id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12950v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12950v1
|
MolecularGPT: Open Large Language Model (LLM) for Few-Shot Molecular Property Prediction
| 2024-06-18T12:54:47 | 2024-06-18T12:54:47 |
Yuyan Liu, Sirui Ding, Sheng Zhou, Wenqi Fan, Qiaoyu Tan
|
q-bio.QM
|
q-bio.QM, cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Molecular property prediction (MPP) is a fundamental and crucial task in drug
discovery. However, prior methods are limited by the requirement for a large
number of labeled molecules and their restricted ability to generalize for
unseen and new tasks, both of which are essential for real-world applications.
To address these challenges, we present MolecularGPT for few-shot MPP. From a
perspective on instruction tuning, we fine-tune large language models (LLMs)
based on curated molecular instructions spanning over 1000 property prediction
tasks. This enables building a versatile and specialized LLM that can be
adapted to novel MPP tasks without any fine-tuning through zero- and few-shot
in-context learning (ICL). MolecularGPT exhibits competitive in-context
reasoning capabilities across 10 downstream evaluation datasets, setting new
benchmarks for few-shot molecular prediction tasks. More importantly, with just
two-shot examples, MolecularGPT can outperform standard supervised graph neural
network methods on 4 out of 7 datasets. It also excels state-of-the-art LLM
baselines by up to 16.6% increase on classification accuracy and decrease of
199.17 on regression metrics (e.g., RMSE) under zero-shot. This study
demonstrates the potential of LLMs as effective few-shot molecular property
predictors. The code is available at https://github.com/NYUSHCS/MolecularGPT.
|
[
-0.2640831768512726,
-0.7759891152381897,
0.6435083150863647,
-0.3346308767795563,
-0.221713125705719,
-0.01864609494805336,
-0.45645391941070557,
-0.1917068213224411,
-0.2102591097354889,
0.5219492316246033,
-0.6277667880058289,
-0.6601386070251465,
-0.8284817934036255,
-0.15953968465328217,
0.13443437218666077,
1.177398920059204,
0.08433699607849121,
0.2775607705116272,
-0.000794554827734828,
0.06771384924650192,
-0.07100760191679001,
-0.13809511065483093,
-0.3762862980365753,
-0.5463545322418213,
0.5503587126731873,
0.6739519238471985,
0.3198665976524353,
0.8281199336051941,
0.9015768766403198,
0.17398862540721893,
-0.08063744008541107,
-0.03332168236374855,
-0.7282990217208862,
-0.14730408787727356,
-0.019998112693428993,
-0.3427562713623047,
-0.6317039132118225,
-0.00003364925942150876,
0.3250599801540375,
0.5865694284439087,
-0.0813620388507843,
0.028295015916228294,
0.09250408411026001,
0.6617274880409241,
-0.6510050892829895,
0.2446509301662445,
-0.7848080992698669,
0.2852627635002136,
-0.3047039210796356,
-0.2740172743797302,
-0.1838098168373108,
0.15596601366996765,
0.331254243850708,
-0.4376178979873657,
0.2517126202583313,
-0.015585149638354778,
0.5613533854484558,
0.337628573179245,
-0.46130865812301636,
0.07421692460775375,
-0.49448153376579285,
0.6269387006759644,
-0.8340662121772766,
0.15335965156555176,
0.27887585759162903,
0.6887500286102295,
-0.6486926078796387,
-0.7374857068061829,
-0.28162696957588196,
-0.7545676827430725,
0.17550428211688995,
0.15622322261333466,
0.07218144834041595,
0.43766942620277405,
0.16059914231300354,
0.25036779046058655,
-0.7272904515266418,
0.07973749190568924,
-0.39475688338279724,
-0.11077261716127396,
0.2397574484348297,
0.17154726386070251,
0.09322943538427353,
-0.10260595381259918,
-0.5743743777275085,
0.05724799633026123,
-0.8539661169052124,
-0.16288627684116364,
0.03769254311919212,
0.7420583367347717,
-0.03806155174970627,
0.8947368860244751,
-0.3351428508758545,
0.7179076671600342,
-0.051307257264852524,
-0.18453864753246307,
-0.19500471651554108,
-0.2649281322956085,
-0.3190366327762604,
0.35361385345458984,
0.7897514700889587,
0.3262159824371338,
0.29450663924217224,
0.09261123090982437,
0.017039092257618904,
-0.21751652657985687,
-0.06363619118928909,
-1.3138691186904907,
-0.5067137479782104,
0.24141637980937958,
-0.15999837219715118,
-0.229958176612854,
0.09148050099611282,
-0.859582781791687,
-0.48640817403793335,
-0.08355960249900818,
0.38575515151023865,
-0.5603389739990234,
0.2986513674259186,
0.192295104265213,
-0.2131412923336029,
-0.14726383984088898,
0.15810197591781616,
-1.1451174020767212,
0.1811668574810028,
0.8340789079666138,
1.01874840259552,
-0.3887089788913727,
-0.4882661700248718,
-0.6914508938789368,
0.319672554731369,
-0.05893217399716377,
0.9539061784744263,
-0.8405240774154663,
-0.23206093907356262,
-0.49992290139198303,
-0.07294056564569473,
0.14936748147010803,
-0.5120210647583008,
0.14809580147266388,
-0.13218174874782562,
-0.15115101635456085,
0.016777947545051575,
-0.7549085021018982,
0.0529211200773716,
0.41576087474823,
-0.3141429126262665,
0.4615517854690552,
0.37931326031684875,
-0.3780801594257355,
0.5360623598098755,
-0.68679279088974,
-0.13085564970970154,
0.24469594657421112,
-0.19270998239517212,
-0.39424559473991394,
0.03784700110554695,
0.19177648425102234,
0.5687693953514099,
-0.06007019802927971,
-0.06907058507204056,
-0.45789864659309387,
-0.47054919600486755,
0.174948588013649,
-0.3773450553417206,
0.3588064908981323,
-0.06217169016599655,
-0.3105829060077667,
0.1481960415840149,
-0.8044477105140686,
0.10554162412881851,
-0.20934928953647614,
-0.5058619379997253,
0.3595331311225891,
-0.4091682732105255,
-0.05068565532565117,
0.24202479422092438,
0.1438569575548172,
-0.5215182304382324,
0.7855326533317566,
-0.5423356294631958,
0.46642404794692993,
0.8548088669776917,
0.24538826942443848,
0.6281942129135132,
-0.06370878219604492,
0.8645205497741699,
0.12223220616579056,
-0.05120193958282471,
-0.15914157032966614,
-0.5969533920288086,
-0.47510671615600586,
-0.3886202871799469,
0.3244202733039856,
0.6978682279586792,
-0.4869863986968994,
0.1646309643983841,
-0.3131483495235443,
-0.5382192134857178,
0.01716596633195877,
0.5770219564437866,
0.5025795102119446,
0.482045441865921,
0.46569302678108215,
-0.1682242453098297,
-0.34169816970825195,
-0.7251216769218445,
-0.4179423153400421,
0.028828278183937073,
-0.19222313165664673,
0.6618664860725403,
0.7198379039764404,
-0.3391764461994171,
0.7047457098960876,
-0.8068665266036987,
-0.6113933324813843,
-0.49007681012153625,
-0.039236873388290405,
0.35567283630371094,
0.3182052671909332,
0.1563405990600586,
-0.1928521692752838,
-0.7290914058685303,
0.3326009213924408,
-0.4185146987438202,
0.0016471192939206958,
0.07870405167341232,
-0.26854774355888367,
0.010009219869971275,
0.3692609965801239,
-0.7355249524116516,
0.17411170899868011,
0.4864465892314911,
-0.14282333850860596,
0.32549726963043213,
-0.0549740344285965,
-0.18240045011043549,
-0.9018065333366394,
-0.23459404706954956,
0.36930587887763977,
-0.15103334188461304,
-0.46298572421073914,
-0.14544610679149628,
-0.26979196071624756,
-0.06506838649511337,
-0.810066282749176,
0.7271185517311096,
-0.16515067219734192,
0.0891532450914383,
-0.4564368724822998,
-0.11122602969408035,
-0.18932890892028809,
0.529405951499939,
0.013517441228032112,
0.7421845197677612,
0.5707980990409851,
-0.3128759562969208,
0.36390846967697144,
0.03754271939396858,
-0.24361419677734375,
0.25798213481903076,
-0.5061146020889282,
0.1610514521598816,
0.09704301506280899,
0.39281097054481506,
-0.5996240377426147,
-0.6213256120681763,
0.35451748967170715,
-0.37322595715522766,
0.5716342926025391,
-0.8745272755622864,
-0.23075249791145325,
-0.005478242877870798,
-0.28603246808052063,
0.022228127345442772,
0.3472629189491272,
-0.411064475774765,
0.41108497977256775,
0.10205313563346863,
-0.04216359555721283,
-0.45549261569976807,
-0.7252515554428101,
-0.02228626236319542,
-0.11612094193696976,
-0.4409111440181732,
0.16591855883598328,
-0.014601340517401695,
0.19686149060726166,
-0.1391827017068863,
-0.20396235585212708,
-0.2556481957435608,
-0.22470687329769135,
0.3302823305130005,
0.1910862922668457,
-0.4050147533416748,
0.2060767412185669,
-0.22096681594848633,
-0.44617515802383423,
-0.2726982533931732,
-0.7196257710456848,
0.41748863458633423,
-0.4739212393760681,
-0.06536488234996796,
-0.04075775668025017,
0.011165308766067028,
0.26736530661582947,
0.011138146743178368,
0.605385422706604,
0.6523085236549377,
-0.06112360954284668,
-0.47747424244880676,
0.23350194096565247,
-0.5132872462272644,
-0.5182320475578308,
0.5481858849525452,
-0.38950854539871216,
-1.0055328607559204,
0.08316897600889206,
-0.3592756390571594,
-0.4624428451061249,
0.1455576866865158,
0.739212155342102,
-0.21878300607204437,
0.6586620807647705,
0.6169087886810303,
-0.03172878175973892,
0.3924442529678345,
-0.46306172013282776,
0.3686387240886688,
-0.7176843881607056,
-0.037294209003448486,
0.0518568754196167,
-0.5742813944816589,
-0.7782958149909973,
-0.5052421689033508,
0.7898939847946167,
0.31582704186439514,
-0.4700431525707245,
0.4172625243663788,
-0.5753511786460876,
0.924233078956604,
0.7342491745948792,
0.3885284960269928,
0.06111355125904083,
0.21027487516403198,
-0.05236554890871048,
-0.02796868234872818,
-0.6537057757377625,
-0.5060486197471619,
1.5765864849090576,
0.1005643829703331,
0.7278904914855957,
-0.08585968613624573,
0.7812814712524414,
-0.03630712628364563,
-0.0035511201713234186,
-1.1719943284988403,
0.5991693735122681,
-0.37540996074676514,
-0.6317149996757507,
-0.3508278429508209,
-0.4742487370967865,
-0.6676934957504272,
-0.1142595186829567,
-0.19347088038921356,
-0.9765598177909851,
-0.03188898041844368,
0.5018050074577332,
-0.5569887757301331,
0.3695639967918396,
-0.6674234867095947,
1.1128017902374268,
-0.27292072772979736,
-0.6424802541732788,
0.06029452756047249,
-0.8011378645896912,
0.4569002091884613,
-0.021816905587911606,
-0.48376739025115967,
-0.36922574043273926,
-0.07049840688705444,
0.19724422693252563,
-0.5549695491790771,
0.6512520909309387,
-0.025559479370713234,
0.2085917741060257,
0.21475113928318024,
0.2864324450492859,
0.5272480249404907,
0.04588165506720543,
0.06577553600072861,
0.20876093208789825,
0.02795986831188202,
-0.4426893889904022,
-0.6642584204673767,
0.8814014196395874,
-0.38463523983955383,
-0.3169344365596771,
-0.39030131697654724,
-0.49661025404930115,
-0.2644043564796448,
0.34435856342315674,
0.6873698830604553,
0.08753617852926254,
-0.046925004571676254,
-0.004214742686599493,
0.4777205288410187,
-0.11728184670209885,
0.18931712210178375,
0.4444403350353241,
0.00440964475274086,
-0.2288396656513214,
1.1886427402496338,
0.08071542531251907,
0.338421106338501,
0.6176044344902039,
0.5871814489364624,
0.12242159992456436,
-0.7000170350074768,
-0.43732279539108276,
-0.19272862374782562,
-0.7892404794692993,
-0.2969093918800354,
-0.38223493099212646,
-0.10872604697942734,
-0.23476894199848175,
-0.26671481132507324,
-0.5742186307907104,
-0.6638177633285522,
-0.14116352796554565,
-0.2605419456958771,
0.587794303894043,
0.5721626281738281,
-0.07921437174081802,
0.5300927758216858,
-0.9336792826652527,
0.5070269107818604,
0.40075668692588806,
0.5611952543258667,
-0.52875155210495,
-0.46279263496398926,
-0.2592408061027527,
0.1011960357427597,
-0.42502501606941223,
-0.5547104477882385,
0.31190964579582214,
0.5202994346618652,
0.21461249887943268,
0.4654855728149414,
-0.36454877257347107,
0.3561822474002838,
-0.7267926931381226,
0.6875198483467102,
-0.16415809094905853,
-0.6167938709259033,
0.8379931449890137,
-0.7114272713661194,
0.3734184503555298,
0.7519637942314148,
0.27852654457092285,
-0.13813963532447815,
0.1012832373380661,
-0.3624017536640167,
-0.780136227607727,
0.5831126570701599,
0.1854880452156067,
-0.12359513342380524,
0.22521106898784637,
0.29716458916664124,
0.06289491802453995,
0.18303769826889038,
-0.6713314652442932,
-0.2306763231754303,
-0.20422528684139252,
-0.22290079295635223,
-0.10801409184932709,
-0.13296106457710266,
-0.05954660847783089,
-0.5115325450897217,
0.7181498408317566,
-0.4463855028152466,
0.2822365462779999,
-0.16617272794246674,
0.08493074029684067,
-0.08562052249908447,
0.5737987756729126,
0.8200780749320984,
0.47176527976989746,
-0.862535297870636,
0.013673308305442333,
0.13767048716545105,
-0.6915952563285828,
0.2542068064212799,
0.1590924710035324,
-0.04971820116043091,
-0.3433891534805298,
0.38039883971214294,
0.7595142126083374,
-0.05257844179868698,
-0.7470165491104126,
0.4855300188064575,
0.346387654542923,
0.03414814919233322,
-0.01835087686777115,
0.3123199939727783,
-0.01608206145465374,
0.32074683904647827,
-0.08910030126571655,
0.12619154155254364,
0.2520962655544281,
-0.5836372375488281,
0.3642820417881012,
0.3872374892234802,
-0.5965826511383057,
-0.11196023970842361,
0.5713813900947571,
-0.062190230935811996,
0.08030257374048233,
0.5517066121101379,
-0.3300033509731293,
-0.4595457911491394,
0.6483568549156189,
0.3925211727619171,
1.0200074911117554,
0.006733303423970938,
0.10350102931261063,
0.3391997516155243,
0.32835519313812256,
0.015115263871848583,
0.13242658972740173,
0.16655510663986206,
-0.7697734832763672,
-0.01922064833343029,
-0.6547675132751465,
-0.5898527503013611,
0.0119263781234622,
-0.03794500231742859,
0.42056047916412354,
-0.8375068306922913,
-0.07007254660129547,
0.2500433027744293,
0.1433214396238327,
-0.3471977710723877,
-0.02250850200653076,
0.2602078318595886,
0.6987790465354919,
-0.614408016204834,
1.116481065750122,
0.49742591381073,
-0.3171461224555969,
-0.5502909421920776,
-0.045358650386333466,
0.5013938546180725,
-0.6668576598167419,
0.7509844303131104,
0.23263470828533173,
-0.19661779701709747,
-0.020668717101216316,
-0.8046437501907349,
-0.6315028071403503,
1.0695236921310425,
0.6361294388771057,
-0.9059079885482788,
0.12226616591215134,
0.40660926699638367,
0.5099833011627197,
-0.4431314468383789,
0.18823669850826263,
1.0546576976776123,
0.6062828302383423,
0.30993565917015076,
-0.6738454103469849,
-0.23539486527442932,
-0.021295426413416862,
-0.0873929113149643,
0.21110621094703674,
-0.4004417359828949,
0.7350190281867981,
-0.5102431774139404,
0.18147391080856323,
-0.0019011700060218573,
0.17649126052856445,
0.6855470538139343,
0.3059377670288086,
-0.14651191234588623,
0.6004945635795593,
0.4760292172431946,
-0.2244299352169037,
1.348225474357605,
-0.3766625225543976,
0.2625288665294647,
1.4095392227172852,
-0.256093829870224,
0.9380137324333191,
0.4479624927043915,
-0.3345339894294739,
0.20008736848831177,
0.5206691026687622,
-0.4374408721923828,
0.6395826935768127,
0.5326979756355286,
-0.4799269735813141,
-0.2160429060459137,
-0.03963061422109604,
-0.04311973601579666,
0.6577470302581787,
0.47578275203704834,
-0.331799179315567,
-0.18680360913276672,
0.010261462070047855,
-0.1810148060321808,
-0.2461024820804596,
-0.25722673535346985,
0.7311697006225586,
0.30287298560142517,
-0.23271207511425018,
0.4207131266593933,
-0.03038649819791317,
0.5937660932540894,
-0.6895660758018494,
-0.3649972975254059,
-0.22551381587982178,
0.4491114616394043,
-0.2499435693025589,
-0.8536087870597839,
-0.19362883269786835,
-0.18610231578350067,
-0.22209253907203674,
0.11349070817232132,
0.8153548240661621,
-0.5482652187347412,
-0.7208935022354126,
0.12075180560350418,
0.1934393048286438,
0.19657489657402039,
-0.3597537875175476,
-0.7499363422393799,
-0.3263799846172333,
-0.08256827294826508,
-0.4108121991157532,
0.3540400266647339,
0.35598430037498474,
0.18362700939178467,
0.8195750713348389,
0.552051305770874,
0.2997424900531769,
0.12487716227769852,
-0.1705545336008072,
0.7882683873176575,
-0.7267967462539673,
0.07037533819675446,
-0.9870222806930542,
0.3546799421310425,
0.26750025153160095,
-0.434488445520401,
0.5023946166038513,
0.7054040431976318,
0.7360408902168274,
-0.24832873046398163,
0.7123825550079346,
0.4144041836261749,
0.2459263801574707,
-0.8252459168434143,
0.6157423257827759,
-0.20779407024383545,
0.5115329623222351,
-0.04984039440751076,
-1.088411569595337,
-0.4206973910331726,
0.5358134508132935,
-0.16754096746444702,
0.3395993113517761,
0.6826801896095276,
1.2094788551330566,
-0.3495159149169922,
-0.37314316630363464,
0.29326245188713074,
0.37595444917678833,
0.36086270213127136,
1.0110278129577637,
0.554038941860199,
-0.3817156255245209,
0.40429994463920593,
-0.5962562561035156,
0.04445885494351387,
-0.2592379152774811,
-1.1045368909835815,
-1.0083447694778442,
-0.0027481408324092627,
-0.32978469133377075,
-0.28621187806129456,
0.12198060750961304,
1.2786310911178589,
0.8795322179794312,
-1.0592741966247559,
-0.14247819781303406,
-0.5973158478736877,
-0.0885845348238945,
0.023067783564329147,
-0.20769913494586945,
0.3149723410606384,
-0.016133537515997887,
-0.5594165325164795,
0.8117490410804749,
0.7423004508018494,
0.49219173192977905,
-0.12728267908096313,
-0.12378787249326706,
-0.028652938082814217,
-0.19733700156211853,
0.6047561764717102,
0.43038490414619446,
-0.6693195104598999,
0.02465507574379444,
-0.13178202509880066,
-0.18153464794158936,
0.3479996621608734,
0.8514689207077026,
-0.7473647594451904,
0.5080727338790894,
0.6154190301895142,
0.49393370747566223,
0.774286687374115,
-0.02328123152256012,
0.6942340731620789,
-0.9882359504699707,
0.2600169777870178,
0.4506719410419464,
0.31394287943840027,
0.14319780468940735,
-0.4968893527984619,
0.6129125952720642,
0.07123995572328568,
-0.539424479007721,
-0.49197426438331604,
0.2428811490535736,
-1.2898399829864502,
-0.4135788381099701,
1.2121602296829224,
-0.11029308289289474,
-0.19961342215538025,
0.3193153738975525,
-0.1279616504907608,
-0.04706541448831558,
-0.6064327359199524,
0.4711689352989197,
0.5524576306343079,
-0.3207373023033142,
-0.6332213878631592,
-0.8630086779594421,
0.7322595715522766,
0.15593688189983368,
-0.8052095770835876,
-0.025680730119347572,
0.5100371837615967,
0.22351227700710297,
-0.3067581057548523,
0.4988645613193512,
0.16993264853954315,
0.2146005630493164,
-0.05764571949839592,
-0.17987574636936188,
-0.32889214158058167,
-0.6025499105453491,
-0.3910304605960846,
-0.07215531915426254,
0.06197378784418106,
0.03275604546070099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12566v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12566v2
|
RichRAG: Crafting Rich Responses for Multi-faceted Queries in Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-06-18T12:52:51 | 2024-06-21T18:12:15 |
Shuting Wang, Xin Yu, Mang Wang, Weipeng Chen, Yutao Zhu, Zhicheng Dou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) effectively addresses issues of static
knowledge and hallucination in large language models. Existing studies mostly
focus on question scenarios with clear user intents and concise answers.
However, it is prevalent that users issue broad, open-ended queries with
diverse sub-intents, for which they desire rich and long-form answers covering
multiple relevant aspects. To tackle this important yet underexplored problem,
we propose a novel RAG framework, namely RichRAG. It includes a sub-aspect
explorer to identify potential sub-aspects of input questions, a multi-faceted
retriever to build a candidate pool of diverse external documents related to
these sub-aspects, and a generative list-wise ranker, which is a key module to
provide the top-k most valuable documents for the final generator. These ranked
documents sufficiently cover various query aspects and are aware of the
generator's preferences, hence incentivizing it to produce rich and
comprehensive responses for users. The training of our ranker involves a
supervised fine-tuning stage to ensure the basic coverage of documents, and a
reinforcement learning stage to align downstream LLM's preferences to the
ranking of documents. Experimental results on two publicly available datasets
prove that our framework effectively and efficiently provides comprehensive and
satisfying responses to users.
|
[
-0.8066781759262085,
-0.8380969166755676,
0.26152971386909485,
0.1854187697172165,
-0.06387682259082794,
0.17773045599460602,
-0.1664734184741974,
-0.4057583808898926,
0.5445907711982727,
0.6074696779251099,
-0.321318119764328,
-0.08412593603134155,
-0.5420143008232117,
0.021075746044516563,
-0.4332907497882843,
1.4740757942199707,
0.1467789262533188,
-0.31850501894950867,
-0.19399595260620117,
-0.18477167189121246,
-0.3208635151386261,
-0.4061447083950043,
-0.5657841563224792,
-0.1910611391067505,
1.0306333303451538,
0.3921240568161011,
0.537642240524292,
0.2542904317378998,
0.21169978380203247,
0.26068180799484253,
-0.2387230098247528,
0.5113382339477539,
-0.8425189256668091,
0.8179073929786682,
-0.422981858253479,
-0.2344464659690857,
-0.3991149663925171,
-0.22443027794361115,
0.403372585773468,
0.5308734178543091,
0.07688659429550171,
0.3099208176136017,
0.2903495132923126,
0.6132828593254089,
-0.8996471166610718,
-0.2901413142681122,
-0.850399374961853,
-0.007318584248423576,
-0.43628883361816406,
-0.4935026466846466,
-0.2806439995765686,
0.10503123700618744,
-0.2564789950847626,
-0.6554852724075317,
0.4800805151462555,
0.09721271693706512,
0.7417343258857727,
0.2776832580566406,
-0.35867705941200256,
-0.3441987931728363,
-0.8075271248817444,
0.5961455702781677,
-0.18784703314304352,
0.3715551495552063,
0.4888116121292114,
0.5991930961608887,
-0.03924212232232094,
-0.6197882890701294,
-0.5908677577972412,
0.20004823803901672,
-0.1780022233724594,
0.3249742090702057,
0.3610880970954895,
-0.15961122512817383,
0.08113877475261688,
0.6290295720100403,
-0.6675305962562561,
-0.09607038646936417,
-0.21323952078819275,
-0.07440505176782608,
0.6913089156150818,
0.11260420829057693,
-0.060874130576848984,
-0.3818497061729431,
-0.2712312638759613,
-0.16077734529972076,
-0.5763760805130005,
-0.015006489120423794,
0.5158240795135498,
0.42483362555503845,
0.15554067492485046,
0.962441086769104,
-0.5378957390785217,
0.6444907784461975,
0.34495121240615845,
-0.0162952933460474,
0.0013572369934991002,
-0.3662862181663513,
0.02265695109963417,
-0.031009050086140633,
0.48453488945961,
-0.034175388514995575,
-0.0971044972538948,
-0.1809442937374115,
-0.6251634955406189,
-0.4140990078449249,
0.4569677710533142,
-1.0800837278366089,
-0.010130050592124462,
0.4959506094455719,
-0.24814358353614807,
-0.3202860951423645,
-0.05495276674628258,
-1.085599660873413,
-0.7318731546401978,
-0.22483167052268982,
0.551091730594635,
-0.06483892351388931,
-0.1651260405778885,
-0.1042192131280899,
-0.14150139689445496,
0.3000704050064087,
0.3111051023006439,
-0.8366613388061523,
0.15343810617923737,
0.8337000608444214,
0.43018707633018494,
0.010507380589842796,
-0.34477493166923523,
-1.2109901905059814,
0.32860618829727173,
-0.1626611053943634,
1.2107274532318115,
-0.7112973928451538,
-0.3306421935558319,
-0.021806005388498306,
-0.16625824570655823,
0.00497132632881403,
-0.668664813041687,
0.44391709566116333,
-0.947301983833313,
0.5217012763023376,
-0.31030768156051636,
-0.27053144574165344,
0.12178613245487213,
0.6184587478637695,
-0.711905300617218,
1.1356786489486694,
0.28181302547454834,
-1.1048089265823364,
0.40042370557785034,
-0.422058641910553,
-0.32924917340278625,
0.28468090295791626,
-0.30488625168800354,
-0.49203112721443176,
0.1345483660697937,
0.29043713212013245,
0.4667266607284546,
-0.3061397671699524,
0.3506222367286682,
-0.12344282865524292,
-0.4177659749984741,
0.19372038543224335,
-0.18059663474559784,
0.39627689123153687,
0.39108899235725403,
-0.23372402787208557,
0.40304574370384216,
-0.5050933957099915,
-0.018168525770306587,
0.09096301347017288,
-0.6048891544342041,
-0.33151042461395264,
-0.043175455182790756,
0.319551020860672,
0.12566159665584564,
0.2514759302139282,
-0.46676522493362427,
0.21762850880622864,
-0.3991614878177643,
-0.19700808823108673,
0.5334765315055847,
0.1314905732870102,
0.3800787627696991,
-0.49103081226348877,
0.6372570395469666,
-0.0349682979285717,
-0.013001525774598122,
-0.13583357632160187,
-0.22385601699352264,
-0.732466995716095,
-0.34913113713264465,
0.3557896018028259,
0.39628246426582336,
-0.9319894313812256,
0.2660803496837616,
-0.3009546399116516,
-0.3574134111404419,
-0.6404069662094116,
0.2619105577468872,
0.3951747417449951,
0.2765135169029236,
0.5118385553359985,
-0.14363451302051544,
-0.40771928429603577,
-0.6926310062408447,
-0.376166433095932,
0.0719241127371788,
-0.13516871631145477,
0.7490139007568359,
0.3671948313713074,
-0.28619205951690674,
0.758495032787323,
-0.4141782820224762,
-0.33800745010375977,
-0.5177070498466492,
0.15836021304130554,
0.054984789341688156,
0.1914708912372589,
0.3555760681629181,
-1.1429332494735718,
-0.5234992504119873,
0.09949969500303268,
-0.4759122431278229,
-0.08882299065589905,
-0.03560831770300865,
-0.40337327122688293,
0.0020811473950743675,
0.10880877822637558,
-0.7003027200698853,
0.09388930350542068,
0.34048721194267273,
-0.3110669255256653,
0.35891762375831604,
0.04237530007958412,
0.20144380629062653,
-1.4216512441635132,
0.3402208983898163,
-0.38944941759109497,
-0.10498521476984024,
-0.30696380138397217,
0.45108479261398315,
-0.16700471937656403,
-0.3440433144569397,
-0.18597272038459778,
0.9648025631904602,
-0.17685961723327637,
-0.400042325258255,
-0.24751457571983337,
0.13098248839378357,
0.12628382444381714,
0.3034023940563202,
-0.12293683737516403,
0.9198473691940308,
0.15146541595458984,
-0.5449802875518799,
0.19067250192165375,
0.28248128294944763,
0.08223401010036469,
0.6722704768180847,
-0.7613051533699036,
0.07219893485307693,
-0.45163199305534363,
0.28419598937034607,
-0.7023323178291321,
-0.6356096863746643,
-0.05764981359243393,
-0.46467578411102295,
0.4614078402519226,
-0.3401826024055481,
-0.37385544180870056,
-0.06292889267206192,
-0.4901362657546997,
0.4930057227611542,
0.1311456710100174,
-0.540813684463501,
0.932846188545227,
0.4091266691684723,
-0.36513569951057434,
-0.8203504681587219,
-0.18403251469135284,
-0.05686274543404579,
-0.2335585504770279,
-0.4785453975200653,
0.42079004645347595,
-0.1775609701871872,
-0.14871619641780853,
0.07190027087926865,
-0.07158163189888,
-0.10036710649728775,
0.10650792717933655,
0.06185857579112053,
-0.08652754873037338,
0.02746247500181198,
-0.0024664869997650385,
0.1763569861650467,
-0.07875452935695648,
-0.3547595143318176,
-0.07747843116521835,
0.7679752111434937,
0.14020277559757233,
-0.4080412983894348,
0.3478308618068695,
0.6230653524398804,
0.41205939650535583,
-0.8132954835891724,
0.6350549459457397,
0.9819434881210327,
-0.19501976668834686,
-0.5864912867546082,
-0.4680825471878052,
-0.18783926963806152,
-0.4127182364463806,
0.24836380779743195,
-0.6146663427352905,
-1.0604428052902222,
0.5787240266799927,
0.0787573978304863,
0.21195189654827118,
0.4382292926311493,
0.7097432613372803,
0.026405997574329376,
0.9633963108062744,
0.46699970960617065,
0.06226694956421852,
0.3115561902523041,
-0.3599269390106201,
0.22867272794246674,
-1.0646916627883911,
-0.3913365602493286,
-0.7255424857139587,
-0.4751247465610504,
-0.6914398670196533,
-0.463467001914978,
0.624196469783783,
0.37462446093559265,
-0.2885085642337799,
0.004314069170504808,
-0.5918172001838684,
0.285328209400177,
0.4447306990623474,
-0.14692148566246033,
0.21644273400306702,
-0.013103044591844082,
-0.051468122750520706,
0.25306805968284607,
-0.5905286073684692,
-0.2172948271036148,
0.9251133799552917,
0.027903489768505096,
0.910636842250824,
0.12051411718130112,
1.0911781787872314,
0.12142182886600494,
0.27840492129325867,
-0.7880403399467468,
0.3736594617366791,
0.006509370170533657,
-0.7854469418525696,
-0.3780464231967926,
-0.5650267601013184,
-1.1054229736328125,
0.5908988118171692,
-0.30730628967285156,
-0.23339320719242096,
0.14335541427135468,
0.0761423259973526,
-0.4104226231575012,
0.08236660063266754,
-0.10974791646003723,
0.6510734558105469,
-0.3901533782482147,
-0.760718822479248,
-0.07334902882575989,
-0.5121862888336182,
0.4035526216030121,
-0.11639561504125595,
0.13818764686584473,
0.1874726265668869,
-0.032966796308755875,
0.5360330939292908,
-0.0905705913901329,
0.37804827094078064,
-0.2081308364868164,
-0.00968626793473959,
0.1886652708053589,
0.20518118143081665,
0.5044012665748596,
0.37464216351509094,
-0.17363479733467102,
-0.43813076615333557,
-0.19953984022140503,
-0.445119708776474,
-0.565493643283844,
0.8015633821487427,
-0.5401456356048584,
-0.4513983428478241,
-0.3424343466758728,
-0.6851041913032532,
-0.3121866285800934,
0.3486365079879761,
0.2168959379196167,
0.4399382472038269,
-0.009064286015927792,
0.32244837284088135,
0.9975230693817139,
-0.44873207807540894,
0.11205035448074341,
0.30269041657447815,
-0.4601273834705353,
-0.5066867470741272,
0.970635175704956,
-0.01427603978663683,
-0.1786736100912094,
0.5556380152702332,
0.22703075408935547,
-0.22634772956371307,
-0.4997877776622772,
-0.7502961158752441,
0.1493588238954544,
-0.373384028673172,
-0.4627809226512909,
-0.9792872071266174,
-0.30009225010871887,
-0.37710049748420715,
-0.02919403463602066,
-0.33001869916915894,
-0.36063647270202637,
-0.0021727036219090223,
0.10214196890592575,
0.3084169924259186,
0.7250985503196716,
0.14151372015476227,
-0.134018212556839,
-0.7410439252853394,
0.7408748865127563,
0.6490501165390015,
0.5138856172561646,
-0.0788913369178772,
-0.3770536482334137,
-0.2793666124343872,
-0.09305133670568466,
-0.41436293721199036,
-0.52554851770401,
0.33950960636138916,
0.2409340888261795,
0.7022156715393066,
0.08749724179506302,
0.26814231276512146,
0.5858202576637268,
-0.3399534821510315,
0.7785455584526062,
-0.4967626929283142,
-0.28840160369873047,
0.5730298161506653,
-0.5364667177200317,
0.07216373085975647,
0.828223466873169,
0.4454670548439026,
-0.36301305890083313,
-0.33719494938850403,
-0.4903710186481476,
-1.1307337284088135,
0.3759738504886627,
0.03961190953850746,
0.1872493177652359,
0.033361662179231644,
0.18267561495304108,
0.28424379229545593,
0.36874908208847046,
-0.381114661693573,
-0.000023881872039055452,
-0.3865780532360077,
-0.09019206464290619,
0.09427042305469513,
-0.2691923677921295,
-0.3118986487388611,
0.044936809688806534,
0.6885795593261719,
-0.3206697702407837,
0.1458657830953598,
0.10001884400844574,
-0.02158726006746292,
-0.13190390169620514,
0.609498918056488,
0.43002891540527344,
0.5030948519706726,
-0.205987811088562,
0.2987346053123474,
-0.25580182671546936,
-0.314389169216156,
-0.2264070361852646,
0.5988690257072449,
-0.2897288501262665,
-0.2007022500038147,
0.26945334672927856,
0.5657100081443787,
0.09044650197029114,
-0.5827928185462952,
0.48961693048477173,
-0.014534318819642067,
0.0032623731531202793,
-0.09938198328018188,
0.06506744027137756,
0.02019495703279972,
0.2610248625278473,
0.47421637177467346,
-0.21232548356056213,
0.38975995779037476,
-0.5441073179244995,
0.20150324702262878,
0.6594939231872559,
-0.14556315541267395,
-0.17766299843788147,
0.84300297498703,
0.19373202323913574,
-0.17620635032653809,
0.3649662137031555,
-0.40276631712913513,
-0.7752456068992615,
0.11306557059288025,
0.368943989276886,
0.7925283908843994,
0.010933137498795986,
0.2547462284564972,
0.15634028613567352,
-0.08340425789356232,
0.08180360496044159,
0.49199485778808594,
-0.44142526388168335,
-0.4608011245727539,
-0.4756939709186554,
-1.1886506080627441,
-0.29863929748535156,
0.22473667562007904,
-0.5574102401733398,
-0.07454951852560043,
-0.15339387953281403,
0.14354166388511658,
-0.14662130177021027,
0.24508218467235565,
-0.6859738826751709,
0.10980047285556793,
-0.20955321192741394,
0.6021247506141663,
-0.44313445687294006,
0.40630581974983215,
0.7897282242774963,
-0.6505866050720215,
-0.7557816505432129,
0.1137700229883194,
-0.30467987060546875,
-0.5149715542793274,
0.5780401825904846,
-0.0769532173871994,
-0.080453060567379,
-0.04944481700658798,
-0.33831483125686646,
-0.6858101487159729,
0.9528142809867859,
0.16168883442878723,
-0.12844182550907135,
0.005943514872342348,
0.028871072456240654,
0.42634832859039307,
-0.1507757157087326,
0.3681899607181549,
0.06729152798652649,
0.41841921210289,
0.18914894759655,
-0.8649423718452454,
-0.16973571479320526,
-0.4214276075363159,
-0.03626972436904907,
0.39618879556655884,
-0.6840544939041138,
0.948890745639801,
0.052032455801963806,
-0.021019650623202324,
0.009707968682050705,
0.4736625850200653,
0.5736609101295471,
0.5262332558631897,
0.28236737847328186,
0.808155357837677,
0.6215660572052002,
0.18664862215518951,
1.278327465057373,
-0.3177381157875061,
0.1985778659582138,
1.1075047254562378,
-0.344648152589798,
0.9033779501914978,
0.4139663577079773,
0.14165949821472168,
0.36884814500808716,
0.4200085699558258,
0.39963123202323914,
0.5627309083938599,
0.15023651719093323,
-0.518953263759613,
-0.29459649324417114,
-0.42199385166168213,
-0.4214017987251282,
0.47489961981773376,
0.21841837465763092,
-0.14337603747844696,
-0.40464693307876587,
-0.05214131250977516,
-0.2269248217344284,
0.20136548578739166,
-0.18111319839954376,
1.0005078315734863,
-0.1746189296245575,
-0.6825315356254578,
0.523191511631012,
0.00225769798271358,
0.7727052569389343,
-0.46621614694595337,
-0.17399683594703674,
-0.6633242964744568,
-0.013083936646580696,
-0.3135596811771393,
-0.8285748958587646,
0.12791360914707184,
0.15170598030090332,
-0.31139805912971497,
-0.3609660267829895,
0.9340791702270508,
-0.5077056884765625,
-0.3502405285835266,
-0.027904003858566284,
0.7834436297416687,
0.1666945070028305,
-0.24509169161319733,
-0.5325794219970703,
0.10884706676006317,
-0.3288120627403259,
-0.6250308156013489,
0.6555852890014648,
0.7456580996513367,
-0.11964377760887146,
0.3997727334499359,
0.5582379698753357,
0.25384971499443054,
0.007402963470667601,
0.2710488438606262,
1.1852213144302368,
-0.3705393075942993,
-0.3849112093448639,
-0.102016381919384,
0.6317301392555237,
-0.24355673789978027,
-0.2507581114768982,
0.7210233211517334,
0.9271406531333923,
0.9459099173545837,
0.18757136166095734,
0.6778915524482727,
-0.23417018353939056,
0.7416512370109558,
-0.26598140597343445,
0.7906840443611145,
-0.7568648457527161,
0.347854346036911,
-0.06138487532734871,
-1.2012611627578735,
-0.04050152748823166,
0.4102915823459625,
0.02734670229256153,
0.23555272817611694,
0.28564319014549255,
0.7969441413879395,
-0.27125054597854614,
-0.39539238810539246,
0.17789813876152039,
-0.08010926842689514,
0.42885881662368774,
0.3233951926231384,
0.7881284356117249,
-0.3540979325771332,
0.5380934476852417,
-0.1711570918560028,
-0.05998201295733452,
-0.2594622075557709,
-0.4808715581893921,
-0.7615881562232971,
-0.511260449886322,
0.3026805818080902,
-0.2531245946884155,
0.09685855358839035,
0.6783294677734375,
0.5721418261528015,
-0.660783588886261,
-0.008951175957918167,
0.16255806386470795,
0.15868966281414032,
0.03978681191802025,
-0.2579144537448883,
0.2763429582118988,
-0.5787141919136047,
-0.5892374515533447,
0.4240800440311432,
0.12541146576404572,
-0.27104443311691284,
-0.5437084436416626,
-0.1206926703453064,
-0.061253469437360764,
-0.0037506965454667807,
0.7946977615356445,
0.1883271336555481,
-0.4340890347957611,
-0.11436796933412552,
0.16423331201076508,
-0.06534357368946075,
-0.16585159301757812,
0.9141330122947693,
-1.0190523862838745,
0.39223209023475647,
0.7045167088508606,
1.2196388244628906,
0.8037391304969788,
0.3170042634010315,
0.16474488377571106,
-0.9369386434555054,
-0.056340716779232025,
0.5446621179580688,
-0.03707617148756981,
0.47093361616134644,
-0.515954852104187,
0.5429869294166565,
-0.08084724098443985,
-0.7019700407981873,
-0.7870544195175171,
0.2575715482234955,
-0.9691614508628845,
-0.2993437349796295,
1.1591923236846924,
0.26742491126060486,
0.0724201574921608,
-0.13571101427078247,
-0.23340825736522675,
0.14274165034294128,
-0.37417513132095337,
0.8488438725471497,
0.2519962191581726,
-0.3414573073387146,
-0.1839560568332672,
-0.7048868536949158,
0.500459611415863,
0.32477378845214844,
-0.9755081534385681,
0.17278429865837097,
0.7703749537467957,
0.06567050516605377,
0.26657724380493164,
0.6215866208076477,
-0.09103289991617203,
0.09744580835103989,
-0.059235431253910065,
-0.2126942276954651,
-0.20760153234004974,
-0.6653388738632202,
0.07752852141857147,
0.687311053276062,
0.3347819149494171,
0.25637882947921753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12564v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12564v1
|
Low-Resource Machine Translation through the Lens of Personalized Federated Learning
| 2024-06-18T12:50:00 | 2024-06-18T12:50:00 |
Viktor Moskvoretskii, Nazarii Tupitsa, Chris Biemann, Samuel Horváth, Eduard Gorbunov, Irina Nikishina
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present a new approach based on the Personalized Federated Learning
algorithm MeritFed that can be applied to Natural Language Tasks with
heterogeneous data. We evaluate it on the Low-Resource Machine Translation
task, using the dataset from the Large-Scale Multilingual Machine Translation
Shared Task (Small Track #2) and the subset of Sami languages from the
multilingual benchmark for Finno-Ugric languages. In addition to its
effectiveness, MeritFed is also highly interpretable, as it can be applied to
track the impact of each language used for training. Our analysis reveals that
target dataset size affects weight distribution across auxiliary languages,
that unrelated languages do not interfere with the training, and auxiliary
optimizer parameters have minimal impact. Our approach is easy to apply with a
few lines of code, and we provide scripts for reproducing the experiments at
https://github.com/VityaVitalich/MeritFed
|
[
-0.2012302726507187,
-0.2798902988433838,
0.3952646255493164,
0.3168332874774933,
-0.18005217611789703,
0.11118702590465546,
-0.5320151448249817,
-0.307737797498703,
0.3920666575431824,
0.5473713278770447,
-0.8659736514091492,
-0.5258844494819641,
-0.7207319736480713,
0.5835575461387634,
0.010295907035470009,
1.0431114435195923,
-0.2712422013282776,
0.37047019600868225,
-0.3903922438621521,
-0.7624979019165039,
-0.4312639534473419,
-0.3274233341217041,
-0.2412545382976532,
-0.43986862897872925,
0.6869924068450928,
0.8923165798187256,
0.37267953157424927,
0.7215085625648499,
0.9921162724494934,
0.3356734812259674,
0.26692360639572144,
0.09347651153802872,
-0.7902988791465759,
0.23683758080005646,
-0.17975521087646484,
-0.6945099234580994,
-0.22038055956363678,
0.0680910274386406,
0.8927282094955444,
0.983181893825531,
-0.017211630940437317,
0.7279414534568787,
-0.025017863139510155,
0.6266590356826782,
-0.49154648184776306,
0.27559927105903625,
-0.508274495601654,
0.18834972381591797,
-0.4672945439815521,
0.019301550462841988,
-0.4243115484714508,
-0.21140681207180023,
-0.17763635516166687,
-0.6348362565040588,
0.28136226534843445,
0.2542249262332916,
0.33746337890625,
0.6883094906806946,
-0.06544782966375351,
0.09062011539936066,
-0.5429094433784485,
1.1868127584457397,
-0.3625611364841461,
0.4391593039035797,
0.538745641708374,
0.5287383794784546,
0.040027398616075516,
-0.7006457448005676,
-0.31553584337234497,
0.05689007788896561,
-0.4721175730228424,
-0.1963307410478592,
-0.2426905483007431,
-0.1429699957370758,
0.2017252892255783,
0.5614886283874512,
-0.5142760872840881,
0.10707703232765198,
-0.22118550539016724,
-0.1885807365179062,
0.6122123599052429,
0.3291429877281189,
0.06973855197429657,
-0.133267343044281,
-0.4017397165298462,
-0.10352969169616699,
-0.31621551513671875,
0.07578330487012863,
0.3433395326137543,
0.8472084403038025,
-0.4441702663898468,
0.4318755567073822,
-0.8908172845840454,
0.5548635125160217,
0.33619382977485657,
-0.3132893443107605,
0.711122989654541,
-0.573663592338562,
-0.3416386842727661,
0.09325572848320007,
0.8466882109642029,
-0.13792720437049866,
-0.459921270608902,
-0.4687659442424774,
-0.3733230531215668,
-0.42760008573532104,
0.004988301079720259,
-0.6794221997261047,
-0.03620404750108719,
-0.17318542301654816,
-0.6008852124214172,
-0.2429671585559845,
-0.28329285979270935,
-0.5624561905860901,
-0.25889042019844055,
-0.48215213418006897,
0.27656370401382446,
-0.2320503294467926,
0.07054813951253891,
-0.2712998688220978,
0.24225130677223206,
-0.08584912121295929,
0.3665633499622345,
-1.0568617582321167,
0.3330615162849426,
0.5753942728042603,
0.980902373790741,
-0.23833513259887695,
-0.3700924217700958,
-1.2974523305892944,
-0.10451020300388336,
0.16611817479133606,
0.5319629907608032,
-0.491703599691391,
0.06898415088653564,
-0.15568074584007263,
0.26823222637176514,
-0.14434808492660522,
-0.40235865116119385,
0.77051842212677,
-0.39209550619125366,
0.47709304094314575,
-0.6464647650718689,
-0.19766472280025482,
-0.3111966848373413,
0.17699584364891052,
-0.6659159064292908,
0.7401734590530396,
0.5730241537094116,
-0.7160406708717346,
0.3811894953250885,
-0.6407420039176941,
-0.680404543876648,
0.28178560733795166,
-0.10669378191232681,
-0.34277084469795227,
0.2028212696313858,
0.07403133809566498,
0.5834574103355408,
-0.6301249861717224,
0.25805947184562683,
-0.4481831192970276,
-0.2380656599998474,
-0.12383748590946198,
-0.44265058636665344,
0.8046271800994873,
0.45115768909454346,
-0.49511972069740295,
0.10708657652139664,
-0.6284494996070862,
0.040833551436662674,
0.17617559432983398,
-0.5848698616027832,
-0.45070692896842957,
-0.39771154522895813,
0.33086514472961426,
0.2805195450782776,
0.4220609664916992,
-0.6387528777122498,
0.0649661123752594,
-0.41620564460754395,
-0.03401772677898407,
0.63184654712677,
-0.32482364773750305,
0.8553067445755005,
-0.054698407649993896,
0.5883519053459167,
-0.2708890438079834,
0.06649389117956161,
0.20396539568901062,
-0.18973441421985626,
-0.6023121476173401,
-0.42032745480537415,
0.3687000274658203,
0.25155991315841675,
-0.936528742313385,
0.1070607379078865,
-0.4272845387458801,
-0.1790759414434433,
-0.9295732378959656,
0.6265566349029541,
0.7083631753921509,
0.5720189213752747,
0.5757561922073364,
-0.4419700801372528,
-0.3611688017845154,
-0.9070647954940796,
-0.08430998772382736,
0.17394088208675385,
-0.04630385339260101,
0.26729094982147217,
0.22600537538528442,
-0.5038082003593445,
0.6629025936126709,
-0.5134247541427612,
-0.5956027507781982,
-0.44060173630714417,
0.12604549527168274,
0.2298864871263504,
0.5452075600624084,
0.6535508036613464,
-0.727469265460968,
-0.6009329557418823,
0.4582541286945343,
-0.6981946229934692,
-0.24754664301872253,
0.15470334887504578,
-0.3368815779685974,
0.03446369990706444,
-0.052481021732091904,
-0.21559327840805054,
-0.25824636220932007,
0.8460158705711365,
-0.37602365016937256,
0.16853858530521393,
-0.20748381316661835,
0.32859671115875244,
-1.1580119132995605,
0.2223927527666092,
0.024564094841480255,
-0.4872581958770752,
-0.5270513296127319,
0.04652566462755203,
-0.1285111904144287,
-0.10916496813297272,
-0.481987327337265,
0.5943458080291748,
-0.3291606903076172,
-0.37900567054748535,
-0.17225290834903717,
-0.10439546406269073,
-0.3260060250759125,
0.5261769890785217,
-0.11968554556369781,
0.5281387567520142,
0.00948577281087637,
-0.2573356032371521,
0.33942246437072754,
0.3610383868217468,
-0.18451827764511108,
0.7954474091529846,
-0.1995435357093811,
-0.008467525243759155,
-0.00911687035113573,
-0.03858930245041847,
-0.44131964445114136,
-0.6903428435325623,
0.5816907286643982,
-0.2667405903339386,
0.21598607301712036,
0.07644238322973251,
-0.41082778573036194,
-0.12864921987056732,
0.004098108503967524,
0.28866052627563477,
0.21738842129707336,
-0.7382333874702454,
0.3116346597671509,
0.4858112335205078,
-0.008659946732223034,
-0.4766647517681122,
-0.6903231739997864,
-0.10312564671039581,
-0.1369393765926361,
-0.46874794363975525,
0.25230860710144043,
-0.006873939651995897,
-0.22693364322185516,
-0.04173910245299339,
-0.07096849381923676,
-0.29001766443252563,
0.39303168654441833,
0.26689472794532776,
-0.1317622810602188,
-0.2998282313346863,
0.19520772993564606,
0.33081701397895813,
-0.11696416884660721,
-0.17728251218795776,
-0.5348494648933411,
0.5222681164741516,
-0.3393033742904663,
-0.28207680583000183,
-0.6491903066635132,
0.27128782868385315,
0.31097087264060974,
-0.3699289858341217,
0.8715556263923645,
1.125218391418457,
-0.33207806944847107,
-0.17909741401672363,
-0.35742005705833435,
-0.11361468583345413,
-0.42758074402809143,
0.258918434381485,
-0.35868632793426514,
-1.0201865434646606,
0.306959867477417,
-0.042834777384996414,
0.11165071278810501,
0.5056155323982239,
0.6724830269813538,
-0.19792932271957397,
0.692546010017395,
1.0344622135162354,
-0.5152063965797424,
0.48977726697921753,
-0.25699639320373535,
-0.15695808827877045,
-0.5782016515731812,
-0.143312469124794,
-0.5093266367912292,
-0.7711933851242065,
-0.5624089241027832,
-0.6893677115440369,
0.10237271338701248,
-0.10102595388889313,
-0.14355935156345367,
0.3665406405925751,
-0.24331450462341309,
0.2401372492313385,
0.8619853258132935,
-0.126360222697258,
0.5172795653343201,
0.3056897222995758,
-0.0009567940724082291,
-0.1701524406671524,
-0.911888599395752,
-0.22022804617881775,
1.026125431060791,
0.18804454803466797,
0.5989710092544556,
0.04019608348608017,
1.0935910940170288,
0.536293089389801,
0.6722753643989563,
-0.5700689554214478,
0.22381235659122467,
-0.3380831778049469,
-0.4361113905906677,
-0.4066987931728363,
-0.9477068781852722,
-0.5929966568946838,
0.4917202889919281,
-0.2664782702922821,
-0.34521448612213135,
0.20521175861358643,
0.30280110239982605,
-0.06685497611761093,
0.12338630110025406,
-0.8052577376365662,
1.0313559770584106,
-0.47343015670776367,
-0.3752880394458771,
-0.3619081676006317,
-0.6697895526885986,
0.5825276970863342,
-0.22672943770885468,
0.13078176975250244,
-0.15505947172641754,
0.17633536458015442,
0.8069009780883789,
-0.3997369706630707,
0.7571726441383362,
-0.23660454154014587,
0.24792683124542236,
-0.10971976816654205,
-0.2593652009963989,
0.5630919933319092,
0.16004358232021332,
-0.1842399686574936,
0.39055806398391724,
-0.3233155310153961,
-0.7007825374603271,
-0.2753792107105255,
0.8351346254348755,
-0.726895809173584,
-0.25848686695098877,
-0.2650783956050873,
-0.6681531071662903,
-0.22139090299606323,
0.4006134569644928,
0.32330453395843506,
0.1263379454612732,
-0.30521905422210693,
0.35722076892852783,
0.38894638419151306,
-0.056733835488557816,
0.3052985966205597,
0.759386420249939,
0.31844115257263184,
-0.6285184621810913,
1.0925170183181763,
-0.09647513926029205,
0.27349403500556946,
0.6569746136665344,
0.19671078026294708,
-0.09975450485944748,
-0.47099512815475464,
-0.6307049989700317,
0.2973584830760956,
-0.5331891775131226,
-0.37745100259780884,
-0.7679057121276855,
0.5668205618858337,
-0.34065935015678406,
-0.15916697680950165,
-0.6233092546463013,
-0.2877746820449829,
-0.2589317858219147,
0.07277868688106537,
0.20170500874519348,
0.33767059445381165,
0.07921455800533295,
0.45635905861854553,
-0.7969430685043335,
0.09573347866535187,
0.09710720181465149,
0.37427154183387756,
-0.3770720064640045,
-0.37620922923088074,
-0.6494197249412537,
0.20134887099266052,
-0.014857438392937183,
-0.39846646785736084,
0.35618826746940613,
0.10356806218624115,
0.7418726086616516,
0.40743812918663025,
0.371794193983078,
0.3933749496936798,
-0.3988911807537079,
0.3112671375274658,
0.6153153777122498,
-0.7953556180000305,
0.25419023633003235,
-0.22889955341815948,
0.49368199706077576,
1.0988268852233887,
0.3367452025413513,
-0.7009151577949524,
-0.4564847946166992,
-0.39482370018959045,
-0.42048150300979614,
1.1275365352630615,
0.2551233768463135,
-0.0006296100909821689,
0.41628044843673706,
0.055821098387241364,
0.3841375410556793,
0.3863108158111572,
-0.5760374665260315,
-0.36404532194137573,
-0.019446132704615593,
-0.6208547949790955,
-0.48056742548942566,
0.09631431102752686,
-0.258653849363327,
-0.20863817632198334,
0.566262423992157,
-0.5192651748657227,
0.19454768300056458,
-0.15236251056194305,
-0.4646025598049164,
-0.4205734133720398,
0.21030443906784058,
0.5915676951408386,
0.1797773540019989,
-0.18477332592010498,
0.012557693757116795,
0.2352549433708191,
-0.48978328704833984,
0.2683928310871124,
0.5561854243278503,
-0.41928255558013916,
0.1914188116788864,
0.4643825888633728,
0.9918310642242432,
0.42906662821769714,
-0.5670243501663208,
0.25417664647102356,
-0.20773321390151978,
-0.3281097710132599,
0.21177887916564941,
-0.12095668911933899,
-0.06269067525863647,
0.40656957030296326,
0.14637687802314758,
0.4223911166191101,
-0.02770281210541725,
-0.10928203165531158,
0.07076209783554077,
0.291380912065506,
-0.6357471346855164,
-0.713009238243103,
0.7985891699790955,
0.6739728450775146,
0.02884058654308319,
0.28678566217422485,
-0.4944410026073456,
-0.3812471330165863,
0.1891440600156784,
0.31989407539367676,
1.0558000802993774,
-0.2174762338399887,
0.6174468994140625,
0.24354076385498047,
0.5290992856025696,
-0.2813783586025238,
-0.1410059779882431,
-0.3037124574184418,
-0.49566856026649475,
-0.3917103707790375,
-0.9461586475372314,
-0.2818184494972229,
-0.03418562933802605,
-0.4724496901035309,
0.09361067414283752,
-0.30098846554756165,
0.03645825386047363,
-0.17265360057353973,
0.3917640447616577,
-1.0577640533447266,
0.0970698744058609,
0.04833890497684479,
0.40114498138427734,
-1.0319490432739258,
0.8329628109931946,
0.8563224673271179,
-0.5763863921165466,
-0.6295129060745239,
0.04256872087717056,
0.07146106660366058,
-0.6015322208404541,
0.9691219925880432,
-0.02997140772640705,
-0.0014607516350224614,
0.09442668408155441,
-0.07272408902645111,
-1.1791719198226929,
1.1465531587600708,
0.777195155620575,
-0.4599452018737793,
0.2580272853374481,
0.2379613071680069,
0.4396180510520935,
-0.4984458088874817,
-0.22641603648662567,
0.44022348523139954,
0.5561895966529846,
-0.20936591923236847,
-0.865933358669281,
0.07021819800138474,
-0.021362073719501495,
-0.1819000095129013,
0.2196502387523651,
-0.6810383796691895,
0.7027159929275513,
-0.1882553994655609,
-0.2752333879470825,
-0.2943509817123413,
0.8140247464179993,
-0.3213404417037964,
0.5686476826667786,
0.5306084156036377,
0.5483065247535706,
1.107612133026123,
-0.013411074876785278,
1.1563267707824707,
-0.04158734530210495,
0.5523026585578918,
1.2662768363952637,
-0.2626325488090515,
0.5542657375335693,
0.5407631397247314,
-0.14431054890155792,
-0.026654701679944992,
0.45599257946014404,
0.11385273188352585,
0.8108039498329163,
-0.09463871270418167,
-0.3074606955051422,
-0.2099897563457489,
-0.44877830147743225,
-0.2908787727355957,
0.5018006563186646,
-0.26226112246513367,
-0.5495777130126953,
-0.3280465602874756,
0.41013652086257935,
-0.11121814697980881,
0.23752163350582123,
-0.3248019814491272,
0.6195644736289978,
0.16843818128108978,
-0.3900168836116791,
0.7458232045173645,
0.4006061553955078,
0.7107609510421753,
-0.35664990544319153,
0.3562164306640625,
-0.5714928507804871,
0.386251300573349,
-0.10054907947778702,
-0.1600264310836792,
0.2933254539966583,
0.23568123579025269,
-0.5518584847450256,
-0.7522009611129761,
0.6482120752334595,
-0.6302770972251892,
-0.6277063488960266,
0.13695469498634338,
0.6641290783882141,
-0.16422823071479797,
0.1254812330007553,
-0.5212187767028809,
-0.10870090126991272,
0.19698351621627808,
-0.17917728424072266,
0.6614668965339661,
0.2955670654773712,
-0.056746792048215866,
0.5702927112579346,
0.539155900478363,
-0.039477840065956116,
-0.1893671751022339,
-0.054374370723962784,
0.7962012887001038,
-0.30948886275291443,
-0.6112021207809448,
-0.3733963668346405,
0.17975850403308868,
-0.031924668699502945,
-0.33952420949935913,
0.8143503665924072,
0.5126597881317139,
1.1871024370193481,
-0.33519425988197327,
0.7506340146064758,
-0.19466686248779297,
0.4646680951118469,
-0.3649234473705292,
0.8135145306587219,
-0.6189260482788086,
0.008588479831814766,
-0.3178248405456543,
-0.9132972359657288,
-0.18074588477611542,
0.22510850429534912,
-0.5201557874679565,
-0.4972313642501831,
0.6367725729942322,
0.3310984969139099,
-0.23459812998771667,
-0.19391387701034546,
0.3373360335826874,
-0.28545790910720825,
0.04101785272359848,
0.47424712777137756,
0.3187258839607239,
-0.3021087348461151,
0.538448691368103,
-0.6510196924209595,
-0.1512340009212494,
-0.5042057037353516,
-0.38072627782821655,
-0.7461512684822083,
-0.6057825088500977,
-0.22269625961780548,
0.15687774121761322,
-0.05280356854200363,
1.293279767036438,
0.6015862226486206,
-0.8612412214279175,
-0.15454939007759094,
0.0245792418718338,
0.5178218483924866,
-0.4387498199939728,
-0.14571940898895264,
0.006491202861070633,
-0.6488330960273743,
-0.9280734658241272,
0.40031465888023376,
0.15666139125823975,
-0.3010508418083191,
-0.14067134261131287,
-0.4396275281906128,
-0.212988942861557,
-0.6266902089118958,
0.6175951361656189,
0.22943556308746338,
-0.52519291639328,
-0.1820889264345169,
-0.020119454711675644,
-0.3834505081176758,
-0.03187836334109306,
0.7046745419502258,
-0.6108493208885193,
0.4322737455368042,
0.7686222791671753,
1.1869287490844727,
0.3122904598712921,
0.08884769678115845,
0.7258425951004028,
-1.0107202529907227,
0.3806290030479431,
0.17333707213401794,
0.19280505180358887,
0.47261354327201843,
-0.5027481913566589,
0.5956591367721558,
0.7155223488807678,
-0.13374824821949005,
-0.9184920787811279,
-0.10527084022760391,
-0.6412784457206726,
0.13282926380634308,
0.8901832103729248,
-0.25572270154953003,
-0.24424079060554504,
0.20334291458129883,
0.16869015991687775,
0.17124204337596893,
-0.5325587391853333,
0.512010395526886,
0.4929790794849396,
0.11856751888990402,
0.014866653829813004,
-0.5876234769821167,
0.5657820105552673,
0.5174974203109741,
-0.9979594945907593,
0.0016300072893500328,
0.6296601295471191,
0.13131055235862732,
0.19240114092826843,
0.7978159785270691,
0.24983704090118408,
0.18682050704956055,
-0.2903425693511963,
0.11826976388692856,
-0.046609122306108475,
-0.09974416345357895,
-0.5672286152839661,
0.13040857017040253,
-0.11351460963487625,
-0.41696813702583313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12549v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12549v1
|
MultiSocial: Multilingual Benchmark of Machine-Generated Text Detection of Social-Media Texts
| 2024-06-18T12:26:09 | 2024-06-18T12:26:09 |
Dominik Macko, Jakub Kopal, Robert Moro, Ivan Srba
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent LLMs are able to generate high-quality multilingual texts,
indistinguishable for humans from authentic human-written ones. Research in
machine-generated text detection is however mostly focused on the English
language and longer texts, such as news articles, scientific papers or student
essays. Social-media texts are usually much shorter and often feature informal
language, grammatical errors, or distinct linguistic items (e.g., emoticons,
hashtags). There is a gap in studying the ability of existing methods in
detection of such texts, reflected also in the lack of existing multilingual
benchmark datasets. To fill this gap we propose the first multilingual (22
languages) and multi-platform (5 social media platforms) dataset for
benchmarking machine-generated text detection in the social-media domain,
called MultiSocial. It contains 472,097 texts, of which about 58k are
human-written and approximately the same amount is generated by each of 7
multilingual LLMs. We use this benchmark to compare existing detection methods
in zero-shot as well as fine-tuned form. Our results indicate that the
fine-tuned detectors have no problem to be trained on social-media texts and
that the platform selection for training matters.
|
[
-0.3470229506492615,
-0.8614922165870667,
0.44957029819488525,
0.4773660898208618,
-0.4917428493499756,
0.532313346862793,
-0.36833563446998596,
-0.7121802568435669,
0.6404843926429749,
0.17096911370754242,
-0.47568368911743164,
-0.8079920411109924,
-0.7482532858848572,
0.569101095199585,
-0.3091173470020294,
0.825588047504425,
-0.09079102426767349,
-0.002278987318277359,
-0.008163969032466412,
-0.5051386952400208,
0.16227605938911438,
-0.5655784606933594,
-0.6859579086303711,
0.046137988567352295,
0.8457831740379333,
0.4919346570968628,
0.28882017731666565,
0.17987549304962158,
0.5352948904037476,
0.3478226065635681,
0.021103888750076294,
0.683414876461029,
-0.457859069108963,
0.11812164634466171,
0.11669646948575974,
-0.07517159730195999,
-0.2576252222061157,
-0.05472242459654808,
0.8163252472877502,
0.24455676972866058,
0.24051015079021454,
0.4333934783935547,
0.20926687121391296,
0.546540379524231,
-0.7414636611938477,
0.01300871092826128,
-0.5510104894638062,
-0.08150636404752731,
-0.40617358684539795,
-0.34073686599731445,
-0.3184831142425537,
-0.35652056336402893,
-0.6522408127784729,
-0.3442622125148773,
0.27518054842948914,
-0.13555456697940826,
0.566651463508606,
-0.13254296779632568,
-0.6024795174598694,
-0.3893806040287018,
-0.5602068305015564,
0.6535745859146118,
-0.5008113384246826,
0.434207558631897,
0.4305265247821808,
0.33273813128471375,
0.09449350088834763,
-0.5010841488838196,
-0.5753237009048462,
-0.015847953036427498,
0.05995844304561615,
0.1541385054588318,
-0.07887916266918182,
-0.3879379332065582,
0.016892114654183388,
-0.20038695633411407,
-0.6971973776817322,
0.17760278284549713,
-0.2817974090576172,
-0.37170031666755676,
0.8372069597244263,
-0.04792346805334091,
0.16113834083080292,
-0.21271513402462006,
-0.18488982319831848,
-0.01806047186255455,
-0.6420109868049622,
-0.135947123169899,
0.5676536560058594,
0.31155407428741455,
-0.3369347155094147,
0.4338894784450531,
-0.32531577348709106,
0.11734231561422348,
-0.3666231036186218,
-0.41237929463386536,
0.5237874388694763,
-0.6038171052932739,
0.18014585971832275,
0.17413927614688873,
1.2071523666381836,
0.5474784970283508,
0.5952141284942627,
-0.012535125948488712,
-0.16096386313438416,
0.23052535951137543,
-0.12735339999198914,
-0.7797704339027405,
0.0571739487349987,
0.014356663450598717,
-0.652038037776947,
-0.6246570944786072,
0.04522327706217766,
-0.5749437212944031,
-0.4945547878742218,
0.031883567571640015,
0.028990909457206726,
-0.28081855177879333,
-0.44516435265541077,
-0.040151357650756836,
-0.007014634553343058,
0.026902690529823303,
0.12818190455436707,
-0.4692089855670929,
0.14096304774284363,
0.49793708324432373,
0.9994093775749207,
0.053247760981321335,
-0.6379472017288208,
-0.6239488124847412,
0.12965098023414612,
-0.3036419451236725,
1.1499773263931274,
-0.40972551703453064,
-0.2186604142189026,
0.23490996658802032,
0.2378416806459427,
0.17752400040626526,
-0.42972657084465027,
0.6340207457542419,
-0.284175843000412,
-0.14662516117095947,
-0.4387957751750946,
-0.3421463370323181,
0.26600757241249084,
0.24737481772899628,
-0.4944700300693512,
1.319913625717163,
-0.281924843788147,
-0.845787763595581,
0.6196965575218201,
-0.4215586185455322,
-0.7284694314002991,
0.15069672465324402,
-0.14505162835121155,
-0.5247697830200195,
-0.05638766661286354,
0.17731915414333344,
0.906030535697937,
-0.20593279600143433,
0.2911701500415802,
-0.9527682065963745,
-0.5559210777282715,
0.5159322619438171,
-0.5516201853752136,
0.5862595438957214,
0.22570936381816864,
-0.15691861510276794,
-0.01870086044073105,
-0.9303328394889832,
-0.09451182186603546,
0.31221452355384827,
-0.3237214982509613,
-0.5205230712890625,
0.04019550606608391,
0.48962679505348206,
0.3718772530555725,
0.3773029148578644,
-0.9473206996917725,
-0.33666715025901794,
0.16842657327651978,
0.6183493733406067,
0.7219070792198181,
-0.020876770839095116,
0.1659235954284668,
-0.23675155639648438,
0.33679699897766113,
0.030979763716459274,
0.08294057846069336,
-0.34046146273612976,
-0.47801336646080017,
-0.3811016082763672,
-0.2867206931114197,
0.09148667007684708,
0.45531970262527466,
-0.9553874731063843,
0.2793205976486206,
-0.11520235240459442,
-0.5785662531852722,
-0.6441909074783325,
0.3652053475379944,
0.40627485513687134,
-0.08136604726314545,
0.13792647421360016,
0.01476712990552187,
-0.538921594619751,
-0.7673946619033813,
-0.635841965675354,
-0.13340233266353607,
0.20506776869297028,
0.2949400246143341,
0.5965117812156677,
-0.2528471350669861,
0.4013456404209137,
-0.312145859003067,
-0.24417604506015778,
-0.19313102960586548,
0.21612608432769775,
-0.12129602581262589,
0.07171093672513962,
0.6520370244979858,
-0.8182218670845032,
-1.049723505973816,
-0.07019758224487305,
-1.0332568883895874,
-0.34954833984375,
0.04186055436730385,
0.07066234946250916,
0.23532480001449585,
0.8583986759185791,
-0.4054144322872162,
0.18457362055778503,
0.6874192357063293,
-0.1355656236410141,
0.48850420117378235,
-0.32192710041999817,
0.309328556060791,
-1.4054008722305298,
-0.12039248645305634,
0.4540303945541382,
-0.4490615725517273,
-0.5272152423858643,
-0.1135871484875679,
0.28125447034835815,
-0.1297721415758133,
-0.6396608352661133,
0.6950283050537109,
-0.5270816087722778,
-0.18859797716140747,
-0.2501677870750427,
0.5019274950027466,
0.04119768366217613,
0.20670579373836517,
-0.192849799990654,
0.7853848934173584,
0.3025851845741272,
-0.5033128261566162,
0.2550019919872284,
-0.1541266143321991,
-0.2745276093482971,
0.9934425354003906,
-0.764147162437439,
0.21155603229999542,
-0.23012056946754456,
0.18884843587875366,
-1.2648228406906128,
-0.19364169239997864,
0.161862313747406,
-0.6921396255493164,
-0.054217904806137085,
0.11244441568851471,
-1.031206727027893,
-0.31970369815826416,
-0.6740002632141113,
0.2485557496547699,
0.000289066054392606,
-0.4062034487724304,
0.2203441858291626,
0.6232783198356628,
-0.24734283983707428,
-0.5054997801780701,
-0.5990622639656067,
0.4216797351837158,
-0.18539924919605255,
-0.6338745355606079,
0.33603280782699585,
-0.03141920641064644,
-0.05929163470864296,
-0.010790259577333927,
0.2696828544139862,
-0.13487793505191803,
0.1377892643213272,
0.028061123564839363,
0.05787043645977974,
-0.1670415848493576,
0.13993223011493683,
0.287104994058609,
-0.1896800547838211,
-0.11604378372430801,
0.1503170132637024,
0.6142310500144958,
-0.11097138375043869,
-0.4061919152736664,
-0.3871830701828003,
0.500076949596405,
0.6322463750839233,
-0.32021015882492065,
0.7274535894393921,
1.1500134468078613,
-0.4760400056838989,
0.07337909191846848,
-0.6093973517417908,
-0.10860715061426163,
-0.5282195210456848,
0.16450545191764832,
-0.30357521772384644,
-1.0642951726913452,
0.5239661931991577,
0.014875335618853569,
-0.14974436163902283,
0.2880437970161438,
0.49844881892204285,
-0.18371081352233887,
1.1010748147964478,
0.5092838406562805,
-0.129644513130188,
0.40025198459625244,
0.2986961305141449,
0.17727656662464142,
-0.4030091464519501,
0.012581730261445045,
-0.7238763570785522,
-0.2588166892528534,
-0.9779548645019531,
-0.3058611750602722,
0.23208929598331451,
-0.18806402385234833,
-0.17496217787265778,
0.5152127742767334,
-0.499138742685318,
0.6166805624961853,
0.5685869455337524,
0.24456435441970825,
0.3737097978591919,
0.00246908375993371,
-0.048039235174655914,
-0.08629833906888962,
-0.4663253426551819,
-0.8316649794578552,
1.1077262163162231,
0.15417781472206116,
0.5053723454475403,
0.0902097225189209,
1.0297154188156128,
0.4616260528564453,
0.40272319316864014,
-0.38230857253074646,
0.6233103275299072,
-0.49540257453918457,
-0.5679791569709778,
-0.08315271139144897,
-0.4061927795410156,
-0.9913669228553772,
0.2171754091978073,
-0.4310704469680786,
-0.6059768199920654,
0.04658188670873642,
-0.12211260944604874,
-0.15872426331043243,
0.21499665081501007,
-0.6599431037902832,
0.8522632718086243,
-0.325571209192276,
-0.424005925655365,
-0.18287135660648346,
-0.6361925005912781,
0.12749411165714264,
-0.32854312658309937,
0.5784655213356018,
-0.5274181365966797,
-0.07590167224407196,
0.608660876750946,
-0.03890132158994675,
1.1429108381271362,
-0.20999273657798767,
0.022727612406015396,
0.34993088245391846,
-0.12804299592971802,
0.5062690377235413,
0.14300882816314697,
0.13258463144302368,
0.2798110246658325,
0.13078834116458893,
-0.5135071277618408,
0.04282693192362785,
0.7095848321914673,
-0.7101983428001404,
0.24973851442337036,
-0.2680369019508362,
-0.14132806658744812,
-0.009325153194367886,
0.46090826392173767,
0.37215495109558105,
0.37422919273376465,
-0.6682108044624329,
0.37332820892333984,
0.44280317425727844,
-0.46007826924324036,
0.5709017515182495,
0.8360847234725952,
-0.12623442709445953,
-0.6143066883087158,
1.0539004802703857,
0.050556477159261703,
-0.10583033412694931,
0.4014908969402313,
0.0773257315158844,
-0.37878870964050293,
-0.2245045304298401,
-0.5225619077682495,
0.37205326557159424,
-0.6487724781036377,
-0.20533765852451324,
-0.9044593572616577,
0.008464745245873928,
-0.5514531135559082,
-0.25948992371559143,
-0.45066845417022705,
-0.03942146152257919,
-0.27958744764328003,
0.10186632722616196,
0.27657800912857056,
0.6329818367958069,
-0.3000304698944092,
0.3320344388484955,
-0.9849036931991577,
0.5800318717956543,
-0.13686522841453552,
0.3150542080402374,
-0.27481043338775635,
-0.07836682349443436,
-0.29003632068634033,
0.13627511262893677,
-0.11689221113920212,
-0.8748182654380798,
0.21297353506088257,
0.3033410310745239,
0.47728613018989563,
0.506818413734436,
0.0010967779671773314,
0.40294820070266724,
-0.5210623145103455,
0.3399614691734314,
0.264544814825058,
-0.7408155798912048,
0.39222797751426697,
-0.5515037775039673,
0.21777786314487457,
0.6946471929550171,
0.44203147292137146,
-0.9480435252189636,
-0.4493447244167328,
-0.44279783964157104,
-0.5136076807975769,
0.3960786461830139,
0.19791793823242188,
0.3743637800216675,
-0.2610398530960083,
0.282079815864563,
0.059605684131383896,
0.3502698838710785,
-0.8963280320167542,
-0.08646658807992935,
-0.04625054448843002,
-0.2741624414920807,
-0.3846760094165802,
-0.3421826958656311,
0.1445845067501068,
0.025609243661165237,
0.39365604519844055,
-0.2738937735557556,
0.2929477393627167,
-0.08082672208547592,
-0.10405963659286499,
-0.14638423919677734,
0.13024882972240448,
0.6558514833450317,
0.3949063718318939,
-0.024022849276661873,
0.3907519578933716,
0.08993148803710938,
-0.5361363291740417,
0.3170034885406494,
0.1300049126148224,
-0.1572551280260086,
0.2735689580440521,
0.4252051115036011,
0.4805320203304291,
0.38785791397094727,
-0.5962998867034912,
0.5429670810699463,
-0.17577962577342987,
-0.36059093475341797,
-0.2781955599784851,
-0.2246343195438385,
0.3694961369037628,
0.32318535447120667,
0.2983543574810028,
-0.10566390305757523,
0.08637508004903793,
-0.6005820035934448,
0.25547876954078674,
0.47003889083862305,
-0.35394105315208435,
-0.423995703458786,
0.5621123313903809,
0.3302757441997528,
-0.49320006370544434,
0.08406046032905579,
-0.5563022494316101,
-0.5098938941955566,
0.6577370762825012,
0.46725761890411377,
0.9798327088356018,
-0.12505972385406494,
0.7057948708534241,
0.1637033075094223,
0.5370312929153442,
-0.07131580263376236,
0.50295090675354,
0.06282183527946472,
-1.170902967453003,
-0.3434780240058899,
-0.5427568554878235,
-0.4305856227874756,
0.08901429921388626,
-0.4868544340133667,
0.5062770843505859,
-0.39492136240005493,
-0.2298010140657425,
0.5039263367652893,
0.02023565210402012,
-0.5726978778839111,
-0.04567433148622513,
0.23545709252357483,
0.6286470293998718,
-1.1166797876358032,
0.7442843317985535,
0.93790602684021,
-0.1080470085144043,
-0.23932698369026184,
-0.13580428063869476,
0.2892259955406189,
-0.8497418165206909,
0.3091404438018799,
0.5454515218734741,
-0.4266793727874756,
-0.04443714767694473,
-0.6331773996353149,
-0.44505882263183594,
0.853314995765686,
0.30483782291412354,
-0.3916477560997009,
0.37346574664115906,
0.4618834853172302,
0.7392459511756897,
-0.32845309376716614,
0.08071287721395493,
0.09417921304702759,
0.41656774282455444,
-0.16535265743732452,
-0.685140073299408,
-0.04450920969247818,
-0.4567308723926544,
-0.11156867444515228,
0.370650053024292,
-1.0517585277557373,
0.7507371306419373,
0.11473245173692703,
-0.24532872438430786,
-0.19723422825336456,
0.300211638212204,
0.4287891387939453,
0.9049488306045532,
0.33256518840789795,
0.2469358891248703,
0.673527181148529,
0.09023252874612808,
0.6823452115058899,
-0.5723657608032227,
0.3627495765686035,
0.8275517821311951,
-0.7248436808586121,
0.8614733219146729,
0.1807316392660141,
-0.19159717857837677,
0.3220769464969635,
0.8626013398170471,
0.05135998874902725,
0.35572293400764465,
-0.1948677897453308,
-0.4833720326423645,
-0.2668801546096802,
-0.2683698832988739,
-0.23742109537124634,
0.5981218218803406,
0.275192528963089,
-0.3122258186340332,
-0.22217553853988647,
-0.09919397532939911,
0.10690551996231079,
0.2239101380109787,
-0.06755220890045166,
0.7404278516769409,
0.14346793293952942,
-0.268700510263443,
0.36090168356895447,
0.3241150379180908,
0.8995856642723083,
-0.419144868850708,
0.2682572901248932,
-0.15418225526809692,
0.3436218202114105,
-0.10020085424184799,
-0.7751906514167786,
0.2889900207519531,
0.11539528518915176,
0.14293302595615387,
-0.27536651492118835,
1.4047095775604248,
-0.3484216034412384,
-0.7088010907173157,
0.6006520986557007,
0.8095972537994385,
0.3731403648853302,
-0.3541231155395508,
-1.000659704208374,
0.07000517845153809,
-0.24283373355865479,
-0.0038394310977309942,
0.32002609968185425,
0.9395607113838196,
0.016779081895947456,
0.46579471230506897,
0.7727488279342651,
-0.11206331849098206,
-0.05515589565038681,
0.30406704545021057,
0.7877686023712158,
-0.5776302814483643,
-0.40461379289627075,
-1.1269627809524536,
0.11595626175403595,
-0.43654370307922363,
-0.48093196749687195,
0.9406181573867798,
0.6703365445137024,
0.9143531918525696,
0.19296784698963165,
0.8851198554039001,
0.08514814078807831,
0.6011584997177124,
-0.23976407945156097,
0.7464550733566284,
-0.7667489647865295,
-0.10414187610149384,
-0.6537225842475891,
-0.9803430438041687,
-0.21481961011886597,
0.5159651637077332,
0.011394663713872433,
0.028519097715616226,
0.5891441106796265,
0.7542181015014648,
-0.10560085624456406,
0.009008849039673805,
0.37784287333488464,
-0.23466062545776367,
0.11543598026037216,
0.30146902799606323,
0.8411667943000793,
-0.5541491508483887,
0.6092826724052429,
-0.23567941784858704,
-0.22585077583789825,
-0.3657895624637604,
-0.9674700498580933,
-1.2421910762786865,
-0.47331681847572327,
-0.19378836452960968,
-0.4092928171157837,
0.09331967681646347,
0.7448438405990601,
0.4538537859916687,
-0.6813119649887085,
-0.2809673249721527,
0.13217027485370636,
0.07473478466272354,
-0.05352945253252983,
-0.1322404146194458,
0.035338301211595535,
-0.10041207820177078,
-0.5542186498641968,
0.25048261880874634,
0.5070663094520569,
0.10552812367677689,
-0.38484498858451843,
-0.09797646105289459,
-0.434600293636322,
0.027714194729924202,
0.9369590878486633,
0.045884065330028534,
-0.13565613329410553,
-0.2578187584877014,
0.4851006865501404,
-0.32415297627449036,
0.053120825439691544,
0.7350540161132812,
-0.1384657472372055,
0.199863001704216,
0.4784283936023712,
0.4596521258354187,
0.5717109441757202,
-0.2743901014328003,
0.09734116494655609,
-0.9801010489463806,
0.30867475271224976,
-0.05656946450471878,
0.3829251229763031,
0.547233521938324,
-0.31491631269454956,
0.5382282733917236,
0.5646045207977295,
-0.6184553503990173,
-0.8871544003486633,
0.053195077925920486,
-0.6733310222625732,
-0.4628308117389679,
1.3738720417022705,
0.00533246248960495,
-0.01356794498860836,
-0.29157379269599915,
-0.13078859448432922,
0.3750035762786865,
-0.5370801687240601,
0.8106539845466614,
0.8238500952720642,
0.3307030200958252,
-0.3111671507358551,
-0.5088560581207275,
0.15215663611888885,
0.08636286109685898,
-0.9638622999191284,
0.000014621894479205366,
0.33334094285964966,
0.1848897784948349,
0.1271517127752304,
1.133172631263733,
0.04965249076485634,
0.1835768073797226,
0.04260392114520073,
0.07690051198005676,
0.2018144130706787,
-0.3837035000324249,
0.06174028292298317,
0.060961876064538956,
-0.08339198678731918,
-0.05300752446055412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12548v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12548v1
|
P-Tailor: Customizing Personality Traits for Language Models via Mixture of Specialized LoRA Experts
| 2024-06-18T12:25:13 | 2024-06-18T12:25:13 |
Yuhao Dan, Jie Zhou, Qin Chen, Junfeng Tian, Liang He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Personalized large language models (LLMs) have attracted great attention in
many applications, such as intelligent education and emotional support. Most
work focuses on controlling the character settings based on the profile (e.g.,
age, skill, experience, and so on). Conversely, the psychological theory-based
personality traits with implicit expression and behavior are not well modeled,
limiting their potential application in more specialized fields such as the
psychological counseling agents. In this paper, we propose a mixture of experts
(MoE)-based personalized LLMs, named P-tailor, to model the Big Five
Personality Traits. Particularly, we learn specialized LoRA experts to
represent various traits, such as openness, conscientiousness, extraversion,
agreeableness and neuroticism. Then, we integrate P-Tailor with a personality
specialization loss, promoting experts to specialize in distinct personality
traits, thereby enhancing the efficiency of model parameter utilization. Due to
the lack of datasets, we also curate a high-quality personality crafting
dataset (PCD) to learn and develop the ability to exhibit different personality
traits across various topics. We conduct extensive experiments to verify the
great performance and effectiveness of P-Tailor in manipulation of the
fine-grained personality traits of LLMs.
|
[
-0.7019731998443604,
-0.7683444023132324,
0.5743024945259094,
0.5380086302757263,
-0.0721559152007103,
0.08780840039253235,
-0.4928388297557831,
-0.17656295001506805,
0.6425372958183289,
0.6417355537414551,
-0.6278699040412903,
-0.4582352340221405,
-0.45520052313804626,
0.12352413684129715,
-0.07454942166805267,
0.6986295580863953,
0.18799273669719696,
0.045473817735910416,
0.10071054100990295,
0.02186155691742897,
-0.6024745106697083,
-0.6208017468452454,
-0.4473889470100403,
-0.4782220423221588,
0.5987114310264587,
0.6372530460357666,
0.43963074684143066,
0.5307409167289734,
0.21093255281448364,
0.31051257252693176,
-0.21848879754543304,
0.2559060752391815,
-0.5134751200675964,
0.03212035074830055,
-0.5423301458358765,
-0.37084776163101196,
-1.0213762521743774,
0.0664134994149208,
0.29876673221588135,
0.6695212721824646,
-0.2996291220188141,
0.1471707969903946,
0.06627720594406128,
0.5304924249649048,
-0.6353168487548828,
-0.030476324260234833,
-0.7138009071350098,
0.049038391560316086,
-0.19287055730819702,
0.10814198851585388,
-0.33860841393470764,
-0.3982757329940796,
0.21289926767349243,
-0.40784889459609985,
0.14772754907608032,
0.04854942485690117,
0.39472225308418274,
0.17152602970600128,
-0.5656246542930603,
-0.010309865698218346,
-0.8601328730583191,
0.9086938500404358,
-0.8975846767425537,
0.021047906950116158,
0.6450244784355164,
0.35988450050354004,
-0.1635146290063858,
-0.2173147350549698,
-0.5206121802330017,
0.09664846956729889,
0.057737287133932114,
0.06875468045473099,
0.22768954932689667,
-0.21672427654266357,
-0.07977849245071411,
0.5797960162162781,
-0.32672998309135437,
0.47737860679626465,
0.0031561432406306267,
-0.07492106407880783,
1.039304256439209,
0.35791751742362976,
0.02255084365606308,
0.34922677278518677,
0.020638151094317436,
0.1707180142402649,
-0.530892550945282,
-0.005217000376433134,
0.641173779964447,
-0.01087865885347128,
0.01085334550589323,
0.4996812641620636,
-0.3140155076980591,
0.459949791431427,
0.5191294550895691,
-0.6485425233840942,
0.1340843290090561,
0.07217662036418915,
-0.08579406142234802,
-0.10268306732177734,
0.7498984932899475,
0.14910849928855896,
0.6470224857330322,
-0.08314933627843857,
-0.01128807757049799,
-0.3408103585243225,
0.08447566628456116,
-0.6820088028907776,
-0.43183615803718567,
0.27030977606773376,
-0.5429784059524536,
-0.3612639904022217,
-0.16734535992145538,
-0.8581850528717041,
-0.6113666892051697,
-0.29863351583480835,
-0.057475194334983826,
-0.6828300952911377,
-0.3850618302822113,
0.18939821422100067,
0.075828418135643,
0.26304227113723755,
0.19724901020526886,
-1.0404919385910034,
0.1774054765701294,
0.4368932843208313,
0.4168749451637268,
-0.26600122451782227,
-0.45004090666770935,
-0.3717792332172394,
0.26998406648635864,
-0.054546553641557693,
0.868802011013031,
-0.9853329658508301,
-0.592745304107666,
-0.12042298913002014,
-0.26592281460762024,
0.06929105520248413,
-0.36414089798927307,
0.6875352263450623,
-0.31799599528312683,
0.3123534321784973,
-0.3976907432079315,
-0.6222256422042847,
-0.04453364387154579,
0.12225289642810822,
-0.2382553517818451,
0.6629990935325623,
0.2905738055706024,
-0.5482761859893799,
0.34468352794647217,
-0.508719265460968,
-0.44804564118385315,
0.03357505425810814,
-0.04794305935502052,
-0.4784623086452484,
0.2571352422237396,
0.5171843767166138,
0.7025487422943115,
-0.10627689212560654,
0.1029478907585144,
-0.8192134499549866,
-0.37389424443244934,
0.6381956934928894,
0.1351800560951233,
0.35715287923812866,
-0.03881587088108063,
-0.07123387604951859,
0.23629102110862732,
-0.8974856734275818,
0.16831108927726746,
0.07689070701599121,
-0.6085138916969299,
-0.2978496551513672,
0.11587319523096085,
0.20467986166477203,
0.1572360396385193,
0.6251852512359619,
-0.4683985412120819,
0.4391879439353943,
-0.3332745432853699,
0.33721640706062317,
1.1911749839782715,
-0.04605109244585037,
0.46796464920043945,
-0.40083175897598267,
0.5346720218658447,
-0.01390560157597065,
0.030311400070786476,
0.19667431712150574,
-0.5242496132850647,
-0.6814387440681458,
-0.8076443672180176,
-0.02058330923318863,
0.4968247413635254,
-0.266198068857193,
1.3352770805358887,
0.07799284160137177,
-0.8051267266273499,
-0.43775784969329834,
0.42051607370376587,
0.4122433662414551,
0.2916133999824524,
0.199702650308609,
-0.3441999554634094,
-0.587710440158844,
-1.0264978408813477,
-0.6919496059417725,
0.1620992124080658,
-0.2109799087047577,
0.35889193415641785,
0.31604036688804626,
-0.33873996138572693,
1.2774029970169067,
-0.8244055509567261,
-0.2863366901874542,
-0.5259608626365662,
-0.2899059057235718,
0.3321501314640045,
0.35266822576522827,
0.6783798336982727,
-0.5335126519203186,
-0.7134510278701782,
-0.03248358517885208,
-0.2969069480895996,
-0.47054606676101685,
0.32058781385421753,
-0.13760235905647278,
-0.06212442368268967,
0.06566149741411209,
-0.2502887547016144,
0.10337752848863602,
0.4672200679779053,
-0.6687824726104736,
0.8183793425559998,
-0.29956263303756714,
-0.4079820513725281,
-1.3448365926742554,
0.20595918595790863,
0.22195395827293396,
-0.11979105323553085,
-0.4314683973789215,
0.02916121669113636,
-0.20245656371116638,
-0.06348393112421036,
-0.07989013940095901,
0.7590702772140503,
-0.19871805608272552,
-0.03582121804356575,
-0.24938824772834778,
-0.10046408325433731,
-0.039960507303476334,
0.7529101967811584,
0.12759022414684296,
0.5168938040733337,
0.5279442071914673,
-0.5564266443252563,
0.4749482274055481,
0.5054124593734741,
-0.1785126030445099,
1.042962670326233,
-0.6665748357772827,
0.5941795706748962,
0.01428060419857502,
0.3155021667480469,
-0.48693060874938965,
-0.5685823559761047,
0.04134608432650566,
-0.1080707386136055,
-0.059956252574920654,
-0.237754687666893,
-0.3557857871055603,
0.0475647933781147,
-0.3062466084957123,
-0.2062809318304062,
0.7830023765563965,
-0.25682002305984497,
0.7894894480705261,
0.32833632826805115,
-0.5612871646881104,
-0.22040072083473206,
-0.47237569093704224,
-0.011361083947122097,
-0.5706422924995422,
-0.5390415787696838,
0.5489976406097412,
-0.5650509595870972,
-0.16890715062618256,
-0.3422730565071106,
0.2077963948249817,
-0.23944373428821564,
0.015973418951034546,
0.10594278573989868,
0.014924165792763233,
-0.26413044333457947,
-0.24631740152835846,
0.16499528288841248,
-0.1400894820690155,
-0.2527224123477936,
-0.1272520124912262,
0.7431656122207642,
-0.2479184865951538,
-0.300972580909729,
-0.45098647475242615,
0.557181179523468,
0.748384416103363,
-0.6928833723068237,
0.9264094233512878,
0.9140429496765137,
-0.015076627023518085,
-0.2777276933193207,
-0.8588289618492126,
-0.15563364326953888,
-0.5195475220680237,
0.4733497202396393,
-0.5641604065895081,
-0.9044597744941711,
0.7779909372329712,
0.06294342875480652,
0.027750927954912186,
-0.03262006863951683,
0.8714012503623962,
-0.05348033457994461,
1.1048952341079712,
0.8176848888397217,
-0.2957599461078644,
0.7060709595680237,
-0.03774024918675423,
0.3313208818435669,
-1.1436412334442139,
-0.17780058085918427,
-0.2791078984737396,
-0.7082526087760925,
-0.5040605664253235,
-0.020745204761624336,
0.4418906569480896,
-0.13046753406524658,
-0.5981282591819763,
0.004708630032837391,
-0.4384918510913849,
0.5409728288650513,
0.6157487034797668,
0.335970014333725,
0.2825283706188202,
0.027857186272740364,
0.13203206658363342,
-0.2717583179473877,
-0.26543736457824707,
-0.6825544834136963,
1.119537115097046,
0.4619622528553009,
0.9914534091949463,
0.2994914948940277,
0.6006041765213013,
-0.0054232110269367695,
0.09589514136314392,
-0.817908525466919,
0.7028940320014954,
-0.5381476879119873,
-0.3180486559867859,
-0.15824899077415466,
-0.26681214570999146,
-0.4141279458999634,
0.15487061440944672,
-0.22700251638889313,
-1.0662775039672852,
0.43494853377342224,
0.3302763104438782,
-0.2103034406900406,
0.14898186922073364,
-0.7942939400672913,
0.5868319869041443,
-0.19032703340053558,
-0.18455573916435242,
-0.2514832019805908,
-0.2616051435470581,
0.3756389319896698,
-0.3385077118873596,
-0.1413644552230835,
-0.15133608877658844,
-0.21786987781524658,
0.4490848183631897,
-0.39391863346099854,
0.9453129172325134,
-0.01568533480167389,
-0.1482505202293396,
-0.3499247431755066,
0.27136537432670593,
0.6888902187347412,
-0.0035560105461627245,
-0.30859723687171936,
-0.25291404128074646,
-0.018741216510534286,
-0.5858887434005737,
-0.6556524634361267,
0.8200279474258423,
-1.0148905515670776,
-0.47979289293289185,
0.06396724283695221,
-0.43301621079444885,
-0.6704310774803162,
0.1788903921842575,
0.2745530903339386,
0.10162460058927536,
-0.2582206726074219,
0.16856230795383453,
0.7402780055999756,
-0.3417171835899353,
0.1827021837234497,
0.8955307006835938,
-0.17114226520061493,
-0.4817008376121521,
1.0482605695724487,
-0.1362922489643097,
-0.07448070496320724,
0.15168899297714233,
0.5899755954742432,
0.07839657366275787,
-0.6114971041679382,
0.12525127828121185,
0.31472229957580566,
-0.5340920686721802,
0.22412137687206268,
-0.4725067913532257,
0.09956807643175125,
-0.5275370478630066,
-0.45829105377197266,
-0.37864917516708374,
-0.009958862327039242,
-0.27831918001174927,
0.3192008137702942,
0.4076181650161743,
0.5238608121871948,
0.5507106781005859,
0.6158028244972229,
-0.5076358914375305,
0.14860904216766357,
0.3935871124267578,
0.5445601940155029,
-0.18078941106796265,
-0.5852441191673279,
-0.07439865171909332,
-0.1808694750070572,
-0.45243871212005615,
-0.8039188385009766,
0.622430145740509,
0.4674173891544342,
0.5138305425643921,
0.8026125431060791,
-0.22305674850940704,
0.48246824741363525,
-0.17410312592983246,
0.555210530757904,
-0.19678840041160583,
-0.9641264081001282,
0.5124160051345825,
-0.5189290046691895,
0.1647203415632248,
0.2755447030067444,
0.16420389711856842,
-0.47583943605422974,
-0.34581899642944336,
-0.5000905394554138,
-0.605046272277832,
0.5573623180389404,
0.05080467090010643,
0.15325339138507843,
0.39138486981391907,
0.5330007076263428,
0.2937829792499542,
0.2727039158344269,
-0.5349193215370178,
-0.03414562717080116,
-0.15105998516082764,
-0.37962114810943604,
-0.04083341360092163,
-0.3606833815574646,
0.057993084192276,
-0.1925298422574997,
0.7739645838737488,
-0.4959399104118347,
0.034662876278162,
-0.021009815856814384,
0.1215362548828125,
0.2377055138349533,
0.48810049891471863,
0.4952632188796997,
0.6305214762687683,
-0.26923176646232605,
-0.2970025837421417,
0.12729305028915405,
-0.40578973293304443,
-0.015943102538585663,
-0.11338520795106888,
0.11973097175359726,
-0.34752407670021057,
0.4027346670627594,
0.6533356308937073,
0.050566770136356354,
-0.651268482208252,
0.26123547554016113,
-0.01098610833287239,
0.10373928397893906,
-0.529729962348938,
0.46431270241737366,
0.23111534118652344,
0.2792147397994995,
0.13962654769420624,
-0.08439690619707108,
-0.14850667119026184,
-0.6329108476638794,
-0.2994270324707031,
0.25494614243507385,
-0.07773981243371964,
-0.5040526390075684,
0.24751442670822144,
0.5037381649017334,
-0.5633482933044434,
0.49625712633132935,
-0.038382768630981445,
-0.3450707793235779,
0.39547446370124817,
0.5005528330802917,
0.8202993273735046,
-0.5451981425285339,
0.0139679666608572,
-0.12925240397453308,
-0.16470326483249664,
0.046015605330467224,
0.3613239824771881,
0.17042632400989532,
-0.9879920482635498,
-0.4974740445613861,
-0.7291143536567688,
-0.4740518033504486,
0.29350095987319946,
-0.5559870004653931,
0.3525312542915344,
-0.7683187127113342,
-0.12335028499364853,
-0.2101009041070938,
-0.0434766449034214,
-0.6557103991508484,
0.08477351814508438,
-0.07176712155342102,
0.7951785922050476,
-0.7072075009346008,
0.8195980787277222,
1.2485514879226685,
-0.23033449053764343,
-0.6722143888473511,
0.06859917938709259,
-0.0574200414121151,
-0.8687898516654968,
0.5618206858634949,
-0.3030949532985687,
0.2843431234359741,
0.14156803488731384,
-0.3448605239391327,
-0.631316065788269,
0.969420850276947,
0.7537083029747009,
-0.49254298210144043,
-0.39212363958358765,
-0.025273887440562248,
0.5928623080253601,
-0.5321998000144958,
0.21542800962924957,
0.7524545192718506,
0.5125465393066406,
0.025731904432177544,
-0.986549973487854,
-0.2696302831172943,
-0.34792202711105347,
0.13427400588989258,
-0.08395928889513016,
-0.9297538995742798,
0.7947105169296265,
0.07254946231842041,
0.5955111980438232,
0.18287210166454315,
0.4111042022705078,
0.40137720108032227,
-0.07749591022729874,
0.4304478168487549,
0.4700324535369873,
0.7209995985031128,
0.2591656744480133,
0.7238547205924988,
-0.48226481676101685,
0.21464309096336365,
1.1453771591186523,
-0.4344402551651001,
0.7137352824211121,
0.3752821385860443,
-0.22048841416835785,
0.6747179627418518,
0.48386603593826294,
-0.09692791849374771,
0.381892591714859,
0.0014121010899543762,
-0.27037420868873596,
-0.45157045125961304,
-0.008281474933028221,
-0.10397878289222717,
0.8146142363548279,
0.41166871786117554,
-0.4731110632419586,
0.2310517579317093,
-0.020424315705895424,
0.08153080195188522,
0.21450698375701904,
-0.22277724742889404,
0.7152338027954102,
0.1288776695728302,
-0.5818207263946533,
0.12048518657684326,
0.42996272444725037,
0.9035462737083435,
-0.7331135869026184,
0.25701528787612915,
-0.5489863157272339,
0.5154159069061279,
-0.43163517117500305,
-0.776884138584137,
0.19067101180553436,
-0.05500788986682892,
-0.3067129850387573,
-0.5144789218902588,
0.7720957398414612,
-0.30160802602767944,
-0.5518889427185059,
-0.1681968867778778,
0.5328717827796936,
-0.09055788815021515,
-0.45390287041664124,
-0.396943598985672,
-0.22057150304317474,
-0.20904532074928284,
-0.32004424929618835,
0.5945311784744263,
0.32147857546806335,
-0.025305625051259995,
0.9269272685050964,
0.5546787977218628,
0.35576626658439636,
-0.2669501304626465,
-0.024639496579766273,
0.8098117113113403,
-0.7081922888755798,
-0.8209812641143799,
-0.9369401931762695,
0.49886462092399597,
-0.07605216652154922,
-0.6894912123680115,
0.665973424911499,
0.2984969913959503,
0.4789767265319824,
-0.3785836100578308,
0.8888494372367859,
-0.05584408715367317,
0.5649206042289734,
-0.44580861926078796,
0.721092939376831,
-0.2011958211660385,
0.21375584602355957,
-0.4313807487487793,
-1.0803552865982056,
0.15098528563976288,
0.6340325474739075,
-0.5301752686500549,
0.38594087958335876,
0.3674231767654419,
0.7221344709396362,
-0.2154461145401001,
-0.2478455901145935,
0.3996076285839081,
0.4596255123615265,
0.572027325630188,
0.7316260933876038,
0.5485126376152039,
0.3450353443622589,
0.14671050012111664,
-0.2927427589893341,
-0.31064915657043457,
-0.5561822652816772,
-0.7494285702705383,
-1.2095685005187988,
-0.5107015371322632,
-0.3004055917263031,
-0.048092734068632126,
-0.26288849115371704,
0.9494073390960693,
0.8713644742965698,
-0.4596661627292633,
-0.08281447738409042,
0.12708641588687897,
0.07168755680322647,
-0.11321012675762177,
-0.2935902178287506,
0.22385762631893158,
0.06960491836071014,
-0.7002483606338501,
0.38013118505477905,
0.2478676587343216,
-0.1586688607931137,
-0.7587998509407043,
0.02627958543598652,
0.3468652367591858,
0.1156778484582901,
0.5964055061340332,
0.11765549331903458,
-0.7408680319786072,
-0.289872407913208,
0.06164915859699249,
0.1824910193681717,
-0.10546830296516418,
0.9024528861045837,
-0.6418769359588623,
0.21303115785121918,
0.4405362606048584,
0.35605499148368835,
0.10354170948266983,
-0.11914573609828949,
0.9401521682739258,
-0.7852614521980286,
0.16684448719024658,
0.31853508949279785,
0.5967363119125366,
0.2688119411468506,
-0.5105721354484558,
0.15205243229866028,
0.22014972567558289,
-0.5449790358543396,
-0.5721272826194763,
0.5469895005226135,
-0.9824374914169312,
0.04519382491707802,
1.0890008211135864,
-0.3204118311405182,
0.03265015780925751,
-0.11194127798080444,
-0.6026617884635925,
-0.10553901642560959,
-0.47554755210876465,
1.0484223365783691,
0.8040501475334167,
-0.4097534716129303,
-0.21217775344848633,
-0.06457497924566269,
0.14583761990070343,
0.49387800693511963,
-0.8315851092338562,
-0.08260399103164673,
0.2547551989555359,
0.6197066307067871,
-0.1185348778963089,
0.5160518288612366,
0.1495874524116516,
-0.07025395333766937,
-0.5446675419807434,
0.1271723210811615,
-0.2600821256637573,
0.20983979105949402,
-0.12311293929815292,
0.1396818608045578,
0.31657060980796814,
0.2884675860404968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12546v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12546v1
|
Liar, Liar, Logical Mire: A Benchmark for Suppositional Reasoning in Large Language Models
| 2024-06-18T12:24:22 | 2024-06-18T12:24:22 |
Philipp Mondorf, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Knights and knaves problems represent a classic genre of logical puzzles
where characters either tell the truth or lie. The objective is to logically
deduce each character's identity based on their statements. The challenge
arises from the truth-telling or lying behavior, which influences the logical
implications of each statement. Solving these puzzles requires not only direct
deductions from individual statements, but the ability to assess the
truthfulness of statements by reasoning through various hypothetical scenarios.
As such, knights and knaves puzzles serve as compelling examples of
suppositional reasoning. In this paper, we introduce $\textit{TruthQuest}$, a
benchmark for suppositional reasoning based on the principles of knights and
knaves puzzles. Our benchmark presents problems of varying complexity,
considering both the number of characters and the types of logical statements
involved. Evaluations on $\textit{TruthQuest}$ show that large language models
like Llama 3 and Mixtral-8x7B exhibit significant difficulties solving these
tasks. A detailed error analysis of the models' output reveals that
lower-performing models exhibit a diverse range of reasoning errors, frequently
failing to grasp the concept of truth and lies. In comparison, more proficient
models primarily struggle with accurately inferring the logical implications of
potentially false statements.
|
[
-0.023415304720401764,
-0.5540908575057983,
1.076480746269226,
0.03414153680205345,
0.025957327336072922,
0.12771113216876984,
0.20581196248531342,
-0.33393052220344543,
0.04586571827530861,
0.7588741779327393,
-0.5779988765716553,
-0.2579059302806854,
-0.5020825862884521,
0.24235253036022186,
-0.08694110065698624,
0.609244167804718,
-0.0712849572300911,
0.22263316810131073,
-0.41321322321891785,
-0.23045501112937927,
-0.6539111137390137,
-0.6177164316177368,
0.03197644278407097,
-0.18703342974185944,
0.46765491366386414,
0.5424087047576904,
0.8975796699523926,
0.7412471771240234,
0.8270192742347717,
0.41987335681915283,
0.027598971500992775,
0.02171861007809639,
-0.3026537299156189,
0.7489914298057556,
-0.5207085013389587,
-0.9078300595283508,
0.22228455543518066,
0.09909798949956894,
0.44852739572525024,
0.9253264665603638,
-0.19545218348503113,
0.33827197551727295,
-0.5589273571968079,
0.6763058304786682,
-0.7526053786277771,
0.17190463840961456,
-0.6616477370262146,
-0.03615598753094673,
-0.4153388440608978,
0.19905386865139008,
-0.4036591053009033,
-0.7483689785003662,
0.15206371247768402,
-0.6831851601600647,
-0.19729267060756683,
0.10818463563919067,
0.8005234599113464,
0.2857537269592285,
-0.39582720398902893,
-0.6087054014205933,
-0.4454471170902252,
0.9791865944862366,
-0.932528018951416,
0.567480206489563,
0.3110423684120178,
0.6895373463630676,
-0.36590221524238586,
-0.49678489565849304,
-0.7410895228385925,
-0.37924084067344666,
0.08230147510766983,
0.04356226325035095,
-0.030643081292510033,
-0.3067690134048462,
0.6438022255897522,
-0.020967187359929085,
-0.6493563652038574,
-0.22706593573093414,
-0.09378624707460403,
-0.11003248393535614,
0.5017161965370178,
0.21265389025211334,
-0.07190309464931488,
-0.3244119882583618,
-0.2928866147994995,
-0.36714404821395874,
-0.5242131948471069,
0.17851492762565613,
0.4866953492164612,
0.17717772722244263,
0.2571380138397217,
0.5664865970611572,
-0.02440015785396099,
0.5226637721061707,
0.012438302859663963,
-0.5502045154571533,
0.21573321521282196,
0.08899743109941483,
-0.0164144616574049,
-0.10102679580450058,
0.35148507356643677,
0.398194283246994,
0.42266595363616943,
0.08739937841892242,
-0.19889022409915924,
0.6363776922225952,
0.10515215992927551,
-0.5231384634971619,
-0.2501097321510315,
-0.01272230688482523,
-0.3097502589225769,
-0.27639123797416687,
-0.11463034152984619,
-0.6993700265884399,
-0.7302811741828918,
-0.1872737854719162,
0.42129912972450256,
-0.3449200987815857,
0.006878901273012161,
0.20177268981933594,
-0.18613301217556,
0.06903029978275299,
0.2941876947879791,
-0.6354842782020569,
0.3339342474937439,
0.7693036794662476,
0.21787820756435394,
-0.11294357478618622,
-0.19288408756256104,
-0.6089407801628113,
0.08367771655321121,
-0.6446357369422913,
0.9271437525749207,
-0.8657898306846619,
-0.2194947600364685,
-0.1557978242635727,
-0.1144312247633934,
0.05726192519068718,
-0.6777479648590088,
1.0642229318618774,
-0.5039019584655762,
0.03726812079548836,
-1.0247490406036377,
-0.6490281224250793,
-0.38943204283714294,
0.507652759552002,
-0.4687102138996124,
0.8041474223136902,
0.21819159388542175,
-0.6556623578071594,
-0.04003196209669113,
-0.24106378853321075,
-0.35677582025527954,
0.20712313055992126,
-0.5441245436668396,
0.02275346778333187,
0.34579187631607056,
0.07185053080320358,
0.2988464832305908,
-0.829067051410675,
0.519485592842102,
-0.36269211769104004,
-0.20922240614891052,
0.7124959230422974,
-0.17374345660209656,
0.7672469019889832,
0.08472339808940887,
-0.23853342235088348,
-0.3081476092338562,
-0.7009757161140442,
0.19215039908885956,
0.3653463125228882,
0.240340918302536,
-0.5259425640106201,
0.2747042179107666,
-0.5909179449081421,
0.2180965542793274,
0.40534693002700806,
-0.6105213761329651,
0.1148083359003067,
-0.47181451320648193,
0.24701744318008423,
0.9156848788261414,
-0.10032592713832855,
0.10917463153600693,
-0.47326093912124634,
0.40729302167892456,
-0.001806061714887619,
0.28209999203681946,
-0.12197607010602951,
-0.35458385944366455,
-0.646099328994751,
-0.12738537788391113,
0.5632582902908325,
0.7136240601539612,
-0.9284340143203735,
0.0517999567091465,
-0.20452046394348145,
-0.49798402190208435,
-0.5869592428207397,
-0.16366086900234222,
0.5509922504425049,
0.9713340401649475,
0.23390433192253113,
0.10430540889501572,
-0.3091442584991455,
-1.350696325302124,
-0.5068145394325256,
-0.49549880623817444,
-0.0009025899926200509,
0.24070876836776733,
0.7918623089790344,
0.09009469300508499,
0.8476331233978271,
-0.495731920003891,
-0.06385497003793716,
0.015706971287727356,
0.18607135117053986,
0.5191547870635986,
0.16135890781879425,
0.3652758300304413,
-1.0705076456069946,
-0.5149729251861572,
-0.2992919385433197,
-0.9572461843490601,
-0.48309049010276794,
-0.07471610605716705,
0.17174765467643738,
0.1491401344537735,
0.03979334235191345,
-0.4720202386379242,
0.35047754645347595,
0.4880688190460205,
-0.28749334812164307,
0.9201240539550781,
0.1009749174118042,
0.25367528200149536,
-0.6259093284606934,
-0.008813494816422462,
-0.3192703425884247,
-0.0824870616197586,
-0.3683054745197296,
0.36869990825653076,
-0.09377337992191315,
0.06971364468336105,
-0.3072611689567566,
0.3280191719532013,
-0.25238996744155884,
-0.36900079250335693,
0.0959637388586998,
0.3523416817188263,
0.2519293427467346,
0.4707009792327881,
-0.07985353469848633,
0.7311331033706665,
0.32264044880867004,
-0.3829771876335144,
0.4747011959552765,
0.29401859641075134,
-0.4490697383880615,
0.9538456201553345,
-0.7987906336784363,
0.19189481437206268,
-0.04141347110271454,
0.10884220153093338,
-1.0753939151763916,
-0.1234695166349411,
0.12435072660446167,
-0.5195352435112,
-0.3224901258945465,
0.054086264222860336,
-0.7776402235031128,
-0.4261159300804138,
-0.2887241840362549,
0.3517729341983795,
0.459406316280365,
-0.5127149820327759,
0.6400187611579895,
0.3294459283351898,
-0.17159435153007507,
-0.8405380249023438,
-0.7062512040138245,
-0.18647998571395874,
-0.13056644797325134,
-0.6934515833854675,
0.2367161512374878,
-0.3102013170719147,
-0.6048534512519836,
-0.01775255985558033,
-0.44595086574554443,
0.062412865459918976,
-0.03759666532278061,
0.2457164078950882,
0.44085997343063354,
-0.20575684309005737,
0.051933836191892624,
-0.10203709453344345,
-0.4135746359825134,
0.17059490084648132,
0.1010112315416336,
0.3807859420776367,
-0.4939049482345581,
-0.7601211071014404,
-0.3579866886138916,
0.6043865084648132,
0.5708064436912537,
-0.24209409952163696,
0.45925042033195496,
-0.2388475388288498,
-0.24900683760643005,
0.02519173175096512,
-0.8201255202293396,
-0.05427953228354454,
-0.4936368763446808,
0.021036572754383087,
-0.6653490662574768,
-0.8985142707824707,
0.7749898433685303,
-0.3181791305541992,
0.012668164446949959,
0.5175172686576843,
0.2217753529548645,
-0.3858926296234131,
1.1437761783599854,
0.19968092441558838,
0.23696233332157135,
-0.32056868076324463,
0.11002499610185623,
0.20219799876213074,
-0.5265718102455139,
-0.07767245918512344,
-0.734000027179718,
-0.43427395820617676,
-0.4247314929962158,
-0.4895287752151489,
0.4934522807598114,
0.25117480754852295,
-0.4562552869319916,
0.2754789888858795,
-0.3867049515247345,
0.8326760530471802,
0.3665015399456024,
-0.39846011996269226,
0.2948625981807709,
-0.2855110764503479,
-0.53334641456604,
-0.7047467827796936,
-0.4392932653427124,
-0.623286783695221,
0.8632757663726807,
0.3736560046672821,
0.48825395107269287,
0.46210333704948425,
0.36749130487442017,
0.18702355027198792,
0.0220822561532259,
-0.5673354864120483,
0.8298544883728027,
-0.160904660820961,
-0.776528537273407,
-0.16570602357387543,
-0.6031457185745239,
-0.5397144556045532,
0.25022006034851074,
-0.19192735850811005,
-0.963431179523468,
0.4088049530982971,
-0.07804044336080551,
-0.28892782330513,
0.12330726534128189,
-0.3468077480792999,
0.8474873900413513,
-0.2827276885509491,
-0.15846402943134308,
-0.11492782086133957,
-0.9625795483589172,
0.4300883114337921,
-0.06603595614433289,
0.3498246967792511,
-0.21352463960647583,
0.16070561110973358,
0.600800096988678,
-0.3349992036819458,
0.6411905884742737,
-0.20958127081394196,
-0.010860762558877468,
0.18018224835395813,
0.6834592223167419,
0.8742440342903137,
-0.14775298535823822,
-0.19784103333950043,
0.15806365013122559,
0.4588879942893982,
-0.1761510819196701,
-1.0957367420196533,
0.4333619177341461,
-0.5814155340194702,
-0.5625386834144592,
-0.7137877345085144,
-0.7350345253944397,
-0.5975584983825684,
0.2110227793455124,
0.13426809012889862,
0.5490269660949707,
-0.003666466102004051,
0.33084794878959656,
0.9265871047973633,
-0.12392798811197281,
0.12647464871406555,
0.9527788162231445,
-0.4474867582321167,
-0.449977844953537,
0.8344658017158508,
0.23783612251281738,
0.2480260729789734,
0.4249533414840698,
0.3880791962146759,
-0.5983638167381287,
-0.45128580927848816,
-0.20410354435443878,
0.5008030533790588,
-0.9603865742683411,
-0.3810601234436035,
-0.19673752784729004,
-0.16167688369750977,
-0.19018810987472534,
-0.2879515290260315,
-0.5620321035385132,
-0.5617446303367615,
0.3110189735889435,
0.2309468537569046,
-0.02163590118288994,
0.4864434003829956,
0.009094271808862686,
0.3806408941745758,
-0.5403571128845215,
0.5846276879310608,
0.6275989413261414,
0.11255533248186111,
-0.2689272463321686,
-0.5217154026031494,
0.3335803747177124,
0.053247760981321335,
-0.27428507804870605,
-1.102022647857666,
0.03542549908161163,
-0.3500794470310211,
0.705943763256073,
0.3249603807926178,
0.48351216316223145,
0.6053207516670227,
-0.6264930963516235,
0.7030593156814575,
0.21232281625270844,
-1.1198316812515259,
0.37338894605636597,
-0.3555412292480469,
0.047161638736724854,
0.9421601891517639,
0.4893086850643158,
-0.6598779559135437,
-0.08083236217498779,
-0.6982728242874146,
-0.31940191984176636,
0.38926926255226135,
0.2745653986930847,
-0.36224204301834106,
-0.22745612263679504,
0.30499565601348877,
0.2142295241355896,
0.357285737991333,
-0.6019483804702759,
-0.13086852431297302,
0.11984451115131378,
-0.27081865072250366,
0.11649034917354584,
-0.37468037009239197,
-0.34621310234069824,
-0.12763711810112,
0.6108010411262512,
-0.054219406098127365,
0.147903710603714,
0.07170739769935608,
-0.29199180006980896,
-0.11253359913825989,
0.32448336482048035,
0.7226227521896362,
0.8493501543998718,
-0.016617437824606895,
0.27303460240364075,
0.1617947816848755,
-0.20403365790843964,
0.20500384271144867,
0.07840291410684586,
-0.2806936204433441,
-0.06289089471101761,
0.6050387620925903,
0.5724270343780518,
0.3163378834724426,
-0.9312999844551086,
0.8243477940559387,
0.15214253962039948,
-0.3618696331977844,
-0.26225584745407104,
-0.04556480795145035,
-0.048437926918268204,
0.8078164458274841,
0.28196170926094055,
0.05556546896696091,
0.25733041763305664,
-0.5640298128128052,
-0.01760745979845524,
0.386062890291214,
-0.0836293175816536,
-0.06396487355232239,
0.45307648181915283,
-0.06818173080682755,
-0.5548691749572754,
0.5465807318687439,
-0.21550272405147552,
-0.9326654672622681,
0.42220908403396606,
0.7338554263114929,
0.45048218965530396,
-0.38430532813072205,
0.5227140188217163,
0.0071768625639379025,
0.32054537534713745,
-0.2178388088941574,
0.494843065738678,
0.16400231420993805,
-0.7989856600761414,
-0.3900551497936249,
-0.5028005242347717,
-0.5907890200614929,
0.04532187432050705,
-0.6458396911621094,
-0.11734964698553085,
-0.4997631907463074,
-0.029455171898007393,
0.05597854405641556,
0.13903309404850006,
-0.24663466215133667,
-0.055505987256765366,
-0.044985853135585785,
0.7911884784698486,
-0.9232222437858582,
0.36115366220474243,
0.4572502374649048,
-0.138981431722641,
-0.8839496970176697,
-0.028655946254730225,
0.1420668512582779,
-0.7578977942466736,
0.7959646582603455,
0.048099372535943985,
-0.3764600455760956,
-0.30987709760665894,
-0.6616971492767334,
-0.8157747387886047,
0.756843626499176,
0.7897723317146301,
-0.634579598903656,
0.05618441477417946,
0.3815540373325348,
0.471481591463089,
-0.35738837718963623,
0.07501161843538284,
0.5800380110740662,
0.6878402829170227,
0.47953319549560547,
-0.8317683339118958,
0.018907442688941956,
-0.16264218091964722,
0.1264842450618744,
0.1605236828327179,
-0.5515594482421875,
1.1400172710418701,
0.04267728328704834,
-0.05637725815176964,
0.10656305402517319,
0.7448239326477051,
0.8996962308883667,
0.18021705746650696,
0.7912960648536682,
0.5915144085884094,
0.9998971223831177,
-0.14456109702587128,
0.8289827108383179,
0.16937248408794403,
-0.02198263257741928,
1.2433969974517822,
-0.715598464012146,
1.0009092092514038,
0.36680787801742554,
-0.21210262179374695,
0.7998027801513672,
0.238012433052063,
0.0070025199092924595,
0.5753393173217773,
0.3367384672164917,
0.08151689171791077,
-0.5872947573661804,
-0.2639695405960083,
-0.6239736080169678,
0.6270222067832947,
0.48808664083480835,
0.047424159944057465,
-0.27406546473503113,
-0.08559250831604004,
-0.013418647460639477,
0.5973176956176758,
-0.0388956144452095,
0.29111865162849426,
-0.05459342151880264,
-0.7368776798248291,
0.3763345777988434,
0.030658401548862457,
0.0521012507379055,
-0.6666399836540222,
-0.3313600420951843,
-0.1188684031367302,
0.2676979601383209,
0.21472890675067902,
-0.889668881893158,
0.12360166758298874,
-0.1003904938697815,
-0.17650246620178223,
-0.187813863158226,
0.6818401217460632,
-0.058502197265625,
-0.5330082178115845,
-0.010506566613912582,
0.2371515929698944,
0.33548152446746826,
-0.013611226342618465,
-0.8503762483596802,
0.4271688759326935,
-0.10004782676696777,
0.018490144982933998,
0.03590523451566696,
0.7052859663963318,
-0.20765772461891174,
0.7871266007423401,
0.5509251356124878,
-0.13433268666267395,
-0.20732904970645905,
-0.010782308876514435,
0.746665358543396,
-0.5334742069244385,
-0.6884732842445374,
-0.7448607087135315,
0.38748905062675476,
-0.17866802215576172,
-0.288315087556839,
0.8543972373008728,
0.4971298575401306,
0.3680088520050049,
0.009924403391778469,
0.4166632890701294,
0.22285525500774384,
1.1028281450271606,
-0.4902302920818329,
0.2399117648601532,
-0.4170614778995514,
0.30287763476371765,
-0.5896638631820679,
-0.9260181188583374,
-0.15107984840869904,
1.1336760520935059,
-0.6145349144935608,
-0.13409419357776642,
0.8151364922523499,
0.46764281392097473,
0.1445271372795105,
0.49129289388656616,
0.29440903663635254,
0.4306733012199402,
0.10639640688896179,
0.8061618804931641,
1.2086304426193237,
-0.4454886317253113,
0.11651972681283951,
-0.02612975239753723,
-0.1365910917520523,
-0.127939835190773,
-0.9315171837806702,
-0.8475409150123596,
-0.6633282899856567,
-0.15283727645874023,
-0.10716340690851212,
0.03882916271686554,
0.6039167046546936,
0.4302785098552704,
-0.779589831829071,
-0.12385580688714981,
0.0834319218993187,
0.30565202236175537,
-0.24518118798732758,
-0.1650339812040329,
0.2774182856082916,
-0.018735479563474655,
-0.22189456224441528,
0.584781289100647,
0.28420165181159973,
-0.11106821894645691,
-0.2981613576412201,
0.037721190601587296,
-0.3100341260433197,
0.37461769580841064,
0.2686043381690979,
0.2561943233013153,
-0.957732081413269,
-0.5465237498283386,
0.20175693929195404,
0.07211025059223175,
-0.09599500149488449,
0.6915335655212402,
-0.8262739181518555,
0.39152583479881287,
0.3516589105129242,
0.6807993650436401,
0.4239402413368225,
0.12164926528930664,
0.38152197003364563,
-0.5373551249504089,
-0.04274692386388779,
0.624079704284668,
0.12801243364810944,
0.20932456851005554,
-0.13467071950435638,
0.5360889434814453,
0.47739118337631226,
-0.5636022090911865,
-1.26075279712677,
0.5258293151855469,
-0.9726507067680359,
-0.4958837628364563,
0.6047288179397583,
-0.11621187627315521,
-0.22923889756202698,
-0.05855855345726013,
-0.0045576984994113445,
-0.1998312771320343,
-0.023146159946918488,
0.5580044984817505,
1.112259030342102,
-0.11584734916687012,
-0.09994484484195709,
-0.922390878200531,
0.3193652629852295,
0.685640811920166,
-0.6954814791679382,
0.196355402469635,
0.6143243908882141,
0.005602592136710882,
0.5208747982978821,
0.4880646765232086,
-0.05040579289197922,
0.24982444941997528,
0.1253151148557663,
-0.3736549913883209,
0.03106675110757351,
-0.7416241765022278,
0.18863579630851746,
0.27732139825820923,
-0.25766757130622864,
0.012461881153285503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12534v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12534v3
|
Unified Active Retrieval for Retrieval Augmented Generation
| 2024-06-18T12:09:02 | 2024-06-27T15:37:15 |
Qinyuan Cheng, Xiaonan Li, Shimin Li, Qin Zhu, Zhangyue Yin, Yunfan Shao, Linyang Li, Tianxiang Sun, Hang Yan, Xipeng Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG), retrieval is not always helpful and
applying it to every instruction is sub-optimal. Therefore, determining whether
to retrieve is crucial for RAG, which is usually referred to as Active
Retrieval. However, existing active retrieval methods face two challenges: 1.
They usually rely on a single criterion, which struggles with handling various
types of instructions. 2. They depend on specialized and highly differentiated
procedures, and thus combining them makes the RAG system more complicated and
leads to higher response latency. To address these challenges, we propose
Unified Active Retrieval (UAR). UAR contains four orthogonal criteria and casts
them into plug-and-play classification tasks, which achieves multifaceted
retrieval timing judgements with negligible extra inference cost. We further
introduce the Unified Active Retrieval Criteria (UAR-Criteria), designed to
process diverse active retrieval scenarios through a standardized procedure.
Experiments on four representative types of user instructions show that UAR
significantly outperforms existing work on the retrieval timing judgement and
the performance of downstream tasks, which shows the effectiveness of UAR and
its helpfulness to downstream tasks.
|
[
-0.24270182847976685,
-0.7010135054588318,
0.45231321454048157,
0.3628605902194977,
-0.3008110523223877,
0.3471333682537079,
-0.04160204529762268,
-0.5798524022102356,
0.02342543751001358,
0.5453013181686401,
-0.00035127089358866215,
0.1950746476650238,
-0.08597399294376373,
0.1207868903875351,
-0.3886188864707947,
0.8940306901931763,
-0.14439862966537476,
-0.08623212575912476,
-0.09454788267612457,
-0.28498053550720215,
-0.7079699635505676,
-0.5619202256202698,
-0.4180162847042084,
-0.4463120996952057,
0.7583000063896179,
0.500201940536499,
0.5405466556549072,
0.5203033089637756,
0.7906316518783569,
0.3294582664966583,
-0.3697456419467926,
0.3415088653564453,
-0.09991571307182312,
0.3809013366699219,
-0.08689538389444351,
-0.25163429975509644,
-0.40551578998565674,
-0.026240065693855286,
0.595906138420105,
0.7179337739944458,
-0.2806328535079956,
0.31449010968208313,
0.057894181460142136,
0.7334516048431396,
-0.9860131144523621,
-0.42836445569992065,
-0.565475344657898,
0.2790559232234955,
-0.42436060309410095,
-0.4562884271144867,
-0.4622524082660675,
-0.24880069494247437,
-0.03598929941654205,
-0.44890809059143066,
0.5801423192024231,
0.10322824865579605,
0.7370789051055908,
0.05200714245438576,
-0.8487746119499207,
-0.1433747559785843,
-1.1219981908798218,
0.7564019560813904,
-0.12357432395219803,
0.40362676978111267,
0.17356166243553162,
0.4854815602302551,
-0.1105274111032486,
-1.025115728378296,
-0.32564687728881836,
-0.18727734684944153,
-0.13433636724948883,
0.23021697998046875,
-0.22859203815460205,
0.08592768758535385,
0.23294207453727722,
0.605242133140564,
-0.4429510533809662,
-0.18843060731887817,
-0.44280973076820374,
-0.22681567072868347,
0.5774922966957092,
-0.012690541334450245,
0.08065620064735413,
-0.38486433029174805,
-0.7378065586090088,
0.07835330814123154,
-0.5752772688865662,
0.1312282532453537,
0.38613030314445496,
0.38786664605140686,
0.48894259333610535,
0.7033418416976929,
-0.26393255591392517,
0.6880107522010803,
0.18453556299209595,
-0.004402915481477976,
0.16902343928813934,
-0.24178072810173035,
0.13900165259838104,
-0.23775941133499146,
0.48835259675979614,
-0.2810952663421631,
-0.36550888419151306,
-0.5658717155456543,
-0.6447167992591858,
0.04345053434371948,
0.7418410778045654,
-0.46154946088790894,
-0.032713279128074646,
-0.10000193864107132,
-0.4719759225845337,
0.06182488426566124,
0.38615038990974426,
-0.6393003463745117,
0.0183402169495821,
-0.4305310547351837,
0.8114870190620422,
-0.048691362142562866,
-0.0679921805858612,
-0.3417854607105255,
-0.1769096404314041,
0.13537651300430298,
0.23900924623012543,
-0.3354320526123047,
0.4028659760951996,
0.44440630078315735,
0.4669108986854553,
-0.5575815439224243,
-0.057809218764305115,
-1.0217353105545044,
0.1103094145655632,
-0.13929960131645203,
1.1440554857254028,
-0.695280909538269,
-0.5686486959457397,
-0.35032129287719727,
-0.14969481527805328,
-0.06661903113126755,
-0.5510287284851074,
0.8661388754844666,
-0.8989239931106567,
0.21501712501049042,
-0.2900450825691223,
-0.0816531851887703,
-0.12754185497760773,
-0.24853827059268951,
-0.7161789536476135,
1.2237749099731445,
0.18196634948253632,
-0.4577171504497528,
0.39897871017456055,
-0.6585999131202698,
-0.776618242263794,
0.536918044090271,
-0.27626800537109375,
-0.43469786643981934,
0.19954165816307068,
-0.0875362828373909,
0.29326528310775757,
-0.22586597502231598,
-0.004667013417929411,
-0.09120697528123856,
-0.5385738015174866,
-0.007008806336671114,
-0.5136652588844299,
0.5904207229614258,
0.6956509947776794,
-0.47291770577430725,
-0.15332990884780884,
-0.7404153347015381,
0.2953508198261261,
-0.06095213443040848,
-0.8337156772613525,
-0.37948834896087646,
-0.0677919015288353,
-0.004016492515802383,
-0.12434040755033493,
0.315164715051651,
-0.5876448750495911,
0.2671296000480652,
0.18469110131263733,
-0.2015434205532074,
0.675701379776001,
0.2002163529396057,
0.6541433334350586,
-0.17259275913238525,
0.5687748789787292,
-0.3197948634624481,
0.23977400362491608,
-0.08774570375680923,
-0.5501264333724976,
-0.6399409770965576,
-0.17763832211494446,
0.46085816621780396,
0.5566534996032715,
-0.6730782389640808,
0.45135626196861267,
0.14966970682144165,
-0.2848585844039917,
-0.43639346957206726,
0.30388298630714417,
0.962273120880127,
0.5347416996955872,
0.5674530267715454,
-0.4640626013278961,
-0.6583602428436279,
-0.46606382727622986,
-0.22162343561649323,
-0.16763894259929657,
-0.1014266163110733,
0.6943697929382324,
0.1678769886493683,
-0.19145849347114563,
0.7685145139694214,
-0.3362368047237396,
-0.386576384305954,
-0.22959409654140472,
0.49806666374206543,
0.14829477667808533,
0.1795261949300766,
0.22913435101509094,
-1.322252869606018,
-0.3896794617176056,
0.06974632292985916,
-0.6987783312797546,
-0.38315510749816895,
0.011251868680119514,
-0.1435515135526657,
0.21743527054786682,
0.22610870003700256,
-0.4350857138633728,
0.6587980389595032,
0.12603776156902313,
-0.45180267095565796,
0.32919779419898987,
-0.42228952050209045,
0.4151783287525177,
-0.6011087894439697,
0.43476617336273193,
-0.3578762412071228,
0.02687544748187065,
-0.294486403465271,
0.37608692049980164,
0.16444352269172668,
0.046476591378450394,
-0.18517716228961945,
0.6138680577278137,
-0.9395016431808472,
-0.3619422912597656,
-0.30081942677497864,
-0.3136569857597351,
0.12236744910478592,
0.15129870176315308,
-0.3985162377357483,
0.9159359931945801,
0.2011152058839798,
-1.0101910829544067,
0.346245139837265,
0.05043446645140648,
0.10184574127197266,
0.4195261597633362,
-0.7222962379455566,
0.46749356389045715,
-0.17193953692913055,
0.17504364252090454,
-0.9136569499969482,
-0.2532896399497986,
-0.2729012668132782,
-0.4958585202693939,
0.6120548844337463,
-0.3098486363887787,
-0.4041089117527008,
-0.6017339825630188,
0.04051581025123596,
0.3240053355693817,
0.6677635312080383,
-0.8021079897880554,
0.9903254508972168,
0.4696056842803955,
0.16328753530979156,
-0.7867943644523621,
-0.12042659521102905,
-0.12580615282058716,
-0.06466595828533173,
-0.19027158617973328,
0.5269026160240173,
0.034149352461099625,
-0.07106821984052658,
0.24188317358493805,
-0.47932466864585876,
0.05001320689916611,
0.09596659988164902,
0.12639333307743073,
0.27614641189575195,
-0.019880076870322227,
-0.2017947882413864,
-0.034113310277462006,
-0.1876957267522812,
-0.4129103124141693,
0.2026827484369278,
0.2330189347267151,
0.1988213062286377,
-0.6026357412338257,
-0.056856606155633926,
0.5240151882171631,
0.20534123480319977,
-0.7145880460739136,
0.15650822222232819,
0.8550160527229309,
-0.021622370928525925,
-0.19040586054325104,
-0.8043546676635742,
-0.04196620360016823,
-0.4945252239704132,
-0.1769033670425415,
-0.5224041938781738,
-0.6431099772453308,
0.4960552155971527,
0.0935177430510521,
0.36563995480537415,
0.4431949257850647,
0.353929728269577,
-0.10299299657344818,
1.5353573560714722,
0.4176800847053528,
0.2983005940914154,
0.47242823243141174,
-0.2677888572216034,
-0.010869280435144901,
-1.0809407234191895,
-0.5659111142158508,
-0.785693347454071,
-0.35605043172836304,
-0.19223099946975708,
-0.37718233466148376,
0.5792366862297058,
0.4374019205570221,
-0.1710301637649536,
0.3825685679912567,
-0.8781933188438416,
0.3582080602645874,
0.5648919343948364,
0.09840554744005203,
0.35756731033325195,
0.210128054022789,
-0.417564332485199,
0.09091732650995255,
-0.5466241836547852,
-0.3203526437282562,
0.9582199454307556,
-0.18178385496139526,
0.9102749824523926,
0.4389690160751343,
0.7406527400016785,
0.6156312227249146,
0.4257480502128601,
-0.5766343474388123,
0.6985920667648315,
-0.42856571078300476,
-0.8382899165153503,
-0.024634508416056633,
-0.9776893258094788,
-1.561070442199707,
0.3196346163749695,
-0.24743840098381042,
-0.5096451640129089,
0.1278582662343979,
0.0381128191947937,
-0.35295671224594116,
0.23741309344768524,
-0.760962963104248,
0.3026512563228607,
-0.41214191913604736,
-0.2558108866214752,
0.08414576202630997,
-0.7378035187721252,
0.18355189263820648,
-0.07400909066200256,
0.11044362932443619,
-0.06805066019296646,
-0.10966425389051437,
0.7260011434555054,
-0.11823347955942154,
0.3012695610523224,
-0.3482052683830261,
0.37683090567588806,
0.4751206934452057,
-0.014378081075847149,
0.23943442106246948,
-0.115372434258461,
-0.01116922590881586,
-0.3996129631996155,
-0.20870181918144226,
-0.3062857389450073,
-0.5775389075279236,
0.7540823817253113,
-0.6935065984725952,
-0.4300040006637573,
-0.619001030921936,
-0.21814987063407898,
-0.08194158226251602,
0.40637314319610596,
0.3146190345287323,
0.52004075050354,
-0.09248903393745422,
0.3123054504394531,
0.6243763566017151,
0.23415149748325348,
0.4014087915420532,
0.8863885998725891,
-0.16580061614513397,
-0.3032841384410858,
0.8971712589263916,
0.1981208622455597,
-0.020171428099274635,
0.5143609046936035,
0.22301289439201355,
-0.5089155435562134,
-0.47838935256004333,
-0.569797694683075,
0.09909190237522125,
-0.4085029661655426,
-0.682341456413269,
-0.7673642635345459,
-0.13136354088783264,
-0.37977564334869385,
0.12355438619852066,
-0.3318443298339844,
-0.4908568263053894,
-0.3881346881389618,
0.2316380888223648,
0.3530137538909912,
0.7953985333442688,
-0.2922084927558899,
-0.08743607252836227,
-1.0815544128417969,
1.1083773374557495,
0.5585627555847168,
0.4737463891506195,
-0.04187425598502159,
-0.8111417293548584,
0.052745379507541656,
-0.14658769965171814,
-0.6935244798660278,
-0.7452722787857056,
0.0015824296278879046,
0.3962283730506897,
1.1692677736282349,
0.2835042178630829,
0.35216161608695984,
0.8783560991287231,
-0.6935086250305176,
0.4474692940711975,
-0.04771390184760094,
-0.47111520171165466,
0.6092361211776733,
0.10581191629171371,
0.10787089169025421,
0.4756016731262207,
0.389658123254776,
-0.04461541399359703,
-0.10368359833955765,
-0.6723101735115051,
-1.282484531402588,
0.6062651872634888,
0.24120062589645386,
0.22747385501861572,
-0.07362091541290283,
0.5300177335739136,
-0.12239501625299454,
-0.1822448968887329,
-0.18139559030532837,
-0.42571496963500977,
0.21611428260803223,
0.3072938621044159,
0.22962962090969086,
-0.184315487742424,
-0.06552167236804962,
-0.1587221771478653,
0.47779926657676697,
0.08311831206083298,
0.47297215461730957,
0.32582998275756836,
0.01867837831377983,
-0.6300961971282959,
0.45595911145210266,
-0.22917436063289642,
0.5839398503303528,
-0.3154497444629669,
0.08433989435434341,
-0.05858976021409035,
-0.6465356945991516,
0.3588484227657318,
0.599147617816925,
-0.34026631712913513,
0.20890063047409058,
0.10069820284843445,
0.425824373960495,
0.3513275980949402,
-0.43764761090278625,
0.43224263191223145,
-0.19145582616329193,
0.040786758065223694,
-0.28565287590026855,
0.30817943811416626,
-0.7118078470230103,
0.1624504178762436,
1.1756839752197266,
0.29481565952301025,
0.6042521595954895,
-0.70253586769104,
0.5506204962730408,
0.44646987318992615,
-0.2209034562110901,
-0.29553475975990295,
0.9692664742469788,
0.15304845571517944,
-0.4246641993522644,
0.5040057301521301,
-0.5761278867721558,
-0.4493272006511688,
0.2501368522644043,
0.587443470954895,
0.817156195640564,
-0.5474565029144287,
0.09598321467638016,
0.26317888498306274,
-0.22702498733997345,
-0.3414211571216583,
0.5844642519950867,
-0.18959297239780426,
-0.38550934195518494,
-0.52933669090271,
-0.9059897065162659,
-0.45918554067611694,
-0.1884823441505432,
-1.1819486618041992,
0.01711471751332283,
-0.09608816355466843,
-0.4713258445262909,
0.2113223820924759,
0.13280385732650757,
-0.505530595779419,
0.03861323744058609,
-0.1116361916065216,
0.5866594910621643,
-0.3888508081436157,
0.367316871881485,
1.2700034379959106,
-0.502436101436615,
-0.8829251527786255,
-0.25558391213417053,
-0.03856859356164932,
-0.4019474685192108,
0.5080094933509827,
-0.041172292083501816,
-0.24485181272029877,
-0.06435657292604446,
-0.27496805787086487,
-0.7311837077140808,
1.0217623710632324,
0.05031643807888031,
0.04934586212038994,
-0.21521374583244324,
-0.5653014183044434,
0.4621035158634186,
-0.12808476388454437,
0.18099667131900787,
0.37795203924179077,
0.37884557247161865,
0.6143363118171692,
-1.0306600332260132,
-0.09041932225227356,
-0.4231836497783661,
0.0798998549580574,
0.5784993171691895,
-0.5129911303520203,
0.9605261087417603,
-0.48493120074272156,
-0.59163498878479,
0.2880702316761017,
0.8157675862312317,
0.4499632716178894,
0.5293780565261841,
0.6351017951965332,
0.6039872169494629,
0.46996521949768066,
-0.05145658180117607,
1.080146312713623,
0.13497747480869293,
0.13316479325294495,
0.6081318855285645,
-0.24258825182914734,
0.9230158925056458,
0.33571478724479675,
-0.3648875653743744,
0.2902292013168335,
0.1673153191804886,
0.1383538544178009,
0.44828277826309204,
-0.22299349308013916,
-0.5722920894622803,
-0.1500326544046402,
-0.2705296277999878,
-0.3638274073600769,
0.559745728969574,
0.23493143916130066,
-0.026471750810742378,
-0.2231443226337433,
-0.04958367347717285,
-0.04181164130568504,
0.21682919561862946,
-0.3443138897418976,
0.9771322011947632,
-0.1537119597196579,
-0.9808729887008667,
0.5572494268417358,
-0.120433010160923,
0.5774912238121033,
-0.5122419595718384,
-0.5194368958473206,
-0.38752660155296326,
0.4705454409122467,
-0.3479279577732086,
-0.6931082606315613,
0.09739544242620468,
0.27351030707359314,
-0.1472637951374054,
-0.261165976524353,
0.7634081244468689,
-0.13697245717048645,
-0.45982322096824646,
0.34455475211143494,
0.6217793226242065,
0.24232815206050873,
-0.014891089871525764,
-0.6427062153816223,
0.0254665520042181,
0.07428786158561707,
-0.37850865721702576,
0.4641117453575134,
0.6628181338310242,
-0.17162242531776428,
0.41245037317276,
0.8820240497589111,
0.22907693684101105,
0.2935531735420227,
0.23874223232269287,
1.038235068321228,
-0.5690856575965881,
-0.1490289866924286,
-0.07027439028024673,
0.4358842372894287,
0.05221157521009445,
-0.20391666889190674,
0.8660039305686951,
0.7642943263053894,
0.5853029489517212,
0.36323973536491394,
0.5510253310203552,
-0.44946974515914917,
1.1069649457931519,
-0.37436288595199585,
0.426713228225708,
-0.8690561056137085,
0.4875096380710602,
-0.12404768913984299,
-1.1535170078277588,
-0.2910737097263336,
0.5708953142166138,
0.25734657049179077,
0.3832530081272125,
0.46732479333877563,
0.4572330713272095,
-0.3443819284439087,
-0.27884483337402344,
0.14744450151920319,
-0.2089136838912964,
0.24482539296150208,
0.14721430838108063,
0.821138858795166,
-0.3846864104270935,
1.030543565750122,
-0.4024028480052948,
-0.4010900855064392,
-0.34301626682281494,
-0.49627885222435,
-0.501002848148346,
-0.541779100894928,
0.0761064812541008,
-0.34107092022895813,
0.0998406931757927,
0.6244141459465027,
0.5773468613624573,
-0.6804940104484558,
-0.04090908542275429,
0.09159210324287415,
0.01949583925306797,
-0.26845815777778625,
-0.25697851181030273,
0.2505999505519867,
-0.7681375741958618,
-0.47713491320610046,
0.5353415608406067,
0.14017625153064728,
-0.020077450200915337,
-0.03176017850637436,
0.029202928766608238,
-0.293435275554657,
-0.09363715350627899,
0.5922803282737732,
0.7504256963729858,
-0.5821866989135742,
-0.19258202612400055,
0.38624826073646545,
-0.19256457686424255,
-0.06613510102033615,
1.1433099508285522,
-0.920856773853302,
0.6030557751655579,
0.44520220160484314,
0.6022555828094482,
0.5867884755134583,
0.3953297734260559,
0.357494980096817,
-0.9325802326202393,
-0.18636314570903778,
0.6352761387825012,
0.255682110786438,
0.2519949972629547,
-0.43258941173553467,
0.6868669986724854,
0.16017749905586243,
-0.9307668805122375,
-0.933014452457428,
0.11506133526563644,
-1.0685324668884277,
-0.14648857712745667,
1.2571431398391724,
-0.1522197127342224,
-0.03883597254753113,
-0.6029939651489258,
-0.30774766206741333,
0.4313277304172516,
-0.5495406985282898,
0.7786149978637695,
-0.21171849966049194,
-0.5804190039634705,
0.026909103617072105,
-0.4543232321739197,
0.2510712146759033,
0.26417815685272217,
-0.425351083278656,
-0.17150594294071198,
0.6021091938018799,
-0.09129813313484192,
0.475728839635849,
0.6436218619346619,
-0.347397118806839,
0.5323755145072937,
-0.13423927128314972,
0.10648422688245773,
-0.029804076999425888,
-0.679876983165741,
-0.14918632805347443,
0.18985632061958313,
-0.010834644548594952,
-0.1877610832452774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12527v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12527v1
|
FuseGen: PLM Fusion for Data-generation based Zero-shot Learning
| 2024-06-18T11:55:05 | 2024-06-18T11:55:05 |
Tianyuan Zou, Yang Liu, Peng Li, Jianqing Zhang, Jingjing Liu, Ya-Qin Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Data generation-based zero-shot learning, although effective in training
Small Task-specific Models (STMs) via synthetic datasets generated by
Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs), is often limited by the low quality of such
synthetic datasets. Previous solutions have primarily focused on single PLM
settings, where synthetic datasets are typically restricted to specific
sub-spaces and often deviate from real-world distributions, leading to severe
distribution bias. To mitigate such bias, we propose FuseGen, a novel data
generation-based zero-shot learning framework that introduces a new criteria
for subset selection from synthetic datasets via utilizing multiple PLMs and
trained STMs. The chosen subset provides in-context feedback to each PLM,
enhancing dataset quality through iterative data generation. Trained STMs are
then used for sample re-weighting as well, further improving data quality.
Extensive experiments across diverse tasks demonstrate that FuseGen
substantially outperforms existing methods, highly effective in boosting STM
performance in a PLM-agnostic way. Code is provided in
https://github.com/LindaLydia/FuseGen.
|
[
-0.15880274772644043,
-0.5196377635002136,
0.34082597494125366,
0.08608325570821762,
-0.37245818972587585,
0.3073360323905945,
-0.20196717977523804,
0.01215967908501625,
0.00833924300968647,
0.5043467879295349,
-0.7479262948036194,
-0.6854238510131836,
-0.28031468391418457,
0.03853645548224449,
-0.47601211071014404,
0.7399408221244812,
-0.05764870345592499,
0.21988315880298615,
-0.6360752582550049,
-0.07950306683778763,
-0.5152866244316101,
-0.2356332242488861,
-0.13731420040130615,
-0.5287952423095703,
0.3166060745716095,
0.7525991201400757,
0.2649286091327667,
0.6787510514259338,
0.29393190145492554,
0.09102160483598709,
0.6161432862281799,
0.28033164143562317,
-0.8888416886329651,
0.2120070606470108,
-0.11079743504524231,
-0.36421433091163635,
0.1719282567501068,
0.13959096372127533,
0.6113561391830444,
0.5920586585998535,
-0.06734773516654968,
0.18088315427303314,
-0.15905511379241943,
0.3882722854614258,
-0.8318619728088379,
-0.08360106498003006,
-0.8367838859558105,
0.15386052429676056,
-0.23030303418636322,
-0.29522788524627686,
-0.6910625696182251,
-0.2473037838935852,
-0.08156568557024002,
-0.6507744193077087,
0.7684215903282166,
0.0643530935049057,
0.7897393703460693,
0.3710482716560364,
-0.371211439371109,
0.3800988793373108,
-0.8169499635696411,
1.1122435331344604,
-0.396770179271698,
0.2774980068206787,
-0.015897853299975395,
0.4635125994682312,
-0.1744927316904068,
-0.3085103929042816,
-0.548314094543457,
-0.000009318114280176815,
0.14467474818229675,
0.47056078910827637,
0.157653346657753,
-0.0324600450694561,
0.13348844647407532,
0.608138382434845,
-0.7911810874938965,
0.08111070096492767,
-0.46554455161094666,
-0.062491580843925476,
0.905287504196167,
0.01461663469672203,
0.06331821531057358,
-0.0801505520939827,
-0.60073322057724,
-0.34750068187713623,
-1.19605553150177,
-0.24761873483657837,
0.4075140953063965,
0.5552312135696411,
-0.15168261528015137,
0.3847653567790985,
-0.3233453035354614,
1.0498371124267578,
-0.020370228216052055,
-0.03749791532754898,
0.5308381915092468,
-0.38990646600723267,
-0.2733649015426636,
0.08612237125635147,
0.8636780977249146,
0.03882967680692673,
-0.1452156901359558,
-0.18037402629852295,
0.015139489434659481,
0.1760087013244629,
0.08405151963233948,
-0.6861802935600281,
-0.37841206789016724,
0.2872721254825592,
-0.12492524087429047,
-0.5663715600967407,
0.22241488099098206,
-0.6390349864959717,
-0.3103521168231964,
-0.14919418096542358,
0.4886620342731476,
-0.5733280181884766,
-0.22308704257011414,
0.16647905111312866,
-0.3929250240325928,
0.45195749402046204,
0.06107432022690773,
-0.543660581111908,
-0.1458115130662918,
0.24083031713962555,
0.6317923069000244,
-0.2854851186275482,
-0.4116535484790802,
-0.6845499277114868,
0.3162675201892853,
-0.271237850189209,
1.0991202592849731,
-0.4985481798648834,
-0.7604802846908569,
-0.07732593268156052,
-0.3346770107746124,
-0.17462386190891266,
-0.710452139377594,
0.3513554036617279,
0.1358375996351242,
0.4459409713745117,
0.004718951415270567,
-0.7289522290229797,
0.10810860991477966,
0.02451970800757408,
-0.32015639543533325,
1.066096544265747,
0.37217503786087036,
-0.366476446390152,
0.6485588550567627,
-0.3452923595905304,
-0.7109478712081909,
0.2888786494731903,
-0.4575244188308716,
-0.5747604966163635,
0.30975985527038574,
0.1524970680475235,
0.48208650946617126,
-0.34066241979599,
0.08807981014251709,
-0.5895999670028687,
-0.3437671959400177,
-0.16387991607189178,
-0.13783732056617737,
0.5691306591033936,
0.18212449550628662,
-0.059065867215394974,
0.3171921670436859,
-0.8073923587799072,
0.0932408794760704,
0.2577165365219116,
0.01642504148185253,
-0.024920130148530006,
-0.01798405684530735,
-0.24269255995750427,
0.662691056728363,
-0.18686281144618988,
-0.8788930773735046,
0.24336501955986023,
-0.6724021434783936,
0.10009359568357468,
0.4885822534561157,
0.14684279263019562,
0.5146344900131226,
-0.6555227637290955,
0.4612289071083069,
0.20865629613399506,
0.09393691271543503,
-0.49884718656539917,
-0.24889688193798065,
-0.6942000985145569,
-0.4160684049129486,
0.3045678734779358,
0.5019891858100891,
-1.2759474515914917,
0.5746357440948486,
-0.22414612770080566,
-0.7367829084396362,
-0.6974359750747681,
0.5131785273551941,
0.30762192606925964,
0.7425572872161865,
0.37849903106689453,
-0.22101904451847076,
-0.5631521344184875,
-0.7599896192550659,
0.11112848669290543,
0.11146777123212814,
-0.23161581158638,
0.334042489528656,
0.3279344439506531,
0.09710505604743958,
1.2269775867462158,
-0.6240048408508301,
-0.5092645883560181,
-0.6734971404075623,
0.23123569786548615,
-0.03469201922416687,
0.33382171392440796,
0.6195480227470398,
-0.5042006373405457,
-0.5386905074119568,
-0.2763277292251587,
-0.696662962436676,
-0.33470258116722107,
-0.32926833629608154,
-0.10914282500743866,
-0.0002361569058848545,
0.08225109428167343,
-0.330429345369339,
0.17029458284378052,
0.5479475855827332,
-0.028289930894970894,
0.443747341632843,
-0.2156822681427002,
-0.23115959763526917,
-1.238599419593811,
0.13631412386894226,
0.0903211161494255,
-0.15764881670475006,
-0.8382322192192078,
-0.1746581792831421,
0.08886202424764633,
-0.28278741240501404,
-0.9863293766975403,
0.67692631483078,
-0.1648179590702057,
-0.041278526186943054,
-0.3311438262462616,
0.13358725607395172,
0.017950713634490967,
0.3675908148288727,
0.26820456981658936,
0.6250206232070923,
0.8465311527252197,
-0.44975656270980835,
0.38085728883743286,
0.38004446029663086,
-0.1938149333000183,
0.6482560634613037,
-0.4676632583141327,
-0.12027433514595032,
-0.3066021800041199,
0.3061944544315338,
-0.9072532057762146,
-0.3760961592197418,
0.05935514345765114,
-0.3872578740119934,
0.3601734936237335,
0.17655925452709198,
-0.6126128435134888,
-0.3385979235172272,
-0.4728487432003021,
0.32304587960243225,
0.7513187527656555,
-0.6039594411849976,
0.3141389787197113,
0.2511291801929474,
0.2659325897693634,
-0.2335304170846939,
-0.41199350357055664,
-0.25813353061676025,
0.05863821506500244,
-0.6098699569702148,
0.4927219748497009,
0.026485491544008255,
0.1898527890443802,
-0.17826031148433685,
-0.2020847052335739,
0.11733083426952362,
-0.09054186195135117,
0.2704208493232727,
0.37520095705986023,
0.2787128686904907,
0.12681522965431213,
0.08943431079387665,
-0.2824276089668274,
-0.4934363067150116,
-0.40723931789398193,
0.5769416093826294,
0.4637438952922821,
-0.4240734279155731,
-0.004858081694692373,
0.21225668489933014,
0.1929280012845993,
-0.1820695847272873,
0.6411728858947754,
0.4974119961261749,
-0.02885863371193409,
-0.8910753726959229,
-0.3427937626838684,
-0.3128412365913391,
-0.399599552154541,
-0.10959426313638687,
-0.11761975288391113,
-0.8980268239974976,
0.15770770609378815,
-0.15991845726966858,
0.2184699922800064,
0.5098860859870911,
0.5675597786903381,
-0.27034494280815125,
1.0757477283477783,
0.45834892988204956,
-0.01574060320854187,
0.4860149025917053,
-0.3932633101940155,
0.1490410566329956,
-0.4348161518573761,
-0.1885351836681366,
-0.14417552947998047,
-0.4678192436695099,
-0.16243070363998413,
-0.5411228537559509,
0.35032957792282104,
-0.10342678427696228,
-0.051423732191324234,
0.3663928806781769,
-0.5889492034912109,
0.5583750009536743,
0.6925551891326904,
0.01867181994020939,
0.11287597566843033,
0.022852353751659393,
-0.14655911922454834,
0.2081596404314041,
-1.0655525922775269,
0.04606867581605911,
1.1727344989776611,
-0.06555047631263733,
0.8203626275062561,
-0.35177046060562134,
0.9763860702514648,
0.13624654710292816,
0.3398117423057556,
-0.6063864231109619,
0.49944522976875305,
-0.484247088432312,
-0.4682224988937378,
0.08283768594264984,
-0.8395030498504639,
-0.7294555902481079,
0.11699163168668747,
-0.2573543190956116,
-0.2870582938194275,
0.11694301664829254,
0.3186510503292084,
-0.5834329724311829,
0.2262612283229828,
-0.6399757862091064,
0.8612129092216492,
-0.4237715005874634,
-0.39727330207824707,
0.08357077836990356,
-0.6629258990287781,
0.5606450438499451,
-0.183100625872612,
-0.15795964002609253,
-0.41780996322631836,
0.3104352355003357,
0.44029700756073,
-0.4211694300174713,
0.7300193309783936,
-0.3817237615585327,
0.1430802196264267,
0.3983495235443115,
-0.11639011651277542,
0.20175237953662872,
-0.20969152450561523,
0.10546086728572845,
0.3195645213127136,
-0.11413126438856125,
-0.5729612708091736,
-0.4376066327095032,
0.8070179224014282,
-0.680158257484436,
-0.24387206137180328,
-0.43307989835739136,
-0.7726797461509705,
-0.5155259370803833,
0.19777989387512207,
0.5856661200523376,
0.12081539630889893,
-0.09079904854297638,
0.4088592827320099,
0.8147286176681519,
-0.39647558331489563,
0.16595302522182465,
0.6863697171211243,
-0.11741647124290466,
-0.4180583655834198,
1.5132743120193481,
0.08303762227296829,
0.41885581612586975,
0.41239795088768005,
-0.03708672150969505,
-0.26614829897880554,
-0.472817987203598,
-0.4927949607372284,
0.19446410238742828,
-0.09616166353225708,
-0.5668172836303711,
-0.22929607331752777,
-0.2894146740436554,
-0.3732624650001526,
-0.3332991302013397,
-0.3327459692955017,
-0.27151602506637573,
-0.34481707215309143,
-0.22281429171562195,
0.11351475864648819,
0.2178177833557129,
0.0059152692556381226,
0.4360315799713135,
-0.7910215854644775,
0.49056604504585266,
0.11157380789518356,
0.44602084159851074,
-0.6266893744468689,
-0.3812755346298218,
-0.0001139240266638808,
0.14855951070785522,
-0.4659520983695984,
-0.7900227904319763,
0.5494605302810669,
0.5179511904716492,
0.5487088561058044,
0.3778090476989746,
0.2810165584087372,
0.4943857789039612,
-0.3087935149669647,
0.8643117547035217,
0.39258548617362976,
-0.6664791107177734,
0.920369029045105,
-0.5491478443145752,
0.6458694934844971,
0.6396998763084412,
0.0882008820772171,
-0.23238235712051392,
-0.5122731328010559,
-0.7944934368133545,
-0.7699275612831116,
0.8973411917686462,
0.15890999138355255,
-0.026275336742401123,
0.0809893012046814,
0.17364604771137238,
0.4330328106880188,
0.4077993929386139,
-0.3403710424900055,
-0.3167429268360138,
-0.45560699701309204,
-0.5107784867286682,
-0.11256987601518631,
0.12088421732187271,
-0.08159060776233673,
-0.2083369791507721,
0.7976551651954651,
-0.31929293274879456,
0.1369161605834961,
-0.005848730448633432,
-0.28715938329696655,
-0.30157479643821716,
0.07053957134485245,
0.4956599771976471,
0.28695371747016907,
-0.24692997336387634,
-0.0326506569981575,
0.1537330150604248,
-0.04272225871682167,
0.31747499108314514,
0.24926264584064484,
-0.5908679962158203,
0.158487468957901,
-0.03326939791440964,
0.8461021184921265,
0.4473416209220886,
-0.9584535360336304,
0.527716338634491,
0.13161982595920563,
-0.6508907079696655,
-0.11526915431022644,
0.5201693773269653,
-0.32752320170402527,
-0.19767692685127258,
0.44108885526657104,
-0.05510547384619713,
-0.34789085388183594,
-0.29319116473197937,
0.6490339040756226,
0.5135138034820557,
-0.2440372258424759,
-0.34026098251342773,
0.6321040987968445,
0.39728444814682007,
0.10686253756284714,
0.5615219473838806,
-0.2886701822280884,
-0.0475541390478611,
0.41432952880859375,
0.5583723187446594,
0.8358471989631653,
-0.3589687645435333,
0.7344319224357605,
0.27915677428245544,
-0.034217577427625656,
-0.06619231402873993,
0.425141304731369,
-0.13916867971420288,
-0.8004775047302246,
-0.47986477613449097,
-0.7943313717842102,
-0.42652803659439087,
0.26060277223587036,
-0.3227415680885315,
0.4604291021823883,
-0.5984563231468201,
0.20062825083732605,
-0.25440335273742676,
-0.12907016277313232,
-0.6321563124656677,
0.0723307654261589,
0.22253380715847015,
1.0543591976165771,
-1.0792144536972046,
1.0858038663864136,
0.4020501375198364,
-0.5890487432479858,
-0.4817322790622711,
-0.2858394682407379,
0.17518076300621033,
-0.7541566491127014,
0.2689765691757202,
0.15202337503433228,
0.24522998929023743,
0.2846669852733612,
-0.4305969774723053,
-0.6840851902961731,
1.2364990711212158,
0.642669141292572,
-0.3120250403881073,
0.0833045020699501,
0.47584766149520874,
0.32077598571777344,
-0.5034822821617126,
-0.13843505084514618,
0.4720225930213928,
0.07006973028182983,
0.7906138896942139,
-0.5920538902282715,
-0.3619135022163391,
-0.06443620473146439,
0.06436041742563248,
0.44448912143707275,
-0.6810528039932251,
0.5033580660820007,
0.12176841497421265,
-0.4493868947029114,
-0.1577250063419342,
0.46985194087028503,
0.40583139657974243,
0.25121086835861206,
0.17117483913898468,
0.8662447929382324,
0.36113980412483215,
-0.41310712695121765,
0.9549245238304138,
-0.4112861454486847,
0.3768235445022583,
1.1981704235076904,
-0.878749668598175,
0.7294476628303528,
0.3444751501083374,
0.08928701281547546,
0.24261480569839478,
0.4562510848045349,
-0.515011727809906,
0.7757903337478638,
0.07166603207588196,
-0.5673890113830566,
-0.4033587872982025,
-0.37714487314224243,
-0.10518784075975418,
0.41854673624038696,
0.19756130874156952,
-0.30384403467178345,
-0.6737598776817322,
0.3488398492336273,
-0.3983045518398285,
-0.15669630467891693,
-0.14435213804244995,
0.7946078181266785,
-0.041926704347133636,
-0.4933837056159973,
0.2966555058956146,
-0.22547000646591187,
0.6531856060028076,
-0.8259034752845764,
-0.028212159872055054,
-0.2196079045534134,
0.19263507425785065,
-0.31008487939834595,
-0.6707118153572083,
0.4037822186946869,
-0.09886791557073593,
-0.16974079608917236,
-0.6152681112289429,
1.0818848609924316,
-0.718532383441925,
-0.5666523575782776,
-0.07502107322216034,
0.7145208716392517,
-0.1900792121887207,
-0.04167480766773224,
-0.575238823890686,
-0.028263939544558525,
0.030334845185279846,
0.18883706629276276,
0.5532298684120178,
-0.29281800985336304,
0.3524496853351593,
0.586710512638092,
0.8588420152664185,
0.3014070391654968,
-0.017983470112085342,
-0.002404566388577223,
0.6908733248710632,
-0.37966302037239075,
-0.19544917345046997,
-0.5562774538993835,
0.6391615867614746,
-0.2750210165977478,
-0.16662150621414185,
1.0267263650894165,
0.6576887965202332,
1.2160882949829102,
-0.1378813236951828,
1.1897002458572388,
-0.02784397080540657,
0.619378924369812,
-0.12380401045084,
0.5442134141921997,
-0.3283992111682892,
0.027488263323903084,
0.19220754504203796,
-0.8676036596298218,
-0.5464062690734863,
0.46487995982170105,
-0.4316500425338745,
-0.049093205481767654,
0.24335463345050812,
0.7376086711883545,
-0.0905895084142685,
-0.15452447533607483,
0.6463850736618042,
-0.05329303815960884,
0.3481651544570923,
0.734477698802948,
0.5753289461135864,
-0.4371180534362793,
0.6037355661392212,
-0.4645097851753235,
-0.12882991135120392,
-0.16990025341510773,
-0.6408659815788269,
-0.6799328923225403,
-0.4253321588039398,
-0.4751211106777191,
0.1391645222902298,
-0.047333914786577225,
0.8970125317573547,
0.8640913963317871,
-0.862042248249054,
-0.12841975688934326,
-0.3675179183483124,
0.0004395958094391972,
-0.1912146359682083,
-0.286141037940979,
-0.07041018456220627,
-0.46756264567375183,
-0.5314849615097046,
0.7942669987678528,
0.501797080039978,
-0.01504773460328579,
-0.3153717517852783,
-0.09650669991970062,
-0.1979960948228836,
0.10008671879768372,
0.5299053192138672,
0.616295337677002,
-0.3198838531970978,
-0.2672034800052643,
0.06377051770687103,
0.057565078139305115,
0.05316973477602005,
0.7918018698692322,
-1.17608642578125,
0.6843520402908325,
0.6658105850219727,
0.5189976692199707,
0.4093588590621948,
0.08741210401058197,
0.8200426697731018,
-1.5285602807998657,
0.1576731950044632,
0.34083470702171326,
0.22158916294574738,
0.30267617106437683,
-0.0474398210644722,
0.4269586205482483,
0.5147472023963928,
-0.3465212285518646,
-0.8394961953163147,
0.35068053007125854,
-0.8117030262947083,
-0.23757323622703552,
1.1099179983139038,
0.119268037378788,
-0.18415459990501404,
0.07308197766542435,
-0.14323784410953522,
0.16415314376354218,
-0.2794801592826843,
0.7829471230506897,
0.3486204147338867,
-0.39905524253845215,
-0.35831528902053833,
-0.2614763081073761,
0.49551159143447876,
0.37439200282096863,
-0.9642149209976196,
0.05276587978005409,
0.8005303144454956,
0.23685026168823242,
-0.03606034070253372,
0.23374992609024048,
0.03321581706404686,
0.33823642134666443,
-0.06162644177675247,
0.019542094320058823,
-0.4267449378967285,
-0.42224493622779846,
-0.38600125908851624,
0.43442630767822266,
-0.31316453218460083,
-0.29055407643318176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12502v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12502v1
|
Code-Optimise: Self-Generated Preference Data for Correctness and Efficiency
| 2024-06-18T11:05:37 | 2024-06-18T11:05:37 |
Leonidas Gee, Milan Gritta, Gerasimos Lampouras, Ignacio Iacobacci
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Code Language Models have been trained to generate accurate solutions,
typically with no regard for runtime. On the other hand, previous works that
explored execution optimisation have observed corresponding drops in functional
correctness. To that end, we introduce Code-Optimise, a framework that
incorporates both correctness (passed, failed) and runtime (quick, slow) as
learning signals via self-generated preference data. Our framework is both
lightweight and robust as it dynamically selects solutions to reduce
overfitting while avoiding a reliance on larger models for learning signals.
Code-Optimise achieves significant improvements in pass@k while decreasing the
competitive baseline runtimes by an additional 6% for in-domain data and up to
3% for out-of-domain data. As a byproduct, the average length of the generated
solutions is reduced by up to 48% on MBPP and 23% on HumanEval, resulting in
faster and cheaper inference. The generated data and codebase will be
open-sourced at www.open-source.link.
|
[
-0.3334714472293854,
-0.21031658351421356,
0.41046422719955444,
0.2331521064043045,
-0.05845683068037033,
-0.036221522837877274,
-0.27680325508117676,
-0.21771638095378876,
0.12158507108688354,
0.5289862751960754,
-0.39958876371383667,
-0.40845394134521484,
-0.02489207498729229,
-0.0942976251244545,
-0.01596481166779995,
0.8938926458358765,
0.1253020018339157,
0.041649408638477325,
-0.39323997497558594,
-0.2728441655635834,
-0.16811813414096832,
-0.7006059885025024,
-0.24984696507453918,
-0.424977570772171,
0.3799342215061188,
0.7967599630355835,
0.6672441363334656,
0.9213706254959106,
0.5214200615882874,
0.08192101866006851,
0.4218301475048065,
-0.008588924072682858,
-0.6203439235687256,
0.08919627219438553,
-0.11475617438554764,
-0.5668860673904419,
-0.39708027243614197,
0.050115637481212616,
0.010180594399571419,
0.4673404097557068,
-0.26033246517181396,
0.5007318258285522,
-0.10163035988807678,
1.1482294797897339,
-1.065415620803833,
0.21797406673431396,
-0.5209356546401978,
0.17170512676239014,
0.07481933385133743,
-0.39457061886787415,
-0.46792280673980713,
-0.6602646112442017,
-0.1909952461719513,
-0.28306281566619873,
0.1366921067237854,
-0.16693174839019775,
0.4789077341556549,
0.55392986536026,
-0.14500057697296143,
-0.4601816236972809,
-0.3417987823486328,
0.9351593255996704,
-0.7762459516525269,
0.4658159911632538,
0.21594734489917755,
0.36683928966522217,
-0.14027689397335052,
-0.628666341304779,
-0.24054765701293945,
-0.3765159845352173,
-0.02757555991411209,
0.06446507573127747,
0.07845597714185715,
0.026564592495560646,
0.36282169818878174,
0.2362567037343979,
-0.6768611669540405,
-0.0626794621348381,
-0.290449857711792,
-0.3037162125110626,
0.8747394680976868,
0.07427842915058136,
0.03495626524090767,
-0.27429601550102234,
-0.15137124061584473,
0.04377170279622078,
-0.711349606513977,
0.24752743542194366,
0.6278972029685974,
0.23446226119995117,
-0.09889940172433853,
0.3596632480621338,
-0.3879321813583374,
0.7811130881309509,
0.1915653496980667,
-0.08620966970920563,
0.4939008355140686,
-0.09675461798906326,
-0.16978155076503754,
-0.012512565590441227,
0.5788467526435852,
0.23300984501838684,
0.5398324728012085,
-0.1558666080236435,
-0.2611026167869568,
0.3289320468902588,
0.5337359309196472,
-0.9716266989707947,
-0.6520944833755493,
0.38869529962539673,
-0.6031330227851868,
-0.5709017515182495,
-0.316350519657135,
-0.5213219523429871,
0.1217140406370163,
-0.6505881547927856,
0.26354753971099854,
-0.4255436062812805,
-0.30361276865005493,
0.5118923187255859,
0.06899778544902802,
0.13084903359413147,
0.06842806190252304,
-0.9453465342521667,
0.003393271705135703,
0.4443569779396057,
0.7411113381385803,
-0.419399619102478,
0.0738663598895073,
-0.5999148488044739,
-0.079282745718956,
-0.5281887650489807,
0.6404244899749756,
-0.3853365182876587,
-0.5809741616249084,
-0.18832431733608246,
-0.45129767060279846,
-0.03618459776043892,
-0.6636058688163757,
0.42283815145492554,
-0.5238823890686035,
0.03763015940785408,
-0.142989382147789,
-0.6933873295783997,
0.24393697082996368,
-0.01956810988485813,
-0.5944288372993469,
1.1592183113098145,
0.373441219329834,
-0.6845491528511047,
0.6448746919631958,
-1.0950580835342407,
-0.40128180384635925,
-0.14762504398822784,
-0.2550014853477478,
-0.4808034300804138,
0.0747399553656578,
0.20656923949718475,
0.5389890670776367,
0.19811876118183136,
0.22286590933799744,
-0.683456301689148,
-0.3524470925331116,
0.06849923729896545,
-0.1156369224190712,
0.6148008704185486,
0.7458163499832153,
-0.5068525671958923,
0.04811658337712288,
-1.0541132688522339,
0.6536334753036499,
0.19041569530963898,
-0.5145790576934814,
-0.17658554017543793,
0.10558384656906128,
-0.01378384605050087,
0.18585972487926483,
0.22661471366882324,
-0.4268575608730316,
0.26982468366622925,
-0.38760682940483093,
0.35204705595970154,
0.823126494884491,
-0.2501375377178192,
0.4203365743160248,
-0.1669103056192398,
0.7616188526153564,
-0.06255339086055756,
0.4984353482723236,
0.04386194422841072,
-0.243007093667984,
-0.6791186928749084,
-0.1660030335187912,
0.237905815243721,
0.416513592004776,
-0.7442479133605957,
0.31343087553977966,
-0.10798767954111099,
-0.27665597200393677,
-0.4040769338607788,
0.28658536076545715,
0.439576119184494,
0.5354918837547302,
0.3775984048843384,
-0.30884620547294617,
-0.43270793557167053,
-1.0112286806106567,
-0.3018609285354614,
-0.22091726958751678,
0.3075668215751648,
0.3571132719516754,
0.4008912742137909,
-0.37591108679771423,
1.347687005996704,
-0.8613387942314148,
0.19339101016521454,
-0.15982449054718018,
-0.09634818881750107,
0.36384493112564087,
0.7043030261993408,
1.0444327592849731,
-0.9611861109733582,
-0.5462415218353271,
-0.2079572081565857,
-0.6703253388404846,
-0.3702450096607208,
0.07192700356245041,
-0.25501489639282227,
0.33989182114601135,
0.2624513804912567,
0.07612184435129166,
0.14296728372573853,
0.6820891499519348,
-0.18633879721164703,
0.7337887287139893,
-0.1599704623222351,
0.22943712770938873,
-0.9611703753471375,
0.3507770895957947,
-0.1939697116613388,
-0.4782710373401642,
-0.17221172153949738,
0.20629501342773438,
0.31598398089408875,
-0.1736324578523636,
-0.5398013591766357,
0.322596937417984,
-0.2547270953655243,
-0.1897578090429306,
0.03093903325498104,
-0.25851020216941833,
0.012218647636473179,
0.6334911584854126,
0.08605441451072693,
1.367270827293396,
0.33019906282424927,
-0.5736937522888184,
0.06155318394303322,
0.0330488495528698,
-0.29949578642845154,
0.3469125032424927,
-0.5295687317848206,
0.40010935068130493,
0.078042171895504,
-0.41220882534980774,
-0.6772857904434204,
-0.3616129159927368,
0.1637500822544098,
-0.6022608280181885,
0.33977583050727844,
-0.5316530466079712,
-0.28958526253700256,
-0.37664496898651123,
-0.358242005109787,
0.4722976088523865,
0.5999860763549805,
-0.8645627498626709,
0.1284407526254654,
0.31791481375694275,
0.23967744410037994,
-0.7939606308937073,
-0.5738518834114075,
-0.24785514175891876,
-0.04141876474022865,
-0.4852726459503174,
-0.03547215834259987,
-0.46613365411758423,
0.10656266659498215,
-0.0244184248149395,
-0.2682257294654846,
-0.3799958825111389,
0.05960046872496605,
0.01584348827600479,
-0.050440989434719086,
-0.27610647678375244,
0.16386549174785614,
0.06308306753635406,
-0.34273234009742737,
0.17561113834381104,
-0.43742409348487854,
0.4021454453468323,
-0.2453807294368744,
-0.43429526686668396,
-0.1736626923084259,
0.3783440589904785,
0.616382360458374,
-0.2556666433811188,
0.4662455916404724,
0.17122069001197815,
0.15883922576904297,
-0.509229838848114,
-0.3739258944988251,
-0.026435645297169685,
-0.5376263856887817,
-0.008702804334461689,
-0.5651246309280396,
-0.9295374155044556,
0.36801236867904663,
0.1263369768857956,
0.12450185418128967,
0.2610662877559662,
0.4345460832118988,
0.06380161643028259,
1.1510205268859863,
0.6203171610832214,
-0.09751077741384506,
0.5352733135223389,
-0.4106241762638092,
0.3166702687740326,
-0.2279527187347412,
-0.0816299095749855,
-0.5415576100349426,
0.2500314712524414,
-0.4723322093486786,
-0.2830043137073517,
0.3734784424304962,
0.0818687155842781,
-0.10774380713701248,
0.444111704826355,
-0.7558853626251221,
0.6051120162010193,
0.4329744875431061,
0.2661851644515991,
0.11581125855445862,
-0.07116828858852386,
-0.10166748613119125,
-0.21304066479206085,
-1.0204927921295166,
-0.4191494286060333,
1.407591700553894,
0.1872841864824295,
1.0229651927947998,
0.05549916625022888,
1.0033472776412964,
0.7245570421218872,
0.29810452461242676,
-0.7289826273918152,
0.25777333974838257,
-0.00917145423591137,
-0.6301174163818359,
0.13223157823085785,
-0.7852510213851929,
-0.6008076667785645,
-0.06758084893226624,
0.014980940148234367,
-0.1695101112127304,
0.1246422529220581,
0.7347981929779053,
-0.49440401792526245,
-0.06339861452579498,
-1.0718823671340942,
1.177810549736023,
-0.35501858592033386,
-0.3972729444503784,
-0.26734793186187744,
-0.4103553891181946,
0.316879540681839,
-0.27346622943878174,
0.11899919807910919,
-0.01972269080579281,
0.13535378873348236,
0.5475158095359802,
-0.4136219322681427,
0.5332996249198914,
-0.2263503521680832,
-0.019165340811014175,
0.43320101499557495,
0.1838761568069458,
0.20857952535152435,
0.09279076755046844,
-0.36968788504600525,
-0.007430496159940958,
0.13703764975070953,
-0.6557230949401855,
-0.7122417092323303,
0.6135022044181824,
-0.5155186057090759,
-0.14813706278800964,
-0.24976429343223572,
-0.17561441659927368,
-0.15331417322158813,
0.24200814962387085,
0.30909794569015503,
0.886225163936615,
0.14582030475139618,
0.23151522874832153,
0.6733795404434204,
-0.19926446676254272,
0.49734851717948914,
0.5666535496711731,
-0.28296011686325073,
-0.5360774993896484,
0.8849414587020874,
-0.05248614773154259,
0.6002665758132935,
0.0018386259907856584,
0.1917792707681656,
-0.519546627998352,
-0.609818696975708,
-0.6561581492424011,
-0.03450527414679527,
-0.9046962261199951,
-0.322272390127182,
-0.6253235936164856,
0.09254033118486404,
-0.4575059413909912,
-0.5571173429489136,
-0.6661273241043091,
-0.45368197560310364,
-0.21747303009033203,
0.015603777952492237,
0.30252161622047424,
0.4163290560245514,
-0.3559056520462036,
0.2106679379940033,
-0.7271496653556824,
0.336404025554657,
0.027498779818415642,
0.7131965756416321,
-0.37829065322875977,
-0.19684909284114838,
-0.5975815057754517,
-0.09891759604215622,
-0.13562314212322235,
-0.6573143601417542,
0.30745771527290344,
0.30776527523994446,
0.5169745683670044,
0.2780844569206238,
0.35019364953041077,
0.5350976586341858,
-0.22093795239925385,
0.7046809792518616,
0.24590934813022614,
-1.089686632156372,
0.8068757057189941,
-0.24182727932929993,
0.2895791828632355,
0.8923720121383667,
0.3702719509601593,
0.03940337896347046,
-0.029777437448501587,
-0.6686801910400391,
-0.5064100623130798,
0.5529540777206421,
0.2376425862312317,
-0.017794938758015633,
-0.1493423730134964,
0.5648248791694641,
0.25438666343688965,
0.2986311614513397,
-0.6634092926979065,
-0.34077492356300354,
-0.12137890607118607,
-0.3447488248348236,
0.057616401463747025,
-0.212942436337471,
0.3201296329498291,
-0.26265254616737366,
0.7059584856033325,
-0.7315946221351624,
0.39905881881713867,
0.18099085986614227,
-0.14836391806602478,
-0.13926486670970917,
0.15078601241111755,
0.3759134113788605,
0.9190666675567627,
-0.28558436036109924,
-0.18552438914775848,
-0.1775279939174652,
-0.38114607334136963,
0.1767890900373459,
-0.47618794441223145,
-0.17521515488624573,
-0.08674224466085434,
0.1490856409072876,
0.36975666880607605,
0.0951077863574028,
-0.7646183967590332,
0.609329879283905,
-0.04936672002077103,
-0.04078347980976105,
-0.2618701159954071,
0.584235429763794,
-0.20065517723560333,
-0.045502919703722,
-0.02956514246761799,
0.48780348896980286,
0.5763671398162842,
-0.3510296940803528,
0.650697648525238,
0.19440589845180511,
-0.14778795838356018,
-0.03819996118545532,
0.7170460224151611,
0.3120104968547821,
-0.06713590770959854,
0.20850948989391327,
-0.34167972207069397,
-0.5655809044837952,
0.8150741457939148,
0.42612725496292114,
0.8933350443840027,
-0.10862045735120773,
0.20781774818897247,
0.390616238117218,
-0.19961358606815338,
-0.04767487943172455,
0.6511386036872864,
-0.34582027792930603,
-0.6455285549163818,
-0.6714006066322327,
-0.8356423377990723,
-0.43883293867111206,
-0.11188877373933792,
-0.8837475180625916,
0.3117258846759796,
-0.4052552282810211,
-0.32690125703811646,
-0.15984782576560974,
0.01659032143652439,
-0.5365188121795654,
0.48664987087249756,
-0.13752734661102295,
1.0185060501098633,
-0.5464140772819519,
1.121627926826477,
0.5877425670623779,
-0.380105584859848,
-0.944302499294281,
-0.08549003303050995,
-0.33932846784591675,
-0.6805304288864136,
0.6092413663864136,
0.2305154800415039,
-0.5439141988754272,
0.10238838940858841,
-0.6958988904953003,
-0.8203126192092896,
0.38150355219841003,
0.7097939252853394,
-0.5182009339332581,
0.2613675892353058,
-0.03719593584537506,
0.35228225588798523,
-0.4886067807674408,
0.10107865929603577,
0.7703434824943542,
0.1784876435995102,
-0.14945223927497864,
-0.8056519627571106,
-0.40078455209732056,
-0.3035604655742645,
-0.15440374612808228,
0.4342372715473175,
-0.5245558619499207,
0.38525351881980896,
-0.3966634273529053,
0.05839947983622551,
-0.30287787318229675,
0.27527251839637756,
-0.08521788567304611,
0.3154151737689972,
0.36496710777282715,
0.5321853756904602,
0.3688359260559082,
0.13240383565425873,
1.0736923217773438,
-0.790928304195404,
0.7730752825737,
0.7999445199966431,
-0.07638221234083176,
0.6851546764373779,
0.32094478607177734,
-0.20475751161575317,
0.4090244770050049,
0.6547072529792786,
0.27916428446769714,
0.7070869207382202,
0.0387057401239872,
0.06211963668465614,
-0.48879000544548035,
0.34451979398727417,
-0.45434510707855225,
0.4984988868236542,
0.0894707664847374,
-0.26440393924713135,
-0.07989374548196793,
-0.20117682218551636,
0.050610825419425964,
0.2255968153476715,
-0.1600848138332367,
0.4874897599220276,
0.06001805514097214,
-0.6950709223747253,
1.023245930671692,
-0.2631647288799286,
0.7106994390487671,
-0.6346205472946167,
0.01882888749241829,
-0.3471601903438568,
0.44176921248435974,
-0.44724565744400024,
-0.6762847304344177,
0.5912254452705383,
-0.047992102801799774,
-0.3812752962112427,
-0.32621026039123535,
0.6716442108154297,
-0.24521270394325256,
-0.2572091519832611,
0.4848444163799286,
0.42720407247543335,
0.0689689889550209,
0.04022076725959778,
-0.9497542977333069,
-0.08424496650695801,
0.28859084844589233,
-0.21237003803253174,
0.14382554590702057,
0.04992226883769035,
0.27259328961372375,
0.8662768006324768,
0.7593284249305725,
0.10293228924274445,
0.09097340703010559,
-0.07679358869791031,
0.8932256698608398,
-0.542350172996521,
-0.8345577716827393,
-0.6773144006729126,
0.4042665958404541,
-0.23791787028312683,
-0.37565040588378906,
0.6046554446220398,
0.9223899841308594,
1.0556614398956299,
-0.45029783248901367,
0.8300189971923828,
-0.15445084869861603,
0.40830227732658386,
-0.7935693860054016,
0.7505246996879578,
-0.7028313875198364,
0.07999073714017868,
-0.3332664370536804,
-0.8749406933784485,
-0.3032820224761963,
0.6611641049385071,
-0.4737933874130249,
0.08438684791326523,
0.49106836318969727,
0.9554704427719116,
-0.34935927391052246,
-0.11030472069978714,
0.4805352985858917,
-0.5273088216781616,
0.3587169647216797,
0.703299343585968,
0.5800825953483582,
-0.21417632699012756,
0.24031686782836914,
-0.5039677023887634,
-0.292864590883255,
-0.45344942808151245,
-1.0525166988372803,
-0.8259558081626892,
-0.34341323375701904,
-0.4761522710323334,
-0.3156197965145111,
0.3225252628326416,
1.3301666975021362,
1.0659795999526978,
-1.0350295305252075,
-0.2981909513473511,
-0.13076671957969666,
-0.1668957620859146,
-0.013277565129101276,
-0.24588215351104736,
0.22036297619342804,
-1.0225189924240112,
-0.22286708652973175,
0.4546146094799042,
0.2729435861110687,
-0.1668444722890854,
-0.09684628993272781,
-0.42267727851867676,
0.3490278124809265,
0.2682267129421234,
0.6308748126029968,
0.32068803906440735,
-0.0915585458278656,
-0.3340561091899872,
-0.025876875966787338,
-0.19796030223369598,
0.493308961391449,
1.228545069694519,
-0.8121680617332458,
0.5826948881149292,
0.3733215928077698,
0.6751099228858948,
0.24739865958690643,
0.0478481724858284,
0.6195183396339417,
-0.5543379783630371,
0.13938963413238525,
0.3712490499019623,
0.2988278865814209,
0.1825752705335617,
-0.6314845681190491,
0.7983034253120422,
0.3259503245353699,
-0.675855278968811,
-0.6328164935112,
0.4661124646663666,
-0.7449998259544373,
-0.2517358362674713,
1.0842324495315552,
-0.2571042478084564,
-0.2655598819255829,
-0.12837958335876465,
-0.1682465374469757,
-0.13423864543437958,
-0.6216212511062622,
0.7183911204338074,
0.20970578491687775,
-0.5865046381950378,
0.08979306370019913,
-0.5779812335968018,
0.8980690240859985,
0.6013628840446472,
-0.7781533598899841,
0.06073075905442238,
0.8017717599868774,
0.585412859916687,
-0.08068609982728958,
0.7412344217300415,
-0.03671012446284294,
0.4553047716617584,
-0.12260320037603378,
0.1839524805545807,
-0.12316591292619705,
-0.37555423378944397,
-0.3269485533237457,
0.34558969736099243,
0.2115505188703537,
-0.3141729533672333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12494v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12494v1
|
LightPAL: Lightweight Passage Retrieval for Open Domain Multi-Document Summarization
| 2024-06-18T10:57:27 | 2024-06-18T10:57:27 |
Masafumi Enomoto, Kunihiro Takeoka, Kosuke Akimoto, Kiril Gashteovski, Masafumi Oyamada
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Open-Domain Multi-Document Summarization (ODMDS) is crucial for addressing
diverse information needs, which aims to generate a summary as answer to user's
query, synthesizing relevant content from multiple documents in a large
collection. Existing approaches that first find relevant passages and then
generate a summary using a language model are inadequate for ODMDS. This is
because open-ended queries often require additional context for the retrieved
passages to cover the topic comprehensively, making it challenging to retrieve
all relevant passages initially. While iterative retrieval methods have been
explored for multi-hop question answering (MQA), they are impractical for ODMDS
due to high latency from repeated large language model (LLM) inference for
reasoning. To address this issue, we propose LightPAL, a lightweight passage
retrieval method for ODMDS that constructs a graph representing passage
relationships using an LLM during indexing and employs random walk instead of
iterative reasoning and retrieval at inference time. Experiments on ODMDS
benchmarks show that LightPAL outperforms baseline retrievers in summary
quality while being significantly more efficient than an iterative MQA
approach.
|
[
-0.12977859377861023,
-0.97883141040802,
0.6821935772895813,
-0.06070009246468544,
-0.5633065700531006,
0.18715612590312958,
-0.025654330849647522,
-0.4592292010784149,
0.268350750207901,
0.49976345896720886,
-0.17632260918617249,
-0.4253525137901306,
-0.3377077579498291,
-0.0007387395016849041,
-0.2420387715101242,
0.9343773126602173,
-0.12035427987575531,
0.030951740220189095,
0.07146774977445602,
-0.26388901472091675,
0.26802778244018555,
0.19122327864170074,
-0.52936190366745,
-0.28282099962234497,
0.5540144443511963,
0.41079479455947876,
0.7762660980224609,
0.07647441327571869,
0.44631174206733704,
0.17937099933624268,
-0.31059783697128296,
0.17661336064338684,
-0.5069981813430786,
0.16580110788345337,
0.02602900192141533,
-0.19305817782878876,
-0.6305015087127686,
0.01162785291671753,
0.7466188669204712,
1.253766417503357,
-0.256098210811615,
0.19668816030025482,
-0.1254466474056244,
0.579259991645813,
-0.8057048916816711,
0.05010703578591347,
-0.34395214915275574,
0.23226448893547058,
-0.33225417137145996,
-0.4126117527484894,
-0.41415438055992126,
-0.3181375563144684,
0.2684454917907715,
-0.602739155292511,
0.25418171286582947,
0.3246666491031647,
0.19891037046909332,
-0.22697146236896515,
-0.6549997925758362,
-0.17112207412719727,
-0.5284743905067444,
0.5026124715805054,
-0.7528116106987,
0.42684030532836914,
-0.006116180680692196,
0.5539240837097168,
0.09353656321763992,
-0.9180256724357605,
-0.5773534774780273,
-0.09294788539409637,
-0.20924928784370422,
0.21514439582824707,
0.21695901453495026,
0.0027447915636003017,
0.15678644180297852,
0.45020440220832825,
-0.6445775032043457,
-0.3669777810573578,
-0.49605458974838257,
-0.019982948899269104,
0.3261108994483948,
0.2973516285419464,
-0.07972580939531326,
-0.33708634972572327,
-0.77205890417099,
0.026330390945076942,
-0.7937270402908325,
0.2518312633037567,
0.20745337009429932,
0.3455422520637512,
0.08145420253276825,
0.7110683917999268,
-0.38702982664108276,
0.9174967408180237,
-0.4027879238128662,
-0.6199203133583069,
0.1953802853822708,
-0.7196667790412903,
0.013527609407901764,
0.053721241652965546,
0.9048846364021301,
0.4339664578437805,
-0.1767749935388565,
-0.2738030254840851,
-0.3161976635456085,
-0.6912893056869507,
-0.007455387152731419,
-0.9113858342170715,
0.05272207036614418,
0.1714976280927658,
-0.8867926001548767,
0.04323292896151543,
0.13436849415302277,
-1.0511597394943237,
-0.36049413681030273,
0.14610834419727325,
0.3089229166507721,
-0.6090744733810425,
-0.18450793623924255,
0.10160117596387863,
-0.4936279058456421,
0.2807893753051758,
0.9520465135574341,
-0.7331727147102356,
0.5408159494400024,
0.48962873220443726,
1.2065576314926147,
-0.2084675133228302,
-0.5078593492507935,
-0.916003942489624,
0.3572024703025818,
-0.30370625853538513,
0.5963628888130188,
-0.48991677165031433,
-0.5095096826553345,
-0.2587842345237732,
-0.31232932209968567,
-0.18460296094417572,
-0.22837980091571808,
0.4388355016708374,
-0.6850389242172241,
0.18511569499969482,
0.05518816411495209,
-0.5657569169998169,
0.0708678737282753,
0.21097028255462646,
-0.5823109149932861,
0.7591261863708496,
0.3844200670719147,
-0.9089395403862,
0.3171277344226837,
-0.33309242129325867,
-0.5174157619476318,
0.20704321563243866,
-0.37246009707450867,
-0.14106236398220062,
-0.012025333940982819,
0.1594085693359375,
0.4550299346446991,
-0.4458603262901306,
0.06583032757043839,
-0.2330775260925293,
-0.49160486459732056,
-0.2330918312072754,
-0.26167032122612,
0.746279239654541,
0.30209439992904663,
-0.18410846590995789,
0.07484783977270126,
-0.6799132227897644,
-0.18227021396160126,
0.29008278250694275,
-0.45760953426361084,
-0.5503409504890442,
0.05391598865389824,
0.13025927543640137,
0.15465709567070007,
0.08232706040143967,
-0.6156333684921265,
0.302701473236084,
-0.17884944379329681,
0.12909159064292908,
0.6257973313331604,
0.10658343881368637,
0.5302220582962036,
-0.17659524083137512,
0.6717306971549988,
-0.03224226459860802,
0.1479591578245163,
-0.5735310912132263,
-0.9327473044395447,
0.034223806113004684,
-0.13335277140140533,
0.016112539917230606,
0.2337215542793274,
-1.0743275880813599,
0.006093214266002178,
-0.3576914072036743,
-0.5798437595367432,
-0.6552994251251221,
0.21889406442642212,
0.3849506378173828,
1.072304368019104,
0.48768654465675354,
-0.39156773686408997,
0.32368263602256775,
-0.3533078730106354,
-0.16313672065734863,
-0.06088801100850105,
0.00560127105563879,
0.6388117074966431,
0.560491144657135,
0.06833062320947647,
0.7774167060852051,
-0.8950097560882568,
-0.45815902948379517,
-0.3557371199131012,
0.10968860983848572,
0.3338284194469452,
0.2445489913225174,
0.7003318071365356,
-1.0073119401931763,
-0.4336547255516052,
-0.221038356423378,
-0.5414032340049744,
0.14339801669120789,
-0.14431995153427124,
-0.1926669329404831,
-0.0918421596288681,
0.5638404488563538,
-0.8325979709625244,
0.4863964915275574,
0.036102112382650375,
-0.7867099642753601,
0.5168853998184204,
-0.3665342926979065,
0.44647088646888733,
-0.8195465803146362,
0.5312126278877258,
-0.5521440505981445,
-0.34283697605133057,
-0.32467368245124817,
0.239867702126503,
0.2994377315044403,
-0.313740611076355,
-0.49752098321914673,
0.8323153853416443,
-0.5743870735168457,
-0.4687589108943939,
0.09541089832782745,
0.9157224893569946,
0.17602138221263885,
0.26569294929504395,
0.0740111693739891,
0.7877241373062134,
0.5249036550521851,
-0.6625196933746338,
0.39041388034820557,
0.4358123540878296,
-0.26088106632232666,
0.6109269261360168,
-0.48570993542671204,
-0.24718531966209412,
-0.20078055560588837,
0.5048842430114746,
-1.1090174913406372,
0.06089667230844498,
0.23050935566425323,
-0.2445971518754959,
0.1156894862651825,
-0.10429448634386063,
-0.447127103805542,
-0.18075791001319885,
-0.8270330429077148,
0.651056170463562,
0.19572217762470245,
-0.7302921414375305,
0.5810037851333618,
0.07187391072511673,
-0.27193483710289,
-0.702752411365509,
-0.26987072825431824,
0.11293081939220428,
0.28593626618385315,
-0.799774169921875,
0.35513052344322205,
-0.1550585925579071,
-0.2163621187210083,
0.0870387926697731,
-0.35649028420448303,
0.23480844497680664,
0.14086134731769562,
-0.39190998673439026,
0.0839877724647522,
-0.36621981859207153,
0.014974716119468212,
-0.06517387181520462,
-0.20263683795928955,
-0.2712220549583435,
-0.22017794847488403,
0.4467012882232666,
0.07633735984563828,
-0.41224566102027893,
0.335171103477478,
0.6539565324783325,
0.40330633521080017,
-0.4048108160495758,
0.8524399995803833,
0.6500195860862732,
-0.03153612092137337,
-0.4570867717266083,
-0.012847368605434895,
-0.09816969931125641,
-0.36552441120147705,
-0.1535838395357132,
-0.5044639110565186,
-0.7939151525497437,
0.40708014369010925,
-0.11959797143936157,
0.08455123752355576,
0.3422084152698517,
0.11619457602500916,
0.029329398646950722,
0.8287082314491272,
0.5469872951507568,
0.05043795704841614,
0.49287813901901245,
-0.135613813996315,
0.10092514753341675,
-1.074279546737671,
-0.4117523729801178,
-0.564590573310852,
-0.15092821419239044,
-0.17082053422927856,
-0.5861545205116272,
0.6747128963470459,
0.37513381242752075,
0.1635478287935257,
-0.05149030312895775,
-0.07382294535636902,
0.26527124643325806,
0.5745253562927246,
-0.005486844107508659,
0.907213568687439,
-0.2666361927986145,
-0.40934693813323975,
0.33497369289398193,
-0.5645481944084167,
-0.37968069314956665,
1.1038098335266113,
-0.2585512697696686,
1.2135905027389526,
0.6992784142494202,
0.6688334941864014,
-0.014816820621490479,
0.09303367882966995,
-0.622660756111145,
0.7011517286300659,
0.15040116012096405,
-0.34988582134246826,
-0.4075763523578644,
-0.8935340642929077,
-0.997135579586029,
0.7863251566886902,
-0.04102986678481102,
-0.9105566143989563,
-0.031716808676719666,
-0.0680832713842392,
-0.25532785058021545,
0.4643493592739105,
-0.5676454901695251,
0.8728458881378174,
-0.0639825090765953,
-0.25535574555397034,
-0.22570185363292694,
-1.0044729709625244,
0.6996747851371765,
-0.007214605342596769,
0.16072522103786469,
-0.02591007947921753,
-0.5881624817848206,
0.603721022605896,
-0.8495094776153564,
0.3255414366722107,
-0.21781037747859955,
-0.2922094762325287,
0.15565387904644012,
-0.043938715010881424,
0.40103888511657715,
0.35794487595558167,
-0.12350436300039291,
-0.35091909766197205,
-0.18686111271381378,
-0.5436780452728271,
-0.6652305722236633,
0.5067943930625916,
-0.4443724751472473,
-0.368161678314209,
-0.43380701541900635,
-0.057709187269210815,
-0.20553933084011078,
0.6137294769287109,
0.20973123610019684,
0.5246305465698242,
-0.22482426464557648,
0.12980623543262482,
0.6860817670822144,
-0.20351633429527283,
0.7257761359214783,
0.7574209570884705,
-0.5278471112251282,
-0.46049290895462036,
0.5244041085243225,
-0.0006929222727194428,
0.5142463445663452,
0.532185971736908,
0.3112277686595917,
-0.2384846955537796,
-0.6419118046760559,
-0.8434869050979614,
0.2906842529773712,
-0.8903669714927673,
-0.21614278852939606,
-0.7194948196411133,
0.14195598661899567,
-0.5620079040527344,
-0.2390977144241333,
-0.2308676540851593,
-0.7265617251396179,
0.03258876875042915,
-0.004718003328889608,
0.3151266276836395,
0.579060971736908,
0.2933878004550934,
0.10733487457036972,
-0.8585484027862549,
1.0069150924682617,
0.21065615117549896,
0.694695234298706,
0.14746108651161194,
-0.32915714383125305,
-0.09859403222799301,
-0.44936925172805786,
-0.12170348316431046,
-0.9933856725692749,
0.04396266117691994,
0.4324706792831421,
0.6645499467849731,
0.6261335611343384,
0.3820110559463501,
0.4759504199028015,
-0.6609830260276794,
0.874089777469635,
0.34122660756111145,
-0.7455145120620728,
0.7280486822128296,
-0.24384154379367828,
0.33751180768013,
0.48451557755470276,
0.48885244131088257,
-0.5662697553634644,
-0.33447733521461487,
-0.6538670659065247,
-1.226182460784912,
0.9034428596496582,
0.30362558364868164,
-0.31207001209259033,
0.16335290670394897,
0.341257780790329,
0.267866313457489,
0.5756334066390991,
-0.4338263273239136,
-0.5219491720199585,
-0.09754151105880737,
0.07870566844940186,
-0.37993812561035156,
0.06806296110153198,
-0.11588525027036667,
-0.005163304042071104,
0.5861458778381348,
-0.5610064268112183,
0.2276190221309662,
0.4314384162425995,
-0.21196451783180237,
-0.29027482867240906,
0.22957228124141693,
0.4940272271633148,
0.8529052734375,
-0.6308956742286682,
0.3962610960006714,
-0.27634894847869873,
-0.6525408029556274,
-0.07134269922971725,
0.41030439734458923,
-0.4410531222820282,
0.24720337986946106,
0.6831907033920288,
0.4419246315956116,
0.19005087018013,
-0.9580516219139099,
0.9684525728225708,
-0.2321663349866867,
0.13432547450065613,
0.134909525513649,
0.06909837573766708,
0.06581161916255951,
0.29648831486701965,
0.6363916993141174,
0.20581449568271637,
0.4460330009460449,
-0.7336220145225525,
0.2021951824426651,
0.4085061252117157,
-0.2130875140428543,
0.011132070794701576,
0.9601942300796509,
0.1552542895078659,
-0.12187932431697845,
0.46169787645339966,
-0.2501629889011383,
-0.04929686337709427,
0.3727044463157654,
0.32071155309677124,
0.6374564170837402,
0.006943285930901766,
0.19948214292526245,
0.06687824428081512,
0.2571936547756195,
0.011351888068020344,
0.6322565078735352,
-0.5990085601806641,
-0.3358411192893982,
-0.3103882670402527,
-0.49982213973999023,
-0.6860018968582153,
-0.46840333938598633,
-0.40045565366744995,
0.10149700939655304,
-0.42437583208084106,
0.21820782124996185,
-0.05738914757966995,
-0.11120915412902832,
-0.2481255978345871,
0.10615112632513046,
-0.08551430702209473,
1.1557559967041016,
-0.3990115821361542,
0.5263036489486694,
0.4475533068180084,
-0.7114195823669434,
-0.5815824866294861,
0.06908134371042252,
0.014064020477235317,
-0.5074567198753357,
0.2029053419828415,
-0.05598337948322296,
-0.4578739404678345,
-0.018287790939211845,
-0.3135072588920593,
-0.5480373501777649,
1.4816670417785645,
0.366146057844162,
-0.0859113484621048,
0.06031928211450577,
-0.20644769072532654,
0.35466909408569336,
-0.23134931921958923,
0.7796216607093811,
0.22421281039714813,
0.1914331465959549,
0.31944069266319275,
-0.8497032523155212,
0.23704008758068085,
-0.22997434437274933,
-0.362779825925827,
0.3599856495857239,
-1.0067435503005981,
1.1578103303909302,
-0.5666760802268982,
0.0977543368935585,
0.03118695691227913,
0.31897199153900146,
0.2509027421474457,
0.4317411184310913,
0.3307623565196991,
0.38625845313072205,
1.0198760032653809,
0.17497804760932922,
1.2219194173812866,
-0.07123558968305588,
0.2556612491607666,
1.1362783908843994,
-0.2916923761367798,
1.0155147314071655,
0.4569559395313263,
-0.09197887033224106,
0.08286450803279877,
0.44918403029441833,
0.4810126721858978,
0.7150437831878662,
-0.13124722242355347,
-0.39859503507614136,
-0.004766664933413267,
0.10725095123052597,
-0.6009179353713989,
0.1090489998459816,
0.08963624387979507,
-0.3599872589111328,
-0.6246860027313232,
-0.170248344540596,
-0.06323463469743729,
-0.2240578532218933,
-0.4183375835418701,
0.7473779916763306,
0.324687123298645,
-0.60480797290802,
0.34547486901283264,
0.15722672641277313,
0.4654198884963989,
-0.7322447896003723,
-0.09548385441303253,
-0.526297926902771,
0.13277336955070496,
-0.12254413962364197,
-0.7978507876396179,
-0.11353352665901184,
-0.1311819702386856,
0.0823773592710495,
-0.5550515055656433,
0.671153724193573,
-0.5162409543991089,
-0.21884845197200775,
0.5135876536369324,
1.0013463497161865,
0.09949811547994614,
0.09966079145669937,
-0.5410552620887756,
-0.5331042408943176,
-0.2360210120677948,
-0.661777138710022,
0.3595426082611084,
0.785314679145813,
0.028682537376880646,
0.7685384154319763,
0.34885767102241516,
0.19092053174972534,
0.1062161847949028,
0.317221462726593,
0.996577799320221,
-0.8590068221092224,
-0.6650543808937073,
-0.6582329273223877,
0.2909240424633026,
-0.15903499722480774,
-0.5360178351402283,
0.8803877830505371,
0.8388772010803223,
0.6303625106811523,
0.01749270409345627,
0.535251796245575,
-0.09469815343618393,
0.5880887508392334,
-0.8453267216682434,
0.6820977330207825,
-0.8066505789756775,
0.4588824510574341,
-0.7522159218788147,
-1.043404459953308,
-0.12769204378128052,
0.5305712819099426,
0.21374687552452087,
0.06612208485603333,
0.8997666239738464,
0.3869175910949707,
-0.45392170548439026,
0.02938375063240528,
0.18351224064826965,
-0.02535761520266533,
0.3891429007053375,
0.47790098190307617,
0.6907602548599243,
-0.4093852639198303,
0.8577988743782043,
-0.019725525751709938,
-0.1797001212835312,
-0.3597468435764313,
-0.8203557133674622,
-0.7166204452514648,
-0.34187525510787964,
-0.24402958154678345,
-0.18524272739887238,
-0.298936665058136,
0.721451461315155,
0.4390243589878082,
-0.4861920475959778,
-0.16802763938903809,
0.11888916790485382,
0.6288673281669617,
-0.30236613750457764,
-0.21066613495349884,
0.5233653783798218,
-0.5026248693466187,
-0.4613354206085205,
0.587672770023346,
0.44386446475982666,
-0.08404700458049774,
-0.22441928088665009,
-0.2198691964149475,
-0.417654812335968,
-0.15137265622615814,
0.4975585639476776,
-0.007468835450708866,
-0.34446272253990173,
0.006010540761053562,
-0.16141049563884735,
-0.15784217417240143,
0.143916055560112,
1.034680962562561,
-0.9167543649673462,
0.6099273562431335,
0.7025371193885803,
0.4465075433254242,
0.8253225684165955,
0.0281173437833786,
0.4584972560405731,
-0.8527953624725342,
0.0733887106180191,
0.3652149736881256,
0.5432701706886292,
0.12992574274539948,
-0.06326364725828171,
0.728951632976532,
0.5582996010780334,
-0.15781909227371216,
-0.5058580636978149,
0.10700640082359314,
-0.9751995801925659,
-0.5860486626625061,
0.8298172354698181,
-0.27251139283180237,
-0.3069804906845093,
-0.24490207433700562,
-0.344698041677475,
-0.14661313593387604,
-0.7343481779098511,
0.2797585725784302,
0.2592816948890686,
-0.42198771238327026,
-0.3761232793331146,
-0.6013861894607544,
0.5547270774841309,
0.06312069296836853,
-0.8069043159484863,
0.057761985808610916,
0.718854546546936,
-0.04407212510704994,
0.3509702682495117,
1.3937944173812866,
0.054975125938653946,
0.33595654368400574,
0.28091564774513245,
-0.34471312165260315,
0.12028467655181885,
-0.2591416537761688,
-0.07564255595207214,
0.7059476971626282,
0.039480194449424744,
0.14525707066059113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12480v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12480v1
|
The Power of LLM-Generated Synthetic Data for Stance Detection in Online Political Discussions
| 2024-06-18T10:36:21 | 2024-06-18T10:36:21 |
Stefan Sylvius Wagner, Maike Behrendt, Marc Ziegele, Stefan Harmeling
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Stance detection holds great potential for enhancing the quality of online
political discussions, as it has shown to be useful for summarizing
discussions, detecting misinformation, and evaluating opinion distributions.
Usually, transformer-based models are used directly for stance detection, which
require large amounts of data. However, the broad range of debate questions in
online political discussion creates a variety of possible scenarios that the
model is faced with and thus makes data acquisition for model training
difficult. In this work, we show how to leverage LLM-generated synthetic data
to train and improve stance detection agents for online political
discussions:(i) We generate synthetic data for specific debate questions by
prompting a Mistral-7B model and show that fine-tuning with the generated
synthetic data can substantially improve the performance of stance detection.
(ii) We examine the impact of combining synthetic data with the most
informative samples from an unlabelled dataset. First, we use the synthetic
data to select the most informative samples, second, we combine both these
samples and the synthetic data for fine-tuning. This approach reduces labelling
effort and consistently surpasses the performance of the baseline model that is
trained with fully labeled data. Overall, we show in comprehensive experiments
that LLM-generated data greatly improves stance detection performance for
online political discussions.
|
[
-0.9177442193031311,
-0.7644956111907959,
0.6883178949356079,
-0.10520365834236145,
-0.5909369587898254,
0.13829271495342255,
-0.21561342477798462,
-0.359821081161499,
0.5053718686103821,
0.46099185943603516,
-0.4214709401130676,
-0.5634941458702087,
-0.6488107442855835,
0.1578630954027176,
-0.4096119701862335,
1.0460708141326904,
0.36806944012641907,
0.27558428049087524,
-0.06320197135210037,
-0.23481623828411102,
-0.14916576445102692,
-0.49318790435791016,
-0.4950883388519287,
-0.5625844597816467,
0.3636558949947357,
0.2963920831680298,
0.6110156178474426,
0.7485060691833496,
0.21012786030769348,
0.35049736499786377,
-0.1682584434747696,
0.4545741677284241,
-0.700875997543335,
0.2185869663953781,
-0.2037065029144287,
-0.7167429327964783,
-0.5321115851402283,
0.11280348896980286,
0.6421982645988464,
0.23310911655426025,
-0.1421053409576416,
-0.1266801804304123,
-0.16848663985729218,
0.61210697889328,
-0.35803595185279846,
0.03281053528189659,
-1.099596381187439,
0.06876132637262344,
-0.2208043783903122,
-0.3226737678050995,
-0.3784777522087097,
-0.48320427536964417,
-0.27029961347579956,
-0.5912174582481384,
0.47608181834220886,
-0.14381329715251923,
0.7441771626472473,
0.1016247496008873,
-0.5149510502815247,
-0.23394452035427094,
-0.9034019708633423,
0.4609605371952057,
-0.7612451910972595,
0.3423222005367279,
0.10432244837284088,
0.3142946660518646,
-0.34088289737701416,
-0.6292715072631836,
-1.0430599451065063,
-0.008838692680001259,
0.07914727181196213,
0.2343246191740036,
-0.3075001537799835,
0.12061301618814468,
0.25608259439468384,
0.2927018105983734,
-0.21800415217876434,
-0.0050239404663443565,
-0.2999415993690491,
-0.23696807026863098,
0.6590477824211121,
0.2550753951072693,
-0.09970257431268692,
-0.6092000007629395,
-0.34893304109573364,
-0.23000562191009521,
-0.6475747227668762,
-0.013492869213223457,
0.8522853851318359,
0.49759116768836975,
0.09635201841592789,
0.676754355430603,
-0.35380828380584717,
0.5945888757705688,
0.7785077095031738,
0.012474930845201015,
-0.08163318037986755,
-0.26839497685432434,
-0.04947294667363167,
-0.09176882356405258,
0.818020224571228,
0.4802938997745514,
-0.012725084088742733,
0.277913898229599,
-0.2154112011194229,
0.2521781921386719,
0.31540006399154663,
-0.8013386726379395,
-0.3058696389198303,
0.3124161660671234,
-0.4513229429721832,
-0.45710840821266174,
0.549113929271698,
-0.8110405802726746,
-0.985650897026062,
-0.8273176550865173,
0.11868714541196823,
-0.10246901959180832,
-0.3738086223602295,
-0.07735351473093033,
-0.34473514556884766,
0.5426692366600037,
0.6519038677215576,
-0.43840286135673523,
0.05265216529369354,
0.9647253751754761,
0.7445302605628967,
-0.44883057475090027,
0.3471931517124176,
-0.4881107211112976,
-0.1468905657529831,
-0.5248520970344543,
1.1666827201843262,
-0.5292913317680359,
-0.32821300625801086,
-0.06858084350824356,
0.02739705704152584,
0.2182990163564682,
-0.9439390897750854,
0.2875896096229553,
-0.5041751861572266,
0.094317227602005,
-0.18663430213928223,
-0.8260279297828674,
0.09431307762861252,
0.7756065130233765,
-0.9015645384788513,
0.9193331003189087,
-0.23730802536010742,
-0.7701541185379028,
0.5047367811203003,
-0.4944285452365875,
-0.2248006910085678,
-0.16460733115673065,
-0.3395310044288635,
-0.5471969246864319,
0.010631952434778214,
0.3247244656085968,
0.45292264223098755,
0.015606699511408806,
0.38496702909469604,
-0.3790110945701599,
-0.11661183089017868,
0.6378071308135986,
-0.2935475707054138,
0.5525664687156677,
-0.044052813202142715,
-0.4192037284374237,
0.3218311667442322,
-0.8129969239234924,
-0.2427387535572052,
-0.0512009896337986,
-0.42901167273521423,
-0.16075876355171204,
0.14833489060401917,
-0.17203103005886078,
0.17819595336914062,
-0.027937715873122215,
-0.5690124034881592,
0.21627773344516754,
-0.5817970037460327,
0.0326370894908905,
0.8554397821426392,
0.3091576099395752,
0.45907318592071533,
-0.3684416115283966,
0.5002331137657166,
0.07428053766489029,
0.07308545708656311,
0.2212275266647339,
-0.45343512296676636,
-0.9730042219161987,
-0.07378645986318588,
0.11672725528478622,
0.46754780411720276,
-0.7102225422859192,
0.2859616279602051,
-0.1956690102815628,
-0.5393915772438049,
-0.5223338007926941,
0.0964697077870369,
-0.003644244046881795,
0.21073418855667114,
0.3238953649997711,
0.09365695714950562,
-0.5878429412841797,
-0.8149152398109436,
-0.5665313601493835,
-0.2237280309200287,
-0.024720920249819756,
0.1885213553905487,
0.3482482433319092,
-0.16165870428085327,
1.159116268157959,
-0.3378060758113861,
-0.02857709676027298,
-0.5534063577651978,
0.24109256267547607,
-0.011562679894268513,
0.08156750351190567,
0.32741475105285645,
-0.8644538521766663,
-0.454926073551178,
-0.012024018913507462,
-0.42633792757987976,
-0.06757946312427521,
-0.39991295337677,
-0.3198827803134918,
0.17676514387130737,
0.3924002945423126,
-0.8686389923095703,
0.31009918451309204,
0.28349581360816956,
-0.11426754295825958,
0.2317124754190445,
0.1629367172718048,
0.24271439015865326,
-1.4457646608352661,
-0.2334064394235611,
0.1329445242881775,
-0.5818513035774231,
-0.8285778760910034,
-0.15643365681171417,
-0.11078068614006042,
0.03854252025485039,
-0.7578725218772888,
0.40445393323898315,
-0.08269257843494415,
0.25551119446754456,
-0.572192907333374,
0.1742074340581894,
-0.09711042046546936,
0.1487388163805008,
0.2036704570055008,
0.4835604131221771,
0.16159465909004211,
-0.5209811329841614,
0.3363291025161743,
0.23589257895946503,
-0.014221100136637688,
0.705903947353363,
-0.46752801537513733,
0.5099140405654907,
-0.1836685985326767,
0.5539835691452026,
-1.093298077583313,
-0.46831002831459045,
0.37895074486732483,
-0.448618620634079,
0.3027907609939575,
-0.4656106233596802,
-0.3471972346305847,
0.0711558535695076,
-0.6422954201698303,
0.03515414521098137,
0.18369728326797485,
-0.7003233432769775,
0.7023194432258606,
0.7922427654266357,
0.2570309638977051,
-0.42119601368904114,
-0.2887997031211853,
-0.08970426768064499,
-0.4567989110946655,
-0.3579304814338684,
0.4381490647792816,
0.31288930773735046,
-0.560242772102356,
-0.2796008884906769,
-0.16644354164600372,
0.25200459361076355,
-0.3812931478023529,
0.39731407165527344,
0.12318683415651321,
-0.039015110582113266,
0.08634908497333527,
0.03861754760146141,
-0.1901993453502655,
0.20423486828804016,
-0.11649961769580841,
0.6437269449234009,
-0.0036470608320087194,
-0.37599024176597595,
-0.6648412942886353,
0.10293325036764145,
0.6770636439323425,
0.25215262174606323,
0.7859217524528503,
0.6386243104934692,
-0.2942958474159241,
-0.622619092464447,
-0.5306750535964966,
-0.3800815939903259,
-0.5263741612434387,
0.09305424988269806,
0.18385307490825653,
-0.7266795039176941,
0.40664151310920715,
-0.428631454706192,
0.11628259718418121,
0.41331177949905396,
0.7370745539665222,
-0.36675888299942017,
1.102728247642517,
0.38325873017311096,
-0.015851326286792755,
0.5083701610565186,
-0.35853996872901917,
0.10346738249063492,
-0.4149623513221741,
-0.28804129362106323,
-0.4123923182487488,
-0.45577943325042725,
-0.7303450107574463,
-0.6473756432533264,
0.42106643319129944,
-0.2829689085483551,
-0.034088823944330215,
0.10396147519350052,
-0.5140509009361267,
0.5164682865142822,
0.11254458129405975,
0.32944929599761963,
0.29833149909973145,
0.11462900042533875,
0.41229695081710815,
-0.17964570224285126,
-0.30476194620132446,
-0.5100932717323303,
1.0590896606445312,
0.15344111621379852,
0.7387524843215942,
-0.0822317972779274,
0.5786808729171753,
0.5282809734344482,
0.40334975719451904,
-1.1062620878219604,
0.7415383458137512,
0.006225131917744875,
-0.4612410068511963,
0.012952200137078762,
-0.4192453622817993,
-0.8272957801818848,
0.4296143054962158,
-0.39202186465263367,
-0.08041627705097198,
0.06976787745952606,
0.4346204102039337,
-0.0653519406914711,
0.592828094959259,
-0.16735978424549103,
0.5932326316833496,
-0.1512349396944046,
-0.15956617891788483,
-0.4501938819885254,
-0.47337427735328674,
0.19986991584300995,
0.0351388081908226,
0.08990159630775452,
-0.14582251012325287,
0.14166171848773956,
0.7722954154014587,
-0.3813396990299225,
1.1695556640625,
-0.46995025873184204,
-0.11288650333881378,
0.42157188057899475,
0.015864059329032898,
0.6080479621887207,
0.1741151511669159,
-0.037247005850076675,
0.11201543360948563,
-0.36829638481140137,
0.07032130658626556,
-0.5913580656051636,
0.44370266795158386,
-0.8481313586235046,
-0.9333306550979614,
-0.33126357197761536,
-0.4795551002025604,
-0.25639358162879944,
-0.28069770336151123,
0.25379329919815063,
0.18073251843452454,
-0.4507829248905182,
0.5051221251487732,
0.5953982472419739,
0.008984736166894436,
0.07888856530189514,
0.32916003465652466,
-0.04148492217063904,
-0.47260841727256775,
0.7587805986404419,
0.05968886986374855,
0.25355347990989685,
0.36059293150901794,
0.41907116770744324,
-0.6477790474891663,
-0.3607303500175476,
-0.18763181567192078,
0.13628649711608887,
-0.9126584529876709,
-0.47775527834892273,
-0.5476040840148926,
-0.1619403213262558,
-0.09376917779445648,
-0.10936510562896729,
-0.5042113661766052,
-0.8424032330513,
-0.31534117460250854,
-0.37560340762138367,
0.5166885852813721,
0.9000636339187622,
-0.026349646970629692,
0.5633092522621155,
-0.3716781735420227,
0.5692362785339355,
0.21203823387622833,
-0.02465316839516163,
-0.4512329697608948,
-0.5868498682975769,
0.20428499579429626,
0.17314550280570984,
-0.7476887702941895,
-1.2037445306777954,
0.3680069148540497,
0.16696177423000336,
0.49671483039855957,
0.6146409511566162,
0.2666587829589844,
0.6190053224563599,
-0.06835604459047318,
0.7315541505813599,
-0.17796459794044495,
-0.7231860160827637,
0.8262790441513062,
-0.5466190576553345,
-0.13095691800117493,
0.2914567291736603,
0.42474791407585144,
-0.016048287972807884,
-0.762887179851532,
-0.5725657939910889,
-0.6844954490661621,
0.7729165554046631,
0.27000942826271057,
0.34947195649147034,
0.04820575192570686,
0.3862513303756714,
0.29186463356018066,
0.17582382261753082,
-0.7424710392951965,
-0.10877063125371933,
-0.38773247599601746,
0.002282150322571397,
0.2565443813800812,
0.1760396659374237,
-0.4032987058162689,
-0.5734375715255737,
0.5856378674507141,
-0.3924226760864258,
0.0788508802652359,
0.00383126363158226,
-0.007888450287282467,
-0.04996941238641739,
0.2558193504810333,
0.43668830394744873,
0.42009738087654114,
0.0889267846941948,
0.20252393186092377,
0.4020620286464691,
-0.29381293058395386,
0.13140203058719635,
-0.19355760514736176,
-0.20628003776073456,
0.22685058414936066,
0.00544314319267869,
0.7599509954452515,
-0.22720159590244293,
-0.25485876202583313,
0.31805741786956787,
0.0008263065828941762,
-0.1587308794260025,
-0.39437243342399597,
0.2695770859718323,
0.40247422456741333,
0.37905043363571167,
0.12049117684364319,
0.09717752039432526,
0.03357793390750885,
-0.6330372095108032,
0.33950528502464294,
0.7728431224822998,
-0.0887221023440361,
-0.3843414783477783,
0.5551128387451172,
0.10049822926521301,
-0.3501655161380768,
0.31974247097969055,
-0.015674449503421783,
-0.7127747535705566,
0.8285626769065857,
0.6041222810745239,
0.44444116950035095,
-0.1388760209083557,
0.5431651473045349,
0.40285831689834595,
0.05007766932249069,
0.07023605704307556,
0.24901317059993744,
0.013117830269038677,
-0.9117205142974854,
0.06384169310331345,
-0.46627968549728394,
-0.6922615766525269,
0.4203369915485382,
-0.4898012578487396,
0.4366186261177063,
-0.7775048017501831,
-0.6679853200912476,
0.059182047843933105,
0.052653178572654724,
-0.4794589877128601,
-0.061252787709236145,
0.14285902678966522,
0.4528866708278656,
-0.9092321991920471,
0.5643677115440369,
0.6556777358055115,
0.03818686306476593,
-0.51643967628479,
0.3150062561035156,
0.40644147992134094,
-0.48551028966903687,
0.2295590192079544,
0.15209653973579407,
-0.4334748089313507,
-0.12109213322401047,
-0.7503812909126282,
-0.3778405487537384,
0.9769404530525208,
0.7733150124549866,
-0.37800416350364685,
0.49853208661079407,
0.6094425916671753,
0.6615572571754456,
-0.3924979269504547,
0.11959809064865112,
0.39953699707984924,
0.565507709980011,
0.198003351688385,
-0.40046074986457825,
0.007532691117376089,
-0.15932118892669678,
-0.27876946330070496,
0.2286953330039978,
-0.6668011546134949,
0.8546077609062195,
0.22661370038986206,
-0.3179672360420227,
-0.4424719512462616,
0.6555142402648926,
0.47173187136650085,
0.27952900528907776,
0.6162331700325012,
0.27780628204345703,
0.7736654281616211,
-0.14277473092079163,
0.8998557925224304,
-0.2782028913497925,
0.3235417306423187,
0.7259446382522583,
-0.30178046226501465,
0.8833383917808533,
0.5171679854393005,
0.06224721297621727,
0.47647207975387573,
0.5932478904724121,
-0.004692214075475931,
-0.009328744374215603,
0.13705839216709137,
-0.41386768221855164,
-0.6378928422927856,
-0.1734677106142044,
-0.12501180171966553,
0.46417495608329773,
0.6174425482749939,
-0.11224529147148132,
-0.22826461493968964,
-0.07778914272785187,
0.02022548019886017,
0.25495627522468567,
-0.22168926894664764,
1.0342015027999878,
0.070701964199543,
-0.6636933088302612,
0.494107186794281,
0.017515985295176506,
0.6321774125099182,
-0.4028412997722626,
-0.2316623330116272,
-0.39351609349250793,
0.311398446559906,
-0.37086787819862366,
-1.0151679515838623,
0.3567925989627838,
0.16963477432727814,
-0.039983123540878296,
-0.2887316346168518,
0.9536721706390381,
-0.35822951793670654,
-0.31657689809799194,
0.19439032673835754,
0.664767861366272,
0.028194189071655273,
-0.04703764244914055,
-0.5668309330940247,
0.10554388165473938,
-0.1413179636001587,
-0.45313578844070435,
0.44327694177627563,
0.31183677911758423,
-0.14003604650497437,
0.5066102147102356,
1.0421409606933594,
0.11035267263650894,
-0.02035428397357464,
0.12966880202293396,
1.2499173879623413,
-0.3738034665584564,
-0.4332718253135681,
-0.9047513008117676,
0.49077221751213074,
-0.34763577580451965,
-0.07166551053524017,
0.63132643699646,
0.5738099217414856,
0.9104165434837341,
-0.043510738760232925,
0.8067921996116638,
0.00502588739618659,
0.3340710699558258,
-0.4975357949733734,
0.8788596987724304,
-0.3883993625640869,
0.14142316579818726,
0.22690322995185852,
-0.7835255265235901,
-0.2533666789531708,
0.8171902298927307,
-0.12099307030439377,
-0.11712080240249634,
0.3018125593662262,
1.1397595405578613,
-0.5034952759742737,
0.052539557218551636,
0.08893411606550217,
0.1386317014694214,
0.585528552532196,
0.06543438881635666,
1.1299564838409424,
-0.09540313482284546,
0.519314169883728,
-0.30334192514419556,
0.22743208706378937,
-0.09028968960046768,
-0.7962343692779541,
-1.2412387132644653,
-0.4950944781303406,
-0.33047762513160706,
-0.4913662075996399,
-0.22308512032032013,
1.2071921825408936,
0.7008535265922546,
-1.0041909217834473,
-0.22195130586624146,
-0.17148542404174805,
0.06429745256900787,
0.2523359954357147,
-0.27151599526405334,
0.17129553854465485,
-0.05347789078950882,
-0.7625858783721924,
0.6196069121360779,
-0.07821469008922577,
0.04173547774553299,
-0.20956356823444366,
-0.1654532551765442,
-0.08588284254074097,
0.4492914080619812,
0.4953010380268097,
0.2984592616558075,
-0.9011147022247314,
-0.36907485127449036,
0.0708310455083847,
0.01561527419835329,
0.472382515668869,
1.036781668663025,
-0.746989905834198,
0.5197612047195435,
0.6644284129142761,
0.6040270328521729,
0.5506172776222229,
0.6370140314102173,
0.6099176406860352,
-0.9332072734832764,
0.15739114582538605,
0.2173391729593277,
0.1936216652393341,
0.4977774918079376,
-0.44002771377563477,
0.16834662854671478,
0.39630332589149475,
-0.2793467044830322,
-0.7276246547698975,
0.20050062239170074,
-1.0386205911636353,
-0.1613234430551529,
1.3143240213394165,
0.2507365942001343,
0.055477190762758255,
-0.1349429488182068,
-0.526785671710968,
0.5359348654747009,
-0.4699869453907013,
0.885981023311615,
0.4896036386489868,
-0.5139764547348022,
-0.029204951599240303,
-0.3881526589393616,
0.6632891893386841,
0.03604936599731445,
-1.109890341758728,
0.08807503432035446,
0.5901733636856079,
0.31576818227767944,
0.0364808663725853,
0.5411301851272583,
0.0519806407392025,
0.010001696646213531,
-0.1451421082019806,
-0.36701303720474243,
-0.00916325580328703,
-0.4085592031478882,
-0.3569576144218445,
0.33846551179885864,
-0.30863428115844727,
-0.04918639734387398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12474v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12474v1
|
Exploring Intra and Inter-language Consistency in Embeddings with ICA
| 2024-06-18T10:24:50 | 2024-06-18T10:24:50 |
Rongzhi Li, Takeru Matsuda, Hitomi Yanaka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, stat.ME
|
Word embeddings represent words as multidimensional real vectors,
facilitating data analysis and processing, but are often challenging to
interpret. Independent Component Analysis (ICA) creates clearer semantic axes
by identifying independent key features. Previous research has shown ICA's
potential to reveal universal semantic axes across languages. However, it
lacked verification of the consistency of independent components within and
across languages. We investigated the consistency of semantic axes in two ways:
both within a single language and across multiple languages. We first probed
into intra-language consistency, focusing on the reproducibility of axes by
performing ICA multiple times and clustering the outcomes. Then, we
statistically examined inter-language consistency by verifying those axes'
correspondences using statistical tests. We newly applied statistical methods
to establish a robust framework that ensures the reliability and universality
of semantic axes.
|
[
-0.33341121673583984,
-0.5559894442558289,
0.5477190613746643,
0.39732420444488525,
-0.2576049566268921,
-0.03328848257660866,
-0.22117802500724792,
-0.4925699830055237,
0.5636135339736938,
0.18103773891925812,
-0.35168105363845825,
-0.9197534918785095,
-0.6789649128913879,
0.19771230220794678,
-0.36112838983535767,
0.3904390037059784,
-0.44214797019958496,
0.5048015117645264,
-0.5059119462966919,
-0.9940042495727539,
-0.7859079837799072,
-0.26750677824020386,
-0.11566441506147385,
-0.24995051324367523,
0.4076465368270874,
0.3826684057712555,
0.9296769499778748,
0.8586336374282837,
0.5859862565994263,
0.2823852598667145,
0.4232683777809143,
0.1746589094400406,
-0.17568425834178925,
0.1342938393354416,
-0.3449679911136627,
-0.21792884171009064,
-0.2997124493122101,
-0.13980832695960999,
0.8009885549545288,
0.7515617609024048,
0.22242508828639984,
-0.18896086513996124,
0.39123502373695374,
0.277584433555603,
-0.7339485287666321,
0.6981311440467834,
-0.7045907378196716,
-0.13588975369930267,
-0.2765817940235138,
0.05266985297203064,
-0.17995929718017578,
-0.39289119839668274,
0.025874121114611626,
-0.6622695326805115,
-0.14594535529613495,
-0.21317046880722046,
0.9507550001144409,
-0.0467224083840847,
-0.6086220741271973,
-0.4255618751049042,
-0.6261199712753296,
0.682066023349762,
-0.5153353810310364,
0.7910590171813965,
0.5149152278900146,
-0.1350201964378357,
-0.20731985569000244,
-0.539228081703186,
-0.7511809468269348,
-0.23070204257965088,
-0.27807414531707764,
-0.030878815799951553,
-0.329926460981369,
-0.0865422859787941,
-0.4104212820529938,
-0.261919230222702,
-0.43406030535697937,
0.39046281576156616,
0.16032657027244568,
-0.3037225604057312,
0.470450758934021,
-0.10857690125703812,
0.7868542075157166,
0.03754201531410217,
-0.4932018518447876,
-0.4553145468235016,
-0.9417259097099304,
-0.08173860609531403,
0.485243558883667,
0.5323768854141235,
-0.1921299397945404,
0.8927925229072571,
-0.0403086319565773,
0.07594295591115952,
-0.23693537712097168,
-0.2933503985404968,
0.3002672493457794,
-0.5255406498908997,
0.27847084403038025,
0.20692244172096252,
0.786928117275238,
0.26122426986694336,
0.03206777945160866,
-0.5272528529167175,
0.13512304425239563,
0.45197564363479614,
0.08259351551532745,
-0.3236786425113678,
0.010100770741701126,
0.22721751034259796,
-0.4165644645690918,
0.150331512093544,
0.2413899153470993,
-0.45867180824279785,
0.07423984259366989,
-0.6434130668640137,
0.6174180507659912,
-0.7230239510536194,
-0.31046831607818604,
-0.07521770149469376,
0.10668117552995682,
0.3805030286312103,
-0.12247510254383087,
-0.7085672616958618,
0.17920808494091034,
1.2016983032226562,
0.49955612421035767,
-0.21111837029457092,
-0.913680374622345,
-0.10170286148786545,
0.2087416797876358,
-0.669169008731842,
1.119673490524292,
-0.6513515114784241,
0.09280538558959961,
0.2394544631242752,
0.17987997829914093,
-0.02033180557191372,
-0.3869737982749939,
0.32232430577278137,
-0.36402302980422974,
-0.19857488572597504,
-0.6542413830757141,
-0.8986614346504211,
-0.2477235198020935,
0.29356253147125244,
-0.4073796272277832,
0.7557900547981262,
-0.15726351737976074,
-0.7610158920288086,
0.9501129984855652,
-0.010679248720407486,
-0.0789886862039566,
-0.10473386198282242,
-0.9050694108009338,
-0.585518479347229,
0.1728258728981018,
0.11571472883224487,
0.3218518793582916,
-0.1342487782239914,
0.21117983758449554,
-0.6533120274543762,
-0.1652672290802002,
0.21979700028896332,
-0.32312431931495667,
0.6802834868431091,
-0.25778454542160034,
-0.25590780377388,
-0.12623193860054016,
-0.7639498114585876,
0.22128669917583466,
-0.08475569635629654,
0.10886342823505402,
-0.6787832975387573,
0.2976846396923065,
-0.2693963944911957,
0.05153891071677208,
0.15696485340595245,
-0.9724751710891724,
0.29902029037475586,
0.0781562402844429,
-0.1979808360338211,
0.7638323903083801,
-0.1477423459291458,
0.16188599169254303,
0.05810955911874771,
0.270410418510437,
0.46692997217178345,
-0.25831249356269836,
-0.004469659645110369,
-0.6650676727294922,
-0.4566187858581543,
-0.41949662566185,
0.33313342928886414,
0.4082079231739044,
-0.6303916573524475,
0.7174369692802429,
-0.43078434467315674,
-0.4471607208251953,
-0.5998319983482361,
0.05965640768408775,
0.5076087713241577,
0.1272929310798645,
0.19257910549640656,
-0.6326780319213867,
-0.39972159266471863,
-1.0734145641326904,
-0.14387273788452148,
-0.26882171630859375,
0.11825872212648392,
-0.24905215203762054,
0.3700398802757263,
-0.48513293266296387,
1.088310956954956,
-0.2716423273086548,
-0.45859453082084656,
-0.14942872524261475,
0.26393774151802063,
-0.2055041342973709,
0.6965449452400208,
0.7437882423400879,
-0.3415272831916809,
-0.6716343760490417,
0.237892746925354,
-1.0135189294815063,
0.004984206985682249,
-0.01312785129994154,
-0.37152737379074097,
-0.06937064230442047,
0.5114752054214478,
-0.3809412717819214,
0.929902970790863,
0.6991716027259827,
-0.46821731328964233,
0.17069518566131592,
-0.5310429930686951,
0.14681699872016907,
-0.8037304282188416,
-0.2063979059457779,
-0.2145683765411377,
0.13523893058300018,
-0.5767267346382141,
-0.029417162761092186,
0.23369468748569489,
0.18801173567771912,
-0.1299063265323639,
0.3204611539840698,
-0.5360494256019592,
-0.227414071559906,
-0.27808240056037903,
0.3823421001434326,
0.021213291212916374,
0.47841677069664,
-0.2449941337108612,
0.6044566631317139,
0.6896228790283203,
-0.44702035188674927,
-0.03075096383690834,
0.4142427146434784,
-0.3878512978553772,
0.842498779296875,
-0.5889931321144104,
0.1889844536781311,
-0.4988992214202881,
-0.05633070692420006,
-1.264507532119751,
0.15368175506591797,
0.16371946036815643,
-0.16913840174674988,
0.30884990096092224,
0.02720005437731743,
-0.6350536942481995,
0.40506628155708313,
-0.3304635286331177,
0.6160945296287537,
-0.036035772413015366,
-0.611977219581604,
0.7906829714775085,
0.6807079315185547,
0.10707949101924896,
-0.609551727771759,
-0.42285558581352234,
-0.16761642694473267,
0.01534368097782135,
-0.8470662832260132,
0.300220787525177,
-0.032762620598077774,
-0.5897566080093384,
0.31050384044647217,
-0.029276520013809204,
-0.16426266729831696,
-0.03826262056827545,
0.2156227082014084,
0.07064014673233032,
-0.26330387592315674,
0.24604550004005432,
0.12414154410362244,
-0.41347765922546387,
-0.26094529032707214,
-0.18299712240695953,
0.42930370569229126,
-0.050692591816186905,
-1.1003749370574951,
-0.8092553019523621,
0.6081428527832031,
0.3264933228492737,
-0.19371125102043152,
0.7918931245803833,
0.5478903651237488,
-0.48881450295448303,
0.03979118913412094,
-0.28988322615623474,
-0.08700858801603317,
-0.37505629658699036,
0.2933177351951599,
-0.6675254106521606,
-0.47815895080566406,
0.8900967836380005,
0.26273274421691895,
0.14451734721660614,
0.6221436262130737,
0.3578026294708252,
0.1213902086019516,
1.181029200553894,
1.0235238075256348,
-0.08040859550237656,
0.03767917677760124,
-0.0334663949906826,
0.4487432837486267,
-0.6269937753677368,
-0.38772499561309814,
-0.8672407865524292,
-0.3120967745780945,
-0.9173088073730469,
-0.2967272698879242,
0.41538205742836,
0.1656871885061264,
0.17915168404579163,
0.2877108156681061,
-0.1758936494588852,
0.5410513877868652,
0.4158037304878235,
-0.3303108513355255,
0.3212953805923462,
0.005105090793222189,
-0.4771658182144165,
-0.2648410201072693,
-0.4835236966609955,
-0.49627599120140076,
0.8520246744155884,
0.22075659036636353,
0.8317881226539612,
0.037496741861104965,
0.5702469944953918,
-0.02202816680073738,
0.23829852044582367,
-0.6472032070159912,
0.3498935103416443,
-0.4433004856109619,
-0.18443326652050018,
-0.10780590027570724,
0.040580783039331436,
-1.231072187423706,
0.6575798392295837,
-0.19119131565093994,
-0.8040456771850586,
0.6720287799835205,
-0.13672487437725067,
0.3415311574935913,
0.4144555628299713,
-0.401297926902771,
0.7997688055038452,
-0.0011384892277419567,
0.002961323596537113,
-0.11858689785003662,
-0.4088837802410126,
-0.03855851665139198,
0.019546041265130043,
0.19611698389053345,
-0.5494834780693054,
0.017907481640577316,
0.48080676794052124,
-0.4726737439632416,
0.7721608877182007,
0.24322739243507385,
-0.35904765129089355,
0.39124009013175964,
0.06852853298187256,
0.46584352850914,
0.09426279366016388,
0.1772734373807907,
0.6200246214866638,
0.1880035251379013,
-0.4863969087600708,
-0.5579982399940491,
0.8505575060844421,
-1.0055347681045532,
-0.10750608891248703,
-0.4784012734889984,
-0.5431827902793884,
-0.39644497632980347,
0.16195756196975708,
0.07532902806997299,
0.6689498424530029,
-0.24829407036304474,
0.29610010981559753,
0.5301093459129333,
-0.09561125189065933,
0.1956399828195572,
0.4329986274242401,
-0.23904730379581451,
-0.2653611898422241,
0.9061815142631531,
0.5330798625946045,
-0.025860054418444633,
0.47668126225471497,
0.266193687915802,
-0.15932099521160126,
-0.5913137793540955,
-0.33625417947769165,
0.39265909790992737,
-0.8148030638694763,
-0.12385593354701996,
-0.6023650765419006,
0.14117753505706787,
-0.6520776152610779,
-0.0837293267250061,
-0.6785459518432617,
-0.19018465280532837,
0.03416965529322624,
-0.11653692275285721,
0.12552793323993683,
1.060450553894043,
-0.3343174457550049,
-0.07381268590688705,
-0.8938326835632324,
0.22427649796009064,
0.26311975717544556,
0.4471379220485687,
-0.02256232313811779,
0.1883298009634018,
-0.1459326446056366,
0.1273987889289856,
0.0440625436604023,
-0.8419267535209656,
0.059108439832925797,
0.14314620196819305,
0.8505371809005737,
0.5138801336288452,
-0.09469035267829895,
0.654562771320343,
-0.5145392417907715,
0.6144015192985535,
0.016106409952044487,
-0.9386630058288574,
-0.04561943560838699,
-0.07571391016244888,
0.536796510219574,
0.5825455188751221,
0.3496280610561371,
-0.5666742324829102,
-0.6675795316696167,
-0.44585445523262024,
-0.9182969331741333,
0.45813173055648804,
0.17483073472976685,
-0.03230136260390282,
-0.30804383754730225,
0.12009145319461823,
0.43607333302497864,
-0.21935194730758667,
-0.23776589334011078,
-0.36185580492019653,
-0.04810689762234688,
-0.5665002465248108,
0.12629933655261993,
-0.3168346881866455,
-0.34004291892051697,
0.12666982412338257,
0.5806382298469543,
-0.44312235713005066,
0.3417503535747528,
-0.01995180733501911,
-0.10387638211250305,
0.13557617366313934,
0.08212251216173172,
0.413629412651062,
1.2127865552902222,
0.12889012694358826,
0.43292224407196045,
-0.027689604088664055,
-0.5909276604652405,
0.15946193039417267,
-0.1071917861700058,
-0.27437394857406616,
0.2305874079465866,
0.6954885125160217,
0.5354418158531189,
0.2044607400894165,
-0.47724011540412903,
0.5428200960159302,
-0.46316149830818176,
0.10580044984817505,
-0.279674232006073,
-0.6116754412651062,
0.04606868699193001,
0.08876337110996246,
0.04399925097823143,
-0.2389666587114334,
-0.31007084250450134,
-0.5713398456573486,
0.3851678967475891,
0.613136351108551,
-0.4654046595096588,
-0.6572847962379456,
0.12642332911491394,
-0.4728143811225891,
0.22688999772071838,
0.6437425017356873,
-0.07763450592756271,
-0.2889721095561981,
0.521205723285675,
0.39979445934295654,
1.047181248664856,
-0.028877096250653267,
0.2607434391975403,
0.08165986835956573,
0.40846049785614014,
0.111860491335392,
0.5518008470535278,
0.32767561078071594,
-1.1052964925765991,
-0.13931730389595032,
-0.3650534749031067,
-0.49284976720809937,
-0.423391729593277,
-0.7431889772415161,
0.18104490637779236,
0.0010560347000136971,
0.12609152495861053,
0.06367146223783493,
-0.24749130010604858,
-0.8928326368331909,
-0.03861222043633461,
-0.1254080981016159,
0.4884851574897766,
-0.8985486030578613,
1.0802152156829834,
0.5614809989929199,
-0.4197658896446228,
-0.9465875029563904,
-0.05722710117697716,
0.10524386167526245,
-0.9288917779922485,
0.5420664548873901,
-0.057227667421102524,
-0.27644437551498413,
-0.7806474566459656,
-0.36469072103500366,
-1.375863790512085,
1.0746564865112305,
0.4967901408672333,
-0.09933987259864807,
0.3126422166824341,
0.6521406769752502,
0.5978121757507324,
-0.51862633228302,
0.05984582379460335,
0.3580279052257538,
0.3465065658092499,
-0.20165224373340607,
-0.7597587704658508,
-0.040375400334596634,
0.12668438255786896,
0.18252810835838318,
0.24861930310726166,
-0.5326206684112549,
0.8023698925971985,
0.17507924139499664,
-0.2915430963039398,
-0.007188296411186457,
1.1898013353347778,
0.18317517638206482,
0.2595597207546234,
0.3778185248374939,
0.7685977220535278,
0.6893406510353088,
-0.22803035378456116,
0.8497166037559509,
-0.6505616903305054,
0.3111008107662201,
1.1903162002563477,
-0.35440900921821594,
0.8539729118347168,
0.40624096989631653,
-0.05135732889175415,
0.6303936839103699,
0.019550321623682976,
0.4287308156490326,
0.5009247660636902,
-0.22935684025287628,
-0.1285807192325592,
0.1415865570306778,
-0.3019804358482361,
-0.252526193857193,
1.0350521802902222,
0.233390212059021,
0.008406330831348896,
-0.401644229888916,
0.3062112331390381,
0.47208765149116516,
0.07191228866577148,
0.05283578857779503,
0.8011009693145752,
-0.07339033484458923,
-0.5738651752471924,
0.18973976373672485,
-0.01963908225297928,
0.3795869052410126,
-1.018855333328247,
-0.0568220429122448,
-0.36106935143470764,
0.4995640814304352,
0.10244128853082657,
-0.8104149699211121,
0.45555993914604187,
-0.49418267607688904,
0.10601472109556198,
-0.06510792672634125,
0.5543555021286011,
-0.8155069947242737,
-0.43265220522880554,
0.5426434278488159,
0.4443260729312897,
-0.014551375061273575,
0.44643059372901917,
-0.3540782332420349,
0.5376508831977844,
-0.13975419104099274,
0.22351273894309998,
0.5830118656158447,
0.8415186405181885,
-0.15072034299373627,
0.47676894068717957,
0.30396026372909546,
-0.11822833120822906,
0.251984566450119,
0.04457477107644081,
0.6575024127960205,
-0.33260777592658997,
-0.3136151134967804,
-0.6607563495635986,
0.4066134989261627,
0.1559794694185257,
-0.5492137670516968,
1.2326661348342896,
0.3582722246646881,
1.1851035356521606,
0.18297912180423737,
0.4433828592300415,
-0.03959823027253151,
0.2210223376750946,
-0.49456074833869934,
0.47597578167915344,
-0.32056206464767456,
-0.020495019853115082,
-0.27817022800445557,
-0.7665342092514038,
-0.3897230923175812,
0.49374085664749146,
0.22627022862434387,
-0.3306146562099457,
0.8228985667228699,
0.7147826552391052,
-0.14115235209465027,
0.04579900577664375,
0.38220545649528503,
0.2877378463745117,
0.6154080033302307,
-0.17957037687301636,
0.40615496039390564,
-0.40947896242141724,
0.1674993932247162,
-0.6772108674049377,
-0.19809551537036896,
0.3284362256526947,
-0.8558453321456909,
-0.37903913855552673,
-0.8370475769042969,
-0.4199795126914978,
-0.4513836205005646,
-0.15570631623268127,
0.9479018449783325,
0.42630311846733093,
-0.9978506565093994,
-0.4567834734916687,
0.2519453465938568,
0.2888641059398651,
-0.6380571126937866,
-0.1688961237668991,
0.8778772950172424,
-0.4817461669445038,
-0.7903972864151001,
0.4660950005054474,
0.5730120539665222,
-0.170943021774292,
-0.6933394074440002,
0.264559805393219,
-0.33718839287757874,
0.2582184076309204,
0.5689151883125305,
0.24498935043811798,
-0.6346765756607056,
-0.8603248596191406,
-0.31280967593193054,
-0.15568362176418304,
0.2244061976671219,
0.8967909216880798,
-0.4876985251903534,
0.7945460081100464,
0.8814570307731628,
0.7627238035202026,
-0.14345386624336243,
-0.23745690286159515,
0.7706485986709595,
-0.5876340866088867,
0.2342444360256195,
-0.021916896104812622,
0.7714275121688843,
0.33138465881347656,
-0.030822981148958206,
0.39309465885162354,
0.002372146351262927,
-0.6417922377586365,
-0.5167697668075562,
0.3217526972293854,
-0.959077775478363,
-0.1691453605890274,
0.7975024580955505,
-0.5589743256568909,
-0.26469001173973083,
-0.2955702841281891,
-0.0021795190405100584,
0.09590522199869156,
-0.03200504556298256,
0.707716703414917,
0.8110570311546326,
-0.24444957077503204,
0.4248725175857544,
0.030047092586755753,
0.3110271096229553,
0.25024178624153137,
-0.7412452697753906,
-0.1528228223323822,
0.2345438003540039,
0.3601117432117462,
0.44156843423843384,
0.5408955812454224,
-0.39201483130455017,
-0.1096385270357132,
0.2608526051044464,
-0.06650695949792862,
0.6078470945358276,
-0.5944204926490784,
-0.17173431813716888,
0.3175146281719208,
0.04853300005197525,
-0.31252244114875793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12471v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12471v1
|
Fighting Randomness with Randomness: Mitigating Optimisation Instability of Fine-Tuning using Delayed Ensemble and Noisy Interpolation
| 2024-06-18T10:20:36 | 2024-06-18T10:20:36 |
Branislav Pecher, Jan Cegin, Robert Belanec, Jakub Simko, Ivan Srba, Maria Bielikova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While fine-tuning of pre-trained language models generally helps to overcome
the lack of labelled training samples, it also displays model performance
instability. This instability mainly originates from randomness in
initialisation or data shuffling. To address this, researchers either modify
the training process or augment the available samples, which typically results
in increased computational costs. We propose a new mitigation strategy, called
Delayed Ensemble with Noisy Interpolation (DENI), that leverages the strengths
of ensembling, noise regularisation and model interpolation, while retaining
computational efficiency. We compare DENI with 9 representative mitigation
strategies across 3 models, 4 tuning strategies and 7 text classification
datasets. We show that: 1) DENI outperforms the best performing mitigation
strategy (Ensemble), while using only a fraction of its cost; 2) the mitigation
strategies are beneficial for parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods,
outperforming full fine-tuning in specific cases; and 3) combining DENI with
data augmentation often leads to even more effective instability mitigation.
|
[
-0.6619557738304138,
-0.7612685561180115,
-0.016810551285743713,
0.2763213515281677,
-0.3378918468952179,
0.5643983483314514,
-0.45975369215011597,
-0.47819602489471436,
-0.019999990239739418,
0.35415521264076233,
-0.6781616806983948,
-0.06271543353796005,
-0.5825461149215698,
0.05794057995080948,
-0.3438687324523926,
0.8426821827888489,
0.1528748869895935,
0.20742009580135345,
-0.05519448220729828,
-0.08873694390058517,
-0.1805107444524765,
-0.5522738695144653,
-1.1409485340118408,
-0.341409295797348,
0.5183520317077637,
0.5477147698402405,
0.7595804333686829,
0.43875762820243835,
0.5038062334060669,
0.29134729504585266,
-0.02255966141819954,
0.19080133736133575,
-0.6525201201438904,
0.3629964590072632,
0.34486663341522217,
-0.6718306541442871,
-0.0900929793715477,
-0.020535750314593315,
0.9204340577125549,
0.5299854874610901,
-0.3129926323890686,
-0.1318661868572235,
0.2074006199836731,
0.7202399969100952,
-0.6896815896034241,
-0.092405304312706,
-0.7928712964057922,
0.07927492260932922,
-0.5185691714286804,
-0.27343156933784485,
-0.3145096004009247,
-0.2566961944103241,
-0.16249094903469086,
-0.6155380010604858,
0.36745771765708923,
0.19134871661663055,
0.9741104245185852,
0.5111400485038757,
0.31156814098358154,
0.006330696400254965,
-0.9924072623252869,
1.0220386981964111,
-0.8242404460906982,
0.3429369032382965,
0.31155630946159363,
0.24923960864543915,
-0.2917044460773468,
-0.3450128436088562,
-0.5225722789764404,
0.07593739032745361,
0.2860928773880005,
0.20756390690803528,
-0.14279507100582123,
0.1745034158229828,
0.266648530960083,
0.10882546752691269,
-0.4031951427459717,
0.8627528548240662,
-0.32998940348625183,
-0.34094753861427307,
0.7852814197540283,
-0.06796151399612427,
0.13813431560993195,
0.6346608400344849,
0.009803866036236286,
-0.5010138154029846,
-0.7544506192207336,
0.14075246453285217,
1.199751853942871,
0.4056137204170227,
0.03297105431556702,
0.38725486397743225,
-0.23977379500865936,
0.6329938173294067,
0.30866527557373047,
-0.051189906895160675,
0.23680800199508667,
-0.24340032041072845,
-0.004929910879582167,
0.2722175121307373,
0.5810359716415405,
0.22779370844364166,
0.45908814668655396,
-0.30913108587265015,
-0.4925430715084076,
0.1451261341571808,
0.16219240427017212,
-0.8023231625556946,
-0.1924758106470108,
0.4417821764945984,
-0.3522914946079254,
-0.8440431356430054,
-0.24954257905483246,
-0.9224637150764465,
0.010740241035819054,
-0.22369663417339325,
0.2628205418586731,
-0.3312179148197174,
-0.16611461341381073,
0.024550313130021095,
-0.1163354143500328,
-0.19660212099552155,
0.32451000809669495,
-1.2090635299682617,
0.5263602137565613,
0.6372273564338684,
0.644149661064148,
-0.10868044197559357,
-0.2841111123561859,
-0.4402358829975128,
0.0012802890269085765,
-0.590843141078949,
0.7806959748268127,
-0.6899252533912659,
-0.4784751832485199,
-0.21585026383399963,
-0.2462722361087799,
-0.1484287828207016,
-0.5725923776626587,
0.40803730487823486,
-0.37578365206718445,
0.19476811587810516,
0.09917248785495758,
-0.3573041260242462,
0.18206553161144257,
0.09026055037975311,
-0.7202073335647583,
1.2074928283691406,
-0.020252646878361702,
-0.7899367809295654,
0.6209518313407898,
-0.39957118034362793,
-0.28840091824531555,
-0.11673806607723236,
-0.2389785498380661,
-0.7740694284439087,
0.11469253897666931,
0.2127075046300888,
0.39699581265449524,
-0.1329018473625183,
0.18486087024211884,
-0.3856934607028961,
-0.7045496702194214,
-0.07125522941350937,
-0.5298582315444946,
0.3628370463848114,
0.6673243045806885,
-0.1064222902059555,
0.1075175330042839,
-0.9848687052726746,
0.2111612856388092,
-0.05755070596933365,
-0.3182511031627655,
-0.4465080499649048,
0.18548500537872314,
-0.0987049862742424,
0.06266973167657852,
-0.05020630732178688,
-0.35338518023490906,
0.24576283991336823,
-0.7343502044677734,
0.588512122631073,
0.8536111116409302,
0.056238532066345215,
0.5996729731559753,
-0.7421541213989258,
0.40450647473335266,
0.3391122817993164,
0.09404610097408295,
0.1878279596567154,
-0.446815550327301,
-0.5225222110748291,
-0.12355846911668777,
0.5722873210906982,
0.5201811194419861,
-0.7064063549041748,
-0.034783195704221725,
-0.27056658267974854,
-0.6737776398658752,
-0.7161768078804016,
0.026166632771492004,
0.3666919767856598,
0.11654272675514221,
0.09917130321264267,
-0.4340781569480896,
-0.5203917622566223,
-0.6326570510864258,
-0.4495616853237152,
-0.003557592863216996,
0.05916563421487808,
0.049364782869815826,
0.06409712135791779,
-0.1727963536977768,
0.5788826942443848,
0.020303480327129364,
-0.025245657190680504,
-0.20266884565353394,
0.6289070248603821,
0.13865967094898224,
0.8089184165000916,
0.6319087147712708,
-0.7830272316932678,
-0.28077393770217896,
-0.12015100568532944,
-0.07070358842611313,
-0.13881351053714752,
-0.23892265558242798,
0.1291133016347885,
0.46989530324935913,
0.55008465051651,
-0.26198068261146545,
0.2677718997001648,
0.35539689660072327,
0.2549512982368469,
0.43463870882987976,
-0.200132355093956,
0.20115859806537628,
-0.7394551634788513,
-0.18413026630878448,
-0.1894926279783249,
0.15511129796504974,
-0.5559314489364624,
-0.0025355955585837364,
-0.1678536832332611,
-0.17561902105808258,
-0.252511203289032,
0.4236885607242584,
-0.3884846568107605,
0.4501885175704956,
-0.05099830776453018,
0.00202252808958292,
-0.3669275939464569,
0.2881617248058319,
-0.0371922105550766,
0.8898791670799255,
0.5212159156799316,
-0.6408509016036987,
-0.3332625925540924,
-0.2818048298358917,
-0.48563453555107117,
-0.013223079964518547,
-0.539024829864502,
0.14668281376361847,
-0.440432071685791,
-0.18246185779571533,
-0.7590357661247253,
-0.21105992794036865,
0.14495664834976196,
-0.3865956664085388,
0.6993017196655273,
-0.20015475153923035,
-0.5857157111167908,
-0.479406476020813,
-0.36573129892349243,
0.45885950326919556,
0.5245541334152222,
-0.27972251176834106,
0.18159912526607513,
0.38046783208847046,
-0.15813972055912018,
-0.784305989742279,
-0.5691919326782227,
-0.25506284832954407,
-0.32951056957244873,
-0.5280044674873352,
0.43705710768699646,
-0.3413897156715393,
-0.39769938588142395,
-0.08816596865653992,
-0.19121503829956055,
-0.24288108944892883,
0.3718818128108978,
0.11918480694293976,
-0.20357951521873474,
-0.03583710640668869,
0.10342413932085037,
0.25589779019355774,
-0.19896887242794037,
-0.27173906564712524,
-0.24412205815315247,
0.846444845199585,
0.17628416419029236,
-0.22411760687828064,
-0.13262449204921722,
0.3295029103755951,
0.38587793707847595,
-0.028080778196454048,
0.6947845220565796,
0.6330159902572632,
-0.3833358585834503,
-0.3556987941265106,
-0.6937819123268127,
-0.5070252418518066,
-0.4889572858810425,
0.2804643511772156,
-0.4961036145687103,
-0.9531703591346741,
0.6567955613136292,
-0.14435063302516937,
0.2633343040943146,
0.17804421484470367,
0.5199108123779297,
-0.1478601098060608,
1.191848635673523,
0.7737541794776917,
-0.2579967677593231,
0.6326748132705688,
-0.1019183099269867,
0.36320996284484863,
-0.19530268013477325,
0.09119954705238342,
-0.7995606660842896,
-0.5721307396888733,
-0.8939446210861206,
-0.24619677662849426,
0.08818383514881134,
0.30173027515411377,
-0.20908457040786743,
0.07654371857643127,
-0.6311547160148621,
0.6062723994255066,
0.6542309522628784,
-0.055558573454618454,
0.21153198182582855,
0.40275174379348755,
-0.10983186960220337,
-0.14886607229709625,
-1.0707331895828247,
-0.3443065285682678,
1.0764987468719482,
0.2772681713104248,
0.9789615273475647,
-0.16637538373470306,
1.0496044158935547,
-0.06911619752645493,
-0.0031171725131571293,
-0.2834372818470001,
0.3599717319011688,
-0.14037667214870453,
-0.3952862620353699,
-0.6109533905982971,
-0.5461913347244263,
-1.0601184368133545,
0.1639869064092636,
-0.4563901722431183,
-0.7844815850257874,
0.5297644734382629,
0.19705933332443237,
-0.5585377216339111,
0.4386655390262604,
-0.6213889122009277,
0.48529812693595886,
0.10562806576490402,
-0.26994580030441284,
-0.39181578159332275,
-0.6533079147338867,
0.30335015058517456,
-0.20038460195064545,
0.4834577441215515,
-0.05455946922302246,
0.21766120195388794,
0.8833028078079224,
-0.34302374720573425,
0.6978757381439209,
0.06786327809095383,
0.1129651814699173,
0.33791205286979675,
-0.041256826370954514,
0.6927614212036133,
0.058006301522254944,
-0.16610121726989746,
0.27080294489860535,
0.1634453684091568,
-0.564072847366333,
-0.6395135521888733,
0.7842287421226501,
-0.9369372129440308,
-0.44569554924964905,
-0.3271945118904114,
-0.450115442276001,
-0.14716224372386932,
0.2221401333808899,
0.6126236319541931,
0.2801663279533386,
-0.06252560019493103,
0.11971011757850647,
0.8531196117401123,
0.1115647554397583,
0.751865804195404,
0.3902446925640106,
-0.023750321939587593,
-0.32893162965774536,
0.9357753992080688,
0.5969051718711853,
0.48332712054252625,
0.2714748680591583,
0.09706167876720428,
0.26079991459846497,
-0.9556677341461182,
-0.19296057522296906,
-0.15906491875648499,
-0.2949943244457245,
-0.11365537345409393,
-0.7222960591316223,
-0.41942211985588074,
-0.5090873837471008,
-0.08545412868261337,
-0.45686793327331543,
-0.7418540716171265,
-0.16566027700901031,
0.017092637717723846,
0.4556047320365906,
0.37678882479667664,
-0.37990787625312805,
0.6123539209365845,
-0.6789551377296448,
0.010052669793367386,
-0.01236014999449253,
0.45374417304992676,
-0.024396833032369614,
-0.2613350450992584,
-0.2033023089170456,
0.12933167815208435,
-0.20631954073905945,
-0.5256243348121643,
0.521354615688324,
0.2293584942817688,
0.6422824859619141,
0.45377621054649353,
0.13799861073493958,
0.802533745765686,
-0.4419749081134796,
0.4701434373855591,
-0.004338142927736044,
-0.4621395468711853,
0.44410938024520874,
-0.3000575602054596,
0.09450028091669083,
0.7615389227867126,
0.1838231235742569,
-0.010349182412028313,
-0.7086301445960999,
-0.7851658463478088,
-1.0522435903549194,
0.5682554244995117,
0.2773902118206024,
-0.03448076546192169,
0.12827031314373016,
0.32341352105140686,
-0.07239409536123276,
0.47376808524131775,
-0.5059394240379333,
-0.17281131446361542,
0.015814432874321938,
-0.09163150936365128,
-0.1369583159685135,
-0.398366242647171,
-0.24964608252048492,
-0.2896919548511505,
0.8109923601150513,
0.04668296501040459,
0.07542001456022263,
0.07153066992759705,
0.0534907765686512,
-0.595957338809967,
0.25777003169059753,
0.568073034286499,
0.19978338479995728,
-0.35394561290740967,
-0.1397600769996643,
0.04493119940161705,
-0.7971884608268738,
0.10227387398481369,
0.18842384219169617,
-0.5446755886077881,
-0.11067302525043488,
0.03104417584836483,
0.7368780970573425,
0.4801938533782959,
-0.6506981253623962,
0.10866760462522507,
-0.13120543956756592,
-0.18475915491580963,
-0.007805206347256899,
0.2718958556652069,
-0.31994345784187317,
0.02242962457239628,
0.14350014925003052,
0.5940849781036377,
-0.03413861617445946,
-0.1869731992483139,
0.2565215826034546,
0.4746473431587219,
-0.3225575387477875,
-0.18336771428585052,
0.6964130997657776,
-0.1229308545589447,
-0.33937183022499084,
0.5200567245483398,
-0.14211952686309814,
-0.07489058375358582,
0.7386709451675415,
0.5346571803092957,
0.766141414642334,
-0.2837027609348297,
0.08764836192131042,
0.2868262231349945,
0.7225069403648376,
-0.3636874258518219,
0.476830393075943,
0.1231517642736435,
-0.8183485865592957,
-0.36818212270736694,
-0.6604236364364624,
-0.4879710078239441,
0.011640834622085094,
-0.6064375638961792,
0.40702369809150696,
-0.718254029750824,
-0.024772020056843758,
-0.2463596761226654,
0.17718949913978577,
-0.6362740397453308,
0.15278765559196472,
-0.19682620465755463,
0.8838407397270203,
-0.7161532640457153,
0.9683316349983215,
0.39027950167655945,
-0.35915398597717285,
-0.8286828398704529,
-0.01883728615939617,
-0.15041957795619965,
-0.5923281311988831,
0.33903998136520386,
0.023780087009072304,
0.08576507866382599,
0.3276805579662323,
-0.7511026859283447,
-1.0786070823669434,
0.8562291264533997,
0.22891299426555634,
-1.2125259637832642,
0.23206764459609985,
-0.051913484930992126,
0.4601336121559143,
-0.12080542743206024,
0.0961720421910286,
0.5500651597976685,
0.5250577926635742,
-0.036778852343559265,
-0.6384966373443604,
-0.2834748327732086,
-0.3094235956668854,
-0.21463853120803833,
0.3353998363018036,
-0.7273393273353577,
0.6890566945075989,
-0.16052573919296265,
-0.41619595885276794,
0.2946185767650604,
0.4175668954849243,
0.18755120038986206,
0.36553719639778137,
0.55598384141922,
1.0164963006973267,
0.9302002787590027,
-0.2718544900417328,
0.9150909781455994,
-0.5020493268966675,
0.008959541097283363,
1.085253357887268,
-0.11798539757728577,
0.8099463582038879,
0.6156111359596252,
-0.18119525909423828,
0.018362920731306076,
0.8436282873153687,
-0.13922427594661713,
0.7281590104103088,
0.36523371934890747,
-0.27227887511253357,
-0.07925479859113693,
0.29402416944503784,
-0.42564526200294495,
0.06667356193065643,
0.22635993361473083,
0.06930608302354813,
-0.35752132534980774,
0.16327768564224243,
-0.025947634130716324,
0.2117420881986618,
-0.22571712732315063,
0.682314395904541,
-0.13667424023151398,
-0.47329869866371155,
0.6187099814414978,
-0.10187006741762161,
0.7270827889442444,
-0.5509418845176697,
0.1309356540441513,
-0.11056536436080933,
0.05201588571071625,
-0.10869523882865906,
-0.2727832794189453,
0.3062092661857605,
-0.3988204300403595,
-0.36021119356155396,
-0.18324342370033264,
0.588898777961731,
-0.597405195236206,
-0.6193801164627075,
0.021901316940784454,
0.33756133913993835,
0.1172063872218132,
0.14592856168746948,
-0.5003805160522461,
0.16131499409675598,
-0.2657836377620697,
-0.224391907453537,
0.8261871337890625,
0.5168760418891907,
-0.3877718150615692,
0.8333349823951721,
0.8359612226486206,
0.2430562973022461,
0.2522950768470764,
0.34884098172187805,
1.061990737915039,
-0.3153547942638397,
-0.3058023750782013,
-0.7943239808082581,
0.2780885696411133,
-0.11732932925224304,
-0.3720620572566986,
0.729414165019989,
0.4835115969181061,
0.9931364059448242,
-0.032897889614105225,
0.6763182878494263,
0.2448049783706665,
0.4104565978050232,
-0.5983472466468811,
0.9788423776626587,
-0.303323894739151,
0.5014678239822388,
-0.3602968752384186,
-0.8148044943809509,
-0.6058009266853333,
0.35042986273765564,
-0.12000972032546997,
-0.12643404304981232,
0.25747358798980713,
1.012218952178955,
0.09839054942131042,
-0.03578449785709381,
0.3564472794532776,
0.33733782172203064,
0.09683293104171753,
0.1707785427570343,
0.7603389620780945,
-0.45547470450401306,
0.2939242124557495,
-0.7877418398857117,
-0.1761658936738968,
0.05913360416889191,
-0.8539441823959351,
-0.7421488761901855,
-0.3249729573726654,
-0.4391568601131439,
-0.34189850091934204,
0.4723898768424988,
0.6749630570411682,
0.7913584113121033,
-1.096066951751709,
-0.07658757269382477,
-0.387850821018219,
0.2906147837638855,
-0.5161787271499634,
-0.19924208521842957,
0.11190550774335861,
-0.8009325265884399,
-0.7775535583496094,
0.4392792284488678,
0.2604367434978485,
0.3339802026748657,
-0.09474775940179825,
0.11651396006345749,
-0.01633942313492298,
0.3118970990180969,
0.12091173976659775,
0.39392852783203125,
-0.45267269015312195,
-0.12869884073734283,
-0.21415287256240845,
0.1560685932636261,
0.04463443532586098,
0.702052116394043,
-0.7655794024467468,
0.504599392414093,
0.30221518874168396,
0.5699967741966248,
0.32886844873428345,
-0.0545446015894413,
0.592150092124939,
-0.811271071434021,
0.7169402241706848,
0.5298553109169006,
0.1690034121274948,
-0.02535243332386017,
-0.47225597500801086,
0.6454043984413147,
0.19240881502628326,
-0.7210326790809631,
-1.2978882789611816,
0.007434288505464792,
-0.6778953671455383,
-0.23237621784210205,
0.7034653425216675,
0.16500252485275269,
-0.18397797644138336,
-0.11298936605453491,
-0.13957959413528442,
0.14296886324882507,
-0.447172611951828,
1.165838599205017,
0.8944922685623169,
0.13821862637996674,
-0.2221371978521347,
-0.48215973377227783,
0.7320183515548706,
0.6063591837882996,
-0.32665112614631653,
-0.24996981024742126,
-0.037241287529468536,
0.0027390788309276104,
0.1116018071770668,
0.6158607602119446,
-0.2510014474391937,
-0.0739109069108963,
0.07975495606660843,
-0.15761816501617432,
0.13773293793201447,
-0.5032210946083069,
-0.37940454483032227,
0.10666545480489731,
0.023309722542762756,
-0.06890808790922165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12468v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12468v1
|
Adaptive Token Biaser: Knowledge Editing via Biasing Key Entities
| 2024-06-18T10:18:06 | 2024-06-18T10:18:06 |
Baolong Bi, Shenghua Liu, Yiwei Wang, Lingrui Mei, Hongcheng Gao, Yilong Xu, Xueqi Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The parametric knowledge memorized by large language models (LLMs) becomes
outdated quickly. In-context editing (ICE) is currently the most effective
method for updating the knowledge of LLMs. Recent advancements involve
enhancing ICE by modifying the decoding strategy, obviating the need for
altering internal model structures or adjusting external prompts. However, this
enhancement operates across the entire sequence generation, encompassing a
plethora of non-critical tokens. In this work, we introduce $\textbf{A}$daptive
$\textbf{T}$oken $\textbf{Bias}$er ($\textbf{ATBias}$), a new decoding
technique designed to enhance ICE. It focuses on the tokens that are mostly
related to knowledge during decoding, biasing their logits by matching key
entities related to new and parametric knowledge. Experimental results show
that ATBias significantly enhances ICE performance, achieving up to a 32.3%
improvement over state-of-the-art ICE methods while incurring only half the
latency. ATBias not only improves the knowledge editing capabilities of ICE but
can also be widely applied to LLMs with negligible cost.
|
[
-0.1986972540616989,
-0.6372849941253662,
0.3842022716999054,
0.04481697082519531,
-0.3511379361152649,
0.4185490310192108,
-0.25735846161842346,
-0.2575191557407379,
0.393953412771225,
0.4594895541667938,
-0.10546016693115234,
-0.6663700342178345,
-0.6247488260269165,
0.04531776160001755,
-0.31009891629219055,
0.960192859172821,
-0.206197589635849,
0.2846556305885315,
-0.10699273645877838,
-0.4172567129135132,
-0.5721203684806824,
-0.37314099073410034,
-0.9500628709793091,
-0.1254855841398239,
0.025572309270501137,
0.45559054613113403,
0.7229928374290466,
0.9058361053466797,
0.1340879201889038,
0.22971144318580627,
-0.542709231376648,
0.3750287890434265,
-0.18818864226341248,
0.23295818269252777,
-0.32364746928215027,
-0.6214628219604492,
-0.8429067730903625,
-0.4412214159965515,
0.7588846683502197,
0.3948020935058594,
-0.036057550460100174,
0.1902390718460083,
-0.08449088037014008,
0.6805597543716431,
-0.7984412908554077,
0.03593391552567482,
-0.9596875309944153,
-0.08672891557216644,
-0.3874119818210602,
-0.14309246838092804,
-0.45326271653175354,
-0.18548361957073212,
0.07814591377973557,
-0.805308997631073,
0.10458255559206009,
0.2977813184261322,
0.45355480909347534,
0.4654201567173004,
-0.1767115443944931,
-0.3655489385128021,
-0.22318705916404724,
0.7856819033622742,
-0.7914695739746094,
0.6225265860557556,
0.2510901093482971,
-0.11053875088691711,
-0.32798904180526733,
-0.560829222202301,
-0.49791765213012695,
0.23449331521987915,
0.10390494018793106,
-0.23160092532634735,
-0.30801600217819214,
0.25447097420692444,
0.2712363302707672,
0.09545417875051498,
0.27265074849128723,
-0.05357643589377403,
-0.13219408690929413,
-0.4663797616958618,
0.24025152623653412,
0.14126792550086975,
0.3641824722290039,
-0.2940968871116638,
-0.0931190699338913,
0.07361886650323868,
-0.7213196754455566,
-0.07875024527311325,
0.1963415890932083,
-0.04442944750189781,
0.013543598353862762,
0.3891051113605499,
-0.053709473460912704,
0.7821832299232483,
0.5047615170478821,
-0.23683227598667145,
0.2941003739833832,
-0.06818998605012894,
-0.27480223774909973,
0.23208121955394745,
0.45330899953842163,
0.5907779932022095,
-0.03152718022465706,
-0.34133708477020264,
-0.3586352467536926,
-0.31046611070632935,
0.03835069015622139,
-0.5433575510978699,
-0.22949236631393433,
0.04576712101697922,
-0.6237386465072632,
-0.3739655315876007,
-0.10083714872598648,
-1.02446448802948,
-0.5922888517379761,
-0.1504480242729187,
0.1265709549188614,
-0.5813710689544678,
0.050971776247024536,
0.13360406458377838,
-0.36326685547828674,
-0.1390312910079956,
0.3411264419555664,
-0.6440271139144897,
0.2980830669403076,
0.41456180810928345,
0.9640985131263733,
-0.10929402709007263,
-0.21340134739875793,
-0.7365591526031494,
0.390800416469574,
-0.4177708923816681,
0.8403609991073608,
-0.8387449979782104,
-0.3652041256427765,
-0.011971456930041313,
-0.5262108445167542,
0.12876206636428833,
-0.596195638179779,
0.648301899433136,
-1.0766820907592773,
-0.08683831244707108,
-0.6325458288192749,
-0.6561148762702942,
-0.007269812747836113,
0.01113002747297287,
-0.6354650855064392,
0.8605327606201172,
-0.03289332985877991,
-0.9493424892425537,
0.8590473532676697,
-1.1386126279830933,
-0.5212492942810059,
-0.25964754819869995,
-0.022109346464276314,
-0.26605668663978577,
0.26232385635375977,
0.8386292457580566,
0.12795116007328033,
-0.25204890966415405,
0.2401074469089508,
-0.27648791670799255,
-0.2766507565975189,
0.3841702938079834,
-0.4027174711227417,
0.7148801684379578,
0.28205814957618713,
-0.4349616467952728,
0.3572792112827301,
-1.003499984741211,
-0.22328105568885803,
-0.3806130588054657,
-0.5478838086128235,
-0.4990096688270569,
0.22548392415046692,
-0.11948864161968231,
-0.0722590759396553,
-0.012505998834967613,
-0.5033782124519348,
0.21900933980941772,
-0.28168779611587524,
0.6969577670097351,
1.134010672569275,
0.21218159794807434,
0.9009405970573425,
-0.19864733517169952,
0.4256574511528015,
0.3195803463459015,
0.0369904488325119,
-0.19212931394577026,
-0.2009870409965515,
-1.034389615058899,
-0.6403719782829285,
0.48373985290527344,
0.49492403864860535,
-1.1323227882385254,
0.23836475610733032,
-0.2987968325614929,
-0.1312713623046875,
-0.9033234119415283,
0.34461215138435364,
0.33704063296318054,
0.6803914308547974,
0.5788580775260925,
-0.2827644944190979,
-0.7665673494338989,
-0.6172691583633423,
-0.655681848526001,
-0.16397282481193542,
-0.1732117235660553,
0.3681223690509796,
0.11483268439769745,
-0.19097775220870972,
1.1727968454360962,
-0.4601899981498718,
-0.38192522525787354,
0.012161367572844028,
-0.0375581793487072,
0.02114861086010933,
0.44539961218833923,
0.7027878165245056,
-0.3309396207332611,
-0.5612611174583435,
-0.3564341962337494,
-0.7480573654174805,
-0.32540106773376465,
0.0009183714282698929,
-0.3580811321735382,
0.34587281942367554,
0.936740517616272,
-0.45147058367729187,
0.33563855290412903,
0.1557486355304718,
-0.5876061916351318,
0.1459207385778427,
-0.1099732369184494,
0.2121678739786148,
-1.0607292652130127,
-0.1299375742673874,
-0.22017431259155273,
-0.20856113731861115,
-0.7316251397132874,
-0.09509984403848648,
0.25243550539016724,
0.08037138730287552,
-0.5564962029457092,
0.6290786266326904,
-0.7820300459861755,
0.2299608737230301,
-0.32199937105178833,
0.003393725259229541,
-0.06910666823387146,
0.27925625443458557,
-0.06794320791959763,
0.8596016764640808,
0.8787904977798462,
-0.6180821061134338,
0.14784224331378937,
0.4261382520198822,
-0.4513564705848694,
0.6625680923461914,
-0.31478843092918396,
0.5374782681465149,
-0.4574246108531952,
0.5467581748962402,
-0.38926512002944946,
-0.10955283045768738,
0.441414475440979,
-0.27926671504974365,
0.41575515270233154,
-0.15058650076389313,
-0.3871017396450043,
-0.04372696951031685,
-0.5612883567810059,
0.7488691210746765,
0.2590111494064331,
-0.7360453009605408,
1.048638939857483,
0.46964332461357117,
0.1088307574391365,
-0.9215078353881836,
-0.5895240306854248,
0.47599729895591736,
-0.39553678035736084,
-0.527357280254364,
0.45665639638900757,
0.042915139347314835,
-0.6025500297546387,
0.14308157563209534,
-0.16586802899837494,
0.04410145804286003,
-0.1917729377746582,
-0.1260576844215393,
0.38737624883651733,
-0.173320472240448,
0.06749264895915985,
0.3981478214263916,
-0.0471205972135067,
0.010710985399782658,
-0.7924337983131409,
0.23738634586334229,
0.20615297555923462,
-0.12092596292495728,
-0.4128466844558716,
0.07980851083993912,
0.8791440725326538,
-0.1483442187309265,
0.869897723197937,
0.3712683618068695,
-0.5275964736938477,
-0.05868101492524147,
-0.9293325543403625,
-0.08957357704639435,
-0.4760565757751465,
0.46751970052719116,
-0.4748240113258362,
-0.7698931097984314,
0.8449211120605469,
0.29497790336608887,
0.12527813017368317,
0.22323766350746155,
0.3547229766845703,
0.2388404756784439,
0.7976251244544983,
0.4587310254573822,
-0.7427883148193359,
0.8322487473487854,
0.20181258022785187,
0.1346375197172165,
-1.1559562683105469,
-0.06799706816673279,
-0.3157038986682892,
-0.31349286437034607,
-0.2793842852115631,
-0.6612938642501831,
0.4084942638874054,
0.09055852144956589,
-0.16330108046531677,
-0.009536602534353733,
-0.17340807616710663,
0.6961183547973633,
0.4891226589679718,
0.41428300738334656,
0.24833333492279053,
-0.06153568997979164,
-0.08911052346229553,
-0.010266228578984737,
-0.9120777249336243,
-0.3992757201194763,
1.5854909420013428,
0.5390878319740295,
0.9746787548065186,
0.05751310661435127,
0.38094326853752136,
0.5792842507362366,
0.4189903140068054,
-0.5325751900672913,
0.33343496918678284,
0.023212702944874763,
-0.6497718095779419,
-0.34075626730918884,
-0.19682665169239044,
-0.2341168224811554,
0.0890888199210167,
-0.37904495000839233,
-0.8006450533866882,
0.40081924200057983,
0.6687490940093994,
-0.4508190155029297,
0.8336212038993835,
-0.6234902739524841,
0.3692111372947693,
0.20384465157985687,
-0.5407930016517639,
-0.2516498863697052,
-0.5778918862342834,
0.055661607533693314,
-0.16442957520484924,
0.38817548751831055,
0.23562410473823547,
-0.2546100616455078,
1.042746663093567,
-0.2794675827026367,
0.722381591796875,
-0.5523909330368042,
0.08458614349365234,
0.42969954013824463,
0.16962648928165436,
0.7945326566696167,
0.49584412574768066,
-0.48502403497695923,
0.1813865602016449,
-0.4154963791370392,
-0.4730290174484253,
-0.6319240927696228,
0.6120399236679077,
-0.6461461782455444,
-0.7336938977241516,
-0.22247572243213654,
-0.7748520970344543,
-0.3063786029815674,
0.2086527794599533,
0.2901414930820465,
0.46177130937576294,
-0.11051634699106216,
0.003966083750128746,
0.812938928604126,
-0.24617567658424377,
0.3078535199165344,
0.4217435121536255,
0.1584317535161972,
-0.6535208225250244,
0.6417443752288818,
-0.07631270587444305,
0.2092990130186081,
0.48719102144241333,
-0.03522628918290138,
-0.176763653755188,
-0.8331685662269592,
-0.752408504486084,
0.025634972378611565,
-1.0992695093154907,
-0.5284152626991272,
-0.8508830070495605,
0.14972881972789764,
-0.5053927898406982,
-0.4018550217151642,
-0.25172677636146545,
-0.36130112409591675,
-0.4058384597301483,
-0.2153526395559311,
0.47652867436408997,
0.6960852742195129,
-0.22535844147205353,
0.28898924589157104,
-0.6817395091056824,
0.2488185614347458,
0.03501322120428085,
0.49984580278396606,
0.16033120453357697,
-0.7488464117050171,
-0.34194502234458923,
-0.08647394180297852,
-0.09986747056245804,
-1.0244717597961426,
0.025864634662866592,
0.22605547308921814,
0.5198330879211426,
0.4507421851158142,
0.10093317180871964,
0.8093032836914062,
-0.5477389693260193,
0.7045105695724487,
-0.08429303765296936,
-1.5494035482406616,
0.28607654571533203,
-0.21453341841697693,
0.3440663814544678,
0.5642613172531128,
-0.22480858862400055,
-0.544511616230011,
-0.5614326000213623,
-0.36076050996780396,
-0.9213585257530212,
1.0390465259552002,
0.010340949520468712,
0.21301470696926117,
-0.1295223832130432,
0.7390512824058533,
-0.0597374252974987,
0.4030342996120453,
-0.4602019488811493,
-0.32524368166923523,
-0.3922289311885834,
-0.33220013976097107,
0.12377352267503738,
-0.6483123302459717,
-0.08670352399349213,
-0.30958324670791626,
0.9631189703941345,
-0.15469084680080414,
0.36912426352500916,
0.25937020778656006,
-0.403976708650589,
-0.3690072000026703,
0.2809130847454071,
0.5787889957427979,
0.774617612361908,
-0.16868352890014648,
0.1828232854604721,
0.9914718866348267,
-0.4871232509613037,
-0.01503145880997181,
-0.30217549204826355,
-0.5414029359817505,
-0.026483982801437378,
0.38289815187454224,
1.1839252710342407,
0.23587778210639954,
-0.44440463185310364,
0.26703548431396484,
0.01040632650256157,
-0.04320153221487999,
0.043407827615737915,
0.008271826431155205,
-0.36900073289871216,
0.27696067094802856,
0.355537086725235,
0.5101181864738464,
0.19458836317062378,
-0.34050673246383667,
0.17239807546138763,
0.2726496458053589,
-0.4148833751678467,
-0.32154127955436707,
0.8403725028038025,
0.3288049101829529,
-0.3159940838813782,
0.6143878102302551,
-0.029758790507912636,
-0.8033040761947632,
0.14901377260684967,
0.554445207118988,
0.8479215502738953,
-0.1888452023267746,
-0.2209983766078949,
0.21082007884979248,
0.22126974165439606,
0.12355118989944458,
-0.05881652981042862,
-0.05058900639414787,
-0.9120337963104248,
-0.2140444666147232,
-0.4640372097492218,
-0.1415122002363205,
0.1356833279132843,
-0.5645349025726318,
0.5242103934288025,
-0.45861223340034485,
-0.14017294347286224,
-0.28382742404937744,
-0.6185735464096069,
-0.5285842418670654,
0.23234431445598602,
-0.1866295337677002,
1.242079734802246,
-0.6779910922050476,
0.8076165914535522,
0.9162151217460632,
0.09048254042863846,
-0.4919954240322113,
0.4396703541278839,
0.16018152236938477,
-0.7281749248504639,
0.3568483889102936,
-0.3820168077945709,
-0.0588383749127388,
-0.0227828212082386,
-0.22321045398712158,
-1.053597092628479,
0.8653059601783752,
0.6071730256080627,
-0.2071058303117752,
-0.31252560019493103,
-0.14955967664718628,
0.320387601852417,
-0.43335652351379395,
0.28016898036003113,
0.7910435199737549,
0.47147196531295776,
-0.09567151218652725,
-0.7316656708717346,
0.22727380692958832,
-0.11884519457817078,
0.06864206492900848,
0.13059747219085693,
-0.547598659992218,
0.5261316895484924,
-0.15995098650455475,
0.03795616328716278,
-0.22510670125484467,
1.031152606010437,
-0.03423057124018669,
0.05635127052664757,
0.7649504542350769,
0.34216827154159546,
0.821594774723053,
0.183756023645401,
0.5957611203193665,
-0.6181937456130981,
-0.08722659945487976,
1.0940163135528564,
0.11009373515844345,
0.5347590446472168,
0.8536855578422546,
0.167358860373497,
0.4999157190322876,
0.3883213698863983,
0.3470587134361267,
0.7055810689926147,
0.15967819094657898,
-0.3628184199333191,
-0.08073048293590546,
0.004073518328368664,
-0.13378269970417023,
0.29109612107276917,
0.3007623851299286,
-0.46459171175956726,
0.11193040013313293,
0.20980417728424072,
0.42163750529289246,
0.16673141717910767,
-0.508658766746521,
0.811664342880249,
-0.11223800480365753,
-0.7937600612640381,
0.2927984893321991,
0.3626861572265625,
0.8466558456420898,
-0.31938913464546204,
0.20008280873298645,
-0.12377817928791046,
0.2960018515586853,
-0.26981592178344727,
-0.4489823281764984,
0.3749161958694458,
0.29182618856430054,
-0.32700449228286743,
-0.1043597087264061,
0.8744029998779297,
-0.271369069814682,
-0.38667288422584534,
0.31256937980651855,
0.18044616281986237,
-0.3786253035068512,
-0.00997560378164053,
-0.514207124710083,
0.32379114627838135,
0.19814294576644897,
-0.2834532558917999,
0.003831590060144663,
0.38988184928894043,
-0.1655324399471283,
0.6881694793701172,
0.40686914324760437,
0.1722116768360138,
0.22217151522636414,
0.010057413950562477,
1.1319295167922974,
-0.41274017095565796,
-0.5674688220024109,
-0.9523168206214905,
0.505088210105896,
-0.07800619304180145,
-0.23842673003673553,
0.5667641758918762,
0.5219160318374634,
0.9045087695121765,
-0.0693025067448616,
0.9941039085388184,
-0.12423461675643921,
0.35383370518684387,
-0.8702345490455627,
0.7012906670570374,
-0.33171841502189636,
0.4379819333553314,
-0.5305452346801758,
-0.92094886302948,
-0.32179099321365356,
0.4823957085609436,
-0.2437019795179367,
-0.16597868502140045,
0.6531675457954407,
0.7241281867027283,
-0.011529235169291496,
-0.02731250412762165,
-0.0654335469007492,
0.3002418279647827,
0.46311333775520325,
0.26448383927345276,
0.47772738337516785,
-0.5027855634689331,
0.40276196599006653,
-0.0768018364906311,
-0.4882868528366089,
0.03264279663562775,
-0.7807475924491882,
-1.161220669746399,
-0.4260275065898895,
-0.14465227723121643,
-0.5425273776054382,
0.48265916109085083,
1.298653483390808,
0.5547887682914734,
-1.0043249130249023,
-0.1341526061296463,
-0.028512265533208847,
0.27225905656814575,
-0.09119366109371185,
-0.14797477424144745,
0.5286068320274353,
-0.477740615606308,
-0.8163008689880371,
0.4785386025905609,
0.09349307417869568,
-0.034704696387052536,
0.16533924639225006,
-0.22891280055046082,
0.056464605033397675,
0.37523728609085083,
0.41590848565101624,
-0.024177128449082375,
-0.6071645617485046,
-0.5305095911026001,
0.11940555274486542,
0.3083188533782959,
0.18562933802604675,
0.9751787781715393,
-0.6554127335548401,
0.6808672547340393,
0.3987574279308319,
0.6106409430503845,
0.3106521666049957,
-0.0771675854921341,
0.8435267806053162,
-0.5816137790679932,
0.26248985528945923,
0.04043307900428772,
0.5463550090789795,
0.33257532119750977,
-0.5055714249610901,
0.08624053746461868,
0.22506766021251678,
-0.3669876456260681,
-0.8364660739898682,
0.029804833233356476,
-0.6045002341270447,
-0.04830567538738251,
1.1372374296188354,
-0.07837437093257904,
-0.2748804986476898,
-0.1869867891073227,
-0.43699437379837036,
0.5537024736404419,
-0.8933807015419006,
1.1005046367645264,
0.9312922358512878,
0.09520310163497925,
0.10546030849218369,
-0.06976372003555298,
0.7960518598556519,
0.5901362895965576,
-0.5412008762359619,
0.15490789711475372,
0.4568546712398529,
0.4338655173778534,
-0.04845771938562393,
0.7135237455368042,
-0.17899686098098755,
0.2975460886955261,
-0.13607585430145264,
-0.021435104310512543,
-0.15698060393333435,
-0.3536215126514435,
-0.3152201175689697,
-0.03972022607922554,
0.5005340576171875,
-0.12965816259384155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12442v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12442v1
|
Abstraction-of-Thought Makes Language Models Better Reasoners
| 2024-06-18T09:46:44 | 2024-06-18T09:46:44 |
Ruixin Hong, Hongming Zhang, Xiaoman Pan, Dong Yu, Changshui Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Abstract reasoning, the ability to reason from the abstract essence of a
problem, serves as a key to generalization in human reasoning. However,
eliciting language models to perform reasoning with abstraction remains
unexplored. This paper seeks to bridge this gap by introducing a novel
structured reasoning format called Abstraction-of-Thought (AoT). The uniqueness
of AoT lies in its explicit requirement for varying levels of abstraction
within the reasoning process. This approach could elicit language models to
first contemplate on the abstract level before incorporating concrete details,
which is overlooked by the prevailing step-by-step Chain-of-Thought (CoT)
method. To align models with the AoT format, we present AoT Collection, a
generic finetuning dataset consisting of 348k high-quality samples with AoT
reasoning processes, collected via an automated and scalable pipeline. We
finetune a wide range of language models with AoT Collection and conduct
extensive evaluations on 23 unseen tasks from the challenging benchmark
Big-Bench Hard. Experimental results indicate that models aligned to AoT
reasoning format substantially outperform those aligned to CoT in many
reasoning tasks.
|
[
-0.48813238739967346,
-0.8103282451629639,
0.8565921187400818,
-0.13757619261741638,
-0.18842187523841858,
-0.04566032066941261,
-0.009699507616460323,
-0.5481784343719482,
-0.41619613766670227,
0.3228766918182373,
-0.4249129295349121,
-0.42805373668670654,
-0.637943685054779,
-0.07702460885047913,
-0.569227397441864,
0.8804633617401123,
-0.3518245220184326,
-0.4033041298389435,
0.09068583697080612,
-0.11670064181089401,
-0.34969624876976013,
-0.262009859085083,
-0.8386649489402771,
-0.6221571564674377,
0.20417721569538116,
0.03370785340666771,
0.7045173645019531,
0.7961126565933228,
0.3451862931251526,
0.29582569003105164,
0.03678291663527489,
0.29459667205810547,
-0.26153215765953064,
-0.009146533906459808,
-0.4315626621246338,
-0.3043029308319092,
-0.7600961327552795,
0.06033074110746384,
0.2822642922401428,
0.974984884262085,
-0.18861959874629974,
0.011617656797170639,
-0.05791568011045456,
0.8150140047073364,
-0.8473727107048035,
0.37037599086761475,
-0.5917622447013855,
-0.12092670798301697,
0.13633538782596588,
0.20040284097194672,
-0.4808605909347534,
-0.11558221280574799,
0.17094336450099945,
-0.587593138217926,
-0.18805404007434845,
0.034505654126405716,
0.5976089239120483,
0.3034871220588684,
-0.11744402348995209,
-0.21084964275360107,
-0.9698965549468994,
0.6312592625617981,
-0.5349513292312622,
0.4117308259010315,
0.44911912083625793,
0.22809390723705292,
0.13075780868530273,
-0.6894355416297913,
-0.5182093381881714,
-0.10245873779058456,
-0.044604577124118805,
-0.030891016125679016,
-0.4414835274219513,
0.16155658662319183,
0.19415254890918732,
0.4676823019981384,
-0.4011003077030182,
-0.1360706388950348,
-0.2966122329235077,
0.10487285256385803,
0.4999271035194397,
0.12608623504638672,
0.21892032027244568,
0.04334580898284912,
-0.3830011785030365,
0.12714871764183044,
-0.5367968082427979,
-0.09223531186580658,
-0.0002083931613015011,
0.1758447140455246,
-0.13548067212104797,
0.35350945591926575,
-0.4773372411727905,
0.8620446920394897,
0.16015784442424774,
0.38846448063850403,
-0.10184589773416519,
-0.26593220233917236,
-0.39368075132369995,
-0.07090281695127487,
0.660559356212616,
0.07643575966358185,
0.4636251628398895,
-0.1465371549129486,
-0.4930306077003479,
0.18005910515785217,
0.22928954660892487,
-0.6621444821357727,
-0.636639416217804,
0.6197713613510132,
-0.30323150753974915,
-0.09649816155433655,
-0.033238962292671204,
-0.056514304131269455,
-0.15820631384849548,
-0.7267865538597107,
0.30480071902275085,
-0.6331002116203308,
-0.3981916010379791,
0.48489418625831604,
-0.01249073725193739,
0.005782640539109707,
0.5683051943778992,
-0.7331689596176147,
0.5669096112251282,
0.8647924661636353,
0.633590817451477,
-0.3237711787223816,
0.010999432764947414,
-0.18868638575077057,
-0.014623712748289108,
-0.4995984137058258,
1.2631398439407349,
-0.6424121856689453,
0.043063919991254807,
-0.47314074635505676,
-0.52934730052948,
0.03721287101507187,
-0.434463232755661,
0.4363378584384918,
-0.26401305198669434,
0.021254410967230797,
0.003063343232497573,
-0.5083703398704529,
-0.06880474835634232,
0.6459713578224182,
-0.6808906197547913,
0.8958446383476257,
0.20402519404888153,
-0.5284923315048218,
0.11741021275520325,
-0.8329533934593201,
-0.15228083729743958,
0.10631619393825531,
-0.550412118434906,
0.03285204619169235,
0.18382766842842102,
0.3628944754600525,
0.2511633336544037,
-0.4100344181060791,
0.2810826301574707,
0.019440392032265663,
-0.22609269618988037,
0.10482723265886307,
-0.504891037940979,
0.7426972985267639,
0.5696786046028137,
-0.3656446039676666,
0.04843780770897865,
-0.7831801176071167,
0.3041278123855591,
0.10745294392108917,
-0.19430576264858246,
-0.4512697756290436,
-0.0994282141327858,
-0.23101089894771576,
0.5092763304710388,
-0.051453255116939545,
-0.49351897835731506,
0.20490418374538422,
-0.5593670606613159,
0.6412378549575806,
0.7095023393630981,
-0.12915177643299103,
0.5085911154747009,
-0.3915709853172302,
0.46151021122932434,
0.1155204027891159,
-0.13475419580936432,
-0.2940821945667267,
-0.14225102961063385,
-0.6211315989494324,
-0.29151883721351624,
0.25639528036117554,
0.3787229359149933,
-0.35750311613082886,
0.22090788185596466,
-0.17681939899921417,
-0.5763913989067078,
-0.6604207754135132,
-0.23818619549274445,
0.6182231903076172,
0.3985537886619568,
0.35822609066963196,
0.013838998042047024,
-0.3959696292877197,
-0.8409140706062317,
-0.41162532567977905,
-0.15468885004520416,
-0.05601363629102707,
0.1561131775379181,
0.46316394209861755,
0.06077713519334793,
0.8644497394561768,
-0.5026990175247192,
0.09548978507518768,
-0.25086256861686707,
0.36921507120132446,
-0.044435758143663406,
0.5554627180099487,
0.06944340467453003,
-0.6197030544281006,
-0.18133527040481567,
0.16373707354068756,
-0.6620493531227112,
0.09323950111865997,
-0.016767635941505432,
-0.43532606959342957,
0.04998856037855148,
0.5697066783905029,
-0.7168952822685242,
0.3587821125984192,
0.17218676209449768,
-0.247340589761734,
0.5775986313819885,
-0.08595778793096542,
-0.02113719843327999,
-0.7911754250526428,
0.16764183342456818,
-0.22121413052082062,
-0.27129489183425903,
-0.3529684245586395,
0.2854616343975067,
-0.08819286525249481,
-0.14627332985401154,
-0.4688165485858917,
0.7397996187210083,
-0.6181369423866272,
0.20342233777046204,
-0.35186585783958435,
0.17276950180530548,
0.23175132274627686,
0.5524584650993347,
0.28770020604133606,
0.4089137613773346,
0.5880168676376343,
-0.7220538258552551,
0.16434836387634277,
0.21530400216579437,
-0.5572875738143921,
0.4659854769706726,
-0.697955310344696,
0.43800872564315796,
-0.283987820148468,
0.28728142380714417,
-0.9103098511695862,
-0.04715901240706444,
0.056882765144109726,
-0.0879870057106018,
0.011262276209890842,
-0.13270257413387299,
-0.3477538824081421,
-0.11167362332344055,
0.09057626128196716,
0.8105653524398804,
0.39264896512031555,
-0.19307972490787506,
0.7048389315605164,
0.4136672914028168,
-0.3399200141429901,
-0.5635828375816345,
-0.5977468490600586,
-0.3080890476703644,
-0.0803624764084816,
-0.32848331332206726,
0.33893218636512756,
0.15693190693855286,
-0.6487478017807007,
-0.006589004769921303,
-0.5729745030403137,
-0.09582772105932236,
-0.006889993324875832,
0.02329855039715767,
0.12923790514469147,
-0.395683228969574,
0.2172219604253769,
0.019978933036327362,
-0.30411359667778015,
0.198857843875885,
-0.6109416484832764,
0.5649994015693665,
-0.4282768964767456,
-0.49475574493408203,
-0.2907695770263672,
0.4461902379989624,
0.44365811347961426,
-0.44854262471199036,
0.356010764837265,
0.049796223640441895,
-0.5643382668495178,
-0.2640027701854706,
-0.33473193645477295,
-0.11768918484449387,
-0.37520524859428406,
0.27704909443855286,
-0.6210525631904602,
-0.4708285331726074,
0.3602379262447357,
-0.2799432873725891,
0.43210139870643616,
0.27102649211883545,
0.26615506410598755,
-0.12462199479341507,
1.2233082056045532,
0.3569817841053009,
0.2162151038646698,
0.2942354679107666,
-0.49171724915504456,
0.27277523279190063,
-0.7999110221862793,
-0.07851120829582214,
-0.45069336891174316,
-0.41077208518981934,
-0.24834778904914856,
-0.3835911750793457,
0.06376279890537262,
0.1694430112838745,
-0.48391082882881165,
0.17624951899051666,
-0.626363217830658,
0.8300605416297913,
0.02247011847794056,
0.15058624744415283,
0.5894788503646851,
-0.12942425906658173,
-0.13578686118125916,
0.48495256900787354,
-0.5564380884170532,
-0.8570317625999451,
0.8444453477859497,
0.19572027027606964,
0.7018486261367798,
-0.057859137654304504,
0.6355969905853271,
0.00255905045196414,
0.37171411514282227,
-0.7779404520988464,
0.557364821434021,
-0.12523294985294342,
-0.6273696422576904,
-0.34627819061279297,
-0.12819544970989227,
-0.9802679419517517,
0.434061735868454,
0.13691599667072296,
-0.7980203032493591,
0.20476078987121582,
0.42745670676231384,
-0.5826237797737122,
0.2640927731990814,
-0.4551297128200531,
0.8419659733772278,
0.049907319247722626,
-0.15750183165073395,
-0.17742548882961273,
-0.5338798761367798,
0.461819052696228,
0.03510095924139023,
0.5241864919662476,
-0.25697600841522217,
0.08283857256174088,
0.4910658299922943,
-0.6268085837364197,
0.48183223605155945,
0.11732650548219681,
-0.36951419711112976,
0.5863996744155884,
0.4475165009498596,
0.6487911343574524,
-0.3197605311870575,
-0.22350357472896576,
-0.07158149778842926,
-0.15165573358535767,
-0.3293860852718353,
-0.7555311918258667,
0.5593308210372925,
-0.35764187574386597,
-0.6534273624420166,
-0.28065893054008484,
-0.8122694492340088,
-0.27133384346961975,
0.25385522842407227,
0.28250813484191895,
0.5457802414894104,
-0.11160624772310257,
-0.10556859523057938,
0.6229263544082642,
0.4872290790081024,
0.26472994685173035,
0.23191796243190765,
-0.2307056486606598,
0.18475286662578583,
0.5593032240867615,
-0.07991212606430054,
0.6938572525978088,
0.4257248342037201,
0.16791695356369019,
-0.2624925673007965,
-0.6878462433815002,
-0.2842673361301422,
-0.04862699285149574,
-0.9170451164245605,
-0.08894575387239456,
-0.9152857065200806,
-0.30407458543777466,
-0.11280813813209534,
-0.006869360338896513,
-0.6216923594474792,
-0.741082489490509,
0.37843161821365356,
-0.2991863489151001,
0.1912832111120224,
0.6059778332710266,
0.16677415370941162,
0.04415057599544525,
-0.5494303703308105,
0.503354012966156,
0.22960926592350006,
0.41930580139160156,
0.24199526011943817,
-0.35174664855003357,
-0.03594134375452995,
0.24373792111873627,
-0.4707557260990143,
-0.4377535283565521,
0.057490479201078415,
0.06958921253681183,
0.4069799780845642,
0.28432804346084595,
0.125772163271904,
0.7916045784950256,
-0.6034314632415771,
0.4641422629356384,
-0.05196518078446388,
-0.8448672890663147,
0.7025312781333923,
-0.3369006812572479,
0.5757809281349182,
0.5576045513153076,
0.35788092017173767,
-0.21526595950126648,
-0.6316830515861511,
-0.7984791994094849,
-0.971244752407074,
0.628662645816803,
0.45794540643692017,
-0.10778789967298508,
-0.3331877887248993,
0.12046505510807037,
0.38217103481292725,
0.0015877294354140759,
-0.6712680459022522,
-0.10422229021787643,
-0.110438272356987,
-0.3103189766407013,
0.2455151528120041,
0.37616583704948425,
-0.01388977188616991,
-0.24703486263751984,
0.39987024664878845,
-0.018341124057769775,
0.23855413496494293,
0.12507648766040802,
-0.2108089029788971,
-0.057668931782245636,
0.5444508194923401,
0.25903773307800293,
0.8271108269691467,
-0.00003686846321215853,
0.41044846177101135,
-0.10767625272274017,
-0.30084919929504395,
0.16423648595809937,
0.0001533031463623047,
-0.08542514592409134,
-0.20563310384750366,
0.27631789445877075,
0.798237681388855,
0.16640563309192657,
-0.7874851822853088,
0.20234866440296173,
0.14971980452537537,
-0.22091631591320038,
-0.16470292210578918,
0.3378906548023224,
0.11735605448484421,
0.07234276086091995,
0.14897854626178741,
0.42562875151634216,
0.39405760169029236,
-0.6840347051620483,
0.045991308987140656,
0.3517872095108032,
-0.3984842002391815,
-0.1539173722267151,
0.6113219857215881,
0.14439110457897186,
-0.17932479083538055,
0.7629303932189941,
-0.023817045614123344,
-0.06083917245268822,
0.583922803401947,
0.6088581085205078,
0.82563716173172,
-0.049779973924160004,
-0.13672085106372833,
0.29119789600372314,
0.18317413330078125,
-0.3845665752887726,
0.4785003662109375,
-0.2831953465938568,
-0.7480096817016602,
-0.6173662543296814,
-0.5971764922142029,
-0.10724231600761414,
0.4565771520137787,
-0.5932616591453552,
0.17750431597232819,
-0.49524715542793274,
0.009810443967580795,
0.21984967589378357,
-0.44315144419670105,
-0.7075794339179993,
0.35252895951271057,
0.1702340841293335,
1.0493298768997192,
-0.8276167511940002,
0.5918248295783997,
0.7181047797203064,
-0.43398517370224,
-1.0616835355758667,
-0.0058386363089084625,
-0.20724782347679138,
-0.6098712682723999,
0.5551925301551819,
0.20961076021194458,
-0.49449753761291504,
0.3507874011993408,
-0.4306142032146454,
-0.716727077960968,
0.7653905749320984,
0.4984365999698639,
-0.5347650647163391,
-0.2525699734687805,
-0.07009663432836533,
0.35557639598846436,
-0.6257903575897217,
0.20544566214084625,
0.9004331827163696,
0.43618008494377136,
0.18853729963302612,
-0.8443742394447327,
0.19701501727104187,
-0.41651684045791626,
-0.1505833864212036,
0.4391731917858124,
-0.1964208036661148,
0.9992852210998535,
-0.35713911056518555,
-0.3972014784812927,
-0.0077935173176229,
0.4825950860977173,
0.7534139752388,
0.1453944593667984,
0.477957546710968,
0.6244246363639832,
0.7248948216438293,
-0.10803519934415817,
1.1716338396072388,
-0.01929684542119503,
-0.14673465490341187,
1.3840495347976685,
-0.05254099890589714,
0.9190942049026489,
0.25665903091430664,
-0.15224020183086395,
0.8526937365531921,
0.39212676882743835,
0.6078410744667053,
0.4977136254310608,
0.18954361975193024,
-0.15040801465511322,
-0.5444811582565308,
0.26658570766448975,
-0.2249687910079956,
0.5580212473869324,
0.48264357447624207,
-0.1898447573184967,
-0.33386483788490295,
-0.06641466915607452,
-0.09161116927862167,
0.37518009543418884,
-0.632486879825592,
0.8980705738067627,
0.27230069041252136,
-0.9345325231552124,
0.7582368850708008,
-0.20440036058425903,
0.2949536144733429,
-0.2574506998062134,
-0.28293582797050476,
-0.12243315577507019,
0.26359444856643677,
-0.18302179872989655,
-0.8919157385826111,
0.4208553433418274,
0.06933166831731796,
-0.2079673707485199,
-0.4052392542362213,
0.5383728742599487,
-0.33306920528411865,
-0.4226216971874237,
-0.19095221161842346,
0.7510247230529785,
0.4921574890613556,
-0.3676433563232422,
-0.6682296395301819,
-0.1202264353632927,
-0.3875865638256073,
-0.24438968300819397,
0.12674149870872498,
0.8357918858528137,
-0.47716403007507324,
0.7310421466827393,
0.41723835468292236,
0.016485080122947693,
-0.2649301290512085,
0.11614461243152618,
0.8260877132415771,
-0.5831745266914368,
-0.7031906247138977,
-1.090335726737976,
0.8568978309631348,
0.08532032370567322,
-0.1678575873374939,
0.18034523725509644,
0.6023231148719788,
0.7507840991020203,
-0.05110950395464897,
0.855852484703064,
-0.009711232036352158,
0.27643927931785583,
-0.5767726302146912,
0.6613858938217163,
-0.2609284818172455,
0.2985326647758484,
-0.3329140245914459,
-0.7251946926116943,
-0.07038497179746628,
0.9128831028938293,
-0.4276232123374939,
0.2504902780056,
0.9815413951873779,
0.26484212279319763,
-0.5060411095619202,
0.22861348092556,
0.09295933693647385,
0.1901765912771225,
0.21113382279872894,
0.8131481409072876,
0.9319171905517578,
-0.47350189089775085,
0.36050945520401,
-0.0024812996853142977,
-0.23223847150802612,
0.2162502259016037,
-1.0810860395431519,
-0.6005171537399292,
-0.5676732063293457,
-0.484770268201828,
-0.03507983312010765,
-0.018632343038916588,
1.0312789678573608,
0.6877410411834717,
-0.7683503031730652,
-0.0830475464463234,
-0.7806313037872314,
-0.03537111356854439,
-0.6844465732574463,
-0.16598059237003326,
0.47376710176467896,
-0.30514323711395264,
-0.695600152015686,
0.20969508588314056,
0.2673545777797699,
0.022153731435537338,
-0.05800367519259453,
0.03237888216972351,
-0.23865914344787598,
0.2930491268634796,
0.7132565379142761,
0.20990577340126038,
-0.9726142883300781,
-0.14997711777687073,
-0.19260835647583008,
-0.07463546842336655,
0.19795306026935577,
0.8154611587524414,
-1.0182894468307495,
0.28064611554145813,
0.3162164092063904,
0.36980336904525757,
0.31461772322654724,
0.2201004922389984,
0.724916398525238,
-0.7177894711494446,
0.22359974682331085,
0.48668184876441956,
0.3941367268562317,
0.07081935554742813,
-0.20221638679504395,
0.4831046164035797,
-0.3100886642932892,
-0.2781844735145569,
-0.802061140537262,
0.5165097117424011,
-0.811018168926239,
-0.5754220485687256,
0.9037060141563416,
-0.169149711728096,
-0.18244697153568268,
-0.44463178515434265,
-0.2993471920490265,
0.177493155002594,
-0.310148686170578,
0.937309205532074,
0.8593788146972656,
-0.5902774930000305,
-0.33191531896591187,
-0.289421021938324,
0.5632404088973999,
0.32735520601272583,
-1.0292223691940308,
0.5437222719192505,
0.49136707186698914,
0.131947323679924,
0.2252017706632614,
0.943829357624054,
-0.4407874345779419,
0.42357367277145386,
0.03632146120071411,
-0.18471229076385498,
-0.32661283016204834,
-0.32114264369010925,
-0.01574280858039856,
0.2515350878238678,
0.19433218240737915,
-0.010795554146170616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12430v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12430v1
|
PlanRAG: A Plan-then-Retrieval Augmented Generation for Generative Large Language Models as Decision Makers
| 2024-06-18T09:25:35 | 2024-06-18T09:25:35 |
Myeonghwa Lee, Seonho An, Min-Soo Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7
|
In this paper, we conduct a study to utilize LLMs as a solution for decision
making that requires complex data analysis. We define Decision QA as the task
of answering the best decision, $d_{best}$, for a decision-making question $Q$,
business rules $R$ and a database $D$. Since there is no benchmark that can
examine Decision QA, we propose Decision QA benchmark, DQA. It has two
scenarios, Locating and Building, constructed from two video games (Europa
Universalis IV and Victoria 3) that have almost the same goal as Decision QA.
To address Decision QA effectively, we also propose a new RAG technique called
the iterative plan-then-retrieval augmented generation (PlanRAG). Our
PlanRAG-based LM generates the plan for decision making as the first step, and
the retriever generates the queries for data analysis as the second step. The
proposed method outperforms the state-of-the-art iterative RAG method by 15.8%
in the Locating scenario and by 7.4% in the Building scenario, respectively. We
release our code and benchmark at https://github.com/myeon9h/PlanRAG.
|
[
-0.47079741954803467,
-0.8861491084098816,
0.5531617999076843,
0.3828793168067932,
-0.19127175211906433,
0.2306477278470993,
-0.13998869061470032,
-0.1538546234369278,
0.38216614723205566,
0.5969665050506592,
-0.45423585176467896,
-0.5872611999511719,
-0.07640591263771057,
-0.11127003282308578,
-0.3306299149990082,
0.7188754081726074,
-0.4120764434337616,
0.08280465751886368,
0.019205180928111076,
0.03838317468762398,
-0.6752841472625732,
-0.4065442383289337,
-1.2032546997070312,
-0.17834879457950592,
0.36805006861686707,
0.31014519929885864,
0.6457531452178955,
0.3252611458301544,
0.42997461557388306,
0.34741777181625366,
-0.11417093873023987,
0.41418740153312683,
-0.6177868843078613,
0.41307881474494934,
-0.10996358096599579,
-0.6976045966148376,
-0.6406135559082031,
-0.29467347264289856,
0.4118858873844147,
0.3675193786621094,
-0.4346514940261841,
0.47040948271751404,
-0.2607141435146332,
0.9761423468589783,
-0.8339253664016724,
0.16905780136585236,
-0.6640950441360474,
0.4166339635848999,
-0.32337814569473267,
-0.46494969725608826,
-0.37076374888420105,
-0.3333645761013031,
-0.23619063198566437,
-0.5891064405441284,
0.18359558284282684,
0.5185377597808838,
0.6055073142051697,
0.5237194895744324,
-0.20576053857803345,
-0.45455220341682434,
-0.9647142291069031,
0.5143522024154663,
-0.5758829712867737,
0.3271266222000122,
0.3151172995567322,
0.7324160933494568,
-0.60630202293396,
-0.8573296070098877,
-0.7956530451774597,
-0.014412141405045986,
0.21731474995613098,
0.2226255089044571,
-0.2650861144065857,
0.058168746531009674,
0.4807750880718231,
0.12364958226680756,
-0.5867823958396912,
0.1351862996816635,
-0.4609817862510681,
0.20872274041175842,
0.8367916345596313,
0.3677615821361542,
0.20109513401985168,
-0.3909837603569031,
-0.4226771891117096,
-0.11811195313930511,
-0.9266767501831055,
0.039585474878549576,
0.17271380126476288,
0.029183685779571533,
0.240054190158844,
0.9823223352432251,
-0.400774210691452,
0.6157445311546326,
0.039081551134586334,
-0.30255410075187683,
0.08849446475505829,
-0.09107444435358047,
-0.40797561407089233,
0.19783255457878113,
0.6733366250991821,
0.4184669852256775,
0.11820700764656067,
-0.1680162101984024,
-0.44557949900627136,
0.25123152136802673,
0.4335806369781494,
-0.8716716170310974,
-0.4145454168319702,
0.3520840108394623,
-0.48770684003829956,
-0.19466422498226166,
-0.3290495276451111,
-0.9596976637840271,
-0.32224759459495544,
-0.25275468826293945,
0.41003960371017456,
-0.11960914731025696,
-0.18913772702217102,
0.32121825218200684,
0.09378660470247269,
0.5295534133911133,
0.1758565455675125,
-0.5676180124282837,
0.27308130264282227,
0.603163480758667,
0.5904204845428467,
-0.42549920082092285,
-0.0769345685839653,
-0.7609028220176697,
0.28650355339050293,
-0.907975971698761,
1.2001607418060303,
-0.3299214243888855,
-0.5374666452407837,
0.006608164869248867,
-0.511031448841095,
0.03676280006766319,
-0.922753095626831,
1.071511149406433,
-0.8671069145202637,
0.2651686668395996,
-0.2178928554058075,
-0.5687819123268127,
-0.1422816514968872,
0.3535477817058563,
-0.7720270156860352,
1.0230507850646973,
-0.09421757608652115,
-0.6459496021270752,
0.5415235161781311,
-0.5202928781509399,
-0.2057611495256424,
0.300301194190979,
-0.5481494069099426,
-0.6381802558898926,
0.03004544787108898,
0.1153479665517807,
0.510799765586853,
-0.46212249994277954,
0.5057091116905212,
-0.2521360516548157,
-0.2366875559091568,
0.16491976380348206,
-0.22977899014949799,
0.5044113993644714,
0.22535747289657593,
-0.34675151109695435,
0.37488481402397156,
-0.57485032081604,
0.4992797076702118,
0.1702970266342163,
-0.724021852016449,
-0.0034698364324867725,
0.4285888969898224,
-0.07042377442121506,
0.3002606928348541,
0.021363431587815285,
-0.1565207988023758,
0.42106008529663086,
0.11460113525390625,
-0.10909901559352875,
0.5241198539733887,
-0.1541295200586319,
0.3190078139305115,
-0.49702733755111694,
0.8260601162910461,
-0.5146986842155457,
-0.06475076079368591,
0.37959328293800354,
-0.2643043100833893,
-0.8813914060592651,
-0.3202246427536011,
0.3621496558189392,
0.5226715207099915,
-1.1534065008163452,
0.14675545692443848,
-0.2393302172422409,
-0.4527117609977722,
-0.40446609258651733,
-0.2241026610136032,
0.418956458568573,
0.31318554282188416,
0.3783983886241913,
0.15225546061992645,
-0.8619856834411621,
-0.6916074752807617,
-0.2212948203086853,
-0.30467769503593445,
-0.10987871885299683,
0.1505374312400818,
0.23896707594394684,
-0.2968701422214508,
0.8825005292892456,
-0.6185886263847351,
-0.39873194694519043,
-0.5679207444190979,
-0.04918192699551582,
0.36550360918045044,
0.0637778714299202,
0.3945607542991638,
-1.0294877290725708,
-0.41118019819259644,
-0.2607611119747162,
-0.7367410063743591,
-0.16468064486980438,
-0.05342286452651024,
-0.33578258752822876,
0.20617793500423431,
0.5425377488136292,
-1.0314950942993164,
0.38238561153411865,
0.38635939359664917,
-0.4372046887874603,
0.9330660700798035,
-0.2501932680606842,
0.2170683890581131,
-1.2508472204208374,
0.11827190220355988,
-0.2600885331630707,
-0.12750831246376038,
-0.5972623229026794,
0.18095196783542633,
-0.05090383440256119,
-0.08622696250677109,
-0.1983477622270584,
0.6211047172546387,
-0.45834141969680786,
-0.4440276324748993,
-0.17680466175079346,
0.23208653926849365,
-0.11748658120632172,
0.46305349469184875,
-0.07363366335630417,
1.0917832851409912,
0.24806304275989532,
-0.9193683862686157,
0.3189134895801544,
0.47101643681526184,
-0.6476356387138367,
0.6019089818000793,
-0.6930869817733765,
-0.08523891121149063,
-0.3311169445514679,
0.367918461561203,
-0.7592638731002808,
-0.24984872341156006,
0.2874782085418701,
-0.3228120505809784,
0.3773232102394104,
-0.0023766930680722,
-0.5228541493415833,
-0.4525389075279236,
-0.29063037037849426,
0.26507362723350525,
0.42914295196533203,
-0.6448588371276855,
0.7909230589866638,
0.8411784172058105,
-0.2963874042034149,
-0.4697786271572113,
-0.13717155158519745,
0.08266603946685791,
-0.4816858470439911,
-0.5122859477996826,
0.8178675770759583,
-0.38396111130714417,
-0.6588090658187866,
-0.09194477647542953,
-0.14366263151168823,
-0.14187641441822052,
-0.11951275914907455,
0.1458769291639328,
0.3411465287208557,
-0.033464930951595306,
0.12275335937738419,
-0.008011667057871819,
-0.3263789713382721,
0.2340070605278015,
0.1173577681183815,
0.6834014654159546,
0.10068761557340622,
-0.18176916241645813,
-0.012264040298759937,
0.30897319316864014,
0.3741489350795746,
-0.4826529920101166,
0.21793696284294128,
0.3189312517642975,
-0.2917381227016449,
-0.7094722986221313,
-0.5681625604629517,
0.2912517786026001,
-0.4785693883895874,
0.45964908599853516,
-0.7679509520530701,
-0.5770436525344849,
0.4746631979942322,
-0.44886311888694763,
0.26414626836776733,
0.3853823244571686,
0.6908398270606995,
-0.35135573148727417,
0.9647063612937927,
0.39625808596611023,
0.02052609622478485,
0.22990253567695618,
-0.4353496730327606,
0.2456054389476776,
-0.8419061303138733,
-0.3741077780723572,
-0.5899962186813354,
-0.5594934225082397,
-0.49097588658332825,
-0.8839870691299438,
0.701323390007019,
0.637052059173584,
-0.2011605203151703,
0.030347980558872223,
-0.18159213662147522,
0.31627941131591797,
0.33408358693122864,
-0.04880516231060028,
0.3475460410118103,
-0.15142540633678436,
-0.039433132857084274,
0.027188455685973167,
-0.930845320224762,
-0.5213379859924316,
1.0046824216842651,
-0.1262345165014267,
0.7622304558753967,
0.31795594096183777,
0.8733282089233398,
0.20154716074466705,
0.24665217101573944,
-0.8995581865310669,
0.8179317116737366,
0.16171099245548248,
-0.4170702397823334,
-0.24652034044265747,
-0.6047898530960083,
-1.2557973861694336,
0.5204735398292542,
-0.44818443059921265,
-0.3684976100921631,
-0.031843144446611404,
-0.11501823365688324,
-0.43962496519088745,
0.4969516396522522,
-0.24373145401477814,
0.6275522708892822,
-0.42571741342544556,
-0.3657182455062866,
-0.21693433821201324,
-0.055400680750608444,
0.37537816166877747,
-0.09985793381929398,
0.290060818195343,
-0.14861658215522766,
-0.1332954615354538,
0.7628822326660156,
-0.3659808039665222,
0.14932025969028473,
-0.16829340159893036,
-0.031092721968889236,
0.4108157157897949,
0.25035905838012695,
0.8307896256446838,
-0.06637538224458694,
-0.2202083021402359,
-0.3329675495624542,
-0.06274111568927765,
-0.07848845422267914,
-0.6247979998588562,
0.4910474121570587,
-0.44081106781959534,
-0.5496066212654114,
-0.22249415516853333,
-0.33723506331443787,
-0.22185705602169037,
0.18725766241550446,
0.23028390109539032,
0.3905906677246094,
-0.1906166970729828,
0.015023930929601192,
0.6995874047279358,
-0.2746126651763916,
0.5422704815864563,
0.6625989079475403,
-0.6875624656677246,
-0.3466060757637024,
0.7226377129554749,
0.15037710964679718,
-0.2940240502357483,
0.484603613615036,
0.11786063760519028,
-0.4968763291835785,
-0.8176987171173096,
-0.5795416235923767,
0.16815967857837677,
-0.33236196637153625,
-0.5281673669815063,
-0.4360913038253784,
-0.018865903839468956,
0.27860143780708313,
-0.07850249856710434,
-0.4652598798274994,
-0.24879226088523865,
-0.008140946738421917,
-0.14507047832012177,
0.051544975489377975,
0.7537621855735779,
0.16812869906425476,
-0.03432965651154518,
-0.5111083984375,
0.6921178102493286,
0.25506100058555603,
0.329334020614624,
-0.30462348461151123,
0.010586380958557129,
0.06999717652797699,
-0.1138017401099205,
-0.18555442988872528,
-0.8587811589241028,
0.5679178237915039,
-0.25305771827697754,
0.7554388046264648,
0.01362770888954401,
0.3805105984210968,
0.7396726012229919,
-0.640729546546936,
0.30735230445861816,
-0.1861599236726761,
-0.5774587988853455,
0.41590118408203125,
-0.2918543815612793,
0.10455489903688431,
0.5873582363128662,
0.21666832268238068,
-0.2841164171695709,
0.04075431823730469,
-0.4390715956687927,
-0.8709077835083008,
0.4349658489227295,
0.20821885764598846,
-0.24976800382137299,
0.054383471608161926,
0.41619643568992615,
-0.16121388971805573,
0.2724069356918335,
-0.4310150742530823,
-0.39137518405914307,
0.5265275239944458,
0.14012804627418518,
0.07887466251850128,
-0.5645292401313782,
0.021901000291109085,
0.015678642317652702,
0.6966150403022766,
-0.12947218120098114,
0.29159483313560486,
0.039113402366638184,
0.1484394073486328,
-0.16137617826461792,
0.3579636514186859,
0.27578455209732056,
0.9527196288108826,
-0.07223071902990341,
-0.06712290644645691,
0.31075942516326904,
-0.012097587808966637,
-0.022744126617908478,
0.21478122472763062,
-0.40653422474861145,
0.17366600036621094,
0.14792491495609283,
0.7649794220924377,
0.25992438197135925,
-0.8479429483413696,
0.2750553786754608,
-0.30875977873802185,
-0.19230157136917114,
-0.5644150972366333,
0.018200719729065895,
0.007920629344880581,
0.6894057393074036,
0.37515386939048767,
-0.10762568563222885,
0.34844017028808594,
-0.32336434721946716,
0.26059097051620483,
0.5551407933235168,
0.08874660730361938,
0.05847667530179024,
0.7430390119552612,
0.05801534652709961,
-0.4760126769542694,
0.4397558271884918,
-0.5889440774917603,
-0.6468830108642578,
0.5091292858123779,
0.5059674382209778,
0.9456172585487366,
-0.1408177763223648,
0.5225651264190674,
0.47174951434135437,
0.04754852131009102,
-0.19340674579143524,
0.803256630897522,
-0.051009345799684525,
-0.6668087244033813,
-0.6310117244720459,
-0.8297780752182007,
-0.4302193820476532,
-0.10214215517044067,
-0.5410929918289185,
0.3678869903087616,
-0.24740777909755707,
-0.13186824321746826,
-0.4090692698955536,
0.29008767008781433,
-0.6871822476387024,
0.1608041375875473,
-0.052914950996637344,
0.7654271721839905,
-0.00697888620197773,
0.6137061715126038,
0.6578673720359802,
-0.035509586334228516,
-1.0350525379180908,
0.003718991531059146,
-0.1677354872226715,
-0.5903304815292358,
0.7628283500671387,
-0.10748176276683807,
-0.22491388022899628,
-0.03498172387480736,
-0.25900211930274963,
-0.935769259929657,
1.37445068359375,
0.3176403343677521,
-0.7120940089225769,
-0.09870117902755737,
-0.11247390508651733,
0.4629962742328644,
-0.15266776084899902,
0.16836340725421906,
0.5156471133232117,
0.4328201115131378,
0.2710582911968231,
-0.7930031418800354,
-0.020987678319215775,
-0.22565077245235443,
0.04186636209487915,
0.541551947593689,
-0.5187444090843201,
0.9418914914131165,
-0.5551129579544067,
-0.6083231568336487,
0.01213574968278408,
0.5871604084968567,
0.8158211708068848,
0.3080827295780182,
0.3269810974597931,
0.8702830076217651,
0.9487057328224182,
0.025215916335582733,
1.1734402179718018,
-0.18810760974884033,
0.3149608373641968,
1.2867244482040405,
-0.28506410121917725,
1.4368218183517456,
0.20079487562179565,
-0.4840534031391144,
0.2531599998474121,
0.6410797834396362,
0.31065016984939575,
0.4650544226169586,
0.4668744206428528,
-0.3035590648651123,
-0.1673087179660797,
0.00269598257727921,
-0.38077256083488464,
0.732067346572876,
0.41493070125579834,
-0.030625028535723686,
-0.2543262243270874,
-0.3803355097770691,
0.27256280183792114,
-0.07788147777318954,
-0.529513955116272,
0.8994660377502441,
-0.21671755611896515,
-0.7554567456245422,
0.6955893039703369,
0.07114677131175995,
0.5570403337478638,
-0.5751911997795105,
-0.09281855076551437,
-0.41059261560440063,
0.1541222482919693,
-0.24931100010871887,
-0.7723203897476196,
0.29335537552833557,
-0.02882433868944645,
-0.21482212841510773,
-0.15230253338813782,
0.625883162021637,
-0.47958675026893616,
-0.5163360238075256,
0.2654893398284912,
0.6476497054100037,
0.08087555319070816,
-0.18168067932128906,
-0.6653764843940735,
0.3670348823070526,
0.05296261981129646,
-0.3375301659107208,
0.13727827370166779,
0.3629727065563202,
-0.16024339199066162,
0.9370537400245667,
0.5983324646949768,
0.1966177523136139,
0.12997986376285553,
-0.08165031671524048,
0.9572622776031494,
-0.630179762840271,
-0.2903643548488617,
-0.5903364419937134,
0.22905147075653076,
-0.08283555507659912,
-0.14745967090129852,
0.582832396030426,
0.8642681241035461,
0.9061094522476196,
0.06436260789632797,
0.6709252595901489,
-0.14026007056236267,
0.4821876287460327,
-0.9437969923019409,
0.6615854501724243,
-0.35364025831222534,
0.4287266135215759,
-0.04905593395233154,
-1.371800184249878,
-0.30249515175819397,
0.5540544390678406,
-0.27560606598854065,
-0.03620290011167526,
0.6111025810241699,
0.8735471367835999,
0.23765406012535095,
-0.11084190756082535,
0.29457002878189087,
0.09676826000213623,
0.5760430693626404,
0.597149670124054,
0.8765580654144287,
-0.3433993458747864,
0.545540988445282,
-0.02928265556693077,
-0.1426123082637787,
-0.06853384524583817,
-0.5742102265357971,
-0.8160924911499023,
-0.5005198121070862,
-0.12254826724529266,
-0.1620088815689087,
-0.0009896507253870368,
0.7869114875793457,
0.47036245465278625,
-0.5377580523490906,
-0.44713813066482544,
-0.1139526218175888,
0.27537891268730164,
0.0037940095644444227,
-0.2234213799238205,
0.5272480845451355,
-0.5176647305488586,
-0.6873753070831299,
0.5774859189987183,
0.2513977289199829,
-0.20379243791103363,
-0.2659561336040497,
-0.31497853994369507,
-0.11287921667098999,
-0.15130415558815002,
0.8664101362228394,
0.22664004564285278,
-0.539501428604126,
0.12371125817298889,
-0.23456215858459473,
-0.05717338249087334,
-0.03809231147170067,
1.0331268310546875,
-0.9827460646629333,
0.6120802164077759,
0.5583555102348328,
0.857579231262207,
0.8505684733390808,
-0.08320873975753784,
0.5920299887657166,
-0.19431491196155548,
-0.29638609290122986,
0.2670138478279114,
0.3920484185218811,
0.1921156346797943,
-0.04668925702571869,
0.7812948226928711,
-0.36349377036094666,
-0.6576077342033386,
-0.5122299790382385,
0.2467128038406372,
-0.8019336462020874,
-0.24466538429260254,
1.2611054182052612,
0.1713780164718628,
-0.12885990738868713,
0.011690405197441578,
-0.7278635501861572,
0.06787313520908356,
-0.2321733832359314,
0.9125958681106567,
0.18137674033641815,
-0.34915828704833984,
-0.03866809606552124,
-0.8298888802528381,
0.910872220993042,
0.30687960982322693,
-1.2774317264556885,
0.006773392204195261,
0.797391414642334,
-0.10958057641983032,
0.058378685265779495,
0.8230332732200623,
0.008420032449066639,
0.04037756472826004,
-0.04413476213812828,
0.016201842576265335,
0.09326238930225372,
-0.43999236822128296,
0.11397551745176315,
0.45915982127189636,
0.070560023188591,
-0.30551406741142273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12428v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12428v1
|
PSLM: Parallel Generation of Text and Speech with LLMs for Low-Latency Spoken Dialogue Systems
| 2024-06-18T09:23:54 | 2024-06-18T09:23:54 |
Kentaro Mitsui, Koh Mitsuda, Toshiaki Wakatsuki, Yukiya Hono, Kei Sawada
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Multimodal language models that process both text and speech have a potential
for applications in spoken dialogue systems. However, current models face two
major challenges in response generation latency: (1) generating a spoken
response requires the prior generation of a written response, and (2) speech
sequences are significantly longer than text sequences. This study addresses
these issues by extending the input and output sequences of the language model
to support the parallel generation of text and speech. Our experiments on
spoken question answering tasks demonstrate that our approach improves latency
while maintaining the quality of response content. Additionally, we show that
latency can be further reduced by generating speech in multiple sequences. Demo
samples are available at https://rinnakk.github.io/research/publications/PSLM.
|
[
-0.25042566657066345,
-0.7283647656440735,
0.8031989336013794,
0.10293326526880264,
-0.31361594796180725,
0.41998228430747986,
0.02897043153643608,
-0.2495543360710144,
0.1226213350892067,
0.6814860105514526,
-0.8613512516021729,
-0.16469170153141022,
-0.32900339365005493,
0.24675872921943665,
-0.32273876667022705,
1.005571961402893,
0.2369198352098465,
0.19828197360038757,
-0.5035992860794067,
0.05428742617368698,
-0.08870993554592133,
-0.9313430190086365,
-0.5811555981636047,
-0.2621602714061737,
0.6314310431480408,
0.4147137403488159,
0.6154484152793884,
0.08568624407052994,
0.648753821849823,
0.27638760209083557,
-0.020125769078731537,
0.34061139822006226,
-0.531036913394928,
0.857434093952179,
0.0865197405219078,
-0.25911468267440796,
-0.6303162574768066,
-0.4507124125957489,
0.9294028878211975,
0.6876937747001648,
-0.15052726864814758,
0.22322076559066772,
0.02462669461965561,
0.48804059624671936,
-0.3040296137332916,
0.0192575566470623,
-0.4775662124156952,
0.2164219319820404,
-0.4013437032699585,
-0.3481563925743103,
-0.4282127320766449,
-0.3998185992240906,
0.09383758902549744,
-0.2251407653093338,
0.21450220048427582,
0.17327666282653809,
0.47057482600212097,
0.193060502409935,
-0.13358823955059052,
-0.1649356186389923,
-0.9175856709480286,
0.9226340055465698,
-1.1671338081359863,
0.24641968309879303,
0.1142752468585968,
0.36063167452812195,
-0.10548864305019379,
-0.95694500207901,
-0.8095560073852539,
-0.13938862085342407,
-0.0069683268666267395,
0.24908195436000824,
0.02470399998128414,
0.2625557780265808,
0.5809539556503296,
0.4035058617591858,
-0.8671544194221497,
-0.17134536802768707,
-0.410643607378006,
-0.3334887623786926,
0.6048370599746704,
0.8045933246612549,
0.12644609808921814,
-0.22657068073749542,
-0.14429880678653717,
0.28547412157058716,
-0.602057695388794,
0.11315782368183136,
0.6896301507949829,
0.6664630174636841,
-0.06591078639030457,
0.8366212248802185,
-0.28712597489356995,
0.8720489144325256,
-0.3561260998249054,
-0.6535354852676392,
0.22477176785469055,
-0.6580567359924316,
-0.17038489878177643,
-0.1461157202720642,
0.8704928755760193,
0.2715604305267334,
-0.1997213363647461,
0.05962057411670685,
-0.350431889295578,
0.28334152698516846,
0.04768764600157738,
-0.9338334798812866,
-0.018430033698678017,
0.2589287757873535,
-0.5443564653396606,
-0.23445001244544983,
-0.25134310126304626,
-0.8325037360191345,
-0.2274058312177658,
-0.3034035563468933,
-0.009257513098418713,
-0.15152394771575928,
-0.1498507857322693,
0.12978634238243103,
0.015196728520095348,
0.03899313136935234,
0.3532138168811798,
-0.6735945343971252,
0.6411604285240173,
0.26560720801353455,
0.8731523156166077,
-0.2990400791168213,
-0.19080254435539246,
-0.8993808031082153,
0.20699137449264526,
-0.02487931400537491,
0.7128058671951294,
-0.47843900322914124,
-0.5411521792411804,
-0.11867731064558029,
-0.11517500132322311,
-0.012996425852179527,
-0.37971335649490356,
0.41637805104255676,
-0.4658045768737793,
0.5279276967048645,
-0.20652930438518524,
-0.5107020139694214,
0.2790609300136566,
-0.21016797423362732,
-0.37713247537612915,
0.999244749546051,
-0.08897032588720322,
-0.9243772029876709,
-0.37130263447761536,
-0.514941394329071,
-0.5958884954452515,
0.14808379113674164,
-0.34270408749580383,
-0.4481568932533264,
0.20819717645645142,
0.11046577244997025,
0.41506966948509216,
-0.5973464250564575,
0.3907158672809601,
-0.2261067032814026,
-0.2743802070617676,
0.16971351206302643,
-0.45692551136016846,
0.3987785279750824,
0.48228511214256287,
-0.027448108419775963,
0.34173378348350525,
-0.9704312682151794,
0.0386202409863472,
0.36577004194259644,
-0.5514035224914551,
0.2322814166545868,
0.46823960542678833,
0.12190429866313934,
0.46862682700157166,
0.23527264595031738,
-0.7259167432785034,
-0.0617697574198246,
-0.3908470571041107,
0.4930342435836792,
0.5722000002861023,
0.04063154757022858,
0.27323272824287415,
-0.6284247636795044,
0.612188458442688,
0.06390688568353653,
-0.0004486891266424209,
-0.6220618486404419,
-0.7623604536056519,
-0.701789379119873,
-0.040616653859615326,
-0.29921260476112366,
0.7259997129440308,
-1.062270164489746,
-0.004210372921079397,
0.03749814257025719,
-0.34159836173057556,
-0.41426342725753784,
0.15217533707618713,
0.46436595916748047,
0.8547105193138123,
0.17102591693401337,
-0.40010717511177063,
-0.8086870312690735,
-0.9088818430900574,
-0.03958640247583389,
-0.38380712270736694,
-0.16319264471530914,
0.5336000919342041,
-0.17575770616531372,
0.052710793912410736,
1.0720783472061157,
-0.5848614573478699,
0.20196618139743805,
-0.321767121553421,
0.017298879101872444,
0.1732049584388733,
0.12605582177639008,
0.3086424171924591,
-0.5955331325531006,
-0.3719637989997864,
-0.3010008931159973,
-0.7799789905548096,
-0.41423895955085754,
0.13253726065158844,
0.26414260268211365,
0.23485620319843292,
0.4290800094604492,
-0.5372317433357239,
0.16005872189998627,
0.7805700302124023,
-0.03109590895473957,
0.6693913340568542,
-0.07008063048124313,
0.07778895646333694,
-1.2124826908111572,
-0.03942238539457321,
-0.40495923161506653,
-0.5936024785041809,
-0.9776306748390198,
-0.2678976356983185,
-0.31595367193222046,
-0.918889045715332,
-0.8329380750656128,
0.21659979224205017,
-0.23925310373306274,
-0.6456954479217529,
-0.43223389983177185,
0.43017709255218506,
0.20430146157741547,
0.555806577205658,
-0.017749153077602386,
1.0883986949920654,
0.49223390221595764,
-0.5667951703071594,
0.6901126503944397,
0.11922191828489304,
-0.26806125044822693,
0.3425312936306,
-0.7829952239990234,
0.4159698188304901,
-0.1992567628622055,
0.22694648802280426,
-1.3182555437088013,
-0.09630220383405685,
0.20909123122692108,
-0.29694581031799316,
-0.04334993660449982,
0.37380993366241455,
-0.7094763517379761,
-0.5366174578666687,
0.0026274025440216064,
0.3344630002975464,
0.5761239528656006,
-0.10208970308303833,
0.44625169038772583,
0.2606227695941925,
-1.0026031732559204,
-0.15949681401252747,
-0.5930255055427551,
-0.11535371840000153,
0.04302893206477165,
-0.785270631313324,
0.0814901664853096,
-0.32573553919792175,
-0.2724948227405548,
-0.1886407434940338,
0.19377347826957703,
0.2625387907028198,
-0.25470268726348877,
0.179390087723732,
0.21042852103710175,
-0.522652804851532,
0.1565917283296585,
0.273870587348938,
0.06383964419364929,
-0.22946292161941528,
-0.22309039533138275,
0.9296489953994751,
-0.09046024084091187,
-0.5594433546066284,
-0.5981515049934387,
0.8687552213668823,
0.7676935195922852,
-0.2764718234539032,
0.5609761476516724,
0.3955174386501312,
-0.13571685552597046,
0.2166227400302887,
-0.29944300651550293,
-0.2986961305141449,
-0.4680253267288208,
0.3193570673465729,
-0.44781917333602905,
-1.1339435577392578,
0.4299301207065582,
-0.03522224724292755,
0.013212999328970909,
0.1286987066268921,
0.8287353515625,
-0.20940887928009033,
1.0784893035888672,
0.5337731838226318,
0.21610905230045319,
0.43828198313713074,
0.4116969704627991,
0.3677011728286743,
-0.7522685527801514,
-0.13496775925159454,
-0.446010947227478,
-0.06920791417360306,
-0.2825195789337158,
-0.6687270998954773,
0.16203805804252625,
-0.007931175641715527,
-0.11031463742256165,
0.13536714017391205,
-0.2694225609302521,
-0.07793068140745163,
0.534045398235321,
0.10963060706853867,
0.5013236999511719,
0.17990417778491974,
-0.3382083475589752,
-0.3685302734375,
-0.8472068309783936,
-0.7192699909210205,
0.7847889065742493,
0.3821655809879303,
0.6644737124443054,
0.25137972831726074,
0.6492530107498169,
0.22024445235729218,
-0.009284698404371738,
-0.4215773344039917,
0.7891807556152344,
-0.2063884139060974,
-0.28553739190101624,
-0.4873270094394684,
-0.4158462584018707,
-0.5316940546035767,
0.35211676359176636,
-0.09799601137638092,
-0.6817294359207153,
-0.21502146124839783,
0.038114774972200394,
-0.5859266519546509,
0.30258139967918396,
-0.5056759119033813,
0.21673204004764557,
-0.16818441450595856,
-0.39805880188941956,
-0.07147032767534256,
-0.7994674444198608,
0.35754382610321045,
-0.13215139508247375,
-0.007949712686240673,
-0.336130827665329,
-0.015359744429588318,
0.7194996476173401,
-0.6028918623924255,
0.9331724047660828,
-0.09011183679103851,
-0.27584904432296753,
0.26596513390541077,
-0.15718790888786316,
0.6724610328674316,
0.07938359677791595,
-0.08219640702009201,
-0.17387807369232178,
-0.3021545708179474,
-0.4640645384788513,
-0.42156726121902466,
0.708644688129425,
-0.5823552012443542,
-0.7403644323348999,
-0.3059457838535309,
-0.900642454624176,
-0.41726717352867126,
0.20061950385570526,
0.15145456790924072,
0.5004934072494507,
0.10085608810186386,
-0.13808183372020721,
0.5834616422653198,
-0.5697906613349915,
0.6068742871284485,
0.5208527445793152,
-0.599333643913269,
-0.6268782019615173,
0.8631364107131958,
-0.07430492341518402,
0.5898723602294922,
0.1390925943851471,
-0.03319692984223366,
-0.32430389523506165,
-0.5081362724304199,
-0.26805001497268677,
0.2921874225139618,
-0.43624964356422424,
-0.058522000908851624,
-0.8145930767059326,
-0.32261061668395996,
-0.6630770564079285,
0.1435691863298416,
-0.2528637647628784,
-0.5457166433334351,
-0.34973782300949097,
0.07096054404973984,
0.20106036961078644,
0.7975465655326843,
0.1517719179391861,
0.635176956653595,
-0.9315893054008484,
0.6760947108268738,
0.5119900703430176,
0.14676882326602936,
-0.12587526440620422,
-0.40161725878715515,
0.05759011209011078,
0.06454311311244965,
-0.4104567766189575,
-0.9618712663650513,
0.5614649057388306,
0.15568676590919495,
0.4963390529155731,
0.08582092821598053,
0.07805086672306061,
0.6054047346115112,
-0.9240739941596985,
1.0928747653961182,
0.5356685519218445,
-0.888117790222168,
0.7985461950302124,
-0.4164179265499115,
0.5318465232849121,
0.07045605033636093,
0.07152550667524338,
-0.6595170497894287,
-0.6863886713981628,
-0.44799891114234924,
-0.7975115776062012,
0.9359914064407349,
0.5639544725418091,
0.08713685721158981,
0.08556149154901505,
0.005658004432916641,
0.03343038633465767,
0.6419593095779419,
-0.39073866605758667,
-0.28563961386680603,
-0.19234336912631989,
0.08534613996744156,
-0.38591468334198,
-0.5092050433158875,
-0.14646606147289276,
0.039120063185691833,
0.49001431465148926,
-0.12608447670936584,
0.44296613335609436,
0.26222357153892517,
0.017005519941449165,
-0.30676373839378357,
0.21655060350894928,
1.1406192779541016,
0.6984156370162964,
-0.12952637672424316,
0.010837670415639877,
0.09149665385484695,
-0.20029425621032715,
0.16527554392814636,
0.19810238480567932,
-0.1490587741136551,
0.37425848841667175,
0.19090071320533752,
1.164534330368042,
0.05980532243847847,
-0.7176116704940796,
0.34815874695777893,
-0.21602760255336761,
-0.0687924474477768,
-0.0723647028207779,
-0.27326032519340515,
0.22721312940120697,
0.38787904381752014,
0.4040612280368805,
0.211333766579628,
0.053967949002981186,
-0.25265055894851685,
0.3283314108848572,
0.15341868996620178,
-0.15313492715358734,
-0.16335129737854004,
0.7056468725204468,
0.41831710934638977,
-0.7583868503570557,
0.5786627531051636,
0.07752681523561478,
-0.3868485391139984,
0.30852407217025757,
0.7856668829917908,
0.5827375054359436,
-0.31262335181236267,
0.267057329416275,
0.1024208515882492,
-0.03912120312452316,
0.21739904582500458,
0.7073161602020264,
-0.24449127912521362,
-0.528019905090332,
-0.6112833619117737,
-0.875690221786499,
-0.5966866612434387,
0.17595472931861877,
-0.5789730548858643,
0.0927560031414032,
-0.4420383870601654,
-0.32803311944007874,
-0.26355791091918945,
-0.151541069149971,
-0.315088152885437,
-0.01432028692215681,
0.4009471833705902,
0.47249215841293335,
-0.8861119151115417,
0.9094560742378235,
0.514336884021759,
-0.23200151324272156,
-0.5355368256568909,
0.031502775847911835,
-0.06713315844535828,
-0.507422685623169,
0.6285995244979858,
-0.16345852613449097,
-0.3187691569328308,
0.04832732304930687,
-0.2467004805803299,
-0.8363690376281738,
0.9555573463439941,
0.5489388704299927,
-0.9325329065322876,
-0.19802969694137573,
0.4321240484714508,
0.5945696830749512,
-0.403146892786026,
0.07056966423988342,
0.22024546563625336,
0.008714385330677032,
0.1291998326778412,
-1.014785885810852,
-0.12654806673526764,
-0.19853566586971283,
0.4582417607307434,
0.08146297186613083,
-0.5466657876968384,
1.0875298976898193,
-0.17796465754508972,
-0.2502085268497467,
0.4540533423423767,
0.7574571967124939,
0.7815698981285095,
0.363326758146286,
0.19713671505451202,
0.3827560245990753,
0.7422229647636414,
-0.17358238995075226,
0.956322968006134,
-0.21710270643234253,
0.2830941081047058,
1.3270031213760376,
-0.7082709074020386,
0.9021727442741394,
0.732499361038208,
-0.38563886284828186,
0.37180107831954956,
0.546863853931427,
0.4202894866466522,
0.6746325492858887,
0.30293068289756775,
-0.6227561235427856,
-0.3167675733566284,
-0.26028382778167725,
-0.4371723234653473,
0.06337416172027588,
0.3791210651397705,
-0.27768126130104065,
-0.3230319917201996,
0.3355259597301483,
-0.37177571654319763,
0.22224915027618408,
-0.023892978206276894,
0.7231691479682922,
0.2021619975566864,
-0.5043308138847351,
0.3287303149700165,
-0.254762202501297,
0.5112746357917786,
-0.6036648750305176,
0.06695446372032166,
-0.3450152277946472,
0.03615693375468254,
-0.11653199046850204,
-0.5771607160568237,
0.4405713975429535,
0.04499989002943039,
-0.4653949439525604,
-0.4323851466178894,
0.9029529690742493,
-0.5105400085449219,
-0.4114057123661041,
0.21526147425174713,
0.7507619857788086,
0.2866140305995941,
0.32592135667800903,
-0.6136435270309448,
0.29043862223625183,
-0.1207817867398262,
-0.25487813353538513,
0.25365960597991943,
0.16966646909713745,
0.1861095279455185,
0.6066960096359253,
0.8222230672836304,
0.253469854593277,
0.4886695444583893,
0.39848533272743225,
0.9114053249359131,
-0.446776419878006,
-0.5398554801940918,
-0.6637858748435974,
0.48672595620155334,
-0.08711759746074677,
-0.01258903369307518,
0.7724151015281677,
0.7099460959434509,
0.481331467628479,
-0.23581184446811676,
1.0137377977371216,
-0.024437353014945984,
0.9347790479660034,
-0.43720877170562744,
0.38604438304901123,
-0.4404568672180176,
0.26846960186958313,
-0.4227343201637268,
-0.8172589540481567,
-0.2529617249965668,
0.26497504115104675,
-0.1603594571352005,
-0.25794923305511475,
0.6506581902503967,
0.850317656993866,
0.16142749786376953,
0.010635395534336567,
0.8194429874420166,
-0.034311093389987946,
0.38722893595695496,
0.6706850528717041,
1.100589394569397,
-0.44994446635246277,
0.6024727821350098,
-0.21524883806705475,
0.11514678597450256,
-0.006015300750732422,
-0.6728957891464233,
-0.8064507842063904,
-0.6356772780418396,
-0.02661737985908985,
-0.414252907037735,
0.24948324263095856,
0.4930051267147064,
0.5670565962791443,
-0.7884812951087952,
-0.48631972074508667,
-0.12994173169136047,
-0.06822726875543594,
0.034680455923080444,
-0.22547616064548492,
-0.06972650438547134,
-0.5470080375671387,
-0.8595922589302063,
0.5466212630271912,
0.5566102862358093,
0.2514782249927521,
-0.40357735753059387,
-0.44517508149147034,
-0.270864874124527,
0.23042647540569305,
0.7954453825950623,
0.2021658718585968,
-0.9684917330741882,
-0.015064512379467487,
0.2151058167219162,
-0.2638985812664032,
-0.007402270101010799,
1.201436161994934,
-0.7210313081741333,
0.3987267315387726,
0.7111825942993164,
0.5568268895149231,
0.5937255620956421,
-0.06913124024868011,
0.8163735270500183,
-0.961165726184845,
0.35444509983062744,
0.5221248865127563,
0.3515523374080658,
0.4599023461341858,
-0.14755000174045563,
0.015504695475101471,
0.4566234052181244,
-0.5074324607849121,
-1.0094369649887085,
0.7429288625717163,
-0.916266918182373,
-0.04108498618006706,
1.0031425952911377,
-0.18830852210521698,
0.062006689608097076,
-0.15050482749938965,
-0.4082925319671631,
0.44640251994132996,
-0.3899228274822235,
0.14500068128108978,
0.68240886926651,
-0.5077444314956665,
-0.5597045421600342,
-0.4625846743583679,
0.35261619091033936,
0.5737555623054504,
-0.7745358943939209,
0.01878337934613228,
0.5154812932014465,
-0.09686283767223358,
0.3439347743988037,
1.0440104007720947,
-0.04966505244374275,
0.1984650194644928,
0.005954769905656576,
-0.18705055117607117,
0.028684288263320923,
-0.3108986020088196,
-0.4226493239402771,
0.3768497705459595,
0.000034154792956542224,
-0.21918651461601257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12422v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12422v1
|
Open-Source Web Service with Morphological Dictionary-Supplemented Deep Learning for Morphosyntactic Analysis of Czech
| 2024-06-18T09:14:58 | 2024-06-18T09:14:58 |
Milan Straka, Jana Straková
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present an open-source web service for Czech morphosyntactic analysis. The
system combines a deep learning model with rescoring by a high-precision
morphological dictionary at inference time. We show that our hybrid method
surpasses two competitive baselines: While the deep learning model ensures
generalization for out-of-vocabulary words and better disambiguation, an
improvement over an existing morphological analyser MorphoDiTa, at the same
time, the deep learning model benefits from inference-time guidance of a
manually curated morphological dictionary. We achieve 50% error reduction in
lemmatization and 58% error reduction in POS tagging over MorphoDiTa, while
also offering dependency parsing. The model is trained on one of the currently
largest Czech morphosyntactic corpora, the PDT-C 1.0, with the trained models
available at https://hdl.handle.net/11234/1-5293. We provide the tool as a web
service deployed at https://lindat.mff.cuni.cz/services/udpipe/. The source
code is available at GitHub (https://github.com/ufal/udpipe/tree/udpipe-2),
along with a Python client for a simple use. The documentation for the models
can be found at https://ufal.mff.cuni.cz/udpipe/2/models#czech_pdtc1.0_model.
|
[
-0.19160734117031097,
-0.5352948307991028,
0.3132736086845398,
0.3908815085887909,
-0.7825132012367249,
0.20255424082279205,
-0.39484864473342896,
-0.5534642338752747,
0.35596999526023865,
0.6321152448654175,
-0.6246323585510254,
-1.0274438858032227,
-0.24065709114074707,
0.4210694432258606,
-0.1582050621509552,
0.6476978659629822,
0.10592912882566452,
0.8390796780586243,
-0.020173002034425735,
0.20017367601394653,
0.07752873003482819,
-0.5815562009811401,
-0.2598751187324524,
-0.0640505701303482,
0.3162355124950409,
0.07405456900596619,
0.3555907905101776,
0.41997432708740234,
0.3737829029560089,
0.3329675793647766,
-0.22743625938892365,
0.1004401445388794,
-0.09377595782279968,
0.5907461643218994,
-0.35398027300834656,
-0.2733266055583954,
-0.535279393196106,
-0.48110345005989075,
0.5459312200546265,
0.9727925062179565,
-0.18650245666503906,
-0.08399400860071182,
-0.027787301689386368,
0.6004456281661987,
-0.5861985087394714,
0.2578490376472473,
-0.8032258152961731,
0.09747469425201416,
-0.49987995624542236,
0.19333584606647491,
-0.28107985854148865,
-0.261871874332428,
0.2754424810409546,
-0.6073193550109863,
0.0325862392783165,
-0.46539896726608276,
0.6667696833610535,
0.1817447692155838,
-0.28781452775001526,
-0.2206284999847412,
-0.6281566619873047,
0.5629797577857971,
-0.6570845246315002,
0.476305216550827,
0.3353239893913269,
0.2367476373910904,
-0.1434442102909088,
-0.5929986834526062,
-0.3115013539791107,
-0.23843614757061005,
0.2552652359008789,
0.3019990921020508,
-0.2667028307914734,
0.26637178659439087,
-0.35112637281417847,
0.5470766425132751,
-0.704574704170227,
0.2018418163061142,
-0.419780969619751,
-0.48438674211502075,
0.35452908277511597,
0.20659881830215454,
0.2615901231765747,
-0.18675509095191956,
-0.16087594628334045,
0.11176539957523346,
-0.49133244156837463,
-0.2853901982307434,
0.6348926424980164,
0.706321120262146,
-0.14910754561424255,
0.8030267953872681,
-0.43650245666503906,
0.5354135036468506,
-0.04588863253593445,
0.3315671384334564,
0.4896274507045746,
-0.42816171050071716,
-0.26457181572914124,
0.04902416840195656,
0.8352078199386597,
0.0304202102124691,
0.03855298459529877,
-0.27426519989967346,
-0.09674247354269028,
0.2137710005044937,
0.13564734160900116,
-0.7944517135620117,
-0.6503852009773254,
0.16448339819908142,
-0.24678963422775269,
-0.21262989938259125,
0.09024736285209656,
-1.0227786302566528,
-0.2533804476261139,
-0.23199795186519623,
0.12026043981313705,
-0.5055499076843262,
-0.4943166971206665,
0.271125853061676,
-0.119144007563591,
-0.11404921114444733,
0.44000503420829773,
-0.9379412531852722,
0.44773298501968384,
0.5775191187858582,
1.1950838565826416,
-0.38332611322402954,
0.03276200592517853,
-0.4899272620677948,
-0.13953714072704315,
-0.27454718947410583,
1.1180964708328247,
-0.24826543033123016,
-0.342713326215744,
0.12419646978378296,
0.1618114411830902,
0.18121026456356049,
-0.7859253287315369,
0.44222402572631836,
-0.3624734580516815,
0.209625244140625,
0.3802529275417328,
-0.404946506023407,
0.10130444169044495,
-0.01327572949230671,
-0.8593705296516418,
1.11031973361969,
0.4060632884502411,
-0.5772673487663269,
0.24829167127609253,
-0.4574204087257385,
-0.20612603425979614,
0.4790944457054138,
-0.07582000643014908,
-0.21930834650993347,
-0.043249573558568954,
-0.12645910680294037,
0.22439895570278168,
-0.09281572699546814,
0.14781874418258667,
-0.6644572019577026,
0.24657726287841797,
-0.11915135383605957,
-0.25893256068229675,
1.5523321628570557,
0.2508998215198517,
-0.07607768476009369,
0.2774581015110016,
-1.1046146154403687,
0.091385118663311,
-0.10281413793563843,
-0.6585962176322937,
-0.5285629034042358,
-0.18264161050319672,
0.4636406898498535,
0.13123303651809692,
0.44828128814697266,
-0.9000617265701294,
0.33336466550827026,
-0.8860791921615601,
0.44504114985466003,
0.6697083115577698,
-0.2068498581647873,
0.2432243973016739,
0.4609983265399933,
0.6226450204849243,
-0.04821169376373291,
0.21789008378982544,
0.22037453949451447,
-0.6893513798713684,
-0.3237696886062622,
-0.5861099362373352,
0.6366549730300903,
0.6152395606040955,
-0.7236929535865784,
0.7753421664237976,
-0.319945752620697,
-0.635670006275177,
-0.6506688594818115,
0.15664584934711456,
0.4966890513896942,
0.3280608355998993,
0.2624179422855377,
-0.45032915472984314,
-0.9531771540641785,
-0.9040501713752747,
0.29688435792922974,
-0.1280055046081543,
-0.2840724289417267,
-0.09813261777162552,
0.6630446314811707,
-0.35196614265441895,
0.9968675971031189,
-0.30375540256500244,
-0.1439998745918274,
-0.11283941566944122,
0.15868067741394043,
0.1088014617562294,
0.47069796919822693,
0.6757380366325378,
-0.9893056750297546,
-0.7089701890945435,
0.3360772430896759,
-0.3260916769504547,
-0.4511258900165558,
0.7007936835289001,
-0.15752749145030975,
0.6178979873657227,
-0.1086740642786026,
-0.780320405960083,
0.07769712805747986,
0.8961394429206848,
-0.5573804974555969,
0.9851301908493042,
-0.07957548648118973,
-0.10927069187164307,
-1.3961995840072632,
0.1926322728395462,
-0.1266932338476181,
-0.17187468707561493,
-0.5398468375205994,
0.09386912733316422,
0.028390733525156975,
-0.0016661679837852716,
-0.7244774699211121,
0.5545006990432739,
-0.21064050495624542,
-0.25275686383247375,
-0.03771159425377846,
-0.016518307849764824,
-0.07030075788497925,
0.31317025423049927,
0.18608535826206207,
0.9470322728157043,
0.6791970133781433,
-0.46107447147369385,
0.8055527210235596,
0.42906737327575684,
-0.6129007935523987,
0.21704518795013428,
-0.2346564531326294,
-0.016351750120520592,
0.49547702074050903,
0.09207254648208618,
-0.8273119926452637,
-0.3520844578742981,
0.4495968222618103,
-0.6677717566490173,
-0.11181113123893738,
-0.6868556141853333,
-0.6556070446968079,
-0.18589787185192108,
-0.3531840145587921,
0.12564121186733246,
0.2626780569553375,
-0.5305808186531067,
0.6084494590759277,
0.4540195167064667,
-0.39406266808509827,
-0.35007309913635254,
-0.8487191796302795,
0.13481925427913666,
0.05435008183121681,
-0.7595494389533997,
0.754307210445404,
-0.19241508841514587,
-0.5603440403938293,
0.3202570080757141,
-0.08727376908063889,
-0.9858616590499878,
0.07568833976984024,
0.17435237765312195,
0.42059141397476196,
-0.37021616101264954,
0.1327454149723053,
0.22237658500671387,
-0.058780692517757416,
-0.2082693725824356,
-0.6550788879394531,
0.9264605641365051,
-0.0801398754119873,
-0.1792317032814026,
-0.6908278465270996,
0.4129844903945923,
0.6441576480865479,
-0.20636241137981415,
0.4122106432914734,
0.3438042998313904,
-0.4413127601146698,
0.09339462965726852,
-0.17351655662059784,
0.1319303661584854,
-0.4065966308116913,
0.29045215249061584,
-0.28408119082450867,
-0.7081805467605591,
0.6759620904922485,
0.01261676475405693,
-0.07603070139884949,
0.733141303062439,
0.7751162052154541,
-0.14025259017944336,
0.9950147271156311,
0.7761853933334351,
0.047902416437864304,
0.5104972124099731,
-0.30214548110961914,
-0.33792251348495483,
-0.5814297795295715,
-0.27397236227989197,
-0.7707110643386841,
0.4291319251060486,
-0.6677271723747253,
-0.057648975402116776,
0.1327791064977646,
0.0919606164097786,
0.12567946314811707,
0.33335965871810913,
-0.417489618062973,
0.04562538489699364,
0.41760772466659546,
0.01060524582862854,
0.4017634391784668,
0.22288504242897034,
-0.4720595180988312,
0.11591283977031708,
-0.4137982130050659,
-0.6479558348655701,
0.8887982368469238,
-0.007156555540859699,
0.7332368493080139,
0.15282514691352844,
0.7389107942581177,
0.20220744609832764,
-0.2542993426322937,
-1.0566378831863403,
0.45267432928085327,
-0.44629570841789246,
-0.449364572763443,
-0.3834555745124817,
-0.46256178617477417,
-1.0810415744781494,
0.43222343921661377,
-0.225836381316185,
-0.6675573587417603,
0.15657870471477509,
0.3395511507987976,
-0.43522581458091736,
0.3119060695171356,
-0.6938602328300476,
0.7994492053985596,
-0.11699387431144714,
-0.08553636819124222,
-0.4063301980495453,
-0.3840024173259735,
0.1418471783399582,
0.13009808957576752,
-0.0008951346389949322,
-0.006521753966808319,
-0.13046258687973022,
0.597484290599823,
-0.4728770852088928,
1.0042424201965332,
-0.2167438268661499,
-0.3706721365451813,
0.03604557737708092,
0.0899379551410675,
0.15391705930233002,
-0.031973570585250854,
-0.1466846913099289,
0.436768501996994,
0.28972384333610535,
-0.4511021375656128,
-0.4568890333175659,
0.6356344819068909,
-0.5571585893630981,
-0.28269273042678833,
-0.37649446725845337,
-0.25266286730766296,
-0.08433309197425842,
0.2999739944934845,
0.27110907435417175,
0.5175448060035706,
-0.24518842995166779,
0.34259670972824097,
0.7660021185874939,
-0.049196336418390274,
0.2044384628534317,
0.39900004863739014,
-0.3120841681957245,
-0.7186642289161682,
0.5975545048713684,
0.2036815732717514,
0.21749618649482727,
0.5143589973449707,
0.22255943715572357,
-0.1585724800825119,
-0.8782743811607361,
-0.7320037484169006,
0.06731385737657547,
-0.592239499092102,
-0.2552642822265625,
-0.6662405133247375,
-0.17748858034610748,
-0.8770716190338135,
0.23902852833271027,
-0.5362332463264465,
-0.6449294090270996,
-0.33491846919059753,
-0.03525694087147713,
0.41322991251945496,
0.5732573866844177,
-0.11382517963647842,
0.2064637988805771,
-0.7751886248588562,
0.03647005930542946,
0.27064698934555054,
0.3832379877567291,
-0.4696757197380066,
-0.23712635040283203,
-0.3726508617401123,
0.059711795300245285,
-0.28113049268722534,
-1.0350602865219116,
0.48820632696151733,
-0.05316859483718872,
0.450284481048584,
0.4012412428855896,
-0.1948145031929016,
0.5670018792152405,
-0.5313720107078552,
1.030238389968872,
0.14743800461292267,
-0.8521179556846619,
0.5082259178161621,
-0.42082974314689636,
0.2498890608549118,
0.4340876042842865,
0.2582073509693146,
-0.4523353576660156,
-0.46346861124038696,
-0.23833461105823517,
-0.8982558250427246,
0.54618901014328,
0.0767248198390007,
0.1546652615070343,
-0.12392841279506683,
0.22152946889400482,
0.4622892439365387,
0.026771459728479385,
-0.5754535794258118,
-0.06405537575483322,
-0.2430037409067154,
-0.3884890675544739,
0.32642173767089844,
-0.17724837362766266,
0.003676444059237838,
-0.3144073784351349,
0.9063034653663635,
-0.13578662276268005,
0.16997846961021423,
0.1799900382757187,
-0.4314621686935425,
-0.1777934730052948,
0.2686108946800232,
0.7731345295906067,
0.7124209403991699,
-0.2974158525466919,
0.10164150595664978,
0.13380371034145355,
-0.8932371735572815,
-0.23681491613388062,
0.15111780166625977,
-0.199122354388237,
0.4369063079357147,
0.35544833540916443,
0.48335200548171997,
0.3241821825504303,
-1.0181151628494263,
0.39074593782424927,
0.08301776647567749,
-0.3429836630821228,
-0.5738481283187866,
-0.08387791365385056,
-0.05383652076125145,
0.4340585172176361,
0.5931901335716248,
-0.25129562616348267,
0.2854653000831604,
-0.3849451243877411,
0.05115032568573952,
0.6183931827545166,
-0.2651090919971466,
-0.6085343956947327,
0.04485185444355011,
0.3098051846027374,
-0.4379890263080597,
0.41452130675315857,
-0.07821935415267944,
-0.6668305397033691,
0.5666232109069824,
0.5692408084869385,
0.9449792504310608,
-0.4215109944343567,
0.3532797396183014,
0.18394175171852112,
-0.03363604471087456,
0.2986602485179901,
0.46165385842323303,
-0.21500398218631744,
-0.5017380714416504,
-0.6228935122489929,
-0.8064633011817932,
-0.4045495390892029,
0.46232327818870544,
-0.7376303672790527,
0.3393893539905548,
-0.27405187487602234,
0.015363776125013828,
-0.0006208914564922452,
0.1790115237236023,
-0.18211203813552856,
0.08063782006502151,
0.0022305769380182028,
1.2107117176055908,
-0.7166460752487183,
1.064279317855835,
0.7625204920768738,
-0.3340063989162445,
-0.001761268824338913,
-0.04962131753563881,
0.03666025772690773,
-0.5753490328788757,
0.8925487399101257,
-0.09545759111642838,
-0.5387762188911438,
0.005803554784506559,
-0.3584464490413666,
-0.8340402841567993,
0.931098461151123,
0.745070219039917,
-0.5999629497528076,
-0.2423948496580124,
-0.25930094718933105,
0.6620513200759888,
-0.21050739288330078,
-0.16061195731163025,
0.21172401309013367,
0.3167099356651306,
-0.1866215020418167,
-1.2140270471572876,
-0.33790168166160583,
-0.32484114170074463,
-0.09357330203056335,
0.36942943930625916,
-0.039427101612091064,
0.8432486057281494,
0.31345298886299133,
-0.4254477620124817,
0.5942427515983582,
0.5187710523605347,
-0.013990875333547592,
0.00831723865121603,
0.39874380826950073,
0.6407703161239624,
0.6396397948265076,
0.16587930917739868,
0.6653929352760315,
-0.20884832739830017,
0.45689094066619873,
1.1094971895217896,
-0.07387548685073853,
0.9225201606750488,
0.67800372838974,
-0.278924822807312,
0.6229867935180664,
0.9091922640800476,
-0.211217999458313,
0.7504537105560303,
-0.08025527000427246,
-0.5349082350730896,
-0.28364598751068115,
0.04551161453127861,
-0.43219706416130066,
0.5062191486358643,
0.3122917711734772,
-0.24744465947151184,
-0.5713304877281189,
0.1444380283355713,
-0.21045735478401184,
0.16607291996479034,
-0.45043566823005676,
0.7533932328224182,
-0.28734317421913147,
-0.2314375340938568,
0.3160126507282257,
-0.04620044678449631,
0.7068865895271301,
-0.6275220513343811,
-0.12542834877967834,
-0.0033773125614970922,
-0.015802884474396706,
-0.10459446161985397,
-0.7086198925971985,
0.4670598804950714,
0.19943982362747192,
-0.25576528906822205,
-0.04812603443861008,
0.40779197216033936,
-0.4514060318470001,
-0.4665471613407135,
0.5805565118789673,
0.44387394189834595,
0.34339460730552673,
0.053482625633478165,
-0.6250793933868408,
-0.1726086139678955,
-0.2479410022497177,
-0.14324738085269928,
0.4002763330936432,
0.4716925323009491,
-0.14774377644062042,
0.5824469923973083,
0.7672905325889587,
0.516909658908844,
0.22280777990818024,
0.2348153442144394,
0.9348794221878052,
-0.3455589711666107,
-0.5127173066139221,
-0.9126161336898804,
0.5551197528839111,
-0.12243520468473434,
-0.3426041603088379,
0.4515801668167114,
0.9165867567062378,
1.2939810752868652,
-0.3238738179206848,
0.8260237574577332,
-0.14159977436065674,
0.4204710125923157,
-0.8040906190872192,
0.5726305246353149,
-0.3683996796607971,
-0.30117374658584595,
0.03493163362145424,
-0.7541163563728333,
-0.5849462747573853,
0.44796428084373474,
-0.19643943011760712,
-0.4360858201980591,
0.6572350859642029,
0.7126055955886841,
-0.23875625431537628,
-0.34498101472854614,
0.46863794326782227,
0.30854249000549316,
-0.026808906346559525,
0.12684668600559235,
0.7237480878829956,
0.25377902388572693,
0.7188416719436646,
-0.5521320700645447,
-0.33501511812210083,
-0.30288952589035034,
-0.5633605718612671,
-0.7560206651687622,
-0.9839812517166138,
-0.08760565519332886,
-0.23027203977108002,
0.19820250570774078,
1.305712103843689,
0.5889209508895874,
-1.0626980066299438,
-0.17319853603839874,
-0.2563853859901428,
-0.1321459859609604,
-0.18788962066173553,
-0.19830141961574554,
0.26529768109321594,
-0.5341940522193909,
-0.8460895419120789,
0.4466691315174103,
0.5058271884918213,
0.09438365697860718,
-0.5659324526786804,
0.04148469492793083,
-0.19381938874721527,
-0.26182040572166443,
0.6742246150970459,
0.1802023947238922,
-0.9956932663917542,
0.12497295439243317,
-0.109796442091465,
-0.2586566209793091,
0.4259341359138489,
0.8562532067298889,
-0.6340039372444153,
0.49660077691078186,
0.5126551389694214,
0.47684961557388306,
0.31528279185295105,
-0.368512362241745,
0.3548373878002167,
-0.4170485734939575,
0.18302403390407562,
0.44909510016441345,
0.5544799566268921,
0.2692573666572571,
-0.49427926540374756,
0.30246302485466003,
0.4936480224132538,
-0.10154005140066147,
-0.95920330286026,
0.3678894639015198,
-1.0721073150634766,
-0.47040432691574097,
0.9504114985466003,
-0.3758145272731781,
-0.31252896785736084,
-0.32468292117118835,
-0.29694095253944397,
0.5953436493873596,
-0.38191741704940796,
1.0010653734207153,
0.8231869339942932,
-0.02784169465303421,
0.019125254824757576,
-0.43950286507606506,
0.36762937903404236,
0.026060735806822777,
-1.0183416604995728,
0.27656063437461853,
0.7299848794937134,
0.41161349415779114,
0.349172443151474,
0.4266180694103241,
-0.3828062415122986,
0.5015243291854858,
-0.21187706291675568,
0.42380720376968384,
0.026875430718064308,
-0.4416448473930359,
-0.7749759554862976,
0.04821342974901199,
-0.21809886395931244,
-0.2202104926109314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12420v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12420v1
|
MMUTF: Multimodal Multimedia Event Argument Extraction with Unified Template Filling
| 2024-06-18T09:14:17 | 2024-06-18T09:14:17 |
Philipp Seeberger, Dominik Wagner, Korbinian Riedhammer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
With the advancement of multimedia technologies, news documents and
user-generated content are often represented as multiple modalities, making
Multimedia Event Extraction (MEE) an increasingly important challenge. However,
recent MEE methods employ weak alignment strategies and data augmentation with
simple classification models, which ignore the capabilities of natural
language-formulated event templates for the challenging Event Argument
Extraction (EAE) task. In this work, we focus on EAE and address this issue by
introducing a unified template filling model that connects the textual and
visual modalities via textual prompts. This approach enables the exploitation
of cross-ontology transfer and the incorporation of event-specific semantics.
Experiments on the M2E2 benchmark demonstrate the effectiveness of our
approach. Our system surpasses the current SOTA on textual EAE by +7% F1, and
performs generally better than the second-best systems for multimedia EAE.
|
[
-0.6127407550811768,
-0.5576611161231995,
0.6093150973320007,
0.09618131816387177,
-0.5607518553733826,
-0.20591840147972107,
-0.12147476524114609,
-0.2790735363960266,
0.06740717589855194,
0.3006373643875122,
-0.8932769298553467,
-0.2699359059333801,
-0.5472384691238403,
0.21319043636322021,
-0.12595319747924805,
0.7165651917457581,
-0.09864137321710587,
-0.017298342660069466,
-0.17593617737293243,
-0.23353655636310577,
-0.8020893931388855,
-0.32157644629478455,
-0.6893095970153809,
-0.07499274611473083,
0.6694322824478149,
0.8714519143104553,
0.40102842450141907,
0.46046561002731323,
0.39269524812698364,
0.2576160430908203,
0.4501918852329254,
0.32747820019721985,
0.02475409023463726,
0.12102410197257996,
-0.28060489892959595,
-0.12789888679981232,
-0.2592703104019165,
0.16577428579330444,
0.34665828943252563,
0.2359803467988968,
-0.05079703405499458,
0.15022209286689758,
-0.013712197542190552,
0.25241923332214355,
-0.7896230220794678,
-0.1597173660993576,
-0.6240593791007996,
0.3210044205188751,
-0.3747934103012085,
-0.5921714901924133,
-0.4264119863510132,
0.39595234394073486,
0.11033845692873001,
-0.7044219374656677,
0.003349514212459326,
-0.17760001122951508,
0.8233295679092407,
0.011865504086017609,
-0.550910234451294,
-0.1704629808664322,
-0.5848499536514282,
0.7261258959770203,
-0.4763638973236084,
0.5837355852127075,
0.019879251718521118,
0.339458167552948,
-0.15151673555374146,
-0.9138491749763489,
-0.8364523649215698,
0.08170395344495773,
0.25717833638191223,
0.4734310209751129,
-0.34510084986686707,
-0.0024005481973290443,
0.1333739310503006,
-0.014568028971552849,
-0.7177912592887878,
0.11734919995069504,
-0.19322188198566437,
-0.219674751162529,
0.37488263845443726,
0.19223248958587646,
0.6459255218505859,
-0.7804074883460999,
-0.6869722604751587,
-0.23991885781288147,
-0.32724735140800476,
-0.06871352344751358,
0.26832085847854614,
-0.08160106092691422,
-0.10928860306739807,
0.7595918774604797,
0.14930355548858643,
0.4885343611240387,
-0.04484229162335396,
-0.2806420624256134,
-0.09974784404039383,
-0.40184536576271057,
-0.4571494460105896,
-0.10212624073028564,
0.9368871450424194,
0.7337719202041626,
-0.022673282772302628,
-0.04846815764904022,
0.25224757194519043,
-0.08045032620429993,
0.025036072358489037,
-0.7424947023391724,
0.02432076446712017,
0.2148689180612564,
-0.4782048761844635,
-0.3147425055503845,
0.28282415866851807,
-1.3691409826278687,
-0.2508452832698822,
-0.3801678717136383,
0.4367416501045227,
-0.34116461873054504,
-0.2012065351009369,
0.04860169067978859,
-0.43991589546203613,
0.15245626866817474,
0.5908294320106506,
-0.7517653703689575,
-0.14434044063091278,
0.4738428294658661,
0.6587210297584534,
-0.318553626537323,
-0.06693045049905777,
-0.9180988073348999,
0.5789777636528015,
0.024351313710212708,
1.1484580039978027,
-0.8297175168991089,
-0.319569855928421,
0.06444288790225983,
0.0810578316450119,
-0.06662900000810623,
-0.22880378365516663,
1.0085372924804688,
-0.3581909239292145,
0.8027716279029846,
-0.25115886330604553,
-0.5564460754394531,
-0.14301741123199463,
0.14784374833106995,
-0.6395372152328491,
1.1058716773986816,
-0.3006167709827423,
-0.6058984398841858,
0.5740275979042053,
-1.016549825668335,
-0.03837381303310394,
-0.08679519593715668,
-0.6322085857391357,
-0.10921251773834229,
-0.00033364605042152107,
0.5146106481552124,
0.4981081783771515,
-0.40677347779273987,
0.26380759477615356,
-0.41403281688690186,
0.1440708041191101,
0.13619287312030792,
-0.9124407172203064,
0.45906394720077515,
0.21673598885536194,
-0.3365585505962372,
0.12925389409065247,
-0.9030323028564453,
-0.3359001576900482,
0.08583430200815201,
-0.27324041724205017,
-0.15706944465637207,
-0.05643938481807709,
0.5484644770622253,
0.6455782651901245,
-0.16514675319194794,
-0.6205753684043884,
0.48757532238960266,
-0.07397165894508362,
0.15209515392780304,
0.81389319896698,
0.07184299826622009,
0.4685724675655365,
0.0076035805977880955,
0.44449782371520996,
0.3502708673477173,
0.07249912619590759,
-0.6184278130531311,
-0.6074750423431396,
-0.2047407478094101,
-0.5827586650848389,
0.3366323411464691,
0.6613708734512329,
-0.8876489996910095,
0.24371446669101715,
-0.11234673112630844,
-0.05550787225365639,
-0.29158225655555725,
0.286425918340683,
-0.22785229980945587,
0.5501716732978821,
0.29430946707725525,
-0.046716950833797455,
-0.8423404097557068,
-0.6917487978935242,
0.13142898678779602,
-0.13200099766254425,
-0.11257858574390411,
0.31790974736213684,
0.11693187803030014,
-0.20505717396736145,
0.8365932703018188,
-0.2582182288169861,
-0.5283718705177307,
-0.32047605514526367,
0.5100460648536682,
-0.022987285628914833,
0.5780705809593201,
0.6054155230522156,
-0.9224581718444824,
-0.2551230490207672,
0.13789984583854675,
-0.981752336025238,
-0.39372795820236206,
-0.47205522656440735,
-0.24426865577697754,
0.2348899096250534,
0.7282533645629883,
-0.7081776857376099,
0.5222405195236206,
0.45364904403686523,
-0.5369880199432373,
0.46585458517074585,
0.05408668518066406,
0.4903988838195801,
-1.4898837804794312,
-0.132401704788208,
-0.09619934856891632,
-0.22468818724155426,
-0.3099413514137268,
-0.2614325284957886,
-0.10034477710723877,
-0.2896518111228943,
-0.5464243292808533,
0.8448459506034851,
-0.4922824800014496,
0.25618860125541687,
-0.2909112572669983,
0.45987701416015625,
0.3358316421508789,
0.3499983549118042,
0.03322111815214157,
0.40224069356918335,
0.5833702087402344,
-0.3144950866699219,
0.40147534012794495,
0.22783292829990387,
0.1441529244184494,
0.8885545134544373,
-0.25641417503356934,
-0.054425619542598724,
-0.17769227921962738,
0.05746125802397728,
-1.1249661445617676,
-0.3394400477409363,
0.24750803411006927,
-0.2863065004348755,
0.5081735253334045,
-0.3022792339324951,
-0.5665480494499207,
-0.13208051025867462,
-0.31840941309928894,
0.4004824757575989,
0.1858813315629959,
-0.6501240730285645,
1.1030710935592651,
0.1615566611289978,
-0.1936638355255127,
-0.5927406549453735,
-0.3974372446537018,
0.4984985888004303,
-0.3498815894126892,
-0.9379078149795532,
0.40369731187820435,
-0.09658844769001007,
0.17966565489768982,
0.056506142020225525,
-0.11269115656614304,
0.011181036941707134,
-0.19491049647331238,
0.22326186299324036,
0.3333556652069092,
-0.7849775552749634,
0.24601948261260986,
0.17015284299850464,
-0.3466305732727051,
-0.2887607514858246,
-0.38641229271888733,
0.39289769530296326,
0.2223733365535736,
-0.7827561497688293,
-0.7371249794960022,
0.998950719833374,
0.6074822545051575,
-0.1999310553073883,
0.49360907077789307,
1.1772640943527222,
-0.6144676208496094,
0.3789064288139343,
-0.8869463205337524,
-0.31949689984321594,
-0.4100857675075531,
0.4067869484424591,
-0.42608368396759033,
-0.679695188999176,
0.4130379259586334,
-0.18852663040161133,
0.2261490374803543,
0.6827468276023865,
0.4371495544910431,
-0.4068395793437958,
1.2618300914764404,
0.4695838391780853,
0.29227691888809204,
0.6693423390388489,
-0.02845161035656929,
-0.3064768612384796,
-0.5992130041122437,
-0.18487805128097534,
-0.3704054057598114,
-0.360664963722229,
-0.16858284175395966,
-0.6381886601448059,
0.26479628682136536,
0.2960568070411682,
0.3128376305103302,
0.04478013888001442,
0.021107900887727737,
0.50083327293396,
0.16070452332496643,
-0.39863160252571106,
0.4806573987007141,
0.30890998244285583,
-0.42965975403785706,
-0.6237767338752747,
-0.7649375200271606,
-0.7430126070976257,
0.7907673120498657,
0.1545838713645935,
0.48327112197875977,
0.38217657804489136,
0.4965054392814636,
0.33314359188079834,
0.4650365114212036,
-0.44054147601127625,
0.3693343698978424,
-0.27010369300842285,
-0.6221351623535156,
-0.16218779981136322,
-0.1473233997821808,
-0.9763614535331726,
0.5087713599205017,
-0.6216345429420471,
-1.1837109327316284,
0.35325106978416443,
-0.2054740935564041,
0.011643907986581326,
0.6032320261001587,
-0.6233195066452026,
1.1642779111862183,
0.09066446125507355,
-0.38861948251724243,
-0.022547243162989616,
-0.35734280943870544,
0.2782667577266693,
0.00877262931317091,
0.3460956811904907,
-0.28577542304992676,
-0.18991567194461823,
0.7977603673934937,
-0.20220385491847992,
0.6179064512252808,
-0.013786593452095985,
0.05011943727731705,
0.28737732768058777,
-0.08169859647750854,
0.3321094512939453,
0.44546666741371155,
0.18569184839725494,
-0.29677632451057434,
0.05033191666007042,
-0.3840670585632324,
-0.8557054400444031,
0.3855327367782593,
-0.45084309577941895,
-0.4748319089412689,
-0.20889344811439514,
-0.2801823318004608,
-0.12206806242465973,
0.19064481556415558,
0.4318869709968567,
1.06526780128479,
-0.34428656101226807,
0.34592366218566895,
0.5636136531829834,
0.02143268659710884,
0.8675867915153503,
0.5691990256309509,
-0.27314692735671997,
-0.6905815005302429,
0.8529865741729736,
-0.11732035130262375,
-0.09535342454910278,
0.4569496810436249,
0.19910456240177155,
-0.4549892544746399,
-0.11883144825696945,
-1.1391565799713135,
0.004869671072810888,
-0.8812219500541687,
-0.4127514958381653,
-1.1898728609085083,
0.1634753942489624,
-0.06017312780022621,
-0.3547745645046234,
-0.37149614095687866,
-0.5670273303985596,
-0.5800230503082275,
-0.09872085601091385,
0.03338569030165672,
0.35159704089164734,
-0.33000972867012024,
0.3696669340133667,
-1.3061857223510742,
0.37956884503364563,
0.22992537915706635,
0.13449427485466003,
-0.2657645046710968,
-0.2948826849460602,
0.2800031006336212,
-0.17486155033111572,
-0.7672944068908691,
-1.3849296569824219,
-0.018669771030545235,
0.3452645540237427,
0.8304046392440796,
0.717570960521698,
-0.21838557720184326,
0.8722414970397949,
-0.4672423005104065,
0.7015925049781799,
0.7195402979850769,
-0.7686495184898376,
0.544198215007782,
-0.3070577085018158,
0.11485433578491211,
0.4055996537208557,
0.24475672841072083,
-0.5396432876586914,
-0.30805546045303345,
-0.8719198703765869,
-0.6074109077453613,
0.48975640535354614,
0.3139817714691162,
0.11907871812582016,
-0.0725373923778534,
0.28643614053726196,
0.21689072251319885,
-0.15902996063232422,
-0.7367659211158752,
-0.09039285778999329,
-0.10170212388038635,
-0.5686715245246887,
0.27741724252700806,
-0.23604506254196167,
0.0005263510975055397,
-0.06107323244214058,
0.381860613822937,
-0.3197796642780304,
0.26446864008903503,
0.3762204647064209,
-0.27533629536628723,
-0.24273031949996948,
0.41443493962287903,
0.7496188879013062,
0.4486290514469147,
-0.030978888273239136,
0.22172263264656067,
0.10639478266239166,
-0.4427131414413452,
0.16256815195083618,
0.17293931543827057,
0.16616655886173248,
0.2663053572177887,
0.4190142750740051,
0.4843275547027588,
0.34979358315467834,
-0.7396747469902039,
0.6536773443222046,
-0.3596697747707367,
-0.3003228008747101,
0.029885664582252502,
-0.2452523410320282,
0.022249825298786163,
0.39335429668426514,
0.5016852021217346,
0.24129252135753632,
0.34044748544692993,
-0.4461081326007843,
0.6904813051223755,
0.39310070872306824,
-0.720164954662323,
-0.3641470968723297,
0.7774376273155212,
0.18305380642414093,
0.11973373591899872,
0.20317305624485016,
-0.12094434350728989,
-0.1384613960981369,
0.3213500678539276,
0.5584982633590698,
0.7740278244018555,
0.07005657255649567,
0.2736632227897644,
0.2819640636444092,
0.33443987369537354,
0.39577150344848633,
0.478424608707428,
0.17628200352191925,
-0.5026364922523499,
-0.6935731768608093,
-0.5006882548332214,
-0.15310123562812805,
0.2745979130268097,
-0.4385450482368469,
0.598017692565918,
-0.08581778407096863,
-0.2022358775138855,
0.2861713171005249,
-0.21431869268417358,
-0.6930544376373291,
0.180927112698555,
0.47045451402664185,
1.0571223497390747,
-0.920063853263855,
0.4598824381828308,
0.8973298072814941,
-0.6173916459083557,
-0.6522729992866516,
-0.26604774594306946,
0.28218188881874084,
-0.18731090426445007,
0.3410196900367737,
0.16809608042240143,
0.14735150337219238,
-0.2202378660440445,
-0.3187664747238159,
-0.6232935786247253,
0.9681820273399353,
0.4587472975254059,
-0.00442739250138402,
0.2440919131040573,
0.047932885587215424,
0.14792953431606293,
-0.7653887271881104,
0.38598164916038513,
0.036628078669309616,
0.7384873032569885,
0.4366023540496826,
-0.5086801648139954,
0.01258813589811325,
-0.23563385009765625,
-0.23106327652931213,
0.09721888601779938,
-0.1645982712507248,
0.4003995358943939,
-0.19804708659648895,
-0.3240501880645752,
-0.12610609829425812,
1.0880937576293945,
0.1431429535150528,
0.6866521239280701,
0.5261242389678955,
0.46217218041419983,
0.6092578768730164,
-0.006517812609672546,
0.7285261154174805,
0.37220990657806396,
0.08423471450805664,
1.0542845726013184,
-0.2456439882516861,
0.8745132088661194,
0.634078323841095,
0.07575111836194992,
0.6141190528869629,
0.5840232372283936,
0.06831639260053635,
0.3127593398094177,
-0.49772945046424866,
-0.11832095682621002,
-0.5258644819259644,
-0.24726422131061554,
-0.37551185488700867,
0.7879018187522888,
0.2740052342414856,
-0.08459455519914627,
-0.5746962428092957,
0.27558133006095886,
-0.059490762650966644,
-0.11887155473232269,
-0.02329339273273945,
0.9360480904579163,
-0.02724234014749527,
-0.4528885781764984,
-0.05113530904054642,
0.15572504699230194,
0.3328695297241211,
-0.4838821589946747,
-0.24714581668376923,
-0.022102901712059975,
-0.1195751503109932,
-0.15610364079475403,
-0.7381506562232971,
0.42228102684020996,
0.035412535071372986,
-0.3786769211292267,
0.15025636553764343,
0.8634150624275208,
-0.511671781539917,
-0.45837855339050293,
0.24897827208042145,
0.7776110172271729,
-0.08387291431427002,
-0.0020160444546490908,
-0.6769117116928101,
-0.06994757801294327,
0.017069470137357712,
-0.291925311088562,
0.3873458504676819,
0.8465467095375061,
-0.21339718997478485,
0.26387739181518555,
0.950829803943634,
-0.40057578682899475,
0.24402965605258942,
0.1949082762002945,
0.6593800187110901,
-0.6521692276000977,
-0.5404927730560303,
-1.1188130378723145,
0.9853302240371704,
-0.4234383702278137,
-0.38865864276885986,
0.36675888299942017,
0.5578166842460632,
0.262635201215744,
-0.1728876233100891,
0.5121909379959106,
-0.02335374243557453,
-0.1430688351392746,
-0.7255327105522156,
0.3633463382720947,
-0.9476154446601868,
-0.05777900293469429,
-0.4603743255138397,
-0.8448317050933838,
-0.2614114582538605,
0.10415806621313095,
0.33766189217567444,
-0.28949081897735596,
0.6665937304496765,
0.5503150820732117,
-0.5884900689125061,
0.4270922839641571,
0.5527170300483704,
-0.2370045930147171,
0.6177785992622375,
0.30705904960632324,
0.9338459968566895,
-0.46407008171081543,
0.7708014249801636,
-0.00482209213078022,
-0.2891058027744293,
-0.413669615983963,
-1.4349149465560913,
-0.8280353546142578,
-0.8040696382522583,
-0.523233950138092,
-0.09400564432144165,
-0.38440465927124023,
1.0982528924942017,
0.761638879776001,
-0.8902773261070251,
0.041473109275102615,
0.3511926531791687,
0.1381387710571289,
-0.09180785715579987,
-0.21804676949977875,
0.27924033999443054,
-0.2604922354221344,
-0.6347971558570862,
0.3623487949371338,
0.7551448941230774,
0.2307361215353012,
0.15603896975517273,
0.07876438647508621,
-0.5244678258895874,
0.3171452283859253,
0.6671109795570374,
0.2250295728445053,
-0.7535516023635864,
-0.33784621953964233,
-0.04802194610238075,
-0.09964675456285477,
0.26894813776016235,
0.8908616900444031,
-0.3058013617992401,
0.5416475534439087,
0.46503540873527527,
0.7454656958580017,
0.36340418457984924,
-0.16632036864757538,
0.6529117226600647,
-1.0519930124282837,
0.24829962849617004,
-0.24969550967216492,
0.7599895000457764,
0.21954424679279327,
-0.18328920006752014,
0.3958733081817627,
0.5305108428001404,
-0.08949872851371765,
-0.8368727564811707,
0.16703206300735474,
-1.541178584098816,
-0.07461230456829071,
1.0107011795043945,
0.2086268812417984,
-0.10369271785020828,
-0.2680257260799408,
-0.6430237293243408,
0.25730663537979126,
-0.2800677418708801,
0.35149267315864563,
0.8522645831108093,
-0.023276545107364655,
-0.47486042976379395,
-0.7868133187294006,
0.30998659133911133,
0.3892393112182617,
-0.83906090259552,
-0.278890460729599,
0.5268186926841736,
0.15694527328014374,
0.31831273436546326,
0.6402202844619751,
-0.2145216017961502,
0.6241382360458374,
-0.1186102107167244,
0.04485644772648811,
-0.13532933592796326,
-0.4107173681259155,
-0.04996645078063011,
0.5079320073127747,
-0.4440751373767853,
-0.16701556742191315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12419v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12419v1
|
AI-Assisted Human Evaluation of Machine Translation
| 2024-06-18T09:12:11 | 2024-06-18T09:12:11 |
Vilém Zouhar, Tom Kocmi, Mrinmaya Sachan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Annually, research teams spend large amounts of money to evaluate the quality
of machine translation systems (WMT, inter alia). This is expensive because it
requires detailed human labor. The recently proposed annotation protocol, Error
Span Annotation (ESA), has annotators marking erroneous parts of the
translation. In our work, we help the annotators by pre-filling the span
annotations with automatic quality estimation. With AI assistance, we obtain
more detailed annotations while cutting down the time per span annotation by
half (71s/error span $\rightarrow$ 31s/error span). The biggest advantage of
ESA$^\mathrm{AI}$ protocol is an accurate priming of annotators (pre-filled
error spans) before they assign the final score as opposed to starting from
scratch. In addition, the annotation budget can be reduced by up to 24% with
filtering of examples that the AI deems to be very likely to be correct.
|
[
-0.4688977599143982,
-0.4736116826534271,
0.3786316514015198,
0.4448522627353668,
-0.24180477857589722,
0.1274256855249405,
-0.08369164913892746,
-0.7607781887054443,
0.19416362047195435,
0.31168898940086365,
-0.36376506090164185,
-0.13793452084064484,
-0.8854895234107971,
0.4765014946460724,
-0.4321959316730499,
0.8511228561401367,
-0.3760139048099518,
0.12856371700763702,
0.12123344838619232,
-0.1210440844297409,
-0.41396328806877136,
-0.41934794187545776,
-0.836747407913208,
-0.20239600539207458,
0.39838117361068726,
0.3799302577972412,
0.9952422380447388,
1.01071298122406,
0.9922518730163574,
0.35446619987487793,
0.10373906046152115,
0.4591655433177948,
0.013498364947736263,
-0.13919125497341156,
0.13963541388511658,
-0.479225754737854,
-0.7501671314239502,
0.2990533411502838,
0.34480032324790955,
0.7400590181350708,
0.18982209265232086,
0.21205930411815643,
-0.059024471789598465,
0.9622893333435059,
-0.49218472838401794,
0.09774820506572723,
-0.28396156430244446,
0.206610769033432,
-0.2090897113084793,
-0.255176305770874,
-0.4451645314693451,
-0.20545144379138947,
0.18698303401470184,
-0.759169340133667,
0.029833346605300903,
0.3869614005088806,
1.1233330965042114,
0.889478325843811,
-0.10815183818340302,
0.01919858530163765,
-0.6760001182556152,
0.7340449690818787,
-0.5435881614685059,
0.18804509937763214,
0.8308698534965515,
0.36108970642089844,
-0.16524989902973175,
-0.7117491364479065,
-0.555921733379364,
-0.2830493450164795,
-0.3041136860847473,
0.23956821858882904,
-0.2801516354084015,
0.38322123885154724,
0.1924765259027481,
0.4230353534221649,
-0.35035061836242676,
0.08304174244403839,
-0.3793744742870331,
-0.4527064263820648,
0.8888133764266968,
-0.024314893409609795,
0.5359380841255188,
-0.015959739685058594,
-0.265550434589386,
-0.27484601736068726,
-0.3650633990764618,
-0.27889037132263184,
0.18198387324810028,
0.0621614083647728,
0.20725587010383606,
0.7085943222045898,
-0.2389245331287384,
0.619245707988739,
0.11671581864356995,
0.12725737690925598,
0.46559399366378784,
-0.4053040146827698,
-0.4657869040966034,
-0.15551301836967468,
0.9005829691886902,
0.5504810810089111,
0.5256686210632324,
-0.37806347012519836,
-0.4619634449481964,
0.19911637902259827,
0.3425770401954651,
-0.5489859580993652,
-0.03986049070954323,
0.19684310257434845,
-0.4911651313304901,
-0.06523552536964417,
0.2103199064731598,
-0.5248494148254395,
-0.15136945247650146,
-0.29073160886764526,
0.6793749928474426,
-0.4379898011684418,
0.22222070395946503,
0.04245365038514137,
-0.1174120381474495,
-0.03346576914191246,
0.5105024576187134,
-0.43908435106277466,
0.2430862933397293,
0.20945583283901215,
0.8703864216804504,
-0.005587036721408367,
-0.564486026763916,
-0.8853492140769958,
-0.04423307254910469,
-0.40420830249786377,
0.8972505331039429,
-0.23179274797439575,
-0.36336296796798706,
-0.3890647888183594,
-0.18805737793445587,
-0.14618262648582458,
-0.4364093542098999,
0.8258054852485657,
-0.4953018128871918,
0.24639487266540527,
-0.22368240356445312,
-0.5448987483978271,
-0.24221237003803253,
0.14943285286426544,
-0.841090202331543,
1.082926630973816,
0.16674885153770447,
-0.6539551019668579,
0.6314914226531982,
-1.189208984375,
-0.4967116713523865,
0.11445122957229614,
0.15522536635398865,
-0.2633775472640991,
0.027034929022192955,
0.6298467516899109,
0.30614328384399414,
-0.19146838784217834,
0.13503830134868622,
0.24718916416168213,
-0.6137192249298096,
0.22182504832744598,
-0.40868040919303894,
0.5386233329772949,
0.5051640868186951,
-0.6063905358314514,
0.47619304060935974,
-0.6497960090637207,
-0.0869055688381195,
-0.18420566618442535,
-0.5593750476837158,
-0.3950919806957245,
-0.11953659355640411,
0.10155123472213745,
0.16626423597335815,
0.002186537254601717,
-0.48229488730430603,
0.22367021441459656,
-0.4978477954864502,
0.23212961852550507,
0.7716950178146362,
-0.13615170121192932,
0.4515005052089691,
-0.38193026185035706,
0.6395504474639893,
-0.2602161765098572,
0.255972683429718,
-0.2250344157218933,
-0.6131279468536377,
-0.9401738047599792,
-0.5352603793144226,
0.7199617624282837,
0.5927584767341614,
-0.4984361529350281,
0.7447156310081482,
-0.026121867820620537,
-0.4483194649219513,
-1.2896062135696411,
-0.005481684114784002,
0.5268746018409729,
0.29214125871658325,
0.6845051050186157,
-0.4625522494316101,
-0.5378002524375916,
-0.9481472373008728,
-0.2577314078807831,
-0.3840150237083435,
-0.08383891731500626,
-0.1249469667673111,
0.5271204710006714,
-0.30442386865615845,
0.8684102296829224,
-0.18669532239437103,
-0.5511237978935242,
-0.09046944975852966,
0.6713840961456299,
-0.31508904695510864,
0.6135532855987549,
0.460584819316864,
-0.7020425796508789,
-0.583693265914917,
-0.1600397527217865,
-0.36013898253440857,
-0.5523068308830261,
-0.2579449415206909,
-0.28855082392692566,
0.2678758203983307,
0.4396473169326782,
-0.5761607885360718,
0.6448848247528076,
0.5255110859870911,
-0.4790799021720886,
0.4767226278781891,
-0.46607306599617004,
0.6512048244476318,
-0.8780874013900757,
0.3382395803928375,
-0.06497595459222794,
-0.3639523983001709,
-0.21900233626365662,
-0.04579675942659378,
-0.008909267373383045,
0.15843452513217926,
-0.17092353105545044,
0.336465984582901,
-0.5388376116752625,
-0.19091248512268066,
-0.32363247871398926,
0.17036791145801544,
0.1642417013645172,
0.3055046796798706,
-0.1298108696937561,
1.1819145679473877,
-0.038375746458768845,
-0.39418524503707886,
0.19138985872268677,
0.3759661614894867,
-0.12874962389469147,
0.575115442276001,
-0.7205074429512024,
0.14982058107852936,
-0.08517926186323166,
0.4113752245903015,
-0.9927281737327576,
-0.21445916593074799,
0.3380450904369354,
-0.704675018787384,
0.2089768350124359,
0.06611417979001999,
-0.6776245832443237,
-0.30143195390701294,
-0.2226700484752655,
0.18022805452346802,
0.44423186779022217,
-0.3634280264377594,
0.44397294521331787,
0.42645373940467834,
-0.03920940309762955,
-0.6499065160751343,
-0.9121860265731812,
0.4610302448272705,
-0.07945919036865234,
-0.46519580483436584,
0.32835492491722107,
0.047544192522764206,
-0.3095574378967285,
0.2661910057067871,
0.09362076967954636,
-0.0036015391815453768,
0.42926928400993347,
0.29170095920562744,
0.11926564574241638,
-0.10653086751699448,
0.12178708612918854,
0.13617883622646332,
-0.582369327545166,
-0.0716724768280983,
-0.2335551679134369,
0.3684827983379364,
-0.16049838066101074,
-0.67083740234375,
-0.9398012757301331,
0.4834916889667511,
0.7726475596427917,
-0.6592705249786377,
0.7206101417541504,
0.6557055115699768,
-0.5721321702003479,
0.21705125272274017,
-0.7020378112792969,
-0.024059860035777092,
-0.3354390263557434,
0.545920729637146,
-0.24937120079994202,
-0.45881399512290955,
0.3064184784889221,
0.030627712607383728,
0.17238345742225647,
0.9620510339736938,
0.13738606870174408,
-0.381771981716156,
1.2319881916046143,
0.5607466101646423,
-0.4130176603794098,
0.36778202652931213,
-0.15588510036468506,
-0.09675829112529755,
-0.7366394996643066,
-0.021016288548707962,
-0.8449386358261108,
-0.5946503281593323,
-0.19300279021263123,
-0.499372661113739,
0.3671463131904602,
0.19331388175487518,
-0.1738881915807724,
0.3752512037754059,
-0.4440593421459198,
0.33320051431655884,
0.853216290473938,
-0.05987607315182686,
0.45128974318504333,
-0.1781250387430191,
0.04480210691690445,
-0.2011413276195526,
-0.36137720942497253,
-0.8471905589103699,
1.0635509490966797,
0.5330305695533752,
0.4149164855480194,
-0.14177894592285156,
0.5537684559822083,
0.7454773783683777,
0.7107976675033569,
-0.7421049475669861,
0.4259074032306671,
0.08361206203699112,
-0.4342349171638489,
-0.4380389451980591,
-0.35618194937705994,
-0.7825749516487122,
0.06551235169172287,
-0.33476659655570984,
-0.5924602746963501,
-0.13098368048667908,
0.3925043046474457,
-0.3649843633174896,
0.25016656517982483,
-0.8807001113891602,
0.8059870600700378,
-0.357817679643631,
0.0539543516933918,
-0.244539275765419,
-0.9494624137878418,
-0.22809846699237823,
-0.22727321088314056,
0.05283249169588089,
-0.023059936240315437,
-0.050511281937360764,
1.0968583822250366,
-0.606361985206604,
0.6792996525764465,
-0.3523533344268799,
0.31580862402915955,
0.29385167360305786,
0.023969532921910286,
0.6729817390441895,
-0.5192723274230957,
-0.19707274436950684,
-0.05363720282912254,
-0.2685856819152832,
-0.40038686990737915,
-0.2979336678981781,
0.00804158765822649,
-0.8768773078918457,
-0.37576815485954285,
-0.32822850346565247,
-0.6629747748374939,
-0.2304716259241104,
0.20674389600753784,
0.3449785113334656,
-0.09621307998895645,
0.027705317363142967,
-0.03775889053940773,
0.04636495187878609,
-0.15122205018997192,
0.37788674235343933,
0.25691553950309753,
0.0055742450058460236,
-0.45787933468818665,
0.5791639089584351,
0.08331993222236633,
0.14369729161262512,
0.3743324875831604,
0.10432250797748566,
-0.2332475632429123,
-0.6833285689353943,
-0.9656820893287659,
0.1762203425168991,
-0.49522000551223755,
-0.3825784921646118,
-0.6519288420677185,
-0.018083490431308746,
-0.12037060409784317,
-0.15594112873077393,
-0.500586986541748,
-0.6048403382301331,
-0.0367094986140728,
-0.40949371457099915,
0.3492443859577179,
0.4727489948272705,
-0.16492798924446106,
0.5675056576728821,
-1.0279580354690552,
-0.006057424005120993,
-0.17461954057216644,
0.13649919629096985,
-0.25898119807243347,
-0.5965422987937927,
-0.5323994159698486,
0.039165228605270386,
-0.20282971858978271,
-0.8577010631561279,
0.35171744227409363,
0.16542944312095642,
0.5160756707191467,
0.2717447876930237,
0.050696711987257004,
1.0220749378204346,
-0.4384136199951172,
0.7597178220748901,
-0.01161911804229021,
-1.2429752349853516,
0.455022394657135,
0.16558900475502014,
0.06683050841093063,
0.7525913715362549,
0.16307684779167175,
-0.5049440860748291,
-0.5663242340087891,
-0.42551469802856445,
-1.1088773012161255,
0.6417122483253479,
0.40872418880462646,
-0.1956169754266739,
0.08391311019659042,
0.33916136622428894,
0.0546860508620739,
0.11293856054544449,
-0.34523090720176697,
-0.28862613439559937,
-0.03490619361400604,
-0.3231615722179413,
-0.039269059896469116,
-0.13627706468105316,
-0.010018456727266312,
-0.10414284467697144,
0.9499778747558594,
-0.05802478641271591,
0.2212095707654953,
0.38837674260139465,
-0.4542510509490967,
-0.5206543803215027,
0.2242855578660965,
0.5894960761070251,
0.7278285026550293,
-0.1718575805425644,
0.10247375816106796,
0.26386162638664246,
-0.34628066420555115,
0.11828146874904633,
0.3617399334907532,
-0.21818217635154724,
0.10908747464418411,
0.5473072528839111,
0.7699830532073975,
-0.4696606397628784,
-0.7560762166976929,
0.5233079195022583,
0.11894773691892624,
-0.09162599593400955,
-0.10491028428077698,
-0.2530350387096405,
-0.19377252459526062,
0.1364489495754242,
0.6034495234489441,
0.44308388233184814,
0.2859724462032318,
-0.0535794273018837,
0.33264991641044617,
0.17612160742282867,
-0.4570172429084778,
-0.2898281216621399,
0.8032710552215576,
0.46292710304260254,
-0.4102708697319031,
0.6451111435890198,
-0.18677093088626862,
-0.7025309205055237,
0.5883015990257263,
0.3620794117450714,
0.9582672715187073,
-0.3978269100189209,
0.11639735847711563,
0.24000561237335205,
0.7192943692207336,
-0.2001403421163559,
0.03013070672750473,
0.05979021266102791,
-0.387800395488739,
-0.9168893098831177,
-0.5685854554176331,
-0.49305590987205505,
-0.15494874119758606,
-0.603794276714325,
0.07689068466424942,
0.09608817845582962,
-0.2393570989370346,
-0.15162450075149536,
-0.0889948233962059,
-0.5913696885108948,
0.6320269703865051,
-0.03472676873207092,
1.012385368347168,
-1.0342307090759277,
0.6220142841339111,
0.9668049812316895,
-0.7682868242263794,
-0.8328846096992493,
0.06700945645570755,
-0.26785871386528015,
-0.7673002481460571,
0.7970139980316162,
0.18365058302879333,
-0.2709426283836365,
-0.04580799117684364,
-0.1543082743883133,
-0.6330658197402954,
0.8134341239929199,
0.3865014612674713,
-0.5697497129440308,
-0.14657807350158691,
0.20671114325523376,
0.7388754487037659,
-0.10376113653182983,
0.30330368876457214,
0.6585796475410461,
0.8429324626922607,
-0.2935464084148407,
-1.2799535989761353,
0.040905844420194626,
-0.3014869689941406,
-0.22327204048633575,
0.41244906187057495,
-0.3914109766483307,
0.47863975167274475,
-0.21501311659812927,
-0.20219074189662933,
0.10427643358707428,
0.7086829543113708,
-0.3139527440071106,
0.3490282893180847,
0.7688000202178955,
0.43407076597213745,
0.808061957359314,
-0.1893775463104248,
1.0467809438705444,
-0.21082787215709686,
0.18723046779632568,
0.8650469779968262,
0.08813530951738358,
0.7722859382629395,
0.8024193644523621,
-0.34635812044143677,
0.025037100538611412,
0.7605844736099243,
-0.06498932838439941,
0.26262354850769043,
0.3220725655555725,
0.09197579324245453,
-0.07562761008739471,
-0.0820007249712944,
-0.2829700708389282,
0.2950485646724701,
0.21176034212112427,
-0.5077869892120361,
0.1066880002617836,
0.0028553486336022615,
0.20441319048404694,
0.19476176798343658,
-0.018865076825022697,
0.7860097289085388,
-0.19556361436843872,
-0.8503578305244446,
0.20572839677333832,
0.31753700971603394,
0.5879088640213013,
-0.3920629918575287,
-0.041519757360219955,
-0.3629591464996338,
0.1507813036441803,
-0.2921856939792633,
-0.4991956055164337,
0.6519197821617126,
0.2744242548942566,
-0.04601304233074188,
-0.1811799556016922,
0.341526061296463,
-0.3325093686580658,
-0.37278756499290466,
0.2114078551530838,
0.620546817779541,
0.4095800518989563,
-0.3438316285610199,
-0.6584013104438782,
0.04912461340427399,
-0.14490555226802826,
-0.4688502848148346,
-0.048201341181993484,
0.21376124024391174,
-0.3256608843803406,
0.5400466322898865,
0.5233651995658875,
0.3050782084465027,
-0.06971398741006851,
-0.04720228537917137,
0.585810661315918,
-0.5831931233406067,
-0.477571576833725,
-0.8780744671821594,
0.6741963624954224,
-0.08501820266246796,
-0.25308266282081604,
0.555694043636322,
0.45130106806755066,
0.8263183832168579,
-0.014314083382487297,
0.9161545634269714,
-0.1157742291688919,
0.32955557107925415,
-0.3531172275543213,
0.8769151568412781,
-0.6698468923568726,
0.17757581174373627,
-0.5030999779701233,
-0.7367082238197327,
-0.6920557022094727,
0.8337015509605408,
-0.1880665272474289,
-0.010085041634738445,
0.7299632430076599,
0.46652647852897644,
0.12138295918703079,
-0.06058167666196823,
0.14907993376255035,
-0.003435302758589387,
0.40692609548568726,
0.2401471734046936,
0.8566709756851196,
-0.5964342355728149,
0.6234583854675293,
-0.1500694304704666,
-0.4624454379081726,
-0.30925217270851135,
-0.8603241443634033,
-0.535844087600708,
-0.4679306447505951,
-0.4663296043872833,
-0.37471726536750793,
0.13447034358978271,
1.3460795879364014,
0.7475076913833618,
-0.8010022044181824,
-0.0729655772447586,
0.030280258506536484,
-0.2667846083641052,
-0.6314959526062012,
-0.1574469804763794,
0.7747536897659302,
-0.44949179887771606,
-1.0746310949325562,
0.320594847202301,
0.34923070669174194,
0.03156716004014015,
-0.07925844937562943,
-0.2291709929704666,
-0.15299928188323975,
0.045842260122299194,
0.3303922116756439,
0.11147726327180862,
-0.6877822279930115,
-0.4918366074562073,
-0.11108403652906418,
-0.3377034366130829,
0.14761985838413239,
0.44167008996009827,
-0.43683290481567383,
0.5444988012313843,
0.29270684719085693,
1.252408504486084,
0.27689531445503235,
0.2457723170518875,
0.6907601356506348,
-0.5768638849258423,
0.13810127973556519,
0.20368081331253052,
0.4635297358036041,
0.43796366453170776,
-0.28546279668807983,
0.7945939302444458,
0.19216525554656982,
-0.6389070153236389,
-0.7815890908241272,
-0.14291369915008545,
-0.8239215016365051,
0.1743348389863968,
0.7304216623306274,
-0.4583912491798401,
-0.18261004984378815,
-0.05224526301026344,
-0.7993665337562561,
0.4951455593109131,
-0.4592134356498718,
0.9835869669914246,
0.7270429730415344,
-0.26171374320983887,
0.2130715250968933,
-0.3580799102783203,
0.5159177184104919,
0.7293200492858887,
-1.046093225479126,
-0.29661160707473755,
0.561333179473877,
-0.10254983603954315,
0.4284559488296509,
0.7100464105606079,
-0.0931166410446167,
0.42489179968833923,
-0.07650905102491379,
0.3425748944282532,
-0.3344652056694031,
-0.2965407967567444,
-0.0006288869772106409,
-0.01821533404290676,
0.426059365272522,
-0.8859210014343262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12416v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12416v2
|
Beyond Under-Alignment: Atomic Preference Enhanced Factuality Tuning for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-18T09:07:30 | 2024-06-27T12:07:55 |
Hongbang Yuan, Yubo Chen, Pengfei Cao, Zhuoran Jin, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success but still tend
to generate factually erroneous responses, a phenomenon known as hallucination.
A recent trend is to use preference learning to fine-tune models to align with
factuality. However, existing work primarily evaluates fine-tuned models on
in-domain (ID) datasets and the factuality on out-of-domain (OOD) datasets
remains underexplored. In this paper, we conduct a comprehensive evaluation of
the factuality of different models tuned by various preference learning
algorithms and demonstrate that their performance on OOD datasets either
increases minimally or decreases. Subsequently, we reveal that the main cause
of model's failure to uphold factuality under a distribution shift is
\textbf{under-alignment}, rather than \textbf{over-alignment}, by analyzing the
token distribution shift of the models before and after tuning. Finally, we
propose \textbf{APEFT} (\textbf{A}tomic \textbf{P}reference \textbf{E}nhanced
\textbf{F}actuality \textbf{T}uning), a framework that enhances model's
awareness of factuality at the granularity of individual facts. Extensive
experiments demonstrate that APEFT improves model performance by an average of
$\boldsymbol{3.45\%}$ on both ID and OOD datasets, which is highly effective.
|
[
-0.4674375653266907,
-0.7887584567070007,
0.7944872975349426,
-0.3731064200401306,
-0.33219483494758606,
-0.0846165344119072,
-0.41252243518829346,
-0.46449440717697144,
0.028595522046089172,
0.5888594388961792,
-0.30843642354011536,
-0.4315255880355835,
-0.4381439685821533,
0.14798958599567413,
-0.09459897875785828,
1.0610268115997314,
0.1886017620563507,
-0.07472813129425049,
-0.21019725501537323,
-0.19511432945728302,
-0.2462487816810608,
-0.5881322622299194,
-0.15648208558559418,
-0.44834378361701965,
0.1639983355998993,
0.4172775149345398,
1.119515061378479,
0.9666239023208618,
0.6338292360305786,
0.23431384563446045,
0.0037881263997405767,
0.6366686820983887,
-0.6028120517730713,
-0.1461101621389389,
-0.38818931579589844,
-0.4657030403614044,
-0.6564656496047974,
-0.029944974929094315,
0.6341812610626221,
0.6828985810279846,
-0.11712885648012161,
0.0418948233127594,
-0.16817235946655273,
0.7730484008789062,
-0.7470635771751404,
0.045056138187646866,
-1.0649455785751343,
-0.1566990613937378,
-0.1241670697927475,
-0.24547839164733887,
-0.5102006793022156,
-0.5111306309700012,
0.2613869905471802,
-0.6938775181770325,
0.3029499351978302,
0.5046671032905579,
1.0609922409057617,
0.39071163535118103,
-0.5794327855110168,
-0.20225316286087036,
-0.7316727638244629,
0.920243501663208,
-0.8903847336769104,
0.6303797364234924,
0.5225387811660767,
-0.07724412530660629,
-0.16491059958934784,
-0.23827099800109863,
-0.6929828524589539,
-0.29658976197242737,
-0.08775615692138672,
-0.14433473348617554,
0.04928692802786827,
0.17475080490112305,
0.1219005435705185,
0.61991286277771,
-0.3615852892398834,
0.18168006837368011,
-0.02875680848956108,
-0.1220402866601944,
0.7594665288925171,
0.01908963918685913,
0.0782008171081543,
-0.013037523254752159,
-0.38137051463127136,
-0.15353693068027496,
-0.8358036875724792,
-0.3433988392353058,
0.4061729907989502,
0.582821249961853,
-0.08364490419626236,
0.6933320760726929,
-0.17438848316669464,
0.5041383504867554,
0.45755839347839355,
-0.09448738396167755,
0.42099234461784363,
-0.18650442361831665,
-0.3619944751262665,
0.37878453731536865,
0.48083269596099854,
0.36606207489967346,
0.26343873143196106,
-0.17047007381916046,
-0.3300234079360962,
0.09765397012233734,
0.35038745403289795,
-0.7623703479766846,
-0.21361975371837616,
0.2658977508544922,
-0.43182921409606934,
-0.28358694911003113,
0.20084726810455322,
-0.5441814064979553,
-0.6531223058700562,
-0.6992712616920471,
0.35216960310935974,
-0.4765819311141968,
-0.37842148542404175,
0.3181927502155304,
0.1304405927658081,
0.043276555836200714,
0.27410054206848145,
-1.151511788368225,
0.17899289727210999,
0.9301648139953613,
0.8752065896987915,
-0.4388611912727356,
-0.1826114058494568,
-0.3604835271835327,
0.0486186146736145,
-0.5969780087471008,
0.9811223149299622,
-0.5920066833496094,
-0.19597460329532623,
-0.12539973855018616,
-0.19526776671409607,
-0.1416967660188675,
-0.7930563688278198,
0.5983266830444336,
-0.7645860910415649,
-0.09417308121919632,
-0.6807196736335754,
-0.8233543038368225,
-0.2468140423297882,
0.19877664744853973,
-0.5345438122749329,
0.8698939085006714,
-0.1610768735408783,
-0.632217526435852,
0.8419158458709717,
-0.6430166363716125,
-0.34625279903411865,
-0.30732086300849915,
-0.1977444440126419,
-0.4578576683998108,
0.42046383023262024,
0.21377962827682495,
0.28134241700172424,
-0.3041365444660187,
0.5580547451972961,
-0.6506414413452148,
-0.30904102325439453,
0.48728689551353455,
-0.574155867099762,
0.5228273272514343,
0.16474668681621552,
-0.40122902393341064,
0.19696742296218872,
-0.8872803449630737,
-0.23744608461856842,
-0.08811106532812119,
-0.2237105667591095,
-0.41577979922294617,
0.14040035009384155,
-0.19541746377944946,
0.06194841116666794,
0.09098994731903076,
-0.48708993196487427,
0.28780388832092285,
-0.7349987030029297,
0.20969423651695251,
0.972788393497467,
-0.15290534496307373,
0.45118266344070435,
-0.5802826881408691,
0.032830312848091125,
0.09669540077447891,
0.07251647859811783,
0.25729164481163025,
-0.23604179918766022,
-0.7474732995033264,
-0.3358665108680725,
0.2381765991449356,
0.3464394807815552,
-0.24908104538917542,
0.7554882168769836,
-0.5026891827583313,
-0.14710856974124908,
-0.6138304471969604,
0.047942109405994415,
0.24863846600055695,
0.69630366563797,
0.47586172819137573,
-0.31517189741134644,
-0.3302075266838074,
-0.804443895816803,
-0.06451305747032166,
-0.3803653120994568,
0.2675187885761261,
0.46627524495124817,
0.4139452576637268,
-0.3545028865337372,
1.1810171604156494,
-0.5819065570831299,
-0.10626719892024994,
-0.0344160720705986,
0.1058831438422203,
0.1819598227739334,
0.3002922832965851,
0.44701462984085083,
-0.9466533064842224,
-0.2660243809223175,
0.30445873737335205,
-0.5669949054718018,
-0.010259795933961868,
0.08183524757623672,
-0.13552595674991608,
0.7247495055198669,
0.2936767041683197,
-0.7653687000274658,
0.31369221210479736,
0.30238261818885803,
-0.22783590853214264,
0.6509183645248413,
-0.19295033812522888,
0.2692246735095978,
-0.8846417665481567,
0.12141948938369751,
-0.14977285265922546,
-0.25160422921180725,
-0.43000733852386475,
-0.04198808968067169,
0.07192499935626984,
0.3372790217399597,
-0.4435521960258484,
0.5609102845191956,
-0.33989542722702026,
-0.15065883100032806,
-0.5179368257522583,
0.1391700804233551,
-0.10027068853378296,
0.3030903935432434,
0.3276900351047516,
0.8471875786781311,
0.4027266204357147,
-0.7577774524688721,
0.20104579627513885,
0.4377264082431793,
-0.4004592299461365,
0.3438788056373596,
-0.3916381895542145,
0.19596092402935028,
-0.11113762855529785,
0.029333114624023438,
-0.9941247701644897,
-0.27184823155403137,
0.15399014949798584,
-0.2645340859889984,
0.3510510325431824,
-0.11482993513345718,
-0.34136825799942017,
0.22092200815677643,
-0.40303879976272583,
0.4921676516532898,
0.4507980942726135,
-0.8361783623695374,
0.3707861304283142,
0.4346863627433777,
0.2337079793214798,
-0.7190932035446167,
-0.455111563205719,
-0.25501400232315063,
-0.42957279086112976,
-0.4126192629337311,
0.30825144052505493,
-0.09831774234771729,
-0.5146705508232117,
-0.06650300323963165,
-0.3296569287776947,
0.2447066307067871,
0.03494931384921074,
0.08900755643844604,
0.45525962114334106,
-0.4883843660354614,
0.28279298543930054,
0.01883646659553051,
-0.08886678516864777,
-0.055363211780786514,
-0.255802720785141,
0.5984944701194763,
-0.2308269739151001,
-0.24369779229164124,
-0.20698760449886322,
-0.17746317386627197,
0.47706130146980286,
-0.01555158756673336,
0.9214766025543213,
0.19352830946445465,
-0.22587475180625916,
-0.2074114978313446,
-0.5791664719581604,
-0.4266963601112366,
-0.5013762712478638,
0.326543390750885,
-0.17721915245056152,
-0.7321816086769104,
0.3669816851615906,
-0.04872822016477585,
0.03381812199950218,
0.5523926615715027,
0.5672034025192261,
0.1814568191766739,
1.0125442743301392,
0.6686791777610779,
-0.2922239899635315,
0.4411284923553467,
0.0505504310131073,
0.3910156488418579,
-0.7170168161392212,
0.08173868805170059,
-0.3968917727470398,
0.013393634930253029,
-0.7120800018310547,
-0.2710350453853607,
0.4015369713306427,
-0.024819426238536835,
-0.4129713177680969,
0.03340757265686989,
-0.06856139749288559,
0.6109794974327087,
0.2272224724292755,
0.05493489280343056,
0.4470573961734772,
0.15340721607208252,
-0.007930602878332138,
0.0747247263789177,
-0.5561031699180603,
-0.5012127161026001,
1.3505915403366089,
0.245416522026062,
0.7489597797393799,
0.12704728543758392,
0.3260342478752136,
0.3789883553981781,
0.1725410670042038,
-0.8843969702720642,
0.3296459913253784,
-0.20289559662342072,
-0.8024045825004578,
-0.5238140225410461,
-0.42829397320747375,
-0.584038257598877,
0.35586971044540405,
-0.48850885033607483,
-0.8007102608680725,
0.5688533186912537,
0.5224681496620178,
-0.5490595102310181,
0.3007606267929077,
-0.5331113934516907,
0.6939308643341064,
-0.24944622814655304,
-0.3113117516040802,
-0.45381417870521545,
-0.6715623140335083,
0.43966758251190186,
-0.22112233936786652,
0.10381241887807846,
-0.36825019121170044,
0.21275819838047028,
0.3006995618343353,
-0.3015305697917938,
0.7720027565956116,
0.20453669130802155,
-0.2943030893802643,
-0.1735307276248932,
0.003553202608600259,
0.6125320792198181,
0.22990940511226654,
-0.3846138119697571,
0.38186115026474,
-0.21134309470653534,
-0.025507032871246338,
-0.5949825048446655,
0.6474525332450867,
-0.9777829051017761,
-0.7286764979362488,
-0.4783429801464081,
-0.546225368976593,
-0.4664527177810669,
0.3464571535587311,
0.37728676199913025,
0.5015526413917542,
-0.25254321098327637,
0.16794627904891968,
1.0206003189086914,
-0.06074156612157822,
0.1490834504365921,
0.5185127854347229,
-0.3002735674381256,
-0.3305337727069855,
0.9740501046180725,
0.08560453355312347,
0.43996158242225647,
0.44899189472198486,
0.36346298456192017,
-0.5944730043411255,
-0.621674120426178,
-0.4397462010383606,
0.509951651096344,
-0.7503374814987183,
-0.2447168380022049,
-0.5634352564811707,
-0.16150502860546112,
-0.7463184595108032,
-0.14289040863513947,
-0.5807981491088867,
-0.388825923204422,
-0.3843942880630493,
-0.28387629985809326,
0.3879353404045105,
0.49509188532829285,
-0.035595111548900604,
0.24863237142562866,
-0.5413012504577637,
0.4968750476837158,
0.11573314666748047,
0.4167143702507019,
-0.16659554839134216,
-0.8997519016265869,
-0.2660304009914398,
0.12598606944084167,
-0.26970353722572327,
-0.4491356909275055,
0.3002748489379883,
0.3256881535053253,
0.32880550622940063,
0.798475444316864,
0.3651520013809204,
0.8644777536392212,
-0.4256783723831177,
0.5523393154144287,
-0.24583376944065094,
-1.1378921270370483,
0.16069646179676056,
-0.2631746828556061,
-0.052769776433706284,
0.6671490669250488,
0.40317752957344055,
-0.25333377718925476,
-0.15156513452529907,
-0.6065958142280579,
-0.9160171151161194,
0.9626797437667847,
0.06473991274833679,
0.050578523427248,
0.06546248495578766,
0.4732498824596405,
0.486174076795578,
0.5703582167625427,
-0.492078572511673,
-0.32659608125686646,
-0.11271918565034866,
-0.11331998556852341,
-0.3460460901260376,
-0.25502440333366394,
-0.07795818895101547,
-0.31986793875694275,
1.0737088918685913,
-0.3173421621322632,
0.013693765737116337,
0.13035690784454346,
-0.13645805418491364,
-0.4165751338005066,
0.22848351299762726,
0.6169764399528503,
0.9300045967102051,
-0.5568642020225525,
0.21199364960193634,
0.04316026344895363,
-0.26625731587409973,
-0.06623528152704239,
-0.021410997956991196,
-0.27319082617759705,
-0.25971275568008423,
0.22593480348587036,
1.2020646333694458,
-0.05512133613228798,
-0.5759435296058655,
0.3605876564979553,
0.2100359946489334,
0.10187505930662155,
-0.12323777377605438,
0.2462080717086792,
-0.4402558207511902,
0.10741639137268066,
0.15170447528362274,
0.21507565677165985,
0.3419762849807739,
-0.7060917019844055,
0.1671881079673767,
0.7353296875953674,
-0.1762361079454422,
-0.4308249056339264,
0.5523850917816162,
-0.07505761086940765,
0.16396677494049072,
0.658544659614563,
0.043205440044403076,
-0.4092737138271332,
0.43125319480895996,
0.7846372127532959,
0.8706099987030029,
0.013654421083629131,
0.26144981384277344,
0.08569937199354172,
0.3411060869693756,
-0.3531985282897949,
0.017320046201348305,
-0.16052234172821045,
-1.386210322380066,
-0.16489961743354797,
-0.6168732047080994,
-0.423862487077713,
0.21120326220989227,
-0.6503665447235107,
0.3274984657764435,
-0.35192427039146423,
-0.3158036172389984,
-0.01219397597014904,
-0.02484792284667492,
-0.2483307421207428,
0.4045078754425049,
0.14572209119796753,
0.5235762596130371,
-1.0379105806350708,
0.882468044757843,
0.7470472455024719,
-0.07120099663734436,
-0.5619054436683655,
0.49373793601989746,
0.08189823478460312,
-0.8244868516921997,
0.27560701966285706,
0.0075831664726138115,
-0.3402986526489258,
-0.002940216101706028,
-0.512116014957428,
-1.1713964939117432,
0.6017966866493225,
0.8151472210884094,
-0.45409151911735535,
0.2189446985721588,
0.25555238127708435,
0.5169504284858704,
-0.4045642912387848,
0.25026145577430725,
0.9273606538772583,
0.43504759669303894,
0.138502836227417,
-0.9030479788780212,
0.0667482540011406,
0.04933302477002144,
-0.08978068083524704,
0.3355964422225952,
-0.9034727215766907,
0.8299077749252319,
-0.2362533062696457,
-0.15549755096435547,
-0.19032517075538635,
0.7672001719474792,
0.41797757148742676,
0.27897152304649353,
0.5070937871932983,
0.46500933170318604,
1.078685998916626,
0.11961939930915833,
0.895938515663147,
-0.22657684981822968,
0.551669716835022,
1.0271131992340088,
-0.6497149467468262,
0.8121381998062134,
0.4934569001197815,
-0.05871107801795006,
0.22368194162845612,
0.6105720400810242,
0.09808909147977829,
0.6344848871231079,
-0.26458847522735596,
0.08450835943222046,
-0.6082077026367188,
-0.16696012020111084,
-0.40771135687828064,
0.29070720076560974,
0.22536753118038177,
-0.23698864877223969,
0.03472407907247543,
-0.1952962428331375,
-0.029595287516713142,
0.05535632371902466,
-0.2639017403125763,
0.8203949332237244,
0.024686913937330246,
-0.5718380212783813,
0.8394644856452942,
-0.057477522641420364,
0.560677707195282,
-0.3926980793476105,
0.10033728927373886,
-0.3128355145454407,
0.2881215810775757,
-0.30514442920684814,
-0.4142530560493469,
0.2527134418487549,
-0.2459697276353836,
-0.4699879288673401,
0.1026853621006012,
0.48442354798316956,
-0.36171284317970276,
-0.379658967256546,
0.07656380534172058,
0.012283268384635448,
-0.08037324994802475,
0.004498362075537443,
-0.524990439414978,
0.17548373341560364,
-0.047043751925230026,
-0.3027147948741913,
0.22393406927585602,
0.4655396342277527,
-0.21184682846069336,
0.5222043395042419,
0.5609932541847229,
0.19387073814868927,
-0.0957774966955185,
-0.13247936964035034,
0.7116559147834778,
-0.5142951011657715,
-0.5259883999824524,
-1.1056091785430908,
0.1920512318611145,
-0.0462004616856575,
-0.47762349247932434,
0.9202325940132141,
0.6987325549125671,
1.0115331411361694,
-0.06364285945892334,
0.7312395572662354,
0.19817830622196198,
0.40201058983802795,
-0.8568642139434814,
0.5977911353111267,
-0.7220462560653687,
0.3105478286743164,
-0.3189738690853119,
-0.9826596975326538,
-0.40103816986083984,
0.5335111618041992,
-0.6215749979019165,
-0.04377513751387596,
0.7113210558891296,
0.8767659068107605,
-0.39853575825691223,
0.1457759141921997,
0.407973974943161,
0.32591667771339417,
0.1604469120502472,
0.0686367005109787,
0.7323717474937439,
-0.21294578909873962,
-0.1497672200202942,
-0.17435862123966217,
-0.10820429772138596,
-0.4851970076560974,
-0.9533908367156982,
-0.9118131995201111,
-0.48366838693618774,
-0.44569528102874756,
-0.23792219161987305,
0.1543274223804474,
1.4819934368133545,
0.797703206539154,
-1.2487800121307373,
-0.1947193145751953,
-0.11140892654657364,
0.1655830442905426,
-0.13484196364879608,
-0.18502290546894073,
0.6165797114372253,
-0.3590414524078369,
-0.591374397277832,
0.448585569858551,
0.23925283551216125,
0.06299614161252975,
0.1480284035205841,
0.002955906093120575,
0.0494370274245739,
0.5992879271507263,
0.48082435131073,
0.21591374278068542,
-0.6748114228248596,
-0.3966212868690491,
-0.16507436335086823,
0.11929503083229065,
0.49689123034477234,
0.810111939907074,
-0.4802936315536499,
0.3226626217365265,
0.38661983609199524,
0.5948166847229004,
0.17587357759475708,
0.548383355140686,
0.5779094696044922,
-0.5202658176422119,
0.2145439237356186,
0.0500190369784832,
0.261340469121933,
0.23964926600456238,
-0.7281548380851746,
0.16580787301063538,
0.366000235080719,
-0.7498899102210999,
-1.08896803855896,
0.1398787498474121,
-0.7773759365081787,
-0.35018211603164673,
1.3084869384765625,
0.2766661047935486,
-0.18869175016880035,
-0.14152520895004272,
-0.19844792783260345,
0.35798004269599915,
-0.6755509376525879,
1.2810441255569458,
0.654927670955658,
-0.2860724925994873,
0.25906649231910706,
-0.18193960189819336,
0.8395251631736755,
0.5849595069885254,
-0.7087345123291016,
0.452657550573349,
0.7531915307044983,
0.2183275669813156,
0.07739447057247162,
0.38643860816955566,
-0.003328408347442746,
0.13446669280529022,
-0.3950040340423584,
-0.08543913811445236,
0.06932481378316879,
-0.6608633995056152,
-0.5673245191574097,
0.022630460560321808,
0.3574105203151703,
-0.034444332122802734
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12403v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12403v1
|
PDSS: A Privacy-Preserving Framework for Step-by-Step Distillation of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-18T08:48:14 | 2024-06-18T08:48:14 |
Tao Fan, Yan Kang, Weijing Chen, Hanlin Gu, Yuanfeng Song, Lixin Fan, Kai Chen, Qiang Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the context of real-world applications, leveraging large language models
(LLMs) for domain-specific tasks often faces two major challenges:
domain-specific knowledge privacy and constrained resources. To address these
issues, we propose PDSS, a privacy-preserving framework for step-by-step
distillation of LLMs. PDSS works on a server-client architecture, wherein
client transmits perturbed prompts to the server's LLM for rationale
generation. The generated rationales are then decoded by the client and used to
enrich the training of task-specific small language model(SLM) within a
multi-task learning paradigm. PDSS introduces two privacy protection
strategies: the Exponential Mechanism Strategy and the Encoder-Decoder
Strategy, balancing prompt privacy and rationale usability. Experiments
demonstrate the effectiveness of PDSS in various text generation tasks,
enabling the training of task-specific SLM with enhanced performance while
prioritizing data privacy protection.
|
[
-0.1422853320837021,
-0.7173639535903931,
0.668799102306366,
0.361454039812088,
-0.19612009823322296,
0.20211298763751984,
-0.2426290065050125,
0.22341808676719666,
-0.2594831883907318,
0.643153727054596,
-0.5841844081878662,
-0.5622184872627258,
-0.45748743414878845,
0.12301592528820038,
-0.5114823579788208,
1.2924968004226685,
-0.023652639240026474,
0.03971317782998085,
-0.15880954265594482,
0.3080657124519348,
0.2037031352519989,
-0.5500664114952087,
-0.8565197587013245,
-0.05985352769494057,
0.4584428668022156,
0.10452036559581757,
0.3623437285423279,
0.732636570930481,
0.21111297607421875,
0.27708837389945984,
-0.21336489915847778,
0.27361127734184265,
-0.5232020020484924,
0.594872772693634,
-0.355968177318573,
-0.5806825757026672,
-0.5041067600250244,
-0.06899111717939377,
0.625098705291748,
0.7178277969360352,
-0.5164819955825806,
0.3448469936847687,
0.3818534016609192,
0.7139268517494202,
-0.7022450566291809,
0.14682751893997192,
-0.41565316915512085,
-0.0485607273876667,
-0.2661653161048889,
-0.24911612272262573,
-0.5671301484107971,
-0.47164061665534973,
0.2832387387752533,
-0.26507261395454407,
0.38775795698165894,
0.03126858174800873,
0.4545767605304718,
0.1805260181427002,
-0.41788479685783386,
0.022491849958896637,
-0.6092934012413025,
0.7383517622947693,
-0.6029978394508362,
0.38549038767814636,
0.6898624897003174,
0.388816237449646,
-0.34018415212631226,
-0.7217237949371338,
-0.6693564653396606,
-0.057462554425001144,
0.08792168647050858,
-0.5047221779823303,
0.0603569820523262,
0.20032130181789398,
0.4807176887989044,
0.2464907020330429,
-0.5833227038383484,
-0.027004053816199303,
-0.06822789460420609,
-0.31290215253829956,
0.5088292956352234,
0.12004557251930237,
-0.047162655740976334,
0.028431767597794533,
-0.42068371176719666,
-0.0062817418947815895,
-1.0374013185501099,
-0.041470080614089966,
0.32148972153663635,
0.31107017397880554,
-0.15719056129455566,
0.35037752985954285,
-0.27998635172843933,
0.533246636390686,
0.3120384216308594,
-0.8112996816635132,
0.060745835304260254,
-0.12019553780555725,
-0.5227213501930237,
-0.17944616079330444,
0.8211811780929565,
0.05252408981323242,
-0.059812743216753006,
-0.36669468879699707,
-0.0986129492521286,
-0.03310622274875641,
0.04927441105246544,
-1.0813026428222656,
-0.33077433705329895,
0.3359801173210144,
-0.3786330819129944,
-0.3974691927433014,
-0.2812913656234741,
-0.7904248833656311,
-0.7226346731185913,
-0.4494309425354004,
-0.06154942885041237,
-0.27172133326530457,
-0.12671634554862976,
0.11058282107114792,
-0.05772670358419418,
-0.2160775065422058,
0.4286809265613556,
-1.0024387836456299,
0.6304436326026917,
0.781511664390564,
0.765205442905426,
-0.2554142475128174,
-0.31951746344566345,
-0.6843103766441345,
0.496730774641037,
-0.12939119338989258,
0.11183975636959076,
-0.293207585811615,
-0.4846411347389221,
0.04869375005364418,
0.14340800046920776,
0.15938319265842438,
-0.37822431325912476,
0.1126449704170227,
-0.6119179725646973,
0.07685552537441254,
-0.481471985578537,
-0.5805028676986694,
0.11174240708351135,
0.18285822868347168,
-0.5060123205184937,
0.6864244341850281,
-0.17402739822864532,
-0.7291023135185242,
0.40630078315734863,
-0.5543749928474426,
-0.4447343945503235,
0.053838808089494705,
-0.3339249789714813,
-0.49902617931365967,
0.0682639479637146,
0.04829084128141403,
0.5976751446723938,
-0.41652634739875793,
0.23991639912128448,
-0.33240607380867004,
0.08598965406417847,
0.38120266795158386,
-0.6498375535011292,
0.9495505690574646,
0.3656845688819885,
-0.38276007771492004,
-0.05750695616006851,
-0.8938199877738953,
-0.17241470515727997,
0.1000228077173233,
-0.4868370294570923,
-0.35441553592681885,
0.11054320633411407,
-0.31016823649406433,
0.1738940328359604,
0.43727922439575195,
-0.7020502090454102,
-0.08582934737205505,
-0.12385078519582748,
0.6451021432876587,
0.8285773396492004,
0.10633761435747147,
0.7181639075279236,
-0.10084855556488037,
0.5764428973197937,
0.22578586637973785,
0.16239437460899353,
-0.30771541595458984,
-0.23169302940368652,
-0.40904536843299866,
-0.5296749472618103,
0.2825801372528076,
0.46987220644950867,
-0.80611652135849,
0.49795621633529663,
-0.28057125210762024,
-0.27603358030319214,
-0.21841101348400116,
0.20081159472465515,
0.44821858406066895,
0.4464096426963806,
-0.09139303117990494,
-0.20851130783557892,
-0.21760016679763794,
-0.7522197365760803,
-0.03883188217878342,
0.07580887526273727,
-0.16799990832805634,
-0.04623265191912651,
0.24270226061344147,
-0.04104602336883545,
0.9475151896476746,
-0.5697388052940369,
-0.3208637535572052,
-0.16464151442050934,
0.10136344283819199,
-0.2708715498447418,
0.6768171191215515,
0.4834170341491699,
-0.7585020065307617,
-0.6855133771896362,
-0.26304781436920166,
-0.5785226821899414,
-0.037488047033548355,
-0.008292908780276775,
-0.11077501624822617,
0.21850353479385376,
0.3406828045845032,
-0.7996219992637634,
0.4553166627883911,
0.5540763139724731,
-0.12309791147708893,
0.2731499969959259,
-0.46916890144348145,
0.06604963541030884,
-1.1262787580490112,
0.012436117976903915,
0.21277004480361938,
-0.5964903235435486,
-0.6802497506141663,
0.13628007471561432,
0.22043262422084808,
-0.3466266989707947,
-0.4172057509422302,
0.213006854057312,
-0.6866546273231506,
0.20092545449733734,
-0.4402213990688324,
0.07812672108411789,
0.21617645025253296,
0.3617798089981079,
0.07847852259874344,
0.7516167163848877,
0.8448290228843689,
-0.767827033996582,
0.2815585732460022,
0.15165305137634277,
-0.11550828069448471,
0.7941767573356628,
-0.3158644139766693,
0.40232911705970764,
-0.2691982686519623,
0.3109927475452423,
-0.7377044558525085,
-0.03971005603671074,
0.1043001189827919,
-0.024220073595643044,
0.5073578357696533,
-0.31858929991722107,
-0.7882643938064575,
-0.12932246923446655,
-0.4128737151622772,
0.058589424937963486,
0.5936754941940308,
-0.649015486240387,
0.5624540448188782,
0.6484726071357727,
-0.4189732074737549,
-0.6399840116500854,
-0.6276315450668335,
0.1480344980955124,
-0.39495304226875305,
-0.2564425468444824,
0.24850048124790192,
-0.13506849110126495,
-0.2660830616950989,
-0.2683325409889221,
-0.29679587483406067,
-0.36325666308403015,
0.10903649777173996,
0.3836899697780609,
0.18918068706989288,
0.2664382755756378,
-0.33123070001602173,
0.60991370677948,
-0.05034569650888443,
0.19151169061660767,
-0.3904707729816437,
0.40193629264831543,
0.306168794631958,
-0.29999563097953796,
-0.6772189736366272,
0.44302934408187866,
0.5750715732574463,
-0.1847364604473114,
0.911270022392273,
0.16637030243873596,
-0.39450034499168396,
-0.7835020422935486,
-0.44074198603630066,
-0.20293721556663513,
-0.5756356716156006,
0.20046783983707428,
-0.5232692360877991,
-1.0402683019638062,
0.31042078137397766,
-0.3510344624519348,
0.23587635159492493,
-0.25295084714889526,
0.42088571190834045,
0.17410719394683838,
0.9658389687538147,
0.7903531789779663,
-0.1710868924856186,
0.34405583143234253,
-0.06330876052379608,
0.42818406224250793,
-0.6286234259605408,
-0.2148728370666504,
-0.5578883290290833,
-0.0526314452290535,
-0.28394871950149536,
-0.3597499132156372,
0.17433269321918488,
-0.03752029687166214,
-0.20735745131969452,
0.4122711420059204,
-0.5249157547950745,
0.7759824991226196,
0.21082347631454468,
0.09400399774312973,
0.3444027900695801,
0.20168665051460266,
0.022908447310328484,
-0.17533917725086212,
-0.43839067220687866,
-0.7537490129470825,
1.2664369344711304,
0.5091205835342407,
1.1003131866455078,
0.301868736743927,
1.147993803024292,
0.3180111348628998,
0.05443757772445679,
-0.29799360036849976,
0.9736703634262085,
-0.12621065974235535,
-0.6079884171485901,
-0.4388585388660431,
-0.6225903630256653,
-0.6479939222335815,
0.3807325065135956,
0.2808012366294861,
-0.8961027264595032,
0.35011738538742065,
0.30205225944519043,
-0.482805460691452,
0.13590745627880096,
-0.5687566995620728,
0.6518800854682922,
-0.054443974047899246,
-0.7800837755203247,
-0.1093922033905983,
-0.7769089341163635,
0.2990435063838959,
-0.17673471570014954,
0.27461743354797363,
-0.061178628355264664,
-0.1576547473669052,
0.460805743932724,
-0.5775530934333801,
1.150505542755127,
-0.5756176710128784,
-0.5064129829406738,
0.005731464363634586,
0.48897963762283325,
0.708092451095581,
0.26554250717163086,
0.09205614030361176,
-0.07371199876070023,
0.15984398126602173,
-0.10007048398256302,
-0.5353812575340271,
1.0371348857879639,
-0.20922748744487762,
-0.6609044075012207,
-0.5081879496574402,
-0.43381839990615845,
-0.19197805225849152,
0.2127838283777237,
0.011004799976944923,
0.20083215832710266,
-0.14476637542247772,
0.12770628929138184,
1.1360197067260742,
0.006504651624709368,
0.5123568177223206,
0.873445451259613,
-0.26749730110168457,
-0.2624504268169403,
0.9628732204437256,
-0.08350098133087158,
0.38537153601646423,
0.4023226201534271,
-0.0646989569067955,
-0.5771732926368713,
-0.7211483716964722,
-0.49919283390045166,
0.13330374658107758,
-0.6689102649688721,
-0.17073588073253632,
-0.5098844766616821,
-0.01743483729660511,
-0.383846640586853,
0.05205390974879265,
-0.28236615657806396,
-0.44751232862472534,
-0.4869316518306732,
-0.1603635996580124,
0.2533947229385376,
0.4833466410636902,
-0.09923652559518814,
0.1991705447435379,
-0.7284774780273438,
0.5376043319702148,
0.3136502206325531,
0.4111568331718445,
-0.09396903216838837,
-0.31727203726768494,
-0.11657428741455078,
0.197965607047081,
-0.259579062461853,
-0.8515805006027222,
0.5359358787536621,
0.224124014377594,
0.376680850982666,
0.2927156984806061,
0.3475528657436371,
0.6147539019584656,
-0.8839657306671143,
0.8544709086418152,
0.19290487468242645,
-1.0925514698028564,
0.512090265750885,
-0.11411552876234055,
-0.09517830610275269,
0.7288605570793152,
0.371567040681839,
-0.11380144953727722,
-0.4121853709220886,
-0.4176378548145294,
-0.6607790589332581,
0.876826286315918,
0.11111843585968018,
0.06661856919527054,
0.02223387360572815,
0.37098246812820435,
0.332592248916626,
0.6767551302909851,
-0.6805532574653625,
-0.31392574310302734,
0.018692288547754288,
-0.30654263496398926,
0.10165396332740784,
-0.13558927178382874,
-0.583564281463623,
-0.13787375390529633,
0.5980270504951477,
-0.010037836618721485,
-0.196323424577713,
-0.04053926840424538,
-0.132533997297287,
-0.01653551124036312,
0.36975976824760437,
0.3418882191181183,
0.5194117426872253,
0.1038169339299202,
0.22216258943080902,
0.013717840425670147,
-0.5426206588745117,
0.42618831992149353,
0.32701581716537476,
-0.37203389406204224,
-0.1427186131477356,
-0.5055771470069885,
0.6846976280212402,
-0.001994814956560731,
-0.6088918447494507,
0.5963613986968994,
-0.1969738006591797,
-0.22957175970077515,
-0.1291242092847824,
0.1570204645395279,
0.06261920183897018,
0.1027115061879158,
0.21654467284679413,
-0.07161355763673782,
0.2844015955924988,
-0.3623206913471222,
0.04341829940676689,
0.35023632645606995,
0.18947196006774902,
-0.38206610083580017,
0.8226761221885681,
0.26406389474868774,
-0.2393016666173935,
-0.08627917617559433,
-0.5261002779006958,
-0.15005910396575928,
0.1207108274102211,
0.6091862320899963,
1.0538232326507568,
-0.4193803369998932,
0.3511086106300354,
-0.08422745019197464,
0.01583467423915863,
-0.5056171417236328,
0.40925121307373047,
-0.5540299415588379,
-0.18205392360687256,
-0.22818760573863983,
-0.7908934354782104,
-0.5288272500038147,
0.10705014318227768,
-0.6407792568206787,
-0.004528638906776905,
-0.8054881691932678,
-0.2922404110431671,
0.09747321903705597,
-0.31180623173713684,
-0.3284761607646942,
0.13277404010295868,
0.1678573042154312,
0.7137355208396912,
-0.5598912239074707,
1.2258974313735962,
0.43083998560905457,
-0.2615533769130707,
-0.6176177859306335,
0.15563620626926422,
0.29019394516944885,
-0.3150458037853241,
0.6458802819252014,
-0.2225322425365448,
-0.17498894035816193,
-0.1062934547662735,
-0.4521414339542389,
-0.8091635704040527,
1.0483886003494263,
0.7312464118003845,
-1.0040595531463623,
-0.2157669961452484,
0.4543682038784027,
0.5725639462471008,
-0.2384369671344757,
-0.6693016886711121,
0.5856208205223083,
0.008985588327050209,
-0.1783130019903183,
-1.0751091241836548,
0.4024917185306549,
0.1271919161081314,
0.32774147391319275,
0.212642103433609,
-0.359966516494751,
0.8427572846412659,
-0.03271729499101639,
-0.3670964241027832,
0.15172894299030304,
0.3723483085632324,
0.5037425756454468,
0.19229991734027863,
0.3998078405857086,
0.4014134407043457,
0.7741798162460327,
0.04618743807077408,
0.8461061716079712,
-0.46140924096107483,
0.29248037934303284,
1.1679356098175049,
-0.8512745499610901,
0.7023457288742065,
0.473553866147995,
-0.47162574529647827,
0.3864429295063019,
0.09622488915920258,
0.48177850246429443,
0.9421541094779968,
0.43640267848968506,
-0.6640903353691101,
0.016045287251472473,
0.19015510380268097,
-0.2616262137889862,
0.10153262317180634,
0.38779449462890625,
-0.5405409336090088,
-0.2818526327610016,
0.13000594079494476,
0.25092199444770813,
0.1851421743631363,
-0.018178889527916908,
0.9178665280342102,
0.24527014791965485,
-0.5677400827407837,
0.43209055066108704,
0.13643130660057068,
0.5076760053634644,
-0.8024348616600037,
0.11230608820915222,
0.10710302740335464,
0.39456596970558167,
-0.11876833438873291,
-0.5391877889633179,
0.18510624766349792,
0.363267719745636,
-0.31888800859451294,
-0.6136992573738098,
0.5221952199935913,
-0.8018366694450378,
-0.1297006756067276,
0.0377257764339447,
0.31345242261886597,
-0.01644498109817505,
0.02277037501335144,
-0.6052614450454712,
0.09741739928722382,
-0.00501511013135314,
-0.22581669688224792,
0.8603432178497314,
0.7404152750968933,
0.265115350484848,
0.5615622997283936,
0.7498542666435242,
0.2992721498012543,
0.12469319999217987,
0.3153817057609558,
0.8836947083473206,
-0.4048786461353302,
-0.84748375415802,
-0.9474602341651917,
0.4269392192363739,
-0.3435480296611786,
0.04392590373754501,
1.0865702629089355,
0.5792036056518555,
0.580292284488678,
-0.08523109555244446,
1.0469133853912354,
0.037781935185194016,
0.8468304872512817,
-0.37807899713516235,
0.9711944460868835,
-0.16683855652809143,
0.650514543056488,
-0.17114250361919403,
-0.7974046468734741,
-0.00799825694411993,
0.5633571147918701,
-0.1203785315155983,
-0.24426059424877167,
0.6033129096031189,
0.7724164128303528,
0.19669826328754425,
0.15234865248203278,
0.15036503970623016,
-0.04645484313368797,
0.5941307544708252,
0.2399846613407135,
0.45962750911712646,
-0.08986648917198181,
0.191368967294693,
-0.5947917103767395,
-0.4703841805458069,
0.387592613697052,
-0.9996668696403503,
-1.0586843490600586,
-0.5771305561065674,
-0.5102025866508484,
-0.3471237123012543,
0.15859198570251465,
0.7721145153045654,
0.7490284442901611,
-0.6758977770805359,
-0.3341774344444275,
-0.34415796399116516,
-0.2248004525899887,
-0.16498737037181854,
-0.14940518140792847,
0.19938938319683075,
-0.30713772773742676,
-0.7572062015533447,
0.46771758794784546,
0.4179980158805847,
0.2170332670211792,
-0.630830705165863,
-0.03544621169567108,
0.21081140637397766,
0.07841581106185913,
0.6727264523506165,
0.3828754723072052,
-0.5758547186851501,
0.09223742038011551,
-0.21284352242946625,
-0.28390559554100037,
-0.30974382162094116,
0.9100067615509033,
-0.5834408402442932,
0.3438591957092285,
0.3709627091884613,
0.6024106740951538,
0.6001676321029663,
-0.08351259678602219,
0.5716542601585388,
-1.0809170007705688,
0.2828424572944641,
0.18426969647407532,
0.4655297100543976,
0.3909514248371124,
-0.45126715302467346,
0.10253594070672989,
0.1285880208015442,
-0.5843223333358765,
-1.2281428575515747,
0.25709930062294006,
-1.0421032905578613,
-0.25419899821281433,
1.114724040031433,
-0.5859184861183167,
-0.27228808403015137,
-0.3521980047225952,
-0.20042270421981812,
-0.04227348417043686,
-0.5872197151184082,
0.7585973739624023,
0.37901195883750916,
0.21545355021953583,
-0.11075031757354736,
-0.17588166892528534,
0.9738315343856812,
0.06130177155137062,
-0.8039653897285461,
0.6992599368095398,
0.7020765542984009,
0.5184441804885864,
0.11844068020582199,
0.8057233095169067,
-0.23175129294395447,
0.04050998017191887,
0.035131387412548065,
-0.40617287158966064,
-0.1109703779220581,
-0.5175162553787231,
-0.38126805424690247,
0.5111755728721619,
0.11191453784704208,
-0.34645238518714905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12402v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12402v1
|
Flee the Flaw: Annotating the Underlying Logic of Fallacious Arguments Through Templates and Slot-filling
| 2024-06-18T08:44:45 | 2024-06-18T08:44:45 |
Irfan Robbani, Paul Reisert, Naoya Inoue, Surawat Pothong, Camélia Guerraoui, Wenzhi Wang, Shoichi Naito, Jungmin Choi, Kentaro Inui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Prior research in computational argumentation has mainly focused on scoring
the quality of arguments, with less attention on explicating logical errors. In
this work, we introduce four sets of explainable templates for common informal
logical fallacies designed to explicate a fallacy's implicit logic. Using our
templates, we conduct an annotation study on top of 400 fallacious arguments
taken from LOGIC dataset and achieve a high agreement score (Krippendorf's
alpha of 0.54) and reasonable coverage (0.83). Finally, we conduct an
experiment for detecting the structure of fallacies and discover that
state-of-the-art language models struggle with detecting fallacy templates
(0.47 accuracy). To facilitate research on fallacies, we make our dataset and
guidelines publicly available.
|
[
-0.4899457097053528,
-0.7649618983268738,
0.7216923832893372,
0.007978396490216255,
-0.25666314363479614,
-0.07123183459043503,
0.0958881750702858,
-0.06900842487812042,
0.029033813625574112,
0.2792763113975525,
-0.5871261954307556,
-0.1954822838306427,
-0.4937049448490143,
0.1943957805633545,
-0.582951545715332,
1.0328446626663208,
-0.22158397734165192,
-0.11970807611942291,
-0.24411733448505402,
-0.2890584170818329,
-0.41570842266082764,
-0.5554497838020325,
-0.3894979953765869,
-0.12102604657411575,
0.5021372437477112,
0.6644320487976074,
0.6565324664115906,
0.5008103251457214,
0.30213162302970886,
0.24809680879116058,
-0.01874641329050064,
0.1931537538766861,
-0.25629037618637085,
-0.26529955863952637,
-0.19175051152706146,
-0.37432897090911865,
-0.19802646338939667,
0.2619958817958832,
0.10449502617120743,
0.6270556449890137,
-0.3356935679912567,
-0.0073190308175981045,
-0.5161057114601135,
0.7772043347358704,
-0.8298705220222473,
0.024012280628085136,
-0.740155816078186,
0.16497136652469635,
-0.2921064794063568,
0.19051484763622284,
-0.663856029510498,
-0.6154876351356506,
0.05653427168726921,
-0.7476145029067993,
0.3621300458908081,
0.07796778529882431,
0.7126133441925049,
0.3012614846229553,
0.09699554741382599,
-0.5758718252182007,
-0.6208752393722534,
0.7521445155143738,
-0.7445796728134155,
0.029965531080961227,
0.06799816340208054,
0.33893200755119324,
-0.20608404278755188,
-0.7447121739387512,
-0.7871286273002625,
-0.17469307780265808,
-0.17645351588726044,
0.14524607360363007,
-0.37560299038887024,
-0.25472044944763184,
0.5764461755752563,
0.2992731034755707,
-0.3471734821796417,
-0.16037017107009888,
-0.5950029492378235,
-0.19630016386508942,
0.52522873878479,
-0.07101009786128998,
0.485055536031723,
-0.08308534324169159,
-0.3068360686302185,
-0.015221210196614265,
-0.9183816313743591,
0.04284921661019325,
0.49661538004875183,
0.0983709767460823,
-0.16806770861148834,
0.3832477033138275,
0.38013190031051636,
0.7813121676445007,
0.14159755408763885,
0.2404874861240387,
0.14135876297950745,
-0.2838788330554962,
-0.3001093566417694,
0.1808319240808487,
0.3428989052772522,
0.3628036379814148,
0.24980773031711578,
-0.10163837671279907,
0.03601671755313873,
0.3650539815425873,
0.5956994295120239,
-0.06294749677181244,
-0.24518203735351562,
0.23351193964481354,
-0.3023116886615753,
-0.6181515455245972,
0.03100428730249405,
-0.7179602980613708,
-0.4955201745033264,
-0.1418667882680893,
0.05928407981991768,
-0.6017885208129883,
-0.13429169356822968,
0.31232133507728577,
-0.6715940237045288,
0.36086204648017883,
0.6792444586753845,
-0.5606193542480469,
0.5701876282691956,
0.8293889760971069,
0.733346164226532,
-0.0900864228606224,
-0.26663604378700256,
-0.44569453597068787,
0.13655942678451538,
-0.8411743640899658,
1.1333194971084595,
-0.6612803936004639,
-0.07084352523088455,
-0.07686344534158707,
-0.18004082143306732,
-0.22481529414653778,
-0.4175400733947754,
1.1576601266860962,
-0.207027867436409,
0.5885117053985596,
-0.3189733326435089,
-0.5191273093223572,
-0.4515507221221924,
0.23621657490730286,
-0.8496894240379333,
0.7816709280014038,
0.2430482804775238,
-0.9747490286827087,
0.48132315278053284,
-0.7159724235534668,
-0.33866268396377563,
-0.04927624389529228,
-0.3123830556869507,
-0.395359069108963,
0.6162827014923096,
0.34095850586891174,
0.041402217000722885,
-0.21178004145622253,
-0.009328375570476055,
-0.4655623137950897,
-0.405387282371521,
0.44000184535980225,
-0.14306434988975525,
0.8573480844497681,
-0.12583792209625244,
-0.5668627023696899,
-0.15058964490890503,
-0.6674386262893677,
-0.3124852478504181,
0.1716410517692566,
-0.11824168264865875,
-0.5774290561676025,
0.2873270511627197,
-0.17040599882602692,
0.3738211989402771,
-0.2785867154598236,
-0.5473891496658325,
0.18389441072940826,
-0.7072033286094666,
0.6057872772216797,
1.013939380645752,
-0.07641075551509857,
0.18505194783210754,
-0.5125812888145447,
0.5528963208198547,
0.3250504434108734,
0.04221609607338905,
-0.018046988174319267,
-0.31758570671081543,
-0.8295265436172485,
-0.2680683732032776,
0.2094959169626236,
0.28752896189689636,
-0.46683433651924133,
0.006384365260601044,
-0.059101954102516174,
-0.41111284494400024,
-0.5223673582077026,
-0.08768041431903839,
0.3473363220691681,
0.8460993766784668,
0.31558090448379517,
0.049381040036678314,
-0.4872032403945923,
-1.1975972652435303,
-0.5248648524284363,
-0.17537975311279297,
0.17173150181770325,
0.22008618712425232,
0.6081326007843018,
0.1908622831106186,
1.1381415128707886,
-0.4292178750038147,
-0.01033033523708582,
-0.25473207235336304,
0.20279137790203094,
0.4010271728038788,
0.39237940311431885,
0.763468325138092,
-0.8161372542381287,
-0.14520125091075897,
-0.3631618022918701,
-0.727496325969696,
-0.19021986424922943,
-0.07015620917081833,
0.045603808015584946,
0.48202022910118103,
0.6030136942863464,
-0.6158121824264526,
0.6374258399009705,
-0.01697121560573578,
-0.2569088339805603,
0.8190488815307617,
0.18675650656223297,
-0.008293225429952145,
-0.9523951411247253,
-0.16130629181861877,
0.08082452416419983,
-0.14003321528434753,
-0.3049198091030121,
0.008045587688684464,
-0.26619330048561096,
0.0028171788435429335,
-0.40522104501724243,
0.4127701222896576,
-0.2818417549133301,
0.2626599967479706,
0.13592024147510529,
0.21085739135742188,
0.09415004402399063,
0.015927791595458984,
-0.04195846617221832,
0.33349406719207764,
0.26371195912361145,
-0.3530370593070984,
0.30206137895584106,
0.175076425075531,
-0.006634996738284826,
0.8217998147010803,
-0.7267870903015137,
0.13851848244667053,
-0.355847030878067,
0.3965654969215393,
-1.1033447980880737,
-0.35755863785743713,
0.48267585039138794,
-0.34442365169525146,
0.021908501163125038,
-0.774345338344574,
-0.256778746843338,
-0.3050808012485504,
-0.5460957884788513,
0.2479686588048935,
0.4295606315135956,
-0.7080926299095154,
0.6515721082687378,
0.2827722728252411,
-0.06436248868703842,
-0.8187856674194336,
-0.6757885813713074,
0.021848486736416817,
-0.6236526966094971,
-0.3990412950515747,
0.18474061787128448,
-0.150929793715477,
-0.48516353964805603,
-0.12174808233976364,
-0.13758818805217743,
0.0665745735168457,
0.07416116446256638,
0.34580197930336,
0.018736684694886208,
-0.36662694811820984,
-0.050240810960531235,
-0.1334361732006073,
-0.36928942799568176,
0.35033535957336426,
-0.315631240606308,
0.2413826584815979,
-0.20923525094985962,
-0.5723355412483215,
0.06648623198270798,
0.6218150854110718,
0.6925331354141235,
0.3001581132411957,
0.4655330777168274,
-0.10463859140872955,
-0.793987512588501,
-0.4912482500076294,
-0.6427496075630188,
0.07236449420452118,
-0.4448772668838501,
-0.02507598325610161,
-0.30805668234825134,
-0.2651999890804291,
0.3706972301006317,
-0.06975138932466507,
0.5794616341590881,
0.5609641075134277,
0.2867032289505005,
-0.2153424769639969,
0.8238112330436707,
0.21880629658699036,
0.1889658421278,
-0.048551708459854126,
0.028131816536188126,
0.4913286566734314,
-0.37555941939353943,
-0.0335661955177784,
-0.6708388924598694,
-0.10932479053735733,
-0.3191414773464203,
-0.5956428647041321,
0.06442841142416,
0.15985053777694702,
-0.1671314239501953,
0.02512483112514019,
-0.5124773383140564,
0.6822495460510254,
0.313798189163208,
-0.318508118391037,
0.04380939155817032,
0.34272199869155884,
-0.30061566829681396,
-0.5638389587402344,
-0.7779849171638489,
-0.6946421265602112,
0.5427654385566711,
0.4032607674598694,
0.6051385402679443,
0.2187526822090149,
0.5472822189331055,
0.5699825286865234,
0.28849315643310547,
-0.5874567031860352,
0.38565120100975037,
-0.08197561651468277,
-0.7072134613990784,
-0.09543867409229279,
-0.35631412267684937,
-0.574974000453949,
0.09934443235397339,
0.03121335431933403,
-0.9152372479438782,
0.13188645243644714,
0.4537407159805298,
0.10434232652187347,
0.24111106991767883,
-0.710557758808136,
0.9726839661598206,
-0.022845882922410965,
-0.17975778877735138,
-0.06215345114469528,
-0.33949553966522217,
0.58954256772995,
0.06825362890958786,
0.4948130249977112,
0.057896729558706284,
0.33346882462501526,
0.8435990810394287,
-0.7477062344551086,
0.8660258054733276,
-0.15518160164356232,
0.03486768156290054,
0.2699635922908783,
0.4432211220264435,
0.28794634342193604,
-0.05375371128320694,
-0.19772367179393768,
-0.020971523597836494,
-0.06816481798887253,
-0.3695506155490875,
-0.8155192136764526,
0.37525948882102966,
-0.34478116035461426,
-0.5284497737884521,
-0.6590332388877869,
0.060537416487932205,
-0.015159759670495987,
0.12016741931438446,
0.3446573317050934,
0.6133884787559509,
-0.25402435660362244,
-0.13827139139175415,
0.5767818093299866,
-0.021027280017733574,
0.49159756302833557,
0.21497000753879547,
0.24018660187721252,
-0.4504718780517578,
0.9291228652000427,
0.15718649327754974,
-0.1863829791545868,
-0.056637685745954514,
0.41479456424713135,
-0.38235026597976685,
-0.6166663765907288,
-0.5311160087585449,
0.1793586164712906,
-1.1834207773208618,
-0.16932198405265808,
-0.4656504988670349,
-0.07234121114015579,
-0.2835559844970703,
-0.7475590705871582,
-0.4134589433670044,
-0.911228358745575,
0.03478294238448143,
-0.29154258966445923,
0.23764432966709137,
0.9254373908042908,
-0.20866647362709045,
0.029658213257789612,
-0.5353379249572754,
0.2908271253108978,
0.02177165262401104,
0.28116923570632935,
-0.010714339092373848,
-0.4240221679210663,
0.20434501767158508,
-0.23145651817321777,
-0.13753937184810638,
-1.1242207288742065,
-0.042804569005966187,
-0.03355143964290619,
0.8161320686340332,
0.5342665314674377,
0.267342209815979,
0.7207602262496948,
-0.5485103130340576,
0.7493667006492615,
0.338520348072052,
-1.1399389505386353,
0.8679720163345337,
-0.23521476984024048,
-0.21942074596881866,
0.6004467010498047,
0.5443299412727356,
-0.38970598578453064,
-0.4257609248161316,
-0.9861351847648621,
-1.0317457914352417,
0.8604875206947327,
0.23115898668766022,
-0.23398558795452118,
-0.13588185608386993,
0.5056325793266296,
0.2687099874019623,
-0.000236009422224015,
-1.1311671733856201,
-0.16436676681041718,
-0.21257071197032928,
-0.33974069356918335,
0.22777250409126282,
-0.2901569902896881,
-0.6693299412727356,
-0.040790826082229614,
0.6177440285682678,
-0.3555237054824829,
0.11309642344713211,
0.17288890480995178,
-0.24390152096748352,
0.02765648066997528,
0.3660213351249695,
0.9072192311286926,
1.0346554517745972,
-0.05690797418355942,
0.47819045186042786,
0.08379791676998138,
-0.22796373069286346,
0.31029781699180603,
0.22591330111026764,
-0.427349716424942,
0.22809910774230957,
0.8310955166816711,
0.26518645882606506,
0.04280475899577141,
-0.496982604265213,
0.5641102194786072,
-0.33503228425979614,
-0.16238464415073395,
-0.7368664145469666,
0.011886299587786198,
0.21407489478588104,
-0.15340019762516022,
0.1325359046459198,
0.1416442096233368,
0.08619636297225952,
-0.34838899970054626,
0.0952134057879448,
0.2368287742137909,
-0.4911072552204132,
-0.21526476740837097,
0.20423156023025513,
0.26473891735076904,
-0.2963721454143524,
0.5526195764541626,
0.03734162822365761,
-0.583405077457428,
0.48647332191467285,
0.518524706363678,
0.5311711430549622,
0.13252601027488708,
0.4202226996421814,
0.16772998869419098,
0.779091477394104,
-0.025119507685303688,
0.1936797946691513,
0.157454252243042,
-0.6082888841629028,
-0.11309392750263214,
-0.4186045825481415,
-0.5068680644035339,
0.3311459720134735,
-0.49485063552856445,
0.2596314251422882,
-0.7125391960144043,
0.3332972228527069,
0.23763827979564667,
-0.37316179275512695,
-0.29532334208488464,
0.20913319289684296,
0.16803522408008575,
1.2056405544281006,
-1.054390549659729,
-0.20484262704849243,
0.9051114916801453,
-0.6385338306427002,
-0.5682006478309631,
0.17637154459953308,
0.1288219541311264,
-0.5496485233306885,
0.509419322013855,
0.24044077098369598,
-0.4075354039669037,
-0.6212628483772278,
-0.7886647582054138,
-0.46954718232154846,
0.310554176568985,
0.5834023356437683,
-0.3420528769493103,
-0.04084029048681259,
0.03264903649687767,
0.2220195084810257,
-0.5621959567070007,
0.34572094678878784,
0.6392297744750977,
0.5858142971992493,
0.11682942509651184,
-0.2685287296772003,
0.42691466212272644,
-0.2506742775440216,
-0.3757511079311371,
-0.10047188401222229,
-0.38761070370674133,
0.6302849054336548,
-0.24175925552845,
-0.08276950567960739,
-0.4868777096271515,
0.3822006285190582,
0.5755727887153625,
0.6635020971298218,
0.7928410172462463,
0.898878812789917,
0.7359796762466431,
-0.23839592933654785,
0.9698089361190796,
0.32823026180267334,
0.05881287902593613,
1.1577670574188232,
-0.3333336114883423,
0.5901643633842468,
0.5099157094955444,
0.06382054835557938,
0.8810150027275085,
0.7389742732048035,
-0.04605651646852493,
0.33444133400917053,
0.6220763921737671,
0.017809990793466568,
-0.4175350069999695,
0.34912461042404175,
-0.29284384846687317,
0.38514193892478943,
0.6767876148223877,
-0.22015492618083954,
-0.35517311096191406,
-0.458607941865921,
0.3095638155937195,
0.19259679317474365,
-0.0258661936968565,
0.6406291723251343,
0.028006676584482193,
-0.784529447555542,
0.3828754425048828,
0.13637958467006683,
0.08529169112443924,
-0.32639080286026,
-0.5202072262763977,
-0.2819596827030182,
0.18453064560890198,
-0.281825989484787,
-0.5349721908569336,
0.2923121154308319,
0.038288913667201996,
-0.23478317260742188,
0.09802030026912689,
0.7666144371032715,
0.42769384384155273,
-0.7095779776573181,
0.04919949918985367,
0.34078875184059143,
0.11541947722434998,
0.3203378915786743,
-0.883732259273529,
-0.02434186451137066,
-0.1927119493484497,
-0.10075807571411133,
-0.21167120337486267,
0.5614995360374451,
-0.14782676100730896,
0.43780940771102905,
0.7309367656707764,
0.09013866633176804,
0.05892304703593254,
-0.07432866841554642,
1.072104573249817,
-0.8010439276695251,
-0.684352695941925,
-1.0194917917251587,
0.5476890802383423,
-0.6689616441726685,
-0.27611595392227173,
0.4146110713481903,
0.5331205725669861,
0.5848879814147949,
-0.17468072474002838,
1.065677285194397,
-0.001702070701867342,
0.7634081840515137,
-0.6465659141540527,
0.46451812982559204,
-0.48052921891212463,
0.27518099546432495,
-0.5300602316856384,
-0.6802716255187988,
-0.29977238178253174,
0.8732085824012756,
-0.3071293830871582,
0.10444417595863342,
0.7478435039520264,
0.3926168382167816,
-0.5137945413589478,
0.09958900511264801,
0.03258021920919418,
0.35803741216659546,
0.42748939990997314,
0.5737317204475403,
1.2057859897613525,
-0.33305639028549194,
0.41925856471061707,
0.10193480551242828,
-0.30726227164268494,
-0.4503782093524933,
-1.3937368392944336,
-0.9608945250511169,
-0.24159318208694458,
-0.7114899158477783,
-0.9232276678085327,
0.16261659562587738,
0.6689732670783997,
0.752254843711853,
-0.7606231570243835,
0.25910764932632446,
-0.4013615846633911,
0.7159624099731445,
-0.20544350147247314,
-0.25787124037742615,
0.2726888954639435,
-0.21982645988464355,
-0.33141809701919556,
0.4709630012512207,
0.24150729179382324,
-0.03123738244175911,
-0.10358712822198868,
0.15059320628643036,
-0.04033692181110382,
0.6204485893249512,
0.07205048203468323,
0.5846678614616394,
-0.8754222989082336,
-0.41566288471221924,
-0.5181158781051636,
0.1270488053560257,
0.18101224303245544,
1.2582194805145264,
-0.629009485244751,
0.3455454111099243,
0.44961416721343994,
0.4304713010787964,
0.146298348903656,
-0.0263968538492918,
0.8618156313896179,
-0.853431761264801,
0.12032477557659149,
0.35666483640670776,
0.46484220027923584,
0.42695698142051697,
-0.19755879044532776,
0.5262049436569214,
0.5681162476539612,
-0.049944616854190826,
-1.1688027381896973,
0.4109446406364441,
-0.9006920456886292,
-0.36295250058174133,
0.7697907090187073,
-0.4105094075202942,
-0.459199994802475,
-0.46425461769104004,
-0.03374692425131798,
-0.1795441210269928,
-0.19930677115917206,
1.0142910480499268,
1.0697615146636963,
-0.19664683938026428,
-0.24396522343158722,
-0.41538047790527344,
0.9861088395118713,
0.375146746635437,
-0.9485471844673157,
0.4516623914241791,
0.7620316743850708,
0.49201446771621704,
0.492153137922287,
0.6732025146484375,
-0.2981831431388855,
0.8954935669898987,
0.26080086827278137,
-0.44613146781921387,
-0.04689587652683258,
-0.23469172418117523,
-0.3678520619869232,
0.3689245283603668,
0.0003708207805175334,
0.002953603398054838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12399v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12399v1
|
QueerBench: Quantifying Discrimination in Language Models Toward Queer Identities
| 2024-06-18T08:40:29 | 2024-06-18T08:40:29 |
Mae Sosto, Alberto Barrón-Cedeño
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
With the increasing role of Natural Language Processing (NLP) in various
applications, challenges concerning bias and stereotype perpetuation are
accentuated, which often leads to hate speech and harm. Despite existing
studies on sexism and misogyny, issues like homophobia and transphobia remain
underexplored and often adopt binary perspectives, putting the safety of
LGBTQIA+ individuals at high risk in online spaces. In this paper, we assess
the potential harm caused by sentence completions generated by English large
language models (LLMs) concerning LGBTQIA+ individuals. This is achieved using
QueerBench, our new assessment framework, which employs a template-based
approach and a Masked Language Modeling (MLM) task. The analysis indicates that
large language models tend to exhibit discriminatory behaviour more frequently
towards individuals within the LGBTQIA+ community, reaching a difference gap of
7.2% in the QueerBench score of harmfulness.
|
[
-0.2598772644996643,
-0.7395501136779785,
0.28265389800071716,
0.34385010600090027,
0.1456543356180191,
-0.055507466197013855,
0.06102386489510536,
-0.8420262932777405,
0.10777003318071365,
0.4783982038497925,
-0.5022473931312561,
-0.4165266454219818,
-0.5403187870979309,
0.2810785472393036,
-0.8229976296424866,
0.7311317920684814,
0.17566122114658356,
0.20742473006248474,
-0.2776125371456146,
-0.007355089299380779,
-0.7283562421798706,
-0.5653399229049683,
-0.32843467593193054,
0.29859474301338196,
0.5841363668441772,
0.011187397874891758,
0.7855923175811768,
0.215715229511261,
0.4983022212982178,
0.2860860526561737,
-0.3500831425189972,
-0.4072209894657135,
-0.5609525442123413,
0.42170658707618713,
-0.463273286819458,
-0.7236788272857666,
-0.3342531621456146,
0.15320985019207,
0.574857234954834,
0.829834520816803,
-0.07313208281993866,
0.31322044134140015,
-0.13441871106624603,
0.5790847539901733,
-0.6886781454086304,
-0.40950900316238403,
-0.7267343401908875,
0.3199014663696289,
-0.45560145378112793,
0.4041491746902466,
-0.22188928723335266,
-0.4904941916465759,
-0.1739574372768402,
0.04941713809967041,
0.20512205362319946,
0.272889107465744,
0.5269414782524109,
0.09279672801494598,
-0.7395502924919128,
-0.1921711415052414,
-0.596230685710907,
0.6277052760124207,
-0.8843122720718384,
0.7640076875686646,
0.5055925250053406,
0.14040100574493408,
-0.11351380497217178,
-0.40372294187545776,
-0.5996893048286438,
-0.16060130298137665,
-0.15166355669498444,
-0.20692609250545502,
-0.1708173155784607,
0.052336327731609344,
0.39890962839126587,
0.46042779088020325,
-0.9332266449928284,
0.4143664240837097,
-0.6429611444473267,
-0.09923265129327774,
1.0244096517562866,
0.20351743698120117,
0.4218944013118744,
-0.46172815561294556,
-0.46796995401382446,
0.2718674838542938,
-0.5576733946800232,
-0.005610720720142126,
0.7391517162322998,
0.29973873496055603,
0.10671162605285645,
0.6702890396118164,
0.3331058919429779,
0.42181047797203064,
-0.054466232657432556,
0.3409050703048706,
0.4643450677394867,
-0.09454233944416046,
-0.26182395219802856,
-0.055320803076028824,
0.5872883200645447,
0.5344903469085693,
0.1842208206653595,
-0.21310614049434662,
-0.06978242099285126,
-0.01938934437930584,
0.5788960456848145,
-0.5033654570579529,
0.39263463020324707,
0.4692457914352417,
-0.3499891757965088,
-0.0597686730325222,
-0.06475546956062317,
-0.8878881931304932,
-0.8916565775871277,
0.1007731556892395,
0.07838724553585052,
-0.09903215616941452,
-0.254360556602478,
0.3180769681930542,
-0.16445587575435638,
0.30306702852249146,
0.32011136412620544,
-0.6252381205558777,
0.3447319567203522,
0.7587258815765381,
0.6192393898963928,
-0.4427497982978821,
-0.08517030626535416,
-0.637840986251831,
-0.19814027845859528,
-0.21301336586475372,
0.2790669798851013,
-0.3651321828365326,
-0.43522584438323975,
0.02038414403796196,
-0.03362876921892166,
0.061725396662950516,
-0.5293419361114502,
0.6951274871826172,
-0.4005717635154724,
0.48842376470565796,
-0.044800277799367905,
-0.8034869432449341,
-0.11144724488258362,
0.2694929242134094,
-0.8487411737442017,
0.9817748665809631,
0.14847958087921143,
-1.018688440322876,
0.30952465534210205,
-0.5280233025550842,
-0.09596642851829529,
0.33711519837379456,
-0.23530036211013794,
-0.31794267892837524,
0.1734946370124817,
-0.31528571248054504,
0.4970576763153076,
-0.22744250297546387,
0.468575656414032,
-0.49130168557167053,
-0.24296995997428894,
0.30648931860923767,
-0.22195850312709808,
0.8745611310005188,
0.030724087730050087,
-0.6124346256256104,
0.41902971267700195,
-0.5859355330467224,
-0.20109932124614716,
-0.08340885490179062,
-0.4180079698562622,
-0.4205808639526367,
-0.10536066442728043,
0.5829829573631287,
0.5429872274398804,
-0.04483736306428909,
-0.6890110373497009,
-0.1884351372718811,
-0.6888788342475891,
-0.21799466013908386,
1.0572326183319092,
-0.3322117328643799,
0.11298873275518417,
-0.15932051837444305,
0.7914974689483643,
-0.2681882977485657,
0.30131593346595764,
0.6012139916419983,
-0.6629850268363953,
-0.4253080487251282,
-0.057006385177373886,
0.3601197302341461,
0.508504331111908,
-0.2993050217628479,
0.641499400138855,
-0.1348157376050949,
-0.32530683279037476,
-0.27045080065727234,
0.31782346963882446,
0.38495030999183655,
-0.06116485968232155,
0.12052840739488602,
-0.4742744565010071,
-0.6507455110549927,
-1.1013870239257812,
-0.6098493337631226,
-0.34583622217178345,
-0.3184320628643036,
0.08974223583936691,
0.6452447175979614,
-0.3955673277378082,
0.943422794342041,
-0.24680615961551666,
-0.18630531430244446,
-0.18791082501411438,
-0.04146507754921913,
0.00691876420751214,
0.3961716294288635,
0.727763831615448,
-1.1325172185897827,
-0.4639926850795746,
-0.48808664083480835,
-0.4272312819957733,
-0.2835850417613983,
0.0626712515950203,
-0.18722891807556152,
0.12208818644285202,
0.6190270185470581,
-0.48238298296928406,
0.5168520212173462,
0.5619450211524963,
-1.1030659675598145,
0.7624061107635498,
0.5288926362991333,
-0.03407549858093262,
-0.8462589383125305,
0.11777713894844055,
0.037965524941682816,
-0.5561844706535339,
-0.5885488986968994,
0.37597382068634033,
-0.20189909636974335,
-0.002119530690833926,
-0.7371018528938293,
0.6812616586685181,
-0.12269121408462524,
0.1438453644514084,
0.03951379656791687,
0.07649492472410202,
-0.10415592044591904,
0.15442189574241638,
-0.3158756196498871,
0.4500495493412018,
0.05683856084942818,
-0.21909643709659576,
0.43459776043891907,
0.36495882272720337,
-0.3302091956138611,
0.47811904549598694,
-0.46647149324417114,
0.03732910752296448,
-0.3874697983264923,
0.07251517474651337,
-0.9977179765701294,
-0.13808409869670868,
0.2110266089439392,
-0.31269603967666626,
0.04283768683671951,
0.36509376764297485,
-0.4455580413341522,
-0.4437389373779297,
-0.6721932888031006,
0.5007869601249695,
0.1762644648551941,
-0.1870175004005432,
0.4756470024585724,
0.4275151789188385,
-0.2560921609401703,
-0.6201783418655396,
-0.8313093781471252,
0.11222317814826965,
-0.4964180886745453,
-0.47735080122947693,
0.12779439985752106,
-0.22823643684387207,
-0.5828524827957153,
-0.3445325493812561,
-0.02450789324939251,
0.0396704375743866,
0.5958162546157837,
0.4419521391391754,
0.08563687652349472,
0.04331604018807411,
0.4898291826248169,
-0.22585321962833405,
0.35773080587387085,
0.2911214828491211,
0.28729385137557983,
0.7044745683670044,
-0.18128064274787903,
-0.41458359360694885,
0.09936296939849854,
0.8085719347000122,
0.32896125316619873,
0.02275151014328003,
0.9193810820579529,
0.6535746455192566,
-0.4173101782798767,
-0.12928326427936554,
-0.5742539763450623,
0.13134433329105377,
-0.44496089220046997,
0.6283624768257141,
0.004013071767985821,
-1.385400414466858,
0.40228891372680664,
0.2646387219429016,
0.21015797555446625,
0.47060081362724304,
0.5307844877243042,
0.04137146472930908,
0.7144140601158142,
0.8847153782844543,
-0.02161106839776039,
0.44367945194244385,
0.43533143401145935,
0.16079813241958618,
-0.4866342842578888,
-0.15527474880218506,
-0.6088932752609253,
-0.3913368582725525,
-0.7919778227806091,
-0.5843713283538818,
0.19212964177131653,
0.16078191995620728,
-0.27345550060272217,
0.1582239717245102,
-0.2543472945690155,
0.37894609570503235,
0.42530786991119385,
-0.1465662568807602,
0.2524038553237915,
-0.08252972364425659,
-0.027843767777085304,
-0.38108861446380615,
-0.24734100699424744,
-0.5475276708602905,
1.0887649059295654,
0.5815346240997314,
0.5046664476394653,
0.5931995511054993,
0.47735515236854553,
0.7548924088478088,
0.36783796548843384,
-0.5579468607902527,
0.5632233619689941,
0.019815562292933464,
-1.299756646156311,
-0.22794589400291443,
-0.5072743892669678,
-0.9771019220352173,
0.3587358295917511,
-0.23876674473285675,
-1.3596678972244263,
0.34836840629577637,
-0.10400979220867157,
-0.07188323140144348,
0.42372655868530273,
-0.39392271637916565,
0.7923765778541565,
-0.35723450779914856,
-0.6063550710678101,
0.01609933190047741,
-0.7361740469932556,
0.6480627655982971,
-0.3914092183113098,
0.4683988392353058,
-0.3638772666454315,
0.01669551245868206,
0.7835707068443298,
-0.22142179310321808,
0.9746564030647278,
-0.14517483115196228,
-0.6012014150619507,
-0.2624514102935791,
0.3463118076324463,
0.21564704179763794,
-0.1893557906150818,
-0.6354495286941528,
0.22104914486408234,
-0.08113075792789459,
-0.31869158148765564,
-0.3179173469543457,
0.38537561893463135,
-0.4992343783378601,
-0.8477643132209778,
-0.26802343130111694,
-0.45724788308143616,
-0.38411974906921387,
0.023690709844231606,
-0.021594824269413948,
-0.0731012150645256,
-0.5559805631637573,
0.01316784881055355,
0.3517070412635803,
-0.7097774147987366,
0.1321311742067337,
0.39723414182662964,
-0.9032579064369202,
-0.13552530109882355,
0.51579749584198,
-0.23461014032363892,
0.27863675355911255,
0.023609451949596405,
-0.05347056686878204,
-0.30018916726112366,
-0.3879828453063965,
-0.06446361541748047,
0.3027361333370209,
-0.7789261937141418,
-0.14192838966846466,
-0.5593011975288391,
-0.1020369753241539,
-0.6058587431907654,
-0.11674316972494125,
-0.2370385378599167,
-0.46787187457084656,
-0.07078467309474945,
-0.31340137124061584,
0.1528039425611496,
0.8157348036766052,
0.06571292877197266,
0.14100082218647003,
-0.7529322504997253,
0.28234896063804626,
0.3458446264266968,
0.4823499321937561,
-0.22481794655323029,
-0.3736374080181122,
-0.15346746146678925,
-0.18717136979103088,
-0.1952066719532013,
-0.9510598182678223,
0.41602668166160583,
0.05718308687210083,
0.4195792078971863,
0.17466048896312714,
0.06269799917936325,
0.24984674155712128,
-0.41814345121383667,
1.0467650890350342,
0.4253711700439453,
-1.1272310018539429,
0.41326814889907837,
-0.2403424084186554,
0.11773345619440079,
0.5546264052391052,
0.6455411911010742,
-1.0868979692459106,
-0.7380741834640503,
-0.5866773724555969,
-1.0492454767227173,
0.5173378586769104,
0.4434519112110138,
0.2986019253730774,
-0.10622259229421616,
0.23424194753170013,
0.26819145679473877,
0.5405060052871704,
-1.191429853439331,
-0.37201470136642456,
0.09338782727718353,
-0.21547433733940125,
0.011874758638441563,
-0.46574535965919495,
0.02192240208387375,
-0.3401969373226166,
0.6096888780593872,
0.11387556791305542,
0.1807478964328766,
-0.08344974368810654,
-0.2539910078048706,
-0.07629148662090302,
0.5728538036346436,
0.28326520323753357,
0.3786316514015198,
-0.20046010613441467,
0.20527690649032593,
0.1702578216791153,
-0.36001056432724,
0.23184314370155334,
0.022323787212371826,
-0.03205634653568268,
0.18206685781478882,
0.41430163383483887,
0.7538837790489197,
-0.12174610048532486,
-0.9884085059165955,
0.7807433605194092,
-0.12658584117889404,
-0.02669251523911953,
-0.17983122169971466,
0.18157458305358887,
0.19319431483745575,
0.3462171256542206,
0.21309392154216766,
-0.16734345257282257,
0.4450751543045044,
-0.4760068356990814,
0.2436516284942627,
0.39045313000679016,
-0.4670853912830353,
-0.1160304844379425,
0.7776609659194946,
0.2809405028820038,
-0.4153570234775543,
0.444594144821167,
-0.10233893990516663,
-0.7240279316902161,
0.4984857439994812,
0.3625500500202179,
0.9079647064208984,
-0.506733238697052,
0.16766837239265442,
0.3077891170978546,
0.4163467586040497,
0.29633915424346924,
0.279946893453598,
0.3368058204650879,
-0.7554406523704529,
-0.03484851121902466,
-0.9889393448829651,
-0.10332505404949188,
0.07505287230014801,
-0.5184593796730042,
0.17927893996238708,
-0.5166215300559998,
-0.28477078676223755,
-0.00822057481855154,
-0.08041790872812271,
-0.5644015669822693,
0.0492098294198513,
0.7710107564926147,
0.775385856628418,
-0.9085550308227539,
0.30654847621917725,
0.4912415146827698,
-0.245518296957016,
-0.4063102900981903,
0.09986452758312225,
0.3962555527687073,
-0.29516494274139404,
0.7770891189575195,
0.4963189363479614,
-0.08298331499099731,
-0.34845972061157227,
-0.4110475182533264,
-0.5953981876373291,
0.4827096462249756,
0.6297295689582825,
-0.8378053903579712,
-0.19779425859451294,
0.7354004979133606,
0.6867050528526306,
-0.1372336447238922,
0.22657786309719086,
0.46525776386260986,
0.4474680423736572,
-0.2531011402606964,
-1.3038452863693237,
0.22241535782814026,
-0.620722770690918,
0.12898100912570953,
0.09017378836870193,
-0.32178476452827454,
1.0400677919387817,
0.24805256724357605,
-0.5179378390312195,
-0.1873580813407898,
0.31144580245018005,
0.0708455890417099,
-0.08649284392595291,
0.687577486038208,
0.3447698950767517,
0.9652701020240784,
0.3119039237499237,
0.9307118058204651,
0.29602763056755066,
0.4288273751735687,
1.2637548446655273,
-0.4123150706291199,
0.8010683059692383,
0.3790283501148224,
-0.49564558267593384,
0.5717285871505737,
0.3409620523452759,
-0.060277994722127914,
-0.20259007811546326,
0.7894837260246277,
-0.2635209560394287,
-0.31580430269241333,
-0.25730931758880615,
-0.31937578320503235,
0.4621030390262604,
0.4345584213733673,
-0.5313693881034851,
-0.2715768814086914,
0.3085411489009857,
0.02203279547393322,
0.2810688316822052,
-0.2415437549352646,
0.42969581484794617,
0.13705474138259888,
-0.09085110574960709,
0.5006647706031799,
0.3088682293891907,
1.1836504936218262,
-0.4281366467475891,
0.12783676385879517,
-0.2186780869960785,
0.021190641447901726,
-0.4025116562843323,
-0.7531455159187317,
0.5701798796653748,
0.1456461250782013,
-0.3845849633216858,
-0.21083927154541016,
0.47974178194999695,
-0.5015957355499268,
-0.6286100745201111,
0.5762056112289429,
0.7379682064056396,
0.17105264961719513,
-0.23354308307170868,
-0.791211724281311,
0.12274064868688583,
0.13566602766513824,
-0.20935088396072388,
0.3160078525543213,
-0.13822798430919647,
-0.23729677498340607,
0.7013097405433655,
0.37309277057647705,
-0.05938652902841568,
0.3483402729034424,
0.018650569021701813,
0.5797371864318848,
-0.879511296749115,
-0.4704831540584564,
-0.886461615562439,
0.45865243673324585,
-0.16437563300132751,
-0.3224024772644043,
0.9495770931243896,
0.7044674754142761,
0.7216122150421143,
0.13485395908355713,
0.4221445322036743,
-0.18656687438488007,
0.6540412306785583,
-0.3047887086868286,
0.8448250889778137,
-0.7468146681785583,
0.49408435821533203,
-0.48468562960624695,
-0.7505191564559937,
-0.5005183815956116,
0.38737061619758606,
-0.24803946912288666,
0.07941561192274094,
0.5814720988273621,
0.8141193985939026,
0.12573488056659698,
0.11488130688667297,
0.5631698966026306,
0.3961147665977478,
0.3333262503147125,
0.3780408203601837,
0.9894347786903381,
-0.42190879583358765,
0.034782715141773224,
0.1531725376844406,
0.23205392062664032,
-0.11662150919437408,
-0.5577425360679626,
-0.9143383502960205,
-0.5324466228485107,
-0.3967339098453522,
-0.40636131167411804,
-0.2016485333442688,
1.1042155027389526,
0.24732381105422974,
-0.7269302010536194,
-0.38771528005599976,
0.026246841996908188,
0.36349278688430786,
0.258474737405777,
-0.3461982309818268,
0.1621033102273941,
-0.09734106808900833,
-0.7707636952400208,
0.06737906485795975,
0.056381359696388245,
-0.22096118330955505,
-0.5937908887863159,
0.0944497287273407,
-0.6251568794250488,
0.1332848221063614,
0.6529049277305603,
-0.07484353333711624,
-0.7220514416694641,
-0.2361016571521759,
-0.3359616696834564,
-0.22083157300949097,
-0.0443684384226799,
0.6371570825576782,
-0.6166730523109436,
0.4001595973968506,
0.40497341752052307,
0.39165419340133667,
0.20695790648460388,
-0.15336115658283234,
0.8463165760040283,
-0.9831691384315491,
0.014292892999947071,
0.4256705939769745,
0.3007352948188782,
0.4208926260471344,
-0.6570745706558228,
0.5086203813552856,
0.3009995222091675,
-0.13268904387950897,
-1.0185630321502686,
0.2604093551635742,
-0.5988690853118896,
-0.5538173317909241,
1.1410446166992188,
-0.16899892687797546,
-0.16478782892227173,
-0.3793802559375763,
-0.12254665046930313,
0.09125940501689911,
-0.05842113122344017,
0.7099115252494812,
0.7165294885635376,
0.08710784465074539,
-0.0332644097507,
-0.6214932799339294,
0.609913170337677,
0.48473966121673584,
-0.9166338443756104,
0.2539530396461487,
0.8250629901885986,
0.40139126777648926,
0.08242929726839066,
0.38044723868370056,
-0.05221228674054146,
0.16551800072193146,
-0.2546232342720032,
0.40982672572135925,
0.28570273518562317,
0.052228327840566635,
-0.5549489855766296,
0.2840160131454468,
-0.04678820073604584,
0.3156452178955078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12397v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12397v1
|
Unveiling the Flaws: Exploring Imperfections in Synthetic Data and Mitigation Strategies for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-18T08:38:59 | 2024-06-18T08:38:59 |
Jie Chen, Yupeng Zhang, Bingning Wang, Wayne Xin Zhao, Ji-Rong Wen, Weipeng Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Synthetic data has been proposed as a solution to address the issue of
high-quality data scarcity in the training of large language models (LLMs).
Studies have shown that synthetic data can effectively improve the performance
of LLMs on downstream benchmarks. However, despite its potential benefits, our
analysis suggests that there may be inherent flaws in synthetic data. The
uniform format of synthetic data can lead to pattern overfitting and cause
significant shifts in the output distribution, thereby reducing the model's
instruction-following capabilities. Our work delves into these specific flaws
associated with question-answer (Q-A) pairs, a prevalent type of synthetic
data, and presents a method based on unlearning techniques to mitigate these
flaws. The empirical results demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach,
which can reverse the instruction-following issues caused by pattern
overfitting without compromising performance on benchmarks at relatively low
cost. Our work has yielded key insights into the effective use of synthetic
data, aiming to promote more robust and efficient LLM training.
|
[
-0.2719806730747223,
-1.136598825454712,
0.6795955300331116,
-0.102707639336586,
-0.18972209095954895,
0.5862530469894409,
-0.09563682973384857,
-0.363188236951828,
-0.07904432713985443,
0.8105593323707581,
-0.639284074306488,
-0.3760027289390564,
-0.3240050673484802,
-0.04851207137107849,
-0.5370662808418274,
0.7588595747947693,
-0.14057017862796783,
0.28562676906585693,
-0.5022150278091431,
-0.10282133519649506,
-0.5685597062110901,
-0.695494532585144,
-0.6584969758987427,
-0.28426358103752136,
0.2788877487182617,
0.6056773066520691,
0.6115843057632446,
0.8877971172332764,
0.260918527841568,
0.2988373041152954,
-0.03515169769525528,
0.5502632260322571,
-0.7549843788146973,
0.32672441005706787,
0.020166436210274696,
-0.6191786527633667,
-0.19634363055229187,
-0.013627720065414906,
0.9173475503921509,
0.8770291805267334,
-0.06211528927087784,
0.11048412322998047,
0.09149633347988129,
0.8816600441932678,
-0.4668865501880646,
0.17185576260089874,
-0.588289737701416,
-0.1207074448466301,
-0.3869453966617584,
-0.14865966141223907,
-0.36362436413764954,
-0.38506877422332764,
-0.27456948161125183,
-0.4583337604999542,
0.46680504083633423,
0.15840671956539154,
0.5527258515357971,
0.3397381901741028,
-0.29256367683410645,
-0.24968856573104858,
-1.0378705263137817,
0.8875537514686584,
-0.8925527334213257,
0.2798455059528351,
0.3251641094684601,
0.31679362058639526,
-0.5828819870948792,
-0.4482828378677368,
-0.651962399482727,
0.01648145169019699,
-0.08210328221321106,
0.027003182098269463,
0.07010546326637268,
-0.06361250579357147,
0.4316440522670746,
0.5564213395118713,
-0.7900249361991882,
0.10802537947893143,
-0.5944169759750366,
-0.18145811557769775,
0.9312011003494263,
0.27665549516677856,
0.31142833828926086,
0.09933480620384216,
-0.037093933671712875,
-0.39898940920829773,
-1.0519033670425415,
0.015153789892792702,
0.7415154576301575,
0.4268946051597595,
0.16109809279441833,
0.7421141266822815,
-0.24497245252132416,
0.37850484251976013,
-0.2558036148548126,
0.24844923615455627,
0.1784851849079132,
-0.4709579348564148,
-0.09627014398574829,
0.04243039712309837,
0.42915064096450806,
0.0504840686917305,
0.29224541783332825,
-0.3200153708457947,
-0.3780667781829834,
-0.0178908109664917,
0.19985586404800415,
-0.6113434433937073,
-0.20742076635360718,
0.4364907443523407,
-0.0942809134721756,
-0.26115724444389343,
0.140619695186615,
-0.8799324631690979,
-0.42806580662727356,
-0.588533878326416,
0.3597767949104309,
-0.29440590739250183,
-0.05953193083405495,
0.09040430188179016,
-0.24077118933200836,
0.26981598138809204,
0.1922193020582199,
-0.7128404974937439,
0.2698154151439667,
0.7224565148353577,
0.6628475785255432,
-0.018193189054727554,
-0.14732970297336578,
-0.4881133437156677,
0.07839804142713547,
-0.5409557223320007,
0.7231485843658447,
-0.4420604705810547,
-0.5866377353668213,
0.01665407605469227,
-0.09749191254377365,
-0.050001416355371475,
-0.9005319476127625,
0.5296453237533569,
-0.3632957339286804,
0.21229280531406403,
-0.47008565068244934,
-0.6308456659317017,
-0.017519813030958176,
0.2041216343641281,
-0.6723912954330444,
1.0555648803710938,
0.1733938455581665,
-0.42242375016212463,
-0.03125195577740669,
-0.44233959913253784,
-0.2827463448047638,
-0.1600358933210373,
-0.2298780381679535,
-0.5532199740409851,
0.2842442989349365,
0.285416841506958,
-0.014817794784903526,
-0.3819863796234131,
0.004420061130076647,
-0.29347825050354004,
-0.5745088458061218,
0.6055231690406799,
-0.7027624249458313,
0.6845698356628418,
-0.04250253736972809,
-0.22230494022369385,
0.018358377739787102,
-1.0297640562057495,
0.19113394618034363,
0.442466676235199,
-0.23086196184158325,
-0.37096622586250305,
0.027601290494203568,
-0.08247023075819016,
0.12515787780284882,
-0.061757367104291916,
-0.7278906106948853,
0.4072817862033844,
-0.5019775032997131,
0.35361960530281067,
0.8994243741035461,
0.1441250890493393,
0.3900250494480133,
-0.6341175436973572,
0.4950062036514282,
0.0357062853872776,
0.16708466410636902,
-0.1984412521123886,
-0.2246685028076172,
-0.9726899266242981,
0.10660647600889206,
0.40944862365722656,
0.47175002098083496,
-0.6109618544578552,
0.05315065011382103,
0.03954002633690834,
-0.47455787658691406,
-0.8165223598480225,
0.3794149160385132,
0.6468925476074219,
0.3689051866531372,
0.47452887892723083,
-0.32447850704193115,
-0.7977578639984131,
-0.8847416639328003,
-0.3607739508152008,
-0.012043843977153301,
0.10386363416910172,
0.15168188512325287,
0.3684788942337036,
-0.2572024464607239,
0.8835024237632751,
-0.5651155710220337,
-0.010406166315078735,
-0.2728745639324188,
0.16219303011894226,
-0.13239596784114838,
0.6646876335144043,
0.19644293189048767,
-0.7172790169715881,
-0.301657110452652,
-0.28040891885757446,
-0.4073528051376343,
0.010927406139671803,
-0.21476776897907257,
-0.11023198068141937,
0.4254000186920166,
0.7656716704368591,
-0.5286256074905396,
0.3365764915943146,
0.5456848740577698,
-0.11747489124536514,
0.6577038168907166,
-0.20536546409130096,
0.10104295611381531,
-0.9359225034713745,
-0.11884453147649765,
-0.18513600528240204,
-0.05174561217427254,
-0.6729750037193298,
0.028983190655708313,
0.014122280292212963,
0.052329257130622864,
-0.2932661771774292,
0.5014048218727112,
-0.3090968728065491,
-0.015152698382735252,
-0.0881187692284584,
-0.13833512365818024,
0.1484307199716568,
0.3915521800518036,
-0.33204367756843567,
0.9329460263252258,
0.14926700294017792,
-0.25837939977645874,
0.4063168466091156,
0.26712897419929504,
-0.1879245489835739,
0.23408570885658264,
-0.6797707676887512,
0.4680602550506592,
-0.35149043798446655,
0.08969302475452423,
-1.122764229774475,
-0.4517291188240051,
0.21421125531196594,
-0.5013831853866577,
0.5552075505256653,
-0.24313583970069885,
-0.6093042492866516,
-0.06613413989543915,
-0.471703439950943,
0.5464082956314087,
0.607322633266449,
-0.5738227963447571,
0.29322129487991333,
0.25113552808761597,
-0.06979823857545853,
-0.4671928882598877,
-0.6859633922576904,
-0.13237003982067108,
-0.25739187002182007,
-0.5173430442810059,
0.3416873812675476,
-0.22949646413326263,
-0.2902737259864807,
-0.07620126754045486,
-0.24095873534679413,
-0.1743009388446808,
0.025024570524692535,
0.1680382788181305,
0.165763720870018,
-0.24406053125858307,
0.19140741229057312,
-0.0870208814740181,
-0.08751590549945831,
0.28255873918533325,
0.00717101851478219,
0.7604888677597046,
0.11993914842605591,
-0.49582353234291077,
-0.21727000176906586,
0.524589478969574,
0.7051741480827332,
-0.23430995643138885,
0.7935308218002319,
0.2258560061454773,
-0.4062032103538513,
-0.6033725738525391,
-0.44071078300476074,
-0.23344109952449799,
-0.5272570252418518,
0.36692145466804504,
0.02578405663371086,
-0.4927365183830261,
0.5045393109321594,
-0.20679646730422974,
0.03325444087386131,
0.17170949280261993,
0.1425412893295288,
-0.318512886762619,
1.2451555728912354,
0.586763322353363,
0.10883365571498871,
0.2119569480419159,
-0.40769630670547485,
0.3998868465423584,
-0.7637388706207275,
-0.43287286162376404,
-0.6264317035675049,
-0.23850296437740326,
-0.6360129714012146,
-0.4925376772880554,
0.28082314133644104,
0.2428438812494278,
-0.2805632948875427,
0.06845337897539139,
-0.08448760211467743,
0.6609638333320618,
0.726832926273346,
0.09996464848518372,
0.3186590075492859,
-0.038169387727975845,
0.09540324658155441,
-0.014335780404508114,
-0.5895035266876221,
-0.5215759873390198,
1.2001758813858032,
0.2558072805404663,
0.7359541058540344,
0.05223919078707695,
0.6132757067680359,
0.06258948147296906,
-0.14276757836341858,
-0.6304574608802795,
0.401344358921051,
-0.18590757250785828,
-0.4648604989051819,
-0.4664313495159149,
-0.5940004587173462,
-0.7143025994300842,
-0.08921708911657333,
-0.22054989635944366,
-0.4011256694793701,
0.10371920466423035,
0.4235664904117584,
-0.1165858805179596,
0.3281126916408539,
-0.7922541499137878,
0.8905762434005737,
-0.3240410387516022,
-0.26880380511283875,
-0.03515618294477463,
-0.3472296893596649,
0.38134095072746277,
-0.37155795097351074,
0.27025100588798523,
0.14398545026779175,
0.30743125081062317,
0.5478546023368835,
-0.34985944628715515,
0.873602032661438,
0.016290174797177315,
-0.13236449658870697,
0.21609625220298767,
0.07317466288805008,
0.7143294811248779,
0.05298946797847748,
0.14143778383731842,
-0.0074738748371601105,
-0.04262363538146019,
-0.7316972017288208,
-0.9529824256896973,
0.6447365880012512,
-0.6704455614089966,
-0.6305025815963745,
-0.2670797109603882,
-0.7265707850456238,
-0.6526440382003784,
-0.053014542907476425,
0.16504302620887756,
0.5552932024002075,
-0.18324004113674164,
0.24433375895023346,
0.7655832171440125,
-0.4097045958042145,
0.35379353165626526,
0.4293551743030548,
-0.07423712313175201,
-0.21255436539649963,
1.000127911567688,
0.3525451123714447,
0.5552440881729126,
0.02392738312482834,
0.1313256174325943,
-0.4268729090690613,
-0.8939415216445923,
-0.4670868217945099,
0.2778806686401367,
-0.5006075501441956,
-0.07174381613731384,
-0.19359250366687775,
-0.436898797750473,
-0.40197378396987915,
0.08483385294675827,
-0.6643438935279846,
-0.5199722647666931,
-0.0811212956905365,
-0.04558393731713295,
0.19668139517307281,
0.8245140314102173,
0.0638679787516594,
0.237251415848732,
-0.9000462889671326,
0.0845053642988205,
0.12736938893795013,
0.35039034485816956,
-0.06110679730772972,
-0.4876714050769806,
-0.17474474012851715,
0.5411611795425415,
-0.3438904881477356,
-0.6910489201545715,
0.4867173433303833,
0.03659922629594803,
0.48431703448295593,
0.12948428094387054,
0.21039234101772308,
0.8682544827461243,
-0.3891962170600891,
0.5725465416908264,
-0.26954180002212524,
-0.7836456298828125,
0.5617560148239136,
-0.320440411567688,
0.10034354031085968,
0.36381784081459045,
0.4011022448539734,
-0.5553866624832153,
-0.5246533751487732,
-0.6617549657821655,
-0.958655834197998,
0.590320348739624,
0.23890572786331177,
0.25204381346702576,
0.2474631816148758,
0.5352720618247986,
0.08828911930322647,
0.18882153928279877,
-0.386884868144989,
-0.3402926027774811,
0.019504932686686516,
-0.226614847779274,
-0.33615782856941223,
-0.211717888712883,
-0.10740810632705688,
-0.25819528102874756,
0.753144383430481,
-0.01049712859094143,
-0.05003736913204193,
0.09638602286577225,
-0.08058686554431915,
-0.3663443922996521,
0.33257484436035156,
0.6487666964530945,
0.5753025412559509,
-0.18815618753433228,
-0.012558745220303535,
0.11350154876708984,
-0.4876759946346283,
0.14374300837516785,
-0.11065337806940079,
-0.3213936388492584,
-0.12070076912641525,
0.3258969783782959,
0.44585251808166504,
-0.08477744460105896,
-0.9889588356018066,
0.1353064775466919,
0.1200082004070282,
-0.08263789117336273,
-0.324464350938797,
0.32113197445869446,
0.022785618901252747,
0.27686312794685364,
0.31752756237983704,
0.03680894151329994,
-0.05254397541284561,
-0.9733544588088989,
0.16373495757579803,
0.4785628616809845,
-0.24371685087680817,
-0.3090781569480896,
0.1288832426071167,
-0.11394108086824417,
-0.34531497955322266,
0.8415153622627258,
-0.19346925616264343,
-0.5746357440948486,
0.7425022721290588,
0.6627214550971985,
0.36576908826828003,
-0.4027961492538452,
0.2919810116291046,
0.23943251371383667,
0.34496256709098816,
-0.19750559329986572,
0.33901575207710266,
0.3227430582046509,
-0.7104085683822632,
-0.41685354709625244,
-0.4091285169124603,
-0.5275442004203796,
0.5126229524612427,
-0.6736689805984497,
0.04017869383096695,
-0.4714833199977875,
0.3807278871536255,
-0.17026923596858978,
0.05543433502316475,
-0.4060429334640503,
0.15269005298614502,
-0.16257651150226593,
0.5474492907524109,
-0.9548525214195251,
0.6612805128097534,
0.453163206577301,
-0.5832061171531677,
-0.8357628583908081,
0.08868709951639175,
0.08656421303749084,
-0.7970705628395081,
0.46483418345451355,
0.03229927644133568,
0.22674152255058289,
0.016479818150401115,
-0.58003830909729,
-0.8806502819061279,
0.7581225633621216,
0.5099359154701233,
-0.7142475843429565,
0.031461142003536224,
0.7767027020454407,
0.49813970923423767,
-0.07319372147321701,
-0.10251707583665848,
0.9101117849349976,
0.4210849702358246,
0.17992156744003296,
-0.6560313105583191,
0.1124795451760292,
-0.21063505113124847,
-0.24264097213745117,
0.5045084953308105,
-0.5195610523223877,
0.8298935890197754,
-0.12847569584846497,
-0.401358038187027,
0.13023637235164642,
0.11035570502281189,
0.20549272000789642,
0.37373554706573486,
0.2417011559009552,
0.5649069547653198,
0.7548738121986389,
-0.28487110137939453,
0.8984200954437256,
0.1368561089038849,
0.20571386814117432,
1.1592882871627808,
-0.21602864563465118,
0.9277095198631287,
0.6396802067756653,
-0.1913577914237976,
0.20034386217594147,
0.5121322870254517,
-0.017452357336878777,
0.39312756061553955,
0.610963761806488,
-0.11716422438621521,
-0.19959795475006104,
-0.07159951329231262,
-0.24042171239852905,
0.5426813364028931,
0.3808937072753906,
-0.08370154350996017,
-0.26390397548675537,
-0.19946731626987457,
-0.1855778694152832,
0.3130055367946625,
-0.1686345934867859,
0.6960096955299377,
-0.01454202365130186,
-0.4682185649871826,
0.6999561786651611,
-0.006279050372540951,
0.3177890181541443,
-0.25857269763946533,
-0.41386932134628296,
-0.643064558506012,
0.234290212392807,
-0.1698835790157318,
-0.544304609298706,
0.5155516862869263,
-0.07785040885210037,
-0.192285418510437,
-0.19721315801143646,
0.4122580289840698,
-0.5982829332351685,
-0.4906725287437439,
-0.02647010236978531,
0.616570234298706,
-0.02436242811381817,
-0.2119460552930832,
-0.4841940999031067,
0.16221103072166443,
-0.027494391426444054,
0.041828129440546036,
0.36384594440460205,
0.31651753187179565,
-0.093610480427742,
0.6027736663818359,
0.9323827624320984,
0.235470250248909,
0.1362975686788559,
-0.025617480278015137,
0.940618634223938,
-0.7297447919845581,
-0.030605832114815712,
-0.7986234426498413,
0.628937840461731,
-0.21009336411952972,
-0.2214127779006958,
0.7892370820045471,
0.6952141523361206,
1.2526053190231323,
0.13336166739463806,
0.6839631795883179,
0.5672366619110107,
0.7797214388847351,
-0.816454291343689,
0.6436417698860168,
-0.3808158338069916,
0.7422571778297424,
0.01314011961221695,
-1.046667218208313,
-0.2970864474773407,
0.27628523111343384,
-0.09499743580818176,
0.05060974881052971,
0.6419268846511841,
1.0216729640960693,
-0.0032184021547436714,
-0.026015976443886757,
0.27187374234199524,
0.397087424993515,
0.4819023609161377,
0.4043563902378082,
1.1383311748504639,
-0.6658118963241577,
0.5260443091392517,
-0.42131778597831726,
0.13639488816261292,
0.006842696573585272,
-0.5371651649475098,
-0.8174514174461365,
-0.49726468324661255,
-0.3024967908859253,
-0.39094078540802,
0.3677603006362915,
0.8109302520751953,
0.40920963883399963,
-0.9654547572135925,
-0.11369713395833969,
-0.5173293948173523,
0.028287088498473167,
0.08375179022550583,
-0.19287365674972534,
0.3488755524158478,
-0.45407813787460327,
-0.6904557943344116,
0.6005275249481201,
0.08668424934148788,
0.5128865242004395,
-0.42302095890045166,
-0.038342565298080444,
0.1561790406703949,
0.36634042859077454,
0.36836475133895874,
0.517358660697937,
-0.514162540435791,
-0.31908321380615234,
0.19481360912322998,
0.1162962019443512,
-0.0017798779299482703,
1.0104731321334839,
-0.6793844103813171,
0.3591628670692444,
0.43630367517471313,
0.8274517059326172,
0.26266318559646606,
0.18763111531734467,
0.9016417860984802,
-1.0900681018829346,
-0.007295862305909395,
0.28929635882377625,
0.2686125934123993,
0.3723333179950714,
-0.3434275984764099,
0.38524460792541504,
0.14485540986061096,
-0.4944583773612976,
-1.2888569831848145,
0.12771429121494293,
-0.6765277981758118,
-0.5682755708694458,
1.1559982299804688,
0.030604572966694832,
-0.1337066888809204,
-0.3264319896697998,
-0.3385903239250183,
0.29138365387916565,
-0.14899781346321106,
1.0901485681533813,
0.7317492365837097,
-0.056211113929748535,
-0.0899495854973793,
-0.6814650893211365,
0.6479897499084473,
0.4821716547012329,
-0.9323038458824158,
0.3858586251735687,
0.5363478064537048,
0.09843293577432632,
-0.05362531542778015,
0.1387380212545395,
-0.2323800027370453,
0.22335882484912872,
-0.029266007244586945,
-0.38218650221824646,
-0.2276473194360733,
-0.4032677412033081,
-0.43851470947265625,
-0.0545523427426815,
0.11553053557872772,
-0.13001269102096558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12946v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12946v1
|
Instruction Data Generation and Unsupervised Adaptation for Speech Language Models
| 2024-06-18T08:27:00 | 2024-06-18T08:27:00 |
Vahid Noroozi, Zhehuai Chen, Somshubra Majumdar, Steve Huang, Jagadeesh Balam, Boris Ginsburg
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we propose three methods for generating synthetic samples to
train and evaluate multimodal large language models capable of processing both
text and speech inputs. Addressing the scarcity of samples containing both
modalities, synthetic data generation emerges as a crucial strategy to enhance
the performance of such systems and facilitate the modeling of cross-modal
relationships between the speech and text domains. Our process employs large
language models to generate textual components and text-to-speech systems to
generate speech components. The proposed methods offer a practical and
effective means to expand the training dataset for these models. Experimental
results show progress in achieving an integrated understanding of text and
speech. We also highlight the potential of using unlabeled speech data to
generate synthetic samples comparable in quality to those with available
transcriptions, enabling the expansion of these models to more languages.
|
[
-0.07821006327867508,
-0.8455297350883484,
0.5103573799133301,
0.002154389163479209,
-0.0701313316822052,
0.15055295825004578,
-0.4618617296218872,
-0.25787076354026794,
-0.12762007117271423,
0.711845338344574,
-0.6860014200210571,
-0.32557448744773865,
-0.14921769499778748,
-0.1414351761341095,
-0.598352313041687,
0.911465585231781,
0.20631267130374908,
0.5136265754699707,
-0.19830439984798431,
0.09658188372850418,
-0.5029774308204651,
-0.6974589228630066,
-0.3511350154876709,
-0.3168299198150635,
0.0909755676984787,
0.36186984181404114,
0.3696122467517853,
0.44040489196777344,
-0.1814432591199875,
0.3513188660144806,
0.3478114902973175,
0.30020084977149963,
-0.3244321346282959,
0.2859160304069519,
-0.29983094334602356,
-0.3477461338043213,
-0.23744353652000427,
0.09521808475255966,
1.0115891695022583,
1.043318510055542,
-0.18971900641918182,
0.1549450159072876,
0.015912050381302834,
0.37909790873527527,
-0.5504449009895325,
0.28612685203552246,
-0.76503586769104,
-0.1296069175004959,
-0.22668848931789398,
-0.3508027493953705,
-0.7684739232063293,
-0.11641574651002884,
0.2186809629201889,
-0.5166803598403931,
0.41478559374809265,
-0.33001524209976196,
-0.02380957268178463,
-0.0012490894878283143,
-0.453665554523468,
-0.41146987676620483,
-1.2244482040405273,
0.9761109352111816,
-0.6866461038589478,
0.7145752906799316,
0.23231734335422516,
0.3686193823814392,
-0.37493205070495605,
-0.9002346396446228,
-0.6589124798774719,
-0.30414485931396484,
0.24339425563812256,
0.13393762707710266,
-0.021720951423048973,
-0.04926282539963722,
0.16235485672950745,
0.07316513359546661,
-0.45303142070770264,
0.09253273159265518,
-0.672406017780304,
-0.15075485408306122,
0.7906559109687805,
-0.020976755768060684,
0.47420817613601685,
-0.1302640289068222,
-0.1562444418668747,
-0.4909649193286896,
-0.5707098245620728,
-0.12683692574501038,
0.5723681449890137,
0.6171618103981018,
-0.16157089173793793,
0.6703605055809021,
0.02459132671356201,
0.8188096880912781,
-0.06345665454864502,
-0.3270117938518524,
0.39695265889167786,
-0.4772008955478668,
-0.2768172323703766,
0.38190898299217224,
0.7139541506767273,
0.08484866470098495,
0.27009010314941406,
-0.13819921016693115,
-0.19774404168128967,
0.1134796142578125,
0.33168721199035645,
-0.5525503754615784,
-0.21815581619739532,
-0.004115517251193523,
-0.20871925354003906,
-0.23879899084568024,
0.07110552489757538,
-1.121425747871399,
-0.25976717472076416,
-0.7529445290565491,
0.3853791356086731,
-0.4822838008403778,
-0.2020225077867508,
-0.005139264278113842,
-0.2988497316837311,
-0.07215780764818192,
0.13910965621471405,
-1.0744990110397339,
0.2802332639694214,
0.2803401052951813,
0.34439677000045776,
-0.38126036524772644,
-0.25256577134132385,
-0.6814563870429993,
0.3873538076877594,
-0.4603157043457031,
0.7022563815116882,
-0.7994626760482788,
-0.5392149090766907,
0.18479642271995544,
0.10253123939037323,
-0.36555734276771545,
-0.5347855687141418,
0.39406606554985046,
-0.3175073564052582,
0.42916300892829895,
0.3226557672023773,
-0.5273073315620422,
-0.20747803151607513,
-0.4560423791408539,
-0.7135655879974365,
1.041476845741272,
0.25607702136039734,
-0.22979258000850677,
0.019040169194340706,
-0.8137005567550659,
-0.5051484107971191,
-0.13879841566085815,
-0.1820031851530075,
-0.08713845908641815,
0.2575429677963257,
0.4460422694683075,
0.4813518822193146,
-0.48485860228538513,
0.3301417827606201,
-0.008365774527192116,
-0.052589721977710724,
0.5779428482055664,
-0.7652066349983215,
0.6411657929420471,
0.19806478917598724,
-0.23722028732299805,
0.05442158505320549,
-1.1301668882369995,
0.3426956236362457,
-0.06528332084417343,
-0.4995260238647461,
-0.24461498856544495,
0.1562158614397049,
0.47439947724342346,
0.0494111105799675,
-0.05124795064330101,
-0.618288516998291,
0.03487825021147728,
-0.48689547181129456,
0.7236827611923218,
0.6249085068702698,
0.07657431811094284,
0.4374697208404541,
-0.13822853565216064,
0.4951186776161194,
0.04417644441127777,
-0.1696394383907318,
-0.4479600787162781,
-0.15299223363399506,
-0.7585455775260925,
-0.07284936308860779,
0.5878564715385437,
0.5180543065071106,
-1.0741981267929077,
0.2918822169303894,
-0.2514604926109314,
-0.4996791183948517,
-0.5964698195457458,
0.0983489528298378,
0.4850757122039795,
0.27828294038772583,
0.41816267371177673,
-0.1431257426738739,
-0.7728311419487,
-0.6988076567649841,
-0.013617271557450294,
-0.0017028748989105225,
-0.24414047598838806,
0.019019456580281258,
0.28839269280433655,
-0.23839044570922852,
0.7816594839096069,
-0.2848321497440338,
0.23283635079860687,
-0.3600216209888458,
0.3009718060493469,
-0.1790141612291336,
0.7338742017745972,
0.5483858585357666,
-0.666689932346344,
-0.1448032706975937,
0.06368660181760788,
-0.39338093996047974,
-0.054244544357061386,
-0.24720627069473267,
0.10344596207141876,
0.3058493733406067,
0.6114417910575867,
-0.1687021255493164,
0.15400169789791107,
0.9293987154960632,
0.10033918172121048,
0.43242284655570984,
-0.33103445172309875,
0.2495313286781311,
-1.3245395421981812,
-0.12135614454746246,
-0.041348718106746674,
-0.2762114703655243,
-1.0168414115905762,
-0.18956080079078674,
-0.2663806080818176,
-0.5222654938697815,
-0.631380558013916,
0.4166582226753235,
-0.5238341689109802,
-0.19867615401744843,
-0.316456139087677,
0.08870149403810501,
-0.12658920884132385,
0.3591589033603668,
0.1246325671672821,
0.9951990246772766,
0.5531564950942993,
-0.5769825577735901,
0.6420341730117798,
0.04286109656095505,
-0.5782790184020996,
0.1082972064614296,
-0.6364908218383789,
0.4378058910369873,
-0.18247388303279877,
0.1987915188074112,
-0.9789174795150757,
-0.5562064051628113,
0.05820183828473091,
-0.4135976731777191,
0.4401305615901947,
-0.015583241358399391,
-0.32561835646629333,
-0.01893431879580021,
-0.023001696914434433,
0.5319393277168274,
0.6593523025512695,
-0.6187669038772583,
0.6607563495635986,
0.651506245136261,
-0.42019250988960266,
-0.21623869240283966,
-0.7179123163223267,
-0.08408092707395554,
0.0599108561873436,
-0.46684494614601135,
0.42423495650291443,
0.07792460918426514,
-0.1256052702665329,
-0.14286772906780243,
0.19707849621772766,
-0.2518865764141083,
-0.398215115070343,
0.23254580795764923,
0.21992285549640656,
-0.29587599635124207,
0.3271629512310028,
0.36534079909324646,
0.12460077553987503,
0.12764735519886017,
-0.3334572911262512,
0.6211742162704468,
0.4606490731239319,
-0.5087438821792603,
-0.494197815656662,
0.6247447729110718,
0.7209625244140625,
-0.21867170929908752,
0.46926257014274597,
0.4717058837413788,
-0.23259034752845764,
-0.6134929060935974,
-0.2889384627342224,
-0.23581723868846893,
-0.4583946764469147,
0.6036590933799744,
-0.2618423402309418,
-0.5456305146217346,
0.028135407716035843,
-0.19792258739471436,
-0.05343214422464371,
0.22160647809505463,
0.8357685208320618,
-0.00470074312761426,
1.222784161567688,
0.5523837804794312,
0.2400173544883728,
0.5651703476905823,
-0.07159283012151718,
0.04952733963727951,
-0.7398265600204468,
-0.2822704315185547,
-0.5943139791488647,
0.004367902409285307,
-0.709832489490509,
-0.9245946407318115,
0.5065305829048157,
-0.2889789342880249,
0.15113680064678192,
0.15620307624340057,
-0.40792903304100037,
0.39157047867774963,
0.8127343654632568,
0.2292923480272293,
-0.01279581617563963,
0.3428332805633545,
-0.08489847928285599,
-0.08809645473957062,
-0.7402749061584473,
-0.4707501530647278,
1.3123232126235962,
0.10204043239355087,
0.7738281488418579,
-0.1281290501356125,
0.25107666850090027,
0.29568660259246826,
-0.10164093971252441,
-0.7008848786354065,
0.38269004225730896,
-0.35343676805496216,
-0.506919801235199,
-0.3489344120025635,
-0.26435965299606323,
-0.775015652179718,
0.07583696395158768,
-0.3691697418689728,
-0.5135790109634399,
0.22735430300235748,
0.03826098144054413,
-0.10655884444713593,
-0.00043320850818417966,
-1.0421802997589111,
0.5312380194664001,
-0.08703508228063583,
-0.06763622909784317,
-0.2904999852180481,
-0.413915753364563,
0.38791972398757935,
-0.4598991274833679,
0.17750148475170135,
0.2474602609872818,
0.2687743902206421,
0.9406627416610718,
-0.15337297320365906,
1.0801585912704468,
-0.17718225717544556,
-0.21697813272476196,
0.4500710964202881,
-0.2245790809392929,
0.28625717759132385,
-0.16889232397079468,
-0.24773365259170532,
0.04127665236592293,
0.16525448858737946,
-0.2719654440879822,
-0.7123501896858215,
0.5489452481269836,
-0.8265431523323059,
-0.40306758880615234,
-0.18191152811050415,
-0.9925957322120667,
-0.5287946462631226,
-0.004313668701797724,
0.06869907677173615,
0.7845245003700256,
-0.29462695121765137,
0.3683737814426422,
0.520689070224762,
-0.6057400703430176,
0.46226128935813904,
0.4089805483818054,
-0.001586636179126799,
-0.5583494901657104,
0.9069502353668213,
0.08692469447851181,
0.5423315167427063,
0.17936304211616516,
0.03406620770692825,
-0.4500846862792969,
-0.5050638318061829,
-0.7085007429122925,
0.1420896053314209,
-0.636588990688324,
0.1680244356393814,
-0.4312555491924286,
-0.39359837770462036,
-0.826577365398407,
0.20299102365970612,
-0.47809454798698425,
-0.5707542300224304,
-0.26680997014045715,
0.08356118947267532,
0.3393939435482025,
0.7287752628326416,
-0.13307295739650726,
0.3535969853401184,
-0.9246879816055298,
0.3706127107143402,
0.45565423369407654,
-0.21562884747982025,
-0.15627065300941467,
-0.6192947030067444,
-0.15981878340244293,
0.5910021066665649,
-0.22818580269813538,
-0.9491134285926819,
0.4704076647758484,
0.4503211975097656,
0.6356698274612427,
0.09247596561908722,
-0.012462211772799492,
0.5466641187667847,
-0.8882238864898682,
0.8840777277946472,
0.10887603461742401,
-1.110615849494934,
0.6937068700790405,
-0.373958557844162,
0.10547246783971786,
0.13648657500743866,
0.3276737332344055,
-0.3148314356803894,
-0.14025017619132996,
-0.360835462808609,
-0.5411335229873657,
0.9231052398681641,
0.1375131607055664,
0.4687564969062805,
0.27586179971694946,
0.20485888421535492,
0.18882666528224945,
0.16218826174736023,
-0.44663602113723755,
-0.03320912644267082,
-0.3496664762496948,
-0.3501567542552948,
-0.20944182574748993,
-0.19481442868709564,
-0.1073397621512413,
-0.33054405450820923,
0.7368486523628235,
-0.18576893210411072,
0.3295731544494629,
-0.1416887491941452,
-0.030876854434609413,
-0.010625069960951805,
0.4438902735710144,
0.7389780282974243,
0.7410734295845032,
0.11439864337444305,
0.05477561056613922,
0.02921876683831215,
-0.610651433467865,
0.3177432119846344,
0.12379731982946396,
-0.10180550813674927,
0.15030603110790253,
0.4261374771595001,
1.098801851272583,
0.24576866626739502,
-0.8886807560920715,
0.18094035983085632,
0.1860118955373764,
-0.14490650594234467,
-0.3056054413318634,
0.3760541081428528,
0.01866675727069378,
0.23366695642471313,
0.08261509239673615,
-0.19096092879772186,
-0.011474833823740482,
-1.0061187744140625,
0.29210007190704346,
0.306081622838974,
-0.3296636641025543,
-0.446296364068985,
0.5420493483543396,
0.15760909020900726,
-0.3186410367488861,
0.6020593047142029,
0.21169880032539368,
-0.18164651095867157,
0.4461667835712433,
1.0522910356521606,
0.663587212562561,
-0.6305446028709412,
0.4556411802768707,
0.2404545247554779,
0.010685398243367672,
0.1554478406906128,
0.2163229137659073,
0.015340035781264305,
-0.6485068202018738,
-0.5968901515007019,
-0.7084423303604126,
-0.37406665086746216,
0.4868979752063751,
-0.6954320073127747,
0.2605421841144562,
-0.07140243053436279,
0.07252656668424606,
0.4140312075614929,
-0.39664551615715027,
-0.20799553394317627,
0.2741765081882477,
0.165932759642601,
0.510703980922699,
-1.0340595245361328,
1.1190816164016724,
0.7391217947006226,
-0.1158890649676323,
-0.7737933397293091,
0.020007966086268425,
-0.07891647517681122,
-0.8008611798286438,
0.7159428000450134,
-0.24664947390556335,
-0.059432029724121094,
0.0643274262547493,
-0.38061246275901794,
-0.8063559532165527,
0.6813569068908691,
0.5312351584434509,
-0.4881826341152191,
-0.08939971774816513,
0.5575250387191772,
0.619448184967041,
-0.4894539713859558,
0.026640381664037704,
0.7509256601333618,
0.32170066237449646,
0.22607675194740295,
-0.7943710684776306,
-0.21385155618190765,
-0.16504856944084167,
0.2593970000743866,
0.05464530363678932,
-0.04968532174825668,
0.9512827396392822,
0.05958838388323784,
-0.31003186106681824,
0.043543215841054916,
0.5862559676170349,
0.15373064577579498,
0.021901171654462814,
0.5004350543022156,
0.12932811677455902,
0.5904396176338196,
0.005202829372137785,
0.7402743697166443,
-0.1323046237230301,
-0.0676933079957962,
1.3247039318084717,
-0.3250327706336975,
0.7894055843353271,
0.43555542826652527,
-0.08530650287866592,
0.40091472864151,
0.30913639068603516,
-0.06302054226398468,
0.5809131860733032,
0.1824052780866623,
-0.4220966398715973,
-0.0940399095416069,
-0.23405209183692932,
-0.3556159436702728,
0.9268472194671631,
0.5090485215187073,
-0.5218291282653809,
-0.33719030022621155,
0.47097048163414,
-0.2936388850212097,
0.21837587654590607,
-0.10904770344495773,
0.765636682510376,
-0.17559289932250977,
-0.7514392733573914,
0.6948666572570801,
0.1097414493560791,
0.15579715371131897,
-0.520733654499054,
-0.27917686104774475,
0.19371534883975983,
0.1381567120552063,
0.06357384473085403,
-0.5439152717590332,
0.23407134413719177,
0.2423398196697235,
-0.4095049798488617,
-0.23587064445018768,
0.488852322101593,
-0.8276776671409607,
-0.8019554018974304,
-0.05366378277540207,
0.38028040528297424,
0.1927943229675293,
0.18903590738773346,
-0.4778498411178589,
0.057692576199769974,
0.15817292034626007,
-0.10662735253572464,
0.32225552201271057,
0.4786403775215149,
-0.14313051104545593,
0.26354363560676575,
0.9495086669921875,
0.2964652478694916,
0.4207537770271301,
0.2474411427974701,
0.8870534300804138,
-0.3475925326347351,
-0.254129022359848,
-0.5987971425056458,
0.4434199631214142,
0.0986928939819336,
-0.12846161425113678,
0.5733710527420044,
0.458095520734787,
0.9457603693008423,
-0.42126455903053284,
1.0545074939727783,
0.08268067985773087,
0.776573657989502,
-1.008890151977539,
0.4659302830696106,
-0.28204643726348877,
-0.030540943145751953,
-0.2115253508090973,
-0.9244303703308105,
0.19642724096775055,
0.4213314354419708,
-0.06824007630348206,
0.0993432030081749,
0.6195895671844482,
0.9133001565933228,
-0.22968682646751404,
0.17660534381866455,
0.2828776240348816,
0.004526567179709673,
0.3313896358013153,
0.48382940888404846,
0.8439252376556396,
-0.5380256772041321,
0.2214830368757248,
-0.3004602789878845,
-0.23601442575454712,
0.19838428497314453,
-0.6219092607498169,
-0.9354096055030823,
-0.910760223865509,
-0.15037290751934052,
-0.17860671877861023,
-0.02536631189286709,
0.8847531080245972,
0.9628648161888123,
-0.9689191579818726,
-0.3995143175125122,
-0.08817961812019348,
-0.38799849152565,
-0.03962797299027443,
-0.21822214126586914,
0.28287792205810547,
-0.48126155138015747,
-1.4058990478515625,
1.0359973907470703,
-0.005395368207246065,
0.32849249243736267,
-0.45594343543052673,
0.1416676938533783,
-0.13351544737815857,
0.32348063588142395,
0.7193652391433716,
0.20592185854911804,
-0.5736300349235535,
-0.10882566124200821,
-0.04765157029032707,
0.3103904128074646,
-0.15846852958202362,
0.9767154455184937,
-0.7285100817680359,
0.6560965776443481,
0.500263512134552,
0.8117188215255737,
0.4634934365749359,
0.006921935360878706,
0.9842129349708557,
-1.0655543804168701,
0.5514618158340454,
0.2107396125793457,
0.048597510904073715,
0.31222739815711975,
-0.08734223246574402,
0.2006932944059372,
0.02797679603099823,
-0.39360934495925903,
-1.0648701190948486,
0.2953867018222809,
-0.8774142861366272,
-0.32671505212783813,
1.2763346433639526,
0.11064380407333374,
-0.2872965633869171,
-0.0072957174852490425,
-0.2885931730270386,
0.635432779788971,
-0.19596752524375916,
0.6220803260803223,
0.5220790505409241,
-0.20896010100841522,
-0.08316670358181,
-0.753770649433136,
0.49640804529190063,
0.1601007580757141,
-1.0292075872421265,
0.2795310914516449,
0.6994169354438782,
0.036368969827890396,
0.20143680274486542,
0.1882242113351822,
-0.18539105355739594,
0.2605641484260559,
0.15233929455280304,
0.13884007930755615,
0.06785611808300018,
-0.4981168210506439,
-0.3162548542022705,
0.032230496406555176,
-0.3761177062988281,
-0.41534367203712463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12389v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12389v1
|
EMO-KNOW: A Large Scale Dataset on Emotion and Emotion-cause
| 2024-06-18T08:26:33 | 2024-06-18T08:26:33 |
Mia Huong Nguyen, Yasith Samaradivakara, Prasanth Sasikumar, Chitralekha Gupta, Suranga Nanayakkara
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Emotion-Cause analysis has attracted the attention of researchers in recent
years. However, most existing datasets are limited in size and number of
emotion categories. They often focus on extracting parts of the document that
contain the emotion cause and fail to provide more abstractive, generalizable
root cause. To bridge this gap, we introduce a large-scale dataset of emotion
causes, derived from 9.8 million cleaned tweets over 15 years. We describe our
curation process, which includes a comprehensive pipeline for data gathering,
cleaning, labeling, and validation, ensuring the dataset's reliability and
richness. We extract emotion labels and provide abstractive summarization of
the events causing emotions. The final dataset comprises over 700,000 tweets
with corresponding emotion-cause pairs spanning 48 emotion classes, validated
by human evaluators. The novelty of our dataset stems from its broad spectrum
of emotion classes and the abstractive emotion cause that facilitates the
development of an emotion-cause knowledge graph for nuanced reasoning. Our
dataset will enable the design of emotion-aware systems that account for the
diverse emotional responses of different people for the same event.
|
[
-0.45600736141204834,
-0.7662250399589539,
0.6384508609771729,
0.09490128606557846,
-0.15051686763763428,
0.029363339766860008,
-0.14527222514152527,
-0.4314194321632385,
0.7039378881454468,
0.3059942424297333,
-0.7427168488502502,
-0.45151081681251526,
-0.6349688768386841,
0.16502216458320618,
-0.518618643283844,
0.9128515124320984,
0.08762888610363007,
-0.4167546033859253,
0.303150475025177,
-0.05973783880472183,
-0.0931507796049118,
-0.0824718177318573,
-0.8753494024276733,
-0.00331351300701499,
0.9925820231437683,
0.938762366771698,
0.2313893735408783,
0.318759560585022,
0.36278796195983887,
0.09595097601413727,
0.1986643373966217,
0.0654095709323883,
-0.7336333990097046,
0.3805244266986847,
-0.03459370508790016,
-0.16346947848796844,
-0.5111262202262878,
-0.3845868706703186,
0.16495637595653534,
0.33164316415786743,
-0.06502620130777359,
0.15922729671001434,
-0.30040231347084045,
0.8853541612625122,
-0.9171595573425293,
-0.17825910449028015,
-0.47411298751831055,
0.33138465881347656,
-0.18089932203292847,
-0.03251532092690468,
-0.024219051003456116,
-0.414995938539505,
-0.08083224296569824,
-0.7339046001434326,
0.025026055052876472,
0.10954108089208603,
0.4974733889102936,
0.27606770396232605,
-0.7412430047988892,
-0.30355405807495117,
-0.5482934713363647,
0.6751400232315063,
-0.3004891276359558,
0.26815178990364075,
0.23580710589885712,
0.22881373763084412,
0.21524357795715332,
-0.43110519647598267,
-0.4741460084915161,
0.589706540107727,
0.3001463711261749,
0.3146086037158966,
-0.5354853868484497,
-0.04411293566226959,
0.47441431879997253,
0.27738621830940247,
-0.588493824005127,
0.09697571396827698,
-0.2939128875732422,
-0.01862780749797821,
0.9286327362060547,
0.24508249759674072,
0.6409191489219666,
0.024074725806713104,
-0.08045098930597305,
0.14217257499694824,
-0.8826473355293274,
-0.15804463624954224,
0.3749951422214508,
-0.20727622509002686,
-0.17570927739143372,
0.5810482501983643,
-0.1419961303472519,
0.3355560004711151,
-0.05452532693743706,
0.30199989676475525,
0.09377229958772659,
0.17346948385238647,
-0.21581228077411652,
0.22282445430755615,
0.940363347530365,
0.5754659175872803,
0.4826343357563019,
-0.28022897243499756,
-0.22035841643810272,
-0.06143536791205406,
0.15518879890441895,
-1.069671630859375,
-0.24576380848884583,
0.9479675889015198,
-0.33403199911117554,
-0.32503649592399597,
-0.08560934662818909,
-1.2757269144058228,
-0.8827208876609802,
-0.4753282368183136,
0.5269354581832886,
-0.30688396096229553,
-0.543144702911377,
-0.01839921437203884,
-0.5385485291481018,
-0.2514571249485016,
0.3889021575450897,
-0.6248592138290405,
0.05871882662177086,
0.7155758142471313,
0.6255741715431213,
0.21859261393547058,
0.09149190783500671,
-0.33248206973075867,
-0.015031890943646431,
-0.5392248034477234,
0.7569761276245117,
-0.5800904035568237,
0.046744536608457565,
0.2396920770406723,
-0.05381816625595093,
0.3154923617839813,
-0.36706891655921936,
0.7603805661201477,
-0.2559696435928345,
-0.12399478256702423,
-0.4929448962211609,
-0.5179392695426941,
-0.04522084817290306,
0.3994661867618561,
-0.6923044919967651,
0.5695210099220276,
0.019762692973017693,
-0.8728674650192261,
0.48385298252105713,
-0.8367657661437988,
-0.5016685724258423,
-0.18088307976722717,
0.13248315453529358,
-0.03397112712264061,
0.3901114761829376,
0.32506945729255676,
0.6730393767356873,
-0.45032474398612976,
0.45317745208740234,
-0.6874509453773499,
-0.09421848505735397,
-0.08316323161125183,
0.37225279211997986,
0.6824527382850647,
0.5160704255104065,
0.012697124853730202,
-0.041550472378730774,
-0.9384413957595825,
-0.4190254509449005,
0.09802333265542984,
0.25380200147628784,
-0.7361018061637878,
-0.06152015179395676,
0.003484046086668968,
0.5022450089454651,
0.13233375549316406,
-1.0373001098632812,
-0.10867498070001602,
-0.056381143629550934,
0.537763774394989,
0.7142062783241272,
0.39636969566345215,
0.33165839314460754,
-0.2438720017671585,
0.6263933181762695,
0.28444188833236694,
0.2853987514972687,
-0.48511478304862976,
-0.2798200845718384,
-0.43809154629707336,
-0.16069775819778442,
-0.3289189040660858,
0.2900855243206024,
-0.4018283784389496,
0.2796538174152374,
-0.08758236467838287,
-0.8377034068107605,
-0.3652149736881256,
-0.18288537859916687,
0.03120507299900055,
0.5260698795318604,
0.09314747154712677,
0.36139175295829773,
-0.8290128111839294,
-0.6899818181991577,
-0.4390695095062256,
0.42122697830200195,
-0.2670086920261383,
0.2000304013490677,
0.6423657536506653,
-0.15984474122524261,
0.8152030110359192,
-0.6063973903656006,
-0.21050681173801422,
0.2695099115371704,
0.11700156331062317,
0.12734223902225494,
0.26037195324897766,
0.5228187441825867,
-0.5492478609085083,
-0.2151053547859192,
0.09831705689430237,
-0.8442931771278381,
-0.4460599422454834,
0.09074939787387848,
-0.4034053683280945,
-0.1895710676908493,
0.2358253300189972,
-0.23543891310691833,
0.18042252957820892,
0.6549673080444336,
-0.46422404050827026,
0.1506359726190567,
0.22132745385169983,
0.322299063205719,
-1.3057643175125122,
0.16109581291675568,
0.23429954051971436,
0.30007100105285645,
-0.47277286648750305,
-0.5612451434135437,
0.001578083261847496,
-0.4909427762031555,
-0.17644038796424866,
0.6638147830963135,
-0.11843527108430862,
0.10443349182605743,
0.04740947112441063,
0.3135180175304413,
0.27847644686698914,
0.23341545462608337,
-0.20426979660987854,
-0.0983942374587059,
0.7450348734855652,
-0.4330786466598511,
0.5179413557052612,
0.20016168057918549,
-0.0020142770372331142,
0.7129698991775513,
-0.5409758687019348,
0.19296082854270935,
-0.3907129764556885,
0.0017236657440662384,
-1.0396828651428223,
-0.7367088198661804,
0.23142199218273163,
-0.4398406147956848,
0.17878049612045288,
-0.15061193704605103,
-0.5257550477981567,
-0.37293586134910583,
-0.2722853720188141,
0.11821731925010681,
0.3117560148239136,
-0.6612879037857056,
0.992543637752533,
0.627114474773407,
-0.22840940952301025,
-0.36522161960601807,
-0.42658162117004395,
0.18234339356422424,
-0.44554007053375244,
-0.8838915228843689,
-0.10957604646682739,
0.10986239463090897,
-0.5150253176689148,
0.012878818437457085,
-0.09451525658369064,
-0.21735070645809174,
0.18739746510982513,
0.613612949848175,
-0.5315631031990051,
0.2445754110813141,
0.8520433902740479,
0.3909803330898285,
0.16643275320529938,
0.4196159243583679,
-0.12055271118879318,
0.32838383316993713,
0.2074616700410843,
-0.05835593864321709,
-0.20617778599262238,
0.5318748950958252,
0.6975927948951721,
-0.043730780482292175,
0.6770766377449036,
0.5638567209243774,
-0.7526162266731262,
-0.4176110029220581,
-0.5404061675071716,
-0.33338552713394165,
-0.3065338134765625,
0.14410758018493652,
-0.16439037024974823,
-0.8333507776260376,
0.9503072500228882,
-0.1683548539876938,
0.2092142254114151,
0.6323407888412476,
0.29642024636268616,
-0.2504860758781433,
0.9270402789115906,
0.29789382219314575,
-0.09141480177640915,
0.5424962639808655,
-0.043540745973587036,
0.26228439807891846,
-0.6327968835830688,
-0.2805522084236145,
-0.6307973861694336,
-0.4037708044052124,
-0.6110673546791077,
0.1179950162768364,
0.16833294928073883,
-0.33647438883781433,
-0.7971835136413574,
-0.13456961512565613,
-0.33177778124809265,
0.22116701304912567,
0.08597403764724731,
0.27954962849617004,
0.12597085535526276,
-0.06834873557090759,
0.5334075093269348,
0.06418424844741821,
-0.5032041072845459,
-0.4117204546928406,
1.134704828262329,
0.2036009132862091,
0.7779821157455444,
0.03661328926682472,
0.798799455165863,
0.35569676756858826,
0.6115652918815613,
-0.7540877461433411,
0.1411384642124176,
-0.13834039866924286,
-0.8844170570373535,
-0.16051796078681946,
-0.41829928755760193,
-0.9653687477111816,
-0.299231618642807,
-0.1644439846277237,
-0.8116071224212646,
0.33671021461486816,
0.229624405503273,
-0.06650494039058685,
0.286191463470459,
-0.9102978706359863,
0.7548343539237976,
-0.17767946422100067,
-0.22938226163387299,
-0.14882250130176544,
-0.6076534390449524,
0.6543256640434265,
-0.7016794085502625,
0.5140916109085083,
-0.33612850308418274,
0.07605047523975372,
1.122643232345581,
-0.49584490060806274,
0.8123839497566223,
-0.221125990152359,
-0.16925199329853058,
0.3907833695411682,
0.19281262159347534,
0.44666510820388794,
-0.03788921236991882,
-0.20538118481636047,
-0.04996104538440704,
-0.30783289670944214,
-0.2619248330593109,
-0.6979178190231323,
0.6110206842422485,
-0.6828798651695251,
-0.14210985600948334,
0.09886094927787781,
-0.3419561982154846,
-0.06509197503328323,
0.07096396386623383,
0.3494126796722412,
0.4248579740524292,
-0.13698792457580566,
0.2555844187736511,
0.5047845840454102,
-0.13977020978927612,
0.39025670289993286,
0.2535731792449951,
-0.2970585823059082,
-0.5619582533836365,
0.6432743072509766,
0.17571668326854706,
0.009870396926999092,
0.41373172402381897,
0.6176700592041016,
0.009682229720056057,
0.08925650268793106,
0.08226123452186584,
0.07173813134431839,
-0.6266710162162781,
-0.32142871618270874,
-0.7973889112472534,
0.45645031332969666,
-0.5570123195648193,
-0.30306491255760193,
-0.45972904562950134,
-0.41818109154701233,
-0.18347670137882233,
-0.25886598229408264,
0.8585182428359985,
0.9391362071037292,
-0.31390807032585144,
0.27731990814208984,
-0.901825487613678,
0.3534601628780365,
0.25393617153167725,
0.4069667160511017,
0.17082621157169342,
-0.34279000759124756,
-0.2437373846769333,
0.04346975311636925,
-0.32542747259140015,
-1.1615606546401978,
0.7264477014541626,
0.3411482870578766,
0.12207499146461487,
1.0777512788772583,
0.5993696451187134,
0.4335278868675232,
0.04547825828194618,
0.47582271695137024,
0.2179705798625946,
-0.9186285138130188,
1.010815978050232,
-0.7157768607139587,
-0.2097446769475937,
0.04721992462873459,
0.5596292614936829,
-0.8916420936584473,
-0.5060299634933472,
-0.9666295647621155,
-0.8568084239959717,
0.6660317778587341,
0.17476676404476166,
-0.10488522797822952,
-0.15072575211524963,
0.23843520879745483,
0.09766098856925964,
0.14084157347679138,
-0.043997276574373245,
-0.14871783554553986,
-0.2607782781124115,
-0.3924565613269806,
0.010721821337938309,
-0.16084305942058563,
-0.3879994750022888,
0.07420020550489426,
0.5426605939865112,
0.015968408435583115,
0.05400979518890381,
0.18067316710948944,
0.01991729997098446,
-0.609529435634613,
0.20251622796058655,
0.19594931602478027,
0.5004313588142395,
-0.5140222311019897,
0.10477301478385925,
-0.11717086285352707,
-0.24937057495117188,
-0.06876291334629059,
0.01447313278913498,
0.11817824840545654,
-0.1811196208000183,
0.2520027458667755,
0.582449197769165,
0.1471244990825653,
-0.7932513952255249,
0.42376479506492615,
0.05316965654492378,
-0.12431517243385315,
-0.4050717353820801,
-0.22904671728610992,
0.2499275505542755,
0.20557530224323273,
0.5315948724746704,
-0.13976800441741943,
0.3675215542316437,
-0.6251466274261475,
0.24329672753810883,
-0.13929297029972076,
-0.43054521083831787,
-0.7280492186546326,
0.5295138955116272,
0.3791395127773285,
-0.08249032497406006,
0.6177478432655334,
0.020927073433995247,
-0.4986342787742615,
1.1099836826324463,
0.133211150765419,
0.9202894568443298,
-0.26349395513534546,
0.08716924488544464,
0.7680764198303223,
0.11689959466457367,
0.0741129219532013,
0.6092053055763245,
0.13988931477069855,
-0.9524976015090942,
-0.25679272413253784,
-0.37336814403533936,
-0.48718714714050293,
-0.026481803506612778,
-0.6926119327545166,
0.27158570289611816,
-0.4465894401073456,
-0.29059308767318726,
-0.006253130733966827,
-0.17097802460193634,
-0.9323291182518005,
0.5473661422729492,
0.15244588255882263,
0.7355390191078186,
-1.639064908027649,
0.1311279684305191,
0.8165032267570496,
-0.3203030228614807,
-0.897398829460144,
-0.37287890911102295,
0.2077234387397766,
-0.670129656791687,
0.7621310353279114,
0.2594006657600403,
0.264396071434021,
-0.07809208333492279,
-0.8560424447059631,
-0.4433344900608063,
0.9748796820640564,
0.13017891347408295,
-0.7676026821136475,
0.36819759011268616,
-0.3337094783782959,
0.6581720113754272,
-0.7285307049751282,
0.2628353536128998,
0.5550717711448669,
0.5344234108924866,
0.24309810996055603,
-0.35667216777801514,
0.08813179284334183,
-0.3043626546859741,
-0.48526731133461,
0.48088565468788147,
-0.6847608685493469,
0.6114501953125,
-0.4441770017147064,
-0.10840699076652527,
-0.7504948973655701,
0.12823298573493958,
0.35326528549194336,
0.891424298286438,
0.4078274667263031,
0.9328331351280212,
0.8942214250564575,
-0.31731918454170227,
1.0336378812789917,
-0.25504475831985474,
0.43194910883903503,
0.9009478092193604,
-0.24911841750144958,
0.5477195978164673,
0.46080705523490906,
0.10982569307088852,
0.055442795157432556,
0.8063638806343079,
0.18458852171897888,
0.1861380636692047,
0.026156367734074593,
-0.29852232336997986,
-0.5039750933647156,
-0.38934311270713806,
-0.042594775557518005,
0.30699026584625244,
0.6532963514328003,
-0.6173880100250244,
-0.2913513481616974,
0.15114761888980865,
0.33093270659446716,
-0.4105833172798157,
-0.4610540270805359,
0.6517854332923889,
0.17257823050022125,
-0.40800678730010986,
-0.22394968569278717,
-0.8586333990097046,
0.2412075698375702,
-0.08759759366512299,
0.08047572523355484,
-0.3711889386177063,
-0.03057822212576866,
-0.5637242197990417,
-1.1005091667175293,
0.2870740294456482,
0.11964523792266846,
-0.043156947940588,
-0.19988371431827545,
0.82750004529953,
-0.25692254304885864,
-0.33446136116981506,
0.4121587872505188,
0.5479668974876404,
0.3047155439853668,
-0.6072676181793213,
-0.1294649839401245,
0.05010603368282318,
-0.2096235752105713,
-0.5524253249168396,
0.10089404881000519,
1.3863064050674438,
0.13547635078430176,
0.6975238919258118,
0.44610875844955444,
-0.11705340445041656,
-0.0194111205637455,
0.2622344493865967,
0.906730055809021,
-0.8570008277893066,
-0.18189217150211334,
-0.7684270143508911,
0.7577674388885498,
-0.24001027643680573,
-0.5025618076324463,
0.2886103391647339,
0.5103626251220703,
0.27991339564323425,
-0.07208836078643799,
0.9437000155448914,
-0.4059179127216339,
0.5610508918762207,
-0.04045809432864189,
0.5461249947547913,
-0.9013673663139343,
-0.1156526505947113,
-0.35993772745132446,
-0.6917042136192322,
-0.4190819561481476,
0.1852496862411499,
-0.30409011244773865,
-0.11541751027107239,
0.35402414202690125,
0.6185256838798523,
0.3534657955169678,
0.23528054356575012,
0.38186463713645935,
0.4560739994049072,
0.5368617177009583,
0.6941811442375183,
0.8871660232543945,
-0.4178241491317749,
0.4654470682144165,
-0.35285356640815735,
-0.24774070084095,
-0.567154586315155,
-1.1017309427261353,
-0.6316938996315002,
-0.7030344605445862,
-0.5585654973983765,
-0.2914447486400604,
-0.061437200754880905,
0.8538560271263123,
0.282599538564682,
-0.6767752766609192,
0.4814164638519287,
-0.05939072370529175,
0.4442105293273926,
0.16052468121051788,
-0.24692320823669434,
0.415353000164032,
-0.35908088088035583,
-0.4326225221157074,
-0.17516328394412994,
0.2778897285461426,
-0.2741086184978485,
0.5050644874572754,
0.12212304770946503,
0.2353123426437378,
-0.010401522740721703,
0.741847574710846,
0.3848502039909363,
-0.2985406219959259,
-0.43607303500175476,
-0.04686427488923073,
0.10559643805027008,
0.011999868787825108,
0.7797368764877319,
-0.24097418785095215,
0.7629890441894531,
0.7641549110412598,
0.31513452529907227,
0.16044455766677856,
-0.1400192379951477,
0.6779085993766785,
-0.701256513595581,
-0.3195733428001404,
0.3842030167579651,
0.6881450414657593,
0.24898283183574677,
-0.4367228150367737,
0.7313427329063416,
0.09701767563819885,
-0.8554942011833191,
-0.4976261854171753,
0.06455773115158081,
-1.2171071767807007,
0.10366792976856232,
1.1046611070632935,
-0.18112985789775848,
-0.22987942397594452,
-0.0057707480154931545,
-0.1599806547164917,
0.7268046736717224,
-0.927747905254364,
1.004127025604248,
0.7283190488815308,
-0.15756475925445557,
-0.40926238894462585,
-0.365831583738327,
0.20041528344154358,
-0.12445785105228424,
-1.1040229797363281,
0.27716827392578125,
0.7280256748199463,
0.3137318193912506,
0.01168920285999775,
0.17382609844207764,
0.005418732762336731,
0.14015184342861176,
0.0917910560965538,
0.5058087706565857,
0.002265176735818386,
-0.23668275773525238,
-0.16926991939544678,
0.3937668204307556,
-0.36527860164642334,
0.0014445409178733826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12387v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12387v1
|
Performant ASR Models for Medical Entities in Accented Speech
| 2024-06-18T08:19:48 | 2024-06-18T08:19:48 |
Tejumade Afonja, Tobi Olatunji, Sewade Ogun, Naome A. Etori, Abraham Owodunni, Moshood Yekini
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
Recent strides in automatic speech recognition (ASR) have accelerated their
application in the medical domain where their performance on accented medical
named entities (NE) such as drug names, diagnoses, and lab results, is largely
unknown. We rigorously evaluate multiple ASR models on a clinical English
dataset of 93 African accents. Our analysis reveals that despite some models
achieving low overall word error rates (WER), errors in clinical entities are
higher, potentially posing substantial risks to patient safety. To empirically
demonstrate this, we extract clinical entities from transcripts, develop a
novel algorithm to align ASR predictions with these entities, and compute
medical NE Recall, medical WER, and character error rate. Our results show that
fine-tuning on accented clinical speech improves medical WER by a wide margin
(25-34 % relative), improving their practical applicability in healthcare
environments.
|
[
-0.009815720841288567,
-0.4082089364528656,
0.5542773008346558,
-0.028066929429769516,
-0.09113271534442902,
0.22528323531150818,
-0.39777931571006775,
-0.8793049454689026,
0.44124773144721985,
0.7125396728515625,
-0.13087698817253113,
-0.4875866174697876,
-0.7632310390472412,
0.2875516712665558,
-0.11919738352298737,
0.6015145182609558,
0.1071287989616394,
0.6528287529945374,
0.04693332314491272,
-0.558007001876831,
-0.43665674328804016,
-0.7484320998191833,
-1.1181145906448364,
-0.28234153985977173,
0.5032784938812256,
0.4557385742664337,
0.7801792025566101,
0.8013453483581543,
0.7361783981323242,
0.2928788363933563,
-0.10475010424852371,
0.3407714366912842,
-0.0766584500670433,
0.12186139076948166,
-0.14136716723442078,
-0.21398501098155975,
-0.5833004713058472,
-0.4254048466682434,
0.4279615581035614,
1.0771490335464478,
-0.38850128650665283,
-0.24667763710021973,
-0.10096114128828049,
0.4450877904891968,
-0.30353686213493347,
0.06969087570905685,
-0.5703927874565125,
-0.339603453874588,
-0.11759274452924728,
-0.1822529286146164,
-0.16718949377536774,
-0.3028877377510071,
0.3926233649253845,
-0.4736270606517792,
0.47970154881477356,
0.1460844725370407,
0.8174394965171814,
0.3863566815853119,
-0.34337398409843445,
-0.610765814781189,
-0.7129486799240112,
0.35205283761024475,
-0.8409083485603333,
0.49275943636894226,
0.2662979066371918,
0.37899789214134216,
-0.12836089730262756,
-0.9521811604499817,
-0.3809969425201416,
-0.24048860371112823,
-0.10133707523345947,
-0.14876960217952728,
-0.24544188380241394,
0.5121716260910034,
0.2353743463754654,
0.4149579703807831,
-0.3025585114955902,
0.44940122961997986,
-0.5406069159507751,
-0.36937984824180603,
0.7605788111686707,
0.2672158181667328,
0.7196241021156311,
0.17323799431324005,
-0.07396302372217178,
0.03942062333226204,
-0.6082165241241455,
0.008066218346357346,
-0.14091810584068298,
0.839413046836853,
-0.002858018036931753,
0.5887910723686218,
-0.1213226318359375,
0.2642703056335449,
0.08025576174259186,
-0.039399441331624985,
0.27922654151916504,
0.09382060170173645,
-0.09417393058538437,
0.6181620359420776,
0.7247156500816345,
0.4414462447166443,
0.3315027356147766,
-0.2356594055891037,
-0.2567630410194397,
0.4394075870513916,
0.582199215888977,
-0.7773513793945312,
-0.42169424891471863,
0.3507627248764038,
-0.39678218960762024,
0.020394138991832733,
-0.3477558195590973,
-0.45044925808906555,
-0.5422656536102295,
-0.2505333125591278,
0.6759372353553772,
-0.6672617197036743,
0.038031160831451416,
0.13624553382396698,
0.012846575118601322,
-0.17106635868549347,
0.2585429847240448,
-0.8196356296539307,
0.7419776320457458,
0.5302091836929321,
0.6058029532432556,
-0.2560788691043854,
0.15490470826625824,
-0.5070421695709229,
-0.14112982153892517,
-0.3925548493862152,
0.7129577994346619,
-0.39947137236595154,
-0.6740599870681763,
0.1133335530757904,
0.11978314816951752,
-0.2537018358707428,
-0.7804509401321411,
0.7475482225418091,
-0.26858413219451904,
-0.43937399983406067,
-0.41315025091171265,
-0.6228449940681458,
-0.18069981038570404,
-0.17950013279914856,
-0.7131823301315308,
0.2778071165084839,
-0.10548407584428787,
-0.26541486382484436,
0.47560375928878784,
-0.7831214666366577,
-0.9355726838111877,
0.04231971129775047,
-0.2558969557285309,
-0.6833547949790955,
0.39990973472595215,
0.3311959505081177,
0.210402712225914,
-0.22982309758663177,
0.12982387840747833,
0.1298322230577469,
-0.24982850253582,
0.3388872444629669,
-0.39262622594833374,
0.5585817098617554,
0.2288064807653427,
-0.32675254344940186,
-0.015421131625771523,
-1.013543963432312,
0.10592310130596161,
-0.05687997117638588,
-0.17868514358997345,
-0.4347052574157715,
0.13357721269130707,
0.2461484670639038,
-0.03585338220000267,
-0.12001948058605194,
-0.55560702085495,
-0.21416306495666504,
-0.5576373934745789,
0.4081886410713196,
0.04744771495461464,
0.362575888633728,
0.1601988673210144,
-0.41219374537467957,
0.4588684141635895,
0.05134816840291023,
-0.2885030508041382,
-0.14612603187561035,
-0.5386629104614258,
-0.8210246562957764,
-0.5888133645057678,
0.5455206632614136,
0.4819828271865845,
-0.4537372887134552,
0.08222568780183792,
-0.23124675452709198,
-0.3422185778617859,
-0.9406521916389465,
-0.42420679330825806,
0.6497997045516968,
0.8871915936470032,
0.5972388982772827,
-0.5940704345703125,
-0.5969128012657166,
-0.9222756028175354,
-0.6196703314781189,
-0.13250242173671722,
-0.2122342735528946,
0.6919184923171997,
0.16616958379745483,
-0.4586307108402252,
0.47814300656318665,
-0.19635239243507385,
-0.3230741322040558,
0.04614897817373276,
0.11237405240535736,
0.09400462359189987,
0.612453043460846,
0.20439277589321136,
-0.6507095098495483,
-0.4031669795513153,
0.057168878614902496,
-0.2991880774497986,
-0.22305935621261597,
0.11446724832057953,
0.3015402555465698,
0.09933234006166458,
0.3219674527645111,
-0.37458065152168274,
0.4046761393547058,
0.39228907227516174,
-0.2111668884754181,
0.2593895494937897,
-0.4579654633998871,
0.39120471477508545,
-0.9474267363548279,
0.028278935700654984,
-0.020737208425998688,
-0.24437209963798523,
-0.966749370098114,
-0.16158659756183624,
0.18923933804035187,
-0.08404159545898438,
-0.20893162488937378,
0.4927191138267517,
-0.7007834315299988,
0.14430730044841766,
-0.17782646417617798,
-0.13578543066978455,
0.09774306416511536,
-0.016255993396043777,
0.22593183815479279,
0.7967430949211121,
0.610764741897583,
-0.7781798243522644,
-0.11852790415287018,
0.5571171641349792,
-0.3594948649406433,
0.7987319231033325,
-0.8463596701622009,
0.23991374671459198,
0.0882299542427063,
-0.19846853613853455,
-0.7817949056625366,
-0.4654398560523987,
-0.42036280035972595,
-0.5995625257492065,
0.8192243576049805,
-0.2372646927833557,
-0.058755062520504,
-0.38039061427116394,
0.4618197977542877,
0.2778986990451813,
0.4741245210170746,
-0.35836324095726013,
0.6096881031990051,
0.663201630115509,
-0.4705321192741394,
-0.440665066242218,
-0.8066332936286926,
0.22114408016204834,
-0.07770441472530365,
-0.3621571660041809,
0.48444998264312744,
0.3157711327075958,
-0.2652575373649597,
-0.14996746182441711,
-0.21297849714756012,
-0.4054870307445526,
0.06393501907587051,
0.3498643636703491,
0.0619373582303524,
-0.5668838620185852,
0.08746414631605148,
-0.06383991986513138,
0.03649578243494034,
0.08032727241516113,
0.023379940539598465,
0.30419662594795227,
0.12269363552331924,
-0.4646362364292145,
-0.5542283058166504,
0.4426749646663666,
0.699674129486084,
-0.30342429876327515,
0.6655576825141907,
0.1832582801580429,
-1.0401824712753296,
0.2079419642686844,
-0.8009754419326782,
-0.37409478425979614,
-0.40617528557777405,
0.5633174777030945,
-0.339810311794281,
-0.5413023233413696,
0.8462345004081726,
0.19313056766986847,
-0.09156239777803421,
0.40362799167633057,
0.5106788277626038,
0.013501504436135292,
1.1370491981506348,
0.43655726313591003,
0.17695225775241852,
0.019231731072068214,
-0.0075170788913965225,
0.143523171544075,
-0.756007969379425,
-0.2528252601623535,
-0.5637263059616089,
-0.06299438327550888,
-0.7332575917243958,
-0.359978049993515,
0.6843692064285278,
-0.24370525777339935,
0.060647569596767426,
0.1275821328163147,
-0.4681135416030884,
0.20731988549232483,
0.30648308992385864,
0.25894832611083984,
0.25681862235069275,
-0.003358825808390975,
-0.27746936678886414,
-0.1543947458267212,
-0.49881842732429504,
-0.5655673742294312,
0.9321404099464417,
0.48384398221969604,
0.6706631183624268,
0.09324640035629272,
0.523540198802948,
0.08490701764822006,
0.3480893075466156,
-0.7558422088623047,
0.008812924847006798,
-0.712447464466095,
-0.6540716290473938,
-0.17070215940475464,
-0.21216386556625366,
-0.9143416285514832,
-0.03227808699011803,
-0.2927636504173279,
-0.6376359462738037,
0.4710733890533447,
0.5351787805557251,
-0.9681117534637451,
-0.02795024961233139,
-0.4732317328453064,
0.6357194781303406,
-0.17987792193889618,
0.07932743430137634,
-0.10820001363754272,
-0.7236589193344116,
-0.11894318461418152,
-0.08824659883975983,
0.07237248867750168,
-0.05288739874958992,
0.015501110814511776,
0.5414158701896667,
-0.6759059429168701,
0.48783940076828003,
-0.26375043392181396,
0.2859572470188141,
0.05750023573637009,
-0.2477414757013321,
0.42157694697380066,
-0.04553260654211044,
-0.31128475069999695,
0.5245957374572754,
-0.07575996965169907,
-0.16402341425418854,
-0.46140146255493164,
0.5025686621665955,
-0.5594857335090637,
-0.30644217133522034,
-0.2909175455570221,
-0.36435219645500183,
-0.6469343304634094,
0.12672372162342072,
0.5502113103866577,
0.9115297794342041,
-0.5696106553077698,
-0.062046777456998825,
0.6335585713386536,
-0.2086319476366043,
0.03944963589310646,
0.7647457122802734,
0.41768908500671387,
-0.6412094235420227,
0.6659043431282043,
0.338701456785202,
0.40701285004615784,
0.14896243810653687,
-0.04953824356198311,
-0.3783737123012543,
-0.9611808657646179,
-0.5879893898963928,
0.23047570884227753,
-0.5818318128585815,
-0.2041451781988144,
-1.1161081790924072,
-0.43818938732147217,
-0.4633694589138031,
-0.2257561981678009,
-0.4976932406425476,
-0.5310699343681335,
-0.41082850098609924,
0.04458634927868843,
0.4685271084308624,
0.517915666103363,
0.15067383646965027,
0.4986286759376526,
-0.7365891933441162,
0.3699165880680084,
0.016371674835681915,
0.3954005241394043,
-0.4193666875362396,
-0.5675370693206787,
-0.14439082145690918,
0.20181410014629364,
0.00543071748688817,
-0.7977302074432373,
0.6706641912460327,
0.5864826440811157,
0.5520586967468262,
0.39948466420173645,
0.12052427232265472,
0.9563806056976318,
-1.1688376665115356,
0.5981603264808655,
0.062260791659355164,
-0.7267375588417053,
0.3212147653102875,
0.008662101812660694,
-0.009425893425941467,
0.8456266522407532,
0.3830964267253876,
-0.6229661107063293,
-0.3993300199508667,
-0.6427527070045471,
-0.9877840876579285,
0.3883095979690552,
0.10655151307582855,
-0.000009777312698133755,
-0.21419382095336914,
0.3519345819950104,
-0.07026834785938263,
0.16559486091136932,
0.14539183676242828,
-0.5036159157752991,
0.19514286518096924,
-0.44256025552749634,
-0.33141374588012695,
-0.31164276599884033,
-0.2812230587005615,
-0.03309863805770874,
0.6390572190284729,
-0.22200006246566772,
0.37467241287231445,
0.56319260597229,
-0.22813796997070312,
-0.17002055048942566,
0.25796934962272644,
0.6070510745048523,
0.3746607303619385,
-0.05195626616477966,
-0.03230176493525505,
0.35032224655151367,
-0.8349242806434631,
0.03650505468249321,
0.6541728973388672,
0.09611225873231888,
0.274531751871109,
0.1212306097149849,
0.9016972780227661,
0.3215574622154236,
-0.7148962616920471,
0.416179895401001,
-0.2936932444572449,
0.14358773827552795,
-0.4143994450569153,
-0.002727522747591138,
-0.05726974457502365,
0.10962673276662827,
0.21427272260189056,
0.3895929157733917,
0.6574872732162476,
-0.5217874050140381,
0.46347251534461975,
0.6193180084228516,
-0.7595699429512024,
-0.24430131912231445,
1.0913535356521606,
0.2514548599720001,
-0.6065464019775391,
0.5677000880241394,
0.24924196302890778,
-0.6245039105415344,
0.7116027474403381,
0.7136050462722778,
0.7814001441001892,
-0.5499420762062073,
-0.3732629418373108,
0.2868208885192871,
0.1477949470281601,
-0.22709383070468903,
0.4595582187175751,
0.431772381067276,
-0.8203439712524414,
-0.2464887946844101,
-0.5297567844390869,
-0.6353974938392639,
-0.004779784940183163,
-1.0019855499267578,
0.4101112484931946,
-0.4054126441478729,
-0.46419262886047363,
0.5982488393783569,
-0.04567349702119827,
-0.6329060792922974,
0.6597029566764832,
0.3629551827907562,
0.7451422810554504,
-0.6718137860298157,
0.677518367767334,
0.9241333603858948,
-0.12250709533691406,
-0.9813358187675476,
-0.1095588207244873,
0.24024397134780884,
-0.782444953918457,
0.09568829834461212,
0.23782789707183838,
-0.07005445659160614,
-0.02368907816708088,
0.005135443992912769,
-0.9623083472251892,
0.6854096055030823,
0.15403848886489868,
-0.7811095118522644,
-0.036067333072423935,
0.18495780229568481,
0.8511051535606384,
-0.5849606990814209,
0.2527107894420624,
0.7349136471748352,
0.012626775540411472,
0.020449243485927582,
-1.4655604362487793,
0.003939052578061819,
-0.19326038658618927,
-0.08984784036874771,
0.11577588319778442,
-0.24158158898353577,
0.6238295435905457,
-0.6585808396339417,
-0.3153568208217621,
0.22585266828536987,
0.4169812798500061,
0.22379328310489655,
0.61040860414505,
0.3875065743923187,
0.1634214073419571,
1.1474552154541016,
-0.20708557963371277,
1.0688706636428833,
-0.4817216694355011,
-0.1975889950990677,
0.9118844866752625,
-0.49315622448921204,
0.7398470044136047,
0.11320770531892776,
-0.028341718018054962,
0.3594242334365845,
0.39593860507011414,
0.27308428287506104,
0.5025848150253296,
-0.014439921826124191,
-0.38842883706092834,
-0.04297950491309166,
-0.1858607977628708,
-0.26280075311660767,
0.5998103618621826,
0.8490661382675171,
-0.696257472038269,
0.5169950723648071,
0.07627398520708084,
0.1074897050857544,
0.1871013194322586,
-0.4005562365055084,
0.8883056044578552,
0.2969133257865906,
-0.47013840079307556,
0.6900748014450073,
-0.2092960923910141,
0.30591505765914917,
-0.3691818118095398,
-0.07106798887252808,
0.12635689973831177,
0.3487035632133484,
-0.1332007199525833,
-0.1468743234872818,
0.29945555329322815,
-0.07563179731369019,
-0.31605058908462524,
0.2241581827402115,
0.5702201128005981,
-0.5893028974533081,
-0.4356285631656647,
-0.07145489007234573,
0.047490447759628296,
0.22527071833610535,
0.02447294257581234,
-0.3291275203227997,
-0.08542448282241821,
-0.13861501216888428,
0.2562923729419708,
-0.0037593909073621035,
0.35815009474754333,
-0.17206740379333496,
0.5395994186401367,
0.484422504901886,
0.6087068319320679,
0.003265833016484976,
0.27172866463661194,
0.6582875847816467,
-0.5690702199935913,
-0.5706778168678284,
-0.6394028663635254,
0.5496602654457092,
-0.15002159774303436,
-0.21697765588760376,
0.3816308081150055,
0.4977709650993347,
0.27026253938674927,
0.06514733284711838,
0.5022076368331909,
0.25250813364982605,
1.0094473361968994,
-0.5811505317687988,
1.091522216796875,
-0.43015843629837036,
0.269784152507782,
-0.24599500000476837,
-0.38030871748924255,
-0.547213613986969,
0.5369325876235962,
-0.07812164723873138,
-0.11625608801841736,
0.5012913942337036,
0.8003098964691162,
0.09132835268974304,
0.21467456221580505,
0.5197650194168091,
0.4632990062236786,
0.2430882453918457,
0.26000407338142395,
0.3166886568069458,
-0.5229626297950745,
0.040364641696214676,
-0.38380497694015503,
-0.04745398461818695,
-0.4575388729572296,
-0.5755388140678406,
-0.57096928358078,
-0.2715100049972534,
-0.48007944226264954,
-0.4731277525424957,
0.5026026964187622,
1.2606635093688965,
0.8391098976135254,
-1.3337812423706055,
0.25693416595458984,
0.28194665908813477,
-0.37517839670181274,
-0.5351668000221252,
-0.10531074553728104,
0.42305880784988403,
-0.18437999486923218,
-0.7270440459251404,
0.7039307951927185,
0.1958412230014801,
0.13111470639705658,
0.34873923659324646,
0.014596103690564632,
0.2901037931442261,
0.4467128813266754,
0.2839736342430115,
0.5107814073562622,
-0.7658157348632812,
-0.28076180815696716,
-0.007823978550732136,
-0.38218122720718384,
0.33775749802589417,
0.7678587436676025,
-0.529931902885437,
0.6806576251983643,
-0.26429641246795654,
0.694387674331665,
0.16295506060123444,
0.17851495742797852,
0.8065778017044067,
-0.5632393956184387,
-0.10436928272247314,
0.6729953289031982,
0.5868075489997864,
0.6897439956665039,
-0.5378530621528625,
0.29072752594947815,
-0.19810594618320465,
-0.723666787147522,
-0.9003428220748901,
-0.11559046059846878,
-0.7654244899749756,
0.30230027437210083,
1.038944125175476,
-0.23573341965675354,
-0.01852096989750862,
-0.49712154269218445,
-0.115699402987957,
0.3944820165634155,
-0.36305657029151917,
0.7662155032157898,
0.23152199387550354,
-0.34130972623825073,
0.1449045091867447,
-0.7193259000778198,
0.9363718628883362,
0.4101984202861786,
-0.5643708109855652,
-0.2309209555387497,
0.6224452257156372,
0.5391777157783508,
0.26292121410369873,
0.6818074584007263,
-0.2052697241306305,
0.49042239785194397,
0.02508663386106491,
0.20680122077465057,
0.13681933283805847,
-0.20057764649391174,
-0.6906477212905884,
-0.17194625735282898,
0.3144211769104004,
-0.3587784469127655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12386v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12386v1
|
IPEval: A Bilingual Intellectual Property Agency Consultation Evaluation Benchmark for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-18T08:18:18 | 2024-06-18T08:18:18 |
Qiyao Wang, Jianguo Huang, Shule Lu, Yuan Lin, Kan Xu, Liang Yang, Hongfei Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rapid development of Large Language Models (LLMs) in vertical domains,
including intellectual property (IP), lacks a specific evaluation benchmark for
assessing their understanding, application, and reasoning abilities. To fill
this gap, we introduce IPEval, the first evaluation benchmark tailored for IP
agency and consulting tasks. IPEval comprises 2657 multiple-choice questions
across four major dimensions: creation, application, protection, and management
of IP. These questions span patent rights (inventions, utility models,
designs), trademarks, copyrights, trade secrets, and other related laws.
Evaluation methods include zero-shot, 5-few-shot, and Chain of Thought (CoT)
for seven LLM types, predominantly in English or Chinese. Results show superior
English performance by models like GPT series and Qwen series, while
Chinese-centric LLMs excel in Chinese tests, albeit specialized IP LLMs lag
behind general-purpose ones. Regional and temporal aspects of IP underscore the
need for LLMs to grasp legal nuances and evolving laws. IPEval aims to
accurately gauge LLM capabilities in IP and spur development of specialized
models. Website: \url{https://ipeval.github.io/}
|
[
-0.409810334444046,
-0.4576328992843628,
0.20923511683940887,
0.9420602917671204,
-0.20855103433132172,
0.42996910214424133,
-0.1424318552017212,
-0.540155291557312,
-0.10101786255836487,
0.5642852187156677,
-0.1681222915649414,
-0.5941859483718872,
-0.39223232865333557,
0.02091713435947895,
-0.2156367152929306,
0.9744832515716553,
-0.1532672792673111,
0.30802908539772034,
-0.08334586769342422,
-0.19260454177856445,
-0.3998948633670807,
-0.4022482633590698,
-0.6605977416038513,
-0.32795748114585876,
0.17467059195041656,
0.16750603914260864,
0.407589852809906,
0.2505732476711273,
0.7164227366447449,
0.1932310312986374,
-0.1459488868713379,
0.11056078225374222,
-0.4123988151550293,
-0.08655043691396713,
-0.34600305557250977,
-0.37535297870635986,
-0.6024393439292908,
0.04103923961520195,
0.7092312574386597,
0.5866190195083618,
-0.164826899766922,
0.48494601249694824,
-0.01771731674671173,
0.8208836913108826,
-0.7245572209358215,
0.08884342759847641,
-0.794628381729126,
0.0780114158987999,
-0.39030641317367554,
0.017644843086600304,
-0.4527377188205719,
-0.3199656903743744,
0.4189363718032837,
-0.24312974512577057,
-0.15142951905727386,
0.3959207534790039,
0.9545568823814392,
0.0018435489619150758,
-0.4760066866874695,
0.10616294294595718,
-0.3273846209049225,
0.7378288507461548,
-0.4707847833633423,
0.2093207687139511,
0.33164775371551514,
0.401949942111969,
0.03518672287464142,
-1.0777119398117065,
-0.4902956783771515,
-0.634868323802948,
0.29024413228034973,
0.15443801879882812,
-0.13248203694820404,
-0.13247063755989075,
0.04949970915913582,
0.2177814096212387,
-0.499593049287796,
0.14791105687618256,
-0.40123361349105835,
-0.08621038496494293,
0.7428213953971863,
0.1124035194516182,
0.5381454229354858,
0.23334597051143646,
-0.5150142908096313,
0.21092930436134338,
-1.4214372634887695,
0.023012759163975716,
0.44434717297554016,
0.1670725792646408,
-0.0376196913421154,
0.4913100302219391,
0.048097845166921616,
0.3252852261066437,
0.017990045249462128,
0.217375710606575,
0.27437758445739746,
-0.2772118151187897,
-0.05250783637166023,
0.08873938024044037,
0.6254981756210327,
0.2250930219888687,
0.2864387035369873,
-0.058276303112506866,
-0.1932547688484192,
-0.6475134491920471,
0.23746471107006073,
-0.8825233578681946,
-0.0879707783460617,
0.24185848236083984,
-0.4454804062843323,
-0.019449984654784203,
-0.05536158010363579,
-0.4101448357105255,
-0.5774227976799011,
-0.32669854164123535,
0.444205105304718,
-0.20807290077209473,
-0.4509820342063904,
-0.059948381036520004,
-0.013242246583104134,
0.6121426224708557,
0.227974534034729,
-0.6152737140655518,
0.4008186459541321,
0.9001178741455078,
0.7983539700508118,
-0.32669520378112793,
-0.8015692234039307,
-0.5372350215911865,
-0.12278865277767181,
-0.49097132682800293,
1.0234246253967285,
-0.4581700563430786,
-0.3663984537124634,
0.06629671156406403,
-0.01285871583968401,
0.10779191553592682,
-0.7519932389259338,
0.4940550625324249,
-0.9256086945533752,
-0.15220734477043152,
-0.3572717607021332,
-0.19156904518604279,
0.21695204079151154,
0.5072447657585144,
-0.58948814868927,
0.7620070576667786,
-0.06472188979387283,
-0.6681467890739441,
0.6121070981025696,
-0.7928571701049805,
-0.3395901024341583,
0.5897218585014343,
-0.27205944061279297,
-0.18577244877815247,
-0.3845413327217102,
0.23284116387367249,
-0.0036608355585485697,
-0.9220362901687622,
0.27264705300331116,
-0.22290125489234924,
-0.3488481938838959,
0.05764174461364746,
-0.43666964769363403,
1.161486268043518,
0.26470640301704407,
-0.30981647968292236,
0.05880572274327278,
-0.44423601031303406,
0.17546354234218597,
-0.024945132434368134,
-0.4422665238380432,
-0.07750829309225082,
0.058723196387290955,
0.00020126109302509576,
0.11557463556528091,
0.6316381692886353,
-0.5311696529388428,
-0.08579212427139282,
-0.3005254566669464,
0.17333386838436127,
0.8688097596168518,
-0.04034353047609329,
-0.22922706604003906,
-0.2663615643978119,
0.7412972450256348,
-0.04117508605122566,
-0.030391480773687363,
-0.0733027458190918,
-0.47461849451065063,
-0.669098973274231,
-0.4681060314178467,
0.5323741436004639,
0.5701910853385925,
-0.5169057250022888,
0.36498627066612244,
-0.42155539989471436,
-0.6434335112571716,
-0.9158390760421753,
0.19503982365131378,
0.5017504096031189,
0.3483041226863861,
0.16703961789608002,
-0.12846049666404724,
-0.25641027092933655,
-1.1484601497650146,
-0.4720498025417328,
-0.48610544204711914,
-0.012078747153282166,
0.33206769824028015,
0.5584050416946411,
0.11549833416938782,
0.7284683585166931,
-0.013366804458200932,
-0.3416418135166168,
-0.2844468951225281,
0.45670831203460693,
0.30722862482070923,
0.014411008916795254,
0.7233317494392395,
-0.7713573575019836,
-1.251326084136963,
0.32407379150390625,
-0.4426122307777405,
-0.48803550004959106,
0.15672042965888977,
-0.1718105971813202,
-0.06956973671913147,
0.16709177196025848,
-0.4029926359653473,
0.2584449052810669,
0.23503531515598297,
-0.3810318410396576,
0.8428229689598083,
-0.33552128076553345,
0.19316153228282928,
-0.714602530002594,
0.25221893191337585,
-0.14396198093891144,
-0.08468744158744812,
-0.42795896530151367,
0.2060806006193161,
0.2838100790977478,
-0.1865576207637787,
-0.8166612982749939,
0.7067481279373169,
-0.6730676889419556,
-0.11466903239488602,
-0.12319113314151764,
0.21714240312576294,
0.09412509202957153,
0.022759150713682175,
-0.07165543735027313,
1.3794970512390137,
0.7597436308860779,
-0.2804797887802124,
0.4859592914581299,
0.18136249482631683,
-0.4736481308937073,
0.9727329611778259,
-0.7793179750442505,
0.19557718932628632,
-0.04034703969955444,
-0.05265333876013756,
-0.7500870823860168,
0.18056628108024597,
-0.21391890943050385,
0.03563690930604935,
0.3071993291378021,
-0.2572939693927765,
-0.4752720892429352,
-0.38011258840560913,
-0.4969054162502289,
0.41303011775016785,
0.4734443426132202,
-0.9457529187202454,
0.34399864077568054,
0.6944699883460999,
-0.4827954173088074,
-1.065842628479004,
-0.7338045835494995,
0.4875854253768921,
-0.19691528379917145,
-0.6980122327804565,
0.4803408682346344,
-0.20653368532657623,
-0.429292231798172,
0.10681303590536118,
0.32346829771995544,
-0.48864221572875977,
-0.13907618820667267,
-0.09523092210292816,
0.22509251534938812,
-0.484795480966568,
-0.03475257754325867,
-0.07616874575614929,
0.12647084891796112,
0.20126873254776,
-0.11605054140090942,
0.44163933396339417,
-0.7759566903114319,
-0.6667730212211609,
-0.24859941005706787,
0.27296534180641174,
0.7956278324127197,
-0.47633418440818787,
0.5231847167015076,
-0.08011379837989807,
-0.2645947337150574,
-0.4495585858821869,
-0.5963464975357056,
0.5499469041824341,
-0.492569237947464,
0.4500216245651245,
-0.6366155743598938,
-0.3074261546134949,
0.6150991916656494,
-0.15888965129852295,
-0.02224919945001602,
0.5719202160835266,
0.8203930854797363,
0.34163016080856323,
0.8074567317962646,
0.48196303844451904,
-0.38913673162460327,
0.10382014513015747,
-0.2260706126689911,
0.5798924565315247,
-0.8778971433639526,
-0.2359604835510254,
-0.305039644241333,
-0.1909896284341812,
-0.4122946858406067,
-0.31953397393226624,
0.5424781441688538,
0.00901738740503788,
-0.317984938621521,
0.2738892138004303,
-0.2678306996822357,
0.8308926224708557,
0.32404813170433044,
-0.11421149224042892,
0.41534048318862915,
-0.031676262617111206,
-0.3560131788253784,
-0.24222075939178467,
-0.28450191020965576,
-0.8035594820976257,
1.3027909994125366,
0.5058178901672363,
0.690175473690033,
0.12423861026763916,
0.4756660759449005,
0.5279502868652344,
0.710708498954773,
-0.6912030577659607,
0.6124604344367981,
-0.26603078842163086,
-0.7023205757141113,
-0.11132460832595825,
0.06738045066595078,
-0.8099903464317322,
0.45261141657829285,
0.2588587701320648,
-0.7054387331008911,
0.13553518056869507,
-0.1725465953350067,
-0.26051393151283264,
0.34590888023376465,
-0.668023943901062,
0.665550708770752,
-0.793653130531311,
-0.6956814527511597,
-0.37514498829841614,
-0.26649582386016846,
0.30147266387939453,
-0.3987255096435547,
-0.07300751656293869,
-0.30625900626182556,
-0.25183892250061035,
0.4778873920440674,
-0.5286334753036499,
0.48288673162460327,
-0.2213924527168274,
0.20991985499858856,
0.3749876618385315,
-0.09715521335601807,
0.30958425998687744,
0.09397774934768677,
-0.5615877509117126,
0.32852378487586975,
0.14386272430419922,
-0.34584102034568787,
-0.10310571640729904,
0.8599060773849487,
-0.9198846220970154,
-0.6732848286628723,
-0.5341449975967407,
-0.42233383655548096,
-0.3853937089443207,
0.36881545186042786,
0.0951361358165741,
0.09969369322061539,
-0.5674159526824951,
0.2637682855129242,
0.30478188395500183,
-0.25971174240112305,
0.2225768119096756,
1.0592238903045654,
-0.13989713788032532,
-0.26807472109794617,
0.7916973233222961,
0.23738816380500793,
-0.02330639585852623,
0.23745235800743103,
0.1384863555431366,
-0.38783496618270874,
-0.8512203097343445,
-0.2831834852695465,
0.14961709082126617,
-0.8245739340782166,
-0.21780970692634583,
-0.3777899146080017,
-0.6734058856964111,
-0.13137172162532806,
0.06151986122131348,
-0.5641724467277527,
-0.06191205978393555,
0.04034975916147232,
-0.03896136209368706,
0.07046692073345184,
0.5519245862960815,
0.04035992920398712,
-0.17598214745521545,
-0.3606216609477997,
0.32427284121513367,
0.36397966742515564,
0.5718488693237305,
-0.21209311485290527,
-0.5921702980995178,
-0.048920802772045135,
-0.04782656207680702,
-0.37049081921577454,
-0.49112722277641296,
0.47208842635154724,
0.3390953838825226,
0.7457255721092224,
0.34982261061668396,
0.1344534009695053,
0.7405427098274231,
-0.8832322955131531,
1.0008572340011597,
-0.040680479258298874,
-0.9825551509857178,
0.37426528334617615,
-0.1480833888053894,
-0.12259207665920258,
0.6727959513664246,
0.43646517395973206,
-0.3111487329006195,
-0.13211408257484436,
-0.26523303985595703,
-1.025954008102417,
0.5847842693328857,
-0.1458643227815628,
0.37915951013565063,
0.008722005411982536,
0.12332561612129211,
0.19172029197216034,
0.2701660692691803,
-0.9151867032051086,
-0.03119899146258831,
0.176129549741745,
0.11861175298690796,
0.5902974605560303,
-0.2785172462463379,
-0.2932831346988678,
-0.2567853331565857,
0.6976591348648071,
0.053157031536102295,
0.06517217308282852,
0.05315929278731346,
-0.3167926073074341,
0.017036153003573418,
0.20322121679782867,
0.2833017110824585,
1.2925007343292236,
-0.1469385176897049,
-0.05551055073738098,
0.290770024061203,
-0.39968112111091614,
0.03323088586330414,
0.21410298347473145,
0.031357575207948685,
-0.2469494789838791,
0.3267783224582672,
0.5707646608352661,
-0.5109438300132751,
-0.9941379427909851,
0.9186668992042542,
-0.10738920420408249,
-0.22779962420463562,
-0.4457149803638458,
-0.2858707308769226,
-0.1350822150707245,
0.3066316246986389,
0.5443009734153748,
-0.41960179805755615,
-0.028202999383211136,
-0.4787740707397461,
0.21386076509952545,
0.5085447430610657,
-0.2897821366786957,
-0.2730952799320221,
0.583441972732544,
0.28188738226890564,
-0.42999085783958435,
0.5311340689659119,
-0.1374964565038681,
-0.4898592233657837,
0.6635772585868835,
0.6225863099098206,
1.1440935134887695,
-0.018756570294499397,
0.21668748557567596,
-0.015763860195875168,
0.5126968622207642,
0.2452024221420288,
0.4485834836959839,
0.10122426599264145,
-0.5472201108932495,
-0.22818945348262787,
-0.4701482057571411,
-0.7712742686271667,
0.35766860842704773,
-0.24492746591567993,
0.5215432643890381,
-0.620070219039917,
0.0358068011701107,
-0.14104428887367249,
0.15516133606433868,
-0.8252167701721191,
-0.132428377866745,
0.047976456582546234,
1.2992970943450928,
-0.6162861585617065,
0.7760034203529358,
0.6245188117027283,
-0.45759931206703186,
-0.36411550641059875,
0.2157711386680603,
-0.18704403936862946,
-1.1117005348205566,
1.2107497453689575,
0.07862871140241623,
-0.33482587337493896,
-0.148495614528656,
-0.45051059126853943,
-0.6140588521957397,
1.0938403606414795,
0.5613865852355957,
-0.32274770736694336,
0.38407957553863525,
0.6167609095573425,
0.90232914686203,
-0.5804350972175598,
0.4301528334617615,
0.6769909858703613,
0.4947642683982849,
-0.17346462607383728,
-1.1327065229415894,
-0.24520762264728546,
-0.7028884887695312,
0.018583694472908974,
-0.11821703612804413,
-0.8730641007423401,
0.7639226913452148,
-0.06462561339139938,
-0.107375368475914,
0.1559784859418869,
0.23437947034835815,
0.4438944160938263,
0.2778889238834381,
0.26335373520851135,
0.353866845369339,
0.7771199941635132,
-0.11790868639945984,
1.220162272453308,
-0.8075593113899231,
0.0031384460162371397,
1.124545693397522,
-0.8681702613830566,
1.1595990657806396,
0.5357937216758728,
-0.4964035153388977,
0.3734568953514099,
0.5038537979125977,
-0.07840757817029953,
0.6365060210227966,
0.33225342631340027,
-0.44039440155029297,
0.2160123586654663,
-0.5029261112213135,
-0.48266422748565674,
0.26509544253349304,
0.47923681139945984,
-0.16176694631576538,
-0.20309263467788696,
-0.2365451604127884,
-0.2401929646730423,
0.03757883608341217,
-0.044007305055856705,
0.531313419342041,
0.010546734556555748,
-0.741533637046814,
0.5298986434936523,
0.17094746232032776,
0.30632221698760986,
-0.7572135925292969,
0.08110618591308594,
-0.32812216877937317,
0.17719833552837372,
0.0965057760477066,
-0.9719653129577637,
0.09252957999706268,
0.3209104835987091,
0.2664507329463959,
-0.3276704251766205,
0.45900872349739075,
-0.3625851273536682,
-0.3508901000022888,
0.500731885433197,
0.31814026832580566,
0.3018432855606079,
-0.09293128550052643,
-0.9372632503509521,
-0.16742077469825745,
-0.4407157897949219,
-0.26347318291664124,
0.19049321115016937,
0.5260433554649353,
-0.22990158200263977,
0.704155683517456,
0.48247289657592773,
0.6540523767471313,
0.1726062148809433,
0.25338470935821533,
0.8371655941009521,
-0.3747803270816803,
-0.3647303879261017,
-0.7003666162490845,
0.67951899766922,
-0.3393387198448181,
-0.5615835785865784,
0.5431340932846069,
0.6147075295448303,
0.5959007143974304,
0.0048450808972120285,
0.8934886455535889,
0.003994187340140343,
0.3919384479522705,
-0.24885143339633942,
0.9676605463027954,
-0.43757617473602295,
0.6905783414840698,
0.08676120638847351,
-0.9514610767364502,
-0.41082698106765747,
0.339717835187912,
-0.7421604990959167,
-0.16180182993412018,
0.7385696172714233,
0.8194506168365479,
-0.09915946424007416,
-0.35903120040893555,
0.43943628668785095,
0.11713743209838867,
0.558906078338623,
0.31755331158638,
1.1718238592147827,
-0.3628377914428711,
0.517890989780426,
-0.1987747997045517,
-0.25673040747642517,
0.012627706862986088,
-1.1585853099822998,
-0.9559770822525024,
-0.23913051187992096,
-0.2521429657936096,
0.03163740783929825,
0.06803145259618759,
0.976233720779419,
0.7988878488540649,
-0.9881129264831543,
-0.6340433955192566,
-0.04672154411673546,
0.017892586067318916,
-0.002739429473876953,
-0.2573821246623993,
0.43288367986679077,
-0.30750739574432373,
-0.6488252282142639,
0.46170565485954285,
0.8126102089881897,
-0.28139418363571167,
-0.461490660905838,
-0.0345146469771862,
-0.25347763299942017,
0.1587548702955246,
0.5662252306938171,
0.44320639967918396,
-0.8087943196296692,
0.024727672338485718,
-0.18092387914657593,
-0.09137113392353058,
0.1849825233221054,
0.7232828736305237,
-0.27575913071632385,
0.8033326268196106,
0.6266636252403259,
0.9966012835502625,
0.47083815932273865,
-0.24038514494895935,
0.7290709614753723,
-0.5994071960449219,
0.37100085616111755,
0.434790700674057,
0.49812808632850647,
0.2660825848579407,
-0.2229117751121521,
0.3986823558807373,
-0.1949387937784195,
-0.6645156145095825,
-0.8241572380065918,
0.07482859492301941,
-0.36842218041419983,
-0.03294101357460022,
0.7115329504013062,
-0.4798888564109802,
0.03609086200594902,
-0.07773349434137344,
-0.4040563106536865,
-0.4401858150959015,
-0.09680670499801636,
0.8304452896118164,
0.9016439914703369,
-0.09323306381702423,
-0.028199542313814163,
-0.5299018025398254,
0.23058629035949707,
0.5513269901275635,
-0.9730329513549805,
0.020378287881612778,
0.23144711554050446,
0.16353914141654968,
0.00036774840555153787,
0.7694831490516663,
-0.3940490782260895,
0.3548729419708252,
-0.11009753495454788,
-0.1484515368938446,
0.13873165845870972,
-0.48353755474090576,
-0.255039244890213,
0.17054343223571777,
0.6296021938323975,
-0.04286354407668114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12382v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12382v1
|
From Instance Training to Instruction Learning: Task Adapters Generation from Instructions
| 2024-06-18T08:14:28 | 2024-06-18T08:14:28 |
Huanxuan Liao, Yao Xu, Shizhu He, Yuanzhe Zhang, Yanchao Hao, Shengping Liu, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have acquired the ability to solve general tasks
by utilizing instruction finetuning (IFT). However, IFT still relies heavily on
instance training of extensive task data, which greatly limits the adaptability
of LLMs to real-world scenarios where labeled task instances are scarce and
broader task generalization becomes paramount. Contrary to LLMs, humans acquire
skills and complete tasks not merely through repeated practice but also by
understanding and following instructional guidelines. This paper is dedicated
to simulating human learning to address the shortcomings of instance training,
focusing on instruction learning to enhance cross-task generalization. Within
this context, we introduce Task Adapters Generation from Instructions (TAGI),
which automatically constructs the task-specific model in a parameter
generation manner based on the given task instructions without retraining for
unseen tasks. Specifically, we utilize knowledge distillation to enhance the
consistency between TAGI developed through Learning with Instruction and
task-specific models developed through Training with Instance, by aligning the
labels, output logits, and adapter parameters between them. TAGI is endowed
with cross-task generalization capabilities through a two-stage training
process that includes hypernetwork pretraining and finetuning. We evaluate TAGI
on the Super-Natural Instructions and P3 datasets. The experimental results
demonstrate that TAGI can match or even outperform traditional meta-trained
models and other hypernetwork models, while significantly reducing
computational requirements.
|
[
-0.09742208570241928,
-0.6910335421562195,
0.5014401078224182,
-0.14632590115070343,
-0.16897733509540558,
-0.28847187757492065,
-0.2674061954021454,
-0.2272159308195114,
-0.430398166179657,
0.3524264097213745,
-0.6857851147651672,
-0.29324808716773987,
-0.5488447546958923,
-0.15661105513572693,
0.016429975628852844,
1.0778332948684692,
-0.013037086464464664,
0.004595893435180187,
-0.2283899337053299,
0.2591172456741333,
-0.7784788012504578,
-0.32805564999580383,
-0.5652843117713928,
-0.6249057054519653,
0.3199813663959503,
0.7613819241523743,
-0.06230924651026726,
0.6865732073783875,
0.14145973324775696,
0.2723206579685211,
0.6440120935440063,
0.31525030732154846,
-0.49209240078926086,
-0.14371098577976227,
-0.3115338981151581,
-0.885333240032196,
-0.269235223531723,
0.07739165425300598,
0.4183552861213684,
0.6432716846466064,
-0.34210070967674255,
0.19456860423088074,
0.4241887032985687,
0.4619695544242859,
-0.5635947585105896,
0.3655082583427429,
-0.889280378818512,
-0.11797469854354858,
0.09682472050189972,
-0.15720535814762115,
-0.4860234260559082,
0.019927849993109703,
0.15737149119377136,
-0.8504692912101746,
0.6601831912994385,
0.14847218990325928,
0.7740598320960999,
0.3025273382663727,
-0.09811080992221832,
-0.351067453622818,
-0.8455226421356201,
1.0596426725387573,
-0.7822539806365967,
0.2596166729927063,
0.34747961163520813,
0.3956533670425415,
-0.28794023394584656,
-0.6937996745109558,
-0.3933701813220978,
-0.18569496273994446,
-0.09130643308162689,
0.16285628080368042,
-0.24789664149284363,
0.1636006236076355,
0.314187616109848,
-0.07920878380537033,
-0.4226110279560089,
0.20672288537025452,
-0.33348536491394043,
0.21963250637054443,
0.3845296800136566,
0.1552867442369461,
0.30765849351882935,
0.12445343285799026,
-0.3879562318325043,
-0.13721823692321777,
-0.686259925365448,
0.05170688405632973,
0.3139142692089081,
0.2891424596309662,
-0.01943185180425644,
0.21379317343235016,
-0.15258021652698517,
1.0452326536178589,
0.2885764241218567,
-0.2309330254793167,
0.01702420972287655,
-0.19510719180107117,
-0.33297228813171387,
-0.07137920707464218,
0.49670904874801636,
0.37800493836402893,
0.2654833495616913,
-0.46789056062698364,
0.03710191696882248,
-0.035521235316991806,
0.7316824793815613,
-0.9072551131248474,
-0.2520233392715454,
-0.10926678031682968,
-0.2637653350830078,
0.02416979894042015,
0.02196544036269188,
-0.33807066082954407,
-0.0635560005903244,
-0.7024913430213928,
0.4184499979019165,
-0.622498095035553,
0.20564411580562592,
-0.013085507787764072,
-0.1082955002784729,
0.23488466441631317,
0.33690372109413147,
-1.0257253646850586,
0.3748171329498291,
0.8067970275878906,
0.4693982005119324,
0.036591075360774994,
-0.6297482848167419,
-0.44210514426231384,
0.4313274919986725,
-0.13844622671604156,
0.5808594822883606,
-0.5224927067756653,
-0.22748692333698273,
-0.2502022981643677,
0.15455923974514008,
-0.4039890766143799,
-0.6746664643287659,
0.3292054235935211,
-0.3200135827064514,
-0.20506976544857025,
0.006543184630572796,
-0.7567519545555115,
-0.3378000557422638,
0.06748615205287933,
-0.3021761178970337,
0.5945389866828918,
0.09527629613876343,
-0.5838342905044556,
0.5565738677978516,
-0.7146663665771484,
-0.4288943409919739,
-0.047673340886831284,
-0.16006314754486084,
-0.40722978115081787,
0.29086679220199585,
0.16211886703968048,
0.9057673811912537,
-0.5139895677566528,
0.23427130281925201,
-0.1755438894033432,
-0.42273667454719543,
-0.13709184527397156,
-0.16770464181900024,
0.28102368116378784,
-0.02676558680832386,
-0.6584306359291077,
-0.017631927505135536,
-0.5949439406394958,
-0.04601037874817848,
0.10198963433504105,
-0.26122570037841797,
-0.5058184862136841,
0.19924095273017883,
-0.3629974126815796,
0.16753609478473663,
-0.07551682740449905,
-0.655184268951416,
0.2938796281814575,
-0.10272376984357834,
0.6066237688064575,
0.5917818546295166,
0.04926114156842232,
0.37589117884635925,
-0.45751506090164185,
0.27885615825653076,
0.20436596870422363,
0.02624404802918434,
-0.1121218129992485,
-0.37759795784950256,
-0.851513683795929,
0.10516950488090515,
0.09861146658658981,
0.7370822429656982,
-0.8821569681167603,
0.43952247500419617,
-0.41339418292045593,
-0.5075141787528992,
-0.47077515721321106,
0.40142858028411865,
0.7035531401634216,
0.5687378644943237,
0.44200652837753296,
-0.13128209114074707,
-0.6165683269500732,
-0.8860589265823364,
-0.06448280066251755,
0.08432561159133911,
-0.23415112495422363,
0.30381327867507935,
0.41834622621536255,
-0.20796601474285126,
0.7377980351448059,
-0.4773128926753998,
-0.35945406556129456,
-0.3251248002052307,
0.46964019536972046,
-0.05265981703996658,
0.7579441666603088,
0.3275050222873688,
-0.5674912333488464,
-0.26740556955337524,
0.04459019750356674,
-0.6332839727401733,
0.12937158346176147,
-0.25651395320892334,
-0.10418146103620529,
-0.0018546596402302384,
0.5232358574867249,
0.005036712624132633,
0.29338064789772034,
0.4994690418243408,
0.161870539188385,
0.26208987832069397,
-0.5828709006309509,
0.14762979745864868,
-1.2946364879608154,
0.0954648032784462,
0.45845144987106323,
-0.11265882104635239,
-0.7153365015983582,
-0.09422703087329865,
-0.05376201122999191,
-0.10749396681785583,
-0.28068575263023376,
0.2240930050611496,
-0.6906214952468872,
0.017226148396730423,
-0.5186384916305542,
-0.2002415806055069,
0.023593399673700333,
0.6972137093544006,
0.17726682126522064,
0.7851494550704956,
0.5707576274871826,
-0.6500731706619263,
0.2857457399368286,
-0.04166758060455322,
-0.31873512268066406,
0.5718806385993958,
-0.8316858410835266,
0.29815635085105896,
-0.01837547868490219,
0.19015948474407196,
-0.8384830951690674,
-0.12053339183330536,
0.15217921137809753,
0.010171981528401375,
0.4451829493045807,
-0.43409106135368347,
-0.21310928463935852,
-0.24503688514232635,
0.07936972379684448,
0.28817570209503174,
0.823285698890686,
-0.5065357089042664,
0.6855356097221375,
0.1676836907863617,
0.18253234028816223,
-0.5069981813430786,
-0.6218760013580322,
-0.34094664454460144,
-0.13123798370361328,
-0.2674717605113983,
0.3194161057472229,
0.008058762177824974,
0.17329153418540955,
0.035574354231357574,
-0.24709802865982056,
-0.3485105633735657,
0.13493070006370544,
0.6479868292808533,
0.2576439380645752,
-0.13157017529010773,
-0.140648752450943,
0.23174718022346497,
0.11464330554008484,
-0.018442630767822266,
-0.520432710647583,
0.28066664934158325,
0.07148341834545135,
-0.4481806755065918,
-0.8095619678497314,
0.22176890075206757,
0.21351341903209686,
-0.13080498576164246,
0.6439657211303711,
0.6154271960258484,
-0.2846139669418335,
-0.6214452385902405,
-0.5047978758811951,
-0.23399657011032104,
-0.4024014174938202,
0.5580320954322815,
-0.5381321310997009,
-0.7541482448577881,
0.029838288202881813,
-0.3892477750778198,
0.3625660836696625,
-0.08158725500106812,
0.2018541693687439,
-0.24725846946239471,
0.7859320044517517,
0.7086488604545593,
-0.08334103971719742,
0.543141782283783,
-0.5313758254051208,
-0.09582647681236267,
-1.0170135498046875,
-0.1553960144519806,
-0.275920033454895,
-0.5096504092216492,
-0.15543414652347565,
-0.7418500185012817,
0.18179212510585785,
0.222080796957016,
-0.02404026687145233,
0.5132555365562439,
-0.5646815896034241,
0.4572986662387848,
0.8395305275917053,
0.5075349807739258,
-0.09252770245075226,
0.04936322569847107,
0.16367729008197784,
0.10520166903734207,
-0.9526757001876831,
-0.441042959690094,
1.1960195302963257,
0.04042382910847664,
0.8297886252403259,
-0.4483563005924225,
1.0239057540893555,
0.38010019063949585,
0.3567017614841461,
-0.563085675239563,
0.4575271010398865,
-0.45411497354507446,
-0.25420689582824707,
-0.20986692607402802,
-0.43227192759513855,
-1.0907658338546753,
-0.00630266172811389,
-0.158797025680542,
-0.6652804613113403,
0.18269722163677216,
0.5569940209388733,
-0.3526580333709717,
0.394844114780426,
-1.1225128173828125,
1.0285757780075073,
-0.05535739287734032,
-0.36400267481803894,
-0.2868598997592926,
-0.6493807435035706,
0.2487582117319107,
0.027942292392253876,
0.08696494996547699,
-0.03473450616002083,
-0.0392063707113266,
0.6363776922225952,
-0.20414979755878448,
1.2892210483551025,
-0.4422006905078888,
0.011995474807918072,
0.46225717663764954,
-0.16647285223007202,
0.37259694933891296,
-0.20271721482276917,
-0.01158903818577528,
-0.10324801504611969,
-0.4275442361831665,
-0.6369335651397705,
-0.8785190582275391,
0.7515078186988831,
-0.9091530442237854,
-0.7762765288352966,
0.12274033576250076,
-0.8533915281295776,
-0.15806318819522858,
-0.08671820163726807,
0.17079663276672363,
0.6004167199134827,
-0.34827136993408203,
-0.1411871463060379,
0.7939509749412537,
0.20067371428012848,
0.25293415784835815,
0.38466188311576843,
0.3361556828022003,
-0.02569332905113697,
1.1686649322509766,
0.046310678124427795,
0.3128874599933624,
0.5729677081108093,
0.0848061740398407,
0.028745274990797043,
-0.6290766596794128,
-0.6536059379577637,
0.10202818363904953,
-0.40329599380493164,
-0.13161177933216095,
-0.35638687014579773,
0.04271218553185463,
-0.24384139478206635,
-0.11733201891183853,
-0.0324394591152668,
0.07697618752717972,
-0.4373067021369934,
0.13347510993480682,
0.11709806323051453,
0.9469603300094604,
0.14670920372009277,
0.47515854239463806,
-0.9299802184104919,
0.36207595467567444,
0.7447705268859863,
0.04503238573670387,
0.06375746428966522,
-0.5696446895599365,
-0.41401341557502747,
0.3976665735244751,
-0.21492500603199005,
-0.6720943450927734,
0.01728113368153572,
0.571088969707489,
0.7627012133598328,
0.24494799971580505,
-0.02233034558594227,
0.9124491214752197,
-0.9791074991226196,
0.41316479444503784,
0.1011892557144165,
-0.9755332469940186,
0.684863269329071,
-0.13851642608642578,
0.1595640629529953,
0.47773393988609314,
0.6917951107025146,
-0.19162803888320923,
-0.15961599349975586,
-0.5138882398605347,
-0.5553622841835022,
1.0826576948165894,
-0.1080385223031044,
0.18446891009807587,
0.18566599488258362,
0.7173452973365784,
0.2664605975151062,
-0.031804900616407394,
-0.3419857621192932,
-0.04343653842806816,
-0.3026389479637146,
-0.3572503626346588,
-0.2461898922920227,
-0.03628638759255409,
-0.18662546575069427,
-0.20816676318645477,
0.8208355903625488,
-0.2295529544353485,
0.23471619188785553,
0.14325964450836182,
-0.31659623980522156,
0.14934392273426056,
0.30855298042297363,
0.5392274260520935,
0.6365413665771484,
-0.030223803594708443,
0.09584027528762817,
0.2710718512535095,
-0.37502890825271606,
0.38662341237068176,
0.1864660233259201,
0.04247511178255081,
-0.24420149624347687,
0.26320239901542664,
1.2046699523925781,
0.4012519121170044,
-0.48653101921081543,
0.30440354347229004,
0.04145844280719757,
-0.24368560314178467,
0.12451758980751038,
0.7235544919967651,
0.2813476622104645,
0.30208924412727356,
0.16755615174770355,
-0.02369954250752926,
0.11824968457221985,
-0.6056017279624939,
0.24883201718330383,
0.20919270813465118,
-0.3911782205104828,
-0.5283336043357849,
0.637225329875946,
0.3678065240383148,
-0.22881020605564117,
0.39012542366981506,
-0.35051852464675903,
-0.17937014997005463,
0.5007526874542236,
0.8542900085449219,
0.6286095380783081,
-0.36967629194259644,
0.1093902736902237,
0.30847761034965515,
0.18991908431053162,
-0.1113588735461235,
0.0010548366699367762,
-0.2528855800628662,
-0.534089982509613,
-0.5259398221969604,
-0.4642191529273987,
-0.32402658462524414,
-0.002548785647377372,
-0.6833446621894836,
0.03286896273493767,
-0.4363507926464081,
0.039137717336416245,
0.0771147832274437,
-0.19902066886425018,
-0.690780520439148,
0.35795748233795166,
0.11494698375463486,
0.5585145354270935,
-1.1109811067581177,
1.220847249031067,
1.1646500825881958,
-0.28553715348243713,
-1.0413565635681152,
0.18111293017864227,
-0.3506214916706085,
-0.8368158936500549,
0.7127970457077026,
0.2036598175764084,
0.041137102991342545,
0.24742911756038666,
-0.4219033420085907,
-0.2626323699951172,
1.27194082736969,
0.40273165702819824,
-0.815869152545929,
-0.3868577480316162,
0.2839774489402771,
0.3683347702026367,
-0.49436742067337036,
0.21308690309524536,
0.5735635161399841,
0.1044638454914093,
-0.08668693900108337,
-0.7132838368415833,
0.12346155941486359,
-0.2139963060617447,
0.41843461990356445,
0.11780322343111038,
-0.37634485960006714,
0.6465782523155212,
-0.1588752716779709,
-0.032876428216695786,
-0.13734470307826996,
0.6879222393035889,
0.20499104261398315,
0.10605848580598831,
0.700022280216217,
0.7018515467643738,
0.2866612672805786,
-0.04459249973297119,
0.9598877429962158,
-0.1580364853143692,
0.03495638072490692,
1.4122700691223145,
-0.2974817156791687,
0.6199773550033569,
0.36582040786743164,
-0.05993517488241196,
0.7229135632514954,
0.14816726744174957,
-0.10817820578813553,
0.30361470580101013,
0.38970789313316345,
-0.11524543911218643,
-0.38420596718788147,
-0.038216009736061096,
-0.051803819835186005,
0.438201367855072,
0.27349546551704407,
-0.19349509477615356,
-0.36340752243995667,
0.25599202513694763,
-0.10685484856367111,
0.21465806663036346,
-0.30827298760414124,
0.9411545991897583,
-0.05646563321352005,
-0.8036618828773499,
0.7232523560523987,
-0.09521900117397308,
0.818401575088501,
-0.7004502415657043,
-0.5271573662757874,
0.14811208844184875,
0.2871688902378082,
-0.08268339931964874,
-0.4527452886104584,
0.1505267322063446,
-0.00296785868704319,
-0.4448709189891815,
-0.14381331205368042,
0.7292807102203369,
-0.5885156393051147,
-0.4110545814037323,
0.11645685136318207,
0.4875620901584625,
0.18957388401031494,
0.1197303980588913,
-0.7384009957313538,
-0.1601806879043579,
0.048725105822086334,
-0.03275325894355774,
0.5834323167800903,
0.4133208096027374,
-0.07975157350301743,
0.5106580853462219,
0.5360169410705566,
-0.1459108591079712,
0.3147051930427551,
-0.1551916003227234,
0.7939738631248474,
-0.23658178746700287,
-0.19505274295806885,
-0.5755700469017029,
0.3983927071094513,
-0.0035194880329072475,
-0.17148616909980774,
0.49144282937049866,
0.5271931290626526,
1.0655725002288818,
-0.3746916353702545,
0.8223140239715576,
-0.2112276554107666,
0.3574070930480957,
-0.5116642117500305,
0.6163593530654907,
-0.48087525367736816,
-0.005940400995314121,
-0.07826563715934753,
-0.8396596908569336,
0.060105036944150925,
0.35903236269950867,
-0.4657396078109741,
0.07017067074775696,
0.3908475339412689,
0.5662721991539001,
-0.5132231712341309,
-0.16411401331424713,
0.4162162244319916,
-0.16162818670272827,
0.06282122433185577,
0.9914659857749939,
0.5768815875053406,
-0.412237286567688,
0.47467488050460815,
-0.5686004757881165,
-0.33162209391593933,
-0.11288072168827057,
-0.7949152588844299,
-1.0729315280914307,
-0.7279550433158875,
-0.3218540549278259,
0.2018260657787323,
0.5704123377799988,
0.7897118926048279,
1.1987886428833008,
-0.7236448526382446,
-0.5496693253517151,
-0.493071049451828,
-0.13751710951328278,
-0.5341978669166565,
-0.16206948459148407,
0.15482839941978455,
-0.6636815667152405,
-0.9720167517662048,
0.49201273918151855,
-0.28369250893592834,
0.046338990330696106,
0.21753595769405365,
-0.00484894635155797,
-0.26651665568351746,
-0.1107354387640953,
0.3052985370159149,
0.3290957808494568,
-0.66818767786026,
-0.30016663670539856,
-0.2257886528968811,
0.04046304523944855,
0.06692138314247131,
0.9959108233451843,
-0.7359634637832642,
0.3603803515434265,
0.16296187043190002,
0.7426688075065613,
0.43079453706741333,
0.10658331960439682,
0.6625019311904907,
-0.9482406377792358,
0.2094530165195465,
-0.10001426190137863,
0.34172630310058594,
0.13591624796390533,
-0.22135046124458313,
0.36614683270454407,
0.1470884084701538,
-0.5968513488769531,
-0.4554721415042877,
0.2683844566345215,
-0.8465896844863892,
-0.3079712688922882,
0.8834468722343445,
-0.7318968772888184,
-0.4476834833621979,
-0.07902370393276215,
-0.3299535810947418,
0.7171239256858826,
-0.2753787040710449,
0.7508102059364319,
0.25847914814949036,
-0.2825113832950592,
-0.03385299816727638,
-0.5603442192077637,
0.3493216335773468,
0.5169425010681152,
-1.129980444908142,
0.10545031726360321,
0.4003067910671234,
0.5861846804618835,
0.05603054538369179,
0.11792745441198349,
0.4414204955101013,
0.29756999015808105,
-0.04733186215162277,
0.506196141242981,
-0.43684616684913635,
-0.40710678696632385,
-0.07322631031274796,
0.01476441789418459,
0.07270090281963348,
-0.6180098056793213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12381v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12381v2
|
QOG:Question and Options Generation based on Language Model
| 2024-06-18T08:09:58 | 2024-07-02T09:21:03 |
Jincheng Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Question-Options Generation (QOG) is a task that involves generating a set of
question-options pairs given context. This task has various applications,
including fine-tuning large models, information retrieval, and automated
multiple-choice question generation for education. In this paper, we develop
QOG models using three different methods based on fine-tuning
sequence-to-sequence language models (LMs). Experiments demonstrate that the
end-to-end QOG model is computationally efficient and stable during both
training and inference, outperforming other methods. Furthermore, our analysis
indicates that our QOG models are competitive on the QOG task compared to the
large language model Llama 3-8B.
|
[
-0.4008031189441681,
-1.2144975662231445,
0.6891437768936157,
-0.4319942891597748,
-0.17096403241157532,
0.20688730478286743,
-0.03693316504359245,
-0.3415068984031677,
-0.2865419089794159,
0.8001419305801392,
-0.4739849865436554,
-0.20555247366428375,
-0.10242711752653122,
0.07811074703931808,
-0.3603646755218506,
0.9986388087272644,
0.0063258507288992405,
-0.007757024839520454,
-0.4002317488193512,
-0.019856968894600868,
-0.47435200214385986,
-0.4483390152454376,
-1.0639156103134155,
-0.07063435763120651,
0.36778688430786133,
0.4562840163707733,
0.805985689163208,
0.33451953530311584,
0.3727221190929413,
0.21784785389900208,
-0.06711491197347641,
0.23162873089313507,
-0.5282568335533142,
0.3084214925765991,
0.012575386092066765,
-0.747229278087616,
-0.21125827729701996,
-0.0689493864774704,
0.8987321257591248,
0.3181278705596924,
-0.34762221574783325,
0.6579851508140564,
-0.13531306385993958,
0.45278385281562805,
-0.5453388094902039,
-0.3210031986236572,
-0.7027838230133057,
-0.08196264505386353,
-0.050827961415052414,
-0.24376511573791504,
-0.37743982672691345,
-0.6604600548744202,
0.11215461045503616,
-0.3122742772102356,
0.04153499752283096,
0.47650086879730225,
0.66045743227005,
0.045350365340709686,
-0.5597670078277588,
-0.32835012674331665,
-0.5450456142425537,
0.8541974425315857,
-1.058449625968933,
0.4195095896720886,
0.3758050799369812,
0.5338842272758484,
-0.3992287516593933,
-0.8461258411407471,
-0.5056015849113464,
-0.16111359000205994,
0.07041674852371216,
0.06365475803613663,
0.1621091365814209,
0.27744215726852417,
0.32105904817581177,
0.367540568113327,
-0.6128431558609009,
0.09291532635688782,
-0.6405788064002991,
0.16474628448486328,
0.7047808766365051,
0.2972806990146637,
0.2681006193161011,
-0.0695820227265358,
-0.1296938806772232,
0.06632436066865921,
-0.8271059393882751,
0.3541812300682068,
0.5482097864151001,
0.20990480482578278,
0.42216694355010986,
0.6305867433547974,
-0.46318286657333374,
1.1520332098007202,
0.2061396688222885,
-0.48201072216033936,
-0.22505274415016174,
-0.2066732794046402,
-0.4836805760860443,
-0.023834414780139923,
0.5072871446609497,
0.5489341020584106,
-0.01696210727095604,
0.0031942289788275957,
-0.2533699572086334,
-0.28303858637809753,
0.159233957529068,
-0.6462298035621643,
0.21583788096904755,
0.5955392122268677,
-0.5478978157043457,
-0.4310339689254761,
-0.464709609746933,
-0.4094008505344391,
0.16484487056732178,
-0.30077674984931946,
0.6449326276779175,
-0.2537423372268677,
-0.17480584979057312,
0.33227822184562683,
-0.1264084130525589,
0.35621747374534607,
0.24330252408981323,
-0.7703280448913574,
0.08861386030912399,
0.36113500595092773,
0.45821237564086914,
-0.05355474352836609,
-0.13282425701618195,
-0.5267987847328186,
0.24401137232780457,
-0.37547487020492554,
0.8059125542640686,
-0.737201988697052,
-0.47640863060951233,
-0.020779332146048546,
-0.14897982776165009,
0.03395168110728264,
-0.5650173425674438,
0.04559650272130966,
-0.7572866082191467,
0.8025703430175781,
0.0168883316218853,
-0.9920248985290527,
-0.3139738142490387,
0.2593403458595276,
-0.5669780373573303,
1.351605772972107,
0.08729976415634155,
-0.4958951473236084,
0.06268368661403656,
-0.5685157775878906,
-0.0542694590985775,
0.2692279815673828,
-0.10222893953323364,
-0.36119234561920166,
0.06526080518960953,
-0.019319741055369377,
0.3939397931098938,
-0.6265037059783936,
0.4667528569698334,
-0.0795404464006424,
-0.3291972279548645,
0.2361452430486679,
-0.16888409852981567,
0.9239246249198914,
0.3080455958843231,
-0.2089814692735672,
0.13033463060855865,
-0.820542573928833,
0.4999060332775116,
0.2428193837404251,
-0.6072571873664856,
-0.1624060422182083,
0.24888750910758972,
-0.4434233605861664,
0.3320498764514923,
0.35873615741729736,
-0.18795746564865112,
0.3313957154750824,
-0.17505572736263275,
0.4866548478603363,
0.5036212205886841,
0.16805525124073029,
0.23059126734733582,
-0.4809618592262268,
0.8215054273605347,
-0.27747049927711487,
0.17780467867851257,
-0.2741530239582062,
-0.8245952129364014,
-0.826837956905365,
0.16980725526809692,
0.3944929838180542,
0.8216386437416077,
-0.6154249906539917,
0.10140484571456909,
0.3097994029521942,
-0.42155545949935913,
-0.7396513223648071,
0.022400209680199623,
0.3347218632698059,
0.4034002721309662,
0.1428665667772293,
-0.07205408066511154,
-0.3331020176410675,
-0.8265120983123779,
-0.19106034934520721,
-0.5320339202880859,
0.04818645864725113,
0.2607007920742035,
0.1955043375492096,
0.14949293434619904,
0.9089857339859009,
-0.5451384782791138,
0.6087945103645325,
-0.3319393992424011,
0.24072910845279694,
0.11708253622055054,
0.3262212574481964,
0.5722968578338623,
-0.6538754105567932,
-0.32297053933143616,
-0.27025964856147766,
-0.46000322699546814,
-0.06205206736922264,
-0.24764643609523773,
-0.4579520523548126,
0.0775328129529953,
0.5938669443130493,
-0.5375609397888184,
0.15944404900074005,
0.5104179382324219,
-0.21432358026504517,
0.6822779774665833,
0.08499106764793396,
0.19595907628536224,
-1.3390053510665894,
-0.018862441182136536,
-0.39019691944122314,
-0.35473230481147766,
-0.9126153588294983,
0.43429702520370483,
-0.02034185081720352,
-0.35179394483566284,
-0.6651941537857056,
0.7251154184341431,
-0.30508938431739807,
0.0622258223593235,
-0.1253451108932495,
0.10604789853096008,
0.05688631534576416,
0.4172499179840088,
0.004046160262078047,
0.7824203968048096,
0.5666865110397339,
-0.7184520959854126,
0.4721894860267639,
0.07611491531133652,
-0.3456937074661255,
0.3687763810157776,
-0.5873035192489624,
0.4131746292114258,
-0.26897406578063965,
-0.05371493846178055,
-1.1583937406539917,
-0.20836809277534485,
0.18804344534873962,
-0.25542524456977844,
0.046331148594617844,
0.0962337851524353,
-0.3793058693408966,
-0.4809619188308716,
-0.22397062182426453,
0.6805633902549744,
0.7330955862998962,
-0.3533177077770233,
0.2172943651676178,
0.2840518355369568,
-0.3692699074745178,
-0.36050108075141907,
-0.14853650331497192,
-0.12981094419956207,
-0.44720301032066345,
-0.5828681588172913,
-0.0017463561380282044,
-0.40289220213890076,
-0.34599751234054565,
-0.10938888043165207,
0.17652301490306854,
-0.17195069789886475,
0.20084212720394135,
-0.13962318003177643,
0.13006362318992615,
-0.34968268871307373,
0.3100321292877197,
0.26926279067993164,
0.36976364254951477,
-0.0818009227514267,
-0.2960321307182312,
0.4037688374519348,
-0.07250736653804779,
-0.33144667744636536,
-0.07540688663721085,
0.7455845475196838,
0.3397868871688843,
-0.45997679233551025,
0.4474165737628937,
0.09307830780744553,
-0.37784019112586975,
-0.2328496128320694,
-0.5787584781646729,
-0.11222071200609207,
-0.48001036047935486,
0.24747489392757416,
-0.2351735532283783,
-1.2286063432693481,
0.371816486120224,
-0.14972460269927979,
0.4106338322162628,
0.12216537445783615,
0.5919875502586365,
-0.08827861398458481,
1.387190580368042,
0.4674545228481293,
0.1637541502714157,
0.47005900740623474,
0.11465317755937576,
0.31425026059150696,
-0.5281769037246704,
0.005744272843003273,
-0.3941415250301361,
-0.19733107089996338,
-0.5309944152832031,
-0.45794782042503357,
0.3902153968811035,
0.7080889344215393,
-0.2821575999259949,
0.06403739750385284,
-0.32889696955680847,
0.5103544592857361,
1.0636191368103027,
-0.021422352641820908,
0.2812359035015106,
0.024573130533099174,
0.0024667277466505766,
0.5190804600715637,
-0.7970473766326904,
-0.8406131863594055,
1.3525840044021606,
0.17744815349578857,
0.5041742920875549,
0.10582313686609268,
0.8691416382789612,
0.10126227140426636,
-0.018747910857200623,
-0.6757587194442749,
0.7929459810256958,
0.38967210054397583,
-0.9207775592803955,
-0.666584849357605,
-0.05837081000208855,
-0.9195367693901062,
0.162434384226799,
-0.26190367341041565,
-0.7764363884925842,
-0.18275471031665802,
0.35042354464530945,
-0.6526526808738708,
0.3456420302391052,
-0.5667710304260254,
0.6377524137496948,
-0.4411250352859497,
-0.2969573140144348,
-0.21554307639598846,
-0.625167965888977,
0.4132511615753174,
0.041748639196157455,
-0.12939339876174927,
-0.075301893055439,
0.2552777826786041,
0.7128142714500427,
-0.05726141110062599,
0.672055721282959,
0.07858044654130936,
-0.291742205619812,
1.0564067363739014,
0.060587383806705475,
0.5304606556892395,
0.17938050627708435,
-0.1316918581724167,
-0.03803594037890434,
-0.0551719032227993,
-0.44062912464141846,
-0.46181735396385193,
0.21761204302310944,
-0.4419398605823517,
-1.0146279335021973,
0.03237774595618248,
-0.5996571183204651,
-0.2507302463054657,
0.4504060745239258,
0.20014722645282745,
0.4375647306442261,
-0.09204088151454926,
-0.1354866325855255,
0.620614230632782,
-0.48775768280029297,
0.42569711804389954,
0.4316575527191162,
-0.5160752534866333,
-0.30373677611351013,
0.750686526298523,
0.169364333152771,
0.6756319999694824,
0.31876370310783386,
-0.06130046397447586,
-0.1880478709936142,
-0.588206946849823,
-0.5797787308692932,
0.1432994157075882,
-0.5752288103103638,
-0.2634725868701935,
-0.3103792369365692,
-0.381989449262619,
-0.3001256287097931,
-0.1836990863084793,
-0.14722919464111328,
-0.5666609406471252,
-0.2617608904838562,
-0.22284072637557983,
0.18702515959739685,
0.7087720036506653,
0.30642226338386536,
0.42599591612815857,
-0.8865078687667847,
0.3417227864265442,
0.8918823003768921,
0.3407212793827057,
-0.15339773893356323,
-0.22081731259822845,
-0.32456085085868835,
0.14733126759529114,
-0.6616902947425842,
-1.089772343635559,
0.1052074208855629,
0.15313173830509186,
0.564116895198822,
0.4387929141521454,
-0.2477627396583557,
0.5905330181121826,
-0.6313389539718628,
1.1856187582015991,
0.012218873016536236,
-0.833319365978241,
0.6356621384620667,
-0.43328356742858887,
0.2586837112903595,
0.230895534157753,
0.25439444184303284,
-0.5402944087982178,
-0.6660097241401672,
-0.7513187527656555,
-0.7971557974815369,
0.5786687135696411,
0.14271479845046997,
-0.14049500226974487,
-0.311175674200058,
0.510827362537384,
0.22271139919757843,
0.5492881536483765,
-0.5665423274040222,
-0.02765236608684063,
-0.013684437610208988,
-0.131181538105011,
0.01955721154808998,
-0.3650071918964386,
-0.08515569567680359,
0.03181898221373558,
0.6341571807861328,
-0.22929421067237854,
0.31740644574165344,
-0.054622478783130646,
0.015854494646191597,
-0.3664100170135498,
0.569533109664917,
0.7355239391326904,
0.728975772857666,
-0.36619287729263306,
-0.10048132389783859,
0.392897367477417,
0.01686811074614525,
0.27886369824409485,
-0.19957411289215088,
-0.42675796151161194,
-0.02194434218108654,
0.06628458946943283,
1.162244200706482,
-0.09341331571340561,
-1.034128189086914,
-0.016544148325920105,
-0.02222076617181301,
-0.2560718059539795,
-0.053269680589437485,
0.340642511844635,
0.12306474149227142,
0.4679657518863678,
0.23197203874588013,
-0.5448925495147705,
0.40402740240097046,
-0.5650049448013306,
-0.07133878022432327,
0.5652259588241577,
0.2046932578086853,
-0.15857285261154175,
0.7639526128768921,
0.16942648589611053,
-0.40562692284584045,
0.5334728360176086,
-0.2502930164337158,
-0.2888793349266052,
0.7280731201171875,
0.8379087448120117,
0.7832995653152466,
-0.4582422971725464,
0.42938119173049927,
0.49031302332878113,
0.13810309767723083,
-0.3908073306083679,
0.665224015712738,
0.006279239431023598,
-0.5963144898414612,
-0.503509521484375,
-0.5700430870056152,
-0.5800178050994873,
0.46917620301246643,
-0.8977574706077576,
0.20809033513069153,
-0.16195090115070343,
-0.34494107961654663,
-0.4254553020000458,
-0.14730194211006165,
-0.40850988030433655,
0.5980515480041504,
0.309658408164978,
0.7944896221160889,
-0.5120699405670166,
0.5212368965148926,
1.0405515432357788,
0.03800731152296066,
-0.8786728382110596,
-0.025396190583705902,
-0.42322108149528503,
-0.7364156246185303,
0.5953828692436218,
0.07958984375,
0.03621450439095497,
0.3017924726009369,
-0.6425420641899109,
-1.261832594871521,
1.1049739122390747,
0.3208882510662079,
-0.8736310601234436,
-0.45399051904678345,
0.324161171913147,
0.3473752439022064,
-0.38520190119743347,
0.25068050622940063,
0.6037419438362122,
0.2261810004711151,
-0.46511152386665344,
-0.8593098521232605,
-0.01306865457445383,
-0.19801019132137299,
0.2564769983291626,
0.3763006329536438,
-1.0050978660583496,
0.8642625212669373,
-0.20870304107666016,
-0.2453383207321167,
0.20699864625930786,
0.5959227681159973,
0.5207594633102417,
0.1093527302145958,
0.45946162939071655,
0.4960346817970276,
0.9200888276100159,
0.07388181984424591,
0.9162895679473877,
-0.6540437936782837,
0.3899402320384979,
0.9294500350952148,
-0.20521686971187592,
0.886600136756897,
0.4980044364929199,
-0.06823460757732391,
0.3013448417186737,
0.9597636461257935,
0.13215139508247375,
0.5327752828598022,
0.25874462723731995,
-0.25755739212036133,
-0.5435134768486023,
0.16699275374412537,
-0.3700834810733795,
0.39911940693855286,
0.26387709379196167,
-0.14685630798339844,
-0.11967658996582031,
-0.13044419884681702,
-0.23533891141414642,
-0.44934314489364624,
-0.571173369884491,
0.8153222799301147,
-0.13222618401050568,
-1.152092456817627,
0.6892520785331726,
-0.05665493756532669,
0.12353051453828812,
-0.4423432946205139,
-0.1727265864610672,
-0.13392388820648193,
-0.5277758836746216,
0.07423712313175201,
-0.7187139987945557,
-0.18534378707408905,
-0.11220429837703705,
-0.13693158328533173,
0.023109188303351402,
0.7869687676429749,
-0.7453965544700623,
-0.5842574834823608,
-0.20281773805618286,
0.5626775622367859,
0.08289472758769989,
0.44688621163368225,
-0.7440650463104248,
-0.4115622043609619,
0.12882111966609955,
-0.6213701963424683,
0.22999127209186554,
0.18669836223125458,
-0.3920370638370514,
0.6315714120864868,
0.4744335412979126,
0.04818465933203697,
0.4896034896373749,
-0.1335975080728531,
0.534217357635498,
-0.7157361507415771,
-0.49300330877304077,
-0.5980133414268494,
0.7905222773551941,
0.006059766747057438,
-0.3202457129955292,
0.5924582481384277,
0.466373473405838,
0.9617449641227722,
-0.0599014051258564,
1.173595666885376,
0.028355509042739868,
0.5471460223197937,
-0.7868131995201111,
0.1992596834897995,
-0.6365982294082642,
0.045122984796762466,
0.01811150275170803,
-0.8021584749221802,
-0.06102241575717926,
0.43260568380355835,
-0.06854752451181412,
0.0825667455792427,
0.5727419257164001,
0.709655225276947,
0.14595337212085724,
-0.05000182241201401,
0.3088420331478119,
-0.09859851747751236,
0.22146756947040558,
0.6349005699157715,
1.0352134704589844,
-0.3714461326599121,
0.376496821641922,
-0.005108251702040434,
-0.025819404050707817,
-0.3663213551044464,
-0.7693700790405273,
-1.089418649673462,
-0.5599437355995178,
-0.16725531220436096,
-0.2132517695426941,
0.20875594019889832,
0.8014059662818909,
0.5553499460220337,
-0.6964369416236877,
-0.4860186278820038,
-0.11369604617357254,
0.1064709722995758,
-0.13994841277599335,
-0.19350774586200714,
0.22240228950977325,
-0.5411173105239868,
-0.8094353675842285,
0.29158255457878113,
0.16628989577293396,
0.16890361905097961,
-0.17146041989326477,
-0.0071357302367687225,
-0.12443491816520691,
0.5084632039070129,
0.6821871399879456,
0.26439449191093445,
-0.7289466261863708,
-0.46970051527023315,
0.05337812379002571,
0.16022641956806183,
0.013407199643552303,
0.7469490766525269,
-0.5522818565368652,
0.49499988555908203,
0.5240775942802429,
0.669255793094635,
0.1351388543844223,
0.1416098177433014,
0.7849826812744141,
-0.6127625703811646,
-0.0504508800804615,
0.07924643903970718,
0.30363887548446655,
0.1356939673423767,
-0.4202651381492615,
0.3147107660770416,
-0.2564806044101715,
-0.8706377744674683,
-1.0724705457687378,
0.48264750838279724,
-0.6205386519432068,
-0.43905746936798096,
1.2417659759521484,
0.15294285118579865,
-0.05833444371819496,
0.14785151183605194,
-0.5767506957054138,
0.4593721330165863,
-0.2820577621459961,
0.7814360857009888,
0.7641546726226807,
-0.33296898007392883,
-0.20610496401786804,
-0.8071631193161011,
0.6321464776992798,
0.6139791011810303,
-0.8085781931877136,
-0.2756801247596741,
0.4449109435081482,
0.26696479320526123,
0.059037234634160995,
0.6351627111434937,
0.273551881313324,
0.4102663993835449,
-0.27549487352371216,
0.05341221019625664,
0.15538586676120758,
-0.21462219953536987,
-0.13019385933876038,
0.36062735319137573,
0.38930150866508484,
-0.0792601928114891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12373v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12373v2
|
WebCanvas: Benchmarking Web Agents in Online Environments
| 2024-06-18T07:58:33 | 2024-06-27T16:56:13 |
Yichen Pan, Dehan Kong, Sida Zhou, Cheng Cui, Yifei Leng, Bing Jiang, Hangyu Liu, Yanyi Shang, Shuyan Zhou, Tongshuang Wu, Zhengyang Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7
|
For web agents to be practically useful, they must adapt to the continuously
evolving web environment characterized by frequent updates to user interfaces
and content. However, most existing benchmarks only capture the static aspects
of the web. To bridge this gap, we introduce WebCanvas, an innovative online
evaluation framework for web agents that effectively addresses the dynamic
nature of web interactions. WebCanvas contains three main components to
facilitate realistic assessments: (1) A novel evaluation metric which reliably
capture critical intermediate actions or states necessary for task completions
while disregarding noise caused by insignificant events or changed
web-elements. (2) A benchmark dataset called Mind2Web-Live, a refined version
of original Mind2Web static dataset containing 542 tasks with 2439 intermediate
evaluation states; (3) Lightweight and generalizable annotation tools and
testing pipelines that enables the community to collect and maintain the
high-quality, up-to-date dataset. Building on WebCanvas, we open-source an
agent framework with extensible modules for reasoning, providing a foundation
for the community to conduct online inference and evaluations. Our
best-performing agent achieves a task success rate of 23.1% and a task
completion rate of 48.8% on the Mind2Web-Live test set. Additionally, we
analyze the performance discrepancies across various websites, domains, and
experimental environments. We encourage the community to contribute further
insights on online agent evaluation, thereby advancing this field of research.
|
[
-0.7716379761695862,
-0.33233442902565,
0.3868754804134369,
0.3240495026111603,
-0.20124836266040802,
0.2831050455570221,
-0.20995166897773743,
-0.8457428216934204,
0.1507866233587265,
0.01642921194434166,
-0.5946505665779114,
-0.36135607957839966,
-0.19840489327907562,
0.06340782344341278,
-0.27762094140052795,
0.7046633362770081,
-0.003490169532597065,
-0.009536171332001686,
-0.721946120262146,
-0.20629243552684784,
-0.2217220962047577,
-0.014531389810144901,
-0.7630385756492615,
-0.3037117123603821,
0.4999345541000366,
0.07728909701108932,
0.507117509841919,
0.2218555361032486,
0.768746018409729,
0.3689652383327484,
0.32112452387809753,
0.4043383002281189,
-0.6137856245040894,
0.3546479642391205,
-0.4764079749584198,
-0.3933666944503784,
-0.6815261840820312,
0.06684558093547821,
0.1504926234483719,
0.30367204546928406,
-0.31674525141716003,
0.3705434203147888,
0.09526719152927399,
0.3182639479637146,
-1.0618702173233032,
0.29465997219085693,
-0.421239972114563,
-0.04840105026960373,
-0.042565006762742996,
-0.1986016184091568,
-0.0740811824798584,
-0.7779608964920044,
0.18413156270980835,
-0.9280552864074707,
0.29477447271347046,
-0.16403228044509888,
0.7328934073448181,
0.4072858393192291,
-0.2620408535003662,
0.01078710611909628,
-0.6147385239601135,
0.4503219425678253,
-0.1789868324995041,
0.41408899426460266,
0.4833967685699463,
0.9165412187576294,
-0.21307581663131714,
-0.8518400192260742,
-0.5548877716064453,
-0.16939660906791687,
0.38951215147972107,
0.356601744890213,
-0.40309855341911316,
-0.15125542879104614,
0.12991617619991302,
0.08643785864114761,
-0.5461265444755554,
-0.1007581576704979,
-0.050375789403915405,
-0.4099932014942169,
0.6300415396690369,
0.35720181465148926,
0.12494935095310211,
0.43510109186172485,
-0.3216162323951721,
-0.6420587301254272,
-0.2703743577003479,
0.37704822421073914,
0.38368144631385803,
0.08382018655538559,
-0.0939558818936348,
0.1885383576154709,
-0.4597429633140564,
0.3702840507030487,
-0.047454074025154114,
0.06561459600925446,
0.3452896177768707,
-0.16706636548042297,
-0.023024046793580055,
-0.4456210732460022,
0.5637981295585632,
0.8909115791320801,
0.18956659734249115,
-0.42132568359375,
-0.3054945170879364,
0.4173058569431305,
0.7045419216156006,
-0.8064457774162292,
-0.14963817596435547,
0.5215509533882141,
-0.35351070761680603,
-0.24690182507038116,
0.17632140219211578,
-0.9527889490127563,
-0.7679089307785034,
0.0006095054559409618,
0.4179455637931824,
-0.2090110033750534,
-0.4271990954875946,
-0.037388622760772705,
-0.639695942401886,
0.3646242320537567,
0.6918978691101074,
-0.16663795709609985,
0.832356870174408,
0.7176902294158936,
0.7190741300582886,
-0.5300489068031311,
-0.3292151093482971,
-0.45156216621398926,
-0.18455545604228973,
-0.3796788156032562,
1.240855097770691,
-0.4051186144351959,
-0.14988133311271667,
0.19135737419128418,
-0.054677072912454605,
0.2664235830307007,
-0.5147301554679871,
0.3032015860080719,
-0.5828234553337097,
-0.21860304474830627,
-0.5189597606658936,
-0.5417747497558594,
-0.09200713783502579,
0.6152098774909973,
-0.7851501107215881,
0.9782915711402893,
0.12095402926206589,
-0.39921778440475464,
0.5759108066558838,
-0.687268853187561,
-0.10678550601005554,
0.1700555831193924,
0.14964823424816132,
-0.15231989324092865,
-0.0988771989941597,
-0.17114923894405365,
0.31841471791267395,
-0.6851257681846619,
-0.32675570249557495,
-0.611962080001831,
-0.5142648816108704,
0.5682237148284912,
-0.1832338124513626,
0.5926292538642883,
0.25139471888542175,
-0.49802759289741516,
0.11780416965484619,
-0.7659194469451904,
0.36621910333633423,
0.18751008808612823,
-0.15384308993816376,
-0.3052215576171875,
0.18262912333011627,
0.3258046805858612,
0.1932324320077896,
0.24126559495925903,
-0.8458572030067444,
0.014450588263571262,
0.1008029505610466,
-0.03303060308098793,
0.6589881181716919,
0.11118058115243912,
-0.2790031135082245,
-0.5319774746894836,
0.7249332070350647,
-0.49883535504341125,
0.48972296714782715,
0.303526908159256,
-0.4578559696674347,
-0.7193340063095093,
-0.3550783097743988,
0.13616928458213806,
0.4117409288883209,
-0.4552193284034729,
0.22920162975788116,
-0.4237351417541504,
-1.012622356414795,
-0.40138670802116394,
-0.018663445487618446,
0.4832465946674347,
-0.10133808106184006,
0.43069353699684143,
-0.7565249800682068,
-0.2579948902130127,
-0.7293593287467957,
-0.2571415305137634,
-0.09403043240308762,
-0.16397111117839813,
0.09098544716835022,
0.3220148980617523,
-0.322855144739151,
1.1457066535949707,
-0.42847660183906555,
-0.2844541668891907,
0.01883508823812008,
0.20331569015979767,
-0.3284873962402344,
0.18609431385993958,
0.48119452595710754,
-0.6530346870422363,
-0.29334062337875366,
-0.002062862040475011,
-0.6480538249015808,
-0.23563405871391296,
0.11037081480026245,
-0.13338671624660492,
-0.34522703289985657,
0.2599732279777527,
-0.5959544777870178,
0.44272229075431824,
0.23289671540260315,
-0.2391240894794464,
0.3914773464202881,
-0.18031294643878937,
0.30248045921325684,
-0.5705119967460632,
0.23881706595420837,
-0.06979397684335709,
-0.565335750579834,
-0.34936636686325073,
0.35954490303993225,
0.12683890759944916,
0.020482391119003296,
-0.6380569934844971,
0.7136155962944031,
-0.4936712980270386,
-0.4421198070049286,
-0.4475325047969818,
0.39565780758857727,
0.07614720612764359,
0.6147847771644592,
-0.4784562885761261,
0.5992714762687683,
0.2566768527030945,
-0.7782671451568604,
0.797080934047699,
-0.015073438175022602,
-0.43610286712646484,
0.7627976536750793,
-0.46683269739151,
0.33597397804260254,
0.13334247469902039,
0.5558590888977051,
-0.8082676529884338,
-0.06970908492803574,
0.05209057405591011,
-0.3038250207901001,
-0.32658854126930237,
0.3237304985523224,
-0.493476003408432,
-0.41384732723236084,
-0.6079809665679932,
0.08416179567575455,
0.26486894488334656,
-0.17920014262199402,
0.5521883964538574,
0.5599755048751831,
0.2993518114089966,
-0.4380996525287628,
-0.3891910910606384,
0.06554320454597473,
0.054731085896492004,
-0.28684476017951965,
0.3442220687866211,
-0.1431049406528473,
-0.5107728838920593,
0.160556361079216,
-0.19807995855808258,
-0.45456069707870483,
0.46351808309555054,
0.3146505057811737,
-0.14487288892269135,
0.08865456283092499,
0.022185878828167915,
-0.08377362787723541,
-0.06406968086957932,
0.12342244386672974,
-0.16564099490642548,
0.39506492018699646,
-0.3713846206665039,
-0.5284274816513062,
-0.47995707392692566,
0.10268198698759079,
0.7055677175521851,
-0.3980022966861725,
0.2703310549259186,
0.7217241525650024,
-0.81500244140625,
-0.13980942964553833,
-0.6849123239517212,
-0.049998361617326736,
-0.4462350010871887,
0.22374050319194794,
-0.6210567355155945,
-0.3559058904647827,
0.6305196285247803,
-0.25812339782714844,
0.4009507894515991,
0.4056639075279236,
0.5235475301742554,
-0.19243133068084717,
0.767173171043396,
0.47389107942581177,
0.34228968620300293,
0.36631515622138977,
-0.17935045063495636,
-0.3857756555080414,
-0.7012490630149841,
-0.282245934009552,
-0.3420640528202057,
-0.3265959322452545,
-0.5418190360069275,
-0.6601235270500183,
0.2511676251888275,
-0.02424660325050354,
-0.02712114341557026,
0.47598233819007874,
-0.30059653520584106,
0.43879440426826477,
0.3212548494338989,
0.3198240101337433,
0.07514476031064987,
-0.21531400084495544,
-0.2951452136039734,
0.3657129108905792,
-0.13504894077777863,
-0.4354512393474579,
1.2381807565689087,
0.11328566819429398,
0.5050098299980164,
0.5635332465171814,
0.14865392446517944,
1.0500990152359009,
0.39577731490135193,
-0.5118726491928101,
0.6434910297393799,
0.3765336573123932,
-0.6405689716339111,
-0.3352135419845581,
0.03891799598932266,
-1.2568329572677612,
0.456796258687973,
-0.23340919613838196,
-0.8402422070503235,
0.18968388438224792,
0.09233636409044266,
-0.3231136202812195,
-0.03662440553307533,
-0.440453439950943,
0.8720144033432007,
-0.21029995381832123,
-0.7761998176574707,
-0.9651201367378235,
-0.406548410654068,
-0.148323193192482,
0.007831444963812828,
-0.05286575108766556,
-0.5024118423461914,
-0.2612745463848114,
0.4710110127925873,
-0.574942946434021,
0.7665368914604187,
-0.3403272330760956,
0.303498774766922,
0.484830379486084,
0.11437258869409561,
0.5248971581459045,
-0.23087279498577118,
0.02558557502925396,
0.055308062583208084,
0.17622330784797668,
-0.6280160546302795,
-0.7360985279083252,
0.5048633813858032,
-0.8539369106292725,
-0.26852911710739136,
-0.608767032623291,
-0.014881511218845844,
-0.6669521927833557,
0.05130014196038246,
-0.11787374317646027,
0.4963638186454773,
-0.6697056889533997,
0.12162534147500992,
0.3702467978000641,
-0.05051175877451897,
0.3967287242412567,
0.8133503198623657,
-0.2661396265029907,
-0.3325848877429962,
0.9477812051773071,
-0.2405901849269867,
0.1297028362751007,
0.4576959013938904,
0.08238480985164642,
-0.4564618468284607,
-0.39315447211265564,
-0.513687014579773,
-0.10833840817213058,
-0.8558397889137268,
-0.15852311253547668,
-0.6520917415618896,
0.24457606673240662,
-0.28040891885757446,
0.07676753401756287,
-0.6504768133163452,
-0.33444827795028687,
0.07194121181964874,
-0.0474582239985466,
0.2844542860984802,
0.7705450057983398,
-0.07587596774101257,
-0.03091876022517681,
-0.5183824300765991,
0.1773780733346939,
0.6480591297149658,
0.4926580488681793,
0.16881611943244934,
0.12113922834396362,
-0.3094434142112732,
-0.23012788593769073,
-0.47674405574798584,
-0.9183056950569153,
-0.0294621754437685,
0.04989463463425636,
0.9199627041816711,
0.5665816068649292,
0.0050592864863574505,
0.8478341698646545,
-0.14335183799266815,
0.5767799615859985,
-0.01956833153963089,
-0.9033263921737671,
0.36389362812042236,
-0.382658451795578,
0.34944480657577515,
0.8685407042503357,
0.35302382707595825,
-0.4904925525188446,
-0.393437922000885,
-0.354478120803833,
-0.5147464871406555,
0.3825482130050659,
0.3560870289802551,
-0.3178044557571411,
0.07132533192634583,
0.12857747077941895,
0.24163399636745453,
0.28024736046791077,
-0.1769370287656784,
-0.1328621357679367,
-0.3929038345813751,
0.08823040872812271,
-0.009079360403120518,
0.20742204785346985,
-0.15808403491973877,
0.06951460987329483,
0.45338383316993713,
-0.3974964916706085,
0.5483262538909912,
0.1824561357498169,
-0.4654824435710907,
0.007648770231753588,
-0.022561993449926376,
0.5916654467582703,
1.1203995943069458,
-0.501349925994873,
0.08686070144176483,
0.3673083484172821,
-0.5893241167068481,
0.21870695054531097,
0.3015502989292145,
0.20686456561088562,
-0.33433592319488525,
0.3796057105064392,
0.46039077639579773,
0.0777544304728508,
-1.0954374074935913,
0.6637591123580933,
-0.5834517478942871,
0.3233211934566498,
-0.49691805243492126,
0.24321500957012177,
-0.10960909724235535,
0.32944783568382263,
0.5725919008255005,
0.10014055669307709,
0.4361410140991211,
-0.4822792410850525,
0.23950105905532837,
0.24168604612350464,
-0.6886745691299438,
-0.4152354300022125,
0.5672098398208618,
0.5896594524383545,
-0.4037627577781677,
0.2525533437728882,
-0.46653056144714355,
-0.3734157681465149,
0.9074922204017639,
0.17823490500450134,
1.2178999185562134,
-0.13936620950698853,
0.20496007800102234,
0.11317282915115356,
0.28582143783569336,
0.06029841676354408,
0.3423057794570923,
-0.3988925516605377,
-0.6331464052200317,
0.08074100315570831,
-0.6718781590461731,
-1.0103387832641602,
-0.13849510252475739,
-0.7178053855895996,
0.1288461685180664,
-0.47695788741111755,
-0.47981396317481995,
-0.1884036660194397,
0.25168663263320923,
-1.070753574371338,
0.4897761046886444,
0.08024581521749496,
0.8398887515068054,
-0.5197519659996033,
0.615075945854187,
0.8205865025520325,
-0.27886515855789185,
-0.12650157511234283,
0.09744326770305634,
0.3489684462547302,
-0.431123822927475,
0.00522729754447937,
0.36818745732307434,
-0.5498363971710205,
-0.24737806618213654,
0.07807625830173492,
-0.8904241919517517,
1.1816167831420898,
0.26843899488449097,
-0.32917121052742004,
0.4748193919658661,
0.017711227759718895,
0.9518796801567078,
-0.2072363644838333,
1.026041030883789,
0.27421730756759644,
0.5432631373405457,
-0.3749362528324127,
-0.9047274589538574,
0.2822730839252472,
-0.6322922706604004,
-0.05039508268237114,
-0.07608555257320404,
-1.0481269359588623,
0.43692103028297424,
0.17205622792243958,
-0.2756682336330414,
-0.1136530265212059,
0.600638747215271,
-0.017645590007305145,
0.39507678151130676,
0.8536669611930847,
0.3352920711040497,
0.9316384196281433,
-0.009318326599895954,
1.12107253074646,
-0.18584910035133362,
0.28689688444137573,
0.9874597191810608,
-0.5215203166007996,
0.8740924596786499,
-0.061390846967697144,
-0.39594826102256775,
0.5917048454284668,
0.8932635188102722,
0.1374024748802185,
0.46743708848953247,
0.3413788676261902,
-0.17583967745304108,
-0.45926105976104736,
-0.3814297318458557,
-0.23124384880065918,
0.729952335357666,
0.18138067424297333,
0.39346200227737427,
-0.2748520076274872,
-0.0026322773192077875,
-0.2449548840522766,
0.04411303997039795,
-0.053229108452796936,
0.5151358842849731,
-0.24468019604682922,
-0.9081589579582214,
0.2390206903219223,
0.12257657945156097,
0.2812342643737793,
-0.7275623083114624,
-0.032791487872600555,
-0.21612508594989777,
0.3538304269313812,
0.029668491333723068,
-0.5361676216125488,
0.18323564529418945,
0.17053450644016266,
0.11722438782453537,
-0.1600460261106491,
0.64034503698349,
0.20536410808563232,
-0.15859918296337128,
0.6859440803527832,
0.5559247136116028,
0.5134063363075256,
-0.2315964251756668,
-0.7490659952163696,
0.15350915491580963,
-0.35456034541130066,
-0.2287180870771408,
0.32243168354034424,
0.10137084126472473,
-0.34501904249191284,
0.9380331039428711,
0.7531595826148987,
-0.08249567449092865,
-0.016648082062602043,
0.12818223237991333,
0.7433431148529053,
-0.6657349467277527,
-0.4884563386440277,
-0.46520957350730896,
0.2582407295703888,
-0.45732712745666504,
-0.643265426158905,
0.4954419732093811,
0.8440511226654053,
0.6684898138046265,
0.24194665253162384,
0.7957649230957031,
-0.07870378345251083,
0.5138446688652039,
0.05705734342336655,
0.7271885871887207,
-0.6041697263717651,
-0.26568350195884705,
-0.2329171746969223,
-1.064691424369812,
0.1723848432302475,
0.35934916138648987,
0.2627783715724945,
-0.15068669617176056,
0.8111407160758972,
0.525921642780304,
0.09987594187259674,
0.02959378995001316,
0.3720929026603699,
-0.03221859037876129,
0.4391804039478302,
0.40228936076164246,
0.902435302734375,
-0.36097678542137146,
0.7054430842399597,
-0.2644347846508026,
-0.4123155176639557,
-0.27244704961776733,
-0.7423291206359863,
-0.9353303909301758,
-0.4459451735019684,
-0.4023117125034332,
-0.287750780582428,
0.3978709280490875,
1.113261103630066,
0.6639493107795715,
-0.7660143971443176,
-0.36813831329345703,
-0.09125270694494247,
-0.007594020571559668,
-0.9216008186340332,
-0.20190943777561188,
0.03315005823969841,
-0.05401621386408806,
-0.750636100769043,
0.3827193081378937,
0.32836225628852844,
-0.12989197671413422,
-0.5728347301483154,
0.07038301229476929,
-0.0911673828959465,
0.28535765409469604,
0.33771079778671265,
0.3265857994556427,
-0.7173555493354797,
-0.278597891330719,
-0.07338263839483261,
-0.45299232006073,
-0.13588856160640717,
0.6800652146339417,
-0.8832165002822876,
0.6849250197410583,
0.4996817409992218,
0.8328567147254944,
0.8745123147964478,
0.10303151607513428,
0.5135514736175537,
-0.19207744300365448,
-0.06611276417970657,
0.2252216637134552,
0.167867049574852,
0.3349459767341614,
-0.02910650707781315,
0.668502926826477,
0.29050949215888977,
-0.2194957584142685,
-0.6670364737510681,
-0.1458899974822998,
-1.0177249908447266,
-0.2603464424610138,
0.81678307056427,
-0.4612259864807129,
-0.04890229180455208,
-0.3800480365753174,
0.3549239933490753,
0.3680683672428131,
-0.33625757694244385,
0.8069706559181213,
0.6529842615127563,
-0.17540724575519562,
0.28093817830085754,
-0.5519322156906128,
0.33193641901016235,
0.22606413066387177,
-1.2371373176574707,
-0.17538310587406158,
0.4416845142841339,
0.2810647189617157,
0.10564826428890228,
0.6277589201927185,
0.4312409460544586,
0.6676197052001953,
0.38856247067451477,
0.5251387357711792,
-0.000572968740016222,
-0.29805999994277954,
0.11796322464942932,
0.3313632607460022,
-0.1458531767129898,
-0.43703964352607727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12369v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12369v1
|
A Comparative Study of Continuous Sign Language Recognition Techniques
| 2024-06-18T07:51:44 | 2024-06-18T07:51:44 |
Sarah Alyami, Hamzah Luqman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Continuous Sign Language Recognition (CSLR) focuses on the interpretation of
a sequence of sign language gestures performed continually without pauses. In
this study, we conduct an empirical evaluation of recent deep learning CSLR
techniques and assess their performance across various datasets and sign
languages. The models selected for analysis implement a range of approaches for
extracting meaningful features and employ distinct training strategies. To
determine their efficacy in modeling different sign languages, these models
were evaluated using multiple datasets, specifically RWTH-PHOENIX-Weather-2014,
ArabSign, and GrSL, each representing a unique sign language. The performance
of the models was further tested with unseen signers and sentences. The
conducted experiments establish new benchmarks on the selected datasets and
provide valuable insights into the robustness and generalization of the
evaluated techniques under challenging scenarios.
|
[
0.13417664170265198,
-0.10521355271339417,
0.24781213700771332,
0.07440482079982758,
-0.361599862575531,
0.6303105354309082,
-0.3461041748523712,
-0.8462736010551453,
-0.30461084842681885,
0.18308806419372559,
-0.37295031547546387,
-0.5836588144302368,
-0.729846715927124,
0.15936748683452606,
-0.43499019742012024,
0.5153600573539734,
-0.060603681951761246,
0.730027437210083,
0.1842862218618393,
-0.3050028085708618,
-0.2536599040031433,
-0.26399391889572144,
-0.9007975459098816,
-0.4260731041431427,
0.11789696663618088,
0.23011155426502228,
0.6563252806663513,
0.10471532493829727,
0.7155341506004333,
0.1992366909980774,
-0.31460246443748474,
0.057994190603494644,
-0.26558491587638855,
-0.021894529461860657,
0.40107834339141846,
0.30435049533843994,
0.23254849016666412,
-0.04126125946640968,
0.8410491943359375,
0.9499500393867493,
0.09910985082387924,
0.22558560967445374,
0.11830784380435944,
0.4601350724697113,
-0.5727585554122925,
-0.17290042340755463,
-0.3096187114715576,
0.5728232860565186,
-0.2037830352783203,
0.4559181332588196,
-0.5164958834648132,
-0.5294522643089294,
0.32512032985687256,
-0.30299463868141174,
0.22189410030841827,
-0.1809096336364746,
0.8062291741371155,
0.03796755149960518,
-0.2234860062599182,
-0.7655563950538635,
-0.8007553815841675,
0.926402747631073,
-1.0224641561508179,
1.00572669506073,
-0.04951143264770508,
0.5151658058166504,
0.1192891001701355,
-0.7239327430725098,
-0.46844935417175293,
-0.8241702914237976,
-0.17182683944702148,
0.07759789377450943,
0.19467951357364655,
0.012450856156647205,
0.3278917968273163,
0.4584595263004303,
-0.8674557209014893,
0.5349388718605042,
-0.6043029427528381,
-0.32453131675720215,
0.6722750067710876,
0.3295830190181732,
0.3017244338989258,
0.23960065841674805,
-0.42320752143859863,
-0.34771808981895447,
-0.4126763939857483,
0.5857982635498047,
0.03990819305181503,
0.6218815445899963,
-0.572492778301239,
0.32343390583992004,
-0.227572962641716,
0.9151654839515686,
-0.08792538940906525,
-0.3298361301422119,
0.2652919292449951,
-0.10506532341241837,
-0.3366996645927429,
-0.3350185453891754,
0.8331676721572876,
-0.0666571781039238,
0.4827340245246887,
-0.29965612292289734,
-0.05763572081923485,
0.07046423852443695,
-0.3996599614620209,
-0.5726497769355774,
-0.15180382132530212,
-0.0006178747862577438,
-0.6764690279960632,
-0.17297270894050598,
0.14500555396080017,
-0.2443799078464508,
-0.8473823666572571,
-0.6634868383407593,
-0.28584814071655273,
-0.29501762986183167,
-0.5770465731620789,
0.2333705723285675,
-0.2726181447505951,
0.5592844486236572,
0.23780092597007751,
-0.4156191945075989,
0.5192591547966003,
0.6285694241523743,
0.8085176944732666,
-0.6444362998008728,
0.15846870839595795,
-0.37936365604400635,
-0.5321694016456604,
-0.28061169385910034,
0.35704419016838074,
-0.8415484428405762,
-0.4139153063297272,
-0.01705353334546089,
-0.14635320007801056,
-0.13990913331508636,
-0.28055453300476074,
0.5044898986816406,
-0.6206128597259521,
-0.18485450744628906,
-0.2706683576107025,
-0.498643159866333,
-0.011086050420999527,
-0.06534816324710846,
-0.7985254526138306,
0.8889657258987427,
-0.2281762659549713,
-0.1581118106842041,
0.8835214972496033,
-0.42868295311927795,
-0.6030430793762207,
0.3720184564590454,
-0.3007216155529022,
-0.7862151265144348,
0.15807181596755981,
-0.08987721800804138,
0.6457974910736084,
0.05204334110021591,
-0.27646708488464355,
-0.21389886736869812,
-0.5152654051780701,
0.603269100189209,
-0.48210516571998596,
0.8126580715179443,
0.5772647261619568,
-0.4121965169906616,
-0.24034763872623444,
-1.017163872718811,
0.2727891802787781,
-0.15887285768985748,
-0.4150220453739166,
0.031521689146757126,
0.09246473759412766,
0.1693384051322937,
0.41749629378318787,
-0.06983701884746552,
-0.700959324836731,
-0.25043785572052,
-0.19491101801395416,
0.2888036370277405,
0.32835522294044495,
-0.1838769018650055,
0.20079392194747925,
0.47288718819618225,
0.6010342836380005,
-0.04697247967123985,
0.3235347270965576,
0.12577034533023834,
-0.19624285399913788,
-0.8186348080635071,
-0.2853565514087677,
0.17814159393310547,
0.42283737659454346,
-0.07494029402732849,
-0.11466465890407562,
-0.13098491728305817,
-0.5805293917655945,
-0.3184032738208771,
0.11921095848083496,
1.058307409286499,
0.16129253804683685,
0.2731519639492035,
-0.6315885186195374,
-0.5948412418365479,
-0.29802390933036804,
-0.20912843942642212,
0.06904983520507812,
0.29431623220443726,
0.0776047632098198,
0.26393434405326843,
0.40760350227355957,
0.3598344922065735,
-0.03905320167541504,
0.033716730773448944,
-0.25118687748908997,
0.08811253309249878,
0.34480157494544983,
0.31501320004463196,
0.324659526348114,
-0.7126801013946533,
-0.8398107290267944,
0.4725804328918457,
-0.7861345410346985,
0.4509131610393524,
-0.5143664479255676,
0.6410972476005554,
0.2190379500389099,
0.6317833662033081,
-0.1526939570903778,
0.7555416226387024,
0.693640947341919,
-0.43191421031951904,
0.6115438342094421,
0.16063982248306274,
0.2700602114200592,
-0.12462970614433289,
0.09968874603509903,
-0.05065710097551346,
-0.12328971922397614,
-0.9539090991020203,
0.09475938230752945,
0.21233347058296204,
-0.45708298683166504,
-0.8584267497062683,
0.3799715042114258,
-1.1895688772201538,
-0.5858411192893982,
-0.23019114136695862,
0.009864188730716705,
-0.2930312752723694,
0.2113329917192459,
0.4362781047821045,
0.6561223268508911,
0.6506294012069702,
-0.8462164998054504,
-0.07040981948375702,
0.032606784254312515,
-0.6543800830841064,
0.1448960304260254,
-0.620491623878479,
0.4680210053920746,
0.0010485310340300202,
-0.07580198347568512,
-1.355926752090454,
0.1959255486726761,
0.3374689519405365,
-0.5990831851959229,
0.35252344608306885,
0.04816215857863426,
-0.11457955092191696,
-0.6701584458351135,
-0.01610896736383438,
0.1307583749294281,
0.7100646495819092,
-0.3882618248462677,
0.5854568481445312,
-0.09624659270048141,
0.3677823841571808,
-0.7774690985679626,
-0.8630237579345703,
0.046233344823122025,
-0.19212546944618225,
-0.1577126681804657,
-0.20792463421821594,
0.06333038955926895,
-0.3016863167285919,
-0.5168214440345764,
-0.11626721173524857,
-0.11046157032251358,
0.28951966762542725,
0.4244905412197113,
-0.13113310933113098,
-0.19860544800758362,
-0.14827416837215424,
-0.19268545508384705,
-0.11134389787912369,
-0.32167649269104004,
0.10628147423267365,
0.3873666822910309,
-0.23542135953903198,
-0.6325139403343201,
-0.9790037274360657,
0.011586837470531464,
0.5605936050415039,
-0.27049946784973145,
0.5319681167602539,
0.44264113903045654,
-0.15879839658737183,
0.12225838750600815,
-0.47836360335350037,
0.11495934426784515,
-0.43117377161979675,
0.021489281207323074,
-0.5249038338661194,
-0.9627361297607422,
0.5308299660682678,
-0.12584790587425232,
0.39898917078971863,
-0.06355622410774231,
0.31282690167427063,
-0.19934462010860443,
0.8102221488952637,
0.5337743163108826,
-0.10324306786060333,
0.5326988697052002,
0.05729438364505768,
0.26630696654319763,
-0.5452906489372253,
-0.2383774071931839,
-0.5107269883155823,
-0.20607438683509827,
-0.09519387036561966,
-0.21603631973266602,
0.01773815229535103,
0.14058414101600647,
-0.18938417732715607,
0.7247269749641418,
-0.5996826887130737,
0.36053043603897095,
-0.10484668612480164,
0.2058526873588562,
0.4217458963394165,
-0.03325343504548073,
-0.2028559148311615,
-0.14819292724132538,
-0.28090977668762207,
-0.6419121623039246,
1.0189348459243774,
0.30368757247924805,
0.33080294728279114,
0.04683371260762215,
0.3582824468612671,
0.4078930616378784,
0.3482297658920288,
-0.5460659265518188,
0.5240976810455322,
-0.26460590958595276,
-0.21844784915447235,
-0.42384621500968933,
0.014643429778516293,
-1.044392466545105,
0.492557555437088,
-0.35630670189857483,
-0.40825924277305603,
0.34017783403396606,
0.19386529922485352,
-0.42121851444244385,
0.17345231771469116,
-0.6424004435539246,
0.5444570183753967,
-0.5364387035369873,
0.09846332669258118,
-0.24995958805084229,
-0.6972740292549133,
0.2133697122335434,
0.00717474240809679,
0.3308050334453583,
-0.1455516666173935,
0.1747961938381195,
0.4251895844936371,
-0.14668093621730804,
1.1146512031555176,
-0.304868221282959,
-0.1986330896615982,
0.24482981860637665,
-0.01979842409491539,
0.47450122237205505,
-0.20777370035648346,
-0.45049092173576355,
0.29488903284072876,
-0.17147505283355713,
-0.265848308801651,
-0.27625229954719543,
0.4277862012386322,
-0.5976178646087646,
0.15615084767341614,
-0.5044153928756714,
0.003681804984807968,
-0.09468977898359299,
0.11187390238046646,
0.06715307384729385,
0.39746102690696716,
-0.6152402758598328,
-0.06904838234186172,
0.4595629572868347,
-0.09887991100549698,
0.8689165711402893,
0.802619218826294,
0.053482137620449066,
-0.318159282207489,
0.5014969706535339,
-0.048559755086898804,
0.5472255945205688,
0.23888647556304932,
0.15306030213832855,
-0.194451242685318,
-1.0621522665023804,
-0.2780127227306366,
-0.005836868658661842,
-0.8210194706916809,
0.08906487375497818,
-0.2017160952091217,
-0.05726339668035507,
-0.5905280113220215,
-0.1605067402124405,
-0.09445953369140625,
-0.44101423025131226,
-0.16570807993412018,
-0.24566568434238434,
0.3222189247608185,
0.4585484564304352,
-0.16389349102973938,
0.25717365741729736,
-0.44655629992485046,
0.15966840088367462,
0.04859278351068497,
0.02555578202009201,
0.2740091383457184,
-0.3280865252017975,
-0.1947617530822754,
-0.026759320870041847,
0.038781650364398956,
-0.5092284083366394,
-0.049163978546857834,
0.5357430577278137,
0.45350193977355957,
0.6821016669273376,
-0.12227686494588852,
0.8640089631080627,
-0.3654335141181946,
0.9131379723548889,
0.7216924428939819,
-0.8867977261543274,
0.20960582792758942,
-0.030209504067897797,
0.41782665252685547,
0.7278345227241516,
0.3166845142841339,
-0.7381072044372559,
-0.27067896723747253,
-0.273896723985672,
-0.598900556564331,
0.02360820211470127,
0.3427634835243225,
-0.00103278539609164,
0.11969783157110214,
0.3755856156349182,
0.3365117907524109,
-0.050385184586048126,
-0.8694515228271484,
-0.06655150651931763,
-0.03359082713723183,
-0.18038904666900635,
0.19345656037330627,
0.21114730834960938,
0.2895883321762085,
-0.34665045142173767,
0.21829549968242645,
0.02412569709122181,
-0.09622660279273987,
-0.06064344942569733,
-0.39742112159729004,
0.1179521307349205,
0.13969764113426208,
0.8505721092224121,
0.8203036785125732,
0.37466558814048767,
-0.22632142901420593,
0.632401704788208,
-0.7662177681922913,
-0.029272273182868958,
-0.3062533736228943,
-0.17752738296985626,
0.2797389626502991,
0.6531281471252441,
0.9312292337417603,
0.1669677495956421,
-0.9063382148742676,
0.36557525396347046,
-0.08814851939678192,
-0.11852826923131943,
-0.8485060334205627,
0.012683835811913013,
-0.2851879894733429,
0.18640445172786713,
0.267614483833313,
0.07085726410150528,
0.18144240975379944,
-0.25757691264152527,
0.14051397144794464,
0.6163650751113892,
-0.7738269567489624,
-0.25478455424308777,
0.32044100761413574,
0.0702642947435379,
-0.3403814435005188,
0.7124660015106201,
0.11876606941223145,
-0.25797808170318604,
0.6607576608657837,
0.14133457839488983,
0.7749232649803162,
-0.2510237395763397,
0.2871815264225006,
0.62043297290802,
0.14937937259674072,
0.09595177322626114,
0.409641832113266,
-0.5994067788124084,
-0.6649217009544373,
-0.5924201011657715,
-0.39762791991233826,
-0.6168744564056396,
0.023145053535699844,
-0.7608304023742676,
0.36278191208839417,
-0.7820661067962646,
-0.04246130585670471,
-0.042535364627838135,
-0.033479977399110794,
-0.9014908671379089,
0.6382239460945129,
0.5858917236328125,
0.7367121577262878,
-1.0810664892196655,
0.5749841332435608,
0.33896663784980774,
-0.2754691243171692,
-0.6750966906547546,
-0.19418954849243164,
0.13073483109474182,
-0.8880517482757568,
0.9061081409454346,
0.09090636670589447,
-0.5043986439704895,
-0.20076726377010345,
-0.5269365310668945,
-0.9712699055671692,
0.909295916557312,
-0.16614210605621338,
-0.9943111538887024,
0.3299742639064789,
0.6518707871437073,
0.7517393231391907,
-0.1524573564529419,
0.1756974160671234,
0.787262499332428,
0.4225188195705414,
0.07533733546733856,
-0.9406414031982422,
0.1162010133266449,
0.04250442609190941,
0.054577119648456573,
0.07637587934732437,
-0.48252546787261963,
0.30193430185317993,
-0.2347882091999054,
-0.6933069825172424,
0.5618990063667297,
0.9984689950942993,
0.5799135565757751,
0.425136923789978,
0.4683472812175751,
0.3585999310016632,
0.8853429555892944,
-0.13675256073474884,
0.6612749695777893,
-0.14117193222045898,
0.2918139696121216,
0.8465215563774109,
-0.569007933139801,
0.8726646304130554,
0.36446383595466614,
-0.3527005910873413,
0.5555630326271057,
0.4671288728713989,
-0.17002080380916595,
0.5978696346282959,
0.5715765357017517,
-0.31783249974250793,
-0.36787325143814087,
0.25091272592544556,
-0.23959419131278992,
0.19405145943164825,
0.42692646384239197,
-0.43071091175079346,
-0.16419504582881927,
0.5842849016189575,
0.10547541826963425,
0.32980072498321533,
-0.3033885359764099,
0.6765009164810181,
0.38189586997032166,
-0.3554825782775879,
0.6054718494415283,
-0.3799479305744171,
0.671285092830658,
-0.5247364044189453,
-0.023614484816789627,
-0.06945831328630447,
0.33360782265663147,
-0.3330364525318146,
-0.6291829347610474,
0.24454958736896515,
0.07999320328235626,
0.26997122168540955,
-0.42149460315704346,
0.8388141989707947,
0.1446138620376587,
-0.4896676540374756,
0.20494413375854492,
-0.061136554926633835,
0.5774575471878052,
0.5375156402587891,
-0.9767096042633057,
0.4922187328338623,
-0.17226539552211761,
0.06889836490154266,
0.039084888994693756,
0.12545375525951385,
-0.06598029285669327,
0.616067111492157,
0.7960327863693237,
0.009017969481647015,
0.18049411475658417,
0.395098477602005,
0.5736796855926514,
-0.6947629451751709,
-0.26849356293678284,
-0.5853224992752075,
0.7650715112686157,
-0.36101385951042175,
-0.8587602972984314,
0.9195253252983093,
0.5356736183166504,
0.6844643950462341,
-0.308142751455307,
0.7438865303993225,
-0.024896996095776558,
0.6832029819488525,
-0.6892874836921692,
0.537209689617157,
0.041045382618904114,
0.029044153168797493,
-0.42594245076179504,
-0.3414722979068756,
-0.6325255036354065,
0.6186964511871338,
-0.24861803650856018,
0.021001165732741356,
0.5902972221374512,
0.5047385692596436,
0.05853300541639328,
0.03865234553813934,
0.3543814420700073,
-0.4446502923965454,
0.22055885195732117,
0.5973569750785828,
0.9259823560714722,
-0.655250608921051,
0.44952550530433655,
0.10212830454111099,
0.11119517683982849,
0.0871611163020134,
-0.8916326761245728,
-1.1007405519485474,
-0.47400322556495667,
-0.7263748645782471,
-0.31167852878570557,
0.1965789645910263,
0.522966206073761,
0.8694274425506592,
-1.0663541555404663,
-0.4233514070510864,
-0.2837892770767212,
-0.35087132453918457,
-0.8420257568359375,
-0.17473727464675903,
0.44719478487968445,
-0.20549993216991425,
-0.37811532616615295,
0.8553000688552856,
-0.20196637511253357,
0.2409997135400772,
-0.12358613312244415,
-0.5148091912269592,
0.24022503197193146,
-0.21375109255313873,
0.5623236894607544,
0.9387269020080566,
-0.7705227136611938,
-0.27171117067337036,
0.03225092962384224,
0.0021139122545719147,
-0.10201422870159149,
0.9416681528091431,
-0.7212826013565063,
0.13683263957500458,
0.4846007227897644,
0.43622061610221863,
0.6004515886306763,
-0.09532688558101654,
0.2812313139438629,
-0.5538595914840698,
0.1516636461019516,
0.27391764521598816,
0.04730673506855965,
0.49620407819747925,
-0.2915463447570801,
0.5444822907447815,
-0.05152997374534607,
-0.10683748871088028,
-0.7757981419563293,
0.4612290561199188,
-1.1220753192901611,
-0.34407275915145874,
1.0710948705673218,
-0.25495773553848267,
0.27123650908470154,
-0.4901299774646759,
0.1513347178697586,
0.02860267274081707,
-0.08854866772890091,
0.2564852833747864,
0.39158883690834045,
-0.37013471126556396,
-0.5389357805252075,
-0.2856135964393616,
0.5935606360435486,
0.23505258560180664,
-0.21036070585250854,
-0.1257959008216858,
0.44717925786972046,
0.44474658370018005,
0.07834334671497345,
0.6002576947212219,
-0.2990822196006775,
0.4513276219367981,
-0.3048625588417053,
0.15888890624046326,
-0.11027552932500839,
-0.0427299365401268,
-0.6627805829048157,
0.20155872404575348,
0.14750432968139648,
-0.20185285806655884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12364v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12364v1
|
Does Context Help Mitigate Gender Bias in Neural Machine Translation?
| 2024-06-18T07:44:13 | 2024-06-18T07:44:13 |
Harritxu Gete, Thierry Etchegoyhen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Neural Machine Translation models tend to perpetuate gender bias present in
their training data distribution. Context-aware models have been previously
suggested as a means to mitigate this type of bias. In this work, we examine
this claim by analysing in detail the translation of stereotypical professions
in English to German, and translation with non-informative context in Basque to
Spanish. Our results show that, although context-aware models can significantly
enhance translation accuracy for feminine terms, they can still maintain or
even amplify gender bias. These results highlight the need for more
fine-grained approaches to bias mitigation in Neural Machine Translation.
|
[
-0.22289417684078217,
-0.6393793225288391,
0.4147195816040039,
0.2954610586166382,
0.025017185136675835,
-0.5182133316993713,
-0.13308271765708923,
-0.4107425808906555,
-0.2809422016143799,
0.5277422070503235,
-0.771149754524231,
-0.38046276569366455,
-0.7628707885742188,
0.34173333644866943,
-0.5830903053283691,
0.8927583694458008,
0.05855605751276016,
0.7006005048751831,
-0.18152233958244324,
-0.17074891924858093,
-1.0340138673782349,
-0.7199053168296814,
-0.5438504815101624,
-0.6587650179862976,
0.254730224609375,
0.023917172104120255,
0.6319867372512817,
0.5590500831604004,
0.2851465940475464,
0.2274123579263687,
-0.360792338848114,
0.15879428386688232,
-0.20688410103321075,
0.2767389714717865,
-0.19179604947566986,
-0.7021270394325256,
-0.49896666407585144,
-0.0031448311638087034,
0.676234245300293,
0.9998594522476196,
0.15128521621227264,
0.04115922376513481,
0.06272309273481369,
0.7205492854118347,
-0.4389280378818512,
-0.11868259310722351,
-0.6549060344696045,
0.44228628277778625,
-0.0373544879257679,
-0.31381115317344666,
-0.5245966911315918,
-0.051641639322042465,
0.3795132339000702,
-0.3209363520145416,
0.49548062682151794,
0.053698085248470306,
0.45700153708457947,
0.4404425323009491,
-0.968726396560669,
-0.11252573877573013,
-0.8373100757598877,
0.8345447778701782,
-0.6279658675193787,
0.3371499478816986,
0.38287848234176636,
0.4577803313732147,
-0.19397766888141632,
-0.21644552052021027,
-0.1401507705450058,
0.1338210254907608,
-0.28903135657310486,
-0.049767352640628815,
-0.38919034600257874,
-0.08699469268321991,
0.35826271772384644,
-0.15181219577789307,
-0.1350329965353012,
0.04438098147511482,
-0.42822471261024475,
-0.17184476554393768,
0.37090548872947693,
0.11018124967813492,
0.6556162238121033,
-0.2718586027622223,
-0.28174230456352234,
0.046391505748033524,
-0.8979974389076233,
-0.10157767683267593,
0.5417910814285278,
0.37400102615356445,
-0.023285429924726486,
0.4667746126651764,
-0.06885585188865662,
0.633050799369812,
0.03751145303249359,
0.03618689998984337,
0.15470732748508453,
-0.2443314641714096,
-0.2061547338962555,
0.3665356934070587,
0.3878514766693115,
0.5491092801094055,
0.34562501311302185,
-0.37772810459136963,
-0.2082386165857315,
-0.1609175056219101,
0.5080455541610718,
-0.6381396055221558,
0.20019148290157318,
-0.03255082294344902,
-0.507125973701477,
-0.40957459807395935,
-0.1672292798757553,
-0.4962255358695984,
-0.258094847202301,
-0.3699673116207123,
0.15979839861392975,
-0.19653144478797913,
-0.06208004802465439,
0.06416860967874527,
-0.45684173703193665,
0.05579761043190956,
0.35205888748168945,
-1.0216522216796875,
0.060866355895996094,
0.549548327922821,
0.6812570095062256,
0.25137200951576233,
-0.1884450763463974,
-0.2145642191171646,
0.24049057066440582,
-0.6019136905670166,
0.3031662702560425,
-0.3248668611049652,
-0.36480358242988586,
-0.12891624867916107,
0.12338059395551682,
-0.22899901866912842,
-0.4739089012145996,
0.40334752202033997,
-0.3523222506046295,
0.3237426280975342,
-0.5248054265975952,
-0.10884853452444077,
-0.19968755543231964,
0.13210232555866241,
-0.5082776546478271,
0.7463456988334656,
0.016643667593598366,
-1.0250085592269897,
0.49594637751579285,
-0.5910564661026001,
-0.6103344559669495,
-0.5289624333381653,
-0.2135576605796814,
-0.172311931848526,
0.317507266998291,
0.45955467224121094,
0.28388968110084534,
-0.21195705235004425,
0.5228105187416077,
0.04710863158106804,
-0.32871800661087036,
0.522932767868042,
-0.5882443785667419,
0.6960436701774597,
0.020268958061933517,
-0.7060957551002502,
0.24708402156829834,
0.038669418543577194,
-0.34796395897865295,
-0.10406116396188736,
-0.02411501854658127,
-0.6488184332847595,
-0.033392444252967834,
0.17292192578315735,
0.695038378238678,
-0.08585023880004883,
-0.2268051952123642,
-0.028953881934285164,
-0.3944013714790344,
0.7186591625213623,
0.663378119468689,
-0.4124414920806885,
1.1080864667892456,
-0.10089514404535294,
0.5142830014228821,
0.26652225852012634,
-0.06742894649505615,
0.1229758933186531,
-0.5502876043319702,
-0.5468986630439758,
-0.2425788938999176,
0.44653934240341187,
0.6339375376701355,
-0.7687150835990906,
0.4216175079345703,
-0.24828840792179108,
-0.18820808827877045,
-0.582892119884491,
0.05758553743362427,
0.7001861333847046,
1.0227795839309692,
0.4629576504230499,
-0.06831154227256775,
-0.5981931090354919,
-1.3572607040405273,
-0.5785570740699768,
0.4015006422996521,
-0.2260088324546814,
0.4458795189857483,
0.6270819306373596,
-0.48346519470214844,
0.9804778099060059,
-0.18124490976333618,
-0.3538137972354889,
-0.13966012001037598,
0.05249405652284622,
0.0001775968266883865,
0.7382286190986633,
0.8906123042106628,
-0.9347890615463257,
0.09912360459566116,
-0.16840842366218567,
-0.8731588125228882,
-0.2590939700603485,
-0.0482422411441803,
-0.6020871996879578,
0.162260502576828,
0.5230885744094849,
-0.4330044984817505,
0.3207261562347412,
0.5413011908531189,
-0.6333609819412231,
0.1823563426733017,
-0.22854366898536682,
0.07448481768369675,
-1.1214258670806885,
0.36202293634414673,
0.0006722937105223536,
-0.5909792184829712,
-0.7901648283004761,
-0.06759855151176453,
0.15674754977226257,
0.20296244323253632,
-0.5583080649375916,
0.7747333645820618,
-0.3349342346191406,
-0.26375478506088257,
-0.2931087613105774,
0.024203423410654068,
-0.04547754302620888,
-0.06977921724319458,
0.2614365816116333,
0.923462450504303,
0.2595861554145813,
-0.7857101559638977,
-0.49552950263023376,
0.4765995740890503,
0.012692918069660664,
0.7031627893447876,
-0.5137972831726074,
0.02326817624270916,
-0.41469356417655945,
0.5485115051269531,
-0.6827815175056458,
-0.20677243173122406,
0.18499699234962463,
-0.43762874603271484,
0.19645965099334717,
-0.257669597864151,
-0.2566346824169159,
-0.13208022713661194,
0.02000052109360695,
0.2888757288455963,
0.34280431270599365,
-0.4622725248336792,
0.24996758997440338,
0.26400935649871826,
0.10262078791856766,
-0.9722182154655457,
-1.322753667831421,
0.08003835380077362,
-0.3555213212966919,
-0.5479393005371094,
0.598207950592041,
0.1258831024169922,
-0.23857896029949188,
-0.2622695565223694,
-0.2924579381942749,
-0.09215470403432846,
0.40235698223114014,
0.08235672116279602,
0.24343693256378174,
-0.03966489061713219,
0.16479375958442688,
0.38343340158462524,
-0.022312598302960396,
0.10505534708499908,
-0.3452218770980835,
0.5985395908355713,
0.004385081119835377,
-0.07902970910072327,
-0.1443164050579071,
0.4572871923446655,
0.5682970881462097,
0.032320138067007065,
0.9620747566223145,
0.6839228272438049,
-0.5594760775566101,
-0.16239698231220245,
-0.2690166234970093,
-0.6503750085830688,
-0.4269130229949951,
0.4011825919151306,
-0.4418301284313202,
-0.9226253628730774,
0.6268843412399292,
0.004696979187428951,
-0.19653677940368652,
0.5706678032875061,
0.39923474192619324,
-0.3222648501396179,
1.4298142194747925,
0.6168832182884216,
-0.03167419135570526,
0.5134763717651367,
-0.056992389261722565,
0.13811875879764557,
-1.1461766958236694,
-0.0052156164310872555,
-0.6411287784576416,
-0.7036941647529602,
-0.7105480432510376,
-0.24178671836853027,
0.2750477194786072,
0.18140241503715515,
-0.28996869921684265,
0.31581029295921326,
-0.6213781833648682,
0.21111898124217987,
0.618227481842041,
0.0994361937046051,
0.12457823753356934,
0.025858953595161438,
0.05620685592293739,
-0.3936239182949066,
-0.8760637044906616,
-0.7352654933929443,
1.0792421102523804,
0.5211899876594543,
0.14935162663459778,
0.20214088261127472,
0.3198168873786926,
0.31372272968292236,
0.3158751428127289,
-0.27730369567871094,
0.31799864768981934,
-0.47476035356521606,
-1.094014286994934,
-0.06473658978939056,
-0.585360050201416,
-0.8245450258255005,
0.2600422501564026,
-0.19690774381160736,
-0.6694028377532959,
0.5130125880241394,
0.28440412878990173,
0.20216549932956696,
0.24357570707798004,
-0.5602417588233948,
0.9547854065895081,
-0.20622222125530243,
-0.23035883903503418,
0.09963838011026382,
-0.6548993587493896,
0.4927894175052643,
-0.08042153716087341,
0.32021158933639526,
0.0010850679827854037,
-0.07906503975391388,
0.5766249299049377,
-0.18570007383823395,
1.0331000089645386,
-0.22571493685245514,
-0.13357652723789215,
-0.23010334372520447,
0.20156599581241608,
0.22010959684848785,
0.00687893433496356,
-0.1309385895729065,
0.45791107416152954,
-0.17198561131954193,
-0.451332151889801,
-0.29213398694992065,
0.4260100722312927,
-0.7744367718696594,
-0.5159039497375488,
-0.12002535164356232,
-1.0595653057098389,
-0.04103785753250122,
0.28523313999176025,
0.5741595029830933,
0.14726665616035461,
-0.1768869310617447,
0.11305259168148041,
0.6613237857818604,
-0.21437576413154602,
0.24230153858661652,
0.3099387288093567,
-0.09817440062761307,
-0.10489363968372345,
0.17856371402740479,
0.15157730877399445,
0.19602687656879425,
0.1846296191215515,
0.1281091719865799,
-0.2431543469429016,
-0.1355964094400406,
-0.8065085411071777,
-0.08498493582010269,
-0.9634572267532349,
-0.03652629256248474,
-0.9063199162483215,
0.08666065335273743,
-0.5246469378471375,
-0.3680128753185272,
-0.29159557819366455,
-0.5877583622932434,
-0.10090122371912003,
-0.019924001768231392,
0.27343472838401794,
0.44656866788864136,
0.40494805574417114,
0.700176477432251,
-0.4637487530708313,
0.12671631574630737,
0.10058565437793732,
-0.17238955199718475,
-0.24060551822185516,
-0.6505002975463867,
0.17849645018577576,
0.223244771361351,
-0.03594715893268585,
-1.0734797716140747,
0.8166157007217407,
-0.062485355883836746,
0.5247107744216919,
0.2084667682647705,
-0.22981461882591248,
0.3204793632030487,
-0.6284982562065125,
0.6545023322105408,
0.07186108082532883,
-1.1746076345443726,
0.6662073731422424,
-0.7102270126342773,
0.4672618806362152,
0.41476109623908997,
0.2792443037033081,
-0.7570134401321411,
-0.28084778785705566,
-0.31162700057029724,
-0.8909425735473633,
0.7803373336791992,
0.24374699592590332,
0.6111122369766235,
-0.06404063105583191,
0.48931261897087097,
0.12540499866008759,
0.7407671213150024,
-0.7330800890922546,
-0.31784337759017944,
-0.13447338342666626,
-0.14201204478740692,
-0.07706384360790253,
-0.15684932470321655,
-0.42415133118629456,
-0.37701836228370667,
0.579036295413971,
-0.15312212705612183,
0.6042614579200745,
0.28290724754333496,
-0.3274412453174591,
0.07787331193685532,
0.4598446190357208,
0.9105749726295471,
0.48157697916030884,
-0.1817365288734436,
0.1569863110780716,
0.41511785984039307,
-0.3417000472545624,
0.17129038274288177,
-0.1575898379087448,
-0.86512291431427,
0.27480456233024597,
0.31529471278190613,
0.8320544362068176,
0.4030311703681946,
-0.3618800640106201,
0.4090821146965027,
0.012142742983996868,
-0.25390443205833435,
-0.14589394629001617,
-0.017116116359829903,
0.2806141972541809,
0.3023805022239685,
0.2959730923175812,
0.5792837142944336,
0.3291812241077423,
-0.45532146096229553,
-0.12079235166311264,
0.42987632751464844,
-0.5038737654685974,
-0.098171167075634,
0.944648265838623,
0.25013643503189087,
-0.22485487163066864,
0.5521848201751709,
0.1800030916929245,
-0.8461898565292358,
0.9771924614906311,
0.961051881313324,
1.0240542888641357,
-0.3392578959465027,
-0.02226865477859974,
0.3475904166698456,
0.5732608437538147,
-0.38721174001693726,
0.09195996820926666,
-0.012520071119070053,
-0.7655591368675232,
-0.07588478922843933,
-0.25782719254493713,
-0.16925759613513947,
-0.35215094685554504,
-0.5545967221260071,
0.2732701897621155,
-0.057385917752981186,
-0.5251080989837646,
-0.19676955044269562,
-0.6989905834197998,
-0.8617900013923645,
0.28281015157699585,
0.05431869626045227,
0.8346303701400757,
-1.056300401687622,
0.9235116243362427,
0.8236787915229797,
-0.293563574552536,
-0.40337103605270386,
-0.020619219169020653,
-0.0032637605909258127,
-0.21677745878696442,
1.157625675201416,
0.3995758891105652,
-0.3021964132785797,
-0.11938893049955368,
-0.19615933299064636,
-0.7151609063148499,
1.1107743978500366,
0.6987990736961365,
-0.48871904611587524,
-0.1653401106595993,
0.21340911090373993,
0.4824278950691223,
-0.5846678018569946,
0.37691056728363037,
0.536638617515564,
0.652895987033844,
-0.4616915285587311,
-1.066146731376648,
0.01766497828066349,
-0.2963641583919525,
0.30958762764930725,
-0.10253186523914337,
-0.04510568082332611,
0.9650006890296936,
0.26830825209617615,
0.1371975839138031,
-0.3285573422908783,
0.2714232802391052,
-0.0338229276239872,
0.4340459108352661,
0.3972136378288269,
0.05006522312760353,
0.7280391454696655,
-0.2799433171749115,
1.1334294080734253,
-0.22298572957515717,
-0.07870197296142578,
1.1824508905410767,
-0.11941944807767868,
0.5672462582588196,
0.6690168976783752,
0.31759777665138245,
0.25378456711769104,
0.5157805681228638,
0.21730004251003265,
0.48300331830978394,
-0.002696454059332609,
-0.22462429106235504,
-0.16260701417922974,
-0.29597753286361694,
-0.5630569458007812,
0.5795437097549438,
0.21527449786663055,
-1.0616592168807983,
0.009136823937296867,
0.27549251914024353,
0.3371143341064453,
0.19929824769496918,
-0.208903506398201,
0.4868607521057129,
0.2503797709941864,
-0.7084931135177612,
0.3825967311859131,
0.42186036705970764,
1.0059958696365356,
-0.33523446321487427,
0.13960708677768707,
-0.2283497303724289,
0.22405236959457397,
-0.28868043422698975,
-0.3043366074562073,
0.5978169441223145,
-0.02605513669550419,
-0.7013026475906372,
-0.5696604251861572,
0.9435326457023621,
-0.5561768412590027,
-0.3880154490470886,
0.36547067761421204,
0.7209922671318054,
-0.040400903671979904,
-0.12322968989610672,
-0.5297363996505737,
-0.4632662236690521,
-0.07086165994405746,
-0.12654966115951538,
0.35801124572753906,
0.09467408061027527,
-0.49791279435157776,
0.6903531551361084,
0.5179538130760193,
0.00008884593262337148,
0.22070398926734924,
0.011840625666081905,
0.4698576033115387,
-0.4387524127960205,
-0.5615531206130981,
-1.0808470249176025,
0.44063130021095276,
-0.15650328993797302,
-0.3376985192298889,
0.8545205593109131,
0.31910836696624756,
0.7881007790565491,
-0.427956223487854,
0.608869194984436,
0.2487916499376297,
0.08246229588985443,
-0.3886875808238983,
1.1049140691757202,
-0.4338139593601227,
0.22238966822624207,
-0.43101146817207336,
-0.9573784470558167,
-0.4255852997303009,
0.7181336879730225,
-0.8274625539779663,
0.24677634239196777,
0.5125667452812195,
0.6705836057662964,
-0.22115790843963623,
-0.0031353093218058348,
0.24139270186424255,
-0.1345694363117218,
0.01310511864721775,
0.2404525876045227,
0.5644689202308655,
-0.646855354309082,
0.2316274344921112,
-0.19254609942436218,
0.11240513622760773,
-0.2756292223930359,
-1.0921663045883179,
-0.9354180693626404,
-0.2512322962284088,
-0.2256508469581604,
-0.28326815366744995,
0.2857671082019806,
0.7437916994094849,
1.0902442932128906,
-0.5554196834564209,
-0.06999730318784714,
-0.36103498935699463,
0.24894066154956818,
-0.29835930466651917,
-0.1470910906791687,
0.1620682179927826,
-0.35767069458961487,
-0.9168840050697327,
0.44294649362564087,
-0.2115955501794815,
-0.01490357518196106,
-0.27854210138320923,
-0.14821608364582062,
-0.10817930847406387,
0.17267701029777527,
0.47638919949531555,
-0.28611764311790466,
-0.6136560440063477,
-0.20520959794521332,
0.2060299813747406,
-0.4694216549396515,
0.08992661535739899,
0.7895119190216064,
-0.5588201284408569,
0.49932312965393066,
0.6267503499984741,
0.5397160649299622,
0.28103530406951904,
-0.1451469361782074,
1.1116652488708496,
-1.1981403827667236,
0.47042226791381836,
0.08970039337873459,
0.40758243203163147,
0.4963695704936981,
-0.8219379186630249,
0.6397895812988281,
0.11172625422477722,
-0.26002827286720276,
-0.7994203567504883,
0.21077927947044373,
-0.3617408275604248,
-0.5965721011161804,
1.0239437818527222,
0.0068724812008440495,
-0.3281656801700592,
0.056407563388347626,
-0.3406488299369812,
0.5699176788330078,
-0.20562130212783813,
0.6553025245666504,
0.8146429061889648,
0.2889818847179413,
-0.07660786807537079,
-1.3429310321807861,
0.5602666735649109,
0.9684705138206482,
-0.623843252658844,
-0.07404343783855438,
0.3924686312675476,
0.44035083055496216,
-0.05091719701886177,
0.41764751076698303,
-0.13040947914123535,
0.39392581582069397,
-0.23368389904499054,
0.315125048160553,
0.07035703957080841,
-0.2968991696834564,
-0.4670041501522064,
-0.24537867307662964,
-0.19206906855106354,
-0.008180749602615833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12354v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12354v1
|
Cross-Lingual Unlearning of Selective Knowledge in Multilingual Language Models
| 2024-06-18T07:40:18 | 2024-06-18T07:40:18 |
Minseok Choi, Kyunghyun Min, Jaegul Choo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pretrained language models memorize vast amounts of information, including
private and copyrighted data, raising significant safety concerns. Retraining
these models after excluding sensitive data is prohibitively expensive, making
machine unlearning a viable, cost-effective alternative. Previous research has
focused on machine unlearning for monolingual models, but we find that
unlearning in one language does not necessarily transfer to others. This
vulnerability makes models susceptible to low-resource language attacks, where
sensitive information remains accessible in less dominant languages. This paper
presents a pioneering approach to machine unlearning for multilingual language
models, selectively erasing information across different languages while
maintaining overall performance. Specifically, our method employs an adaptive
unlearning scheme that assigns language-dependent weights to address different
language performances of multilingual language models. Empirical results
demonstrate the effectiveness of our framework compared to existing unlearning
baselines, setting a new standard for secure and adaptable multilingual
language models.
|
[
-0.08577492088079453,
-0.542361855506897,
0.006293626967817545,
-0.07019608467817307,
-0.28437384963035583,
0.3429485857486725,
-0.43523970246315,
-0.3740873336791992,
-0.1995326280593872,
0.761502206325531,
-0.4448981285095215,
-0.29818615317344666,
-0.4989085793495178,
-0.22018398344516754,
-0.19000118970870972,
1.0142143964767456,
-0.008665456436574459,
0.21584847569465637,
-0.07388520985841751,
-0.534371018409729,
-0.35831761360168457,
-0.758317232131958,
-0.2677239775657654,
-0.45617592334747314,
0.5827605724334717,
0.4175993502140045,
0.5506247878074646,
0.44215816259384155,
0.19577042758464813,
0.2414204329252243,
-0.005675164982676506,
0.05948745831847191,
-0.704664945602417,
0.18279032409191132,
-0.500105082988739,
-0.4479328989982605,
-0.027249721810221672,
-0.16372646391391754,
0.7522600293159485,
1.0213900804519653,
-0.2678844928741455,
0.11906252056360245,
0.2739536464214325,
0.8259413242340088,
-1.0700970888137817,
-0.06981731951236725,
-1.0026229619979858,
0.17309902608394623,
-0.3264634609222412,
-0.06392641365528107,
-0.7166003584861755,
0.19262045621871948,
-0.04850124940276146,
-0.7275741696357727,
0.14102239906787872,
-0.2385215312242508,
0.5055000185966492,
0.07307954132556915,
-0.3114892244338989,
-0.09198086708784103,
-0.7091614603996277,
1.039932131767273,
-0.21210190653800964,
0.8498197197914124,
0.6021040081977844,
0.16333158314228058,
0.2607141435146332,
-0.5722457766532898,
0.07846863567829132,
0.1619827002286911,
-0.0999152809381485,
0.0949321910738945,
-0.4194067716598511,
-0.2763950824737549,
0.015586871653795242,
-0.043167538940906525,
-0.4944421052932739,
0.34798216819763184,
-0.5649484992027283,
-0.2914115786552429,
0.3698892593383789,
-0.3459516167640686,
0.3435569703578949,
0.09594331681728363,
-0.4580744206905365,
0.01384846679866314,
-0.8370781540870667,
0.004781439900398254,
0.41243982315063477,
0.501539409160614,
-0.07804443687200546,
0.32449665665626526,
-0.18695922195911407,
0.39149099588394165,
-0.13413257896900177,
-0.19263547658920288,
0.3240872919559479,
-0.12184419482946396,
-0.13414590060710907,
0.08196870237588882,
0.674959123134613,
0.004339470528066158,
0.46258604526519775,
-0.5658854246139526,
-0.15855728089809418,
-0.1868763118982315,
0.19195011258125305,
-0.7050080299377441,
-0.2750590145587921,
-0.08731777220964432,
-0.47089919447898865,
-0.11155006289482117,
-0.1523294597864151,
-0.8057904243469238,
-0.39289698004722595,
-0.07532351464033127,
0.3906802833080292,
-0.47673726081848145,
-0.43912774324417114,
-0.11271525174379349,
-0.06299494206905365,
-0.20874638855457306,
-0.00910225324332714,
-1.0059001445770264,
0.11681366711854935,
0.3303847312927246,
0.5131136178970337,
-0.06464776396751404,
-0.697959303855896,
-0.49717000126838684,
0.38624072074890137,
-0.31529903411865234,
0.3906761109828949,
-0.6768726706504822,
-0.372994601726532,
-0.03298962861299515,
0.24358703196048737,
-0.16241420805454254,
-0.5534561276435852,
-0.04609754681587219,
-0.8900061845779419,
0.1985921859741211,
-0.20803329348564148,
-0.39965617656707764,
-0.3562719523906708,
0.03281547874212265,
-0.7248197793960571,
0.7099893093109131,
0.03167906031012535,
-0.8660361170768738,
0.500459611415863,
-0.40876057744026184,
-0.6101577877998352,
-0.18136756122112274,
0.13255123794078827,
-0.4454633891582489,
0.019240787252783775,
0.2453232705593109,
0.24181681871414185,
-0.24392864108085632,
0.2599511742591858,
-0.36066290736198425,
-0.018321750685572624,
0.1574528068304062,
-0.6334356665611267,
1.0966392755508423,
0.47165003418922424,
-0.05603545531630516,
0.053661081939935684,
-0.8523334264755249,
0.1516728550195694,
0.1778535395860672,
-0.4490491449832916,
-0.6161425709724426,
-0.19608192145824432,
0.06571713835000992,
0.1005859225988388,
0.4429294168949127,
-0.4971143305301666,
-0.08821450918912888,
-0.16422870755195618,
0.30792471766471863,
0.7712311744689941,
-0.12788444757461548,
0.7454848885536194,
-0.378064900636673,
0.5504213571548462,
0.13462257385253906,
0.176556795835495,
-0.1359015852212906,
-0.22463145852088928,
-0.49927136301994324,
-0.44888418912887573,
0.47739171981811523,
0.7098557949066162,
-0.7519295811653137,
-0.08525251597166061,
0.03127237781882286,
-0.5765279531478882,
-0.753452718257904,
0.6574358344078064,
0.8120645880699158,
0.34480375051498413,
0.43938761949539185,
-0.21596503257751465,
-0.5383409261703491,
-0.7473236918449402,
-0.6199637055397034,
-0.0949026569724083,
0.05856230482459068,
-0.0476040281355381,
0.3095841109752655,
-0.23023851215839386,
0.5250285863876343,
-0.15367990732192993,
-0.05935603380203247,
-0.4002425968647003,
0.1661638468503952,
-0.3134978711605072,
0.6702236533164978,
0.4402458965778351,
-0.8886150121688843,
-0.5278529524803162,
0.3307980000972748,
-0.8885645866394043,
0.016314497217535973,
-0.022220218554139137,
-0.2315186709165573,
0.42132365703582764,
0.47286105155944824,
-0.18369464576244354,
0.21916277706623077,
0.7048091888427734,
-0.028448842465877533,
0.2116471827030182,
-0.5368350744247437,
-0.08523835241794586,
-0.9271970987319946,
0.32043617963790894,
-0.5030863285064697,
-0.16355666518211365,
-0.899725079536438,
0.26948994398117065,
0.3161376714706421,
-0.13384169340133667,
-0.6477255821228027,
0.7071135640144348,
-0.8351109027862549,
-0.032775942236185074,
-0.27961063385009766,
-0.13034364581108093,
0.054100438952445984,
0.6553492546081543,
0.18700328469276428,
0.3937690556049347,
0.672707736492157,
-0.5231508016586304,
-0.0351930670440197,
0.04929693788290024,
-0.37092339992523193,
0.3841238021850586,
-0.26742544770240784,
0.22931493818759918,
-0.31574785709381104,
-0.26287418603897095,
-0.5019306540489197,
0.06897882372140884,
-0.03519885614514351,
-0.2804795801639557,
0.5159504413604736,
-0.5431711673736572,
-0.14608824253082275,
0.33222681283950806,
-0.09637713432312012,
0.7639455199241638,
0.5231744647026062,
-0.6073144674301147,
0.6050323247909546,
0.873047411441803,
-0.1863505095243454,
-0.909778892993927,
-0.6990596055984497,
-0.11047393828630447,
-0.23259523510932922,
-0.33581751585006714,
0.19817599654197693,
-0.10307293385267258,
-0.23030832409858704,
-0.08460836857557297,
0.008644578978419304,
-0.5918926000595093,
0.3363152742385864,
0.09871257841587067,
0.06715930998325348,
0.04310707375407219,
0.12834511697292328,
0.07740779221057892,
-0.2994866967201233,
-0.20299945771694183,
-0.5296589136123657,
0.5294914841651917,
0.2805696427822113,
-0.5516636371612549,
-0.13962000608444214,
0.6390557885169983,
0.6341602802276611,
-0.6020777225494385,
0.7971131205558777,
0.678150475025177,
-0.7668939828872681,
-0.3905056416988373,
-0.3064824342727661,
-0.029056638479232788,
-0.4502720534801483,
0.4749279320240021,
-0.4110417366027832,
-0.7577822804450989,
0.6567332148551941,
0.11546897143125534,
0.3704361915588379,
0.06785335391759872,
0.5481913089752197,
0.2397496998310089,
1.0420687198638916,
1.0439093112945557,
-0.278567373752594,
0.5886052846908569,
0.1877978891134262,
0.12242939323186874,
-0.4159228205680847,
-0.3030702769756317,
-0.5131940841674805,
-0.07447929680347443,
-0.6799368858337402,
-0.3023472726345062,
0.1203235313296318,
0.35890471935272217,
-0.240342915058136,
0.2261948585510254,
-0.1628485769033432,
0.7063412070274353,
0.7582805752754211,
0.11021539568901062,
0.4406292140483856,
0.14638487994670868,
-0.36072948575019836,
0.011571458540856838,
-0.8493732213973999,
-0.1873985230922699,
1.3288428783416748,
0.06175515800714493,
0.8376123905181885,
0.19096291065216064,
0.5486428141593933,
0.010549759492278099,
0.3910435140132904,
-0.2622741162776947,
0.09225734323263168,
-0.5139936804771423,
-0.8385568261146545,
-0.38760945200920105,
-0.7164568901062012,
-1.0178931951522827,
0.5283645391464233,
-0.07143933326005936,
-0.824018120765686,
0.055665794759988785,
0.04673484340310097,
-0.1509113907814026,
0.7005895972251892,
-0.6851673722267151,
1.0408636331558228,
-0.3943577706813812,
-0.34487587213516235,
-0.23251211643218994,
-0.4615446925163269,
0.284974604845047,
-0.6747637987136841,
0.5399618148803711,
-0.022953111678361893,
0.06421737372875214,
0.879365086555481,
-0.041828762739896774,
0.9627460837364197,
-0.30675214529037476,
-0.03824758902192116,
-0.006673590280115604,
0.3219919502735138,
0.3941156268119812,
0.043660908937454224,
-0.18928739428520203,
0.316404789686203,
0.03169703111052513,
-0.6397536993026733,
-0.3907274901866913,
0.48121821880340576,
-0.7438183426856995,
-0.3204021453857422,
0.01378406211733818,
-0.7528384327888489,
-0.3185838460922241,
0.5509495139122009,
0.3832492530345917,
0.08063256740570068,
-0.3717232048511505,
0.10131923854351044,
0.7415271401405334,
-0.34788182377815247,
0.4083561301231384,
0.9569404721260071,
-0.22932222485542297,
-0.41110336780548096,
1.123219609260559,
0.2820689082145691,
0.4747645854949951,
0.7454468607902527,
0.05610361322760582,
-0.14719617366790771,
-0.3683511018753052,
-0.4779815077781677,
0.10996755957603455,
-0.865142285823822,
-0.00196279538795352,
-0.7104622721672058,
-0.014179384335875511,
-0.37579017877578735,
-0.25589460134506226,
-0.6813309192657471,
-0.3771439492702484,
-0.15832827985286713,
-0.14997468888759613,
0.10605057328939438,
0.5682746767997742,
-0.2932787835597992,
0.13952158391475677,
-0.9374356865882874,
0.299812912940979,
0.25224024057388306,
0.38592538237571716,
-0.07289683818817139,
-0.6570684313774109,
-0.38642632961273193,
0.24165955185890198,
-0.11793310940265656,
-0.5860897302627563,
0.4743993878364563,
0.2602172791957855,
0.8024547696113586,
0.4279588758945465,
0.27187928557395935,
0.5467821359634399,
-0.43608415126800537,
0.26497671008110046,
0.31016281247138977,
-0.9158837199211121,
0.2624828815460205,
-0.1573856621980667,
0.4043782651424408,
0.6316705346107483,
0.5369243025779724,
-0.7576890587806702,
-0.2865128815174103,
-0.5371682643890381,
-0.8154716491699219,
0.7545694708824158,
-0.23601004481315613,
0.04122161120176315,
0.48615002632141113,
0.04905229061841965,
0.45803940296173096,
0.19522571563720703,
-0.817326545715332,
-0.08879724144935608,
-0.1491895616054535,
-0.17292022705078125,
-0.347854346036911,
-0.22102703154087067,
-0.16666090488433838,
-0.08091072738170624,
0.6868257522583008,
-0.10949243605136871,
-0.20160585641860962,
-0.35648876428604126,
-0.6587444543838501,
-0.17816264927387238,
0.3210158348083496,
0.25805845856666565,
0.670012891292572,
0.09313911199569702,
0.225483238697052,
0.435477077960968,
-0.41977372765541077,
0.24802298843860626,
-0.11372267454862595,
-0.46031126379966736,
-0.24223987758159637,
0.3450542390346527,
0.5737484693527222,
0.4196498990058899,
-0.6702336072921753,
0.26684147119522095,
0.030599238350987434,
-0.08510357141494751,
-0.017439695075154305,
-0.16811254620552063,
0.11428191512823105,
0.030215192586183548,
-0.010965796187520027,
0.15228432416915894,
-0.28273117542266846,
-0.5604219436645508,
0.4744900166988373,
0.4260806441307068,
-0.648298442363739,
-0.427762508392334,
0.6604102253913879,
-0.05487922579050064,
-0.01685142144560814,
0.6107487082481384,
0.08362329006195068,
-0.43957650661468506,
0.2579696774482727,
0.5484113097190857,
0.74455326795578,
-0.5384860038757324,
0.18657052516937256,
0.04650311544537544,
0.5753958225250244,
-0.14514701068401337,
0.341746062040329,
-0.030212147161364555,
-0.8818821310997009,
-0.12673991918563843,
-0.5404584407806396,
-0.2899593114852905,
0.10613249242305756,
-0.7415614724159241,
-0.020584944635629654,
-0.6319597959518433,
0.18350645899772644,
0.06721336394548416,
-0.23801863193511963,
-0.6248984336853027,
0.09166955202817917,
0.06666231155395508,
0.6203360557556152,
-0.8672494292259216,
1.082505702972412,
0.6586712002754211,
-0.34900110960006714,
-0.5366021990776062,
-0.29053327441215515,
0.0869472324848175,
-1.0202925205230713,
0.4157955050468445,
0.02428119257092476,
-0.008601129055023193,
-0.23363032937049866,
0.016418468207120895,
-0.8833951950073242,
0.5829083323478699,
0.8726264238357544,
-0.38014477491378784,
0.16598835587501526,
0.38923630118370056,
0.17922437191009521,
-0.154794380068779,
0.060163866728544235,
0.3454580307006836,
0.37723374366760254,
-0.41481345891952515,
-0.8543620705604553,
-0.11638754606246948,
-0.34675073623657227,
-0.34832507371902466,
0.2344183325767517,
-0.7081165909767151,
1.0999541282653809,
-0.24248264729976654,
-0.3099859654903412,
-0.2000586837530136,
0.4330889880657196,
-0.05899794027209282,
0.19434042274951935,
0.5256522297859192,
0.4309539198875427,
1.2255727052688599,
0.2256723791360855,
0.5312013626098633,
-0.5434142351150513,
0.1324600875377655,
1.0254346132278442,
-0.48129022121429443,
0.6693226099014282,
0.31953585147857666,
0.17316491901874542,
0.1432730257511139,
0.39921319484710693,
0.3201136589050293,
0.725614607334137,
0.03638429567217827,
-0.2557674050331116,
-0.4682673215866089,
-0.1759929060935974,
-0.1926741898059845,
0.6676673293113708,
0.002381134545430541,
-0.30413171648979187,
-0.3035729229450226,
0.37755417823791504,
0.3133370578289032,
0.06466546654701233,
-0.19007165729999542,
0.7803986072540283,
-0.03254007175564766,
-0.615276038646698,
0.7327912449836731,
0.20209114253520966,
0.5000894069671631,
-0.7822459936141968,
0.26754477620124817,
-0.28800833225250244,
0.5465094447135925,
-0.15101759135723114,
-0.23839415609836578,
0.25288453698158264,
0.337126225233078,
-0.5069858431816101,
-0.5683255791664124,
0.5769370198249817,
-0.7192946672439575,
-0.6182709336280823,
0.7766804099082947,
0.7546104192733765,
0.01998673379421234,
-0.10279333591461182,
-0.7011576890945435,
-0.18377098441123962,
0.22434455156326294,
-0.22132910788059235,
0.8381281495094299,
0.6097016334533691,
-0.33734968304634094,
0.8648399114608765,
0.7965750098228455,
-0.009256014600396156,
0.17448903620243073,
0.353974848985672,
0.7735634446144104,
-0.5109196305274963,
-0.7043833136558533,
-0.6123549342155457,
0.43192538619041443,
0.2652488946914673,
-0.24701356887817383,
0.7643001079559326,
0.6037144660949707,
1.3589674234390259,
0.21015650033950806,
1.0040844678878784,
0.39350026845932007,
0.46653687953948975,
-0.652988612651825,
1.2199848890304565,
-0.6936371922492981,
0.2983618676662445,
-0.2558721601963043,
-0.5138280987739563,
-0.3037746548652649,
0.23936519026756287,
0.07056566327810287,
0.1877608597278595,
0.5073968768119812,
0.9447275996208191,
-0.15449975430965424,
0.030442358925938606,
0.5787665247917175,
-0.015572983771562576,
0.06205309182405472,
0.6433561444282532,
0.7291041612625122,
-0.15105101466178894,
0.7181126475334167,
-0.5522916913032532,
-0.34250888228416443,
0.11769019067287445,
-0.622239887714386,
-0.8767858743667603,
-0.5307116508483887,
-0.10699623078107834,
0.05897478759288788,
0.32744133472442627,
0.48507463932037354,
0.7828313112258911,
-0.9789636731147766,
-0.46418002247810364,
0.2658829689025879,
0.41760680079460144,
-0.45907458662986755,
-0.12235554307699203,
0.26151949167251587,
-0.34134992957115173,
-0.49447545409202576,
0.6306590437889099,
0.05340675637125969,
0.002687565516680479,
-0.191586434841156,
-0.1594064086675644,
-0.18451520800590515,
-0.09196201711893082,
0.32317695021629333,
0.5346778631210327,
-0.2553642690181732,
-0.06901245564222336,
-0.02944464236497879,
-0.014560614712536335,
-0.0661318302154541,
0.960777223110199,
-0.531436562538147,
0.40915006399154663,
0.457670658826828,
0.7199079990386963,
0.32714220881462097,
-0.403286337852478,
0.5539146065711975,
-1.0614625215530396,
0.4709298312664032,
0.03976844996213913,
0.6383501291275024,
0.3617698848247528,
-0.2999995946884155,
0.21218888461589813,
0.2874889075756073,
-0.22639092803001404,
-0.9941072463989258,
0.2636273503303528,
-0.44716235995292664,
-0.8681926727294922,
0.8410940170288086,
-0.42092663049697876,
-0.3157443404197693,
-0.37649208307266235,
0.20419666171073914,
0.4210861325263977,
-0.17035318911075592,
0.6488260626792908,
0.4861466586589813,
0.45775121450424194,
-0.17188574373722076,
-0.287134051322937,
0.3089921474456787,
0.622882604598999,
-0.6120432615280151,
0.6964454054832458,
0.2447088062763214,
0.4242567718029022,
0.061165135353803635,
0.5551717877388,
-0.2997725009918213,
0.31553247570991516,
0.08995974063873291,
0.1847710907459259,
-0.11684028059244156,
-0.8147420883178711,
-0.4070993959903717,
0.4150623679161072,
-0.07858353853225708,
-0.05022866651415825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12347v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12347v1
|
Interpreting Bias in Large Language Models: A Feature-Based Approach
| 2024-06-18T07:28:15 | 2024-06-18T07:28:15 |
Nirmalendu Prakash, Lee Ka Wei Roy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) such as Mistral and LLaMA have showcased
remarkable performance across various natural language processing (NLP) tasks.
Despite their success, these models inherit social biases from the diverse
datasets on which they are trained. This paper investigates the propagation of
biases within LLMs through a novel feature-based analytical approach. Drawing
inspiration from causal mediation analysis, we hypothesize the evolution of
bias-related features and validate them using interpretability techniques like
activation and attribution patching. Our contributions are threefold: (1) We
introduce and empirically validate a feature-based method for bias analysis in
LLMs, applied to LLaMA-2-7B, LLaMA-3-8B, and Mistral-7B-v0.3 with templates
from a professions dataset. (2) We extend our method to another form of gender
bias, demonstrating its generalizability. (3) We differentiate the roles of
MLPs and attention heads in bias propagation and implement targeted debiasing
using a counterfactual dataset. Our findings reveal the complex nature of bias
in LLMs and emphasize the necessity for tailored debiasing strategies, offering
a deeper understanding of bias mechanisms and pathways for effective
mitigation.
|
[
-0.39166000485420227,
-0.8970778584480286,
0.6086037158966064,
0.4078347384929657,
-0.08015888184309006,
-0.15406692028045654,
-0.18234582245349884,
-0.48191794753074646,
0.24877293407917023,
0.819331705570221,
-0.695391058921814,
-0.34068894386291504,
-1.018850326538086,
-0.04790954291820526,
-0.5547201037406921,
0.9994909167289734,
0.06808945536613464,
0.3545599579811096,
-0.0772925615310669,
-0.2802759110927582,
-0.7038672566413879,
-0.45351046323776245,
-0.37209025025367737,
-0.7128452062606812,
0.45072227716445923,
0.12852489948272705,
0.7267209887504578,
0.6702237725257874,
0.23473741114139557,
0.16558079421520233,
-0.5103176832199097,
0.058977484703063965,
-0.587589681148529,
0.12242360413074493,
-0.23633286356925964,
-0.7103331089019775,
-0.42487430572509766,
0.06521277129650116,
0.6108341813087463,
0.9423670768737793,
0.08016089349985123,
0.4808720350265503,
0.451852411031723,
0.5578421354293823,
-0.5818356275558472,
0.19161321222782135,
-0.8896003365516663,
0.013715555891394615,
-0.33421987295150757,
-0.04353461042046547,
-0.32758739590644836,
-0.22720231115818024,
0.23709021508693695,
-0.1686273068189621,
0.4188162386417389,
-0.1233038529753685,
0.5330252051353455,
0.4319324791431427,
-0.5418513417243958,
-0.31520766019821167,
-0.6296679377555847,
0.991401731967926,
-0.5577760338783264,
0.32393166422843933,
0.27380067110061646,
0.07876420021057129,
-0.30027809739112854,
-0.2626775801181793,
-0.44131773710250854,
0.02150265872478485,
-0.08362419903278351,
-0.40885621309280396,
-0.20882463455200195,
-0.2470044046640396,
0.3464500606060028,
0.13875043392181396,
-0.03734472021460533,
0.2971859872341156,
-0.09126745164394379,
0.034279439598321915,
0.5271268486976624,
-0.05565968155860901,
0.18237079679965973,
-0.030572079122066498,
-0.263624370098114,
0.24863700568675995,
-0.991777241230011,
-0.207657590508461,
0.4207945466041565,
0.32133445143699646,
-0.19620263576507568,
0.5262932777404785,
-0.007782211527228355,
0.45510491728782654,
0.23831763863563538,
-0.025171296671032906,
0.22577448189258575,
0.1174670159816742,
-0.2848987281322479,
0.1887071281671524,
0.5837509036064148,
0.2021564245223999,
0.31062817573547363,
0.0585143081843853,
-0.00739977927878499,
0.22231201827526093,
0.21621489524841309,
-0.36176472902297974,
0.22969458997249603,
0.0843556821346283,
-0.6483569741249084,
-0.7958061099052429,
-0.3129802644252777,
-0.8669322729110718,
-0.911756157875061,
-0.3108402490615845,
0.22470512986183167,
0.17781832814216614,
-0.3494841754436493,
-0.00014740755432285368,
-0.04333570599555969,
0.11020918935537338,
0.2743763029575348,
-0.8173724412918091,
0.23469465970993042,
0.8520872592926025,
0.6266288757324219,
-0.1335757076740265,
-0.2964054346084595,
-0.3419504463672638,
0.14074301719665527,
-0.18296541273593903,
0.6140415072441101,
-0.7414889931678772,
-0.1448436826467514,
0.1854507029056549,
-0.12982524931430817,
0.10532482713460922,
-0.7024328112602234,
0.5789005160331726,
-0.4832039177417755,
-0.11051204055547714,
-0.7493600845336914,
-0.1595497578382492,
-0.2959609627723694,
0.11675193905830383,
-0.8707403540611267,
0.975652813911438,
-0.006599868182092905,
-1.13540780544281,
0.7353156805038452,
-0.6172912120819092,
-0.25730395317077637,
-0.5714441537857056,
-0.3806470036506653,
-0.37429893016815186,
0.2238050252199173,
0.4979003369808197,
0.3308614194393158,
-0.6982254385948181,
0.7422048449516296,
-0.6618059277534485,
-0.3150206208229065,
0.49076688289642334,
-0.7283298373222351,
0.936058759689331,
-0.126328706741333,
-0.854895830154419,
-0.02382582426071167,
-0.586509108543396,
-0.5851805210113525,
-0.004214752931147814,
0.07404576987028122,
-0.37987419962882996,
0.26199865341186523,
-0.06263208389282227,
0.26206961274147034,
-0.08702877163887024,
-0.22742657363414764,
0.09807811677455902,
-0.09874396026134491,
0.33215007185935974,
0.7808830738067627,
0.05790802836418152,
0.5677181482315063,
-0.02636122703552246,
0.3879426121711731,
0.28208956122398376,
0.3828420042991638,
0.06965358555316925,
-0.47690778970718384,
-0.744304895401001,
-0.3921993672847748,
0.0924062505364418,
0.36210423707962036,
-0.5528160929679871,
0.34600433707237244,
-0.13257485628128052,
-0.2558012306690216,
-0.7326066493988037,
0.4033186137676239,
0.31526997685432434,
0.5145502686500549,
0.3421229422092438,
-0.2471337765455246,
-0.4562014937400818,
-1.2110943794250488,
-0.6128197312355042,
-0.06323239207267761,
0.043724171817302704,
0.12787437438964844,
0.3098491430282593,
-0.4954579472541809,
0.9650312662124634,
-0.439276784658432,
-0.35989078879356384,
-0.4057500660419464,
0.29036951065063477,
0.26228174567222595,
0.17918021976947784,
0.5171694159507751,
-0.5459776520729065,
-0.01026731077581644,
-0.2904592752456665,
-0.6937851905822754,
-0.7648184299468994,
-0.18176652491092682,
-0.18658769130706787,
-0.01635137014091015,
0.4240368604660034,
-0.5238323211669922,
0.544154942035675,
0.5703710317611694,
-0.4278307855129242,
0.4546821713447571,
0.3960569500923157,
-0.14951007068157196,
-0.6553537249565125,
0.07489190995693207,
0.32787394523620605,
-0.1441296488046646,
-0.6599689722061157,
-0.12712007761001587,
-0.37975820899009705,
0.36821284890174866,
-0.21768304705619812,
0.5946578979492188,
-0.5213293433189392,
-0.35820525884628296,
-0.3359836935997009,
0.026542656123638153,
0.01743873953819275,
0.2995302975177765,
-0.031212521716952324,
0.28795790672302246,
0.4007631838321686,
-0.3922499716281891,
0.048219628632068634,
0.19402359426021576,
-0.2725261449813843,
0.5364906787872314,
-0.48250699043273926,
0.02330383099615574,
-0.38780486583709717,
0.5046725869178772,
-0.799162745475769,
0.04433060064911842,
0.3860681653022766,
-0.12294171750545502,
0.07655484229326248,
-0.292178213596344,
-0.3400309979915619,
-0.09353260695934296,
-0.38373276591300964,
0.5066623687744141,
0.20344603061676025,
-0.5588183999061584,
0.4416709244251251,
0.43733227252960205,
-0.09716199338436127,
-0.9834035038948059,
-0.7058263421058655,
0.03650795295834541,
-0.5020697116851807,
-0.28820547461509705,
0.0031173755414783955,
0.38143467903137207,
-0.67435222864151,
-0.12866950035095215,
0.0009059372241608799,
-0.07188423722982407,
0.2547079026699066,
0.4605846405029297,
0.15047825872898102,
-0.1096477285027504,
-0.0684531033039093,
0.2195967733860016,
0.023904338479042053,
0.30472344160079956,
0.07910999655723572,
0.5381075739860535,
0.3520026206970215,
-0.5554132461547852,
-0.1644865721464157,
0.15693333745002747,
0.677557647228241,
-0.10727892816066742,
0.8070552945137024,
0.6227331757545471,
-0.2932766377925873,
-0.4721137583255768,
-0.8788220286369324,
-0.31037330627441406,
-0.37900084257125854,
0.4339121878147125,
-0.06833131611347198,
-0.8266273140907288,
0.6647136807441711,
0.012133066542446613,
0.03170448914170265,
0.4247819185256958,
0.8453832268714905,
0.2568379342556,
0.9473525285720825,
0.684791088104248,
-0.5661916732788086,
0.46130093932151794,
-0.07507805526256561,
0.12551671266555786,
-0.9282649755477905,
-0.1483592838048935,
-0.47533541917800903,
-0.3857537508010864,
-0.5772103667259216,
-0.590718150138855,
0.23051020503044128,
0.13304120302200317,
-0.26354163885116577,
-0.1931387484073639,
-0.27106183767318726,
0.2350550889968872,
0.41257914900779724,
0.13940995931625366,
0.21155902743339539,
0.028548017144203186,
0.09470272064208984,
-0.13819092512130737,
-0.5139659643173218,
-0.5884915590286255,
1.1615756750106812,
0.8449083566665649,
0.9095829725265503,
-0.0338619090616703,
0.27623942494392395,
0.4545948803424835,
0.7373664975166321,
-0.496325820684433,
0.3457363545894623,
0.051177579909563065,
-0.7389577031135559,
-0.4089523255825043,
-0.12743881344795227,
-0.644698977470398,
0.5777201056480408,
-0.49497103691101074,
-0.7429407238960266,
0.48541325330734253,
0.16805870831012726,
0.17070893943309784,
0.30181217193603516,
-0.43162575364112854,
0.66192227602005,
-0.11565884947776794,
-0.5070956945419312,
-0.33028116822242737,
-0.3458555340766907,
0.6652599573135376,
-0.2864888608455658,
0.3647865355014801,
-0.2001638412475586,
0.04659781605005264,
0.5552740693092346,
-0.037913572043180466,
1.2906967401504517,
-0.26313450932502747,
-0.5274553298950195,
0.12494388222694397,
0.11355579644441605,
0.34645503759384155,
0.0674968883395195,
-0.31924235820770264,
0.44617488980293274,
-0.33351758122444153,
-0.15453822910785675,
-0.6215938925743103,
0.6081335544586182,
-0.7198569774627686,
-0.7376356720924377,
-0.2541584074497223,
-0.566987156867981,
-0.23317724466323853,
0.10401641577482224,
-0.07708144187927246,
0.3534315526485443,
-0.23062390089035034,
-0.1032419204711914,
0.6376940011978149,
-0.3648504614830017,
0.12567216157913208,
0.37719178199768066,
-0.34884992241859436,
0.03389903903007507,
0.36951184272766113,
0.2357977032661438,
0.15707802772521973,
0.12929196655750275,
0.31462833285331726,
-0.1633460521697998,
-0.4900556802749634,
-0.3339366912841797,
0.43990060687065125,
-0.679648756980896,
0.1077766865491867,
-0.6056431531906128,
-0.07662994414567947,
-0.2977809011936188,
-0.037207115441560745,
-0.3054904043674469,
0.018996290862560272,
-0.3083374500274658,
-0.043660759925842285,
0.08799475431442261,
0.9966163039207458,
0.12354599684476852,
0.42336979508399963,
-0.3979627788066864,
0.34380751848220825,
0.24864226579666138,
0.23490415513515472,
0.41826823353767395,
-0.5187869071960449,
-0.09762696176767349,
-0.027446988970041275,
-0.27256113290786743,
-1.1014913320541382,
0.4129127264022827,
-0.20292693376541138,
0.5762385725975037,
0.5212097764015198,
-0.25289660692214966,
0.454013854265213,
-0.5252403616905212,
0.6832658648490906,
-0.0031454365234822035,
-1.0100295543670654,
0.4307989180088043,
-0.48064762353897095,
0.07668481767177582,
0.36152559518814087,
0.21121570467948914,
-0.5296311974525452,
-0.6349748373031616,
-0.6611121296882629,
-0.7786411046981812,
0.6299903392791748,
0.004017340485006571,
0.11403083801269531,
-0.08146481215953827,
0.506377637386322,
0.1991267055273056,
0.42892709374427795,
-0.8259055614471436,
-0.4277850091457367,
0.18505138158798218,
-0.1314847320318222,
-0.1755104959011078,
-0.7456285953521729,
-0.2543441653251648,
0.00964125245809555,
0.47778409719467163,
-0.12115293741226196,
0.18238519132137299,
0.092021644115448,
-0.5397621989250183,
-0.015557640232145786,
0.38057905435562134,
0.6372115612030029,
0.8026218414306641,
-0.14536097645759583,
0.22826698422431946,
0.2956613600254059,
-0.5407595038414001,
0.045750170946121216,
-0.0947735607624054,
-0.3402496874332428,
0.11842672526836395,
0.6497775912284851,
0.8613914847373962,
0.17508700489997864,
-0.2858203947544098,
0.6499993205070496,
0.4123552441596985,
0.10447944700717926,
-0.07531590014696121,
-0.13564163446426392,
-0.000723126984667033,
0.6041505336761475,
0.3695965111255646,
-0.2456711381673813,
0.3831164836883545,
-0.5482715964317322,
0.053700998425483704,
0.5289856195449829,
-0.6982161402702332,
-0.4302027225494385,
0.6196798086166382,
0.16646872460842133,
0.23943014442920685,
0.14285346865653992,
0.21638822555541992,
-0.6349928975105286,
0.6428493857383728,
0.42685723304748535,
1.0553712844848633,
-0.228611558675766,
0.18750905990600586,
0.05237063765525818,
0.5575993657112122,
-0.3034273386001587,
0.07218429446220398,
0.2809669077396393,
-0.8835926651954651,
-0.6009977459907532,
-0.5927982330322266,
-0.18122611939907074,
0.2888031005859375,
-0.7529743313789368,
0.34575825929641724,
-0.21152643859386444,
-0.18435782194137573,
0.12211107462644577,
-0.4010782539844513,
-0.716346263885498,
0.09042934328317642,
0.3584461510181427,
0.7820619940757751,
-1.4022133350372314,
0.6566416621208191,
0.5347471237182617,
0.03395967185497284,
-0.3871224522590637,
0.2625197470188141,
0.45111608505249023,
-1.0868545770645142,
1.0120580196380615,
0.08388856798410416,
-0.07268775254487991,
-0.4559958577156067,
-0.3737410306930542,
-0.7850180268287659,
0.7851973176002502,
0.5150473117828369,
-0.39976766705513,
0.09778814762830734,
0.43481898307800293,
0.4487531781196594,
-0.5206484198570251,
0.4678536355495453,
0.9065817594528198,
0.38401538133621216,
-0.3113013207912445,
-0.9870497584342957,
0.24478194117546082,
0.2590957581996918,
0.15763767063617706,
0.0208514966070652,
-0.49864405393600464,
0.6755518913269043,
0.10944348573684692,
0.3088745176792145,
-0.4859655499458313,
0.5139830708503723,
0.2552832067012787,
0.2554982900619507,
0.6815879344940186,
0.3233840763568878,
0.6014451384544373,
0.11594393849372864,
0.8129687905311584,
0.0001633639622014016,
0.2815110981464386,
1.026209831237793,
-0.43257802724838257,
0.5686125159263611,
0.743903398513794,
-0.17825762927532196,
0.515103280544281,
0.3093157410621643,
0.11441413313150406,
0.3193618655204773,
0.43928104639053345,
-0.1301247626543045,
0.04202273115515709,
-0.48144641518592834,
-0.09200114011764526,
0.5952523350715637,
0.268893837928772,
-0.8185673356056213,
-0.2657512128353119,
-0.07324928045272827,
0.3629598915576935,
-0.07074195146560669,
-0.4892351031303406,
0.4587983787059784,
0.21967896819114685,
-0.4471307098865509,
0.25814130902290344,
-0.05096546933054924,
0.8180473446846008,
-0.33114781975746155,
-0.20590399205684662,
-0.19264620542526245,
0.17795276641845703,
-0.2979719936847687,
-0.6608394980430603,
0.18877455592155457,
0.12603572010993958,
-0.4712908864021301,
-0.20753322541713715,
0.7821733355522156,
-0.40962469577789307,
-0.458140105009079,
0.32582008838653564,
0.6356769800186157,
-0.18111500144004822,
-0.06532681733369827,
-0.6603554487228394,
0.498380571603775,
0.11988507956266403,
-0.4111579358577728,
0.3348112106323242,
0.3263237774372101,
-0.5445274710655212,
0.7371636629104614,
0.2841600775718689,
0.3915367126464844,
0.06998661160469055,
0.46217969059944153,
0.8478281497955322,
-0.5501030087471008,
-0.3051612675189972,
-1.132025957107544,
0.3613233268260956,
-0.02803020551800728,
-0.04676894471049309,
0.7312452793121338,
0.2127605676651001,
0.3764587640762329,
0.13517703115940094,
0.767876923084259,
0.3053959608078003,
0.5533973574638367,
-0.3848836123943329,
0.7056134343147278,
-0.23831462860107422,
0.5009588003158569,
-0.5455083250999451,
-1.1488977670669556,
-0.23708707094192505,
0.38729584217071533,
-0.5916537642478943,
0.10878165811300278,
0.31516072154045105,
0.6857073307037354,
0.013321585953235626,
-0.028676077723503113,
-0.03632139042019844,
0.38666510581970215,
0.41872239112854004,
0.12184935063123703,
0.8884333372116089,
-0.10990848392248154,
0.04691543057560921,
-0.006315723527222872,
-0.36690831184387207,
-0.3536461889743805,
-1.0101969242095947,
-1.0144864320755005,
-0.15179045498371124,
-0.21771405637264252,
-0.40159639716148376,
-0.08356945961713791,
0.8419038653373718,
0.3727073073387146,
-0.5563485622406006,
-0.2831437885761261,
0.25380784273147583,
0.43863117694854736,
-0.18001163005828857,
-0.215611532330513,
0.3930632770061493,
-0.32151222229003906,
-0.5437448024749756,
-0.09803910553455353,
0.023470498621463776,
-0.3517369031906128,
-0.7519786357879639,
0.2097242921590805,
-0.07118745893239975,
0.15623149275779724,
0.7443436980247498,
-0.06792127341032028,
-0.9667119383811951,
-0.3654688894748688,
-0.30835139751434326,
-0.030007999390363693,
-0.14084838330745697,
0.8881560564041138,
-0.6690430045127869,
0.24829839169979095,
0.26066944003105164,
0.5526760220527649,
0.318439781665802,
-0.1973898857831955,
0.7969585061073303,
-0.48064911365509033,
0.26326510310173035,
-0.18393266201019287,
0.292825311422348,
0.3342829942703247,
-0.38241392374038696,
0.4522474706172943,
0.24626341462135315,
-0.24634015560150146,
-1.06687331199646,
0.23576991260051727,
-0.6503185033798218,
-0.2713169753551483,
1.4297431707382202,
0.20307406783103943,
-0.15112674236297607,
-0.20028920471668243,
-0.23799405992031097,
0.3597377836704254,
-0.10603759437799454,
1.0188597440719604,
0.6596939563751221,
0.009830502793192863,
-0.13311654329299927,
-0.8936241865158081,
0.5784267783164978,
0.4600534737110138,
-0.4600315988063812,
0.35158026218414307,
0.4912823736667633,
0.47311675548553467,
0.0411379374563694,
0.4764464199542999,
-0.20930801331996918,
-0.022115914151072502,
-0.1608867645263672,
0.2521660327911377,
0.16787970066070557,
-0.147603377699852,
-0.6744471192359924,
-0.06699908524751663,
0.3425922691822052,
0.2165049910545349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12336v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12336v1
|
A Compass for Navigating the World of Sentence Embeddings for the Telecom Domain
| 2024-06-18T07:03:34 | 2024-06-18T07:03:34 |
Sujoy Roychowdhury, Sumit Soman, H. G. Ranjani, Vansh Chhabra, Neeraj Gunda, Subhadip Bandyopadhyay, Sai Krishna Bala
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7
|
A plethora of sentence embedding models makes it challenging to choose one,
especially for domains such as telecom, rich with specialized vocabulary. We
evaluate multiple embeddings obtained from publicly available models and their
domain-adapted variants, on both point retrieval accuracies as well as their
(95\%) confidence intervals. We establish a systematic method to obtain
thresholds for similarity scores for different embeddings. We observe that
fine-tuning improves mean bootstrapped accuracies as well as tightens
confidence intervals. The pre-training combined with fine-tuning makes
confidence intervals even tighter. To understand these variations, we analyse
and report significant correlations between the distributional overlap between
top-$K$, correct and random sentence similarities with retrieval accuracies and
similarity thresholds. Following current literature, we analyze if retrieval
accuracy variations can be attributed to isotropy of embeddings. Our
conclusions are that isotropy of embeddings (as measured by two independent
state-of-the-art isotropy metric definitions) cannot be attributed to better
retrieval performance. However, domain adaptation which improves retrieval
accuracies also improves isotropy. We establish that domain adaptation moves
domain specific embeddings further away from general domain embeddings.
|
[
-0.2630445063114166,
-0.6661898493766785,
0.6527784466743469,
0.1258016973733902,
-0.3464951515197754,
-0.07522152364253998,
-0.24637837707996368,
-0.35955220460891724,
0.2937747836112976,
0.18442244827747345,
-0.20019306242465973,
-0.6220446228981018,
-0.6537165641784668,
0.20116972923278809,
-0.1460576206445694,
0.5138360261917114,
0.07928083837032318,
0.18970680236816406,
-0.21636106073856354,
-0.3936222493648529,
-0.3962388336658478,
-0.580141544342041,
0.018568778410553932,
-0.14033493399620056,
0.14018553495407104,
0.37770041823387146,
0.9535606503486633,
0.6129270792007446,
0.4704418480396271,
0.16320499777793884,
-0.038054458796978,
0.16652849316596985,
-0.44346779584884644,
0.14721117913722992,
0.03538474068045616,
-0.4635743796825409,
-0.15750378370285034,
0.07523012906312943,
0.46445411443710327,
0.7266989350318909,
-0.33778706192970276,
0.06011568754911423,
0.33542242646217346,
0.4763146936893463,
-0.7608222365379333,
-0.11974503844976425,
-0.8102843761444092,
0.1993957906961441,
0.02546815387904644,
-0.3449285328388214,
-0.4303915202617645,
-0.5686790347099304,
0.4711156487464905,
-0.9445859789848328,
0.10445462912321091,
0.34416815638542175,
1.1905694007873535,
0.1984574943780899,
-0.6585004329681396,
-0.4219549000263214,
-0.27553245425224304,
0.8791770339012146,
-0.494674950838089,
0.7166841626167297,
0.3948635458946228,
0.055814266204833984,
0.14705747365951538,
-0.6501242518424988,
-0.22201111912727356,
-0.1907954216003418,
0.19947285950183868,
0.08337582647800446,
-0.25188732147216797,
0.10459325462579727,
0.027839353308081627,
0.06645627319812775,
-0.36185985803604126,
0.01840192824602127,
-0.1557050496339798,
-0.1232326552271843,
0.3013828694820404,
-0.04860462248325348,
0.0833454430103302,
-0.03356635943055153,
-0.4785917103290558,
0.05802639573812485,
-0.9424644708633423,
-0.1444416493177414,
0.6337119340896606,
0.22013677656650543,
0.13748544454574585,
0.6278076171875,
-0.13491664826869965,
0.7463168501853943,
0.05438942462205887,
0.2739016115665436,
0.3526356518268585,
-0.21878093481063843,
-0.15950001776218414,
0.11571920663118362,
0.4263933598995209,
0.5826091170310974,
0.7692652344703674,
-0.2449367195367813,
0.04986843094229698,
-0.3609955608844757,
0.5877375602722168,
-0.500832200050354,
-0.21161866188049316,
0.014985709451138973,
-0.599210798740387,
-0.05833551287651062,
0.4526464343070984,
-0.36754682660102844,
-0.15149861574172974,
-0.2697949707508087,
0.41781625151634216,
-0.6855379343032837,
-0.00986533798277378,
0.3965686559677124,
-0.2901029884815216,
0.30129891633987427,
0.22160141170024872,
-0.649177610874176,
0.41184014081954956,
0.8227546811103821,
0.9726352691650391,
-0.09301237761974335,
-0.12084181606769562,
-0.29756027460098267,
-0.004597082734107971,
-0.3446001708507538,
0.6040860414505005,
-0.9355503916740417,
-0.3650935888290405,
0.5771315097808838,
-0.10098060965538025,
-0.3404167890548706,
-0.5932119488716125,
0.78605717420578,
-0.8514935374259949,
0.1755443960428238,
-0.3438945710659027,
-0.8586653470993042,
-0.4059314429759979,
0.077176533639431,
-0.604081928730011,
0.843332827091217,
-0.03749938681721687,
-0.686530590057373,
0.44489338994026184,
-0.2707250416278839,
-0.25047779083251953,
-0.2210293412208557,
0.015612424351274967,
-0.33222365379333496,
0.3493826985359192,
-0.011285336688160896,
0.45171937346458435,
-0.21774236857891083,
-0.14787352085113525,
-0.45521196722984314,
-0.5374434590339661,
0.2786247432231903,
0.049083467572927475,
0.8889402151107788,
0.4335499107837677,
0.08288407325744629,
-0.4335707426071167,
-0.5935314893722534,
0.45673444867134094,
-0.4334953725337982,
0.002696976298466325,
-0.7716508507728577,
-0.04298466444015503,
0.12805959582328796,
-0.046543385833501816,
0.07076464593410492,
-0.687707245349884,
0.0859142616391182,
-0.11562317609786987,
0.6706619262695312,
0.46876874566078186,
0.22364068031311035,
0.4937257468700409,
-0.4076363742351532,
0.3965616822242737,
0.36902254819869995,
-0.08318354189395905,
0.1176254004240036,
-0.5801497101783752,
-0.4027077257633209,
-0.028809430077672005,
0.5360378623008728,
0.5760758519172668,
-0.45950794219970703,
0.5147035121917725,
-0.46574535965919495,
-0.4257248342037201,
-0.9692965149879456,
0.12925784289836884,
0.33683302998542786,
0.2019035518169403,
0.5348173379898071,
-0.2494296282529831,
-0.2209603488445282,
-0.8611809015274048,
-0.771999716758728,
0.1104663610458374,
0.017088493332266808,
0.39053863286972046,
0.3643353283405304,
0.03835821524262428,
0.9457255601882935,
-0.8269405961036682,
-0.4582279920578003,
0.1431960016489029,
0.06579209119081497,
-0.034208957105875015,
0.3557547628879547,
0.44738608598709106,
-0.9282155632972717,
-0.5659443140029907,
-0.2334073781967163,
-0.5675962567329407,
-0.017127111554145813,
-0.1491294652223587,
0.27029740810394287,
-0.08126970380544662,
0.47229433059692383,
-0.5205724835395813,
0.1733083724975586,
0.4121558368206024,
-0.23813676834106445,
0.44641727209091187,
-0.3030458688735962,
0.24717645347118378,
-1.1709578037261963,
-0.2032271772623062,
0.27324602007865906,
-0.30058881640434265,
-0.4580964744091034,
0.06293419748544693,
0.29071205854415894,
0.07440204918384552,
-0.28130725026130676,
0.11404077708721161,
-0.7369215488433838,
-0.07024041563272476,
0.03843100368976593,
0.5007490515708923,
0.16280105710029602,
0.07589516788721085,
-0.25267699360847473,
0.9433765411376953,
0.5490620136260986,
-0.656035840511322,
-0.01095631718635559,
0.49521464109420776,
-0.753059446811676,
0.5586259365081787,
-0.7944839000701904,
0.11468306928873062,
0.11240535229444504,
-0.006698915734887123,
-0.8033688068389893,
0.23645642399787903,
-0.2122056633234024,
-0.4003731310367584,
0.021297702565789223,
-0.20101934671401978,
-0.3370971083641052,
0.277273029088974,
-0.4636610746383667,
0.40483248233795166,
0.5292606949806213,
-0.305387943983078,
0.09965936094522476,
0.47677311301231384,
-0.1349218785762787,
-0.8142228722572327,
-0.7194639444351196,
0.11091969162225723,
-0.223977193236351,
-0.6000772714614868,
0.8918005228042603,
0.3092185854911804,
-0.18506456911563873,
0.15148022770881653,
0.033892303705215454,
-0.2695688009262085,
0.04535446688532829,
0.16598092019557953,
-0.01073132548481226,
-0.4186301827430725,
0.3531641364097595,
0.15909981727600098,
-0.0016473447903990746,
-0.044855885207653046,
-0.5581926703453064,
0.20666469633579254,
-0.11679128557443619,
-0.24517059326171875,
-0.41015926003456116,
0.25187361240386963,
0.15919001400470734,
-0.09014540165662766,
0.699158787727356,
0.5258920192718506,
-0.22181083261966705,
-0.281876802444458,
-0.5246753692626953,
-0.1187126412987709,
-0.46071237325668335,
0.2033950388431549,
-0.7742370367050171,
-0.9947569966316223,
0.4122874438762665,
-0.35736793279647827,
-0.2518990933895111,
0.2231462448835373,
0.10719214379787445,
-0.11862324923276901,
0.679729700088501,
1.0107555389404297,
0.21103422343730927,
0.44621971249580383,
-0.10430166870355606,
0.36224380135536194,
-0.9828172326087952,
-0.14671137928962708,
-0.664344847202301,
-0.3096288740634918,
-0.918990433216095,
-0.34150081872940063,
0.33477193117141724,
0.043902646750211716,
-0.14139577746391296,
0.6042956113815308,
-0.35536032915115356,
0.419152170419693,
0.3522167503833771,
0.17511507868766785,
0.37100934982299805,
0.24151912331581116,
-0.534156322479248,
-0.3137652277946472,
-0.8034248948097229,
-0.5463493466377258,
1.0431389808654785,
0.13675273954868317,
1.010262370109558,
0.2042396068572998,
0.582943856716156,
0.3424256443977356,
-0.23960696160793304,
-0.6373756527900696,
0.25470587611198425,
-0.3728082478046417,
-0.28513213992118835,
-0.07494676113128662,
-0.4901649057865143,
-0.861552894115448,
0.13007910549640656,
-0.2280549556016922,
-0.8587571978569031,
0.5663521885871887,
-0.14392468333244324,
-0.3832671344280243,
0.0465506985783577,
-0.7663528919219971,
0.7000783085823059,
0.30798253417015076,
-0.16042247414588928,
-0.2952387034893036,
-0.528990626335144,
-0.12234460562467575,
0.044317640364170074,
-0.079465351998806,
0.029046770185232162,
-0.4498480260372162,
0.5237877368927002,
-0.19664312899112701,
0.6744588613510132,
-0.08132942765951157,
0.10763054341077805,
0.2570365071296692,
0.21977034211158752,
0.09909253567457199,
-0.07022926211357117,
-0.45316529273986816,
0.21365880966186523,
0.29035937786102295,
-0.3066515028476715,
-0.5713258385658264,
0.8686422109603882,
-0.9469907283782959,
-0.612777829170227,
-0.3223571479320526,
-0.33460092544555664,
-0.34134799242019653,
0.14159394800662994,
0.41622865200042725,
0.5428128242492676,
-0.4097696542739868,
0.5940306186676025,
0.726736843585968,
-0.21217875182628632,
0.2544512450695038,
0.14962661266326904,
0.3189196288585663,
-0.27022916078567505,
0.54547119140625,
0.30895358324050903,
0.31997406482696533,
0.7124265432357788,
-0.12235606461763382,
-0.6059027314186096,
-0.422637015581131,
-0.22876733541488647,
0.15969571471214294,
-0.7837937474250793,
-0.37155112624168396,
-0.7220717072486877,
-0.2236326038837433,
-0.5500332117080688,
-0.3519108295440674,
-0.13541829586029053,
-0.8603294491767883,
-0.4947108328342438,
-0.261601060628891,
0.5307109355926514,
0.5886741876602173,
0.17631754279136658,
0.4123954176902771,
-0.7312085628509521,
-0.033229582011699677,
-0.2177218794822693,
0.39092376828193665,
-0.21350660920143127,
-0.7515134215354919,
-0.4216425120830536,
0.12961074709892273,
-0.42237916588783264,
-0.8390364646911621,
0.2849602997303009,
0.7785813212394714,
0.36667001247406006,
0.17895540595054626,
0.1489274501800537,
0.7984954118728638,
-0.6777510643005371,
0.9919112324714661,
-0.01590542681515217,
-1.050695538520813,
0.2938600182533264,
-0.011219319887459278,
0.10434389114379883,
0.7319429516792297,
0.9162414073944092,
-0.40885257720947266,
-0.12314414978027344,
-0.6584532856941223,
-0.5837591886520386,
0.07576768100261688,
-0.058793436735868454,
0.503199577331543,
0.06474895030260086,
0.5418793559074402,
0.17025631666183472,
0.13734780251979828,
-0.3162948787212372,
-0.17916230857372284,
-0.21796664595603943,
-0.35198646783828735,
0.0984436571598053,
-0.18762974441051483,
-0.15045683085918427,
0.06583108007907867,
0.38687336444854736,
-0.03604753315448761,
0.44367095828056335,
0.4991143047809601,
-0.4996553361415863,
0.1602715700864792,
0.2798592150211334,
0.38739436864852905,
0.7040224671363831,
-0.1517152339220047,
0.2109164297580719,
0.08985231071710587,
-0.6785476207733154,
0.16796571016311646,
-0.022786809131503105,
-0.13815201818943024,
0.44065791368484497,
0.24444115161895752,
0.39943215250968933,
0.3088196814060211,
-0.3637086749076843,
0.7456251382827759,
0.10555936396121979,
-0.1902141273021698,
-0.30743131041526794,
0.023633074015378952,
-0.07141941785812378,
0.04940120503306389,
0.46390995383262634,
-0.010946269147098064,
0.2612076699733734,
-0.42261171340942383,
0.455383837223053,
0.40496450662612915,
-0.603378176689148,
-0.18643330037593842,
0.6222027540206909,
0.17799369990825653,
-0.45461514592170715,
0.7058829069137573,
-0.008538461290299892,
-0.40409812331199646,
0.30969715118408203,
0.5596937537193298,
0.9858639240264893,
-0.038700394332408905,
0.37589147686958313,
0.16724130511283875,
0.20424336194992065,
-0.22046953439712524,
0.4129112660884857,
0.05828831344842911,
-0.8813048005104065,
-0.23147305846214294,
-0.2822064161300659,
-0.3939579725265503,
-0.5134590864181519,
-0.8984926342964172,
0.2725352644920349,
-0.2589856684207916,
-0.5210559964179993,
-0.01667858473956585,
0.06563768535852432,
-0.7770189046859741,
0.09010736644268036,
-0.4780828058719635,
1.2718404531478882,
-0.5697253346443176,
0.9656995534896851,
0.7290173768997192,
-0.3497771620750427,
-0.6720770001411438,
0.30203771591186523,
-0.03620380908250809,
-0.7846516370773315,
0.6223424077033997,
0.10639779269695282,
-0.27211421728134155,
0.3290329575538635,
-0.16176694631576538,
-0.6931700110435486,
1.408729076385498,
0.16308818757534027,
-0.46225303411483765,
0.0418245755136013,
0.14369727671146393,
0.47377723455429077,
-0.7792537808418274,
0.3667633533477783,
0.1328464299440384,
0.1292201429605484,
-0.3765430748462677,
-0.8238643407821655,
0.2587295174598694,
0.026014475151896477,
0.17198364436626434,
-0.03989780321717262,
-0.6160101294517517,
0.6025936603546143,
-0.3293772339820862,
-0.28704604506492615,
0.04928438365459442,
0.4625418186187744,
-0.1329834759235382,
0.13085706532001495,
0.40861502289772034,
0.6556041836738586,
0.6685667037963867,
-0.1342606246471405,
0.979387640953064,
-0.6109498739242554,
0.46627357602119446,
0.8100868463516235,
-0.33558663725852966,
1.0894687175750732,
0.4827449917793274,
0.09379053860902786,
0.8120323419570923,
0.5544462203979492,
0.0049081589095294476,
0.7263196706771851,
0.18485185503959656,
-0.05044609308242798,
-0.1073494628071785,
-0.08280277252197266,
-0.45545825362205505,
0.42441001534461975,
0.3789622485637665,
-0.5217728018760681,
-0.18007338047027588,
0.011293384246528149,
-0.07960841804742813,
0.2340337187051773,
0.09086687117815018,
0.6367248892784119,
0.5287919640541077,
-0.5773949027061462,
0.7928847670555115,
0.11194484680891037,
0.5688971281051636,
-0.4358879327774048,
0.0523516945540905,
-0.023152519017457962,
0.12436304241418839,
-0.16179431974887848,
-0.774909257888794,
0.22663699090480804,
-0.147506445646286,
0.16427569091320038,
-0.41761314868927,
0.6500738263130188,
-0.4215555191040039,
0.01772235706448555,
0.2204025387763977,
0.7713367342948914,
0.10361747443675995,
-0.03998001292347908,
-0.7985172271728516,
0.196645125746727,
-0.109347864985466,
-0.20891836285591125,
0.2571265399456024,
0.7634420394897461,
0.4079538583755493,
0.7123816013336182,
0.3623218238353729,
0.11182691156864166,
0.03446851670742035,
0.09613539278507233,
0.648879885673523,
-0.7183841466903687,
-0.5592413544654846,
-0.6342934370040894,
0.15494264662265778,
-0.23244629800319672,
-0.8383599519729614,
0.7640230655670166,
0.6435957551002502,
0.908370852470398,
-0.2374628335237503,
0.4956037104129791,
0.0774252787232399,
0.12723152339458466,
-0.77973473072052,
0.5286175608634949,
-0.45442327857017517,
0.39292216300964355,
-0.027572685852646828,
-1.1866850852966309,
-0.2907038629055023,
0.830398440361023,
-0.40155330300331116,
0.002369549823924899,
0.9485720992088318,
1.0036565065383911,
-0.43977561593055725,
0.16593067348003387,
0.3452703356742859,
0.1083512008190155,
-0.014895167201757431,
0.43051624298095703,
0.7038769721984863,
-0.6694426536560059,
0.5702933669090271,
0.11551973968744278,
-0.09404577314853668,
-0.5004771947860718,
-0.9345226287841797,
-0.4364702105522156,
-0.7847538590431213,
-0.47264808416366577,
-0.345506876707077,
0.45455384254455566,
0.8388961553573608,
0.8388739824295044,
-0.5857593417167664,
-0.22586551308631897,
0.11168459802865982,
0.10550427436828613,
-0.4781564474105835,
-0.24341195821762085,
0.23397193849086761,
-0.5662215352058411,
-0.5279426574707031,
0.11984813213348389,
0.1409827023744583,
-0.07673264294862747,
0.12139683216810226,
0.17929302155971527,
-0.36540454626083374,
0.12330783158540726,
0.4091919958591461,
-0.04531330615282059,
-0.6047493815422058,
-0.7021113634109497,
0.3922778069972992,
-0.39883238077163696,
0.10328759998083115,
1.1190681457519531,
-0.6163272857666016,
0.2077031284570694,
0.3381060063838959,
0.8613548874855042,
0.2745039165019989,
0.10414604097604752,
0.7308658361434937,
-0.8810182213783264,
-0.07917884737253189,
0.26174354553222656,
0.32978811860084534,
0.250155508518219,
-0.41989296674728394,
0.5676660537719727,
0.16083884239196777,
-0.7076967358589172,
-0.7004669308662415,
0.3315804898738861,
-1.1169610023498535,
-0.29481908679008484,
1.2257163524627686,
-0.40217044949531555,
0.0972423180937767,
-0.3660479187965393,
0.12080013751983643,
-0.025951489806175232,
-0.3364810645580292,
0.9027183651924133,
0.963100790977478,
-0.035902008414268494,
-0.10106053203344345,
-0.5656516551971436,
0.6908848881721497,
0.5096262097358704,
-0.306856632232666,
-0.08491628617048264,
0.24339181184768677,
0.561292290687561,
0.18382862210273743,
0.3024563193321228,
-0.21835960447788239,
0.1423623263835907,
0.17946431040763855,
-0.5173330903053284,
-0.05163446441292763,
-0.2692312002182007,
-0.37627124786376953,
0.24690866470336914,
0.007016381714493036,
-0.32826244831085205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12335v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12335v1
|
Attention Score is not All You Need for Token Importance Indicator in KV Cache Reduction: Value Also Matters
| 2024-06-18T07:01:11 | 2024-06-18T07:01:11 |
Zhiyu Guo, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Scaling the context size of large language models (LLMs) enables them to
perform various new tasks, e.g., book summarization. However, the memory cost
of the Key and Value (KV) cache in attention significantly limits the practical
applications of LLMs. Recent works have explored token pruning for KV cache
reduction in LLMs, relying solely on attention scores as a token importance
indicator. However, our investigation into value vector norms revealed a
notably non-uniform pattern questioning their reliance only on attention
scores. Inspired by this, we propose a new method: Value-Aware Token Pruning
(VATP) which uses both attention scores and the $ \ell_{1} $ norm of value
vectors to evaluate token importance. Extensive experiments on LLaMA2-7B-chat
and Vicuna-v1.5-7B across 16 LongBench tasks demonstrate VATP's superior
performance.
|
[
-0.3455725908279419,
-0.4262007176876068,
0.31491148471832275,
0.46740564703941345,
-0.5425117611885071,
-0.257767915725708,
-0.3174463212490082,
-0.23414751887321472,
0.3899790644645691,
0.2895071506500244,
-0.25049862265586853,
-0.4575096666812897,
-0.48898935317993164,
-0.2721545994281769,
-0.3720712661743164,
0.8755144476890564,
0.15003883838653564,
-0.12094835191965103,
-0.44914525747299194,
-0.31829333305358887,
-0.8626781105995178,
-0.7644258141517639,
-0.656669020652771,
0.08329802006483078,
0.683408796787262,
0.3831780254840851,
-0.07400625199079514,
0.7871713042259216,
0.7418573498725891,
0.1810380518436432,
-0.4405859708786011,
0.14445087313652039,
-0.7874413728713989,
0.2261219173669815,
0.04733230173587799,
-0.774052619934082,
-0.723054826259613,
0.0842546820640564,
0.6844276785850525,
0.33174535632133484,
0.28337863087654114,
0.5406355857849121,
-0.28346458077430725,
0.7642070055007935,
-0.9979124665260315,
0.42684677243232727,
-0.6089348793029785,
-0.07258855551481247,
-0.44256913661956787,
-0.3990010917186737,
-0.47429975867271423,
-0.09330347925424576,
-0.28258341550827026,
-0.2712971866130829,
0.1125480905175209,
0.07804371416568756,
0.993728756904602,
0.501428484916687,
-0.3292895555496216,
0.5343448519706726,
-0.6180406808853149,
1.0795072317123413,
-0.3700854182243347,
0.20878112316131592,
0.3417532444000244,
0.14014579355716705,
-0.02394840307533741,
-0.6713276505470276,
-0.38280749320983887,
0.2396981120109558,
0.1738225519657135,
0.17184218764305115,
-0.18834485113620758,
0.30448445677757263,
0.11867868155241013,
0.41788598895072937,
0.04231064021587372,
0.06928820163011551,
-0.5576832294464111,
-0.38252565264701843,
0.16858308017253876,
0.3087691068649292,
-0.10099200904369354,
-0.23424366116523743,
-0.4269389808177948,
-0.26699525117874146,
-0.9083518981933594,
0.46662524342536926,
0.02852586843073368,
0.1637897789478302,
0.2146591991186142,
0.4189704358577728,
0.07595904171466827,
0.5607985854148865,
0.11885291337966919,
-0.28686878085136414,
0.08446552604436874,
-0.4141865074634552,
-0.32290342450141907,
0.0034317439422011375,
0.417253315448761,
0.733958899974823,
0.3087088465690613,
-0.08098195493221283,
-0.04147866740822792,
0.10814642161130905,
0.48424240946769714,
-0.8891268372535706,
0.0395844429731369,
0.2830507457256317,
-0.6745055913925171,
-0.35757192969322205,
-0.07524420320987701,
-0.5005680322647095,
0.09777304530143738,
-0.19206808507442474,
0.19814956188201904,
-0.0829213336110115,
-0.32036855816841125,
-0.22070322930812836,
-0.3624536395072937,
0.5070566534996033,
0.6066445112228394,
-0.8434377312660217,
0.3359074294567108,
0.8295243382453918,
0.8688786625862122,
-0.5273149013519287,
-0.11768698692321777,
-0.913216233253479,
-0.0314306877553463,
-0.44435861706733704,
0.674303412437439,
-0.5771950483322144,
-0.4648350477218628,
-0.3411501348018646,
-0.11966732889413834,
0.09865481406450272,
-0.5908249616622925,
0.6315790414810181,
-0.5611016154289246,
-0.38983285427093506,
-0.7336359620094299,
-0.4771411716938019,
-0.10807982832193375,
0.32894381880760193,
-0.8069460391998291,
1.3240776062011719,
0.3703765869140625,
-0.7425543069839478,
0.6510968804359436,
-0.46136474609375,
-0.5371647477149963,
-0.016837233677506447,
-0.0072612399235367775,
-0.4056609272956848,
0.4905437231063843,
0.18065941333770752,
0.43083250522613525,
-0.2969835698604584,
0.1080457866191864,
-0.16521055996418,
-0.667494535446167,
0.13613887131214142,
-0.627730131149292,
0.31816017627716064,
-0.04511009156703949,
-0.3612498939037323,
0.23601526021957397,
-0.6543242335319519,
0.15433208644390106,
-0.14436110854148865,
-0.5725002884864807,
-0.43294593691825867,
-0.1934388130903244,
0.33148515224456787,
0.3157569468021393,
0.19843031466007233,
-0.347005158662796,
0.2478094846010208,
-0.5134320855140686,
0.5907114744186401,
1.069364070892334,
0.06739577651023865,
0.38275566697120667,
-0.26304712891578674,
0.5850470066070557,
0.12821166217327118,
0.35903844237327576,
0.01874634250998497,
-0.5581584572792053,
-1.2742432355880737,
-0.6654236912727356,
0.3849159777164459,
0.03656093403697014,
-0.02451656013727188,
0.34269702434539795,
-0.5393151044845581,
-0.32885122299194336,
-0.6992159485816956,
-0.06494180113077164,
0.4670385420322418,
0.39791640639305115,
0.4237643778324127,
-0.5804091691970825,
-0.504844069480896,
-0.9395453333854675,
-0.2560071647167206,
-0.42514652013778687,
0.09587342292070389,
0.49460193514823914,
0.23368249833583832,
0.2105051726102829,
1.2716383934020996,
-0.2153223156929016,
-0.42846256494522095,
-0.09041932225227356,
-0.14598308503627777,
0.028827447444200516,
0.2908604145050049,
0.53074049949646,
-0.8005403876304626,
-0.3135172426700592,
-0.19464392960071564,
0.0011151653015986085,
-0.1102134957909584,
0.01635609194636345,
-0.03287811577320099,
0.20555227994918823,
0.6773722767829895,
-0.7044873237609863,
0.7652813196182251,
0.35328948497772217,
-0.12370972335338593,
0.4174312949180603,
-0.0882473811507225,
0.15636442601680756,
-0.6647458672523499,
0.35201382637023926,
-0.26765966415405273,
-0.48218992352485657,
-0.5321477651596069,
-0.23138226568698883,
0.3304573595523834,
0.17151156067848206,
-0.7404365539550781,
0.993644118309021,
-0.2752126157283783,
-0.22162650525569916,
-0.2824465334415436,
-0.05458211526274681,
0.23860494792461395,
0.7261845469474792,
-0.1841568797826767,
0.9273285865783691,
0.08710037171840668,
-0.8886387348175049,
-0.03949330374598503,
-0.08490124344825745,
-0.15884262323379517,
0.37038853764533997,
-0.5208249092102051,
0.0025944248773157597,
-0.060513999313116074,
-0.0046227965503931046,
-1.2520078420639038,
0.2867371737957001,
-0.005073227919638157,
-0.4765286147594452,
0.4878268539905548,
-0.17403411865234375,
-0.44081324338912964,
-0.14194253087043762,
-0.518022358417511,
0.7366930842399597,
0.5039363503456116,
-0.4637344181537628,
0.3553260564804077,
0.6401872634887695,
0.11129270493984222,
-0.5823127031326294,
-0.5511937737464905,
-0.07209738343954086,
-0.4426220655441284,
-0.2809770703315735,
0.4673269987106323,
0.03861236572265625,
-0.16909748315811157,
-0.10029815882444382,
-0.5404432415962219,
-0.009643821977078915,
0.18741199374198914,
0.3876180946826935,
0.058152928948402405,
0.004658493213355541,
0.6252886652946472,
-0.07072466611862183,
-0.44127199053764343,
0.028166646137833595,
-0.29090407490730286,
0.48989352583885193,
-0.15704573690891266,
-0.44144222140312195,
-0.2667667269706726,
0.20189742743968964,
1.0569349527359009,
-0.4856823980808258,
0.7575862407684326,
0.674506664276123,
-0.1743038445711136,
0.05233057215809822,
-0.7730526924133301,
-0.1432049423456192,
-0.42262300848960876,
0.3804832100868225,
-0.10203098505735397,
-1.1580402851104736,
0.5410054922103882,
-0.08762411773204803,
0.06977218389511108,
0.6485082507133484,
0.830482006072998,
0.2654319405555725,
0.8082298040390015,
0.6175071597099304,
-0.49123090505599976,
0.6562373638153076,
-0.018790027126669884,
0.4796064496040344,
-1.0761171579360962,
-0.00423398008570075,
-0.5121999382972717,
-0.4812001883983612,
-0.40640905499458313,
-0.8037912249565125,
0.39902639389038086,
0.013527574017643929,
-0.018016183748841286,
-0.12773479521274567,
-0.8013178706169128,
0.5786668062210083,
0.45071250200271606,
-0.10948639363050461,
0.15665405988693237,
-0.03593536838889122,
0.18283602595329285,
-0.30456069111824036,
-0.7114763855934143,
-0.16467596590518951,
1.258386492729187,
0.2979808449745178,
0.24722003936767578,
-0.028508765622973442,
0.3697201609611511,
0.1656377911567688,
0.5102818012237549,
-1.0330561399459839,
0.4396706223487854,
0.21103085577487946,
-0.6143457293510437,
-0.5547928810119629,
-0.4562782347202301,
-0.961369514465332,
0.38687169551849365,
0.29505112767219543,
-0.7215468287467957,
0.013813194818794727,
0.14489954710006714,
-0.3327122628688812,
0.038298968225717545,
-0.7443339228630066,
0.717572808265686,
0.0523926317691803,
-0.16448214650154114,
-0.43406471610069275,
-0.4533223509788513,
0.3049880862236023,
0.03618062660098076,
0.1580740511417389,
-0.23120994865894318,
-0.2777746915817261,
1.0245860815048218,
-0.594948410987854,
0.9216349720954895,
-0.12805917859077454,
0.3306659460067749,
0.3123282790184021,
-0.10015682876110077,
0.6324887275695801,
0.11558464169502258,
0.19014383852481842,
0.0010653773788362741,
-0.15614302456378937,
-0.486427366733551,
-0.4930456280708313,
0.8717443943023682,
-0.6876886487007141,
-0.7598707675933838,
-0.19743888080120087,
-0.24399617314338684,
0.037776101380586624,
0.14733187854290009,
0.037395693361759186,
0.06292235851287842,
-0.09963413327932358,
0.28679734468460083,
0.7806815505027771,
0.14447246491909027,
0.46858298778533936,
0.11936290562152863,
0.17798884212970734,
-0.19463911652565002,
0.826960563659668,
0.3973619341850281,
0.33752378821372986,
0.6042627692222595,
0.19559788703918457,
-0.09578878432512283,
-0.48166051506996155,
0.17868702113628387,
0.15143030881881714,
-1.0216901302337646,
-0.3286653757095337,
-0.6691275238990784,
-0.20001570880413055,
-0.2847970724105835,
-0.15519560873508453,
-0.6874295473098755,
-0.5957897901535034,
-0.39195525646209717,
-0.24192364513874054,
0.8151918053627014,
0.10943339765071869,
0.15425291657447815,
0.2438451647758484,
-0.6691156625747681,
0.16756124794483185,
0.5159199237823486,
0.4200465977191925,
0.34328001737594604,
-0.46060991287231445,
-0.30904436111450195,
-0.46274685859680176,
-0.032665517181158066,
-0.5224303007125854,
0.6562172770500183,
0.08549731224775314,
0.49930810928344727,
0.417669415473938,
0.08551730960607529,
0.9047900438308716,
-0.31279587745666504,
0.660717785358429,
0.15039019286632538,
-1.1207664012908936,
0.38386696577072144,
-0.09857811778783798,
0.5047206878662109,
0.7174561619758606,
-0.2721123695373535,
-0.7214999198913574,
-0.33691471815109253,
-0.8814857602119446,
-1.278973937034607,
0.6453142166137695,
0.3957992494106293,
0.0756390392780304,
-0.35755616426467896,
0.5557134747505188,
-0.17575591802597046,
0.4265805780887604,
-0.5524425506591797,
-0.34998080134391785,
0.052043866366147995,
-0.04889450967311859,
0.08247353881597519,
-0.4897589683532715,
0.03218751400709152,
-0.5400410890579224,
0.30448588728904724,
0.03592411056160927,
0.41382941603660583,
0.18225201964378357,
-0.05863337591290474,
-0.05673038586974144,
0.11157234758138657,
0.4817548096179962,
0.5352704524993896,
-0.11179058253765106,
0.06883248686790466,
0.36119452118873596,
-0.635633647441864,
-0.06040356680750847,
-0.677832305431366,
0.10686510801315308,
0.10597753524780273,
0.21904008090496063,
0.7001787424087524,
0.5420812964439392,
-0.5850966572761536,
0.8653535842895508,
-0.36422663927078247,
0.08322537690401077,
-0.17968370020389557,
0.08996699750423431,
0.16271010041236877,
-0.17119921743869781,
0.022730354219675064,
-0.06943563371896744,
-0.04905809834599495,
-0.20225873589515686,
-0.022336533293128014,
0.2733788788318634,
-0.7460301518440247,
-0.13781195878982544,
0.3620286285877228,
0.3386571705341339,
-0.2983857989311218,
0.6265898942947388,
0.01593487709760666,
-0.5016078352928162,
0.9466713070869446,
0.14750368893146515,
0.75697922706604,
-0.1882384866476059,
-0.2576923966407776,
0.28345102071762085,
0.5082281827926636,
-0.033860113471746445,
0.080485038459301,
-0.4229109287261963,
-0.2238258421421051,
-0.6630250215530396,
-0.6778132319450378,
-0.2837648093700409,
0.26445600390434265,
-0.6384331583976746,
0.38867703080177307,
-0.6236026883125305,
-0.3191063404083252,
-0.0512053519487381,
-0.06793223321437836,
-0.8494887351989746,
0.16416023671627045,
-0.3761836886405945,
0.687716007232666,
-0.6462584733963013,
0.8039789795875549,
0.301841676235199,
-0.18964286148548126,
-0.6937337517738342,
-0.2122364640235901,
-0.1172972321510315,
-0.7269642949104309,
0.8404054045677185,
0.4502960741519928,
0.08846607804298401,
0.005981239024549723,
-0.24798627197742462,
-1.072417974472046,
1.0214921236038208,
0.30445030331611633,
-0.4885098338127136,
0.10070046037435532,
-0.17438599467277527,
0.4334651231765747,
-0.1825476586818695,
0.238472580909729,
0.6537012457847595,
0.6850039958953857,
-0.03285426273941994,
-0.9413809776306152,
-0.03901015222072601,
-0.36581090092658997,
0.0670742616057396,
0.6482338309288025,
-1.1920905113220215,
0.9139265418052673,
0.08909697085618973,
-0.22771261632442474,
-0.43697240948677063,
0.4334470331668854,
0.07326722890138626,
-0.1476983278989792,
0.414333313703537,
0.5530056357383728,
0.8143208622932434,
-0.020021522417664528,
0.8632773756980896,
-0.18582302331924438,
0.30483487248420715,
0.696427047252655,
0.07621827721595764,
0.738602340221405,
1.0682183504104614,
-0.2642144560813904,
-0.17013606429100037,
0.6719695925712585,
0.17231832444667816,
0.525474488735199,
0.3900289237499237,
-0.03049601800739765,
-0.5456288456916809,
-0.0459585003554821,
-0.23513439297676086,
0.5926206707954407,
0.5499374270439148,
-0.29266515374183655,
-0.04795918986201286,
-0.26983344554901123,
0.1370907574892044,
-0.5035422444343567,
-0.39718881249427795,
0.6062788367271423,
0.17076729238033295,
-0.7292512655258179,
0.6720927357673645,
0.11742502450942993,
0.30786752700805664,
-0.4331344962120056,
-0.05943436920642853,
-0.09536894410848618,
0.352007120847702,
0.13683874905109406,
-0.26276183128356934,
0.22317636013031006,
-0.0416216105222702,
-0.4662935137748718,
-0.212265282869339,
0.6277573108673096,
-0.027088293805718422,
-0.26823028922080994,
0.21697567403316498,
0.34229183197021484,
0.21502360701560974,
-0.27077630162239075,
-0.17597386240959167,
0.10654659569263458,
-0.20009444653987885,
-0.6133377552032471,
0.7704893350601196,
0.5141351819038391,
-0.4030989110469818,
0.7086923122406006,
0.7659443616867065,
0.21975377202033997,
-0.045495662838220596,
0.14517387747764587,
1.1653785705566406,
-0.6851285099983215,
-0.6039371490478516,
-0.8921452760696411,
0.44997212290763855,
-0.195261612534523,
-0.7088673710823059,
0.6856434941291809,
0.38652926683425903,
0.647811233997345,
0.24753935635089874,
0.6989898085594177,
0.38108620047569275,
0.10035115480422974,
-0.3765692710876465,
0.6340337991714478,
-0.5918505191802979,
0.21811480820178986,
-0.1726808249950409,
-0.8133348822593689,
-0.4856850802898407,
0.5176923871040344,
-0.1462402194738388,
-0.037195488810539246,
0.8094853162765503,
0.5141326189041138,
0.15814071893692017,
-0.4670979976654053,
0.5016282796859741,
-0.006202910095453262,
0.5204693078994751,
0.5452976822853088,
0.2784756124019623,
-0.3273567259311676,
0.7187827229499817,
0.12639445066452026,
-0.3441968262195587,
-0.8186406493186951,
-0.9101540446281433,
-1.0689107179641724,
-0.5065140724182129,
-0.17341944575309753,
-0.20908330380916595,
-0.0829601138830185,
0.6312769651412964,
0.7781540155410767,
-0.5864110589027405,
0.142221137881279,
-0.13330787420272827,
0.22006450593471527,
-0.4135196805000305,
-0.2288353592157364,
0.7141748666763306,
-0.5515939593315125,
-0.45359164476394653,
0.07318398356437683,
0.8974871039390564,
-0.1818426549434662,
-0.3417060077190399,
0.1450771689414978,
0.08876754343509674,
0.20453694462776184,
0.5074204206466675,
0.23600739240646362,
-0.8178113102912903,
-0.5037041902542114,
0.16543184220790863,
-0.26842331886291504,
0.3640297055244446,
0.9459660053253174,
-0.849855363368988,
0.6514398455619812,
0.5965650081634521,
0.561622679233551,
0.7778427004814148,
-0.1942519247531891,
0.5323305130004883,
-1.0058741569519043,
0.42575180530548096,
0.4548712968826294,
0.35221341252326965,
0.17409473657608032,
-0.45167508721351624,
0.15627765655517578,
0.29854893684387207,
-0.527118444442749,
-0.8833133578300476,
0.11287010461091995,
-1.208296298980713,
-0.08290555328130722,
1.2360910177230835,
-0.0960559993982315,
-0.8598476052284241,
-0.28383690118789673,
-0.2856033146381378,
0.2001621425151825,
-0.4880290925502777,
0.8778334856033325,
1.0390958786010742,
0.3042128384113312,
-0.24719835817813873,
-0.3290758728981018,
0.6188075542449951,
0.694520115852356,
-0.6181902885437012,
0.5315898656845093,
0.13589784502983093,
-0.06403324753046036,
0.16518814861774445,
0.9293128848075867,
-0.23661251366138458,
0.5051523447036743,
-0.03898680955171585,
0.1669122725725174,
-0.1331823319196701,
-0.3711283802986145,
-0.24261489510536194,
0.31849753856658936,
0.42691171169281006,
-0.17752347886562347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12331v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12331v1
|
Retrieval Meets Reasoning: Dynamic In-Context Editing for Long-Text Understanding
| 2024-06-18T06:54:28 | 2024-06-18T06:54:28 |
Weizhi Fei, Xueyan Niu, Guoqing Xie, Yanhua Zhang, Bo Bai, Lei Deng, Wei Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Current Large Language Models (LLMs) face inherent limitations due to their
pre-defined context lengths, which impede their capacity for multi-hop
reasoning within extensive textual contexts. While existing techniques like
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) have attempted to bridge this gap by
sourcing external information, they fall short when direct answers are not
readily available. We introduce a novel approach that re-imagines information
retrieval through dynamic in-context editing, inspired by recent breakthroughs
in knowledge editing. By treating lengthy contexts as malleable external
knowledge, our method interactively gathers and integrates relevant
information, thereby enabling LLMs to perform sophisticated reasoning steps.
Experimental results demonstrate that our method effectively empowers
context-limited LLMs, such as Llama2, to engage in multi-hop reasoning with
improved performance, which outperforms state-of-the-art context window
extrapolation methods and even compares favorably to more advanced commercial
long-context models. Our interactive method not only enhances reasoning
capabilities but also mitigates the associated training and computational
costs, making it a pragmatic solution for enhancing LLMs' reasoning within
expansive contexts.
|
[
-0.24533317983150482,
-1.0783649682998657,
1.301916241645813,
0.001756954239681363,
-0.2829437255859375,
0.35960155725479126,
-0.5028566122055054,
-0.6582072377204895,
0.14304056763648987,
0.46393829584121704,
-0.49587810039520264,
-0.15308120846748352,
-0.40952032804489136,
0.11142434924840927,
-0.27295348048210144,
0.6808584928512573,
-0.29698729515075684,
-0.4852571487426758,
-0.4397514760494232,
-0.25320032238960266,
-0.6092424988746643,
-0.3276245594024658,
-0.4416753649711609,
-0.17189761996269226,
0.653099536895752,
0.4237988293170929,
0.7592670321464539,
0.5614964365959167,
0.21136474609375,
0.3439767062664032,
-0.654862642288208,
0.7294727563858032,
-0.4981180727481842,
0.6778907179832458,
-0.4232085049152374,
-0.387620210647583,
-0.36894771456718445,
-0.24987761676311493,
0.8763036131858826,
0.6074485182762146,
0.1217498928308487,
-0.032022926956415176,
-0.051101990044116974,
0.5978572368621826,
-0.5558991432189941,
-0.08410070836544037,
-0.9553143978118896,
-0.10944260656833649,
-0.241738960146904,
-0.5114130973815918,
-0.5288050174713135,
-0.12024742364883423,
0.14855864644050598,
-0.8679476380348206,
-0.3289790153503418,
-0.021854670718312263,
0.43274739384651184,
0.49361133575439453,
-0.8174962401390076,
-0.49422159790992737,
-0.591230034828186,
0.6608368754386902,
-0.3930486738681793,
0.5215069651603699,
0.22885967791080475,
0.4296197295188904,
-0.513102650642395,
-1.0199352502822876,
-0.6485118269920349,
-0.2496149092912674,
-0.1391545832157135,
-0.09491563588380814,
0.12204005569219589,
-0.12851159274578094,
0.39826372265815735,
-0.013577692210674286,
-0.05329115688800812,
-0.1998426914215088,
-0.1290784776210785,
0.18662838637828827,
0.4387114644050598,
-0.017515167593955994,
0.09975180774927139,
-0.15757368505001068,
-0.4801420569419861,
0.20428907871246338,
-0.8080664873123169,
0.07572569698095322,
0.018624572083353996,
0.14581073820590973,
0.3165307939052582,
0.6521543860435486,
-0.1721673309803009,
0.7707964777946472,
0.10395601391792297,
-0.15869885683059692,
0.04897845908999443,
-0.25329652428627014,
-0.2461932748556137,
-0.0066010672599077225,
0.21900613605976105,
0.1395920217037201,
-0.10097403079271317,
-0.2597711682319641,
-0.21104665100574493,
-0.6084139347076416,
0.1953076720237732,
-0.6208649277687073,
0.29731935262680054,
0.2865428924560547,
-0.23743268847465515,
-0.1981244683265686,
-0.11889344453811646,
-0.8428544998168945,
-0.523448646068573,
-0.4500516653060913,
0.5022913813591003,
-0.4620460569858551,
0.041842032223939896,
0.009560424834489822,
-0.30322593450546265,
-0.030988303944468498,
0.8458966612815857,
-0.5400886535644531,
-0.10976444184780121,
0.6881874203681946,
0.703545093536377,
-0.17539016902446747,
-0.1997125893831253,
-0.6575372219085693,
0.7083525061607361,
-0.2098018229007721,
0.7366541028022766,
-1.0093166828155518,
-0.38347724080085754,
-0.10638703405857086,
-0.0894150510430336,
0.2123844474554062,
-0.5464338064193726,
0.5533410310745239,
-1.0701663494110107,
0.10359422117471695,
-0.2705383896827698,
-0.5986025929450989,
-0.22211648523807526,
0.4250659942626953,
-0.5760735869407654,
1.2174725532531738,
-0.019352775067090988,
-0.789513111114502,
0.3377617299556732,
-0.7264699935913086,
-0.3716649115085602,
0.006630313582718372,
-0.1842137575149536,
0.006169359665364027,
0.08948838710784912,
0.298208624124527,
0.23931729793548584,
-0.06700710207223892,
0.4622251093387604,
-0.21625113487243652,
-0.43702375888824463,
0.39351117610931396,
-0.43464791774749756,
0.47845321893692017,
0.11779849231243134,
-0.25262588262557983,
0.2647339403629303,
-0.7606188654899597,
0.029913675040006638,
0.04091920703649521,
-0.7437397241592407,
-0.5522531867027283,
0.2169826477766037,
-0.30394089221954346,
0.17871487140655518,
0.4574001431465149,
-0.29854828119277954,
0.5949324369430542,
-0.27939704060554504,
0.40423160791397095,
0.7051472067832947,
0.07241187989711761,
0.5741387605667114,
-0.17913591861724854,
0.3293580114841461,
-0.26647239923477173,
-0.0023823881056159735,
-0.5184182524681091,
-0.23635458946228027,
-0.6691240668296814,
-0.2610308825969696,
-0.03643115609884262,
0.5223170518875122,
-0.9516487121582031,
0.12230107933282852,
-0.361699640750885,
-0.2229508012533188,
-0.2596123218536377,
0.1603105515241623,
0.07028413563966751,
0.6411336064338684,
0.7029430866241455,
0.2292216569185257,
-0.46585923433303833,
-0.5744366645812988,
-0.6056165099143982,
0.03244460001587868,
-0.007665558718144894,
0.5927349925041199,
0.39967775344848633,
-0.5629830956459045,
1.0638363361358643,
-0.41171130537986755,
0.06248559057712555,
-0.2906121015548706,
-0.022980721667408943,
0.2564381957054138,
0.3026382327079773,
0.15838591754436493,
-0.8902688026428223,
-0.35655975341796875,
0.030969135463237762,
-0.8005465269088745,
-0.1898055374622345,
-0.4415314197540283,
-0.46834149956703186,
0.04025445505976677,
0.8209685683250427,
-0.8177834749221802,
0.41505783796310425,
0.20228330790996552,
-0.37105900049209595,
0.5724316835403442,
-0.2972498834133148,
0.1728530377149582,
-0.9555615782737732,
0.08548939228057861,
-0.44087326526641846,
-0.463524729013443,
-0.3955059349536896,
0.36250466108322144,
0.19541853666305542,
-0.03796258568763733,
-0.26491087675094604,
0.9360995292663574,
-0.8050026893615723,
0.018896635621786118,
-0.4656575620174408,
0.5384827852249146,
0.2838124930858612,
0.21054749190807343,
-0.03155476599931717,
0.9330490231513977,
0.11263556033372879,
-0.5068630576133728,
0.38607147336006165,
0.3083505630493164,
-0.5526984930038452,
0.31424301862716675,
-0.3319285809993744,
0.27435144782066345,
-0.260879784822464,
0.8207871317863464,
-0.6683939099311829,
-0.34793969988822937,
-0.07027208060026169,
-0.12778328359127045,
0.3879810869693756,
-0.2766236960887909,
-0.5993648767471313,
0.017079176381230354,
-0.2337062507867813,
0.7389815449714661,
0.1429368108510971,
-1.0138163566589355,
0.8083918690681458,
0.3389545977115631,
-0.15791890025138855,
-0.7218292355537415,
-0.5032374858856201,
0.38133734464645386,
-0.4185899794101715,
-0.7319046854972839,
0.6859481334686279,
-0.0703558474779129,
-0.6080473065376282,
-0.14040812849998474,
-0.08299890160560608,
-0.09423773735761642,
0.137221559882164,
-0.11872213333845139,
-0.0054651955142617226,
0.09158496558666229,
0.4890151917934418,
0.5062974095344543,
0.08111587911844254,
-0.14410778880119324,
-0.07938594371080399,
0.263540655374527,
0.08626934885978699,
-0.4174253046512604,
-0.2513473927974701,
0.5621950030326843,
0.7297218441963196,
-0.37969517707824707,
0.5333759188652039,
0.21678955852985382,
-0.3555563688278198,
-0.38204115629196167,
-0.6316744089126587,
-0.05600956827402115,
-0.5473054051399231,
0.27073803544044495,
-0.629684567451477,
-1.1287885904312134,
0.38741061091423035,
-0.5719639658927917,
0.1057196781039238,
0.1305556744337082,
0.37057286500930786,
-0.1653778851032257,
0.882646918296814,
0.5344714522361755,
0.5473911166191101,
0.5473072528839111,
0.029951535165309906,
0.11366022378206253,
-1.1695846319198608,
-0.45050743222236633,
-0.10388980805873871,
-0.3519822359085083,
-0.41044285893440247,
-0.9713737964630127,
0.6675121784210205,
0.4463277757167816,
-0.2906656861305237,
-0.05760227143764496,
-0.28185197710990906,
0.7208188772201538,
0.3258391320705414,
0.26923617720603943,
0.5165686011314392,
-0.2525511384010315,
-0.24404273927211761,
0.04823470488190651,
-0.4333518147468567,
-0.5034026503562927,
0.708946704864502,
0.3479551076889038,
0.6560467481613159,
0.5227129459381104,
0.4299764335155487,
0.07689164578914642,
0.2910822331905365,
-0.8736670017242432,
0.616448700428009,
0.28746458888053894,
-0.5558283925056458,
-0.4097323417663574,
-0.3811822533607483,
-0.8992148041725159,
0.4485107660293579,
-0.26478102803230286,
-0.78822261095047,
0.11266621947288513,
0.08481556922197342,
-0.3192453682422638,
0.4567365050315857,
-0.4467957019805908,
0.5615866184234619,
-0.4488475024700165,
-0.7911686301231384,
-0.40946048498153687,
-0.7005988955497742,
0.39321887493133545,
-0.2833859324455261,
0.39355817437171936,
-0.03424747288227081,
-0.45710402727127075,
0.37818071246147156,
-0.39455798268318176,
0.5254713296890259,
-0.2081252485513687,
-0.18079981207847595,
0.38488855957984924,
0.381572425365448,
0.7969681620597839,
0.43003568053245544,
-0.42095157504081726,
-0.43348363041877747,
-0.10815726220607758,
-0.1765960305929184,
-1.0227241516113281,
0.7661908268928528,
-0.17772772908210754,
-0.9009830355644226,
-0.35870635509490967,
-0.8057483434677124,
-0.47831568121910095,
0.2097429782152176,
-0.3230361044406891,
0.43151694536209106,
0.07982951402664185,
0.39313748478889465,
0.6167043447494507,
-0.47543394565582275,
0.3881932199001312,
0.4114344120025635,
-0.42190438508987427,
-0.292435884475708,
0.34469106793403625,
0.07086200267076492,
0.12887637317180634,
0.6746218204498291,
0.3023194670677185,
-0.39600253105163574,
-0.29445338249206543,
-0.5371249914169312,
0.23317484557628632,
-0.9289688467979431,
-0.11970701068639755,
-0.7750756740570068,
0.17786405980587006,
0.028941145166754723,
-0.3648528754711151,
-0.061896950006484985,
-0.4433573782444,
-0.23362857103347778,
-0.14838242530822754,
0.47578510642051697,
0.7126797437667847,
-0.031204214319586754,
0.21496963500976562,
-0.84328693151474,
0.17619991302490234,
0.4107464849948883,
0.4023895561695099,
0.17921960353851318,
-0.6657042503356934,
-0.30353885889053345,
-0.2585960626602173,
-0.2719375491142273,
-1.1300349235534668,
0.18079917132854462,
0.13315138220787048,
0.5681263208389282,
0.15734076499938965,
-0.038519132882356644,
0.9551807641983032,
-0.7954830527305603,
0.6956945061683655,
-0.26932746171951294,
-1.0433954000473022,
0.7023986577987671,
-0.4653322696685791,
0.39491719007492065,
0.6430306434631348,
0.30296868085861206,
-0.5438401699066162,
-0.15066732466220856,
-0.3997964560985565,
-1.179507851600647,
0.3881254494190216,
-0.08195024728775024,
0.19386646151542664,
-0.10087644308805466,
0.6558548808097839,
0.1852377951145172,
0.19402803480625153,
-0.38333860039711,
0.12435872107744217,
0.14191600680351257,
-0.027091918513178825,
0.18758080899715424,
-0.5482631921768188,
-0.09978874772787094,
-0.5454718470573425,
0.6339608430862427,
-0.2445376217365265,
0.18772681057453156,
0.3193872570991516,
-0.3048439621925354,
0.09902650862932205,
0.42804545164108276,
0.5447147488594055,
1.0922943353652954,
-0.22960829734802246,
0.3184705376625061,
0.5876877307891846,
-0.055344972759485245,
-0.0278161708265543,
0.08221816271543503,
0.03675875812768936,
-0.02089727856218815,
0.3496304154396057,
0.7519353628158569,
0.530174195766449,
-1.0290322303771973,
0.39593788981437683,
0.0064485506154596806,
0.2701592743396759,
-0.43981680274009705,
-0.04569564759731293,
0.17630495131015778,
0.6398245692253113,
0.5761820077896118,
-0.19651615619659424,
0.07175060361623764,
-0.7138547897338867,
0.4298243522644043,
0.4091096520423889,
-0.10538647323846817,
0.025598717853426933,
0.7362866401672363,
0.18795593082904816,
-0.2915107011795044,
0.4824165999889374,
-0.07512138783931732,
-0.5056660771369934,
0.3150339126586914,
0.5469760298728943,
0.5473462343215942,
0.12406763434410095,
-0.15057291090488434,
0.23000794649124146,
0.009689592756330967,
-0.024762801826000214,
0.10131169855594635,
-0.4169136583805084,
-0.4879741072654724,
-0.8239051699638367,
-0.4805373251438141,
-0.6108514666557312,
0.1677161008119583,
-0.37151941657066345,
0.250598669052124,
-0.2612873315811157,
-0.10796251893043518,
-0.23318347334861755,
0.006779761984944344,
-0.31068524718284607,
0.14557094871997833,
-0.01757907122373581,
1.3144283294677734,
-0.12988661229610443,
0.8990689516067505,
0.6658889055252075,
-0.14867612719535828,
-0.5458678603172302,
0.3369852304458618,
-0.01229183841496706,
-0.48148664832115173,
0.6522231698036194,
0.3894752264022827,
-0.28720971941947937,
-0.05325765162706375,
-0.5684624910354614,
-1.0768574476242065,
1.2232165336608887,
0.37634554505348206,
-0.4831150472164154,
-0.1116822138428688,
-0.2628934383392334,
0.46454182267189026,
-0.07236594706773758,
0.3407409191131592,
0.6115533113479614,
0.6583850383758545,
0.23644152283668518,
-0.7984116077423096,
0.09036421030759811,
-0.16531045734882355,
-0.25190088152885437,
0.23783142864704132,
-0.6431993246078491,
0.6199164986610413,
-0.31924381852149963,
-0.19563712179660797,
0.13878732919692993,
0.7885314226150513,
0.4664369225502014,
0.3040057122707367,
0.5433443188667297,
0.4492306709289551,
1.0178989171981812,
0.14015468955039978,
0.9971805214881897,
-0.3242633044719696,
0.10784051567316055,
1.404145359992981,
-0.20531295239925385,
0.9570927619934082,
0.712249219417572,
0.11620481312274933,
0.7087621092796326,
0.4305633306503296,
0.5731812715530396,
0.3715178072452545,
0.08117181062698364,
-0.6977387070655823,
-0.35825350880622864,
-0.03560931235551834,
-0.160973459482193,
0.5443028807640076,
0.5292278528213501,
-0.22989772260189056,
-0.13993728160858154,
-0.05049007013440132,
0.2761791944503784,
0.3161199986934662,
-0.2219824194908142,
0.708605170249939,
0.026830216869711876,
-0.8056125640869141,
0.4599713087081909,
0.16945777833461761,
0.6776554584503174,
-0.4663977026939392,
-0.22294580936431885,
-0.07136896252632141,
0.06873529404401779,
-0.06707625091075897,
-1.2390308380126953,
0.5187777876853943,
0.20974868535995483,
-0.12574175000190735,
-0.44879451394081116,
0.7781972289085388,
-0.5181741118431091,
-0.25035324692726135,
0.4893852472305298,
0.5691527724266052,
0.06206384301185608,
-0.10865609347820282,
-0.4742679297924042,
0.19391022622585297,
-0.09176003932952881,
-0.5425970554351807,
0.29082340002059937,
0.8264307975769043,
-0.2101113647222519,
0.7869167327880859,
0.6320756673812866,
-0.08427929878234863,
-0.043159350752830505,
-0.10763546079397202,
1.0601037740707397,
-0.7027603387832642,
-0.45221811532974243,
-0.7513322830200195,
0.6360968947410583,
-0.3418368995189667,
-0.1449573040008545,
0.4396194517612457,
0.5193057656288147,
0.7137714624404907,
0.2879393696784973,
0.7502631545066833,
0.03370457515120506,
0.6468344330787659,
-0.5819085836410522,
0.533309817314148,
-0.916313111782074,
0.3675830662250519,
-0.04030026122927666,
-0.7109458446502686,
-0.3019948899745941,
0.5637887120246887,
-0.4421572983264923,
-0.030748993158340454,
0.5535830855369568,
0.5367718935012817,
-0.2297007292509079,
-0.14844241738319397,
0.10549592971801758,
0.36032596230506897,
0.5556183457374573,
0.43975821137428284,
1.0210871696472168,
-0.022546710446476936,
0.5288949608802795,
-0.0677475780248642,
-0.3028494119644165,
-0.142914280295372,
-1.1605418920516968,
-0.6420854926109314,
-0.4979149401187897,
0.20561374723911285,
-0.21000967919826508,
0.17153272032737732,
1.0003995895385742,
0.34748342633247375,
-0.18955041468143463,
0.01336890459060669,
0.18247520923614502,
0.3337695002555847,
0.07773041725158691,
-0.2446276992559433,
0.4358167350292206,
-0.4617760181427002,
-0.7739080190658569,
1.126852035522461,
0.3381909728050232,
-0.231442391872406,
-0.037295158952474594,
0.10568931698799133,
-0.4569830298423767,
0.36894673109054565,
1.0870201587677002,
0.19284221529960632,
-0.6882766485214233,
-0.5734922289848328,
-0.2394183725118637,
0.02684742957353592,
0.07965321838855743,
0.7012627124786377,
-1.1049349308013916,
0.6294924020767212,
0.7287535667419434,
0.9766404032707214,
0.5498071312904358,
0.3771750330924988,
0.3724147379398346,
-0.7449777722358704,
0.22054505348205566,
0.23936806619167328,
0.34078797698020935,
0.320856511592865,
-0.4640268087387085,
0.3474346101284027,
0.1486636996269226,
-0.6624862551689148,
-0.9029515981674194,
0.43397873640060425,
-1.043595314025879,
-0.604961097240448,
1.4318171739578247,
0.008102175779640675,
-0.0563945434987545,
-0.07948920875787735,
-0.46100276708602905,
0.31254974007606506,
-0.2267114520072937,
0.712409496307373,
0.48006945848464966,
-0.3686094582080841,
-0.06575359404087067,
-0.6027058959007263,
0.4993624687194824,
0.3748601973056793,
-0.9619407057762146,
0.16284172236919403,
0.6679316759109497,
0.12594687938690186,
0.00876710843294859,
0.48130640387535095,
-0.00666732108220458,
0.0022473111748695374,
-0.414867103099823,
-0.49202588200569153,
-0.24593400955200195,
-0.5960789918899536,
-0.06077250465750694,
0.19689518213272095,
-0.00438475888222456,
0.3652139902114868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12329v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12329v1
|
SNAP: Unlearning Selective Knowledge in Large Language Models with Negative Instructions
| 2024-06-18T06:54:05 | 2024-06-18T06:54:05 |
Minseok Choi, Daniel Rim, Dohyun Lee, Jaegul Choo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction-following large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, have
become increasingly popular with the general audience, many of whom are
incorporating them into their daily routines. However, these LLMs inadvertently
disclose personal or copyrighted information, which calls for a machine
unlearning method to remove selective knowledge. Previous attempts sought to
forget the link between the target information and its associated entities, but
it rather led to generating undesirable responses about the target,
compromising the end-user experience. In this work, we propose SNAP, an
innovative framework designed to selectively unlearn information by 1) training
an LLM with negative instructions to generate obliterated responses, 2)
augmenting hard positives to retain the original LLM performance, and 3)
applying the novel Wasserstein regularization to ensure adequate deviation from
the initial weights of the LLM. We evaluate our framework on various NLP
benchmarks and demonstrate that our approach retains the original LLM
capabilities, while successfully unlearning the specified information.
|
[
-0.28034698963165283,
-0.7838839888572693,
0.2963813245296478,
-0.13274873793125153,
-0.5333206057548523,
0.26236703991889954,
-0.5126861333847046,
-0.1286894977092743,
0.24897713959217072,
0.8066241145133972,
-0.6043205857276917,
-0.5135882496833801,
-0.5683562159538269,
-0.28814634680747986,
-0.6513840556144714,
1.1917709112167358,
0.23145247995853424,
0.04889846220612526,
-0.10663822293281555,
-0.006981014274060726,
-0.24801909923553467,
-0.5201556086540222,
-0.28601714968681335,
-0.5593582391738892,
0.4491141736507416,
0.6668793559074402,
0.5972189903259277,
0.47395071387290955,
0.20269721746444702,
0.2120116651058197,
-0.16825778782367706,
0.21056246757507324,
-0.9131671190261841,
0.14575347304344177,
-0.2861335277557373,
-0.38535404205322266,
-0.14796540141105652,
0.05145712196826935,
0.6887244582176208,
0.7872026562690735,
-0.21051239967346191,
0.24933622777462006,
0.4297960698604584,
0.7125853896141052,
-0.8745814561843872,
0.15394899249076843,
-0.8459572196006775,
0.10055491328239441,
-0.046310752630233765,
-0.2771415710449219,
-0.758887529373169,
-0.21736764907836914,
0.08136189728975296,
-0.3464190363883972,
0.2436550259590149,
-0.2492443323135376,
0.747246265411377,
0.22424349188804626,
-0.1774282306432724,
-0.2792099416255951,
-0.8159478306770325,
0.7893433570861816,
-0.6359474658966064,
0.31775322556495667,
0.47385281324386597,
0.2464701235294342,
-0.29165884852409363,
-0.24650655686855316,
-0.2269083708524704,
-0.04012242704629898,
0.11103148758411407,
0.21354253590106964,
-0.1536785066127777,
0.020484091714024544,
0.16139912605285645,
0.18886786699295044,
-0.4775071144104004,
0.40065234899520874,
-0.4747706651687622,
-0.17306634783744812,
0.5872889757156372,
-0.11498525738716125,
0.24365442991256714,
-0.08251553773880005,
-0.5428869724273682,
0.10455162823200226,
-0.8670434951782227,
-0.18501681089401245,
0.33729320764541626,
0.4635816216468811,
0.046261467039585114,
0.9342807531356812,
-0.19132587313652039,
0.33905237913131714,
0.09245537966489792,
0.09470956027507782,
0.3732733726501465,
0.18914400041103363,
-0.055857956409454346,
0.100688137114048,
0.7228397727012634,
0.18076808750629425,
0.23730577528476715,
-0.46036919951438904,
-0.3700259327888489,
-0.061761274933815,
0.11247576028108597,
-0.6448657512664795,
-0.028353173285722733,
0.02067725919187069,
-0.2903861403465271,
-0.15117672085762024,
-0.09037404507398605,
-0.5856499075889587,
-0.5823447108268738,
-0.25101399421691895,
0.4973411560058594,
-0.6198506355285645,
-0.09642752259969711,
0.16054034233093262,
-0.21243241429328918,
0.3425278663635254,
0.457302987575531,
-0.9038633704185486,
0.27326497435569763,
0.7576457262039185,
0.5711321830749512,
-0.1293812394142151,
-0.3901950418949127,
-0.7554300427436829,
0.1317165046930313,
-0.13668054342269897,
0.5438191890716553,
-0.6849192976951599,
-0.343841552734375,
-0.08194698393344879,
-0.19660191237926483,
-0.03044161945581436,
-0.5872644186019897,
0.20765908062458038,
-0.7905686497688293,
0.2460484355688095,
-0.16830384731292725,
-0.7946462631225586,
-0.3719247877597809,
0.42738601565361023,
-0.41956406831741333,
0.6986150145530701,
0.15920387208461761,
-0.5768154859542847,
0.18124450743198395,
-0.39259445667266846,
-0.39812740683555603,
0.15567289292812347,
-0.20163100957870483,
-0.39388060569763184,
0.08594346791505814,
0.22801433503627777,
0.441742479801178,
-0.30058154463768005,
0.21725963056087494,
-0.434743195772171,
-0.6888163089752197,
0.11660988628864288,
-0.7048053741455078,
0.7982134222984314,
-0.006561571732163429,
-0.24458281695842743,
0.06212432682514191,
-0.7499857544898987,
-0.06088985502719879,
0.2146081179380417,
-0.668839693069458,
-0.32194218039512634,
-0.08154597878456116,
-0.3820091187953949,
0.04454033821821213,
0.24413061141967773,
-0.6454131603240967,
0.3119746148586273,
-0.438385009765625,
0.3290969133377075,
0.8872179388999939,
0.07741004973649979,
0.57198166847229,
-0.2727530300617218,
0.5241005420684814,
0.13327346742153168,
0.08554056286811829,
-0.3752312660217285,
-0.41916850209236145,
-0.8327040076255798,
-0.2594725787639618,
0.18615058064460754,
0.5901058912277222,
-0.7909883856773376,
0.3350927531719208,
-0.1504254788160324,
-0.41155731678009033,
-0.5975269079208374,
0.4902980923652649,
0.5072264671325684,
0.6226964592933655,
0.5581707954406738,
-0.20072954893112183,
-0.6161194443702698,
-0.6592886447906494,
-0.36818361282348633,
0.023463664576411247,
-0.2899439036846161,
0.24670632183551788,
0.31417593359947205,
-0.45063450932502747,
0.8212243914604187,
-0.499016672372818,
-0.3568013310432434,
-0.4535943865776062,
0.10363247245550156,
0.31804776191711426,
0.24637511372566223,
0.0480259545147419,
-0.6360377669334412,
-0.2148107886314392,
-0.24168746173381805,
-0.5098506212234497,
0.05077245831489563,
-0.09245213866233826,
0.05088997632265091,
0.10991896688938141,
0.42393016815185547,
-0.7077544331550598,
0.4931280016899109,
0.43232467770576477,
-0.10255219042301178,
0.7607572674751282,
-0.18267138302326202,
0.02971905656158924,
-1.1559834480285645,
-0.0535668209195137,
-0.16783404350280762,
-0.1885661482810974,
-0.3754546046257019,
-0.03973735496401787,
0.060949765145778656,
-0.28434082865715027,
-0.6888455748558044,
0.6022741198539734,
-0.6577240824699402,
0.009993119165301323,
-0.32629549503326416,
0.2839469611644745,
0.04280082881450653,
0.7372521162033081,
-0.001984658185392618,
0.6432985663414001,
0.28974393010139465,
-0.6023674607276917,
0.15021173655986786,
0.4480881989002228,
-0.245089590549469,
0.014987512491643429,
-0.37595123052597046,
0.26532959938049316,
-0.3744873106479645,
0.06746917217969894,
-0.868259608745575,
-0.2833319306373596,
0.19184152781963348,
-0.529068648815155,
0.36216092109680176,
-0.49876880645751953,
-0.37032783031463623,
-0.23970937728881836,
-0.4653213918209076,
0.2747328281402588,
0.8129258155822754,
-0.7125855684280396,
0.5103853940963745,
0.4691608250141144,
0.16838043928146362,
-0.7105454206466675,
-0.6974517107009888,
0.07317155599594116,
-0.09556148201227188,
-0.2647944688796997,
0.3214644491672516,
0.04396812617778778,
0.06674668937921524,
0.014694553799927235,
0.07990469038486481,
-0.17809532582759857,
0.01377987489104271,
0.2335585504770279,
0.19754953682422638,
-0.20549896359443665,
0.26262378692626953,
0.08392464369535446,
-0.18940642476081848,
-0.13944292068481445,
-0.1721518188714981,
0.811621904373169,
-0.060101885348558426,
-0.6959922313690186,
-0.3640916645526886,
0.1930767446756363,
0.5203383564949036,
-0.2821475565433502,
0.7566611170768738,
0.5614979863166809,
-0.35228967666625977,
-0.36286601424217224,
-0.4434240460395813,
-0.35683679580688477,
-0.4977050721645355,
0.3643259108066559,
0.06275875866413116,
-1.0230423212051392,
0.4688274562358856,
-0.24909885227680206,
0.22907650470733643,
-0.11759968101978302,
0.4548291265964508,
-0.03356791287660599,
0.990630567073822,
0.6232354640960693,
-0.2524174749851227,
0.5944345593452454,
-0.20971344411373138,
0.25334182381629944,
-0.967390239238739,
-0.052360739558935165,
-0.2526572346687317,
-0.3603741526603699,
-0.3139371871948242,
-0.38708582520484924,
0.21579182147979736,
0.307105153799057,
-0.338868647813797,
0.3690146803855896,
-0.27628666162490845,
0.8331096768379211,
0.7170928120613098,
0.48265865445137024,
0.22427035868167877,
-0.18494050204753876,
-0.12588973343372345,
0.2828334867954254,
-0.6791408658027649,
-0.4484487473964691,
1.0384827852249146,
0.26886579394340515,
1.0965198278427124,
0.04007202386856079,
1.0546855926513672,
0.23361879587173462,
0.3038356900215149,
-0.9571985602378845,
0.7077648639678955,
-0.36642691493034363,
-0.3560090959072113,
-0.4123450815677643,
-0.5350509881973267,
-0.8278297781944275,
0.29760998487472534,
-0.16110630333423615,
-0.9956310987472534,
-0.25473541021347046,
0.4752185046672821,
-0.362382173538208,
0.4834156930446625,
-0.9934025406837463,
0.5535651445388794,
-0.07715611904859543,
-0.37612661719322205,
-0.032270397990942,
-0.48269322514533997,
0.45018213987350464,
-0.09347812086343765,
0.041884645819664,
-0.15954451262950897,
-0.0038903621025383472,
0.583267867565155,
-0.30972185730934143,
1.3461247682571411,
-0.1912849247455597,
0.12926669418811798,
0.34395164251327515,
0.3219434320926666,
0.72379070520401,
-0.028530627489089966,
-0.15882131457328796,
0.10151650756597519,
-0.3699081838130951,
-0.3311910331249237,
-0.7007991075515747,
0.37941643595695496,
-0.6481242179870605,
-0.7338084578514099,
0.20372527837753296,
-0.4252917766571045,
-0.2843204140663147,
0.47016629576683044,
0.3697526156902313,
0.30481716990470886,
-0.17491695284843445,
0.15502595901489258,
0.6965786218643188,
-0.3170715868473053,
0.34711572527885437,
0.6450044512748718,
-0.14924301207065582,
-0.34041687846183777,
0.9945310950279236,
0.17924298346042633,
0.16246430575847626,
0.6028949618339539,
0.38564378023147583,
-0.28626757860183716,
-0.5361663103103638,
-0.31516948342323303,
0.2959297299385071,
-0.7727565169334412,
-0.2865517735481262,
-0.45529648661613464,
-0.4295174777507782,
-0.3085309565067291,
-0.23567821085453033,
-0.6664080619812012,
-0.3689125180244446,
-0.6880607008934021,
-0.020697876811027527,
0.09526638686656952,
0.5500584840774536,
0.11765708029270172,
0.34646284580230713,
-1.1511671543121338,
0.13749998807907104,
0.05055731162428856,
0.42207080125808716,
0.15939824283123016,
-0.7406245470046997,
-0.13539423048496246,
0.34271207451820374,
-0.29230448603630066,
-0.6712304353713989,
0.37959346175193787,
0.12683990597724915,
0.45055830478668213,
0.6144574880599976,
0.4275679290294647,
0.5380532741546631,
-0.5935718417167664,
0.6173701286315918,
0.3309173285961151,
-0.8477172255516052,
0.48487091064453125,
-0.35468098521232605,
0.6360514163970947,
0.4651329517364502,
0.378695011138916,
-0.7084668278694153,
-0.4877191483974457,
-0.519658088684082,
-1.041757583618164,
0.6392952799797058,
-0.26037606596946716,
0.4139491319656372,
-0.08931109309196472,
0.3296160101890564,
0.3854125738143921,
0.28087079524993896,
-0.5707900524139404,
0.1370927095413208,
0.09182023257017136,
-0.17131055891513824,
-0.08537350594997406,
-0.49378907680511475,
0.08166363090276718,
-0.022293560206890106,
0.8428316116333008,
-0.0779309794306755,
0.0371641144156456,
-0.21611301600933075,
-0.48096877336502075,
0.05224601924419403,
0.44182178378105164,
0.3846079409122467,
0.43758946657180786,
-0.04909185692667961,
0.2779090106487274,
0.13419294357299805,
-0.5217201709747314,
0.07123153656721115,
-0.2877107560634613,
-0.5079904794692993,
-0.38569894433021545,
0.3967951536178589,
0.5604800581932068,
0.5065895318984985,
-0.7724140882492065,
0.6171759366989136,
0.08447911590337753,
-0.06698095798492432,
-0.227058544754982,
0.35018518567085266,
0.09002167731523514,
0.22570055723190308,
0.20482106506824493,
0.10097537189722061,
0.05192286893725395,
-0.29684552550315857,
0.5033423900604248,
0.4210193157196045,
-0.5243911147117615,
-0.48935821652412415,
0.36380770802497864,
0.23319505155086517,
-0.3863677382469177,
0.8478417992591858,
-0.25478190183639526,
-0.6935340762138367,
0.26098307967185974,
0.6896079182624817,
0.9309037327766418,
-0.16458025574684143,
0.41725024580955505,
0.1685127466917038,
0.25664371252059937,
-0.06937267631292343,
0.10146114230155945,
-0.19600096344947815,
-1.0025677680969238,
-0.44288715720176697,
-0.43861091136932373,
-0.43293431401252747,
0.3799442648887634,
-0.6935563087463379,
0.4514583647251129,
-0.5993708968162537,
-0.035690516233444214,
-0.18653585016727448,
-0.31964874267578125,
-0.5273302793502808,
-0.17992161214351654,
0.11869736760854721,
0.808772087097168,
-0.7123928070068359,
0.5558990240097046,
0.5161126852035522,
-0.43319055438041687,
-0.690674901008606,
0.07093048840761185,
0.3240226209163666,
-1.0746480226516724,
0.2315252274274826,
0.30238690972328186,
-0.25085121393203735,
-0.02994958683848381,
-0.5823761224746704,
-0.8298454880714417,
0.6619241237640381,
0.708154022693634,
-0.5566654205322266,
-0.027490492910146713,
0.12575000524520874,
0.23893699049949646,
-0.08120787143707275,
0.1855461299419403,
0.33830198645591736,
-0.04280726984143257,
0.2794148325920105,
-0.5708828568458557,
0.013002234511077404,
-0.19460466504096985,
-0.31170591711997986,
0.32120630145072937,
-0.6904489994049072,
0.6506425738334656,
-0.6711601614952087,
-0.40745800733566284,
-0.14438749849796295,
0.36608994007110596,
0.07681403309106827,
0.02759227342903614,
0.31667056679725647,
0.43067467212677,
0.9226609468460083,
0.2307521104812622,
0.5564549565315247,
-0.03480570763349533,
0.4228244423866272,
1.5558089017868042,
-0.310430645942688,
0.9373704791069031,
0.5302168130874634,
0.20770429074764252,
0.0018513109534978867,
0.47984179854393005,
0.04341595619916916,
0.49259158968925476,
0.24036948382854462,
-0.2886977195739746,
-0.288895845413208,
-0.09501681476831436,
-0.01732831448316574,
0.8436893224716187,
0.2924198508262634,
-0.3549512028694153,
-0.6761730313301086,
0.1645636409521103,
0.09062992036342621,
-0.027209380641579628,
-0.18323737382888794,
0.9016029238700867,
0.05312436819076538,
-0.4499027132987976,
0.791901171207428,
-0.12094506621360779,
0.569539487361908,
-0.5335771441459656,
-0.28876179456710815,
-0.17394162714481354,
0.3192005753517151,
-0.24995477497577667,
-0.6938510537147522,
0.106700100004673,
0.05200130492448807,
-0.3434756398200989,
-0.2532213032245636,
0.7686876654624939,
-0.572232723236084,
-0.09390264004468918,
0.40110912919044495,
0.43781983852386475,
0.1997617483139038,
-0.07426144927740097,
-0.7317066192626953,
0.02746874839067459,
0.22673660516738892,
-0.44044482707977295,
0.43304550647735596,
0.3318062126636505,
0.002781015820801258,
0.991729199886322,
0.5899667739868164,
-0.042535942047834396,
-0.1321554034948349,
0.3265930712223053,
1.2166234254837036,
-0.6117399334907532,
-0.4462302029132843,
-0.9703255891799927,
0.38565894961357117,
0.07096042484045029,
-0.20626011490821838,
0.7317517399787903,
0.6686119437217712,
0.9006372690200806,
0.01569545641541481,
0.8096276521682739,
0.3549375832080841,
0.6504605412483215,
-0.6105724573135376,
0.8572512865066528,
-0.29662051796913147,
0.6644629836082458,
-0.23564913868904114,
-0.8822171688079834,
-0.31899797916412354,
0.041330736130476,
-0.45651480555534363,
0.0360209159553051,
0.22681458294391632,
0.807651937007904,
-0.189239963889122,
0.17920011281967163,
0.54277503490448,
0.18676643073558807,
0.3787725269794464,
0.46075770258903503,
0.948356032371521,
-0.09268023818731308,
0.6103799343109131,
-0.19519124925136566,
-0.4444475471973419,
-0.36294734477996826,
-0.7812038064002991,
-1.005515694618225,
-0.3928689956665039,
-0.15274208784103394,
-0.14724700152873993,
0.12663933634757996,
1.1444329023361206,
0.5659783482551575,
-0.6974717378616333,
-0.08628363907337189,
0.04247236251831055,
0.4020788371562958,
-0.03514901548624039,
-0.19224999845027924,
0.36213481426239014,
-0.37481364607810974,
-0.3620533347129822,
0.5466347932815552,
0.3431074321269989,
0.22755305469036102,
-0.132605642080307,
-0.03676428645849228,
-0.045989252626895905,
0.004565359093248844,
0.6954100728034973,
0.38857558369636536,
-0.4553220272064209,
-0.35979703068733215,
-0.01288535911589861,
0.13174955546855927,
0.08417577296495438,
0.7414047122001648,
-0.7560747861862183,
0.37516605854034424,
0.39142322540283203,
0.8741049766540527,
0.37279775738716125,
0.08380542695522308,
0.49733054637908936,
-0.9597612023353577,
0.13075672090053558,
0.5185908675193787,
0.3104555010795593,
0.3018728196620941,
-0.5015305876731873,
0.17891466617584229,
-0.006486704107373953,
-0.2867071330547333,
-0.8370293378829956,
0.2262231856584549,
-0.5808088779449463,
-0.48837417364120483,
1.3014689683914185,
-0.18969817459583282,
-0.511640727519989,
-0.06209590286016464,
-0.11854252219200134,
0.21144326031208038,
-0.5573573112487793,
0.8764742016792297,
0.4215448200702667,
-0.17646369338035583,
-0.26691246032714844,
-0.12807878851890564,
0.14523561298847198,
0.09291348606348038,
-0.41409435868263245,
0.46696144342422485,
0.41565263271331787,
0.3223167955875397,
-0.0164837297052145,
0.682769775390625,
-0.19994080066680908,
0.24029883742332458,
-0.07620210945606232,
0.1937485635280609,
-0.27800291776657104,
-0.4522123336791992,
-0.2556826174259186,
0.09827830642461777,
-0.0004267062759026885,
-0.3398734927177429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12321v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12321v1
|
Automatic benchmarking of large multimodal models via iterative experiment programming
| 2024-06-18T06:43:46 | 2024-06-18T06:43:46 |
Alessandro Conti, Enrico Fini, Paolo Rota, Yiming Wang, Massimiliano Mancini, Elisa Ricci
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Assessing the capabilities of large multimodal models (LMMs) often requires
the creation of ad-hoc evaluations. Currently, building new benchmarks requires
tremendous amounts of manual work for each specific analysis. This makes the
evaluation process tedious and costly. In this paper, we present APEx,
Automatic Programming of Experiments, the first framework for automatic
benchmarking of LMMs. Given a research question expressed in natural language,
APEx leverages a large language model (LLM) and a library of pre-specified
tools to generate a set of experiments for the model at hand, and progressively
compile a scientific report. The report drives the testing procedure: based on
the current status of the investigation, APEx chooses which experiments to
perform and whether the results are sufficient to draw conclusions. Finally,
the LLM refines the report, presenting the results to the user in natural
language. Thanks to its modularity, our framework is flexible and extensible as
new tools become available. Empirically, APEx reproduces the findings of
existing studies while allowing for arbitrary analyses and hypothesis testing.
|
[
-0.38932016491889954,
-0.7148861289024353,
0.5595628619194031,
0.33912959694862366,
0.04905657842755318,
-0.05580352246761322,
-0.4709774851799011,
-0.33172646164894104,
-0.12341724336147308,
0.1133563444018364,
-0.4259549677371979,
-0.54216068983078,
-0.4656433165073395,
0.4354884922504425,
-0.513665497303009,
0.4382342994213104,
-0.2845824360847473,
0.16691578924655914,
-0.5440192818641663,
-0.269706666469574,
-0.1594669669866562,
-0.13443787395954132,
-0.4131454527378082,
-0.20692802965641022,
0.2984365224838257,
0.2571714222431183,
0.6058284044265747,
0.6790420413017273,
0.5937331318855286,
0.41611966490745544,
0.374228835105896,
0.24373628199100494,
-0.3828117549419403,
0.10625703632831573,
-0.20507661998271942,
-0.17387859523296356,
-0.24374794960021973,
-0.02613489143550396,
0.8264082074165344,
0.761879026889801,
-0.009746604599058628,
0.37440168857574463,
-0.007152123376727104,
0.23986391723155975,
-0.9077640175819397,
0.46118152141571045,
-0.5202981233596802,
0.019253864884376526,
0.11967667937278748,
-0.21925696730613708,
-0.39990130066871643,
-0.5150326490402222,
-0.2299075722694397,
-0.5793992877006531,
-0.04253016412258148,
0.17329466342926025,
0.538351833820343,
0.3507980704307556,
-0.6067917346954346,
-0.23461569845676422,
-0.6850115656852722,
1.057893991470337,
-0.8682734370231628,
0.4237547516822815,
0.36579394340515137,
0.4696256220340729,
-0.06998726725578308,
-0.7298884987831116,
-0.5873405933380127,
-0.7526230812072754,
-0.058235328644514084,
-0.12076412886381149,
-0.3497820198535919,
-0.19257852435112,
0.1570539027452469,
0.3125041723251343,
-0.7008338570594788,
0.09499509632587433,
-0.3776351511478424,
-0.12759041786193848,
0.9514585733413696,
0.4704619348049164,
0.09076841175556183,
-0.013469019904732704,
-0.22194960713386536,
-0.47752243280410767,
-0.4744071364402771,
-0.06087270751595497,
0.09534823149442673,
0.5198559165000916,
0.15653565526008606,
0.6901387572288513,
-0.47377750277519226,
0.7582482695579529,
-0.39702001214027405,
-0.1057252362370491,
0.4679885804653168,
-0.44815948605537415,
-0.26057004928588867,
-0.0998106375336647,
0.9071014523506165,
0.5979130864143372,
0.049551304429769516,
-0.1421094685792923,
-0.3468277156352997,
0.33849936723709106,
0.28449931740760803,
-0.819459855556488,
-0.21605220437049866,
0.29924276471138,
-0.19301313161849976,
-0.15284083783626556,
-0.2678658664226532,
-0.7046546339988708,
-0.22623440623283386,
-0.49738380312919617,
0.8158775568008423,
-0.45816951990127563,
-0.3275950849056244,
-0.0053982241079211235,
-0.0036491225473582745,
-0.2961418330669403,
0.21443066000938416,
-0.591683030128479,
0.5798459053039551,
0.49865853786468506,
0.8116961717605591,
-0.4260362386703491,
-0.46166977286338806,
-0.7759236693382263,
0.04351760447025299,
-0.4694235920906067,
0.9889128804206848,
-0.7573094367980957,
-0.6526833176612854,
-0.01856045052409172,
-0.1097799614071846,
-0.11665680259466171,
-0.5438644886016846,
0.31924697756767273,
-0.24667268991470337,
-0.042620010673999786,
-0.08050619810819626,
-0.6899483799934387,
0.03634263947606087,
0.43608158826828003,
-0.5419214963912964,
1.3906174898147583,
0.20723816752433777,
-0.37625929713249207,
0.4509834051132202,
-0.7221353054046631,
-0.17880523204803467,
-0.013564725406467915,
-0.5170938372612,
-0.32919400930404663,
-0.02722594141960144,
0.17893573641777039,
0.2470032274723053,
-0.5423437356948853,
0.17410212755203247,
-0.5015601515769958,
-0.13533909618854523,
0.06730104237794876,
-0.06690147519111633,
0.45419439673423767,
0.3014957308769226,
-0.3852146565914154,
0.5780134201049805,
-0.8528586626052856,
0.4564328193664551,
0.08975249528884888,
-0.30219393968582153,
-0.25463882088661194,
0.10802596807479858,
0.2500537037849426,
-0.01452806405723095,
0.03685086593031883,
-0.5657086968421936,
0.5690246224403381,
0.004349233582615852,
0.4186720550060272,
0.7237847447395325,
-0.26174765825271606,
0.3795086741447449,
-0.3296351134777069,
0.47589418292045593,
-0.4282703697681427,
0.2940846085548401,
-0.34482884407043457,
-0.15197621285915375,
-0.43742620944976807,
-0.3372025787830353,
0.30222979187965393,
0.3104028105735779,
-0.5203222036361694,
0.16664433479309082,
-0.18741628527641296,
-0.6041003465652466,
-0.2696288824081421,
0.28420940041542053,
0.3151116967201233,
0.32259494066238403,
0.32385167479515076,
-0.25131574273109436,
-0.4747653007507324,
-1.301965594291687,
-0.13935023546218872,
-0.13439467549324036,
-0.120219387114048,
0.3309158384799957,
0.7515182495117188,
-0.1646289825439453,
1.07776939868927,
-0.7146443724632263,
-0.3517124056816101,
-0.04529479891061783,
0.7140488028526306,
-0.06802121549844742,
0.41272521018981934,
0.5352193713188171,
-0.7509492635726929,
-0.380780965089798,
-0.2213074117898941,
-0.8092760443687439,
-0.3868785798549652,
0.054652512073516846,
0.00785452127456665,
-0.2441152036190033,
0.6898491382598877,
-0.23579934239387512,
0.22062203288078308,
0.6002147197723389,
0.011034644208848476,
0.8598577380180359,
-0.19548660516738892,
0.2872123718261719,
-0.6889048218727112,
0.3117538392543793,
-0.006470483262091875,
-0.19175906479358673,
-0.09284171462059021,
0.1817937046289444,
0.26380854845046997,
-0.1863323301076889,
-0.32912206649780273,
0.8455536961555481,
-0.5918198823928833,
-0.2421734482049942,
-0.306829035282135,
-0.1564340889453888,
-0.06324896216392517,
0.350783109664917,
0.047736749053001404,
0.8579766750335693,
0.5675076246261597,
-0.7081756591796875,
0.4286389648914337,
0.17164672911167145,
-0.4736780822277069,
0.49643272161483765,
-0.7365208864212036,
0.09201997518539429,
0.06796904653310776,
0.12464437633752823,
-0.8845520615577698,
-0.15002897381782532,
-0.18905551731586456,
-0.30357739329338074,
-0.02632858231663704,
-0.13558261096477509,
-0.6239993572235107,
-0.34118035435676575,
-0.47050052881240845,
0.2990611493587494,
0.30070099234580994,
-0.21275371313095093,
0.9063504338264465,
0.36334723234176636,
-0.23109811544418335,
-0.3212980628013611,
-0.24252277612686157,
0.208078533411026,
0.1528490036725998,
-0.6050782799720764,
0.3417895436286926,
-0.5245022773742676,
-0.6149353384971619,
0.15849857032299042,
-0.01698344014585018,
-0.15282513201236725,
0.04224564507603645,
0.35830429196357727,
0.0231691412627697,
-0.20564210414886475,
0.17912282049655914,
-0.20387037098407745,
-0.0798039361834526,
0.09615458548069,
0.0907461941242218,
0.5076056718826294,
-0.29226410388946533,
-0.6345049142837524,
-0.11945055425167084,
0.527359664440155,
0.4252767860889435,
-0.4130289852619171,
0.19538381695747375,
0.39529383182525635,
-0.34650102257728577,
-0.5575648546218872,
-0.39346036314964294,
-0.12962482869625092,
-0.5189515948295593,
0.3255433440208435,
-0.32994914054870605,
-0.5137495398521423,
0.16934892535209656,
-0.4367556869983673,
0.3063208758831024,
0.2974373698234558,
0.7056826949119568,
0.3531624972820282,
1.4086508750915527,
0.8548848032951355,
0.23299184441566467,
0.42045196890830994,
-0.21423397958278656,
-0.23569893836975098,
-0.6720704436302185,
-0.023313401266932487,
-0.5296177864074707,
-0.19192881882190704,
-0.025269480422139168,
-0.41581863164901733,
0.8327006101608276,
-0.2491292804479599,
-0.14933046698570251,
0.3302554488182068,
-0.43965160846710205,
0.49872058629989624,
0.5700391530990601,
-0.21279512345790863,
0.5486539602279663,
-0.4283573031425476,
-0.20994244515895844,
0.124517060816288,
-0.47239822149276733,
-0.52999347448349,
1.2933669090270996,
-0.14450252056121826,
0.8956761956214905,
-0.08834829181432724,
0.4513028562068939,
0.5668332576751709,
0.7171594500541687,
-0.6483290791511536,
0.6381407976150513,
0.27929002046585083,
-0.5315789580345154,
-0.20435333251953125,
-0.47090744972229004,
-0.8262039422988892,
0.35077619552612305,
-0.2755174934864044,
-0.6982909440994263,
0.04457499459385872,
0.29548147320747375,
-0.4520168602466583,
0.06294412165880203,
-0.7016773819923401,
0.9509891867637634,
-0.40238329768180847,
-0.6845076084136963,
-0.2821364402770996,
-0.2317318320274353,
0.24499376118183136,
-0.05091390386223793,
0.30914565920829773,
-0.2807033658027649,
0.14011836051940918,
0.6282926201820374,
-0.2163228839635849,
0.5423592925071716,
-0.11711891740560532,
-0.11207585781812668,
0.0318557508289814,
0.4195138216018677,
0.4421478807926178,
0.18643172085285187,
-0.28871795535087585,
-0.11841242015361786,
0.19187913835048676,
-0.26204097270965576,
-0.3975888788700104,
0.8955998420715332,
-0.55449378490448,
-0.4211355745792389,
-0.5678656101226807,
-0.7072197794914246,
-0.4285752475261688,
0.47775813937187195,
-0.0716242790222168,
0.6693483591079712,
-0.5262075662612915,
0.1664997637271881,
0.3545904755592346,
-0.30784156918525696,
0.41408079862594604,
0.8234185576438904,
-0.6085783839225769,
-0.042711906135082245,
0.5982847809791565,
-0.027201494202017784,
0.14191682636737823,
0.17559082806110382,
0.2095838040113449,
-0.16727665066719055,
-0.8448107242584229,
-0.6153517961502075,
-0.17436301708221436,
-0.6945639848709106,
-0.23644283413887024,
-0.7240923643112183,
0.20275463163852692,
-0.4471423923969269,
-0.17680388689041138,
-0.8090497255325317,
-0.15823331475257874,
0.3556530475616455,
0.1099410131573677,
0.2678818702697754,
0.759657621383667,
-0.31909409165382385,
-0.03596419841051102,
-0.6787719130516052,
0.4534345269203186,
0.43015769124031067,
0.4361916482448578,
-0.04072228819131851,
-0.056867826730012894,
-0.2350558042526245,
-0.07834015041589737,
-0.2605186104774475,
-0.4326055347919464,
0.47714880108833313,
0.42266422510147095,
0.6306724548339844,
0.20920634269714355,
0.22356881201267242,
0.5493011474609375,
-0.7249877452850342,
0.6942142844200134,
-0.09133221954107285,
-0.9468368291854858,
0.527446448802948,
-0.32223188877105713,
0.4077816307544708,
0.7565839886665344,
0.5241211652755737,
-0.2819099426269531,
-0.35375702381134033,
-0.10941560566425323,
-1.2058765888214111,
0.4932849705219269,
0.1422102302312851,
-0.06682732701301575,
-0.05394548922777176,
-0.25134018063545227,
0.42814964056015015,
0.3053821325302124,
-0.445109099149704,
-0.0018408318283036351,
-0.059765975922346115,
0.00991668552160263,
-0.25223347544670105,
0.08087052404880524,
-0.7063419818878174,
-0.3207095265388489,
0.514670729637146,
-0.433282732963562,
0.18226277828216553,
0.13695357739925385,
-0.5963378548622131,
-0.29737892746925354,
0.06705991923809052,
0.4600386321544647,
1.3292107582092285,
-0.5484407544136047,
0.2802504003047943,
0.14239364862442017,
-0.05530431866645813,
-0.11056531220674515,
0.2651616036891937,
0.14920265972614288,
-0.11887580156326294,
0.5135652422904968,
0.5459498763084412,
0.4555116295814514,
-1.3046374320983887,
0.4896904528141022,
-0.24201911687850952,
-0.18866991996765137,
-0.6850460767745972,
0.1678030788898468,
0.04757828265428543,
0.22496382892131805,
0.7298341393470764,
-0.11003363877534866,
0.2471223920583725,
-0.7197564244270325,
0.5235885381698608,
0.4341827630996704,
-0.030256908386945724,
-0.3301142156124115,
0.8622222542762756,
0.23444849252700806,
-0.14105366170406342,
0.5020387172698975,
-0.36822009086608887,
-0.2918824255466461,
0.6585824489593506,
0.45584484934806824,
0.6200284361839294,
-0.17188766598701477,
0.05224777013063431,
0.5646957755088806,
0.2783830165863037,
-0.19477182626724243,
0.23458437621593475,
0.03199194744229317,
-0.4882509410381317,
-0.49091118574142456,
-0.7257843017578125,
-0.780406653881073,
0.030804496258497238,
-0.7311388254165649,
0.290290504693985,
-0.44121021032333374,
-0.022938627749681473,
0.49993056058883667,
-0.2647622525691986,
-0.7623138427734375,
0.1393832117319107,
0.3513723611831665,
1.0253503322601318,
-0.9133507013320923,
0.6239300966262817,
0.7540001273155212,
-0.2602936625480652,
-0.38463786244392395,
-0.5121082663536072,
0.39148303866386414,
-0.908201277256012,
0.8107447028160095,
0.13854199647903442,
-0.2601795196533203,
-0.07381118834018707,
-0.703868567943573,
-0.9797489643096924,
1.0016236305236816,
0.25970736145973206,
-0.5333682298660278,
0.3200766444206238,
-0.015447420999407768,
0.4898594319820404,
-0.4787787199020386,
0.6844291090965271,
0.3245910108089447,
0.7871229648590088,
-0.10004721581935883,
-1.3592013120651245,
0.08032790571451187,
-0.8628824353218079,
-0.20477870106697083,
0.24547360837459564,
-0.417809396982193,
1.2218784093856812,
-0.10733815282583237,
-0.10045380145311356,
-0.07431349158287048,
0.4923935532569885,
0.02487955242395401,
0.3375691771507263,
0.7271245718002319,
0.5043116211891174,
0.4849236011505127,
0.08098569512367249,
1.1980440616607666,
-0.42618587613105774,
0.41972604393959045,
1.2078452110290527,
-0.8497512340545654,
0.8571377396583557,
0.25991111993789673,
-0.25428202748298645,
0.3103204369544983,
0.4464774429798126,
-0.33217209577560425,
0.4326445460319519,
0.3654443919658661,
-0.15988214313983917,
-0.3559727370738983,
-0.15319035947322845,
-0.38298824429512024,
0.4922083914279938,
0.13347361981868744,
-0.17154021561145782,
-0.6264466643333435,
0.11989864706993103,
-0.019653957337141037,
0.19522662460803986,
-0.26702243089675903,
0.6186851263046265,
-0.04656625911593437,
-0.6325443983078003,
0.7274793982505798,
0.08101891726255417,
0.7104392647743225,
-1.1085797548294067,
-0.13474039733409882,
-0.14504744112491608,
0.4665440022945404,
-0.12893377244472504,
-0.51610267162323,
0.3538832366466522,
0.03362942859530449,
0.027497543022036552,
-0.3399796485900879,
0.35089707374572754,
-0.27093496918678284,
-0.624323844909668,
0.4098414480686188,
0.4846543073654175,
-0.07995573431253433,
-0.22329482436180115,
-0.642667293548584,
0.4210418462753296,
-0.31141096353530884,
-0.5293543338775635,
0.5025372505187988,
0.0411536730825901,
-0.25780966877937317,
1.0085296630859375,
0.7899048924446106,
0.014931339770555496,
-0.10904219001531601,
0.018878350034356117,
1.1186680793762207,
-0.6711781024932861,
-0.5006749629974365,
-0.8398450613021851,
0.35514628887176514,
-0.1215926855802536,
-0.4311341941356659,
0.9533717632293701,
0.9289748072624207,
0.7613871097564697,
-0.009652216918766499,
0.9886026978492737,
-0.2788967490196228,
0.43691304326057434,
-0.37655821442604065,
0.4372989535331726,
-0.8229630589485168,
0.11389663815498352,
-0.19779431819915771,
-0.9399179816246033,
-0.16670559346675873,
0.40667861700057983,
-0.2944273352622986,
-0.11707888543605804,
0.8330132961273193,
0.8309536576271057,
-0.3018967807292938,
-0.1395293027162552,
0.0620616115629673,
0.33563798666000366,
0.39473816752433777,
0.455114483833313,
0.7513247728347778,
-0.03669163957238197,
0.5259000658988953,
-0.32192665338516235,
-0.4388192296028137,
-0.27555692195892334,
-1.3068739175796509,
-0.7200848460197449,
-0.5360216498374939,
-0.4449848234653473,
-0.047139570116996765,
0.01960025168955326,
1.3114190101623535,
0.8049408197402954,
-0.8324099183082581,
-0.5208677649497986,
0.34367552399635315,
-0.2530645728111267,
-0.5765220522880554,
-0.22662906348705292,
0.4732266366481781,
-0.09741469472646713,
-0.9514116048812866,
0.7681499123573303,
0.2823890447616577,
-0.47018060088157654,
-0.3559366762638092,
0.2565428614616394,
-0.3469504415988922,
-0.013243701308965683,
0.6186326742172241,
0.37409988045692444,
-0.16174544394016266,
-0.24288098514080048,
-0.028573131188750267,
0.09391826391220093,
0.06767448782920837,
0.8920086622238159,
-0.7586444020271301,
0.6418518424034119,
0.3765842318534851,
0.5119088292121887,
0.5200130343437195,
-0.08520049601793289,
0.9232062697410583,
-0.7063124179840088,
0.0581759512424469,
0.5068690180778503,
0.30526378750801086,
0.30473190546035767,
0.12137435376644135,
0.6523962616920471,
-0.05913373455405235,
-0.5484941601753235,
-1.3581061363220215,
0.12399447709321976,
-0.9686326384544373,
-0.5619920492172241,
1.240930438041687,
0.05049299821257591,
-0.2381160408258438,
-0.025632841512560844,
-0.20221658051013947,
-0.011170826852321625,
-0.41121935844421387,
1.0500516891479492,
0.6328650712966919,
-0.3567364513874054,
0.10800555348396301,
-0.8982843160629272,
0.4789833128452301,
0.3182556927204132,
-0.901671826839447,
0.19834747910499573,
0.4112744927406311,
0.4208708107471466,
0.13775165379047394,
0.5293115973472595,
-0.04186646640300751,
0.14699611067771912,
0.21966552734375,
0.4707711935043335,
-0.6414542198181152,
-0.0454084575176239,
-0.0035239653661847115,
0.22127583622932434,
-0.041923582553863525,
0.19940994679927826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12319v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12319v1
|
PRePair: Pointwise Reasoning Enhance Pairwise Evaluating for Robust Instruction-Following Assessments
| 2024-06-18T06:43:04 | 2024-06-18T06:43:04 |
Hawon Jeong, ChaeHun Park, Jimin Hong, Jaegul Choo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pairwise evaluation using large language models (LLMs) is widely used for
evaluating natural language generation (NLG) tasks. However, the reliability of
LLMs is often compromised by biases, such as favoring verbosity and
authoritative tone. In the study, we focus on the comparison of two LLM-based
evaluation approaches, pointwise and pairwise. Our findings demonstrate that
pointwise evaluators exhibit more robustness against undesirable preferences.
Further analysis reveals that pairwise evaluators can accurately identify the
shortcomings of low-quality outputs even when their judgment is incorrect.
These results indicate that LLMs are more severely influenced by their bias in
a pairwise evaluation setup. To mitigate this, we propose a hybrid method that
integrates pointwise reasoning into pairwise evaluation. Experimental results
show that our method enhances the robustness of pairwise evaluators against
adversarial samples while preserving accuracy on normal samples.
|
[
-0.15279720723628998,
-0.8237988352775574,
0.5714040994644165,
0.37397393584251404,
-0.06337030231952667,
0.36634862422943115,
-0.41691458225250244,
-0.08733180910348892,
-0.001453409786336124,
0.3306533694267273,
-0.11436247080564499,
-0.6798557043075562,
-0.6437892913818359,
0.014496330171823502,
-0.32026925683021545,
0.8337602019309998,
-0.0073010604828596115,
0.13754193484783173,
-0.5552359223365784,
-0.1923876702785492,
-0.5716120600700378,
-0.45179513096809387,
-0.78789883852005,
-0.35091617703437805,
0.1418154388666153,
0.26517295837402344,
0.7409057021141052,
0.3422689139842987,
0.2843049168586731,
0.3051575720310211,
0.013407078571617603,
0.32584434747695923,
-0.47679510712623596,
0.22220416367053986,
0.03939949348568916,
-0.17967469990253448,
-0.5725474953651428,
0.025532014667987823,
0.546341061592102,
0.6347486972808838,
-0.017492767423391342,
-0.08093630522489548,
0.29057610034942627,
0.6641302108764648,
-0.9056803584098816,
-0.17040184140205383,
-0.6643069982528687,
-0.17424626648426056,
0.17993870377540588,
-0.22971230745315552,
-0.5912183523178101,
-0.5380169749259949,
0.26291176676750183,
-0.5639104843139648,
0.012457187287509441,
-0.15456467866897583,
0.5299901962280273,
0.4148723781108856,
-0.13716275990009308,
-0.1354028731584549,
-0.5260009169578552,
1.0215141773223877,
-1.031000018119812,
0.4548984169960022,
0.4329497814178467,
0.021251650527119637,
-0.35091084241867065,
-0.6440737247467041,
-0.4835645854473114,
-0.43881338834762573,
-0.09193513542413712,
0.3162105977535248,
-0.14499245584011078,
0.2148747742176056,
0.1183726117014885,
0.17476379871368408,
-0.5963915586471558,
0.3388078510761261,
-0.2152109593153,
-0.2811676561832428,
0.8206369876861572,
-0.06456055492162704,
0.23882804811000824,
-0.514938473701477,
-0.40376046299934387,
-0.19820867478847504,
-0.8432131409645081,
0.12098122388124466,
0.5263862609863281,
0.204431414604187,
0.07914087921380997,
0.36507225036621094,
0.033300936222076416,
0.990227460861206,
0.32667726278305054,
-0.2250973880290985,
0.07361555099487305,
-0.4211704432964325,
-0.22262020409107208,
0.04522711783647537,
0.9948056936264038,
0.6681185960769653,
0.09297507256269455,
-0.23221361637115479,
-0.22341687977313995,
0.14391565322875977,
0.32679086923599243,
-0.5909571647644043,
-0.3573976755142212,
0.29445019364356995,
-0.5002077221870422,
-0.42190995812416077,
0.1995425671339035,
-0.8299237489700317,
-0.31423571705818176,
-0.2312350571155548,
0.565082311630249,
-0.4474771022796631,
0.007832447066903114,
-0.11134083569049835,
-0.08476105332374573,
0.21408991515636444,
0.16203919053077698,
-0.7534966468811035,
0.27320924401283264,
1.0136432647705078,
0.6418740749359131,
-0.4800976812839508,
-0.31367573142051697,
-0.9316487908363342,
-0.00961211696267128,
-0.34611743688583374,
0.7669125199317932,
-0.688292384147644,
-0.6808683276176453,
-0.15213917195796967,
-0.4669405221939087,
-0.21302956342697144,
-0.6425808668136597,
0.5561389327049255,
-0.4131920635700226,
0.5257686376571655,
-0.13635650277137756,
-0.4214889705181122,
-0.05213369429111481,
0.256348192691803,
-0.38740450143814087,
1.3187346458435059,
0.1787300705909729,
-0.8722057342529297,
0.538451075553894,
-0.3293611705303192,
-0.691314697265625,
0.0708889588713646,
-0.40130162239074707,
-0.3628762364387512,
-0.052687983959913254,
0.46621987223625183,
0.4828927516937256,
-0.039141323417425156,
0.3743301331996918,
-0.4334654211997986,
-0.5542044639587402,
-0.04764881357550621,
-0.34259700775146484,
0.5507438778877258,
-0.20236963033676147,
-0.5605589747428894,
0.5447575449943542,
-0.7625031471252441,
0.1429087519645691,
0.02861770987510681,
-0.27073612809181213,
-0.6197786927223206,
0.16073879599571228,
-0.46131032705307007,
0.012307786382734776,
0.29741212725639343,
-0.26202133297920227,
-0.031893663108348846,
-0.5038003325462341,
0.26565513014793396,
0.8795390725135803,
0.10853052139282227,
0.6397544741630554,
-0.3697957396507263,
0.5145716667175293,
-0.3361511826515198,
0.24182479083538055,
0.259295254945755,
-0.537528395652771,
-0.7492774128913879,
0.02215706557035446,
0.21895703673362732,
0.7271723747253418,
-0.948508083820343,
0.6416528820991516,
-0.10581421852111816,
-0.38834255933761597,
-0.3809516727924347,
0.5501803159713745,
0.7776468396186829,
0.9458950161933899,
0.32647785544395447,
-0.09186191111803055,
-0.4511978328227997,
-0.6871374249458313,
-0.34097591042518616,
-0.33990156650543213,
-0.1667557954788208,
0.012315962463617325,
0.11505775153636932,
0.09628105908632278,
0.7137291431427002,
-0.05933304503560066,
0.5544192790985107,
-0.530207633972168,
0.20520654320716858,
0.1209220290184021,
0.4707592725753784,
0.48917317390441895,
-0.6097118258476257,
-0.297679603099823,
-0.40965691208839417,
-0.5417042374610901,
-0.2836659252643585,
-0.156915545463562,
-0.37657493352890015,
0.32251161336898804,
0.2689514756202698,
-0.22675706446170807,
0.5092000365257263,
0.6679787039756775,
-0.3390904366970062,
0.5672035217285156,
-0.13520082831382751,
0.18092159926891327,
-0.9875375032424927,
-0.17034821212291718,
0.26408591866493225,
-0.08695821464061737,
-0.602274477481842,
-0.05250745639204979,
-0.1079169437289238,
0.23200061917304993,
-0.2685134708881378,
0.4791276752948761,
-0.2802392840385437,
-0.2649257779121399,
-0.2323593646287918,
0.4547339677810669,
0.43587708473205566,
0.20157434046268463,
0.11712761968374252,
0.9220685958862305,
0.3559953272342682,
-0.5288998484611511,
0.27969855070114136,
0.2862507104873657,
-0.14434312283992767,
0.7465196847915649,
-0.8716549873352051,
0.4499204754829407,
0.22407138347625732,
0.23053483664989471,
-0.6980517506599426,
0.02611495368182659,
0.4045272469520569,
-0.4925347864627838,
0.4382602870464325,
-0.030969463288784027,
-0.3754359483718872,
-0.29725855588912964,
-0.8876343965530396,
0.09456897526979446,
0.5327578186988831,
-0.8276716470718384,
0.3000911474227905,
-0.005968997720628977,
-0.1289927214384079,
-0.5415551066398621,
-0.5446656346321106,
-0.0967753678560257,
-0.37924328446388245,
-0.800704836845398,
0.20345720648765564,
-0.0664701983332634,
-0.602400541305542,
-0.19550281763076782,
-0.3826355040073395,
0.21454869210720062,
0.1770663857460022,
0.1804029792547226,
0.7020728588104248,
-0.20580196380615234,
-0.1519649773836136,
0.18654689192771912,
-0.20051920413970947,
0.3698148727416992,
-0.2848646938800812,
0.3625113368034363,
-0.23421408236026764,
-0.38138547539711,
-0.07883793860673904,
0.32524991035461426,
0.21546030044555664,
-0.27551743388175964,
0.46822816133499146,
0.5577160716056824,
-0.2570561170578003,
-0.4763483703136444,
-0.5354623794555664,
-0.28364527225494385,
-0.5134193301200867,
0.15877114236354828,
-0.06714914739131927,
-0.6360906958580017,
-0.0010284765157848597,
0.20808598399162292,
0.051370978355407715,
0.31329119205474854,
0.31958770751953125,
-0.13774581253528595,
0.9488612413406372,
0.22887839376926422,
0.1154649406671524,
0.24336682260036469,
-0.11816763132810593,
0.42970383167266846,
-1.0151182413101196,
-0.25538742542266846,
-0.29886430501937866,
-0.37332871556282043,
-0.37355008721351624,
-0.2786847949028015,
0.644528865814209,
0.43603426218032837,
-0.11499247699975967,
0.1569124311208725,
-0.6729118824005127,
0.3130972385406494,
1.011146068572998,
0.3310758173465729,
0.17558130621910095,
-0.08383132517337799,
-0.11411093920469284,
0.010309230536222458,
-0.8189176321029663,
-0.8811425566673279,
1.391254186630249,
0.013206416741013527,
0.4379453957080841,
-0.11525246500968933,
0.8363898992538452,
0.14126449823379517,
0.26720213890075684,
-0.7945746183395386,
0.723605215549469,
-0.25671714544296265,
-0.06732355803251266,
-0.22953124344348907,
-0.5652984976768494,
-0.637107253074646,
0.031189026311039925,
-0.47916388511657715,
-0.9788712859153748,
-0.12084541469812393,
0.38807767629623413,
-0.6769620180130005,
0.40132278203964233,
-0.8117357492446899,
0.834326446056366,
-0.7437946796417236,
-0.6918613910675049,
-0.2096865326166153,
-0.6291537284851074,
0.4557749927043915,
-0.004470020066946745,
-0.05944067984819412,
0.17565785348415375,
0.029976731166243553,
1.0564600229263306,
-0.5568789839744568,
0.6371824145317078,
-0.1473594754934311,
0.0870620384812355,
0.3349425196647644,
0.31600797176361084,
0.35759416222572327,
0.1120186373591423,
-0.2610723078250885,
0.04800856485962868,
-0.04981638491153717,
-0.4422188103199005,
-0.8884701132774353,
1.0098363161087036,
-0.588341236114502,
-0.943697988986969,
-0.15606904029846191,
-0.6093170046806335,
-0.7109832167625427,
0.06297535449266434,
0.3780038356781006,
0.5556690096855164,
-0.007280032150447369,
-0.10241593420505524,
0.5746996402740479,
-0.36445513367652893,
0.508301854133606,
0.06642093509435654,
-0.1023213267326355,
-0.4953106939792633,
0.9022899270057678,
-0.2259720414876938,
0.6149085760116577,
0.38567668199539185,
0.5834524035453796,
-0.293483704328537,
-0.9425042271614075,
-0.46909454464912415,
0.07069490849971771,
-0.7321071028709412,
-0.17208810150623322,
-0.2062142789363861,
-0.0782666951417923,
-0.47558361291885376,
-0.41858941316604614,
-0.08358916640281677,
-0.4953514337539673,
-0.09721463173627853,
-0.21588626503944397,
0.28788912296295166,
0.8213088512420654,
-0.016774823889136314,
0.345647394657135,
-0.7387399077415466,
0.24003872275352478,
0.4530661106109619,
0.218679279088974,
-0.2268134504556656,
-0.473239928483963,
0.2713026702404022,
-0.13641326129436493,
-0.35751378536224365,
-0.899660587310791,
0.053757958114147186,
-0.10308117419481277,
0.6641978621482849,
0.6189130544662476,
0.1883309930562973,
0.4731728136539459,
-0.021496783941984177,
0.8239880800247192,
0.1634349524974823,
-1.051478385925293,
0.7571516633033752,
-0.20866218209266663,
0.15542298555374146,
0.7410153150558472,
0.2963351905345917,
-0.08020578324794769,
-0.2922150194644928,
-0.6610309481620789,
-0.7683019638061523,
0.3897755444049835,
-0.06633420288562775,
-0.3504077196121216,
0.02305740863084793,
0.15907356142997742,
0.16156013309955597,
0.08624246716499329,
-0.38730987906455994,
-0.08899666368961334,
-0.3909350335597992,
-0.2575643062591553,
-0.05564295873045921,
-0.30655431747436523,
-0.20534396171569824,
-0.231176495552063,
0.5748496651649475,
-0.08738195896148682,
-0.08274361491203308,
0.0685054212808609,
0.06743673980236053,
0.08049970865249634,
0.39773932099342346,
0.48561030626296997,
0.898876965045929,
-0.2661294937133789,
0.11911866813898087,
0.4204159080982208,
-0.2710154354572296,
-0.12925033271312714,
0.21624942123889923,
-0.569668173789978,
-0.05178035423159599,
0.7709940671920776,
0.773645281791687,
0.5735480189323425,
-0.6585234999656677,
0.7864135503768921,
0.030273618176579475,
-0.032310258597135544,
-0.061069365590810776,
0.03780185431241989,
0.020428791642189026,
0.05549708753824234,
0.05010247975587845,
0.1428503394126892,
0.052845828235149384,
-0.2559269964694977,
0.06409185379743576,
0.549148678779602,
-0.0752360075712204,
-0.29300329089164734,
0.605686366558075,
0.4104149341583252,
-0.3712344169616699,
0.5580495595932007,
-0.2778356373310089,
-0.7348989248275757,
0.48351603746414185,
0.5315989851951599,
0.8542940616607666,
-0.21506346762180328,
0.16886746883392334,
0.32477909326553345,
0.3081768751144409,
0.11220291256904602,
0.3425323963165283,
-0.21472719311714172,
-0.6902102828025818,
-0.3901052474975586,
-0.4770938754081726,
-0.6382573843002319,
-0.007792622782289982,
-0.7204152941703796,
0.12069830298423767,
-0.8701981902122498,
0.0474461168050766,
-0.465169221162796,
-0.1310984492301941,
-0.39641085267066956,
0.10092449933290482,
0.25124964118003845,
0.7915687561035156,
-0.6849620938301086,
0.7186546921730042,
0.7421136498451233,
-0.16804750263690948,
-1.0388706922531128,
0.18336106836795807,
0.09651320427656174,
-0.9747031927108765,
0.37993961572647095,
0.05141934007406235,
-0.3359794020652771,
-0.43914851546287537,
-0.16767041385173798,
-0.40729808807373047,
1.0541468858718872,
0.14841073751449585,
-0.6404221653938293,
-0.020761117339134216,
-0.0959148034453392,
0.3441338837146759,
-0.10346227139234543,
0.37235966324806213,
0.8810904026031494,
0.6878682971000671,
0.16361981630325317,
-0.8664930462837219,
0.16518697142601013,
-0.18608412146568298,
-0.07253266125917435,
0.2383514642715454,
-0.44795140624046326,
0.40215909481048584,
-0.35191288590431213,
-0.1258934885263443,
-0.047292087227106094,
0.5319628119468689,
0.6731476187705994,
0.6973077058792114,
0.7587774991989136,
0.5212118029594421,
0.7320404648780823,
-0.1839280128479004,
1.0534350872039795,
-0.42513972520828247,
-0.3250274956226349,
1.3051339387893677,
-0.296728253364563,
1.0823904275894165,
0.5416396856307983,
-0.21121671795845032,
0.46800559759140015,
0.5091776847839355,
0.1623029112815857,
0.27542799711227417,
0.25248268246650696,
-0.27928370237350464,
-0.3804013133049011,
0.10750427842140198,
-0.2120080143213272,
0.4440174102783203,
0.17355217039585114,
-0.1274971216917038,
0.05029379203915596,
-0.3746405243873596,
0.29823267459869385,
0.6886563897132874,
-0.4344531297683716,
0.6025779247283936,
0.048309460282325745,
-0.9536817669868469,
0.46543920040130615,
-0.13220031559467316,
0.9653774499893188,
-0.5804524421691895,
0.01591133140027523,
-0.3159802556037903,
0.010093973018229008,
-0.48416006565093994,
-0.705382227897644,
0.36371251940727234,
0.20752784609794617,
0.17776373028755188,
-0.3730904757976532,
0.9213385581970215,
-0.15682458877563477,
-0.5526894927024841,
0.5080435276031494,
0.5404551029205322,
-0.24452130496501923,
0.06881020218133926,
-0.5787267684936523,
0.0869007259607315,
0.04064202308654785,
-0.08572079241275787,
0.15787319839000702,
-0.11862543225288391,
-0.2416049689054489,
0.4227633774280548,
0.7186723351478577,
0.30192774534225464,
0.17588907480239868,
0.14139120280742645,
0.7141206860542297,
-0.43373069167137146,
-0.21215344965457916,
-0.8554317355155945,
0.22292135655879974,
-0.16315825283527374,
-0.38132694363594055,
0.9016571640968323,
0.4608161747455597,
0.9207296371459961,
0.3440271317958832,
0.8662860989570618,
0.11487924307584763,
0.48599687218666077,
-0.7052018642425537,
0.5715505480766296,
-0.19084741175174713,
0.4781501293182373,
-0.3509090542793274,
-0.9373494386672974,
-0.2727853059768677,
0.48439064621925354,
-0.8475285172462463,
0.10257067531347275,
0.6360429525375366,
0.7529547810554504,
-0.02084028348326683,
0.052814334630966187,
0.21604718267917633,
-0.023618454113602638,
0.175919771194458,
0.7661400437355042,
1.1648348569869995,
-0.1326584368944168,
0.563384473323822,
-0.6095941066741943,
-0.4081856906414032,
0.2010941356420517,
-0.9716559648513794,
-1.1935133934020996,
-0.1292448192834854,
-0.26406049728393555,
-0.49829623103141785,
0.17637817561626434,
0.9567049741744995,
0.6478054523468018,
-0.8221516013145447,
-0.18575580418109894,
-0.04427158087491989,
0.3222081959247589,
-0.134697824716568,
-0.24814216792583466,
0.48469167947769165,
-0.07521318644285202,
-0.6703525185585022,
0.9320011734962463,
0.34148138761520386,
-0.22172395884990692,
-0.4163516163825989,
-0.4764375686645508,
0.046340201050043106,
0.02051762118935585,
0.46479952335357666,
0.20242959260940552,
-0.7936122417449951,
-0.4105556607246399,
-0.09768698364496231,
0.07085159420967102,
0.05341744050383568,
0.7709686756134033,
-0.8369647860527039,
0.4213884472846985,
0.7526015639305115,
0.6924881935119629,
-0.04854125156998634,
0.30609485507011414,
0.8801377415657043,
-0.5193151235580444,
0.08688608556985855,
0.3843132257461548,
0.46315085887908936,
0.6061062812805176,
-0.2647918462753296,
0.3176425099372864,
0.1396765559911728,
-0.4210927486419678,
-0.5970090627670288,
0.06044642627239227,
-1.1034204959869385,
-0.044951461255550385,
1.2766940593719482,
-0.3239164352416992,
-0.005826101638376713,
0.3458663821220398,
0.0026558369863778353,
0.23591093719005585,
-0.34740161895751953,
0.6652035117149353,
0.4478013813495636,
-0.34079205989837646,
-0.07145827263593674,
-0.29198288917541504,
0.2594854533672333,
0.7438744902610779,
-0.956716001033783,
-0.5495493412017822,
0.4650310277938843,
0.19528339803218842,
-0.02151682786643505,
0.22055207192897797,
0.06872046738862991,
0.2800537943840027,
-0.05833907797932625,
-0.2857723534107208,
-0.2251957654953003,
-0.20926184952259064,
-0.4556185007095337,
0.03382481634616852,
0.19858267903327942,
-0.3297884464263916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12317v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12317v1
|
Finding Task-specific Subnetworks in Multi-task Spoken Language Understanding Model
| 2024-06-18T06:39:41 | 2024-06-18T06:39:41 |
Hayato Futami, Siddhant Arora, Yosuke Kashiwagi, Emiru Tsunoo, Shinji Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Recently, multi-task spoken language understanding (SLU) models have emerged,
designed to address various speech processing tasks. However, these models
often rely on a large number of parameters. Also, they often encounter
difficulties in adapting to new data for a specific task without experiencing
catastrophic forgetting of previously trained tasks. In this study, we propose
finding task-specific subnetworks within a multi-task SLU model via neural
network pruning. In addition to model compression, we expect that the
forgetting of previously trained tasks can be mitigated by updating only a
task-specific subnetwork. We conduct experiments on top of the state-of-the-art
multi-task SLU model ``UniverSLU'', trained for several tasks such as emotion
recognition (ER), intent classification (IC), and automatic speech recognition
(ASR). We show that pruned models were successful in adapting to additional ASR
or IC data with minimal performance degradation on previously trained tasks.
|
[
-0.2091824859380722,
-0.5673001408576965,
0.317959189414978,
0.12405122071504593,
-0.37758272886276245,
-0.2915964424610138,
-0.29585519433021545,
-0.11021920293569565,
0.2501121461391449,
0.44133928418159485,
-0.8201069831848145,
-0.41368231177330017,
-0.3864791691303253,
-0.23310013115406036,
-0.3123578131198883,
0.7203917503356934,
0.05611133947968483,
-0.2810872197151184,
-0.3434649407863617,
-0.3325483500957489,
-0.7186780571937561,
-0.6513273119926453,
-0.7533080577850342,
-0.6438451409339905,
0.4042533338069916,
0.5574260950088501,
0.14865659177303314,
0.15163061022758484,
0.14011195302009583,
0.37710168957710266,
-0.3634168803691864,
0.08586963266134262,
-0.4810028374195099,
0.19253326952457428,
-0.017666194587945938,
-0.7080998420715332,
-0.33289533853530884,
-0.3166033625602722,
0.9126648306846619,
0.7223014235496521,
-0.36169546842575073,
0.278433233499527,
0.12336497753858566,
0.5365742444992065,
-0.5111885666847229,
0.20232178270816803,
-0.6664954423904419,
0.24555906653404236,
-0.15415352582931519,
-0.19333899021148682,
-0.5001420378684998,
0.38759347796440125,
0.226339191198349,
-0.6477771401405334,
0.45652252435684204,
-0.26566600799560547,
0.6830869913101196,
0.37453389167785645,
-0.25717851519584656,
0.030572062358260155,
-0.5854208469390869,
0.7892683744430542,
-0.8871724009513855,
0.4665950536727905,
0.37947985529899597,
-0.08677433431148529,
-0.20699550211429596,
-0.5387352705001831,
-0.22252966463565826,
-0.30570968985557556,
-0.17915818095207214,
0.2873525321483612,
-0.5850366950035095,
0.20003171265125275,
0.20210491120815277,
0.032669320702552795,
-0.5270846486091614,
0.1413763165473938,
-0.4703102111816406,
-0.25813430547714233,
0.3441474735736847,
0.016304466873407364,
0.2716240882873535,
0.014008305966854095,
-0.11169314384460449,
0.21678024530410767,
-0.5779683589935303,
0.15173391997814178,
0.334883451461792,
0.32929813861846924,
0.15755745768547058,
0.31035035848617554,
-0.137492373585701,
0.6832878589630127,
-0.15242236852645874,
-0.09269528836011887,
0.41174790263175964,
-0.3296435475349426,
-0.4481338560581207,
-0.03951716795563698,
0.46644681692123413,
-0.1291513741016388,
0.4459722638130188,
-0.21315060555934906,
-0.19214428961277008,
0.0032615007366985083,
0.4917547106742859,
-0.20273646712303162,
-0.5185949206352234,
0.1825752556324005,
-0.5297316908836365,
0.10167841613292694,
-0.4126752018928528,
0.08852856606245041,
-0.11967450380325317,
-0.3818050026893616,
0.2337101250886917,
-0.4637176990509033,
-0.5368850231170654,
-0.046406373381614685,
-0.11422323435544968,
-0.27407318353652954,
0.3109334707260132,
-0.43301233649253845,
0.28651708364486694,
0.4772695004940033,
0.9101837277412415,
-0.08612918108701706,
-0.7624830603599548,
-0.39349302649497986,
-0.13802453875541687,
-0.150155171751976,
0.544467568397522,
-0.26023679971694946,
-0.15232357382774353,
-0.3275493383407593,
0.20797385275363922,
-0.6053420305252075,
-0.6341832876205444,
0.510558009147644,
-0.3076331913471222,
-0.3852055072784424,
-0.08872154355049133,
-0.3716883361339569,
-0.4604722857475281,
0.2264057695865631,
-0.7815578579902649,
0.8117138147354126,
-0.29323717951774597,
-0.7652578949928284,
-0.17678788304328918,
-0.6227999925613403,
-0.706140398979187,
-0.054856814444065094,
-0.0047096991911530495,
-0.5575069189071655,
0.707843005657196,
0.12460269033908844,
0.45719465613365173,
-0.10996757447719574,
0.4290722608566284,
-0.07880648225545883,
-0.353899210691452,
0.21914216876029968,
-0.24243919551372528,
0.5848621726036072,
0.05988740548491478,
-0.13136713206768036,
0.5219135284423828,
-0.41022437810897827,
-0.12812864780426025,
0.06724730134010315,
-0.3014475405216217,
-0.5228955149650574,
0.09238392859697342,
-0.10504038631916046,
0.16534629464149475,
0.0957992672920227,
-0.5613905787467957,
-0.03448078781366348,
-0.0876883789896965,
0.7176490426063538,
0.6632548570632935,
-0.0930345207452774,
0.3801763653755188,
-0.47293075919151306,
0.5461137890815735,
0.5030558705329895,
0.13679859042167664,
-0.23459357023239136,
-0.4301908314228058,
-1.0672471523284912,
0.20950761437416077,
0.14019794762134552,
0.5781503915786743,
-0.5404541492462158,
0.008368401788175106,
-0.15312959253787994,
-0.6314586997032166,
-0.6527912020683289,
0.12610265612602234,
0.495472252368927,
0.5220675468444824,
0.3827444911003113,
-0.41334062814712524,
-0.4912005662918091,
-1.1217516660690308,
-0.28294336795806885,
-0.05068819969892502,
0.06548377871513367,
0.5036482810974121,
0.43174293637275696,
-0.0933927670121193,
0.7851367592811584,
-0.2928348481655121,
-0.4741404354572296,
-0.4960078299045563,
0.4315609335899353,
0.259843111038208,
0.603039026260376,
0.1437249630689621,
-1.0292162895202637,
-0.082516610622406,
-0.05311768501996994,
-0.4364128112792969,
-0.0210834089666605,
-0.4780126214027405,
0.3583035469055176,
-0.2952517569065094,
0.3777661919593811,
-0.7264969348907471,
0.4497045576572418,
0.5054079294204712,
0.07122015208005905,
0.731357991695404,
-0.3528677225112915,
-0.16776210069656372,
-0.8096578121185303,
0.07751323282718658,
0.26298898458480835,
-0.12960128486156464,
-1.2095500230789185,
-0.0006013410747982562,
0.06881732493638992,
-0.225608691573143,
-0.5549662709236145,
0.22713357210159302,
-0.7636125087738037,
-0.345348060131073,
-0.24629327654838562,
0.08934438228607178,
-0.06916698813438416,
0.8576938509941101,
0.33310797810554504,
0.5396154522895813,
0.8085771203041077,
-0.746189534664154,
0.2269655466079712,
0.05050458386540413,
-0.22599051892757416,
0.11083360016345978,
-0.6731269359588623,
0.4900730848312378,
-0.40056556463241577,
0.31027084589004517,
-0.7569931745529175,
0.31652355194091797,
-0.11098448932170868,
-0.39944273233413696,
0.25879964232444763,
-0.5321177244186401,
-0.009416832588613033,
-0.12780587375164032,
0.22405773401260376,
0.40845468640327454,
0.17797061800956726,
-0.18866784870624542,
0.9541012048721313,
0.5457067489624023,
-0.3177521824836731,
-0.645738422870636,
-0.7816289663314819,
-0.015905657783150673,
-0.21363849937915802,
-0.5583760142326355,
0.5397229790687561,
-0.028072591871023178,
-0.03500333055853844,
0.029075052589178085,
-0.3880729675292969,
-0.1641140878200531,
0.2812526226043701,
0.4349866211414337,
-0.1318492591381073,
-0.23521050810813904,
0.14171630144119263,
-0.07508458197116852,
-0.19593282043933868,
-0.1219257265329361,
-0.3042394518852234,
0.6324748396873474,
-0.2061331868171692,
-0.4890015423297882,
-0.6585091352462769,
0.5460789799690247,
0.6763253211975098,
-0.5481812357902527,
0.45021530985832214,
0.7508253455162048,
-0.5223307013511658,
-0.3074875473976135,
-0.5312321186065674,
-0.2955082356929779,
-0.4234773814678192,
0.7715673446655273,
-0.6758348345756531,
-1.0013841390609741,
0.5985971689224243,
-0.28083840012550354,
0.20837807655334473,
0.03908233344554901,
0.38322004675865173,
-0.10246581584215164,
0.7408885955810547,
0.7322260737419128,
-0.21477611362934113,
0.6177888512611389,
-0.19354000687599182,
0.11679555475711823,
-1.0756536722183228,
-0.15117602050304413,
-0.5058545470237732,
-0.6011518239974976,
-0.06009983271360397,
-0.3916429281234741,
0.2279539406299591,
0.09883594512939453,
0.236812561750412,
0.5550198554992676,
-0.42767980694770813,
0.20960572361946106,
0.8815581798553467,
0.2607642114162445,
0.13009019196033478,
-0.14587563276290894,
-0.08654270321130753,
0.12157680094242096,
-1.0917121171951294,
-0.03939609229564667,
0.5546045899391174,
0.3730311095714569,
0.4922664165496826,
-0.01915569417178631,
0.6449393630027771,
0.13826194405555725,
0.16913573443889618,
-0.7006760239601135,
0.552782416343689,
-0.46386703848838806,
-0.2743065357208252,
-0.33396831154823303,
-0.6999072432518005,
-1.0182219743728638,
0.405415415763855,
0.0777844712138176,
-0.932185173034668,
0.2887665331363678,
0.39037904143333435,
-0.2851639688014984,
0.328104168176651,
-0.8548473715782166,
0.8892724514007568,
-0.15563978254795074,
0.2659118175506592,
-0.4143974483013153,
-0.48751288652420044,
0.168412446975708,
0.09603670984506607,
0.2911604940891266,
-0.2829242944717407,
0.3461819887161255,
0.9738495945930481,
0.005028727930039167,
1.0459903478622437,
-0.4412679672241211,
0.2634687125682831,
0.26661166548728943,
0.13696728646755219,
0.47156742215156555,
-0.18302775919437408,
-0.008462945930659771,
0.11080782860517502,
-0.15659621357917786,
-0.33935990929603577,
-0.5342636704444885,
0.7323625087738037,
-0.6536002159118652,
-0.5590006113052368,
-0.15819424390792847,
-0.9272794723510742,
-0.19703762233257294,
0.06554887443780899,
0.1923920065164566,
0.6225074529647827,
0.05004739388823509,
0.20542114973068237,
0.8187539577484131,
-0.20375841856002808,
0.4556182622909546,
0.4606567621231079,
0.28964635729789734,
0.0885852724313736,
0.8988208174705505,
0.21356190741062164,
0.15820716321468353,
0.3371959924697876,
0.21260617673397064,
-0.09609394520521164,
-1.0160508155822754,
-0.17645399272441864,
0.1437540501356125,
-0.6166728734970093,
-0.16516521573066711,
-0.4809061288833618,
-0.07403777539730072,
-0.3655073940753937,
0.2651214301586151,
-0.49552518129348755,
-0.09986226260662079,
-0.5449821352958679,
-0.10624920576810837,
0.21319466829299927,
0.5932213068008423,
0.09776485711336136,
0.4492216110229492,
-0.8561062216758728,
0.2539343535900116,
0.12593668699264526,
0.09089402109384537,
0.2537895143032074,
-0.7155866026878357,
-0.18961356580257416,
0.14291439950466156,
0.1715199202299118,
-1.0801323652267456,
0.47266992926597595,
0.5874282717704773,
0.7458241581916809,
0.05591747537255287,
0.05244852975010872,
0.9651760458946228,
-0.47583523392677307,
0.508367121219635,
0.3419085443019867,
-1.012844204902649,
0.5978301167488098,
-0.037614643573760986,
0.8254250288009644,
0.4355289936065674,
0.2559814453125,
-0.8824148774147034,
-0.22973424196243286,
-0.6069864630699158,
-0.9125056862831116,
0.871242880821228,
0.2159568816423416,
0.0710562989115715,
0.3383701741695404,
0.406064510345459,
-0.26475247740745544,
0.13216394186019897,
-0.7619413137435913,
-0.3563939929008484,
-0.10666655004024506,
-0.18136289715766907,
-0.1622404307126999,
-0.0881921648979187,
-0.09080018848180771,
-0.16969476640224457,
0.7070074081420898,
-0.14613918960094452,
0.35860776901245117,
0.3943946659564972,
-0.6154916882514954,
0.06335793435573578,
0.40738189220428467,
0.5685521960258484,
0.581001877784729,
0.11751724034547806,
0.2715734541416168,
0.40972062945365906,
-0.5596064925193787,
0.10052629560232162,
0.015336408279836178,
-0.1286812275648117,
0.21668025851249695,
0.3972637355327606,
1.237337589263916,
0.39560824632644653,
-0.6508172750473022,
0.26336729526519775,
-0.12559129297733307,
-0.14764323830604553,
-0.28211766481399536,
0.07034069299697876,
0.3699122369289398,
0.25682076811790466,
0.591236412525177,
0.24019008874893188,
-0.02231314592063427,
-0.5338558554649353,
0.3865751326084137,
0.24921417236328125,
-0.5242712497711182,
-0.33568015694618225,
0.17222951352596283,
-0.016721319407224655,
-0.5813133120536804,
0.8027677536010742,
-0.13306201994419098,
-0.6844872236251831,
0.8326902389526367,
0.7620515823364258,
0.6223976016044617,
-0.3305934965610504,
0.10960033535957336,
0.10730920732021332,
0.49258002638816833,
-0.05834149196743965,
0.265768438577652,
-0.05678116902709007,
-0.8405096530914307,
-0.6022179126739502,
-0.43838074803352356,
-0.2111825793981552,
0.2822187542915344,
-0.8443055152893066,
-0.17028236389160156,
-0.17393018305301666,
-0.2930313050746918,
0.014310553669929504,
-0.18072734773159027,
-0.5859302878379822,
0.42988690733909607,
0.12054557353258133,
0.7975899577140808,
-0.9891915321350098,
1.2369616031646729,
0.8751344680786133,
-0.0007974403561092913,
-0.9901167750358582,
-0.28811725974082947,
0.11976197361946106,
-0.47799158096313477,
0.3706183135509491,
0.08952556550502777,
-0.1072433665394783,
0.14268529415130615,
0.006083908025175333,
-0.8570480346679688,
1.0391967296600342,
0.43404704332351685,
-0.9772817492485046,
-0.09897765517234802,
-0.1929490864276886,
0.23894374072551727,
-0.2433062493801117,
0.29889971017837524,
0.5265528559684753,
0.21963469684123993,
-0.12656933069229126,
-1.1839373111724854,
-0.028772320598363876,
-0.6159713864326477,
-0.28542670607566833,
0.3690730035305023,
-0.4750547409057617,
0.9922446608543396,
-0.19546915590763092,
-0.119580939412117,
-0.21655721962451935,
0.6946690678596497,
0.2538275122642517,
0.3686649203300476,
0.9629924297332764,
0.7166640758514404,
0.7852637767791748,
-0.14900846779346466,
0.3810480535030365,
0.10705042630434036,
0.4625244438648224,
1.3316192626953125,
0.053423184901475906,
0.6984127759933472,
0.4152125418186188,
0.07066208869218826,
0.15139146149158478,
0.6342344284057617,
0.17140883207321167,
0.368733286857605,
0.3186115026473999,
-0.10414198786020279,
-0.4030936062335968,
-0.23026251792907715,
0.027605712413787842,
0.4629179537296295,
0.47443056106567383,
-0.0425507053732872,
-0.05340496823191643,
0.33820483088493347,
0.076752208173275,
-0.2756170928478241,
-0.4357290267944336,
0.7419003248214722,
0.2361426204442978,
-0.819719135761261,
0.5732366442680359,
0.05688628554344177,
0.6459172368049622,
-0.7237386107444763,
0.1752195805311203,
-0.2782515287399292,
0.09596895426511765,
-0.235602468252182,
-0.5021477937698364,
0.4518371820449829,
-0.19618315994739532,
-0.1448344737291336,
-0.24667765200138092,
1.0860904455184937,
-0.5721880793571472,
-0.2134978473186493,
0.46791979670524597,
0.4445111155509949,
0.240379199385643,
-0.41911423206329346,
-0.9916313290596008,
0.21826161444187164,
0.28512370586395264,
-0.24417805671691895,
0.4875127673149109,
0.14920209348201752,
0.09628802537918091,
0.8755671381950378,
0.7346811890602112,
0.046608079224824905,
0.14191178977489471,
0.4435877203941345,
0.7375669479370117,
-0.5079450607299805,
-0.5619386434555054,
-0.5386264324188232,
0.36002224683761597,
-0.028492815792560577,
-0.3949468731880188,
0.5821201205253601,
0.19369031488895416,
0.707841694355011,
-0.037300728261470795,
0.6994587182998657,
0.060672711580991745,
0.18705058097839355,
-0.362745076417923,
0.5247087478637695,
-0.6109250783920288,
-0.032051797956228256,
-0.13835184276103973,
-0.4852457046508789,
-0.2155345380306244,
0.6910310983657837,
-0.23199106752872467,
-0.21487005054950714,
0.6074532270431519,
0.7202182412147522,
-0.23532456159591675,
0.12837402522563934,
0.27600809931755066,
0.3020492494106293,
0.03626721724867821,
0.8698914647102356,
0.5216969847679138,
-0.08243224024772644,
0.5945211052894592,
-0.5760774612426758,
-0.20175953209400177,
-0.0021908048074692488,
-0.7838044166564941,
-0.7665984630584717,
-0.8465357422828674,
-0.47791460156440735,
0.021165354177355766,
0.13926753401756287,
0.5171090960502625,
1.0312860012054443,
-0.7323801517486572,
-0.32621634006500244,
-0.21790586411952972,
0.15592211484909058,
-0.6215376853942871,
-0.13308316469192505,
0.3629484474658966,
-0.2031661719083786,
-0.47503745555877686,
0.9064396619796753,
0.23760907351970673,
-0.19345234334468842,
-0.10012905299663544,
-0.045076884329319,
-0.558364748954773,
-0.24057048559188843,
0.2042926698923111,
0.39367353916168213,
-0.6904247403144836,
-0.11692304164171219,
0.03487665206193924,
0.5039449334144592,
-0.008536085486412048,
1.1926056146621704,
-0.638364851474762,
0.20782223343849182,
0.36488911509513855,
0.5074098110198975,
0.8324233293533325,
-0.018414553254842758,
0.49783003330230713,
-1.1902711391448975,
0.24847394227981567,
0.456180602312088,
0.7553077340126038,
0.29467567801475525,
-0.24713294208049774,
0.07364197820425034,
0.20023325085639954,
-0.4664815068244934,
-0.7789009809494019,
0.4660979211330414,
-0.9699422717094421,
-0.4919942021369934,
0.9223200082778931,
-0.5545137524604797,
-0.30348169803619385,
-0.3890916705131531,
-0.024545365944504738,
0.4099036157131195,
-0.18429332971572876,
0.31945425271987915,
0.48588159680366516,
-0.2291577011346817,
-0.5514224171638489,
-0.4057733118534088,
0.20722270011901855,
0.8829360008239746,
-0.6260585784912109,
0.28247612714767456,
0.11248846352100372,
0.2843852937221527,
0.21762442588806152,
0.6607648730278015,
0.480753093957901,
0.2909581959247589,
-0.1076819896697998,
-0.05168544128537178,
-0.3578941524028778,
-0.6914234757423401,
-0.3086673319339752,
0.26151660084724426,
-0.10224192589521408,
-0.3612247109413147
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12307v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12307v1
|
Can Tool-augmented Large Language Models be Aware of Incomplete Conditions?
| 2024-06-18T06:28:06 | 2024-06-18T06:28:06 |
Seungbin Yang, ChaeHun Park, Taehee Kim, Jaegul Choo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in integrating large language models (LLMs) with tools
have allowed the models to interact with real-world environments. However,
these tool-augmented LLMs often encounter incomplete scenarios when users
provide partial information or the necessary tools are unavailable. Recognizing
and managing such scenarios is crucial for LLMs to ensure their reliability,
but this exploration remains understudied. This study examines whether LLMs can
identify incomplete conditions and appropriately determine when to refrain from
using tools. To this end, we address a dataset by manipulating instances from
two datasets by removing necessary tools or essential information for tool
invocation. We confirm that most LLMs are challenged to identify the additional
information required to utilize specific tools and the absence of appropriate
tools. Our research can contribute to advancing reliable LLMs by addressing
scenarios that commonly arise during interactions between humans and LLMs.
|
[
-0.2784324288368225,
-0.9204831719398499,
1.1121528148651123,
0.25527527928352356,
-0.18523412942886353,
0.39940887689590454,
-0.4457428753376007,
-0.6617429256439209,
0.016920069232583046,
0.4777802526950836,
-0.7003457546234131,
-0.23236481845378876,
-0.6052669286727905,
0.11379721015691757,
-0.6259569525718689,
0.6468371748924255,
-0.28262558579444885,
-0.15135236084461212,
-0.7118786573410034,
-0.05634821951389313,
-0.786587655544281,
-0.4772120714187622,
-0.5250825881958008,
-0.6186268329620361,
0.36430859565734863,
0.4443495273590088,
0.8191030621528625,
0.34493130445480347,
0.5048902630805969,
0.3506676256656647,
-0.23731866478919983,
0.1200803592801094,
-0.3151436746120453,
0.18591611087322235,
-0.08993355184793472,
-0.1532253921031952,
-0.5920929312705994,
-0.060925502330064774,
0.47928112745285034,
1.2502951622009277,
-0.19512170553207397,
0.127824068069458,
0.4922114610671997,
0.16025717556476593,
-0.5524781942367554,
0.08582541346549988,
-0.6284334659576416,
0.29359346628189087,
-0.2279316484928131,
-0.24171416461467743,
-0.3660426437854767,
0.03072340413928032,
0.1950000822544098,
-0.5629620552062988,
0.19143061339855194,
-0.029137080535292625,
0.6133256554603577,
0.42870256304740906,
-0.4904825687408447,
-0.25514236092567444,
-0.9487099051475525,
0.5919030904769897,
-0.6901068091392517,
0.291774719953537,
0.7312815189361572,
-0.024011163040995598,
-0.776235818862915,
-0.37124621868133545,
-0.7324983477592468,
-0.014297903515398502,
-0.34735679626464844,
-0.010968491435050964,
-0.09527618438005447,
0.12431123107671738,
0.6052456498146057,
0.11387556046247482,
-0.21394194662570953,
0.5197380185127258,
-0.48675215244293213,
-0.4176200032234192,
0.20300619304180145,
0.4138903021812439,
0.39195170998573303,
-0.4705977737903595,
-0.13123859465122223,
0.3343232572078705,
-0.9667144417762756,
-0.06281345337629318,
0.2888219356536865,
0.2838534712791443,
-0.3554660975933075,
0.8888370394706726,
0.22030767798423767,
0.8974704742431641,
-0.21207474172115326,
-0.27873823046684265,
0.28087010979652405,
-0.3123491108417511,
-0.5403504967689514,
-0.07023494690656662,
0.5854372978210449,
0.09513749182224274,
0.08186497539281845,
-0.4441675543785095,
-0.6410912275314331,
-0.45003554224967957,
0.0604042112827301,
-0.15967537462711334,
0.06691808998584747,
0.6512200832366943,
-0.050304822623729706,
-0.03928598016500473,
-0.13735021650791168,
-0.4138569235801697,
-0.866599440574646,
-0.42440372705459595,
0.6306652426719666,
0.03029656782746315,
-0.6614235043525696,
-0.1541178971529007,
-0.21020907163619995,
0.15919871628284454,
0.5005972385406494,
-0.33303552865982056,
0.24437856674194336,
0.6180497407913208,
0.9705365896224976,
-0.056204717606306076,
-0.2808731496334076,
-0.7593028545379639,
0.2959761619567871,
-0.4172405004501343,
0.33569255471229553,
-0.5616170167922974,
-0.6221842169761658,
0.05042455717921257,
0.3264477849006653,
0.16673141717910767,
-0.6478793025016785,
0.4242696166038513,
-0.41272348165512085,
0.18104375898838043,
-0.3862278461456299,
-0.48559293150901794,
-0.09672888368368149,
0.17532497644424438,
-0.873613178730011,
1.0703409910202026,
0.2607302963733673,
-0.818058431148529,
0.32140496373176575,
-0.40911564230918884,
-0.543225109577179,
0.09199748188257217,
-0.14859071373939514,
-0.47311854362487793,
0.12485670298337936,
-0.0020129845943301916,
0.5856630206108093,
-0.34587016701698303,
0.5099153518676758,
-0.7287154793739319,
-0.5603600740432739,
0.18330954015254974,
-0.3978732228279114,
0.5616516470909119,
0.07390852272510529,
-0.19767706096172333,
-0.051840923726558685,
-0.5518115758895874,
-0.1457117646932602,
0.2139573097229004,
-0.4377409517765045,
-0.3280036747455597,
0.2666328251361847,
0.05258767679333687,
0.30092889070510864,
0.4310780167579651,
-0.5439368486404419,
0.1536264717578888,
-0.3604256510734558,
0.4541473686695099,
0.9219911694526672,
0.022568529471755028,
0.3991551399230957,
-0.09605319797992706,
0.5809425711631775,
0.17909350991249084,
-0.05464094504714012,
0.07879140228033066,
-0.0839349627494812,
-1.2193083763122559,
-0.15313182771205902,
0.29822415113449097,
0.6949529647827148,
-0.9473972320556641,
0.5315836071968079,
-0.22393660247325897,
-0.08544326573610306,
-0.437104731798172,
0.3561534881591797,
0.3391256332397461,
0.33162492513656616,
0.1285991668701172,
0.015929030254483223,
-0.7668753862380981,
-0.8265783786773682,
0.06076239421963692,
0.06365001201629639,
-0.14549532532691956,
0.38879141211509705,
0.32267630100250244,
-0.08270324766635895,
1.0542237758636475,
-0.009742899797856808,
-0.1623082309961319,
-0.5442268252372742,
-0.11009550094604492,
0.4539015591144562,
0.24457019567489624,
0.3791169226169586,
-0.6624714136123657,
-0.09903884679079056,
0.05825591832399368,
-0.9415028691291809,
-0.13102681934833527,
-0.30644625425338745,
0.37797239422798157,
0.2671981155872345,
0.7395120859146118,
-0.6114720106124878,
0.6643298268318176,
0.6878073811531067,
0.03125118464231491,
0.44131380319595337,
-0.4404853284358978,
-0.10145865380764008,
-0.7469739317893982,
0.19981098175048828,
0.16652952134609222,
-0.5356073379516602,
-0.5578616261482239,
-0.32106736302375793,
0.09588250517845154,
-0.11286534368991852,
-0.4793334901332855,
0.9021743535995483,
-0.757489025592804,
-0.2868025302886963,
-0.33942854404449463,
0.33585724234580994,
-0.10465198010206223,
0.23214639723300934,
0.16899043321609497,
0.7813751697540283,
0.6374412178993225,
-0.5642800331115723,
0.09941821545362473,
-0.04113652557134628,
-0.3926444947719574,
0.3196779191493988,
-0.9351205825805664,
0.12337836623191833,
-0.13158200681209564,
0.09872004389762878,
-0.7547276020050049,
-0.6157171130180359,
0.585001528263092,
0.005817505065351725,
0.2793170213699341,
-0.4869913160800934,
-0.9505564570426941,
-0.42859819531440735,
0.09621861577033997,
0.260916531085968,
0.5677480697631836,
-0.412350058555603,
0.7855204343795776,
0.3311830461025238,
-0.4215626120567322,
-0.4989233613014221,
-0.5112905502319336,
0.3247404396533966,
-0.3219723105430603,
-0.1960548758506775,
-0.0680544525384903,
0.06621202081441879,
-0.30266618728637695,
0.1256522536277771,
-0.21220532059669495,
-0.19006122648715973,
0.35306861996650696,
0.7090871930122375,
0.4924992024898529,
0.23796430230140686,
0.2997753918170929,
0.02088349685072899,
0.22129301726818085,
0.15865838527679443,
0.3981510400772095,
0.39771977066993713,
0.377857506275177,
-0.8847196698188782,
-0.35121676325798035,
0.2489701807498932,
0.6518423557281494,
-0.05413432791829109,
0.6798631548881531,
0.4965437352657318,
-0.598546028137207,
0.08338729292154312,
-0.8744491934776306,
-0.05068334937095642,
-0.5193980932235718,
0.3074311316013336,
-0.4191780686378479,
-0.7996737360954285,
0.738181471824646,
-0.14388984441757202,
0.1336759328842163,
0.12235743552446365,
0.5640957355499268,
-0.2628604769706726,
1.0649888515472412,
0.6549205183982849,
-0.20539739727973938,
0.2552656829357147,
0.18049615621566772,
0.1712154597043991,
-1.1175026893615723,
-0.2637259364128113,
-0.3122962713241577,
-0.15837933123111725,
-0.2864115536212921,
-0.17298448085784912,
0.5821517705917358,
0.13875791430473328,
0.05837971717119217,
0.06616485863924026,
-0.11971374601125717,
0.5506974458694458,
0.21812346577644348,
0.33557191491127014,
0.12354861199855804,
-0.17129045724868774,
-0.2905080318450928,
0.3099933862686157,
-0.7201254367828369,
-0.4270267188549042,
0.9605087637901306,
0.2717311680316925,
0.5353354215621948,
0.04390576481819153,
0.5436509251594543,
0.3491915166378021,
0.23736871778964996,
-0.7791451811790466,
0.4784208834171295,
0.30653810501098633,
-0.48283737897872925,
-0.1636352390050888,
-0.37481775879859924,
-1.1724110841751099,
0.12312433123588562,
-0.24855412542819977,
-0.8342748880386353,
0.13935090601444244,
0.22860655188560486,
-0.4906105399131775,
0.07890886813402176,
-0.816918671131134,
0.6962993144989014,
-0.16523493826389313,
-0.2657303512096405,
-0.05469277501106262,
-0.5594328045845032,
0.400165319442749,
-0.4349241554737091,
0.6868250966072083,
-0.271096795797348,
0.05974728241562843,
0.6334702372550964,
-0.5168482065200806,
1.0687389373779297,
-0.19348223507404327,
-0.1622864007949829,
0.11909862607717514,
0.1895310878753662,
0.8252160549163818,
-0.05973199009895325,
-0.06757763028144836,
-0.031729426234960556,
0.01173868402838707,
-0.47218775749206543,
-0.455707311630249,
0.8961730003356934,
-0.7228408455848694,
-0.8411784172058105,
-0.5796800255775452,
-0.4987953007221222,
-0.4166751801967621,
0.24218203127384186,
-0.20451620221138,
0.4389983117580414,
0.0878705307841301,
-0.017693614587187767,
0.4111129343509674,
-0.34259772300720215,
0.657500684261322,
0.6039648056030273,
-0.21997198462486267,
0.15331774950027466,
0.6985993981361389,
0.1472247689962387,
0.30875900387763977,
-0.38866710662841797,
-0.1626252681016922,
-0.02532145008444786,
-0.7811015844345093,
-0.21870647370815277,
0.30597639083862305,
-0.7470983266830444,
-0.13635486364364624,
-0.2978736460208893,
-0.26802629232406616,
0.04486638680100441,
0.1231071725487709,
0.017621980980038643,
-0.07626179605722427,
-0.7218870520591736,
-0.07926298677921295,
0.3198098838329315,
0.8433198928833008,
0.06999213993549347,
0.22103628516197205,
-1.0582355260849,
0.13031898438930511,
0.028595853596925735,
0.26919543743133545,
0.2252492606639862,
-0.5031828284263611,
-0.22857777774333954,
0.17370714247226715,
0.18944011628627777,
-0.6844862699508667,
0.09659625589847565,
0.1523505449295044,
0.7481625080108643,
0.20733307301998138,
0.09340114891529083,
0.8765174746513367,
-0.5843877792358398,
0.6242828965187073,
-0.04400895908474922,
-0.9888860583305359,
0.40442436933517456,
-0.45935699343681335,
0.3353590667247772,
0.14954839646816254,
0.431560754776001,
-0.6820073127746582,
-0.6152174472808838,
-0.36206164956092834,
-0.8865358829498291,
0.8261831402778625,
0.0388224795460701,
0.17270490527153015,
0.030270610004663467,
0.5130975246429443,
-0.01111159473657608,
0.14936351776123047,
-0.6929827332496643,
0.03886807709932327,
0.339307576417923,
0.056304093450307846,
0.06524819135665894,
-0.2558706998825073,
-0.2255697250366211,
-0.2233317345380783,
0.3295520544052124,
0.20374071598052979,
-0.173677459359169,
-0.04205331578850746,
-0.41533350944519043,
-0.2779266834259033,
0.3511144518852234,
0.38238227367401123,
1.0174894332885742,
-0.20044636726379395,
0.03330888971686363,
0.43345651030540466,
-0.11507225781679153,
0.16798429191112518,
-0.16944754123687744,
0.18021900951862335,
-0.19256961345672607,
0.6350583434104919,
0.6596750020980835,
0.2648361027240753,
-1.0904115438461304,
0.5220772624015808,
0.09069610387086868,
0.14771820604801178,
-0.6427156925201416,
0.11920563131570816,
0.21267668902873993,
0.2157370001077652,
0.27357298135757446,
0.07427537441253662,
-0.001996260369196534,
-0.5309414267539978,
-0.07663120329380035,
0.583739161491394,
-0.6058648824691772,
-0.409991979598999,
0.1988908350467682,
0.33647286891937256,
-0.23115508258342743,
0.8247311115264893,
-0.2630966007709503,
-0.4124416708946228,
0.5186138153076172,
0.23752595484256744,
0.6314318180084229,
0.22805172204971313,
-0.08436351269483566,
-0.07946467399597168,
0.4861716330051422,
-0.13380558788776398,
0.21461471915245056,
0.22195278108119965,
-0.6825639605522156,
-0.8451542854309082,
-0.5385703444480896,
-0.4087965786457062,
0.33925342559814453,
-0.7165509462356567,
0.49689000844955444,
-0.4039013981819153,
-0.1940029114484787,
-0.07825967669487,
-0.4316062331199646,
-1.031299352645874,
0.02367376908659935,
-0.049520835280418396,
0.5718901753425598,
-0.990050196647644,
0.8744299411773682,
0.6109182834625244,
-0.17455627024173737,
-0.8098418712615967,
-0.11589627712965012,
0.3523336350917816,
-0.6644849181175232,
0.4367222785949707,
-0.1678982526063919,
-0.13682088255882263,
-0.323350727558136,
-0.4007362723350525,
-0.7286575436592102,
0.7714613080024719,
0.543475866317749,
-0.6423137784004211,
0.13940632343292236,
0.006741039454936981,
0.4553227424621582,
0.2201916128396988,
0.11807405948638916,
0.7069870233535767,
0.7741730809211731,
0.27048689126968384,
-1.486557960510254,
0.16970357298851013,
-0.07327145338058472,
-0.2892385423183441,
0.44533106684684753,
-0.33922746777534485,
0.6495102643966675,
-0.30161282420158386,
-0.47307541966438293,
0.1296941339969635,
0.24718327820301056,
-0.02434440329670906,
0.2837195098400116,
0.6270784735679626,
0.508882999420166,
0.6391550898551941,
-0.14082863926887512,
0.9848122000694275,
0.07945185899734497,
0.21754014492034912,
1.2160871028900146,
-0.6052313446998596,
0.8794900178909302,
0.5051795244216919,
-0.2776736915111542,
-0.06822791695594788,
0.9354764819145203,
0.17551472783088684,
0.16803078353405,
-0.1047491580247879,
-0.43616119027137756,
-0.7539023160934448,
-0.11349984258413315,
-0.34965279698371887,
0.5793182253837585,
0.5407186150550842,
-0.09784387052059174,
-0.23134972155094147,
0.22197988629341125,
0.11682798713445663,
-0.2901345193386078,
-0.09610944986343384,
0.8902348279953003,
-0.0637444257736206,
-0.5721389651298523,
0.6161792278289795,
-0.05754629522562027,
0.46270042657852173,
-0.5390534996986389,
-0.12745673954486847,
-0.16618628799915314,
-0.20262645184993744,
-0.4397296607494354,
-0.89699387550354,
0.18060512840747833,
-0.10358502715826035,
-0.21190153062343597,
0.035801250487565994,
0.4883844256401062,
-0.4480776786804199,
-0.6975911855697632,
0.10239800065755844,
0.8643211126327515,
0.1551867127418518,
0.09870891273021698,
-0.38407835364341736,
0.4206024408340454,
-0.16354040801525116,
-0.1960456818342209,
0.5278635621070862,
0.5181671977043152,
-0.009819017723202705,
0.9451585412025452,
0.5541019439697266,
0.3350207209587097,
-0.3163997232913971,
0.004234132822602987,
0.8891066312789917,
-0.5490424036979675,
0.199041947722435,
-0.9774016737937927,
0.2973979115486145,
-0.16419383883476257,
0.09298630803823471,
0.8219993710517883,
0.32288792729377747,
0.45194974541664124,
0.15103870630264282,
1.0934200286865234,
-0.11145957559347153,
0.8187841176986694,
-0.7738198637962341,
0.509706437587738,
-0.9263924360275269,
0.7474153637886047,
-0.2524239718914032,
-0.9407213926315308,
-0.16119994223117828,
0.22451697289943695,
-0.2525060176849365,
0.08322316408157349,
0.5715821385383606,
0.585460364818573,
-0.3027384877204895,
-0.4463842809200287,
0.13640443980693817,
0.19361303746700287,
0.46152105927467346,
0.3629318177700043,
0.8294178247451782,
0.17249812185764313,
0.5161351561546326,
-0.012005100958049297,
-0.08740702271461487,
-0.06109979748725891,
-1.0538140535354614,
-0.8866867423057556,
-0.5205444693565369,
-0.25590574741363525,
-0.1705983579158783,
0.05360613390803337,
1.0740782022476196,
0.4802885353565216,
-0.5000610947608948,
-0.2080252319574356,
0.2554895579814911,
0.5006974339485168,
0.1886403113603592,
-0.15300318598747253,
0.31013092398643494,
-0.24659296870231628,
-0.7647614479064941,
0.4382617473602295,
0.5246039628982544,
0.3352983295917511,
-0.5766806602478027,
0.06756875663995743,
-0.046379879117012024,
-0.002891965676099062,
0.5339133739471436,
0.3946838676929474,
-0.9866245985031128,
-0.6684086918830872,
-0.21155475080013275,
0.1591552495956421,
0.013037321157753468,
0.7485501766204834,
-0.8530905246734619,
0.4717235565185547,
0.18378658592700958,
0.4700256884098053,
0.11555762588977814,
-0.18209005892276764,
0.6617683172225952,
-1.1961373090744019,
0.4559621512889862,
0.24582993984222412,
0.6380195617675781,
0.5191158652305603,
-0.240579292178154,
0.3368840515613556,
-0.01761900633573532,
-0.4580228626728058,
-1.110664963722229,
0.08811759203672409,
-0.8897426724433899,
-0.1876799613237381,
1.3583370447158813,
-0.20318879187107086,
-0.06899973750114441,
-0.5926222205162048,
-0.1934744268655777,
-0.16708242893218994,
-0.12146158516407013,
0.6714800596237183,
1.1524077653884888,
-0.05419732257723808,
-0.26877325773239136,
-0.7446821928024292,
0.3082573711872101,
0.2519298195838928,
-0.8284236192703247,
0.10166236758232117,
0.6743053793907166,
0.4246552288532257,
-0.08895278722047806,
0.5031542181968689,
0.26037225127220154,
0.23811128735542297,
-0.3870888352394104,
-0.13791106641292572,
-0.05854988098144531,
-0.15069152414798737,
0.027793746441602707,
-0.004117964301258326,
0.4863632917404175,
0.3093554973602295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12304v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12304v1
|
COT: A Generative Approach for Hate Speech Counter-Narratives via Contrastive Optimal Transport
| 2024-06-18T06:24:26 | 2024-06-18T06:24:26 |
Linhao Zhang, Li Jin, Guangluan Xu, Xiaoyu Li, Xian Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68U15, I.2.7
|
Counter-narratives, which are direct responses consisting of non-aggressive
fact-based arguments, have emerged as a highly effective approach to combat the
proliferation of hate speech. Previous methodologies have primarily focused on
fine-tuning and post-editing techniques to ensure the fluency of generated
contents, while overlooking the critical aspects of individualization and
relevance concerning the specific hatred targets, such as LGBT groups,
immigrants, etc. This research paper introduces a novel framework based on
contrastive optimal transport, which effectively addresses the challenges of
maintaining target interaction and promoting diversification in generating
counter-narratives. Firstly, an Optimal Transport Kernel (OTK) module is
leveraged to incorporate hatred target information in the token
representations, in which the comparison pairs are extracted between original
and transported features. Secondly, a self-contrastive learning module is
employed to address the issue of model degeneration. This module achieves this
by generating an anisotropic distribution of token representations. Finally, a
target-oriented search method is integrated as an improved decoding strategy to
explicitly promote domain relevance and diversification in the inference
process. This strategy modifies the model's confidence score by considering
both token similarity and target relevance. Quantitative and qualitative
experiments have been evaluated on two benchmark datasets, which demonstrate
that our proposed model significantly outperforms current methods evaluated by
metrics from multiple aspects.
|
[
-0.6597586870193481,
-0.6499402523040771,
0.332972913980484,
-0.18476815521717072,
-0.4337579607963562,
0.1905188411474228,
-0.0249144546687603,
-0.2557104527950287,
0.4414723515510559,
0.404828280210495,
-0.543682336807251,
-0.5140543580055237,
-0.5835856199264526,
-0.07725786417722702,
-0.7836618423461914,
1.1145259141921997,
0.1964251697063446,
0.01490738894790411,
0.22395916283130646,
-0.5382940769195557,
-0.4220921993255615,
-0.5728175640106201,
-0.5804445743560791,
0.14999404549598694,
0.5155884623527527,
0.24031323194503784,
0.7461897134780884,
0.6160225868225098,
0.26006126403808594,
0.21962910890579224,
-0.24005059897899628,
-0.19174550473690033,
-0.8542650938034058,
0.33365342020988464,
-0.6592430472373962,
-0.3979963958263397,
0.13278359174728394,
-0.22207258641719818,
0.4190666973590851,
0.21538065373897552,
0.08918674290180206,
-0.05357038974761963,
-0.03648597374558449,
0.1409091204404831,
-0.806284487247467,
-0.6315050721168518,
-0.8739510178565979,
0.14909277856349945,
-0.31178736686706543,
-0.007635484915226698,
-0.2884894013404846,
-0.11789006739854813,
-0.10286694765090942,
-0.5550709366798401,
0.5805935859680176,
0.16211219131946564,
0.5431128144264221,
0.10438444465398788,
-0.6977654099464417,
-0.41051772236824036,
-0.7462098002433777,
0.9697486758232117,
-0.4519291818141937,
0.24802160263061523,
-0.03592274710536003,
0.22982648015022278,
0.20897528529167175,
-0.3711204528808594,
-0.6065663695335388,
-0.0642852783203125,
-0.03367379307746887,
0.21514137089252472,
-0.4625259041786194,
-0.06331400573253632,
-0.31801050901412964,
0.30004531145095825,
-0.6590521931648254,
0.3722655773162842,
-0.5342546701431274,
-0.20981872081756592,
0.6720350980758667,
0.5180293321609497,
0.32639220356941223,
-0.17572665214538574,
-0.853047251701355,
0.06869828701019287,
-0.6136621236801147,
-0.30658528208732605,
0.7257177233695984,
0.47172439098358154,
-0.36068955063819885,
0.4812907576560974,
-0.0340745747089386,
0.36171165108680725,
0.13175490498542786,
0.13318398594856262,
0.19145433604717255,
-0.2731505036354065,
0.021721741184592247,
0.09246242791414261,
0.7879026532173157,
0.335423082113266,
0.07834602892398834,
-0.3771623969078064,
-0.18248414993286133,
0.3399278223514557,
0.7756067514419556,
-0.6264321208000183,
0.1162378340959549,
0.13344110548496246,
-0.46951448917388916,
-0.6712695360183716,
-0.3273850083351135,
-1.3772445917129517,
-0.5363913178443909,
-0.11977504193782806,
0.3625098764896393,
-0.6606966853141785,
-0.3664485812187195,
-0.38683778047561646,
-0.17468573153018951,
0.15905822813510895,
0.12625151872634888,
-0.925429105758667,
0.3795861005783081,
0.32806241512298584,
0.91087406873703,
-0.798679530620575,
0.13348369300365448,
-0.45412054657936096,
0.21813036501407623,
-0.3526105582714081,
0.759562611579895,
-0.7789570689201355,
-0.627346932888031,
-0.023271897807717323,
-0.4141160547733307,
0.14165948331356049,
-0.47635698318481445,
0.7260181307792664,
-0.43485236167907715,
-0.0006956852157600224,
-0.07625916600227356,
-0.44363754987716675,
0.05687357857823372,
0.30147260427474976,
-0.4087683856487274,
0.6461659669876099,
0.3773951530456543,
-0.7166382074356079,
0.14476042985916138,
-0.4647124111652374,
-0.4229031205177307,
0.06592319160699844,
-0.25454676151275635,
-0.4691682457923889,
0.1084505096077919,
0.0029166683088988066,
-0.07718484103679657,
-0.2943306565284729,
0.24116723239421844,
-0.1189054325222969,
-0.24097579717636108,
-0.1386658400297165,
-0.4219517707824707,
0.7315167784690857,
0.630315899848938,
-0.5888525247573853,
0.41947105526924133,
-0.5434696674346924,
-0.6093568205833435,
0.20964309573173523,
0.04992011934518814,
-0.4044210612773895,
-0.2238314300775528,
0.23314984142780304,
0.18374237418174744,
-0.15684480965137482,
-0.8519659042358398,
-0.3351915776729584,
-0.5951741933822632,
-0.10200630128383636,
1.0994625091552734,
-0.07970382273197174,
0.4252135157585144,
-0.24036158621311188,
0.8873950839042664,
0.5070256590843201,
0.3842746615409851,
0.24150724709033966,
-0.35517987608909607,
-0.5419933199882507,
-0.10103920102119446,
-0.2232743352651596,
0.34553098678588867,
-0.6288027167320251,
0.11792124062776566,
0.0865764319896698,
-0.4464488923549652,
-0.31671103835105896,
-0.13340836763381958,
0.4182623624801636,
0.7697309851646423,
0.87277752161026,
-0.2956765592098236,
-0.868044376373291,
-0.9123948216438293,
-0.19602540135383606,
-0.11317415535449982,
0.2238374799489975,
0.14988060295581818,
0.20436686277389526,
-0.2135467678308487,
0.8288676738739014,
-0.5486729741096497,
-0.27354735136032104,
-0.4692489802837372,
0.2975781559944153,
-0.334805965423584,
0.45538702607154846,
0.9757384061813354,
-1.2229667901992798,
-0.630493700504303,
-0.2987939715385437,
-0.38080939650535583,
-0.1648910939693451,
-0.0805652067065239,
-0.5136098265647888,
0.07396382838487625,
0.4436267912387848,
-0.15959379076957703,
0.707141101360321,
0.4626094102859497,
-0.5735052824020386,
0.6515727639198303,
0.42532533407211304,
0.35884320735931396,
-0.9965336918830872,
-0.09606508165597916,
-0.21365833282470703,
-0.10494683682918549,
-0.7313458323478699,
0.10535240918397903,
-0.6167546510696411,
-0.09496039897203445,
-0.6467005610466003,
0.5591408610343933,
0.16864149272441864,
0.3244766891002655,
-0.4655224680900574,
0.3822399079799652,
-0.24513660371303558,
0.3983074724674225,
-0.05863040313124657,
0.5652338862419128,
0.35467031598091125,
-0.5168036222457886,
0.4071270227432251,
0.35485029220581055,
-0.02504448965191841,
1.0998510122299194,
-0.20484116673469543,
-0.04034857824444771,
-0.42623579502105713,
0.010890514589846134,
-1.259496808052063,
0.46601811051368713,
0.41515615582466125,
-0.2592580020427704,
0.027573207393288612,
-0.1273883432149887,
0.017523963004350662,
-0.16582520306110382,
-0.24117346107959747,
0.8360404372215271,
0.6313462853431702,
-0.5170282125473022,
0.717818558216095,
0.4577327370643616,
-0.15256769955158234,
-0.5436139106750488,
-0.7381857633590698,
0.05931897461414337,
-0.6940461993217468,
-0.10973194986581802,
0.7188400030136108,
-0.17641466856002808,
-0.29266437888145447,
0.07346561551094055,
-0.1459752917289734,
0.07743698358535767,
-0.23750564455986023,
0.15412169694900513,
0.13536958396434784,
-0.15524041652679443,
0.14284153282642365,
0.08866924047470093,
-0.03878520429134369,
-0.12966251373291016,
-0.2357998639345169,
0.6585294604301453,
0.25091299414634705,
-0.0035743422340601683,
-0.0044085197150707245,
0.6826232671737671,
0.39962732791900635,
0.0548088476061821,
0.9327182769775391,
0.9132178425788879,
0.07683037221431732,
-0.14917290210723877,
-0.5475755333900452,
-0.023136815056204796,
-0.4208050072193146,
0.31345298886299133,
-0.46265771985054016,
-0.7292537689208984,
0.4907597005367279,
0.011931173503398895,
0.023386122658848763,
0.6875311136245728,
0.6603107452392578,
0.22749802470207214,
0.7290036082267761,
0.4744744896888733,
-0.10638168454170227,
0.49324899911880493,
-0.0975256860256195,
0.3255864679813385,
-0.6742385029792786,
-0.22059501707553864,
-0.6125693917274475,
-0.23900364339351654,
-0.4995768368244171,
-0.4889509677886963,
0.3820725679397583,
-0.3037492632865906,
-0.4756494462490082,
0.393639475107193,
-0.49158525466918945,
0.22336526215076447,
0.27574965357780457,
0.0528498999774456,
0.16109122335910797,
0.06834287941455841,
-0.5173361301422119,
-0.10301253199577332,
-0.6987151503562927,
-0.19757089018821716,
1.0916235446929932,
0.0851784199476242,
0.5988056063652039,
0.45990607142448425,
0.6604601740837097,
0.5610678195953369,
0.5300298929214478,
-0.3966721296310425,
0.5014313459396362,
-0.483457088470459,
-0.6384966969490051,
-0.27486452460289,
-0.5815487504005432,
-0.9916346669197083,
0.3496098518371582,
-0.23329922556877136,
-0.7921328544616699,
0.3130829334259033,
0.12224427610635757,
-0.21941828727722168,
0.7299466133117676,
-0.5092678070068359,
0.8029711246490479,
-0.09287308156490326,
-0.5395834445953369,
-0.6245859265327454,
-0.6314106583595276,
0.29964277148246765,
-0.04862099513411522,
0.41306501626968384,
0.028033776208758354,
-0.061667781323194504,
0.6450608968734741,
-0.3098766505718231,
0.6903005838394165,
-0.06933605670928955,
-0.07313982397317886,
0.3594827353954315,
0.3641541600227356,
0.2505315840244293,
-0.44932428002357483,
-0.3777516186237335,
0.09277763962745667,
-0.3419257700443268,
-0.48903974890708923,
-0.49371182918548584,
0.6599746346473694,
-0.6483432650566101,
-0.5847306847572327,
0.029527774080634117,
-0.5219607353210449,
-0.1176198422908783,
0.07528027147054672,
0.38784757256507874,
0.39437344670295715,
-0.621730387210846,
-0.02446174807846546,
0.4925980865955353,
-0.5655966997146606,
0.2793658673763275,
0.38008323311805725,
0.01674075238406658,
-0.4337262809276581,
0.8834460377693176,
-0.071787528693676,
0.4692404568195343,
0.4947567284107208,
0.3955053687095642,
-0.5782783031463623,
-0.6277338266372681,
-0.3224729895591736,
-0.003836393356323242,
-0.8080340027809143,
-0.3168763816356659,
-0.9049437642097473,
-0.13383957743644714,
-0.5270857214927673,
-0.6189334392547607,
-0.47650933265686035,
-0.09818167239427567,
-0.10098495334386826,
-0.17293287813663483,
0.20937961339950562,
0.7631043791770935,
-0.3494488596916199,
0.29968586564064026,
-0.009698628447949886,
0.8344039916992188,
0.23040983080863953,
0.2815851867198944,
0.1745966523885727,
-0.8766638040542603,
-0.27839040756225586,
-0.052521489560604095,
-0.4960762560367584,
-0.9837371110916138,
0.5238020420074463,
-0.47927069664001465,
0.5937873125076294,
0.31402090191841125,
0.5881270170211792,
0.5410619974136353,
-0.32463207840919495,
0.72579425573349,
0.3852331340312958,
-0.877780020236969,
0.606137216091156,
-0.10534998029470444,
0.01470169797539711,
0.4023900032043457,
0.6132877469062805,
-0.2161806970834732,
-0.8795790672302246,
-0.8535032272338867,
-1.1421592235565186,
0.5269893407821655,
0.4988786578178406,
0.29413968324661255,
-0.2917992174625397,
-0.1649523675441742,
0.1693194955587387,
0.05730454996228218,
-0.7955719828605652,
-0.24484196305274963,
-0.5206538438796997,
-0.5162883400917053,
-0.039155565202236176,
-0.4102436602115631,
-0.09377007931470871,
0.071701280772686,
0.7161352634429932,
0.2081095576286316,
0.015560226514935493,
0.1266460418701172,
0.0029423730447888374,
0.1151016503572464,
0.33272191882133484,
0.5773994326591492,
0.3744298815727234,
-0.12272276729345322,
0.45132124423980713,
0.25269487500190735,
-0.4765087068080902,
0.3529658317565918,
-0.2638445794582367,
-0.2488202601671219,
0.16090188920497894,
-0.010097610764205456,
0.7354567646980286,
-0.014783033169806004,
-0.6667810082435608,
0.4983609616756439,
0.16676053404808044,
0.05401778221130371,
-0.23062992095947266,
0.001308974577113986,
-0.20674404501914978,
0.22578559815883636,
0.15887793898582458,
0.06908616423606873,
0.32317420840263367,
-0.34617215394973755,
0.2479725182056427,
0.3284517526626587,
-0.4687216579914093,
0.09622257202863693,
0.8226239681243896,
0.34676840901374817,
-0.335653692483902,
0.2839932441711426,
-0.33134469389915466,
-0.4683566391468048,
0.5663984417915344,
0.6265292167663574,
0.8798630833625793,
-0.5639917254447937,
0.4158461093902588,
0.5766720771789551,
0.13711699843406677,
0.5081281065940857,
-0.32070305943489075,
-0.13282465934753418,
-0.8065887093544006,
0.24776357412338257,
-0.6329742670059204,
-0.19528014957904816,
0.09319092333316803,
-0.5809177160263062,
0.36945903301239014,
-0.32290834188461304,
0.1234348714351654,
-0.1617029905319214,
-0.3970593214035034,
-0.5233474373817444,
0.3799159824848175,
0.2594783902168274,
0.5847652554512024,
-0.8054863214492798,
0.3205988109111786,
0.026544950902462006,
-0.4887559711933136,
-0.3650210499763489,
0.22896058857440948,
0.1788203865289688,
-0.6327739953994751,
0.6488178372383118,
-0.06117663159966469,
-0.5134016275405884,
-0.08426392078399658,
-0.29344642162323,
-0.6519893407821655,
0.580169141292572,
0.30002567172050476,
-0.5108743906021118,
0.2682218849658966,
0.3560413718223572,
0.5821067690849304,
-0.708385169506073,
0.23149147629737854,
0.43170368671417236,
0.08948317170143127,
0.37266677618026733,
-0.4541608989238739,
0.28534767031669617,
0.1028367131948471,
0.06184074282646179,
-0.0596422404050827,
-0.7753728628158569,
0.6505851745605469,
-0.023968946188688278,
-0.15230213105678558,
0.039588265120983124,
0.41782981157302856,
0.15001210570335388,
0.11476029455661774,
0.761734664440155,
0.5701816082000732,
0.2790227234363556,
0.42514440417289734,
0.833651602268219,
-0.03556142374873161,
0.13246968388557434,
1.0321323871612549,
-0.035914674401283264,
0.43885931372642517,
0.3652583658695221,
0.025962065905332565,
0.6682600975036621,
-0.034555260092020035,
0.02598409727215767,
0.6458175778388977,
0.7529199123382568,
-0.5724530816078186,
-0.022676242515444756,
-0.4382551312446594,
-0.10913427174091339,
0.5979950428009033,
0.26417070627212524,
-0.4516819417476654,
-0.4856783449649811,
0.32539278268814087,
-0.02627442590892315,
0.615116536617279,
-0.3778133988380432,
0.7342231273651123,
-0.2140718549489975,
-0.37047743797302246,
0.5323053598403931,
0.15671996772289276,
0.850716233253479,
-0.5568757057189941,
0.20518870651721954,
-0.3783738613128662,
-0.05173799395561218,
0.02690805494785309,
-0.5637861490249634,
0.7579600811004639,
0.2834431231021881,
-0.10399478673934937,
-0.24192564189434052,
0.30093422532081604,
-0.47235485911369324,
-0.3622928857803345,
0.5003346800804138,
-0.004692953545600176,
0.14259934425354004,
0.17697402834892273,
-0.648088276386261,
0.3913951814174652,
0.14224651455879211,
0.022644629701972008,
0.3522352874279022,
0.3936862647533417,
0.09856690466403961,
0.4974020719528198,
0.21138101816177368,
0.17258009314537048,
-0.06887809187173843,
0.2883438467979431,
0.9225410223007202,
-0.6832723617553711,
-0.8733648657798767,
-0.8349024653434753,
0.5329216718673706,
-0.16777949035167694,
-0.3842660188674927,
0.40546977519989014,
0.840957522392273,
0.7559676766395569,
0.07581638544797897,
0.8006284832954407,
-0.05802440270781517,
0.6957337856292725,
-0.40044137835502625,
0.303791880607605,
-0.47855430841445923,
0.2590773403644562,
-0.5120769739151001,
-0.5467593669891357,
-0.033843472599983215,
0.5171400904655457,
-0.4117428660392761,
0.05976038798689842,
0.633980929851532,
1.0507440567016602,
-0.20026196539402008,
-0.07604881376028061,
0.47325950860977173,
0.4150231182575226,
0.4591321647167206,
0.6803176999092102,
0.7458077073097229,
-0.45091718435287476,
0.9115949273109436,
-0.05898487940430641,
-0.027961691841483116,
-0.11375884711742401,
-0.49941614270210266,
-0.7424538135528564,
-0.6069809198379517,
-0.40189501643180847,
-0.46360018849372864,
0.29656463861465454,
0.6510752439498901,
0.7398967146873474,
-0.8508960008621216,
-0.1809394508600235,
-0.3011886775493622,
0.3817405700683594,
0.105450339615345,
-0.3347194492816925,
0.2046506404876709,
-0.4603242576122284,
-0.6035091876983643,
0.08992721885442734,
0.31962066888809204,
0.11943447589874268,
-0.22002537548542023,
-0.07013459503650665,
-0.3381401598453522,
0.38865014910697937,
0.5652424693107605,
0.049387235194444656,
-0.7086024284362793,
-0.27492591738700867,
-0.44615045189857483,
-0.08996123820543289,
0.06112939864397049,
1.0191686153411865,
-0.9227079749107361,
0.4662337899208069,
0.06885022670030594,
0.5919915437698364,
0.5752164721488953,
0.2527839243412018,
0.6268222332000732,
-0.6728541254997253,
0.5106970071792603,
0.5397908091545105,
0.023560376837849617,
0.22866451740264893,
-0.49559321999549866,
0.4177709221839905,
0.45271632075309753,
-0.03329622745513916,
-0.745756208896637,
0.6174494028091431,
-0.8444230556488037,
-0.5863754749298096,
1.2043057680130005,
-0.06547224521636963,
0.0967085063457489,
-0.4984286427497864,
-0.3088832497596741,
0.37955984473228455,
-0.21949782967567444,
0.9680609107017517,
0.3466522693634033,
-0.1259351521730423,
-0.2431119829416275,
0.12797634303569794,
0.46255773305892944,
0.5082072615623474,
-0.5711779594421387,
-0.008907271549105644,
0.3612810969352722,
0.14220726490020752,
0.10341626405715942,
0.5364788174629211,
-0.32836923003196716,
-0.13491776585578918,
0.4241587221622467,
-0.12004434317350388,
0.20206262171268463,
-0.3508952856063843,
-0.05274338647723198,
0.4177522361278534,
-0.47281375527381897,
-0.16424210369586945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12295v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12295v1
|
Fast and Slow Generating: An Empirical Study on Large and Small Language Models Collaborative Decoding
| 2024-06-18T05:59:28 | 2024-06-18T05:59:28 |
Kaiyan Zhang, Jianyu Wang, Ning Ding, Biqing Qi, Ermo Hua, Xingtai Lv, Bowen Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate impressive performance in diverse
applications, yet they face significant drawbacks, including high inference
latency, expensive training cost, and generation of hallucination.
Collaborative decoding between large and small language models (SLMs) offers a
novel approach to address these challenges. Inspired by dual-process cognitive
theory, we integrate these methods into a unified framework termed Fast and
Slow Generating (FS-GEN). This paper explores several techniques within the
FS-GEN framework, including speculative decoding, contrastive decoding, and
emulator or proxy fine-tuning. We provide a comprehensive analysis of these
methodologies, offering insights into their similarities and differences under
this framework. Our study delves into the differential knowledge capabilities
of LLMs versus SLMs through the FS-GEN lens, revealing that fewer than 20% of
collaborative interactions are required across various methods. These
interactions adhere to a scaling law relative to the parameter ratios, thereby
facilitating predictable collaboration. Furthermore, we investigate the
specific positions where collaboration is most effective from an uncertainty
perspective, yielding novel insights that could refine FS-GEN methods. Our
findings reveal that the essential difference between models of different sizes
lies in the uncertainty of the next token prediction, where interventions by
larger models are most needed to assist the smaller ones. Code for
Reproduction: https://github.com/TsinghuaC3I/FS-GEN
|
[
-0.29622453451156616,
-0.7941974401473999,
0.7423627972602844,
0.08936958014965057,
-0.1421140879392624,
0.3421851396560669,
-0.5337549448013306,
-0.5796700716018677,
0.11335152387619019,
0.3822900354862213,
-0.6294753551483154,
-0.0510951429605484,
-0.5758119225502014,
0.14772449433803558,
-0.23031923174858093,
0.6231539845466614,
0.07433923333883286,
0.29564717411994934,
-0.20648014545440674,
0.13140013813972473,
-0.10622426122426987,
-0.3615586459636688,
-0.9810985922813416,
-0.35922425985336304,
0.4874289333820343,
0.4084794819355011,
0.9443137645721436,
0.7331601977348328,
0.4774787724018097,
0.3148525655269623,
-0.14749903976917267,
0.1528385579586029,
-0.6705396771430969,
0.1620711237192154,
-0.1315976232290268,
-0.43466898798942566,
-0.2674996256828308,
-0.13290174305438995,
0.4238203465938568,
1.0257892608642578,
-0.02267950214445591,
0.2960647642612457,
0.17817836999893188,
0.6170993447303772,
-0.6393091082572937,
0.15716688334941864,
-0.7926097512245178,
0.0009746890282258391,
-0.2621246576309204,
0.07842696458101273,
-0.49201029539108276,
-0.28384825587272644,
0.19585131108760834,
-0.49385151267051697,
0.5786391496658325,
0.26563578844070435,
0.31460097432136536,
0.34905123710632324,
-0.15027326345443726,
-0.64389967918396,
-1.019317865371704,
0.9508761167526245,
-0.6731116771697998,
0.3857186436653137,
0.27116072177886963,
0.07772886008024216,
-0.3064815402030945,
-0.8361888527870178,
-0.42220380902290344,
-0.1259220391511917,
0.022902974858880043,
-0.34000611305236816,
-0.13449034094810486,
0.11949099600315094,
0.25590789318084717,
0.542048990726471,
-0.4498446583747864,
0.37327244877815247,
-0.20616766810417175,
-0.39024144411087036,
0.6987406611442566,
0.477835476398468,
0.03807207942008972,
0.03452981635928154,
-0.034596338868141174,
-0.03426984325051308,
-0.6990936398506165,
-0.06595034152269363,
0.3021712005138397,
0.37598562240600586,
-0.2062193602323532,
0.4686419367790222,
-0.17793293297290802,
0.4761553108692169,
0.26402145624160767,
-0.20769797265529633,
0.1346447914838791,
-0.7525561451911926,
-0.15291298925876617,
-0.18029627203941345,
0.9718892574310303,
0.15211306512355804,
-0.08380549401044846,
-0.39940136671066284,
-0.3050094246864319,
0.23606547713279724,
-0.2020990252494812,
-0.6957483291625977,
-0.01607361063361168,
0.12893974781036377,
-0.6229032874107361,
-0.298266738653183,
-0.07308140397071838,
-0.8861751556396484,
-0.3625529408454895,
-0.2837529182434082,
0.23545627295970917,
-0.31542065739631653,
-0.3492020070552826,
0.19381792843341827,
-0.05031304433941841,
-0.021128233522176743,
0.27690377831459045,
-1.1197084188461304,
0.2834104001522064,
0.6749320030212402,
0.7407937049865723,
-0.10151459276676178,
-0.43292176723480225,
-0.7351576685905457,
0.18316088616847992,
-0.32786887884140015,
0.39471569657325745,
-0.20318827033042908,
-0.4371345341205597,
-0.09330938756465912,
-0.18669520318508148,
-0.05357208475470543,
-0.3854922652244568,
0.17180997133255005,
-0.38557320833206177,
-0.12372183054685593,
-0.43649980425834656,
-0.4567328095436096,
0.30240917205810547,
-0.30744606256484985,
-0.8271875977516174,
0.800177812576294,
0.007911719381809235,
-0.8573662638664246,
0.3681415319442749,
-0.2924034893512726,
-0.4116736054420471,
0.13869892060756683,
-0.39554837346076965,
-0.25438636541366577,
0.5682372450828552,
0.05244860798120499,
0.6634123921394348,
-0.7695643305778503,
0.28578662872314453,
-0.4951801002025604,
-0.48310598731040955,
0.22408084571361542,
-0.21142813563346863,
0.4699004888534546,
0.566826343536377,
-0.21849115192890167,
0.022116661071777344,
-0.7478494048118591,
-0.004094691947102547,
0.4007362127304077,
-0.2454105168581009,
-0.22357428073883057,
0.19402486085891724,
-0.2551550567150116,
0.13991481065750122,
0.4304896295070648,
-0.2721598744392395,
0.01591205783188343,
-0.2909172773361206,
0.6762763857841492,
0.5879117846488953,
-0.0012668773997575045,
0.824070394039154,
-0.19719000160694122,
0.4079468548297882,
-0.15029723942279816,
0.22088509798049927,
-0.12236761301755905,
-0.2672348916530609,
-0.6827782988548279,
-0.11102849990129471,
0.2778848111629486,
0.17933475971221924,
-1.1671810150146484,
0.08588500320911407,
-0.2694571912288666,
-0.3972952961921692,
-0.6304587721824646,
0.3457612991333008,
0.5348767042160034,
0.020888620987534523,
-0.004567100200802088,
-0.353755384683609,
-0.5757787823677063,
-0.5938663482666016,
-0.19128327071666718,
-0.15870004892349243,
-0.024362238124012947,
0.09337866306304932,
0.40127676725387573,
-0.19124217331409454,
0.6495374441146851,
-0.3850680887699127,
0.0914350375533104,
-0.4379100501537323,
0.28619393706321716,
-0.09728934615850449,
0.28212952613830566,
0.5339239835739136,
-0.5168123841285706,
-0.42079201340675354,
-0.3126581609249115,
-0.7431257963180542,
0.10480471700429916,
0.00449327751994133,
0.13678379356861115,
0.29952219128608704,
0.6679131388664246,
-0.5425150394439697,
0.18879981338977814,
0.7305613160133362,
-0.2110743373632431,
0.5333241820335388,
-0.28106197714805603,
-0.07586253434419632,
-0.916885495185852,
-0.23001301288604736,
-0.1288325935602188,
0.22004254162311554,
-0.6950125694274902,
0.2606135606765747,
-0.25834164023399353,
0.08211053907871246,
-0.37605470418930054,
0.20094217360019684,
-0.7856141924858093,
-0.3557763397693634,
-0.1335216760635376,
0.11055432260036469,
-0.21254535019397736,
0.2854527235031128,
0.006462362129241228,
0.8384521007537842,
0.3662620186805725,
-0.4099811911582947,
0.148027241230011,
-0.12062455713748932,
-0.3684670031070709,
-0.004517771769315004,
-0.46451619267463684,
0.36359041929244995,
0.16247232258319855,
0.13849706947803497,
-0.5708065032958984,
-0.273113876581192,
-0.08372826129198074,
-0.24797503650188446,
0.1842239648103714,
-0.12508556246757507,
-0.9371864199638367,
-0.6325092911720276,
-0.3284491300582886,
0.4995558559894562,
0.5924093723297119,
-0.32409411668777466,
0.3672865033149719,
0.32889842987060547,
-0.11975503712892532,
-0.3487907648086548,
-0.8798342347145081,
-0.1209976002573967,
-0.10870274901390076,
-0.8751645684242249,
0.1686004102230072,
-0.17848913371562958,
-0.5569029450416565,
0.014685500413179398,
0.09688210487365723,
0.016885245218873024,
0.08380650728940964,
0.24177950620651245,
-0.06447191536426544,
-0.4085715115070343,
-0.12503260374069214,
0.0634673461318016,
-0.12802699208259583,
0.008271553553640842,
-0.2401483654975891,
0.5963708162307739,
-0.19914983212947845,
-0.14791741967201233,
-0.22163274884223938,
0.45806002616882324,
0.6987308263778687,
-0.14679072797298431,
0.8371468186378479,
0.7600136399269104,
-0.15948614478111267,
-0.3236023485660553,
-0.5189937949180603,
-0.31143397092819214,
-0.49935293197631836,
0.06443413347005844,
-0.45553162693977356,
-1.1148619651794434,
0.7281191945075989,
-0.21732845902442932,
-0.2916322946548462,
0.28113695979118347,
0.7490274310112,
0.2334362119436264,
1.0567070245742798,
0.9682358503341675,
-0.06188294664025307,
0.46308374404907227,
-0.3300117254257202,
0.12219099700450897,
-0.5325830578804016,
-0.14369745552539825,
-0.5300858020782471,
0.030760712921619415,
-0.514261782169342,
-0.5923859477043152,
0.07362909615039825,
0.44786185026168823,
0.0030514481477439404,
0.02669147029519081,
-0.33829066157341003,
0.36475780606269836,
0.6724902987480164,
-0.15278945863246918,
0.45765072107315063,
0.16206568479537964,
-0.41992810368537903,
-0.16680549085140228,
-0.9819620251655579,
-0.3765917122364044,
1.0653471946716309,
0.22670815885066986,
0.8190279603004456,
-0.01068465318530798,
0.8535271286964417,
0.10269611328840256,
-0.025216471403837204,
-0.6795334815979004,
0.6611714363098145,
-0.310187429189682,
-0.31998732686042786,
-0.2620523273944855,
-0.5942631959915161,
-0.8968654274940491,
0.1365242749452591,
-0.4628983438014984,
-0.6393776535987854,
-0.00764488847926259,
0.11929836869239807,
-0.5172054171562195,
0.35924872756004333,
-0.8136980533599854,
0.5052683353424072,
-0.13469284772872925,
-0.6585943698883057,
-0.3361136019229889,
-0.8638768196105957,
0.4879494607448578,
-0.3742656707763672,
0.4388759732246399,
-0.007506342604756355,
0.19478479027748108,
0.5939486622810364,
-0.4424477517604828,
0.7283139824867249,
-0.12372787296772003,
-0.15849819779396057,
0.46526286005973816,
0.1521899402141571,
0.4707339406013489,
0.03973356634378433,
-0.3154209852218628,
0.17549975216388702,
-0.17719808220863342,
-0.223653644323349,
-0.2295294851064682,
0.7968769669532776,
-0.7523553371429443,
-0.38088151812553406,
-0.16540217399597168,
-0.6892687082290649,
-0.16329722106456757,
0.2268160730600357,
0.5211024284362793,
0.22783121466636658,
-0.35768556594848633,
-0.0017234102124348283,
0.6467838287353516,
-0.13074688613414764,
0.6212655305862427,
0.5579274892807007,
-0.1569022387266159,
-0.3904392123222351,
0.7601834535598755,
0.04018547385931015,
0.4929371178150177,
0.21621626615524292,
0.022722184658050537,
0.01996327005326748,
-0.8838291764259338,
-0.32354122400283813,
0.3902299702167511,
-0.41168642044067383,
-0.09924542903900146,
-0.31409600377082825,
-0.09659857302904129,
-0.5375044345855713,
-0.38827887177467346,
-0.5239264369010925,
-0.35012781620025635,
-0.35818958282470703,
0.06741403788328171,
0.2481798380613327,
1.0280648469924927,
-0.3410826623439789,
0.43655139207839966,
-0.8443136811256409,
0.28193995356559753,
0.07504058629274368,
0.20453780889511108,
0.2904260456562042,
0.025578530505299568,
-0.5458032488822937,
0.20545603334903717,
-0.09739934653043747,
-0.6067758798599243,
0.14888033270835876,
-0.20979547500610352,
0.4790094494819641,
0.35838496685028076,
0.037309449166059494,
0.5665686726570129,
-0.5016195774078369,
1.0612422227859497,
0.31982943415641785,
-1.0760248899459839,
0.2651348412036896,
-0.26573583483695984,
0.19697004556655884,
0.5612462759017944,
0.03691416233778,
-0.17598456144332886,
-0.4673812687397003,
-0.6186150908470154,
-0.8657951951026917,
0.8569508194923401,
0.18163944780826569,
-0.22129186987876892,
0.09997865557670593,
0.3828257918357849,
0.33144062757492065,
0.24924929440021515,
-0.26769334077835083,
-0.132481649518013,
0.21336661279201508,
-0.25708866119384766,
-0.36401742696762085,
-0.31977298855781555,
0.025645647197961807,
-0.0313885435461998,
0.31278833746910095,
-0.10942285507917404,
0.33104991912841797,
-0.16167880594730377,
-0.15926678478717804,
-0.530563235282898,
0.14617493748664856,
0.4875465929508209,
0.41019725799560547,
-0.043979011476039886,
0.12407676875591278,
-0.006150288973003626,
-0.3773372173309326,
0.08043412864208221,
0.10027219355106354,
-0.1320711076259613,
-0.08669280260801315,
0.4875890016555786,
0.8830057978630066,
0.18862780928611755,
-0.4475308656692505,
0.4353138208389282,
-0.3346760869026184,
-0.3185025453567505,
-0.049229465425014496,
0.06024855375289917,
0.18026697635650635,
0.5273839235305786,
0.43138840794563293,
0.14269587397575378,
-0.06009887158870697,
-0.4882810413837433,
0.01819514110684395,
0.33380162715911865,
0.20658405125141144,
-0.608649492263794,
0.7325165867805481,
0.33261868357658386,
-0.28858256340026855,
0.5139250755310059,
-0.5218669772148132,
-0.1518416404724121,
0.590755045413971,
0.3430919051170349,
0.8368434906005859,
-0.16581366956233978,
0.1916974037885666,
0.05646464228630066,
0.27645978331565857,
-0.5852797627449036,
0.3022529184818268,
-0.09501080214977264,
-0.7512691020965576,
-0.6475225687026978,
-0.7138127088546753,
-0.4316626787185669,
0.26733478903770447,
-0.8074751496315002,
0.08937986195087433,
-0.4452380836009979,
-0.2099352777004242,
-0.024807903915643692,
0.3054872155189514,
-0.8762153387069702,
-0.12648019194602966,
0.12856335937976837,
0.682249903678894,
-0.8096904754638672,
0.8916736841201782,
0.47666409611701965,
-0.40645432472229004,
-1.0273661613464355,
0.14271928369998932,
0.19129624962806702,
-0.5762776732444763,
0.4403422474861145,
-0.09847183525562286,
-0.3730679154396057,
0.0597100704908371,
-0.5079501867294312,
-0.9347057342529297,
1.2987958192825317,
0.41935309767723083,
-0.7628334164619446,
-0.4123232662677765,
0.20887845754623413,
0.672650158405304,
-0.5281599760055542,
-0.2619079649448395,
0.6413639783859253,
0.10524816811084747,
0.09120828658342361,
-1.0182783603668213,
0.3636055886745453,
0.24129986763000488,
0.19931507110595703,
0.254913330078125,
-0.7895058989524841,
0.9728865027427673,
-0.5983089804649353,
-0.22067365050315857,
0.5734013319015503,
0.4572983682155609,
0.2629973590373993,
0.6464744210243225,
0.3808248043060303,
0.4595295190811157,
0.5803488492965698,
0.01354546844959259,
0.7227509617805481,
-0.5654464364051819,
0.3792639374732971,
1.1134318113327026,
-0.40760883688926697,
0.7246332764625549,
0.6864475607872009,
-0.1543036699295044,
0.2905574142932892,
0.5237388014793396,
0.09135644882917404,
0.6271489262580872,
0.07793120294809341,
-0.06954227387905121,
-0.09443993866443634,
0.11735519766807556,
-0.3814500570297241,
0.21447166800498962,
0.7165514230728149,
-0.5779646039009094,
0.002033156342804432,
0.014762074686586857,
-0.01836472563445568,
-0.03310920298099518,
-0.3461441099643707,
0.7722721099853516,
0.3017779290676117,
-0.5902711153030396,
0.45930159091949463,
0.019899578765034676,
0.7799678444862366,
-0.5534887313842773,
0.3432258367538452,
-0.1430763453245163,
0.3705040514469147,
0.023029077798128128,
-0.48636582493782043,
0.1813627928495407,
-0.13113875687122345,
-0.3663029968738556,
-0.24822980165481567,
0.6793209910392761,
-0.4039985239505768,
-0.16923634707927704,
0.5692143440246582,
0.946986198425293,
0.05583736672997475,
0.3268384337425232,
-0.7143764495849609,
0.5876948833465576,
0.06736712157726288,
-0.14180375635623932,
0.28557315468788147,
0.6189107298851013,
-0.02206585928797722,
0.47467973828315735,
0.667380154132843,
0.3233070969581604,
0.14830563962459564,
0.10013923048973083,
0.6858965754508972,
-0.5300774574279785,
-0.3146399259567261,
-0.7282449007034302,
0.15158653259277344,
0.19319765269756317,
-0.020306941121816635,
0.9271945953369141,
0.3520849049091339,
1.007196068763733,
-0.17825324833393097,
0.7651496529579163,
-0.01900395192205906,
0.35337430238723755,
-0.6990021467208862,
0.5718297362327576,
-0.39383772015571594,
0.41169965267181396,
-0.28247082233428955,
-0.7178043723106384,
-0.12474428862333298,
0.28369423747062683,
-0.15918684005737305,
-0.1128205731511116,
0.7898304462432861,
0.7494572997093201,
0.1252651810646057,
0.19733482599258423,
0.24339547753334045,
0.3157085180282593,
0.11347084492444992,
0.7511911988258362,
0.8686603903770447,
-0.1797277331352234,
0.5538934469223022,
-0.3896808922290802,
-0.035057201981544495,
-0.3113246262073517,
-0.6634396910667419,
-0.8636854290962219,
-0.5287395119667053,
-0.14099787175655365,
-0.37005487084388733,
0.03765742853283882,
0.8100309371948242,
0.6428518295288086,
-0.3862629234790802,
-0.35226529836654663,
-0.3779240548610687,
0.028236020356416702,
-0.17838557064533234,
-0.18587744235992432,
0.10518350452184677,
-0.20481693744659424,
-0.6741207242012024,
0.4648999273777008,
0.045767515897750854,
0.2816835939884186,
-0.5659105777740479,
-0.29127711057662964,
0.15399521589279175,
0.15795081853866577,
0.5717965364456177,
0.2046208530664444,
-0.7631468176841736,
-0.045394014567136765,
-0.05631067231297493,
-0.23029163479804993,
-0.3788313567638397,
1.235148549079895,
-0.6960795521736145,
0.2352280616760254,
0.6329860687255859,
0.40927037596702576,
0.6743628978729248,
-0.39891162514686584,
0.67877197265625,
-0.6568956971168518,
0.4594140350818634,
0.04029465839266777,
0.33985093235969543,
0.46971437335014343,
-0.43228110671043396,
0.5315673351287842,
0.3548700511455536,
-0.6132816672325134,
-0.9681544899940491,
0.5109807848930359,
-0.6464678049087524,
-0.4090845286846161,
1.1587554216384888,
-0.07820208370685577,
-0.08399558812379837,
0.01898832991719246,
0.0789315328001976,
0.31189897656440735,
-0.41188910603523254,
0.4764111638069153,
0.6153647899627686,
-0.1384909301996231,
0.09118011593818665,
-0.3201056122779846,
0.6318221092224121,
0.2939628064632416,
-0.35180357098579407,
0.1270630806684494,
0.5886834859848022,
0.2825748920440674,
0.31082332134246826,
0.8374155163764954,
0.1636980026960373,
0.02880769968032837,
0.4292551875114441,
-0.1262386292219162,
-0.02703840471804142,
-0.3309009075164795,
-0.5099737644195557,
0.2646467089653015,
0.2727075517177582,
0.1373918503522873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12277v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12277v1
|
What Matters in Learning Facts in Language Models? Multifaceted Knowledge Probing with Diverse Multi-Prompt Datasets
| 2024-06-18T05:11:35 | 2024-06-18T05:11:35 |
Xin Zhao, Naoki Yoshinaga, Daisuke Oba
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) face issues in handling factual knowledge,
making it vital to evaluate their true ability to understand facts. In this
study, we introduce knowledge probing frameworks, BELIEF(-ICL), to evaluate the
knowledge understanding ability of not only encoder-based PLMs but also
decoder-based PLMs from diverse perspectives. BELIEFs utilize a multi-prompt
dataset to evaluate PLM's accuracy, consistency, and reliability in factual
knowledge understanding. To provide a more reliable evaluation with BELIEFs, we
semi-automatically create MyriadLAMA, which has more diverse prompts than
existing datasets. We validate the effectiveness of BELIEFs in correctly and
comprehensively evaluating PLM's factual understanding ability through
extensive evaluations. We further investigate key factors in learning facts in
LLMs, and reveal the limitation of the prompt-based knowledge probing. The
dataset is anonymously publicized.
|
[
-0.42861640453338623,
-0.6522181630134583,
1.0690289735794067,
0.28974011540412903,
-0.09915338456630707,
0.11639553308486938,
-0.11673731356859207,
-0.07208622246980667,
-0.4490486681461334,
0.20237217843532562,
-0.3598406910896301,
-0.628459095954895,
-0.6580004692077637,
0.2105720043182373,
-0.05871245265007019,
0.95650315284729,
0.11106153577566147,
0.15657338500022888,
-0.5427276492118835,
-0.2358628660440445,
-0.38222044706344604,
-0.4255357086658478,
-0.4733625650405884,
-0.3213839828968048,
0.5681783556938171,
0.5722233653068542,
0.4547247588634491,
0.4192454218864441,
0.19577723741531372,
0.27096107602119446,
-0.10025262832641602,
0.4828747808933258,
-0.3830829858779907,
0.11132048070430756,
-0.2856004238128662,
-0.8215016722679138,
0.20851552486419678,
0.04509834200143814,
0.8334764838218689,
0.7278180718421936,
-0.06010952964425087,
0.30221912264823914,
0.03929876908659935,
0.4575081169605255,
-0.49055567383766174,
0.3696121871471405,
-0.6923462152481079,
0.04042541980743408,
-0.0857868567109108,
-0.03677304461598396,
-0.6511545181274414,
-0.5404572486877441,
0.3301759958267212,
-0.3552471399307251,
0.2510988116264343,
0.2658354938030243,
0.6397266387939453,
0.03835093230009079,
-0.9475681185722351,
-0.6176409125328064,
-0.47542276978492737,
0.8631167411804199,
-0.7359593510627747,
0.691985011100769,
0.3540121912956238,
0.2610177993774414,
-0.10090295970439911,
-0.3200456500053406,
-0.738429605960846,
-0.3786081075668335,
-0.10514318943023682,
-0.06619298458099365,
0.07922664284706116,
0.15906855463981628,
0.5491751432418823,
0.2734135091304779,
-0.493113249540329,
0.06222469359636307,
-0.20195411145687103,
-0.3397698700428009,
0.23540610074996948,
0.06021225452423096,
0.3615393042564392,
-0.2243804633617401,
-0.5228020548820496,
-0.06411025673151016,
-0.9940266609191895,
0.3722408711910248,
0.27416855096817017,
0.03327231481671333,
-0.42051443457603455,
0.389934778213501,
-0.039507556706666946,
0.6916254162788391,
-0.07020744681358337,
-0.6975876092910767,
0.2111148238182068,
-0.26996004581451416,
-0.25451457500457764,
-0.014428003691136837,
0.5535346865653992,
0.08013559132814407,
0.027461234480142593,
-0.3039175570011139,
-0.21201016008853912,
-0.001977431820705533,
-0.2786273956298828,
-0.5877487063407898,
0.11407410353422165,
0.23459666967391968,
-0.33289575576782227,
0.21347710490226746,
0.21460680663585663,
-0.5572506189346313,
-0.6660444140434265,
-0.39680948853492737,
0.4008120596408844,
-0.6820359826087952,
-0.14041998982429504,
0.19239014387130737,
-0.18257850408554077,
0.2731165289878845,
0.585371732711792,
-0.6767019629478455,
0.012541745789349079,
0.6086594462394714,
0.613104522228241,
-0.033534396439790726,
-0.38274291157722473,
-0.5529108047485352,
-0.005166065879166126,
-0.31782710552215576,
0.7739267945289612,
-0.41453954577445984,
-0.1633533239364624,
-0.09644081443548203,
-0.08988942950963974,
-0.5054433345794678,
-0.4436775743961334,
0.5173688530921936,
-0.6734044551849365,
0.12643489241600037,
-0.8378421664237976,
-0.9564419984817505,
-0.6603848338127136,
0.41271528601646423,
-0.5333443880081177,
0.45812126994132996,
-0.29735344648361206,
-0.7896748185157776,
0.5712525248527527,
-0.6115058660507202,
-0.2468729466199875,
0.020067822188138962,
-0.327541321516037,
-0.09966663271188736,
0.15806452929973602,
0.06592617183923721,
0.44661566615104675,
-0.2917894721031189,
0.7206258773803711,
-0.4680120646953583,
-0.03723158687353134,
0.7253291606903076,
-0.7475593090057373,
0.7920634150505066,
0.32627424597740173,
-0.22486765682697296,
-0.05713789165019989,
-0.5796619057655334,
-0.30519601702690125,
-0.026805289089679718,
-0.5020440816879272,
-0.22502641379833221,
0.19050495326519012,
-0.5641801953315735,
0.2235201895236969,
0.13795897364616394,
-0.8386521935462952,
0.023161394521594048,
-0.3641531765460968,
-0.10331462323665619,
0.7225040793418884,
0.17703410983085632,
0.10115497559309006,
-0.524481475353241,
0.3621913194656372,
0.32426178455352783,
0.09510408341884613,
-0.39562350511550903,
-0.6209163665771484,
-1.017025351524353,
-0.021515382453799248,
0.08537187427282333,
0.41132327914237976,
-0.6757987141609192,
0.13590355217456818,
-0.060711897909641266,
-0.35880860686302185,
-0.49636971950531006,
0.1012328639626503,
0.35749372839927673,
0.7778306603431702,
0.11483721435070038,
0.2486734539270401,
-0.4622752070426941,
-0.9221314191818237,
-0.2387695610523224,
-0.27086132764816284,
0.2134530246257782,
0.3059297800064087,
0.6129319071769714,
-0.036572638899087906,
1.0376585721969604,
-0.35616832971572876,
0.14646019041538239,
-0.2895292043685913,
0.35128098726272583,
0.24324029684066772,
0.24892166256904602,
0.5872079730033875,
-0.8449888229370117,
-0.5090168118476868,
-0.04792040213942528,
-0.8989686369895935,
0.15399950742721558,
-0.31290578842163086,
0.38355958461761475,
0.17855022847652435,
0.11978280544281006,
-0.7841564416885376,
0.2882785201072693,
0.6582775712013245,
-0.4165855944156647,
0.5406347513198853,
-0.19931986927986145,
0.29888224601745605,
-0.7832251191139221,
-0.159568190574646,
0.19598321616649628,
-0.18872730433940887,
-0.6059122681617737,
0.06629562377929688,
0.22123168408870697,
0.2618735432624817,
-0.37899163365364075,
0.48828592896461487,
-0.35068419575691223,
-0.1197034940123558,
-0.07926465570926666,
0.1043257936835289,
0.06270069628953934,
0.3112863302230835,
0.19250355660915375,
0.9339308142662048,
0.8043162226676941,
-0.8304452896118164,
0.2674839496612549,
0.1610931009054184,
-0.7417362928390503,
0.09936101734638214,
-0.34222412109375,
0.1659434735774994,
-0.2592996060848236,
-0.05148129165172577,
-1.0224970579147339,
0.022581355646252632,
0.23105095326900482,
-0.30595046281814575,
0.10734020918607712,
-0.18580421805381775,
-0.7221416234970093,
0.08063143491744995,
-0.029717182740569115,
0.02770565077662468,
0.32881036400794983,
-0.8127399682998657,
0.5105594396591187,
0.33954110741615295,
-0.1278737485408783,
-0.6521604061126709,
-0.2615813612937927,
0.07248114794492722,
-0.2754247784614563,
-0.5169401168823242,
-0.08482899516820908,
-0.4466729462146759,
-0.6259220242500305,
-0.205331489443779,
-0.05017838627099991,
0.09106165915727615,
0.15006688237190247,
0.02557363174855709,
0.18930596113204956,
-0.34795352816581726,
0.4451519846916199,
0.010817006230354309,
0.1040392592549324,
0.3349541425704956,
-0.24673081934452057,
0.4411325752735138,
-0.3041748106479645,
-0.7697160243988037,
-0.1332779973745346,
0.0036725325044244528,
0.6918103694915771,
-0.1414829045534134,
1.0119916200637817,
0.41336166858673096,
-0.16267815232276917,
-0.46197861433029175,
-0.7969195246696472,
-0.2552589774131775,
-0.4277011454105377,
0.23700577020645142,
-0.40087684988975525,
-1.0037999153137207,
0.6596305966377258,
-0.13011063635349274,
0.040139779448509216,
0.3921942114830017,
0.43234628438949585,
-0.20350603759288788,
0.9850308895111084,
0.44259464740753174,
0.16065876185894012,
-0.16844864189624786,
0.10533550381660461,
0.21985380351543427,
-0.6741623878479004,
-0.5087900757789612,
-0.39192891120910645,
0.24572089314460754,
-0.36157718300819397,
-0.431049644947052,
0.6588470339775085,
-0.11316803097724915,
-0.3145948350429535,
-0.3859866261482239,
0.2231617271900177,
0.36403027176856995,
0.3543226718902588,
0.17956572771072388,
0.4479953348636627,
-0.1693102866411209,
-0.3910088837146759,
0.001602139906026423,
-0.6872656345367432,
-0.538502037525177,
0.9869576692581177,
0.5396637916564941,
0.6739873290061951,
0.46993958950042725,
0.19696591794490814,
0.2642821967601776,
0.1620078682899475,
-0.9583303928375244,
0.40538841485977173,
-0.036875706166028976,
-0.6831847429275513,
-0.11967813223600388,
-0.4401014745235443,
-0.43856894969940186,
0.3655216693878174,
-0.10933449864387512,
-0.4474834203720093,
0.32712817192077637,
0.05172131210565567,
-0.4559665620326996,
0.5613422989845276,
-0.6795487403869629,
0.5995474457740784,
-0.463207483291626,
-0.0017062685219570994,
-0.3378255069255829,
-0.494381308555603,
0.5465085506439209,
-0.20363225042819977,
0.31019675731658936,
-0.07345321029424667,
0.11484697461128235,
0.6914864778518677,
-0.12673720717430115,
1.2316642999649048,
-0.3023342788219452,
-0.2956126928329468,
0.2836841344833374,
0.02445441111922264,
0.3433539569377899,
0.37245750427246094,
-0.07039052993059158,
0.03596881777048111,
-0.06038688123226166,
-0.11122148483991623,
-0.7574288845062256,
0.38991931080818176,
-0.8023594617843628,
-0.914876401424408,
-0.4475388824939728,
-0.6076596975326538,
-0.4468008577823639,
0.0013357913121581078,
0.0951312705874443,
0.751995325088501,
-0.05674441531300545,
0.5128484964370728,
1.2940212488174438,
-0.44402655959129333,
0.18224787712097168,
0.9012645483016968,
-0.2214028239250183,
-0.04133443161845207,
0.9122305512428284,
0.1692037433385849,
0.3387739658355713,
0.5156614184379578,
0.3290848731994629,
-0.6325374841690063,
-0.7148358821868896,
-0.3431131839752197,
0.3136708736419678,
-1.2056264877319336,
-0.1662081629037857,
-0.7507227659225464,
-0.08410926163196564,
-0.35017502307891846,
0.2707095146179199,
-0.0758705884218216,
0.09635177254676819,
-0.2101258486509323,
-0.33666813373565674,
0.45925334095954895,
0.7968207001686096,
0.01171681098639965,
0.13677144050598145,
-0.8540697693824768,
0.42818373441696167,
0.4771486520767212,
0.23681966960430145,
-0.17487110197544098,
-0.5765752196311951,
-0.24008598923683167,
0.19994233548641205,
0.17360779643058777,
-0.9466007947921753,
0.19507300853729248,
0.1985747218132019,
0.9485236406326294,
0.5549572706222534,
0.07700949907302856,
0.3138797879219055,
-0.14335502684116364,
0.5714121460914612,
-0.043329738080501556,
-1.0363420248031616,
0.4176081120967865,
-0.13839761912822723,
0.2427925169467926,
0.33710238337516785,
0.5223575234413147,
-0.6912829875946045,
-0.24821093678474426,
-0.38042014837265015,
-0.135856494307518,
0.7879018783569336,
-0.17948749661445618,
-0.08789949864149094,
0.04001336172223091,
0.18981018662452698,
0.5910288691520691,
0.3887949585914612,
-0.6613887548446655,
-0.5001193881034851,
-0.13185110688209534,
-0.23975688219070435,
0.017782075330615044,
-0.4093876779079437,
-0.20545892417430878,
-0.2116253823041916,
0.5260044932365417,
-0.4119480848312378,
-0.008958502672612667,
0.05000760406255722,
-0.4169588088989258,
0.17351588606834412,
0.5673930644989014,
0.5049150586128235,
0.939594566822052,
-0.1884787380695343,
0.40947577357292175,
0.320230096578598,
-0.36319223046302795,
0.06430944800376892,
-0.02934817411005497,
-0.3888969123363495,
-0.08688297867774963,
0.3478721082210541,
1.1863993406295776,
0.2657047510147095,
-0.7484601140022278,
0.5194085836410522,
-0.09339588135480881,
0.006655484903603792,
-0.12018821388483047,
0.10784169286489487,
0.08834892511367798,
0.016786957159638405,
0.4065815210342407,
0.4625542163848877,
0.04766836017370224,
-0.6115013957023621,
0.2688477039337158,
0.2261687070131302,
-0.07875754684209824,
-0.5215911269187927,
0.10415206104516983,
-0.017863556742668152,
0.2686460316181183,
0.6056041717529297,
-0.4146195948123932,
-0.6703463196754456,
0.6027058362960815,
0.6675823330879211,
0.3750256299972534,
-0.3059273064136505,
0.6140129566192627,
0.27604687213897705,
0.43599703907966614,
0.05648498609662056,
0.27950066328048706,
0.006237547378987074,
-1.370192289352417,
-0.6006975173950195,
-0.5258643627166748,
-0.433765172958374,
0.25797590613365173,
-0.36549878120422363,
0.09953220188617706,
-0.5328512191772461,
0.08267015963792801,
-0.35970890522003174,
0.08339521288871765,
-0.8533923625946045,
0.4030967652797699,
0.3249853253364563,
1.102660059928894,
-0.9885613918304443,
0.8269497752189636,
0.5575201511383057,
-0.5019606351852417,
-0.9067766666412354,
0.024697573855519295,
0.15218733251094818,
-0.9201231002807617,
0.9897934198379517,
0.04304935038089752,
-0.24108481407165527,
-0.04944365471601486,
-0.7051517367362976,
-1.0289249420166016,
0.7987660765647888,
0.7372990846633911,
-0.4223887622356415,
0.17894767224788666,
0.1299913078546524,
0.20543929934501648,
-0.4707554578781128,
0.33684322237968445,
0.3883858025074005,
0.6897680163383484,
0.12174692749977112,
-0.7994478940963745,
-0.13624359667301178,
0.010515259578824043,
-0.4889378845691681,
-0.29279062151908875,
-0.629296064376831,
1.0779415369033813,
-0.3562192916870117,
-0.3997390866279602,
-0.3521779179573059,
0.6187746524810791,
0.7144973874092102,
0.3635631501674652,
0.5766105055809021,
0.38411945104599,
1.076409101486206,
-0.036567602306604385,
0.997910737991333,
-0.19152410328388214,
0.3699098825454712,
0.892918050289154,
-0.2527892291545868,
0.4402289092540741,
0.2624088227748871,
-0.2059796005487442,
0.6248669624328613,
0.6842706203460693,
-0.046030789613723755,
0.3920839726924896,
-0.17658887803554535,
-0.3256366550922394,
-0.5512503385543823,
-0.26374468207359314,
-0.15497322380542755,
0.6065065264701843,
0.7850461006164551,
-0.14081424474716187,
-0.37612536549568176,
0.09532061219215393,
0.1169482171535492,
-0.01026936899870634,
-0.07729663699865341,
0.7368162870407104,
0.12373779714107513,
-0.6491466760635376,
0.3117315173149109,
0.0034985910169780254,
0.634342610836029,
-0.8203145265579224,
-0.21724845468997955,
-0.10445842146873474,
-0.20634543895721436,
-0.10188528150320053,
-1.0051339864730835,
-0.10687954723834991,
-0.02798824943602085,
-0.21058693528175354,
-0.15879204869270325,
0.8389319181442261,
-0.43655410408973694,
-0.2560080885887146,
0.09990116953849792,
0.7526476383209229,
0.09678269177675247,
-0.13838347792625427,
-0.6440704464912415,
0.11588580906391144,
0.2717565894126892,
-0.1076023280620575,
0.2319875806570053,
0.5931592583656311,
0.21793553233146667,
0.907879650592804,
0.5947772860527039,
0.1523178666830063,
0.09390633553266525,
0.24548491835594177,
0.7789518237113953,
-0.4103533625602722,
-0.43169155716896057,
-0.8108996748924255,
0.502986490726471,
0.017320528626441956,
-0.20534004271030426,
1.1752680540084839,
0.5145528316497803,
0.6301277279853821,
-0.051681432873010635,
1.1237409114837646,
0.1821177750825882,
0.6715306043624878,
-0.962005615234375,
0.7542946338653564,
-0.13868585228919983,
0.35030412673950195,
0.30100491642951965,
-0.5712946653366089,
-0.08718348294496536,
0.4685889184474945,
-0.5310739874839783,
0.08071811497211456,
0.6774155497550964,
0.49795034527778625,
0.025827864184975624,
0.3893497586250305,
0.4442559480667114,
0.4875999987125397,
0.3639514744281769,
0.23153817653656006,
1.1061689853668213,
-0.12988035380840302,
0.1370350420475006,
-0.11862803995609283,
-0.18244440853595734,
0.019290568307042122,
-0.9096426367759705,
-0.8380272388458252,
-0.7755348086357117,
-0.2821996510028839,
-0.018365919589996338,
-0.14503945410251617,
1.0253461599349976,
0.5947139859199524,
-1.0518792867660522,
-0.20189236104488373,
0.052702613174915314,
0.5920763611793518,
0.1077989712357521,
-0.23667772114276886,
0.45861247181892395,
-0.6716928482055664,
-0.5080750584602356,
0.6659507751464844,
0.29700300097465515,
-0.06844350695610046,
-0.3887179493904114,
-0.17776863276958466,
-0.24582579731941223,
-0.09704285115003586,
0.7399688959121704,
0.17970699071884155,
-0.8190217018127441,
-0.4027906656265259,
0.10288747400045395,
0.07665346562862396,
0.09082739800214767,
0.7778593897819519,
-0.9312705993652344,
0.5989765524864197,
0.48349669575691223,
0.6635833382606506,
0.06338493525981903,
-0.028254834935069084,
0.5864214897155762,
-0.6101047396659851,
-0.13119672238826752,
0.022837691009044647,
0.6757510900497437,
0.6152666211128235,
-0.44547995924949646,
-0.05709753558039665,
0.5202756524085999,
-0.41841593384742737,
-0.567084014415741,
0.3508633077144623,
-0.653676450252533,
-0.31806862354278564,
1.268601655960083,
-0.40518566966056824,
-0.18469581007957458,
-0.6022698879241943,
-0.032846979796886444,
0.08243606239557266,
-0.3899625241756439,
0.5301876664161682,
0.8001279234886169,
-0.13676966726779938,
-0.38907790184020996,
-0.6417028903961182,
0.5341917872428894,
0.22507907450199127,
-0.6612234711647034,
0.08201798051595688,
0.45785942673683167,
0.49483877420425415,
0.20735695958137512,
0.2948562204837799,
0.08772075921297073,
-0.04983660206198692,
-0.11480862647294998,
-0.21950607001781464,
0.041444968432188034,
-0.4904557764530182,
-0.19098250567913055,
0.31532585620880127,
0.2805517315864563,
0.1310274451971054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12276v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12276v1
|
CodeNav: Beyond tool-use to using real-world codebases with LLM agents
| 2024-06-18T05:10:38 | 2024-06-18T05:10:38 |
Tanmay Gupta, Luca Weihs, Aniruddha Kembhavi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SE
|
We present CodeNav, an LLM agent that navigates and leverages previously
unseen code repositories to solve user queries. In contrast to tool-use LLM
agents that require ``registration'' of all relevant tools via manual
descriptions within the LLM context, CodeNav automatically indexes and searches
over code blocks in the target codebase, finds relevant code snippets, imports
them, and uses them to iteratively generate a solution with execution feedback.
To highlight the core-capabilities of CodeNav, we first showcase three case
studies where we use CodeNav for solving complex user queries using three
diverse codebases. Next, on three benchmarks, we quantitatively compare the
effectiveness of code-use (which only has access to the target codebase) to
tool-use (which has privileged access to all tool names and descriptions).
Finally, we study the effect of varying kinds of tool and library descriptions
on code-use performance, as well as investigate the advantage of the agent
seeing source code as opposed to natural descriptions of code. All code will be
made open source under a permissive license.
|
[
-0.21996904909610748,
-0.1902722418308258,
0.27485373616218567,
0.09707460552453995,
-0.14466536045074463,
0.6357684135437012,
-0.1191498264670372,
-0.42121773958206177,
0.3793032169342041,
0.6766142845153809,
-0.38605815172195435,
-0.7477309107780457,
0.0974944457411766,
-0.0669027790427208,
-0.5001683831214905,
0.4745384156703949,
0.04349786788225174,
-0.07368268072605133,
-0.4986569881439209,
-0.14551523327827454,
-0.29281920194625854,
-0.9323395490646362,
-0.1062907874584198,
-0.22370722889900208,
0.7335981726646423,
0.6689344048500061,
0.8761475682258606,
0.6433575749397278,
0.6576119661331177,
0.2249220907688141,
0.21215422451496124,
0.0655960738658905,
-0.5030972957611084,
0.4326302111148834,
-0.09665621072053909,
-0.890035092830658,
-0.3097645342350006,
-0.02883131615817547,
0.18641896545886993,
0.3085256516933441,
-0.12062346190214157,
0.3060278296470642,
-0.07061559706926346,
0.6167835593223572,
-0.6813806295394897,
0.015588745474815369,
-0.5681861042976379,
0.06445717066526413,
-0.2266741842031479,
-0.5565222501754761,
-0.17374026775360107,
-0.49708300828933716,
0.055971551686525345,
-0.5708884000778198,
-0.024630581960082054,
-0.014933177269995213,
0.6842969655990601,
0.5686145424842834,
-0.4296852648258209,
-0.401720255613327,
-0.6299310922622681,
0.4941750466823578,
-0.4571100175380707,
0.15346640348434448,
0.21130584180355072,
0.608988881111145,
-0.2343961000442505,
-0.9513793587684631,
-0.2462717592716217,
-0.473254531621933,
0.02955581247806549,
-0.010958938859403133,
-0.29468104243278503,
-0.03092772141098976,
0.2955228388309479,
0.2780107259750366,
-0.5095949769020081,
0.07356971502304077,
-0.3898346424102783,
-0.4373779296875,
0.622769296169281,
0.27431654930114746,
0.2457713484764099,
0.2527134418487549,
-0.5020686388015747,
0.007090712431818247,
-0.9288602471351624,
0.1925698071718216,
0.2809109687805176,
0.037495121359825134,
0.29936838150024414,
0.7633568048477173,
-0.10150034725666046,
0.5917257070541382,
-0.5325074791908264,
0.13527147471904755,
0.463173508644104,
-0.2835443913936615,
-0.11963970959186554,
-0.12362843006849289,
0.2698112428188324,
0.4786907434463501,
0.46804070472717285,
-0.47713354229927063,
-0.30991268157958984,
0.003435812657698989,
0.5156301856040955,
-0.7056640982627869,
-0.3006281852722168,
0.1508254110813141,
-0.47127559781074524,
-0.4344073534011841,
0.20550420880317688,
-0.430596262216568,
-0.9205967783927917,
-0.14099735021591187,
0.16799457371234894,
0.15547572076320648,
-0.35426071286201477,
-0.14588604867458344,
-0.27868419885635376,
0.49182257056236267,
0.31957799196243286,
-0.013609997928142548,
0.3309372365474701,
0.4971507489681244,
0.8584040999412537,
-0.3538840711116791,
-0.2489563375711441,
-0.7055351734161377,
-0.0003201610816176981,
-0.305798202753067,
0.6677412986755371,
-0.6213129758834839,
-0.6522592902183533,
0.06467457115650177,
-0.025263186544179916,
0.39116644859313965,
-0.741991400718689,
-0.0891716256737709,
-0.8043814897537231,
-0.36355432868003845,
-0.2235247790813446,
-0.3383045494556427,
-0.27017685770988464,
0.3491989076137543,
-0.8017421364784241,
1.0882633924484253,
0.23731637001037598,
-0.231700137257576,
0.3386293649673462,
-0.7315276861190796,
-0.30878153443336487,
0.23542387783527374,
-0.337467223405838,
0.04136764630675316,
-0.010683778673410416,
-0.16961634159088135,
0.36999985575675964,
0.000487981247715652,
-0.0637068971991539,
-0.12401285767555237,
-0.6569330096244812,
0.4115537106990814,
0.1396598368883133,
0.588324248790741,
0.5344609022140503,
-0.36279863119125366,
0.23276527225971222,
-0.5424462556838989,
0.06292174756526947,
0.15810954570770264,
-0.4844593405723572,
-0.1895754188299179,
0.20538325607776642,
-0.045942749828100204,
0.17573867738246918,
0.3423173427581787,
-0.28338465094566345,
0.6908268928527832,
-0.46353012323379517,
0.3770988881587982,
0.37930598855018616,
0.012538024224340916,
0.5744082927703857,
-0.25795695185661316,
1.0879254341125488,
-0.16102056205272675,
0.21292690932750702,
-0.21913449466228485,
-0.3880269229412079,
-0.5432688593864441,
-0.11544998735189438,
0.2786441445350647,
0.7357428073883057,
-0.9428153038024902,
-0.0573589988052845,
-0.09708963334560394,
-0.6082647442817688,
-0.27483853697776794,
0.341105580329895,
0.39212772250175476,
0.07328642159700394,
0.1284026950597763,
-0.5250759720802307,
-0.6497783064842224,
-0.7781566381454468,
-0.4663999378681183,
-0.2677420675754547,
0.02363477647304535,
0.6009679436683655,
0.4398358464241028,
-0.4837952256202698,
1.0581233501434326,
-0.6388425827026367,
-0.2942381203174591,
-0.3255753219127655,
-0.32821419835090637,
0.11970695108175278,
0.15630175173282623,
0.34732088446617126,
-0.8922423720359802,
-0.25773707032203674,
0.06589458882808685,
-0.6836352944374084,
-0.25155553221702576,
-0.1267096847295761,
-0.15753276646137238,
0.2075977772474289,
0.8408573865890503,
-0.26952093839645386,
0.6505737900733948,
0.39270609617233276,
-0.21470598876476288,
0.3894340991973877,
-0.06069491431117058,
-0.01870950311422348,
-0.8758173584938049,
0.11760285496711731,
-0.3055342137813568,
-0.5622735619544983,
-0.4220111668109894,
0.6734333038330078,
0.2276284098625183,
-0.21649594604969025,
-0.7468759417533875,
0.4990932047367096,
-0.733590304851532,
-0.6800003051757812,
-0.20376305282115936,
0.2111297845840454,
0.024359283968806267,
0.3955690562725067,
-0.30357763171195984,
1.4497019052505493,
0.43996554613113403,
-0.5317063331604004,
0.5346964001655579,
-0.0830807164311409,
-0.04732588678598404,
0.03431796655058861,
-0.5525230169296265,
0.23923009634017944,
0.3992084860801697,
0.20957788825035095,
-0.6999829411506653,
0.03860858455300331,
0.3154381215572357,
-0.3847927451133728,
0.014051171950995922,
-0.5948867797851562,
-0.8213517665863037,
-0.28492116928100586,
-0.44191059470176697,
0.09937231242656708,
0.6126895546913147,
-0.4767972528934479,
0.6868922114372253,
0.491181880235672,
0.31694546341896057,
-0.67716383934021,
-0.6891452074050903,
0.47603920102119446,
-0.15786363184452057,
-0.5129199028015137,
0.06926023960113525,
-0.21603915095329285,
-0.41995769739151,
-0.023821210488677025,
-0.46586230397224426,
-0.42721307277679443,
0.5317257046699524,
0.5518737435340881,
0.22776810824871063,
-0.19628554582595825,
0.47709450125694275,
-0.2368192970752716,
-0.05782706290483475,
0.07526610046625137,
-0.2433052957057953,
0.40118974447250366,
-0.430869460105896,
-0.4493076205253601,
0.23782658576965332,
0.12084910273551941,
0.3428252339363098,
-0.5389479994773865,
0.28004083037376404,
0.20023734867572784,
-0.17343716323375702,
-0.349068284034729,
-0.47979581356048584,
0.027671001851558685,
-0.5191470384597778,
0.1437176913022995,
-0.5120092630386353,
-0.8639346957206726,
0.7108930349349976,
-0.33647024631500244,
0.08356321603059769,
-0.0813848152756691,
0.5658185482025146,
-0.09442723542451859,
0.5463598966598511,
0.6961127519607544,
0.04261511191725731,
0.6227591633796692,
-0.4251748025417328,
-0.0623592883348465,
-0.4696860909461975,
-0.3852227032184601,
-0.45901089906692505,
-0.41531500220298767,
-0.2594558000564575,
-0.7909857630729675,
0.22855167090892792,
0.16472360491752625,
0.16599984467029572,
0.8003197312355042,
-0.7109757661819458,
0.8986254334449768,
0.49349960684776306,
0.001514095813035965,
0.6601019501686096,
-0.254985511302948,
-0.026909910142421722,
0.27617111802101135,
-0.6673992872238159,
-0.6902353763580322,
1.354475736618042,
0.17833811044692993,
0.8943503499031067,
0.10124046355485916,
1.0783848762512207,
0.6999221444129944,
0.3088769018650055,
-0.9743326902389526,
0.7039785981178284,
0.3512721657752991,
-0.6583114266395569,
-0.05563942715525627,
-0.24971804022789001,
-1.15804922580719,
0.3343644440174103,
0.13468614220619202,
-0.5011650919914246,
0.27810078859329224,
0.19317282736301422,
-0.14991189539432526,
0.11841502040624619,
-0.8725804686546326,
0.7727137804031372,
-0.2846162021160126,
-0.1867932677268982,
-0.21716132760047913,
-0.6028320789337158,
0.05823635309934616,
0.09092320501804352,
0.060955338180065155,
0.014198415912687778,
-0.7341388463973999,
0.2987416982650757,
-0.4447416067123413,
0.6803077459335327,
-0.30057036876678467,
-0.12417515367269516,
0.38353878259658813,
0.47726577520370483,
0.5257436037063599,
0.10367061197757721,
-0.005381612107157707,
0.09034620970487595,
0.14040975272655487,
-0.3482609987258911,
-0.6051327586174011,
0.7603626847267151,
-0.6226783990859985,
-0.6812616586685181,
-0.4153346121311188,
-0.28700876235961914,
0.05685119330883026,
0.299936980009079,
-0.06490008533000946,
0.6144638061523438,
-0.15988516807556152,
0.2759128510951996,
0.5656107068061829,
-0.08497611433267593,
0.4516482353210449,
0.6955426335334778,
-0.5486447215080261,
0.16703787446022034,
0.8609076738357544,
0.12485569715499878,
0.06520506739616394,
0.316523015499115,
-0.1456802934408188,
-0.08116002380847931,
-0.6053981781005859,
-0.3109673261642456,
0.05351987108588219,
-0.8284226059913635,
-0.39849454164505005,
-0.44887837767601013,
-0.0009109077509492636,
0.1762271225452423,
-0.30397528409957886,
-0.33846133947372437,
-0.5776803493499756,
-0.44256436824798584,
-0.03240522742271423,
0.39989835023880005,
0.756872296333313,
0.21026146411895752,
0.1562323421239853,
-0.7558763027191162,
0.25634849071502686,
0.12584544718265533,
0.5270793437957764,
-0.35710424184799194,
-0.06588984280824661,
-0.5753222107887268,
-0.27284520864486694,
-0.21768270432949066,
-0.9713512063026428,
0.3269987404346466,
-0.024428335949778557,
0.7757471799850464,
0.0585457943379879,
0.31321263313293457,
0.31154146790504456,
-0.27860933542251587,
0.819699227809906,
-0.21741445362567902,
-0.7906990051269531,
0.5621204972267151,
-0.048984576016664505,
0.17424486577510834,
0.7343313694000244,
0.25458359718322754,
-0.25294479727745056,
-0.5672339200973511,
-0.31473544239997864,
-0.7918288111686707,
0.3883759081363678,
0.4469585716724396,
0.0658831000328064,
0.2332780957221985,
0.368839830160141,
-0.08733577281236649,
0.3850899040699005,
-0.5300247073173523,
-0.4923775792121887,
-0.2980319559574127,
0.26136597990989685,
-0.014288674108684063,
0.008312768302857876,
-0.3375658690929413,
-0.07348988950252533,
0.2380945086479187,
-0.2650318443775177,
0.16892045736312866,
0.3457429111003876,
-0.8362681865692139,
0.054098889231681824,
0.2421320080757141,
0.4281165301799774,
1.0785431861877441,
-0.19200727343559265,
0.12717029452323914,
0.10651591420173645,
-0.3807995915412903,
-0.09033191949129105,
-0.015971746295690536,
0.321963369846344,
-0.0829358771443367,
0.1779993772506714,
0.0635598823428154,
0.20900452136993408,
-1.0491578578948975,
0.6408784985542297,
-0.15505875647068024,
-0.20295944809913635,
-0.4647248685359955,
0.4797857105731964,
0.20366023480892181,
0.711683988571167,
0.5039909482002258,
0.19121018052101135,
0.4397641122341156,
-0.5302978157997131,
0.3090091347694397,
0.24863822758197784,
-0.41109782457351685,
0.04034684598445892,
0.6424371004104614,
0.4952836036682129,
-0.5561811923980713,
0.24727840721607208,
-0.09381337463855743,
-0.5797340869903564,
0.9628113508224487,
0.08084066212177277,
0.9044961929321289,
0.294060081243515,
0.08951222151517868,
-0.2951241731643677,
0.33920252323150635,
0.25020670890808105,
0.4748493731021881,
-0.4351228177547455,
-0.4380573630332947,
-0.343099981546402,
0.10435641556978226,
-0.6944637298583984,
-0.48233649134635925,
-0.7069740295410156,
0.19096936285495758,
-0.5387873649597168,
-0.2057398557662964,
-0.35571661591529846,
0.2806323766708374,
-0.720437228679657,
-0.2962600886821747,
0.07559866458177567,
1.4152659177780151,
-0.29549553990364075,
1.1191009283065796,
1.0539710521697998,
-0.6546860337257385,
-0.7143741846084595,
0.024000011384487152,
0.21738961338996887,
-1.016771674156189,
0.5125898718833923,
0.18403105437755585,
-0.4363920986652374,
0.1007135882973671,
-0.8161574602127075,
-0.6559739708900452,
1.5728496313095093,
0.13141730427742004,
-0.43172281980514526,
0.15531185269355774,
-0.3431631326675415,
0.6795148253440857,
-0.4646477997303009,
0.18166576325893402,
0.6668519377708435,
0.2605196237564087,
-0.08304347842931747,
-0.60379958152771,
0.05780867114663124,
-0.4266505241394043,
0.057600703090429306,
0.10644926875829697,
-0.35998719930648804,
0.48802679777145386,
-0.28097862005233765,
-0.1764202117919922,
0.03369499742984772,
0.30843204259872437,
0.24507084488868713,
0.37949880957603455,
0.4737817645072937,
-0.09715975075960159,
0.5474795699119568,
0.10993494093418121,
1.133386492729187,
-0.4921157658100128,
0.24039527773857117,
0.8521003723144531,
-0.34713125228881836,
0.6898759007453918,
0.41798362135887146,
-0.18747520446777344,
0.5704657435417175,
0.3690107464790344,
-0.10244924575090408,
0.18812383711338043,
0.490600049495697,
-0.11035726964473724,
-0.17673057317733765,
-0.06458365172147751,
-0.5739275217056274,
0.16952569782733917,
0.17153333127498627,
-0.056255094707012177,
-0.1512778103351593,
-0.2015358805656433,
0.003269035369157791,
0.29863440990448,
-0.1859620064496994,
0.7412412762641907,
0.12338755279779434,
-0.3150999844074249,
0.54619300365448,
-0.22901968657970428,
0.5548660755157471,
-0.6889508962631226,
-0.15003156661987305,
-0.42398184537887573,
0.050321899354457855,
-0.4213915765285492,
-0.916924238204956,
0.21749348938465118,
0.1016526147723198,
-0.0060203722678124905,
-0.35663726925849915,
0.9637432098388672,
-0.05229542776942253,
0.09116531908512115,
0.5109927654266357,
0.7205376625061035,
0.4788997769355774,
-0.28890615701675415,
-0.7063505053520203,
0.012953761965036392,
-0.0428457111120224,
-0.37345775961875916,
0.4796103239059448,
0.2925260663032532,
-0.0723840594291687,
1.1592108011245728,
0.5970442295074463,
0.13785101473331451,
0.11176184564828873,
0.1950921267271042,
1.2829357385635376,
-0.7607336044311523,
-0.33197134733200073,
-0.56727534532547,
0.4784621000289917,
-0.07196057587862015,
-0.04341016337275505,
0.7936047911643982,
0.6948509216308594,
0.8371748328208923,
-0.13379785418510437,
0.6685141324996948,
0.043585482984781265,
0.4401852488517761,
-0.3956603407859802,
0.6083637475967407,
-0.6587720513343811,
0.7740163803100586,
-0.10253217816352844,
-1.0414832830429077,
-0.516023576259613,
0.36353379487991333,
-0.09865183383226395,
-0.2341092824935913,
0.4931058883666992,
1.1216456890106201,
0.15763673186302185,
-0.5051102042198181,
0.49595656991004944,
-0.17972210049629211,
0.43126365542411804,
0.3007989525794983,
1.2562118768692017,
0.025348784402012825,
1.1897876262664795,
-0.03928574547171593,
-0.07423529028892517,
-0.5223953127861023,
-0.7921706438064575,
-0.9962180852890015,
-0.19901669025421143,
-0.09591924399137497,
-0.40758731961250305,
-0.011899958364665508,
1.1031367778778076,
0.5962182879447937,
-0.5370603203773499,
-0.5656952261924744,
0.14699000120162964,
0.5521316528320312,
-0.140264630317688,
-0.2208939492702484,
-0.25930458307266235,
-0.37374043464660645,
-0.21346363425254822,
0.5675926804542542,
0.26718243956565857,
-0.1924590915441513,
-0.4748248755931854,
-0.2169223427772522,
0.05876905843615532,
-0.04742537438869476,
0.39044275879859924,
0.5209243297576904,
-0.6112526059150696,
0.028208935633301735,
0.211526021361351,
-0.36705344915390015,
0.3499518930912018,
1.3307164907455444,
-1.209731936454773,
0.5897933840751648,
0.38682425022125244,
0.6586514115333557,
0.4868600070476532,
0.11311031132936478,
0.6417428851127625,
-0.8336567878723145,
-0.06432833522558212,
0.35905933380126953,
0.16894084215164185,
-0.17397616803646088,
-0.4227422773838043,
0.8592542409896851,
-0.07341422885656357,
-0.5175338983535767,
-0.9148926138877869,
0.33512791991233826,
-0.9970076084136963,
-0.3856711983680725,
1.1397768259048462,
-0.2556888163089752,
0.09822813421487808,
-0.5149058103561401,
-0.46830832958221436,
-0.1574041247367859,
-0.657078742980957,
0.07030712813138962,
0.23450244963169098,
-0.12203960120677948,
-0.21569009125232697,
-0.7028191089630127,
0.3481084406375885,
-0.1054065078496933,
-0.7127830386161804,
-0.1383606642484665,
0.5478286147117615,
0.26356953382492065,
-0.035511743277311325,
0.66294926404953,
0.019569018855690956,
0.374379962682724,
-0.10651954263448715,
0.2777249813079834,
-0.6055105328559875,
-0.44198352098464966,
-0.47558683156967163,
0.05770423635840416,
0.44107696413993835,
-0.26723411679267883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12274v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12274v1
|
SafeInfer: Context Adaptive Decoding Time Safety Alignment for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-18T05:03:23 | 2024-06-18T05:03:23 |
Somnath Banerjee, Soham Tripathy, Sayan Layek, Shanu Kumar, Animesh Mukherjee, Rima Hazra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Safety-aligned language models often exhibit fragile and imbalanced safety
mechanisms, increasing the likelihood of generating unsafe content. In
addition, incorporating new knowledge through editing techniques to language
models can further compromise safety. To address these issues, we propose
SafeInfer, a context-adaptive, decoding-time safety alignment strategy for
generating safe responses to user queries. SafeInfer comprises two phases: the
safety amplification phase, which employs safe demonstration examples to adjust
the model's hidden states and increase the likelihood of safer outputs, and the
safety-guided decoding phase, which influences token selection based on
safety-optimized distributions, ensuring the generated content complies with
ethical guidelines. Further, we present HarmEval, a novel benchmark for
extensive safety evaluations, designed to address potential misuse scenarios in
accordance with the policies of leading AI tech giants.
|
[
0.036390550434589386,
-0.7436227202415466,
0.027304857969284058,
0.28055840730667114,
-0.2319953739643097,
0.07487814128398895,
0.04694202169775963,
-0.6329647898674011,
-0.3641345500946045,
0.37532806396484375,
-0.30515286326408386,
-0.5236006379127502,
-0.409854918718338,
-0.031842708587646484,
-0.5655895471572876,
0.931736171245575,
0.17324669659137726,
-0.08679098635911942,
0.023573212325572968,
-0.19399869441986084,
-0.7565590739250183,
-0.5516205430030823,
-1.0445125102996826,
-0.03174067288637161,
0.37682676315307617,
0.34279894828796387,
1.014936089515686,
0.8949469923973083,
0.6084166169166565,
0.29124563932418823,
-0.16080667078495026,
0.0672188550233841,
-0.25510871410369873,
0.4165094494819641,
-0.35930928587913513,
-0.07229214906692505,
-0.77171391248703,
-0.3185445964336395,
0.45437872409820557,
0.6211849451065063,
-0.3862937092781067,
-0.18654803931713104,
0.2513493001461029,
0.37697333097457886,
-0.9424418807029724,
-0.1430712342262268,
-0.6003598570823669,
0.07108833640813828,
0.04527248442173004,
-0.23981590569019318,
-0.6538065671920776,
-0.6471344828605652,
0.06309971958398819,
-0.5251259803771973,
-0.11458277702331543,
0.43156296014785767,
0.5158069133758545,
0.3583791255950928,
-0.6088922619819641,
-0.09354674071073532,
-0.5244140028953552,
0.6442819833755493,
-0.8011191487312317,
0.42065495252609253,
0.41179436445236206,
0.369798481464386,
-0.5272253155708313,
-0.7065916061401367,
-0.48078233003616333,
0.055131006985902786,
-0.034726954996585846,
-0.2856164276599884,
-0.07971534878015518,
0.19622395932674408,
0.11566685140132904,
-0.09675106406211853,
-0.5116671323776245,
0.19897891581058502,
-0.07863413542509079,
-0.522234320640564,
0.7878263592720032,
0.23287002742290497,
0.531449556350708,
-0.2970408499240875,
-0.36514812707901,
-0.4540030360221863,
-0.6769232153892517,
-0.09912404417991638,
0.23286499083042145,
0.36531099677085876,
-0.07600608468055725,
0.38256922364234924,
-0.34744101762771606,
0.6288993954658508,
0.11940254271030426,
0.01843814179301262,
0.30894964933395386,
-0.3658851683139801,
-0.2169535756111145,
0.6560803651809692,
1.03639554977417,
0.7414801716804504,
0.11749252676963806,
-0.15441343188285828,
-0.12056651711463928,
-0.29504552483558655,
0.5257063508033752,
-0.844648003578186,
0.023296833038330078,
0.41844263672828674,
-0.2565191090106964,
-0.791683554649353,
-0.07214269042015076,
-0.8977984189987183,
-0.6591036915779114,
0.33336132764816284,
0.4798744320869446,
-0.46648865938186646,
-0.16277825832366943,
0.37589189410209656,
0.14190632104873657,
0.10026635974645615,
-0.07617799937725067,
-0.739495575428009,
0.08617259562015533,
0.7350773811340332,
0.669288694858551,
-0.12812462449073792,
-0.38919365406036377,
-1.041174054145813,
0.29646795988082886,
-0.7041932940483093,
0.5591228604316711,
-0.29282426834106445,
-0.4594302177429199,
0.3424435555934906,
0.3312232792377472,
0.0850742757320404,
-0.2302924543619156,
0.960608720779419,
-0.8490250706672668,
0.010939043946564198,
-0.18799780309200287,
-0.43093258142471313,
-0.08691730350255966,
0.0806267261505127,
-0.6475574374198914,
0.7053455710411072,
-0.07757604867219925,
-0.9652926325798035,
0.670304536819458,
-0.8805676698684692,
-0.812504768371582,
-0.10663100332021713,
0.34955042600631714,
-0.4072960913181305,
-0.19903147220611572,
0.34764009714126587,
0.3999751806259155,
0.06481785327196121,
0.4038132429122925,
-0.3764658570289612,
-0.20658598840236664,
0.40149760246276855,
-0.5356861352920532,
0.8475479483604431,
0.41554567217826843,
-0.44318780303001404,
0.42940667271614075,
-0.7701057195663452,
0.051795441657304764,
0.08672492951154709,
-0.35400980710983276,
-0.5956804752349854,
0.3627565801143646,
0.13795806467533112,
0.1524844616651535,
0.10717897117137909,
-0.5912936925888062,
-0.2536464333534241,
-0.4921230375766754,
0.42828458547592163,
0.8022589683532715,
0.19606368243694305,
0.47777339816093445,
-0.16312366724014282,
0.09286759793758392,
0.061123769730329514,
0.541870653629303,
-0.024035783484578133,
-0.005858270917087793,
-0.6017876267433167,
0.21560436487197876,
0.4402256906032562,
0.7852497696876526,
-0.5144190192222595,
0.4743964672088623,
-0.36074164509773254,
-0.18206262588500977,
-0.3797082304954529,
0.008266311138868332,
0.5712403655052185,
0.7319679856300354,
0.39693644642829895,
-0.17356714606285095,
-0.36219677329063416,
-0.8453742861747742,
-0.5030470490455627,
-0.33361977338790894,
0.10542665421962738,
-0.028704309836030006,
0.2016538679599762,
-0.2944800555706024,
0.6737505793571472,
-0.24684089422225952,
0.056712839752435684,
0.0646645575761795,
0.14877939224243164,
-0.35439103841781616,
0.9148608446121216,
0.6497973799705505,
-0.8198227286338806,
-0.22475938498973846,
0.11887788027524948,
-0.7841696739196777,
0.03285861387848854,
-0.061718326061964035,
-0.4579814374446869,
0.3877970576286316,
0.7343602776527405,
-0.29407256841659546,
0.22546619176864624,
0.37107428908348083,
-0.8071072101593018,
0.0723673477768898,
-0.12442798167467117,
0.4887354075908661,
-1.2447412014007568,
0.09841818362474442,
-0.4507623314857483,
-0.5217888951301575,
-0.743380069732666,
0.16924569010734558,
0.4210631847381592,
-0.024437444284558296,
-0.8998034596443176,
0.517239511013031,
-0.1753343790769577,
0.1940467357635498,
-0.23586690425872803,
0.25289642810821533,
-0.02644118294119835,
0.06943924725055695,
-0.19902291893959045,
0.8039538264274597,
0.377224326133728,
-0.4886711835861206,
0.24177300930023193,
0.418833464384079,
-0.5369307398796082,
0.3923617899417877,
-0.7518129348754883,
0.35159191489219666,
-0.036983150988817215,
-0.08028919994831085,
-0.6104060411453247,
-0.6715026497840881,
0.29067984223365784,
-0.2555404305458069,
0.32198289036750793,
-0.148028165102005,
-0.337114155292511,
-0.10523371398448944,
-0.16730986535549164,
0.7124695777893066,
0.45771798491477966,
-0.44866588711738586,
0.34159913659095764,
0.5192739963531494,
-0.4318658113479614,
-1.033011555671692,
-0.7212579250335693,
0.21065199375152588,
-0.263587087392807,
-0.6109560132026672,
0.24205665290355682,
-0.1334645301103592,
-0.3208487927913666,
0.11281148344278336,
-0.04552062600851059,
-0.1162959411740303,
0.4326571822166443,
0.29648342728614807,
0.14448724687099457,
0.06472212076187134,
-0.10659884661436081,
0.5241872668266296,
-0.16404877603054047,
0.05219091475009918,
-0.08531364053487778,
0.3134881556034088,
-0.047003574669361115,
-0.4150286912918091,
-0.4826644957065582,
0.6816733479499817,
0.7913500070571899,
-0.2128668576478958,
0.7195208668708801,
0.34578877687454224,
-0.6710335612297058,
0.041364867240190506,
-0.35698023438453674,
-0.08906558156013489,
-0.5422438979148865,
0.40679341554641724,
0.07987310737371445,
-0.8445518612861633,
0.30163776874542236,
0.2713623642921448,
0.5489577651023865,
0.35986313223838806,
0.2428445965051651,
0.03362110257148743,
1.34030282497406,
0.5896046161651611,
-0.0503879189491272,
0.4190562963485718,
0.4449530243873596,
0.14532896876335144,
-0.27931684255599976,
-0.4108291566371918,
-0.5315902829170227,
-0.03914487361907959,
-0.46741846203804016,
-0.16137202084064484,
0.25297412276268005,
0.19854089617729187,
-0.5005316734313965,
0.22657611966133118,
-0.3087390959262848,
0.5577125549316406,
0.45756101608276367,
0.04168933629989624,
0.22346332669258118,
-0.03287741169333458,
-0.1394374966621399,
0.11513712257146835,
-0.6970279216766357,
-0.4438531994819641,
0.8021194338798523,
0.16190284490585327,
0.8451484441757202,
0.2183106541633606,
0.4082471430301666,
0.5682758688926697,
0.17357702553272247,
-0.4865439236164093,
0.4778251349925995,
-0.18808861076831818,
-0.9261685609817505,
-0.22832421958446503,
-0.29968589544296265,
-0.7821158170700073,
-0.017149532213807106,
-0.5699167847633362,
-0.6485117673873901,
0.16485686600208282,
0.3240765333175659,
-0.6038961410522461,
0.16362139582633972,
-0.6276413798332214,
0.9746179580688477,
-0.4579426944255829,
-0.4448661804199219,
-0.2969191074371338,
-0.8377046585083008,
0.2483457624912262,
-0.21866963803768158,
0.3896966576576233,
-0.04787600412964821,
0.04943310469388962,
0.7016057968139648,
-0.3149678409099579,
0.683245837688446,
-0.12519831955432892,
0.13568150997161865,
0.3468334972858429,
0.42377156019210815,
0.6229111552238464,
0.1099102646112442,
-0.33918851613998413,
0.046233657747507095,
0.26862528920173645,
-0.42171207070350647,
-0.3222464621067047,
0.7498018145561218,
-0.4351889193058014,
-0.5037119388580322,
-0.5257542133331299,
-0.6504873037338257,
-0.32000717520713806,
0.5236532688140869,
0.21639813482761383,
0.5384553074836731,
-0.3470204174518585,
0.46982240676879883,
0.5570936799049377,
-0.4449237585067749,
0.8827406167984009,
0.271593302488327,
0.07341153919696808,
-0.5951047539710999,
0.5445951223373413,
-0.3140438199043274,
0.26746559143066406,
0.24895131587982178,
0.04964997619390488,
-0.4667443633079529,
-0.6808269619941711,
-0.47576236724853516,
-0.2481478899717331,
-0.8832536935806274,
-0.3233254551887512,
-0.79961758852005,
-0.20947802066802979,
-0.43643200397491455,
-0.2938917577266693,
-0.4235978126525879,
-0.3667052388191223,
-0.03980124369263649,
-0.3116614818572998,
0.43724068999290466,
0.40906524658203125,
-0.27063000202178955,
0.2239847481250763,
-1.0341960191726685,
0.11455664038658142,
0.29670408368110657,
0.5403211712837219,
-0.38188573718070984,
-0.15825548768043518,
-0.20459343492984772,
0.03682919964194298,
-0.08384938538074493,
-0.798550546169281,
0.10414579510688782,
0.2627319097518921,
0.5175334811210632,
0.360808789730072,
0.6826398372650146,
0.48618221282958984,
-0.6800706386566162,
0.8893458843231201,
0.1575407087802887,
-1.0139317512512207,
0.5777736306190491,
-0.30722835659980774,
0.10009714215993881,
0.6782315373420715,
0.2056446671485901,
-0.5864025950431824,
-0.17852714657783508,
-0.20506833493709564,
-0.9049407243728638,
0.5129500031471252,
0.2114865481853485,
0.30073487758636475,
-0.30470913648605347,
0.3698582351207733,
0.12584757804870605,
0.08819832652807236,
-0.406894713640213,
0.07585318386554718,
-0.289295494556427,
-0.40667980909347534,
0.14258743822574615,
-0.6153336763381958,
-0.38659706711769104,
0.2281591147184372,
0.6328054070472717,
-0.23057228326797485,
0.17632386088371277,
0.10150936990976334,
-0.12480209022760391,
-0.20502129197120667,
0.5105385780334473,
0.5266915559768677,
0.4883268177509308,
-0.15163807570934296,
0.13873368501663208,
0.37435129284858704,
-0.4886764883995056,
0.1729813814163208,
0.30441710352897644,
-0.1857239007949829,
-0.19421298801898956,
0.33914539217948914,
0.6304731369018555,
0.16028165817260742,
-0.7374467849731445,
0.5140151381492615,
-0.39626190066337585,
-0.06584165245294571,
-0.0022788401693105698,
0.48022153973579407,
-0.21259592473506927,
0.2282637357711792,
0.29518941044807434,
0.10164384543895721,
0.14657986164093018,
-0.1557588428258896,
0.4207848906517029,
0.29229605197906494,
-0.5564103126525879,
-0.11435206234455109,
1.0786778926849365,
0.4772253632545471,
-0.43017661571502686,
0.40397486090660095,
0.08285632729530334,
-0.195662260055542,
0.4247468411922455,
0.4963720738887787,
1.180508017539978,
-0.5011220574378967,
-0.05825234577059746,
0.3883035480976105,
0.39166009426116943,
-0.16311115026474,
0.3541831970214844,
0.34755802154541016,
-0.5954596400260925,
-0.3914239704608917,
-0.6260068416595459,
-0.2529038190841675,
0.0527932271361351,
-0.6513199806213379,
0.05631130188703537,
-0.46646416187286377,
-0.24139833450317383,
-0.23958420753479004,
-0.3936142921447754,
-0.2986840605735779,
0.38703233003616333,
-0.32847869396209717,
0.9756297469139099,
-0.5857449173927307,
0.49007847905158997,
0.7232341170310974,
0.06022864207625389,
-0.7325119972229004,
0.14632876217365265,
0.15162897109985352,
-0.21225793659687042,
0.16243158280849457,
-0.03654728829860687,
-0.29022225737571716,
-0.25172826647758484,
-0.4601535201072693,
-0.7483958601951599,
0.982151448726654,
0.5387393236160278,
-0.6226568222045898,
0.06508941203355789,
0.14871689677238464,
0.2139173448085785,
-0.2474183887243271,
-0.35976511240005493,
0.3548091650009155,
0.15440921485424042,
-0.25659388303756714,
-0.8988672494888306,
0.3684920370578766,
-0.2726781368255615,
-0.06224251165986061,
0.23535506427288055,
-0.4074084758758545,
0.382210373878479,
-0.20040284097194672,
-0.32706978917121887,
0.13898813724517822,
0.6987634301185608,
0.007100499700754881,
0.43700191378593445,
0.793900728225708,
0.11339682340621948,
0.6807472705841064,
-0.11549706757068634,
0.9782577753067017,
-0.6492829322814941,
0.1235443577170372,
1.0485230684280396,
-0.07669846713542938,
0.8770980834960938,
0.3920155167579651,
0.394010990858078,
0.26144081354141235,
0.6978378295898438,
0.5329235792160034,
0.85358726978302,
-0.43880510330200195,
-0.343203067779541,
-0.40999114513397217,
-0.20375072956085205,
-0.502992570400238,
0.41757309436798096,
0.20554493367671967,
-0.3187545835971832,
0.022353971377015114,
0.08306001871824265,
0.2961925268173218,
-0.17802774906158447,
-0.05810334160923958,
0.7554351687431335,
-0.12895654141902924,
-0.8651644587516785,
0.5269889831542969,
0.034688860177993774,
0.3279978930950165,
-0.3979143500328064,
0.0027897206600755453,
-0.2861742079257965,
0.264786958694458,
-0.07203836739063263,
-0.8984109163284302,
0.49848589301109314,
0.16033482551574707,
0.05781398341059685,
0.021133095026016235,
0.8516421914100647,
-0.2671150863170624,
-0.3491205871105194,
0.3434457778930664,
0.05369814485311508,
-0.23412096500396729,
0.36902835965156555,
-0.6098530888557434,
0.10235694795846939,
-0.19829152524471283,
-0.16812297701835632,
0.22964078187942505,
0.18605458736419678,
-0.2938145399093628,
0.6841868758201599,
0.6124660968780518,
-0.3387652039527893,
0.21123754978179932,
0.09725109487771988,
0.617811918258667,
-0.7007070183753967,
-0.6564869284629822,
-0.6670204997062683,
0.7463030219078064,
-0.19133758544921875,
-0.16210457682609558,
0.37428420782089233,
0.17779284715652466,
0.7392778396606445,
0.09207438677549362,
0.8526607155799866,
-0.22067871689796448,
0.12019772082567215,
-0.6186956167221069,
1.1458635330200195,
-0.7169846296310425,
0.1689613163471222,
-0.49066704511642456,
-0.6981058120727539,
-0.6502207517623901,
0.3572084903717041,
0.0003144860966131091,
-0.12921631336212158,
0.5245884656906128,
0.9121069312095642,
-0.022130822762846947,
0.1048894077539444,
0.19700831174850464,
0.1066802516579628,
0.5070596933364868,
0.4567095935344696,
0.7456662654876709,
-0.5250033140182495,
0.7977203726768494,
-0.3814225196838379,
-0.18430311977863312,
-0.26202303171157837,
-1.4300318956375122,
-0.8166565299034119,
-0.467180073261261,
-0.44158753752708435,
-0.5218023657798767,
0.5251584649085999,
1.0264759063720703,
0.8080013990402222,
-1.0594050884246826,
0.09137043356895447,
-0.011507549323141575,
0.047205664217472076,
-0.31930699944496155,
-0.13476163148880005,
0.3787703514099121,
-0.26142728328704834,
-0.7286674976348877,
0.713137686252594,
0.20781829953193665,
0.14482517540454865,
0.2566733956336975,
-0.043098125606775284,
-0.0028690032195299864,
0.10082439333200455,
0.5054601430892944,
0.29662996530532837,
-0.4424020051956177,
-0.8275047540664673,
0.09348755329847336,
-0.26939308643341064,
-0.2625592052936554,
0.6208925247192383,
-0.17713108658790588,
0.5710198879241943,
0.6305192112922668,
0.9492948651313782,
-0.15255507826805115,
0.08225398510694504,
0.6974038481712341,
-0.6356066465377808,
0.25267869234085083,
0.050829701125621796,
0.45493221282958984,
0.49695953726768494,
-0.6081681251525879,
0.34438076615333557,
-0.17580671608448029,
-0.6460174918174744,
-0.8907638192176819,
0.20314788818359375,
-0.9505879282951355,
-0.27908679842948914,
1.1655491590499878,
-0.04804876074194908,
-0.25958508253097534,
-0.29241034388542175,
-0.10642100125551224,
0.39137721061706543,
-0.4700600504875183,
0.8268908262252808,
0.4526316523551941,
0.051658179610967636,
-0.022216463461518288,
-0.43521589040756226,
0.6738876700401306,
0.5102623105049133,
-0.8052061200141907,
0.20714214444160461,
0.6927034258842468,
0.5016120076179504,
0.07372461259365082,
0.2282259464263916,
-0.38310784101486206,
0.4979323148727417,
-0.027473798021674156,
-0.2526310980319977,
-0.08079063892364502,
-0.35582980513572693,
-0.2752993106842041,
0.3806925415992737,
0.2067311406135559,
-0.4151971638202667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12269v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12269v1
|
Unveiling Implicit Table Knowledge with Question-Then-Pinpoint Reasoner for Insightful Table Summarization
| 2024-06-18T04:55:09 | 2024-06-18T04:55:09 |
Kwangwook Seo, Jinyoung Yeo, Dongha Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Implicit knowledge hidden within the explicit table cells, such as data
insights, is the key to generating a high-quality table summary. However,
unveiling such implicit knowledge is a non-trivial task. Due to the complex
nature of structured tables, it is challenging even for large language models
(LLMs) to mine the implicit knowledge in an insightful and faithful manner. To
address this challenge, we propose a novel table reasoning framework
Question-then-Pinpoint. Our work focuses on building a plug-and-play table
reasoner that can self-question the insightful knowledge and answer it by
faithfully pinpointing evidence on the table to provide explainable guidance
for the summarizer. To train a reliable reasoner, we collect table knowledge by
guiding a teacher LLM to follow the coarse-to-fine reasoning paths and refine
it through two quality enhancement strategies to selectively distill the
high-quality knowledge to the reasoner. Extensive experiments on two table
summarization datasets, including our newly proposed InsTaSumm, validate the
general effectiveness of our framework.
|
[
-0.385351300239563,
-0.5434359908103943,
0.938734233379364,
-0.08087805658578873,
-0.37469741702079773,
-0.07056595385074615,
0.1445169597864151,
-0.25314798951148987,
-0.12720242142677307,
0.43260347843170166,
-0.5349026322364807,
-0.5562211871147156,
-0.4378865361213684,
-0.2050771862268448,
-0.826286792755127,
1.235342264175415,
-0.16813509166240692,
0.018296953290700912,
-0.566318929195404,
-0.038716282695531845,
-0.51777184009552,
-0.22828860580921173,
-0.28533267974853516,
-0.515731930732727,
0.382062703371048,
1.1911617517471313,
0.26977235078811646,
0.6958485245704651,
0.2727661728858948,
0.15499435365200043,
0.03385677933692932,
0.35632607340812683,
-0.3233698606491089,
0.2943311929702759,
-0.2899703085422516,
-0.7446441650390625,
-0.3922181725502014,
-0.2692539691925049,
0.30983057618141174,
0.7625581622123718,
0.09304939210414886,
0.33552151918411255,
0.2419007271528244,
0.7958775162696838,
-0.4220525622367859,
0.5952146649360657,
-0.7843927145004272,
-0.07923165708780289,
-0.18669044971466064,
-0.003670195583254099,
-0.3341703414916992,
-0.683908998966217,
0.11980348080396652,
-0.446950227022171,
0.3079133629798889,
0.005717315711081028,
0.6309735178947449,
0.30299270153045654,
-0.5548951029777527,
-0.1896296739578247,
-0.8302775621414185,
0.265849769115448,
-0.5660718679428101,
0.37538692355155945,
0.12865346670150757,
0.5528284311294556,
-0.24690012633800507,
-0.9074252843856812,
-0.7355945706367493,
-0.1828935444355011,
-0.3366044759750366,
0.03647306561470032,
0.12138209491968155,
-0.17033272981643677,
0.2812805473804474,
0.2981175184249878,
-0.716595470905304,
-0.3552446663379669,
-0.12590034306049347,
0.12416687607765198,
0.5156986117362976,
0.020660260692238808,
0.21464380621910095,
0.14357934892177582,
-0.31908804178237915,
0.1513490229845047,
-0.8051955699920654,
0.2783178687095642,
-0.1364528238773346,
-0.07111642509698868,
0.2074963003396988,
0.5794170498847961,
-0.3687516152858734,
0.6291215419769287,
0.1165371909737587,
-0.018287591636180878,
-0.4529566168785095,
-0.17283453047275543,
0.27198347449302673,
0.43908098340034485,
0.3440842926502228,
0.4146788716316223,
0.3354487121105194,
-0.3591906726360321,
-0.15401379764080048,
0.25936686992645264,
-0.1205287054181099,
-0.8316131830215454,
-0.5388801097869873,
0.33557018637657166,
-0.0862642377614975,
-0.08386199176311493,
0.0921357050538063,
-0.6884381175041199,
-0.35371753573417664,
-0.28616249561309814,
0.47196197509765625,
-0.29344484210014343,
-0.24216464161872864,
-0.15072165429592133,
-0.2480776160955429,
0.3612118363380432,
0.4701789319515228,
-0.9495181441307068,
0.2821345031261444,
0.7715523838996887,
0.7024164795875549,
-0.043103672564029694,
-0.1252046376466751,
-0.4898340106010437,
0.6314399242401123,
-0.5108140707015991,
1.1991724967956543,
-0.18500633537769318,
-0.19684180617332458,
-0.08602605760097504,
-0.18922987580299377,
0.2518361210823059,
-0.4036675989627838,
0.562113344669342,
-0.3942657709121704,
0.37768861651420593,
-0.7981091737747192,
-0.5809707641601562,
-0.17222656309604645,
0.4698232114315033,
-0.3427383303642273,
0.9341163635253906,
-0.07743249088525772,
-0.5883178114891052,
0.8952977657318115,
-0.6428031325340271,
-0.33598682284355164,
0.1696942299604416,
-0.44785764813423157,
-0.3913203179836273,
0.18390588462352753,
0.4670567214488983,
0.43909385800361633,
-0.2557937502861023,
0.5176083445549011,
-0.2043735533952713,
-0.43891969323158264,
0.2373977154493332,
0.01198231615126133,
0.29521510004997253,
-0.13241560757160187,
-0.4112752377986908,
0.3354579210281372,
-0.7245035767555237,
0.12916670739650726,
0.25023773312568665,
-0.23206382989883423,
-0.15904287993907928,
0.26936399936676025,
-0.41317522525787354,
0.3641863167285919,
0.03734361007809639,
-0.40880003571510315,
0.02358228527009487,
-0.18277637660503387,
0.31459420919418335,
0.5386313199996948,
0.23137196898460388,
0.42167848348617554,
-0.4645753800868988,
0.20069383084774017,
-0.002210413571447134,
0.08952250331640244,
-0.20992936193943024,
-0.30944639444351196,
-1.0161012411117554,
0.07839212566614151,
0.10522358864545822,
0.3124799132347107,
-0.7349313497543335,
0.2189297080039978,
-0.3139640688896179,
-0.5564189553260803,
-0.2941475212574005,
-0.0012403151486068964,
0.41838207840919495,
1.103812336921692,
0.7135983109474182,
0.36577174067497253,
-0.31941062211990356,
-0.8027573227882385,
-0.5283662676811218,
-0.2545248568058014,
-0.0751379206776619,
0.09849726408720016,
0.6155321598052979,
0.2844785451889038,
1.2890876531600952,
-0.6724597811698914,
-0.31363749504089355,
-0.693539023399353,
0.1645170897245407,
0.37317177653312683,
0.658653974533081,
0.25482550263404846,
-0.5333459973335266,
-0.4144614636898041,
-0.29575276374816895,
-0.763256311416626,
-0.22251175343990326,
-0.02131154201924801,
-0.36605504155158997,
-0.10826888680458069,
0.7308582663536072,
-0.6793537735939026,
0.35346290469169617,
-0.14580971002578735,
-0.4918149411678314,
0.6313183903694153,
-0.1680464893579483,
-0.015271750278770924,
-0.8217625021934509,
0.10641903430223465,
-0.29409414529800415,
-0.12966103851795197,
-0.5525652170181274,
-0.14281035959720612,
0.15619948506355286,
-0.11437910050153732,
-0.13417160511016846,
0.34438782930374146,
-0.5383248329162598,
0.02909155748784542,
-0.25472715497016907,
0.1759827584028244,
0.2961052358150482,
0.5535786747932434,
-0.00017895092605613172,
0.5939233899116516,
0.18511049449443817,
-0.7230124473571777,
0.06038830056786537,
0.5441592335700989,
-0.35917091369628906,
0.6917271614074707,
-1.0362842082977295,
0.07634560018777847,
-0.33883556723594666,
0.16970905661582947,
-1.3342996835708618,
-0.2185046225786209,
0.13393762707710266,
-0.4235908091068268,
0.41860470175743103,
-0.481812983751297,
-0.49875637888908386,
-0.2557571530342102,
-0.10714200884103775,
0.23948848247528076,
0.2915361225605011,
-0.8520814180374146,
0.5940760970115662,
0.39406412839889526,
-0.12683410942554474,
-0.6098878383636475,
-0.5862447023391724,
-0.08171442896127701,
-0.23499828577041626,
-0.7116563320159912,
0.4775673449039459,
-0.17016282677650452,
-0.42293378710746765,
-0.08632377535104752,
-0.6935254335403442,
0.06275968253612518,
-0.032443687319755554,
0.23528099060058594,
0.12372227758169174,
-0.09350091964006424,
0.2796509265899658,
0.49517256021499634,
-0.5684267282485962,
0.6392859220504761,
-0.46970659494400024,
0.42572903633117676,
-0.37397074699401855,
-0.3858165144920349,
-0.03971831873059273,
0.4811722934246063,
0.4182412028312683,
-0.3507702350616455,
0.5391103625297546,
0.31312084197998047,
-0.41749775409698486,
-0.36895376443862915,
-0.7019282579421997,
-0.5315194725990295,
-0.4138564467430115,
0.32802891731262207,
-0.43818530440330505,
-0.7536424994468689,
0.6335999369621277,
-0.2752666175365448,
0.2628806531429291,
0.4288680851459503,
0.14819055795669556,
-0.3782603144645691,
1.2179185152053833,
0.3334108591079712,
0.2662465572357178,
0.029098156839609146,
-0.2721925973892212,
0.10827883332967758,
-0.4763432443141937,
-0.770806074142456,
-0.6860939264297485,
-0.19489720463752747,
0.0428721159696579,
-0.025888098403811455,
0.5250136852264404,
0.17087097465991974,
-0.16941574215888977,
-0.05537622421979904,
-0.36378294229507446,
0.8282843828201294,
0.6123226284980774,
0.15976084768772125,
0.46206575632095337,
-0.3220553994178772,
-0.1355297714471817,
-0.028455831110477448,
-0.8012834787368774,
-0.4818791151046753,
0.5699745416641235,
0.15457934141159058,
0.5693328976631165,
0.13927991688251495,
0.5703119039535522,
-0.003298369236290455,
0.27912887930870056,
-0.46071648597717285,
0.694280207157135,
0.18192622065544128,
-0.7371910810470581,
-0.3331182599067688,
-0.36199918389320374,
-0.4121384918689728,
0.4343098998069763,
-0.2584157884120941,
-0.41254952549934387,
0.28045332431793213,
0.46424105763435364,
-0.07387615740299225,
0.19366128742694855,
-0.7124896049499512,
1.221103549003601,
-0.24105699360370636,
-0.5446550250053406,
0.16009122133255005,
-0.6693844199180603,
0.5456308722496033,
0.19471053779125214,
0.11551371216773987,
-0.3115418255329132,
0.06186893209815025,
0.6598840951919556,
-0.9562680125236511,
0.4065597653388977,
-0.4047428369522095,
-0.07836706191301346,
0.23534677922725677,
0.3905506432056427,
0.5745145678520203,
0.3718942403793335,
0.20469732582569122,
-0.036063022911548615,
-0.11696972697973251,
-0.14308364689350128,
-0.8890129923820496,
0.5567418932914734,
-0.28497540950775146,
-0.6798266172409058,
-0.3643304109573364,
-0.5757599472999573,
-0.4004775285720825,
0.2689799964427948,
0.3756519556045532,
0.39312925934791565,
0.07538209110498428,
-0.0244483333081007,
0.812861979007721,
0.40895676612854004,
0.4032760560512543,
0.7214138507843018,
-0.07549387961626053,
-0.1390773057937622,
0.8734316229820251,
0.279626727104187,
-0.08881926536560059,
0.5472751259803772,
0.41559693217277527,
-0.693245530128479,
-0.7334174513816833,
-0.5229812860488892,
0.15184427797794342,
-0.7208592891693115,
-0.3130708634853363,
-0.621701180934906,
-0.04118850454688072,
-0.04495894908905029,
-0.16373132169246674,
-0.11587882786989212,
-0.6816370487213135,
-0.09529878199100494,
-0.39294660091400146,
0.5012374520301819,
0.5084109902381897,
0.05072054639458656,
0.39903706312179565,
-0.644717812538147,
0.26529034972190857,
0.7098448276519775,
0.4694080352783203,
-0.18938210606575012,
-0.5714057087898254,
-0.11680164188146591,
-0.1968812197446823,
0.09348085522651672,
-1.2368857860565186,
0.30271637439727783,
0.20416846871376038,
0.7034850716590881,
0.43924495577812195,
0.1916225552558899,
0.7378167510032654,
-0.40638598799705505,
0.40461912751197815,
-0.011540730483829975,
-1.000159740447998,
0.9138171672821045,
-0.24421881139278412,
0.3848499357700348,
0.8800722360610962,
0.3634733259677887,
-0.17133420705795288,
-0.43701058626174927,
-0.3769727051258087,
-1.1335968971252441,
0.6688216924667358,
0.04337609186768532,
-0.3968118727207184,
0.20828849077224731,
0.6760841012001038,
0.43800655007362366,
0.21210071444511414,
-0.9294515252113342,
-0.2910837233066559,
-0.3101206123828888,
-0.16459546983242035,
0.11320618540048599,
-0.6725350022315979,
-0.14414890110492706,
-0.32275107502937317,
0.6742908954620361,
-0.22908124327659607,
-0.003404296236112714,
0.14099757373332977,
-0.5146471858024597,
-0.03398614749312401,
0.5405036211013794,
0.3530643582344055,
1.0940972566604614,
-0.384461909532547,
0.5282756686210632,
0.3207109868526459,
-0.30265897512435913,
0.14156055450439453,
0.23195287585258484,
-0.48006415367126465,
0.09349377453327179,
0.32240965962409973,
0.22422456741333008,
0.19549678266048431,
-0.39770686626434326,
0.532286524772644,
-0.30990180373191833,
-0.2806586027145386,
-0.38546398282051086,
0.27347081899642944,
0.024700619280338287,
0.2808913588523865,
0.38113096356391907,
-0.262717604637146,
0.2802453935146332,
-0.21276293694972992,
0.3120597302913666,
0.3965388238430023,
-0.5668909549713135,
-0.09353487938642502,
0.8427773118019104,
-0.09029422700405121,
0.10842980444431305,
0.5319995284080505,
-0.1650194227695465,
-0.5303955078125,
0.3634456396102905,
0.6089652180671692,
0.5525760054588318,
-0.24413339793682098,
0.2061154544353485,
0.3568221926689148,
0.4485110342502594,
0.04666430875658989,
0.7060169577598572,
-0.43591251969337463,
-0.4965984523296356,
-0.3645554184913635,
-0.008422454819083214,
-0.4040466248989105,
-0.002442695666104555,
-0.6136394739151001,
0.09297337383031845,
-0.42141425609588623,
0.2302744835615158,
-0.2542644441127777,
-0.24107182025909424,
-0.2705972492694855,
0.13038578629493713,
-0.19142650067806244,
0.7764491438865662,
-0.8364660739898682,
0.4946545362472534,
0.3905138671398163,
-0.5378223061561584,
-0.9052415490150452,
-0.0991552546620369,
-0.16178949177265167,
-0.6812329292297363,
0.34778478741645813,
0.1360052078962326,
-0.08124147355556488,
0.08247122913599014,
-0.6726459860801697,
-0.8193697929382324,
1.1414378881454468,
0.5773629546165466,
-0.5912944078445435,
0.04790627211332321,
0.3315694034099579,
0.3551972806453705,
-0.07933980971574783,
0.5441824197769165,
0.9360882043838501,
0.5110644698143005,
0.3967811167240143,
-0.16093891859054565,
0.36479490995407104,
-0.4067939519882202,
-0.39227885007858276,
0.4014816880226135,
-0.20427197217941284,
0.5754950046539307,
-0.562174379825592,
-0.10178942233324051,
-0.5546243190765381,
1.0130815505981445,
0.5021962523460388,
0.525474488735199,
0.6065974235534668,
0.44956910610198975,
0.6234050989151001,
-0.5717441439628601,
0.574557900428772,
-0.25810226798057556,
-0.16388162970542908,
1.469374656677246,
-0.12495184689760208,
0.530991792678833,
0.46807223558425903,
0.0705253854393959,
0.7252537608146667,
0.4405728876590729,
0.09740588068962097,
0.4697694182395935,
0.17928273975849152,
-0.13385041058063507,
-0.3865222930908203,
-0.22228477895259857,
-0.6460219621658325,
0.44539061188697815,
0.48141857981681824,
-0.03311222046613693,
-0.4532393217086792,
-0.45468929409980774,
0.12872105836868286,
0.0993596762418747,
-0.49389341473579407,
0.8938154578208923,
-0.01006101444363594,
-0.6040476560592651,
0.20117439329624176,
-0.21202726662158966,
-0.0198516808450222,
-0.5344601273536682,
-0.4176517724990845,
-0.5941271185874939,
0.1221010833978653,
-0.3837854862213135,
-0.8505164980888367,
0.285400390625,
-0.02121569588780403,
-0.22538433969020844,
-0.1556679904460907,
0.7152886986732483,
-0.7264296412467957,
-0.21488313376903534,
-0.1290988326072693,
0.6953923106193542,
0.08177346736192703,
-0.42918723821640015,
-0.5084246397018433,
-0.4186643958091736,
-0.24941684305667877,
0.14371666312217712,
0.03203628957271576,
0.58271324634552,
0.021070048213005066,
0.7145758271217346,
0.818218469619751,
-0.17510700225830078,
-0.2480228841304779,
0.2397204488515854,
1.0486619472503662,
-0.549170970916748,
-0.8691927790641785,
-0.9635499119758606,
0.8283727169036865,
-0.1525183916091919,
-0.1992127001285553,
0.8595501780509949,
0.71024090051651,
0.5496119856834412,
-0.017086025327444077,
0.41971704363822937,
0.27305033802986145,
0.703460693359375,
-0.5261414647102356,
0.9058593511581421,
-0.5095550417900085,
0.37087735533714294,
-0.40473228693008423,
-0.9355576038360596,
-0.3280476927757263,
0.5058180689811707,
-0.32712826132774353,
0.06325799971818924,
0.7527089715003967,
0.5797461271286011,
0.17540448904037476,
0.2025901973247528,
-0.013968993909657001,
0.3896816372871399,
0.5769943594932556,
0.5985301733016968,
1.205541729927063,
-0.13236822187900543,
0.9916101098060608,
-0.33482080698013306,
-0.41276147961616516,
-0.11278174072504044,
-0.9672800302505493,
-0.8962732553482056,
-0.6485022306442261,
-0.3028414845466614,
-0.2830522954463959,
-0.03455004096031189,
0.7385470867156982,
0.6701949834823608,
-0.8290949463844299,
-0.08950179815292358,
-0.5853925347328186,
0.4750358462333679,
-0.18447993695735931,
-0.24598649144172668,
0.7512521147727966,
-0.1496831774711609,
-0.09162504971027374,
0.35722219944000244,
0.24406670033931732,
0.11095240712165833,
-0.00839835312217474,
0.16024665534496307,
-0.018521111458539963,
-0.17506419122219086,
0.537527322769165,
0.3593980073928833,
-0.31969958543777466,
-0.04730171337723732,
-0.028583526611328125,
0.2577707767486572,
-0.08200179785490036,
1.011591911315918,
-0.6927750110626221,
0.34710103273391724,
0.5222795009613037,
0.2252471148967743,
0.7891054749488831,
0.01593584008514881,
0.5542259812355042,
-0.8094717264175415,
-0.11123011261224747,
0.33511996269226074,
0.612843930721283,
0.005829681176692247,
-0.42783188819885254,
0.4094754457473755,
0.040264710783958435,
-0.5763934850692749,
-0.7501113414764404,
0.13741281628608704,
-0.9497779607772827,
-0.16813746094703674,
0.643430769443512,
-0.16214488446712494,
-0.19732339680194855,
-0.4822807013988495,
-0.23154810070991516,
0.29444462060928345,
-0.38069266080856323,
1.1046863794326782,
0.20867638289928436,
-0.30714789032936096,
-0.41292551159858704,
-0.0008459716336801648,
0.8359721899032593,
0.38234075903892517,
-1.2605611085891724,
0.00729129184037447,
0.531235933303833,
0.05943189188838005,
-0.13100755214691162,
0.4061618149280548,
-0.2657032310962677,
0.42667555809020996,
-0.10097958892583847,
0.014680405147373676,
-0.5541971325874329,
-0.7953813076019287,
0.004465428180992603,
0.5072715282440186,
0.13241946697235107,
-0.04556955769658089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12266v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12266v2
|
Towards a Client-Centered Assessment of LLM Therapists by Client Simulation
| 2024-06-18T04:46:55 | 2024-06-20T22:06:47 |
Jiashuo Wang, Yang Xiao, Yanran Li, Changhe Song, Chunpu Xu, Chenhao Tan, Wenjie Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Although there is a growing belief that LLMs can be used as therapists,
exploring LLMs' capabilities and inefficacy, particularly from the client's
perspective, is limited. This work focuses on a client-centered assessment of
LLM therapists with the involvement of simulated clients, a standard approach
in clinical medical education. However, there are two challenges when applying
the approach to assess LLM therapists at scale. Ethically, asking humans to
frequently mimic clients and exposing them to potentially harmful LLM outputs
can be risky and unsafe. Technically, it can be difficult to consistently
compare the performances of different LLM therapists interacting with the same
client. To this end, we adopt LLMs to simulate clients and propose ClientCAST,
a client-centered approach to assessing LLM therapists by client simulation.
Specifically, the simulated client is utilized to interact with LLM therapists
and complete questionnaires related to the interaction. Based on the
questionnaire results, we assess LLM therapists from three client-centered
aspects: session outcome, therapeutic alliance, and self-reported feelings. We
conduct experiments to examine the reliability of ClientCAST and use it to
evaluate LLMs therapists implemented by Claude-3, GPT-3.5, LLaMA3-70B, and
Mixtral 8*7B. Codes are released at https://github.com/wangjs9/ClientCAST.
|
[
-0.42061710357666016,
-0.5004406571388245,
0.5322278738021851,
0.3819811940193176,
-0.19116155803203583,
0.3776296377182007,
-0.17865386605262756,
-0.5241722464561462,
0.3375876545906067,
0.2491094022989273,
-0.49121642112731934,
-0.28563013672828674,
-0.5147559642791748,
0.09146988391876221,
0.06604842841625214,
0.5703175067901611,
-0.12088805437088013,
0.8585606813430786,
-0.40471452474594116,
-0.20881901681423187,
-0.5518065094947815,
-0.5086272358894348,
-0.651015043258667,
-0.6608533263206482,
0.5061684846878052,
0.31206047534942627,
0.2617291808128357,
0.13641873002052307,
0.36054959893226624,
0.20923399925231934,
0.1250646561384201,
-0.05170853063464165,
-0.6107995510101318,
-0.03798554465174675,
-0.025794701650738716,
-0.25631117820739746,
-0.9504554867744446,
0.5355595350265503,
0.5915260910987854,
1.0396243333816528,
-0.5147851705551147,
0.3866722881793976,
0.043746404349803925,
0.2625802755355835,
-0.3808668553829193,
-0.36097460985183716,
-0.49630945920944214,
0.304612934589386,
0.06914091110229492,
-0.27021706104278564,
-0.468595415353775,
-0.5411480665206909,
0.30413806438446045,
-0.11496803164482117,
0.2844955027103424,
0.05320805683732033,
0.18018917739391327,
0.01829344592988491,
-0.6105403900146484,
0.021504387259483337,
-0.6470478177070618,
0.5644954442977905,
-0.5516158938407898,
0.3673851788043976,
0.0489574559032917,
0.5763079524040222,
-0.22824695706367493,
-0.5985811352729797,
-0.21243448555469513,
-0.3735853433609009,
0.2625065743923187,
0.5031760931015015,
0.2362527847290039,
0.20397773385047913,
0.4751858115196228,
0.08554676920175552,
-0.5170541405677795,
0.45120155811309814,
-0.10657539963722229,
-0.15815310180187225,
0.6003297567367554,
0.39234083890914917,
0.10450102388858795,
0.2568461000919342,
-0.66371750831604,
0.24831876158714294,
-0.7840709686279297,
0.16940389573574066,
0.2517302632331848,
-0.05231147259473801,
0.18274112045764923,
0.5637139081954956,
0.3442479074001312,
0.3088165521621704,
0.061608631163835526,
-0.49660372734069824,
-0.09656782448291779,
0.29694947600364685,
-0.39721184968948364,
0.47565391659736633,
0.5602397322654724,
0.9335957169532776,
-0.07189901173114777,
-0.14111782610416412,
0.0803011953830719,
-0.0011742380447685719,
0.6869118809700012,
-0.9659397602081299,
0.18095681071281433,
0.557164192199707,
-0.7052299380302429,
-0.34420904517173767,
-0.19087955355644226,
-0.5921316146850586,
-0.4580313563346863,
-0.30095162987709045,
0.2913825511932373,
-0.23670640587806702,
-0.4843725562095642,
0.1815529763698578,
0.05284427851438522,
0.3577447533607483,
0.7226812839508057,
-0.4187098443508148,
0.7689248919487,
0.5596292018890381,
0.40898099541664124,
-0.3173069655895233,
-0.2784644365310669,
-0.40253716707229614,
0.22677956521511078,
0.026793215423822403,
0.5877857804298401,
-0.04676922783255577,
-0.8816791772842407,
0.047813545912504196,
0.06567617505788803,
-0.06557872146368027,
-0.5339187979698181,
0.26637977361679077,
-0.4221418797969818,
0.16762249171733856,
-0.45794808864593506,
-0.9657721519470215,
0.10624974220991135,
0.7236947417259216,
-0.21695245802402496,
0.5170692205429077,
0.3195827603340149,
-0.6853635907173157,
0.43020838499069214,
-0.629292368888855,
0.022660085931420326,
0.3758525848388672,
-0.21630574762821198,
-0.24840907752513885,
0.11778486520051956,
-0.22495047748088837,
0.26524245738983154,
-0.17734234035015106,
0.06562932580709457,
-0.7801390290260315,
-0.7046312093734741,
0.7994415760040283,
-0.39409419894218445,
0.6596209406852722,
0.0905744656920433,
-0.024034535512328148,
-0.004503427539020777,
-0.5142244100570679,
0.21898876130580902,
-0.04032643139362335,
-0.15599048137664795,
0.0989476814866066,
-0.22722069919109344,
0.2596786916255951,
-0.03474003076553345,
0.16883708536624908,
-0.8198836445808411,
0.42497578263282776,
-0.16165392100811005,
-0.07897468656301498,
0.6143189668655396,
0.22297675907611847,
0.1509779691696167,
-0.6061650514602661,
0.9473567605018616,
-0.27476930618286133,
0.6537613272666931,
0.3753548562526703,
-0.29169806838035583,
-0.3322368562221527,
-0.47405242919921875,
0.05153244733810425,
0.2028215229511261,
-0.38720259070396423,
0.05083590745925903,
-0.0035641256254166365,
-0.7803255915641785,
-0.4419584572315216,
0.09660354256629944,
0.433018296957016,
0.5826675891876221,
0.08236727118492126,
-0.8403631448745728,
-0.34924212098121643,
-0.6049987077713013,
-0.33264434337615967,
-0.1458977609872818,
0.04679093882441521,
0.25049322843551636,
0.19154976308345795,
-0.24793894588947296,
0.7692420482635498,
-0.1708189994096756,
-0.3279613256454468,
-0.3040126860141754,
-0.24614381790161133,
0.1437278687953949,
0.543052077293396,
0.6140799522399902,
-0.36561456322669983,
-0.5983243584632874,
-0.110309898853302,
-0.835623562335968,
0.0024117473512887955,
-0.04780342057347298,
0.1844126135110855,
-0.2895589768886566,
0.22555996477603912,
-0.254848837852478,
0.47468581795692444,
0.3124191164970398,
-0.23117998242378235,
0.7132553458213806,
-0.5159942507743835,
0.10825599730014801,
-0.629517138004303,
0.1960274577140808,
-0.21317555010318756,
-0.3820003867149353,
-0.6142189502716064,
-0.27226999402046204,
-0.2429080605506897,
0.0013191459001973271,
-0.7611693143844604,
0.5383748412132263,
-0.37180212140083313,
-0.4630867540836334,
-0.3373361825942993,
0.18443019688129425,
-0.057226330041885376,
0.2804494798183441,
-0.29711416363716125,
0.6028874516487122,
0.43528294563293457,
-0.2384527325630188,
0.3943360149860382,
0.001248643733561039,
-0.07147086411714554,
1.0215970277786255,
-0.5655827522277832,
0.4588370621204376,
0.11263684183359146,
0.3130165934562683,
-0.5331703424453735,
-0.08206672966480255,
0.3108660876750946,
-0.22853776812553406,
0.4023815989494324,
-0.33461660146713257,
-0.331035852432251,
-0.27134284377098083,
-0.43359434604644775,
0.6459116339683533,
0.3939570486545563,
-0.1763148307800293,
0.5149465203285217,
0.2311413288116455,
0.0733085572719574,
-0.5697038173675537,
-0.29406723380088806,
0.05536523088812828,
-0.5276533961296082,
-0.4454440474510193,
0.06516343355178833,
-0.36574360728263855,
-0.19396165013313293,
-0.2529942989349365,
0.015597028657793999,
0.1703060418367386,
0.36346113681793213,
0.4970243275165558,
0.3842749297618866,
0.17140856385231018,
-0.23014934360980988,
0.05968964099884033,
-0.1116987094283104,
0.3425002098083496,
-0.16635394096374512,
0.4142453670501709,
-0.463962584733963,
-1.067153811454773,
-0.5562160611152649,
0.2537987530231476,
0.44081032276153564,
0.16535472869873047,
0.4808495342731476,
0.7302036881446838,
-0.27282464504241943,
0.06491933763027191,
-1.0085822343826294,
-0.14537003636360168,
-0.38231533765792847,
0.09790967404842377,
-0.24085932970046997,
-0.9775053262710571,
0.6967136859893799,
-0.39664557576179504,
-0.03768039867281914,
-0.1251244693994522,
0.9720883965492249,
-0.36706629395484924,
0.9421106576919556,
0.34011125564575195,
0.22453467547893524,
0.13383641839027405,
-0.4782675802707672,
0.045362383127212524,
-1.0676345825195312,
-0.33294034004211426,
-0.038730770349502563,
-0.4151250422000885,
-0.4313230812549591,
-0.469207763671875,
0.6542961001396179,
0.03386419638991356,
-0.25914493203163147,
-0.06160449981689453,
-0.4162101447582245,
0.20795664191246033,
0.267977237701416,
0.26613667607307434,
0.3811541497707367,
-0.2552902102470398,
-0.4602762460708618,
-0.271841824054718,
-0.4916989207267761,
-0.7001308798789978,
1.223283052444458,
0.8025139570236206,
0.47395774722099304,
0.12611347436904907,
0.8280021548271179,
0.05027148127555847,
1.337443232536316,
-0.8119362592697144,
0.542508065700531,
0.4707118570804596,
-0.6803758144378662,
-0.1244635134935379,
-0.096799835562706,
-0.8444453477859497,
0.5282877087593079,
-0.0005724757211282849,
-0.8916177153587341,
0.17718163132667542,
-0.11276741325855255,
-0.24991707503795624,
0.134191632270813,
-0.3953532576560974,
0.7792184352874756,
-0.4115474820137024,
-0.41990193724632263,
-0.442624568939209,
-0.6743449568748474,
0.3541988432407379,
-0.14459660649299622,
0.2493511289358139,
-0.36508285999298096,
-0.02136189676821232,
0.45296746492385864,
-0.48405569791793823,
0.8877713084220886,
-0.5963285565376282,
0.08157180994749069,
0.2370198369026184,
0.4390430748462677,
-0.0023356357123702765,
0.4148259162902832,
-0.1219957247376442,
-0.23267698287963867,
0.6062448620796204,
-0.7041465044021606,
-0.8520120978355408,
0.5802379846572876,
-1.0083107948303223,
-0.5346270799636841,
-0.4590604603290558,
-0.4291611611843109,
-0.7184611558914185,
0.0439596101641655,
-0.06067221239209175,
0.429231196641922,
-0.8375328183174133,
-0.1496196985244751,
0.2621382176876068,
-0.1949804723262787,
0.10655373334884644,
0.8437297344207764,
-0.6410826444625854,
-0.7112311124801636,
0.6241374015808105,
-0.05375828593969345,
0.3245023488998413,
-0.44473960995674133,
0.012701569125056267,
-0.33141273260116577,
-0.7186539769172668,
-0.0627296194434166,
0.38068243861198425,
-0.6522312760353088,
-0.02375311776995659,
-0.19440607726573944,
-0.1546200066804886,
-0.12492578476667404,
-0.1745506078004837,
-0.38039258122444153,
-0.025649433955550194,
-0.18887212872505188,
-0.2391485571861267,
-0.2416248470544815,
0.7002626061439514,
0.046083349734544754,
0.3831157088279724,
-0.5379355549812317,
-0.30787038803100586,
0.339466392993927,
0.345949649810791,
0.04107843339443207,
-0.1700039505958557,
-0.1988915652036667,
0.018937280401587486,
-0.7560957670211792,
-0.6380653381347656,
0.3540976941585541,
-0.3477590084075928,
0.6979272365570068,
0.8982254862785339,
-0.08486564457416534,
0.6668344736099243,
-0.33009248971939087,
0.6539170742034912,
0.6343825459480286,
-0.6714591383934021,
0.24481570720672607,
-0.41979870200157166,
-0.30179697275161743,
0.7408040761947632,
0.2361723929643631,
-0.44991326332092285,
-0.3805598020553589,
-0.927899956703186,
-0.0806022435426712,
0.3881424069404602,
-0.06027969717979431,
0.06565847247838974,
0.09172625839710236,
0.7037410736083984,
0.0951448380947113,
0.2252773642539978,
-0.6615485548973083,
-0.0693245381116867,
-0.10879442095756531,
-0.004745997488498688,
0.049652960151433945,
-0.45741990208625793,
-0.6750869154930115,
-0.11514763534069061,
0.30058053135871887,
-0.25323358178138733,
0.41926565766334534,
0.5945132970809937,
0.08221017569303513,
-0.41038644313812256,
0.12676429748535156,
0.5005430579185486,
0.7457404732704163,
-0.6540871262550354,
0.30776315927505493,
0.6564751863479614,
-0.38051390647888184,
0.30431392788887024,
-0.06874756515026093,
0.497943639755249,
-0.2541956901550293,
0.505025327205658,
0.23914282023906708,
0.2252839058637619,
-0.7472343444824219,
0.8137627243995667,
-0.3828985393047333,
-0.5262230038642883,
-0.4864542782306671,
-0.09109532088041306,
0.17454707622528076,
0.4276108145713806,
-0.05435388907790184,
-0.03732289373874664,
0.13692665100097656,
-0.3566884994506836,
0.16759537160396576,
0.5146068930625916,
-0.9070023894309998,
-0.32558223605155945,
0.40521034598350525,
0.03481779992580414,
-0.36848947405815125,
0.4857880771160126,
0.04719178378582001,
-0.3632563352584839,
0.6619369387626648,
0.4678289294242859,
0.7803455591201782,
-0.16119560599327087,
0.012146919034421444,
-0.10294274985790253,
0.04446808993816376,
0.07588031142950058,
0.24881881475448608,
0.16162730753421783,
-0.7157390117645264,
-0.40328115224838257,
-0.3098275065422058,
-0.9668784737586975,
-0.310269296169281,
-1.0402474403381348,
0.1265416145324707,
-0.7231227159500122,
-0.5972012281417847,
-0.5795913934707642,
0.554587721824646,
-0.6442247629165649,
-0.12156223505735397,
0.19926941394805908,
1.123671531677246,
-0.6170477271080017,
1.107328176498413,
1.022136926651001,
-0.18834185600280762,
-0.834691047668457,
-0.3344929814338684,
0.07643334567546844,
-0.9501377940177917,
0.6133857369422913,
0.15851472318172455,
-0.06973498314619064,
-0.166909322142601,
-0.502000093460083,
-0.27330246567726135,
1.6268914937973022,
0.5600250363349915,
-0.10594826936721802,
0.09448635578155518,
0.40066662430763245,
0.7964902520179749,
-0.5972614288330078,
0.7086432576179504,
0.3444993793964386,
0.33365747332572937,
0.2510793209075928,
-1.1037390232086182,
-0.015989186242222786,
0.0006797157693654299,
0.14585117995738983,
-0.6468923091888428,
-0.71670001745224,
0.3394169509410858,
-0.18114422261714935,
0.19590260088443756,
0.23055511713027954,
0.34773340821266174,
0.6623828411102295,
0.548447847366333,
0.7474386096000671,
0.40064823627471924,
0.7286567687988281,
0.3235224485397339,
0.8879738450050354,
-0.42342397570610046,
0.5994478464126587,
0.8825375437736511,
-0.7827138304710388,
0.3543032109737396,
0.798715353012085,
-0.45735281705856323,
0.15496455132961273,
0.6437462568283081,
-0.1432432234287262,
0.08221200108528137,
0.47159332036972046,
-0.453105092048645,
-0.2948493957519531,
-0.5762223601341248,
-0.31299880146980286,
0.3462914824485779,
0.2362620234489441,
-0.0038392716087400913,
-0.22021733224391937,
0.27335289120674133,
-0.0715419352054596,
0.03759455308318138,
-0.06056155264377594,
0.5171203017234802,
0.6307464838027954,
-0.23683352768421173,
0.24143368005752563,
-0.09947816282510757,
0.016455762088298798,
-0.34053003787994385,
0.047309789806604385,
-0.21139530837535858,
0.3952493965625763,
-0.14746445417404175,
-0.30065131187438965,
0.003009506268426776,
-0.197537362575531,
0.3785543441772461,
-0.6924867033958435,
0.7314870357513428,
-0.23153056204319,
-0.2725374698638916,
0.48364096879959106,
0.8797139525413513,
0.30366063117980957,
0.2892800271511078,
-0.7231802940368652,
0.14487811923027039,
-0.32858744263648987,
-0.39549943804740906,
0.943632960319519,
0.29869863390922546,
0.3195778727531433,
0.9547927975654602,
0.6234468817710876,
0.4114644229412079,
-0.23687225580215454,
0.4374662935733795,
0.8499462604522705,
-0.22318072617053986,
-0.09733095020055771,
-0.6275069117546082,
0.10990125685930252,
-0.023584093898534775,
-0.04769512265920639,
0.6296482682228088,
0.532646656036377,
0.3128693997859955,
0.10883335024118423,
0.3310007154941559,
0.280427485704422,
0.5937235951423645,
-0.2320658564567566,
0.6581960916519165,
-0.6166630387306213,
0.4785265326499939,
-0.28260329365730286,
-0.8969871997833252,
-0.2243887484073639,
0.39367011189460754,
-0.23907795548439026,
-0.1399766057729721,
0.5363478064537048,
0.5556590557098389,
0.15100958943367004,
0.11919534206390381,
0.5140105485916138,
0.028033019974827766,
0.7545620203018188,
0.5042700171470642,
1.2586663961410522,
-0.16138847172260284,
-0.01501863170415163,
-0.31311917304992676,
-0.32837721705436707,
-0.257270485162735,
-0.8417695760726929,
-0.922572135925293,
0.03949839249253273,
-0.28325963020324707,
-0.439312607049942,
-0.3134486973285675,
1.2442665100097656,
0.5685032606124878,
-0.2993256449699402,
-0.760704517364502,
0.3421182334423065,
0.0073619200848042965,
-0.248212531208992,
-0.16066358983516693,
0.22420254349708557,
-0.076093889772892,
-0.45101478695869446,
0.3783862292766571,
0.25220972299575806,
0.21543669700622559,
-0.6491969227790833,
-0.2770809233188629,
0.3137698173522949,
-0.29066234827041626,
0.2643511891365051,
-0.019090212881565094,
-0.6617028117179871,
-0.4959515333175659,
-0.06299945712089539,
-0.27588385343551636,
-0.04819026589393616,
0.8826499581336975,
-0.7352806329727173,
0.4226278066635132,
-0.3387802839279175,
0.46832430362701416,
0.6150123476982117,
0.09329375624656677,
0.6409852504730225,
-0.11034484207630157,
0.1687050759792328,
0.41609519720077515,
0.36568132042884827,
-0.009591436013579369,
-0.2530905306339264,
0.3259720206260681,
0.3103578984737396,
-0.5890519022941589,
-1.0421462059020996,
-0.15103107690811157,
-1.3898941278457642,
-0.019615763798356056,
0.7685893177986145,
-0.5930419564247131,
0.045864056795835495,
-0.19225507974624634,
-0.4882705807685852,
0.20873621106147766,
0.05042440444231033,
0.5915404558181763,
0.38185903429985046,
-0.4660748839378357,
0.03924153372645378,
-0.6834421157836914,
0.4147605299949646,
0.5582913160324097,
-0.46371451020240784,
-0.28040051460266113,
0.11961257457733154,
0.8534775376319885,
-0.16002558171749115,
1.0349256992340088,
-0.13699333369731903,
0.1144680306315422,
-0.39058294892311096,
0.38445454835891724,
-0.249273419380188,
0.16156983375549316,
-0.31126946210861206,
0.225204199552536,
0.5358678102493286,
0.21727722883224487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12263v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12263v1
|
Defending Against Social Engineering Attacks in the Age of LLMs
| 2024-06-18T04:39:40 | 2024-06-18T04:39:40 |
Lin Ai, Tharindu Kumarage, Amrita Bhattacharjee, Zizhou Liu, Zheng Hui, Michael Davinroy, James Cook, Laura Cassani, Kirill Trapeznikov, Matthias Kirchner, Arslan Basharat, Anthony Hoogs, Joshua Garland, Huan Liu, Julia Hirschberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The proliferation of Large Language Models (LLMs) poses challenges in
detecting and mitigating digital deception, as these models can emulate human
conversational patterns and facilitate chat-based social engineering (CSE)
attacks. This study investigates the dual capabilities of LLMs as both
facilitators and defenders against CSE threats. We develop a novel dataset,
SEConvo, simulating CSE scenarios in academic and recruitment contexts, and
designed to examine how LLMs can be exploited in these situations. Our findings
reveal that, while off-the-shelf LLMs generate high-quality CSE content, their
detection capabilities are suboptimal, leading to increased operational costs
for defense. In response, we propose ConvoSentinel, a modular defense pipeline
that improves detection at both the message and the conversation levels,
offering enhanced adaptability and cost-effectiveness. The retrieval-augmented
module in ConvoSentinel identifies malicious intent by comparing messages to a
database of similar conversations, enhancing CSE detection at all stages. Our
study highlights the need for advanced strategies to leverage LLMs in
cybersecurity.
|
[
-0.19229647517204285,
-0.880312979221344,
0.36682504415512085,
-0.06005281209945679,
-0.09553898125886917,
0.7788727283477783,
0.03888026997447014,
-0.49515387415885925,
0.3925827443599701,
0.41792380809783936,
-0.6990146040916443,
-0.4820569157600403,
-0.5806809663772583,
-0.09430959820747375,
-0.6411812901496887,
0.6819230914115906,
0.40210577845573425,
0.07946004718542099,
-0.1301659643650055,
0.2202715426683426,
-0.30278685688972473,
-0.7403034567832947,
-0.9340222477912903,
-0.2567567825317383,
0.4751933217048645,
0.4301915764808655,
0.5611869096755981,
-0.2214735895395279,
0.38283905386924744,
0.4147411584854126,
-0.1539851576089859,
0.0650697723031044,
-0.855147123336792,
0.3804773986339569,
-0.15674719214439392,
-0.5248920321464539,
-0.17931480705738068,
-0.19813448190689087,
0.12594138085842133,
0.33154037594795227,
0.019287336617708206,
0.051562514156103134,
0.3281519114971161,
0.5825602412223816,
-0.691769540309906,
-0.17895030975341797,
-0.9632889032363892,
-0.3048468828201294,
-0.19418935477733612,
0.026140661910176277,
-0.6155509948730469,
-0.4442833960056305,
0.14949162304401398,
-0.38065534830093384,
0.06742843240499496,
-0.027082892134785652,
0.5365830063819885,
-0.037531256675720215,
-0.3271804451942444,
-0.282981812953949,
-0.49919405579566956,
0.5013678073883057,
-0.6081600189208984,
0.25577765703201294,
0.1258709877729416,
0.4920876622200012,
-0.5429938435554504,
-0.7213563919067383,
-0.15280862152576447,
-0.34589698910713196,
0.03111494518816471,
-0.06951543688774109,
-0.43740054965019226,
0.22294782102108002,
0.16480739414691925,
0.07366414368152618,
-0.5782793760299683,
0.33389362692832947,
-0.6173005700111389,
-0.5641826391220093,
0.9124739766120911,
0.21241135895252228,
0.5088150501251221,
0.006495630834251642,
-0.29298636317253113,
0.08458876609802246,
-0.7302836775779724,
0.09029090404510498,
0.5462589263916016,
0.16082872450351715,
-0.33870837092399597,
0.3117288053035736,
0.03862418979406357,
-0.017865760251879692,
0.1544036716222763,
0.15713916718959808,
-0.23166140913963318,
-0.07547768205404282,
-0.243729367852211,
0.225768581032753,
0.8307080864906311,
0.08793636411428452,
0.3252720534801483,
-0.1503671556711197,
-0.057054851204156876,
0.4499015510082245,
0.5720801949501038,
-0.8656929135322571,
-0.20478050410747528,
0.3454664945602417,
-0.4394069314002991,
-0.6863749623298645,
0.024815643206238747,
-0.6370239853858948,
-0.835740864276886,
-0.1400248408317566,
0.13960479199886322,
-0.408695787191391,
-0.32124364376068115,
0.23738333582878113,
-0.26132932305336,
0.22957433760166168,
0.12027644366025925,
-0.3926101326942444,
0.629623293876648,
0.9340111613273621,
0.9160179495811462,
-0.20775246620178223,
-0.009557983838021755,
-0.4145629107952118,
-0.0691261813044548,
-0.4482988715171814,
0.5799834132194519,
-0.44381991028785706,
-0.778854489326477,
0.2210562825202942,
0.024156270548701286,
0.24910925328731537,
-0.30600032210350037,
0.5537567138671875,
-0.7814337015151978,
-0.2832373082637787,
-0.21089300513267517,
-0.44214412569999695,
0.058447614312171936,
0.38069450855255127,
-0.4799160659313202,
0.8232836127281189,
-0.16742070019245148,
-0.8659342527389526,
-0.12533411383628845,
-0.4066653549671173,
-0.3887125849723816,
0.3100718855857849,
-0.4265354871749878,
-0.3259536325931549,
0.22318293154239655,
-0.27136939764022827,
0.6320496797561646,
-0.3785201609134674,
0.21832089126110077,
-0.790230393409729,
-0.5095449090003967,
0.35481250286102295,
-0.4634663760662079,
0.8303966522216797,
0.2752684950828552,
-0.19497527182102203,
0.030934441834688187,
-0.4458669126033783,
-0.23598216474056244,
0.1846301108598709,
0.07748079299926758,
-0.5243351459503174,
0.3378406763076782,
-0.43526527285575867,
-0.10007043927907944,
0.34236910939216614,
-0.7769010066986084,
-0.12791870534420013,
-0.5492085218429565,
0.4095143675804138,
0.8839060068130493,
0.17082254588603973,
0.4735088646411896,
-0.19186997413635254,
0.580374002456665,
-0.1594967544078827,
0.4368380904197693,
0.24714282155036926,
-0.14337417483329773,
-0.43060415983200073,
-0.32723838090896606,
-0.14775197207927704,
0.7357314229011536,
-1.118683934211731,
0.0325566790997982,
-0.2203862965106964,
-0.8360346555709839,
-0.21020737290382385,
-0.08666971325874329,
0.32927075028419495,
-0.17546944320201874,
0.0013651688350364566,
0.15355552732944489,
-0.5807967782020569,
-1.1264216899871826,
-0.3024721145629883,
-0.1684272587299347,
-0.044393617659807205,
0.1348821073770523,
0.36572930216789246,
-0.24459877610206604,
0.7075445652008057,
-0.47652021050453186,
0.12625834345817566,
-0.25339043140411377,
-0.14835956692695618,
-0.006159665994346142,
0.26479053497314453,
0.6208660006523132,
-0.6822254061698914,
-0.43545249104499817,
0.03689293935894966,
-0.8490036725997925,
-0.2547449767589569,
-0.1323438435792923,
-0.07270409166812897,
-0.22858969867229462,
0.7885284423828125,
-0.3897942900657654,
0.2850829064846039,
0.5401217341423035,
-0.3763745129108429,
0.8063557744026184,
0.23165276646614075,
0.2882102131843567,
-1.2360426187515259,
-0.39527660608291626,
0.17920486629009247,
-0.18276886641979218,
-1.0282237529754639,
0.1305980533361435,
0.038421519100666046,
-0.4532727897167206,
-0.8986409306526184,
0.43681108951568604,
-0.45480021834373474,
0.22221089899539948,
-0.40921255946159363,
0.3378238081932068,
-0.12216953933238983,
0.1892343908548355,
-0.5370206236839294,
0.857964813709259,
0.8421606421470642,
-0.6095705032348633,
0.48635005950927734,
0.05113653093576431,
-0.2603203058242798,
0.8316059708595276,
-0.9476152658462524,
0.3598940074443817,
-0.0710996761918068,
0.31075015664100647,
-0.8579901456832886,
-0.1615840643644333,
0.04062638431787491,
-0.5824424028396606,
0.4749596416950226,
-0.25016799569129944,
-0.2923842966556549,
-0.3971191644668579,
-0.8696153163909912,
0.2195427268743515,
0.11973436176776886,
-0.4841613471508026,
0.8686957955360413,
0.6590412259101868,
-0.2194288820028305,
-0.6434733271598816,
-0.8194829821586609,
0.3482561707496643,
-0.27929675579071045,
-0.8915090560913086,
0.43571335077285767,
-0.025040503591299057,
-0.5996094942092896,
-0.46630245447158813,
-0.1393548846244812,
0.17916658520698547,
0.6005846858024597,
0.3424117863178253,
0.40721970796585083,
-0.04038228094577789,
-0.15659283101558685,
0.039476968348026276,
-0.016946034505963326,
0.41078564524650574,
-0.16506201028823853,
0.6490864157676697,
0.18990157544612885,
-0.6017810702323914,
-0.5102382898330688,
0.4676089286804199,
0.6231979131698608,
0.15842793881893158,
0.5966857075691223,
0.10853095352649689,
-0.31917569041252136,
-0.31839802861213684,
-0.6482435464859009,
-0.5424831509590149,
-0.6422208547592163,
0.4433208107948303,
-0.26918405294418335,
-1.1279103755950928,
0.4716350734233856,
-0.2428009957075119,
0.25632983446121216,
-0.007540972903370857,
0.26644468307495117,
0.002211141400039196,
0.7379938960075378,
0.3256317377090454,
-0.3784027099609375,
0.513191282749176,
-0.2324618548154831,
0.4371066987514496,
-0.5893492102622986,
-0.24950473010540009,
-0.463578999042511,
-0.2679835259914398,
-0.8412032723426819,
0.08574865758419037,
0.3844045102596283,
-0.18626564741134644,
-0.22621069848537445,
0.5383773446083069,
-0.5562738180160522,
0.5165997743606567,
0.2196885198354721,
0.43454495072364807,
-0.12880270183086395,
-0.10780730843544006,
0.18638934195041656,
0.12846297025680542,
-0.47921764850616455,
-0.758906364440918,
0.8331140875816345,
0.48268160223960876,
0.9503976702690125,
0.3702892065048218,
0.6737836599349976,
0.7141808867454529,
0.06842747330665588,
-0.5194451808929443,
1.0698102712631226,
-0.23743771016597748,
-0.5285643935203552,
0.06797328591346741,
-0.24943368136882782,
-0.8914670944213867,
0.32117584347724915,
-0.2367372214794159,
-0.9066301584243774,
0.345714271068573,
-0.046930618584156036,
-0.4013107120990753,
0.3881039321422577,
-0.7166011929512024,
0.58812016248703,
-0.341600626707077,
-0.615228533744812,
-0.506506621837616,
-0.3449903428554535,
0.3194632828235626,
-0.05386359244585037,
0.25315210223197937,
-0.21235528588294983,
0.15780696272850037,
0.46385735273361206,
-0.10139539837837219,
1.4005495309829712,
-0.062450241297483444,
-0.03474082425236702,
0.3272712826728821,
0.5415412187576294,
0.8118680119514465,
0.0999680906534195,
-0.10585708916187286,
0.2812422513961792,
0.21046237647533417,
-0.4790363609790802,
-0.3152853846549988,
0.9531936049461365,
-0.6559864282608032,
-1.0301058292388916,
-0.49553120136260986,
-0.12953287363052368,
-0.0310553926974535,
-0.12627173960208893,
0.06859727203845978,
0.4587157666683197,
-0.8154664635658264,
0.41632509231567383,
0.8130746483802795,
-0.3926451504230499,
0.3109472393989563,
0.46076563000679016,
0.07395391911268234,
-0.359164297580719,
0.7011900544166565,
0.029606694355607033,
0.5695177912712097,
0.13777144253253937,
0.11814908683300018,
-0.10451845824718475,
-0.5237144231796265,
0.1406434178352356,
0.1615578979253769,
-0.5006942749023438,
-0.3658585250377655,
-0.7284684777259827,
-0.45286476612091064,
-0.5641803741455078,
-0.5783604383468628,
-0.1285613626241684,
-0.19955438375473022,
-0.14242038130760193,
-0.2739715874195099,
0.36204537749290466,
0.6569986343383789,
0.016563840210437775,
0.3970384895801544,
-0.40811455249786377,
0.02102084644138813,
0.33691567182540894,
-0.06525442004203796,
-0.07873857766389847,
-0.36565452814102173,
-0.0944405272603035,
0.21292220056056976,
-0.40434348583221436,
-1.1363884210586548,
0.028156844899058342,
-0.2182590663433075,
0.53807532787323,
0.2907119691371918,
0.3141956031322479,
0.20759816467761993,
-0.3387041687965393,
0.9582220911979675,
0.06419225037097931,
-0.7118409276008606,
0.42227429151535034,
-0.34694725275039673,
-0.058940958231687546,
0.4805292785167694,
0.37801939249038696,
-0.5607718825340271,
-0.6098690032958984,
-0.712627112865448,
-0.6115521788597107,
0.43349596858024597,
0.2714957594871521,
0.4294939637184143,
-0.11156929284334183,
0.30297213792800903,
-0.3011968731880188,
0.003405687166377902,
-0.5692413449287415,
-0.14570236206054688,
0.18809962272644043,
-0.21866115927696228,
0.3884030878543854,
-0.5605546832084656,
-0.1914559304714203,
0.21778927743434906,
0.9599997997283936,
0.05560886859893799,
0.048133689910173416,
0.03474992886185646,
0.05940169841051102,
0.5256571769714355,
0.35090264678001404,
0.3213445246219635,
0.11335448175668716,
0.26322048902511597,
0.17233183979988098,
0.6337723135948181,
-0.4707273840904236,
0.31145989894866943,
-0.1214958131313324,
-0.2607267200946808,
-0.14306695759296417,
0.17679481208324432,
0.3772226572036743,
0.3550156354904175,
-0.51446932554245,
0.6434604525566101,
0.06723115593194962,
-0.24491865932941437,
-0.561991274356842,
0.22713874280452728,
0.14267180860042572,
0.5003421306610107,
0.28102052211761475,
-0.2873264253139496,
0.2589321732521057,
-0.5745810270309448,
0.09591899812221527,
0.9472070336341858,
-0.28164970874786377,
-0.3255377411842346,
0.5273794531822205,
0.2852630019187927,
-0.636235237121582,
0.09335396438837051,
-0.06717642396688461,
-0.6348934769630432,
0.6729384064674377,
0.3211651146411896,
1.088755488395691,
-0.4012967050075531,
0.1956178992986679,
-0.008553894236683846,
0.47143426537513733,
0.03802407532930374,
0.122843898832798,
0.19144964218139648,
-0.6831952333450317,
-0.184833362698555,
-0.1643010973930359,
-0.46308210492134094,
0.019593441858887672,
-0.3038707971572876,
0.6219388842582703,
-0.6051512956619263,
-0.22970406711101532,
0.07916063815355301,
-0.13866278529167175,
-0.39830145239830017,
-0.31203365325927734,
0.1947370022535324,
0.9778323769569397,
-0.737366259098053,
0.6179904341697693,
0.3210020661354065,
-0.05317717045545578,
-0.4397483766078949,
-0.2285415083169937,
0.5880665183067322,
-0.49520164728164673,
0.49334588646888733,
0.12113268673419952,
-0.733042299747467,
-0.23781529068946838,
-0.8804311752319336,
-0.4827819764614105,
1.1568361520767212,
0.5302663445472717,
-0.6853023171424866,
0.031672630459070206,
0.3248266279697418,
0.46528103947639465,
-0.1973072588443756,
0.11359580606222153,
0.5033657550811768,
0.06207544729113579,
-0.05165228992700577,
-0.5186397433280945,
0.06727441400289536,
-0.12984143197536469,
-0.052919402718544006,
0.25165632367134094,
-0.8344849944114685,
0.3566858172416687,
0.23899079859256744,
-0.5818828344345093,
-0.30554676055908203,
0.5317805409431458,
0.3623356521129608,
0.461669385433197,
0.35903406143188477,
0.07886277139186859,
0.5927010178565979,
-0.03353538364171982,
0.8985491394996643,
-0.3939415514469147,
0.02847438119351864,
0.9559241533279419,
-0.45191413164138794,
0.5493994355201721,
0.2268725484609604,
-0.0571594275534153,
0.534304678440094,
0.6188147664070129,
0.13256923854351044,
0.22229628264904022,
0.4267561733722687,
-0.5636722445487976,
-0.23552419245243073,
-0.17097432911396027,
-0.0683659240603447,
0.16574278473854065,
0.47439712285995483,
-0.016615785658359528,
-0.12699246406555176,
0.14378206431865692,
0.4235486090183258,
0.45308658480644226,
-0.28617045283317566,
0.8142870664596558,
0.37116801738739014,
-0.21667832136154175,
0.26327192783355713,
-0.13479351997375488,
0.8480626344680786,
-0.8283329606056213,
0.3409513235092163,
-0.1784808337688446,
0.32627996802330017,
-0.16256313025951385,
-0.6502256393432617,
0.42131340503692627,
-0.1017722561955452,
0.18071922659873962,
-0.016109904274344444,
1.0866321325302124,
-0.0967477485537529,
-0.2844170928001404,
0.6598939895629883,
0.17605368793010712,
-0.10927329957485199,
-0.15406376123428345,
-0.8358682990074158,
0.2464408576488495,
-0.14232884347438812,
0.023943142965435982,
0.3692026436328888,
0.4838259816169739,
-0.041006676852703094,
0.964794933795929,
0.694764256477356,
-0.021121038123965263,
-0.1503787785768509,
0.15920713543891907,
1.0888127088546753,
-0.14859703183174133,
-0.4819903075695038,
-1.3505291938781738,
0.22821715474128723,
-0.7269303202629089,
0.2510167062282562,
0.8402535915374756,
0.6569460034370422,
0.6017497777938843,
0.23855136334896088,
0.7033960223197937,
0.15940377116203308,
0.44423115253448486,
-0.36424052715301514,
0.5889593362808228,
-0.27404436469078064,
0.6113453507423401,
-0.18978968262672424,
-0.3796381950378418,
0.09394703805446625,
0.020492492243647575,
-0.37457165122032166,
-0.4476830065250397,
0.4996991753578186,
1.262559175491333,
-0.07434677332639694,
0.26288899779319763,
0.42099711298942566,
0.2713764011859894,
0.6964320540428162,
0.43487539887428284,
1.0248245000839233,
-0.29379671812057495,
0.5570741891860962,
0.20116731524467468,
-0.27287304401397705,
0.05735595151782036,
-0.5393227934837341,
-1.3898979425430298,
-0.22356802225112915,
-0.2686777412891388,
-0.6999284625053406,
0.4236343502998352,
1.0322051048278809,
0.5471456050872803,
-0.8374776840209961,
-0.28689754009246826,
0.23546840250492096,
0.11309044063091278,
0.05891114100813866,
-0.20750777423381805,
-0.06178003177046776,
-0.2533452808856964,
-0.41454634070396423,
0.7695096135139465,
0.41489407420158386,
0.09423734992742538,
-0.6511172652244568,
0.1318311244249344,
-0.37700244784355164,
0.6763786673545837,
0.7123124599456787,
0.1961175799369812,
-0.5393334627151489,
-0.4195495545864105,
0.22834229469299316,
-0.2776775658130646,
-0.3896036446094513,
0.9479842782020569,
-0.4127172529697418,
0.030141878873109818,
0.6041359305381775,
0.9840936660766602,
0.22277884185314178,
-0.26347115635871887,
0.5882090330123901,
-0.7733786106109619,
0.24172234535217285,
0.1000058576464653,
0.4396193325519562,
0.23558993637561798,
-0.7013669610023499,
0.5722434520721436,
0.203753262758255,
-0.5390777587890625,
-0.7484159469604492,
0.40273842215538025,
-0.5451415181159973,
-0.6542328596115112,
1.2186295986175537,
0.10786690562963486,
-0.1642736941576004,
-0.45728200674057007,
-0.3956415355205536,
-0.062438659369945526,
-0.47183534502983093,
0.8702470064163208,
0.6202141046524048,
0.5187963247299194,
0.07758936285972595,
-0.5805193781852722,
0.44649261236190796,
0.09370504319667816,
-0.6717219948768616,
0.15768474340438843,
0.45481088757514954,
0.2639215588569641,
0.2180543690919876,
0.4743404686450958,
-0.0030847599264234304,
0.14903444051742554,
-0.2284340262413025,
-0.09362973272800446,
0.03898392245173454,
-0.21289300918579102,
0.06310978531837463,
0.22838906943798065,
-0.14787034690380096,
-0.29081106185913086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12260v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12260v1
|
Self-Supervised Time-Series Anomaly Detection Using Learnable Data Augmentation
| 2024-06-18T04:25:56 | 2024-06-18T04:25:56 |
Kukjin Choi, Jihun Yi, Jisoo Mok, Sungroh Yoon
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Continuous efforts are being made to advance anomaly detection in various
manufacturing processes to increase the productivity and safety of industrial
sites. Deep learning replaced rule-based methods and recently emerged as a
promising method for anomaly detection in diverse industries. However, in the
real world, the scarcity of abnormal data and difficulties in obtaining labeled
data create limitations in the training of detection models. In this study, we
addressed these shortcomings by proposing a learnable data augmentation-based
time-series anomaly detection (LATAD) technique that is trained in a
self-supervised manner. LATAD extracts discriminative features from time-series
data through contrastive learning. At the same time, learnable data
augmentation produces challenging negative samples to enhance learning
efficiency. We measured anomaly scores of the proposed technique based on
latent feature similarities. As per the results, LATAD exhibited comparable or
improved performance to the state-of-the-art anomaly detection assessments on
several benchmark datasets and provided a gradient-based diagnosis technique to
help identify root causes.
|
[
-0.35157474875450134,
-0.6506482362747192,
0.27795135974884033,
-0.07836192846298218,
-0.3933868110179901,
0.12226809561252594,
0.40024885535240173,
-0.6566320657730103,
0.2922462522983551,
0.40838879346847534,
-1.0225422382354736,
-0.4224812388420105,
-0.28806254267692566,
-0.06436270475387573,
-0.45253366231918335,
0.9573985934257507,
-0.20427535474300385,
-0.43798646330833435,
0.09423311054706573,
-0.23287902772426605,
-0.3741283118724823,
-0.654828667640686,
-0.5858222246170044,
-0.1845058649778366,
0.2254868894815445,
0.174102321267128,
0.24105709791183472,
0.7248312830924988,
0.47927457094192505,
0.24332356452941895,
0.23816297948360443,
0.665625274181366,
-0.14386703073978424,
0.2381274700164795,
0.12803930044174194,
-0.27113470435142517,
-0.5343676805496216,
-0.27839937806129456,
0.4038900136947632,
0.6618114113807678,
-0.15486808121204376,
0.15889495611190796,
0.20356042683124542,
0.6723602414131165,
-0.44715964794158936,
0.16282369196414948,
-0.31040501594543457,
0.5248611569404602,
-0.3527761995792389,
-0.3087517321109772,
0.1898641437292099,
-0.1818666309118271,
-0.28493326902389526,
-0.6059662103652954,
0.828830361366272,
-0.0884382426738739,
0.5011183619499207,
0.6732531785964966,
-0.15019938349723816,
-0.174326553940773,
-0.7103220820426941,
0.8857451677322388,
-0.77085942029953,
0.14752988517284393,
0.0945972129702568,
0.5296697616577148,
0.013097072020173073,
-0.6602067351341248,
-0.4311453700065613,
0.20513483881950378,
-0.12859544157981873,
0.12031552195549011,
-0.10741249471902847,
-0.4202883839607239,
0.22901158034801483,
0.5493506789207458,
-0.6136100888252258,
0.7734094262123108,
-0.19316630065441132,
-0.20996008813381195,
0.43624308705329895,
0.6671547293663025,
-0.16148675978183746,
-0.1330678015947342,
-0.4388739764690399,
-0.044864535331726074,
-0.20189666748046875,
0.07453359663486481,
0.6469491720199585,
0.5359795093536377,
-0.3440067768096924,
0.03026774898171425,
-0.5128278732299805,
0.4261394441127777,
0.07571150362491608,
0.15358136594295502,
0.6939301490783691,
-0.2127978801727295,
-0.22600078582763672,
0.20160232484340668,
0.44325798749923706,
0.028729790821671486,
-0.24860848486423492,
0.04911491274833679,
-0.4041661024093628,
-0.02316259779036045,
0.14089004695415497,
-0.5153375864028931,
-0.4553426206111908,
0.36189109086990356,
-0.4674302041530609,
-0.5115259885787964,
-0.004554789047688246,
-0.8947314620018005,
-0.5518019795417786,
-0.22537602484226227,
0.49178269505500793,
-0.11367230117321014,
-0.5875182151794434,
-0.10307186841964722,
0.08331158757209778,
0.1641114205121994,
0.23239348828792572,
-0.7536225318908691,
-0.17276082932949066,
0.6080040335655212,
0.7780927419662476,
-0.5264360904693604,
-0.012949666939675808,
-0.6318787336349487,
0.06248582527041435,
-0.35040372610092163,
0.7938994765281677,
-0.18653005361557007,
-0.6654747128486633,
-0.2019825279712677,
0.20698143541812897,
0.19742518663406372,
-0.9445923566818237,
0.419232577085495,
-0.44955918192863464,
-0.040031127631664276,
0.0704883262515068,
-0.3273513913154602,
0.049222711473703384,
0.40919598937034607,
-0.6198943853378296,
1.1233394145965576,
0.35246214270591736,
-0.7216530442237854,
0.5747238993644714,
-0.726423978805542,
-0.35516297817230225,
0.034654080867767334,
-0.2539246678352356,
-1.0519229173660278,
-0.1813667118549347,
0.5788829326629639,
0.7718620896339417,
0.09144557267427444,
0.21462169289588928,
-0.5773480534553528,
-0.13964292407035828,
0.27009138464927673,
-0.7536020278930664,
0.48784127831459045,
0.35835206508636475,
-0.4303703010082245,
-0.17104309797286987,
-0.9123666286468506,
-0.02199334092438221,
0.09789884090423584,
0.06560743600130081,
-0.277934193611145,
-0.3158186972141266,
-0.2922461926937103,
0.03895113244652748,
0.1865731179714203,
-0.5230109691619873,
0.12616661190986633,
-0.2916218638420105,
-0.11941543966531754,
0.8854917883872986,
0.4896673560142517,
-0.07665608823299408,
-0.4089839458465576,
0.535291314125061,
0.7461674213409424,
0.15289995074272156,
-0.3736712336540222,
-0.0699138343334198,
-0.8329213261604309,
-0.40506622195243835,
-0.002888708608224988,
0.575981080532074,
-0.7473381757736206,
0.5815277099609375,
-0.017814770340919495,
-0.2910953164100647,
-0.387067973613739,
0.33890819549560547,
0.09282894432544708,
0.9599936604499817,
0.5454506278038025,
-0.2151551991701126,
-0.6029751300811768,
-0.8915424346923828,
-0.31227967143058777,
0.527206540107727,
-0.042075131088495255,
0.05702944099903107,
0.2856142520904541,
-0.3234047591686249,
0.8432939052581787,
-0.8188472390174866,
-0.7365540862083435,
0.21763376891613007,
0.4253246486186981,
0.7627717852592468,
0.7392833232879639,
0.5666295289993286,
-0.5486589074134827,
-0.35322126746177673,
0.19844463467597961,
-1.0712825059890747,
-0.09559399634599686,
-0.09993932396173477,
0.5110691785812378,
0.3762015402317047,
0.7457208037376404,
0.2249612957239151,
0.5445430874824524,
0.35092097520828247,
-0.02832932025194168,
0.4322696626186371,
-0.30220043659210205,
0.1695176362991333,
-1.1747969388961792,
-0.08075298368930817,
0.1599874347448349,
-0.14744381606578827,
-0.6287558078765869,
-0.4347047805786133,
-0.032289259135723114,
-0.09819960594177246,
-0.3767191171646118,
0.19107109308242798,
-0.19555184245109558,
0.04288025572896004,
-0.2072787880897522,
-0.41797366738319397,
0.01425137184560299,
0.5181038975715637,
-0.13785012066364288,
0.824032187461853,
0.48080554604530334,
-0.8012599945068359,
0.506382942199707,
-0.3010999262332916,
-0.5406352281570435,
0.5966964960098267,
-0.3592924475669861,
0.14505158364772797,
-0.21957243978977203,
-0.20091180503368378,
-0.9044701457023621,
-0.2984488010406494,
0.49760305881500244,
-0.26508378982543945,
0.538972020149231,
-0.09587207436561584,
-0.16567043960094452,
-0.22203750908374786,
-0.247528076171875,
0.5492410659790039,
0.38885053992271423,
-1.0427601337432861,
0.47976112365722656,
0.14157302677631378,
0.087651327252388,
-0.7553889751434326,
-0.8687195181846619,
-0.6420223712921143,
-0.6020243167877197,
-0.23381364345550537,
0.20984011888504028,
0.10857787728309631,
-0.09564674645662308,
-0.059867046773433685,
-0.40620532631874084,
-0.36890125274658203,
0.29047340154647827,
0.1787973940372467,
0.16287115216255188,
-0.2693619132041931,
0.1650257408618927,
0.06595925241708755,
-0.2081078290939331,
0.1397061049938202,
-0.10366805642843246,
0.3424718677997589,
-0.14838877320289612,
-0.6645084023475647,
-0.650844395160675,
0.29817789793014526,
0.20209956169128418,
0.2445579469203949,
0.4500337839126587,
0.8177837133407593,
-0.3605937361717224,
-0.46939629316329956,
-0.4442870318889618,
-0.2630482614040375,
-0.5982038378715515,
0.3577945828437805,
-0.19277745485305786,
-0.5545172691345215,
0.7071045637130737,
-0.2365722805261612,
-0.17228913307189941,
0.5816062092781067,
0.03356340527534485,
-0.42279866337776184,
0.6878604888916016,
0.4243205785751343,
-0.1785290688276291,
0.44045260548591614,
-0.6318120956420898,
0.27186745405197144,
-0.8423282504081726,
-0.44271549582481384,
-0.21275822818279266,
-0.271034836769104,
-0.580172598361969,
-0.24997104704380035,
0.7717269062995911,
-0.28208127617836,
-0.23299023509025574,
-0.02352181449532509,
-0.48619985580444336,
0.19433118402957916,
0.26632896065711975,
0.48111337423324585,
0.28455403447151184,
0.22599071264266968,
0.1410074234008789,
-0.34267258644104004,
-0.5138534307479858,
0.12122869491577148,
0.7987395524978638,
0.29016774892807007,
0.7643255591392517,
0.04333219677209854,
0.7347347736358643,
1.1590967178344727,
0.04598941281437874,
-0.4896208345890045,
0.11245612055063248,
-0.2907867729663849,
-0.25308138132095337,
-0.3730746805667877,
-0.4826526343822479,
-0.985327959060669,
-0.0774276927113533,
-0.17499808967113495,
-0.41630613803863525,
0.6768904328346252,
0.44502419233322144,
-0.4903337359428406,
0.44973722100257874,
-0.7542813420295715,
0.7321285009384155,
-0.6318312883377075,
-0.37083011865615845,
-0.06879232078790665,
-0.2655446231365204,
0.29182013869285583,
-0.46931254863739014,
0.2909717261791229,
-0.1267523616552353,
-0.026510873809456825,
0.6404968500137329,
-0.48009607195854187,
1.0858608484268188,
-0.3946034908294678,
-0.2480207085609436,
0.1986963003873825,
-0.07220792770385742,
0.5154603719711304,
0.04999542608857155,
-0.04134903475642204,
0.2933584153652191,
-0.35017725825309753,
-0.46044135093688965,
-0.6927495002746582,
0.7481454014778137,
-0.5768355131149292,
-0.6207329630851746,
-0.6516379117965698,
-0.4004284143447876,
-0.25671693682670593,
0.05688076466321945,
0.11842998117208481,
0.6438376307487488,
0.024022044613957405,
0.18957756459712982,
0.5945735573768616,
0.0009913642425090075,
0.7658125162124634,
0.5997939705848694,
0.15947557985782623,
-0.15024858713150024,
1.2365087270736694,
0.21496640145778656,
-0.08148927241563797,
0.2265622615814209,
0.052753690630197525,
-0.2790665030479431,
-0.44126641750335693,
-0.08180789649486542,
0.004476144444197416,
-0.5613874197006226,
-0.33241507411003113,
-0.516250729560852,
-0.3373258709907532,
-0.28767895698547363,
-0.03327907249331474,
-0.33928054571151733,
-0.45208537578582764,
-0.8212518095970154,
0.1938038170337677,
0.3829021751880646,
0.4885498881340027,
-0.37925034761428833,
0.40668511390686035,
-0.8487691879272461,
0.393821656703949,
0.6363826394081116,
0.3951689600944519,
0.07999839633703232,
-0.7154048681259155,
-0.2511187195777893,
-0.005657057277858257,
-0.46505630016326904,
-0.29446640610694885,
0.6191043257713318,
0.0994579941034317,
0.7226876616477966,
0.7779359817504883,
0.4014972150325775,
0.6013121008872986,
0.14951132237911224,
0.49324172735214233,
0.13357698917388916,
-0.6146057844161987,
0.54719078540802,
-0.5672175884246826,
0.20280282199382782,
0.06369395554065704,
0.31980565190315247,
-0.062150996178388596,
0.16040363907814026,
-0.6509461402893066,
-0.9277639985084534,
0.7415810227394104,
-0.04392018914222717,
-0.12752294540405273,
0.24979612231254578,
0.44765424728393555,
0.42782318592071533,
0.27068161964416504,
-0.4984642267227173,
-0.3472331762313843,
-0.33846914768218994,
-0.06348627805709839,
-0.12784844636917114,
0.06723693758249283,
0.07135561853647232,
-0.015443244017660618,
0.55368971824646,
-0.18764236569404602,
0.1588274985551834,
0.2732897400856018,
0.07397689670324326,
0.04664912819862366,
0.2541232407093048,
0.4091382324695587,
0.4835962951183319,
-0.33065909147262573,
-0.21707533299922943,
0.42178407311439514,
-0.39801594614982605,
0.045187778770923615,
0.33393052220344543,
0.19037120044231415,
-0.17132870852947235,
0.23768460750579834,
0.5667900443077087,
-0.24966737627983093,
-0.3663196861743927,
0.23910285532474518,
0.40192919969558716,
-0.011640926823019981,
-0.7109029293060303,
0.3796631693840027,
-0.5253689885139465,
0.6226121783256531,
0.7090438604354858,
0.11363609880208969,
0.32076722383499146,
-0.4105275571346283,
0.1947401612997055,
0.49369874596595764,
-0.4178045690059662,
-0.06868494302034378,
0.4805481731891632,
0.17371249198913574,
-0.13462458550930023,
0.5531710982322693,
-0.11000175774097443,
-0.44239237904548645,
1.0978341102600098,
0.35302045941352844,
0.6388674974441528,
-0.37967097759246826,
-0.03449248522520065,
0.08812349289655685,
0.3653612732887268,
0.06906026601791382,
0.25211331248283386,
-0.21081025898456573,
-0.7621119618415833,
-0.18969275057315826,
-0.21551145613193512,
-0.3839103877544403,
0.8139348030090332,
-0.7900996208190918,
0.3496025800704956,
-0.47800585627555847,
-0.010683813132345676,
-0.11259964853525162,
-0.09780100733041763,
-0.5608441829681396,
0.3575393259525299,
-0.13090378046035767,
0.4611138701438904,
-1.1326733827590942,
0.6015497446060181,
0.1749579906463623,
-0.10779386758804321,
-0.444560706615448,
0.03322005644440651,
-0.11899670213460922,
-0.7754880785942078,
0.4827342927455902,
0.3392809331417084,
-0.11761239171028137,
-0.030820557847619057,
-0.07197859138250351,
-0.5769513249397278,
1.0902976989746094,
0.07829257100820541,
-0.52601557970047,
0.39912718534469604,
0.13881276547908783,
0.47674623131752014,
-0.3185984790325165,
-0.12934625148773193,
0.706498920917511,
0.16457918286323547,
-0.23428349196910858,
-0.40683162212371826,
-0.1385229527950287,
-0.22977185249328613,
-0.442120760679245,
0.7059551477432251,
-0.6830285787582397,
0.6641834378242493,
-0.1405387818813324,
0.04863716661930084,
-0.1935781091451645,
0.8477025628089905,
0.027109717950224876,
0.9277862310409546,
0.5571138262748718,
0.6128942370414734,
0.8547345995903015,
-0.05044470727443695,
0.6832439303398132,
-0.004503350239247084,
0.290762335062027,
1.1167123317718506,
-0.1759541779756546,
0.40862298011779785,
0.18507909774780273,
-0.2172844558954239,
0.5003440976142883,
0.7302506566047668,
-0.3554548919200897,
0.6778537631034851,
-0.19593524932861328,
-0.38226157426834106,
-0.37107595801353455,
-0.1373576521873474,
-0.8548036813735962,
0.39837729930877686,
0.7430444359779358,
-0.33612242341041565,
-0.17759378254413605,
-0.08570379763841629,
-0.31232357025146484,
-0.0657181367278099,
-0.47797420620918274,
0.4474439024925232,
-0.069708913564682,
-0.19106772541999817,
0.6059798002243042,
-0.48707276582717896,
0.7918372750282288,
-0.4872022271156311,
-0.34267231822013855,
-0.4599713087081909,
0.3143415153026581,
-0.38967493176460266,
-0.7070543169975281,
0.450053870677948,
-0.18068954348564148,
-0.1627134084701538,
-0.06393802911043167,
0.6531711220741272,
-0.04423515871167183,
-0.4079211950302124,
0.0013438317691907287,
0.4974677860736847,
0.12131790816783905,
0.22960549592971802,
-0.23844647407531738,
-0.2503318190574646,
-0.026773424819111824,
0.15601053833961487,
0.2506392300128937,
0.26925161480903625,
-0.12215036153793335,
0.7602995038032532,
0.5711479187011719,
-0.03478304296731949,
-0.15290631353855133,
-0.04927691072225571,
0.9137936234474182,
-0.4637221693992615,
-0.7659540772438049,
-0.5634503960609436,
0.40030762553215027,
-0.3759343922138214,
-0.09437984228134155,
0.47422468662261963,
0.5802109241485596,
0.7112006545066833,
-0.3161901533603668,
0.8777315020561218,
0.32055628299713135,
1.0507738590240479,
-0.7294650077819824,
0.5392788052558899,
-0.6507608890533447,
0.8654168844223022,
0.02370396815240383,
-0.6186591386795044,
-0.2952783703804016,
0.16615112125873566,
-0.30250170826911926,
0.2913624048233032,
0.4650445580482483,
0.7267659902572632,
-0.5175410509109497,
0.02660803124308586,
0.2387898862361908,
0.2528681457042694,
0.08808393031358719,
0.3407682776451111,
0.8716434240341187,
-0.28805097937583923,
0.617713987827301,
-0.4693746566772461,
-0.11104726046323776,
-0.4027758836746216,
-1.2012338638305664,
-0.9814048409461975,
-0.29523563385009766,
-0.3707345128059387,
-0.23119992017745972,
0.011695323511958122,
0.8622697591781616,
0.5072153210639954,
-1.143823504447937,
0.10934676975011826,
-0.03932855278253555,
-0.10646446794271469,
-0.4374341368675232,
-0.2881585657596588,
0.6849707961082458,
-0.2758272588253021,
-0.5857634544372559,
0.6464852690696716,
0.02926870435476303,
0.37763240933418274,
-0.2729576528072357,
0.2881487011909485,
0.2868083119392395,
-0.45737946033477783,
0.14367254078388214,
0.6716764569282532,
-0.22949521243572235,
-0.15618610382080078,
-0.04377760365605354,
0.5607925057411194,
0.1505550891160965,
0.7627093195915222,
-0.9812118411064148,
0.5947412252426147,
0.24486735463142395,
0.7160102128982544,
0.6626492738723755,
0.09882792085409164,
0.19949467480182648,
-1.021901249885559,
0.5029148459434509,
0.04452797770500183,
0.2881009578704834,
0.4592771530151367,
-0.8813654184341431,
0.44589170813560486,
0.45350220799446106,
-0.4849475622177124,
-0.9199175834655762,
0.23202304542064667,
-0.6453014612197876,
-0.042780451476573944,
0.482726514339447,
-0.08330562710762024,
0.11975123733282089,
-0.5991415977478027,
0.3352647125720978,
0.3789336681365967,
-0.5317285060882568,
1.215386152267456,
0.030101701617240906,
-0.764220118522644,
0.05862255021929741,
-0.30854326486587524,
0.3384886384010315,
0.18799495697021484,
-0.9249978065490723,
-0.1779893934726715,
0.1571115404367447,
0.3206229507923126,
0.0998997613787651,
0.12312944233417511,
0.16152088344097137,
0.41096746921539307,
-0.20184919238090515,
-0.4177863299846649,
-0.5048057436943054,
-0.1990637332201004,
-0.6829055547714233,
0.1423712819814682,
-0.26519888639450073,
-0.6745132207870483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12255v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12255v1
|
A Hopfieldian View-based Interpretation for Chain-of-Thought Reasoning
| 2024-06-18T04:07:13 | 2024-06-18T04:07:13 |
Lijie Hu, Liang Liu, Shu Yang, Xin Chen, Hongru Xiao, Mengdi Li, Pan Zhou, Muhammad Asif Ali, Di Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) holds a significant place in augmenting the reasoning
performance for large language models (LLMs). While some studies focus on
improving CoT accuracy through methods like retrieval enhancement, yet a
rigorous explanation for why CoT achieves such success remains unclear. In this
paper, we analyze CoT methods under two different settings by asking the
following questions: (1) For zero-shot CoT, why does prompting the model with
"let's think step by step" significantly impact its outputs? (2) For few-shot
CoT, why does providing examples before questioning the model could
substantially improve its reasoning ability? To answer these questions, we
conduct a top-down explainable analysis from the Hopfieldian view and propose a
Read-and-Control approach for controlling the accuracy of CoT. Through
extensive experiments on seven datasets for three different tasks, we
demonstrate that our framework can decipher the inner workings of CoT, provide
reasoning error localization, and control to come up with the correct reasoning
path.
|
[
-0.3552353084087372,
-0.8748387098312378,
0.9053955674171448,
-0.11860819905996323,
-0.22784937918186188,
0.37181827425956726,
-0.09257012605667114,
-0.5395563840866089,
0.10860847681760788,
0.6272457838058472,
-0.4568686783313751,
-0.30463358759880066,
-0.7098631858825684,
0.08938556909561157,
-0.28812992572784424,
0.987355649471283,
-0.5272948145866394,
-0.4450671672821045,
0.21036770939826965,
0.10413595288991928,
-0.610988974571228,
-0.392238974571228,
-0.588434636592865,
-0.21375338733196259,
0.7116611003875732,
0.33162468671798706,
1.0301200151443481,
0.5514280200004578,
0.5326470732688904,
0.08719735592603683,
-0.5880123972892761,
0.4146013557910919,
-0.5214651226997375,
0.052213627845048904,
-0.44013917446136475,
-0.9603906869888306,
-0.4849851727485657,
0.024468325078487396,
0.3084820806980133,
0.7179328203201294,
0.08853936940431595,
0.0034275418147444725,
-0.06644203513860703,
0.6378254890441895,
-1.1856963634490967,
-0.26994213461875916,
-0.585328996181488,
0.07097943872213364,
0.14182572066783905,
-0.3203364908695221,
-0.7156493067741394,
-0.21497930586338043,
0.05551585182547569,
-0.205064594745636,
0.03547285124659538,
0.28530749678611755,
0.34477731585502625,
-0.026169458404183388,
-0.6651152968406677,
-0.3945755362510681,
-0.82662034034729,
0.7161824107170105,
-0.6030671000480652,
0.3589623272418976,
0.5806246995925903,
0.07092597335577011,
-0.39911749958992004,
-0.3099512755870819,
-0.7286038398742676,
-0.10734447836875916,
-0.26391467452049255,
0.11634892970323563,
0.06618453562259674,
0.13281264901161194,
0.4314056932926178,
0.29438382387161255,
-0.35905197262763977,
-0.3644793927669525,
-0.25500568747520447,
0.1897815465927124,
0.510888397693634,
0.18464267253875732,
-0.04996916279196739,
0.04301103204488754,
-0.4771347939968109,
0.013863892294466496,
-0.5872029066085815,
0.16394607722759247,
-0.035525619983673096,
0.2676655054092407,
-0.02499995566904545,
0.49021321535110474,
-0.13365627825260162,
1.009647011756897,
0.10494186729192734,
0.19105008244514465,
-0.20532886683940887,
-0.2910177707672119,
-0.5342745780944824,
0.004689323250204325,
0.5576673746109009,
0.12371736019849777,
0.2270204722881317,
-0.22907285392284393,
-0.0261614378541708,
-0.05077383294701576,
0.5993984341621399,
-0.4992409646511078,
0.16011279821395874,
0.6231317520141602,
-0.2768653631210327,
-0.6139149069786072,
0.08297472447156906,
-0.44356903433799744,
-0.3806033432483673,
-0.18260829150676727,
0.34513717889785767,
-0.417329341173172,
-0.2971718907356262,
0.29432782530784607,
-0.052351802587509155,
0.3007110059261322,
0.5095500349998474,
-0.8069269061088562,
0.4221577048301697,
0.6950138807296753,
0.8906120657920837,
-0.2981031537055969,
-0.38795340061187744,
-0.6007062792778015,
0.28763461112976074,
-1.1806639432907104,
0.8219391107559204,
-0.4862583875656128,
-0.09501458704471588,
-0.23336461186408997,
-0.30569595098495483,
-0.1965264081954956,
-0.19589674472808838,
-0.12095367163419724,
-0.6381146311759949,
0.05732446163892746,
-0.4419560432434082,
-0.5131397247314453,
-0.042176298797130585,
0.5263119339942932,
-0.4449673891067505,
0.6535168290138245,
-0.1811947226524353,
-0.9696356058120728,
0.5232403874397278,
-0.3604453206062317,
-0.14415104687213898,
-0.15951190888881683,
-0.42507249116897583,
0.24596840143203735,
0.3423563241958618,
0.3037317097187042,
0.18325699865818024,
-0.2734518051147461,
0.20044872164726257,
-0.17239968478679657,
-0.5224327445030212,
0.4096052050590515,
-0.4789181053638458,
0.8665083050727844,
0.2657042145729065,
-0.608025074005127,
0.1010359451174736,
-0.5313013792037964,
0.36129558086395264,
-0.14994795620441437,
-0.02753540687263012,
-0.27600520849227905,
0.05136483535170555,
-0.48356693983078003,
0.21358995139598846,
-0.3132159113883972,
-0.2398870587348938,
0.344899982213974,
-0.33540523052215576,
0.08139616996049881,
0.5997741222381592,
0.31458935141563416,
0.4157201945781708,
-0.4255877137184143,
0.6663486957550049,
0.17645125091075897,
0.33226069808006287,
-0.04846390709280968,
-0.2715218961238861,
-0.5167420506477356,
-0.10846968740224838,
0.09203080087900162,
0.3172808289527893,
-0.6304061412811279,
0.11672674864530563,
0.21627548336982727,
-0.2825380265712738,
-0.33238643407821655,
-0.06341780722141266,
0.3365846276283264,
0.5986587405204773,
0.34873878955841064,
-0.1899968683719635,
-0.05109434574842453,
-0.5433139801025391,
-0.4467320144176483,
-0.35254746675491333,
0.2333970069885254,
0.08156084269285202,
0.4551607668399811,
0.04831802472472191,
0.8676788210868835,
-0.3815900385379791,
0.30009645223617554,
-0.4194716811180115,
0.10160846263170242,
0.554743230342865,
0.34258896112442017,
0.03749885782599449,
-0.62635737657547,
-0.13468368351459503,
0.11523645371198654,
-0.695029616355896,
0.14068275690078735,
-0.46475303173065186,
-0.7931349277496338,
0.030889352783560753,
0.4717480540275574,
-0.549000084400177,
1.0004194974899292,
0.07929236441850662,
-0.5323998928070068,
0.6940765976905823,
-0.15804722905158997,
0.4113350510597229,
-0.6886186599731445,
-0.15950854122638702,
-0.4968675971031189,
-0.3232634961605072,
-0.4564219117164612,
0.48203930258750916,
0.07281792908906937,
0.40703657269477844,
-0.429657518863678,
0.03820022940635681,
-0.3012179136276245,
-0.030906109139323235,
-0.49205297231674194,
0.3751367926597595,
0.2584632635116577,
0.3784812092781067,
0.24112260341644287,
0.7544576525688171,
0.5091066360473633,
-0.7407504320144653,
0.1777622401714325,
0.4675654470920563,
-0.16812582314014435,
0.38513731956481934,
-0.4181508719921112,
0.31019413471221924,
-0.2300119549036026,
0.5386553406715393,
-0.9036453366279602,
0.03388785570859909,
0.25170356035232544,
-0.2830200493335724,
0.00783564243465662,
0.07573438435792923,
-0.14753152430057526,
-0.1327735036611557,
-0.2707861661911011,
0.39977315068244934,
0.180946484208107,
-0.7656381130218506,
0.5063751339912415,
-0.13518115878105164,
0.27084681391716003,
-0.7842854261398315,
-0.7644042372703552,
-0.14104270935058594,
-0.05912616476416588,
-0.16010716557502747,
0.11611726135015488,
0.12864604592323303,
-0.5525830984115601,
-0.17537418007850647,
-0.5301932692527771,
0.02942012809216976,
-0.1106635257601738,
-0.03548845276236534,
0.47913914918899536,
0.05213235691189766,
0.4553906321525574,
0.006519270595163107,
-0.01155856903642416,
0.1487530618906021,
-0.48354005813598633,
0.42277058959007263,
-0.18664155900478363,
-0.17292888462543488,
-0.3230589032173157,
0.29800286889076233,
0.5553170442581177,
-0.22952263057231903,
0.8643145561218262,
-0.10850854218006134,
-0.21747621893882751,
-0.46245864033699036,
-0.26096174120903015,
0.1278267204761505,
-0.35901540517807007,
-0.1384098380804062,
-0.5681278109550476,
-0.4973083734512329,
0.34919384121894836,
-0.1650448590517044,
0.08568159490823746,
0.31612059473991394,
0.6126512289047241,
-0.42846399545669556,
0.7524497509002686,
0.41513195633888245,
0.15851420164108276,
0.17295649647712708,
-0.5949659943580627,
0.358218789100647,
-1.0664727687835693,
-0.3555099368095398,
-0.34352907538414,
-0.2934577465057373,
-0.5756513476371765,
-0.5740403532981873,
0.12495201081037521,
0.5617942214012146,
-0.48841431736946106,
0.504944384098053,
-0.347262978553772,
0.5644325613975525,
0.24995861947536469,
0.3364662826061249,
0.6010147333145142,
-0.30328595638275146,
-0.5486838817596436,
0.5162325501441956,
-0.7864617705345154,
-0.6895999908447266,
0.8675858974456787,
0.14141316711902618,
1.0735281705856323,
0.11281933635473251,
0.681311845779419,
0.18612170219421387,
-0.03789083659648895,
-0.836109459400177,
0.25561946630477905,
0.3810414969921112,
-0.8630533218383789,
-0.19901731610298157,
-0.37837594747543335,
-0.6025537848472595,
0.4482063055038452,
-0.2121347039937973,
-1.1166149377822876,
0.4107958972454071,
0.4565233290195465,
-0.42794057726860046,
0.640839159488678,
-0.47356465458869934,
0.6692401170730591,
-0.4550924599170685,
-0.6834054589271545,
-0.3677174150943756,
-0.6253734827041626,
0.2707962393760681,
0.054679300636053085,
0.37075021862983704,
0.4605535566806793,
-0.07351513206958771,
0.4758087694644928,
-0.6842556595802307,
0.592331051826477,
0.31878843903541565,
-0.2502506971359253,
0.7189148664474487,
0.5187153816223145,
0.667774498462677,
-0.10203363746404648,
0.02551097236573696,
0.03208158165216446,
0.38839152455329895,
-0.46034225821495056,
-0.9316226243972778,
0.3486775755882263,
-0.4751531481742859,
-0.6732420325279236,
-0.6506585478782654,
-0.7113946080207825,
-0.5375232696533203,
0.00706045376136899,
0.3145257830619812,
0.5082891583442688,
0.24905700981616974,
-0.06119362264871597,
0.37452951073646545,
-0.19615386426448822,
0.24343612790107727,
-0.016088396310806274,
-0.8646706342697144,
-0.13015757501125336,
0.2846292555332184,
-0.04266463220119476,
0.8743403553962708,
0.5615368485450745,
0.14253924787044525,
-0.12944164872169495,
-0.38981521129608154,
-0.2768101692199707,
0.12704098224639893,
-0.738720178604126,
0.0958826020359993,
-0.4782674312591553,
-0.025502396747469902,
-0.1903916746377945,
-0.27082642912864685,
-0.3391779959201813,
-0.305586576461792,
0.184766486287117,
-0.43180617690086365,
0.26487916707992554,
0.9094655513763428,
0.08632436394691467,
0.3892888128757477,
-0.25959447026252747,
0.34495824575424194,
0.11867497116327286,
0.6308892965316772,
0.27898404002189636,
-0.27539944648742676,
-0.18292304873466492,
0.01861456409096718,
-0.36016735434532166,
-0.9019383788108826,
-0.010290484875440598,
-0.4751989245414734,
0.13749945163726807,
0.3058255612850189,
0.025538843125104904,
0.9232080578804016,
-0.3486935794353485,
0.5628112554550171,
0.16265127062797546,
-1.04818856716156,
0.8842275738716125,
0.05005413293838501,
0.33333662152290344,
0.5459379553794861,
0.48900657892227173,
-0.37519195675849915,
-0.500898540019989,
-0.610466480255127,
-0.5586440563201904,
0.6478577852249146,
0.4846699833869934,
-0.2777203619480133,
-0.20250502228736877,
0.5110756754875183,
0.15070025622844696,
-0.017061160877346992,
-0.3279537856578827,
0.14494553208351135,
0.22617042064666748,
0.12858480215072632,
0.15055757761001587,
-0.05291907489299774,
0.02397497557103634,
-0.08795420825481415,
0.6307814717292786,
-0.07980085164308548,
0.21450337767601013,
0.5879979133605957,
-0.12402192503213882,
-0.4043594300746918,
0.39726272225379944,
0.3271041810512543,
1.1978925466537476,
-0.4795059263706207,
0.4518370032310486,
0.2509081959724426,
-0.42780157923698425,
0.19552451372146606,
-0.734714150428772,
-0.19792142510414124,
-0.14006160199642181,
0.965475857257843,
0.9165343046188354,
-0.26565369963645935,
-0.5540838241577148,
0.33248424530029297,
0.019828839227557182,
-0.09184501320123672,
-0.08348414301872253,
0.4219752550125122,
-0.15500029921531677,
0.3890937268733978,
0.09786386042833328,
0.2888854146003723,
0.07688389718532562,
-0.8088998794555664,
0.13706742227077484,
0.3325735032558441,
-0.5537995100021362,
0.07241318374872208,
0.5464873909950256,
-0.23522575199604034,
-0.359772264957428,
0.5086930394172668,
0.13339389860630035,
-0.42680633068084717,
0.5572172403335571,
0.6215329170227051,
0.6617569923400879,
0.3663704991340637,
0.27023032307624817,
0.15927563607692719,
0.4736347794532776,
-0.08041145652532578,
0.4370037913322449,
-0.39521992206573486,
-0.8876478672027588,
-0.7547154426574707,
-0.30293938517570496,
-0.6414963603019714,
0.12436187267303467,
-1.026100754737854,
0.1380743682384491,
-0.577397346496582,
-0.21215756237506866,
-0.11994210630655289,
-0.16906149685382843,
-0.6207829713821411,
0.5106754899024963,
0.0635269358754158,
1.2733234167099,
-0.4642230272293091,
0.562190055847168,
0.2052728235721588,
-0.5000295639038086,
-1.1340328454971313,
0.5702787637710571,
-0.21616502106189728,
-0.6040418744087219,
0.45060476660728455,
-0.037441711872816086,
-0.662282407283783,
-0.16358710825443268,
-0.6831973791122437,
-0.798034131526947,
0.917050838470459,
0.021437618881464005,
-0.973875105381012,
-0.16596031188964844,
-0.2903170883655548,
0.45420345664024353,
-0.5177463889122009,
0.5768666863441467,
0.8380110263824463,
0.028251199051737785,
0.41351860761642456,
-0.8262531757354736,
-0.017343079671263695,
0.17249834537506104,
0.07049032300710678,
0.324847936630249,
-0.39765188097953796,
0.4909895062446594,
-0.6872112154960632,
0.1679811030626297,
-0.28993305563926697,
0.40589168667793274,
0.47827959060668945,
0.2512557804584503,
0.5256455540657043,
0.24035781621932983,
0.8010784983634949,
0.2856901288032532,
1.5749783515930176,
0.009206559509038925,
0.4491625130176544,
1.3108975887298584,
-0.259452223777771,
0.9653412103652954,
0.7308720350265503,
-0.4145987033843994,
0.7841530442237854,
0.4751379191875458,
0.5990614295005798,
0.5695860385894775,
0.16089586913585663,
-0.13175880908966064,
-0.3573334515094757,
0.1980777531862259,
-0.037594862282276154,
0.5715530514717102,
0.20859579741954803,
-0.5432037711143494,
0.0009734683553688228,
-0.1182255670428276,
-0.10875151306390762,
-0.09455297887325287,
-0.5155666470527649,
0.6046484708786011,
0.026740290224552155,
-0.7597529888153076,
0.763571560382843,
-0.47881588339805603,
0.1461361050605774,
-0.30444541573524475,
-0.06616208702325821,
-0.023850442841649055,
0.2556007206439972,
-0.10664179176092148,
-0.8169119358062744,
0.4056665003299713,
0.4477248787879944,
-0.041273459792137146,
-0.1022675633430481,
0.471990168094635,
-0.11188890039920807,
-0.5674208998680115,
0.4076198935508728,
0.6751240491867065,
0.35090529918670654,
0.10058680176734924,
-0.37802332639694214,
0.2587036192417145,
-0.14725224673748016,
-0.31772878766059875,
-0.2014070302248001,
0.5043875575065613,
-0.4490374028682709,
0.476148784160614,
0.335184246301651,
0.592144250869751,
-0.11825573444366455,
0.07511531561613083,
0.7190941572189331,
-0.9661882519721985,
-0.4569322168827057,
-1.0201239585876465,
0.3829476833343506,
-0.09767170250415802,
-0.33690908551216125,
0.07282596081495285,
0.29226455092430115,
0.9826709628105164,
0.20340067148208618,
0.8341713547706604,
-0.272026389837265,
0.42029446363449097,
-0.5990473628044128,
0.5308736562728882,
-0.3500894606113434,
0.280341237783432,
-0.3855268359184265,
-0.7133352756500244,
-0.2513434588909149,
0.9536398649215698,
-0.6796683669090271,
0.0556742399930954,
1.3030608892440796,
0.4934765100479126,
0.08323638886213303,
0.27416032552719116,
0.45713675022125244,
0.5724826455116272,
0.40089279413223267,
0.6494221091270447,
0.950944721698761,
-0.44152164459228516,
0.29730871319770813,
-0.2794877290725708,
-0.5430322289466858,
0.36520916223526,
-1.011177659034729,
-0.844801664352417,
-0.20273669064044952,
-0.2898435592651367,
-0.489198237657547,
0.09377127885818481,
1.0989798307418823,
0.5167009830474854,
-0.9977734088897705,
-0.33975350856781006,
-0.6681996583938599,
0.2094097137451172,
-0.5953545570373535,
-0.11962691694498062,
0.45218756794929504,
-0.6043850183486938,
-0.32650792598724365,
0.12795846164226532,
0.4806077480316162,
-0.3979485332965851,
0.08605808764696121,
0.010038229636847973,
-0.5782414674758911,
0.3618142902851105,
0.5985051393508911,
-0.20679005980491638,
-0.9580591917037964,
-0.42367345094680786,
0.008593791164457798,
-0.032666195183992386,
0.007848037406802177,
0.9344232678413391,
-1.0424394607543945,
0.8242850303649902,
0.29859235882759094,
0.4973428249359131,
0.6793971657752991,
0.22796835005283356,
0.6491450667381287,
-0.12700167298316956,
-0.08271101117134094,
0.15781418979167938,
0.20719324052333832,
-0.15355484187602997,
-0.569161593914032,
0.6401910781860352,
-0.003744435729458928,
-0.44534027576446533,
-0.5029117465019226,
0.3580258786678314,
-0.905102014541626,
-0.4061620831489563,
0.9368319511413574,
-0.10688420385122299,
-0.3423278033733368,
0.07041165232658386,
-0.5077933073043823,
0.41721928119659424,
0.10735076665878296,
0.808872640132904,
0.8603057265281677,
-0.7400794625282288,
-0.29140588641166687,
-0.40916723012924194,
0.3380616307258606,
0.20866380631923676,
-0.7520654797554016,
0.28240641951560974,
0.3691212832927704,
0.10824853181838989,
0.1302834004163742,
0.7540979981422424,
-0.11637891083955765,
0.25362226366996765,
0.03811195120215416,
-0.34320127964019775,
0.1304219365119934,
-0.6000379920005798,
-0.1712801307439804,
-0.010533391498029232,
0.1342587172985077,
-0.23711226880550385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12252v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12252v1
|
Language and Multimodal Models in Sports: A Survey of Datasets and Applications
| 2024-06-18T03:59:26 | 2024-06-18T03:59:26 |
Haotian Xia, Zhengbang Yang, Yun Zhao, Yuqing Wang, Jingxi Li, Rhys Tracy, Zhuangdi Zhu, Yuan-fang Wang, Hanjie Chen, Weining Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent integration of Natural Language Processing (NLP) and multimodal models
has advanced the field of sports analytics. This survey presents a
comprehensive review of the datasets and applications driving these innovations
post-2020. We overviewed and categorized datasets into three primary types:
language-based, multimodal, and convertible datasets. Language-based and
multimodal datasets are for tasks involving text or multimodality (e.g., text,
video, audio), respectively. Convertible datasets, initially single-modal
(video), can be enriched with additional annotations, such as explanations of
actions and video descriptions, to become multimodal, offering future potential
for richer and more diverse applications. Our study highlights the
contributions of these datasets to various applications, from improving fan
experiences to supporting tactical analysis and medical diagnostics. We also
discuss the challenges and future directions in dataset development,
emphasizing the need for diverse, high-quality data to support real-time
processing and personalized user experiences. This survey provides a
foundational resource for researchers and practitioners aiming to leverage NLP
and multimodal models in sports, offering insights into current trends and
future opportunities in the field.
|
[
-0.309501588344574,
-0.5919793844223022,
0.12425928562879562,
0.3532369136810303,
0.14610473811626434,
0.3697567880153656,
-0.1530008316040039,
-0.7464549541473389,
0.2908688485622406,
0.14823931455612183,
-1.0006744861602783,
-0.49484989047050476,
-0.5159562230110168,
-0.08074301481246948,
-0.34810811281204224,
0.9763320088386536,
-0.20609989762306213,
0.294973224401474,
-0.49808719754219055,
-0.5526745915412903,
-0.7547134160995483,
-0.8989107012748718,
-0.5350464582443237,
-0.29465624690055847,
0.17056456208229065,
0.04690859839320183,
0.5174707174301147,
0.42115381360054016,
0.9453390836715698,
0.29274314641952515,
0.34400472044944763,
0.25645262002944946,
-0.3469151556491852,
0.6438026428222656,
0.02568218484520912,
-0.12084337323904037,
-0.7331940531730652,
0.22982287406921387,
0.6707194447517395,
0.9821819067001343,
0.0015714498003944755,
0.17783738672733307,
-0.32484450936317444,
0.5214356780052185,
-0.5600733160972595,
0.4298224449157715,
-0.054508108645677567,
0.2537202537059784,
-0.26291680335998535,
-0.5044754147529602,
0.036530252546072006,
-0.18674443662166595,
-0.004252081271260977,
-0.6204160451889038,
0.25698208808898926,
0.05564847216010094,
0.2055746614933014,
0.10329023748636246,
-0.5771026015281677,
-0.34725281596183777,
-0.9709043502807617,
0.9933019280433655,
-0.562094509601593,
0.8663228750228882,
0.28960689902305603,
0.5208130478858948,
0.07518470287322998,
-0.2491932511329651,
-0.22488132119178772,
-0.08066502213478088,
0.07151854038238525,
0.3555355370044708,
-0.14385706186294556,
0.018528321757912636,
0.11940361559391022,
0.10441424697637558,
-0.7090445160865784,
0.1344066858291626,
-0.22756369411945343,
0.13332480192184448,
1.0270224809646606,
0.6550143361091614,
0.3641861379146576,
0.23340150713920593,
-0.09272212535142899,
-0.10068317502737045,
-0.37571537494659424,
0.1677703857421875,
0.24409620463848114,
0.3116682171821594,
-0.2341698557138443,
0.7016274929046631,
-0.6672763228416443,
0.8162181973457336,
-0.5167086720466614,
-0.4451618194580078,
0.37263599038124084,
-0.710522472858429,
-0.11861592531204224,
-0.054700542241334915,
0.6749280691146851,
0.7019765377044678,
0.12612344324588776,
-0.49791601300239563,
0.004445603117346764,
0.004887313582003117,
-0.2909402549266815,
-0.5627289414405823,
-0.20959770679473877,
0.3680262267589569,
-0.6639233827590942,
-0.24668656289577484,
0.07612183690071106,
-0.9754815697669983,
-0.5083746910095215,
-0.6107308268547058,
0.026361150667071342,
-0.3098030984401703,
-0.29192960262298584,
0.4122389853000641,
-0.4128649830818176,
0.25947505235671997,
0.14130431413650513,
-0.8245392441749573,
0.47828903794288635,
0.46240195631980896,
0.568668782711029,
-0.08722882717847824,
-0.2555627226829529,
-0.34273841977119446,
0.2452852576971054,
-0.3129447102546692,
0.9770543575286865,
-0.7250496745109558,
-0.10816866904497147,
0.6096518635749817,
-0.1535542905330658,
-0.06037452444434166,
-0.3554966151714325,
0.3165239989757538,
-0.31185582280158997,
0.2323456108570099,
-0.054080743342638016,
-0.485864520072937,
-0.4002212882041931,
0.5133851766586304,
-0.9140282869338989,
0.9240071177482605,
-0.15549784898757935,
-0.46747156977653503,
0.7280516028404236,
-1.09738290309906,
-0.6234162449836731,
-0.2071274369955063,
-0.054823536425828934,
-0.3574856221675873,
0.1140456572175026,
0.2945896089076996,
0.6285315752029419,
-0.4592721164226532,
0.15136200189590454,
-0.7149674296379089,
-0.08568879961967468,
0.4224516451358795,
-0.41170579195022583,
0.5335360169410706,
0.11131942272186279,
0.27448025345802307,
-0.1417563110589981,
-0.7483541965484619,
-0.029638107866048813,
-0.06594517827033997,
-0.22544458508491516,
0.031192906200885773,
0.5464922785758972,
0.4069967567920685,
0.4850696921348572,
0.047016043215990067,
-0.456924170255661,
0.17606106400489807,
0.06563448905944824,
0.16974325478076935,
0.33462151885032654,
-0.06065164506435394,
0.47405606508255005,
-0.15776130557060242,
0.8537161946296692,
0.05387864261865616,
0.35807517170906067,
-0.24836385250091553,
-0.5109471678733826,
-0.07594534754753113,
-0.10466036200523376,
0.15753136575222015,
0.5585567355155945,
-0.7595850825309753,
0.005839566234499216,
-0.5685815215110779,
-0.6055225729942322,
-0.257750928401947,
0.11782828718423843,
-0.12997844815254211,
0.3967134356498718,
0.2629619538784027,
0.1726510226726532,
-0.7965238690376282,
-0.7389095425605774,
-0.3506007790565491,
-0.18110787868499756,
0.3891931474208832,
0.3433094024658203,
0.37694838643074036,
0.08210194110870361,
0.841395378112793,
-0.6532317399978638,
-0.2725856602191925,
-0.5403416752815247,
0.14913804829120636,
0.21131280064582825,
0.5411373376846313,
1.0842409133911133,
-1.0637006759643555,
-0.4963899254798889,
-0.024658365175127983,
-1.1078546047210693,
-0.017612066119909286,
-0.02702639438211918,
0.29243409633636475,
-0.14294523000717163,
0.17644010484218597,
-0.2900198996067047,
0.3861066997051239,
1.0318210124969482,
-0.5428162813186646,
0.549166738986969,
0.020713811740279198,
0.7543789148330688,
-0.7122175693511963,
0.2687307298183441,
0.13776659965515137,
-0.23773148655891418,
-0.9431601762771606,
-0.3219815492630005,
-0.45674073696136475,
-0.13580816984176636,
-0.4001936614513397,
0.627785861492157,
-0.460498183965683,
-0.24186360836029053,
-0.3913055658340454,
-0.2924646735191345,
0.08639731258153915,
0.10186443477869034,
0.397375226020813,
0.5583041906356812,
0.6397596001625061,
-0.6748324632644653,
0.8264515399932861,
0.3860462009906769,
-0.38625362515449524,
0.46945446729660034,
-0.3405996263027191,
-0.27362167835235596,
-0.41792526841163635,
0.2929631471633911,
-0.7954230904579163,
-0.5541899800300598,
0.3640972077846527,
-0.22807279229164124,
0.15070737898349762,
0.028981268405914307,
-0.46978527307510376,
-0.4325850009918213,
-0.43617281317710876,
0.8314252495765686,
-0.042345304042100906,
-0.05394956097006798,
0.6132927536964417,
0.6648943424224854,
-0.23498475551605225,
-0.4335222840309143,
-0.6928960084915161,
0.17562395334243774,
-0.2131478637456894,
-0.38254380226135254,
0.15146301686763763,
-0.3845735192298889,
-0.19477912783622742,
-0.006364790722727776,
0.11764439940452576,
-0.7516036629676819,
0.15222305059432983,
0.0022075767628848553,
0.4013478755950928,
-0.2498263567686081,
0.18310406804084778,
-0.30033406615257263,
0.15529485046863556,
-0.2350374311208725,
0.1020236387848854,
0.3682440221309662,
0.14355328679084778,
-0.04352099820971489,
-0.5384587645530701,
0.867981493473053,
0.2382885068655014,
-0.16500885784626007,
0.7578778266906738,
0.5388472080230713,
-0.18023070693016052,
0.13189156353473663,
-0.3756519854068756,
-0.11283426731824875,
-0.3339728116989136,
0.5290416479110718,
-0.2504400908946991,
-0.8000603318214417,
0.46586695313453674,
0.07406166195869446,
0.15028934180736542,
0.21963846683502197,
0.5399777889251709,
-0.6244107484817505,
1.3295769691467285,
0.31007540225982666,
-0.16495290398597717,
0.5459644198417664,
-0.17508426308631897,
0.06490401923656464,
-0.4247935712337494,
-0.4234303832054138,
-0.5999237298965454,
-0.5945965051651001,
-0.43520238995552063,
-0.11965925246477127,
0.14530523121356964,
-0.31091806292533875,
-0.017235931009054184,
0.3391532599925995,
-0.13225898146629333,
0.6266156435012817,
0.18415142595767975,
-0.05941477417945862,
0.30155616998672485,
-0.2623589336872101,
0.7720747590065002,
-0.44744178652763367,
-0.8417564034461975,
0.06131098419427872,
0.9928780198097229,
0.2499352991580963,
0.7260543704032898,
0.41149505972862244,
0.28054147958755493,
0.5872074365615845,
0.20131030678749084,
-0.8509666323661804,
0.19391581416130066,
-0.40757641196250916,
-1.2364128828048706,
-0.17840197682380676,
-0.29056060314178467,
-0.7211672067642212,
0.0125776631757617,
-0.44887879490852356,
-0.32841429114341736,
0.37031397223472595,
0.1724047213792801,
-0.2262292206287384,
0.3362388014793396,
-0.5471736192703247,
0.48033982515335083,
-0.27693605422973633,
-0.31684765219688416,
0.27917802333831787,
-0.2617279291152954,
0.6353519558906555,
-0.04881427437067032,
0.5302993655204773,
-0.41312167048454285,
-0.13491222262382507,
0.9840457439422607,
0.03280163183808327,
0.6636092066764832,
-0.20422214269638062,
0.049348361790180206,
0.17269669473171234,
-0.043331217020750046,
0.00009900705481413752,
-0.016084738075733185,
-0.1658293455839157,
0.1587096005678177,
0.3142410218715668,
-0.45025959610939026,
-0.6817549467086792,
0.4376615881919861,
-0.3534516394138336,
-0.14506344497203827,
-0.5774227380752563,
-0.6230853199958801,
-0.7398520112037659,
0.0003063848416786641,
-0.20652861893177032,
0.7218310832977295,
-0.2761520743370056,
0.5736740231513977,
0.2804272174835205,
-0.01499876193702221,
0.7895652651786804,
0.4235466420650482,
-0.3045105040073395,
-0.36206597089767456,
0.8615992069244385,
0.279229074716568,
-0.27888235449790955,
0.40922877192497253,
0.009092164225876331,
-0.6360769867897034,
-0.7696385979652405,
0.036182958632707596,
0.05700594559311867,
-0.46688541769981384,
-0.3823543190956116,
-0.16404321789741516,
0.08673067390918732,
-0.7208132147789001,
0.2058238387107849,
-0.4432038962841034,
-0.448703795671463,
0.017266368493437767,
-0.1977083832025528,
0.4034823179244995,
0.8317705392837524,
-0.182582288980484,
0.38540613651275635,
-0.8250063061714172,
0.46530792117118835,
-0.06803708523511887,
0.8299018740653992,
-0.272647887468338,
-0.18242397904396057,
-0.4143182933330536,
0.0644063800573349,
0.052428871393203735,
-0.8108841180801392,
0.48778215050697327,
0.44019368290901184,
0.6188012957572937,
0.40886741876602173,
-0.414373517036438,
0.6073004603385925,
-0.6024384498596191,
1.0550036430358887,
0.3932182490825653,
-0.3609955608844757,
0.29322102665901184,
-0.7091750502586365,
-0.023371173068881035,
0.7779720425605774,
0.48377710580825806,
-0.8829169273376465,
0.43331751227378845,
-0.16386687755584717,
-0.40616074204444885,
0.8622678518295288,
-0.05078249052166939,
0.16177710890769958,
0.13262537121772766,
0.08756764233112335,
0.278291791677475,
0.4617958664894104,
-0.4026847183704376,
-0.21038754284381866,
-0.3189041018486023,
-0.30184951424598694,
-0.3798998296260834,
0.23748019337654114,
-0.09298968315124512,
-0.29995131492614746,
0.5003232359886169,
-0.20059633255004883,
0.22729048132896423,
-0.2960605025291443,
-0.0015457477420568466,
0.24042387306690216,
-0.08250319212675095,
0.6767686605453491,
0.6791706681251526,
-0.33271467685699463,
-0.26532694697380066,
-0.09387040883302689,
-0.37826257944107056,
0.14794033765792847,
0.006371863652020693,
-0.009105969220399857,
0.1586284190416336,
0.6682066321372986,
0.6606043577194214,
0.4324808120727539,
-0.767805814743042,
0.47746530175209045,
0.12217123806476593,
-0.4336741864681244,
-0.050850361585617065,
-0.3888404965400696,
-0.14250576496124268,
0.1448206901550293,
0.11260649561882019,
0.10401197522878647,
0.5500181913375854,
-0.7211799621582031,
0.0650998130440712,
0.4407050907611847,
-0.3616488575935364,
-0.593737006187439,
0.8163298964500427,
0.2122088223695755,
0.05842495337128639,
0.27777114510536194,
0.4871680438518524,
-0.15224827826023102,
0.17277675867080688,
0.2868468463420868,
0.5558544397354126,
-0.05153508484363556,
0.4230479896068573,
0.059137992560863495,
-0.2220839560031891,
0.023683080449700356,
0.3453250825405121,
0.03307737037539482,
-0.793850839138031,
-0.6001103520393372,
-0.5101268887519836,
-0.342868447303772,
0.02690020762383938,
-0.5714325308799744,
-0.03699619323015213,
-0.07587117701768875,
-0.513501763343811,
0.28085553646087646,
-0.08335552364587784,
-1.1510014533996582,
0.5195707678794861,
0.5356626510620117,
0.9318931102752686,
-1.0009280443191528,
0.6241110563278198,
0.8574045300483704,
-0.8359355330467224,
-0.10922793298959732,
-0.4966566264629364,
0.12848792970180511,
-0.42604365944862366,
0.9099016189575195,
-0.4106494188308716,
0.1911514848470688,
-0.21416442096233368,
-0.45941805839538574,
-0.3733642101287842,
0.8424445986747742,
0.04042170196771622,
0.03806488215923309,
-0.327764093875885,
0.6737930178642273,
0.2194613665342331,
-0.32119277119636536,
0.2776830494403839,
0.7338413596153259,
0.5197789669036865,
-0.03802325576543808,
-0.7171617746353149,
-0.6088161468505859,
-0.14525896310806274,
-0.08330672979354858,
0.01597905531525612,
-0.7477394938468933,
0.5269511342048645,
0.4576977491378784,
0.20978710055351257,
-0.13756869733333588,
0.5714953541755676,
0.10206293314695358,
0.28461024165153503,
0.10730552673339844,
0.2782682180404663,
0.35212013125419617,
-0.2221243679523468,
1.0885181427001953,
-0.06600205600261688,
0.3456207811832428,
0.872891902923584,
-0.5588100552558899,
0.5733757019042969,
0.4160865545272827,
-0.3122950494289398,
0.24169716238975525,
0.34176817536354065,
-0.10756117850542068,
0.4327678680419922,
-0.27371931076049805,
-0.3551933169364929,
-0.43301236629486084,
-0.25016531348228455,
-0.31228873133659363,
0.9522311091423035,
0.22258859872817993,
-0.1659327745437622,
-0.5378302931785583,
0.36829298734664917,
-0.015524652786552906,
-0.02311871387064457,
-0.2184317260980606,
0.963589608669281,
-0.40099725127220154,
-0.452128142118454,
-0.23449888825416565,
-0.08898699283599854,
0.6042271852493286,
-0.8542404174804688,
-0.2181989848613739,
-0.11749342828989029,
0.06366129964590073,
-0.07140574604272842,
-1.1301953792572021,
0.34710726141929626,
-0.030909372493624687,
-0.42118772864341736,
-0.5544982552528381,
0.8037421703338623,
-0.32015419006347656,
-0.5531373620033264,
0.015568559058010578,
0.584338366985321,
0.17254920303821564,
-0.0036736787296831608,
-0.7514990568161011,
0.24869005382061005,
-0.2813689708709717,
-0.2115452140569687,
0.20245595276355743,
0.17073114216327667,
0.05584981292486191,
0.6302452683448792,
0.5815168619155884,
0.33526214957237244,
0.4453423321247101,
0.13619060814380646,
0.5663970112800598,
-0.6782689094543457,
-0.23245233297348022,
-0.5819352269172668,
0.5390633344650269,
-0.18272416293621063,
-0.3498725891113281,
0.7634233832359314,
1.0605412721633911,
0.44118359684944153,
-0.40617871284484863,
0.9662266373634338,
-0.08640686422586441,
0.6372910737991333,
-0.5181803703308105,
0.6828730702400208,
-0.49011364579200745,
-0.2913871705532074,
0.04164433851838112,
-0.6187557578086853,
-0.7381042838096619,
0.1513521820306778,
-0.13475234806537628,
0.02512126974761486,
0.20198363065719604,
0.10265032947063446,
-0.08215417712926865,
0.26147493720054626,
0.3371225893497467,
-0.27801820635795593,
0.5893506407737732,
0.17215827107429504,
0.6484086513519287,
-0.6889153122901917,
0.371673583984375,
-0.22517216205596924,
-0.23336464166641235,
-0.48045703768730164,
-0.7759509682655334,
-0.7934297323226929,
-0.6889586448669434,
-0.3784675598144531,
-0.051103632897138596,
0.10211815685033798,
0.8519319295883179,
0.8086904287338257,
-1.080426573753357,
-0.4296726882457733,
0.4518314003944397,
-0.46797701716423035,
-0.43088099360466003,
-0.1725616753101349,
0.19172507524490356,
-0.3977647125720978,
-0.9455876350402832,
0.5229582190513611,
0.15077313780784607,
-0.03886760026216507,
-0.12864086031913757,
0.006155568175017834,
-0.48891547322273254,
0.010710550472140312,
0.9616760015487671,
0.7671518325805664,
-0.3872435986995697,
-0.172495499253273,
0.30569398403167725,
0.27725812792778015,
0.10774878412485123,
0.9846827387809753,
-0.7943994402885437,
0.58473801612854,
0.8545430898666382,
0.5003363490104675,
0.2987131178379059,
0.07163270562887192,
0.6960468292236328,
-0.6705442667007446,
0.2013922929763794,
0.49793460965156555,
0.1761973798274994,
0.05344284698367119,
0.24093197286128998,
0.5222009420394897,
0.5672900676727295,
-0.15169040858745575,
-0.7557278871536255,
-0.016150759533047676,
-0.9531484246253967,
-0.1883324682712555,
1.0072810649871826,
0.43321457505226135,
-0.10801646113395691,
-0.32502567768096924,
-0.008847557939589024,
0.08962055295705795,
-0.1585111916065216,
0.3902682065963745,
1.1552295684814453,
-0.6247415542602539,
0.08579901605844498,
-0.9369046092033386,
0.7508363127708435,
-0.17913874983787537,
-0.8843340277671814,
0.2682300806045532,
0.6897760033607483,
-0.06790629029273987,
-0.2607892155647278,
0.5674054622650146,
-0.051297809928655624,
0.18637771904468536,
0.04260250926017761,
0.005833343602716923,
-0.2747894823551178,
-0.4948151111602783,
-0.08762580156326294,
0.30434051156044006,
-0.4383898377418518,
-0.23301225900650024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12251v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12251v1
|
Mitigate Negative Transfer with Similarity Heuristic Lifelong Prompt Tuning
| 2024-06-18T03:57:49 | 2024-06-18T03:57:49 |
Chenyuan Wu, Gangwei Jiang, Defu Lian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Lifelong prompt tuning has significantly advanced parameter-efficient
lifelong learning with its efficiency and minimal storage demands on various
tasks. Our empirical studies, however, highlights certain transferability
constraints in the current methodologies: a universal algorithm that guarantees
consistent positive transfer across all tasks is currently unattainable,
especially when dealing dissimilar tasks that may engender negative transfer.
Identifying the misalignment between algorithm selection and task specificity
as the primary cause of negative transfer, we present the Similarity Heuristic
Lifelong Prompt Tuning (SHLPT) framework. This innovative strategy partitions
tasks into two distinct subsets by harnessing a learnable similarity metric,
thereby facilitating fruitful transfer from tasks regardless of their
similarity or dissimilarity. Additionally, SHLPT incorporates a parameter pool
to combat catastrophic forgetting effectively. Our experiments shows that SHLPT
outperforms state-of-the-art techniques in lifelong learning benchmarks and
demonstrates robustness against negative transfer in diverse task sequences.
|
[
-0.3021094799041748,
-0.5085874795913696,
0.43860501050949097,
0.26102831959724426,
-0.33038508892059326,
0.08671695739030838,
0.014369990676641464,
-0.35939741134643555,
0.1445460468530655,
0.22718042135238647,
-0.9934595227241516,
-0.1391458362340927,
-0.4714571535587311,
-0.21892260015010834,
-0.15208959579467773,
0.9523107409477234,
-0.008024790324270725,
-0.15802936255931854,
-0.24411089718341827,
-0.3880902826786041,
-0.9327545762062073,
-0.32810407876968384,
-1.0037238597869873,
-0.5274111032485962,
0.7100467085838318,
0.5948160290718079,
0.22898371517658234,
0.4421963095664978,
0.6488288044929504,
0.15005822479724884,
0.2946573495864868,
-0.17978931963443756,
-0.7353599667549133,
0.33724266290664673,
-0.629718542098999,
-0.2587834298610687,
0.08023705333471298,
-0.17623399198055267,
0.49842965602874756,
0.4729357063770294,
-0.023835480213165283,
0.4405669867992401,
0.27798590064048767,
0.8397505283355713,
-0.8080601096153259,
-0.06904704868793488,
-0.7511383295059204,
0.24007846415042877,
-0.3737541139125824,
-0.48921242356300354,
-0.23004528880119324,
-0.6165828108787537,
0.04603930935263634,
-0.5806856751441956,
0.25967180728912354,
0.052631180733442307,
0.6381286978721619,
0.48189854621887207,
-0.2585158050060272,
-0.06535220146179199,
-0.5712419748306274,
0.761997401714325,
-0.5395689606666565,
0.18855319917201996,
0.25820663571357727,
0.4839276373386383,
0.19393539428710938,
-0.08158953487873077,
-0.3158147633075714,
-0.36736467480659485,
0.2807981073856354,
0.16787484288215637,
0.24172741174697876,
-0.07338574528694153,
0.18073579668998718,
0.04865265637636185,
-0.6778571605682373,
0.20453841984272003,
-0.4369466304779053,
-0.4677381217479706,
0.25217166543006897,
0.2304016500711441,
0.3166470527648926,
0.10709525644779205,
-0.5749266147613525,
0.07931054383516312,
-0.8521149754524231,
-0.10152401775121689,
0.07850362360477448,
0.37177905440330505,
0.08605712652206421,
0.22592861950397491,
-0.06084504351019859,
0.5518024563789368,
0.1739199161529541,
0.014196662232279778,
0.06902480125427246,
-0.3361583948135376,
0.20934443175792694,
-0.00015375993098132312,
0.4033176004886627,
0.49728840589523315,
0.273711621761322,
-0.4409341812133789,
-0.048230089247226715,
0.137703999876976,
0.4489397704601288,
-0.6090943813323975,
-0.250503808259964,
-0.2957192361354828,
-0.33359295129776,
-0.13783514499664307,
-0.08867800235748291,
-0.7601585984230042,
-0.3543057441711426,
-0.44780418276786804,
0.8990978598594666,
-0.5762757658958435,
0.13174861669540405,
-0.0779358521103859,
-0.15015950798988342,
0.23260445892810822,
0.20619575679302216,
-0.8709092736244202,
0.1602376252412796,
0.8318424224853516,
0.9454297423362732,
-0.6493624448776245,
-0.7146185636520386,
-0.9462328553199768,
0.33555859327316284,
-0.02399185299873352,
0.817829430103302,
-0.40172138810157776,
-0.18367622792720795,
-0.24981650710105896,
-0.059772759675979614,
-0.450743705034256,
-0.5971139669418335,
0.43879812955856323,
-0.49310776591300964,
0.14670197665691376,
-0.744388997554779,
-0.6138348579406738,
-0.1723664402961731,
0.21953098475933075,
-0.4722996652126312,
0.7938572764396667,
0.3288581669330597,
-0.5282308459281921,
0.416098028421402,
-0.5284268856048584,
-0.750001072883606,
0.11769348382949829,
0.23440618813037872,
-0.6016560196876526,
0.15443287789821625,
-0.3176875710487366,
0.2708912193775177,
-0.2433772087097168,
0.044042784720659256,
-0.712109386920929,
-0.8557350635528564,
-0.16810522973537445,
-0.37969887256622314,
0.7359498143196106,
0.20867738127708435,
-0.5225463509559631,
0.09808050841093063,
-0.5325474739074707,
-0.17984700202941895,
-0.2090947926044464,
-0.0201248899102211,
-0.4514821469783783,
-0.3684197664260864,
-0.14495566487312317,
0.4699947237968445,
0.3936039209365845,
-0.5024738311767578,
0.28327476978302,
0.04977709427475929,
0.5775688290596008,
1.0182878971099854,
0.35457131266593933,
0.5510673522949219,
-0.8551298379898071,
0.5539633631706238,
-0.0042414008639752865,
0.26360294222831726,
0.005436677020043135,
-0.22199146449565887,
-0.47253677248954773,
-0.06626464426517487,
-0.17668703198432922,
0.9396762251853943,
-0.4328741133213043,
0.4963468015193939,
-0.048748113214969635,
-0.3704908788204193,
-0.27418169379234314,
0.21206693351268768,
0.2608506977558136,
1.1268396377563477,
0.5779709219932556,
-0.45559656620025635,
-0.4307587444782257,
-0.7741914391517639,
-0.4047737121582031,
-0.012656757608056068,
0.22495421767234802,
0.21780812740325928,
0.40079614520072937,
-0.1368049532175064,
0.5575459599494934,
-0.41637417674064636,
-0.536191999912262,
0.16672523319721222,
0.033092014491558075,
0.32970505952835083,
0.876531183719635,
0.4993579089641571,
-0.602939784526825,
-0.7053550481796265,
-0.2366262823343277,
-0.5485655665397644,
-0.06157734990119934,
-0.8736060261726379,
-0.3081172704696655,
0.01186656579375267,
0.5717113018035889,
-0.809650182723999,
0.17121225595474243,
0.15811756253242493,
-0.4890384376049042,
0.7161044478416443,
-0.3142571449279785,
0.2941809594631195,
-1.0037890672683716,
0.41426417231559753,
-0.17932021617889404,
-0.24834372103214264,
-0.13180576264858246,
0.18175636231899261,
0.24373430013656616,
-0.040179021656513214,
-0.4148785173892975,
0.7689331769943237,
0.005966025870293379,
0.09816469997167587,
-0.14030832052230835,
-0.1735697090625763,
-0.23691347241401672,
0.6061925888061523,
-0.407710999250412,
1.0097023248672485,
0.6426612734794617,
-0.6542791724205017,
0.3674538731575012,
0.30456626415252686,
0.10941434651613235,
1.2907160520553589,
-0.528012216091156,
-0.013826536945998669,
-0.079373300075531,
0.2677449584007263,
-0.8890132308006287,
0.2784595191478729,
0.4757313132286072,
-0.21934117376804352,
0.22694499790668488,
-0.040584977716207504,
-0.06963419914245605,
-0.41158196330070496,
-0.4329706132411957,
0.4033588767051697,
1.0202127695083618,
-0.4205890893936157,
0.22026249766349792,
-0.3987462818622589,
-0.3424378037452698,
-0.5434512495994568,
-0.4300355017185211,
0.08131096512079239,
-0.6950590014457703,
-0.1814691722393036,
0.6019251346588135,
-0.46101415157318115,
0.33582648634910583,
0.04164363816380501,
-0.5073299407958984,
-0.07458692789077759,
0.3334662914276123,
0.3119141757488251,
0.24196143448352814,
-0.21531809866428375,
0.14081619679927826,
0.20321322977542877,
-0.4206760823726654,
-0.10206770151853561,
-0.6507399082183838,
0.4008738696575165,
0.13192933797836304,
-0.6582565903663635,
-0.7917055487632751,
0.2932111918926239,
0.7067605257034302,
0.091912642121315,
0.6955641508102417,
1.017708420753479,
-0.05666622146964073,
-0.0765606015920639,
-0.6960544586181641,
-0.4578041136264801,
-0.4728735089302063,
0.12922924757003784,
-0.2981633245944977,
-0.9354375600814819,
0.6683400273323059,
-0.1670108139514923,
0.17117321491241455,
0.32711029052734375,
0.24708813428878784,
-0.5359756350517273,
0.39572396874427795,
0.6129750609397888,
-0.4283434748649597,
0.8086321949958801,
0.12560902535915375,
-0.0633053258061409,
-0.6592448353767395,
0.050101060420274734,
-0.5100187063217163,
-0.5508711338043213,
-0.1819079965353012,
-0.14294852316379547,
0.14037196338176727,
0.26392295956611633,
-0.8159761428833008,
0.5668249130249023,
-0.3914046287536621,
0.6560764312744141,
0.7860317230224609,
0.21329694986343384,
0.14944647252559662,
-0.013307342305779457,
-0.06893552094697952,
-0.2712324261665344,
-0.46720972657203674,
0.09941019862890244,
0.797615110874176,
-0.014453699812293053,
0.5417517423629761,
-0.05116048827767372,
1.1490317583084106,
0.8075611591339111,
0.25272926688194275,
-0.36389708518981934,
0.4797573685646057,
-0.38332074880599976,
-0.32678282260894775,
-0.4790496528148651,
-0.588432788848877,
-0.6616954207420349,
-0.03413206338882446,
0.03900307044386864,
-0.7924162745475769,
0.058848969638347626,
0.5030889511108398,
-0.42053598165512085,
0.3465844392776489,
-0.5639252066612244,
0.7476693987846375,
0.0680568739771843,
-0.6737257838249207,
-0.5219697952270508,
-0.7936822175979614,
0.015742521733045578,
-0.35093924403190613,
-0.15479683876037598,
-0.22448523342609406,
0.009304801933467388,
0.5150887966156006,
-0.09771153330802917,
0.7801616787910461,
-0.6166749596595764,
-0.05178241804242134,
0.008614111691713333,
0.34675726294517517,
0.7137438058853149,
0.05450371652841568,
-0.19347357749938965,
-0.08357029408216476,
-0.035933468490839005,
-0.8775486946105957,
-0.5851555466651917,
0.8438053131103516,
-0.5148793458938599,
-0.5744856595993042,
-0.04338483139872551,
-0.5018318295478821,
-0.25800415873527527,
0.5396924018859863,
0.4940965473651886,
0.2365742325782776,
-0.03128698468208313,
-0.18817074596881866,
0.858883798122406,
0.05895979702472687,
0.3609746992588043,
0.4067985713481903,
0.4823847711086273,
-0.1607183963060379,
1.550992727279663,
0.008995703421533108,
0.3085085451602936,
0.6097736954689026,
0.2808936536312103,
-0.30613213777542114,
-0.5026159286499023,
-0.3567018210887909,
0.28476107120513916,
-0.5776746273040771,
-0.32618334889411926,
-0.2343929558992386,
-0.1258045732975006,
-0.21006923913955688,
-0.7714450359344482,
-0.360169917345047,
-0.46775132417678833,
-0.46799013018608093,
0.07223187386989594,
0.20609310269355774,
0.32137009501457214,
-0.4550020396709442,
0.15246273577213287,
-0.9405002593994141,
0.6143304109573364,
0.7353506088256836,
0.46765515208244324,
0.1366523653268814,
-0.746694028377533,
0.1488150954246521,
-0.08216708153486252,
-0.4159546494483948,
-0.7196208238601685,
0.17139199376106262,
0.5403963327407837,
0.6861100196838379,
0.2506387233734131,
0.2383945882320404,
0.8213926553726196,
-0.45407217741012573,
0.591422438621521,
0.37861716747283936,
-1.0215375423431396,
0.2649385929107666,
-0.45389941334724426,
0.6620916724205017,
1.2249855995178223,
0.466900110244751,
-0.7550248503684998,
-0.1709362119436264,
-0.3955121636390686,
-0.8423137068748474,
0.34741681814193726,
-0.25362536311149597,
0.1309436410665512,
0.2620543837547302,
0.5583797097206116,
0.7106192708015442,
0.05459374189376831,
-0.5177806615829468,
-0.048437949270009995,
-0.14871995151042938,
-0.16047026216983795,
-0.1280514895915985,
0.1403801441192627,
0.032826464623212814,
-0.16186316311359406,
0.7274692058563232,
-0.16753877699375153,
0.33125603199005127,
0.057299546897411346,
-0.363872230052948,
-0.2578776776790619,
0.2758464217185974,
0.5748827457427979,
0.5199747085571289,
-0.3176935613155365,
0.16992440819740295,
0.31033292412757874,
-0.4107604920864105,
0.558232307434082,
-0.011809646151959896,
-0.3580438196659088,
-0.428711473941803,
0.38811808824539185,
0.5667200684547424,
0.40160757303237915,
-0.3684149384498596,
0.3354433476924896,
0.19415903091430664,
-0.1997707635164261,
-0.1921379417181015,
0.29385191202163696,
0.1791914999485016,
0.2824200689792633,
0.43209439516067505,
0.7573317289352417,
0.14781242609024048,
-0.20725023746490479,
0.5449514985084534,
0.2753298878669739,
-0.7953351736068726,
-0.3781663775444031,
0.5634029507637024,
0.3160597085952759,
-0.5166862607002258,
1.0466736555099487,
-0.3319317698478699,
-0.4795299470424652,
0.6018040180206299,
0.7062702178955078,
0.9028480648994446,
-0.22186332941055298,
0.3949606418609619,
0.5269812941551208,
0.09092403203248978,
-0.28909197449684143,
0.2379392832517624,
-0.6424405574798584,
-0.36430829763412476,
-0.3496382236480713,
-0.33102086186408997,
-0.26064741611480713,
-0.13571526110172272,
-0.9018548130989075,
-0.027085870504379272,
-0.4102109372615814,
0.12921620905399323,
-0.48884958028793335,
-0.1480497121810913,
-0.7184167504310608,
-0.25599774718284607,
0.11730870604515076,
0.9075546860694885,
-1.0377633571624756,
0.7170968651771545,
0.4123243987560272,
-0.12583427131175995,
-0.2371147722005844,
0.10095558315515518,
0.07430010288953781,
-0.876274585723877,
0.3944471478462219,
0.32209616899490356,
-0.10167120397090912,
0.15224474668502808,
-0.12135613709688187,
-0.8501289486885071,
1.1321377754211426,
0.3947674334049225,
-0.869559645652771,
-0.2786562442779541,
-0.18850518763065338,
0.2291896492242813,
0.1560012400150299,
-0.22170081734657288,
0.5109097361564636,
0.5840179324150085,
0.2255493551492691,
-0.9054831862449646,
0.4236278831958771,
0.024366652593016624,
-0.21733228862285614,
0.3908845782279968,
-0.7484807372093201,
0.5581815838813782,
-0.5570278763771057,
-0.265123575925827,
0.24352499842643738,
0.3048516511917114,
0.4283452033996582,
0.3891078531742096,
0.3997228741645813,
0.6933862566947937,
0.6767581105232239,
0.2608148753643036,
0.5185946822166443,
-0.29491811990737915,
0.40822315216064453,
1.1281996965408325,
-0.45192626118659973,
0.5351813435554504,
0.7132548689842224,
-0.14949782192707062,
0.13611267507076263,
0.5935437083244324,
-0.16896291077136993,
0.9019692540168762,
0.23795025050640106,
-0.18950599431991577,
-0.3646174371242523,
-0.06873685866594315,
-0.5199916362762451,
-0.1013689637184143,
0.16277764737606049,
0.06741665303707123,
-0.49763163924217224,
0.20567584037780762,
-0.24573564529418945,
0.05193640664219856,
-0.32386550307273865,
0.8007965087890625,
0.15316033363342285,
-0.8215991854667664,
0.6048392653465271,
-0.6202282309532166,
1.066534399986267,
-0.650119960308075,
-0.19859294593334198,
-0.38254812359809875,
0.1613788902759552,
-0.10290558636188507,
-0.4011564254760742,
0.4958442747592926,
-0.7849345207214355,
-0.1722531020641327,
-0.45009100437164307,
0.7100210189819336,
-0.16695503890514374,
-0.08683346211910248,
0.11325482279062271,
0.4469192326068878,
-0.318693608045578,
-0.009555000811815262,
-1.0104721784591675,
-0.12515605986118317,
0.20505240559577942,
0.041389547288417816,
0.5790611505508423,
0.1908910870552063,
-0.13319151103496552,
0.9304192066192627,
0.504216730594635,
0.30593594908714294,
-0.040116336196660995,
-0.11095986515283585,
0.6009935736656189,
-0.9046525955200195,
-0.8414352536201477,
-0.8668784499168396,
0.12015023082494736,
0.17485183477401733,
-0.4781597852706909,
0.6679499745368958,
0.21113474667072296,
0.6066094040870667,
-0.2576621472835541,
0.6400702595710754,
0.0037645609118044376,
0.37584006786346436,
-0.42247942090034485,
0.6366189122200012,
-0.29816994071006775,
0.17002369463443756,
-0.31979748606681824,
-1.2320775985717773,
-0.29498013854026794,
0.4671175181865692,
-0.2598626911640167,
-0.06202489510178566,
0.6905059814453125,
0.6039460301399231,
-0.233835369348526,
-0.057753488421440125,
0.3091091215610504,
-0.09494931250810623,
0.30083197355270386,
1.1138427257537842,
0.8320209980010986,
-0.11060278862714767,
0.32046523690223694,
-0.23232759535312653,
-0.14698952436447144,
-0.366794615983963,
-1.0457478761672974,
-0.5547544360160828,
-0.7622477412223816,
-0.4672746956348419,
-0.12767598032951355,
0.604840099811554,
0.8829575777053833,
1.033740758895874,
-0.8361757397651672,
0.01883358508348465,
-0.492725133895874,
0.14754816889762878,
-0.6679278016090393,
-0.2599937319755554,
0.4386270046234131,
-0.4249506890773773,
-0.01850714720785618,
0.1953783631324768,
0.2733047306537628,
0.0017964759608730674,
-0.10657305270433426,
-0.08094047755002975,
0.1557391732931137,
-0.08856537938117981,
0.42527511715888977,
0.755590558052063,
-0.321880042552948,
-0.45839548110961914,
-0.18974052369594574,
-0.04877050220966339,
0.006511581130325794,
1.0928966999053955,
-0.8878572583198547,
-0.021922040730714798,
0.5192084908485413,
0.9874811768531799,
0.29646366834640503,
-0.05212247371673584,
0.36588048934936523,
-0.4440540075302124,
0.00826752558350563,
0.5589616894721985,
-0.03682071343064308,
0.17681559920310974,
-0.6356862187385559,
0.196039617061615,
0.3723452687263489,
-0.6656593084335327,
-0.5695698857307434,
0.35523131489753723,
-0.9879474639892578,
-0.4587407112121582,
0.7064298987388611,
-0.16850900650024414,
0.0029294996056705713,
-0.23534449934959412,
-0.16378451883792877,
0.054514531046152115,
-0.617622971534729,
1.1738533973693848,
0.3983893394470215,
-0.35182568430900574,
-0.20816068351268768,
-0.24527934193611145,
0.37265288829803467,
0.717431902885437,
-0.7041823267936707,
-0.060546208173036575,
0.2940414249897003,
0.7278575301170349,
-0.11041206866502762,
0.6462501883506775,
0.10124611109495163,
0.6968278288841248,
-0.12392356991767883,
-0.3023458421230316,
-0.2094862461090088,
-0.42129042744636536,
-0.4544864296913147,
0.4584864377975464,
0.01800667680799961,
-0.038059379905462265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12246v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12246v2
|
TroL: Traversal of Layers for Large Language and Vision Models
| 2024-06-18T03:42:00 | 2024-06-19T21:40:03 |
Byung-Kwan Lee, Sangyun Chung, Chae Won Kim, Beomchan Park, Yong Man Ro
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Large language and vision models (LLVMs) have been driven by the
generalization power of large language models (LLMs) and the advent of visual
instruction tuning. Along with scaling them up directly, these models enable
LLVMs to showcase powerful vision language (VL) performances by covering
diverse tasks via natural language instructions. However, existing open-source
LLVMs that perform comparably to closed-source LLVMs such as GPT-4V are often
considered too large (e.g., 26B, 34B, and 110B parameters), having a larger
number of layers. These large models demand costly, high-end resources for both
training and inference. To address this issue, we present a new efficient LLVM
family with 1.8B, 3.8B, and 7B LLM model sizes, Traversal of Layers (TroL),
which enables the reuse of layers in a token-wise manner. This layer traversing
technique simulates the effect of looking back and retracing the answering
stream while increasing the number of forward propagation layers without
physically adding more layers. We demonstrate that TroL employs a simple layer
traversing approach yet efficiently outperforms the open-source LLVMs with
larger model sizes and rivals the performances of the closed-source LLVMs with
substantial sizes.
|
[
-0.30660954117774963,
-0.4846278131008148,
0.5717635154724121,
0.24142596125602722,
-0.5600461363792419,
0.3584405481815338,
0.0044257319532334805,
-0.7658684253692627,
-0.16026443243026733,
0.9609465003013611,
-0.4127395749092102,
-0.6134707927703857,
-0.41315075755119324,
-0.3424304127693176,
-0.35610705614089966,
0.5716854929924011,
0.08541032671928406,
-0.20133844017982483,
-0.09546486288309097,
-0.10101769119501114,
-0.18366886675357819,
-0.24100808799266815,
-0.6974305510520935,
-0.2618619203567505,
0.8520339727401733,
0.2759985029697418,
0.6259545683860779,
0.8329010605812073,
0.6252543926239014,
0.34813547134399414,
-0.16800564527511597,
0.4142630696296692,
-0.3634854853153229,
0.07019157707691193,
-0.12169800698757172,
-0.31855645775794983,
-0.3581726551055908,
-0.059650175273418427,
0.853882372379303,
0.5816245675086975,
-0.1736585795879364,
0.2641567587852478,
-0.16420921683311462,
0.8304163813591003,
-0.7264854311943054,
-0.03759520873427391,
-0.5386679768562317,
0.16924339532852173,
-0.15999312698841095,
-0.18746954202651978,
-0.6718636751174927,
-0.10166122019290924,
0.5658631920814514,
-0.6242079138755798,
0.1991041600704193,
0.14064307510852814,
0.538125216960907,
0.12485591322183609,
-0.252383291721344,
0.16003146767616272,
-0.6862651705741882,
0.8930158019065857,
-0.7151065468788147,
0.7746135592460632,
-0.01671244204044342,
0.4389129877090454,
0.21503379940986633,
-1.0978147983551025,
-0.39414700865745544,
-0.345935583114624,
0.17943350970745087,
-0.12474152445793152,
-0.19901201128959656,
0.2706088423728943,
0.3406163454055786,
0.18323762714862823,
-0.5197449326515198,
0.012739610858261585,
-0.5263272523880005,
-0.13596604764461517,
0.3225947320461273,
0.030847078189253807,
0.2633688449859619,
0.030801469460129738,
-0.6234601736068726,
-0.30299219489097595,
-0.7321493625640869,
0.004664530046284199,
0.0346081405878067,
0.1444273293018341,
-0.03733908385038376,
0.3671104907989502,
-0.03574368357658386,
1.046194314956665,
-0.18945863842964172,
-0.3135320544242859,
0.3172812759876251,
-0.22782734036445618,
-0.45047447085380554,
-0.11914151161909103,
0.4161180555820465,
0.2192191630601883,
0.23824867606163025,
-0.21052956581115723,
-0.1910925954580307,
-0.2608225345611572,
0.2887815237045288,
-0.78117835521698,
-0.10010524839162827,
0.10918871313333511,
-0.31110161542892456,
-0.38239097595214844,
-0.1545165628194809,
-0.8682772517204285,
-0.15366119146347046,
-0.08519599586725235,
0.45135533809661865,
-0.34294024109840393,
0.012882959097623825,
0.18867997825145721,
-0.07891881465911865,
0.5719895958900452,
0.6304324269294739,
-0.5192420482635498,
0.29901421070098877,
0.5513584613800049,
1.0468685626983643,
-0.06747370958328247,
-0.309660404920578,
-1.0705175399780273,
0.3060435354709625,
-0.35112011432647705,
0.5272168517112732,
-0.7888402938842773,
-0.25464800000190735,
-0.056928250938653946,
-0.14465752243995667,
0.05406392365694046,
-0.5417240262031555,
0.42411068081855774,
-0.7235909104347229,
0.13356097042560577,
0.0446198508143425,
-0.18812832236289978,
-0.4242279529571533,
0.3493903577327728,
-0.7692394852638245,
0.7370293140411377,
0.18001192808151245,
-0.6739437580108643,
0.019149545580148697,
-0.41194793581962585,
-0.433431476354599,
0.2334119826555252,
-0.025397134944796562,
-0.4641817510128021,
0.26828694343566895,
0.48511311411857605,
0.2017066329717636,
-0.4285328984260559,
-0.1643567532300949,
-0.10357946902513504,
-0.4406015872955322,
-0.28621673583984375,
-0.21645869314670563,
0.8208953738212585,
0.2080250382423401,
-0.23529554903507233,
0.2326451539993286,
-0.6905468702316284,
0.20910118520259857,
-0.003956454806029797,
-0.48682552576065063,
-0.48522621393203735,
0.006479648407548666,
-0.2733787000179291,
0.24551397562026978,
0.13187569379806519,
-0.5521745085716248,
0.20668651163578033,
-0.5285640358924866,
0.5903695225715637,
0.7819476127624512,
-0.21473295986652374,
0.37813588976860046,
0.03760462999343872,
0.5759735703468323,
0.27805572748184204,
0.3742225468158722,
-0.15912622213363647,
-0.5138370394706726,
-0.8917326927185059,
-0.2489202618598938,
0.01490335538983345,
0.38578060269355774,
-1.2202420234680176,
-0.11889554560184479,
-0.3450009822845459,
-0.45379966497421265,
-0.3725684583187103,
0.2684813141822815,
0.5411375761032104,
0.6163452863693237,
0.39022698998451233,
-0.30222079157829285,
-0.5193396806716919,
-0.9225247502326965,
-0.03551588952541351,
-0.30796971917152405,
-0.10463659465312958,
0.5944322347640991,
0.45480290055274963,
-0.06825117021799088,
0.519324779510498,
-0.4751755893230438,
-0.05467798188328743,
-0.37356045842170715,
-0.17150551080703735,
-0.017830507829785347,
0.29604166746139526,
0.45407548546791077,
-0.6368759274482727,
-0.3020714223384857,
0.31063249707221985,
-0.4890301525592804,
-0.09278799593448639,
0.11897702515125275,
-0.17669729888439178,
0.12300039827823639,
0.3766462206840515,
-0.5237100720405579,
0.15520510077476501,
0.795968770980835,
-0.24118229746818542,
0.45920318365097046,
-0.24321770668029785,
-0.24301421642303467,
-0.7400508522987366,
-0.031177276745438576,
0.10472733527421951,
-0.5070908069610596,
-0.7695859670639038,
0.5298522710800171,
0.10490994155406952,
-0.11099211126565933,
-0.830848217010498,
0.5657922029495239,
-0.6430364847183228,
-0.4374956488609314,
-0.016943324357271194,
0.2296592891216278,
0.3290907144546509,
0.530183732509613,
0.040042053908109665,
0.7123976349830627,
0.7523033618927002,
-0.41492360830307007,
0.6755958199501038,
-0.06776920706033707,
-0.35033732652664185,
0.17077983915805817,
-0.6815246343612671,
0.43884071707725525,
-0.03538357838988304,
0.2153121680021286,
-0.5628235340118408,
0.14957810938358307,
0.23509274423122406,
-0.04044913873076439,
0.22117979824543,
-0.2174665927886963,
-0.19214831292629242,
-0.4749129116535187,
-0.5235282182693481,
0.6760832667350769,
0.5828831195831299,
-0.981080174446106,
1.138791799545288,
0.20732569694519043,
0.25708281993865967,
-0.7446560263633728,
-0.8872453570365906,
0.35710662603378296,
-0.23148490488529205,
-0.9696857929229736,
0.18764019012451172,
0.01295887678861618,
-0.11609435826539993,
-0.12266302853822708,
-0.12904618680477142,
-0.021809594705700874,
-0.2172074168920517,
0.00019128223357256502,
0.32955867052078247,
-0.3944869935512543,
-0.15907680988311768,
-0.29654407501220703,
0.20715273916721344,
0.04249576851725578,
-1.04420804977417,
0.6275513172149658,
-0.2984994947910309,
-0.1623646318912506,
-0.046175532042980194,
0.1376824826002121,
0.6441757082939148,
-0.7006555795669556,
0.5766099691390991,
0.3812107443809509,
-0.18360073864459991,
-0.6570478081703186,
-0.6581105589866638,
0.15240249037742615,
-0.5287401676177979,
0.49120524525642395,
-0.3812507390975952,
-0.9327307939529419,
0.47227033972740173,
0.18971599638462067,
0.06801382452249527,
0.11908405274152756,
0.30719679594039917,
0.02757973037660122,
0.8220601081848145,
0.4468151032924652,
-0.000013990385923534632,
0.5715620517730713,
-0.4315812289714813,
-0.00418907031416893,
-0.9252145886421204,
-0.2655118405818939,
-0.1830161064863205,
-0.4453778564929962,
-0.46166542172431946,
-0.948273241519928,
0.31013157963752747,
-0.2702562212944031,
-0.1831403225660324,
0.10866028815507889,
-0.4337638318538666,
0.6165640354156494,
0.8219519853591919,
0.3818609118461609,
0.4356064200401306,
0.3870287537574768,
-0.22501325607299805,
0.39786580204963684,
-0.736291766166687,
-0.1853542923927307,
0.8579211235046387,
0.5866031646728516,
0.9130314588546753,
0.13575242459774017,
0.47507837414741516,
0.07858648151159286,
0.07839594781398773,
-0.6409872174263,
0.9875266551971436,
-0.6353687047958374,
-0.32642942667007446,
-0.3361365795135498,
-0.5753098130226135,
-0.584368884563446,
0.38534823060035706,
0.168972909450531,
-0.6760274767875671,
0.30071815848350525,
0.22615273296833038,
-0.1422729641199112,
0.8401908278465271,
-0.6301829218864441,
0.5648394227027893,
-0.281948447227478,
-0.6223142147064209,
-0.16354823112487793,
-0.7933964729309082,
0.5345105528831482,
0.02753312885761261,
-0.216497540473938,
0.25787869095802307,
-0.18994492292404175,
0.5101779699325562,
-0.492191880941391,
0.864117443561554,
-0.26686257123947144,
-0.1412421315908432,
0.535149872303009,
0.12717410922050476,
0.662348747253418,
-0.22955027222633362,
0.23172760009765625,
0.20995751023292542,
-0.29673296213150024,
-0.3675265312194824,
-0.7258242964744568,
0.8066776394844055,
-0.7432047128677368,
-0.745032548904419,
-0.25538408756256104,
-0.58456951379776,
-0.12302097678184509,
0.1706659197807312,
0.014336228370666504,
0.6114581823348999,
0.2768101096153259,
0.31918731331825256,
0.6337273716926575,
-0.5267812609672546,
0.2751460373401642,
0.3294268846511841,
-0.43881261348724365,
-0.22144073247909546,
1.0486927032470703,
-0.05553606525063515,
0.6038483381271362,
0.6154715418815613,
0.3037336468696594,
-0.35344016551971436,
-0.9242061376571655,
-0.4968261122703552,
0.2193952351808548,
-0.6222817301750183,
-0.06721662729978561,
-0.37226346135139465,
-0.5804916620254517,
-0.09297355264425278,
0.05128399655222893,
-0.3253043293952942,
-0.3904731571674347,
0.02139923721551895,
-0.14431630074977875,
0.050288427621126175,
0.523898720741272,
0.08260557055473328,
0.3081745207309723,
-0.762054443359375,
0.28506922721862793,
0.6383324265480042,
0.6469542980194092,
0.20064643025398254,
-0.548397421836853,
-0.2977723777294159,
-0.23387235403060913,
-0.14496128261089325,
-0.5649976134300232,
0.45772629976272583,
0.2388380616903305,
0.34144988656044006,
0.30550941824913025,
-0.29466813802719116,
0.7597514986991882,
-0.6690261960029602,
0.6965563893318176,
0.21072439849376678,
-0.8890993595123291,
0.45491158962249756,
-0.21056301891803741,
0.3531009554862976,
0.09029973298311234,
-0.15772446990013123,
-0.3997285068035126,
-0.40748298168182373,
-0.3523041307926178,
-0.7967859506607056,
0.6485500931739807,
0.11547235399484634,
-0.05309054255485535,
0.25615477561950684,
0.5045469999313354,
-0.1963486224412918,
0.08732878416776657,
-0.7032721042633057,
-0.02244562655687332,
-0.44579094648361206,
-0.06843725591897964,
0.0012100758031010628,
-0.3674560785293579,
0.024247262626886368,
-0.05793408304452896,
0.4601276218891144,
-0.05126256123185158,
0.030977420508861542,
0.3641861081123352,
-0.13796447217464447,
-0.12431669235229492,
0.1055617481470108,
0.6192907691001892,
0.7306886315345764,
-0.34700286388397217,
0.6475294828414917,
0.19941139221191406,
-0.7664639949798584,
0.04531925171613693,
-0.11203103512525558,
-0.4343593716621399,
-0.1800764799118042,
0.5477307438850403,
1.1444282531738281,
0.0610162615776062,
-0.7376444339752197,
0.34256085753440857,
0.07354693114757538,
-0.2914840877056122,
-0.009675217792391777,
0.24634534120559692,
0.1118394136428833,
0.60288006067276,
0.14107738435268402,
-0.15887856483459473,
0.04846484586596489,
-0.4146476686000824,
0.17045599222183228,
0.4907899796962738,
-0.23427452147006989,
-0.24237516522407532,
0.6221281290054321,
0.4038501977920532,
-0.40056490898132324,
0.7567209005355835,
0.14947111904621124,
-0.5217306017875671,
0.5058482885360718,
0.5510278940200806,
0.9366812109947205,
-0.17497225105762482,
0.283681184053421,
0.21551570296287537,
0.4758930802345276,
-0.015581682324409485,
0.09735660254955292,
0.10751056671142578,
-0.7533788681030273,
-0.7321691513061523,
-0.666137158870697,
-0.46167847514152527,
0.2404647320508957,
-0.2740652859210968,
0.030943648889660835,
-0.7370782494544983,
0.16024209558963776,
-0.27290356159210205,
-0.03646186366677284,
-0.6115017533302307,
0.2897660732269287,
0.49781614542007446,
1.2886251211166382,
-0.3701099157333374,
1.1306676864624023,
0.6176506280899048,
-0.19083045423030853,
-0.8321280479431152,
-0.014434225857257843,
-0.25354674458503723,
-1.1122390031814575,
0.9796854257583618,
0.1494535356760025,
-0.5885847806930542,
0.19436021149158478,
-0.7034638524055481,
-0.6520175337791443,
1.1381219625473022,
0.4244718849658966,
-0.7655073404312134,
-0.5857969522476196,
0.2525731027126312,
0.4930689334869385,
-0.5545685887336731,
-0.0032576178200542927,
0.3688172399997711,
0.3313276469707489,
0.4656992554664612,
-0.6000464558601379,
-0.0033470222260802984,
-0.10512814670801163,
0.31012576818466187,
0.14485393464565277,
-0.7298787236213684,
0.8132975101470947,
-0.5182709097862244,
-0.25359243154525757,
0.01364923920482397,
0.6164038181304932,
0.47878068685531616,
0.2075972557067871,
0.9663066864013672,
0.5731706023216248,
0.3948734402656555,
0.029187308624386787,
1.0888913869857788,
-0.26927122473716736,
0.16447405517101288,
1.0715898275375366,
-0.1466623991727829,
0.7971442937850952,
0.6200646162033081,
0.022944243624806404,
0.4406375586986542,
0.3191082179546356,
-0.0968700647354126,
0.495862752199173,
0.2593114376068115,
-0.2937086224555969,
-0.4119085967540741,
-0.0055184513330459595,
-0.13483314216136932,
0.44097039103507996,
0.08706390112638474,
-0.39876726269721985,
-0.1970950961112976,
-0.13409776985645294,
-0.5965304970741272,
-0.2340383529663086,
-0.6100326776504517,
0.292313814163208,
0.15251874923706055,
-0.42721521854400635,
0.36658716201782227,
-0.1169823408126831,
0.3194896876811981,
-0.6501041650772095,
-0.12844225764274597,
-0.27421531081199646,
0.12865445017814636,
-0.015922630205750465,
-0.9612151384353638,
0.03552234545350075,
0.017845485359430313,
0.12373591959476471,
-0.0739704892039299,
0.8354858756065369,
-0.3639480173587799,
-0.7629417181015015,
0.5480694770812988,
0.6049574613571167,
-0.01661359705030918,
-0.006851374637335539,
-0.38811612129211426,
0.10968281328678131,
0.10765431076288223,
-0.47349458932876587,
0.07234896719455719,
0.38395965099334717,
-0.11490681022405624,
1.1158583164215088,
0.687982976436615,
0.39449915289878845,
0.39851897954940796,
0.31268495321273804,
1.0514436960220337,
-0.7504640817642212,
-0.49313873052597046,
-0.7259926795959473,
0.4516173303127289,
-0.009163940325379372,
-0.03349384292960167,
0.41210687160491943,
0.5260858535766602,
0.9522818922996521,
0.004976462107151747,
0.5081189870834351,
0.34016820788383484,
0.32095780968666077,
-0.6959328651428223,
0.24103549122810364,
-0.8223528265953064,
0.5229902863502502,
-0.1922331005334854,
-1.0633865594863892,
-0.5784410238265991,
0.6336033940315247,
-0.28722327947616577,
0.16461524367332458,
0.3853159546852112,
0.48926329612731934,
-0.18326438963413239,
-0.1602013260126114,
0.5376895666122437,
0.5476464629173279,
0.6261995434761047,
0.8765690326690674,
0.8156257271766663,
-0.06439200043678284,
0.7648007869720459,
-0.36401405930519104,
-0.04673318192362785,
-0.06482669711112976,
-0.9949114918708801,
-0.902564525604248,
-0.2675239145755768,
-0.06808368861675262,
-0.19349834322929382,
0.292682409286499,
0.5099271535873413,
0.845301628112793,
-0.428363561630249,
-0.21399135887622833,
-0.09752196818590164,
0.15050488710403442,
-0.10987327992916107,
-0.15501350164413452,
0.340645968914032,
-0.03972788155078888,
-0.6933560371398926,
0.3208950459957123,
0.5179165601730347,
0.010886331088840961,
-0.6623544692993164,
-0.1926058828830719,
-0.09650374948978424,
0.014069589786231518,
0.9180652499198914,
0.21320292353630066,
-0.9198095202445984,
-0.652934193611145,
0.11601042002439499,
0.05055312067270279,
0.28482070565223694,
0.6685348749160767,
-0.9510881304740906,
0.4660029411315918,
0.6235095858573914,
0.6125383377075195,
0.8128766417503357,
-0.032732103019952774,
0.5805423855781555,
-0.8621937036514282,
0.13758933544158936,
0.21858444809913635,
0.3690643310546875,
0.3174687325954437,
-0.04460078105330467,
0.5698116421699524,
0.1568102240562439,
-0.31132468581199646,
-0.8028322458267212,
0.36422643065452576,
-1.3387912511825562,
-0.2020929902791977,
0.9993252158164978,
-0.0834353044629097,
-0.3536264896392822,
0.2962314486503601,
-0.14596647024154663,
-0.024288242682814598,
-0.18929843604564667,
0.47245699167251587,
0.4201136529445648,
-0.007820896804332733,
-0.878929615020752,
-0.6804283857345581,
0.0881345272064209,
0.07821854948997498,
-0.6829794645309448,
0.18605215847492218,
0.3315209448337555,
0.25810325145721436,
0.13496918976306915,
0.3661215901374817,
-0.05488838255405426,
0.12926656007766724,
-0.15992887318134308,
-0.05556173250079155,
-0.4658832550048828,
-0.6395978331565857,
-0.08559991419315338,
0.2313936948776245,
-0.011495356447994709,
-0.27434760332107544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12238v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12238v1
|
PFID: Privacy First Inference Delegation Framework for LLMs
| 2024-06-18T03:27:09 | 2024-06-18T03:27:09 |
Haoyan Yang, Zhitao Li, Yong Zhang, Jianzong Wang, Ning Cheng, Ming Li, Jing Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces a novel privacy-preservation framework named PFID for
LLMs that addresses critical privacy concerns by localizing user data through
model sharding and singular value decomposition. When users are interacting
with LLM systems, their prompts could be subject to being exposed to
eavesdroppers within or outside LLM system providers who are interested in
collecting users' input. In this work, we proposed a framework to camouflage
user input, so as to alleviate privacy issues. Our framework proposes to place
model shards on the client and the public server, we sent compressed hidden
states instead of prompts to and from servers. Clients have held back
information that can re-privatized the hidden states so that overall system
performance is comparable to traditional LLMs services. Our framework was
designed to be communication efficient, computation can be delegated to the
local client so that the server's computation burden can be lightened. We
conduct extensive experiments on machine translation tasks to verify our
framework's performance.
|
[
-0.16161902248859406,
-0.8462512493133545,
0.5259478688240051,
0.3353959918022156,
-0.13105376064777374,
-0.11272821575403214,
0.16002172231674194,
-0.11756780743598938,
0.1028718501329422,
0.6941258907318115,
-0.5036476850509644,
-0.6182988286018372,
-0.3436155617237091,
-0.22100920975208282,
-0.37489718198776245,
0.6741533875465393,
-0.02971944399178028,
-0.017596255987882614,
-0.5835552215576172,
0.29379719495773315,
0.3880428075790405,
-0.9196450710296631,
-0.41319209337234497,
-0.20077861845493317,
0.22756358981132507,
0.5013083219528198,
0.6609787344932556,
0.634023129940033,
0.4280548095703125,
0.27654555439949036,
-0.09254227578639984,
0.3152727782726288,
-0.7371513247489929,
0.2831006944179535,
-0.37119045853614807,
-0.3364335298538208,
-0.6203073263168335,
-0.16020436584949493,
0.7763742208480835,
0.7419756650924683,
-0.14521190524101257,
0.2835771143436432,
0.03239087760448456,
0.4009419083595276,
-1.039370059967041,
0.17816480994224548,
-0.1886461228132248,
0.13340145349502563,
-0.23089541494846344,
-0.03914682939648628,
-0.5196903347969055,
-0.1834743171930313,
0.06295016407966614,
-0.43331122398376465,
0.29943811893463135,
0.1086784154176712,
0.7199400663375854,
0.32312461733818054,
-0.5765334367752075,
0.45510372519493103,
-0.7024513483047485,
0.43551385402679443,
-0.4740893244743347,
0.3803171217441559,
0.6716155409812927,
-0.004563008435070515,
-0.32401344180107117,
-0.9900286793708801,
-0.3321634531021118,
0.09777351468801498,
-0.2952549159526825,
-0.147101029753685,
-0.2367609292268753,
0.4115756154060364,
0.13685019314289093,
0.611301600933075,
-0.1545981764793396,
0.1621263325214386,
0.08205975592136383,
-0.5825257301330566,
0.7346929311752319,
0.18312916159629822,
-0.21357542276382446,
0.07689345628023148,
-0.8289323449134827,
0.08485174924135208,
-0.941923201084137,
0.14798927307128906,
0.42054781317710876,
-0.2143900990486145,
-0.2549074590206146,
0.454565167427063,
-0.5552480220794678,
0.3203856647014618,
0.17902672290802002,
-0.2898240089416504,
0.1396823674440384,
-0.17520293593406677,
-0.5943812727928162,
-0.3053085505962372,
0.7702488899230957,
0.3988231420516968,
-0.36740872263908386,
-0.4064657688140869,
-0.3321828544139862,
-0.36296677589416504,
-0.1256982684135437,
-1.0363279581069946,
-0.3046761751174927,
0.17805854976177216,
-0.8701469898223877,
-0.46069639921188354,
0.3651686906814575,
-0.5571237802505493,
-0.6761558651924133,
0.13763466477394104,
0.19174599647521973,
0.05942269414663315,
-0.48858773708343506,
0.12933477759361267,
0.1693212240934372,
0.29814767837524414,
0.34836217761039734,
-0.7824695706367493,
0.8384401798248291,
0.8876622915267944,
0.6277236342430115,
-0.5553067922592163,
-0.22155651450157166,
-0.3891909122467041,
0.2407170534133911,
-0.10132742673158646,
0.3960014283657074,
-0.20518863201141357,
-0.8106682896614075,
-0.04435116797685623,
0.2543216347694397,
-0.003769318573176861,
-0.6002837419509888,
0.6561437845230103,
-0.5575994253158569,
-0.020716574043035507,
-0.4730965793132782,
-0.7595033049583435,
-0.20798909664154053,
-0.10914099961519241,
-0.6493634581565857,
0.7634137868881226,
0.0275824386626482,
-0.7176296710968018,
0.029039936140179634,
-0.7128822207450867,
-0.2814807593822479,
0.26505258679389954,
-0.10824120044708252,
-0.6868389248847961,
0.2360251098871231,
0.19366802275180817,
0.8073692917823792,
-0.19805949926376343,
0.1917651891708374,
-0.5913637280464172,
-0.42023801803588867,
0.42535126209259033,
-0.5598815679550171,
0.8281145691871643,
0.6257526278495789,
-0.22834357619285583,
0.08577843010425568,
-0.41364359855651855,
-0.04159841313958168,
0.07694980502128601,
-0.25757551193237305,
-0.011867137625813484,
0.15663093328475952,
0.08545554429292679,
-0.3577842712402344,
0.5069372653961182,
-0.578435480594635,
-0.034965988248586655,
-0.3741929233074188,
0.39564844965934753,
0.8573974370956421,
0.5370172262191772,
0.7722691297531128,
-0.5190650224685669,
0.5913882255554199,
0.19136939942836761,
0.3618412911891937,
-0.14758647978305817,
-0.47762438654899597,
-0.3203129768371582,
-0.6854897141456604,
0.1836380809545517,
0.6411738991737366,
-0.37896037101745605,
0.2658875584602356,
-0.16207152605056763,
0.0035777464509010315,
-0.3371090292930603,
0.22965876758098602,
0.5167875289916992,
0.502717137336731,
-0.22031396627426147,
0.02343684248626232,
-0.0835515707731247,
-1.4605814218521118,
-0.010569026693701744,
-0.1339305192232132,
-0.2423781156539917,
0.3573756814002991,
0.36405259370803833,
-0.10552454739809036,
0.893248438835144,
-0.45344746112823486,
-0.1690979301929474,
0.2053641378879547,
-0.18684284389019012,
-0.14060010015964508,
0.8329839706420898,
0.10718322545289993,
-1.105101227760315,
0.0760311558842659,
-0.19799208641052246,
-0.6290079355239868,
-0.11925769597291946,
0.0029002041555941105,
-0.47867387533187866,
0.06030893325805664,
0.44779953360557556,
-0.4574337899684906,
0.6222981810569763,
0.49170011281967163,
-0.5203551054000854,
0.33529552817344666,
-0.3475794792175293,
0.21756145358085632,
-1.0485808849334717,
0.056877583265304565,
-0.40632134675979614,
-0.7744516134262085,
-0.5174527764320374,
0.45604562759399414,
0.2782215476036072,
-0.43384745717048645,
-0.6735804080963135,
0.5891538262367249,
-0.582288384437561,
-0.20267975330352783,
-0.09621698409318924,
-0.2885016202926636,
-0.04264233633875847,
0.33658313751220703,
0.18030047416687012,
0.9504463076591492,
0.5769891142845154,
-0.6831247210502625,
0.21407441794872284,
0.12398546934127808,
-0.08871769905090332,
0.6255958676338196,
-0.4223296344280243,
0.45367756485939026,
0.16258294880390167,
0.060852959752082825,
-0.9218447804450989,
-0.3901171386241913,
0.36075150966644287,
-0.3901011347770691,
0.22197343409061432,
-0.27254438400268555,
-0.6304927468299866,
-0.00042148615466430783,
-0.3618175685405731,
0.3265749216079712,
0.4851835370063782,
-0.5446994304656982,
0.7182300686836243,
0.5894303321838379,
0.03991986811161041,
-0.2625873386859894,
-0.7010310292243958,
0.1128634363412857,
-0.2621569037437439,
-0.840951144695282,
0.6968583464622498,
-0.19437463581562042,
-0.5289945602416992,
0.07304969429969788,
-0.11645972728729248,
-0.47254374623298645,
0.6216463446617126,
0.8150007128715515,
0.009109415113925934,
-0.20720802247524261,
-0.15655702352523804,
0.3256306052207947,
-0.14921461045742035,
0.22954225540161133,
-0.31879836320877075,
0.16603636741638184,
-0.2115190327167511,
-0.6670075058937073,
-1.0259790420532227,
0.7832502126693726,
0.36121171712875366,
-0.26275941729545593,
0.8320124745368958,
0.4360506236553192,
-0.5346968173980713,
-0.288943350315094,
-0.6606571078300476,
-0.2783675789833069,
-0.5416879653930664,
0.130644753575325,
-0.5675138831138611,
-1.0132604837417603,
0.6337530612945557,
-0.3747210204601288,
0.11918073147535324,
-0.12053216248750687,
0.6517957448959351,
-0.17968569695949554,
0.8280139565467834,
0.8701688647270203,
-0.10520656406879425,
0.4769841134548187,
-0.17908643186092377,
-0.02325049601495266,
-0.6797835230827332,
-0.27299216389656067,
-0.3169236481189728,
-0.2484530508518219,
-0.4543004631996155,
-0.5010538697242737,
0.3154646158218384,
0.31109893321990967,
-0.05067232996225357,
-0.3585032820701599,
-0.37053337693214417,
0.6892312169075012,
0.59996497631073,
0.4941680431365967,
0.1874421089887619,
0.09678962826728821,
0.07020224630832672,
0.09684048593044281,
-0.39233672618865967,
-0.6239165663719177,
1.0232112407684326,
0.4941345751285553,
0.9493710994720459,
0.2745858430862427,
1.224636197090149,
0.4383247494697571,
0.20946474373340607,
-0.5864725112915039,
0.6819962859153748,
0.18004977703094482,
-0.5222418904304504,
-0.05100161209702492,
-0.48375794291496277,
-0.6831158995628357,
0.4113460183143616,
0.004298853687942028,
-0.9322434067726135,
0.5219649076461792,
0.1873209923505783,
-0.48560255765914917,
0.4081234931945801,
-1.0417119264602661,
0.5867979526519775,
0.11434333026409149,
-0.8848863840103149,
0.11911872029304504,
-0.5711483955383301,
0.541886568069458,
0.16358895599842072,
-0.024886993691325188,
0.00510592432692647,
-0.4090905487537384,
0.7786689400672913,
-0.6876563429832458,
0.9540857076644897,
-0.6723203659057617,
-0.08912540972232819,
-0.03413959592580795,
0.5550523400306702,
0.6510686874389648,
0.5127218961715698,
-0.12285526096820831,
0.15727294981479645,
0.2247006893157959,
-0.47583574056625366,
-0.45001330971717834,
0.90858393907547,
-0.5584151148796082,
-0.8460347056388855,
-0.1360597461462021,
-0.5439348816871643,
-0.09274382144212723,
0.26401659846305847,
0.04205811396241188,
0.032507576048374176,
-0.11065909266471863,
0.40272191166877747,
1.0771915912628174,
0.0006355852237902582,
0.4898754358291626,
0.7278503775596619,
-0.2074737846851349,
-0.29001373052597046,
0.549292802810669,
-0.2310047447681427,
0.3369031548500061,
0.4191022217273712,
0.08993318676948547,
-0.42877689003944397,
-0.6597565412521362,
-0.29414260387420654,
0.17210106551647186,
-0.7666600346565247,
-0.1785138100385666,
-0.35681775212287903,
0.05259627848863602,
-0.48529666662216187,
-0.25492772459983826,
-0.35217007994651794,
-0.4055841863155365,
-0.50264573097229,
-0.33167213201522827,
0.07513818144798279,
0.5266285538673401,
-0.05746947601437569,
0.3065747320652008,
-0.27028435468673706,
0.34995847940444946,
-0.0936727523803711,
0.31036943197250366,
-0.4733613133430481,
-0.21285437047481537,
0.19564583897590637,
0.04532170668244362,
0.014557179994881153,
-0.8981060981750488,
0.13468895852565765,
0.11329655349254608,
0.8100669384002686,
0.611789882183075,
0.5202873349189758,
0.49761295318603516,
-0.020263491198420525,
1.0001487731933594,
-0.23400968313217163,
-1.0709973573684692,
0.25683796405792236,
-0.10045239329338074,
0.022648148238658905,
0.5253340005874634,
0.09409712255001068,
-0.16356834769248962,
-0.1778053194284439,
-0.7209069728851318,
-0.7719915509223938,
0.7107855081558228,
0.09179289638996124,
0.15711817145347595,
0.2817826569080353,
0.6284212470054626,
0.011039689183235168,
0.26923584938049316,
-0.5693975687026978,
-0.6675788164138794,
0.12560777366161346,
-0.03854120522737503,
0.2493913769721985,
-0.5834449529647827,
-0.3973926603794098,
-0.15643776953220367,
0.5555691123008728,
-0.005873875226825476,
0.6737715601921082,
0.41185903549194336,
-0.2093578279018402,
0.1686377376317978,
-0.13795043528079987,
0.4900091886520386,
0.6164016723632812,
0.06261340528726578,
0.34849002957344055,
0.1325896829366684,
-0.34269416332244873,
0.16299033164978027,
0.07349766790866852,
-0.6142767667770386,
-0.25819990038871765,
0.029691729694604874,
0.5850603580474854,
0.3562181293964386,
-0.09208426624536514,
0.8883223533630371,
-0.10483170300722122,
-0.41993802785873413,
-0.3201753497123718,
0.12012870609760284,
0.17087587714195251,
0.2315232753753662,
0.24166996777057648,
-0.007591502740979195,
0.2784571647644043,
0.03580044209957123,
0.28002339601516724,
0.4978986382484436,
0.06856001913547516,
-0.19445838034152985,
0.9057536125183105,
0.18517936766147614,
-0.47542038559913635,
0.28116002678871155,
-0.43457743525505066,
-0.27365586161613464,
0.2629581391811371,
0.5441853404045105,
0.9479482769966125,
-0.29487118124961853,
0.2140020728111267,
-0.2108529955148697,
0.07581627368927002,
0.07602842897176743,
0.41366955637931824,
-0.8177224397659302,
-0.4836287498474121,
-0.027567172423005104,
-0.5626131892204285,
-0.504100501537323,
0.029967328533530235,
-0.8458458781242371,
0.040543630719184875,
-0.7465090751647949,
-0.10564187169075012,
-0.37685370445251465,
0.06531708687543869,
-0.5123860239982605,
-0.2798658609390259,
0.2783118188381195,
0.8161720633506775,
-0.6167894601821899,
1.0912752151489258,
0.46975114941596985,
-0.06530307978391647,
-0.6170659065246582,
-0.07874539494514465,
0.39154666662216187,
-0.6527746319770813,
0.49245837330818176,
-0.24883639812469482,
-0.4488826394081116,
0.11583791673183441,
-0.6360135674476624,
-0.6955859661102295,
1.2560248374938965,
0.7641147375106812,
-0.32958224415779114,
0.12161873281002045,
0.06095259636640549,
0.10401875525712967,
-0.17422720789909363,
-0.08079898357391357,
0.34772035479545593,
0.43089479207992554,
-0.09047999233007431,
-0.8303689956665039,
0.21189570426940918,
-0.07671200484037399,
0.04509532079100609,
-0.13886529207229614,
-0.5307937860488892,
0.8400864601135254,
-0.10198269039392471,
-0.5052983164787292,
0.24276359379291534,
0.8404198288917542,
-0.01718788780272007,
0.3679322600364685,
0.22114044427871704,
0.18628820776939392,
1.1114100217819214,
-0.05819111689925194,
1.156644344329834,
-0.29786816239356995,
0.4036145508289337,
0.9682457447052002,
-0.5022261142730713,
0.7650924921035767,
0.5980241298675537,
-0.1491854190826416,
0.14520715177059174,
0.5774036049842834,
0.25966450572013855,
0.536017894744873,
0.12375593930482864,
-0.7167392373085022,
-0.27721506357192993,
0.011462558060884476,
-0.25637000799179077,
0.2333803027868271,
0.19044333696365356,
-0.5730544924736023,
-0.20290111005306244,
-0.028224214911460876,
0.31736767292022705,
0.07024838775396347,
-0.22826676070690155,
0.8492423295974731,
0.030617667362093925,
-0.24061256647109985,
0.5223104953765869,
0.6077129244804382,
0.6942576766014099,
-0.5791006684303284,
0.1486184000968933,
-0.46167296171188354,
0.4078351557254791,
-0.49084165692329407,
-0.4134269058704376,
0.09720094501972198,
-0.24503496289253235,
-0.2934204936027527,
-0.8255801200866699,
0.7421422004699707,
-0.21029353141784668,
-0.30892765522003174,
0.0000721672986401245,
0.2910011410713196,
0.22766180336475372,
-0.13231635093688965,
-0.6362456679344177,
0.10497080534696579,
0.015997422859072685,
-0.42426764965057373,
0.494251549243927,
0.20548132061958313,
-0.20850791037082672,
0.7345544695854187,
0.742093026638031,
0.16981005668640137,
0.11292491108179092,
-0.07404250651597977,
0.793165385723114,
-0.2531719505786896,
-0.7449015974998474,
-0.9042965173721313,
0.23346984386444092,
-0.18396063148975372,
-0.11522476375102997,
0.8785830140113831,
0.7306463718414307,
0.7171245217323303,
0.04846348986029625,
0.43054038286209106,
0.184524804353714,
0.45395100116729736,
-0.6105283498764038,
1.043333649635315,
-0.013652658089995384,
0.3428713083267212,
0.05986609309911728,
-0.43095844984054565,
-0.2877953350543976,
0.5028029680252075,
-0.244548499584198,
-0.2618156969547272,
0.5075168609619141,
1.3063738346099854,
-0.1944107860326767,
0.058641280978918076,
0.4903329610824585,
0.055633291602134705,
0.453462153673172,
0.5362138748168945,
0.6593060493469238,
-0.26486438512802124,
0.018483391031622887,
-0.6954813599586487,
-0.32041648030281067,
-0.03605865314602852,
-0.8006945252418518,
-0.7354123592376709,
-0.5952755808830261,
-0.3527901768684387,
-0.12771698832511902,
-0.04015554487705231,
0.7394818663597107,
1.1118613481521606,
-0.732654333114624,
-0.24713648855686188,
0.01563560590147972,
0.36784929037094116,
-0.14081567525863647,
-0.25182992219924927,
0.34238651394844055,
0.1678663045167923,
-0.5766593813896179,
0.6087450385093689,
0.12176091223955154,
0.00848996452987194,
-0.6450003981590271,
-0.26708582043647766,
0.03492296114563942,
-0.24121913313865662,
0.24779967963695526,
0.16906318068504333,
-0.8014654517173767,
-0.09955736249685287,
-0.16777868568897247,
0.005648416932672262,
-0.2709773778915405,
1.0043200254440308,
-0.6866301894187927,
0.33183059096336365,
0.37904092669487,
0.8277165293693542,
0.7257103323936462,
0.4219416379928589,
0.42164427042007446,
-0.8818902969360352,
0.44667455554008484,
0.32006925344467163,
0.37666699290275574,
0.19153785705566406,
-0.9042054414749146,
0.04578397050499916,
0.3923414945602417,
-0.5783007740974426,
-1.036155343055725,
0.236750066280365,
-0.6409763693809509,
-0.10111375898122787,
1.072329044342041,
-0.8055968284606934,
-0.6569668054580688,
-0.16194677352905273,
-0.1048271656036377,
-0.27605536580085754,
-0.36630281805992126,
0.21225199103355408,
0.45202144980430603,
-0.14441564679145813,
-0.22138381004333496,
-0.2739340364933014,
0.5985641479492188,
0.3465661108493805,
-0.6819140911102295,
0.36722332239151,
0.7418521642684937,
0.6188602447509766,
-0.28817692399024963,
1.0348150730133057,
-0.3981184661388397,
0.2618998885154724,
0.06181439012289047,
-0.22199468314647675,
-0.6661107540130615,
-0.15783998370170593,
-0.6575164794921875,
0.5473390221595764,
0.09919782727956772,
-0.553514301776886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12233v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12233v1
|
SyncVSR: Data-Efficient Visual Speech Recognition with End-to-End Crossmodal Audio Token Synchronization
| 2024-06-18T03:14:22 | 2024-06-18T03:14:22 |
Young Jin Ahn, Jungwoo Park, Sangha Park, Jonghyun Choi, Kee-Eung Kim
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Visual Speech Recognition (VSR) stands at the intersection of computer vision
and speech recognition, aiming to interpret spoken content from visual cues. A
prominent challenge in VSR is the presence of homophenes-visually similar lip
gestures that represent different phonemes. Prior approaches have sought to
distinguish fine-grained visemes by aligning visual and auditory semantics, but
often fell short of full synchronization. To address this, we present SyncVSR,
an end-to-end learning framework that leverages quantized audio for frame-level
crossmodal supervision. By integrating a projection layer that synchronizes
visual representation with acoustic data, our encoder learns to generate
discrete audio tokens from a video sequence in a non-autoregressive manner.
SyncVSR shows versatility across tasks, languages, and modalities at the cost
of a forward pass. Our empirical evaluations show that it not only achieves
state-of-the-art results but also reduces data usage by up to ninefold.
|
[
-0.03281329572200775,
-0.43855786323547363,
0.039592258632183075,
-0.047917500138282776,
-0.4945426285266876,
0.06576906144618988,
-0.040866054594516754,
-0.32107824087142944,
0.23503290116786957,
0.05075526237487793,
-0.4416775107383728,
-0.371058851480484,
-0.5078273415565491,
-0.11388177424669266,
-0.6877771019935608,
0.5164125561714172,
-0.04001495614647865,
0.3307715654373169,
-0.5667722821235657,
-0.4051694869995117,
-0.31434351205825806,
-0.34576019644737244,
-0.28556379675865173,
-0.07906726002693176,
0.18334230780601501,
0.2966131567955017,
0.6170225739479065,
0.9479156732559204,
0.4681227505207062,
0.3692002296447754,
-0.0016692352946847677,
0.09247871488332748,
-0.33431288599967957,
0.2911053001880646,
0.025563539937138557,
-0.33598971366882324,
-0.2591603696346283,
-0.25860628485679626,
0.47612643241882324,
0.373199462890625,
-0.32521766424179077,
0.4194379448890686,
-0.10743574798107147,
0.519725501537323,
-0.6452179551124573,
0.1899065524339676,
-0.4988083839416504,
0.3791825771331787,
-0.3889296352863312,
-0.4588605463504791,
-0.041241131722927094,
-0.03168832138180733,
0.433949738740921,
-0.7134338617324829,
0.1057807207107544,
0.03505183011293411,
0.6408359408378601,
0.5537484288215637,
-0.25532975792884827,
-0.06007733196020126,
-0.6729608774185181,
0.6560184359550476,
-0.02187115140259266,
1.0647177696228027,
0.2658822536468506,
0.5776858329772949,
0.2712060213088989,
-1.0399792194366455,
-0.7168921828269958,
0.30272501707077026,
0.479826420545578,
0.39304712414741516,
-0.30754968523979187,
-0.05689577758312225,
0.22357116639614105,
0.5001612901687622,
-0.8678531050682068,
-0.16096428036689758,
-0.33976227045059204,
-0.4416062831878662,
0.2410569041967392,
0.0812222883105278,
0.25728556513786316,
-0.1542753428220749,
-0.7977562546730042,
-0.39586934447288513,
-0.07767923921346664,
0.4178124666213989,
-0.09426027536392212,
0.13378769159317017,
-0.3164980709552765,
0.6516156792640686,
0.001061027287505567,
0.7637195587158203,
0.13347917795181274,
-0.2063978761434555,
0.4377661943435669,
-0.42539510130882263,
-0.6381143927574158,
0.39770546555519104,
0.725369930267334,
0.45321375131607056,
0.1658596694469452,
-0.1231403723359108,
-0.31588125228881836,
0.39898207783699036,
-0.030909856781363487,
-0.590461254119873,
-0.06294634938240051,
0.1096448227763176,
-0.31559479236602783,
0.21451067924499512,
0.0177912674844265,
-0.5015913844108582,
-0.024353446438908577,
-0.5697001218795776,
0.5576246380805969,
-0.4451352655887604,
0.019138498231768608,
-0.03060716763138771,
-0.4129484295845032,
0.42102956771850586,
0.3000861406326294,
-0.6637315154075623,
0.3730435371398926,
0.5766405463218689,
0.9302446842193604,
-0.00886607076972723,
-0.04214027523994446,
-1.0196900367736816,
0.28757399320602417,
-0.3133881688117981,
0.3750699460506439,
-0.6660820245742798,
-0.5479631423950195,
-0.05914142355322838,
-0.20339901745319366,
0.13129113614559174,
-0.7219743728637695,
0.15819676220417023,
-0.12259266525506973,
0.3776503801345825,
-0.31840214133262634,
-0.5582760572433472,
0.12395536154508591,
-0.21146851778030396,
-0.24369831383228302,
0.8527159690856934,
-0.06387080997228622,
-0.6472694873809814,
0.8043867945671082,
0.07150903344154358,
-0.3343808352947235,
0.29420316219329834,
-0.4601547122001648,
-0.5927734971046448,
0.05725064128637314,
0.09607820957899094,
0.3242442309856415,
-0.27990490198135376,
0.17824600636959076,
-0.10079426318407059,
-0.30546486377716064,
0.02407749556005001,
-0.4299285113811493,
0.3084363639354706,
0.2785056531429291,
-0.19080998003482819,
0.36739009618759155,
-1.0340468883514404,
-0.1263195276260376,
-0.17672859132289886,
0.00948647502809763,
-0.49282675981521606,
0.027121705934405327,
0.3856393098831177,
0.2774718105792999,
0.1502504199743271,
-0.6944978833198547,
-0.26447609066963196,
-0.004367093089967966,
0.627054750919342,
0.6921372413635254,
-0.4397009015083313,
0.5111657381057739,
-0.3369368314743042,
0.3565562963485718,
0.18766912817955017,
0.47210055589675903,
-0.5401953458786011,
-0.4316505491733551,
-0.6888770461082458,
-0.7004806995391846,
-0.006287869997322559,
0.6305945515632629,
-0.8149727582931519,
0.42807266116142273,
-0.4709208011627197,
-0.16936863958835602,
-0.7616637349128723,
0.06946314126253128,
0.6553348898887634,
0.5408631563186646,
0.4259069859981537,
-0.7406553030014038,
-0.8240672945976257,
-0.5807674527168274,
-0.03049737587571144,
-0.08341556042432785,
-0.03134588897228241,
0.3082166910171509,
0.3000052571296692,
-0.20877264440059662,
1.173295021057129,
0.22439546883106232,
-0.7197672724723816,
0.32237154245376587,
-0.0009953596163541079,
-0.14159609377384186,
0.4960993230342865,
0.20860902965068817,
-1.161530613899231,
-0.3797149062156677,
0.22831235826015472,
-0.7345720529556274,
0.0747210681438446,
-0.14449752867221832,
0.09178618341684341,
-0.10481157153844833,
0.7168473601341248,
-0.1274043619632721,
0.29028916358947754,
0.7095259428024292,
-0.26819097995758057,
-0.017676129937171936,
-0.06724898517131805,
-0.010952879674732685,
-1.0401039123535156,
-0.0764685869216919,
0.02264348790049553,
-0.6833993196487427,
-0.4893702566623688,
-0.7306858897209167,
-0.14842592179775238,
-0.3230282664299011,
-0.5802543759346008,
0.2919895350933075,
-0.4648878574371338,
-0.43339210748672485,
0.16496171057224274,
0.25830668210983276,
-0.24705719947814941,
0.3571959435939789,
0.17680373787879944,
0.8801921010017395,
0.8300278186798096,
-0.15240104496479034,
0.5835698246955872,
0.39543014764785767,
-0.12816421687602997,
0.8048149943351746,
-0.693541944026947,
0.018305227160453796,
-0.2259763926267624,
-0.08245515823364258,
-0.939274787902832,
-0.12824063003063202,
-0.03639283403754234,
-0.6916703581809998,
0.2642976641654968,
-0.16775773465633392,
-0.07499468326568604,
0.01367969624698162,
-0.21359984576702118,
0.4679078757762909,
0.6930949687957764,
-0.6865656971931458,
0.7482090592384338,
0.48213931918144226,
0.09146376699209213,
-0.541097104549408,
-0.9960749745368958,
0.04195751994848251,
0.03161030262708664,
-0.4142456352710724,
0.28188925981521606,
0.11840921640396118,
-0.013884847983717918,
0.10730139166116714,
-0.6690091490745544,
-0.14410534501075745,
-0.5766822695732117,
0.6979266405105591,
0.16754761338233948,
-0.08755585551261902,
-0.20147189497947693,
-0.22607091069221497,
-0.13970816135406494,
-0.04998502507805824,
-0.5885521769523621,
0.32734304666519165,
-0.03184763714671135,
-0.47311481833457947,
-0.7637897729873657,
0.3457085192203522,
0.9088532328605652,
-0.3891301453113556,
0.11763285845518112,
0.6368473172187805,
-0.22676913440227509,
-0.05125685781240463,
-0.30645275115966797,
0.16533365845680237,
-0.4836673438549042,
0.36986368894577026,
-0.36426159739494324,
-1.0250062942504883,
0.4840075671672821,
0.08933832496404648,
-0.10620924830436707,
-0.17777904868125916,
0.3715245723724365,
-0.13165132701396942,
0.7127529978752136,
0.4699605107307434,
-0.032214224338531494,
1.1307398080825806,
-0.1513279229402542,
0.013932646252214909,
-0.7663978934288025,
-0.6800329685211182,
0.018036803230643272,
-0.12405113130807877,
-0.5355808734893799,
-0.8949447274208069,
0.3344264328479767,
-0.08086902648210526,
-0.07159214466810226,
0.39444923400878906,
-0.403001993894577,
0.43465757369995117,
0.6813790202140808,
0.15970081090927124,
0.059811193495988846,
0.15667182207107544,
-0.08682755380868912,
-0.1656799018383026,
-0.5603700280189514,
0.0160299614071846,
0.6320514678955078,
0.16664598882198334,
0.7787618041038513,
-0.09733106940984726,
0.6072579622268677,
0.43430274724960327,
-0.4427482485771179,
-0.6129791736602783,
0.6268948316574097,
-0.08311348408460617,
-0.05089160054922104,
-0.2776215374469757,
-0.5135456323623657,
-0.512604296207428,
0.3253563940525055,
-0.2983986735343933,
-0.49355548620224,
0.5824149250984192,
0.3781592845916748,
-0.030520791187882423,
0.23406092822551727,
-0.3734589219093323,
0.6870779991149902,
-0.15362827479839325,
-0.5326977968215942,
0.017146870493888855,
-0.9925777912139893,
0.020862461999058723,
0.04962136596441269,
0.16832967102527618,
0.06226872652769089,
-0.14111018180847168,
0.5161228179931641,
-0.34642818570137024,
0.6987350583076477,
-0.19137679040431976,
0.054580915719270706,
0.18706049025058746,
-0.042325764894485474,
0.2788994312286377,
-0.1578701138496399,
0.42817848920822144,
0.09333374351263046,
-0.15018020570278168,
-0.23896221816539764,
-0.3669716417789459,
0.31904247403144836,
-0.40712395310401917,
-0.0017505250871181488,
-0.3697931468486786,
-0.47149407863616943,
-0.09341569244861603,
-0.006680995225906372,
0.1650652289390564,
0.8170750737190247,
-0.1577218919992447,
0.2154214233160019,
0.6402482390403748,
-0.21687571704387665,
0.5123512148857117,
0.16076989471912384,
-0.30373141169548035,
-0.9680664539337158,
1.1798129081726074,
0.0020946599543094635,
0.3539658486843109,
0.622048556804657,
-0.09493179619312286,
-0.225763201713562,
-0.13909253478050232,
-0.42436864972114563,
-0.12653926014900208,
-0.5990813970565796,
-0.04050752893090248,
-0.3694722354412079,
-0.00022710218036081642,
-0.29805347323417664,
-0.23845185339450836,
-0.6310519576072693,
-0.3529972434043884,
-0.30998995900154114,
0.09543661773204803,
0.25888386368751526,
-0.048992086201906204,
-0.23243845999240875,
0.28717315196990967,
-0.7597373127937317,
0.6612865328788757,
0.8747104406356812,
0.23013456165790558,
-0.3504873514175415,
-0.5423405170440674,
-0.26872962713241577,
-0.1770218312740326,
0.20720210671424866,
-0.5302662253379822,
0.4675770699977875,
0.5529887080192566,
0.31234490871429443,
0.6444830298423767,
-0.0782608836889267,
1.2509835958480835,
-0.6514530777931213,
0.7051903605461121,
0.8086914420127869,
-1.4505943059921265,
0.435181200504303,
-0.06251025944948196,
0.20516617596149445,
0.17056378722190857,
0.26755258440971375,
-0.7118036150932312,
-0.1217925027012825,
-0.20985166728496552,
-0.9960596561431885,
0.3516484797000885,
0.13724151253700256,
-0.10844530165195465,
0.03305954486131668,
-0.09169616550207138,
-0.0014280484756454825,
0.32668986916542053,
-0.3271740674972534,
-0.1314646601676941,
-0.6437429785728455,
-0.2815936803817749,
0.07434539496898651,
0.011225446127355099,
-0.018714269623160362,
-0.40795931220054626,
0.18125998973846436,
-0.1857883632183075,
0.2125767022371292,
0.6699654459953308,
-0.350745290517807,
-0.31676602363586426,
0.26285520195961,
0.4625298082828522,
0.28439879417419434,
0.0545823872089386,
0.23702672123908997,
0.1348380595445633,
-0.48120617866516113,
-0.040776390582323074,
0.04704335331916809,
0.14888499677181244,
0.10813789814710617,
0.4161423146724701,
1.1225484609603882,
0.17633625864982605,
-1.008711814880371,
0.9038797616958618,
-0.15371264517307281,
-0.23545682430267334,
-0.42132309079170227,
-0.2567739486694336,
-0.2753380835056305,
0.696625292301178,
0.3086581230163574,
0.19414152204990387,
0.23016460239887238,
-0.4950856566429138,
0.5896582007408142,
0.4150610566139221,
-0.8458713293075562,
-0.4594492018222809,
1.0922337770462036,
0.24746720492839813,
-0.2776768207550049,
0.4849163889884949,
0.22200194001197815,
-0.3426208198070526,
0.21692140400409698,
0.34901052713394165,
0.9016284942626953,
-0.38267192244529724,
0.08620518445968628,
-0.03151614964008331,
0.04411664605140686,
0.29425305128097534,
0.8863646984100342,
-0.8704562187194824,
-0.28142136335372925,
-0.40431609749794006,
-0.6759669780731201,
-0.5050026774406433,
-0.596177875995636,
-1.0089274644851685,
0.15000483393669128,
-0.3913414180278778,
-0.20516645908355713,
-0.17779482901096344,
-0.8342368602752686,
-0.2949248254299164,
0.25287002325057983,
0.577506422996521,
0.6620408892631531,
-0.838973343372345,
0.8650252819061279,
0.5034812092781067,
-0.339243084192276,
-0.3330891728401184,
-0.2813975512981415,
0.2370823621749878,
-0.7415866255760193,
0.6688722968101501,
0.07363211363554001,
-0.25958698987960815,
-0.03877547010779381,
-0.2584117352962494,
-0.67887943983078,
1.104030728340149,
0.3794114291667938,
-1.221411943435669,
-0.017669685184955597,
0.23792728781700134,
0.46789494156837463,
0.05281452462077141,
-0.006070172879844904,
0.17266876995563507,
-0.0038128856103867292,
0.4003393054008484,
-1.25699782371521,
-0.3049425184726715,
-0.29808926582336426,
0.21394142508506775,
0.3349526524543762,
-0.4990517795085907,
0.8593904376029968,
-0.30076590180397034,
-0.348039448261261,
-0.2608182430267334,
0.9994643926620483,
-0.027527272701263428,
0.4860673248767853,
0.6097082495689392,
0.6293690204620361,
0.6295012831687927,
-0.11009351909160614,
0.7096841931343079,
-0.21020430326461792,
0.14262057840824127,
1.0372486114501953,
-0.3434843420982361,
0.9870471954345703,
0.9085818529129028,
0.06647387892007828,
0.19338403642177582,
0.2996271550655365,
-0.05432998389005661,
0.9160939455032349,
0.12802790105342865,
-0.3596060276031494,
-0.4792262613773346,
-0.49042177200317383,
-0.22156719863414764,
0.6068750619888306,
0.1169726699590683,
-0.224151149392128,
0.12597838044166565,
0.5714113712310791,
-0.4759974479675293,
0.07132260501384735,
-0.2860604226589203,
0.916000485420227,
0.2425612360239029,
0.079771988093853,
0.4259839653968811,
-0.8703245520591736,
0.7151142358779907,
-0.577292263507843,
-0.25265073776245117,
0.15977546572685242,
0.2991447150707245,
-0.1958884745836258,
-0.6776089072227478,
0.1914932131767273,
0.05647796392440796,
-0.2559913694858551,
-0.5467491149902344,
0.2041412591934204,
-0.7937307953834534,
-0.05244787409901619,
0.3871031105518341,
0.3577486276626587,
-0.07022646814584732,
0.24814020097255707,
-0.41610103845596313,
0.17279863357543945,
-0.14546141028404236,
0.018012892454862595,
0.1310538798570633,
0.5722594261169434,
-0.06685619801282883,
0.7097976207733154,
0.8101425766944885,
0.12622977793216705,
0.3508601784706116,
0.10501015186309814,
0.7144884467124939,
-0.6192772388458252,
-0.6545410752296448,
-0.6236417293548584,
0.48941275477409363,
0.050007037818431854,
-0.26274847984313965,
0.7934885621070862,
0.8746126294136047,
1.246076226234436,
0.15507373213768005,
0.5725970268249512,
0.03031308948993683,
0.26475653052330017,
-0.4975818693637848,
0.1545134037733078,
-0.7372543215751648,
0.0272743571549654,
-0.38252344727516174,
-0.5642958879470825,
-0.3228761553764343,
0.5599921941757202,
0.26439163088798523,
-0.24839654564857483,
0.2894648015499115,
0.42393699288368225,
-0.19861644506454468,
0.05524686351418495,
0.5712807178497314,
-0.009149028919637203,
0.09660156071186066,
0.5272178649902344,
0.8862252235412598,
-0.5528782606124878,
0.5643460750579834,
-0.2365344762802124,
-0.03842048719525337,
0.10084620118141174,
-0.49507129192352295,
-0.7368809580802917,
-0.8569438457489014,
-0.37641283869743347,
-0.02361958473920822,
0.4272703230381012,
1.0940204858779907,
0.9717934131622314,
-0.5022387504577637,
-0.3793354332447052,
-0.10121499001979828,
-0.3211619257926941,
-0.3369009792804718,
-0.10693179816007614,
0.16185949742794037,
0.016487296670675278,
-0.7620611190795898,
0.518847644329071,
0.5470952987670898,
0.284683495759964,
0.1403340995311737,
-0.3554418087005615,
0.23158347606658936,
-0.0781225711107254,
0.5641655921936035,
0.3766355514526367,
-0.6867762804031372,
-0.12909576296806335,
0.08835598826408386,
0.06500723958015442,
0.2670791745185852,
0.8099014163017273,
-0.9337600469589233,
0.9239570498466492,
0.7487337589263916,
0.4642355144023895,
0.7325988411903381,
-0.09325028210878372,
0.5059342980384827,
-0.8299795389175415,
0.2325824499130249,
0.1211400181055069,
0.49884629249572754,
0.4241253733634949,
0.19351531565189362,
0.20396989583969116,
0.4883209466934204,
-0.42524123191833496,
-0.9617390036582947,
0.02673441171646118,
-1.4733059406280518,
0.03483845666050911,
0.6653565168380737,
0.0433882474899292,
-0.3697958290576935,
0.04518578201532364,
-0.1665593981742859,
0.43836963176727295,
-0.5041571855545044,
0.07985690236091614,
-0.038893163204193115,
-0.11217610538005829,
-0.43141043186187744,
-0.36152103543281555,
0.3959203362464905,
0.3099920153617859,
-0.48525241017341614,
0.2606104016304016,
0.6178237199783325,
0.19979695975780487,
0.05423962324857712,
0.39391958713531494,
-0.18229807913303375,
0.5630123615264893,
0.18490183353424072,
0.18226827681064606,
-0.29981252551078796,
-0.4053081274032593,
-0.5465265512466431,
0.03386680409312248,
-0.6397973299026489,
-0.8449521064758301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12232v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12232v1
|
"You Gotta be a Doctor, Lin": An Investigation of Name-Based Bias of Large Language Models in Employment Recommendations
| 2024-06-18T03:11:43 | 2024-06-18T03:11:43 |
Huy Nghiem, John Prindle, Jieyu Zhao, Hal Daumé III
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Social science research has shown that candidates with names indicative of
certain races or genders often face discrimination in employment practices.
Similarly, Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated racial and gender
biases in various applications. In this study, we utilize GPT-3.5-Turbo and
Llama 3-70B-Instruct to simulate hiring decisions and salary recommendations
for candidates with 320 first names that strongly signal their race and gender,
across over 750,000 prompts. Our empirical results indicate a preference among
these models for hiring candidates with White female-sounding names over other
demographic groups across 40 occupations. Additionally, even among candidates
with identical qualifications, salary recommendations vary by as much as 5%
between different subgroups. A comparison with real-world labor data reveals
inconsistent alignment with U.S. labor market characteristics, underscoring the
necessity of risk investigation of LLM-powered systems.
|
[
-0.10774420201778412,
-0.3307195007801056,
0.9007689952850342,
-0.138671413064003,
-0.08355319499969482,
-0.020944982767105103,
-0.13092166185379028,
-0.6317163109779358,
0.566626250743866,
0.37013885378837585,
-0.4831429123878479,
-0.22903071343898773,
-0.7895551323890686,
-0.06727910786867142,
-0.4285692274570465,
1.062161922454834,
0.3280707895755768,
0.6066262722015381,
0.17814384400844574,
0.12305789440870285,
-0.43695148825645447,
-0.41680118441581726,
-0.7260392904281616,
-0.20452232658863068,
0.8131780028343201,
0.28127866983413696,
1.0224814414978027,
0.5820707678794861,
0.23308320343494415,
0.17679749429225922,
-0.1675928384065628,
-0.1649671196937561,
-0.3203040361404419,
0.2351231575012207,
-0.3716033697128296,
-0.44273003935813904,
-0.39851996302604675,
0.370535671710968,
0.1199982687830925,
1.0323108434677124,
-0.07976485043764114,
0.5031629800796509,
-0.49656617641448975,
0.7693855166435242,
-0.5809054970741272,
-0.1765291541814804,
-0.728756844997406,
0.00519173638895154,
-0.22353897988796234,
0.09366192668676376,
-0.21859432756900787,
-0.8140537142753601,
0.4479905366897583,
-0.21794576942920685,
0.30747172236442566,
0.2501629590988159,
1.0127718448638916,
-0.048498302698135376,
-0.5699747800827026,
-0.12067078053951263,
-0.8625622987747192,
0.5454483032226562,
-0.6035988926887512,
0.48107632994651794,
0.5242743492126465,
0.4119560420513153,
0.09232795983552933,
-0.44639354944229126,
-0.367950439453125,
-0.2289523184299469,
-0.1100681871175766,
-0.17359761893749237,
0.09075330942869186,
0.09181768447160721,
0.503113329410553,
0.19772137701511383,
-0.37180066108703613,
0.48842576146125793,
-0.7251109480857849,
-0.08492955565452576,
0.8503598570823669,
0.33982184529304504,
0.33183085918426514,
0.3697783946990967,
-0.0963241308927536,
-0.032241977751255035,
-0.8151317834854126,
-0.01830030232667923,
0.9037665724754333,
0.17885132133960724,
-0.017614299431443214,
0.490023672580719,
-0.2975870370864868,
0.7077015042304993,
-0.018054384738206863,
-0.0738612487912178,
0.04443460702896118,
-0.02822118066251278,
-0.3198389708995819,
0.3196062445640564,
0.7271143794059753,
0.5805901288986206,
0.7327799201011658,
-0.20932091772556305,
-0.0051105874590575695,
-0.05172977223992348,
0.4503158628940582,
-0.4875478744506836,
-0.10697411000728607,
0.01714571937918663,
-0.40984031558036804,
-0.4019255042076111,
-0.06314238905906677,
-0.7697536945343018,
-0.7989639639854431,
-0.29163530468940735,
0.03462253510951996,
0.03229062259197235,
-0.24688497185707092,
-0.09143248945474625,
-0.07190018892288208,
0.1563345342874527,
0.3187197744846344,
-1.178490400314331,
-0.007416729815304279,
0.6320484280586243,
0.39553385972976685,
-0.11707008630037308,
-0.2307155281305313,
-0.3265444338321686,
0.05926244705915451,
-0.3819117248058319,
0.4827538728713989,
-0.6502842307090759,
-0.5334491729736328,
-0.07657879590988159,
0.13354375958442688,
0.05876496061682701,
-0.4790956676006317,
0.3322484791278839,
-0.46035441756248474,
0.07072337716817856,
-0.5541210174560547,
-0.3168974816799164,
-0.054785069078207016,
-0.030163301154971123,
-0.44046714901924133,
0.6289713382720947,
0.3707183003425598,
-0.5343376994132996,
0.9306461215019226,
-0.31647083163261414,
-0.3927804231643677,
0.10433728992938995,
-0.6446695923805237,
-0.2930186986923218,
0.19089950621128082,
-0.046275872737169266,
0.3085765242576599,
-0.4902540147304535,
0.5592637658119202,
-0.22922353446483612,
-0.41186901926994324,
0.2425670325756073,
-0.19011467695236206,
0.946383535861969,
0.01261158287525177,
-0.4567575752735138,
-0.029444444924592972,
-0.3740319609642029,
-0.1439579874277115,
0.04413537308573723,
-0.05929483845829964,
-0.421733021736145,
0.05168559402227402,
-0.19002540409564972,
0.057481683790683746,
-0.1515689194202423,
-0.6795417666435242,
0.418649286031723,
-0.2813242971897125,
0.03191570192575455,
0.9682456254959106,
-0.35103487968444824,
0.2171308696269989,
-0.3862631916999817,
0.7707825899124146,
-0.15165218710899353,
-0.038741644471883774,
0.4380221664905548,
-0.575433611869812,
-0.5281273722648621,
-0.07573956996202469,
0.5213886499404907,
0.550014317035675,
-0.32987409830093384,
-0.04120391979813576,
-0.08384012430906296,
-0.6656365394592285,
-0.5636864304542542,
-0.026581143960356712,
0.09230790287256241,
0.4382696747779846,
0.0030536120757460594,
-0.03324861451983452,
-0.7373009920120239,
-1.277432918548584,
-0.6880583763122559,
-0.36577361822128296,
-0.11484959721565247,
0.6444105505943298,
0.34556248784065247,
-0.4218043386936188,
1.0120275020599365,
-0.7449284195899963,
0.011530921794474125,
0.0748574510216713,
-0.1700097769498825,
0.6920618414878845,
0.16203927993774414,
0.7288998961448669,
-0.335141658782959,
-0.4384177029132843,
-0.03898794576525688,
-0.23827819526195526,
-0.26952606439590454,
0.08539468795061111,
-0.44762498140335083,
-0.13944396376609802,
0.41629353165626526,
-0.23899483680725098,
0.3635018467903137,
0.7198337316513062,
-0.5905728340148926,
0.9727606773376465,
-0.150407612323761,
-0.29285767674446106,
-0.9378423094749451,
0.12386267632246017,
0.2764385938644409,
-0.23738668859004974,
-0.45028409361839294,
-0.2473289519548416,
-0.06409800052642822,
-0.19053056836128235,
-0.31179046630859375,
0.7391981482505798,
-0.48274746537208557,
-0.12118768692016602,
-0.13479894399642944,
-0.12697415053844452,
-0.3031422197818756,
0.0164888184517622,
-0.1387944519519806,
0.723969042301178,
0.5027778148651123,
-0.9396336674690247,
0.4494885802268982,
0.10247968882322311,
-0.48272812366485596,
0.7461239099502563,
-0.7259228825569153,
0.27020594477653503,
-0.09512725472450256,
0.26823124289512634,
-0.7722204327583313,
-0.26154470443725586,
-0.15102282166481018,
0.012525349855422974,
0.0597948394715786,
-0.10909204185009003,
-0.24329619109630585,
-0.7296143174171448,
-0.050577472895383835,
0.6034862399101257,
0.3732013702392578,
-0.45082077383995056,
0.1716204583644867,
0.6139014363288879,
-0.45099106431007385,
-0.633838951587677,
-0.7180947661399841,
-0.06536245346069336,
-0.17690244317054749,
-0.3781755864620209,
0.35190412402153015,
-0.13931092619895935,
-0.41669532656669617,
-0.2825174629688263,
0.022572576999664307,
-0.45637667179107666,
0.11140543222427368,
0.2849500775337219,
0.7021782994270325,
-0.08568171411752701,
0.03585099056363106,
-0.2102840393781662,
0.017371147871017456,
0.2798583507537842,
-0.038777079433202744,
0.29230985045433044,
0.35092291235923767,
-0.34036073088645935,
-0.06535954028367996,
0.028662240132689476,
0.7276571393013,
0.1675363928079605,
0.5448859930038452,
0.46935105323791504,
-0.1701178401708603,
0.013113930821418762,
-0.7526276707649231,
-0.3585909903049469,
-0.45399755239486694,
0.3936270773410797,
0.0946284607052803,
-0.851935625076294,
0.4087950885295868,
0.0409354604780674,
0.13153484463691711,
0.310372918844223,
0.7155821919441223,
-0.01588459312915802,
1.0124675035476685,
0.571033775806427,
-0.4338742792606354,
0.2575260400772095,
0.16125045716762543,
0.4430476427078247,
-0.6298438310623169,
-0.05716397240757942,
-0.4407069981098175,
-0.7810280323028564,
-0.7742727994918823,
-0.1332707703113556,
0.37387242913246155,
-0.5307071805000305,
-0.26076027750968933,
0.007710527162998915,
-0.6858416795730591,
0.5720415115356445,
0.5103022456169128,
-0.09113102406263351,
0.005894388072192669,
-0.10796405375003815,
-0.23131056129932404,
-0.10389041155576706,
-0.19733034074306488,
-0.2911662459373474,
1.203712821006775,
0.5194478631019592,
0.836036205291748,
0.22168409824371338,
0.4132061302661896,
0.24032998085021973,
0.34796690940856934,
-0.4886675775051117,
0.3193170428276062,
-0.3946012556552887,
-1.0792111158370972,
-0.5031985640525818,
-0.18468095362186432,
-0.9622048735618591,
0.30380845069885254,
-0.2026059627532959,
-0.8664501905441284,
0.41684192419052124,
0.028788667172193527,
-0.3902536928653717,
0.42298200726509094,
-0.4180010259151459,
0.4467878043651581,
-0.534763514995575,
-0.06753916293382645,
0.12064038962125778,
-0.31845033168792725,
0.7308139801025391,
-0.1973579078912735,
0.3535924255847931,
-0.4785451889038086,
0.11483196914196014,
0.555080771446228,
-0.6957385540008545,
0.7076727151870728,
-0.1864812970161438,
-0.05709570646286011,
-0.33412104845046997,
0.1594819575548172,
0.6514665484428406,
0.23386862874031067,
-0.6876728534698486,
0.44404175877571106,
0.08093616366386414,
-0.13238662481307983,
-0.16540345549583435,
0.5718312859535217,
-0.7120648622512817,
-0.6442257761955261,
-0.44297951459884644,
-0.5953958034515381,
-0.2822759747505188,
0.24879325926303864,
0.47293156385421753,
0.005124656483530998,
-0.18199098110198975,
-0.04163533076643944,
0.2231505811214447,
-0.3588492274284363,
-0.1998596489429474,
0.5417255163192749,
-0.42787882685661316,
-0.07671348005533218,
0.6243482232093811,
0.23066368699073792,
0.10431405156850815,
-0.4532397389411926,
0.25363829731941223,
-0.16527263820171356,
-0.061961814761161804,
-0.5033199787139893,
0.5560303926467896,
-0.2983604967594147,
-0.00970898475497961,
-0.49674269556999207,
-0.3961900770664215,
-0.3577071726322174,
-0.26547443866729736,
-0.14923050999641418,
-0.05246206745505333,
-0.025614049285650253,
-0.24445071816444397,
0.3331015110015869,
1.0618517398834229,
0.34507450461387634,
0.1433776617050171,
0.04872254654765129,
0.26949477195739746,
0.7317494750022888,
0.6759213209152222,
-0.16800126433372498,
-0.348244845867157,
-0.12615583837032318,
0.05064181610941887,
-0.05535469576716423,
-0.8532668352127075,
0.36788973212242126,
-0.027228567749261856,
0.7752559781074524,
0.44911468029022217,
-0.06992609053850174,
0.23845836520195007,
-0.5314337611198425,
0.7648602724075317,
0.22562859952449799,
-0.5443136096000671,
0.31420621275901794,
-0.4112814962863922,
0.01974504441022873,
0.7579955458641052,
0.28698477149009705,
-0.661526083946228,
-0.4104371666908264,
-0.48140469193458557,
-0.9794304370880127,
0.9308673143386841,
-0.08659728616476059,
0.3079373240470886,
-0.12094728648662567,
0.2812311053276062,
0.2777421474456787,
0.29213833808898926,
-0.6932746171951294,
-0.7106826901435852,
0.3439146876335144,
0.049196165055036545,
0.005349410232156515,
-0.7294601798057556,
-0.23024852573871613,
-0.3377656936645508,
0.51387619972229,
0.13275645673274994,
0.09390376508235931,
0.05724700540304184,
-0.012827016413211823,
-0.054485831409692764,
0.3226677477359772,
0.9533053040504456,
0.6983098387718201,
-0.08837714046239853,
0.05876205116510391,
0.5221583843231201,
-0.5183113217353821,
0.35920530557632446,
-0.11580713838338852,
-0.0068270619958639145,
0.47720620036125183,
-0.09012794494628906,
0.8725457191467285,
0.13550305366516113,
-0.42482835054397583,
0.3491858243942261,
-0.10152404755353928,
-0.5391381978988647,
-0.3741961121559143,
0.047384995967149734,
0.16223816573619843,
0.0665227472782135,
0.24938537180423737,
-0.338559627532959,
-0.050432268530130386,
-0.6144947409629822,
-0.2986239492893219,
0.5806662440299988,
-0.5401124954223633,
0.06506078690290451,
0.841580331325531,
0.44099661707878113,
-0.4098494052886963,
0.607459306716919,
-0.2547261416912079,
-0.4698109030723572,
0.7335073351860046,
0.3585214614868164,
0.7387555241584778,
-0.3678436577320099,
0.23524600267410278,
0.32924604415893555,
0.18341264128684998,
-0.3015017807483673,
0.12398568540811539,
0.42434120178222656,
-0.6412895917892456,
-0.1570787876844406,
-0.6368195414543152,
-0.7120270133018494,
0.02343134395778179,
-0.3699108362197876,
0.501826286315918,
-0.653483510017395,
-0.46197280287742615,
0.13814875483512878,
-0.5023337006568909,
-0.9205278158187866,
0.24051928520202637,
0.400941401720047,
0.6912631988525391,
-0.8318955898284912,
0.6995270252227783,
0.8958456516265869,
-0.10154660791158676,
-1.109747052192688,
0.02600395306944847,
0.15533500909805298,
-0.8735687136650085,
1.2904243469238281,
-0.05058008059859276,
0.21727384626865387,
-0.2590485215187073,
-0.10784545540809631,
-0.957946240901947,
1.1538058519363403,
0.8235517740249634,
-0.736766517162323,
-0.3616061508655548,
0.14652949571609497,
0.2300603687763214,
-0.4076142907142639,
0.8750062584877014,
0.6082421541213989,
0.6488905549049377,
-0.34875476360321045,
-1.4101959466934204,
-0.14941425621509552,
0.12605436146259308,
0.1758374273777008,
0.04885222390294075,
-0.5445943474769592,
1.1744613647460938,
-0.4578431248664856,
0.028650375083088875,
-0.28877758979797363,
0.21919022500514984,
0.5472129583358765,
0.304948627948761,
0.71372389793396,
0.05923481658101082,
1.1984503269195557,
0.0011478380765765905,
1.1320922374725342,
-0.47724878787994385,
0.38803666830062866,
0.7774034142494202,
-0.528579831123352,
0.0719657763838768,
0.22630575299263,
-0.44725146889686584,
0.890987753868103,
0.6073523759841919,
-0.2395063042640686,
0.15418283641338348,
0.48945215344429016,
-0.07770227640867233,
0.05486733466386795,
-0.32013392448425293,
-0.6975221633911133,
0.43854984641075134,
0.1822873204946518,
-0.8145483732223511,
0.03235616907477379,
-0.2941400706768036,
0.04200960323214531,
-0.19240568578243256,
-0.274146169424057,
0.30232951045036316,
0.23761790990829468,
-0.5427181124687195,
0.1897275447845459,
-0.13631774485111237,
0.8894123435020447,
-0.5353694558143616,
0.0863204151391983,
-0.07855231314897537,
-0.1350206732749939,
-0.47853684425354004,
-0.6317765116691589,
0.004973973613232374,
-0.024797452613711357,
-0.5365203022956848,
0.0023304917849600315,
0.5158119797706604,
-0.35595691204071045,
-0.7054433822631836,
0.25530147552490234,
0.32352274656295776,
0.29349616169929504,
0.04773122817277908,
-0.45235973596572876,
-0.2952764630317688,
0.13383197784423828,
-0.10654060542583466,
0.3793414533138275,
0.0986938551068306,
-0.03094254806637764,
0.5929402709007263,
0.6488519906997681,
0.7321394085884094,
0.019395120441913605,
0.3337204158306122,
0.4267118573188782,
-0.7552430629730225,
-0.8288120031356812,
-1.0164326429367065,
0.18180549144744873,
-0.1476002037525177,
-0.3530243933200836,
0.34507396817207336,
0.39745044708251953,
0.5276026129722595,
-0.14675410091876984,
0.6766893863677979,
0.238553985953331,
0.6732940077781677,
-0.439435213804245,
0.8310863971710205,
-0.4745887219905853,
0.3489956259727478,
-0.5580742955207825,
-1.097962737083435,
0.19255714118480682,
0.34631553292274475,
-0.5169165730476379,
0.596542477607727,
0.6520902514457703,
0.6638237237930298,
-0.058083683252334595,
-0.11057471483945847,
0.5804503560066223,
0.10846685618162155,
0.0962282195687294,
0.284466028213501,
0.3088476061820984,
0.043409910053014755,
0.2719622552394867,
-0.06470128148794174,
0.12146750092506409,
-0.8300224542617798,
-0.7509585022926331,
-0.49888715147972107,
-0.010064474307000637,
-0.38923701643943787,
-0.3760465085506439,
0.0288508590310812,
0.7585828900337219,
0.9473865032196045,
-0.6999797224998474,
-0.38913866877555847,
0.44443216919898987,
0.2733278274536133,
-0.022548219189047813,
-0.2447093278169632,
-0.01803469844162464,
0.07061852514743805,
-0.6657121181488037,
0.4352315664291382,
0.011861425824463367,
-0.2069619745016098,
-0.31888315081596375,
-0.012987473048269749,
-0.03846871107816696,
-0.051056165248155594,
0.23693226277828217,
0.3850337862968445,
-0.9311537146568298,
-0.40874183177948,
-0.3037770092487335,
-0.5207228064537048,
-0.3343776762485504,
0.8882461190223694,
-0.5323353409767151,
0.5446290969848633,
0.10599249601364136,
0.5372114777565002,
0.16724544763565063,
0.001501753693446517,
1.0063375234603882,
-0.6712033748626709,
0.11409934610128403,
0.026909252628684044,
0.4780346155166626,
0.04448382928967476,
-0.8119509220123291,
0.7673770785331726,
0.14909255504608154,
-0.8227190375328064,
-0.9237527847290039,
0.19486524164676666,
-0.670315146446228,
-0.21748001873493195,
1.3306150436401367,
0.4763689339160919,
0.1429813653230667,
-0.13201294839382172,
-0.25323769450187683,
0.0874517634510994,
-0.4834536015987396,
0.6719744205474854,
0.8146066069602966,
-0.1411912590265274,
0.029736217111349106,
-1.1579225063323975,
0.43873971700668335,
0.6110959053039551,
-0.1805214285850525,
-0.048707254230976105,
0.18555723130702972,
0.589065432548523,
-0.15170574188232422,
0.8705311417579651,
0.2393260896205902,
0.46629971265792847,
-0.3196476101875305,
0.3278457820415497,
-0.12737169861793518,
0.23399928212165833,
-0.2750440835952759,
-0.2735648453235626,
0.5241700410842896,
0.07332726567983627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12230v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12230v1
|
MCSD: An Efficient Language Model with Diverse Fusion
| 2024-06-18T03:08:01 | 2024-06-18T03:08:01 |
Hua Yang, Duohai Li, Shiman Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Transformers excel in Natural Language Processing (NLP) due to their prowess
in capturing long-term dependencies but suffer from exponential resource
consumption with increasing sequence lengths. To address these challenges, we
propose MCSD model, an efficient language model with linear scaling and fast
inference speed. MCSD model leverages diverse feature fusion, primarily through
the multi-channel slope and decay (MCSD) block, to robustly represent features.
This block comprises slope and decay sections that extract features across
diverse temporal receptive fields, facilitating capture of both local and
global information. In addition, MCSD block conducts element-wise fusion of
diverse features to further enhance the delicate feature extraction capability.
For inference, we formulate the inference process into a recurrent
representation, slashing space complexity to $O(1)$ and time complexity to
$O(N)$ respectively. Our experiments show that MCSD attains higher throughput
and lower GPU memory consumption compared to Transformers, while maintaining
comparable performance to larger-scale language learning models on benchmark
tests. These attributes position MCSD as a promising base for edge deployment
and embodied intelligence.
|
[
-0.6943217515945435,
-0.8420630693435669,
0.3602203130722046,
0.23495608568191528,
-0.05405966192483902,
0.3976573646068573,
-0.16156788170337677,
-0.32707101106643677,
0.2098589390516281,
0.5672048926353455,
-0.644459068775177,
-0.4536096155643463,
-0.6010227799415588,
-0.13740822672843933,
-0.414948970079422,
0.8370665907859802,
0.3902263939380646,
-0.1181197464466095,
-0.021120740100741386,
-0.25003841519355774,
-0.15792439877986908,
-0.14213845133781433,
-0.637728214263916,
-0.34340712428092957,
0.29071351885795593,
0.14521093666553497,
1.0429987907409668,
0.9323855638504028,
0.39361122250556946,
0.3587714731693268,
-0.11001608520746231,
0.06091201305389404,
-0.4260028004646301,
0.16920584440231323,
-0.3545503616333008,
-0.1735459864139557,
-0.5320509672164917,
-0.165588840842247,
0.6284148097038269,
0.9740456938743591,
-0.20701126754283905,
0.12113002687692642,
-0.14946159720420837,
0.3812532126903534,
-0.670635998249054,
-0.11842570453882217,
-0.811927855014801,
-0.18575941026210785,
-0.0906372144818306,
0.3181154131889343,
-0.5002630949020386,
-0.06306581944227219,
0.1090315654873848,
-0.3029366731643677,
0.39406681060791016,
-0.2670041620731354,
0.6258596181869507,
0.36875346302986145,
-0.35859328508377075,
-0.2806623876094818,
-0.7788058519363403,
1.027342438697815,
-0.5911234617233276,
0.8636611104011536,
0.1932062953710556,
0.537852942943573,
-0.11409568786621094,
-0.9758611917495728,
-0.632473886013031,
-0.11079882085323334,
0.21921661496162415,
-0.06265987455844879,
-0.039832718670368195,
0.17592091858386993,
0.1713731437921524,
0.34643951058387756,
-0.374159574508667,
0.3079918324947357,
-0.1158611997961998,
-0.3554125130176544,
0.5362330675125122,
0.2571670413017273,
0.5098832845687866,
-0.5053569674491882,
-0.37094005942344666,
-0.20724919438362122,
-0.3490479290485382,
0.06763984262943268,
0.25099918246269226,
0.6146448850631714,
-0.22801031172275543,
0.5562706589698792,
-0.0485430583357811,
0.7596588134765625,
-0.30916497111320496,
-0.4509207010269165,
0.21502244472503662,
-0.40101200342178345,
-0.06667418777942657,
-0.1315287947654724,
0.6653649210929871,
0.04519149288535118,
-0.10224778950214386,
-0.14628997445106506,
-0.13941578567028046,
0.40119287371635437,
0.3144080638885498,
-0.7424936890602112,
-0.2249513566493988,
0.29930415749549866,
-0.48587921261787415,
0.14199578762054443,
-0.15360839664936066,
-1.168358325958252,
-0.41948190331459045,
-0.18563731014728546,
0.02095959708094597,
-0.6113324761390686,
-0.5156981945037842,
0.008580217137932777,
-0.2937208116054535,
0.025902343913912773,
0.10443790256977081,
-0.9869977235794067,
0.5491297245025635,
0.754941999912262,
1.0097110271453857,
-0.3839031159877777,
-0.2697766125202179,
-0.5344247221946716,
0.03736431524157524,
0.09608037024736404,
0.6952385306358337,
-0.8563442230224609,
-0.5505782961845398,
-0.3034978210926056,
-0.3739919066429138,
0.061659712344408035,
-0.3436855375766754,
0.4917447566986084,
-0.2162601798772812,
-0.2511858642101288,
0.06900661438703537,
-0.25407275557518005,
-0.035710789263248444,
-0.10048197954893112,
-0.8719136118888855,
1.1610865592956543,
0.20412974059581757,
-0.6545831561088562,
0.1636764109134674,
-0.6090479493141174,
-0.4170851707458496,
0.1571795493364334,
-0.20141838490962982,
-0.2417006939649582,
0.12347818911075592,
0.38113173842430115,
0.5443567633628845,
-0.3510403335094452,
0.326904833316803,
-0.5811293125152588,
-0.15431243181228638,
-0.010720165446400642,
-0.5832808613777161,
0.6346509456634521,
0.32622984051704407,
-0.22878451645374298,
-0.04834078997373581,
-1.072773814201355,
-0.08893292397260666,
0.03798691928386688,
-0.24355120956897736,
-0.33592280745506287,
0.1964542418718338,
-0.038666218519210815,
0.3421277105808258,
-0.057805631309747696,
-0.7316223978996277,
0.06005648523569107,
-0.10939040780067444,
0.4584137797355652,
0.5751546621322632,
-0.1409214437007904,
0.7080929279327393,
-0.04381402209401131,
0.4654533863067627,
0.015635548159480095,
0.013763830997049809,
-0.5311217904090881,
-0.5991072654724121,
-0.5346156358718872,
-0.9165188074111938,
0.17829646170139313,
0.33159852027893066,
-0.9176977276802063,
0.2879289984703064,
-0.5244885087013245,
-0.6806707382202148,
-0.9701146483421326,
0.19286833703517914,
0.3014325201511383,
0.5518417954444885,
0.6015525460243225,
-0.02021993324160576,
-0.46046605706214905,
-1.0212129354476929,
-0.10596770793199539,
0.11481180787086487,
-0.2847682535648346,
0.16016443073749542,
0.2596867084503174,
-0.537432849407196,
1.146971344947815,
-0.5632506012916565,
0.015553590841591358,
-0.624440610408783,
0.2520335018634796,
0.04756385460495949,
0.3405945897102356,
0.3588181138038635,
-0.8587487936019897,
-0.176627516746521,
-0.06402279436588287,
-0.39837124943733215,
-0.15761642158031464,
-0.24055860936641693,
-0.08796782791614532,
0.06249074265360832,
0.43351051211357117,
-0.6833832859992981,
0.25629937648773193,
0.831244945526123,
-0.13515707850456238,
0.20290854573249817,
-0.08258002251386642,
-0.15771034359931946,
-1.062065839767456,
0.08776678144931793,
0.04283135011792183,
-0.21085546910762787,
-0.7419649362564087,
0.048677269369363785,
0.14487867057323456,
-0.3889528810977936,
-0.5309453010559082,
0.587846577167511,
-0.4380611777305603,
-0.25946947932243347,
-0.1885678619146347,
0.5230830907821655,
-0.1196570172905922,
0.572243332862854,
0.016256825998425484,
0.5431149005889893,
0.4155239164829254,
-0.9219617247581482,
0.1675713211297989,
0.03142472356557846,
-0.05658042058348656,
0.6110525727272034,
-0.42645716667175293,
-0.12814795970916748,
-0.23280271887779236,
0.2534271776676178,
-0.9433582425117493,
0.03320565074682236,
-0.2615290582180023,
-0.23687848448753357,
0.3093990981578827,
-0.0037283911369740963,
-0.35290732979774475,
-0.4743271470069885,
-0.2420525848865509,
0.34217777848243713,
0.5992990732192993,
-0.6403464078903198,
1.174620270729065,
0.5907607674598694,
-0.188120499253273,
-0.6000913977622986,
-0.6406263709068298,
-0.06137401983141899,
0.12215344607830048,
-0.631911039352417,
0.5294823050498962,
0.12158991396427155,
-0.0808606967329979,
0.018549449741840363,
-0.000985766644589603,
0.18169419467449188,
0.1838526874780655,
0.37984055280685425,
0.06960267573595047,
-0.15774580836296082,
0.2542057931423187,
0.26995256543159485,
-0.3868234157562256,
-0.3470005691051483,
-0.0028614357579499483,
1.0851354598999023,
-0.1433444619178772,
-0.5900058150291443,
-0.28961363434791565,
0.5371290445327759,
0.8100141882896423,
-0.4022693932056427,
0.7088353037834167,
0.753305971622467,
-0.43258237838745117,
-0.5075082778930664,
-0.5728124380111694,
-0.0185368824750185,
-0.4755139648914337,
0.71406489610672,
-0.5603213310241699,
-0.6144958734512329,
0.7443677186965942,
-0.3760693669319153,
0.10174047201871872,
0.7219409942626953,
0.39770132303237915,
0.12541544437408447,
1.2804259061813354,
0.7190858721733093,
0.06445198506116867,
0.3731791079044342,
-0.42802220582962036,
0.305518239736557,
-1.0632282495498657,
-0.25778844952583313,
-0.6187222003936768,
-0.29608508944511414,
-0.5713163018226624,
-0.4037579894065857,
-0.007135521154850721,
0.05890357494354248,
-0.18611881136894226,
0.3324534595012665,
-0.32405149936676025,
0.2344234138727188,
0.2876652181148529,
0.06128909811377525,
0.20981016755104065,
-0.1455923616886139,
-0.3072000741958618,
-0.24688389897346497,
-0.615402102470398,
-0.42461660504341125,
0.8173325061798096,
0.6078186631202698,
0.8671499490737915,
0.13916628062725067,
0.4909455180168152,
0.17744854092597961,
0.18448364734649658,
-0.5526991486549377,
0.727706789970398,
-0.49000075459480286,
-0.20090699195861816,
-0.21948553621768951,
-0.4687316119670868,
-0.6592346429824829,
0.31834128499031067,
-0.34966397285461426,
-0.7119542956352234,
-0.1138388141989708,
-0.054472196847200394,
-0.07741729170084,
0.6501911878585815,
-0.6907027363777161,
0.6389756798744202,
-0.18574422597885132,
-0.07703062891960144,
-0.3965897858142853,
-0.6578464508056641,
0.43672874569892883,
0.04493676871061325,
0.23549839854240417,
-0.2307516485452652,
-0.14477571845054626,
0.5027297735214233,
-0.2509431838989258,
0.7083715796470642,
-0.08179168403148651,
0.13861820101737976,
0.08439352363348007,
0.17096777260303497,
0.21598240733146667,
0.02868597023189068,
-0.14764077961444855,
0.26045987010002136,
-0.48791956901550293,
-0.4199123978614807,
-0.7836161851882935,
0.8255714178085327,
-0.6273609399795532,
-0.30242592096328735,
-0.07208483666181564,
-0.715600848197937,
-0.14181768894195557,
0.2005549967288971,
0.1672641485929489,
0.6598896980285645,
-0.1419793963432312,
0.12773102521896362,
0.6575732827186584,
-0.36094287037849426,
0.8774868249893188,
0.05716510862112045,
-0.5486320853233337,
-0.508401095867157,
0.9918924570083618,
0.14786496758460999,
0.8252377510070801,
0.1942881941795349,
-0.10152312368154526,
-0.36511820554733276,
-0.44572654366493225,
-0.60086590051651,
0.3765820562839508,
-0.7944807410240173,
-0.18337053060531616,
-1.2480864524841309,
-0.4176344871520996,
-0.2509109079837799,
-0.3213319778442383,
-0.8507028818130493,
-0.46200522780418396,
-0.11327219754457474,
-0.09330597519874573,
0.17453600466251373,
0.6536223888397217,
0.1327824592590332,
0.4185151755809784,
-0.7669623494148254,
0.8607955574989319,
0.26495516300201416,
0.5888692140579224,
0.20016834139823914,
-0.16569048166275024,
0.03856074810028076,
0.22306691110134125,
-0.26834291219711304,
-0.7064436674118042,
0.29159581661224365,
0.2784813344478607,
0.9180988073348999,
0.3073481321334839,
-0.07068974524736404,
0.7733250856399536,
-0.3457774221897125,
0.9959203004837036,
0.2435532510280609,
-1.1451541185379028,
0.3084571361541748,
-0.019032076001167297,
0.6446295380592346,
0.3926903307437897,
0.4291742444038391,
-0.6247552037239075,
-0.7128739356994629,
-0.7175665497779846,
-0.8511343002319336,
0.47239214181900024,
0.007110401522368193,
0.21898069977760315,
-0.18356236815452576,
0.00009269724250771105,
0.2635761797428131,
0.04094339907169342,
-0.4870070219039917,
-0.2630194127559662,
-0.3443247377872467,
-0.45525190234184265,
-0.12277784198522568,
-0.1714884489774704,
0.30040812492370605,
-0.15022337436676025,
0.48544472455978394,
-0.25949445366859436,
0.19193609058856964,
-0.04077977314591408,
-0.40984851121902466,
0.38079988956451416,
0.15519757568836212,
0.6442602276802063,
0.4644177258014679,
-0.07261057198047638,
0.4845545291900635,
0.3196805715560913,
-0.7403861284255981,
0.037917912006378174,
-0.03225397318601608,
0.07855097204446793,
0.12016122788190842,
0.3540067970752716,
0.7455652356147766,
0.4443511664867401,
-0.6193091869354248,
0.18048709630966187,
-0.13791923224925995,
0.3017399311065674,
0.22794599831104279,
0.0809972733259201,
0.4050341546535492,
0.15334810316562653,
0.47930315136909485,
0.28774285316467285,
-0.02925681136548519,
-0.4521615207195282,
0.47225937247276306,
0.4925071597099304,
-0.43055763840675354,
-0.0833006352186203,
0.5470265746116638,
0.26935312151908875,
-0.4592147171497345,
0.8752481937408447,
-0.143506720662117,
-0.49392130970954895,
0.47462406754493713,
0.7091854214668274,
0.7325538992881775,
-0.4718567132949829,
0.47678515315055847,
0.19381903111934662,
0.15279115736484528,
-0.0004755203553941101,
0.14365160465240479,
-0.06058291345834732,
-0.5769509673118591,
-0.44789451360702515,
-0.9115814566612244,
-0.23329636454582214,
-0.2771165668964386,
-0.48188483715057373,
0.313892126083374,
-0.620323657989502,
-0.30754756927490234,
0.06652693450450897,
-0.30453944206237793,
-0.5639896988868713,
0.08466290682554245,
0.23830077052116394,
1.0800048112869263,
-0.862253725528717,
0.7506117224693298,
0.18801790475845337,
-0.28658056259155273,
-0.4493146240711212,
-0.3541600704193115,
0.030822167173027992,
-0.5723143219947815,
0.594284176826477,
0.3274645209312439,
-0.4384056627750397,
0.1797790825366974,
-0.33871063590049744,
-0.958228588104248,
1.1041656732559204,
0.558887243270874,
-0.23287208378314972,
0.16253244876861572,
0.15701717138290405,
0.4861312806606293,
-0.6435128450393677,
0.4605848491191864,
0.6760356426239014,
0.18037334084510803,
0.36893847584724426,
-0.7734078764915466,
-0.01617935113608837,
-0.17149174213409424,
0.3895339369773865,
0.6025876998901367,
-0.26994913816452026,
1.1281708478927612,
-0.2510538697242737,
-0.5038692355155945,
-0.16864749789237976,
0.8820976614952087,
0.2539839744567871,
-0.05018490552902222,
0.41285231709480286,
0.7523196935653687,
0.8347452878952026,
-0.15368056297302246,
1.0478249788284302,
-0.061568908393383026,
0.24653242528438568,
0.905015230178833,
-0.17447324097156525,
0.9935362935066223,
0.27254459261894226,
-0.039723750203847885,
0.7543349862098694,
0.2403206080198288,
0.20881424844264984,
0.559598982334137,
0.09148060530424118,
-0.21018655598163605,
-0.2178480178117752,
-0.2619454562664032,
-0.21673254668712616,
0.5001564621925354,
0.5864608883857727,
-0.21979205310344696,
-0.4661902189254761,
0.25561389327049255,
0.12296026200056076,
0.17873331904411316,
-0.4168052673339844,
0.5738712549209595,
0.07470746338367462,
-0.576316773891449,
0.2843664586544037,
0.06503592431545258,
0.7841745615005493,
-0.8056491017341614,
-0.14137330651283264,
-0.14011403918266296,
0.36694425344467163,
-0.1528434157371521,
-0.7573225498199463,
0.357413649559021,
-0.22561322152614594,
-0.20371221005916595,
-0.23080354928970337,
0.5519118905067444,
-0.45549967885017395,
-0.5589607954025269,
0.525091290473938,
0.2050989270210266,
-0.20386573672294617,
0.1422906368970871,
-0.5780338048934937,
0.27283015847206116,
-0.15623235702514648,
0.04268396273255348,
0.2612789571285248,
0.029450474306941032,
-0.001952621154487133,
1.2181730270385742,
0.7270357012748718,
0.09862811118364334,
0.3853309750556946,
0.027180900797247887,
0.8059502840042114,
-0.705112099647522,
-0.5853662490844727,
-0.9096018075942993,
0.9267280101776123,
-0.3396538197994232,
-0.23537294566631317,
0.48706814646720886,
0.36081263422966003,
0.5583791732788086,
0.16663911938667297,
0.6188386678695679,
0.04070207476615906,
0.4771844446659088,
-0.6142450571060181,
0.5935992002487183,
-0.22695356607437134,
0.2508828639984131,
-0.3349989056587219,
-1.073702335357666,
-0.34217825531959534,
0.29397597908973694,
0.08504513651132584,
0.1396263688802719,
0.689826488494873,
0.607826828956604,
-0.3622351884841919,
0.25514093041419983,
0.20591968297958374,
0.037626203149557114,
0.6910873651504517,
0.42210638523101807,
0.3438434898853302,
-0.22757704555988312,
0.4587699770927429,
-0.3070334494113922,
-0.26772066950798035,
-0.055742885917425156,
-0.9530656933784485,
-0.7532991170883179,
-0.7379376292228699,
-0.14788492023944855,
-0.24166427552700043,
-0.41716504096984863,
0.8853507041931152,
0.6552728414535522,
-0.6584046483039856,
-0.12789933383464813,
0.01720026135444641,
0.33797672390937805,
-0.2684142589569092,
-0.2088272124528885,
0.35157135128974915,
-0.37588658928871155,
-0.6644582748413086,
0.3189014196395874,
0.5710886716842651,
0.08802739530801773,
-0.7172116041183472,
-0.18404227495193481,
-0.4465114176273346,
0.03612278029322624,
0.6261240839958191,
0.22370758652687073,
-0.8092530369758606,
-0.24069397151470184,
0.12482548505067825,
-0.37657129764556885,
-0.06277252733707428,
0.7638928294181824,
-0.9698078036308289,
0.6281552910804749,
0.4702383279800415,
0.9742039442062378,
0.5673184394836426,
-0.040839459747076035,
0.7622491121292114,
-0.5882522463798523,
0.2357041835784912,
0.187583327293396,
0.3311954736709595,
0.5472100377082825,
-0.07449713349342346,
0.3154289424419403,
0.1308758556842804,
-0.1829688549041748,
-0.8472396731376648,
0.5797674059867859,
-1.0403482913970947,
-0.32107192277908325,
0.9451894760131836,
0.0839737206697464,
-0.2319577932357788,
-0.22364050149917603,
-0.10209240019321442,
0.22849825024604797,
-0.23310457170009613,
0.3969936966896057,
0.4511905312538147,
-0.00369510380551219,
-0.35738885402679443,
-0.4138544797897339,
0.46967822313308716,
0.17339785397052765,
-0.6166794896125793,
-0.04010435938835144,
0.1885308027267456,
-0.04356615990400314,
0.6159810423851013,
0.3329120874404907,
-0.04316495731472969,
0.02525254897773266,
0.396791934967041,
0.16365349292755127,
-0.08580352365970612,
-0.4691988527774811,
-0.31273478269577026,
0.3991398811340332,
-0.36205431818962097,
-0.048307694494724274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12223v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12223v1
|
ToxiCloakCN: Evaluating Robustness of Offensive Language Detection in Chinese with Cloaking Perturbations
| 2024-06-18T02:44:56 | 2024-06-18T02:44:56 |
Yunze Xiao, Yujia Hu, Kenny Tsu Wei Choo, Roy Ka-wei Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Detecting hate speech and offensive language is essential for maintaining a
safe and respectful digital environment. This study examines the limitations of
state-of-the-art large language models (LLMs) in identifying offensive content
within systematically perturbed data, with a focus on Chinese, a language
particularly susceptible to such perturbations. We introduce
\textsf{ToxiCloakCN}, an enhanced dataset derived from ToxiCN, augmented with
homophonic substitutions and emoji transformations, to test the robustness of
LLMs against these cloaking perturbations. Our findings reveal that existing
models significantly underperform in detecting offensive content when these
perturbations are applied. We provide an in-depth analysis of how different
types of offensive content are affected by these perturbations and explore the
alignment between human and model explanations of offensiveness. Our work
highlights the urgent need for more advanced techniques in offensive language
detection to combat the evolving tactics used to evade detection mechanisms.
|
[
-0.03471991792321205,
-1.0496402978897095,
0.006326644215732813,
0.21447430551052094,
-0.45467835664749146,
0.10552266985177994,
-0.1308407485485077,
-0.6268936395645142,
-0.06593717634677887,
0.64903724193573,
-0.2665208876132965,
-0.6108970642089844,
-0.8400906920433044,
0.0922461673617363,
-0.5583463907241821,
0.8617833256721497,
0.19859720766544342,
0.008996469900012016,
0.5208501219749451,
-0.23145660758018494,
-0.0610196515917778,
-0.7143768668174744,
-0.7719766497612,
-0.05119713768362999,
0.7609629034996033,
0.20079711079597473,
0.8707952499389648,
0.4214615821838379,
0.5929816961288452,
0.2833777368068695,
-0.38941308856010437,
0.004189282655715942,
-0.7001816034317017,
0.39411792159080505,
0.1653071492910385,
-0.24214735627174377,
-0.3388497829437256,
-0.25652024149894714,
0.49107930064201355,
-0.0388023816049099,
-0.015816448256373405,
-0.13104858994483948,
-0.05806050822138786,
0.25285083055496216,
-0.9277136921882629,
-0.06256052106618881,
-0.8130113482475281,
0.25757789611816406,
-0.5517300963401794,
0.3009764552116394,
-0.5565832257270813,
0.024242954328656197,
-0.10007727146148682,
-0.4065976142883301,
-0.36873024702072144,
-0.302062451839447,
0.5826684832572937,
0.03225192800164223,
-0.39026859402656555,
-0.4481717646121979,
-0.5818657875061035,
0.7697945237159729,
-1.1226540803909302,
0.3662923276424408,
0.4027506709098816,
0.10448016971349716,
-0.12720517814159393,
-0.6054196357727051,
-0.7060912251472473,
-0.5891094207763672,
0.08186692744493484,
0.3692386746406555,
-0.3875226676464081,
0.035319793969392776,
0.22319844365119934,
0.3155496418476105,
-0.44504350423812866,
0.5311707258224487,
0.13552308082580566,
-0.4885329604148865,
0.8224350810050964,
0.3257330060005188,
0.868314802646637,
-0.19990773499011993,
-0.25010812282562256,
-0.15190812945365906,
-0.6297901272773743,
-0.0994979590177536,
0.8707018494606018,
0.43688464164733887,
-0.16631488502025604,
0.38045430183410645,
0.10129041969776154,
0.4393845498561859,
-0.13088324666023254,
0.020395545288920403,
-0.00915121752768755,
-0.2154700607061386,
0.027923064306378365,
0.035192765295505524,
0.9566459655761719,
0.2992350161075592,
0.21725678443908691,
0.047815967351198196,
-0.3981621265411377,
0.10126753896474838,
0.17034736275672913,
-0.6648058295249939,
-0.4175644814968109,
0.13351193070411682,
-0.27129489183425903,
-0.6735585927963257,
-0.026521077379584312,
-0.7865152359008789,
-0.9445061683654785,
0.27711302042007446,
0.06856950372457504,
-0.3334372043609619,
-0.489511638879776,
-0.15413382649421692,
-0.11808677762746811,
0.22807654738426208,
0.19021980464458466,
-0.7704158425331116,
0.0896153599023819,
0.6522798538208008,
0.7169094085693359,
-0.3713832199573517,
-0.20601676404476166,
-0.3450377881526947,
0.02782638557255268,
-0.4385603070259094,
0.4323011040687561,
-0.742323100566864,
-0.20595084130764008,
0.3865334987640381,
0.04610884189605713,
0.3728504180908203,
-0.7440372705459595,
0.7545351386070251,
-0.6065970659255981,
-0.05215153470635414,
-0.1765272617340088,
-0.1560944765806198,
-0.048473794013261795,
0.3179776072502136,
-0.7224998474121094,
0.8435589671134949,
0.1706208437681198,
-1.2002454996109009,
0.09783591330051422,
-0.5250548124313354,
-0.6246286034584045,
0.18739649653434753,
0.22919027507305145,
-0.6337584853172302,
-0.05062541738152504,
-0.07343394309282303,
0.2500181794166565,
0.09531311690807343,
-0.11019567400217056,
-0.573360025882721,
-0.3897997736930847,
0.41411280632019043,
-0.4282459616661072,
1.0783531665802002,
0.5310192108154297,
-0.4920053482055664,
0.3857111930847168,
-0.46351489424705505,
-0.4872823655605316,
0.5342593789100647,
-0.4651215672492981,
-0.6541886329650879,
0.16766692698001862,
0.48062655329704285,
0.11351396143436432,
0.1742742955684662,
-0.728521466255188,
-0.2980402410030365,
-0.5420700311660767,
0.43162965774536133,
0.924908459186554,
-0.35228219628334045,
0.04254675284028053,
-0.22859463095664978,
0.5203966498374939,
0.21571728587150574,
0.34486153721809387,
-0.1271771639585495,
-0.48529958724975586,
-0.2716202139854431,
0.013722906820476055,
-0.14863058924674988,
0.7411205172538757,
-0.8227783441543579,
0.267285019159317,
0.09736454486846924,
-0.39693689346313477,
-0.10776515305042267,
0.008748406544327736,
0.3983890116214752,
0.23655961453914642,
0.03916243091225624,
-0.1884043663740158,
-0.6492165327072144,
-0.7040768265724182,
-0.6167670488357544,
-0.38715770840644836,
-0.2140326201915741,
0.41392549872398376,
0.2059909552335739,
-0.35070663690567017,
0.2567578852176666,
0.003731487086042762,
-0.09575379639863968,
-0.21055881679058075,
0.039983104914426804,
-0.053935348987579346,
0.18195156753063202,
0.529381275177002,
-1.0467644929885864,
-0.9736744165420532,
0.16701047122478485,
-0.5792078375816345,
-0.5385215282440186,
0.11402135342359543,
0.16199550032615662,
0.2047855705022812,
0.484022319316864,
0.014067700132727623,
0.344210147857666,
0.9762998223304749,
-0.3091059625148773,
0.7801731824874878,
0.37032321095466614,
0.23668260872364044,
-0.6918154954910278,
-0.08308655023574829,
-0.07009683549404144,
-0.21507954597473145,
-1.1098036766052246,
0.6244773268699646,
-0.03236820176243782,
-0.01460697315633297,
-0.8185311555862427,
0.4491657614707947,
-0.08624517172574997,
0.44310262799263,
-0.38459232449531555,
0.3031542897224426,
-0.41883596777915955,
0.163816437125206,
-0.09765718132257462,
0.500667154788971,
0.3131989538669586,
-0.34549617767333984,
0.678581178188324,
0.1430024802684784,
-0.21007119119167328,
0.14586777985095978,
-0.40877804160118103,
0.3276548981666565,
0.0035865497775375843,
0.1327270269393921,
-1.2237128019332886,
-0.342894583940506,
0.7040484547615051,
-0.3269627094268799,
0.2309655100107193,
-0.19010630249977112,
-0.5993891358375549,
-0.35729652643203735,
-0.5779109597206116,
0.7812768816947937,
0.3471026122570038,
-0.689121663570404,
0.4850988984107971,
0.6551671028137207,
0.12136046588420868,
-0.7257766723632812,
-0.8631981015205383,
0.26711905002593994,
-0.5441076755523682,
-0.5834933519363403,
-0.049753595143556595,
-0.1614818274974823,
-0.2785980701446533,
-0.5712532997131348,
0.03433451056480408,
-0.15085813403129578,
0.3611160218715668,
0.08994687348604202,
0.22166697680950165,
-0.30634719133377075,
-0.2900100648403168,
-0.17139938473701477,
0.4504163861274719,
0.3613445460796356,
-0.048530399799346924,
0.5150384306907654,
-0.007042978424578905,
-0.12659825384616852,
-0.3791658580303192,
0.007900598458945751,
0.763705849647522,
0.09621762484312057,
0.6287969350814819,
0.6259786486625671,
-0.36142900586128235,
-0.010330223478376865,
-0.4433470666408539,
-0.0701529011130333,
-0.5701862573623657,
0.7236541509628296,
0.10844699293375015,
-0.874517023563385,
0.8343810439109802,
0.2303304225206375,
-0.0023122408892959356,
0.3790954649448395,
0.606722891330719,
0.17210878431797028,
1.0978963375091553,
0.20176146924495697,
-0.3298603594303131,
0.765978217124939,
0.34505146741867065,
0.2734889090061188,
-0.764752209186554,
-0.09680096805095673,
-0.3603380024433136,
0.006882127840071917,
-0.9258890151977539,
-0.05774591490626335,
0.14786173403263092,
-0.4305322766304016,
-0.5309906601905823,
0.4046623706817627,
-0.3770919442176819,
0.47862130403518677,
-0.2343742847442627,
0.40803292393684387,
0.10372304916381836,
0.10086492449045181,
-0.07724756747484207,
-0.14180822670459747,
-0.5458360314369202,
-0.31702920794487,
0.8962894678115845,
0.7250909209251404,
0.7412664294242859,
0.3397539258003235,
0.15221884846687317,
0.39949968457221985,
0.5163292288780212,
-0.8034335970878601,
0.40726715326309204,
-0.8304263353347778,
-0.9322434067726135,
-0.4031085968017578,
-0.4407886862754822,
-0.7870818376541138,
0.20110630989074707,
-0.25053954124450684,
-0.9745936989784241,
-0.052557848393917084,
0.2142798751592636,
-0.07467526197433472,
0.8731895089149475,
-0.39266613125801086,
0.6495629549026489,
-0.36615225672721863,
-0.581874668598175,
0.1249985545873642,
-0.3443175256252289,
0.6985172033309937,
-0.3191431164741516,
0.39702463150024414,
-0.03042001836001873,
-0.1986718624830246,
0.675608217716217,
0.07036121189594269,
1.0489128828048706,
-0.022805532440543175,
-0.7191618084907532,
0.25661954283714294,
0.517039954662323,
0.5379346013069153,
-0.23487786948680878,
-0.3199504315853119,
0.5589246153831482,
-0.15527434647083282,
-0.4509941041469574,
-0.33466458320617676,
0.5521209239959717,
-0.2972241938114166,
-0.7165021896362305,
-0.23992396891117096,
-0.6215750575065613,
0.09053956717252731,
0.3457570970058441,
0.502021312713623,
-0.007411428261548281,
-0.2580976188182831,
0.015458810143172741,
0.5421398878097534,
-0.7857188582420349,
0.14141945540905,
0.4891226589679718,
-0.4752501845359802,
-0.12206590175628662,
0.8896847367286682,
-0.026082370430231094,
0.36054614186286926,
0.24007728695869446,
0.5854415893554688,
-0.09379322081804276,
-0.6890692710876465,
-0.16399578750133514,
0.03323069587349892,
-0.7346180081367493,
0.0399191789329052,
-0.41094231605529785,
-0.4197459816932678,
-0.4892294108867645,
0.13765963912010193,
-0.41156500577926636,
0.048773206770420074,
-0.14457273483276367,
0.28756850957870483,
-0.09936543554067612,
1.020259141921997,
-0.04345444589853287,
0.42906448245048523,
-0.625498354434967,
0.15682509541511536,
0.13407211005687714,
0.3889933228492737,
0.17368124425411224,
-1.076300024986267,
-0.2139313966035843,
0.25571516156196594,
-0.3455348312854767,
-1.0938985347747803,
0.3615410625934601,
-0.12288539111614227,
0.42133697867393494,
0.9395619630813599,
0.3250454366207123,
0.24459801614284515,
-0.28428369760513306,
0.9661138653755188,
0.13536874949932098,
-0.8830491304397583,
0.5001425743103027,
-0.680650532245636,
0.3191145360469818,
0.008289641700685024,
0.563224196434021,
-0.728757917881012,
-0.8270148634910583,
-0.3357032239437103,
-0.7267675995826721,
0.596620500087738,
0.23677024245262146,
0.7114073038101196,
-0.08704759925603867,
0.32189300656318665,
-0.024235274642705917,
-0.14444111287593842,
-1.0730093717575073,
-0.4726846516132355,
-0.4073265492916107,
0.06920822709798813,
0.04478534683585167,
-0.627135157585144,
-0.05433337017893791,
-0.10385149717330933,
0.3769667446613312,
0.1543581336736679,
0.09116988629102707,
0.0045761349610984325,
-0.07800399512052536,
-0.2195039987564087,
0.043680306524038315,
0.7438909411430359,
0.30926352739334106,
-0.004750940483063459,
0.1778986006975174,
0.4524044394493103,
-0.8451252579689026,
-0.03280819579958916,
-0.434542715549469,
-0.11209028959274292,
-0.15990671515464783,
0.5512314438819885,
0.5681686401367188,
0.021669819951057434,
-0.8276718854904175,
0.6755860447883606,
-0.057537466287612915,
0.08770034462213516,
-0.28548508882522583,
0.060103703290224075,
-0.24808046221733093,
0.0035467122215777636,
0.07083095610141754,
-0.24160589277744293,
0.27161839604377747,
-0.6041275262832642,
0.1892130821943283,
0.4894371032714844,
-0.49356287717819214,
-0.5046349167823792,
0.6352785229682922,
-0.06049010902643204,
-0.4811737835407257,
0.5635517835617065,
0.105525441467762,
-1.1112961769104004,
0.5404650568962097,
0.7780527472496033,
0.7608699798583984,
-0.6807281374931335,
0.17275135219097137,
0.4964781105518341,
0.46337249875068665,
0.3390408456325531,
-0.05577004328370094,
0.10030519217252731,
-0.9979602694511414,
-0.10671939700841904,
-0.32141146063804626,
-0.26235631108283997,
0.6255841255187988,
-0.32926300168037415,
0.2262202948331833,
-0.9197584390640259,
-0.1605672985315323,
-0.10206309705972672,
-0.4216305613517761,
-0.021105213090777397,
-0.009540579281747341,
0.7182873487472534,
0.7884737849235535,
-0.9298320412635803,
0.47905096411705017,
0.4712253510951996,
-0.10824904590845108,
-0.6238651275634766,
0.3257862627506256,
0.35269561409950256,
-0.812804639339447,
0.5648496747016907,
-0.1251927763223648,
-0.11006231606006622,
-0.48195546865463257,
-0.9558137655258179,
-0.3629836440086365,
0.3619981110095978,
0.45095881819725037,
-0.3888973593711853,
0.2361142635345459,
0.24427802860736847,
0.759276270866394,
-0.13927097618579865,
0.26150962710380554,
0.6287010312080383,
0.565801739692688,
0.021304896101355553,
-0.6841453909873962,
0.25102803111076355,
-0.25160813331604004,
-0.1186840757727623,
0.013660288415849209,
-0.7683943510055542,
0.9459577798843384,
0.11702648550271988,
-0.5423175692558289,
0.10905266553163528,
0.31273841857910156,
0.04704194515943527,
0.36667338013648987,
0.5734551548957825,
0.24091729521751404,
0.4229632019996643,
0.022016039118170738,
1.0571647882461548,
0.0832526832818985,
0.148339182138443,
0.9003645777702332,
-0.16346518695354462,
0.8346447348594666,
0.17812177538871765,
-0.17755341529846191,
0.6892989277839661,
0.5741473436355591,
-0.13367114961147308,
0.16292916238307953,
0.5072851777076721,
-0.437446266412735,
-0.1646137535572052,
-0.24462898075580597,
-0.22454191744327545,
0.7387123107910156,
0.43047165870666504,
-0.1970372200012207,
-0.04098349064588547,
0.07920793443918228,
0.17062176764011383,
0.2755280137062073,
-0.26546698808670044,
0.8318377137184143,
-0.024646174162626266,
-0.17735564708709717,
0.7407490611076355,
-0.004740111529827118,
1.0629805326461792,
-0.5015923976898193,
0.1437602937221527,
-0.27320629358291626,
-0.025236712768673897,
-0.3946774899959564,
-0.8114887475967407,
0.32389289140701294,
0.0406760536134243,
0.4005983769893646,
0.1925659477710724,
0.8035564422607422,
-0.32114893198013306,
-0.1625169962644577,
0.7978781461715698,
-0.2781548798084259,
0.22533543407917023,
-0.07030939310789108,
-0.7544231414794922,
0.3321068286895752,
-0.0025369939394295216,
-0.07627679407596588,
0.33185866475105286,
0.3431210517883301,
0.019708003848791122,
0.6902893781661987,
0.6466235518455505,
0.28062161803245544,
0.2313871532678604,
0.1510583609342575,
0.838346004486084,
-0.28841185569763184,
-0.46065643429756165,
-1.0007691383361816,
0.33879247307777405,
0.04662168025970459,
-0.013996223919093609,
0.9260041117668152,
0.3963472843170166,
0.986240565776825,
-0.03736414760351181,
0.6825523972511292,
0.12786255776882172,
0.132055401802063,
-0.4095960557460785,
1.1835674047470093,
-0.5990435481071472,
0.48362523317337036,
-0.6271892786026001,
-0.7127041816711426,
-0.6950386762619019,
0.3964003026485443,
-0.2412124127149582,
-0.011996756307780743,
0.3436940014362335,
0.8970322608947754,
-0.03188861533999443,
0.027964387089014053,
0.7580451965332031,
0.689375102519989,
0.4528363347053528,
0.43565717339515686,
1.2466411590576172,
-0.6239829063415527,
0.6097740530967712,
-0.37119626998901367,
-0.2054455578327179,
-0.0750848576426506,
-0.8661226034164429,
-0.9688851237297058,
-0.5173293948173523,
-0.19467423856258392,
-0.609160840511322,
0.35583001375198364,
0.4650493264198303,
0.4388735592365265,
-1.3140696287155151,
-0.36524540185928345,
0.15897250175476074,
0.33505168557167053,
0.18765553832054138,
-0.2333223521709442,
0.11031936854124069,
-0.0245647095143795,
-0.7558740973472595,
0.2061769664287567,
0.15439650416374207,
0.07775185257196426,
-0.16714736819267273,
-0.2258872240781784,
-0.24389711022377014,
0.2186766117811203,
0.8234273195266724,
0.36209943890571594,
-0.9122594594955444,
-0.3773997128009796,
0.0023802209179848433,
-0.14885225892066956,
-0.01877337321639061,
0.8710786700248718,
-0.06878338754177094,
0.6500229239463806,
0.5198675990104675,
0.7288936972618103,
0.04316329210996628,
-0.08074245601892471,
0.2945885956287384,
-0.531426727771759,
0.34798508882522583,
0.301805317401886,
0.16520489752292633,
0.3366636633872986,
-0.7072501182556152,
0.14046500623226166,
0.14777430891990662,
-0.5294488072395325,
-0.9383559823036194,
0.32214584946632385,
-0.6953259110450745,
-0.4116828739643097,
1.364507794380188,
-0.4182872176170349,
-0.1692388951778412,
-0.39008811116218567,
-0.30609267950057983,
0.3657955527305603,
-0.34310683608055115,
1.0583689212799072,
0.7973672747612,
0.19772283732891083,
-0.2546020448207855,
-0.23786760866641998,
0.4923393130302429,
0.49344825744628906,
-0.40863052010536194,
0.4198686480522156,
0.2900155186653137,
0.1890043020248413,
0.1637727916240692,
0.13864107429981232,
-0.3036990761756897,
0.47832465171813965,
0.01819421537220478,
-0.39450618624687195,
0.09936816245317459,
-0.10238154977560043,
-0.48426327109336853,
-0.016624154523015022,
-0.011407935991883278,
0.03754059225320816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12221v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12221v1
|
On-Policy Fine-grained Knowledge Feedback for Hallucination Mitigation
| 2024-06-18T02:43:49 | 2024-06-18T02:43:49 |
Xueru Wen, Xinyu Lu, Xinyan Guan, Yaojie Lu, Hongyu Lin, Ben He, Xianpei Han, Le Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Hallucination occurs when large language models (LLMs) exhibit behavior that
deviates from the boundaries of their knowledge during the response generation
process. Previous learning-based methods focus on detecting knowledge
boundaries and finetuning models with instance-level feedback, but they suffer
from inaccurate signals due to off-policy data sampling and coarse-grained
feedback. In this paper, we introduce \textit{\b{R}einforcement \b{L}earning
\b{f}or \b{H}allucination} (RLFH), a fine-grained feedback-based online
reinforcement learning method for hallucination mitigation. Unlike previous
learning-based methods, RLFH enables LLMs to explore the boundaries of their
internal knowledge and provide on-policy, fine-grained feedback on these
explorations. To construct fine-grained feedback for learning reliable
generation behavior, RLFH decomposes the outcomes of large models into atomic
facts, provides statement-level evaluation signals, and traces back the signals
to the tokens of the original responses. Finally, RLFH adopts the online
reinforcement algorithm with these token-level rewards to adjust model behavior
for hallucination mitigation. For effective on-policy optimization, RLFH also
introduces an LLM-based fact assessment framework to verify the truthfulness
and helpfulness of atomic facts without human intervention. Experiments on
HotpotQA, SQuADv2, and Biography benchmarks demonstrate that RLFH can balance
their usage of internal knowledge during the generation process to eliminate
the hallucination behavior of LLMs.
|
[
-0.508783221244812,
-1.2320597171783447,
0.5677328109741211,
0.16371071338653564,
0.1557704359292984,
-0.13102152943611145,
-0.4498017728328705,
-0.40061017870903015,
0.19814075529575348,
0.6199949383735657,
-0.7177035808563232,
-0.2838584780693054,
-0.12463501840829849,
-0.1907389760017395,
0.06630569696426392,
1.0706707239151,
0.11232809722423553,
0.030709072947502136,
-0.3527381420135498,
0.127571702003479,
-0.34863612055778503,
-0.44742706418037415,
-0.5560855865478516,
-0.6618561148643494,
0.4568192660808563,
0.5187588334083557,
0.4972028136253357,
0.42761093378067017,
0.3746320307254791,
0.22716307640075684,
-0.07504880428314209,
0.45484623312950134,
-0.748843789100647,
0.14893591403961182,
-0.22076666355133057,
-0.2262657731771469,
-0.28564998507499695,
-0.3390958607196808,
0.4631733000278473,
0.49781352281570435,
-0.5568873286247253,
-0.1736694574356079,
0.16360414028167725,
0.588474452495575,
-0.7500972747802734,
0.25499144196510315,
-0.6508519053459167,
0.24103446304798126,
0.17903535068035126,
-0.5021459460258484,
-0.5040114521980286,
-0.667069673538208,
-0.037263620644807816,
-0.4390099048614502,
0.10410076379776001,
0.08382418751716614,
0.8624817728996277,
0.41684573888778687,
0.09650349617004395,
-0.41703182458877563,
-0.9239094853401184,
0.9003074765205383,
-0.6530380249023438,
0.5468943119049072,
0.7295718193054199,
0.39295363426208496,
-0.3489925265312195,
-0.4811490774154663,
-0.4934062957763672,
-0.4470478296279907,
-0.20978011190891266,
0.011071373708546162,
0.11668853461742401,
0.21482624113559723,
0.23720471560955048,
0.3457580506801605,
-0.21664254367351532,
0.2245764285326004,
-0.23468363285064697,
-0.5605932474136353,
0.45128893852233887,
0.06488968431949615,
-0.13999083638191223,
-0.14772361516952515,
-0.4604977071285248,
-0.21587112545967102,
-0.7505829334259033,
0.06905282288789749,
0.2696206271648407,
0.5032140612602234,
0.11266124248504639,
0.4019755423069,
-0.48646169900894165,
0.4040464460849762,
0.10308384895324707,
-0.052883733063936234,
0.1475762575864792,
-0.08650568872690201,
-0.04160797968506813,
0.29485562443733215,
0.5636293888092041,
0.28163638710975647,
0.17391018569469452,
-0.4259788691997528,
-0.673795759677887,
-0.003029115730896592,
0.2594047784805298,
-1.0213792324066162,
-0.00899227149784565,
0.15767385065555573,
-0.4447705149650574,
-0.2730306088924408,
0.10655522346496582,
-1.1382277011871338,
-0.5831018090248108,
-0.17883774638175964,
0.6646760106086731,
-0.3477044701576233,
-0.2637694776058197,
-0.01890784502029419,
0.006031909957528114,
0.35958167910575867,
0.2548710107803345,
-1.0566034317016602,
0.4572798013687134,
0.575079083442688,
0.8450198769569397,
-0.15538683533668518,
-0.3848748803138733,
-0.9583851099014282,
0.05295849218964577,
-0.006243716925382614,
0.8840246200561523,
-0.360636830329895,
-0.2518581748008728,
0.2443397343158722,
-0.08797601610422134,
0.11735612154006958,
-0.823336124420166,
0.19724954664707184,
-0.3111140727996826,
-0.07504509389400482,
-0.2983502447605133,
-0.5923282504081726,
-0.22927741706371307,
0.5152531266212463,
-0.49611639976501465,
0.838172972202301,
0.10656704753637314,
-0.5138857364654541,
0.2242511659860611,
-0.587436854839325,
-0.4126347303390503,
-0.06613629311323166,
-0.37894052267074585,
-0.5450292825698853,
0.14900991320610046,
0.1776924729347229,
0.5630373954772949,
0.007912005297839642,
0.3616669476032257,
-0.47307950258255005,
-0.37687453627586365,
0.2585073411464691,
-0.4500346779823303,
0.2102551907300949,
0.14794887602329254,
-0.6591067314147949,
0.45532822608947754,
-0.8126551508903503,
-0.015743296593427658,
0.07828128337860107,
-0.35641440749168396,
-0.10289686918258667,
0.19232885539531708,
-0.050792694091796875,
0.16177235543727875,
0.0630442202091217,
-0.5195115804672241,
0.06615922600030899,
-0.4283725321292877,
0.23019033670425415,
0.7693517804145813,
0.3145255446434021,
0.22002273797988892,
-0.690566897392273,
0.3334988057613373,
-0.15609458088874817,
0.2560453414916992,
0.16325578093528748,
-0.25670361518859863,
-0.7619972825050354,
-0.050916191190481186,
0.08599089831113815,
0.4652162790298462,
-0.646233856678009,
0.454719215631485,
-0.03513624891638756,
-0.22626939415931702,
-0.41652071475982666,
0.027649903669953346,
0.4850555956363678,
0.17585498094558716,
0.583124041557312,
-0.14167720079421997,
-0.32787612080574036,
-0.5417017936706543,
-0.06402803212404251,
-0.010251128114759922,
0.13225023448467255,
0.3754722774028778,
0.42031148076057434,
-0.3791118562221527,
0.9379770755767822,
-0.5099955201148987,
-0.6350259184837341,
-0.27641960978507996,
0.36931678652763367,
-0.2699008882045746,
0.3908318877220154,
0.049848008900880814,
-0.380829393863678,
0.10610111802816391,
0.18718717992305756,
-0.5645080804824829,
-0.13982447981834412,
-0.33245787024497986,
0.05472540855407715,
0.5273964405059814,
0.5870833396911621,
-0.5183430910110474,
0.401115357875824,
0.306779146194458,
-0.29240792989730835,
0.574192464351654,
-0.28807416558265686,
0.046140410006046295,
-0.4603438675403595,
-0.06392911076545715,
-0.22990810871124268,
-0.33592066168785095,
-0.44953736662864685,
0.16901612281799316,
-0.2901827096939087,
0.38910818099975586,
-0.5419106483459473,
0.6162228584289551,
-0.12032384425401688,
-0.3000790774822235,
-0.4383170008659363,
0.18076853454113007,
-0.3066187798976898,
0.8834155797958374,
0.18287697434425354,
0.5233905911445618,
0.19630838930606842,
-0.9158597588539124,
0.2677859663963318,
0.11646836996078491,
-0.3738289177417755,
0.4021580219268799,
-0.2724919319152832,
0.09573976695537567,
-0.042937010526657104,
0.14409005641937256,
-0.5121000409126282,
-0.21798838675022125,
0.3456834554672241,
-0.34017109870910645,
0.12060587853193283,
0.32261884212493896,
-0.31410810351371765,
-0.03370026871562004,
-0.4834146201610565,
0.13611716032028198,
0.35192784667015076,
-0.6564518809318542,
0.5676780939102173,
0.3608536124229431,
0.05779225006699562,
-0.36545586585998535,
-0.5749529600143433,
-0.4829377233982086,
-0.08667479455471039,
-0.24918827414512634,
0.2896147072315216,
-0.20143122971057892,
-0.3506009876728058,
0.02605769969522953,
-0.12102734297513962,
0.012278471142053604,
0.19478127360343933,
0.14095622301101685,
0.03830393776297569,
-0.027102984488010406,
0.12041779607534409,
0.05867448449134827,
0.06950465589761734,
0.2597428858280182,
-0.015182075090706348,
0.9073124527931213,
-0.15626272559165955,
-0.2755395770072937,
-0.34559187293052673,
0.018152384087443352,
0.441503643989563,
0.09998591244220734,
0.6328809857368469,
0.8024675846099854,
-0.47054046392440796,
-0.5520786643028259,
-0.5026600956916809,
-0.8990446925163269,
-0.43243035674095154,
0.35877928137779236,
-0.30559757351875305,
-0.9467695355415344,
0.5283044576644897,
-0.21476860344409943,
0.1391669064760208,
0.32324594259262085,
0.6493772864341736,
0.2959729731082916,
0.8403691649436951,
0.2912183701992035,
0.07605462521314621,
0.30876991152763367,
-0.2931143045425415,
0.15768374502658844,
-0.6683144569396973,
-0.5308820009231567,
-0.37144753336906433,
-0.15988032519817352,
-0.49462059140205383,
-0.34114870429039,
0.10239853709936142,
0.20000497996807098,
-0.22975671291351318,
-0.17290189862251282,
-0.35384318232536316,
0.422118216753006,
0.49148815870285034,
0.4840850830078125,
0.36264467239379883,
0.10037355124950409,
-0.16234171390533447,
0.16280044615268707,
-0.7353712916374207,
-0.057023707777261734,
0.8140847682952881,
0.5477304458618164,
1.0523463487625122,
-0.002573756966739893,
0.7910131216049194,
0.5601571798324585,
0.12950028479099274,
-1.1136213541030884,
0.5614001750946045,
0.2782645523548126,
-0.23944790661334991,
-0.5720415115356445,
-0.7987868785858154,
-0.6487215161323547,
0.14850760996341705,
-0.3852819502353668,
-0.7748047709465027,
0.08715594559907913,
0.218348890542984,
-0.6876676082611084,
0.31133919954299927,
-0.19312337040901184,
0.5915550589561462,
-0.2795805037021637,
-0.531236469745636,
-0.6536867618560791,
-0.407701700925827,
0.392416775226593,
0.042448561638593674,
0.350572794675827,
0.16410720348358154,
0.5673026442527771,
0.6996468901634216,
-0.4482581913471222,
1.0165554285049438,
-0.5351081490516663,
-0.18175865709781647,
0.17695489525794983,
0.1179330050945282,
0.8870490193367004,
-0.05786433070898056,
0.23036199808120728,
0.013986313715577126,
-0.14485976099967957,
0.04306740686297417,
-0.5786794424057007,
0.7817078232765198,
-0.7136166095733643,
-0.5750414133071899,
-0.29857125878334045,
-0.702099084854126,
-0.2908453345298767,
-0.06477805972099304,
0.13588806986808777,
0.3991910517215729,
-0.17125335335731506,
0.27302971482276917,
0.972191572189331,
-0.35026535391807556,
0.3487226068973541,
0.3936544358730316,
-0.7999764680862427,
-0.5482848882675171,
1.3850572109222412,
-0.04138077422976494,
0.3709573447704315,
0.31383538246154785,
0.611448347568512,
-0.40465641021728516,
-0.33255982398986816,
-0.33804410696029663,
0.20153167843818665,
-0.677696943283081,
-0.34279996156692505,
-0.5976807475090027,
-0.5198792219161987,
-0.37375500798225403,
-0.0641961544752121,
-0.36426615715026855,
-0.3290162980556488,
-0.1003333255648613,
-0.0762406513094902,
0.4198572635650635,
0.8407883644104004,
-0.30423346161842346,
0.2887794077396393,
-0.641335666179657,
0.3696715533733368,
0.42859378457069397,
0.4214463531970978,
0.24069447815418243,
-0.4405093789100647,
-0.34618133306503296,
0.1451938897371292,
-0.5442922711372375,
-0.6132165789604187,
0.17161951959133148,
0.24880282580852509,
0.6326469779014587,
0.6928539276123047,
0.18076488375663757,
0.550731897354126,
-0.18425486981868744,
0.49931710958480835,
-0.06753996759653091,
-0.8779328465461731,
0.44192150235176086,
-0.09088432043790817,
0.056997790932655334,
0.37133243680000305,
0.13249793648719788,
-0.4128077030181885,
-0.6031262874603271,
-0.4430953860282898,
-0.8313887119293213,
0.825000524520874,
0.08215345442295074,
-0.22499066591262817,
0.10203481465578079,
0.21320421993732452,
0.23883448541164398,
0.2673755884170532,
-0.867304265499115,
-0.0164773091673851,
-0.19132637977600098,
-0.028502102941274643,
0.3506433665752411,
-0.17843836545944214,
-0.11077248305082321,
-0.230547234416008,
0.9418432116508484,
-0.28058186173439026,
0.2524111568927765,
0.1654893457889557,
-0.2592531740665436,
-0.29591238498687744,
0.32910364866256714,
0.8302010893821716,
0.4202782213687897,
-0.4130580723285675,
0.08514034748077393,
0.2290859967470169,
-0.2654840350151062,
-0.044002432376146317,
-0.1381809413433075,
-0.33218318223953247,
-0.22353574633598328,
0.1022733598947525,
1.0373599529266357,
0.2687869668006897,
-0.6791843175888062,
0.39604052901268005,
0.11659717559814453,
-0.34809887409210205,
-0.20731207728385925,
0.16834498941898346,
-0.397199809551239,
0.42507970333099365,
0.132649764418602,
-0.1896769404411316,
0.05938982218503952,
-0.7147554159164429,
0.5916116237640381,
0.5598265528678894,
-0.560044527053833,
-0.08950402587652206,
0.38577309250831604,
0.1612352430820465,
-0.20783506333827972,
0.5609224438667297,
-0.5169852375984192,
-0.6832326054573059,
0.45914262533187866,
0.7914786338806152,
0.8229244351387024,
-0.3361482322216034,
0.5138849020004272,
0.3514593243598938,
0.30746909976005554,
-0.36686068773269653,
0.45341041684150696,
-0.19387583434581757,
-0.7373253107070923,
-0.2648800015449524,
-0.9134865403175354,
-0.4187305271625519,
0.3913428783416748,
-0.7145471572875977,
0.13890431821346283,
-0.7372956275939941,
-0.01641148328781128,
-0.5044216513633728,
-0.13151445984840393,
-0.3705345690250397,
0.04118867591023445,
0.08774233609437943,
0.4934611916542053,
-0.8264949917793274,
0.734069287776947,
0.3250003159046173,
-0.4916999638080597,
-0.6650578379631042,
0.41144779324531555,
-0.03431166335940361,
-0.7812801003456116,
0.4948858618736267,
0.37509870529174805,
-0.2788137197494507,
0.23388712108135223,
-0.26598501205444336,
-0.624701201915741,
0.901761531829834,
0.08040208369493484,
-0.57829350233078,
0.1165878102183342,
0.19383765757083893,
0.2084420919418335,
-0.23726704716682434,
0.16879568994045258,
0.730202317237854,
0.7498305439949036,
0.20373018085956573,
-0.6971386671066284,
0.28832733631134033,
0.3238002061843872,
-0.19002574682235718,
0.3375355899333954,
-0.5619640946388245,
0.5699384212493896,
-0.3009234368801117,
-0.11969539523124695,
-0.05477668717503548,
0.7805832028388977,
0.4492708146572113,
0.36987045407295227,
0.6292178630828857,
0.7491206526756287,
0.8001195788383484,
-0.08734380453824997,
0.7059394717216492,
-0.1542281210422516,
0.5458145141601562,
0.9462122917175293,
-0.23425431549549103,
0.9123803377151489,
0.6794298887252808,
-0.0140274902805686,
0.5941171646118164,
0.45430880784988403,
-0.1308625340461731,
0.7972640991210938,
0.5496038198471069,
-0.1820802390575409,
-0.24140062928199768,
-0.4638589024543762,
-0.19738690555095673,
0.33203306794166565,
0.48170754313468933,
0.1509304940700531,
-0.3636002838611603,
0.35748291015625,
0.031661227345466614,
0.09988591074943542,
-0.5515179634094238,
0.9657838940620422,
-0.022065669298171997,
-0.7663464546203613,
0.7135205864906311,
-0.11932174116373062,
0.7102604508399963,
-0.5850147604942322,
-0.32890141010284424,
-0.3978012800216675,
0.41678330302238464,
-0.40207377076148987,
-0.42793986201286316,
0.4764295816421509,
-0.1873299479484558,
-0.11819031089544296,
-0.01808258704841137,
0.6308982968330383,
-0.6346930265426636,
-0.19200728833675385,
0.45696398615837097,
0.3260776400566101,
0.18544156849384308,
-0.12902460992336273,
-0.34748801589012146,
0.14191804826259613,
0.04601147398352623,
-0.293944776058197,
0.38614794611930847,
0.26920920610427856,
-0.14918245375156403,
0.5901026725769043,
0.4741169214248657,
0.3903544247150421,
-0.012570527382194996,
0.3294048011302948,
0.7420533299446106,
-0.7074905037879944,
-0.4522685110569,
-0.7889983057975769,
0.12925031781196594,
0.050789475440979004,
-0.0038084418047219515,
0.510890543460846,
0.4202486276626587,
1.0193750858306885,
-0.07421953231096268,
0.6792601943016052,
-0.055433522909879684,
0.21601539850234985,
-0.9263620376586914,
0.8876606225967407,
-0.6488342881202698,
0.28061971068382263,
0.0702565535902977,
-0.999987006187439,
-0.2304266393184662,
0.8455265760421753,
0.03941839560866356,
0.010589647106826305,
0.8785198926925659,
1.1167970895767212,
0.04629566892981529,
0.06145823374390602,
0.4356338679790497,
0.45147138833999634,
0.06456279754638672,
0.3390764892101288,
0.9725742340087891,
-0.03284735605120659,
0.4274701476097107,
-0.36312195658683777,
-0.24736186861991882,
-0.476730078458786,
-0.5759739279747009,
-0.9226903915405273,
-0.4169374406337738,
-0.21104741096496582,
-0.5326273441314697,
0.11150616407394409,
1.265368938446045,
0.4041970372200012,
-0.9867987036705017,
-0.4057721495628357,
-0.39675068855285645,
0.21430933475494385,
-0.489874929189682,
-0.3484008312225342,
0.2930006682872772,
-0.7156631946563721,
-0.3410314619541168,
0.4440101087093353,
0.12038247287273407,
-0.13227738440036774,
-0.7364621162414551,
-0.5558115243911743,
-0.09446097165346146,
0.17073826491832733,
0.5727160573005676,
0.34527045488357544,
-0.8423049449920654,
-0.3671397268772125,
-0.19680872559547424,
-0.04591452702879906,
-0.07762506604194641,
0.8503106832504272,
-0.8824942111968994,
0.12741734087467194,
0.4530157148838043,
0.9293046593666077,
0.3199388384819031,
-0.140384241938591,
0.34595048427581787,
-0.7150328159332275,
0.037383269518613815,
0.13726910948753357,
0.19841767847537994,
0.2071400135755539,
-0.5030022859573364,
0.27401918172836304,
0.34267258644104004,
-0.7286368012428284,
-0.8468560576438904,
0.23139287531375885,
-0.6995373964309692,
-0.47518813610076904,
1.3616681098937988,
0.014550206251442432,
-0.31330811977386475,
-0.027143599465489388,
-0.09295683354139328,
0.3777729868888855,
-0.5530902147293091,
1.3798118829727173,
0.6062617897987366,
-0.1763225793838501,
-0.09454222768545151,
-0.48145735263824463,
0.8035843372344971,
0.4613070785999298,
-1.1976861953735352,
0.2922310531139374,
0.6636219620704651,
-0.17139381170272827,
0.0543488971889019,
0.4116547107696533,
0.17755067348480225,
0.15578493475914001,
-0.19280704855918884,
0.29614344239234924,
-0.1490733027458191,
-0.845448911190033,
-0.2873491942882538,
0.15887075662612915,
0.13290704786777496,
-0.1627630740404129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12216v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12216v1
|
Is persona enough for personality? Using ChatGPT to reconstruct an agent's latent personality from simple descriptions
| 2024-06-18T02:32:57 | 2024-06-18T02:32:57 |
Yongyi Ji, Zhisheng Tang, Mayank Kejriwal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Personality, a fundamental aspect of human cognition, contains a range of
traits that influence behaviors, thoughts, and emotions. This paper explores
the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) in reconstructing these
complex cognitive attributes based only on simple descriptions containing
socio-demographic and personality type information. Utilizing the HEXACO
personality framework, our study examines the consistency of LLMs in recovering
and predicting underlying (latent) personality dimensions from simple
descriptions. Our experiments reveal a significant degree of consistency in
personality reconstruction, although some inconsistencies and biases, such as a
tendency to default to positive traits in the absence of explicit information,
are also observed. Additionally, socio-demographic factors like age and number
of children were found to influence the reconstructed personality dimensions.
These findings have implications for building sophisticated agent-based
simulacra using LLMs and highlight the need for further research on robust
personality generation in LLMs.
|
[
-0.30511727929115295,
-0.5060902237892151,
0.9430371522903442,
0.45082566142082214,
0.02493204176425934,
0.2617188096046448,
-0.44098833203315735,
-0.30297189950942993,
0.33624008297920227,
0.7058081030845642,
-0.5761110782623291,
-0.038231704384088516,
-0.38211145997047424,
-0.1416289508342743,
-0.12775155901908875,
1.1513080596923828,
0.4504072666168213,
-0.05236798897385597,
-0.270840048789978,
0.15051020681858063,
-0.3307996392250061,
-0.7408793568611145,
-0.852454423904419,
-0.5304633975028992,
0.7715534567832947,
0.5396242737770081,
0.678752601146698,
0.41013333201408386,
0.15715382993221283,
0.26423704624176025,
0.03249511867761612,
0.0030617748852819204,
-0.6089237332344055,
0.15084193646907806,
-0.35916227102279663,
-0.3675326406955719,
-0.7869922518730164,
0.24157483875751495,
0.6694682240486145,
0.919840931892395,
-0.11703876405954361,
-0.10176731646060944,
0.24967701733112335,
0.473652184009552,
-0.42375418543815613,
0.3440885543823242,
-0.6309811472892761,
-0.15824273228645325,
0.011212467215955257,
-0.138887420296669,
-0.5121123194694519,
-0.2539386749267578,
0.2280321717262268,
-0.1693776696920395,
0.21840538084506989,
0.08896922320127487,
0.6672281622886658,
-0.03312424197793007,
-0.7670073509216309,
-0.18371960520744324,
-1.3023916482925415,
0.7279595732688904,
-0.4383513331413269,
-0.06505522131919861,
0.609017550945282,
0.5553577542304993,
-0.3440287709236145,
-0.36183470487594604,
-0.6411924958229065,
-0.3399938642978668,
-0.30197614431381226,
0.10372336208820343,
-0.0969957485795021,
-0.19565428793430328,
0.374218225479126,
0.18385784327983856,
-0.3482471704483032,
0.14076676964759827,
-0.24398912489414215,
-0.4796600341796875,
0.7516476511955261,
0.5017305612564087,
0.28347375988960266,
-0.2181667983531952,
-0.15802106261253357,
-0.152243971824646,
-0.7957648038864136,
0.17700856924057007,
0.6147271394729614,
0.2192382961511612,
-0.18052299320697784,
0.5757147073745728,
-0.10981497913599014,
-0.04519744962453842,
0.21841278672218323,
-0.565030038356781,
0.012483290396630764,
-0.11139446496963501,
0.2176055908203125,
-0.10607906430959702,
0.6329842805862427,
0.1226036474108696,
0.6336272954940796,
-0.21553929150104523,
0.00908913929015398,
0.09297285974025726,
0.5451087951660156,
-0.8380765318870544,
-0.2143600583076477,
0.4644286036491394,
-0.3734980523586273,
-0.10137451440095901,
-0.035753633826971054,
-0.8154365420341492,
-0.595832109451294,
-0.2319035530090332,
-0.122001513838768,
-0.5325747132301331,
-0.307487428188324,
-0.17860278487205505,
0.1885199099779129,
0.6912371516227722,
0.5244035720825195,
-0.7922095060348511,
0.22953034937381744,
0.6698935031890869,
0.48679375648498535,
-0.2464970350265503,
-0.35659658908843994,
-0.2971070408821106,
0.10395325720310211,
-0.23822999000549316,
0.7969584465026855,
-0.5311602354049683,
-0.3928978741168976,
-0.10766708105802536,
0.19345316290855408,
0.09354154765605927,
-0.33363083004951477,
0.4984813630580902,
-0.32742413878440857,
-0.013774523511528969,
-0.6138902902603149,
-0.37632638216018677,
0.1698720008134842,
0.2708027958869934,
-0.542655348777771,
0.45976901054382324,
0.2980800271034241,
-0.5018954277038574,
0.1252617985010147,
-0.08751534670591354,
-0.25213518738746643,
0.2265535444021225,
-0.3736434876918793,
-0.45242542028427124,
0.13021449744701385,
-0.1498815417289734,
0.6919570565223694,
-0.0797957107424736,
0.18421505391597748,
-0.459930956363678,
-0.0673065260052681,
0.7797908782958984,
-0.2574146091938019,
0.6243200302124023,
0.08829344809055328,
-0.0697401687502861,
0.0014247397193685174,
-0.7571227550506592,
-0.02249160036444664,
0.253312349319458,
-0.45114463567733765,
0.148801788687706,
0.28711998462677,
-0.03381936997175217,
0.2082214057445526,
0.5312132835388184,
-0.8198683857917786,
0.34640035033226013,
-0.023946525529026985,
0.4541655480861664,
0.7755714058876038,
0.010443927720189095,
0.48672378063201904,
-0.5718008875846863,
0.512352466583252,
-0.02807391621172428,
-0.2719273567199707,
0.004270818550139666,
-0.25404757261276245,
-0.6502521634101868,
-0.6085910201072693,
-0.2098512500524521,
0.5356644988059998,
-0.6771700978279114,
0.5885918140411377,
-0.4176453649997711,
-0.6580067873001099,
0.029535692185163498,
-0.07446737587451935,
0.3771466314792633,
0.1958048790693283,
-0.17662839591503143,
-0.3521997928619385,
-0.6382981538772583,
-1.1031464338302612,
-0.03283539414405823,
-0.36337992548942566,
-0.272705614566803,
0.6115058064460754,
0.5087055563926697,
-0.4030686020851135,
0.9176059365272522,
-0.49114012718200684,
-0.017782973125576973,
-0.5728785991668701,
-0.28702032566070557,
-0.1585453301668167,
0.2538014352321625,
0.8715685606002808,
-0.45227769017219543,
-0.47270336747169495,
-0.12404891103506088,
-0.6437641978263855,
-0.11863064020872116,
-0.1067381501197815,
-0.06906232237815857,
-0.14130423963069916,
0.10863329470157623,
-0.7492947578430176,
0.4561019539833069,
0.26631999015808105,
-0.49749723076820374,
0.6995277404785156,
-0.30989256501197815,
-0.12765510380268097,
-0.9180467128753662,
0.06959144026041031,
-0.04373330622911453,
-0.4981101155281067,
-0.652590811252594,
-0.034962449222803116,
-0.12412333488464355,
-0.12161131203174591,
-0.19526171684265137,
0.7357475757598877,
-0.3754325211048126,
-0.34766316413879395,
-0.5383683443069458,
0.13941270112991333,
-0.07500962913036346,
0.6522507071495056,
0.1051759198307991,
0.6248438954353333,
0.5143210291862488,
-0.46561750769615173,
0.23957405984401703,
0.2906469404697418,
-0.02810642682015896,
1.0687965154647827,
-0.5814824104309082,
0.5546963810920715,
-0.5664461255073547,
0.5587174892425537,
-1.0144786834716797,
-0.7008154392242432,
-0.03395671769976616,
-0.300496369600296,
0.12372499704360962,
-0.05649907886981964,
-0.3963671624660492,
-0.13577502965927124,
-0.1901775747537613,
-0.06625127047300339,
0.6657918691635132,
-0.2135738879442215,
1.0789552927017212,
0.26468533277511597,
-0.5146117806434631,
-0.025689950212836266,
-0.3181699812412262,
0.04712728038430214,
-0.19977176189422607,
-0.4114086627960205,
0.19477573037147522,
-0.44491663575172424,
-0.3638049364089966,
-0.38830941915512085,
0.14828048646450043,
-0.19933626055717468,
-0.01731942594051361,
0.4142541289329529,
0.4138437509536743,
0.025623105466365814,
-0.0555451475083828,
-0.29031553864479065,
-0.007804570719599724,
-0.06619526445865631,
0.11269670724868774,
0.8804080486297607,
-0.3834196627140045,
-0.0512608177959919,
-0.11097919940948486,
0.23545794188976288,
0.6901041269302368,
-0.07894884794950485,
0.864054799079895,
0.5376943945884705,
-0.2716591954231262,
-0.11684577912092209,
-0.4231383800506592,
-0.19997310638427734,
-0.38824698328971863,
0.2665401101112366,
-0.47554081678390503,
-0.9086894989013672,
0.9329141974449158,
0.0983349159359932,
-0.15692153573036194,
0.3005097806453705,
0.7305857539176941,
-0.3585575222969055,
0.789513111114502,
0.6140827536582947,
0.08478835225105286,
0.3035154938697815,
0.14314602315425873,
0.00675987359136343,
-0.9690827131271362,
-0.3319424092769623,
-0.4698145389556885,
-0.2688203454017639,
-0.6628077626228333,
0.0059569040313363075,
0.07980093359947205,
-0.4956223964691162,
-0.40785959362983704,
0.2585967481136322,
-0.12801484763622284,
0.3864259421825409,
0.14210771024227142,
0.28363168239593506,
0.07036352157592773,
-0.019755171611905098,
0.3007674515247345,
-0.2656717300415039,
-0.1902168244123459,
-0.9662874937057495,
1.193234920501709,
0.4238795340061188,
0.7667202353477478,
0.4107493758201599,
0.5111679434776306,
0.18512693047523499,
0.3315946161746979,
-0.8414656519889832,
0.7698343992233276,
-0.17823339998722076,
-0.6089398860931396,
-0.26200059056282043,
-0.46432924270629883,
-1.0876076221466064,
0.1293030083179474,
-0.443729966878891,
-1.2423789501190186,
0.30307257175445557,
0.17181168496608734,
-0.5430510640144348,
-0.10451428592205048,
-0.3962624669075012,
0.312631756067276,
-0.25732409954071045,
-0.3960535228252411,
-0.09601406008005142,
-0.5611756443977356,
0.2738344967365265,
-0.3093916177749634,
-0.2181950956583023,
-0.33549538254737854,
0.020319581031799316,
0.36693301796913147,
-0.47686830163002014,
1.037854552268982,
-0.006780500058084726,
-0.1912805587053299,
0.16978777945041656,
0.2648451328277588,
0.4844028353691101,
0.01646161451935768,
0.059701014310121536,
-0.07767660915851593,
0.41136741638183594,
-0.6312825083732605,
-0.8211914300918579,
0.6930030584335327,
-1.0664247274398804,
-0.536512017250061,
-0.252631276845932,
-0.5513880848884583,
-0.3731165826320648,
-0.03570139780640602,
-0.014505969360470772,
0.1543712466955185,
-0.6039133071899414,
0.4688793420791626,
0.8138443827629089,
-0.3729490339756012,
0.20810270309448242,
0.6040105819702148,
-0.2867000997066498,
-0.06374455243349075,
0.8448850512504578,
0.06343966722488403,
0.24992692470550537,
0.016372593119740486,
0.28668874502182007,
0.16892844438552856,
-0.17425774037837982,
0.08677901327610016,
0.44271746277809143,
-0.44075894355773926,
0.2671396732330322,
-0.6668154001235962,
-0.3498364984989166,
-0.4294705092906952,
-0.040636662393808365,
-0.5986015796661377,
-0.18363717198371887,
0.026282696053385735,
0.25286874175071716,
-0.08439013361930847,
0.7031735181808472,
0.25959670543670654,
0.7748399972915649,
-0.3386653661727905,
0.3073819875717163,
0.5236947536468506,
0.09639906883239746,
0.1607186496257782,
-0.45922043919563293,
0.05616935342550278,
0.14528784155845642,
-0.36039918661117554,
-0.852897047996521,
0.49255234003067017,
0.3353477120399475,
0.6060336232185364,
0.490726113319397,
-0.299783319234848,
0.15516029298305511,
-0.36027592420578003,
0.6702571511268616,
-0.307392418384552,
-0.6052557229995728,
0.41151562333106995,
-0.47668808698654175,
0.3495296835899353,
0.340132474899292,
0.3456419110298157,
-0.4283317029476166,
-0.08950039744377136,
-0.7530936002731323,
-0.45867231488227844,
0.4641205966472626,
0.5617374777793884,
0.4084647297859192,
-0.040111761540174484,
0.7861806750297546,
0.08103208243846893,
0.27170708775520325,
-0.663892388343811,
-0.09602700918912888,
-0.2235049456357956,
-0.2652202546596527,
-0.12555792927742004,
-0.5346229672431946,
-0.12171562016010284,
0.04127485677599907,
0.3585214614868164,
-0.3353957533836365,
0.5965655446052551,
-0.15645885467529297,
0.09459898620843887,
0.24879300594329834,
0.5228092670440674,
0.44596466422080994,
0.42711135745048523,
-0.23595485091209412,
0.17865581810474396,
-0.13322895765304565,
-0.5567041039466858,
0.17340503633022308,
-0.3409707546234131,
0.007926852442324162,
-0.5570129752159119,
0.5672914385795593,
0.6569739580154419,
0.05351164937019348,
-0.6553527116775513,
0.674481987953186,
-0.17076048254966736,
0.0780283734202385,
-0.8380977511405945,
0.26940420269966125,
0.2851390242576599,
0.3476608693599701,
0.28326791524887085,
-0.13813477754592896,
-0.30522584915161133,
-1.145829439163208,
-0.021733906120061874,
0.5571111440658569,
-0.15880364179611206,
-0.6827879548072815,
0.37269577383995056,
-0.05641422048211098,
-0.3994182348251343,
0.7811754941940308,
-0.14912396669387817,
-0.3282192349433899,
0.6571482419967651,
0.5068315267562866,
0.8386721611022949,
-0.2563178837299347,
0.27598902583122253,
0.22518271207809448,
0.05160089582204819,
-0.0693010464310646,
0.37077462673187256,
0.09537632763385773,
-1.186455249786377,
-0.20778726041316986,
-0.6877204775810242,
-0.3810344934463501,
0.08059871941804886,
-0.4538405239582062,
-0.04709243401885033,
-0.9510046243667603,
-0.2426934391260147,
0.04112747311592102,
0.008895821869373322,
-1.008937120437622,
0.15271194279193878,
0.15457244217395782,
0.3508892059326172,
-0.7832384705543518,
0.876688539981842,
0.5793753862380981,
-0.5049413442611694,
-0.8644415140151978,
0.12387128174304962,
0.15976373851299286,
-0.7430423498153687,
0.5880744457244873,
-0.13818810880184174,
-0.11302114278078079,
-0.11580003798007965,
-1.015031337738037,
-0.7870921492576599,
1.1840087175369263,
0.5785243511199951,
-0.3182644546031952,
-0.2769836187362671,
0.24201874434947968,
0.9171253442764282,
-0.869181215763092,
0.18475385010242462,
0.5011783242225647,
0.3718867301940918,
0.4634377658367157,
-0.838222324848175,
-0.09001363813877106,
-0.026158543303608894,
0.1036563366651535,
-0.3977794945240021,
-0.8906987905502319,
0.9868023991584778,
-0.29614174365997314,
-0.20232999324798584,
0.3875894546508789,
0.6146655082702637,
0.3102540373802185,
-0.20467114448547363,
0.376454621553421,
0.06661858409643173,
0.7348632216453552,
-0.0731813907623291,
1.1720514297485352,
-0.20549052953720093,
0.16464872658252716,
1.2824078798294067,
-0.4798678457736969,
0.7137483954429626,
0.21167266368865967,
-0.16820095479488373,
0.7442705631256104,
0.40979236364364624,
0.14878107607364655,
0.1966373175382614,
-0.12053287029266357,
-0.05192092806100845,
-0.44046732783317566,
-0.14856110513210297,
0.25061294436454773,
1.0388456583023071,
0.3446790874004364,
-0.3559158444404602,
0.05635297670960426,
0.04340020567178726,
0.23831872642040253,
0.026560425758361816,
-0.16521598398685455,
0.7942006587982178,
0.1461416333913803,
-0.628639280796051,
0.011026154272258282,
-0.13861726224422455,
0.45021745562553406,
-0.6024945378303528,
0.04896922409534454,
-0.4796192944049835,
0.1504107415676117,
-0.2780168950557709,
-0.8482264876365662,
0.2746231257915497,
-0.324139803647995,
-0.20368768274784088,
-0.2806023061275482,
1.0196863412857056,
-0.4284009039402008,
-0.18645194172859192,
-0.05574313551187515,
0.7861147522926331,
0.4522707462310791,
-0.16635724902153015,
-0.14121918380260468,
-0.15481428802013397,
-0.009135591797530651,
-0.17250728607177734,
0.4636688828468323,
0.4454177916049957,
-0.23803620040416718,
0.9221221208572388,
0.36783018708229065,
0.20616769790649414,
-0.3652416169643402,
-0.058527037501335144,
0.5752201080322266,
-0.7653623223304749,
-0.344745397567749,
-0.7990261912345886,
0.534910261631012,
-0.09971706569194794,
-0.029867593199014664,
0.701856791973114,
0.31201064586639404,
0.4671822488307953,
-0.155919149518013,
0.7661336064338684,
-0.02505440078675747,
0.4930250942707062,
-0.22273501753807068,
0.6998059749603271,
-0.1609746366739273,
0.25132516026496887,
-0.24332353472709656,
-1.2198173999786377,
0.3848797678947449,
0.5252891778945923,
-0.34819838404655457,
0.34311991930007935,
0.5726882219314575,
0.6223894953727722,
0.11668780446052551,
-0.29971784353256226,
0.5586569309234619,
0.3280071020126343,
0.38869357109069824,
0.5588259100914001,
0.7482536435127258,
0.14427846670150757,
0.3562960922718048,
0.0531267374753952,
-0.39012593030929565,
-0.07426765561103821,
-0.6911950707435608,
-1.0277467966079712,
-0.4989057183265686,
-0.31575220823287964,
-0.6270570158958435,
-0.3500145375728607,
0.7940411567687988,
0.5134222507476807,
-0.3379458487033844,
-0.12511475384235382,
0.5433225035667419,
-0.08832753449678421,
0.06078591197729111,
-0.22108541429042816,
0.011963814496994019,
0.12804390490055084,
-0.6937038898468018,
-0.02511233277618885,
0.4056374430656433,
0.2755323052406311,
-0.9963688254356384,
-0.12480251491069794,
0.2702631950378418,
0.5634804964065552,
0.7644392251968384,
0.430841863155365,
-0.737357497215271,
-0.8143451809883118,
0.0438644140958786,
-0.4239310920238495,
0.09761760383844376,
0.9206704497337341,
-0.6248174905776978,
0.09896393120288849,
0.21278567612171173,
0.3488978445529938,
0.3902670443058014,
-0.030480293557047844,
0.5748468637466431,
-0.9372714757919312,
0.14226004481315613,
0.07971213012933731,
0.5471729636192322,
0.5593813061714172,
-0.5069372057914734,
0.40436285734176636,
0.14945350587368011,
-0.5567144751548767,
-0.27818164229393005,
0.7667602300643921,
-1.4496095180511475,
-0.13321834802627563,
1.518241286277771,
-0.28130754828453064,
-0.4062393307685852,
-0.10200043022632599,
-0.4611820876598358,
-0.14737153053283691,
-0.3146333396434784,
0.8150285482406616,
0.8901499509811401,
-0.284533828496933,
-0.47056883573532104,
-0.3081439435482025,
0.2339126020669937,
0.021354064345359802,
-0.8347443342208862,
0.04724040627479553,
0.6322076320648193,
0.49051129817962646,
0.18975916504859924,
0.9179487228393555,
0.011690112762153149,
-0.04695511236786842,
0.1325330287218094,
0.12201640754938126,
0.3704235851764679,
-0.1718197464942932,
0.09619662165641785,
0.2429574579000473,
0.3600998520851135,
0.5767701864242554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12213v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12213v3
|
LLM-Oracle Machines
| 2024-06-18T02:25:33 | 2024-07-03T12:59:21 |
Jie Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.FL, F.1.1; F.4.1; I.2.0
|
Contemporary AI applications leverage large language models (LLMs) to harness
their knowledge and reasoning abilities for natural language processing tasks.
This approach shares similarities with the concept of oracle Turing machines
(OTMs). To capture the broader potential of these computations, including those
not yet realized, we propose an extension to OTMs: the LLM-oracle machine
(LLM-OM), by employing a cluster of LLMs as the oracle. Each LLM acts as a
black box, capable of answering queries within its expertise, albeit with a
delay. We introduce four variants of the LLM-OM: basic, augmented,
fault-avoidance, and $\epsilon$-fault. The first two are commonly observed in
existing AI applications. The latter two are specifically designed to address
the challenges of LLM hallucinations, biases, and inconsistencies, aiming to
ensure reliable outcomes.
|
[
-0.3973115086555481,
-1.1126587390899658,
1.0631216764450073,
0.056129373610019684,
0.03126341477036476,
0.043613918125629425,
-0.08752366900444031,
-0.8788561224937439,
0.44075965881347656,
0.9242336750030518,
-0.67893385887146,
-0.3894539773464203,
-0.47755154967308044,
0.4337555468082428,
-0.5695319771766663,
0.5779680013656616,
0.08398328721523285,
-0.19338683784008026,
-0.23959630727767944,
-0.07333655655384064,
-0.4642491042613983,
-0.5361838936805725,
-0.7412129044532776,
-0.5961296558380127,
0.38816285133361816,
0.32556354999542236,
0.8265070915222168,
0.8764737844467163,
0.48994171619415283,
0.32174205780029297,
0.22531425952911377,
0.2654467225074768,
-0.03523869812488556,
0.2895902693271637,
0.086960569024086,
-0.8105618953704834,
-0.6871249079704285,
-0.2382226437330246,
0.5555334091186523,
0.9074041247367859,
-0.05697831138968468,
-0.0312516912817955,
-0.30963006615638733,
0.6337696313858032,
-0.4725378453731537,
0.2819231152534485,
-0.725567638874054,
0.05595070868730545,
-0.09560629725456238,
0.14970126748085022,
-0.48786064982414246,
-0.588009774684906,
0.03090653568506241,
-0.5438393354415894,
-0.29652631282806396,
0.28065747022628784,
0.5198747515678406,
0.8250605463981628,
-0.12872648239135742,
-0.3833000659942627,
-0.9575930833816528,
0.7538939118385315,
-0.6179124712944031,
0.13996680080890656,
0.14004549384117126,
0.5786697268486023,
-0.09746993333101273,
-0.5261728763580322,
-0.7129917740821838,
-0.3680110275745392,
-0.09822145104408264,
-0.11634410172700882,
-0.1253080815076828,
0.1976756602525711,
0.07369553297758102,
0.39367878437042236,
-0.45746153593063354,
0.46710941195487976,
-0.3652110695838928,
0.06677384674549103,
0.5473005771636963,
0.6008886694908142,
0.23597092926502228,
0.16666322946548462,
-0.18145596981048584,
0.13846547901630402,
-0.8614774942398071,
-0.31339123845100403,
-0.02237449213862419,
0.22256526350975037,
0.27158740162849426,
0.9167532324790955,
-0.11819535493850708,
1.097386121749878,
-0.09139253944158554,
-0.2530544102191925,
0.0012840802082791924,
0.023235704749822617,
-0.4973890483379364,
0.23292630910873413,
0.6524648666381836,
-0.13418833911418915,
0.17058165371418,
-0.37494704127311707,
-0.22330507636070251,
0.2220480591058731,
0.41229522228240967,
-0.332699716091156,
0.11141213774681091,
0.44474852085113525,
-0.3864918053150177,
-0.22986598312854767,
-0.046664293855428696,
-0.7844185829162598,
-0.6426278352737427,
-0.47388118505477905,
0.6280004978179932,
-0.533598780632019,
-0.010173399932682514,
0.05957397446036339,
0.039848774671554565,
0.5002089142799377,
0.32238414883613586,
-0.5588784217834473,
0.512380838394165,
0.8328818678855896,
0.5123292207717896,
-0.44023144245147705,
-0.3766593635082245,
-0.5315423607826233,
0.3680680990219116,
-0.3629196286201477,
0.8485323786735535,
-0.8829728960990906,
-0.20067904889583588,
0.2018587291240692,
-0.17863436043262482,
0.037924785166978836,
-0.737337052822113,
0.5005781054496765,
-0.4347410798072815,
0.19452466070652008,
-0.05435577780008316,
-0.6018584370613098,
-0.46019768714904785,
0.4615459144115448,
-0.7259383201599121,
1.0425305366516113,
-0.050081755965948105,
-0.22575412690639496,
0.20694392919540405,
-0.9884923100471497,
-0.539925217628479,
-0.012364166788756847,
-0.2534984350204468,
-0.3205215632915497,
0.11772103607654572,
0.11672216653823853,
0.37878045439720154,
-0.7179148197174072,
-0.14989399909973145,
-0.36516210436820984,
-0.5219884514808655,
0.028780970722436905,
-0.07579658180475235,
0.5068472623825073,
0.15249165892601013,
-0.2798035740852356,
0.33881694078445435,
-0.9556194543838501,
-0.13592810928821564,
0.23766322433948517,
-0.2598804235458374,
-0.42824530601501465,
0.1392725259065628,
-0.52277010679245,
0.0005163868772797287,
0.49780091643333435,
-0.32202622294425964,
0.3358558714389801,
-0.5826814770698547,
0.4207915961742401,
0.7504333257675171,
-0.3344811201095581,
0.545148491859436,
-0.4426923394203186,
0.4672749936580658,
-0.2265353798866272,
0.06415403634309769,
-0.29612335562705994,
-0.6469005346298218,
-1.2301526069641113,
-0.2841768264770508,
-0.12711629271507263,
0.9007964134216309,
-0.8736560344696045,
0.6608417630195618,
-0.02612103335559368,
-0.39149853587150574,
-0.7565284967422485,
0.09005742520093918,
0.23000980913639069,
0.2467876672744751,
0.34997016191482544,
0.16030888259410858,
-0.5805408954620361,
-0.9939112067222595,
-0.22691042721271515,
-0.35671287775039673,
-0.15600541234016418,
0.47792112827301025,
0.21052004396915436,
-0.40633201599121094,
0.9502474069595337,
-0.30618906021118164,
-0.28130486607551575,
-0.2692587673664093,
-0.028026603162288666,
0.43180903792381287,
0.08892901241779327,
0.22981823980808258,
-0.49763092398643494,
-0.35718852281570435,
0.05680089816451073,
-1.129082202911377,
-0.19845633208751678,
-0.1941046267747879,
0.24056465923786163,
0.6147288680076599,
0.7103831171989441,
-0.8300899267196655,
0.31212231516838074,
0.3060365915298462,
-0.1757102608680725,
0.5883028507232666,
-0.20053163170814514,
0.06149502471089363,
-1.023107647895813,
-0.1727517992258072,
-0.4473837912082672,
-0.041670769453048706,
-0.7304419279098511,
0.09620967507362366,
-0.29220932722091675,
-0.029730603098869324,
-0.4847366213798523,
0.6275705695152283,
-0.44664260745048523,
-0.4624703526496887,
-0.484232097864151,
0.15642999112606049,
-0.33296632766723633,
0.37412229180336,
0.11750500649213791,
0.7478455305099487,
0.6564396023750305,
-0.7986846566200256,
0.5812928676605225,
0.02430737018585205,
0.11975066363811493,
0.7122907638549805,
-0.742389976978302,
0.33300721645355225,
-0.20264576375484467,
-0.2970495820045471,
-0.6752002239227295,
-0.1748296171426773,
0.208883136510849,
-0.21105311810970306,
0.15227025747299194,
0.21146439015865326,
-0.6932022571563721,
-0.5541025996208191,
-0.19444486498832703,
0.30329540371894836,
0.6938109397888184,
-0.5965723395347595,
1.0041471719741821,
0.35760074853897095,
0.015192103572189808,
-0.5362452268600464,
-0.8103681802749634,
0.27582547068595886,
-0.4419906735420227,
-0.7269736528396606,
0.19249239563941956,
0.08544455468654633,
-0.6449012756347656,
0.2802015244960785,
0.23872950673103333,
-0.18690386414527893,
0.005782283842563629,
0.41497310996055603,
0.27815937995910645,
-0.5360924601554871,
0.07202082127332687,
-0.17140060663223267,
-0.1628875881433487,
0.10593563318252563,
-0.4711964428424835,
0.7095175981521606,
-0.3549005389213562,
-0.663300633430481,
-0.3029848039150238,
0.29831334948539734,
0.6661710143089294,
0.03122721239924431,
0.8761922121047974,
0.19559864699840546,
-0.720361053943634,
-0.20270580053329468,
-0.7578157186508179,
-0.3158594071865082,
-0.4782564640045166,
0.24696692824363708,
-0.3595578372478485,
-1.03608238697052,
0.41935715079307556,
0.06050541251897812,
0.07663104683160782,
0.41527628898620605,
0.7563891410827637,
-0.04091833904385567,
0.5576350092887878,
0.8753944635391235,
-0.33072346448898315,
0.067776158452034,
0.1595427691936493,
0.32280465960502625,
-0.5663841962814331,
-0.18017856776714325,
-0.7265787124633789,
-0.1120210662484169,
-0.4206252694129944,
-0.44702595472335815,
0.37370526790618896,
-0.23299254477024078,
-0.4171404540538788,
0.44425880908966064,
-0.4959537982940674,
0.5005179047584534,
0.6770113110542297,
-0.18615245819091797,
0.4496587812900543,
-0.1562276929616928,
0.06344807147979736,
0.11332337558269501,
-0.6646216511726379,
-0.6836520433425903,
0.9379723072052002,
0.2381855845451355,
0.8158401250839233,
-0.04540928453207016,
0.5838798880577087,
0.3994366228580475,
0.27998557686805725,
-0.571952760219574,
0.7493813037872314,
-0.10180521011352539,
-0.6598175764083862,
-0.5330072641372681,
-0.2184760719537735,
-1.0839508771896362,
0.0988035649061203,
-0.23864559829235077,
-0.9556547999382019,
-0.19906046986579895,
-0.004710263106971979,
-0.3034486472606659,
0.4358161985874176,
-0.6217614412307739,
0.6875091195106506,
-0.3357433080673218,
-0.036122143268585205,
-0.3294351100921631,
-0.43897148966789246,
0.7011768221855164,
-0.1303929090499878,
0.1389816850423813,
0.08884227275848389,
-0.1544288694858551,
0.3241453468799591,
-0.3910786509513855,
0.9282577037811279,
0.23706084489822388,
0.1113315150141716,
0.3702227473258972,
0.1835031807422638,
0.508977472782135,
-0.11349174380302429,
-0.18132571876049042,
0.07127901166677475,
-0.44070398807525635,
-0.3046647906303406,
-0.331973135471344,
0.6276867985725403,
-0.761958122253418,
-0.8010638952255249,
-0.4307144284248352,
-0.6513095498085022,
-0.21300233900547028,
0.3859049379825592,
-0.23887287080287933,
-0.23051872849464417,
-0.16616040468215942,
-0.042350344359874725,
0.6902818083763123,
-0.5654685497283936,
0.48912784457206726,
0.5413327217102051,
-0.3025748133659363,
-0.11970052123069763,
0.7666329145431519,
-0.21187222003936768,
0.3143455386161804,
0.5558173060417175,
-0.14690952003002167,
-0.19662824273109436,
-0.6420522928237915,
-0.2941889464855194,
0.23832856118679047,
-0.5754517912864685,
-0.051785629242658615,
-0.6384994983673096,
-0.5419397354125977,
-0.10292337089776993,
-0.20415787398815155,
-0.45761004090309143,
-0.4898444712162018,
-0.11342158913612366,
-0.0003749870229512453,
0.4762718975543976,
0.9541575312614441,
0.14183369278907776,
0.3105168044567108,
-0.7295682430267334,
0.5131540298461914,
0.6821796894073486,
0.40105897188186646,
-0.13888312876224518,
-0.19597215950489044,
0.18460457026958466,
-0.09872259944677353,
-0.18703535199165344,
-0.8404593467712402,
0.33606237173080444,
0.05905285105109215,
0.7001302242279053,
0.21238912642002106,
-0.0597725436091423,
0.4855315089225769,
-0.6748085021972656,
0.7873881459236145,
0.08236468583345413,
-0.7116230130195618,
0.5272876620292664,
-0.12000977993011475,
-0.016634494066238403,
0.3536725640296936,
0.11410724371671677,
-0.35346555709838867,
-0.5588071942329407,
-0.4014001786708832,
-0.6459522843360901,
0.6829628944396973,
0.3537409007549286,
-0.28889551758766174,
0.052808649837970734,
0.5352887511253357,
0.37698763608932495,
0.28719115257263184,
-0.7071670293807983,
-0.5082187652587891,
0.11204798519611359,
-0.09819977730512619,
-0.0032935773488134146,
-0.10548717528581619,
-0.0022142475936561823,
0.255979984998703,
0.44489508867263794,
-0.034062016755342484,
0.47980430722236633,
0.037160392850637436,
-0.17847585678100586,
-0.08127746731042862,
0.214661106467247,
0.4654979407787323,
0.4479382336139679,
-0.11985365301370621,
0.22515134513378143,
0.350650429725647,
-0.06823183596134186,
-0.014111105352640152,
0.021475451067090034,
-0.47155386209487915,
-0.12106997519731522,
0.23530179262161255,
0.6602768898010254,
-0.26471808552742004,
-0.8973881006240845,
-0.12924325466156006,
0.04744146391749382,
-0.032378192991018295,
-0.6342769265174866,
0.3279373347759247,
0.2628784477710724,
0.42627355456352234,
0.3525906205177307,
-0.008593647740781307,
0.15554384887218475,
-0.7976052165031433,
0.17636148631572723,
0.5748898386955261,
-0.4154026210308075,
-0.07302816957235336,
0.817173957824707,
0.07550516724586487,
-0.8370056748390198,
0.6104272603988647,
-0.12094374746084213,
-0.3807033598423004,
0.8932388424873352,
0.4664473235607147,
0.8734046816825867,
-0.08436349034309387,
-0.03807934373617172,
-0.11595168709754944,
0.7620876431465149,
0.04567697271704674,
0.2590107321739197,
0.41773220896720886,
-0.6803424954414368,
-0.6523469686508179,
-0.6810727119445801,
-0.6857602596282959,
0.18624217808246613,
-0.25740304589271545,
0.3585132360458374,
-0.45747557282447815,
0.1700008064508438,
-0.0962604358792305,
-0.2630845010280609,
-0.5742807984352112,
0.030024519190192223,
0.4232073128223419,
0.9253031611442566,
-0.48370563983917236,
1.018797516822815,
0.7987315058708191,
-0.39597049355506897,
-0.3920881748199463,
-0.24122139811515808,
-0.04942549392580986,
-1.1563799381256104,
0.3248847723007202,
0.07972977310419083,
0.18979862332344055,
-0.4115001857280731,
-0.2377704679965973,
-0.6894100308418274,
1.1304457187652588,
0.5108458995819092,
-0.3001943528652191,
0.13955029845237732,
0.7863262295722961,
0.5789382457733154,
-0.6130250692367554,
0.151493638753891,
0.9730826020240784,
0.7691115736961365,
-0.11152341961860657,
-1.0403568744659424,
0.03358619287610054,
-0.013977211900055408,
-0.30401891469955444,
0.27679428458213806,
-0.5543107390403748,
0.8383404612541199,
-0.11290638148784637,
0.26088327169418335,
0.29471638798713684,
0.5982423424720764,
0.6462147831916809,
0.3874092698097229,
0.5393893718719482,
0.6682865023612976,
0.7378479242324829,
-0.3452252447605133,
1.1575833559036255,
-0.18917709589004517,
-0.35128912329673767,
0.9577106833457947,
-0.3943015933036804,
0.5972948670387268,
0.5071319341659546,
-0.36454513669013977,
0.3204179108142853,
0.500114917755127,
0.03741767257452011,
0.15776866674423218,
0.09522742033004761,
-0.034078821539878845,
-0.2269320785999298,
-0.06469190120697021,
-0.31717339158058167,
0.22939558327198029,
0.6645603775978088,
-0.03639151528477669,
-0.0892770066857338,
-0.24834594130516052,
-0.17547142505645752,
0.18282344937324524,
-0.4396215081214905,
0.9087811708450317,
0.20011667907238007,
-0.675818145275116,
0.475686252117157,
-0.01551505271345377,
0.554031252861023,
-0.35292303562164307,
-0.1180434376001358,
-0.12550686299800873,
0.2049349993467331,
-0.026363663375377655,
-0.793026864528656,
0.6359158158302307,
-0.15240751206874847,
-0.3010331094264984,
0.014892788603901863,
0.812091052532196,
-0.3342020809650421,
-0.6763306260108948,
0.40801867842674255,
0.5630985498428345,
0.27990514039993286,
-0.15225180983543396,
-0.6060190796852112,
0.13425324857234955,
-0.24771176278591156,
0.13219206035137177,
0.19756028056144714,
0.6126315593719482,
-0.16475196182727814,
0.9368067979812622,
0.35393697023391724,
0.12563027441501617,
0.5023590326309204,
-0.19564874470233917,
0.7616249322891235,
-0.8348497748374939,
-0.33256226778030396,
-0.9483554363250732,
0.23229877650737762,
-0.09593100100755692,
-0.017409030348062515,
0.5116370320320129,
0.32961326837539673,
0.3240126967430115,
-0.1627606451511383,
0.9117452502250671,
-0.0605696402490139,
0.5555561780929565,
-0.6103781461715698,
0.44345948100090027,
-0.6613128185272217,
0.562816321849823,
-0.20602168142795563,
-1.1578421592712402,
-0.4779195487499237,
0.5495467185974121,
-0.15766918659210205,
-0.10585121065378189,
0.7459258437156677,
0.5585588216781616,
0.17847169935703278,
0.1591184437274933,
0.39062634110450745,
0.5595933198928833,
0.3537229895591736,
0.8957852721214294,
0.9601684808731079,
-0.24627423286437988,
0.6919872164726257,
-0.10630274564027786,
-0.10562020540237427,
-0.2978539764881134,
-0.8721013069152832,
-1.118904709815979,
-0.23691491782665253,
-0.11843516677618027,
-0.1708587110042572,
0.31256258487701416,
0.7065625786781311,
0.6928830146789551,
-0.8735650181770325,
-0.3170320987701416,
-0.16487470269203186,
0.5059463381767273,
-0.20004020631313324,
-0.12453284859657288,
0.31061726808547974,
-0.5476523637771606,
-0.7105448842048645,
0.5381460189819336,
0.644446074962616,
-0.1823670119047165,
-0.35212114453315735,
-0.331699401140213,
0.1526281237602234,
0.3327045738697052,
0.5071273446083069,
0.4420913755893707,
-0.8973484635353088,
-0.23374666273593903,
0.2980755865573883,
0.030798885971307755,
0.0713527649641037,
0.5825444459915161,
-0.7641041278839111,
0.15610121190547943,
0.17452605068683624,
1.1233433485031128,
0.38489237427711487,
-0.3355626165866852,
0.7674660682678223,
-0.31066635251045227,
0.44895488023757935,
0.42460209131240845,
0.5373768210411072,
0.14948487281799316,
-0.3112676441669464,
0.6053523421287537,
0.1082218736410141,
-0.46091029047966003,
-0.7809976935386658,
0.34864354133605957,
-0.9749703407287598,
-0.438541054725647,
0.9696327447891235,
0.22387486696243286,
-0.32928791642189026,
-0.23579491674900055,
-0.14448529481887817,
-0.1468246877193451,
-0.2624549865722656,
1.0941247940063477,
0.6700926423072815,
-0.40228331089019775,
-0.23676489293575287,
-0.538263201713562,
0.32200658321380615,
0.453336238861084,
-1.1396068334579468,
-0.16394217312335968,
0.30142584443092346,
-0.2271120399236679,
0.34963878989219666,
0.4916943609714508,
-0.20155583322048187,
0.3530777096748352,
-0.10806062817573547,
0.22295834124088287,
0.00033983224420808256,
-0.4931168854236603,
-0.17094786465168,
0.3970286548137665,
0.2718714475631714,
-0.04946036636829376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12209v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12209v1
|
Interface Design for Self-Supervised Speech Models
| 2024-06-18T02:13:48 | 2024-06-18T02:13:48 |
Yi-Jen Shih, David Harwath
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Self-supervised speech (SSL) models have recently become widely adopted for
many downstream speech processing tasks. The general usage pattern is to employ
SSL models as feature extractors, and then train a downstream prediction head
to solve a specific task. However, different layers of SSL models have been
shown to capture different types of information, and the methods of combining
them are not well studied. To this end, we extend the general framework for SSL
model utilization by proposing the interface that connects the upstream and
downstream. Under this view, the dominant technique of combining features via a
layerwise weighted sum can be regarded as a specific interface. We propose
several alternative interface designs and demonstrate that the weighted sum
interface is suboptimal for many tasks. In particular, we show that a
convolutional interface whose depth scales logarithmically with the depth of
the upstream model consistently outperforms many other interface designs.
|
[
-0.6126750707626343,
-0.4021919369697571,
0.4020102322101593,
0.27595216035842896,
-0.23171471059322357,
-0.08807200938463211,
0.258833646774292,
-0.7334460020065308,
0.3485044240951538,
0.5588589310646057,
-0.5536282658576965,
-0.08842575550079346,
-0.44015926122665405,
-0.3346760869026184,
-0.620619535446167,
0.9550173282623291,
0.25817734003067017,
-0.08380760252475739,
-0.2771465480327606,
-0.05370628461241722,
-0.4218555986881256,
-0.6772060394287109,
-0.7674912810325623,
-0.6364462375640869,
0.5585024356842041,
0.2970527410507202,
0.5428739786148071,
0.42710453271865845,
0.5228986144065857,
0.2959034740924835,
0.12384512275457382,
-0.18961216509342194,
-0.23433487117290497,
-0.03558190166950226,
-0.062483642250299454,
-0.04973491281270981,
-0.5769339203834534,
0.3289824426174164,
0.46785590052604675,
0.9629418253898621,
-0.17327214777469635,
0.4283906817436218,
0.32796671986579895,
0.779130756855011,
-0.7251970171928406,
-0.042725082486867905,
-0.163113072514534,
0.12966986000537872,
-0.22409780323505402,
-0.03964684158563614,
-0.3188247084617615,
0.07529200613498688,
0.48599115014076233,
-0.3186255991458893,
-0.09053239226341248,
-0.2319956123828888,
0.13755926489830017,
0.41419321298599243,
-0.3596377968788147,
-0.15153475105762482,
-0.7761794328689575,
0.6909658908843994,
-0.9017651677131653,
0.5101064443588257,
0.23917073011398315,
0.2512931525707245,
0.17885242402553558,
-0.7171452045440674,
-0.12040755897760391,
-0.21592962741851807,
-0.41838395595550537,
0.3309909403324127,
-0.3418651819229126,
0.08080007880926132,
-0.018260477110743523,
0.31535640358924866,
-0.5195516347885132,
0.4671260118484497,
-0.5956833958625793,
-0.0337117575109005,
1.0467196702957153,
0.17171910405158997,
0.1406296193599701,
0.0552438348531723,
-0.5749912261962891,
0.20298443734645844,
-0.6101818084716797,
0.5797149538993835,
0.5652549266815186,
0.46735405921936035,
-0.48949113488197327,
0.39603668451309204,
-0.4735373556613922,
0.9011899828910828,
0.30233943462371826,
-0.005671920720487833,
0.24235743284225464,
-0.1640511006116867,
-0.21959441900253296,
0.3830101191997528,
0.5739532709121704,
-0.02190454863011837,
0.4408237934112549,
-0.010845585726201534,
-0.24528877437114716,
-0.2879379987716675,
0.4034300148487091,
-0.6621469259262085,
-0.6073725819587708,
0.6107935905456543,
-0.6583370566368103,
-0.3619651198387146,
-0.2841886579990387,
-0.26555997133255005,
-0.08081518858671188,
-0.70982825756073,
0.5801246166229248,
-0.025936778634786606,
-0.6187074780464172,
-0.251605361700058,
-0.36874476075172424,
0.2786804735660553,
0.09501060098409653,
-1.0846550464630127,
0.44289448857307434,
0.6049062013626099,
0.9154109358787537,
-0.3776286244392395,
-0.10537133365869522,
-0.7346938848495483,
0.1558789312839508,
-0.3185298442840576,
0.6352825164794922,
-0.5261415243148804,
-0.5566408038139343,
-0.23296646773815155,
-0.35133230686187744,
0.029624884948134422,
-0.3509693443775177,
0.36800849437713623,
-0.1280701756477356,
0.2360512912273407,
0.014544645324349403,
-0.7207365036010742,
0.18318210542201996,
-0.47923606634140015,
-0.5203810930252075,
0.5942322611808777,
0.17043821513652802,
-0.8555363416671753,
-0.04849550873041153,
-0.6801503896713257,
-0.7092968225479126,
0.345845103263855,
-0.24111336469650269,
-0.49913325905799866,
0.26231589913368225,
0.041318152099847794,
0.49492064118385315,
0.08370067179203033,
0.2717558741569519,
-0.6067748069763184,
-0.49589094519615173,
0.1333339661359787,
-0.15422117710113525,
0.9487434029579163,
0.6161215901374817,
-0.10897216200828552,
0.06632129848003387,
-0.9295040369033813,
-0.04277748614549637,
-0.2491883933544159,
-0.32585543394088745,
-0.7068600654602051,
0.12409117072820663,
-0.04228619858622551,
0.09195739030838013,
0.30292585492134094,
-0.6437203288078308,
-0.31211963295936584,
-0.1718684583902359,
0.7823836207389832,
0.6868829727172852,
-0.18097704648971558,
0.5500522255897522,
0.02232016623020172,
0.2558649182319641,
0.33357805013656616,
0.4384324848651886,
0.11759857088327408,
-0.3723769187927246,
-0.6396660208702087,
-0.2913387715816498,
0.40920954942703247,
0.4387817084789276,
-0.3856978118419647,
0.24828532338142395,
-0.006759711541235447,
-0.6770932674407959,
-0.6276277899742126,
0.2279355376958847,
0.5238465666770935,
0.8189102411270142,
0.5716123580932617,
-0.25600486993789673,
-0.33120232820510864,
-1.3372207880020142,
-0.3694226145744324,
-0.11378844827413559,
-0.43777868151664734,
0.2875252366065979,
0.051064979285001755,
0.42244961857795715,
1.1123257875442505,
-0.2338942587375641,
-0.44996458292007446,
-0.2414676398038864,
0.3502686023712158,
0.32972899079322815,
0.894875705242157,
0.5483461022377014,
-0.8130847215652466,
-0.38758695125579834,
-0.20951208472251892,
-0.855069100856781,
-0.181155264377594,
-0.015033875592052937,
0.15789522230625153,
-0.19131387770175934,
0.37540385127067566,
-0.4691428542137146,
0.4689425826072693,
0.7032186388969421,
0.10457426309585571,
0.12479648739099503,
-0.16653235256671906,
-0.2731766998767853,
-0.7204364538192749,
-0.18665066361427307,
0.435476690530777,
-0.07606353610754013,
-1.1848199367523193,
-0.0824945792555809,
0.2396770417690277,
-0.207513689994812,
-0.807989776134491,
0.5117031335830688,
-0.410325825214386,
-0.30412229895591736,
-0.4557914435863495,
0.06790918111801147,
-0.12936057150363922,
0.6525251269340515,
0.3492700159549713,
0.7104973793029785,
0.5934740900993347,
-0.719931960105896,
0.2411922663450241,
0.04164619743824005,
-0.020074276253581047,
0.6666518449783325,
-1.0870534181594849,
0.07794231921434402,
-0.18021930754184723,
0.21713975071907043,
-1.244123101234436,
-0.088150255382061,
-0.04721297696232796,
-0.5176259875297546,
0.3283175528049469,
-0.2992668151855469,
0.43020471930503845,
-0.25920236110687256,
-0.32804641127586365,
0.5543663501739502,
0.6293485760688782,
-0.5595928430557251,
0.999276876449585,
0.7661173939704895,
-0.23869219422340393,
-0.23866793513298035,
-1.2259132862091064,
-0.0687580406665802,
-0.526965320110321,
-0.6814824342727661,
0.4136374294757843,
0.07909677177667618,
-0.11799417436122894,
-0.10447802394628525,
-0.09655030071735382,
0.03028029203414917,
0.07615766674280167,
0.3996579051017761,
0.08075118809938431,
-0.2776219844818115,
0.05016425997018814,
0.1788855791091919,
-0.19345498085021973,
0.08228588849306107,
-0.29008764028549194,
0.15668651461601257,
0.10434526205062866,
-0.41521090269088745,
-0.7384405136108398,
0.6797565817832947,
0.1767614185810089,
-0.37128084897994995,
0.25848302245140076,
0.459179550409317,
-0.2643187344074249,
0.027094189077615738,
-0.6914326548576355,
-0.05423744395375252,
-0.5218874216079712,
0.03818867355585098,
-0.7772237658500671,
-0.958282470703125,
0.5069227814674377,
0.07830984145402908,
0.25562581419944763,
0.45151346921920776,
0.2870326042175293,
-0.6094066500663757,
1.136199712753296,
0.7493792176246643,
-0.2877811789512634,
0.46449071168899536,
-0.19440290331840515,
0.2943923771381378,
-1.378086805343628,
0.12770234048366547,
-0.43115463852882385,
-0.42421865463256836,
-0.7926129698753357,
0.5191911458969116,
0.3297528922557831,
-0.030265657231211662,
-0.252388060092926,
0.44479525089263916,
-0.5201467275619507,
0.040580835193395615,
0.9599717259407043,
0.1301780492067337,
0.08664356917142868,
-0.26616835594177246,
0.18523767590522766,
0.22318007051944733,
-0.6340771913528442,
-0.045928601175546646,
0.7819918990135193,
0.5231491923332214,
1.064430832862854,
0.08669669181108475,
0.9317561984062195,
0.5899083018302917,
0.11061706393957138,
-0.30568963289260864,
0.29024946689605713,
-0.6138537526130676,
-0.4406659007072449,
-0.6551994681358337,
-0.3073635995388031,
-0.7521737217903137,
0.3619694113731384,
0.06571942567825317,
-0.6926572918891907,
0.6935368776321411,
0.550480306148529,
-0.5151699781417847,
-0.1925704926252365,
-0.9277909398078918,
0.6903782486915588,
-0.2510344088077545,
-0.15112753212451935,
-0.22357787191867828,
-0.648123562335968,
0.5129728317260742,
-0.12183615565299988,
0.2685951590538025,
-0.12669982016086578,
0.30113929510116577,
0.621411919593811,
-0.4281909465789795,
1.0612891912460327,
-0.4434833526611328,
-0.24753351509571075,
0.37935587763786316,
-0.07327932119369507,
0.3436115086078644,
-0.12163353711366653,
0.1426403969526291,
0.36924755573272705,
-0.08000944554805756,
-0.30674275755882263,
-0.359510600566864,
0.8733684420585632,
-0.7607703804969788,
-0.7147941589355469,
0.006624976173043251,
-0.2731286585330963,
-0.25050216913223267,
-0.12813007831573486,
0.07223786413669586,
0.9197620153427124,
0.2947161793708801,
0.18346139788627625,
0.37418413162231445,
-0.013351335190236568,
0.6449368596076965,
0.507001519203186,
0.06523893028497696,
-0.0962405875325203,
1.151766061782837,
0.37693387269973755,
0.5149721503257751,
0.23653993010520935,
0.47818320989608765,
-0.5228070616722107,
-0.653302013874054,
-0.36146265268325806,
-0.2781967222690582,
-0.5410569310188293,
-0.037341635674238205,
-0.4852752983570099,
-0.9302628636360168,
-0.6107445359230042,
0.13070650398731232,
-0.3087433874607086,
-0.6409711837768555,
-0.2456970065832138,
0.0023462409153580666,
0.07158885151147842,
0.3222304880619049,
-0.32660168409347534,
0.44305670261383057,
-0.4089881479740143,
0.5412108302116394,
0.8854515552520752,
0.3512187600135803,
0.19124077260494232,
-0.7452338933944702,
-0.16212812066078186,
0.06006348133087158,
-0.05234823748469353,
-0.5531190037727356,
0.2584119141101837,
0.35023733973503113,
0.7515453100204468,
0.3458729088306427,
0.13180968165397644,
0.7790977954864502,
-0.5078902840614319,
0.736407995223999,
0.2585549056529999,
-0.9001020789146423,
0.750469446182251,
-0.13095775246620178,
0.45858636498451233,
0.3041412830352783,
0.45128321647644043,
-0.39574408531188965,
-0.7957378029823303,
-0.5847756266593933,
-0.539381206035614,
0.31331804394721985,
0.2497359663248062,
0.24563826620578766,
0.2377348244190216,
0.22641409933567047,
0.07743800431489944,
0.04029542952775955,
-0.7473553419113159,
-0.25457489490509033,
-0.5410017371177673,
-0.3502993881702423,
0.01080236304551363,
-0.20545707643032074,
0.015242195688188076,
-0.25478026270866394,
0.4656022787094116,
-0.12370102107524872,
-0.14600570499897003,
0.3762390613555908,
0.03645453229546547,
0.050706300884485245,
0.05099866911768913,
0.5311684608459473,
0.7273252606391907,
-0.11596269905567169,
0.4273785948753357,
0.04003297910094261,
-0.1777932047843933,
-0.09117042273283005,
-0.06465302407741547,
-0.299431711435318,
-0.26405641436576843,
0.5048562288284302,
0.7862993478775024,
0.2707378566265106,
-0.11508666723966599,
0.36834922432899475,
-0.0667557567358017,
-0.3701234757900238,
-0.44752174615859985,
0.304536908864975,
0.3324434161186218,
0.5273413062095642,
0.5828383564949036,
-0.1565355360507965,
0.7152464985847473,
-0.3256871700286865,
0.2218475490808487,
0.8308249711990356,
-0.4085352420806885,
-0.028030171990394592,
0.9136005640029907,
0.5496957302093506,
-0.5791355967521667,
0.5732582211494446,
0.3064580261707306,
-0.18614999949932098,
0.49989232420921326,
0.2863163650035858,
0.9384610652923584,
-0.3637102246284485,
0.010128860361874104,
0.20267941057682037,
0.01324361003935337,
0.43939635157585144,
0.030970515683293343,
-0.4602005183696747,
-0.47225722670555115,
-0.6053798198699951,
-0.7059983015060425,
-0.4842696487903595,
0.2117842435836792,
-0.6184194087982178,
0.0694364458322525,
-0.2573748826980591,
-0.13761985301971436,
0.4837525188922882,
-0.32166150212287903,
-0.5938960313796997,
0.46144580841064453,
0.386096715927124,
0.7100557684898376,
-0.9121118783950806,
1.049645185470581,
0.07304554432630539,
-0.40667852759361267,
-0.6563324332237244,
-0.51642245054245,
-0.13750337064266205,
-0.8933209180831909,
0.7798585295677185,
-0.023386454209685326,
-0.3455118238925934,
0.13442067801952362,
-0.4088764488697052,
-1.0588372945785522,
0.7159026265144348,
0.020292101427912712,
-0.7138652801513672,
0.13988491892814636,
0.31998512148857117,
0.4311964809894562,
-0.7025544047355652,
0.15487565100193024,
0.4254757761955261,
0.2220897227525711,
0.14963601529598236,
-0.8522465825080872,
-0.11947991698980331,
-0.20572315156459808,
0.2884041368961334,
-0.1064184233546257,
-0.8233746886253357,
0.9261621832847595,
0.09544523805379868,
-0.1831187903881073,
-0.20458181202411652,
0.9654797911643982,
0.13158394396305084,
0.20931963622570038,
0.8612350821495056,
0.44259360432624817,
0.23625828325748444,
0.07529739290475845,
0.7012284994125366,
-0.20030970871448517,
0.20435771346092224,
1.4045403003692627,
-0.11217636615037918,
0.8543257117271423,
0.43460315465927124,
-0.265567421913147,
0.22376880049705505,
0.8770358562469482,
0.12513746321201324,
0.7818463444709778,
0.30469268560409546,
-0.02819507196545601,
-0.3701068162918091,
-0.10535401105880737,
-0.5046099424362183,
0.6182103157043457,
0.09121605008840561,
-0.11515414714813232,
-0.09285717457532883,
0.04795527085661888,
-0.662752091884613,
-0.33571240305900574,
-0.4863012731075287,
0.9041127562522888,
0.32143986225128174,
-0.5586938261985779,
0.2530505657196045,
-0.33138227462768555,
0.5796149373054504,
-0.43611109256744385,
-0.02145247533917427,
-0.588367223739624,
-0.05088363587856293,
-0.4228602349758148,
-0.9430423974990845,
0.2525578737258911,
-0.29587575793266296,
0.05557039752602577,
-0.20869477093219757,
0.7726076245307922,
-0.5378854274749756,
-0.6170215010643005,
0.3769799768924713,
0.373586505651474,
0.21242505311965942,
-0.05008016899228096,
-0.38955068588256836,
-0.08394069969654083,
-0.3656618595123291,
-0.21594975888729095,
0.5178357362747192,
0.09925141930580139,
-0.01671351119875908,
0.8419760465621948,
0.6210964322090149,
0.0724402368068695,
0.3171140253543854,
0.5941590666770935,
0.8017145991325378,
-0.4456208646297455,
-0.6377156376838684,
-0.7981239557266235,
0.6414014101028442,
-0.22227491438388824,
-0.2281782478094101,
0.4631991386413574,
0.4801909923553467,
0.8448165655136108,
0.07887677848339081,
0.8433874845504761,
0.3655093312263489,
0.7302936911582947,
-0.6153439283370972,
0.4011588990688324,
-0.6984583735466003,
-0.07577439397573471,
-0.1885485053062439,
-0.7514935731887817,
0.1806560605764389,
0.5115512013435364,
-0.025325700640678406,
0.13269226253032684,
0.25931811332702637,
0.2231113165616989,
-0.3885001242160797,
0.2286716252565384,
0.44029805064201355,
-0.042920563369989395,
0.3983018696308136,
0.5677710771560669,
0.833812952041626,
-0.11883257329463959,
0.21843299269676208,
-0.4923512935638428,
-0.370018869638443,
-0.0777624174952507,
-0.908842146396637,
-0.8497390151023865,
-0.7128527760505676,
-0.4033818542957306,
0.363478422164917,
-0.10833856463432312,
0.24357059597969055,
1.1246230602264404,
-0.7791991829872131,
-0.3956367075443268,
0.009597407653927803,
-0.034765370190143585,
-0.17341019213199615,
-0.23086203634738922,
0.1939181536436081,
-0.4989023208618164,
-0.5440532565116882,
0.5624787211418152,
0.49648404121398926,
0.18475386500358582,
-0.8535153269767761,
0.07116080820560455,
0.0129067562520504,
-0.00672714039683342,
0.5653825402259827,
0.44690197706222534,
-0.8135361075401306,
-0.47650328278541565,
-0.39076098799705505,
0.06720136106014252,
0.0007189472671598196,
0.9002797603607178,
-0.832821786403656,
0.11980395019054413,
0.36543795466423035,
0.6698894500732422,
0.8186088800430298,
0.31906142830848694,
0.476129949092865,
-0.8373415470123291,
0.067625492811203,
-0.2061605304479599,
0.3211425244808197,
0.19273576140403748,
-0.45237988233566284,
0.6317656636238098,
-0.23099154233932495,
-0.45535027980804443,
-0.5455182194709778,
0.3395300507545471,
-0.9897438287734985,
-0.3693700432777405,
0.5885685682296753,
-0.052646394819021225,
-0.14393725991249084,
-0.038376256823539734,
0.17623285949230194,
-0.009355698712170124,
-0.12327604740858078,
0.6623576283454895,
0.6161177754402161,
-0.7666664123535156,
-0.4636552333831787,
-0.39233165979385376,
0.38622143864631653,
0.21174544095993042,
-0.5583223104476929,
-0.046676624566316605,
0.18127427995204926,
0.31416016817092896,
0.1889020800590515,
0.8106463551521301,
0.13144943118095398,
0.09387604147195816,
-0.19075407087802887,
-0.1831822246313095,
-0.1350765973329544,
-0.462088018655777,
-0.42546337842941284,
0.16771851480007172,
-0.14335069060325623,
-0.4209011197090149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12208v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12208v1
|
Knowledge Fusion By Evolving Weights of Language Models
| 2024-06-18T02:12:34 | 2024-06-18T02:12:34 |
Guodong Du, Jing Li, Hanting Liu, Runhua Jiang, Shuyang Yu, Yifei Guo, Sim Kuan Goh, Ho-Kin Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.NE
|
Fine-tuning pre-trained language models, particularly large language models,
demands extensive computing resources and can result in varying performance
outcomes across different domains and datasets. This paper examines the
approach of integrating multiple models from diverse training scenarios into a
unified model. This unified model excels across various data domains and
exhibits the ability to generalize well on out-of-domain data. We propose a
knowledge fusion method named Evolver, inspired by evolutionary algorithms,
which does not need further training or additional training data. Specifically,
our method involves aggregating the weights of different language models into a
population and subsequently generating offspring models through mutation and
crossover operations. These offspring models are then evaluated against their
parents, allowing for the preservation of those models that show enhanced
performance on development datasets. Importantly, our model evolving strategy
can be seamlessly integrated with existing model merging frameworks, offering a
versatile tool for model enhancement. Experimental results on mainstream
language models (i.e., encoder-only, decoder-only, encoder-decoder) reveal that
Evolver outperforms previous state-of-the-art models by large margins. The code
is publicly available at {https://github.com/duguodong7/model-evolution}.
|
[
-0.4296177327632904,
-0.486526757478714,
0.24332264065742493,
-0.1698131561279297,
-0.029806260019540787,
0.31675970554351807,
-0.35919493436813354,
-0.4653173089027405,
-0.08507303148508072,
0.5411432981491089,
-0.3997196853160858,
-0.13780300319194794,
-0.634553074836731,
-0.22231420874595642,
-0.40335211157798767,
0.7955635786056519,
0.15172500908374786,
0.1713835746049881,
-0.531933069229126,
-0.19048990309238434,
-0.31925731897354126,
-0.21044884622097015,
-0.1922832876443863,
-0.7826983332633972,
0.04596898704767227,
0.2196662276983261,
0.7812985181808472,
0.7727910280227661,
0.28987011313438416,
0.28158584237098694,
-0.11846252530813217,
0.42967647314071655,
-0.7071276307106018,
0.051353804767131805,
-0.33595624566078186,
-0.14617611467838287,
-0.17376671731472015,
-0.36316925287246704,
0.5870068073272705,
0.8412712216377258,
-0.17938068509101868,
0.001300264149904251,
0.12850983440876007,
0.4377534091472626,
-0.6772999167442322,
-0.18259137868881226,
-0.6605516076087952,
-0.18587686121463776,
-0.15030264854431152,
0.055092617869377136,
-0.3129003345966339,
-0.4347274899482727,
0.3310529291629791,
-0.4133959412574768,
0.030504979193210602,
-0.08140364289283752,
0.7568894624710083,
0.046582527458667755,
-0.24779000878334045,
0.043478429317474365,
-1.0663955211639404,
0.8467159867286682,
-0.7907975912094116,
0.7570021152496338,
-0.1433921754360199,
0.24416664242744446,
-0.32514163851737976,
-0.6536663174629211,
-0.7449904680252075,
0.03920585289597511,
-0.06834910064935684,
-0.014165508560836315,
-0.41867268085479736,
-0.026378406211733818,
-0.2390412837266922,
0.44110897183418274,
-0.5491753816604614,
0.29878318309783936,
-0.5140101909637451,
0.06240023300051689,
0.6592293381690979,
-0.14412494003772736,
0.6831361055374146,
0.32933130860328674,
-0.13041438162326813,
-0.29461565613746643,
-0.7191540002822876,
-0.23126371204853058,
0.38085228204727173,
0.5170993804931641,
-0.06944993138313293,
0.519840657711029,
-0.2709692716598511,
1.0054693222045898,
0.14013022184371948,
-0.04040418192744255,
0.26387619972229004,
-0.317231684923172,
-0.06621219217777252,
-0.10533618927001953,
0.7369244694709778,
0.013686287216842175,
0.16070200502872467,
-0.49551910161972046,
-0.1402830183506012,
0.10658320039510727,
0.20015200972557068,
-0.4641910791397095,
-0.46348094940185547,
0.042410265654325485,
-0.29509222507476807,
-0.2996947169303894,
-0.23794767260551453,
-1.0150296688079834,
-0.5060900449752808,
-0.2801195979118347,
0.7413573861122131,
-0.6066968441009521,
-0.5663825869560242,
0.4729653000831604,
-0.34044086933135986,
0.26727718114852905,
-0.04605119302868843,
-1.0598273277282715,
0.2801150381565094,
0.6825295090675354,
0.45114433765411377,
-0.20465166866779327,
-0.46987468004226685,
-0.26535916328430176,
0.10227397084236145,
-0.07084585726261139,
0.8230018615722656,
-0.7530669569969177,
-0.42027193307876587,
0.034238051623106,
-0.3900575339794159,
-0.3393001854419708,
-0.507000207901001,
0.33236566185951233,
-0.701525092124939,
0.3981158435344696,
0.12561479210853577,
-0.7960286736488342,
-0.2724260985851288,
-0.09070398658514023,
-0.5564088821411133,
0.9894014000892639,
0.46256470680236816,
-0.5519896149635315,
0.5207102298736572,
-0.9702568650245667,
-0.5937118530273438,
0.395616352558136,
-0.07676396518945694,
-0.26220476627349854,
0.054467540234327316,
0.4458478093147278,
0.3692411482334137,
-0.4925018548965454,
0.2243259698152542,
-0.37550634145736694,
-0.05814897269010544,
-0.06793950498104095,
0.13093021512031555,
0.7067421078681946,
0.3821616768836975,
-0.18837139010429382,
0.044643327593803406,
-0.6829915046691895,
0.15507331490516663,
0.3059402406215668,
-0.3841228187084198,
-0.5515512824058533,
0.06826278567314148,
-0.2752256691455841,
0.1738291233778,
0.32547906041145325,
-0.4503849446773529,
0.39576950669288635,
-0.45838749408721924,
0.34574851393699646,
0.2324855923652649,
0.007868262007832527,
0.7899424433708191,
-0.3872601091861725,
0.41364097595214844,
0.0031856198329478502,
0.15898767113685608,
-0.054494984447956085,
-0.5141072869300842,
-0.9076634645462036,
0.08951561897993088,
0.4845471680164337,
0.27061140537261963,
-0.6739817261695862,
0.7576144337654114,
-0.8425464034080505,
-0.6826134920120239,
-0.9060277342796326,
0.4455913305282593,
0.30740946531295776,
0.30570077896118164,
0.4898056089878082,
-0.23700128495693207,
-0.634345293045044,
-0.7675564289093018,
-0.3075563907623291,
-0.09932390600442886,
0.044028010219335556,
0.08316642045974731,
0.2746411859989166,
-0.510362446308136,
1.1505472660064697,
-0.4137550890445709,
0.22421300411224365,
-0.6455374956130981,
0.05945038050413132,
-0.13251350820064545,
0.7571049332618713,
0.5119243860244751,
-0.8479423522949219,
-0.0719861090183258,
0.5394536256790161,
-0.6715495586395264,
0.05278484895825386,
0.03661666065454483,
-0.2036801427602768,
-0.2838982343673706,
0.19998286664485931,
-0.3435627520084381,
-0.2249992936849594,
0.8249630331993103,
-0.18130721151828766,
0.28900304436683655,
-0.24210695922374725,
0.14377962052822113,
-1.244994878768921,
0.007991925813257694,
-0.08273465931415558,
0.03987165912985802,
-1.157119870185852,
0.40705808997154236,
0.162416473031044,
-0.05016767606139183,
-0.374377965927124,
0.7462112307548523,
-0.4136667251586914,
0.08346004039049149,
-0.13803033530712128,
0.13950210809707642,
-0.07252098619937897,
0.15203040838241577,
0.018387671560049057,
0.5589056015014648,
0.7384080290794373,
-0.8266070485115051,
0.41597121953964233,
0.2541068494319916,
-0.4790501296520233,
0.13838647305965424,
-0.37278273701667786,
0.20755144953727722,
-0.1966547966003418,
-0.13639946281909943,
-0.5994533896446228,
-0.19646872580051422,
-0.07481759786605835,
-0.31188613176345825,
0.3760626018047333,
-0.26387277245521545,
-0.2734277844429016,
-0.5745991468429565,
0.0764792338013649,
0.3302091062068939,
0.8921899199485779,
-0.9240831732749939,
1.0521892309188843,
0.509044885635376,
-0.16810522973537445,
-0.2930010259151459,
-0.463615745306015,
-0.04443309083580971,
-0.33752864599227905,
-0.9255098700523376,
0.4503838121891022,
-0.11845599114894867,
-0.14377743005752563,
0.0954948365688324,
0.12197332829236984,
-0.03684912994503975,
-0.11865369230508804,
-0.22766657173633575,
0.20770059525966644,
-0.42082059383392334,
0.1584189534187317,
0.46598491072654724,
0.26485389471054077,
-0.3838452398777008,
-0.7241562604904175,
0.7614303827285767,
0.04398239776492119,
-0.3340180814266205,
0.02515510469675064,
0.08843974769115448,
0.7681381702423096,
-0.4028703570365906,
0.9155441522598267,
0.37100979685783386,
-0.35839566588401794,
-0.34939438104629517,
-0.7926454544067383,
-0.030394304543733597,
-0.45709896087646484,
0.3973879814147949,
-0.33805885910987854,
-0.9790692329406738,
0.48906317353248596,
-0.6144013404846191,
0.204700767993927,
0.6089943647384644,
0.3697381317615509,
0.3210461437702179,
1.2458295822143555,
1.0500556230545044,
-0.14303812384605408,
0.46423307061195374,
-0.19542939960956573,
0.16288481652736664,
-0.8808914422988892,
-0.3872806131839752,
-0.439199298620224,
-0.22261568903923035,
-0.27166229486465454,
-0.3231504559516907,
0.01106322929263115,
0.3589343726634979,
-0.18193082511425018,
0.5499128699302673,
-0.5202717781066895,
0.6104327440261841,
0.30988168716430664,
0.04957428202033043,
0.29372280836105347,
0.007217057980597019,
-0.25387877225875854,
0.18292959034442902,
-1.104634165763855,
-0.17824487388134003,
1.1044809818267822,
0.22789548337459564,
0.8345023989677429,
0.22646553814411163,
0.7196131944656372,
0.0765305832028389,
0.1989467889070511,
-0.37503018975257874,
0.26111164689064026,
-0.4139327108860016,
-0.28970420360565186,
-0.24252133071422577,
-0.6446245908737183,
-0.8649557828903198,
0.37082430720329285,
-0.4684164226055145,
-0.7356019616127014,
0.428617924451828,
0.039330773055553436,
-0.36213234066963196,
0.3395470976829529,
-0.8010461330413818,
0.7285181879997253,
-0.454865425825119,
-0.015497536398470402,
-0.22149869799613953,
-0.3369680643081665,
0.7748197317123413,
-0.4884328246116638,
0.29300016164779663,
0.13143301010131836,
0.27666905522346497,
0.8260582685470581,
-0.15266327559947968,
0.4210381507873535,
-0.08661547303199768,
-0.0979803130030632,
0.05627024173736572,
-0.005087511148303747,
0.49558621644973755,
-0.3800511062145233,
-0.16769514977931976,
0.1170593649148941,
-0.35490861535072327,
-0.324657678604126,
-0.6729680299758911,
0.650537371635437,
-0.9730846285820007,
-0.4411962926387787,
0.2309948205947876,
-0.538212239742279,
-0.4777790307998657,
0.3442782163619995,
0.27286723256111145,
0.36883166432380676,
-0.15717923641204834,
0.13410541415214539,
0.6631492376327515,
-0.14605717360973358,
0.15707649290561676,
0.6283391118049622,
-0.32549193501472473,
-0.3556824028491974,
0.9255339503288269,
-0.21620723605155945,
0.4674905240535736,
0.34099647402763367,
0.40059810876846313,
-0.2527483105659485,
-0.6656635403633118,
-0.48289400339126587,
0.09606882929801941,
-0.6355942487716675,
-0.3380429446697235,
-0.8816779255867004,
-0.31544727087020874,
-0.588870108127594,
-0.1830025166273117,
-0.46962621808052063,
-0.17132870852947235,
-0.015676721930503845,
0.14304959774017334,
0.49519798159599304,
0.9088287353515625,
-0.09465740621089935,
0.5106464624404907,
-0.930791437625885,
0.1516546756029129,
0.5027734041213989,
0.41304853558540344,
0.15122395753860474,
-0.6448901891708374,
-0.2766816020011902,
0.3642674386501312,
-0.07403802126646042,
-0.5985448956489563,
0.3906346559524536,
0.4908102750778198,
0.8664084076881409,
0.495411217212677,
-0.08521060645580292,
0.7852529883384705,
-0.25654131174087524,
0.7772067785263062,
0.24390800297260284,
-0.9015874862670898,
0.5839171409606934,
-0.3064436614513397,
0.5077182650566101,
0.5219401121139526,
0.32219213247299194,
-0.4294328987598419,
-0.34613317251205444,
-0.4897683262825012,
-0.6663011312484741,
0.5988628268241882,
0.020324865356087685,
0.21605339646339417,
0.3994837701320648,
0.38971617817878723,
0.30942362546920776,
-0.13368819653987885,
-0.48993179202079773,
-0.09906397014856339,
-0.06867665797472,
-0.3605601191520691,
-0.050152938812971115,
0.06893908232450485,
-0.08599184453487396,
-0.5606698989868164,
0.7123581171035767,
-0.018373902887105942,
-0.03771810606122017,
-0.4396805167198181,
-0.44106370210647583,
-0.20787125825881958,
0.18102380633354187,
0.37910255789756775,
0.6029345989227295,
0.1630147099494934,
-0.0009905720362439752,
0.39104321599006653,
-0.4508587718009949,
0.051449764519929886,
0.3371281623840332,
-0.12717950344085693,
-0.32943180203437805,
0.26406022906303406,
0.8473340272903442,
0.43873536586761475,
-0.5794130563735962,
0.26568546891212463,
-0.15696609020233154,
-0.21962818503379822,
0.36502134799957275,
0.38598424196243286,
0.1868198812007904,
0.3906098008155823,
0.29740098118782043,
0.18747977912425995,
-0.1744581162929535,
-0.37963035702705383,
0.32603558897972107,
0.33795884251594543,
-0.11764156073331833,
-0.3320164680480957,
0.4984184205532074,
0.276802122592926,
-0.056345585733652115,
0.6023615598678589,
-0.1539609134197235,
-0.7225806713104248,
0.17992916703224182,
0.8211841583251953,
0.8359353542327881,
-0.4828862249851227,
0.12336460500955582,
0.06734013557434082,
0.13664758205413818,
-0.36711791157722473,
0.1153680682182312,
0.03562316298484802,
-1.2551887035369873,
-0.4586338698863983,
-1.0281753540039062,
-0.2845263183116913,
0.18903720378875732,
-0.3020317256450653,
0.30846431851387024,
0.06224584951996803,
0.1841193437576294,
0.06837847828865051,
-0.23415488004684448,
-0.7128077149391174,
0.08312886953353882,
0.27927374839782715,
0.7845443487167358,
-0.8968084454536438,
0.9833942651748657,
0.9238108992576599,
-0.23098719120025635,
-0.6478924751281738,
-0.08643986284732819,
-0.16879387199878693,
-0.9307683110237122,
0.5456207394599915,
-0.2589576244354248,
-0.18252445757389069,
0.42796555161476135,
-0.42109033465385437,
-1.1431820392608643,
0.9088606238365173,
0.40072330832481384,
-0.43932005763053894,
0.07572408020496368,
0.04204699397087097,
0.4684150815010071,
-0.7098770141601562,
-0.061509937047958374,
0.8864742517471313,
0.38037919998168945,
0.20482634007930756,
-0.7033398151397705,
-0.23041950166225433,
-0.3849218785762787,
0.08942343294620514,
0.4242921769618988,
-0.2510107457637787,
0.6463595032691956,
-0.32108089327812195,
-0.4093305766582489,
-0.07050373405218124,
0.6766784191131592,
0.05960889533162117,
-0.3577954173088074,
0.5005156993865967,
0.6725952625274658,
0.7644855380058289,
-0.05525197833776474,
0.807532012462616,
-0.6057202816009521,
0.30510076880455017,
0.8773767352104187,
-0.2706807255744934,
0.6968123316764832,
0.0714821070432663,
-0.16784127056598663,
0.551613986492157,
0.27130216360092163,
-0.14677000045776367,
0.5438987016677856,
0.09881911426782608,
-0.31207719445228577,
-0.25855734944343567,
-0.05461830273270607,
-0.37502068281173706,
0.6266877055168152,
0.3211172819137573,
-0.14902786910533905,
-0.3034513294696808,
0.21268697082996368,
-0.038093630224466324,
0.0019274145597591996,
-0.2094184309244156,
1.088329553604126,
-0.28014901280403137,
-0.7095751166343689,
0.47548121213912964,
-0.06877879798412323,
0.9772704839706421,
-0.7911022901535034,
0.15436530113220215,
-0.1456693857908249,
0.3060392737388611,
-0.10071846097707748,
-0.5496566891670227,
0.04953693598508835,
-0.12229898571968079,
-0.04421555995941162,
0.003862373996526003,
0.9266552925109863,
-0.8272891640663147,
-0.4768792688846588,
0.48424673080444336,
0.7118933200836182,
-0.25354453921318054,
0.31028294563293457,
-0.46900689601898193,
0.16181901097297668,
-0.01055989321321249,
0.09006419777870178,
0.48440179228782654,
0.11535729467868805,
0.325923889875412,
0.6598246693611145,
0.785148024559021,
0.1890343278646469,
0.2583363950252533,
0.14171361923217773,
1.0754352807998657,
-0.34272056818008423,
-0.4106757342815399,
-0.8326833844184875,
0.6349136233329773,
-0.15781977772712708,
-0.37780478596687317,
0.5145015120506287,
0.5091752409934998,
0.8384355306625366,
-0.04294915497303009,
1.013213872909546,
-0.11216910183429718,
0.32946017384529114,
-0.3782038390636444,
0.9662867188453674,
-0.5534521341323853,
-0.052967000752687454,
-0.2004445195198059,
-1.0247008800506592,
-0.27083665132522583,
0.19241060316562653,
-0.2128448188304901,
0.22407788038253784,
0.33653101325035095,
0.6384539008140564,
-0.21736370027065277,
0.18129990994930267,
0.2943589687347412,
0.03153662756085396,
0.24569901823997498,
0.44660475850105286,
0.7224770784378052,
-0.30535075068473816,
0.4197462797164917,
-0.2362029254436493,
-0.3336208164691925,
-0.15457621216773987,
-0.6465953588485718,
-0.705885112285614,
-0.633593738079071,
-0.3295114040374756,
0.026361193507909775,
0.23304547369480133,
0.7583449482917786,
0.9270632266998291,
-0.78058260679245,
-0.22022850811481476,
-0.12994524836540222,
-0.021623099222779274,
-0.29181942343711853,
-0.19535361230373383,
0.07726261764764786,
-0.37171095609664917,
-0.6520368456840515,
0.731286883354187,
0.11434204876422882,
0.14260044693946838,
-0.34422338008880615,
-0.39847466349601746,
-0.12292010337114334,
0.1302228420972824,
0.46787095069885254,
0.4518802762031555,
-0.47736886143684387,
-0.1680060774087906,
-0.08885852992534637,
0.28343090415000916,
-0.18238630890846252,
0.674024224281311,
-0.9307997822761536,
0.8230324983596802,
0.4273081123828888,
0.8991466760635376,
0.2923767566680908,
0.034435201436281204,
1.0555065870285034,
-0.6156758666038513,
-0.2128618061542511,
0.15928585827350616,
0.39870011806488037,
0.49189841747283936,
-0.2865365743637085,
0.24381974339485168,
-0.0010728308698162436,
-0.46612995862960815,
-0.8361908793449402,
0.2644886076450348,
-0.4666140377521515,
-0.27568957209587097,
0.9952192306518555,
0.22000713646411896,
0.06587876379489899,
-0.13634152710437775,
0.365823358297348,
0.27869343757629395,
-0.2856441140174866,
0.7527269721031189,
0.4655788540840149,
-0.17241841554641724,
-0.24632249772548676,
-0.009371954947710037,
0.46162304282188416,
0.15963740646839142,
-0.9233875274658203,
0.2038068324327469,
0.07306645810604095,
0.2461787462234497,
0.349249005317688,
-0.018300736322999,
-0.10046682506799698,
0.17594729363918304,
0.16710035502910614,
0.37980881333351135,
-0.03647357597947121,
-0.1506003886461258,
-0.6431063413619995,
0.00846036896109581,
0.09931506216526031,
0.1458740085363388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12197v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12197v1
|
Debate as Optimization: Adaptive Conformal Prediction and Diverse Retrieval for Event Extraction
| 2024-06-18T01:53:49 | 2024-06-18T01:53:49 |
Sijia Wang, Lifu Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We propose a multi-agent debate as optimization (DAO) system for event
extraction, where the primary objective is to iteratively refine the large
language models (LLMs) outputs through debating without parameter tuning. In
DAO, we introduce two novel modules: the Diverse-RAG (DRAG) module and the
Adaptive Conformal Prediction (AdaCP) module. DRAG systematically retrieves
supporting information that best fits the debate discussion, while AdaCP
enhances the accuracy and reliability of event extraction by effectively
rejecting less promising answers. Experimental results demonstrate a
significant reduction in the performance gap between supervised approaches and
tuning-free LLM-based methods by 18.1% and 17.8% on ACE05 and 17.9% and 15.2%
on CASIE for event detection and argument extraction respectively.
|
[
-0.6662307977676392,
-0.821153998374939,
0.4621621072292328,
0.006262702401727438,
-0.34948331117630005,
0.17226190865039825,
-0.44276389479637146,
-0.5518196821212769,
0.3661043345928192,
0.38828831911087036,
-0.7075029015541077,
-0.13493043184280396,
-0.6002272963523865,
0.10477897524833679,
-0.024679599329829216,
0.974853515625,
0.12343831360340118,
0.07631730288267136,
-0.07796527445316315,
-0.22074203193187714,
-0.23258334398269653,
-0.2503363788127899,
-0.88478684425354,
-0.17783652245998383,
0.4348353445529938,
0.6465072631835938,
0.3427410423755646,
0.684611976146698,
0.28557753562927246,
0.38376930356025696,
-0.42288529872894287,
0.3983927369117737,
-0.4013059735298157,
0.569978654384613,
-0.18648149073123932,
-0.29492175579071045,
-0.4500150978565216,
0.018464289605617523,
0.9108260869979858,
0.28322136402130127,
-0.5360327363014221,
-0.05740250647068024,
-0.1577298939228058,
0.7480055093765259,
-0.8576176762580872,
-0.07826567441225052,
-1.334909200668335,
-0.25096237659454346,
-0.23052532970905304,
0.007264772895723581,
-0.3638366162776947,
-0.231160968542099,
0.254219651222229,
-0.7947238683700562,
0.26902806758880615,
-0.04677002131938934,
0.9521909952163696,
0.28031763434410095,
-0.4123289883136749,
-0.44086021184921265,
-0.7098350524902344,
0.9052456617355347,
-0.6545941829681396,
0.08874937146902084,
-0.034107401967048645,
0.3455877900123596,
-0.30707335472106934,
-0.8934494256973267,
-0.6467774510383606,
-0.030051475390791893,
0.37532728910446167,
0.3127172291278839,
-0.35910436511039734,
0.049640413373708725,
-0.02032289281487465,
0.13712704181671143,
-0.15164218842983246,
0.31648775935173035,
-0.4493440091609955,
-0.056260786950588226,
0.9321387410163879,
0.1970943659543991,
-0.03881381079554558,
-0.1387142837047577,
-0.22871990501880646,
0.05332747474312782,
-0.33616575598716736,
-0.031108805909752846,
0.46552225947380066,
0.2772989571094513,
0.07462405413389206,
0.06939532607793808,
-0.2382352650165558,
0.46892598271369934,
0.29616379737854004,
0.04849712550640106,
0.07950042933225632,
-0.21450620889663696,
0.02717011049389839,
-0.18994975090026855,
0.9652321934700012,
-0.04588942974805832,
-0.04160724952816963,
-0.1622917205095291,
-0.10027490556240082,
-0.1164536252617836,
0.4305935800075531,
-0.7239314317703247,
-0.29895928502082825,
0.19257380068302155,
-0.2659783363342285,
-0.3605809211730957,
0.15007498860359192,
-1.457157015800476,
-0.3470746874809265,
-0.21008366346359253,
0.03153042122721672,
-0.02848515287041664,
-0.36299246549606323,
0.12654034793376923,
-0.43779295682907104,
0.13493964076042175,
0.9326751828193665,
-0.6316511034965515,
0.4116075336933136,
0.7233670353889465,
0.6487342119216919,
-0.846182107925415,
-0.03332969918847084,
-1.0581505298614502,
0.2684357464313507,
-0.21482127904891968,
1.2889182567596436,
-1.0904474258422852,
-0.3804723620414734,
-0.2807685136795044,
-0.14092384278774261,
-0.1258133202791214,
-0.6684481501579285,
0.8583321571350098,
-0.7682586908340454,
0.15546351671218872,
-0.29983994364738464,
-0.651617705821991,
-0.12743370234966278,
0.06942277401685715,
-1.0706120729446411,
0.7818137407302856,
-0.4799959063529968,
-0.4793570637702942,
0.3152809739112854,
-0.8970963954925537,
-0.25886404514312744,
0.029825130477547646,
-0.3726053535938263,
-0.6616820693016052,
-0.033034421503543854,
0.4102686643600464,
0.05011898651719093,
-0.37544775009155273,
0.11831127852201462,
-0.6687428951263428,
0.0007796360296197236,
0.11634666472673416,
-0.18604645133018494,
0.603054404258728,
0.4925568997859955,
-0.3618338406085968,
0.2876100242137909,
-1.0432207584381104,
-0.1841435730457306,
-0.04197525978088379,
-0.6340402960777283,
-0.060922469943761826,
0.5076368451118469,
-0.06628651171922684,
0.008874022401869297,
0.10082997381687164,
-0.8232315182685852,
0.358122855424881,
-0.5272077322006226,
0.2699563205242157,
1.0726110935211182,
0.050070784986019135,
0.5512475371360779,
-0.21320579946041107,
0.8203234076499939,
0.13080821931362152,
-0.15352027118206024,
0.18168748915195465,
-0.6520386338233948,
-0.5384818315505981,
-0.45813286304473877,
0.1404658704996109,
0.3359808623790741,
-0.7252553105354309,
-0.0032704074401408434,
0.0033280120696872473,
-0.3258861005306244,
-0.5151256918907166,
0.1233706995844841,
0.16310808062553406,
0.3064819276332855,
0.14304445683956146,
-0.026156872510910034,
-0.6468612551689148,
-0.48500382900238037,
-0.31485655903816223,
-0.3951447308063507,
0.18620143830776215,
0.37043800950050354,
0.15187272429466248,
-0.03072374127805233,
0.7913318872451782,
-0.6801844239234924,
0.030078819021582603,
-0.3234642446041107,
0.44039666652679443,
-0.03718051686882973,
0.20746386051177979,
0.5603728294372559,
-0.954014778137207,
-0.7149491906166077,
0.47922283411026,
-0.22729738056659698,
-0.23548121750354767,
0.026402581483125687,
-0.11938142776489258,
0.6183895468711853,
0.37186914682388306,
-0.4536072909832001,
0.39797207713127136,
0.253124862909317,
-0.14383038878440857,
0.6531030535697937,
0.17267027497291565,
0.02015434391796589,
-1.0567004680633545,
0.029856551438570023,
-0.15800443291664124,
-0.18691101670265198,
-0.6309270858764648,
0.10506734997034073,
-0.06493985652923584,
0.03217758238315582,
-0.16507725417613983,
0.7322545647621155,
-0.608549177646637,
0.21393407881259918,
-0.6607192754745483,
0.46424904465675354,
0.16783110797405243,
0.3992924988269806,
0.2245984673500061,
0.5636880993843079,
0.49995723366737366,
-0.6761060357093811,
0.4357754588127136,
0.2693537175655365,
0.042896971106529236,
0.37703078985214233,
-0.353662371635437,
0.5860905051231384,
-0.330367773771286,
-0.03740239888429642,
-1.091448426246643,
0.08016997575759888,
0.13777293264865875,
-0.4124618470668793,
0.4036661684513092,
-0.290330708026886,
0.19060257077217102,
-0.21044178307056427,
-0.5265934467315674,
0.2940150499343872,
0.2242165505886078,
-0.3428758680820465,
0.606532096862793,
0.9758310914039612,
-0.4667336642742157,
-0.8778730034828186,
0.11573713272809982,
-0.012686562724411488,
-0.36794179677963257,
-0.30376335978507996,
0.021231884136795998,
-0.19999369978904724,
-0.2942498028278351,
-0.15452569723129272,
-0.2861688733100891,
-0.3783459961414337,
0.1201842725276947,
-0.06198229268193245,
0.1974892020225525,
-0.3516268730163574,
0.264410138130188,
0.05959474295377731,
0.11527319252490997,
-0.123800128698349,
-0.1334368884563446,
0.14296549558639526,
-0.1923668384552002,
-0.14595498144626617,
-0.24057462811470032,
0.6688960790634155,
0.35792770981788635,
-0.2390296906232834,
0.39432719349861145,
0.6655009984970093,
-0.1989200860261917,
-0.35168877243995667,
-0.8247825503349304,
-0.10460755974054337,
-0.5315598845481873,
0.4770328998565674,
-0.45976611971855164,
-1.0347391366958618,
0.7448427677154541,
-0.2502487003803253,
0.4261143207550049,
0.6428961157798767,
0.7241159081459045,
-0.06717512756586075,
0.8087553381919861,
0.5819694995880127,
0.002714740578085184,
0.7040836215019226,
0.1280422806739807,
-0.44077691435813904,
-0.7559985518455505,
-0.08705059438943863,
-0.9940240383148193,
-0.3253993093967438,
-0.4340629279613495,
-0.31088075041770935,
0.33851611614227295,
0.09568821638822556,
0.03329242765903473,
0.07738795876502991,
-0.44434645771980286,
0.393179327249527,
0.2820416986942291,
-0.2339579313993454,
0.4775600731372833,
-0.06864237040281296,
-0.0005217433208599687,
-0.14965294301509857,
-0.579172670841217,
-0.4676538109779358,
1.1097149848937988,
0.0836983248591423,
0.8157654404640198,
0.20065048336982727,
0.6596027612686157,
0.11372983455657959,
0.5080702304840088,
-0.8908287882804871,
0.44291505217552185,
-0.16285985708236694,
-0.7852112650871277,
-0.5399780869483948,
-0.5893998742103577,
-1.2830291986465454,
0.5757930278778076,
-0.12522681057453156,
-0.9962066411972046,
0.5582325458526611,
-0.05079735815525055,
-0.21905089914798737,
0.5220487117767334,
-0.3264142572879791,
0.6180174350738525,
0.33590030670166016,
-0.11410529166460037,
-0.5286642909049988,
-0.4840063750743866,
0.11929409205913544,
-0.2207760065793991,
0.25649482011795044,
-0.2015688568353653,
-0.30222511291503906,
0.9230270981788635,
-0.18898898363113403,
0.4506070017814636,
-0.026615768671035767,
-0.0491778738796711,
0.6199663281440735,
0.027752382680773735,
0.6071270704269409,
0.10005946457386017,
-0.5394644737243652,
-0.14134638011455536,
0.1836353987455368,
-0.12467306107282639,
-0.6036374568939209,
0.47577965259552,
-0.9599283933639526,
-0.9628924131393433,
-0.1318693608045578,
-0.44731780886650085,
-0.08557894825935364,
-0.08476037532091141,
-0.029292600229382515,
0.396450936794281,
-0.3591901957988739,
0.1912219524383545,
0.34338510036468506,
0.12915703654289246,
0.7026262283325195,
0.9526833295822144,
0.13214439153671265,
-0.7223330140113831,
0.7875639796257019,
-0.04077855870127678,
0.19687120616436005,
0.3386305868625641,
0.45462730526924133,
-0.19112592935562134,
-0.7162935137748718,
-0.556669294834137,
0.17828398942947388,
-0.8142973184585571,
-0.4019535779953003,
-0.9049771428108215,
-0.01621990278363228,
-0.37258803844451904,
0.0881321057677269,
-0.6325409412384033,
-0.8349727988243103,
-0.5681495070457458,
-0.04958134889602661,
0.28480586409568787,
0.9271738529205322,
-0.260253369808197,
0.24177958071231842,
-0.8150503635406494,
0.26681649684906006,
0.23061996698379517,
0.11536547541618347,
-0.013320361264050007,
-0.6463971138000488,
-0.20110125839710236,
-0.1317697912454605,
-1.1021735668182373,
-1.139085292816162,
0.3360786736011505,
0.6457719206809998,
0.9237461686134338,
0.6639655828475952,
0.258029967546463,
0.8236359357833862,
-0.574331521987915,
0.603373646736145,
0.08139947056770325,
-0.8697656393051147,
0.798891544342041,
-0.18680769205093384,
-0.14389576017856598,
0.5753650069236755,
0.40783703327178955,
-0.21454666554927826,
-0.6482406854629517,
-0.604110062122345,
-0.6534770727157593,
1.1923773288726807,
0.0841020867228508,
-0.18836553394794464,
-0.02482357621192932,
0.6568445563316345,
0.3503018319606781,
0.2273022085428238,
-0.7090303897857666,
-0.20966875553131104,
0.13702137768268585,
0.0826030969619751,
0.24701961874961853,
-0.21886222064495087,
-0.2921781837940216,
-0.19934216141700745,
0.5824205875396729,
-0.3296507000923157,
0.029067032039165497,
0.2458328902721405,
0.23040223121643066,
-0.6690337061882019,
0.23889325559139252,
0.5943950414657593,
0.780579686164856,
-0.10859338939189911,
-0.08275147527456284,
0.2808323800563812,
-0.5691900253295898,
0.1445966362953186,
0.225784569978714,
0.07921568304300308,
0.12371829152107239,
0.1932448446750641,
0.7391198873519897,
-0.2117677628993988,
-0.6023144721984863,
0.22978492081165314,
-0.19223202764987946,
-0.25092020630836487,
0.07078339904546738,
0.10592439770698547,
0.01185818761587143,
0.48347020149230957,
0.4100392162799835,
-0.10923485457897186,
0.523985743522644,
-0.4190306067466736,
0.5938225388526917,
0.7278589606285095,
-0.47658929228782654,
-0.4598652720451355,
0.8031917214393616,
0.4118557274341583,
-0.2254725992679596,
0.274970680475235,
-0.13490420579910278,
-0.33674904704093933,
0.8473563194274902,
0.39155688881874084,
1.0562827587127686,
-0.4436805248260498,
0.2942611575126648,
0.3645663261413574,
0.1076807901263237,
0.25048011541366577,
0.2891019880771637,
-0.09506712853908539,
-0.9017057418823242,
-0.5148496627807617,
-0.699450671672821,
-0.663756251335144,
0.18434685468673706,
-0.8143832683563232,
0.42205438017845154,
-0.3531883656978607,
-0.18013408780097961,
0.4054170846939087,
0.4402965009212494,
-0.141547292470932,
-0.31859180331230164,
0.41258540749549866,
0.7669215798377991,
-0.5567160248756409,
0.9301557540893555,
1.0888010263442993,
-0.010592831298708916,
-0.5035693049430847,
0.08168933540582657,
0.13003501296043396,
-0.4229264557361603,
0.4275539815425873,
-0.1724175065755844,
-0.17573769390583038,
-0.22279484570026398,
-0.486288458108902,
-0.9032140970230103,
0.7948788404464722,
0.7247430682182312,
-0.4744624197483063,
0.1144372746348381,
-0.25960779190063477,
0.3793920874595642,
-0.4275822937488556,
0.26884955167770386,
0.3252328038215637,
0.46126076579093933,
0.7205777764320374,
-1.0728567838668823,
-0.032364621758461,
-0.19882433116436005,
-0.24009649455547333,
0.13648739457130432,
-0.8794724941253662,
0.869132936000824,
-0.1349707543849945,
-0.4934113025665283,
0.07673430442810059,
0.8051185607910156,
0.2364535927772522,
0.4445917010307312,
0.45455440878868103,
0.2793443202972412,
0.8525288701057434,
0.061256684362888336,
0.774316132068634,
0.11217724531888962,
0.3877299726009369,
0.9932605028152466,
-0.3639110028743744,
0.7951490879058838,
0.4534308612346649,
-0.18349450826644897,
0.5723886489868164,
0.5134941935539246,
0.4552801251411438,
0.43013232946395874,
0.07598868012428284,
-0.302311509847641,
-0.5677735805511475,
0.3322288393974304,
-0.09267015755176544,
0.6216365098953247,
0.4296049475669861,
0.322502464056015,
-0.3262602984905243,
-0.28261876106262207,
0.0037021683529019356,
0.20389461517333984,
-0.2211686670780182,
1.2825417518615723,
0.12141004949808121,
-0.8113915324211121,
0.5826208591461182,
0.1024019792675972,
0.3703630566596985,
-0.5826940536499023,
-0.09406405687332153,
-0.19042004644870758,
0.17121802270412445,
0.1341882348060608,
-0.45166054368019104,
0.4724804759025574,
-0.28690633177757263,
-0.07321254163980484,
0.20725750923156738,
0.7821020483970642,
-0.4779621660709381,
-0.34854739904403687,
0.274178683757782,
0.5664362907409668,
0.16182926297187805,
0.03539601340889931,
-0.9386866092681885,
0.20928141474723816,
-0.005263034719973803,
-0.7056331634521484,
0.2519529163837433,
0.8486850261688232,
-0.030354877933859825,
0.7600598931312561,
0.39458030462265015,
0.30747005343437195,
0.04259422793984413,
-0.09748281538486481,
1.3197766542434692,
-0.5543023347854614,
-0.5819318294525146,
-1.0240005254745483,
0.3205673098564148,
-0.26654696464538574,
-0.16914577782154083,
0.270455002784729,
0.4374019503593445,
0.36417660117149353,
0.13495376706123352,
0.5937014818191528,
0.19030030071735382,
0.4802093207836151,
-0.3385464549064636,
0.45750680565834045,
-0.7962312698364258,
0.1772688329219818,
-0.4555988311767578,
-0.5625729560852051,
-0.0369299054145813,
0.46612003445625305,
-0.029278850182890892,
-0.177617609500885,
0.6665727496147156,
0.5863981246948242,
-0.02498413249850273,
0.36760765314102173,
0.19023236632347107,
0.11693169176578522,
0.5956882238388062,
0.5561935305595398,
0.9790157675743103,
-0.16954724490642548,
0.8250313401222229,
0.2535247206687927,
-0.3378169536590576,
-0.1771111935377121,
-0.826888382434845,
-0.8315803408622742,
-0.7263870239257812,
-0.5995309352874756,
-0.009673058986663818,
0.12893126904964447,
0.7416172623634338,
0.6109301447868347,
-1.1088173389434814,
-0.5525988936424255,
0.1954076588153839,
0.5671547651290894,
-0.25167304277420044,
-0.2486547827720642,
0.26926785707473755,
-0.8251248002052307,
-1.1292405128479004,
0.4121074378490448,
0.36980485916137695,
-0.31045448780059814,
0.20466724038124084,
-0.0439806766808033,
-0.4634788930416107,
0.2866230309009552,
0.38142552971839905,
0.41471654176712036,
-0.7074938416481018,
-0.48440852761268616,
-0.24138283729553223,
0.0928877592086792,
0.3675936460494995,
0.7807243466377258,
-0.5909296274185181,
0.6037253737449646,
0.4651142656803131,
0.8593176007270813,
0.7481051683425903,
0.08736066520214081,
0.8414417505264282,
-0.6624907851219177,
0.28848159313201904,
0.30687493085861206,
0.20981094241142273,
-0.1441294103860855,
-0.36697882413864136,
0.37881600856781006,
0.5070517659187317,
-0.6645314693450928,
-0.8940985798835754,
0.3719214200973511,
-1.1756426095962524,
-0.33844152092933655,
1.3071675300598145,
-0.26726654171943665,
-0.0921550840139389,
-0.40321481227874756,
-0.3330566883087158,
0.23912368714809418,
-0.6849090456962585,
0.9571192264556885,
0.7429460287094116,
-0.26788586378097534,
-0.2504139840602875,
-0.3535900413990021,
0.7882569432258606,
0.30676111578941345,
-0.7920089960098267,
0.18859417736530304,
0.5505911707878113,
0.2293601930141449,
0.19801174104213715,
0.7679001092910767,
-0.16718293726444244,
0.3096414804458618,
-0.14075393974781036,
0.014010712504386902,
0.10476621985435486,
-0.3997873067855835,
-0.3681061565876007,
0.3970722556114197,
-0.03714362159371376,
-0.19501768052577972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12182v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12182v1
|
Aqulia-Med LLM: Pioneering Full-Process Open-Source Medical Language Models
| 2024-06-18T01:30:07 | 2024-06-18T01:30:07 |
Lulu Zhao, Weihao Zeng, Xiaofeng Shi, Hua Zhou, Donglin Hao, Yonghua Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recently, both closed-source LLMs and open-source communities have made
significant strides, outperforming humans in various general domains. However,
their performance in specific professional fields such as medicine, especially
within the open-source community, remains suboptimal due to the complexity of
medical knowledge. We propose Aquila-Med, a bilingual medical LLM based on
Aquila, addressing these challenges through continue pre-training, supervised
fine-tuning (SFT), and reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF). We
construct a large-scale Chinese and English medical dataset for continue
pre-training and a high-quality SFT dataset, covering extensive medical
specialties. Additionally, we develop a high-quality Direct Preference
Optimization (DPO) dataset for further alignment. Aquila-Med achieves notable
results across single-turn, multi-turn dialogues, and medical multiple-choice
questions, demonstrating the effectiveness of our approach. We open-source the
datasets and the entire training process, contributing valuable resources to
the research community. Our models and datasets will released at
https://huggingface.co/BAAI/AquilaMed-RL.
|
[
0.037067312747240067,
-0.5929197072982788,
0.649697482585907,
0.41053852438926697,
-0.33950626850128174,
0.0681944489479065,
-0.5329296588897705,
-0.37886670231819153,
0.385118305683136,
0.557287335395813,
-0.72626131772995,
-0.5203322172164917,
-0.44655361771583557,
0.07875745743513107,
0.06491474062204361,
0.8372360467910767,
-0.36702898144721985,
0.8665834069252014,
0.011294220574200153,
-0.43885743618011475,
-0.10736358165740967,
-0.5687309503555298,
-1.0271189212799072,
-0.40416547656059265,
0.8553887009620667,
0.40788471698760986,
0.8524274230003357,
1.0226906538009644,
0.2088422030210495,
0.1481163054704666,
0.16067029535770416,
0.23260779678821564,
-0.4768935739994049,
0.09155461192131042,
-0.3219195306301117,
-0.46467286348342896,
-0.3573075830936432,
0.015832118690013885,
0.45853713154792786,
0.44801485538482666,
-0.5388219356536865,
0.07323776930570602,
-0.3184778392314911,
0.7048226594924927,
-0.229389026761055,
0.08613529801368713,
-0.42222079634666443,
0.22332823276519775,
-0.114268958568573,
-0.21733012795448303,
-0.10733678936958313,
-0.6633694171905518,
0.19475892186164856,
-0.7352941036224365,
-0.21896953880786896,
0.06647057831287384,
0.8532206416130066,
0.39875149726867676,
-0.30447492003440857,
-0.41709771752357483,
-0.6653614044189453,
0.7842514514923096,
-0.7441943287849426,
0.40312060713768005,
0.19380418956279755,
0.25509870052337646,
-0.23688705265522003,
-0.46749383211135864,
-0.2949162423610687,
-0.3230799734592438,
0.1757829189300537,
0.1814667135477066,
-0.09703115373849869,
0.09259337931871414,
-0.15897463262081146,
0.39781269431114197,
-0.3988499641418457,
0.4853411614894867,
-0.45839807391166687,
-0.029982665553689003,
0.4053238034248352,
0.23847469687461853,
0.534295916557312,
0.5690014362335205,
-0.4349074065685272,
0.21836329996585846,
-0.8465477228164673,
0.1184297427535057,
-0.06608384102582932,
0.05771839618682861,
-0.23604029417037964,
0.5925024151802063,
-0.1403801590204239,
0.3710021376609802,
-0.253368616104126,
-0.152654230594635,
0.3199748694896698,
-0.18424639105796814,
-0.24291548132896423,
-0.06464731693267822,
1.2059599161148071,
-0.012839091010391712,
0.29144757986068726,
-0.3035925030708313,
-0.057308707386255264,
-0.10432726889848709,
0.23030759394168854,
-0.8231390714645386,
-0.30239251255989075,
0.5613401532173157,
-0.4651925563812256,
-0.35154852271080017,
-0.37325695157051086,
-0.3529326617717743,
-0.3986847698688507,
-0.5284619331359863,
0.4084502160549164,
-0.3588927984237671,
-0.22502738237380981,
0.366248220205307,
0.4726451635360718,
-0.02923119068145752,
0.49896037578582764,
-0.6925908327102661,
0.30654338002204895,
0.38465461134910583,
0.7918755412101746,
-0.4912637174129486,
-0.4252600371837616,
-0.3683716356754303,
-0.04321308806538582,
-0.3140043616294861,
0.6336386203765869,
-0.11786434799432755,
-0.3573276102542877,
-0.06913493573665619,
0.17780126631259918,
-0.06979403644800186,
-0.6636708378791809,
0.4628554880619049,
-0.30600786209106445,
0.39455801248550415,
-0.20986923575401306,
-0.22077222168445587,
-0.08639119565486908,
0.3040032386779785,
-0.6008977293968201,
0.43806347250938416,
0.15780311822891235,
-0.721484899520874,
0.07355290651321411,
-0.5982677340507507,
-0.3313882052898407,
-0.05908309295773506,
-0.35832881927490234,
-0.44381627440452576,
-0.12563160061836243,
0.33738332986831665,
-0.013652639463543892,
-0.7342398166656494,
0.506127119064331,
-0.2543010711669922,
-0.20755580067634583,
0.36958369612693787,
-0.2965090572834015,
1.1130337715148926,
0.1467483639717102,
0.0821247547864914,
0.597505509853363,
-0.6028236150741577,
-0.1224040687084198,
0.1306726187467575,
-0.5915311574935913,
-0.0652916356921196,
0.17014625668525696,
-0.10131536424160004,
0.5764973759651184,
0.3766069710254669,
-0.8306117057800293,
0.20624735951423645,
-0.5743751525878906,
0.4861049950122833,
0.557197093963623,
0.017315221950411797,
0.2306559979915619,
-0.5201712250709534,
0.7266294956207275,
0.09570541232824326,
0.6594308018684387,
0.11596155166625977,
-0.5529542565345764,
-0.5959753394126892,
-0.741491973400116,
0.3695226013660431,
1.0016605854034424,
-0.7705180048942566,
0.09550949931144714,
0.03238428011536598,
-0.3049777150154114,
-1.1993426084518433,
0.2745888829231262,
0.39882102608680725,
0.7806394696235657,
0.5119873881340027,
-0.4369606077671051,
-0.38093477487564087,
-0.9489859342575073,
0.072654128074646,
-0.2392226904630661,
-0.1483561098575592,
0.41287049651145935,
0.09403309226036072,
-0.5839154124259949,
0.7679203748703003,
-0.4775694012641907,
-0.5306985974311829,
0.016374602913856506,
-0.12495113164186478,
0.31879499554634094,
0.3507748544216156,
0.42503294348716736,
-0.43723011016845703,
-0.33851855993270874,
0.19401009380817413,
-0.7570012211799622,
-0.23867538571357727,
0.30104145407676697,
-0.47445130348205566,
0.11966522783041,
0.09475664049386978,
-0.46738380193710327,
-0.045113302767276764,
0.6407763957977295,
-0.196980819106102,
0.4858952760696411,
-0.5278932452201843,
0.25916457176208496,
-1.2268786430358887,
0.11928664147853851,
-0.18247362971305847,
0.02315429039299488,
-0.6298270225524902,
0.012684520334005356,
0.11227104812860489,
-0.04310430958867073,
-0.7760894298553467,
0.7254078388214111,
-0.016150102019309998,
0.32075992226600647,
-0.1952558159828186,
-0.28176435828208923,
-0.27812138199806213,
0.49838992953300476,
0.21447795629501343,
0.6211617588996887,
0.6534070372581482,
-0.4172826409339905,
0.6118299961090088,
0.3095439076423645,
-0.045692652463912964,
0.27696284651756287,
-0.6137065291404724,
-0.12089192122220993,
-0.049082137644290924,
0.11301026493310928,
-0.508984386920929,
-0.261883020401001,
0.34841689467430115,
-0.3596170246601105,
0.00686230231076479,
0.007356226909905672,
-0.5345811247825623,
-0.29608553647994995,
-0.3425580561161041,
0.4551752209663391,
0.3691105842590332,
-0.575968325138092,
0.24564188718795776,
0.4716208875179291,
-0.3072420358657837,
-0.470308780670166,
-0.4869186282157898,
-0.13819821178913116,
0.16461029648780823,
-0.4932171404361725,
0.0838281586766243,
-0.18679223954677582,
-0.1288992017507553,
0.15105801820755005,
0.22154608368873596,
-0.4477962553501129,
-0.05881596729159355,
0.09133393317461014,
0.48582378029823303,
-0.34115031361579895,
0.3101683259010315,
0.27048468589782715,
0.044955991208553314,
0.060374125838279724,
-0.3661878705024719,
0.3050559461116791,
0.11502005904912949,
-0.21500812470912933,
-0.39697539806365967,
0.2608882486820221,
0.6113978624343872,
-0.5066148638725281,
0.6744239330291748,
0.35756751894950867,
-0.4052220582962036,
-0.0840645506978035,
-0.4268818497657776,
0.09270008653402328,
-0.3575974404811859,
0.21403484046459198,
0.14496439695358276,
-1.0310852527618408,
0.5389759540557861,
-0.05382080376148224,
0.28851619362831116,
0.2737293541431427,
0.9665258526802063,
-0.17298148572444916,
0.9943543672561646,
0.37805378437042236,
-0.1414399892091751,
0.33686205744743347,
0.10980667173862457,
-0.13579368591308594,
-0.3777720034122467,
-0.4275530278682709,
-0.27608343958854675,
-0.06015312671661377,
-0.4480981230735779,
-0.6040858030319214,
0.6640238165855408,
-0.08836427330970764,
-0.22099286317825317,
-0.18749120831489563,
-0.2890513837337494,
0.26721057295799255,
0.5711085796356201,
0.487339049577713,
0.4999764859676361,
-0.24613851308822632,
-0.32164445519447327,
0.049294326454401016,
-0.5890277624130249,
-0.1062474176287651,
1.156150460243225,
0.5348437428474426,
0.8295574188232422,
-0.03959030285477638,
0.7235461473464966,
-0.05692341923713684,
0.5521404147148132,
-1.0019031763076782,
0.211073100566864,
-0.40914660692214966,
-0.4397338926792145,
-0.39288097620010376,
-0.632062554359436,
-1.075455665588379,
0.2586642801761627,
-0.416251003742218,
-0.21529275178909302,
-0.14947600662708282,
0.21839506924152374,
-0.3982292115688324,
0.3185325264930725,
-0.41726452112197876,
0.8044331669807434,
-0.5087950229644775,
-0.3733903467655182,
-0.19570983946323395,
-0.5623728036880493,
0.6461963057518005,
-0.34429168701171875,
0.4116162657737732,
-0.30972301959991455,
-0.2981013059616089,
0.34421631693840027,
-0.41749152541160583,
0.6004956364631653,
-0.10513265430927277,
-0.2757425308227539,
0.08278084546327591,
-0.027260301634669304,
0.02666991949081421,
0.27783650159835815,
0.057843614369630814,
0.2678372859954834,
0.06985365599393845,
-0.4891091287136078,
-0.35097476840019226,
0.7633731961250305,
-0.9655454158782959,
-0.4149605631828308,
-0.28803008794784546,
-0.48353153467178345,
-0.5248180627822876,
0.23779955506324768,
0.21154434978961945,
0.27236130833625793,
-0.3637300133705139,
-0.09852741658687592,
0.8577969670295715,
-0.6519883871078491,
-0.13189375400543213,
1.0370360612869263,
-0.3597799241542816,
-0.7157060503959656,
0.8224382996559143,
-0.03451704606413841,
-0.11260056495666504,
0.3207451403141022,
0.3971424996852875,
-0.22509640455245972,
-0.5411192178726196,
-0.8698383569717407,
0.49455785751342773,
-0.19302970170974731,
-0.10504566133022308,
-0.6033620238304138,
-0.4077455699443817,
-0.260678231716156,
-0.012622245587408543,
-0.3957170248031616,
-0.30873581767082214,
-0.3677491247653961,
0.17226403951644897,
0.22368139028549194,
0.7872951626777649,
0.13921020925045013,
-0.025490833446383476,
-0.9666968584060669,
0.5429038405418396,
0.2864953577518463,
0.6573218703269958,
-0.1035602018237114,
-0.2064390331506729,
-0.46968868374824524,
0.06444846093654633,
-0.19764654338359833,
-0.9189370274543762,
0.5522924661636353,
-0.04340735450387001,
0.6892825961112976,
0.2775755226612091,
-0.19325216114521027,
0.1916527897119522,
-0.6903892159461975,
0.5653218626976013,
0.3075326085090637,
-0.42624592781066895,
0.7556354999542236,
-0.46813201904296875,
0.4634292423725128,
0.6594706773757935,
0.6280530095100403,
-0.39567485451698303,
-0.5920757055282593,
-0.07052796334028244,
-0.6191967129707336,
0.7898532152175903,
-0.0315776988863945,
-0.17834292352199554,
-0.01651427149772644,
0.2360682189464569,
0.16143669188022614,
0.2788378596305847,
-0.5343669056892395,
-0.11989100277423859,
-0.0037798606790602207,
-0.42569151520729065,
-0.04045364633202553,
0.01941768079996109,
-0.444778174161911,
-0.4887155592441559,
0.8303006887435913,
-0.02637452818453312,
-0.04618057236075401,
0.20917537808418274,
0.06241597607731819,
-0.25882312655448914,
0.34808677434921265,
0.608009397983551,
0.5289592146873474,
-0.06176292896270752,
-0.32034027576446533,
0.060366496443748474,
-0.5623401403427124,
0.29008519649505615,
0.16299152374267578,
-0.15553142130374908,
-0.0935322716832161,
0.08137920498847961,
0.6238999962806702,
0.2343798577785492,
-1.0887947082519531,
0.5198040008544922,
-0.19253937900066376,
-0.34095999598503113,
-0.13796918094158173,
-0.09886465221643448,
0.008373643271625042,
0.28060445189476013,
0.07821683585643768,
-0.1764068305492401,
0.16084039211273193,
-0.48112961649894714,
0.15624898672103882,
0.1749822050333023,
-0.5248559713363647,
-0.34247463941574097,
0.7576905488967896,
0.22730009257793427,
-0.0614967904984951,
0.42200109362602234,
0.10293067991733551,
-0.2893301248550415,
0.4388633370399475,
0.406686007976532,
0.7905511856079102,
-0.47192540764808655,
0.20628312230110168,
0.42515361309051514,
0.13818567991256714,
-0.5123232007026672,
0.5393592119216919,
0.10153917968273163,
-0.6100119352340698,
-0.3997468948364258,
-0.6612698435783386,
-0.8383780121803284,
0.09284636378288269,
-0.6398565769195557,
0.3724733293056488,
-0.5685270428657532,
-0.1101297065615654,
-0.3808170258998871,
-0.03543027117848396,
-0.39252278208732605,
0.2975064516067505,
-0.0936070904135704,
0.8210418820381165,
-0.6317700147628784,
1.2569420337677002,
0.878178060054779,
-0.45362555980682373,
-0.6502546668052673,
-0.16344329714775085,
0.029279349371790886,
-0.9260901212692261,
0.17248299717903137,
-0.2784595489501953,
-0.06202644854784012,
-0.2063845545053482,
-0.41231560707092285,
-0.6942612528800964,
1.117501974105835,
0.7295303344726562,
-0.40349704027175903,
-0.3949388265609741,
-0.09154629707336426,
0.8443856835365295,
-0.4191007912158966,
-0.06284233927726746,
0.4838699400424957,
0.0009604471852071583,
0.14460855722427368,
-1.3135870695114136,
-0.05162598192691803,
-0.16805307567119598,
-0.2536798417568207,
0.08869510143995285,
-0.9146527647972107,
0.794110119342804,
-0.3789691925048828,
-0.0368661992251873,
0.11835234612226486,
0.2766256034374237,
0.4150615334510803,
0.17483079433441162,
0.23064422607421875,
0.5328012704849243,
0.6789836287498474,
0.03913935273885727,
0.7246862053871155,
-0.5972872376441956,
0.04697132855653763,
1.016271948814392,
-0.15967102348804474,
0.9976102709770203,
0.4112260639667511,
-0.1274522840976715,
0.39370590448379517,
0.5421749353408813,
0.14810477197170258,
0.4314948618412018,
0.2609321177005768,
-0.5068672895431519,
-0.11544939875602722,
-0.30764132738113403,
-0.3967989385128021,
0.3228895664215088,
0.4465982913970947,
-0.5449933409690857,
-0.0030610202811658382,
0.07536113262176514,
0.06249068304896355,
0.1142311692237854,
-0.3844490647315979,
0.8642058372497559,
0.17639043927192688,
-0.756271481513977,
0.4793310761451721,
0.06887052953243256,
0.7161363959312439,
-0.8283135294914246,
0.16866521537303925,
-0.30464962124824524,
-0.0797291100025177,
-0.17415368556976318,
-0.48841947317123413,
0.06810587644577026,
-0.03703288361430168,
-0.17441518604755402,
-0.22591321170330048,
0.4452560544013977,
-0.8692440390586853,
-0.41413232684135437,
0.44432827830314636,
0.6152381896972656,
-0.031378671526908875,
0.27467283606529236,
-0.6054290533065796,
-0.15198318660259247,
-0.11628765612840652,
-0.027062643319368362,
0.46269187331199646,
0.4125877320766449,
-0.07491501420736313,
0.7215450406074524,
0.6532952189445496,
0.6396605968475342,
0.04159070551395416,
0.14070534706115723,
1.0333844423294067,
-0.45671069622039795,
-0.45488545298576355,
-0.609573245048523,
-0.040746722370386124,
0.3054805397987366,
-0.34563136100769043,
0.28211134672164917,
0.7282822728157043,
0.636599600315094,
-0.1511026918888092,
0.6538459062576294,
0.5545387268066406,
0.7767931222915649,
-0.5636547803878784,
0.9601247310638428,
-0.5622507333755493,
0.029735013842582703,
0.39892280101776123,
-0.5228102803230286,
-0.2911777198314667,
0.24420355260372162,
0.1352114975452423,
-0.30929264426231384,
0.4486048221588135,
0.6648374199867249,
0.10836813598871231,
-0.20003169775009155,
0.35719582438468933,
0.38983413577079773,
0.15218284726142883,
0.9695103168487549,
0.7001653909683228,
0.03402841091156006,
0.45841431617736816,
-0.1068248450756073,
-0.5034919381141663,
0.005881705787032843,
-0.4759649634361267,
-0.8204329609870911,
-0.14721152186393738,
-0.17765748500823975,
-0.31665265560150146,
0.10528217256069183,
1.4196046590805054,
0.4811538755893707,
-0.9141976833343506,
-0.414623498916626,
0.2797563672065735,
-0.07710223644971848,
-0.027980580925941467,
-0.09868985414505005,
0.18934090435504913,
-0.4550330638885498,
-0.5729390382766724,
0.6282450556755066,
0.4651128649711609,
0.06854251027107239,
-0.5419185161590576,
-0.2547853887081146,
-0.11416533589363098,
0.26978516578674316,
0.4353695511817932,
0.7135668992996216,
-0.7625491619110107,
0.2826318144798279,
0.11988330632448196,
-0.4846898317337036,
0.12678679823875427,
0.8749133944511414,
-0.6872863173484802,
0.6756189465522766,
0.28874343633651733,
0.634858250617981,
0.3153297007083893,
-0.17420394718647003,
0.8896118998527527,
-0.3088492453098297,
0.047249067574739456,
0.4281257092952728,
0.28767478466033936,
-0.014198518358170986,
-0.20113977789878845,
0.4732593297958374,
0.07099789381027222,
-0.4217376708984375,
-0.595787525177002,
0.09190891683101654,
-0.8570573329925537,
-0.26149722933769226,
1.1821115016937256,
-0.31294798851013184,
-0.11597096174955368,
-0.20051434636116028,
-0.601921796798706,
0.4812873601913452,
-0.3949364125728607,
0.8562031984329224,
0.5803982019424438,
-0.32946521043777466,
-0.0005463644047267735,
-0.6172803044319153,
0.6745529770851135,
0.3390873372554779,
-0.9096633791923523,
-0.27802157402038574,
0.4179762303829193,
0.4431481659412384,
-0.31479641795158386,
1.3354177474975586,
-0.44123274087905884,
0.42997288703918457,
-0.610526978969574,
0.19332191348075867,
-0.17430280148983002,
-0.26914432644844055,
-0.5298051238059998,
0.09268935769796371,
0.3424046039581299,
-0.24548645317554474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12168v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12168v2
|
BPO: Supercharging Online Preference Learning by Adhering to the Proximity of Behavior LLM
| 2024-06-18T00:41:40 | 2024-06-19T05:25:27 |
Wenda Xu, Jiachen Li, William Yang Wang, Lei Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Direct alignment from preferences (DAP) has emerged as a promising paradigm
for aligning large language models (LLMs) to human desiderata from
pre-collected, offline preference datasets. While recent studies indicate that
existing offline DAP methods can directly benefit from online training samples,
we highlight the need to develop specific online DAP algorithms to fully
harness the power of online training. Specifically, we identify that the
learned LLM should adhere to the proximity of the behavior LLM, which collects
the training samples. To this end, we propose online Preference Optimization in
proximity to the Behavior LLM (BPO), emphasizing the importance of constructing
a proper trust region for LLM alignment.
We conduct extensive experiments to validate the effectiveness and
applicability of our approach by integrating it with various DAP methods,
resulting in significant performance improvements across a wide range of tasks
when training with the same amount of preference data. Even when only
introducing one additional data collection phase, our online BPO improves its
offline DAP baseline from 72.0% to 80.2% on TL;DR and from 82.2% to 89.1% on
Anthropic Helpfulness in terms of win rate against human reference text.
|
[
-0.5664545893669128,
-0.43289923667907715,
0.6268060207366943,
-0.09288231283426285,
-0.08964847773313522,
0.033281028270721436,
-0.214029923081398,
-0.6143445372581482,
0.3798556923866272,
0.24575203657150269,
-0.6717774868011475,
-0.08714108169078827,
-0.49604323506355286,
-0.03884023427963257,
0.33335524797439575,
0.9559007883071899,
0.14423872530460358,
0.09134607017040253,
-0.3825281262397766,
0.06922171264886856,
-0.33782875537872314,
-0.8538994193077087,
-0.7356745004653931,
-0.4074455499649048,
0.24804309010505676,
0.41329219937324524,
0.5072343945503235,
0.9178882241249084,
0.46280598640441895,
0.2949788272380829,
-0.04163411259651184,
0.5085053443908691,
-0.6579550504684448,
0.09194140881299973,
-0.11381885409355164,
-0.42943328619003296,
-0.732258677482605,
-0.004225917160511017,
0.3379141390323639,
0.48586592078208923,
-0.3484637141227722,
0.05100124329328537,
0.07850618660449982,
1.0927472114562988,
-0.598017692565918,
0.06913396716117859,
-0.6878862380981445,
0.14584006369113922,
0.0960857942700386,
-0.1942155808210373,
-0.12043453007936478,
-0.7400940656661987,
0.6296907067298889,
-0.7342662215232849,
0.03112366981804371,
0.1387576311826706,
1.0653650760650635,
0.4107302129268646,
-0.2816322147846222,
-0.08069711178541183,
-0.581377387046814,
0.8702571988105774,
-0.4814486503601074,
0.418803334236145,
0.640069305896759,
0.06873506307601929,
-0.24446064233779907,
-0.17488640546798706,
-0.6341518759727478,
0.02017306350171566,
0.29466474056243896,
0.013533439487218857,
0.08424315601587296,
0.21128830313682556,
0.0056577702052891254,
0.24972626566886902,
-0.13821496069431305,
0.17843230068683624,
0.14927947521209717,
0.03257296606898308,
0.6263284683227539,
-0.13368432223796844,
-0.037707410752773285,
0.21353033185005188,
-0.3814217448234558,
-0.06443476676940918,
-0.4637724459171295,
0.28540313243865967,
0.5406850576400757,
0.3286522626876831,
-0.11595717817544937,
0.3088708221912384,
-0.008826490491628647,
0.7473664879798889,
0.8339381814002991,
-0.2927466332912445,
0.3027104437351227,
-0.30823826789855957,
0.056103263050317764,
0.2146805077791214,
0.48327669501304626,
0.7419437170028687,
0.3052957057952881,
-0.2648318111896515,
0.047558240592479706,
-0.10706040263175964,
0.5368682146072388,
-0.5570802092552185,
0.1472901552915573,
0.5128403902053833,
-0.2832017242908478,
-0.291426420211792,
0.06348195672035217,
-0.7191129326820374,
-0.4932880699634552,
-0.7511771321296692,
0.1928885281085968,
-0.17068873345851898,
-0.2271183282136917,
0.046512801200151443,
-0.04795755073428154,
0.31043741106987,
0.16115188598632812,
-1.4542572498321533,
0.3055347800254822,
0.8598601222038269,
0.9758130311965942,
-0.4467134177684784,
-0.09369061887264252,
-0.6701693534851074,
0.39437350630760193,
-0.2816063463687897,
0.7707889080047607,
-0.6380751132965088,
-0.2620435953140259,
0.21555431187152863,
-0.35575544834136963,
0.09330666810274124,
-0.6497927904129028,
0.603796660900116,
-0.6409469246864319,
0.12239712476730347,
-0.4141540825366974,
-0.8641007542610168,
0.0033370228484272957,
0.2897387146949768,
-0.44609710574150085,
1.0588369369506836,
-0.0897357240319252,
-0.6403842568397522,
0.5596944689750671,
-0.7439523935317993,
-0.13152524828910828,
-0.4942672550678253,
-0.1270432323217392,
-0.5256040096282959,
0.13420738279819489,
0.24300692975521088,
0.5239990949630737,
0.1757844239473343,
0.09951695054769516,
-0.6508602499961853,
-0.2361825555562973,
0.19352403283119202,
0.34824466705322266,
0.6039324402809143,
0.007267779670655727,
-0.5939629077911377,
0.25003668665885925,
-0.6037968993186951,
-0.01759876124560833,
0.05299102142453194,
-0.21921740472316742,
-0.5645157098770142,
0.09591653943061829,
-0.34308600425720215,
0.356193482875824,
0.4810181260108948,
-0.6845731139183044,
0.5060939192771912,
-0.7254668474197388,
0.24014532566070557,
1.3570435047149658,
-0.27218306064605713,
0.6869640350341797,
-0.4880596101284027,
0.386936753988266,
-0.33711349964141846,
0.30066657066345215,
0.5279932618141174,
-0.36933544278144836,
-0.532224178314209,
-0.3964150846004486,
0.02467561699450016,
0.3253239095211029,
-0.29022300243377686,
1.0113906860351562,
-0.45412155985832214,
-0.28728097677230835,
-0.5471845865249634,
0.12306590378284454,
0.42011964321136475,
0.6926949620246887,
0.33368486166000366,
-0.43954741954803467,
-0.4712698757648468,
-0.8190094232559204,
-0.02850300818681717,
-0.016831498593091965,
-0.02514888532459736,
0.5424657464027405,
-0.14360490441322327,
-0.23344168066978455,
1.3458565473556519,
-0.6762428879737854,
-0.6094846129417419,
-0.181043341755867,
-0.24120475351810455,
0.08278880268335342,
0.12094021588563919,
0.5793522000312805,
-0.8073708415031433,
-0.7271600365638733,
-0.11186166852712631,
-0.36568179726600647,
-0.2090226262807846,
0.25885096192359924,
-0.3028688132762909,
0.6188769340515137,
0.04462695121765137,
-0.26750287413597107,
-0.11628242582082748,
0.7875152230262756,
-0.058340661227703094,
0.13515707850456238,
-0.4196239113807678,
0.20398101210594177,
-1.144976019859314,
-0.031048903241753578,
0.018176550045609474,
-0.22600217163562775,
-0.7097837924957275,
0.0041889892891049385,
-0.19495698809623718,
0.0949966311454773,
-0.38969653844833374,
0.5185584425926208,
-0.4096289575099945,
-0.24590398371219635,
-0.4300081431865692,
0.3459627628326416,
-0.1284731924533844,
0.5599187016487122,
0.5992010831832886,
0.5925747156143188,
0.4425290524959564,
-0.8726826310157776,
0.31267011165618896,
0.47816145420074463,
0.030206507071852684,
0.5875343680381775,
-0.2946518361568451,
0.6576940417289734,
-0.06692031770944595,
0.2615002393722534,
-0.8641623854637146,
-0.12180516123771667,
0.11558354645967484,
-0.2826772630214691,
0.4052709937095642,
-0.20227022469043732,
-0.15214070677757263,
0.14231708645820618,
-0.6436612606048584,
0.2511001229286194,
0.4412761926651001,
-0.8082178831100464,
0.4790571928024292,
0.8870473504066467,
-0.06668902933597565,
-0.7031242251396179,
-0.2878109812736511,
-0.3979015648365021,
-0.3927466571331024,
-0.44855543971061707,
0.41894596815109253,
-0.09819740802049637,
-0.2302698791027069,
-0.5690489411354065,
-0.2364283949136734,
-0.08047910034656525,
0.05981773883104324,
0.35745182633399963,
0.42220500111579895,
0.35188737511634827,
0.02710201032459736,
-0.24509721994400024,
-0.28211989998817444,
-0.057179372757673264,
-0.4063659906387329,
0.7334288954734802,
-0.03385310620069504,
-0.11217916756868362,
-0.517416775226593,
0.2524705231189728,
0.1271577924489975,
0.03508845344185829,
0.7557210326194763,
0.23687401413917542,
-0.1580270677804947,
-0.10697266459465027,
-0.5975245833396912,
-0.32726290822029114,
-0.5483715534210205,
0.15578904747962952,
-0.3218362033367157,
-0.6379864811897278,
0.10228602588176727,
0.04207310080528259,
0.14652682840824127,
-0.16669251024723053,
0.4193154573440552,
-0.2756040394306183,
0.9312303066253662,
0.893911600112915,
-0.3855750560760498,
0.8459959030151367,
-0.03940075635910034,
0.13934290409088135,
-0.685421347618103,
-0.20656462013721466,
-0.4377436339855194,
-0.32696449756622314,
-0.6207460761070251,
-0.31747353076934814,
0.36524707078933716,
-0.11300826817750931,
-0.1841658055782318,
0.2966698706150055,
-0.47460559010505676,
0.4046293795108795,
0.7030997276306152,
0.4242398738861084,
0.27430999279022217,
0.3637683093547821,
-0.04693938046693802,
-0.4527110755443573,
-0.4805290102958679,
-0.4642711877822876,
1.3848929405212402,
0.3129562735557556,
0.3070111572742462,
0.21348333358764648,
0.8575180768966675,
0.24835093319416046,
0.04285566136240959,
-0.9883547425270081,
0.4458920657634735,
0.005303983110934496,
-0.5115534067153931,
-0.2705093324184418,
-0.2849024534225464,
-0.9688636064529419,
-0.07648584246635437,
-0.21087293326854706,
-0.7414093017578125,
0.07716894894838333,
0.6694678068161011,
-0.4843176305294037,
0.24309350550174713,
-0.6960887908935547,
0.6943439841270447,
-0.3854384422302246,
-0.5762197375297546,
-0.4457318186759949,
-0.7793745398521423,
-0.015161185525357723,
-0.15493300557136536,
0.23960715532302856,
-0.07092880457639694,
-0.2990659177303314,
0.5358113646507263,
-0.27638891339302063,
0.625720739364624,
-0.18042729794979095,
-0.29501524567604065,
-0.10703501105308533,
-0.07098473608493805,
0.6874721050262451,
-0.3982878029346466,
-0.19080469012260437,
0.44300565123558044,
-0.09090766310691833,
-0.43537479639053345,
-0.5237881541252136,
0.7093031406402588,
-1.0014599561691284,
-0.5546371936798096,
-0.675510823726654,
-0.378661185503006,
-0.6998974084854126,
-0.14380796253681183,
-0.017169812694191933,
0.18337184190750122,
0.07721630483865738,
-0.04949917644262314,
0.7967869639396667,
-0.015863962471485138,
0.3551715016365051,
0.54893958568573,
-0.13916881382465363,
-0.4262508153915405,
1.0586360692977905,
-0.06248578429222107,
0.5274620056152344,
0.7198834419250488,
0.4942849278450012,
-0.8053314089775085,
-0.5102736949920654,
-0.2370193600654602,
0.2288724035024643,
-0.4015856683254242,
0.21213917434215546,
-0.47791731357574463,
0.3951660096645355,
-0.5188208818435669,
-0.4537949562072754,
-0.45156797766685486,
-0.21625345945358276,
-0.235987588763237,
-0.06075974553823471,
0.2619994580745697,
0.459681898355484,
-0.22700119018554688,
0.18356958031654358,
-0.8212605714797974,
0.46091240644454956,
0.37348875403404236,
0.4414712190628052,
-0.1806853711605072,
-0.7730410099029541,
-0.20316727459430695,
0.08406691253185272,
-0.4366275668144226,
-0.663497805595398,
0.30743101239204407,
0.26615530252456665,
0.6026630401611328,
0.8708437085151672,
0.23559454083442688,
0.9318040013313293,
-0.46721509099006653,
0.5003395676612854,
0.12062832713127136,
-0.8851122260093689,
0.6011268496513367,
-0.3932054042816162,
-0.1723284274339676,
0.7428057789802551,
1.0752817392349243,
-0.36449143290519714,
-0.031827911734580994,
-0.5766158699989319,
-0.7675793766975403,
0.835888147354126,
-0.005663630086928606,
0.05540333688259125,
0.15348127484321594,
0.5141465663909912,
0.2005062848329544,
0.4359876811504364,
-0.6394276022911072,
-0.541484534740448,
-0.11302721500396729,
-0.15312835574150085,
-0.02993399277329445,
-0.10609102994203568,
-0.22888895869255066,
-0.06638092547655106,
0.8675675392150879,
-0.3159000277519226,
0.1916213184595108,
0.0914592295885086,
0.26827871799468994,
-0.14593346416950226,
0.07502910494804382,
0.37142273783683777,
0.7862336039543152,
-0.5831841230392456,
-0.1378430873155594,
-0.025741837918758392,
-0.4222778081893921,
0.2923597991466522,
-0.044491395354270935,
-0.24364766478538513,
-0.48206982016563416,
-0.07671350240707397,
0.430144339799881,
-0.1280110627412796,
-0.6676675081253052,
0.4761385917663574,
-0.009636041708290577,
0.12114670872688293,
-0.2566477358341217,
0.11794854700565338,
-0.07383236289024353,
0.0743633359670639,
0.2111702561378479,
-0.10229401290416718,
0.1629582941532135,
-0.636983335018158,
0.15897856652736664,
0.7398286461830139,
-0.4987412691116333,
-0.17277833819389343,
0.4517078399658203,
0.5758224725723267,
-0.24378842115402222,
0.2735242247581482,
-0.16019810736179352,
-0.47346970438957214,
0.4065282940864563,
0.44080138206481934,
0.8280549645423889,
-0.19118492305278778,
0.07968098670244217,
0.4031048119068146,
-0.14582368731498718,
-0.1172814592719078,
0.0499982088804245,
-0.24357596039772034,
-1.0036214590072632,
-0.2450087070465088,
-0.6807647347450256,
-0.7357816100120544,
0.0683784931898117,
-0.7369404435157776,
0.41129621863365173,
-0.6124600172042847,
-0.2683699131011963,
-0.2992638647556305,
0.16332513093948364,
-0.18866972625255585,
0.10372116416692734,
0.2693018615245819,
0.34101685881614685,
-0.6234434247016907,
0.8481839299201965,
0.7648143172264099,
-0.2163230925798416,
-0.6087723970413208,
0.3353727161884308,
0.20234841108322144,
-0.9892465472221375,
0.5892348885536194,
0.21200349926948547,
-0.3771129250526428,
0.2267162799835205,
-0.2852417230606079,
-0.8887606859207153,
0.7979562282562256,
0.532878577709198,
-0.8206915855407715,
-0.09434088319540024,
-0.01017652079463005,
0.4502387046813965,
-0.3524457812309265,
0.34252145886421204,
0.554319441318512,
0.3000757396221161,
-0.05968921631574631,
-1.1389210224151611,
-0.014550946652889252,
0.27136725187301636,
-0.12729117274284363,
0.29795780777931213,
-0.9446690678596497,
0.07889657467603683,
-0.3003518879413605,
-0.009346498176455498,
-0.28601810336112976,
0.534916877746582,
0.42068544030189514,
0.04082052409648895,
0.632229745388031,
0.5695681571960449,
0.6585444211959839,
-0.011071881279349327,
0.9565001130104065,
-0.30104827880859375,
0.19697967171669006,
1.2118146419525146,
-0.500385582447052,
0.9442043900489807,
0.7988630533218384,
-0.3928106725215912,
0.28771141171455383,
0.9635196924209595,
0.19615140557289124,
0.6723939180374146,
0.10355696082115173,
-0.2388738989830017,
-0.28819361329078674,
-0.5334697365760803,
-0.46807125210762024,
0.3242008090019226,
-0.12127586454153061,
-0.020567232742905617,
0.23037366569042206,
-0.32424965500831604,
-0.03312217444181442,
0.35576918721199036,
-0.36851269006729126,
1.046350359916687,
-0.14546678960323334,
-0.7984916567802429,
0.4866315722465515,
-0.18224869668483734,
0.823411226272583,
-0.9046491384506226,
0.09525416046380997,
-0.2706156373023987,
0.4390621483325958,
-0.27275601029396057,
-0.42882925271987915,
0.2684688866138458,
-0.22163839638233185,
-0.19724132120609283,
-0.494415283203125,
0.2778688967227936,
-0.30858591198921204,
0.00017898535588756204,
0.5871242880821228,
0.20836596190929413,
0.12711644172668457,
-0.2047063410282135,
-0.5712746381759644,
-0.14828994870185852,
0.009665600955486298,
-0.11194945126771927,
0.8154252767562866,
0.10711198300123215,
0.2774803936481476,
0.7670064568519592,
0.751406729221344,
0.30222082138061523,
-0.04437287896871567,
-0.058433763682842255,
0.7184605598449707,
-0.36288124322891235,
-0.7886735796928406,
-0.8739916682243347,
0.09731531143188477,
-0.18180939555168152,
-0.27252548933029175,
0.8330860137939453,
0.6959073543548584,
1.1491212844848633,
-0.09163522720336914,
0.6750681400299072,
-0.0042138900607824326,
0.6035618782043457,
-0.5060543417930603,
0.3670506179332733,
-0.5634565353393555,
-0.004097164608538151,
-0.34360355138778687,
-1.0676647424697876,
0.11814931780099869,
0.6654612421989441,
-0.4241308271884918,
-0.06578712910413742,
0.6026768684387207,
0.6989977359771729,
0.018528858199715614,
-0.19983214139938354,
0.24134884774684906,
-0.19946818053722382,
0.11188548058271408,
0.5402191877365112,
0.45346754789352417,
-0.04411807656288147,
0.5611364841461182,
-0.4815475642681122,
-0.47731107473373413,
-0.23079046607017517,
-1.2091768980026245,
-0.9189037680625916,
-0.5118159651756287,
-0.31060218811035156,
-0.40204766392707825,
0.010356208309531212,
1.6931854486465454,
0.9012726545333862,
-0.8626498579978943,
-0.38459640741348267,
-0.12813536822795868,
-0.022681863978505135,
-0.4178580939769745,
-0.1971708983182907,
0.34639066457748413,
-0.3933955430984497,
-1.125443935394287,
0.27918541431427,
0.19001121819019318,
0.1606397181749344,
-0.1425032615661621,
-0.36732521653175354,
-0.3559315800666809,
0.009335340932011604,
0.4740464687347412,
0.2739165425300598,
-0.6696497201919556,
-0.33110472559928894,
0.07970936596393585,
-0.06260297447443008,
0.39246422052383423,
0.8171660900115967,
-0.4427734911441803,
0.6907220482826233,
0.4924403429031372,
0.9827049970626831,
0.40604671835899353,
0.49935317039489746,
0.8730853199958801,
-0.709842324256897,
0.04508565738797188,
0.11135450750589371,
0.15527944266796112,
0.25825947523117065,
-0.48900097608566284,
0.3483346402645111,
0.3274754285812378,
-0.7028481364250183,
-0.5150363445281982,
0.32472917437553406,
-1.1131559610366821,
-0.06894825398921967,
1.2980377674102783,
-0.2592932879924774,
-0.049856510013341904,
-0.4394795894622803,
-0.39818817377090454,
0.28432151675224304,
-0.8595468997955322,
1.4710768461227417,
0.7277027368545532,
-0.6434758901596069,
0.19385819137096405,
-0.23475278913974762,
0.9196716547012329,
0.5239372849464417,
-0.986412525177002,
0.05689093470573425,
0.544008195400238,
0.14370618760585785,
0.19165687263011932,
0.7284966707229614,
0.28808656334877014,
-0.009610658511519432,
-0.4130714237689972,
0.20602422952651978,
-0.12917962670326233,
-0.18258190155029297,
-0.5654768943786621,
0.18420515954494476,
0.11646844446659088,
-0.44808539748191833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12165v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12165v1
|
Statistical Uncertainty in Word Embeddings: GloVe-V
| 2024-06-18T00:35:02 | 2024-06-18T00:35:02 |
Andrea Vallebueno, Cassandra Handan-Nader, Christopher D. Manning, Daniel E. Ho
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Static word embeddings are ubiquitous in computational social science
applications and contribute to practical decision-making in a variety of fields
including law and healthcare. However, assessing the statistical uncertainty in
downstream conclusions drawn from word embedding statistics has remained
challenging. When using only point estimates for embeddings, researchers have
no streamlined way of assessing the degree to which their model selection
criteria or scientific conclusions are subject to noise due to sparsity in the
underlying data used to generate the embeddings. We introduce a method to
obtain approximate, easy-to-use, and scalable reconstruction error variance
estimates for GloVe (Pennington et al., 2014), one of the most widely used word
embedding models, using an analytical approximation to a multivariate normal
model. To demonstrate the value of embeddings with variance (GloVe-V), we
illustrate how our approach enables principled hypothesis testing in core word
embedding tasks, such as comparing the similarity between different word pairs
in vector space, assessing the performance of different models, and analyzing
the relative degree of ethnic or gender bias in a corpus using different word
lists.
|
[
-0.1589561104774475,
-0.9659942388534546,
0.5931870341300964,
0.12659750878810883,
-0.2014661282300949,
0.1359589844942093,
-0.05752983316779137,
-0.12510913610458374,
0.285390168428421,
0.18665488064289093,
-0.3426090478897095,
-0.7591895461082458,
-0.9839765429496765,
-0.1567988395690918,
-0.32728680968284607,
0.3452005982398987,
-0.16405822336673737,
0.27579265832901,
-0.3537824749946594,
-0.2847810387611389,
-0.2872355878353119,
-0.19737742841243744,
0.10223132371902466,
0.22211025655269623,
0.010926485061645508,
0.3766573667526245,
0.9375065565109253,
0.4869999289512634,
0.389205664396286,
0.18517757952213287,
0.23666691780090332,
0.23404590785503387,
-0.26282164454460144,
0.20281842350959778,
0.10518436878919601,
-0.5426256060600281,
-0.4222763180732727,
0.13072621822357178,
0.24825476109981537,
1.0121533870697021,
-0.061397209763526917,
0.3170524835586548,
0.08377420157194138,
0.33115142583847046,
-1.070310115814209,
0.05954153835773468,
-0.4103696644306183,
0.20569735765457153,
-0.18151520192623138,
-0.06611061096191406,
-0.25450053811073303,
-0.36468157172203064,
0.22407039999961853,
-0.5560625791549683,
0.504518985748291,
0.35651540756225586,
0.6248841285705566,
0.2446952760219574,
-0.0763392299413681,
-0.38636478781700134,
-0.5437033772468567,
0.8871252536773682,
-0.5065041780471802,
0.6964614987373352,
0.9425521492958069,
-0.11426998674869537,
-0.13702768087387085,
-0.2672859728336334,
-0.3984316885471344,
-0.33088311553001404,
0.27113884687423706,
0.2024095058441162,
-0.23196148872375488,
-0.17948096990585327,
0.11312088370323181,
0.03182419016957283,
-0.29479342699050903,
-0.1293424367904663,
-0.19367650151252747,
-0.22502470016479492,
0.5940941572189331,
-0.05386008322238922,
0.29580187797546387,
0.031751345843076706,
-0.11017361283302307,
-0.2883352041244507,
-0.45503610372543335,
-0.029824236407876015,
0.604904055595398,
0.25798577070236206,
-0.28692811727523804,
0.8628178238868713,
0.08292996138334274,
0.4825502634048462,
-0.06499671190977097,
-0.04633494094014168,
0.4125925302505493,
-0.17012286186218262,
-0.09312625229358673,
-0.19467808306217194,
0.4819364845752716,
0.5913340449333191,
-0.06509280204772949,
-0.2149658203125,
0.10063472390174866,
0.045052189379930496,
0.39437344670295715,
-0.25326278805732727,
-0.10483057051897049,
0.31108057498931885,
-0.3130975663661957,
-0.2817656993865967,
0.3412461280822754,
-0.9875319004058838,
-0.7311767339706421,
-0.10476768761873245,
0.45612648129463196,
-0.4417928159236908,
-0.20389120280742645,
0.30046114325523376,
-0.5645692348480225,
0.19169501960277557,
0.33201271295547485,
-0.44316303730010986,
0.5719327330589294,
0.5741825699806213,
0.7419584393501282,
-0.04259215667843819,
-0.02362026274204254,
-0.3087882101535797,
-0.023469502106308937,
-0.6934565901756287,
0.47898241877555847,
-0.6682515144348145,
-0.8834033608436584,
0.22979019582271576,
-0.25241824984550476,
0.16653969883918762,
-0.12331477552652359,
0.6216247081756592,
-0.09344511479139328,
-0.20687319338321686,
-0.6586045026779175,
-0.8088862895965576,
0.052073944360017776,
0.130840465426445,
-0.49021148681640625,
1.0195752382278442,
0.23836201429367065,
-1.2186675071716309,
0.7713002562522888,
-0.12038945406675339,
-0.11515749245882034,
-0.23956941068172455,
-0.24120362102985382,
-0.7191879749298096,
0.4351525604724884,
0.36209791898727417,
0.7496883869171143,
-0.25674518942832947,
-0.30634328722953796,
-1.1905971765518188,
-0.29298460483551025,
0.535132884979248,
-0.3190155625343323,
0.49552175402641296,
-0.11994745582342148,
-0.39435943961143494,
-0.23325875401496887,
-0.6153616905212402,
-0.2046600580215454,
-0.08284585922956467,
0.47959962487220764,
-0.7126078605651855,
0.36947908997535706,
-0.0835728794336319,
-0.3364199101924896,
0.123837411403656,
-0.6658335328102112,
0.1258796602487564,
0.12407241761684418,
-0.07311863452196121,
0.5902847647666931,
-0.04641582444310188,
0.5093861818313599,
-0.359489768743515,
0.5236330628395081,
0.013652238063514233,
0.04804670810699463,
0.5764840245246887,
-0.5994058847427368,
-0.4774607717990875,
-0.5194746255874634,
0.3724507987499237,
0.5608416795730591,
-0.5228077173233032,
0.504759669303894,
-0.2829396426677704,
-0.765384316444397,
-0.6660109758377075,
-0.04814184457063675,
0.26973363757133484,
0.04179408773779869,
0.3366868495941162,
-0.1718975454568863,
-0.4223329424858093,
-0.781865119934082,
-0.4934667944908142,
-0.02677365019917488,
-0.12415695935487747,
0.23374323546886444,
0.6341689229011536,
-0.3118429183959961,
0.8715024590492249,
-0.7020021080970764,
0.0552634596824646,
0.04525918886065483,
0.5408720374107361,
-0.07962211221456528,
0.3791343569755554,
0.3872133493423462,
-0.4337756037712097,
-0.3428947627544403,
-0.24395357072353363,
-0.522423505783081,
0.09060873091220856,
0.10560640692710876,
-0.032972436398267746,
-0.1620684415102005,
0.47893136739730835,
-0.3176826536655426,
0.9750930070877075,
0.5891948342323303,
-0.25070852041244507,
0.6924362182617188,
-0.4098507761955261,
0.2644842565059662,
-0.9036373496055603,
-0.10527215898036957,
0.3775651752948761,
-0.18596109747886658,
-0.3647128641605377,
-0.01045942958444357,
0.24043361842632294,
0.1712338924407959,
-0.040796201676130295,
0.2515478730201721,
-0.7746225595474243,
-0.2820332944393158,
-0.1315382868051529,
-0.07907714694738388,
-0.355433851480484,
-0.20191356539726257,
-0.01835913397371769,
0.7882137894630432,
0.6387857794761658,
-0.5200706124305725,
-0.15719980001449585,
0.10466040670871735,
-0.3720764219760895,
0.5498396158218384,
-0.7786617279052734,
-0.10380374640226364,
-0.282945454120636,
0.1605149507522583,
-1.0493446588516235,
-0.34085267782211304,
0.16388657689094543,
-0.5142529010772705,
0.3412973880767822,
0.06034828722476959,
-0.30755093693733215,
-0.42146724462509155,
-0.8528335690498352,
0.15631040930747986,
0.5485274195671082,
-0.04017217457294464,
0.08548589795827866,
0.9601823687553406,
-0.10120846331119537,
-0.7603033781051636,
-0.4995756447315216,
-0.2708776891231537,
-0.15661747753620148,
-0.2482697069644928,
0.20221836864948273,
0.04466763138771057,
-0.5081748962402344,
0.04034961387515068,
-0.371537983417511,
-0.21217802166938782,
0.2407069355249405,
0.45183056592941284,
0.19405509531497955,
0.047607094049453735,
0.07339251041412354,
0.23403207957744598,
0.08344988524913788,
-0.04440848156809807,
0.05949835479259491,
0.07868009060621262,
-0.02059192582964897,
-0.8157357573509216,
0.07114987075328827,
0.34649980068206787,
0.4496544599533081,
0.136783629655838,
0.48301923274993896,
0.8212447166442871,
-0.7213500738143921,
-0.3023965060710907,
-0.6546416282653809,
-0.03662277013063431,
-0.388809472322464,
0.4412836730480194,
-0.28190529346466064,
-0.7009527683258057,
0.43497490882873535,
0.035232774913311005,
0.02562820538878441,
0.40117931365966797,
0.5274919867515564,
-0.3970303237438202,
0.8599668741226196,
0.5625261664390564,
-0.029571056365966797,
0.046888552606105804,
-0.054949916899204254,
0.08282726258039474,
-0.7145494818687439,
0.18041105568408966,
-0.694743275642395,
-0.08992214500904083,
-0.751365065574646,
-1.1143206357955933,
0.46777674555778503,
0.026919646188616753,
-0.06156149134039879,
0.27117010951042175,
-0.23070451617240906,
0.075006403028965,
0.6288553476333618,
0.3838960826396942,
-0.26697632670402527,
0.025913994759321213,
0.03367398679256439,
-0.2534250020980835,
-0.4815974831581116,
-0.4665176272392273,
1.2665212154388428,
0.41507938504219055,
0.9301819801330566,
0.05937378853559494,
0.823803186416626,
0.3860027492046356,
0.25630953907966614,
-0.5532378554344177,
-0.11569403856992722,
-0.13344694674015045,
-0.43389052152633667,
-0.3947300910949707,
-0.17397423088550568,
-0.8895885944366455,
0.36151060461997986,
-0.6609114408493042,
-1.1454755067825317,
0.34294989705085754,
0.16596491634845734,
-0.3897773027420044,
0.4241490960121155,
-0.4703378975391388,
0.37810930609703064,
0.4300194978713989,
-0.34309816360473633,
0.005740414839237928,
-0.5130712389945984,
0.3739364743232727,
-0.012402508407831192,
0.7010086178779602,
-0.2001769244670868,
-0.33083823323249817,
0.8189091086387634,
-0.3549361526966095,
1.1156821250915527,
-0.17644421756267548,
0.051477350294589996,
0.3147895634174347,
0.24013885855674744,
0.46542224287986755,
0.07787567377090454,
-0.20634911954402924,
0.16697251796722412,
0.27808573842048645,
-0.5153625011444092,
-0.38517364859580994,
0.26416146755218506,
-0.7976121306419373,
-0.5594425201416016,
-0.6052183508872986,
-0.47789448499679565,
-0.5388292074203491,
-0.17082946002483368,
0.45032209157943726,
0.32517415285110474,
-0.46461740136146545,
0.42457205057144165,
0.7799172401428223,
-0.33850255608558655,
0.12880313396453857,
-0.08241340517997742,
0.19125081598758698,
-0.1945192962884903,
0.690714418888092,
0.46896833181381226,
-0.11344028264284134,
0.32152941823005676,
0.48161786794662476,
-0.3956473767757416,
-0.4858224093914032,
-0.20047540962696075,
0.008902761153876781,
-0.3516314625740051,
-0.06704582273960114,
-0.7197359204292297,
0.18358509242534637,
-0.5019327402114868,
-0.4252944886684418,
-0.4913348853588104,
-0.2682344913482666,
-0.2797539532184601,
-0.3776852786540985,
0.33155956864356995,
0.8046548366546631,
-0.2690555155277252,
0.05518074706196785,
-0.721517026424408,
0.25184768438339233,
0.0388413704931736,
0.2966412901878357,
-0.31401771306991577,
-0.2657764256000519,
-0.14030419290065765,
0.23353569209575653,
-0.1338929384946823,
-1.3061250448226929,
0.314354807138443,
0.08910363912582397,
0.6174119114875793,
0.2017529457807541,
0.3447106182575226,
0.5641453862190247,
-0.5307917594909668,
1.008980393409729,
0.22921746969223022,
-1.0837632417678833,
0.11546885967254639,
-0.3253360092639923,
-0.25768864154815674,
0.47882068157196045,
0.6581546068191528,
-0.14784985780715942,
-0.49892792105674744,
-0.9283922910690308,
-0.7405248880386353,
-0.09685605019330978,
0.09958890825510025,
0.005481834057718515,
-0.10917225480079651,
0.12893597781658173,
0.33948203921318054,
0.1268840879201889,
-0.017877256497740746,
-0.3581030070781708,
-0.08167759329080582,
-0.29824796319007874,
-0.26303306221961975,
-0.40643495321273804,
-0.2748902440071106,
-0.21269218623638153,
0.3703477680683136,
-0.12809719145298004,
0.5672893524169922,
0.28660598397254944,
-0.286390095949173,
0.09166905283927917,
0.08839058876037598,
0.6171090602874756,
0.6446214318275452,
-0.295062392950058,
0.381664514541626,
0.5200888514518738,
-0.6891677379608154,
0.1798555552959442,
-0.08805686235427856,
0.056138020008802414,
0.30019012093544006,
0.6544438600540161,
0.40309229493141174,
0.43378564715385437,
-0.3742222189903259,
0.9975504875183105,
-0.08362547308206558,
-0.22316280007362366,
-0.2770095467567444,
-0.3612591326236725,
0.1460765153169632,
-0.021012745797634125,
0.11366255581378937,
0.13694125413894653,
0.38177114725112915,
-0.21995586156845093,
0.4742162823677063,
0.4392262101173401,
-0.5639682412147522,
-0.28587812185287476,
0.43556368350982666,
-0.04948796331882477,
0.1701037585735321,
0.014975832775235176,
-0.20712009072303772,
-0.32760050892829895,
0.4102610647678375,
0.2510945498943329,
0.7481396794319153,
-0.006541626062244177,
0.34434351325035095,
0.49434033036231995,
0.4147511422634125,
-0.22646073997020721,
0.5048790574073792,
0.16180282831192017,
-0.8899868130683899,
-0.05666882544755936,
-0.44028395414352417,
-0.6487898230552673,
-0.556631326675415,
-1.0470080375671387,
0.020790645852684975,
-0.3225439488887787,
-0.4533902108669281,
-0.1514238566160202,
-0.11129290610551834,
-0.972829282283783,
0.08952995389699936,
-0.1446690708398819,
0.7477161288261414,
-1.0411280393600464,
0.4246846139431,
0.4146864712238312,
-0.19568873941898346,
-0.6002603769302368,
0.21067751944065094,
0.3197556436061859,
-0.9355231523513794,
0.23137804865837097,
-0.17660102248191833,
-0.029415378347039223,
-0.5048185586929321,
-0.6174924969673157,
-0.8703543543815613,
0.881314754486084,
0.19765809178352356,
-0.4215719699859619,
0.3269210457801819,
-0.009531181305646896,
0.09247767180204391,
0.17798858880996704,
0.34459319710731506,
0.3919409215450287,
0.43483802676200867,
-0.3995102047920227,
-0.5437605381011963,
0.2841828167438507,
0.09551411122083664,
0.02024565450847149,
-0.02314036525785923,
-0.09190842509269714,
0.7868121266365051,
-0.2547379732131958,
-0.026897115632891655,
0.01615549996495247,
0.876575767993927,
0.3368058502674103,
0.14388111233711243,
0.6457616686820984,
0.47661954164505005,
1.1093851327896118,
-0.023633575066924095,
1.2235972881317139,
-0.3220731317996979,
0.5093811750411987,
0.9730653166770935,
-0.1290697455406189,
0.8902467489242554,
0.5053500533103943,
-0.5517109632492065,
0.11461073160171509,
0.6035248637199402,
0.19143380224704742,
0.192780002951622,
0.6229761242866516,
-0.1735994815826416,
-0.1583070456981659,
0.08370774984359741,
-0.5079439282417297,
0.2968520522117615,
0.7593665719032288,
-0.03750334680080414,
-0.040132567286491394,
-0.21384063363075256,
0.106186643242836,
-0.020706210285425186,
0.1014457419514656,
0.41225680708885193,
0.17454619705677032,
-0.2273683100938797,
0.024030400440096855,
0.017350507900118828,
0.807964026927948,
-0.47089171409606934,
0.00978800654411316,
0.20222677290439606,
-0.0724712461233139,
0.0009080995223484933,
-0.7207578420639038,
0.3711985647678375,
-0.0921579971909523,
0.1558160036802292,
0.1335127353668213,
0.7067978382110596,
-0.3116258382797241,
-0.8428904414176941,
0.03360726684331894,
0.6622723937034607,
0.03069871850311756,
0.0861547663807869,
-0.5133760571479797,
0.2945758104324341,
-0.2678164839744568,
-0.2735368609428406,
0.17633453011512756,
0.3893105983734131,
0.10336807370185852,
0.4932335317134857,
0.4564247727394104,
0.2590784430503845,
0.27484482526779175,
-0.20510898530483246,
0.32943886518478394,
-0.2846732437610626,
-0.34701403975486755,
-0.706331193447113,
0.4954202175140381,
-0.2604554295539856,
-0.5819829106330872,
0.937675952911377,
0.17910246551036835,
0.5190737247467041,
-0.375118225812912,
1.0632965564727783,
-0.06638369709253311,
0.431001216173172,
-0.41313907504081726,
0.6182590126991272,
-0.5170671343803406,
-0.2730560898780823,
-0.7331849932670593,
-0.49699997901916504,
-0.45552682876586914,
0.8753791451454163,
-0.16129770874977112,
-0.14768530428409576,
0.5787713527679443,
0.813347339630127,
-0.16261796653270721,
0.14017042517662048,
0.6255660653114319,
0.010064376518130302,
0.09166347980499268,
-0.23540566861629486,
0.40303558111190796,
-0.521660327911377,
-0.2967856824398041,
-0.4899212419986725,
-0.6110935211181641,
-0.2565937638282776,
-0.9511553049087524,
-0.4899745583534241,
-0.6848961710929871,
-0.47389328479766846,
-0.6304991245269775,
0.0570104606449604,
1.1483631134033203,
0.704984724521637,
-0.7259090542793274,
-0.15219490230083466,
0.1839885115623474,
0.1381487101316452,
-0.5992224216461182,
-0.11529491096735,
0.7359556555747986,
-0.18347741663455963,
-0.6095543503761292,
0.16712339222431183,
-0.10964962095022202,
-0.023709146305918694,
-0.004265257157385349,
0.19535109400749207,
-0.016888393089175224,
0.3409290015697479,
0.37255528569221497,
0.0886847972869873,
-0.581679105758667,
-0.6740860342979431,
-0.10857350379228592,
-0.13275666534900665,
-0.513526976108551,
0.6872013807296753,
0.09502677619457245,
0.5537660121917725,
0.657471239566803,
0.9755837321281433,
0.3528800308704376,
-0.24990521371364594,
0.8793421983718872,
-0.7806779146194458,
0.01618465594947338,
0.07261042296886444,
0.7597761750221252,
0.18360622227191925,
-0.26318100094795227,
0.38286903500556946,
0.3437196910381317,
-0.16731595993041992,
-0.8091275095939636,
0.09052123129367828,
-1.0784177780151367,
-0.3817937970161438,
1.2320600748062134,
-0.2998872399330139,
-0.40124958753585815,
-0.2502094805240631,
-0.0657554566860199,
0.3839605152606964,
-0.20702439546585083,
0.697192907333374,
0.8553963303565979,
0.31064555048942566,
0.1801280826330185,
-0.7328183054924011,
0.4239068031311035,
0.19233791530132294,
-0.3381921350955963,
0.07105804234743118,
0.10215790569782257,
0.40237608551979065,
0.16145919263362885,
0.4593275487422943,
-0.03963956981897354,
0.2601553499698639,
0.6653875112533569,
0.15911510586738586,
0.2452496439218521,
0.04899328574538231,
0.12547482550144196,
0.1964549869298935,
0.03160729259252548,
-0.45068037509918213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12159v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12159v1
|
Exploring the Impact of a Transformer's Latent Space Geometry on Downstream Task Performance
| 2024-06-18T00:17:30 | 2024-06-18T00:17:30 |
Anna C. Marbut, John W. Chandler, Travis J. Wheeler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
It is generally thought that transformer-based large language models benefit
from pre-training by learning generic linguistic knowledge that can be focused
on a specific task during fine-tuning. However, we propose that much of the
benefit from pre-training may be captured by geometric characteristics of the
latent space representations, divorced from any specific linguistic knowledge.
In this work we explore the relationship between GLUE benchmarking task
performance and a variety of measures applied to the latent space resulting
from BERT-type contextual language models. We find that there is a strong
linear relationship between a measure of quantized cell density and average
GLUE performance and that these measures may be predictive of otherwise
surprising GLUE performance for several non-standard BERT-type models from the
literature. These results may be suggestive of a strategy for decreasing
pre-training requirements, wherein model initialization can be informed by the
geometric characteristics of the model's latent space.
|
[
-0.3754064738750458,
-0.5849962830543518,
0.5798467993736267,
0.07036115974187851,
-0.05356264114379883,
-0.18932150304317474,
-0.08126024901866913,
-0.15997259318828583,
0.1549926996231079,
0.2686951160430908,
-0.5588155388832092,
-0.20932815968990326,
-0.7785223126411438,
-0.4174252152442932,
-0.32451340556144714,
0.9719663262367249,
-0.11521222442388535,
-0.23440033197402954,
-0.38030338287353516,
0.12398205697536469,
-0.39406129717826843,
-0.6023434996604919,
-0.11980640888214111,
-0.16389039158821106,
0.7952680587768555,
-0.17920228838920593,
0.8667662739753723,
0.5994056463241577,
0.6106200814247131,
0.3501695692539215,
-0.13808533549308777,
-0.5255351662635803,
-0.5981228351593018,
-0.043860435485839844,
0.10476332902908325,
-0.7556402087211609,
-0.5712958574295044,
0.4249659776687622,
0.7443264722824097,
1.053157091140747,
-0.07158340513706207,
0.023452242836356163,
0.416735976934433,
0.5995691418647766,
-0.6924445629119873,
0.18852974474430084,
-0.47272810339927673,
0.08672021329402924,
-0.4032280445098877,
-0.07578858733177185,
-0.3501479923725128,
-0.3641929626464844,
0.4798654615879059,
-0.7888275384902954,
0.39768803119659424,
-0.13674628734588623,
0.9818256497383118,
0.7292947173118591,
-0.2892848253250122,
-0.13059930503368378,
-0.8904057741165161,
0.8164785504341125,
-0.5567348003387451,
0.5163424611091614,
0.32930344343185425,
0.3062475919723511,
-0.10633603483438492,
-0.7412638068199158,
-0.06240468472242355,
-0.0006530643440783024,
-0.5058994293212891,
0.15738916397094727,
-0.129055917263031,
-0.10083663463592529,
0.3870605230331421,
0.3930177092552185,
-0.5304775834083557,
-0.03808606415987015,
-0.5266480445861816,
-0.17756493389606476,
0.3092482388019562,
0.024221057072281837,
0.19943517446517944,
0.10474982857704163,
-0.25731128454208374,
-0.35829415917396545,
-0.7637460231781006,
0.48305511474609375,
0.3925762474536896,
0.2354649156332016,
-0.19550032913684845,
0.5193668007850647,
0.11948695033788681,
0.4283047914505005,
0.02183639444410801,
0.1285921335220337,
0.03250499442219734,
0.01347654964774847,
-0.058915019035339355,
-0.24874085187911987,
0.5707613825798035,
-0.2933558523654938,
0.05213484168052673,
-0.3438205420970917,
-0.16102683544158936,
0.12041351199150085,
0.7360283732414246,
-0.8628866076469421,
-0.6682418584823608,
-0.2746953070163727,
-0.574396550655365,
0.15744511783123016,
0.16602823138237,
-0.21396636962890625,
0.10382132232189178,
-0.4108569622039795,
0.4197244644165039,
-0.47658368945121765,
-0.15031586587429047,
-0.3121050000190735,
-0.04691161960363388,
0.19767609238624573,
0.1395002007484436,
-0.8124727606773376,
0.23426522314548492,
0.849846601486206,
0.924027144908905,
-0.24419145286083221,
-0.09832321107387543,
-0.4927177429199219,
0.13879214227199554,
-0.3470601439476013,
1.0888324975967407,
-0.6843510866165161,
-0.35132265090942383,
-0.08075613528490067,
0.08228858560323715,
-0.41042593121528625,
-0.5949587225914001,
0.35196980834007263,
-0.5078747272491455,
0.29668736457824707,
-0.42057862877845764,
-0.6370232105255127,
-0.17409208416938782,
-0.2624451518058777,
-0.9201754927635193,
1.0073504447937012,
0.48787492513656616,
-0.5032647848129272,
0.7656503319740295,
-0.47012847661972046,
-0.5038252472877502,
0.09988105297088623,
-0.3317367732524872,
-0.5368610620498657,
0.5828062891960144,
-0.004449720028787851,
0.5496076345443726,
0.08097951114177704,
0.2774357199668884,
-0.4177769422531128,
-0.5426140427589417,
0.20184090733528137,
-0.2370680421590805,
0.239724799990654,
-0.025962231680750847,
-0.32054027915000916,
0.10737541317939758,
-0.49249324202537537,
-0.11143863946199417,
-0.2903388738632202,
-0.36456939578056335,
-0.3481728732585907,
0.17817123234272003,
-0.13674050569534302,
0.3548201024532318,
0.25815197825431824,
-0.38112178444862366,
0.07439744472503662,
-0.44650915265083313,
0.035224299877882004,
0.5791852474212646,
-0.3200283348560333,
0.6928160786628723,
-0.23569732904434204,
0.43098771572113037,
0.10733041167259216,
-0.023299945518374443,
0.043018639087677,
-0.547432005405426,
-0.795261025428772,
-0.3183012306690216,
0.10587877780199051,
0.19244353473186493,
-0.5857354998588562,
0.45845693349838257,
-0.33164316415786743,
-0.7114434242248535,
-0.2850628197193146,
0.13595572113990784,
0.41749632358551025,
0.3413388431072235,
0.19806279242038727,
-0.3478713035583496,
-0.22662712633609772,
-1.0725077390670776,
-0.3034934103488922,
-0.010913563892245293,
-0.3602463901042938,
0.4686637818813324,
0.34712642431259155,
0.11007751524448395,
1.2349162101745605,
-0.9102407097816467,
-0.45305800437927246,
0.036278996616601944,
0.2338714748620987,
0.5835915803909302,
0.42532363533973694,
0.6972268223762512,
-0.5798555612564087,
-0.42337048053741455,
-0.1782074123620987,
-0.5353561043739319,
-0.1268356591463089,
0.20997925102710724,
-0.13441184163093567,
0.22382277250289917,
0.5782471895217896,
-0.5640661120414734,
0.7202185392379761,
0.8608847856521606,
-0.573406994342804,
0.6616224050521851,
-0.34590181708335876,
-0.0070311506278812885,
-0.8407098054885864,
0.21841424703598022,
0.05713152512907982,
0.16209620237350464,
-0.6028652191162109,
-0.5788289904594421,
-0.0313560925424099,
-0.26677820086479187,
-0.6269900798797607,
0.2081925868988037,
-0.27043837308883667,
-0.3598291575908661,
-0.2996729612350464,
-0.02655310370028019,
-0.18559981882572174,
0.6533498167991638,
0.31759464740753174,
1.1454859972000122,
0.30925023555755615,
-0.5841612815856934,
-0.25806528329849243,
0.2713814973831177,
-0.4112052917480469,
0.2740615904331207,
-0.8952234387397766,
-0.09530781954526901,
0.10612280666828156,
0.2747693359851837,
-1.2369340658187866,
0.019936854019761086,
-0.4993783235549927,
-0.277031809091568,
0.2613995671272278,
0.0432652086019516,
-0.2667028307914734,
-0.32966721057891846,
0.10885986685752869,
0.47560930252075195,
0.7489227056503296,
-0.2524835765361786,
0.6013934016227722,
0.29804712533950806,
-0.1958388239145279,
-0.19528846442699432,
-0.423973947763443,
-0.5409227609634399,
-0.4401102662086487,
-0.844893753528595,
0.5099084377288818,
0.2106674760580063,
0.2057163268327713,
0.011382351629436016,
-0.31005430221557617,
-0.2634080648422241,
0.1510934680700302,
0.45968249440193176,
0.24119088053703308,
-0.564530074596405,
0.04670717939734459,
0.11604750156402588,
-0.2777281105518341,
0.32188600301742554,
-0.3238207995891571,
0.431897908449173,
-0.26827335357666016,
-0.2680925726890564,
-0.2843843996524811,
0.07193072140216827,
0.30329394340515137,
0.013152390718460083,
1.0974129438400269,
0.7875074148178101,
-0.12922827899456024,
-0.010816322639584541,
-0.49380627274513245,
-0.4105425477027893,
-0.5246944427490234,
0.41645684838294983,
-0.4101826846599579,
-1.0034905672073364,
0.5796317458152771,
-0.28805017471313477,
-0.11911503970623016,
0.5537739992141724,
0.48968273401260376,
-0.4612806439399719,
0.7087332606315613,
0.9674919843673706,
0.1739615648984909,
0.546564519405365,
-0.37935084104537964,
0.5130085945129395,
-0.9583811163902283,
-0.12162253260612488,
-0.49658963084220886,
-0.48297253251075745,
-0.632570207118988,
-0.6373674869537354,
0.4045679271221161,
0.23586174845695496,
-0.1808219999074936,
0.6574925780296326,
-0.3037516176700592,
0.26098260283470154,
0.4983268976211548,
-0.08657942712306976,
-0.13507148623466492,
-0.09662415087223053,
-0.0885569378733635,
-0.3172290325164795,
-0.8071120977401733,
-0.7423447370529175,
0.8164975643157959,
0.3082970678806305,
0.6974550485610962,
0.011209791526198387,
0.22410643100738525,
-0.09956652671098709,
0.2137051373720169,
-0.4059167206287384,
0.3139937222003937,
-0.6106540560722351,
-0.35586199164390564,
-0.3101593852043152,
-0.3850216269493103,
-1.0989186763763428,
0.16595503687858582,
-0.11814098805189133,
-0.9519802927970886,
0.0806698277592659,
0.25192463397979736,
-0.3068704903125763,
0.3178207278251648,
-0.6954424977302551,
1.0375272035598755,
-0.14591719210147858,
-0.2642633020877838,
-0.2369910180568695,
-0.3862886130809784,
-0.012280869297683239,
-0.22614485025405884,
-0.10421925038099289,
-0.13648535311222076,
0.03800337389111519,
0.9478075504302979,
-0.4555051922798157,
0.8686913847923279,
-0.30083173513412476,
-0.26889991760253906,
0.15446896851062775,
0.05624355003237724,
0.2653253972530365,
-0.16683484613895416,
0.29805248975753784,
0.4305156171321869,
-0.121501624584198,
-0.45114365220069885,
-0.726344883441925,
0.5898624062538147,
-1.136177897453308,
-0.6434505581855774,
0.12432435154914856,
-0.9558616280555725,
-0.39321085810661316,
-0.043892037123441696,
0.42202261090278625,
0.4352453351020813,
-0.15695929527282715,
0.6532053351402283,
0.5882036685943604,
-0.28609922528266907,
0.7068548798561096,
0.2223428189754486,
0.12973862886428833,
0.21570570766925812,
0.6698985695838928,
0.31858548521995544,
0.13851597905158997,
0.4856884479522705,
0.0850624069571495,
-0.4306662082672119,
-0.23031699657440186,
0.18435831367969513,
0.3015775680541992,
-0.3623639941215515,
0.10635796189308167,
-0.616378903388977,
-0.35511425137519836,
-0.24316278100013733,
-0.40587449073791504,
-0.7283892631530762,
-0.48417729139328003,
-0.2962513566017151,
0.26116788387298584,
-0.025827400386333466,
0.8680402040481567,
0.35164088010787964,
0.6594775319099426,
-0.8012914657592773,
-0.10299926996231079,
0.3357296288013458,
0.8004553318023682,
-0.03187381476163864,
-0.5678309202194214,
-0.5394142866134644,
-0.10400477796792984,
-0.6139498949050903,
-0.3692602217197418,
0.3168385326862335,
0.1464361697435379,
0.7249624133110046,
0.448751837015152,
-0.2844095826148987,
0.6295278668403625,
-0.6865056753158569,
0.8463449478149414,
0.16739530861377716,
-0.9231795072555542,
0.72769695520401,
-0.5644100308418274,
0.46382084488868713,
0.07970394194126129,
0.5050414204597473,
0.0275814738124609,
-0.6317141652107239,
-0.6743285655975342,
-0.6897450685501099,
0.6977021098136902,
0.5296586751937866,
-0.02892361767590046,
0.23766157031059265,
0.1978868693113327,
0.14390195906162262,
0.06278663873672485,
-0.6706351637840271,
-0.03788948804140091,
-0.216494619846344,
0.09995895624160767,
-0.34197190403938293,
-0.188271164894104,
0.22161684930324554,
-0.14589497447013855,
0.3902048170566559,
-0.07891568541526794,
0.40608322620391846,
-0.1496429145336151,
-0.22119459509849548,
0.13302560150623322,
0.0010717505356296897,
0.6591739058494568,
0.5228068232536316,
-0.1722719818353653,
-0.17838767170906067,
0.08894181251525879,
-0.6334258317947388,
0.04782086983323097,
0.0264255553483963,
0.24880775809288025,
-0.05101444199681282,
0.6039082407951355,
0.9671820402145386,
0.4097471535205841,
-0.1851639300584793,
0.404384583234787,
-0.013671849854290485,
-0.2714099586009979,
-0.11475120484828949,
0.313312828540802,
0.07129783183336258,
0.2381792515516281,
0.5058566331863403,
0.1051749736070633,
0.03784138709306717,
-0.11175724864006042,
0.3485357463359833,
0.3238130509853363,
-0.7718808650970459,
-0.7143261432647705,
0.5330849289894104,
0.16196608543395996,
-0.243833526968956,
0.6645733118057251,
0.2751522660255432,
-0.3568645715713501,
0.6363289952278137,
0.37531909346580505,
0.7756244540214539,
-0.3976185917854309,
-0.08262652903795242,
0.20081788301467896,
0.1871003955602646,
0.37435469031333923,
-0.26036328077316284,
-0.09772556275129318,
-0.4587319791316986,
-0.7758466005325317,
-0.6438149213790894,
0.12246236205101013,
0.12259192019701004,
-0.6909340620040894,
0.10867838561534882,
-0.09467000514268875,
-0.351706862449646,
-0.07036419957876205,
-0.06374304741621017,
-0.851423978805542,
0.2490828037261963,
0.25211817026138306,
0.6080595254898071,
-0.9891940951347351,
0.8694231510162354,
0.776423990726471,
-0.0376930758357048,
-1.0922032594680786,
-0.014660525135695934,
-0.1408243477344513,
-0.3351837694644928,
1.0614686012268066,
0.3705314099788666,
-0.017458125948905945,
-0.348705917596817,
0.06764649599790573,
-1.3900147676467896,
1.0300450325012207,
0.537225067615509,
-0.5105397701263428,
-0.1844729334115982,
0.47480419278144836,
0.6533302664756775,
-0.4539671540260315,
0.4649755656719208,
0.6036934852600098,
0.12161547690629959,
0.18297399580478668,
-0.9890503287315369,
-0.1040518581867218,
-0.30054330825805664,
0.45169588923454285,
0.5789845585823059,
-0.3811491131782532,
1.0350168943405151,
0.043859001249074936,
-0.3501918613910675,
-0.19521866738796234,
0.8969460725784302,
0.2543018162250519,
-0.14465516805648804,
0.5326991677284241,
0.5769652724266052,
0.33355075120925903,
-0.5796756744384766,
1.116098403930664,
-0.4167892038822174,
0.45388635993003845,
0.8761734366416931,
-0.028947366401553154,
0.9613403081893921,
0.5824323892593384,
-0.34224721789360046,
0.7431637048721313,
0.3351925313472748,
0.043395861983299255,
0.6000375747680664,
0.2662440240383148,
0.22489608824253082,
-0.10016520321369171,
-0.03998907655477524,
-0.34296751022338867,
0.6437366604804993,
0.506102979183197,
-0.03132551908493042,
-0.25033167004585266,
-0.05775647982954979,
-0.2601628303527832,
0.024945156648755074,
-0.059377271682024,
0.8077988624572754,
0.1562284231185913,
-0.8211224675178528,
0.437787264585495,
-0.6898627281188965,
0.5115451812744141,
-0.43598541617393494,
0.07018683850765228,
-0.06518002599477768,
0.30434975028038025,
-0.19028401374816895,
-0.8766905665397644,
0.8293478488922119,
-0.2856971323490143,
-0.373444527387619,
-0.3782135546207428,
0.5889743566513062,
-0.2685147225856781,
-0.3120048940181732,
0.43635737895965576,
0.5452559590339661,
0.1501254141330719,
-0.054419390857219696,
-0.3855384886264801,
0.05000818893313408,
-0.3361624479293823,
-0.42497363686561584,
0.3318623900413513,
0.40602052211761475,
0.052346933633089066,
0.4986787736415863,
0.5996410846710205,
0.05976312980055809,
0.11492562294006348,
0.09364975988864899,
0.9384375214576721,
-0.441779762506485,
-0.691589891910553,
-0.5988280773162842,
0.7403675317764282,
0.0851757675409317,
-0.2137642204761505,
0.6887513399124146,
0.6472665667533875,
0.7444663047790527,
-0.27454060316085815,
0.31298503279685974,
0.023145433515310287,
0.39677926898002625,
-0.5736497640609741,
0.9236608743667603,
-0.4929092824459076,
0.21556630730628967,
-0.4597506523132324,
-1.4513182640075684,
0.09862034767866135,
0.6954883933067322,
-0.7940698862075806,
0.290991872549057,
1.016467809677124,
0.4869749844074249,
-0.2721310257911682,
-0.0717160627245903,
0.5299351811408997,
0.1340535581111908,
0.49592065811157227,
0.8149569630622864,
0.9925113916397095,
-0.3890460133552551,
0.5572987794876099,
-0.21131902933120728,
-0.21866896748542786,
-0.010716899298131466,
-0.8400403261184692,
-1.0852259397506714,
-0.9527972936630249,
-0.30940765142440796,
0.058119866997003555,
-0.393206387758255,
0.037146519869565964,
1.2130011320114136,
-0.6192781925201416,
-0.36309006810188293,
-0.05492591857910156,
-0.34988582134246826,
0.1374930441379547,
-0.20021125674247742,
0.5460762977600098,
-0.7171770334243774,
-0.4836937189102173,
0.08343200385570526,
0.35605013370513916,
0.029455039650201797,
-0.009750799275934696,
0.17733146250247955,
-0.09257736802101135,
-0.06891167163848877,
0.5399209260940552,
-0.21845313906669617,
-0.7948705554008484,
-0.1238059252500534,
0.09586792439222336,
-0.10245051234960556,
0.19024382531642914,
1.1929817199707031,
-1.0415970087051392,
-0.0812334343791008,
0.26775646209716797,
0.4906706213951111,
0.6198952794075012,
-0.06953456252813339,
0.8740171194076538,
-1.0599004030227661,
0.4721238911151886,
0.11226855963468552,
0.37458282709121704,
0.10350250452756882,
-0.5360674262046814,
0.40633624792099,
0.013263467699289322,
-0.6597501039505005,
-0.34397372603416443,
0.07791087031364441,
-0.6718823909759521,
-0.24099783599376678,
0.7137997150421143,
-0.49640944600105286,
-0.3872055411338806,
0.12881983816623688,
0.15477879345417023,
0.3126448094844818,
-0.23575353622436523,
0.7039440274238586,
0.7296239733695984,
-0.19734136760234833,
0.04301401600241661,
-0.415533185005188,
0.6445618867874146,
0.7649272680282593,
-0.8478366732597351,
-0.11818438023328781,
0.2265365719795227,
0.08994051814079285,
0.53581303358078,
0.18270371854305267,
-0.00881985668092966,
0.24150113761425018,
-0.07924139499664307,
-0.2707935571670532,
0.3503347337245941,
-0.5218172073364258,
-0.12689626216888428,
0.23921747505664825,
-0.15817362070083618,
0.107208251953125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12158v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12158v1
|
LLMs Are Prone to Fallacies in Causal Inference
| 2024-06-18T00:14:07 | 2024-06-18T00:14:07 |
Nitish Joshi, Abulhair Saparov, Yixin Wang, He He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent work shows that causal facts can be effectively extracted from LLMs
through prompting, facilitating the creation of causal graphs for causal
inference tasks. However, it is unclear if this success is limited to
explicitly-mentioned causal facts in the pretraining data which the model can
memorize. Thus, this work investigates: Can LLMs infer causal relations from
other relational data in text? To disentangle the role of memorized causal
facts vs inferred causal relations, we finetune LLMs on synthetic data
containing temporal, spatial and counterfactual relations, and measure whether
the LLM can then infer causal relations. We find that: (a) LLMs are susceptible
to inferring causal relations from the order of two entity mentions in text
(e.g. X mentioned before Y implies X causes Y); (b) if the order is randomized,
LLMs still suffer from the post hoc fallacy, i.e. X occurs before Y (temporal
relation) implies X causes Y. We also find that while LLMs can correctly deduce
the absence of causal relations from temporal and spatial relations, they have
difficulty inferring causal relations from counterfactuals, questioning their
understanding of causality.
|
[
-0.04653637483716011,
-1.0880427360534668,
1.1242154836654663,
0.12289433181285858,
-0.19336435198783875,
-0.2870343029499054,
0.21962688863277435,
-0.5431245565414429,
0.11279968172311783,
0.49311280250549316,
-0.7856307029724121,
-0.290385901927948,
-0.5664739608764648,
0.15211938321590424,
-0.36943310499191284,
0.9076889157295227,
-0.06504326313734055,
0.2503353953361511,
-0.5580376386642456,
-0.0794312059879303,
-0.19302667677402496,
-0.7901793718338013,
-0.40741845965385437,
-0.7738953232765198,
0.8178747296333313,
-0.0031126283574849367,
0.4997577667236328,
0.44622495770454407,
0.4872983992099762,
0.32263538241386414,
0.09341083467006683,
0.22191670536994934,
-0.733570396900177,
-0.02011501044034958,
-0.4516908526420593,
-0.9421365261077881,
-0.1956518590450287,
0.18646809458732605,
0.4699830710887909,
0.6892767548561096,
-0.15347614884376526,
0.07205989956855774,
-0.03327126055955887,
0.6810083389282227,
-0.49103406071662903,
0.19791534543037415,
-0.8204633593559265,
-0.030977169051766396,
-0.1786797046661377,
-0.4060957729816437,
-0.5293912291526794,
-0.40839052200317383,
0.11808683723211288,
-0.6972115635871887,
0.40972042083740234,
0.29955148696899414,
0.9436739087104797,
0.4094109535217285,
-0.7332401871681213,
-0.2825698256492615,
-0.8600574135780334,
0.6147744655609131,
-0.5844559669494629,
0.2351568192243576,
0.41163700819015503,
0.08181656152009964,
-0.39461421966552734,
-0.7726900577545166,
-0.7389892935752869,
-0.27972808480262756,
-0.5312008261680603,
0.19442737102508545,
0.047312911599874496,
-0.12771739065647125,
0.7701873183250427,
0.20540578663349152,
-0.3927166163921356,
-0.052662480622529984,
-0.19357605278491974,
0.023379463702440262,
0.4196842908859253,
0.4348887801170349,
0.345793753862381,
-0.1919724941253662,
-0.6506596207618713,
0.2945482134819031,
-1.1937395334243774,
-0.199097141623497,
0.26068106293678284,
0.15221618115901947,
-0.14211925864219666,
0.5933699607849121,
0.2663801908493042,
0.2448461353778839,
0.005322529003024101,
-0.07435405999422073,
0.019299225881695747,
-0.3286433815956116,
-0.30878475308418274,
0.22461095452308655,
0.8421517014503479,
0.24449336528778076,
0.40607327222824097,
-0.26729705929756165,
0.19449079036712646,
0.2982456684112549,
0.12938138842582703,
-0.4947739243507385,
-0.0881093218922615,
-0.03808428719639778,
-0.3081185519695282,
-0.051867954432964325,
0.14520032703876495,
-0.3817274868488312,
-0.4017440974712372,
-0.4055017828941345,
0.5569337010383606,
-0.12215062230825424,
-0.03913998603820801,
-0.21832580864429474,
-0.24407878518104553,
-0.14742395281791687,
0.35211610794067383,
-0.5706602334976196,
0.2890909016132355,
0.42053866386413574,
0.5945672988891602,
-0.1870334893465042,
-0.6499301791191101,
-0.13507577776908875,
0.5641679763793945,
-0.38891348242759705,
0.8343392610549927,
-0.33894598484039307,
-0.5270926356315613,
-0.1897871494293213,
0.3043743073940277,
-0.5060065984725952,
-0.5045346617698669,
0.324616938829422,
-0.7259353995323181,
0.18797403573989868,
-0.5604289174079895,
-0.780552089214325,
-0.15144124627113342,
0.13329653441905975,
-0.6160273551940918,
0.8606950640678406,
-0.14760173857212067,
-1.1865798234939575,
0.5454582571983337,
0.1517258882522583,
-0.6051040887832642,
-0.5345296859741211,
-0.5191235542297363,
-0.4484790861606598,
0.0699690580368042,
-0.03629346936941147,
0.28545084595680237,
-0.41356518864631653,
0.6729586124420166,
-0.7178113460540771,
-0.209546759724617,
0.6393419504165649,
-0.40347039699554443,
0.8399362564086914,
-0.05028482899069786,
-0.36488908529281616,
-0.15630489587783813,
-0.8378784656524658,
-0.558680534362793,
0.2608698010444641,
-0.35404065251350403,
-0.6257753372192383,
0.3906557857990265,
-0.48866942524909973,
0.2871111035346985,
-0.15803074836730957,
-0.4782613515853882,
0.06417442113161087,
-0.15304827690124512,
0.056776028126478195,
0.7337793111801147,
0.4081629812717438,
0.29605650901794434,
-0.6121585965156555,
0.073693186044693,
0.48761147260665894,
-0.14587877690792084,
0.03946053236722946,
-0.2918969690799713,
-0.6781112551689148,
-0.01998121105134487,
-0.18263642489910126,
0.7010089159011841,
-0.8491634130477905,
-0.019206779077649117,
-0.2111831158399582,
-0.3783740699291229,
0.3027571439743042,
-0.037402890622615814,
0.4640129506587982,
1.049068570137024,
0.3162498474121094,
0.1778644174337387,
-0.6935418844223022,
-0.6088367700576782,
-0.5286816358566284,
-0.43516528606414795,
0.07701580971479416,
0.4630766808986664,
0.6937175393104553,
-0.07741009443998337,
0.8875505328178406,
-0.6453706622123718,
0.08268464356660843,
0.02384173683822155,
0.1719617396593094,
0.3817307651042938,
0.34174802899360657,
0.5769988298416138,
-0.5211012363433838,
-0.034004561603069305,
-0.5558526515960693,
-1.2377521991729736,
-0.1291947364807129,
-0.22030365467071533,
-0.07901149243116379,
0.23559772968292236,
0.905526876449585,
-0.9514038562774658,
0.5884960889816284,
0.09703096747398376,
-0.3815286159515381,
0.7070137858390808,
-0.19914229214191437,
0.06771814823150635,
-0.8311147689819336,
-0.15318293869495392,
-0.1398676037788391,
-0.08613981306552887,
-0.5629866123199463,
-0.7046751976013184,
-0.23302647471427917,
0.5148467421531677,
-0.5118684768676758,
0.5358617901802063,
-0.32987961173057556,
-0.018635299056768417,
0.024495895951986313,
0.16745968163013458,
-0.07415267825126648,
0.3435613214969635,
0.2700829803943634,
0.3282549977302551,
0.3303004205226898,
-0.9935776591300964,
-0.026474008336663246,
0.2091822773218155,
-0.32681146264076233,
0.5687538981437683,
-0.5823078155517578,
-0.2588801085948944,
-0.35982656478881836,
0.27738288044929504,
-1.1010234355926514,
-0.039566803723573685,
0.20081351697444916,
-0.35821834206581116,
0.19931724667549133,
-0.18221303820610046,
-0.6482965350151062,
-0.25512760877609253,
0.0006901011220179498,
0.25769099593162537,
0.36283424496650696,
-0.6574362516403198,
0.22566722333431244,
0.3534003794193268,
0.18546050786972046,
-0.45253464579582214,
-0.9577509164810181,
-0.32587501406669617,
-0.45571422576904297,
-0.32539132237434387,
0.09266366064548492,
0.029473507776856422,
-0.6016402244567871,
0.05455005541443825,
-0.17933449149131775,
-0.10400526970624924,
0.10474619269371033,
0.6054795980453491,
0.21146000921726227,
-0.2219226062297821,
0.403889000415802,
-0.2067851573228836,
-0.09073790907859802,
0.5790265798568726,
0.13752229511737823,
0.018130633980035782,
0.510301947593689,
-0.5271798968315125,
-0.16541536152362823,
0.012761814519762993,
0.3546868562698364,
0.5442970395088196,
0.9303350448608398,
0.21881403028964996,
-0.5229368209838867,
-0.17819100618362427,
-0.4996206760406494,
-0.4143293797969818,
-0.38288360834121704,
0.1368882656097412,
-0.17339375615119934,
-0.6123092174530029,
0.6208541393280029,
-0.2459288239479065,
-0.23048105835914612,
0.530799925327301,
0.43785303831100464,
-0.44551175832748413,
0.555571436882019,
0.2786451578140259,
0.07990190386772156,
0.30549880862236023,
-0.16857941448688507,
-0.03142951428890228,
-0.6327457427978516,
-0.36334019899368286,
-0.41766366362571716,
-0.047931015491485596,
-0.7573462724685669,
-0.20788508653640747,
0.2100324183702469,
0.17007207870483398,
-0.5727202296257019,
0.0637878030538559,
0.25884416699409485,
0.3365178108215332,
0.46825867891311646,
0.42346352338790894,
0.4511994421482086,
0.12083287537097931,
-0.17108826339244843,
-0.3041820526123047,
-0.8510217666625977,
-0.37786397337913513,
0.9949811100959778,
0.050493061542510986,
0.9330254793167114,
0.16295172274112701,
0.543967068195343,
0.05608530715107918,
0.5258565545082092,
-0.3127192556858063,
0.5003699064254761,
0.1109975054860115,
-0.9444763660430908,
-0.24602346122264862,
-0.6386281251907349,
-0.9833219051361084,
0.2473079264163971,
-0.3389591574668884,
-0.8085558414459229,
0.27482935786247253,
0.23738440871238708,
-0.057336531579494476,
0.303092896938324,
-0.4706363081932068,
0.5512856245040894,
-0.09514006972312927,
-0.7130026817321777,
-0.10541843622922897,
-0.8238435387611389,
0.7650997042655945,
0.03483564779162407,
0.40468892455101013,
-0.30985692143440247,
0.26081952452659607,
0.9682357311248779,
-0.7352673411369324,
1.196711778640747,
-0.06026855856180191,
-0.01924029178917408,
0.5242946147918701,
0.23577359318733215,
0.5119432806968689,
0.320277601480484,
0.053738564252853394,
0.20727838575839996,
-0.016553498804569244,
-0.22845853865146637,
-0.6873137354850769,
0.6108716130256653,
-0.798264741897583,
-0.6874603033065796,
-0.6004291772842407,
-0.47177839279174805,
-0.23449692130088806,
0.30974113941192627,
0.35083022713661194,
0.3551580011844635,
-0.3692404329776764,
-0.21595744788646698,
0.5462847948074341,
-0.04863659664988518,
0.6321346759796143,
0.7802721858024597,
-0.1761784553527832,
-0.36440351605415344,
0.5127409100532532,
0.3016728162765503,
0.27498960494995117,
0.5520600080490112,
0.3035123646259308,
-0.40387657284736633,
-0.38187652826309204,
0.1509738713502884,
0.6715941429138184,
-0.8112714290618896,
0.06118204444646835,
-0.4961271584033966,
-0.1265871524810791,
-0.05694645643234253,
0.07067238539457321,
-0.16006998717784882,
-0.48565077781677246,
-0.49832668900489807,
-0.3097449541091919,
0.35344114899635315,
0.8503100275993347,
-0.1280781328678131,
0.274625301361084,
-0.8326744437217712,
0.5003414154052734,
0.35961413383483887,
-0.14120633900165558,
0.0301480945199728,
-0.5662062168121338,
0.03493855148553848,
-0.06889370083808899,
-0.14163640141487122,
-0.9823399186134338,
0.05836859345436096,
-0.08232253789901733,
0.7908626794815063,
0.6054635047912598,
0.223084956407547,
0.8734965920448303,
-0.7700506448745728,
0.6443497538566589,
0.24315091967582703,
-0.49874311685562134,
0.42231327295303345,
-0.4566435217857361,
-0.06404676288366318,
0.32877859473228455,
0.6592949628829956,
-0.16720403730869293,
-0.47657161951065063,
-0.9497742652893066,
-0.6141586303710938,
0.7076468467712402,
0.152478888630867,
-0.1503983587026596,
-0.4764900803565979,
0.6209248900413513,
0.010549664497375488,
0.30466780066490173,
-0.993216335773468,
-0.6797913908958435,
0.24927979707717896,
0.040243327617645264,
-0.27593162655830383,
-0.5662534236907959,
-0.31644201278686523,
-0.10968014597892761,
0.48713159561157227,
0.3373107314109802,
0.06420659273862839,
0.5703440308570862,
-0.3479507267475128,
-0.1985986977815628,
-0.11915496736764908,
0.6421034932136536,
1.1530702114105225,
-0.20408691465854645,
0.7029992341995239,
0.32783210277557373,
-0.3392593264579773,
0.316859632730484,
-0.020526453852653503,
-0.41968870162963867,
0.10426938533782959,
0.9412268996238708,
0.6377280354499817,
0.5136132836341858,
-0.3179920017719269,
0.2982013523578644,
0.029635122045874596,
-0.1189255341887474,
-0.21546101570129395,
0.016139118000864983,
0.39447030425071716,
0.32009193301200867,
0.14668218791484833,
-0.008017807267606258,
-0.15330515801906586,
-0.7313287854194641,
0.3036489188671112,
0.31613805890083313,
-0.2049974501132965,
-0.44746652245521545,
0.8143106698989868,
-0.0973670557141304,
-0.04205293580889702,
0.46007266640663147,
0.09649181365966797,
-0.2876582145690918,
0.7395296096801758,
0.7934437394142151,
0.4988625943660736,
-0.28598251938819885,
0.05427246540784836,
0.6678106784820557,
0.45648330450057983,
-0.04029529169201851,
0.2599911689758301,
0.20342350006103516,
-0.8409948945045471,
-0.22497111558914185,
-0.2759174108505249,
-0.29907381534576416,
0.09925514459609985,
-0.47488000988960266,
0.19056165218353271,
-0.3202970325946808,
-0.3475736677646637,
-0.21980798244476318,
-0.24199949204921722,
-0.45241284370422363,
0.2525804340839386,
-0.06690014153718948,
0.5163967609405518,
-1.0527948141098022,
0.6396510601043701,
0.2941291630268097,
-0.4412758946418762,
-0.5827746391296387,
-0.09075864404439926,
0.07758702337741852,
-0.7657548189163208,
1.1200090646743774,
-0.016933705657720566,
-0.15646159648895264,
-0.2833388149738312,
-0.37119773030281067,
-0.8374627232551575,
1.103756070137024,
0.6131762266159058,
-0.5800343751907349,
-0.13305652141571045,
0.3263361155986786,
0.384235143661499,
-0.10452291369438171,
0.3183329701423645,
0.3534623980522156,
0.3182576298713684,
0.21358555555343628,
-0.527006983757019,
0.3895021378993988,
0.25015735626220703,
-0.2691350281238556,
0.08694982528686523,
-0.606350839138031,
1.0043810606002808,
-0.5943245887756348,
-0.34467554092407227,
-0.4567003846168518,
0.4939309358596802,
0.5357067584991455,
0.8531069159507751,
0.4185495376586914,
0.5917134284973145,
0.7508344054222107,
0.039681900292634964,
0.9845035672187805,
0.022737089544534683,
0.2598852813243866,
1.4984040260314941,
-0.3269246816635132,
0.48077136278152466,
0.8128313422203064,
-0.5328983664512634,
0.5447462797164917,
0.8106962442398071,
0.2046213448047638,
0.571511447429657,
0.19863975048065186,
-0.021863626316189766,
-0.27192747592926025,
0.18206444382667542,
-0.38489770889282227,
0.027932332828640938,
0.44151878356933594,
-0.5135668516159058,
-0.3053116798400879,
-0.5581466555595398,
0.4117608070373535,
0.007085074670612812,
-0.2299753725528717,
0.7564249038696289,
0.5440189242362976,
-0.6001970171928406,
0.37524110078811646,
-0.4719032049179077,
0.06946326792240143,
-0.5426540374755859,
0.010731407441198826,
-0.21606028079986572,
0.2775428295135498,
-0.31907206773757935,
-0.41541042923927307,
0.49694859981536865,
-0.3309831917285919,
-0.3452235162258148,
0.07052472233772278,
0.5984172821044922,
-0.35478267073631287,
-0.6228621602058411,
0.3832674026489258,
0.782314121723175,
0.09875762462615967,
0.23430374264717102,
-0.42240405082702637,
-0.3901619613170624,
-0.2102237045764923,
-0.4735376834869385,
0.24706068634986877,
0.6721639037132263,
-0.24750180542469025,
0.6110020279884338,
0.5669220685958862,
0.11081277579069138,
0.26235905289649963,
0.06311763823032379,
0.6886783242225647,
-0.8687224984169006,
-0.3764190673828125,
-1.439183235168457,
0.1981414556503296,
0.05814645439386368,
-0.07745662331581116,
1.1008323431015015,
0.3211546540260315,
0.6694883108139038,
-0.19327157735824585,
0.6449335813522339,
0.30828574299812317,
0.5743156671524048,
-0.9243283271789551,
0.6275662183761597,
-0.3978637456893921,
0.38645732402801514,
-0.31516537070274353,
-0.6713199615478516,
-0.28263765573501587,
0.1961754709482193,
-0.7320444583892822,
0.013916381634771824,
1.1432191133499146,
0.62957763671875,
0.12582489848136902,
-0.08155834674835205,
0.1997651904821396,
0.42778897285461426,
0.1806703805923462,
0.6144386529922485,
1.09023916721344,
-0.3447708487510681,
0.4342755079269409,
0.005862201098352671,
0.2159276306629181,
-0.10068480670452118,
-1.0363324880599976,
-1.3053935766220093,
-0.4106496572494507,
-0.5094354748725891,
-0.26028794050216675,
-0.08914437890052795,
0.3094466030597687,
0.2822198271751404,
-0.5625250935554504,
-0.14112670719623566,
-0.36419355869293213,
0.8124717473983765,
0.11475583165884018,
-0.19929930567741394,
0.4304032623767853,
-0.1324041336774826,
-0.30419936776161194,
0.17111334204673767,
0.06246011331677437,
0.3852187693119049,
0.22511599957942963,
0.021250851452350616,
-0.45134416222572327,
0.2199256420135498,
0.5116739273071289,
0.13282400369644165,
-0.6091557741165161,
-0.3332098722457886,
-0.3207401633262634,
-0.07221542298793793,
-0.01963495835661888,
1.0674914121627808,
-0.6981552839279175,
0.11377999186515808,
0.5993068218231201,
0.14776700735092163,
0.5701612830162048,
0.0014676814898848534,
0.44291797280311584,
-0.6293123960494995,
0.27955642342567444,
-0.1973189115524292,
0.5542404651641846,
0.14349104464054108,
-0.3833068609237671,
0.4802556037902832,
0.8488637208938599,
-0.5197112560272217,
-0.8123816251754761,
0.3985752761363983,
-0.5284092426300049,
-0.38955986499786377,
0.9909749031066895,
-0.3652207553386688,
-0.3922761082649231,
-0.19222775101661682,
0.14510196447372437,
0.4854111075401306,
0.17647337913513184,
0.7162185907363892,
0.717345654964447,
-0.502528727054596,
0.09199125319719315,
-0.6561518907546997,
0.5513205528259277,
0.15922409296035767,
-0.8039622902870178,
0.024860799312591553,
0.551150381565094,
0.4174864888191223,
0.04825349152088165,
0.9193860292434692,
0.018896745517849922,
0.13456608355045319,
0.215498149394989,
-0.48527786135673523,
-0.022505681961774826,
-0.13906729221343994,
0.18325099349021912,
-0.019153239205479622,
-0.006039865780621767,
-0.10968942195177078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15487v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15487v1
|
Improving Text-To-Audio Models with Synthetic Captions
| 2024-06-18T00:02:15 | 2024-06-18T00:02:15 |
Zhifeng Kong, Sang-gil Lee, Deepanway Ghosal, Navonil Majumder, Ambuj Mehrish, Rafael Valle, Soujanya Poria, Bryan Catanzaro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
It is an open challenge to obtain high quality training data, especially
captions, for text-to-audio models. Although prior methods have leveraged
\textit{text-only language models} to augment and improve captions, such
methods have limitations related to scale and coherence between audio and
captions. In this work, we propose an audio captioning pipeline that uses an
\textit{audio language model} to synthesize accurate and diverse captions for
audio at scale. We leverage this pipeline to produce a dataset of synthetic
captions for AudioSet, named \texttt{AF-AudioSet}, and then evaluate the
benefit of pre-training text-to-audio models on these synthetic captions.
Through systematic evaluations on AudioCaps and MusicCaps, we find leveraging
our pipeline and synthetic captions leads to significant improvements on audio
generation quality, achieving a new \textit{state-of-the-art}.
|
[
-0.5046629309654236,
-0.44157874584198,
0.3566000461578369,
0.14753055572509766,
-0.33231621980667114,
0.5246297717094421,
-0.3254702687263489,
-0.44631218910217285,
0.4886874556541443,
0.4838159680366516,
-0.92286616563797,
-0.41230812668800354,
-0.4747801721096039,
0.29066380858421326,
-0.7289878726005554,
1.003741979598999,
-0.0013560655061155558,
0.25585922598838806,
-0.12196606397628784,
-0.1887131929397583,
-0.8744749426841736,
-0.18768657743930817,
-0.6921050548553467,
0.040361564606428146,
0.17610540986061096,
0.4855077266693115,
0.5052534341812134,
0.6784992218017578,
0.49696382880210876,
0.1607777625322342,
0.1819458305835724,
0.3790584206581116,
-0.18674474954605103,
0.2265423983335495,
0.09283550083637238,
-0.2052699327468872,
-0.5418288707733154,
0.27586060762405396,
0.637528657913208,
0.4871615171432495,
-0.07993031293153763,
0.24662645161151886,
-0.30723223090171814,
0.4590553045272827,
-0.2397899329662323,
0.1599315106868744,
-0.6955268979072571,
0.15721075236797333,
0.10847961157560349,
-0.463598370552063,
-0.48471909761428833,
0.0873817577958107,
0.33424022793769836,
-0.9286304116249084,
0.5248262882232666,
0.5812419652938843,
0.7383338212966919,
0.45839303731918335,
-0.15503409504890442,
-0.22139154374599457,
-0.9602852463722229,
0.7394747138023376,
-0.7532861828804016,
0.599198043346405,
0.14634214341640472,
0.7345882654190063,
0.39483919739723206,
-0.9918414354324341,
-0.568426787853241,
-0.27149131894111633,
0.024166930466890335,
0.13731297850608826,
0.07167478650808334,
0.033908914774656296,
0.2075360268354416,
0.92140793800354,
-0.2795933783054352,
-0.1076917052268982,
-0.5033215880393982,
-0.3451729118824005,
0.8608742356300354,
-0.05981786176562309,
0.6456801891326904,
0.06945012509822845,
-0.30448558926582336,
-0.43422365188598633,
-0.6988039016723633,
-0.23800599575042725,
0.49261680245399475,
0.5338137745857239,
-0.3319884240627289,
0.6792818903923035,
-0.13129922747612,
0.4445524513721466,
0.17511792480945587,
0.24217896163463593,
0.346760630607605,
-0.6396733522415161,
-0.15630783140659332,
0.2711790204048157,
0.7881600856781006,
0.3526531755924225,
0.37707027792930603,
-0.40189480781555176,
-0.38955795764923096,
0.12015987187623978,
0.38556376099586487,
-0.5899261832237244,
-0.48463162779808044,
0.42359521985054016,
-0.14309494197368622,
-0.26598280668258667,
0.1901434063911438,
-0.5902659893035889,
-0.16947004199028015,
-0.826484739780426,
0.6999523639678955,
-0.3361917734146118,
-0.24466979503631592,
0.009096297435462475,
-0.38212326169013977,
-0.09357713162899017,
0.03533640131354332,
-1.0205161571502686,
0.3456329107284546,
0.32910504937171936,
0.8971114158630371,
-0.28512752056121826,
0.036725450307130814,
-0.9721705913543701,
0.19631949067115784,
-0.28320273756980896,
0.8241565823554993,
-0.3443846106529236,
-0.18414953351020813,
0.10261718183755875,
-0.2961215376853943,
0.2750455141067505,
-0.6258611083030701,
0.4853488504886627,
-0.20687708258628845,
0.3627040684223175,
0.002380714751780033,
-0.5970078706741333,
0.057276103645563126,
-0.039797890931367874,
-0.9427334070205688,
0.7991595268249512,
0.03891860321164131,
-0.4776659607887268,
0.5631711483001709,
-0.9954870343208313,
-0.6055134534835815,
-0.1376301795244217,
0.016320768743753433,
-0.5534836053848267,
0.15058286488056183,
0.7540614008903503,
0.33251121640205383,
-0.3183787763118744,
0.39030545949935913,
0.02460819110274315,
-0.4291171431541443,
0.23907753825187683,
-0.4992339313030243,
0.32889237999916077,
0.18949933350086212,
-0.06704527139663696,
0.31952956318855286,
-0.9387828707695007,
-0.17498096823692322,
-0.06906064599752426,
-0.13705119490623474,
-0.015417000278830528,
-0.03180215507745743,
0.5658266544342041,
-0.19822952151298523,
-0.11995392292737961,
-0.6808715462684631,
-0.24406488239765167,
-0.6979109644889832,
0.9068567752838135,
0.44137337803840637,
0.03228187933564186,
0.8577912449836731,
-0.6131526827812195,
0.5410996675491333,
-0.218193918466568,
-0.09734288603067398,
-0.6322593688964844,
-0.17506326735019684,
-0.6509996652603149,
-0.7032161951065063,
0.5317776799201965,
0.371019184589386,
-0.43440937995910645,
0.5395628213882446,
-0.40002354979515076,
-0.459238737821579,
-0.7928736209869385,
-0.1049942672252655,
-0.012873389758169651,
0.20369312167167664,
0.6315597295761108,
-0.48769673705101013,
-0.8379946351051331,
-0.7537142038345337,
-0.23922744393348694,
-0.0052412450313568115,
-0.4279264211654663,
0.3347815275192261,
0.09431169927120209,
-0.20474733412265778,
1.328006386756897,
-0.2388543337583542,
-0.4283141493797302,
-0.03989099711179733,
0.23105427622795105,
0.06175120919942856,
0.7277565598487854,
0.4789282977581024,
-0.7469452619552612,
-0.3674181401729584,
-0.23743069171905518,
-0.4326689541339874,
-0.20510032773017883,
-0.2809910178184509,
-0.14488744735717773,
-0.14856477081775665,
0.7520520091056824,
-0.657400906085968,
-0.24051658809185028,
0.6546005010604858,
-0.03272010013461113,
0.6353642344474792,
0.14077657461166382,
0.22599609196186066,
-1.1643329858779907,
0.02825894206762314,
-0.17940892279148102,
-0.47265681624412537,
-0.5863413214683533,
-0.11633524298667908,
-0.33932244777679443,
-0.4952079951763153,
-0.5396807789802551,
0.6410703659057617,
-0.4416169226169586,
-0.2950729727745056,
-0.07264280319213867,
0.16756010055541992,
0.12015503644943237,
0.3948763310909271,
0.3353351652622223,
0.861154317855835,
0.6167613863945007,
-0.18880918622016907,
0.5100703239440918,
0.45385828614234924,
-0.492292582988739,
0.43181243538856506,
-0.6279420852661133,
0.12175409495830536,
-0.03954390063881874,
0.36324912309646606,
-1.2289220094680786,
-0.407439649105072,
-0.05358467996120453,
-0.6757680177688599,
0.5347920656204224,
0.04685557633638382,
-0.588117778301239,
-0.08034363389015198,
-0.09258817136287689,
0.5946139693260193,
0.37855544686317444,
-0.7105228900909424,
0.7362780570983887,
0.35452088713645935,
-0.3116501271724701,
-0.15810972452163696,
-0.6021327376365662,
0.24703143537044525,
-0.33977848291397095,
-0.5437898635864258,
0.43893709778785706,
-0.14774399995803833,
-0.0006559034809470177,
-0.2745104134082794,
-0.3310823440551758,
-0.35669514536857605,
-0.3567490577697754,
0.090475894510746,
0.17579399049282074,
-0.3352358937263489,
0.2855112850666046,
0.4688679277896881,
-0.006455067545175552,
0.20755521953105927,
-0.4971248507499695,
0.49167370796203613,
0.16510994732379913,
-0.0372990220785141,
-0.5647016167640686,
0.37131595611572266,
0.6570960879325867,
-0.5916204452514648,
0.30348774790763855,
0.43515124917030334,
-0.23181870579719543,
-0.40596383810043335,
-0.4994626045227051,
-0.7857725620269775,
-0.4855920374393463,
0.3121229410171509,
-0.1095099076628685,
-0.8767269849777222,
0.2784692049026489,
-0.08810108155012131,
0.36259377002716064,
0.3646779954433441,
0.2524128258228302,
-0.5055379867553711,
1.0062059164047241,
0.28434962034225464,
0.15932923555374146,
0.6521459817886353,
-0.5488051176071167,
0.09975611418485641,
-0.6061991453170776,
-0.02833518013358116,
-0.36066341400146484,
-0.22995586693286896,
-0.5288071632385254,
-0.42410510778427124,
0.27464956045150757,
-0.418712854385376,
-0.4679963290691376,
0.7095761299133301,
-0.5162026882171631,
0.428645521402359,
0.6139351725578308,
0.20559290051460266,
0.36555299162864685,
0.5958526134490967,
0.09885619580745697,
-0.06797522306442261,
-0.7829179167747498,
-0.27067482471466064,
1.2884116172790527,
0.6173774003982544,
0.45536816120147705,
-0.08880215883255005,
0.6142022013664246,
0.6568595170974731,
0.3308955430984497,
-0.7531687617301941,
0.154418483376503,
-0.29817861318588257,
-0.8262012600898743,
-0.6052734851837158,
-0.36124005913734436,
-0.4855901896953583,
-0.016695646569132805,
-0.5923498868942261,
-0.17285166680812836,
-0.16587379574775696,
0.17864179611206055,
-0.3350384533405304,
0.08685730397701263,
-0.5486516952514648,
0.8471558690071106,
0.025341207161545753,
0.00932257529348135,
-0.01618216186761856,
-0.5811435580253601,
0.09508568793535233,
-0.22330717742443085,
0.3817102015018463,
-0.07525663077831268,
0.22466909885406494,
0.6847582459449768,
-0.4594477713108063,
0.6208415031433105,
-0.03178931400179863,
-0.2202165573835373,
0.6777751445770264,
0.034941304475069046,
0.2318691909313202,
0.22931568324565887,
0.23613907396793365,
0.3707306981086731,
0.006349295377731323,
-0.26161259412765503,
-0.5516570806503296,
0.3886042535305023,
-0.7347404360771179,
-0.2723923623561859,
-0.10098890215158463,
-0.9828362464904785,
-0.5177345275878906,
0.07392321527004242,
0.37556543946266174,
0.7428054213523865,
-0.08563858270645142,
0.32107123732566833,
0.5165542364120483,
-0.33114752173423767,
0.46838676929473877,
0.22337986528873444,
-0.013081671670079231,
-0.8871456384658813,
0.7839604020118713,
-0.19328546524047852,
0.5505703687667847,
0.5835933089256287,
0.10953212529420853,
-0.6591852307319641,
-0.522123396396637,
-0.6754008531570435,
0.16546836495399475,
-0.3707909882068634,
-0.18821607530117035,
-0.5204228758811951,
-0.24817772209644318,
-0.4254910349845886,
-0.02944149263203144,
-0.7481902837753296,
-0.6545665860176086,
-0.21282126009464264,
-0.33011043071746826,
0.503951907157898,
0.0935579389333725,
-0.14536768198013306,
0.6287881731987,
-1.0843297243118286,
0.5221393704414368,
0.31869181990623474,
0.2646277844905853,
-0.28667354583740234,
-0.7464994788169861,
-0.2947827875614166,
0.263231098651886,
-0.03711851313710213,
-0.5777400732040405,
0.45939749479293823,
0.45380479097366333,
0.16468580067157745,
0.049613479524850845,
0.15503863990306854,
0.30204397439956665,
-0.7960377931594849,
0.7936962842941284,
0.4379286766052246,
-1.0048414468765259,
0.6032707691192627,
-0.7369232177734375,
0.23584994673728943,
0.6061214208602905,
-0.11416973173618317,
-0.36586207151412964,
-0.673407256603241,
-0.39936158061027527,
-0.8768338561058044,
0.4376569092273712,
0.716269850730896,
0.6005170345306396,
0.13276222348213196,
0.23232585191726685,
0.17371176183223724,
0.44169968366622925,
-0.9049932360649109,
-0.07152865827083588,
-0.572645902633667,
-0.5104358792304993,
-0.23833920061588287,
0.19301708042621613,
-0.10607190430164337,
-0.1283528208732605,
0.7485364675521851,
-0.14556051790714264,
0.27461549639701843,
0.12708638608455658,
0.10656259208917618,
-0.271885484457016,
0.20404145121574402,
0.3937722146511078,
0.2515096664428711,
-0.26688820123672485,
-0.10681496560573578,
0.11436629295349121,
-0.3791493773460388,
0.35260167717933655,
0.037491682916879654,
0.026463782414793968,
0.12191858142614365,
0.5087860822677612,
0.9433117508888245,
0.10866592824459076,
-0.9502126574516296,
0.3552300035953522,
0.11407048255205154,
-0.24438902735710144,
-0.6011558175086975,
0.039110030978918076,
-0.012869196012616158,
-0.0514410100877285,
0.2751903533935547,
0.38971981406211853,
0.2522050738334656,
-0.5603503584861755,
0.4265696108341217,
0.040194086730480194,
-0.5817946195602417,
0.008867728523910046,
0.9746524095535278,
0.520348310470581,
-0.37746280431747437,
0.613817572593689,
0.3598824441432953,
-0.015520735643804073,
0.6005690097808838,
0.4316014051437378,
1.0167852640151978,
-0.07190723717212677,
0.09626514464616776,
0.5746524930000305,
0.266928106546402,
-0.13034819066524506,
0.04313354939222336,
-0.2667253911495209,
-0.5359205007553101,
-0.8068758249282837,
-0.6596723198890686,
-0.48984065651893616,
0.13951978087425232,
-0.5252718329429626,
0.51520174741745,
-0.39436569809913635,
-0.09990806877613068,
-0.09663205593824387,
-0.40710872411727905,
-0.3874853849411011,
0.6724978089332581,
-0.004124846775084734,
0.86453777551651,
-1.0887361764907837,
0.3842654228210449,
0.5833863019943237,
-0.609769880771637,
-0.8118094205856323,
-0.01700272597372532,
-0.4202468991279602,
-0.23749035596847534,
0.2547098994255066,
0.40694499015808105,
0.09744010120630264,
0.1317393034696579,
-0.6733190417289734,
-0.7787535786628723,
0.9019057750701904,
0.3466043472290039,
-0.9659562706947327,
-0.03754820674657822,
0.586406409740448,
0.7235044240951538,
-0.6753441095352173,
-0.13766157627105713,
0.4666564166545868,
0.4370042085647583,
0.17543677985668182,
-0.9092022776603699,
-0.2758241891860962,
-0.11031730473041534,
-0.2899920642375946,
0.02841012179851532,
-0.22889064252376556,
0.5435791611671448,
0.03336869180202484,
-0.1427270472049713,
0.29848846793174744,
0.8367617726325989,
0.3629445433616638,
0.4110250473022461,
0.7784115076065063,
0.47875475883483887,
0.2260553389787674,
-0.29418736696243286,
1.0235469341278076,
-0.1434493213891983,
0.2101234346628189,
1.323848009109497,
0.14235487580299377,
0.8141773343086243,
0.4884210228919983,
0.0025391618255525827,
0.34273919463157654,
0.6617152690887451,
-0.24306458234786987,
0.7399654388427734,
0.3877086341381073,
-0.24024583399295807,
-0.43309006094932556,
-0.13196103274822235,
0.007056036032736301,
0.5278642773628235,
0.023255791515111923,
-0.5263878107070923,
0.2599713206291199,
0.2368306964635849,
-0.4694075584411621,
0.4218057692050934,
-0.10295022279024124,
0.6622210741043091,
0.060790061950683594,
-0.4827747344970703,
0.3176005184650421,
-0.28441932797431946,
0.5431906580924988,
-0.2661386728286743,
-0.13139700889587402,
-0.03353190794587135,
-0.2545802891254425,
-0.0463343970477581,
-0.441333532333374,
0.376274049282074,
0.15909676253795624,
-0.5201302766799927,
-0.20362338423728943,
0.2681311368942261,
-0.8714606761932373,
-0.5677952170372009,
0.11191646754741669,
0.1925683170557022,
0.05100467801094055,
-0.315173476934433,
-0.21253445744514465,
-0.08589468896389008,
-0.17815124988555908,
0.24780552089214325,
-0.24797582626342773,
0.1458440124988556,
0.10809314250946045,
0.37771111726760864,
0.9390325546264648,
0.27405038475990295,
0.0007093584863469005,
0.43770459294319153,
0.3848974108695984,
-0.28770196437835693,
-0.7327717542648315,
-0.4536302089691162,
0.711493968963623,
-0.05593554303050041,
0.1217740848660469,
0.28705617785453796,
0.791322648525238,
0.916771411895752,
-0.49500635266304016,
0.9844913482666016,
0.1142139881849289,
0.7694758176803589,
-0.676067590713501,
0.8800827264785767,
-0.6929799318313599,
0.3354705572128296,
-0.3919063210487366,
-1.376552700996399,
-0.3254048824310303,
0.3998534083366394,
0.1843227744102478,
0.032674893736839294,
0.4560542702674866,
0.7989664077758789,
-0.45033836364746094,
0.23832783102989197,
0.13024328649044037,
0.1502619832754135,
0.3894420862197876,
0.17886291444301605,
0.81610107421875,
-0.88729327917099,
0.7274525165557861,
-0.14883337914943695,
0.06331419199705124,
0.14524079859256744,
-0.8801053762435913,
-0.871903121471405,
-0.6611740589141846,
-0.6542339324951172,
-0.15727534890174866,
0.028337348252534866,
0.894611656665802,
1.027780294418335,
-1.1770864725112915,
-0.19988225400447845,
-0.4124850034713745,
-0.45053476095199585,
-0.31388041377067566,
-0.2526315152645111,
0.26014697551727295,
-0.25510889291763306,
-1.0891000032424927,
0.6745379567146301,
-0.01580425538122654,
0.2831144630908966,
-0.19154764711856842,
-0.22542521357536316,
0.18643313646316528,
0.4480553865432739,
0.6050682067871094,
0.10049428045749664,
-0.5432772040367126,
-0.45288407802581787,
-0.019698455929756165,
0.282981276512146,
0.14546775817871094,
0.7940260767936707,
-0.36215740442276,
0.7125828266143799,
0.45475083589553833,
0.5700704455375671,
0.7115903496742249,
-0.11759398132562637,
1.0353795289993286,
-1.2045152187347412,
-0.026639148592948914,
0.21818746626377106,
0.17697098851203918,
0.6636529564857483,
0.026581158861517906,
0.5774917006492615,
0.15781505405902863,
-0.32318341732025146,
-0.9169507026672363,
-0.038813162595033646,
-1.2185478210449219,
0.09285112470388412,
1.1535924673080444,
0.09252814948558807,
0.3096212148666382,
0.27140310406684875,
-0.5830886960029602,
0.6187808513641357,
-0.534863293170929,
0.8227784633636475,
0.5885891914367676,
0.2638314366340637,
-0.3083045482635498,
-0.4730430245399475,
0.6908292770385742,
0.34310227632522583,
-0.7499324679374695,
0.11583097279071808,
0.7871774435043335,
0.27554550766944885,
0.2887004017829895,
0.11077935248613358,
-0.2079053372144699,
0.4969184696674347,
0.02552935853600502,
-0.021435679867863655,
-0.3994455933570862,
-0.6400324106216431,
-0.019438453018665314,
-0.010270830243825912,
-0.25516462326049805,
-0.4457458257675171
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12141v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12141v1
|
A dual task learning approach to fine-tune a multilingual semantic speech encoder for Spoken Language Understanding
| 2024-06-17T23:07:53 | 2024-06-17T23:07:53 |
Gaëlle Laperrière, Sahar Ghannay, Bassam Jabaian, Yannick Estève
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Self-Supervised Learning is vastly used to efficiently represent speech for
Spoken Language Understanding, gradually replacing conventional approaches.
Meanwhile, textual SSL models are proposed to encode language-agnostic
semantics. SAMU-XLSR framework employed this semantic information to enrich
multilingual speech representations. A recent study investigated SAMU-XLSR
in-domain semantic enrichment by specializing it on downstream transcriptions,
leading to state-of-the-art results on a challenging SLU task. This study's
interest lies in the loss of multilingual performances and lack of
specific-semantics training induced by such specialization in close languages
without any SLU implication. We also consider SAMU-XLSR's loss of initial
cross-lingual abilities due to a separate SLU fine-tuning. Therefore, this
paper proposes a dual task learning approach to improve SAMU-XLSR semantic
enrichment while considering distant languages for multilingual and language
portability experiments.
|
[
-0.14695002138614655,
-0.5047366619110107,
0.41120925545692444,
-0.17609848082065582,
-0.39602699875831604,
0.17445708811283112,
-0.4737820327281952,
-0.5914136171340942,
0.11373800039291382,
0.5007254481315613,
-0.7458643913269043,
-0.24911801517009735,
-0.6758849024772644,
0.14245107769966125,
0.19865655899047852,
0.9058490991592407,
0.04984765499830246,
0.42779088020324707,
-0.1670318841934204,
-0.35096660256385803,
-0.45508232712745667,
-0.3929451107978821,
-0.7933189868927002,
-0.17815150320529938,
0.4282016158103943,
0.4871382415294647,
0.4441739618778229,
0.4292331337928772,
0.14524632692337036,
0.2828728258609772,
-0.12796145677566528,
0.3168676197528839,
-0.39185309410095215,
0.2689428925514221,
-0.5058842301368713,
-0.4568820595741272,
-0.12047027796506882,
-0.35138389468193054,
0.9510008692741394,
0.529569149017334,
0.08283887058496475,
0.35054275393486023,
0.19572113454341888,
0.46152955293655396,
-0.5516983270645142,
0.4381712079048157,
-0.8780019283294678,
0.01722467876970768,
-0.2937600314617157,
0.005113440100103617,
-0.40684783458709717,
0.32215169072151184,
-0.10673241317272186,
-0.4622690975666046,
0.11245490610599518,
-0.4517311453819275,
0.79250168800354,
0.6244895458221436,
-0.7043271660804749,
-0.27072030305862427,
-0.632818877696991,
1.012244701385498,
-0.471819132566452,
0.8994148373603821,
0.38923314213752747,
0.21019022166728973,
0.23481158912181854,
-0.44074952602386475,
-0.33451008796691895,
-0.18331779539585114,
-0.3393821120262146,
0.27201515436172485,
-0.03611517325043678,
-0.04495302960276604,
0.0017279167659580708,
0.05871296674013138,
-0.6549758911132812,
0.16519205272197723,
-0.3868291676044464,
-0.20161885023117065,
0.6486807465553284,
0.011272873729467392,
0.3360012471675873,
-0.23093119263648987,
-0.3248368799686432,
0.012257016263902187,
-0.5176701545715332,
0.17669327557086945,
0.2715061902999878,
0.7285338044166565,
-0.10344868153333664,
0.357021301984787,
-0.07962064445018768,
0.5956844091415405,
-0.015705911442637444,
-0.3068147301673889,
0.45623666048049927,
-0.6452412605285645,
-0.0373275987803936,
0.2667393386363983,
0.40231597423553467,
-0.21647930145263672,
-0.19919513165950775,
-0.41944122314453125,
-0.08361129462718964,
0.2779722809791565,
0.16691507399082184,
-0.39763143658638,
0.19163984060287476,
0.13708744943141937,
-0.19931316375732422,
0.2988962233066559,
-0.027453329414129257,
-0.30907610058784485,
0.16434040665626526,
-0.8687992095947266,
0.5361939668655396,
-0.405739426612854,
-0.5076556205749512,
-0.005067203659564257,
-0.02262960374355316,
-0.026604823768138885,
0.000047303874453064054,
-0.80538010597229,
0.30428263545036316,
0.6846580505371094,
0.5766183137893677,
-0.12409057468175888,
-0.5408067107200623,
-0.9108998775482178,
0.5182429552078247,
0.1492132544517517,
0.46603792905807495,
-0.5621414184570312,
-0.26481106877326965,
-0.3094378113746643,
0.25848764181137085,
-0.3337799310684204,
-0.3476497530937195,
0.5376449823379517,
-0.36442768573760986,
-0.14151979982852936,
-0.15793411433696747,
-0.3298841714859009,
-0.22289228439331055,
-0.27181363105773926,
-0.45765915513038635,
0.9108555912971497,
0.050874724984169006,
-0.5817214250564575,
0.5591429471969604,
-0.4939205050468445,
-0.7272244691848755,
0.15300743281841278,
-0.3966546654701233,
-0.34259167313575745,
0.015908313915133476,
0.0767916664481163,
0.55423504114151,
0.1822541058063507,
0.3643127381801605,
-0.024485575035214424,
-0.34844085574150085,
0.01929817907512188,
-0.06362968683242798,
0.6600399613380432,
0.37757229804992676,
-0.4968971312046051,
0.1635512113571167,
-0.6573464274406433,
0.19320791959762573,
-0.08739471435546875,
0.0483415387570858,
-0.6130358576774597,
-0.12178774923086166,
0.0706699937582016,
0.4653652608394623,
0.3294471204280853,
-0.8530712127685547,
-0.48723772168159485,
-0.39075401425361633,
0.609303891658783,
0.5301384329795837,
-0.3454711437225342,
0.43987587094306946,
0.017955085262656212,
0.3152465224266052,
0.24007254838943481,
-0.07741779088973999,
-0.013651198707520962,
-0.20548808574676514,
-0.7095751762390137,
-0.22252009809017181,
0.14958959817886353,
0.6832217574119568,
-0.6378540396690369,
0.40182140469551086,
-0.39155903458595276,
-0.2594897150993347,
-1.0051095485687256,
0.3582296073436737,
0.7445057034492493,
0.28781455755233765,
0.5970628261566162,
-0.15870504081249237,
-0.6262325644493103,
-1.0129250288009644,
-0.31502851843833923,
0.1547345221042633,
0.16284091770648956,
0.3161659836769104,
0.3790188431739807,
-0.4962040185928345,
0.7942453026771545,
-0.10248198360204697,
-0.6593925356864929,
-0.4645141661167145,
0.07459466904401779,
-0.16241012513637543,
0.5509704947471619,
0.11843524873256683,
-1.0505422353744507,
-0.6419253349304199,
0.3710233271121979,
-0.5980734825134277,
0.2619263529777527,
-0.19442251324653625,
-0.08670129626989365,
0.3621416389942169,
0.4032176733016968,
-0.5486719608306885,
0.3437473773956299,
0.5786236524581909,
-0.14482007920742035,
0.2636301517486572,
-0.4475259482860565,
0.14746975898742676,
-1.039955496788025,
-0.11591906100511551,
-0.043050527572631836,
-0.2767944633960724,
-0.8015468716621399,
0.34218427538871765,
0.37561726570129395,
-0.22441832721233368,
-0.40030041337013245,
0.3906177878379822,
-0.5273370742797852,
-0.1721552461385727,
-0.31516048312187195,
0.510372519493103,
-0.08568207174539566,
0.40852901339530945,
0.46199530363082886,
0.8482359647750854,
0.7098919153213501,
-0.4602477252483368,
-0.01901664026081562,
0.1760353147983551,
-0.0142833786085248,
0.4288804829120636,
-0.4690645933151245,
0.15359008312225342,
-0.39355435967445374,
0.0832793265581131,
-0.8937134742736816,
0.031018320471048355,
0.1168704554438591,
-0.4142201840877533,
0.7277611494064331,
-0.25170794129371643,
-0.3121207654476166,
-0.073267363011837,
0.184905543923378,
0.39578795433044434,
0.3921853303909302,
-0.5221617221832275,
0.634268581867218,
0.5518105626106262,
-0.2767932116985321,
-0.7016147375106812,
-1.062320590019226,
0.01641058549284935,
-0.18527348339557648,
-0.63362056016922,
0.41541850566864014,
0.09135080873966217,
-0.1283530592918396,
0.02910344861447811,
-0.16028918325901031,
0.08692251145839691,
-0.1908065229654312,
0.3011666536331177,
-0.04789319634437561,
-0.2366591840982437,
0.34036481380462646,
0.5148329138755798,
-0.3847346603870392,
-0.03893672674894333,
-0.4268449544906616,
0.18002545833587646,
-0.28769606351852417,
-0.41099438071250916,
-0.7847262620925903,
0.5878656506538391,
0.12842418253421783,
-0.5289416909217834,
0.7482413649559021,
0.7826926112174988,
-0.04588055983185768,
-0.09973068535327911,
-0.6025280356407166,
-0.13302825391292572,
-0.4447490870952606,
0.3681085407733917,
-0.9472141861915588,
-1.1378501653671265,
0.3694927394390106,
0.017981691285967827,
-0.09625563025474548,
0.4234907329082489,
0.3579994738101959,
0.1921636313199997,
0.7733438014984131,
0.5921347141265869,
0.018198950216174126,
0.17595863342285156,
-0.19487227499485016,
0.12066152691841125,
-0.7383354902267456,
-0.1646522432565689,
-0.4443804919719696,
0.0505661703646183,
-0.6163592338562012,
-0.5401614308357239,
0.16550900042057037,
-0.20942287147045135,
-0.07566240429878235,
0.5632254481315613,
-0.2672612965106964,
0.2046179473400116,
0.4920385479927063,
0.33023375272750854,
0.3029279410839081,
0.044860292226076126,
-0.24332286417484283,
-0.21446476876735687,
-0.6029189229011536,
-0.3430650234222412,
0.6960490345954895,
0.20634205639362335,
0.5310516953468323,
0.16119277477264404,
0.9985525608062744,
-0.007056318689137697,
-0.3995738625526428,
-0.42781516909599304,
0.42723584175109863,
-0.5434916019439697,
-0.3078508973121643,
-0.6109327673912048,
-0.6253171563148499,
-0.8899974822998047,
0.6076425909996033,
0.10710360109806061,
-0.610532283782959,
-0.02354378253221512,
0.10662506520748138,
-0.12395912408828735,
0.2224174439907074,
-0.7916092276573181,
1.0172960758209229,
-0.29919713735580444,
-0.3649364411830902,
-0.6666945815086365,
-1.0444625616073608,
0.013470863923430443,
-0.16869288682937622,
0.5920352935791016,
-0.05256097391247749,
-0.16336973011493683,
0.48294660449028015,
0.05440463870763779,
0.9503535628318787,
-0.32177239656448364,
-0.24404992163181305,
-0.015528665855526924,
-0.20541812479496002,
0.3844415545463562,
0.2662557065486908,
-0.04890873283147812,
0.16559632122516632,
0.11216401308774948,
-0.5120264291763306,
-0.4016956388950348,
0.8137222528457642,
-0.7840113043785095,
-0.45432496070861816,
-0.265026718378067,
-0.4379168152809143,
-0.29508814215660095,
0.04462600499391556,
0.17898523807525635,
0.5293383598327637,
-0.013002138584852219,
-0.12950251996517181,
0.688792884349823,
-0.04708154872059822,
0.1555449217557907,
0.5696377754211426,
0.20210382342338562,
-0.19967326521873474,
1.062696099281311,
0.06225334852933884,
0.5729870796203613,
0.6386286616325378,
0.04505746811628342,
-0.3995736837387085,
-0.45027104020118713,
-0.7559619545936584,
0.5107491612434387,
-0.6912515163421631,
0.006929205730557442,
-0.7541112303733826,
-0.13344848155975342,
-0.6623463034629822,
0.13842326402664185,
-0.3873271644115448,
-0.33544960618019104,
-0.5211726427078247,
-0.03164805471897125,
0.15406443178653717,
0.5420738458633423,
-0.25944405794143677,
0.059676069766283035,
-0.9452961087226868,
0.3777083158493042,
0.0976216271519661,
0.161554753780365,
-0.11656033247709274,
-0.7147766351699829,
-0.3381815254688263,
0.42960408329963684,
0.1995866894721985,
-0.5503161549568176,
0.1798275262117386,
0.5705210566520691,
0.7893672585487366,
0.2585712969303131,
0.04745587334036827,
1.063598394393921,
-0.6198441386222839,
0.6990821361541748,
0.1278211921453476,
-1.065384030342102,
0.8174920082092285,
-0.0065154111944139,
0.5849950313568115,
0.6550648212432861,
0.513572633266449,
-0.6196051836013794,
-0.6192821264266968,
-0.5215501189231873,
-0.5421006083488464,
0.9141760468482971,
0.07525505870580673,
0.1419016718864441,
0.09794562309980392,
0.2693055272102356,
0.5571740865707397,
-0.18931844830513,
-0.7199059128761292,
-0.3441820740699768,
-0.22016239166259766,
0.010667956434190273,
-0.42092230916023254,
-0.29078030586242676,
0.12736009061336517,
-0.30127623677253723,
0.9167245030403137,
-0.11673279851675034,
-0.003907057922333479,
0.054642800241708755,
-0.5338823199272156,
-0.17872454226016998,
0.5771413445472717,
0.4656359851360321,
0.5970079898834229,
0.14909562468528748,
0.19704429805278778,
0.33169710636138916,
-0.40906548500061035,
0.08809195458889008,
0.40590032935142517,
-0.11704842001199722,
0.050405826419591904,
0.1032504066824913,
1.027913212776184,
0.5332118272781372,
-0.7532033324241638,
0.2562256157398224,
-0.0646471381187439,
-0.022338103502988815,
-0.41432157158851624,
-0.06811916828155518,
0.07225315272808075,
0.14879560470581055,
0.25260186195373535,
0.02751452848315239,
0.166825070977211,
-0.4825500249862671,
0.3665945827960968,
0.638533353805542,
-0.5329951643943787,
-0.23246361315250397,
0.6084191203117371,
-0.06643246859312057,
0.1246466264128685,
0.2744767963886261,
-0.5318974852561951,
-0.35983484983444214,
0.22079098224639893,
0.6797114014625549,
0.6519094109535217,
-0.5593586564064026,
0.18935047090053558,
0.35062387585639954,
0.09509662538766861,
0.2847907245159149,
0.29604360461235046,
-0.5132742524147034,
-0.5160920023918152,
-0.6893210411071777,
-0.6392508149147034,
-0.11672192066907883,
-0.15772153437137604,
-0.8846265077590942,
0.2590477764606476,
0.3472089469432831,
-0.08115226775407791,
0.08787038922309875,
-0.07130002230405807,
-0.49862930178642273,
0.20274238288402557,
0.22006505727767944,
0.4074896574020386,
-0.7035527229309082,
1.1850115060806274,
0.8981464505195618,
-0.24738462269306183,
-0.6673518419265747,
-0.19955919682979584,
-0.10845797508955002,
-0.6166994571685791,
1.1009674072265625,
0.14125896990299225,
-0.672282874584198,
-0.01674332469701767,
0.24547627568244934,
-1.0824273824691772,
0.9746185541152954,
0.39829736948013306,
-0.5237327814102173,
0.030630061402916908,
0.4762251377105713,
0.4450390040874481,
-0.11328946053981781,
0.08310628682374954,
0.44337305426597595,
0.1621502935886383,
0.12991559505462646,
-1.1919136047363281,
-0.06178837642073631,
-0.047148093581199646,
0.10688062757253647,
0.4672461152076721,
-0.6407630443572998,
0.44131335616111755,
-0.25255048274993896,
-0.3535158038139343,
0.054226383566856384,
0.8987549543380737,
-0.18754319846630096,
0.38538891077041626,
0.49303367733955383,
0.4960927665233612,
0.568096399307251,
0.0733204260468483,
0.45343437790870667,
-0.1721503585577011,
0.3430986702442169,
1.3542338609695435,
-0.3268093466758728,
1.045790433883667,
0.5190422534942627,
-0.15483501553535461,
0.4109884798526764,
0.36765098571777344,
0.2798185348510742,
0.604512095451355,
-0.08318386226892471,
-0.5232983827590942,
-0.43518689274787903,
-0.09749095886945724,
-0.3700735569000244,
0.7419915199279785,
0.6063293814659119,
-0.1769440472126007,
-0.33754992485046387,
0.6309810876846313,
-0.06654968857765198,
0.1979016363620758,
-0.3467455506324768,
0.8642134666442871,
0.15034997463226318,
-0.5563201308250427,
0.5458478927612305,
-0.02309303544461727,
0.6544196009635925,
-0.7609513401985168,
0.13370883464813232,
0.10440603643655777,
0.2661880850791931,
-0.14193303883075714,
-0.5719122290611267,
0.5719920992851257,
-0.28170284628868103,
0.08281022310256958,
-0.3372485339641571,
0.7928714752197266,
-0.788002073764801,
-0.32341858744621277,
0.6103762984275818,
0.4598865807056427,
0.2737293243408203,
0.03237506002187729,
-0.739458441734314,
0.03481358289718628,
0.08237642794847488,
0.340663880109787,
0.6639364957809448,
0.3540426194667816,
0.26999998092651367,
0.5712530016899109,
0.38766664266586304,
-0.06711636483669281,
0.04549659788608551,
0.21249593794345856,
0.5970816612243652,
-0.48477357625961304,
-0.8256664276123047,
-0.6704447865486145,
0.3995912969112396,
0.02204248122870922,
-0.08107675611972809,
0.9038735032081604,
0.7328327298164368,
1.1737020015716553,
-0.2393614500761032,
0.8300590515136719,
-0.004230695776641369,
0.6988948583602905,
-0.659302830696106,
0.4819480776786804,
-0.7553597688674927,
-0.06922540068626404,
-0.16758890450000763,
-0.37445494532585144,
-0.24869781732559204,
0.5346118211746216,
-0.15519078075885773,
-0.17713439464569092,
0.7161215543746948,
0.7886610627174377,
-0.25594013929367065,
0.31100448966026306,
0.5629170536994934,
-0.0269315242767334,
-0.2747229337692261,
0.5691857933998108,
0.6702427864074707,
-0.24103671312332153,
0.5094683766365051,
-0.5269160270690918,
-0.22807617485523224,
0.12735244631767273,
-0.5353795886039734,
-0.9338516592979431,
-1.0407838821411133,
-0.4073405861854553,
-0.12157203257083893,
0.3299473524093628,
0.7601375579833984,
0.7301607728004456,
-0.8130713105201721,
-0.3914829194545746,
0.12655790150165558,
-0.12806446850299835,
-0.5139098167419434,
-0.14612676203250885,
0.47922033071517944,
-0.8888478875160217,
-0.6309112906455994,
0.6689305901527405,
0.1943644881248474,
-0.17857186496257782,
-0.120170459151268,
-0.1735387146472931,
-0.16953922808170319,
-0.4624389708042145,
0.7486580610275269,
0.187018483877182,
-1.112012267112732,
-0.12048839777708054,
-0.16868817806243896,
0.09127311408519745,
0.10037600249052048,
0.75273597240448,
-0.8771860599517822,
0.4134429395198822,
0.14830152690410614,
0.7362403273582458,
0.7233076691627502,
-0.2063242644071579,
0.2269168645143509,
-0.8149293065071106,
0.26682335138320923,
0.05799566209316254,
0.40993309020996094,
0.2166016846895218,
-0.5929481387138367,
0.40209928154945374,
0.046875856816768646,
-0.5662352442741394,
-0.46616145968437195,
0.36896106600761414,
-1.1712510585784912,
-0.3409736156463623,
1.2025657892227173,
-0.21934783458709717,
0.018923237919807434,
-0.34538841247558594,
-0.2418660968542099,
0.4985470473766327,
-0.4256923496723175,
0.19477355480194092,
0.33249783515930176,
-0.22498570382595062,
-0.21383124589920044,
-0.5785025358200073,
0.4343617856502533,
0.6312750577926636,
-0.550810694694519,
0.27873536944389343,
0.270679235458374,
0.21929386258125305,
0.13554376363754272,
0.2639486789703369,
-0.061169013381004333,
0.42168381810188293,
-0.08577360957860947,
-0.2866758704185486,
0.08767976611852646,
-0.19719991087913513,
-0.5727394223213196,
-0.1329154670238495,
0.13130852580070496,
-0.21624459326267242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12138v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12138v1
|
Bias in Text Embedding Models
| 2024-06-17T22:58:36 | 2024-06-17T22:58:36 |
Vasyl Rakivnenko, Nestor Maslej, Jessica Cervi, Volodymyr Zhukov
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Text embedding is becoming an increasingly popular AI methodology, especially
among businesses, yet the potential of text embedding models to be biased is
not well understood. This paper examines the degree to which a selection of
popular text embedding models are biased, particularly along gendered
dimensions. More specifically, this paper studies the degree to which these
models associate a list of given professions with gendered terms. The analysis
reveals that text embedding models are prone to gendered biases but in varying
ways. Although there are certain inter-model commonalities, for instance,
greater association of professions like nurse, homemaker, and socialite with
female identifiers, and greater association of professions like CEO, manager,
and boss with male identifiers, not all models make the same gendered
associations for each occupation. Furthermore, the magnitude and directionality
of bias can also vary on a model-by-model basis and depend on the particular
words models are prompted with. This paper demonstrates that gender bias
afflicts text embedding models and suggests that businesses using this
technology need to be mindful of the specific dimensions of this problem.
|
[
-0.14549602568149567,
-0.5979393720626831,
0.6078452467918396,
0.34161660075187683,
0.033358294516801834,
-0.02374272234737873,
0.18194182217121124,
-0.5527015924453735,
-0.07177775353193283,
0.4908835291862488,
-0.6217738389968872,
-0.3630359470844269,
-0.9180057048797607,
0.19761374592781067,
-0.29640114307403564,
1.0175340175628662,
0.12750616669654846,
0.600744903087616,
-0.687707245349884,
-0.36446577310562134,
-0.7718731760978699,
-0.7268105745315552,
-0.21070891618728638,
-0.5446211099624634,
0.15910296142101288,
-0.07184707373380661,
1.114251971244812,
0.7558336853981018,
0.43666163086891174,
0.2204716056585312,
-0.08380573987960815,
0.048030830919742584,
-0.07526781409978867,
0.13545092940330505,
-0.18846704065799713,
-0.5404282212257385,
-0.4915693998336792,
0.2645277678966522,
0.30610084533691406,
0.8665094375610352,
0.18826264142990112,
0.27451878786087036,
0.18682055175304413,
0.7290355563163757,
-0.4627213180065155,
0.25110334157943726,
-0.37658676505088806,
0.14661161601543427,
0.09570500254631042,
0.24280305206775665,
-0.344738632440567,
-0.38164108991622925,
0.7708545923233032,
-0.22297406196594238,
0.28747209906578064,
0.2966804802417755,
0.5816470980644226,
0.1685284674167633,
-0.7543593049049377,
-0.5611715912818909,
-0.79423987865448,
0.8556803464889526,
-0.36566343903541565,
0.5954161882400513,
0.559907078742981,
-0.00521422503516078,
0.3434010446071625,
-0.11684376001358032,
-0.11233983188867569,
-0.08180829137563705,
-0.02417808584868908,
-0.3453865945339203,
-0.2718028724193573,
-0.06752394884824753,
0.3568326532840729,
0.03244014456868172,
0.025444259867072105,
0.27331605553627014,
-0.1218947097659111,
0.34050771594047546,
0.50877845287323,
0.038365621119737625,
0.4653675854206085,
-0.052353981882333755,
-0.27650728821754456,
-0.05322827398777008,
-0.5994152426719666,
-0.1804170459508896,
0.8116390109062195,
0.24212512373924255,
0.06646613031625748,
0.5891660451889038,
0.3373032808303833,
0.6037733554840088,
0.19886435568332672,
-0.007429004181176424,
0.20673032104969025,
-0.2645173966884613,
-0.27659717202186584,
0.3284946382045746,
0.6600218415260315,
0.41336503624916077,
0.42460182309150696,
-0.03191082924604416,
-0.08886352181434631,
-0.129346564412117,
0.7698602080345154,
-0.4604407548904419,
0.17108698189258575,
0.22775065898895264,
-0.7548171281814575,
-0.49300268292427063,
0.10829871892929077,
-0.5409979820251465,
-0.7914861440658569,
-0.08750870078802109,
0.27947863936424255,
-0.12537449598312378,
-0.14675335586071014,
-0.26950472593307495,
-0.5831646919250488,
0.049758899956941605,
0.11455903947353363,
-0.990225613117218,
0.06399859488010406,
0.8246014714241028,
0.7198473811149597,
0.24885229766368866,
-0.1707613319158554,
0.02318934164941311,
0.31537455320358276,
-0.45966023206710815,
0.5062339901924133,
-0.9475731253623962,
-0.6241109371185303,
0.2547609210014343,
-0.18109777569770813,
-0.0524040125310421,
-0.467597633600235,
0.2970699071884155,
-0.1584191918373108,
0.36714136600494385,
-0.6098883152008057,
-0.6017851233482361,
-0.26372355222702026,
0.24419765174388885,
-0.8708619475364685,
0.7442331910133362,
-0.049892134964466095,
-1.070257544517517,
0.8049473762512207,
-0.5739034414291382,
-0.1419047862291336,
-0.3562864363193512,
-0.7046083807945251,
-0.7509878873825073,
0.11442537605762482,
0.2587951123714447,
0.6309431791305542,
-0.48902347683906555,
0.4429977238178253,
-0.36663374304771423,
-0.11942944675683975,
0.384556382894516,
-0.43567654490470886,
0.7831721305847168,
-0.19403722882270813,
-0.47426968812942505,
-0.08800259232521057,
-0.26606395840644836,
-0.6321919560432434,
-0.14925120770931244,
0.008072365075349808,
-0.8836750984191895,
0.35379505157470703,
0.056301940232515335,
0.1797860711812973,
0.11050710827112198,
-0.4894059896469116,
0.17529980838298798,
-0.14940191805362701,
0.44620585441589355,
0.8588021993637085,
-0.1447327584028244,
0.8559967875480652,
-0.6204522252082825,
0.4889516234397888,
0.12127339094877243,
-0.11380457133054733,
0.17555329203605652,
-0.7323429584503174,
-0.15340344607830048,
-0.37964335083961487,
0.3937813341617584,
0.47883591055870056,
-0.3088255524635315,
0.3742682933807373,
-0.2220122516155243,
-0.5828448534011841,
-0.7592263221740723,
0.02757876180112362,
0.4563314616680145,
0.10383456200361252,
-0.03082926757633686,
-0.03558001294732094,
-0.10940684378147125,
-1.3370288610458374,
-1.022493839263916,
0.12561596930027008,
0.012570507824420929,
0.6995097398757935,
0.5699272155761719,
-0.5201482176780701,
1.1075454950332642,
-0.572001039981842,
-0.6460325717926025,
-0.2471090704202652,
0.035054247826337814,
0.20124199986457825,
0.48285868763923645,
0.8747995495796204,
-0.8308424353599548,
-0.25980234146118164,
-0.1985534429550171,
-0.5832757949829102,
0.05835415795445442,
-0.36963191628456116,
-0.18813271820545197,
0.18192054331302643,
0.33004921674728394,
-0.5035902857780457,
0.6718112230300903,
0.5446760654449463,
-0.6237314939498901,
0.34673210978507996,
-0.18551480770111084,
-0.18764157593250275,
-1.09225332736969,
-0.0916341245174408,
0.5635948181152344,
-0.4071243107318878,
-0.5785475969314575,
-0.09218603372573853,
-0.030289094895124435,
-0.0219820998609066,
-0.04257415980100632,
0.4358542561531067,
-0.7017975449562073,
-0.36557695269584656,
-0.25255313515663147,
0.024619771167635918,
0.11395177990198135,
0.003200542414560914,
0.15769493579864502,
0.47793129086494446,
0.4285714328289032,
-0.6755548715591431,
-0.03609219565987587,
0.5884777307510376,
-0.33005285263061523,
0.6043305993080139,
-0.7895495891571045,
0.14929915964603424,
-0.2336397022008896,
0.4314947724342346,
-0.7409539818763733,
0.22977754473686218,
0.12403306365013123,
-0.27175286412239075,
0.19290344417095184,
0.02529836632311344,
-0.45379137992858887,
-0.218120276927948,
-0.37725213170051575,
0.5208394527435303,
0.21357131004333496,
-0.4042285084724426,
0.7670778036117554,
0.4714156687259674,
-0.01249627210199833,
-0.7144668102264404,
-1.1298487186431885,
-0.271240234375,
-0.08907435834407806,
-0.5524465441703796,
0.5678130984306335,
0.20195631682872772,
-0.4134388864040375,
0.03619430214166641,
-0.01902759075164795,
-0.18756340444087982,
0.05584903806447983,
0.4776279032230377,
0.18127287924289703,
0.2354193478822708,
0.07141637802124023,
0.1753556728363037,
0.09089355170726776,
0.2234223335981369,
-0.06160948425531387,
0.41711923480033875,
0.26320186257362366,
-0.5734947919845581,
-0.36185401678085327,
0.5036447644233704,
0.6471783518791199,
-0.10822063684463501,
1.0980490446090698,
0.5319028496742249,
-0.7068945169448853,
-0.183536559343338,
-0.40460312366485596,
-0.22973878681659698,
-0.4546397924423218,
0.5761334896087646,
-0.008687198162078857,
-0.7082568407058716,
0.5091414451599121,
0.03253592923283577,
0.2992677688598633,
0.4043419659137726,
0.5903655290603638,
-0.0011070342734456062,
1.446817398071289,
0.9336945414543152,
-0.41135770082473755,
0.39563649892807007,
-0.16882435977458954,
0.4869767427444458,
-0.747444212436676,
-0.36503171920776367,
-0.8988940715789795,
-0.5493514537811279,
-1.2002832889556885,
-0.07615448534488678,
0.014570758678019047,
-0.47585633397102356,
-0.3119605779647827,
-0.07939413189888,
-0.6444537043571472,
0.02485341764986515,
0.8370815515518188,
0.1702350378036499,
-0.11850498616695404,
-0.0340302512049675,
-0.10705480724573135,
-0.25375527143478394,
-0.6237752437591553,
-0.697289228439331,
0.9764728546142578,
0.7729999423027039,
0.741478443145752,
0.26134538650512695,
0.4551144540309906,
0.6381054520606995,
0.1847015768289566,
-0.6185272336006165,
0.019054077565670013,
-0.51100093126297,
-1.1594715118408203,
-0.06567604839801788,
0.00649539940059185,
-0.6433165073394775,
0.06030029430985451,
-0.40066972374916077,
-0.6466505527496338,
0.6087272763252258,
0.04396374151110649,
-0.053474731743335724,
0.4818480610847473,
-0.4460427165031433,
0.6830626130104065,
0.10505621880292892,
-0.3594948649406433,
-0.04376628249883652,
-0.2665008008480072,
0.1402284950017929,
-0.05555380880832672,
0.46164384484291077,
0.06615166366100311,
0.07022988796234131,
0.793117105960846,
-0.38307496905326843,
1.1879394054412842,
-0.11200534552335739,
-0.22077950835227966,
-0.1026180237531662,
-0.0030185256619006395,
0.49018800258636475,
0.027495333924889565,
-0.22686667740345,
0.3432392477989197,
-0.055203769356012344,
-0.3614276647567749,
-0.2418082058429718,
0.4378841519355774,
-0.9870144128799438,
-0.6381374001502991,
-0.8270734548568726,
-0.3981713354587555,
-0.26051411032676697,
0.02637419104576111,
0.37977856397628784,
0.5715001821517944,
-0.301663875579834,
0.20743301510810852,
0.6788248419761658,
-0.5715139508247375,
0.2538095712661743,
-0.10829764604568481,
-0.15649612247943878,
-0.021593112498521805,
0.5341253280639648,
0.3295234143733978,
0.03671709820628166,
0.24958230555057526,
0.1511794775724411,
-0.12018216401338577,
0.06526259332895279,
-0.4057718813419342,
0.13621512055397034,
-0.4767442047595978,
-0.06513415277004242,
-0.7722477912902832,
-0.28320956230163574,
-0.4514295756816864,
-0.4082794487476349,
-0.3374395966529846,
-0.15249353647232056,
-0.6765453219413757,
-0.2066350281238556,
0.3597070276737213,
1.0362529754638672,
0.5927441716194153,
0.3508231043815613,
-0.5599021911621094,
0.20151692628860474,
0.27501025795936584,
0.3226325213909149,
0.22146610915660858,
-0.25233450531959534,
-0.0907229483127594,
0.09287992119789124,
-0.32065799832344055,
-1.222017765045166,
0.35584667325019836,
0.04281512647867203,
0.6665332317352295,
0.665951132774353,
-0.25262394547462463,
-0.006142361089587212,
-0.5517900586128235,
0.9864296317100525,
-0.029268544167280197,
-1.0015815496444702,
0.24170240759849548,
-0.5543941855430603,
0.13183991611003876,
0.3301415741443634,
0.8339579701423645,
-0.46507585048675537,
-0.37475934624671936,
-0.5599294304847717,
-0.732855498790741,
0.6821329593658447,
-0.01909210905432701,
0.6426599025726318,
-0.1201581358909607,
0.3600427210330963,
0.51949542760849,
0.6866117715835571,
-0.8720847964286804,
-0.5367591977119446,
-0.057086311280727386,
-0.3179819881916046,
0.3315548002719879,
-0.7173251509666443,
0.12989942729473114,
-0.18572717905044556,
0.5736063718795776,
0.21339699625968933,
0.8842648267745972,
0.07403441518545151,
-0.13665278255939484,
0.2831907868385315,
0.13219526410102844,
0.36390990018844604,
0.806927502155304,
-0.31172746419906616,
-0.0721983090043068,
-0.1507386863231659,
-0.6886863112449646,
-0.015616519376635551,
-0.21301642060279846,
-0.33097684383392334,
0.2500447928905487,
0.4158468246459961,
0.9282072186470032,
0.04076480120420456,
-0.18735995888710022,
0.7156673073768616,
0.1410050094127655,
-0.4251940846443176,
-0.3263024687767029,
-0.06381791830062866,
0.006326019298285246,
0.4127748906612396,
0.44136807322502136,
0.19489213824272156,
0.21718157827854156,
-0.6995021104812622,
-0.2964368462562561,
0.708834171295166,
-0.7440659403800964,
-0.00037748125032521784,
0.8933137059211731,
0.36829179525375366,
-0.474721223115921,
0.6081717610359192,
0.14983688294887543,
-0.7788063287734985,
0.7586730122566223,
0.5250088572502136,
1.2022173404693604,
-0.14459234476089478,
0.21791188418865204,
0.03709426894783974,
0.601039469242096,
-0.18050038814544678,
0.3069682717323303,
0.44969674944877625,
-0.8536382913589478,
0.14978332817554474,
-0.2503271996974945,
-0.4723498225212097,
-0.3339862823486328,
-0.590833306312561,
0.4226609766483307,
-0.5832080245018005,
-0.6716436743736267,
0.048117272555828094,
-0.3269394338130951,
-1.090160846710205,
0.21915730834007263,
0.026233278214931488,
0.7525096535682678,
-0.876065194606781,
0.4425201117992401,
0.9189016819000244,
-0.18655627965927124,
-0.3106454610824585,
0.2237091213464737,
0.018116392195224762,
-0.5780208110809326,
0.7067791223526001,
0.4374113380908966,
0.13577468693256378,
-0.22600308060646057,
-0.22877399623394012,
-0.5813518762588501,
1.1360725164413452,
0.07552117109298706,
-0.6790060997009277,
-0.3409576714038849,
0.2974216639995575,
0.34529441595077515,
-0.7813894152641296,
0.5735934376716614,
0.23301050066947937,
0.32562053203582764,
-0.920264720916748,
-0.8470302820205688,
0.10842357575893402,
0.10902298241853714,
0.39271652698516846,
-0.17218519747257233,
-0.6815474033355713,
0.7243623733520508,
-0.0016619147500023246,
0.32270607352256775,
-0.40125763416290283,
0.3956224024295807,
0.17386704683303833,
0.5314279794692993,
0.3746708333492279,
0.2632821202278137,
0.7815084457397461,
0.04627097770571709,
1.0468430519104004,
-0.3264302611351013,
0.06466430425643921,
0.8710017800331116,
-0.16750715672969818,
0.5038175582885742,
0.18809375166893005,
-0.08220425248146057,
0.9284061193466187,
0.4051586389541626,
-0.3450321853160858,
0.3678034543991089,
-0.026284782215952873,
0.037163350731134415,
0.06231914088129997,
-0.30566683411598206,
-0.49264928698539734,
0.6173800826072693,
0.25274065136909485,
-1.2174197435379028,
0.29180335998535156,
0.09402349591255188,
0.15761585533618927,
-0.020678609609603882,
-0.19946801662445068,
0.5223568081855774,
0.2475728690624237,
-0.27221307158470154,
-0.3834216594696045,
0.4170539677143097,
0.8875668048858643,
-0.3562711477279663,
0.13388319313526154,
0.0482419952750206,
0.033218007534742355,
-0.2551453709602356,
-0.6352365016937256,
0.2293291687965393,
-0.007553547155112028,
-0.622721791267395,
-0.4744141101837158,
0.8590527176856995,
-0.3224036395549774,
-0.5540183186531067,
0.2071361392736435,
0.7393350005149841,
-0.3265244960784912,
-0.2648560106754303,
-0.5804557204246521,
-0.16322556138038635,
0.14976420998573303,
-0.1627182513475418,
0.36793282628059387,
0.24451541900634766,
-0.17542259395122528,
0.669124186038971,
0.28677260875701904,
-0.23235799372196198,
-0.09751652181148529,
0.11439841240644455,
0.5109990835189819,
-0.6831895112991333,
-0.7504227757453918,
-1.1244268417358398,
0.20523282885551453,
-0.06901749968528748,
-0.3643246591091156,
0.812666118144989,
0.44251102209091187,
0.45659056305885315,
-0.17678244411945343,
0.8946449160575867,
0.4533609449863434,
0.2906382083892822,
-0.1840439736843109,
1.0833052396774292,
-0.4367510676383972,
0.3145804703235626,
-0.6153216361999512,
-1.2763558626174927,
0.1345989853143692,
0.5146201252937317,
-0.5040274858474731,
0.6558188199996948,
0.420356422662735,
0.2470889538526535,
0.0492144338786602,
0.29310929775238037,
0.06735491752624512,
0.03754417970776558,
0.14235149323940277,
-0.1281375139951706,
0.46833813190460205,
-0.24735023081302643,
0.033672504127025604,
-0.12349254637956619,
-0.15008026361465454,
-0.42929404973983765,
-1.1528816223144531,
-1.0852597951889038,
-0.4800681173801422,
-0.6361202001571655,
-0.2619295120239258,
-0.00019063314539380372,
0.9585160613059998,
0.5534632802009583,
-0.33620503544807434,
-0.13818487524986267,
0.09799598902463913,
0.4730599820613861,
-0.18991310894489288,
-0.24425318837165833,
0.16291894018650055,
0.19139952957630157,
-0.7538845539093018,
-0.3615446090698242,
0.0341508649289608,
-0.10576652735471725,
-0.5604430437088013,
0.37091752886772156,
-0.3379795253276825,
0.43790319561958313,
0.3197266459465027,
-0.39767152070999146,
-0.511491596698761,
-0.20129165053367615,
-0.016331961378455162,
-0.22214525938034058,
-0.14644378423690796,
0.7725363373756409,
-0.6402915120124817,
0.34451356530189514,
0.44857555627822876,
0.6408904790878296,
0.022918984293937683,
0.0449596606194973,
0.8595573902130127,
-0.9565716981887817,
0.026213431730866432,
0.009766990318894386,
0.23484745621681213,
0.4228361248970032,
-0.7975488901138306,
0.2717520296573639,
0.2907874584197998,
-0.5127723813056946,
-0.8069292902946472,
0.16128987073898315,
-0.4350108504295349,
-0.6404106020927429,
1.164047122001648,
0.37255802750587463,
-0.18863901495933533,
-0.03503341227769852,
-0.1833091676235199,
0.18523766100406647,
-0.415396511554718,
0.6361857056617737,
0.9325924515724182,
0.04320480301976204,
0.06716050952672958,
-0.8215240240097046,
0.5548645853996277,
0.37421971559524536,
-0.3125133514404297,
-0.03219329193234444,
0.38171082735061646,
0.31239405274391174,
0.08778831362724304,
0.39953750371932983,
0.04143229126930237,
0.06650687754154205,
0.07514496892690659,
-0.014824419282376766,
0.05796037241816521,
-0.18404585123062134,
-0.23373326659202576,
-0.10493253916501999,
0.25271812081336975,
-0.10387609153985977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12131v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12131v1
|
Gram2Vec: An Interpretable Document Vectorizer
| 2024-06-17T22:42:14 | 2024-06-17T22:42:14 |
Peter Zeng, Eric Sclafani, Owen Rambow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present Gram2Vec, a grammatical style embedding algorithm that embeds
documents into a higher dimensional space by extracting the normalized relative
frequencies of grammatical features present in the text. Compared to neural
approaches, Gram2Vec offers inherent interpretability based on how the feature
vectors are generated. In our demo, we present a way to visualize a mapping of
authors to documents based on their Gram2Vec vectors and highlight the ability
to drop or add features to view which authors make certain linguistic choices.
Next, we use authorship attribution as an application to show how Gram2Vec can
explain why a document is attributed to a certain author, using cosine
similarities between the Gram2Vec feature vectors to calculate the distances
between candidate documents and a query document.
|
[
-0.1721353828907013,
-0.5921772718429565,
0.8769424557685852,
0.0972563773393631,
-0.01940048485994339,
-0.058301154524087906,
-0.23603160679340363,
-0.2856276333332062,
0.3228607177734375,
0.20789538323879242,
-0.4608268737792969,
-0.708976149559021,
-0.9289342761039734,
-0.14056481420993805,
-0.5007346868515015,
0.740098774433136,
0.07526814192533493,
0.07278073579072952,
-0.9056591987609863,
-0.09973137080669403,
-0.5561307072639465,
-0.4089488387107849,
-0.38467735052108765,
-0.1942252516746521,
0.39197197556495667,
0.653128981590271,
0.7963409423828125,
0.570156991481781,
0.42111214995384216,
0.26337939500808716,
-0.3404887616634369,
0.030736109241843224,
-0.7303455471992493,
0.13290558755397797,
-0.2204311043024063,
-0.8313586115837097,
-0.3956388235092163,
0.25832170248031616,
0.6104387044906616,
0.23332329094409943,
0.03114517591893673,
0.04364888370037079,
0.1699853539466858,
0.3411743938922882,
-0.5233889818191528,
0.5682758688926697,
-0.26988929510116577,
-0.0439722016453743,
-0.26131224632263184,
-0.3043164610862732,
-0.5302445888519287,
-0.8590874671936035,
-0.20562568306922913,
-0.717352032661438,
0.31042957305908203,
-0.12342242896556854,
0.7669711112976074,
-0.014705044217407703,
-0.38789430260658264,
-0.7510024309158325,
-0.614301860332489,
0.6579278707504272,
-0.1436634510755539,
0.49021539092063904,
0.5755447745323181,
0.3979221284389496,
-0.0700611099600792,
-0.8692185878753662,
-0.5938108563423157,
0.16999411582946777,
-0.3210950195789337,
0.3303280174732208,
-0.2407110333442688,
-0.19523212313652039,
-0.03324712812900543,
0.3938046097755432,
-0.5604322552680969,
0.015371750108897686,
-0.3833458125591278,
-0.04154784232378006,
0.3155996799468994,
-0.1760299652814865,
0.5458125472068787,
-0.43781957030296326,
-0.22814051806926727,
-0.14304816722869873,
-0.5511651039123535,
0.29825204610824585,
0.7108136415481567,
-0.06795917451381683,
0.12285809218883514,
0.6246512532234192,
0.35247713327407837,
0.48903340101242065,
-0.24643678963184357,
0.10342307388782501,
0.2450716346502304,
-0.13929659128189087,
0.18898576498031616,
0.0695803314447403,
0.5259674787521362,
0.47560158371925354,
0.44247081875801086,
-0.12316910177469254,
-0.034089818596839905,
0.10955314338207245,
0.6496273875236511,
-0.658176839351654,
-0.3816371262073517,
-0.07832018285989761,
-0.7719534635543823,
-0.5555172562599182,
0.5992916822433472,
-1.074200987815857,
-0.4641578793525696,
-0.26333022117614746,
0.2191028743982315,
-0.5632262825965881,
-0.19921326637268066,
-0.2564905881881714,
-0.6235373616218567,
0.4310457110404968,
0.19537656009197235,
-1.1349153518676758,
0.3957502543926239,
1.205884575843811,
0.9868833422660828,
0.047028426080942154,
0.03687309846282005,
-0.758660614490509,
-0.08140664547681808,
-0.2905617654323578,
0.8850415349006653,
-1.0940139293670654,
-0.7067452669143677,
0.33810311555862427,
0.07894407212734222,
0.17124302685260773,
-0.2476733922958374,
0.6848549842834473,
-0.5470626354217529,
0.2213950753211975,
-0.26640596985816956,
-0.6166906356811523,
-0.29144394397735596,
-0.08188267052173615,
-0.6560080051422119,
1.12071692943573,
0.4478969871997833,
-0.6116172075271606,
0.2256079763174057,
-0.45172733068466187,
-0.33885371685028076,
0.10530638694763184,
-0.44707170128822327,
-0.3492024838924408,
0.23934955894947052,
0.15139229595661163,
0.4808611273765564,
0.06267935037612915,
-0.13405971229076385,
-0.2281149923801422,
-0.18186745047569275,
0.18712849915027618,
-0.12158379703760147,
0.6849483847618103,
0.3018054664134979,
0.06929147988557816,
0.22432772815227509,
-1.0322542190551758,
-0.0075475675985217094,
0.13249963521957397,
-0.3653063178062439,
-0.6192718744277954,
0.2616325318813324,
0.35969847440719604,
0.0233165230602026,
0.23275160789489746,
-0.4149312973022461,
0.2647207975387573,
-0.3001301884651184,
0.47201183438301086,
0.7191835641860962,
0.01330433040857315,
0.7686647176742554,
-0.0024662839714437723,
0.8121873736381531,
-0.7298063039779663,
-0.025252914056181908,
0.0798654779791832,
-0.8773130178451538,
-0.5321773290634155,
-0.4012480676174164,
0.1927003264427185,
0.7331174612045288,
-0.586148738861084,
0.5193911790847778,
-0.5774369239807129,
-0.3730192482471466,
-0.5376853346824646,
0.4583333432674408,
0.5563462972640991,
0.3472987115383148,
0.27074891328811646,
-0.11413931846618652,
-0.33307942748069763,
-0.8404477834701538,
-0.3011291027069092,
-0.38239148259162903,
-0.29415857791900635,
0.2962914705276489,
0.2451060563325882,
-0.10632254928350449,
0.8019863367080688,
-0.830767810344696,
-0.39606568217277527,
-0.21929723024368286,
0.3383564054965973,
-0.2537026107311249,
0.35435250401496887,
0.7443150281906128,
-0.7776147127151489,
-0.373612642288208,
0.051162149757146835,
-0.8729389309883118,
-0.31859344244003296,
-0.029798759147524834,
-0.4603244364261627,
-0.026562953367829323,
1.0419327020645142,
-0.15449537336826324,
0.5356165170669556,
0.6317542195320129,
-0.779379665851593,
-0.09742625057697296,
-0.3872848153114319,
0.0389225110411644,
-1.1982762813568115,
-0.09041725099086761,
0.052154090255498886,
-0.39880919456481934,
-0.41041427850723267,
-0.04144744947552681,
0.3748030364513397,
-0.05585363507270813,
-0.10680245608091354,
0.29906323552131653,
-0.5126436352729797,
-0.304012268781662,
0.04635974019765854,
0.3802662193775177,
0.3509792685508728,
0.0738847553730011,
-0.18212106823921204,
0.611013650894165,
0.1908709704875946,
-0.0822637602686882,
0.3911827802658081,
0.8371084928512573,
-0.4412805736064911,
0.7222838401794434,
-0.40363916754722595,
0.31963425874710083,
-0.3228996992111206,
-0.006408995017409325,
-1.2852423191070557,
-0.17945674061775208,
0.13639888167381287,
-0.776398777961731,
0.4425166845321655,
-0.31995370984077454,
-0.2966986894607544,
-0.009652062319219112,
-0.5213139653205872,
0.091457299888134,
0.6588022708892822,
-0.7217844724655151,
0.9574554562568665,
0.14150816202163696,
-0.39871877431869507,
-0.007102999836206436,
-0.9325578212738037,
0.1060035452246666,
0.18510107696056366,
-0.9352500438690186,
0.2955162823200226,
0.30331218242645264,
-0.38375845551490784,
0.45558902621269226,
0.41043621301651,
0.13694201409816742,
0.0816197544336319,
0.7726861238479614,
0.2060013860464096,
-0.09881213307380676,
0.34912750124931335,
0.26678019762039185,
-0.26068198680877686,
0.12008236348628998,
-0.33235496282577515,
0.3233867883682251,
-0.10733435302972794,
-0.17437061667442322,
-0.23978941142559052,
0.5675088167190552,
0.3725764751434326,
-0.4001258909702301,
0.6408445835113525,
0.8174647092819214,
-0.28835219144821167,
-0.27737656235694885,
-0.29381710290908813,
0.2317991554737091,
-0.4508310556411743,
0.3109612464904785,
-0.6051065921783447,
-0.7384463548660278,
0.5058708190917969,
0.009135383181273937,
-0.2915852963924408,
0.7683445811271667,
0.5760024785995483,
-0.061540767550468445,
0.5591700077056885,
0.7732489705085754,
0.08633771538734436,
0.6919708847999573,
-0.37539833784103394,
0.15550614893436432,
-0.7680804133415222,
-0.8823119401931763,
-0.6782506704330444,
-0.42136305570602417,
-0.5903465151786804,
-0.7346243858337402,
0.13186341524124146,
0.06836793571710587,
0.36947447061538696,
0.3114526867866516,
-0.6030399799346924,
0.5502273440361023,
0.7646236419677734,
-0.21107645332813263,
-0.02310550957918167,
0.06223541125655174,
-0.1500924825668335,
-0.09302693605422974,
-0.29321128129959106,
-0.6286329030990601,
0.7816277742385864,
0.4968549311161041,
0.7939910888671875,
0.5400176048278809,
0.5329509377479553,
0.3817999064922333,
-0.1367451399564743,
-1.180029034614563,
0.2335713654756546,
-0.4488692581653595,
-0.23065637052059174,
-0.14465831220149994,
-0.05435631796717644,
-0.6296588182449341,
-0.0016985888360068202,
-0.49611377716064453,
-0.7233995199203491,
0.6929606199264526,
0.014611479826271534,
-0.24015018343925476,
0.1466810703277588,
-0.9100706577301025,
0.9571333527565002,
0.02494448609650135,
-0.07901980727910995,
-0.160541370511055,
-0.3867451846599579,
-0.22881639003753662,
0.21760043501853943,
0.26282408833503723,
0.31497806310653687,
-0.08584534376859665,
0.6729850769042969,
-0.3938893675804138,
0.6640188097953796,
-0.22804531455039978,
-0.029902935028076172,
0.26610031723976135,
0.35904163122177124,
0.6201979517936707,
0.20928023755550385,
-0.18773019313812256,
0.13097959756851196,
-0.12650930881500244,
-0.24328111112117767,
-0.9950515627861023,
0.9047139286994934,
-0.7000422477722168,
-0.323739230632782,
-0.33874955773353577,
-0.13156303763389587,
-0.055211685597896576,
0.03708892688155174,
0.37843379378318787,
0.6116772890090942,
-0.6019415855407715,
0.29603010416030884,
0.4379149377346039,
-0.2530519366264343,
0.16564685106277466,
0.042502254247665405,
-0.1642322838306427,
-0.3805496394634247,
1.0444691181182861,
0.02836153469979763,
0.08324871212244034,
0.44488033652305603,
0.2598080039024353,
-0.34525763988494873,
-0.5212453603744507,
-0.23443178832530975,
0.0032634162344038486,
-1.0519440174102783,
0.22464025020599365,
-0.8169218897819519,
-0.15263597667217255,
-0.6259053945541382,
-0.5882371664047241,
-0.14107011258602142,
-0.6980608105659485,
-0.7751937508583069,
-0.35862958431243896,
0.5039581656455994,
1.2701213359832764,
-0.0586918480694294,
0.3650686740875244,
-0.5461114645004272,
0.31067416071891785,
0.44379982352256775,
0.31686028838157654,
-0.487509161233902,
-0.7154116630554199,
-0.03712436556816101,
-0.5829777717590332,
-0.12535259127616882,
-0.7272161841392517,
0.24142833054065704,
0.32813408970832825,
0.38945725560188293,
0.7754120826721191,
-0.5561918616294861,
0.27521246671676636,
-0.6320477724075317,
0.9726011157035828,
0.025560615584254265,
-0.925275981426239,
0.8827689290046692,
-0.0648910328745842,
-0.025731991976499557,
0.4904075264930725,
0.37451860308647156,
-0.7027980089187622,
-0.21105672419071198,
-0.39297497272491455,
-0.7735521197319031,
0.47922030091285706,
0.2899506986141205,
0.11838480830192566,
0.008074335753917694,
0.6470609903335571,
0.06844978034496307,
-0.3563319146633148,
-0.12676705420017242,
0.010960188694298267,
-0.5657802224159241,
-0.6776383519172668,
-0.45040586590766907,
-1.1472111940383911,
-0.07693413645029068,
-0.14193949103355408,
0.5281071066856384,
-0.046842437237501144,
0.47886890172958374,
0.01230597123503685,
-0.18430329859256744,
0.1982364058494568,
0.25796645879745483,
0.6229661703109741,
0.5751236081123352,
-0.28660672903060913,
0.34370994567871094,
-0.25010550022125244,
-0.6305322051048279,
-0.13459263741970062,
0.1704212874174118,
-0.1148238480091095,
0.08655425906181335,
0.80800461769104,
0.9068862795829773,
0.06334370374679565,
-0.042073629796504974,
0.905148446559906,
-0.23059625923633575,
-0.504621148109436,
-0.5298046469688416,
0.07286564260721207,
0.2340489774942398,
0.30335181951522827,
-0.17748650908470154,
0.12458396703004837,
0.2818368971347809,
-0.5584868788719177,
0.13932815194129944,
0.23395274579524994,
-0.9036049842834473,
-0.46714094281196594,
0.8666636347770691,
0.39170002937316895,
-0.37652525305747986,
0.6102295517921448,
-0.24386581778526306,
-0.6062345504760742,
0.5347992181777954,
0.3542425334453583,
1.0528141260147095,
-0.09550271928310394,
0.29676565527915955,
0.27631035447120667,
0.3804386258125305,
-0.001997999846935272,
0.3904680609703064,
0.19922354817390442,
-0.47665414214134216,
-0.007308304775506258,
-0.6303565502166748,
0.011736977845430374,
-0.4390314519405365,
-0.7659536600112915,
0.3013332784175873,
-0.5576927661895752,
0.013949614949524403,
0.4541102349758148,
-0.3895067572593689,
-0.5516319870948792,
-0.20818114280700684,
0.34492453932762146,
0.6434178352355957,
-1.0405609607696533,
0.8533205986022949,
0.8103734254837036,
-0.4628531336784363,
-0.5843712687492371,
-0.07812842726707458,
0.658429741859436,
-0.8288039565086365,
0.7742048501968384,
0.03354543447494507,
-0.23827865719795227,
-0.15474441647529602,
-0.2952989339828491,
-0.6851179599761963,
1.1884651184082031,
0.1582966446876526,
-0.3199581205844879,
-0.027165070176124573,
-0.00745245348662138,
0.5471671223640442,
-0.2935656011104584,
0.13644972443580627,
0.569534182548523,
0.6297191977500916,
0.1899280548095703,
-0.2855679392814636,
0.0022023385390639305,
-0.6268868446350098,
0.5082268714904785,
0.07389042526483536,
-0.343993604183197,
0.7258193492889404,
0.06513581424951553,
-0.27347347140312195,
-0.010647151619195938,
0.7978843450546265,
-0.7378413677215576,
0.10505300015211105,
0.41996046900749207,
0.5717263221740723,
1.0590856075286865,
-0.15705156326293945,
1.3518035411834717,
0.021755894646048546,
0.377485066652298,
1.2766157388687134,
0.21874311566352844,
0.8480278253555298,
0.386556476354599,
-0.039696503430604935,
0.8537653088569641,
0.19750353693962097,
-0.5003548860549927,
0.5261294841766357,
0.17226094007492065,
-0.25235363841056824,
-0.16504111886024475,
-0.06276999413967133,
-0.07562941312789917,
0.6174518465995789,
0.27339601516723633,
-0.6981660723686218,
0.08371173590421677,
0.114527627825737,
0.10137879103422165,
0.7412188053131104,
-0.13789620995521545,
0.8726422786712646,
0.1777142435312271,
-0.35967451333999634,
0.09927177429199219,
0.19138076901435852,
0.5095110535621643,
-0.44093555212020874,
-0.33229443430900574,
0.0021889579948037863,
0.3245404362678528,
-0.6183837652206421,
-1.1010770797729492,
0.4411361515522003,
0.07905205339193344,
-0.42972034215927124,
-0.44947710633277893,
0.917827844619751,
-0.44291257858276367,
-0.7785608768463135,
0.4888571500778198,
0.2489098459482193,
0.15542078018188477,
-0.08698475360870361,
-0.10292592644691467,
-0.03194008022546768,
-0.12130651623010635,
-0.26781874895095825,
0.02793717570602894,
0.6092550158500671,
-0.07923778891563416,
0.4389226734638214,
0.4297805726528168,
0.06214316561818123,
0.005367442965507507,
0.38320252299308777,
0.7216704487800598,
-0.5146363377571106,
-0.545524001121521,
-0.7977402806282043,
0.26618140935897827,
-0.050625286996364594,
-0.17961831390857697,
0.7096883058547974,
0.6613306999206543,
0.6645193696022034,
-0.16815203428268433,
0.7566260695457458,
-0.20103831589221954,
0.3084007203578949,
-0.7284758687019348,
1.0459961891174316,
-0.5587498545646667,
-0.0404982753098011,
-0.03136012703180313,
-0.8427993059158325,
-0.3336462378501892,
0.6635610461235046,
-0.2663959562778473,
-0.15897253155708313,
0.7436728477478027,
0.9077795743942261,
-0.06755667179822922,
0.003914158791303635,
0.3214607536792755,
0.15344229340553284,
0.6228942275047302,
0.10286060720682144,
0.6609665751457214,
-0.2079586535692215,
0.6719146966934204,
-0.0667046383023262,
-0.2883583605289459,
-0.4031657874584198,
-0.6758348941802979,
-1.0239064693450928,
-0.7385505437850952,
-0.14341358840465546,
-0.4860483407974243,
0.006007645279169083,
0.7526969313621521,
0.1879304051399231,
-0.6931090354919434,
0.2179051786661148,
0.06283728033304214,
0.11248965561389923,
-0.16026926040649414,
-0.2441026270389557,
0.5713559985160828,
-0.29216212034225464,
-0.8220454454421997,
0.2932201027870178,
0.28701895475387573,
-0.08772801607847214,
-0.1828218400478363,
-0.07739143818616867,
-0.24206691980361938,
0.06772314757108688,
0.7815627455711365,
0.01638944447040558,
-0.6433400511741638,
-0.6843854784965515,
-0.2585225999355316,
-0.1468278467655182,
0.10685385763645172,
0.8739883303642273,
-0.3430843651294708,
0.9480488300323486,
0.9021879434585571,
0.573992133140564,
0.5043659210205078,
0.2216978669166565,
0.5495864748954773,
-0.8025281429290771,
0.19959969818592072,
-0.0630483627319336,
0.3202465772628784,
0.27331820130348206,
-0.6944580078125,
0.5801511406898499,
0.2806534767150879,
-0.3171725571155548,
-0.17746584117412567,
-0.1133417934179306,
-1.293031096458435,
-0.33510497212409973,
1.6067456007003784,
-0.37528732419013977,
-0.43562960624694824,
0.04644352197647095,
-0.2954673171043396,
0.21485039591789246,
-0.46176931262016296,
0.19037584960460663,
0.9679664373397827,
0.316662073135376,
0.08329401910305023,
-0.8953860998153687,
0.6932247877120972,
0.1027594730257988,
-0.5730932354927063,
-0.11490993201732635,
0.6425792574882507,
0.30445754528045654,
0.20827992260456085,
0.47220608592033386,
-0.4496372640132904,
0.026190143078565598,
0.2632814645767212,
0.3530494272708893,
-0.3724404573440552,
-0.4548855423927307,
-0.6346454620361328,
0.1418502777814865,
0.21246452629566193,
-0.3792356848716736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12128v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12128v1
|
AI "News" Content Farms Are Easy to Make and Hard to Detect: A Case Study in Italian
| 2024-06-17T22:19:00 | 2024-06-17T22:19:00 |
Giovanni Puccetti, Anna Rogers, Chiara Alzetta, Felice Dell'Orletta, Andrea Esuli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly used as "content farm" models
(CFMs), to generate synthetic text that could pass for real news articles. This
is already happening even for languages that do not have high-quality
monolingual LLMs. We show that fine-tuning Llama (v1), mostly trained on
English, on as little as 40K Italian news articles, is sufficient for producing
news-like texts that native speakers of Italian struggle to identify as
synthetic.
We investigate three LLMs and three methods of detecting synthetic texts
(log-likelihood, DetectGPT, and supervised classification), finding that they
all perform better than human raters, but they are all impractical in the real
world (requiring either access to token likelihood information or a large
dataset of CFM texts). We also explore the possibility of creating a proxy CFM:
an LLM fine-tuned on a similar dataset to one used by the real "content farm".
We find that even a small amount of fine-tuning data suffices for creating a
successful detector, but we need to know which base LLM is used, which is a
major challenge.
Our results suggest that there are currently no practical methods for
detecting synthetic news-like texts 'in the wild', while generating them is too
easy. We highlight the urgency of more NLP research on this problem.
|
[
-0.4588135778903961,
-0.7392081618309021,
0.5659080743789673,
0.1219334602355957,
-0.4566924571990967,
0.2669978439807892,
-0.32998764514923096,
-0.7887623310089111,
0.37446779012680054,
0.47778844833374023,
-0.7345215082168579,
-0.630452036857605,
-0.7053151726722717,
0.4901334345340729,
-0.9188170433044434,
1.225730538368225,
0.12370291352272034,
-0.08432315289974213,
0.005207019858062267,
-0.11550038307905197,
-0.04669710621237755,
-0.31403297185897827,
-0.9688028693199158,
-0.14986595511436462,
0.6614870429039001,
0.22594691812992096,
0.7870486378669739,
0.8591846227645874,
0.2940402626991272,
0.29249107837677,
-0.23602965474128723,
0.7643895149230957,
-0.613335371017456,
-0.08812902122735977,
-0.1937219500541687,
-0.5697327256202698,
-0.02294510044157505,
0.20687049627304077,
0.6430609822273254,
0.5398792028427124,
0.2544887959957123,
0.05202903598546982,
-0.014644858427345753,
0.7401450872421265,
-0.369424968957901,
-0.12214308977127075,
-1.0862715244293213,
0.12304511666297913,
-0.33412662148475647,
-0.22109785676002502,
-0.4756418466567993,
-0.14871567487716675,
-0.2552623748779297,
-0.5912672281265259,
0.3527078926563263,
0.18368308246135712,
1.044825553894043,
0.23788312077522278,
-0.6198585629463196,
-0.5342108011245728,
-0.8977062702178955,
0.7731806039810181,
-0.66778963804245,
0.09099104255437851,
0.26501110196113586,
0.012002570554614067,
-0.6045745015144348,
-0.6244502067565918,
-1.0338791608810425,
-0.3109853267669678,
-0.18453918397426605,
-0.0825633630156517,
-0.257638543844223,
-0.1998003125190735,
-0.0047330092638731,
0.4367815852165222,
-0.4260534644126892,
0.371499240398407,
-0.29453277587890625,
-0.28391531109809875,
0.6676792502403259,
0.19315069913864136,
0.33929842710494995,
0.012799561955034733,
-0.1594194620847702,
0.05179606005549431,
-0.7491227984428406,
-0.18025079369544983,
0.5924277305603027,
0.30046799778938293,
0.01569381356239319,
0.6664698719978333,
-0.22282584011554718,
0.6816092729568481,
0.03417998179793358,
-0.38204246759414673,
0.09143827855587006,
-0.3527500331401825,
0.004880771040916443,
0.1651923954486847,
0.9144913554191589,
0.20350602269172668,
0.45242953300476074,
-0.09486862272024155,
-0.41514018177986145,
0.3026835024356842,
0.4005502462387085,
-0.502837061882019,
0.06905003637075424,
0.14545714855194092,
-0.21171046793460846,
-0.48333755135536194,
0.0044856686145067215,
-0.37310290336608887,
-0.4900817275047302,
-0.19613982737064362,
0.3359377682209015,
-0.16242164373397827,
-0.10304165631532669,
0.048753347247838974,
-0.13471165299415588,
0.2686617970466614,
0.26419150829315186,
-0.7244800925254822,
0.07439322769641876,
0.7199952602386475,
0.9370792508125305,
-0.4507519602775574,
-0.2507398724555969,
-0.6603178977966309,
0.10221201926469803,
-0.6677941679954529,
1.1631795167922974,
-0.24876396358013153,
-0.14714281260967255,
0.13982219994068146,
0.18552781641483307,
0.03353912755846977,
-0.5932206511497498,
0.5833598375320435,
-0.5492867827415466,
0.11451708525419235,
0.027566928416490555,
-0.5457050800323486,
0.008102848194539547,
0.47566652297973633,
-0.89718097448349,
0.8055396676063538,
0.054017871618270874,
-0.6836528182029724,
0.44149816036224365,
-0.13078512251377106,
-0.9846943616867065,
-0.27642038464546204,
0.001977714942768216,
-0.46416836977005005,
0.22922199964523315,
0.1708725094795227,
0.36315298080444336,
0.0711071565747261,
0.2671634554862976,
0.1323051154613495,
-0.4590895473957062,
0.2760607898235321,
-0.7665297389030457,
0.30537423491477966,
0.372496098279953,
-0.3480035066604614,
-0.2213888168334961,
-0.9328306317329407,
-0.32447147369384766,
-0.11234568804502487,
-0.7282293438911438,
-0.2660517692565918,
0.359881192445755,
-0.03596794977784157,
-0.04112865775823593,
0.17041489481925964,
-0.4421117305755615,
0.1153881698846817,
-0.5849230885505676,
0.3956835865974426,
0.5355131030082703,
-0.24671798944473267,
0.3700655400753021,
-0.6784364581108093,
0.30550578236579895,
0.20579704642295837,
-0.18815161287784576,
-0.4175035059452057,
-0.46432656049728394,
-1.0628300905227661,
-0.2563566565513611,
0.21284320950508118,
0.426249235868454,
-0.8449326157569885,
0.22894780337810516,
-0.18582552671432495,
-0.6865254044532776,
-0.6500530242919922,
0.42248809337615967,
0.23355720937252045,
0.22239580750465393,
0.18745851516723633,
-0.0670899748802185,
-0.3939349055290222,
-0.8975034356117249,
-0.6724901795387268,
0.0976291224360466,
0.047795191407203674,
-0.05611550435423851,
0.2215704321861267,
-0.22247840464115143,
0.8679983019828796,
-0.17992186546325684,
-0.36907219886779785,
-0.325235515832901,
0.2791038453578949,
0.5638559460639954,
0.38239020109176636,
0.4933455288410187,
-1.0213394165039062,
-0.3812218904495239,
0.11819746345281601,
-0.6830364465713501,
0.06156503036618233,
-0.33657222986221313,
0.0638263151049614,
0.44660231471061707,
0.4927278459072113,
-0.9128973484039307,
0.23622845113277435,
0.6513358354568481,
-0.12270727008581161,
0.44116121530532837,
-0.17118869721889496,
0.061807550489902496,
-1.1769330501556396,
-0.20571617782115936,
0.18688705563545227,
-0.5367536544799805,
-0.6804828643798828,
0.15144214034080505,
-0.28274428844451904,
-0.019711995497345924,
-0.7649155855178833,
0.6909856796264648,
-0.41564276814460754,
-0.02277838997542858,
-0.5626826882362366,
0.023671602830290794,
-0.01480055321007967,
0.31097331643104553,
0.1919335126876831,
0.8397677540779114,
0.06793202459812164,
-0.7193151712417603,
0.3620859384536743,
-0.050677306950092316,
-0.6820147633552551,
0.25954949855804443,
-0.46114039421081543,
0.10277795791625977,
-0.3823245167732239,
0.509105384349823,
-0.8368077278137207,
-0.37907978892326355,
0.24371272325515747,
-0.37338894605636597,
0.06093461066484451,
0.026732977479696274,
-0.7557541728019714,
-0.26830217242240906,
-0.26710137724876404,
0.1837485283613205,
0.3381320834159851,
-0.6319523453712463,
0.4581744074821472,
0.3343179523944855,
-0.07971753180027008,
-0.2874354422092438,
-0.8321301937103271,
0.3686131238937378,
-0.1094619408249855,
-0.5569126009941101,
0.32991519570350647,
0.07922729104757309,
-0.23036037385463715,
0.13081379234790802,
-0.15289880335330963,
-0.16171589493751526,
0.16082897782325745,
-0.03124220296740532,
-0.14584583044052124,
-0.25105613470077515,
0.18215171992778778,
0.2849307060241699,
-0.06351522356271744,
-0.08401942998170853,
-0.44495686888694763,
0.4764697551727295,
0.08619975298643112,
-0.2132205069065094,
-0.6527333855628967,
0.324393093585968,
0.7133821845054626,
-0.1121387854218483,
0.8614787459373474,
0.7582286596298218,
-0.4607614278793335,
-0.5662124752998352,
-0.5392560958862305,
-0.15960419178009033,
-0.4852030277252197,
0.20173460245132446,
0.0077194105833768845,
-0.7212413549423218,
0.2164345234632492,
-0.04634792357683182,
0.1966879963874817,
0.6609739661216736,
0.630744457244873,
-0.15454044938087463,
1.3835935592651367,
0.4799724817276001,
-0.1510484516620636,
0.3706337511539459,
-0.22709834575653076,
0.21225109696388245,
-0.18729281425476074,
-0.19270005822181702,
-0.6407991647720337,
-0.5683711767196655,
-0.911762535572052,
-0.1571321040391922,
0.45856839418411255,
-0.24586467444896698,
-0.019803868606686592,
0.2733527421951294,
-0.46452605724334717,
0.729570209980011,
0.8433833122253418,
0.042729754000902176,
0.858328640460968,
0.24786950647830963,
0.2312847524881363,
0.25104060769081116,
-0.7015841007232666,
-0.7748236656188965,
0.7559494972229004,
0.13625584542751312,
0.7732255458831787,
-0.19735032320022583,
0.529024064540863,
0.5923982858657837,
0.46223708987236023,
-0.9303506016731262,
0.3523999750614166,
-0.7395358085632324,
-0.5279625058174133,
-0.01855618692934513,
-0.333597332239151,
-0.8898714184761047,
0.027756690979003906,
-0.5337218642234802,
-0.2636197805404663,
-0.014106049202382565,
0.13306525349617004,
-0.27360817790031433,
0.39239874482154846,
-0.6016501188278198,
0.4533112943172455,
-0.17747417092323303,
-0.29126694798469543,
-0.3132960796356201,
-0.15656442940235138,
0.31488609313964844,
-0.276065856218338,
0.6693998575210571,
-0.3066699206829071,
-0.0739484578371048,
0.42807096242904663,
-0.3877277970314026,
1.0909667015075684,
0.31275486946105957,
-0.30788153409957886,
0.5589990019798279,
0.16931192576885223,
0.7457261681556702,
0.30800583958625793,
-0.16203737258911133,
0.263792484998703,
-0.05490574240684509,
-0.40264758467674255,
-0.34591758251190186,
0.8521236777305603,
-0.9085352420806885,
-0.769953191280365,
-0.490896999835968,
-0.47617340087890625,
-0.04030560702085495,
0.23873034119606018,
0.5392143130302429,
0.2122652679681778,
-0.0505451001226902,
0.16749264299869537,
0.4547576904296875,
-0.2230938971042633,
0.3602800667285919,
0.6336730122566223,
0.2094082534313202,
-0.04495067149400711,
1.1011544466018677,
0.041381724178791046,
0.05539882928133011,
0.34069815278053284,
0.07373076677322388,
-0.04314856603741646,
-0.6389656066894531,
-0.8140988945960999,
-0.008349001407623291,
-0.21782749891281128,
-0.3355972468852997,
-0.6194661259651184,
-0.5044264197349548,
0.07385580986738205,
-0.26124006509780884,
-0.5018383860588074,
-0.28611472249031067,
-0.7069992423057556,
-0.060641296207904816,
0.1738859862089157,
0.7662498950958252,
-0.025821413844823837,
0.48540472984313965,
-0.9978917837142944,
0.5234231352806091,
0.22521042823791504,
0.10738614946603775,
-0.33669379353523254,
-0.3330104351043701,
-0.4404650330543518,
0.65501868724823,
-0.3541373610496521,
-0.7245310544967651,
0.631238579750061,
0.385931134223938,
0.25006332993507385,
0.5541866421699524,
0.11401352286338806,
0.3090382516384125,
-0.48740091919898987,
0.8310410380363464,
-0.14771215617656708,
-0.789854884147644,
0.5897296667098999,
-0.5353642106056213,
0.11781331151723862,
0.4718509316444397,
0.6314980387687683,
-0.332493394613266,
-0.8962844014167786,
-0.23068708181381226,
-0.6441432237625122,
0.5395968556404114,
0.11561743915081024,
0.8323767185211182,
-0.6070467233657837,
0.4277285039424896,
0.23890992999076843,
0.3979641795158386,
-1.0122382640838623,
0.05035664141178131,
0.0375441275537014,
-0.2884231209754944,
-0.047882791608572006,
-0.14689438045024872,
0.043455660343170166,
-0.11998419463634491,
0.6477068066596985,
-0.23593084514141083,
-0.051429204642772675,
0.31872132420539856,
-0.10637213289737701,
-0.3500005900859833,
0.08733717352151871,
0.4124111235141754,
0.42054483294487,
0.2121013104915619,
0.24347569048404694,
0.0057702562771737576,
-0.27761346101760864,
0.24413089454174042,
-0.08162002265453339,
-0.5332818031311035,
0.2987881600856781,
0.7043290138244629,
0.7254104018211365,
0.3080742359161377,
-1.0400258302688599,
0.49451735615730286,
0.07935500144958496,
-0.27712395787239075,
-0.6074375510215759,
0.3886767029762268,
0.06048284098505974,
0.2913907766342163,
0.4834608733654022,
0.027964653447270393,
-0.03781247138977051,
-0.9516226649284363,
0.013598568737506866,
0.5371848940849304,
-0.29931870102882385,
-0.2920314371585846,
0.6421282291412354,
0.25958889722824097,
-0.39490747451782227,
0.8012019395828247,
-0.44639846682548523,
-0.4833414852619171,
0.8792533278465271,
0.6612904071807861,
0.44334083795547485,
0.1886591911315918,
0.5290874242782593,
0.0772213414311409,
0.4549625813961029,
-0.3652741312980652,
-0.00004191258267383091,
0.39225468039512634,
-1.1683591604232788,
-0.6408976912498474,
-0.8458857536315918,
-0.2587789297103882,
0.3208843469619751,
-0.32211247086524963,
0.4999755620956421,
-0.46572595834732056,
-0.07996740937232971,
0.24144460260868073,
0.06808475404977798,
-0.6468181014060974,
0.2273571789264679,
0.25340378284454346,
1.077839732170105,
-0.8351985216140747,
0.7052465677261353,
0.803312361240387,
-0.046215735375881195,
-0.6087778806686401,
0.004115403164178133,
0.07774896174669266,
-0.8332932591438293,
0.3426015377044678,
0.3922840654850006,
0.14044193923473358,
0.16361784934997559,
-0.7646060585975647,
-0.46976935863494873,
0.8759683966636658,
0.4293903112411499,
-0.7910538911819458,
-0.16877079010009766,
0.35071349143981934,
0.800930917263031,
-0.42950794100761414,
-0.05157265439629555,
0.6102361083030701,
0.6572542786598206,
0.19253233075141907,
-0.6730877161026001,
-0.2670080065727234,
-0.039292652159929276,
-0.36246734857559204,
0.15435977280139923,
-0.934255838394165,
0.8102165460586548,
-0.324474573135376,
-0.4538182318210602,
0.2110794633626938,
0.6415418982505798,
-0.005792751908302307,
0.7167360186576843,
0.5704463124275208,
0.5321722030639648,
0.5554395914077759,
-0.09165998548269272,
1.1313363313674927,
-0.39136847853660583,
0.013450209982693195,
0.7788227796554565,
-0.01458226889371872,
0.8096055388450623,
0.34412333369255066,
0.10196206718683243,
0.6830148100852966,
0.7736683487892151,
-0.23182378709316254,
0.37762734293937683,
0.4285396933555603,
-0.503673255443573,
-0.496907502412796,
-0.5154590010643005,
-0.06198824569582939,
0.7690682411193848,
0.34942489862442017,
-0.41681069135665894,
-0.13181297481060028,
0.03763175755739212,
0.21708057820796967,
0.3175313174724579,
-0.43158721923828125,
0.9450471997261047,
0.22327931225299835,
-0.8668535947799683,
0.4423868954181671,
0.3190179169178009,
0.7217012047767639,
-0.5030106902122498,
0.07338026165962219,
-0.5676561594009399,
-0.04337843134999275,
-0.24665813148021698,
-0.5768225193023682,
0.5614481568336487,
0.32325953245162964,
-0.3344551920890808,
-0.05298234149813652,
0.6610355377197266,
-0.4549563527107239,
-0.8023459911346436,
0.08795984834432602,
0.6488692164421082,
0.011442764662206173,
-0.2710323631763458,
-0.134030282497406,
0.09501461684703827,
-0.11518242955207825,
-0.45227667689323425,
0.28225407004356384,
0.4745228588581085,
-0.13546232879161835,
0.6398256421089172,
1.101704478263855,
0.311928927898407,
-0.027563834562897682,
-0.1855764240026474,
0.9237420558929443,
-0.5292091965675354,
-0.2955383062362671,
-0.8924952745437622,
0.023945143446326256,
0.055558983236551285,
-0.23692813515663147,
0.4466429650783539,
0.493234783411026,
1.0864262580871582,
-0.02221512235701084,
0.8160833716392517,
0.20859450101852417,
0.34886693954467773,
-0.7743497490882874,
0.7683403491973877,
-0.7515812516212463,
0.34836262464523315,
0.16021722555160522,
-0.9699616432189941,
-0.16813290119171143,
0.3328315317630768,
0.1090422123670578,
-0.2647016644477844,
0.5116090178489685,
0.8517158031463623,
-0.09788256138563156,
0.04991234838962555,
0.21172143518924713,
0.5509291291236877,
0.1640663892030716,
0.4768100380897522,
1.046386957168579,
-0.13819900155067444,
0.8178730010986328,
-0.11663975566625595,
-0.026914840564131737,
-0.03831407055258751,
-1.1226955652236938,
-0.9507080316543579,
-0.32605645060539246,
-0.08655626326799393,
-0.18384329974651337,
0.40437325835227966,
0.7767266631126404,
0.7660572528839111,
-0.7785041332244873,
0.1444869041442871,
-0.22027325630187988,
0.4378771185874939,
-0.20064681768417358,
-0.195292130112648,
0.14068083465099335,
-0.4796685576438904,
-1.2275325059890747,
0.5344502925872803,
-0.0062186443246901035,
0.0507521852850914,
-0.3149949610233307,
0.14275230467319489,
-0.08643127977848053,
0.26323068141937256,
0.5505827069282532,
0.2251071035861969,
-0.45581623911857605,
-0.30786362290382385,
-0.13434436917304993,
-0.21839311718940735,
-0.15959641337394714,
0.6915647387504578,
-0.9949033856391907,
0.12819385528564453,
0.37001824378967285,
0.7264177203178406,
0.4808400571346283,
-0.09590926766395569,
0.5892502069473267,
-0.838821291923523,
0.1951003223657608,
0.11302492767572403,
0.10656340420246124,
0.3536769449710846,
-0.5229871869087219,
0.3486885726451874,
0.38682854175567627,
-0.31517672538757324,
-0.5779154896736145,
0.12976917624473572,
-0.628780722618103,
-0.31438374519348145,
1.3168038129806519,
0.08473726361989975,
-0.3432498872280121,
0.031046979129314423,
-0.17397597432136536,
0.11124509572982788,
-0.21965400874614716,
1.0695605278015137,
0.663971483707428,
0.27164608240127563,
0.15593375265598297,
-0.6403519511222839,
0.646153450012207,
0.19729503989219666,
-0.7530153393745422,
-0.48143792152404785,
0.48002320528030396,
0.2833171486854553,
0.1746937334537506,
0.4652557969093323,
0.2024848461151123,
0.18602359294891357,
-0.1487317979335785,
-0.497488796710968,
-0.1736660897731781,
-0.5350877046585083,
0.12051556259393692,
-0.00875829253345728,
-0.025007260963320732,
0.1831168234348297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12125v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12125v1
|
Efficient Sequential Decision Making with Large Language Models
| 2024-06-17T22:13:22 | 2024-06-17T22:13:22 |
Dingyang Chen, Qi Zhang, Yinglun Zhu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
This paper focuses on extending the success of large language models (LLMs)
to sequential decision making. Existing efforts either (i) re-train or finetune
LLMs for decision making, or (ii) design prompts for pretrained LLMs. The
former approach suffers from the computational burden of gradient updates, and
the latter approach does not show promising results. In this paper, we propose
a new approach that leverages online model selection algorithms to efficiently
incorporate LLMs agents into sequential decision making. Statistically, our
approach significantly outperforms both traditional decision making algorithms
and vanilla LLM agents. Computationally, our approach avoids the need for
expensive gradient updates of LLMs, and throughout the decision making process,
it requires only a small number of LLM calls. We conduct extensive experiments
to verify the effectiveness of our proposed approach. As an example, on a
large-scale Amazon dataset, our approach achieves more than a $6$x performance
gain over baselines while calling LLMs in only $1.5$\% of the time steps.
|
[
-0.27584901452064514,
-0.7099136114120483,
0.8731840252876282,
0.5752593278884888,
-0.10853813588619232,
0.3569171726703644,
-0.5946425199508667,
-0.33944380283355713,
0.10211269557476044,
0.4866364598274231,
-0.6097060441970825,
-0.3559485375881195,
-0.31235823035240173,
0.20824916660785675,
-0.23750856518745422,
0.5541701912879944,
0.03909450024366379,
0.26941514015197754,
0.02765536867082119,
0.04773499444127083,
-0.21943438053131104,
-0.21336142718791962,
-1.4232702255249023,
-0.4882190525531769,
0.5869624018669128,
0.20746740698814392,
0.6330311894416809,
0.6030489206314087,
0.4000207483768463,
0.41949883103370667,
-0.05703235790133476,
0.23215848207473755,
-0.4922967553138733,
0.27227774262428284,
-0.17737488448619843,
-0.5984508991241455,
-0.38517436385154724,
-0.23080560564994812,
0.7299355268478394,
0.7321749329566956,
-0.40576496720314026,
0.12495081126689911,
-0.044917311519384384,
0.7678484916687012,
-0.5266406536102295,
0.02249365858733654,
-0.7011168599128723,
0.3550936281681061,
-0.02085217833518982,
-0.2011631578207016,
-0.8258036375045776,
-0.5804144144058228,
0.26418906450271606,
-0.5924229621887207,
-0.07622361928224564,
0.20089490711688995,
0.12469188868999481,
0.25905266404151917,
-0.19111278653144836,
-0.17410454154014587,
-0.9024292826652527,
0.9326731562614441,
-0.7897211909294128,
0.5776088833808899,
0.32292672991752625,
0.321158766746521,
-0.3708118796348572,
-0.9656000733375549,
-0.4088471531867981,
-0.5572212934494019,
0.09869644045829773,
-0.09245148301124573,
0.11114008724689484,
-0.02878829836845398,
0.4151290953159332,
-0.06341610848903656,
-0.4562733769416809,
0.693286657333374,
0.03477118909358978,
0.1511213630437851,
0.658781886100769,
0.21730729937553406,
-0.08960197865962982,
0.26084598898887634,
-0.22065404057502747,
-0.07413047552108765,
-0.8102495670318604,
-0.09142367541790009,
0.26049965620040894,
0.377415269613266,
0.1073986366391182,
0.3076905608177185,
-0.2766776978969574,
0.7980783581733704,
0.2487647384405136,
-0.3197639286518097,
0.29394975304603577,
-0.20473389327526093,
-0.2383066713809967,
-0.17567040026187897,
0.8001781702041626,
0.1955670863389969,
0.360755056142807,
-0.1068517193198204,
-0.44841334223747253,
-0.2985207438468933,
0.07557757198810577,
-0.929714560508728,
0.08333013951778412,
0.4377523362636566,
-0.5542788505554199,
-0.20916764438152313,
-0.30315038561820984,
-0.767476499080658,
-0.6259719133377075,
-0.46415436267852783,
0.21487349271774292,
-0.04204625263810158,
0.0163487046957016,
0.12259254604578018,
-0.01795043796300888,
0.10801738500595093,
0.7944936156272888,
-0.9194190502166748,
0.35273241996765137,
0.6032326221466064,
0.987857460975647,
-0.19246307015419006,
-0.22622215747833252,
-0.7433080077171326,
-0.06080878525972366,
-0.6876676678657532,
0.7640277147293091,
-0.6084835529327393,
-0.4564661681652069,
0.0561407133936882,
-0.24212123453617096,
0.15057876706123352,
-0.6290977597236633,
0.41449353098869324,
-0.8864361643791199,
0.04075152799487114,
-0.017494646832346916,
-0.4696030020713806,
-0.004068299662321806,
0.17416536808013916,
-0.8200031518936157,
0.9918938875198364,
-0.13284701108932495,
-0.46090516448020935,
0.4284338355064392,
-0.327003538608551,
-0.4487176239490509,
-0.031944531947374344,
-0.2158326953649521,
-0.3814891576766968,
-0.05908888578414917,
0.17305703461170197,
0.6396923065185547,
-0.5653570890426636,
0.25929808616638184,
-0.5488531589508057,
-0.2113831490278244,
0.1742437183856964,
-0.07885263860225677,
0.6347097158432007,
0.28596988320350647,
-0.3221130669116974,
0.2664337754249573,
-0.7644843459129333,
0.0689471885561943,
0.15170195698738098,
-0.6091892719268799,
-0.19037850201129913,
0.5126538276672363,
-0.2862780690193176,
0.2399265468120575,
0.17352664470672607,
-0.20355330407619476,
0.5079666972160339,
-0.26437559723854065,
0.4183852970600128,
1.0103541612625122,
-0.2677408754825592,
0.7383245825767517,
-0.4800797402858734,
0.5525728464126587,
-0.4489646255970001,
0.12606102228164673,
-0.0021753800101578236,
-0.4458654224872589,
-1.0738166570663452,
-0.4799557626247406,
0.5642151832580566,
0.6409229040145874,
-0.8413525819778442,
0.5138736367225647,
-0.2642621397972107,
-0.34729427099227905,
-0.33443310856819153,
0.09855461865663528,
0.04336601495742798,
0.03126034140586853,
0.14002256095409393,
-0.25487440824508667,
-0.6666457653045654,
-0.6416743993759155,
-0.057951316237449646,
-0.04714261367917061,
-0.15101271867752075,
0.13330435752868652,
0.3329489529132843,
-0.36376118659973145,
0.9730398654937744,
-0.4330436587333679,
-0.05200505256652832,
-0.3202514350414276,
0.15687012672424316,
0.4302482306957245,
0.20878636837005615,
0.4513765573501587,
-0.393844336271286,
-0.5698421001434326,
0.15441429615020752,
-0.6512937545776367,
-0.07805521786212921,
-0.5580980777740479,
-0.05137895047664642,
0.20576609671115875,
0.6461771130561829,
-0.7593526244163513,
-0.0013633809285238385,
0.23893707990646362,
0.08407822996377945,
0.21565815806388855,
-0.35028940439224243,
-0.10058575868606567,
-0.7010969519615173,
-0.10230683535337448,
0.06677189469337463,
-0.5116091966629028,
-0.6369960904121399,
0.04856554791331291,
-0.06491171568632126,
0.17240308225154877,
-0.4832843244075775,
0.8046872019767761,
-0.7089247703552246,
-0.3344345986843109,
-0.11821270734071732,
0.1280965954065323,
-0.49615585803985596,
0.6023731231689453,
0.19421268999576569,
0.4904422461986542,
0.5702728629112244,
-0.7188146710395813,
0.2807832956314087,
0.057334449142217636,
-0.7520855665206909,
0.03867613896727562,
-0.5513799786567688,
0.35027727484703064,
-0.44923415780067444,
0.6522616147994995,
-0.6887606978416443,
0.06076737865805626,
0.24505051970481873,
-0.09355722367763519,
0.1988377720117569,
-0.03352280333638191,
-0.5264135599136353,
-0.333845317363739,
-0.5084548592567444,
0.15994369983673096,
0.5517926216125488,
-0.6852594017982483,
0.8264278173446655,
0.2806747555732727,
-0.4742303192615509,
-0.46641620993614197,
-0.6283375024795532,
-0.03819608315825462,
-0.23312728106975555,
-0.46985679864883423,
0.1855868250131607,
-0.3535515069961548,
-0.5462828874588013,
-0.29500311613082886,
0.2504090368747711,
0.1821787804365158,
0.23722395300865173,
-0.11050449311733246,
0.23566147685050964,
-0.08193720132112503,
-0.016307031735777855,
-0.3198569118976593,
-0.10366597026586533,
-0.1722889393568039,
-0.6053832173347473,
0.655900776386261,
0.21388520300388336,
-0.16736404597759247,
-0.29068517684936523,
0.18296177685260773,
0.5611832141876221,
-0.27405500411987305,
0.7093234062194824,
0.2803767919540405,
-0.267605185508728,
-0.8896586298942566,
-0.6410697102546692,
-0.21405422687530518,
-0.4974612295627594,
0.3307775557041168,
-0.20725750923156738,
-0.8355302810668945,
0.5140492916107178,
-0.33076348900794983,
0.313383013010025,
0.09679744392633438,
0.7928715944290161,
0.07504052668809891,
1.1630749702453613,
0.2793577313423157,
0.007645462639629841,
0.9132067561149597,
-0.14919233322143555,
0.16562481224536896,
-0.4805572032928467,
-0.1270405799150467,
-0.4326082766056061,
-0.2520000636577606,
-0.6987276673316956,
-0.7620756030082703,
0.35164132714271545,
-0.054930731654167175,
-0.40905067324638367,
-0.09685984998941422,
-0.0037921264301985502,
0.5213468074798584,
0.5467804074287415,
0.1467948704957962,
0.3589058816432953,
0.05003519356250763,
-0.11856797337532043,
0.2309240698814392,
-0.7644522190093994,
-0.39376741647720337,
1.1927789449691772,
0.3545363247394562,
0.7835304141044617,
0.2786306142807007,
0.5930428504943848,
0.4002957046031952,
0.5503626465797424,
-0.876539409160614,
0.78132563829422,
0.0023102310951799154,
-0.2567381262779236,
-0.43673279881477356,
-0.573417603969574,
-1.1252918243408203,
0.6522387266159058,
-0.5174860954284668,
-0.550814151763916,
0.07289458811283112,
0.016132371500134468,
-0.7405552268028259,
0.1267409771680832,
-0.49416854977607727,
0.458413302898407,
-0.5362621545791626,
-0.49185726046562195,
-0.5575168132781982,
-0.585867166519165,
0.2956662178039551,
-0.5829746127128601,
0.40483617782592773,
-0.018305694684386253,
-0.2470894306898117,
0.7708250284194946,
-0.5585274696350098,
0.7961252331733704,
0.07526561617851257,
-0.04127226769924164,
0.2388385832309723,
-0.0036187656223773956,
1.0569714307785034,
-0.17898230254650116,
-0.4074386954307556,
-0.0028824415057897568,
-0.5392759442329407,
0.032594554126262665,
-0.7079052925109863,
0.7816328406333923,
-0.6903380155563354,
-0.605835497379303,
-0.50606769323349,
-0.04312277212738991,
-0.5026629567146301,
0.3429381549358368,
-0.09783230721950531,
0.41454577445983887,
-0.12372932583093643,
0.13075187802314758,
0.4593486487865448,
-0.3826102614402771,
0.7255005836486816,
0.8342668414115906,
-0.5330687761306763,
-0.548038899898529,
0.7348027229309082,
0.21106740832328796,
0.357963502407074,
0.5010814666748047,
0.4513263702392578,
-0.5338762998580933,
-0.9540758728981018,
-0.26973143219947815,
0.23537077009677887,
-0.6743667721748352,
0.0007659196853637695,
-0.4923972189426422,
0.15040655434131622,
-0.26032790541648865,
-0.06351598352193832,
-0.17038178443908691,
-0.4207036793231964,
-0.23144960403442383,
-0.13825012743473053,
0.09410814940929413,
0.9053344130516052,
-0.07695573568344116,
0.39771923422813416,
-0.7919173240661621,
0.33431312441825867,
0.39301732182502747,
0.3966458737850189,
0.415963739156723,
-0.4352031350135803,
-0.17419417202472687,
-0.18885540962219238,
-0.2760072350502014,
-0.672236979007721,
0.4414946436882019,
0.13167434930801392,
0.726467490196228,
0.38189151883125305,
-0.12026359885931015,
0.6551229357719421,
-0.9135622978210449,
0.3925524055957794,
0.12666179239749908,
-0.7014074921607971,
0.39641833305358887,
-0.47684210538864136,
0.19603799283504486,
0.5304486155509949,
0.48308637738227844,
-0.421254962682724,
-0.1805112510919571,
-0.475615918636322,
-0.8487693071365356,
0.8246452808380127,
0.10100910812616348,
-0.26947474479675293,
0.02645137533545494,
0.057694610208272934,
0.06954128295183182,
0.3023196756839752,
-0.5152732133865356,
-0.364719957113266,
0.4979504942893982,
0.08668570220470428,
-0.2284024953842163,
-0.0316552072763443,
0.13276992738246918,
-0.334513396024704,
0.6444485187530518,
-0.1718245893716812,
0.03391072154045105,
-0.06399688869714737,
-0.03640782833099365,
-0.07327067106962204,
0.08255382627248764,
0.41296592354774475,
0.7726424932479858,
-0.10839547961950302,
-0.25880908966064453,
0.37136489152908325,
0.005998543929308653,
0.06521821022033691,
0.07020943611860275,
-0.23888175189495087,
-0.1310928910970688,
0.4040307104587555,
0.9330609440803528,
0.3854160010814667,
-0.8215864896774292,
0.27599695324897766,
-0.16248582303524017,
0.024108216166496277,
-0.5354836583137512,
-0.20956607162952423,
0.06471746414899826,
0.5384567379951477,
0.27167823910713196,
0.2008172869682312,
0.06287617236375809,
-0.6841041445732117,
0.17489881813526154,
0.4403286278247833,
0.39352893829345703,
0.04926611855626106,
0.3633435070514679,
0.5878244638442993,
-0.4467763304710388,
0.7166415452957153,
-0.2698194086551666,
-0.4417061507701874,
0.5367287397384644,
0.3372422754764557,
0.8388136029243469,
-0.24071674048900604,
0.3085947036743164,
0.340917706489563,
0.07641338557004929,
-0.8225840926170349,
0.15526661276817322,
0.06338419765233994,
-0.9101864695549011,
-0.6228349208831787,
-0.623604416847229,
-0.6036144495010376,
0.06088857725262642,
-0.26192209124565125,
0.5100537538528442,
-1.004331350326538,
-0.31891709566116333,
-0.1963861733675003,
-0.05163539946079254,
-0.6868782043457031,
0.18913006782531738,
0.4694163203239441,
0.9337573051452637,
-0.4091395437717438,
0.8448947668075562,
0.381116658449173,
-0.05615079030394554,
-0.5912672281265259,
-0.16627441346645355,
0.08260959386825562,
-0.8687593340873718,
0.6914747953414917,
0.04578619450330734,
-0.19221770763397217,
0.22593382000923157,
-0.34907060861587524,
-0.9933764934539795,
1.0819586515426636,
0.530744194984436,
-0.9935392141342163,
0.10123182088136673,
-0.1611080914735794,
0.4633925259113312,
-0.37637385725975037,
0.7463364005088806,
0.6806658506393433,
0.520382821559906,
0.43716728687286377,
-0.9909977912902832,
-0.04240283742547035,
0.06066111475229263,
-0.053104907274246216,
0.3721553385257721,
-0.7599387764930725,
0.995863139629364,
-0.5632026791572571,
-0.4234205186367035,
0.17342181503772736,
0.7368243336677551,
0.4967021942138672,
-0.0866914838552475,
0.6764708757400513,
0.5956348180770874,
1.172295093536377,
0.1882963478565216,
1.2386242151260376,
-0.10320202261209488,
0.3196397125720978,
1.2904365062713623,
-0.6127606630325317,
1.2451159954071045,
0.15142449736595154,
-0.3537622094154358,
0.4520787298679352,
1.0546821355819702,
-0.03148968517780304,
0.6088842153549194,
0.3596654236316681,
-0.3884042203426361,
-0.6586998701095581,
-0.02433941885828972,
-0.17170728743076324,
0.15926402807235718,
0.20641006529331207,
-0.20819534361362457,
-0.032605063170194626,
-0.2893263101577759,
0.05461561679840088,
-0.26654550433158875,
-0.4268246293067932,
0.7178860306739807,
0.1713562309741974,
-0.9176394939422607,
0.4322032034397125,
0.1682383120059967,
0.7372545599937439,
-0.7837134599685669,
0.053842294961214066,
-0.1408393681049347,
0.41848888993263245,
-0.19741585850715637,
-0.5911129713058472,
-0.24671922624111176,
-0.15433354675769806,
0.029256360605359077,
-0.6482661962509155,
0.4791262149810791,
-0.4934077858924866,
-0.6734886169433594,
0.43528488278388977,
0.6014525294303894,
-0.15621301531791687,
0.06262858211994171,
-0.5796694159507751,
0.24362796545028687,
-0.10629798471927643,
-0.27639228105545044,
0.32736971974372864,
0.1262854039669037,
-0.3484244644641876,
1.0885794162750244,
0.8912108540534973,
0.4327335059642792,
-0.005487381014972925,
0.3113773763179779,
0.5955110788345337,
-0.7175107002258301,
-0.8451025485992432,
-0.9364920854568481,
0.32062724232673645,
-0.1343141496181488,
-0.0981474220752716,
0.5734694600105286,
0.34945136308670044,
0.9136091470718384,
-0.12790866196155548,
1.0505938529968262,
0.2128295749425888,
0.3564232587814331,
-0.892231285572052,
0.3139195144176483,
-0.351310133934021,
0.4982118010520935,
0.09201765060424805,
-0.9523526430130005,
-0.3513961732387543,
0.8216128349304199,
-0.49396249651908875,
0.14667612314224243,
0.861541748046875,
0.8127191066741943,
0.33030179142951965,
0.14373907446861267,
0.15380148589611053,
0.43614858388900757,
0.28193962574005127,
0.5644673705101013,
1.1933115720748901,
0.08965950459241867,
-0.05661822855472565,
0.10684797912836075,
-0.350474089384079,
-0.14469917118549347,
-1.1375638246536255,
-1.1024525165557861,
-0.15390896797180176,
-0.24282413721084595,
0.02043149806559086,
-0.08037422597408295,
1.5884743928909302,
0.6817038655281067,
-0.7555392384529114,
-0.4884396493434906,
0.14928707480430603,
0.24388740956783295,
-0.12909765541553497,
-0.052132803946733475,
0.06126070395112038,
-0.3504916727542877,
-0.7303609251976013,
0.7267301678657532,
-0.016538338735699654,
-0.03129365295171738,
-0.2561373710632324,
-0.336664617061615,
-0.2930879294872284,
0.12968631088733673,
0.895516037940979,
0.17693988978862762,
-0.6860726475715637,
-0.06117437407374382,
-0.37576666474342346,
0.034209080040454865,
0.009822612628340721,
1.1762139797210693,
-0.8679442405700684,
0.26159143447875977,
0.7371149659156799,
0.9587664604187012,
0.614851176738739,
-0.07851078361272812,
0.7725088596343994,
-0.3091873228549957,
0.1320996880531311,
0.28377842903137207,
0.593268632888794,
0.4302683174610138,
0.024325557053089142,
0.44173663854599,
0.19745580852031708,
-0.5065944790840149,
-0.5692487359046936,
0.07457590103149414,
-0.8167325854301453,
-0.3349357843399048,
1.5454076528549194,
0.11233168095350266,
-0.016478918492794037,
-0.015024470165371895,
-0.1876690834760666,
-0.20350632071495056,
-0.6189833283424377,
0.41478362679481506,
0.5945959687232971,
-0.20030555129051208,
-0.029566388577222824,
-0.6369900703430176,
0.4968303442001343,
0.3100285530090332,
-0.7804664373397827,
-0.011745860800147057,
0.6199893951416016,
0.1285255402326584,
-0.136227548122406,
0.9333266019821167,
0.3513104021549225,
-0.12545788288116455,
-0.34886154532432556,
-0.23433835804462433,
0.23178568482398987,
-0.5185753703117371,
-0.5315839052200317,
0.16059213876724243,
0.37463662028312683,
-0.04060157760977745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12117v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12117v1
|
Decoding the Narratives: Analyzing Personal Drug Experiences Shared on Reddit
| 2024-06-17T21:56:57 | 2024-06-17T21:56:57 |
Layla Bouzoubaa, Elham Aghakhani, Max Song, Minh Trinh, Rezvaneh Rezapour
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Online communities such as drug-related subreddits serve as safe spaces for
people who use drugs (PWUD), fostering discussions on substance use
experiences, harm reduction, and addiction recovery. Users' shared narratives
on these forums provide insights into the likelihood of developing a substance
use disorder (SUD) and recovery potential. Our study aims to develop a
multi-level, multi-label classification model to analyze online user-generated
texts about substance use experiences. For this purpose, we first introduce a
novel taxonomy to assess the nature of posts, including their intended
connections (Inquisition or Disclosure), subjects (e.g., Recovery, Dependency),
and specific objectives (e.g., Relapse, Quality, Safety). Using various
multi-label classification algorithms on a set of annotated data, we show that
GPT-4, when prompted with instructions, definitions, and examples, outperformed
all other models. We apply this model to label an additional 1,000 posts and
analyze the categories of linguistic expression used within posts in each
class. Our analysis shows that topics such as Safety, Combination of
Substances, and Mental Health see more disclosure, while discussions about
physiological Effects focus on harm reduction. Our work enriches the
understanding of PWUD's experiences and informs the broader knowledge base on
SUD and drug use.
|
[
-0.3798597455024719,
-0.6675954461097717,
0.7596011161804199,
0.18763256072998047,
0.002606502501294017,
0.2383112907409668,
0.057986460626125336,
-0.7462481260299683,
0.3774665594100952,
0.5821442604064941,
-0.47413134574890137,
-0.9108030200004578,
-0.9288399815559387,
0.35844919085502625,
-0.24932587146759033,
1.550088882446289,
-0.2191213220357895,
-0.19558005034923553,
-0.06990807503461838,
-0.00717263063415885,
-0.7403199076652527,
-0.8248562216758728,
-0.6097920536994934,
-0.06553053855895996,
1.052619457244873,
0.11959292739629745,
0.03899122029542923,
0.08622420579195023,
0.6205458045005798,
0.21549062430858612,
0.13966046273708344,
-0.18962498009204865,
-0.6793990135192871,
-0.09541191905736923,
-0.26258009672164917,
-0.22877731919288635,
-0.34393587708473206,
0.09046941995620728,
0.06299079209566116,
0.590989887714386,
-0.26317745447158813,
0.14653509855270386,
0.16505904495716095,
0.1449836790561676,
-0.6103174090385437,
-0.11762278527021408,
-0.12474147230386734,
0.06436723470687866,
-0.13184459507465363,
-0.34064263105392456,
-0.41689661145210266,
-0.4108399748802185,
0.013085109181702137,
-0.776388943195343,
0.30346429347991943,
0.13063128292560577,
0.6666725277900696,
-0.026555949822068214,
-0.7257004380226135,
-0.4918753504753113,
-0.7500335574150085,
0.40293267369270325,
-0.5414012670516968,
0.22289732098579407,
0.47781509160995483,
0.14178742468357086,
-0.09411750733852386,
-0.9578714966773987,
-0.538703978061676,
0.397306352853775,
-0.6953641176223755,
-0.13657133281230927,
-0.05427271127700806,
0.20479081571102142,
0.21827425062656403,
0.44377610087394714,
-0.6666630506515503,
-0.029845409095287323,
-0.7099403738975525,
-0.39758020639419556,
0.42841836810112,
0.466083824634552,
0.5985706448554993,
-0.26594841480255127,
-0.7633788585662842,
0.34065407514572144,
-0.49245625734329224,
0.0704786628484726,
0.18392875790596008,
0.0541401244699955,
-0.16135725378990173,
0.6194528937339783,
0.07971977442502975,
0.46727702021598816,
-0.28967079520225525,
-0.4533674418926239,
0.4916588366031647,
-0.6421053409576416,
0.022773200646042824,
-0.014587393961846828,
0.956577718257904,
0.926237940788269,
-0.12250154465436935,
-0.08084791153669357,
-0.14792810380458832,
0.06907480955123901,
0.4889087677001953,
-0.9194250106811523,
-0.5781185030937195,
0.22988970577716827,
-0.8842568397521973,
-0.2699532210826874,
-0.03007448837161064,
-0.7931757569313049,
-0.9914913177490234,
-0.13532112538814545,
0.5146934390068054,
-0.19045355916023254,
-0.4557723104953766,
0.08324362337589264,
-0.26929721236228943,
-0.25155046582221985,
0.18710419535636902,
-0.873102068901062,
0.6620249152183533,
0.6042661070823669,
1.0740971565246582,
-0.5114853978157043,
-0.27456653118133545,
-0.1366206258535385,
0.22844935953617096,
0.20425303280353546,
0.9319536089897156,
-0.3393919765949249,
-0.37936675548553467,
-0.011147272773087025,
0.3823704719543457,
-0.029994143173098564,
-0.49660825729370117,
0.8731846809387207,
-0.4188578724861145,
0.15296849608421326,
-0.4974188804626465,
-0.729399561882019,
-0.31202083826065063,
0.23960921168327332,
-0.6051839590072632,
0.3446720242500305,
0.057031478732824326,
-1.1389306783676147,
0.6193434000015259,
-0.8214213252067566,
-0.2669866979122162,
0.057322777807712555,
0.057544365525245667,
-0.07389339059591293,
0.14046837389469147,
0.0031240375246852636,
0.3096633851528168,
0.02413497306406498,
0.17979557812213898,
-0.0830686166882515,
-0.344234436750412,
0.3169316053390503,
-0.280575692653656,
0.7590782642364502,
0.2495749145746231,
0.1804523468017578,
0.2691533863544464,
-0.6191942691802979,
-0.2787190079689026,
-0.24259421229362488,
-0.5074812173843384,
-0.6884952187538147,
-0.29818689823150635,
0.20869067311286926,
0.27899354696273804,
-0.024729730561375618,
-0.8152936100959778,
0.029611511155962944,
-0.21392224729061127,
0.30817487835884094,
0.5319873690605164,
0.7520814538002014,
-0.05129704251885414,
-0.371412456035614,
0.6082342267036438,
0.18042288720607758,
0.1519877314567566,
-0.24684792757034302,
-0.6136518716812134,
-0.13294516503810883,
-0.2723698616027832,
0.26952335238456726,
0.5032247304916382,
-0.5846015810966492,
0.2092094123363495,
-0.043714623898267746,
-0.28908073902130127,
-0.49001383781433105,
0.14179731905460358,
0.3500150740146637,
0.692676842212677,
0.7925692796707153,
-0.3298303484916687,
-0.42450404167175293,
-0.9266617298126221,
-0.43472638726234436,
0.14211232960224152,
-0.2254653424024582,
0.2488037645816803,
0.6287241578102112,
-0.4235571324825287,
0.7514938116073608,
-0.8465977907180786,
-0.6565373539924622,
-0.09161112457513809,
0.711135745048523,
-0.05231281369924545,
0.1349835842847824,
0.3164387345314026,
-0.6744544506072998,
-0.649682879447937,
-0.047388408333063126,
-0.6775918006896973,
-0.10188313573598862,
-0.09777497500181198,
-0.06066766008734703,
-0.3673834502696991,
0.18532811105251312,
-0.2569804787635803,
0.44940289855003357,
0.3131130635738373,
-0.6769768595695496,
0.5051806569099426,
-0.262766033411026,
0.35636427998542786,
-0.766357958316803,
-0.14426776766777039,
0.23259811103343964,
0.24236325919628143,
-0.778927206993103,
-0.4138525724411011,
-0.18511223793029785,
-0.07615189254283905,
-0.24861404299736023,
0.2830811142921448,
-0.42924609780311584,
-0.05680513754487038,
-0.28032186627388,
-0.11577173322439194,
0.051453348249197006,
0.27818962931632996,
0.2420206516981125,
0.3643288314342499,
0.5880554914474487,
-0.42705675959587097,
0.22915108501911163,
0.09992033243179321,
-0.4678795039653778,
0.55412757396698,
-0.4278963506221771,
0.011917226016521454,
-0.10041194409132004,
0.2991198003292084,
-1.2200734615325928,
-0.5730144381523132,
0.5419614315032959,
-0.3817671537399292,
0.13709646463394165,
-0.08798767626285553,
-0.43462881445884705,
-0.2596885561943054,
-0.1117548793554306,
0.577314019203186,
0.10823741555213928,
-0.21739207208156586,
0.30741384625434875,
0.8729615211486816,
-0.3466000258922577,
-0.39419543743133545,
-0.46515023708343506,
0.18240703642368317,
-0.5891494750976562,
-0.24908135831356049,
0.34873348474502563,
-0.10569245368242264,
-0.3027878999710083,
0.1742761880159378,
0.16776007413864136,
-0.19470086693763733,
-0.04094991832971573,
0.1836547553539276,
0.03259895741939545,
0.11065816134214401,
0.2932686507701874,
0.1785881221294403,
-0.17737357318401337,
0.35213178396224976,
0.2878910303115845,
0.5519164204597473,
-0.17929385602474213,
0.2769715189933777,
-0.6341233849525452,
0.6213029026985168,
0.2664642930030823,
-0.05950552225112915,
1.1472209692001343,
0.5765843391418457,
-0.39012473821640015,
-0.1680224984884262,
-0.2415822446346283,
-0.2866791784763336,
-0.4261247515678406,
-0.04661356285214424,
-0.2935386598110199,
-0.7570900917053223,
0.3948309123516083,
-0.15880191326141357,
0.10422946512699127,
0.03306583687663078,
0.5382328033447266,
-0.5026336908340454,
0.6744613647460938,
0.4336651861667633,
0.5617721676826477,
-0.07480023056268692,
-0.0884198471903801,
0.3352702558040619,
-0.6490119695663452,
-0.3385649025440216,
0.09671138226985931,
-0.4447922110557556,
-0.3582453429698944,
-0.3855169415473938,
0.5397316217422485,
-0.10714767873287201,
-0.11640030145645142,
0.15069034695625305,
-0.5961127877235413,
0.5859825611114502,
0.2579970955848694,
0.13946422934532166,
0.49152904748916626,
-0.026727044954895973,
0.3399941623210907,
-0.5335869193077087,
-0.36787664890289307,
-0.39338061213493347,
1.0669273138046265,
0.6176354885101318,
0.6107993721961975,
0.12354806810617447,
0.8464933037757874,
0.5570255517959595,
0.8488323092460632,
-0.7228987216949463,
0.349538117647171,
-0.09619995951652527,
-0.6226217150688171,
-0.0027875008527189493,
-0.5135139226913452,
-1.146996259689331,
0.3754664659500122,
-0.40354788303375244,
-0.6643490195274353,
0.13044679164886475,
-0.16538837552070618,
-0.5982782244682312,
0.30801355838775635,
-0.9389174580574036,
0.9635592699050903,
-0.3429562449455261,
0.00885293073952198,
-0.16023430228233337,
-0.8478853702545166,
0.9275716543197632,
-0.333315372467041,
0.8315228223800659,
-0.03976025804877281,
-0.061950236558914185,
1.0744651556015015,
-0.2786550223827362,
0.8439698815345764,
-0.25410211086273193,
-0.2303958684206009,
0.3628263771533966,
-0.035106875002384186,
-0.22830665111541748,
-0.10970775038003922,
0.42745816707611084,
0.19558283686637878,
0.18310607969760895,
-0.06436044722795486,
-0.5781819224357605,
0.8044986128807068,
-0.8458560109138489,
-0.23696765303611755,
-0.25972819328308105,
-0.30889052152633667,
-0.3216283619403839,
0.2709684371948242,
0.3559512495994568,
0.4077436327934265,
-0.008749926462769508,
0.06837686151266098,
0.5071362853050232,
-0.6183087825775146,
0.051197558641433716,
0.15732233226299286,
-0.45276933908462524,
-0.4434835612773895,
0.801933765411377,
0.3166826367378235,
0.0998489186167717,
0.16572506725788116,
0.41668203473091125,
-0.4531584680080414,
-0.647177517414093,
0.0763188898563385,
0.596706748008728,
-0.7305717468261719,
-0.09728120267391205,
-0.7378352284431458,
-0.019581781700253487,
-0.48277631402015686,
0.21484114229679108,
-0.06764764338731766,
-0.22421753406524658,
-0.12325235456228256,
-0.5426693558692932,
0.2301882803440094,
1.187839388847351,
-0.2495037168264389,
0.2577436566352844,
-1.049001693725586,
0.7231001853942871,
0.2046663761138916,
0.5326523780822754,
-0.029855642467737198,
-0.11407790333032608,
-0.08186814188957214,
-0.2474493533372879,
-0.26665905117988586,
-1.274260401725769,
0.3117862343788147,
-0.03170805424451828,
0.6933435797691345,
0.3342202305793762,
0.6411036849021912,
0.3177762031555176,
-0.1625245362520218,
0.7580857276916504,
0.5102236270904541,
-0.455143004655838,
0.5074622631072998,
-0.45218127965927124,
-0.2902432978153229,
0.588245153427124,
0.9377833008766174,
-0.8762233257293701,
-0.0839802697300911,
-0.2972450256347656,
-0.9397011995315552,
0.6145710945129395,
0.22255262732505798,
0.10096345096826553,
-0.23033364117145538,
0.1325473040342331,
0.4991343021392822,
0.12873482704162598,
-1.0770554542541504,
-0.5379514694213867,
-0.18067575991153717,
-0.13673736155033112,
0.22999544441699982,
-0.45718076825141907,
-0.4142114222049713,
-0.20787623524665833,
0.3308246433734894,
0.27253031730651855,
0.25815704464912415,
-0.018529949709773064,
-0.036661162972450256,
0.23331739008426666,
0.4167516827583313,
0.3413100242614746,
0.6699102520942688,
-0.11984699219465256,
0.45831772685050964,
-0.11648061871528625,
-0.6023983359336853,
0.2808876931667328,
-0.322070837020874,
-0.08533596247434616,
-0.2934457063674927,
0.26614829897880554,
0.8341737985610962,
0.12032762914896011,
-0.6512290239334106,
0.4320257306098938,
-0.49205583333969116,
-0.2785803973674774,
0.0028535346500575542,
-0.05591729283332825,
0.10435465723276138,
0.025644123554229736,
0.2480567991733551,
0.11635331064462662,
0.37165966629981995,
-0.9824586510658264,
0.47492823004722595,
-0.29353153705596924,
-0.26572853326797485,
-0.3408387303352356,
0.5163663625717163,
0.3758804500102997,
-0.5027381777763367,
0.4489814341068268,
-0.2425541877746582,
-0.2946957051753998,
0.11987917125225067,
0.4526215195655823,
0.6735036373138428,
0.05234849080443382,
0.4361990988254547,
0.8696839809417725,
-0.09288661181926727,
0.18293921649456024,
-0.21851667761802673,
-0.016842719167470932,
-0.8317845463752747,
0.055137354880571365,
-0.764508843421936,
0.1572689265012741,
0.2961292862892151,
-0.6955247521400452,
0.1286521553993225,
-0.48839741945266724,
-0.48936519026756287,
-0.05969984084367752,
-0.2667810022830963,
-0.3078528940677643,
0.18259207904338837,
0.11142417788505554,
0.3069959580898285,
-1.0354511737823486,
0.5430808663368225,
0.3690457344055176,
-0.44841524958610535,
-0.596920907497406,
0.18452493846416473,
0.08146996051073074,
0.014642184600234032,
0.4303051233291626,
0.2662878930568695,
-0.29924023151397705,
-0.011762232519686222,
-0.17792794108390808,
-0.4988408088684082,
0.9800313711166382,
-0.29300230741500854,
-0.35263916850090027,
-0.008116624318063259,
0.11979309469461441,
0.8172743916511536,
-0.4802510142326355,
-0.06746705621480942,
0.7516111731529236,
0.30519115924835205,
0.22301015257835388,
-0.8991912603378296,
0.005688312463462353,
-0.22493799030780792,
-0.19164463877677917,
0.055358629673719406,
-0.29176074266433716,
0.9178749918937683,
-0.43970412015914917,
-0.6318370699882507,
-0.16448532044887543,
0.24565592408180237,
0.37011322379112244,
0.4462624490261078,
0.5611430406570435,
0.37127193808555603,
1.007577657699585,
0.03966621682047844,
1.0566459894180298,
-0.06106243282556534,
0.5145178437232971,
1.2051433324813843,
-0.12438978999853134,
0.725915789604187,
0.3217613995075226,
-0.16259904205799103,
0.7725699543952942,
0.7391853332519531,
0.005710921715945005,
0.8056129813194275,
0.19547715783119202,
-0.2935539484024048,
-0.09175297617912292,
-0.0941319689154625,
-0.4095374047756195,
0.07095032185316086,
0.7168442606925964,
-0.5675615668296814,
-0.21640489995479584,
0.45164981484413147,
-0.10225003957748413,
0.06172238290309906,
-0.3829561471939087,
0.9543365240097046,
0.10060373693704605,
-0.49916109442710876,
0.40181517601013184,
-0.04157528281211853,
0.6728954315185547,
-0.18779197335243225,
0.03005467914044857,
-0.01813368871808052,
0.20905494689941406,
-0.45209622383117676,
-1.1417522430419922,
0.5113191604614258,
-0.010956265032291412,
-0.025506310164928436,
-0.3992311656475067,
0.942535936832428,
-0.5762443542480469,
-0.482879638671875,
0.4253220558166504,
0.4985446631908417,
0.34232884645462036,
0.2058168649673462,
-0.5258932113647461,
-0.008777613751590252,
-0.11618562042713165,
-0.05510563775897026,
0.43383872509002686,
0.45643219351768494,
0.09626345336437225,
0.5002968311309814,
0.4628870487213135,
0.2085912972688675,
0.15317970514297485,
0.14706535637378693,
0.5122921466827393,
-0.5781360864639282,
-0.5316179990768433,
-0.5488697290420532,
0.5675034523010254,
-0.14244385063648224,
-0.5518143773078918,
0.8606098890304565,
0.5712295770645142,
0.7244321703910828,
-0.16317041218280792,
0.8153846263885498,
-0.023288816213607788,
0.9867274761199951,
-0.28575658798217773,
1.0652451515197754,
-0.47802734375,
0.43459227681159973,
-0.23951639235019684,
-0.5408958196640015,
-0.30920547246932983,
0.68072110414505,
-0.3960435688495636,
-0.06964870542287827,
0.7338179349899292,
0.5729057192802429,
0.1722128689289093,
0.01961388997733593,
0.06932775676250458,
0.4014749825000763,
0.27234798669815063,
0.4314347207546234,
1.1095386743545532,
-0.3005709946155548,
0.569506824016571,
-0.29618674516677856,
-0.022219862788915634,
0.22856108844280243,
-0.3723776936531067,
-0.9306301474571228,
-0.6626858115196228,
-0.23237986862659454,
-0.3591925799846649,
-0.37108275294303894,
0.5688164234161377,
0.2650884985923767,
-0.7027040123939514,
-0.19334983825683594,
0.054340679198503494,
0.20390664041042328,
0.08385656774044037,
-0.3279763162136078,
0.025821799412369728,
-0.1388612687587738,
-0.3911147713661194,
0.1264224350452423,
0.1363265961408615,
-0.13340555131435394,
-0.21578922867774963,
-0.1825796216726303,
-0.22328422963619232,
-0.2912611961364746,
0.6889901161193848,
0.027130186557769775,
-0.6043805480003357,
-0.15236611664295197,
-0.06019297242164612,
-0.09943230450153351,
0.1449880748987198,
1.2333133220672607,
-0.4894360601902008,
0.45891648530960083,
0.5894579291343689,
0.3202165365219116,
0.46165940165519714,
0.4042102098464966,
0.4857458174228668,
-0.5509142875671387,
-0.6226702332496643,
0.34286966919898987,
0.25174301862716675,
0.3035060167312622,
-0.35143107175827026,
0.34502607583999634,
0.51119464635849,
-0.4670674800872803,
-0.8008587956428528,
0.004236963577568531,
-0.7574019432067871,
-0.8481051325798035,
1.1481977701187134,
-0.43171176314353943,
0.09833013266324997,
-0.8692074418067932,
-0.6245113611221313,
-0.030464181676506996,
-0.3751346468925476,
0.9440488219261169,
0.9713816046714783,
-0.6197669506072998,
-0.3084469437599182,
-0.7311034202575684,
0.7900202870368958,
-0.6000716090202332,
-1.083029866218567,
0.3474368155002594,
0.7478073239326477,
0.7267696261405945,
0.3450752794742584,
1.0097066164016724,
-0.029977940022945404,
0.030812399461865425,
0.15920256078243256,
-0.2929781973361969,
0.09618084132671356,
-0.445966899394989,
0.027429969981312752,
0.6807370185852051,
-0.4176581799983978,
0.06647355854511261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12114v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12114v1
|
Enhancing Text Classification through LLM-Driven Active Learning and Human Annotation
| 2024-06-17T21:45:48 | 2024-06-17T21:45:48 |
Hamidreza Rouzegar, Masoud Makrehchi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7
|
In the context of text classification, the financial burden of annotation
exercises for creating training data is a critical issue. Active learning
techniques, particularly those rooted in uncertainty sampling, offer a
cost-effective solution by pinpointing the most instructive samples for manual
annotation. Similarly, Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT-3.5 provide an
alternative for automated annotation but come with concerns regarding their
reliability. This study introduces a novel methodology that integrates human
annotators and LLMs within an Active Learning framework. We conducted
evaluations on three public datasets. IMDB for sentiment analysis, a Fake News
dataset for authenticity discernment, and a Movie Genres dataset for
multi-label classification.The proposed framework integrates human annotation
with the output of LLMs, depending on the model uncertainty levels. This
strategy achieves an optimal balance between cost efficiency and classification
performance. The empirical results show a substantial decrease in the costs
associated with data annotation while either maintaining or improving model
accuracy.
|
[
0.04484032467007637,
-0.6482788324356079,
0.4633912444114685,
-0.06106926128268242,
-0.271477609872818,
0.19363759458065033,
-0.36835601925849915,
-0.7695427536964417,
-0.2555818259716034,
0.5128960609436035,
-0.09147313237190247,
-0.4870476722717285,
-0.3478069305419922,
0.07246577739715576,
-0.31095942854881287,
1.0086601972579956,
-0.4895355701446533,
0.0034474674612283707,
0.06102374568581581,
-0.21932758390903473,
0.09518945962190628,
-0.7592815160751343,
-0.6071319580078125,
-0.1541467159986496,
0.6842243075370789,
0.23604746162891388,
0.7514224648475647,
0.8633870482444763,
0.4525400996208191,
0.178704172372818,
-0.06929472088813782,
0.4450918436050415,
0.05943015217781067,
0.2467464655637741,
-0.017477260902523994,
-0.4854683578014374,
-0.3424149453639984,
0.43188077211380005,
0.6442906260490417,
0.5082716941833496,
-0.07175252586603165,
0.04573339968919754,
-0.0056151426397264,
0.3194507658481598,
-0.6893641352653503,
0.30772823095321655,
-0.5365864038467407,
0.1312316209077835,
-0.320812463760376,
0.03555906563997269,
-0.3257244825363159,
-0.30891284346580505,
0.07260597497224808,
-0.5371097922325134,
0.25667518377304077,
0.034291401505470276,
0.9402256011962891,
0.4344088137149811,
-0.33213189244270325,
-0.40653374791145325,
-0.8062218427658081,
0.677112340927124,
-0.3592342734336853,
0.24362188577651978,
0.5832207202911377,
0.16182002425193787,
0.25353559851646423,
-0.5494589805603027,
-0.6760274171829224,
-0.07071792334318161,
0.06704200804233551,
0.12535524368286133,
0.11504758149385452,
0.11362340301275253,
0.09328772127628326,
0.44513392448425293,
-0.050695665180683136,
0.41399991512298584,
-0.2303929477930069,
-0.38128939270973206,
0.6183943748474121,
-0.34568214416503906,
0.1423809677362442,
-0.24029721319675446,
-0.46357476711273193,
-0.10177110135555267,
-0.5543126463890076,
-0.20344237983226776,
0.5167479515075684,
0.40539881587028503,
0.29513415694236755,
0.5802553296089172,
-0.03504052385687828,
0.4923180043697357,
-0.2971716821193695,
-0.22892779111862183,
0.4371497929096222,
-0.1654132455587387,
-0.18433184921741486,
0.17157283425331116,
0.6903472542762756,
0.10036193579435349,
0.23948751389980316,
-0.16004736721515656,
-0.5563031435012817,
0.06434544920921326,
0.22200174629688263,
-0.5490865707397461,
-0.28213897347450256,
0.09449002891778946,
-0.10188354551792145,
-0.6747419238090515,
0.23407994210720062,
-0.49976223707199097,
-0.6513067483901978,
-0.3061554431915283,
0.6555265188217163,
-0.07766111940145493,
-0.23173263669013977,
-0.11628514528274536,
0.18919649720191956,
-0.009975869208574295,
0.7635743618011475,
-0.6420506834983826,
0.11844655871391296,
0.28612375259399414,
0.9467347264289856,
-0.33600398898124695,
0.09600279480218887,
-0.39948320388793945,
0.3713540732860565,
-0.15779051184654236,
0.8740758895874023,
-0.2891601324081421,
0.0019675029907375574,
0.1419275850057602,
-0.09867241978645325,
0.2262694388628006,
-0.34977987408638,
0.8098362684249878,
-0.5215327739715576,
0.31564295291900635,
0.19823679327964783,
-0.35998064279556274,
-0.47241270542144775,
0.38369041681289673,
-0.9993488192558289,
1.2787545919418335,
0.1846330165863037,
-0.762999415397644,
0.5741554498672485,
-0.6865047216415405,
-0.43909579515457153,
0.25360268354415894,
-0.20290127396583557,
-0.8377978205680847,
-0.18215367197990417,
0.2758362293243408,
0.9148465394973755,
-0.1156899482011795,
0.36401066184043884,
-0.2016882300376892,
-0.3976171612739563,
0.4384298324584961,
-0.7232368588447571,
0.3623494505882263,
0.22049503028392792,
-0.5042256712913513,
0.028100134804844856,
-0.8273215293884277,
-0.33472010493278503,
-0.1511285901069641,
-0.8466317057609558,
-0.3678751587867737,
0.09261895716190338,
0.23324517905712128,
0.10602429509162903,
0.13101346790790558,
-0.39194679260253906,
0.3436441421508789,
-0.14612486958503723,
0.18165823817253113,
0.7377818822860718,
0.18681110441684723,
0.606338381767273,
-0.1365644335746765,
0.41073787212371826,
-0.10463877022266388,
-0.04234858602285385,
-0.2097538560628891,
-0.46201226115226746,
-0.7446751594543457,
-0.6800878047943115,
0.6580076813697815,
0.7456550598144531,
-0.620026707649231,
0.47355136275291443,
-0.14523419737815857,
-0.4942440688610077,
-0.5837656259536743,
0.33845797181129456,
0.1267826408147812,
0.21905368566513062,
0.41997745633125305,
0.0037398452404886484,
-0.32476910948753357,
-0.6929111480712891,
-0.11031652241945267,
-0.48599672317504883,
-0.21598652005195618,
0.14210113883018494,
0.18466278910636902,
-0.34707939624786377,
0.8313759565353394,
-0.29478219151496887,
-0.3750440180301666,
-0.20532956719398499,
0.47714102268218994,
-0.09286300837993622,
0.2779639959335327,
0.19658547639846802,
-1.000224232673645,
-0.36786726117134094,
0.06268133968114853,
-0.6060590147972107,
-0.18108181655406952,
-0.37630075216293335,
0.11878618597984314,
0.44698861241340637,
0.37098628282546997,
-0.2870708703994751,
0.43272653222084045,
0.2595478892326355,
-0.09845011681318283,
0.13110804557800293,
-0.0864463523030281,
0.10529246181249619,
-0.7554531097412109,
0.021220967173576355,
0.2532092034816742,
-0.24716569483280182,
-0.3541446924209595,
-0.3219934403896332,
0.2901417016983032,
-0.003955021034926176,
-0.22539326548576355,
0.6061291694641113,
-0.6270078420639038,
0.15877243876457214,
-0.3037787079811096,
0.20800349116325378,
-0.12845709919929504,
0.4296058416366577,
0.21633344888687134,
0.6694727540016174,
0.35565969347953796,
-0.5454728007316589,
0.34046199917793274,
-0.08169875293970108,
-0.3903389275074005,
0.13427400588989258,
-0.12086775153875351,
0.06273175030946732,
-0.12273958325386047,
0.2648204565048218,
-0.9913566708564758,
-0.4695727825164795,
0.3677714765071869,
-0.33046048879623413,
0.4684598445892334,
-0.18406710028648376,
-0.754737913608551,
-0.032967254519462585,
-0.28894662857055664,
-0.08090609312057495,
0.47922801971435547,
-0.508695125579834,
0.748154878616333,
0.41363444924354553,
-0.2083245813846588,
-0.5450723171234131,
-0.7890833020210266,
0.15013086795806885,
-0.2854692339897156,
-0.05048307776451111,
0.21761754155158997,
0.3261757791042328,
-0.2928767800331116,
-0.03883196413516998,
-0.21253976225852966,
-0.2209618240594864,
0.4265052080154419,
0.23441694676876068,
0.3054911196231842,
0.17774325609207153,
0.5383549928665161,
0.16044344007968903,
-0.0875815823674202,
-0.15708452463150024,
-0.32798677682876587,
-0.048270177096128464,
0.19786293804645538,
-0.28968143463134766,
-0.4368777275085449,
0.0009164241491816938,
0.38835352659225464,
-0.36577901244163513,
0.5976505875587463,
0.9780672788619995,
-0.48231935501098633,
-0.38848912715911865,
-0.6628260612487793,
0.013221699744462967,
-0.3950846195220947,
0.37634360790252686,
-0.005955797620117664,
-0.7977138161659241,
0.15465067327022552,
-0.16592422127723694,
0.2991800010204315,
0.5248585939407349,
0.5324491262435913,
-0.1294873207807541,
0.8425672054290771,
0.4691384732723236,
-0.030975710600614548,
0.7824430465698242,
-0.009728915989398956,
-0.047783054411411285,
-0.39379993081092834,
-0.12322311103343964,
-0.38408952951431274,
-0.25726962089538574,
-0.3421385586261749,
-0.83168625831604,
0.09636817872524261,
0.17316611111164093,
-0.12511026859283447,
-0.05822678282856941,
-0.49644601345062256,
0.42676401138305664,
0.5199204683303833,
0.28019073605537415,
0.3956408202648163,
0.21551476418972015,
0.18288646638393402,
0.0797242820262909,
-0.48518887162208557,
-0.9618457555770874,
1.1527881622314453,
0.7312610745429993,
0.8019905686378479,
0.2882363796234131,
0.525987982749939,
0.4527706503868103,
0.9784690141677856,
-0.8898553252220154,
0.4204029142856598,
0.06239135563373566,
-0.7846500277519226,
-0.369453489780426,
-0.567967414855957,
-0.5752586722373962,
0.09054173529148102,
-0.5669207572937012,
-0.39378392696380615,
0.08076850324869156,
0.1809597909450531,
-0.3464948236942291,
0.4823477566242218,
-0.7552232146263123,
0.45836347341537476,
-0.47851449251174927,
-0.5129067301750183,
0.16653425991535187,
-0.5135535597801208,
0.12131255120038986,
-0.6527983546257019,
0.35918474197387695,
-0.15376602113246918,
-0.5642218589782715,
1.0751235485076904,
0.12612687051296234,
1.124709129333496,
-0.34182897210121155,
-0.11685442179441452,
0.46357327699661255,
-0.21386641263961792,
0.6423704028129578,
0.1638513058423996,
-0.34868359565734863,
0.03614196553826332,
-0.6143701672554016,
-0.2850094139575958,
-0.38580963015556335,
0.3635970950126648,
-0.9006012082099915,
-0.2268287092447281,
-0.6446044445037842,
-0.36648795008659363,
-0.2575121223926544,
0.11546734720468521,
-0.22145284712314606,
0.1629864126443863,
0.17403928935527802,
0.19116456806659698,
0.7958846688270569,
-0.09996578842401505,
0.42194485664367676,
0.3709454834461212,
0.04822392016649246,
-0.7346253395080566,
0.6428968906402588,
0.2956719696521759,
0.14149990677833557,
0.4648105502128601,
0.14508864283561707,
-0.36156749725341797,
-0.9000531435012817,
-0.42838719487190247,
0.1597396582365036,
-0.8843545913696289,
-0.4706207513809204,
-0.7176317572593689,
-0.03975338488817215,
-0.1511993408203125,
-0.09471109509468079,
-0.10375184565782547,
-0.5877860188484192,
-0.4455346465110779,
-0.6098268628120422,
0.5800586342811584,
0.7279573678970337,
0.12033002823591232,
0.5296555161476135,
-0.6497275233268738,
0.12261098623275757,
0.44568493962287903,
0.4253969192504883,
-0.1806005984544754,
-0.42354273796081543,
-0.481606662273407,
-0.11994955688714981,
-0.31050482392311096,
-0.8662763237953186,
0.1991642415523529,
0.418275386095047,
0.6815992593765259,
0.46206361055374146,
0.24387846887111664,
0.22029730677604675,
-0.19440004229545593,
0.6632772088050842,
0.05716191977262497,
-0.885936439037323,
0.46381714940071106,
-0.420775830745697,
0.03740115091204643,
0.7537971138954163,
0.6155776381492615,
-0.1705671101808548,
-0.35633429884910583,
-0.5703701376914978,
-1.1075704097747803,
0.6904258728027344,
0.22785350680351257,
-0.05799279361963272,
0.06058204919099808,
0.7329185605049133,
0.04464900121092796,
0.12142322957515717,
-1.06679368019104,
-0.012822942808270454,
-0.059366341680288315,
-0.6284703016281128,
-0.15776067972183228,
-0.17683447897434235,
-0.005792464129626751,
-0.1420959085226059,
0.9350335597991943,
-0.2470071017742157,
0.049949441105127335,
0.2610433101654053,
-0.25791969895362854,
-0.12327729910612106,
0.10226605087518692,
0.17840497195720673,
0.28273874521255493,
-0.2815839648246765,
0.33384132385253906,
0.28226032853126526,
-0.6764673590660095,
0.24539263546466827,
0.2149035632610321,
-0.24076984822750092,
-0.04824460670351982,
0.46446356177330017,
0.7187219262123108,
0.21123434603214264,
-0.6671034693717957,
0.5530056953430176,
-0.023426534608006477,
-0.1784561723470688,
-0.3448864221572876,
0.13719919323921204,
-0.12232448160648346,
0.19437085092067719,
0.7522182464599609,
0.10852529853582382,
-0.000056789293012116104,
-0.4311150908470154,
0.25176557898521423,
0.0003213497984688729,
-0.7044139504432678,
-0.16959428787231445,
0.5353296399116516,
0.4217374920845032,
-0.16683512926101685,
0.5159528255462646,
-0.23867769539356232,
-0.769378662109375,
0.12521468102931976,
0.152705579996109,
0.8644904494285583,
-0.24377751350402832,
0.09763620793819427,
0.2830013930797577,
0.3672278821468353,
-0.5628674030303955,
0.011430143378674984,
-0.21663598716259003,
-0.7040572166442871,
-0.6161931753158569,
-0.8020889759063721,
-0.778374969959259,
-0.1531859189271927,
-0.4969499707221985,
0.5919223427772522,
-0.4100041389465332,
-0.12409378588199615,
-0.18113496899604797,
0.27596768736839294,
-0.2786470949649811,
0.436015248298645,
0.4250396490097046,
0.6429573893547058,
-1.0641498565673828,
0.910106897354126,
1.084061622619629,
-0.520354688167572,
-0.6125067472457886,
0.09117364138364792,
-0.1449422687292099,
-0.34180453419685364,
0.5254822373390198,
0.4433825612068176,
0.07959380000829697,
0.03682037070393562,
-0.555931031703949,
-0.5755188465118408,
1.1266024112701416,
0.04957892745733261,
-0.4289429783821106,
-0.004944557789713144,
-0.211111381649971,
0.4276922047138214,
-0.16263392567634583,
0.03701953962445259,
0.16267290711402893,
0.5533186197280884,
0.10896638035774231,
-0.6974638104438782,
-0.005132608115673065,
-0.1287669986486435,
-0.43399086594581604,
0.43170222640037537,
-0.3739042282104492,
0.5314326286315918,
-0.05620849132537842,
-0.25276127457618713,
-0.27853259444236755,
0.8245282173156738,
0.1716861128807068,
0.3076734244823456,
0.8261034488677979,
0.22763654589653015,
1.093294382095337,
-0.19300022721290588,
0.7465001940727234,
0.0796443298459053,
0.3497866690158844,
0.6562254428863525,
-0.3165813982486725,
0.9871447086334229,
0.32818102836608887,
-0.31525087356567383,
0.24839657545089722,
0.8410979509353638,
-0.31284257769584656,
0.22567376494407654,
0.2632297873497009,
-0.5570901036262512,
-0.3941231966018677,
0.09465759247541428,
0.1874290555715561,
0.31431546807289124,
0.43376123905181885,
-0.3868884742259979,
0.015318685211241245,
0.22252300381660461,
0.3355811834335327,
0.1253371685743332,
-0.3052930235862732,
0.8629052639007568,
-0.18611545860767365,
-0.35540997982025146,
0.1543206423521042,
0.06347223371267319,
0.9005194902420044,
-0.62004554271698,
0.06059669703245163,
0.0929623693227768,
0.25616350769996643,
-0.2656836211681366,
-0.6923877000808716,
0.11277793347835541,
0.2692229151725769,
-0.14748266339302063,
-0.4001982510089874,
0.6281319856643677,
-0.5233986973762512,
-0.6249324679374695,
-0.019162006676197052,
0.24224978685379028,
0.14234624803066254,
-0.2332676351070404,
-0.5014178156852722,
0.0024638185277581215,
0.06355311721563339,
-0.40081897377967834,
0.22233355045318604,
0.6321625113487244,
-0.28626689314842224,
0.5236562490463257,
0.7145172357559204,
0.2484046369791031,
-0.1476827710866928,
-0.0673544779419899,
0.7792087197303772,
-0.6667891144752502,
-0.39693742990493774,
-0.6872400045394897,
0.414745569229126,
-0.2204888015985489,
-0.15900181233882904,
0.7502647042274475,
0.520855188369751,
0.593043327331543,
0.21080657839775085,
1.0587153434753418,
0.13218215107917786,
0.6886366009712219,
-0.509733259677887,
0.7881360650062561,
-0.4651876389980316,
0.49977943301200867,
-0.28350329399108887,
-1.0343319177627563,
-0.7955512404441833,
0.7958652377128601,
-0.32470864057540894,
-0.005847643129527569,
0.4757600724697113,
0.4294956624507904,
0.03417956456542015,
-0.08139646053314209,
0.0760592520236969,
-0.038647960871458054,
0.431023508310318,
0.03330438584089279,
0.8094481229782104,
-0.38717707991600037,
0.6472727656364441,
-0.2579458951950073,
-0.4939049780368805,
-0.1027936115860939,
-0.879111111164093,
-0.9190767407417297,
-0.43770867586135864,
-0.6681745648384094,
-0.198114812374115,
0.015838928520679474,
0.9526187777519226,
0.6164436340332031,
-0.6382110714912415,
0.07656103372573853,
0.10984355211257935,
-0.025365201756358147,
-0.14743518829345703,
-0.20622923970222473,
0.6141035556793213,
-0.343498170375824,
-0.8316951394081116,
0.11623774468898773,
0.1342237889766693,
0.40678179264068604,
-0.4100368022918701,
0.16168546676635742,
-0.33715084195137024,
-0.0004563372931443155,
0.43704622983932495,
-0.0015042515005916357,
-0.5393023490905762,
-0.23793935775756836,
-0.2530004680156708,
-0.11207380145788193,
-0.08878707885742188,
0.5523807406425476,
-0.7856000065803528,
0.25414344668388367,
0.20679517090320587,
0.9137512445449829,
0.4624751806259155,
0.2862790524959564,
0.3910645842552185,
-0.8924767374992371,
0.06030306592583656,
0.43436217308044434,
0.14587433636188507,
0.6598993539810181,
-0.4482162296772003,
0.6451436281204224,
0.26097169518470764,
-0.6042833924293518,
-1.000006079673767,
-0.10170511156320572,
-1.0664032697677612,
-0.2422717660665512,
1.3846445083618164,
-0.23806145787239075,
-0.3005848228931427,
-0.4759168028831482,
-0.33672139048576355,
0.3170316219329834,
-0.35923346877098083,
0.6363008618354797,
0.7260282039642334,
-0.009283757768571377,
-0.2337023764848709,
-0.5948671102523804,
0.44157326221466064,
0.06804369390010834,
-0.8240302205085754,
0.34457001090049744,
0.5313301682472229,
-0.021325942128896713,
0.28181058168411255,
0.25107502937316895,
-0.11957263201475143,
-0.0411817841231823,
-0.25896716117858887,
0.5460113286972046,
-0.23287920653820038,
-0.27420902252197266,
-0.43249136209487915,
0.3657110333442688,
0.24915644526481628,
-0.0323888398706913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12109v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12109v1
|
Can LLMs Learn Macroeconomic Narratives from Social Media?
| 2024-06-17T21:37:09 | 2024-06-17T21:37:09 |
Almog Gueta, Amir Feder, Zorik Gekhman, Ariel Goldstein, Roi Reichart
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CE
|
This study empirically tests the $\textit{Narrative Economics}$ hypothesis,
which posits that narratives (ideas that are spread virally and affect public
beliefs) can influence economic fluctuations. We introduce two curated datasets
containing posts from X (formerly Twitter) which capture economy-related
narratives (Data will be shared upon paper acceptance). Employing Natural
Language Processing (NLP) methods, we extract and summarize narratives from the
tweets. We test their predictive power for $\textit{macroeconomic}$ forecasting
by incorporating the tweets' or the extracted narratives' representations in
downstream financial prediction tasks. Our work highlights the challenges in
improving macroeconomic models with narrative data, paving the way for the
research community to realistically address this important challenge. From a
scientific perspective, our investigation offers valuable insights and NLP
tools for narrative extraction and summarization using Large Language Models
(LLMs), contributing to future research on the role of narratives in economics.
|
[
-0.21778684854507446,
-1.0544835329055786,
0.7201852202415466,
0.2513240873813629,
-0.4112800359725952,
0.46515774726867676,
-0.14117707312107086,
-0.7447481751441956,
0.6436047554016113,
0.5733317732810974,
-0.7189411520957947,
-0.4599231779575348,
-0.6956707835197449,
0.13262450695037842,
-0.3532796800136566,
1.0188772678375244,
0.15843845903873444,
-0.246869295835495,
-0.004940134938806295,
0.1987857073545456,
0.09257501363754272,
-0.07075196504592896,
-0.722277045249939,
-0.020962802693247795,
0.8578699827194214,
0.2794055640697479,
0.8153948783874512,
0.7145588397979736,
0.20151518285274506,
0.1988680213689804,
0.13057494163513184,
0.41839900612831116,
-0.5735668540000916,
0.004715620540082455,
-0.17046712338924408,
-0.3234874904155731,
-0.31670573353767395,
0.043264489620923996,
0.6243388652801514,
0.474338173866272,
-0.07867716997861862,
0.582731306552887,
0.34102490544319153,
0.5022598505020142,
-0.32604193687438965,
0.4443596303462982,
-0.6157941222190857,
-0.22583052515983582,
0.15857456624507904,
-0.25067558884620667,
-0.21507342159748077,
-0.7761746644973755,
0.24312248826026917,
-0.244363471865654,
0.05118287354707718,
0.15425026416778564,
0.8000256419181824,
-0.11721926927566528,
-0.6953521370887756,
-0.33816736936569214,
-0.9495981931686401,
0.574007511138916,
-0.5578343868255615,
-0.026459941640496254,
0.299474835395813,
0.3236691653728485,
0.2559870779514313,
-0.8707081079483032,
-0.26903989911079407,
0.20619449019432068,
-0.05725763738155365,
0.21192340552806854,
-0.5585449934005737,
-0.22123147547245026,
0.1899162232875824,
0.19994831085205078,
-0.27639350295066833,
-0.05911965295672417,
-0.7324604392051697,
0.1264469474554062,
0.7298346161842346,
0.2202015221118927,
0.21202853322029114,
-0.3750889003276825,
-0.2069340944290161,
-0.019267598167061806,
-0.6207999587059021,
0.09677711874246597,
0.26449310779571533,
0.4371211528778076,
-0.40017053484916687,
0.6215943098068237,
0.05324852094054222,
0.15778501331806183,
-0.24553833901882172,
-0.41694876551628113,
0.12304516136646271,
-0.3215251863002777,
-0.26479873061180115,
0.2272549271583557,
0.7535525560379028,
0.8125401735305786,
0.5186663269996643,
-0.10458721220493317,
-0.2875550091266632,
-0.28326520323753357,
-0.03021278791129589,
-0.6377890110015869,
0.15503673255443573,
-0.06840492784976959,
-0.5105008482933044,
-0.5341971516609192,
0.022270070388913155,
-1.2696173191070557,
-0.5329191088676453,
-0.20358775556087494,
0.20961783826351166,
-0.09109874069690704,
-0.1190921738743782,
-0.08100339025259018,
-0.48957520723342896,
0.14974811673164368,
0.03925716131925583,
-0.9850795865058899,
0.3322533965110779,
0.769140899181366,
1.1894780397415161,
0.2911913990974426,
-0.08988560736179352,
-0.29576852917671204,
0.42558881640434265,
-0.3133448362350464,
1.0984933376312256,
-0.24512577056884766,
-0.42690321803092957,
0.45248380303382874,
-0.07164966315031052,
-0.27188926935195923,
-0.4243137240409851,
-0.05169091373682022,
-0.28790736198425293,
-0.22216466069221497,
-0.3455447852611542,
-0.5101922154426575,
-0.034644965082407,
0.16500157117843628,
-0.762281060218811,
0.6279236674308777,
0.025878380984067917,
-0.8386263251304626,
0.37511593103408813,
-0.4181489646434784,
-0.49124661087989807,
-0.3853662312030792,
0.08432925492525101,
-0.21565863490104675,
0.2194843590259552,
0.5112891793251038,
0.46401792764663696,
-0.40895840525627136,
0.5478306412696838,
-0.553895115852356,
-0.07713942974805832,
0.35491684079170227,
-0.7755683660507202,
0.910856306552887,
-0.15002185106277466,
-0.19711808860301971,
-0.28695836663246155,
-0.7517827153205872,
-0.49407830834388733,
0.1668708622455597,
-0.04849035665392876,
-0.04273265227675438,
0.30118367075920105,
-0.04206440597772598,
-0.15416806936264038,
0.08331836014986038,
-0.37306123971939087,
0.3491494357585907,
-0.19675834476947784,
0.6236202120780945,
0.9275956153869629,
0.5843198299407959,
0.2652950882911682,
-0.7274736762046814,
0.5713639259338379,
-0.4205089807510376,
0.0021317170467227697,
-0.33354735374450684,
-0.4112938642501831,
-0.22584255039691925,
-0.03886944800615311,
-0.06474976986646652,
0.5151369571685791,
-0.6572625041007996,
-0.3808619976043701,
-0.08020831644535065,
-0.6140285730361938,
-0.09066881239414215,
0.14043380320072174,
-0.22344249486923218,
0.489452600479126,
0.2034127414226532,
0.5568258762359619,
-0.9462504982948303,
-0.71640944480896,
-0.5941342711448669,
-0.3726613223552704,
-0.21411345899105072,
0.4042026996612549,
0.40626809000968933,
-0.39818528294563293,
0.9915184378623962,
-0.7149344682693481,
0.09772039204835892,
-0.7556593418121338,
0.6869212985038757,
0.4956408739089966,
-0.21181747317314148,
0.6763737201690674,
-0.598115086555481,
-0.4979340136051178,
-0.06477446109056473,
-0.6075229048728943,
-0.2509535849094391,
-0.3603077530860901,
0.46998849511146545,
0.4646259844303131,
0.43362605571746826,
-0.6212248802185059,
0.4964711666107178,
0.5841406583786011,
-0.31831783056259155,
0.7752231955528259,
-0.1905478686094284,
0.02412877045571804,
-1.0799241065979004,
-0.54494708776474,
0.5025890469551086,
-0.4072597026824951,
-0.18505273759365082,
-0.6546695828437805,
-0.3185112178325653,
0.2803334891796112,
-0.24885374307632446,
0.4973028302192688,
-0.28370627760887146,
-0.2772573232650757,
-0.11954481154680252,
0.05014413222670555,
0.0011527864262461662,
0.0236626286059618,
0.13767488300800323,
0.6032257676124573,
0.35576045513153076,
-0.3970641493797302,
0.3823569118976593,
-0.001524446764960885,
-0.5399186015129089,
-0.08382148295640945,
-0.7078632712364197,
-0.2747170031070709,
-0.13966654241085052,
0.2698444128036499,
-0.9433618187904358,
-0.40439465641975403,
-0.11034312844276428,
-0.3323429524898529,
-0.0014166302280500531,
0.029483899474143982,
-0.7527269721031189,
-0.22837521135807037,
-0.4090427756309509,
-0.4186604917049408,
0.5541499257087708,
-0.441413551568985,
0.5857879519462585,
0.46655163168907166,
-0.5594853758811951,
-0.19567488133907318,
-0.6012511849403381,
0.19940711557865143,
-0.46883946657180786,
-0.4541139006614685,
0.05799586698412895,
0.17955778539180756,
-0.7588794827461243,
-0.019455203786492348,
-0.09684036672115326,
-0.054748110473155975,
0.10517662018537521,
-0.015204762108623981,
0.5510008931159973,
-0.39545077085494995,
0.19148626923561096,
0.128459632396698,
-0.046229831874370575,
0.6368111968040466,
-0.29539257287979126,
0.3426860570907593,
-0.06857119500637054,
0.3774888515472412,
-0.02803315408527851,
-0.0680386945605278,
0.3653392493724823,
0.4218732416629791,
0.9511092901229858,
0.6628856062889099,
-0.34857577085494995,
-0.10330276936292648,
-0.5639778971672058,
-0.029807858169078827,
-0.45576363801956177,
0.0626574158668518,
0.28276526927948,
-0.9086781740188599,
0.45260947942733765,
-0.19032932817935944,
0.11401175707578659,
0.7001726627349854,
0.3847692310810089,
-0.4691644310951233,
0.8550612926483154,
0.8582099676132202,
-0.2544211149215698,
0.4169654846191406,
-0.4399230182170868,
0.3158274292945862,
-0.3139888346195221,
-0.057977095246315,
-0.3029758036136627,
-0.2036444991827011,
-0.6448257565498352,
-0.2035522162914276,
0.2457384318113327,
-0.13039158284664154,
-0.2074095904827118,
0.19141902029514313,
0.3256242573261261,
0.6912577152252197,
0.3747107684612274,
0.23292285203933716,
0.3652227222919464,
-0.017291205003857613,
0.33637988567352295,
-0.10381283611059189,
-0.3971897065639496,
-0.9044312834739685,
1.0254719257354736,
0.26487022638320923,
0.5468016862869263,
-0.1002110093832016,
0.5845834016799927,
0.5935467481613159,
0.3058609068393707,
-0.30836060643196106,
0.3493184745311737,
-0.07822855561971664,
-0.22931547462940216,
-0.35458964109420776,
-0.5511779189109802,
-0.6483592391014099,
-0.29977405071258545,
-0.41628530621528625,
-1.1070959568023682,
0.11946504563093185,
-0.15301121771335602,
-0.6338033080101013,
0.5125706791877747,
-0.5330595374107361,
0.8129939436912537,
-0.29745399951934814,
-0.4056452512741089,
-0.22148744761943817,
-0.5225577354431152,
0.37986353039741516,
-0.217336967587471,
0.6588652729988098,
-0.2067391723394394,
-0.016655437648296356,
0.6471390128135681,
-0.16876952350139618,
1.2994064092636108,
0.27277618646621704,
-0.031996019184589386,
0.48473477363586426,
-0.008959518745541573,
0.4106597602367401,
0.4955293536186218,
0.018287166953086853,
0.12154998630285263,
0.0929947942495346,
-0.37464699149131775,
-0.31673237681388855,
0.46269381046295166,
-0.726337194442749,
-0.4913572072982788,
-0.12659865617752075,
-0.6614757776260376,
-0.2275564819574356,
-0.13655129075050354,
0.21943984925746918,
0.3898504972457886,
-0.5304375290870667,
0.20677506923675537,
0.4576985836029053,
-0.10007599741220474,
0.9256138801574707,
0.16449210047721863,
-0.4991992712020874,
-0.5085165500640869,
0.786750316619873,
0.5018416047096252,
0.2965250611305237,
0.49182483553886414,
0.6103540062904358,
-0.1825847327709198,
-0.1815534383058548,
0.008894340135157108,
0.3343888819217682,
-0.46173039078712463,
-0.2007865160703659,
-0.6595802903175354,
-0.1942673921585083,
-0.7003815174102783,
-0.6018836498260498,
-0.12436971068382263,
-0.3618674874305725,
-0.5197619795799255,
-0.979468822479248,
0.5009042620658875,
1.1356900930404663,
-0.7084986567497253,
0.3473648428916931,
-1.1311252117156982,
0.43027710914611816,
0.36154091358184814,
-0.09226240962743759,
0.09070690721273422,
-0.05554880574345589,
-0.5493860840797424,
0.3593980371952057,
-0.15612637996673584,
-0.9142709374427795,
0.9882420897483826,
0.050267599523067474,
0.02897070348262787,
0.73077392578125,
-0.03317328542470932,
0.7375670671463013,
-0.35002800822257996,
0.6662817597389221,
0.1304360181093216,
-0.7747306227684021,
0.5113476514816284,
-0.813624918460846,
0.11615076661109924,
0.30936914682388306,
0.6162566542625427,
-0.4255657494068146,
-0.5088021755218506,
-0.7908976078033447,
-0.9437044858932495,
0.4742400348186493,
0.04866407439112663,
0.35507357120513916,
-0.3951283097267151,
0.2605274021625519,
0.3746049404144287,
0.3885117173194885,
-0.6927298903465271,
-0.0870344340801239,
0.056831374764442444,
-0.10064153373241425,
-0.4119243323802948,
-0.725924015045166,
0.39641863107681274,
-0.30315837264060974,
0.312744140625,
0.1914142221212387,
-0.08966190367937088,
0.07575514912605286,
-0.031571149826049805,
-0.3083861768245697,
-0.2540723979473114,
0.2813447415828705,
0.9591708779335022,
-0.5869919657707214,
0.2698051631450653,
0.12965618073940277,
-0.2558648884296417,
-0.2101605087518692,
-0.044693611562252045,
-0.09800206869840622,
0.2569098174571991,
0.6226984858512878,
0.5394681096076965,
0.5527510643005371,
-0.919802188873291,
0.2970990538597107,
-0.13879534602165222,
-0.3763044476509094,
-0.575430154800415,
-0.30728718638420105,
0.4621763527393341,
0.8219491243362427,
0.47155648469924927,
-0.0316103957593441,
0.1643972098827362,
-1.052829623222351,
0.15724770724773407,
0.08848299831151962,
-0.1636640727519989,
-0.5911440849304199,
0.76651531457901,
-0.14731091260910034,
-0.2423277199268341,
0.3947877585887909,
-0.0006755783688277006,
-0.2821323871612549,
1.0181535482406616,
0.7996372580528259,
0.8564398288726807,
0.11452820897102356,
0.6780213713645935,
0.3084203600883484,
0.4672378897666931,
-0.44760289788246155,
-0.046578679233789444,
0.09927472472190857,
-0.6167739033699036,
-0.46661630272865295,
-0.5970615744590759,
-0.45967069268226624,
-0.01526004821062088,
-0.6381288170814514,
0.45626208186149597,
-0.38418421149253845,
-0.0010404669446870685,
0.11991865187883377,
-0.1766735315322876,
-0.4172922670841217,
0.1523832231760025,
0.4923950433731079,
0.7619698643684387,
-1.0285903215408325,
0.4701792895793915,
0.12022043764591217,
-0.501361072063446,
-0.6221859455108643,
0.0783485695719719,
0.14221107959747314,
-0.8001139760017395,
0.6027092933654785,
0.3241078853607178,
-0.027168333530426025,
-0.05892103537917137,
-0.6399006247520447,
-0.83970046043396,
1.1854560375213623,
0.3915804624557495,
-0.4263855218887329,
-0.2989658713340759,
0.3865860104560852,
0.3912601172924042,
-0.7800507545471191,
0.20500053465366364,
0.7299314141273499,
0.4490951895713806,
0.19709032773971558,
-0.5275881886482239,
-0.2786625623703003,
0.016590509563684464,
-0.3555360734462738,
-0.06786449998617172,
-0.48518702387809753,
0.80028235912323,
-0.45084384083747864,
-0.1411532610654831,
-0.19882477819919586,
0.7322559952735901,
0.05081925168633461,
1.021760106086731,
0.28077933192253113,
0.16308031976222992,
0.7005326747894287,
0.2655585706233978,
1.2660084962844849,
-0.3646039366722107,
0.5213705897331238,
0.9133205413818359,
-0.15210160613059998,
0.8078724145889282,
0.20776069164276123,
-0.17748573422431946,
0.7303509712219238,
0.8042864203453064,
-0.026661358773708344,
0.37410449981689453,
-0.11392642557621002,
-0.14654973149299622,
-0.14779634773731232,
-0.06388732045888901,
0.1169603168964386,
0.2542037069797516,
0.443888783454895,
-0.39838987588882446,
-0.25279200077056885,
-0.06794945150613785,
0.3108665943145752,
0.03485768660902977,
-0.7062402367591858,
0.8861234188079834,
0.43729183077812195,
-0.20130965113639832,
-0.19183336198329926,
-0.4217008650302887,
0.3995544910430908,
-0.330744206905365,
-0.03497369959950447,
-0.2873411178588867,
-0.009633513167500496,
-0.009511752985417843,
-0.5456200242042542,
0.866413414478302,
0.2666417360305786,
-0.10483711212873459,
-0.7509963512420654,
0.8906991481781006,
-0.3005887567996979,
-0.8692689538002014,
0.3253477215766907,
0.7917717695236206,
-0.11798286437988281,
-0.20880891382694244,
-0.11641519516706467,
-0.4380609393119812,
0.07630018889904022,
-0.43367812037467957,
0.38330432772636414,
0.6544909477233887,
0.43465563654899597,
0.5024737119674683,
0.2721322476863861,
0.06792868673801422,
-0.07727164775133133,
-0.06919127702713013,
0.690348744392395,
-0.9255866408348083,
-0.4816969633102417,
-1.4514281749725342,
0.23526114225387573,
-0.18262779712677002,
-0.06287890672683716,
0.7620425820350647,
0.5781258344650269,
0.6131041646003723,
-0.04206504300236702,
1.0213779211044312,
0.290710985660553,
0.6605954170227051,
-0.5694261789321899,
0.5555212497711182,
-0.34024885296821594,
0.31060168147087097,
-0.19754168391227722,
-0.6951790452003479,
-0.0572824701666832,
0.3015439212322235,
-0.4677116274833679,
-0.2847096025943756,
0.7449135780334473,
0.18731267750263214,
0.19534756243228912,
0.3616926074028015,
0.18960608541965485,
0.47340431809425354,
-0.04048556834459305,
-0.13258661329746246,
0.6479954123497009,
0.2036159783601761,
0.6663275957107544,
-0.40882694721221924,
0.11502806097269058,
-0.3311476409435272,
-0.9545063972473145,
-0.9739184379577637,
-0.2310197651386261,
-0.3725391626358032,
-0.5006563663482666,
0.2866259813308716,
0.9801508784294128,
-0.19984446465969086,
-0.17298972606658936,
-0.667173445224762,
-0.018525246530771255,
0.5298087000846863,
-0.1157117411494255,
-0.2897036075592041,
0.354507178068161,
-0.41146206855773926,
-0.610130250453949,
0.04804152995347977,
0.5937217473983765,
0.11850527673959732,
0.03770974278450012,
0.4259597063064575,
-0.25812268257141113,
0.5546335577964783,
0.6698728203773499,
-0.05955302342772484,
-0.18180833756923676,
-0.26900729537010193,
0.28172382712364197,
0.02608846127986908,
0.0326235368847847,
0.8990066647529602,
-0.6228141784667969,
-0.12092996388673782,
0.2638460397720337,
0.38654425740242004,
0.5152342915534973,
0.0016888909740373492,
0.717420220375061,
-0.4169618785381317,
-0.1981368213891983,
-0.03572569042444229,
0.6067546606063843,
-0.11874475330114365,
-0.3057917356491089,
0.5051862001419067,
0.47574788331985474,
-0.4320559799671173,
-0.6217766404151917,
-0.13906577229499817,
-0.7366827726364136,
-0.5579882860183716,
1.2847356796264648,
-0.12611854076385498,
-0.6371837258338928,
-0.03962411358952522,
-0.00030268149566836655,
0.25746047496795654,
-0.4795677661895752,
1.1575673818588257,
0.6889644861221313,
0.22891676425933838,
-0.4834280014038086,
-1.002970814704895,
0.1358145922422409,
-0.5888265371322632,
-0.5158829689025879,
0.26819679141044617,
0.3990073502063751,
-0.02360687218606472,
-0.363212525844574,
0.7699384093284607,
0.3558078110218048,
0.03292247653007507,
0.23022250831127167,
-0.24359187483787537,
0.11123667657375336,
-0.059401314705610275,
0.09125196188688278,
0.1695190817117691,
-0.39402464032173157,
0.285753071308136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12104v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12104v1
|
End-to-end Text-to-SQL Generation within an Analytics Insight Engine
| 2024-06-17T21:33:01 | 2024-06-17T21:33:01 |
Karime Maamari, Amine Mhedhbi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.LG
|
Recent advancements in Text-to-SQL have pushed database management systems
towards greater democratization of data access. Today's language models are at
the core of these advancements. They enable impressive Text-to-SQL generation
as experienced in the development of Distyl AI's Analytics Insight Engine. Its
early deployment with enterprise customers has highlighted three core
challenges. First, data analysts expect support with authoring SQL queries of
very high complexity. Second, requests are ad-hoc and, as such, require low
latency. Finally, generation requires an understanding of domain-specific
terminology and practices.
The design and implementation of our Text-to-SQL generation pipeline, powered
by large language models, tackles these challenges. The core tenants of our
approach rely on external knowledge that we extract in a pre-processing phase,
on retrieving the appropriate external knowledge at query generation time, and
on decomposing SQL query generation following a hierarchical CTE-based
structure. Finally, an adaptation framework leverages feedback to update the
external knowledge, in turn improving query generation over time. We give an
overview of our end-to-end approach and highlight the operators generating SQL
during inference.
|
[
-0.2396324723958969,
-0.8218052387237549,
0.6624811291694641,
0.046599131077528,
-0.19943134486675262,
0.16498883068561554,
-0.09753087162971497,
-0.4947986602783203,
0.11950115114450455,
0.5180294513702393,
-1.0053303241729736,
-0.5291339159011841,
-0.39438265562057495,
0.17075854539871216,
-0.47547268867492676,
1.1169711351394653,
0.2918061316013336,
-0.17064093053340912,
-0.3949713110923767,
0.0651128888130188,
-0.5051431059837341,
-0.7845357656478882,
-0.8561426401138306,
0.2370852828025818,
0.21510793268680573,
0.31277012825012207,
0.20370961725711823,
0.598904013633728,
0.28428274393081665,
0.27735722064971924,
0.1164129301905632,
0.3954525291919708,
-0.7711383700370789,
0.6298607587814331,
-0.2064094841480255,
-0.5072905421257019,
-0.6499878764152527,
-0.40508249402046204,
0.17441560328006744,
0.710328221321106,
-0.36440515518188477,
0.15364232659339905,
-0.13058626651763916,
1.049102544784546,
-0.7000667452812195,
0.19697214663028717,
-1.070332407951355,
-0.16911667585372925,
-0.18241311609745026,
-0.25247472524642944,
-0.7305182814598083,
-0.14097745716571808,
0.22434990108013153,
-0.450308233499527,
0.14645211398601532,
0.18385100364685059,
0.5794013142585754,
0.4829046428203583,
-0.5736429691314697,
-0.5908111333847046,
-0.6939173340797424,
0.5017180442810059,
-0.476413369178772,
0.16965042054653168,
-0.044726938009262085,
0.5365808010101318,
-0.19920586049556732,
-1.093912959098816,
-0.36426296830177307,
0.11492516845464706,
-0.05107460916042328,
0.18481871485710144,
-0.19339534640312195,
-0.15588028728961945,
-0.04345317184925079,
0.1029677465558052,
-0.40421590209007263,
-0.018055101856589317,
-0.20867368578910828,
0.27268698811531067,
0.9351627826690674,
0.44983354210853577,
-0.09998425841331482,
0.15611164271831512,
-0.1321088969707489,
0.22302818298339844,
-0.6777071952819824,
-0.3993819057941437,
0.24637609720230103,
0.37177205085754395,
0.17559771239757538,
0.4825083911418915,
-0.33735203742980957,
0.5916082262992859,
0.14989367127418518,
0.7068269848823547,
-0.05243949592113495,
-0.4830990433692932,
-0.24819332361221313,
0.27191290259361267,
0.712141752243042,
0.31772589683532715,
0.1653585284948349,
-0.2710345685482025,
-0.09148328751325607,
-0.20340749621391296,
0.38334912061691284,
-1.0082371234893799,
-0.15044409036636353,
0.43959054350852966,
-0.256355345249176,
-0.3411710262298584,
-0.22289788722991943,
-0.9130368232727051,
-0.5823095440864563,
-0.4674922823905945,
0.19177448749542236,
-0.4184623956680298,
-0.3388350009918213,
-0.12027063220739365,
-0.19786888360977173,
0.43491891026496887,
0.26296040415763855,
-0.8208222985267639,
0.47165367007255554,
0.5331447124481201,
0.6793944239616394,
-0.13417285680770874,
0.14431129395961761,
-0.49810701608657837,
0.29922616481781006,
-0.48482710123062134,
0.7692309021949768,
-0.34359297156333923,
-0.4105251431465149,
0.11517290771007538,
-0.2633630633354187,
0.15225186944007874,
-0.40997952222824097,
0.21290022134780884,
-0.6107503771781921,
0.4139741063117981,
-0.12321627140045166,
-0.925934910774231,
0.11417201161384583,
0.08095336705446243,
-0.26857632398605347,
0.9018314480781555,
0.0654686689376831,
-0.6715982556343079,
0.6674457788467407,
-0.7871723771095276,
-0.4920370876789093,
0.31396549940109253,
-0.390041708946228,
-0.4245002567768097,
0.4274160861968994,
0.26528647541999817,
0.38674846291542053,
-0.7361260652542114,
0.1276353895664215,
-0.06285504996776581,
0.09885494410991669,
0.026979725807905197,
-0.21105818450450897,
0.6697881817817688,
0.4550895690917969,
-0.25770798325538635,
0.0013077396433800459,
-1.0345008373260498,
0.1855565905570984,
0.5158023834228516,
0.16669927537441254,
-0.3509252369403839,
0.48441603779792786,
0.07890473306179047,
-0.0724463239312172,
0.3181092441082001,
-0.2535690665245056,
0.13723354041576385,
-0.30552709102630615,
0.6129235029220581,
0.7172846794128418,
0.2954499423503876,
0.16619716584682465,
0.3066079616546631,
0.3950252830982208,
0.2294197380542755,
0.14986898005008698,
-0.5041655898094177,
-0.1028067097067833,
-0.6642573475837708,
-0.09384484589099884,
-0.004904174245893955,
0.49095144867897034,
-0.5259085297584534,
0.5457500219345093,
-0.36906957626342773,
-0.6150153875350952,
-0.29983270168304443,
-0.15091297030448914,
-0.03882534056901932,
0.38273707032203674,
0.24719452857971191,
-0.019266538321971893,
-0.6431835889816284,
-0.857716977596283,
-0.2565654218196869,
-0.11723984032869339,
-0.034088052809238434,
0.285631000995636,
0.35598596930503845,
-0.06513494998216629,
1.209691047668457,
-0.992117166519165,
-0.2401939183473587,
-0.3107724189758301,
0.041904084384441376,
0.18541279435157776,
0.24338197708129883,
0.5101584196090698,
-0.8600814938545227,
-0.6573286652565002,
0.15678881108760834,
-0.799250602722168,
-0.008097878657281399,
-0.07380149513483047,
-0.44644737243652344,
0.5306783318519592,
0.4659595191478729,
-0.4237956702709198,
0.2203163355588913,
0.06942093372344971,
-0.4518025517463684,
0.4346370995044708,
-0.1292552351951599,
-0.041456423699855804,
-1.5465556383132935,
0.023897912353277206,
-0.006844033021479845,
-0.1251114159822464,
-0.7305313944816589,
-0.12654028832912445,
-0.241261824965477,
-0.2724844217300415,
-0.16412730515003204,
0.17458634078502655,
-0.6611467599868774,
-0.058344174176454544,
-0.08347079157829285,
0.02368141897022724,
0.14889606833457947,
0.15764372050762177,
0.2089831531047821,
0.7089534997940063,
0.6912733316421509,
-0.7782043814659119,
0.4201701581478119,
0.29312264919281006,
-0.2162814736366272,
0.8193694949150085,
-0.658315122127533,
0.4209660291671753,
-0.18665631115436554,
0.054232627153396606,
-0.7173315286636353,
-0.3469385802745819,
-0.20825627446174622,
-0.641020655632019,
0.36846038699150085,
-0.20218509435653687,
-0.37568071484565735,
-0.002421671524643898,
-0.11598015576601028,
-0.03191182017326355,
0.5472868084907532,
-0.6018579006195068,
0.6627833843231201,
0.472292959690094,
-0.3922001123428345,
-0.42097213864326477,
-0.619384229183197,
0.43288952112197876,
-0.3372068405151367,
-0.7507662177085876,
0.15422023832798004,
0.09266846626996994,
-0.4233015179634094,
-0.04468897357583046,
0.14534053206443787,
-0.40908828377723694,
0.023049550130963326,
-0.17326225340366364,
0.25450485944747925,
-0.26984110474586487,
0.09501232206821442,
0.41106221079826355,
0.09403988718986511,
0.45882299542427063,
-0.5688337683677673,
0.3745778501033783,
0.39729470014572144,
-0.2218157798051834,
-0.2124388962984085,
0.7280261516571045,
0.5445363521575928,
-0.4195552468299866,
0.9832085371017456,
0.16974738240242004,
-0.45583397150039673,
-0.5599556565284729,
-0.28290727734565735,
-0.2433249056339264,
-0.43595564365386963,
0.8180877566337585,
-0.41929835081100464,
-0.2873373329639435,
0.2771286964416504,
-0.20779716968536377,
0.36261340975761414,
0.5471292734146118,
0.5972074270248413,
-0.1586500108242035,
1.2669386863708496,
0.795961856842041,
0.24208468198776245,
0.319431334733963,
-0.2245178073644638,
0.4414721131324768,
-0.5048434138298035,
-0.4603579044342041,
-0.6345178484916687,
0.09027440845966339,
-0.3916035592556,
-0.07761824131011963,
0.4959215223789215,
0.04405753314495087,
-0.13259772956371307,
0.04730505123734474,
-0.5573736429214478,
0.3251909911632538,
0.11765358597040176,
-0.19941937923431396,
0.29583239555358887,
0.17482809722423553,
0.5802559852600098,
-0.16035428643226624,
-0.5911444425582886,
-0.21795359253883362,
1.1261712312698364,
0.01406075805425644,
0.7160034775733948,
0.28076744079589844,
0.6258742809295654,
0.48082688450813293,
0.06710927933454514,
-0.6263033151626587,
0.5336040258407593,
-0.22790813446044922,
-0.6012077927589417,
-0.08187627047300339,
-0.42814701795578003,
-0.4634518623352051,
0.03713521733880043,
-0.11325815320014954,
-0.5025606155395508,
0.1078442856669426,
0.30313989520072937,
0.10358960181474686,
-0.0040849316865205765,
-1.032334804534912,
0.7368974685668945,
-0.29775381088256836,
-0.7206907868385315,
-0.15813402831554413,
-0.657613217830658,
0.29233747720718384,
-0.11190129071474075,
0.13502447307109833,
0.33862873911857605,
0.024324914440512657,
0.3798164427280426,
-0.6407977342605591,
0.6881522536277771,
-0.45392975211143494,
-0.14247754216194153,
0.5517449975013733,
0.04816265031695366,
0.7124568819999695,
0.01867031306028366,
-0.1471889317035675,
-0.041933704167604446,
-0.09571702778339386,
-0.18942683935165405,
-0.615238606929779,
0.3583154082298279,
-0.33526402711868286,
-0.42878222465515137,
-0.32133907079696655,
-0.3961220383644104,
-0.2822156250476837,
0.00895286537706852,
0.4728662073612213,
0.5270063877105713,
-0.3377644121646881,
0.24390266835689545,
0.5688396096229553,
-0.07471977919340134,
0.24823935329914093,
0.33635613322257996,
-0.26298290491104126,
-0.15804514288902283,
0.8829120397567749,
0.05257931724190712,
0.3114734888076782,
0.4185565710067749,
-0.11814349889755249,
-0.84195876121521,
-0.745218813419342,
-0.6415619254112244,
-0.08312123268842697,
-0.6195745468139648,
-0.16285216808319092,
-0.5568554401397705,
-0.15971322357654572,
-0.612809419631958,
-0.1132848933339119,
-0.4026257395744324,
-0.3759531080722809,
-0.28214433789253235,
-0.09155591577291489,
0.6050337553024292,
0.773377537727356,
0.330035001039505,
0.25857770442962646,
-0.7257204055786133,
-0.2511635720729828,
-0.12188377231359482,
0.048068899661302567,
-0.142223060131073,
-0.17845502495765686,
-0.6020893454551697,
-0.1033625453710556,
-0.20194265246391296,
-0.9406353831291199,
0.3422670364379883,
0.5367549061775208,
0.19939562678337097,
0.1542157530784607,
0.16003912687301636,
0.47465935349464417,
-0.5487753748893738,
0.88509601354599,
0.020548708736896515,
-0.8645995855331421,
0.8765733242034912,
-0.18181778490543365,
-0.034920524805784225,
0.4856439530849457,
0.32480117678642273,
-0.20421883463859558,
-0.20956403017044067,
-0.35063469409942627,
-1.1943022012710571,
0.5627814531326294,
0.13847659528255463,
-0.023444170132279396,
-0.0789581909775734,
0.5293887853622437,
0.3394719660282135,
0.5486660599708557,
-0.39116933941841125,
-0.19324389100074768,
-0.30251920223236084,
-0.44559451937675476,
0.0418793261051178,
0.0332370363175869,
0.02460993453860283,
0.06453076750040054,
0.5998480319976807,
-0.46672937273979187,
0.00009101199975702912,
0.11110661178827286,
-0.18567079305648804,
0.3737003207206726,
0.3590377867221832,
0.04342551901936531,
0.8779415488243103,
-0.08626087754964828,
-0.3599412441253662,
0.004267262294888496,
-0.3072480261325836,
-0.22185443341732025,
-0.029008636251091957,
-0.2688954174518585,
-0.03183973953127861,
0.20188596844673157,
0.9283841252326965,
-0.5545998811721802,
-0.731421947479248,
0.27789419889450073,
-0.21331587433815002,
-0.2912196218967438,
-0.5050230622291565,
-0.007774522993713617,
0.024788618087768555,
-0.02519838884472847,
0.6301753520965576,
-0.38010790944099426,
0.4393661320209503,
-0.5163280963897705,
0.09893155843019485,
0.5530347228050232,
-0.24044792354106903,
-0.34293100237846375,
0.9825281500816345,
0.4158053398132324,
0.08041349053382874,
0.7303937673568726,
-0.14990584552288055,
-0.1567171961069107,
0.5800111889839172,
0.5887777209281921,
1.122652530670166,
-0.10486011952161789,
-0.0621366985142231,
0.242513045668602,
0.1397039294242859,
0.5137320756912231,
0.41458427906036377,
-0.10599157214164734,
-0.32549476623535156,
-0.6149131655693054,
-0.631784200668335,
-0.2983226478099823,
-0.1428886353969574,
-0.8170018196105957,
0.4406312108039856,
-0.16378262639045715,
0.01809876598417759,
0.032084956765174866,
-0.1645268052816391,
-0.4247341454029083,
0.24731256067752838,
-0.20902401208877563,
0.9560487866401672,
-0.6831293106079102,
0.5437218546867371,
0.719235360622406,
-0.3497142791748047,
-0.4537404775619507,
-0.2729467749595642,
0.0619894303381443,
-0.5015670657157898,
0.5620377659797668,
0.02998613566160202,
-0.12332266569137573,
0.2590760886669159,
-0.5048003196716309,
-0.2455184906721115,
1.0790759325027466,
0.2809731364250183,
-0.7011467814445496,
-0.20972363650798798,
0.22472475469112396,
0.6944578289985657,
-0.7165337800979614,
0.2811654210090637,
0.8463025689125061,
0.1886003166437149,
0.18418307602405548,
-0.2317175269126892,
-0.08507087081670761,
-0.15773271024227142,
-0.043380361050367355,
0.48967599868774414,
-0.38569530844688416,
0.6166959404945374,
-0.2877040207386017,
-0.2449035346508026,
-0.3866516649723053,
0.7952617406845093,
-0.016159508377313614,
0.4084435999393463,
0.44323277473449707,
0.41126492619514465,
0.5294750332832336,
-0.022839751094579697,
0.8951845169067383,
-0.36421510577201843,
0.06251661479473114,
1.3173481225967407,
-0.5870408415794373,
0.8784025311470032,
0.4655137360095978,
-0.20547515153884888,
0.3736400902271271,
0.6414752006530762,
0.2261790633201599,
0.5600467920303345,
-0.014137727208435535,
-0.2536253035068512,
0.03722543641924858,
-0.29503190517425537,
-0.36517134308815,
0.41509774327278137,
0.6110864877700806,
-0.17418809235095978,
0.007607188541442156,
-0.4945294260978699,
-0.08423101156949997,
0.24265225231647491,
-0.2424096018075943,
1.2309590578079224,
-0.06457759439945221,
-0.5168306231498718,
0.14383110404014587,
-0.356674462556839,
0.18787933886051178,
-0.7831824421882629,
-0.09904558211565018,
-0.23112253844738007,
0.2008521407842636,
-0.2180340439081192,
-0.7572550773620605,
0.6336191892623901,
0.2355845868587494,
-0.2336907535791397,
0.015004415065050125,
0.5212014317512512,
-0.39449504017829895,
-0.34613844752311707,
0.30011799931526184,
0.584598958492279,
0.08864255249500275,
-0.20778366923332214,
-0.37451472878456116,
-0.10753244161605835,
0.19276712834835052,
-0.42362841963768005,
0.3001084327697754,
0.8026164770126343,
0.0964459627866745,
0.4482841491699219,
0.5163834095001221,
0.20473332703113556,
0.31553903222084045,
0.209529310464859,
0.7580397129058838,
-0.4696366786956787,
-0.5884190201759338,
-0.882339358329773,
0.7197597026824951,
-0.3788928687572479,
-0.16525277495384216,
0.39438602328300476,
0.8201285600662231,
0.2895961403846741,
0.11527779698371887,
0.9396070837974548,
-0.34506648778915405,
0.45500946044921875,
-0.6661916971206665,
0.8071362972259521,
-0.8641833066940308,
0.2560827434062958,
-0.025691712275147438,
-1.0604314804077148,
0.21174168586730957,
-0.08032914996147156,
0.1724635809659958,
-0.0362989641726017,
0.7436847686767578,
0.6041585206985474,
0.2314700484275818,
0.1803344041109085,
-0.03902646154165268,
0.46213415265083313,
0.6855307221412659,
0.4459822177886963,
0.5655564665794373,
-0.32028988003730774,
0.6469976902008057,
0.10504210740327835,
-0.29880601167678833,
0.06831034272909164,
-0.8644064664840698,
-0.5285187363624573,
-0.8114156723022461,
-0.2009608894586563,
-0.16558633744716644,
0.14439639449119568,
0.7083075642585754,
0.6466730833053589,
-0.5531337261199951,
-0.2390052229166031,
-0.5264914631843567,
-0.35223710536956787,
-0.06141567975282669,
-0.2715640962123871,
0.392241507768631,
-0.6281440258026123,
-0.923313319683075,
0.3895833492279053,
0.4057147800922394,
-0.2611401379108429,
-0.38992366194725037,
0.18719473481178284,
0.01666807010769844,
0.12821869552135468,
0.7797353267669678,
-0.036058973520994186,
0.035179413855075836,
0.025454901158809662,
0.10303464531898499,
0.2146769016981125,
-0.05753793567419052,
0.7318246364593506,
-0.6465350985527039,
0.3138604462146759,
0.411628395318985,
1.0350769758224487,
0.7510046362876892,
0.02005465142428875,
0.8992888331413269,
-0.9659035801887512,
-0.00024004181614145637,
0.3378707468509674,
0.18124547600746155,
0.3372465968132019,
-0.6116164922714233,
0.5881609320640564,
0.12057716399431229,
-0.6216791272163391,
-0.9813237190246582,
0.41133278608322144,
-0.5871036648750305,
-0.27357879281044006,
0.5726315379142761,
0.2835838198661804,
-0.3075781762599945,
-0.06501910835504532,
-0.12841026484966278,
0.11239150166511536,
-0.44826945662498474,
0.5249468088150024,
0.5391786694526672,
-0.4857025444507599,
-0.041045207530260086,
-0.4738123118877411,
0.4026046097278595,
0.4372923970222473,
-1.2985557317733765,
0.5513631105422974,
0.8021350502967834,
0.02047976478934288,
-0.06480838358402252,
0.5773653984069824,
-0.007851779460906982,
-0.17576368153095245,
0.2695639133453369,
-0.015563316643238068,
-0.004493404179811478,
-0.36441847681999207,
-0.05418798327445984,
0.03784697875380516,
0.11051040142774582,
-0.27597713470458984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12094v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12094v1
|
Who's asking? User personas and the mechanics of latent misalignment
| 2024-06-17T21:15:12 | 2024-06-17T21:15:12 |
Asma Ghandeharioun, Ann Yuan, Marius Guerard, Emily Reif, Michael A. Lepori, Lucas Dixon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite investments in improving model safety, studies show that misaligned
capabilities remain latent in safety-tuned models. In this work, we shed light
on the mechanics of this phenomenon. First, we show that even when model
generations are safe, harmful content can persist in hidden representations and
can be extracted by decoding from earlier layers. Then, we show that whether
the model divulges such content depends significantly on its perception of who
it is talking to, which we refer to as user persona. In fact, we find
manipulating user persona to be even more effective for eliciting harmful
content than direct attempts to control model refusal. We study both natural
language prompting and activation steering as control methods and show that
activation steering is significantly more effective at bypassing safety
filters. We investigate why certain personas break model safeguards and find
that they enable the model to form more charitable interpretations of otherwise
dangerous queries. Finally, we show we can predict a persona's effect on
refusal given only the geometry of its steering vector.
|
[
-0.2264152318239212,
-0.744469165802002,
0.7108076214790344,
0.1369262933731079,
0.10510190576314926,
0.08012200146913528,
0.4320005178451538,
-0.5927485823631287,
-0.12577460706233978,
0.6631975769996643,
-0.7537273168563843,
0.1807401478290558,
-0.5387114882469177,
-0.18390962481498718,
-0.25540417432785034,
0.9314032196998596,
0.4437655806541443,
0.005004152189940214,
-0.27580514550209045,
0.08929099142551422,
-0.649174153804779,
-0.6093322038650513,
-0.5603457689285278,
-0.4015555679798126,
0.875545859336853,
0.3065722584724426,
1.0910143852233887,
0.403556764125824,
0.29494571685791016,
0.2979976236820221,
-0.1398932784795761,
-0.46489736437797546,
-0.5444952249526978,
0.46552687883377075,
-0.4721248745918274,
-0.6888094544410706,
-0.39949551224708557,
0.3167499899864197,
0.20170606672763824,
1.0054429769515991,
0.014912760816514492,
-0.287710577249527,
0.2333640158176422,
0.4279843866825104,
-0.8850688934326172,
-0.3736076056957245,
-0.45669981837272644,
-0.18710410594940186,
-0.3356226086616516,
-0.3589384853839874,
-0.5992647409439087,
-0.29506346583366394,
0.3590334951877594,
-0.5434346199035645,
0.10039758682250977,
0.2912907600402832,
0.7433509230613708,
0.49292629957199097,
-0.7954859733581543,
0.018482835963368416,
-0.9198731184005737,
0.7588990926742554,
-0.3261170983314514,
0.44680729508399963,
0.8785802125930786,
0.36292925477027893,
-0.28377261757850647,
-0.5166487097740173,
-0.5384909510612488,
0.051381275057792664,
-0.21060830354690552,
0.015863176435232162,
-0.40787288546562195,
0.22789885103702545,
0.3963317275047302,
-0.12006399035453796,
-0.6596240997314453,
0.35670992732048035,
-0.5693922638893127,
-0.377663791179657,
0.7353041768074036,
-0.01914960891008377,
0.43597155809402466,
-0.5363263487815857,
-0.6066873073577881,
-0.1569780856370926,
-0.9531760215759277,
0.019956059753894806,
0.8533268570899963,
0.04330376535654068,
-0.014636400155723095,
0.6646108627319336,
0.12115971744060516,
0.5547814965248108,
0.4831430912017822,
0.12660911679267883,
-0.07463319599628448,
0.013519864529371262,
-0.09637289494276047,
-0.005102965049445629,
0.742461621761322,
0.5305087566375732,
0.26468268036842346,
-0.1452675312757492,
-0.15029779076576233,
-0.25377005338668823,
0.7849814891815186,
-0.353628009557724,
-0.3206144869327545,
0.2715511620044708,
-0.5636664032936096,
-0.449607789516449,
0.16533038020133972,
-0.7024422287940979,
-0.7954807877540588,
-0.233504980802536,
0.44554081559181213,
-0.3960074186325073,
-0.31842300295829773,
0.13798266649246216,
0.06209113821387291,
0.2616497874259949,
0.16095899045467377,
-1.0100297927856445,
0.03373526409268379,
0.6804266571998596,
0.29281389713287354,
-0.020320633426308632,
-0.1369912177324295,
-0.742027759552002,
0.22675049304962158,
-0.2122916728258133,
0.8439416885375977,
-0.5716019868850708,
-0.7296788692474365,
-0.17848855257034302,
0.10498674213886261,
-0.22139972448349,
-0.5191553235054016,
0.432363361120224,
-0.7918957471847534,
0.49548113346099854,
-0.7901353240013123,
-0.20842427015304565,
-0.24284206330776215,
0.1217825710773468,
-0.6411604285240173,
0.6942866444587708,
-0.03714650124311447,
-0.8368987441062927,
0.26149386167526245,
-0.5414705276489258,
-0.3333728611469269,
0.042849101126194,
-0.21527287364006042,
-0.2011692076921463,
0.20220497250556946,
0.010749411769211292,
0.40269777178764343,
0.071295365691185,
0.2948276698589325,
-0.4173530340194702,
0.007227946072816849,
0.6657199859619141,
-0.486812561750412,
1.0358495712280273,
0.28564453125,
-0.11880116164684296,
0.07205043733119965,
-0.31164243817329407,
-0.16026586294174194,
-0.022418545559048653,
-0.17698049545288086,
-0.4716116189956665,
0.16084156930446625,
0.016187630593776703,
0.4075530767440796,
0.09445714950561523,
-0.2961376905441284,
-0.2084287405014038,
-0.37113797664642334,
0.22322092950344086,
0.8286672830581665,
0.4513205289840698,
0.7129721641540527,
-0.4895084500312805,
0.7820741534233093,
0.05766642466187477,
0.2964036166667938,
0.11822178959846497,
-0.7009724974632263,
-0.49185606837272644,
0.5340083837509155,
0.04780044034123421,
0.6663393974304199,
-0.7597708702087402,
0.2169831246137619,
0.09267676621675491,
-0.1488901823759079,
-0.23673388361930847,
-0.12068594992160797,
0.620829164981842,
0.8666457533836365,
0.20896513760089874,
-0.2504548132419586,
-0.2338811755180359,
-1.0592660903930664,
-0.5201753973960876,
-0.8259938955307007,
-0.11374107748270035,
0.23308341205120087,
0.20632709562778473,
0.08378658443689346,
0.8902508020401001,
-0.4850403368473053,
0.2671024799346924,
-0.13758696615695953,
0.39301472902297974,
-0.5304446816444397,
0.7550144791603088,
0.7986106276512146,
-1.1621489524841309,
-0.22653807699680328,
-0.3870508074760437,
-0.6466432809829712,
-0.27405431866645813,
-0.24686697125434875,
-0.2858662009239197,
0.12240615487098694,
0.6858277320861816,
-0.5692270994186401,
0.5716362595558167,
0.2367294430732727,
-0.5413317084312439,
0.5480731129646301,
-0.21820680797100067,
0.16633836925029755,
-0.8921120762825012,
0.22646479308605194,
0.10589207708835602,
-0.2114904820919037,
-0.8111513257026672,
0.008865739218890667,
0.09265454858541489,
-0.15589329600334167,
-0.6953882575035095,
0.18085826933383942,
-0.36490175127983093,
-0.004407448694109917,
-0.33432137966156006,
0.1133599504828453,
0.07761609554290771,
0.19297337532043457,
-0.2267104983329773,
0.8513516187667847,
0.37462347745895386,
-0.9906716346740723,
-0.05367061868309975,
0.4043344259262085,
-0.12838898599147797,
1.1759709119796753,
-0.7757085561752319,
0.42061924934387207,
-0.45034101605415344,
-0.09103018045425415,
-1.040540337562561,
-0.5800418257713318,
0.6413214206695557,
-0.6290186643600464,
0.4059102535247803,
-0.29936620593070984,
-0.2530233561992645,
-0.25246065855026245,
0.1445540189743042,
0.30889296531677246,
0.49685439467430115,
-0.1781379133462906,
0.5107819437980652,
0.7227276563644409,
-0.27586302161216736,
-0.5926186442375183,
-0.6738797426223755,
-0.1169772520661354,
-0.566290020942688,
-0.6432772278785706,
0.4035901427268982,
-0.364066481590271,
-0.5060504078865051,
-0.12458238005638123,
-0.22281332314014435,
-0.23716478049755096,
0.4630243182182312,
0.5490361452102661,
0.14639107882976532,
0.07274674624204636,
0.26931488513946533,
0.35974857211112976,
-0.3602670729160309,
0.3470492959022522,
0.0005357425543479621,
0.2665163278579712,
0.10223926603794098,
-0.5550602674484253,
-0.5624133944511414,
0.5006263256072998,
0.4852876365184784,
-0.26118046045303345,
0.7370557188987732,
0.19209852814674377,
-0.4566001296043396,
0.4385855495929718,
-0.5207363367080688,
-0.534579873085022,
-0.5422956943511963,
0.0505988709628582,
-0.14874088764190674,
-0.7960712313652039,
0.4713616967201233,
0.020978977903723717,
-0.0025881449691951275,
0.25271645188331604,
0.18472838401794434,
-0.45936819911003113,
1.2153102159500122,
0.8564321994781494,
0.04079785197973251,
0.17085139453411102,
0.10590710490942001,
0.26014724373817444,
-0.5167607069015503,
-0.5712897777557373,
-0.7719535231590271,
-0.5191039443016052,
-0.43025702238082886,
-0.23848840594291687,
0.43846261501312256,
0.040102969855070114,
-0.23692293465137482,
0.3921966552734375,
-0.14668381214141846,
0.5826391577720642,
0.2677859961986542,
0.12212809920310974,
0.24597403407096863,
-0.18562129139900208,
-0.037624601274728775,
-0.4763389825820923,
-0.4756200909614563,
-0.6757716536521912,
0.6456549763679504,
0.34769484400749207,
1.0243196487426758,
0.434197336435318,
0.24199411273002625,
0.18690508604049683,
0.016878511756658554,
-0.5283878445625305,
0.563307523727417,
0.3504166007041931,
-1.2837995290756226,
-0.09105908870697021,
-0.02021588385105133,
-1.1081016063690186,
0.19115273654460907,
-0.41931095719337463,
-1.0495671033859253,
0.5412521958351135,
0.4087260663509369,
-0.772070050239563,
0.23402975499629974,
-0.6910296082496643,
0.7139028906822205,
-0.5118322968482971,
-0.5478881001472473,
-0.15557968616485596,
-1.1455905437469482,
0.2579205334186554,
0.04886193200945854,
0.046958647668361664,
-0.05166136100888252,
-0.1360265612602234,
0.653712272644043,
-0.2583470940589905,
1.0578750371932983,
-0.38362887501716614,
-0.121271513402462,
0.09244407713413239,
0.4162801206111908,
0.30875328183174133,
-0.03418247401714325,
-0.04432234168052673,
-0.2824309468269348,
-0.147491455078125,
-0.3165256679058075,
-0.7611554265022278,
0.6796874403953552,
-0.5996789932250977,
-0.9804192185401917,
-0.3855438828468323,
-0.36013826727867126,
-0.4185241162776947,
0.3003789186477661,
0.5314962863922119,
0.04917719587683678,
-0.22599449753761292,
0.21685990691184998,
1.0912925004959106,
-0.3051713705062866,
0.43332070112228394,
0.4762957990169525,
-0.11812469363212585,
0.2794644832611084,
0.5573224425315857,
0.029069337993860245,
0.47071701288223267,
0.2460898607969284,
0.04369255527853966,
-0.4840812385082245,
-0.43259140849113464,
-0.39655357599258423,
0.2621389925479889,
-0.5196726322174072,
0.03837822750210762,
-0.7914328575134277,
-0.10586618632078171,
-0.40245863795280457,
-0.08418672531843185,
-0.28207841515541077,
-0.432930052280426,
-0.6533044576644897,
-0.337252140045166,
-0.08783163875341415,
0.7738025784492493,
-0.03224797919392586,
0.7525889277458191,
-0.4381401836872101,
0.044107332825660706,
0.45674851536750793,
0.12072715163230896,
-0.2105305939912796,
-0.41915956139564514,
0.26130080223083496,
-0.14286966621875763,
-0.7277161478996277,
-1.3503248691558838,
0.282632052898407,
-0.2398935854434967,
0.8133916854858398,
0.7838314771652222,
0.441702663898468,
0.4283420443534851,
-0.20054982602596283,
0.6493541598320007,
0.08008888363838196,
-0.6507794857025146,
0.6674730181694031,
-0.5230032801628113,
-0.04103884473443031,
0.6418924927711487,
0.8744280934333801,
-0.5796510577201843,
-0.15840229392051697,
-0.7369717955589294,
-0.5273563265800476,
0.7316080331802368,
0.17486774921417236,
0.3793145418167114,
0.18090613186359406,
0.5318102240562439,
0.1860659122467041,
0.17016258835792542,
-0.7439245581626892,
-0.36466190218925476,
-0.15113742649555206,
0.14729493856430054,
0.10947613418102264,
-0.6448442339897156,
-0.1426052302122116,
0.15140973031520844,
0.45020535588264465,
-0.04146154597401619,
0.20425176620483398,
-0.055201902985572815,
-0.08934103697538376,
-0.4560675323009491,
0.31345444917678833,
0.5012843012809753,
0.7025989890098572,
0.0439201295375824,
0.07596033811569214,
-0.14621134102344513,
-0.4090310335159302,
0.07541829347610474,
-0.005475236568599939,
-0.3615967631340027,
-0.5103396773338318,
-0.004558153450489044,
0.7384674549102783,
0.5833370685577393,
-0.32352957129478455,
0.5626170039176941,
-0.07545048743486404,
-0.18013238906860352,
-0.1433752179145813,
0.40011066198349,
-0.03822413086891174,
0.1568981111049652,
0.35043954849243164,
0.3735171854496002,
0.1261397898197174,
-0.32415133714675903,
0.06410396099090576,
0.4185797870159149,
-0.6150321364402771,
-0.6373013257980347,
1.0956430435180664,
0.24985270202159882,
-0.4933857321739197,
0.664311408996582,
0.2136262059211731,
-0.4498317837715149,
0.23726734519004822,
0.35339412093162537,
0.701776921749115,
-0.5038653612136841,
0.409437358379364,
0.2857705056667328,
0.3995051980018616,
0.13009846210479736,
0.32185864448547363,
0.02141529694199562,
-0.6686891317367554,
-0.25155654549598694,
-0.07442386448383331,
-0.43531665205955505,
0.34524279832839966,
-0.8969373106956482,
-0.014078502543270588,
-0.6105948090553284,
-0.4989053010940552,
0.02175879292190075,
-0.43403103947639465,
-0.33201083540916443,
0.17241926491260529,
-0.05233588442206383,
0.640674352645874,
-0.8786818981170654,
0.34538698196411133,
0.7626021504402161,
-0.395510196685791,
-0.7920089364051819,
0.5063085556030273,
0.4448366165161133,
-0.4490625560283661,
0.40303099155426025,
0.03753914684057236,
-0.014728059060871601,
-0.13441985845565796,
-1.000159502029419,
-0.881215512752533,
0.8116861581802368,
0.6127690672874451,
-0.24085445702075958,
-0.372185617685318,
0.07155846804380417,
0.25135332345962524,
0.047276731580495834,
-0.18462297320365906,
0.3193853199481964,
0.5072522759437561,
0.16446523368358612,
-0.8363652229309082,
-0.11142420023679733,
-0.21543794870376587,
-0.06695427000522614,
-0.0725741982460022,
-0.5810678005218506,
0.8653273582458496,
-0.38979917764663696,
-0.3350078761577606,
0.06079786643385887,
0.6332339644432068,
0.2803288698196411,
0.3205035626888275,
0.7402223944664001,
0.23582792282104492,
0.939429759979248,
-0.123844213783741,
1.273464560508728,
0.07869309931993484,
-0.1746869683265686,
0.8682867884635925,
-0.10014260560274124,
0.5639301538467407,
0.5829459428787231,
0.04729921743273735,
0.6462443470954895,
0.6774303913116455,
0.5022699236869812,
0.5369677543640137,
-0.29838401079177856,
-0.2353123277425766,
-0.6964390873908997,
0.01635647378861904,
-0.4121650755405426,
0.5943835377693176,
0.5096853971481323,
-0.25063958764076233,
-0.07506422698497772,
0.13951759040355682,
0.22264862060546875,
0.2586089074611664,
0.07609532028436661,
0.575596809387207,
0.12528164684772491,
-0.9846370816230774,
0.04622996225953102,
0.14435335993766785,
0.27650314569473267,
-0.4059877395629883,
0.38766250014305115,
-0.0703968033194542,
-0.0689084529876709,
-0.10455166548490524,
-0.8075557947158813,
0.4588406980037689,
-0.22729913890361786,
-0.1501520872116089,
-0.4295197129249573,
1.1230745315551758,
0.006311898119747639,
-0.1370561420917511,
0.06152816116809845,
0.8378422260284424,
0.22623978555202484,
-0.053133271634578705,
-0.8732432723045349,
-0.11211279779672623,
-0.14386577904224396,
-0.1803998053073883,
0.3948313593864441,
0.17905843257904053,
-0.33156144618988037,
0.9117419123649597,
0.544749915599823,
-0.29121828079223633,
0.10354198515415192,
-0.039672404527664185,
0.7774262428283691,
-0.6270122528076172,
-0.7789943218231201,
-0.5191762447357178,
0.8586755990982056,
-0.007072482258081436,
-0.2808131277561188,
0.7982485890388489,
0.2391769140958786,
0.9219611287117004,
-0.029661552980542183,
0.6414393782615662,
-0.0661015436053276,
0.47009050846099854,
-0.4396536946296692,
1.306023120880127,
-0.5970531702041626,
0.34505385160446167,
-0.35876402258872986,
-0.6051468253135681,
-0.16351880133152008,
0.6837498545646667,
-0.7000994086265564,
0.36773741245269775,
0.401321142911911,
0.8499544858932495,
-0.04372415319085121,
0.27374061942100525,
0.27372223138809204,
0.06329721212387085,
0.3656887412071228,
0.4628821015357971,
1.175878882408142,
-0.24058747291564941,
0.3343275487422943,
-0.15416564047336578,
0.04339218512177467,
-0.3169019818305969,
-0.8600172996520996,
-0.8292334675788879,
-0.8036676645278931,
-0.45393452048301697,
-0.45285528898239136,
-0.018359053879976273,
0.382670134305954,
1.0730417966842651,
-0.5516862273216248,
0.08008971065282822,
-0.0035438230261206627,
0.34352052211761475,
0.3174314498901367,
-0.1579425185918808,
-0.21871738135814667,
0.0476217195391655,
-0.7503124475479126,
0.5144580602645874,
0.18545329570770264,
0.5588068962097168,
-0.5562446117401123,
-0.1135312169790268,
-0.282153457403183,
0.056038059294223785,
0.2619859278202057,
0.64324951171875,
-0.532374382019043,
-0.4060523211956024,
0.19812656939029694,
-0.18760287761688232,
-0.0026880805380642414,
0.9817972183227539,
-0.854698121547699,
0.4411216676235199,
0.3859979808330536,
0.357143372297287,
0.08497586101293564,
0.33497533202171326,
0.7301402688026428,
-0.7260597944259644,
0.06580379605293274,
0.30576997995376587,
0.204213947057724,
0.4863888919353485,
-0.7578374147415161,
0.13936670124530792,
0.39651432633399963,
-0.5732348561286926,
-0.6498886346817017,
0.5271890163421631,
-0.7930107116699219,
-0.2811669111251831,
0.899577260017395,
0.12596431374549866,
-0.25261396169662476,
-0.5399171710014343,
-0.2565523087978363,
-0.01638098619878292,
-0.17796747386455536,
0.6795152425765991,
0.5614741444587708,
-0.31599709391593933,
-0.34579354524612427,
-0.6481500267982483,
0.5723862051963806,
0.627167284488678,
-0.6428079009056091,
-0.09637430310249329,
0.744644820690155,
0.43290138244628906,
0.13999031484127045,
0.6121562123298645,
-0.19720108807086945,
0.3811229467391968,
-0.2532525956630707,
-0.5880926847457886,
0.024344976991415024,
-0.6375240087509155,
-0.2722703218460083,
0.29989588260650635,
0.161992609500885,
0.06399937719106674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12091v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12091v2
|
Is poisoning a real threat to LLM alignment? Maybe more so than you think
| 2024-06-17T21:06:00 | 2024-06-19T17:56:17 |
Pankayaraj Pathmanathan, Souradip Chakraborty, Xiangyu Liu, Yongyuan Liang, Furong Huang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Recent advancements in Reinforcement Learning with Human Feedback (RLHF) have
significantly impacted the alignment of Large Language Models (LLMs). The
sensitivity of reinforcement learning algorithms such as Proximal Policy
Optimization (PPO) has led to new line work on Direct Policy Optimization
(DPO), which treats RLHF in a supervised learning framework. The increased
practical use of these RLHF methods warrants an analysis of their
vulnerabilities. In this work, we investigate the vulnerabilities of DPO to
poisoning attacks under different scenarios and compare the effectiveness of
preference poisoning, a first of its kind. We comprehensively analyze DPO's
vulnerabilities under different types of attacks, i.e., backdoor and
non-backdoor attacks, and different poisoning methods across a wide array of
language models, i.e., LLama 7B, Mistral 7B, and Gemma 7B. We find that unlike
PPO-based methods, which, when it comes to backdoor attacks, require at least
4\% of the data to be poisoned to elicit harmful behavior, we exploit the true
vulnerabilities of DPO more simply so we can poison the model with only as much
as 0.5\% of the data. We further investigate the potential reasons behind the
vulnerability and how well this vulnerability translates into backdoor vs
non-backdoor attacks.
|
[
0.028213052079081535,
-0.6221218109130859,
0.5790460705757141,
0.009181932546198368,
0.1600675880908966,
-0.03782130032777786,
0.03473103046417236,
-0.380684494972229,
-0.30150532722473145,
0.8324313759803772,
-0.6452635526657104,
-0.3935507535934448,
-0.34226706624031067,
-0.034197285771369934,
-0.07505788654088974,
1.0322755575180054,
0.11501877009868622,
-0.10263409465551376,
-0.024129126220941544,
0.1648101806640625,
-0.7208214402198792,
-0.8187850117683411,
-0.5715346932411194,
-0.39055949449539185,
0.7645291686058044,
0.45743462443351746,
0.8189818859100342,
0.5754363536834717,
0.5312733054161072,
0.2569662034511566,
-0.04255712032318115,
-0.10486428439617157,
-0.6384378671646118,
0.3855830729007721,
-0.31612110137939453,
-0.5120251774787903,
-0.5250942707061768,
0.03970839083194733,
0.29148387908935547,
0.1171325072646141,
-0.30284592509269714,
-0.29097890853881836,
-0.08716553449630737,
0.8985589742660522,
-0.8470001220703125,
-0.4395308494567871,
-0.9557137489318848,
0.2713466286659241,
-0.05302172154188156,
-0.26167672872543335,
-0.7702270150184631,
-0.2068311870098114,
0.3064126968383789,
-0.5498154163360596,
-0.420806348323822,
0.15839503705501556,
0.7613322138786316,
0.5855962038040161,
-0.4433225691318512,
-0.19357766211032867,
-0.5597119331359863,
0.8951243758201599,
-0.5805234909057617,
0.08744984120130539,
0.28427430987358093,
0.33694881200790405,
-0.7016030550003052,
-0.24760040640830994,
-0.5469273328781128,
-0.4210381507873535,
0.02775793895125389,
0.0486803837120533,
-0.22343093156814575,
0.3354468047618866,
0.04389817267656326,
0.28321030735969543,
-0.7185431122779846,
0.6085205078125,
0.20397211611270905,
-0.2887265682220459,
0.8267104625701904,
0.4536190629005432,
0.5711656808853149,
-0.32739633321762085,
-0.7672377228736877,
-0.39706236124038696,
-1.008750319480896,
-0.18274898827075958,
1.0087953805923462,
0.1680232137441635,
0.12593978643417358,
0.2769983112812042,
0.22464437782764435,
0.6794582009315491,
-0.015397006645798683,
-0.18553422391414642,
-0.2269625961780548,
-0.2176155000925064,
-0.11702127754688263,
0.32056427001953125,
0.9139206409454346,
0.6215223073959351,
0.3646829128265381,
-0.2170950472354889,
-0.050491053611040115,
-0.1472606211900711,
0.5772306323051453,
-0.516342282295227,
-0.33900347352027893,
0.6127097606658936,
0.11016170680522919,
-0.8312242031097412,
-0.16847416758537292,
-0.9628812074661255,
-0.5712039470672607,
0.25543180108070374,
0.32405373454093933,
-0.2878422737121582,
-0.3273295760154724,
0.051351651549339294,
0.029416369274258614,
0.4223318099975586,
-0.028314007446169853,
-1.1110128164291382,
0.09642733633518219,
1.0669816732406616,
0.5482498407363892,
-0.4221433699131012,
-0.49764302372932434,
-0.4854964315891266,
0.24410168826580048,
-0.322706401348114,
0.5672518014907837,
-0.36214107275009155,
-0.5463300347328186,
0.0755687952041626,
-0.24249990284442902,
0.047138262540102005,
-0.8116182684898376,
0.5859226584434509,
-0.7265547513961792,
0.08675188571214676,
-0.17157164216041565,
-0.2808728814125061,
0.05885223299264908,
0.27622756361961365,
-0.6041972041130066,
0.7247758507728577,
-0.22962446510791779,
-0.952339768409729,
0.1763797551393509,
-0.103984534740448,
-0.3400515913963318,
-0.38484740257263184,
-0.006225477438420057,
-0.5722814202308655,
-0.2828742563724518,
-0.0021068654023110867,
0.20527631044387817,
0.01786275953054428,
0.41942304372787476,
-0.4720480740070343,
-0.1927138715982437,
0.5706902146339417,
-0.5311253666877747,
0.7339538335800171,
0.32364359498023987,
0.03679383918642998,
0.3926163911819458,
-0.6451864838600159,
-0.02533981390297413,
0.22334618866443634,
-0.37402963638305664,
-0.3675636649131775,
0.14556469023227692,
-0.2123958021402359,
0.3744281828403473,
0.19886033236980438,
-0.3199383616447449,
0.4637722074985504,
-0.5685213208198547,
0.4398604929447174,
1.1847282648086548,
0.44179782271385193,
0.5216741561889648,
-0.4170452356338501,
0.5694843530654907,
0.024337656795978546,
0.6143763065338135,
0.1412535011768341,
-0.14265090227127075,
-0.27664434909820557,
-0.30619579553604126,
0.13186614215373993,
0.9046952724456787,
-0.5013028383255005,
0.6403114795684814,
-0.13309365510940552,
-0.5713211894035339,
-0.2338235080242157,
-0.08971867710351944,
0.7991616725921631,
0.8053027391433716,
0.18080484867095947,
0.002374913776293397,
-0.33950573205947876,
-0.9013383388519287,
-0.4194858968257904,
-0.28022992610931396,
0.2338876873254776,
0.24976909160614014,
0.415790319442749,
-0.35505178570747375,
0.8752978444099426,
-0.6545892357826233,
-0.22152742743492126,
-0.10381711274385452,
-0.4259302616119385,
0.1296888142824173,
0.557957112789154,
0.5275036692619324,
-0.42137205600738525,
-0.3997478187084198,
-0.09345300495624542,
-0.6612982153892517,
-0.32081547379493713,
-0.16107283532619476,
-0.46532657742500305,
0.24248984456062317,
0.1401337832212448,
-0.3380742371082306,
0.23461955785751343,
0.6244704723358154,
-0.005196466110646725,
0.8024400472640991,
-0.02865905873477459,
-0.17308208346366882,
-0.8944205045700073,
-0.03286341577768326,
-0.09927988797426224,
0.011058073490858078,
-0.9270670413970947,
0.2023979276418686,
0.06393866240978241,
-0.27197161316871643,
-0.8646402955055237,
0.4810650944709778,
-0.09930215775966644,
0.17273472249507904,
-0.1019757017493248,
-0.06563280522823334,
0.051880039274692535,
0.49881085753440857,
-0.07472912967205048,
0.9168204665184021,
0.5136613845825195,
-0.5659130215644836,
0.4418947696685791,
0.13375630974769592,
-0.06035199761390686,
0.29119637608528137,
-0.4635470509529114,
0.3123856782913208,
0.2623094320297241,
0.2515066862106323,
-0.7994993925094604,
-0.4004739820957184,
0.5679091215133667,
-0.21460163593292236,
0.6324310302734375,
-0.1820128858089447,
-0.3363869786262512,
-0.01833532191812992,
-0.7661867141723633,
0.266918808221817,
0.27819132804870605,
-0.7001568675041199,
0.16514886915683746,
0.36565420031547546,
0.18509769439697266,
-1.0988572835922241,
-0.479761004447937,
0.08721493929624557,
-0.6164268255233765,
-0.7419272065162659,
0.38788139820098877,
0.06302138417959213,
-0.47569987177848816,
-0.2623661458492279,
-0.31633511185646057,
0.16801373660564423,
0.5124690532684326,
0.19473333656787872,
0.32471174001693726,
0.36205142736434937,
-0.22824189066886902,
-0.027979958802461624,
-0.29673099517822266,
0.10799853503704071,
0.025623800233006477,
0.6795690059661865,
0.18334659934043884,
-0.3447587192058563,
-0.8065001964569092,
0.4524785876274109,
0.42533254623413086,
-0.02723587304353714,
0.5492690801620483,
-0.251487135887146,
0.016406092792749405,
-0.2685321569442749,
-0.150323286652565,
-0.2616811990737915,
-0.5214087963104248,
0.47657978534698486,
-0.23220448195934296,
-0.42123958468437195,
0.5064762830734253,
0.11502612382173538,
-0.051128827035427094,
0.15767614543437958,
0.4246049225330353,
0.08738142251968384,
0.8832481503486633,
0.4396006166934967,
-0.3837980628013611,
0.6147201657295227,
0.016689585521817207,
0.12421561777591705,
-0.9326512813568115,
-0.10634926706552505,
-0.12703408300876617,
-0.17681431770324707,
-0.6798946261405945,
0.03664987161755562,
0.40674179792404175,
-0.026836128905415535,
-0.43207353353500366,
0.2838982045650482,
-0.47142118215560913,
0.6889458298683167,
0.46240532398223877,
0.08431307226419449,
0.29832714796066284,
-0.034082621335983276,
-0.21388857066631317,
-0.14685633778572083,
-0.490104079246521,
-0.5297130346298218,
1.2143058776855469,
0.5326575040817261,
1.1835228204727173,
0.242738276720047,
0.9536405205726624,
0.20323128998279572,
0.05584140121936798,
-0.9039322733879089,
0.47727739810943604,
0.14802679419517517,
-0.7018991708755493,
-0.2079208493232727,
-0.360319048166275,
-1.080479621887207,
0.35585683584213257,
0.010335076600313187,
-0.7682351469993591,
0.12442052364349365,
0.30899128317832947,
-0.4228335916996002,
0.2138206660747528,
-0.86640465259552,
0.9251598715782166,
-0.6554079055786133,
-0.6328052282333374,
0.014737915247678757,
-0.6876970529556274,
0.6174332499504089,
-0.0885288417339325,
-0.04059019684791565,
-0.1456374078989029,
-0.002288084477186203,
0.5947302579879761,
-0.5614258646965027,
0.8307921886444092,
0.0037833142559975386,
-0.505979061126709,
0.008522173389792442,
0.25102460384368896,
0.5554138422012329,
0.04271884262561798,
-0.15248434245586395,
0.17683036625385284,
-0.010119699873030186,
-0.30558064579963684,
-0.5215901136398315,
0.8916709423065186,
-0.9612319469451904,
-1.0896682739257812,
-0.9098044037818909,
-0.2812800109386444,
-0.32209521532058716,
-0.010874854400753975,
0.2439274787902832,
0.0935443863272667,
-0.029292069375514984,
-0.45058709383010864,
0.6684757471084595,
-0.5280141830444336,
0.38387495279312134,
0.5249066948890686,
-0.23810438811779022,
-0.5897310376167297,
0.9635725021362305,
-0.01599067449569702,
0.6323637366294861,
0.38821256160736084,
0.413457989692688,
-0.09503241628408432,
-0.5746711492538452,
-0.30777111649513245,
0.44540929794311523,
-0.6407503485679626,
-0.30501049757003784,
-0.32387489080429077,
-0.09928429871797562,
-0.5390855669975281,
-0.07532057911157608,
-0.28710150718688965,
0.03135128691792488,
-0.40503859519958496,
-0.17431554198265076,
0.35687124729156494,
0.5510857105255127,
-0.01911277137696743,
0.4700060784816742,
-0.6422252655029297,
-0.21799172461032867,
0.41481053829193115,
0.03521652892231941,
0.013669868931174278,
-0.38396182656288147,
0.21506944298744202,
-0.29986295104026794,
-0.63901287317276,
-1.4983820915222168,
0.5532245635986328,
-0.1217321902513504,
0.526069700717926,
0.5446799993515015,
0.3019658327102661,
0.5209967494010925,
-0.607703447341919,
0.7516708374023438,
0.15026012063026428,
-0.6874361038208008,
0.5721557140350342,
-0.4256049692630768,
-0.20109984278678894,
0.6088479161262512,
0.5018278360366821,
-0.6676644682884216,
-0.16022218763828278,
-0.3188202381134033,
-1.0588515996932983,
0.7416926622390747,
-0.1454641968011856,
0.08133280277252197,
-0.03892343118786812,
0.44732868671417236,
0.10952720046043396,
0.06326237320899963,
-0.5948575139045715,
-0.17828837037086487,
0.15368196368217468,
-0.01900411583483219,
0.29069942235946655,
-0.5167394876480103,
-0.24256297945976257,
-0.006527959369122982,
0.7748777866363525,
0.21552608907222748,
-0.0751604288816452,
0.16449278593063354,
-0.07422030717134476,
-0.0861276164650917,
0.3860083222389221,
0.7054963707923889,
0.3948535621166229,
-0.2838366627693176,
0.2031359076499939,
0.051387980580329895,
-0.5085009336471558,
0.35748112201690674,
-0.24281980097293854,
-0.04547181725502014,
-0.7348621487617493,
0.5334330201148987,
0.5992774963378906,
0.16183477640151978,
-0.8246738314628601,
0.45519518852233887,
-0.09950192272663116,
0.16338226199150085,
-0.3928470015525818,
0.3028715252876282,
-0.2600846588611603,
0.014837322756648064,
0.178172305226326,
-0.37377306818962097,
-0.11487745493650436,
-0.7192210555076599,
0.19436118006706238,
0.5502119064331055,
-0.2970869243144989,
-0.2824029326438904,
0.37672093510627747,
0.27540507912635803,
-0.3578644394874573,
0.514387845993042,
0.19013214111328125,
-0.9212972521781921,
0.35659676790237427,
0.5866747498512268,
0.785176694393158,
-0.6160611510276794,
-0.09557844698429108,
0.12052839249372482,
0.2723216116428375,
0.2014419436454773,
-0.0067750015296041965,
0.024446235969662666,
-0.8241358399391174,
-0.2513519823551178,
-0.5175624489784241,
-0.600751519203186,
0.23749347031116486,
-0.5652444362640381,
0.059856582432985306,
-0.6420292854309082,
-0.18982556462287903,
-0.2362712323665619,
-0.0600435696542263,
0.19184623658657074,
-0.2275974154472351,
-0.01896549202501774,
0.44997233152389526,
-0.9346850514411926,
0.7115870714187622,
0.30354347825050354,
-0.3193311095237732,
-0.6459605097770691,
0.48085111379623413,
0.2433464676141739,
-0.9563909769058228,
0.7151128053665161,
0.04603296145796776,
-0.13816945254802704,
-0.06578093767166138,
-0.3920274078845978,
-0.7035557627677917,
0.8671891093254089,
0.402843713760376,
-0.6633769869804382,
-0.18390153348445892,
0.0340893417596817,
0.35818472504615784,
0.1495753675699234,
-0.17532022297382355,
0.8015733957290649,
0.49299848079681396,
-0.11216385662555695,
-0.8355486989021301,
0.06312845647335052,
0.12895433604717255,
-0.05488898605108261,
0.36734455823898315,
-0.6826096773147583,
0.5711402297019958,
-0.16677531599998474,
-0.2530066668987274,
-0.23914377391338348,
0.34076908230781555,
0.2843119502067566,
0.08834660053253174,
0.38411712646484375,
0.9637017250061035,
0.6167859435081482,
0.06579464673995972,
1.2314972877502441,
-0.013620647601783276,
0.17090009152889252,
1.1712185144424438,
-0.8060081005096436,
0.9816092848777771,
0.7634643912315369,
-0.3037343919277191,
0.34978336095809937,
0.708706796169281,
0.16190195083618164,
0.881367564201355,
0.5100616216659546,
-0.3231269419193268,
-0.12229756265878677,
0.022021280601620674,
-0.2398565709590912,
0.21630680561065674,
0.30338719487190247,
-0.17765772342681885,
-0.06161841005086899,
0.022611256688833237,
0.5526354312896729,
0.17103679478168488,
-0.044830240309238434,
1.0595169067382812,
0.03360855206847191,
-1.0429999828338623,
0.6337665915489197,
-0.1729985475540161,
0.6621254086494446,
-0.48141029477119446,
0.2123851776123047,
-0.23323948681354523,
0.4378838837146759,
-0.41963300108909607,
-0.9062844514846802,
0.35896092653274536,
-0.09267915785312653,
0.06246126443147659,
-0.033267393708229065,
0.5988009572029114,
-0.18986375629901886,
0.29504355788230896,
0.525902509689331,
-0.09937816858291626,
-0.12365230917930603,
-0.10040812939405441,
-0.6058789491653442,
0.24288727343082428,
0.0049682073295116425,
-0.3201036751270294,
0.6749469041824341,
-0.08263934403657913,
-0.0522921159863472,
0.8044083714485168,
0.685256838798523,
0.23712366819381714,
0.2639214098453522,
-0.2627497613430023,
0.8542624115943909,
-0.4177056849002838,
-0.21767011284828186,
-1.2876852750778198,
0.21190427243709564,
-0.09642375260591507,
-0.11581060290336609,
0.8310537934303284,
0.3496325612068176,
0.7329631447792053,
0.05706821754574776,
0.5423488020896912,
0.39444780349731445,
0.05378154665231705,
-0.6565952897071838,
0.8165903687477112,
-0.4193987250328064,
0.4281637966632843,
-0.16356037557125092,
-0.7148266434669495,
-0.3450150787830353,
0.2934108078479767,
-0.7269687056541443,
-0.3287999629974365,
0.6635287404060364,
1.0252289772033691,
0.41680005192756653,
-0.24112342298030853,
0.2008245587348938,
0.1279783546924591,
0.588463544845581,
0.701446533203125,
1.2249057292938232,
-0.07000821083784103,
0.5861445069313049,
-0.38510432839393616,
-0.2496127337217331,
-0.4449349045753479,
-1.0019123554229736,
-0.8020561933517456,
-0.29605504870414734,
-0.2560120224952698,
-0.6021023988723755,
0.18832430243492126,
0.7377225160598755,
0.44822558760643005,
-0.5969139933586121,
-0.08633478730916977,
-0.09543737024068832,
0.48377856612205505,
-0.01591736264526844,
-0.27321159839630127,
0.2808662950992584,
-0.2375483363866806,
-0.5395413041114807,
0.38912665843963623,
0.30979299545288086,
0.029999205842614174,
-0.4457494616508484,
-0.09741794317960739,
-0.290336936712265,
0.03203651309013367,
0.25066184997558594,
0.5048199892044067,
-0.8045182824134827,
-0.44295254349708557,
-0.20976948738098145,
-0.2588108479976654,
0.030041111633181572,
0.5904972553253174,
-0.3758184611797333,
0.4588955342769623,
0.6852274537086487,
0.6692928075790405,
-0.026995884254574776,
0.12555073201656342,
0.617379367351532,
-0.8124236464500427,
0.14004573225975037,
0.4372624456882477,
0.25496000051498413,
0.2286529541015625,
-0.8043944239616394,
0.2583410441875458,
0.06471012532711029,
-0.7994585633277893,
-1.1274850368499756,
0.7361809611320496,
-0.9985523819923401,
-0.31035423278808594,
1.3326133489608765,
-0.1317153424024582,
-0.623417317867279,
0.0443156473338604,
-0.32209402322769165,
-0.0029975625220686197,
-0.5685639977455139,
0.7603909373283386,
0.6168007850646973,
-0.22234976291656494,
0.2898217439651489,
-0.5691815614700317,
0.6598456501960754,
0.3967199921607971,
-0.7996248006820679,
0.3361310064792633,
0.40610969066619873,
0.49183088541030884,
0.08015074580907822,
0.32529938220977783,
-0.21447324752807617,
0.10215837508440018,
-0.23523162305355072,
-0.08661922812461853,
-0.024625487625598907,
-0.3941366374492645,
-0.6408735513687134,
0.014899223111569881,
0.2740339934825897,
-0.1725040227174759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12084v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12084v1
|
When Reasoning Meets Information Aggregation: A Case Study with Sports Narratives
| 2024-06-17T20:49:35 | 2024-06-17T20:49:35 |
Yebowen Hu, Kaiqiang Song, Sangwoo Cho, Xiaoyang Wang, Wenlin Yao, Hassan Foroosh, Dong Yu, Fei Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Reasoning is most powerful when an LLM accurately aggregates relevant
information. We examine the critical role of information aggregation in
reasoning by requiring the LLM to analyze sports narratives. To succeed at this
task, an LLM must infer points from actions, identify related entities,
attribute points accurately to players and teams, and compile key statistics to
draw conclusions. We conduct comprehensive experiments with real NBA basketball
data and present SportsGen, a new method to synthesize game narratives. By
synthesizing data, we can rigorously evaluate LLMs' reasoning capabilities
under complex scenarios with varying narrative lengths and density of
information. Our findings show that most models, including GPT-4o, often fail
to accurately aggregate basketball scores due to frequent scoring patterns.
Open-source models like Llama-3 further suffer from significant score
hallucinations. Finally, the effectiveness of reasoning is influenced by
narrative complexity, information density, and domain-specific terms,
highlighting the challenges in analytical reasoning tasks.
|
[
-0.24713602662086487,
-0.8978893160820007,
1.0049409866333008,
0.13606011867523193,
-0.19846419990062714,
0.3110971748828888,
0.15470103919506073,
-0.6736109852790833,
0.014345582574605942,
0.1309773176908493,
-0.35225909948349,
-0.4879392087459564,
-0.7149364352226257,
-0.06246756762266159,
-0.44224926829338074,
0.7538027763366699,
-0.24670828878879547,
-0.12179084867238998,
-0.5844677090644836,
-0.3415445387363434,
-0.517169177532196,
-0.604817807674408,
-0.5855441689491272,
-0.3881182372570038,
-0.07855001837015152,
0.3138751685619354,
0.6868979334831238,
0.770600438117981,
0.7466241121292114,
0.3771580755710602,
0.20446129143238068,
0.605694591999054,
-0.7370910048484802,
0.5281633138656616,
-0.22913457453250885,
-0.6655212044715881,
-0.5801489353179932,
0.2062498778104782,
0.3094428777694702,
0.6543675661087036,
-0.2006891369819641,
0.261814147233963,
-0.12359856814146042,
0.5857378840446472,
-0.4345383048057556,
0.12579520046710968,
-0.35231813788414,
0.05510398745536804,
-0.01341478805989027,
-0.5507801175117493,
-0.1506023406982422,
-0.430738627910614,
-0.038418762385845184,
-0.6956724524497986,
0.16744941473007202,
0.04100460931658745,
0.6799248456954956,
0.3708667755126953,
-0.3104637861251831,
-0.40985631942749023,
-1.0671151876449585,
0.694797933101654,
-0.44603419303894043,
0.23826730251312256,
0.4328075647354126,
0.23429732024669647,
-0.14782346785068512,
-0.34156543016433716,
-0.41496092081069946,
0.03200879693031311,
0.017738286405801773,
0.38037699460983276,
-0.41689515113830566,
-0.1600225418806076,
0.32979822158813477,
0.13677985966205597,
-0.4602193236351013,
-0.20750612020492554,
-0.7063623070716858,
0.2051164209842682,
0.90877765417099,
0.5298580527305603,
0.24183732271194458,
0.15651892125606537,
-0.4342552423477173,
0.40147504210472107,
-0.4671576917171478,
0.2753676176071167,
0.32202669978141785,
-0.1772889345884323,
0.12828731536865234,
0.7240977883338928,
-0.21129824221134186,
0.5165776014328003,
0.10050670802593231,
-0.4442978501319885,
0.05593357980251312,
-0.18515627086162567,
-0.2254437506198883,
0.580511212348938,
0.678733229637146,
0.7443936467170715,
0.07576607912778854,
-0.43480849266052246,
0.12996944785118103,
0.09405063092708588,
0.28848305344581604,
-0.38331711292266846,
-0.04838778078556061,
0.639989972114563,
-0.49180397391319275,
-0.16306167840957642,
0.1315561681985855,
-0.46851488947868347,
-0.5085749626159668,
-0.5332061648368835,
0.43865934014320374,
-0.6365841627120972,
0.1679598093032837,
0.1082361713051796,
-0.651151180267334,
0.30680587887763977,
0.44222331047058105,
-0.7054997682571411,
0.1955738067626953,
0.7847092151641846,
0.7981966733932495,
-0.18925774097442627,
-0.40139642357826233,
-0.4723396301269531,
0.5809637308120728,
-0.5766713619232178,
1.2242470979690552,
-0.4833715558052063,
-0.1925840973854065,
-0.2542566657066345,
-0.6857591271400452,
0.20773600041866302,
-0.5313392281532288,
0.4187414348125458,
-0.07864265888929367,
-0.10245784372091293,
-0.04187936335802078,
-1.0216152667999268,
-0.0621190071105957,
0.42231085896492004,
-0.4253809452056885,
0.9216495156288147,
0.0854838490486145,
-0.3998754620552063,
0.6145427823066711,
-0.4076453745365143,
-0.43453249335289,
0.12077252566814423,
-0.3425581157207489,
-0.025851137936115265,
0.36913132667541504,
0.15112997591495514,
0.27224811911582947,
-0.42522555589675903,
0.21083509922027588,
-0.2802666127681732,
-0.5654547214508057,
0.39266306161880493,
-0.021479686722159386,
0.38821208477020264,
0.1976919025182724,
-0.01342878770083189,
-0.23190410435199738,
-0.5068475008010864,
-0.1345614343881607,
0.11608458310365677,
-0.3503931164741516,
-0.2774112820625305,
0.4698573350906372,
-0.944358766078949,
-0.11773768067359924,
-0.06781807541847229,
-0.04064434766769409,
0.325204998254776,
-0.14842699468135834,
-0.022575801238417625,
0.6312588453292847,
-0.035738203674554825,
0.631754994392395,
-0.4213798940181732,
0.5151568651199341,
-0.1803378313779831,
0.35029909014701843,
0.02659384347498417,
-0.6510325074195862,
-0.13655327260494232,
-0.05428794026374817,
-0.18619295954704285,
0.7307842373847961,
-0.6818975210189819,
0.14921438694000244,
-0.3063802123069763,
-0.829882800579071,
-0.15248307585716248,
0.12332300841808319,
-0.144429013133049,
0.7727658152580261,
0.2233397215604782,
0.11312302201986313,
-0.42246684432029724,
-0.5328943729400635,
-0.6430450081825256,
-0.4027513861656189,
0.12125959992408752,
0.3395475745201111,
0.2012171596288681,
0.21087345480918884,
0.7471573352813721,
-0.6948440670967102,
-0.23987248539924622,
-0.5822315216064453,
0.23213820159435272,
0.4136669635772705,
0.14915896952152252,
0.7627425789833069,
-0.6055191159248352,
-0.052389174699783325,
-0.2354041188955307,
-1.3587665557861328,
-0.21574734151363373,
-0.18979676067829132,
-0.3088392913341522,
-0.4050224721431732,
0.4632856249809265,
-0.9847449660301208,
0.6411671042442322,
0.4276106357574463,
-0.6386858820915222,
0.45868781208992004,
-0.255563884973526,
0.5765736103057861,
-0.36360591650009155,
-0.3900515139102936,
0.255218505859375,
0.1061878353357315,
-0.8914206624031067,
-0.07027804106473923,
-0.5591534376144409,
0.2963426411151886,
-0.05770017206668854,
0.4293058216571808,
-0.3744262456893921,
-0.2733765244483948,
-0.48250043392181396,
0.32810142636299133,
0.1647382229566574,
0.14318124949932098,
-0.07816675305366516,
0.4346622824668884,
0.5132107138633728,
-0.9084025025367737,
0.8867762684822083,
0.2074083685874939,
-0.657997727394104,
0.6326523423194885,
-0.2423376888036728,
-0.16220858693122864,
-0.4521850049495697,
0.27801957726478577,
-0.7432923316955566,
-0.40008804202079773,
0.20244121551513672,
-0.5434617400169373,
0.007121913135051727,
0.1550932228565216,
-0.37126728892326355,
-0.33473289012908936,
-0.31021130084991455,
0.5333141684532166,
0.2852797508239746,
-0.18586257100105286,
0.9883478879928589,
0.7209972143173218,
-0.09480444341897964,
-0.2694704234600067,
-0.6984227895736694,
-0.04430660605430603,
-0.4882884621620178,
-0.6791112422943115,
0.13790881633758545,
-0.2815060615539551,
-0.8930606245994568,
0.023235227912664413,
-0.374945729970932,
-0.35609176754951477,
0.19509920477867126,
0.1441822201013565,
0.3783417344093323,
-0.17658236622810364,
0.2713651657104492,
-0.06991806626319885,
0.09652706980705261,
0.19157221913337708,
0.01989685744047165,
0.19660058617591858,
0.14255376160144806,
-0.19710955023765564,
-0.08224739134311676,
0.37886613607406616,
0.2230723649263382,
0.20842845737934113,
0.7591618895530701,
0.21644757688045502,
-0.13631099462509155,
-0.1575823426246643,
-0.5271182060241699,
-0.05405407026410103,
-0.34365665912628174,
0.054985471069812775,
-0.35890284180641174,
-0.812842845916748,
0.36936137080192566,
-0.04596531763672829,
0.1200321763753891,
0.5145310163497925,
0.5544995069503784,
-0.48675158619880676,
1.2931721210479736,
-0.14118832349777222,
0.15373452007770538,
0.007994365878403187,
-0.005295547191053629,
0.32849135994911194,
-0.494285523891449,
-0.4680868983268738,
-0.2352021038532257,
-0.5527951717376709,
-0.14853619039058685,
-0.4269797205924988,
0.38502275943756104,
0.36659589409828186,
-0.20950058102607727,
-0.08435255289077759,
-0.37277376651763916,
1.0421830415725708,
0.5627216696739197,
0.3362232446670532,
0.3876122832298279,
-0.2435544729232788,
0.47133561968803406,
0.16771307587623596,
-0.6868268251419067,
-0.384552925825119,
0.802314817905426,
0.09534578770399094,
0.6034725308418274,
0.4883445203304291,
0.7183858752250671,
0.3716830611228943,
0.22620290517807007,
-0.9218360185623169,
0.4533239006996155,
-0.10652848333120346,
-0.6610079407691956,
-0.3199674189090729,
-0.528068482875824,
-0.7642224431037903,
0.052841510623693466,
-0.32945379614830017,
-0.8179672956466675,
0.04508204385638237,
0.1662997305393219,
-0.658811092376709,
0.2994529902935028,
-0.7728568315505981,
0.3167421817779541,
-0.4594816267490387,
-0.4650121331214905,
0.10495835542678833,
-0.2960491478443146,
0.8602954745292664,
-0.06294305622577667,
0.6586953401565552,
-0.46189188957214355,
-0.08236127346754074,
0.6295086145401001,
-0.3760843873023987,
0.3296954333782196,
0.23096001148223877,
0.1124577671289444,
0.8894892930984497,
0.47861093282699585,
0.2644089162349701,
-0.10258475691080093,
-0.10875707864761353,
0.22014360129833221,
-0.12849493324756622,
-0.4512534737586975,
-0.8028138875961304,
0.48571643233299255,
-0.5911136269569397,
-1.052629828453064,
-0.4643854796886444,
-0.6476563215255737,
-0.4817473292350769,
-0.32185766100883484,
0.2375781387090683,
0.20124180614948273,
-0.03238818049430847,
0.11631418019533157,
0.4067521095275879,
0.13265949487686157,
0.22682686150074005,
0.14499163627624512,
-0.03153896704316139,
-0.039496418088674545,
0.6462809443473816,
0.18223130702972412,
-0.10594554990530014,
0.23013460636138916,
0.434957355260849,
-0.11413916200399399,
-0.7359107136726379,
-0.02182089164853096,
0.10478087514638901,
-0.9775375723838806,
-0.35093873739242554,
-0.14334160089492798,
-0.09469525516033173,
-0.3186951279640198,
-0.1446930468082428,
-0.07343573123216629,
-0.2816705107688904,
-0.10712143778800964,
-0.7584027647972107,
0.2202637493610382,
0.9187358617782593,
-0.3675198554992676,
0.07943384349346161,
-1.1679797172546387,
0.3863435685634613,
0.23030295968055725,
0.21962280571460724,
-0.04923444241285324,
-0.4198426306247711,
-0.15396811068058014,
-0.21489012241363525,
-0.1346084475517273,
-1.0126018524169922,
0.2726159691810608,
-0.1936710774898529,
0.9806477427482605,
0.509804904460907,
-0.2602404057979584,
0.7499080896377563,
-0.3964611887931824,
0.9735457897186279,
0.2627792954444885,
-0.6932264566421509,
0.5794349908828735,
-0.44465962052345276,
0.3582178056240082,
0.3842910826206207,
0.34797361493110657,
0.06345885992050171,
-0.4678260087966919,
-0.6565752029418945,
-0.5896279215812683,
0.8204054236412048,
0.29709839820861816,
-0.06110759079456329,
-0.2773914635181427,
0.42142435908317566,
0.2012428641319275,
0.09557602554559708,
-0.29199835658073425,
-0.282298743724823,
-0.04314973205327988,
-0.19080275297164917,
-0.07557826489210129,
-0.35119542479515076,
-0.1548791080713272,
-0.3414001762866974,
0.5846655964851379,
0.2469630092382431,
0.008894059807062149,
0.16811881959438324,
0.030321504920721054,
-0.08054208010435104,
-0.21706658601760864,
0.6460075974464417,
0.9637287259101868,
-0.054678238928318024,
0.2586209774017334,
0.2323593944311142,
-0.1414605677127838,
0.19682857394218445,
-0.16474749147891998,
0.0873914510011673,
-0.12545843422412872,
0.8434464335441589,
0.7149900197982788,
0.11152636259794235,
-0.8688191771507263,
0.39449572563171387,
-0.05063297599554062,
-0.6671823263168335,
0.10239864885807037,
0.34620770812034607,
0.14722806215286255,
0.6436583399772644,
0.4853956401348114,
0.18795739114284515,
0.2080819457769394,
-1.0486069917678833,
0.06072518602013588,
0.08935095369815826,
-0.13298290967941284,
-0.04376786947250366,
0.7290180325508118,
-0.06313628703355789,
-0.0333368182182312,
0.4594873785972595,
-0.00789053924381733,
-0.5259485244750977,
0.6704174280166626,
0.15970537066459656,
0.268231064081192,
-0.35357367992401123,
0.2989632487297058,
0.3890151381492615,
0.1791258603334427,
-0.38495156168937683,
0.04623064026236534,
0.05309014022350311,
-0.8610233068466187,
-0.5913258790969849,
-0.350606232881546,
-0.34145253896713257,
-0.13200882077217102,
-0.10720404982566833,
-0.12686747312545776,
-0.18403175473213196,
-0.16018015146255493,
0.0262933187186718,
-0.4688606560230255,
-0.44430598616600037,
0.30067989230155945,
0.33260053396224976,
0.6430566906929016,
-0.6967192888259888,
0.018930546939373016,
0.42346522212028503,
-0.6335756778717041,
-0.9537165760993958,
-0.3172171115875244,
0.2555672824382782,
-0.8606976270675659,
0.9474056959152222,
-0.22296015918254852,
-0.011849994771182537,
-0.17132623493671417,
-0.84365314245224,
-0.5726836323738098,
1.20554518699646,
0.3756561577320099,
-0.2662178874015808,
-0.05326704680919647,
0.06266007572412491,
0.4640332758426666,
-0.41000667214393616,
0.2589932084083557,
0.942171573638916,
0.4224714934825897,
0.7334303855895996,
-0.45847785472869873,
-0.22982174158096313,
0.05294056609272957,
-0.7210723161697388,
0.1453431397676468,
-0.7383503317832947,
0.7453967928886414,
-0.4300612211227417,
-0.042738690972328186,
-0.23151171207427979,
0.6264652609825134,
0.5496495962142944,
0.6892829537391663,
0.2021966576576233,
0.5429925322532654,
1.0824644565582275,
-0.22571805119514465,
1.2751209735870361,
-0.05374661833047867,
0.04333335533738136,
1.046105980873108,
-0.49385619163513184,
0.3240898549556732,
0.2958979606628418,
-0.20057551562786102,
0.19186663627624512,
0.3927995562553406,
-0.13803377747535706,
0.21448834240436554,
0.14214453101158142,
-0.28996774554252625,
-0.6080933213233948,
-0.05329379811882973,
0.07926756143569946,
0.9823895692825317,
0.2905091643333435,
-0.36923748254776,
-0.2865481376647949,
-0.3932487666606903,
0.13366039097309113,
0.16676631569862366,
-0.6491188406944275,
0.9014539122581482,
0.0805804431438446,
-0.8960136771202087,
-0.34496375918388367,
-0.38313329219818115,
-0.13554807007312775,
-0.34345346689224243,
-0.22809866070747375,
-0.5029129981994629,
0.07756354659795761,
-0.2606707215309143,
-0.9797606468200684,
0.34063246846199036,
0.29928696155548096,
-0.05936102941632271,
-0.08435090631246567,
0.8458158373832703,
-0.18922880291938782,
-0.4962351322174072,
0.041833799332380295,
0.8979811072349548,
0.42473429441452026,
-0.19570359587669373,
-0.533392071723938,
0.19414518773555756,
-0.08453096449375153,
-0.2436106950044632,
0.30889812111854553,
0.8794965147972107,
0.10462170094251633,
0.6903921365737915,
0.5508498549461365,
0.35610291361808777,
0.16096436977386475,
0.07539371401071548,
0.5027872920036316,
-0.6515464186668396,
-0.2960665225982666,
-1.319588541984558,
0.29267555475234985,
-0.4627158045768738,
-0.07271216064691544,
0.7996602058410645,
0.9263922572135925,
0.25924625992774963,
0.05525389313697815,
0.9444880485534668,
0.2476196587085724,
0.4299294352531433,
-0.6670041084289551,
0.31347182393074036,
-0.33669155836105347,
0.40008407831192017,
0.13027070462703705,
-0.882423996925354,
-0.4279031455516815,
0.4331883192062378,
-0.33854153752326965,
-0.13753525912761688,
0.6086887121200562,
0.02147708274424076,
0.17747937142848969,
0.24407151341438293,
0.2849976718425751,
0.28096044063568115,
0.3273603320121765,
0.5519497990608215,
1.040578007698059,
-0.15676544606685638,
0.8781859874725342,
0.07536862790584564,
-0.41625234484672546,
-0.11622384935617447,
-0.7076444625854492,
-0.9346815943717957,
-0.16962102055549622,
-0.37290695309638977,
-0.31912145018577576,
-0.003180727595463395,
0.6172705888748169,
0.14120902121067047,
-0.4324263036251068,
-0.22239120304584503,
0.06548184901475906,
0.3392072021961212,
-0.265575647354126,
-0.28310322761535645,
0.26153138279914856,
-0.3174973726272583,
-0.5106077790260315,
0.45351406931877136,
0.6153929829597473,
-0.03030351921916008,
0.3091757297515869,
-0.12838132679462433,
-0.22852961719036102,
0.4555675685405731,
0.8066710829734802,
0.11137572675943375,
-0.47794848680496216,
-0.31244421005249023,
-0.06080259755253792,
0.0153767429292202,
0.20830005407333374,
0.8540694117546082,
-0.6837892532348633,
0.44647425413131714,
0.6359853148460388,
0.3614475429058075,
0.34203794598579407,
0.5563454031944275,
0.6417135000228882,
-0.312811017036438,
-0.23030239343643188,
0.1393420398235321,
0.39089667797088623,
0.01627371646463871,
-0.24138502776622772,
0.8445050716400146,
0.4732969105243683,
-0.4846029579639435,
-0.49375519156455994,
-0.10785125195980072,
-0.8250579237937927,
-0.6279780268669128,
1.156295895576477,
0.14743328094482422,
-0.3188984990119934,
-0.13306570053100586,
-0.20903277397155762,
0.1417362540960312,
-0.31012827157974243,
0.9064987897872925,
1.1820329427719116,
-0.9035314917564392,
-0.1530987173318863,
-0.5828512907028198,
0.5730397701263428,
-0.4529261589050293,
-0.8625726699829102,
-0.17289721965789795,
0.6567553877830505,
-0.25101613998413086,
0.14452973008155823,
0.8042315244674683,
0.3018503785133362,
0.2186557650566101,
0.46230077743530273,
-0.6027864217758179,
-0.18797659873962402,
-0.13993069529533386,
0.49986565113067627,
0.476707398891449,
-0.2699492871761322,
0.17885366082191467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12074v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12074v1
|
COMMUNITY-CROSS-INSTRUCT: Unsupervised Instruction Generation for Aligning Large Language Models to Online Communities
| 2024-06-17T20:20:47 | 2024-06-17T20:20:47 |
Zihao He, Rebecca Dorn, Siyi Guo, Minh Duc Chu, Kristina Lerman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social scientists use surveys to probe the opinions and beliefs of
populations, but these methods are slow, costly, and prone to biases. Recent
advances in large language models (LLMs) enable creating computational
representations or "digital twins" of populations that generate human-like
responses mimicking the population's language, styles, and attitudes. We
introduce Community-Cross-Instruct, an unsupervised framework for aligning LLMs
to online communities to elicit their beliefs. Given a corpus of a community's
online discussions, Community-Cross-Instruct automatically generates
instruction-output pairs by an advanced LLM to (1) finetune an foundational LLM
to faithfully represent that community, and (2) evaluate the alignment of the
finetuned model to the community. We demonstrate the method's utility in
accurately representing political and fitness communities on Reddit. Unlike
prior methods requiring human-authored instructions, Community-Cross-Instruct
generates instructions in a fully unsupervised manner, enhancing scalability
and generalization across domains. This work enables cost-effective and
automated surveying of diverse online communities.
|
[
-0.4876999258995056,
-0.5639486312866211,
0.5875974893569946,
-0.10077560693025589,
-0.13132227957248688,
0.5974445343017578,
-0.5340626239776611,
-0.19484636187553406,
0.6203243136405945,
0.4480758607387543,
-0.5042006969451904,
-0.5802483558654785,
-0.5834766626358032,
-0.31336066126823425,
-0.46495649218559265,
0.8742005825042725,
0.1749841570854187,
0.3065260350704193,
-0.6172258257865906,
-0.02639799565076828,
-0.014014297164976597,
-0.5095773935317993,
-0.2675594091415405,
-0.3951427936553955,
0.2920871675014496,
0.6557261347770691,
0.5719102621078491,
0.3850380778312683,
0.10267169028520584,
0.2584042251110077,
0.21981731057167053,
0.2906692922115326,
-0.7010667324066162,
-0.12820662558078766,
-0.3241988718509674,
-0.39063534140586853,
-0.07321486622095108,
0.11202652752399445,
0.5120441913604736,
1.0673478841781616,
-0.13205361366271973,
0.4611814618110657,
0.35841092467308044,
0.649337649345398,
-0.7553567886352539,
-0.07774366438388824,
-0.5757387280464172,
-0.31620344519615173,
-0.012715558521449566,
-0.18798260390758514,
-0.3613101840019226,
-0.7890904545783997,
0.06098391115665436,
-0.3583735525608063,
0.47525960206985474,
-0.13235270977020264,
0.2484472393989563,
0.007394855376332998,
-0.5187061429023743,
-0.35333022475242615,
-0.747122585773468,
0.8895542621612549,
-0.40000131726264954,
0.4641982913017273,
0.2678712010383606,
0.29226720333099365,
-0.2231154590845108,
-0.4376395642757416,
-0.506885826587677,
0.27166837453842163,
0.03214852139353752,
0.11407218128442764,
-0.08829016238451004,
-0.11739630252122879,
-0.11578211933374405,
0.1766858696937561,
-0.3824654221534729,
0.23996466398239136,
-0.3709936738014221,
0.0885627493262291,
0.7348958253860474,
0.17296387255191803,
0.1646471917629242,
-0.04825243353843689,
-0.13473960757255554,
-0.11592016369104385,
-0.88570237159729,
-0.15155452489852905,
0.4993389844894409,
0.30442312359809875,
-0.07124796509742737,
0.6321559548377991,
-0.07605113089084625,
0.4204510748386383,
0.6877982020378113,
0.13637752830982208,
0.16423138976097107,
-0.2887224853038788,
0.005720469634979963,
0.1244422122836113,
0.6664959192276001,
0.6267408132553101,
0.29142990708351135,
-0.06670165807008743,
0.014492728747427464,
0.280624657869339,
0.12280239164829254,
-0.591278612613678,
-0.23369424045085907,
0.12709768116474152,
-0.524532675743103,
-0.35031670331954956,
0.35071250796318054,
-1.1107978820800781,
-0.5466712117195129,
-0.371508926153183,
0.1740378439426422,
0.18760287761688232,
-0.37350136041641235,
0.12512825429439545,
0.03028368204832077,
-0.014992848969995975,
0.4157353639602661,
-0.9638850688934326,
0.39934635162353516,
0.7661079168319702,
0.5822349190711975,
-0.23152142763137817,
-0.1562737673521042,
-0.41807013750076294,
0.3358910381793976,
-0.1221541240811348,
0.7883997559547424,
-0.9292307496070862,
-0.36664268374443054,
0.32300451397895813,
-0.006665773689746857,
0.15906144678592682,
-0.4069735109806061,
-0.37935981154441833,
-0.4834248125553131,
0.46213865280151367,
-0.2698739469051361,
-0.7596847414970398,
0.17210091650485992,
0.2957405745983124,
-0.5328875184059143,
1.0240122079849243,
0.10774505883455276,
-0.6311531662940979,
0.154687762260437,
-0.6689683794975281,
-0.27020472288131714,
-0.13316422700881958,
-0.2511788308620453,
-0.21832787990570068,
0.061241909861564636,
0.42044395208358765,
0.42175790667533875,
-0.2795904576778412,
0.05136171728372574,
-0.46959787607192993,
-0.1402505338191986,
0.3999260365962982,
-0.21356670558452606,
0.8892339468002319,
-0.05330519750714302,
-0.5695520043373108,
0.12183938920497894,
-0.32937121391296387,
-0.048530690371990204,
0.017476841807365417,
-0.28557372093200684,
-0.5393837094306946,
0.3395812213420868,
-0.13156159222126007,
-0.18214890360832214,
0.2902345657348633,
-0.7537700533866882,
0.3293144404888153,
-0.4077538847923279,
0.529625415802002,
0.7571490406990051,
0.0603954903781414,
0.660603404045105,
-0.25177454948425293,
0.4945896565914154,
-0.34988781809806824,
0.36347225308418274,
0.2513992488384247,
-0.5229886770248413,
-0.7177478075027466,
0.07367594540119171,
0.22207824885845184,
0.27991849184036255,
-0.6218833327293396,
0.38827353715896606,
-0.2619965672492981,
-0.5939659476280212,
-0.5710505843162537,
0.2120196521282196,
0.284761518239975,
0.061068832874298096,
0.4157589375972748,
-0.15623173117637634,
-0.4737195372581482,
-0.5399978160858154,
-0.15985529124736786,
-0.0716109648346901,
-0.15364794433116913,
-0.024794965982437134,
0.364124059677124,
-0.4606662094593048,
0.7533299326896667,
-0.6163760423660278,
0.13805781304836273,
-0.2591204047203064,
0.3933824896812439,
-0.30745601654052734,
0.20703482627868652,
0.38033077120780945,
-0.46044015884399414,
-0.688962459564209,
0.011846935376524925,
-0.28387314081192017,
-0.24663624167442322,
0.05532919242978096,
-0.26465117931365967,
-0.011415953747928143,
0.38953691720962524,
-0.20717841386795044,
0.3329291045665741,
0.7594446539878845,
-0.008066145703196526,
0.11025594919919968,
-0.06433158367872238,
0.4418032765388489,
-1.3037068843841553,
-0.31336551904678345,
0.08430789411067963,
-0.29372602701187134,
-0.3525876998901367,
0.18978121876716614,
-0.2046755850315094,
0.04855886846780777,
-0.2464936077594757,
0.30528077483177185,
-0.6846733689308167,
-0.13771356642246246,
-0.3667958974838257,
0.29425904154777527,
-0.14505703747272491,
0.24587160348892212,
0.10325364768505096,
0.449323832988739,
0.21866631507873535,
-0.3596542775630951,
0.401754230260849,
0.23954620957374573,
-0.3606387972831726,
0.49038177728652954,
-0.3097066879272461,
0.5135798454284668,
-0.22886936366558075,
0.40116071701049805,
-0.8485568165779114,
-0.41752922534942627,
0.13479888439178467,
-0.45055535435676575,
-0.06476885825395584,
-0.26541468501091003,
-0.42741236090660095,
-0.2844984233379364,
-0.3951955735683441,
0.5395308136940002,
0.5588036775588989,
-0.8585072755813599,
0.5375072360038757,
0.7879299521446228,
0.06773821264505386,
-0.2616444230079651,
-0.6468125581741333,
-0.18137146532535553,
-0.0911804735660553,
-0.31915920972824097,
0.022328676655888557,
-0.10880842804908752,
-0.486642062664032,
0.11732882261276245,
0.28211987018585205,
-0.23382620513439178,
-0.2367878258228302,
0.2472275048494339,
0.17821595072746277,
-0.0796680822968483,
0.17509403824806213,
0.30929115414619446,
0.12050694227218628,
0.1771288812160492,
-0.45020586252212524,
0.701728105545044,
0.044631119817495346,
-0.9080671072006226,
-0.1979321837425232,
0.8319042921066284,
0.4514995217323303,
-0.3087668716907501,
0.5203038454055786,
0.1272515207529068,
-0.4514506459236145,
-0.4448913037776947,
-0.6206874847412109,
-0.3749091625213623,
-0.49587884545326233,
0.2114972472190857,
0.5213270783424377,
-1.1642580032348633,
0.1557619720697403,
-0.3084452152252197,
0.300060510635376,
0.2497129589319229,
0.7169116139411926,
-0.372928649187088,
0.9463911056518555,
0.47563600540161133,
0.03869662061333656,
0.3635358512401581,
0.01889917626976967,
0.047148920595645905,
-0.3286835849285126,
-0.3017193675041199,
-0.5348536372184753,
-0.5588427186012268,
-0.3777309060096741,
-0.8497788310050964,
0.3716889023780823,
-0.2078360915184021,
-0.3690231740474701,
0.20993244647979736,
-0.7554237842559814,
0.7450927495956421,
0.49342992901802063,
0.2985498607158661,
0.1505196988582611,
0.2918751835823059,
0.2161826491355896,
-0.2017873078584671,
-0.6729966998100281,
-0.46673479676246643,
1.353121042251587,
-0.02561499923467636,
0.8997256755828857,
0.22236885130405426,
0.9926568865776062,
0.49705785512924194,
0.6973546743392944,
-0.6019930243492126,
0.32276660203933716,
-0.3324053883552551,
-0.5136908292770386,
-0.12732098996639252,
-0.34490782022476196,
-0.9910416603088379,
-0.1261741667985916,
-0.5608656406402588,
-0.438419908285141,
0.26349765062332153,
0.4245545268058777,
-0.41181889176368713,
0.5859917402267456,
-0.47950834035873413,
0.6201112270355225,
-0.4791605472564697,
-0.10740771144628525,
-0.6974672079086304,
-0.42103469371795654,
0.24661237001419067,
-0.2094998061656952,
0.328739196062088,
0.24944685399532318,
0.09944561123847961,
0.5209432244300842,
-0.33490264415740967,
1.3697484731674194,
-0.11788417398929596,
0.08186906576156616,
0.4264308214187622,
-0.028390217572450638,
0.29743674397468567,
-0.1762198805809021,
0.06271287798881531,
-0.04159259423613548,
0.0003854433598462492,
-0.3023380935192108,
-0.6545177102088928,
0.8410107493400574,
-0.960745632648468,
-0.5728726387023926,
0.026888148859143257,
-0.26263830065727234,
-0.22471588850021362,
-0.10110912472009659,
0.07919607311487198,
0.3487869203090668,
-0.45854735374450684,
0.20911909639835358,
0.9712538719177246,
-0.24667948484420776,
-0.03486332297325134,
0.28312262892723083,
-0.35454821586608887,
-0.5576290488243103,
0.8286129832267761,
-0.03005124069750309,
0.7107858657836914,
0.5177831649780273,
0.3395017087459564,
-0.2952660322189331,
-0.12751035392284393,
-0.27658510208129883,
0.1296071708202362,
-0.8178313970565796,
-0.2062256634235382,
-0.3831499218940735,
-0.0009670575382187963,
-0.4469486474990845,
-0.4709884822368622,
-0.46422624588012695,
-0.37324583530426025,
-0.21497438848018646,
-0.03520160913467407,
0.2909756004810333,
1.3176567554473877,
-0.2329060286283493,
0.41224706172943115,
-0.8086361289024353,
0.1003337949514389,
0.6193044781684875,
0.1158711314201355,
0.0890175849199295,
-0.20349308848381042,
-0.2308058887720108,
0.5379108190536499,
-0.1086072102189064,
-1.1524969339370728,
-0.03415430709719658,
0.09050819277763367,
0.5850654244422913,
0.45792996883392334,
0.3422122299671173,
0.6985454559326172,
-0.3139187693595886,
0.5415589213371277,
0.4114476144313812,
-0.9006760716438293,
0.5386937856674194,
-0.07944761961698532,
0.08186998963356018,
0.7141332030296326,
0.6149125695228577,
-0.6689141392707825,
-0.5326356291770935,
-0.43051955103874207,
-0.548486053943634,
0.27031394839286804,
-0.19251038134098053,
0.3293207287788391,
-0.25852614641189575,
0.25356024503707886,
0.2981480360031128,
0.09095979481935501,
-0.5249108672142029,
-0.08256486803293228,
-0.5004651546478271,
-0.32539185881614685,
0.22614827752113342,
-0.09891514480113983,
-0.4262215793132782,
-0.40428802371025085,
0.4372932016849518,
-0.2976382374763489,
0.24814803898334503,
-0.09462729841470718,
-0.012670593336224556,
-0.5104621648788452,
0.12022125720977783,
0.35304081439971924,
0.6189354062080383,
0.20550774037837982,
0.26049596071243286,
0.11364134401082993,
-0.1121751070022583,
0.03664185479283333,
-0.2809394299983978,
-0.23381192982196808,
-0.09377162903547287,
0.42031919956207275,
0.3515520393848419,
0.36732354760169983,
-0.3788461983203888,
0.791508138179779,
-0.007602074183523655,
-0.2139533907175064,
-0.29327592253685,
-0.0013731539947912097,
0.5248857736587524,
0.2876093089580536,
0.14653852581977844,
-0.09465738385915756,
-0.3003421723842621,
-0.6733856797218323,
0.06874251365661621,
0.6417109966278076,
-0.2724689245223999,
-0.32651323080062866,
0.6663932204246521,
0.5972577333450317,
-0.3345378339290619,
0.5875667929649353,
-0.11824453622102737,
-0.6311065554618835,
0.47429385781288147,
0.23515434563159943,
0.8783907294273376,
-0.1983698457479477,
0.33026203513145447,
0.5254506468772888,
0.3292507827281952,
-0.14454984664916992,
0.15735213458538055,
0.007349969353526831,
-0.7464898824691772,
-0.4625890552997589,
-0.5299123525619507,
-0.5787740349769592,
-0.08791553974151611,
-0.7420641779899597,
0.07450199872255325,
-0.6858343482017517,
-0.00728622218593955,
-0.007586047984659672,
-0.17367614805698395,
-0.49799206852912903,
-0.019703717902302742,
0.20243889093399048,
0.6564728021621704,
-1.1826162338256836,
0.7433674931526184,
0.747379720211029,
-0.1709212213754654,
-0.7569623589515686,
0.40009525418281555,
0.2956395745277405,
-0.7620418667793274,
0.3753085434436798,
-0.025159427896142006,
-0.4003930389881134,
-0.10648608952760696,
-1.078919768333435,
-0.5724712610244751,
0.8609691262245178,
0.42443349957466125,
-0.6870152950286865,
0.16306787729263306,
0.5464199781417847,
0.5394251346588135,
-0.6990193128585815,
0.033907461911439896,
-0.007332435343414545,
0.4290638566017151,
-0.09243056178092957,
-0.6991581916809082,
-0.04441538080573082,
0.03767722472548485,
-0.3821899890899658,
0.26464155316352844,
-0.6551450490951538,
0.5378872752189636,
-0.1621212363243103,
-0.2988818287849426,
-0.15108251571655273,
0.7760300636291504,
0.03818540275096893,
0.09668848663568497,
0.739651620388031,
0.2696191966533661,
0.7767677903175354,
0.1455051600933075,
0.6365393996238708,
-0.4044798016548157,
0.40466514229774475,
1.0417312383651733,
-0.21832764148712158,
0.9188833236694336,
0.4256972074508667,
-0.2119189351797104,
0.7087607979774475,
0.6563639044761658,
0.029253169894218445,
0.29752516746520996,
0.12951283156871796,
-0.40717944502830505,
-0.6862090229988098,
-0.008497248403728008,
-0.3038369417190552,
0.3762599527835846,
0.3384767472743988,
-0.3047264516353607,
-0.2984018325805664,
-0.24578917026519775,
-0.22179295122623444,
0.7007639408111572,
-0.3870210349559784,
0.6523114442825317,
-0.07975658029317856,
-0.7540773749351501,
0.25800925493240356,
-0.16501764953136444,
0.694216251373291,
-0.46459153294563293,
-0.2798718214035034,
-0.22570283710956573,
0.18616913259029388,
-0.3837742805480957,
-1.0049529075622559,
0.35021939873695374,
0.1329498589038849,
-0.19918233156204224,
-0.3877120018005371,
0.4799303710460663,
-0.7941424250602722,
-0.6618475317955017,
0.44240933656692505,
0.45635756850242615,
0.2283470779657364,
0.19060909748077393,
-0.5140716433525085,
-0.07631422579288483,
0.23435792326927185,
0.1050422191619873,
0.42945772409439087,
0.27101370692253113,
-0.3174690902233124,
0.35979312658309937,
0.6525652408599854,
-0.06668645143508911,
0.14674757421016693,
0.28003156185150146,
1.0324146747589111,
-0.22247514128684998,
-0.1358756422996521,
-0.6226420998573303,
0.2671525478363037,
-0.2185412049293518,
-0.14175482094287872,
0.6420000791549683,
0.6414185166358948,
1.1813771724700928,
0.07815665006637573,
1.0177122354507446,
-0.06983201950788498,
0.5832201838493347,
-0.2398029863834381,
0.8038979768753052,
-0.5934460163116455,
0.06637701392173767,
-0.05650389567017555,
-0.9587162733078003,
-0.13099981844425201,
0.32277315855026245,
-0.2448844611644745,
-0.1618768870830536,
0.45752429962158203,
0.9846789836883545,
-0.37560901045799255,
0.026745200157165527,
-0.10522151738405228,
-0.11741850525140762,
0.04429510608315468,
0.5140252709388733,
0.8756154179573059,
0.23782211542129517,
0.5607916712760925,
-0.2831099033355713,
-0.43845659494400024,
0.13937479257583618,
-0.7211981415748596,
-1.2353999614715576,
-0.34633564949035645,
-0.4777577519416809,
-0.4284835457801819,
0.034850042313337326,
1.4064526557922363,
0.48277077078819275,
-0.8863474726676941,
-0.49648696184158325,
0.18928945064544678,
-0.08910869807004929,
-0.08423585444688797,
-0.16748958826065063,
0.2505822777748108,
0.1637493371963501,
-0.8962912559509277,
0.3275763690471649,
0.10083744674921036,
-0.20791849493980408,
-0.8629513382911682,
-0.2957049608230591,
-0.38470497727394104,
0.09247628599405289,
0.3633060157299042,
0.38569116592407227,
-0.6964753866195679,
-0.457849383354187,
0.03497762978076935,
-0.23853811621665955,
0.0028642364777624607,
0.9021879434585571,
-0.4008697271347046,
0.47282904386520386,
0.5033312439918518,
0.9360868334770203,
0.4226641058921814,
0.16103164851665497,
0.5672107934951782,
-0.6592639684677124,
-0.30059993267059326,
0.08916491270065308,
0.09667453169822693,
0.5098307728767395,
-0.34626638889312744,
0.2163393348455429,
0.3688635230064392,
-0.54184889793396,
-0.3578426241874695,
0.3488622009754181,
-0.7089530825614929,
-0.4019414484500885,
1.1427441835403442,
0.08451883494853973,
-0.20060858130455017,
-0.1737338900566101,
-0.01655014418065548,
0.32987114787101746,
-0.3141021728515625,
1.0483558177947998,
0.3850271999835968,
-0.0509217269718647,
-0.16304084658622742,
-0.22092606127262115,
0.06742477416992188,
0.2783223092556,
-0.9260080456733704,
0.2363547384738922,
0.5607815384864807,
0.3504036068916321,
0.06753706932067871,
0.4518136978149414,
0.20855265855789185,
0.2439286857843399,
-0.17085394263267517,
0.29028043150901794,
0.1193523034453392,
0.04658731073141098,
0.04936502128839493,
0.16703014075756073,
-0.18099108338356018,
-0.028329776600003242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12069v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12069v1
|
Satyrn: A Platform for Analytics Augmented Generation
| 2024-06-17T20:14:16 | 2024-06-17T20:14:16 |
Marko Sterbentz, Cameron Barrie, Shubham Shahi, Abhratanu Dutta, Donna Hooshmand, Harper Pack, Kristian J. Hammond
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are capable of producing documents, and
retrieval augmented generation (RAG) has shown itself to be a powerful method
for improving accuracy without sacrificing fluency. However, not all
information can be retrieved from text. We propose an approach that uses the
analysis of structured data to generate fact sets that are used to guide
generation in much the same way that retrieved documents are used in RAG. This
analytics augmented generation (AAG) approach supports the ability to utilize
standard analytic techniques to generate facts that are then converted to text
and passed to an LLM. We present a neurosymbolic platform, Satyrn that
leverages AAG to produce accurate, fluent, and coherent reports grounded in
large scale databases. In our experiments, we find that Satyrn generates
reports in which over 86% accurate claims while maintaining high levels of
fluency and coherence, even when using smaller language models such as
Mistral-7B, as compared to GPT-4 Code Interpreter in which just 57% of claims
are accurate.
|
[
-0.09471248835325241,
-0.8625718355178833,
0.5703909397125244,
0.21302016079425812,
-0.10605432838201523,
0.2698630392551422,
-0.5145446062088013,
-0.3559928834438324,
0.8047480583190918,
0.6743364930152893,
-0.38970425724983215,
-0.5988802909851074,
-0.43235546350479126,
0.05079442635178566,
-0.4429354965686798,
1.2795989513397217,
0.18459969758987427,
0.08921878039836884,
-0.3127661943435669,
-0.005211271811276674,
-0.2996082603931427,
-0.6478071808815002,
-0.558632493019104,
-0.45718735456466675,
0.47425606846809387,
0.4029795229434967,
0.7958447933197021,
0.6773508191108704,
0.5377322435379028,
0.2966896891593933,
0.20403513312339783,
0.49598994851112366,
-0.40021467208862305,
0.5938147306442261,
-0.10785356909036636,
-0.4136838912963867,
-0.840654730796814,
-0.06944970041513443,
0.5040532350540161,
0.6421351432800293,
-0.46620145440101624,
0.31268084049224854,
-0.030977128073573112,
0.5090637803077698,
-0.45945820212364197,
0.3045954406261444,
-0.5404490828514099,
-0.2894098460674286,
-0.25376468896865845,
-0.30053243041038513,
-0.4087613523006439,
-0.4912659227848053,
-0.11905466020107269,
-0.8335772156715393,
0.46190351247787476,
-0.03827785700559616,
0.7830567359924316,
0.3434622287750244,
-0.41848209500312805,
-0.6572332382202148,
-0.5693377256393433,
0.5736802816390991,
-0.8023728132247925,
0.21508778631687164,
0.425595760345459,
0.1701749861240387,
-0.5467262268066406,
-0.9572578072547913,
-0.5890766978263855,
-0.5014044642448425,
-0.10371512919664383,
0.22942079603672028,
0.16615302860736847,
0.005636929534375668,
0.2757926285266876,
0.18337787687778473,
-0.5536832809448242,
-0.13067074120044708,
-0.14203909039497375,
0.04185246676206589,
1.0095164775848389,
0.2914118766784668,
0.23406825959682465,
-0.6490504741668701,
-0.11199479550123215,
-0.086922787129879,
-0.5987012982368469,
-0.5724772810935974,
0.21388205885887146,
0.5143741965293884,
0.08956145495176315,
0.8167256712913513,
-0.13644152879714966,
0.6536027193069458,
0.3339550197124481,
-0.3372798562049866,
0.22461679577827454,
-0.15268474817276,
-0.06821215152740479,
0.49979183077812195,
0.6444096565246582,
0.1857612133026123,
-0.05593172833323479,
-0.25420013070106506,
-0.22553011775016785,
0.26525089144706726,
0.47398871183395386,
-0.8111668825149536,
-0.5998175144195557,
0.23022864758968353,
-0.23686297237873077,
-0.30787792801856995,
-0.17425744235515594,
-0.801163375377655,
-0.8954014778137207,
-0.5943329930305481,
0.35989242792129517,
-0.5306167006492615,
-0.38171330094337463,
-0.0774410143494606,
-0.009655250236392021,
0.03109038434922695,
0.31392335891723633,
-0.7373321056365967,
0.4466173052787781,
0.6828722357749939,
0.8103222250938416,
-0.4634697437286377,
0.04911673814058304,
-0.661817729473114,
0.2991168797016144,
-0.48405325412750244,
0.9289310574531555,
-0.3264126777648926,
-0.013050896115601063,
-0.17492243647575378,
-0.4647664427757263,
-0.18420857191085815,
-0.40982916951179504,
0.3727061152458191,
-0.5407305359840393,
0.10291051119565964,
0.06190958991646767,
-0.6074668169021606,
-0.0982450470328331,
0.4864756762981415,
-0.688873291015625,
1.1953895092010498,
-0.046411290764808655,
-0.6996755003929138,
0.6174456477165222,
-0.6410483717918396,
-0.5239367485046387,
0.4854057729244232,
-0.5184299349784851,
-0.2002020627260208,
0.32060739398002625,
0.2883468270301819,
0.44548243284225464,
-0.3929414451122284,
0.6677581071853638,
0.04860303923487663,
-0.08991087973117828,
0.3842853009700775,
-0.27363327145576477,
0.49310246109962463,
0.2134293168783188,
-0.44500598311424255,
-0.046827282756567,
-1.1927822828292847,
0.21740473806858063,
-0.030258361250162125,
-0.657153844833374,
-0.2570945918560028,
0.12783631682395935,
0.09412706643342972,
-0.09982391446828842,
0.3755013644695282,
-0.6739130020141602,
0.008422496728599072,
-0.5733258724212646,
-0.04696742817759514,
0.47223353385925293,
0.0256761834025383,
0.19826146960258484,
-0.07219157367944717,
0.6802201271057129,
-0.26543769240379333,
-0.4761717915534973,
-0.12582138180732727,
-0.07375019788742065,
-0.7827572822570801,
-0.4625212252140045,
0.5867394804954529,
0.4602793753147125,
-0.9547882080078125,
0.36899977922439575,
-0.6317285299301147,
-0.2733994424343109,
-0.23325103521347046,
0.00613095797598362,
0.12360820919275284,
0.5042957067489624,
0.061544694006443024,
0.08427966386079788,
-0.6986173987388611,
-0.7484692335128784,
-0.5298395156860352,
-0.08683083951473236,
0.0137809282168746,
0.343229204416275,
0.33290523290634155,
0.019770242273807526,
0.7512339353561401,
-0.5026348233222961,
-0.05372817814350128,
-0.41378653049468994,
0.22950507700443268,
0.5579361915588379,
0.436682790517807,
0.31899794936180115,
-0.7704171538352966,
-0.553199291229248,
0.3424215018749237,
-0.9469017386436462,
-0.08729226887226105,
-0.24810318648815155,
0.12779872119426727,
0.38290995359420776,
0.29565781354904175,
-0.8115575909614563,
0.5584257245063782,
0.45059069991111755,
-0.3721529543399811,
0.3904268741607666,
-0.24397635459899902,
0.21181726455688477,
-1.402132511138916,
0.20935948193073273,
-0.03170979768037796,
-0.495458722114563,
-0.5559143424034119,
0.028741760179400444,
-0.22379548847675323,
-0.4029114842414856,
0.2134680151939392,
0.3295588493347168,
-0.43527600169181824,
-0.010800245217978954,
-0.5364364981651306,
0.28970152139663696,
-0.0475848987698555,
0.16210278868675232,
-0.10858713090419769,
0.8963908553123474,
0.41261276602745056,
-0.43978649377822876,
0.584189236164093,
0.4753732979297638,
-0.3268163204193115,
0.6295897364616394,
-0.5358001589775085,
0.0806480199098587,
-0.16681049764156342,
0.1216200441122055,
-0.8527370691299438,
-0.8914798498153687,
0.017502449452877045,
-0.7780634164810181,
0.4632827937602997,
-0.07035612314939499,
-0.703555703163147,
-0.05050656571984291,
0.0780193954706192,
-0.1017591580748558,
0.3656468987464905,
-0.8193289637565613,
1.2070634365081787,
0.4897654056549072,
-0.4367106556892395,
-0.4268024265766144,
-0.7108430862426758,
0.5399302840232849,
-0.2242054045200348,
-0.9183205962181091,
0.08332772552967072,
0.3222019672393799,
-0.2786710560321808,
-0.08946792036294937,
-0.3773708939552307,
0.04812512919306755,
-0.17571793496608734,
0.350302517414093,
0.3110986649990082,
-0.3444056808948517,
0.23129841685295105,
-0.04382411763072014,
-0.10902047157287598,
0.1821812093257904,
-0.2981712520122528,
0.4932858645915985,
0.04733885079622269,
0.07799266278743744,
-0.09694353491067886,
0.28475528955459595,
0.3558073043823242,
-0.14783446490764618,
0.8689447045326233,
0.20388102531433105,
-0.34131625294685364,
-0.6468089818954468,
-0.562311589717865,
-0.12239278852939606,
-0.5082249045372009,
0.15941448509693146,
-0.3381935954093933,
-0.6125089526176453,
0.4494803547859192,
-0.3314223289489746,
0.046877577900886536,
0.43754544854164124,
0.5060732364654541,
-0.12482915073633194,
1.329573154449463,
0.6189627647399902,
0.5597777962684631,
0.2684655785560608,
-0.247433602809906,
0.4011216461658478,
-0.46525490283966064,
-0.37632104754447937,
-0.4571755826473236,
-0.17161479592323303,
-0.5211977958679199,
-0.13299910724163055,
0.6793292164802551,
0.012956501916050911,
-0.07844926416873932,
0.2455979734659195,
-0.3974915146827698,
0.5569112300872803,
0.35481324791908264,
0.1953069269657135,
0.26683101058006287,
0.446639746427536,
0.04570236802101135,
-0.07622447609901428,
-0.9628185629844666,
-0.5330960154533386,
1.3020775318145752,
-0.07845231890678406,
0.9419217109680176,
-0.001138283871114254,
0.8024028539657593,
0.5457360744476318,
0.5482861995697021,
-0.7538912892341614,
0.614936113357544,
-0.24213621020317078,
-0.8213467597961426,
0.09073421359062195,
-0.7223529815673828,
-0.8104972243309021,
0.23338253796100616,
-0.4980389177799225,
-0.6622704863548279,
0.24666310846805573,
0.24137993156909943,
-0.30303242802619934,
-0.06252849847078323,
-0.6514365077018738,
0.484767884016037,
-0.31225594878196716,
-0.4757065773010254,
-0.318536639213562,
-0.3888894319534302,
0.3571396470069885,
-0.09124460816383362,
-0.1691831350326538,
0.11598125100135803,
0.08640218526124954,
0.8495227098464966,
-0.5005735158920288,
0.7037670016288757,
-0.13206249475479126,
0.12176893651485443,
0.41299009323120117,
0.29664167761802673,
0.57770836353302,
0.12689900398254395,
-0.32262951135635376,
-0.1467370241880417,
-0.052405793219804764,
-0.32361331582069397,
-0.6509789824485779,
1.0020911693572998,
-0.5643677115440369,
-0.46754753589630127,
-0.7991585731506348,
-0.9892488121986389,
-0.3069249093532562,
0.29873228073120117,
0.05679330974817276,
0.6621860861778259,
-0.13316501677036285,
0.4069484770298004,
0.6554345488548279,
-0.013974977657198906,
0.14006789028644562,
0.3886995017528534,
-0.27824798226356506,
-0.9186331629753113,
1.0336353778839111,
0.27594637870788574,
-0.1133246049284935,
-0.26027563214302063,
0.02339559979736805,
-0.32094642519950867,
-0.617871105670929,
-0.4958825409412384,
0.4009578824043274,
-0.6891084313392639,
-0.5516529083251953,
-0.5804538130760193,
-0.10250933468341827,
-0.4215688407421112,
-0.05682173743844032,
-0.2674608528614044,
-0.7747407555580139,
0.0040116566233336926,
-0.26319894194602966,
0.6056872606277466,
0.8580431938171387,
-0.1488099992275238,
0.7695242166519165,
-0.4999646842479706,
0.5195883512496948,
-0.21065373718738556,
0.33594727516174316,
-0.2996012568473816,
-0.17340022325515747,
-0.4918537437915802,
0.17181986570358276,
-0.19688111543655396,
-0.796273946762085,
0.564346432685852,
0.21813714504241943,
0.40076619386672974,
-0.04786914959549904,
-0.10912245512008667,
0.6455857753753662,
-0.19964304566383362,
0.8215473294258118,
0.30766579508781433,
-0.8128124475479126,
0.47585999965667725,
-0.6056377291679382,
-0.058168068528175354,
0.6135653257369995,
0.20589995384216309,
-0.16663704812526703,
-0.1686023473739624,
-0.8303241729736328,
-0.8528410196304321,
0.8685962557792664,
0.26286712288856506,
-0.05477394536137581,
-0.1607580929994583,
0.6762006282806396,
0.0350993387401104,
0.42200231552124023,
-0.4905308187007904,
0.045538000762462616,
-0.21276910603046417,
-0.5555548667907715,
-0.10902545601129532,
0.11512317508459091,
-0.3905475437641144,
-0.04303911328315735,
0.7390771508216858,
-0.38906168937683105,
-0.188360333442688,
0.28898850083351135,
-0.13562609255313873,
-0.007779841776937246,
-0.06441992521286011,
0.05116870254278183,
1.0265759229660034,
-0.03529364988207817,
0.2065606266260147,
-0.005342953372746706,
-0.7683209776878357,
-0.10145252197980881,
0.3460169732570648,
-0.37410178780555725,
0.09636738896369934,
0.22652262449264526,
0.6662893891334534,
-0.3135489523410797,
-0.7301785349845886,
0.3059469163417816,
0.18849019706249237,
-0.22821171581745148,
-0.43915611505508423,
0.23557715117931366,
0.045101165771484375,
0.25582221150398254,
0.38458505272865295,
-0.008643833920359612,
0.05837259441614151,
-0.3867739140987396,
0.344929575920105,
0.2479276955127716,
0.003934952430427074,
-0.13491307199001312,
0.627332866191864,
0.08944793045520782,
-0.19756950438022614,
0.6685818433761597,
0.06831297278404236,
-0.31028982996940613,
0.6341000199317932,
0.8656157851219177,
0.8542828559875488,
-0.06093469262123108,
0.49407318234443665,
0.3743828535079956,
0.12811678647994995,
-0.09504999965429306,
0.5780162811279297,
0.011861835606396198,
-0.47642186284065247,
-0.825062096118927,
-0.8546733260154724,
-0.10505352169275284,
0.06885894387960434,
-0.6011019349098206,
0.02257423847913742,
-0.738635241985321,
-0.45023709535598755,
0.2608351707458496,
0.1456892192363739,
-0.31120386719703674,
0.3892952799797058,
0.03621470928192139,
0.7263727188110352,
-0.6269482970237732,
0.45956021547317505,
0.7812040448188782,
-0.46258097887039185,
-0.934544026851654,
-0.05927678570151329,
-0.16842113435268402,
-0.5095962285995483,
0.6769337058067322,
-0.0852142870426178,
-0.23153172433376312,
-0.009205455891788006,
-0.9934646487236023,
-0.8997220993041992,
1.029972791671753,
0.5135804414749146,
-0.16286800801753998,
0.1443377137184143,
0.25467976927757263,
0.81878662109375,
-0.6752975583076477,
-0.15468178689479828,
0.7056379318237305,
0.5136467814445496,
0.20507828891277313,
-0.56272292137146,
0.038289424031972885,
-0.2682894468307495,
-0.1126076951622963,
0.5272193551063538,
-0.37970399856567383,
0.6214603781700134,
0.02326376549899578,
-0.3558630645275116,
0.10680574178695679,
0.7050487995147705,
0.44298142194747925,
0.5343306064605713,
0.18596066534519196,
0.6519608497619629,
0.8569942712783813,
0.0217534638941288,
1.1551791429519653,
-0.28181192278862,
0.05422459542751312,
1.2986515760421753,
-0.38518568873405457,
0.726428747177124,
0.4427313804626465,
0.27443498373031616,
0.6341257095336914,
0.14238066971302032,
-0.025628304108977318,
0.13791143894195557,
0.1350896954536438,
-0.28268012404441833,
-0.46198204159736633,
-0.2119680941104889,
0.03882741555571556,
0.49864915013313293,
0.6804705262184143,
-0.2865963578224182,
-0.30009955167770386,
-0.0166186410933733,
0.19175037741661072,
0.4125211536884308,
-0.3452317714691162,
0.8835526704788208,
-0.010653914883732796,
-0.8044742345809937,
0.7004280090332031,
-0.05567958578467369,
0.16018414497375488,
-0.627120316028595,
-0.3686577081680298,
-0.2425534576177597,
0.3826066851615906,
-0.5757628679275513,
-0.6148859858512878,
0.24266357719898224,
0.3319125175476074,
-0.11691191047430038,
-0.07435629516839981,
1.0333001613616943,
-0.3995550870895386,
-0.6854337453842163,
-0.1348075568675995,
0.5084207653999329,
0.14768753945827484,
0.138081356883049,
-0.3993644118309021,
-0.025179704651236534,
-0.11639225482940674,
-0.2808084487915039,
0.08946425467729568,
0.32504886388778687,
-0.06194398179650307,
0.5927515625953674,
0.8585215210914612,
0.3900120258331299,
0.2616272568702698,
-0.18147097527980804,
1.0468865633010864,
-0.6090428829193115,
-0.6060946583747864,
-0.3998505771160126,
0.4653787612915039,
-0.42418667674064636,
-0.2624705731868744,
1.1133424043655396,
0.8134188055992126,
0.17457641661167145,
0.19131244719028473,
0.7666677236557007,
-0.43204811215400696,
0.664857029914856,
-0.4762320816516876,
0.7597377300262451,
-0.4328252673149109,
0.2439306080341339,
0.11016097664833069,
-1.1055158376693726,
-0.3802671730518341,
0.5186624526977539,
-0.33906611800193787,
-0.11814099550247192,
0.557350754737854,
0.8727025985717773,
-0.3081304728984833,
0.2344328910112381,
-0.053233109414577484,
0.48083004355430603,
0.2897593677043915,
-0.02730904519557953,
0.779419481754303,
-0.44660574197769165,
0.46816137433052063,
0.1355910748243332,
-0.36165907979011536,
0.025485264137387276,
-0.6897587776184082,
-0.9956507086753845,
-0.23311300575733185,
-0.295306921005249,
-0.9715806245803833,
0.26718175411224365,
0.7784115076065063,
0.589702308177948,
-0.7757488489151001,
-0.3733842968940735,
-0.26819494366645813,
-0.25677475333213806,
0.1072520762681961,
-0.25154149532318115,
0.6496686339378357,
-0.4406600594520569,
-0.2973769009113312,
0.689447283744812,
0.10295180231332779,
-0.3850466012954712,
-0.1444624811410904,
-0.08270789682865143,
-0.2394120842218399,
0.31208834052085876,
0.4522276818752289,
0.08768501877784729,
-0.24027690291404724,
-0.12308601289987564,
0.14056958258152008,
-0.03258410468697548,
0.053872983902692795,
1.024151086807251,
-1.0557588338851929,
0.40682902932167053,
0.7058212757110596,
0.8271315693855286,
0.8884212374687195,
0.2940620183944702,
0.698932409286499,
-0.7006811499595642,
-0.0586894191801548,
0.48497992753982544,
-0.036186788231134415,
0.48034441471099854,
-0.5313292145729065,
0.501537561416626,
0.10248375684022903,
-0.7009430527687073,
-0.9529764652252197,
0.10386190563440323,
-0.9170196652412415,
-0.22152790427207947,
1.0849575996398926,
0.02945808134973049,
-0.5644552707672119,
0.043293293565511703,
-0.16176879405975342,
0.15118806064128876,
-0.3061584532260895,
0.7910211086273193,
0.43621826171875,
-0.415792852640152,
0.1155012920498848,
-0.5556456446647644,
0.5051330924034119,
0.3761289715766907,
-0.8672265410423279,
0.31662246584892273,
1.0642118453979492,
0.28817084431648254,
0.5368117094039917,
0.2626776695251465,
-0.09951716661453247,
0.2911299765110016,
0.38694965839385986,
0.08010635524988174,
-0.06340430676937103,
-0.6144441962242126,
-0.2600095868110657,
0.21976344287395477,
-0.20879054069519043,
0.11962459236383438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12066v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12066v2
|
Language Models are Surprisingly Fragile to Drug Names in Biomedical Benchmarks
| 2024-06-17T20:09:24 | 2024-06-19T03:59:41 |
Jack Gallifant, Shan Chen, Pedro Moreira, Nikolaj Munch, Mingye Gao, Jackson Pond, Leo Anthony Celi, Hugo Aerts, Thomas Hartvigsen, Danielle Bitterman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Medical knowledge is context-dependent and requires consistent reasoning
across various natural language expressions of semantically equivalent phrases.
This is particularly crucial for drug names, where patients often use brand
names like Advil or Tylenol instead of their generic equivalents. To study
this, we create a new robustness dataset, RABBITS, to evaluate performance
differences on medical benchmarks after swapping brand and generic drug names
using physician expert annotations.
We assess both open-source and API-based LLMs on MedQA and MedMCQA, revealing
a consistent performance drop ranging from 1-10\%. Furthermore, we identify a
potential source of this fragility as the contamination of test data in widely
used pre-training datasets. All code is accessible at
https://github.com/BittermanLab/RABBITS, and a HuggingFace leaderboard is
available at https://huggingface.co/spaces/AIM-Harvard/rabbits-leaderboard.
|
[
0.14558839797973633,
-0.6559502482414246,
0.5263932943344116,
-0.1363983005285263,
0.018328925594687462,
0.23653359711170197,
-0.2579195201396942,
-0.7983617782592773,
-0.148793563246727,
0.4336663484573364,
-0.29912465810775757,
-0.45242926478385925,
-1.0315814018249512,
0.34579944610595703,
-0.24549926817417145,
1.0375922918319702,
-0.23389996588230133,
0.32388126850128174,
-0.20796069502830505,
-0.8031782507896423,
-0.2631699740886688,
-0.5793443322181702,
-0.3096713125705719,
-0.46026572585105896,
0.4235610365867615,
-0.14564299583435059,
0.9678349494934082,
0.8402743339538574,
0.9064531922340393,
0.298370897769928,
-0.04888405650854111,
0.0001419975742464885,
-0.31826692819595337,
0.3081026077270508,
-0.39373356103897095,
-0.5905357599258423,
-0.45853370428085327,
-0.021209601312875748,
0.2362196445465088,
0.799841582775116,
-0.13365311920642853,
0.010928020812571049,
-0.18910983204841614,
0.46564316749572754,
-0.5755760669708252,
0.25515952706336975,
-0.9104054570198059,
-0.2984369695186615,
-0.33257949352264404,
0.0931677594780922,
-0.23262549936771393,
-0.33187106251716614,
0.1775214672088623,
-0.7474520206451416,
0.09954451024532318,
-0.006416613701730967,
1.4945094585418701,
0.5583664178848267,
0.04559475556015968,
-0.3685445189476013,
-0.2140253633260727,
0.8005856275558472,
-0.681672990322113,
0.3824942111968994,
0.4972778558731079,
0.4387282133102417,
-0.43702223896980286,
-0.6595714688301086,
0.03601691126823425,
-0.23910017311573029,
0.05028751865029335,
-0.173730731010437,
-0.18838459253311157,
-0.12130717933177948,
0.15298444032669067,
0.2263626903295517,
-0.2699353098869324,
0.09297695010900497,
-0.3394365608692169,
-0.3485903739929199,
0.40749868750572205,
0.14327269792556763,
0.41057196259498596,
-0.02630002424120903,
-0.5650490522384644,
-0.23069871962070465,
-0.7821000218391418,
0.136225163936615,
-0.18523040413856506,
0.6351683139801025,
0.10250629484653473,
0.427712082862854,
-0.01727975532412529,
0.4428786039352417,
-0.020736346021294594,
-0.22131136059761047,
0.7816429138183594,
-0.14574868977069855,
-0.5240567922592163,
-0.046053845435380936,
0.8046860694885254,
0.4926663339138031,
0.3224542737007141,
-0.33443060517311096,
-0.12328657507896423,
0.2681237459182739,
0.2266470342874527,
-0.652145266532898,
-0.6759882569313049,
0.49099037051200867,
-0.3615913987159729,
-0.40148866176605225,
-0.4171362519264221,
-0.5253359079360962,
-0.6980259418487549,
-0.041838254779577255,
0.5185188055038452,
-0.7242549657821655,
-0.18887817859649658,
0.24004724621772766,
-0.058399394154548645,
-0.03344359248876572,
0.13482992351055145,
-0.7279325127601624,
0.4098179042339325,
0.6977124214172363,
0.6181991696357727,
-0.34195855259895325,
-0.2934396266937256,
-0.45976462960243225,
0.020562108606100082,
-0.45638635754585266,
1.048085331916809,
-0.5891005396842957,
-0.5433768630027771,
-0.1023067757487297,
0.19409625232219696,
-0.1891886442899704,
-1.3636553287506104,
0.5350973010063171,
-0.12479261308908463,
-0.11153285950422287,
-0.5284902453422546,
-0.7546253204345703,
0.13075804710388184,
0.18897973001003265,
-0.6718727946281433,
0.7321496605873108,
0.1545342206954956,
-0.8340087532997131,
0.9306519031524658,
-0.19728755950927734,
-0.38255515694618225,
0.10707499086856842,
-0.49768131971359253,
-0.5893832445144653,
0.03831935673952103,
0.15525700151920319,
0.19432732462882996,
-0.04289121553301811,
0.36182349920272827,
-0.6469026803970337,
-0.1682460904121399,
0.6946752667427063,
-0.0017272679833695292,
0.7245540022850037,
0.12356796860694885,
-0.11677796393632889,
-0.2282288819551468,
-0.8567610383033752,
0.0026349565014243126,
0.1024148017168045,
-0.3950483202934265,
-0.48730218410491943,
0.021640611812472343,
0.1430257260799408,
0.10029873996973038,
-0.12683159112930298,
-0.36254382133483887,
0.1469966173171997,
-0.3392546474933624,
0.5435924530029297,
0.77830970287323,
-0.08071078360080719,
0.05718966946005821,
-0.6894651055335999,
0.390154093503952,
0.1620330661535263,
0.24490849673748016,
0.18909935653209686,
-0.5346668362617493,
-0.38815101981163025,
-0.49545353651046753,
0.705771803855896,
0.6002233028411865,
-0.48405247926712036,
-0.006869533099234104,
-0.3177061975002289,
-0.34028011560440063,
-0.6646170020103455,
0.29511547088623047,
0.5672784447669983,
0.6612694263458252,
0.5788019895553589,
-0.2919718623161316,
-0.28498873114585876,
-1.1491214036941528,
-0.9898680448532104,
-0.440629780292511,
-0.14874397218227386,
0.3878771662712097,
0.39415615797042847,
-0.6166104078292847,
0.6370307803153992,
-0.31235095858573914,
-0.1942088007926941,
-0.008605019189417362,
-0.02394198626279831,
0.16865023970603943,
0.3441827595233917,
0.5601049065589905,
-0.3669273555278778,
-0.06171032786369324,
-0.4289449453353882,
-0.5602923035621643,
-0.2740311920642853,
-0.03051440790295601,
-0.34810036420822144,
0.03779526427388191,
0.4015812277793884,
-0.6814306378364563,
0.12295395135879517,
0.5448846817016602,
-0.13737253844738007,
0.5847505927085876,
0.030607646331191063,
0.10652759671211243,
-1.1061559915542603,
0.06001503765583038,
0.2594301402568817,
-0.08668834716081619,
-0.5122113227844238,
-0.04218445345759392,
0.030858254060149193,
0.28004780411720276,
-0.6242465972900391,
0.6153469085693359,
-0.21821032464504242,
0.3298822045326233,
0.20655545592308044,
0.06211363151669502,
0.11047672480344772,
-0.12887029349803925,
-0.1547108143568039,
0.7017531394958496,
0.6986332535743713,
-0.4997502863407135,
0.05986615642905235,
0.481231689453125,
-0.34433189034461975,
0.6552585363388062,
-0.6421501636505127,
-0.49420180916786194,
0.5329288840293884,
-0.056297581642866135,
-0.5196478366851807,
-0.5273815989494324,
0.28233394026756287,
-0.4519299566745758,
0.5913286805152893,
-0.1065320298075676,
-0.6927696466445923,
-0.14786292612552643,
-0.1925254762172699,
0.3763842284679413,
0.49610471725463867,
-0.42150136828422546,
0.09009446948766708,
0.7090574502944946,
-0.04983540624380112,
-0.47855299711227417,
-1.0568253993988037,
0.12744265794754028,
-0.3414033055305481,
-0.3417952358722687,
0.1753365397453308,
-0.19876740872859955,
-0.5355211496353149,
0.04791443794965744,
-0.2811841368675232,
-0.4065021872520447,
0.08175893872976303,
0.3551025092601776,
0.31680136919021606,
-0.023557476699352264,
0.6600026488304138,
-0.03336367756128311,
-0.12522880733013153,
0.3433957099914551,
0.2722293436527252,
-0.13199952244758606,
-0.13472816348075867,
-0.09482879191637039,
-0.16919878125190735,
0.06684619933366776,
0.7264560461044312,
-0.027871225029230118,
0.6005297303199768,
0.12741559743881226,
-0.49467435479164124,
-0.3046553134918213,
-0.3781811594963074,
-0.07061570137739182,
-0.42645955085754395,
0.18346723914146423,
-0.3109208941459656,
-0.4638245403766632,
0.5558016896247864,
-0.3853422701358795,
-0.10485267639160156,
0.4333157241344452,
0.6966924071311951,
-0.07447074353694916,
0.7014262676239014,
0.37355008721351624,
0.13744093477725983,
0.0171278715133667,
0.14536629617214203,
0.0833408311009407,
-0.5340583324432373,
-0.29878613352775574,
-0.3651561737060547,
-0.14618173241615295,
-0.516998291015625,
-0.561585545539856,
-0.010105444118380547,
-0.09799661487340927,
-0.16529537737369537,
0.37409383058547974,
-0.6200540065765381,
0.20037800073623657,
0.2090758979320526,
0.16200117766857147,
0.30945107340812683,
-0.07005200535058975,
-0.400562584400177,
-0.16023199260234833,
-0.36070412397384644,
-0.5442551970481873,
1.3707287311553955,
0.41076967120170593,
1.0414179563522339,
-0.18902331590652466,
0.6642791032791138,
0.07266432046890259,
0.48576921224594116,
-0.5110432505607605,
0.39445748925209045,
-0.3654659688472748,
-0.6804732084274292,
0.2215425968170166,
-0.475331574678421,
-1.0370309352874756,
-0.08400353789329529,
-0.3712509572505951,
-0.6318865418434143,
0.1479388177394867,
-0.0611833892762661,
-0.45793357491493225,
0.31607744097709656,
-0.6324942708015442,
0.7651628851890564,
-0.39876699447631836,
-0.3310820162296295,
0.35548636317253113,
-0.6580439209938049,
0.27197104692459106,
-0.40796607732772827,
0.4686228930950165,
-0.6148344278335571,
-0.1726778894662857,
0.5766205191612244,
-0.7885850071907043,
0.448059618473053,
0.2082652598619461,
0.0022131691221147776,
-0.18052218854427338,
0.20488105714321136,
-0.008879562839865685,
0.14157280325889587,
-0.1618064045906067,
0.5518304705619812,
0.3797571659088135,
-0.5083814859390259,
-0.17407482862472534,
0.8725284934043884,
-0.7000881433486938,
-0.20273888111114502,
-0.48670926690101624,
-0.5747166275978088,
-0.6483489274978638,
0.20952153205871582,
0.4675253629684448,
0.37916505336761475,
-0.009022102691233158,
0.0855727568268776,
0.7785390019416809,
-0.4536696970462799,
-0.1439032107591629,
0.6546618938446045,
0.014068013988435268,
-0.4653729498386383,
0.49094146490097046,
0.2765050530433655,
0.29006227850914,
0.11435291916131973,
0.16491013765335083,
-0.3208272457122803,
-0.5423247814178467,
-0.3879427909851074,
0.28863850235939026,
-0.6438646912574768,
-0.3338932991027832,
-0.5916240215301514,
-0.06916283071041107,
-0.22985868155956268,
-0.20714035630226135,
-0.7157443761825562,
-0.1877874881029129,
0.04707513749599457,
-0.008399219252169132,
0.5173613429069519,
0.6791250705718994,
0.06960972398519516,
-0.18319495022296906,
-0.7394177913665771,
0.2583597004413605,
-0.002914897631853819,
0.745603621006012,
-0.7660905122756958,
-0.23456527292728424,
-0.14143036305904388,
-0.06687793880701065,
-0.00851823017001152,
-0.8348132371902466,
0.10616081953048706,
0.2677791118621826,
0.8993790745735168,
0.2569386959075928,
0.22347339987754822,
0.4358622133731842,
-0.4062606394290924,
0.5908742547035217,
0.06404810398817062,
-0.6768068671226501,
0.70511394739151,
-0.3650851249694824,
0.3140273094177246,
1.113326072692871,
0.19184742867946625,
-0.11459847539663315,
-0.7854142189025879,
-0.486961305141449,
-0.9791938662528992,
0.28996968269348145,
0.3217839002609253,
-0.2923993766307831,
-0.13650068640708923,
0.3104531764984131,
0.4285925626754761,
0.11204569041728973,
-0.4023089110851288,
-0.29216763377189636,
0.19175876677036285,
-0.35933417081832886,
-0.03965707868337631,
-0.02574988454580307,
-0.5551934242248535,
-0.20237813889980316,
0.4949795603752136,
0.11453543603420258,
-0.11976733803749084,
0.15420742332935333,
-0.15327546000480652,
-0.14578232169151306,
0.2266186624765396,
0.2798316180706024,
0.6802074313163757,
-0.33536580204963684,
-0.027000032365322113,
0.11104428023099899,
-0.6236799955368042,
0.03927187994122505,
0.3536665737628937,
0.06218628212809563,
0.17219163477420807,
0.43703988194465637,
0.25828200578689575,
0.6303697228431702,
-1.2439755201339722,
0.380094438791275,
-0.3753029406070709,
-0.3303559422492981,
0.06589863449335098,
-0.037261344492435455,
-0.0856228619813919,
0.15742850303649902,
0.084261454641819,
0.4164646863937378,
0.08123583346605301,
-0.4610932171344757,
0.5459194779396057,
0.133697047829628,
-0.3863197863101959,
-0.08435364812612534,
1.0100470781326294,
0.040376801043748856,
-0.048183418810367584,
0.3470206558704376,
0.14484411478042603,
-0.21431706845760345,
0.5068907141685486,
0.04963324964046478,
0.759400486946106,
-0.20890256762504578,
0.045535724610090256,
0.15137532353401184,
0.22932541370391846,
-0.08312442898750305,
0.05930627882480621,
0.40581297874450684,
-0.3418949842453003,
0.018184170126914978,
-0.5715882778167725,
-0.599453330039978,
0.16553719341754913,
-0.6387642621994019,
0.36267510056495667,
-0.44997039437294006,
-0.7220566868782043,
0.20011427998542786,
-0.03712407499551773,
-0.610188901424408,
0.2529371380805969,
0.07352893799543381,
0.8991599678993225,
-0.962336003780365,
0.8525953888893127,
1.1507688760757446,
-0.388103723526001,
-0.826206624507904,
-0.03996315225958824,
0.15624544024467468,
-0.7017473578453064,
0.481669157743454,
0.22795672714710236,
0.1749742031097412,
-0.8621476292610168,
-0.3361227810382843,
-0.8596488833427429,
1.0265880823135376,
0.36601516604423523,
-0.4521520137786865,
0.08712203800678253,
0.17692077159881592,
0.7501353025436401,
-0.1955920308828354,
0.045596569776535034,
0.6446881294250488,
0.1844104826450348,
0.024322858080267906,
-1.0494060516357422,
0.14108949899673462,
-0.5596707463264465,
-0.2299354374408722,
0.052802182734012604,
-0.5480051040649414,
1.0202898979187012,
-0.2378338724374771,
-0.18496453762054443,
0.2868669629096985,
-0.18891586363315582,
0.573557436466217,
0.45717811584472656,
0.2922583222389221,
0.7549073100090027,
0.8045174479484558,
-0.3600589334964752,
0.8962085247039795,
-0.5664432644844055,
0.4823918640613556,
1.164987325668335,
-0.37607207894325256,
1.0342814922332764,
0.43632635474205017,
-0.4025629162788391,
0.5672944784164429,
0.8286662101745605,
-0.2997473478317261,
0.5909327268600464,
0.2444014698266983,
0.08521132171154022,
-0.3754158616065979,
0.08907926827669144,
-0.5713995695114136,
0.3304298520088196,
0.5563849210739136,
-0.48501846194267273,
-0.3558182120323181,
-0.01203740295022726,
0.2890302240848541,
0.040283411741256714,
0.1454758644104004,
0.5677778720855713,
0.1360754519701004,
-0.3612447679042816,
0.9084050059318542,
-0.39945465326309204,
0.3038964867591858,
-0.5665168762207031,
0.13155540823936462,
-0.20001493394374847,
0.6818392872810364,
-0.18125243484973907,
-0.628812849521637,
0.1433849036693573,
-0.11430349200963974,
-0.05901668593287468,
0.09378766268491745,
0.5280097723007202,
-0.3223583996295929,
-0.5147470831871033,
0.6309795379638672,
0.4987223744392395,
0.24254700541496277,
0.210000678896904,
-1.0842195749282837,
0.4843956232070923,
-0.43941980600357056,
-0.07894009351730347,
0.5244030952453613,
0.3726785182952881,
0.09948903322219849,
0.9984045028686523,
0.29182127118110657,
0.4137735366821289,
0.06888770312070847,
0.05112390220165253,
1.0643738508224487,
-0.1965179145336151,
0.030797075480222702,
-0.6193335652351379,
0.23826494812965393,
-0.04637670889496803,
-0.46631017327308655,
0.742296040058136,
0.6023222208023071,
0.6378795504570007,
0.06258069723844528,
0.5837666988372803,
0.27349281311035156,
0.7795594334602356,
-0.35395586490631104,
1.1245224475860596,
-0.76053386926651,
0.5329476594924927,
-0.29043829441070557,
-0.4743883013725281,
-0.5907742977142334,
0.09373300522565842,
-0.17652954161167145,
0.02278316020965576,
0.7105651497840881,
0.6847974061965942,
0.10471101850271225,
-0.31615254282951355,
0.33015602827072144,
0.5519765019416809,
0.47264060378074646,
0.8680716753005981,
0.4274519681930542,
-0.5783371329307556,
0.6745108962059021,
-0.3132854700088501,
-0.30286622047424316,
-0.379048228263855,
-0.6787273287773132,
-0.9920312166213989,
-0.24376045167446136,
-0.625180721282959,
-0.6132901310920715,
0.565183162689209,
0.7370825409889221,
0.8580798506736755,
-1.0857175588607788,
0.2149377018213272,
0.11919321864843369,
-0.2615512013435364,
-0.19322144985198975,
-0.1821409910917282,
0.47860559821128845,
-0.5856297016143799,
-0.47688937187194824,
0.3440956771373749,
0.24527589976787567,
-0.09472598135471344,
0.0904315635561943,
0.05878515914082527,
-0.05158373713493347,
0.3074938654899597,
0.1913374662399292,
0.4084383249282837,
-0.9842961430549622,
-0.28008756041526794,
-0.08998245000839233,
-0.5091438293457031,
0.11700131744146347,
0.5332469940185547,
-0.8596876263618469,
0.955701470375061,
0.17557182908058167,
0.6679955720901489,
-0.292582631111145,
0.19534140825271606,
0.5178333520889282,
-0.29924267530441284,
-0.17959478497505188,
0.1897890716791153,
0.49191105365753174,
0.49523216485977173,
-0.0830439105629921,
0.46669501066207886,
0.48749256134033203,
-0.6657130122184753,
-0.9156516790390015,
-0.02225472591817379,
-1.0417083501815796,
-0.4750373363494873,
1.2693891525268555,
-0.19466744363307953,
-0.4333980977535248,
-0.22507421672344208,
0.07521827518939972,
0.07057368010282516,
-0.4131847620010376,
0.9547132849693298,
0.79483562707901,
-0.2936745882034302,
0.22085393965244293,
-0.8406983613967896,
0.8442275524139404,
0.3505421578884125,
-0.6823360323905945,
0.14598026871681213,
0.32545971870422363,
0.7006747722625732,
0.030320079997181892,
0.607780933380127,
-0.5162462592124939,
0.15873171389102936,
0.23794201016426086,
-0.026020515710115433,
0.06886199861764908,
0.11180569976568222,
-0.2310747653245926,
-0.10276071727275848,
0.19215068221092224,
-0.3433719277381897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12060v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12060v1
|
Not Eliminate but Aggregate: Post-Hoc Control over Mixture-of-Experts to Address Shortcut Shifts in Natural Language Understanding
| 2024-06-17T20:00:04 | 2024-06-17T20:00:04 |
Ukyo Honda, Tatsushi Oka, Peinan Zhang, Masato Mita
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent models for natural language understanding are inclined to exploit
simple patterns in datasets, commonly known as shortcuts. These shortcuts hinge
on spurious correlations between labels and latent features existing in the
training data. At inference time, shortcut-dependent models are likely to
generate erroneous predictions under distribution shifts, particularly when
some latent features are no longer correlated with the labels. To avoid this,
previous studies have trained models to eliminate the reliance on shortcuts. In
this study, we explore a different direction: pessimistically aggregating the
predictions of a mixture-of-experts, assuming each expert captures relatively
different latent features. The experimental results demonstrate that our
post-hoc control over the experts significantly enhances the model's robustness
to the distribution shift in shortcuts. Besides, we show that our approach has
some practical advantages. We also analyze our model and provide results to
support the assumption.
|
[
-0.3291303217411041,
-1.0223917961120605,
0.5703661441802979,
0.06488336622714996,
-0.47899675369262695,
0.3077371418476105,
-0.14224816858768463,
-0.30591171979904175,
0.3453286290168762,
0.6432909369468689,
-0.4239296019077301,
-0.4607926309108734,
-1.1229649782180786,
0.08516176044940948,
-0.41815024614334106,
1.2079678773880005,
0.034506380558013916,
-0.4933871924877167,
-0.16052253544330597,
-0.3089020550251007,
-0.31097328662872314,
-0.2907342314720154,
-0.44917020201683044,
-0.25224605202674866,
0.43039822578430176,
0.21024636924266815,
1.1275992393493652,
0.6040116548538208,
0.4299798011779785,
0.2934320867061615,
-0.5264934301376343,
-0.032246559858322144,
-0.369696706533432,
-0.1733846515417099,
-0.3622422516345978,
-0.48377200961112976,
-0.5824621915817261,
0.0826706662774086,
0.39861389994621277,
1.1964224576950073,
-0.40605127811431885,
-0.2418949156999588,
0.19677618145942688,
0.37384188175201416,
-0.5249941945075989,
-0.15851464867591858,
-0.9648568034172058,
-0.2578463554382324,
-0.2950868010520935,
-0.1531902253627777,
-0.1779233068227768,
-0.29208168387413025,
0.3663117289543152,
-0.5615920424461365,
0.34790438413619995,
-0.043711837381124496,
0.5275125503540039,
0.43493399024009705,
-0.49998292326927185,
-0.28400200605392456,
-0.5200779438018799,
0.9540857672691345,
-0.6952998042106628,
0.16558195650577545,
0.6083611249923706,
0.2875380516052246,
-0.0533330999314785,
-0.23372066020965576,
-0.22648775577545166,
0.15568172931671143,
-0.235030397772789,
-0.04562447592616081,
0.09962838143110275,
-0.008763343095779419,
-0.27197906374931335,
0.2661629319190979,
-0.2959938645362854,
0.28516241908073425,
-0.2402038276195526,
-0.2010158896446228,
0.6799302697181702,
0.18663354218006134,
0.17398148775100708,
0.06046263501048088,
-0.1639658361673355,
0.2488640993833542,
-0.615098774433136,
0.12237289547920227,
0.08259132504463196,
0.34039369225502014,
-0.2345019280910492,
0.6334471702575684,
-0.13264259696006775,
0.8896163702011108,
0.21847470104694366,
-0.309693843126297,
0.17201480269432068,
-0.3803018629550934,
-0.18242095410823822,
0.1042829304933548,
0.7202913165092468,
0.0860384851694107,
0.07482178509235382,
-0.5183233022689819,
-0.23189996182918549,
0.08945845067501068,
-0.09606129676103592,
-0.2304840385913849,
-0.5765039324760437,
0.06711381673812866,
-0.3977285921573639,
-0.4851505756378174,
-0.0770256370306015,
-0.6388037800788879,
-0.27398666739463806,
-0.3112926781177521,
0.3463749885559082,
-0.2667303681373596,
-0.38316428661346436,
0.07092611491680145,
-0.21198135614395142,
-0.13310027122497559,
0.43463319540023804,
-0.8563209772109985,
0.49200013279914856,
0.766949474811554,
0.7805134057998657,
-0.2285899817943573,
-0.36757078766822815,
-0.6087409257888794,
0.37644264101982117,
-0.31690433621406555,
0.7571158409118652,
-0.8631198406219482,
-0.6819857358932495,
-0.2762443423271179,
-0.3986831307411194,
-0.2356577068567276,
-0.6085137128829956,
0.26386740803718567,
-0.3823917806148529,
0.518871009349823,
-0.13934201002120972,
-0.5185584425926208,
-0.010060549713671207,
0.10749038308858871,
-0.3516205847263336,
0.9150286316871643,
0.12420818954706192,
-0.9678664207458496,
0.44589701294898987,
-0.2662507891654968,
-0.5972892045974731,
-0.2811608612537384,
-0.40703076124191284,
-0.4208814799785614,
0.3061373233795166,
0.43325796723365784,
0.13008958101272583,
-0.0902094766497612,
0.6854827404022217,
-0.5169574618339539,
-0.0668780729174614,
0.2976452708244324,
-0.2874225676059723,
0.6577118635177612,
0.00338905886746943,
-0.28848329186439514,
-0.07572219520807266,
-0.6411224603652954,
-0.33873486518859863,
-0.10271463543176651,
-0.24317681789398193,
-0.9141190052032471,
0.10802903771400452,
-0.4666854441165924,
0.46054208278656006,
-0.01718803122639656,
-0.02261394076049328,
0.2513313889503479,
-0.5454981923103333,
0.17715159058570862,
0.9347411394119263,
0.4110293388366699,
1.1122562885284424,
-0.16159166395664215,
0.5069938898086548,
0.2070697546005249,
0.14823415875434875,
0.2221461832523346,
-0.6026403903961182,
-0.5433654189109802,
-0.2549585998058319,
0.09121078252792358,
0.3244502544403076,
-1.1026896238327026,
0.6234711408615112,
-0.27563992142677307,
-0.439581960439682,
-0.3747907876968384,
0.4249257743358612,
0.47746890783309937,
0.7607342600822449,
0.49071356654167175,
-0.24760712683200836,
0.031203053891658783,
-0.7952753901481628,
-0.8683133721351624,
-0.043008964508771896,
-0.21349076926708221,
0.20760776102542877,
0.20681743323802948,
-0.08590726554393768,
1.1438779830932617,
-0.726612389087677,
-0.0033797197975218296,
-0.3758675754070282,
0.6947264671325684,
0.32811567187309265,
0.43715745210647583,
0.6022821664810181,
-0.7508096098899841,
-0.593805193901062,
-0.19694635272026062,
-0.3144512176513672,
-0.21993635594844818,
-0.09835794568061829,
-0.3312087059020996,
-0.16770538687705994,
0.2509121000766754,
-0.6712934970855713,
0.4661126136779785,
0.3594745397567749,
-0.3557170629501343,
0.3871326446533203,
0.017666921019554138,
-0.18443234264850616,
-0.850125789642334,
-0.24839334189891815,
0.03260303661227226,
-0.05678834766149521,
-0.7317947149276733,
-0.42163267731666565,
-0.10700936615467072,
0.12708120048046112,
-0.31212136149406433,
0.4936838746070862,
-0.4042325019836426,
0.07137728482484818,
-0.3081427216529846,
-0.11216382682323456,
0.09631824493408203,
0.4168418049812317,
0.3702479600906372,
0.6318797469139099,
0.6672919392585754,
-0.9573538303375244,
-0.4917808771133423,
0.3505795896053314,
-0.15003737807273865,
0.4309484362602234,
-0.5497274994850159,
0.20031990110874176,
-0.21031375229358673,
0.04866544529795647,
-0.6881412267684937,
-0.19937387108802795,
0.33598077297210693,
-0.5036171078681946,
0.22085896134376526,
0.016498474404215813,
-0.1914370208978653,
-0.046463895589113235,
-0.15991675853729248,
0.13934226334095,
0.5562825202941895,
-0.08279282599687576,
0.7565580010414124,
0.506544828414917,
-0.5484105348587036,
-0.3963395059108734,
-0.7129254341125488,
-0.17341895401477814,
-0.5169202089309692,
-0.36606934666633606,
0.3880114257335663,
0.14021457731723785,
-0.5733429789543152,
0.08887073397636414,
-0.270145058631897,
-0.39945748448371887,
0.34520789980888367,
-0.06560511887073517,
0.0800485759973526,
0.13370686769485474,
0.20308126509189606,
0.49130168557167053,
-0.20271258056163788,
0.03384539112448692,
-0.1431892365217209,
0.14484526216983795,
0.3714377284049988,
-0.34222447872161865,
-0.13496199250221252,
0.5809404850006104,
0.45152920484542847,
-0.34112444519996643,
0.9118881225585938,
0.3336125910282135,
-0.17182908952236176,
0.09442569315433502,
-0.44885578751564026,
-0.33812543749809265,
-0.5136529207229614,
0.3162572383880615,
-0.12778131663799286,
-0.8667360544204712,
0.5236530900001526,
-0.05913151055574417,
0.14596569538116455,
0.4086282551288605,
0.25038382411003113,
-0.3038245737552643,
1.015000343322754,
0.7507673501968384,
-0.3561675548553467,
0.433939129114151,
-0.0146818608045578,
0.3327125906944275,
-0.4945446252822876,
-0.05858824402093887,
-0.6799915432929993,
-0.1350158303976059,
-0.30395087599754333,
-0.3898935616016388,
0.46712619066238403,
0.1755206435918808,
0.1634022295475006,
0.04997818171977997,
-0.2986391484737396,
0.33544957637786865,
0.39083224534988403,
0.19270116090774536,
0.10943502932786942,
-0.11118316650390625,
-0.0031025740318000317,
-0.05857187509536743,
-0.7642382979393005,
-0.22712285816669464,
0.7927516102790833,
0.06053166836500168,
0.8012025356292725,
0.07118045538663864,
0.8359096646308899,
0.24255777895450592,
0.24976088106632233,
-0.5669087767601013,
0.43116462230682373,
-0.03704759478569031,
-0.433134526014328,
-0.39974695444107056,
-0.5862209796905518,
-0.7771592736244202,
0.3019579350948334,
-0.1747273951768875,
-0.7332174181938171,
0.4709382951259613,
0.521043598651886,
-0.49826571345329285,
0.24763844907283783,
-0.7142438888549805,
0.7184907793998718,
-0.33057406544685364,
-0.3436962366104126,
-0.16155362129211426,
-0.9345632195472717,
0.3391624689102173,
-0.29126256704330444,
0.6865653991699219,
-0.09680827707052231,
-0.06881983578205109,
0.9192959666252136,
-0.6878652572631836,
0.7785487771034241,
-0.18728306889533997,
0.032741107046604156,
0.5034059286117554,
0.14574368298053741,
0.9828809499740601,
-0.14434771239757538,
-0.007973837666213512,
-0.10129904001951218,
-0.5094792246818542,
-0.5725499391555786,
-0.6624792218208313,
0.30480918288230896,
-0.8817082047462463,
-0.5186558365821838,
-0.11372363567352295,
-0.28992417454719543,
-0.40388572216033936,
0.0561966635286808,
0.41152718663215637,
0.3633808195590973,
-0.017114369198679924,
-0.01071274746209383,
0.5376315712928772,
-0.009127781726419926,
0.5036404132843018,
0.3699241578578949,
0.0576944425702095,
-0.4293960630893707,
0.834913432598114,
0.21383501589298248,
0.5401965975761414,
0.4103816747665405,
0.43515467643737793,
-0.43305954337120056,
-0.8896684050559998,
0.16230233013629913,
0.10510843247175217,
-0.6364022493362427,
0.07986418157815933,
-0.9607581496238708,
0.23182234168052673,
-0.6937229037284851,
-0.4138176441192627,
-0.39741918444633484,
-0.38032495975494385,
-0.6398576498031616,
-0.28568515181541443,
0.2394159436225891,
0.5237663984298706,
0.11913992464542389,
0.885022759437561,
-1.0484569072723389,
0.2904103994369507,
0.5544893145561218,
0.047212548553943634,
0.004736972041428089,
-0.5819998979568481,
-0.4897156059741974,
-0.022560320794582367,
-0.23241400718688965,
-1.193511724472046,
0.6448372006416321,
0.3829253911972046,
0.8637083768844604,
0.6873359084129333,
0.13243557512760162,
0.6679338812828064,
-0.23095688223838806,
0.694054365158081,
0.33909836411476135,
-1.030490517616272,
0.5077217817306519,
-0.5271633267402649,
0.38500821590423584,
0.9165209531784058,
0.34303221106529236,
-0.33989137411117554,
-0.8729598522186279,
-0.9086713790893555,
-0.8761934041976929,
0.6699981689453125,
0.3730778098106384,
-0.18160460889339447,
0.002595728961750865,
0.016095537692308426,
0.5064875483512878,
0.49801966547966003,
-0.4409492015838623,
-0.11218086630105972,
-0.0940294861793518,
-0.1531355082988739,
-0.24352233111858368,
-0.42073819041252136,
-0.08277948200702667,
-0.3129902184009552,
0.47764214873313904,
0.11023066937923431,
-0.14324752986431122,
-0.1252286583185196,
-0.4108292758464813,
0.0807424783706665,
0.4348423480987549,
0.33617451786994934,
0.8506519198417664,
-0.2875007092952728,
0.39444366097450256,
0.07839461416006088,
-0.3638575077056885,
0.08520720154047012,
0.04294301196932793,
-0.1663886308670044,
0.23018597066402435,
0.4278152585029602,
0.6518148183822632,
0.4185383915901184,
-0.16733628511428833,
0.3327799141407013,
0.2234412133693695,
-0.07821687310934067,
0.2576916515827179,
0.04010380432009697,
-0.0021709995344281197,
-0.1596529185771942,
0.36963531374931335,
0.6213616728782654,
0.33322903513908386,
-0.2124299854040146,
0.2741759717464447,
0.17933809757232666,
-0.24505507946014404,
-0.6219723224639893,
0.4993424415588379,
0.3474617302417755,
-0.21368277072906494,
0.4298124611377716,
-0.1725492775440216,
-0.5521970987319946,
0.6230162978172302,
0.03352458402514458,
0.8855646848678589,
-0.38071954250335693,
0.2626332640647888,
-0.0555449053645134,
0.3592739999294281,
0.02720119245350361,
-0.1205524280667305,
-0.26201340556144714,
-0.7440691590309143,
-0.4193800985813141,
-0.19916844367980957,
-0.390220582485199,
-0.23542311787605286,
-0.8362753987312317,
0.2755674123764038,
-0.14500877261161804,
-0.22966523468494415,
-0.0041128648445010185,
-0.4699495732784271,
-0.7263804078102112,
0.20138272643089294,
-0.24470798671245575,
0.6786184310913086,
-1.5207853317260742,
0.9771389365196228,
0.6849380731582642,
0.02708154171705246,
-0.6781921982765198,
0.23959319293498993,
0.02726037986576557,
-0.395263671875,
0.08399458229541779,
-0.07672940939664841,
0.18911798298358917,
-0.22056661546230316,
-0.45648208260536194,
-0.8711260557174683,
0.5377981066703796,
0.06044292077422142,
-0.4768558740615845,
-0.006687612738460302,
0.019685575738549232,
0.35889172554016113,
-0.13860060274600983,
0.24854689836502075,
0.8738594651222229,
0.35270586609840393,
0.20302730798721313,
-0.9652498960494995,
-0.2739490866661072,
-0.025631124153733253,
-0.3110111355781555,
0.3139290511608124,
-0.24366168677806854,
1.1947191953659058,
-0.06344445049762726,
-0.05776369944214821,
-0.5114750862121582,
0.6865320801734924,
0.3102591633796692,
0.48075905442237854,
0.7425702810287476,
0.4343019723892212,
0.8059697151184082,
0.2733144164085388,
1.0443028211593628,
-0.006498278118669987,
0.346975713968277,
1.5868064165115356,
-0.10231409221887589,
0.5107762217521667,
0.7316030859947205,
-0.33832991123199463,
0.15072494745254517,
0.819514274597168,
0.7077934145927429,
1.2460211515426636,
-0.46874910593032837,
-0.2595750093460083,
-0.523529052734375,
0.041436661034822464,
-0.5824559330940247,
0.36408746242523193,
0.6308442950248718,
-0.520368754863739,
-0.5158648490905762,
-0.17913025617599487,
0.09234710037708282,
0.1440458446741104,
-0.3312397301197052,
1.0048727989196777,
0.18386943638324738,
-0.7647266983985901,
0.3805774450302124,
-0.18475094437599182,
0.7797902226448059,
-0.4787866771221161,
0.17403699457645416,
-0.21646511554718018,
-0.12163269519805908,
-0.03354928269982338,
-0.6637816429138184,
0.6482206583023071,
-0.25941261649131775,
-0.043795231729745865,
-0.24476388096809387,
0.766033947467804,
-0.6087950468063354,
-0.687347948551178,
0.09477204084396362,
0.6899146437644958,
0.14658136665821075,
-0.2897671163082123,
-0.781337559223175,
-0.2641635239124298,
0.15056535601615906,
-0.11120542138814926,
0.381405770778656,
0.5747550129890442,
-0.15312138199806213,
0.3120780885219574,
0.28558704257011414,
0.17500096559524536,
0.22982148826122284,
-0.1545296013355255,
1.1215097904205322,
-0.4294384717941284,
-0.8255954384803772,
-0.987887978553772,
0.5375379323959351,
-0.1602127104997635,
-0.2796463966369629,
0.6370225548744202,
0.2463926076889038,
0.43891191482543945,
-0.06503637880086899,
0.9088932871818542,
0.19962099194526672,
0.7441202998161316,
-0.44836676120758057,
0.5401352047920227,
-0.5294660329818726,
0.24692577123641968,
-0.40759342908859253,
-0.7192457318305969,
-0.24561567604541779,
0.2543862462043762,
-0.8648520112037659,
-0.10310579836368561,
0.522802472114563,
0.499742716550827,
-0.12824200093746185,
-0.09426438808441162,
0.15658427774906158,
0.1730988770723343,
0.4798274040222168,
0.4205617606639862,
0.6773092150688171,
0.3147677481174469,
0.4045768678188324,
-0.5175410509109497,
-0.21059799194335938,
-0.2562025189399719,
-0.791630744934082,
-0.8929932117462158,
-0.018645551055669785,
-0.4692116379737854,
0.06477447599172592,
-0.05547839030623436,
0.8040525913238525,
0.4748658835887909,
-0.8201836943626404,
0.11748223751783371,
-0.3520803153514862,
0.5605974197387695,
-0.30395734310150146,
-0.17975394427776337,
0.48191404342651367,
-0.20205697417259216,
-0.47474488615989685,
0.28690314292907715,
0.41774240136146545,
0.3096122741699219,
0.061588555574417114,
-0.08594381809234619,
-0.12612447142601013,
0.10497169196605682,
0.3119249641895294,
0.08793294429779053,
-0.7055662274360657,
-0.09736453741788864,
-0.0825522243976593,
-0.029427247121930122,
0.16980284452438354,
0.826363205909729,
-0.6223071217536926,
0.4315478503704071,
0.7080130577087402,
0.4401419758796692,
0.02332843467593193,
0.34771671891212463,
0.6662043333053589,
-0.9344774484634399,
0.5754055380821228,
0.39966824650764465,
0.26711246371269226,
0.23864616453647614,
-0.47668394446372986,
0.1993473619222641,
0.21153853833675385,
-0.36101582646369934,
-0.5338006615638733,
-0.028043562546372414,
-0.7494285106658936,
-0.32922178506851196,
0.959642767906189,
-0.1492953598499298,
-0.36603477597236633,
-0.47098082304000854,
0.03630630671977997,
0.2986631989479065,
-0.43017202615737915,
0.8992467522621155,
0.5053197145462036,
-0.14958803355693817,
-0.24759481847286224,
-0.13514840602874756,
0.4572613537311554,
0.5493391156196594,
-0.7644076347351074,
-0.2515541911125183,
0.39794090390205383,
0.16593214869499207,
-0.03360501676797867,
0.9875474572181702,
0.06852816790342331,
-0.0706663653254509,
-0.18373139202594757,
-0.18565115332603455,
0.24368616938591003,
-0.4475492537021637,
-0.22260990738868713,
0.1113877072930336,
0.28163307905197144,
-0.41227930784225464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12058v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12058v3
|
WellDunn: On the Robustness and Explainability of Language Models and Large Language Models in Identifying Wellness Dimensions
| 2024-06-17T19:50:40 | 2024-06-28T04:08:12 |
Seyedali Mohammadi, Edward Raff, Jinendra Malekar, Vedant Palit, Francis Ferraro, Manas Gaur
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Language Models (LMs) are being proposed for mental health applications where
the heightened risk of adverse outcomes means predictive performance may not be
a sufficient litmus test of a model's utility in clinical practice. A model
that can be trusted for practice should have a correspondence between
explanation and clinical determination, yet no prior research has examined the
attention fidelity of these models and their effect on ground truth
explanations. We introduce an evaluation design that focuses on the robustness
and explainability of LMs in identifying Wellness Dimensions (WD). We focus on
two mental health and well-being datasets: (a) Multi-label Classification-based
MultiWD, and (b) WellXplain for evaluating attention mechanism veracity against
expert-labeled explanations. The labels are based on Halbert Dunn's theory of
wellness, which gives grounding to our evaluation. We reveal four surprising
results about LMs/LLMs: (1) Despite their human-like capabilities, GPT-3.5/4
lag behind RoBERTa, and MedAlpaca, a fine-tuned LLM fails to deliver any
remarkable improvements in performance or explanations. (2) Re-examining LMs'
predictions based on a confidence-oriented loss function reveals a significant
performance drop. (3) Across all LMs/LLMs, the alignment between attention and
explanations remains low, with LLMs scoring a dismal 0.0. (4) Most mental
health-specific LMs/LLMs overlook domain-specific knowledge and undervalue
explanations, causing these discrepancies. This study highlights the need for
further research into their consistency and explanations in mental health and
well-being.
|
[
-0.295487642288208,
-0.693114697933197,
0.8857213854789734,
0.08472343534231186,
0.001740447711199522,
-0.1320241242647171,
-0.32338008284568787,
-0.5648424029350281,
0.025749871507287025,
0.1591048538684845,
-0.7234556674957275,
-0.5241869688034058,
-0.7370153665542603,
0.05106067284941673,
-0.022233473137021065,
1.038454294204712,
0.26170939207077026,
0.010134461335837841,
-0.27438244223594666,
-0.21960805356502533,
-0.5691287517547607,
-0.4441336393356323,
-0.48548009991645813,
-0.6512734293937683,
0.5344804525375366,
0.06112237647175789,
1.0433036088943481,
0.43553102016448975,
0.66414475440979,
0.18774615228176117,
-0.23342502117156982,
0.009849149733781815,
-0.8394476771354675,
-0.12359990924596786,
-0.3341626524925232,
-0.2534807622432709,
-0.6965559720993042,
-0.1302923709154129,
0.36788395047187805,
0.9549785256385803,
-0.12236161530017853,
0.3102567195892334,
0.34101077914237976,
0.6240572929382324,
-0.7480307221412659,
-0.043778568506240845,
-0.20678895711898804,
0.06805740296840668,
-0.026497604325413704,
0.057479459792375565,
-0.14443311095237732,
-0.3106374740600586,
0.1067962720990181,
-0.4806288778781891,
-0.03430910408496857,
-0.052356574684381485,
0.9416347742080688,
0.6436660289764404,
-0.3617396056652069,
-0.20326825976371765,
-0.8418834805488586,
0.8824405670166016,
-1.0182985067367554,
0.49777036905288696,
0.6124951243400574,
0.09423178434371948,
-0.039702158421278,
-0.47902432084083557,
-0.4100746810436249,
-0.06136619672179222,
-0.18855851888656616,
0.3239174485206604,
-0.42418646812438965,
0.16243812441825867,
0.5999535918235779,
0.5950555205345154,
-0.7359234094619751,
0.14590619504451752,
-0.02918871119618416,
-0.373026043176651,
0.5843303203582764,
0.3314304053783417,
0.26034125685691833,
-0.2664247155189514,
-0.1812187284231186,
0.36907321214675903,
-0.46517637372016907,
0.3493940532207489,
-0.2790391147136688,
0.03676557168364525,
-0.2811921536922455,
0.6672355532646179,
-0.03845485672354698,
0.5856571197509766,
-0.038067176938056946,
-0.9143944978713989,
0.08660327643156052,
-0.2637732923030853,
-0.3828987777233124,
-0.018215861171483994,
0.738288938999176,
0.6660938262939453,
0.21025285124778748,
-0.3717331886291504,
-0.139036163687706,
0.18521243333816528,
0.2445140928030014,
-0.7467383146286011,
-0.19046804308891296,
0.5033353567123413,
-0.8208132982254028,
0.23157919943332672,
-0.15123781561851501,
-0.6762058734893799,
-0.5717621445655823,
-0.3805975317955017,
0.39756402373313904,
-0.5483428835868835,
-0.3504205346107483,
0.4461824595928192,
0.2857787609100342,
0.001645682961679995,
0.051160428673028946,
-0.7517045140266418,
0.21243524551391602,
0.7797272801399231,
0.7178448438644409,
-0.46340397000312805,
-0.148342102766037,
-0.3182675242424011,
-0.008062446489930153,
-0.28086721897125244,
0.5401871800422668,
-0.3330892324447632,
-0.2310408651828766,
-0.0021625428926199675,
0.1337483674287796,
-0.08650755882263184,
-0.4861495792865753,
0.6903944611549377,
-0.20220503211021423,
0.13576069474220276,
-0.7105401158332825,
-0.5766993165016174,
-0.014070571400225163,
0.32535839080810547,
-0.5057218074798584,
0.7666886448860168,
0.2302863746881485,
-1.0858042240142822,
0.35532522201538086,
-0.5575777888298035,
-0.4661495089530945,
-0.05172715336084366,
0.18362675607204437,
-0.3540116548538208,
0.2548177242279053,
0.05075393244624138,
0.4687868058681488,
-0.2221597284078598,
0.4118245840072632,
-0.6753783226013184,
-0.44155943393707275,
0.6164641976356506,
-0.5459045171737671,
0.8926540613174438,
0.31548869609832764,
-0.11277353763580322,
0.010859137400984764,
-0.8761700391769409,
0.12639544904232025,
0.07219578325748444,
-0.2079174518585205,
-0.44337061047554016,
-0.05471421405673027,
-0.26003551483154297,
0.25368064641952515,
0.28211191296577454,
-0.21438893675804138,
-0.4797881543636322,
-0.39768579602241516,
0.2787926197052002,
0.38679638504981995,
0.02030087634921074,
0.19890490174293518,
-0.18300281465053558,
0.797083854675293,
-0.2825632691383362,
0.3298287093639374,
-0.2851860225200653,
-0.361532986164093,
-0.14234142005443573,
-0.7355643510818481,
0.06584756821393967,
0.3986572027206421,
-0.20729292929172516,
0.3839402198791504,
-0.4003477692604065,
-0.0996408760547638,
-0.5660118460655212,
0.09467996656894684,
0.39888885617256165,
0.6107348203659058,
0.27865681052207947,
-0.31944572925567627,
-0.2540450394153595,
-0.9656496047973633,
-0.5164496302604675,
0.008609134703874588,
-0.13802507519721985,
0.09198527038097382,
0.3360409140586853,
-0.4750846326351166,
0.8558289408683777,
-0.21278955042362213,
0.10281451791524887,
-0.182749405503273,
-0.11359831690788269,
0.1418331265449524,
0.02235502377152443,
0.5560513138771057,
-0.4112274944782257,
-0.15305708348751068,
-0.29117849469184875,
-0.8406237959861755,
-0.027718177065253258,
0.09989704936742783,
-0.024473190307617188,
-0.32171472907066345,
-0.07688941061496735,
-0.7254756093025208,
0.4248306453227997,
0.45543545484542847,
-0.29246285557746887,
0.6010919809341431,
-0.09903110563755035,
-0.17755363881587982,
-1.0088891983032227,
-0.027475349605083466,
0.25560256838798523,
-0.28825896978378296,
-0.6794112324714661,
0.06651033461093903,
-0.07576090097427368,
-0.12959681451320648,
0.004441373515874147,
0.3675937056541443,
-0.345002144575119,
-0.06632057577371597,
-0.3379150331020355,
0.12247110903263092,
0.24252039194107056,
0.19821201264858246,
-0.3552974760532379,
0.38502541184425354,
0.8324811458587646,
-0.4874936640262604,
0.3799068331718445,
-0.019560839980840683,
-0.2999875843524933,
0.8216521739959717,
-0.7121714353561401,
-0.11003702878952026,
-0.18203236162662506,
0.11460430175065994,
-1.0513131618499756,
-0.43872547149658203,
0.16826169192790985,
-0.3061479330062866,
0.30199867486953735,
0.2776370942592621,
-0.35468199849128723,
-0.5002498030662537,
-0.1778447926044464,
0.17402900755405426,
0.42186981439590454,
-0.33029717206954956,
0.2684585750102997,
0.5554285645484924,
-0.042163025587797165,
-0.38798803091049194,
-0.7156314253807068,
0.13323277235031128,
-0.7185070514678955,
-0.45065367221832275,
0.16318078339099884,
-0.05742567777633667,
-0.6399072408676147,
-0.002101176418364048,
-0.4230864942073822,
0.029000502079725266,
0.5658757090568542,
0.27642732858657837,
0.1602546125650406,
-0.32442963123321533,
0.5278255939483643,
-0.2040262371301651,
-0.21908503770828247,
0.5784454345703125,
-0.07740215957164764,
0.13726451992988586,
-0.2307090312242508,
-0.3330898582935333,
-0.575910210609436,
0.38467347621917725,
0.5998023152351379,
-0.45557159185409546,
0.9641016721725464,
0.691280722618103,
-0.7968816161155701,
0.10463377088308334,
-0.3356560170650482,
-0.3439079821109772,
-0.33838310837745667,
0.44079792499542236,
-0.32648834586143494,
-0.8609740734100342,
0.5659804344177246,
-0.08480951189994812,
-0.08580835163593292,
0.4795936346054077,
0.6290069818496704,
-0.1574423760175705,
1.2374519109725952,
0.7811778783798218,
0.0610882043838501,
0.095087930560112,
-0.004275830462574959,
0.8195978403091431,
-0.8055334687232971,
-0.22224971652030945,
-0.40979838371276855,
-0.20999853312969208,
-0.654306948184967,
-0.02915175072848797,
0.30692222714424133,
0.2763911485671997,
-0.23682041466236115,
-0.2502800524234772,
-0.44416365027427673,
0.202158123254776,
0.035202402621507645,
0.06333214044570923,
0.2752489745616913,
-0.08789591491222382,
0.004285055212676525,
-0.41854536533355713,
-0.6325919032096863,
-0.7276660799980164,
0.8574724197387695,
0.8854689002037048,
1.2566194534301758,
0.2873365879058838,
0.5401483178138733,
0.16078171133995056,
0.5328729152679443,
-0.9671000242233276,
0.21667814254760742,
0.04383077099919319,
-0.6147080063819885,
-0.5325655341148376,
-0.3613482415676117,
-0.855459451675415,
0.11654402315616608,
-0.11949951946735382,
-1.2458932399749756,
0.1634766012430191,
0.14427433907985687,
-0.750152587890625,
-0.0759715735912323,
-0.6813879609107971,
0.9468859434127808,
-0.41549959778785706,
-0.4173830449581146,
-0.20020774006843567,
-0.6746906042098999,
0.7422871589660645,
-0.16893665492534637,
0.3820645213127136,
-0.3659663796424866,
0.31620943546295166,
0.612628161907196,
-0.2199825942516327,
0.667650580406189,
0.17750683426856995,
-0.5403362512588501,
-0.1456046849489212,
0.016975080594420433,
0.09987413138151169,
0.33403322100639343,
-0.2180997133255005,
0.03799320384860039,
0.28767654299736023,
-0.23608432710170746,
-0.8384446501731873,
0.8400769829750061,
-0.6917784214019775,
-0.6764855980873108,
-0.21160250902175903,
-0.652468740940094,
-0.5927486419677734,
0.13949839770793915,
0.15802466869354248,
0.5284113883972168,
-0.12688058614730835,
0.10694035142660141,
0.9004355669021606,
-0.31815922260284424,
-0.03583281859755516,
0.35116347670555115,
-0.3256895840167999,
-0.20691227912902832,
0.8527182936668396,
0.005285243969410658,
0.32349109649658203,
0.12435340881347656,
0.3555331826210022,
-0.39330434799194336,
-0.25000566244125366,
0.07929195463657379,
0.39089810848236084,
-0.8073827624320984,
-0.004609277471899986,
-0.5439079999923706,
-0.17798511683940887,
-0.3462163209915161,
0.2273409068584442,
-0.4049639105796814,
-0.159468874335289,
-0.21018564701080322,
-0.22491934895515442,
-0.014595241285860538,
0.7288424968719482,
-0.1789967268705368,
-0.09582445025444031,
-0.548526406288147,
0.5752586722373962,
0.2630844712257385,
0.5488074421882629,
0.3640820384025574,
-0.48221051692962646,
-0.665632963180542,
0.31854766607284546,
-0.4364301264286041,
-1.2588801383972168,
0.10209836065769196,
0.14020709693431854,
0.7890608310699463,
0.8479121327400208,
0.1158292144536972,
0.7098718881607056,
-0.17433761060237885,
0.7158404588699341,
0.23144996166229248,
-0.8871056437492371,
0.5345438122749329,
-0.07496121525764465,
0.4387306869029999,
0.33705225586891174,
0.5610888004302979,
-0.3439634442329407,
-0.41878849267959595,
-0.5399484038352966,
-0.48197484016418457,
0.4952968657016754,
0.05222455784678459,
-0.043540943413972855,
-0.04663998633623123,
0.5556254982948303,
0.19543075561523438,
-0.11441454291343689,
-0.6644722819328308,
-0.3946135938167572,
-0.37921062111854553,
-0.16080905497074127,
-0.2695087790489197,
-0.6650353074073792,
-0.4512326717376709,
-0.2556237280368805,
0.45774129033088684,
-0.23131175339221954,
0.3710574805736542,
0.3299328088760376,
0.11953335255384445,
-0.24037273228168488,
0.5551537871360779,
0.6806566715240479,
1.1247020959854126,
-0.20212383568286896,
0.5648679733276367,
0.11852060258388519,
-0.19467659294605255,
-0.02298481948673725,
0.16284847259521484,
0.12425441294908524,
-0.02586050145328045,
0.7259112596511841,
0.785198986530304,
0.13528962433338165,
-0.5694693922996521,
0.22781267762184143,
0.0325106643140316,
0.010961970314383507,
0.15543198585510254,
0.07436554878950119,
0.443023145198822,
0.26443958282470703,
0.090031698346138,
-0.17987559735774994,
0.3727312982082367,
-0.7351218461990356,
-0.12233420461416245,
0.6574115753173828,
-0.5845904350280762,
-0.5643407106399536,
0.6752000451087952,
-0.3074670433998108,
-0.3538612127304077,
0.3706224858760834,
-0.10922790318727493,
-0.46583762764930725,
0.36375364661216736,
0.6087881922721863,
0.7179998159408569,
-0.22871503233909607,
0.33863791823387146,
0.38811391592025757,
0.4136090576648712,
-0.10665170103311539,
0.35501906275749207,
0.04357929527759552,
-0.6661568284034729,
-0.5622069239616394,
-0.6846506595611572,
-0.15547320246696472,
0.5677375197410583,
-1.0522857904434204,
-0.442649245262146,
-0.1177096739411354,
-0.6548253893852234,
-0.011072397232055664,
-0.017532233148813248,
-0.7733023762702942,
0.2959756553173065,
0.3738844692707062,
0.6405636072158813,
-0.8295527696609497,
0.49097156524658203,
0.7410870790481567,
-0.07389325648546219,
-0.900827944278717,
0.6084690093994141,
0.08485104143619537,
-0.5591461062431335,
0.20146659016609192,
0.21240240335464478,
-0.19018994271755219,
-0.3004486560821533,
-0.4276299476623535,
-0.9567970037460327,
0.9083666205406189,
0.766488790512085,
-0.3334769308567047,
0.08411408215761185,
0.2002534568309784,
0.8630844950675964,
-0.181360125541687,
0.15575852990150452,
0.6327188611030579,
0.6815707087516785,
-0.08247487992048264,
-1.0124927759170532,
0.14453497529029846,
0.04838625341653824,
0.19310441613197327,
-0.36499664187431335,
-0.5274129509925842,
0.5654895305633545,
-0.7127934694290161,
-0.37887823581695557,
-0.1261308193206787,
0.5031226277351379,
0.4465020000934601,
0.4716748297214508,
0.1531035602092743,
0.7187759876251221,
1.1209404468536377,
-0.11017005145549774,
1.3234819173812866,
-0.2726292908191681,
0.778609037399292,
0.9564159512519836,
-0.4090130925178528,
0.45763230323791504,
0.38353049755096436,
-0.4326418340206146,
0.2949095070362091,
0.985583484172821,
0.331856906414032,
0.7118965983390808,
0.299780011177063,
0.012394506484270096,
-0.5116989612579346,
-0.34544000029563904,
-0.2673323154449463,
0.20759789645671844,
0.37162184715270996,
-0.2982363998889923,
-0.28072866797447205,
0.2484348565340042,
-0.02046011947095394,
-0.028487153351306915,
-0.1464020013809204,
0.5559734106063843,
0.5216258764266968,
-0.48947423696517944,
0.6934698224067688,
0.09276805073022842,
0.12604574859142303,
-0.36977386474609375,
0.0982150286436081,
-0.20898054540157318,
0.354206383228302,
-0.3160950839519501,
-0.7753109931945801,
0.37853074073791504,
-0.08696214109659195,
-0.3584350347518921,
-0.1896902173757553,
0.8689115047454834,
-0.3038126230239868,
-0.49824804067611694,
0.25017431378364563,
0.6817023158073425,
0.20009557902812958,
0.007838919758796692,
-0.7594431042671204,
0.1718772053718567,
-0.263990581035614,
-0.2985799312591553,
0.3792637288570404,
0.8546451330184937,
-0.04614010825753212,
0.8720189929008484,
0.35510122776031494,
-0.009980046190321445,
-0.10797932744026184,
0.18002091348171234,
0.5038421750068665,
-0.4433097839355469,
-0.25313684344291687,
-1.0535104274749756,
0.4426923394203186,
0.13683509826660156,
-0.20646147429943085,
0.8584877848625183,
0.38668113946914673,
0.24876433610916138,
0.042221710085868835,
0.7114849090576172,
0.31435853242874146,
0.37608835101127625,
-0.5185412764549255,
0.7384763360023499,
-0.8483873009681702,
0.21467703580856323,
-0.06350965797901154,
-0.817069947719574,
-0.18902206420898438,
0.7072318196296692,
-0.38332223892211914,
0.23538213968276978,
0.8596815466880798,
0.5204954147338867,
-0.06391414999961853,
-0.02233904041349888,
0.5429589152336121,
0.5929759740829468,
0.28349336981773376,
0.6425818204879761,
0.7700748443603516,
0.017053775489330292,
-0.06807372719049454,
-0.20957225561141968,
-0.24496908485889435,
-0.16672857105731964,
-0.8100631833076477,
-0.9832133054733276,
-0.2714690864086151,
-0.39652687311172485,
-0.45791634917259216,
0.15386326611042023,
0.5568833947181702,
0.6427410244941711,
-0.6339701414108276,
0.17825552821159363,
0.35773923993110657,
0.4335654079914093,
-0.463255912065506,
-0.23257780075073242,
0.4374254643917084,
-0.16376346349716187,
-0.16366247832775116,
0.1367703676223755,
0.5146671533584595,
-0.2314946949481964,
-0.7323516011238098,
-0.26597490906715393,
0.34944257140159607,
-0.006172616500407457,
0.6085004806518555,
0.15996912121772766,
-1.2183011770248413,
-0.2030418962240219,
0.07187239825725555,
-0.33223578333854675,
-0.0023187489714473486,
0.46881404519081116,
-0.5571684837341309,
0.37695154547691345,
0.02382967434823513,
0.5550279021263123,
-0.056608133018016815,
0.015571211464703083,
0.38244524598121643,
-0.12004965543746948,
-0.4569062888622284,
0.06725145131349564,
0.45251280069351196,
0.46525657176971436,
-0.5759872794151306,
0.23883236944675446,
-0.015592323616147041,
-0.47319748997688293,
-0.8192237019538879,
0.2101348638534546,
-0.9894028306007385,
-0.04522792994976044,
1.2208669185638428,
-0.3964111804962158,
-0.22183758020401,
-0.09217962622642517,
-0.05809948593378067,
0.05137588083744049,
0.02885018289089203,
1.1091406345367432,
1.0631273984909058,
-0.19398564100265503,
-0.38578662276268005,
-0.8105475306510925,
0.49192947149276733,
0.3951205015182495,
-0.7960090041160583,
0.2011984884738922,
0.40698668360710144,
0.483773797750473,
0.2799486219882965,
0.48835375905036926,
-0.07262624800205231,
0.3841509222984314,
-0.3930366039276123,
-0.10021708905696869,
0.22783195972442627,
-0.046593017876148224,
-0.3494991362094879,
-0.00848003663122654,
0.16928119957447052,
0.16499175131320953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12053v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12053v1
|
InternalInspector $I^2$: Robust Confidence Estimation in LLMs through Internal States
| 2024-06-17T19:46:05 | 2024-06-17T19:46:05 |
Mohammad Beigi, Ying Shen, Runing Yang, Zihao Lin, Qifan Wang, Ankith Mohan, Jianfeng He, Ming Jin, Chang-Tien Lu, Lifu Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite their vast capabilities, Large Language Models (LLMs) often struggle
with generating reliable outputs, frequently producing high-confidence
inaccuracies known as hallucinations. Addressing this challenge, our research
introduces InternalInspector, a novel framework designed to enhance confidence
estimation in LLMs by leveraging contrastive learning on internal states
including attention states, feed-forward states, and activation states of all
layers. Unlike existing methods that primarily focus on the final activation
state, InternalInspector conducts a comprehensive analysis across all internal
states of every layer to accurately identify both correct and incorrect
prediction processes. By benchmarking InternalInspector against existing
confidence estimation methods across various natural language understanding and
generation tasks, including factual question answering, commonsense reasoning,
and reading comprehension, InternalInspector achieves significantly higher
accuracy in aligning the estimated confidence scores with the correctness of
the LLM's predictions and lower calibration error. Furthermore,
InternalInspector excels at HaluEval, a hallucination detection benchmark,
outperforming other internal-based confidence estimation methods in this task.
|
[
-0.3174096643924713,
-0.39552658796310425,
0.7156773805618286,
0.11189291626214981,
-0.053487639874219894,
0.29683178663253784,
-0.31509923934936523,
-0.5992876887321472,
0.15341641008853912,
0.20872315764427185,
-0.43129396438598633,
-0.4318731129169464,
-0.5865761637687683,
0.1380244940519333,
-0.34747207164764404,
0.3958410322666168,
0.08996749669313431,
0.33391255140304565,
-0.4955879747867584,
0.33456867933273315,
-0.2966936230659485,
-0.42656582593917847,
-0.5548171401023865,
-0.6537157297134399,
0.14812451601028442,
0.6248797178268433,
0.41650334000587463,
-0.07190565764904022,
0.3288441300392151,
0.41004011034965515,
-0.045972857624292374,
0.505374550819397,
-0.5081393718719482,
0.3266199827194214,
-0.1294507086277008,
-0.44223952293395996,
0.07611235976219177,
-0.21616333723068237,
0.7672540545463562,
0.40266042947769165,
-0.015386000275611877,
-0.1296660602092743,
0.5801350474357605,
0.5763317942619324,
-0.9646310210227966,
0.24462054669857025,
-0.8663737177848816,
0.11797329783439636,
0.031882550567388535,
-0.2381991297006607,
-0.40434974431991577,
-0.6181187033653259,
-0.01261364296078682,
-0.19775372743606567,
0.04110225290060043,
-0.141869455575943,
0.6868261694908142,
0.4570460021495819,
-0.2021399438381195,
-0.278240829706192,
-0.39283934235572815,
0.6664972901344299,
-0.6964998841285706,
0.44950202107429504,
0.6488882303237915,
0.20151540637016296,
-0.38701218366622925,
-0.825131893157959,
-0.6046940088272095,
-0.6114596128463745,
-0.20929180085659027,
0.17085213959217072,
-0.031980328261852264,
0.2151869386434555,
-0.025353912264108658,
0.5666374564170837,
-0.4771682620048523,
0.3141261637210846,
-0.018316131085157394,
-0.44930481910705566,
0.33253052830696106,
0.009048822335898876,
-0.10362103581428528,
-0.04592462629079819,
-0.2545362412929535,
-0.04948930814862251,
-0.4873262643814087,
0.20207086205482483,
0.4085439145565033,
0.3025206923484802,
0.06224561482667923,
0.5098606944084167,
-0.27462971210479736,
0.280348539352417,
0.4526716470718384,
-0.24120646715164185,
0.3439459800720215,
-0.09438097476959229,
-0.33237171173095703,
0.34009695053100586,
0.5810682773590088,
0.13658729195594788,
0.20546413958072662,
-0.3440607190132141,
-0.3054717183113098,
0.30245473980903625,
0.4406766891479492,
-0.9667488932609558,
-0.39938217401504517,
0.5188299417495728,
-0.15770885348320007,
-0.2859663963317871,
0.42005014419555664,
-0.7416133284568787,
-0.7425556778907776,
-0.3367663025856018,
0.5926581621170044,
-0.679541826248169,
-0.31367743015289307,
-0.12556655704975128,
0.19043421745300293,
0.2833689749240875,
0.15169812738895416,
-0.4385764002799988,
0.5508472919464111,
0.7879893183708191,
0.876757800579071,
-0.5533691644668579,
-0.21022473275661469,
-0.7426169514656067,
-0.09898434579372406,
-0.5053454041481018,
0.9203372001647949,
-0.5485095381736755,
-0.2262173295021057,
0.15033642947673798,
0.14399486780166626,
-0.06982330232858658,
-0.7904812097549438,
0.5256798267364502,
-0.11407444626092911,
0.12537267804145813,
-0.053210314363241196,
-0.8930771946907043,
-0.244637131690979,
0.47938865423202515,
-0.387910932302475,
1.3859955072402954,
0.11818958073854446,
-0.73433917760849,
0.2375156581401825,
-0.2271759808063507,
-0.2542975842952728,
0.1419348120689392,
-0.3390118479728699,
-0.30517029762268066,
0.31883302330970764,
0.09348330646753311,
0.6505506038665771,
-0.13875462114810944,
0.026702338829636574,
-0.18597452342510223,
-0.7446702122688293,
0.5817062854766846,
-0.1329115331172943,
0.44808271527290344,
-0.09931391477584839,
-0.503328800201416,
0.5086755752563477,
-0.6920742988586426,
0.14736877381801605,
-0.24680566787719727,
0.020654091611504555,
-0.18789561092853546,
-0.12638817727565765,
-0.19239507615566254,
0.10601605474948883,
0.19013550877571106,
-0.6106821298599243,
-0.2966363728046417,
-0.47958654165267944,
-0.07785298675298691,
0.8619791865348816,
0.20862837135791779,
0.32820773124694824,
-0.16268892586231232,
0.4754849076271057,
0.20149585604667664,
-0.1015002429485321,
0.019058987498283386,
-0.35567158460617065,
-0.6445017457008362,
-0.4835032522678375,
-0.06972598284482956,
0.48087626695632935,
-0.553375244140625,
0.745744526386261,
0.007517979014664888,
-0.619570255279541,
-0.4795158803462982,
0.2734893262386322,
0.5910033583641052,
0.850050687789917,
0.3205636739730835,
-0.15376245975494385,
-0.42600423097610474,
-0.9300790429115295,
-0.18227414786815643,
-0.17071883380413055,
-0.1823703944683075,
-0.22566205263137817,
0.4275946319103241,
-0.3521850109100342,
0.49734705686569214,
-0.2530796527862549,
-0.49179431796073914,
-0.1738651841878891,
0.1181180402636528,
0.20206038653850555,
0.4568959176540375,
0.08923590183258057,
-0.48398101329803467,
-0.6526635885238647,
0.058383237570524216,
-0.7419194579124451,
0.09003141522407532,
-0.04408359155058861,
-0.19070683419704437,
0.28382572531700134,
0.7636392712593079,
-0.4057098627090454,
0.32677918672561646,
0.5411332249641418,
-0.2194838523864746,
0.4573521018028259,
-0.10448077321052551,
0.0959036648273468,
-1.1103049516677856,
-0.1416376680135727,
0.3123701512813568,
-0.2340644896030426,
-0.5320100784301758,
0.1927952766418457,
0.3799227774143219,
0.44176599383354187,
-0.1723133772611618,
0.43251490592956543,
-0.5586677193641663,
-0.03433440253138542,
-0.3308837115764618,
0.2661232650279999,
-0.22864046692848206,
0.37137314677238464,
-0.033281031996011734,
0.9092444777488708,
0.5321788787841797,
-0.5023993849754333,
0.07309113442897797,
0.10709220170974731,
-0.8859115242958069,
0.7345991730690002,
-0.446246862411499,
0.24983935058116913,
-0.17754322290420532,
-0.01352122612297535,
-1.3542977571487427,
-0.3646651804447174,
0.25415951013565063,
-0.528999924659729,
0.6016831994056702,
0.05641154572367668,
-0.59184330701828,
-0.06881099194288254,
-0.4577977657318115,
-0.17101213335990906,
0.5078527927398682,
-0.6465399861335754,
0.6625213027000427,
0.48689672350883484,
-0.04046061262488365,
-0.6345769762992859,
-0.7667835354804993,
0.10255753248929977,
0.005991097539663315,
-0.30310752987861633,
0.30148592591285706,
-0.2527301013469696,
-0.5018220543861389,
-0.12913991510868073,
-0.25192591547966003,
-0.32381972670555115,
0.020062362775206566,
0.5240929126739502,
0.084446020424366,
-0.015476331114768982,
0.31387531757354736,
0.07820018380880356,
-0.0957556813955307,
0.19090460240840912,
0.019668037071824074,
0.5046752095222473,
-0.25413841009140015,
-0.3964096009731293,
-0.6471739411354065,
0.12824879586696625,
0.34049269556999207,
-0.017878791317343712,
0.6191250085830688,
0.5879928469657898,
-0.6989333033561707,
-0.45070499181747437,
-0.7833736538887024,
-0.5012526512145996,
-0.5130032300949097,
0.5840560793876648,
-0.5719878673553467,
-0.7179474830627441,
0.39864233136177063,
0.12432259321212769,
-0.132740318775177,
0.27852627635002136,
0.5353146195411682,
-0.10705924034118652,
0.7692902088165283,
0.5317625999450684,
-0.03927150368690491,
0.2855013906955719,
0.009150557219982147,
0.04216218739748001,
-0.867364227771759,
-0.49095600843429565,
-0.4639216661453247,
-0.2753013074398041,
-0.46713531017303467,
-0.462383896112442,
0.43695876002311707,
-0.04338904097676277,
-0.35506996512413025,
0.03844008222222328,
-0.6264047026634216,
0.5172085165977478,
0.4858257472515106,
0.3651862144470215,
0.3485226631164551,
0.16998110711574554,
-0.1988992989063263,
-0.48795419931411743,
-0.340631902217865,
-0.30975180864334106,
0.8502398133277893,
0.4594855010509491,
0.9079038500785828,
0.08251070231199265,
0.7377212643623352,
0.012170675210654736,
0.5722160935401917,
-0.9205885529518127,
0.5126686692237854,
0.03548875078558922,
-0.2908394932746887,
-0.1831352710723877,
-0.30718323588371277,
-0.3670487105846405,
0.3131598234176636,
-0.20160411298274994,
-0.9261694550514221,
0.39707645773887634,
0.12857064604759216,
-0.1549939513206482,
0.318138062953949,
-0.46096155047416687,
0.47239547967910767,
-0.12862779200077057,
-0.5193488597869873,
-0.252887099981308,
-0.545294463634491,
0.5579288005828857,
-0.08725359290838242,
-0.2881053686141968,
-0.15877753496170044,
-0.24194999039173126,
0.15958306193351746,
-0.10029302537441254,
1.0518298149108887,
0.0051611983217298985,
-0.26110437512397766,
0.18310976028442383,
0.3537987470626831,
0.7238368988037109,
0.09217219799757004,
-0.49381139874458313,
0.16970551013946533,
-0.2311786413192749,
0.018949953839182854,
-0.38103291392326355,
0.9948774576187134,
-0.5596038699150085,
-0.24115565419197083,
-0.5797625780105591,
-0.43207061290740967,
-0.651688277721405,
-0.13518688082695007,
0.5360776782035828,
0.31450340151786804,
-0.20202891528606415,
0.38590535521507263,
0.8168882727622986,
-0.09363474696874619,
0.316622257232666,
0.18790076673030853,
0.1328088641166687,
-0.5046434998512268,
0.8252317905426025,
-0.09536121785640717,
0.27807074785232544,
0.5611609816551208,
0.19497795403003693,
-0.4896489977836609,
-0.44342806935310364,
0.149093359708786,
0.25016453862190247,
-1.0394175052642822,
-0.41101038455963135,
-0.6035265326499939,
-0.5703283548355103,
-0.30289411544799805,
-0.03399193286895752,
-0.4233156144618988,
0.012866097502410412,
-0.23580209910869598,
-0.35628843307495117,
0.08028692752122879,
0.6345580816268921,
-0.017312468960881233,
0.15256722271442413,
-0.32556477189064026,
0.3432910740375519,
0.33438554406166077,
0.42538154125213623,
-0.17993146181106567,
-0.8366857767105103,
-0.2630939781665802,
-0.25785547494888306,
-0.16379953920841217,
-0.8710412383079529,
0.39403969049453735,
0.26721665263175964,
0.823722779750824,
0.6278445720672607,
0.0538090281188488,
0.8944475054740906,
-0.16739626228809357,
0.6646391749382019,
0.06229820102453232,
-1.0327584743499756,
0.15724553167819977,
0.4014809727668762,
0.4556390941143036,
0.9321000576019287,
0.5076006650924683,
-0.2033398449420929,
-0.6910865306854248,
-0.19759628176689148,
-0.5308781266212463,
0.2440640926361084,
0.11795875430107117,
-0.07112841308116913,
-0.0557764396071434,
0.2719642221927643,
0.344888836145401,
0.33819273114204407,
-0.8065811991691589,
-0.026368778198957443,
-0.14127206802368164,
-0.44441649317741394,
-0.1988452970981598,
-0.5319165587425232,
-0.07954465597867966,
-0.2689260244369507,
0.9268538951873779,
-0.47698748111724854,
0.3102371096611023,
0.4767756760120392,
-0.3457542955875397,
-0.2846392095088959,
0.04627521336078644,
0.5047467350959778,
0.8057450652122498,
-0.4843460023403168,
0.33774977922439575,
0.11739731580018997,
-0.4433172941207886,
-0.028217189013957977,
0.10882523655891418,
-0.039292629808187485,
0.19300399720668793,
0.40887507796287537,
0.4403616786003113,
0.4813319146633148,
-0.6811766028404236,
0.4870823919773102,
-0.060343142598867416,
-0.16425707936286926,
-0.824987530708313,
-0.08631971478462219,
-0.07205789536237717,
0.48795953392982483,
0.31737712025642395,
-0.16894598305225372,
0.2812075912952423,
-0.4026535451412201,
0.22545310854911804,
0.5919991135597229,
-0.9635809659957886,
-0.2309335321187973,
0.4596758782863617,
0.047179847955703735,
-0.10088542103767395,
0.5377853512763977,
-0.16415071487426758,
-0.40487605333328247,
0.4019838571548462,
0.638709306716919,
1.513309121131897,
-0.5195600390434265,
0.15856356918811798,
0.6715927124023438,
0.5911831855773926,
-0.16162392497062683,
0.48992109298706055,
-0.022216346114873886,
-0.9608102440834045,
-0.3990268111228943,
-0.5831872224807739,
-0.6499117016792297,
0.3694396913051605,
-0.5839037299156189,
-0.09796880185604095,
-0.47035250067710876,
0.05405324697494507,
-0.4848180115222931,
0.03619115427136421,
-0.4907890856266022,
0.1004871353507042,
0.23847873508930206,
0.8534848690032959,
-0.518274188041687,
0.933618426322937,
0.36844363808631897,
-0.33157649636268616,
-0.4303165674209595,
0.5431122779846191,
0.1702992022037506,
-0.6530439853668213,
0.5336092710494995,
0.5509908199310303,
-0.6948091983795166,
-0.14259269833564758,
-0.6362816691398621,
-0.7549042105674744,
0.9471572637557983,
0.42744651436805725,
-0.565477192401886,
0.20777861773967743,
-0.19187961518764496,
0.3612535893917084,
-0.4673737585544586,
0.17635269463062286,
0.5156014561653137,
0.5078202486038208,
0.029595524072647095,
-0.4941616356372833,
0.20453430712223053,
-0.1773524284362793,
-0.07294729351997375,
0.02932027354836464,
-0.29497775435447693,
0.7523767948150635,
-0.12395047396421432,
-0.3363458812236786,
0.32958438992500305,
0.8316314220428467,
0.3883945047855377,
0.010163143277168274,
0.6401904821395874,
0.3415668308734894,
0.8840050101280212,
-0.12038199603557587,
1.036699891090393,
-0.6563134789466858,
-0.14005988836288452,
1.614137887954712,
-0.3065022826194763,
1.0017051696777344,
0.6453573107719421,
0.11797161400318146,
0.7562950849533081,
0.6167840957641602,
0.11114419251680374,
0.4695020020008087,
0.14822067320346832,
-0.42674943804740906,
-0.3175099790096283,
0.0032825125381350517,
-0.26094990968704224,
0.3516762852668762,
0.5439671277999878,
-0.2630665898323059,
0.2506444752216339,
-0.2692906856536865,
-0.038029272109270096,
0.24914520978927612,
-0.172397181391716,
0.8015274405479431,
0.1815289855003357,
-0.7377747893333435,
0.3249153792858124,
-0.2916746139526367,
0.8036525249481201,
-0.8564021587371826,
-0.16882602870464325,
-0.3591861128807068,
0.6444992423057556,
-0.1493971198797226,
-0.8379138708114624,
0.012707943096756935,
-0.38749995827674866,
0.38316571712493896,
0.1144818663597107,
0.7484294176101685,
-0.6000164747238159,
-0.5565134286880493,
0.4847281277179718,
0.28637611865997314,
-0.06606319546699524,
-0.545020341873169,
-0.4101036787033081,
-0.05156417191028595,
-0.27481788396835327,
-0.2001495510339737,
0.15691302716732025,
0.32559671998023987,
0.29747578501701355,
0.725898027420044,
0.3196311295032501,
0.1357133388519287,
-0.15479911863803864,
0.00413922592997551,
0.6565988063812256,
-0.49911314249038696,
-0.5075196623802185,
-0.6825085282325745,
0.6576704978942871,
-0.4796123802661896,
-0.46425989270210266,
0.9322314858436584,
0.503841757774353,
0.8657357096672058,
-0.12638717889785767,
0.6316283345222473,
0.4401976764202118,
0.6065699458122253,
-0.47062480449676514,
0.517305850982666,
-0.5171321034431458,
0.07697645574808121,
-0.2971747815608978,
-1.0333284139633179,
-0.24274758994579315,
0.7187362909317017,
0.10340245813131332,
-0.13118232786655426,
1.0191080570220947,
1.1901592016220093,
0.044146034866571426,
-0.17417047917842865,
0.5810601115226746,
0.5364887714385986,
0.05978564918041229,
0.2925461530685425,
0.8649443984031677,
-0.24055729806423187,
0.27414384484291077,
-0.7487330436706543,
-0.22261269390583038,
-0.16248565912246704,
-0.8220394253730774,
-1.1240566968917847,
-0.6711835861206055,
-0.18974092602729797,
-0.46496447920799255,
-0.11233055591583252,
1.0150820016860962,
0.6490386724472046,
-1.066054344177246,
-0.6063340306282043,
-0.09793055802583694,
-0.04505657032132149,
-0.35768193006515503,
-0.2622142434120178,
0.19969256222248077,
-0.6121742725372314,
-0.8356366753578186,
0.776565670967102,
0.4742635488510132,
-0.09016668796539307,
-0.6014067530632019,
-0.19987356662750244,
-0.09983182698488235,
0.2259337157011032,
0.5601311922073364,
0.1107553020119667,
-0.868800938129425,
-0.26351025700569153,
-0.20092834532260895,
-0.1696333885192871,
0.09267382323741913,
0.6391870975494385,
-0.8113996386528015,
0.5841239094734192,
0.42269840836524963,
0.7441508769989014,
0.5392891764640808,
-0.09403328597545624,
0.4492667019367218,
-0.7989572882652283,
0.3842037618160248,
0.2814282178878784,
0.4514721930027008,
0.6370657086372375,
-0.5455164313316345,
0.7655321955680847,
-0.12781953811645508,
-0.46291181445121765,
-0.9339250326156616,
0.1857604831457138,
-0.7175029516220093,
-0.3576565682888031,
0.9555812478065491,
0.19889357686042786,
-0.07070127874612808,
-0.11447394639253616,
-0.04180658981204033,
0.027446452528238297,
-0.43998125195503235,
0.8668639063835144,
0.44510048627853394,
-0.17963474988937378,
-0.36032769083976746,
-0.4699203372001648,
0.7630462050437927,
0.30566343665122986,
-1.0437873601913452,
-0.26764440536499023,
0.40145209431648254,
0.15870310366153717,
0.18876244127750397,
0.3616737723350525,
-0.08939453214406967,
0.05580780282616615,
-0.10175435245037079,
0.20835445821285248,
0.07125860452651978,
-0.4278194010257721,
-0.45323824882507324,
0.4323834180831909,
-0.02239164337515831,
-0.23759837448596954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12052v1
|
UniGLM: Training One Unified Language Model for Text-Attributed Graphs
| 2024-06-17T19:45:21 | 2024-06-17T19:45:21 |
Yi Fang, Dongzhe Fan, Sirui Ding, Ninghao Liu, Qiaoyu Tan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Representation learning on text-attributed graphs (TAGs), where nodes are
represented by textual descriptions, is crucial for textual and relational
knowledge systems and recommendation systems. Currently, state-of-the-art
embedding methods for TAGs primarily focus on fine-tuning language models
(e.g., BERT) using structure-aware training signals. While effective, these
methods are tailored for individual TAG and cannot generalize across various
graph scenarios. Given the shared textual space, leveraging multiple TAGs for
joint fine-tuning, aligning text and graph structure from different aspects,
would be more beneficial. Motivated by this, we introduce a novel Unified Graph
Language Model (UniGLM) framework, the first graph embedding model that
generalizes well to both in-domain and cross-domain TAGs. Specifically, UniGLM
is trained over multiple TAGs with different domains and scales using
self-supervised contrastive learning. UniGLM includes an adaptive positive
sample selection technique for identifying structurally similar nodes and a
lazy contrastive module that is devised to accelerate training by minimizing
repetitive encoding calculations. Extensive empirical results across 9
benchmark TAGs demonstrate UniGLM's efficacy against leading embedding
baselines in terms of generalization (various downstream tasks and backbones)
and transfer learning (in and out of domain scenarios). The code is available
at https://github.com/NYUSHCS/UniGLM.
|
[
-0.04683592915534973,
-0.48770031332969666,
0.2556801438331604,
-0.08278965204954147,
-0.583695650100708,
0.5691559910774231,
-0.005153476260602474,
-0.20775893330574036,
0.10475246608257294,
0.5046115517616272,
-0.21991586685180664,
-0.896912693977356,
-0.34045854210853577,
-0.285473495721817,
-0.14846259355545044,
1.15518057346344,
-0.12358029186725616,
0.13251623511314392,
-0.30200114846229553,
-0.3926892876625061,
-0.3053748905658722,
-0.5724553465843201,
-0.360564649105072,
-0.8613842725753784,
0.5374715924263,
0.0770966187119484,
0.3969254493713379,
0.4519350528717041,
0.3361847996711731,
0.2214130163192749,
0.13267159461975098,
0.4256959557533264,
-0.5151368975639343,
-0.1805965006351471,
-0.24299749732017517,
0.13619479537010193,
-0.3296612501144409,
-0.11068715900182724,
0.707425057888031,
1.1355304718017578,
-0.08023873716592789,
0.011092266999185085,
0.3915540874004364,
0.5190138816833496,
-0.3643236756324768,
0.18589890003204346,
-0.765631377696991,
-0.1504143625497818,
-0.04602700471878052,
0.047093749046325684,
-0.6691957116127014,
-0.006835657637566328,
0.07139578461647034,
-0.7077556252479553,
0.10800493508577347,
0.2548983097076416,
0.891523540019989,
0.15746618807315826,
-0.6041277647018433,
-0.06591829657554626,
-0.2747012674808502,
0.5060259699821472,
-0.411060631275177,
0.5205777883529663,
0.20314881205558777,
0.04538339748978615,
-0.21116553246974945,
-1.1618187427520752,
-0.058836452662944794,
0.0666131004691124,
-0.426748663187027,
-0.06576700508594513,
-0.4302283227443695,
0.22875691950321198,
-0.3313854932785034,
0.03438000753521919,
-0.6494074463844299,
0.24699847400188446,
-0.11712141335010529,
-0.23532944917678833,
0.35711029171943665,
-0.031938426196575165,
0.26235297322273254,
-0.026326097548007965,
-0.8004239201545715,
0.19571907818317413,
-0.6446724534034729,
-0.10418383777141571,
0.28960269689559937,
0.6604437828063965,
0.08729838579893112,
0.2477729171514511,
-0.013644651509821415,
0.7332600951194763,
-0.25508445501327515,
0.36802855134010315,
0.40248003602027893,
-0.034952983260154724,
-0.4774811863899231,
-0.08134550601243973,
0.9711069464683533,
0.2252519428730011,
0.34386318922042847,
-0.5448370575904846,
-0.07016763091087341,
0.1748458594083786,
0.20290054380893707,
-0.636908233165741,
-0.6621149778366089,
-0.19179758429527283,
-0.35851210355758667,
-0.12456455081701279,
0.05338296666741371,
-0.4717143476009369,
-0.2704847455024719,
-0.008825251832604408,
0.30744627118110657,
-0.3636217415332794,
-0.11431464552879333,
0.204012930393219,
-0.19368278980255127,
-0.3165777623653412,
0.07098724693059921,
-0.6445416808128357,
0.3797875940799713,
0.39522436261177063,
0.7346014380455017,
-0.16512706875801086,
-0.47852271795272827,
-0.296431303024292,
0.3533952832221985,
-0.17055974900722504,
1.0459215641021729,
-0.8020693063735962,
-0.33683526515960693,
0.14243634045124054,
0.11853998154401779,
-0.1852751225233078,
-0.042855728417634964,
0.6131343841552734,
-0.5037587881088257,
0.0015527349896728992,
-0.03686158359050751,
-0.8169459700584412,
-0.3081008791923523,
0.08202347159385681,
-0.5642110705375671,
1.2150152921676636,
0.3900357186794281,
-0.9574462175369263,
0.25940898060798645,
-0.6613801121711731,
-0.5327407121658325,
0.2740272283554077,
-0.07827090471982956,
-0.4635952413082123,
-0.13108493387699127,
0.24471279978752136,
0.6798402667045593,
-0.27710190415382385,
0.14674563705921173,
-0.5430617332458496,
-0.29292261600494385,
-0.0000803611328592524,
-0.16304334998130798,
0.712187647819519,
0.13906054198741913,
0.15886233747005463,
0.17436686158180237,
-0.6686818599700928,
0.331394225358963,
0.2895611822605133,
-0.23406340181827545,
-0.7722315192222595,
-0.10689667612314224,
0.24526602029800415,
-0.12500089406967163,
0.1762377768754959,
-0.8527939915657043,
0.40715062618255615,
-0.3585292100906372,
0.6170979738235474,
0.7149759531021118,
-0.025164010003209114,
0.3702445924282074,
-0.10106459259986877,
0.12530037760734558,
-0.18425370752811432,
-0.21560968458652496,
-0.3430391252040863,
-0.34929633140563965,
-0.35673072934150696,
-0.4294101297855377,
0.5986201167106628,
0.12003462761640549,
-0.5841761827468872,
0.4498809278011322,
-0.2761550545692444,
-0.45185837149620056,
-0.6196663975715637,
0.3215026259422302,
0.7325226068496704,
0.5341293811798096,
0.4066774845123291,
-0.40839675068855286,
-0.5153165459632874,
-0.5257067084312439,
-0.31727349758148193,
-0.11963025480508804,
0.15895196795463562,
0.20245271921157837,
0.4144485294818878,
-0.45593735575675964,
0.9426103234291077,
-0.7197457551956177,
-0.7146826982498169,
-0.17483894526958466,
0.3778170943260193,
-0.04862460866570473,
0.44410911202430725,
0.652622640132904,
-0.624708354473114,
-0.8513829708099365,
0.30588632822036743,
-0.6078262329101562,
-0.062496643513441086,
0.1655178666114807,
-0.09721407294273376,
0.2027612328529358,
0.40880677103996277,
-0.29068219661712646,
0.2701469659805298,
0.6986100077629089,
-0.45854732394218445,
-0.021594781428575516,
-0.5227177143096924,
-0.32633963227272034,
-0.9747087359428406,
0.05360133573412895,
-0.05136656388640404,
-0.5187392830848694,
-0.4805331230163574,
-0.022759851068258286,
0.10232077538967133,
0.0006815558299422264,
-0.12684562802314758,
0.659646213054657,
-0.758732259273529,
-0.05915220454335213,
-0.13969938457012177,
0.225568026304245,
0.31582197546958923,
0.7861712574958801,
-0.32241290807724,
0.3799290955066681,
0.7574082612991333,
-0.348025918006897,
0.2812878489494324,
0.23040664196014404,
-0.14160428941249847,
0.4614838659763336,
-0.7113066911697388,
0.4605240225791931,
-0.10310107469558716,
0.22780129313468933,
-1.4496846199035645,
0.0010403391206637025,
0.06917934864759445,
-0.4533984661102295,
0.5432159304618835,
-0.4418652057647705,
-0.4227132797241211,
-0.46354109048843384,
-0.17215083539485931,
0.2733732759952545,
0.4368831515312195,
-0.8656421303749084,
0.7493236660957336,
0.6090193390846252,
0.2765715420246124,
-0.6143366694450378,
-0.6487277150154114,
-0.2589794099330902,
0.055710550397634506,
-0.34502488374710083,
0.48386621475219727,
-0.041597891598939896,
0.4119691550731659,
0.534525454044342,
-0.03743588551878929,
-0.20222890377044678,
0.2283363789319992,
0.3631118834018707,
0.0975390300154686,
0.08859650790691376,
0.5486844778060913,
0.15093833208084106,
-0.32866138219833374,
-0.2562766969203949,
-0.839268147945404,
0.6698969006538391,
-0.17112529277801514,
-0.5408002734184265,
-0.17697404325008392,
0.37258583307266235,
0.20314708352088928,
-0.4791976809501648,
0.4239145815372467,
0.7177960276603699,
-0.32166656851768494,
-0.48807772994041443,
0.0032482142560184,
0.34439924359321594,
-0.4577704668045044,
0.5209550857543945,
-0.32066813111305237,
-1.0175507068634033,
0.520111083984375,
-0.4845934212207794,
-0.017223043367266655,
0.42700985074043274,
0.43873846530914307,
-0.30675771832466125,
1.1782398223876953,
0.8539304733276367,
-0.23968000710010529,
0.37431600689888,
-0.2921384871006012,
0.07716862112283707,
-0.9639227986335754,
-0.33532699942588806,
-0.49536654353141785,
-0.1770448088645935,
-0.5232030749320984,
-0.40873992443084717,
-0.010671762749552727,
0.18971651792526245,
-0.4637947380542755,
0.22456791996955872,
-0.9067586064338684,
0.7474861741065979,
0.3024648129940033,
-0.05976032838225365,
0.3120889961719513,
0.2518988847732544,
-0.6573629975318909,
0.10237863659858704,
-0.698688268661499,
-0.4154518246650696,
1.2409874200820923,
0.23426030576229095,
1.2385042905807495,
-0.16758482158184052,
0.6112613081932068,
0.5191089510917664,
0.6058028340339661,
-0.5651726126670837,
0.19775784015655518,
-0.7169901132583618,
-0.3398451507091522,
-0.2085573971271515,
-0.32228749990463257,
-1.1762287616729736,
0.414593905210495,
-0.054325170814991,
-0.9033743143081665,
-0.11048220098018646,
0.2335064709186554,
0.03352363407611847,
0.5881461501121521,
-0.6986562609672546,
0.9445176124572754,
-0.23823244869709015,
0.10289506614208221,
0.23788946866989136,
-0.651475727558136,
-0.28519320487976074,
0.05443419888615608,
0.11365287750959396,
-0.33206844329833984,
0.11313535273075104,
0.6401174068450928,
0.0889345109462738,
1.0938661098480225,
-0.14523008465766907,
0.19613368809223175,
0.2862885892391205,
0.10954906046390533,
0.5106990337371826,
-0.06799742579460144,
0.14612352848052979,
0.2824515402317047,
-0.21406400203704834,
-0.38723430037498474,
-0.43406596779823303,
0.7405543923377991,
-0.9350813031196594,
-0.11426610499620438,
-0.280986487865448,
-0.5860416889190674,
-0.2664806544780731,
0.5368853211402893,
0.2563561499118805,
0.626752495765686,
-0.6491040587425232,
0.1301966905593872,
0.49624353647232056,
0.27775225043296814,
0.3595246970653534,
0.37936487793922424,
-0.4318684935569763,
-0.4843290150165558,
0.9139113426208496,
0.01296385657042265,
0.0973077118396759,
0.5572512149810791,
0.14671777188777924,
-0.4284892976284027,
-0.5186101794242859,
-0.3997892141342163,
0.3211899995803833,
-0.9979997277259827,
-0.5239192843437195,
-0.832144021987915,
-0.022129463031888008,
-0.5235605835914612,
-0.24143551290035248,
-0.35042423009872437,
-0.2862265706062317,
-0.3936396837234497,
-0.2383458912372589,
0.23423241078853607,
1.037102460861206,
0.09919174760580063,
0.44023242592811584,
-0.5648308396339417,
0.011722489260137081,
0.2175690233707428,
0.7236849665641785,
-0.16861675679683685,
-0.42321696877479553,
-0.2851506173610687,
-0.03048897162079811,
-0.16610462963581085,
-0.782940685749054,
0.30423247814178467,
0.4133084714412689,
0.8917093276977539,
0.2720429599285126,
0.07253921777009964,
0.4042621850967407,
-0.5999994874000549,
0.3878757059574127,
0.35304030776023865,
-0.9293370842933655,
0.12943489849567413,
-0.3008202016353607,
0.04813773185014725,
0.4374341666698456,
0.5997246503829956,
-0.5005775094032288,
-0.0947267934679985,
-0.46582895517349243,
-0.6731534600257874,
0.4031268358230591,
-0.10953453928232193,
0.3388824760913849,
0.1153060644865036,
0.28247812390327454,
-0.0194537416100502,
0.122309610247612,
-0.8793200850486755,
-0.48490360379219055,
-0.30852141976356506,
-0.4773794114589691,
-0.07761484384536743,
-0.12208078056573868,
-0.27253517508506775,
-0.3813897967338562,
0.5071825385093689,
-0.6520698070526123,
0.36090782284736633,
0.13224314153194427,
-0.23399950563907623,
-0.14631423354148865,
0.1669219732284546,
-0.11554262787103653,
0.5038440227508545,
-0.1649027168750763,
0.42940279841423035,
0.0674675852060318,
-0.08667733520269394,
0.039483442902565,
0.3802371025085449,
-0.11650387197732925,
0.13717912137508392,
0.37671878933906555,
0.9309242367744446,
0.3241438567638397,
-0.33448997139930725,
0.4247702658176422,
0.058389026671648026,
-0.12691067159175873,
0.22438789904117584,
-0.3313233554363251,
0.2554166615009308,
0.009224358946084976,
0.2818812131881714,
-0.10981921851634979,
0.02404676377773285,
-0.555927038192749,
0.3503379821777344,
0.7026035189628601,
-0.8054250478744507,
-0.3178897500038147,
0.6035868525505066,
0.2813308835029602,
-0.22220084071159363,
0.4302482306957245,
-0.5101935863494873,
-0.820701003074646,
0.24671457707881927,
0.9629186391830444,
0.8253519535064697,
-0.21840880811214447,
0.5580309629440308,
0.07416171580553055,
0.22311708331108093,
0.3133751153945923,
0.1046445295214653,
0.2169131189584732,
-0.8564753532409668,
-0.10649368911981583,
-0.5657634735107422,
-0.20363877713680267,
-0.4905109703540802,
-0.5391587615013123,
-0.017231561243534088,
-0.4062667191028595,
-0.05943208932876587,
0.19065620005130768,
0.018341904506087303,
-0.6187281012535095,
-0.003341902978718281,
-0.029665615409612656,
0.5939640402793884,
-1.03797447681427,
1.1286619901657104,
1.1645511388778687,
-0.39521166682243347,
-0.8291945457458496,
-0.40871453285217285,
-0.22732141613960266,
-1.0136491060256958,
0.4850182831287384,
0.10187956690788269,
-0.22218352556228638,
0.37501060962677,
-0.6678704023361206,
-0.8093087077140808,
1.0315401554107666,
0.5064608454704285,
-0.1932397186756134,
-0.04974754899740219,
-0.0018134359270334244,
0.6605998277664185,
-0.948463499546051,
0.04128716140985489,
0.23104876279830933,
0.08740926533937454,
0.1692475527524948,
-0.6483398675918579,
0.11390793323516846,
-0.1691451370716095,
0.06815078854560852,
0.5540677905082703,
-0.6653509140014648,
0.9942736029624939,
-0.2865341007709503,
-0.4477778673171997,
-0.06130354851484299,
0.4843951165676117,
-0.1998041570186615,
0.17545509338378906,
0.30322515964508057,
0.7488127946853638,
1.1152316331863403,
-0.13380086421966553,
1.0187902450561523,
-0.19156070053577423,
0.8680484890937805,
1.3036785125732422,
-0.38472920656204224,
0.5479837656021118,
0.15971975028514862,
0.004541453439742327,
0.9147018790245056,
0.519831120967865,
-0.07227658480405807,
0.6783766746520996,
0.05818900465965271,
0.09869709610939026,
-0.39707937836647034,
-0.4866779148578644,
-0.29257139563560486,
0.3352876305580139,
0.17424915730953217,
-0.3864137828350067,
-0.546321451663971,
-0.03157762065529823,
0.09795472025871277,
0.25852155685424805,
-0.19917993247509003,
0.6936245560646057,
0.03626829758286476,
-0.21231698989868164,
0.43695539236068726,
0.011287933215498924,
0.4520350694656372,
-0.7609225511550903,
-0.11991038173437119,
-0.10783553868532181,
0.27074599266052246,
-0.09212519228458405,
-0.8786348700523376,
-0.08289725333452225,
-0.18391261994838715,
-0.00358417141251266,
-0.2185637354850769,
1.0848164558410645,
-0.6450477838516235,
-0.41775745153427124,
0.7887896299362183,
0.3737618327140808,
-0.11911015957593918,
0.06257190555334091,
-0.8104208111763,
-0.14614154398441315,
0.04998735338449478,
-0.00124997622333467,
0.3203047513961792,
0.6475470662117004,
-0.03600621223449707,
0.6829364895820618,
0.6986035108566284,
-0.15775805711746216,
-0.07608868181705475,
0.38563528656959534,
1.2916722297668457,
-0.424450546503067,
-0.5609630346298218,
-0.7050726413726807,
0.5045025944709778,
-0.12113600224256516,
-0.3383648991584778,
0.7472624182701111,
0.37416574358940125,
0.9510720372200012,
0.2635860741138458,
0.6754376292228699,
0.14583361148834229,
0.3528273105621338,
-0.37848958373069763,
0.6783345937728882,
-0.6322228908538818,
-0.08701128512620926,
-0.3564857840538025,
-0.7087845802307129,
-0.533891499042511,
0.49913665652275085,
0.22665870189666748,
0.042330361902713776,
0.7600031495094299,
0.42784592509269714,
0.020076744258403778,
-0.2728703022003174,
0.3740227520465851,
0.08644923567771912,
0.21068093180656433,
0.69783616065979,
0.5797897577285767,
-0.37231600284576416,
0.5912858843803406,
0.04198885336518288,
-0.03292911872267723,
-0.001937215798534453,
-0.9138278365135193,
-1.3260059356689453,
-0.6921257376670837,
-0.20445294678211212,
-0.1153239756822586,
0.027438197284936905,
0.848680853843689,
0.6731249690055847,
-0.5849822759628296,
0.00016358328866772354,
0.0501372367143631,
0.3108046352863312,
-0.024458425119519234,
-0.10245472937822342,
0.5926041603088379,
-0.3770133852958679,
-0.46455278992652893,
0.18717801570892334,
0.44451895356178284,
0.18553614616394043,
-0.1721358746290207,
-0.11185499280691147,
-0.3951447308063507,
-0.0867554321885109,
0.3672294318675995,
0.16378425061702728,
-0.4600687623023987,
-0.4979608654975891,
-0.13746771216392517,
-0.2323375940322876,
0.28349483013153076,
0.9961729049682617,
-0.6854248642921448,
0.6814091205596924,
0.3999685049057007,
0.7631142139434814,
0.49979424476623535,
0.04462961107492447,
0.23941895365715027,
-1.2854830026626587,
0.10120254755020142,
0.11957984417676926,
0.6892748475074768,
0.5472007393836975,
-0.27219024300575256,
0.6499622464179993,
0.3486621677875519,
-0.4895789623260498,
-0.9508277773857117,
0.2329959124326706,
-0.9567865133285522,
-0.5112090110778809,
0.9646028280258179,
-0.5689875483512878,
-0.04930046200752258,
-0.3658354580402374,
-0.14343757927417755,
0.4874725341796875,
-0.33504220843315125,
0.27896347641944885,
0.4349219799041748,
0.005129445344209671,
0.15269871056079865,
0.1786966472864151,
0.27386409044265747,
0.0895102471113205,
-0.6479593515396118,
0.316987007856369,
0.2750522196292877,
0.33756184577941895,
0.15867163240909576,
0.8702159523963928,
0.16335946321487427,
-0.16805709898471832,
-0.02792590670287609,
0.227412611246109,
-0.431298166513443,
-0.5165783762931824,
-0.31315964460372925,
0.21347415447235107,
0.045702386647462845,
-0.16431763768196106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12050v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12050v1
|
Learn Beyond The Answer: Training Language Models with Reflection for Mathematical Reasoning
| 2024-06-17T19:42:22 | 2024-06-17T19:42:22 |
Zhihan Zhang, Zhenwen Liang, Wenhao Yu, Dian Yu, Mengzhao Jia, Dong Yu, Meng Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Supervised fine-tuning enhances the problem-solving abilities of language
models across various mathematical reasoning tasks. To maximize such benefits,
existing research focuses on broadening the training set with various data
augmentation techniques, which is effective for standard single-round
question-answering settings. Our work introduces a novel technique aimed at
cultivating a deeper understanding of the training problems at hand, enhancing
performance not only in standard settings but also in more complex scenarios
that require reflective thinking. Specifically, we propose reflective
augmentation, a method that embeds problem reflection into each training
instance. It trains the model to consider alternative perspectives and engage
with abstractions and analogies, thereby fostering a thorough comprehension
through reflective reasoning. Extensive experiments validate the achievement of
our aim, underscoring the unique advantages of our method and its complementary
nature relative to existing augmentation techniques.
|
[
-0.6986573934555054,
-0.8415893912315369,
0.6401121020317078,
-0.021264616400003433,
-0.06521264463663101,
0.28702637553215027,
-0.39102035760879517,
-0.36441770195961,
-0.08900213241577148,
0.802979588508606,
-0.915663480758667,
-0.20649339258670807,
-0.4672330915927887,
-0.09918053448200226,
-0.1471177488565445,
1.0523426532745361,
-0.013475276529788971,
0.3407358229160309,
-0.5410792827606201,
-0.04469049721956253,
-0.4811968207359314,
-0.25061288475990295,
-0.49070900678634644,
-0.37727823853492737,
0.17594300210475922,
0.4732210338115692,
0.5186073780059814,
0.2622436583042145,
0.5330222249031067,
0.2969845235347748,
0.2001437246799469,
0.7606183290481567,
-0.48426640033721924,
0.22305981814861298,
-0.2230508178472519,
-0.8400689959526062,
-0.1528913676738739,
0.14088675379753113,
0.641829252243042,
1.126644253730774,
-0.15672461688518524,
0.3321102559566498,
0.03428938612341881,
0.7785643935203552,
-0.7633547782897949,
0.3017933666706085,
-0.7256893515586853,
0.1029684916138649,
0.21069037914276123,
-0.05486099421977997,
-0.3420465886592865,
-0.6396899223327637,
0.1837443858385086,
-0.8373661637306213,
0.25675395131111145,
-0.3758285641670227,
0.40144258737564087,
0.348696231842041,
-0.21446506679058075,
0.0412958525121212,
-0.7547814846038818,
0.8972794413566589,
-0.6206163167953491,
0.34368565678596497,
0.34894445538520813,
0.38089972734451294,
0.1511453539133072,
-0.520514190196991,
-0.4749998152256012,
-0.0410202331840992,
-0.12465772032737732,
0.23367191851139069,
0.339129775762558,
0.07966644316911697,
0.5478813648223877,
0.47889459133148193,
-0.37760016322135925,
-0.5620306134223938,
-0.4804627001285553,
0.22596167027950287,
0.7693513631820679,
0.20336326956748962,
0.19309063255786896,
0.38327959179878235,
0.10796751081943512,
-0.01089579425752163,
-0.5588564276695251,
0.13667377829551697,
0.16942521929740906,
0.41389450430870056,
0.41313421726226807,
0.37658706307411194,
-0.27826935052871704,
0.863027811050415,
-0.06504295766353607,
0.24633890390396118,
0.20888637006282806,
-0.20511870086193085,
0.026245955377817154,
-0.08741144835948944,
0.11820784956216812,
0.17620861530303955,
0.49860769510269165,
-0.19224844872951508,
-0.206222802400589,
0.10199888795614243,
0.44006437063217163,
-0.768114447593689,
-0.37575989961624146,
-0.030419042333960533,
-0.046840328723192215,
-0.3254329264163971,
0.22506017982959747,
-0.6263144612312317,
-0.19494567811489105,
-0.8509863615036011,
0.5406582355499268,
-0.29820603132247925,
-0.5692062973976135,
0.55417799949646,
-0.12057637423276901,
0.09904143959283829,
0.4777015447616577,
-0.9766743779182434,
0.5588216781616211,
1.0507010221481323,
0.5282822847366333,
0.28683409094810486,
-0.13950034976005554,
-0.7308579683303833,
0.057955075055360794,
-0.6520542502403259,
0.8214857578277588,
-0.951336145401001,
-0.3394981622695923,
0.18721704185009003,
-0.12609460949897766,
-0.1058155819773674,
-0.7362568378448486,
0.39449891448020935,
-0.5598470568656921,
0.581104040145874,
-0.4158453643321991,
-0.55438631772995,
-0.413178950548172,
0.3662309944629669,
-0.4962083101272583,
1.3305329084396362,
0.2627192735671997,
-0.4139930307865143,
0.3561173379421234,
-0.9099170565605164,
-0.35334011912345886,
0.09442158043384552,
-0.12926514446735382,
-0.338527649641037,
0.49157455563545227,
0.5843616724014282,
0.21958166360855103,
-0.03547578305006027,
0.06052783504128456,
-0.5194224715232849,
-0.3371734619140625,
0.18125459551811218,
-0.2643842399120331,
0.6992426514625549,
0.003957108128815889,
-0.07615868747234344,
-0.09933992475271225,
-0.7843518853187561,
0.4567711353302002,
0.0411413311958313,
0.08018280565738678,
-0.542834997177124,
-0.17690452933311462,
-0.26203933358192444,
0.2617470324039459,
0.23160699009895325,
-0.7568572759628296,
0.35050734877586365,
-0.8074318170547485,
0.1246994286775589,
0.6360333561897278,
0.10310324281454086,
0.387991338968277,
-0.45354393124580383,
0.47807472944259644,
-0.06730860471725464,
0.19049225747585297,
-0.35007625818252563,
-0.3245353698730469,
-0.8450414538383484,
0.019524922594428062,
0.01466588769108057,
0.6546126008033752,
-0.933070182800293,
-0.1624777913093567,
-0.15500010550022125,
-0.3366526961326599,
-1.0503966808319092,
0.4337349534034729,
0.6420890092849731,
0.8394902348518372,
0.694896936416626,
-0.13174191117286682,
-0.733944296836853,
-0.8044033050537109,
-0.47480955719947815,
0.2756718695163727,
-0.015814118087291718,
0.3690641224384308,
0.49617800116539,
0.20225319266319275,
0.8932833671569824,
-1.0275126695632935,
-0.1409284770488739,
-0.07897919416427612,
0.13690215349197388,
0.2559691071510315,
0.6507492661476135,
0.2658475339412689,
-0.8471354246139526,
-0.5353366732597351,
-0.019036831334233284,
-0.9227995872497559,
0.16898919641971588,
-0.15127761662006378,
-0.035343483090400696,
-0.11559008806943893,
0.4036654233932495,
-0.29970017075538635,
0.3286552131175995,
0.0793440043926239,
-0.007466305512934923,
0.515527606010437,
-0.301439493894577,
0.28134971857070923,
-0.808585524559021,
-0.25597724318504333,
0.12899149954319,
-0.2789800763130188,
-0.8317315578460693,
0.33539432287216187,
-0.130174458026886,
-0.10783916711807251,
-0.29387685656547546,
0.42876777052879333,
-0.4523695707321167,
0.21830840408802032,
-0.30851373076438904,
0.3368696868419647,
0.28791606426239014,
0.2694983184337616,
0.27160340547561646,
1.1170604228973389,
0.6167486906051636,
-0.48027223348617554,
0.33674898743629456,
0.38239455223083496,
-0.5417284965515137,
0.6213948130607605,
-0.7249014973640442,
0.3493189811706543,
-0.4254969358444214,
-0.08009130507707596,
-1.0503818988800049,
-0.014894112944602966,
-0.07528501003980637,
-0.505267858505249,
0.2663501501083374,
-0.09426224231719971,
-0.3474506735801697,
-0.33514493703842163,
-0.3627919852733612,
0.515310525894165,
0.5294930338859558,
-0.674326479434967,
0.5786324739456177,
0.3100934624671936,
-0.17176203429698944,
-0.5814894437789917,
-0.7900446057319641,
-0.03465273976325989,
-0.13245870172977448,
-0.7403492331504822,
0.07159288227558136,
-0.09330334514379501,
-0.48357802629470825,
-0.23790013790130615,
-0.04086783900856972,
-0.2107921540737152,
0.12886746227741241,
-0.1493442952632904,
0.3204108476638794,
-0.33096736669540405,
0.28131401538848877,
0.32873696088790894,
-0.29146939516067505,
0.31199386715888977,
-0.3374183475971222,
0.30557864904403687,
-0.38488680124282837,
-0.4432215690612793,
-0.296741783618927,
0.6694527864456177,
0.03726343810558319,
-0.6603537797927856,
0.8296814560890198,
0.4732440710067749,
-0.4128357470035553,
-0.4780939221382141,
-0.7260899543762207,
-0.5471658706665039,
-0.5228512287139893,
0.3770139515399933,
-0.607940137386322,
-0.7844688892364502,
0.5936006903648376,
-0.12298647314310074,
0.11578959226608276,
-0.013200716115534306,
0.222167506814003,
-0.19204701483249664,
1.6243735551834106,
0.6275192499160767,
0.45498237013816833,
0.5015120506286621,
-0.5563738942146301,
0.1700330525636673,
-1.2121107578277588,
-0.22593024373054504,
-0.21156033873558044,
-0.01845407858490944,
-0.2875524163246155,
-0.4154181480407715,
0.38569754362106323,
-0.001775676035322249,
-0.2579304575920105,
0.14252792298793793,
-0.7453897595405579,
0.7544865608215332,
0.3555012047290802,
0.5602652430534363,
0.4498976767063141,
-0.2361467182636261,
0.14350482821464539,
-0.2951469123363495,
-0.4505910575389862,
-0.39800265431404114,
1.0722346305847168,
0.08769696205854416,
0.502528190612793,
-0.07735894620418549,
0.6370487809181213,
-0.29349759221076965,
0.6133699417114258,
-0.6114406585693359,
0.4905194342136383,
-0.11258837580680847,
-0.8190332651138306,
-0.3097097873687744,
-0.3376244902610779,
-0.5438697338104248,
0.5491071343421936,
-0.09353882819414139,
-0.5643408298492432,
-0.01543383114039898,
0.06913897395133972,
-0.45208579301834106,
0.2229127585887909,
-0.6354895830154419,
0.684451162815094,
-0.03513730317354202,
-0.3800768554210663,
-0.34826958179473877,
-0.4789193272590637,
0.4807610511779785,
0.09458331763744354,
0.2800655961036682,
0.24345971643924713,
-0.11688142269849777,
0.3491526246070862,
-0.34782320261001587,
0.7147870063781738,
-0.4531624913215637,
-0.31718993186950684,
0.3341507017612457,
0.186594620347023,
0.32661211490631104,
0.28207114338874817,
-0.015189362689852715,
-0.3007623851299286,
0.14937724173069,
-0.5430834889411926,
-1.3704032897949219,
0.4739070534706116,
-0.3450413942337036,
-0.9059725403785706,
-0.14029821753501892,
-0.8699333667755127,
-0.7504134178161621,
0.1233733743429184,
-0.2148483693599701,
0.5227536559104919,
0.10928099602460861,
0.06818898767232895,
1.3163713216781616,
0.16613736748695374,
0.1460740864276886,
0.47627967596054077,
-0.42764273285865784,
-0.40327388048171997,
0.9864413738250732,
0.15025243163108826,
0.5212631225585938,
0.341473251581192,
0.10393782705068588,
-0.3336356282234192,
-0.5060722827911377,
-0.3221678137779236,
0.14389967918395996,
-0.7551208138465881,
-0.0033806641586124897,
-0.33077460527420044,
-0.18158139288425446,
-0.36599797010421753,
-0.04582015052437782,
-0.39219754934310913,
-0.7349779009819031,
-0.24950839579105377,
-0.2783735692501068,
0.319267213344574,
0.4218105375766754,
-0.003778393380343914,
0.12713685631752014,
-0.8349265456199646,
0.23311841487884521,
0.5221545100212097,
0.47793200612068176,
0.07998441159725189,
-0.5850207805633545,
-0.24262374639511108,
0.5343220829963684,
-0.3189421594142914,
-0.5069048404693604,
0.10919393599033356,
0.34188762307167053,
0.5602644085884094,
0.34105053544044495,
-0.02707287110388279,
0.9186644554138184,
-0.6706437468528748,
0.6510661244392395,
0.02109174244105816,
-0.9738101959228516,
0.8144974708557129,
-0.3651134669780731,
0.21752284467220306,
0.9851752519607544,
0.2549477219581604,
-0.3288130462169647,
-0.41576969623565674,
-0.51517254114151,
-0.40665334463119507,
0.4655899703502655,
-0.128181591629982,
0.5483853816986084,
0.008298824541270733,
0.6920550465583801,
0.15620218217372894,
0.3263554573059082,
-0.5175727009773254,
-0.14966285228729248,
-0.2501857578754425,
-0.220686137676239,
-0.17236363887786865,
0.19960086047649384,
-0.4443107843399048,
-0.7906731367111206,
0.7828376293182373,
-0.3804008364677429,
-0.024857988581061363,
0.20123443007469177,
-0.11084362119436264,
-0.17969182133674622,
-0.05033544450998306,
0.6786917448043823,
0.9192214012145996,
-0.007063501048833132,
0.06774529069662094,
0.5684036016464233,
-0.34435853362083435,
-0.12580369412899017,
0.06584139168262482,
-0.06690848618745804,
-0.13192938268184662,
0.36847540736198425,
0.6276367902755737,
0.16791361570358276,
-0.7350345253944397,
0.39535853266716003,
0.1643226593732834,
-0.39120304584503174,
-0.28477048873901367,
0.42970091104507446,
-0.13891983032226562,
0.2975580394268036,
0.43020114302635193,
0.07215162366628647,
0.39968082308769226,
-0.5460779666900635,
0.33462658524513245,
0.7856512069702148,
-0.6756010055541992,
-0.19857890903949738,
0.418699711561203,
-0.2366117686033249,
-0.28555527329444885,
0.5071221590042114,
-0.003926683217287064,
-0.6828000545501709,
0.5009069442749023,
0.6191282868385315,
0.7003324627876282,
-0.20923905074596405,
0.32438912987709045,
0.3686031699180603,
0.2144477814435959,
-0.13016009330749512,
0.6263598799705505,
-0.3816242814064026,
-0.7256738543510437,
-0.8987811207771301,
-0.14713285863399506,
-0.4141036868095398,
-0.14664463698863983,
-1.0932000875473022,
-0.05583934113383293,
-0.38312146067619324,
0.14378321170806885,
-0.05044819414615631,
0.17989280819892883,
-0.36563175916671753,
0.34398153424263,
0.06720393896102905,
0.9224450588226318,
-0.8719437122344971,
0.553479790687561,
0.7951853275299072,
-0.6001746654510498,
-0.7092039585113525,
-0.2835604250431061,
-0.36998251080513,
-0.9594225287437439,
0.6147865653038025,
0.1421898603439331,
-0.3730891942977905,
-0.026729194447398186,
-0.8515713214874268,
-0.6085682511329651,
0.6759195327758789,
0.43604210019111633,
-0.21692180633544922,
0.10086703300476074,
0.2694751024246216,
0.7246248722076416,
-0.42648324370384216,
0.42411303520202637,
0.6666373610496521,
0.4843451678752899,
0.251877099275589,
-0.7194222211837769,
0.03746221587061882,
-0.38181233406066895,
0.16304045915603638,
0.3815096616744995,
-0.5612192749977112,
0.6186599731445312,
-0.33329564332962036,
0.06550358235836029,
0.004911031574010849,
0.6534196734428406,
0.15022984147071838,
0.3105507791042328,
0.2791093587875366,
0.7773467898368835,
0.6574041843414307,
-0.1782698929309845,
0.863467812538147,
-0.09452115744352341,
0.4899294078350067,
1.3188966512680054,
-0.1328541338443756,
0.6454265713691711,
0.6446865200996399,
-0.27297213673591614,
0.6827082633972168,
0.3105238974094391,
0.05909011512994766,
0.7525251507759094,
0.14524991810321808,
-0.5428457856178284,
-0.7867156267166138,
-0.06178129464387894,
-0.5860421657562256,
0.2073274403810501,
0.5369461178779602,
-0.03666379675269127,
-0.278094083070755,
0.32448098063468933,
-0.22902818024158478,
0.7461793422698975,
-0.5120545625686646,
0.9082021713256836,
0.20859406888484955,
-0.8607419729232788,
0.664826512336731,
-0.4609740376472473,
0.22325429320335388,
-0.2239953726530075,
-0.42487072944641113,
-0.018962224945425987,
0.4361301064491272,
-0.30743569135665894,
-0.9885510802268982,
0.5467866063117981,
-0.41181856393814087,
-0.23358194530010223,
-0.36280345916748047,
0.4014086127281189,
-0.6244640946388245,
-0.7451921105384827,
-0.11523891985416412,
0.5727688074111938,
-0.16230422258377075,
-0.17945994436740875,
-0.746173083782196,
-0.3024396002292633,
-0.1287834793329239,
-0.07202684134244919,
0.17574365437030792,
0.5209792256355286,
0.3091685175895691,
0.9002901911735535,
0.7345624566078186,
0.02673165313899517,
-0.06789279729127884,
0.34597426652908325,
1.1783729791641235,
-0.2604198157787323,
-0.29524683952331543,
-0.720328688621521,
0.7285532355308533,
-0.39213505387306213,
-0.31421053409576416,
0.8475337028503418,
0.6813686490058899,
0.956426203250885,
-0.17715643346309662,
0.7071406245231628,
0.5757434368133545,
0.9693096280097961,
-0.49596235156059265,
0.23984506726264954,
-0.49485185742378235,
0.30869540572166443,
-0.45245301723480225,
-0.7637240886688232,
-0.6601497530937195,
0.9863958358764648,
-0.9294525384902954,
0.07124751806259155,
0.45548486709594727,
0.6937854886054993,
-0.16385836899280548,
0.42817145586013794,
0.17161963880062103,
-0.17070899903774261,
0.37537306547164917,
0.7080231308937073,
1.1502327919006348,
-0.5509542226791382,
0.3087269961833954,
-0.4374968409538269,
-0.22143962979316711,
0.30941250920295715,
-0.5577262043952942,
-1.100034475326538,
-0.5419183373451233,
-0.3183503746986389,
-0.31923410296440125,
0.0686294287443161,
0.8101118206977844,
0.8204889893531799,
-0.8987064361572266,
-0.05037911236286163,
-0.41897886991500854,
0.006863894872367382,
-0.4084552228450775,
-0.27579164505004883,
0.18689283728599548,
-0.8719081282615662,
-0.6437414884567261,
0.24377958476543427,
0.2028733342885971,
-0.29694077372550964,
-0.4882618188858032,
0.12377047538757324,
-0.23780739307403564,
0.3204423189163208,
0.5219074487686157,
0.1102161705493927,
-0.35466575622558594,
-0.35781213641166687,
0.19053354859352112,
0.42297330498695374,
0.24356737732887268,
0.9487901926040649,
-0.9062235355377197,
0.711853563785553,
0.21098504960536957,
0.8961097598075867,
0.7924849987030029,
0.26137346029281616,
0.5501933693885803,
-0.6201821565628052,
0.09410300850868225,
0.5577464699745178,
0.04057040065526962,
0.3017217516899109,
-0.40674111247062683,
0.38412749767303467,
-0.04349278658628464,
-0.3235243260860443,
-1.1288918256759644,
0.40839946269989014,
-0.5297637581825256,
-0.3586004376411438,
0.6626752614974976,
-0.13869813084602356,
0.08295457065105438,
-0.17059896886348724,
-0.3205908238887787,
0.06668054312467575,
-0.07585618644952774,
0.9439155459403992,
0.8314167261123657,
-0.32369524240493774,
-0.44117575883865356,
-0.7339575886726379,
0.5603368282318115,
0.7540549635887146,
-0.9946596622467041,
0.14281849563121796,
0.2521142065525055,
0.25281742215156555,
0.22851182520389557,
0.22542467713356018,
-0.17879629135131836,
0.4289114475250244,
-0.1307082623243332,
-0.4230959415435791,
-0.3237810432910919,
-0.39714252948760986,
-0.3224261403083801,
0.058466531336307526,
-0.13125668466091156,
-0.0867159441113472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12045v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12045v1
|
$τ$-bench: A Benchmark for Tool-Agent-User Interaction in Real-World Domains
| 2024-06-17T19:33:08 | 2024-06-17T19:33:08 |
Shunyu Yao, Noah Shinn, Pedram Razavi, Karthik Narasimhan
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Existing benchmarks do not test language agents on their interaction with
human users or ability to follow domain-specific rules, both of which are vital
for deploying them in real world applications. We propose $\tau$-bench, a
benchmark emulating dynamic conversations between a user (simulated by language
models) and a language agent provided with domain-specific API tools and policy
guidelines. We employ an efficient and faithful evaluation process that
compares the database state at the end of a conversation with the annotated
goal state. We also propose a new metric (pass^k) to evaluate the reliability
of agent behavior over multiple trials. Our experiments show that even
state-of-the-art function calling agents (like gpt-4o) succeed on <50% of the
tasks, and are quite inconsistent (pass^8 <25% in retail). Our findings point
to the need for methods that can improve the ability of agents to act
consistently and follow rules reliably.
|
[
-0.4106053411960602,
-0.9718640446662903,
0.4667913317680359,
0.10872277617454529,
-0.08007344603538513,
0.4065763056278229,
-0.17815546691417694,
-0.6946101784706116,
0.08726629614830017,
0.10923635959625244,
-0.5409727096557617,
-0.3723362684249878,
-0.16618898510932922,
-0.056261930614709854,
-0.2664324641227722,
0.577079713344574,
-0.11857744306325912,
-0.08337729424238205,
-0.1099136471748352,
-0.2683260142803192,
-0.4436887204647064,
-0.5778053998947144,
-0.879478931427002,
-0.5598018169403076,
0.38563936948776245,
0.09961281716823578,
1.110710620880127,
0.49611571431159973,
0.4117812216281891,
0.3045903146266937,
0.3487703204154968,
0.12363983690738678,
-0.46653905510902405,
0.2956758439540863,
-0.24483400583267212,
-0.42139002680778503,
-0.7029979228973389,
0.22610092163085938,
0.4517705738544464,
0.45700541138648987,
-0.21282748878002167,
-0.04438352212309837,
-0.18441209197044373,
0.15681947767734528,
-0.5940598249435425,
0.3771798014640808,
-0.3822096288204193,
-0.17340438067913055,
-0.023370569571852684,
-0.08455155044794083,
-0.33704763650894165,
-0.5933671593666077,
-0.02723950892686844,
-0.7996386289596558,
-0.20033428072929382,
0.03620080649852753,
1.2447434663772583,
0.17659828066825867,
-0.2602444291114807,
-0.032613158226013184,
-0.7010486125946045,
0.7893810272216797,
-0.6726214289665222,
0.43498194217681885,
0.697257936000824,
0.6341820359230042,
-0.37723347544670105,
-0.9784837365150452,
-0.7267269492149353,
-0.6052672863006592,
-0.0021165169309824705,
-0.026804031804203987,
-0.18602249026298523,
-0.0802837461233139,
0.19368894398212433,
-0.0505167618393898,
-0.07808980345726013,
-0.13343073427677155,
0.2539782226085663,
-0.03193053603172302,
0.5356397032737732,
0.2402048408985138,
0.20010825991630554,
0.34168630838394165,
-0.3132701814174652,
-0.6250858306884766,
-0.56644606590271,
0.16569776833057404,
0.2958899140357971,
0.26380687952041626,
-0.04245820641517639,
0.1895514577627182,
-0.23757556080818176,
0.44372686743736267,
-0.20843783020973206,
-0.14151670038700104,
0.40464338660240173,
-0.3511585593223572,
-0.012339918874204159,
-0.4052942395210266,
0.6461107134819031,
0.4748174250125885,
0.5189899802207947,
-0.6390471458435059,
-0.40699201822280884,
0.15085269510746002,
0.6523389220237732,
-0.592292308807373,
0.18060137331485748,
0.22112418711185455,
-0.054335396736860275,
-0.15028253197669983,
-0.009881318546831608,
-0.5866527557373047,
-0.3096461892127991,
-0.4052145779132843,
0.5043152570724487,
-0.5478612184524536,
-0.47772854566574097,
-0.3318260908126831,
-0.0753275528550148,
0.5701745748519897,
0.2559545636177063,
-0.5176195502281189,
1.0664803981781006,
1.0215040445327759,
0.6532544493675232,
-0.23746027052402496,
-0.8095996379852295,
-0.7028600573539734,
0.06994950026273727,
-0.41194745898246765,
0.7804416418075562,
-0.6857705116271973,
-0.5923105478286743,
0.18398450314998627,
0.05370771139860153,
-0.11446788907051086,
-0.5695216059684753,
0.6776458621025085,
-0.3493362367153168,
-0.47132760286331177,
-0.7023534178733826,
-0.5361142158508301,
0.17618772387504578,
0.6000316143035889,
-0.2973414957523346,
1.2690361738204956,
0.48447179794311523,
-0.053654301911592484,
0.6461970210075378,
-0.6178086996078491,
-0.45769768953323364,
0.1419428437948227,
-0.3580906391143799,
-0.2640659511089325,
-0.22180534899234772,
-0.19785834848880768,
0.015373035334050655,
-0.4234173893928528,
0.06539015471935272,
-0.5117432475090027,
-0.6820328235626221,
0.5677977204322815,
-0.2054472267627716,
0.3390428125858307,
0.14653488993644714,
-0.8242285251617432,
0.01836674101650715,
-0.6116566061973572,
0.2690477669239044,
0.1924949288368225,
-0.062233585864305496,
-0.16375306248664856,
0.1020250916481018,
0.36194074153900146,
0.048002030700445175,
0.12971214950084686,
-0.7069779634475708,
0.133212611079216,
-0.08923980593681335,
0.032762859016656876,
0.6905332207679749,
-0.1937982738018036,
0.107009157538414,
-0.6115474104881287,
0.5891684889793396,
-0.471204936504364,
0.3041931986808777,
0.40278056263923645,
-0.26008135080337524,
-0.4944626986980438,
-0.22613130509853363,
0.3377307951450348,
0.2937562167644501,
-0.5847730040550232,
0.457620233297348,
-0.38698872923851013,
-0.8525963425636292,
-0.32795077562332153,
-0.11590717732906342,
0.6363206505775452,
0.5091755390167236,
0.1946365088224411,
-0.6452929973602295,
0.006402106024324894,
-0.6769367456436157,
-0.37857240438461304,
-0.43240872025489807,
0.22398579120635986,
0.6724036931991577,
0.23413175344467163,
-0.29131609201431274,
1.0922737121582031,
-0.08461280167102814,
-0.14423726499080658,
-0.11683668196201324,
0.24408623576164246,
-0.16845852136611938,
0.33075135946273804,
0.7090614438056946,
-0.5834471583366394,
-0.6146872639656067,
-0.06293746083974838,
-0.7876940965652466,
-0.27959132194519043,
0.24458545446395874,
-0.18532173335552216,
0.292409747838974,
0.36650964617729187,
-0.6628143191337585,
0.4906492829322815,
0.1911727339029312,
-0.3979528546333313,
0.6802356243133545,
-0.24413441121578217,
0.39539313316345215,
-0.549074113368988,
0.27276521921157837,
-0.03212951496243477,
-0.38045021891593933,
-0.6042399406433105,
0.1815672665834427,
0.03600301221013069,
-0.19399337470531464,
-0.6349084973335266,
0.9537175297737122,
-0.28398755192756653,
-0.5459416508674622,
-0.37531620264053345,
0.12132357805967331,
-0.14435002207756042,
0.5492251515388489,
-0.12155463546514511,
1.0219649076461792,
0.4115074574947357,
-0.6372272968292236,
0.37164926528930664,
0.2365293800830841,
-0.2978894114494324,
1.0379667282104492,
-0.7759771347045898,
0.2352847158908844,
0.4527108371257782,
0.36890649795532227,
-0.8292471170425415,
0.08325278013944626,
0.13402222096920013,
-0.13444499671459198,
0.0393744520843029,
-0.05631130933761597,
-1.0399765968322754,
-0.24128970503807068,
-0.31920912861824036,
0.36706939339637756,
0.5701804757118225,
-0.3249697685241699,
0.6663455963134766,
0.5133507251739502,
0.2097722589969635,
-0.6548914909362793,
-0.5014803409576416,
0.1800696849822998,
0.019705679267644882,
-0.34876391291618347,
0.17360854148864746,
-0.0016879042377695441,
-0.37411895394325256,
0.09941402077674866,
-0.1899155080318451,
-0.025899941101670265,
0.27575111389160156,
0.2413434386253357,
-0.1252278834581375,
-0.10554789006710052,
-0.013532919809222221,
-0.23992998898029327,
-0.14349137246608734,
0.10100015997886658,
0.12748359143733978,
0.7220446467399597,
-0.34730419516563416,
-0.6801251173019409,
-0.5753027200698853,
0.050723232328891754,
0.6480855345726013,
-0.1728081852197647,
0.46289217472076416,
0.49267199635505676,
-0.24407218396663666,
-0.14313717186450958,
-0.5749313831329346,
-0.4481513798236847,
-0.5118280649185181,
0.10211383551359177,
-0.8958293199539185,
-0.2863137423992157,
0.5324080586433411,
-0.45327407121658325,
0.36869072914123535,
0.1068134754896164,
0.4841000735759735,
-0.0731574073433876,
0.8014280796051025,
0.5023312568664551,
0.04738790541887283,
0.4555128216743469,
-0.12348043918609619,
0.0631406381726265,
-0.44225090742111206,
-0.02458854578435421,
-0.4763648808002472,
-0.46755966544151306,
-0.3414841294288635,
-0.2090355008840561,
0.22449786961078644,
-0.15794818103313446,
-0.35291004180908203,
0.6594104766845703,
-0.29939305782318115,
0.3120689392089844,
0.6647907495498657,
-0.13212087750434875,
0.07372993975877762,
-0.280843585729599,
-0.1983335018157959,
0.0037723188288509846,
-0.3217153549194336,
-0.5697792172431946,
0.9085553288459778,
0.24019889533519745,
0.9410819411277771,
0.45332539081573486,
0.5311750173568726,
0.6865458488464355,
0.4589598774909973,
-0.5988399982452393,
0.7960007190704346,
0.22951620817184448,
-0.47659119963645935,
-0.45333003997802734,
-0.2779707908630371,
-1.2397751808166504,
0.3739897310733795,
-0.08986502885818481,
-0.9581871628761292,
0.2437317669391632,
0.07284480333328247,
0.007850976660847664,
0.09956702589988708,
-0.7715432047843933,
1.2015093564987183,
-0.3326131999492645,
-0.5519760251045227,
-0.3136751651763916,
-0.36240342259407043,
-0.10683877766132355,
-0.010216066613793373,
0.20740674436092377,
-0.6866046786308289,
-0.23205693066120148,
0.3670065701007843,
-0.9368085265159607,
0.8636980652809143,
-0.43497607111930847,
0.1994493007659912,
0.31959035992622375,
0.21175357699394226,
0.6989665031433105,
-0.20001564919948578,
-0.11617492139339447,
-0.1332458257675171,
0.4095551073551178,
-0.5456545948982239,
-0.6191518902778625,
0.6853928565979004,
-0.9594705700874329,
-0.27524620294570923,
-0.6319547891616821,
-0.4750242233276367,
-0.7317976951599121,
0.17439237236976624,
-0.3639305830001831,
0.5041708946228027,
-0.6966705918312073,
-0.056675732135772705,
0.042417749762535095,
0.14868465065956116,
0.3222971260547638,
1.0205684900283813,
-0.04555502161383629,
-0.03643284738063812,
0.9059332609176636,
0.028001818805933,
0.28490766882896423,
0.0671129822731018,
0.07588502019643784,
-0.5907421708106995,
-0.08342067897319794,
-0.41108742356300354,
0.3353625237941742,
-0.6945990324020386,
-0.009653478860855103,
-0.46183013916015625,
0.016471989452838898,
-0.24618734419345856,
-0.09878445416688919,
-0.5003264546394348,
-0.26331964135169983,
0.3234723210334778,
0.1526903659105301,
0.35205212235450745,
0.4867151081562042,
0.07677741348743439,
0.31083616614341736,
-0.49121230840682983,
0.11423797160387039,
0.3029747009277344,
0.6251776814460754,
0.05937968194484711,
-0.221065953373909,
-0.2265125811100006,
-0.15338890254497528,
-0.3341074287891388,
-0.6622963547706604,
0.04203157499432564,
0.17282235622406006,
1.014432430267334,
-0.040575072169303894,
0.36119842529296875,
0.45331186056137085,
-0.4539543688297272,
0.5109342336654663,
-0.2211831510066986,
-0.8942419290542603,
0.3333572447299957,
-0.2955605387687683,
0.3429175019264221,
0.9593629837036133,
0.18187688291072845,
-0.5521693825721741,
-0.6517897844314575,
-0.8672482371330261,
-0.6944111585617065,
0.7256848216056824,
0.31580400466918945,
0.10055069625377655,
-0.051200974732637405,
0.2838553786277771,
-0.01661255955696106,
0.30463603138923645,
-0.21197903156280518,
-0.3308162987232208,
-0.11389721184968948,
-0.07999484241008759,
-0.01536298356950283,
0.13185268640518188,
-0.36409202218055725,
0.11336157470941544,
0.5835337042808533,
-0.2236519157886505,
0.11808750033378601,
-0.03451235964894295,
-0.11134348064661026,
-0.10464034974575043,
0.24435311555862427,
0.42614680528640747,
1.1481096744537354,
-0.451958566904068,
0.04950517416000366,
0.0771847814321518,
-0.47569504380226135,
0.21484704315662384,
0.49371737241744995,
-0.059885866940021515,
0.013897269032895565,
-0.15750253200531006,
0.44092875719070435,
0.4398007094860077,
-1.079378366470337,
0.4935612380504608,
-0.45545780658721924,
-0.13139420747756958,
-0.44617369771003723,
0.1036132350564003,
-0.11012697964906693,
0.149969682097435,
0.30567142367362976,
-0.34150230884552,
-0.08521205186843872,
-0.9882005453109741,
0.5394511222839355,
0.3771701157093048,
-0.5500942468643188,
-0.32212671637535095,
0.6369898915290833,
0.46148231625556946,
-0.7135338187217712,
0.29174402356147766,
-0.42121782898902893,
-0.2045280933380127,
0.6326147317886353,
0.36013564467430115,
0.8006961345672607,
0.02926688641309738,
0.17169979214668274,
0.024884097278118134,
0.122096948325634,
-0.1684217005968094,
0.42030325531959534,
-0.1415831595659256,
-0.6966328620910645,
-0.1585041731595993,
-0.3855520784854889,
-1.1432856321334839,
-0.08160076290369034,
-0.44552773237228394,
0.07715565711259842,
-0.5377982258796692,
-0.6584132313728333,
0.13310249149799347,
0.334978312253952,
-0.7293675541877747,
0.067995585501194,
-0.26645591855049133,
1.0260601043701172,
-0.5152773857116699,
1.1559299230575562,
0.7307098507881165,
-0.5687631964683533,
-0.5906045436859131,
-0.15487298369407654,
0.13912667334079742,
-0.8637092709541321,
0.3569514751434326,
0.03393452614545822,
-0.2938600778579712,
-0.14635345339775085,
-0.1618136614561081,
-0.47948649525642395,
1.157894253730774,
0.3194245994091034,
-0.22808045148849487,
0.44843974709510803,
0.26838308572769165,
0.7527601718902588,
-0.28449276089668274,
0.5121312141418457,
0.9226869940757751,
0.6050153970718384,
-0.07911349833011627,
-1.1979756355285645,
0.1655665934085846,
-0.3844614326953888,
-0.280568927526474,
0.2419857680797577,
-0.9702765941619873,
0.5584251880645752,
0.2970679700374603,
-0.13345134258270264,
0.18997211754322052,
0.41368454694747925,
0.406606525182724,
0.42726442217826843,
0.9028713703155518,
0.5218316316604614,
0.7694351673126221,
-0.3456054627895355,
1.4439057111740112,
-0.5990570783615112,
0.2121448665857315,
1.0629135370254517,
-0.7777678370475769,
0.9714755415916443,
0.23115088045597076,
-0.34005507826805115,
0.4924112558364868,
0.39351245760917664,
0.013636779971420765,
0.4177364706993103,
0.2851680517196655,
-0.29568302631378174,
-0.0327056385576725,
-0.4123854339122772,
-0.1507461667060852,
0.2549065053462982,
0.28962603211402893,
0.39792945981025696,
-0.1082615777850151,
-0.3343627154827118,
0.19360117614269257,
0.304284930229187,
0.12735043466091156,
0.6863623261451721,
0.1301743984222412,
-0.8274626731872559,
0.7208647727966309,
-0.03878730535507202,
0.4376142919063568,
-0.8349857926368713,
0.00031835754634812474,
-0.3152250051498413,
0.43299973011016846,
0.16960245370864868,
-0.6905893683433533,
0.05302286520600319,
-0.033201321959495544,
0.3477462828159332,
-0.13644105195999146,
0.5376988053321838,
-0.05887533724308014,
-0.08686637133359909,
0.47292396426200867,
0.7330716252326965,
0.537609875202179,
0.12060485780239105,
-1.046019196510315,
0.3611571788787842,
-0.7264896035194397,
-0.17461605370044708,
0.4718838334083557,
0.3417293429374695,
-0.21757474541664124,
0.8682636618614197,
0.4657946527004242,
-0.11070948094129562,
-0.14343559741973877,
0.5959974527359009,
0.658130943775177,
-0.6166276931762695,
-0.5195181965827942,
-0.38451242446899414,
0.14362464845180511,
-0.39507603645324707,
-0.3988761901855469,
0.5687094926834106,
0.5316442847251892,
0.5816699862480164,
0.30844613909721375,
0.619077205657959,
-0.10497040301561356,
0.6374766826629639,
0.08096679300069809,
0.7161591053009033,
-0.5616011023521423,
0.18716026842594147,
-0.18521654605865479,
-0.9423262476921082,
0.22516097128391266,
0.32570260763168335,
-0.1272953748703003,
0.31924620270729065,
0.7148541808128357,
0.7608804702758789,
-0.2282402217388153,
-0.14613422751426697,
0.5508612990379333,
-0.04714116454124451,
0.5033332705497742,
0.207620769739151,
0.8244480490684509,
-0.3705376088619232,
0.7765857577323914,
-0.2618483006954193,
-0.3220241665840149,
-0.22387772798538208,
-0.4643101990222931,
-0.6866753101348877,
-0.366946816444397,
-0.2704300880432129,
-0.5223231315612793,
0.5082500576972961,
0.7995061278343201,
0.8998435735702515,
-0.6389558911323547,
-0.5959337949752808,
0.015179692767560482,
-0.15089985728263855,
-0.8786646723747253,
-0.19015659391880035,
0.3510914444923401,
-0.7368398904800415,
-0.8666430115699768,
0.3892817497253418,
0.1092846468091011,
-0.038180697709321976,
-0.1758470982313156,
-0.33430033922195435,
-0.11857178062200546,
0.265067458152771,
0.26727157831192017,
0.8219097256660461,
-0.8119861483573914,
-0.4345177412033081,
-0.059254806488752365,
-0.5129348635673523,
0.06070059537887573,
0.7952522039413452,
-0.7861719727516174,
0.4169546365737915,
-0.010810879990458488,
0.9997782111167908,
0.6478281617164612,
0.21101254224777222,
0.8856527209281921,
-0.6997795701026917,
0.060365669429302216,
0.2378028780221939,
0.27099812030792236,
0.27736347913742065,
0.14504286646842957,
0.9439167976379395,
0.20931370556354523,
-0.6319255232810974,
-0.7778252363204956,
0.12088923156261444,
-1.1087943315505981,
-0.16886675357818604,
1.047515630722046,
-0.3511965870857239,
-0.23755969107151031,
-0.47947853803634644,
-0.14491420984268188,
-0.026383116841316223,
-0.707345724105835,
0.6255714297294617,
0.4419479966163635,
-0.22264577448368073,
-0.14523594081401825,
-0.5638310313224792,
0.6559004783630371,
0.5191566348075867,
-1.0038505792617798,
0.18537700176239014,
0.29990729689598083,
0.15951907634735107,
0.013622412458062172,
1.121557593345642,
0.0012931973906233907,
0.570468544960022,
0.30745112895965576,
0.06225718930363655,
0.01915913075208664,
0.10869047045707703,
0.2276717871427536,
-0.03515475243330002,
0.5173280835151672,
-0.2921842336654663
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12038v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12038v1
|
Soft Prompting for Unlearning in Large Language Models
| 2024-06-17T19:11:40 | 2024-06-17T19:11:40 |
Karuna Bhaila, Minh-Hao Van, Xintao Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The widespread popularity of Large Language Models (LLMs), partly due to
their unique ability to perform in-context learning, has also brought to light
the importance of ethical and safety considerations when deploying these
pre-trained models. In this work, we focus on investigating machine unlearning
for LLMs motivated by data protection regulations. In contrast to the growing
literature on fine-tuning methods to achieve unlearning, we focus on a
comparatively lightweight alternative called soft prompting to realize the
unlearning of a subset of training data. With losses designed to enforce
forgetting as well as utility preservation, our framework \textbf{S}oft
\textbf{P}rompting for \textbf{U}n\textbf{l}earning (SPUL) learns prompt tokens
that can be appended to an arbitrary query to induce unlearning of specific
examples at inference time without updating LLM parameters. We conduct a
rigorous evaluation of the proposed method and our results indicate that SPUL
can significantly improve the trade-off between utility and forgetting in the
context of text classification with LLMs. We further validate our method using
multiple LLMs to highlight the scalability of our framework and provide
detailed insights into the choice of hyperparameters and the influence of the
size of unlearning data. Our implementation is available at
\url{https://github.com/karuna-bhaila/llm_unlearning}.
|
[
0.036343757063150406,
-0.7198807001113892,
0.4219561517238617,
-0.11160887777805328,
-0.39278751611709595,
-0.18945804238319397,
-0.7466352581977844,
0.21033670008182526,
-0.37018051743507385,
0.7007256150245667,
-0.6687093377113342,
-0.45413774251937866,
-0.3695097267627716,
-0.06652980297803879,
-0.2117520123720169,
1.3385542631149292,
0.11663989722728729,
-0.010012134909629822,
-0.3919448256492615,
-0.28473690152168274,
-0.5460032224655151,
-0.5049213171005249,
-0.5585657358169556,
-0.41520053148269653,
0.6964014172554016,
0.6906028985977173,
0.31682106852531433,
0.5429103970527649,
-0.1655360758304596,
0.34314781427383423,
-0.3026517331600189,
0.2846764326095581,
-0.6921259164810181,
0.4487561881542206,
-0.3525678217411041,
-0.43207624554634094,
-0.17080548405647278,
0.06407545506954193,
0.7264799475669861,
0.9580182433128357,
-0.4417017698287964,
0.33268511295318604,
0.6074353456497192,
0.8805853724479675,
-0.9332332611083984,
0.2720998525619507,
-0.926188051700592,
-0.07729174941778183,
-0.15476013720035553,
-0.4925292432308197,
-0.8085978627204895,
-0.15474534034729004,
0.012278052046895027,
-0.25453153252601624,
0.24115584790706635,
-0.22241513431072235,
0.5973448753356934,
0.41339918971061707,
-0.2954805791378021,
-0.3855244219303131,
-0.38451504707336426,
1.0379829406738281,
-0.3725716769695282,
0.39195716381073,
0.5187342762947083,
0.011185524053871632,
-0.18638227880001068,
-0.731346845626831,
-0.3682493567466736,
-0.126206174492836,
0.08766086399555206,
0.15716657042503357,
-0.05215280503034592,
0.020413357764482498,
0.2343742847442627,
0.2459254264831543,
-0.18440833687782288,
0.5088325142860413,
-0.40095505118370056,
-0.1366252899169922,
0.5123618245124817,
0.05604623258113861,
-0.017013244330883026,
-0.021306324750185013,
-0.39203137159347534,
-0.029820457100868225,
-1.1842551231384277,
0.10946647822856903,
0.5253555774688721,
0.4643450975418091,
0.11432895064353943,
0.4405197203159332,
0.06301064789295197,
0.27917492389678955,
0.04626094922423363,
0.03398030996322632,
0.33638814091682434,
0.2968120276927948,
-0.23331218957901,
0.12608477473258972,
0.6969783902168274,
0.3319335877895355,
0.5473999977111816,
-0.23823858797550201,
-0.48070192337036133,
-0.3519923686981201,
0.07935836911201477,
-0.8198898434638977,
0.07434390485286713,
0.15456539392471313,
-0.595940351486206,
-0.1570696085691452,
-0.0016532849986106157,
-0.6903566122055054,
-0.596602737903595,
-0.38448745012283325,
0.47631949186325073,
-0.34092235565185547,
-0.4101608693599701,
0.33842483162879944,
-0.017062561586499214,
0.08502013981342316,
0.1007806658744812,
-1.0179957151412964,
0.10454846918582916,
0.6448891162872314,
0.566277265548706,
0.00020537272212095559,
-0.5168064832687378,
-0.8603376746177673,
-0.025839125737547874,
-0.1259532868862152,
0.44196784496307373,
-0.2197648286819458,
-0.5343958735466003,
0.31409889459609985,
0.2722080945968628,
-0.19455905258655548,
-0.6529032588005066,
0.48924392461776733,
-0.4582322835922241,
0.35121384263038635,
-0.2218092679977417,
-0.7432620525360107,
-0.3198116421699524,
-0.05495075136423111,
-0.46322688460350037,
0.9063503742218018,
-0.0877990573644638,
-0.6178606748580933,
0.7866925597190857,
-0.4834655523300171,
-0.4510590732097626,
0.24241334199905396,
-0.14209601283073425,
-0.7541569471359253,
0.2508361339569092,
-0.058788809925317764,
0.8869098424911499,
-0.19625826179981232,
0.5934700965881348,
-0.3847202658653259,
-0.4835103452205658,
0.3370446264743805,
-0.9405732154846191,
0.9702589511871338,
0.19447369873523712,
-0.39864179491996765,
0.1896456778049469,
-0.5950077772140503,
-0.0553317628800869,
0.19741016626358032,
-0.4675942361354828,
-0.3853922188282013,
0.07985333353281021,
-0.15255843102931976,
-0.07958049327135086,
0.23381225764751434,
-0.3964098393917084,
0.2606266140937805,
-0.42397183179855347,
0.547366201877594,
1.2168761491775513,
-0.029845882207155228,
0.5856306552886963,
-0.23233160376548767,
0.2599775791168213,
0.00775016937404871,
0.041784659028053284,
-0.37632206082344055,
-0.133184015750885,
-0.7129021883010864,
-0.33381447196006775,
0.379253089427948,
0.41206222772598267,
-0.5836305022239685,
0.38600805401802063,
-0.05107627809047699,
-0.21525079011917114,
-0.5210136771202087,
0.749549388885498,
0.48576608300209045,
0.42416834831237793,
0.15797816216945648,
0.1198415756225586,
-0.36097127199172974,
-0.5666346549987793,
-0.4043525755405426,
0.013105512596666813,
-0.20959168672561646,
0.4502063989639282,
0.34591132402420044,
-0.17414610087871552,
0.8462738990783691,
-0.2571510076522827,
-0.2565218210220337,
-0.6229143738746643,
0.07540004700422287,
0.2945994734764099,
0.4635319113731384,
0.27822214365005493,
-0.8427078127861023,
-0.21278713643550873,
-0.3767525255680084,
-0.725275456905365,
-0.22220131754875183,
-0.21799436211585999,
0.21011501550674438,
0.5130851864814758,
0.7683612108230591,
-0.6271225810050964,
0.43295830488204956,
0.17363327741622925,
-0.12704969942569733,
0.5532048344612122,
-0.5261436104774475,
-0.22135885059833527,
-0.9588404297828674,
0.14404505491256714,
-0.1930522471666336,
-0.07666701078414917,
-0.39229485392570496,
-0.20134751498699188,
0.2208777219057083,
-0.10231137275695801,
-0.7887417078018188,
0.71120685338974,
-0.6179968118667603,
0.21411436796188354,
-0.4059309959411621,
-0.21018314361572266,
-0.08193366974592209,
0.6267299056053162,
0.08595040440559387,
0.7830197811126709,
0.7001240253448486,
-1.0226463079452515,
-0.15410076081752777,
0.06032246723771095,
-0.2103450447320938,
0.36924561858177185,
-0.7021299004554749,
0.32747405767440796,
-0.4191707372665405,
0.20062826573848724,
-0.6137625575065613,
-0.057022325694561005,
-0.013545705936849117,
-0.28076499700546265,
0.40919405221939087,
-0.4760169982910156,
-0.6444997191429138,
-0.06296946853399277,
-0.4134606122970581,
0.2932385206222534,
0.7249792814254761,
-0.9263193607330322,
0.3801814019680023,
0.3346903622150421,
-0.14449986815452576,
-0.605025053024292,
-0.4495183229446411,
-0.09442926943302155,
-0.6768895983695984,
-0.14694975316524506,
0.05394382402300835,
-0.12102583050727844,
-0.09725331515073776,
-0.16526958346366882,
0.0063621485605835915,
-0.003238129895180464,
0.18696777522563934,
0.48538342118263245,
0.33376359939575195,
-0.16097481548786163,
0.3499405086040497,
0.10162423551082611,
-0.45930561423301697,
0.03747810423374176,
-0.412876695394516,
0.4380212128162384,
-0.0859769657254219,
-0.30947065353393555,
-0.3702423870563507,
0.21920807659626007,
0.6421800851821899,
-0.12864911556243896,
0.9272028207778931,
0.5200157165527344,
-0.39961880445480347,
-0.6086582541465759,
-0.5063148140907288,
-0.26289457082748413,
-0.6535443067550659,
0.07769404351711273,
-0.16282504796981812,
-0.979582667350769,
0.2520458400249481,
-0.36560162901878357,
0.27724209427833557,
0.1915026307106018,
0.7318621277809143,
0.001642922405153513,
1.0471535921096802,
0.7424312829971313,
-0.1291070580482483,
0.42798513174057007,
-0.17175231873989105,
0.03880533203482628,
-0.5182700157165527,
-0.4176262617111206,
-0.4314827024936676,
-0.04918249323964119,
-0.5012763142585754,
0.008739063516259193,
0.21666908264160156,
0.16314049065113068,
-0.2592223584651947,
-0.02908475138247013,
-0.4179726839065552,
0.8105738759040833,
0.6425959467887878,
0.07794152945280075,
0.07563629746437073,
0.09001389145851135,
-0.02284199744462967,
0.07117992639541626,
-0.7984362244606018,
-0.45891904830932617,
1.0024429559707642,
0.3966532051563263,
0.8604388236999512,
-0.06259479373693466,
0.6795395016670227,
0.2784495949745178,
0.15345317125320435,
-0.8865299224853516,
0.6636380553245544,
-0.3396044373512268,
-0.26749661564826965,
-0.19986076653003693,
-0.7451116442680359,
-1.2670732736587524,
-0.023474380373954773,
0.023270316421985626,
-0.8186394572257996,
0.047308508306741714,
0.30487877130508423,
-0.3440755009651184,
0.4355160593986511,
-0.837874174118042,
0.7352966070175171,
-0.26107269525527954,
-0.4846267104148865,
-0.15343621373176575,
-0.3987763822078705,
0.1665358990430832,
0.00239286245778203,
-0.0203864648938179,
-0.127068892121315,
-0.006443594116717577,
0.8343778848648071,
-0.42942506074905396,
1.2588356733322144,
-0.4395548403263092,
-0.09733036905527115,
0.3497636616230011,
0.11071288585662842,
0.4309759736061096,
0.14072413742542267,
-0.25724977254867554,
0.08805794268846512,
-0.22389385104179382,
-0.3838405907154083,
-0.35544610023498535,
0.6462677121162415,
-0.41642090678215027,
-0.4957074224948883,
-0.3266737759113312,
-0.5477114319801331,
-0.2928413152694702,
0.3709482252597809,
0.4876822531223297,
0.45741111040115356,
0.11389997601509094,
0.5244179368019104,
0.9840635657310486,
-0.41554731130599976,
0.5169190764427185,
0.8044900298118591,
0.14037302136421204,
-0.07286261022090912,
1.2172611951828003,
0.12468897551298141,
0.08418954163789749,
0.1401503086090088,
0.5631541609764099,
-0.6655819416046143,
-0.59873366355896,
-0.458233505487442,
0.1687813103199005,
-0.657076358795166,
-0.4848857522010803,
-0.4156705141067505,
-0.13543134927749634,
-0.31563690304756165,
-0.2892586290836334,
-0.21786607801914215,
-0.10651383548974991,
-0.5406742095947266,
-0.2186921089887619,
0.5822359919548035,
0.7978674173355103,
0.02714136615395546,
0.30638587474823,
-0.8192471265792847,
-0.14126460254192352,
0.1461257040500641,
0.5863014459609985,
0.04303679242730141,
-0.7235360145568848,
-0.1324271857738495,
-0.16850952804088593,
-0.09455116093158722,
-0.37049323320388794,
0.2708440124988556,
0.33414265513420105,
0.6197855472564697,
0.580974280834198,
0.3050430715084076,
0.3403472304344177,
-0.5208961963653564,
0.453425794839859,
0.24423883855342865,
-0.9109573364257812,
0.39683547616004944,
-0.4945639371871948,
0.3044663071632385,
0.967415988445282,
0.3267483413219452,
-0.5371688008308411,
-0.13339842855930328,
-0.7594338655471802,
-1.229680061340332,
0.6194424033164978,
-0.4023885726928711,
0.4517785310745239,
0.005119540728628635,
0.530855655670166,
0.5290284156799316,
0.41955846548080444,
-0.5121974945068359,
-0.11525237560272217,
0.11432556062936783,
-0.33395594358444214,
-0.0032502051908522844,
-0.4449680745601654,
0.16119752824306488,
-0.0994177758693695,
0.6753147840499878,
-0.15412816405296326,
-0.2590183615684509,
-0.2294941395521164,
-0.4916278123855591,
0.03224136307835579,
0.3946765661239624,
0.08983276039361954,
0.5051636695861816,
0.06172194331884384,
0.21131689846515656,
0.495395302772522,
-0.3810919523239136,
0.07160463184118271,
-0.1979042887687683,
-0.36748790740966797,
-0.25365665555000305,
0.10706383734941483,
0.5166042447090149,
0.5666574239730835,
-0.8777695894241333,
0.6086183786392212,
0.10980603843927383,
-0.39802849292755127,
-0.16608400642871857,
0.1779823899269104,
-0.08845986425876617,
-0.1130131185054779,
0.3020232021808624,
-0.28619131445884705,
0.010007853619754314,
-0.4563310444355011,
0.4887923002243042,
0.22742509841918945,
-0.4790794253349304,
-0.18499940633773804,
0.4732681214809418,
0.25595346093177795,
-0.22681362926959991,
0.8163393139839172,
-0.3379300832748413,
-0.5249723196029663,
0.23821569979190826,
0.5446736216545105,
0.8391156792640686,
-0.18386739492416382,
0.13521568477153778,
0.09083784371614456,
0.020784011110663414,
-0.279979944229126,
0.09479445219039917,
-0.21409930288791656,
-0.4280356466770172,
-0.4096531271934509,
-0.5708977580070496,
-0.34625864028930664,
0.4440528154373169,
-0.6294249892234802,
0.24267518520355225,
-0.6413297653198242,
0.20000049471855164,
-0.2119532823562622,
-0.021675994619727135,
-0.5104552507400513,
-0.01511295698583126,
0.058758821338415146,
0.922968864440918,
-0.7600533366203308,
0.5916876196861267,
0.5101544857025146,
-0.3666979968547821,
-0.7692518830299377,
-0.02619188092648983,
0.3926563560962677,
-0.926067054271698,
0.4029824435710907,
0.4234517812728882,
-0.2931513488292694,
-0.06596355140209198,
-0.5971620082855225,
-0.20236638188362122,
0.857565701007843,
0.6110930442810059,
-0.5465943813323975,
0.3074036240577698,
0.054775774478912354,
0.03744765743613243,
0.044856708496809006,
0.03683364391326904,
0.4967786371707916,
0.18113088607788086,
-0.057354021817445755,
-0.6322632431983948,
0.18007412552833557,
-0.14447712898254395,
-0.5204111933708191,
0.3361566960811615,
-0.6926563382148743,
0.725875973701477,
-0.33543524146080017,
-0.35955363512039185,
0.03735518455505371,
0.4778478443622589,
0.2507370412349701,
0.5821438431739807,
0.9046398997306824,
0.19137494266033173,
1.0124226808547974,
0.10713345557451248,
0.6971762180328369,
-0.0299632977694273,
0.38009268045425415,
0.9739440679550171,
-0.3627249002456665,
0.6816052794456482,
0.39574486017227173,
0.15933236479759216,
0.163681298494339,
0.5960067510604858,
0.11207828670740128,
0.34227117896080017,
0.3694380521774292,
-0.4541691243648529,
-0.21312516927719116,
-0.285521924495697,
-0.0928480327129364,
0.464526891708374,
0.3657665550708771,
-0.19049859046936035,
-0.32885366678237915,
0.23782756924629211,
0.4052681028842926,
0.06012630835175514,
-0.4738383889198303,
0.9037683010101318,
0.31131258606910706,
-0.596182107925415,
0.5556831359863281,
-0.14296872913837433,
0.8132433295249939,
-0.7273915410041809,
0.04576818645000458,
-0.19066177308559418,
0.5685501098632812,
-0.18531478941440582,
-0.7230137586593628,
0.018847666680812836,
0.26879647374153137,
-0.21233610808849335,
-0.6925999522209167,
0.7830953001976013,
-0.6215913891792297,
-0.30651164054870605,
0.28144571185112,
0.520361065864563,
0.25815916061401367,
-0.08021288365125656,
-0.8933750987052917,
-0.13383764028549194,
-0.11438964307308197,
-0.38798871636390686,
0.6793012022972107,
0.75508052110672,
0.02683146670460701,
0.7723680734634399,
0.844613790512085,
-0.020097684115171432,
-0.39672815799713135,
0.6097663044929504,
0.7770811915397644,
-0.5947006344795227,
-0.6196668744087219,
-0.9771007895469666,
0.4228905439376831,
0.12201961874961853,
-0.41782230138778687,
0.8301922082901001,
0.47578397393226624,
0.6400728821754456,
0.218826562166214,
0.6854115724563599,
0.32024329900741577,
0.4259963035583496,
-0.8769885897636414,
1.026755928993225,
-0.6799042820930481,
0.3999004065990448,
-0.04286325350403786,
-0.5466284155845642,
-0.1107461154460907,
0.15732519328594208,
-0.21891269087791443,
0.26625415682792664,
0.43670520186424255,
0.7114278674125671,
-0.19084088504314423,
-0.039464399218559265,
0.32484564185142517,
0.019104762002825737,
0.025074031203985214,
0.3636055886745453,
0.8720933198928833,
0.24903467297554016,
0.6401777863502502,
0.04628024250268936,
-0.30097734928131104,
-0.2872307002544403,
-0.9763069748878479,
-0.9168234467506409,
-0.5930406451225281,
-0.2055307775735855,
-0.514930009841919,
0.24229100346565247,
1.0209027528762817,
0.6516594886779785,
-0.6570961475372314,
-0.19444651901721954,
-0.1104457676410675,
0.17687363922595978,
-0.17496301233768463,
-0.21126064658164978,
0.6210663914680481,
-0.6370949149131775,
-0.5216586589813232,
0.46017247438430786,
0.17649824917316437,
0.030025765299797058,
-0.23922227323055267,
-0.13718941807746887,
0.14963047206401825,
-0.06357397139072418,
0.5132862329483032,
0.5479423999786377,
-0.15762144327163696,
-0.049324970692396164,
-0.0643705427646637,
0.2468109130859375,
-0.24953415989875793,
1.1937826871871948,
-0.7894821166992188,
0.03563703969120979,
0.2836484909057617,
0.8942331075668335,
0.2601880133152008,
-0.24642616510391235,
0.5995208024978638,
-1.1055223941802979,
0.3196287155151367,
0.21737007796764374,
0.5910153985023499,
0.37374386191368103,
-0.5911906361579895,
0.18535540997982025,
0.024440480396151543,
-0.6689079999923706,
-1.119202971458435,
0.07766979187726974,
-0.5363019108772278,
-0.47127705812454224,
1.2751922607421875,
-0.11086665093898773,
-0.49146226048469543,
-0.2655395567417145,
-0.2109135389328003,
0.13867664337158203,
-0.6292639970779419,
0.7269025444984436,
0.3609999120235443,
0.25193142890930176,
-0.08356624841690063,
-0.4996602237224579,
0.5923459529876709,
0.7484332323074341,
-0.5164554715156555,
0.817981481552124,
0.3481917381286621,
0.4780994653701782,
-0.3675081431865692,
0.6430453658103943,
0.019314736127853394,
0.44544440507888794,
-0.2525632679462433,
-0.2027919888496399,
-0.3073466718196869,
-0.5463112592697144,
-0.6897588968276978,
0.051810480654239655,
0.033666569739580154,
-0.282930850982666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12036v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12036v4
|
MedCalc-Bench: Evaluating Large Language Models for Medical Calculations
| 2024-06-17T19:07:21 | 2024-06-30T15:12:10 |
Nikhil Khandekar, Qiao Jin, Guangzhi Xiong, Soren Dunn, Serina S Applebaum, Zain Anwar, Maame Sarfo-Gyamfi, Conrad W Safranek, Abid A Anwar, Andrew Zhang, Aidan Gilson, Maxwell B Singer, Amisha Dave, Andrew Taylor, Aidong Zhang, Qingyu Chen, Zhiyong Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As opposed to evaluating computation and logic-based reasoning, current
benchmarks for evaluating large language models (LLMs) in medicine are
primarily focused on question-answering involving domain knowledge and
descriptive reasoning. While such qualitative capabilities are vital to medical
diagnosis, in real-world scenarios, doctors frequently use clinical calculators
that follow quantitative equations and rule-based reasoning paradigms for
evidence-based decision support. To this end, we propose MedCalc-Bench, a
first-of-its-kind dataset focused on evaluating the medical calculation
capability of LLMs. MedCalc-Bench contains an evaluation set of over 1000
manually reviewed instances from 55 different medical calculation tasks. Each
instance in MedCalc-Bench consists of a patient note, a question requesting to
compute a specific medical value, a ground truth answer, and a step-by-step
explanation showing how the answer is obtained. While our evaluation results
show the potential of LLMs in this area, none of them are effective enough for
clinical settings. Common issues include extracting the incorrect entities, not
using the correct equation or rules for a calculation task, or incorrectly
performing the arithmetic for the computation. We hope our study highlights the
quantitative knowledge and reasoning gaps in LLMs within medical settings,
encouraging future improvements of LLMs for various clinical calculation tasks.
|
[
-0.12548770010471344,
-0.6931763291358948,
1.1926928758621216,
0.2966201603412628,
-0.10517928749322891,
-0.12493602186441422,
-0.36946797370910645,
-0.23981668055057526,
-0.049285173416137695,
0.39141154289245605,
-0.4625398814678192,
-0.7681151032447815,
-0.6575661897659302,
0.12188172340393066,
-0.21841759979724884,
0.5665225386619568,
-0.08021822571754456,
0.8002520203590393,
-0.6128385663032532,
-0.3555580675601959,
-0.39227956533432007,
-0.5066172480583191,
-0.6556234955787659,
-0.47341838479042053,
0.5175443887710571,
0.31392693519592285,
0.679392397403717,
0.3640882968902588,
0.8951916694641113,
0.2573438882827759,
0.19445423781871796,
0.3099054992198944,
-0.3284544348716736,
0.007266624830663204,
-0.25600117444992065,
-0.610793948173523,
-0.5763662457466125,
-0.003082855837419629,
0.5549270510673523,
1.0657583475112915,
-0.2713436782360077,
0.04761376976966858,
-0.6349795460700989,
0.793620228767395,
-0.6426211595535278,
0.4058912396430969,
-0.33927208185195923,
0.07607880234718323,
-0.10573803633451462,
-0.1970776915550232,
-0.477956086397171,
-0.7411368489265442,
-0.03733490779995918,
-0.4158581495285034,
-0.03043866716325283,
-0.055581312626600266,
0.4391441345214844,
0.30605176091194153,
-0.2730049192905426,
-0.20990623533725739,
-0.4439244866371155,
0.758842945098877,
-0.8074033260345459,
0.3598540723323822,
0.7790055871009827,
0.7808772921562195,
-0.3372300863265991,
-0.7161489129066467,
-0.2699887454509735,
-0.48643869161605835,
0.11041619628667831,
0.14538544416427612,
-0.09231860935688019,
0.07097911089658737,
0.3578881621360779,
0.330870121717453,
-0.5457566976547241,
0.2207968831062317,
-0.3140430748462677,
-0.06416747719049454,
0.6663814187049866,
0.5758066177368164,
0.24525001645088196,
0.04447800666093826,
-0.12767550349235535,
-0.04911036416888237,
-0.8992213010787964,
-0.25824204087257385,
-0.606341540813446,
-0.015018354170024395,
-0.22164982557296753,
0.6354844570159912,
0.06865191459655762,
0.7158624529838562,
-0.21938736736774445,
-0.3362116813659668,
0.177565798163414,
-0.2684827148914337,
-0.24582454562187195,
0.12085393816232681,
0.8272494673728943,
0.6355512142181396,
0.31021010875701904,
-0.18552809953689575,
-0.1294894814491272,
0.16403920948505402,
0.34419745206832886,
-0.8951408863067627,
-0.03381657227873802,
0.19683413207530975,
-0.4901275038719177,
-0.32679614424705505,
-0.37538468837738037,
-0.4461435079574585,
-0.7039400935173035,
-0.38422897458076477,
0.149195596575737,
-0.4503144919872284,
0.0798502191901207,
0.15158724784851074,
0.2578109800815582,
-0.11598847806453705,
0.4514552652835846,
-0.3996821939945221,
0.7096376419067383,
0.5131242871284485,
0.6340587735176086,
-0.075098916888237,
-0.055708881467580795,
-0.38698360323905945,
-0.30976539850234985,
-0.4992316961288452,
0.941039502620697,
-0.4320361912250519,
-0.509850800037384,
-0.020257405936717987,
0.08162888139486313,
-0.15709984302520752,
-0.9602558016777039,
0.7486386299133301,
-0.2195299118757248,
-0.14276587963104248,
-0.38686761260032654,
-0.6987375020980835,
0.10524003207683563,
0.20316077768802643,
-0.7169312238693237,
0.7122524976730347,
0.4025757908821106,
-0.45217812061309814,
0.31658193469047546,
-0.5356019139289856,
-0.4254133403301239,
0.10916056483983994,
-0.591211199760437,
-0.25864753127098083,
0.14445780217647552,
0.2638072371482849,
0.2488456517457962,
-1.1674946546554565,
0.5002242922782898,
-0.29362788796424866,
-0.2488003671169281,
0.7373949885368347,
-0.33124732971191406,
0.5209690928459167,
0.35839828848838806,
-0.0871824398636818,
-0.12753257155418396,
-0.7771613597869873,
0.29371747374534607,
0.10450278967618942,
-0.2363201081752777,
-0.2645339071750641,
0.12309423834085464,
-0.07214492559432983,
0.31071457266807556,
0.057930126786231995,
-0.5460977554321289,
0.030698681250214577,
-0.3911098837852478,
0.31880173087120056,
0.47767379879951477,
0.0037840474396944046,
0.06258179247379303,
-0.6399971842765808,
0.5456796288490295,
-0.2327301949262619,
0.16657760739326477,
0.04552292078733444,
-0.25836533308029175,
-0.2680651843547821,
-0.3759929835796356,
0.47652167081832886,
0.5293179154396057,
-0.4418376684188843,
0.12340928614139557,
-0.18513889610767365,
-0.5701217651367188,
-0.5231521725654602,
-0.25449490547180176,
0.5818032026290894,
0.7732736468315125,
0.24452413618564606,
-0.03328967094421387,
-0.4891442656517029,
-1.0968906879425049,
-0.2562331557273865,
-0.09583744406700134,
-0.0030697002075612545,
0.6976865530014038,
0.34913063049316406,
-0.253323495388031,
0.8610190749168396,
-0.5208079814910889,
-0.2567548453807831,
-0.07082956284284592,
-0.0012515736743807793,
0.36536073684692383,
0.3321938216686249,
0.7132065296173096,
-0.467620849609375,
-0.21904364228248596,
0.11937469244003296,
-1.056329607963562,
-0.579074501991272,
0.08945323526859283,
-0.00019677338423207402,
0.013977820985019207,
0.5456151962280273,
-0.5640615224838257,
0.4760845899581909,
0.4833584129810333,
-0.08684716373682022,
0.7007470726966858,
-0.42740413546562195,
0.5930858850479126,
-0.6969967484474182,
0.2343529462814331,
0.06146160140633583,
-0.2747655212879181,
-0.27264654636383057,
-0.05402098223567009,
0.30797404050827026,
-0.03484948351979256,
-0.2684042453765869,
0.7023138403892517,
-0.06275027990341187,
0.04475466534495354,
-0.20241974294185638,
0.24407245218753815,
-0.11400026082992554,
0.013480126857757568,
-0.2037504017353058,
0.7774263024330139,
0.23646073043346405,
-0.3881497383117676,
0.3413955867290497,
0.10535968840122223,
-0.6046169996261597,
0.7196347117424011,
-0.60552579164505,
0.001258071162737906,
0.042070597410202026,
0.2411860078573227,
-0.8023099303245544,
-0.1788693368434906,
-0.2765367329120636,
-0.31042200326919556,
0.18355166912078857,
-0.011043816804885864,
-0.768682062625885,
-0.6343281865119934,
-0.10919257253408432,
0.8594545722007751,
0.28070610761642456,
-0.2557571530342102,
0.34307387471199036,
0.5820525884628296,
-0.3005801737308502,
-0.3158721923828125,
-0.7184845209121704,
0.04245219752192497,
0.2010214924812317,
-0.6754420399665833,
0.2705267071723938,
-0.16782242059707642,
-0.49155113101005554,
-0.16162043809890747,
-0.10578954219818115,
-0.31713852286338806,
-0.11326009035110474,
0.4082987904548645,
0.4218328595161438,
-0.20069032907485962,
0.36167895793914795,
0.018504347652196884,
-0.1278650015592575,
0.46401745080947876,
0.12050334364175797,
0.5530741214752197,
-0.19435985386371613,
-0.7273916602134705,
-0.3094891905784607,
0.2713279128074646,
0.9750167727470398,
-0.22085534036159515,
0.6245214343070984,
0.0639001876115799,
-0.7761440873146057,
0.12193288654088974,
-0.9855632185935974,
-0.043704282492399216,
-0.31689688563346863,
0.5758505463600159,
-0.3410034775733948,
-0.6003295183181763,
0.581453263759613,
-0.41854390501976013,
0.07118386030197144,
0.482008159160614,
0.965029239654541,
0.014136423356831074,
1.3351985216140747,
0.08342305570840836,
0.24597857892513275,
-0.10339483618736267,
0.0118173249065876,
0.048202354460954666,
-0.6497170925140381,
-0.4157673716545105,
-0.5782729983329773,
-0.1322273463010788,
-0.27896448969841003,
-0.6786289215087891,
0.7141821980476379,
-0.38617128133773804,
-0.28121936321258545,
-0.02117440477013588,
-0.14037950336933136,
0.35537606477737427,
-0.0029168520122766495,
0.4608314633369446,
0.2068987786769867,
-0.1646409034729004,
-0.702929675579071,
-0.22936195135116577,
-0.5647261738777161,
-0.3338700234889984,
1.3268241882324219,
0.2869420647621155,
0.9402987360954285,
-0.053196992725133896,
0.43242594599723816,
0.43967515230178833,
0.612801730632782,
-0.9327487945556641,
0.6347907185554504,
-0.38668015599250793,
-0.5652813911437988,
0.043254952877759933,
-0.7146281599998474,
-0.8776185512542725,
0.23091581463813782,
-0.15225769579410553,
-0.4964386224746704,
-0.16282153129577637,
-0.23541943728923798,
-0.3721969425678253,
0.11872028559446335,
-0.792363703250885,
0.8373371958732605,
-0.48367613554000854,
-0.3691151440143585,
-0.42849594354629517,
-0.4102216958999634,
0.2996884286403656,
-0.3586553931236267,
0.6159722208976746,
-0.2403125911951065,
-0.07876590639352798,
0.6188156604766846,
-0.8094649910926819,
0.5641835331916809,
-0.18828509747982025,
0.0257309190928936,
-0.0074586714617908,
0.26192569732666016,
0.11978816986083984,
0.1194094866514206,
-0.3439232110977173,
-0.17118215560913086,
0.5392976403236389,
-0.38553276658058167,
-0.7445452809333801,
0.7877029776573181,
-0.5542423129081726,
-0.31987419724464417,
-0.497788667678833,
-0.7463489770889282,
-0.6935160160064697,
0.15621620416641235,
-0.12985026836395264,
0.615757405757904,
-0.5365201830863953,
0.194495290517807,
0.3111717700958252,
-0.24614039063453674,
-0.1099090576171875,
0.9165230393409729,
-0.3212583065032959,
-0.5769729614257812,
0.38747355341911316,
0.018785854801535606,
0.22485016286373138,
0.2065909504890442,
0.43545669317245483,
-0.3409132957458496,
-0.5725858807563782,
-0.3625214099884033,
0.49176475405693054,
-0.7951353788375854,
-0.2820136845111847,
-0.39707085490226746,
-0.2871555984020233,
-0.12212769687175751,
-0.08292347192764282,
-0.386112779378891,
-0.34708037972450256,
0.26317572593688965,
0.1436387300491333,
0.29456934332847595,
0.5170246958732605,
0.09165018796920776,
0.07598324120044708,
-0.8510728478431702,
0.26653948426246643,
-0.017425838857889175,
0.484813392162323,
-0.15778954327106476,
-0.3582295775413513,
-0.2999947667121887,
0.06525696069002151,
-0.014220550656318665,
-0.7275878190994263,
0.37662383913993835,
0.008620415814220905,
0.6495541334152222,
0.28651514649391174,
-0.0925944596529007,
0.7226675748825073,
-0.7245028614997864,
0.2726556956768036,
0.5193048715591431,
-0.5032472014427185,
0.4098946452140808,
-0.06423038989305496,
0.4877561628818512,
0.8206374049186707,
0.20340478420257568,
-0.48409321904182434,
-0.0403205081820488,
-0.3620550334453583,
-0.4298405945301056,
0.6194973587989807,
0.09961077570915222,
-0.40374237298965454,
-0.12796245515346527,
0.4086514413356781,
0.03602961450815201,
0.10032693296670914,
-0.13421449065208435,
-0.14998865127563477,
0.45938044786453247,
-0.525826096534729,
-0.1048051044344902,
-0.043157678097486496,
-0.4530755281448364,
-0.5612895488739014,
0.27912890911102295,
-0.13046520948410034,
0.17390842735767365,
0.30008336901664734,
-0.1395614594221115,
-0.2989061176776886,
0.315297931432724,
0.6489309072494507,
1.1456841230392456,
-0.33066025376319885,
0.13526560366153717,
0.5110791921615601,
-0.701568603515625,
-0.12446901202201843,
0.3137573003768921,
0.25243282318115234,
-0.06056477501988411,
0.1991177797317505,
0.3241196572780609,
0.6270965933799744,
-1.2717084884643555,
0.6981195211410522,
-0.36352184414863586,
-0.37538132071495056,
-0.39113283157348633,
-0.19049972295761108,
0.13149820268154144,
0.11139153689146042,
0.06658446788787842,
0.19690069556236267,
0.05595048889517784,
-0.5362682938575745,
0.28131914138793945,
0.3220454156398773,
-0.37930983304977417,
0.058513764292001724,
0.4504660665988922,
-0.04802747815847397,
-0.1506921499967575,
0.6109604239463806,
0.2572709918022156,
-0.3162027895450592,
0.7916354537010193,
0.7493767738342285,
0.43756452202796936,
-0.1251021921634674,
-0.05593809485435486,
0.39845237135887146,
0.160264790058136,
-0.02789948135614395,
0.33972829580307007,
0.19520077109336853,
-0.3917384445667267,
-0.49032944440841675,
-0.5568830966949463,
-0.5975550413131714,
0.1083369255065918,
-0.5457494258880615,
0.31406015157699585,
-0.6438987255096436,
-0.4907936751842499,
0.27133041620254517,
0.0016466493252664804,
-0.7031112909317017,
0.3509480357170105,
0.16232722997665405,
1.095890760421753,
-0.43310031294822693,
0.7097136378288269,
0.6981756091117859,
-0.19892269372940063,
-0.6987143754959106,
-0.6145787239074707,
0.09584339708089828,
-1.0412369966506958,
0.5335545539855957,
0.010596003383398056,
-0.12723177671432495,
-0.5173726677894592,
-0.514802098274231,
-0.45077192783355713,
1.0465333461761475,
0.578345000743866,
-0.6018180847167969,
-0.004200762137770653,
0.3464849293231964,
0.6860703229904175,
-0.5740257501602173,
0.601570725440979,
0.8291240930557251,
0.46056753396987915,
0.15402504801750183,
-1.3150522708892822,
0.17801693081855774,
-0.4413248896598816,
-0.37617459893226624,
0.28427907824516296,
-0.35983383655548096,
0.8822526335716248,
-0.35897406935691833,
0.09690121561288834,
0.23008304834365845,
-0.19760628044605255,
0.5236070156097412,
0.5952895879745483,
0.32672110199928284,
0.7055502533912659,
0.8719318509101868,
-0.2169264703989029,
1.3235224485397339,
-0.38178136944770813,
0.23901519179344177,
0.9134573340415955,
-0.5905869603157043,
0.6742369532585144,
0.22316475212574005,
-0.6435301303863525,
0.3651168644428253,
0.4457972049713135,
0.03793608769774437,
0.2554453909397125,
0.5493738055229187,
-0.41393253207206726,
-0.47556737065315247,
-0.1705484837293625,
-0.4797424077987671,
0.20532484352588654,
0.7468759417533875,
-0.6608798503875732,
-0.32670119404792786,
-0.1928257793188095,
0.18780918419361115,
0.12352417409420013,
-0.3957410156726837,
0.5467897653579712,
0.3928914964199066,
-0.7112253904342651,
0.9268923997879028,
0.04763662442564964,
-0.10461317747831345,
-0.7636927366256714,
-0.18191468715667725,
-0.0816023051738739,
0.4886256754398346,
-0.39806607365608215,
-0.7402089834213257,
-0.019981903955340385,
0.18399351835250854,
-0.1733298897743225,
0.19095158576965332,
0.5786157250404358,
-0.0789218544960022,
-0.6390945315361023,
0.153517484664917,
0.6052420139312744,
0.35738828778266907,
-0.11773107200860977,
-0.6047179698944092,
0.008334921672940254,
-0.28721368312835693,
0.33072614669799805,
0.4270819425582886,
0.3876100480556488,
-0.1848762482404709,
0.8025580048561096,
0.6202965974807739,
0.10982342064380646,
-0.13063162565231323,
0.7172537446022034,
1.007896065711975,
-0.6550138592720032,
-0.06603865325450897,
-0.7634176015853882,
0.027320051565766335,
-0.0004234812513459474,
-0.18257291615009308,
0.20111703872680664,
0.7139666676521301,
0.09448263794183731,
0.00825008936226368,
0.5535359978675842,
0.1620035320520401,
0.5829422473907471,
-0.49473169445991516,
0.8389259576797485,
-0.6494140028953552,
0.26589247584342957,
-0.021110566332936287,
-0.5555590391159058,
-0.4938618838787079,
0.5610657930374146,
-0.6394790410995483,
0.05066322907805443,
1.1459366083145142,
0.6336522102355957,
0.09685014188289642,
0.3166850209236145,
0.43230515718460083,
0.36416181921958923,
0.20930175483226776,
0.8882533311843872,
0.7052134275436401,
-0.27060574293136597,
0.2851327657699585,
-0.20835146307945251,
-0.6765964031219482,
-0.19309383630752563,
-0.5641879439353943,
-0.8613155484199524,
-0.19219942390918732,
-0.09128279238939285,
-0.4046182930469513,
0.05609877407550812,
1.1758726835250854,
0.7243662476539612,
-0.8646329045295715,
-0.33475133776664734,
0.0001242322032339871,
-0.2400231659412384,
-0.09857963770627975,
-0.13008201122283936,
0.5476390719413757,
-0.29073798656463623,
-0.36987102031707764,
0.545870304107666,
0.335042268037796,
-0.3633226752281189,
-0.12263219803571701,
-0.0052582514472305775,
-0.1442222148180008,
0.048525821417570114,
0.6651782393455505,
0.20285522937774658,
-0.6076140999794006,
0.1745339184999466,
0.15513357520103455,
-0.4249993562698364,
0.18189390003681183,
1.006359338760376,
-1.01502525806427,
0.6228041648864746,
0.1690828651189804,
0.7717655301094055,
0.5758309364318848,
-0.13036634027957916,
0.5791574120521545,
-0.08024037629365921,
-0.08373181521892548,
0.5421151518821716,
0.6372705101966858,
0.09122590720653534,
0.06797698885202408,
0.5061929821968079,
0.14707669615745544,
-0.75747150182724,
-0.7175179719924927,
-0.08626826852560043,
-1.084124207496643,
-0.20184272527694702,
0.8945674896240234,
-0.11291607469320297,
-0.40301403403282166,
-0.037524979561567307,
-0.4167480766773224,
0.05305926129221916,
-0.18855272233486176,
0.6641695499420166,
0.5512537360191345,
-0.29759880900382996,
0.06726215034723282,
-0.9853323101997375,
0.24497899413108826,
0.6046047806739807,
-1.0067511796951294,
0.037109069526195526,
0.6295143365859985,
0.34923943877220154,
-0.07531680166721344,
0.6249660849571228,
-0.7722382545471191,
0.7136780619621277,
-0.09616545587778091,
-0.13106481730937958,
0.05162365362048149,
0.05768937990069389,
0.0025449444074183702,
0.08056900650262833,
0.1801285594701767,
0.12306979298591614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12034v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12034v1
|
Self-MoE: Towards Compositional Large Language Models with Self-Specialized Experts
| 2024-06-17T19:06:54 | 2024-06-17T19:06:54 |
Junmo Kang, Leonid Karlinsky, Hongyin Luo, Zhen Wang, Jacob Hansen, James Glass, David Cox, Rameswar Panda, Rogerio Feris, Alan Ritter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present Self-MoE, an approach that transforms a monolithic LLM into a
compositional, modular system of self-specialized experts, named MiXSE (MiXture
of Self-specialized Experts). Our approach leverages self-specialization, which
constructs expert modules using self-generated synthetic data, each equipped
with a shared base LLM and incorporating self-optimized routing. This allows
for dynamic and capability-specific handling of various target tasks, enhancing
overall capabilities, without extensive human-labeled data and added
parameters. Our empirical results reveal that specializing LLMs may exhibit
potential trade-offs in performances on non-specialized tasks. On the other
hand, our Self-MoE demonstrates substantial improvements over the base LLM
across diverse benchmarks such as knowledge, reasoning, math, and coding. It
also consistently outperforms other methods, including instance merging and
weight merging, while offering better flexibility and interpretability by
design with semantic experts and routing. Our findings highlight the critical
role of modularity and the potential of self-improvement in achieving
efficient, scalable, and adaptable systems.
|
[
-0.5239220261573792,
-0.6892954111099243,
0.4995177090167999,
0.3572758138179779,
0.17985133826732635,
0.22982065379619598,
-0.4034212827682495,
-0.3915358781814575,
0.6806901097297668,
0.6381008625030518,
-0.5344188213348389,
-0.3608500361442566,
-0.4891054928302765,
0.05568321421742439,
-0.35993722081184387,
0.647797167301178,
0.2512803077697754,
-0.08060969412326813,
-0.22666232287883759,
0.023404985666275024,
-0.6400464177131653,
-0.4294195771217346,
-0.36026185750961304,
-0.2305690348148346,
0.57178795337677,
0.5635578632354736,
0.48571738600730896,
0.7495885491371155,
0.17136426270008087,
0.3997842073440552,
0.32554689049720764,
0.1946408450603485,
-0.45579200983047485,
0.37875455617904663,
-0.5102983117103577,
-0.5031905174255371,
-1.0068116188049316,
-0.17220856249332428,
0.5456439256668091,
0.7308671474456787,
-0.1891276240348816,
-0.029085325077176094,
0.011835522018373013,
0.6511318683624268,
-0.5839148163795471,
0.06711680442094803,
-0.7125113606452942,
0.10360335558652878,
-0.35401812195777893,
-0.041233476251363754,
-0.3620573878288269,
0.3720279633998871,
0.10461919009685516,
-0.4862036108970642,
-0.04149796441197395,
-0.03982461616396904,
-0.13235510885715485,
0.47337064146995544,
-0.429778128862381,
-0.12972888350486755,
-0.5447697043418884,
0.9232543110847473,
-0.9734486937522888,
0.3979983925819397,
0.14761601388454437,
0.25067973136901855,
-0.31644508242607117,
-0.4223533868789673,
-0.32669708132743835,
-0.017392633482813835,
0.1465766727924347,
0.3861210346221924,
0.038534920662641525,
-0.019776469096541405,
-0.21468597650527954,
0.5145263671875,
-0.44548875093460083,
0.36328476667404175,
-0.43572795391082764,
-0.18964895606040955,
1.0697946548461914,
0.3341864049434662,
0.4945903420448303,
-0.13395360112190247,
-0.3833785355091095,
0.38218262791633606,
-0.5962381362915039,
-0.23607724905014038,
0.36145758628845215,
0.057249054312705994,
0.10940297693014145,
0.6195641160011292,
-0.46345508098602295,
0.6275613903999329,
0.295946329832077,
-0.1268632411956787,
0.06498877704143524,
-0.21287283301353455,
-0.16457943618297577,
-0.0017942533595487475,
0.9916585683822632,
-0.02951628528535366,
0.1868697553873062,
-0.44004887342453003,
-0.3284386694431305,
-0.44173651933670044,
0.46653681993484497,
-0.38132336735725403,
-0.628291130065918,
0.23976117372512817,
-0.37590980529785156,
-0.20589804649353027,
-0.19225722551345825,
-0.6843072772026062,
0.030399268493056297,
-0.46667638421058655,
0.6204974055290222,
-0.3681105077266693,
-0.49293771386146545,
0.23153230547904968,
0.12102768570184708,
-0.17984406650066376,
0.41084668040275574,
-1.3220256567001343,
0.3532862663269043,
0.6645587086677551,
0.628333568572998,
-0.6731239557266235,
-0.5354355573654175,
-0.056261539459228516,
0.6352432370185852,
-0.4573780596256256,
0.6946168541908264,
-0.5676879286766052,
-0.673413872718811,
-0.43396487832069397,
-0.49204984307289124,
-0.09337235242128372,
-0.7125675678253174,
0.12402404099702835,
-0.46945884823799133,
0.0845290794968605,
0.051359497010707855,
-0.7326306104660034,
-0.0794459879398346,
0.23029085993766785,
-0.42635291814804077,
1.0724602937698364,
0.15455278754234314,
-0.44334250688552856,
-0.04254736378788948,
-0.7196348905563354,
-0.7169609665870667,
0.13039126992225647,
-0.2895888090133667,
0.2192729264497757,
0.3810635507106781,
0.21368996798992157,
0.7038571238517761,
-0.11400480568408966,
0.21189384162425995,
-0.4330218732357025,
0.11199039965867996,
0.23008422553539276,
-0.27894675731658936,
0.47974246740341187,
0.33916693925857544,
-0.20203471183776855,
0.1528540700674057,
-0.7751260995864868,
0.16486258804798126,
-0.15033696591854095,
-0.6020158529281616,
-0.43560296297073364,
0.2376200258731842,
-0.336484432220459,
0.11291808634996414,
0.8296452164649963,
-0.38280731439590454,
0.5238066911697388,
-0.31716546416282654,
0.401299387216568,
1.132240891456604,
-0.37103506922721863,
0.8118414282798767,
-0.26140740513801575,
0.3983679711818695,
0.12888148427009583,
0.14644025266170502,
-0.3988906741142273,
-0.6124703884124756,
-1.0817488431930542,
-0.6405482292175293,
0.14480268955230713,
0.32569465041160583,
-0.5591660737991333,
0.7388680577278137,
-0.3021893799304962,
-0.4592368006706238,
-0.5312792062759399,
0.5309991836547852,
0.18989872932434082,
0.5669459700584412,
0.6266021132469177,
-0.3814808130264282,
-0.35655543208122253,
-1.284361720085144,
-0.1578228771686554,
-0.03561271354556084,
0.10114791244268417,
0.07500341534614563,
0.16992752254009247,
-0.5284969806671143,
1.25562584400177,
-0.5439292788505554,
-0.22718243300914764,
-0.19721020758152008,
0.0645020604133606,
0.09486427903175354,
0.8126959204673767,
0.3354085385799408,
-0.3677590787410736,
-0.7142364978790283,
0.21589414775371552,
-0.9183908700942993,
-0.25979241728782654,
0.14040470123291016,
-0.32005059719085693,
-0.009324409998953342,
0.4986744821071625,
-0.48026686906814575,
-0.1524757444858551,
0.6456727385520935,
-0.023818738758563995,
0.6045531034469604,
-0.35729020833969116,
-0.14006608724594116,
-1.2962654829025269,
-0.320453405380249,
-0.2576797902584076,
-0.27362900972366333,
-0.6844251155853271,
0.2558508813381195,
0.018692459911108017,
0.0625094324350357,
-0.09763635694980621,
0.7077307105064392,
-0.5352472066879272,
-0.0940137431025505,
-0.32233214378356934,
-0.28920260071754456,
-0.321113646030426,
0.4866943061351776,
-0.15793868899345398,
0.933502733707428,
0.9642505049705505,
-0.6798434853553772,
0.46412813663482666,
-0.027931900694966316,
-0.13926655054092407,
0.600865364074707,
-0.6053248047828674,
0.16035358607769012,
0.062174029648303986,
-0.04231766611337662,
-0.8744625449180603,
-0.45886948704719543,
0.17458093166351318,
-0.2390115112066269,
0.3817330598831177,
-0.08943206816911697,
-0.46110236644744873,
-0.15036259591579437,
0.007376108318567276,
0.5626540780067444,
0.5470102429389954,
-0.20803625881671906,
1.078239917755127,
0.47434383630752563,
-0.4876754879951477,
-0.40013036131858826,
-0.94306880235672,
0.29522833228111267,
-0.04791465029120445,
-0.9217578172683716,
0.25678402185440063,
-0.5240184664726257,
-0.08700000494718552,
0.0439005009829998,
-0.10875653475522995,
-0.2293773591518402,
0.21738575398921967,
-0.007758706342428923,
-0.15090908110141754,
-0.5257417559623718,
0.2916693091392517,
0.4338639974594116,
-0.26826128363609314,
0.157013401389122,
-0.5605310797691345,
0.41436728835105896,
-0.021460261195898056,
-0.7078945636749268,
-0.3828139305114746,
0.7056533694267273,
0.6353849172592163,
-0.37434160709381104,
0.375619500875473,
0.32868528366088867,
0.021218739449977875,
-0.6015492677688599,
-0.870769202709198,
-0.05921769514679909,
-0.5317094922065735,
0.22596873342990875,
-0.64873206615448,
-1.0678331851959229,
0.617253839969635,
0.030476879328489304,
0.04110972583293915,
0.5876305103302002,
0.7387014031410217,
-0.24706290662288666,
0.8912703990936279,
0.4651166498661041,
-0.26852643489837646,
0.3978235721588135,
-0.1763308346271515,
0.17709167301654816,
-0.8475534319877625,
-0.15399262309074402,
0.04884001612663269,
-0.5036665797233582,
-0.3749999701976776,
-0.66981440782547,
0.48480024933815,
-0.1888950765132904,
-0.03545117750763893,
0.2639584541320801,
-0.30491623282432556,
0.43147942423820496,
0.6347041726112366,
0.09417638927698135,
0.4070049822330475,
-0.2566854953765869,
-0.032411690801382065,
0.06367609649896622,
-1.042719841003418,
-0.36126357316970825,
1.3228570222854614,
0.2892869710922241,
1.1360507011413574,
0.14677609503269196,
1.0188279151916504,
0.41320955753326416,
0.32851511240005493,
-0.7985812425613403,
0.8002458214759827,
-0.14195935428142548,
-0.7677878737449646,
-0.41637951135635376,
-0.5114235281944275,
-0.6619238257408142,
0.4575534164905548,
-0.08447131514549255,
-0.45434993505477905,
0.024989232420921326,
0.1473361849784851,
-0.14394110441207886,
0.26992449164390564,
-0.7742156386375427,
0.6795320510864258,
-0.475452721118927,
-0.12729716300964355,
-0.5559040904045105,
-0.3906133472919464,
0.4398488700389862,
-0.4962426424026489,
0.2743224799633026,
-0.2712602913379669,
-0.3767203390598297,
0.48395419120788574,
-0.19778963923454285,
0.9921287298202515,
0.3027130961418152,
-0.3645557761192322,
0.1762615442276001,
0.4887996017932892,
0.257960706949234,
0.07234790176153183,
-0.4012920558452606,
0.281772255897522,
-0.28564688563346863,
-0.6817086935043335,
-0.7737984657287598,
0.9930704236030579,
-0.9058718085289001,
-0.9098092913627625,
0.14271312952041626,
-0.7875988483428955,
-0.3169320821762085,
0.3484951853752136,
-0.004320170730352402,
0.5789402723312378,
-0.11442308127880096,
0.2128237932920456,
0.7533882260322571,
0.19864831864833832,
0.3773172199726105,
0.6859946250915527,
-0.08789761364459991,
-0.5569107532501221,
0.9471749663352966,
0.42534980177879333,
0.33744820952415466,
0.4021530747413635,
0.2758965492248535,
-0.0031984560191631317,
-0.6457700133323669,
-0.47512751817703247,
0.09315819293260574,
-0.8089845776557922,
-0.004909267649054527,
-0.8436955809593201,
-0.05126505345106125,
-0.40747588872909546,
-0.32720640301704407,
-0.8890409469604492,
-0.4293012320995331,
-0.45109644532203674,
0.051268547773361206,
-0.16501463949680328,
1.0588608980178833,
-0.16776663064956665,
0.30085331201553345,
-0.81342613697052,
0.09644987434148788,
0.734002947807312,
0.36883676052093506,
0.23341231048107147,
-0.4156225025653839,
-0.47480371594429016,
-0.06651203334331512,
-0.23504044115543365,
-0.739060640335083,
0.1316901594400406,
0.12443572282791138,
1.0646090507507324,
0.4359559714794159,
0.07631824910640717,
0.6667155027389526,
-0.699858546257019,
0.6464778184890747,
0.24351352453231812,
-1.114827275276184,
0.5253254771232605,
-0.6801941394805908,
0.20601674914360046,
0.4011055827140808,
0.17043231427669525,
-0.1694399118423462,
-0.6182568073272705,
-0.5127214193344116,
-0.6617490649223328,
0.532069206237793,
0.14990496635437012,
0.5347947478294373,
-0.1279950588941574,
0.245381698012352,
0.3810417056083679,
0.2428554743528366,
-0.7139883041381836,
-0.2669123709201813,
-0.0715009793639183,
-0.3977488577365875,
-0.05490079149603844,
-0.30941808223724365,
-0.16796475648880005,
-0.2601453959941864,
0.5253720283508301,
-0.25074392557144165,
0.13154298067092896,
0.19735337793827057,
-0.23942086100578308,
0.05305427685379982,
0.32305869460105896,
0.5409078001976013,
0.9536301493644714,
0.3070825934410095,
0.361165851354599,
0.3360798954963684,
0.15638473629951477,
0.00930433627218008,
-0.45072633028030396,
0.010484556667506695,
-0.3293100595474243,
0.478270947933197,
0.4427315592765808,
0.6903082132339478,
-0.496932715177536,
0.29997602105140686,
0.46574047207832336,
-0.06119455397129059,
-0.06826364994049072,
0.4991050958633423,
0.1736101508140564,
0.3997194766998291,
0.47036290168762207,
0.054798442870378494,
0.27330562472343445,
-0.5914594531059265,
0.21412692964076996,
0.38333627581596375,
-0.009169908240437508,
-0.5900738835334778,
0.4631761312484741,
0.6282753348350525,
-0.39960548281669617,
0.055250782519578934,
0.0776619017124176,
-0.37084344029426575,
0.37880733609199524,
0.5453057289123535,
0.8542969226837158,
-0.6032279133796692,
0.011953937821090221,
-0.013407832942903042,
0.2490694671869278,
-0.12403550744056702,
-0.05080050602555275,
-0.3080426752567291,
-0.6427473425865173,
-0.5338213443756104,
-0.39571988582611084,
-0.294036328792572,
-0.35179558396339417,
-0.5109997987747192,
0.05243244022130966,
-0.5587455630302429,
-0.06237820163369179,
-0.21232035756111145,
-0.47482606768608093,
-0.35256847739219666,
0.1488599330186844,
0.007341747637838125,
0.8205291032791138,
-0.5817969441413879,
0.7327004671096802,
0.924634575843811,
-0.13562732934951782,
-0.5457062721252441,
-0.012145442888140678,
-0.4028717279434204,
-0.845914363861084,
0.8238320350646973,
-0.1030304878950119,
-0.11301182955503464,
0.1804383397102356,
-0.3729115426540375,
-0.9366434216499329,
0.9605987071990967,
0.3346479833126068,
-0.39218878746032715,
0.04401536285877228,
-0.021947359666228294,
0.5646241307258606,
-0.5486233234405518,
0.13467571139335632,
0.16613233089447021,
0.39592063426971436,
-0.08875735849142075,
-1.1309319734573364,
-0.2409067302942276,
-0.15945935249328613,
0.008559121750295162,
0.22895671427249908,
-0.9352796673774719,
1.0080691576004028,
0.2296321839094162,
0.1377410888671875,
-0.10494425892829895,
0.9132066369056702,
-0.23633429408073425,
0.023674702271819115,
0.3531686067581177,
0.7167221903800964,
0.6181809902191162,
0.38096508383750916,
0.8010069131851196,
-0.5046988129615784,
0.33774057030677795,
1.0144902467727661,
-0.09693917632102966,
0.8987547159194946,
0.3822730779647827,
-0.13048739731311798,
0.7065786719322205,
0.3358907103538513,
0.3247455954551697,
0.396117240190506,
-0.09433791041374207,
-0.4425604045391083,
-0.8476606607437134,
0.4702838063240051,
-0.34807154536247253,
0.5882699489593506,
0.3678961992263794,
-0.1358201950788498,
-0.31190454959869385,
-0.00508570671081543,
-0.2365259975194931,
0.015442333184182644,
-0.3779166042804718,
0.8778238892555237,
0.05208075791597366,
-0.680595874786377,
0.15873581171035767,
0.07743168622255325,
0.8408238887786865,
-0.6218162775039673,
0.4199640452861786,
-0.2531128227710724,
-0.01135269831866026,
-0.2918807566165924,
-0.9946569204330444,
0.35129380226135254,
-0.41339877247810364,
-0.40576934814453125,
-0.4242844879627228,
0.7794523239135742,
-0.5127119421958923,
-0.5551139116287231,
0.3861270248889923,
0.8304320573806763,
0.0784103199839592,
0.03601177781820297,
-0.6475852727890015,
-0.198019877076149,
-0.26597288250923157,
-0.27091142535209656,
0.42144089937210083,
0.7083005905151367,
0.10483265668153763,
1.1013412475585938,
0.5989583134651184,
0.022753586992621422,
0.46550318598747253,
-0.31411564350128174,
1.056218147277832,
-0.5967313051223755,
-0.7415527701377869,
-0.7871389389038086,
0.645448625087738,
0.05144356191158295,
-0.1083373948931694,
0.8773403763771057,
0.554730236530304,
0.8642326593399048,
-0.2996004521846771,
0.8725233674049377,
0.09421998262405396,
0.29448559880256653,
-0.6309148073196411,
0.6142669320106506,
-0.8634741902351379,
0.24026770889759064,
0.006942661013454199,
-0.8281218409538269,
0.003459247527644038,
0.4745017886161804,
-0.3971779942512512,
0.17555168271064758,
0.32591256499290466,
0.7055417895317078,
-0.6023995876312256,
-0.32077035307884216,
0.6831337809562683,
0.22204139828681946,
0.2733822762966156,
0.3392718732357025,
0.8124607801437378,
0.03363867476582527,
0.23440015316009521,
-0.04062403738498688,
-0.1995345503091812,
-0.4891546964645386,
-0.6337201595306396,
-1.0477700233459473,
-0.41365090012550354,
-0.26739490032196045,
0.40862008929252625,
-0.20300686359405518,
0.9305689334869385,
1.19955313205719,
-0.6175267696380615,
-0.47039881348609924,
0.009288358502089977,
0.18774497509002686,
0.2840115427970886,
-0.19081951677799225,
-0.2608274817466736,
-0.7434094548225403,
-0.7625890970230103,
0.9267366528511047,
0.8759481310844421,
-0.06865359842777252,
-0.8269787430763245,
-0.15510046482086182,
0.17230439186096191,
0.29113563895225525,
0.7970049977302551,
0.09793777763843536,
-0.9126524329185486,
-0.07009600102901459,
0.04683980718255043,
-0.18599897623062134,
0.14045405387878418,
0.8932055830955505,
-0.496213436126709,
0.8141217827796936,
0.6300066113471985,
0.966137170791626,
0.20523220300674438,
-0.1060919389128685,
0.7761181592941284,
-0.5570602416992188,
-0.08366566151380539,
0.16959726810455322,
0.4322081506252289,
0.09143219143152237,
-0.35684868693351746,
0.3459656238555908,
0.2329220473766327,
-0.637403666973114,
-0.36408567428588867,
0.47570130228996277,
-1.1624187231063843,
-0.3282078206539154,
0.9873467087745667,
-0.18250218033790588,
-0.14088250696659088,
-0.09889184683561325,
-0.10401151329278946,
-0.32425615191459656,
-0.3599158823490143,
0.7942115068435669,
0.8485069274902344,
-0.2701062858104706,
-0.22385725378990173,
-0.43094906210899353,
-0.152715265750885,
0.6897665858268738,
-0.9012882709503174,
-0.19506129622459412,
0.3894115090370178,
0.7167819142341614,
0.1977618932723999,
0.8632011413574219,
0.14499323070049286,
0.004401892889291048,
-0.29566052556037903,
0.1840902715921402,
-0.2576659917831421,
-0.418625146150589,
-0.07227727025747299,
0.10371848940849304,
0.044156625866889954,
0.11387442797422409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12033v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12033v2
|
Unveiling and Mitigating Bias in Mental Health Analysis with Large Language Models
| 2024-06-17T19:05:32 | 2024-06-19T18:28:22 |
Yuqing Wang, Yun Zhao, Sara Alessandra Keller, Anne de Hond, Marieke M. van Buchem, Malvika Pillai, Tina Hernandez-Boussard
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The advancement of large language models (LLMs) has demonstrated strong
capabilities across various applications, including mental health analysis.
However, existing studies have focused on predictive performance, leaving the
critical issue of fairness underexplored, posing significant risks to
vulnerable populations. Despite acknowledging potential biases, previous works
have lacked thorough investigations into these biases and their impacts. To
address this gap, we systematically evaluate biases across seven social factors
(e.g., gender, age, religion) using ten LLMs with different prompting methods
on eight diverse mental health datasets. Our results show that GPT-4 achieves
the best overall balance in performance and fairness among LLMs, although it
still lags behind domain-specific models like MentalRoBERTa in some cases.
Additionally, our tailored fairness-aware prompts can effectively mitigate bias
in mental health predictions, highlighting the great potential for fair
analysis in this field.
|
[
-0.3581916391849518,
-0.7111181020736694,
0.9544339776039124,
0.2233424186706543,
0.1535327136516571,
-0.10808857530355453,
-0.2775927186012268,
-0.42077013850212097,
-0.12102316319942474,
0.31031322479248047,
-0.7924655079841614,
-0.3779720067977905,
-0.9342877864837646,
0.10407033562660217,
0.061943016946315765,
1.3294250965118408,
0.30635809898376465,
0.5553946495056152,
-0.057832270860672,
-0.019741542637348175,
-0.6024790406227112,
-0.7003370523452759,
-0.9033081531524658,
-0.6808741688728333,
0.5472287535667419,
0.09590964019298553,
0.7820351719856262,
0.16818371415138245,
0.39925578236579895,
0.20470640063285828,
-0.11652401834726334,
-0.16248278319835663,
-0.6734135150909424,
0.06554210931062698,
-0.405790239572525,
-0.43413543701171875,
-0.7477222084999084,
0.18074411153793335,
0.5270534157752991,
0.8200803995132446,
-0.2615082263946533,
0.312068909406662,
0.15507765114307404,
0.7212100028991699,
-0.4830407202243805,
0.13535553216934204,
-0.571983277797699,
0.21986885368824005,
-0.5260252952575684,
-0.07674479484558105,
-0.18593208491802216,
-0.5047765970230103,
0.10256398469209671,
-0.29979071021080017,
0.306587815284729,
-0.019534924998879433,
0.44215667247772217,
0.39327365159988403,
-0.5771288871765137,
0.06052856147289276,
-0.49757757782936096,
0.9088565111160278,
-0.8572755455970764,
0.2646145224571228,
0.40274688601493835,
0.3877270519733429,
-0.3024595379829407,
-0.39272359013557434,
-0.40994131565093994,
0.23444679379463196,
0.1784735769033432,
0.02142561972141266,
-0.34781545400619507,
0.16861902177333832,
0.7100640535354614,
0.19007828831672668,
-0.469832181930542,
0.11850208044052124,
-0.4169391393661499,
-0.4454607367515564,
0.49329230189323425,
0.3565238416194916,
0.41352635622024536,
-0.05509359389543533,
0.14984130859375,
0.28435954451560974,
-0.7158191204071045,
0.12094949185848236,
0.404468297958374,
0.1460653394460678,
-0.10942540317773819,
0.5844107866287231,
-0.007335031405091286,
0.18500277400016785,
0.10129671543836594,
-0.24090860784053802,
0.3582553267478943,
-0.05289381369948387,
-0.1445702761411667,
0.03561709076166153,
0.6795381307601929,
0.8323178887367249,
0.4265454411506653,
-0.16943329572677612,
-0.183834969997406,
0.3540113866329193,
0.09854203462600708,
-0.9486642479896545,
0.04122670367360115,
0.20058144629001617,
-0.6402716636657715,
0.05961435288190842,
-0.29579076170921326,
-1.1308962106704712,
-0.6703906655311584,
-0.32529279589653015,
0.018378816545009613,
-0.2229829728603363,
-0.29862475395202637,
0.2757112383842468,
-0.012217848561704159,
0.07269340008497238,
0.34905022382736206,
-0.7923502326011658,
0.44910958409309387,
0.7191460728645325,
0.7055351734161377,
-0.21146894991397858,
0.07050411403179169,
-0.7954907417297363,
0.21566253900527954,
-0.13291384279727936,
0.5370787978172302,
-0.7007108330726624,
-0.2527404725551605,
-0.004068935289978981,
-0.0991065576672554,
0.2525663673877716,
-0.34570908546447754,
0.735896646976471,
-0.14324983954429626,
0.4830419421195984,
-1.0085123777389526,
-0.4676104784011841,
-0.10277713090181351,
0.02634536474943161,
-0.6139606833457947,
0.6470204591751099,
0.19341517984867096,
-1.1740570068359375,
0.5687177181243896,
-0.7289010882377625,
-0.4216679632663727,
-0.07308631390333176,
-0.5503859519958496,
-0.4560920298099518,
0.295562744140625,
0.6029080748558044,
0.345716267824173,
-0.4629206359386444,
0.6519545316696167,
-0.6226427555084229,
-0.5117260813713074,
0.11192815005779266,
-0.6032071113586426,
0.7758851647377014,
0.21192021667957306,
-0.6715636253356934,
0.15267632901668549,
-0.20152202248573303,
-0.11509411782026291,
0.11945989727973938,
0.07046595215797424,
-0.156554713845253,
-0.06775026023387909,
-0.03316192701458931,
0.40625107288360596,
0.05432111397385597,
-0.4529981017112732,
-0.15082751214504242,
-0.4662792980670929,
0.36400124430656433,
1.0364729166030884,
-0.21294179558753967,
0.30704426765441895,
-0.45298096537590027,
0.8166720271110535,
-0.15745355188846588,
0.4640517830848694,
0.30344128608703613,
-0.7811054587364197,
-0.018221039324998856,
-0.5905879139900208,
0.11419418454170227,
0.4387838542461395,
-0.5867010951042175,
0.15007054805755615,
-0.202409029006958,
0.012248384766280651,
-0.660100519657135,
-0.00033453499781899154,
0.3290482759475708,
0.38077065348625183,
0.1707126647233963,
-0.3324835002422333,
-0.34310483932495117,
-0.9567159414291382,
-0.5545770525932312,
0.07534997165203094,
-0.05483078211545944,
0.20507431030273438,
0.3226368725299835,
-0.33328720927238464,
0.7995190024375916,
-0.3092183470726013,
-0.2686011493206024,
-0.22906389832496643,
-0.044009726494550705,
0.2523915469646454,
0.09025441855192184,
0.7712582349777222,
-0.4384295344352722,
-0.23188826441764832,
-0.349485844373703,
-0.6565654277801514,
-0.7167478203773499,
0.44369539618492126,
-0.16312001645565033,
-0.04020193964242935,
0.1581888198852539,
-0.49716904759407043,
0.38207587599754333,
0.6444592475891113,
-0.49241140484809875,
0.38471999764442444,
0.10908298194408417,
0.1496034562587738,
-0.6519470810890198,
0.00490294536575675,
0.1586654782295227,
-0.1448194682598114,
-0.4701317846775055,
-0.2799067795276642,
-0.06980124861001968,
-0.038779016584157944,
-0.24443139135837555,
0.6876440048217773,
-0.2616322338581085,
-0.15066631138324738,
-0.2865963280200958,
-0.07222342491149902,
-0.1369309425354004,
0.11626221984624863,
-0.39651399850845337,
0.7247583270072937,
0.46478644013404846,
-0.0715869814157486,
-0.08794775605201721,
-0.15756598114967346,
0.02394341118633747,
0.6494368314743042,
-0.5959283113479614,
0.10889516770839691,
-0.33973339200019836,
0.5680897235870361,
-0.7358909845352173,
-0.14016659557819366,
0.3350335955619812,
-0.36080530285835266,
0.13831642270088196,
0.09420186281204224,
-0.39964625239372253,
-0.45911675691604614,
-0.5710494518280029,
0.6264550089836121,
0.45499560236930847,
-0.1860220730304718,
0.40818506479263306,
0.7180083394050598,
-0.4677324593067169,
-0.6717541813850403,
-0.36635854840278625,
-0.04980906471610069,
-0.6397157907485962,
-0.5435822010040283,
0.3047972023487091,
-0.33734744787216187,
-0.4979346692562103,
-0.20383773744106293,
-0.18406911194324493,
0.18256162106990814,
0.0842675194144249,
0.28124114871025085,
0.36902257800102234,
0.1556086540222168,
0.1321738213300705,
0.04019489884376526,
-0.15415871143341064,
0.3472071886062622,
-0.08822078257799149,
0.5057173371315002,
-0.1991928517818451,
-0.2905515432357788,
-0.23254968225955963,
0.5233824253082275,
0.4678463339805603,
-0.24767713248729706,
0.5590476393699646,
0.6543914675712585,
-0.6685312986373901,
-0.011983176693320274,
-0.7954705953598022,
-0.31574320793151855,
-0.45913171768188477,
0.33524617552757263,
-0.1111239641904831,
-1.2412981986999512,
0.5305365920066833,
0.21889838576316833,
-0.015218831598758698,
0.25676411390304565,
0.7941537499427795,
0.25217053294181824,
1.3933361768722534,
0.6577199101448059,
-0.36680158972740173,
0.4140043258666992,
0.25125065445899963,
0.5470852255821228,
-0.6144229173660278,
0.027276217937469482,
-0.45338737964630127,
-0.1344524770975113,
-0.7603055834770203,
-0.49011749029159546,
0.47664931416511536,
-0.19439594447612762,
-0.4387459456920624,
-0.6395997405052185,
-0.5166569948196411,
0.28502580523490906,
0.21761171519756317,
0.17933671176433563,
0.28394484519958496,
-0.11937695741653442,
-0.17247320711612701,
-0.47843030095100403,
-0.47130507230758667,
-0.5217510461807251,
1.402639389038086,
0.6927408576011658,
0.7810231447219849,
0.09292470663785934,
0.5072852373123169,
0.3161296248435974,
0.7339017391204834,
-0.45611605048179626,
0.3390278220176697,
-0.11751490086317062,
-0.9126937985420227,
-0.3605189323425293,
-0.7320660948753357,
-0.8810959458351135,
0.2526386082172394,
0.02608771063387394,
-0.872473955154419,
0.017312508076429367,
0.08678986132144928,
-0.40196555852890015,
0.17119146883487701,
-0.6694114208221436,
0.478895902633667,
-0.278181791305542,
-0.3494931757450104,
-0.20828324556350708,
-0.4701549708843231,
0.6755297183990479,
-0.30388569831848145,
0.659554660320282,
-0.7251397967338562,
0.17669664323329926,
0.7600913643836975,
-0.10523133724927902,
0.6542146801948547,
-0.3211858570575714,
-0.32739704847335815,
-0.24026429653167725,
-0.09833942353725433,
0.2598682641983032,
0.3843342363834381,
-0.26132944226264954,
0.25258511304855347,
0.06814602017402649,
-0.4870087802410126,
-0.6345205307006836,
0.860041081905365,
-0.6989096999168396,
-0.7776237726211548,
-0.517368733882904,
-0.6451005935668945,
-0.5484625697135925,
0.2191183716058731,
0.12262298166751862,
0.18351970613002777,
-0.048572443425655365,
-0.3248877227306366,
0.7031844258308411,
-0.546920657157898,
0.1596754491329193,
0.4998021423816681,
-0.5093653798103333,
-0.45079925656318665,
0.4931930601596832,
0.18419033288955688,
0.05216396600008011,
-0.2612136900424957,
0.41960400342941284,
-0.3242078721523285,
-0.39842161536216736,
0.004339816048741341,
0.5031294822692871,
-0.5970678925514221,
-0.1996016651391983,
-0.575189471244812,
-0.026030493900179863,
-0.676826000213623,
-0.028762156143784523,
-0.22865159809589386,
0.015940722078084946,
0.1816328912973404,
-0.33703720569610596,
0.2876633405685425,
0.7593745589256287,
-0.08818131685256958,
0.11720338463783264,
-0.34157848358154297,
0.38040822744369507,
0.3089160621166229,
0.640011727809906,
0.26787063479423523,
-0.2625850439071655,
0.13741181790828705,
-0.053249187767505646,
-0.3843229413032532,
-0.8762903809547424,
0.31542861461639404,
-0.19705553352832794,
0.7842110991477966,
0.4959237575531006,
0.043869342654943466,
0.4466194212436676,
-0.7105526924133301,
0.6864224076271057,
0.5541719198226929,
-0.9697754383087158,
0.6024724245071411,
-0.4801676273345947,
0.26786282658576965,
0.4094026982784271,
0.3114284873008728,
-0.531982421875,
-0.526779055595398,
-0.5633411407470703,
-0.7087711691856384,
0.5190947651863098,
0.2483796626329422,
-0.057668473571538925,
-0.18534837663173676,
0.30252107977867126,
0.30525270104408264,
0.16999050974845886,
-0.8425173759460449,
-0.19420857727527618,
-0.16604967415332794,
-0.3499916195869446,
-0.08370696008205414,
-0.34031856060028076,
-0.4668891429901123,
-0.43445974588394165,
0.43639424443244934,
-0.19493265450000763,
0.3674747347831726,
0.09174302965402603,
0.19434130191802979,
-0.34241265058517456,
0.40539059042930603,
0.4575127065181732,
0.7445449233055115,
-0.2258928120136261,
0.16842132806777954,
0.2562476694583893,
-0.5487524271011353,
0.2426053285598755,
0.20230284333229065,
-0.056992776691913605,
-0.2207551896572113,
0.3485869765281677,
0.5853945016860962,
-0.0749417319893837,
-0.6581166386604309,
0.6633848547935486,
-0.22916938364505768,
0.004338332451879978,
0.12429557740688324,
0.03147925063967705,
-0.004480977077037096,
0.5304844379425049,
0.24573904275894165,
-0.4449085593223572,
0.43998467922210693,
-0.48669713735580444,
0.11957722157239914,
0.6260956525802612,
-0.40129154920578003,
-0.3771161437034607,
0.7763510346412659,
0.15514077246189117,
-0.11325612664222717,
0.4477064609527588,
-0.007464895024895668,
-0.42403218150138855,
0.48371875286102295,
0.4789275527000427,
0.6505728363990784,
-0.2847682237625122,
0.17446599900722504,
0.1482182890176773,
0.4827064573764801,
-0.12843886017799377,
0.4601411521434784,
0.5336438417434692,
-0.6883164048194885,
-0.5725967288017273,
-0.5263156294822693,
-0.1729569286108017,
0.3151698112487793,
-0.7510029077529907,
0.027854422107338905,
-0.4059421122074127,
-0.8331540822982788,
-0.09483687579631805,
0.30514955520629883,
-1.1448392868041992,
0.2221144586801529,
0.45193400979042053,
0.6655871272087097,
-0.9293034076690674,
0.6257100701332092,
0.4041074514389038,
-0.1929207742214203,
-0.5935959815979004,
0.32591935992240906,
0.3158675730228424,
-0.7011622190475464,
0.33287885785102844,
0.44368523359298706,
-0.06119532138109207,
-0.2841954231262207,
-0.49335744976997375,
-0.7191275358200073,
0.9262112975120544,
0.9597615599632263,
-0.6409660577774048,
-0.111723393201828,
0.10467582195997238,
0.4001008868217468,
-0.22662213444709778,
0.4531738758087158,
0.8403580784797668,
0.7563936710357666,
-0.3765501379966736,
-1.0525895357131958,
0.2474251389503479,
-0.1370767503976822,
0.21850897371768951,
-0.06587008386850357,
-0.5187316536903381,
0.667752742767334,
-0.26732203364372253,
-0.10518614947795868,
-0.3927580416202545,
0.3806796967983246,
0.5626774430274963,
0.5159986019134521,
0.5163417458534241,
0.43694010376930237,
1.1957298517227173,
-0.07293572276830673,
1.0723559856414795,
0.04150394722819328,
0.27920717000961304,
1.1319386959075928,
-0.7192828059196472,
0.1644156128168106,
0.47299617528915405,
-0.4494599997997284,
0.06364726275205612,
0.6380481123924255,
0.24756769835948944,
0.5233858227729797,
0.5040836930274963,
-0.25574052333831787,
-0.06287553906440735,
-0.2824555039405823,
-0.5110000967979431,
0.14284588396549225,
0.45090535283088684,
-0.31251057982444763,
-0.19331026077270508,
0.10268717259168625,
0.3734682500362396,
-0.00766109861433506,
-0.35530003905296326,
0.3375805616378784,
0.28776106238365173,
-0.4105207622051239,
0.08446601033210754,
0.04347427934408188,
0.9805461764335632,
-0.5008062124252319,
-0.005514981225132942,
-0.4247376620769501,
-0.1106804832816124,
-0.10284443199634552,
-0.6886177659034729,
0.16592366993427277,
-0.04124253988265991,
-0.4851824939250946,
-0.06963837891817093,
0.7653701901435852,
-0.2123105525970459,
-0.5281092524528503,
0.7193894386291504,
0.7146207690238953,
-0.02689671888947487,
-0.17034117877483368,
-0.6551459431648254,
0.22897744178771973,
-0.06103205680847168,
-0.15123552083969116,
0.6362341642379761,
0.7666189670562744,
-0.3772962987422943,
0.7312136888504028,
0.520582914352417,
0.31345459818840027,
0.01151240523904562,
0.4032318890094757,
0.6896436810493469,
-0.764348566532135,
-0.37654203176498413,
-1.0461622476577759,
0.27084624767303467,
-0.11525879055261612,
-0.10673590749502182,
0.7681725025177002,
0.2208871841430664,
0.3932996690273285,
0.2400495707988739,
0.8729423880577087,
0.4001092314720154,
0.4734012186527252,
-0.3043972849845886,
0.8648973703384399,
-0.3465464413166046,
0.2752804756164551,
-0.5552855730056763,
-0.7638188600540161,
-0.2532058358192444,
0.4882468581199646,
-0.6499229073524475,
0.3909657895565033,
0.6378715634346008,
0.7344546318054199,
0.3289344310760498,
0.04864945635199547,
0.2744404971599579,
0.16551747918128967,
0.7301624417304993,
0.6168925762176514,
0.7353605628013611,
0.07320521026849747,
-0.045928727835416794,
0.1234956756234169,
-0.48611241579055786,
0.07595206797122955,
-1.060740351676941,
-0.9909185767173767,
0.03247682377696037,
-0.07453329861164093,
-0.31089937686920166,
0.32317304611206055,
0.7321116924285889,
0.522599458694458,
-0.687751829624176,
0.0011860219528898597,
0.4335845112800598,
0.22654221951961517,
-0.14903448522090912,
-0.2243497520685196,
0.2913978099822998,
-0.11319156736135483,
-0.4861277639865875,
-0.039545319974422455,
0.26283910870552063,
-0.3418812155723572,
-0.3454395830631256,
-0.1073169857263565,
0.24636107683181763,
0.18945325911045074,
0.6105121970176697,
-0.24980492889881134,
-0.9270464181900024,
-0.37051355838775635,
-0.36133840680122375,
-0.12326212972402573,
0.0035022974479943514,
0.7776932120323181,
-0.581524670124054,
0.22393789887428284,
0.22316914796829224,
0.5797784328460693,
0.013810229487717152,
-0.2630334496498108,
0.9112629890441895,
-0.37642383575439453,
-0.17754864692687988,
0.26196417212486267,
0.557773768901825,
0.42140522599220276,
-0.7263430953025818,
0.5402337908744812,
0.10344591736793518,
-0.6136047840118408,
-0.8033900856971741,
-0.030120978131890297,
-0.6530108451843262,
-0.29228878021240234,
1.1702539920806885,
0.10531622916460037,
0.0035613025538623333,
-0.16547837853431702,
-0.36258289217948914,
0.31799036264419556,
-0.6947928071022034,
0.9844390153884888,
0.9339336156845093,
-0.15020716190338135,
-0.1604803204536438,
-1.1527057886123657,
0.5636444091796875,
0.5821565985679626,
-0.8534356355667114,
0.13648764789104462,
0.5686218738555908,
0.5421950817108154,
-0.4704746603965759,
1.0949220657348633,
-0.420452356338501,
0.2838917374610901,
-0.6399138569831848,
0.058936957269907,
0.3493422865867615,
-0.12256760895252228,
-0.5496436357498169,
0.042734283953905106,
0.04968160390853882,
0.46143820881843567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12031v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12031v1
|
Large Scale Transfer Learning for Tabular Data via Language Modeling
| 2024-06-17T18:58:20 | 2024-06-17T18:58:20 |
Josh Gardner, Juan C. Perdomo, Ludwig Schmidt
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Tabular data -- structured, heterogeneous, spreadsheet-style data with rows
and columns -- is widely used in practice across many domains. However, while
recent foundation models have reduced the need for developing task-specific
datasets and predictors in domains such as language modeling and computer
vision, this transfer learning paradigm has not had similar impact in the
tabular domain. In this work, we seek to narrow this gap and present TabuLa-8B,
a language model for tabular prediction. We define a process for extracting a
large, high-quality training dataset from the TabLib corpus, proposing methods
for tabular data filtering and quality control. Using the resulting dataset,
which comprises over 1.6B rows from 3.1M unique tables, we fine-tune a Llama
3-8B large language model (LLM) for tabular data prediction (classification and
binned regression) using a novel packing and attention scheme for tabular
prediction. Through evaluation across a test suite of 329 datasets, we find
that TabuLa-8B has zero-shot accuracy on unseen tables that is over 15
percentage points (pp) higher than random guessing, a feat that is not possible
with existing state-of-the-art tabular prediction models (e.g. XGBoost,
TabPFN). In the few-shot setting (1-32 shots), without any fine-tuning on the
target datasets, TabuLa-8B is 5-15 pp more accurate than XGBoost and TabPFN
models that are explicitly trained on equal, or even up to 16x more data. We
release our model, code, and data along with the publication of this paper.
|
[
-0.1835458129644394,
-0.8795968890190125,
0.2938060164451599,
0.10938404500484467,
0.08213599771261215,
-0.016280440613627434,
-0.3523479104042053,
-0.5592236518859863,
-0.17229411005973816,
0.8143845200538635,
-0.13353249430656433,
-0.6487969160079956,
-0.5107589364051819,
-0.2741245925426483,
-0.586875855922699,
1.1144481897354126,
-0.1478399932384491,
0.0021227169781923294,
0.10702379047870636,
0.12667861580848694,
-0.6805320978164673,
-0.14615026116371155,
-0.18750032782554626,
-0.20754267275333405,
0.5475834608078003,
0.7223444581031799,
0.4379526376724243,
0.9434686303138733,
0.7216829061508179,
0.13862039148807526,
0.06531152129173279,
-0.03217628225684166,
-0.7168280482292175,
-0.23135614395141602,
-0.10244694352149963,
-0.6123881936073303,
-0.597976565361023,
-0.13334645330905914,
0.8570269346237183,
0.7719007134437561,
-0.35439854860305786,
0.49018239974975586,
0.05309036374092102,
0.6347422003746033,
-0.28306642174720764,
0.541012167930603,
-0.9898290038108826,
0.24196270108222961,
-0.35758864879608154,
0.08141013979911804,
-0.8383884429931641,
-0.43417519330978394,
-0.00811735074967146,
-0.3104749321937561,
0.10661929100751877,
0.3356986343860626,
0.7061449289321899,
-0.07064380496740341,
-0.3140340745449066,
0.15958546102046967,
-0.778236985206604,
0.5051261782646179,
-0.4245437979698181,
0.46181604266166687,
0.4712488055229187,
0.519058883190155,
-0.3329757750034332,
-0.5228875279426575,
-0.6297653317451477,
-0.4636056423187256,
0.16818338632583618,
-0.18856093287467957,
0.07748845964670181,
-0.06304147839546204,
0.32729822397232056,
0.11151140183210373,
-0.9175164103507996,
0.2738487422466278,
-0.7164617776870728,
-0.004669242072850466,
0.39656150341033936,
0.08482121676206589,
0.06702789664268494,
0.07771938294172287,
-0.44659173488616943,
-0.1976584941148758,
-0.7584165334701538,
0.14413020014762878,
-0.02249474637210369,
0.6032006740570068,
-0.0772189199924469,
0.3755921721458435,
-0.2714061737060547,
0.9204283952713013,
0.04010969027876854,
-0.17166592180728912,
0.19813860952854156,
0.02936914935708046,
-0.31836074590682983,
-0.10197421163320541,
0.44623884558677673,
0.27872151136398315,
0.16023282706737518,
-0.248612642288208,
-0.12860244512557983,
0.1321224719285965,
0.295306921005249,
-0.7612278461456299,
-0.37213027477264404,
0.009054230526089668,
-0.250142902135849,
-0.3249731659889221,
-0.02404087781906128,
-0.8312194347381592,
-0.435261607170105,
-0.3588595986366272,
0.463077187538147,
-0.23715080320835114,
0.12648580968379974,
-0.10244805365800858,
0.45881786942481995,
0.24210797250270844,
0.5034576058387756,
-0.8661344647407532,
0.30989721417427063,
0.4422740042209625,
0.6554484367370605,
-0.5427007079124451,
-0.3929314613342285,
-0.85063236951828,
0.25324612855911255,
-0.7170296907424927,
1.1822916269302368,
-0.5868473052978516,
0.05792156234383583,
0.03513212502002716,
0.09277171641588211,
0.08188110589981079,
-0.6288857460021973,
0.3728218078613281,
-0.2944021224975586,
-0.28287628293037415,
0.017461556941270828,
-0.45665109157562256,
-0.24542395770549774,
0.2346404492855072,
-0.8506049513816833,
0.8706072568893433,
0.4252142608165741,
-0.2424447238445282,
0.672203779220581,
-0.35917040705680847,
-0.36779189109802246,
0.29504773020744324,
-0.23877526819705963,
-0.693488359451294,
-0.07881508767604828,
0.01514824852347374,
0.6557408571243286,
-0.32364514470100403,
0.49664732813835144,
-0.6291379332542419,
-0.1620909869670868,
0.35020312666893005,
-0.1458262950181961,
0.1507733017206192,
0.12101206183433533,
-0.1679263561964035,
0.12991923093795776,
-0.8476817607879639,
0.14537550508975983,
-0.20125025510787964,
-0.44266369938850403,
0.3879735469818115,
-0.5442705154418945,
0.3239419162273407,
0.314935564994812,
-0.01890878565609455,
-0.4229207932949066,
0.45945215225219727,
0.014006886631250381,
0.15023347735404968,
0.6321894526481628,
-0.3152639865875244,
0.764212965965271,
-0.3655385375022888,
0.5152497291564941,
0.12041503190994263,
0.012806238606572151,
0.07652240991592407,
-0.23950502276420593,
-0.3752349019050598,
-0.07799313217401505,
0.5386882424354553,
0.4478882849216461,
-0.5557990074157715,
0.2514951229095459,
-0.41945573687553406,
-0.7123958468437195,
-0.13883079588413239,
0.31094276905059814,
0.29894348978996277,
0.6407326459884644,
0.36295086145401,
-0.12810227274894714,
-0.43315231800079346,
-0.8072227835655212,
0.04064129292964935,
0.0014451645547524095,
0.2300778031349182,
0.13716524839401245,
0.4252493381500244,
0.02230389416217804,
0.5121030211448669,
-0.5930016040802002,
-0.7342151403427124,
-0.8494214415550232,
0.1768832504749298,
0.36439022421836853,
0.5039697289466858,
0.42346978187561035,
-0.6311353445053101,
-0.982245147228241,
0.5211923718452454,
-0.5061938166618347,
0.042609620839357376,
-0.21838568150997162,
-0.2471684217453003,
0.2298811972141266,
0.3529987633228302,
-0.555907130241394,
0.6440678834915161,
0.5156108736991882,
-0.29350990056991577,
0.6932313442230225,
-0.009243625216186047,
-0.07945169508457184,
-1.03513765335083,
0.18031343817710876,
0.17221534252166748,
-0.2829900085926056,
-0.9384850859642029,
-0.19769926369190216,
0.37365180253982544,
-0.2316761612892151,
-0.4471033215522766,
0.641689121723175,
-0.5510525107383728,
-0.30856752395629883,
-0.33057358860969543,
-0.11068934947252274,
-0.03157461807131767,
0.6120003461837769,
0.08297009766101837,
0.6985005140304565,
0.5226514339447021,
-0.3706815540790558,
0.37326565384864807,
0.5063982009887695,
-0.6727004647254944,
0.4296286106109619,
-0.15871135890483856,
-0.190281942486763,
-0.015305396169424057,
0.6173527836799622,
-0.9020886421203613,
-0.2429903745651245,
-0.0700281485915184,
-0.40474700927734375,
0.6472225189208984,
-0.2408542037010193,
-0.0812835842370987,
-0.47521528601646423,
0.012716185301542282,
0.1425725221633911,
0.34008681774139404,
-0.353555828332901,
0.5603192448616028,
0.563073992729187,
-0.23297365009784698,
-0.7284340858459473,
-0.7379662394523621,
0.014308219775557518,
-0.21508407592773438,
-0.2705489993095398,
0.32444024085998535,
0.10889172554016113,
0.1807197481393814,
-0.040553826838731766,
-0.21236953139305115,
-0.4158402383327484,
-0.13587814569473267,
0.26170825958251953,
0.5688774585723877,
-0.07026660442352295,
0.12114574015140533,
-0.1945040076971054,
0.05678709223866463,
-0.09034238755702972,
-0.27227967977523804,
0.5174612998962402,
-0.09091819077730179,
0.16237720847129822,
-0.33479660749435425,
-0.010640195570886135,
0.37185657024383545,
-0.23143289983272552,
0.9204350709915161,
0.804011344909668,
-0.5599042177200317,
-0.6260947585105896,
-0.5596792697906494,
-0.08603373169898987,
-0.37145256996154785,
0.672980546951294,
-0.4950393736362457,
-0.5330093502998352,
0.7713923454284668,
0.14205509424209595,
0.051219161599874496,
0.009767965413630009,
0.5959232449531555,
-0.10127217322587967,
0.5283412933349609,
0.7475546598434448,
-0.2786804735660553,
0.78947514295578,
-0.563220202922821,
0.09171067178249359,
-0.740153431892395,
-0.25253939628601074,
-0.6637722253799438,
-0.40583062171936035,
-0.5904202461242676,
-0.44323912262916565,
0.2707114815711975,
-0.2824237048625946,
-0.1410231590270996,
0.6347437500953674,
-0.08217496424913406,
0.5032825469970703,
0.3066086173057556,
0.4468704164028168,
0.1702984720468521,
0.2507883608341217,
0.13192375004291534,
0.2509167194366455,
-0.5574551820755005,
-0.23350201547145844,
1.3179796934127808,
0.3624492883682251,
1.12107253074646,
-0.25699329376220703,
0.35975831747055054,
0.42794069647789,
0.6530188322067261,
-0.6572950482368469,
0.4506611227989197,
-0.2884346544742584,
-0.524029552936554,
-0.6027124524116516,
-0.7206907272338867,
-1.0163499116897583,
0.09041064232587814,
-0.3402118980884552,
-1.0851068496704102,
0.0771242082118988,
0.31024402379989624,
-0.3011213541030884,
0.42515796422958374,
-0.6846021413803101,
1.1218156814575195,
-0.048425186425447464,
-0.715883731842041,
-0.050938740372657776,
-0.6226314306259155,
0.23782014846801758,
-0.1773163229227066,
0.18437112867832184,
-0.26720112562179565,
0.49621081352233887,
0.7167481184005737,
0.002354237250983715,
0.6173248887062073,
-0.14628908038139343,
-0.03195078670978546,
0.23686517775058746,
0.4121529459953308,
0.65216463804245,
-0.3784562349319458,
-0.02705269493162632,
0.03366513550281525,
-0.13136211037635803,
-0.3341140151023865,
-0.5958360433578491,
0.6657466888427734,
-0.6867217421531677,
-0.255645751953125,
-0.02729213796555996,
-0.9402235150337219,
-0.37123337388038635,
0.15546177327632904,
0.005621679592877626,
0.6739316582679749,
0.030707141384482384,
0.6016867160797119,
0.6339433193206787,
-0.10572843998670578,
0.0811721533536911,
0.3253713846206665,
-0.364124059677124,
-0.27932798862457275,
1.010085940361023,
0.5548222661018372,
0.15150682628154755,
0.6764366626739502,
0.17343886196613312,
-0.4063716530799866,
-0.688634991645813,
-0.5820407271385193,
0.19021785259246826,
-0.4789889454841614,
-0.7218837141990662,
-0.3770214319229126,
-0.2266707867383957,
-0.5305438041687012,
0.007143029477447271,
-0.3212777376174927,
-0.29828405380249023,
-0.0883898138999939,
-0.34277287125587463,
0.25354552268981934,
0.6796157360076904,
0.19345900416374207,
0.4520955979824066,
-0.8296421766281128,
0.3757114112377167,
-0.13796930015087128,
0.5984799265861511,
-0.007032136898487806,
-0.9619529247283936,
-0.5643894076347351,
-0.2212689369916916,
-0.37610429525375366,
-0.8685826659202576,
0.7665285468101501,
0.2627347409725189,
0.5254204869270325,
0.12457281351089478,
-0.10974889993667603,
0.7380115389823914,
-0.5455718636512756,
0.17529603838920593,
0.18181200325489044,
-0.6391633152961731,
0.2723720967769623,
-0.40415313839912415,
0.20124706625938416,
0.47262051701545715,
0.2526857256889343,
-0.31167882680892944,
-0.12696129083633423,
-0.3304154574871063,
-0.49563074111938477,
0.8341426253318787,
-0.21631182730197906,
-0.3235227167606354,
0.5580618977546692,
0.33089613914489746,
0.4981255829334259,
0.24101673066616058,
-1.1493324041366577,
0.16808591783046722,
0.24987979233264923,
-0.378201961517334,
-0.037930119782686234,
0.09256888926029205,
0.31862103939056396,
-0.14116032421588898,
0.5505440831184387,
-0.30974796414375305,
0.1426168978214264,
-0.18047933280467987,
-0.43822160363197327,
-0.32608845829963684,
0.2694840729236603,
0.3817554712295532,
0.8232057690620422,
-0.2791011929512024,
0.017434345558285713,
0.17519903182983398,
-0.6706835627555847,
0.22644957900047302,
0.10110519826412201,
-0.06727243214845657,
-0.38716259598731995,
0.037848182022571564,
0.8916624188423157,
-0.06757920980453491,
-0.509477436542511,
0.31664639711380005,
0.15816624462604523,
-0.23995143175125122,
-0.1043364405632019,
-0.1924564391374588,
-0.18194012343883514,
0.25738653540611267,
0.2829809784889221,
-0.37871378660202026,
0.43410542607307434,
-0.7560977935791016,
0.32569634914398193,
0.3564310669898987,
-0.1449088156223297,
-0.329963356256485,
0.46051275730133057,
-0.09125881642103195,
0.08615231513977051,
0.5523080229759216,
-0.005844536703079939,
-0.3630109429359436,
0.6413875222206116,
0.7090901732444763,
0.39914220571517944,
-0.3466517925262451,
0.45456215739250183,
0.43900907039642334,
0.2222331464290619,
-0.17924678325653076,
0.24355697631835938,
0.036179885268211365,
-0.5902267098426819,
-0.4024162292480469,
-0.8393493890762329,
-0.5226633548736572,
0.4497121274471283,
-0.6994097232818604,
0.3953014612197876,
-0.2847127914428711,
-0.16879521310329437,
-0.010657692328095436,
0.28851383924484253,
-0.859814465045929,
0.15632285177707672,
0.4037075340747833,
0.857183039188385,
-1.0511143207550049,
0.9743828177452087,
0.4913637638092041,
-0.2765912711620331,
-1.0957564115524292,
-0.3721126317977905,
-0.5728415846824646,
-0.709175705909729,
0.6423712968826294,
0.35769808292388916,
0.47389253973960876,
-0.20291981101036072,
-0.5357668399810791,
-0.9508837461471558,
0.8165882229804993,
0.5366346836090088,
-0.7787385582923889,
-0.2690831124782562,
0.46948572993278503,
0.3981936573982239,
-0.35682806372642517,
0.21947453916072845,
0.8537881374359131,
0.45573291182518005,
0.1421407014131546,
-1.1195849180221558,
-0.04941426217556,
0.07185564190149307,
0.07154498249292374,
0.31876516342163086,
-0.47805851697921753,
0.696506679058075,
-0.24657778441905975,
0.16454234719276428,
-0.1966288834810257,
0.7273406386375427,
0.014298285357654095,
0.20541323721408844,
0.11075681447982788,
0.5488421320915222,
0.5479423403739929,
-0.014401313848793507,
0.5880571603775024,
-0.034708645194768906,
0.3161206841468811,
1.3177311420440674,
-0.6316934823989868,
1.1265404224395752,
0.2805183231830597,
-0.24084214866161346,
0.3351629674434662,
0.4324731230735779,
-0.26232531666755676,
0.418207585811615,
0.20651589334011078,
0.21888616681098938,
-0.10948377847671509,
-0.09387381374835968,
-0.10370422899723053,
0.579351544380188,
0.5826038122177124,
-0.15588058531284332,
-0.24024921655654907,
0.18807421624660492,
-0.2635612487792969,
-0.07375054806470871,
-0.49060362577438354,
0.8037687540054321,
-0.1352880597114563,
-0.6200495362281799,
0.6360617876052856,
-0.39661726355552673,
0.04025542363524437,
-0.23670566082000732,
-0.23063059151172638,
-0.3402006924152374,
0.24995364248752594,
-0.3515511453151703,
-0.8952730894088745,
0.047763824462890625,
-0.1465664803981781,
-0.08380722999572754,
-0.1653236299753189,
0.6373393535614014,
-0.836738646030426,
-0.5683888792991638,
-0.04314667358994484,
0.501443088054657,
0.2938750982284546,
0.05601881444454193,
-0.461245059967041,
0.2192915380001068,
0.03563885763287544,
-0.21124345064163208,
0.6353233456611633,
0.4290551543235779,
-0.29251712560653687,
0.9608878493309021,
0.4923888146877289,
0.4483111798763275,
0.27779367566108704,
-0.030467204749584198,
0.8983814716339111,
-0.5840911269187927,
-0.5670457482337952,
-0.4844859838485718,
0.3214350640773773,
0.17547616362571716,
0.03802918270230293,
0.23773951828479767,
0.6516429781913757,
0.7755230069160461,
-0.3082232177257538,
0.6151428818702698,
0.06694354116916656,
0.5077693462371826,
-0.48302316665649414,
0.6269972324371338,
-0.18859955668449402,
-0.07719942927360535,
-0.14986245334148407,
-1.1070696115493774,
-0.38977059721946716,
0.6702473759651184,
-0.4558360278606415,
-0.13143251836299896,
0.6290895938873291,
0.7275750041007996,
-0.019058462232351303,
-0.365191787481308,
0.7137157320976257,
0.47160789370536804,
0.3267260789871216,
0.6282274723052979,
0.5869842171669006,
-0.3993401825428009,
0.8062184453010559,
-0.11726914346218109,
-0.34530726075172424,
-0.4316648542881012,
-0.6205354332923889,
-0.7343454957008362,
-0.6381484866142273,
-0.09275700896978378,
-0.23468337953090668,
0.08432730287313461,
0.8924906849861145,
0.8293890357017517,
-0.7641786932945251,
-0.6136202812194824,
-0.09082482755184174,
-0.08483662456274033,
-0.16258136928081512,
-0.23733438551425934,
0.4098547101020813,
-0.20250046253204346,
-0.38628801703453064,
-0.00705221900716424,
0.14918087422847748,
0.08685944974422455,
-0.12688128650188446,
0.41721630096435547,
-0.040763262659311295,
-0.3243211805820465,
0.5022161602973938,
0.2099868208169937,
-0.42965906858444214,
-0.13335859775543213,
-0.01600981317460537,
-0.07159140706062317,
0.49812012910842896,
0.38088735938072205,
-0.6920202374458313,
0.15221944451332092,
0.2743898332118988,
0.7073697447776794,
0.8285929560661316,
0.09379249811172485,
0.4060685336589813,
-0.38688650727272034,
-0.04751362279057503,
0.19810260832309723,
0.429149329662323,
0.2648248076438904,
-0.4385668933391571,
0.4052978456020355,
-0.1739259511232376,
-0.7932834625244141,
-1.055755853652954,
0.009464248083531857,
-1.232527732849121,
0.08801776170730591,
1.19527268409729,
-0.1817919760942459,
-0.7297250032424927,
0.1846293807029724,
-0.2700013220310211,
0.3032223582267761,
-0.6716762781143188,
1.023350715637207,
0.4067386984825134,
-0.07366732507944107,
-0.37142249941825867,
-0.6325088143348694,
0.38631701469421387,
-0.039073821157217026,
-1.2098313570022583,
0.5438467264175415,
0.5976361632347107,
0.2625367045402527,
0.0010201354743912816,
0.14579081535339355,
-0.014675440266728401,
0.435988187789917,
-0.0346289798617363,
0.30966147780418396,
0.07831909507513046,
-0.9039314985275269,
-0.18340066075325012,
0.3751336932182312,
0.23411400616168976,
0.07994960248470306
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.