424,
-0.4113289713859558,
-0.6495258212089539,
0.27187326550483704,
-0.21300284564495087,
0.6222770810127258,
0.23244088888168335,
-0.31726861000061035,
0.19384266436100006,
-0.7854982614517212,
0.502010703086853,
0.046987734735012054,
-0.22222435474395752,
-0.5523586273193359,
0.3145914375782013,
0.08505230396986008,
0.24579304456710815,
0.27460235357284546,
-0.865320086479187,
0.3999231159687042,
-0.3785526752471924,
0.37828758358955383,
0.7064235806465149,
-0.21218560636043549,
0.10667379200458527,
0.0059534409083426,
0.4997639060020447,
-0.303610235452652,
0.11121118813753128,
0.20653030276298523,
-0.5572746396064758,
-0.6913152933120728,
-0.16239745914936066,
0.3839353919029236,
0.6130738258361816,
-0.24376115202903748,
0.18806736171245575,
-0.18783065676689148,
-0.8130254149436951,
-0.6041408181190491,
0.29597777128219604,
0.4730338454246521,
0.31470751762390137,
0.49032461643218994,
-0.3766513764858246,
-0.22828499972820282,
-0.8801880478858948,
-0.42261219024658203,
-0.15387946367263794,
-0.306194543838501,
0.24222427606582642,
0.7697009444236755,
-0.056013304740190506,
0.7304871678352356,
-0.5714783668518066,
-0.07522772997617722,
0.052411265671253204,
0.3828381597995758,
0.23073454201221466,
0.3632347583770752,
0.23404698073863983,
-0.647110641002655,
-0.3687165379524231,
-0.10099968314170837,
-0.6260246634483337,
-0.4246775209903717,
0.22642312943935394,
0.22876597940921783,
0.38230136036872864,
0.5815958976745605,
-0.301042377948761,
0.015705382451415062,
0.41840147972106934,
-0.6049927473068237,
0.7085055708885193,
-0.43549126386642456,
0.3494425117969513,
-0.8443059921264648,
0.20945574343204498,
0.2552754282951355,
-0.1093427762389183,
-0.38800951838493347,
0.34991663694381714,
0.31395596265792847,
-0.15281358361244202,
-0.5489791035652161,
0.8903115391731262,
-0.37849846482276917,
-0.1727389693260193,
-0.2730656564235687,
0.11571011692285538,
0.04657933488488197,
0.22169408202171326,
0.22932168841362,
0.593171238899231,
0.559146523475647,
-0.2665920555591583,
0.3171749413013458,
-0.09890047460794449,
-0.5584052801132202,
0.5239531993865967,
-0.8491539359092712,
0.11423666030168533,
0.09850171208381653,
0.17256858944892883,
-0.821314811706543,
0.01132820826023817,
-0.3870416283607483,
-0.1943785846233368,
0.0593755766749382,
0.03658634051680565,
-0.6185539364814758,
-0.5514613389968872,
-0.22554150223731995,
0.35994458198547363,
0.43084344267845154,
-0.3851691484451294,
0.45454928278923035,
-0.1170947402715683,
-0.3163979649543762,
-0.5630428791046143,
-0.18334761261940002,
0.21348388493061066,
-0.055084336549043655,
-0.6941527724266052,
0.4468040466308594,
-0.5028382539749146,
-0.556389331817627,
-0.07316074520349503,
-0.06899353861808777,
0.013418427668511868,
0.42639416456222534,
0.27769801020622253,
0.4340113401412964,
-0.22429174184799194,
-0.19166390597820282,
0.09765411168336868,
-0.14661088585853577,
0.39904385805130005,
0.1404028981924057,
0.3471847474575043,
-0.43994876742362976,
-0.4330947697162628,
-0.2420860081911087,
0.5860083699226379,
0.8053011298179626,
-0.19763615727424622,
0.09470762312412262,
0.3171810209751129,
-0.3378349840641022,
-0.14774517714977264,
-0.8346686959266663,
-0.3941172957420349,
-0.48595672845840454,
0.5891086459159851,
-0.508957028388977,
-0.8817978501319885,
0.44141095876693726,
-0.14659039676189423,
0.10785038024187088,
0.5236467123031616,
0.5109763741493225,
-0.1313590258359909,
1.392011046409607,
0.5097803473472595,
-0.0631493628025055,
-0.12750068306922913,
0.03981603682041168,
0.053134653717279434,
-0.5754278302192688,
-0.3603357970714569,
-0.9453803300857544,
-0.12473592907190323,
-0.5326119661331177,
-0.350635290145874,
0.44539085030555725,
0.27995604276657104,
-0.26724594831466675,
0.37184709310531616,
-0.49485257267951965,
0.7791105508804321,
0.6099058389663696,
-0.27013373374938965,
0.556543231010437,
-0.12081574648618698,
-0.31610360741615295,
-0.13559813797473907,
-0.43197718262672424,
-0.6398672461509705,
1.0667757987976074,
0.31975406408309937,
0.8377535939216614,
-0.20657438039779663,
0.4536677598953247,
0.21100662648677826,
0.5756837129592896,
-0.5556964874267578,
0.8836743235588074,
-0.19227372109889984,
-0.42426401376724243,
-0.0714225172996521,
-0.684371292591095,
-0.7327226400375366,
0.38760432600975037,
-0.22643856704235077,
-0.7378910183906555,
-0.09292906522750854,
-0.1867927759885788,
-0.024168066680431366,
0.1600215584039688,
-0.686580240726471,
0.8744491934776306,
-0.603732705116272,
-0.6335555911064148,
-0.5319705605506897,
-0.5366853475570679,
0.13374166190624237,
-0.15195691585540771,
0.23150493204593658,
-0.2174782156944275,
-0.011886565014719963,
1.1538206338882446,
-0.0727415680885315,
0.6195991039276123,
-0.10753672569990158,
0.14297442138195038,
-0.11257223039865494,
0.39468154311180115,
0.1925758570432663,
0.08283250778913498,
-0.32080721855163574,
0.30237603187561035,
0.5487225651741028,
-0.3439875543117523,
-0.4885227084159851,
0.9178056120872498,
-1.0338478088378906,
-0.7178636789321899,
-0.7433691024780273,
-0.6239994168281555,
-0.17010298371315002,
0.336704820394516,
-0.055313847959041595,
0.20935845375061035,
-0.20269419252872467,
-0.01890113763511181,
0.5230087637901306,
-0.16079922020435333,
0.2529999315738678,
1.0889819860458374,
-0.04787823185324669,
-0.2914906144142151,
0.9579304456710815,
-0.07567822933197021,
0.12994016706943512,
0.40450605750083923,
0.41550174355506897,
-0.5371435284614563,
-0.6304119825363159,
-0.5019533634185791,
0.3455679416656494,
-0.889289379119873,
-0.14663144946098328,
-0.74176424741745,
0.0005413935869000852,
-0.5624447464942932,
-0.2273746281862259,
-0.27240949869155884,
-0.4101920425891876,
-0.15200872719287872,
0.2573990225791931,
0.22582480311393738,
0.798828125,
0.07402271777391434,
-0.23444750905036926,
-0.5888755917549133,
-0.12482989579439163,
0.20945052802562714,
0.41788798570632935,
-0.25576409697532654,
-0.4358506500720978,
0.07887108623981476,
-0.21811573207378387,
-0.4100165367126465,
-0.4707760810852051,
0.2463090866804123,
0.1489296555519104,
0.7227197289466858,
0.3381507396697998,
-0.13518832623958588,
0.48403191566467285,
-0.3850060999393463,
0.7737599015235901,
0.07193238288164139,
-1.0770343542099,
0.36258989572525024,
-0.07315841317176819,
0.04670814052224159,
0.6467100977897644,
0.6848856806755066,
-0.6575272083282471,
-0.5518953800201416,
-0.3380773961544037,
-0.6655163764953613,
0.4716559052467346,
-0.2477581948041916,
-0.17913353443145752,
0.1313709169626236,
0.2975395619869232,
0.12481402605772018,
0.09026796370744705,
-0.7600322961807251,
-0.09358252584934235,
-0.052529316395521164,
-0.09829892218112946,
-0.3570577800273895,
-0.08660275489091873,
-0.06037219241261482,
-0.4467913806438446,
0.640005350112915,
-0.2393551468849182,
0.09230183064937592,
0.0431169718503952,
-0.1451508104801178,
-0.059923965483903885,
0.5080703496932983,
0.7607812881469727,
0.6305157542228699,
-0.5212157964706421,
0.14269354939460754,
0.4155455529689789,
-0.4872415363788605,
0.21395060420036316,
0.21471314132213593,
-0.08176050335168839,
-0.22715094685554504,
0.30861279368400574,
0.2389160543680191,
0.1570521593093872,
-1.0072765350341797,
0.5528605580329895,
-0.1259334683418274,
-0.4781953692436218,
-0.21586297452449799,
0.2743206322193146,
0.0005595528054982424,
0.051288388669490814,
0.6143386960029602,
-0.007627764251083136,
0.09872984141111374,
-0.41710907220840454,
0.06896492838859558,
0.40401437878608704,
-0.10761209577322006,
-0.22453908622264862,
0.8068369626998901,
0.24110844731330872,
-0.308993399143219,
0.5729892253875732,
-0.21353580057621002,
-0.7509304881095886,
0.7038769721984863,
0.639954149723053,
0.5455971956253052,
-0.39771604537963867,
-0.04100045934319496,
0.44395408034324646,
0.2557697296142578,
-0.11823703348636627,
0.47970446944236755,
-0.06975959986448288,
-0.3163626790046692,
-0.6934585571289062,
-0.7737054824829102,
-1.1238183975219727,
-0.019752535969018936,
-0.5049222707748413,
0.4661265015602112,
-0.3383259177207947,
0.2507155239582062,
-0.07340138405561447,
0.5740708708763123,
-0.5415872931480408,
0.33233413100242615,
0.03900860622525215,
1.3333467245101929,
-1.0097596645355225,
0.685116171836853,
0.9864346981048584,
0.020741356536746025,
-0.5862622261047363,
-0.7674952745437622,
-0.11523247510194778,
-0.44061774015426636,
0.8957443237304688,
0.2719702124595642,
-0.07931853085756302,
-0.10852102935314178,
-0.32108452916145325,
-0.9417669773101807,
1.0193984508514404,
0.2624165117740631,
-0.7142270803451538,
-0.006259934511035681,
0.21740224957466125,
0.8614258766174316,
-0.15761834383010864,
0.9905535578727722,
0.23879241943359375,
0.6358293890953064,
-0.09198063611984253,
-0.8543632626533508,
0.14945563673973083,
-0.78055739402771,
-0.36705735325813293,
0.15214496850967407,
-0.6758056282997131,
0.8659228086471558,
-0.06264563649892807,
-0.026191143319010735,
0.12028157711029053,
0.6084012389183044,
0.257803350687027,
0.48762550950050354,
0.5890752673149109,
0.5242041349411011,
0.7660960555076599,
-0.24528835713863373,
0.8806626796722412,
-0.4509858191013336,
0.23874840140342712,
0.7771134972572327,
-0.8315092325210571,
1.0040912628173828,
0.4863279461860657,
-0.2869512140750885,
0.5945630073547363,
0.7075847387313843,
-0.5451518297195435,
0.08545038104057312,
0.7353707551956177,
-0.2139449119567871,
-0.5614792108535767,
-0.1702355295419693,
-0.37956199049949646,
0.5145738124847412,
0.21090251207351685,
0.031640950590372086,
-0.3471086621284485,
0.12828361988067627,
-0.0846463069319725,
0.20319418609142303,
-0.4412623643875122,
0.4049767851829529,
-0.047883015125989914,
-0.8060285449028015,
0.3286541998386383,
0.3028562366962433,
0.7662906646728516,
-0.6598919630050659,
0.030807914212346077,
-0.35465243458747864,
0.3096218407154083,
-0.21011769771575928,
-0.7024260759353638,
0.01694796420633793,
0.19792181253433228,
-0.0205190721899271,
-0.3791181445121765,
0.48990219831466675,
-0.321312814950943,
-0.7141698598861694,
0.3666679561138153,
0.3456921875476837,
0.7020495533943176,
0.007692926563322544,
-0.6255716681480408,
-0.008813075721263885,
-0.3416621685028076,
-0.23264843225479126,
0.5141446590423584,
-0.2149890810251236,
-0.3569580316543579,
0.9077642560005188,
0.5981974601745605,
0.30581292510032654,
-0.1195632666349411,
0.1260853260755539,
0.5909358263015747,
-0.5762733817100525,
-0.3299294412136078,
-0.6166658401489258,
-0.03352496400475502,
-0.15619264543056488,
-0.3262035548686981,
0.9111343622207642,
0.8934435844421387,
0.9707671403884888,
0.11465228348970413,
0.44614142179489136,
0.19371581077575684,
0.564699649810791,
-0.16517791152000427,
0.8446158170700073,
-0.7928348779678345,
0.07421733438968658,
-0.40492913126945496,
-0.9094365835189819,
-0.39873233437538147,
0.375376433134079,
-0.2582883834838867,
-0.07541153579950333,
0.9221412539482117,
0.7730814814567566,
0.13919802010059357,
0.17004817724227905,
0.2874271869659424,
0.08353590965270996,
0.396538108587265,
0.8326061367988586,
0.8575363159179688,
-0.246664896607399,
0.4827224910259247,
-0.492350310087204,
-0.42248404026031494,
-0.11584257334470749,
-0.9831264615058899,
-0.9967804551124573,
-0.4608529508113861,
-0.6387571096420288,
-0.2400948703289032,
-0.11501584947109222,
1.1157399415969849,
0.5102139711380005,
-0.8784731030464172,
-0.5055997371673584,
0.22013092041015625,
0.04686085507273674,
-0.3604830801486969,
-0.2535568177700043,
0.6715132594108582,
0.004264483693987131,
-0.8895494937896729,
0.8364738821983337,
0.21001698076725006,
0.07780368626117706,
-0.4457893967628479,
0.07692395150661469,
0.10010476410388947,
-0.09619946777820587,
0.5964187383651733,
0.11917721480131149,
-0.5134864449501038,
-0.2305949479341507,
0.41766250133514404,
-0.16346955299377441,
-0.1243176981806755,
0.7839503288269043,
-0.763397753238678,
0.17625485360622406,
0.5314536094665527,
0.4557150900363922,
0.3905256986618042,
-0.28845012187957764,
0.31371256709098816,
-0.22680100798606873,
-0.24467919766902924,
0.4983168840408325,
0.4315621554851532,
0.22454912960529327,
-0.1782776117324829,
0.42325958609580994,
0.3768194913864136,
-0.7483342289924622,
-1.0995173454284668,
-0.24224720895290375,
-1.0194638967514038,
-0.3830741047859192,
0.9509981870651245,
-0.16436374187469482,
-0.30422165989875793,
-0.07297419011592865,
0.16433998942375183,
-0.0837339535355568,
-0.2019585520029068,
0.860291600227356,
0.7350432276725769,
-0.05962636321783066,
0.12096023559570312,
-0.36164554953575134,
0.1853424608707428,
0.9997170567512512,
-0.903514564037323,
0.006952766794711351,
0.3063400685787201,
0.7055092453956604,
0.18685078620910645,
0.36360955238342285,
-0.12610304355621338,
0.4910297393798828,
-0.31304553151130676,
0.5188665390014648,
-0.29850900173187256,
-0.39340683817863464,
-0.3612251281738281,
0.3527248799800873,
0.050820134580135345,
0.39176127314567566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10402v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10402v1
|
Determination of the Number of Topics Intrinsically: Is It Possible?
| 2024-06-14T20:07:46 | 2024-06-14T20:07:46 |
Victor Bulatov, Vasiliy Alekseev, Konstantin Vorontsov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, math.PR
|
The number of topics might be the most important parameter of a topic model.
The topic modelling community has developed a set of various procedures to
estimate the number of topics in a dataset, but there has not yet been a
sufficiently complete comparison of existing practices. This study attempts to
partially fill this gap by investigating the performance of various methods
applied to several topic models on a number of publicly available corpora.
Further analysis demonstrates that intrinsic methods are far from being
reliable and accurate tools. The number of topics is shown to be a method- and
a model-dependent quantity, as opposed to being an absolute property of a
particular corpus. We conclude that other methods for dealing with this problem
should be developed and suggest some promising directions for further research.
|
[
-0.8489730954170227,
-0.9590268731117249,
0.891279935836792,
0.40974703431129456,
-0.22715705633163452,
0.14344722032546997,
-0.22982189059257507,
-0.3259417712688446,
0.2403385192155838,
0.16689832508563995,
-0.29359251260757446,
-0.2709439694881439,
-0.750836968421936,
0.36928316950798035,
-1.1111876964569092,
0.6044340133666992,
0.16441258788108826,
0.13367833197116852,
-0.5782482624053955,
-0.0266293752938509,
-0.5279417634010315,
-0.5090048909187317,
-0.00010554044274613261,
0.05352360010147095,
0.5791819095611572,
0.3759726881980896,
0.2038855105638504,
0.4604673683643341,
0.9019586443901062,
0.24983346462249756,
-0.5868933796882629,
-0.15083256363868713,
-0.3946775197982788,
-0.020663343369960785,
-0.30520763993263245,
-0.6371193528175354,
-0.007708445657044649,
0.20955213904380798,
0.878753662109375,
1.0227810144424438,
0.16280990839004517,
0.20361663401126862,
-0.29864758253097534,
0.7134434580802917,
-0.5199838876724243,
-0.4173870384693146,
-0.5353854894638062,
-0.1535477191209793,
-0.4105992615222931,
-0.08483476936817169,
-0.3530444800853729,
-0.14661958813667297,
0.5831725001335144,
-0.18444834649562836,
0.3871152102947235,
-0.15062735974788666,
0.6907777190208435,
0.03981645405292511,
-0.1988913118839264,
-0.5940538048744202,
-0.640205442905426,
0.9861801266670227,
-0.5520548224449158,
0.1104121282696724,
0.7879615426063538,
-0.15202054381370544,
0.24700391292572021,
-0.6068915724754333,
-0.2317192703485489,
-0.40832895040512085,
-0.0062191118486225605,
-0.11915095895528793,
-0.28991350531578064,
-0.5533729791641235,
0.4369685649871826,
0.4386371076107025,
-0.5233836770057678,
-0.07404738664627075,
-0.7804374694824219,
0.030440473929047585,
0.3562523424625397,
0.16605232656002045,
0.3423404097557068,
-0.39298421144485474,
-0.09775198996067047,
0.32256391644477844,
-0.8184455037117004,
-0.26642096042633057,
0.48310843110084534,
0.01832033321261406,
-0.06672537326812744,
0.6904970407485962,
-0.30027464032173157,
0.7584962248802185,
0.31093132495880127,
-0.12739954888820648,
-0.24320101737976074,
-0.46564868092536926,
0.36160194873809814,
0.0804346576333046,
0.22900278866291046,
-0.1219695657491684,
-0.1793949455022812,
-0.33384209871292114,
-0.023043567314743996,
0.3387503921985626,
0.5094691514968872,
-0.6996046304702759,
0.12379878014326096,
0.7201324701309204,
-0.25654593110084534,
-0.20040388405323029,
0.31379857659339905,
-0.5117851495742798,
0.03203696385025978,
-0.48178935050964355,
0.15712285041809082,
-0.3674190640449524,
-0.3534431457519531,
-0.19777461886405945,
-0.22877717018127441,
-0.0909218043088913,
0.41171541810035706,
-0.8395838141441345,
0.44329047203063965,
1.1579316854476929,
1.3602635860443115,
-0.4956868588924408,
-0.23478689789772034,
-0.08361463248729706,
-0.1060761883854866,
-0.7025806307792664,
1.1777623891830444,
-0.9101437926292419,
-0.6064800024032593,
-0.3572280704975128,
-0.017251964658498764,
0.2543337047100067,
-0.4543340504169464,
0.28131282329559326,
-0.6108643412590027,
0.19554519653320312,
-0.6374403834342957,
-1.0440576076507568,
0.09636885672807693,
0.03407330438494682,
-0.7729217410087585,
0.9081031680107117,
0.008212510496377945,
-0.990888237953186,
0.3454078137874603,
-0.6200622916221619,
-0.2306138277053833,
-0.1518627107143402,
-0.24455437064170837,
-0.04246623441576958,
0.4632883369922638,
-0.2868879735469818,
0.35545071959495544,
-0.5141960978507996,
0.8066087961196899,
-0.40685608983039856,
-0.42424365878105164,
0.5901081562042236,
-0.47068098187446594,
0.6855596303939819,
0.4533851444721222,
-0.20729318261146545,
-0.0014520627446472645,
-0.7028401494026184,
-0.5107455849647522,
-0.344087153673172,
0.03730058670043945,
-0.4671436548233032,
0.12776023149490356,
-0.29337942600250244,
0.14760510623455048,
0.4432464838027954,
-0.5142307877540588,
0.07799100875854492,
-0.15460841357707977,
0.6495067477226257,
0.565997302532196,
0.21786051988601685,
0.5622240900993347,
-0.5182326436042786,
0.34872040152549744,
-0.06086660176515579,
-0.30698302388191223,
-0.1708521991968155,
-0.8841379284858704,
-0.6072480082511902,
-0.28558149933815,
0.9588192701339722,
0.2022487372159958,
-0.020385077223181725,
0.4327453374862671,
0.04935549944639206,
-0.9946791529655457,
-0.25817421078681946,
-0.2935207486152649,
0.29374533891677856,
0.35048627853393555,
0.013389511033892632,
-0.3272826075553894,
-0.11566561460494995,
-0.8530628085136414,
0.13121525943279266,
-0.23766601085662842,
0.1607259213924408,
0.08411607891321182,
0.9931676983833313,
0.23826274275779724,
1.2930227518081665,
-0.6837208867073059,
0.3211311995983124,
0.2055066078901291,
0.8196506500244141,
0.36556392908096313,
0.45114168524742126,
0.6726871728897095,
-1.0021240711212158,
-0.4203232228755951,
-0.22116687893867493,
-0.7569460272789001,
-0.16003157198429108,
0.10025010257959366,
-0.3386484384536743,
0.11362955719232559,
0.2251540869474411,
-0.43009868264198303,
0.4191022515296936,
0.38789841532707214,
-0.09783370792865753,
0.5734044909477234,
-0.19092808663845062,
-0.030158119276165962,
-0.6181097030639648,
0.22483240067958832,
0.3086202144622803,
0.01610192097723484,
-0.65673828125,
0.2638978958129883,
0.1728452891111374,
-0.5238825678825378,
-0.6042429208755493,
0.6939978003501892,
-0.4618440270423889,
-0.2572459578514099,
-0.5496188402175903,
0.1366262584924698,
-0.028604716062545776,
0.2794186770915985,
0.3228832185268402,
0.8361524343490601,
1.0258551836013794,
-0.8565866947174072,
0.3415488600730896,
0.20693530142307281,
-0.32700061798095703,
0.5917178392410278,
-0.7641466856002808,
0.20186708867549896,
-0.14523135125637054,
0.07602369040250778,
-1.1374880075454712,
-0.27250415086746216,
0.04849698394536972,
-0.3208739161491394,
0.154251366853714,
-0.34391504526138306,
-0.19910484552383423,
-0.055715952068567276,
-0.2533709406852722,
-0.023470191285014153,
0.13840070366859436,
0.053220853209495544,
0.1672905683517456,
0.494712769985199,
-0.6639877557754517,
-0.3496820628643036,
-0.37148258090019226,
0.1294533610343933,
-0.5114781856536865,
-0.8078042268753052,
0.540409505367279,
-0.21456928551197052,
-0.6392873525619507,
0.3352281451225281,
-0.21752092242240906,
-0.1202818751335144,
0.28476011753082275,
0.14563807845115662,
0.10219831764698029,
0.06791756302118301,
0.27178001403808594,
0.023969197645783424,
-0.37774091958999634,
-0.0839758813381195,
-0.14155447483062744,
0.6154521107673645,
-0.21375849843025208,
-0.6322401762008667,
-0.1411079615354538,
0.8389420509338379,
0.4279036819934845,
-0.46023377776145935,
0.7849262356758118,
0.2462102472782135,
-0.6092914938926697,
0.17705893516540527,
-0.6383659839630127,
-0.1804935485124588,
-0.3913576006889343,
0.21693675220012665,
-0.25273293256759644,
-0.6325972080230713,
0.7298909425735474,
-0.06339604407548904,
-0.10381907224655151,
0.6192675828933716,
0.6611937880516052,
0.0867958515882492,
0.6852586269378662,
0.38317200541496277,
0.219484344124794,
0.3094961941242218,
-0.38743311166763306,
-0.04720568656921387,
-0.5407041907310486,
-0.05802423134446144,
-0.9463219046592712,
-0.12523511052131653,
-0.8020545840263367,
-0.28078052401542664,
0.40351390838623047,
0.11847691237926483,
0.009286795742809772,
0.42080506682395935,
-0.40004104375839233,
0.1125306785106659,
0.7952483296394348,
0.1312333196401596,
0.31558701395988464,
-0.00859126728028059,
0.30995434522628784,
-0.0629052147269249,
-0.30662015080451965,
-0.9810072183609009,
0.8709475994110107,
0.25273334980010986,
0.39079925417900085,
0.4300614893436432,
0.5233410596847534,
0.4488072693347931,
0.46033939719200134,
-0.5999080538749695,
0.5489362478256226,
-0.39195942878723145,
-1.1451077461242676,
-0.7278751730918884,
-0.359591543674469,
-0.6195719838142395,
-0.01638876646757126,
-0.019513150677084923,
-0.7573104500770569,
0.64488285779953,
-0.36015215516090393,
-0.22595088183879852,
-0.017776690423488617,
-0.42939019203186035,
0.6442309617996216,
-0.2865409255027771,
-0.5294514298439026,
-0.24602675437927246,
-0.5241069197654724,
0.11292106658220291,
-0.7622067332267761,
-0.07712401449680328,
-0.565795361995697,
-0.15240316092967987,
1.1600821018218994,
-0.37422651052474976,
0.7700809836387634,
0.03214491531252861,
-0.22618365287780762,
0.5927537083625793,
-0.2887679636478424,
0.23108230531215668,
0.29410502314567566,
-0.3605004847049713,
0.15565450489521027,
0.1954014152288437,
-0.598389208316803,
-0.5538438558578491,
0.5805187225341797,
-0.9211771488189697,
-0.8222529888153076,
-0.6136699914932251,
-0.10362660139799118,
-0.23582564294338226,
0.20272676646709442,
0.41638946533203125,
0.917631208896637,
-0.29402175545692444,
0.42196401953697205,
0.6376113295555115,
-0.2655452787876129,
0.6361889243125916,
0.7288339734077454,
-0.18578016757965088,
-0.07914116978645325,
1.2447516918182373,
0.6631240844726562,
0.1062731146812439,
0.679954469203949,
0.24980907142162323,
-0.19494399428367615,
-0.7543852925300598,
-0.1724015474319458,
0.289845734834671,
-0.43570634722709656,
0.07606387138366699,
-0.9231422543525696,
0.03948868066072464,
-0.2991899251937866,
-0.10558544844388962,
-0.47774258255958557,
-0.4277356266975403,
-0.6868199110031128,
-0.1105395257472992,
0.5918181538581848,
0.564978301525116,
-0.27599895000457764,
0.21780261397361755,
-0.6101326942443848,
0.6199355125427246,
0.41141819953918457,
0.3035060465335846,
-0.028141364455223083,
-0.6991153359413147,
0.10063166916370392,
-0.07660698890686035,
-0.23868457973003387,
-1.1552551984786987,
0.46452194452285767,
-0.13367383182048798,
0.5329719185829163,
0.5547894239425659,
0.32229501008987427,
0.5072427988052368,
-0.29284432530403137,
0.6146771311759949,
-0.11147042363882065,
-1.0537364482879639,
0.6878838539123535,
-0.48867058753967285,
-0.13214822113513947,
0.6234982013702393,
1.1149107217788696,
-0.5729529857635498,
-0.4038460850715637,
-0.9841712713241577,
-0.7872583866119385,
0.7001731991767883,
0.4625880718231201,
0.25103679299354553,
-0.2853820025920868,
0.17093174159526825,
0.3455878794193268,
0.22121155261993408,
0.0038522002287209034,
-0.2984794080257416,
-0.0031543802469968796,
0.4551960229873657,
0.395929217338562,
-0.47022682428359985,
-0.017254363745450974,
-0.11571771651506424,
0.6101667881011963,
0.06601119041442871,
0.6042315363883972,
0.10986783355474472,
0.04057757556438446,
0.06508231908082962,
0.2598249912261963,
0.9583540558815002,
1.688718318939209,
-0.6920170187950134,
0.06570284813642502,
-0.04217475652694702,
-0.32891473174095154,
0.19862288236618042,
-0.03257119655609131,
-0.28384190797805786,
0.3008647561073303,
0.17533530294895172,
0.6185441017150879,
0.017549987882375717,
-0.5597169995307922,
0.3607533574104309,
0.0508565679192543,
-0.09252460300922394,
-0.5638134479522705,
-0.2146543711423874,
0.3110719919204712,
-0.13799957931041718,
0.6516685485839844,
-0.06649603694677353,
0.127845898270607,
-0.8272606730461121,
0.5107876658439636,
-0.016111621633172035,
-0.7555502653121948,
-0.2593395411968231,
0.4021452069282532,
0.2931007146835327,
-0.37182316184043884,
0.6005486845970154,
-0.23583509027957916,
-0.16794158518314362,
0.9639821648597717,
0.27310630679130554,
0.4105076789855957,
0.2924104630947113,
0.5681161880493164,
0.2648618221282959,
-0.18197621405124664,
-0.42761051654815674,
0.06973078846931458,
0.31324031949043274,
-0.60773766040802,
-0.5721607804298401,
-0.46410974860191345,
-0.9067254662513733,
-0.03844873234629631,
-0.8565585613250732,
0.2887803614139557,
-0.01860516518354416,
-0.5300204157829285,
0.4970143735408783,
0.24899858236312866,
-0.0676511749625206,
0.11807405203580856,
-0.01743263378739357,
1.0171420574188232,
-0.7915268540382385,
0.3326164484024048,
0.7943371534347534,
-0.5264771580696106,
-0.20651064813137054,
-0.17263256013393402,
-0.14387638866901398,
-0.2349178045988083,
0.6576215028762817,
-0.3052137494087219,
0.20910455286502838,
-0.3112271726131439,
-0.7028284072875977,
-1.1488088369369507,
0.7165074944496155,
0.20621073246002197,
-0.4988611042499542,
0.028144119307398796,
-0.134654238820076,
0.5603711009025574,
-0.08172732591629028,
0.35437825322151184,
0.12571436166763306,
0.6787705421447754,
0.09119927138090134,
-0.6580913662910461,
-0.3231724500656128,
-0.37260931730270386,
-0.15129658579826355,
0.13595686852931976,
-0.7328695058822632,
0.8838052749633789,
0.1954355686903,
-0.057581521570682526,
0.18796846270561218,
0.8833862543106079,
0.5817813277244568,
0.4532545506954193,
0.08580595254898071,
0.0950767919421196,
0.935642659664154,
-0.10553979873657227,
1.0385552644729614,
-0.6927911639213562,
0.5803807973861694,
0.5020468235015869,
-0.4002114534378052,
0.6124261021614075,
0.1989961415529251,
-0.575057327747345,
-0.10397640615701675,
0.9939135909080505,
-0.06671282649040222,
0.5684047341346741,
0.36909815669059753,
-0.19797562062740326,
-0.19871768355369568,
-0.2528614103794098,
-0.572445273399353,
0.36822009086608887,
0.6583070158958435,
-0.17388008534908295,
0.006545023061335087,
-0.12228100001811981,
0.10959791392087936,
-0.16888019442558289,
-0.01950608380138874,
0.5617873668670654,
-0.07273606956005096,
-0.7526957988739014,
0.0837322250008583,
0.34318047761917114,
0.6326393485069275,
-0.5244845151901245,
-0.07287495583295822,
-0.4916342496871948,
-0.4053809940814972,
-0.05607135593891144,
-0.6598165035247803,
0.37250393629074097,
0.3352386951446533,
-0.32524681091308594,
-0.12309599667787552,
0.9112593531608582,
0.04059363901615143,
-0.8779119253158569,
-0.18935544788837433,
0.8236837387084961,
0.5308224558830261,
-0.25743111968040466,
-0.261748731136322,
-0.0664045661687851,
-0.2391040027141571,
-0.04424086585640907,
0.46452292799949646,
0.6238927245140076,
-0.23592732846736908,
0.53114914894104,
0.35417985916137695,
0.10722801834344864,
-0.04625912383198738,
-0.24446052312850952,
0.7119284868240356,
-0.7752519249916077,
-0.38981857895851135,
-0.763380765914917,
0.25404542684555054,
-0.12468916922807693,
-0.6581885814666748,
0.5998136401176453,
0.5136512517929077,
0.7255442142486572,
0.019011324271559715,
0.7891051769256592,
-0.24852891266345978,
0.7079666256904602,
-0.4601774215698242,
0.38166847825050354,
-0.4445597529411316,
0.6208218336105347,
-0.5911087989807129,
-1.0309864282608032,
0.047411806881427765,
0.6576013565063477,
-0.5041117072105408,
-0.040193911641836166,
0.7362015843391418,
0.6600639820098877,
0.019030127674341202,
0.395535945892334,
0.35513466596603394,
-0.1269729733467102,
0.054012034088373184,
-0.18474656343460083,
1.5025907754898071,
0.09249086678028107,
0.09783435612916946,
-0.7622681856155396,
-0.2065553069114685,
-0.16121786832809448,
-1.0164377689361572,
-0.487397164106369,
-0.7588399648666382,
-0.49898776412010193,
0.18256732821464539,
0.27542638778686523,
0.5084257125854492,
0.8722197413444519,
-0.8616620302200317,
-0.17108438909053802,
0.03569020703434944,
0.2657581567764282,
-0.016630008816719055,
-0.12388674169778824,
0.5936218500137329,
0.1202821433544159,
-0.6547234654426575,
0.14191658794879913,
0.16464877128601074,
-0.25147008895874023,
-0.5791197419166565,
0.447316974401474,
-0.3514121472835541,
-0.03034585900604725,
0.38992074131965637,
0.27524086833000183,
-0.5630654692649841,
-0.040617894381284714,
0.4505530893802643,
-0.0539364255964756,
0.034694772213697433,
1.127747654914856,
-0.38909438252449036,
-0.11386518180370331,
0.7868013978004456,
0.40782222151756287,
0.6544539332389832,
0.45045289397239685,
0.45126909017562866,
-0.5784482955932617,
-0.07653187215328217,
0.10525496304035187,
0.2217719852924347,
0.0763990730047226,
-0.18035203218460083,
0.786098062992096,
0.3310849070549011,
-0.44344204664230347,
-0.9204026460647583,
0.04972900077700615,
-1.1014562845230103,
-0.6985402703285217,
1.154631495475769,
0.007434457540512085,
-0.08698179572820663,
-0.37656745314598083,
-0.06513718515634537,
-0.08351994305849075,
-0.7045643925666809,
0.6176364421844482,
0.9574824571609497,
-0.45055341720581055,
0.06101945787668228,
-0.6058451533317566,
-0.23435667157173157,
0.22585123777389526,
-0.6959658861160278,
-0.06448417156934738,
0.37702250480651855,
0.02285919152200222,
0.8199148178100586,
0.6811395883560181,
-0.14920981228351593,
0.12235469371080399,
0.1326599419116974,
-0.43874111771583557,
0.39121267199516296,
-0.7718232274055481,
0.03672773391008377,
0.4623817503452301,
0.11220935732126236,
0.37447884678840637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10400v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10400v1
|
Self-Reflection Outcome is Sensitive to Prompt Construction
| 2024-06-14T20:07:11 | 2024-06-14T20:07:11 |
Fengyuan Liu, Nouar AlDahoul, Gregory Eady, Yasir Zaki, Bedoor AlShebli, Talal Rahwan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate impressive zero-shot and few-shot
reasoning capabilities. Some propose that such capabilities can be improved
through self-reflection, i.e., letting LLMs reflect on their own output to
identify and correct mistakes in the initial responses. However, despite some
evidence showing the benefits of self-reflection, recent studies offer mixed
results. Here, we aim to reconcile these conflicting findings by first
demonstrating that the outcome of self-reflection is sensitive to prompt
wording; e.g., LLMs are more likely to conclude that it has made a mistake when
explicitly prompted to find mistakes. Consequently, idiosyncrasies in
reflection prompts may lead LLMs to change correct responses unnecessarily. We
show that most prompts used in the self-reflection literature are prone to this
bias. We then propose different ways of constructing prompts that are
conservative in identifying mistakes and show that self-reflection using such
prompts results in higher accuracy. Our findings highlight the importance of
prompt engineering in self-reflection tasks. We release our code at
https://github.com/Michael98Liu/mixture-of-prompts.
|
[
-0.1317649632692337,
-0.677476704120636,
1.0747517347335815,
0.7186073660850525,
0.03363221511244774,
0.08388780057430267,
0.011785421520471573,
-0.14289923012256622,
0.34192267060279846,
0.43402060866355896,
-0.4885518550872803,
-0.13419181108474731,
-0.46821585297584534,
0.5704376697540283,
-0.24397043883800507,
0.8559698462486267,
-0.07525701075792313,
0.23852398991584778,
-0.02792353928089142,
-0.1031259298324585,
-0.9254538416862488,
-0.33321845531463623,
-0.1632579267024994,
-0.10557665675878525,
0.8768643736839294,
0.4290485084056854,
0.35829228162765503,
0.6771669387817383,
0.1762373298406601,
0.26441308856010437,
0.19765666127204895,
0.009971057064831257,
-0.20568735897541046,
0.4772067368030548,
-0.3677842617034912,
-0.3438047170639038,
-0.1167895570397377,
0.39130300283432007,
0.5281754732131958,
0.42144978046417236,
0.025247108191251755,
0.20053532719612122,
0.5328409075737,
0.4241185486316681,
-0.8002781867980957,
0.0630408376455307,
-0.3672471344470978,
0.05875472351908684,
-0.1778090000152588,
-0.4439886808395386,
-0.5882375836372375,
-0.07220365107059479,
-0.1922733634710312,
-0.19164401292800903,
0.2732432782649994,
0.1134895607829094,
0.3633478283882141,
0.4924847483634949,
-0.37905728816986084,
-0.5009225606918335,
-0.572529673576355,
0.8776105046272278,
-0.9691781997680664,
-0.0017215593252331018,
-0.1447860300540924,
0.25033122301101685,
-0.44976186752319336,
-0.3967573046684265,
-0.4283927381038666,
-0.28264468908309937,
-0.13562850654125214,
0.23600883781909943,
0.32960644364356995,
0.09607988595962524,
0.4512982666492462,
0.10524041950702667,
-0.4010487496852875,
0.45361584424972534,
-0.00997246615588665,
-0.32937631011009216,
0.6027281880378723,
0.46850815415382385,
0.2221488207578659,
-0.4418511688709259,
-0.5493794679641724,
0.025840364396572113,
-0.8743382096290588,
0.15624554455280304,
0.40561264753341675,
0.8359905481338501,
0.23943449556827545,
0.5661522746086121,
-0.18171082437038422,
0.7557386755943298,
0.2953455448150635,
-0.3403809368610382,
-0.11424010246992111,
-0.24859678745269775,
0.17202840745449066,
0.3336935341358185,
0.9443711042404175,
0.3295063078403473,
0.11682551354169846,
0.14321690797805786,
-0.2885418236255646,
0.050387755036354065,
0.2582419514656067,
-0.7114620804786682,
-0.06367136538028717,
0.18994130194187164,
-0.39936473965644836,
-0.2763596773147583,
-0.14359283447265625,
-0.6076588034629822,
-0.7317045331001282,
-0.2426578551530838,
0.3895462155342102,
0.013311369344592094,
0.035171251744031906,
0.21092663705348969,
-0.01183255948126316,
0.13994577527046204,
0.6558727622032166,
-0.6257491707801819,
-0.07188703864812851,
0.750239908695221,
0.8420180082321167,
-0.2552749216556549,
-0.5229877233505249,
-0.8153345584869385,
-0.1675977259874344,
-0.4963221848011017,
0.9561699628829956,
-0.4116297960281372,
-0.6236954927444458,
0.17568251490592957,
-0.2609753906726837,
0.1722859889268875,
-0.4192695617675781,
0.7028513550758362,
0.056386034935712814,
0.625906765460968,
-0.849511981010437,
-0.5629948377609253,
0.10345059633255005,
0.05873623490333557,
-0.3721678853034973,
0.8441788554191589,
-0.021349377930164337,
-0.730712890625,
0.32888516783714294,
-0.20444390177726746,
-0.2135930061340332,
0.2229754775762558,
-0.6705098748207092,
-0.04154748097062111,
0.3393723964691162,
0.027109328657388687,
0.5147749781608582,
-0.20376156270503998,
0.3762456178665161,
-0.386641263961792,
-0.4217687249183655,
0.37651166319847107,
-0.40642112493515015,
0.7841943502426147,
0.1457933634519577,
-0.6264619827270508,
-0.15976707637310028,
-0.5280035734176636,
-0.04737720265984535,
0.0681832879781723,
-0.29362350702285767,
-0.16096231341362,
-0.031358782202005386,
-0.4787251949310303,
0.5772781372070312,
0.20639614760875702,
-0.7964257597923279,
0.4191714823246002,
-0.1517922580242157,
-0.020935742184519768,
1.1402994394302368,
-0.007985458709299564,
0.34884247183799744,
-0.5021991729736328,
0.6283729076385498,
0.08243957906961441,
0.026586320251226425,
-0.4226610064506531,
-0.6336960792541504,
-0.47382116317749023,
-0.17080485820770264,
-0.031166013330221176,
0.4862516224384308,
-0.7027513980865479,
0.04957955330610275,
0.22262214124202728,
-0.3911398649215698,
-0.6928021311759949,
0.2996211647987366,
0.6584674715995789,
0.9326223731040955,
0.30249178409576416,
-0.09233387559652328,
-0.5086861252784729,
-0.8533319234848022,
-0.8314276337623596,
-0.30167871713638306,
0.2512856721878052,
0.3015114367008209,
0.20018711686134338,
0.2158302217721939,
1.1441227197647095,
-0.6084117889404297,
-0.34792330861091614,
-0.07259675115346909,
0.28587302565574646,
0.41774827241897583,
0.44870951771736145,
0.6807100176811218,
-0.14370156824588776,
-0.6170631647109985,
-0.7352905869483948,
-0.8679642081260681,
-0.5322484374046326,
-0.460811048746109,
0.015381055884063244,
0.18053007125854492,
0.22562135756015778,
-0.607012152671814,
0.0427984781563282,
0.3160778284072876,
-0.5381064414978027,
0.9317759275436401,
0.04950743541121483,
0.29987987875938416,
-0.7291609048843384,
-0.34277480840682983,
0.11124742776155472,
-0.06341920793056488,
-0.5133016109466553,
-0.08378883451223373,
0.027206066995859146,
0.3670128881931305,
-0.5734397172927856,
0.7504828572273254,
-0.5752896666526794,
0.13205702602863312,
-0.559981644153595,
0.17080844938755035,
0.10552889853715897,
0.24909277260303497,
-0.13129274547100067,
1.129203200340271,
0.3493957221508026,
-0.6090196371078491,
0.16347284615039825,
0.24990063905715942,
-0.22831551730632782,
0.4833211898803711,
-0.606825053691864,
0.2639724016189575,
-0.2275528907775879,
0.08947861939668655,
-1.1688547134399414,
-0.12612003087997437,
0.49956297874450684,
-0.35414600372314453,
0.3761647045612335,
0.18552765250205994,
-0.22680234909057617,
-0.45081618428230286,
-0.6676188111305237,
0.3110280930995941,
0.44303953647613525,
-0.8596345782279968,
0.5166758894920349,
-0.07036954909563065,
-0.20966273546218872,
-0.8751804828643799,
-0.7488898038864136,
0.0852685198187828,
-0.1588713526725769,
-0.4680718183517456,
-0.025702130049467087,
-0.37549328804016113,
-0.4462951421737671,
-0.2621873915195465,
-0.10468239337205887,
0.4620746374130249,
0.1703343391418457,
0.23014141619205475,
0.1875048577785492,
-0.22148039937019348,
0.15929362177848816,
-0.14299693703651428,
-0.04781924933195114,
0.4612325131893158,
0.11100243031978607,
0.3313167691230774,
-0.17241869866847992,
-0.4833533763885498,
-0.21834449470043182,
0.5123808979988098,
0.15067832171916962,
0.09430290013551712,
0.5356764197349548,
0.003087689634412527,
0.11181506514549255,
-0.3708787262439728,
-0.9459083676338196,
-0.4179157316684723,
-0.5696679353713989,
-0.20671343803405762,
-0.4342823326587677,
-0.9231184124946594,
0.6277537941932678,
0.12909375131130219,
0.1378583014011383,
0.4833390712738037,
0.39135974645614624,
-0.5100616812705994,
1.1069464683532715,
0.2872735559940338,
0.32334253191947937,
0.33284324407577515,
0.1877020001411438,
0.24932001531124115,
-0.9282848238945007,
0.036342553794384,
-0.6575479507446289,
-0.20164531469345093,
-0.7763562202453613,
-0.07769596576690674,
0.08217073231935501,
-0.2845799922943115,
-0.12225614488124847,
0.08187919855117798,
-0.8015335202217102,
0.3570603132247925,
0.6521942019462585,
-0.03095531091094017,
0.3976808786392212,
-0.41078048944473267,
0.06043154001235962,
-0.38707682490348816,
-0.7208247184753418,
-0.7001843452453613,
0.7747408151626587,
0.15006564557552338,
1.0081411600112915,
-0.11685596406459808,
1.113481044769287,
0.21380846202373505,
0.3161039650440216,
-0.6526443362236023,
0.6969257593154907,
0.3266788423061371,
-0.6915981769561768,
-0.21971847116947174,
-0.42011940479278564,
-0.837790846824646,
0.2423887401819229,
0.03415306657552719,
-0.43088650703430176,
0.3591555655002594,
0.338273286819458,
-0.5480175018310547,
0.0847739651799202,
-0.6707828044891357,
0.7166747450828552,
-0.3653007447719574,
-0.487080842256546,
0.3364430367946625,
-0.559116542339325,
0.39075344800949097,
-0.02028011903166771,
0.1717790812253952,
-0.1699766218662262,
0.0490078404545784,
0.5503557324409485,
-0.3052290380001068,
1.1809210777282715,
-0.32880163192749023,
-0.47644686698913574,
0.6260093450546265,
0.6072019934654236,
0.5637043714523315,
0.0066299643367528915,
0.08210588991641998,
-0.15621107816696167,
-0.17885732650756836,
-0.35385388135910034,
-0.8989137411117554,
0.7353977560997009,
-0.41818684339523315,
-1.3826924562454224,
-0.7534854412078857,
-0.32497403025627136,
-0.033278338611125946,
0.01982196792960167,
0.4067921042442322,
0.48589664697647095,
-0.048778701573610306,
-0.36997857689857483,
0.5587223172187805,
-0.19107000529766083,
0.8567668795585632,
0.7810506820678711,
-0.30753007531166077,
-0.10620985180139542,
0.6995639204978943,
0.5086150765419006,
0.2643548846244812,
-0.21338006854057312,
0.37341636419296265,
-0.25339823961257935,
-0.40322133898735046,
-0.41211074590682983,
0.4852536618709564,
-0.8345790505409241,
-0.4380042254924774,
-0.4830336570739746,
0.1016981303691864,
-0.5103403329849243,
-0.3057995140552521,
-0.42074668407440186,
-0.38901209831237793,
-0.4576334059238434,
-0.14973706007003784,
0.048412639647722244,
0.8840292096138,
-0.2594161033630371,
0.06845418363809586,
-0.7865471243858337,
-0.16140489280223846,
0.3308069109916687,
0.1466657668352127,
-0.04639206826686859,
-0.5931269526481628,
0.005049822852015495,
-0.011432128958404064,
-0.20631463825702667,
-1.0841232538223267,
0.1309446394443512,
-0.05294445902109146,
0.4913329482078552,
0.3011831045150757,
0.22205722332000732,
0.38690847158432007,
-0.6487757563591003,
1.0283468961715698,
0.210889995098114,
-0.8884118795394897,
0.7133110761642456,
-0.41206514835357666,
0.5058712363243103,
0.7086519002914429,
0.22294430434703827,
-0.5265807509422302,
-0.6621446013450623,
-0.5691295266151428,
-0.3821598291397095,
0.5458340048789978,
-0.3129773437976837,
0.35808804631233215,
-0.5171533823013306,
0.5372253060340881,
0.44299376010894775,
0.10621262341737747,
-0.7925035953521729,
-0.27194008231163025,
-0.19969801604747772,
-0.0835166871547699,
0.034606266766786575,
-0.773835301399231,
-0.16749116778373718,
0.1673211306333542,
0.5924064517021179,
-0.3880273997783661,
0.15011908113956451,
0.5959882736206055,
0.029611097648739815,
-0.1118999719619751,
0.3504123389720917,
0.6800525188446045,
0.4159504175186157,
0.017684610560536385,
0.3677436113357544,
0.1800609827041626,
-0.1816856563091278,
0.46595343947410583,
-0.3069879114627838,
-0.4066756069660187,
0.18651606142520905,
0.5785630941390991,
0.432242214679718,
0.06786840409040451,
-0.36142435669898987,
0.7767886519432068,
0.10930030047893524,
0.09052309393882751,
-0.11652525514364243,
0.1934826672077179,
-0.2065170556306839,
0.21225421130657196,
0.30006659030914307,
-0.05021580308675766,
0.599376380443573,
-0.6364072561264038,
-0.09848227351903915,
0.3843517601490021,
-0.1690404713153839,
-0.382414847612381,
0.5110762715339661,
0.16467858850955963,
-0.48893845081329346,
0.4403191804885864,
-0.4253769814968109,
-0.41176435351371765,
0.3002271354198456,
0.6255936622619629,
1.001957893371582,
-0.7319415211677551,
0.5051023364067078,
0.39697128534317017,
0.07547912746667862,
-0.2082013338804245,
0.6126648187637329,
-0.014435782097280025,
-0.5475945472717285,
-0.7554128170013428,
-0.36595138907432556,
-0.40254518389701843,
-0.43138587474823,
-0.4681096374988556,
0.20455554127693176,
-0.4729612469673157,
-0.20384378731250763,
-0.35820314288139343,
-0.21567592024803162,
-0.4370376467704773,
0.0599379688501358,
0.016479790210723877,
0.8091846108436584,
-0.845590353012085,
0.150059312582016,
0.5527384281158447,
-0.5521559119224548,
-0.9832409620285034,
-0.10672374814748764,
0.08963716775178909,
-0.6517732739448547,
0.8118737936019897,
0.286298543214798,
-0.435748428106308,
-0.29251915216445923,
-0.7450566291809082,
-0.7819826602935791,
0.741303563117981,
0.4922370910644531,
-0.5814197659492493,
-0.12277759611606598,
0.2620702087879181,
0.5506801009178162,
-0.3635305166244507,
0.3894577622413635,
0.049847327172756195,
0.29476815462112427,
0.03208101540803909,
-0.843134880065918,
0.5807231068611145,
0.20010431110858917,
0.061573367565870285,
0.02162753976881504,
-0.8655197620391846,
0.8419407606124878,
-0.4314797520637512,
-0.4893346428871155,
-0.085028275847435,
0.7661849856376648,
0.3026840388774872,
0.37776532769203186,
0.20161829888820648,
0.2789347469806671,
0.47934627532958984,
-0.15995526313781738,
1.0037710666656494,
-0.13594189286231995,
0.15488344430923462,
1.4955716133117676,
-0.47557976841926575,
0.4491055905818939,
0.6320998072624207,
0.0392807237803936,
0.6422014236450195,
0.3847027122974396,
0.09619008749723434,
0.5292080640792847,
0.04983754828572273,
-0.33379465341567993,
-0.41524821519851685,
-0.3352334201335907,
-0.36105766892433167,
0.4956591725349426,
0.01372534316033125,
-0.22399109601974487,
-0.32317695021629333,
-0.022247200831770897,
0.12560763955116272,
0.3471347987651825,
-0.0674886628985405,
0.6744940280914307,
0.36743757128715515,
-0.9294039607048035,
0.29713648557662964,
-0.37187284231185913,
0.6508086323738098,
-0.08699511736631393,
-0.1361646056175232,
-0.38389289379119873,
-0.13093210756778717,
-0.36379167437553406,
-1.2304502725601196,
0.17925535142421722,
-0.25156882405281067,
-0.03428926318883896,
-0.6527724266052246,
0.8317533135414124,
-0.14314576983451843,
-0.03272198885679245,
0.297116756439209,
0.8820750117301941,
-0.05152786895632744,
-0.09709329158067703,
-0.4766637682914734,
-0.05659833550453186,
-0.026940103620290756,
-0.4725675880908966,
0.21085405349731445,
0.5447884798049927,
0.2941136062145233,
0.5202468037605286,
0.36509767174720764,
-0.06848011910915375,
0.13412104547023773,
0.11199267208576202,
0.6810762882232666,
-0.8080425262451172,
-0.18909703195095062,
-1.162023901939392,
0.6463479399681091,
-0.023113979026675224,
-0.561471700668335,
1.15863037109375,
0.53310626745224,
0.4925362765789032,
-0.14428168535232544,
0.5404281616210938,
0.2977233827114105,
0.712276816368103,
-0.5548191070556641,
0.10931340605020523,
-0.3639332056045532,
0.33475443720817566,
-0.4165973961353302,
-0.9507510662078857,
-0.22494828701019287,
0.45387548208236694,
-0.42242327332496643,
0.14624357223510742,
0.6159060001373291,
0.78807532787323,
0.378246009349823,
0.008071674033999443,
0.295735627412796,
0.3183724582195282,
0.4412641227245331,
0.2202921062707901,
1.330782413482666,
-0.17382706701755524,
0.17645609378814697,
-0.1949251890182495,
-0.24826575815677643,
-0.16334788501262665,
-0.9731942415237427,
-0.9585617184638977,
-0.6910234093666077,
-0.55824214220047,
-0.5717048048973083,
-0.049279578030109406,
0.9667602181434631,
0.14527550339698792,
-0.6145265102386475,
-0.07805792987346649,
-0.06957770138978958,
0.08441273868083954,
0.0680842325091362,
-0.24472518265247345,
0.018545983359217644,
-0.7776561379432678,
-0.4029294550418854,
0.5412536263465881,
0.4859393537044525,
0.2335849553346634,
-0.41647112369537354,
-0.10806670784950256,
-0.026646273210644722,
0.3047962486743927,
0.3884076476097107,
0.34787043929100037,
-0.7667497992515564,
-0.7494736313819885,
0.32703617215156555,
-0.46068131923675537,
0.29571202397346497,
0.7550116181373596,
-0.8810959458351135,
0.4787645637989044,
0.5342584252357483,
0.4293437600135803,
0.13305893540382385,
-0.06539350748062134,
0.5384883284568787,
-0.5656769275665283,
-0.4189336597919464,
0.37008774280548096,
0.567844808101654,
0.5179096460342407,
-0.7582743167877197,
0.5441266894340515,
0.11971817165613174,
-0.8500059843063354,
-0.8682184815406799,
0.46209484338760376,
-0.676706075668335,
-0.2949920892715454,
1.1942321062088013,
-0.10456059128046036,
-0.2175348550081253,
0.2576678991317749,
-0.56961590051651,
0.0038079239893704653,
-0.35069596767425537,
1.1990866661071777,
1.0166995525360107,
-0.4119587242603302,
-0.15083378553390503,
-0.2112700492143631,
0.52458655834198,
0.8109046816825867,
-0.4969521462917328,
-0.015672290697693825,
0.6422736644744873,
0.2671872079372406,
0.41396114230155945,
0.7621235251426697,
0.2704315483570099,
0.2635984420776367,
-0.03339241072535515,
0.041737545281648636,
0.06848953664302826,
-0.44848525524139404,
-0.6223000884056091,
0.04193319380283356,
0.44399502873420715,
0.056591056287288666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10393v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10393v1
|
EWEK-QA: Enhanced Web and Efficient Knowledge Graph Retrieval for Citation-based Question Answering Systems
| 2024-06-14T19:40:38 | 2024-06-14T19:40:38 |
Mohammad Dehghan, Mohammad Ali Alomrani, Sunyam Bagga, David Alfonso-Hermelo, Khalil Bibi, Abbas Ghaddar, Yingxue Zhang, Xiaoguang Li, Jianye Hao, Qun Liu, Jimmy Lin, Boxing Chen, Prasanna Parthasarathi, Mahdi Biparva, Mehdi Rezagholizadeh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The emerging citation-based QA systems are gaining more attention especially
in generative AI search applications. The importance of extracted knowledge
provided to these systems is vital from both accuracy (completeness of
information) and efficiency (extracting the information in a timely manner). In
this regard, citation-based QA systems are suffering from two shortcomings.
First, they usually rely only on web as a source of extracted knowledge and
adding other external knowledge sources can hamper the efficiency of the
system. Second, web-retrieved contents are usually obtained by some simple
heuristics such as fixed length or breakpoints which might lead to splitting
information into pieces. To mitigate these issues, we propose our enhanced web
and efficient knowledge graph (KG) retrieval solution (EWEK-QA) to enrich the
content of the extracted knowledge fed to the system. This has been done
through designing an adaptive web retriever and incorporating KGs triples in an
efficient manner. We demonstrate the effectiveness of EWEK-QA over the
open-source state-of-the-art (SoTA) web-based and KG baseline models using a
comprehensive set of quantitative and human evaluation experiments. Our model
is able to: first, improve the web-retriever baseline in terms of extracting
more relevant passages (>20\%), the coverage of answer span (>25\%) and self
containment (>35\%); second, obtain and integrate KG triples into its pipeline
very efficiently (by avoiding any LLM calls) to outperform the web-only and
KG-only SoTA baselines significantly in 7 quantitative QA tasks and our human
evaluation.
|
[
-0.47881177067756653,
-0.7048722505569458,
0.5470451712608337,
0.22403301298618317,
-0.15330789983272552,
0.25984901189804077,
0.36851322650909424,
-0.6496254205703735,
0.3233879506587982,
0.00927739031612873,
-0.1556270867586136,
-0.2519107758998871,
-0.39920109510421753,
0.3387546241283417,
-0.009472229517996311,
0.5605161190032959,
0.003760821186006069,
0.04257645085453987,
-0.47795289754867554,
-0.2500748634338379,
-0.2949991822242737,
-0.17713990807533264,
-0.5304610729217529,
-0.4342862069606781,
0.6421290636062622,
0.3580111265182495,
0.7834447622299194,
0.4456491470336914,
0.48244813084602356,
0.20671828091144562,
-0.13301724195480347,
0.24548101425170898,
-0.513279914855957,
0.22950014472007751,
-0.1367371380329132,
-0.25310903787612915,
-0.3799540400505066,
-0.1793326586484909,
0.3464113771915436,
0.5852751135826111,
-0.15974508225917816,
0.2683144211769104,
0.08142570406198502,
0.9411497116088867,
-1.0867359638214111,
0.25144535303115845,
-0.32085466384887695,
-0.161479651927948,
0.10547684878110886,
-0.22799599170684814,
-0.2611357271671295,
-0.814301609992981,
0.2895524203777313,
-1.0658690929412842,
-0.3426862359046936,
-0.004969839937984943,
0.9751850366592407,
0.15148140490055084,
-0.5776199698448181,
-0.3935685157775879,
-0.34233996272087097,
0.4927425980567932,
-0.41070491075515747,
0.782237708568573,
0.44877395033836365,
0.6171139478683472,
-0.12542568147182465,
-0.8862123489379883,
-0.5096381902694702,
-0.10252570360898972,
0.051513269543647766,
0.46785110235214233,
-0.35873767733573914,
-0.15727709233760834,
0.09276443719863892,
0.13180939853191376,
-0.457607239484787,
-0.015679750591516495,
-0.3583393394947052,
-0.45573705434799194,
0.45355892181396484,
-0.023815954104065895,
0.40902215242385864,
-0.3258518576622009,
-0.2411472201347351,
-0.2819526195526123,
-0.6990752816200256,
0.11902586370706558,
0.24472185969352722,
0.08948024362325668,
0.38407233357429504,
0.5183749794960022,
-0.6793121099472046,
0.7524129748344421,
-0.0071646287105977535,
-0.10778352618217468,
0.2273566871881485,
-0.21471711993217468,
0.03466906026005745,
-0.3365301787853241,
0.6191843748092651,
0.25984805822372437,
0.044181860983371735,
-0.4158814251422882,
0.20011766254901886,
-0.3006535768508911,
0.15283983945846558,
-0.8980026245117188,
-0.45139381289482117,
0.24794988334178925,
-0.40626060962677,
-0.12350772321224213,
0.03195933625102043,
-0.8311623930931091,
-0.27433231472969055,
-0.11632755398750305,
0.6893442869186401,
-0.5424214601516724,
-0.2853122055530548,
-0.27855658531188965,
-0.5577083230018616,
0.3147452175617218,
0.3411281108856201,
-0.3618830442428589,
0.0023033299949020147,
0.3156173527240753,
0.59234219789505,
-0.028578195720911026,
-0.0297611802816391,
-0.6401768922805786,
0.35743585228919983,
-0.17989596724510193,
0.7831211090087891,
-0.5362959504127502,
-0.22964982688426971,
-0.054836440831422806,
-0.3468908369541168,
0.09451128542423248,
-0.6313797831535339,
0.425411581993103,
-1.373390555381775,
-0.040213312953710556,
-0.47852224111557007,
-0.5728045105934143,
-0.21615341305732727,
0.45768073201179504,
-0.7930293083190918,
1.089769959449768,
0.23715350031852722,
-0.630632221698761,
0.18618544936180115,
-0.7514752149581909,
-0.3943120539188385,
0.14695952832698822,
0.15680357813835144,
-0.28979915380477905,
-0.2182217538356781,
0.53716641664505,
0.17769399285316467,
-0.40253713726997375,
-0.11419645696878433,
-0.5620346069335938,
-0.2909621000289917,
0.05148962885141373,
0.05919734388589859,
0.9030135273933411,
0.5149772763252258,
0.08425039052963257,
-0.1818869560956955,
-0.8445598483085632,
0.700949490070343,
0.22645673155784607,
-0.6453485488891602,
-0.5662503242492676,
-0.28975436091423035,
-0.24918633699417114,
0.14315949380397797,
0.2360704243183136,
-0.6787804961204529,
0.022766264155507088,
-0.14190444350242615,
0.21274025738239288,
0.6472316980361938,
0.023759713396430016,
0.27595606446266174,
-0.15505924820899963,
0.6254369616508484,
-0.21244753897190094,
0.17964032292366028,
0.31764984130859375,
-0.5360148549079895,
-0.5656189322471619,
-0.37807992100715637,
0.6283054947853088,
0.5475366115570068,
-1.148207187652588,
0.2985285520553589,
-0.48293372988700867,
-0.5127737522125244,
-0.5802812576293945,
0.13890980184078217,
0.3744804859161377,
0.4597215950489044,
0.45151668787002563,
-0.09318558126688004,
-0.4747030735015869,
-0.7114356756210327,
-0.44400107860565186,
-0.2755807042121887,
-0.3002479672431946,
0.33141595125198364,
0.32205715775489807,
-0.04519149661064148,
1.2616868019104004,
-0.873257577419281,
0.058140628039836884,
0.02593059279024601,
0.06902854889631271,
-0.13943664729595184,
0.13302522897720337,
0.23535920679569244,
-1.073203444480896,
-0.9453685283660889,
-0.13120415806770325,
-0.9227575659751892,
-0.36407387256622314,
0.5262748599052429,
-0.45487913489341736,
-0.4021252691745758,
0.2636075019836426,
-0.4859718680381775,
0.3864516019821167,
0.06706707924604416,
-0.36751788854599,
0.6166165471076965,
0.058484625071287155,
0.21317295730113983,
-1.041745662689209,
0.3440561294555664,
-0.31093090772628784,
-0.3818452060222626,
-0.5082650184631348,
0.5618029236793518,
0.4049341380596161,
-0.18058274686336517,
-0.10409010946750641,
0.3117641806602478,
-0.4587533473968506,
-0.19877636432647705,
-0.345125287771225,
0.42704707384109497,
0.32930973172187805,
0.39833298325538635,
-0.39632079005241394,
0.7250630259513855,
0.03860252723097801,
-0.7392866611480713,
0.3885570466518402,
0.43216854333877563,
0.0030697339680045843,
0.760220468044281,
-0.4647822976112366,
0.5806692242622375,
-0.09084475785493851,
0.20908969640731812,
-0.7064539790153503,
-0.016457129269838333,
0.2427016794681549,
-0.537623941898346,
0.1399889588356018,
-0.08852162957191467,
-0.49761539697647095,
-0.5730865001678467,
-0.4230199158191681,
0.31115496158599854,
0.36005517840385437,
-0.8020976185798645,
0.625639021396637,
0.3146701455116272,
-0.36242496967315674,
-0.6810147762298584,
-0.08060202747583389,
0.004857948515564203,
0.13458803296089172,
-0.7086617946624756,
0.34858372807502747,
-0.1565985530614853,
-0.06478338688611984,
0.2657409608364105,
-0.1472385823726654,
-0.3451790511608124,
0.267305850982666,
-0.11957062035799026,
0.13424481451511383,
-0.08316298574209213,
0.24818138778209686,
0.07906696200370789,
-0.1079699769616127,
-0.2582370340824127,
-0.3787909150123596,
0.427458256483078,
-0.06409268081188202,
-0.3107738196849823,
-0.6113552451133728,
0.3912227749824524,
0.5472789406776428,
-0.21936236321926117,
0.776017963886261,
0.5563006401062012,
-0.25793376564979553,
0.35540473461151123,
-0.6505905985832214,
-0.04832092672586441,
-0.44415584206581116,
0.3707425594329834,
-0.6233747005462646,
-0.8245775103569031,
0.5418157577514648,
-0.3369063138961792,
-0.16800221800804138,
0.5284293293952942,
0.15138399600982666,
-0.46813905239105225,
1.0765066146850586,
0.43184375762939453,
-0.048209428787231445,
0.3907293379306793,
-0.17814500629901886,
0.13604700565338135,
-1.0739535093307495,
-0.22184306383132935,
-0.6718119978904724,
-0.09930363297462463,
-0.3229500949382782,
-0.09218159317970276,
0.655082643032074,
0.799350380897522,
-0.28587883710861206,
0.04744679108262062,
-0.33027273416519165,
0.36652660369873047,
0.6310526132583618,
0.3348138928413391,
0.42347201704978943,
0.04381889849901199,
-0.4079875349998474,
0.31807026267051697,
-0.8305684328079224,
-0.23525919020175934,
1.3742496967315674,
-0.004673398565500975,
0.36956706643104553,
0.5357565879821777,
0.5158367156982422,
0.3741559684276581,
0.4551357626914978,
-0.5266785621643066,
0.3676241934299469,
0.33611446619033813,
-0.5654070377349854,
-0.5208942294120789,
-0.6623539924621582,
-0.8641575574874878,
0.4774326682090759,
-0.004059103783220053,
-0.5392652750015259,
0.24132367968559265,
0.0032123709097504616,
-0.41522157192230225,
0.10816163569688797,
-0.77277010679245,
0.4793274700641632,
0.23401378095149994,
-0.4503711760044098,
-0.21349532902240753,
-0.6092432141304016,
-0.01924998313188553,
-0.05360855907201767,
0.12954068183898926,
0.06682823598384857,
0.08362828195095062,
0.8014683723449707,
-0.6442513465881348,
0.4034881889820099,
-0.4285926818847656,
0.1277288943529129,
0.49327510595321655,
-0.11819058656692505,
0.913528561592102,
-0.18699291348457336,
-0.1780618578195572,
-0.18888580799102783,
0.2998502552509308,
-0.8203262090682983,
-0.8834220170974731,
0.3251468539237976,
-1.005086898803711,
-0.5769597887992859,
-0.0548127144575119,
-0.4681825041770935,
-0.44932034611701965,
0.3365764319896698,
0.032801054418087006,
0.3140365481376648,
-0.06174023076891899,
0.2476322054862976,
0.28102439641952515,
-0.19415463507175446,
0.17065487802028656,
0.7474997043609619,
-0.2430778592824936,
-0.7054557204246521,
0.9745470285415649,
0.15557312965393066,
0.36107900738716125,
0.4133469760417938,
0.3437010943889618,
-0.5701482892036438,
-0.6126338839530945,
-0.6461418867111206,
-0.05805538594722748,
-0.9007343649864197,
-0.5383025407791138,
-0.7613662481307983,
-0.08761952072381973,
-0.6774982810020447,
0.12738461792469025,
0.009818841703236103,
-0.5805716514587402,
-0.13121148943901062,
-0.15655693411827087,
0.36113080382347107,
0.5311049222946167,
-0.2002381980419159,
0.13768324255943298,
-1.0669512748718262,
0.5010455846786499,
0.7119662165641785,
0.3052978813648224,
0.34144899249076843,
-0.20273232460021973,
-0.27909836173057556,
0.08301548659801483,
-0.5380322933197021,
-1.078224778175354,
0.14543484151363373,
0.18084660172462463,
0.6019058227539062,
0.3275569677352905,
0.2609710991382599,
0.9203358292579651,
-0.12452782690525055,
0.5200172066688538,
0.1762431561946869,
-0.6404942274093628,
0.4062574803829193,
-0.2682916224002838,
0.3596629202365875,
0.7487516403198242,
0.4568221867084503,
-0.3786541521549225,
-0.152777761220932,
-0.23155789077281952,
-0.7498865127563477,
0.5138980150222778,
0.4937017261981964,
-0.30334708094596863,
0.031772468239068985,
0.5673747658729553,
0.1489001363515854,
0.028181249275803566,
-0.48059791326522827,
-0.1613532453775406,
-0.31862038373947144,
-0.343158483505249,
0.4451766312122345,
-0.4807758033275604,
-0.05780589580535889,
-0.27080246806144714,
0.9863771200180054,
-0.36403951048851013,
0.3012569546699524,
0.36435621976852417,
-0.5968073010444641,
0.008551309816539288,
0.3591153919696808,
0.016526294872164726,
0.8991068601608276,
-0.31881922483444214,
0.03453685715794563,
0.21657304465770721,
-0.6271166801452637,
0.20766685903072357,
0.33566218614578247,
-0.43636199831962585,
-0.44227176904678345,
0.19399017095565796,
0.2617816627025604,
-0.0699148178100586,
-0.5497545599937439,
0.3313828110694885,
0.11467999964952469,
0.18340237438678741,
-0.10833781957626343,
-0.3081587255001068,
0.31870001554489136,
0.432888388633728,
0.8726591467857361,
-0.2778065502643585,
0.25670528411865234,
-0.35876399278640747,
0.18775959312915802,
0.30610978603363037,
-0.3334483504295349,
-0.18184828758239746,
0.34929847717285156,
0.3867318034172058,
-0.2007763832807541,
0.8556183576583862,
-0.48374101519584656,
-0.7158381342887878,
0.6104368567466736,
0.6213164925575256,
0.6271752119064331,
-0.11541296541690826,
0.27458369731903076,
0.2759389579296112,
-0.035390980541706085,
0.27633529901504517,
0.4981269836425781,
-0.15806815028190613,
-0.9185376167297363,
-0.28181880712509155,
-0.7408610582351685,
-0.2314123660326004,
-0.23176133632659912,
-0.836500883102417,
-0.249799445271492,
-0.07101963460445404,
-0.11226007342338562,
-0.13136279582977295,
0.1619136482477188,
-0.6723417639732361,
0.027141932398080826,
-0.2805139124393463,
0.8373847007751465,
-0.4664539098739624,
0.5811631083488464,
0.6500281095504761,
-0.6315458416938782,
-0.8578053712844849,
0.021623287349939346,
-0.264507919549942,
-0.7765355110168457,
0.7839274406433105,
-0.08229249715805054,
-0.07266473770141602,
0.4269697070121765,
-0.23805396258831024,
-1.1257025003433228,
1.4984532594680786,
0.3180159628391266,
-0.1782132089138031,
0.050153810530900955,
0.050457581877708435,
0.40248438715934753,
0.013098156079649925,
0.516926646232605,
0.34977850317955017,
0.5962532162666321,
0.25792038440704346,
-0.8781338334083557,
0.2167552411556244,
-0.30949509143829346,
-0.16111548244953156,
0.1892952024936676,
-0.8354893326759338,
0.2704300880432129,
-0.1571608930826187,
-0.34857437014579773,
0.14936137199401855,
0.7600145936012268,
0.34693029522895813,
0.3397696316242218,
0.5558066964149475,
0.7836980819702148,
1.064335823059082,
0.19304077327251434,
1.101792812347412,
-0.19319334626197815,
0.27256712317466736,
0.7939673066139221,
-0.20309172570705414,
0.9666084051132202,
0.4309609532356262,
-0.554889440536499,
0.6264908313751221,
0.5749292373657227,
0.37339380383491516,
0.6342633962631226,
0.004593146499246359,
-0.16536739468574524,
-0.3707787096500397,
-0.19134651124477386,
-0.3747328519821167,
0.3292614221572876,
0.07962559908628464,
-0.11330974847078323,
-0.29147350788116455,
-0.02965169958770275,
-0.14432714879512787,
-0.13907305896282196,
-0.27408042550086975,
0.831556499004364,
0.0077031501568853855,
-0.5879679918289185,
0.5007617473602295,
-0.12082876265048981,
0.3407396376132965,
-0.5196859836578369,
-0.14205987751483917,
-0.0746871829032898,
-0.16875208914279938,
-0.15206120908260345,
-0.3062865138053894,
0.06411432474851608,
-0.10275954008102417,
-0.2783663272857666,
0.019369157031178474,
0.993382453918457,
-0.041569214314222336,
-0.3413529098033905,
0.3396499454975128,
0.8046034574508667,
0.15514276921749115,
-0.33924001455307007,
-0.548632025718689,
-0.3025282025337219,
0.03569096699357033,
-0.17178456485271454,
0.3453351557254791,
0.11678311973810196,
0.043288394808769226,
0.8325697779655457,
0.8480124473571777,
-0.11808203160762787,
0.2932666838169098,
0.06363390386104584,
0.9304254651069641,
-0.5829859972000122,
-0.6865206360816956,
-0.470297247171402,
0.16768616437911987,
-0.4052976071834564,
0.17283520102500916,
0.628305196762085,
0.7206183671951294,
0.4273773729801178,
0.21133525669574738,
0.8281658291816711,
-0.25882136821746826,
0.4824638366699219,
-0.39830467104911804,
0.8121672868728638,
-0.5160216689109802,
0.06973027437925339,
-0.13098374009132385,
-0.9190677404403687,
-0.028843659907579422,
0.18715402483940125,
-0.13466687500476837,
0.05938737466931343,
0.6491804718971252,
0.6530172228813171,
0.08656302839517593,
0.3328886330127716,
0.2644604444503784,
0.174839049577713,
0.4277145564556122,
0.48445233702659607,
0.9442939758300781,
-0.5339316129684448,
1.0598151683807373,
-0.08910476416349411,
-0.23800665140151978,
-0.3604257106781006,
-0.559310257434845,
-0.31078019738197327,
-0.3980594873428345,
-0.23246356844902039,
-0.3275172710418701,
0.22880132496356964,
0.6240483522415161,
0.5931136608123779,
-0.764309823513031,
0.27341964840888977,
0.10641656816005707,
0.2620037794113159,
-0.3978159427642822,
-0.2677076458930969,
0.8042106628417969,
-0.26202237606048584,
-0.4263775944709778,
0.48299676179885864,
0.14252613484859467,
-0.17621763050556183,
0.0020838803611695766,
-0.14869222044944763,
-0.3900267779827118,
-0.11774112284183502,
0.7145956158638,
0.39276623725891113,
-0.3897276222705841,
-0.6314489245414734,
0.1205512061715126,
-0.06121133640408516,
0.14603884518146515,
0.48222774267196655,
-0.9636164307594299,
0.6898276209831238,
0.7433916330337524,
0.843965470790863,
0.6421554088592529,
0.13821212947368622,
0.7155908942222595,
-0.5329787135124207,
-0.43619504570961,
0.2351442128419876,
0.0920834094285965,
0.2702079117298126,
-0.4463268220424652,
0.6771599054336548,
0.3336913287639618,
-0.36449316143989563,
-0.5616897344589233,
0.20428265631198883,
-0.639998197555542,
-0.348870187997818,
1.0013436079025269,
-0.4227871894836426,
-0.04129486903548241,
-0.5253857970237732,
0.10345402359962463,
0.49791544675827026,
-0.30704066157341003,
0.8819563388824463,
0.6818652153015137,
-0.33268705010414124,
0.11948716640472412,
-0.4272977113723755,
0.17509055137634277,
0.3517239987850189,
-0.8383195996284485,
-0.2929809093475342,
0.4442029893398285,
0.5028884410858154,
0.3549376130104065,
0.674582302570343,
-0.1750868260860443,
0.45041921734809875,
-0.025288768112659454,
0.042669571936130524,
-0.3455721139907837,
0.02053968235850334,
0.03756784275174141,
0.7720299363136292,
0.03555708006024361,
-0.22511939704418182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10382v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10382v2
|
Efficient Prompting for LLM-based Generative Internet of Things
| 2024-06-14T19:24:00 | 2024-06-18T01:26:33 |
Bin Xiao, Burak Kantarci, Jiawen Kang, Dusit Niyato, Mohsen Guizani
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capacities on
various tasks, and integrating the capacities of LLMs into the Internet of
Things (IoT) applications has drawn much research attention recently. Due to
security concerns, many institutions avoid accessing state-of-the-art
commercial LLM services, requiring the deployment and utilization of
open-source LLMs in a local network setting. However, open-source LLMs usually
have more limitations regarding their performance, such as their arithmetic
calculation and reasoning capacities, and practical systems of applying LLMs to
IoT have yet to be well-explored. Therefore, we propose a text-based generative
IoT (GIoT) system deployed in the local network setting in this study. To
alleviate the limitations of LLMs and provide service with competitive
performance, we apply prompt engineering methods to enhance the capacities of
the open-source LLMs, design a Prompt Management Module and a Post-processing
Module to manage the tailored prompts for different tasks and process the
results generated by the LLMs. To demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed
system, we discuss a challenging Table Question Answering (Table-QA) task as a
case study of the proposed system, as tabular data is usually more challenging
than plain text because of their complex structures, heterogeneous data types
and sometimes huge sizes. We conduct comprehensive experiments on two popular
Table-QA datasets, and the results show that our proposal can achieve
competitive performance compared with state-of-the-art LLMs, demonstrating that
the proposed LLM-based GIoT system can provide competitive performance with
tailored prompting methods and is easily extensible to new tasks without
training.
|
[
-0.25253725051879883,
-1.0669808387756348,
0.6634970307350159,
0.20716442167758942,
-0.44028475880622864,
-0.041012030094861984,
-0.1279822438955307,
-0.450162798166275,
0.26586878299713135,
0.24968312680721283,
-0.46132469177246094,
-0.6730085015296936,
-0.26440727710723877,
0.45404720306396484,
-0.5354382991790771,
0.7407623529434204,
0.018751543015241623,
-0.15520140528678894,
-0.2316092997789383,
0.20243848860263824,
-0.7405710220336914,
-0.025315111503005028,
-0.6948301792144775,
-0.12651397287845612,
0.42955639958381653,
0.6960516571998596,
0.3955048620700836,
0.32590004801750183,
0.5468884110450745,
0.3450169265270233,
-0.030833490192890167,
0.24029169976711273,
-0.14348727464675903,
0.4393118619918823,
0.15557613968849182,
-0.716059684753418,
-0.5620744228363037,
-0.2643849551677704,
0.3243255913257599,
0.15783017873764038,
-0.2361319214105606,
0.12920211255550385,
-0.005838843993842602,
0.723436713218689,
-0.10865234583616257,
0.2921304702758789,
-1.0562281608581543,
-0.025310706347227097,
-0.06212406978011131,
-0.48454853892326355,
-0.5068145394325256,
-0.44075489044189453,
0.28417742252349854,
-0.7722445130348206,
0.07930781692266464,
0.060551926493644714,
0.7393814325332642,
0.22462719678878784,
-0.07014920562505722,
-0.3981744050979614,
-0.6665676236152649,
0.34971562027931213,
-0.5488362908363342,
0.22743862867355347,
0.34950968623161316,
0.2649436891078949,
-0.2929382622241974,
-0.5883249044418335,
-0.7413145303726196,
-0.44252827763557434,
0.12285130470991135,
0.3899311125278473,
-0.2607758939266205,
-0.19953793287277222,
0.19789105653762817,
0.14731444418430328,
-0.874895453453064,
0.21851564943790436,
-0.02942795120179653,
0.33542177081108093,
0.28370049595832825,
0.20657309889793396,
0.22287617623806,
-0.40710341930389404,
-0.5200666785240173,
0.185719832777977,
-0.8636840581893921,
-0.02363399975001812,
0.17736773192882538,
0.42531946301460266,
-0.24281586706638336,
0.7082865238189697,
-0.7841192483901978,
0.6185540556907654,
0.0731472373008728,
-0.047116052359342575,
-0.08468499779701233,
-0.08001111447811127,
-0.018779834732413292,
-0.11717858910560608,
0.911363959312439,
0.42083540558815,
0.1276710033416748,
-0.2540656328201294,
-0.31880247592926025,
-0.12325684726238251,
0.17390598356723785,
-0.525170087814331,
-0.014027616940438747,
0.3833934962749481,
-0.14387691020965576,
-0.1388104408979416,
-0.18017487227916718,
-0.7774215936660767,
-0.27977171540260315,
-0.1271945983171463,
0.49676549434661865,
-0.3948393166065216,
0.07700228691101074,
0.03911697492003441,
-0.11319411545991898,
0.2945379912853241,
0.5415098667144775,
-0.8659917712211609,
-0.263692170381546,
0.5575713515281677,
1.1032828092575073,
-0.03848406299948692,
0.10596635937690735,
-0.4370376765727997,
0.21608848869800568,
-0.07527951896190643,
0.8909454345703125,
-0.13089199364185333,
-0.7090652585029602,
-0.030185000970959663,
-0.27502474188804626,
0.15963035821914673,
-0.5249488949775696,
0.6360600590705872,
-0.8987182378768921,
0.16223682463169098,
0.1565508246421814,
-0.3887162208557129,
0.15485359728336334,
0.4709379971027374,
-0.5770758390426636,
0.7164097428321838,
-0.05088057368993759,
-0.6464807987213135,
0.23993271589279175,
-0.993813693523407,
-0.5596210360527039,
0.6793763637542725,
-0.18585966527462006,
-0.44532451033592224,
-0.033188339322805405,
0.44707411527633667,
0.7294734716415405,
-0.5632322430610657,
0.22590942680835724,
-0.1609904170036316,
-0.12856997549533844,
0.2522732615470886,
-0.6293293833732605,
0.5472362041473389,
0.44623345136642456,
-0.2718510031700134,
0.34761568903923035,
-0.5532897114753723,
0.32952210307121277,
0.23411911725997925,
-0.47661539912223816,
-0.09782744199037552,
0.14225131273269653,
-0.31224122643470764,
-0.35626763105392456,
0.37784290313720703,
-0.5009186267852783,
0.4496358633041382,
-0.2848895788192749,
0.7844230532646179,
0.7895524501800537,
-0.20736075937747955,
0.29600444436073303,
-0.4719509780406952,
0.6603084802627563,
-0.2708558440208435,
0.22766932845115662,
-0.17884455621242523,
-0.7105459570884705,
-0.5943539142608643,
-0.5480484366416931,
0.2255503535270691,
0.9581531286239624,
-1.4063862562179565,
0.5261558294296265,
-0.8240766525268555,
-0.4489421546459198,
-0.2881224751472473,
0.1322011947631836,
-0.11682521551847458,
0.8348751664161682,
0.2289707064628601,
0.3681992292404175,
-0.16412854194641113,
-0.7098821401596069,
0.1673046201467514,
-0.22438350319862366,
-0.49205639958381653,
0.17433880269527435,
0.20955410599708557,
-0.12218301743268967,
1.2532504796981812,
-0.425624281167984,
-0.10038712620735168,
-0.2651541829109192,
0.27398985624313354,
0.4498361349105835,
0.2532995939254761,
0.12522770464420319,
-0.7308474183082581,
-0.5987064838409424,
0.2791941165924072,
-0.7945873141288757,
-0.26773136854171753,
0.05993017181754112,
-0.05246386304497719,
0.1940223127603531,
0.315216988325119,
-0.7970724701881409,
0.3421163856983185,
0.46024543046951294,
-0.09619634598493576,
0.460629940032959,
-0.039733171463012695,
0.05784420669078827,
-1.371618390083313,
0.04365876689553261,
-0.19431568682193756,
-0.32226020097732544,
-0.4662244915962219,
-0.03942842781543732,
0.07367711514234543,
-0.3972572088241577,
-0.48673516511917114,
0.672856867313385,
-0.2738572359085083,
0.34275856614112854,
-0.15931464731693268,
0.3863842785358429,
-0.04780469834804535,
0.3311210572719574,
-0.054873231798410416,
1.054805040359497,
0.4175313711166382,
-0.7127537131309509,
0.5724270939826965,
0.029512465000152588,
-0.22546039521694183,
0.9324657320976257,
-0.7997277975082397,
-0.04145735502243042,
-0.09556632488965988,
0.10044551640748978,
-0.8822392821311951,
-0.32819631695747375,
0.2844594717025757,
-0.44040489196777344,
-0.04520130529999733,
-0.18287082016468048,
-0.6802241802215576,
-0.5190405249595642,
-0.4506387710571289,
0.15797553956508636,
0.7854219675064087,
-0.7059759497642517,
0.7260245680809021,
-0.08725877106189728,
-0.5162067413330078,
-0.14288948476314545,
-0.5022125840187073,
0.20356407761573792,
-0.6292839646339417,
-0.8796169757843018,
0.2922799289226532,
-0.09071281552314758,
0.05749509483575821,
-0.041808661073446274,
0.14621208608150482,
0.1149921715259552,
0.306306391954422,
0.17991219460964203,
0.440909206867218,
-0.08886972069740295,
0.3735036849975586,
-0.0549776591360569,
-0.2863982021808624,
0.015872709453105927,
-0.4867788255214691,
0.5781040787696838,
-0.16163994371891022,
-0.3702075779438019,
-0.8894798755645752,
0.41419199109077454,
0.393942266702652,
-0.08204840868711472,
0.33171796798706055,
0.31991350650787354,
-0.11498823016881943,
-0.37988919019699097,
-0.39781829714775085,
-0.33469387888908386,
-0.5827475786209106,
0.12985971570014954,
-0.4072686433792114,
-1.0421162843704224,
0.6573120951652527,
-0.27826961874961853,
0.018128693103790283,
0.383747935295105,
0.4399464428424835,
-0.5531095862388611,
0.7617921233177185,
0.07363655418157578,
-0.11509868502616882,
0.7988317012786865,
-0.2618866264820099,
0.29771628975868225,
-0.8749728798866272,
-0.04858919605612755,
-0.687945544719696,
-0.20779713988304138,
-0.6427379846572876,
-0.3334992229938507,
0.9132709503173828,
0.4085189998149872,
-0.05827759578824043,
-0.008207765407860279,
-0.6378135681152344,
0.3321482837200165,
0.7687711119651794,
0.330976665019989,
0.5530992150306702,
0.3444164991378784,
0.14505410194396973,
0.5431320667266846,
-0.9376910924911499,
-0.7037643790245056,
1.069709300994873,
0.04615331068634987,
0.9725471138954163,
0.2953729033470154,
0.48272669315338135,
0.38521748781204224,
0.6033348441123962,
-0.7226089835166931,
0.7806112170219421,
-0.00715324142947793,
-0.22036732733249664,
-0.6434364914894104,
-0.6931650042533875,
-1.2864018678665161,
-0.22243480384349823,
0.010385199449956417,
-0.7654309868812561,
-0.25522011518478394,
0.17130006849765778,
-0.28418585658073425,
0.16730691492557526,
-0.9132893085479736,
0.3057035207748413,
-0.27135169506073,
-0.0626804530620575,
0.12028109282255173,
-0.2821941077709198,
0.2286418080329895,
0.23740701377391815,
-0.06877926737070084,
-0.092228963971138,
0.02990780957043171,
0.4307503402233124,
-0.6040833592414856,
0.8406267166137695,
-0.046564504504203796,
-0.1936948448419571,
0.5978095531463623,
-0.1774549037218094,
0.9544881582260132,
0.46457526087760925,
-0.17280788719654083,
0.022354012355208397,
-0.40091314911842346,
-0.2994522750377655,
-0.6807319521903992,
0.8422479033470154,
-0.529843270778656,
-0.6691001653671265,
-0.1212211400270462,
-0.25343015789985657,
-0.35931962728500366,
0.18762759864330292,
0.4261690378189087,
0.3437376916408539,
0.16196921467781067,
0.37911245226860046,
0.8394439816474915,
-0.0761619359254837,
0.6419151425361633,
0.4553073048591614,
-0.2666078507900238,
-0.541681170463562,
1.0172160863876343,
0.04283609241247177,
0.2693991959095001,
0.7552837133407593,
0.3838233947753906,
-0.40148428082466125,
-0.6438129544258118,
-0.9039273858070374,
-0.20722141861915588,
-0.47576525807380676,
-0.6326878070831299,
-0.526374101638794,
-0.016655104234814644,
-0.13145241141319275,
-0.4152435064315796,
0.13634361326694489,
-0.2205711305141449,
-0.48483559489250183,
0.03098713792860508,
0.9717279076576233,
0.3253910541534424,
0.42174336314201355,
0.450727641582489,
-0.8740442395210266,
0.44109898805618286,
0.7168537378311157,
0.5940651297569275,
0.10528609901666641,
-0.27157047390937805,
-0.07301676273345947,
-0.04340970516204834,
-0.1903965026140213,
-0.8430929780006409,
0.034666333347558975,
-0.13001838326454163,
0.34025007486343384,
0.2373855710029602,
0.33375293016433716,
0.35076287388801575,
-0.3444863259792328,
0.6993706822395325,
0.20592264831066132,
-0.854003369808197,
0.693373441696167,
-0.7915239930152893,
0.5792554616928101,
0.32897260785102844,
0.08216386288404465,
-0.39746367931365967,
-0.27613112330436707,
-0.32918938994407654,
-1.0010851621627808,
0.42980363965034485,
0.05847637355327606,
0.3162166476249695,
-0.2804018259048462,
0.39747393131256104,
-0.025540350005030632,
0.23400302231311798,
-0.8084880709648132,
-0.006337171420454979,
-0.0785592719912529,
-0.4139568507671356,
0.5526915192604065,
-0.026265613734722137,
-0.0647517740726471,
0.22036506235599518,
0.5829104781150818,
-0.3590075671672821,
0.5218267440795898,
0.32379886507987976,
0.05051755905151367,
0.3528379201889038,
0.5599955916404724,
0.6224095821380615,
0.2647235691547394,
0.1373891979455948,
-0.03411128371953964,
0.3241199254989624,
-0.34470459818840027,
0.20823344588279724,
0.14818786084651947,
-0.713426947593689,
-0.1278214156627655,
0.28108784556388855,
0.7058188915252686,
-0.3261878788471222,
-0.697842538356781,
0.167997345328331,
-0.16452664136886597,
0.06734739989042282,
-0.09133437275886536,
0.12951862812042236,
0.2923402488231659,
0.2267582267522812,
0.5047080516815186,
-0.5194780230522156,
0.05103806033730507,
-0.2865883708000183,
-0.27837488055229187,
0.666853129863739,
0.04594115912914276,
-0.06904065608978271,
0.5205035209655762,
0.6628703474998474,
-0.7112749218940735,
0.6640033721923828,
-0.4991008937358856,
-0.35624971985816956,
0.5402176380157471,
0.27707430720329285,
0.9826655983924866,
-0.06366939842700958,
0.43492698669433594,
-0.033830419182777405,
0.36012816429138184,
0.20631226897239685,
0.7767278552055359,
-0.1482374519109726,
-0.3954487144947052,
-0.3536057472229004,
-0.3988233804702759,
-0.2859170734882355,
0.14404582977294922,
-0.23920412361621857,
0.19249369204044342,
-0.43317994475364685,
-0.2603287100791931,
-0.4725201427936554,
-0.29475632309913635,
-0.6972213387489319,
0.11585242301225662,
-0.3204447031021118,
0.693905234336853,
-0.12590010464191437,
0.4795953035354614,
0.4790042042732239,
-0.1283247321844101,
-0.8794555068016052,
-0.13874536752700806,
-0.3419498801231384,
-0.7841907739639282,
0.6670280694961548,
-0.029605258256196976,
-0.2198600172996521,
0.08706747740507126,
-0.3861270248889923,
-0.5308691263198853,
1.2742347717285156,
0.21489650011062622,
-0.5733102560043335,
0.18930044770240784,
0.3279370963573456,
0.4263731837272644,
-0.025204813107848167,
0.3130614161491394,
-0.27404019236564636,
0.5411878228187561,
-0.04217569902539253,
-0.8047311902046204,
0.012941733933985233,
-0.14677661657333374,
0.020071985200047493,
0.20450067520141602,
-0.6253184676170349,
0.5320424437522888,
-0.009966871701180935,
-0.4067002236843109,
0.2959425151348114,
0.6362152099609375,
0.04179319366812706,
0.3237779438495636,
0.39710748195648193,
0.4591645300388336,
0.6790562272071838,
-0.19612130522727966,
0.8587892055511475,
-0.28336480259895325,
0.10436513274908066,
0.9896203875541687,
-0.39366504549980164,
1.0260306596755981,
0.39563438296318054,
-0.22214952111244202,
0.2053888887166977,
0.3813549280166626,
0.2624019384384155,
0.38504189252853394,
0.2827056050300598,
-0.7046757340431213,
0.1935376226902008,
-0.25675228238105774,
-0.34704717993736267,
0.2661780118942261,
0.33061525225639343,
0.11317310482263565,
-0.23603008687496185,
0.20622019469738007,
-0.16366514563560486,
-0.13874658942222595,
-0.2774905860424042,
0.9327008724212646,
-0.11656288802623749,
-0.4603126645088196,
0.3188073933124542,
0.006891776341944933,
0.8493722677230835,
-0.6938360333442688,
0.05044546350836754,
-0.30810025334358215,
-0.4211820363998413,
-0.024007780477404594,
-0.7448949813842773,
0.13145321607589722,
0.290874719619751,
-0.40903985500335693,
-0.3871893584728241,
0.4576738476753235,
-0.18393754959106445,
-0.3781096637248993,
-0.11306004226207733,
0.48002922534942627,
-0.10041317343711853,
-0.12375311553478241,
-0.33656615018844604,
-0.037136826664209366,
-0.08816635608673096,
-0.29235389828681946,
0.007515576668083668,
0.797436535358429,
-0.18045347929000854,
1.027779459953308,
0.8758134841918945,
0.008885488845407963,
0.10560278594493866,
-0.10108043998479843,
0.6889436841011047,
-0.5850055813789368,
-0.6803044676780701,
-0.6882267594337463,
0.6056289076805115,
-0.11420848220586777,
-0.33678802847862244,
0.5259827971458435,
0.2809871733188629,
0.70527583360672,
-0.17504025995731354,
0.7946832180023193,
-0.16168583929538727,
0.3782767057418823,
-0.8401299118995667,
0.5103592276573181,
-0.33886662125587463,
0.5251588225364685,
0.11116442829370499,
-0.6329649090766907,
-0.174232617020607,
0.32586967945098877,
-0.2911711633205414,
0.05141007527709007,
0.33723267912864685,
0.5987498164176941,
0.24984945356845856,
0.1756587028503418,
0.32139649987220764,
0.0195703636854887,
0.5571771860122681,
0.3514452874660492,
0.8329216241836548,
-0.11376463621854782,
0.5834011435508728,
0.16262215375900269,
-0.25657111406326294,
-0.5244176983833313,
-1.0544276237487793,
-0.6445261836051941,
-0.5439375638961792,
-0.06229287385940552,
0.11207816004753113,
0.10692210495471954,
0.754594087600708,
0.6202220320701599,
-0.3859405517578125,
-0.02407010830938816,
-0.31167879700660706,
0.3885466754436493,
0.07372048497200012,
-0.32494717836380005,
0.26501739025115967,
-0.15416349470615387,
-0.6414794325828552,
0.44839075207710266,
0.36906003952026367,
0.29900506138801575,
-0.18977278470993042,
0.10339885205030441,
-0.002268976764753461,
-0.15386728942394257,
0.810960054397583,
0.15957863628864288,
-0.7813712954521179,
-0.3224218189716339,
0.17685164511203766,
-0.1493111550807953,
0.07635879516601562,
0.5030532479286194,
-0.8052231073379517,
0.4549572765827179,
0.6776219010353088,
0.8541184067726135,
0.03182760998606682,
0.08393201231956482,
0.2910219430923462,
-0.6133266687393188,
-0.15758748352527618,
0.33761292695999146,
0.17163437604904175,
0.26336100697517395,
-0.5384964346885681,
0.40333127975463867,
-0.08831998705863953,
-0.5127955675125122,
-0.5942937135696411,
0.3297024369239807,
-1.01543128490448,
-0.023933323100209236,
0.8547526001930237,
-0.099765844643116,
-0.033483803272247314,
0.008853709325194359,
-0.15949802100658417,
-0.03197503089904785,
-0.7030399441719055,
1.0087336301803589,
0.607198178768158,
-0.2559431195259094,
-0.10798421502113342,
-0.5708934664726257,
0.09157956391572952,
0.507967472076416,
-1.3047232627868652,
0.007435867562890053,
0.24824176728725433,
0.0006824650336056948,
0.11954650282859802,
0.5172826051712036,
0.18309922516345978,
0.18700452148914337,
-0.3438664972782135,
-0.0192563533782959,
-0.08873753994703293,
-0.24550996720790863,
-0.22884726524353027,
0.2116260975599289,
0.1738106608390808,
-0.29392296075820923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10328v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10328v1
|
From Pixels to Prose: A Large Dataset of Dense Image Captions
| 2024-06-14T17:59:53 | 2024-06-14T17:59:53 |
Vasu Singla, Kaiyu Yue, Sukriti Paul, Reza Shirkavand, Mayuka Jayawardhana, Alireza Ganjdanesh, Heng Huang, Abhinav Bhatele, Gowthami Somepalli, Tom Goldstein
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Training large vision-language models requires extensive, high-quality
image-text pairs. Existing web-scraped datasets, however, are noisy and lack
detailed image descriptions. To bridge this gap, we introduce PixelProse, a
comprehensive dataset of over 16M (million) synthetically generated captions,
leveraging cutting-edge vision-language models for detailed and accurate
descriptions. To ensure data integrity, we rigorously analyze our dataset for
problematic content, including child sexual abuse material (CSAM), personally
identifiable information (PII), and toxicity. We also provide valuable metadata
such as watermark presence and aesthetic scores, aiding in further dataset
filtering. We hope PixelProse will be a valuable resource for future
vision-language research. PixelProse is available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/tomg-group-umd/pixelprose
|
[
-0.44358694553375244,
-0.4317087233066559,
0.3334234654903412,
0.2297244518995285,
-0.3308425545692444,
0.13358989357948303,
-0.1838703602552414,
-0.4098012447357178,
-0.09258612990379333,
0.6856495141983032,
-0.5331655740737915,
-0.43602070212364197,
-0.4080905616283417,
0.09615931659936905,
-0.7513872385025024,
1.1066597700119019,
0.11426150053739548,
0.35312652587890625,
-0.38357439637184143,
0.10211920738220215,
-0.0505317747592926,
-0.13260045647621155,
-0.45778122544288635,
0.27544814348220825,
0.7930282354354858,
0.3490085303783417,
0.654948353767395,
0.7639412879943848,
0.7455940842628479,
0.20246900618076324,
0.2663298547267914,
0.17753538489341736,
-0.49991077184677124,
-0.0959787368774414,
-0.3618631660938263,
-0.185519739985466,
-0.14077183604240417,
0.15072351694107056,
0.6018872261047363,
0.6440780162811279,
0.13807931542396545,
0.005785428453236818,
0.1138874813914299,
0.6849398016929626,
-0.7172867059707642,
0.16340744495391846,
-0.567704975605011,
0.13622544705867767,
-0.31880226731300354,
-0.1419866979122162,
-0.38371211290359497,
-0.15829847753047943,
0.15765272080898285,
-0.6315934658050537,
0.6038092970848083,
0.10138598084449768,
1.0053927898406982,
0.15168258547782898,
-0.10708726197481155,
0.21208374202251434,
-0.4331071972846985,
0.7370692491531372,
-0.3055529296398163,
0.07205218076705933,
0.29086804389953613,
0.43912726640701294,
-0.025770224630832672,
-1.057819128036499,
-0.6656420230865479,
-0.008116795681416988,
-0.050611596554517746,
0.15995816886425018,
-0.3395487666130066,
0.08482984453439713,
0.12564855813980103,
0.3687298595905304,
-0.6031349301338196,
-0.07460913062095642,
-0.48637744784355164,
-0.38537779450416565,
0.8846192955970764,
0.18083955347537994,
0.5496531128883362,
-0.20091892778873444,
-0.3961050510406494,
-0.26101744174957275,
-0.7926516532897949,
-0.1557023972272873,
0.5025097131729126,
0.030330175533890724,
-0.11506631225347519,
0.6515767574310303,
-0.04677042365074158,
0.7637685537338257,
-0.3893006443977356,
0.3251972198486328,
-0.07130412757396698,
-0.5800523161888123,
-0.008697775192558765,
-0.017150020226836205,
1.0009275674819946,
0.5222463607788086,
0.6290708780288696,
-0.31317827105522156,
-0.25385618209838867,
0.2492765188217163,
0.5161189436912537,
-0.889599621295929,
-0.742994487285614,
0.14465482532978058,
-0.3876308798789978,
-0.45672500133514404,
0.25863951444625854,
-1.3148075342178345,
-0.9014894962310791,
-0.43973270058631897,
0.18587331473827362,
-0.45803752541542053,
0.05088469013571739,
0.11139741539955139,
-0.49742600321769714,
0.12133117765188217,
0.24840575456619263,
-0.7540541291236877,
0.6033793687820435,
0.41799354553222656,
0.8186099529266357,
-0.5933694839477539,
-0.29470667243003845,
-0.5020997524261475,
-0.0394616425037384,
-0.5385252833366394,
0.9192215204238892,
-0.6427425146102905,
-0.012330216355621815,
0.1903187334537506,
0.04470554366707802,
-0.010598254390060902,
-0.6772732734680176,
0.4904443621635437,
-0.3313716948032379,
-0.0013819921296089888,
-0.16505801677703857,
-0.4744933247566223,
0.07774312794208527,
0.02850063145160675,
-0.7876840233802795,
0.670745849609375,
0.2434079498052597,
-0.7652286291122437,
0.3603680729866028,
-0.7655086517333984,
-0.37622135877609253,
0.38897910714149475,
-0.14144283533096313,
-0.34026771783828735,
0.07210124284029007,
0.45697131752967834,
0.6266937255859375,
-0.10609236359596252,
0.39528727531433105,
-0.05693411827087402,
-0.36847877502441406,
0.35074561834335327,
-0.6267173886299133,
0.5436131954193115,
0.2958887815475464,
-0.07743189483880997,
0.2770395576953888,
-0.7799481153488159,
-0.24233752489089966,
0.45298561453819275,
-0.0329403318464756,
0.0531131848692894,
0.3617230951786041,
0.6780515313148499,
-0.17198999226093292,
0.2998988628387451,
-0.8419496417045593,
-0.0632966086268425,
-0.1376187950372696,
0.7631008625030518,
0.6550060510635376,
-0.10175831615924835,
0.21609483659267426,
-0.2473691999912262,
0.6823247671127319,
0.11776256561279297,
0.2933603525161743,
-0.6454952359199524,
-0.3588534891605377,
-0.6963075995445251,
-0.2816135883331299,
0.1527257263660431,
0.3520902991294861,
-0.966006875038147,
0.24954767525196075,
-0.6168412566184998,
-0.4365966022014618,
-0.4024645686149597,
0.12044960260391235,
0.49775439500808716,
0.4269174635410309,
0.3593871295452118,
-0.2982597053050995,
-0.4280376732349396,
-1.2290626764297485,
-0.01326776947826147,
0.19871200621128082,
-0.06308230757713318,
0.4754912555217743,
0.5747137665748596,
0.04141572117805481,
1.167548656463623,
-0.6937410235404968,
-0.46764838695526123,
-0.2196286916732788,
-0.027729270979762077,
-0.10572996735572815,
0.38551169633865356,
0.6036790013313293,
-1.0517094135284424,
-0.48526814579963684,
-0.16763800382614136,
-0.4206687808036804,
-0.16773851215839386,
-0.1754690557718277,
0.1265779584646225,
0.17132042348384857,
0.406110942363739,
-0.5230019092559814,
0.32939857244491577,
0.7470763921737671,
-0.3586573898792267,
0.9764272570610046,
-0.04533204063773155,
0.18551772832870483,
-0.9802332520484924,
0.24703048169612885,
0.494488000869751,
-0.33146145939826965,
-0.14452889561653137,
0.15759766101837158,
0.025492660701274872,
-0.2831954061985016,
-0.6878702640533447,
0.44290047883987427,
-0.31181466579437256,
-0.17805863916873932,
-0.017422979697585106,
0.16284118592739105,
0.07165221124887466,
0.2486138790845871,
0.03365050256252289,
1.3346425294876099,
0.8043909668922424,
-0.14931881427764893,
0.8480175733566284,
0.4085254669189453,
-0.6851127743721008,
0.515332818031311,
-0.6474187970161438,
-0.18268831074237823,
-0.031707096844911575,
0.23071540892124176,
-1.1570720672607422,
-0.7076141238212585,
0.12445972114801407,
-0.4359467029571533,
0.1369219273328781,
-0.24451597034931183,
-0.8978585004806519,
-0.25517135858535767,
-0.34908148646354675,
0.425476998090744,
0.4031069874763489,
-0.6856626868247986,
0.1268560141324997,
0.4202072024345398,
-0.5585871338844299,
-0.3087526559829712,
-0.41522711515426636,
0.9846577644348145,
-0.08116256445646286,
-0.5925740599632263,
0.45200780034065247,
0.1699192076921463,
-0.006623842753469944,
0.0216168612241745,
0.37222355604171753,
-0.4262509047985077,
-0.2454221099615097,
0.07760603725910187,
0.3566415011882782,
0.03622797876596451,
0.187388613820076,
-0.08073984831571579,
0.044342540204524994,
0.15410137176513672,
-0.09834744781255722,
0.8909523487091064,
-0.17584635317325592,
-0.05146750435233116,
-0.4083101153373718,
0.36479923129081726,
0.6012681126594543,
-0.3181942105293274,
0.32049354910850525,
0.6130753755569458,
-0.2713892161846161,
-0.3633524179458618,
-0.2425016611814499,
-0.09173702448606491,
-0.4622729420661926,
0.6245501041412354,
-0.0944804698228836,
-0.5804506540298462,
0.3433731198310852,
0.16654205322265625,
-0.15506631135940552,
0.361397922039032,
-0.04133834317326546,
-0.5099831223487854,
1.1282998323440552,
0.39332565665245056,
-0.18331453204154968,
0.4194600284099579,
-0.26502636075019836,
0.1095183938741684,
-0.7013620734214783,
-0.3177075982093811,
-0.256277859210968,
-0.41002967953681946,
-0.2626572549343109,
-0.32801422476768494,
0.25743767619132996,
-0.2756480276584625,
-0.17200222611427307,
0.4477520287036896,
-0.5645882487297058,
0.760597288608551,
0.5049335360527039,
0.2818315029144287,
-0.014502630569040775,
0.4642881751060486,
0.24111340939998627,
-0.34106048941612244,
-0.6430822014808655,
-0.6539418697357178,
0.9600184559822083,
0.20138636231422424,
0.6922004222869873,
-0.0777091458439827,
0.07374978810548782,
0.6422837972640991,
-0.2562912404537201,
-0.8214526176452637,
0.9024710655212402,
-0.6567851305007935,
-0.3956761062145233,
0.02461979351937771,
-0.26162758469581604,
-1.1715574264526367,
-0.1258079707622528,
-0.2198520302772522,
-0.6306856870651245,
0.017496073618531227,
0.10165953636169434,
-0.16351310908794403,
0.30729371309280396,
-0.5254215002059937,
0.9387316107749939,
-0.20600807666778564,
-0.6799803972244263,
-0.3018683195114136,
-0.6519445180892944,
0.17119893431663513,
-0.018775438889861107,
0.11544311791658401,
0.17124028503894806,
-0.2396099716424942,
0.7309030294418335,
-0.281993567943573,
1.10258948802948,
-0.07564154267311096,
-0.1177995577454567,
0.22771863639354706,
0.16730517148971558,
0.02944958209991455,
-0.2521263659000397,
0.5103486776351929,
0.2582210302352905,
0.06419678777456284,
-0.5235099792480469,
-0.28802406787872314,
0.5948902368545532,
-0.5645062327384949,
-0.21743610501289368,
-0.3746073544025421,
-0.6960983872413635,
-0.2503008544445038,
0.14739280939102173,
0.345759779214859,
0.6391444802284241,
-0.05609038472175598,
0.28949740529060364,
0.6613695621490479,
-0.5210036635398865,
0.7578165531158447,
-0.0886162668466568,
-0.287786602973938,
-0.7156339883804321,
1.0921673774719238,
-0.09230651706457138,
0.20095530152320862,
-0.006806906312704086,
0.1490916907787323,
-0.2774922847747803,
-0.7763069272041321,
-0.6829414963722229,
0.06453638523817062,
-0.5231055617332458,
-0.2775982618331909,
-0.43082523345947266,
-0.42105624079704285,
-0.3329952657222748,
-0.3316613435745239,
-0.3325883448123932,
-0.14241459965705872,
-0.355498343706131,
0.06035355478525162,
0.3435136377811432,
0.6186442375183105,
0.2758732736110687,
0.5781179666519165,
-1.0141586065292358,
0.6021766066551208,
0.00684217968955636,
0.6580935120582581,
-0.2957412004470825,
-0.35680660605430603,
-0.058279428631067276,
0.1834084689617157,
-0.2798946797847748,
-0.7401068806648254,
0.6387230157852173,
0.5766887664794922,
0.19845585525035858,
0.7173146605491638,
-0.051265522837638855,
0.6637421250343323,
-0.5743193626403809,
1.22726309299469,
0.34922149777412415,
-0.7321359515190125,
0.6731449961662292,
-0.804038941860199,
-0.028696537017822266,
0.2990248501300812,
0.29914748668670654,
-0.40458279848098755,
-0.14799468219280243,
-0.5021589398384094,
-0.7531054019927979,
0.5368136763572693,
0.2336038053035736,
0.7218149304389954,
-0.0043571460992097855,
0.2865135073661804,
0.19218963384628296,
0.16159199178218842,
-0.7444943785667419,
0.12561661005020142,
-0.14074666798114777,
-0.5738233923912048,
-0.04080548882484436,
-0.2813785970211029,
-0.16794942319393158,
-0.41091349720954895,
0.42892611026763916,
-0.2940959632396698,
0.045292410999536514,
0.19773632287979126,
-0.18827784061431885,
0.06327124685049057,
-0.1025993600487709,
0.3146786689758301,
0.5335338115692139,
0.2158467173576355,
0.3102194368839264,
-0.4356532692909241,
-0.7283573150634766,
-0.2102385014295578,
-0.06165830045938492,
-0.18548913300037384,
-0.1742624044418335,
0.6188126802444458,
0.651273250579834,
-0.011793089099228382,
-1.3781987428665161,
0.9751611351966858,
0.2202923595905304,
-0.2786167860031128,
-0.40814805030822754,
0.21389608085155487,
-0.1084073930978775,
-0.21056298911571503,
0.3973287343978882,
0.2840022146701813,
0.31232401728630066,
-0.5295356512069702,
0.49753743410110474,
0.2019120156764984,
-0.686562180519104,
-0.22021448612213135,
0.5438621044158936,
0.1390269696712494,
0.01365362387150526,
0.7537436485290527,
-0.028871767222881317,
-0.48250526189804077,
0.8236885070800781,
0.3532588481903076,
0.4958372414112091,
0.22154022753238678,
0.6876582503318787,
0.33864375948905945,
0.03758084401488304,
0.0035869248677045107,
0.19830869138240814,
0.06115477532148361,
-0.7966393232345581,
-0.44596660137176514,
-0.7314202189445496,
-0.17110826075077057,
0.07220866531133652,
-0.475269615650177,
0.24974985420703888,
-0.655927300453186,
0.079103022813797,
0.16062897443771362,
-0.2361956238746643,
-0.2688486576080322,
0.4340290129184723,
0.32132941484451294,
0.8351792693138123,
-1.0086510181427002,
0.43747344613075256,
0.759531557559967,
-0.652619481086731,
-0.09789762645959854,
-0.3005107045173645,
-0.12104692310094833,
-0.7056641578674316,
0.4214794635772705,
0.319786936044693,
0.06313034892082214,
0.22788627445697784,
-1.3291795253753662,
-0.4657555818557739,
0.6513864994049072,
0.4425770044326782,
-0.559619128704071,
0.22911487519741058,
0.493918776512146,
0.6706883907318115,
-0.344645619392395,
-0.31553027033805847,
0.5167593955993652,
0.32858189940452576,
0.185567706823349,
-0.5216693878173828,
-0.20540156960487366,
-0.4682910442352295,
-0.08160808682441711,
-0.11827517300844193,
-0.43512359261512756,
0.5523984432220459,
-0.22346128523349762,
-0.3445507287979126,
0.330786794424057,
0.13953891396522522,
-0.02355005592107773,
0.1779327541589737,
0.31818875670433044,
0.5706691741943359,
0.28904667496681213,
-0.3509905934333801,
1.1460843086242676,
-0.0671384185552597,
-0.01540372148156166,
1.1187187433242798,
-0.047467924654483795,
1.0118635892868042,
0.4292789101600647,
-0.28489959239959717,
0.29110684990882874,
0.8661150932312012,
-0.7681010365486145,
0.41662806272506714,
0.3424623906612396,
-0.3631604313850403,
-0.34436702728271484,
-0.5844305157661438,
0.3404283821582794,
0.5178418755531311,
0.21073240041732788,
-0.5651952624320984,
-0.19129039347171783,
0.2028275728225708,
-0.2177911251783371,
0.4860556125640869,
-0.3281674087047577,
0.8923495411872864,
-0.103944331407547,
-0.4847005009651184,
0.12853634357452393,
-0.41129741072654724,
0.4994015097618103,
-0.27742671966552734,
-0.25810250639915466,
-0.04071769863367081,
0.08426018804311752,
-0.3929693102836609,
-1.377903938293457,
0.2390783280134201,
0.2835458219051361,
-0.05628771707415581,
-0.36569052934646606,
0.6791059374809265,
-0.4045543670654297,
-0.6786041259765625,
0.18503515422344208,
0.1489853411912918,
0.30489617586135864,
-0.44204220175743103,
-0.520760178565979,
-0.19892363250255585,
-0.05732565000653267,
0.03224484995007515,
0.2085193693637848,
-0.033871348947286606,
0.004348956514149904,
0.8048517107963562,
0.7139096856117249,
0.4470054507255554,
0.2629905045032501,
0.20145459473133087,
0.7597947120666504,
-0.43724778294563293,
-0.18572139739990234,
-0.840117335319519,
0.6185917854309082,
-0.47961026430130005,
-0.2015184909105301,
0.35182520747184753,
0.974203884601593,
0.7083868384361267,
-0.34189295768737793,
0.9798449873924255,
-0.11778824031352997,
0.06202365830540657,
-0.36667126417160034,
1.1258556842803955,
-0.4935199022293091,
-0.062035150825977325,
-0.1608404666185379,
-1.2111492156982422,
-0.43311619758605957,
0.454367458820343,
0.06823448836803436,
-0.17718449234962463,
0.5538153648376465,
0.8163408637046814,
-0.19190487265586853,
-0.01713305525481701,
0.29378676414489746,
0.14314933121204376,
0.3255540728569031,
0.3285597264766693,
0.9161837100982666,
-0.4665842056274414,
0.6754052042961121,
-0.21127501130104065,
-0.053963661193847656,
0.18471881747245789,
-0.8836648464202881,
-0.60658860206604,
-0.8220792412757874,
-0.5977948904037476,
-0.06846604496240616,
-0.07741567492485046,
0.4578903913497925,
0.7209871411323547,
-0.8596662282943726,
0.015072831884026527,
-0.4777502715587616,
-0.5316221714019775,
-0.02571127377450466,
-0.24346500635147095,
0.4084363281726837,
-0.526171863079071,
-0.9487978219985962,
0.09379445016384125,
0.27680620551109314,
0.18510204553604126,
-0.4079165756702423,
0.1960630863904953,
0.21179914474487305,
0.07942058145999908,
0.5365958213806152,
-0.20378056168556213,
-0.5195397734642029,
-0.15576530992984772,
-0.11786075681447983,
-0.04484923183917999,
0.17665265500545502,
0.6089948415756226,
-0.547852098941803,
0.5262758731842041,
0.32298535108566284,
0.661582350730896,
0.2232504040002823,
0.04510146751999855,
0.46548572182655334,
-0.7385496497154236,
-0.1325031965970993,
0.37322306632995605,
0.5837898850440979,
0.5017377734184265,
-0.12327214330434799,
0.49369892477989197,
0.39155328273773193,
-0.1777159571647644,
-0.5668370127677917,
0.32196784019470215,
-1.3359112739562988,
-0.4797660708427429,
1.2723731994628906,
-0.2905530333518982,
-0.19747380912303925,
-0.10829833894968033,
-0.6291450262069702,
-0.10870786756277084,
-0.23643602430820465,
0.8420159220695496,
0.791311502456665,
0.243487149477005,
-0.63423752784729,
-0.3425750732421875,
0.47524014115333557,
0.16120503842830658,
-0.8605123162269592,
0.3865310251712799,
1.0790519714355469,
0.21453790366649628,
0.13892608880996704,
0.00516565702855587,
-0.4349021911621094,
0.27573010325431824,
0.249256432056427,
0.2305452972650528,
-0.16423408687114716,
-0.6094183921813965,
-0.13605725765228271,
0.36260369420051575,
-0.41355210542678833,
-0.32141387462615967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10228v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10228v1
|
VEGA: Learning Interleaved Image-Text Comprehension in Vision-Language Large Models
| 2024-06-14T17:59:40 | 2024-06-14T17:59:40 |
Chenyu Zhou, Mengdan Zhang, Peixian Chen, Chaoyou Fu, Yunhang Shen, Xiawu Zheng, Xing Sun, Rongrong Ji
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The swift progress of Multi-modal Large Models (MLLMs) has showcased their
impressive ability to tackle tasks blending vision and language. Yet, most
current models and benchmarks cater to scenarios with a narrow scope of visual
and textual contexts. These models often fall short when faced with complex
comprehension tasks, which involve navigating through a plethora of irrelevant
and potentially misleading information in both text and image forms. To bridge
this gap, we introduce a new, more demanding task known as Interleaved
Image-Text Comprehension (IITC). This task challenges models to discern and
disregard superfluous elements in both images and text to accurately answer
questions and to follow intricate instructions to pinpoint the relevant image.
In support of this task, we further craft a new VEGA dataset, tailored for the
IITC task on scientific content, and devised a subtask, Image-Text Association
(ITA), to refine image-text correlation skills. Our evaluation of four leading
closed-source models, as well as various open-source models using VEGA,
underscores the rigorous nature of IITC. Even the most advanced models, such as
Gemini-1.5-pro and GPT4V, only achieved modest success. By employing a
multi-task, multi-scale post-training strategy, we have set a robust baseline
for MLLMs on the IITC task, attaining an $85.8\%$ accuracy rate in image
association and a $0.508$ Rouge score. These results validate the effectiveness
of our dataset in improving MLLMs capabilities for nuanced image-text
comprehension.
|
[
-0.39626386761665344,
-0.7863249182701111,
0.5456547737121582,
0.3381269574165344,
-0.6330705285072327,
0.09878718852996826,
0.038256172090768814,
-0.7017949819564819,
-0.17749200761318207,
0.39797380566596985,
-0.5181815028190613,
-0.30604878067970276,
-0.6147651076316833,
0.01951413042843342,
-0.518431544303894,
0.7263978719711304,
-0.22162722051143646,
0.3450350761413574,
-0.7498888373374939,
-0.5181116461753845,
-0.3711012005805969,
-0.3192336857318878,
-0.5093488693237305,
-0.27045491337776184,
0.7041903138160706,
0.367339164018631,
0.33753564953804016,
0.7490329742431641,
0.9650757312774658,
0.2482176423072815,
-0.01596757024526596,
0.29330742359161377,
-0.40310895442962646,
-0.015212511643767357,
-0.3786974251270294,
-0.26709648966789246,
-0.022477472200989723,
-0.07585151493549347,
0.5341716408729553,
0.41295701265335083,
0.3047144114971161,
0.2092915028333664,
0.21666622161865234,
0.7075036764144897,
-0.4446667730808258,
0.5284653306007385,
-0.8574326038360596,
0.030384421348571777,
-0.07388442754745483,
-0.6085566282272339,
-0.498456209897995,
0.09075409173965454,
0.18746942281723022,
-0.9787624478340149,
0.21729005873203278,
0.22128348052501678,
0.9252409338951111,
0.7031561732292175,
-0.6354082226753235,
-0.1068183183670044,
-0.4917128384113312,
0.5624641180038452,
-0.24454593658447266,
0.2776348888874054,
0.6161183714866638,
-0.006886005401611328,
0.1985684335231781,
-0.8774729371070862,
-0.7525964379310608,
-0.2939566373825073,
0.11439075320959091,
0.3131377398967743,
-0.26981040835380554,
0.05252422019839287,
0.2072220742702484,
0.25231581926345825,
-0.43885087966918945,
0.1474466770887375,
-0.7172508239746094,
-0.16253313422203064,
0.13128723204135895,
0.04669792577624321,
0.24580717086791992,
0.027711743488907814,
-0.5975162386894226,
-0.33658960461616516,
-0.547829270362854,
0.18212395906448364,
0.2764027416706085,
-0.037107206881046295,
0.08895372599363327,
1.0851329565048218,
-0.08198336511850357,
0.5838227868080139,
-0.32468220591545105,
0.21899305284023285,
-0.10197803378105164,
-0.6803157329559326,
-0.11027392745018005,
-0.22627995908260345,
0.6617178916931152,
0.49192187190055847,
0.26326873898506165,
-0.0005248439847491682,
0.051100458949804306,
0.33463427424430847,
0.29840925335884094,
-0.7961754202842712,
-0.28510725498199463,
0.08790946006774902,
-0.3578740954399109,
-0.23999041318893433,
0.060071252286434174,
-0.583836555480957,
-0.2693789303302765,
-0.505287230014801,
0.7494840621948242,
-0.6306959986686707,
-0.16236279904842377,
-0.1089668944478035,
-0.08661649376153946,
0.4256744086742401,
0.3459787666797638,
-0.5577226281166077,
0.2385038435459137,
0.5246341228485107,
1.027286410331726,
-0.18570293486118317,
-0.6158866286277771,
-0.9453335404396057,
-0.20129342377185822,
-0.3481500446796417,
0.9430839419364929,
-0.4664177894592285,
-0.11139840632677078,
-0.1650869995355606,
-0.025009632110595703,
0.06465430557727814,
-0.4038844406604767,
0.4138037860393524,
-0.6719542145729065,
0.014240646734833717,
-0.5937854051589966,
-0.42387568950653076,
-0.4680938720703125,
0.4200505316257477,
-0.753441572189331,
1.1408164501190186,
0.038450248539447784,
-0.9709364175796509,
0.24333113431930542,
-0.5126027464866638,
-0.5095576643943787,
0.050257131457328796,
-0.20329223573207855,
-0.3693733215332031,
-0.12139170616865158,
0.30421194434165955,
0.6003932356834412,
-0.42200422286987305,
0.2589254677295685,
-0.49314412474632263,
-0.3362877070903778,
0.2756858766078949,
-0.3501192331314087,
0.35329940915107727,
-0.0832786038517952,
-0.3253290355205536,
0.5265033841133118,
-0.5642469525337219,
0.019092172384262085,
-0.08050251752138138,
-0.15325269103050232,
-0.44374310970306396,
-0.27132031321525574,
0.36058443784713745,
0.2913495898246765,
-0.021989136934280396,
-0.5492029190063477,
0.040472324937582016,
-0.035021886229515076,
0.6752410531044006,
0.7583369612693787,
-0.11126163601875305,
0.3491556644439697,
-0.10920104384422302,
0.3322252929210663,
0.23530934751033783,
0.0978955551981926,
-0.42635372281074524,
-0.6997271180152893,
-0.8969401717185974,
-0.09994857013225555,
0.1498412936925888,
0.6763900518417358,
-1.328689694404602,
-0.0528874509036541,
-0.12324266135692596,
-0.5426763892173767,
-0.6270358562469482,
0.08237752318382263,
0.5640634298324585,
0.959200918674469,
0.818612813949585,
-0.14739976823329926,
-0.25081297755241394,
-0.9248990416526794,
-0.23997493088245392,
-0.12043879181146622,
0.2870022654533386,
0.27540072798728943,
0.7556787729263306,
-0.3189074695110321,
0.5040387511253357,
-0.21683673560619354,
-0.4256440997123718,
0.16677281260490417,
0.23224219679832458,
-0.2170255333185196,
0.41921618580818176,
0.24668511748313904,
-1.1178135871887207,
-0.5260734558105469,
0.3372722864151001,
-0.7727174162864685,
0.415045827627182,
0.012648568488657475,
-0.11230650544166565,
0.09703078866004944,
0.9875390529632568,
-0.27175992727279663,
0.6086254119873047,
0.5769054889678955,
-0.5505643486976624,
0.4881449043750763,
-0.5517410635948181,
0.348587304353714,
-0.9284154772758484,
0.29441067576408386,
0.489098459482193,
-0.2751305401325226,
-0.29261064529418945,
0.1875343769788742,
0.361934095621109,
0.21224786341190338,
-0.4490568935871124,
0.6674500107765198,
-0.3320067226886749,
-0.30456840991973877,
-0.23677830398082733,
-0.3071648180484772,
0.19746951758861542,
0.3821355104446411,
0.08733130246400833,
0.9448196887969971,
0.5935500264167786,
-0.60208660364151,
0.3105936646461487,
0.2894289791584015,
-0.6784747838973999,
0.6905272603034973,
-0.7785470485687256,
0.018775571137666702,
-0.3910779654979706,
0.2544206380844116,
-1.0563033819198608,
-0.42394477128982544,
-0.03634793683886528,
-0.2115277647972107,
0.08074211329221725,
0.056558869779109955,
-0.5260660648345947,
-0.34101346135139465,
0.15851174294948578,
0.6245567202568054,
0.4034266769886017,
-0.6289809942245483,
0.6204627156257629,
0.12010965496301651,
-0.057421501725912094,
-0.8933809399604797,
-0.8321726322174072,
0.16261924803256989,
-0.04394635185599327,
-0.6269702315330505,
0.33183610439300537,
-0.32433071732521057,
-0.3996133804321289,
0.2762141525745392,
0.07891453057527542,
-0.29901084303855896,
-0.22501753270626068,
0.21853159368038177,
0.4113990068435669,
-0.27094566822052,
0.25884515047073364,
0.07909617573022842,
-0.15670116245746613,
-0.27956852316856384,
-0.21864236891269684,
0.3673047125339508,
-0.4191087484359741,
-0.4608277976512909,
-0.5078446269035339,
0.4864881634712219,
0.8704556822776794,
-0.4814041256904602,
0.5428252816200256,
0.9581207036972046,
-0.35616132616996765,
0.31270238757133484,
-0.5141873955726624,
-0.36175641417503357,
-0.4109131991863251,
0.5045028328895569,
-0.4764643609523773,
-0.5899328589439392,
0.49374571442604065,
0.12611807882785797,
0.1113172248005867,
0.4895673990249634,
0.3056565523147583,
-0.49537065625190735,
0.8062720894813538,
0.8070479035377502,
0.43641766905784607,
0.36545926332473755,
-0.4281894564628601,
-0.16832691431045532,
-0.8345924615859985,
-0.5824337601661682,
-0.007215319667011499,
-0.3387494683265686,
0.052215076982975006,
-0.7845373749732971,
0.4957607090473175,
-0.2798152565956116,
-0.01235946174710989,
0.039374373853206635,
-0.49630898237228394,
0.670809268951416,
0.9064738750457764,
0.48046398162841797,
0.45083847641944885,
0.15032441914081573,
0.042240697890520096,
-0.12880562245845795,
-0.5882488489151001,
-0.11067333072423935,
0.8727617263793945,
0.2614317238330841,
0.6055057048797607,
-0.3045724630355835,
-0.10344056785106659,
0.2300538569688797,
0.20144334435462952,
-0.9486945867538452,
0.5114989280700684,
-0.38671720027923584,
-0.29842233657836914,
-0.07218623161315918,
-0.15364970266819,
-0.6839144229888916,
0.3481079339981079,
-0.330798476934433,
-0.1953255981206894,
0.30219870805740356,
0.3300946056842804,
-0.2941034138202667,
0.392907977104187,
-0.6431251764297485,
0.9302211999893188,
-0.04876816272735596,
-0.4549886882305145,
-0.31848642230033875,
-0.8604247570037842,
0.5184565782546997,
-0.17743492126464844,
0.21621017158031464,
0.02447931282222271,
-0.26425692439079285,
0.42784973978996277,
-0.3605918884277344,
0.6529632210731506,
0.21165047585964203,
0.19075661897659302,
0.17614084482192993,
-0.08806269615888596,
0.43034541606903076,
-0.068410724401474,
-0.15078185498714447,
0.07933023571968079,
0.1977788805961609,
-0.550464928150177,
-0.2233019471168518,
0.6156922578811646,
-0.6609075665473938,
-0.09683888405561447,
-0.42400166392326355,
-0.7768062949180603,
-0.1924816519021988,
0.08278852701187134,
0.8352614045143127,
0.7284625768661499,
-0.037448953837156296,
0.47480344772338867,
1.087161660194397,
-0.11175394058227539,
0.37918442487716675,
0.0749453753232956,
0.05529182776808739,
-0.4619062542915344,
0.9304594397544861,
0.005998238921165466,
0.3587745428085327,
0.4076387584209442,
0.07022170722484589,
-0.39373886585235596,
-0.4460427165031433,
-0.4889589250087738,
0.14220014214515686,
-1.0684863328933716,
-0.29033806920051575,
-0.9631853699684143,
-0.13587923347949982,
-0.033482857048511505,
-0.09915370494127274,
-0.19750259816646576,
-0.04015570878982544,
-0.7262088656425476,
0.01634293422102928,
0.5720974802970886,
0.6924095153808594,
0.14923691749572754,
0.2974141240119934,
-0.609308660030365,
0.6038168668746948,
0.3353015184402466,
0.2800753116607666,
-0.21560755372047424,
-0.5767922401428223,
-0.06824352592229843,
-0.00327651877887547,
0.13065694272518158,
-0.5638861060142517,
0.22196699678897858,
0.3660968542098999,
0.2695178687572479,
0.12926679849624634,
-0.019719241186976433,
0.8480921387672424,
-0.3962564468383789,
0.4386850595474243,
0.2825794517993927,
-0.76865553855896,
0.2734846770763397,
-0.3550746738910675,
0.3920530378818512,
0.6691765785217285,
0.27848732471466064,
-0.2689519226551056,
-0.20484302937984467,
-0.4297829568386078,
-0.7901990413665771,
0.5294299125671387,
0.15825171768665314,
0.1023445799946785,
0.4375116527080536,
0.5524287819862366,
0.32570937275886536,
0.0845135897397995,
-1.0128501653671265,
0.05415916442871094,
-0.4371989071369171,
-0.3838104009628296,
-0.10118913650512695,
-0.12261901050806046,
-0.1859998106956482,
-0.6118648648262024,
0.7971621155738831,
-0.49244043231010437,
-0.03630649670958519,
0.4110690951347351,
-0.2807798981666565,
-0.001480774488300085,
-0.15422306954860687,
0.5299623608589172,
0.5398856401443481,
0.2400032877922058,
0.28655388951301575,
-0.13775330781936646,
-0.7265249490737915,
0.0014646108029410243,
0.21275444328784943,
-0.049954697489738464,
-0.3102928102016449,
0.4486445188522339,
1.0364069938659668,
-0.018293380737304688,
-0.8076162338256836,
0.5578399300575256,
-0.309024840593338,
-0.48540982604026794,
0.036883339285850525,
-0.17576466500759125,
0.0011352990986779332,
0.4511396288871765,
0.33787640929222107,
0.5562260746955872,
0.09713568538427353,
-0.632445752620697,
0.21001863479614258,
0.3280943036079407,
-0.7857393026351929,
-0.1733086109161377,
0.670722246170044,
-0.09626258164644241,
0.12150455266237259,
0.6754769086837769,
-0.0008001652895472944,
-0.33659741282463074,
0.9085317850112915,
0.39637479186058044,
0.4864371120929718,
0.1400984674692154,
0.29926231503486633,
0.43528348207473755,
0.6627490520477295,
-0.3260568678379059,
0.5737558007240295,
0.01338708121329546,
-0.39923009276390076,
-0.6335387825965881,
-0.3966843783855438,
-0.3754344880580902,
0.21802888810634613,
-0.566763162612915,
0.28248465061187744,
-0.35552653670310974,
0.05412505939602852,
0.13299593329429626,
-0.3389739990234375,
-0.7697633504867554,
0.26806965470314026,
-0.13510817289352417,
0.929137647151947,
-0.7315933108329773,
0.8942320346832275,
0.719576358795166,
-0.5128427147865295,
-0.6439529061317444,
0.0017933384515345097,
-0.3365907371044159,
-0.7753189206123352,
0.5556519031524658,
0.3564891815185547,
0.061590541154146194,
0.3472224473953247,
-0.6467987895011902,
-0.7387896180152893,
0.9499132633209229,
0.42766544222831726,
-0.5255427956581116,
0.011873629875481129,
-0.14675475656986237,
0.4112511873245239,
-0.0975506380200386,
0.11350800842046738,
0.22020868957042694,
0.4865427017211914,
0.44965270161628723,
-0.7099714875221252,
-0.03166459873318672,
-0.4380139112472534,
-0.27868393063545227,
-0.10380946844816208,
-0.6587473154067993,
0.9295861721038818,
-0.5916029810905457,
-0.004385582637041807,
0.28559157252311707,
0.6732133626937866,
0.13075512647628784,
0.5546165704727173,
0.6696766018867493,
0.393196702003479,
0.7660027146339417,
-0.08287645131349564,
0.9688156247138977,
0.010907216928899288,
-0.018539346754550934,
1.0586971044540405,
-0.019316863268613815,
0.9728536605834961,
0.7778581380844116,
0.2441420704126358,
0.4450891315937042,
0.9683952927589417,
-0.02656886726617813,
0.557802677154541,
-0.2583792209625244,
-0.2878062129020691,
-0.48234957456588745,
-0.21800392866134644,
-0.3547505736351013,
0.43869543075561523,
0.595076322555542,
-0.23188647627830505,
-0.029496323317289352,
0.694394052028656,
-0.5359323620796204,
0.15831880271434784,
-0.3663997948169708,
0.8652244210243225,
0.27331963181495667,
-0.9020373821258545,
0.19323696196079254,
-0.33015233278274536,
0.5466745495796204,
-0.5866679549217224,
-0.03307365998625755,
0.21948622167110443,
0.2646169662475586,
-0.04770151525735855,
-1.2505583763122559,
0.28385084867477417,
-0.13598211109638214,
-0.2997935116291046,
-0.060079287737607956,
0.6734948754310608,
-0.6560237407684326,
-0.45673075318336487,
0.1882941573858261,
0.19859904050827026,
0.040919229388237,
-0.5104078054428101,
-0.6938887238502502,
0.20808768272399902,
-0.10831140726804733,
-0.011555355042219162,
0.036300744861364365,
0.24294915795326233,
-0.2038012146949768,
0.711717963218689,
0.7872602343559265,
-0.34826400876045227,
0.08737972378730774,
-0.13860152661800385,
0.7408109903335571,
-0.4187345504760742,
-0.6276611089706421,
-0.7919574975967407,
0.6129626631736755,
-0.16238448023796082,
-0.42626702785491943,
0.3883786201477051,
0.5025393962860107,
0.5516919493675232,
-0.06389205157756805,
0.8449294567108154,
0.20225030183792114,
-0.022253813222050667,
-0.6981843709945679,
0.4740064740180969,
-0.8975916504859924,
-0.05033448711037636,
-0.10410025715827942,
-0.937211275100708,
-0.32574567198753357,
0.3165650963783264,
-0.08381128311157227,
-0.41666993498802185,
0.8195416927337646,
0.4318828582763672,
-0.4471076726913452,
0.0010529268765822053,
0.26890918612480164,
0.13959160447120667,
0.2964751422405243,
0.17001090943813324,
0.891161322593689,
-0.6093762516975403,
0.818528950214386,
-0.2761254608631134,
-0.2686545252799988,
-0.23619422316551208,
-0.8638520836830139,
-0.8746950626373291,
-1.2199608087539673,
-0.3300964832305908,
-0.44958212971687317,
-0.2845560312271118,
0.4980511963367462,
0.7378478646278381,
-0.32362374663352966,
0.24112568795681,
-0.4115014374256134,
-0.14357511699199677,
-0.2052677571773529,
-0.12643688917160034,
0.37651270627975464,
-0.2190110832452774,
-0.6244970560073853,
0.2249910980463028,
0.5952421426773071,
0.3501374125480652,
-0.44868171215057373,
0.12985508143901825,
-0.24943222105503082,
0.16436435282230377,
0.875855028629303,
0.41817474365234375,
-0.8869750499725342,
0.017563404515385628,
0.33638086915016174,
-0.27237728238105774,
0.17086061835289001,
0.7722005248069763,
-0.7725285887718201,
0.7811893224716187,
0.54449462890625,
0.812527596950531,
0.7154325842857361,
-0.19747820496559143,
0.3123054802417755,
-0.5754337906837463,
0.3194303810596466,
0.26926109194755554,
0.6010908484458923,
0.6747922897338867,
-0.44521352648735046,
0.4684496819972992,
0.27099135518074036,
-0.4011112153530121,
-0.8960290551185608,
0.19699673354625702,
-1.3194512128829956,
-0.467924565076828,
1.3222532272338867,
0.1526077389717102,
-0.35127541422843933,
-0.148884117603302,
-0.5514088273048401,
0.16775424778461456,
0.09796702116727829,
0.45606347918510437,
0.6465046405792236,
0.054043352603912354,
-0.2344496250152588,
-0.5832608342170715,
0.3348178565502167,
0.46424075961112976,
-1.1423100233078003,
-0.08395048975944519,
0.30373916029930115,
0.21425653994083405,
-0.03314739838242531,
0.6803225874900818,
0.10965371131896973,
0.45111754536628723,
-0.06020768731832504,
-0.16602174937725067,
-0.05571434274315834,
-0.5345523953437805,
-0.03817291185259819,
-0.012780878692865372,
-0.36735230684280396,
-0.24304328858852386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10325v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10325v1
|
Enhancing Multilingual Voice Toxicity Detection with Speech-Text Alignment
| 2024-06-14T17:56:53 | 2024-06-14T17:56:53 |
Joseph Liu, Mahesh Kumar Nandwana, Janne Pylkkönen, Hannes Heikinheimo, Morgan McGuire
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
Toxicity classification for voice heavily relies on the semantic content of
speech. We propose a novel framework that utilizes cross-modal learning to
integrate the semantic embedding of text into a multilabel speech toxicity
classifier during training. This enables us to incorporate textual information
during training while still requiring only audio during inference. We evaluate
this classifier on large-scale datasets with real-world characteristics to
validate the effectiveness of this framework. Through ablation studies, we
demonstrate that general-purpose semantic text embeddings are rich and aligned
with speech for toxicity classification purposes. Conducting experiments across
multiple languages at scale, we show improvements in voice toxicity
classification across five languages and different toxicity categories.
|
[
0.021122027188539505,
-0.5170747637748718,
0.4359591007232666,
0.22945797443389893,
-0.11374252289533615,
-0.1443178802728653,
-0.13657204806804657,
-0.5315890908241272,
0.12258961796760559,
0.6492641568183899,
-0.42241737246513367,
-0.7394081354141235,
-0.5855740308761597,
-0.025130216032266617,
-0.17796185612678528,
1.1319589614868164,
0.6584606170654297,
0.35068944096565247,
-0.013274389319121838,
-0.42062315344810486,
-0.5266866087913513,
-0.5091776251792908,
-0.6730502247810364,
-0.28300952911376953,
1.236289143562317,
0.48380959033966064,
0.8093158602714539,
0.5426812767982483,
-0.09459338337182999,
0.3907168209552765,
0.01760665886104107,
-0.02166193351149559,
-0.14741671085357666,
0.4897289574146271,
-0.26247525215148926,
-0.4274792969226837,
-0.12135373055934906,
-0.016107456758618355,
0.4460824429988861,
0.31755775213241577,
-0.3601989150047302,
-0.3033488988876343,
-0.09463898092508316,
0.039024267345666885,
-0.8221940994262695,
0.05215800553560257,
-0.7896172404289246,
0.1387842446565628,
-0.14967164397239685,
-0.3780982792377472,
-0.6644226312637329,
-0.05604745075106621,
0.23570594191551208,
-0.5661713480949402,
-0.34934431314468384,
-0.14870788156986237,
0.5009563565254211,
0.47961607575416565,
-0.7795412540435791,
-0.4834238290786743,
-0.5896741151809692,
0.9608930945396423,
-0.6381799578666687,
0.7724589109420776,
0.2324415147304535,
0.35863766074180603,
0.2538834512233734,
-0.5955227017402649,
-0.43566858768463135,
-0.05087653174996376,
0.019496047869324684,
0.19285552203655243,
-0.07419051975011826,
0.31236207485198975,
-0.09846770763397217,
-0.06878083944320679,
-0.5883967876434326,
0.3829689621925354,
-0.17621582746505737,
-0.7752296924591064,
0.550011396408081,
0.09944984316825867,
0.7811083197593689,
-0.19139544665813446,
-0.4546102285385132,
-0.18635866045951843,
-0.30804869532585144,
-0.26946821808815,
0.3691536486148834,
0.7372961044311523,
0.01718306727707386,
0.4185572564601898,
0.3230069875717163,
0.5904979705810547,
-0.34274402260780334,
-0.2982688844203949,
0.6037882566452026,
-0.2958836853504181,
-0.24660725891590118,
0.8437637090682983,
0.8332961797714233,
0.19252251088619232,
0.003439957043156028,
-0.06809970736503601,
0.28769513964653015,
0.21609878540039062,
0.34788233041763306,
-1.0187244415283203,
0.09526706486940384,
0.2964812219142914,
-0.23788632452487946,
-0.45763254165649414,
-0.35530397295951843,
-0.6611123085021973,
-0.5963151454925537,
-0.1149759441614151,
0.5680859684944153,
-0.33278995752334595,
-0.4756462872028351,
0.17123666405677795,
-0.3200175166130066,
-0.13715703785419464,
0.07522720843553543,
-0.8166549205780029,
-0.20184986293315887,
0.5143982768058777,
0.8121497631072998,
0.06456877291202545,
-0.25185221433639526,
-0.899307370185852,
0.38393452763557434,
-0.144438698887825,
0.8543177247047424,
-0.9456265568733215,
-0.2753612995147705,
0.06903484463691711,
0.09766609966754913,
-0.056574538350105286,
-0.6990864872932434,
0.9090216755867004,
-0.26009654998779297,
0.4700241684913635,
-0.04880235716700554,
-0.26034674048423767,
-0.41736316680908203,
0.06068585440516472,
-0.5685817003250122,
0.7911584377288818,
0.016690192744135857,
-0.7494030594825745,
0.6087589263916016,
-0.3075336515903473,
-0.4446694552898407,
-0.34381332993507385,
-0.06688077002763748,
-0.7609036564826965,
-0.29354044795036316,
-0.09765465557575226,
0.44100046157836914,
-0.14264506101608276,
0.29022789001464844,
-0.4062040150165558,
-0.1214710995554924,
0.19276370108127594,
-0.5218955874443054,
0.9822009801864624,
0.4656188488006592,
-0.30612099170684814,
0.4835212528705597,
-0.7181981801986694,
0.31879979372024536,
-0.45390695333480835,
-0.41213104128837585,
-0.5432056188583374,
0.01910609006881714,
0.48124930262565613,
0.5596215724945068,
-0.3994697630405426,
-0.7884511351585388,
-0.5686482787132263,
-0.32454171776771545,
0.28697633743286133,
0.24712024629116058,
0.1003541499376297,
0.25616753101348877,
-0.49846768379211426,
0.26209545135498047,
0.21154795587062836,
0.11731113493442535,
-0.18985912203788757,
-0.5329985618591309,
-0.4568084180355072,
-0.5107961893081665,
0.0938672199845314,
0.8633434772491455,
-0.5615719556808472,
0.7736896872520447,
-0.19543176889419556,
-0.6830044388771057,
-0.46624353528022766,
0.15236800909042358,
0.6136186122894287,
0.5800361037254333,
0.5740870237350464,
0.10299357771873474,
-0.5566695928573608,
-0.7583945393562317,
-0.3644632399082184,
-0.2969996929168701,
-0.06312430649995804,
0.5140286087989807,
0.09624545276165009,
-0.5560158491134644,
0.5720385909080505,
-0.21683596074581146,
-0.8434199094772339,
0.07749616354703903,
0.1487877070903778,
-0.37467506527900696,
0.3932305574417114,
0.5579222440719604,
-0.9364808201789856,
-0.610818088054657,
0.4336836338043213,
-0.6098974943161011,
-0.6098995804786682,
-0.1970897614955902,
-0.1577787697315216,
-0.0004908209666609764,
0.5702092051506042,
-0.010820710100233555,
0.10584540665149689,
0.7543789148330688,
-0.3378388583660126,
0.043389078229665756,
0.12422146648168564,
0.20037947595119476,
-1.0602415800094604,
-0.2243404984474182,
0.12956422567367554,
-0.06187950074672699,
-0.9995393753051758,
-0.5974615812301636,
-0.020742878317832947,
-0.3229473829269409,
-0.8742321133613586,
0.3661554753780365,
-0.09483817219734192,
0.23299124836921692,
-0.22542254626750946,
0.21686753630638123,
0.2446443885564804,
0.19631704688072205,
0.39273756742477417,
0.5991231203079224,
0.4602853059768677,
-0.41788142919540405,
0.43803995847702026,
0.22951790690422058,
0.1065911203622818,
0.961833655834198,
-0.4274674952030182,
-0.15578094124794006,
-0.023231741040945053,
0.3413654565811157,
-1.040573000907898,
-0.11260417848825455,
0.175184965133667,
-0.5368260741233826,
0.2782701551914215,
-0.15069401264190674,
-0.2754453122615814,
0.25853589177131653,
0.08032935112714767,
0.4385558068752289,
0.1436997801065445,
-0.39524853229522705,
0.8410620093345642,
0.6787248849868774,
-0.2902107834815979,
-0.5651496052742004,
-1.0180774927139282,
-0.054005593061447144,
-0.5287649631500244,
-0.6896378397941589,
0.2604852616786957,
0.215951606631279,
0.009290714748203754,
0.02974556013941765,
-0.0969165712594986,
-0.39468300342559814,
-0.05669517442584038,
0.13430443406105042,
-0.26244014501571655,
-0.13814334571361542,
0.5535556077957153,
0.35628798604011536,
-0.22256582975387573,
0.12760330736637115,
-0.00008108077599899843,
0.24793459475040436,
0.0963054895401001,
-0.3970966041088104,
-0.6078760027885437,
0.7625678181648254,
0.8443412780761719,
-0.30810627341270447,
0.4941354990005493,
0.8816182613372803,
-0.29680290818214417,
-0.2005370408296585,
-0.4329923987388611,
0.09498290717601776,
-0.44965580105781555,
0.5837185978889465,
0.0021750342566519976,
-0.7500019669532776,
0.6238340139389038,
-0.059745486825704575,
-0.26039955019950867,
0.3060513138771057,
0.5756500959396362,
0.11719376593828201,
1.2902801036834717,
0.3245563209056854,
-0.1186772882938385,
0.6595969200134277,
0.18961045145988464,
0.018749823793768883,
-0.6786805391311646,
-0.49185073375701904,
-0.815528929233551,
-0.01399244461208582,
-0.37069666385650635,
-0.5327519774436951,
0.5727489590644836,
-0.24060282111167908,
-0.6287940144538879,
0.05001511052250862,
-0.6470728516578674,
0.3972289264202118,
0.03527393937110901,
0.27448776364326477,
0.17939399182796478,
-0.01487374771386385,
-0.24055881798267365,
-0.23117783665657043,
-0.6177248954772949,
-0.27701640129089355,
0.6705860495567322,
0.5130000114440918,
0.7526331543922424,
0.2828390896320343,
0.5159153938293457,
0.028977766633033752,
0.47177794575691223,
-0.9018587470054626,
0.019696561619639397,
-0.3021071255207062,
-1.0299252271652222,
-0.40198129415512085,
-0.4612850546836853,
-0.8351287841796875,
0.7244104146957397,
-0.3580591380596161,
-0.4780054986476898,
0.25803473591804504,
-0.1772170215845108,
-0.17044317722320557,
0.27961885929107666,
-1.0123144388198853,
1.135456919670105,
-0.6246604919433594,
-0.3050849437713623,
-0.2520847022533417,
-0.6762502193450928,
0.16386070847511292,
-0.22038030624389648,
0.5455424785614014,
-0.2419118583202362,
-0.2999853491783142,
0.4754350185394287,
-0.48215577006340027,
1.1284350156784058,
-0.32764309644699097,
-0.5376622676849365,
0.2851017117500305,
-0.3087807297706604,
0.08997579663991928,
-0.003920812159776688,
-0.33135342597961426,
0.20077651739120483,
0.01801859773695469,
-0.22712601721286774,
-0.4978936016559601,
0.7358100414276123,
-0.5520172119140625,
-0.16594544053077698,
-0.45628848671913147,
-0.49720823764801025,
-0.5172091722488403,
0.36070123314857483,
0.2916301190853119,
0.26180604100227356,
-0.06918589025735855,
0.2957548499107361,
0.8441351056098938,
-0.907422661781311,
0.06552723050117493,
0.45772212743759155,
-0.14638635516166687,
-0.6210057139396667,
1.0657762289047241,
0.06554318964481354,
0.6218305230140686,
0.22426290810108185,
0.568235456943512,
-0.4927440881729126,
-0.2483968883752823,
-0.5151157975196838,
0.1103454977273941,
-0.9068413376808167,
-0.347684770822525,
-0.790720522403717,
-0.27899307012557983,
-0.3544166684150696,
0.04352879151701927,
-0.3130474388599396,
0.23087504506111145,
-0.42119690775871277,
-0.04624902456998825,
0.40009698271751404,
0.5102288126945496,
-0.2119119018316269,
0.3772326707839966,
-1.2072153091430664,
0.17057321965694427,
0.4546833634376526,
0.4742477834224701,
-0.18027274310588837,
-0.2989114224910736,
-0.06025787442922592,
0.2505561113357544,
-0.2609332501888275,
-1.2467604875564575,
0.19922083616256714,
0.6594371795654297,
0.8010967373847961,
0.528258740901947,
0.23803745210170746,
0.7174533605575562,
-0.42534568905830383,
0.6966995000839233,
0.26424404978752136,
-1.1444953680038452,
0.5568932294845581,
-0.5458780527114868,
0.009798537939786911,
0.6000986695289612,
0.641908586025238,
-1.0491628646850586,
-0.589164137840271,
-0.18109337985515594,
-0.7084200978279114,
0.6050591468811035,
-0.05899795889854431,
0.4417901337146759,
-0.11966332793235779,
-0.1562775820493698,
0.017692172899842262,
-0.07782509177923203,
-0.6289563775062561,
-0.16698354482650757,
-0.3913058936595917,
-0.4169962704181671,
0.012203008867800236,
-0.2406536042690277,
-0.186041921377182,
-0.4108666181564331,
0.7131994962692261,
-0.1592424511909485,
0.07948153465986252,
0.11635640263557434,
-0.2304176539182663,
-0.03241622820496559,
0.5833589434623718,
0.5918979048728943,
0.05461716651916504,
0.032844427973032,
0.1229245737195015,
0.28964662551879883,
-0.4214904308319092,
0.4530220627784729,
-0.022833624854683876,
0.25857213139533997,
0.0704413428902626,
0.4024786949157715,
0.6929109692573547,
0.6631940007209778,
-0.7605080604553223,
0.7115655541419983,
-0.014409362338483334,
-0.3243212103843689,
-0.07356500625610352,
-0.035096485167741776,
0.22375477850437164,
0.26941993832588196,
0.11703583598136902,
-0.23572833836078644,
0.5422999262809753,
-0.6698046922683716,
0.5977282524108887,
0.43427684903144836,
-0.9098645448684692,
0.14023348689079285,
0.6808582544326782,
0.4349566102027893,
0.11977926641702652,
0.20645436644554138,
0.23449242115020752,
-0.7863917946815491,
0.2664664089679718,
0.5822155475616455,
0.8665114045143127,
-0.6919389367103577,
0.3193763494491577,
0.2251688838005066,
-0.007132973987609148,
0.41703999042510986,
0.3357224762439728,
0.06394083052873611,
-0.6625555157661438,
-0.5378159880638123,
-0.5301563143730164,
-0.3610415458679199,
-0.1536892205476761,
-0.5781850218772888,
0.3082868158817291,
-0.30320805311203003,
-0.03812132030725479,
0.34003934264183044,
-0.34225261211395264,
-0.07311698794364929,
0.21568633615970612,
0.39969712495803833,
0.5298993587493896,
-1.4972559213638306,
0.7693076729774475,
0.6445426344871521,
-0.3590145409107208,
-0.8012911081314087,
-0.22884811460971832,
0.4453151226043701,
-0.5898045301437378,
0.8067355155944824,
0.4540804326534271,
-0.3076872229576111,
-0.11106608062982559,
-0.0011701537296175957,
-0.7314847707748413,
0.7168669700622559,
0.3620538115501404,
-0.2461976259946823,
0.1603904664516449,
0.18745741248130798,
0.7201880812644958,
-0.17134320735931396,
0.4849916100502014,
0.15615898370742798,
0.639707624912262,
0.19346311688423157,
-1.2228448390960693,
0.015913384035229683,
-0.262295126914978,
-0.06416867673397064,
0.18202365934848785,
-0.5212993621826172,
0.5508677363395691,
0.06506995111703873,
-0.44647490978240967,
-0.28109943866729736,
0.4101666510105133,
-0.21464546024799347,
0.46785953640937805,
0.9050805568695068,
0.731607973575592,
0.7936158180236816,
-0.06665151566267014,
0.5368565917015076,
0.12373705208301544,
0.03678913414478302,
1.0706384181976318,
-0.41741567850112915,
0.7794199585914612,
0.1956930160522461,
0.1285027712583542,
0.8342837691307068,
0.5763120651245117,
0.22319377958774567,
0.6297311782836914,
0.2584141492843628,
-0.6253872513771057,
-0.5237730145454407,
-0.6285655498504639,
-0.3619453012943268,
0.7409501671791077,
0.7178537845611572,
-0.4563761055469513,
-0.554242730140686,
0.7034937739372253,
0.040465421974658966,
0.1637100875377655,
-0.09511567652225494,
1.1065434217453003,
-0.07811397314071655,
-0.37298911809921265,
0.6731008291244507,
-0.4182940721511841,
0.8355626463890076,
-0.5381327867507935,
-0.11785008758306503,
0.5337690114974976,
0.3024849593639374,
-0.59363853931427,
-0.6745743155479431,
0.752393901348114,
-0.34219691157341003,
0.025849347934126854,
-0.19199135899543762,
0.5752177238464355,
-0.9005175232887268,
-0.18148592114448547,
0.7651454210281372,
0.22181497514247894,
0.05800760164856911,
-0.17730450630187988,
-0.7465059757232666,
0.28856757283210754,
-0.1427350640296936,
0.06370694935321808,
0.3302888572216034,
0.6551675796508789,
-0.08676523715257645,
0.6068689823150635,
0.7228652238845825,
0.049319811165332794,
0.16077134013175964,
0.2859891951084137,
0.8639514446258545,
-0.4720960557460785,
-0.5341723561286926,
-0.5625657439231873,
0.7352865934371948,
0.0011018621735274792,
-0.1220514103770256,
0.5445589423179626,
0.6980152726173401,
0.762717604637146,
0.27426251769065857,
0.9017083048820496,
0.08649597316980362,
0.5262288451194763,
-0.520622968673706,
0.8188557624816895,
-0.6229277849197388,
0.11092718690633774,
-0.3447762727737427,
-0.7219704985618591,
-0.683129608631134,
0.7036358714103699,
0.03972547873854637,
0.043829113245010376,
0.7214467525482178,
0.8637810349464417,
0.08435725420713425,
0.07150410115718842,
0.3547777235507965,
-0.017144888639450073,
0.46860602498054504,
0.4611055552959442,
0.7370222210884094,
-0.27513059973716736,
0.8262109756469727,
-0.3409879505634308,
-0.12350478768348694,
-0.17225530743598938,
-0.9604776501655579,
-0.8634308576583862,
-0.6993498802185059,
-0.21992507576942444,
-0.47643908858299255,
-0.12448704987764359,
0.8023268580436707,
0.8284481167793274,
-0.7871218919754028,
0.16201624274253845,
0.3554917871952057,
0.28405076265335083,
-0.14443472027778625,
-0.2653135359287262,
-0.0669313296675682,
-0.5355163812637329,
-0.7824270725250244,
0.4101376235485077,
0.20348338782787323,
0.02154362201690674,
-0.11392182111740112,
-0.16063643991947174,
-0.33398544788360596,
-0.13042552769184113,
0.6758291721343994,
0.10155443102121353,
-0.8362386226654053,
-0.6137728095054626,
-0.19796189665794373,
-0.2885892689228058,
-0.04441726580262184,
0.8188529014587402,
-0.4558993875980377,
0.7575238943099976,
0.6042142510414124,
0.6937674283981323,
0.12482231855392456,
-0.17363376915454865,
0.3792461156845093,
-0.8916798233985901,
0.23955464363098145,
0.578596830368042,
0.1737959235906601,
0.2908368408679962,
-0.48207467794418335,
0.1754605621099472,
-0.08499544858932495,
-0.5099994540214539,
-0.8011854290962219,
0.2283262014389038,
-1.0802758932113647,
-0.4040396511554718,
1.3776732683181763,
-0.07291875034570694,
-0.09389762580394745,
-0.6153771877288818,
-0.46932220458984375,
0.4917106330394745,
-0.4278007745742798,
0.24421143531799316,
0.5560332536697388,
-0.23353475332260132,
-0.16135939955711365,
-0.6208548545837402,
0.4901743233203888,
0.41869670152664185,
-0.9234434962272644,
0.20234502851963043,
0.7394379377365112,
0.4987027943134308,
0.5261280536651611,
0.39663493633270264,
-0.4841873049736023,
0.2571263909339905,
-0.003539819037541747,
0.030507031828165054,
0.045423269271850586,
-0.3272051513195038,
-0.4311443567276001,
-0.10880592465400696,
-0.18457229435443878,
0.0033855631481856108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10221v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10221v1
|
Short Film Dataset (SFD): A Benchmark for Story-Level Video Understanding
| 2024-06-14T17:54:54 | 2024-06-14T17:54:54 |
Ridouane Ghermi, Xi Wang, Vicky Kalogeiton, Ivan Laptev
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent advances in vision-language models have significantly propelled video
understanding. Existing datasets and tasks, however, have notable limitations.
Most datasets are confined to short videos with limited events and narrow
narratives. For example, datasets with instructional and egocentric videos
often document the activities of one person in a single scene. Although some
movie datasets offer richer content, they are often limited to short-term
tasks, lack publicly available videos and frequently encounter data leakage
given the use of movie forums and other resources in LLM training. To address
the above limitations, we propose the Short Film Dataset (SFD) with 1,078
publicly available amateur movies, a wide variety of genres and minimal data
leakage issues. SFD offers long-term story-oriented video tasks in the form of
multiple-choice and open-ended question answering. Our extensive experiments
emphasize the need for long-term reasoning to solve SFD tasks. Notably, we find
strong signals in movie transcripts leading to the on-par performance of people
and LLMs. We also show significantly lower performance of current models
compared to people when using vision data alone.
|
[
-0.3239736258983612,
-0.46892547607421875,
0.7136550545692444,
-0.06288817524909973,
-0.49389564990997314,
0.1485472321510315,
-0.09607067704200745,
-0.10634961724281311,
0.08214814960956573,
0.6983522772789001,
-0.8189452290534973,
-0.5132005214691162,
-0.7115510702133179,
-0.05165817216038704,
-0.621032178401947,
1.0418120622634888,
-0.4321061372756958,
0.01926838792860508,
-0.37577882409095764,
-0.41232237219810486,
-0.09983168542385101,
-0.4081689715385437,
-0.44134554266929626,
0.15911684930324554,
0.5302019119262695,
0.5324544310569763,
0.6377577185630798,
1.0200464725494385,
0.6623643040657043,
0.09023585170507431,
0.1378612369298935,
0.1740630567073822,
-0.7592287063598633,
-0.2444532960653305,
-0.26559188961982727,
-0.33716848492622375,
0.10654234141111374,
-0.04632825776934624,
0.7637539505958557,
0.8185422420501709,
0.15285784006118774,
0.6484166383743286,
-0.10808070003986359,
0.7806539535522461,
-0.633564829826355,
0.04429274797439575,
-0.11603394150733948,
0.3136367201805115,
-0.4791448414325714,
-0.07116736471652985,
0.045386794954538345,
-0.09684355556964874,
0.0950663685798645,
-0.5053664445877075,
0.681509256362915,
-0.03501269966363907,
0.6440247297286987,
0.6502327919006348,
-0.2606451213359833,
0.1469872146844864,
-0.8310595154762268,
0.49723079800605774,
-0.22679100930690765,
0.4131896495819092,
0.44368189573287964,
0.47158282995224,
0.34359848499298096,
-0.3408212959766388,
-0.4558086693286896,
-0.009875576943159103,
0.17261233925819397,
-0.25651177763938904,
-0.0028907961677759886,
0.20657575130462646,
0.5345025062561035,
0.4727087616920471,
-0.6568067073822021,
0.2229713350534439,
-0.708835244178772,
0.1810494065284729,
0.6257979869842529,
0.5481783151626587,
0.06039255112409592,
-0.5285071134567261,
-0.5741754174232483,
-0.11907362937927246,
-0.5474950671195984,
0.34584587812423706,
0.23697194457054138,
-0.13013479113578796,
-0.30267614126205444,
0.7523150444030762,
-0.33833906054496765,
0.5194265246391296,
-0.0917065218091011,
-0.21801064908504486,
0.06719675660133362,
-0.418950617313385,
-0.3638736307621002,
-0.2036876380443573,
0.5095993876457214,
0.6685974597930908,
0.49157020449638367,
-0.10566091537475586,
-0.02308576926589012,
0.011689291335642338,
0.007469814270734787,
-0.8536802530288696,
-0.11583799123764038,
0.01576036959886551,
-0.4173492193222046,
-0.08667559921741486,
0.16462327539920807,
-0.7072122097015381,
-0.6955012083053589,
-0.3435894250869751,
0.5518314838409424,
-0.21564173698425293,
0.08102060854434967,
0.05035385116934776,
-0.3737870156764984,
0.14429420232772827,
0.3700335621833801,
-0.7840742468833923,
0.5407482385635376,
0.4398473799228668,
0.9254672527313232,
-0.6011520624160767,
-0.5450018644332886,
-0.6275987029075623,
0.4799850583076477,
-0.4178796708583832,
0.5890346765518188,
-0.12434138357639313,
-0.1051340326666832,
-0.22568099200725555,
-0.04944925010204315,
0.040687933564186096,
-0.5662496089935303,
0.35198697447776794,
-0.11632810533046722,
0.028007956221699715,
-0.07157386839389801,
-0.44623544812202454,
-0.09464693814516068,
0.10745362192392349,
-0.8576764464378357,
0.8601238131523132,
0.19792398810386658,
-0.5741645097732544,
0.627727746963501,
-0.4983224868774414,
-0.20779353380203247,
-0.1979939341545105,
-0.6073886752128601,
-0.041793499141931534,
0.19427122175693512,
0.642522931098938,
0.6666621565818787,
-0.353511244058609,
0.6144744753837585,
-0.3650668263435364,
-0.6648225784301758,
0.05063288286328316,
-0.6261715292930603,
0.2288234531879425,
0.13175895810127258,
0.011347025632858276,
-0.2875176668167114,
-0.7189063429832458,
-0.39204099774360657,
0.0012512539979070425,
-0.07787565141916275,
-0.033885497599840164,
0.041956644505262375,
-0.16020247340202332,
0.1965695172548294,
-0.12673309445381165,
-0.4558355212211609,
-0.19473426043987274,
-0.14421036839485168,
0.34915924072265625,
1.0048021078109741,
0.2389596700668335,
0.3630267381668091,
-0.33633944392204285,
0.8481409549713135,
0.3974170684814453,
0.14460515975952148,
-0.36460933089256287,
-0.04328479617834091,
-0.5931575894355774,
-0.22575408220291138,
-0.2334894984960556,
0.3548266887664795,
-0.831674337387085,
-0.2225668728351593,
-0.4300392270088196,
-0.15723362565040588,
-0.4974755644798279,
0.506788969039917,
0.12530751526355743,
0.5869938135147095,
0.3776477873325348,
-0.3524380624294281,
-0.43126335740089417,
-1.0932039022445679,
-0.006543973460793495,
-0.08089587092399597,
-0.28301477432250977,
0.570880651473999,
0.3919953405857086,
0.14644259214401245,
1.1197007894515991,
-0.7852519154548645,
-0.5053412914276123,
-0.4934776723384857,
-0.0760459154844284,
0.5627830028533936,
0.10882660001516342,
0.4432298243045807,
-0.7536866068840027,
-0.1369590163230896,
-0.48531484603881836,
-0.9902844429016113,
0.22809836268424988,
-0.22025305032730103,
0.294946551322937,
-0.14561182260513306,
0.48739123344421387,
-0.5810126662254333,
0.6718837022781372,
0.3765757381916046,
-0.25553521513938904,
0.46339547634124756,
-0.18049080669879913,
0.3251936733722687,
-0.6352495551109314,
-0.21310646831989288,
0.22560496628284454,
-0.2660853862762451,
-0.4579961597919464,
-0.3108348846435547,
-0.23180894553661346,
-0.49379831552505493,
-0.8311491012573242,
0.5339583158493042,
-0.08102276921272278,
-0.5931684970855713,
-0.10359853506088257,
0.2189193218946457,
0.0062555428594350815,
0.7078222632408142,
0.3709058463573456,
0.7732590436935425,
0.6362407207489014,
-0.6581599712371826,
0.4632240831851959,
0.2945135533809662,
-0.8223486542701721,
0.5480453372001648,
-0.4590817391872406,
-0.12984010577201843,
-0.5382710695266724,
0.2629290819168091,
-0.7205143570899963,
-0.6464013457298279,
0.04592188075184822,
-0.13085061311721802,
-0.22280269861221313,
-0.2834126353263855,
-0.46907204389572144,
-0.35111889243125916,
-0.3364887535572052,
0.6036854386329651,
0.4535759687423706,
-0.7062188386917114,
0.33144065737724304,
0.13219481706619263,
-0.16392390429973602,
-0.4740758538246155,
-0.706380307674408,
0.08038553595542908,
-0.6298900246620178,
-0.8503801226615906,
0.27390655875205994,
-0.03749365732073784,
-0.09473081678152084,
-0.03303968906402588,
-0.3448517322540283,
-0.47878798842430115,
-0.2587807774543762,
0.3552032709121704,
0.08669046312570572,
-0.2723143696784973,
0.1625523567199707,
-0.1739315688610077,
0.006787943188101053,
0.028558293357491493,
0.24811990559101105,
0.0329647995531559,
0.16934601962566376,
-0.23652474582195282,
-0.405266672372818,
0.657227635383606,
0.4183984398841858,
0.09697191417217255,
0.39689385890960693,
0.6791034936904907,
-0.3482801616191864,
-0.34795650839805603,
-0.3930937945842743,
-0.018877984955906868,
-0.430295467376709,
0.524868369102478,
-0.1941157728433609,
-0.9411750435829163,
0.3354228436946869,
0.03830813989043236,
-0.3986372649669647,
0.1006142795085907,
0.18245460093021393,
-0.589358925819397,
0.7256467342376709,
0.7403753399848938,
-0.0013392631663009524,
0.5077965259552002,
-0.3481239378452301,
-0.03680620342493057,
-0.5471917390823364,
-0.1362418383359909,
0.00592740997672081,
-0.4136377274990082,
-0.07519020885229111,
-0.7119109034538269,
0.4229607582092285,
0.2899099886417389,
-0.3396255373954773,
0.23482853174209595,
-0.05500948801636696,
1.0081355571746826,
0.15288518369197845,
0.220986008644104,
0.3804835379123688,
-0.09683898091316223,
0.2965959906578064,
-0.17776647210121155,
-0.5157511234283447,
-0.4738466441631317,
1.0502030849456787,
0.5203473567962646,
1.0016531944274902,
0.07345820963382721,
0.631596028804779,
0.5959826707839966,
-0.265739381313324,
-0.30354705452919006,
0.6532055139541626,
-0.5357054471969604,
-0.5560352802276611,
-0.2272951602935791,
-0.20156985521316528,
-0.3810785114765167,
-0.1799064725637436,
0.21626587212085724,
-0.9166064858436584,
0.385684609413147,
0.01726333424448967,
-0.5006347298622131,
0.3025243282318115,
-0.816392719745636,
0.9775643348693848,
-0.505361020565033,
-0.5605862140655518,
-0.23799340426921844,
-0.8563024997711182,
0.48130977153778076,
-0.2668335735797882,
0.2552938759326935,
-0.30870750546455383,
0.10105864703655243,
0.9875167012214661,
-0.4164600074291229,
0.8437203168869019,
-0.31416305899620056,
0.3680298626422882,
0.37813249230384827,
-0.1970529705286026,
0.3750966489315033,
0.3911639451980591,
0.24591486155986786,
-0.06606147438287735,
0.14465978741645813,
-0.19109563529491425,
-0.64356529712677,
0.38888269662857056,
-0.6103723049163818,
-0.5386289358139038,
-0.38616347312927246,
-0.39011532068252563,
-0.25120019912719727,
-0.08811137825250626,
0.10724452883005142,
0.422996461391449,
-0.2118934839963913,
0.28431108593940735,
0.7513556480407715,
-0.19783978164196014,
0.5198308825492859,
0.35088828206062317,
-0.32969361543655396,
-0.3211177587509155,
0.8087611794471741,
-0.03083033300936222,
0.329885870218277,
0.2985902726650238,
-0.1453542411327362,
-0.20487956702709198,
-0.5182594060897827,
-0.6247297525405884,
0.06589248031377792,
-0.8465136289596558,
-0.09267201274633408,
-0.3073863685131073,
-0.1929500699043274,
0.12972494959831238,
-0.24859857559204102,
-0.308434396982193,
-0.38968777656555176,
-0.47224339842796326,
-0.7771554589271545,
0.4158104956150055,
0.541635274887085,
-0.1652747392654419,
0.12697100639343262,
-0.5471913814544678,
1.0699927806854248,
0.27000969648361206,
0.5588666200637817,
-0.3274671733379364,
-0.30806148052215576,
-0.5215649604797363,
-0.16826008260250092,
-0.16409285366535187,
-0.6639530062675476,
0.1370578110218048,
0.47619277238845825,
0.4173315167427063,
0.4739576280117035,
0.037455134093761444,
0.8635583519935608,
-0.3360402286052704,
0.9768953919410706,
0.13599629700183868,
-0.6489211916923523,
0.7207674980163574,
-0.4043785631656647,
0.07989311963319778,
0.7871916890144348,
0.5475874543190002,
-0.5277101993560791,
0.015744566917419434,
-0.5567766427993774,
-0.556100606918335,
0.9723435044288635,
0.1314922571182251,
-0.009852420538663864,
0.2391194850206375,
0.19986175000667572,
0.4163433909416199,
0.3018382787704468,
-0.49405837059020996,
-0.07723628729581833,
-0.3772583603858948,
-0.09087622165679932,
-0.50625079870224,
0.1677113026380539,
-0.06807642430067062,
-0.4915006160736084,
0.06866350769996643,
-0.21659258008003235,
0.08427483588457108,
0.26246583461761475,
-0.23119516670703888,
-0.11077257990837097,
0.10493708401918411,
0.17098921537399292,
0.6680209040641785,
-0.6125824451446533,
0.08952176570892334,
0.24075628817081451,
-0.4495358169078827,
0.32322272658348083,
-0.09866521507501602,
0.003242119448259473,
-0.0533081516623497,
0.26291510462760925,
1.0594401359558105,
0.22672004997730255,
-1.1753939390182495,
0.7337525486946106,
0.22355704009532928,
-0.23708611726760864,
-0.2933172583580017,
0.25555363297462463,
-0.17488722503185272,
0.24528655409812927,
0.4448715150356293,
0.07908659428358078,
0.0477200523018837,
-0.669631838798523,
0.4275849163532257,
-0.11448133736848831,
-0.3677046597003937,
-0.1119028851389885,
0.6511019468307495,
-0.047012072056531906,
-0.1382380574941635,
0.7795332670211792,
0.12372597306966782,
-0.11733927577733994,
0.7679718136787415,
-0.05209069699048996,
0.6380251049995422,
0.4959586560726166,
0.5265791416168213,
0.24030528962612152,
0.05464167892932892,
-0.22513045370578766,
0.05021330714225769,
-0.3847838342189789,
-0.5420083403587341,
-0.5236207246780396,
-0.6076603531837463,
-0.5201201438903809,
0.34554117918014526,
-0.7809903025627136,
0.48210540413856506,
-0.5025690793991089,
0.26986995339393616,
-0.17090865969657898,
-0.15222486853599548,
-0.7988547086715698,
0.4759475290775299,
0.3136570155620575,
0.9530001878738403,
-0.886259138584137,
0.9752169251441956,
0.06578538566827774,
-0.6497766971588135,
-0.5632632970809937,
-0.2485654503107071,
-0.10204258561134338,
-0.6013798117637634,
0.7192927598953247,
0.2617698013782501,
0.0531608872115612,
-0.20540016889572144,
-0.4971238076686859,
-0.7323406934738159,
1.2216360569000244,
0.5253614187240601,
-0.4694195091724396,
-0.5134984254837036,
0.4696667790412903,
0.6143983006477356,
-0.5150153636932373,
-0.1169159784913063,
0.8438059687614441,
0.22493615746498108,
0.056183550506830215,
-0.5098750591278076,
-0.31527549028396606,
-0.03331363946199417,
-0.23071148991584778,
0.12408477067947388,
-0.49914276599884033,
0.49028125405311584,
-0.5772865414619446,
-0.244531512260437,
0.07201733440160751,
0.5519029498100281,
0.3536612391471863,
0.7281205058097839,
0.3958633542060852,
0.45340248942375183,
0.4625947177410126,
-0.015486017800867558,
0.9291254281997681,
0.3490203320980072,
0.05558602884411812,
1.2227637767791748,
-0.1754899024963379,
0.7693414688110352,
0.7033914923667908,
-0.14585906267166138,
0.24637329578399658,
0.761786937713623,
-0.4402952492237091,
0.8303337693214417,
0.18125440180301666,
-0.10687442123889923,
-0.5303305387496948,
-0.1680077165365219,
-0.06678307801485062,
0.43764016032218933,
0.23196259140968323,
-0.3891695737838745,
-0.3502551317214966,
0.436049222946167,
-0.5088731050491333,
0.16139434278011322,
-0.492257297039032,
0.678069531917572,
0.15266907215118408,
-0.45869311690330505,
0.17121697962284088,
-0.3181021809577942,
0.45529496669769287,
-0.5801554918289185,
0.006255124229937792,
-0.3269769847393036,
0.06561585515737534,
-0.2765897512435913,
-1.0584962368011475,
0.3379133641719818,
0.5978478193283081,
-0.4102827310562134,
-0.4254530370235443,
0.39057520031929016,
-0.37106966972351074,
-0.39964959025382996,
0.06762070953845978,
0.420549213886261,
0.4586166441440582,
0.005913116037845612,
-0.4010111391544342,
0.012895757332444191,
-0.12559884786605835,
0.0006487826467491686,
0.4759673476219177,
0.218716561794281,
-0.1936451643705368,
0.7367017865180969,
0.23084665834903717,
0.09171748161315918,
-0.025034284219145775,
0.027765069156885147,
0.6207230687141418,
-0.8537881374359131,
-0.5443271994590759,
-0.5437214970588684,
0.39318132400512695,
0.09230869263410568,
-0.40151700377464294,
0.4999346435070038,
0.7147098779678345,
1.0285053253173828,
-0.30194416642189026,
0.6627363562583923,
0.08580417186021805,
0.619364857673645,
-0.8664112091064453,
0.29364556074142456,
-0.47915852069854736,
0.36281394958496094,
-0.2806445360183716,
-0.8711448311805725,
-0.012942954897880554,
0.20726658403873444,
-0.3312103748321533,
-0.1389080137014389,
0.844806969165802,
0.5258597731590271,
-0.23844438791275024,
0.1526651233434677,
0.21918316185474396,
-0.0492677241563797,
0.219562366604805,
0.9225383996963501,
1.071864366531372,
-0.26833224296569824,
0.8805422186851501,
-0.5377540588378906,
0.10632636398077011,
-0.04386875033378601,
-0.8771466016769409,
-0.8858118653297424,
-0.5083501935005188,
-0.34098559617996216,
0.2954123616218567,
0.28141728043556213,
0.6989163756370544,
0.7014520764350891,
-0.33118337392807007,
-0.3091713488101959,
-0.011393925175070763,
0.1526295393705368,
-0.321521133184433,
-0.2095402032136917,
0.5559348464012146,
0.3975312411785126,
-0.46657347679138184,
0.7076503038406372,
0.3231791853904724,
0.03492385521531105,
-0.43025392293930054,
-0.23533421754837036,
0.12837807834148407,
0.023157702758908272,
0.21273057162761688,
0.40398621559143066,
-0.5311211347579956,
-0.407831072807312,
-0.15123924612998962,
0.17961840331554413,
0.39383748173713684,
0.9786909818649292,
-1.0210686922073364,
0.28636470437049866,
0.45315343141555786,
0.43437331914901733,
1.016582727432251,
0.25165581703186035,
0.5357943177223206,
-1.091209888458252,
-0.008917528204619884,
0.1608530879020691,
0.2899114191532135,
0.34844109416007996,
-0.4470893442630768,
0.761143684387207,
0.16587814688682556,
-0.329904705286026,
-0.9005770087242126,
0.20355963706970215,
-1.2312135696411133,
-0.11433907598257065,
0.8591487407684326,
-0.06157935410737991,
-0.1148635521531105,
-0.030532119795680046,
-0.1505071520805359,
-0.17511537671089172,
-0.33467450737953186,
0.369161456823349,
0.8129166960716248,
-0.4387415647506714,
-0.5782381892204285,
-0.6840074062347412,
0.5943012237548828,
0.03558832034468651,
-0.8388185501098633,
0.30011171102523804,
0.5689195394515991,
0.3580041229724884,
-0.3290053904056549,
0.719876766204834,
0.026735402643680573,
0.5109698176383972,
-0.1065649464726448,
-0.6667951941490173,
-0.2994478940963745,
-0.805504560470581,
-0.4959438741207123,
0.4415184259414673,
-0.25713682174682617,
-0.13454949855804443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10216v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10216v1
|
Regularizing Hidden States Enables Learning Generalizable Reward Model for LLMs
| 2024-06-14T17:49:59 | 2024-06-14T17:49:59 |
Rui Yang, Ruomeng Ding, Yong Lin, Huan Zhang, Tong Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Reward models trained on human preference data have been proven to be
effective for aligning Large Language Models (LLMs) with human intent within
the reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) framework. However, the
generalization capabilities of current reward models to unseen prompts and
responses are limited. This limitation can lead to an unexpected phenomenon
known as reward over-optimization, where excessive optimization of rewards
results in a decline in actual performance. While previous research has
advocated for constraining policy optimization, our study proposes a novel
approach to enhance the reward model's generalization ability against
distribution shifts by regularizing the hidden states. Specifically, we retain
the base model's language model head and incorporate a suite of text-generation
losses to preserve the hidden states' text generation capabilities, while
concurrently learning a reward head behind the same hidden states. Our
experimental results demonstrate that the introduced regularization technique
markedly improves the accuracy of learned reward models across a variety of
out-of-distribution (OOD) tasks and effectively alleviate the over-optimization
issue in RLHF, offering a more reliable and robust preference learning
paradigm.
|
[
-0.167708620429039,
-0.28962242603302,
0.47609734535217285,
-0.1726585477590561,
-0.28994861245155334,
0.011876214295625687,
-0.7581691145896912,
-0.07778137177228928,
0.281093031167984,
0.49951982498168945,
-0.7610626220703125,
-0.4148522615432739,
-0.5082826614379883,
-0.04093087464570999,
0.2494567334651947,
1.12981379032135,
-0.00124922429677099,
-0.25028008222579956,
-0.003982519265264273,
0.0684470385313034,
-0.30444300174713135,
-0.6360988616943359,
-0.46463876962661743,
-0.46952685713768005,
0.6226481795310974,
0.29913529753685,
0.5823336243629456,
0.7732425332069397,
0.287607878446579,
0.14488519728183746,
-0.05379922688007355,
0.3497709333896637,
-0.8924009799957275,
0.05001041665673256,
-0.3289356827735901,
-0.7462705969810486,
-0.21395285427570343,
-0.04032079875469208,
0.8081480264663696,
0.48745012283325195,
-0.5027770400047302,
-0.1423533409833908,
0.17823533713817596,
0.9607126116752625,
-1.1324325799942017,
0.3204350769519806,
-0.6161125898361206,
0.0699499249458313,
0.08976130932569504,
-0.39243653416633606,
-0.4721521735191345,
-0.573223888874054,
0.18101729452610016,
-0.6662936806678772,
0.13961412012577057,
-0.19498829543590546,
1.0610326528549194,
0.5928544998168945,
-0.1520945131778717,
-0.04015273228287697,
-0.8677454590797424,
1.1893959045410156,
-0.45094025135040283,
0.3427560031414032,
0.540982186794281,
0.26980531215667725,
-0.033964987844228745,
-0.1600026786327362,
-0.21579323709011078,
-0.3571609854698181,
-0.12116095423698425,
0.22457943856716156,
-0.14189936220645905,
0.17847344279289246,
0.01295233704149723,
0.3438522517681122,
-0.3230917751789093,
0.2156667411327362,
-0.016369419172406197,
-0.0421866811811924,
0.5980848670005798,
0.20848160982131958,
0.007132153958082199,
0.14743976294994354,
-0.3625006675720215,
-0.5809193253517151,
-0.676838755607605,
0.5512146353721619,
0.4875100553035736,
0.4074387848377228,
-0.14502790570259094,
0.3663483262062073,
-0.3738434612751007,
0.5104655623435974,
0.1617376208305359,
-0.05989910289645195,
0.17442142963409424,
-0.06401194632053375,
-0.15263059735298157,
-0.15182332694530487,
0.5361234545707703,
0.32590386271476746,
0.25170424580574036,
-0.12895894050598145,
-0.5185293555259705,
0.36020350456237793,
0.30533644556999207,
-0.8044453263282776,
-0.007930295541882515,
0.0670887678861618,
-0.5223650932312012,
-0.6944769024848938,
0.029702818021178246,
-0.47585567831993103,
-0.5692390203475952,
-0.0711246058344841,
0.1907791942358017,
0.07742180675268173,
-0.20497556030750275,
0.5488147139549255,
-0.13870765268802643,
-0.06337437778711319,
0.048841144889593124,
-1.4593534469604492,
0.45742103457450867,
0.5166276693344116,
0.5501990914344788,
-0.5722902417182922,
-0.15256914496421814,
-0.613429605960846,
0.27688854932785034,
-0.47026947140693665,
0.5784355401992798,
-0.6782212853431702,
-0.31993594765663147,
0.11924052983522415,
-0.0806238204240799,
-0.1411285698413849,
-0.5898767709732056,
0.4343625009059906,
-0.6840099096298218,
0.15152697265148163,
-0.22637516260147095,
-0.3897055387496948,
0.18411272764205933,
0.4174030125141144,
-0.6003457307815552,
0.8426611423492432,
0.009756268002092838,
-0.5719260573387146,
0.5522338151931763,
-0.7340052127838135,
-0.20371904969215393,
-0.18934892117977142,
-0.3288089632987976,
-0.573713481426239,
0.33329111337661743,
0.4098080098628998,
0.36738336086273193,
-0.07737862318754196,
0.33434492349624634,
-0.018490156158804893,
-0.5952396988868713,
0.28647541999816895,
-0.3776799440383911,
0.24997301399707794,
0.03671079874038696,
-0.4752078950405121,
0.41266754269599915,
-0.4787786304950714,
-0.11832879483699799,
0.22471213340759277,
-0.8548144698143005,
-0.5101285576820374,
0.1704806536436081,
-0.19226902723312378,
-0.16852618753910065,
0.30496224761009216,
-0.6886566281318665,
0.5333502292633057,
-0.8322889804840088,
0.334301620721817,
0.9588439464569092,
0.020899392664432526,
0.760994017124176,
-0.254258394241333,
0.6528931260108948,
-0.05598471686244011,
0.2346673458814621,
0.04867229238152504,
-0.21103623509407043,
-0.5559710264205933,
-0.41102907061576843,
0.44037118554115295,
0.5015659928321838,
-0.4056723117828369,
0.6048635244369507,
-0.28158602118492126,
-0.08275362849235535,
-0.5722086429595947,
-0.13546210527420044,
0.35142287611961365,
0.2663065493106842,
0.4479617178440094,
-0.2212301641702652,
-0.12302662432193756,
-0.8079596161842346,
-0.26740723848342896,
0.15109792351722717,
-0.13232773542404175,
0.48699724674224854,
0.24768729507923126,
-0.45671308040618896,
0.9849918484687805,
-0.8189554810523987,
-0.4024227261543274,
-0.3260202705860138,
-0.048616815358400345,
0.17305873334407806,
0.506341814994812,
0.2093685269355774,
-0.7001314163208008,
-0.3589896261692047,
-0.013615944422781467,
-0.29293397068977356,
0.32305973768234253,
-0.2934078276157379,
-0.05401954427361488,
0.3529294431209564,
0.1608121544122696,
-0.4064897894859314,
0.431385338306427,
0.31464099884033203,
-0.3066248297691345,
0.23272007703781128,
-0.5152283906936646,
-0.06325224041938782,
-0.5786905884742737,
-0.12718738615512848,
-0.17814479768276215,
-0.2663506865501404,
-0.29609957337379456,
-0.018060840666294098,
0.37122827768325806,
-0.22766973078250885,
-0.12141526490449905,
0.6522682905197144,
-0.42245930433273315,
0.04644162207841873,
-0.38327357172966003,
-0.27934029698371887,
-0.04607487469911575,
0.936517596244812,
0.41886231303215027,
0.6295342445373535,
0.5582289695739746,
-0.6257227063179016,
0.2181468904018402,
0.0859069675207138,
-0.07833991199731827,
0.2012358158826828,
-0.546656608581543,
-0.055003196001052856,
-0.3401077091693878,
0.36445021629333496,
-0.7928478121757507,
-0.176946759223938,
0.26823318004608154,
-0.4214211106300354,
0.4857840836048126,
-0.10273856669664383,
-0.1899772584438324,
0.08849325031042099,
-0.6778838634490967,
0.28579390048980713,
0.6634353399276733,
-0.6176008582115173,
0.2981726825237274,
0.37808290123939514,
0.07535465061664581,
-0.7885668277740479,
-0.5183506011962891,
-0.29653632640838623,
-0.22445890307426453,
-0.04870018735527992,
0.536980926990509,
-0.1820996254682541,
0.11679498106241226,
-0.10342662781476974,
-0.20110192894935608,
0.12800197303295135,
0.2368890345096588,
0.04507007449865341,
0.2587619423866272,
0.1690777689218521,
0.27671340107917786,
0.30515286326408386,
-0.3724050521850586,
-0.13516148924827576,
-0.47650274634361267,
0.663382351398468,
-0.06412285566329956,
-0.07873263955116272,
-0.45200371742248535,
0.2385428100824356,
0.12481915950775146,
-0.368147075176239,
0.7793196439743042,
0.37817391753196716,
-0.33602553606033325,
-0.3050852119922638,
-0.25061696767807007,
-0.615746796131134,
-0.5279924869537354,
0.4112676680088043,
-0.2538195252418518,
-0.9827771782875061,
0.039002709090709686,
-0.06240399181842804,
0.1299550086259842,
0.11744430661201477,
0.5023949146270752,
0.10492923855781555,
1.416964054107666,
1.0145564079284668,
-0.29374074935913086,
0.695978581905365,
-0.2917577922344208,
-0.1701260805130005,
-0.5393887758255005,
-0.1836642324924469,
-0.2894013822078705,
-0.3079155683517456,
-0.6758303642272949,
-0.20238374173641205,
0.2833596169948578,
0.07677694410085678,
-0.16864334046840668,
-0.06009674817323685,
-0.6312959790229797,
0.6370322108268738,
0.6344138383865356,
0.49677497148513794,
0.03766531124711037,
0.3413549065589905,
-0.15220533311367035,
-0.16505569219589233,
-0.5968151092529297,
-0.26606494188308716,
1.2174981832504272,
0.510733962059021,
1.0557644367218018,
0.005000563804060221,
1.1615134477615356,
0.3925533592700958,
0.18110007047653198,
-0.7887184023857117,
0.1468106508255005,
-0.1932297796010971,
-0.10174397379159927,
-0.8340667486190796,
-0.5242246985435486,
-1.2243064641952515,
0.2562698423862457,
-0.2561374306678772,
-0.6902788877487183,
0.5216673016548157,
0.3654436469078064,
-0.6276529431343079,
0.09217951446771622,
-0.6100808382034302,
0.7991825342178345,
-0.07304594665765762,
-0.2152405083179474,
-0.35261669754981995,
-0.6418846249580383,
0.08167611807584763,
0.30226701498031616,
0.13814562559127808,
-0.03263810649514198,
-0.3768763542175293,
0.6115158796310425,
-0.20141340792179108,
0.8655751347541809,
-0.2259845733642578,
-0.24933049082756042,
-0.21976515650749207,
-0.012300360947847366,
0.9797083735466003,
0.032755009829998016,
0.0704604908823967,
-0.28512316942214966,
-0.4724663496017456,
-0.4997260272502899,
-0.7734339237213135,
0.7491878271102905,
-0.9256925582885742,
-0.4486839771270752,
-0.293985515832901,
-0.778535783290863,
-0.4484706521034241,
0.05223255977034569,
0.26037663221359253,
0.2293221801519394,
0.034727491438388824,
-0.017397848889231682,
1.089003562927246,
-0.3563583195209503,
0.26149219274520874,
0.32466816902160645,
-0.022788219153881073,
-0.4817642867565155,
1.2557631731033325,
-0.2342846393585205,
0.41745510697364807,
0.7130581140518188,
0.6338342428207397,
-0.5354466438293457,
-0.3145027160644531,
-0.31611180305480957,
0.3705403804779053,
-0.5509587526321411,
0.10050681233406067,
-0.37197229266166687,
0.19560521841049194,
-0.4164051115512848,
-0.2805241644382477,
-0.454642653465271,
-0.308378130197525,
-0.3680143356323242,
-0.20213142037391663,
0.13237842917442322,
0.7473848462104797,
-0.26223164796829224,
0.21195325255393982,
-0.5403118133544922,
0.37926530838012695,
0.5439463257789612,
0.5806251764297485,
-0.10337528586387634,
-0.4612105190753937,
-0.30782535672187805,
0.09655032306909561,
-0.05882524326443672,
-0.7134104371070862,
0.4491313695907593,
0.019429698586463928,
0.6669573187828064,
0.4496632516384125,
0.24980708956718445,
0.3357577919960022,
-0.3163023591041565,
0.5149831175804138,
0.41399624943733215,
-0.6016265153884888,
0.44134047627449036,
-0.37784498929977417,
0.33880627155303955,
0.3698921203613281,
0.4146445393562317,
-0.3502732515335083,
-0.1598806083202362,
-0.558202862739563,
-0.7659926414489746,
0.792810320854187,
0.09968233853578568,
0.27958133816719055,
0.06429843604564667,
0.2520284652709961,
0.07561484724283218,
0.3968394994735718,
-0.8995985388755798,
-0.3947991132736206,
-0.2640349268913269,
-0.19855235517024994,
-0.23811867833137512,
-0.4509607255458832,
-0.27235183119773865,
-0.008439329452812672,
0.5755957961082458,
-0.1510048657655716,
0.1970859169960022,
0.010101976804435253,
-0.05231991782784462,
-0.28508487343788147,
0.5280523300170898,
0.8942158222198486,
0.4518841505050659,
-0.4984782934188843,
0.11329302936792374,
-0.15320469439029694,
-0.3614851236343384,
0.15867021679878235,
-0.06100023537874222,
-0.4357145130634308,
-0.22094063460826874,
-0.22425417602062225,
1.0380090475082397,
0.106943778693676,
-0.6575102210044861,
0.547362208366394,
-0.15093711018562317,
-0.061697568744421005,
-0.017292847856879234,
0.31985098123550415,
-0.013568618334829807,
0.17702746391296387,
0.3929557204246521,
0.0030138478614389896,
0.060789480805397034,
-0.4752315282821655,
0.10899308323860168,
0.5385249853134155,
-0.6221018433570862,
0.015535023994743824,
0.6363204717636108,
0.10320436954498291,
-0.18028120696544647,
0.22845301032066345,
-0.3396841883659363,
-0.47253966331481934,
0.3932223320007324,
0.5056906342506409,
0.8129206895828247,
-0.030664928257465363,
0.3554772734642029,
0.282301664352417,
0.34851011633872986,
-0.3130458891391754,
0.29875481128692627,
-0.3664276599884033,
-0.7706051468849182,
-0.2520950138568878,
-0.39331963658332825,
-0.3430890738964081,
0.10178106278181076,
-0.86740642786026,
0.04660281538963318,
-0.46868178248405457,
-0.22080521285533905,
-0.37691667675971985,
-0.09488857537508011,
-0.47170189023017883,
0.2031509280204773,
0.29250234365463257,
0.38457661867141724,
-0.8504734635353088,
0.7673310041427612,
0.5568305253982544,
-0.3694387376308441,
-0.6775694489479065,
0.16694653034210205,
-0.4232865571975708,
-0.7258902192115784,
0.6385191082954407,
-0.020705968141555786,
-0.21787568926811218,
0.16986805200576782,
-0.6351770162582397,
-0.8519625663757324,
0.8303240537643433,
0.4798908531665802,
-0.5411293506622314,
-0.056086067110300064,
0.11867871135473251,
0.4194457530975342,
-0.33773869276046753,
0.1903582066297531,
0.6238629817962646,
0.26906779408454895,
-0.24349626898765564,
-0.7505031228065491,
0.139692485332489,
0.13739457726478577,
0.2681104838848114,
0.4242696464061737,
-0.5583049654960632,
0.6946608424186707,
-0.3570239245891571,
-0.32395291328430176,
-0.18030083179473877,
0.5473878979682922,
0.6643969416618347,
-0.14860723912715912,
0.5982061624526978,
0.4027770757675171,
0.7209123373031616,
0.14999601244926453,
1.122383952140808,
0.09271381795406342,
0.656926691532135,
0.8403725624084473,
-0.1566278636455536,
0.7851656079292297,
0.6302857995033264,
-0.05580277368426323,
0.553609311580658,
0.7030695080757141,
0.17428071796894073,
1.152902364730835,
0.4282287061214447,
-0.04648459330201149,
-0.5476179122924805,
-0.2830045819282532,
-0.34333088994026184,
-0.14304344356060028,
0.2201671451330185,
-0.12017328292131424,
-0.3532288670539856,
0.04507648944854736,
-0.16418327391147614,
0.3643106520175934,
-0.4203035235404968,
0.5957478284835815,
-0.2730412781238556,
-0.6132528781890869,
0.9930636286735535,
0.21567757427692413,
1.0956355333328247,
-0.6327197551727295,
-0.23450304567813873,
-0.35613182187080383,
0.28778669238090515,
-0.1346474438905716,
-0.37974977493286133,
-0.08274909108877182,
-0.18963471055030823,
-0.4388921856880188,
-0.34991559386253357,
0.5882378816604614,
-0.6525517702102661,
-0.1685997098684311,
0.12428801506757736,
-0.0399409644305706,
0.009393473155796528,
-0.19629299640655518,
-0.6434453725814819,
-0.03872643783688545,
0.08529771864414215,
-0.39883142709732056,
0.5863327383995056,
-0.08735616505146027,
-0.23203861713409424,
0.7454941868782043,
0.654840350151062,
0.38230186700820923,
0.048495102673769,
0.15401825308799744,
0.7998932003974915,
-0.6842638850212097,
-1.1938204765319824,
-0.7571262121200562,
0.46066445112228394,
-0.04496760666370392,
-0.15966203808784485,
0.38053032755851746,
0.44871774315834045,
0.9836695194244385,
-0.35370153188705444,
0.817003607749939,
0.41908326745033264,
0.7202844619750977,
-0.4831603467464447,
0.6232507824897766,
-0.7015601396560669,
0.23032531142234802,
-0.07141963392496109,
-0.580541729927063,
-0.164483442902565,
0.4965571165084839,
-0.33283349871635437,
-0.08880257606506348,
0.6083999276161194,
0.7894502878189087,
0.07676426321268082,
-0.5127703547477722,
0.5467034578323364,
-0.2557010054588318,
0.07851678133010864,
0.7649664878845215,
0.8720476627349854,
-0.11519564688205719,
0.5635003447532654,
-0.3745158910751343,
-0.34178584814071655,
-0.1814231127500534,
-0.6237481236457825,
-0.887004554271698,
-0.3427402675151825,
-0.23364688456058502,
-0.15401104092597961,
0.24549983441829681,
0.9777482748031616,
0.6542649865150452,
-0.8832647204399109,
-0.4208250343799591,
-0.0998179093003273,
0.25292399525642395,
-0.512589693069458,
-0.25547170639038086,
0.5850664973258972,
-0.5363523364067078,
-0.6973510384559631,
0.6125125885009766,
0.30554866790771484,
0.04402599111199379,
-0.35533571243286133,
-0.499355673789978,
0.05026433616876602,
0.11865442246198654,
0.28445327281951904,
0.3680211305618286,
-0.6465726494789124,
-0.17349250614643097,
0.17362360656261444,
-0.34111809730529785,
0.04287252202630043,
1.010673999786377,
-0.7352461218833923,
0.319790780544281,
0.380880743265152,
0.8960727453231812,
0.502638578414917,
0.2485249638557434,
0.6512636542320251,
-1.0237222909927368,
0.24011315405368805,
0.1781553328037262,
0.1599595993757248,
0.12602689862251282,
-0.6353803277015686,
0.3402775824069977,
0.17719100415706635,
-0.39473333954811096,
-1.0056688785552979,
0.49084383249282837,
-0.7254117131233215,
-0.38238105177879333,
1.3323155641555786,
-0.09356686472892761,
-0.11621206253767014,
0.08550678938627243,
-0.10907066613435745,
0.21596018970012665,
-0.7890782356262207,
1.050513744354248,
0.23977027833461761,
-0.15598051249980927,
-0.05132847651839256,
-0.15270312130451202,
0.9274239540100098,
0.7198472023010254,
-0.7931658625602722,
0.14519691467285156,
0.4266809821128845,
0.29238173365592957,
-0.11138360947370529,
0.6460241079330444,
0.17149046063423157,
0.41149356961250305,
-0.4061362147331238,
0.21152722835540771,
-0.16910536587238312,
-0.4489445090293884,
-0.8308073878288269,
0.023050714284181595,
0.2578815221786499,
-0.6429315209388733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10215v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10215v1
|
DevBench: A multimodal developmental benchmark for language learning
| 2024-06-14T17:49:41 | 2024-06-14T17:49:41 |
Alvin Wei Ming Tan, Sunny Yu, Bria Long, Wanjing Anya Ma, Tonya Murray, Rebecca D. Silverman, Jason D. Yeatman, Michael C. Frank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
How (dis)similar are the learning trajectories of vision-language models and
children? Recent modeling work has attempted to understand the gap between
models' and humans' data efficiency by constructing models trained on less
data, especially multimodal naturalistic data. However, such models are often
evaluated on adult-level benchmarks, with limited breadth in language abilities
tested, and without direct comparison to behavioral data. We introduce
DevBench, a multimodal benchmark comprising seven language evaluation tasks
spanning the domains of lexical, syntactic, and semantic ability, with
behavioral data from both children and adults. We evaluate a set of
vision-language models on these tasks, comparing models and humans not only on
accuracy but on their response patterns. Across tasks, models exhibit variation
in their closeness to human response patterns, and models that perform better
on a task also more closely resemble human behavioral responses. We also
examine the developmental trajectory of OpenCLIP over training, finding that
greater training results in closer approximations to adult response patterns.
DevBench thus provides a benchmark for comparing models to human language
development. These comparisons highlight ways in which model and human language
learning processes diverge, providing insight into entry points for improving
language models.
|
[
-0.46623679995536804,
-0.5322814583778381,
0.16007396578788757,
0.15774692595005035,
0.10107377171516418,
0.4272499680519104,
-0.5098932385444641,
-0.4964250922203064,
-0.18019016087055206,
0.21243420243263245,
-0.6580724120140076,
-0.4931248724460602,
-0.3266575336456299,
-0.15423989295959473,
-0.3463435471057892,
0.5207648277282715,
-0.04956426844000816,
0.005687288474291563,
-0.40731242299079895,
-0.07991854846477509,
-0.370890349149704,
-0.09382056444883347,
-0.4938209354877472,
-0.1763470321893692,
0.43070748448371887,
0.46116718649864197,
0.4631982147693634,
0.7262104153633118,
0.5573288202285767,
0.25532034039497375,
-0.01742536947131157,
-0.21393151581287384,
-0.4179717004299164,
0.3328136205673218,
-0.3169018030166626,
-0.3069746196269989,
-0.33478477597236633,
0.08644510060548782,
0.57065349817276,
1.1266286373138428,
-0.2470773160457611,
0.37679582834243774,
0.18435922265052795,
0.7766175270080566,
-0.8586739897727966,
0.2528458535671234,
-0.22245222330093384,
0.11095567047595978,
-0.39322200417518616,
0.3377979099750519,
-0.4529123604297638,
-0.43903806805610657,
0.1370846927165985,
-0.26327136158943176,
0.6185449957847595,
-0.23647671937942505,
0.48782429099082947,
-0.1531798392534256,
-0.47772416472435,
-0.05908896401524544,
-0.6332570910453796,
0.7489780783653259,
-0.5120882391929626,
0.8883572816848755,
0.3105090856552124,
0.2846772372722626,
0.03748350962996483,
-0.6502447724342346,
-0.5125552415847778,
-0.5805239677429199,
0.2821040451526642,
0.01006967294961214,
0.04124826565384865,
0.08434772491455078,
0.28903067111968994,
0.11243272572755814,
-0.8778676390647888,
0.017740799114108086,
-0.6614821553230286,
-0.2988916337490082,
0.4784000515937805,
0.2701813578605652,
0.2003161758184433,
-0.029890399426221848,
-0.44116976857185364,
-0.8108027577400208,
-0.5239447951316833,
0.3014299273490906,
0.5155136585235596,
0.4482538104057312,
-0.28440091013908386,
0.46239644289016724,
-0.358541876077652,
0.9069223999977112,
-0.20589172840118408,
-0.2879544198513031,
0.471558541059494,
-0.46765467524528503,
0.4411846697330475,
-0.3166961371898651,
0.49632948637008667,
0.5202022790908813,
0.4278113842010498,
-0.42003104090690613,
-0.19081860780715942,
0.6149868369102478,
0.353343665599823,
-0.6032078266143799,
-0.4245620369911194,
-0.2566337585449219,
-0.4676256775856018,
-0.1561894565820694,
0.07499457895755768,
-1.4085263013839722,
-0.4893531799316406,
-0.224720761179924,
-0.07066995650529861,
-0.32869815826416016,
-0.47992104291915894,
-0.06823040544986725,
-0.15689192712306976,
0.34726592898368835,
0.07484587281942368,
-1.0755436420440674,
0.7470285296440125,
0.6264508366584778,
0.7739059329032898,
-0.4193057119846344,
-0.6222345232963562,
-0.42778605222702026,
-0.20318932831287384,
-0.507872462272644,
0.7723677754402161,
-0.7806761264801025,
-0.41256779432296753,
-0.19062018394470215,
-0.30635756254196167,
-0.2218250334262848,
-0.7908914685249329,
0.28278690576553345,
-0.30657005310058594,
-0.0700618177652359,
0.01146185863763094,
-0.17176194489002228,
-0.30429041385650635,
0.24266549944877625,
-0.6491667032241821,
0.9019091725349426,
0.29174748063087463,
-0.5954391956329346,
0.7748181223869324,
-0.5982226729393005,
-0.43202003836631775,
-0.18782809376716614,
-0.1026359274983406,
-0.08809205889701843,
0.36555323004722595,
-0.0653102770447731,
0.1036965548992157,
-0.30917245149612427,
0.1520734429359436,
-0.6211675405502319,
-0.035567883402109146,
-0.02567722089588642,
-0.466243714094162,
0.5084775686264038,
0.066096730530262,
-0.3084971308708191,
0.2237931489944458,
-1.0471217632293701,
0.4541734457015991,
0.08357901126146317,
-0.5575165152549744,
-0.3299504518508911,
0.05055951699614525,
0.059241119772195816,
0.42657846212387085,
0.08576195687055588,
-0.6864371299743652,
0.13847725093364716,
-0.28545811772346497,
0.3723215162754059,
0.6439751386642456,
-0.2408706098794937,
0.30096420645713806,
-0.1847974956035614,
0.6851503849029541,
-0.022654475644230843,
0.32644036412239075,
-0.1759534776210785,
-0.37819626927375793,
-0.6480126976966858,
-0.09802701324224472,
0.39526769518852234,
0.14672145247459412,
-0.3973093032836914,
-0.1511557698249817,
-0.4029434621334076,
-0.526913583278656,
-0.5830835700035095,
0.2998478412628174,
0.7077928185462952,
0.26640769839286804,
0.1867116242647171,
-1.175865888595581,
-0.4423448145389557,
-0.8869214057922363,
-0.22815155982971191,
-0.2973855435848236,
0.09914617240428925,
0.15400497615337372,
0.4249468743801117,
0.018332885578274727,
0.7665556073188782,
-0.2823776304721832,
-0.05087118223309517,
-0.23224444687366486,
0.2474079728126526,
-0.23139752447605133,
0.37720987200737,
0.5991572141647339,
-0.6675301194190979,
-0.36676281690597534,
-0.15343983471393585,
-0.3639827072620392,
-0.016624953597784042,
0.2607254981994629,
0.004742924589663744,
-0.0017320998013019562,
0.3808556795120239,
-0.36335718631744385,
0.45677807927131653,
0.8380712270736694,
-0.5433012247085571,
0.5980471968650818,
-0.10804244130849838,
0.05396214500069618,
-0.5975379347801208,
0.2767332196235657,
-0.281934529542923,
-0.09298426657915115,
-0.6896973848342896,
0.22108103334903717,
0.18588873744010925,
-0.1515183448791504,
-0.4322778284549713,
0.4922560155391693,
-0.4006102681159973,
-0.647466778755188,
-0.011938557960093021,
0.4311489164829254,
0.020847342908382416,
0.5506752133369446,
-0.14482396841049194,
0.9922603964805603,
0.4783938527107239,
-0.46465155482292175,
0.3564424216747284,
0.018885409459471703,
-0.4822303056716919,
0.5265567898750305,
-0.581325888633728,
0.31414899230003357,
-0.015476491302251816,
-0.22890187799930573,
-1.0701889991760254,
-0.1414620727300644,
-0.016259053722023964,
-0.31540238857269287,
0.1889793574810028,
0.22325465083122253,
-0.5654929280281067,
-0.38073965907096863,
-0.5168042182922363,
0.395728200674057,
0.3983404338359833,
-0.3523682653903961,
0.5113122463226318,
0.26230189204216003,
-0.24957284331321716,
-0.4143369197845459,
-0.4974639117717743,
-0.05681825429201126,
0.1173175498843193,
-0.6388704776763916,
0.347889244556427,
-0.1411266028881073,
-0.34257492423057556,
-0.0857466459274292,
-0.2407640963792801,
-0.3195880949497223,
0.15701933205127716,
0.1956653743982315,
-0.008246063254773617,
-0.3970215916633606,
0.24135780334472656,
-0.31564170122146606,
-0.09676867723464966,
0.04140777513384819,
0.17287644743919373,
0.7604749798774719,
-0.29979076981544495,
-0.4360789358615875,
0.11514568328857422,
0.021632423624396324,
0.5764096975326538,
-0.4900621771812439,
0.45588788390159607,
0.3316001892089844,
-0.09520074725151062,
-0.1425078958272934,
-0.3549189269542694,
-0.3370424807071686,
-0.38554614782333374,
0.3587913513183594,
-0.5271890759468079,
-0.3481287956237793,
0.4975760877132416,
-0.06631411612033844,
0.09965459257364273,
0.15894201397895813,
0.4598168730735779,
0.21367625892162323,
1.0132853984832764,
0.9123252034187317,
0.2822304964065552,
0.5810814499855042,
-0.21699051558971405,
-0.2369421124458313,
-0.9268982410430908,
-0.3477781116962433,
-0.347232460975647,
-0.4434397220611572,
-0.3620968759059906,
-0.4413813352584839,
-0.0019556055776774883,
0.1279626041650772,
-0.1714085191488266,
0.3477770984172821,
-0.17440584301948547,
0.40186095237731934,
0.6019699573516846,
0.028021609410643578,
0.5152310132980347,
-0.12098444998264313,
-0.5068122744560242,
-0.2644834816455841,
-0.6864743828773499,
-0.37115997076034546,
1.146689534187317,
0.10097039490938187,
0.9057938456535339,
0.27577316761016846,
0.3931250274181366,
0.13663271069526672,
0.4545654356479645,
-0.3843719959259033,
0.5998274087905884,
-0.16712668538093567,
-0.803239107131958,
0.07072105258703232,
-0.2561822235584259,
-1.0079736709594727,
0.6486842036247253,
-0.10979854315519333,
-0.7883763909339905,
0.41661882400512695,
0.05157070606946945,
-0.06705905497074127,
0.175190269947052,
-0.8764305710792542,
1.251227855682373,
-0.4354782998561859,
-0.6405187249183655,
-0.49353107810020447,
-0.7164257168769836,
0.3621133863925934,
-0.02724606730043888,
0.20517872273921967,
-0.3442133367061615,
-0.15984810888767242,
0.7553799152374268,
-0.061756085604429245,
1.036992073059082,
-0.19789545238018036,
0.0517616830766201,
0.1750044822692871,
0.3944637179374695,
-0.10797542333602905,
-0.32676106691360474,
0.05463503673672676,
-0.16830496490001678,
-0.06412059813737869,
-0.32402151823043823,
-0.4084872305393219,
0.6441973447799683,
-0.624214231967926,
-0.3317318856716156,
-0.3582233190536499,
-0.43064436316490173,
-0.48610788583755493,
0.27487778663635254,
-0.1964576244354248,
0.5268044471740723,
-0.36502668261528015,
0.14826984703540802,
0.2880992591381073,
-0.1314225196838379,
0.43309879302978516,
0.6635555028915405,
-0.4778934121131897,
-0.20964649319648743,
0.7918301224708557,
-0.24998688697814941,
0.7010871767997742,
0.06661900877952576,
0.19308413565158844,
-0.23991885781288147,
-0.444257915019989,
-0.35617366433143616,
0.15895958244800568,
-0.8974930047988892,
0.008192792534828186,
-0.26179173588752747,
0.14469046890735626,
-0.14802494645118713,
0.14829446375370026,
-0.6370783448219299,
-0.2909703552722931,
0.28569889068603516,
0.016403188928961754,
0.1606959104537964,
0.7939813137054443,
-0.13579793274402618,
0.005073984153568745,
-0.6132153868675232,
0.33430758118629456,
0.2805121839046478,
0.7614119052886963,
0.35810500383377075,
-0.2287423014640808,
-0.04737168923020363,
0.19022303819656372,
-0.6379870176315308,
-0.6414508819580078,
0.13117317855358124,
0.50589919090271,
0.4747907519340515,
0.3712919056415558,
-0.15975917875766754,
0.7900896668434143,
-0.3478536009788513,
0.6646326780319214,
0.19081445038318634,
-0.8667201995849609,
0.5527663230895996,
-0.1484515368938446,
0.3852980434894562,
0.7245894074440002,
-0.01932380348443985,
-0.546026349067688,
-0.21783661842346191,
-0.5318745374679565,
-0.6932929754257202,
0.7123984098434448,
-0.12231101095676422,
0.04195962846279144,
0.2082279622554779,
-0.02219783142209053,
0.34720122814178467,
0.4063042104244232,
-0.6306307315826416,
0.22074396908283234,
-0.12921006977558136,
-0.19627490639686584,
-0.26891466975212097,
0.14781604707241058,
-0.10431157052516937,
-0.18276579678058624,
-0.07555019110441208,
-0.21719075739383698,
0.11445138603448868,
-0.2171805202960968,
-0.32480379939079285,
-0.15846410393714905,
0.2852414548397064,
0.7369794249534607,
0.9099130034446716,
-0.024875815957784653,
0.22951601445674896,
0.03401074558496475,
-0.6402217149734497,
0.1263672560453415,
-0.06790351122617722,
0.19368301331996918,
-0.2475123554468155,
0.8400951027870178,
0.8108624815940857,
0.4883803427219391,
-1.2342063188552856,
0.5661461353302002,
-0.0740603655576706,
-0.03756743296980858,
0.006007601507008076,
0.20933476090431213,
0.0789538025856018,
0.3502177596092224,
-0.09554252028465271,
0.3072393238544464,
0.03375941514968872,
-0.7498283982276917,
0.20257942378520966,
0.10495792329311371,
-0.3744286298751831,
-0.6625402569770813,
0.7152894735336304,
0.24654008448123932,
-0.30187052488327026,
0.9158941507339478,
-0.10726198554039001,
-0.2915312945842743,
0.6971328258514404,
0.4287816286087036,
0.8500351905822754,
-0.1734490990638733,
0.36236098408699036,
0.1740473508834839,
0.3337410092353821,
0.026885999366641045,
0.4253101348876953,
-0.29056745767593384,
-0.612767219543457,
-0.30205807089805603,
-0.5645013451576233,
-0.325636088848114,
-0.1890479326248169,
-0.7515178918838501,
0.002438698895275593,
-0.5109557509422302,
-0.27808013558387756,
0.04741518944501877,
-0.28346601128578186,
-0.9316760301589966,
-0.010218407958745956,
0.16888834536075592,
0.8958372473716736,
-0.6867709755897522,
0.6990070939064026,
0.7455391883850098,
-0.5317545533180237,
-0.45521125197410583,
0.1709105521440506,
-0.15008299052715302,
-0.7754995226860046,
1.0630772113800049,
0.2628655731678009,
-0.4273679852485657,
-0.00897600781172514,
-0.14627277851104736,
-0.839018702507019,
0.8141785860061646,
0.3194315731525421,
-0.512594997882843,
-0.12858864665031433,
-0.03508538752794266,
0.829170823097229,
-0.3622595965862274,
0.16868892312049866,
0.6032072901725769,
0.3565653860569,
-0.17421677708625793,
-1.0259953737258911,
-0.13602116703987122,
-0.1926654577255249,
0.21071147918701172,
0.29154664278030396,
-0.5693718194961548,
0.9439929723739624,
-0.6357684135437012,
-0.4548506438732147,
0.0030896547250449657,
0.21935799717903137,
0.057758014649152756,
0.15167264640331268,
0.5206130146980286,
0.46828871965408325,
0.22866792976856232,
-0.12239540368318558,
0.9495545029640198,
-0.4014882445335388,
0.33860036730766296,
0.9157254695892334,
-0.40926432609558105,
1.1923106908798218,
0.4721318781375885,
-0.4421647787094116,
0.6646032929420471,
0.5086825489997864,
0.1325230598449707,
0.8026934266090393,
0.2521754801273346,
0.04799465462565422,
-0.018328679725527763,
-0.0167064405977726,
-0.0734935998916626,
0.5249150991439819,
0.3685440719127655,
-0.04857547953724861,
-0.49477165937423706,
0.34205353260040283,
-0.320374459028244,
0.3144710659980774,
-0.0472012460231781,
0.8395901322364807,
-0.07588446140289307,
-0.7961398363113403,
0.7412484288215637,
0.06052151694893837,
0.48836758732795715,
-0.6464908123016357,
0.09652341157197952,
-0.23876288533210754,
0.5501551628112793,
0.06795255094766617,
-0.8728036284446716,
0.1857166886329651,
-0.005244923755526543,
-0.15722787380218506,
-0.030835991725325584,
0.4312496781349182,
-0.482165664434433,
-0.2031228393316269,
0.633471667766571,
0.6509042382240295,
-0.10467765480279922,
0.3386744558811188,
-0.7418989539146423,
0.32368844747543335,
-0.20883603394031525,
-0.3310353755950928,
0.26779210567474365,
-0.11643086373806,
-0.18700136244297028,
0.9521756768226624,
0.5050774812698364,
0.13232004642486572,
0.5433318018913269,
0.1848859041929245,
0.7530536651611328,
-0.602491557598114,
-0.23677031695842743,
-0.7204188704490662,
0.2995746433734894,
-0.04866494983434677,
-0.677727997303009,
0.5404839515686035,
0.4651886224746704,
1.2465986013412476,
-0.26716551184654236,
0.5297248959541321,
-0.25433170795440674,
0.6088659763336182,
-0.357333242893219,
0.15779337286949158,
-0.4718267619609833,
-0.1208777129650116,
-0.07905618846416473,
-1.1201236248016357,
-0.2315271943807602,
0.6929247975349426,
-0.33308857679367065,
0.4524933695793152,
0.8324891328811646,
0.7028654217720032,
-0.27800092101097107,
-0.10500868409872055,
0.22468909621238708,
0.034973252564668655,
0.24350732564926147,
0.5275718569755554,
0.8158180713653564,
-0.06538205593824387,
0.42786768078804016,
-0.5229232311248779,
-0.15811388194561005,
-0.18547631800174713,
-0.5138527154922485,
-0.9168206453323364,
-0.5192952156066895,
-0.033051345497369766,
0.0828830897808075,
0.34666046500205994,
0.759358286857605,
0.7622207999229431,
-0.6940683722496033,
-0.6358469128608704,
-0.23643553256988525,
-0.2362957000732422,
-0.6136975884437561,
-0.22898733615875244,
0.15672937035560608,
-0.3089984953403473,
-0.583710253238678,
0.49568337202072144,
0.1695273071527481,
-0.005322249140590429,
-0.7041457295417786,
0.0493110753595829,
-0.07941464334726334,
-0.22119000554084778,
0.4714435935020447,
0.3614611327648163,
-0.8388775587081909,
-0.3002549409866333,
0.02628711424767971,
-0.11600687354803085,
0.09904611855745316,
0.933738112449646,
-0.9309677481651306,
1.0163824558258057,
0.5292379260063171,
0.385495662689209,
0.5676879286766052,
-0.10225585848093033,
0.6932342052459717,
-0.8044801354408264,
0.35572803020477295,
0.21788015961647034,
0.02999359741806984,
0.5366612672805786,
0.4812103807926178,
0.6773908734321594,
0.26593878865242004,
-0.17510758340358734,
-0.8116572499275208,
0.4240165650844574,
-0.5294118523597717,
-0.1157456710934639,
0.6351807117462158,
-0.11215607076883316,
-0.12830877304077148,
-0.0018612954299896955,
-0.06475995481014252,
-0.05251263827085495,
-0.33874407410621643,
0.7912709712982178,
0.7482815384864807,
-0.15333746373653412,
-0.2965826392173767,
-0.796716570854187,
0.2489941269159317,
0.19711002707481384,
-0.6965269446372986,
0.32826483249664307,
0.27945923805236816,
0.25537240505218506,
0.31708893179893494,
0.31544041633605957,
-0.1723666787147522,
0.4871993064880371,
0.49720802903175354,
0.4324154555797577,
0.11676692962646484,
-0.5826057195663452,
-0.21991054713726044,
0.17022743821144104,
0.43355032801628113,
-0.19359438121318817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10209v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10209v1
|
Be like a Goldfish, Don't Memorize! Mitigating Memorization in Generative LLMs
| 2024-06-14T17:44:22 | 2024-06-14T17:44:22 |
Abhimanyu Hans, Yuxin Wen, Neel Jain, John Kirchenbauer, Hamid Kazemi, Prajwal Singhania, Siddharth Singh, Gowthami Somepalli, Jonas Geiping, Abhinav Bhatele, Tom Goldstein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models can memorize and repeat their training data, causing
privacy and copyright risks. To mitigate memorization, we introduce a subtle
modification to the next-token training objective that we call the goldfish
loss. During training, a randomly sampled subset of tokens are excluded from
the loss computation. These dropped tokens are not memorized by the model,
which prevents verbatim reproduction of a complete chain of tokens from the
training set. We run extensive experiments training billion-scale Llama-2
models, both pre-trained and trained from scratch, and demonstrate significant
reductions in extractable memorization with little to no impact on downstream
benchmarks.
|
[
-0.12134218961000443,
-0.6611559391021729,
0.2913545072078705,
-0.07116575539112091,
-0.5136915445327759,
0.14922647178173065,
-0.16579817235469818,
-0.22535449266433716,
0.07230361551046371,
0.8287909626960754,
-0.7837930917739868,
-0.43480193614959717,
-0.614700436592102,
-0.043668583035469055,
-0.5594317317008972,
1.4021868705749512,
-0.03970163315534592,
-0.0545339360833168,
-0.27775588631629944,
-0.14943304657936096,
-0.28071895241737366,
-0.7098796367645264,
-0.904416024684906,
-0.5361477732658386,
0.5298717021942139,
0.29980534315109253,
0.47980889678001404,
0.7586695551872253,
0.45502808690071106,
0.24816150963306427,
-0.44946280121803284,
0.21722960472106934,
-0.9312412142753601,
-0.06066004931926727,
-0.05758720636367798,
-1.2890347242355347,
-0.36836695671081543,
0.04694485664367676,
0.5741395354270935,
0.6603394746780396,
-0.14499901235103607,
0.2723684310913086,
-0.22223787009716034,
0.7580193281173706,
-0.712742805480957,
0.19390790164470673,
-0.9991499781608582,
0.4799584448337555,
-0.32117176055908203,
-0.5882299542427063,
-0.373019278049469,
-0.1319294571876526,
-0.10781171917915344,
-0.7392277717590332,
0.4533126950263977,
-0.028094612061977386,
0.8327731490135193,
0.32394716143608093,
0.018116513267159462,
-0.11114554107189178,
-0.6950476765632629,
0.8383563160896301,
-0.6012437343597412,
-0.006719900760799646,
0.7932871580123901,
-0.02458067424595356,
-0.023770593106746674,
-0.7005135416984558,
-0.650142252445221,
0.030041897669434547,
0.16024529933929443,
0.10139907151460648,
-0.1326783150434494,
0.19378462433815002,
0.20269957184791565,
0.32674071192741394,
-0.6683151125907898,
0.01311972364783287,
-0.5444126725196838,
-0.3235372304916382,
0.521877110004425,
0.1178906112909317,
0.36914297938346863,
0.2854454815387726,
-0.5134169459342957,
-0.16857147216796875,
-1.1562161445617676,
-0.3028537631034851,
0.45515790581703186,
0.20770031213760376,
0.09210391342639923,
0.5868796110153198,
0.28851184248924255,
0.12365603446960449,
-0.00998803973197937,
-0.31888189911842346,
0.48820433020591736,
0.11651979386806488,
-0.36142024397850037,
0.12826895713806152,
0.381373792886734,
0.4050661027431488,
0.6024011373519897,
-0.4660108685493469,
-0.25663381814956665,
0.22401884198188782,
0.11033762246370316,
-0.33971020579338074,
-0.3875804543495178,
0.07248861342668533,
-0.6260479092597961,
-0.23580223321914673,
-0.26914462447166443,
-0.31477880477905273,
-0.10306131094694138,
-0.22241568565368652,
0.7547415494918823,
-0.38450753688812256,
0.017143553122878075,
-0.029103249311447144,
-0.5058659911155701,
0.03400350362062454,
0.043307773768901825,
-1.2245391607284546,
0.6178562045097351,
0.9208517670631409,
0.9002685546875,
0.014767004176974297,
-0.6270158290863037,
-0.38164183497428894,
0.7037367224693298,
-0.4887832999229431,
0.7404777407646179,
-0.4667834937572479,
-0.7908482551574707,
-0.32156845927238464,
0.017461443319916725,
-0.3991682231426239,
-0.9439840316772461,
-0.037788357585668564,
-0.6326503753662109,
-0.08044465631246567,
-0.39462342858314514,
-0.7287084460258484,
-0.4661993086338043,
0.23224827647209167,
-0.5940470695495605,
0.5400682687759399,
0.08092252910137177,
-0.7126370072364807,
0.3298059403896332,
-0.2405788153409958,
-0.37930193543434143,
0.006938534323126078,
0.01173696294426918,
-0.5738009214401245,
0.19531530141830444,
-0.09701545536518097,
0.1441660374403,
0.24122293293476105,
-0.23444312810897827,
-0.35789644718170166,
-0.7877718210220337,
0.2967033088207245,
-0.3243403732776642,
0.4676874279975891,
0.18816769123077393,
-0.34128373861312866,
-0.06424650549888611,
-0.5842958092689514,
-0.13474677503108978,
0.26967984437942505,
-0.5941489934921265,
-0.5223039984703064,
0.10548266023397446,
-0.13231146335601807,
0.029701482504606247,
0.09184428304433823,
-0.2746036946773529,
0.25462013483047485,
-0.4375990331172943,
0.6478599905967712,
0.964816689491272,
0.19988615810871124,
0.5008770227432251,
-0.8233188390731812,
0.5694413185119629,
0.20663906633853912,
0.24666443467140198,
-0.14978808164596558,
-0.23448345065116882,
-0.9868190884590149,
-0.29134222865104675,
0.08826293796300888,
0.7397432923316956,
-0.47632232308387756,
-0.05317488685250282,
-0.42038556933403015,
-0.2962789833545685,
-0.42736348509788513,
0.6768653988838196,
0.6379772424697876,
0.24356573820114136,
0.1503530591726303,
-0.6353809237480164,
-0.6527611613273621,
-0.6802575588226318,
-0.38813596963882446,
-0.14924809336662292,
0.03367219492793083,
0.05209243670105934,
0.6652209758758545,
-0.22413063049316406,
0.6474074125289917,
-0.2651117146015167,
-0.5500005483627319,
-0.37423333525657654,
0.007631049957126379,
-0.2179170399904251,
0.6491152048110962,
0.4480034112930298,
-0.9498538970947266,
-0.09540499001741409,
-0.23399534821510315,
-0.5925939083099365,
0.1712668240070343,
-0.32138919830322266,
0.07210283726453781,
0.37627702951431274,
0.816498875617981,
-1.0090020895004272,
0.5047938227653503,
0.45304203033447266,
-0.06433019042015076,
-0.014746771194040775,
-0.3770442008972168,
-0.43526652455329895,
-0.7939044237136841,
0.1316598355770111,
-0.6510496139526367,
-0.0010275274980813265,
-0.4128163158893585,
-0.06782029569149017,
0.0727081447839737,
-0.033904582262039185,
-0.4338234066963196,
0.37931564450263977,
-0.22608815133571625,
-0.24540846049785614,
-0.14889879524707794,
-0.0013281982392072678,
0.07322628051042557,
0.5686511397361755,
0.010187343694269657,
1.0310814380645752,
0.1963840126991272,
-0.8177275061607361,
-0.2624417841434479,
0.5652614831924438,
-0.1494610458612442,
0.38275155425071716,
-0.6375128626823425,
0.19063004851341248,
-0.5406346321105957,
0.32285282015800476,
-0.9059139490127563,
0.07418493926525116,
0.22629189491271973,
-0.4693446159362793,
0.581604540348053,
-0.1811649650335312,
-0.547934889793396,
-0.21988077461719513,
-0.7141494154930115,
0.30231353640556335,
0.6435531973838806,
-0.6241687536239624,
0.263074666261673,
0.29791590571403503,
-0.29428741335868835,
-0.6094732284545898,
-1.3323947191238403,
0.1502443104982376,
-0.5875934362411499,
-0.12889230251312256,
0.41637730598449707,
-0.2374868541955948,
-0.044380541890859604,
-0.01500605046749115,
-0.12225721031427383,
0.13041947782039642,
0.27288010716438293,
0.5030145645141602,
0.22351907193660736,
0.09122323244810104,
0.3918466567993164,
-0.00955421756953001,
-0.3389839828014374,
-0.0102752186357975,
-0.45485416054725647,
0.8253414034843445,
0.001792376977391541,
-0.42982250452041626,
-0.5365137457847595,
0.2993834614753723,
0.5357113480567932,
-0.36097273230552673,
0.8095468282699585,
0.40478938817977905,
-0.1492234617471695,
-0.3098537027835846,
-0.5395854711532593,
-0.035426896065473557,
-0.512590765953064,
0.47099247574806213,
-0.06456255167722702,
-0.7345471978187561,
0.7182539701461792,
-0.0070334188640117645,
0.23101478815078735,
0.35741952061653137,
0.32447537779808044,
-0.29457417130470276,
0.774105429649353,
0.6746645569801331,
-0.27898046374320984,
0.5971136689186096,
-0.586081862449646,
0.07119398564100266,
-0.9508296847343445,
-0.5304189324378967,
-0.13333484530448914,
-0.4066236913204193,
-0.45032215118408203,
-0.3513587713241577,
0.138362318277359,
0.197490394115448,
-0.3350703716278076,
0.05642933025956154,
-0.1945449411869049,
0.7359724640846252,
0.5133444666862488,
0.07735428959131241,
0.3403134346008301,
0.38009750843048096,
0.17234329879283905,
0.0013261354761198163,
-0.7192478179931641,
-0.657378613948822,
1.5068325996398926,
0.26257362961769104,
0.8955112099647522,
0.016282232478260994,
1.2488094568252563,
0.35995668172836304,
0.39363396167755127,
-0.5775889754295349,
0.6064326763153076,
-0.33879485726356506,
-0.6595659255981445,
-0.2275998592376709,
-0.6857898831367493,
-1.0201464891433716,
0.16841153800487518,
0.22029320895671844,
-0.7391353845596313,
-0.09930205345153809,
0.38707420229911804,
-0.37887921929359436,
0.7424706816673279,
-0.6177138090133667,
0.5252019762992859,
-0.09686945378780365,
-0.04541381821036339,
-0.15480610728263855,
-0.48009398579597473,
0.3145174980163574,
-0.2265048623085022,
0.3808371126651764,
-0.022508719936013222,
-0.4171178936958313,
0.8195713758468628,
-0.5245222449302673,
1.042279601097107,
-0.09749602526426315,
0.03975679725408554,
0.5818109512329102,
0.12473197281360626,
0.492561399936676,
-0.2232116460800171,
0.24346685409545898,
0.013547493144869804,
-0.16556639969348907,
-0.502438485622406,
-0.21960791945457458,
0.5912623405456543,
-0.9527992606163025,
-0.310529887676239,
-0.09330974519252777,
-0.5631663799285889,
0.09006284922361374,
-0.07450003921985626,
0.5608190894126892,
-0.006637350656092167,
-0.03571806102991104,
-0.22319528460502625,
0.8526447415351868,
-0.12126628309488297,
0.6947898268699646,
0.20706558227539062,
0.17789635062217712,
-0.6121543049812317,
1.2153558731079102,
0.5605087280273438,
0.4992782473564148,
0.19952337443828583,
-0.11756857484579086,
-0.18265053629875183,
-0.7053378820419312,
-0.14165671169757843,
0.4915843904018402,
-1.0774319171905518,
-0.1368696093559265,
-0.5323968529701233,
-0.04321679100394249,
-0.18893121182918549,
-0.09395845979452133,
-0.30956581234931946,
-0.7571880221366882,
-0.64567631483078,
-0.3904803991317749,
0.40655383467674255,
0.6994048953056335,
-0.3067851960659027,
0.682015597820282,
-0.9319444298744202,
0.16601219773292542,
0.34617146849632263,
0.37875252962112427,
0.2413891851902008,
-0.7415547370910645,
0.10177849978208542,
-0.19598865509033203,
-0.41338011622428894,
-0.47671833634376526,
0.6019654870033264,
0.6870750784873962,
0.6635305881500244,
0.5502268075942993,
-0.2145043909549713,
0.8454521298408508,
-0.41238561272621155,
0.7746533751487732,
0.12749935686588287,
-0.9955176115036011,
0.3918101191520691,
-0.280697226524353,
0.30916497111320496,
0.7146748304367065,
-0.05078575760126114,
-0.37126192450523376,
-0.2803967595100403,
-0.8199395537376404,
-1.1232932806015015,
0.6510002613067627,
0.14293606579303741,
0.6700252294540405,
-0.2599901258945465,
0.725090503692627,
0.0857853963971138,
0.5591917634010315,
-0.7824227809906006,
-0.25440114736557007,
-0.1006019338965416,
-0.14216288924217224,
-0.4125196635723114,
-0.5999704599380493,
-0.21221515536308289,
-0.1404399871826172,
0.7702443599700928,
0.2589970529079437,
0.06392689794301987,
-0.020271873101592064,
-0.402164489030838,
-0.2770967185497284,
-0.06517566740512848,
0.7540401220321655,
0.33353090286254883,
-0.057710323482751846,
0.2961743175983429,
0.5151433348655701,
-0.7696318030357361,
0.14542998373508453,
-0.30774828791618347,
-0.44891616702079773,
0.062487952411174774,
0.5201814770698547,
0.6033911108970642,
0.4711451530456543,
-0.8700515031814575,
0.4191826581954956,
0.09994211047887802,
-0.541471004486084,
-0.6008435487747192,
0.2664521336555481,
0.31011906266212463,
0.11449558287858963,
0.2401455044746399,
0.12433315068483353,
-0.14211659133434296,
-0.5909584760665894,
0.1343999058008194,
0.20970489084720612,
-0.13583478331565857,
-0.29922303557395935,
0.7888937592506409,
-0.19064320623874664,
-0.2185082733631134,
0.8480606079101562,
0.009056942537426949,
-0.5860602259635925,
0.8060722947120667,
0.7486311197280884,
0.7681545615196228,
-0.30705076456069946,
0.043153274804353714,
0.07855649292469025,
0.40095579624176025,
-0.35109221935272217,
0.4491696357727051,
-0.2978578507900238,
-0.2916507422924042,
-0.04215017333626747,
-0.3706645369529724,
-0.24450521171092987,
0.22627347707748413,
-0.8671588897705078,
-0.2570219039916992,
-0.9156791567802429,
-0.3964028060436249,
-0.1427878439426422,
-0.14512313902378082,
-0.5108387470245361,
0.07825414091348648,
0.3659410774707794,
0.7175919413566589,
-0.7919854521751404,
0.6492664217948914,
0.36511388421058655,
-0.39790618419647217,
-0.5348005890846252,
-0.14687934517860413,
-0.016503313556313515,
-0.9033234119415283,
0.6459122896194458,
0.3622792363166809,
0.11961454153060913,
-0.05102057382464409,
-0.8961725234985352,
-0.9785207509994507,
1.2802900075912476,
0.48251873254776,
-0.5638851523399353,
0.026866376399993896,
0.29335907101631165,
0.32664820551872253,
-0.022609220817685127,
-0.2947717607021332,
0.6928294897079468,
0.35455307364463806,
0.038132764399051666,
-0.8035457730293274,
-0.3877469003200531,
-0.20262975990772247,
0.14455701410770416,
0.07907065004110336,
-0.9051644802093506,
1.2819740772247314,
-0.5142689347267151,
-0.32199594378471375,
0.25665706396102905,
0.22230471670627594,
0.3878557085990906,
0.406575083732605,
0.3587396740913391,
0.7943679690361023,
0.9814825654029846,
0.15616361796855927,
1.0809597969055176,
-0.12839427590370178,
0.45461350679397583,
1.0278414487838745,
-0.17591366171836853,
0.9437081813812256,
0.8808534741401672,
-0.19567622244358063,
0.23442155122756958,
0.5720028877258301,
-0.2309565544128418,
0.8440085053443909,
0.5271358489990234,
-0.3875353932380676,
-0.3062785565853119,
0.11221306025981903,
-0.40170207619667053,
0.4958275854587555,
0.5501962304115295,
-0.5128679275512695,
-0.08019565790891647,
-0.023239873349666595,
0.37524330615997314,
0.11578726768493652,
-0.5577132105827332,
0.9758127927780151,
0.3784489333629608,
-0.4177432060241699,
0.8763754367828369,
-0.19002793729305267,
0.6035701632499695,
-0.6926383376121521,
0.13699492812156677,
-0.5360575318336487,
0.5833354592323303,
-0.299753874540329,
-0.02132796309888363,
0.3554621934890747,
-0.06482505798339844,
-0.28590765595436096,
0.06606698036193848,
0.21845436096191406,
-0.5074125528335571,
-0.40482625365257263,
0.20673546195030212,
0.1009691059589386,
0.4674997329711914,
0.09477067738771439,
-0.5347932577133179,
0.1528334617614746,
-0.16566559672355652,
-0.4881446957588196,
0.5235450267791748,
0.08088773488998413,
-0.19308385252952576,
1.1607998609542847,
0.678696870803833,
0.06261620670557022,
0.19369207322597504,
0.08754534274339676,
0.9195948839187622,
-0.5839179158210754,
-0.44711893796920776,
-1.0583076477050781,
-0.013431035913527012,
0.15642744302749634,
-0.16224855184555054,
0.760285496711731,
0.5966119170188904,
1.1713407039642334,
-0.3746643662452698,
0.9165350198745728,
0.6135590076446533,
0.25902247428894043,
-0.5643351078033447,
1.0010658502578735,
-0.5478382110595703,
0.4476543366909027,
-0.1996634602546692,
-0.6704062819480896,
-0.4517747759819031,
0.70977383852005,
-0.16417349874973297,
0.1110893115401268,
0.35024988651275635,
0.7549663782119751,
0.057164374738931656,
-0.12201377004384995,
0.39205724000930786,
-0.011337480507791042,
0.31944212317466736,
0.8662658929824829,
0.8759840130805969,
-0.4347877502441406,
0.866619348526001,
-0.14104358851909637,
0.2024689018726349,
-0.19608429074287415,
-0.5484901666641235,
-1.2011502981185913,
-0.1822589486837387,
-0.325760155916214,
-0.05145780369639397,
0.29671257734298706,
0.6269693970680237,
0.6667055487632751,
-0.7057287693023682,
-0.09921586513519287,
-0.2798730731010437,
-0.03816799446940422,
-0.12708191573619843,
-0.09268797934055328,
0.544137716293335,
-0.39289626479148865,
-0.3879838287830353,
0.16160497069358826,
0.3587717115879059,
0.765388548374176,
-0.12313751131296158,
-0.14511416852474213,
0.10619179159402847,
0.19018137454986572,
0.3603796660900116,
0.5164709687232971,
-0.7338089346885681,
-0.09863834083080292,
-0.3084963262081146,
0.016212396323680878,
-0.04927163943648338,
0.6825092434883118,
-0.7407748699188232,
0.26247870922088623,
0.10081219673156738,
0.4409807324409485,
0.6143039464950562,
-0.07870442420244217,
0.25731614232063293,
-0.7003558874130249,
0.4661862850189209,
0.16590946912765503,
0.1267652064561844,
0.5257967114448547,
-0.27503836154937744,
0.2757246494293213,
0.43242356181144714,
-0.23766906559467316,
-0.8092973828315735,
0.06975750625133514,
-0.820039689540863,
-0.35760968923568726,
1.0116171836853027,
-0.5717019438743591,
-0.46961840987205505,
-0.0692528560757637,
-0.11322317272424698,
0.2713926136493683,
-0.0016443710774183273,
0.9988211989402771,
0.3359528183937073,
0.2920009195804596,
-0.07160844653844833,
-0.6694051623344421,
0.6092212796211243,
0.7131986021995544,
-0.6024947166442871,
0.2463735193014145,
0.11208617687225342,
0.8234315514564514,
-0.11419103294610977,
0.7745637893676758,
-0.3299928903579712,
0.2923799753189087,
0.22185149788856506,
-0.0020676134154200554,
-0.3015693128108978,
-0.30395030975341797,
-0.47052788734436035,
0.12430141866207123,
0.17914406955242157,
-0.45284417271614075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10323v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10323v1
|
GenQA: Generating Millions of Instructions from a Handful of Prompts
| 2024-06-14T17:44:08 | 2024-06-14T17:44:08 |
Jiuhai Chen, Rifaa Qadri, Yuxin Wen, Neel Jain, John Kirchenbauer, Tianyi Zhou, Tom Goldstein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Most public instruction finetuning datasets are relatively small compared to
the closed source datasets used to train industry models. To study questions
about finetuning at scale, such as curricula and learning rate cooldown
schedules, there is a need for industrial-scale datasets. However, this scale
necessitates a data generation process that is almost entirely automated. In
this work, we study methods for generating large instruction datasets from a
single prompt. With little human oversight, we get LLMs to write diverse sets
of instruction examples ranging from simple completion tasks to complex
multi-turn dialogs across a variety of subject areas. When finetuning a Llama-3
8B base model, our dataset meets or exceeds both WizardLM and Ultrachat on both
knowledge-intensive leaderboard tasks as well as conversational evaluations. We
release our dataset, the "generator" prompts that created it, and our finetuned
model checkpoints.
|
[
-0.5248667001724243,
-0.7891958355903625,
0.4838424623012543,
0.03229599446058273,
0.018373772501945496,
-0.322404682636261,
-0.13744039833545685,
0.28297698497772217,
-0.2525048553943634,
0.6650916337966919,
-0.9941835999488831,
-0.5888662338256836,
0.06610506772994995,
0.15802156925201416,
-0.4222760498523712,
1.0601909160614014,
0.2176843136548996,
0.059010330587625504,
-0.31286144256591797,
0.2848648130893707,
-0.6707847118377686,
-0.3579524755477905,
-0.5247814059257507,
-0.32489877939224243,
0.4236270785331726,
1.2029199600219727,
0.4006103575229645,
0.8754878640174866,
0.13718824088573456,
0.17894025146961212,
0.3169446289539337,
0.41477930545806885,
-0.7166692614555359,
-0.02388669364154339,
0.011721176095306873,
-0.4444425404071808,
-0.08477416634559631,
0.22549857199192047,
0.5932217836380005,
1.0002727508544922,
-0.15337984263896942,
0.6546329259872437,
0.4471246004104614,
0.6825993061065674,
-0.39256176352500916,
0.10269468277692795,
-0.5037927627563477,
0.022151093930006027,
-0.24652327597141266,
-0.09671568125486374,
-0.6391271352767944,
-0.7464909553527832,
0.024993255734443665,
-0.5699207782745361,
0.43877583742141724,
0.03926661238074303,
0.524368941783905,
0.4420320391654968,
-0.3928127586841583,
-0.30856460332870483,
-0.7195775508880615,
0.760706901550293,
-0.4485667943954468,
0.026204729452729225,
0.30403992533683777,
0.5221608877182007,
-0.40035974979400635,
-0.8594687581062317,
-0.32788169384002686,
-0.04220828041434288,
0.26490283012390137,
-0.02821960113942623,
-0.13714472949504852,
0.08134002238512039,
0.5911304950714111,
0.2870050370693207,
-0.24195560812950134,
0.39453989267349243,
-0.6001664996147156,
-0.009199144318699837,
0.49131402373313904,
0.8222101330757141,
-0.004865772556513548,
-0.37265440821647644,
-0.250580370426178,
-0.16834206879138947,
-0.8941055536270142,
-0.011414969339966774,
0.323364794254303,
0.37740761041641235,
0.0031435794662684202,
0.5477324724197388,
-0.5578576326370239,
0.7531285881996155,
0.417766809463501,
-0.036029916256666183,
-0.08784453570842743,
-0.24496732652187347,
-0.3229387700557709,
0.053423840552568436,
0.9061511754989624,
0.45956891775131226,
0.21064788103103638,
-0.17097435891628265,
-0.02973010204732418,
-0.2626963257789612,
0.20876237750053406,
-0.9843063950538635,
-0.3894570469856262,
0.18461266160011292,
-0.3157942593097687,
-0.25211766362190247,
-0.14648975431919098,
-0.7863883376121521,
-0.5739860534667969,
-0.7553072571754456,
0.42439135909080505,
-0.2942042648792267,
0.5254244208335876,
-0.0546366311609745,
0.031440652906894684,
0.4042542278766632,
0.3385731279850006,
-0.9943300485610962,
0.019326651468873024,
0.5969419479370117,
0.5329245328903198,
0.10890994966030121,
-0.20521180331707,
-0.6671773791313171,
0.012057975865900517,
-0.5703027844429016,
0.6609722375869751,
-0.32362794876098633,
-0.4312039613723755,
-0.20594803988933563,
-0.08572056144475937,
-0.007322107441723347,
-0.5964908599853516,
0.12924492359161377,
-0.24227967858314514,
0.30311548709869385,
-0.4063831865787506,
-0.7004640698432922,
-0.07928324490785599,
-0.04562436789274216,
-0.5791513919830322,
0.7351284027099609,
-0.08548759669065475,
-0.41799458861351013,
0.3110179603099823,
-0.6017951369285583,
-0.21753127872943878,
0.1719408482313156,
-0.6023947596549988,
-0.10475625097751617,
-0.11976040154695511,
0.28525784611701965,
0.8754727840423584,
-0.5736687183380127,
0.21292708814144135,
0.12460815906524658,
-0.3236400783061981,
0.15968237817287445,
-0.8566166162490845,
0.800764799118042,
0.2424880564212799,
-0.5194866061210632,
-0.18244832754135132,
-0.8946600556373596,
0.06509833037853241,
0.03709835186600685,
-0.5937894582748413,
0.009092935360968113,
-0.2352587729692459,
-0.41587671637535095,
-0.08880000561475754,
0.22588570415973663,
-0.4727431833744049,
0.46283021569252014,
-0.12921743094921112,
0.4354889988899231,
0.9513031840324402,
0.4615958034992218,
0.32651981711387634,
-0.5834601521492004,
0.6186378598213196,
-0.1896018236875534,
0.11484486609697342,
-0.4090561866760254,
-0.5220584273338318,
-0.9312067627906799,
-0.1456965208053589,
0.30747586488723755,
0.5273411273956299,
-0.6852429509162903,
0.3200945258140564,
-0.11951147764921188,
-0.6809000372886658,
-0.5837380290031433,
0.26173731684684753,
0.44746652245521545,
0.7030412554740906,
0.18380405008792877,
0.15138477087020874,
-0.32850199937820435,
-0.9292085766792297,
0.3726871907711029,
0.3516731560230255,
-0.506536602973938,
0.22461143136024475,
0.23502083122730255,
-0.04245540499687195,
0.9428713917732239,
-0.7213152050971985,
0.013121508061885834,
0.0321684330701828,
0.4323590099811554,
0.27671337127685547,
0.5373650789260864,
0.3593475818634033,
-0.1490115374326706,
-0.12418681383132935,
-0.2784813642501831,
-0.8023692965507507,
-0.0381343849003315,
-0.5682709813117981,
-0.41638579964637756,
-0.13150352239608765,
0.5713134407997131,
-0.45527616143226624,
0.11176769435405731,
0.13963162899017334,
0.020697016268968582,
0.580399751663208,
-0.027521474286913872,
0.2127709984779358,
-1.1720480918884277,
-0.2487567961215973,
-0.2597438395023346,
0.029553906992077827,
-0.5981852412223816,
-0.06541314721107483,
-0.27678072452545166,
-0.3344328999519348,
-0.49945753812789917,
0.20543934404850006,
-0.5116196870803833,
-0.073037289083004,
0.08401615172624588,
-0.03202296793460846,
0.04014034569263458,
0.6308403611183167,
-0.42231401801109314,
0.9559916853904724,
0.3723542094230652,
-0.9124613404273987,
0.6054382920265198,
0.6015121936798096,
-0.5427798628807068,
0.31562843918800354,
-0.5554317235946655,
0.35480961203575134,
-0.15980997681617737,
0.16721709072589874,
-0.9454070329666138,
-0.6654053330421448,
0.16972528398036957,
-0.1173756942152977,
0.002480877097696066,
-0.1383020579814911,
-0.390674889087677,
-0.4350424110889435,
-0.251472532749176,
-0.016271324828267097,
0.704955518245697,
-0.8962616324424744,
0.29846805334091187,
0.05552048981189728,
-0.24591036140918732,
-0.2488194704055786,
-0.6177235245704651,
-0.1437869369983673,
-0.23222890496253967,
-0.47877779603004456,
-0.33380356431007385,
-0.2781095802783966,
-0.06073283776640892,
-0.5070917010307312,
0.010333766229450703,
0.03420979902148247,
0.19852577149868011,
0.5458618998527527,
0.3174753189086914,
-0.30533477663993835,
0.13361607491970062,
0.1846669614315033,
0.11479207873344421,
0.43681955337524414,
-0.2511789798736572,
0.49651196599006653,
0.0448291040956974,
-0.4824300706386566,
-0.7041792869567871,
0.4304340183734894,
0.48717719316482544,
0.2183724045753479,
0.46717900037765503,
0.3023940622806549,
-0.35164934396743774,
-0.5134934782981873,
-0.27691319584846497,
-0.3639376163482666,
-0.5331076979637146,
-0.05355837941169739,
-0.2776971459388733,
-0.5806428790092468,
0.3389103412628174,
-0.18375931680202484,
0.6583281755447388,
0.3374471664428711,
0.6201487183570862,
-0.02870064415037632,
0.9630727171897888,
0.25092586874961853,
0.11297772824764252,
0.3414168059825897,
-0.517906665802002,
-0.1424832046031952,
-0.5267636179924011,
-0.38445186614990234,
-0.49885472655296326,
-0.24467334151268005,
-0.5307725071907043,
-0.49853774905204773,
0.3658541440963745,
0.07368814945220947,
-0.6877759695053101,
0.06130261719226837,
-0.7636302709579468,
0.6890081167221069,
1.1627352237701416,
0.3021175265312195,
0.19496317207813263,
0.20974265038967133,
-0.09603182971477509,
0.12928226590156555,
-1.012857437133789,
-0.9770917892456055,
1.2940009832382202,
0.12269489467144012,
1.0002174377441406,
-0.18870213627815247,
1.0310871601104736,
0.30594101548194885,
0.21041348576545715,
-0.760571300983429,
0.6966733336448669,
-0.3223626911640167,
-0.377875953912735,
-0.3922675848007202,
-0.5650641918182373,
-0.9719380140304565,
-0.42705950140953064,
-0.21865636110305786,
-0.4345346689224243,
0.17718639969825745,
0.3442259132862091,
-0.9783425331115723,
0.09802918136119843,
-1.0175883769989014,
0.8170851469039917,
0.0026663613971322775,
-0.13655561208724976,
0.08171859383583069,
-0.6387037038803101,
0.5894775986671448,
-0.17985478043556213,
0.005629381164908409,
-0.05536670982837677,
0.34049054980278015,
1.018722653388977,
-0.576129138469696,
1.087308645248413,
-0.08092528581619263,
-0.23027947545051575,
0.7281162142753601,
-0.02319863997399807,
0.2800610065460205,
-0.0697886049747467,
-0.014604172669351101,
-0.1263270229101181,
-0.22639697790145874,
-0.29862186312675476,
-0.3273092210292816,
0.5780251026153564,
-0.8933053612709045,
-0.578569769859314,
0.19198225438594818,
-0.6275103688240051,
-0.26779717206954956,
-0.03417836129665375,
0.6586331725120544,
0.9266399145126343,
-0.1774265170097351,
0.09884310513734818,
0.9178966283798218,
-0.3402308523654938,
0.23243087530136108,
0.18118250370025635,
0.15423351526260376,
-0.21641021966934204,
1.2069798707962036,
0.34679943323135376,
0.3842158913612366,
0.11430227011442184,
0.08913704007863998,
0.0997820794582367,
-0.20092782378196716,
-0.8623995184898376,
-0.15872928500175476,
-0.8139111399650574,
-0.5034501552581787,
-0.31168073415756226,
-0.33462586998939514,
-0.34366869926452637,
-0.32481470704078674,
-0.10469122231006622,
-0.43277373909950256,
-0.7167607545852661,
-0.17193356156349182,
0.5705155730247498,
1.1106772422790527,
-0.1089242622256279,
0.5126553773880005,
-0.915242075920105,
0.5256397724151611,
1.031267523765564,
-0.03470030054450035,
0.18423080444335938,
-0.34457510709762573,
-0.2267661839723587,
0.38057374954223633,
-0.4578186571598053,
-0.5895822644233704,
-0.07313426584005356,
0.24229353666305542,
0.4615979790687561,
0.6149719953536987,
0.25993531942367554,
0.5898342132568359,
-0.7961198687553406,
1.0745776891708374,
0.10439207404851913,
-0.691613495349884,
0.5296399593353271,
-0.42174506187438965,
0.4382128119468689,
0.49041154980659485,
0.48271888494491577,
-0.22774092853069305,
-0.4173662066459656,
-0.609863817691803,
-0.6959908604621887,
0.7654298543930054,
-0.0776076391339302,
0.2509298622608185,
-0.15391811728477478,
0.2752673029899597,
0.4392293691635132,
0.08536821603775024,
0.15705594420433044,
-0.2737234830856323,
-0.15245388448238373,
-0.5972951054573059,
0.26521381735801697,
-0.055516116321086884,
-0.4188854992389679,
-0.05149746686220169,
0.4446669816970825,
-0.1576484888792038,
0.30321407318115234,
-0.21578413248062134,
0.1029488816857338,
-0.003480810672044754,
0.4187334179878235,
0.5250385403633118,
0.5506157279014587,
0.006423294078558683,
-0.09700902551412582,
0.1647544652223587,
-0.5834589600563049,
0.18831820785999298,
0.18884685635566711,
-0.32804808020591736,
-0.20168614387512207,
0.24490325152873993,
0.7961553931236267,
0.021851439028978348,
-0.5731838345527649,
0.08563384413719177,
-0.055926695466041565,
-0.34493133425712585,
-0.030069297179579735,
0.4437437355518341,
0.07837027311325073,
0.294540673494339,
0.5546813607215881,
-0.2243492752313614,
0.23012448847293854,
-0.306697279214859,
0.4248305559158325,
0.0690380334854126,
0.22026731073856354,
0.012235837988555431,
0.893912672996521,
0.528236985206604,
0.10648022592067719,
1.0635945796966553,
-0.1658789962530136,
-0.07120925933122635,
0.9460769891738892,
0.155410498380661,
0.5762723684310913,
-0.03468432277441025,
0.4188694655895233,
0.4876406192779541,
0.17742781341075897,
-0.1512567698955536,
0.19917230308055878,
-0.0691983699798584,
-0.3235701322555542,
-0.3991067111492157,
-0.5808144807815552,
-0.8066983819007874,
0.20774774253368378,
-0.9301166534423828,
0.13660497963428497,
-0.7679903507232666,
-0.04820472002029419,
0.14072251319885254,
-0.026299258694052696,
-0.8925321102142334,
0.27516186237335205,
0.4176824688911438,
0.7670847177505493,
-0.9111368060112,
0.23014399409294128,
0.44072648882865906,
-0.5299243330955505,
-1.3922812938690186,
-0.18353596329689026,
0.16045808792114258,
-0.8233494758605957,
0.4241819381713867,
0.2538835406303406,
0.18806642293930054,
0.3689568042755127,
-1.0721828937530518,
-0.45210903882980347,
1.23960280418396,
0.5271626114845276,
-0.929288387298584,
-0.2764872908592224,
0.21615833044052124,
0.07910914719104767,
-0.4096420705318451,
-0.0849958211183548,
0.8282272219657898,
0.22208735346794128,
-0.050381023436784744,
-0.5488490462303162,
0.12268266826868057,
0.1295386403799057,
-0.2354304939508438,
0.0025598607026040554,
-0.6687280535697937,
0.9085003137588501,
-0.4389994740486145,
-0.33812612295150757,
0.17965520918369293,
0.7377245426177979,
0.3717532157897949,
0.24672392010688782,
0.23341535031795502,
0.44978344440460205,
1.0261106491088867,
-0.07491355389356613,
0.8232818245887756,
-0.07220415025949478,
-0.049916692078113556,
1.3864104747772217,
0.21833156049251556,
0.46748265624046326,
0.0540819950401783,
-0.003652390791103244,
0.33180809020996094,
0.9142577648162842,
-0.3250671923160553,
0.286837100982666,
0.324418306350708,
-0.15638211369514465,
-0.43845507502555847,
-0.18823008239269257,
-0.26071667671203613,
0.2344827800989151,
0.27922046184539795,
-0.1098528578877449,
-0.2525993585586548,
0.4405374825000763,
0.005090088117867708,
-0.11218935996294022,
-0.5583994388580322,
0.9248648881912231,
0.04634695500135422,
-0.5304118394851685,
0.8446887731552124,
-0.3919231593608856,
0.3124377727508545,
-0.2640995979309082,
-0.3044772446155548,
-0.547182023525238,
-0.11520794779062271,
-0.18463702499866486,
-0.7850912809371948,
-0.3584953248500824,
0.3859073221683502,
-0.34065449237823486,
-0.29407769441604614,
0.038950107991695404,
-0.5593274235725403,
-0.39438629150390625,
-0.6852126717567444,
0.3793569505214691,
0.5652989745140076,
0.38482511043548584,
-0.23155663907527924,
-0.2592966556549072,
0.23789045214653015,
-0.2920468747615814,
0.13070757687091827,
0.7417090535163879,
-0.09114108979701996,
0.6772024035453796,
0.5131475329399109,
-0.22807425260543823,
0.5380068421363831,
0.22402121126651764,
0.9643648862838745,
-0.5283159613609314,
-0.1406838744878769,
-0.35185205936431885,
0.46042025089263916,
0.1130484938621521,
-0.5437004566192627,
0.7809423208236694,
0.44438934326171875,
0.7351888418197632,
-0.1645091474056244,
0.88686203956604,
-0.02146008424460888,
0.38592201471328735,
-0.7479454874992371,
0.5291257500648499,
-0.08203429728746414,
0.22728301584720612,
0.12891885638237,
-0.6925685405731201,
0.27000218629837036,
0.24903813004493713,
-0.08478623628616333,
-0.15925781428813934,
0.37874743342399597,
0.6997157335281372,
0.08507996052503586,
0.08664990216493607,
0.13199245929718018,
0.11980485916137695,
0.11300849169492722,
0.6879605650901794,
0.8145419955253601,
-0.2581958472728729,
0.7843576669692993,
-0.2752954959869385,
-0.1573924720287323,
-0.098784439265728,
-0.49555444717407227,
-1.0516847372055054,
-0.39037737250328064,
-0.21574296057224274,
-0.16526462137699127,
-0.10994008183479309,
1.0225704908370972,
0.5044415593147278,
-0.760550320148468,
-0.15473875403404236,
-0.0291319340467453,
-0.01823754794895649,
-0.11211330443620682,
-0.26535889506340027,
0.35178083181381226,
-0.462341845035553,
-0.6551536321640015,
0.5595338940620422,
-0.3683199882507324,
0.2478213906288147,
-0.37870216369628906,
0.17547625303268433,
0.07663556933403015,
0.2189575433731079,
0.33645880222320557,
0.2812127470970154,
-0.3057892620563507,
-0.30771544575691223,
-0.06009287014603615,
-0.36229202151298523,
-0.15438725054264069,
0.6161654591560364,
-0.773229718208313,
0.2706010639667511,
0.3742115795612335,
0.8233361840248108,
0.19980096817016602,
0.25055816769599915,
0.7168311476707458,
-0.9773762226104736,
-0.1710808426141739,
0.01780112087726593,
-0.06329425424337387,
0.38398054242134094,
-0.4428655803203583,
0.3614194095134735,
-0.1567733734846115,
-0.821578323841095,
-0.6468634605407715,
0.12154655903577805,
-0.7728695273399353,
-0.05936231464147568,
0.9658166766166687,
0.06680148094892502,
-0.28266721963882446,
0.061149962246418,
-0.32814455032348633,
0.3694024980068207,
-0.5476908683776855,
0.6862766146659851,
0.49168694019317627,
-0.2788042426109314,
0.1414552927017212,
-0.7315770983695984,
0.44314923882484436,
0.05714043229818344,
-0.9625546932220459,
0.3805057406425476,
1.060265302658081,
0.3428838849067688,
0.07667426019906998,
0.3677349388599396,
0.45560744404792786,
0.3971504271030426,
0.31872332096099854,
0.10398229956626892,
-0.23222480714321136,
-0.5057281255722046,
-0.2451341450214386,
0.23095357418060303,
-0.012524731457233429,
-0.6308538913726807
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.